id
stringlengths 33
33
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
33
| title
stringlengths 13
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 6
16.6k
| category_primary
stringclasses 60
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
132
| abstract
stringlengths 123
1.99k
| embeddings
listlengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.01775v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.01775v1
|
OLoRA: Orthonormal Low-Rank Adaptation of Large Language Models
| 2024-06-03T20:37:27 | 2024-06-03T20:37:27 |
Kerim Büyükakyüz
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The advent of large language models (LLMs) has revolutionized natural
language processing, enabling unprecedented capabilities in understanding and
generating human-like text. However, the computational cost and convergence
times associated with fine-tuning these models remain significant challenges.
Low-Rank Adaptation (LoRA) has emerged as a promising method to mitigate these
issues by introducing efficient fine-tuning techniques with a reduced number of
trainable parameters. In this paper, we present OLoRA, an enhancement to the
LoRA method that leverages orthonormal matrix initialization through QR
decomposition. OLoRA significantly accelerates the convergence of LLM training
while preserving the efficiency benefits of LoRA, such as the number of
trainable parameters and GPU memory footprint. Our empirical evaluations
demonstrate that OLoRA not only converges faster but also exhibits improved
performance compared to standard LoRA across a variety of language modeling
tasks. This advancement opens new avenues for more efficient and accessible
fine-tuning of LLMs, potentially enabling broader adoption and innovation in
natural language applications.
|
[
-0.24845212697982788,
-0.9593750834465027,
0.4744207262992859,
-0.14774177968502045,
-0.18797747790813446,
0.07560756802558899,
-0.49277740716934204,
-0.29362931847572327,
-0.16227327287197113,
0.4768065810203552,
-0.31919732689857483,
-0.6447721719741821,
-0.4447527527809143,
-0.08768114447593689,
-0.14361070096492767,
0.9422580599784851,
0.2169472724199295,
-0.16563400626182556,
0.11658794432878494,
-0.35616129636764526,
-0.2846413850784302,
-0.14750604331493378,
-0.885935366153717,
-0.03249610960483551,
0.659311830997467,
0.7215467691421509,
0.6697904467582703,
0.8376757502555847,
0.31892216205596924,
0.3282650411128998,
-0.11253677308559418,
0.20849119126796722,
-1.0062683820724487,
0.385966956615448,
0.09228537976741791,
-0.60489821434021,
-0.8574069738388062,
-0.36851072311401367,
1.1157938241958618,
0.8165194988250732,
-0.2731422483921051,
0.5155714154243469,
0.20218008756637573,
0.8336228728294373,
-1.185874342918396,
-0.022370582446455956,
-0.5689281821250916,
-0.13960249722003937,
-0.2653779089450836,
-0.22922177612781525,
-0.2502375841140747,
-0.4617233872413635,
-0.1349092274904251,
-0.7184452414512634,
-0.22202199697494507,
0.2804582715034485,
0.3207094073295593,
0.539016842842102,
0.0279205534607172,
0.026910487562417984,
-0.8866804242134094,
0.7793439030647278,
-0.6801102161407471,
0.5068566799163818,
0.1889200061559677,
0.4224165976047516,
-0.24977579712867737,
-0.3704758584499359,
-0.5491246581077576,
-0.09421411901712418,
0.3627004325389862,
-0.054139621555805206,
-0.4740428626537323,
-0.1307755410671234,
0.20325572788715363,
0.5159720182418823,
-0.48154860734939575,
0.5395050644874573,
-0.33593517541885376,
0.41405269503593445,
0.20810116827487946,
0.22724488377571106,
0.15898215770721436,
0.021770548075437546,
-0.08198520541191101,
-0.38206717371940613,
-0.6289476752281189,
0.12063208967447281,
0.21948961913585663,
0.6689330339431763,
-0.1921139508485794,
0.44059309363365173,
-0.27789387106895447,
0.5369859337806702,
0.07387187331914902,
-0.5802012085914612,
0.07087541371583939,
-0.024449683725833893,
-0.4321475327014923,
0.25427260994911194,
0.5910376310348511,
-0.012790394015610218,
-0.03284697234630585,
-0.09217575192451477,
-0.12712904810905457,
0.06305304914712906,
0.0007955258479341865,
-1.0235302448272705,
-0.16582784056663513,
0.007056556176394224,
-0.47875985503196716,
-0.12836214900016785,
-0.19844716787338257,
-0.9582843780517578,
-0.6443649530410767,
-0.15682663023471832,
0.6289198398590088,
-0.42855721712112427,
-0.03081491030752659,
0.43643879890441895,
0.23423190414905548,
0.2634311020374298,
0.5251713991165161,
-0.9113817811012268,
0.5524711608886719,
0.6185141205787659,
0.6024466156959534,
-0.3269925117492676,
-0.13840855658054352,
-1.2079886198043823,
-0.08993574231863022,
-0.45930925011634827,
0.6870392560958862,
-0.38949063420295715,
-0.20627419650554657,
0.03623088821768761,
-0.337569922208786,
-0.1159268468618393,
-0.6072094440460205,
0.5760211944580078,
-0.745373547077179,
0.15053002536296844,
0.0014356353785842657,
0.09575092792510986,
0.1332465559244156,
0.022228270769119263,
-0.6002541184425354,
1.2928723096847534,
0.3111223876476288,
-0.5502968430519104,
0.25147387385368347,
-0.9677649140357971,
-0.4019906520843506,
-0.1030585989356041,
0.17763368785381317,
-0.5278472304344177,
0.27848705649375916,
0.35633930563926697,
0.19807402789592743,
-0.5955875515937805,
-0.5783957839012146,
-0.44484373927116394,
-0.4173720180988312,
0.1569468080997467,
0.08438340574502945,
0.7426958084106445,
0.16635510325431824,
-0.09521719813346863,
0.2404676228761673,
-1.2437024116516113,
-0.03498294949531555,
0.27951720356941223,
-0.40067481994628906,
-0.6818764209747314,
-0.18041346967220306,
0.014142635278403759,
-0.2292211800813675,
0.21850982308387756,
-0.41031670570373535,
0.25939589738845825,
-0.5311960577964783,
0.5997560620307922,
0.6601060628890991,
-0.25745806097984314,
0.8741250038146973,
-0.18266595900058746,
0.600166380405426,
-0.2067163586616516,
0.008651459589600563,
0.01711379736661911,
-0.22778967022895813,
-1.0827722549438477,
-0.7047123908996582,
0.43815770745277405,
0.41605958342552185,
-0.6436986327171326,
0.42996343970298767,
-0.52060866355896,
-0.4336264431476593,
-0.9197267293930054,
0.31944626569747925,
0.31887686252593994,
0.4493105113506317,
0.4477526843547821,
-0.08247902244329453,
-0.5072473883628845,
-0.6229479908943176,
0.06913495808839798,
-0.3369155526161194,
-0.10884121060371399,
-0.06520155817270279,
0.2680075168609619,
-0.14288051426410675,
0.9905597567558289,
-0.6241469383239746,
-0.6043153405189514,
-0.26960548758506775,
0.1963851898908615,
0.34507524967193604,
0.34103140234947205,
0.6132819652557373,
-0.2349640130996704,
-0.5174931287765503,
0.02581844851374626,
-0.41682571172714233,
-0.17308101058006287,
0.33866697549819946,
-0.3723181188106537,
0.45912453532218933,
0.7022728323936462,
-0.24347056448459625,
0.38975250720977783,
0.6826386451721191,
-0.1339036524295807,
0.045654743909835815,
-0.41994941234588623,
0.015657706186175346,
-1.027270793914795,
0.11612710356712341,
-0.33028578758239746,
-0.3168025016784668,
-0.5671490430831909,
0.011863553896546364,
-0.051572076976299286,
-0.09574486315250397,
-0.1329696625471115,
0.5659751296043396,
-0.34000036120414734,
-0.12393977493047714,
-0.29189780354499817,
0.2050219476222992,
-0.10059934854507446,
0.3889286518096924,
-0.11005918681621552,
0.9195236563682556,
0.4730737507343292,
-0.6543415188789368,
-0.17430303990840912,
0.4476967751979828,
-0.42908182740211487,
0.7983689308166504,
-0.4754352867603302,
0.2775794565677643,
-0.29928621649742126,
-0.20110513269901276,
-0.8908073902130127,
0.013690602034330368,
0.3418903052806854,
-0.27145397663116455,
0.11317816376686096,
-0.09750795364379883,
-0.6170938611030579,
0.18558408319950104,
-0.5954495668411255,
0.5799535512924194,
0.91501784324646,
-0.8256124258041382,
0.8255858421325684,
0.308183878660202,
-0.2976216673851013,
-0.1504656970500946,
-0.3198080062866211,
-0.24593424797058105,
-0.4764620363712311,
-0.332042396068573,
0.3671518862247467,
-0.2472483217716217,
-0.38913655281066895,
-0.11859478056430817,
0.31373512744903564,
0.29355812072753906,
0.2709720730781555,
0.25270432233810425,
0.10603567957878113,
-0.7662380337715149,
0.15914446115493774,
-0.014683147892355919,
-0.11791688203811646,
-0.23983198404312134,
-0.14595283567905426,
0.46196961402893066,
-0.15556441247463226,
-0.051088474690914154,
-0.23207290470600128,
0.16499744355678558,
0.6710609793663025,
-0.26637816429138184,
0.8876575827598572,
0.6810745000839233,
-0.32086753845214844,
-0.6180554628372192,
-0.3133612871170044,
-0.07739605754613876,
-0.44707849621772766,
0.5950824618339539,
-0.35793283581733704,
-0.9775013327598572,
0.4175649881362915,
0.09898214787244797,
-0.08881362527608871,
0.4070936441421509,
0.7243048548698425,
0.12283983081579208,
0.8756641745567322,
1.0352082252502441,
-0.39280256628990173,
0.6590740084648132,
0.10228097438812256,
0.3031599819660187,
-0.900640606880188,
0.17461247742176056,
-0.8597883582115173,
-0.2662554979324341,
-0.6698837876319885,
-0.5309235453605652,
0.8275186419487,
0.23925165832042694,
-0.4773542284965515,
0.11004061251878738,
-0.11697617918252945,
0.16615448892116547,
0.6427294611930847,
0.03620719537138939,
0.7914553880691528,
0.15419453382492065,
0.4142262041568756,
0.15157105028629303,
-0.8679012060165405,
-0.22368216514587402,
1.0332213640213013,
0.4943293333053589,
0.874547004699707,
0.5078995227813721,
0.5847445726394653,
0.32389914989471436,
0.27589017152786255,
-0.8623141646385193,
0.39416635036468506,
-0.2526714503765106,
-0.08752552419900894,
-0.7750349044799805,
-0.35343557596206665,
-1.135326623916626,
0.20155832171440125,
-0.5599708557128906,
-0.8646844029426575,
0.3135910928249359,
0.09850530326366425,
-0.977069079875946,
0.08728741854429245,
-0.3999708592891693,
0.5086814761161804,
0.030500730499625206,
-0.43578118085861206,
-0.24968552589416504,
-0.16918104887008667,
0.2712354362010956,
-0.35411757230758667,
0.27521762251853943,
-0.06568306684494019,
-0.19792824983596802,
0.9247428178787231,
-0.3474697470664978,
0.7391914129257202,
0.04026588425040245,
-0.4458017349243164,
-0.13844764232635498,
-0.1253998726606369,
0.4423189163208008,
0.2035931795835495,
-0.11931116133928299,
-0.1262894719839096,
-0.060210760682821274,
-0.32862722873687744,
-0.5638558864593506,
0.7291737794876099,
-0.9868088364601135,
-0.29246199131011963,
-0.2951575815677643,
-0.6043260097503662,
-0.49271371960639954,
0.24211539328098297,
-0.06853164732456207,
0.18871107697486877,
-0.4339781403541565,
0.06972545385360718,
0.8152558207511902,
-0.35220274329185486,
0.2440701723098755,
0.5787804126739502,
-0.5965403914451599,
-0.54799485206604,
0.7571746706962585,
-0.0898611843585968,
0.19915731251239777,
0.40564781427383423,
0.17595848441123962,
0.010511312633752823,
-0.7621398568153381,
-0.3877434730529785,
0.3444693386554718,
-0.6756081581115723,
-0.3302510380744934,
-0.41210541129112244,
-0.09836741536855698,
-0.36178404092788696,
0.01492738164961338,
-0.44269609451293945,
-0.37111759185791016,
-0.39501330256462097,
0.3315325379371643,
0.6821427345275879,
0.602729082107544,
0.0640246570110321,
0.5602326989173889,
-0.5518583655357361,
0.6499565839767456,
0.6769868731498718,
0.37777259945869446,
0.027415968477725983,
-0.9478736519813538,
-0.3987448811531067,
-0.24357828497886658,
0.047406405210494995,
-0.3223109543323517,
0.24462611973285675,
0.5468235611915588,
0.26731574535369873,
0.41406145691871643,
0.38374537229537964,
0.7725965976715088,
-0.5769420862197876,
0.2364661991596222,
-0.033793676644563675,
-0.8827182054519653,
0.2122587412595749,
-0.5208539962768555,
0.5411694645881653,
0.6814159154891968,
0.04929228127002716,
-0.0872039645910263,
-0.06278425455093384,
-0.03660556301474571,
-0.7401458024978638,
0.7322508692741394,
0.09594465792179108,
-0.043542373925447464,
0.20217406749725342,
0.13737492263317108,
0.1689721792936325,
-0.018565848469734192,
-0.3930422067642212,
-0.016567477956414223,
0.10680756717920303,
-0.048522528260946274,
-0.24391235411167145,
-0.5073044300079346,
-0.05428748205304146,
-0.1398518830537796,
0.7495664954185486,
-0.3482367694377899,
0.22381986677646637,
-0.1546219140291214,
-0.402517169713974,
-0.44532808661460876,
0.537358283996582,
0.6221091747283936,
0.45439326763153076,
-0.5307993292808533,
0.11992862075567245,
0.3973453938961029,
-0.2927173376083374,
-0.17520242929458618,
0.1974957287311554,
-0.1362181007862091,
-0.354465514421463,
0.30591580271720886,
0.9595293402671814,
0.5136010050773621,
-0.6694192290306091,
0.07020317763090134,
-0.014695974066853523,
0.035446275025606155,
-0.27148520946502686,
0.1904946118593216,
-0.02641761675477028,
0.6389175653457642,
0.46339598298072815,
-0.1967764049768448,
0.0800013616681099,
-0.734050989151001,
-0.33989691734313965,
0.26705098152160645,
-0.20246167480945587,
-0.3264850378036499,
0.5972863435745239,
-0.07247861474752426,
-0.26395779848098755,
0.4441644549369812,
0.0009090041858144104,
-0.2035534530878067,
0.07012473046779633,
0.5617133378982544,
0.7175135016441345,
-0.24466858804225922,
-0.1645258218050003,
0.3281421363353729,
0.08964711427688599,
-0.03434905782341957,
0.31110361218452454,
0.13255509734153748,
-0.7008382081985474,
-0.34546032547950745,
-1.0044448375701904,
-0.2685554623603821,
0.15051902830600739,
-0.913490355014801,
0.3204435706138611,
-0.6158788800239563,
-0.21006843447685242,
0.07673831284046173,
-0.2597028911113739,
-0.47420573234558105,
-0.21896080672740936,
0.4213627278804779,
0.8077138066291809,
-0.7214546203613281,
1.0464707612991333,
0.5925701856613159,
-0.18071258068084717,
-0.2045915126800537,
-0.050928931683301926,
-0.291046142578125,
-0.8446241617202759,
0.68989497423172,
-0.25872600078582764,
-0.5445971488952637,
0.3121702969074249,
-0.210168719291687,
-0.9290106892585754,
1.058919906616211,
0.620161235332489,
-0.38412150740623474,
0.028411054983735085,
0.2668639123439789,
0.6160056591033936,
-0.4455820918083191,
-0.008022960275411606,
0.8515493273735046,
0.39828261733055115,
-0.20915871858596802,
-1.0008858442306519,
0.005300124641507864,
-0.11082755774259567,
0.3614051043987274,
0.3322521448135376,
-0.4091968536376953,
1.0575711727142334,
-0.18691441416740417,
-0.07842740416526794,
0.6865128874778748,
0.9225083589553833,
0.28119486570358276,
-0.07829641550779343,
0.6636515855789185,
0.5091325044631958,
0.8242209553718567,
0.18949532508850098,
0.749504804611206,
-0.1207609549164772,
0.05295860022306442,
1.01007878780365,
-0.4417266845703125,
1.406815767288208,
0.4740508794784546,
-0.19731998443603516,
0.5637844204902649,
0.10645902156829834,
0.3545299172401428,
0.6312144994735718,
0.08179780095815659,
-0.008536369539797306,
-0.42486658692359924,
-0.18910717964172363,
-0.4602310359477997,
0.6365525126457214,
0.3628515303134918,
-0.17061465978622437,
-0.3243028521537781,
0.21903996169567108,
0.11435110121965408,
0.29296085238456726,
-0.7336806058883667,
0.7553155422210693,
-0.0016649675089865923,
-0.3846299648284912,
1.0345877408981323,
0.12824510037899017,
0.5134110450744629,
-0.36156925559043884,
-0.048075251281261444,
-0.17375923693180084,
0.4355064630508423,
0.011636645533144474,
-0.06884592771530151,
-0.1713199019432068,
-0.10003405809402466,
-0.4048401415348053,
-0.08604622632265091,
0.47741931676864624,
-0.4446024000644684,
-0.4267738163471222,
0.3933861553668976,
0.5267650485038757,
-0.317210853099823,
-0.14675994217395782,
-0.26308298110961914,
0.28660812973976135,
-0.504683256149292,
-0.12182868272066116,
0.731897234916687,
0.38876402378082275,
-0.21894341707229614,
0.47982779145240784,
0.6401132345199585,
-0.06210379675030708,
-0.04972507059574127,
-0.12374653667211533,
1.117780089378357,
-0.4900984764099121,
-0.4564438462257385,
-0.6589492559432983,
0.2946186065673828,
0.24815918505191803,
-0.20871993899345398,
0.6363149881362915,
0.3970983028411865,
0.44280800223350525,
-0.18709775805473328,
0.6910760402679443,
0.16782423853874207,
0.8585857152938843,
-0.9661927819252014,
0.8890418410301208,
-0.6158682703971863,
0.3240554630756378,
-0.14586329460144043,
-1.09097158908844,
-0.37774771451950073,
0.6445610523223877,
-0.46837085485458374,
0.005093620624393225,
0.6828057169914246,
0.7132688164710999,
-0.15499374270439148,
-0.38646531105041504,
0.5079504251480103,
0.4945681095123291,
-0.21549491584300995,
0.5268062353134155,
0.7648378610610962,
-0.42496931552886963,
0.41046929359436035,
0.09600764513015747,
-0.33830398321151733,
-0.648814857006073,
-0.9190247058868408,
-1.1232277154922485,
-0.33550333976745605,
-0.36850520968437195,
-0.39656031131744385,
0.45194491744041443,
0.9978877902030945,
0.6435537934303284,
-0.8954451680183411,
-0.3219524621963501,
0.3492434024810791,
-0.0005510856281034648,
-0.11169138550758362,
-0.11678806692361832,
0.5785129070281982,
-0.33622920513153076,
-0.9148519039154053,
0.5843396186828613,
0.4519706666469574,
-0.3706294894218445,
-0.3335739076137543,
-0.26442471146583557,
0.13507604598999023,
0.07519878447055817,
0.7388023734092712,
0.5696147680282593,
-0.3812941610813141,
-0.1712782382965088,
0.026252560317516327,
-0.1929945945739746,
0.463985413312912,
0.4691762924194336,
-0.9787468314170837,
0.19833803176879883,
0.552009642124176,
0.6475052237510681,
0.30063629150390625,
-0.03956430032849312,
0.4769558310508728,
-0.3286086618900299,
0.23575882613658905,
0.016884835436940193,
0.26080894470214844,
0.16842862963676453,
-0.07027475535869598,
0.3364141285419464,
-0.28155696392059326,
-0.27860644459724426,
-1.1184381246566772,
0.05481957271695137,
-1.2400752305984497,
-0.07308853417634964,
1.1540576219558716,
0.15662413835525513,
-0.5266667604446411,
-0.04032285138964653,
-0.26585853099823,
0.12810038030147552,
-0.5936875939369202,
0.9505314230918884,
-0.015028081834316254,
0.24018900096416473,
-0.37057411670684814,
-0.6324026584625244,
0.5433076620101929,
0.4409880042076111,
-0.9951310753822327,
-0.027511147782206535,
0.22451822459697723,
-0.015688035637140274,
0.16085508465766907,
0.5939598679542542,
0.05322028696537018,
0.32513588666915894,
-0.3588421940803528,
0.19276699423789978,
-0.12748070061206818,
-0.16368786990642548,
-0.6276238560676575,
0.3890525996685028,
0.8875573873519897,
-0.17158366739749908
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.01771v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.01771v1
|
LLMs Beyond English: Scaling the Multilingual Capability of LLMs with Cross-Lingual Feedback
| 2024-06-03T20:25:12 | 2024-06-03T20:25:12 |
Wen Lai, Mohsen Mesgar, Alexander Fraser
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
To democratize large language models (LLMs) to most natural languages, it is
imperative to make these models capable of understanding and generating texts
in many languages, in particular low-resource ones. While recent multilingual
LLMs demonstrate remarkable performance in such capabilities, these LLMs still
support a limited number of human languages due to the lack of training data
for low-resource languages. Moreover, these LLMs are not yet aligned with human
preference for downstream tasks, which is crucial for the success of LLMs in
English. In this paper, we introduce xLLaMA-100 and xBLOOM-100 (collectively
xLLMs-100), which scale the multilingual capabilities of LLaMA and BLOOM to 100
languages. To do so, we construct two datasets: a multilingual instruction
dataset including 100 languages, which represents the largest language coverage
to date, and a cross-lingual human feedback dataset encompassing 30 languages.
We perform multilingual instruction tuning on the constructed instruction data
and further align the LLMs with human feedback using the DPO algorithm on our
cross-lingual human feedback dataset. We evaluate the multilingual
understanding and generating capabilities of xLLMs-100 on five multilingual
benchmarks. Experimental results show that xLLMs-100 consistently outperforms
its peers across the benchmarks by considerable margins, defining a new
state-of-the-art multilingual LLM that supports 100 languages.
|
[
-0.3949485421180725,
-0.28334417939186096,
0.4360315799713135,
0.4097083508968353,
0.12118265777826309,
0.5304527282714844,
-0.5900323390960693,
-0.5580804347991943,
0.247135192155838,
0.3107597231864929,
-0.6136361360549927,
-0.422922819852829,
-0.4898117184638977,
0.32426121830940247,
-0.052057668566703796,
0.8313478231430054,
-0.19301825761795044,
0.48161187767982483,
-0.14788012206554413,
-0.2978329658508301,
-0.5397828817367554,
-0.5386406779289246,
-0.64577317237854,
-0.401195764541626,
0.7814778685569763,
0.5348522663116455,
0.47476324439048767,
0.5224094986915588,
0.24821507930755615,
0.3459875285625458,
-0.0070662773214280605,
0.5244956612586975,
-0.5695667266845703,
-0.06421437859535217,
-0.09005989134311676,
-0.792079746723175,
-0.7503951787948608,
-0.3592926561832428,
0.9205327033996582,
0.8054415583610535,
0.024884486570954323,
0.13584013283252716,
0.17386998236179352,
0.6100311875343323,
-0.34417110681533813,
0.15361270308494568,
-0.5246968269348145,
0.11000458896160126,
-0.24921247363090515,
-0.16664190590381622,
-0.5783092975616455,
0.09243611246347427,
-0.2951405346393585,
-0.6205052733421326,
-0.3544178009033203,
0.37433210015296936,
0.4515981078147888,
-0.15189144015312195,
-0.5020804405212402,
-0.40525755286216736,
-0.6697880625724792,
1.2835047245025635,
-0.576496422290802,
0.7673898339271545,
0.37810268998146057,
0.07020007073879242,
0.19366730749607086,
-0.3542242646217346,
-0.21710185706615448,
-0.3211687505245209,
-0.13538967072963715,
-0.0435439795255661,
-0.17702077329158783,
-0.3335815370082855,
-0.048395708203315735,
0.2218168079853058,
-0.48980623483657837,
0.5082114338874817,
-0.19303420186042786,
-0.103358194231987,
0.7059385776519775,
0.33580854535102844,
0.31690549850463867,
0.03635009005665779,
-0.2926401197910309,
-0.011240954510867596,
-1.0836825370788574,
0.15977677702903748,
0.1822417825460434,
0.42942187190055847,
-0.18423326313495636,
0.4068947434425354,
0.038184624165296555,
0.46214327216148376,
-0.2766505479812622,
-0.46652427315711975,
0.24618209898471832,
-0.4882678687572479,
-0.0783328264951706,
0.005042893812060356,
0.658312201499939,
0.20455975830554962,
0.05857209861278534,
-0.25593096017837524,
-0.3363913893699646,
-0.24421849846839905,
-0.06179184094071388,
-0.5932049751281738,
0.32464268803596497,
0.2246505618095398,
-0.22201578319072723,
0.06976843625307083,
-0.1801949441432953,
-0.6192082166671753,
-0.2635229825973511,
-0.48425808548927307,
0.3476848006248474,
-0.32115301489830017,
-0.3561173677444458,
0.05574868991971016,
0.32893043756484985,
0.25416243076324463,
0.3118233382701874,
-0.9937692284584045,
0.2699390649795532,
0.6916323304176331,
0.9301811456680298,
-0.22633986175060272,
-0.6756401062011719,
-0.35133954882621765,
0.306459903717041,
-0.6875253319740295,
0.7040774822235107,
-0.4655572772026062,
-0.4233602285385132,
0.0011475953506305814,
0.29979193210601807,
0.09694120287895203,
-0.4516963064670563,
0.21530340611934662,
-0.5314509272575378,
0.32155734300613403,
-0.45535507798194885,
-0.5846987962722778,
-0.19269688427448273,
0.4875551462173462,
-0.47618749737739563,
0.8998732566833496,
-0.04503346607089043,
-0.4657231569290161,
0.3061172664165497,
-0.5136414170265198,
-0.45833709836006165,
0.1967000961303711,
-0.10042963922023773,
-0.13004378974437714,
0.10798267275094986,
0.23447059094905853,
0.3013856112957001,
-0.29577186703681946,
-0.02887098677456379,
-0.20875339210033417,
-0.3952491879463196,
-0.0786910131573677,
-0.593275249004364,
0.7791450619697571,
-0.04036875441670418,
-0.4953113794326782,
0.2263508141040802,
-0.577167809009552,
0.33692142367362976,
0.1139376312494278,
-0.4226089417934418,
-0.27441534399986267,
-0.09829849749803543,
-0.02600177749991417,
0.12434042990207672,
0.3537895083427429,
-0.6098067760467529,
0.1987401843070984,
-0.24385666847229004,
0.3836710453033447,
0.7421262860298157,
-0.5681784152984619,
0.4577769637107849,
-0.34902867674827576,
0.8495538830757141,
-0.36068037152290344,
-0.0021869090851396322,
-0.6450859904289246,
-0.41826722025871277,
-0.7894738912582397,
-0.4149566888809204,
0.08492688089609146,
0.7661048173904419,
-0.6104475259780884,
0.23734338581562042,
-0.4881857633590698,
-0.416822224855423,
-0.6535494923591614,
0.697544276714325,
0.44325241446495056,
0.1048046126961708,
0.25821995735168457,
0.0067320349626243114,
-0.6214208602905273,
-0.5804049372673035,
0.09449990093708038,
-0.1118064597249031,
-0.15151308476924896,
0.3987237513065338,
0.13617606461048126,
-0.4320146441459656,
0.47630807757377625,
-0.19259801506996155,
-0.5131891965866089,
-0.4687988758087158,
-0.2224363535642624,
0.09648091346025467,
0.04124566912651062,
0.4184887111186981,
-0.5141683220863342,
-0.577591061592102,
0.4579905569553375,
-0.6147274374961853,
-0.14766883850097656,
-0.052106186747550964,
-0.06773211807012558,
0.6763681173324585,
0.4943028390407562,
-0.29167720675468445,
-0.08829322457313538,
1.0243241786956787,
-0.1477680206298828,
0.3673538267612457,
-0.4497167766094208,
0.18134158849716187,
-1.1819968223571777,
-0.15767012536525726,
-0.28344491124153137,
-0.4205344319343567,
-0.46614816784858704,
0.06911872327327728,
0.2659515142440796,
0.07023216784000397,
-0.6052122116088867,
0.7412592768669128,
-0.7754862904548645,
-0.1929541975259781,
-0.35611769556999207,
0.34188780188560486,
0.31016024947166443,
0.3312239646911621,
0.19902648031711578,
0.6714597344398499,
0.557243287563324,
-0.327152281999588,
0.5756421089172363,
0.10765287280082703,
-0.23569706082344055,
0.4494333267211914,
-0.5339613556861877,
-0.03864907845854759,
-0.02847309410572052,
0.3092871308326721,
-0.8861469626426697,
-0.034373149275779724,
-0.19288432598114014,
-0.1544826775789261,
0.48441705107688904,
0.11910269409418106,
-0.4419083893299103,
-0.26507171988487244,
-0.6230944395065308,
0.3161105811595917,
0.3892069160938263,
-0.5502492785453796,
0.6201068758964539,
0.44099244475364685,
-0.3544867932796478,
-0.6355634927749634,
-0.879756510257721,
0.3591478168964386,
-0.11666269600391388,
-0.5761914849281311,
0.26383647322654724,
-0.12884876132011414,
-0.4033524692058563,
-0.186366006731987,
0.30264487862586975,
0.2005642056465149,
-0.2956036627292633,
0.22560743987560272,
0.34080031514167786,
-0.34080156683921814,
0.3390336334705353,
0.1694464087486267,
0.00444745272397995,
0.015480663627386093,
-0.2598707973957062,
0.6867413520812988,
-0.20991864800453186,
-0.5624843239784241,
-0.18478111922740936,
0.5089784264564514,
0.5249795913696289,
-0.22091540694236755,
0.6992535591125488,
0.4947070777416229,
-0.1540548950433731,
-0.29549023509025574,
-0.2969494163990021,
-0.10718590021133423,
-0.4427075982093811,
0.6254501342773438,
-0.39981168508529663,
-0.8234806060791016,
0.41580525040626526,
0.028216185048222542,
0.4984525144100189,
0.17764444649219513,
0.8919366002082825,
-0.007265624590218067,
1.1402382850646973,
0.8235803842544556,
-0.27892768383026123,
0.3324182331562042,
-0.24311907589435577,
0.08950232714414597,
-0.6813182234764099,
-0.32258108258247375,
-0.29726123809814453,
-0.25075045228004456,
-0.7134991884231567,
-0.5443021655082703,
0.27519315481185913,
-0.14003175497055054,
0.04791980981826782,
0.25245457887649536,
0.04758324846625328,
0.4977569580078125,
0.5235630869865417,
-0.1843864917755127,
0.4143175482749939,
0.13084553182125092,
-0.09454561024904251,
-0.1588277518749237,
-0.8592705130577087,
-0.646305501461029,
1.071054458618164,
0.39774858951568604,
0.8818888664245605,
0.1389515995979309,
0.6397923231124878,
0.029407218098640442,
0.5198687314987183,
-0.7478175759315491,
0.4153778553009033,
-0.44475236535072327,
-0.4904896020889282,
-0.45787370204925537,
-0.45585474371910095,
-0.9231679439544678,
0.32618948817253113,
0.029888112097978592,
-0.29427680373191833,
-0.23404425382614136,
-0.039505485445261,
-0.29448240995407104,
0.5930100083351135,
-0.7329888939857483,
0.4537684917449951,
-0.6949192881584167,
-0.5046637654304504,
-0.4026835560798645,
-0.33070671558380127,
0.172699972987175,
-0.3616896867752075,
0.6896811723709106,
-0.12831570208072662,
-0.5616106986999512,
0.4835279583930969,
-0.04376157373189926,
0.9702073931694031,
0.1624140739440918,
-0.8797865509986877,
-0.06683249026536942,
-0.0273866206407547,
0.2444104552268982,
0.2265130877494812,
-0.06507154554128647,
0.5085925459861755,
-0.034936852753162384,
-0.5216324925422668,
-0.3367564082145691,
0.9992796182632446,
-0.8960897326469421,
-0.608307957649231,
-0.1264144480228424,
-0.9762527346611023,
-0.40420398116111755,
0.21542784571647644,
0.13268792629241943,
0.4752408564090729,
0.03273089975118637,
0.10213617235422134,
0.5170497298240662,
-0.3890593349933624,
0.5660578012466431,
0.788547933101654,
-0.6372575163841248,
-0.5076985359191895,
1.0556570291519165,
0.3980497717857361,
0.30370795726776123,
0.7410507798194885,
0.04661516845226288,
-0.44116663932800293,
-0.24080069363117218,
-0.8493510484695435,
0.4062427878379822,
-0.6120514869689941,
-0.23314093053340912,
-0.38834571838378906,
0.010628389194607735,
-0.4159533381462097,
-0.18675316870212555,
-0.32857173681259155,
-0.23220592737197876,
-0.20100939273834229,
0.02286517061293125,
0.015114386565983295,
1.0940523147583008,
-0.19289106130599976,
-0.004282260779291391,
-1.044419527053833,
0.12113972008228302,
0.3582213521003723,
0.27242526412010193,
0.06985282152891159,
-0.7825756669044495,
-0.5227593183517456,
0.2845747470855713,
-0.26486364006996155,
-0.6294888854026794,
0.4168870449066162,
0.385196328163147,
0.44472911953926086,
0.35378971695899963,
-0.2490951418876648,
0.7462315559387207,
-0.8399107456207275,
0.701149582862854,
0.037870101630687714,
-1.0601632595062256,
0.3246992230415344,
-0.1066114604473114,
0.4259283244609833,
0.058506473898887634,
0.7108351588249207,
-0.7205851078033447,
-0.5050137042999268,
-0.053021062165498734,
-0.8688825368881226,
0.7563170194625854,
-0.23710374534130096,
0.5828543901443481,
0.19965805113315582,
0.05552349239587784,
0.34410834312438965,
0.044633086770772934,
-0.8030227422714233,
-0.20244313776493073,
0.029818780720233917,
-0.039620719850063324,
-0.25487184524536133,
-0.24469788372516632,
-0.18414077162742615,
-0.0723506361246109,
0.7290103435516357,
-0.31634974479675293,
-0.1385587453842163,
-0.15546177327632904,
-0.11271543055772781,
-0.24305883049964905,
0.3348103165626526,
0.7453130483627319,
0.9381574392318726,
0.0378531888127327,
0.1496487259864807,
0.5440425872802734,
-0.34548646211624146,
0.4645977318286896,
-0.14517895877361298,
-0.027654515579342842,
-0.0697406455874443,
0.9682541489601135,
0.8038774728775024,
0.27845942974090576,
-0.8962498307228088,
0.10496886074542999,
-0.07460413128137589,
0.04747448489069939,
-0.14987130463123322,
-0.03620871156454086,
0.32910430431365967,
0.16682033240795135,
0.43266597390174866,
-0.4136779308319092,
-0.2873525321483612,
-0.5431326031684875,
0.1800629198551178,
0.5626890659332275,
-0.3139714002609253,
-0.5301612019538879,
0.40302973985671997,
0.2793194651603699,
-0.24143579602241516,
0.2912274897098541,
-0.14825581014156342,
-0.3735071122646332,
0.3918890058994293,
0.562214195728302,
0.5117733478546143,
-0.3241685628890991,
0.25779736042022705,
0.2864677309989929,
0.5123422741889954,
0.08977201581001282,
0.32297375798225403,
-0.04979284107685089,
-0.6718671321868896,
-0.872623085975647,
-0.4908272624015808,
-0.611714243888855,
0.024213772267103195,
-0.6457576751708984,
0.4175429940223694,
-0.19562742114067078,
-0.13002139329910278,
-0.2635536193847656,
0.33482030034065247,
-0.24327616393566132,
0.0650099664926529,
0.48989924788475037,
0.935695230960846,
-0.8005545735359192,
0.975986123085022,
0.909488320350647,
-0.05439187213778496,
-0.7928213477134705,
-0.18900147080421448,
0.011323511600494385,
-1.1004297733306885,
0.7560508251190186,
0.23161660134792328,
-0.1945931315422058,
-0.03913835808634758,
-0.06206627935171127,
-0.8507786393165588,
1.1768327951431274,
0.7344509363174438,
-1.0513020753860474,
-0.06017781049013138,
0.5273138880729675,
0.6407700181007385,
-0.4051014184951782,
0.36221444606781006,
0.3690018057823181,
0.42345893383026123,
-0.13418316841125488,
-1.00453519821167,
-0.23421718180179596,
0.037567175924777985,
0.08105207234621048,
0.22116073966026306,
-0.8712254762649536,
0.6879833936691284,
-0.41072699427604675,
-0.1031641960144043,
-0.017248906195163727,
0.603256106376648,
0.4663101136684418,
0.1921698898077011,
0.4901910722255707,
0.4791930317878723,
0.7049363851547241,
0.00702269934117794,
1.1480584144592285,
-0.5472916960716248,
0.22602863609790802,
0.992207407951355,
-0.5707249641418457,
1.052319884300232,
0.5410811305046082,
-0.416910856962204,
0.4805855453014374,
0.5350806713104248,
0.35023704171180725,
0.122073233127594,
0.04098401218652725,
-0.3044208586215973,
-0.176680326461792,
-0.41913142800331116,
-0.29145196080207825,
0.4668445587158203,
0.26111212372779846,
-0.1311013102531433,
-0.1611367166042328,
0.25546973943710327,
0.31972557306289673,
-0.03832434490323067,
-0.5526363253593445,
0.7180253863334656,
0.15599650144577026,
-0.5103211402893066,
0.699962317943573,
0.03806808590888977,
0.9275974035263062,
-0.9484757781028748,
0.03792988881468773,
-0.6606826782226562,
0.22917227447032928,
-0.27613043785095215,
-0.90385901927948,
0.19740258157253265,
0.1316535472869873,
-0.220261812210083,
-0.5680393576622009,
0.18997065722942352,
-0.7637378573417664,
-0.8896017670631409,
0.8063238859176636,
0.5889675617218018,
-0.10428332537412643,
0.2707540690898895,
-0.4692244231700897,
0.4115141034126282,
0.15584470331668854,
-0.3225472569465637,
0.4670286774635315,
0.535740852355957,
-0.19960136711597443,
0.8164664506912231,
0.5005930662155151,
0.586922287940979,
0.23376472294330597,
0.16995100677013397,
0.6243098378181458,
-0.4450114965438843,
-0.22367490828037262,
-0.8458777070045471,
0.13101401925086975,
0.25214865803718567,
-0.20347623527050018,
1.1596838235855103,
0.40244272351264954,
1.131596326828003,
0.10257133841514587,
0.5497263669967651,
0.06129550561308861,
0.44759729504585266,
-0.4487326145172119,
0.5249487161636353,
-0.9221426844596863,
0.3818817138671875,
0.1423366516828537,
-0.8162632584571838,
-0.22742785513401031,
0.10616833716630936,
-0.15064334869384766,
0.1453910768032074,
0.443899542093277,
0.8597252368927002,
0.13951212167739868,
-0.26684096455574036,
0.7010390758514404,
0.09547103941440582,
0.3885340690612793,
0.6644447445869446,
0.6885842084884644,
-0.17841216921806335,
0.7251551151275635,
-0.3087746202945709,
-0.27289047837257385,
0.08485031127929688,
-0.7499048113822937,
-0.7516322731971741,
-0.3978818356990814,
-0.05943939462304115,
0.08276427537202835,
-0.3112110495567322,
0.7885593175888062,
0.9832490086555481,
-0.9640241861343384,
-0.6451081037521362,
0.27163583040237427,
0.2336840182542801,
-0.13240884244441986,
-0.19460661709308624,
0.22798460721969604,
-0.6799278259277344,
-1.2137551307678223,
0.6180236339569092,
0.6001923680305481,
-0.04553000256419182,
-0.8715681433677673,
-0.40526285767555237,
0.015229570679366589,
0.22785207629203796,
0.8343858122825623,
0.09989067912101746,
-0.7128420472145081,
0.1906701922416687,
0.3678494691848755,
-0.14975868165493011,
-0.032794039696455,
0.7395163178443909,
-0.6042270064353943,
0.24125805497169495,
0.4226245582103729,
0.6840347051620483,
-0.009969053789973259,
-0.5274293422698975,
0.6865410208702087,
-0.8971190452575684,
0.29522088170051575,
-0.08685196191072464,
0.4667912423610687,
0.6313865184783936,
-0.21985824406147003,
0.37819284200668335,
-0.14419281482696533,
-0.45662015676498413,
-0.9437513947486877,
0.12523750960826874,
-0.3787247836589813,
-0.27615973353385925,
1.2434955835342407,
-0.4143035411834717,
-0.23959383368492126,
0.10844559222459793,
-0.3103553056716919,
-0.1568610966205597,
-0.20641833543777466,
0.6222336888313293,
0.7537975907325745,
-0.09449777752161026,
-0.3038104474544525,
-0.3871820569038391,
0.10547970235347748,
0.7025465965270996,
-1.0429972410202026,
0.14501020312309265,
0.236413836479187,
0.13583074510097504,
0.37396126985549927,
0.4622817039489746,
-0.04943818971514702,
0.1320732682943344,
-0.190887451171875,
0.02087268978357315,
0.020675180479884148,
-0.36899521946907043,
-0.5185003280639648,
0.0574512779712677,
0.19723404943943024,
0.027474135160446167
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.06575v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.06575v1
|
Ask-EDA: A Design Assistant Empowered by LLM, Hybrid RAG and Abbreviation De-hallucination
| 2024-06-03T19:40:28 | 2024-06-03T19:40:28 |
Luyao Shi, Michael Kazda, Bradley Sears, Nick Shropshire, Ruchir Puri
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Electronic design engineers are challenged to find relevant information
efficiently for a myriad of tasks within design construction, verification and
technology development. Large language models (LLM) have the potential to help
improve productivity by serving as conversational agents that effectively
function as subject-matter experts. In this paper we demonstrate Ask-EDA, a
chat agent designed to serve as a 24x7 expert available to provide guidance to
design engineers. Ask-EDA leverages LLM, hybrid retrieval augmented generation
(RAG) and abbreviation de-hallucination (ADH) techniques to deliver more
relevant and accurate responses. We curated three evaluation datasets, namely
q2a-100, cmds-100 and abbr-100. Each dataset is tailored to assess a distinct
aspect: general design question answering, design command handling and
abbreviation resolution. We demonstrated that hybrid RAG offers over a 40%
improvement in Recall on the q2a-100 dataset and over a 60% improvement on the
cmds-100 dataset compared to not using RAG, while ADH yields over a 70%
enhancement in Recall on the abbr-100 dataset. The evaluation results show that
Ask-EDA can effectively respond to design-related inquiries.
|
[
-0.8195236921310425,
-1.3885695934295654,
0.681053638458252,
0.16619867086410522,
-0.2984844744205475,
0.5241509675979614,
0.02507833018898964,
-0.6515046954154968,
0.7308685779571533,
0.2797224223613739,
-0.4529292583465576,
-0.21162760257720947,
-0.04396964609622955,
0.04783929884433746,
-0.09309235215187073,
0.39863070845603943,
-0.38930001854896545,
-0.08205556124448776,
-0.048317693173885345,
0.08549299836158752,
-0.8946117162704468,
-0.3048214912414551,
-0.8708537817001343,
0.1337919533252716,
0.4757568836212158,
0.3214503824710846,
0.5211309194564819,
0.047502435743808746,
0.4654884338378906,
0.35459375381469727,
-0.25031590461730957,
0.7929644584655762,
-0.201834037899971,
0.3896079957485199,
0.07076568901538849,
-0.3917929232120514,
-1.0202161073684692,
-0.20343026518821716,
-0.10498908162117004,
0.544743537902832,
-0.18023008108139038,
0.3589370548725128,
-0.053141798824071884,
0.7469735741615295,
-0.504526674747467,
0.14799487590789795,
-0.5474923253059387,
-0.145638108253479,
0.1049649640917778,
-0.5652815699577332,
-0.5905379056930542,
-0.24244403839111328,
-0.10876685380935669,
-0.9216330051422119,
-0.2572684586048126,
0.0672539621591568,
0.7007099986076355,
0.49673736095428467,
-0.2670052945613861,
-0.5902897715568542,
-1.080431580543518,
0.4462697505950928,
-0.36076125502586365,
0.8228235840797424,
0.3722775876522064,
0.3015291392803192,
-0.1772899329662323,
-0.33609721064567566,
-0.5875859260559082,
-0.13967277109622955,
-0.045510027557611465,
0.3411024808883667,
-0.11395630240440369,
0.31584158539772034,
0.1078927144408226,
0.32912808656692505,
-0.7353768944740295,
0.1068539023399353,
-0.381803423166275,
-0.08145254850387573,
0.8000235557556152,
0.051232676953077316,
0.4226059019565582,
0.01645750366151333,
-0.066194087266922,
0.02333124540746212,
-0.5449411869049072,
-0.31802627444267273,
0.35949981212615967,
-0.00866592675447464,
0.04406709223985672,
0.30308204889297485,
-0.049053341150283813,
0.6930912137031555,
0.23575741052627563,
0.292690634727478,
0.16261717677116394,
-0.18316145241260529,
-0.013302793726325035,
-0.4065740704536438,
0.4534268081188202,
0.2850596308708191,
0.10221362113952637,
-0.20604975521564484,
-0.361541748046875,
-0.09047064185142517,
0.45078763365745544,
-0.5447623133659363,
-0.27286985516548157,
0.5746156573295593,
-0.43864551186561584,
-0.01401439681649208,
-0.020961854606866837,
-1.073662519454956,
-0.44524726271629333,
-0.7573803663253784,
0.4528368413448334,
0.1979483962059021,
-0.45344653725624084,
0.15760579705238342,
-0.3125165104866028,
0.3340890109539032,
0.46109601855278015,
-0.5558820962905884,
0.21694302558898926,
0.5386456251144409,
0.4508860111236572,
-0.15269231796264648,
0.270327627658844,
-0.4004511833190918,
-0.06993893533945084,
-0.6925463676452637,
0.9592243432998657,
-0.5143532156944275,
-0.805037796497345,
-0.2118103802204132,
-0.29493945837020874,
-0.08819489926099777,
-0.8474727869033813,
0.4569016695022583,
-0.9509212374687195,
0.24840354919433594,
-0.040913790464401245,
-0.16329988837242126,
-0.029255056753754616,
0.19330276548862457,
-0.6420666575431824,
0.9036189913749695,
0.010059265419840813,
-0.5137667655944824,
0.16875378787517548,
-0.7885246276855469,
-0.20755639672279358,
0.3509537875652313,
-0.6005958318710327,
-0.2353755682706833,
0.09191065281629562,
0.36582204699516296,
0.2591220438480377,
-0.17279134690761566,
0.19101861119270325,
-0.2946338355541229,
-0.279437780380249,
0.11333920806646347,
-0.3074563145637512,
0.37916120886802673,
0.4142618179321289,
-0.2364281713962555,
0.1250440627336502,
-0.8459505438804626,
0.2346513718366623,
0.14807680249214172,
-0.445640504360199,
-0.5580841302871704,
-0.20443712174892426,
0.1136590838432312,
0.07260944694280624,
0.2599296569824219,
-0.6457915306091309,
-0.009893171489238739,
-0.30553680658340454,
-0.06357141584157944,
0.9937343597412109,
0.04265804961323738,
0.3462221622467041,
-0.6346622705459595,
0.7708536386489868,
-0.4046032428741455,
0.03085564449429512,
0.1402221918106079,
-0.5879387855529785,
-0.8730051517486572,
-0.30047091841697693,
0.026468105614185333,
0.709102988243103,
-1.1160087585449219,
0.5239744186401367,
-0.05544742941856384,
-0.4804285764694214,
-0.5229843258857727,
0.08023020625114441,
0.1301305592060089,
0.19447529315948486,
0.24869750440120697,
0.014425446279346943,
-0.823667049407959,
-0.9212774634361267,
-0.10697536170482635,
-0.3803097605705261,
-0.4456976652145386,
0.8145233392715454,
0.10545158386230469,
-0.32755693793296814,
0.8149406313896179,
-0.6263023018836975,
0.04276068136096001,
-0.29327383637428284,
0.20033301413059235,
0.05250554904341698,
0.09073144197463989,
0.4953211545944214,
-0.9180161356925964,
-0.7693626880645752,
0.13502046465873718,
-0.7041193246841431,
-0.24920403957366943,
-0.34627315402030945,
-0.3162870705127716,
0.18549971282482147,
0.21173636615276337,
-0.8396279215812683,
0.18142488598823547,
0.3245878517627716,
-0.23160682618618011,
0.23272931575775146,
-0.17354753613471985,
0.3548302948474884,
-1.3854988813400269,
0.10737273097038269,
-0.32710862159729004,
0.05922736972570419,
-0.6682106256484985,
0.17971855401992798,
0.07153777033090591,
-0.3869149684906006,
-0.3110073506832123,
0.8161129951477051,
-0.5534467101097107,
0.09956056624650955,
-0.44599080085754395,
0.34734591841697693,
0.12813526391983032,
0.4975486695766449,
-0.10617689043283463,
1.1861544847488403,
0.21655842661857605,
-0.7807475924491882,
0.23901903629302979,
0.5063371658325195,
0.003037247573956847,
0.621523380279541,
-0.9362915754318237,
0.8188825249671936,
-0.38158681988716125,
0.17360346019268036,
-0.8778771162033081,
-0.10995423048734665,
-0.06455906480550766,
-0.29015281796455383,
0.3552134037017822,
0.4916062653064728,
-0.4923363924026489,
-0.7149624824523926,
-0.4349759519100189,
0.2848864793777466,
0.5032188296318054,
-0.8302918076515198,
0.899933397769928,
0.8562838435173035,
-0.4119274318218231,
-0.1890183985233307,
-0.21292196214199066,
-0.06979193538427353,
-0.10766024142503738,
-0.9977002739906311,
0.46505290269851685,
-0.5643666386604309,
-0.6470003128051758,
-0.444064199924469,
-0.17835475504398346,
-0.323093980550766,
0.3362608850002289,
0.13986703753471375,
0.6063616275787354,
-0.023924333974719048,
0.3806218206882477,
0.060359567403793335,
0.15347132086753845,
0.24740199744701385,
0.3073006868362427,
0.6252583265304565,
0.07139500975608826,
-0.3621082305908203,
-0.5438084602355957,
0.6659061312675476,
0.6036803126335144,
-0.14353884756565094,
0.20896536111831665,
0.10259854048490524,
-0.3876025378704071,
-0.5736674666404724,
-0.7176096439361572,
-0.37454020977020264,
-0.5918319821357727,
0.4242542088031769,
-0.7879524230957031,
-0.5416156649589539,
0.5803536176681519,
-0.020068975165486336,
0.6120099425315857,
0.39806419610977173,
0.4964275360107422,
-0.20871703326702118,
1.03534996509552,
0.6562857627868652,
0.15226417779922485,
0.4903016984462738,
-0.2525659203529358,
0.3431795835494995,
-0.8146264553070068,
-0.18770694732666016,
-0.378867506980896,
-0.27024027705192566,
-0.269486665725708,
-0.3982001841068268,
0.4512381851673126,
-0.399277001619339,
0.09894227236509323,
0.43155327439308167,
-0.597427248954773,
0.3281399607658386,
0.19580377638339996,
0.42102310061454773,
0.20047517120838165,
-0.2610778510570526,
0.32198646664619446,
0.2645995020866394,
-0.5179392099380493,
-0.6628625988960266,
0.8990179300308228,
0.5582248568534851,
1.2430334091186523,
0.04261281341314316,
0.6396080851554871,
0.23700456321239471,
0.06730208545923233,
-0.8649486899375916,
0.6562448143959045,
0.22566130757331848,
-0.6097215414047241,
-0.18604937195777893,
-0.33354490995407104,
-0.6970849633216858,
0.11535020917654037,
0.1603195071220398,
-0.35986196994781494,
0.4601826071739197,
0.189851775765419,
-0.5129430294036865,
0.2897961139678955,
-0.7667975425720215,
0.33219990134239197,
-0.3905895948410034,
-0.0574985146522522,
-0.42550525069236755,
-0.09769207239151001,
0.11862865835428238,
-0.32207927107810974,
0.4252183735370636,
0.15545043349266052,
-0.1687171757221222,
0.8400223851203918,
-0.07116498798131943,
0.6714602708816528,
0.11811596900224686,
-0.3352130949497223,
0.5129339694976807,
0.2519488036632538,
0.7478194236755371,
-0.10653701424598694,
-0.1404579132795334,
-0.42331838607788086,
-0.059981051832437515,
-0.007926170714199543,
-0.726317822933197,
0.653012216091156,
-0.8009622097015381,
-0.8528022766113281,
0.18850745260715485,
-0.5346325635910034,
-0.43165600299835205,
-0.20975565910339355,
0.023085789754986763,
0.5321869850158691,
-0.3118446171283722,
0.24372148513793945,
0.8045080900192261,
-0.40271857380867004,
0.2485862374305725,
0.5508797764778137,
-0.1366344690322876,
-0.19584804773330688,
0.8296334147453308,
0.11661885678768158,
0.1673625111579895,
0.5980696678161621,
0.04398532584309578,
-0.22078736126422882,
-0.19770768284797668,
-0.9232959151268005,
0.20286023616790771,
-0.7110726237297058,
-0.15434566140174866,
-1.1266371011734009,
-0.31158751249313354,
-0.2176535576581955,
-0.31099528074264526,
-0.4217805564403534,
-0.5940970778465271,
-0.35116034746170044,
-0.3134605884552002,
0.42927247285842896,
0.8865585327148438,
0.29074880480766296,
-0.20498026907444,
-0.7391519546508789,
0.4444233775138855,
0.5965911149978638,
0.35620129108428955,
-0.1196703240275383,
-0.5897690057754517,
0.09026756882667542,
-0.007412184029817581,
-0.5624217987060547,
-0.9965914487838745,
0.18783147633075714,
0.10827163606882095,
0.8725610971450806,
-0.006670523434877396,
0.28658851981163025,
0.2281407117843628,
-0.3493076264858246,
0.5821662545204163,
-0.27936774492263794,
-0.44747039675712585,
0.5236126184463501,
-0.3642180860042572,
0.037698112428188324,
0.26302370429039,
0.3741471767425537,
-0.3625519871711731,
-0.4032633900642395,
-0.6419663429260254,
-0.6593680381774902,
0.3073282241821289,
0.09846898913383484,
0.3059670031070709,
0.007326056715101004,
0.04025372862815857,
0.1739676147699356,
0.03833523765206337,
-0.10934845358133316,
-0.37341493368148804,
0.18685367703437805,
-0.15778686106204987,
0.5973110198974609,
-0.3821020722389221,
-0.25818920135498047,
0.024526463821530342,
0.6452435255050659,
-0.10507041215896606,
0.523025393486023,
0.05807443708181381,
0.135442852973938,
-0.12140822410583496,
0.5764597654342651,
0.5706202387809753,
1.072826862335205,
-0.05424685403704643,
-0.0673915445804596,
0.5126292705535889,
-0.3894178867340088,
-0.01979253813624382,
0.13050630688667297,
-0.012748392298817635,
0.3698105812072754,
-0.11311960965394974,
0.5210185647010803,
-0.20816825330257416,
-0.6914389133453369,
0.10687630623579025,
-0.2568606734275818,
-0.2749214172363281,
-0.2733466625213623,
-0.10228227078914642,
0.08313000947237015,
-0.029347941279411316,
0.41334855556488037,
-0.4934915006160736,
0.30600640177726746,
-0.5118340253829956,
0.43669161200523376,
0.5556002259254456,
-0.11501268297433853,
-0.3221937417984009,
0.8146277070045471,
0.7896304130554199,
-0.6845633387565613,
0.36761710047721863,
-0.0789719745516777,
-0.4318654537200928,
0.9865070581436157,
0.3287583887577057,
1.152024745941162,
-0.07092409580945969,
0.39637047052383423,
0.2636279761791229,
0.12972630560398102,
0.5407108068466187,
0.7890363335609436,
0.007883048616349697,
-0.3697788119316101,
-0.18262772262096405,
-0.38579636812210083,
-0.7880488038063049,
0.1664838343858719,
-0.37198248505592346,
0.3815908133983612,
-0.4759681224822998,
-0.10020969063043594,
0.022225618362426758,
-0.18426118791103363,
-0.683038592338562,
0.0008901138789951801,
-0.12272565811872482,
0.7487549781799316,
-0.505832850933075,
0.20453812181949615,
0.8756334781646729,
-0.256542831659317,
-0.86993008852005,
-0.32746291160583496,
-0.08404763042926788,
-0.5339035987854004,
0.6215388178825378,
-0.06671369820833206,
-0.005124326329678297,
-0.13988728821277618,
-0.09659019857645035,
-0.6298142671585083,
1.115901231765747,
-0.04577850177884102,
-0.6061198711395264,
-0.10175739973783493,
-0.12347305566072464,
0.610361635684967,
-0.16565659642219543,
0.7481070160865784,
0.3495357036590576,
0.277606725692749,
0.10197246819734573,
-1.387812614440918,
-0.001544024096801877,
-0.5551323890686035,
-0.22936618328094482,
0.347311407327652,
-0.7726390957832336,
0.6760796308517456,
-0.08312784135341644,
-0.35814279317855835,
-0.14674799144268036,
0.5272670388221741,
0.32918938994407654,
0.24370591342449188,
0.5973657369613647,
0.057953719049692154,
0.8799159526824951,
0.15917514264583588,
0.6769518256187439,
-0.6305953860282898,
-0.03408795967698097,
0.938700258731842,
0.02636905014514923,
0.7903746962547302,
0.45457199215888977,
-0.1109866350889206,
0.37580323219299316,
0.7190297842025757,
0.5254966020584106,
0.18127965927124023,
0.08016830682754517,
-0.39537161588668823,
-0.15678319334983826,
-0.17709685862064362,
-0.4410479962825775,
0.18720680475234985,
0.46736830472946167,
-0.2079213261604309,
-0.11049669981002808,
0.18194784224033356,
-0.17093531787395477,
0.19290989637374878,
-0.09576314687728882,
1.0103867053985596,
0.19310534000396729,
-0.4913909137248993,
0.6011870503425598,
-0.2651309669017792,
0.5596458911895752,
-0.27727946639060974,
-0.34794431924819946,
-0.44347068667411804,
0.25946399569511414,
0.01627419702708721,
-0.6306501030921936,
0.4695199429988861,
-0.18032772839069366,
-0.09918424487113953,
-0.2446773201227188,
0.5540104508399963,
-0.16205449402332306,
-0.33904871344566345,
0.2095504105091095,
0.736636757850647,
0.19561904668807983,
-0.09099636971950531,
-0.5720543265342712,
0.18567416071891785,
-0.19703102111816406,
-0.21401436626911163,
-0.003352057421579957,
0.23146021366119385,
-0.06735809892416,
0.7977936267852783,
0.3073630928993225,
0.04124210402369499,
-0.033792994916439056,
0.02052883803844452,
1.276641845703125,
-0.1929498016834259,
-0.4319765567779541,
-0.28617364168167114,
0.4144035279750824,
-0.16431768238544464,
-0.23472513258457184,
0.623110294342041,
0.5873730778694153,
0.7486861944198608,
-0.20780695974826813,
0.8550515174865723,
-0.060365382581949234,
0.8112949132919312,
-0.3988378047943115,
0.5646008253097534,
-0.5597293972969055,
0.46432948112487793,
-0.1403665691614151,
-0.9158015251159668,
0.19708958268165588,
0.397919237613678,
-0.202499657869339,
0.06419432908296585,
0.666222095489502,
1.1424198150634766,
-0.15214647352695465,
0.2696627378463745,
0.28864169120788574,
-0.15628467500209808,
0.8870263695716858,
0.4378410875797272,
0.9087578654289246,
-0.3565411865711212,
0.5853524804115295,
-0.3305184543132782,
-0.4238194525241852,
-0.0357416570186615,
-0.22391684353351593,
-1.141303539276123,
-0.5110264420509338,
-0.15211470425128937,
0.051401421427726746,
0.04911527410149574,
1.186482548713684,
0.5453776121139526,
-0.6820308566093445,
-0.15080280601978302,
0.064874067902565,
0.014121460728347301,
0.09175248444080353,
-0.20640051364898682,
0.4255315661430359,
-0.2892405390739441,
-0.914211630821228,
0.6618735790252686,
0.03899119421839714,
0.10963254421949387,
-0.4500557780265808,
0.1485081911087036,
0.041839271783828735,
0.431812047958374,
0.608493983745575,
0.22515219449996948,
-0.5728859305381775,
-0.28215330839157104,
0.5361390709877014,
-0.21227280795574188,
-0.06955353915691376,
0.5151336193084717,
-0.5273613929748535,
0.8581362366676331,
0.9071428179740906,
1.1978299617767334,
-0.034599851816892624,
0.23687177896499634,
0.8492175340652466,
-0.47283801436424255,
0.04692772403359413,
0.26616501808166504,
0.10466007888317108,
0.18097513914108276,
-0.7366725206375122,
0.46215224266052246,
-0.06025433540344238,
-0.807950496673584,
-0.5401849150657654,
0.0902649536728859,
-0.7474030256271362,
-0.1858171820640564,
1.2283413410186768,
0.2557961344718933,
-0.03723999485373497,
-0.38387539982795715,
-0.8143596649169922,
-0.05096691474318504,
-0.45592111349105835,
1.090540885925293,
0.47556477785110474,
-0.2621961832046509,
-0.17950716614723206,
-0.8166094422340393,
0.4472842514514923,
0.4350843131542206,
-1.2513172626495361,
0.0007864240324124694,
0.49974703788757324,
-0.18499082326889038,
0.2928840219974518,
0.8222118020057678,
0.25040218234062195,
0.4794694781303406,
-0.021824050694704056,
-0.07378211617469788,
-0.1138940304517746,
-0.5313677191734314,
0.24534568190574646,
-0.1548500955104828,
0.204248309135437,
-0.6497923731803894
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.01749v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.01749v1
|
Towards Harnessing Large Language Models for Comprehension of Conversational Grounding
| 2024-06-03T19:34:39 | 2024-06-03T19:34:39 |
Kristiina Jokinen, Phillip Schneider, Taiga Mori
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Conversational grounding is a collaborative mechanism for establishing mutual
knowledge among participants engaged in a dialogue. This experimental study
analyzes information-seeking conversations to investigate the capabilities of
large language models in classifying dialogue turns related to explicit or
implicit grounding and predicting grounded knowledge elements. Our experimental
results reveal challenges encountered by large language models in the two tasks
and discuss ongoing research efforts to enhance large language model-based
conversational grounding comprehension through pipeline architectures and
knowledge bases. These initiatives aim to develop more effective dialogue
systems that are better equipped to handle the intricacies of grounded
knowledge in conversations.
|
[
-0.4501054584980011,
-0.994411289691925,
0.8775365948677063,
0.1489456444978714,
-0.17312386631965637,
0.09544175863265991,
-0.2395380735397339,
-0.2389640510082245,
-0.16042834520339966,
0.6140365600585938,
-0.3707250654697418,
-0.387077659368515,
-0.6218799948692322,
-0.49898630380630493,
-0.47498536109924316,
0.8507739305496216,
0.16219697892665863,
0.222962886095047,
-0.37313327193260193,
-0.246717169880867,
-0.8663473129272461,
-0.8172286152839661,
-0.4981231689453125,
-0.4805426597595215,
0.3040066361427307,
0.45534560084342957,
0.9138296842575073,
0.040781233459711075,
0.180489182472229,
0.27404457330703735,
-0.3822866976261139,
-0.20917175710201263,
-0.8047112822532654,
0.3107199966907501,
-0.3229324519634247,
-0.738321840763092,
0.07096337527036667,
0.126384899020195,
0.6059809327125549,
1.3168931007385254,
-0.11687782406806946,
-0.21789531409740448,
-0.026649359613656998,
0.6627132892608643,
-0.5104565620422363,
0.37708109617233276,
-0.7267696857452393,
0.1442701518535614,
0.415137380361557,
-0.3467721939086914,
-0.609544575214386,
-0.11753307282924652,
0.5066917538642883,
-0.33921876549720764,
0.15407629311084747,
0.20228126645088196,
0.6418752074241638,
0.04667431488633156,
-0.46454375982284546,
-0.418037086725235,
-0.7125824093818665,
0.5577127933502197,
-0.6278440356254578,
0.7036454677581787,
0.5313783288002014,
0.13525229692459106,
-0.07508870214223862,
-0.49497416615486145,
-0.5565118789672852,
-0.5311451554298401,
-0.19191543757915497,
0.10651098191738129,
0.12781618535518646,
0.4053502380847931,
0.523883044719696,
0.6454059481620789,
-0.09486633539199829,
-0.2086092084646225,
-0.3572765290737152,
0.1685217171907425,
0.10094621777534485,
0.03653395548462868,
0.3731158375740051,
-0.027007510885596275,
0.10313716530799866,
0.10383442044258118,
-0.6012718081474304,
0.11595688760280609,
0.19107091426849365,
0.06663339585065842,
-0.18613757193088531,
0.6940104961395264,
-0.5174492001533508,
0.7121362686157227,
0.20291510224342346,
-0.005591972731053829,
-0.0014754720032215118,
-0.18068398535251617,
-0.3870788514614105,
0.039006590843200684,
0.26911911368370056,
0.6140127778053284,
0.31494373083114624,
-0.3200194239616394,
-0.0020362460054457188,
-0.013648292049765587,
0.1343785971403122,
-0.6970246434211731,
-0.1682034581899643,
0.19157208502292633,
-0.4871200919151306,
-0.4351607859134674,
0.14830094575881958,
-0.4463137090206146,
-0.5095601677894592,
-0.7413853406906128,
0.12135259062051773,
-0.3995583951473236,
-0.5668756365776062,
0.20733581483364105,
-0.5218111276626587,
0.4287027418613434,
0.3902750611305237,
-0.8410837054252625,
0.306141197681427,
0.8586292266845703,
0.8650708198547363,
0.24094951152801514,
-0.16773152351379395,
-0.48828718066215515,
0.16758142411708832,
-0.4491625428199768,
0.3597722053527832,
-0.47624504566192627,
-0.40702781081199646,
0.0805705264210701,
0.07375723123550415,
-0.027202369645237923,
-0.31017422676086426,
0.4712224006652832,
-0.7740017175674438,
0.4052020013332367,
-0.42766568064689636,
-0.34911373257637024,
-0.36644628643989563,
0.6322215795516968,
-0.27759721875190735,
0.6571089625358582,
0.013672702014446259,
-1.0137439966201782,
0.23926453292369843,
-0.37248703837394714,
-0.1517460197210312,
0.07936786860227585,
-0.2171143740415573,
0.2374064326286316,
0.23529505729675293,
0.014634155668318272,
0.6315789222717285,
-0.5434853434562683,
0.8633632063865662,
-0.3017495572566986,
-0.2198621779680252,
0.40076133608818054,
-0.3801249861717224,
0.52750563621521,
0.054719191044569016,
-0.45844078063964844,
0.0032056774944067,
-0.7070208787918091,
0.09437327086925507,
0.020736772567033768,
-0.1746719926595688,
-0.4890613257884979,
0.22702214121818542,
-0.28271207213401794,
0.260193794965744,
-0.05378572270274162,
-0.13516469299793243,
0.005636014975607395,
-0.6906712651252747,
0.4995458722114563,
0.37889012694358826,
0.16296891868114471,
0.6608979105949402,
-0.2562410831451416,
0.11133905500173569,
0.06755167990922928,
-0.33676043152809143,
-0.6746870875358582,
-0.4482195973396301,
-1.2781263589859009,
0.3051789700984955,
0.022757526487112045,
0.4762401282787323,
-0.5721574425697327,
0.49601131677627563,
-0.3353295922279358,
-0.34359821677207947,
-0.1167655661702156,
-0.16876661777496338,
0.4342595338821411,
0.526384174823761,
0.14012105762958527,
-0.05459490790963173,
-0.4006098210811615,
-0.8041817545890808,
0.1379868984222412,
-0.38025400042533875,
-0.07882744818925858,
0.49003732204437256,
0.2012801170349121,
-0.281046986579895,
1.068225383758545,
-0.36930835247039795,
0.08081725984811783,
-0.18789581954479218,
0.55064457654953,
0.28505420684814453,
0.4702157974243164,
0.5666313171386719,
-0.9202183485031128,
-0.3583747148513794,
0.21920664608478546,
-1.0928157567977905,
-0.06749977171421051,
0.19611819088459015,
-0.16300879418849945,
-0.170330211520195,
0.8466567993164062,
-0.859156608581543,
0.3508913815021515,
0.612586259841919,
-0.28847795724868774,
0.5158905386924744,
0.10160420835018158,
0.394062340259552,
-0.8262677788734436,
0.07275709509849548,
-0.33458274602890015,
-0.0638430118560791,
-0.7946919798851013,
0.254759281873703,
-0.27335745096206665,
-0.4049379229545593,
-0.1966439038515091,
0.2706609070301056,
-0.5657283663749695,
-0.07013731449842453,
-0.2264108508825302,
0.13942629098892212,
0.054287392646074295,
0.39678481221199036,
0.40649640560150146,
0.7877880930900574,
0.7934849858283997,
-0.7585840821266174,
0.291949987411499,
0.3083489239215851,
-0.36586523056030273,
0.7348154783248901,
-0.7687904238700867,
0.42637792229652405,
-0.3534195125102997,
0.41403165459632874,
-1.1854257583618164,
-0.41088855266571045,
-0.0699833333492279,
-0.4381149709224701,
-0.07413484901189804,
-0.5752951502799988,
-0.24169421195983887,
-0.2101583331823349,
0.2805153727531433,
0.3226696252822876,
0.5182219743728638,
-0.5088774561882019,
0.608505368232727,
0.42701250314712524,
-0.38899099826812744,
-0.32970261573791504,
-0.2878876030445099,
0.1903170943260193,
-0.3753920793533325,
-1.0204154253005981,
-0.14063580334186554,
-0.035785675048828125,
-0.8355927467346191,
-0.41140496730804443,
0.05103427544236183,
-0.14734318852424622,
0.11862759292125702,
0.5644206404685974,
-0.16566616296768188,
-0.47103944420814514,
0.31272539496421814,
-0.11841894686222076,
-0.22938871383666992,
0.46268051862716675,
-0.42839109897613525,
0.884486734867096,
-0.09313447773456573,
-0.5451192855834961,
-0.2599743902683258,
0.584559440612793,
1.0070172548294067,
-0.04630023613572121,
1.0513105392456055,
0.14445242285728455,
-0.29143598675727844,
0.05132461339235306,
-1.0162320137023926,
-0.17788735032081604,
-0.45707273483276367,
0.12738031148910522,
-0.6477968096733093,
-1.088865876197815,
0.5499718189239502,
-0.338765412569046,
-0.08282971382141113,
0.18153411149978638,
0.407950222492218,
-0.04403704032301903,
1.2850817441940308,
0.5381770730018616,
-0.2690061032772064,
0.3036503791809082,
-0.15962816774845123,
0.3731327950954437,
-0.5569931268692017,
-0.2538938820362091,
-0.6549633145332336,
0.18201954662799835,
0.16538883745670319,
-0.49419209361076355,
0.22407962381839752,
0.4225788116455078,
-0.08853873610496521,
-0.2792162001132965,
-0.1810024231672287,
0.47641682624816895,
0.5593785643577576,
0.08231104165315628,
0.3245372474193573,
0.05508022382855415,
-0.2623106837272644,
-0.11906936019659042,
-0.3513175845146179,
-0.41315171122550964,
0.6029180884361267,
0.5288487672805786,
0.6082700490951538,
-0.10328146070241928,
-0.11854980140924454,
0.031969036906957626,
-0.019149327650666237,
-1.0202527046203613,
0.4383362829685211,
0.5564077496528625,
-0.46292707324028015,
-0.2649328112602234,
-0.24932220578193665,
-0.6213822364807129,
0.2737516462802887,
-0.11990531533956528,
-0.8336542844772339,
-0.0924435630440712,
-0.04708072543144226,
0.0738937184214592,
0.15424394607543945,
-0.6970478892326355,
0.64756178855896,
-0.2063729166984558,
-0.2348790317773819,
-0.5164783596992493,
-0.7657398581504822,
0.3572901487350464,
0.09461849927902222,
0.493737131357193,
0.04792649671435356,
0.7591301798820496,
0.6172651648521423,
-0.2941226065158844,
0.7307961583137512,
-0.40972909331321716,
-0.339776873588562,
0.33792275190353394,
0.20688943564891815,
0.549131453037262,
0.13924185931682587,
-0.14537586271762848,
0.18316635489463806,
-0.24811656773090363,
-0.2848169505596161,
-0.7739427089691162,
0.5786385536193848,
-0.7940118312835693,
-0.9465358257293701,
-0.15280689299106598,
-0.38652095198631287,
-0.49568507075309753,
0.2516028881072998,
0.13036836683750153,
0.3113101124763489,
-0.49568381905555725,
0.6998591423034668,
0.9977019429206848,
-0.11531510949134827,
-0.06576276570558548,
0.605452835559845,
-0.3571670949459076,
-0.11881941556930542,
0.46195751428604126,
-0.15947583317756653,
0.5550116896629333,
0.42272770404815674,
0.1226905956864357,
-0.01252292562276125,
-0.8303086161613464,
-0.13465483486652374,
0.050126440823078156,
-0.9264618158340454,
0.17297977209091187,
-1.2376492023468018,
-0.4357421398162842,
-0.5221421718597412,
-0.3122027814388275,
-0.1931760013103485,
-0.1628376692533493,
-0.24306757748126984,
-0.6204100847244263,
0.17848974466323853,
0.7944583892822266,
0.3013800382614136,
0.5889701247215271,
-0.8888967037200928,
0.2354608029127121,
0.48954886198043823,
0.19913004338741302,
-0.012534729205071926,
-0.5577583312988281,
-0.06643126904964447,
0.4641461670398712,
-0.008662904612720013,
-0.8853162527084351,
0.13977991044521332,
-0.2712151110172272,
0.5534164905548096,
0.5368351936340332,
0.019983578473329544,
0.8192636966705322,
-0.48448026180267334,
0.9168447852134705,
0.344396710395813,
-1.169432520866394,
0.6812167763710022,
-0.762711226940155,
0.13164851069450378,
0.5966877937316895,
0.3030009865760803,
-0.912828803062439,
-0.34477221965789795,
-0.6055672764778137,
-0.78354811668396,
0.741328775882721,
0.28994888067245483,
0.34396809339523315,
0.04502495005726814,
0.17574596405029297,
-0.1397947072982788,
0.40789276361465454,
-0.7029225826263428,
0.0523759126663208,
0.054395608603954315,
0.23785312473773956,
-0.1561759114265442,
-0.6137100458145142,
-0.4949195683002472,
-0.19246098399162292,
0.5171099305152893,
-0.17135468125343323,
0.25755977630615234,
0.04689640551805496,
-0.3021339178085327,
-0.3092910945415497,
0.31609252095222473,
0.2941107153892517,
0.7486291527748108,
-0.17386411130428314,
0.2625233232975006,
0.30472493171691895,
-0.09480661153793335,
0.14171616733074188,
-0.2812567353248596,
0.04177828133106232,
-0.15438303351402283,
0.2154148370027542,
1.1775133609771729,
0.46905064582824707,
-0.6897148489952087,
0.5497215390205383,
-0.049277521669864655,
-0.3208145201206207,
-0.5476043224334717,
0.07487563788890839,
0.21406936645507812,
0.07966524362564087,
0.442371666431427,
-0.10482734441757202,
0.1732097566127777,
-0.8238500356674194,
0.24505464732646942,
0.4685176908969879,
-0.5631487965583801,
-0.18361233174800873,
0.2201947420835495,
0.3379483222961426,
-0.3154153823852539,
0.8278358578681946,
0.10964702814817429,
-0.7755377888679504,
0.4531838595867157,
0.5373230576515198,
0.5045533776283264,
-0.026306258514523506,
0.20474794507026672,
0.24731573462486267,
0.012341911904513836,
-0.27761948108673096,
-0.3387485444545746,
-0.23128832876682281,
-1.0163891315460205,
-0.32766056060791016,
-0.3535827696323395,
-0.6065201163291931,
0.2729495167732239,
-0.5472577214241028,
0.4654695391654968,
-0.538312554359436,
0.22407732903957367,
-0.16637085378170013,
-0.34799790382385254,
-0.48690181970596313,
0.34945017099380493,
0.26194605231285095,
0.7000042796134949,
-0.9770119786262512,
0.4752837121486664,
0.661908745765686,
-0.18964263796806335,
-1.0001416206359863,
0.005933294538408518,
-0.16962087154388428,
-0.611107349395752,
0.93299800157547,
0.4538535475730896,
-0.21473468840122223,
0.03698605298995972,
-0.8595384955406189,
-0.9992653131484985,
0.828771710395813,
0.11437927931547165,
-0.28930145502090454,
-0.3546355664730072,
0.04340182617306709,
0.5213998556137085,
-0.43818387389183044,
0.5662516355514526,
0.601877748966217,
0.4108743369579315,
0.4899156391620636,
-1.1027835607528687,
-0.03544896841049194,
-0.4501221179962158,
-0.2553298771381378,
0.0383569672703743,
-0.7220423221588135,
0.8502852320671082,
0.2381431609392166,
-0.20570619404315948,
0.10930781066417694,
0.5209109783172607,
0.2847823202610016,
0.5023863315582275,
0.7359986305236816,
0.6170546412467957,
0.7052087783813477,
-0.20816609263420105,
0.7011550068855286,
-0.37544819712638855,
0.20896369218826294,
0.9571386575698853,
-0.43046805262565613,
0.3854978680610657,
0.2714492082595825,
-0.017645370215177536,
0.5571905970573425,
0.2568574845790863,
0.46272245049476624,
0.28461283445358276,
0.15493527054786682,
-0.3379432260990143,
-0.34604182839393616,
-0.21080297231674194,
-0.6363587975502014,
0.40377694368362427,
0.8539246916770935,
-0.34076088666915894,
0.07684595137834549,
0.14156745374202728,
-0.0759657770395279,
0.028265951201319695,
-0.1293850988149643,
1.1626614332199097,
0.022513164207339287,
-1.0776493549346924,
0.5513059496879578,
-0.011672110296785831,
0.30235546827316284,
-0.3897233307361603,
-0.1629185527563095,
-0.011351590044796467,
-0.1262943595647812,
-0.07545583695173264,
-0.6722344160079956,
0.1422191709280014,
-0.2333945631980896,
-0.28010377287864685,
-0.3171493113040924,
0.922281801700592,
-0.2518250048160553,
0.058608729392290115,
0.4836520850658417,
0.520553469657898,
0.1604854315519333,
-0.3986022472381592,
-0.44467708468437195,
0.0892850011587143,
0.05171363428235054,
-0.176848903298378,
0.22960583865642548,
0.8906256556510925,
0.07500605285167694,
0.7357989549636841,
0.8718336224555969,
-0.30499741435050964,
0.05616249889135361,
0.19027714431285858,
1.1363236904144287,
-0.7751460075378418,
-0.7654399871826172,
-0.4466501772403717,
0.7613227367401123,
-0.2877994477748871,
0.19525718688964844,
0.6116872429847717,
0.36018288135528564,
0.4258524477481842,
-0.12247622013092041,
1.0140646696090698,
-0.18634966015815735,
0.5878319144248962,
-0.7687187194824219,
0.4977457523345947,
-0.037212226539850235,
0.10593226552009583,
-0.35459956526756287,
-1.1021428108215332,
0.05793991684913635,
0.8743597865104675,
-0.4717685580253601,
-0.18443170189857483,
0.8555901646614075,
0.45712798833847046,
-0.19271965324878693,
0.3391677737236023,
0.523534893989563,
0.429404079914093,
0.39485472440719604,
0.24451343715190887,
1.5099360942840576,
-0.0366298109292984,
0.10252997279167175,
0.02259957231581211,
-0.3884875774383545,
-0.180539071559906,
-0.6646791696548462,
-1.3892936706542969,
-0.5992920994758606,
0.0411042757332325,
-0.5030325055122375,
0.18256087601184845,
0.8109212517738342,
1.008406639099121,
-0.7788179516792297,
-0.1785297989845276,
-0.7076860070228577,
0.04230372980237007,
0.42031919956207275,
-0.3335452377796173,
-0.3036095201969147,
-0.4930132329463959,
-0.6985687017440796,
0.5874024033546448,
0.17867723107337952,
-0.020671319216489792,
-0.21964554488658905,
-0.09403587132692337,
-0.06429925560951233,
-0.08602596819400787,
0.679000973701477,
0.1474040001630783,
-0.604984700679779,
-0.4851822853088379,
-0.09992019087076187,
0.17005766928195953,
-0.0073036374524235725,
1.2743369340896606,
-0.7618492245674133,
0.3331655263900757,
0.44155871868133545,
0.6518138647079468,
0.45409393310546875,
0.2888590693473816,
0.9806384444236755,
-0.7528897523880005,
0.7498724460601807,
0.1263851374387741,
0.35595086216926575,
0.3812318444252014,
-0.5047123432159424,
0.4575589597225189,
0.29358819127082825,
-0.6425822973251343,
-0.7471091151237488,
0.21833907067775726,
-0.940226137638092,
-0.07462255656719208,
1.4230183362960815,
-0.2641269266605377,
0.3662038743495941,
-0.38893166184425354,
-0.7275135517120361,
0.1566101312637329,
-0.23679687082767487,
0.5743277072906494,
1.178261160850525,
0.5792133808135986,
-0.4832155108451843,
-0.4795774817466736,
0.21474583446979523,
0.5450902581214905,
-0.6896615624427795,
0.22828322649002075,
0.8146432042121887,
0.10522378981113434,
0.5522263646125793,
0.7909256815910339,
0.18793830275535583,
-0.026976585388183594,
-0.03886682167649269,
-0.2851713299751282,
0.40889787673950195,
-0.5107904076576233,
-0.11802595853805542,
0.44291776418685913,
0.3244197368621826,
0.48253944516181946
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.06574v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.06574v1
|
Towards Transparency: Exploring LLM Trainings Datasets through Visual Topic Modeling and Semantic Frame
| 2024-06-03T18:44:13 | 2024-06-03T18:44:13 |
Charles de Dampierre, Andrei Mogoutov, Nicolas Baumard
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
LLMs are now responsible for making many decisions on behalf of humans: from
answering questions to classifying things, they have become an important part
of everyday life. While computation and model architecture have been rapidly
expanding in recent years, the efforts towards curating training datasets are
still in their beginnings. This underappreciation of training datasets has led
LLMs to create biased and low-quality content. In order to solve that issue, we
present Bunka, a software that leverages AI and Cognitive Science to improve
the refinement of textual datasets. We show how Topic Modeling coupled with
2-dimensional Cartography can increase the transparency of datasets. We then
show how the same Topic Modeling techniques can be applied to Preferences
datasets to accelerate the fine-tuning process and increase the capacities of
the model on different benchmarks. Lastly, we show how using Frame Analysis can
give insights into existing biases in the training corpus. Overall, we argue
that we need better tools to explore and increase the quality and transparency
of LLMs training datasets.
|
[
-0.5249330401420593,
-0.7408440709114075,
0.6856407523155212,
-0.14892682433128357,
-0.15103666484355927,
0.05797630548477173,
-0.19329197704792023,
-0.2457488477230072,
0.23511691391468048,
0.8660669922828674,
-0.6120549440383911,
-0.935518205165863,
-0.8144351243972778,
-0.5105031728744507,
-0.31856876611709595,
0.9127793312072754,
-0.27218976616859436,
0.5176640152931213,
-0.5030255317687988,
-0.08693299442529678,
-0.918092668056488,
-0.33274373412132263,
-0.466100811958313,
-0.44106826186180115,
0.28352686762809753,
0.7211549878120422,
0.7291476130485535,
0.6089249849319458,
0.40568777918815613,
0.21736662089824677,
-0.0719367265701294,
-0.03303445875644684,
-0.9116765856742859,
0.28856998682022095,
-0.2712464928627014,
-0.9351714253425598,
-0.301144003868103,
0.22174334526062012,
0.5773955583572388,
0.6184412837028503,
0.15668219327926636,
0.2291206270456314,
-0.00648642098531127,
1.01859712600708,
-0.5931184887886047,
0.3508664667606354,
-0.6384714841842651,
0.21342970430850983,
-0.19323979318141937,
-0.2247832715511322,
-0.21166302263736725,
-0.2574072480201721,
0.24743589758872986,
-0.7521538138389587,
0.4820212125778198,
0.10587302595376968,
0.9500666260719299,
0.7660676836967468,
-0.2696534991264343,
-0.4207302927970886,
-0.6040923595428467,
0.8614493012428284,
-0.2221914529800415,
0.47455960512161255,
0.5903574228286743,
0.17602671682834625,
-0.16209636628627777,
-0.6444143056869507,
-0.32309776544570923,
0.04332645609974861,
-0.04836517944931984,
0.032137077301740646,
-0.007238241843879223,
-0.085872583091259,
0.20343536138534546,
0.3530731797218323,
-0.48355919122695923,
0.03718689829111099,
-0.4413522779941559,
-0.305492639541626,
0.680392861366272,
0.34441983699798584,
0.37456345558166504,
-0.234121173620224,
-0.22910815477371216,
-0.2060297578573227,
-0.8198843002319336,
0.034557074308395386,
0.49814146757125854,
-0.01738811656832695,
-0.08365634828805923,
0.7012138962745667,
-0.3637494742870331,
0.5115296244621277,
-0.22304436564445496,
0.04228803142905235,
0.03997021168470383,
-0.01842590607702732,
-0.13738282024860382,
0.13069996237754822,
0.35523512959480286,
0.5424570441246033,
0.09443751722574234,
-0.11512970924377441,
-0.01811804808676243,
0.38505399227142334,
0.48550936579704285,
-0.8065561652183533,
-0.24493299424648285,
0.4105255603790283,
-0.4584267735481262,
-0.22343139350414276,
0.011052561923861504,
-0.6815175414085388,
-0.43394291400909424,
-0.8524655699729919,
0.03378568962216377,
-0.31704652309417725,
0.02194041572511196,
0.4404316842556,
0.045066941529512405,
0.4195614457130432,
0.7346665859222412,
-0.9361793994903564,
0.11806513369083405,
1.1427534818649292,
0.6784552335739136,
-0.46168527007102966,
-0.03686046227812767,
-0.21188734471797943,
-0.0003233252791687846,
-0.5479828119277954,
0.8893709778785706,
-0.53716641664505,
-0.4003114700317383,
-0.1483941525220871,
0.005396849475800991,
0.4196167290210724,
-0.4199070632457733,
0.5667791366577148,
-0.652256190776825,
0.30275410413742065,
-0.4159385561943054,
-0.6582632064819336,
-0.24533472955226898,
0.487109512090683,
-0.6793562769889832,
1.0596827268600464,
-0.1492154598236084,
-0.6651655435562134,
0.5553799271583557,
-0.6656345725059509,
0.10504338145256042,
-0.16210927069187164,
-0.5721114873886108,
-0.6112604141235352,
0.05150379240512848,
0.45320746302604675,
0.5679937601089478,
-0.16721723973751068,
0.7131182551383972,
-0.20162801444530487,
-0.41338226199150085,
0.14407892525196075,
-0.44096019864082336,
0.6606249213218689,
0.17363989353179932,
-0.03676064312458038,
0.37744641304016113,
-0.26352113485336304,
-0.11573827266693115,
-0.18681545555591583,
-0.1468685120344162,
-0.21408456563949585,
-0.04889284446835518,
-0.04505498334765434,
0.03693567216396332,
0.2518637478351593,
-0.21907375752925873,
0.32545843720436096,
-0.2423517256975174,
0.34454357624053955,
0.9409078359603882,
-0.15079371631145477,
0.7085679173469543,
-0.3309585154056549,
0.35588061809539795,
0.1012481078505516,
0.26941490173339844,
-0.21531370282173157,
-0.7884333729743958,
-0.9588363766670227,
-0.2224060446023941,
0.48597922921180725,
0.2675570845603943,
-0.6352375149726868,
0.23135343194007874,
-0.35769739747047424,
-0.22556589543819427,
-0.7330190539360046,
0.05745752900838852,
0.15942838788032532,
0.41134050488471985,
0.1309775412082672,
-0.670505940914154,
-0.20237649977207184,
-0.8668419122695923,
0.00833346787840128,
0.0548255629837513,
-0.12152312695980072,
0.44401416182518005,
0.5194505453109741,
-0.19179382920265198,
1.2937387228012085,
-0.7518745064735413,
-0.4290398061275482,
0.11395327746868134,
0.22214418649673462,
0.0030166124925017357,
0.48003512620925903,
0.3129846453666687,
-0.9250098466873169,
-0.2844850718975067,
-0.3156016170978546,
-0.9844571948051453,
0.12238910049200058,
0.07443379610776901,
-0.5547155141830444,
0.07440666854381561,
0.49133601784706116,
-0.2806117534637451,
0.6204595565795898,
0.29592618346214294,
-0.46025270223617554,
0.1625460386276245,
-0.09229045361280441,
0.0792989656329155,
-0.9112579822540283,
-0.30311867594718933,
-0.13531328737735748,
-0.2961275279521942,
-0.4148437976837158,
-0.0810975432395935,
-0.07953114807605743,
-0.3102046549320221,
-0.5515928864479065,
0.67458575963974,
-0.4557015597820282,
-0.5155080556869507,
-0.5203397870063782,
0.17920131981372833,
0.09305687993764877,
0.4995775818824768,
0.24079720675945282,
0.8373257517814636,
0.8966026306152344,
-0.24085484445095062,
0.17933201789855957,
0.6837443709373474,
-0.4472688138484955,
0.5030186772346497,
-0.3364424705505371,
0.1436738818883896,
-0.45394328236579895,
0.254523366689682,
-0.8018187880516052,
-0.4309007227420807,
0.37443986535072327,
-0.28736409544944763,
0.42886170744895935,
-0.2526390254497528,
-0.3603127896785736,
0.12416329979896545,
-0.5814885497093201,
0.1626274585723877,
0.3791945278644562,
-0.622559666633606,
0.39803922176361084,
0.7594875693321228,
-0.051041245460510254,
-0.7804437875747681,
-0.7036156058311462,
0.2123624086380005,
-0.18851740658283234,
-0.7402138113975525,
0.5826370120048523,
-0.1547323763370514,
-0.22904321551322937,
0.10588159412145615,
-0.16727370023727417,
0.0032002925872802734,
0.06764858216047287,
0.648555338382721,
0.3903166353702545,
-0.1685931384563446,
0.12452022731304169,
0.04037892818450928,
-0.36224424839019775,
0.05063088238239288,
-0.2541647255420685,
0.5238423943519592,
-0.4253860414028168,
-0.6132267713546753,
-0.5929469466209412,
0.09708190709352493,
0.1018514335155487,
0.015212283469736576,
0.5642412900924683,
0.6077830195426941,
-0.2886727750301361,
-0.2233428657054901,
-0.5670801401138306,
-0.405986487865448,
-0.46619516611099243,
0.2093670517206192,
-0.10996389389038086,
-1.0407589673995972,
0.3441028594970703,
-0.28567948937416077,
-0.18463757634162903,
0.10165750235319138,
0.798812985420227,
-0.05078164488077164,
0.4582182765007019,
0.9856759905815125,
-0.02916571870446205,
0.6904308795928955,
-0.6332377791404724,
-0.08931893110275269,
-0.7953369617462158,
-0.5687439441680908,
-0.269562691450119,
-0.42151620984077454,
-0.8529071807861328,
-0.6454983353614807,
0.3419564366340637,
0.1568700075149536,
-0.11930530518293381,
-0.20660437643527985,
-0.6873266696929932,
0.9071849584579468,
0.6954621076583862,
0.48309648036956787,
0.37768885493278503,
0.15586082637310028,
0.31453967094421387,
-0.18638642132282257,
-0.6526648998260498,
-1.0464569330215454,
1.4894819259643555,
0.5288500785827637,
0.8941752314567566,
-0.33222925662994385,
0.570046067237854,
0.4547162353992462,
0.6468173861503601,
-0.8576443791389465,
0.5642728805541992,
-0.1172441840171814,
-0.5962415337562561,
-0.45658037066459656,
-0.10787024348974228,
-0.7719658613204956,
0.16907741129398346,
-0.3293110132217407,
-0.4124002456665039,
0.39522236585617065,
-0.09724462032318115,
0.05547839403152466,
0.3366676867008209,
-0.5107447504997253,
0.6895244121551514,
-0.2511198818683624,
-0.8118708729743958,
-0.06339054554700851,
-0.5651190280914307,
0.471086710691452,
-0.04966876283288002,
-0.1704901158809662,
-0.5445945858955383,
-0.08576936274766922,
0.7641562819480896,
-0.1304434984922409,
0.9042274951934814,
0.04599505290389061,
-0.15963056683540344,
0.2020116150379181,
-0.10773421823978424,
0.2594873309135437,
0.465661883354187,
-0.22060659527778625,
0.7225216627120972,
-0.3878025412559509,
-0.547078549861908,
-0.6300859451293945,
0.7515817880630493,
-0.9742832183837891,
-0.6889917850494385,
-0.32427021861076355,
-0.6184108257293701,
-0.27171745896339417,
-0.05863554775714874,
0.12898357212543488,
0.10554780811071396,
-0.24596285820007324,
0.11820251494646072,
0.9032496809959412,
-0.2063816338777542,
0.04526131972670555,
0.43364980816841125,
-0.07996141910552979,
-0.1397681087255478,
0.758751630783081,
0.03658412769436836,
-0.2194264978170395,
0.294101744890213,
-0.05719389021396637,
-0.2468748539686203,
-0.7518958449363708,
-0.3444966971874237,
-0.02280263602733612,
-0.9263717532157898,
-0.1862397938966751,
-0.38470184803009033,
-0.20246320962905884,
-0.08490780740976334,
-0.3409976065158844,
-0.3874768912792206,
-0.5139848589897156,
-0.5934547781944275,
-0.13643556833267212,
0.31777679920196533,
0.9084672331809998,
0.07350262254476547,
0.4773721694946289,
-0.216651052236557,
0.5518165230751038,
0.2898174822330475,
0.587385892868042,
-0.317856103181839,
-0.25764504075050354,
-0.07206572592258453,
0.01864997297525406,
-0.6112991571426392,
-0.570466160774231,
0.4549831449985504,
-0.4156242609024048,
0.5662990212440491,
0.2626708149909973,
-0.05851832032203674,
0.2695298194885254,
-0.4078262746334076,
0.9243515729904175,
-0.0025537642650306225,
-0.8805569410324097,
0.7254124879837036,
-0.2171764075756073,
-0.3352571725845337,
0.6089393496513367,
0.5596259236335754,
-0.17517727613449097,
-0.3761550188064575,
-0.5127052664756775,
-0.8228105306625366,
0.9036582112312317,
0.3780830204486847,
0.2028978317975998,
0.5240049958229065,
0.6315186023712158,
0.2543116509914398,
0.3265882134437561,
-0.5830045342445374,
-0.3349139094352722,
-0.5620996952056885,
-0.2239914834499359,
0.02449727989733219,
-0.3700805902481079,
-0.3006848096847534,
-0.14723852276802063,
0.7371267676353455,
-0.1233675479888916,
0.1545773148536682,
0.0024802256375551224,
-0.032132722437381744,
0.09616100043058395,
0.2540864944458008,
0.3750496804714203,
0.6909887790679932,
-0.33060410618782043,
0.04210665076971054,
0.10047490894794464,
-0.5164940357208252,
0.16997389495372772,
-0.26170411705970764,
-0.4565524458885193,
-0.10594265162944794,
0.2128811627626419,
1.071397066116333,
0.07132130116224289,
-0.46232956647872925,
0.47026652097702026,
-0.15100517868995667,
-0.15213210880756378,
-0.01625381037592888,
0.3866477608680725,
0.039067111909389496,
0.2890244424343109,
0.02934858947992325,
-0.13999177515506744,
0.10304713249206543,
-0.4881976842880249,
0.2221347689628601,
0.5522149205207825,
-0.5553479194641113,
0.14570476114749908,
0.6506892442703247,
0.054598357528448105,
-0.13680827617645264,
0.7306593060493469,
0.20649278163909912,
-0.2758863568305969,
0.663025438785553,
-0.08056505769491196,
0.7442068457603455,
0.10882457345724106,
0.39693334698677063,
0.12985242903232574,
0.344117671251297,
-0.2709932029247284,
0.124118871986866,
-0.1676187962293625,
-0.8321619033813477,
-0.20521004498004913,
-0.6328043341636658,
-0.8653186559677124,
0.2669743001461029,
-0.6700624823570251,
0.5041658878326416,
-0.1580079197883606,
-0.19052347540855408,
-0.11386099457740784,
0.19194245338439941,
-0.6031866073608398,
0.2375982254743576,
0.18319597840309143,
0.6440874338150024,
-0.6817697882652283,
0.7934788465499878,
0.36759084463119507,
-0.3681606650352478,
-0.2841711938381195,
0.047017112374305725,
-0.15320906043052673,
-0.8526564836502075,
0.802623450756073,
0.11716540157794952,
0.051068443804979324,
-0.4205287992954254,
-0.9819927215576172,
-0.748889148235321,
1.3065520524978638,
0.73384028673172,
-0.5174670815467834,
0.036280930042266846,
0.5829402804374695,
0.5272384285926819,
-0.5329146385192871,
0.1436663120985031,
0.4559710919857025,
0.46621939539909363,
0.03998379409313202,
-0.22338786721229553,
-0.17656300961971283,
-0.0025444908533245325,
0.14696583151817322,
-0.18665166199207306,
-0.6268664002418518,
0.8639324903488159,
-0.01962864026427269,
-0.0926472619175911,
-0.3275049328804016,
0.6699855923652649,
0.3030587136745453,
0.6390570998191833,
0.10699404031038284,
0.41346120834350586,
0.9505496025085449,
-0.36820709705352783,
0.8512982130050659,
-0.39680221676826477,
0.4267769753932953,
1.2458747625350952,
-0.30712348222732544,
0.6624433398246765,
0.4583820104598999,
0.13720834255218506,
0.3571130037307739,
0.8971782326698303,
-0.17064540088176727,
0.5564259886741638,
0.3349815607070923,
-0.07131495326757431,
-0.2884712815284729,
-0.26082277297973633,
-0.27204734086990356,
0.34852832555770874,
0.592476487159729,
-0.14056581258773804,
-0.33557671308517456,
0.17390884459018707,
-0.2511191666126251,
0.11248011142015457,
-0.39382830262184143,
0.7246963977813721,
0.006677433382719755,
-0.35954511165618896,
0.4031313359737396,
0.03313080966472626,
0.7174262404441833,
-0.4303366243839264,
-0.07791254669427872,
-0.5117442011833191,
-0.3159947395324707,
-0.1861668825149536,
-1.139506220817566,
0.4769781827926636,
0.000998193514533341,
-0.35950860381126404,
-0.593912661075592,
0.8686261177062988,
-0.32746556401252747,
-0.31703588366508484,
0.11174717545509338,
0.5958164930343628,
0.2816719710826874,
-0.08943270146846771,
-0.8186997771263123,
0.3480580747127533,
-0.16923314332962036,
-0.2507387697696686,
0.23370075225830078,
0.3656778931617737,
-0.3395007848739624,
0.8944184184074402,
0.710651695728302,
0.024898329749703407,
-0.11379994451999664,
-0.1507561355829239,
0.9818678498268127,
-0.6206722855567932,
-0.4904837906360626,
-0.59083491563797,
0.22724267840385437,
-0.0465095154941082,
-0.07046257704496384,
0.5555066466331482,
0.7981154322624207,
0.9957860708236694,
-0.005308204796165228,
0.6031402945518494,
0.6217546463012695,
0.1425171047449112,
-1.0603660345077515,
0.9486234784126282,
-0.46363890171051025,
0.6596838235855103,
0.1617298573255539,
-0.7331938743591309,
-0.14779214560985565,
0.4754229784011841,
-0.6149103045463562,
-0.19484522938728333,
0.4456965923309326,
0.9655589461326599,
-0.23061169683933258,
0.3005119562149048,
0.31161805987358093,
0.1285513937473297,
0.3023262917995453,
0.3310985267162323,
1.0990256071090698,
-0.37066352367401123,
0.07957350462675095,
-0.20989945530891418,
-0.048996731638908386,
-0.14370153844356537,
-0.8726245164871216,
-1.0458159446716309,
-0.5923933982849121,
-0.3363354206085205,
-0.14926230907440186,
0.22007349133491516,
0.4777437448501587,
1.0471978187561035,
-0.722650945186615,
-0.17871256172657013,
-0.24123582243919373,
0.5604323744773865,
0.4805555045604706,
-0.2285364866256714,
0.6890292167663574,
-0.3280443549156189,
-0.803142249584198,
0.16983145475387573,
0.25844430923461914,
0.19176237285137177,
-0.6412481665611267,
-0.031963832676410675,
0.32088392972946167,
0.15595467388629913,
0.39375996589660645,
-0.1558142900466919,
-0.7604576945304871,
0.071698397397995,
-0.2755805253982544,
-0.190390944480896,
0.4139556586742401,
1.0281946659088135,
-0.927528977394104,
0.4387960731983185,
0.4083770513534546,
0.6441686153411865,
1.0588465929031372,
-0.14473271369934082,
0.3281182050704956,
-0.6575019955635071,
0.2725716829299927,
0.039252739399671555,
0.151153564453125,
0.5674597024917603,
-0.5100030303001404,
0.7913162112236023,
0.02316090278327465,
-0.46366754174232483,
-0.7830695509910583,
0.14420510828495026,
-0.9857207536697388,
-0.551040768623352,
0.9208884835243225,
0.04002971574664116,
-0.4244430363178253,
-0.2713129222393036,
-0.4603134095668793,
0.2151624858379364,
-0.45378348231315613,
1.052110195159912,
0.8539909720420837,
-0.3538152277469635,
0.2808983027935028,
-0.9700289964675903,
0.686795711517334,
0.32476529479026794,
-1.2641273736953735,
0.0670887753367424,
0.5258515477180481,
0.4427559971809387,
0.06123175844550133,
0.7158406376838684,
-0.08915172517299652,
-0.13664104044437408,
-0.14177492260932922,
0.007852987386286259,
-0.20990614593029022,
-0.5697408318519592,
-0.4443729817867279,
0.17255593836307526,
-0.22847111523151398,
-0.12323661148548126
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.01721v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.01721v1
|
Rotation and Permutation for Advanced Outlier Management and Efficient Quantization of LLMs
| 2024-06-03T18:27:44 | 2024-06-03T18:27:44 |
Haokun Lin, Haobo Xu, Yichen Wu, Jingzhi Cui, Yingtao Zhang, Linzhan Mou, Linqi Song, Zhenan Sun, Ying Wei
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Quantizing large language models (LLMs) presents significant challenges,
primarily due to outlier activations that compromise the efficiency of low-bit
representation. Traditional approaches mainly focus on solving Normal
Outliers-activations with consistently high magnitudes across all tokens.
However, these techniques falter when dealing with Massive Outliers, which are
significantly higher in value and often cause substantial performance losses
during low-bit quantization. In this study, we propose DuQuant, an innovative
quantization strategy employing rotation and permutation transformations to
more effectively eliminate both types of outliers. Initially, DuQuant
constructs rotation matrices informed by specific outlier dimensions,
redistributing these outliers across adjacent channels within different
rotation blocks. Subsequently, a zigzag permutation is applied to ensure a
balanced distribution of outliers among blocks, minimizing block-wise variance.
An additional rotation further enhances the smoothness of the activation
landscape, thereby improving model performance. DuQuant streamlines the
quantization process and demonstrates superior outlier management, achieving
top-tier results in multiple tasks with various LLM architectures even under
4-bit weight-activation quantization. Our code is available at
https://github.com/Hsu1023/DuQuant.
|
[
-0.076960988342762,
-0.8828269243240356,
0.5642374753952026,
0.38120150566101074,
-0.6608851552009583,
0.3268483281135559,
-0.12791390717029572,
0.20134735107421875,
0.30220264196395874,
0.7168251276016235,
-0.29661449790000916,
-0.6898074746131897,
-0.44708383083343506,
-0.31194794178009033,
-0.7201206684112549,
0.8263905644416809,
0.08343532681465149,
0.2981925904750824,
-0.13370643556118011,
-0.2610566318035126,
-0.34046122431755066,
-0.7612000107765198,
-0.599735677242279,
-0.40492570400238037,
0.15290836989879608,
0.5715348124504089,
1.0500184297561646,
0.4586530029773712,
0.7759550213813782,
0.3415096402168274,
-0.05308238044381142,
0.2248689830303192,
-0.5975376963615417,
0.2474927306175232,
0.1680022031068802,
-0.40950116515159607,
-0.46273109316825867,
-0.26530659198760986,
0.7093416452407837,
0.6966692209243774,
-0.5079915523529053,
0.05784952640533447,
-0.015583057887852192,
1.0876725912094116,
-0.5436520576477051,
-0.16985340416431427,
-0.5985587239265442,
0.11284413188695908,
-0.646818995475769,
-0.23982353508472443,
0.052740637212991714,
-0.5664716958999634,
-0.42715826630592346,
-0.5157468914985657,
-0.17194989323616028,
-0.1713002324104309,
0.4706466495990753,
0.33668649196624756,
-0.15707464516162872,
-0.06473240256309509,
-0.6554423570632935,
0.8081487417221069,
-0.6567693948745728,
0.3783115744590759,
0.03433554619550705,
0.30903133749961853,
-0.5512962937355042,
-0.5366404056549072,
-0.6049423217773438,
0.08310575038194656,
0.2873041331768036,
0.056684959679841995,
-0.3011818826198578,
-0.2160768210887909,
0.14779089391231537,
0.6607147455215454,
-0.7669509053230286,
0.20705252885818481,
0.14667682349681854,
0.004642418585717678,
0.6407742500305176,
0.2643406093120575,
0.10537270456552505,
0.15682406723499298,
-0.33697307109832764,
-0.23826643824577332,
-0.9128756523132324,
0.002656883094459772,
0.9703262448310852,
-0.11472975462675095,
-0.1341821551322937,
0.8150296211242676,
-0.20826825499534607,
0.47634992003440857,
0.25516051054000854,
-0.012030241079628468,
0.2761414051055908,
-0.3326607048511505,
-0.19009797275066376,
-0.01775471121072769,
0.752510666847229,
-0.07256150245666504,
0.2530882656574249,
0.07634136825799942,
-0.4062577188014984,
-0.30813342332839966,
0.02837679721415043,
-0.7654770016670227,
-0.5100439190864563,
0.346982479095459,
-0.22986911237239838,
-0.4396955966949463,
0.055829644203186035,
-0.6710634827613831,
-0.598118007183075,
-0.1412612646818161,
0.7324305176734924,
-0.7004860043525696,
-0.2278033345937729,
0.33761465549468994,
0.051588382571935654,
-0.17710280418395996,
0.2980400025844574,
-0.7301744818687439,
-0.16876044869422913,
0.7237403988838196,
0.643646240234375,
-0.36818790435791016,
0.012482588179409504,
-0.45035678148269653,
0.058747299015522,
-0.32703304290771484,
0.520057737827301,
-0.4550527036190033,
-0.30764085054397583,
-0.10540585964918137,
-0.5675785541534424,
0.23938699066638947,
-0.7073102593421936,
0.23455068469047546,
-1.017402172088623,
-0.14107458293437958,
-0.08588848263025284,
-0.3270643651485443,
-0.2254818230867386,
0.19505806267261505,
-0.7066764831542969,
0.9870269298553467,
0.3253365755081177,
-0.5728205442428589,
-0.08505849540233612,
-0.585245668888092,
-0.2651332914829254,
0.37389034032821655,
-0.16492074728012085,
-0.6332489252090454,
0.43321317434310913,
0.21873292326927185,
0.061526693403720856,
-0.44523724913597107,
0.2575422525405884,
-0.038884054869413376,
-0.537317156791687,
0.800742506980896,
-0.7270023822784424,
1.0352166891098022,
0.08383839577436447,
-0.10499550402164459,
0.23141153156757355,
-0.8509798645973206,
0.2940976321697235,
0.1810746043920517,
-0.5195099115371704,
-0.3164161741733551,
-0.3909786641597748,
-0.11525317281484604,
-0.1521950215101242,
0.42023932933807373,
-0.31924816966056824,
0.20353466272354126,
-0.32420089840888977,
0.31902381777763367,
0.6319276094436646,
0.10309914499521255,
0.45668864250183105,
-0.3296301066875458,
0.6240904331207275,
0.46031293272972107,
0.2318335771560669,
-0.10259935259819031,
-0.32404544949531555,
-0.878477156162262,
-0.6995603442192078,
0.3455894887447357,
0.590989887714386,
-0.9894523620605469,
0.7039150595664978,
-0.43728435039520264,
-0.4066811203956604,
-0.45031872391700745,
0.43261003494262695,
0.2477700561285019,
0.17500664293766022,
0.33561745285987854,
-0.3707866966724396,
-0.3939632475376129,
-0.6380024552345276,
-0.394924521446228,
0.01829623058438301,
0.05117844417691231,
-0.5611951947212219,
0.3148091733455658,
-0.6002024412155151,
1.0169754028320312,
-0.32932648062705994,
-0.4703780710697174,
-0.1664828062057495,
0.32228562235832214,
0.3699524998664856,
0.5130496025085449,
0.1774914264678955,
-0.7826120257377625,
-0.7383771538734436,
0.025755606591701508,
-0.58631432056427,
-0.27194786071777344,
-0.03917756304144859,
-0.13887141644954681,
0.31634923815727234,
0.5901816487312317,
-0.46469810605049133,
0.5399056673049927,
0.8968315124511719,
0.07361454516649246,
0.3563024699687958,
-0.007379699498414993,
-0.07114562392234802,
-0.6809989213943481,
-0.22520758211612701,
-0.4719093441963196,
-0.31127920746803284,
-0.7113037109375,
-0.08958572894334793,
0.06511739641427994,
0.11064903438091278,
-0.3130791187286377,
0.08694525808095932,
-0.27225562930107117,
0.0001930055150296539,
-0.186361163854599,
-0.09399276971817017,
-0.06012121960520744,
0.3835922181606293,
-0.40091997385025024,
0.6665738821029663,
0.4016289710998535,
-0.246339350938797,
0.5730433464050293,
0.04508597031235695,
-0.49795377254486084,
0.6083805561065674,
-0.27120742201805115,
0.16408416628837585,
-0.2204943299293518,
-0.07747264206409454,
-1.0099824666976929,
0.12974409759044647,
0.29796209931373596,
-0.35236820578575134,
0.13029895722866058,
-0.20117107033729553,
-0.7987660765647888,
0.006130767520517111,
-0.6998111605644226,
0.8476189970970154,
0.4873233139514923,
-0.616592288017273,
0.5276160836219788,
0.3640281558036804,
-0.12595362961292267,
-0.3668425381183624,
-0.589203417301178,
-0.11470509320497513,
-0.5668261051177979,
-0.8009623885154724,
0.3680458962917328,
-0.11760344356298447,
-0.3492981195449829,
-0.13834436237812042,
-0.14891839027404785,
0.12621989846229553,
-0.018248802050948143,
0.15681034326553345,
-0.13774897158145905,
-0.08467355370521545,
0.09024134278297424,
0.001918918453156948,
-0.41284671425819397,
-0.12692780792713165,
-0.31598392128944397,
0.96645587682724,
-0.2656278610229492,
-0.6524323225021362,
-0.23246881365776062,
0.3512813448905945,
0.7174776196479797,
-0.18276074528694153,
0.48476549983024597,
0.6598679423332214,
-0.20619045197963715,
-0.040581196546554565,
-0.6701622009277344,
0.04180585965514183,
-0.5742930173873901,
0.5476133823394775,
-0.37163418531417847,
-0.7651777267456055,
0.5046175718307495,
-0.07302276045084,
-0.07362771779298782,
-0.032322630286216736,
0.7182170748710632,
-0.19107873737812042,
1.0452858209609985,
0.5010205507278442,
0.0959170013666153,
0.7900373339653015,
-0.5300647020339966,
0.4962034821510315,
-0.9836417436599731,
0.09280209988355637,
-0.02122120000422001,
-0.24067828059196472,
-0.7049329280853271,
-0.845680832862854,
0.999557614326477,
0.47286614775657654,
-0.4170707166194916,
0.08474551141262054,
-0.22394323348999023,
0.40799009799957275,
0.6304576396942139,
-0.06739791482686996,
0.796316385269165,
0.6912975311279297,
-0.12156383693218231,
-0.1389804482460022,
-0.5711985230445862,
-0.3776334822177887,
1.0966637134552002,
0.19309073686599731,
0.9282369017601013,
0.5254054665565491,
0.8469072580337524,
0.07041207700967789,
0.3566647171974182,
-0.5822182893753052,
0.6297590732574463,
-0.4116154611110687,
-0.12991976737976074,
-0.9567282795906067,
-0.5246388912200928,
-1.0015981197357178,
0.5746585130691528,
-0.18118494749069214,
-0.44938379526138306,
0.13092650473117828,
0.08800780028104782,
-0.5094843506813049,
0.3718327283859253,
-0.4048706293106079,
0.5159518718719482,
-0.5251004695892334,
-0.059122875332832336,
-0.3716437518596649,
-0.16675031185150146,
0.32032686471939087,
-0.4942513704299927,
0.27866029739379883,
-0.11875948309898376,
0.009521027095615864,
0.4720383286476135,
-0.7782652974128723,
0.5155816078186035,
0.11261061578989029,
-0.26621997356414795,
0.3346293270587921,
0.37207844853401184,
0.834930419921875,
0.2644340395927429,
-0.08130522072315216,
0.5223182439804077,
-0.2447579801082611,
-0.3162924647331238,
-0.5427771210670471,
0.6876679062843323,
-0.8068922162055969,
-0.6581790447235107,
-0.45574453473091125,
-0.5815355181694031,
-0.29868969321250916,
0.07842106372117996,
0.3858514428138733,
0.045591454952955246,
0.10289186239242554,
0.2485046088695526,
0.40338197350502014,
-0.1723109632730484,
0.5144241452217102,
0.6658358573913574,
-0.15643179416656494,
-0.6413047313690186,
1.0485637187957764,
0.13049498200416565,
0.32171645760536194,
0.4398491382598877,
0.30367785692214966,
-0.0755111575126648,
-0.8483055830001831,
-0.19526606798171997,
0.2972506880760193,
-0.7775271534919739,
-0.5705010294914246,
-0.43786314129829407,
-0.31907081604003906,
-0.3132474422454834,
-0.09111138433218002,
-0.5031859278678894,
-0.4056023359298706,
-0.17305582761764526,
0.26256781816482544,
0.484854131937027,
0.18604646623134613,
-0.26138365268707275,
0.763792872428894,
-0.7153849005699158,
0.3491816222667694,
0.6609953045845032,
0.19454410672187805,
-0.12533557415008545,
-0.7831882238388062,
-0.3767246603965759,
0.1316649317741394,
-0.5626546740531921,
-0.7334429621696472,
0.6553195118904114,
-0.1549370139837265,
0.1801597774028778,
0.2761495113372803,
-0.18892483413219452,
1.0189722776412964,
-0.1847921907901764,
0.4217801094055176,
0.4474725127220154,
-1.133886456489563,
0.01689033769071102,
-0.25400105118751526,
0.27257928252220154,
0.4172840118408203,
0.12016168236732483,
-0.6375621557235718,
-0.3824506998062134,
-0.46577683091163635,
-1.2019007205963135,
0.4627561569213867,
0.290300577878952,
0.044821374118328094,
0.24237406253814697,
0.1257120668888092,
0.041597455739974976,
0.5900967121124268,
-0.7397804260253906,
-0.3329907953739166,
-0.19289611279964447,
-0.25906136631965637,
0.1443057805299759,
-0.40332940220832825,
-0.06877673417329788,
-0.10886837542057037,
0.6744043231010437,
-0.13379323482513428,
0.0979105532169342,
-0.27539825439453125,
-0.49393031001091003,
-0.4920065104961395,
0.22648955881595612,
0.4021179974079132,
0.6125021576881409,
0.004325487185269594,
0.11393685638904572,
0.21230292320251465,
-0.5756815075874329,
0.1628977656364441,
0.05588412657380104,
-0.3358147144317627,
-0.14282065629959106,
0.1422225534915924,
0.4265204071998596,
0.05109595134854317,
-0.5339288711547852,
0.5394994020462036,
0.16009032726287842,
0.21631301939487457,
-0.7292599678039551,
-0.22046399116516113,
0.03819020465016365,
0.5786893367767334,
0.5045108199119568,
-0.32050490379333496,
0.003009702078998089,
-0.4587908983230591,
-0.28586456179618835,
0.6856686472892761,
-0.04961470514535904,
-0.28294453024864197,
0.26419761776924133,
0.05488612502813339,
-0.2857138514518738,
0.7906407713890076,
-0.27268821001052856,
-0.4451286792755127,
0.38917189836502075,
0.38269951939582825,
0.8757290244102478,
-0.0992310419678688,
0.2693093717098236,
-0.08254019916057587,
0.16629046201705933,
-0.08592917770147324,
0.4397350549697876,
0.30735889077186584,
-1.138690710067749,
-0.3553195893764496,
-0.5554602146148682,
-0.2715241014957428,
0.42219221591949463,
-0.3861348032951355,
0.30720919370651245,
-0.3715396225452423,
-0.09814570844173431,
-0.1327393800020218,
-0.11202362179756165,
-0.4706183075904846,
-0.18340978026390076,
0.09112139791250229,
0.3337433338165283,
-0.5770772695541382,
1.0591524839401245,
0.7952005863189697,
-0.23867857456207275,
-0.28554633259773254,
-0.11579465866088867,
-0.08478759974241257,
-1.0299814939498901,
0.6298717260360718,
-0.20257075130939484,
-0.03268624469637871,
0.2201455533504486,
-0.3410676121711731,
-1.2034398317337036,
1.1914880275726318,
0.4899963140487671,
-0.928285539150238,
0.34968146681785583,
0.6237683296203613,
0.44749170541763306,
-0.1148856058716774,
0.05696697533130646,
0.7984167337417603,
0.5621029138565063,
0.18055804073810577,
-0.4617231786251068,
0.01279165968298912,
0.26768916845321655,
0.24496042728424072,
0.5913292765617371,
-0.6394487619400024,
0.991941511631012,
-0.1135420873761177,
-0.23307764530181885,
0.23235447704792023,
0.5577110648155212,
0.5629379749298096,
-0.03672119230031967,
0.6174623370170593,
0.7597041726112366,
0.8753502368927002,
-0.2211156040430069,
0.5354858636856079,
-0.20353515446186066,
0.2825578451156616,
0.9548419713973999,
-0.21279816329479218,
0.46374693512916565,
0.7625928521156311,
-0.2762201130390167,
0.5003483295440674,
0.047673214226961136,
0.13293702900409698,
0.5013869404792786,
0.6242069602012634,
-0.3932259976863861,
-0.523357629776001,
0.46635597944259644,
-0.2840994894504547,
0.39066600799560547,
0.5280434489250183,
0.1181328147649765,
-0.24580663442611694,
-0.0004946536500938237,
0.11166568845510483,
0.0227822158485651,
-0.20933552086353302,
0.48075518012046814,
0.08602552115917206,
-0.3491063117980957,
0.5303303003311157,
0.2606218457221985,
0.7700701355934143,
-0.4377230107784271,
-0.05887339636683464,
-0.5618165731430054,
0.3774130940437317,
-0.18231618404388428,
-0.6511403918266296,
0.15616656839847565,
-0.31555265188217163,
-0.09568049013614655,
-0.37484419345855713,
0.22254163026809692,
-0.658394455909729,
-0.6427581310272217,
0.020886076614260674,
0.4318912923336029,
0.047698285430669785,
-0.4548642933368683,
-0.5581430196762085,
0.26216307282447815,
0.04507433623075485,
-0.2013670653104782,
0.5104888677597046,
0.7852824926376343,
-0.6397868990898132,
0.6915320754051208,
0.9162804484367371,
0.15291112661361694,
0.1364433765411377,
0.12622378766536713,
0.8435813188552856,
-0.8682520389556885,
-0.4304064214229584,
-0.9678493142127991,
0.5328419208526611,
0.12214931845664978,
-0.30324897170066833,
0.8152422904968262,
0.5749020576477051,
0.6291263699531555,
-0.03152358904480934,
0.4630497395992279,
0.3989276885986328,
0.23987312614917755,
-0.5242982506752014,
0.3871206045150757,
-0.24787835776805878,
0.7505942583084106,
0.12535463273525238,
-0.870451033115387,
-0.49991321563720703,
0.6246562600135803,
-0.08407066017389297,
-0.12762415409088135,
0.5881102681159973,
1.0245109796524048,
0.29881396889686584,
-0.16357652842998505,
0.6168504357337952,
0.26511430740356445,
0.48417550325393677,
0.4200591742992401,
1.096178412437439,
-0.48875194787979126,
0.7889462113380432,
-0.2994990944862366,
-0.18940165638923645,
-0.6237684488296509,
-0.953219473361969,
-0.7208950519561768,
-0.3126470744609833,
-0.6583126783370972,
-0.24566811323165894,
0.11671795696020126,
0.8566922545433044,
0.4242495596408844,
-0.8732300996780396,
-0.3442974388599396,
-0.19052280485630035,
0.5208947658538818,
-0.3139401972293854,
-0.26085278391838074,
0.3477696478366852,
-0.30650487542152405,
-0.6700869202613831,
0.2905818819999695,
0.5238997340202332,
0.373697429895401,
-0.39734745025634766,
0.03491543233394623,
0.23066438734531403,
0.08415741473436356,
0.6313440203666687,
0.07481561601161957,
-0.49365150928497314,
-0.12040339410305023,
-0.2564148008823395,
-0.03748811408877373,
0.05898335576057434,
0.9561026692390442,
-0.778074324131012,
0.26300469040870667,
0.5827901363372803,
0.2454788237810135,
0.6521351933479309,
0.12520216405391693,
0.3486655056476593,
-0.8418092131614685,
0.1576007604598999,
0.22332648932933807,
0.08890674263238907,
0.4735889136791229,
-0.2856164872646332,
0.5496851205825806,
0.22177015244960785,
-0.3920126259326935,
-0.9928679466247559,
0.22680474817752838,
-0.7997125387191772,
-0.025079570710659027,
1.3607993125915527,
0.1719198226928711,
0.0718488097190857,
-0.17784558236598969,
0.04759979248046875,
-0.00845074001699686,
-0.32428795099258423,
0.7792673707008362,
0.4750335216522217,
-0.09652967005968094,
0.02983582392334938,
-0.17313115298748016,
0.36995360255241394,
0.642737865447998,
-0.4303196370601654,
-0.03485728055238724,
0.23379671573638916,
0.3024557828903198,
0.25350359082221985,
0.47686871886253357,
-0.5629391074180603,
0.16728512942790985,
-0.4447519779205322,
0.21004198491573334,
-0.12792247533798218,
-0.035585928708314896,
-0.7358558177947998,
0.019872959703207016,
0.07306841015815735,
-0.19530029594898224
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.06573v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.06573v1
|
MedFuzz: Exploring the Robustness of Large Language Models in Medical Question Answering
| 2024-06-03T18:15:56 | 2024-06-03T18:15:56 |
Robert Osazuwa Ness, Katie Matton, Hayden Helm, Sheng Zhang, Junaid Bajwa, Carey E. Priebe, Eric Horvitz
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG, I.2.7
|
Large language models (LLM) have achieved impressive performance on medical
question-answering benchmarks. However, high benchmark accuracy does not imply
that the performance generalizes to real-world clinical settings. Medical
question-answering benchmarks rely on assumptions consistent with quantifying
LLM performance but that may not hold in the open world of the clinic. Yet LLMs
learn broad knowledge that can help the LLM generalize to practical conditions
regardless of unrealistic assumptions in celebrated benchmarks. We seek to
quantify how well LLM medical question-answering benchmark performance
generalizes when benchmark assumptions are violated. Specifically, we present
an adversarial method that we call MedFuzz (for medical fuzzing). MedFuzz
attempts to modify benchmark questions in ways aimed at confounding the LLM. We
demonstrate the approach by targeting strong assumptions about patient
characteristics presented in the MedQA benchmark. Successful "attacks" modify a
benchmark item in ways that would be unlikely to fool a medical expert but
nonetheless "trick" the LLM into changing from a correct to an incorrect
answer. Further, we present a permutation test technique that can ensure a
successful attack is statistically significant. We show how to use performance
on a "MedFuzzed" benchmark, as well as individual successful attacks. The
methods show promise at providing insights into the ability of an LLM to
operate robustly in more realistic settings.
|
[
-0.23038697242736816,
-1.4531993865966797,
0.7420835494995117,
-0.20866531133651733,
0.07936080545186996,
0.12476449459791183,
-0.19185307621955872,
-0.12056396901607513,
-0.11204042285680771,
0.669509768486023,
-0.7208184599876404,
-0.3063991665840149,
-0.6233705282211304,
0.10777512937784195,
-0.4033660888671875,
1.00026535987854,
0.021294547244906425,
0.511802077293396,
-0.33669883012771606,
-0.23823285102844238,
-0.1770874708890915,
-0.8255226016044617,
-0.5828616619110107,
-0.33552831411361694,
0.5313670635223389,
0.2493622601032257,
1.1253079175949097,
0.5183267593383789,
0.8085082173347473,
0.25818896293640137,
0.08440129458904266,
0.11536131054162979,
-0.629898190498352,
0.21471966803073883,
0.03223478049039841,
-0.8771510720252991,
-0.22347724437713623,
-0.14658713340759277,
0.512712299823761,
0.9398301243782043,
-0.4379544258117676,
-0.01859515719115734,
-0.5091743469238281,
0.4204626679420471,
-0.38880065083503723,
-0.28268343210220337,
-0.8164126873016357,
-0.014431864954531193,
-0.2299538403749466,
-0.053486358374357224,
-0.4912686049938202,
-0.39970505237579346,
-0.2912561595439911,
-0.4331798553466797,
0.268423467874527,
0.14838719367980957,
0.8013403415679932,
0.6576185822486877,
-0.25155848264694214,
-0.11535108089447021,
-0.6538761854171753,
0.4800381362438202,
-0.8621038794517517,
0.2383854240179062,
0.6118622422218323,
0.6400074362754822,
-0.6081646680831909,
-0.8162263035774231,
-0.39198336005210876,
-0.12296567857265472,
0.0596066489815712,
-0.17250488698482513,
-0.23082320392131805,
0.18535637855529785,
0.5465277433395386,
0.434638649225235,
-0.6423153281211853,
0.02682926133275032,
-0.2583310902118683,
-0.18602770566940308,
0.6073828339576721,
0.4412185549736023,
0.430664598941803,
0.31625616550445557,
-0.37785905599594116,
0.0036356602795422077,
-0.7627255916595459,
0.1707604080438614,
-0.023190731182694435,
-0.18013998866081238,
0.13207940757274628,
0.4906790256500244,
-0.005125340539962053,
0.6288818717002869,
0.07444745302200317,
-0.24671073257923126,
0.09318353235721588,
-0.06328307092189789,
-0.41456687450408936,
-0.30911996960639954,
0.8217682242393494,
0.23052063584327698,
0.44313886761665344,
-0.4976218640804291,
-0.0406002514064312,
-0.03136351332068443,
0.5453091859817505,
-0.7323647141456604,
-0.38843998312950134,
0.5053669810295105,
-0.28272634744644165,
-0.5576338171958923,
-0.030285337939858437,
-0.7855353355407715,
-0.6495733261108398,
0.43223604559898376,
0.4098702073097229,
-0.4763547480106354,
-0.04744700714945793,
0.14295397698879242,
0.05781690403819084,
0.0694785863161087,
0.20763392746448517,
-0.7068964838981628,
0.49375417828559875,
0.8245046734809875,
0.390332967042923,
0.07700800895690918,
-0.2792471945285797,
-0.7632158994674683,
0.04994381591677666,
-0.43441084027290344,
0.8091667294502258,
-0.5453692078590393,
-0.5076674818992615,
-0.18101194500923157,
-0.0607115812599659,
-0.21209938824176788,
-0.8224101662635803,
0.4002896249294281,
-0.46126702427864075,
0.0751316100358963,
-0.3879457414150238,
-0.6652956008911133,
-0.0662098303437233,
0.35011982917785645,
-0.526770830154419,
0.6816637516021729,
0.2934997081756592,
-0.918431282043457,
0.08547716587781906,
-0.49716803431510925,
-0.48458197712898254,
-0.15748754143714905,
-0.39355432987213135,
-0.4821956753730774,
0.31205105781555176,
0.4129253327846527,
0.2982560098171234,
-0.4601966142654419,
0.3155444860458374,
-0.6391311287879944,
-0.427080899477005,
0.9543507099151611,
-0.7320776581764221,
0.7271809577941895,
0.22603267431259155,
-0.059310272336006165,
-0.09946668893098831,
-0.4385291337966919,
0.2316732406616211,
0.4142003059387207,
-0.19177699089050293,
-0.009687590412795544,
-0.006883847527205944,
-0.20058567821979523,
0.0725061371922493,
-0.08375368267297745,
-0.3914279341697693,
0.30282339453697205,
-0.7738106846809387,
0.4418925642967224,
0.503729522228241,
0.2954424321651459,
-0.12544409930706024,
-0.6802911758422852,
0.8405424356460571,
-0.22759364545345306,
0.4009641408920288,
-0.07204411923885345,
-0.5453381538391113,
-0.351743221282959,
-0.33813780546188354,
0.44992563128471375,
0.6689372062683105,
-0.8405122756958008,
-0.2505635917186737,
0.04629242792725563,
-0.5013341903686523,
-0.7886782884597778,
0.26261812448501587,
0.35755735635757446,
0.858879566192627,
0.3521477282047272,
-0.053899019956588745,
-0.08029401302337646,
-0.9620047211647034,
-0.5978897213935852,
-0.4485814869403839,
-0.14920738339424133,
0.4845239818096161,
0.4083816707134247,
-0.24112655222415924,
0.34392064809799194,
-0.8630571365356445,
0.07390721142292023,
-0.02995769865810871,
0.07317112386226654,
0.42632734775543213,
0.2720786929130554,
0.6947224140167236,
-0.9974693655967712,
-0.1087082251906395,
-0.3268711268901825,
-0.39620888233184814,
-0.20747500658035278,
-0.014798115007579327,
0.09673845767974854,
-0.06860583275556564,
0.5643399357795715,
-0.6270741820335388,
0.2636822760105133,
0.4960241913795471,
-0.4253862798213959,
0.7681458592414856,
-0.22738997638225555,
0.4985955059528351,
-0.8804340958595276,
0.18085335195064545,
-0.3232579529285431,
-0.21808524429798126,
-0.8626718521118164,
0.4608002305030823,
0.04371621832251549,
0.0437447763979435,
-0.4084557890892029,
0.3098165690898895,
0.01608210988342762,
0.31000977754592896,
-0.11006505787372589,
-0.4108014702796936,
-0.06695292890071869,
0.23011694848537445,
-0.619181215763092,
0.9423532485961914,
0.3998855948448181,
-0.20326535403728485,
0.4544120132923126,
0.11183662712574005,
-0.23184418678283691,
0.6684529185295105,
-0.6916218400001526,
0.1949855089187622,
0.0042607709765434265,
0.11419786512851715,
-1.2709627151489258,
-0.5670632719993591,
-0.01824621669948101,
-0.7081493735313416,
0.41952070593833923,
-0.03891158849000931,
-0.7942519783973694,
-0.5114572644233704,
-0.14243344962596893,
0.3830718398094177,
0.5966836214065552,
-0.1905152052640915,
0.44146817922592163,
0.45719626545906067,
-0.24971482157707214,
-0.6225612759590149,
-0.90782231092453,
-0.009524843655526638,
-0.34493744373321533,
-0.5521544814109802,
-0.03593192994594574,
-0.3299061954021454,
-0.46234139800071716,
-0.2695409059524536,
-0.16664396226406097,
-0.5327251553535461,
0.5888515114784241,
0.2612830400466919,
0.21568870544433594,
-0.35843977332115173,
0.16647207736968994,
-0.1588222086429596,
0.08592487871646881,
0.482210636138916,
0.22368717193603516,
0.501826822757721,
-0.0859825536608696,
-0.713897705078125,
0.02006950043141842,
0.43970099091529846,
0.8589645028114319,
-0.1911872774362564,
0.67117840051651,
0.5298004746437073,
-0.6445927023887634,
-0.08611483126878738,
-0.8223437666893005,
-0.31349611282348633,
-0.4685601592063904,
0.4826830327510834,
-0.2444620430469513,
-0.815888524055481,
0.4983774721622467,
-0.14501464366912842,
0.17812278866767883,
0.31802430748939514,
0.747973620891571,
-0.4376661479473114,
1.2811721563339233,
0.3279656767845154,
-0.06620264053344727,
-0.2853119969367981,
0.1292591542005539,
0.011230521835386753,
-0.3296828269958496,
-0.17021209001541138,
-0.6428627371788025,
-0.3132844567298889,
-0.27228620648384094,
-0.607266366481781,
0.5582297444343567,
-0.021102072671055794,
-0.17793072760105133,
-0.23236289620399475,
-0.15950612723827362,
0.45317214727401733,
0.21566352248191833,
0.24548758566379547,
0.12951374053955078,
-0.15799859166145325,
-0.38838011026382446,
-0.07828094065189362,
-0.9173842072486877,
-0.07491550594568253,
1.2080641984939575,
0.48906052112579346,
1.1173402070999146,
0.17552776634693146,
0.4628937542438507,
0.11108007282018661,
0.5419536828994751,
-0.5073791742324829,
0.3082992434501648,
-0.2861259877681732,
-0.8643401861190796,
-0.0563054196536541,
-0.6245670914649963,
-0.8306053280830383,
0.09977755695581436,
-0.44029510021209717,
-0.6593946218490601,
-0.3081412613391876,
0.2273072749376297,
-0.520027756690979,
0.5042557120323181,
-0.6995363831520081,
0.8341564536094666,
-0.38035592436790466,
-0.13026200234889984,
-0.010508749634027481,
-0.7333850860595703,
0.30497297644615173,
-0.21371078491210938,
0.481922447681427,
0.03189267963171005,
-0.21640686690807343,
0.4137696623802185,
-0.47317826747894287,
0.6503808498382568,
-0.00591894518584013,
0.006825410295277834,
-0.17212773859500885,
0.17547884583473206,
0.1874486654996872,
0.15620574355125427,
-0.21450844407081604,
-0.019280891865491867,
0.2966485619544983,
-0.6661314964294434,
-0.847905158996582,
0.7669533491134644,
-0.5704206228256226,
-0.9619204998016357,
-0.19596415758132935,
-0.8042119145393372,
-0.8255645632743835,
0.17023175954818726,
0.3387777805328369,
0.4574737548828125,
-0.3302183747291565,
0.33131322264671326,
0.9464046955108643,
-0.23339660465717316,
-0.1772967427968979,
0.4916642904281616,
-0.21476112306118011,
-0.3926090598106384,
0.4496663510799408,
0.052935197949409485,
0.4310929775238037,
0.41293999552726746,
0.284770667552948,
-0.271927148103714,
-0.7746689915657043,
-0.5417413711547852,
0.3509989380836487,
-0.710873544216156,
-0.2522018551826477,
-0.6001525521278381,
-0.3213411569595337,
-0.3176206052303314,
-0.263918936252594,
-0.13009808957576752,
-0.23582813143730164,
0.03569026663899422,
0.12108533829450607,
0.2813835144042969,
0.64737468957901,
0.4686734974384308,
0.004977825563400984,
-0.7078519463539124,
0.3861203193664551,
0.27007052302360535,
0.337006539106369,
-0.28246092796325684,
-0.4231429100036621,
0.04179682955145836,
0.135593444108963,
-0.12055785953998566,
-1.221293330192566,
0.02894093096256256,
0.10350356996059418,
0.7976547479629517,
0.45361989736557007,
0.20451867580413818,
0.6055047512054443,
-0.5874095559120178,
0.6375470161437988,
0.07533349841833115,
-0.3628052771091461,
0.4898544251918793,
-0.3832191228866577,
0.3970576524734497,
0.7660657167434692,
0.4061442017555237,
-0.25241968035697937,
-0.7800536751747131,
-0.9333427548408508,
-0.4378204345703125,
0.16166965663433075,
0.07441120594739914,
-0.03330733999609947,
0.09484163671731949,
0.6496062874794006,
0.0038299316074699163,
0.32923057675361633,
-0.30741193890571594,
-0.44590044021606445,
0.2024904489517212,
-0.49385011196136475,
-0.2402038872241974,
-0.12877099215984344,
-0.6143786907196045,
-0.19092899560928345,
0.4068850874900818,
-0.1431608647108078,
0.1487606316804886,
0.29533252120018005,
0.03283393010497093,
-0.22606083750724792,
0.35417991876602173,
0.5198128819465637,
0.7485711574554443,
-0.11908096820116043,
0.22526779770851135,
0.60252845287323,
-0.6447276473045349,
0.19534258544445038,
0.3423285484313965,
0.009912912733852863,
-0.1455734670162201,
0.45394930243492126,
0.18812870979309082,
0.35842007398605347,
-1.074201226234436,
0.6284591555595398,
-0.3161742687225342,
-0.27739307284355164,
0.07690262049436569,
0.3789936900138855,
0.18656259775161743,
0.24016907811164856,
0.2508607804775238,
0.08695795387029648,
0.1921587884426117,
-0.49672043323516846,
0.4347382187843323,
0.6998639106750488,
-0.45099562406539917,
-0.006263928487896919,
0.9500269889831543,
-0.17118403315544128,
-0.3669672906398773,
0.4560248553752899,
0.41852349042892456,
-0.6051666140556335,
0.8433992266654968,
0.5946457386016846,
0.46307745575904846,
-0.408890038728714,
0.021220024675130844,
0.10018522292375565,
0.4903794825077057,
0.14130976796150208,
0.2675177752971649,
0.36662280559539795,
-0.3577403426170349,
-0.3280907869338989,
-0.21215298771858215,
-0.5711207985877991,
0.39786863327026367,
-0.5764509439468384,
-0.01299205794930458,
-0.7751988172531128,
-0.2707383632659912,
0.2539443373680115,
0.07684306800365448,
-0.5205374360084534,
0.455310195684433,
0.09684944152832031,
1.186444640159607,
-0.6265467405319214,
0.8222300410270691,
0.8665730357170105,
-0.08795129507780075,
-0.8991259336471558,
0.20324233174324036,
0.26152482628822327,
-1.0130572319030762,
-0.015748878940939903,
-0.08000822365283966,
0.07348586618900299,
-0.30474743247032166,
-0.7303430438041687,
-0.5650047063827515,
0.8563418984413147,
0.5342856049537659,
-0.21574676036834717,
0.05059331655502319,
0.1678258776664734,
0.6445671916007996,
-0.2801363170146942,
0.06213223561644554,
0.48434868454933167,
0.22392651438713074,
0.09629976004362106,
-0.812581479549408,
0.24189552664756775,
-0.2728443443775177,
-0.45653581619262695,
0.26866409182548523,
-0.590450644493103,
0.7999748587608337,
-0.7667120695114136,
0.06369835883378983,
0.2679235637187958,
0.11910692602396011,
0.238016277551651,
0.35849547386169434,
0.4877060055732727,
0.504389226436615,
0.9589215517044067,
-0.3109807074069977,
1.3254426717758179,
-0.1867135465145111,
0.2576281726360321,
0.8662757873535156,
-0.07261519879102707,
0.9017109870910645,
0.5587992072105408,
-0.39735957980155945,
0.2154964804649353,
0.4192405641078949,
-0.18631908297538757,
0.33719682693481445,
0.3429403305053711,
-0.14686226844787598,
-0.42782989144325256,
0.2515951693058014,
-0.5766607522964478,
0.27290621399879456,
0.5423168540000916,
-0.3549758195877075,
-0.1621961146593094,
-0.1350226104259491,
0.535943865776062,
0.14894600212574005,
-0.15673962235450745,
0.7096186876296997,
0.05461746081709862,
-0.733605682849884,
0.8272967338562012,
-0.013249027542769909,
0.2819364070892334,
-0.7720836400985718,
0.01031024195253849,
-0.22295546531677246,
0.28185001015663147,
-0.17981654405593872,
-0.7045883536338806,
0.18085230886936188,
0.10177253186702728,
-0.2132628709077835,
0.25392696261405945,
0.7724300026893616,
-0.3273864686489105,
-0.6631264090538025,
-0.08418592065572739,
0.4497857689857483,
0.1358407437801361,
0.11041450500488281,
-0.9960557222366333,
-0.03809657692909241,
0.06259901076555252,
-0.06369218230247498,
0.3701097369194031,
0.307166188955307,
0.2609885334968567,
1.0486857891082764,
0.7108638882637024,
0.35195624828338623,
-0.2014310657978058,
-0.011089598760008812,
0.9113444685935974,
-0.4015962779521942,
-0.42833471298217773,
-0.9835209250450134,
0.15790072083473206,
0.003313590306788683,
-0.235895037651062,
0.6089471578598022,
0.31934016942977905,
0.5115824937820435,
0.08730122447013855,
0.5856789350509644,
0.34480705857276917,
0.5596846342086792,
-0.5529050827026367,
1.1371376514434814,
-0.72464919090271,
0.25907662510871887,
-0.21119961142539978,
-0.1821189671754837,
-0.43404677510261536,
0.30799445509910583,
-0.335661917924881,
0.03967646136879921,
0.6398980617523193,
0.7514671683311462,
0.09250857681035995,
0.15811629593372345,
0.5342452526092529,
0.7616241574287415,
0.2670339047908783,
0.94587641954422,
0.7163017392158508,
-0.3795454800128937,
0.5999890565872192,
-0.24652314186096191,
-0.36503341794013977,
-0.20254339277744293,
-0.5335632562637329,
-1.046020269393921,
-0.17062723636627197,
-0.30785638093948364,
-0.6318646669387817,
0.2381860315799713,
0.6817293763160706,
0.637369692325592,
-0.8827128410339355,
0.17912963032722473,
0.45490485429763794,
0.08514229208230972,
-0.33809810876846313,
-0.16342554986476898,
0.17836067080497742,
-0.18387062847614288,
-0.20831046998500824,
0.3758842945098877,
0.1601443737745285,
-0.07993767410516739,
-0.266781210899353,
0.19189508259296417,
-0.17365530133247375,
0.3902011811733246,
0.019808832556009293,
0.2783092260360718,
-0.7505859136581421,
-0.0849350318312645,
0.19286595284938812,
-0.20140738785266876,
0.12181684374809265,
0.7649339437484741,
-0.4972012937068939,
0.49364301562309265,
0.12595084309577942,
1.1116101741790771,
0.027253303676843643,
0.19493922591209412,
0.698226809501648,
-0.43734413385391235,
-0.13746817409992218,
0.30476075410842896,
0.3645096719264984,
0.297730416059494,
-0.5656998753547668,
0.3690492808818817,
0.16085276007652283,
-0.6506505012512207,
-1.007365107536316,
0.17433777451515198,
-0.6472484469413757,
-0.6011921763420105,
0.9996290802955627,
-0.30345115065574646,
-0.2581828236579895,
-0.25454431772232056,
-0.17791469395160675,
-0.22332653403282166,
0.08060470968484879,
0.79433673620224,
0.9379063844680786,
-0.23335079848766327,
0.01796938292682171,
-0.9074264168739319,
0.6114030480384827,
0.5523821711540222,
-0.907849133014679,
-0.07371486723423004,
0.3503340482711792,
0.7780806422233582,
-0.09519902616739273,
0.6874194741249084,
-0.40481626987457275,
0.7478243708610535,
-0.008926382288336754,
-0.6600959897041321,
-0.22079521417617798,
-0.002849332056939602,
-0.23713654279708862,
0.5029699206352234,
0.2441222071647644,
0.0923617035150528
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.01592v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.01592v1
|
Text-guided Controllable Mesh Refinement for Interactive 3D Modeling
| 2024-06-03T17:59:43 | 2024-06-03T17:59:43 |
Yun-Chun Chen, Selena Ling, Zhiqin Chen, Vladimir G. Kim, Matheus Gadelha, Alec Jacobson
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.GR, cs.LG
|
We propose a novel technique for adding geometric details to an input coarse
3D mesh guided by a text prompt. Our method is composed of three stages. First,
we generate a single-view RGB image conditioned on the input coarse geometry
and the input text prompt. This single-view image generation step allows the
user to pre-visualize the result and offers stronger conditioning for
subsequent multi-view generation. Second, we use our novel multi-view normal
generation architecture to jointly generate six different views of the normal
images. The joint view generation reduces inconsistencies and leads to sharper
details. Third, we optimize our mesh with respect to all views and generate a
fine, detailed geometry as output. The resulting method produces an output
within seconds and offers explicit user control over the coarse structure,
pose, and desired details of the resulting 3D mesh. Project page:
https://text-mesh-refinement.github.io.
|
[
-0.46309924125671387,
-1.1330772638320923,
0.7553613185882568,
0.2409694939851761,
-0.11614717543125153,
-0.21847407519817352,
-0.028951482847332954,
-0.3482016921043396,
-0.006397612858563662,
0.5423973202705383,
-0.7730408310890198,
-0.8028325438499451,
-0.13261494040489197,
0.2612355351448059,
-0.12939873337745667,
0.826995313167572,
-0.2385408878326416,
-0.11631668359041214,
-0.4984923005104065,
0.21267028152942657,
-0.1081204041838646,
-0.32633495330810547,
-0.6915496587753296,
-0.2387516051530838,
0.7729363441467285,
0.48281440138816833,
0.733844518661499,
1.1016746759414673,
0.36931127309799194,
0.36914944648742676,
-0.1858094185590744,
0.4149775505065918,
-0.7113320231437683,
-0.10255417227745056,
-0.028925560414791107,
-0.2160055786371231,
-0.4157591760158539,
-0.0504344180226326,
0.6245166659355164,
0.8249388337135315,
-0.08310013264417648,
-0.04469677060842514,
0.44634705781936646,
0.7545727491378784,
-0.40052178502082825,
0.14348672330379486,
-0.08416208624839783,
0.01932305283844471,
-0.22430485486984253,
-0.17644019424915314,
-0.24690520763397217,
-0.6651883721351624,
0.1906706839799881,
-1.1199793815612793,
0.663171112537384,
0.13316529989242554,
0.8706300854682922,
0.3008759915828705,
-0.29864129424095154,
0.05788760259747505,
-0.7579461932182312,
0.7369118928909302,
-0.7276835441589355,
0.30320870876312256,
0.1383068561553955,
0.4495397210121155,
-0.27937614917755127,
-1.0094245672225952,
-0.25260213017463684,
-0.17755818367004395,
-0.4577491879463196,
0.06862078607082367,
0.08678123354911804,
0.5016785264015198,
0.3485548794269562,
0.458249568939209,
-0.5456505417823792,
-0.12047675251960754,
-0.6447451114654541,
-0.345492422580719,
0.670108437538147,
0.13794158399105072,
0.26219722628593445,
-0.01738296076655388,
-0.529342770576477,
-0.10134030133485794,
-0.5050562620162964,
0.25655773282051086,
0.5631265640258789,
0.3619585931301117,
-0.4516591727733612,
0.6428677439689636,
-0.4648490846157074,
1.1472208499908447,
0.010494047775864601,
-0.04935992509126663,
0.13629330694675446,
-0.23236678540706635,
-0.178602397441864,
-0.1814720630645752,
0.9603914022445679,
0.5031223893165588,
0.0800098404288292,
0.19127753376960754,
-0.11631928384304047,
-0.38327354192733765,
0.6378622651100159,
-0.8712050318717957,
-0.4407707750797272,
0.19348865747451782,
-0.5509626865386963,
-0.5190961360931396,
0.20839673280715942,
-1.0561715364456177,
-0.7007216811180115,
-0.5526946783065796,
0.3735634386539459,
-0.22830995917320251,
0.05030060186982155,
0.4107982814311981,
-0.06679750978946686,
-0.19206325709819794,
0.8719527721405029,
-0.515910804271698,
0.2216431051492691,
0.24969536066055298,
0.7336217164993286,
-0.08625617623329163,
-0.08282233774662018,
-0.27224329113960266,
0.24902741611003876,
-0.2848140299320221,
1.022118330001831,
-0.46966880559921265,
-0.5287337303161621,
-0.09603255242109299,
-0.20511913299560547,
0.14238668978214264,
-0.2818004786968231,
0.44134214520454407,
0.06102708354592323,
0.45136210322380066,
-0.000923996907658875,
-0.17712529003620148,
-0.7217312455177307,
0.47548189759254456,
-0.907873272895813,
0.9518857598304749,
0.22811320424079895,
-0.8907013535499573,
-0.018215404823422432,
-0.48848533630371094,
-0.054406069219112396,
-0.033106230199337006,
-0.5914947390556335,
-0.48203495144844055,
0.1049266904592514,
0.3349139988422394,
0.48235976696014404,
-0.14341141283512115,
-0.03761700168251991,
-0.48684102296829224,
-0.23683758080005646,
-0.09177934378385544,
-0.1674388200044632,
0.06808476895093918,
0.1352417916059494,
-0.03302283585071564,
0.4351487159729004,
-1.129690170288086,
0.2683352828025818,
-0.08060593903064728,
-0.4191462993621826,
0.14533868432044983,
-0.032874464988708496,
0.07661352306604385,
0.0026725430507212877,
0.32176390290260315,
-0.750640332698822,
0.19339321553707123,
-0.44359055161476135,
-0.08721106499433517,
0.4414924383163452,
0.23947888612747192,
0.43383949995040894,
-0.4611188471317291,
0.46025463938713074,
-0.14483100175857544,
0.2252817302942276,
-0.3752982020378113,
-0.5270357131958008,
-0.696320652961731,
-0.2672577500343323,
0.1093449741601944,
0.3156096935272217,
-0.9125855565071106,
-0.19296202063560486,
0.2614680826663971,
-0.5486460328102112,
0.04793399199843407,
0.004933972842991352,
0.5079373121261597,
0.7224978804588318,
0.39778026938438416,
-0.036490023136138916,
-0.2338876873254776,
-1.1849733591079712,
-0.3262808620929718,
0.09837442636489868,
-0.44519785046577454,
0.2718513011932373,
-0.10383925586938858,
0.13495449721813202,
0.8618254065513611,
-0.8481957316398621,
-0.22664588689804077,
-0.1913301795721054,
0.44712767004966736,
0.06030721962451935,
0.7804147005081177,
0.6540160775184631,
-0.8027490973472595,
-0.3067377209663391,
0.3080906569957733,
-0.5504462718963623,
-0.2676633596420288,
-0.2925766408443451,
-0.27799952030181885,
-0.14528541266918182,
0.8029521107673645,
-0.16402262449264526,
0.8531429767608643,
0.498607337474823,
-0.5463377833366394,
0.4562063217163086,
-0.46076977252960205,
0.33135268092155457,
-0.9699466228485107,
-0.02918599173426628,
0.33946287631988525,
-0.29001903533935547,
-0.7759891748428345,
0.07742207497358322,
0.11401614546775818,
-0.21084237098693848,
-0.6571812033653259,
0.623203694820404,
-0.4718950688838959,
0.4341619610786438,
-0.3765549659729004,
0.0137636112049222,
0.3711882531642914,
0.8675976395606995,
0.0481453612446785,
0.43615975975990295,
0.29889973998069763,
-1.0041803121566772,
0.4338986575603485,
-0.0026561457198113203,
-0.22225424647331238,
0.5052464008331299,
-0.9630032181739807,
0.17591167986392975,
-0.19050337374210358,
0.2400525063276291,
-1.090636134147644,
-0.5195097327232361,
0.27260908484458923,
-0.3352692127227783,
0.1573103815317154,
0.13048698008060455,
-0.29117369651794434,
-0.23842577636241913,
-0.2738831639289856,
0.6466187834739685,
-0.11059467494487762,
-0.358123779296875,
1.0338597297668457,
0.007068740203976631,
-0.536502480506897,
0.28505897521972656,
-0.538666844367981,
-0.3855131268501282,
0.13722124695777893,
-0.6811366677284241,
0.5553305149078369,
-0.32800784707069397,
-0.14230413734912872,
-0.16158166527748108,
-0.06669037789106369,
-0.3198414444923401,
-0.22068005800247192,
0.3703869879245758,
0.114744171500206,
0.06479250639677048,
-0.04645916074514389,
0.5290446281433105,
-0.19952046871185303,
-0.18103674054145813,
0.023806046694517136,
0.2664433717727661,
0.025194227695465088,
-0.3521481156349182,
-1.0006563663482666,
0.6468843817710876,
0.31810179352760315,
-0.07542356103658676,
0.15797749161720276,
0.4983692467212677,
-0.7059388160705566,
-0.08767007291316986,
-0.3627416789531708,
-0.10988585650920868,
-0.5217012763023376,
0.24457696080207825,
-0.5945317149162292,
-0.7378289699554443,
0.36609262228012085,
-0.23400701582431793,
0.5388117432594299,
0.5852498412132263,
0.3577079474925995,
-0.11078043282032013,
1.5109621286392212,
1.1401735544204712,
0.7711779475212097,
0.36994460225105286,
-0.13357168436050415,
-0.0053865015506744385,
-0.7097116708755493,
-0.7069602012634277,
-0.9225026369094849,
-0.5871101021766663,
-0.29147762060165405,
-0.4768821597099304,
0.3904620409011841,
0.29817456007003784,
-0.22655165195465088,
0.007588586769998074,
-0.6756452918052673,
0.41950440406799316,
0.49760183691978455,
0.4752334952354431,
0.19250880181789398,
-0.0856010690331459,
-0.5560815930366516,
-0.17075645923614502,
-0.6196439266204834,
-0.6368381381034851,
0.487222820520401,
0.25675418972969055,
0.9772673845291138,
-0.1604306399822235,
0.5271667242050171,
-0.024863893166184425,
0.16259434819221497,
-0.6039298176765442,
0.370097279548645,
0.11035939306020737,
-0.20579196512699127,
-0.06937479972839355,
-0.5105514526367188,
-0.740798830986023,
0.04934943839907646,
-0.5952326059341431,
-0.7040203213691711,
0.15762607753276825,
0.5295822024345398,
-0.878700315952301,
0.3131484389305115,
-0.8946271538734436,
0.6385422945022583,
0.09293565899133682,
-0.45916879177093506,
0.21403926610946655,
-0.3288878798484802,
0.3037758469581604,
0.03405967727303505,
0.31037527322769165,
-0.13940809667110443,
-0.161722332239151,
0.4628409445285797,
-0.6189889907836914,
0.8437585234642029,
-0.14980997145175934,
-0.353447824716568,
0.07034178823232651,
0.3149237036705017,
0.30454006791114807,
0.3033543825149536,
-0.18410181999206543,
-0.05264442786574364,
-0.10640577971935272,
-0.28438636660575867,
-0.7181182503700256,
0.5919617414474487,
-0.4486343264579773,
-0.4402388036251068,
-0.06317830085754395,
-0.7253122329711914,
-0.24946294724941254,
0.492825984954834,
0.4191487729549408,
0.7774865031242371,
-0.15660183131694794,
0.2797931432723999,
0.7296789288520813,
-0.4611334502696991,
0.18978852033615112,
0.06356621533632278,
-0.5280277132987976,
-0.5584461092948914,
0.5758847594261169,
-0.4069903492927551,
0.20120833814144135,
0.5021355748176575,
0.29609569907188416,
-0.23866388201713562,
-0.6077370643615723,
-0.5318989157676697,
0.27510571479797363,
-0.2864399552345276,
-0.3578851819038391,
-0.49397552013397217,
-0.2691786587238312,
-0.460034042596817,
-0.5890386700630188,
-0.47517234086990356,
-0.5245876908302307,
-0.5780966281890869,
0.014987626112997532,
0.4373820126056671,
1.3280082941055298,
0.1281394362449646,
0.6205788254737854,
-0.9483305215835571,
0.7976820468902588,
0.3561767041683197,
0.8684058785438538,
-0.3194930851459503,
-0.15481063723564148,
-0.13490216434001923,
0.28482335805892944,
-0.3429658114910126,
-0.46555832028388977,
0.1235734149813652,
0.04796392843127251,
0.5578382611274719,
0.42707568407058716,
0.06883309781551361,
0.7769768238067627,
-0.5646622776985168,
0.8909164667129517,
0.36217015981674194,
-0.5078389644622803,
0.724973201751709,
-0.5479874014854431,
0.9174124002456665,
0.5362916588783264,
0.23149190843105316,
-0.22198793292045593,
-0.5834981203079224,
-0.5116382837295532,
-0.7059245705604553,
0.7790781855583191,
0.21066981554031372,
-0.01410418190062046,
0.3830014765262604,
0.7705253958702087,
0.3533374071121216,
-0.1286131739616394,
-0.451590895652771,
-0.297485888004303,
-0.1802094727754593,
-0.24673017859458923,
0.2030152827501297,
-0.3277417719364166,
-0.23930998146533966,
-0.22330820560455322,
0.4550155699253082,
-0.14270837604999542,
0.12894019484519958,
0.4049307703971863,
0.3446559011936188,
0.02910519950091839,
-0.2538059949874878,
0.8521625399589539,
0.6642215847969055,
-0.050342708826065063,
-0.01325269602239132,
-0.20974598824977875,
-0.6398797035217285,
-0.291231632232666,
0.24936048686504364,
-0.19329863786697388,
0.16990283131599426,
-0.06202384829521179,
0.8141897916793823,
0.19765789806842804,
-0.03452172875404358,
0.22208625078201294,
-0.5282407402992249,
-0.9097253084182739,
0.18660055100917816,
0.08912651985883713,
-0.2838348150253296,
0.25642290711402893,
0.17696122825145721,
0.26682889461517334,
0.3868328928947449,
0.212215855717659,
0.3221094310283661,
-0.040797553956508636,
-0.5193870663642883,
-0.18492449820041656,
0.8974311947822571,
0.4795611500740051,
-0.2232574075460434,
0.3042513430118561,
0.012176979333162308,
-0.23434723913669586,
0.4698423147201538,
0.47149768471717834,
0.7778584361076355,
-0.21793058514595032,
0.18035119771957397,
0.8986489176750183,
0.0426788330078125,
0.10072476416826248,
0.4042860269546509,
-0.10572873055934906,
-0.2591138184070587,
-0.33277156949043274,
-0.6338896155357361,
-0.507031261920929,
-0.09218062460422516,
-0.7253670692443848,
0.6230586171150208,
-0.7243912816047668,
-0.020352678373456,
-0.188136488199234,
-0.061115533113479614,
-0.47046715021133423,
0.4997088313102722,
0.2320639193058014,
0.983500063419342,
-0.2971547245979309,
0.3793315291404724,
0.7420653104782104,
0.1185998022556305,
-0.8288416266441345,
-0.0603296160697937,
0.33408406376838684,
-0.28732767701148987,
-0.10664643347263336,
0.3354884386062622,
-0.4958001971244812,
0.2708680331707001,
-0.6617772579193115,
-0.8383256793022156,
0.9857780337333679,
0.17110265791416168,
-0.43645137548446655,
-0.1483238786458969,
0.031257856637239456,
0.19626590609550476,
-0.1697118729352951,
-0.028697971254587173,
0.1733158379793167,
0.5543971657752991,
0.49277377128601074,
-0.7137948870658875,
-0.009642697870731354,
-0.5618243217468262,
0.5354900360107422,
0.22628197073936462,
-0.28349751234054565,
0.6874865889549255,
-0.203054741024971,
-0.42273035645484924,
0.39336898922920227,
1.0545614957809448,
0.3790637254714966,
0.04947565495967865,
0.5755902528762817,
0.5546024441719055,
0.660400390625,
-0.2922728359699249,
1.1884171962738037,
0.015254161320626736,
0.1467123180627823,
1.0744136571884155,
0.2736954391002655,
0.2564297616481781,
0.2796757221221924,
0.30720874667167664,
0.47936415672302246,
0.7097833752632141,
0.23828481137752533,
0.35218676924705505,
0.29239413142204285,
-0.050474997609853745,
-0.054797276854515076,
0.041209954768419266,
-0.3834245800971985,
0.26372361183166504,
0.393380343914032,
0.007091186940670013,
-0.663811445236206,
0.1029135137796402,
0.11192147433757782,
0.5236482620239258,
-0.5649015307426453,
0.755203366279602,
-0.2261858433485031,
-0.23550787568092346,
0.36243724822998047,
0.15364965796470642,
0.6190712451934814,
-0.7542740702629089,
-0.39682185649871826,
-0.09552804380655289,
0.0280062984675169,
-0.37635400891304016,
-0.8328037261962891,
0.392689973115921,
0.07917986065149307,
-0.10098161548376083,
-0.5044681429862976,
0.42022284865379333,
-0.5840655565261841,
-0.7568433284759521,
-0.22045880556106567,
0.19319671392440796,
0.0640798881649971,
-0.2775709927082062,
-0.5558573603630066,
0.17592865228652954,
0.3410242199897766,
-0.43528854846954346,
-0.1904778927564621,
0.7178179621696472,
-0.07308869808912277,
0.41963082551956177,
0.6178221702575684,
-0.07108934968709946,
0.18175572156906128,
0.2331215888261795,
1.0339823961257935,
-0.662726640701294,
-0.4825170636177063,
-0.4914206564426422,
0.8827049732208252,
-0.13432642817497253,
-0.40001875162124634,
0.7020865082740784,
0.7144758701324463,
1.0096355676651,
-0.012949836440384388,
0.5547587275505066,
0.04160284623503685,
0.698549747467041,
-0.7173543572425842,
0.9749389290809631,
-0.6655027270317078,
-0.15151318907737732,
-0.16368137300014496,
-0.8413366079330444,
-0.9840318560600281,
0.5599771738052368,
0.10819222778081894,
0.21321339905261993,
0.8446951508522034,
0.8013750910758972,
0.018674112856388092,
-0.09291458129882812,
0.16405119001865387,
-0.10902862250804901,
0.5634943842887878,
0.11013834178447723,
0.4982539713382721,
-0.18869651854038239,
0.6366904973983765,
-0.7548186182975769,
-0.4541296362876892,
0.10000834614038467,
-1.1191903352737427,
-0.6917575001716614,
-0.41536733508110046,
-0.5135552883148193,
-0.032472655177116394,
-0.6393643021583557,
0.44195738434791565,
0.7281879186630249,
-0.448636919260025,
-0.14962024986743927,
-0.21062389016151428,
0.10804785043001175,
-0.055966079235076904,
-0.2681690454483032,
0.049218904227018356,
-0.3177301585674286,
-0.9922888278961182,
0.2172940969467163,
0.24680590629577637,
0.4122295081615448,
-0.029027843847870827,
0.1585952341556549,
-0.1379772424697876,
-0.04373243823647499,
0.4772323966026306,
0.21923591196537018,
-0.3512662351131439,
-0.12459296733140945,
-0.13924965262413025,
-0.32001760601997375,
0.07045838236808777,
1.0416326522827148,
-0.7400273084640503,
0.8202630281448364,
0.631420910358429,
0.37861168384552,
0.33501163125038147,
0.2437317818403244,
1.0726661682128906,
-0.8979703187942505,
0.25909075140953064,
0.15337054431438446,
0.1529524028301239,
0.19406306743621826,
-0.6001793146133423,
0.16885297000408173,
-0.22240537405014038,
-0.326898992061615,
-0.3108869194984436,
0.28892454504966736,
-1.1211251020431519,
-0.22672967612743378,
0.851976752281189,
0.03471995145082474,
-0.39653268456459045,
-0.04488024115562439,
-0.8490091562271118,
0.23886889219284058,
-0.2227598875761032,
0.5938157439231873,
0.4982934296131134,
-0.38611581921577454,
-0.19308075308799744,
-0.44418102502822876,
0.7336665391921997,
-0.16418491303920746,
-1.0275020599365234,
-0.08075834810733795,
0.8896996974945068,
-0.244437575340271,
0.12070534378290176,
0.36969882249832153,
-0.5503537654876709,
0.36736300587654114,
-0.24178174138069153,
0.38084980845451355,
-0.4145204722881317,
-0.5688461065292358,
-0.4246571958065033,
0.12407651543617249,
-0.22166867554187775,
-0.24106979370117188
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.01574v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.01574v4
|
MMLU-Pro: A More Robust and Challenging Multi-Task Language Understanding Benchmark
| 2024-06-03T17:53:00 | 2024-06-23T15:57:16 |
Yubo Wang, Xueguang Ma, Ge Zhang, Yuansheng Ni, Abhranil Chandra, Shiguang Guo, Weiming Ren, Aaran Arulraj, Xuan He, Ziyan Jiang, Tianle Li, Max Ku, Kai Wang, Alex Zhuang, Rongqi Fan, Xiang Yue, Wenhu Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In the age of large-scale language models, benchmarks like the Massive
Multitask Language Understanding (MMLU) have been pivotal in pushing the
boundaries of what AI can achieve in language comprehension and reasoning
across diverse domains. However, as models continue to improve, their
performance on these benchmarks has begun to plateau, making it increasingly
difficult to discern differences in model capabilities. This paper introduces
MMLU-Pro, an enhanced dataset designed to extend the mostly knowledge-driven
MMLU benchmark by integrating more challenging, reasoning-focused questions and
expanding the choice set from four to ten options. Additionally, MMLU-Pro
eliminates the trivial and noisy questions in MMLU. Our experimental results
show that MMLU-Pro not only raises the challenge, causing a significant drop in
accuracy by 16% to 33% compared to MMLU but also demonstrates greater stability
under varying prompts. With 24 different prompt styles tested, the sensitivity
of model scores to prompt variations decreased from 4-5% in MMLU to just 2% in
MMLU-Pro. Additionally, we found that models utilizing Chain of Thought (CoT)
reasoning achieved better performance on MMLU-Pro compared to direct answering,
which is in stark contrast to the findings on the original MMLU, indicating
that MMLU-Pro includes more complex reasoning questions. Our assessments
confirm that MMLU-Pro is a more discriminative benchmark to better track
progress in the field.
|
[
-0.6042041182518005,
-0.8607961535453796,
0.6169643998146057,
-0.0743865966796875,
0.08019860833883286,
0.33351489901542664,
-0.23783904314041138,
-0.5053912997245789,
-0.4997851550579071,
0.23736681044101715,
-0.8180170655250549,
-0.14766527712345123,
-0.6675618290901184,
0.4252638816833496,
0.12298564612865448,
0.9143621921539307,
-0.005721591878682375,
0.051892396062612534,
-0.388586163520813,
-0.5527942776679993,
-0.5814263820648193,
-0.5963281393051147,
-0.6108839511871338,
-0.4162655174732208,
0.4607306718826294,
0.2698648273944855,
0.700009822845459,
0.3099652826786041,
0.39408329129219055,
0.2436896115541458,
-0.018533702939748764,
0.4563138782978058,
-0.16281147301197052,
0.02933536283671856,
0.036796506494283676,
-0.6116229891777039,
-0.6317287087440491,
0.11912927776575089,
0.48101431131362915,
0.7728086113929749,
0.15151351690292358,
0.38433802127838135,
0.15257062017917633,
0.7309494614601135,
-0.8710113763809204,
0.276024729013443,
-0.5587665438652039,
-0.19831405580043793,
-0.17230577766895294,
0.12561865150928497,
-0.5793357491493225,
0.12044475972652435,
0.0029241202864795923,
-0.845827043056488,
0.08038777112960815,
-0.02189301885664463,
0.6915656328201294,
0.3728010654449463,
-0.44321781396865845,
-0.02843107469379902,
-0.4936123788356781,
0.7596977949142456,
-0.5142102837562561,
0.7613089084625244,
0.41269153356552124,
0.7023146152496338,
-0.06906680762767792,
-0.39690297842025757,
-0.5941564440727234,
-0.4885055124759674,
0.13799834251403809,
0.20723126828670502,
-0.17966966331005096,
-0.12923218309879303,
0.3860200345516205,
0.008505510166287422,
-0.696951687335968,
-0.030896242707967758,
-0.10598011314868927,
-0.22785213589668274,
0.4410967528820038,
0.26483726501464844,
-0.09981843084096909,
0.15051262080669403,
-0.12559844553470612,
-0.1846214234828949,
-0.7034748792648315,
0.4315447509288788,
0.3414213955402374,
0.036314092576503754,
0.1907208412885666,
0.49151867628097534,
-0.3611825108528137,
0.9185281991958618,
-0.1345127671957016,
-0.29990875720977783,
0.41872894763946533,
-0.3920195400714874,
-0.23648260533809662,
-0.4081641435623169,
0.6142607927322388,
0.3315487802028656,
0.32489514350891113,
0.08103901892900467,
-0.002934391377493739,
0.1270156055688858,
0.13949277997016907,
-0.5381597876548767,
-0.2707541882991791,
0.4373857080936432,
-0.30175209045410156,
0.05106864497065544,
-0.16474869847297668,
-0.5038440227508545,
-0.44567370414733887,
-0.40688398480415344,
0.11547073721885681,
-0.47990795969963074,
-0.3689771294593811,
0.172037735581398,
-0.053149204701185226,
0.08911366015672684,
0.5785549879074097,
-0.6149495840072632,
0.21729682385921478,
1.0036957263946533,
0.6125422716140747,
0.012921108864247799,
-0.43009093403816223,
-0.7500399947166443,
-0.0971352830529213,
-0.3092113733291626,
0.9258003234863281,
-0.7822790145874023,
-0.10970937460660934,
-0.32223138213157654,
-0.065066397190094,
-0.4162589907646179,
-0.7843242287635803,
0.7048804759979248,
-0.3104616105556488,
0.12395896762609482,
-0.5786063075065613,
-0.44450610876083374,
-0.17008467018604279,
0.6331709623336792,
-0.7343266010284424,
0.988361656665802,
0.0804356262087822,
-0.7015963792800903,
0.42544102668762207,
-0.7339661717414856,
-0.008784031495451927,
0.10646442323923111,
-0.3393770456314087,
-0.08186906576156616,
0.012442052364349365,
0.4909965693950653,
0.29675617814064026,
-0.5049262046813965,
0.5173394083976746,
-0.50114905834198,
-0.16344840824604034,
0.35751956701278687,
-0.4482802748680115,
0.720894455909729,
0.3688730299472809,
-0.14442092180252075,
0.3170628845691681,
-0.685988187789917,
-0.12988919019699097,
0.044744644314050674,
-0.2868219316005707,
-0.3149585425853729,
-0.023158598691225052,
-0.20593462884426117,
0.3770888149738312,
0.12097913771867752,
-0.526755154132843,
0.048308275640010834,
0.014720507897436619,
0.2178322821855545,
0.7071593999862671,
-0.558174729347229,
0.23768216371536255,
-0.47161442041397095,
0.5645941495895386,
0.049428075551986694,
0.34050410985946655,
-0.03040432557463646,
-0.7942246198654175,
-0.5924527645111084,
-0.30416256189346313,
0.22179783880710602,
0.6276038289070129,
-0.6883631348609924,
0.316627562046051,
-0.18537962436676025,
-0.41622260212898254,
-1.1392232179641724,
0.052686795592308044,
0.34690526127815247,
0.7733407020568848,
0.5130254626274109,
0.03240935131907463,
-0.3603426218032837,
-0.7004961371421814,
-0.32747799158096313,
-0.326920747756958,
-0.1203392744064331,
0.580568790435791,
0.4660360515117645,
-0.13219928741455078,
0.5961740612983704,
-0.46435704827308655,
-0.11890818923711777,
-0.47380006313323975,
0.214638814330101,
0.4012709856033325,
0.33124181628227234,
0.3197367489337921,
-0.7281271815299988,
-0.43511494994163513,
0.005806627683341503,
-0.6468561887741089,
-0.11653025448322296,
-0.2741582989692688,
-0.032600000500679016,
-0.1333473175764084,
0.30168646574020386,
-0.7723302245140076,
-0.17383474111557007,
0.5648643374443054,
-0.4493853747844696,
1.3525010347366333,
-0.2744385898113251,
0.23119917511940002,
-0.7616369724273682,
0.38483482599258423,
-0.04911021888256073,
-0.16581475734710693,
-0.7395294308662415,
0.4502602219581604,
0.3231711685657501,
-0.1058388501405716,
-0.2949088215827942,
0.46560177206993103,
-0.32441017031669617,
-0.09663916379213333,
-0.25491389632225037,
0.2711277902126312,
0.23824477195739746,
0.3470461964607239,
-0.09866387397050858,
1.057281494140625,
0.6676286458969116,
-0.6179512143135071,
0.21776096522808075,
0.20651006698608398,
-0.49628978967666626,
0.6241000294685364,
-0.604930579662323,
0.14773905277252197,
-0.21944782137870789,
0.389409601688385,
-0.7573769092559814,
0.1408650130033493,
0.020883683115243912,
-0.4264245331287384,
-0.03491281718015671,
0.16581226885318756,
-0.44369664788246155,
-0.47104552388191223,
-0.3189502954483032,
0.3285938799381256,
0.16252170503139496,
-0.4547388255596161,
0.529842734336853,
0.130340114235878,
0.01170878391712904,
-1.029611349105835,
-0.3629269003868103,
0.022510197013616562,
-0.1969255954027176,
-0.4914272129535675,
0.2563824951648712,
-0.45633751153945923,
-0.4775872528553009,
-0.17664651572704315,
-0.15091577172279358,
-0.0423395112156868,
0.3752071261405945,
-0.12037836015224457,
0.24031130969524384,
-0.35207778215408325,
0.16314072906970978,
-0.045292071998119354,
-0.3266907036304474,
0.12052550911903381,
-0.053135067224502563,
0.6451651453971863,
-0.21579855680465698,
-0.283903032541275,
-0.3924657702445984,
0.43381592631340027,
0.7402775883674622,
-0.5754516124725342,
0.7538210153579712,
0.7801032066345215,
-0.24176247417926788,
-0.0018833575304597616,
-0.5117177963256836,
-0.05889301374554634,
-0.43305620551109314,
0.3183217942714691,
-1.056450605392456,
-0.9538280963897705,
0.5653665065765381,
-0.2735397517681122,
0.42147743701934814,
0.5397166609764099,
0.3997437059879303,
-0.20129041373729706,
1.2235137224197388,
0.3873623311519623,
-0.142921581864357,
0.07850204408168793,
-0.10410597920417786,
-0.03012566640973091,
-1.1958367824554443,
-0.285188227891922,
-0.5960366725921631,
-0.16507895290851593,
-0.19468609988689423,
-0.5477635264396667,
0.09811913967132568,
0.3185422718524933,
-0.12648150324821472,
0.3250305652618408,
-0.21065294742584229,
0.28577709197998047,
0.4408986270427704,
0.13973306119441986,
0.3798825740814209,
-0.6949502229690552,
-0.3502390384674072,
0.06070441007614136,
-0.5144441723823547,
-0.456651508808136,
1.0230498313903809,
0.3261229991912842,
0.41825562715530396,
0.217230424284935,
0.20049883425235748,
0.10919944941997528,
0.23913997411727905,
-0.5371044874191284,
0.48935526609420776,
-0.2588135302066803,
-0.6907560229301453,
-0.09376377612352371,
-0.40287718176841736,
-0.8528692722320557,
0.6199873685836792,
-0.18842962384223938,
-0.7193016409873962,
0.06502722203731537,
0.11813534051179886,
-0.5938891768455505,
0.08252374827861786,
-0.7289554476737976,
1.005663514137268,
-0.13648734986782074,
-0.07379898428916931,
-0.18870382010936737,
-0.37909042835235596,
0.3420889675617218,
-0.118806853890419,
0.46682223677635193,
-0.5355864763259888,
-0.09800510108470917,
0.5866592526435852,
-0.18980422616004944,
0.5436413288116455,
-0.21228885650634766,
-0.019702352583408356,
0.19267785549163818,
-0.04357944056391716,
0.4707162082195282,
0.10687607526779175,
-0.2627708315849304,
-0.2694820165634155,
-0.003246504347771406,
-0.40022942423820496,
-0.6541065573692322,
0.5884938836097717,
-0.6827979683876038,
-0.7720164060592651,
-0.015395687893033028,
-0.9553085565567017,
-0.36121630668640137,
-0.03193400427699089,
-0.0051832846365869045,
0.5750753879547119,
0.02497481182217598,
0.1762092411518097,
0.4703110158443451,
-0.2573007345199585,
0.3001162111759186,
0.5492180585861206,
-0.09094088524580002,
-0.2017465978860855,
0.6939632892608643,
0.08104004710912704,
0.23212996125221252,
0.41000622510910034,
0.4791104197502136,
-0.6480525135993958,
-0.5498062968254089,
-0.6773270964622498,
0.004610161762684584,
-0.7175511717796326,
-0.07557396590709686,
-1.0560879707336426,
0.25307390093803406,
-0.5113883018493652,
0.16589879989624023,
-0.3110925257205963,
-0.27667272090911865,
-0.18214601278305054,
-0.13355647027492523,
0.1449050009250641,
0.4106036126613617,
0.17221666872501373,
0.15119828283786774,
-0.7144313454627991,
0.3810397684574127,
0.24349287152290344,
0.2362300306558609,
-0.07887189090251923,
-0.4458976984024048,
-0.024752561002969742,
-0.16162589192390442,
-0.2276761382818222,
-0.9916186928749084,
0.18033695220947266,
0.3693167269229889,
0.9152413606643677,
0.33250534534454346,
0.2449093461036682,
0.9412499070167542,
-0.46509045362472534,
0.7032938599586487,
0.0516890324652195,
-0.8588826656341553,
0.4442509710788727,
-0.2588731050491333,
0.773044228553772,
0.8523918986320496,
0.4601162374019623,
-0.38142967224121094,
-0.6111676692962646,
-0.5144162774085999,
-0.33382225036621094,
0.3851487934589386,
0.06338236480951309,
-0.20677955448627472,
0.16771015524864197,
0.18490073084831238,
0.4856277108192444,
0.029555723071098328,
-0.6078542470932007,
-0.32264798879623413,
0.04131553694605827,
-0.18569611012935638,
-0.3650314509868622,
-0.07609659433364868,
0.0010092305019497871,
-0.4739625155925751,
0.3335122764110565,
-0.427315354347229,
0.24821072816848755,
0.04588911682367325,
-0.3615979850292206,
0.2991446852684021,
0.43451160192489624,
0.5516943335533142,
0.8008890748023987,
-0.19033759832382202,
0.4347704350948334,
0.34257620573043823,
-0.47414451837539673,
0.01620572805404663,
0.26448220014572144,
0.1005125343799591,
-0.1229144036769867,
0.4803933799266815,
0.8068476915359497,
-0.10537432134151459,
-0.9402981400489807,
0.21704748272895813,
-0.09201129525899887,
-0.42406344413757324,
0.1675407588481903,
0.0975632593035698,
0.08947780728340149,
0.39070966839790344,
0.46958327293395996,
0.15182150900363922,
0.28613370656967163,
-0.586990475654602,
0.3513181507587433,
0.35656240582466125,
-0.28642943501472473,
-0.30370816588401794,
0.79015052318573,
0.10587133467197418,
-0.2501949667930603,
0.4058071970939636,
-0.27162715792655945,
-0.446270614862442,
0.6095463037490845,
0.5464699864387512,
0.5309866070747375,
-0.21433855593204498,
0.31021949648857117,
0.46609821915626526,
0.3204170763492584,
-0.016648845747113228,
0.5334357023239136,
-0.26901674270629883,
-0.8042993545532227,
-0.7506104707717896,
-0.29862573742866516,
-0.5315941572189331,
0.5030354857444763,
-0.5416921973228455,
-0.0803464949131012,
-0.33119723200798035,
-0.3167448937892914,
0.14915306866168976,
0.30141589045524597,
-0.6819104552268982,
0.27534982562065125,
0.024966005235910416,
1.0274863243103027,
-0.8719431161880493,
1.1607463359832764,
0.6971863508224487,
-0.08644662797451019,
-0.5239940285682678,
-0.20167972147464752,
0.11233316361904144,
-0.49192681908607483,
0.2869567275047302,
0.7686294913291931,
0.02974851056933403,
-0.0879768505692482,
-0.1114516332745552,
-0.5305288434028625,
0.918724775314331,
0.49898090958595276,
-0.6990386247634888,
0.3617565333843231,
0.08393500745296478,
0.4338693916797638,
-0.4439324140548706,
0.5567344427108765,
0.9881680607795715,
0.48180368542671204,
-0.30441078543663025,
-0.9972809553146362,
0.09993819147348404,
-0.4008166790008545,
-0.6789156794548035,
0.13396446406841278,
-0.44351816177368164,
0.9881734251976013,
-0.37146103382110596,
-0.04100961238145828,
-0.13933849334716797,
0.536702036857605,
0.6714816093444824,
0.49965712428092957,
0.7188088893890381,
0.37020447850227356,
1.0193151235580444,
-0.16391418874263763,
0.9068912863731384,
-0.0998438224196434,
0.1718425303697586,
1.3856886625289917,
-0.32208865880966187,
0.9442141652107239,
0.34595438838005066,
-0.28564196825027466,
0.4174979031085968,
0.6602272391319275,
0.04381079971790314,
0.3624744415283203,
0.06264763325452805,
-0.3753635883331299,
-0.530623197555542,
-0.2558222711086273,
-0.36561334133148193,
0.3955641984939575,
0.2603265941143036,
0.07555977255105972,
-0.14939334988594055,
0.2886013090610504,
-0.041917648166418076,
0.14623022079467773,
-0.06576482951641083,
0.6669855117797852,
-0.10673077404499054,
-0.7678168416023254,
0.5569414496421814,
-0.22408920526504517,
0.7435703873634338,
-0.4374334514141083,
0.1349831372499466,
-0.20434248447418213,
0.2769724726676941,
0.10147875547409058,
-0.8992643356323242,
0.34558364748954773,
0.1349593549966812,
-0.037598371505737305,
-0.1502782702445984,
0.6215770840644836,
-0.278188019990921,
-0.35173937678337097,
0.4493650496006012,
0.8758062720298767,
0.17681172490119934,
-0.36809638142585754,
-1.1863399744033813,
0.15018944442272186,
-0.1898782104253769,
-0.13321055471897125,
0.27509865164756775,
0.23265543580055237,
0.023550599813461304,
0.9558170437812805,
0.7033135294914246,
-0.3092270493507385,
0.10418204218149185,
0.4872920513153076,
0.7960213422775269,
-0.2541845142841339,
-0.4107937216758728,
-0.8466196656227112,
0.4828127920627594,
-0.2684613764286041,
-0.48569199442863464,
0.6191929578781128,
0.5269554853439331,
0.7831160426139832,
-0.07478658854961395,
0.6464401483535767,
-0.01735985092818737,
0.3272870182991028,
-0.28843432664871216,
0.6326888799667358,
-0.6540521383285522,
0.05875222012400627,
-0.17998084425926208,
-0.6518412232398987,
-0.27568739652633667,
0.4666009247303009,
-0.21562451124191284,
-0.17868497967720032,
0.7801560163497925,
0.5971273183822632,
0.02638867311179638,
0.03442887216806412,
0.5720754265785217,
-0.19855691492557526,
0.5679264664649963,
0.7801032066345215,
0.8802098631858826,
-0.38925960659980774,
0.6492695212364197,
-0.3056604564189911,
-0.3122166097164154,
0.0825871080160141,
-0.6476375460624695,
-0.9041916131973267,
-0.6758125424385071,
-0.3699977397918701,
0.06464722007513046,
0.025791235268115997,
0.7157996296882629,
0.8264672160148621,
-0.9217604398727417,
-0.13959762454032898,
-0.07816816866397858,
0.010511030443012714,
-0.821537435054779,
-0.168554425239563,
0.34585753083229065,
-0.49510911107063293,
-0.6312240362167358,
0.7090418338775635,
0.09527307003736496,
-0.3434954583644867,
0.011915474198758602,
-0.2608656585216522,
-0.39832380414009094,
0.003352266736328602,
0.7660357356071472,
0.07706744223833084,
-0.8195775151252747,
-0.2664613425731659,
0.29296445846557617,
0.14798687398433685,
0.05915874242782593,
0.7488881349563599,
-0.745625913143158,
0.6043462753295898,
0.4993024170398712,
0.8320392966270447,
0.216744527220726,
-0.04892346262931824,
0.6968931555747986,
-0.6584560871124268,
0.04750169813632965,
0.05088916793465614,
0.5034881830215454,
0.20208671689033508,
-0.3263219892978668,
0.4328669309616089,
0.15568694472312927,
-0.38700956106185913,
-0.7746283411979675,
0.2801811993122101,
-0.8165428042411804,
-0.584600567817688,
0.9347149133682251,
-0.3455585241317749,
0.022398753091692924,
-0.5505183935165405,
-0.2701299488544464,
0.25838959217071533,
-0.27731937170028687,
0.4782885015010834,
0.7872576117515564,
-0.26652294397354126,
-0.7292695641517639,
-0.9265095591545105,
0.4793294668197632,
0.6982988715171814,
-1.0888824462890625,
0.43191641569137573,
0.3604784905910492,
-0.01507127471268177,
0.10782143473625183,
0.7301487326622009,
0.0324726365506649,
0.47681403160095215,
0.12359294295310974,
-0.4174794852733612,
-0.3648439347743988,
-0.668773353099823,
-0.14427828788757324,
0.4049665033817291,
0.15233518183231354,
-0.34350860118865967
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.01566v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.01566v1
|
Helix: Distributed Serving of Large Language Models via Max-Flow on Heterogeneous GPUs
| 2024-06-03T17:47:53 | 2024-06-03T17:47:53 |
Yixuan Mei, Yonghao Zhuang, Xupeng Miao, Juncheng Yang, Zhihao Jia, Rashmi Vinayak
|
cs.DC
|
cs.DC, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
This paper introduces Helix, a distributed system for high-throughput,
low-latency large language model (LLM) serving on heterogeneous GPU clusters. A
key idea behind Helix is to formulate inference computation of LLMs over
heterogeneous GPUs and network connections as a max-flow problem for a
directed, weighted graph, whose nodes represent GPU instances and edges capture
both GPU and network heterogeneity through their capacities. Helix then uses a
mixed integer linear programming (MILP) algorithm to discover highly optimized
strategies to serve LLMs. This approach allows Helix to jointly optimize model
placement and request scheduling, two highly entangled tasks in heterogeneous
LLM serving. Our evaluation on several heterogeneous cluster settings ranging
from 24 to 42 GPU nodes shows that Helix improves serving throughput by up to
2.7$\times$ and reduces prompting and decoding latency by up to 2.8$\times$ and
1.3$\times$, respectively, compared to best existing approaches.
|
[
-0.569219708442688,
-1.4968750476837158,
0.673940122127533,
0.564337968826294,
0.0961819514632225,
0.10263143479824066,
-0.24300406873226166,
-0.3606344163417816,
0.4288181662559509,
0.6394402980804443,
-0.5960605144500732,
-0.4162345230579376,
-0.3545026481151581,
0.14948713779449463,
-0.15343943238258362,
0.5932517051696777,
0.12277084589004517,
0.015197869390249252,
-0.5099754333496094,
-0.05362783372402191,
-0.32748326659202576,
-0.23621682822704315,
-0.6333009600639343,
-0.46147000789642334,
0.5893622040748596,
0.5556687712669373,
0.9517280459403992,
1.1519463062286377,
0.8581572771072388,
0.31559616327285767,
-0.16960245370864868,
-0.048401277512311935,
-0.6422997713088989,
0.49504223465919495,
0.1067056804895401,
-0.30261197686195374,
-0.669016420841217,
0.04473916068673134,
0.8993415236473083,
1.2091903686523438,
-0.40313562750816345,
0.38299551606178284,
0.0006988568929955363,
0.5613517165184021,
-0.7951635718345642,
0.07108817994594574,
-0.3142079710960388,
0.3170437812805176,
-0.6701115369796753,
-0.08309482783079147,
-0.5007893443107605,
-0.33811503648757935,
0.014401973225176334,
-0.8895290493965149,
-0.15251891314983368,
0.18585221469402313,
0.4971861243247986,
0.42208752036094666,
-0.15304479002952576,
0.15077543258666992,
-0.9224335551261902,
0.7058331966400146,
-0.7119812369346619,
0.4526708126068115,
0.11856634169816971,
0.5796011686325073,
-0.2718314230442047,
-0.8678534626960754,
-0.5726733803749084,
0.09381559491157532,
0.43197157979011536,
0.11035800725221634,
-0.15449532866477966,
0.048494454473257065,
0.4514842927455902,
0.5832223296165466,
-0.7443327903747559,
0.32125598192214966,
-0.10910699516534805,
0.22601160407066345,
0.4179544746875763,
0.28489434719085693,
0.33249902725219727,
0.38893362879753113,
-0.14211143553256989,
0.03906935825943947,
-0.9228066802024841,
0.05121109262108803,
0.4386212229728699,
0.4704304337501526,
-0.1944901943206787,
0.8576887845993042,
-0.4189077615737915,
0.7638058662414551,
0.2361784726381302,
0.11441890150308609,
0.10513380914926529,
0.10806349664926529,
-0.5901563167572021,
0.07881639897823334,
0.3942531645298004,
0.0001729630312183872,
-0.2245226502418518,
0.009664826095104218,
0.032120976597070694,
0.07703093439340591,
0.2303229570388794,
-0.7443798184394836,
-0.06727954745292664,
0.19088086485862732,
-0.4640566110610962,
-0.1804538518190384,
-0.25340282917022705,
-0.7567669153213501,
-0.38632869720458984,
-0.01392355840653181,
-0.015260422602295876,
0.18727649748325348,
-0.4091901481151581,
0.17836473882198334,
0.020253444090485573,
0.06987813115119934,
0.33372265100479126,
-0.9784675240516663,
0.5181794166564941,
0.9730573892593384,
1.1197750568389893,
-0.43775850534439087,
-0.3042697012424469,
-0.9956408143043518,
0.5096144676208496,
-0.20394064486026764,
0.7212429046630859,
-0.8129397034645081,
-0.24545130133628845,
0.15165185928344727,
0.0017836653860285878,
-0.16518154740333557,
-0.5150356888771057,
0.4430343508720398,
-0.5725777745246887,
-0.07561038434505463,
-0.14364750683307648,
-0.8339625597000122,
-0.21217074990272522,
-0.012273777276277542,
-0.8933801054954529,
0.778297483921051,
-0.05792665109038353,
-0.8188425302505493,
0.13052748143672943,
-0.6677263379096985,
-0.5626694560050964,
0.7461214661598206,
-0.16311369836330414,
-0.2646300792694092,
0.04552902281284332,
0.18211795389652252,
0.6901131868362427,
-0.51209557056427,
0.05869544669985771,
-1.034080982208252,
-0.40495041012763977,
-0.37366750836372375,
-0.17157240211963654,
0.8757231831550598,
0.39520367980003357,
-0.11368569731712341,
0.3111792206764221,
-0.3333345651626587,
0.024722816422581673,
0.09098352491855621,
-0.647578239440918,
-0.22306984663009644,
0.1580904722213745,
0.1589815765619278,
-0.21222703158855438,
0.07999933511018753,
-0.7926613092422485,
0.7835986018180847,
-0.2548125982284546,
0.6078745722770691,
0.8018057346343994,
-0.48664361238479614,
0.6127912402153015,
-0.2513924837112427,
0.6521904468536377,
-0.41553449630737305,
0.40847474336624146,
0.12440264970064163,
-0.8525837659835815,
-0.5284510850906372,
-0.32643619179725647,
-0.4304702877998352,
0.5880445837974548,
-0.6464124917984009,
-0.005855295807123184,
-0.26428836584091187,
-0.5160269737243652,
-0.5619957447052002,
0.16878895461559296,
0.0435357503592968,
0.4435288906097412,
0.19322799146175385,
0.003864148398861289,
-0.38509443402290344,
-0.8836131691932678,
0.16687241196632385,
-0.07189901918172836,
0.35023704171180725,
0.6441975235939026,
0.21100890636444092,
-0.7319959402084351,
0.6403312683105469,
-0.6942247152328491,
-0.06321829557418823,
-0.5067444443702698,
-0.02609284035861492,
0.8145975470542908,
0.5368767380714417,
0.3470464050769806,
-0.5984157919883728,
-0.6592278480529785,
0.2404014617204666,
-0.8768093585968018,
-0.12728238105773926,
0.17390109598636627,
-0.1614750772714615,
0.13473862409591675,
0.49578070640563965,
-0.5319236516952515,
0.004242101684212685,
1.144797921180725,
-0.24075615406036377,
0.8343790173530579,
-0.3991372585296631,
-0.0883498266339302,
-0.9824163913726807,
-0.2115928828716278,
0.049399349838495255,
-0.270835280418396,
-0.5023987889289856,
0.31325188279151917,
-0.2500624656677246,
-0.26692596077919006,
-0.2275668829679489,
0.3288804292678833,
-0.32405033707618713,
-0.20166923105716705,
-0.32072731852531433,
-0.5002220273017883,
-0.28617456555366516,
0.25032877922058105,
0.03525185212492943,
0.9753561615943909,
1.068605899810791,
-0.6050098538398743,
0.7984514832496643,
0.11039099842309952,
-0.05654093250632286,
0.8052738904953003,
-0.8347815275192261,
0.1455909013748169,
0.27611860632896423,
0.4765447676181793,
-0.6270653009414673,
-0.3833024501800537,
-0.0261966772377491,
-0.09217074513435364,
-0.10113994032144547,
-0.31617552042007446,
-0.3197052478790283,
-0.5774049758911133,
-0.1032840758562088,
0.6862987875938416,
0.24431629478931427,
-0.7991451621055603,
0.7405768632888794,
0.7194777727127075,
-0.14753952622413635,
-0.523553192615509,
-0.5324696898460388,
0.10870400816202164,
-0.2929953634738922,
-1.1516211032867432,
0.1519532948732376,
-0.29295918345451355,
-0.1929963082075119,
-0.07464414834976196,
0.18206726014614105,
-0.4082779586315155,
0.21661965548992157,
0.7604110240936279,
0.170084610581398,
-0.6003390550613403,
-0.24671576917171478,
0.0881902426481247,
-0.10815519839525223,
-0.11462832242250443,
-0.6208820343017578,
0.967170000076294,
-0.587674081325531,
-0.6602150201797485,
-0.6806994676589966,
0.6197167038917542,
0.5544618964195251,
0.040617216378450394,
0.7501792311668396,
0.7481739521026611,
-0.25074175000190735,
-0.33943942189216614,
-0.46148741245269775,
-0.10879835486412048,
-0.5285065174102783,
0.20386278629302979,
-0.6243582963943481,
-1.2340232133865356,
0.6086159348487854,
-0.11877051740884781,
0.08825471252202988,
0.4326038360595703,
0.8110736012458801,
-0.39615505933761597,
1.129036784172058,
0.9826753735542297,
-0.4621717631816864,
0.39658060669898987,
-0.25389793515205383,
0.19254320859909058,
-0.7364688515663147,
0.16749350726604462,
-0.37785792350769043,
-0.22220158576965332,
-0.7351325750350952,
-0.5481024384498596,
0.48398417234420776,
0.12179527431726456,
-0.43013572692871094,
0.25719234347343445,
-0.4593333601951599,
0.3595213294029236,
0.7115162014961243,
-0.26373282074928284,
0.382519006729126,
0.018948324024677277,
-0.4044342041015625,
0.3786241114139557,
-0.9250904321670532,
-0.32655659317970276,
0.8294956684112549,
0.45920366048812866,
0.9735893607139587,
0.14201359450817108,
0.4289180338382721,
0.4480646848678589,
0.15093962848186493,
-0.5343961119651794,
0.5291750431060791,
0.10680419206619263,
-0.41633373498916626,
-0.45742711424827576,
-0.6216260194778442,
-0.7129411101341248,
0.1737200915813446,
-0.2598583698272705,
-0.7300258874893188,
-0.17740878462791443,
0.028838548809289932,
-0.388145387172699,
0.720227837562561,
-0.4036053717136383,
0.5287226438522339,
0.33584049344062805,
-0.4358949661254883,
-0.4281129539012909,
-0.2074202299118042,
0.30227476358413696,
0.2349155843257904,
-0.09717102348804474,
-0.07850499451160431,
0.5489986538887024,
0.5782768130302429,
-0.39420461654663086,
0.35619062185287476,
-0.1880520135164261,
-0.0040006390772759914,
-0.10559926182031631,
0.24045273661613464,
0.6973994970321655,
0.4830074906349182,
-0.007287447340786457,
0.2597125470638275,
-0.1078905463218689,
-0.33266139030456543,
-0.3888578414916992,
1.0028389692306519,
-0.7703244090080261,
-0.6856558322906494,
-0.46827512979507446,
-0.8450777530670166,
-0.021996160969138145,
0.1884266436100006,
-0.07790634036064148,
0.2155405580997467,
0.012824220582842827,
0.3371053636074066,
0.7034953832626343,
-0.45225292444229126,
0.5010557174682617,
0.35797548294067383,
-0.25493547320365906,
-0.10730302333831787,
0.7545133829116821,
-0.19036053121089935,
0.1959875375032425,
0.06818543374538422,
0.11391069740056992,
0.0615093931555748,
-0.7579060792922974,
-0.7079715728759766,
0.3915051519870758,
-0.38287919759750366,
0.06466731429100037,
-0.7309119701385498,
-0.20798926055431366,
-0.5302027463912964,
-0.49476465582847595,
-0.8428810238838196,
-0.24401968717575073,
-0.21999534964561462,
0.0881912112236023,
0.29294463992118835,
0.8166367411613464,
-0.18580622971057892,
0.6385995745658875,
-0.4908701777458191,
0.18351218104362488,
0.2331009954214096,
0.6165785789489746,
-0.05170106515288353,
-0.23758114874362946,
-0.39079558849334717,
-0.10291508585214615,
0.05200396850705147,
-0.42934587597846985,
0.30801862478256226,
0.10083538293838501,
0.5967623591423035,
0.7698850035667419,
-0.23926421999931335,
0.7968330979347229,
-0.6161536574363708,
0.4899410009384155,
0.14468546211719513,
-0.8119092583656311,
0.18026958405971527,
-0.6259844303131104,
0.40932753682136536,
0.2601621747016907,
0.40494388341903687,
-1.0413715839385986,
-0.5688116550445557,
-0.1959272176027298,
-0.8044639825820923,
0.6231802105903625,
0.10999992489814758,
-0.02514270506799221,
0.14122359454631805,
0.28383809328079224,
-0.040414486080408096,
-0.07595191150903702,
-0.5562843084335327,
-0.34606367349624634,
0.14327462017536163,
0.14333027601242065,
0.05203183367848396,
-0.12468788027763367,
-0.137062668800354,
-0.4612375497817993,
0.7511586546897888,
-0.24504049122333527,
0.47951456904411316,
-0.1748482584953308,
-0.11747314780950546,
-0.29240986704826355,
-0.08426199853420258,
0.5021251440048218,
0.7695605158805847,
-0.43815237283706665,
0.22616076469421387,
-0.08707679063081741,
-0.751704216003418,
-0.18255361914634705,
0.12274335324764252,
-0.3280316889286041,
-0.3522374629974365,
0.33241745829582214,
0.7755439281463623,
-0.5876405239105225,
-0.43052414059638977,
0.15408524870872498,
-0.2318490594625473,
-0.009474046528339386,
0.029788756743073463,
0.190839022397995,
0.37036415934562683,
0.7924181818962097,
0.365927129983902,
-0.308164119720459,
0.024646740406751633,
-0.19489923119544983,
0.14039282500743866,
0.625115156173706,
-0.2696201205253601,
-0.24336856603622437,
0.8622547388076782,
0.12968504428863525,
-0.14476388692855835,
0.8957049250602722,
0.07513926178216934,
-0.19515462219715118,
0.3880898356437683,
0.8184075355529785,
0.7652665972709656,
-0.127084419131279,
0.35284262895584106,
0.1604679524898529,
0.0072722528129816055,
-0.18063673377037048,
0.20125016570091248,
-0.03933939337730408,
-0.7706145644187927,
-0.5531395077705383,
-0.8024991750717163,
-0.48561835289001465,
-0.18110306560993195,
-0.5945850610733032,
-0.17938388884067535,
-0.5045448541641235,
-0.21688471734523773,
0.1494794636964798,
0.13807864487171173,
-0.4924142062664032,
-0.3125162124633789,
0.4459253251552582,
0.7874630093574524,
-0.959080159664154,
1.0232723951339722,
0.7194145321846008,
-0.14865191280841827,
-0.7144123911857605,
-0.6215053200721741,
0.06526260823011398,
-0.6508170962333679,
0.7853389382362366,
-0.08266464620828629,
-0.3578201234340668,
0.10183288156986237,
-0.4784593880176544,
-0.963123619556427,
0.9372765421867371,
0.36232492327690125,
-0.5706335306167603,
0.06849014014005661,
0.4398582875728607,
0.1720230132341385,
-0.5013852715492249,
0.41168269515037537,
0.12352219969034195,
0.6150644421577454,
0.2360527515411377,
-1.0468395948410034,
-0.14259818196296692,
-0.4306187629699707,
-0.0004192658234387636,
-0.03292156010866165,
-0.3044864237308502,
1.2775418758392334,
-0.0649162083864212,
-0.17726905643939972,
-0.26940295100212097,
0.8722436428070068,
0.3833881616592407,
0.22107727825641632,
0.42983248829841614,
0.8742555379867554,
1.0326344966888428,
0.007482901681214571,
1.182235598564148,
-0.1581297069787979,
0.5161721110343933,
1.0017098188400269,
-0.6118894219398499,
0.6619066596031189,
0.6980358362197876,
-0.010715226642787457,
0.1443966031074524,
0.7594581246376038,
0.0928247720003128,
0.43039581179618835,
0.28823551535606384,
-0.30924537777900696,
-0.19871750473976135,
-0.14081445336341858,
-0.3743899464607239,
0.16418199241161346,
0.11113877594470978,
0.18056991696357727,
-0.34598666429519653,
0.3175036311149597,
-0.02242671139538288,
-0.30057060718536377,
-0.4165797531604767,
0.5163158178329468,
-0.024064840748906136,
-0.26274263858795166,
0.645316481590271,
0.20227493345737457,
0.8006386756896973,
-0.1385643631219864,
-0.016015803441405296,
-0.3775571882724762,
0.3215161859989166,
-0.30411794781684875,
-0.6725490689277649,
0.19066627323627472,
-0.07174587994813919,
-0.40374791622161865,
-0.515477180480957,
0.35013559460639954,
-0.14845868945121765,
-0.48946264386177063,
0.4254889190196991,
0.624763548374176,
0.10775468498468399,
-0.24358804523944855,
-0.6104360222816467,
0.23331888020038605,
-0.33805927634239197,
-0.5174473524093628,
0.12842957675457,
0.12082797288894653,
-0.11640915274620056,
1.1147037744522095,
0.8705976009368896,
0.3602418899536133,
0.5141300559043884,
0.17030417919158936,
0.9163024425506592,
-0.3762458562850952,
-0.525243878364563,
-0.8385060429573059,
-0.17271190881729126,
0.14342713356018066,
-0.11312413960695267,
0.9575169086456299,
0.7714666128158569,
0.9132723808288574,
0.13460633158683777,
0.5175769329071045,
-0.06338395923376083,
0.10472283512353897,
-0.28357386589050293,
0.9360601305961609,
-0.4917444586753845,
0.14991448819637299,
-0.10775883495807648,
-1.2075427770614624,
-0.42673441767692566,
0.7218904495239258,
-0.2539445459842682,
-0.47630736231803894,
0.5179157853126526,
0.7200498580932617,
-0.4622214436531067,
0.2776780128479004,
0.1699155569076538,
0.13412770628929138,
0.6453579664230347,
0.6410022974014282,
0.7196388244628906,
0.16333067417144775,
-0.19782468676567078,
-0.0894225537776947,
-0.1087695062160492,
-0.4918190836906433,
-0.6220803260803223,
-0.549888551235199,
-0.5994856357574463,
-0.20655018091201782,
-0.2035372108221054,
0.1183486133813858,
0.9458562731742859,
0.8663415908813477,
-0.5996527075767517,
-0.9348622560501099,
-0.14899492263793945,
0.23145821690559387,
-0.497886598110199,
-0.16419851779937744,
0.31840258836746216,
-0.2817663252353668,
-0.7289624214172363,
0.5841866135597229,
0.635464072227478,
-0.4464586079120636,
-0.38238614797592163,
-0.3218669593334198,
-0.5096473097801208,
-0.03392709419131279,
0.4614374041557312,
0.18695548176765442,
-0.31806957721710205,
-0.07490473240613937,
0.030544521287083626,
-0.3269152045249939,
0.24962562322616577,
0.8905184268951416,
-0.394744336605072,
0.3161650598049164,
0.6096779108047485,
1.0110409259796143,
0.847537636756897,
-0.1314001977443695,
0.649351179599762,
-0.24563300609588623,
0.22911502420902252,
0.3949020206928253,
0.29806432127952576,
-0.16457565128803253,
-0.3844030499458313,
0.21723176538944244,
0.3513869345188141,
-0.6303845643997192,
-0.9309254288673401,
0.31163474917411804,
-1.3168035745620728,
-0.30295154452323914,
1.0780797004699707,
-0.14657697081565857,
-0.47157022356987,
-0.0275057815015316,
0.5029403567314148,
0.3960804343223572,
-0.34241238236427307,
0.4833790361881256,
0.5182170867919922,
-0.22419919073581696,
-0.054539360105991364,
-1.0602456331253052,
0.28766176104545593,
0.3113557994365692,
-0.8694720268249512,
0.12578140199184418,
0.48270049691200256,
0.038292016834020615,
-0.172520250082016,
0.5464662909507751,
0.36094149947166443,
-0.028702622279524803,
-0.25402411818504333,
0.07306593656539917,
-0.31673142313957214,
-0.5247256755828857,
-0.11862973123788834,
0.34114333987236023,
-0.32160359621047974,
0.08875814080238342
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.01563v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.01563v1
|
LoFiT: Localized Fine-tuning on LLM Representations
| 2024-06-03T17:45:41 | 2024-06-03T17:45:41 |
Fangcong Yin, Xi Ye, Greg Durrett
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Recent work in interpretability shows that large language models (LLMs) can
be adapted for new tasks in a learning-free way: it is possible to intervene on
LLM representations to elicit desired behaviors for alignment. For instance,
adding certain bias vectors to the outputs of certain attention heads is
reported to boost the truthfulness of models. In this work, we show that
localized fine-tuning serves as an effective alternative to such representation
intervention methods. We introduce a framework called Localized Fine-Tuning on
LLM Representations (LoFiT), which identifies a subset of attention heads that
are most important for learning a specific task, then trains offset vectors to
add to the model's hidden representations at those selected heads. LoFiT
localizes to a sparse set of heads (3%) and learns the offset vectors from
limited training data, comparable to the settings used for representation
intervention. For truthfulness and reasoning tasks, we find that LoFiT's
intervention vectors are more effective for LLM adaptation than vectors from
representation intervention methods such as Inference-time Intervention. We
also find that the localization step is important: selecting a task-specific
set of attention heads can lead to higher performance than intervening on heads
selected for a different task. Finally, for the tasks we study, LoFiT achieves
comparable performance to other parameter-efficient fine-tuning methods such as
LoRA, despite modifying 20x-200x fewer parameters than these methods.
|
[
-0.3356938362121582,
-0.8475971817970276,
0.5971761345863342,
0.006729476153850555,
-0.259676456451416,
-0.14329655468463898,
-0.6795943379402161,
-0.3392804265022278,
0.14420217275619507,
0.5696735978126526,
-0.4666971266269684,
-0.5280167460441589,
-0.6241680979728699,
-0.05730966478586197,
-0.052688952535390854,
0.882989227771759,
-0.28363147377967834,
0.0005597975105047226,
-0.19888383150100708,
-0.36261898279190063,
-0.7084671854972839,
-0.26173678040504456,
-0.7818618416786194,
-0.4163435995578766,
0.7957687973976135,
0.531963586807251,
0.5824370980262756,
1.0612844228744507,
0.6977499723434448,
0.3094964325428009,
-0.06406878679990768,
0.46446698904037476,
-0.7828482389450073,
0.015518199652433395,
-0.5151660442352295,
-0.7822355031967163,
-0.42538243532180786,
-0.06525812298059464,
0.7462605237960815,
0.768872857093811,
0.13707782328128815,
0.12577424943447113,
0.2014797031879425,
0.7433915734291077,
-0.8141281604766846,
0.2122943103313446,
-0.8149439692497253,
0.03236836567521095,
-0.13483253121376038,
-0.27870187163352966,
-0.18302181363105774,
-0.3151828646659851,
-0.027575017884373665,
-0.6256669163703918,
0.30936765670776367,
-0.29463866353034973,
0.7443618774414062,
0.8882015943527222,
-0.3892996907234192,
0.025087008252739906,
-0.705346405506134,
0.952540397644043,
-0.7153696417808533,
0.35103273391723633,
0.42270031571388245,
0.09790006279945374,
-0.22810140252113342,
-0.36116892099380493,
-0.12724155187606812,
0.0565158911049366,
-0.16700299084186554,
0.05724417790770531,
-0.13172835111618042,
0.1725713610649109,
0.41448792815208435,
0.34033912420272827,
-0.14842863380908966,
0.18674424290657043,
0.027152689173817635,
-0.19533893465995789,
0.4604504108428955,
-0.026790671050548553,
-0.17967310547828674,
0.06436196714639664,
-0.138706237077713,
0.23000216484069824,
-0.8828473687171936,
0.0807715579867363,
0.17022691667079926,
0.5995991230010986,
-0.05086822435259819,
0.4785636365413666,
-0.4461634159088135,
0.9584627151489258,
0.5302562117576599,
-0.2867453098297119,
0.0831272080540657,
-0.1621425449848175,
-0.20909710228443146,
-0.01149003580212593,
0.3275703191757202,
0.10723230987787247,
0.3006610572338104,
-0.09289436787366867,
-0.45524856448173523,
-0.06536521017551422,
0.28453513979911804,
-0.68822181224823,
0.03937758505344391,
-0.08837350457906723,
-0.279550701379776,
-0.2881557047367096,
-0.1948525756597519,
-0.10178515315055847,
-0.38918912410736084,
-0.7803176641464233,
0.5069365501403809,
-0.30207154154777527,
0.06893275678157806,
0.247904971241951,
0.35958996415138245,
0.3943875730037689,
0.3766302168369293,
-0.8482097387313843,
0.010407174937427044,
0.7227029800415039,
0.7524534463882446,
-0.5233374834060669,
-0.1422150731086731,
-1.0442761182785034,
0.16254925727844238,
-0.26454928517341614,
0.9732558727264404,
-0.6654650568962097,
-0.0030647614039480686,
0.02389511466026306,
0.1769048571586609,
-0.22833143174648285,
-0.689095675945282,
0.5491462349891663,
-0.35781583189964294,
-0.22158972918987274,
-0.6501121520996094,
-0.5422292947769165,
-0.08527884632349014,
0.19785435497760773,
-0.5558866262435913,
0.9473050832748413,
0.1400832086801529,
-0.7390796542167664,
0.1990908831357956,
-0.6774663925170898,
-0.6391476392745972,
-0.30055105686187744,
-0.21120955049991608,
-0.2639853358268738,
0.4355185031890869,
0.5654575824737549,
0.6924907565116882,
0.13577373325824738,
-0.006135016214102507,
-0.19266515970230103,
-0.6771636009216309,
-0.0873650535941124,
-0.354611337184906,
0.3214985132217407,
0.0856495201587677,
-0.33093899488449097,
0.16159681975841522,
-0.6858172416687012,
-0.09112390130758286,
-0.00035521475365385413,
-0.4400457441806793,
-0.37380871176719666,
0.01257091574370861,
-0.3946300745010376,
-0.2639966905117035,
0.4876381456851959,
-0.346052885055542,
0.34618905186653137,
-0.6863153576850891,
0.3227604329586029,
0.782042384147644,
0.1253064125776291,
0.6605423092842102,
-0.18925662338733673,
0.44623687863349915,
0.06873336434364319,
-0.1400781273841858,
-0.13677319884300232,
-0.2784932553768158,
-0.9629966616630554,
-0.402894526720047,
0.40210145711898804,
0.4041562080383301,
-0.8114685416221619,
0.3273712396621704,
-0.3061913847923279,
-0.2287159562110901,
-0.459158331155777,
0.3333033323287964,
0.41192662715911865,
0.5874457955360413,
0.11145847290754318,
-0.1435040831565857,
-0.30688437819480896,
-0.9416316747665405,
-0.5012712478637695,
0.38276296854019165,
0.19034424424171448,
0.1685255914926529,
0.3715500235557556,
-0.19373561441898346,
1.0473116636276245,
-0.5953457355499268,
-0.4239071011543274,
-0.04261653870344162,
0.20971332490444183,
0.33389848470687866,
0.46705910563468933,
0.5686221718788147,
-0.7129636406898499,
-0.5975903272628784,
0.3249254822731018,
-0.5465514659881592,
-0.11402863264083862,
-0.1686534732580185,
-0.1377798616886139,
0.12784959375858307,
0.6053743362426758,
-0.4431726336479187,
0.3299625515937805,
0.3551998436450958,
-0.2543697655200958,
0.1352262794971466,
-0.30210208892822266,
-0.02975478209555149,
-0.8719519972801208,
0.0027192640118300915,
-0.17002765834331512,
-0.6645132303237915,
-0.544928789138794,
0.26751378178596497,
0.19692641496658325,
0.10914678871631622,
-0.37425997853279114,
0.5707243084907532,
-0.4257197082042694,
-0.0785500705242157,
-0.39684510231018066,
0.4121236503124237,
-0.0922478437423706,
0.8201302886009216,
0.13211116194725037,
0.8797996044158936,
0.3992390036582947,
-0.4406477212905884,
0.1297455132007599,
0.22870449721813202,
-0.3785998523235321,
0.7182555198669434,
-0.543079674243927,
0.3447447717189789,
-0.25049716234207153,
-0.13392598927021027,
-0.689486563205719,
-0.2604736387729645,
-0.04078291356563568,
-0.2508014440536499,
0.369315505027771,
-0.25774824619293213,
-0.37494537234306335,
0.17141181230545044,
-0.18022094666957855,
0.2410798966884613,
0.18590021133422852,
-0.6205394864082336,
0.724570631980896,
0.21221186220645905,
0.02580358274281025,
-0.6268258094787598,
-0.5037282109260559,
-0.4699897766113281,
-0.2771386206150055,
-0.3730338215827942,
0.2814445495605469,
-0.08446763455867767,
-0.004722132347524166,
-0.08183281123638153,
-0.35449936985969543,
0.11201228201389313,
0.2158048301935196,
0.21751125156879425,
-0.2098468691110611,
-0.35932570695877075,
0.16237416863441467,
0.23792043328285217,
-0.24728457629680634,
-0.3188305199146271,
-0.23261025547981262,
0.2793063521385193,
-0.17820578813552856,
-0.47015181183815,
-0.1629060059785843,
0.2455933392047882,
0.35897356271743774,
-0.626417338848114,
0.5747144818305969,
1.0200002193450928,
-0.5160580277442932,
-0.09333395957946777,
-0.6227934956550598,
-0.15231658518314362,
-0.5173852443695068,
0.5474284887313843,
-0.40066489577293396,
-1.1871737241744995,
0.5015044808387756,
-0.28146520256996155,
0.16230158507823944,
0.08915440738201141,
0.648698627948761,
-0.14610952138900757,
1.144283413887024,
0.861622154712677,
-0.2592064440250397,
0.7491036653518677,
-0.22397556900978088,
0.21812453866004944,
-0.8408576846122742,
0.28117895126342773,
-0.32369574904441833,
-0.6550531983375549,
-0.5262159109115601,
-0.6944010257720947,
0.3868245780467987,
0.43311408162117004,
-0.27026739716529846,
0.27776747941970825,
-0.436603307723999,
0.9116213917732239,
0.38688981533050537,
0.12885965406894684,
0.3693016469478607,
0.268531858921051,
-0.0007473459700122476,
-0.2402423471212387,
-0.6644265055656433,
-0.2349240928888321,
0.803393542766571,
0.3164502680301666,
0.6306673884391785,
-0.12737971544265747,
0.8025591969490051,
0.09300458431243896,
0.3233654499053955,
-0.9381372928619385,
0.38373419642448425,
-0.3526538908481598,
-0.15302138030529022,
-0.28638020157814026,
-0.3512832820415497,
-0.9482609033584595,
0.18026579916477203,
-0.21641500294208527,
-0.8644653558731079,
0.34804731607437134,
0.3924940824508667,
-0.567970335483551,
0.3349180519580841,
-0.7703145742416382,
0.7935754060745239,
-0.006825069431215525,
-0.3289080560207367,
-0.3066260516643524,
-0.22553949058055878,
-0.011260433122515678,
-0.2902676463127136,
0.11467382311820984,
-0.27858254313468933,
-0.10095439851284027,
0.5178452730178833,
0.06745351105928421,
1.0666255950927734,
-0.28334206342697144,
-0.5130008459091187,
-0.060349542647600174,
0.12191828340291977,
1.062678575515747,
0.2219136357307434,
-0.06082196906208992,
0.05391398444771767,
-0.07098706066608429,
-0.42980241775512695,
-0.9261727929115295,
1.0808138847351074,
-0.7364109754562378,
-0.7167443633079529,
-0.041247107088565826,
-0.9449909925460815,
-0.5929652452468872,
0.49017587304115295,
0.20504868030548096,
0.36475369334220886,
-0.04281550645828247,
0.2991091310977936,
1.0749480724334717,
-0.054107416421175,
0.07668843865394592,
0.5163441300392151,
-0.16491125524044037,
-0.30388060212135315,
1.1515973806381226,
0.10417083650827408,
0.2556431293487549,
0.7350950837135315,
0.09354828298091888,
0.11993272602558136,
-0.6140801906585693,
0.09222646057605743,
0.4517395794391632,
-0.8593529462814331,
-0.3769392967224121,
-0.22224698960781097,
-0.05174164101481438,
-0.16124451160430908,
-0.3111765682697296,
-0.6157948970794678,
-0.4541826844215393,
-0.3740553855895996,
0.025801721960306168,
0.3621932864189148,
0.6717692613601685,
-0.2360563427209854,
0.47081172466278076,
-0.40662872791290283,
0.498709499835968,
0.3057255148887634,
0.5787209868431091,
-0.30329927802085876,
-0.6044221520423889,
-0.6675139665603638,
0.042677801102399826,
-0.1813850849866867,
-0.40900325775146484,
0.057802729308605194,
0.16229571402072906,
0.36687910556793213,
0.5375913381576538,
-0.04864310473203659,
0.9185234308242798,
-0.5278423428535461,
0.39613863825798035,
-0.18291763961315155,
-0.8744149208068848,
0.6024191975593567,
-0.5955400466918945,
0.654554009437561,
0.46600601077079773,
0.21528975665569305,
-0.3766237795352936,
-0.39169567823410034,
-0.16944575309753418,
-0.6016665697097778,
0.641545295715332,
0.11409787088632584,
0.1970871239900589,
0.1622813642024994,
0.8385455012321472,
-0.08269002288579941,
0.02954702638089657,
-0.49342554807662964,
-0.2654425799846649,
0.13909666240215302,
-0.2790283262729645,
-0.14757227897644043,
-0.2796531021595001,
-0.26109418272972107,
-0.5085888504981995,
0.5222705006599426,
-0.6484726667404175,
0.617099404335022,
0.2530713677406311,
-0.14141327142715454,
-0.3608630895614624,
-0.03505096212029457,
0.5967590808868408,
0.5430015325546265,
-0.15254268050193787,
0.10911033302545547,
0.4217835068702698,
-0.3102983236312866,
-0.22854335606098175,
-0.0018073308747261763,
-0.2801083028316498,
-0.11241477727890015,
0.6278788447380066,
0.9639865756034851,
0.5119937062263489,
-0.44411882758140564,
0.39966756105422974,
0.08776004612445831,
-0.09431926161050797,
-0.06653165817260742,
0.4059321880340576,
0.1856505572795868,
0.591943085193634,
-0.09104857593774796,
0.17246417701244354,
-0.15644747018814087,
-0.14874525368213654,
-0.06543389707803726,
0.6299020051956177,
-0.6282034516334534,
-0.22580446302890778,
0.5004886984825134,
0.09719143807888031,
-0.18479564785957336,
0.2589971721172333,
-0.05312199518084526,
-0.2512812912464142,
0.31099334359169006,
0.4202108383178711,
0.7194005846977234,
-0.1121010035276413,
0.01713377796113491,
0.3681756556034088,
0.23617976903915405,
0.059860266745090485,
0.3115101456642151,
-0.18052247166633606,
-0.9420015811920166,
-0.7819762825965881,
-0.5604130029678345,
-0.18619650602340698,
0.2039056420326233,
-0.7671234607696533,
0.1904173046350479,
-0.36706581711769104,
-0.14425702393054962,
-0.1108480840921402,
0.01368276309221983,
-0.715405285358429,
-0.006942932493984699,
0.17302270233631134,
0.9052677750587463,
-0.5648102760314941,
0.9792933464050293,
0.7883925437927246,
-0.054163865745067596,
-0.6883451342582703,
0.13969852030277252,
-0.2494136095046997,
-0.8288698792457581,
0.43350234627723694,
-0.013594001531600952,
-0.18835081160068512,
0.11901502311229706,
-0.7631714344024658,
-1.2850607633590698,
1.039548635482788,
1.041603922843933,
-0.7114232778549194,
-0.09399387985467911,
0.17446790635585785,
0.4140944182872772,
-0.2890751361846924,
-0.19935853779315948,
0.8584773540496826,
0.40907660126686096,
-0.21568097174167633,
-0.887364387512207,
-0.049087610095739365,
0.07325970381498337,
0.17081955075263977,
0.183897465467453,
-0.750981867313385,
0.5237554907798767,
-0.23744738101959229,
-0.0763443261384964,
0.03467749431729317,
0.8206507563591003,
-0.0077280825935304165,
-0.21467959880828857,
0.42871880531311035,
0.3671236038208008,
0.9742806553840637,
-0.2326330691576004,
0.9312053322792053,
-0.23559391498565674,
0.42891600728034973,
1.4065297842025757,
-0.04152827337384224,
0.8485146164894104,
0.6950539350509644,
0.147004172205925,
0.20054104924201965,
0.4713633358478546,
0.12430749833583832,
0.6750928163528442,
-0.19624002277851105,
-0.07324196398258209,
-0.6309952735900879,
-0.13293753564357758,
-0.04683176055550575,
0.393309623003006,
0.32279273867607117,
-0.0716010257601738,
-0.2932839095592499,
0.2477516382932663,
-0.09869974851608276,
0.22501035034656525,
-0.49333810806274414,
0.6725925207138062,
0.11825621128082275,
-0.5538952350616455,
0.8463739156723022,
0.09103726595640182,
0.5372381806373596,
-0.6088979244232178,
-0.18000884354114532,
-0.43982329964637756,
0.5185479521751404,
-0.2574212849140167,
-0.5629410743713379,
0.33261367678642273,
-0.11927812546491623,
-0.3529708683490753,
-0.2872750163078308,
0.7235690355300903,
-0.4538045823574066,
-0.36040279269218445,
0.13393722474575043,
0.29773685336112976,
-0.18301409482955933,
-0.29992416501045227,
-0.6013911962509155,
0.09057226777076721,
0.32262122631073,
-0.488882839679718,
0.40372946858406067,
0.5421311259269714,
-0.2161649465560913,
0.676567554473877,
0.5092616081237793,
0.27795302867889404,
-0.1660710573196411,
-0.003210825612768531,
0.7846745252609253,
-0.6003952622413635,
-0.26731401681900024,
-0.5472486615180969,
0.2708483338356018,
0.17850516736507416,
-0.11553743481636047,
0.5560780167579651,
0.29404568672180176,
0.9857913255691528,
-0.10348460078239441,
0.5858258605003357,
0.1773301213979721,
0.5067468285560608,
-0.7567487359046936,
0.5664814114570618,
-0.603943943977356,
0.15607567131519318,
-0.020008310675621033,
-0.9326846599578857,
-0.48627907037734985,
0.8580435514450073,
-0.6308172345161438,
-0.1742510050535202,
0.5781134366989136,
0.9728578329086304,
-0.34592509269714355,
-0.220873162150383,
0.545880913734436,
0.46031031012535095,
0.14892685413360596,
0.44088849425315857,
0.4949212670326233,
-0.26747098565101624,
0.23229143023490906,
-0.3105810880661011,
-0.08044598251581192,
0.02279284968972206,
-0.9277434945106506,
-1.0720208883285522,
-0.4184935986995697,
-0.36233168840408325,
0.03295179456472397,
-0.004678850527852774,
1.0059199333190918,
0.6915993094444275,
-0.9214977622032166,
0.019462184980511665,
0.167942613363266,
0.27265191078186035,
-0.40317845344543457,
-0.15020884573459625,
0.5586954951286316,
-0.6356823444366455,
-0.8686439990997314,
0.43685007095336914,
0.28405216336250305,
-0.26691892743110657,
-0.12097637355327606,
-0.15471023321151733,
0.00029993485077284276,
0.08013854175806046,
0.6475380063056946,
0.1290530413389206,
-0.7584981918334961,
-0.5397422313690186,
-0.10487278550863266,
0.046730272471904755,
0.34179821610450745,
0.9624364376068115,
-0.7916322350502014,
0.3655671179294586,
0.2617238461971283,
0.7822183966636658,
0.5610833764076233,
-0.14519573748111725,
0.6264523863792419,
-1.0940855741500854,
0.28115615248680115,
0.010513575747609138,
0.538636326789856,
0.35128316283226013,
-0.566763699054718,
0.5544431805610657,
0.00047892623115330935,
-0.45694729685783386,
-0.7633936405181885,
0.38733506202697754,
-0.8785537481307983,
-0.0015181031776592135,
1.2028683423995972,
-0.2050771862268448,
-0.24172578752040863,
0.10977713018655777,
-0.4164767265319824,
0.31201374530792236,
-0.18915539979934692,
0.5703303813934326,
0.5326568484306335,
-0.17885687947273254,
-0.08634206652641296,
-0.5927943587303162,
0.6322290897369385,
0.5246963500976562,
-0.5772806406021118,
0.3167933523654938,
0.14257177710533142,
0.4142262041568756,
0.13365384936332703,
0.47844043374061584,
0.04280029237270355,
0.19126498699188232,
-0.6553232669830322,
-0.23008139431476593,
-0.04713602364063263,
-0.15176478028297424,
-0.5904784202575684,
-0.21648217737674713,
0.319728821516037,
0.10171819478273392
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.01561v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.01561v2
|
Long and Short Guidance in Score identity Distillation for One-Step Text-to-Image Generation
| 2024-06-03T17:44:11 | 2024-06-22T04:48:56 |
Mingyuan Zhou, Zhendong Wang, Huangjie Zheng, Hai Huang
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, stat.ML
|
Diffusion-based text-to-image generation models trained on extensive
text-image pairs have shown the capacity to generate photorealistic images
consistent with textual descriptions. However, a significant limitation of
these models is their slow sample generation, which requires iterative
refinement through the same network. In this paper, we enhance Score identity
Distillation (SiD) by developing long and short classifier-free guidance (LSG)
to efficiently distill pretrained Stable Diffusion models without using real
training data. SiD aims to optimize a model-based explicit score matching loss,
utilizing a score-identity-based approximation alongside the proposed LSG for
practical computation. By training exclusively with fake images synthesized
with its one-step generator, SiD equipped with LSG rapidly improves FID and
CLIP scores, achieving state-of-the-art FID performance while maintaining a
competitive CLIP score. Specifically, its data-free distillation of Stable
Diffusion 1.5 achieves a record low FID of 8.15 on the COCO-2014 validation
set, with a CLIP score of 0.304 at an LSG scale of 1.5, and a FID of 9.56 with
a CLIP score of 0.313 at an LSG scale of 2. Our SiD-LSG code and distilled
one-step text-to-image generators are available at
https://github.com/mingyuanzhou/SiD-LSG
|
[
-0.36497363448143005,
-0.6749271154403687,
0.7534784078598022,
0.358293741941452,
-0.863629162311554,
0.13482066988945007,
-0.1313239336013794,
-0.09275761991739273,
0.13777759671211243,
0.19589240849018097,
-0.49303629994392395,
-0.6351918578147888,
-0.7258121967315674,
-0.08111334592103958,
-0.29910174012184143,
1.324417233467102,
0.005975441541522741,
-0.005465237889438868,
-0.37516090273857117,
-0.15268534421920776,
-0.27411502599716187,
-0.0008500706171616912,
-0.9329220652580261,
-0.17189045250415802,
0.7663133144378662,
0.15778250992298126,
0.4702853560447693,
0.48812755942344666,
0.4162724018096924,
0.1684160679578781,
-0.3102567493915558,
0.2204558551311493,
-0.722620964050293,
0.24774384498596191,
-0.37994489073753357,
-0.026494184508919716,
-0.3927137851715088,
0.194998636841774,
0.6432756185531616,
0.29037943482398987,
0.016017325222492218,
0.31889447569847107,
0.32974186539649963,
0.9884397983551025,
-0.6505234837532043,
0.19899782538414001,
-0.5166010856628418,
-0.1660281866788864,
-0.375597208738327,
-0.045494917780160904,
-0.44451120495796204,
-0.5505709648132324,
0.07792153209447861,
-0.6369573473930359,
0.518051266670227,
0.07155188918113708,
0.8440757393836975,
0.3693578839302063,
-0.3870270550251007,
-0.38041481375694275,
-0.6346005201339722,
0.6312281489372253,
-0.4300857484340668,
-0.16051991283893585,
0.15275363624095917,
0.545822262763977,
-0.064629465341568,
-0.8338299989700317,
-0.47201141715049744,
0.04957341402769089,
-0.03823241963982582,
0.22634536027908325,
-0.010484226047992706,
0.1574195772409439,
0.1063026487827301,
0.41566988825798035,
-0.22735987603664398,
-0.038363464176654816,
-0.6631602048873901,
-0.07321307808160782,
0.906970202922821,
-0.2011573314666748,
-0.3731636703014374,
0.10030437260866165,
-0.53785640001297,
-0.10648460686206818,
-0.49703797698020935,
-0.09072750061750412,
0.4714394807815552,
0.1961032599210739,
-0.03439093753695488,
0.09679047018289566,
0.11777101457118988,
0.5364548563957214,
0.5864176750183105,
-0.35207095742225647,
0.25910571217536926,
-0.18754340708255768,
-0.07541390508413315,
0.27004021406173706,
1.0142831802368164,
0.5390543937683105,
0.3550264835357666,
0.21897576749324799,
-0.23772844672203064,
-0.018753277137875557,
0.04933056980371475,
-1.201673984527588,
-0.2916536331176758,
-0.15542829036712646,
-0.578687846660614,
-0.7040156722068787,
0.028240609914064407,
-0.8872770667076111,
-0.22884376347064972,
0.04997343569993973,
0.4960535168647766,
-0.3819694519042969,
-0.18008244037628174,
-0.19036832451820374,
-0.420002281665802,
0.06456150114536285,
0.5763265490531921,
-0.4606216549873352,
0.09912294149398804,
0.23451390862464905,
1.1922132968902588,
-0.6085748076438904,
-0.014885741285979748,
-0.654996931552887,
-0.03004305437207222,
-0.5268563628196716,
0.6013794541358948,
-0.1862902194261551,
-0.8498610854148865,
-0.3711912930011749,
0.019083164632320404,
0.3118768632411957,
-0.5595280528068542,
0.5891055464744568,
-0.3519335389137268,
0.1537436544895172,
-0.10226381570100784,
-0.5639194846153259,
0.025153299793601036,
0.02856159210205078,
-0.6544910073280334,
1.0028835535049438,
0.18512596189975739,
-0.6458642482757568,
0.4240091145038605,
-0.7016265988349915,
-0.5501377582550049,
0.1211010068655014,
-0.13675306737422943,
-0.6257871389389038,
0.2108909785747528,
0.16911455988883972,
0.5117239952087402,
-0.3017790615558624,
0.27860885858535767,
-0.32118868827819824,
-0.5141983032226562,
-0.4011300206184387,
-0.7637758851051331,
0.6960213780403137,
0.2909272313117981,
-0.21931105852127075,
-0.17639726400375366,
-0.8689665198326111,
-0.026944216340780258,
0.2610524892807007,
-0.3169720768928528,
-0.3856760561466217,
-0.12414669245481491,
-0.012091624550521374,
0.11261370033025742,
0.06984669715166092,
-0.549975574016571,
0.2509305775165558,
0.24480555951595306,
0.1636226773262024,
1.139113426208496,
0.3899650573730469,
0.5013996958732605,
-0.3336417078971863,
0.6165140867233276,
0.3429723381996155,
0.11595357209444046,
-0.6743005514144897,
-0.7888731956481934,
-0.37810423970222473,
-0.6451433300971985,
0.4503341615200043,
0.20858606696128845,
-0.8762547373771667,
0.3061448633670807,
-0.3807615637779236,
-0.684391975402832,
-0.718822717666626,
0.1881166249513626,
0.43033185601234436,
0.879096508026123,
0.48473799228668213,
-0.531186580657959,
0.0897093266248703,
-0.6680846810340881,
0.05457659810781479,
-0.04410010576248169,
-0.05600455030798912,
0.16361699998378754,
0.5080255270004272,
0.0697360709309578,
1.0126285552978516,
-0.8552266359329224,
-0.7151395678520203,
0.1734001636505127,
0.19670990109443665,
0.20167331397533417,
0.545531153678894,
0.8737406730651855,
-0.8027254939079285,
-0.8330166339874268,
-0.20562218129634857,
-0.39429062604904175,
-0.00933821965008974,
-0.1937071681022644,
-0.2298586070537567,
0.050798408687114716,
0.3943467140197754,
-0.28939512372016907,
0.6947104334831238,
0.5743458271026611,
-0.3103684186935425,
0.5022916197776794,
-0.43939486145973206,
0.28924524784088135,
-1.0841840505599976,
0.08122546225786209,
0.4004260301589966,
-0.509946346282959,
-0.29870304465293884,
-0.03264036774635315,
0.08203639090061188,
-0.11465070396661758,
-0.8620628714561462,
0.7338481545448303,
-0.4262627959251404,
0.4923902153968811,
-0.16675570607185364,
-0.004151890520006418,
0.40170717239379883,
0.5667185187339783,
0.02771919220685959,
0.6155986785888672,
0.8209386467933655,
-0.7485995888710022,
0.3343100845813751,
-0.05361912027001381,
-0.6874608993530273,
0.8842989802360535,
-0.6903762221336365,
0.27214255928993225,
-0.5778086185455322,
0.4688384532928467,
-1.0625908374786377,
0.05821036547422409,
0.29190224409103394,
-0.1898675560951233,
0.4324468970298767,
-0.4211520850658417,
-0.2055094838142395,
-0.2879544198513031,
-0.3624374270439148,
0.8068323135375977,
1.118898630142212,
-0.8357223272323608,
0.41559168696403503,
-0.19260863959789276,
0.07542642205953598,
-0.21520663797855377,
-0.700581967830658,
-0.3069884777069092,
-0.31818535923957825,
-0.424576997756958,
0.8123993873596191,
-0.3291616141796112,
0.019927820190787315,
-0.044477857649326324,
-0.10689764469861984,
-0.151716411113739,
-0.21131102740764618,
0.2817158102989197,
0.33370068669319153,
-0.0461009256541729,
0.1690545231103897,
0.4639225900173187,
-0.11246516555547714,
-0.09339478611946106,
-0.062212008982896805,
0.04133348539471626,
0.38883113861083984,
-0.23934534192085266,
-0.6008533835411072,
0.41830435395240784,
0.7375233173370361,
-0.050960056483745575,
0.7032307386398315,
0.442929744720459,
-0.00479337340220809,
-0.4387989938259125,
-0.13656257092952728,
0.14527563750743866,
-0.5548853278160095,
0.04533732309937477,
-0.37757641077041626,
-0.4886947572231293,
0.3885442018508911,
-0.42778125405311584,
0.14002187550067902,
0.5926698446273804,
0.18609263002872467,
-0.3764099180698395,
0.7822192907333374,
0.2970726490020752,
0.025905083864927292,
0.5230597853660583,
-0.1931649148464203,
-0.01223174948245287,
-0.6626467108726501,
-0.15150506794452667,
-0.2325286865234375,
-0.45876410603523254,
-0.25463250279426575,
-0.7549422383308411,
0.6093470454216003,
0.13914459943771362,
0.01398445013910532,
-0.14534467458724976,
-0.8820557594299316,
0.8547499179840088,
0.3711223602294922,
0.20067457854747772,
0.20744115114212036,
-0.02338649518787861,
-0.15251611173152924,
-0.04757073521614075,
-0.3247949481010437,
-0.1942436844110489,
1.1360386610031128,
0.27535971999168396,
1.036710500717163,
-0.16645997762680054,
1.1060487031936646,
0.7460148930549622,
0.26159706711769104,
-0.7953270077705383,
0.4893046021461487,
-0.2989139258861542,
-0.33902493119239807,
0.022919688373804092,
-0.4024598300457001,
-0.4741887152194977,
0.016526801511645317,
-0.1708879917860031,
-0.0027942718006670475,
0.05136731266975403,
0.5359998941421509,
-0.279254674911499,
0.07120536267757416,
-0.7643104195594788,
0.7239675521850586,
-0.4548872709274292,
-0.4828779995441437,
-0.07187043130397797,
-0.46879926323890686,
0.5033240914344788,
-0.41101452708244324,
0.09383990615606308,
-0.14392885565757751,
0.2389652580022812,
0.65313720703125,
-0.4784232974052429,
0.5454050898551941,
-0.6752827167510986,
-0.3454975485801697,
0.5979646444320679,
-0.11329680681228638,
0.640446126461029,
-0.04636860638856888,
-0.3093171715736389,
0.34075990319252014,
-0.005988565273582935,
-0.4067852199077606,
-0.7448524832725525,
0.7712356448173523,
-0.22259561717510223,
-0.6081570982933044,
-0.2990206480026245,
0.1592949479818344,
0.35615265369415283,
0.2535732388496399,
0.6626275777816772,
0.07008571922779083,
-0.3929537236690521,
0.06912919133901596,
0.8478567004203796,
0.0489167757332325,
0.5337010025978088,
-0.11662285029888153,
-0.2803824245929718,
-0.48876920342445374,
0.8429372310638428,
-0.02804386056959629,
0.5685965418815613,
0.019780796021223068,
0.22726275026798248,
-0.37573111057281494,
-0.42660441994667053,
-0.5974385142326355,
0.07057873159646988,
-0.7493337392807007,
-0.35441845655441284,
0.12355952709913254,
-0.21383176743984222,
-0.3990460932254791,
-0.18355543911457062,
-0.522412121295929,
-0.30774033069610596,
-0.6982886791229248,
0.05307263880968094,
0.36673247814178467,
0.5010725855827332,
0.17334318161010742,
0.5150797963142395,
-0.6455190181732178,
0.6211531758308411,
0.2026628851890564,
0.5446731448173523,
-0.008543954230844975,
-0.5117092728614807,
-0.2246338129043579,
0.13970717787742615,
-0.4408950209617615,
-0.8745110630989075,
0.006947415880858898,
0.7482287287712097,
0.32810673117637634,
0.864305853843689,
0.3775944709777832,
1.0205390453338623,
-0.7748250365257263,
0.9234669804573059,
0.5173909664154053,
-0.904859185218811,
0.8050947785377502,
-0.04949368163943291,
0.4046687185764313,
0.6374408006668091,
0.4923017621040344,
-0.22733615338802338,
-0.20338879525661469,
-0.35858461260795593,
-0.7191434502601624,
0.5113905072212219,
0.212945818901062,
0.14636088907718658,
-0.16904887557029724,
0.6178066730499268,
0.293660044670105,
-0.020117126405239105,
-0.566070020198822,
-0.4910448491573334,
-0.38690483570098877,
-0.32553502917289734,
-0.05033165216445923,
-0.012163102626800537,
-0.07744795829057693,
-0.3837142586708069,
0.8629320859909058,
-0.28585362434387207,
-0.15533187985420227,
0.2871963679790497,
0.08318690210580826,
0.10459712147712708,
-0.14145256578922272,
0.3999749422073364,
0.17564813792705536,
-0.09915003180503845,
-0.11052335798740387,
-0.2790086269378662,
-0.4452398419380188,
0.42804664373397827,
-0.2895822525024414,
-0.35807934403419495,
0.3487852215766907,
-0.04801349714398384,
0.9025088548660278,
-0.1542390137910843,
-0.3948903977870941,
0.7323023676872253,
-0.10496880114078522,
-0.6229915022850037,
-0.21510879695415497,
0.315034955739975,
-0.16219817101955414,
0.13431237637996674,
0.5413538813591003,
0.3145770728588104,
-0.10550104081630707,
-0.31756487488746643,
0.07216724753379822,
0.4054557681083679,
-0.31426510214805603,
-0.13679741322994232,
0.8825822472572327,
0.3734265863895416,
-0.28725868463516235,
0.6383360028266907,
-0.5969662070274353,
0.07791069895029068,
0.4289380609989166,
0.41389819979667664,
0.992514967918396,
-0.2552012503147125,
0.39054128527641296,
0.5558180212974548,
-0.16254682838916779,
-0.4862702488899231,
-0.21149377524852753,
-0.4570764899253845,
-0.3278801441192627,
0.010774283669888973,
-0.7285371422767639,
-0.08472929894924164,
-0.11480367183685303,
-0.8497928380966187,
0.616912841796875,
-0.7838204503059387,
-0.3288143575191498,
0.0988641232252121,
-0.34761670231819153,
-0.4810352921485901,
0.3147794306278229,
0.18371574580669403,
0.8581438660621643,
-0.7548441886901855,
1.0719921588897705,
0.24626030027866364,
-0.3211939334869385,
-0.3749659061431885,
0.08498254418373108,
-0.07714660465717316,
-0.336759090423584,
0.33985424041748047,
0.27170273661613464,
-0.2640390694141388,
0.11358654499053955,
-0.6174572110176086,
-0.4976748824119568,
1.481109857559204,
0.468303382396698,
-0.7691900134086609,
-0.4431970417499542,
-0.22089630365371704,
0.48538485169410706,
-0.5238871574401855,
0.016524221748113632,
0.4308909475803375,
0.3035315275192261,
0.7580928802490234,
-0.6049271821975708,
0.06430014222860336,
-0.21162308752536774,
0.1653706133365631,
0.23903429508209229,
-0.784278154373169,
0.6970424056053162,
-0.37348267436027527,
-0.46398240327835083,
0.17154641449451447,
0.5659167170524597,
0.33438435196876526,
0.4817662239074707,
0.5646399855613708,
0.5681030750274658,
0.7184925675392151,
0.00007317693962249905,
0.5595547556877136,
-0.1568221151828766,
0.4272556006908417,
1.249770164489746,
-0.23620203137397766,
0.5201313495635986,
0.7443665862083435,
0.005092928186058998,
0.6476143598556519,
0.5921363234519958,
-0.18209308385849,
1.085355520248413,
0.16717803478240967,
-0.44817474484443665,
-0.02539248764514923,
0.2920010983943939,
-0.2779378592967987,
0.2291317880153656,
0.18015451729297638,
-0.8514905571937561,
-0.346343994140625,
0.09622521698474884,
-0.14863723516464233,
-0.01792965456843376,
-0.37365880608558655,
0.6422597765922546,
-0.034777820110321045,
-0.7195634841918945,
0.6031804084777832,
-0.03382454439997673,
1.029667854309082,
-0.6855525374412537,
-0.3093886375427246,
-0.22906818985939026,
0.1316678524017334,
-0.09833195060491562,
-0.6934150457382202,
0.22372578084468842,
0.11731079965829849,
-0.2503358721733093,
-0.6720229387283325,
0.5018689632415771,
-0.48779603838920593,
-0.6777581572532654,
0.19123820960521698,
0.0014615477994084358,
0.28409674763679504,
-0.10290448367595673,
-0.5342779159545898,
-0.17682966589927673,
0.10208024829626083,
-0.2769682705402374,
0.3132920563220978,
0.30199968814849854,
-0.1240115612745285,
0.2943710684776306,
0.5909458994865417,
0.2456575185060501,
0.025460263714194298,
-0.08167419582605362,
0.759253978729248,
-0.434565007686615,
-0.44736769795417786,
-0.9942722916603088,
0.5673404932022095,
-0.055742114782333374,
-0.42308375239372253,
0.3405210077762604,
0.5671353340148926,
0.7626704573631287,
-0.2735440135002136,
0.6727211475372314,
-0.1342332363128662,
0.22401198744773865,
-0.5200931429862976,
1.157301664352417,
-0.6569738388061523,
0.039849910885095596,
-0.305131196975708,
-1.078680396080017,
-0.032446473836898804,
0.5415442585945129,
0.15155644714832306,
-0.00015009458002168685,
0.5078240633010864,
0.7073602080345154,
-0.2512468099594116,
-0.5014590620994568,
0.3192066550254822,
-0.2366628795862198,
0.6159177422523499,
0.38730621337890625,
0.3262140154838562,
-0.5889654755592346,
0.5114505290985107,
-0.30461573600769043,
-0.2047550082206726,
0.10947616398334503,
-1.3066825866699219,
-0.7786024808883667,
-0.6437333822250366,
-0.6518896222114563,
-0.3340345323085785,
-0.08726122230291367,
0.5795828104019165,
0.7962961792945862,
-0.34397193789482117,
0.22555072605609894,
-0.1364900916814804,
0.14205433428287506,
-0.21961554884910583,
-0.29713189601898193,
0.278208464384079,
-0.05443159118294716,
-0.9455296397209167,
0.3083268404006958,
0.2608083188533783,
0.40436121821403503,
-0.33973756432533264,
-0.34755784273147583,
0.012558911927044392,
0.14134733378887177,
0.3922889828681946,
0.17888982594013214,
-0.5006968379020691,
-0.05187836289405823,
-0.449709951877594,
0.08673369884490967,
0.2381124198436737,
0.6971272230148315,
-0.9901515245437622,
0.4704422056674957,
0.1913261115550995,
0.1631890833377838,
0.745078444480896,
0.2998318672180176,
0.266044557094574,
-1.2249078750610352,
0.2930542528629303,
0.18349355459213257,
0.12334712594747543,
0.24300241470336914,
-0.324792742729187,
0.2247459888458252,
0.36896631121635437,
-0.40704146027565,
-0.7136169075965881,
0.20199652016162872,
-0.9774044752120972,
-0.1907917708158493,
0.9986467957496643,
-0.5819234251976013,
-0.46873441338539124,
0.4401066303253174,
-0.3622486889362335,
0.21150949597358704,
-0.5696771740913391,
0.8425012826919556,
0.5611242651939392,
0.03988727554678917,
-0.16349299252033234,
0.2446763515472412,
0.7197823524475098,
-0.05186781659722328,
-0.6021398305892944,
-0.18704360723495483,
0.7023934721946716,
0.47616681456565857,
0.23368163406848907,
0.9406301379203796,
-0.07069183886051178,
0.3451552391052246,
0.005693075712770224,
-0.22872090339660645,
-0.2515003979206085,
-0.535641610622406,
-0.3174876570701599,
0.15980485081672668,
-0.10365990549325943,
-0.6307633519172668
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.01549v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.01549v1
|
An Information Bottleneck Perspective for Effective Noise Filtering on Retrieval-Augmented Generation
| 2024-06-03T17:31:06 | 2024-06-03T17:31:06 |
Kun Zhu, Xiaocheng Feng, Xiyuan Du, Yuxuan Gu, Weijiang Yu, Haotian Wang, Qianglong Chen, Zheng Chu, Jingchang Chen, Bing Qin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Retrieval-augmented generation integrates the capabilities of large language
models with relevant information retrieved from an extensive corpus, yet
encounters challenges when confronted with real-world noisy data. One recent
solution is to train a filter module to find relevant content but only achieve
suboptimal noise compression. In this paper, we propose to introduce the
information bottleneck theory into retrieval-augmented generation. Our approach
involves the filtration of noise by simultaneously maximizing the mutual
information between compression and ground output, while minimizing the mutual
information between compression and retrieved passage. In addition, we derive
the formula of information bottleneck to facilitate its application in novel
comprehensive evaluations, the selection of supervised fine-tuning data, and
the construction of reinforcement learning rewards. Experimental results
demonstrate that our approach achieves significant improvements across various
question answering datasets, not only in terms of the correctness of answer
generation but also in the conciseness with $2.5\%$ compression rate.
|
[
-1.086677074432373,
-0.9425985217094421,
0.19573991000652313,
-0.06353652477264404,
-0.1490429937839508,
-0.11524450778961182,
-0.2732302248477936,
-0.4065609276294708,
-0.05130447447299957,
0.6196749210357666,
-0.6282036304473877,
-0.04864789918065071,
-0.36857497692108154,
-0.0010605438146740198,
-0.31185322999954224,
0.8303530216217041,
0.3529921770095825,
-0.2860032021999359,
-0.3846132159233093,
0.178758442401886,
-0.7012273073196411,
-0.4603877067565918,
-0.5694582462310791,
-0.2359035611152649,
0.2651941180229187,
0.41443440318107605,
0.47533029317855835,
0.6216686367988586,
0.3260277807712555,
0.20759490132331848,
-0.3578864336013794,
0.5150304436683655,
-0.7348300814628601,
0.42968565225601196,
-0.16239377856254578,
-0.33937737345695496,
0.3084679841995239,
-0.3223770558834076,
0.3935967683792114,
0.7726330757141113,
-0.2614157199859619,
0.15403896570205688,
0.20405597984790802,
0.807339072227478,
-0.8612071871757507,
-0.0771453008055687,
-0.806815505027771,
0.11546650528907776,
-0.14402751624584198,
-0.5380863547325134,
-0.15009024739265442,
-0.2837134897708893,
-0.07111281901597977,
-0.9098642468452454,
0.35991501808166504,
0.5571021437644958,
0.923424482345581,
0.5792898535728455,
0.1373860090970993,
-0.4360063970088959,
-0.6081017255783081,
0.7014145851135254,
-0.1726464480161667,
0.32552146911621094,
0.5434432029724121,
-0.04635932296514511,
-0.21475368738174438,
-0.1990189254283905,
-0.5114522576332092,
0.12390264123678207,
0.16699182987213135,
0.02632947266101837,
-0.18940627574920654,
0.1049189642071724,
0.47762611508369446,
0.6292740702629089,
-0.42423370480537415,
-0.20779237151145935,
-0.7550061941146851,
-0.2246287316083908,
0.4195168614387512,
-0.2051703929901123,
-0.09045255184173584,
-0.10871242731809616,
-0.26665741205215454,
0.14411979913711548,
-0.6722103357315063,
-0.09041255712509155,
0.5839351415634155,
0.46052053570747375,
0.4687087833881378,
0.2688336670398712,
-0.5626712441444397,
0.867974042892456,
0.21675743162631989,
0.23087655007839203,
0.19328024983406067,
-0.6452940702438354,
0.15006275475025177,
0.028500404208898544,
0.4100631773471832,
0.11530577391386032,
0.2672589421272278,
-0.12701702117919922,
-0.1157253310084343,
-0.29045140743255615,
0.4898223578929901,
-0.9976688027381897,
-0.27459388971328735,
0.1977093517780304,
-0.28330695629119873,
-0.3778238594532013,
0.0872093141078949,
-0.9286977052688599,
-0.30695897340774536,
-0.2055763453245163,
0.607247531414032,
-0.15084615349769592,
-0.5752772092819214,
0.16181902587413788,
-0.14686612784862518,
-0.3679044544696808,
-0.16609865427017212,
-0.6263421177864075,
0.3017420768737793,
0.45032554864883423,
0.7825948596000671,
0.06046248972415924,
0.23570026457309723,
-0.9955170154571533,
-0.10992114990949631,
-0.25123268365859985,
0.8620985746383667,
-0.3785187304019928,
-0.32963359355926514,
0.11312966048717499,
-0.5208393931388855,
0.3028245270252228,
-1.0562559366226196,
0.39311444759368896,
-0.7940108776092529,
-0.003920943010598421,
-0.3723987936973572,
-0.3738725781440735,
0.22257299721240997,
0.09781821817159653,
-0.7385715246200562,
1.220227599143982,
0.2315366268157959,
-0.6961319446563721,
0.3102230429649353,
-0.4989766776561737,
-0.4126523435115814,
0.0015223745722323656,
0.10298896580934525,
-0.4024277329444885,
0.025328464806079865,
0.2710924446582794,
-0.0713125616312027,
-0.5353982448577881,
0.14127376675605774,
-0.09829390794038773,
-0.6613417863845825,
0.0620940625667572,
-0.10932942479848862,
0.4845966696739197,
0.750096321105957,
0.10608336329460144,
-0.45555543899536133,
-0.7721067667007446,
0.14646543562412262,
-0.2865948975086212,
-0.5047324299812317,
-0.3895709216594696,
-0.18905502557754517,
-0.3840716779232025,
0.026605673134326935,
0.19340690970420837,
-0.502623438835144,
0.19720470905303955,
-0.18033216893672943,
0.16681867837905884,
0.6318044066429138,
0.5728687644004822,
0.16897593438625336,
-0.41285398602485657,
0.3909166753292084,
0.03882551193237305,
0.20152240991592407,
-0.0005912031629122794,
-0.08464100956916809,
-0.5465942621231079,
0.0011614636750891805,
0.32068344950675964,
0.5102903246879578,
-1.1318212747573853,
0.10479853302240372,
-0.03737662360072136,
-0.04644851014018059,
-0.6076330542564392,
0.5479421615600586,
0.5377538204193115,
0.786658525466919,
0.5000755190849304,
-0.49280276894569397,
-0.6807704567909241,
-0.5272034406661987,
-0.4819497764110565,
-0.4776521623134613,
0.05426279082894325,
0.46722427010536194,
-0.0479440875351429,
0.2114780843257904,
0.6642132997512817,
-0.5270518064498901,
-0.057993244379758835,
0.029964150860905647,
0.5707617998123169,
0.36660951375961304,
0.4854048192501068,
0.0011495574144646525,
-1.1882421970367432,
-0.15329515933990479,
-0.4472668170928955,
-0.35054826736450195,
-0.7539034485816956,
0.04190603643655777,
-0.36891236901283264,
-0.34819480776786804,
0.5248080492019653,
-0.5507107973098755,
0.3039207458496094,
-0.05946888402104378,
-0.0018383028218522668,
0.5542879104614258,
-0.190652996301651,
0.17457574605941772,
-0.48588234186172485,
-0.07505026459693909,
-0.14532139897346497,
0.01038079708814621,
-0.6559348702430725,
0.025214908644557,
-0.47302407026290894,
0.08972691744565964,
-0.02149326354265213,
0.18503208458423615,
-0.4451596140861511,
0.03711105138063431,
-0.5653334259986877,
0.42206865549087524,
0.07402065396308899,
0.5294015407562256,
-0.21889211237430573,
0.8932608962059021,
0.131344273686409,
-1.1165533065795898,
0.25393450260162354,
0.24110202491283417,
-0.4760783612728119,
0.7535112500190735,
-0.3416191637516022,
-0.009187160059809685,
-0.4994063973426819,
-0.2278100699186325,
-0.7868236899375916,
-0.08311578631401062,
-0.08683432638645172,
-0.5648520588874817,
0.34894925355911255,
-0.16467337310314178,
-0.4809451997280121,
-0.31385764479637146,
-0.20076899230480194,
0.3989916443824768,
0.5189302563667297,
-0.6164771318435669,
-0.06980527192354202,
0.477451890707016,
-0.04080900177359581,
-0.9198799729347229,
-0.48680517077445984,
-0.27405959367752075,
-0.10812980681657791,
-0.3591376841068268,
0.2506234347820282,
-0.3102031350135803,
-0.11928180605173111,
0.28867360949516296,
-0.3976779580116272,
-0.5050874352455139,
0.04671163856983185,
0.09348922222852707,
0.0676058977842331,
-0.005866270046681166,
0.8030160665512085,
-0.11873950809240341,
0.1785859763622284,
-0.1671234369277954,
-0.3252658545970917,
0.4450577199459076,
0.08511737734079361,
0.10101031512022018,
0.0958518385887146,
0.35072609782218933,
0.08294320851564407,
-0.01983913779258728,
0.5267544984817505,
0.8078612089157104,
-0.17736487090587616,
-0.2243930697441101,
-0.698646068572998,
-0.16031834483146667,
-0.4405718445777893,
0.5583682060241699,
-0.6020180583000183,
-1.0034581422805786,
0.18572171032428741,
-0.30379778146743774,
-0.1577484905719757,
0.31326940655708313,
0.18998447060585022,
-0.041825927793979645,
0.8595288991928101,
0.43291541934013367,
0.0020600054413080215,
0.7645834684371948,
-0.2552732229232788,
0.15492689609527588,
-0.9977511763572693,
-0.05561809614300728,
-0.4977581799030304,
-0.03938702493906021,
-0.5038566589355469,
-0.20514075458049774,
0.5009780526161194,
0.8745232224464417,
-0.7824857234954834,
0.1433074027299881,
-0.7809593677520752,
0.37578028440475464,
0.8908299803733826,
0.2817881405353546,
0.377987265586853,
0.3667231798171997,
0.061525944620370865,
0.11796688288450241,
-1.1008265018463135,
0.11610840260982513,
0.8950971961021423,
-0.15243251621723175,
0.5658615827560425,
0.0802515521645546,
0.4388848841190338,
0.25569453835487366,
-0.11755846440792084,
-0.22566816210746765,
0.30459460616111755,
-0.07899433374404907,
-0.6651068925857544,
-0.4742480218410492,
-0.8207138776779175,
-0.9079524874687195,
0.17855194211006165,
-0.4790087640285492,
-0.6082579493522644,
0.4416143298149109,
0.32420939207077026,
-0.31204739212989807,
0.25581035017967224,
-0.39249271154403687,
0.6011597514152527,
0.0621146559715271,
-0.8026448488235474,
-0.354608416557312,
-0.4101073741912842,
0.30019211769104004,
-0.08051963150501251,
0.592582106590271,
0.10722168534994125,
0.05458781495690346,
0.5520434975624084,
-0.539678156375885,
0.22144587337970734,
-0.4824186861515045,
0.39057743549346924,
0.9263618588447571,
-0.05775659903883934,
0.5212606191635132,
-0.033499497920274734,
-0.08428625762462616,
-0.08741103112697601,
-0.027050286531448364,
-0.38312792778015137,
-0.7713699340820312,
0.6040576696395874,
-0.5598844885826111,
-0.5648700594902039,
-0.017316514626145363,
-0.6466144919395447,
-0.25818249583244324,
0.07261264324188232,
0.4172825813293457,
0.22724130749702454,
0.34766918420791626,
0.15425324440002441,
1.0741668939590454,
-0.26710161566734314,
-0.03829243406653404,
0.501279890537262,
-0.05735047534108162,
-0.3918997645378113,
1.2533032894134521,
0.29309937357902527,
0.20272904634475708,
0.48915690183639526,
0.14334437251091003,
-0.1966349184513092,
-0.5972520709037781,
-0.245622456073761,
0.015315791592001915,
-0.4878123700618744,
-0.48829910159111023,
-0.3737289607524872,
-0.2724817097187042,
-0.11812955141067505,
0.5435559749603271,
-0.3595665693283081,
-0.33759382367134094,
-0.1611650586128235,
0.08177994191646576,
0.3743055462837219,
0.5550532937049866,
-0.5872764587402344,
0.3792473375797272,
-0.4028233289718628,
0.4744875431060791,
0.40989771485328674,
0.3445480763912201,
-0.15469658374786377,
-0.4270288944244385,
-0.5092644095420837,
0.048743825405836105,
-0.42772263288497925,
-0.5367518663406372,
0.03284052014350891,
0.38342198729515076,
0.33746007084846497,
0.0774882510304451,
0.5093648433685303,
1.034430980682373,
-0.2057829201221466,
0.7534672617912292,
0.03505329787731171,
-0.6684892773628235,
0.4590344727039337,
0.28847041726112366,
0.3055233955383301,
0.7438350915908813,
0.06456024944782257,
-0.28018590807914734,
-0.3091634213924408,
-0.5271481275558472,
-1.0729053020477295,
0.40203967690467834,
0.22053192555904388,
-0.17188318073749542,
-0.0906679704785347,
0.7581871747970581,
-0.1025184690952301,
0.7904322147369385,
-0.429205060005188,
-0.1262100636959076,
0.009078577160835266,
-0.21058987081050873,
0.5216914415359497,
-0.4256090223789215,
0.1352819800376892,
0.1235838234424591,
0.9325999021530151,
0.21489499509334564,
0.4281444847583771,
0.4844872057437897,
-0.18294665217399597,
-0.4262274205684662,
0.2857188582420349,
0.2402832955121994,
0.293441504240036,
-0.33904653787612915,
0.2509981095790863,
0.1328539103269577,
-0.5215742588043213,
0.03923789784312248,
-0.041756559163331985,
-0.4001976251602173,
0.08488286286592484,
0.1626170128583908,
0.9198099374771118,
-0.13583774864673615,
-0.7786094546318054,
0.5264863967895508,
0.1800379902124405,
-0.005969025660306215,
-0.20702917873859406,
0.30914226174354553,
-0.4690344035625458,
0.3372766673564911,
0.6189743876457214,
0.11813841015100479,
0.41412481665611267,
-0.4396277070045471,
0.4504433274269104,
0.5653494000434875,
-0.48243069648742676,
0.0748826265335083,
0.6561402082443237,
-0.11753404140472412,
-0.0527506098151207,
0.5962923169136047,
-0.33258056640625,
-0.46069616079330444,
0.3834804594516754,
0.2132435142993927,
0.4265674352645874,
-0.15578214824199677,
0.00830696802586317,
0.7274619936943054,
0.2527145445346832,
-0.1922842413187027,
0.4541701078414917,
-0.6234950423240662,
-0.4757246673107147,
-0.7714777588844299,
-0.6977736353874207,
-0.13056674599647522,
0.28603556752204895,
-0.7659552097320557,
0.05654777213931084,
-0.06093938276171684,
-0.12874820828437805,
-0.2804061472415924,
0.2675979733467102,
-0.542695939540863,
0.34340354800224304,
-0.24433831870555878,
0.6830926537513733,
-0.37088432908058167,
0.38816073536872864,
0.24157392978668213,
-0.6298096776008606,
-0.5445783734321594,
-0.031001955270767212,
-0.4843665361404419,
-0.6622150540351868,
0.857738733291626,
-0.056849267333745956,
-0.14061328768730164,
-0.11426299810409546,
-0.6700366139411926,
-0.8965155482292175,
0.7526956796646118,
0.3461432456970215,
-0.5514319539070129,
0.03361859545111656,
-0.03203829750418663,
0.42499208450317383,
-0.3439135253429413,
0.2545273005962372,
0.39024817943573,
0.44815534353256226,
0.3583762049674988,
-0.6472904086112976,
-0.0829639881849289,
-0.4718404710292816,
-0.06382998079061508,
0.30247461795806885,
-0.6157687902450562,
0.7839928269386292,
-0.05304679647088051,
-0.37917593121528625,
0.17750491201877594,
0.3425939679145813,
0.12068843841552734,
0.4165911376476288,
0.798254668712616,
0.5517863035202026,
0.8620615601539612,
-0.042190950363874435,
0.8651746511459351,
-0.5885374546051025,
0.2920101583003998,
1.1191771030426025,
0.38349950313568115,
0.7397156357765198,
0.5555092692375183,
-0.13515043258666992,
0.37526482343673706,
0.6504291296005249,
0.17102447152137756,
0.8119696378707886,
0.6426425576210022,
-0.44647353887557983,
-0.1980445832014084,
-0.6688339710235596,
-0.3937651216983795,
-0.17774350941181183,
0.3078002631664276,
-0.2316581755876541,
0.0458952970802784,
0.09191049635410309,
-0.2229800969362259,
0.1123635545372963,
-0.45650458335876465,
0.8715925216674805,
-0.16195273399353027,
-0.7352107763290405,
0.9118694067001343,
-0.45786839723587036,
0.439106285572052,
-0.18203794956207275,
-0.23233434557914734,
-0.12920457124710083,
-0.163454070687294,
-0.2268780916929245,
-0.5844084620475769,
0.362356573343277,
-0.047877661883831024,
-0.42407917976379395,
0.015862686559557915,
0.7826842665672302,
-0.8256754875183105,
-0.03995756432414055,
-0.08588562160730362,
0.3249936103820801,
0.5070669651031494,
-0.4689178764820099,
-0.35473257303237915,
0.17998114228248596,
0.008328130468726158,
-0.1525338739156723,
0.07815583050251007,
0.5052796006202698,
0.24271367490291595,
0.5472023487091064,
0.5906277298927307,
0.681418776512146,
0.07999946177005768,
-0.15330609679222107,
0.8829928040504456,
-0.40477439761161804,
-0.4286210536956787,
-0.37885600328445435,
0.22929787635803223,
-0.39640387892723083,
-0.19513007998466492,
0.19212433695793152,
0.647161066532135,
0.9794131517410278,
0.17420312762260437,
0.8990731239318848,
-0.11758106201887131,
0.9216914176940918,
-0.45370933413505554,
0.22266243398189545,
-0.5167407989501953,
0.7031529545783997,
-0.1332266479730606,
-0.9335944056510925,
-0.006902822759002447,
0.5627684593200684,
-0.08116868883371353,
-0.07968691736459732,
0.3553716242313385,
0.9321309924125671,
0.1013718694448471,
-0.08037730306386948,
0.16794484853744507,
0.2993548512458801,
-0.06885459274053574,
0.7759034037590027,
0.6414437294006348,
-0.5852968692779541,
1.1321393251419067,
-0.4360542893409729,
-0.10208423435688019,
-0.2467465102672577,
-0.46393081545829773,
-0.5480727553367615,
-0.6473981142044067,
-0.4245753884315491,
-0.4666019380092621,
0.28327375650405884,
0.49792614579200745,
0.7660000920295715,
-0.5009881854057312,
-0.16095617413520813,
-0.6118913292884827,
0.3898741602897644,
-0.35506194829940796,
-0.2768324613571167,
0.10949442535638809,
-0.7396042943000793,
-0.5634974837303162,
0.13320526480674744,
0.12297765165567398,
-0.2857726514339447,
-0.22652389109134674,
-0.0627177283167839,
-0.15542881190776825,
0.20757374167442322,
0.3163951337337494,
0.5847691297531128,
-0.2569594383239746,
-0.4024868607521057,
-0.2608218193054199,
0.29249048233032227,
0.151178777217865,
0.8328339457511902,
-0.9938875436782837,
0.9983780384063721,
0.31278130412101746,
0.7887441515922546,
1.0190244913101196,
0.37682589888572693,
0.18392732739448547,
-1.0255467891693115,
0.2684774696826935,
0.07853741943836212,
-0.2319195717573166,
0.33148276805877686,
-0.6239281892776489,
0.6698746085166931,
0.30220746994018555,
-0.6652252674102783,
-1.0806210041046143,
0.37740010023117065,
-0.3745304048061371,
-0.36715763807296753,
0.882850706577301,
0.009242676198482513,
-0.14552584290504456,
-0.26586130261421204,
-0.20018482208251953,
0.4687809944152832,
-0.35075435042381287,
0.8920369148254395,
0.8822037577629089,
-0.3047555387020111,
-0.3592958152294159,
-0.9088132381439209,
0.6204574108123779,
0.39586812257766724,
-0.3164491355419159,
-0.05340477079153061,
0.5302066802978516,
-0.10752573609352112,
0.46358588337898254,
0.3802219331264496,
0.14407095313072205,
0.20579683780670166,
0.20590201020240784,
0.026477167382836342,
-0.3755493760108948,
-0.19473238289356232,
0.02828800678253174,
0.5745232105255127,
-0.0005798868369311094,
-0.2336214780807495
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.01538v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.01538v2
|
What Are Large Language Models Mapping to in the Brain? A Case Against Over-Reliance on Brain Scores
| 2024-06-03T17:13:27 | 2024-06-20T20:35:36 |
Ebrahim Feghhi, Nima Hadidi, Bryan Song, Idan A. Blank, Jonathan C. Kao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Given the remarkable capabilities of large language models (LLMs), there has
been a growing interest in evaluating their similarity to the human brain. One
approach towards quantifying this similarity is by measuring how well a model
predicts neural signals, also called "brain score". Internal representations
from LLMs achieve state-of-the-art brain scores, leading to speculation that
they share computational principles with human language processing. This
inference is only valid if the subset of neural activity predicted by LLMs
reflects core elements of language processing. Here, we question this
assumption by analyzing three neural datasets used in an impactful study on
LLM-to-brain mappings, with a particular focus on an fMRI dataset where
participants read short passages. We first find that when using shuffled
train-test splits, as done in previous studies with these datasets, a trivial
feature that encodes temporal autocorrelation not only outperforms LLMs but
also accounts for the majority of neural variance that LLMs explain. We
therefore use contiguous splits moving forward. Second, we explain the
surprisingly high brain scores of untrained LLMs by showing they do not account
for additional neural variance beyond two simple features: sentence length and
sentence position. This undermines evidence used to claim that the transformer
architecture biases computations to be more brain-like. Third, we find that
brain scores of trained LLMs on this dataset can largely be explained by
sentence length, position, and pronoun-dereferenced static word embeddings; a
small, additional amount is explained by sense-specific embeddings and
contextual representations of sentence structure. We conclude that
over-reliance on brain scores can lead to over-interpretations of similarity
between LLMs and brains, and emphasize the importance of deconstructing what
LLMs are mapping to in neural signals.
|
[
-0.3508641719818115,
-0.613651692867279,
0.8568872213363647,
0.3213391602039337,
-0.15324093401432037,
-0.03255033120512962,
-0.42090746760368347,
-0.5661019086837769,
0.13266366720199585,
0.34722355008125305,
-0.14618338644504547,
-0.3025805652141571,
-0.6081907153129578,
-0.17456136643886566,
-0.5645288825035095,
0.702055811882019,
0.12310214340686798,
0.12888820469379425,
-0.7586000561714172,
-0.20507554709911346,
-0.44154441356658936,
-0.7430108785629272,
-0.35371437668800354,
-0.8878386616706848,
0.7657039761543274,
-0.08053012192249298,
0.8355782628059387,
0.8723587393760681,
0.38171982765197754,
0.19920416176319122,
-0.21178825199604034,
-0.24589212238788605,
-0.3534330427646637,
0.008034605532884598,
-0.05417314171791077,
-0.8989860415458679,
-0.2708708941936493,
-0.013584395870566368,
0.5722590088844299,
0.9460521340370178,
-0.033356815576553345,
0.09330566972494125,
0.06803704053163528,
0.5727747082710266,
-0.463055819272995,
0.11964571475982666,
-0.4265819191932678,
-0.00827358290553093,
-0.40625911951065063,
-0.3013622462749481,
-0.3544597029685974,
-0.24851173162460327,
0.05223414674401283,
0.029932938516139984,
0.09035387635231018,
0.2567107677459717,
0.6640953421592712,
0.3246501088142395,
-0.6378889083862305,
-0.2074875682592392,
-0.42744332551956177,
0.8136901259422302,
-0.5504255294799805,
0.2517225742340088,
0.37677934765815735,
0.04394664987921715,
-0.18307222425937653,
-0.2624715268611908,
-0.6924372315406799,
-0.34797781705856323,
-0.343187540769577,
0.027891358360648155,
-0.23721837997436523,
0.06293337047100067,
0.3886362314224243,
0.24271260201931,
-0.5772590637207031,
0.4556088149547577,
-0.3418014645576477,
-0.04674892500042915,
0.5615987181663513,
0.40620630979537964,
0.29840144515037537,
-0.0719563439488411,
-0.26635536551475525,
-0.17785291373729706,
-0.8232165575027466,
0.04768623411655426,
0.35182633996009827,
0.10655707865953445,
-0.0011381367221474648,
0.6595439910888672,
0.3174729645252228,
0.7031225562095642,
-0.06190093606710434,
0.12561041116714478,
0.3886929452419281,
0.15184937417507172,
-0.12161748111248016,
0.14150142669677734,
0.8765658140182495,
0.402275413274765,
0.7336474657058716,
-0.4942578375339508,
-0.1842687875032425,
0.20029714703559875,
0.3055994510650635,
-0.603922426700592,
0.01724519394338131,
0.12288541346788406,
-0.5149267911911011,
0.08257580548524857,
-0.13885805010795593,
-0.6161405444145203,
-0.43939676880836487,
-0.42172083258628845,
0.18459300696849823,
-0.32973742485046387,
-0.053360093384981155,
0.18699729442596436,
0.03485614061355591,
0.3485619127750397,
0.010776064358651638,
-0.9517937898635864,
0.44644105434417725,
0.8001490831375122,
0.7892751097679138,
-0.4682086408138275,
-0.6089053153991699,
0.02144637331366539,
-0.12326618283987045,
-0.5121564865112305,
0.8582322001457214,
-0.46278271079063416,
-0.2587268352508545,
-0.09390764683485031,
-0.17216913402080536,
-0.17206524312496185,
-0.6519659161567688,
0.17825517058372498,
-0.6617671251296997,
0.24434532225131989,
-0.43903154134750366,
-0.6606767177581787,
-0.2192174196243286,
0.09573157131671906,
-0.5720950961112976,
0.7898869514465332,
-0.16006100177764893,
-0.5678398013114929,
0.2534998059272766,
-0.47135263681411743,
-0.7363428473472595,
-0.29048407077789307,
-0.35516223311424255,
0.05159059166908264,
0.5731362104415894,
-0.07279413193464279,
0.4266796112060547,
-0.5613217353820801,
0.2771444320678711,
-0.4492936134338379,
-0.5835532546043396,
0.7542513608932495,
-0.5080275535583496,
0.7122446894645691,
-0.0468033067882061,
-0.2594911754131317,
-0.12589335441589355,
-0.40346166491508484,
0.18453001976013184,
0.0037328284233808517,
-0.3722703754901886,
-0.4168161451816559,
0.2244911640882492,
0.04256119951605797,
0.40301698446273804,
0.13209865987300873,
-0.6242291927337646,
0.1358109712600708,
-0.48724812269210815,
0.6745529770851135,
0.4864058196544647,
-0.1843942552804947,
0.4822019040584564,
-0.4568313658237457,
0.21321721374988556,
0.12513789534568787,
-0.22835837304592133,
-0.20409248769283295,
-0.3423234522342682,
-0.6567388772964478,
-0.17745335400104523,
0.38287052512168884,
0.4002625644207001,
0.1032874658703804,
0.544708788394928,
-0.636432945728302,
-0.27102604508399963,
-0.7236658930778503,
-0.19872282445430756,
0.07952510565519333,
0.19087935984134674,
0.533973217010498,
-0.22589635848999023,
-0.23046264052391052,
-1.1037447452545166,
-0.37889406085014343,
-0.022391656413674355,
-0.3261977732181549,
0.10787548124790192,
0.5856782793998718,
-0.21033470332622528,
1.014837622642517,
-0.48986321687698364,
-0.42262354493141174,
0.006981866434216499,
0.030733374878764153,
0.2664826512336731,
0.33046838641166687,
0.46205276250839233,
-0.42735105752944946,
-0.0051501779817044735,
-0.19981995224952698,
-0.7766611576080322,
-0.010740901343524456,
-0.21253393590450287,
0.16392016410827637,
0.06804057955741882,
0.6178019046783447,
-0.8582443594932556,
0.21807189285755157,
0.5124308466911316,
-0.37186768651008606,
0.03948250412940979,
-0.28002434968948364,
0.03622495383024216,
-0.7574324607849121,
0.0614200234413147,
-0.09647944569587708,
-0.01292020920664072,
-0.16499635577201843,
-0.08656764775514603,
0.018356528133153915,
0.31048473715782166,
-0.008047566749155521,
0.47329917550086975,
-0.5548940896987915,
-0.3662012219429016,
-0.5133655071258545,
0.20165173709392548,
0.1307346075773239,
0.5694825053215027,
-0.1869102269411087,
0.4370492994785309,
0.48933547735214233,
-0.21602153778076172,
0.16124886274337769,
-0.033645592629909515,
-0.5521437525749207,
0.3417309820652008,
-0.7611520290374756,
0.28705504536628723,
-0.2989553213119507,
0.2601087689399719,
-1.09340238571167,
0.08605657517910004,
-0.3259245753288269,
-0.4112132787704468,
0.3462999165058136,
0.27853497862815857,
-0.647638738155365,
-0.10107025504112244,
0.06817873567342758,
0.47134339809417725,
0.6991920471191406,
-0.3233124911785126,
0.7570239305496216,
0.4844781160354614,
0.23064947128295898,
-0.4591118097305298,
-1.2834346294403076,
0.14542311429977417,
-0.18266144394874573,
-0.48036500811576843,
0.49988609552383423,
0.1020527333021164,
-0.35325926542282104,
0.06268741190433502,
-0.015363677404820919,
0.033304162323474884,
-0.0597761869430542,
0.5892019867897034,
0.0879344716668129,
-0.3921336531639099,
0.21835842728614807,
-0.24849742650985718,
0.1291636824607849,
0.601082444190979,
0.01132754422724247,
0.5455458760261536,
-0.023351915180683136,
-0.44685623049736023,
-0.017908692359924316,
0.3739734888076782,
0.9756236672401428,
0.009466337040066719,
0.7200609445571899,
0.2154616415500641,
-0.4933881163597107,
-0.10031458735466003,
-0.563579797744751,
-0.24839220941066742,
-0.3785244822502136,
0.4807845652103424,
-0.35550427436828613,
-0.916941225528717,
0.575084924697876,
-0.011508896946907043,
-0.17844010889530182,
0.4746178090572357,
0.6772769093513489,
-0.3960120975971222,
0.8911912441253662,
0.40951061248779297,
-0.39986059069633484,
0.2216395139694214,
-0.11069754511117935,
0.17431522905826569,
-1.0581616163253784,
-0.2839890718460083,
-0.42104122042655945,
-0.7195005416870117,
-0.5198580026626587,
-0.40761592984199524,
-0.08351866155862808,
-0.21999739110469818,
-0.1380242109298706,
-0.027843862771987915,
-0.18087080121040344,
0.777347981929779,
0.2827039062976837,
-0.0035789143294095993,
0.022058596834540367,
-0.16349399089813232,
-0.3511493504047394,
-0.1734653264284134,
-0.6150215268135071,
-0.22204715013504028,
1.0940930843353271,
0.4313744604587555,
0.775799036026001,
-0.27703750133514404,
0.31513938307762146,
0.27757248282432556,
0.320724219083786,
-0.9724401235580444,
0.6206513047218323,
-0.26349151134490967,
-0.6743600368499756,
-0.04654466733336449,
-0.29249176383018494,
-0.9620768427848816,
0.3547310531139374,
-0.15750926733016968,
-0.6616232395172119,
0.2665550708770752,
-0.1469353586435318,
-0.4415067732334137,
0.021108750253915787,
-0.6155969500541687,
0.7341733574867249,
-0.5079437494277954,
-0.276492714881897,
-0.4705542325973511,
-0.5352057218551636,
0.3556157350540161,
-0.12791560590267181,
0.1604156494140625,
-0.04647775739431381,
-0.05269801989197731,
0.6857169270515442,
0.020367251709103584,
0.9353051781654358,
0.17598223686218262,
-0.1091672033071518,
0.06500386446714401,
-0.014810721389949322,
-0.030170295387506485,
-0.05834527313709259,
-0.10037612915039062,
0.5631362795829773,
-0.05125803127884865,
-0.3238013684749603,
-0.7450045347213745,
1.076138973236084,
-0.9552123546600342,
-0.5202621817588806,
-0.6883132457733154,
-0.7479721903800964,
-0.10814882814884186,
0.11897541582584381,
0.3255009949207306,
0.3828030824661255,
-0.153291717171669,
0.31989091634750366,
0.6049810647964478,
-0.003963198978453875,
0.4586977958679199,
0.3567560017108917,
-0.21707381308078766,
-0.2421826720237732,
0.54170161485672,
0.33293813467025757,
0.15798594057559967,
0.5643042325973511,
0.04663626849651337,
-0.4428417384624481,
-0.6336050629615784,
-0.013726619072258472,
0.36541077494621277,
-0.79344642162323,
0.13225135207176208,
-0.416260302066803,
-0.11827627569437027,
-0.14271564781665802,
-0.047516532242298126,
-0.30154430866241455,
-0.06284497678279877,
-0.2557964026927948,
-0.07415162026882172,
0.05404292419552803,
0.7404794096946716,
0.18921798467636108,
0.33963876962661743,
-0.5373923182487488,
0.2017117142677307,
0.22365383803844452,
0.32762420177459717,
0.23805157840251923,
-0.6543442606925964,
-0.38142213225364685,
0.10481611639261246,
-0.10268346965312958,
-0.8114017248153687,
0.2209540605545044,
0.17182011902332306,
0.5768377780914307,
0.25123831629753113,
-0.3004237413406372,
0.7397780418395996,
-0.6866889595985413,
0.6715484261512756,
0.013081762008368969,
-0.8770666718482971,
0.02067665569484234,
-0.11645598709583282,
0.7985700368881226,
0.41875356435775757,
0.4570423364639282,
-0.6271740794181824,
-0.32368168234825134,
-0.40513017773628235,
-0.6774077415466309,
0.3730319142341614,
-0.1060020700097084,
0.2722531259059906,
-0.21589866280555725,
0.5143112540245056,
-0.08011151105165482,
0.003495511133223772,
-0.6629077792167664,
-0.2799227833747864,
0.04134964942932129,
-0.28688496351242065,
-0.36120954155921936,
-0.22000059485435486,
-0.11838104575872421,
-0.16099846363067627,
0.03873314708471298,
-0.10415588319301605,
0.5403228998184204,
0.10320718586444855,
-0.20276379585266113,
-0.19818219542503357,
0.12547917664051056,
0.602369487285614,
0.6422112584114075,
-0.04809301346540451,
0.2724044620990753,
0.3510212302207947,
-0.445116251707077,
-0.014953293837606907,
-0.17024730145931244,
0.08602003008127213,
-0.08233374357223511,
0.6704789400100708,
0.7618311047554016,
0.22419928014278412,
-0.5643875598907471,
0.5242925882339478,
-0.0088263601064682,
0.02612704038619995,
-0.45600783824920654,
0.023126620799303055,
0.45988261699676514,
0.4686058461666107,
0.39278241991996765,
0.36469030380249023,
-0.11348633468151093,
-0.5888291597366333,
0.09332673251628876,
0.44807061553001404,
-0.43452826142311096,
-0.5823696255683899,
0.41815152764320374,
-0.13505461812019348,
-0.44344547390937805,
0.8311904072761536,
0.3014604449272156,
-0.4330742657184601,
0.5953744649887085,
0.5453810095787048,
0.8085573315620422,
-0.02615370601415634,
-0.35924237966537476,
0.12890467047691345,
0.5078095197677612,
-0.4223203659057617,
0.14265193045139313,
0.18071386218070984,
-0.8169405460357666,
-0.6787059307098389,
-0.5326306819915771,
0.02972949482500553,
0.2974514961242676,
-0.636049211025238,
0.23042908310890198,
-0.28420165181159973,
-0.419071227312088,
-0.004006536677479744,
-0.2604677081108093,
-0.6569874286651611,
0.414998322725296,
0.5659729242324829,
0.7827681303024292,
-0.8490354418754578,
1.1107327938079834,
0.4651834964752197,
-0.13218022882938385,
-0.41732844710350037,
0.22131161391735077,
-0.31060636043548584,
-0.7308806777000427,
0.7649686932563782,
0.2793077826499939,
0.02274111844599247,
-0.05546233803033829,
-0.24602974951267242,
-0.9720411896705627,
0.8685927987098694,
0.5212334990501404,
-0.7428755760192871,
-0.3590642511844635,
0.37649691104888916,
0.8949976563453674,
-0.5693394541740417,
0.6031694412231445,
0.701218843460083,
0.2676852345466614,
-0.2215682864189148,
-0.6019815802574158,
0.2621275782585144,
-0.018885072320699692,
-0.01245556678622961,
0.43227899074554443,
-0.5521886348724365,
0.820580244064331,
-0.24576854705810547,
-0.01680435799062252,
-0.274746298789978,
0.6202714443206787,
0.013887811452150345,
0.037008993327617645,
0.36438027024269104,
0.5781128406524658,
0.5113452672958374,
-0.13841216266155243,
1.0607457160949707,
-0.28132200241088867,
0.22726444900035858,
1.108988881111145,
-0.28981566429138184,
1.0163742303848267,
0.8031837344169617,
-0.1564926952123642,
0.5493336319923401,
0.48235899209976196,
-0.15499937534332275,
0.5388489365577698,
0.6126125454902649,
0.18495947122573853,
-0.2889813780784607,
0.23841600120067596,
-0.13239026069641113,
0.6724712252616882,
0.4512063264846802,
-0.6755538582801819,
-0.14736270904541016,
0.005432337522506714,
-0.05466089025139809,
0.09765364974737167,
-0.03956816345453262,
0.5058619379997253,
0.45983943343162537,
-0.7336550951004028,
0.6412461400032043,
-0.2586425542831421,
0.7057520747184753,
-0.5896797180175781,
0.25580930709838867,
-0.20802417397499084,
0.24138407409191132,
-0.04367009550333023,
-0.9623327851295471,
0.44780513644218445,
-0.1708943396806717,
-0.4390581548213959,
-0.42917078733444214,
0.3802635967731476,
-0.43080785870552063,
-0.11973808705806732,
0.6718168258666992,
0.4965648651123047,
0.2643451988697052,
-0.13440366089344025,
-0.46155574917793274,
0.08306017518043518,
-0.22925657033920288,
-0.5367292165756226,
0.691095232963562,
0.4540075659751892,
-0.02812858857214451,
0.5684066414833069,
0.41592147946357727,
0.2747747600078583,
0.031458619982004166,
0.07717828452587128,
0.6244328618049622,
-1.0045461654663086,
-0.25451207160949707,
-1.2905157804489136,
0.23121103644371033,
0.08938781172037125,
-0.6279382705688477,
0.5074188709259033,
0.5723501443862915,
0.6296519041061401,
0.008577745407819748,
0.5705558657646179,
0.1783023625612259,
0.17064984142780304,
-0.4905915856361389,
0.8444709777832031,
-0.4995492994785309,
0.21936611831188202,
0.23125764727592468,
-1.0192142724990845,
-0.3781874179840088,
0.4922937750816345,
-0.6398744583129883,
0.018682071939110756,
0.9494525790214539,
0.549144983291626,
0.007238110527396202,
0.021331870928406715,
0.4733772575855255,
0.4338725209236145,
0.09442280977964401,
0.7864745855331421,
0.9717801809310913,
-0.3876592516899109,
0.35434165596961975,
0.07809510827064514,
0.02212652936577797,
-0.039485812187194824,
-0.776148796081543,
-1.016774296760559,
-0.4780283272266388,
-0.23832069337368011,
-0.14492671191692352,
-0.07767090201377869,
0.7177848815917969,
0.45398271083831787,
-0.6404423713684082,
-0.5108250379562378,
0.012727389112114906,
-0.1294620931148529,
-0.19404169917106628,
-0.2153719663619995,
0.3053712844848633,
-0.19024670124053955,
-0.5476981997489929,
0.4122459888458252,
0.22380822896957397,
-0.1774950921535492,
-0.5342185497283936,
0.3031795024871826,
-0.1701473444700241,
0.16200986504554749,
0.46846356987953186,
-0.08929824829101562,
-0.8520963191986084,
-0.40466076135635376,
0.2921386957168579,
-0.5342324376106262,
0.19135771691799164,
0.8280856013298035,
-0.9875935316085815,
0.019564900547266006,
0.6775488257408142,
0.7306126952171326,
0.3749925196170807,
-0.37400275468826294,
0.6926192045211792,
-0.48347207903862,
-0.14412790536880493,
0.3685857653617859,
0.5668331384658813,
0.43753331899642944,
-0.41041481494903564,
0.2046218067407608,
-0.023924773558974266,
-0.6938584446907043,
-0.7441736459732056,
0.12653237581253052,
-0.9888865947723389,
-0.33306705951690674,
1.1729601621627808,
-0.03633049502968788,
-0.5472365021705627,
0.03735509142279625,
0.06716398149728775,
0.11741805076599121,
-0.1576252579689026,
1.1136149168014526,
0.9974767565727234,
-0.16549251973628998,
0.043203823268413544,
-0.5497828722000122,
0.2667950987815857,
0.5824079513549805,
-0.46793195605278015,
0.06345909833908081,
0.3196755647659302,
0.44084084033966064,
0.43876421451568604,
0.32707273960113525,
-0.049079976975917816,
0.018754655495285988,
-0.1495300978422165,
0.054981768131256104,
0.13790254294872284,
-0.11274983733892441,
-0.5722392201423645,
0.3725969195365906,
-0.15240539610385895,
-0.20098876953125
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.06572v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.06572v1
|
Graph Neural Network Enhanced Retrieval for Question Answering of LLMs
| 2024-06-03T17:07:46 | 2024-06-03T17:07:46 |
Zijian Li, Qingyan Guo, Jiawei Shao, Lei Song, Jiang Bian, Jun Zhang, Rui Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR
|
Retrieval augmented generation has revolutionized large language model (LLM)
outputs by providing factual supports. Nevertheless, it struggles to capture
all the necessary knowledge for complex reasoning questions. Existing retrieval
methods typically divide reference documents into passages, treating them in
isolation. These passages, however, are often interrelated, such as passages
that are contiguous or share the same keywords. Therefore, recognizing the
relatedness is crucial for enhancing the retrieval process. In this paper, we
propose a novel retrieval method, called GNN-Ret, which leverages graph neural
networks (GNNs) to enhance retrieval by considering the relatedness between
passages. Specifically, we first construct a graph of passages by connecting
passages that are structure-related and keyword-related. A graph neural network
(GNN) is then leveraged to exploit the relationships between passages and
improve the retrieval of supporting passages. Furthermore, we extend our method
to handle multi-hop reasoning questions using a recurrent graph neural network
(RGNN), named RGNN-Ret. At each step, RGNN-Ret integrates the graphs of
passages from previous steps, thereby enhancing the retrieval of supporting
passages. Extensive experiments on benchmark datasets demonstrate that GNN-Ret
achieves higher accuracy for question answering with a single query of LLMs
than strong baselines that require multiple queries, and RGNN-Ret further
improves accuracy and achieves state-of-the-art performance, with up to 10.4%
accuracy improvement on the 2WikiMQA dataset.
|
[
-0.2451072335243225,
-1.1217174530029297,
0.7291492223739624,
-0.16266651451587677,
-0.45393386483192444,
0.3236658573150635,
0.08486919105052948,
-0.4177713096141815,
0.5189921855926514,
0.5436448454856873,
-0.507108747959137,
-0.429656058549881,
-0.4896560609340668,
0.19350188970565796,
-0.27157676219940186,
0.5800150036811829,
-0.0007318074349313974,
-0.0651068240404129,
-0.36060988903045654,
-0.2337401658296585,
-0.36296892166137695,
-0.48387694358825684,
-0.7942900657653809,
-0.6180207133293152,
0.9827066659927368,
-0.07251383364200592,
0.6172692775726318,
0.5945443511009216,
0.5189198851585388,
0.32023900747299194,
-0.4692559242248535,
0.4541670083999634,
-0.3734980821609497,
0.36866652965545654,
0.023164939135313034,
-0.3164787292480469,
-0.2964213490486145,
-0.25989699363708496,
0.6559746265411377,
0.7204298377037048,
0.08044347912073135,
0.08969855308532715,
0.10129718482494354,
0.5889997482299805,
-0.31152215600013733,
0.2811572849750519,
-0.7685533165931702,
-0.02463267557322979,
0.04354304075241089,
-0.36940798163414,
-0.28667327761650085,
-0.6786237359046936,
0.2005305290222168,
-0.7264584302902222,
0.31228938698768616,
0.07726433873176575,
0.7154112458229065,
0.16656802594661713,
-0.4172729253768921,
-0.17594033479690552,
-0.11507552117109299,
0.24026265740394592,
-0.6356818675994873,
0.6263324618339539,
0.08476296812295914,
0.039159055799245834,
-0.2973948121070862,
-1.2621004581451416,
-0.5149384140968323,
-0.31405434012413025,
-0.2789463698863983,
0.2548430860042572,
0.02190393954515457,
0.10539999604225159,
0.3021846115589142,
0.13136985898017883,
-0.6250845193862915,
-0.3966350853443146,
-0.18510638177394867,
-0.4610256850719452,
0.3182486891746521,
0.1304478496313095,
0.3535761833190918,
-0.40750473737716675,
-0.3363407254219055,
-0.009529819712042809,
-0.6774426102638245,
-0.10244257748126984,
0.30190062522888184,
0.4752863347530365,
0.6243643164634705,
0.5125347971916199,
-0.3084847629070282,
0.929926872253418,
-0.15812332928180695,
0.10377481579780579,
0.4136539101600647,
-0.682702362537384,
0.07544277608394623,
-0.14122138917446136,
0.6025121212005615,
0.1610473394393921,
0.3711658716201782,
-0.3832748234272003,
0.02624867483973503,
-0.38622692227363586,
0.20815972983837128,
-0.6654739379882812,
-0.1628490537405014,
-0.145868182182312,
-0.3628545105457306,
0.05527881160378456,
-0.12507373094558716,
-0.5530311465263367,
-0.20141716301441193,
-0.4182630479335785,
0.16260568797588348,
-0.4086054265499115,
-0.22095844149589539,
-0.1324601024389267,
-0.15751132369041443,
0.27091914415359497,
0.38642486929893494,
-0.4826253652572632,
0.11445438861846924,
0.7659915089607239,
0.9497523903846741,
0.0015833500074222684,
-0.35812562704086304,
-0.7020851969718933,
0.05650937929749489,
-0.09489662200212479,
0.8054687976837158,
-0.5900751352310181,
-0.2582310438156128,
-0.08387691527605057,
-0.041741229593753815,
-0.40166065096855164,
-0.5600234866142273,
0.4671880602836609,
-1.2035638093948364,
-0.04462224245071411,
-0.19593626260757446,
-0.6676623225212097,
-0.5262054800987244,
0.7643211483955383,
-0.7890346646308899,
1.0156135559082031,
-0.07861810177564621,
-0.8383073806762695,
-0.18255360424518585,
-0.16775844991207123,
-0.4510769248008728,
0.02463892288506031,
-0.3387888967990875,
-0.37071511149406433,
-0.16261062026023865,
0.43117088079452515,
0.19622595608234406,
-0.09367527812719345,
0.18855583667755127,
-0.38038259744644165,
-0.5426701307296753,
0.04547591507434845,
-0.4300907850265503,
0.5546225905418396,
-0.058920372277498245,
0.1970895677804947,
0.21345730125904083,
-0.40036264061927795,
0.4428936839103699,
0.09024705737829208,
-0.6591396927833557,
-0.32801583409309387,
-0.31674158573150635,
-0.43040701746940613,
0.2462809979915619,
0.22053363919258118,
-0.5876373052597046,
0.1883244812488556,
-0.3636605441570282,
0.48506584763526917,
0.5358507633209229,
0.4330998957157135,
0.07367934286594391,
-0.27147749066352844,
0.5295096635818481,
-0.12676651775836945,
-0.18804742395877838,
-0.054378192871809006,
-0.7920085191726685,
-0.42454957962036133,
0.218966543674469,
0.28776299953460693,
0.8862901926040649,
-0.8802014589309692,
0.18913604319095612,
-0.45538875460624695,
-0.17907549440860748,
-0.5312514901161194,
0.28380507230758667,
0.39499956369400024,
0.9762430191040039,
0.5181252956390381,
-0.035179443657398224,
-0.42492759227752686,
-0.716690182685852,
-0.19770438969135284,
-0.2236439436674118,
0.12737025320529938,
0.7779991030693054,
0.39415010809898376,
0.04401152953505516,
0.7856794595718384,
-0.675918459892273,
-0.01792985387146473,
-0.16626091301441193,
-0.06068764999508858,
0.38644886016845703,
0.12383998930454254,
0.10135722905397415,
-0.990559995174408,
-0.483845978975296,
-0.009641257114708424,
-0.7687358260154724,
0.14387694001197815,
0.15575626492500305,
-0.2587513029575348,
-0.23938758671283722,
0.9277101159095764,
-0.6394047141075134,
0.3235286474227905,
0.050396278500556946,
-0.2071729302406311,
0.4614400863647461,
-0.29223179817199707,
0.05179215595126152,
-1.1192353963851929,
0.2113187164068222,
-0.31550833582878113,
-0.34760165214538574,
-0.35263463854789734,
0.11848409473896027,
0.09715049713850021,
-0.08980444073677063,
-0.2954081594944,
0.4178581237792969,
-0.5019741654396057,
-0.21614982187747955,
-0.2534753084182739,
0.7442165613174438,
0.37996906042099,
0.4383154809474945,
-0.03670846298336983,
0.9046182632446289,
0.1913517713546753,
-0.3732532262802124,
0.898712694644928,
0.5363847613334656,
-0.213217630982399,
0.11037725955247879,
-0.7800235152244568,
0.5475870370864868,
-0.381278932094574,
0.5224263072013855,
-1.1223496198654175,
0.3438194692134857,
0.30975133180618286,
-0.584365725517273,
0.32065901160240173,
-0.34604206681251526,
-0.55003821849823,
-0.3870476186275482,
0.013078331016004086,
0.45347824692726135,
-0.020056750625371933,
-0.43284717202186584,
0.760112464427948,
-0.13548608124256134,
-0.35984745621681213,
-0.8318188190460205,
-0.4853588938713074,
0.08620843291282654,
-0.01727331429719925,
-0.86219322681427,
0.25013160705566406,
0.08432097733020782,
0.16200482845306396,
0.34447333216667175,
-0.1421363800764084,
0.11209738254547119,
0.0964834913611412,
-0.16102419793605804,
0.33989712595939636,
-0.31700870394706726,
0.3892415165901184,
-0.1959792822599411,
-0.2828449606895447,
0.029727734625339508,
-0.49309372901916504,
0.5588428974151611,
-0.14404349029064178,
-0.27965837717056274,
-0.14039203524589539,
0.4505034387111664,
0.27688515186309814,
-0.4590933620929718,
0.48594751954078674,
0.6023481488227844,
-0.11737804859876633,
0.27005183696746826,
-0.37525445222854614,
-0.3207190930843353,
-0.36536890268325806,
0.6140103340148926,
-0.696065366268158,
-1.0149122476577759,
0.7434759736061096,
-0.24237622320652008,
-0.3001813292503357,
0.15495933592319489,
0.17102022469043732,
-0.06893453747034073,
0.6080731749534607,
-0.03289245814085007,
-0.15174227952957153,
0.5416126251220703,
-0.3604368567466736,
0.17727601528167725,
-1.373976230621338,
-0.4277278184890747,
-0.34092044830322266,
-0.34657394886016846,
-0.4017058312892914,
-0.48082685470581055,
0.2571910321712494,
0.27698928117752075,
-0.2725285291671753,
0.22119896113872528,
-0.44509831070899963,
0.4217308461666107,
0.6909935474395752,
0.5314101576805115,
0.5449582934379578,
0.07513560354709625,
-0.6524561047554016,
0.23402106761932373,
-0.6966522336006165,
-0.10764186084270477,
1.0005357265472412,
0.04242269694805145,
0.5905178785324097,
0.17356295883655548,
0.6076378226280212,
0.07773379981517792,
0.2649332582950592,
-0.6122402548789978,
0.6909999251365662,
-0.00138015765696764,
-0.4856964647769928,
-0.4671327471733093,
-0.7024573087692261,
-0.9277701377868652,
0.5708880424499512,
0.030865011736750603,
-0.7675368785858154,
-0.08722954988479614,
-0.1349848210811615,
-0.39614149928092957,
0.29246124625205994,
-0.5100414752960205,
0.6964709758758545,
-0.204965740442276,
-0.3175778388977051,
-0.018918732181191444,
-0.8911793828010559,
0.07345671951770782,
0.21949371695518494,
-0.39686447381973267,
-0.03033282235264778,
0.016832241788506508,
0.6465815901756287,
-0.3050917983055115,
0.4899533987045288,
-0.01394028402864933,
0.21302615106105804,
0.5742359161376953,
-0.13064587116241455,
0.7634592056274414,
0.08390233665704727,
-0.32347896695137024,
-0.07964738458395004,
-0.15111574530601501,
-0.1873634308576584,
-1.1447157859802246,
0.8263503909111023,
-0.5679254531860352,
-0.8782531023025513,
-0.17792074382305145,
-0.6521862745285034,
-0.33479365706443787,
0.4933435618877411,
0.14167864620685577,
0.5952700972557068,
0.13368815183639526,
0.28460973501205444,
0.6302236914634705,
0.023477859795093536,
0.19741417467594147,
0.11611047387123108,
-0.3578920066356659,
-0.8031848669052124,
0.745843231678009,
0.3523772656917572,
0.4129623472690582,
0.54823237657547,
0.18561337888240814,
-0.8267414569854736,
-0.6067957282066345,
-0.49734583497047424,
0.4422968327999115,
-0.9475099444389343,
-0.34957027435302734,
-0.7712792158126831,
-0.46933767199516296,
-0.5613461136817932,
0.2990836501121521,
0.17109858989715576,
-0.38535910844802856,
-0.17322096228599548,
-0.41280877590179443,
0.5547828078269958,
0.41713741421699524,
0.23452043533325195,
0.03775247558951378,
-0.7975488901138306,
0.3836100399494171,
0.40072566270828247,
0.386889785528183,
0.2338920682668686,
-0.49473193287849426,
0.09297753125429153,
-0.0009945076890289783,
-0.2726447880268097,
-0.8970320224761963,
-0.03512199595570564,
0.07924714684486389,
0.751944899559021,
-0.08268063515424728,
-0.037932656705379486,
0.7667564153671265,
-0.5004944205284119,
0.34843724966049194,
-0.012842702679336071,
-0.5309044122695923,
0.4561633765697479,
-0.2577782869338989,
0.10931792855262756,
0.6441368460655212,
0.21785271167755127,
-0.6605954170227051,
0.020246703177690506,
-0.5860915184020996,
-1.0505985021591187,
0.39407047629356384,
0.23031657934188843,
0.08944755047559738,
-0.06252755224704742,
0.8643814325332642,
-0.3874185383319855,
0.23188890516757965,
-0.4585352838039398,
-0.46563848853111267,
-0.26007217168807983,
-0.177760049700737,
0.16735512018203735,
-0.09488297253847122,
0.0469215027987957,
-0.26661571860313416,
0.6617895364761353,
-0.4043179750442505,
0.33910003304481506,
0.5605274438858032,
0.025468911975622177,
0.2856934070587158,
0.198355570435524,
0.2882406413555145,
0.5909136533737183,
-0.31083154678344727,
0.22947289049625397,
0.31224778294563293,
-0.5606608986854553,
0.16225333511829376,
0.43414902687072754,
-0.34263259172439575,
0.1333203762769699,
0.5002037882804871,
0.732737123966217,
-0.1660207211971283,
-0.22757479548454285,
0.32141178846359253,
-0.08361636847257614,
0.015827136114239693,
-0.13391220569610596,
-0.1895451843738556,
0.5323997139930725,
0.35964035987854004,
0.25946786999702454,
-0.19995370507240295,
0.0682641938328743,
-0.3886922001838684,
0.6049485802650452,
0.539725124835968,
-0.44227683544158936,
0.18900346755981445,
0.40864700078964233,
0.05944538861513138,
-0.47132056951522827,
1.2658867835998535,
-0.12265036255121231,
-0.7704284191131592,
0.7996853590011597,
0.788114607334137,
0.7352755665779114,
0.11535502970218658,
0.14926712214946747,
0.4921492338180542,
0.10516567528247833,
0.25234249234199524,
0.4513692259788513,
-0.034283991903066635,
-0.9617660045623779,
-0.5276809930801392,
-0.37839630246162415,
-0.19740383327007294,
0.0697677806019783,
-0.49310100078582764,
-0.17417921125888824,
-0.32491469383239746,
-0.20513524115085602,
-0.24472786486148834,
0.15082025527954102,
-0.4186909794807434,
0.14053073525428772,
-0.0042065163142979145,
0.9637088775634766,
-0.3968798518180847,
0.7233564257621765,
0.742779552936554,
-0.5665512084960938,
-1.1375372409820557,
-0.00556689640507102,
-0.2926272451877594,
-0.8688713312149048,
0.667477548122406,
0.08662186563014984,
-0.19142977893352509,
0.40091001987457275,
-0.08980059623718262,
-0.9656031131744385,
1.4145017862319946,
0.26256465911865234,
-0.380827933549881,
-0.29353684186935425,
0.018509702757000923,
0.4360746145248413,
-0.39001765847206116,
0.4787265360355377,
0.4249415993690491,
0.37269678711891174,
0.4862203598022461,
-0.473617821931839,
0.2574968636035919,
-0.3191448450088501,
0.038053855299949646,
0.2959171235561371,
-0.6016203761100769,
0.6413040161132812,
-0.2889896631240845,
0.019884979352355003,
0.14520083367824554,
0.7400131225585938,
0.5010572671890259,
0.40302813053131104,
0.4678751826286316,
0.640903651714325,
1.111647367477417,
-0.1404685378074646,
0.9953569769859314,
-0.3273908495903015,
0.4387942850589752,
1.3152908086776733,
-0.15122799575328827,
0.8861257433891296,
0.460833877325058,
-0.04901266098022461,
0.5234501361846924,
0.6548428535461426,
0.23105499148368835,
0.36765849590301514,
0.49027061462402344,
-0.39485296607017517,
-0.4805639088153839,
-0.2692370116710663,
-0.4306173622608185,
0.08888697624206543,
0.20729267597198486,
-0.473249226808548,
-0.4745789170265198,
-0.2207994908094406,
-0.054021287709474564,
0.10424581170082092,
-0.25796228647232056,
0.8719311952590942,
0.24872669577598572,
-0.6703492403030396,
0.33361801505088806,
-0.49335527420043945,
0.17026172578334808,
-0.5931894779205322,
-0.1795942336320877,
-0.4254676401615143,
0.11218985170125961,
-0.16924573481082916,
-1.0417503118515015,
0.21100305020809174,
-0.5068952441215515,
-0.22063606977462769,
0.11602386832237244,
0.9549204707145691,
-0.49541425704956055,
-0.5901708006858826,
0.609447717666626,
0.8539411425590515,
0.04656483978033066,
-0.20604006946086884,
-0.8521664142608643,
-0.263915091753006,
0.04687121883034706,
-0.2553858160972595,
0.04521266743540764,
0.4684683382511139,
0.047414589673280716,
0.9220730662345886,
0.7064345479011536,
0.18235144019126892,
0.22092223167419434,
0.39681288599967957,
0.942559003829956,
-0.7686336040496826,
-0.4809572100639343,
-0.6473426222801208,
-0.010614784434437752,
-0.07893127202987671,
-0.1002587229013443,
0.6718112826347351,
0.6411081552505493,
0.6218468546867371,
0.22757995128631592,
0.6322437524795532,
0.2202955186367035,
0.6317656636238098,
-0.5820878148078918,
0.5237678289413452,
-0.42902570962905884,
0.20337709784507751,
-0.2606143653392792,
-0.9681283831596375,
-0.4200320541858673,
0.5449250936508179,
-0.34838899970054626,
0.1416943371295929,
0.616055965423584,
0.9781811237335205,
-0.07006825506687164,
0.124733567237854,
0.21375195682048798,
0.028749218210577965,
0.375169962644577,
0.6586260199546814,
0.9807243943214417,
-0.6328877210617065,
0.9643269777297974,
-0.03149665147066116,
0.23430772125720978,
-0.049419105052948,
-0.7232719659805298,
-0.570953905582428,
-0.34324121475219727,
-0.23509372770786285,
-0.5845572352409363,
0.19354479014873505,
0.6716883778572083,
0.34677577018737793,
-0.5331802368164062,
0.19526490569114685,
-0.15295523405075073,
0.5844495892524719,
-0.23566845059394836,
-0.19984622299671173,
0.7898659110069275,
-0.32023707032203674,
-0.4196040630340576,
0.3901127874851227,
0.10509832948446274,
-0.07530264556407928,
-0.014215250499546528,
-0.04055801406502724,
-0.8089300990104675,
-0.22536435723304749,
0.47968488931655884,
0.14397096633911133,
-0.5678335428237915,
-0.6460418105125427,
0.31242015957832336,
-0.08191419392824173,
0.22913576662540436,
0.9386434555053711,
-0.9916309118270874,
0.3838677406311035,
0.9126932621002197,
1.066236138343811,
0.5478214621543884,
0.4668272137641907,
0.1968059241771698,
-0.7468461990356445,
-0.21374723315238953,
0.3290780186653137,
0.48111915588378906,
0.36101847887039185,
-0.4817386865615845,
0.6194982528686523,
0.552079975605011,
-0.6118466258049011,
-0.198106050491333,
0.38762524724006653,
-0.9554582834243774,
-0.11832708865404129,
1.1451634168624878,
-0.49398162961006165,
-0.10167818516492844,
-0.4521726071834564,
-0.24168506264686584,
0.4616568386554718,
-0.3534095287322998,
0.2988852858543396,
0.6490642428398132,
-0.42538028955459595,
-0.31817442178726196,
-0.46393153071403503,
0.009892161004245281,
0.25446197390556335,
-0.5553311109542847,
0.05751277878880501,
0.42480146884918213,
0.4279218912124634,
0.34860268235206604,
0.6404708623886108,
-0.05230151489377022,
0.16915354132652283,
-0.12466824799776077,
-0.4633268117904663,
-0.493520587682724,
-0.26803287863731384,
-0.13986285030841827,
0.4231673777103424,
-0.05844198167324066,
-0.3117898106575012
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.01514v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.01514v3
|
Decoupled Alignment for Robust Plug-and-Play Adaptation
| 2024-06-03T16:46:18 | 2024-06-06T04:25:40 |
Haozheng Luo, Jiahao Yu, Wenxin Zhang, Jialong Li, Jerry Yao-Chieh Hu, Xinyu Xing, Han Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CR
|
We introduce a low-resource safety enhancement method for aligning large
language models (LLMs) without the need for supervised fine-tuning (SFT) or
reinforcement learning from human feedback (RLHF). Our main idea is to exploit
knowledge distillation to extract the alignment information from existing
well-aligned LLMs and integrate it into unaligned LLMs in a plug-and-play
fashion. Methodology, we employ delta debugging to identify the critical
components of knowledge necessary for effective distillation. On the harmful
question dataset, our method significantly enhances the average defense success
rate by approximately 14.41%, reaching as high as 51.39%, in 17 unaligned
pre-trained LLMs, without compromising performance.
|
[
-0.19672490656375885,
-0.6283206939697266,
0.505950391292572,
0.01279283408075571,
-0.31513097882270813,
0.5599842071533203,
-0.3696482181549072,
-0.40291109681129456,
-0.16933071613311768,
0.36642733216285706,
-0.6489182710647583,
-0.459811806678772,
-0.5088216662406921,
-0.024138640612363815,
-0.11751575767993927,
1.0733977556228638,
0.10670153796672821,
-0.16735219955444336,
-0.18566426634788513,
-0.08684433251619339,
-0.6708444356918335,
-0.18322506546974182,
-0.4639081656932831,
-0.31933826208114624,
0.21451407670974731,
0.5057319402694702,
0.761857807636261,
0.8380618095397949,
0.700792133808136,
0.3079063892364502,
-0.32039782404899597,
0.3104647994041443,
-0.5324199795722961,
0.10987517237663269,
-0.4309697449207306,
-0.33556780219078064,
-0.5822475552558899,
-0.3191278576850891,
0.42188504338264465,
0.5965086221694946,
-0.4802170395851135,
-0.06012606993317604,
0.4661513864994049,
0.8057951331138611,
-0.9735431671142578,
0.014190487563610077,
-0.7667878866195679,
-0.008401211351156235,
0.002878887578845024,
-0.09466499090194702,
-0.503509521484375,
-0.5388429760932922,
0.1664527952671051,
-0.7799248099327087,
0.028256595134735107,
-0.11852295696735382,
0.5672210454940796,
0.6081398129463196,
-0.5639370679855347,
0.04924968257546425,
-0.8692905902862549,
0.897118091583252,
-0.8806077241897583,
0.3175120949745178,
0.0024548720102757215,
0.3010668456554413,
-0.5974648594856262,
-0.4638717770576477,
-0.4192104935646057,
0.19433586299419403,
-0.18249934911727905,
0.201365128159523,
-0.14536169171333313,
0.298074871301651,
0.3149576187133789,
0.3385920226573944,
-0.5356770753860474,
0.4965274930000305,
-0.22717532515525818,
-0.3281523883342743,
0.8114880919456482,
0.10744608938694,
0.17061708867549896,
0.2504340708255768,
-0.6077893972396851,
-0.14997775852680206,
-0.8614915013313293,
0.10381370037794113,
0.14925691485404968,
0.5125608444213867,
-0.375081330537796,
0.35232439637184143,
-0.07904848456382751,
0.88257896900177,
0.4732225239276886,
-0.5212839245796204,
0.15883462131023407,
-0.47915318608283997,
-0.37157052755355835,
0.47937828302383423,
0.8639040589332581,
0.35572129487991333,
0.03671817108988762,
-0.10926036536693573,
-0.17933833599090576,
-0.06812848150730133,
0.40200504660606384,
-0.6282132267951965,
-0.3950899541378021,
0.08016154170036316,
-0.18522809445858002,
-0.5123791694641113,
-0.0059598879888653755,
-1.0536199808120728,
-0.7618759870529175,
-0.3312644958496094,
0.3880663812160492,
-0.3573969602584839,
-0.3073786795139313,
0.16953341662883759,
0.013974619098007679,
0.3379741311073303,
0.17337064445018768,
-1.117116093635559,
0.16074329614639282,
0.6659365296363831,
0.8034026026725769,
-0.3537614345550537,
-0.11774314194917679,
-0.6720943450927734,
0.3786408305168152,
-0.44301629066467285,
0.7221177816390991,
-0.15750539302825928,
-0.4708344042301178,
0.07457602769136429,
0.2384166717529297,
0.06700333207845688,
-0.5069159269332886,
0.6302694082260132,
-0.607191801071167,
0.17636753618717194,
-0.3565272092819214,
-0.5038098692893982,
-0.11190551519393921,
0.27604418992996216,
-0.700700581073761,
0.757880449295044,
0.04474063590168953,
-0.9568621516227722,
0.5642603039741516,
-0.6387637257575989,
-0.5969853401184082,
-0.12260033190250397,
-0.15821082890033722,
-0.5447575449943542,
-0.014645189046859741,
0.4850761294364929,
0.13145075738430023,
-0.05167953670024872,
0.20491182804107666,
-0.5286986231803894,
-0.3318062424659729,
0.10405200719833374,
-0.41472917795181274,
0.9837785363197327,
0.2712661623954773,
-0.37291964888572693,
0.11849339306354523,
-0.894547164440155,
-0.06273331493139267,
-0.08337901532649994,
-0.843341588973999,
-0.28391021490097046,
0.12486668676137924,
-0.3825066089630127,
0.13443101942539215,
0.3425392210483551,
-0.352037250995636,
0.324114590883255,
-0.48707205057144165,
0.23740534484386444,
0.8120335936546326,
0.05393155664205551,
0.7394669651985168,
-0.25468727946281433,
0.6534436941146851,
0.14535771310329437,
0.1104801744222641,
0.09710536152124405,
-0.08134817332029343,
-0.6159748435020447,
-0.6170597076416016,
0.5045648217201233,
0.7967889904975891,
-0.741128146648407,
1.0072702169418335,
-0.24899207055568695,
-0.3153676986694336,
-0.4518602192401886,
0.4154394567012787,
0.44593435525894165,
0.7788384556770325,
0.36031651496887207,
-0.27709823846817017,
-0.6726287007331848,
-0.6853014826774597,
-0.05273301899433136,
-0.2159491777420044,
-0.03176192566752434,
-0.2533067464828491,
-0.04232175648212433,
-0.18871155381202698,
0.8835092186927795,
-0.5103145241737366,
-0.23715457320213318,
-0.11759429425001144,
0.056128088384866714,
0.05556207150220871,
0.5446719527244568,
0.5003025531768799,
-0.26224541664123535,
-0.41788047552108765,
0.18258187174797058,
-0.7363850474357605,
-0.15237672626972198,
-0.018484774976968765,
-0.3279966115951538,
0.3416752517223358,
0.7411393523216248,
-0.5507594347000122,
0.1621670126914978,
0.7579138278961182,
-0.2841617465019226,
0.29986023902893066,
-0.2342674434185028,
0.16854174435138702,
-1.339855432510376,
0.06452696770429611,
-0.16091476380825043,
-0.35164105892181396,
-0.637780487537384,
-0.10541033744812012,
0.2561434805393219,
0.10528537631034851,
-0.5702724456787109,
0.07019712775945663,
-0.5627611875534058,
0.0633973553776741,
-0.26036354899406433,
0.2365814447402954,
0.2859605550765991,
0.1787649691104889,
-0.11053794622421265,
0.8500380516052246,
0.6027920246124268,
-0.7196525931358337,
0.3239380419254303,
0.22654181718826294,
-0.6682441234588623,
0.5728548169136047,
-0.455441951751709,
0.09724180400371552,
-0.06607219576835632,
0.04599643871188164,
-0.9944168925285339,
-0.26394301652908325,
-0.006412798538804054,
0.19723263382911682,
0.7017422318458557,
-0.2707679867744446,
-0.1380387842655182,
0.09159918129444122,
-0.26966410875320435,
0.4927678406238556,
0.6889632344245911,
-0.819775402545929,
0.48764869570732117,
0.46570736169815063,
-0.20115946233272552,
-0.9444297552108765,
-0.6386866569519043,
-0.24790143966674805,
-0.7862080931663513,
-0.4118081033229828,
0.4005816876888275,
0.03135235235095024,
-0.2655889093875885,
-0.21925416588783264,
-0.16597554087638855,
-0.03248831629753113,
0.4445558786392212,
0.048602428287267685,
0.5215051174163818,
-0.2899978756904602,
0.18481270968914032,
0.21103011071681976,
0.02764127030968666,
-0.06552041321992874,
-0.09239444881677628,
0.1856803447008133,
0.1488320231437683,
-0.47945722937583923,
-0.5096222162246704,
0.07780880481004715,
0.7015715837478638,
-0.09344464540481567,
0.67739337682724,
0.4236021637916565,
-0.09763584285974503,
0.007751459255814552,
-0.3534493148326874,
-0.15143944323062897,
-0.5747392773628235,
0.3363915979862213,
0.03524279221892357,
-0.9736778736114502,
0.5085286498069763,
-0.3075762093067169,
0.2702253758907318,
0.18637439608573914,
0.39659979939460754,
-0.2023351788520813,
0.9087311029434204,
0.9227580428123474,
-0.32330766320228577,
0.4963405430316925,
0.24409852921962738,
0.44426676630973816,
-0.5172435641288757,
-0.2004033327102661,
-0.38653430342674255,
-0.5065165758132935,
-0.6581414341926575,
-0.1809452772140503,
0.21973663568496704,
0.6284158825874329,
-0.3580322563648224,
0.44012486934661865,
-0.6782213449478149,
0.6855615377426147,
0.2542988657951355,
0.06596262007951736,
0.45841073989868164,
-0.05920196324586868,
-0.021803805604577065,
-0.16367602348327637,
-0.6720480918884277,
-0.2774529755115509,
1.099951982498169,
0.34304314851760864,
1.1150318384170532,
0.5536274313926697,
0.8711686730384827,
0.25195518136024475,
-0.023908907547593117,
-0.8904438018798828,
0.35448622703552246,
-0.04954518750309944,
-0.4302937686443329,
-0.3357166349887848,
-0.2725164592266083,
-0.8842476606369019,
0.07551775872707367,
-0.41916993260383606,
-0.8040884733200073,
0.3265024423599243,
0.4113490879535675,
-0.8820440769195557,
0.11542428284883499,
-0.8062703013420105,
0.8077672719955444,
-0.4325377941131592,
-0.1798563003540039,
-0.02970617450773716,
-0.4951973855495453,
0.8283716440200806,
-0.3580280840396881,
0.239817813038826,
0.07647785544395447,
0.10778596252202988,
0.6003157496452332,
-0.3448306918144226,
0.7650474905967712,
-0.12046186625957489,
-0.501125693321228,
0.28579390048980713,
0.12702572345733643,
0.6404574513435364,
-0.11085458844900131,
0.10533763468265533,
-0.028165185824036598,
0.11722582578659058,
-0.285573810338974,
-0.7814680933952332,
0.7456989288330078,
-0.6538073420524597,
-0.7979724407196045,
-0.406268835067749,
-0.7269109487533569,
-0.29741171002388,
0.22246530652046204,
0.14793865382671356,
-0.02166038192808628,
-0.39697787165641785,
0.18691378831863403,
1.0533208847045898,
-0.15347836911678314,
0.7982115149497986,
0.6653499603271484,
-0.12898306548595428,
-0.569728434085846,
0.5891657471656799,
-0.20944640040397644,
0.47561129927635193,
0.4128088653087616,
0.026676878333091736,
-0.5910925269126892,
-0.4968872666358948,
-0.3136848509311676,
-0.06455196440219879,
-0.7191210389137268,
-0.5723531246185303,
-0.367061972618103,
-0.21272334456443787,
-0.4265178442001343,
-0.16157656908035278,
-0.5407330989837646,
-0.49484509229660034,
-0.3593142032623291,
-0.3826958239078522,
0.4985552132129669,
0.6634064316749573,
-0.3245895504951477,
0.3897840976715088,
-0.9288433194160461,
0.015452449209988117,
0.45430248975753784,
0.25269603729248047,
-0.40579524636268616,
-0.7073246240615845,
-0.39495405554771423,
0.014830813743174076,
-0.6041474342346191,
-0.7000215649604797,
0.040581829845905304,
0.21045687794685364,
0.5090060234069824,
0.7803339958190918,
0.4675159752368927,
1.0039474964141846,
-0.48295387625694275,
0.6857139468193054,
0.3804280459880829,
-0.8425977826118469,
0.4318629503250122,
-0.12352854013442993,
0.34964117407798767,
0.7662760019302368,
0.22132118046283722,
0.15123064815998077,
-0.07266318798065186,
-0.230804443359375,
-0.6552720665931702,
0.66728276014328,
-0.20707814395427704,
-0.1297636181116104,
0.21630606055259705,
0.11509954929351807,
-0.0598013699054718,
-0.1733877956867218,
-0.5681547522544861,
0.13745568692684174,
0.1439496874809265,
-0.4018765985965729,
-0.09858859330415726,
-0.21624255180358887,
-0.6322188973426819,
-0.3514283001422882,
0.7642236351966858,
-0.19823868572711945,
-0.0464923232793808,
-0.17726373672485352,
-0.15050144493579865,
-0.15573948621749878,
0.44184786081314087,
0.8632361888885498,
0.5793198347091675,
-0.28294637799263,
0.3323323130607605,
0.448489785194397,
-0.4072451889514923,
0.5646893382072449,
0.08180415630340576,
0.044212937355041504,
-0.1816880851984024,
0.33887946605682373,
0.4958707392215729,
0.254647821187973,
-0.5244234204292297,
0.3276810348033905,
-0.07023078948259354,
-0.19698573648929596,
0.07840414345264435,
0.27939876914024353,
0.15789654850959778,
0.4823845326900482,
-0.1583189219236374,
-0.036823127418756485,
-0.15804238617420197,
-0.3177674114704132,
0.333972692489624,
0.6222381591796875,
-0.5176215171813965,
-0.18882858753204346,
0.4003249704837799,
0.3231014013290405,
-0.1360340714454651,
0.360076367855072,
-0.02812221460044384,
-0.16337080299854279,
0.35827985405921936,
0.5591186285018921,
0.8905102014541626,
-0.40077918767929077,
-0.011703422293066978,
0.3376045823097229,
0.37752506136894226,
-0.3098393678665161,
0.08245721459388733,
0.012430869974195957,
-0.7261675596237183,
-0.6479143500328064,
-0.5325139760971069,
-0.12041734904050827,
0.4375266432762146,
-0.8254291415214539,
0.45952045917510986,
-0.5157105326652527,
-0.16725033521652222,
-0.25704726576805115,
-0.2898252308368683,
-0.3892200291156769,
-0.1283251941204071,
-0.06725775450468063,
0.9242115020751953,
-1.110190749168396,
0.9844929575920105,
0.5663848519325256,
-0.1624605655670166,
-0.8402520418167114,
0.299279123544693,
0.22707517445087433,
-0.40392065048217773,
0.3424268960952759,
-0.20515219867229462,
-0.18963800370693207,
-0.038358911871910095,
-0.29698696732521057,
-1.0011305809020996,
1.3767400979995728,
0.8692071437835693,
-0.819507896900177,
0.06987925618886948,
0.15815556049346924,
0.44254881143569946,
-0.2757995128631592,
-0.12952005863189697,
1.053966760635376,
0.2117011547088623,
-0.005857329349964857,
-1.0713330507278442,
0.14367713034152985,
0.22779624164104462,
0.02940971963107586,
0.19704042375087738,
-0.46362394094467163,
0.4385620653629303,
-0.16512683033943176,
-0.43804582953453064,
-0.27669984102249146,
0.5134751200675964,
0.3951774537563324,
-0.09366068989038467,
0.5175044536590576,
0.8733218908309937,
0.8076810836791992,
-0.013608383946120739,
0.5180398225784302,
-0.34451034665107727,
0.2886490225791931,
1.4395196437835693,
-0.380657434463501,
0.6969078779220581,
0.6949453353881836,
-0.17587226629257202,
0.5868004560470581,
0.5466095209121704,
0.39567288756370544,
1.132987380027771,
0.03219513222575188,
-0.48505455255508423,
-0.37762129306793213,
0.08968202024698257,
-0.46564942598342896,
0.5064318776130676,
0.13512474298477173,
-0.3382447063922882,
-0.3832795023918152,
-0.3493448793888092,
0.05167471989989281,
0.12439640611410141,
-0.050985146313905716,
1.3185906410217285,
0.0429823212325573,
-0.8099100589752197,
0.9667699337005615,
-0.22879591584205627,
0.6813782453536987,
-0.3708052337169647,
-0.09356878697872162,
-0.32006704807281494,
0.46928396821022034,
-0.4485339820384979,
-0.6481435894966125,
0.3911949098110199,
-0.04299769178032875,
-0.37955617904663086,
0.06692573428153992,
0.6411482691764832,
-0.5979769825935364,
-0.36336326599121094,
0.30508437752723694,
0.24527491629123688,
-0.31825897097587585,
0.42501041293144226,
-0.5718527436256409,
0.10950082540512085,
0.11455783993005753,
-0.06263505667448044,
0.670030951499939,
0.5231032371520996,
0.08296788483858109,
0.4719981849193573,
0.4449877142906189,
-0.10554305464029312,
0.10740360617637634,
-0.20500344038009644,
1.0633561611175537,
-0.34250155091285706,
-0.3935382664203644,
-1.1342960596084595,
0.887283205986023,
-0.18109458684921265,
0.2058938592672348,
0.5704860687255859,
0.4502958357334137,
0.816631019115448,
-0.10519696772098541,
0.9566136002540588,
0.05964699387550354,
0.3489062488079071,
-0.749485194683075,
0.8298026323318481,
-0.30275022983551025,
0.5575300455093384,
-0.3530585467815399,
-1.0032812356948853,
-0.25873464345932007,
0.5763468742370605,
0.02470434457063675,
-0.36186134815216064,
0.5281506180763245,
1.089188575744629,
-0.4116063714027405,
-0.30626818537712097,
0.4614373743534088,
-0.14245359599590302,
0.47836169600486755,
0.6294179558753967,
0.7505138516426086,
-0.3291356563568115,
0.5929027795791626,
-0.2466195672750473,
-0.4326052963733673,
-0.07842637598514557,
-1.3933826684951782,
-1.0296586751937866,
-0.16119356453418732,
-0.6382014751434326,
-0.4954517185688019,
-0.014336837455630302,
0.7803197503089905,
0.5873587131500244,
-1.148610234260559,
-0.10077635943889618,
-0.24666421115398407,
0.16896727681159973,
-0.3396089971065521,
-0.2174977958202362,
0.2667280435562134,
-0.46701571345329285,
-0.4498582184314728,
0.8289042115211487,
0.3036036193370819,
0.21978279948234558,
-0.2023676037788391,
-0.2917284369468689,
-0.21239414811134338,
0.0452314093708992,
0.4245010018348694,
0.5381814241409302,
-0.5970837473869324,
-0.5055994987487793,
-0.29434794187545776,
-0.06875447928905487,
0.03556179255247116,
0.6152552962303162,
-0.4618310034275055,
0.5361935496330261,
0.5467631816864014,
0.8706446290016174,
-0.060314420610666275,
0.3153320252895355,
0.7769758105278015,
-0.980925440788269,
0.4554583430290222,
-0.06572165340185165,
0.45811113715171814,
0.29012805223464966,
-0.4743722379207611,
0.28880512714385986,
-0.013243461959064007,
-0.7389601469039917,
-0.9445213079452515,
0.4762725234031677,
-0.9899317026138306,
-0.0881766751408577,
1.087458610534668,
-0.4938759207725525,
-0.02001952938735485,
-0.2703530788421631,
-0.13653868436813354,
0.47202515602111816,
-0.2888004183769226,
1.2058396339416504,
0.6060675978660583,
-0.024690061807632446,
-0.25779789686203003,
0.02050590142607689,
0.9328075647354126,
0.3044595718383789,
-0.9858120083808899,
0.27363473176956177,
0.4882340729236603,
0.4264083504676819,
0.28820887207984924,
0.2560495138168335,
-0.16426660120487213,
0.13819757103919983,
-0.30061331391334534,
0.12271255254745483,
0.00838296115398407,
-0.26468607783317566,
-0.697324812412262,
-0.15274333953857422,
0.43685877323150635,
-0.5253249406814575
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.01512v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.01512v1
|
MAD: Multi-Alignment MEG-to-Text Decoding
| 2024-06-03T16:43:10 | 2024-06-03T16:43:10 |
Yiqian Yang, Hyejeong Jo, Yiqun Duan, Qiang Zhang, Jinni Zhou, Won Hee Lee, Renjing Xu, Hui Xiong
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Deciphering language from brain activity is a crucial task in brain-computer
interface (BCI) research. Non-invasive cerebral signaling techniques including
electroencephalography (EEG) and magnetoencephalography (MEG) are becoming
increasingly popular due to their safety and practicality, avoiding invasive
electrode implantation. However, current works under-investigated three points:
1) a predominant focus on EEG with limited exploration of MEG, which provides
superior signal quality; 2) poor performance on unseen text, indicating the
need for models that can better generalize to diverse linguistic contexts; 3)
insufficient integration of information from other modalities, which could
potentially constrain our capacity to comprehensively understand the intricate
dynamics of brain activity.
This study presents a novel approach for translating MEG signals into text
using a speech-decoding framework with multiple alignments. Our method is the
first to introduce an end-to-end multi-alignment framework for totally unseen
text generation directly from MEG signals. We achieve an impressive BLEU-1
score on the $\textit{GWilliams}$ dataset, significantly outperforming the
baseline from 5.49 to 10.44 on the BLEU-1 metric. This improvement demonstrates
the advancement of our model towards real-world applications and underscores
its potential in advancing BCI research. Code is available at
$\href{https://github.com/NeuSpeech/MAD-MEG2text}{https://github.com/NeuSpeech/MAD-MEG2text}$.
|
[
-0.16982683539390564,
-0.9198206067085266,
0.7332685589790344,
0.4250114858150482,
-0.32842254638671875,
-0.06206064671278,
-0.07963617146015167,
-0.47109243273735046,
0.25586551427841187,
0.2190473973751068,
-0.9086976051330566,
-0.7893422842025757,
-0.674579918384552,
0.16528074443340302,
-0.36996567249298096,
0.8685562610626221,
-0.0029556634835898876,
0.17327572405338287,
-0.09497043490409851,
-0.01203290093690157,
-0.7783829569816589,
-0.46217942237854004,
-0.3223218023777008,
-0.2736542522907257,
0.5885674357414246,
0.2201152890920639,
0.35155990719795227,
0.6103505492210388,
0.32114771008491516,
0.13075536489486694,
-0.19820336997509003,
0.6053454875946045,
-0.38145774602890015,
0.050672631710767746,
0.054936040192842484,
-0.13905924558639526,
-0.6071012616157532,
-0.28355541825294495,
0.6536039113998413,
0.5890592336654663,
-0.21478718519210815,
0.044807858765125275,
0.03861900418996811,
0.6804552674293518,
-0.7879887223243713,
0.158957377076149,
-0.5485839247703552,
-0.26520466804504395,
-0.06398174166679382,
-0.09498614072799683,
-0.8444639444351196,
-0.05302093178033829,
0.028915537521243095,
-0.5628848075866699,
-0.17960509657859802,
0.22969163954257965,
1.0884321928024292,
0.038816023617982864,
-0.5848385095596313,
-0.038307271897792816,
-0.46899351477622986,
0.7649247646331787,
-0.6500874757766724,
0.507700502872467,
0.42991355061531067,
-0.02898292802274227,
-0.34760454297065735,
-0.4094434082508087,
-0.7130025029182434,
0.19830793142318726,
-0.10849739611148834,
0.3515129089355469,
-0.37110331654548645,
0.10684126615524292,
-0.07905896008014679,
0.07386520504951477,
-0.632916271686554,
0.09710908681154251,
-0.022545570507645607,
-0.25137439370155334,
0.44649162888526917,
0.20287898182868958,
0.5877773761749268,
0.04727942496538162,
-0.12395358830690384,
-0.24084989726543427,
-0.3686973750591278,
-0.346694678068161,
0.49810782074928284,
0.2610693573951721,
-0.44430533051490784,
0.799164891242981,
-0.01234561949968338,
0.8483479022979736,
-0.005796336103230715,
0.09012288600206375,
0.3790683150291443,
-0.285460501909256,
-0.06831800192594528,
0.24083194136619568,
0.8877184987068176,
0.3770785927772522,
0.012483359314501286,
-0.5114036798477173,
0.04354482889175415,
0.14555050432682037,
0.2266266793012619,
-0.6678920388221741,
-0.19947293400764465,
0.4043181538581848,
-0.4944041073322296,
0.12521401047706604,
-0.15154294669628143,
-1.0011216402053833,
-0.4718957841396332,
-0.3466228246688843,
0.7093403935432434,
-0.6781957745552063,
-0.48291268944740295,
0.4906204342842102,
-0.10584356635808945,
0.3099166750907898,
0.118599072098732,
-0.9100766181945801,
0.13297514617443085,
0.554634153842926,
1.1585243940353394,
-0.4061664044857025,
-0.5059741735458374,
-0.17755012214183807,
0.5574260950088501,
-0.2688426673412323,
0.9302501678466797,
-0.23370762169361115,
-0.3187892436981201,
-0.1541854739189148,
-0.09005136042833328,
-0.3589693605899811,
-0.0061784908175468445,
0.49678725004196167,
-0.4317624866962433,
0.35027140378952026,
-0.13458001613616943,
-0.42347490787506104,
-0.3405066430568695,
0.14586985111236572,
-0.598008930683136,
0.5110987424850464,
-0.3589843809604645,
-0.9646629691123962,
-0.15342046320438385,
-0.9190598726272583,
-0.7115458846092224,
-0.3712763786315918,
0.07109631597995758,
-0.6004460453987122,
0.27182137966156006,
0.3189318776130676,
0.35072118043899536,
-0.17737680673599243,
0.12124686688184738,
-0.31965771317481995,
-0.41310468316078186,
0.3319154679775238,
-0.7571683526039124,
0.74737548828125,
0.04753967002034187,
-0.17991198599338531,
-0.08601294457912445,
-0.936863124370575,
0.24137818813323975,
0.1745993196964264,
-0.07794548571109772,
-0.2694896459579468,
0.25072458386421204,
-0.009570718742907047,
0.227006196975708,
0.4295973479747772,
-0.7175681591033936,
-0.09704030305147171,
-0.40652504563331604,
0.34717127680778503,
0.4213517904281616,
-0.04755645990371704,
0.1769973784685135,
-0.1955924928188324,
-0.06189638376235962,
0.21619512140750885,
-0.1604333072900772,
-0.4551611542701721,
-0.5609668493270874,
-0.5829817652702332,
-0.6671909689903259,
0.30868905782699585,
0.797398567199707,
-0.4091868996620178,
0.46680527925491333,
-0.47506797313690186,
-0.46783438324928284,
-1.0188632011413574,
-0.5211817026138306,
0.2716572880744934,
0.5063030123710632,
0.8672888875007629,
-0.08267732709646225,
-0.547527015209198,
-0.976478636264801,
-0.28844931721687317,
-0.18013685941696167,
0.03784402459859848,
0.14804121851921082,
0.08808577805757523,
-0.5905836224555969,
0.6601987481117249,
-0.7015913128852844,
-0.24136625230312347,
-0.016751078888773918,
0.4723774790763855,
0.20651856064796448,
0.5102405548095703,
-0.101284921169281,
-0.380391001701355,
-0.13724704086780548,
0.4141908884048462,
-0.6340291500091553,
-0.1664542853832245,
-0.20133306086063385,
-0.7070800065994263,
0.24107640981674194,
0.1832539588212967,
-0.7333424687385559,
0.2734602391719818,
0.722439169883728,
-0.46920493245124817,
0.46915000677108765,
-0.32134634256362915,
0.39334335923194885,
-1.0900654792785645,
0.3649088144302368,
-0.03721591830253601,
0.051694564521312714,
-0.864041805267334,
-0.2618545591831207,
0.22775153815746307,
0.14580336213111877,
-0.16988064348697662,
0.18333372473716736,
-0.8090032935142517,
0.2407345473766327,
-0.4655933380126953,
0.16235396265983582,
0.16570621728897095,
0.66916823387146,
0.12323370575904846,
0.6192907094955444,
0.6043409109115601,
-0.6105671525001526,
-0.24473127722740173,
0.45424866676330566,
0.04547518119215965,
0.5294867753982544,
-0.358843594789505,
0.45067891478538513,
-0.43182334303855896,
-0.16084519028663635,
-1.1939575672149658,
-0.060507528483867645,
0.1160307303071022,
-0.7977370023727417,
0.6260032057762146,
-0.021922504529356956,
-0.6193212270736694,
0.07685046643018723,
-0.058863986283540726,
0.40895384550094604,
0.4348710775375366,
-0.4100034534931183,
0.6105324625968933,
0.8003649115562439,
0.02059745043516159,
-0.5807744860649109,
-0.9719287753105164,
0.1372756063938141,
-0.0020608571358025074,
-0.5189658999443054,
0.25908902287483215,
-0.04318700730800629,
0.20247484743595123,
-0.29735714197158813,
-0.34764328598976135,
-0.24678801000118256,
-0.1887269765138626,
0.08079098165035248,
0.43928325176239014,
-0.09313144534826279,
-0.14847125113010406,
0.6625226736068726,
-0.07624253630638123,
0.21669043600559235,
-0.2696777284145355,
0.5481017827987671,
0.23201966285705566,
-0.33957934379577637,
-0.5716953277587891,
0.742385745048523,
0.8351800441741943,
-0.3654957711696625,
0.7652915120124817,
0.7031922936439514,
-0.650874674320221,
0.19764988124370575,
-0.32323065400123596,
0.02088353969156742,
-0.4562208950519562,
0.6259709596633911,
-0.34392330050468445,
-0.6686499714851379,
0.21765898168087006,
-0.29938623309135437,
0.1896233856678009,
0.15347619354724884,
0.6339783668518066,
-0.10365338623523712,
1.71114981174469,
0.6968451142311096,
0.17359113693237305,
0.29267939925193787,
0.08022908866405487,
0.5061831474304199,
-0.9573037624359131,
-0.6567543745040894,
-0.261694997549057,
-0.33474022150039673,
-0.25117287039756775,
-0.03636864572763443,
0.20999707281589508,
0.03514808043837547,
0.06435654312372208,
0.39669716358184814,
-0.7139602899551392,
0.44093549251556396,
0.03984121233224869,
0.33732831478118896,
0.2915523052215576,
0.2523719370365143,
-0.25501781702041626,
-0.23762497305870056,
-0.48802515864372253,
-0.473543643951416,
0.8984917998313904,
0.2637147307395935,
0.5744213461875916,
0.30468547344207764,
0.44140443205833435,
0.02032122202217579,
0.13150697946548462,
-0.7364922761917114,
0.636003851890564,
-0.057161845266819,
-0.37754714488983154,
0.01636594906449318,
-0.35900551080703735,
-1.1574432849884033,
0.5392080545425415,
-0.3818680942058563,
-1.132083535194397,
0.12498413026332855,
0.09456104785203934,
-0.11202745139598846,
0.23640041053295135,
-1.1260817050933838,
0.8753529191017151,
-0.009596938267350197,
-0.418722927570343,
-0.28724655508995056,
-0.6705935001373291,
0.374826043844223,
-0.08538065105676651,
0.2516235411167145,
-0.20034369826316833,
-0.16524627804756165,
0.7412517070770264,
0.12944722175598145,
0.5872176289558411,
0.04328089579939842,
-0.3778451085090637,
0.1720792055130005,
0.263485848903656,
0.2974884808063507,
0.005817791912704706,
0.04913688823580742,
0.6376270651817322,
0.13406866788864136,
-0.27043309807777405,
-0.32281962037086487,
0.7988426089286804,
-0.8256736993789673,
-0.16177824139595032,
-0.36090779304504395,
-0.7985523343086243,
-0.4179201126098633,
0.49557945132255554,
0.31230607628822327,
0.2701687514781952,
-0.006451006978750229,
-0.3972528874874115,
0.8158273696899414,
0.05542594939470291,
0.6217731237411499,
0.44012585282325745,
-0.03388207405805588,
-0.7441874146461487,
1.2407037019729614,
-0.04147351160645485,
0.02161649987101555,
0.7084128856658936,
-0.27021342515945435,
-0.5049754977226257,
-0.6417443156242371,
-0.553054928779602,
0.6039907932281494,
-0.39386194944381714,
-0.23168252408504486,
-1.069865345954895,
0.10660243034362793,
-0.22596269845962524,
0.19616812467575073,
-0.3731706142425537,
-0.09493419528007507,
-0.522555947303772,
0.02488442324101925,
0.11209458112716675,
0.3494895100593567,
-0.012035952880978584,
0.6488712430000305,
-0.9100928902626038,
0.49477720260620117,
-0.07274558395147324,
0.3526720404624939,
-0.0809176117181778,
-0.26391685009002686,
-0.4650605618953705,
0.3156442940235138,
-0.3483078181743622,
-1.4839023351669312,
0.615011990070343,
-0.04566700756549835,
0.34159186482429504,
0.20837323367595673,
-0.12912170588970184,
1.1357166767120361,
-0.8507116436958313,
0.5600090622901917,
0.5081429481506348,
-1.1448270082473755,
0.36029109358787537,
-0.2680633068084717,
0.45557543635368347,
0.5232492685317993,
0.19844023883342743,
-0.5786370038986206,
-0.23358199000358582,
-0.3448293209075928,
-1.0435311794281006,
0.8310570120811462,
0.29140594601631165,
0.02322429232299328,
-0.08609340339899063,
0.18145833909511566,
0.28443586826324463,
0.25816234946250916,
-0.5657812356948853,
-0.5044966340065002,
-0.04737124219536781,
-0.6582591533660889,
0.2378436028957367,
-0.15919291973114014,
-0.0678362175822258,
-0.20796915888786316,
0.5646257996559143,
-0.17098017036914825,
0.9411045908927917,
0.293380469083786,
-0.29206621646881104,
0.0740676075220108,
0.2972995340824127,
0.6153252124786377,
0.31206071376800537,
0.0779060646891594,
0.20665882527828217,
0.34241780638694763,
-0.8358421325683594,
0.1016305685043335,
0.1700599491596222,
0.10447974503040314,
0.24380287528038025,
0.00250835414044559,
0.8276955485343933,
-0.23232437670230865,
-0.6204017996788025,
0.4581228494644165,
-0.20861250162124634,
-0.09518681466579437,
0.06064371392130852,
-0.3399237394332886,
0.031805265694856644,
0.013357256539165974,
0.14865230023860931,
0.17048263549804688,
0.31926730275154114,
-0.008900563232600689,
0.15938600897789001,
0.4738587439060211,
-0.3939207196235657,
-0.6385768055915833,
0.6314386129379272,
-0.09888988733291626,
-0.1957239806652069,
0.49119657278060913,
-0.14421507716178894,
0.02099844068288803,
0.10243017226457596,
1.0685253143310547,
0.9751256108283997,
0.011975702829658985,
-0.00950845330953598,
0.3326355516910553,
0.3292475938796997,
-0.28119784593582153,
0.6127203702926636,
0.11823946982622147,
-0.5634827613830566,
-0.7812209129333496,
-0.3685215711593628,
-0.3127974271774292,
0.12013198435306549,
-0.6401659250259399,
0.5140650272369385,
-0.23380431532859802,
-0.316508024930954,
-0.15145215392112732,
-0.4175228476524353,
-0.2179841697216034,
0.08520086854696274,
0.44513577222824097,
0.5582772493362427,
-0.58245450258255,
0.7109654545783997,
0.8838198184967041,
0.16315366327762604,
-0.4665237069129944,
0.2575031816959381,
-0.1305059939622879,
-0.6943445801734924,
-0.21800324320793152,
0.49537256360054016,
-0.47623732686042786,
0.5112243890762329,
-0.55345219373703,
-0.8602194786071777,
0.9532477855682373,
0.7129510045051575,
-0.4628705084323883,
-0.1580704152584076,
-0.20140522718429565,
0.309526264667511,
-0.09765846282243729,
0.4634201228618622,
0.5854790210723877,
0.605930745601654,
-0.18732716143131256,
-0.6516367793083191,
-0.02679179050028324,
-0.38365107774734497,
-0.16676878929138184,
0.5560241937637329,
-0.5082588791847229,
0.5136727690696716,
-0.29274627566337585,
-0.5957829356193542,
-0.029945921152830124,
1.0549982786178589,
0.3679514229297638,
0.3438786268234253,
0.04685341194272041,
0.5446895956993103,
0.7781338691711426,
-0.1822350174188614,
0.5686866641044617,
-0.33151155710220337,
0.3491958677768707,
0.6599175333976746,
0.034945618361234665,
0.8120700716972351,
0.7453834414482117,
0.07823771238327026,
0.5763739943504333,
0.31754255294799805,
0.23530536890029907,
0.8159881234169006,
0.07901554554700851,
-0.2518165111541748,
-0.3199777901172638,
0.10558971762657166,
-0.011909079737961292,
0.24444784224033356,
0.5069963932037354,
0.16318823397159576,
-0.2056429237127304,
-0.058115873485803604,
0.2791111469268799,
0.04620788246393204,
-0.3088046908378601,
0.702498733997345,
-0.07063982635736465,
-0.5564090013504028,
0.47594138979911804,
0.1821349412202835,
0.8737998008728027,
-0.7287807464599609,
-0.25590649247169495,
0.2445109486579895,
0.052448008209466934,
-0.16125136613845825,
-0.6822757720947266,
0.3185935318470001,
-0.06381242722272873,
-0.25893449783325195,
0.03599795699119568,
0.5589250922203064,
-0.655547022819519,
-0.21534551680088043,
0.326463907957077,
0.6159560680389404,
0.1710883378982544,
0.02047804743051529,
-0.5049691200256348,
0.08602829277515411,
-0.0379134900867939,
-0.030101027339696884,
0.2833692133426666,
0.5394543409347534,
0.09286615997552872,
0.45407551527023315,
0.6438158750534058,
-0.03407950699329376,
0.21474675834178925,
-0.18303662538528442,
0.4947408437728882,
-0.7181253433227539,
-0.6045831441879272,
-1.3301547765731812,
0.726356565952301,
-0.03201451525092125,
-0.35455456376075745,
0.7407557964324951,
0.551298975944519,
0.5527597665786743,
-0.03643769398331642,
0.518497109413147,
0.0831463560461998,
0.22779197990894318,
-0.4892333149909973,
0.9046634435653687,
-0.48565584421157837,
-0.19909411668777466,
-0.46360331773757935,
-0.525026798248291,
-0.5802038311958313,
0.5669843554496765,
0.12377311289310455,
-0.2900831401348114,
0.9944705963134766,
0.7751261591911316,
-0.0027413880452513695,
0.3597915768623352,
0.3851432502269745,
0.06901461631059647,
0.03848922997713089,
0.6856111884117126,
0.6397477984428406,
-0.5662376284599304,
0.6569323539733887,
0.1580178290605545,
-0.22264787554740906,
0.17320552468299866,
-0.7789210081100464,
-0.7448339462280273,
-0.5282909870147705,
-0.5455365777015686,
-0.40437808632850647,
0.012809993699193,
0.6691491007804871,
0.5443286895751953,
-0.6973544359207153,
-0.31073370575904846,
-0.21386975049972534,
0.18108350038528442,
-0.5253072381019592,
-0.12425515055656433,
0.3985293209552765,
-0.20203560590744019,
-0.8550093770027161,
0.5775536298751831,
0.4193228781223297,
0.2741779685020447,
0.23209361732006073,
-0.06344210356473923,
-0.38992631435394287,
0.280118852853775,
0.765354335308075,
0.17946240305900574,
-0.2725553512573242,
-0.09332782030105591,
0.31978338956832886,
-0.21436376869678497,
0.10962586104869843,
0.5447058081626892,
-0.5425020456314087,
0.2454664558172226,
0.5270777344703674,
0.8490472435951233,
0.32663482427597046,
-0.18004828691482544,
0.43668651580810547,
-0.6441260576248169,
-0.1894790679216385,
0.03538224846124649,
0.30729714035987854,
0.21250343322753906,
-0.46769118309020996,
-0.03697080910205841,
0.13516168296337128,
-0.5153967142105103,
-0.9385970234870911,
0.1660863310098648,
-1.5119982957839966,
-0.19431409239768982,
1.3456603288650513,
0.2107037901878357,
-0.5273505449295044,
-0.1837252974510193,
-0.6470184922218323,
0.5444455146789551,
-0.4651883840560913,
0.7408363223075867,
0.8397116661071777,
-0.4424118399620056,
-0.12405946105718613,
-0.2580944001674652,
-0.0920160785317421,
0.6440044045448303,
-0.7952646613121033,
0.2711579501628876,
0.6543679237365723,
-0.0454031340777874,
0.3037644922733307,
0.44719892740249634,
-0.4389607608318329,
0.223664790391922,
-0.03182876855134964,
0.32408496737480164,
-0.19122731685638428,
-0.3261696994304657,
-0.5661768913269043,
0.18622274696826935,
-0.2600957453250885,
-0.7911890149116516
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.06571v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.06571v2
|
SUBLLM: A Novel Efficient Architecture with Token Sequence Subsampling for LLM
| 2024-06-03T16:43:04 | 2024-06-17T09:23:13 |
Quandong Wang, Yuxuan Yuan, Xiaoyu Yang, Ruike Zhang, Kang Zhao, Wei Liu, Jian Luan, Daniel Povey, Bin Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.7
|
While Large Language Models (LLMs) have achieved remarkable success in
various fields, the efficiency of training and inference remains a major
challenge. To address this issue, we propose SUBLLM, short for
Subsampling-Upsampling-Bypass Large Language Model, an innovative architecture
that extends the core decoder-only framework by incorporating subsampling,
upsampling, and bypass modules. The subsampling modules are responsible for
shortening the sequence, while the upsampling modules restore the sequence
length, and the bypass modules enhance convergence. In comparison to LLaMA, the
proposed SUBLLM exhibits significant enhancements in both training and
inference speeds as well as memory usage, while maintaining competitive
few-shot performance. During training, SUBLLM increases speeds by 26% and cuts
memory by 10GB per GPU. In inference, it boosts speeds by up to 37% and reduces
memory by 1GB per GPU. The training and inference speeds can be enhanced by 34%
and 52% respectively when the context window is expanded to 8192. We shall
release the source code of the proposed architecture in the published version.
|
[
-0.3824787139892578,
-0.7971013784408569,
0.1427530199289322,
0.09159527719020844,
-0.6631197929382324,
0.27644890546798706,
-0.18781910836696625,
-0.24405060708522797,
0.2536904215812683,
0.41922450065612793,
-0.337846577167511,
-0.5305683612823486,
-0.5525052547454834,
-0.09453049302101135,
-0.5429593920707703,
0.5225103497505188,
0.5007485151290894,
0.06017870083451271,
-0.26683855056762695,
-0.04017854854464531,
-0.36161452531814575,
-0.6306016445159912,
-0.7134880423545837,
-0.5343010425567627,
0.22341200709342957,
0.2809777557849884,
0.5853756666183472,
0.8444744348526001,
0.2497183382511139,
0.31573572754859924,
-0.3430536687374115,
0.1202155202627182,
-0.5929182171821594,
-0.27149441838264465,
-0.06977387517690659,
-0.4849246144294739,
-0.7238747477531433,
-0.3858279883861542,
0.9176627397537231,
0.6231807470321655,
-0.1213328167796135,
0.15093527734279633,
-0.06436959654092789,
0.7749111652374268,
-0.5909402370452881,
0.05184892937541008,
-0.8473396897315979,
0.03714155778288841,
-0.3601486384868622,
-0.2507208585739136,
-0.5264585018157959,
0.13645829260349274,
-0.2529414892196655,
-0.31099167466163635,
0.1032218337059021,
0.19671925902366638,
0.42144227027893066,
0.3400895893573761,
0.023328982293605804,
0.18182283639907837,
-0.24584996700286865,
0.7856230139732361,
-0.9934273958206177,
0.49557748436927795,
0.07180598378181458,
0.11391256004571915,
-0.15306356549263,
-0.707929790019989,
-0.4916081130504608,
-0.0537017285823822,
-0.04279767721891403,
0.02743264101445675,
-0.3746357560157776,
0.23316538333892822,
0.16587969660758972,
0.4903082847595215,
-0.6191442608833313,
0.3708392381668091,
-0.336748331785202,
-0.11524844169616699,
0.4953397512435913,
0.31351688504219055,
0.19955740869045258,
0.14116324484348297,
-0.5644730925559998,
0.49119481444358826,
-1.0713932514190674,
-0.3562787175178528,
0.32469049096107483,
0.25661879777908325,
-0.044687457382678986,
0.4352181851863861,
-0.1391661912202835,
0.5875978469848633,
-0.16090042889118195,
-0.1508483588695526,
0.0642690509557724,
-0.21201059222221375,
-0.6586945652961731,
0.20169495046138763,
0.5284133553504944,
0.19555504620075226,
-0.048162028193473816,
-0.08195614814758301,
-0.16095705330371857,
-0.12099401652812958,
0.04447733238339424,
-0.7751213312149048,
-0.1795705258846283,
0.2948366701602936,
-0.5254530906677246,
0.042620375752449036,
-0.08405614644289017,
-0.8434494733810425,
-0.17927202582359314,
-0.18063920736312866,
0.1638302356004715,
-0.32997944951057434,
-0.2552877962589264,
0.2842637598514557,
0.1179887130856514,
0.45443716645240784,
0.3092826008796692,
-0.8430761098861694,
0.5684745907783508,
0.9534139037132263,
0.8911030292510986,
-0.5153285264968872,
-0.25998374819755554,
-0.6452627778053284,
0.02857302315533161,
-0.28235724568367004,
0.5823019742965698,
-0.5977082252502441,
-0.4913276433944702,
-0.32694774866104126,
-0.27428826689720154,
0.06778126209974289,
-0.7357853055000305,
0.15003418922424316,
-0.8036671876907349,
-0.2884427011013031,
0.1909225732088089,
-0.726104199886322,
-0.20415620505809784,
0.1853840947151184,
-0.7981226444244385,
1.065482258796692,
-0.04447230324149132,
-0.6834134459495544,
0.05986304208636284,
-0.5409671068191528,
-0.506830632686615,
0.42092233896255493,
0.02430468052625656,
-0.24197892844676971,
0.2367449849843979,
0.2766340672969818,
0.211777463555336,
-0.655872106552124,
0.1170245110988617,
-0.023372774943709373,
-0.8704491853713989,
0.03523487225174904,
-0.3483613431453705,
0.5938543081283569,
0.37313899397850037,
-0.19024881720542908,
0.23724211752414703,
-0.5815854072570801,
-0.11361366510391235,
-0.1649697721004486,
-0.7952188849449158,
-0.3123621940612793,
-0.3288514018058777,
0.040142759680747986,
-0.15579889714717865,
0.37063756585121155,
-0.49087101221084595,
0.2870159447193146,
-0.3128204345703125,
0.4490620493888855,
0.7858132719993591,
-0.40462160110473633,
0.4782738983631134,
-0.16811220347881317,
0.6687583923339844,
0.1077488511800766,
0.07673351466655731,
-0.49395686388015747,
-0.41399750113487244,
-0.8509081602096558,
-0.823889970779419,
0.6032437682151794,
0.6398460865020752,
-0.4681225121021271,
0.4183975160121918,
-0.3474598526954651,
-0.27475428581237793,
-0.5742443799972534,
0.2855350971221924,
0.6188795566558838,
0.47081416845321655,
0.6665946245193481,
-0.4194827675819397,
-0.9984927177429199,
-0.7717382907867432,
-0.22911038994789124,
-0.14514198899269104,
0.23677180707454681,
0.01322707999497652,
0.44631609320640564,
-0.27224448323249817,
0.9154984951019287,
-0.20906990766525269,
-0.16699129343032837,
-0.8971228003501892,
-0.08960782736539841,
0.3705718517303467,
0.669219970703125,
0.2595396339893341,
-0.5617620348930359,
-0.1535210907459259,
-0.29031577706336975,
-0.36716148257255554,
-0.34474316239356995,
-0.03587627038359642,
-0.04670174419879913,
0.3932037353515625,
0.7263966202735901,
-0.8200198411941528,
0.432695597410202,
0.39551958441734314,
0.08848904818296432,
0.5412617921829224,
-0.18169187009334564,
-0.22069929540157318,
-1.1766507625579834,
-0.0074324216693639755,
-0.46951645612716675,
-0.33140861988067627,
-0.38911035656929016,
0.24449610710144043,
-0.05591626092791557,
0.09761342406272888,
-0.7394576668739319,
0.6824387311935425,
-0.6497650146484375,
-0.3311653435230255,
-0.47036755084991455,
-0.2667408287525177,
-0.16540732979774475,
0.4277040362358093,
0.0583314411342144,
0.8754077553749084,
0.5831735134124756,
-0.5402408838272095,
0.33473634719848633,
-0.08570963144302368,
-0.3994966745376587,
0.18244342505931854,
-0.5687420964241028,
0.21935825049877167,
-0.1578744649887085,
0.33148089051246643,
-0.8968269228935242,
0.0037722387351095676,
-0.21527211368083954,
-0.28975802659988403,
0.448659211397171,
-0.11106538772583008,
-0.2610839903354645,
-0.14761868119239807,
-0.44150859117507935,
0.5255489349365234,
0.8819304704666138,
-0.6414942741394043,
0.8205680251121521,
0.5611881017684937,
0.0865863710641861,
-0.8673399090766907,
-0.9826871156692505,
0.3637367784976959,
-0.3142547905445099,
-0.1183396428823471,
0.28093835711479187,
0.03417549282312393,
-0.09441350400447845,
0.12867113947868347,
0.029263313859701157,
0.2823614776134491,
0.04265405237674713,
0.1593688428401947,
0.2034708708524704,
-0.3076098561286926,
-0.04910995438694954,
0.19615969061851501,
-0.33476537466049194,
-0.3242350220680237,
-0.48943719267845154,
0.8698046207427979,
-0.1453428864479065,
-0.33364659547805786,
-0.4529363214969635,
0.5752176642417908,
0.5310262441635132,
-0.15207016468048096,
0.5679294466972351,
0.33595865964889526,
-0.4713369309902191,
-0.3651810884475708,
-0.5377005338668823,
0.037439897656440735,
-0.4126986563205719,
0.7117104530334473,
-0.49894464015960693,
-1.1838834285736084,
0.44349682331085205,
-0.3344232439994812,
-0.03598787635564804,
0.12890389561653137,
0.8179147839546204,
0.31316274404525757,
0.6751254796981812,
0.5770193338394165,
-0.4344891607761383,
0.3257352411746979,
-0.2817126214504242,
0.13160695135593414,
-0.92938631772995,
-0.13886834681034088,
-0.22549933195114136,
-0.41286325454711914,
0.014343907125294209,
-0.902895450592041,
0.04251730814576149,
0.4189505875110626,
-0.1980241984128952,
0.40049904584884644,
-0.07198292016983032,
0.7868053913116455,
0.6657798886299133,
-0.08231202512979507,
0.6463187336921692,
0.00781478825956583,
-0.39238283038139343,
0.13696372509002686,
-0.9684035181999207,
-0.4722893536090851,
0.9056884050369263,
0.3792577087879181,
1.3584824800491333,
0.06578125804662704,
0.6225566267967224,
0.5626997351646423,
0.5035898685455322,
-0.9123515486717224,
0.9756378531455994,
-0.1610376089811325,
-0.4776596128940582,
-0.11423911154270172,
-0.3407410979270935,
-0.606377363204956,
0.315416544675827,
0.028681019321084023,
-0.5608725547790527,
-0.12311233580112457,
0.2711855471134186,
-0.25406956672668457,
0.5731220841407776,
-0.47341182827949524,
0.5481406450271606,
-0.007258896715939045,
-0.16624219715595245,
-0.27742984890937805,
-0.6505207419395447,
0.6011571884155273,
-0.150229811668396,
0.05897114425897598,
-0.06241082027554512,
-0.3650985658168793,
0.496002197265625,
-0.5978512167930603,
0.9674467444419861,
-0.038664475083351135,
0.08585723489522934,
0.3571844696998596,
0.06644893437623978,
0.2702585756778717,
0.08121537417173386,
-0.22536657750606537,
0.3543757200241089,
-0.32731935381889343,
-0.5006476044654846,
-0.45509088039398193,
0.6496456861495972,
-0.4866815507411957,
-0.6632646322250366,
-0.23420119285583496,
-0.7909114956855774,
-0.11395493894815445,
0.21282903850078583,
0.19663676619529724,
0.5030202269554138,
-0.1597142219543457,
0.3380122780799866,
0.5973159074783325,
-0.2535489797592163,
0.5914714336395264,
0.5263171792030334,
-0.2710922062397003,
-0.45739245414733887,
0.5342596173286438,
-0.07931695133447647,
0.3056056797504425,
0.8266075253486633,
0.06207254156470299,
-0.7229198813438416,
-1.0447607040405273,
-0.6492763161659241,
0.18576249480247498,
-0.7793574333190918,
-0.3569365441799164,
-0.5924103260040283,
-0.22180263698101044,
-0.5083296895027161,
-0.0031220740638673306,
-0.5069016218185425,
-0.3341573178768158,
-0.16088756918907166,
-0.3950388729572296,
0.27061107754707336,
0.35484579205513,
-0.1203819066286087,
0.3251534402370453,
-0.8173143267631531,
0.08822815865278244,
0.33719387650489807,
-0.0493064746260643,
0.24577797949314117,
-0.7196807265281677,
-0.2841469347476959,
-0.40823251008987427,
0.11460328102111816,
-0.38868191838264465,
0.3666207790374756,
0.45550352334976196,
0.5897076725959778,
0.31466299295425415,
0.041109271347522736,
1.0319749116897583,
-0.5779316425323486,
0.7326353192329407,
0.13509519398212433,
-1.0996143817901611,
0.11922847479581833,
0.11739728599786758,
0.5117785334587097,
0.4290615916252136,
0.15814243257045746,
-0.36135005950927734,
-0.2816769480705261,
-0.13758836686611176,
-0.8785443305969238,
0.5271010398864746,
-0.08924960345029831,
0.37672001123428345,
-0.2535696029663086,
0.39479517936706543,
0.1734246164560318,
0.18244414031505585,
-0.39189833402633667,
-0.26186057925224304,
-0.06285103410482407,
-0.35068634152412415,
-0.009812046773731709,
-0.42960986495018005,
0.0006112602422945201,
-0.34484320878982544,
0.6410388350486755,
-0.2827170193195343,
0.263312429189682,
0.18475812673568726,
-0.424076110124588,
0.14704391360282898,
0.4593692719936371,
0.5515304207801819,
0.6378473043441772,
0.041083406656980515,
0.587520182132721,
0.6736117601394653,
-0.6320483684539795,
0.09868317097425461,
-0.10723650455474854,
-0.2813996970653534,
-0.09862478822469711,
0.5525362491607666,
0.8650668859481812,
0.22664198279380798,
-1.0518580675125122,
0.26950210332870483,
0.0593930147588253,
-0.033872805535793304,
0.010251602157950401,
0.10643446445465088,
0.3724048435688019,
0.44197607040405273,
0.6463221907615662,
-0.34325477480888367,
-0.02912338450551033,
-0.5570351481437683,
0.39878180623054504,
0.47834882140159607,
-0.2842269837856293,
-0.23940874636173248,
0.8115032911300659,
0.09832143038511276,
-0.27149301767349243,
0.4887010157108307,
0.05035797879099846,
-0.5569714903831482,
0.5714607834815979,
0.8835383653640747,
0.7441794872283936,
-0.06353941559791565,
-0.23695072531700134,
0.178373783826828,
0.42941388487815857,
-0.09083868563175201,
0.4370558261871338,
-0.16774563491344452,
-0.6557329893112183,
-0.6948830485343933,
-1.142380714416504,
-0.3794676959514618,
0.380383163690567,
-0.43965283036231995,
0.029389003291726112,
-0.5218038558959961,
0.1283792108297348,
-0.6698200702667236,
-0.2687019407749176,
-0.07678691297769547,
0.2616701126098633,
0.1786961555480957,
1.5234386920928955,
-0.4163539707660675,
1.387266993522644,
0.6537602543830872,
0.0599181093275547,
-0.6485611796379089,
-0.2727200388908386,
-0.025577370077371597,
-0.9335395097732544,
0.5616943836212158,
0.21872931718826294,
-0.4606083333492279,
0.3531426787376404,
-0.24867206811904907,
-0.47263386845588684,
1.1404246091842651,
0.5580811500549316,
-0.6685231328010559,
0.08550170063972473,
0.25203898549079895,
0.4017246663570404,
-0.7368829250335693,
0.042447809129953384,
0.8114778399467468,
0.21476998925209045,
0.24430684745311737,
-0.6619481444358826,
0.29751232266426086,
-0.3077104389667511,
0.36122554540634155,
0.20781025290489197,
-0.7025889754295349,
0.8953202366828918,
-0.3489806056022644,
-0.09161221235990524,
0.6246848702430725,
0.8926314115524292,
0.3318476676940918,
0.023139871656894684,
0.47916921973228455,
1.0326991081237793,
0.4101529121398926,
-0.041169870644807816,
0.7639272212982178,
-0.33662867546081543,
0.4449801743030548,
1.1524802446365356,
-0.21661391854286194,
0.8781274557113647,
0.6080679297447205,
-0.09677357226610184,
0.2834094762802124,
0.6386687159538269,
0.396293967962265,
0.5573883652687073,
0.3556095063686371,
-0.519008219242096,
-0.5374523401260376,
-0.0583101324737072,
-0.46596822142601013,
0.4838922917842865,
0.4314926266670227,
-0.37566888332366943,
-0.326745867729187,
-0.20376922190189362,
0.03777463361620903,
-0.1977519392967224,
-0.5821753144264221,
0.5805540680885315,
0.22106872498989105,
-0.5073709487915039,
0.5660650730133057,
0.184956893324852,
0.944956362247467,
-0.6693947315216064,
0.021216420456767082,
-0.6378129720687866,
0.2843431234359741,
-0.18116794526576996,
-0.3500518202781677,
0.37491774559020996,
0.04259408265352249,
0.16033117473125458,
-0.15377338230609894,
0.8017330765724182,
-0.5391595959663391,
-0.2814546525478363,
0.2968185842037201,
0.4869195222854614,
0.37437036633491516,
0.022728851065039635,
-0.7357691526412964,
0.38493257761001587,
-0.4553931951522827,
-0.2830788493156433,
0.437700480222702,
0.0654204934835434,
-0.04265729337930679,
0.5557540059089661,
0.8317316174507141,
0.03585834056138992,
0.4046674966812134,
0.25399255752563477,
1.0158348083496094,
-0.8202674388885498,
-0.4890735447406769,
-1.230947494506836,
0.30075380206108093,
0.14738281071186066,
-0.15899021923542023,
0.7595266699790955,
0.9661272764205933,
0.8317055702209473,
-0.19715076684951782,
0.5907917022705078,
0.040756966918706894,
0.24241261184215546,
-0.7591688632965088,
0.4647739827632904,
-0.5637861490249634,
0.5124530792236328,
-0.03154382482171059,
-0.7404423952102661,
-0.49250712990760803,
0.30612513422966003,
-0.009966372512280941,
-0.038455672562122345,
0.5736196041107178,
0.9579719305038452,
-0.20320448279380798,
-0.08670243620872498,
0.4860771596431732,
0.1984548717737198,
0.1445060819387436,
0.8067363500595093,
0.7749003767967224,
-0.24544762074947357,
0.517009437084198,
0.013930389657616615,
-0.3077217638492584,
-0.4028540849685669,
-0.9696512818336487,
-1.0578060150146484,
-0.045742906630039215,
-0.029442235827445984,
-0.06942971795797348,
-0.020313026383519173,
0.8879797458648682,
0.937779426574707,
-0.7338382601737976,
-0.251990407705307,
-0.30921006202697754,
0.22768916189670563,
-0.21009886264801025,
-0.17643645405769348,
0.3222810924053192,
-0.17326346039772034,
-1.0200674533843994,
0.6173164248466492,
0.8104979991912842,
-0.13102644681930542,
-0.4501911699771881,
-0.2669129967689514,
-0.3322725296020508,
0.2825085520744324,
0.7146927714347839,
0.3392503261566162,
-0.755419909954071,
-0.01502941269427538,
-0.040622420608997345,
-0.0021574851125478745,
0.12414627522230148,
1.0667749643325806,
-0.8394442200660706,
0.19426049292087555,
0.7147485017776489,
1.098572850227356,
0.5117588043212891,
0.2170344889163971,
0.29681873321533203,
-0.6012260913848877,
0.4116889238357544,
0.0992463231086731,
0.5719490051269531,
0.23999282717704773,
-0.24231263995170593,
0.4288792312145233,
0.485859751701355,
-0.11172129958868027,
-0.93636155128479,
0.39882397651672363,
-0.9267730116844177,
-0.37635529041290283,
0.9143766164779663,
-0.3339492380619049,
-0.5605207085609436,
-0.3144252598285675,
-0.2818036377429962,
0.17658725380897522,
-0.2906739115715027,
0.5463122725486755,
0.44726210832595825,
-0.3770335912704468,
-0.4702495336532593,
-0.13854356110095978,
0.21284119784832,
0.530585765838623,
-0.8568515777587891,
0.010318190790712833,
0.20128832757472992,
0.2348490059375763,
-0.17072831094264984,
0.9806202054023743,
-0.33714646100997925,
0.26989129185676575,
0.031818538904190063,
-0.062072012573480606,
-0.5128452777862549,
-0.49555039405822754,
-0.37800413370132446,
0.3294751048088074,
-0.13877493143081665,
-0.21337434649467468
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.01506v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.01506v1
|
The Geometry of Categorical and Hierarchical Concepts in Large Language Models
| 2024-06-03T16:34:01 | 2024-06-03T16:34:01 |
Kiho Park, Yo Joong Choe, Yibo Jiang, Victor Veitch
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, stat.ML
|
Understanding how semantic meaning is encoded in the representation spaces of
large language models is a fundamental problem in interpretability. In this
paper, we study the two foundational questions in this area. First, how are
categorical concepts, such as {'mammal', 'bird', 'reptile', 'fish'},
represented? Second, how are hierarchical relations between concepts encoded?
For example, how is the fact that 'dog' is a kind of 'mammal' encoded? We show
how to extend the linear representation hypothesis to answer these questions.
We find a remarkably simple structure: simple categorical concepts are
represented as simplices, hierarchically related concepts are orthogonal in a
sense we make precise, and (in consequence) complex concepts are represented as
polytopes constructed from direct sums of simplices, reflecting the
hierarchical structure. We validate these theoretical results on the Gemma
large language model, estimating representations for 957 hierarchically related
concepts using data from WordNet.
|
[
-0.29863572120666504,
-0.7382484078407288,
0.6781229972839355,
0.20882844924926758,
-0.09254137426614761,
-0.07822183519601822,
-0.17831085622310638,
-0.6377533674240112,
0.2328425645828247,
0.3308705985546112,
-0.4723030626773834,
-0.3672252595424652,
-0.6725126504898071,
-0.010008038952946663,
-0.32351845502853394,
0.6580584049224854,
0.07110833376646042,
0.029547305777668953,
-0.24226294457912445,
-0.391154408454895,
-0.37035083770751953,
-0.8815917372703552,
-0.2225765734910965,
-0.4337199330329895,
0.5629912614822388,
-0.17359799146652222,
1.4246915578842163,
1.1353892087936401,
0.7164674997329712,
0.32069796323776245,
-0.4430740475654602,
0.07814560830593109,
-0.2948002219200134,
-0.012279851362109184,
-0.4075097143650055,
-0.7934482097625732,
-0.3006884753704071,
0.008419466204941273,
0.6690765619277954,
1.3885716199874878,
-0.09878361970186234,
0.07587636262178421,
0.08784382045269012,
0.3781375288963318,
-0.4779103100299835,
0.6322548985481262,
-0.5539912581443787,
0.09302698075771332,
-0.20352311432361603,
-0.5141089558601379,
-0.3873707056045532,
-0.11671934276819229,
0.04925808683037758,
-1.0307345390319824,
-0.0524614155292511,
0.3280496597290039,
1.0201082229614258,
0.0952700600028038,
-0.5250146985054016,
-0.7331365346908569,
-0.6016337275505066,
0.8452050089836121,
-0.188786581158638,
0.46189630031585693,
0.45393532514572144,
0.11924365162849426,
-0.47282424569129944,
-0.6472314596176147,
-0.44263607263565063,
-0.38509872555732727,
-0.37655869126319885,
-0.11990359425544739,
-0.3902510404586792,
0.09346248209476471,
0.3883262574672699,
0.6318196058273315,
-0.5853633284568787,
0.12479995936155319,
-0.1415061205625534,
-0.13587209582328796,
0.5027326345443726,
0.22726856172084808,
0.6812769770622253,
-0.3836667835712433,
-0.4062615633010864,
-0.1904812455177307,
-0.695906937122345,
0.09732789546251297,
0.13007652759552002,
0.4164466857910156,
-0.1303815394639969,
0.8892233371734619,
0.15123358368873596,
0.44810751080513,
-0.15205621719360352,
-0.1004098579287529,
0.1713009774684906,
-0.29003074765205383,
-0.16729363799095154,
-0.20143283903598785,
0.4214061498641968,
-0.057253945618867874,
0.4574402868747711,
-0.16213837265968323,
0.019804803654551506,
0.21675217151641846,
0.16356413066387177,
-0.3859725296497345,
-0.17439332604408264,
0.23084577918052673,
-0.56746906042099,
-0.15815035998821259,
0.19669334590435028,
-0.18702369928359985,
-0.15682122111320496,
-0.461053729057312,
0.4822879433631897,
-0.3497268855571747,
-0.43594494462013245,
0.700722873210907,
-0.1066524013876915,
0.4728698432445526,
0.2699466645717621,
-1.1003715991973877,
0.6077237725257874,
1.0806386470794678,
0.44095081090927124,
0.2632124722003937,
-0.37508392333984375,
-0.06275518238544464,
0.31049051880836487,
-0.563618004322052,
0.5910835266113281,
-0.8000326156616211,
-0.05895258113741875,
-0.018804259598255157,
0.13627587258815765,
0.032227467745542526,
-0.41527611017227173,
0.12116845697164536,
-0.405055433511734,
0.04333493113517761,
-0.3572337031364441,
-0.717545747756958,
-0.27736830711364746,
0.2991192638874054,
-0.7601417899131775,
0.6999079585075378,
-0.19975954294204712,
-0.9551715850830078,
0.18670454621315002,
-0.33410367369651794,
0.05009407922625542,
0.00768576143309474,
-0.5074993968009949,
0.24727031588554382,
0.2937997877597809,
0.06214739382266998,
0.46278974413871765,
-0.47732865810394287,
0.21461935341358185,
-0.38537973165512085,
-0.0878387987613678,
0.33885324001312256,
-0.02545582689344883,
0.6962592601776123,
0.047335781157016754,
-0.02091795951128006,
-0.2624587416648865,
-0.5532186627388,
0.04180892929434776,
0.21896663308143616,
-0.10391152650117874,
-0.6915764212608337,
0.3549814224243164,
-0.060805562883615494,
-0.02150052785873413,
0.30327820777893066,
-0.5406394600868225,
0.3964729607105255,
-0.07289621978998184,
0.3142964839935303,
0.3637838065624237,
-0.2276797741651535,
0.49802833795547485,
-0.017839612439274788,
0.3702316880226135,
0.1032782793045044,
-0.07299560308456421,
0.12341415882110596,
-0.4922385811805725,
-0.6212807297706604,
-0.023958630859851837,
0.2985023558139801,
0.2919127941131592,
-0.7472246289253235,
0.2975870668888092,
-0.42084816098213196,
-0.1312905251979828,
-0.05140795558691025,
-0.19448551535606384,
0.3011613190174103,
-0.1276649683713913,
0.024303648620843887,
-0.09583935886621475,
-0.34606096148490906,
-1.0377840995788574,
0.03074951469898224,
-0.41003286838531494,
-0.03917064890265465,
0.10024628043174744,
0.7773287296295166,
-0.18088898062705994,
0.6725864410400391,
-0.7720383405685425,
-0.010866397060453892,
-0.017290310934185982,
0.26374807953834534,
0.15731048583984375,
0.5161457657814026,
0.5907957553863525,
-0.800172746181488,
0.19694826006889343,
0.226167231798172,
-1.003436803817749,
0.333580881357193,
-0.01610744185745716,
-0.22567534446716309,
-0.45598453283309937,
0.4725712239742279,
-0.785719633102417,
0.45092687010765076,
0.38590899109840393,
-0.4172283709049225,
0.41544482111930847,
-0.21949325501918793,
-0.2715808153152466,
-0.8311225175857544,
-0.07792287319898605,
-0.3058589696884155,
-0.051172081381082535,
-0.6013638377189636,
0.4823739230632782,
-0.09506965428590775,
-0.11556588113307953,
-0.08692625164985657,
0.34446465969085693,
-0.3594566881656647,
-0.4844694435596466,
-0.09256414324045181,
0.041282352060079575,
0.13524794578552246,
0.4489213824272156,
0.5101015567779541,
0.41925880312919617,
0.7309242486953735,
-0.5464741587638855,
0.09072832018136978,
0.3865034878253937,
-0.18144360184669495,
0.4056081771850586,
-0.7863090634346008,
-0.22317861020565033,
-0.5175356268882751,
0.4846937954425812,
-0.9048476219177246,
-0.1872633695602417,
0.005696876440197229,
-0.47636961936950684,
-0.03837859258055687,
0.06821238994598389,
-0.7803032398223877,
-0.1381606012582779,
-0.04933730140328407,
0.7762936949729919,
0.3482602536678314,
-0.43127167224884033,
0.24237070977687836,
0.5272011160850525,
0.013974273577332497,
-0.5931441783905029,
-0.731938898563385,
-0.0029076437931507826,
-0.11382471024990082,
-0.614503026008606,
0.10604052990674973,
0.27985480427742004,
-0.5434442758560181,
0.21509017050266266,
-0.05361979082226753,
-0.29962655901908875,
-0.04377629980444908,
0.12689000368118286,
0.1357877105474472,
-0.710437536239624,
0.6181614995002747,
-0.3151347041130066,
-0.060048677027225494,
0.25176170468330383,
-0.4912979304790497,
0.5147671103477478,
-0.13623307645320892,
-0.27315399050712585,
-0.29093313217163086,
0.4198256731033325,
0.8079490065574646,
-0.09307684004306793,
0.7547353506088257,
0.3021920919418335,
-0.7885197401046753,
-0.17210786044597626,
-0.017376964911818504,
0.12785913050174713,
-0.3564687669277191,
0.3372606635093689,
-0.6889576315879822,
-0.7093725204467773,
0.685994029045105,
-0.013059351593255997,
-0.04280448704957962,
0.5817892551422119,
0.31717628240585327,
-0.24120259284973145,
0.9355835914611816,
0.8203023672103882,
0.19968698918819427,
-0.049303341656923294,
-0.5083833336830139,
0.05568413808941841,
-0.7635501027107239,
-0.5990551114082336,
-0.8164265155792236,
0.01532113179564476,
-0.7544787526130676,
-0.7515293955802917,
0.10621902346611023,
0.2877832055091858,
-0.447103887796402,
0.3779815137386322,
-0.15494240820407867,
0.384304016828537,
0.12759087979793549,
-0.04649565741419792,
0.35431942343711853,
0.1343768686056137,
-0.15982119739055634,
-0.20556439459323883,
-0.6350242495536804,
-0.6049299240112305,
0.551472008228302,
0.860578715801239,
0.8996393084526062,
0.3242459297180176,
0.2093840092420578,
-0.06900604814291,
-0.18712040781974792,
-1.1050562858581543,
0.22506079077720642,
-0.3737562298774719,
-0.8077498078346252,
-0.23356083035469055,
-0.2887095510959625,
-1.0210657119750977,
0.6128929257392883,
-0.05575079843401909,
-0.9211577773094177,
0.6820118427276611,
-0.1177850291132927,
0.003968663513660431,
0.5011432766914368,
-0.23592224717140198,
0.5847136974334717,
-0.03959101065993309,
0.10501717776060104,
-0.31407469511032104,
-0.36106187105178833,
0.46645936369895935,
0.011770054697990417,
0.3267226815223694,
-0.0628807470202446,
-0.2920849025249481,
0.6211090087890625,
-0.7578040957450867,
0.7841220498085022,
0.19589325785636902,
-0.3042498826980591,
0.2660827338695526,
0.3513462245464325,
0.19525146484375,
-0.10765961557626724,
0.0009137353044934571,
0.1376633644104004,
0.4344598650932312,
-0.7606266140937805,
-0.8802687525749207,
0.06808294355869293,
-0.95589679479599,
-0.5353047847747803,
-0.4650081992149353,
-1.0024473667144775,
-0.36228713393211365,
-0.0918036550283432,
0.1597563624382019,
0.9650558829307556,
0.042068954557180405,
0.5992634296417236,
0.6087142825126648,
-0.4998355805873871,
-0.07497783750295639,
-0.03476444259285927,
-0.6803226470947266,
0.016191110014915466,
0.5477488040924072,
0.00400363327935338,
0.492116779088974,
0.7690043449401855,
0.20481930673122406,
-0.5096703171730042,
-0.3814665675163269,
-0.18856973946094513,
0.38101431727409363,
-0.8429177403450012,
0.17632223665714264,
-0.41474649310112,
-0.38661327958106995,
0.3327904939651489,
0.007334549445658922,
-0.21252313256263733,
-0.4273042678833008,
0.031132834032177925,
-0.03436567261815071,
0.341520220041275,
1.3370206356048584,
0.06953674554824829,
0.3988502323627472,
-0.4852178692817688,
0.4455346167087555,
0.331755667924881,
0.16307751834392548,
0.30127841234207153,
-0.45473530888557434,
0.015792159363627434,
0.18730129301548004,
0.1626814901828766,
-0.6608949303627014,
0.007120160385966301,
0.18056005239486694,
0.4389092028141022,
0.35273119807243347,
-0.20310401916503906,
1.0287196636199951,
-0.476183146238327,
0.5897369980812073,
0.3479093015193939,
-0.9555678367614746,
0.23372748494148254,
-0.5601514577865601,
0.048773977905511856,
0.07883944362401962,
0.5723124146461487,
-0.5410345196723938,
-0.4025469720363617,
-0.5161066055297852,
-0.36610791087150574,
0.4763495624065399,
0.5408435463905334,
0.4418218731880188,
-0.08497738838195801,
0.28434085845947266,
0.16298027336597443,
-0.023565417155623436,
-0.8166334629058838,
-0.3095548152923584,
-0.23203539848327637,
-0.09909097850322723,
-0.22270295023918152,
-0.38824915885925293,
0.10597975552082062,
-0.30829861760139465,
-0.08476037532091141,
0.14395742118358612,
0.42153218388557434,
0.03624993935227394,
-0.20530173182487488,
0.08275599032640457,
0.19170841574668884,
0.4044445753097534,
0.9384627938270569,
-0.20786310732364655,
0.47753313183784485,
-0.21831397712230682,
-0.5975766181945801,
0.19955453276634216,
-0.378154456615448,
0.27329280972480774,
0.12930282950401306,
0.9692680239677429,
0.7006059885025024,
0.4467765986919403,
-0.3242855370044708,
0.29737478494644165,
0.10810798406600952,
-0.10057888180017471,
-0.23852239549160004,
-0.29514962434768677,
0.4389190673828125,
0.044993285089731216,
0.38975560665130615,
-0.3305916488170624,
0.06633314490318298,
-1.1439083814620972,
0.12262237071990967,
0.3050493001937866,
-0.26389172673225403,
-0.4262879192829132,
0.24319137632846832,
-0.2764551043510437,
0.12666310369968414,
0.4470324218273163,
0.05539603903889656,
-0.4900398552417755,
0.9195762872695923,
0.7544500231742859,
0.3332691788673401,
0.02122785896062851,
0.4582700729370117,
0.4315868616104126,
0.213918536901474,
0.12114153802394867,
0.2975243031978607,
0.041424576193094254,
-0.8733388781547546,
-0.31931740045547485,
-0.9190398454666138,
-0.22232839465141296,
0.12977805733680725,
-1.0705589056015015,
-0.14146941900253296,
-0.3656858205795288,
0.21461571753025055,
0.7137974500656128,
-0.20905251801013947,
-0.37785327434539795,
0.21209979057312012,
0.4058751165866852,
1.0347638130187988,
-0.8597110509872437,
0.8339511752128601,
0.8498401045799255,
-0.5464670658111572,
-1.2844215631484985,
-0.020273689180612564,
-0.11012984067201614,
-1.0348283052444458,
1.2136013507843018,
-0.06465626507997513,
-0.19298122823238373,
-0.22891555726528168,
-0.5924374461174011,
-1.1555367708206177,
0.8291904926300049,
0.20340180397033691,
-0.44516775012016296,
-0.09707381576299667,
0.6379401087760925,
0.7673280835151672,
-0.5956676602363586,
-0.0021279093343764544,
0.3779437839984894,
0.3305063545703888,
0.42596831917762756,
-0.9202452301979065,
-0.019534245133399963,
-0.2272556573152542,
0.28526854515075684,
0.11736007779836655,
-0.08636924624443054,
1.1781007051467896,
0.10337311774492264,
-0.3344823122024536,
0.2505727708339691,
0.46449074149131775,
0.22448565065860748,
-0.25122126936912537,
0.4498021900653839,
0.4180346429347992,
0.7743909358978271,
-0.09939919412136078,
1.330004096031189,
-0.05885031819343567,
0.6030466556549072,
0.591459333896637,
0.20074352622032166,
0.912019670009613,
0.31596624851226807,
-0.35803624987602234,
0.6506953239440918,
0.7758356332778931,
0.24076446890830994,
0.2984932065010071,
0.5266096591949463,
0.09876848012208939,
-0.4033893346786499,
-0.4250224828720093,
-0.4877176284790039,
0.6433677077293396,
0.9329201579093933,
-0.2215125411748886,
-0.4980626106262207,
-0.026425249874591827,
0.051812898367643356,
-0.02827438898384571,
-0.6731606721878052,
0.6747539043426514,
0.359096497297287,
-0.35525837540626526,
0.9100592136383057,
-0.2124636322259903,
0.19123966991901398,
-0.540044367313385,
-0.08981314301490784,
-0.03562468662858009,
0.20943212509155273,
-0.3145180344581604,
-1.119700312614441,
0.2160235494375229,
-0.27061185240745544,
-0.2909144163131714,
0.06279689073562622,
0.3688651919364929,
-0.4941618740558624,
-0.5682485103607178,
0.43980512022972107,
0.5324366688728333,
0.505038857460022,
0.21992897987365723,
-0.6251993775367737,
0.28014054894447327,
-0.2946965992450714,
0.20724840462207794,
-0.08391658216714859,
0.7475319504737854,
-0.3733912408351898,
0.6632702350616455,
0.4083182215690613,
0.2351914942264557,
0.1303601861000061,
-0.01765511929988861,
0.670879602432251,
-0.8149689435958862,
-0.45774590969085693,
-0.6357877254486084,
0.3474479615688324,
0.3465476632118225,
-0.11976855993270874,
0.42306268215179443,
0.11565539240837097,
0.6008515954017639,
-0.1733642965555191,
0.2814253270626068,
-0.10110965371131897,
-0.0651371031999588,
-0.6099408864974976,
0.2936353385448456,
-0.6241002082824707,
0.026840630918741226,
-0.3171539902687073,
-0.9684666991233826,
-0.3855781555175781,
0.6525118350982666,
-0.575366735458374,
-0.3271518349647522,
1.1661429405212402,
0.46860137581825256,
-0.4164254069328308,
-0.022252829745411873,
0.43695902824401855,
0.2637401819229126,
-0.03467989340424538,
0.5892033576965332,
1.35185968875885,
-0.3608384132385254,
0.2827053964138031,
-0.04779069125652313,
0.0315263532102108,
0.14751818776130676,
-0.41485556960105896,
-0.6718921661376953,
-0.749531090259552,
-0.09464751183986664,
-0.16284780204296112,
-0.007420049514621496,
0.733936607837677,
0.7398916482925415,
-0.6915751695632935,
-0.44218242168426514,
0.052152495831251144,
0.09188432991504669,
0.08543415367603302,
-0.11204029619693756,
0.7657711505889893,
-0.4095119535923004,
-0.5641230344772339,
-0.3997347950935364,
0.372884601354599,
-0.038330890238285065,
-0.36761149764060974,
-0.08680984377861023,
-0.024890566244721413,
0.1251412183046341,
0.8486045002937317,
0.18296298384666443,
-1.0667532682418823,
-0.6845858097076416,
-0.08093912899494171,
-0.34649741649627686,
0.11085555702447891,
0.7561354041099548,
-0.4983210563659668,
0.1841493546962738,
0.38529402017593384,
0.5789481997489929,
0.16328319907188416,
0.21737398207187653,
0.5765858292579651,
-0.45165103673934937,
0.5152309536933899,
0.03818054869771004,
0.5311606526374817,
0.11570395529270172,
-0.2731323540210724,
0.3309597074985504,
0.07649170607328415,
0.02363475039601326,
-0.5659744143486023,
0.631451427936554,
-1.071846604347229,
-0.5037826895713806,
0.9716342091560364,
-0.28894954919815063,
-0.4125522971153259,
-0.24546034634113312,
0.0034825350157916546,
-0.30774107575416565,
0.30227068066596985,
0.2255115658044815,
0.7435184121131897,
-0.09475906193256378,
-0.059593237936496735,
-0.7207925915718079,
0.345123827457428,
0.23989780247211456,
-0.6104133725166321,
0.01114930585026741,
0.4666609764099121,
0.26673460006713867,
0.6490968465805054,
0.20888710021972656,
-0.4105658531188965,
0.28020110726356506,
0.25479570031166077,
0.12969091534614563,
0.31325018405914307,
-0.27067849040031433,
-0.248997762799263,
0.23096337914466858,
0.2534525990486145,
-0.35883766412734985
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.01495v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.01495v1
|
Reflection-Reinforced Self-Training for Language Agents
| 2024-06-03T16:21:38 | 2024-06-03T16:21:38 |
Zi-Yi Dou, Cheng-Fu Yang, Xueqing Wu, Kai-Wei Chang, Nanyun Peng
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Self-training can potentially improve the performance of language agents
without relying on demonstrations from humans or stronger models. The general
process involves generating samples from a model, evaluating their quality, and
updating the model by training on high-quality samples. However, self-training
can face limitations because achieving good performance requires a good amount
of high-quality samples, yet relying solely on model sampling for obtaining
such samples can be inefficient. In addition, these methods often disregard
low-quality samples, failing to leverage them effectively. To address these
limitations, we present Reflection-Reinforced Self-Training (Re-ReST), which
leverages a reflection model to refine low-quality samples and subsequently
uses these improved samples to augment self-training. The reflection model
takes both the model output and feedback from an external environment (e.g.,
unit test results in code generation) as inputs and produces improved samples
as outputs. By employing this technique, we effectively enhance the quality of
inferior samples, and enrich the self-training dataset with higher-quality
samples efficiently. We perform extensive experiments on open-source language
agents across tasks, including multi-hop question answering, sequential
decision-making, code generation, visual question answering, and text-to-image
generation. Results demonstrate improvements over self-training baselines
across settings. Moreover, ablation studies confirm the reflection model's
efficiency in generating quality self-training samples and its compatibility
with self-consistency decoding.
|
[
-0.34804344177246094,
-0.3976275622844696,
0.23166531324386597,
0.25378233194351196,
-0.1340135931968689,
0.3180236518383026,
-0.2544092535972595,
-0.45728567242622375,
0.4891142249107361,
0.8092913627624512,
-0.3244451582431793,
-0.1795581728219986,
-0.37840551137924194,
0.3583914339542389,
-0.4356236755847931,
0.937118411064148,
-0.07407942414283752,
0.2307339757680893,
-0.04838903248310089,
-0.12138445675373077,
-0.3618355393409729,
-0.1958080232143402,
-0.5152250528335571,
-0.4143771231174469,
0.30811965465545654,
0.48095181584358215,
0.3502565026283264,
0.529895007610321,
0.23485732078552246,
0.3656790554523468,
0.8116471171379089,
0.29762670397758484,
-0.5763004422187805,
0.4738157093524933,
-0.3080868422985077,
-0.14349722862243652,
-0.29652291536331177,
0.2991056740283966,
0.8121955990791321,
0.3273315131664276,
-0.32110995054244995,
0.25223809480667114,
0.3102049231529236,
0.5543608665466309,
-0.6439224481582642,
0.05620795115828514,
-0.40353861451148987,
-0.1641654074192047,
0.28444454073905945,
-0.49191707372665405,
-0.562515139579773,
-0.2610301375389099,
-0.2781429588794708,
-0.3226901888847351,
0.5610672235488892,
-0.20840643346309662,
0.7907998561859131,
0.4633406102657318,
-0.12321867048740387,
-0.01203383132815361,
-0.8176621198654175,
0.6763786673545837,
-0.7586933970451355,
0.70454341173172,
0.38989248871803284,
0.3545498847961426,
-0.25294098258018494,
-0.5743603706359863,
-0.34834593534469604,
-0.37530753016471863,
-0.06562650203704834,
0.21692483127117157,
0.3354814350605011,
0.13866810500621796,
-0.1219969242811203,
0.3097694516181946,
-0.3951245844364166,
-0.2970086336135864,
-0.18330077826976776,
-0.1321922242641449,
0.5756045579910278,
0.07140529155731201,
0.33437201380729675,
0.16774730384349823,
-0.2175905853509903,
-0.6211193799972534,
-0.6382755637168884,
-0.0538058876991272,
0.2463175654411316,
0.7622700929641724,
0.32225683331489563,
0.24368426203727722,
-0.3801030218601227,
0.5614932775497437,
0.08804278075695038,
-0.25468161702156067,
0.3336430490016937,
-0.3462597727775574,
0.026300935074687004,
-0.12759271264076233,
0.6758579611778259,
-0.008785370737314224,
-0.00042751681758090854,
-0.3231063485145569,
-0.5872195363044739,
-0.32300975918769836,
0.6146942973136902,
-0.9248409867286682,
-0.17375624179840088,
0.13872450590133667,
-0.4622160494327545,
-0.2325114607810974,
0.04881545156240463,
-0.5979689359664917,
-0.011237181723117828,
-0.2664961814880371,
0.6097534894943237,
-0.32240867614746094,
-0.49659207463264465,
0.1707434356212616,
-0.047948211431503296,
0.21750274300575256,
0.3818093538284302,
-0.8944072127342224,
0.47321486473083496,
0.32235366106033325,
0.6559509038925171,
0.1103699803352356,
-0.7627404928207397,
-0.6194861531257629,
0.08444667607545853,
-0.4091683626174927,
0.9770209789276123,
-0.3490854501724243,
-0.2708829343318939,
0.07749591767787933,
0.04719046130776405,
0.11228225380182266,
-0.57527756690979,
0.03741874545812607,
-0.2575286626815796,
0.15054607391357422,
-0.27022960782051086,
-0.28293702006340027,
0.09358157217502594,
0.4037109911441803,
-0.6231469511985779,
1.2019966840744019,
0.5404224395751953,
-0.31137946248054504,
0.3456181287765503,
-0.168538436293602,
-0.40839430689811707,
0.012469930574297905,
-0.3821020722389221,
-0.4407747685909271,
0.1509951800107956,
0.08846406638622284,
0.3198791444301605,
-0.13953538239002228,
-0.29052940011024475,
-0.21796008944511414,
-0.33428695797920227,
0.14247052371501923,
-0.2611731290817261,
0.2610424757003784,
0.1994190514087677,
-0.5223755836486816,
-0.2880888283252716,
-0.9102736711502075,
0.3000945448875427,
0.15564456582069397,
-0.6090176701545715,
-0.27918094396591187,
-0.10302672535181046,
-0.15494953095912933,
0.2737695276737213,
0.14669527113437653,
-0.784476101398468,
0.28908953070640564,
-0.603298008441925,
-0.020245354622602463,
0.6466505527496338,
-0.011976775713264942,
0.30750012397766113,
-0.302205890417099,
0.5226702094078064,
-0.3065279424190521,
0.11830133199691772,
-0.13247783482074738,
0.12093240022659302,
-0.8371767401695251,
-0.2945314645767212,
0.17931154370307922,
0.27213138341903687,
-1.0551754236221313,
0.13352569937705994,
-0.16523639857769012,
-0.3919258117675781,
-1.008988857269287,
0.4832559823989868,
0.772952675819397,
0.5278757810592651,
0.6235818266868591,
-0.7812671065330505,
-0.612349271774292,
-0.633487343788147,
-0.3143499493598938,
-0.15115900337696075,
0.23538747429847717,
0.03145578131079674,
0.5136563181877136,
-0.04728717356920242,
1.186002492904663,
-0.25356483459472656,
-0.3044230341911316,
-0.35564956068992615,
0.3190883994102478,
-0.17277339100837708,
0.6557191014289856,
0.3242344558238983,
-0.18239712715148926,
-0.5409319996833801,
-0.3612454831600189,
-0.5563396215438843,
-0.18295587599277496,
-0.17403846979141235,
-0.03212039917707443,
0.35087478160858154,
0.4192675054073334,
-0.16734828054904938,
0.1286020576953888,
0.6651185750961304,
-0.21912577748298645,
0.6513743996620178,
-0.5040102005004883,
0.3283122777938843,
-0.9112157225608826,
-0.1503419131040573,
-0.1998201459646225,
-0.613360583782196,
-0.7966745495796204,
0.059396326541900635,
-0.0763871818780899,
0.16061687469482422,
-0.24021980166435242,
0.7494376301765442,
-0.7739750146865845,
-0.2612479031085968,
-0.9639500975608826,
-0.04356895014643669,
0.19458512961864471,
0.4013063907623291,
0.22316987812519073,
1.066532015800476,
0.24993126094341278,
-0.5385084748268127,
0.1643882840871811,
0.16093730926513672,
-0.13887113332748413,
0.381962388753891,
-0.5893701314926147,
0.4098464846611023,
-0.1204124316573143,
0.22591452300548553,
-1.136684775352478,
0.07040902227163315,
0.3358290493488312,
-0.4847606122493744,
0.4234224259853363,
-0.13529251515865326,
-0.3341803550720215,
-0.1828015297651291,
-0.2873934805393219,
0.32692649960517883,
0.543648362159729,
-0.9162626266479492,
0.7812385559082031,
-0.01091016735881567,
0.2957628667354584,
-0.9764471054077148,
-0.8029129505157471,
-0.025485165417194366,
0.3317231237888336,
-0.42730584740638733,
-0.0021577735897153616,
0.08309890329837799,
0.03390524163842201,
0.07413623481988907,
0.05375159531831741,
0.10875123739242554,
0.03259630501270294,
0.1169007420539856,
-0.25910526514053345,
-0.07287213951349258,
0.1962035447359085,
-0.15718916058540344,
-0.21455956995487213,
-0.02590853162109852,
-0.3687881827354431,
0.672335684299469,
-0.33309370279312134,
-0.5689100623130798,
-0.2212984710931778,
0.1392417550086975,
0.07367607951164246,
-0.41257935762405396,
0.7992421984672546,
0.4137059450149536,
0.0403018556535244,
-0.6678716540336609,
-0.8878943920135498,
-0.66236412525177,
-0.5361416935920715,
0.21012388169765472,
-0.4852798581123352,
-0.7691153287887573,
0.3550688326358795,
0.16472169756889343,
0.10589943081140518,
-0.032692283391952515,
0.43086734414100647,
-0.22012917697429657,
1.082087755203247,
0.5340024828910828,
-0.030050357803702354,
0.7072703838348389,
-0.3295450806617737,
0.05543961003422737,
-0.7440081834793091,
0.05658690631389618,
-0.3888018727302551,
0.0301702618598938,
-0.43214550614356995,
-0.38697105646133423,
-0.0759628638625145,
-0.3885461986064911,
-0.2410273402929306,
0.4785388112068176,
-0.764899492263794,
0.26076698303222656,
0.7863227128982544,
0.25795823335647583,
0.3856479823589325,
-0.05815017968416214,
0.3399750888347626,
0.257842093706131,
-0.4355860650539398,
-0.5587217211723328,
1.0307567119598389,
0.3969354033470154,
1.2904173135757446,
-0.14427241683006287,
1.184656023979187,
0.4307234287261963,
0.4580609202384949,
-0.32343611121177673,
0.49470794200897217,
0.12456846237182617,
-0.4748789072036743,
-0.4857449531555176,
-0.527886152267456,
-1.0192962884902954,
0.4575989246368408,
0.09760415554046631,
-0.010782487690448761,
0.2641964852809906,
0.6049515008926392,
-0.14898495376110077,
0.1629789024591446,
-0.5849546194076538,
0.7068184018135071,
-0.3206294775009155,
-0.4174939692020416,
-0.23445653915405273,
-0.33244338631629944,
0.1709814965724945,
0.32855767011642456,
0.037294697016477585,
-0.08405567705631256,
0.17116977274417877,
0.3727337121963501,
-0.5239419341087341,
1.0014979839324951,
-0.4656029939651489,
-0.33909502625465393,
0.6271513104438782,
0.3917047679424286,
0.47096675634384155,
-0.17635463178157806,
0.26855185627937317,
-0.1638326495885849,
0.09429074823856354,
-0.5905418992042542,
-0.9558214545249939,
0.21556921303272247,
-0.9189078211784363,
-0.6516200304031372,
-0.27847397327423096,
-0.22136230766773224,
-0.2718525528907776,
-0.0031118516344577074,
0.024536363780498505,
0.5540883541107178,
-0.18539221584796906,
-0.12147011607885361,
0.42906099557876587,
-0.060126662254333496,
0.17118757963180542,
0.879235029220581,
-0.18564963340759277,
-0.664432942867279,
1.2889336347579956,
0.1017441675066948,
0.5860710144042969,
0.15826304256916046,
0.11919683963060379,
-0.3768220841884613,
-0.4514845907688141,
-0.2594800293445587,
0.5118235349655151,
-0.8073583841323853,
-0.24946242570877075,
-0.2980290949344635,
-0.19706518948078156,
-0.8251676559448242,
0.12277403473854065,
-0.9346520900726318,
-0.24668215215206146,
-0.01588575541973114,
0.010624275542795658,
0.004060786683112383,
0.6773494482040405,
-0.3299688398838043,
0.3182375133037567,
-0.7218047380447388,
0.12389770150184631,
0.46908894181251526,
0.582266628742218,
0.006088929250836372,
-0.6789360642433167,
-0.624106228351593,
0.139475017786026,
-0.16019964218139648,
-0.7304052710533142,
0.4209612011909485,
0.3034696578979492,
0.5920343995094299,
0.2651757001876831,
-0.01725621148943901,
0.46907150745391846,
-0.5466396808624268,
0.554182767868042,
-0.04208111763000488,
-0.6843999028205872,
0.5958014726638794,
-0.15479175746440887,
0.07075688242912292,
1.0063952207565308,
-0.10302892327308655,
-0.5072158575057983,
-0.798160970211029,
-0.45421743392944336,
-0.4718829393386841,
0.57423996925354,
-0.01471550390124321,
0.25493359565734863,
-0.24903619289398193,
0.6432271003723145,
0.09750261902809143,
0.25292783975601196,
-0.9132121205329895,
-0.04836772009730339,
-0.9382601976394653,
-0.31427818536758423,
-0.17871594429016113,
-0.13450457155704498,
-0.22586345672607422,
-0.051860760897397995,
0.9206240773200989,
-0.5054709911346436,
0.347552090883255,
0.6509801149368286,
-0.3960733711719513,
-0.15011577308177948,
0.165891632437706,
0.5542855858802795,
0.3481793701648712,
-0.23875555396080017,
0.5124598145484924,
0.23015280067920685,
-0.4401390850543976,
0.5480336546897888,
-0.23142197728157043,
-0.08168038725852966,
-0.1230984702706337,
0.32195040583610535,
0.47214969992637634,
-0.08075808733701706,
-0.707318902015686,
0.5148362517356873,
-0.0967339277267456,
-0.12731920182704926,
-0.4406708776950836,
0.2646788954734802,
-0.46986448764801025,
0.322476863861084,
0.20631657540798187,
-0.46919363737106323,
0.23432937264442444,
-0.6788275837898254,
0.2937650978565216,
0.5580258965492249,
-0.2344064563512802,
-0.3697466552257538,
0.29695773124694824,
0.25606584548950195,
-0.393381267786026,
0.6800438761711121,
-0.3462579846382141,
-0.4835362732410431,
0.29894036054611206,
0.8517572283744812,
0.9238682985305786,
-0.6276606917381287,
0.4363585412502289,
0.5100924968719482,
0.3861953616142273,
-0.4362257421016693,
0.4395418167114258,
-0.18874511122703552,
-0.9779217839241028,
-0.5635256171226501,
-0.45298266410827637,
-0.5928393006324768,
-0.08650430291891098,
-0.532774031162262,
-0.07205623388290405,
-0.424028217792511,
-0.0172775536775589,
-0.9409610629081726,
0.07566650956869125,
-0.3599732518196106,
0.43002191185951233,
-0.04439307376742363,
0.758384644985199,
-0.8570278286933899,
0.7953945398330688,
0.46134841442108154,
-0.8891156315803528,
-0.8860896825790405,
-0.2356477528810501,
-0.4761251211166382,
-1.0274689197540283,
0.5705137848854065,
0.07836342602968216,
-0.6454364657402039,
0.0671132504940033,
-0.6931899785995483,
-1.0973081588745117,
0.887070894241333,
0.5029999017715454,
-0.14162470400333405,
0.04679189994931221,
0.3723858892917633,
0.8259872794151306,
-0.4659516513347626,
0.5262120366096497,
0.5126699209213257,
0.22443872690200806,
-0.09451494365930557,
-0.5857723355293274,
0.31670165061950684,
-0.22671179473400116,
0.058928605169057846,
0.03704269230365753,
-0.9077215194702148,
0.6439614295959473,
0.10095495730638504,
-0.24932226538658142,
0.06327691674232483,
0.9766872525215149,
0.1679450422525406,
-0.04526853933930397,
0.6338018774986267,
0.4934641718864441,
0.31825879216194153,
0.033232636749744415,
0.9126722812652588,
-0.6396987438201904,
0.3999897837638855,
1.5866203308105469,
-0.23866665363311768,
0.771922767162323,
0.401413232088089,
0.21810588240623474,
0.7822544574737549,
0.3137716054916382,
-0.1726442575454712,
0.553557813167572,
-0.02905263565480709,
-0.1622537523508072,
-0.4722084403038025,
-0.03982168808579445,
-0.2963273525238037,
0.4759383797645569,
-0.15215812623500824,
-0.31137388944625854,
-0.2461739331483841,
0.2725924551486969,
-0.3927997648715973,
0.3818618953227997,
0.07783880829811096,
0.8014124631881714,
-0.07790113985538483,
-0.9094228148460388,
0.7140081524848938,
-0.2483697235584259,
0.33457711338996887,
-0.4167110323905945,
-0.28946468234062195,
-0.4829854667186737,
0.27698761224746704,
-0.12767484784126282,
-0.6370095610618591,
0.13250763714313507,
-0.32122066617012024,
0.1189974844455719,
-0.7025977373123169,
0.780683696269989,
-0.611519992351532,
-0.022539081051945686,
0.4977046847343445,
0.6096495389938354,
0.33445239067077637,
-0.10443735122680664,
-0.5053822994232178,
-0.14476001262664795,
-0.2885708212852478,
-0.43928563594818115,
0.36435186862945557,
0.13559465110301971,
0.595394492149353,
0.8113979697227478,
0.3578362464904785,
0.22139403223991394,
0.08093741536140442,
0.41446956992149353,
0.7888259291648865,
-0.5513750314712524,
-0.18999707698822021,
-0.6805363297462463,
0.3265010714530945,
0.0029316102154552937,
-0.15228939056396484,
0.7842493057250977,
0.5372464656829834,
0.9312632083892822,
-0.04369204863905907,
0.7278274893760681,
0.20501460134983063,
0.9092527031898499,
-0.4044458568096161,
0.5191940069198608,
-0.7147876620292664,
-0.04684298112988472,
-0.22686073184013367,
-0.6737743020057678,
0.22642192244529724,
0.7682667374610901,
-0.055617183446884155,
0.36669251322746277,
0.4155040979385376,
0.9602043032646179,
0.09491776674985886,
-0.42087239027023315,
0.3988473117351532,
0.09704747051000595,
0.6681418418884277,
0.1871623694896698,
1.1268250942230225,
-0.38505294919013977,
0.6422175168991089,
-0.40005916357040405,
0.0007980638765729964,
-0.14384832978248596,
-0.4598776400089264,
-0.9933359622955322,
-0.8167209625244141,
-0.13557741045951843,
-0.7448863983154297,
0.10324566811323166,
1.163641095161438,
0.8302801251411438,
-0.6129541993141174,
-0.4329402446746826,
-0.11727306991815567,
-0.17124854028224945,
-0.37806499004364014,
-0.17693106830120087,
0.04442518949508667,
-1.0673798322677612,
-0.6000513434410095,
0.6405984163284302,
0.0029846499674022198,
0.277722030878067,
-0.7532909512519836,
-0.3036942780017853,
0.015052209608256817,
0.1908401995897293,
0.4238562285900116,
0.6987792253494263,
-0.46302053332328796,
-0.7030565738677979,
0.011472289450466633,
-0.38780513405799866,
0.4218812882900238,
0.8147960901260376,
-0.8367756605148315,
0.4614456295967102,
0.24734243750572205,
0.8163368701934814,
0.49972596764564514,
0.3776516020298004,
0.5611498355865479,
-0.9054865837097168,
-0.11105182021856308,
0.20398001372814178,
0.2800714075565338,
0.4261167049407959,
-0.26566699147224426,
0.6234222650527954,
0.011170786805450916,
-0.7194483876228333,
-0.9188031554222107,
0.18048368394374847,
-0.5697216391563416,
-0.3104945421218872,
1.0620849132537842,
-0.07585428655147552,
-0.3878789246082306,
-0.07986313104629517,
-0.2265794277191162,
0.3432837426662445,
-0.43398815393447876,
1.235106110572815,
0.4789382517337799,
-0.3123227655887604,
-0.47066912055015564,
-0.18261094391345978,
0.6653446555137634,
0.5361747741699219,
-0.9978840351104736,
0.16676326096057892,
0.31979718804359436,
0.6084650754928589,
0.19617041945457458,
1.1092203855514526,
0.20052194595336914,
0.29755058884620667,
0.12728148698806763,
0.7872734069824219,
-0.1446199119091034,
-0.584354817867279,
-0.35541024804115295,
0.014843834564089775,
0.5105690360069275,
-0.23848769068717957
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.01468v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.01468v1
|
Understanding Token Probability Encoding in Output Embeddings
| 2024-06-03T15:57:29 | 2024-06-03T15:57:29 |
Hakaze Cho, Yoshihiro Sakai, Kenshiro Tanaka, Mariko Kato, Naoya Inoue
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
In this paper, we investigate the output token probability information in the
output embedding of language models. We provide an approximate common
log-linear encoding of output token probabilities within the output embedding
vectors and demonstrate that it is accurate and sparse when the output space is
large and output logits are concentrated. Based on such findings, we edit the
encoding in output embedding to modify the output probability distribution
accurately. Moreover, the sparsity we find in output probability encoding
suggests that a large number of dimensions in the output embedding do not
contribute to causal language modeling. Therefore, we attempt to delete the
output-unrelated dimensions and find more than 30% of the dimensions can be
deleted without significant movement in output distribution and degeneration on
sequence generation. Additionally, in training dynamics, we use such encoding
as a probe and find that the output embeddings capture token frequency
information in early steps, even before an obvious convergence starts.
|
[
-0.017705677077174187,
-0.591968297958374,
0.3879307508468628,
-0.11087032407522202,
-0.4241618514060974,
-0.3008785545825958,
-0.33771684765815735,
-0.11560153216123581,
0.43811944127082825,
0.15207019448280334,
-0.312845379114151,
-0.379476934671402,
-0.895289421081543,
-0.42020168900489807,
-0.5740412473678589,
0.9760100245475769,
0.15998390316963196,
0.4252937138080597,
-0.12967878580093384,
-0.006025625392794609,
-0.5480656027793884,
-1.118452548980713,
-0.8748296499252319,
-0.043540891259908676,
0.3315214514732361,
0.016612233594059944,
0.4833075702190399,
0.9307613372802734,
0.3150041997432709,
0.21892693638801575,
-0.07292726635932922,
-0.33031386137008667,
-0.8688566088676453,
-0.1361726075410843,
0.08177565038204193,
-0.4944804012775421,
-0.240174800157547,
-0.0462215319275856,
1.0677989721298218,
0.9440457224845886,
-0.17587722837924957,
0.08122611790895462,
0.26970374584198,
0.23935334384441376,
-0.6029719710350037,
0.41637057065963745,
-0.7958760261535645,
0.31027668714523315,
-0.18345865607261658,
-0.43048951029777527,
-0.8661682605743408,
-0.07100320607423782,
-0.5034089684486389,
-0.2890409529209137,
0.28320205211639404,
0.11726363003253937,
0.4571727216243744,
0.1062551885843277,
-0.5740854144096375,
-0.30846500396728516,
-1.0034350156784058,
0.7464451193809509,
-0.5734664797782898,
0.5457378029823303,
0.48086386919021606,
0.04526383429765701,
-0.27648672461509705,
-0.6114190816879272,
-0.5690484642982483,
0.1280072182416916,
-0.0855150818824768,
-0.1492154449224472,
-0.22857007384300232,
0.33382466435432434,
0.1769137978553772,
0.29214200377464294,
-0.46288001537323,
0.2202371060848236,
-0.22141070663928986,
-0.36345070600509644,
0.45740145444869995,
0.1776631623506546,
0.18013575673103333,
-0.16201640665531158,
-0.1759161353111267,
-0.23610518872737885,
-0.5806445479393005,
-0.03904318809509277,
0.3842965066432953,
0.3349674940109253,
-0.11620359122753143,
0.7744336128234863,
0.3733190894126892,
0.5043508410453796,
-0.05482364073395729,
-0.020138993859291077,
0.13481460511684418,
-0.44107210636138916,
-0.290030300617218,
0.08524664491415024,
0.6206467747688293,
0.15114319324493408,
0.19408108294010162,
-0.21115994453430176,
-0.21412165462970734,
-0.21950218081474304,
0.25807633996009827,
-0.4492497742176056,
0.045634008944034576,
0.2637038230895996,
-0.5816823244094849,
-0.16434751451015472,
0.3537842035293579,
-0.3397022485733032,
-0.13138224184513092,
-0.10937336087226868,
0.4577484726905823,
-0.5013259053230286,
-0.18129511177539825,
0.2167280614376068,
-0.33834898471832275,
0.02384960651397705,
0.025768298655748367,
-1.147064208984375,
0.5009779334068298,
0.8925238847732544,
0.5453153252601624,
0.06695125997066498,
-0.17872756719589233,
-1.1048928499221802,
0.31363922357559204,
-0.2927466332912445,
0.07335210591554642,
-0.5259101390838623,
-0.04769770801067352,
0.32094287872314453,
0.01530320756137371,
-0.10430503636598587,
-0.06556113064289093,
0.3136419355869293,
-0.6141480803489685,
-0.19374915957450867,
-0.20897167921066284,
-0.93607497215271,
-0.015523755922913551,
-0.3510688245296478,
-0.7505140900611877,
0.6073054671287537,
-0.16765624284744263,
-0.9059948921203613,
0.6802616715431213,
-0.15093691647052765,
-0.2075042724609375,
-0.15014693140983582,
-0.16337627172470093,
-0.12169013172388077,
0.6305092573165894,
0.012177140451967716,
0.44578057527542114,
0.3015860915184021,
0.40205323696136475,
-0.23802590370178223,
-0.680161714553833,
0.6321595907211304,
-0.9733908772468567,
0.5864561796188354,
0.04035872220993042,
-0.23921380937099457,
-0.13774588704109192,
-0.8285263180732727,
-0.333524614572525,
0.0029165365267544985,
-0.38869497179985046,
-0.17408494651317596,
0.16809192299842834,
0.16076402366161346,
0.0033361646346747875,
0.1567111611366272,
-0.668234646320343,
0.1518941968679428,
-0.2971974313259125,
0.42094892263412476,
0.9214354157447815,
0.1256965696811676,
0.6022273898124695,
0.10263931006193161,
0.3885664939880371,
0.34336352348327637,
0.0541943795979023,
-0.17794467508792877,
-0.6379581093788147,
-0.6015254259109497,
-0.3648829162120819,
0.5709325671195984,
0.2106398493051529,
-0.5043626427650452,
0.4458114206790924,
-0.2699349820613861,
-0.09109063446521759,
-0.22227582335472107,
-0.026025762781500816,
0.30333706736564636,
0.12118811160326004,
-0.15488845109939575,
-0.4645697772502899,
-0.6965839266777039,
-0.657113254070282,
-0.2997928857803345,
-0.4321271479129791,
0.1399020552635193,
0.03562289476394653,
0.45946067571640015,
0.23257577419281006,
0.8632220029830933,
-0.5488582849502563,
0.05039467662572861,
-0.2794334590435028,
0.15315313637256622,
0.45490285754203796,
0.8413568139076233,
0.5931684374809265,
-0.41616591811180115,
0.0028177022468298674,
-0.15127944946289062,
-0.5690264701843262,
0.27357640862464905,
-0.1957269310951233,
-0.06536099314689636,
0.4248364269733429,
0.344716876745224,
-0.7434110641479492,
0.8341703414916992,
0.5976638197898865,
-0.6572969555854797,
0.3061583340167999,
-0.545096755027771,
0.06137236952781677,
-0.809646725654602,
0.054227884858846664,
-0.3251529037952423,
-0.3201189935207367,
-0.7135282754898071,
-0.058345358818769455,
-0.024589886888861656,
-0.25527966022491455,
-0.3120036721229553,
0.3634325861930847,
-0.2911633551120758,
-0.363503098487854,
0.006435872055590153,
0.14821061491966248,
-0.009322935715317726,
0.6369462609291077,
-0.16297022998332977,
0.5510298013687134,
0.23950444161891937,
-0.474161297082901,
0.12029006332159042,
0.17660214006900787,
-0.3042565584182739,
-0.1858958899974823,
-0.46907246112823486,
0.03622223064303398,
-0.3823911249637604,
0.30749592185020447,
-1.2218093872070312,
-0.09926975518465042,
0.15592637658119202,
-0.5351048111915588,
0.7058370113372803,
-0.1605793982744217,
-0.8256365656852722,
-0.2150096595287323,
-0.2846224904060364,
0.5371610522270203,
0.7372502684593201,
-0.4311898946762085,
0.22732436656951904,
0.532891571521759,
0.22917801141738892,
-0.9734618663787842,
-0.9970052242279053,
-0.047651346772909164,
-0.14027880132198334,
-0.2416176199913025,
0.1185535192489624,
0.1250174641609192,
0.10559815168380737,
0.19873933494091034,
0.07998081296682358,
0.09162919968366623,
0.27024465799331665,
0.2547268271446228,
-0.0731993243098259,
-0.36146190762519836,
0.38766202330589294,
0.14898571372032166,
-0.05189527943730354,
0.134531632065773,
-0.646207332611084,
0.6971300840377808,
0.4315286874771118,
-0.8923770189285278,
-0.5423327684402466,
0.46357887983322144,
0.2919449508190155,
0.0581965371966362,
1.3865258693695068,
0.942242443561554,
-0.6254686117172241,
0.03763234615325928,
-0.2999194860458374,
-0.25731727480888367,
-0.42495226860046387,
0.6593672037124634,
-0.3559229075908661,
-0.8908007144927979,
0.94277423620224,
0.27616241574287415,
-0.05401398986577988,
0.5952069759368896,
0.5182561874389648,
0.0009307239088229835,
1.2991770505905151,
0.6950108408927917,
0.11536229401826859,
0.45387840270996094,
-0.2859551012516022,
0.6002025008201599,
-0.5728118419647217,
-0.47526460886001587,
-0.529643714427948,
-0.20096711814403534,
-0.4608921706676483,
-0.5807421207427979,
0.04640352725982666,
0.38041597604751587,
-0.19888313114643097,
0.3396267294883728,
-0.15473416447639465,
0.24679820239543915,
0.7918949127197266,
-0.1486579179763794,
-0.015405836515128613,
0.14243848621845245,
-0.26105135679244995,
-0.45982155203819275,
-1.1137028932571411,
-0.26841089129447937,
0.9993559122085571,
0.5916860699653625,
0.7096308469772339,
0.14417211711406708,
0.8340252637863159,
0.4045087695121765,
-0.20225508511066437,
-0.45911821722984314,
0.16882900893688202,
-0.3609619140625,
-0.27344152331352234,
-0.4149380326271057,
-0.39957916736602783,
-0.9322266578674316,
-0.1911674588918686,
-0.316749632358551,
-1.1016420125961304,
0.41367682814598083,
0.3271138668060303,
0.039673734456300735,
0.8028159737586975,
-0.9134007692337036,
0.9190592765808105,
0.22725974023342133,
-0.07988186180591583,
-0.37889689207077026,
-0.14316929876804352,
0.1481451839208603,
-0.004159929696470499,
0.44857972860336304,
0.2683732509613037,
0.008218293078243732,
0.7934095859527588,
-0.5282301306724548,
1.2631120681762695,
-0.24660097062587738,
-0.06369215995073318,
0.24907024204730988,
0.17372478544712067,
0.6392408013343811,
0.18183663487434387,
-0.06271462887525558,
0.18769261240959167,
-0.0761936604976654,
-0.5047359466552734,
-0.6930192708969116,
0.6338651180267334,
-0.9339221715927124,
-0.6389649510383606,
-0.25917771458625793,
-0.5008348226547241,
0.13010908663272858,
-0.16894331574440002,
0.2754671275615692,
0.9739696383476257,
-0.488524466753006,
0.1418416053056717,
0.32949498295783997,
-0.6258656978607178,
0.5613874197006226,
-0.19911858439445496,
-0.2978672683238983,
-0.4473269581794739,
1.1165717840194702,
0.33362433314323425,
0.13549964129924774,
0.6483287811279297,
-0.17246322333812714,
-0.4778806269168854,
-0.3891398012638092,
-0.32207754254341125,
0.24245679378509521,
-1.2933285236358643,
-0.12333022803068161,
-0.7041403651237488,
-0.39798906445503235,
-0.5226824283599854,
-0.12531161308288574,
-0.10958985984325409,
-0.9914535880088806,
-0.2903420627117157,
-0.3130664825439453,
0.3457971513271332,
1.1631884574890137,
-0.35990598797798157,
0.27926984429359436,
-0.8391366004943848,
-0.30944252014160156,
0.27464351058006287,
0.41685107350349426,
0.40318992733955383,
-0.6848140358924866,
-0.7522774934768677,
0.0037671562749892473,
-0.006499061826616526,
-0.887357234954834,
0.36062169075012207,
0.33028146624565125,
0.7326112389564514,
0.7016907930374146,
-0.11675694584846497,
0.3988993167877197,
-0.6241648197174072,
1.1488885879516602,
0.33745911717414856,
-1.3424030542373657,
0.36360403895378113,
-0.011483128182590008,
0.061126090586185455,
-0.08229032903909683,
0.12592020630836487,
-0.45930206775665283,
-0.5916590690612793,
-0.8459802865982056,
-0.5761146545410156,
0.8874750733375549,
0.2820185422897339,
0.5873157382011414,
-0.5641757845878601,
0.22780154645442963,
0.3966461420059204,
0.19529587030410767,
-0.556183397769928,
-0.2902293801307678,
-0.33582285046577454,
-0.384883314371109,
-0.37790894508361816,
-0.8167845010757446,
-0.0015092265093699098,
-0.20197030901908875,
0.37075597047805786,
0.19254359602928162,
0.8368514776229858,
-0.20818795263767242,
-0.24949926137924194,
-0.06337845325469971,
-0.04590092971920967,
0.9663186073303223,
0.49365049600601196,
-0.12544119358062744,
0.4900362193584442,
0.17922690510749817,
-0.47555333375930786,
0.17973171174526215,
-0.4764610230922699,
0.3218396008014679,
0.47417232394218445,
0.8449385762214661,
1.2018018960952759,
0.4540291428565979,
-0.43710607290267944,
0.8424904346466064,
-0.16593411564826965,
-0.00757992547005415,
-0.4070621728897095,
-0.03345448523759842,
0.16647760570049286,
-0.15515241026878357,
0.5361798405647278,
0.07400321215391159,
0.07151679694652557,
-0.46159520745277405,
0.24984967708587646,
0.4538183808326721,
-0.36662718653678894,
-0.6788090467453003,
0.9447341561317444,
0.06495092809200287,
-0.3504103124141693,
0.6109402775764465,
-0.25751882791519165,
-0.322182834148407,
0.687311589717865,
0.9166247248649597,
0.7752878665924072,
0.09718556702136993,
0.25966301560401917,
0.7061010599136353,
0.34348806738853455,
0.3143496811389923,
0.2059013396501541,
0.01276231836527586,
-0.7202852368354797,
-0.8329128623008728,
-0.8121369481086731,
0.016296986490488052,
0.0625109076499939,
-0.7250226736068726,
0.14772537350654602,
-0.4446667432785034,
-0.3222123980522156,
-0.11643364280462265,
-0.3517727553844452,
-0.7750000953674316,
-0.10096948593854904,
0.2758672833442688,
0.8926221132278442,
-1.181045651435852,
0.7578943967819214,
0.36858925223350525,
-0.3333800733089447,
-0.7415745854377747,
-0.1677503138780594,
-0.17265574634075165,
-0.9262825846672058,
1.009920597076416,
0.012430301867425442,
0.3513527810573578,
-0.11855075508356094,
-0.5369126796722412,
-1.0622129440307617,
0.7889484167098999,
0.6797993779182434,
-0.32225024700164795,
0.09398596733808517,
0.4146602153778076,
0.39485713839530945,
-0.5505325794219971,
0.07710037380456924,
0.2766539752483368,
0.16100716590881348,
-0.0908624604344368,
-0.5801356434822083,
0.09260174632072449,
-0.13032883405685425,
0.3772025406360626,
0.17096218466758728,
-0.08097314834594727,
0.8081362247467041,
-0.015019928105175495,
-0.4043888449668884,
-0.10979761928319931,
0.7022053599357605,
0.08690175414085388,
-0.0986090749502182,
0.27551034092903137,
0.42209377884864807,
0.6606946587562561,
-0.17084021866321564,
1.3084129095077515,
-0.6294466257095337,
0.44499671459198,
0.7113314867019653,
0.15822404623031616,
0.86408531665802,
0.681843638420105,
-0.19230179488658905,
0.3599792718887329,
0.5044336318969727,
0.19769544899463654,
0.5021419525146484,
0.2862066626548767,
-0.11560940742492676,
-0.13701246678829193,
-0.18884481489658356,
-0.20326630771160126,
0.43885645270347595,
0.34604230523109436,
-0.5154095888137817,
0.09614965319633484,
0.16956038773059845,
-0.24127203226089478,
-0.005187290254980326,
-0.11901436001062393,
0.6926937103271484,
0.11460219323635101,
-0.29915186762809753,
0.6034518480300903,
0.0790339931845665,
0.3515361249446869,
-0.38156604766845703,
-0.16167911887168884,
-0.19281639158725739,
0.14198489487171173,
-0.06224540248513222,
-0.889472246170044,
0.5214910507202148,
-0.11397334933280945,
-0.25063562393188477,
-0.13223165273666382,
0.4782593548297882,
-0.5042712688446045,
-0.3764727711677551,
0.2423636019229889,
0.31357353925704956,
0.5036136507987976,
0.47442686557769775,
-0.17841516435146332,
0.3373269736766815,
-0.010816392488777637,
-0.20383556187152863,
0.4110215902328491,
0.7683091759681702,
0.09612947702407837,
0.33453869819641113,
0.5555651783943176,
0.3568904399871826,
0.4049878418445587,
0.3304324448108673,
0.499504029750824,
-0.5862429141998291,
-0.5531485080718994,
-0.8633574843406677,
0.6185891628265381,
-0.043117597699165344,
-0.283889502286911,
0.4876456558704376,
0.37855690717697144,
0.8949338793754578,
-0.4185269773006439,
0.4245932698249817,
0.15546032786369324,
-0.2975034713745117,
-0.6794735789299011,
0.6188134551048279,
-0.26519277691841125,
0.13815025985240936,
-0.07422236353158951,
-0.9424842596054077,
-0.24246996641159058,
0.41597768664360046,
0.05955637991428375,
0.018281223252415657,
0.6866781115531921,
0.5067096948623657,
-0.1455567479133606,
-0.3118962049484253,
0.723313570022583,
0.29704549908638,
0.10979964584112167,
0.3915751874446869,
0.5095384120941162,
-0.6264086961746216,
0.39378422498703003,
-0.013338327407836914,
-0.08497260510921478,
-0.33694323897361755,
-0.8764246106147766,
-0.7819940447807312,
-0.9265304207801819,
-0.28409719467163086,
-0.33657899498939514,
-0.11856044083833694,
0.8041817545890808,
0.5179607272148132,
-1.0110783576965332,
-0.21617421507835388,
-0.0940411388874054,
0.05049716681241989,
-0.4703143537044525,
-0.23223929107189178,
0.5789813995361328,
-0.4326411485671997,
-0.7007168531417847,
-0.0030185531359165907,
0.26978930830955505,
0.05150110274553299,
-0.26043012738227844,
-0.20169146358966827,
-0.07205988466739655,
0.20072945952415466,
0.43031299114227295,
-0.08307169377803802,
-0.7473978996276855,
-0.8102647066116333,
-0.11504881829023361,
-0.11677676439285278,
-0.05685869976878166,
0.7330026626586914,
-0.5226757526397705,
0.3368043899536133,
0.7113827466964722,
0.763942539691925,
0.5787872076034546,
-0.3974081575870514,
1.0582140684127808,
-1.4529703855514526,
0.6252639889717102,
-0.17542485892772675,
0.7210407853126526,
0.3526065945625305,
-0.5624450445175171,
0.31942668557167053,
0.23400138318538666,
-0.28011056780815125,
-1.1083858013153076,
0.14758539199829102,
-0.8435987830162048,
-0.08739852905273438,
1.0321508646011353,
-0.3252395689487457,
-0.35638511180877686,
0.04913965240120888,
0.08630387485027313,
0.6538975834846497,
-0.13599662482738495,
0.3876905143260956,
0.8108793497085571,
0.31901949644088745,
-0.06995470076799393,
-0.31260356307029724,
0.4074436128139496,
0.27207151055336,
0.19458171725273132,
0.0566183365881443,
0.11496458202600479,
0.05907807871699333,
0.15295088291168213,
0.6111419200897217,
-0.06079767644405365,
0.2438204437494278,
0.5506373643875122,
0.26204919815063477,
0.0954832211136818,
-0.045928992331027985,
-0.7899186611175537,
0.2778875231742859,
0.360757052898407,
-0.3442767262458801
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.06570v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.06570v1
|
Review of Computational Epigraphy
| 2024-06-03T15:55:24 | 2024-06-03T15:55:24 |
Vishal Kumar
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Computational Epigraphy refers to the process of extracting text from stone
inscription, transliteration, interpretation, and attribution with the aid of
computational methods. Traditional epigraphy methods are time consuming, and
tend to damage the stone inscriptions while extracting text. Additionally,
interpretation and attribution are subjective and can vary between different
epigraphers. However, using modern computation methods can not only be used to
extract text, but also interpret and attribute the text in a robust way. We
survey and document the existing computational methods that aid in the
above-mentioned tasks in epigraphy.
|
[
-0.1325111985206604,
-1.11807119846344,
0.6659888029098511,
0.20066186785697937,
-0.2951166033744812,
0.4576430320739746,
-0.08888543397188187,
-0.9328722357749939,
0.4643714427947998,
0.5715911984443665,
-0.5226590633392334,
-0.10691038519144058,
-0.5366078019142151,
0.3092404007911682,
0.07576029747724533,
0.7061905860900879,
-0.49769675731658936,
0.03790886327624321,
-0.30979740619659424,
0.40884119272232056,
-0.045683883130550385,
-0.5722737908363342,
-0.5195164680480957,
-0.27066901326179504,
0.384977787733078,
0.1879187971353531,
0.5069597959518433,
0.9660102128982544,
0.8283895254135132,
0.42967846989631653,
-0.10011781007051468,
0.1718643605709076,
-0.4343177378177643,
0.13597150146961212,
0.11879467219114304,
-0.3844134509563446,
0.021580146625638008,
0.26203685998916626,
0.5500266551971436,
0.6425668001174927,
-0.12744095921516418,
0.15800274908542633,
-0.39473986625671387,
0.5987347960472107,
-0.8789404034614563,
0.167714923620224,
-0.19933806359767914,
0.14589576423168182,
-0.5953795313835144,
-0.8187409043312073,
-0.49763354659080505,
-0.7398848533630371,
0.4126354157924652,
-1.0605946779251099,
0.32219308614730835,
0.04532105475664139,
0.7321250438690186,
0.2624894976615906,
0.22385607659816742,
-0.7796621918678284,
-1.218458890914917,
1.0248051881790161,
-0.2939477860927582,
-0.01226827409118414,
0.5741480588912964,
0.6187767386436462,
0.4308117926120758,
-1.1474722623825073,
-0.37378570437431335,
-0.024465840309858322,
-0.17877532541751862,
0.1506618708372116,
0.3888840079307556,
0.09128741919994354,
0.31125974655151367,
0.6622377038002014,
0.054185137152671814,
-0.3686150014400482,
-0.345276802778244,
-0.6211202144622803,
0.5712581276893616,
0.2618134021759033,
0.8360459804534912,
0.16851618885993958,
-0.26571106910705566,
-0.18755224347114563,
-0.8922701478004456,
0.028519071638584137,
0.5792049765586853,
0.4894436001777649,
0.02875460684299469,
0.28431177139282227,
0.0895497053861618,
0.8422670364379883,
-0.0460992194712162,
-0.3894229829311371,
0.10514790564775467,
-0.23066936433315277,
-0.3198752701282501,
0.39141449332237244,
0.46327513456344604,
-0.17290721833705902,
0.19846530258655548,
-0.3392164409160614,
0.19458481669425964,
-0.12535038590431213,
0.3969789147377014,
-0.8013839721679688,
-0.2462618499994278,
-0.04137961193919182,
-0.6738474369049072,
-0.6680047512054443,
-0.07248485833406448,
-0.8348836302757263,
-0.5939638614654541,
-0.25243231654167175,
0.030070839449763298,
-0.07675163447856903,
-0.34082499146461487,
-0.2579463720321655,
-0.6078804135322571,
-0.021016698330640793,
0.7736303210258484,
-0.9742802381515503,
0.3875854015350342,
0.6618034839630127,
0.9817303419113159,
0.10970108956098557,
-0.1692861169576645,
-0.016604823991656303,
0.11079925298690796,
-0.08800657838582993,
1.1954026222229004,
-0.773175060749054,
-0.40301233530044556,
-0.14301568269729614,
-0.16759291291236877,
-0.23158465325832367,
-0.34566962718963623,
1.0401824712753296,
-0.2855057716369629,
-0.06431112438440323,
-0.44456201791763306,
-0.22172150015830994,
-0.40770411491394043,
0.14435796439647675,
-1.1330572366714478,
0.7170036435127258,
0.3227870464324951,
-0.7907726764678955,
-0.0787515714764595,
-0.43933841586112976,
-0.466695100069046,
0.3410356938838959,
-0.47557345032691956,
-0.30935904383659363,
0.16622580587863922,
0.09648599475622177,
0.16535106301307678,
-0.7451026439666748,
-0.40395161509513855,
-0.11577856540679932,
-0.5950558185577393,
0.2885882258415222,
-0.12834320962429047,
0.989301860332489,
0.5133896470069885,
-0.2970278263092041,
-0.3222214877605438,
-0.6026169657707214,
0.29848432540893555,
0.07138416916131973,
-0.2934173345565796,
-0.29209208488464355,
0.3683129847049713,
0.48312270641326904,
0.0819641724228859,
0.03512709215283394,
-0.914964497089386,
0.0335986502468586,
-0.7079153060913086,
0.4263671338558197,
0.6792212128639221,
0.15601247549057007,
0.33129507303237915,
-0.5536055564880371,
0.45683348178863525,
-0.6130774617195129,
-0.3328438103199005,
-0.2536545991897583,
-0.547480583190918,
-0.0703696608543396,
-0.5147255659103394,
0.5168153643608093,
0.6142239570617676,
-0.7906143665313721,
-0.3360593914985657,
-0.3483932912349701,
-0.787907063961029,
-0.4569573402404785,
-0.28509047627449036,
0.6861155033111572,
0.20338505506515503,
-0.14975140988826752,
-0.37767425179481506,
-0.5414853096008301,
-0.5548056364059448,
-0.5123814940452576,
-0.24999995529651642,
0.25889599323272705,
0.41102835536003113,
0.042798012495040894,
0.3597940504550934,
0.6853649616241455,
-0.665009081363678,
-0.17911683022975922,
0.05411495268344879,
0.6961811780929565,
-0.07714460045099258,
0.2636193633079529,
0.6263173222541809,
-1.0693620443344116,
-0.959735631942749,
0.332975298166275,
-0.721399188041687,
-0.19662655889987946,
-0.5827057957649231,
0.012020221911370754,
0.031011756509542465,
0.43774881958961487,
-0.12171930074691772,
0.6137887239456177,
0.07677019387483597,
-0.018128955736756325,
0.5591747164726257,
0.11400055885314941,
0.6149260401725769,
-0.4944959878921509,
0.1647387146949768,
0.13179904222488403,
-0.04665294289588928,
-0.9628996253013611,
0.6305890679359436,
-0.07017715275287628,
0.16722802817821503,
-0.4924949109554291,
0.1552547961473465,
-0.8811125755310059,
0.2091653048992157,
-0.4569992423057556,
-0.12389727681875229,
-0.22583620250225067,
0.4550284147262573,
0.381188303232193,
0.39414268732070923,
0.287386417388916,
-0.23221367597579956,
0.5656518936157227,
0.15386320650577545,
-0.11623010784387589,
0.4890965521335602,
-0.24602682888507843,
0.5617827773094177,
0.01231938786804676,
0.10045302659273148,
-1.09632408618927,
-0.22666366398334503,
0.35530349612236023,
-0.7432634830474854,
0.5665387511253357,
-0.15311037003993988,
-0.22748963534832,
-0.12728069722652435,
-0.7341005802154541,
0.6052568554878235,
0.11292680352926254,
-0.1291356235742569,
1.0186634063720703,
0.42013415694236755,
-0.6148093342781067,
-0.5572556257247925,
-0.6955413222312927,
-0.011954555287957191,
-0.09806988388299942,
-0.5909017324447632,
0.6956350803375244,
0.07995864748954773,
-0.6145009994506836,
-0.24751625955104828,
0.2895442545413971,
-0.34585708379745483,
0.08854353427886963,
0.5417749881744385,
0.2789422571659088,
0.1536652147769928,
-0.3387546241283417,
-0.24267049133777618,
-0.2605714499950409,
0.06590249389410019,
0.17400924861431122,
0.45804858207702637,
0.34924665093421936,
-0.2749083340167999,
-0.8956765532493591,
0.41964635252952576,
0.4569011926651001,
0.306899756193161,
0.5760325789451599,
0.379228800535202,
-0.726349413394928,
0.28225117921829224,
-0.3440863788127899,
0.08412744104862213,
-0.4701433777809143,
-0.0732051432132721,
-0.5597272515296936,
-0.5914519429206848,
0.604203462600708,
-0.5696282386779785,
0.05663478001952171,
0.7718889713287354,
0.7257995009422302,
-0.20359370112419128,
0.7633074522018433,
0.6550169587135315,
-0.09925319999456406,
0.3754018545150757,
-0.03829916566610336,
0.2125576138496399,
-0.6435176134109497,
-0.27155545353889465,
-1.0054895877838135,
-0.3077452778816223,
-0.6463024616241455,
-0.02466888166964054,
0.007075224071741104,
-0.10670308023691177,
0.0432586669921875,
-0.01592831127345562,
-0.7180299758911133,
0.41088417172431946,
0.23578345775604248,
0.13785113394260406,
0.015662267804145813,
0.6389888525009155,
0.028379835188388824,
-0.262955904006958,
0.004571930970996618,
-0.4961410462856293,
1.1617085933685303,
0.059340983629226685,
0.6396647691726685,
-0.013532832264900208,
0.659599781036377,
0.5261104106903076,
0.46949252486228943,
-0.6841603517532349,
0.0737006664276123,
0.23861470818519592,
-0.6219851970672607,
-0.3657432496547699,
-0.3271349370479584,
-0.5660314559936523,
-0.04048647731542587,
-0.36889830231666565,
-1.1306431293487549,
0.06609811633825302,
0.09656935185194016,
-0.5234645009040833,
0.4981204867362976,
-0.38749006390571594,
0.3259204030036926,
0.016383549198508263,
-0.5062763094902039,
-0.1102137640118599,
-0.7507269382476807,
-0.18117812275886536,
-0.2561010718345642,
0.40967854857444763,
0.38083088397979736,
0.29291969537734985,
0.721805989742279,
-0.487881600856781,
0.8615016937255859,
-0.24192610383033752,
-0.14357218146324158,
0.9019138216972351,
0.24672117829322815,
0.7629693150520325,
-0.6807643175125122,
-0.2546868324279785,
0.03917677700519562,
0.291646808385849,
-0.35068994760513306,
-0.5268951058387756,
0.6523320078849792,
-0.9332758784294128,
-0.17679516971111298,
-0.7513654828071594,
-0.1393781453371048,
0.16309069097042084,
-0.15786102414131165,
0.46381381154060364,
0.5274803042411804,
-0.5281366109848022,
-0.504367470741272,
0.2125145047903061,
-0.08651458472013474,
0.4710554778575897,
-0.2756660282611847,
0.1398867666721344,
-0.6524145007133484,
1.3005365133285522,
0.023004285991191864,
0.287075936794281,
0.57563716173172,
0.1555962860584259,
-0.19075508415699005,
-1.013288140296936,
-0.7285973429679871,
0.17701545357704163,
-0.6850241422653198,
0.2000454068183899,
-0.3171064257621765,
-0.13956846296787262,
-0.5005369186401367,
-0.5721097588539124,
0.07035452127456665,
-0.8864299058914185,
-0.30185094475746155,
0.05315754935145378,
0.2240007072687149,
0.9347269535064697,
0.0930061787366867,
0.48691821098327637,
-0.8482798337936401,
0.09418030083179474,
-0.13125169277191162,
-0.009497704915702343,
0.0764688029885292,
0.012666742317378521,
-0.31494706869125366,
0.12651389837265015,
-0.3703228831291199,
-0.9071743488311768,
0.2212945520877838,
0.10447152704000473,
0.5306718349456787,
0.5097634196281433,
-0.38558316230773926,
0.7164030075073242,
-0.27469658851623535,
0.8632310032844543,
0.263412207365036,
-0.6484898924827576,
0.15768256783485413,
-0.5769893527030945,
-0.002825983101502061,
0.7340725064277649,
0.5429337024688721,
-0.7728438377380371,
0.10144956409931183,
-0.4570911228656769,
-0.7801392674446106,
0.9356486797332764,
0.4231529235839844,
-0.15570512413978577,
0.22900842130184174,
0.779589831829071,
0.09783302992582321,
0.08346595615148544,
-0.40190577507019043,
-0.41715729236602783,
0.16296595335006714,
-0.3395141065120697,
0.10058143734931946,
-0.14604006707668304,
-0.022709809243679047,
-0.29515302181243896,
0.44989439845085144,
0.09733910113573074,
0.8715729117393494,
0.23531527817249298,
-0.4248141646385193,
-0.7131664156913757,
-0.1798861175775528,
0.6532847881317139,
0.805668294429779,
-0.13826428353786469,
0.14195388555526733,
-0.0008239059243351221,
-1.1826039552688599,
-0.17920571565628052,
0.04977710545063019,
-0.40879014134407043,
-0.3319903314113617,
0.6845527291297913,
0.32765620946884155,
-0.19638389348983765,
-0.31506168842315674,
0.16992013156414032,
0.011241033673286438,
-0.31427380442619324,
-0.5848020911216736,
-0.3629439175128937,
-0.0822218582034111,
-0.1469191610813141,
0.522572934627533,
0.2800580859184265,
0.4956671893596649,
-0.769310474395752,
-0.35897746682167053,
0.1809893548488617,
-0.4300041198730469,
-0.28797125816345215,
0.2616488039493561,
0.3474082946777344,
-0.6412689685821533,
0.7916719913482666,
-0.09284176677465439,
-0.6977527737617493,
0.7430107593536377,
0.6531131863594055,
0.8136026859283447,
-0.39905598759651184,
0.21277020871639252,
0.5238406658172607,
0.12279369682073593,
0.14400078356266022,
0.6039739847183228,
-0.28953316807746887,
-0.3149172067642212,
-0.617908239364624,
-0.7863647937774658,
-0.6441938877105713,
-0.5571176409721375,
-0.3255912661552429,
-0.027181027457118034,
-0.6527045965194702,
-0.02463448792695999,
0.4723639190196991,
0.06859812140464783,
-0.1864241659641266,
0.29849204421043396,
0.4431201219558716,
0.3902730345726013,
-0.7423756122589111,
0.1806344836950302,
0.7382301688194275,
-0.20164720714092255,
-0.6730847954750061,
-0.3111077547073364,
0.7902689576148987,
-0.483913779258728,
0.5475339889526367,
0.09392660111188889,
-0.6743039488792419,
0.05541494861245155,
-0.7034636735916138,
-0.6909482479095459,
0.9928445219993591,
-0.02939038909971714,
-0.10836858302354813,
-0.0011996917892247438,
0.38502421975135803,
0.6201210618019104,
-0.15698643028736115,
0.8389582633972168,
0.4528696537017822,
0.5181100964546204,
0.477694571018219,
-0.958576500415802,
0.20608627796173096,
-0.7241834998130798,
-0.1195325031876564,
0.5638526082038879,
-0.361426442861557,
0.9022454023361206,
0.037680283188819885,
-0.7919325232505798,
0.4205643832683563,
0.3446638286113739,
-0.13295453786849976,
0.4073846936225891,
0.1782238781452179,
0.47997167706489563,
0.7850095629692078,
-0.3579179644584656,
1.1902903318405151,
-0.15305446088314056,
0.3343278765678406,
0.62205970287323,
-0.14715903997421265,
0.6136212348937988,
0.3891153037548065,
-0.43818432092666626,
0.923915445804596,
1.1020268201828003,
0.21928656101226807,
0.5744880437850952,
0.4358636438846588,
-0.4623458683490753,
-0.1608899086713791,
-0.001250026747584343,
-0.17965510487556458,
0.2436678260564804,
0.43104779720306396,
-0.5776232481002808,
-0.05122816190123558,
-0.29906362295150757,
0.11524228006601334,
0.22793099284172058,
-0.46092489361763,
0.8156347870826721,
-0.10289956629276276,
-0.6678604483604431,
0.2924230396747589,
0.23734474182128906,
0.45090967416763306,
-0.3950478434562683,
-0.565864622592926,
0.7251250147819519,
0.07225489616394043,
-0.4292426109313965,
-0.38391467928886414,
0.5054724216461182,
-0.3201214671134949,
0.1833023875951767,
-0.5386322140693665,
1.2621374130249023,
0.2590590715408325,
-0.4170520305633545,
-0.19631098210811615,
0.4842744469642639,
0.4208228886127472,
-0.2728065550327301,
-0.5307114720344543,
-0.05660015344619751,
0.13320861756801605,
-0.1383095234632492,
-0.09967926889657974,
0.16497375071048737,
-0.16787275671958923,
0.265452116727829,
0.7837468385696411,
0.21653026342391968,
0.0002665405336301774,
0.01977427862584591,
0.8148888945579529,
-0.8453047275543213,
-0.3738700747489929,
-1.1754076480865479,
0.17666636407375336,
-0.24726037681102753,
-0.2221398949623108,
0.6348419189453125,
0.5943458676338196,
0.6046927571296692,
-0.047460559755563736,
1.0583062171936035,
-0.3956095278263092,
0.5311275124549866,
-0.3906475901603699,
0.8912780284881592,
-0.07192327827215195,
-0.3108757436275482,
-0.8067910075187683,
-0.8124863505363464,
-0.4023735821247101,
0.7711800932884216,
-0.4100211262702942,
-0.100194551050663,
0.9495466351509094,
0.4050637483596802,
0.19729304313659668,
0.9445316195487976,
-0.22429558634757996,
-0.30016762018203735,
-0.13962532579898834,
0.29654479026794434,
1.003792405128479,
-0.10246537625789642,
0.1611948162317276,
-0.2880350649356842,
-0.4317006468772888,
-0.1400737464427948,
-0.6502432823181152,
-0.6108610033988953,
-0.7207267880439758,
-0.17150729894638062,
-0.1504490077495575,
-0.11360837519168854,
0.8642522096633911,
0.3205190896987915,
-0.4907892048358917,
-0.19817107915878296,
0.048635710030794144,
-0.2688460052013397,
-0.5863288640975952,
-0.0881151333451271,
0.593101978302002,
0.14442883431911469,
-0.8925003409385681,
0.0263200756162405,
0.31459757685661316,
0.014956100843846798,
-0.13783450424671173,
-0.02533710189163685,
-0.2262216955423355,
0.005996359046548605,
0.25747987627983093,
0.49116432666778564,
-0.3210306763648987,
-0.01503809168934822,
-0.17997673153877258,
-0.0023275509011000395,
0.33679744601249695,
1.4435065984725952,
-0.3708798885345459,
0.920724093914032,
0.9243152141571045,
0.4488208591938019,
0.9941753149032593,
0.08307832479476929,
0.43927648663520813,
-0.22952859103679657,
-0.09840338677167892,
0.1571141630411148,
0.11247801035642624,
0.31011688709259033,
-0.8108528852462769,
0.5157543420791626,
0.5060490965843201,
-0.3047201633453369,
-0.5602038502693176,
0.20137280225753784,
-0.9241505265235901,
-0.2692921757698059,
0.6671305894851685,
-0.3662000596523285,
-0.598607063293457,
-0.488044410943985,
-0.3783171474933624,
0.6225311756134033,
0.2729754149913788,
0.7964382171630859,
1.1248117685317993,
-0.2766436040401459,
0.011242923326790333,
-0.24091216921806335,
0.6124471426010132,
-0.23905329406261444,
-1.0468729734420776,
-0.0441751591861248,
0.5807477831840515,
0.1273069977760315,
0.7984147667884827,
0.952299952507019,
-0.3970678746700287,
0.3089663088321686,
0.38777464628219604,
0.11780126392841339,
-0.10369829833507538,
-0.31529778242111206,
-0.12795424461364746,
0.27297157049179077,
0.13538749516010284,
0.2342797964811325
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.01462v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.01462v1
|
Understanding Preference Fine-Tuning Through the Lens of Coverage
| 2024-06-03T15:51:04 | 2024-06-03T15:51:04 |
Yuda Song, Gokul Swamy, Aarti Singh, J. Andrew Bagnell, Wen Sun
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Learning from human preference data has emerged as the dominant paradigm for
fine-tuning large language models (LLMs). The two most common families of
techniques -- online reinforcement learning (RL) such as Proximal Policy
Optimization (PPO) and offline contrastive methods such as Direct Preference
Optimization (DPO) -- were positioned as equivalent in prior work due to the
fact that both have to start from the same offline preference dataset. To
further expand our theoretical understanding of the similarities and
differences between online and offline techniques for preference fine-tuning,
we conduct a rigorous analysis through the lens of dataset coverage, a concept
that captures how the training data covers the test distribution and is widely
used in RL. We prove that a global coverage condition is both necessary and
sufficient for offline contrastive methods to converge to the optimal policy,
but a weaker partial coverage condition suffices for online RL methods. This
separation provides one explanation of why online RL methods can perform better
than offline methods, especially when the offline preference data is not
diverse enough. Finally, motivated by our preceding theoretical observations,
we derive a hybrid preference optimization (HyPO) algorithm that uses offline
data for contrastive-based preference optimization and online data for KL
regularization. Theoretically and empirically, we demonstrate that HyPO is more
performant than its pure offline counterpart DPO, while still preserving its
computation and memory efficiency.
|
[
-0.8011505007743835,
-0.5270060300827026,
0.5074577331542969,
-0.08436956256628036,
-0.08736100047826767,
0.23889808356761932,
-0.5108654499053955,
-0.37484392523765564,
0.1869201809167862,
0.404958039522171,
-0.5982105135917664,
-0.17199590802192688,
-0.2312304675579071,
-0.0428188256919384,
0.3459322154521942,
1.056091070175171,
-0.25576260685920715,
-0.09681045264005661,
-0.06644783914089203,
-0.1771969348192215,
-0.11353845149278641,
-0.14887471497058868,
-0.5552151203155518,
-0.5402480959892273,
0.540194034576416,
0.7669905424118042,
0.882642388343811,
0.7278973460197449,
0.3240772783756256,
0.2693691551685333,
-0.13815662264823914,
0.6185843348503113,
-0.8950405120849609,
-0.15215319395065308,
-0.032849427312612534,
-0.7061965465545654,
0.04719315096735954,
0.0260046124458313,
0.4593711495399475,
0.5967085957527161,
-0.17451627552509308,
-0.40713033080101013,
0.12255550175905228,
0.8400987982749939,
-0.9334735870361328,
-0.09142762422561646,
-0.6219542622566223,
0.25673261284828186,
0.10409462451934814,
-0.46957486867904663,
-0.3166640102863312,
-0.5473120808601379,
0.38883620500564575,
-1.0412092208862305,
0.26298534870147705,
0.16734878718852997,
1.0568112134933472,
0.15725064277648926,
-0.3874844014644623,
-0.06834592670202255,
-0.9533983469009399,
1.0033292770385742,
-0.36137324571609497,
0.17092181742191315,
0.8988518118858337,
0.4743536412715912,
-0.11385418474674225,
-0.06798607110977173,
-0.4034789502620697,
-0.32143330574035645,
-0.09278663247823715,
0.21602389216423035,
0.09454484283924103,
0.419834703207016,
0.046640362590551376,
0.7739053964614868,
-0.0880436971783638,
0.3491327464580536,
-0.24052143096923828,
-0.23168013989925385,
0.6834291219711304,
-0.04328017681837082,
-0.018166877329349518,
0.1385709047317505,
-0.31517109274864197,
-0.17366129159927368,
-0.7324612140655518,
0.3518334925174713,
0.44011640548706055,
0.026910725980997086,
-0.2082749307155609,
0.369210809469223,
-0.4707264006137848,
0.6749172806739807,
0.13513506948947906,
-0.3051466941833496,
0.15762901306152344,
-0.32323628664016724,
-0.22758503258228302,
0.013365792110562325,
0.3496406674385071,
0.634183406829834,
0.5033252835273743,
-0.2940213680267334,
-0.09360568970441818,
0.019260279834270477,
0.15963613986968994,
-0.530909538269043,
-0.006342810112982988,
0.18261249363422394,
-0.33809056878089905,
-0.49470415711402893,
0.05455869436264038,
-0.6371666789054871,
-0.3729819655418396,
-0.6543586850166321,
0.30107077956199646,
-0.04162745550274849,
-0.24927610158920288,
0.3065313696861267,
-0.015361441299319267,
0.1808474361896515,
0.2686350345611572,
-0.981167197227478,
0.3817983567714691,
0.5470495820045471,
0.7840832471847534,
-0.36075693368911743,
-0.2452227622270584,
-0.45350706577301025,
-0.080293208360672,
-0.5692848563194275,
0.6172284483909607,
-0.3496458828449249,
-0.3325052261352539,
0.19138778746128082,
-0.2106330245733261,
-0.08403720706701279,
-0.6011240482330322,
0.40300068259239197,
-0.789950430393219,
0.17719292640686035,
-0.33846649527549744,
-0.680974543094635,
-0.12028458714485168,
0.306894987821579,
-0.6873302459716797,
0.9059744477272034,
0.1700497567653656,
-0.7641882300376892,
0.7563241720199585,
-0.46462929248809814,
-0.1964779794216156,
-0.3496752977371216,
0.012477220967411995,
-0.7758665084838867,
0.04117128998041153,
-0.03789765015244484,
0.3425420820713043,
-0.15843863785266876,
0.05273713171482086,
-0.6318866610527039,
-0.5129092931747437,
0.25202319025993347,
0.1973579227924347,
0.3288612365722656,
0.16529783606529236,
-0.5322036743164062,
0.471857488155365,
-0.6364096403121948,
0.12481443583965302,
0.14210550487041473,
-0.3735153377056122,
-0.5934015512466431,
0.3112421929836273,
-0.011508581228554249,
0.07765334099531174,
-0.1507348120212555,
-0.658370316028595,
0.11125772446393967,
-0.6125080585479736,
0.6770691871643066,
0.7613758444786072,
-0.07646096497774124,
0.7621473073959351,
-0.565146803855896,
0.28316038846969604,
-0.27236953377723694,
0.2854304909706116,
-0.0012944157933816314,
-0.10606775432825089,
-0.872845470905304,
-0.1946374624967575,
0.15392142534255981,
0.4189736545085907,
-0.6325454711914062,
0.28337281942367554,
-0.061333686113357544,
-0.23998874425888062,
-0.5292443633079529,
0.12010319530963898,
0.709882378578186,
0.32658571004867554,
0.5454267859458923,
0.014231177046895027,
-0.3660844564437866,
-1.1897852420806885,
-0.16506341099739075,
0.23404857516288757,
0.20415252447128296,
0.8287659883499146,
0.09291493892669678,
-0.15536704659461975,
1.1596183776855469,
-0.8850497007369995,
-0.371966153383255,
-0.6083356142044067,
-0.13686534762382507,
-0.08262751996517181,
0.1716659814119339,
0.4117237627506256,
-0.9363104104995728,
-0.7718009352684021,
0.16951709985733032,
-0.35314545035362244,
0.02279122918844223,
-0.14173035323619843,
-0.08192799240350723,
0.3489241600036621,
0.40688711404800415,
-0.04295264184474945,
0.30180156230926514,
0.4869127869606018,
-0.1560755968093872,
0.2796653211116791,
-0.7106351852416992,
0.11427398771047592,
-0.8355270624160767,
-0.2939850091934204,
0.1555555909872055,
-0.39472609758377075,
-0.5844247341156006,
0.2163391411304474,
0.016403546556830406,
0.21380528807640076,
-0.43653714656829834,
0.39904695749282837,
-0.3213517367839813,
-0.1897779256105423,
-0.39053869247436523,
-0.09706203639507294,
0.19760310649871826,
0.41902294754981995,
0.1561325043439865,
0.8035376667976379,
0.3824288547039032,
-0.8724625706672668,
0.08909483999013901,
0.0605289451777935,
-0.2649853825569153,
0.14453847706317902,
-0.5261751413345337,
-0.11202660948038101,
-0.06264150142669678,
0.24549943208694458,
-0.8874605894088745,
-0.2290925234556198,
0.11447041481733322,
0.16627034544944763,
0.23880217969417572,
-0.15007755160331726,
-0.3310389220714569,
0.07021382451057434,
-0.5098975300788879,
0.48782089352607727,
0.5710055828094482,
-0.7586308717727661,
0.11068090796470642,
0.6421120762825012,
0.33074894547462463,
-0.2766364812850952,
-0.44734683632850647,
-0.5066068172454834,
-0.5158544778823853,
-0.38348814845085144,
0.8390318155288696,
0.1281779706478119,
-0.5042427182197571,
-0.31284090876579285,
0.059193503111600876,
-0.14382821321487427,
0.13099932670593262,
0.03436455875635147,
0.280947208404541,
-0.05161099508404732,
-0.04694371297955513,
-0.024426305666565895,
-0.3025917410850525,
-0.25141197443008423,
-0.08006329834461212,
0.5048490166664124,
-0.06568054109811783,
-0.17832288146018982,
-0.2856491208076477,
0.21206195652484894,
0.06468675285577774,
-0.08952441066503525,
0.4914320707321167,
0.17964951694011688,
0.06878914684057236,
-0.38552287220954895,
-0.4564932584762573,
-0.37043845653533936,
-0.47660568356513977,
0.09944748133420944,
-0.31154197454452515,
-0.7403640151023865,
0.43296724557876587,
0.03812534734606743,
-0.062314920127391815,
0.24204440414905548,
0.40004050731658936,
-0.16812756657600403,
0.8238728046417236,
0.7866975665092468,
-0.16249601542949677,
0.6786681413650513,
-0.3614257276058197,
-0.26257064938545227,
-0.5825551748275757,
-0.15125799179077148,
-0.25469231605529785,
-0.4622713327407837,
-0.9507086277008057,
-0.22487232089042664,
0.23042647540569305,
0.2990945875644684,
-0.15091384947299957,
0.1204540953040123,
-0.36682042479515076,
0.7621681690216064,
0.7212792634963989,
0.5403817296028137,
0.40282464027404785,
0.18709640204906464,
-0.23801451921463013,
-0.19068995118141174,
-0.5815945863723755,
0.030680585652589798,
1.1538277864456177,
0.32275381684303284,
0.7117704749107361,
-0.14232759177684784,
0.6059393286705017,
0.2071828991174698,
-0.04220698028802872,
-0.9379576444625854,
0.15956725180149078,
-0.02808937430381775,
-0.4407784938812256,
-0.34310945868492126,
-0.5170428156852722,
-1.0870373249053955,
0.36213549971580505,
-0.25602951645851135,
-0.3722662031650543,
0.28850483894348145,
0.7405999898910522,
-0.43687304854393005,
0.3709695041179657,
-0.7015920877456665,
0.5507007241249084,
-0.27974456548690796,
-0.6447683572769165,
-0.6428312659263611,
-0.6552338004112244,
0.1822744458913803,
0.11197683215141296,
0.07017234712839127,
-0.05361131951212883,
0.01882731355726719,
0.5203786492347717,
-0.25527581572532654,
0.6582702994346619,
-0.08258664608001709,
0.19192913174629211,
0.005793641321361065,
-0.0771799385547638,
0.34057050943374634,
-0.0039186323992908,
0.20582325756549835,
-0.09648087620735168,
-0.026244666427373886,
-0.516594409942627,
-0.47325387597084045,
0.6668006181716919,
-0.999900221824646,
-0.23844793438911438,
-0.43612173199653625,
-0.47376447916030884,
-0.6251368522644043,
0.11088208109140396,
0.2853791415691376,
0.31126919388771057,
0.0014038815861567855,
0.16477465629577637,
1.0241312980651855,
-0.3760790228843689,
0.26428937911987305,
0.5830546617507935,
-0.3248235583305359,
-0.28130850195884705,
1.0885719060897827,
0.08807671070098877,
0.684329628944397,
0.583548903465271,
0.7669406533241272,
-0.24962103366851807,
-0.5641457438468933,
-0.39278310537338257,
0.20297051966190338,
-0.5394451022148132,
0.35955139994621277,
-0.2193097025156021,
0.0651715099811554,
0.2319456934928894,
-0.296314537525177,
-0.2963258922100067,
-0.07542360574007034,
-0.15329134464263916,
0.020638801157474518,
0.42917242646217346,
0.5345189571380615,
0.03226308524608612,
0.3050406575202942,
-0.2762088477611542,
0.43254515528678894,
0.16437603533267975,
0.5435271263122559,
-0.2956387996673584,
-0.31306228041648865,
-0.2503073215484619,
0.08918885886669159,
-0.3220333755016327,
-0.6001465916633606,
0.2075674831867218,
0.326812207698822,
0.5448502898216248,
0.6720837950706482,
0.2486584484577179,
0.5972352623939514,
-0.31073489785194397,
0.1121513769030571,
-0.18532636761665344,
-0.43299925327301025,
0.383991003036499,
-0.4496290385723114,
0.019610095769166946,
1.0387276411056519,
0.5888600945472717,
-0.41328564286231995,
0.06560813635587692,
-0.5499295592308044,
-0.834321141242981,
0.7227912545204163,
0.014437926933169365,
-0.021196601912379265,
0.4533538818359375,
0.31764310598373413,
0.22742526233196259,
0.16707853972911835,
-0.3577624261379242,
-0.36341381072998047,
-0.1408967524766922,
0.26243746280670166,
-0.4178212881088257,
-0.14948688447475433,
-0.28904712200164795,
-0.16454088687896729,
0.5339324474334717,
-0.30486220121383667,
0.10235103219747543,
0.1911526471376419,
0.025115886703133583,
0.02662838250398636,
0.3508927822113037,
0.8270704746246338,
0.6108361482620239,
-0.4969669282436371,
-0.08178021758794785,
0.020576950162649155,
-0.28541797399520874,
0.029789678752422333,
-0.03710459917783737,
-0.4965761601924896,
-0.33675962686538696,
0.044138118624687195,
1.2804218530654907,
0.4979695975780487,
-0.5254840850830078,
0.42529475688934326,
0.20573687553405762,
-0.31106075644493103,
-0.12227772176265717,
0.2728295922279358,
-0.23987947404384613,
-0.1832982450723648,
0.0943346694111824,
0.11852677166461945,
0.21536530554294586,
-0.5376750230789185,
0.16260169446468353,
0.3939870595932007,
-0.564592182636261,
-0.06470464169979095,
0.19205069541931152,
0.12594446539878845,
0.04741065576672554,
0.27806606888771057,
-0.18629533052444458,
-0.6807774901390076,
0.6943713426589966,
0.4770522713661194,
0.44135382771492004,
0.2286902517080307,
0.5043525099754333,
0.10411868244409561,
-0.014066058211028576,
-0.2835381329059601,
0.2584933936595917,
-0.22282588481903076,
-0.9400084018707275,
-0.33910688757896423,
-0.39293715357780457,
-0.7508260607719421,
0.18202181160449982,
-0.8842294216156006,
0.13548530638217926,
-0.49394428730010986,
0.21853655576705933,
-0.14064082503318787,
0.11342890560626984,
-0.5202353596687317,
0.38881176710128784,
-0.14904993772506714,
0.8743585348129272,
-0.8570516705513,
0.7814027070999146,
0.42006421089172363,
-0.14512436091899872,
-0.7952368855476379,
0.27692046761512756,
-0.029773246496915817,
-0.9624723196029663,
0.4644544720649719,
0.19482555985450745,
-0.13788510859012604,
0.10584837198257446,
0.10959616303443909,
-0.7078301310539246,
0.8118525743484497,
0.20753484964370728,
-0.5408228039741516,
0.11791112273931503,
0.17588357627391815,
0.43586596846580505,
-0.26146623492240906,
0.40478795766830444,
0.7035084366798401,
0.4378530979156494,
0.03364085778594017,
-1.0122473239898682,
-0.20285570621490479,
0.2650640606880188,
-0.05409322679042816,
0.41342753171920776,
-0.7692896127700806,
0.36667394638061523,
-0.31417784094810486,
0.016289126127958298,
-0.41722559928894043,
0.16805985569953918,
0.27693748474121094,
0.36841675639152527,
0.6162276268005371,
0.41346055269241333,
0.3625611364841461,
-0.2371910959482193,
1.5511304140090942,
-0.13216714560985565,
0.49334636330604553,
0.8885173797607422,
-0.13510429859161377,
0.8758851289749146,
0.4921651780605316,
-0.33508485555648804,
0.07743432372808456,
1.057619333267212,
0.1575920283794403,
1.0244436264038086,
0.3774588704109192,
-0.029751624912023544,
-0.4535762071609497,
-0.23585574328899384,
-0.4433908760547638,
0.32346922159194946,
-0.05977042764425278,
-0.30848559737205505,
-0.3299367129802704,
0.11925164610147476,
-0.025261539965867996,
0.2453605830669403,
-0.6738357543945312,
1.0350053310394287,
-0.16826286911964417,
-0.9320846796035767,
0.7050608992576599,
0.10015875101089478,
0.7314508557319641,
-0.69093257188797,
0.2916943430900574,
-0.22461633384227753,
0.6040313243865967,
-0.3312130272388458,
-0.7844893336296082,
0.3044411838054657,
-0.6050012707710266,
-0.2903903126716614,
-0.276846706867218,
0.5867098569869995,
-0.20850734412670135,
-0.10654870420694351,
0.4859173893928528,
0.14973084628582,
-0.11603596061468124,
-0.009688273072242737,
-0.6791291236877441,
-0.07791054993867874,
0.13353008031845093,
-0.3850800395011902,
0.7243385910987854,
-0.17115448415279388,
-0.256888210773468,
0.6462974548339844,
0.7437534928321838,
0.4263814687728882,
-0.016206759959459305,
0.06550749391317368,
0.8384822010993958,
-0.2621096670627594,
-0.9251429438591003,
-0.8344552516937256,
0.21669816970825195,
-0.23462635278701782,
-0.6164052486419678,
0.7081789374351501,
0.6788696646690369,
1.1236778497695923,
0.06056825816631317,
0.7824373245239258,
0.2912437915802002,
0.5985509157180786,
-0.7893478274345398,
0.5328071117401123,
-0.7319621443748474,
-0.03136196732521057,
0.012536098249256611,
-0.7793589234352112,
-0.27680885791778564,
0.7623302340507507,
-0.7698594331741333,
-0.0838177502155304,
0.4986540377140045,
0.758068859577179,
-0.3594242334365845,
-0.0162737425416708,
0.23317186534404755,
-0.27167612314224243,
0.07187946140766144,
0.37836822867393494,
0.5696079134941101,
0.0007709136698395014,
0.41918230056762695,
-0.5134922862052917,
-0.5166006088256836,
-0.44015786051750183,
-0.8891534805297852,
-0.9064474105834961,
-0.40649616718292236,
-0.021777743473649025,
-0.5240767002105713,
0.13685990869998932,
1.0441994667053223,
0.9242146015167236,
-0.8577304482460022,
-0.14030830562114716,
-0.44104161858558655,
0.011441687121987343,
-0.22216816246509552,
-0.2130509614944458,
0.3290422558784485,
-0.38294273614883423,
-0.5599609017372131,
0.37689390778541565,
0.09912349283695221,
-0.061889175325632095,
-0.4117429554462433,
-0.5049167275428772,
0.06297917664051056,
0.10008416324853897,
0.39863207936286926,
0.5648530125617981,
-0.7303239107131958,
0.07243607938289642,
-0.03210025653243065,
-0.13025496900081635,
0.41758012771606445,
1.1752434968948364,
-0.6899645328521729,
0.6944928765296936,
0.7061517238616943,
0.9121032953262329,
0.760247528553009,
0.05480461195111275,
0.579947292804718,
-0.32909417152404785,
0.03539888188242912,
-0.024649936705827713,
0.18599224090576172,
0.20220482349395752,
-0.30066293478012085,
0.2525392174720764,
0.21730442345142365,
-0.6022409200668335,
-0.7205299735069275,
0.5910120606422424,
-0.7467275857925415,
-0.27904409170150757,
1.4513019323349,
-0.10567779093980789,
0.08330193907022476,
-0.3701971173286438,
-0.48545658588409424,
-0.07702364772558212,
-0.48756328225135803,
0.9798955917358398,
0.393888920545578,
-0.33156025409698486,
-0.177779421210289,
-0.5947576761245728,
0.9830785393714905,
0.5574593544006348,
-0.8970743417739868,
-0.16812807321548462,
0.1401696801185608,
0.41400572657585144,
0.04148416966199875,
0.5839077830314636,
0.40055951476097107,
0.17900905013084412,
-0.45072489976882935,
-0.2666063904762268,
-0.30245718359947205,
-0.38910210132598877,
-0.2635307312011719,
0.07192444056272507,
0.0932983011007309,
-0.2824593782424927
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.06569v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.06569v1
|
Enhancing Clinical Documentation with Synthetic Data: Leveraging Generative Models for Improved Accuracy
| 2024-06-03T15:49:03 | 2024-06-03T15:49:03 |
Anjanava Biswas, Wrick Talukdar
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Accurate and comprehensive clinical documentation is crucial for delivering
high-quality healthcare, facilitating effective communication among providers,
and ensuring compliance with regulatory requirements. However, manual
transcription and data entry processes can be time-consuming, error-prone, and
susceptible to inconsistencies, leading to incomplete or inaccurate medical
records. This paper proposes a novel approach to augment clinical documentation
by leveraging synthetic data generation techniques to generate realistic and
diverse clinical transcripts. We present a methodology that combines
state-of-the-art generative models, such as Generative Adversarial Networks
(GANs) and Variational Autoencoders (VAEs), with real-world clinical transcript
and other forms of clinical data to generate synthetic transcripts. These
synthetic transcripts can then be used to supplement existing documentation
workflows, providing additional training data for natural language processing
models and enabling more accurate and efficient transcription processes.
Through extensive experiments on a large dataset of anonymized clinical
transcripts, we demonstrate the effectiveness of our approach in generating
high-quality synthetic transcripts that closely resemble real-world data.
Quantitative evaluation metrics, including perplexity scores and BLEU scores,
as well as qualitative assessments by domain experts, validate the fidelity and
utility of the generated synthetic transcripts. Our findings highlight
synthetic data generation's potential to address clinical documentation
challenges, improving patient care, reducing administrative burdens, and
enhancing healthcare system efficiency.
|
[
-0.03920872136950493,
-0.8226582407951355,
0.7479689717292786,
0.06987467408180237,
-0.2824435532093048,
0.2586778700351715,
-0.09720116853713989,
-0.2542339265346527,
0.30105826258659363,
0.5227338671684265,
-0.4949943423271179,
-0.8323953151702881,
-0.4447731673717499,
0.2387029379606247,
-0.490125447511673,
0.9079214930534363,
-0.06028509512543678,
0.4564533829689026,
-0.389308363199234,
-0.08778916299343109,
-0.1826602816581726,
-0.6672542691230774,
-0.22638188302516937,
-0.24874047935009003,
0.4948135316371918,
0.1063406690955162,
0.7962095737457275,
1.0523978471755981,
0.44269099831581116,
0.23468324542045593,
0.2248021513223648,
0.7283080816268921,
-0.1178661361336708,
0.38767340779304504,
0.2349380999803543,
-0.44386011362075806,
-0.7618957161903381,
-0.21163204312324524,
0.49246156215667725,
0.5308665037155151,
-0.4297366142272949,
0.013056539930403233,
-0.3184189796447754,
0.42807695269584656,
-0.33059194684028625,
0.023597627878189087,
-0.27781981229782104,
0.3252803087234497,
-0.13182997703552246,
-0.5618712306022644,
-0.3101774752140045,
-0.6352094411849976,
0.08518173545598984,
-1.0019283294677734,
0.9663536548614502,
-0.26375648379325867,
0.6855521202087402,
-0.03931942582130432,
-0.23822560906410217,
-0.6379472017288208,
-0.8183788061141968,
0.05364980548620224,
-0.9245554208755493,
0.2663823962211609,
0.12875930964946747,
0.5170389413833618,
-0.14223095774650574,
-1.214911937713623,
-0.5856581926345825,
-0.5141997933387756,
-0.4650767147541046,
0.5557289123535156,
-0.008901966735720634,
0.20122991502285004,
0.4568343758583069,
0.8382049798965454,
-0.7978090643882751,
-0.05190117284655571,
-0.5443778038024902,
-0.21364180743694305,
0.5817252397537231,
0.5809827446937561,
0.5818605422973633,
-0.16701480746269226,
-0.16830657422542572,
-0.4222937226295471,
-0.6350767612457275,
-0.3985723555088043,
0.23093388974666595,
0.05709582939743996,
-0.11249062418937683,
0.6583194136619568,
-0.1542118489742279,
0.6023238897323608,
-0.07328900694847107,
-0.15502502024173737,
0.23511071503162384,
-0.4743344187736511,
-0.30620911717414856,
0.04818836972117424,
0.797027587890625,
0.2511501610279083,
-0.3709064722061157,
-0.3345629870891571,
0.007395513821393251,
0.3642042875289917,
0.8054350018501282,
-0.6040903925895691,
-0.4234496057033539,
0.3419894278049469,
-0.5871840119361877,
-0.5534917116165161,
0.11365688592195511,
-0.9040513634681702,
-0.5081713795661926,
-0.8845410943031311,
0.11604012548923492,
-0.7146079540252686,
0.14167004823684692,
-0.0010831290856003761,
-0.280058890581131,
-0.17448994517326355,
0.6134603023529053,
-0.6591069102287292,
0.26206135749816895,
0.46170270442962646,
0.81104975938797,
-0.021941062062978745,
0.10041137784719467,
-0.5970516800880432,
0.3247567117214203,
-0.4485199451446533,
0.4524684250354767,
-0.16079571843147278,
-0.6903103590011597,
0.1829296052455902,
-0.02897045947611332,
0.14670899510383606,
-0.6773200631141663,
0.6079959869384766,
-0.16340970993041992,
0.26384106278419495,
0.1306110918521881,
-0.47696593403816223,
0.12431751191616058,
0.29717135429382324,
-0.7949744462966919,
0.6362200975418091,
0.4203917384147644,
-0.26078951358795166,
0.17361634969711304,
-0.6026160717010498,
-0.548089861869812,
0.33245474100112915,
-0.5354393720626831,
-0.5560572743415833,
0.25023531913757324,
0.3944595456123352,
0.1438625603914261,
-0.529208242893219,
0.4191080927848816,
0.10679156333208084,
-0.13826264441013336,
0.31908249855041504,
-0.6468215584754944,
0.6286541819572449,
0.2865932583808899,
-0.007632886059582233,
0.029370922595262527,
-1.0568652153015137,
-0.0712016299366951,
-0.07766404002904892,
-0.22351984679698944,
0.048204150050878525,
-0.5398340821266174,
-0.02371523529291153,
0.16084086894989014,
-0.11744444072246552,
-0.5492772459983826,
0.47088712453842163,
-0.49497735500335693,
0.223103329539299,
0.2187686562538147,
0.38177409768104553,
0.20643621683120728,
-0.8290207386016846,
0.9745177030563354,
0.03475594520568848,
0.43474262952804565,
-0.4257025420665741,
-0.33791670203208923,
-0.559516191482544,
-0.22756357491016388,
0.49207213521003723,
0.4842543601989746,
-0.7473424077033997,
0.2621285319328308,
-0.6407290697097778,
-0.6699511408805847,
-0.889295220375061,
-0.06450079381465912,
0.4413047134876251,
0.9105443954467773,
0.6052788496017456,
-0.4062958359718323,
-0.7479344606399536,
-0.7423667907714844,
0.10874312371015549,
-0.20161613821983337,
-0.36287370324134827,
0.16506987810134888,
0.21342691779136658,
-0.4538853168487549,
0.7079753279685974,
-0.6105436086654663,
-0.3448109030723572,
-0.11111059039831161,
0.5262057781219482,
0.0947151929140091,
0.6145461797714233,
0.24285869300365448,
-0.561406672000885,
-0.25470805168151855,
0.007536849472671747,
-0.9739491939544678,
-0.02606729045510292,
-0.6373676657676697,
-0.10689159482717514,
-0.034608449786901474,
0.37515854835510254,
-0.7267688512802124,
0.5711511373519897,
0.10106685757637024,
0.07974740117788315,
0.604278564453125,
-0.912371039390564,
0.2266734391450882,
-0.9750570058822632,
0.30709680914878845,
-0.2156486213207245,
-0.19510789215564728,
-0.7266132235527039,
0.058501310646533966,
0.34502506256103516,
-0.2024492621421814,
-0.21031306684017181,
0.2990567684173584,
-0.446481317281723,
0.3973817825317383,
0.2470453530550003,
-0.26171958446502686,
0.5404592752456665,
0.1263045370578766,
-0.008789842948317528,
0.5601941347122192,
0.3412493169307709,
-0.24499376118183136,
0.7317718267440796,
0.6908326148986816,
-0.07979784160852432,
0.5440871715545654,
-0.5526590943336487,
0.13965480029582977,
-0.35067927837371826,
0.5444226264953613,
-0.41991010308265686,
-0.5417385697364807,
0.12863080203533173,
-0.5362039804458618,
0.5463635921478271,
-0.24478046596050262,
-0.6855117082595825,
-0.2787264287471771,
-0.10751480609178543,
0.13144008815288544,
0.7833284139633179,
-0.3503316640853882,
0.669160783290863,
-0.03330381214618683,
-0.10244341194629669,
-0.12243346869945526,
-0.8975117206573486,
0.5383023023605347,
0.14179082214832306,
-0.558218240737915,
0.797002375125885,
0.12079057842493057,
0.0553707629442215,
-0.10327369719743729,
0.11496313661336899,
0.0543811060488224,
-0.2871745824813843,
0.2567347586154938,
0.5019258856773376,
-0.46322381496429443,
0.1087474450469017,
0.25022637844085693,
0.05847438797354698,
0.09830843657255173,
-0.34440842270851135,
0.2861725986003876,
0.2871609032154083,
-0.5706057548522949,
-0.5535587668418884,
0.5718066096305847,
0.8316410183906555,
-0.14196841418743134,
0.5783290266990662,
0.6744004487991333,
-0.5523566603660583,
-0.27988070249557495,
-0.5952901244163513,
-0.122948557138443,
-0.3912562429904938,
0.022429944947361946,
-0.02588844671845436,
-0.18222704529762268,
0.5144900679588318,
-0.07150537520647049,
-0.04330860823392868,
0.32091861963272095,
0.6165944933891296,
-0.25126132369041443,
1.0617938041687012,
-0.20523780584335327,
0.6411207914352417,
0.044249288737773895,
-0.4418798089027405,
0.12867094576358795,
-0.891852617263794,
-0.4792729616165161,
-0.13174082338809967,
0.17274489998817444,
-0.5458932518959045,
-0.7892555594444275,
0.7386942505836487,
-0.061014752835035324,
0.35588207840919495,
0.24824237823486328,
-0.5287671685218811,
0.009351328015327454,
0.4942812919616699,
0.5565701127052307,
0.4263029098510742,
-0.04592868313193321,
-0.2026388794183731,
0.05060069262981415,
-0.8272240161895752,
-0.6210251450538635,
1.2438594102859497,
0.3079410493373871,
0.5445324182510376,
-0.04375956580042839,
0.6159861087799072,
0.5378701090812683,
0.5909953713417053,
-0.2455662190914154,
0.08128545433282852,
-0.4623234272003174,
-0.18318437039852142,
-0.050988685339689255,
-0.17867781221866608,
-0.7269874811172485,
0.02934849075973034,
-0.3485524654388428,
-0.047260113060474396,
0.28720924258232117,
0.5056028962135315,
-0.629084050655365,
-0.15755468606948853,
-0.5574150681495667,
0.8534988760948181,
-0.2456449270248413,
-0.22978779673576355,
0.03692837432026863,
-0.714695394039154,
0.28613728284835815,
-0.027940137311816216,
-0.014284598641097546,
0.34328991174697876,
0.15447069704532623,
0.2797045409679413,
-0.9874981045722961,
0.7660524249076843,
0.046688731759786606,
-0.22108198702335358,
0.11353602260351181,
0.034274619072675705,
0.7095902562141418,
0.46629437804222107,
-0.08852620422840118,
-0.01755569502711296,
0.0202022697776556,
-0.24665023386478424,
-1.1388208866119385,
0.5045046806335449,
-0.38102853298187256,
-0.36983752250671387,
-0.20260606706142426,
-0.4105831980705261,
-0.3712158799171448,
-0.08734160661697388,
0.5765148997306824,
0.9404251575469971,
-0.43463194370269775,
-0.08997365087270737,
0.4927501976490021,
-0.4627975523471832,
-0.2971724569797516,
0.4312436580657959,
0.4264860451221466,
-0.6838061213493347,
0.8538480401039124,
0.06602664291858673,
0.33738815784454346,
0.269233375787735,
0.038314320147037506,
-0.5684913992881775,
-0.7920499444007874,
-0.8803945183753967,
0.3126263916492462,
-0.8596392273902893,
-0.24390751123428345,
-0.703423798084259,
-0.4372953772544861,
-0.8118446469306946,
-0.30925247073173523,
-0.04559199884533882,
-0.5050397515296936,
-0.5327879786491394,
-0.19408178329467773,
0.13287565112113953,
0.4949935972690582,
0.034647922962903976,
0.18499287962913513,
-1.205557107925415,
0.7145414352416992,
0.12143850326538086,
0.11760222166776657,
-0.07276573032140732,
-0.3130275011062622,
-0.032411910593509674,
0.36493468284606934,
-0.2699951231479645,
-0.6657617092132568,
0.7542950510978699,
0.06599262356758118,
0.56779944896698,
0.20857326686382294,
0.0908278375864029,
0.9946385622024536,
-0.49544063210487366,
0.7061119675636292,
0.2348986268043518,
-0.6822549700737,
0.683944821357727,
-0.6107452511787415,
0.14506536722183228,
0.5455726981163025,
0.04313431307673454,
-0.5406914353370667,
-0.5801551342010498,
-0.9178900122642517,
-0.7444945573806763,
0.5107287764549255,
0.48631197214126587,
0.1000932976603508,
-0.04808419197797775,
0.5246756076812744,
0.300802618265152,
0.16122397780418396,
-0.09643878042697906,
-0.1754174381494522,
-0.4015379548072815,
-0.6604591012001038,
0.04511042311787605,
-0.053966596722602844,
-0.5411338210105896,
-0.21603885293006897,
0.44334372878074646,
-0.05839060992002487,
0.3427387773990631,
0.5616551637649536,
-0.06742335855960846,
0.07109767198562622,
0.007641557138413191,
0.8023716807365417,
0.609366238117218,
0.0025593650061637163,
0.029435841366648674,
0.022623708471655846,
-0.654609739780426,
0.09395800530910492,
0.19626712799072266,
-0.19082781672477722,
0.400829017162323,
0.45529112219810486,
0.8693095445632935,
-0.3274134695529938,
-0.7936221957206726,
0.35064804553985596,
-0.25068846344947815,
-0.3482370376586914,
-0.5039330720901489,
0.1370140016078949,
-0.0050832056440413,
-0.22022314369678497,
-0.06928321719169617,
0.09119182825088501,
0.2302127480506897,
-0.4360317587852478,
0.37277752161026,
0.09389285743236542,
-0.1364220529794693,
-0.14616383612155914,
0.5986996293067932,
0.05548669770359993,
-0.3141176700592041,
0.7365991473197937,
0.11275514215230942,
-0.07526413351297379,
0.7648287415504456,
0.730256974697113,
0.6653613448143005,
-0.1645994633436203,
0.4224990904331207,
0.3888162672519684,
-0.07194321602582932,
-0.22392654418945312,
0.0893288180232048,
-0.08396740257740021,
-0.06369134783744812,
-0.2501264214515686,
-0.5551772117614746,
-0.5832780003547668,
0.3697148263454437,
-0.8467727899551392,
0.33033373951911926,
-0.3640168607234955,
0.06491702049970627,
0.13193292915821075,
-0.552050769329071,
-0.523281455039978,
0.5633797645568848,
0.07250334322452545,
0.7164410352706909,
-0.704494297504425,
0.6318324208259583,
0.4659682810306549,
-0.6095141768455505,
-0.643403947353363,
-0.015505081973969936,
-0.04995129629969597,
-0.6319953203201294,
0.27970921993255615,
-0.24565154314041138,
0.22806423902511597,
-0.1462852507829666,
0.10156390815973282,
-0.4455212950706482,
1.196252465248108,
0.2864653468132019,
-0.5246077179908752,
-0.3115549087524414,
0.6221681237220764,
1.208451747894287,
-0.3565064072608948,
0.29431307315826416,
0.5103868246078491,
0.2045614868402481,
0.32749781012535095,
-0.5485588908195496,
0.3931564688682556,
-0.5825032591819763,
0.19962354004383087,
-0.11245036125183105,
-0.11221936345100403,
0.46512922644615173,
0.09034056216478348,
-0.25534093379974365,
0.18562637269496918,
0.2415841817855835,
0.11974691599607468,
0.2314685434103012,
0.1376250833272934,
0.426497220993042,
0.8826801180839539,
-0.040422361344099045,
1.1763124465942383,
-0.22175855934619904,
-0.21461009979248047,
1.03141188621521,
-0.16429835557937622,
0.1382436901330948,
0.10591995716094971,
-0.14570260047912598,
0.6054159998893738,
0.2545192241668701,
-0.2389184981584549,
0.08599436283111572,
0.44147393107414246,
-0.638310968875885,
-0.17059992253780365,
-0.13903671503067017,
-0.3789951801300049,
0.23014014959335327,
0.5842761993408203,
-0.9347397089004517,
-0.08191395550966263,
0.08250022679567337,
-0.29836854338645935,
0.11374277621507645,
0.18231092393398285,
1.0323081016540527,
-0.0704401284456253,
-0.9920974373817444,
0.7708649635314941,
-0.061413489282131195,
-0.09196619689464569,
-0.6182626485824585,
-0.4243011474609375,
-0.233114555478096,
-0.029185304418206215,
-0.28743600845336914,
-0.41116371750831604,
0.4392837882041931,
0.1474524885416031,
-0.16105443239212036,
-0.6188467144966125,
0.37459665536880493,
-0.5416094064712524,
-0.6761493682861328,
-0.3640209436416626,
0.2606888711452484,
-0.24824705719947815,
0.22988756000995636,
-0.4012881815433502,
-0.3454008996486664,
-0.14026641845703125,
0.25571081042289734,
0.26137933135032654,
0.5447897911071777,
-0.07938012480735779,
0.22031323611736298,
1.1101974248886108,
0.614690899848938,
0.004572740755975246,
0.4727845788002014,
0.7649998664855957,
-0.2840862274169922,
-0.6537569165229797,
-0.6589829921722412,
0.5278971791267395,
-0.4783496856689453,
-0.37293675541877747,
0.37816110253334045,
0.7285066246986389,
0.40754374861717224,
-0.3566855490207672,
1.0252071619033813,
0.2303244024515152,
0.6295470595359802,
-0.6654857993125916,
0.7988046407699585,
-0.27719753980636597,
0.22504626214504242,
0.0402604378759861,
-0.14718815684318542,
-0.5503131747245789,
0.19998988509178162,
0.11318325251340866,
-0.4647175371646881,
0.5039981007575989,
0.9133264422416687,
-0.2064548134803772,
0.08044791221618652,
0.15539142489433289,
0.05435551702976227,
0.6342450380325317,
0.330950528383255,
0.6751430630683899,
-0.4929144084453583,
0.41439735889434814,
-0.4266945719718933,
-0.037481680512428284,
-0.17158319056034088,
-0.6891984343528748,
-0.47973504662513733,
-0.43053627014160156,
-0.4437941610813141,
-0.5454738736152649,
0.23688115179538727,
0.6979701519012451,
0.6365318298339844,
-0.7061461210250854,
0.31907209753990173,
-0.6542780995368958,
-0.46235522627830505,
-0.17795394361019135,
-0.17049217224121094,
0.5884311199188232,
-0.3258567452430725,
-0.5688706636428833,
0.43474239110946655,
0.3258228302001953,
0.6780939698219299,
-0.10549914091825485,
-0.10170502960681915,
0.2924429774284363,
-0.06289094686508179,
0.2826225459575653,
0.30536720156669617,
-0.667294979095459,
0.41238483786582947,
0.0869741141796112,
-0.3944433033466339,
0.2778833508491516,
0.9831224083900452,
-0.7759169340133667,
0.8481561541557312,
0.5288020968437195,
0.5520864129066467,
0.6902967095375061,
0.47600993514060974,
1.0449775457382202,
-0.7655704021453857,
-0.243009552359581,
0.6726961135864258,
0.07094404846429825,
0.3545302450656891,
-0.7051150798797607,
0.42191648483276367,
0.2964003384113312,
-0.07081864774227142,
-0.893744170665741,
-0.0563478097319603,
-0.8187151551246643,
0.006655162200331688,
0.9543659687042236,
-0.30231064558029175,
0.06341931223869324,
-0.3281994163990021,
-0.29058244824409485,
0.5727369785308838,
0.13516314327716827,
1.0747506618499756,
0.29880616068840027,
-0.46439144015312195,
0.2417834848165512,
-0.403526246547699,
0.8490464687347412,
0.31113681197166443,
-1.0863484144210815,
0.17776595056056976,
0.6632332801818848,
-0.03008541651070118,
0.2067156583070755,
0.6427094340324402,
-0.4796616733074188,
0.7267886400222778,
0.12182506173849106,
-0.2953462302684784,
-0.41456711292266846,
-0.004791031125932932,
-0.3386610448360443,
0.15242598950862885,
-0.44662877917289734,
-0.06311987340450287
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.01457v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.01457v1
|
Differentially Private Tabular Data Synthesis using Large Language Models
| 2024-06-03T15:43:57 | 2024-06-03T15:43:57 |
Toan V. Tran, Li Xiong
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CR
|
Synthetic tabular data generation with differential privacy is a crucial
problem to enable data sharing with formal privacy. Despite a rich history of
methodological research and development, developing differentially private
tabular data generators that can provide realistic synthetic datasets remains
challenging. This paper introduces DP-LLMTGen -- a novel framework for
differentially private tabular data synthesis that leverages pretrained large
language models (LLMs). DP-LLMTGen models sensitive datasets using a two-stage
fine-tuning procedure with a novel loss function specifically designed for
tabular data. Subsequently, it generates synthetic data through sampling the
fine-tuned LLMs. Our empirical evaluation demonstrates that DP-LLMTGen
outperforms a variety of existing mechanisms across multiple datasets and
privacy settings. Additionally, we conduct an ablation study and several
experimental analyses to deepen our understanding of LLMs in addressing this
important problem. Finally, we highlight the controllable generation ability of
DP-LLMTGen through a fairness-constrained generation setting.
|
[
-0.25262314081192017,
-0.7635945081710815,
0.6378130912780762,
0.20000207424163818,
-0.14313295483589172,
0.4104222059249878,
-0.25298160314559937,
-0.09914431720972061,
-0.23738141357898712,
0.6504993438720703,
-0.7693080902099609,
-0.8367577791213989,
-0.28867286443710327,
0.03945246711373329,
-0.6138284802436829,
1.026562213897705,
-0.1667199432849884,
0.03354364633560181,
0.16621866822242737,
0.2535875141620636,
-0.09070815145969391,
-0.6606482863426208,
-0.01302606426179409,
-0.027073107659816742,
0.5407053232192993,
0.4564443826675415,
0.5676174163818359,
0.977605402469635,
0.4139873683452606,
0.3232164680957794,
0.18105342984199524,
0.20876498520374298,
-0.7590649127960205,
0.31811216473579407,
0.028701959177851677,
-0.5049168467521667,
-0.6348777413368225,
-0.033539846539497375,
1.0555838346481323,
0.6945438981056213,
-0.2974647581577301,
0.1925322562456131,
0.21255315840244293,
0.9133960604667664,
-0.4111657738685608,
0.10290426760911942,
-1.1656785011291504,
0.38606908917427063,
-0.5320771336555481,
-0.13861116766929626,
-0.450975626707077,
-0.815409243106842,
-0.32850146293640137,
-0.20855674147605896,
0.5403890013694763,
0.11275272071361542,
0.2685345709323883,
0.2546488642692566,
-0.349697470664978,
0.14382921159267426,
-0.862271785736084,
0.5792899131774902,
-0.5788633227348328,
0.584455668926239,
0.2954308092594147,
0.32430824637413025,
-0.5099791288375854,
-0.7986115217208862,
-0.7041924595832825,
-0.4929736256599426,
-0.088715560734272,
-0.28254926204681396,
-0.04266006499528885,
0.15131284296512604,
0.22392022609710693,
0.4804808795452118,
-0.6584059000015259,
0.3887384831905365,
-0.32417866587638855,
-0.13939428329467773,
0.7249296307563782,
0.4431200623512268,
-0.06445033848285675,
0.05840333178639412,
-0.1419091820716858,
0.006763167213648558,
-0.9852691888809204,
-0.31356388330459595,
0.9535571932792664,
0.4497770071029663,
-0.1972878873348236,
0.6062616109848022,
-0.2787860035896301,
0.47677797079086304,
0.0362824872136116,
0.015900036320090294,
0.04391104727983475,
-0.05722248926758766,
-0.3262290060520172,
0.22412025928497314,
0.7358408570289612,
0.25161096453666687,
0.11962234973907471,
-0.27832600474357605,
-0.1527305543422699,
0.21648503839969635,
-0.023227617144584656,
-0.8093231916427612,
-0.2732618451118469,
0.22211283445358276,
-0.13825654983520508,
-0.7756386399269104,
-0.17315062880516052,
-0.9895176887512207,
-0.5785313844680786,
-0.2453734278678894,
0.18138913810253143,
0.13339143991470337,
-0.09942497313022614,
0.014556282199919224,
0.17110824584960938,
-0.32691627740859985,
0.029966620728373528,
-1.033104419708252,
0.6798545122146606,
0.5751522183418274,
0.5021978616714478,
-0.4063294231891632,
-0.18007168173789978,
-0.6605895161628723,
0.507729709148407,
-0.44536739587783813,
0.25967979431152344,
-0.45307254791259766,
-0.4897516369819641,
0.12366453558206558,
-0.017226871103048325,
0.45311638712882996,
-0.6340097188949585,
0.10073152929544449,
-0.29781776666641235,
0.1581539660692215,
-0.11046391725540161,
-0.23362086713314056,
0.21314261853694916,
0.056128520518541336,
-0.5938352942466736,
0.5307629108428955,
0.2244800627231598,
-0.6462029218673706,
0.4807185232639313,
-0.5222986340522766,
-0.36913001537323,
0.054533351212739944,
-0.6264128088951111,
-0.813800036907196,
0.3210781514644623,
-0.18692193925380707,
0.542807400226593,
-0.19053710997104645,
0.5589221119880676,
-0.4458146095275879,
-0.10530433803796768,
0.613865077495575,
-0.5264647603034973,
0.3290542662143707,
0.26235127449035645,
-0.5541786551475525,
-0.117316834628582,
-0.9978983402252197,
-0.025830792263150215,
0.14049793779850006,
-0.314314067363739,
0.04911371320486069,
-0.1025627925992012,
-0.14600954949855804,
0.008610062301158905,
0.27519795298576355,
-0.5096058249473572,
0.19153860211372375,
-0.3354138731956482,
0.3736981451511383,
0.9857473969459534,
-0.07506618648767471,
0.6051769256591797,
-0.2859337627887726,
0.487815260887146,
-0.01463730912655592,
0.16389191150665283,
0.4131391942501068,
-0.051071491092443466,
-0.1459289938211441,
-0.3191092610359192,
0.5610361695289612,
0.28111037611961365,
-0.25607097148895264,
0.41774454712867737,
-0.1501745581626892,
-0.27981239557266235,
-0.16554206609725952,
-0.012514756061136723,
0.32775643467903137,
0.6300540566444397,
0.04316524416208267,
-0.08412887901067734,
-0.4693250358104706,
-1.1932188272476196,
-0.03850235044956207,
0.23822161555290222,
-0.008982888422906399,
0.4394777715206146,
0.15322642028331757,
-0.0964510515332222,
0.5845958590507507,
-0.6245381236076355,
-0.49522730708122253,
-0.2976864278316498,
-0.07035022974014282,
0.07575003802776337,
0.6972586512565613,
0.38244497776031494,
-0.5826513171195984,
-0.6276854872703552,
0.001369639066979289,
-0.388906866312027,
-0.36645615100860596,
-0.0524895079433918,
-0.32253700494766235,
0.29172787070274353,
0.11634837836027145,
-0.40314769744873047,
0.5260944366455078,
0.7273472547531128,
-0.14891815185546875,
0.29686781764030457,
-0.27728918194770813,
0.09733272343873978,
-0.7507018446922302,
0.0031558480113744736,
-0.30802595615386963,
-0.4433344900608063,
-0.7304650545120239,
-0.0017310481052845716,
0.0928322896361351,
-0.32941171526908875,
-0.6924263834953308,
0.429334431886673,
-0.4191981256008148,
-0.2246331125497818,
-0.19288106262683868,
-0.07129604369401932,
-0.032414939254522324,
0.49495604634284973,
-0.09537124633789062,
0.5654619336128235,
0.39087778329849243,
-0.6643049120903015,
0.14742493629455566,
0.4087132513523102,
-0.10079455375671387,
0.09245993942022324,
-0.4364585876464844,
0.07042751461267471,
-0.095547616481781,
0.2807656228542328,
-0.7336063385009766,
-0.3902199864387512,
0.40417876839637756,
-0.1708008199930191,
0.5705541372299194,
-0.19129496812820435,
-0.6156231164932251,
-0.14522503316402435,
-0.28636837005615234,
0.32172998785972595,
0.8367303609848022,
-0.4544227123260498,
0.2592936158180237,
0.7338874340057373,
-0.29353034496307373,
-0.5506523847579956,
-1.10685133934021,
-0.008196830749511719,
-0.46916601061820984,
-0.4379275143146515,
0.7423732280731201,
-0.03134562820196152,
-0.40166735649108887,
-0.174527108669281,
-0.25712040066719055,
-0.20731239020824432,
-0.029695099219679832,
0.22123587131500244,
-0.006739635486155748,
0.4668690264225006,
-0.09982763975858688,
0.5274419188499451,
-0.12303853034973145,
0.0617796890437603,
-0.08226815611124039,
0.7330948114395142,
0.15033383667469025,
-0.19363205134868622,
-0.44747093319892883,
0.49641141295433044,
0.0742252916097641,
-0.20064713060855865,
0.6915507316589355,
0.39178532361984253,
-0.29393646121025085,
-0.7822282314300537,
-0.44659000635147095,
-0.18600690364837646,
-0.6135345697402954,
0.3335350751876831,
-0.18871933221817017,
-0.7082472443580627,
0.6584817171096802,
-0.03452610597014427,
0.2490692138671875,
-0.0710480734705925,
0.8007346391677856,
0.23341163992881775,
0.9474044442176819,
0.5624654293060303,
0.2528538107872009,
0.3737892210483551,
-0.2449924349784851,
0.01571531593799591,
-0.37373217940330505,
-0.134746253490448,
-0.5960655808448792,
-0.6126075387001038,
-1.1406176090240479,
-0.11585388332605362,
0.5385432243347168,
-0.43250811100006104,
-0.26343992352485657,
-0.0740048736333847,
-0.677948534488678,
0.5250840783119202,
0.48931920528411865,
0.3280700147151947,
0.40337935090065,
0.21444296836853027,
0.005575912073254585,
-0.15847332775592804,
-0.3076377809047699,
-0.4343041479587555,
1.1757224798202515,
0.269600510597229,
1.0579830408096313,
0.09856413304805756,
1.24839448928833,
0.24267995357513428,
0.19054514169692993,
-0.08990196138620377,
0.7850322127342224,
-0.6173157691955566,
-0.6118913888931274,
-0.3080858290195465,
-0.8303283452987671,
-0.8205184936523438,
-0.021785322576761246,
-0.11924217641353607,
-0.6433658003807068,
0.06548432260751724,
0.4964061975479126,
-0.09764004498720169,
0.18175052106380463,
-0.6324899792671204,
0.7033087611198425,
-0.155424103140831,
-0.9460020065307617,
-0.05414557084441185,
-0.553169846534729,
0.5505394339561462,
-0.4186409115791321,
0.16008363664150238,
-0.2947239279747009,
0.22801357507705688,
0.4815686345100403,
-0.355876624584198,
0.7583582401275635,
-0.6345498561859131,
-0.23713594675064087,
0.032427720725536346,
0.5799082517623901,
0.6657308340072632,
0.5246715545654297,
-0.1099630743265152,
0.19442935287952423,
-0.16431450843811035,
0.033475685864686966,
-0.29728272557258606,
1.0747079849243164,
-0.45173677802085876,
-0.79813551902771,
-0.12669984996318817,
-0.6598008871078491,
-0.34312695264816284,
0.3191167116165161,
0.15097616612911224,
0.4298956096172333,
-0.04834451153874397,
0.33042752742767334,
0.5500702857971191,
-0.5561872720718384,
0.229302778840065,
0.592866837978363,
-0.23962098360061646,
-0.25647398829460144,
0.8279964923858643,
0.26089808344841003,
0.04894273728132248,
0.46455612778663635,
0.36816340684890747,
-0.6240142583847046,
-0.9158731698989868,
-0.3382115364074707,
0.13594184815883636,
-0.21835578978061676,
-0.2763447165489197,
-0.5240004658699036,
-0.2399732768535614,
-0.3213551342487335,
-0.03261249139904976,
-0.5195174813270569,
-0.6849035620689392,
-0.1686193346977234,
-0.40484651923179626,
0.3589473068714142,
0.3942556381225586,
-0.5600853562355042,
0.10677818953990936,
-0.7905556559562683,
0.7078302502632141,
0.1999717801809311,
0.726747989654541,
-0.28889331221580505,
-0.20186156034469604,
0.09338512271642685,
0.11065183579921722,
-0.48708227276802063,
-0.9680517315864563,
0.6941728591918945,
0.05679319426417351,
0.5231854319572449,
-0.22652576863765717,
0.5277231335639954,
0.43213340640068054,
-0.8921816945075989,
0.5959659814834595,
-0.1703910380601883,
-0.901497483253479,
0.26392027735710144,
-0.6237161755561829,
-0.12749533355236053,
0.6375962495803833,
0.1004415974020958,
0.06493344902992249,
-0.7465367317199707,
-0.4492892026901245,
-0.9372725486755371,
0.6055004000663757,
0.3948501944541931,
0.23670315742492676,
0.39897507429122925,
0.3655141294002533,
0.7378891706466675,
0.6505584716796875,
-1.0898557901382446,
-0.27795907855033875,
-0.004531301092356443,
-0.400934100151062,
0.06501724570989609,
-0.016402101144194603,
-0.48406416177749634,
0.05661874637007713,
0.3973352611064911,
0.24736323952674866,
0.2161833941936493,
0.03042803704738617,
0.2105179876089096,
-0.28796419501304626,
0.4426494240760803,
0.5479090809822083,
0.6255767941474915,
-0.2730059027671814,
0.08625008910894394,
-0.12520477175712585,
-0.39731594920158386,
0.3998291492462158,
0.49204516410827637,
-0.1944962590932846,
-0.0943489596247673,
-0.5082007050514221,
0.44362035393714905,
-0.42319610714912415,
-0.4016760289669037,
0.3267748951911926,
-0.35095348954200745,
-0.6075147390365601,
-0.46160122752189636,
0.14308343827724457,
-0.2169799953699112,
0.15161378681659698,
0.20015743374824524,
-0.4152251183986664,
0.2132141888141632,
-0.21355536580085754,
0.4199404716491699,
0.442888468503952,
0.1982850879430771,
-0.25607991218566895,
1.0960928201675415,
0.08601163327693939,
-0.18170613050460815,
0.32237112522125244,
-0.1917056292295456,
0.0006734704948030412,
0.253406822681427,
0.34647977352142334,
0.9378610253334045,
-0.19750404357910156,
0.39954885840415955,
-0.22265195846557617,
0.12094169855117798,
0.1682860106229782,
0.4622034430503845,
-0.14816948771476746,
-0.3561992049217224,
-0.10982568562030792,
-0.8008294105529785,
-0.4501630663871765,
0.5389899611473083,
-0.5189763903617859,
0.07942651212215424,
-0.6227971911430359,
-0.09774882346391678,
-0.18362100422382355,
0.053336139768362045,
-0.7309684157371521,
0.10009513795375824,
0.07881762087345123,
0.28935134410858154,
-0.6144042015075684,
0.7630670666694641,
0.04931974038481712,
0.1698899269104004,
-0.6311644315719604,
0.06537973135709763,
-0.0921861082315445,
-0.7299372553825378,
0.6228159070014954,
-0.052473604679107666,
0.19721223413944244,
0.07614126801490784,
-0.3629392683506012,
-0.48182806372642517,
0.8286899328231812,
0.6501438617706299,
-1.1050143241882324,
-0.04355922341346741,
0.8620269298553467,
0.6129713654518127,
-0.0636722669005394,
-0.64119553565979,
0.5210770964622498,
0.6019002199172974,
-0.24669045209884644,
-0.7790613174438477,
0.265855073928833,
0.2204454243183136,
-0.15296390652656555,
0.2928127944469452,
-0.5638044476509094,
0.8107646107673645,
0.16618628799915314,
-0.12900786101818085,
-0.0904337540268898,
0.35784584283828735,
0.4599565267562866,
0.41312748193740845,
0.21589922904968262,
0.298168420791626,
0.5136715173721313,
-0.08629418909549713,
0.5977047681808472,
-0.5184093117713928,
-0.021407542750239372,
1.0394978523254395,
-0.697886049747467,
0.31856614351272583,
0.4122922718524933,
-0.08947435021400452,
-0.03200746327638626,
0.2589331567287445,
-0.006634420715272427,
0.9022004008293152,
0.7949557304382324,
-0.39683523774147034,
0.1652117371559143,
0.01185576617717743,
-0.6565602421760559,
0.3219335675239563,
0.2850249707698822,
-0.6234766840934753,
-0.10799936205148697,
-0.16685904562473297,
-0.03526347875595093,
0.3264799416065216,
-0.13610899448394775,
0.6331679224967957,
-0.007729746401309967,
-0.2691560387611389,
0.6085227131843567,
0.12541131675243378,
0.26365625858306885,
-0.5230919718742371,
0.10704948753118515,
-0.41013583540916443,
0.34804606437683105,
-0.2323145568370819,
-0.5988754034042358,
0.45176681876182556,
0.2337169200181961,
0.09010668843984604,
-0.5049346089363098,
0.33955806493759155,
-0.6714162826538086,
-0.39173224568367004,
-0.18164868652820587,
0.5552623271942139,
-0.015509292483329773,
0.23548638820648193,
-0.46722596883773804,
0.27306464314460754,
0.19205226004123688,
-0.4023342430591583,
0.7250816822052002,
0.5699560642242432,
0.1689463108778,
0.33609235286712646,
0.6222456097602844,
0.4102798402309418,
0.10157430917024612,
0.22183838486671448,
1.1613819599151611,
-0.6169472336769104,
-0.8144435882568359,
-0.9285324215888977,
0.609958291053772,
0.17727799713611603,
0.11808160692453384,
0.6697754859924316,
0.5414823293685913,
0.7635334134101868,
-0.23386703431606293,
1.0554900169372559,
0.130522683262825,
0.6713597178459167,
-0.684683620929718,
0.9358508586883545,
-0.5459561347961426,
0.41827794909477234,
-0.2707849442958832,
-0.9434314966201782,
-0.4624602496623993,
0.35690972208976746,
-0.17039477825164795,
-0.09498750418424606,
0.37469035387039185,
1.0193533897399902,
0.03614906594157219,
-0.27802979946136475,
0.42043963074684143,
0.46066954731941223,
0.693820595741272,
0.41357284784317017,
0.976784348487854,
-0.11352569609880447,
0.5657615065574646,
-0.5715860724449158,
-0.2942448854446411,
0.2631802260875702,
-1.0271166563034058,
-0.8562304973602295,
-0.5279038548469543,
-0.1841886192560196,
-0.15458090603351593,
0.20692121982574463,
0.7032688856124878,
0.5763625502586365,
-0.3829330801963806,
-0.17907749116420746,
-0.640613853931427,
-0.03471694886684418,
0.3457702100276947,
-0.2369215190410614,
0.29851633310317993,
0.18012532591819763,
-0.9099180698394775,
0.4368308186531067,
0.07107574492692947,
0.48157599568367004,
-0.5251191854476929,
0.2646036446094513,
0.6125659942626953,
-0.16009950637817383,
0.07039576023817062,
0.07950390130281448,
-0.2383849024772644,
-0.02587953209877014,
-0.21028859913349152,
0.08542677760124207,
0.05766426771879196,
0.774355947971344,
-0.5678015947341919,
0.10205613821744919,
0.4274086654186249,
0.3863053321838379,
0.6301746964454651,
0.15385623276233673,
0.7009788155555725,
-1.2066924571990967,
0.520779550075531,
0.4719797968864441,
0.12821893393993378,
0.189968541264534,
-0.7535544633865356,
0.17281930148601532,
-0.060605794191360474,
-0.9658146500587463,
-1.4676588773727417,
0.4817740321159363,
-0.8577595949172974,
-0.09382864832878113,
1.0979729890823364,
0.0982259213924408,
-0.2832016050815582,
0.16527171432971954,
-0.10890895128250122,
0.2539694011211395,
-0.7555500268936157,
1.2701091766357422,
-0.002813120372593403,
-0.2803678512573242,
0.08960392326116562,
-0.315710186958313,
0.7772080302238464,
-0.03878803178668022,
-0.8273094892501831,
0.6531647443771362,
0.7959049940109253,
0.15659759938716888,
-0.40807345509529114,
0.7378630042076111,
-0.5166283845901489,
-0.06527731567621231,
0.03874312713742256,
-0.28565844893455505,
-0.5555926561355591,
-0.5334897637367249,
-0.15512555837631226,
0.29694727063179016,
-0.10081900656223297,
-0.21268579363822937
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.01446v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.01446v1
|
Enabling ASR for Low-Resource Languages: A Comprehensive Dataset Creation Approach
| 2024-06-03T15:38:40 | 2024-06-03T15:38:40 |
Ara Yeroyan, Nikolay Karpov
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG, eess.AS, eess.SP
|
In recent years, automatic speech recognition (ASR) systems have
significantly improved, especially in languages with a vast amount of
transcribed speech data. However, ASR systems tend to perform poorly for
low-resource languages with fewer resources, such as minority and regional
languages. This study introduces a novel pipeline designed to generate ASR
training datasets from audiobooks, which typically feature a single transcript
associated with hours-long audios. The common structure of these audiobooks
poses a unique challenge due to the extensive length of audio segments, whereas
optimal ASR training requires segments ranging from 4 to 15 seconds. To address
this, we propose a method for effectively aligning audio with its corresponding
text and segmenting it into lengths suitable for ASR training. Our approach
simplifies data preparation for ASR systems in low-resource languages and
demonstrates its application through a case study involving the Armenian
language. Our method, which is "portable" to many low-resource languages, not
only mitigates the issue of data scarcity but also enhances the performance of
ASR models for underrepresented languages.
|
[
-0.2570134103298187,
-0.09616091847419739,
0.035150252282619476,
-0.10352988541126251,
-0.43016019463539124,
0.15679165720939636,
-0.500128448009491,
-0.3171009123325348,
0.25433436036109924,
0.5120569467544556,
-0.5098956823348999,
-0.3238830864429474,
-0.3916705846786499,
0.23134943842887878,
-0.5295953154563904,
0.9342419505119324,
0.09366229921579361,
0.0003819455741904676,
-0.014345178380608559,
-0.62114417552948,
-0.45160412788391113,
-0.38224753737449646,
-0.6793275475502014,
-0.29528093338012695,
0.11780296266078949,
0.7598941326141357,
0.3777911961078644,
1.280640721321106,
0.5025058388710022,
0.2624864876270294,
-0.10023808479309082,
0.0872204378247261,
-0.003519980004057288,
0.24494588375091553,
0.17024832963943481,
-0.015334971249103546,
-0.21754015982151031,
-0.48876115679740906,
0.9547693729400635,
0.8682920336723328,
-0.4288119673728943,
0.5283056497573853,
0.2252787947654724,
0.8912544250488281,
-0.5493723154067993,
-0.2298622727394104,
-0.4171459376811981,
0.13589179515838623,
-0.7381065487861633,
0.011838396079838276,
0.05252475664019585,
-0.0830112025141716,
0.1622384935617447,
-0.6358415484428406,
0.49856480956077576,
0.0040838406421244144,
0.41747358441352844,
0.5366299152374268,
-0.2219662070274353,
-0.4874129891395569,
-1.0449177026748657,
0.9149640202522278,
-0.5867807269096375,
0.4636041522026062,
0.4820495843887329,
0.48777157068252563,
0.38370728492736816,
-0.3088121712207794,
-0.6386887431144714,
0.10494089871644974,
-0.007577487267553806,
-0.24927669763565063,
-0.03204522281885147,
-0.22457413375377655,
0.33618491888046265,
0.3766965866088867,
-0.682634174823761,
0.028743872418999672,
-0.535052478313446,
-0.13705533742904663,
0.6411780714988708,
0.30909398198127747,
0.3179203271865845,
-0.2691994607448578,
0.15125764906406403,
-0.207142174243927,
-0.4840344488620758,
0.26122280955314636,
0.4896411895751953,
0.8509601950645447,
-0.10372717678546906,
0.7336097359657288,
-0.21857184171676636,
0.724083662033081,
-0.06299762427806854,
-0.3569530248641968,
0.34295645356178284,
-0.3555384576320648,
0.015752676874399185,
0.7409988045692444,
0.7792201638221741,
-0.08580434322357178,
-0.006697688717395067,
0.09490661323070526,
-0.4510466754436493,
0.1530720442533493,
0.06414760649204254,
-0.5639827251434326,
-0.1279059797525406,
0.14627361297607422,
-0.5257673859596252,
0.0054722679778933525,
-0.31222373247146606,
-0.610019326210022,
-0.38281869888305664,
-0.38116830587387085,
0.2331087589263916,
-0.4623596966266632,
-0.05210350081324577,
0.08927560597658157,
-0.05263955146074295,
0.018416883423924446,
-0.017909370362758636,
-1.116135597229004,
0.7117230892181396,
0.28784090280532837,
0.9195621609687805,
-0.08034639805555344,
-0.049981094896793365,
-0.8745735883712769,
0.40261754393577576,
-0.13129980862140656,
0.8442245721817017,
-0.5675941109657288,
-0.42104822397232056,
0.103000707924366,
-0.22935929894447327,
0.2902376055717468,
-0.5715035200119019,
0.6641636490821838,
-0.17240528762340546,
-0.08726757764816284,
-0.2010185569524765,
-0.43036332726478577,
0.16068072617053986,
0.07219110429286957,
-0.8261300921440125,
0.983962893486023,
-0.22209253907203674,
-0.6091613173484802,
0.2493482083082199,
-0.6896358132362366,
-0.716037392616272,
0.049495745450258255,
-0.4232746660709381,
-0.3625640869140625,
-0.2093907743692398,
0.4426632523536682,
0.11424217373132706,
-0.4444723427295685,
-0.1399562805891037,
0.36965689063072205,
-0.3674715757369995,
0.1133158877491951,
-0.48608288168907166,
0.5859023928642273,
0.27580323815345764,
-0.17228445410728455,
-0.21140863001346588,
-1.0308609008789062,
0.013257049024105072,
-0.019446156919002533,
-0.758095383644104,
-0.44175493717193604,
0.2112646996974945,
0.4319400191307068,
-0.25067779421806335,
0.18488499522209167,
-0.8658942580223083,
0.029843632131814957,
-0.4669361710548401,
0.25956809520721436,
0.4264433979988098,
-0.17681358754634857,
0.5594676733016968,
-0.249605193734169,
0.5159929394721985,
-0.24780453741550446,
-0.1408929079771042,
-0.24587196111679077,
0.07428090274333954,
-0.843501091003418,
-0.3401009142398834,
0.47195425629615784,
0.6618286967277527,
-0.6183179616928101,
0.5707567930221558,
-0.35997530817985535,
-0.29663461446762085,
-0.777431309223175,
0.3849855661392212,
0.6464176774024963,
0.4351336658000946,
0.4390071928501129,
-0.5033623576164246,
-0.7075537443161011,
-0.7471125721931458,
-0.008942250162363052,
0.02772330678999424,
-0.33914920687675476,
0.4089148938655853,
-0.016922088339924812,
-0.15099719166755676,
0.7938482761383057,
-0.33846384286880493,
-0.5744217038154602,
-0.4439486265182495,
-0.20839495956897736,
0.29713115096092224,
0.7118067145347595,
0.17164209485054016,
-0.5054139494895935,
-0.5043423175811768,
0.18247191607952118,
-0.371111661195755,
-0.10729983448982239,
0.13915838301181793,
0.09069431573152542,
0.18984998762607574,
0.5087354183197021,
-0.10273473709821701,
0.05083056166768074,
0.4478457272052765,
-0.20144367218017578,
0.21465687453746796,
-0.08981268852949142,
0.03687320649623871,
-0.9582370519638062,
0.22024789452552795,
-0.09920191764831543,
-0.09160809963941574,
-0.6939370036125183,
-0.8081486225128174,
-0.3792889416217804,
-0.3883521556854248,
-0.18816792964935303,
0.6862659454345703,
-0.4099360406398773,
-0.23169797658920288,
-0.20715099573135376,
0.04652019590139389,
-0.155925914645195,
0.13855871558189392,
0.2866668701171875,
0.5410014986991882,
0.41774314641952515,
-0.5403262972831726,
0.2820287048816681,
0.8526368141174316,
-0.6038413047790527,
0.3149917423725128,
-0.4967639744281769,
0.2013855278491974,
-0.07484955340623856,
0.027840686962008476,
-0.4464600682258606,
-0.32952821254730225,
0.1616622507572174,
-0.32965824007987976,
0.4983820915222168,
-0.42869287729263306,
-0.27174094319343567,
-0.057764746248722076,
0.23851656913757324,
0.921242892742157,
0.5549907684326172,
-0.4177175462245941,
0.6057262420654297,
0.7747530937194824,
-0.671310544013977,
-0.8136921525001526,
-0.7028022408485413,
-0.08456791937351227,
-0.3893100619316101,
-0.3828064203262329,
0.14812248945236206,
0.1751347929239273,
-0.19484513998031616,
-0.02901734597980976,
-0.2624458372592926,
-0.32963165640830994,
-0.3167880177497864,
0.02948807366192341,
-0.003035471076145768,
-0.3513803780078888,
0.2786945104598999,
-0.004517397843301296,
-0.2847902178764343,
-0.43746957182884216,
-0.35508882999420166,
0.356123685836792,
0.031567350029945374,
-0.4769640266895294,
-0.5417782664299011,
0.671082079410553,
0.28969481587409973,
-0.4650641083717346,
0.16657719016075134,
0.4211183488368988,
-0.36867672204971313,
-0.36052343249320984,
-0.5104275345802307,
-0.0011393539607524872,
-0.4690910279750824,
0.15873956680297852,
-0.04029203578829765,
-0.7091633677482605,
0.41520071029663086,
0.2697419822216034,
0.0720631405711174,
0.1994788497686386,
0.3763628900051117,
-0.03225266933441162,
0.6179641485214233,
0.6174416542053223,
-0.2130822241306305,
0.8751013278961182,
-0.22543543577194214,
0.021826349198818207,
-0.7025083303451538,
-0.24836231768131256,
-0.7923389673233032,
-0.3575815260410309,
-0.3774092197418213,
-0.424808531999588,
0.2913525700569153,
-0.37240204215049744,
-0.33963990211486816,
0.2338101714849472,
-0.6074236631393433,
0.7859165072441101,
0.7214483022689819,
-0.043948765844106674,
0.30644547939300537,
0.24387769401073456,
0.20834487676620483,
-0.03328604996204376,
-0.7767542600631714,
-0.7934877276420593,
1.0191586017608643,
0.07280827313661575,
0.8133255243301392,
0.22065536677837372,
0.7729436159133911,
0.47985824942588806,
-0.34183770418167114,
-0.990853488445282,
0.22798720002174377,
-0.6471489667892456,
-0.48745742440223694,
-0.8779241442680359,
-0.32574930787086487,
-0.8508243560791016,
-0.17581437528133392,
-0.12155554443597794,
-0.44302934408187866,
0.3407152593135834,
0.37873518466949463,
-0.7907009720802307,
0.041820038110017776,
-0.4234793186187744,
0.683800995349884,
-0.32219502329826355,
-0.03685983642935753,
-0.02433772198855877,
-0.7198460102081299,
-0.1689886897802353,
-0.11957862973213196,
0.25087159872055054,
-0.24363923072814941,
0.09138338267803192,
1.142379641532898,
-0.5088006854057312,
0.6343883275985718,
-0.28479042649269104,
0.4115859270095825,
0.5683736801147461,
-0.009711754508316517,
0.23065833747386932,
-0.15302738547325134,
-0.12803317606449127,
0.08995002508163452,
-0.04477614909410477,
-0.5093759298324585,
-0.312212735414505,
0.17680977284908295,
-0.7340283393859863,
0.011824085377156734,
-0.46474263072013855,
-0.4903402030467987,
-0.36276665329933167,
0.16853801906108856,
0.19753451645374298,
0.8621256947517395,
-0.3802637457847595,
0.20708206295967102,
0.6854767799377441,
-0.37216681241989136,
0.4968857169151306,
0.5357091426849365,
0.41961708664894104,
-0.5444110035896301,
1.0693161487579346,
0.2337193787097931,
-0.047798335552215576,
0.21962793171405792,
0.16952194273471832,
-0.2378564029932022,
-0.6953781247138977,
-0.581508219242096,
0.0051146917976439,
-0.44207853078842163,
-0.27321118116378784,
-0.4122381806373596,
-0.2501618564128876,
-0.21037378907203674,
-0.32299524545669556,
-0.6795545220375061,
-0.6147754788398743,
-0.11411445587873459,
0.12774819135665894,
0.4645717740058899,
0.6402993202209473,
-0.3762030601501465,
0.43406468629837036,
-1.114390254020691,
0.3078964650630951,
0.3116215467453003,
0.2770603597164154,
-0.005654032342135906,
-0.6343417763710022,
-0.6623544692993164,
-0.20114225149154663,
-0.02762899175286293,
-0.22958922386169434,
0.4794381856918335,
0.6228416562080383,
0.4307631850242615,
0.413936585187912,
0.1879207193851471,
0.6162089705467224,
-1.0721055269241333,
0.6623009443283081,
0.25756174325942993,
-0.9840112924575806,
0.7496329545974731,
-0.4345044791698456,
0.2270272821187973,
0.8138101696968079,
0.08431557565927505,
-0.7618176937103271,
-0.2047797441482544,
-0.3248516023159027,
-1.035627007484436,
0.9849590063095093,
0.36830899119377136,
0.1674208641052246,
0.2516009509563446,
-0.02797728218138218,
0.31636476516723633,
0.19534911215305328,
-0.28510478138923645,
-0.13276886940002441,
-0.34719136357307434,
-0.6284121870994568,
-0.2436675727367401,
-0.08433862775564194,
-0.2719806432723999,
-0.08346535265445709,
0.7520994544029236,
-0.1308918595314026,
0.12130353599786758,
0.015131374821066856,
-0.09812546521425247,
-0.15697816014289856,
0.29801642894744873,
0.24376793205738068,
0.08739859610795975,
-0.15331530570983887,
0.05528837442398071,
0.003550874534994364,
-0.6613053679466248,
0.61008620262146,
0.426941841840744,
0.14316833019256592,
0.030057480558753014,
0.5122890472412109,
0.7519443035125732,
-0.12318200618028641,
-0.9523665904998779,
0.33951035141944885,
-0.13076846301555634,
0.12695883214473724,
-0.571099042892456,
-0.01684682071208954,
-0.1133960485458374,
0.43026480078697205,
0.36327052116394043,
0.04939188435673714,
0.23221217095851898,
-0.18268869817256927,
0.28281766176223755,
0.08154866844415665,
-0.2861842215061188,
-0.07921769469976425,
0.3728778660297394,
0.41697511076927185,
-0.5038420557975769,
0.8783783912658691,
0.05708039179444313,
-0.1915605068206787,
0.5490835905075073,
0.33941930532455444,
0.7723947167396545,
-0.3319926857948303,
0.053850773721933365,
0.43005409836769104,
0.17781195044517517,
-0.20261986553668976,
0.13362720608711243,
-0.38040024042129517,
-0.8657148480415344,
-0.30736398696899414,
-1.0126551389694214,
-0.4571390151977539,
0.13878943026065826,
-0.9165398478507996,
0.24943807721138,
-0.30692654848098755,
-0.0367361418902874,
0.0324343703687191,
0.006005562376230955,
-0.6319413185119629,
0.18086880445480347,
0.4039495587348938,
0.7557937502861023,
-1.1527410745620728,
0.7216790318489075,
0.5789797306060791,
-0.23570874333381653,
-0.7538162469863892,
0.08476095646619797,
0.13878998160362244,
-0.5207962989807129,
0.47900262475013733,
0.001874720212072134,
-0.13289882242679596,
-0.12530072033405304,
-0.12189102172851562,
-1.031673789024353,
0.8567141890525818,
0.482808917760849,
-0.6971085667610168,
0.05874932184815407,
0.26307213306427,
0.4999343454837799,
-0.38621118664741516,
-0.4764062762260437,
0.6979089379310608,
0.12501321732997894,
0.26817694306373596,
-0.9309055209159851,
-0.1914469450712204,
-0.4061053395271301,
-0.0031898021697998047,
0.2437743842601776,
-0.45201680064201355,
0.3136022090911865,
0.013866680674254894,
-0.1975427269935608,
0.09986764937639236,
0.5570945739746094,
0.2590896487236023,
0.2458602786064148,
0.5177315473556519,
0.40421414375305176,
0.8795018792152405,
0.15861152112483978,
0.8390940427780151,
-0.11828521639108658,
-0.08434122800827026,
1.279701828956604,
-0.2591190040111542,
0.8351050615310669,
0.2793198823928833,
-0.015617633238434792,
0.158342644572258,
0.5530735850334167,
-0.019867021590471268,
0.7395124435424805,
0.13206660747528076,
-0.6834025979042053,
-0.4021708071231842,
-0.5043578743934631,
-0.11213111877441406,
0.7174230217933655,
0.3107536733150482,
-0.1599544733762741,
0.0069769336842000484,
0.15086813271045685,
-0.32764315605163574,
0.13044524192810059,
-0.40573516488075256,
0.9655320644378662,
0.09949822723865509,
-0.0539344884455204,
0.36071646213531494,
-0.32219868898391724,
0.4063979387283325,
-0.6260908246040344,
0.045733723789453506,
-0.14961278438568115,
0.13992875814437866,
-0.12921744585037231,
-0.4552232325077057,
0.45286864042282104,
0.6070882081985474,
-0.6164340376853943,
-0.19680358469486237,
0.4905529320240021,
-0.6442273259162903,
-0.7617023587226868,
-0.03778751567006111,
0.48997315764427185,
0.230951726436615,
0.47406673431396484,
-0.35215479135513306,
0.2085919976234436,
-0.07472121715545654,
-0.004486643709242344,
0.1416359394788742,
0.5473251938819885,
0.0493408665060997,
0.41353684663772583,
0.5209329128265381,
0.41789501905441284,
-0.13831976056098938,
0.026098083704710007,
0.7294550538063049,
-0.5142621994018555,
-0.6275774836540222,
-0.5695781111717224,
0.6285352110862732,
0.056637462228536606,
-0.07581198960542679,
0.42710158228874207,
0.7625935077667236,
0.82846599817276,
0.0657864585518837,
1.162184238433838,
-0.23439176380634308,
0.8799458146095276,
-0.5481684803962708,
0.9067723155021667,
-0.5658190846443176,
0.3168790936470032,
-0.25281667709350586,
-0.7675057649612427,
-0.3357854187488556,
0.823047935962677,
-0.08671804517507553,
-0.2516799569129944,
0.369367778301239,
0.6055561304092407,
-0.20263539254665375,
-0.2361053228378296,
0.08213665336370468,
-0.14714522659778595,
0.1471591740846634,
0.25814852118492126,
0.5961742401123047,
-0.31132060289382935,
0.9735051393508911,
-0.1634531170129776,
-0.09069058299064636,
0.03138623386621475,
-0.6539604663848877,
-0.7179432511329651,
-0.7212597727775574,
-0.2129366099834442,
-0.13945768773555756,
0.032524142414331436,
1.1924558877944946,
0.5934664607048035,
-1.074878215789795,
-0.6219561696052551,
0.20098945498466492,
-0.15911097824573517,
-0.14330770075321198,
-0.06879572570323944,
0.5154560804367065,
-0.08054451644420624,
-0.6650775671005249,
0.6179982423782349,
0.01967957429587841,
0.21536797285079956,
0.1899929940700531,
-0.3144715130329132,
0.09634298086166382,
0.000790622434578836,
0.21141231060028076,
0.685805082321167,
-0.24713510274887085,
-0.13530480861663818,
-0.2768215239048004,
0.105994313955307,
0.2636328637599945,
0.9770714640617371,
-0.6537819504737854,
0.5817293524742126,
0.21414722502231598,
0.8728384971618652,
0.5150167346000671,
0.047426220029592514,
0.7024969458580017,
-1.118690013885498,
0.31119441986083984,
0.6242803335189819,
0.2495674192905426,
0.7744507193565369,
-0.21959051489830017,
0.41655534505844116,
-0.04919227585196495,
-0.5160456299781799,
-1.0378525257110596,
0.13921065628528595,
-0.8667938709259033,
0.26591452956199646,
1.0983799695968628,
0.10080718249082565,
-0.043527811765670776,
-0.19868846237659454,
-0.21023309230804443,
0.528386652469635,
-0.6635973453521729,
0.6941306591033936,
0.4848525822162628,
-0.2445778101682663,
0.13596908748149872,
-0.40621286630630493,
0.787192165851593,
-0.02869747206568718,
-0.4860953986644745,
0.4375236928462982,
0.7105101346969604,
0.2307220846414566,
0.37309837341308594,
0.8112370371818542,
0.0870017558336258,
0.16245582699775696,
0.23944421112537384,
0.2594159245491028,
-0.05426355451345444,
-0.37154915928840637,
-0.5788816809654236,
-0.19303758442401886,
0.14181359112262726,
-0.3480631411075592
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.01441v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.01441v2
|
LexMatcher: Dictionary-centric Data Collection for LLM-based Machine Translation
| 2024-06-03T15:30:36 | 2024-07-02T08:00:23 |
Yongjing Yin, Jiali Zeng, Yafu Li, Fandong Meng, Yue Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The fine-tuning of open-source large language models (LLMs) for machine
translation has recently received considerable attention, marking a shift
towards data-centric research from traditional neural machine translation.
However, the area of data collection for instruction fine-tuning in machine
translation remains relatively underexplored. In this paper, we present
LexMatcher, a simple yet effective method for data curation, the design of
which is driven by the coverage of senses found in bilingual dictionaries. The
construction process comprises data retrieval from an existing corpus and data
augmentation that supplements the infrequent senses of polysemous words.
Utilizing LLaMA2 as our base model, our approach outperforms the established
baselines on the WMT2022 test sets and also exhibits remarkable performance in
tasks related to word sense disambiguation and specialized terminology
translation. These results underscore the effectiveness of LexMatcher in
enhancing LLM-based machine translation. The code, data, and models are
available at https://github.com/ARIES-LM/Lexmatcher-MT.git.
|
[
-0.5198221206665039,
-0.4883195459842682,
0.6098409295082092,
-0.06038709729909897,
-0.372795432806015,
0.10646297037601471,
-0.38804811239242554,
-0.09493865072727203,
0.3114559054374695,
0.3743951916694641,
-0.4734542965888977,
-0.9054207801818848,
-0.6925261616706848,
0.20012259483337402,
-0.5304278135299683,
0.9487282633781433,
-0.14283044636249542,
-0.07678927481174469,
-0.1517842710018158,
-0.41050294041633606,
-0.3202422559261322,
-0.5442101955413818,
-0.3427348732948303,
-0.4207473397254944,
0.6065440773963928,
0.5973830819129944,
0.7418573498725891,
0.8502870798110962,
0.3452177345752716,
0.25055932998657227,
-0.16459272801876068,
0.6392029523849487,
-0.4023822247982025,
0.13195455074310303,
-0.3004187047481537,
-0.6926167011260986,
-0.5107352137565613,
-0.06047641858458519,
0.6011985540390015,
0.7616354823112488,
-0.2099580019712448,
0.1877371072769165,
0.02659105695784092,
0.7211315631866455,
-0.5450018048286438,
0.11910872161388397,
-0.7703028917312622,
0.0001683256559772417,
-0.6223396062850952,
-0.1352173089981079,
-0.42386874556541443,
-0.07428962737321854,
-0.7238125801086426,
-0.6966730952262878,
0.19940555095672607,
0.03630814701318741,
0.4611354470252991,
0.5164457559585571,
-0.37502026557922363,
-0.3337700068950653,
-0.4034717082977295,
0.7957944869995117,
-0.7042077779769897,
0.5235242247581482,
0.5846747756004333,
0.20319485664367676,
-0.10829532146453857,
-0.6928710341453552,
-0.6578933000564575,
-0.0742245614528656,
-0.006686767563223839,
0.2575185000896454,
-0.26366275548934937,
-0.20555329322814941,
0.31883004307746887,
0.4064622223377228,
-0.40804049372673035,
0.32022106647491455,
-0.03972044214606285,
-0.04984952136874199,
0.4820901155471802,
0.37809035181999207,
0.1987285166978836,
0.04204385355114937,
-0.20534327626228333,
-0.15711264312267303,
-0.6449484825134277,
-0.008408086374402046,
0.2597437798976898,
0.296420156955719,
-0.09812358766794205,
0.883884072303772,
-0.27672839164733887,
0.7586791515350342,
-0.02552185021340847,
0.17318831384181976,
0.36336225271224976,
-0.5600799918174744,
0.07980570197105408,
-0.0057420069351792336,
0.6338787078857422,
0.45722177624702454,
0.27966398000717163,
-0.3291368782520294,
-0.4918033480644226,
0.03803790360689163,
0.18236669898033142,
-0.9669676423072815,
-0.08556690812110901,
0.17287597060203552,
-0.16160793602466583,
-0.3368527293205261,
0.31830310821533203,
-0.5510396957397461,
-0.4402913749217987,
-0.6595218181610107,
0.025914950296282768,
-0.4748244881629944,
-0.1970681995153427,
0.2746308445930481,
-0.056710608303546906,
0.04847406595945358,
0.07469896227121353,
-0.824406623840332,
0.4424000382423401,
0.9785099625587463,
0.8780820369720459,
-0.40496838092803955,
-0.20077182352542877,
-1.126301884651184,
-0.020207013934850693,
-0.4794865846633911,
0.5244075059890747,
-0.4619966149330139,
-0.5318617224693298,
0.057637885212898254,
0.10053719580173492,
0.09010997414588928,
-0.738520085811615,
0.48153507709503174,
-0.46345800161361694,
-0.23385024070739746,
-0.22517941892147064,
-0.8460317254066467,
0.08944743871688843,
0.12157025933265686,
-0.6047829389572144,
1.065895676612854,
0.12940329313278198,
-0.6861927509307861,
0.2821361720561981,
-0.5299963355064392,
-0.7019796371459961,
0.24234424531459808,
-0.16721214354038239,
-0.399453729391098,
0.5730281472206116,
0.26330360770225525,
0.3299429416656494,
-0.20456957817077637,
0.3087226450443268,
-0.20259490609169006,
-0.4631691575050354,
0.3629615902900696,
-0.1496862918138504,
0.6250686049461365,
0.2779991924762726,
-0.17060650885105133,
-0.06797970086336136,
-0.8266143202781677,
-0.10064584761857986,
0.1706351637840271,
-0.3526709973812103,
-0.5580808520317078,
0.10828081518411636,
0.12584754824638367,
-0.11421415954828262,
0.5058337450027466,
-0.6968595385551453,
0.29924577474594116,
-0.37781763076782227,
0.2456919103860855,
0.4472155272960663,
-0.4169912338256836,
0.5085684061050415,
-0.3890582025051117,
0.48844805359840393,
0.16837459802627563,
-0.04956073686480522,
-0.18344193696975708,
-0.3150745928287506,
-0.9098261594772339,
-0.21512898802757263,
0.262594610452652,
0.5040375590324402,
-0.7164352536201477,
0.5600706338882446,
-0.3487795889377594,
-0.5381061434745789,
-0.6718776226043701,
0.6156822443008423,
0.30133843421936035,
0.5854005813598633,
0.5658511519432068,
-0.20991985499858856,
-0.36259573698043823,
-0.7318347692489624,
-0.13902968168258667,
0.15123216807842255,
-0.15825630724430084,
0.12288865447044373,
0.2346060425043106,
-0.5666977167129517,
0.8975334763526917,
-0.3985197842121124,
-0.31427785754203796,
-0.33171138167381287,
0.0747382715344429,
0.35731109976768494,
0.22800347208976746,
0.3624187111854553,
-0.479836106300354,
-0.3165859878063202,
0.06695649772882462,
-0.6548024415969849,
-0.5052536725997925,
0.16782386600971222,
-0.11358289420604706,
0.18738983571529388,
0.6455901861190796,
-0.48992863297462463,
0.18452639877796173,
0.5736242532730103,
-0.18439114093780518,
0.394120454788208,
-0.25585007667541504,
-0.3522643446922302,
-1.370769739151001,
0.3206799328327179,
-0.22003555297851562,
-0.3304555416107178,
-0.6383479237556458,
0.13885292410850525,
0.5075334310531616,
0.21185332536697388,
-0.3669688105583191,
0.5935698747634888,
-0.27447184920310974,
0.021588420495390892,
-0.4681709110736847,
0.24005457758903503,
0.07006549090147018,
0.12085053324699402,
-0.09251049160957336,
1.0054810047149658,
0.3582274317741394,
-0.47612228989601135,
0.39116474986076355,
0.3337130546569824,
-0.4018237888813019,
0.7073076367378235,
-0.5734104514122009,
0.3161413073539734,
-0.07942286878824234,
-0.16430962085723877,
-0.6648571491241455,
-0.06865556538105011,
0.05930979177355766,
-0.36963948607444763,
0.33686742186546326,
-0.17762422561645508,
-0.9346044063568115,
-0.10791359096765518,
-0.1683010309934616,
0.1870720088481903,
0.4026024639606476,
-0.8393674492835999,
0.21134063601493835,
0.4719257950782776,
-0.13941101729869843,
-0.1991943120956421,
-0.7604523301124573,
0.25412288308143616,
-0.1354421079158783,
-0.2739178240299225,
0.35603466629981995,
-0.15340957045555115,
-0.4574572443962097,
-0.2547418475151062,
-0.226201593875885,
0.14728215336799622,
0.2736990451812744,
0.20020157098770142,
0.14555492997169495,
0.008339597843587399,
0.3650555908679962,
0.21474513411521912,
-0.3081439435482025,
-0.008831572718918324,
-0.1309337019920349,
0.5667948126792908,
-0.15611152350902557,
-0.5211867094039917,
-0.1538054645061493,
0.26615533232688904,
0.4912903904914856,
-0.5088695287704468,
0.5354553461074829,
0.6623393893241882,
-0.1364760845899582,
-0.47908100485801697,
-0.3873954117298126,
-0.32182639837265015,
-0.4520792067050934,
0.21245047450065613,
-0.6006160974502563,
-0.8278589248657227,
0.2652444541454315,
-0.18455761671066284,
0.06119171157479286,
0.1313411444425583,
0.49358847737312317,
-0.08778153359889984,
1.069480061531067,
0.4863477051258087,
-0.4723442494869232,
0.28657999634742737,
-0.20170146226882935,
0.06075229123234749,
-0.817373514175415,
0.10446305572986603,
-0.39596277475357056,
-0.3687744736671448,
-0.45004719495773315,
-0.4434047341346741,
0.2646654546260834,
0.07861924171447754,
0.01978323794901371,
0.4628629684448242,
-0.3475455343723297,
0.2783585488796234,
0.751213788986206,
-0.09838608652353287,
0.6463350653648376,
0.05011938139796257,
-0.34073567390441895,
-0.13068392872810364,
-0.48843860626220703,
-0.5125802755355835,
1.1669433116912842,
0.1458059549331665,
0.6837275624275208,
0.06325141340494156,
0.8569446206092834,
0.052542638033628464,
0.22794529795646667,
-1.0763976573944092,
0.5243340134620667,
-0.3682976961135864,
-0.10283050686120987,
-0.025119654834270477,
-0.46186065673828125,
-0.7867186665534973,
0.0990411564707756,
0.10543248057365417,
-0.1775277554988861,
-0.06421312689781189,
-0.0421440564095974,
-0.00238632969558239,
0.2497914731502533,
-0.240744948387146,
0.622912585735321,
-0.4293479025363922,
-0.35699716210365295,
-0.1978132277727127,
-0.3328665494918823,
0.177879199385643,
-0.5558642745018005,
0.25924408435821533,
-0.23525592684745789,
-0.3334186375141144,
0.3753470778465271,
-0.7379118204116821,
0.6737763285636902,
-0.3542052209377289,
-0.24049264192581177,
-0.10234656184911728,
0.3310820460319519,
0.6235299110412598,
0.23366300761699677,
-0.3212599754333496,
0.4187587797641754,
-0.007196045946329832,
-0.07795096188783646,
-0.4685259759426117,
0.6183174252510071,
-0.44845274090766907,
-0.4088663160800934,
-0.1540798842906952,
-0.9474015235900879,
-0.3292984366416931,
0.2686680853366852,
0.05550922453403473,
0.25795382261276245,
-0.11746436357498169,
0.37815332412719727,
0.5500401258468628,
-0.16577011346817017,
0.15143661201000214,
0.8938595652580261,
-0.3415040373802185,
-0.20680081844329834,
0.9519495368003845,
-0.09845730662345886,
0.06078287214040756,
0.43122178316116333,
0.11193624883890152,
-0.3291787803173065,
-0.6600324511528015,
-0.42376986145973206,
0.21614062786102295,
-0.3212144672870636,
-0.43295130133628845,
-0.28879621624946594,
-0.170009583234787,
-0.08223973214626312,
0.06724973767995834,
-0.4612817168235779,
-0.23291417956352234,
-0.2831113934516907,
-0.07834606617689133,
0.6600103974342346,
0.4843890070915222,
-0.16391901671886444,
0.4795054495334625,
-0.6923720240592957,
0.41723355650901794,
0.07713481038808823,
0.3471693694591522,
-0.6152057647705078,
-0.6301631331443787,
-0.38510245084762573,
0.28663507103919983,
-0.08359241485595703,
-0.4623469412326813,
0.5876780152320862,
0.12455316632986069,
0.33846715092658997,
0.40378743410110474,
0.1054365485906601,
0.6168862581253052,
-0.549425482749939,
0.2522183954715729,
-0.03441610559821129,
-0.9399547576904297,
0.601262629032135,
-0.19858583807945251,
0.3990270793437958,
0.7495107650756836,
0.023163968697190285,
-0.7257071137428284,
-0.6432168483734131,
-0.1521621197462082,
-0.6560424566268921,
0.6655476689338684,
0.07603964954614639,
0.19105032086372375,
-0.12966866791248322,
0.14203955233097076,
0.152837872505188,
0.20015612244606018,
-0.06209130585193634,
-0.12722668051719666,
-0.08371437340974808,
-0.6069631576538086,
-0.6102848052978516,
-0.15366560220718384,
-0.18520964682102203,
-0.28870296478271484,
0.3497391939163208,
-0.32976070046424866,
-0.2538222372531891,
-0.10346304625272751,
-0.5195209383964539,
0.11576897650957108,
0.253546804189682,
0.4011722207069397,
0.3284744322299957,
-0.19620968401432037,
0.420976847410202,
0.1226264238357544,
-0.5478278398513794,
-0.06682955473661423,
0.38346177339553833,
-0.29507023096084595,
0.23183229565620422,
-0.011004234664142132,
0.6138052344322205,
0.15341587364673615,
-0.8154670000076294,
0.5563652515411377,
0.16524669528007507,
-0.22562532126903534,
-0.20462018251419067,
0.05627158656716347,
0.2590934932231903,
0.10065102577209473,
0.019499294459819794,
-0.1765870898962021,
0.11147473007440567,
-0.08516841381788254,
0.38035309314727783,
0.3887414038181305,
-0.13447953760623932,
-0.3706558048725128,
0.7812442779541016,
-0.12718819081783295,
-0.11231353133916855,
0.7083163857460022,
-0.21345749497413635,
-0.17064854502677917,
0.5164249539375305,
0.5600897073745728,
0.481262743473053,
-0.05163026601076126,
0.042293284088373184,
0.25611168146133423,
0.2903740704059601,
-0.019682396203279495,
0.36440402269363403,
-0.3430933654308319,
-0.8273223638534546,
-0.16770800948143005,
-0.8691778779029846,
-0.4756263196468353,
0.03647990897297859,
-0.7687487602233887,
0.26499053835868835,
-0.2740982174873352,
-0.12451779842376709,
-0.2198830395936966,
0.05134155601263046,
-0.6190671324729919,
-0.24612723290920258,
0.2843148708343506,
1.2305123805999756,
-0.6280006170272827,
1.2304189205169678,
0.6215802431106567,
-0.4713377356529236,
-0.5041484832763672,
-0.2273445576429367,
0.17831698060035706,
-1.1269326210021973,
0.5763342976570129,
0.2135067731142044,
-0.09377554059028625,
0.30732262134552,
-0.3502654433250427,
-0.5810320377349854,
1.0024805068969727,
0.31920385360717773,
-1.0269057750701904,
0.30268949270248413,
0.6993898749351501,
0.4812728464603424,
-0.06910968571901321,
-0.06801802664995193,
0.842735767364502,
0.6755236983299255,
-0.07750116288661957,
-0.6593348979949951,
-0.10163435339927673,
-0.4960761070251465,
0.10807912796735764,
0.2557706832885742,
-0.2737804353237152,
0.5507699251174927,
-0.020205996930599213,
-0.14665587246418,
0.1370328813791275,
0.3527621924877167,
0.4742128551006317,
0.19852067530155182,
0.5775222182273865,
1.043058156967163,
0.8318848609924316,
-0.06926272064447403,
0.9407435655593872,
-0.6484877467155457,
0.08305909484624863,
1.3754150867462158,
-0.32237496972084045,
0.89774090051651,
0.7645201086997986,
-0.11963561177253723,
0.029437610879540443,
0.36078861355781555,
-0.26576101779937744,
0.48099130392074585,
0.3250125050544739,
-0.30425044894218445,
-0.16465777158737183,
-0.23168179392814636,
-0.1433190554380417,
0.5302983522415161,
0.520854115486145,
-0.2519649565219879,
-0.29736295342445374,
-0.014167161658406258,
0.1796671450138092,
0.20948126912117004,
-0.10892167687416077,
0.8575423359870911,
0.24957023561000824,
-0.507687509059906,
0.5628082156181335,
0.183071106672287,
0.6603183746337891,
-0.3756023645401001,
0.10171102732419968,
-0.7818722128868103,
0.4195680320262909,
-0.08583170175552368,
-0.851544201374054,
0.4195324778556824,
0.2374495565891266,
-0.034675225615501404,
-0.43007799983024597,
0.43119311332702637,
-0.6323043704032898,
-0.6029604077339172,
0.4123407304286957,
0.7403743267059326,
0.2297113537788391,
-0.28067195415496826,
-0.43932807445526123,
0.29249024391174316,
-0.28240031003952026,
-0.06402716040611267,
0.15879197418689728,
0.4522677958011627,
0.07194697111845016,
0.3347376883029938,
0.7480420470237732,
0.31451672315597534,
0.1928330957889557,
0.5677246451377869,
0.7723696231842041,
-0.5275055170059204,
-0.012980068102478981,
-0.8151952624320984,
0.4415574073791504,
0.046687230467796326,
-0.04086470976471901,
0.7414739727973938,
0.8987467885017395,
0.9759034514427185,
0.011523486115038395,
0.7480085492134094,
0.1543179452419281,
0.6537778377532959,
-0.3738539516925812,
0.8371458053588867,
-0.7502796053886414,
0.14571388065814972,
0.28798237442970276,
-0.7528085708618164,
-0.4117969572544098,
0.3223233222961426,
-0.10223430395126343,
-0.3805597722530365,
0.4273959994316101,
1.1767834424972534,
-0.40494099259376526,
-0.2280014306306839,
0.33199799060821533,
0.12659181654453278,
0.27205678820610046,
0.516274094581604,
0.6730213761329651,
-0.2799413204193115,
0.38013190031051636,
-0.3998972475528717,
-0.2843247950077057,
-0.40427684783935547,
-0.5810855031013489,
-0.7665903568267822,
-0.5671305060386658,
0.10735499858856201,
0.09671101719141006,
-0.055822037160396576,
0.6541900038719177,
0.4525199234485626,
-0.7989721894264221,
-0.3555147647857666,
-0.4517556428909302,
-0.08059775084257126,
-0.11658062785863876,
-0.10402233898639679,
0.05755169317126274,
-0.9841546416282654,
-1.0135009288787842,
0.7443728446960449,
0.15465623140335083,
-0.14407707750797272,
-0.010371006093919277,
-0.1980462670326233,
0.3008268177509308,
-0.1734485626220703,
0.688994824886322,
0.08724597096443176,
-0.5652074217796326,
0.19642037153244019,
0.17534783482551575,
-0.3636215925216675,
0.06983208656311035,
0.5444027781486511,
-0.5638934373855591,
0.6927177906036377,
0.3062191307544708,
0.8924936652183533,
0.5510240793228149,
-0.03615344688296318,
0.45272138714790344,
-0.6304906010627747,
0.2266540229320526,
-0.028844565153121948,
0.601231038570404,
0.34996673464775085,
-0.0640551745891571,
0.561280369758606,
0.25884270668029785,
-0.17047333717346191,
-0.7334829568862915,
0.12287191301584244,
-1.0814610719680786,
-0.03698664531111717,
1.229780912399292,
0.1598229706287384,
0.009983095340430737,
0.14470013976097107,
-0.2228669375181198,
0.34962937235832214,
-0.2029300034046173,
0.6916809678077698,
0.5363250970840454,
0.3170377314090729,
-0.08606497943401337,
-0.7440255284309387,
0.15871229767799377,
0.6338798999786377,
-0.8106947541236877,
0.20090167224407196,
0.5193572640419006,
0.2541157901287079,
-0.13827723264694214,
0.34322917461395264,
-0.20402789115905762,
0.0073429592885077,
-0.2580523192882538,
0.2041938751935959,
-0.5674737095832825,
-0.3069891631603241,
-0.37846940755844116,
-0.11230040341615677,
0.15391139686107635,
-0.3118252754211426
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.01436v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.01436v1
|
Editing the Mind of Giants: An In-Depth Exploration of Pitfalls of Knowledge Editing in Large Language Models
| 2024-06-03T15:28:21 | 2024-06-03T15:28:21 |
Cheng-Hsun Hsueh, Paul Kuo-Ming Huang, Tzu-Han Lin, Che-Wei Liao, Hung-Chieh Fang, Chao-Wei Huang, Yun-Nung Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Knowledge editing is a rising technique for efficiently updating factual
knowledge in Large Language Models (LLMs) with minimal alteration of
parameters. However, recent studies have identified concerning side effects,
such as knowledge distortion and the deterioration of general abilities, that
have emerged after editing. This survey presents a comprehensive study of these
side effects, providing a unified view of the challenges associated with
knowledge editing in LLMs. We discuss related works and summarize potential
research directions to overcome these limitations. Our work highlights the
limitations of current knowledge editing methods, emphasizing the need for
deeper understanding of inner knowledge structures of LLMs and improved
knowledge editing methods. To foster future research, we have released the
complementary materials such as paper collection publicly at
https://github.com/MiuLab/EditLLM-Survey
|
[
-0.5037224292755127,
-0.9044716358184814,
0.5782307386398315,
-0.30682069063186646,
0.08876684308052063,
0.25344765186309814,
-0.48182228207588196,
-0.6011348366737366,
0.27469247579574585,
0.8651049733161926,
-0.2980101406574249,
-0.3222750127315521,
-0.8672835826873779,
0.06830156594514847,
-0.37630710005760193,
1.2013682126998901,
-0.15075528621673584,
-0.022398095577955246,
-0.2881280183792114,
-0.291059285402298,
-0.6039417386054993,
-0.5967385172843933,
-0.7896943688392639,
-0.11445926874876022,
0.4466352164745331,
0.22148428857326508,
1.083269715309143,
0.35344940423965454,
0.5226296782493591,
0.30242016911506653,
-0.8856111168861389,
0.30597206950187683,
-0.6145678162574768,
-0.03384184092283249,
-0.5101367235183716,
-0.4710071384906769,
-0.7939433455467224,
-0.0898510292172432,
0.9420015215873718,
0.7454168200492859,
-0.08032379299402237,
0.09695249050855637,
0.01965518482029438,
0.9521153569221497,
-0.5748425722122192,
-0.05947829410433769,
-0.6945822238922119,
0.029463114216923714,
-0.44049128890037537,
-0.010401088744401932,
-0.08273938298225403,
-0.33271023631095886,
0.3255249261856079,
-0.5553789138793945,
0.08971492946147919,
0.143045574426651,
0.46451517939567566,
0.5213423371315002,
-0.1786521077156067,
-0.6454414129257202,
-0.6061962842941284,
0.569584846496582,
-0.6694671511650085,
0.33735939860343933,
0.1702846884727478,
0.07627040147781372,
-0.22808794677257538,
-0.49610280990600586,
-0.8591467142105103,
-0.007064399309456348,
-0.03761084005236626,
-0.10986669361591339,
-0.3707621395587921,
0.2895929217338562,
0.6057553887367249,
0.589321494102478,
-0.2511726915836334,
0.19030462205410004,
-0.6088281869888306,
-0.0757424533367157,
0.5264885425567627,
0.1879601627588272,
0.6809705495834351,
-0.23070774972438812,
0.13966305553913116,
-0.02253761887550354,
-1.0923752784729004,
-0.15682482719421387,
0.5831258296966553,
-0.08860769867897034,
0.29513874650001526,
0.7967052459716797,
-0.158738374710083,
0.9909446835517883,
0.08785166591405869,
-0.08411353081464767,
-0.17634110152721405,
0.06968338042497635,
-0.440591424703598,
-0.051998503506183624,
0.4874227046966553,
0.5748669505119324,
-0.060976460576057434,
-0.2897833287715912,
-0.05353451892733574,
-0.27040553092956543,
0.2024402767419815,
-0.4283170998096466,
-0.06639911979436874,
0.12790916860103607,
-0.1314934343099594,
-0.18945133686065674,
-0.36901041865348816,
-0.8372749090194702,
-0.8866255283355713,
-0.14078091084957123,
0.46528327465057373,
-0.4564761519432068,
-0.05127173289656639,
0.5651524066925049,
-0.16015325486660004,
-0.1215081512928009,
0.5478063821792603,
-0.8342320919036865,
0.2598409056663513,
0.5262109637260437,
0.4670184552669525,
0.051700472831726074,
-0.37174922227859497,
-0.03336444869637489,
0.2552352249622345,
-0.44738122820854187,
0.6515708565711975,
-0.38834500312805176,
-0.6721245646476746,
-0.23022349178791046,
-0.3830392360687256,
0.0912991464138031,
-0.6535665392875671,
0.675255537033081,
-0.9009392857551575,
0.26256048679351807,
-0.7553088068962097,
-0.7480632066726685,
-0.39697492122650146,
0.28647685050964355,
-0.7306432127952576,
0.3475141227245331,
0.11447037011384964,
-0.9505231976509094,
0.05557936429977417,
-0.6907234191894531,
-0.22679200768470764,
-0.16490162909030914,
0.0241731908172369,
-0.020515749230980873,
0.36641958355903625,
0.35741886496543884,
0.3795274496078491,
-0.23984010517597198,
0.20678561925888062,
-0.0771283358335495,
-0.011467832140624523,
0.40967169404029846,
0.001555352471768856,
0.8405987620353699,
0.14991728961467743,
0.1453230232000351,
0.1430576741695404,
-0.35100993514060974,
-0.22845475375652313,
0.005418968852609396,
-0.21531891822814941,
-0.5434805154800415,
0.017388084903359413,
-0.44532185792922974,
0.14176329970359802,
0.3030858635902405,
-0.41373005509376526,
0.7286487221717834,
-0.11951851844787598,
0.3882399797439575,
0.7943280339241028,
0.31187453866004944,
0.5165002942085266,
-0.4161756634712219,
0.5491876006126404,
-0.029138930141925812,
0.3047133684158325,
0.19059152901172638,
-0.3760649859905243,
-0.71626216173172,
0.19412434101104736,
0.4482468068599701,
0.5499727725982666,
-0.9581096172332764,
0.26811349391937256,
-0.2917538285255432,
-0.6301738023757935,
-0.5427982807159424,
0.3689012825489044,
0.44107890129089355,
0.4805317223072052,
0.33479273319244385,
-0.1491813361644745,
-0.3343067765235901,
-0.9951903223991394,
-0.7756512761116028,
-0.15690165758132935,
0.2262447029352188,
0.24735835194587708,
0.5522950887680054,
-0.558090090751648,
0.8309326767921448,
-0.8827783465385437,
-0.40806150436401367,
-0.23281501233577728,
-0.18320555984973907,
0.053499866276979446,
0.5226985812187195,
0.48423925042152405,
-0.5289067029953003,
-0.15473851561546326,
-0.008480069227516651,
-0.5738953948020935,
-0.027646740898489952,
-0.048501431941986084,
0.07525739818811417,
0.13950291275978088,
0.47245168685913086,
-1.010298728942871,
0.12940408289432526,
0.757876992225647,
-0.22912292182445526,
0.89031982421875,
-0.16375747323036194,
0.3870530128479004,
-0.8777236342430115,
-0.16397953033447266,
-0.1225830689072609,
0.2232857346534729,
-0.6113258600234985,
0.3694196939468384,
0.15132899582386017,
0.025887005031108856,
-0.33933261036872864,
0.4786778688430786,
-0.4997009336948395,
0.17633044719696045,
-0.11837102472782135,
0.13401062786579132,
-0.12786540389060974,
0.2022506445646286,
-0.29911401867866516,
0.7910290956497192,
0.49694955348968506,
-0.5569025278091431,
0.496389240026474,
0.46633243560791016,
-0.6770397424697876,
0.46227407455444336,
-0.4067491590976715,
0.35523295402526855,
-0.39561519026756287,
0.14209076762199402,
-0.6322904229164124,
-0.3787904977798462,
0.37927404046058655,
-0.31654876470565796,
0.5594696402549744,
0.049661893397569656,
-0.6270661354064941,
-0.3053610324859619,
-0.28867006301879883,
0.3161349594593048,
0.2839086651802063,
-0.37725651264190674,
0.45063576102256775,
0.7764569520950317,
-0.42246535420417786,
-0.670924723148346,
-0.8233526349067688,
0.5892678499221802,
-0.34984344244003296,
-0.5913082957267761,
0.24033582210540771,
-0.3248853385448456,
-0.7301474809646606,
0.23654265701770782,
0.016014350578188896,
0.022072041407227516,
-0.07831307500600815,
-0.26474544405937195,
0.1575240045785904,
0.3231493830680847,
0.23469705879688263,
0.360567569732666,
0.2292022705078125,
0.05973561108112335,
0.01044140662997961,
0.02303421124815941,
-0.05121169239282608,
-0.14772304892539978,
-0.25122538208961487,
0.2207505851984024,
0.6707199215888977,
-0.23350036144256592,
0.49614062905311584,
-0.052299026399850845,
-0.5734008550643921,
-0.168172687292099,
-0.9629191756248474,
0.10519134998321533,
-0.4169553518295288,
0.7061877250671387,
-0.2220684289932251,
-1.1818060874938965,
0.45218658447265625,
-0.1246010959148407,
-0.04075608775019646,
0.6931434273719788,
0.2391694337129593,
0.10009763389825821,
0.7471938729286194,
0.7740528583526611,
-0.2862917184829712,
0.1929297298192978,
-0.24059297144412994,
0.1829645037651062,
-1.2830661535263062,
0.001824879669584334,
-0.46948662400245667,
-0.17688602209091187,
-0.5338998436927795,
-0.6383231282234192,
0.5625057816505432,
0.2962905466556549,
0.21463614702224731,
0.14669382572174072,
-0.36753714084625244,
0.6483380198478699,
0.006416661199182272,
0.07220838218927383,
0.6124521493911743,
-0.2563927173614502,
0.1271887868642807,
-0.23720437288284302,
-0.7440810203552246,
-0.5189417004585266,
1.1015229225158691,
0.3014528155326843,
0.8697481751441956,
0.29144108295440674,
0.292400062084198,
0.30070143938064575,
0.34243243932724,
-0.779052734375,
0.5833975076675415,
-0.1307668536901474,
-0.9785531759262085,
-0.6145859360694885,
-0.3283402621746063,
-0.36507827043533325,
0.2038135826587677,
-0.2860853374004364,
-0.7242536544799805,
0.14760266244411469,
0.3160276710987091,
-0.57029128074646,
0.9705374240875244,
-0.5504261255264282,
0.6413209438323975,
-0.27875760197639465,
-0.22839553654193878,
-0.5601681470870972,
-0.4324549436569214,
0.6608410477638245,
-0.3530779778957367,
0.3307478129863739,
0.4019128680229187,
-0.050342291593551636,
0.922343909740448,
-0.02725515328347683,
0.5909162759780884,
-0.03986170142889023,
-0.3284192383289337,
0.34172865748405457,
0.2826915681362152,
0.7767330408096313,
0.045012664049863815,
-0.14874950051307678,
0.07798724621534348,
-0.1651059091091156,
-0.19467008113861084,
-0.7301483154296875,
0.8111943602561951,
-0.7057521343231201,
-0.8831131458282471,
-0.2767009735107422,
-0.8671290278434753,
-0.5890508890151978,
0.0513276644051075,
0.09404338151216507,
0.17924357950687408,
-0.35684582591056824,
-0.06437287479639053,
0.9422374963760376,
-0.651862382888794,
0.11057330667972565,
0.2426433116197586,
-0.6132100820541382,
-0.6575202345848083,
0.7966699600219727,
0.6911311745643616,
0.3135184943675995,
0.034245334565639496,
0.0018184017390012741,
-0.14734891057014465,
-0.9965198636054993,
-0.5599071979522705,
0.361355185508728,
-0.8419420123100281,
0.2924623191356659,
-0.7018131017684937,
0.10554077476263046,
-0.4867003858089447,
-0.18205809593200684,
-0.2808783948421478,
-0.41228583455085754,
-0.19491395354270935,
-0.13329394161701202,
0.22456017136573792,
1.2170746326446533,
-0.06678369641304016,
0.48696544766426086,
-0.6463414430618286,
0.25571009516716003,
0.5425905585289001,
0.4649558365345001,
0.07234548032283783,
-0.4712839126586914,
-0.504168689250946,
-0.11967775225639343,
-0.28642117977142334,
-0.9200205206871033,
0.1947038769721985,
-0.31973138451576233,
0.40362614393234253,
0.397030770778656,
-0.17494076490402222,
0.9457825422286987,
-0.37745335698127747,
0.7688330411911011,
0.16222891211509705,
-1.1049669981002808,
0.29096975922584534,
-0.41759800910949707,
0.3892568349838257,
0.4630236327648163,
0.39100441336631775,
-1.0878692865371704,
-0.2610624134540558,
-0.6847439408302307,
-0.5665169954299927,
0.36117783188819885,
-0.12080039083957672,
-0.009233947843313217,
0.17879892885684967,
0.6101691126823425,
0.17407284677028656,
0.4130247235298157,
-0.3563910126686096,
-0.14485424757003784,
0.2504000961780548,
0.5072948336601257,
-0.23986583948135376,
-0.6230922341346741,
-0.1351926475763321,
-0.47495582699775696,
0.9038036465644836,
0.19039945304393768,
-0.14202755689620972,
0.388153076171875,
-0.46411746740341187,
-0.34862399101257324,
0.5846587419509888,
0.7454022169113159,
1.0631393194198608,
-0.07089308649301529,
-0.005656762979924679,
0.7384840846061707,
-0.2943499684333801,
-0.24011263251304626,
-0.16701442003250122,
-0.33693692088127136,
-0.30342286825180054,
0.23918569087982178,
0.8571717143058777,
0.06263594329357147,
-0.5932194590568542,
0.10678807646036148,
0.09270627051591873,
-0.1508387178182602,
-0.22203928232192993,
-0.014949891716241837,
0.20139022171497345,
0.25316140055656433,
0.2932582497596741,
0.39186376333236694,
0.08356699347496033,
-0.4828189015388489,
-0.31385982036590576,
0.3805519640445709,
-0.2801036536693573,
-0.3049200177192688,
0.5375849008560181,
-0.07029159367084503,
-0.16319304704666138,
0.4758560061454773,
-0.15808100998401642,
-0.47002068161964417,
0.14431074261665344,
0.226982980966568,
0.7242239713668823,
-0.21183092892169952,
-0.035384777933359146,
0.03141383081674576,
0.7199928164482117,
-0.05042746290564537,
-0.051906514912843704,
0.31573793292045593,
-0.8899862766265869,
-0.7560009360313416,
-0.3993491530418396,
-0.8497503399848938,
0.4876045286655426,
-0.42830079793930054,
0.0022159162908792496,
-0.5714786052703857,
-0.22217808663845062,
-0.1572657972574234,
-0.10614825785160065,
-0.5452354550361633,
0.22200150787830353,
0.061366405338048935,
0.7972204089164734,
-0.5647740364074707,
0.6788092851638794,
0.9782310724258423,
-0.1834138184785843,
-0.41514402627944946,
0.0014521785778924823,
0.21342429518699646,
-0.35754457116127014,
0.18592169880867004,
-0.2978665828704834,
-0.017102031037211418,
0.12744951248168945,
-0.7067663073539734,
-0.7732937932014465,
0.7419959902763367,
0.41315898299217224,
-0.6536647081375122,
-0.2865855097770691,
0.18972328305244446,
0.4550642967224121,
0.04897840693593025,
-0.20719051361083984,
0.8102471232414246,
0.7327960133552551,
-0.2595217227935791,
-0.9122925400733948,
0.026567457243800163,
0.1801646500825882,
0.06586334854364395,
0.13918320834636688,
-0.7591283321380615,
0.8947094082832336,
-0.3787524104118347,
-0.01938731223344803,
-0.049215223640203476,
0.545637845993042,
-0.12693831324577332,
-0.2404002696275711,
0.5526495575904846,
1.175302267074585,
0.8808174729347229,
0.18156610429286957,
0.9916521906852722,
-0.2253720462322235,
0.41033706068992615,
0.9558324217796326,
-0.16095466911792755,
0.3847765028476715,
0.6206892132759094,
-0.257532000541687,
0.24149967730045319,
0.3865400552749634,
0.21948590874671936,
0.03552877902984619,
0.3310679793357849,
-0.4566960036754608,
-0.0629296600818634,
0.07361004501581192,
-0.45927074551582336,
0.2700135409832001,
0.5250985026359558,
-0.07711261510848999,
-0.12622876465320587,
0.0340607725083828,
0.532128095626831,
0.08741426467895508,
-0.5076572895050049,
0.4421767294406891,
-0.011962011456489563,
-0.6109421849250793,
0.1914289891719818,
0.021350566297769547,
0.7835274934768677,
-0.5213530659675598,
0.052128251641988754,
0.12045116722583771,
0.06564631313085556,
-0.3000004291534424,
-1.0196908712387085,
0.603175699710846,
-0.02632364071905613,
-0.2360408455133438,
-0.26780766248703003,
0.7923452258110046,
-0.2752905488014221,
-0.23337700963020325,
0.29800480604171753,
0.6723060607910156,
0.10655559599399567,
-0.478943407535553,
-0.5656508207321167,
0.3107301890850067,
-0.03125052526593208,
-0.44882628321647644,
0.33142608404159546,
0.39506104588508606,
0.004690895322710276,
0.7169702649116516,
0.48811832070350647,
0.591853678226471,
-0.11062503606081009,
-0.2763269245624542,
0.7823507785797119,
-0.9597575664520264,
-0.20975683629512787,
-0.8861915469169617,
0.4694047272205353,
-0.008963748812675476,
-0.4967738687992096,
0.816169023513794,
0.390423446893692,
1.1049872636795044,
-0.3816528618335724,
0.9925042986869812,
-0.3089006543159485,
0.4993881583213806,
-0.4596339762210846,
1.202094316482544,
-0.38309556245803833,
0.2072724848985672,
-0.6231817007064819,
-0.7704274654388428,
-0.4766901731491089,
0.03985673189163208,
-0.6211802363395691,
-0.2554663419723511,
0.8437444567680359,
0.81633061170578,
0.36320656538009644,
0.06915868818759918,
0.5087831616401672,
0.7756832838058472,
0.13747623562812805,
0.3598194420337677,
0.867418110370636,
-0.24109412729740143,
0.3210577964782715,
-0.4664931297302246,
-0.15113131701946259,
0.08820592612028122,
-0.7026380300521851,
-0.8280267119407654,
-0.49855169653892517,
-0.2878880798816681,
-0.17027324438095093,
0.3492174446582794,
0.718990683555603,
0.10523559898138046,
-0.5496421456336975,
-0.2638697922229767,
0.3659183084964752,
0.5426861643791199,
-0.18301506340503693,
-0.13226355612277985,
0.4734781086444855,
-0.03902827203273773,
-0.8585501313209534,
0.39739903807640076,
0.18129509687423706,
-0.013277214020490646,
-0.41698530316352844,
0.0737682357430458,
-0.11599332094192505,
-0.10107887536287308,
0.8158449530601501,
0.3447621166706085,
-0.6362404823303223,
-0.5183688998222351,
-0.2814409136772156,
0.12687160074710846,
-0.28410473465919495,
0.6445820927619934,
-0.4873037338256836,
0.6822364330291748,
0.4937589764595032,
0.8226298689842224,
0.1112968847155571,
-0.3117324709892273,
0.33710595965385437,
-0.2066100388765335,
-0.20689277350902557,
0.08645613491535187,
0.5023781657218933,
0.476019024848938,
-0.4944305121898651,
0.28974562883377075,
0.2939728796482086,
-0.7245157361030579,
-0.7272629141807556,
0.12825287878513336,
-1.0104877948760986,
-0.22443969547748566,
1.0826789140701294,
0.22502733767032623,
-0.22035269439220428,
0.05555462837219238,
-0.572846531867981,
0.3210921585559845,
-0.0038811496924608946,
1.0496591329574585,
1.2024660110473633,
-0.130177304148674,
0.032053250819444656,
-0.9132882356643677,
0.5897859334945679,
0.26574578881263733,
-0.664207398891449,
0.25311464071273804,
0.8991933465003967,
0.33005908131599426,
0.11756400018930435,
0.44264093041419983,
-0.3641768991947174,
0.17331035435199738,
-0.32996055483818054,
0.42279672622680664,
-0.1197516992688179,
-0.211584210395813,
-0.5679067373275757,
0.19283263385295868,
0.33097389340400696,
0.47174233198165894
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.01428v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.01428v2
|
Superhuman performance in urology board questions by an explainable large language model enabled for context integration of the European Association of Urology guidelines: the UroBot study
| 2024-06-03T15:26:06 | 2024-06-04T05:39:15 |
Martin J. Hetz, Nicolas Carl, Sarah Haggenmüller, Christoph Wies, Maurice Stephan Michel, Frederik Wessels, Titus J. Brinker
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CV
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) are revolutionizing medical Question-Answering
(medQA) through extensive use of medical literature. However, their performance
is often hampered by outdated training data and a lack of explainability, which
limits clinical applicability. This study aimed to create and assess UroBot, a
urology-specialized chatbot, by comparing it with state-of-the-art models and
the performance of urologists on urological board questions, ensuring full
clinician-verifiability. UroBot was developed using OpenAI's GPT-3.5, GPT-4,
and GPT-4o models, employing retrieval-augmented generation (RAG) and the
latest 2023 guidelines from the European Association of Urology (EAU). The
evaluation included ten runs of 200 European Board of Urology (EBU) In-Service
Assessment (ISA) questions, with performance assessed by the mean Rate of
Correct Answers (RoCA). UroBot-4o achieved an average RoCA of 88.4%, surpassing
GPT-4o by 10.8%, with a score of 77.6%. It was also clinician-verifiable and
exhibited the highest run agreement as indicated by Fleiss' Kappa (k = 0.979).
By comparison, the average performance of urologists on board questions, as
reported in the literature, is 68.7%. UroBot's clinician-verifiable nature and
superior accuracy compared to both existing models and urologists on board
questions highlight its potential for clinical integration. The study also
provides the necessary code and instructions for further development of UroBot.
|
[
-0.36365458369255066,
-0.9707152247428894,
0.8588771224021912,
-0.0020694341510534286,
-0.46675705909729004,
-0.05471934378147125,
-0.03001571074128151,
-0.589438796043396,
0.33905482292175293,
0.7257921695709229,
-0.2699503004550934,
-0.5075993537902832,
-0.6665928959846497,
0.3873950242996216,
-0.22520811855793,
1.0341627597808838,
0.07521186023950577,
0.2788260281085968,
-0.3216809332370758,
-0.24209614098072052,
-0.8030728101730347,
-0.5633161664009094,
-0.1470087468624115,
-0.3315610885620117,
0.11886492371559143,
0.16227303445339203,
0.8566069006919861,
0.29513227939605713,
1.0204434394836426,
0.3211923837661743,
-0.1698409765958786,
0.15447689592838287,
-0.4241240918636322,
0.22845472395420074,
-0.21516640484333038,
-0.5019014477729797,
-0.7619565725326538,
-0.23365671932697296,
0.46410295367240906,
0.758730411529541,
-0.35769063234329224,
-0.01974240317940712,
-0.3746985197067261,
0.5041378736495972,
-0.11662334203720093,
-0.08779899030923843,
-0.4068666398525238,
-0.03625327721238136,
0.06996580958366394,
-0.6145046949386597,
-0.3604693114757538,
-0.5408571362495422,
0.10690231621265411,
-0.20270857214927673,
-0.0110589899122715,
0.07228058576583862,
0.7334533929824829,
0.21612384915351868,
-0.39179158210754395,
-0.3613095283508301,
-0.8573296070098877,
0.36378607153892517,
-0.6704428195953369,
0.5697509050369263,
0.21688057482242584,
0.2908163070678711,
-0.3088461756706238,
-0.8713186383247375,
-0.09589727222919464,
-0.3832111060619354,
-0.019452795386314392,
0.23158061504364014,
-0.240758016705513,
0.2539770305156708,
0.14884325861930847,
0.2144232988357544,
-0.6632834076881409,
0.10349858552217484,
-0.30607345700263977,
-0.022363705560564995,
0.5540555119514465,
0.2844502925872803,
0.21605047583580017,
-0.17870214581489563,
-0.33452704548835754,
0.15965557098388672,
-0.5169843435287476,
0.10635565221309662,
0.18145200610160828,
0.0013960039941594005,
0.19517982006072998,
0.43314406275749207,
-0.33521217107772827,
0.4171615242958069,
-0.2409556657075882,
-0.10950548201799393,
-0.054049380123615265,
-0.21391291916370392,
-0.028952807188034058,
-0.24242354929447174,
0.836810827255249,
0.40979325771331787,
0.32820895314216614,
-0.30108335614204407,
-0.031372182071208954,
-0.22279253602027893,
0.4447397291660309,
-1.0144932270050049,
-0.3051131069660187,
0.4937148988246918,
-0.4429455101490021,
-0.22423668205738068,
-0.052528031170368195,
-0.6255600452423096,
-0.20758730173110962,
0.029122207313776016,
0.4278852045536041,
-0.4053555428981781,
0.018938390538096428,
0.06302471458911896,
-0.05330254137516022,
0.32869717478752136,
0.681125283241272,
-0.495868980884552,
0.5775057673454285,
0.3755214512348175,
0.6166298389434814,
-0.11479921638965607,
0.014411150477826595,
-0.29330021142959595,
-0.052591659128665924,
-0.4252396523952484,
1.0797698497772217,
-0.6745443940162659,
-0.37120524048805237,
-0.14157959818840027,
-0.21287263929843903,
-0.09281015396118164,
-0.5290425419807434,
0.3429000675678253,
-0.3534175455570221,
0.10926967114210129,
-0.016644256189465523,
-0.6535378098487854,
-0.10917387157678604,
0.21616807579994202,
-0.4677029848098755,
0.8577980399131775,
0.048640355467796326,
-0.40054938197135925,
0.2722490429878235,
-0.7306504845619202,
-0.3034577965736389,
0.3417350649833679,
-0.2945740520954132,
-0.04707742854952812,
0.10313986241817474,
0.32394638657569885,
0.4779190421104431,
-0.5593573451042175,
0.484077125787735,
-0.21683964133262634,
-0.6145924925804138,
0.5134780406951904,
-0.41812461614608765,
0.6544994711875916,
-0.27083298563957214,
-0.2656242847442627,
-0.001349515514448285,
-0.4744112491607666,
0.14834608137607574,
-0.014305594377219677,
-0.11919272691011429,
0.025312285870313644,
-0.10545934736728668,
-0.16453908383846283,
0.24300041794776917,
0.10238330811262131,
-0.5689185261726379,
0.24901366233825684,
-0.15823055803775787,
0.4881432354450226,
0.8075466752052307,
0.14920926094055176,
-0.33820876479148865,
-0.23316214978694916,
0.7111303806304932,
-0.7236945033073425,
0.6056515574455261,
0.11915302276611328,
-1.1284232139587402,
-0.1579897254705429,
-0.504262387752533,
0.39110931754112244,
0.48518845438957214,
-0.15327957272529602,
0.4612993001937866,
-0.3388619124889374,
-0.7341911792755127,
-0.35986536741256714,
0.3676134943962097,
0.3061634302139282,
0.45635056495666504,
0.29891034960746765,
-0.4050863981246948,
-0.09272115677595139,
-0.943900465965271,
0.04844343289732933,
-0.5525828003883362,
-0.04783937707543373,
0.8425378799438477,
0.8214705586433411,
-0.3955349624156952,
0.5880845189094543,
-0.4078417122364044,
-0.286612331867218,
-0.3086186647415161,
-0.02786741964519024,
0.3795349895954132,
0.28077638149261475,
0.334957480430603,
-0.7806258797645569,
-0.21662920713424683,
0.2134588211774826,
-0.8801733255386353,
-0.148521289229393,
0.25117018818855286,
-0.39183032512664795,
0.04733530059456825,
0.46085885167121887,
-0.6542579531669617,
0.6458503007888794,
0.5831984281539917,
-0.40117931365966797,
0.7006775736808777,
-0.5588300228118896,
0.2947537899017334,
-0.6033955216407776,
0.48502346873283386,
-0.5063033699989319,
-0.38878047466278076,
-0.5198946595191956,
0.25874093174934387,
0.014980243518948555,
-0.16930609941482544,
-0.30607444047927856,
0.6564465165138245,
-0.01988881826400757,
0.026532456278800964,
-0.13307102024555206,
0.42098021507263184,
-0.26476195454597473,
0.5143359899520874,
-0.11880761384963989,
0.3704271614551544,
0.29324960708618164,
-0.5525659322738647,
0.5139302611351013,
0.5757275819778442,
-0.056869808584451675,
0.6726264953613281,
-0.8058380484580994,
0.2579338550567627,
0.3653489649295807,
0.4244746267795563,
-1.389392614364624,
-0.619873046875,
0.044136468321084976,
-0.564244270324707,
0.039973821491003036,
-0.32733574509620667,
-0.45783087611198425,
-0.7090184688568115,
-0.22473138570785522,
0.4148278832435608,
0.7538931965827942,
-0.3011707365512848,
0.8049197793006897,
0.23250529170036316,
-0.46913912892341614,
-0.5345619320869446,
-0.22686466574668884,
0.11410638689994812,
-0.06481591612100601,
-0.5308873653411865,
-0.04250558093190193,
-0.37997063994407654,
-0.026019146665930748,
-0.06287377327680588,
-0.3461076319217682,
-0.1897507756948471,
0.20322388410568237,
0.370899498462677,
0.45248764753341675,
-0.015455611050128937,
0.07970978319644928,
0.10629916936159134,
0.08961541950702667,
0.2197563648223877,
0.3277491331100464,
0.7563612461090088,
-0.25785964727401733,
-0.6605703830718994,
-0.9215177893638611,
0.10238814353942871,
0.6412178874015808,
-0.09864483773708344,
0.433339387178421,
0.36399978399276733,
-0.36989280581474304,
0.2774958610534668,
-0.7621951103210449,
-0.3386501967906952,
-0.37693673372268677,
0.4256174564361572,
-0.32078295946121216,
-0.7645382285118103,
0.6339707970619202,
-0.0006433171802200377,
0.23583762347698212,
0.17124535143375397,
0.5676413774490356,
-0.5074441432952881,
1.2161530256271362,
0.5117170810699463,
0.3657565414905548,
0.10656648129224777,
0.0439143031835556,
0.27230000495910645,
-0.7695826888084412,
-0.5121899843215942,
-0.4908491373062134,
-0.31355586647987366,
-0.8237379789352417,
-0.3124217689037323,
0.25486698746681213,
0.1223667711019516,
0.015956785529851913,
0.13397905230522156,
-0.3407456576824188,
0.1250484138727188,
0.3790520429611206,
0.4041930139064789,
0.4607829451560974,
-0.00764479860663414,
-0.0833176001906395,
0.12601205706596375,
-0.7444753050804138,
-0.6633104681968689,
1.5697972774505615,
0.32011014223098755,
0.8895074129104614,
0.30751436948776245,
0.7542243003845215,
0.4840552806854248,
0.5189318060874939,
-0.7436125874519348,
0.7534834742546082,
0.00852679368108511,
-0.9113211035728455,
-0.44203981757164,
-0.3949875831604004,
-1.0279297828674316,
0.3240945637226105,
-0.08857864886522293,
-1.0378055572509766,
-0.11104738712310791,
0.032338276505470276,
-0.28740501403808594,
0.18317663669586182,
-0.37977299094200134,
0.6641992330551147,
-0.3490850031375885,
-0.20209206640720367,
-0.15894542634487152,
-0.6274220943450928,
0.19873663783073425,
-0.19951198995113373,
0.12954799830913544,
-0.2874114215373993,
-0.29003626108169556,
0.8002662062644958,
-0.37700706720352173,
0.6191214919090271,
-0.049857690930366516,
0.08725028485059738,
0.015465528704226017,
0.135612353682518,
0.228488951921463,
0.5415095090866089,
0.16133174300193787,
0.29611462354660034,
0.13662093877792358,
-0.5743911266326904,
-0.6653689742088318,
0.5464034080505371,
-0.7371050119400024,
-0.8363326191902161,
-0.17652375996112823,
-0.5472456812858582,
-0.3547142744064331,
0.08297671377658844,
-0.06177496165037155,
0.7346852421760559,
-0.33992597460746765,
0.4905755817890167,
0.6042030453681946,
-0.2887762784957886,
-0.14012190699577332,
0.39705970883369446,
-0.34347599744796753,
-0.514275074005127,
0.44993874430656433,
-0.22789646685123444,
0.31086546182632446,
0.4175400733947754,
0.2533848285675049,
-0.44591355323791504,
-0.6176357269287109,
-0.5035393834114075,
0.6081823110580444,
-0.6250850558280945,
-0.28565970063209534,
-0.8149506449699402,
-0.24115046858787537,
-0.382826566696167,
-0.20097124576568604,
-0.1586737483739853,
-0.0907755196094513,
0.44160497188568115,
0.045767735689878464,
0.3664102256298065,
0.8182674050331116,
0.1241326853632927,
0.19403541088104248,
-0.48630866408348083,
0.26887011528015137,
0.2798577845096588,
0.4287950396537781,
-0.5033780932426453,
-0.853969931602478,
0.05610388517379761,
-0.22869111597537994,
-0.16707932949066162,
-0.8265653252601624,
0.16623471677303314,
0.00040098687168210745,
0.7244022488594055,
0.6450066566467285,
-0.08257891982793808,
0.693166196346283,
-0.27902233600616455,
0.5194957852363586,
0.0411067008972168,
-0.6523968577384949,
0.6841885447502136,
-0.40545541048049927,
0.20641276240348816,
0.4160318076610565,
0.40878960490226746,
-0.3940097987651825,
-0.8141771554946899,
-0.787788450717926,
-0.8337108492851257,
0.7439871430397034,
0.6415786147117615,
0.2001672238111496,
0.03981676697731018,
0.39189404249191284,
0.3350266218185425,
0.22162699699401855,
-0.5892637372016907,
-0.051427606493234634,
0.27094319462776184,
0.05563683435320854,
0.2554210424423218,
-0.34526190161705017,
-0.39481887221336365,
-0.09082473814487457,
0.5516498684883118,
-0.13174447417259216,
0.683868944644928,
0.22845542430877686,
-0.33664801716804504,
0.05758345499634743,
0.21710529923439026,
0.5537583827972412,
1.192420482635498,
-0.7328305244445801,
-0.26972848176956177,
0.18193946778774261,
-0.6557920575141907,
0.018052514642477036,
0.27014198899269104,
0.15246520936489105,
0.11379148811101913,
0.7036926746368408,
0.39926376938819885,
0.27078336477279663,
-1.125392198562622,
0.49520400166511536,
-0.321853905916214,
-0.449054479598999,
0.05746978148818016,
0.008704842999577522,
-0.11638206988573074,
0.30665063858032227,
0.2559609115123749,
-0.13076648116111755,
0.1885388046503067,
-0.5089865326881409,
0.12804874777793884,
0.19652818143367767,
-0.47355350852012634,
-0.2049858719110489,
0.6509701609611511,
0.31004226207733154,
-0.3051675856113434,
0.694843590259552,
0.2050851285457611,
-0.3501720726490021,
0.7021397948265076,
0.5037139058113098,
0.3897166848182678,
-0.33206290006637573,
0.2534560263156891,
0.45090219378471375,
0.32185354828834534,
0.08463701605796814,
0.4456109404563904,
0.01731315441429615,
-0.39862072467803955,
-0.27368515729904175,
-0.4893537759780884,
-0.8206996917724609,
0.22405220568180084,
-0.9229938387870789,
0.00889884028583765,
-0.7299150824546814,
-0.3567606508731842,
-0.10576830059289932,
0.08009862154722214,
-0.8016190528869629,
0.28902754187583923,
0.053806986659765244,
0.9088002443313599,
-0.7746275067329407,
0.2881344258785248,
1.0068082809448242,
-0.4780901372432709,
-0.474456787109375,
-0.15810006856918335,
-0.42169758677482605,
-1.0012269020080566,
0.386311799287796,
0.30209967494010925,
0.03722817078232765,
-0.2429588884115219,
-0.42220059037208557,
-0.7526457905769348,
1.0649884939193726,
0.3206203877925873,
-0.3920225203037262,
-0.05286403000354767,
0.004917440935969353,
0.6594911217689514,
-0.1451539546251297,
0.7334690690040588,
0.5275466442108154,
0.29414016008377075,
-0.18396495282649994,
-1.13516104221344,
0.19159460067749023,
-0.1712372601032257,
-0.15900707244873047,
0.1709500402212143,
-0.5721794366836548,
0.35410067439079285,
-0.44713571667671204,
0.24296370148658752,
0.6742756366729736,
0.2179296314716339,
0.583311140537262,
0.09097703546285629,
0.2537812888622284,
0.33411121368408203,
0.8887660503387451,
-0.2561386525630951,
1.1356390714645386,
-0.38225340843200684,
0.16230931878089905,
0.8116758465766907,
-0.20589716732501984,
0.8963954448699951,
0.42036643624305725,
-0.26481229066848755,
0.7836371064186096,
0.30789706110954285,
0.026818564161658287,
0.09358349442481995,
-0.14028355479240417,
0.1016421765089035,
-0.5509370565414429,
-0.008928939700126648,
-0.5025269389152527,
0.7351547479629517,
0.24760735034942627,
-0.32380566000938416,
-0.035453591495752335,
0.1519484668970108,
-0.12963402271270752,
-0.16726884245872498,
-0.1403743177652359,
0.6567133069038391,
-0.05259455367922783,
-0.5373221039772034,
0.4867989718914032,
-0.37601718306541443,
0.14871607720851898,
-0.8380024433135986,
-0.16977471113204956,
-0.6001814603805542,
0.3434496819972992,
-0.014678412117064,
-0.8174103498458862,
-0.321927011013031,
0.20053645968437195,
0.31287604570388794,
0.0024459469132125378,
0.41033053398132324,
0.1328742951154709,
-0.3297325372695923,
0.32350850105285645,
0.6227239966392517,
0.8820862174034119,
0.02807701751589775,
-0.7427006363868713,
-0.11477155238389969,
-0.2360055148601532,
-0.19310230016708374,
0.14131078124046326,
0.5298755764961243,
-0.277818500995636,
1.1137295961380005,
0.6393557786941528,
0.10804241895675659,
-0.15261247754096985,
0.25222593545913696,
0.7808821797370911,
-0.7484341263771057,
-0.34851503372192383,
-0.6808879971504211,
0.14966002106666565,
-0.12097345292568207,
-0.4219667911529541,
0.5084415674209595,
0.4477561116218567,
0.518547534942627,
0.053155604749917984,
0.47673559188842773,
-0.25538232922554016,
0.17215345799922943,
-0.4098365008831024,
0.6634261012077332,
-0.5919058322906494,
-0.03859331086277962,
-0.4225207567214966,
-0.8874233961105347,
-0.29629722237586975,
0.6077737212181091,
-0.19648848474025726,
0.26727551221847534,
0.927331805229187,
0.6294965147972107,
0.18768858909606934,
-0.00610737781971693,
0.662796139717102,
0.3482283055782318,
0.5104512572288513,
0.46149763464927673,
0.8098590970039368,
-0.4349447786808014,
1.0464715957641602,
-0.22093357145786285,
-0.3910011351108551,
-0.6210017204284668,
-0.34547287225723267,
-1.1450985670089722,
-0.04110872000455856,
-0.14563436806201935,
-0.1966322660446167,
0.38770559430122375,
0.6903037428855896,
0.7010164856910706,
-0.6983314752578735,
-0.2769003212451935,
0.16161207854747772,
-0.06595456600189209,
-0.20628181099891663,
-0.10223551094532013,
0.4570523202419281,
-0.1525191068649292,
-0.5769585371017456,
0.10374511033296585,
0.37139812111854553,
-0.20709078013896942,
-0.002843942027539015,
-0.06735822558403015,
-0.28554877638816833,
0.08071709424257278,
0.5277014970779419,
0.2341989278793335,
-0.9601675868034363,
-0.09152043610811234,
0.19046807289123535,
-0.11952020972967148,
0.2315247356891632,
0.4851478636264801,
-0.6584001183509827,
0.5270649790763855,
0.28621789813041687,
0.625022292137146,
0.1532517671585083,
-0.006419667508453131,
0.5131245255470276,
-0.021358154714107513,
-0.16120795905590057,
0.34960100054740906,
0.464614599943161,
0.08181601017713547,
-0.21035005152225494,
0.6436331272125244,
0.38532888889312744,
-0.7681050896644592,
-1.021162986755371,
-0.08934237062931061,
-1.002742886543274,
-0.226265087723732,
1.0561105012893677,
0.02511421963572502,
-0.13004304468631744,
-0.24178749322891235,
-0.3949648141860962,
0.03373507410287857,
-0.5003429651260376,
0.7673411965370178,
0.5296734571456909,
-0.682292640209198,
0.32961511611938477,
-0.8321568369865417,
0.1072906106710434,
0.49621689319610596,
-0.9858081340789795,
-0.09119639545679092,
0.3699187934398651,
0.5271959900856018,
0.013659331947565079,
0.8584723472595215,
-0.4109930396080017,
0.8044215440750122,
-0.13790804147720337,
0.17107552289962769,
-0.08363379538059235,
-0.43674519658088684,
-0.04946957528591156,
0.06301932781934738,
0.15637598931789398,
0.07509619742631912
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.01424v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.01424v1
|
Universal In-Context Approximation By Prompting Fully Recurrent Models
| 2024-06-03T15:25:13 | 2024-06-03T15:25:13 |
Aleksandar Petrov, Tom A. Lamb, Alasdair Paren, Philip H. S. Torr, Adel Bibi
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Zero-shot and in-context learning enable solving tasks without model
fine-tuning, making them essential for developing generative model solutions.
Therefore, it is crucial to understand whether a pretrained model can be
prompted to approximate any function, i.e., whether it is a universal
in-context approximator. While it was recently shown that transformer models do
possess this property, these results rely on their attention mechanism. Hence,
these findings do not apply to fully recurrent architectures like RNNs, LSTMs,
and the increasingly popular SSMs. We demonstrate that RNNs, LSTMs, GRUs,
Linear RNNs, and linear gated architectures such as Mamba and Hawk/Griffin can
also serve as universal in-context approximators. To streamline our argument,
we introduce a programming language called LSRL that compiles to these fully
recurrent architectures. LSRL may be of independent interest for further
studies of fully recurrent models, such as constructing interpretability
benchmarks. We also study the role of multiplicative gating and observe that
architectures incorporating such gating (e.g., LSTMs, GRUs, Hawk/Griffin) can
implement certain operations more stably, making them more viable candidates
for practical in-context universal approximation.
|
[
-0.33872196078300476,
-0.49062374234199524,
0.7838468551635742,
0.29181867837905884,
0.0083291782066226,
-0.16181276738643646,
-0.17292454838752747,
-0.40125226974487305,
-0.34356680512428284,
0.14401809871196747,
-0.6933172345161438,
-0.08282127231359482,
-0.19445757567882538,
-0.009148773737251759,
-0.6459007263183594,
0.9896880984306335,
0.13526493310928345,
0.03475891798734665,
-0.0451810322701931,
-0.20201042294502258,
-0.26981833577156067,
-0.7191742062568665,
-0.22176331281661987,
-0.6125256419181824,
0.28417837619781494,
0.008262126706540585,
0.565399169921875,
0.1246623694896698,
0.35690057277679443,
0.21429108083248138,
-0.2314222902059555,
-0.2984003722667694,
-0.19318567216396332,
0.15766385197639465,
-0.12715016305446625,
-0.26815924048423767,
-0.13896992802619934,
-0.24676267802715302,
0.7501482963562012,
0.8766186237335205,
-0.10298703610897064,
0.27290764451026917,
0.3212122619152069,
0.6919755935668945,
-0.6328415870666504,
-0.004461774602532387,
-0.5190538763999939,
0.5323778986930847,
0.3039475381374359,
-0.2620881199836731,
-0.6481671333312988,
-0.17876696586608887,
0.3431174159049988,
-0.49301666021347046,
0.38537654280662537,
-0.3696281313896179,
0.6493709087371826,
0.36674994230270386,
-0.3082394003868103,
-0.17958387732505798,
-1.0300637483596802,
0.9414507150650024,
-0.6656361818313599,
0.42618268728256226,
-0.30215227603912354,
0.26313066482543945,
-0.3731362223625183,
-0.9750416874885559,
-0.2695668935775757,
-0.5046074986457825,
-0.12335146963596344,
0.20653630793094635,
-0.4162675440311432,
0.45354294776916504,
0.6281927227973938,
0.35954126715660095,
-0.12941959500312805,
-0.18259398639202118,
-0.1927305907011032,
0.17852815985679626,
0.044201336801052094,
0.23174677789211273,
0.16259287297725677,
0.0683753490447998,
-0.6388798952102661,
0.13825291395187378,
-0.7345452904701233,
0.24500134587287903,
-0.38880932331085205,
0.21347397565841675,
0.00901242345571518,
0.290324866771698,
0.07882554829120636,
1.2186964750289917,
0.21303614974021912,
0.34511661529541016,
-0.1112074926495552,
-0.3270043730735779,
-0.6742929220199585,
-0.2906807065010071,
0.4541231393814087,
0.1244354248046875,
0.47444525361061096,
-0.4718424379825592,
-0.10038790851831436,
0.01753917708992958,
0.5920678973197937,
-0.461396723985672,
0.22828790545463562,
0.10466498881578445,
-0.196437269449234,
-0.25536760687828064,
0.22847698628902435,
-0.6062880158424377,
-0.021776117384433746,
-0.5844911932945251,
0.5569156408309937,
-0.15516164898872375,
0.05920286476612091,
0.04638618975877762,
0.1669677197933197,
0.7052486538887024,
0.18397948145866394,
-0.6149917840957642,
0.37046018242836,
0.6507071852684021,
0.8754227161407471,
0.11524549126625061,
-0.5319246053695679,
-0.4847566783428192,
0.23518596589565277,
-0.42594102025032043,
0.6055371761322021,
-0.579531729221344,
-0.4219815731048584,
-0.0030358328949660063,
0.031680528074502945,
-0.112237349152565,
-0.22380520403385162,
0.3580382764339447,
-0.4382939636707306,
0.07478021085262299,
-0.07624615728855133,
-0.5836349129676819,
-0.12041040509939194,
-0.129816472530365,
-0.5472961068153381,
0.7683519124984741,
0.31864482164382935,
-0.5342901349067688,
0.16288383305072784,
-1.1342699527740479,
-0.4783823490142822,
-0.11009291559457779,
-0.12772470712661743,
-0.08523207902908325,
0.5084372162818909,
0.1623551994562149,
0.6162688136100769,
-0.18039359152317047,
0.2503912150859833,
-0.33348599076271057,
-0.6414405703544617,
0.27116018533706665,
-0.6973326802253723,
0.6264556050300598,
0.3329373896121979,
-0.40656787157058716,
0.45354554057121277,
-0.19807960093021393,
0.2907881736755371,
-0.057222649455070496,
-0.0875120684504509,
0.010690782219171524,
-0.20399585366249084,
0.03265073150396347,
0.12553024291992188,
-0.08212529122829437,
-0.32693666219711304,
0.1234356239438057,
-0.37244734168052673,
0.7130875587463379,
0.6837893128395081,
-0.021079933270812035,
0.7604987621307373,
-0.30270323157310486,
0.6622287631034851,
-0.32851120829582214,
0.30385398864746094,
-0.5618969202041626,
-0.44653478264808655,
-0.6193424463272095,
-0.303914874792099,
0.28642693161964417,
0.40014854073524475,
-0.21457970142364502,
0.2887820601463318,
-0.3281506896018982,
-0.2169530689716339,
-0.5102666616439819,
-0.23120690882205963,
0.6346134543418884,
0.4810735881328583,
0.2894793748855591,
-0.15070152282714844,
-0.6936659216880798,
-0.6581336855888367,
-0.23987971246242523,
0.35622844099998474,
-0.511188805103302,
0.07801266014575958,
0.18452653288841248,
0.0027396781370043755,
1.0183804035186768,
-0.1933959722518921,
-0.26885414123535156,
-0.3043447434902191,
-0.0791330486536026,
0.43532729148864746,
0.17064689099788666,
0.5005694627761841,
-0.6527518630027771,
-0.572145938873291,
0.005539124831557274,
-0.893122673034668,
0.27259600162506104,
-0.247845858335495,
0.1716913878917694,
0.17167030274868011,
0.5208994746208191,
-0.642987072467804,
0.6737193465232849,
0.3245874047279358,
0.039533358067274094,
0.42347192764282227,
-0.4026431739330292,
-0.1701674461364746,
-0.9130728244781494,
0.3365757167339325,
0.16130363941192627,
-0.3906148672103882,
-1.0928040742874146,
0.6372295022010803,
0.04961147531867027,
-0.3437231183052063,
-0.6109733581542969,
0.7411389350891113,
-0.5831547379493713,
-0.4882849156856537,
-0.13388273119926453,
0.002645285567268729,
-0.1206195205450058,
0.5729434490203857,
0.1835666000843048,
0.8746522665023804,
0.7169732451438904,
-0.7485213875770569,
-0.026785291731357574,
0.015346280299127102,
-0.5190637707710266,
0.41075247526168823,
-0.8644964694976807,
-0.05530775710940361,
-0.34580716490745544,
0.471578449010849,
-0.7174676656723022,
-0.2080882042646408,
0.08926086127758026,
-0.3732099235057831,
0.3973661959171295,
-0.21028122305870056,
0.09780268371105194,
-0.40756702423095703,
-0.2592478394508362,
0.3286432921886444,
0.5749218463897705,
-0.7331294417381287,
0.6600349545478821,
0.06946493685245514,
0.35752245783805847,
-0.8774239420890808,
-0.668170154094696,
-0.07427120208740234,
-0.12446919083595276,
-0.060954924672842026,
0.2746633291244507,
-0.25086647272109985,
-0.06548696011304855,
-0.008965764194726944,
-0.21091562509536743,
-0.039677564054727554,
0.10232078284025192,
0.3497047424316406,
0.23729035258293152,
-0.2676366865634918,
-0.2005588263273239,
-0.46552443504333496,
-0.2575449049472809,
-0.2162921279668808,
-0.30769872665405273,
0.49022138118743896,
-0.7297213673591614,
-0.5965750217437744,
-0.5318723917007446,
0.22655373811721802,
0.794988214969635,
0.22091680765151978,
0.22060437500476837,
0.3237186372280121,
-0.21732640266418457,
-0.02052619867026806,
-0.39596661925315857,
-0.07954824715852737,
-0.48745056986808777,
0.374862402677536,
-0.47043880820274353,
-0.9298907518386841,
0.49526447057724,
0.14998885989189148,
0.20001386106014252,
0.21105237305164337,
0.5872913599014282,
-0.224495530128479,
0.8563616871833801,
0.49668705463409424,
-0.3207089602947235,
0.48672473430633545,
-0.2984250783920288,
0.11958480626344681,
-1.1635088920593262,
0.05088341236114502,
-0.3068017363548279,
-0.2971722185611725,
-0.316305935382843,
-0.2306927889585495,
0.29526594281196594,
0.13319510221481323,
-0.524044394493103,
0.4317193925380707,
-0.8200719356536865,
0.8015972971916199,
0.5941299796104431,
-0.07032060623168945,
0.12624576687812805,
0.31193864345550537,
-0.12681199610233307,
-0.022571420297026634,
-0.91973876953125,
-0.09151975065469742,
0.9393770694732666,
0.2648790180683136,
0.7827324867248535,
-0.16500894725322723,
0.3682028353214264,
0.34953197836875916,
0.7603714466094971,
-0.8900643587112427,
0.2980881929397583,
-0.021135836839675903,
-0.49906614422798157,
-0.42901551723480225,
-0.16283364593982697,
-1.1077734231948853,
0.30936744809150696,
0.30319657921791077,
-0.8254655599594116,
0.13615138828754425,
0.1766315996646881,
-0.6637696027755737,
0.4997711181640625,
-0.5355364084243774,
0.7010628581047058,
-0.03458504378795624,
-0.0001421033957740292,
0.08071542531251907,
-0.7191694974899292,
0.27237826585769653,
0.1813245266675949,
0.15433083474636078,
0.2916971743106842,
0.17284083366394043,
0.20874415338039398,
-0.11790819466114044,
0.8799156546592712,
-0.27013731002807617,
0.05905076116323471,
0.366097092628479,
0.19967730343341827,
0.3637933135032654,
-0.22024989128112793,
0.026993008330464363,
0.17822681367397308,
0.06262154132127762,
-0.45249471068382263,
-0.9426600933074951,
0.7010137438774109,
-0.5248608589172363,
-0.7444533705711365,
-0.45874446630477905,
-0.5326708555221558,
-0.209971085190773,
-0.02918201871216297,
0.3713092803955078,
0.750924825668335,
-0.1323980987071991,
0.4728875756263733,
0.4312985837459564,
0.2523391544818878,
0.7701146006584167,
0.37116044759750366,
-0.31507477164268494,
-0.23914141952991486,
0.5591937899589539,
-0.2522781491279602,
0.43540018796920776,
0.4826805591583252,
-0.0030088990461081266,
-0.4346609115600586,
-0.20249921083450317,
-0.6371831893920898,
-0.03810081258416176,
-0.7308152914047241,
-0.2696015238761902,
-0.3200516402721405,
-0.580867350101471,
0.1440911889076233,
-0.6891422867774963,
-0.09165183454751968,
-0.389943927526474,
-0.19727542996406555,
-0.11769178509712219,
0.12572509050369263,
0.9159831404685974,
-0.12422626465559006,
0.17485292255878448,
-0.8266794681549072,
0.16621994972229004,
0.465251088142395,
0.39548447728157043,
0.6613945364952087,
-0.8378212451934814,
-0.09942629933357239,
0.21747983992099762,
-0.2622050940990448,
-0.521248996257782,
0.06644311547279358,
0.4950907826423645,
0.6574648022651672,
0.43797051906585693,
-0.21979691088199615,
1.0229597091674805,
-0.7093682885169983,
0.7842581272125244,
0.4144086241722107,
-1.0493706464767456,
0.246169775724411,
-0.1390845775604248,
0.5534223318099976,
0.451158732175827,
0.34562239050865173,
-0.6379731893539429,
-0.2110673040151596,
-0.49643880128860474,
-0.5512287020683289,
0.6904873847961426,
0.1719517856836319,
0.4782898724079132,
0.002629024675115943,
0.5028716921806335,
-0.23800288140773773,
0.10330159962177277,
-0.9885139465332031,
-0.2664022147655487,
-0.38027870655059814,
-0.18179099261760712,
0.009853537194430828,
-0.39433619379997253,
-0.11751867830753326,
-0.2565816342830658,
0.15592323243618011,
-0.07584146410226822,
0.6294375061988831,
0.4500837028026581,
-0.1743483692407608,
-0.17415396869182587,
0.4817740321159363,
0.9257626533508301,
0.8737834095954895,
-0.2057485729455948,
0.021262554451823235,
0.33953964710235596,
-0.10356307029724121,
0.5416532754898071,
-0.3399418592453003,
-0.4603292644023895,
0.03628963604569435,
0.35337960720062256,
0.8254317045211792,
0.9397480487823486,
-0.5601069927215576,
0.5639234781265259,
0.04183477535843849,
-0.07877323031425476,
-0.5127912163734436,
0.011360835283994675,
-0.0708141103386879,
0.19793832302093506,
0.6020761728286743,
0.34149348735809326,
-0.04491536319255829,
-0.4271993041038513,
0.4185231029987335,
0.7308898568153381,
-0.9519787430763245,
-0.47612398862838745,
0.7474088072776794,
-0.016521276906132698,
-0.47625505924224854,
0.39498889446258545,
0.07417789101600647,
-0.4751494824886322,
0.6572895050048828,
0.808141827583313,
1.0668576955795288,
-0.34797707200050354,
0.06304164230823517,
0.4481659233570099,
0.11506294459104538,
-0.28924983739852905,
-0.027209321036934853,
-0.461311936378479,
-0.5967163443565369,
-0.8345676064491272,
-0.7059634327888489,
-0.35639235377311707,
0.1753029227256775,
-0.9957438707351685,
-0.13028444349765778,
-0.559928297996521,
-0.06900662928819656,
0.03253215551376343,
-0.4720921218395233,
-0.7187529802322388,
0.0163175780326128,
0.06583905965089798,
0.8372492790222168,
-0.34563302993774414,
0.9312335252761841,
0.6063351631164551,
-0.38322171568870544,
-0.514002799987793,
0.053304534405469894,
-0.1982022225856781,
-0.6439898610115051,
0.670360267162323,
0.15407687425613403,
-0.3131250739097595,
0.18382112681865692,
-0.47406524419784546,
-0.8441793918609619,
0.8913110494613647,
0.3299454152584076,
-0.5900991559028625,
-0.30647027492523193,
0.08845687657594681,
0.5616239905357361,
-0.4287659227848053,
0.32752975821495056,
0.3864024579524994,
0.47074228525161743,
0.3195067346096039,
-0.9054035544395447,
-0.037654198706150055,
-0.06165751442313194,
0.20294199883937836,
0.16443949937820435,
-0.3360055685043335,
0.6810229420661926,
-0.5137026906013489,
-0.3667180836200714,
0.35767823457717896,
0.6866037845611572,
0.20058321952819824,
0.13162708282470703,
0.31058743596076965,
0.5090524554252625,
0.29762184619903564,
0.08737600594758987,
1.2957701683044434,
-0.5954921245574951,
0.6638376712799072,
1.2811765670776367,
-0.29058441519737244,
0.6120796799659729,
0.42363840341567993,
-0.5501688718795776,
0.2725079357624054,
0.23291072249412537,
-0.10288075357675552,
0.529854416847229,
0.06002627685666084,
-0.4312429130077362,
-0.21092724800109863,
0.12270907312631607,
-0.4517037272453308,
0.03339351713657379,
0.2945699095726013,
-0.186325803399086,
-0.516143262386322,
-0.013270125724375248,
-0.15880869328975677,
-0.1692199558019638,
-0.47590476274490356,
0.6421151757240295,
0.31240618228912354,
-0.6608512997627258,
0.7770910263061523,
-0.23033148050308228,
0.7584364414215088,
-0.8160401582717896,
0.05393185839056969,
-0.3466780185699463,
0.1019541397690773,
-0.08310937881469727,
-0.8703106641769409,
0.37350961565971375,
-0.06645797938108444,
-0.2633693516254425,
-0.011292751878499985,
0.6625640392303467,
-0.2864299714565277,
-0.5210756659507751,
0.43468040227890015,
0.11570389568805695,
0.029206475242972374,
-0.14745782315731049,
-0.5065709352493286,
-0.3281099498271942,
0.2061179131269455,
-0.2763172388076782,
0.6197766065597534,
0.06672915816307068,
0.10957939922809601,
1.032241940498352,
0.588233232498169,
-0.07793890684843063,
0.143325075507164,
0.11344972997903824,
0.6257648468017578,
-0.8597011566162109,
-0.19392135739326477,
-0.8919522166252136,
0.4283022880554199,
0.16819728910923004,
-0.009875558316707611,
0.6942721009254456,
0.17039959132671356,
0.9036925435066223,
-0.45711106061935425,
0.7962744832038879,
0.050211187452077866,
0.15106436610221863,
-0.3756798803806305,
0.587087869644165,
-0.6449866890907288,
-0.06922035664319992,
-0.28307828307151794,
-1.1591720581054688,
-0.5739201307296753,
0.6050929427146912,
-0.12218870222568512,
0.05277901515364647,
0.44262954592704773,
0.6188830733299255,
-0.3764309585094452,
0.0818471685051918,
0.8157531023025513,
0.036690447479486465,
0.046365946531295776,
0.582537829875946,
0.8195911049842834,
-0.33501923084259033,
0.4403839707374573,
-0.12241007387638092,
-0.05245712399482727,
-0.13605694472789764,
-0.8941234350204468,
-0.6300786733627319,
-0.5809540152549744,
0.1539572924375534,
-0.3393520712852478,
-0.09028742462396622,
0.9404228925704956,
0.7017207741737366,
-1.0277915000915527,
-0.2855505347251892,
-0.2014552503824234,
0.05738439783453941,
-0.2921719253063202,
-0.21380934119224548,
0.40992820262908936,
-0.6836217641830444,
-0.508732259273529,
0.5692585706710815,
0.3623751997947693,
0.05077610909938812,
-0.30177637934684753,
-0.17140935361385345,
0.1441417932510376,
0.15151230990886688,
0.8822088837623596,
0.8383875489234924,
-1.0631344318389893,
-0.4119177460670471,
0.08343927562236786,
0.13689854741096497,
0.1931258738040924,
1.1943386793136597,
-0.8199390769004822,
0.44732922315597534,
-0.08943487703800201,
0.5886481404304504,
0.41339269280433655,
0.16716311872005463,
0.4976409375667572,
-0.7417809963226318,
0.49346837401390076,
0.1107589527964592,
0.2317863553762436,
0.18155726790428162,
-0.10402396321296692,
0.6495906114578247,
-0.08607826381921768,
-0.6401872634887695,
-0.8504099249839783,
0.49533605575561523,
-0.6923765540122986,
-0.23131607472896576,
0.8847048878669739,
-0.28421398997306824,
-0.43199872970581055,
-0.125980943441391,
0.10896684974431992,
-0.04389111325144768,
-0.1634458750486374,
0.7601555585861206,
0.420387864112854,
-0.3025180995464325,
-0.09810876101255417,
-0.5329883098602295,
0.704282820224762,
0.4828842282295227,
-0.27409952878952026,
0.20917271077632904,
0.2182164043188095,
0.4109269678592682,
0.11394089460372925,
0.6236906051635742,
-0.056340016424655914,
0.4945918321609497,
-0.38109394907951355,
0.2029772251844406,
-0.10197190195322037,
-0.43708786368370056,
-0.7217287421226501,
0.17454726994037628,
-0.11354439705610275,
-0.0008050634642131627
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.01422v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.01422v1
|
How to Understand Whole Software Repository?
| 2024-06-03T15:20:06 | 2024-06-03T15:20:06 |
Yingwei Ma, Qingping Yang, Rongyu Cao, Binhua Li, Fei Huang, Yongbin Li
|
cs.SE
|
cs.SE, cs.CL
|
Recently, Large Language Model (LLM) based agents have advanced the
significant development of Automatic Software Engineering (ASE). Although
verified effectiveness, the designs of the existing methods mainly focus on the
local information of codes, e.g., issues, classes, and functions, leading to
limitations in capturing the global context and interdependencies within the
software system. From the practical experiences of the human SE developers, we
argue that an excellent understanding of the whole repository will be the
critical path to ASE. However, understanding the whole repository raises
various challenges, e.g., the extremely long code input, the noisy code
information, the complex dependency relationships, etc. To this end, we develop
a novel ASE method named RepoUnderstander by guiding agents to comprehensively
understand the whole repositories. Specifically, we first condense the critical
information of the whole repository into the repository knowledge graph in a
top-to-down mode to decrease the complexity of repository. Subsequently, we
empower the agents the ability of understanding whole repository by proposing a
Monte Carlo tree search based repository exploration strategy. In addition, to
better utilize the repository-level knowledge, we guide the agents to
summarize, analyze, and plan. Then, they can manipulate the tools to
dynamically acquire information and generate the patches to solve the
real-world GitHub issues. Extensive experiments demonstrate the superiority and
effectiveness of the proposed RepoUnderstander. It achieved 18.5\% relative
improvement on the SWE-bench Lite benchmark compared to SWE-agent.
|
[
-0.6274212002754211,
-0.23290036618709564,
0.5936761498451233,
0.05594862625002861,
-0.26111292839050293,
0.30574458837509155,
-0.17612674832344055,
-0.27083852887153625,
0.16851401329040527,
0.6866328120231628,
-0.780910313129425,
-0.5558276176452637,
-0.31892603635787964,
0.07076002657413483,
-0.3743107318878174,
0.7251259684562683,
-0.26633238792419434,
-0.038763925433158875,
0.16714046895503998,
-0.07365630567073822,
-0.5681215524673462,
0.10211832821369171,
-0.4635254144668579,
-0.23580865561962128,
0.35084590315818787,
0.443942666053772,
0.27000948786735535,
0.46786952018737793,
0.3792668282985687,
0.41050636768341064,
-0.003381409216672182,
-0.36087384819984436,
-0.4189850091934204,
0.3577035069465637,
-0.32579609751701355,
-0.5193911194801331,
0.04963814467191696,
-0.32537123560905457,
0.2786061763763428,
0.11092092841863632,
-0.049768395721912384,
0.26537179946899414,
0.05215516313910484,
0.8032622337341309,
-0.7158905863761902,
0.4071439504623413,
-0.3307306468486786,
0.06791258603334427,
-0.1393769532442093,
-0.4813251793384552,
-0.5694566965103149,
0.007683641742914915,
0.1424153447151184,
-0.8441840410232544,
0.016134649515151978,
-0.10258520394563675,
0.8328297138214111,
0.4033251106739044,
-0.4727473855018616,
-0.32789912819862366,
-0.7285783886909485,
0.5143159031867981,
-0.6477686166763306,
0.2767360508441925,
-0.0949040874838829,
0.7592533826828003,
-0.3422311246395111,
-0.49103492498397827,
-0.3146575391292572,
-0.43242987990379333,
-0.0035381661728024483,
0.1760556846857071,
0.05511997267603874,
0.27439558506011963,
0.23442445695400238,
0.41607245802879333,
-0.6093254685401917,
-0.1250164657831192,
-0.15510044991970062,
-0.3402511179447174,
0.6438376307487488,
-0.26365289092063904,
0.595808744430542,
-0.17918485403060913,
-0.41780200600624084,
-0.400086909532547,
-0.5495270490646362,
-0.13082005083560944,
-0.013015770353376865,
0.1776839941740036,
0.11614476144313812,
0.4465700387954712,
0.13927075266838074,
0.3151555061340332,
-0.17972728610038757,
0.23450258374214172,
0.06885272264480591,
-0.09897950291633606,
-0.3610473573207855,
-0.15245631337165833,
0.5201916694641113,
-0.06674712896347046,
0.3887149393558502,
-0.23284736275672913,
-0.45944347977638245,
0.0373879075050354,
0.5494019389152527,
-0.5243276953697205,
-0.13549771904945374,
0.6181502938270569,
-0.2747802734375,
-0.31358179450035095,
0.29121527075767517,
-0.5907347798347473,
-0.6414980888366699,
-0.45503148436546326,
0.5231043696403503,
-0.6011929512023926,
-0.4183492958545685,
-0.3764626085758209,
-0.2619215250015259,
0.3045210540294647,
0.44711124897003174,
-0.18884819746017456,
0.24520540237426758,
0.8611791133880615,
0.7666215300559998,
0.2157164067029953,
-0.533945620059967,
-0.5385098457336426,
0.31151413917541504,
-0.18682435154914856,
1.0872715711593628,
-0.15246498584747314,
-0.3054998517036438,
-0.18452921509742737,
0.09868358075618744,
0.14524781703948975,
-0.4079516530036926,
-0.11914395540952682,
-0.7629575133323669,
-0.09550736844539642,
-0.06088092178106308,
-0.7094369530677795,
-0.24863100051879883,
0.3642897605895996,
-0.6967474222183228,
0.3280286490917206,
0.37251484394073486,
-0.6143427491188049,
0.17496182024478912,
-0.9580274224281311,
-0.06775174289941788,
0.14246156811714172,
-0.36475083231925964,
-0.15073667466640472,
0.04277602210640907,
0.2146831452846527,
-0.021244896575808525,
-0.18214210867881775,
0.28913095593452454,
0.026898767799139023,
-0.6712391376495361,
0.1729229986667633,
-0.01851988211274147,
0.9016895294189453,
0.3256003260612488,
-0.6005010604858398,
0.3755906820297241,
-0.25530073046684265,
-0.11869025230407715,
-0.0548834428191185,
0.024821007624268532,
-0.28145503997802734,
-0.18322023749351501,
0.09810564666986465,
-0.0923248901963234,
0.045358806848526,
-0.4694010019302368,
0.43699732422828674,
-0.46892011165618896,
0.43419238924980164,
0.9793756604194641,
0.2882396876811981,
0.8160200119018555,
-0.15872520208358765,
0.8196888566017151,
-0.03241245076060295,
0.3931552469730377,
-0.34630143642425537,
-0.0372878722846508,
-0.31013330817222595,
-0.3535114824771881,
0.5887578129768372,
0.7604868412017822,
-0.8392332792282104,
0.23860998451709747,
-0.20780561864376068,
-0.26005494594573975,
-0.6035786867141724,
0.20608645677566528,
0.48054039478302,
-0.16832409799098969,
0.3151801824569702,
-0.32895132899284363,
-0.6389685869216919,
-0.7676544189453125,
-0.1751682460308075,
-0.35338881611824036,
-0.38790634274482727,
0.42046064138412476,
0.6740304827690125,
-0.589178204536438,
1.0296038389205933,
-0.5078677535057068,
-0.39672061800956726,
-0.15001089870929718,
0.07386975735425949,
0.020685510709881783,
0.2291603684425354,
0.19846530258655548,
-0.8255786895751953,
-0.33443111181259155,
0.18532948195934296,
-0.9315349459648132,
-0.15495796501636505,
-0.3101606070995331,
-0.2329191267490387,
0.19186510145664215,
0.5515398383140564,
-0.6625924706459045,
0.3001656234264374,
0.22891944646835327,
-0.35219311714172363,
0.3836180567741394,
-0.185064435005188,
0.26055917143821716,
-1.0456488132476807,
0.0523587241768837,
0.08736053109169006,
-0.04355946183204651,
-0.24624097347259521,
0.6688764095306396,
0.35477587580680847,
-0.24932582676410675,
-0.21251961588859558,
0.5300074219703674,
-0.8907713294029236,
-0.5662693381309509,
-0.27944523096084595,
0.5308946967124939,
-0.08715246617794037,
0.19304350018501282,
-0.33487966656684875,
0.865513026714325,
0.3467320203781128,
-0.3072390854358673,
0.5374111533164978,
0.051893118768930435,
-0.1337580382823944,
0.3082945644855499,
-0.5227690935134888,
-0.18357719480991364,
-0.12735387682914734,
0.5049874782562256,
-1.0222305059432983,
-0.012219123542308807,
0.05147659778594971,
-0.6615227460861206,
0.6027013063430786,
-0.602394700050354,
-0.2805967628955841,
-0.5043795704841614,
-0.3537270724773407,
-0.10554837435483932,
0.2885831296443939,
-0.40932485461235046,
0.7736663222312927,
0.48749327659606934,
-0.11187663674354553,
-0.7224213480949402,
-0.4824479818344116,
0.19611035287380219,
-0.07004602998495102,
-0.97052001953125,
0.1477304846048355,
0.20892667770385742,
-0.6629992723464966,
-0.1123034656047821,
-0.44338008761405945,
-0.1532313972711563,
0.20933769643306732,
0.25711220502853394,
0.1814533770084381,
-0.5196265578269958,
0.337088018655777,
-0.04383974149823189,
-0.6300811767578125,
0.02707933820784092,
-0.39041611552238464,
0.270190566778183,
-0.12483503669500351,
-0.5685610771179199,
-0.3481457531452179,
0.08169884234666824,
0.748729944229126,
-0.08262472599744797,
0.2630866765975952,
0.21920748054981232,
-0.06196818873286247,
-0.3299037218093872,
-0.6018985509872437,
-0.6563958525657654,
-0.4848925471305847,
0.403160035610199,
-0.5012537240982056,
-0.6785730719566345,
0.8238098621368408,
-0.2533973753452301,
0.30225715041160583,
0.2374958097934723,
-0.04908762872219086,
-0.12130451202392578,
0.547995388507843,
0.717393159866333,
-0.3037349283695221,
0.5082906484603882,
-0.6041345000267029,
0.13705849647521973,
-0.6953907012939453,
0.10770260542631149,
-0.5431501269340515,
-0.21692590415477753,
-0.41206392645835876,
-0.4439701735973358,
0.17001770436763763,
0.19369220733642578,
-0.5806379914283752,
0.6359785795211792,
-0.8454053997993469,
0.6789559125900269,
0.22626061737537384,
-0.059491660445928574,
0.4482690095901489,
-0.1067023053765297,
0.0031928266398608685,
0.024391785264015198,
-0.3086281418800354,
-0.4988407492637634,
0.7557290196418762,
0.4671328365802765,
0.7123869061470032,
0.11549105495214462,
1.0681818723678589,
0.47577103972435,
0.4822463393211365,
-0.6393757462501526,
0.4551953971385956,
0.24247276782989502,
-0.5427167415618896,
-0.7392265796661377,
-0.48206111788749695,
-0.8598088026046753,
0.5919487476348877,
0.30079472064971924,
-0.48032182455062866,
0.1177457943558693,
0.011820575222373009,
-0.13419444859027863,
0.17028801143169403,
-0.9196092486381531,
0.9222413897514343,
-0.1745515614748001,
0.027293236926198006,
-0.07557033747434616,
-0.7460035085678101,
0.046551283448934555,
0.10565970093011856,
0.580051064491272,
0.10185205936431885,
-0.2620600759983063,
0.4419252276420593,
-0.7007685303688049,
0.4234333336353302,
-0.6546006202697754,
-0.26792052388191223,
0.4220397472381592,
0.4276314377784729,
0.7929145097732544,
0.2460097074508667,
0.05778404325246811,
-0.2121327966451645,
-0.03193128481507301,
-0.49821415543556213,
-0.816326379776001,
0.6874781250953674,
-1.0678424835205078,
-0.5347765684127808,
-0.4580034911632538,
-0.42193782329559326,
-0.05604610964655876,
0.016830680891871452,
0.12061280012130737,
0.21880213916301727,
0.00021496856061276048,
-0.05182143673300743,
0.5356592535972595,
-0.27699199318885803,
0.23917768895626068,
0.9942182302474976,
-0.22882428765296936,
-0.25040674209594727,
0.787353515625,
0.21482831239700317,
-0.07634875923395157,
0.4719223082065582,
-0.008802056312561035,
-0.2175113409757614,
-0.36827608942985535,
-0.7490177154541016,
0.45486119389533997,
-0.6174749732017517,
-0.30316147208213806,
-0.4803697168827057,
-0.2657293379306793,
-0.25035127997398376,
-0.5590851902961731,
-0.3750927448272705,
0.011355442926287651,
-0.027413763105869293,
-0.056307945400476456,
0.5900657176971436,
0.9051855802536011,
0.13615882396697998,
0.12894071638584137,
-1.0130925178527832,
0.14564791321754456,
0.16098667681217194,
0.3447246551513672,
0.12930648028850555,
-0.5693838000297546,
-0.04776523634791374,
0.18683423101902008,
-0.1606464385986328,
-1.1086291074752808,
0.4002724587917328,
-0.4215177893638611,
0.751801609992981,
0.23207400739192963,
0.31606146693229675,
0.6122865080833435,
-0.0934719368815422,
0.4634506404399872,
-0.25980767607688904,
-1.0119277238845825,
0.8012169599533081,
-0.4314306378364563,
0.20961403846740723,
0.7480578422546387,
-0.02952285297214985,
-0.5136619806289673,
-0.693996250629425,
-0.5536004304885864,
-1.1530007123947144,
0.6350824236869812,
0.2811163067817688,
-0.23605620861053467,
0.3893767297267914,
0.3439963161945343,
-0.11349708586931229,
0.048869602382183075,
-0.6979185342788696,
0.004391887225210667,
-0.09934007376432419,
-0.11934031546115875,
0.004101891536265612,
0.04339948296546936,
-0.05305758863687515,
0.11725134402513504,
0.8610122799873352,
-0.08940082788467407,
0.26138627529144287,
0.10863631963729858,
-0.5450161099433899,
-0.2738545536994934,
0.6658975481987,
0.48041269183158875,
0.696895182132721,
-0.247894287109375,
0.034872740507125854,
0.10719196498394012,
-0.45735490322113037,
0.3074950575828552,
0.00830275472253561,
-0.024271149188280106,
-0.13854579627513885,
0.3973495662212372,
0.39164936542510986,
0.311147004365921,
-0.701777994632721,
0.681892991065979,
0.0553407222032547,
0.00015966553473845124,
-0.661473274230957,
0.00319004338234663,
0.25760766863822937,
0.6272535920143127,
0.6489431858062744,
-0.051729220896959305,
0.23306599259376526,
-0.5962674617767334,
0.4176371693611145,
0.16825628280639648,
-0.6423655152320862,
0.11021410673856735,
0.08080124855041504,
0.35573217272758484,
-0.3871457576751709,
0.7745069265365601,
-0.012533435598015785,
-0.4219748377799988,
1.2483716011047363,
0.42128536105155945,
1.0842466354370117,
-0.17719945311546326,
0.33982670307159424,
0.05408259853720665,
0.3890986740589142,
-0.07233978062868118,
0.05238702520728111,
-0.3690647780895233,
-0.518941342830658,
-0.8428536653518677,
-0.32951274514198303,
-0.47161778807640076,
-0.24793533980846405,
-0.6571159958839417,
0.13392210006713867,
-0.07949430495500565,
0.2618042528629303,
-0.10158690065145493,
0.3392045497894287,
0.01219003926962614,
-0.19486317038536072,
-0.15818218886852264,
1.192197322845459,
-0.9134646654129028,
0.7512104511260986,
0.9203402996063232,
-0.6658440232276917,
-0.8278340101242065,
0.11995557695627213,
0.21198153495788574,
-0.650808572769165,
0.4432362914085388,
0.09718583524227142,
0.019479207694530487,
0.055070389062166214,
-0.5766016840934753,
-0.7677052617073059,
1.345810055732727,
0.20581479370594025,
-0.7561009526252747,
0.12554103136062622,
-0.4207982122898102,
0.6932703852653503,
-0.36147353053092957,
0.6897433400154114,
0.3753620982170105,
0.7749136090278625,
0.264500230550766,
-0.7508673667907715,
0.026903478428721428,
-0.6138193607330322,
0.33301255106925964,
0.5949018597602844,
-0.295484721660614,
0.6122270822525024,
-0.3408256769180298,
-0.1711677610874176,
-0.08822046965360641,
0.29723459482192993,
0.7015309929847717,
0.4359777271747589,
0.6741528511047363,
0.11488828808069229,
0.48713892698287964,
0.023815438151359558,
1.1339179277420044,
-0.4154631793498993,
0.5480329394340515,
0.932718813419342,
-0.3275166153907776,
0.6988680958747864,
0.46249547600746155,
-0.28464028239250183,
0.4739779233932495,
0.6259815692901611,
-0.08274707943201065,
0.2273702472448349,
0.46529972553253174,
-0.13250750303268433,
-0.10961678624153137,
0.3167453408241272,
-0.5127318501472473,
0.02560691349208355,
0.20688463747501373,
-0.3281475305557251,
-0.2164812833070755,
0.3890313506126404,
-0.23086121678352356,
0.04935218393802643,
-0.2182069718837738,
1.056844711303711,
0.09632913768291473,
-0.35617345571517944,
0.3273484706878662,
-0.32039427757263184,
0.46523919701576233,
-0.5025666952133179,
0.026269953697919846,
-0.27343153953552246,
0.4438169002532959,
-0.16684554517269135,
-0.8983855247497559,
0.19090363383293152,
-0.17816205322742462,
-0.1755271703004837,
-0.18864454329013824,
0.7511929273605347,
0.0025534904561936855,
0.15228162705898285,
0.7614284157752991,
0.29933735728263855,
0.22423583269119263,
-0.47098788619041443,
-0.6814814209938049,
0.08724763244390488,
0.22337843477725983,
-0.47577235102653503,
0.44127312302589417,
0.7802345156669617,
0.03895385563373566,
0.9784581661224365,
0.33877700567245483,
0.006445370614528656,
-0.4657663404941559,
0.08765025436878204,
0.9558002352714539,
-0.7828522324562073,
-0.5709058046340942,
-0.726999044418335,
0.6134284734725952,
-0.34489279985427856,
0.10526978969573975,
0.7435070872306824,
0.45237624645233154,
0.6167289614677429,
-0.12349747121334076,
0.7389580011367798,
0.1279953569173813,
0.4736139476299286,
-0.1187332272529602,
0.8695156574249268,
-0.4930391311645508,
0.6901744604110718,
-0.42815157771110535,
-0.9590929746627808,
-0.23833055794239044,
0.9855119585990906,
-0.3145007789134979,
-0.07052269577980042,
0.6128401756286621,
0.8564872741699219,
0.08431143313646317,
0.34552648663520813,
0.14528705179691315,
0.6283679604530334,
0.19997528195381165,
0.37383726239204407,
0.8909841179847717,
-0.6067176461219788,
0.7276933193206787,
-0.12792518734931946,
-0.336247056722641,
-0.262135773897171,
-0.21546781063079834,
-0.49091723561286926,
-0.4463844299316406,
-0.18824808299541473,
-0.4805830717086792,
0.2339116632938385,
0.8676401972770691,
0.5449168682098389,
-0.9758761525154114,
-0.44328880310058594,
-0.46029993891716003,
0.37213781476020813,
-0.0848560705780983,
-0.295238733291626,
0.13401374220848083,
-0.3841601014137268,
-0.0784521996974945,
0.2502939701080322,
0.62189120054245,
-0.05039575695991516,
-0.5429844856262207,
-0.23895247280597687,
-0.02017330564558506,
-0.20246174931526184,
0.46013256907463074,
0.46762803196907043,
-0.6007323265075684,
-0.11446812003850937,
0.07324779778718948,
-0.4726242125034332,
-0.05348233878612518,
1.0455234050750732,
-0.7325639724731445,
0.3317486047744751,
0.5689393877983093,
0.30456000566482544,
0.6825531125068665,
-0.08533134311437607,
0.7687743306159973,
-0.42278850078582764,
0.134333997964859,
0.3646239638328552,
0.33677688241004944,
-0.053689926862716675,
-0.47211217880249023,
0.8297856450080872,
-0.10315969586372375,
-0.8607859015464783,
-0.8034704923629761,
0.1595027893781662,
-0.8211605548858643,
-0.7483267188072205,
0.9592339396476746,
-0.22088773548603058,
-0.4189676344394684,
-0.6054210662841797,
-0.5134046673774719,
0.3449041545391083,
-0.5428377389907837,
0.8309689164161682,
0.22512854635715485,
0.1366061568260193,
-0.5929693579673767,
-0.5026252269744873,
0.099458247423172,
-0.02326185069978237,
-0.8687154054641724,
0.12168098241090775,
0.6109863519668579,
0.3726809322834015,
0.3727231025695801,
0.7856608629226685,
-0.15248964726924896,
0.2705423831939697,
0.28986993432044983,
0.3759413957595825,
-0.049132633954286575,
-0.307614803314209,
-0.11073634773492813,
0.2930733859539032,
0.16454638540744781,
0.06757761538028717
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.01392v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.01392v2
|
Sparsity-Accelerated Training for Large Language Models
| 2024-06-03T14:56:09 | 2024-06-06T16:38:34 |
Da Ma, Lu Chen, Pengyu Wang, Hongshen Xu, Hanqi Li, Liangtai Sun, Su Zhu, Shuai Fan, Kai Yu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated proficiency across various
natural language processing (NLP) tasks but often require additional training,
such as continual pre-training and supervised fine-tuning. However, the costs
associated with this, primarily due to their large parameter count, remain
high. This paper proposes leveraging \emph{sparsity} in pre-trained LLMs to
expedite this training process. By observing sparsity in activated neurons
during forward iterations, we identify the potential for computational
speed-ups by excluding inactive neurons. We address associated challenges by
extending existing neuron importance evaluation metrics and introducing a
ladder omission rate scheduler. Our experiments on Llama-2 demonstrate that
Sparsity-Accelerated Training (SAT) achieves comparable or superior performance
to standard training while significantly accelerating the process.
Specifically, SAT achieves a $45\%$ throughput improvement in continual
pre-training and saves $38\%$ training time in supervised fine-tuning in
practice. It offers a simple, hardware-agnostic, and easily deployable
framework for additional LLM training. Our code is available at
https://github.com/OpenDFM/SAT.
|
[
-0.3581768870353699,
-0.7360743880271912,
0.4356245696544647,
0.5566763877868652,
-0.30655550956726074,
-0.057627078145742416,
-0.5390756130218506,
-0.29900920391082764,
0.3442530035972595,
0.34002646803855896,
-0.4429026246070862,
-0.07291371375322342,
-0.8883252739906311,
-0.003551164409145713,
-0.34281036257743835,
0.8933678269386292,
0.023345569148659706,
0.027034442871809006,
-0.05893980339169502,
-0.06456248462200165,
-0.3343639373779297,
-0.38094037771224976,
-0.7858746647834778,
-0.47233837842941284,
0.7328845262527466,
0.11659238487482071,
0.7937467098236084,
0.6607471108436584,
0.3455820679664612,
0.30238857865333557,
-0.3164660632610321,
0.2642052471637726,
-0.6458489298820496,
0.2078840583562851,
0.190388485789299,
-0.11460630595684052,
-0.6861110925674438,
-0.0935804471373558,
0.9390439987182617,
0.7821491956710815,
-0.32469189167022705,
0.14208808541297913,
0.11099708825349808,
0.6748781800270081,
-0.6955623626708984,
-0.0961303636431694,
-0.8224438428878784,
0.045853231102228165,
-0.07457424700260162,
-0.5482082962989807,
-0.33897313475608826,
-0.24194583296775818,
-0.08162462711334229,
-0.7100922465324402,
0.1836174726486206,
-0.12388662248849869,
0.8800464868545532,
0.5231891870498657,
0.09269143640995026,
0.08411204814910889,
-0.4127134680747986,
0.44210177659988403,
-0.60575270652771,
0.5175490975379944,
0.30672842264175415,
-0.06150471791625023,
-0.5002264976501465,
-0.648321807384491,
-0.33935675024986267,
-0.4274863302707672,
0.05188274383544922,
-0.13522771000862122,
-0.10163414478302002,
0.1602945178747177,
0.5057452321052551,
0.23866349458694458,
-0.6392024755477905,
0.42403534054756165,
-0.13745717704296112,
0.10667282342910767,
0.37126997113227844,
0.12025117874145508,
0.17400139570236206,
0.47777003049850464,
-0.19606463611125946,
0.0830310508608818,
-0.8838664889335632,
-0.07236503809690475,
0.2729952037334442,
0.3374076783657074,
-0.08066593110561371,
0.58553147315979,
-0.053755711764097214,
0.8306390643119812,
-0.022761858999729156,
0.2750833332538605,
0.4253552556037903,
-0.008507119491696358,
-0.1366746723651886,
-0.028337078168988228,
0.3621388077735901,
-0.30151405930519104,
0.34799569845199585,
-0.4770565629005432,
-0.43783512711524963,
-0.03017347678542137,
0.30075544118881226,
-0.9362273216247559,
-0.01202221680432558,
0.03796318173408508,
-0.12796498835086823,
0.0580509752035141,
-0.3846450448036194,
-0.4926808774471283,
-0.37903133034706116,
-0.45683568716049194,
0.4442920684814453,
-0.2730978727340698,
-0.31187736988067627,
0.33599722385406494,
-0.05740931257605553,
0.0407516285777092,
0.4517379701137543,
-0.9603632688522339,
0.45019009709358215,
0.8880649209022522,
0.9518353343009949,
-0.2621041536331177,
-0.6958407759666443,
-1.2196780443191528,
0.011458267457783222,
-0.5030394196510315,
0.8419601321220398,
-0.6146765351295471,
0.03814154490828514,
-0.1753358095884323,
-0.02991901896893978,
-0.23642070591449738,
-0.3855036795139313,
0.28710177540779114,
-0.6880567669868469,
-0.4886270761489868,
-0.04683055728673935,
-0.3118835389614105,
0.225478395819664,
0.2687942683696747,
-0.5532785654067993,
1.3925807476043701,
-0.0206490196287632,
-0.4721132814884186,
0.3506353795528412,
-0.5486501455307007,
-0.7962775826454163,
0.10497325658798218,
-0.027652842923998833,
-0.3397321105003357,
0.42851629853248596,
0.2797568142414093,
0.6756324768066406,
-0.17068104445934296,
0.5445635318756104,
-0.23984645307064056,
-0.8162522912025452,
0.28214702010154724,
-0.2916656732559204,
0.3292299807071686,
-0.06051010265946388,
-0.3799719214439392,
0.050744783133268356,
-0.8872799873352051,
0.03682278096675873,
-0.04572736471891403,
-0.6672521829605103,
-0.2513126730918884,
0.005252665374428034,
-0.07128208130598068,
0.09892512112855911,
0.085136279463768,
-0.1594807505607605,
0.09262984991073608,
-0.8826201558113098,
0.3087085783481598,
0.8970029354095459,
-0.3278087079524994,
0.38353684544563293,
0.0739525780081749,
0.46642613410949707,
-0.283311128616333,
-0.04946769028902054,
0.03525654971599579,
-0.3156062066555023,
-1.0226387977600098,
-0.42379647493362427,
0.24363477528095245,
0.12827453017234802,
-0.507881224155426,
0.6265097260475159,
-0.4591553807258606,
-0.40100526809692383,
-0.4028647541999817,
0.1972220242023468,
0.46653124690055847,
0.10053521394729614,
0.5317429304122925,
-0.38011687994003296,
-0.43095260858535767,
-0.6157315373420715,
-0.36125707626342773,
0.2584867775440216,
0.06032438576221466,
0.032551757991313934,
0.5031479597091675,
-0.1364416778087616,
0.5568810105323792,
-0.38855406641960144,
-0.21166983246803284,
-0.28746867179870605,
0.3274992108345032,
0.28447064757347107,
0.535153329372406,
0.24554091691970825,
-0.45430058240890503,
-0.1940045803785324,
-0.04867991432547569,
-0.3628920316696167,
-0.09328612685203552,
-0.11960411071777344,
-0.04991971328854561,
0.21788077056407928,
0.47837701439857483,
-0.9189507961273193,
0.36670759320259094,
0.47080495953559875,
0.039013881236314774,
0.3333251178264618,
-0.4827168583869934,
-0.027459317818284035,
-0.6877270936965942,
0.19112713634967804,
0.053306665271520615,
-0.0679020807147026,
-0.6475397944450378,
-0.16022194921970367,
-0.11531245708465576,
-0.2444448322057724,
-0.19996900856494904,
0.6254904866218567,
-0.8030567169189453,
-0.6572845578193665,
-0.3616074025630951,
0.3057699203491211,
-0.23416590690612793,
0.6359316110610962,
0.23259226977825165,
0.9150412082672119,
0.5197079181671143,
-0.729890763759613,
-0.2232506424188614,
0.024026833474636078,
-0.3481284976005554,
-0.1060752123594284,
-0.7938035726547241,
0.12426542490720749,
-0.06363916397094727,
0.045760512351989746,
-0.7842405438423157,
-0.07515093684196472,
-0.029353249818086624,
-0.46549326181411743,
0.5027331709861755,
-0.07112853974103928,
-0.6517639756202698,
-0.16031573712825775,
-0.1697341650724411,
0.29201462864875793,
0.42117562890052795,
-0.7246832847595215,
0.6381892561912537,
0.40782153606414795,
-0.11592791229486465,
-0.9589730501174927,
-0.6364439725875854,
0.1198648139834404,
0.26783931255340576,
-0.37593114376068115,
0.2954168915748596,
0.16339580714702606,
0.1483331322669983,
-0.12210060656070709,
-0.05776172876358032,
0.0823322981595993,
0.3962711691856384,
0.4017581343650818,
-0.07121572643518448,
-0.2090594619512558,
0.32516229152679443,
0.11222264170646667,
-0.3725144565105438,
-0.14355804026126862,
-0.10106503963470459,
0.8081845045089722,
-0.23827706277370453,
-0.36304014921188354,
-0.41089770197868347,
0.028237154707312584,
0.37300238013267517,
-0.3073899745941162,
0.7529585361480713,
0.5687242746353149,
-0.43689876794815063,
-0.2913579046726227,
-0.7590668797492981,
-0.21128025650978088,
-0.48803022503852844,
0.7592637538909912,
-0.08310975134372711,
-0.9731037616729736,
0.09780411422252655,
-0.10488760471343994,
0.03773589804768562,
0.13743369281291962,
0.5755360126495361,
0.20118552446365356,
0.9459412097930908,
0.683556854724884,
-0.2340800166130066,
0.48878318071365356,
-0.08177877217531204,
0.30404987931251526,
-0.650584876537323,
-0.03739142417907715,
-0.6185964345932007,
-0.32561710476875305,
-0.14383536577224731,
-0.5685710310935974,
0.20432782173156738,
-0.021673355251550674,
-0.3247677981853485,
0.24598048627376556,
-0.3494645655155182,
0.6810758113861084,
0.1715586930513382,
0.009725281968712807,
0.18541735410690308,
0.31140440702438354,
0.16725456714630127,
-0.01304437406361103,
-0.8970983624458313,
-0.20248115062713623,
0.7966799139976501,
0.34863099455833435,
0.7350064516067505,
-0.35631731152534485,
0.2743288278579712,
0.22579672932624817,
0.4307906925678253,
-0.6428954005241394,
0.812457799911499,
-0.1980411410331726,
-0.21661145985126495,
-0.23767206072807312,
-0.5017447471618652,
-0.9821969866752625,
0.30176135897636414,
-0.38623055815696716,
-0.5588132739067078,
0.0208300594240427,
0.4420596659183502,
-0.3354431986808777,
0.2448514997959137,
-0.49984505772590637,
0.6566699147224426,
-0.4259016215801239,
-0.4376813471317291,
-0.7057218551635742,
-0.5391930341720581,
0.12281692773103714,
0.07020552456378937,
-0.08141543716192245,
-0.22038207948207855,
-0.17065487802028656,
0.6843529343605042,
-0.15671691298484802,
0.8482688069343567,
-0.2800239026546478,
0.24087795615196228,
-0.11605829000473022,
-0.05732408165931702,
0.6456295251846313,
0.07502651959657669,
-0.041564300656318665,
0.2595122158527374,
-0.6305052638053894,
-0.2969244420528412,
-0.4223874509334564,
0.940146803855896,
-0.7227423191070557,
-0.4772028923034668,
-0.5615304708480835,
-0.6747235059738159,
-0.36833879351615906,
0.03890248015522957,
-0.14002813398838043,
0.40151700377464294,
-0.02709968015551567,
0.15143314003944397,
0.6808541417121887,
-0.2844814360141754,
0.3410702645778656,
0.3735775649547577,
0.013229740783572197,
-0.44688358902931213,
0.9829203486442566,
0.1849866807460785,
0.19529123604297638,
0.25099533796310425,
-0.0936024934053421,
-0.09919487684965134,
-0.9061231017112732,
-0.27793726325035095,
0.352868914604187,
-0.47393038868904114,
-0.2738132178783417,
-0.8822230100631714,
-0.3473547697067261,
-0.3379155695438385,
-0.3047490119934082,
-0.5550268292427063,
-0.547274649143219,
-0.4847743809223175,
-0.1361541897058487,
0.5147032737731934,
0.3789401948451996,
-0.09208204597234726,
0.7552278637886047,
-0.7255361676216125,
0.4092586934566498,
0.07936597615480423,
0.5614513754844666,
0.2157284915447235,
-0.7404377460479736,
-0.4200698137283325,
-0.15286299586296082,
-0.15530340373516083,
-0.25851255655288696,
0.49955394864082336,
0.44769424200057983,
0.6564397811889648,
0.19532306492328644,
-0.5025447010993958,
1.046426773071289,
-0.5411354303359985,
0.5780807733535767,
0.3396562933921814,
-0.8009974956512451,
0.34587201476097107,
-0.0013494337908923626,
0.11188223958015442,
0.5615550875663757,
0.500914454460144,
-0.22082699835300446,
-0.11641865968704224,
-0.2944626808166504,
-1.0151065587997437,
0.7378666996955872,
0.1413428783416748,
0.1650494486093521,
-0.10262441635131836,
0.5876858830451965,
0.12743467092514038,
0.2036406546831131,
-0.7134832739830017,
0.03425883874297142,
0.13231346011161804,
0.10912659019231796,
-0.3493911921977997,
-0.3794872760772705,
-0.01756536029279232,
-0.37043699622154236,
0.9379976391792297,
-0.13718007504940033,
0.10877346992492676,
0.015266232192516327,
-0.3822895288467407,
-0.08396174013614655,
0.22900328040122986,
0.45467594265937805,
0.5536486506462097,
-0.13182029128074646,
0.05183594301342964,
0.36361998319625854,
-0.5372695922851562,
0.1270005702972412,
0.3172607123851776,
0.022445008158683777,
-0.09239976853132248,
0.12343849986791611,
0.9031276106834412,
0.5376225113868713,
-0.729817271232605,
0.5615554451942444,
-0.031370267271995544,
-0.09339538961648941,
-0.19214557111263275,
0.06078226864337921,
0.1362740844488144,
0.2673824429512024,
0.26230430603027344,
0.23904849588871002,
-0.11210139840841293,
-0.17366273701190948,
0.012579116970300674,
0.5056732892990112,
-0.2610175907611847,
-0.40112051367759705,
0.4222012162208557,
0.1579287052154541,
-0.32111334800720215,
0.6304747462272644,
-0.001997182844206691,
-0.34197381138801575,
0.5250498652458191,
0.5869739651679993,
0.9198512434959412,
-0.11723384261131287,
-0.029141830280423164,
0.38109463453292847,
0.45571625232696533,
-0.5630276203155518,
0.15879057347774506,
-0.10289641469717026,
-0.5822874307632446,
-0.712703287601471,
-0.8493524789810181,
-0.15135276317596436,
0.19519053399562836,
-0.385596364736557,
0.37905624508857727,
-0.5417211651802063,
-0.2630789875984192,
-0.1962224245071411,
-0.32367992401123047,
-0.3926555812358856,
0.21117132902145386,
0.0827590674161911,
0.9922702312469482,
-0.8073504567146301,
0.8215079307556152,
0.3510739803314209,
-0.06155037879943848,
-0.5269851088523865,
-0.20084741711616516,
-0.5734646916389465,
-0.7982251048088074,
0.7385451197624207,
0.5112029910087585,
-0.5173613429069519,
0.10573067516088486,
-0.5526138544082642,
-0.9079397320747375,
0.8048126697540283,
0.6701202988624573,
-0.653045117855072,
0.027671566233038902,
-0.02592840977013111,
0.7220174670219421,
-0.2571429908275604,
0.13180996477603912,
0.6819115281105042,
0.2490469515323639,
-0.1692546159029007,
-0.5092021226882935,
0.03280249983072281,
-0.3654078245162964,
0.1130126342177391,
0.367902547121048,
-0.289491206407547,
0.6489188075065613,
-0.3311118483543396,
-0.1579275280237198,
0.2153632640838623,
0.7326237559318542,
0.45379534363746643,
0.20640559494495392,
0.5438193678855896,
0.7588741779327393,
0.6191666722297668,
-0.10644077509641647,
0.8030853271484375,
-0.29038292169570923,
0.05834444612264633,
1.1926931142807007,
-0.3750614523887634,
1.0466035604476929,
0.8255822658538818,
-0.0639856606721878,
-0.017674146220088005,
0.5719867944717407,
0.0014348149998113513,
0.41600003838539124,
0.4342716932296753,
-0.0857861191034317,
-0.48179322481155396,
-0.13451838493347168,
-0.6079605221748352,
0.045809511095285416,
0.4494727849960327,
-0.19108067452907562,
-0.17210529744625092,
-0.06510823220014572,
-0.08448117971420288,
0.0886918306350708,
-0.4484335780143738,
0.4758830666542053,
0.15626998245716095,
-0.7859001159667969,
0.8317387700080872,
-0.17700083553791046,
0.7864289879798889,
-0.9645454287528992,
-0.09975160658359528,
-0.15901733934879303,
0.2696520984172821,
-0.14722664654254913,
-0.5350698232650757,
0.14687713980674744,
0.17180967330932617,
0.042757224291563034,
-0.29448482394218445,
0.7093574404716492,
-0.22350825369358063,
-0.31798964738845825,
0.6049529314041138,
0.3097899854183197,
0.22263653576374054,
-0.14719568192958832,
-0.5661823153495789,
0.09537982195615768,
-0.4685315191745758,
-0.6462237238883972,
0.7410802245140076,
0.1325668841600418,
0.14185811579227448,
0.8022278547286987,
0.7668314576148987,
0.37513068318367004,
0.26462653279304504,
0.3166864216327667,
1.305436611175537,
-0.35368600487709045,
-0.24159328639507294,
-0.7166587114334106,
0.26153942942619324,
-0.04202058166265488,
-0.45683613419532776,
0.45785510540008545,
0.6178168058395386,
0.6010869741439819,
-0.06646586954593658,
0.3677685260772705,
0.08750706911087036,
0.3378888964653015,
-0.6808476448059082,
0.7245218753814697,
-0.7413094639778137,
0.3317733108997345,
-0.07186451554298401,
-0.8219932913780212,
-0.5538265705108643,
0.5449204444885254,
-0.33361008763313293,
0.07448038458824158,
0.46081671118736267,
1.0908533334732056,
-0.11007314920425415,
-0.03625647351145744,
0.21822676062583923,
0.24151958525180817,
0.0498204305768013,
0.4498871862888336,
1.0029116868972778,
-0.2550046443939209,
0.46678510308265686,
-0.1368364840745926,
-0.10223110020160675,
-0.0248408280313015,
-0.9321156144142151,
-0.9341519474983215,
-0.30264100432395935,
-0.30451154708862305,
-0.3226032853126526,
0.4750567674636841,
1.0735938549041748,
0.6619822382926941,
-0.5033453702926636,
-0.24329590797424316,
-0.3002456724643707,
-0.1773790717124939,
-0.34494030475616455,
-0.1044648289680481,
0.37129703164100647,
-0.7334652543067932,
-0.3386602997779846,
0.7110430598258972,
0.5084219574928284,
-0.01067331898957491,
-0.023063886910676956,
-0.16970843076705933,
-0.44242724776268005,
-0.1241568922996521,
0.531643807888031,
0.37827637791633606,
-0.4359269440174103,
0.009060846641659737,
-0.005978439003229141,
0.06087162345647812,
0.2082868367433548,
0.9703373908996582,
-0.6675018668174744,
0.017723465338349342,
0.4753933846950531,
1.128072738647461,
0.7138081192970276,
-0.06500805169343948,
0.4501906931400299,
-0.828675389289856,
0.5195013284683228,
0.3372688293457031,
0.36293232440948486,
0.33883240818977356,
-0.42465344071388245,
0.5035024285316467,
0.12459696829319,
-0.6860731244087219,
-1.1424983739852905,
-0.11456266045570374,
-1.047861933708191,
-0.11436265707015991,
1.1855440139770508,
-0.18376073241233826,
-0.24717923998832703,
-0.042641617357730865,
0.06777050346136093,
0.16251413524150848,
-0.3752911686897278,
0.6644200086593628,
0.34199437499046326,
0.056618690490722656,
0.024744432419538498,
-0.5549514293670654,
0.4154890179634094,
0.7598180770874023,
-0.8944670557975769,
0.2996082305908203,
0.4363156259059906,
0.11821824312210083,
-0.15225601196289062,
0.772322416305542,
-0.036906205117702484,
0.3497181832790375,
-0.09057196229696274,
0.26100850105285645,
-0.21660038828849792,
-0.6988330483436584,
-0.6270118355751038,
0.13033166527748108,
0.19147054851055145,
0.09915981441736221
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.01382v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.01382v1
|
Do Large Language Models Perform the Way People Expect? Measuring the Human Generalization Function
| 2024-06-03T14:45:21 | 2024-06-03T14:45:21 |
Keyon Vafa, Ashesh Rambachan, Sendhil Mullainathan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
What makes large language models (LLMs) impressive is also what makes them
hard to evaluate: their diversity of uses. To evaluate these models, we must
understand the purposes they will be used for. We consider a setting where
these deployment decisions are made by people, and in particular, people's
beliefs about where an LLM will perform well. We model such beliefs as the
consequence of a human generalization function: having seen what an LLM gets
right or wrong, people generalize to where else it might succeed. We collect a
dataset of 19K examples of how humans make generalizations across 79 tasks from
the MMLU and BIG-Bench benchmarks. We show that the human generalization
function can be predicted using NLP methods: people have consistent structured
ways to generalize. We then evaluate LLM alignment with the human
generalization function. Our results show that -- especially for cases where
the cost of mistakes is high -- more capable models (e.g. GPT-4) can do worse
on the instances people choose to use them for, exactly because they are not
aligned with the human generalization function.
|
[
-0.36574429273605347,
-0.2843655049800873,
0.7974706888198853,
0.3487653136253357,
-0.06513924151659012,
-0.05924332141876221,
-0.314387708902359,
-0.6439455151557922,
-0.09963597357273102,
0.3595777750015259,
-0.31499218940734863,
-0.4453916847705841,
-0.6227437257766724,
0.0975542664527893,
-0.46371036767959595,
0.8259750604629517,
0.14921459555625916,
-0.05028722062706947,
-0.2847652733325958,
-0.007850335910916328,
-0.5122348070144653,
-0.677029550075531,
-0.3543574810028076,
-0.7424668669700623,
0.5495601892471313,
0.17710399627685547,
1.0705808401107788,
0.6546454429626465,
0.3983478546142578,
0.2343440055847168,
-0.059057608246803284,
-0.025578614324331284,
-0.478686660528183,
-0.18092574179172516,
-0.26118600368499756,
-0.48995184898376465,
-0.427839457988739,
0.20323708653450012,
0.6873511075973511,
0.9902583360671997,
-0.5197415947914124,
0.01872246526181698,
0.20949538052082062,
0.4516785740852356,
-0.2449856400489807,
-0.03809906914830208,
-0.6008899211883545,
-0.04729108512401581,
0.0015342773403972387,
0.25707048177719116,
-0.26549193263053894,
-0.3005748987197876,
0.3136623203754425,
-0.304332971572876,
0.16521838307380676,
0.20952801406383514,
0.6952003836631775,
0.1011233776807785,
-0.6271392703056335,
-0.2479255646467209,
-0.8678851127624512,
1.0629857778549194,
-0.7520381808280945,
0.2142699807882309,
0.48231375217437744,
0.3813413083553314,
-0.521862268447876,
-0.276638388633728,
-0.44740450382232666,
-0.3629731833934784,
-0.017826780676841736,
-0.05419248715043068,
-0.0019577029161155224,
0.1524370014667511,
0.3599205017089844,
0.3070071339607239,
-0.6862847208976746,
0.4474203288555145,
-0.3891502320766449,
-0.03716593235731125,
0.728522777557373,
0.20000451803207397,
0.3037036061286926,
0.00623887125402689,
-0.19423966109752655,
-0.09820117056369781,
-0.7473487854003906,
-0.09883313626050949,
0.5863513946533203,
0.0903577134013176,
-0.039190225303173065,
0.5389688014984131,
-0.21777425706386566,
0.7530815005302429,
-0.283211886882782,
-0.028216011822223663,
0.2466995120048523,
-0.2389756739139557,
-0.3615623116493225,
-0.2797599136829376,
0.6511350274085999,
0.5198816657066345,
0.7918170094490051,
-0.26514437794685364,
-0.4649585783481598,
0.14912594854831696,
0.40616780519485474,
-0.46068355441093445,
0.12476714700460434,
0.14564207196235657,
-0.3035155236721039,
-0.24589556455612183,
0.10937707126140594,
-0.558615505695343,
-0.5032313466072083,
-0.2968718409538269,
0.10117635875940323,
-0.16392822563648224,
-0.17509765923023224,
0.3413780927658081,
0.0069787208922207355,
0.39352619647979736,
0.43111661076545715,
-1.1706098318099976,
0.5734124779701233,
0.921589732170105,
0.522626519203186,
-0.31042614579200745,
-0.676452100276947,
-0.46145203709602356,
0.005701269954442978,
-0.45335671305656433,
0.7093743681907654,
-0.305847704410553,
-0.3960610628128052,
0.07512306421995163,
-0.34982627630233765,
-0.09671183675527573,
-0.9003971219062805,
0.7529087066650391,
-0.30957865715026855,
-0.06609421223402023,
-0.49614131450653076,
-0.5398548245429993,
-0.1176801398396492,
0.19899272918701172,
-0.381665974855423,
0.581422746181488,
0.03842166066169739,
-0.36330869793891907,
0.5412325859069824,
-0.3625829219818115,
-0.3854179382324219,
0.06020151078701019,
-0.36598512530326843,
-0.304358571767807,
0.4287587106227875,
0.09142021089792252,
0.5170555114746094,
-0.4495462477207184,
0.4371601641178131,
-0.49012959003448486,
-0.41306954622268677,
0.5473565459251404,
-0.3276301920413971,
0.6009010076522827,
0.20442894101142883,
-0.2859216630458832,
-0.008380736224353313,
-0.31358522176742554,
0.08627196401357651,
0.03272829204797745,
-0.6971786022186279,
-0.23378397524356842,
0.41950321197509766,
-0.035238634794950485,
0.3259768784046173,
0.015260930173099041,
-0.3776439130306244,
0.347105473279953,
-0.4622054398059845,
0.2983561158180237,
0.8078320026397705,
-0.2624903917312622,
0.4164808392524719,
-0.43237459659576416,
0.5397207736968994,
-0.15292246639728546,
0.2064809501171112,
0.25792863965034485,
-0.7754914164543152,
-0.43256038427352905,
0.03249159827828407,
0.28743264079093933,
0.2943727374076843,
-0.06791379302740097,
0.40916889905929565,
-0.38084688782691956,
-0.42787298560142517,
-0.3053661584854126,
0.46078529953956604,
0.3354356586933136,
0.37914687395095825,
0.058453578501939774,
-0.1853281706571579,
-0.4313049912452698,
-1.1555547714233398,
-0.4059632122516632,
-0.3866826891899109,
-0.33672231435775757,
0.18771302700042725,
0.5036851763725281,
-0.5087904334068298,
0.9011211395263672,
-0.335004061460495,
0.00572931207716465,
-0.2774713933467865,
0.29880914092063904,
0.32870739698410034,
0.17980894446372986,
0.4059050381183624,
-0.9114150404930115,
-0.2239416241645813,
0.16838759183883667,
-0.7359787225723267,
-0.23145750164985657,
0.04401722177863121,
0.2163867950439453,
0.16942937672138214,
0.220168799161911,
-0.5492187142372131,
0.11954136192798615,
0.8480755090713501,
-0.28319263458251953,
0.6451154351234436,
-0.3656691908836365,
0.015981238335371017,
-0.8427979350090027,
-0.009518027305603027,
0.3317544758319855,
-0.3484360873699188,
-0.5894737243652344,
0.03410151228308678,
-0.039377860724925995,
0.07372807711362839,
-0.1521090567111969,
0.35578325390815735,
-0.3292742073535919,
-0.5060074329376221,
-0.1838749796152115,
-0.02983601950109005,
-0.2211158722639084,
0.17873051762580872,
-0.09629134088754654,
0.5704294443130493,
0.3100985288619995,
-0.4876396358013153,
0.2605603039264679,
-0.05967293307185173,
-0.6767261624336243,
0.3257640600204468,
-0.8995413184165955,
0.08177311718463898,
-0.070203997194767,
0.08997800946235657,
-1.055485725402832,
-0.47111448645591736,
-0.20233288407325745,
-0.19524510204792023,
0.03187796100974083,
-0.07004167139530182,
-0.6444113254547119,
-0.527881383895874,
0.027897503226995468,
0.16902926564216614,
0.7050170302391052,
-0.330729603767395,
0.49777281284332275,
0.4034844636917114,
-0.06747990101575851,
-0.5786289572715759,
-0.8609840869903564,
0.16605426371097565,
-0.42014777660369873,
-0.6310254335403442,
0.12852533161640167,
-0.06495533883571625,
-0.5414703488349915,
-0.24496781826019287,
-0.06125209853053093,
-0.04803382605314255,
0.31001320481300354,
0.4070045053958893,
0.3360764682292938,
-0.139993354678154,
0.2534644305706024,
-0.43354520201683044,
0.12365204840898514,
0.08174115419387817,
-0.27251002192497253,
0.5560887455940247,
-0.3516097664833069,
-0.6848704814910889,
-0.10166969150304794,
0.20390287041664124,
0.5252518057823181,
0.054007016122341156,
0.5350099802017212,
0.30947041511535645,
-0.36126235127449036,
-0.09887281060218811,
-0.8511117100715637,
0.12764953076839447,
-0.4410170614719391,
0.6059311032295227,
-0.20933879911899567,
-0.8304383158683777,
0.5485822558403015,
0.046504195779561996,
0.2991234064102173,
0.45842549204826355,
0.5722090601921082,
-0.4004935920238495,
1.180167317390442,
0.6705635190010071,
-0.09778343886137009,
0.12573431432247162,
0.06154877692461014,
-0.02748691849410534,
-0.5965303778648376,
0.09918173402547836,
-0.47276005148887634,
-0.48776721954345703,
-0.6944257020950317,
-0.25469040870666504,
0.2100135236978531,
0.3405922055244446,
-0.09803471714258194,
0.14136400818824768,
-0.2765290439128876,
0.5926051735877991,
0.40224531292915344,
-0.3117503523826599,
0.34517285227775574,
0.07735404372215271,
0.04111742973327637,
-0.00644032983109355,
-0.36924269795417786,
-0.7811247706413269,
1.1490139961242676,
0.4963712990283966,
0.9198782444000244,
0.18857236206531525,
0.7197631597518921,
0.29180896282196045,
0.6100467443466187,
-0.7879992723464966,
0.3970194160938263,
-0.26513829827308655,
-0.5636074542999268,
-0.39217889308929443,
-0.5107408165931702,
-1.0126309394836426,
0.32799234986305237,
-0.10277478396892548,
-0.8342689275741577,
0.095489501953125,
0.30497220158576965,
-0.2630736529827118,
0.0955233946442604,
-0.9423650503158569,
0.7698362469673157,
-0.3990458846092224,
0.20744366943836212,
-0.2667061388492584,
-0.5065720081329346,
0.44197720289230347,
-0.3010619580745697,
0.34306615591049194,
-0.25954973697662354,
-0.10602346807718277,
0.7889192700386047,
-0.00868029985576868,
0.8251634240150452,
-0.16876189410686493,
-0.06365934759378433,
0.15571749210357666,
-0.054736990481615067,
0.4555111229419708,
-0.35733848810195923,
-0.33281415700912476,
0.2633942663669586,
-0.2452908158302307,
-0.3554057478904724,
-0.6761330962181091,
0.6118346452713013,
-0.9104012250900269,
-0.8014712333679199,
-0.1963074803352356,
-0.38623371720314026,
-0.2663595974445343,
0.0007813054835423827,
0.3017641007900238,
0.18809714913368225,
-0.4005841314792633,
0.10117606818675995,
0.5229493379592896,
-0.17031821608543396,
0.25290825963020325,
0.2602090537548065,
-0.538330078125,
-0.17701579630374908,
0.7724789977073669,
0.32136544585227966,
0.5950801968574524,
0.21483469009399414,
0.4654647707939148,
-0.29044386744499207,
-0.7580468058586121,
-0.3117082715034485,
0.3153926432132721,
-0.7256141304969788,
0.20592258870601654,
-0.5379405617713928,
0.14156904816627502,
-0.40980786085128784,
-0.17298412322998047,
-0.17390219867229462,
-0.16621823608875275,
-0.058266110718250275,
-0.08657778054475784,
-0.2887047529220581,
1.1590659618377686,
0.15615881979465485,
0.31791043281555176,
-0.6042860150337219,
0.1526941955089569,
0.6537163853645325,
0.28096795082092285,
-0.10479505360126495,
-0.5764098763465881,
-0.2882266938686371,
0.06356817483901978,
-0.4296718239784241,
-0.4582452178001404,
0.2798979580402374,
0.1947941780090332,
0.7244673371315002,
0.27547430992126465,
-0.29435569047927856,
0.4224318563938141,
-0.5321292281150818,
0.49298325181007385,
0.1857144981622696,
-0.7033618688583374,
0.12727949023246765,
-0.41360601782798767,
0.3262137770652771,
0.28394925594329834,
0.30052873492240906,
-1.0012446641921997,
-0.3090817928314209,
-0.4760579466819763,
-0.4663836658000946,
0.4852997064590454,
-0.027364367619156837,
0.2844184339046478,
-0.047744445502758026,
0.4375336766242981,
0.02857111394405365,
0.12167971581220627,
-0.7858574390411377,
-0.07448294758796692,
0.08415362983942032,
-0.1919521987438202,
-0.4174134135246277,
-0.36732327938079834,
-0.0452338382601738,
0.13650482892990112,
0.2730521559715271,
-0.2307358980178833,
0.20899203419685364,
-0.13282553851604462,
-0.033058471977710724,
-0.3002845048904419,
0.5950508713722229,
0.8898438215255737,
0.9935279488563538,
-0.1814315915107727,
0.08065462112426758,
0.18464717268943787,
-0.09641347080469131,
0.26450467109680176,
-0.018509522080421448,
0.10386724025011063,
-0.23073981702327728,
0.4304431974887848,
0.5414911508560181,
0.28662189841270447,
-0.7605221271514893,
0.6367916464805603,
-0.05273092910647392,
-0.23397187888622284,
-0.27060046792030334,
0.17838270962238312,
0.5473102331161499,
0.18226048350334167,
0.5493534207344055,
0.017141971737146378,
0.07342932373285294,
-0.674705445766449,
-0.031331583857536316,
0.47309210896492004,
-0.04632632061839104,
-0.5038868188858032,
0.5342675447463989,
0.10582827776670456,
-0.4751575291156769,
0.696948766708374,
-0.16877181828022003,
-0.536913275718689,
0.7064648270606995,
0.49434852600097656,
0.8543802499771118,
-0.2398928850889206,
0.16983520984649658,
0.08889146894216537,
0.5372990369796753,
-0.5713008046150208,
0.03128882497549057,
0.29937493801116943,
-1.0109189748764038,
-0.7566750049591064,
-0.8545718789100647,
-0.5639508962631226,
0.06773784756660461,
-0.45861127972602844,
0.2629058361053467,
-0.4015139043331146,
-0.2080049365758896,
0.12698128819465637,
-0.22066980600357056,
-0.8168835043907166,
0.26040762662887573,
0.37472838163375854,
0.74016273021698,
-0.9970003366470337,
0.7741597890853882,
0.6700152158737183,
-0.09366548806428909,
-0.7680566310882568,
0.09935460239648819,
0.023792123422026634,
-1.026413083076477,
0.9103342890739441,
0.3035551607608795,
0.1424720585346222,
-0.3505081236362457,
-0.4316336214542389,
-0.7304002046585083,
0.7640645503997803,
0.603445827960968,
-0.8470925092697144,
-0.32707592844963074,
0.3502562940120697,
0.7698934078216553,
-0.5110327005386353,
0.015354911796748638,
0.4790475368499756,
0.423469603061676,
-0.1653939187526703,
-1.072110652923584,
-0.12203916162252426,
0.17248447239398956,
0.25631436705589294,
0.14751426875591278,
-0.4282253384590149,
0.8312758207321167,
-0.4069884717464447,
-0.19072602689266205,
-0.1344822347164154,
0.3669607937335968,
0.14161734282970428,
0.10640760511159897,
0.6352875828742981,
0.5603461861610413,
0.8584092855453491,
-0.07126123458147049,
1.5637155771255493,
0.3548029959201813,
0.3611023426055908,
1.1698124408721924,
-0.42514511942863464,
0.8457764387130737,
0.3821735680103302,
-0.5156036019325256,
0.27486851811408997,
0.4818287789821625,
-0.051198139786720276,
0.231075718998909,
0.445393443107605,
-0.06615693867206573,
-0.4427366256713867,
0.12951622903347015,
-0.005194215569645166,
0.482441782951355,
0.31604883074760437,
-0.43561387062072754,
-0.17091019451618195,
-0.149174302816391,
-0.43154701590538025,
-0.05700557678937912,
-0.2192181944847107,
0.8003327250480652,
0.26682692766189575,
-0.943866491317749,
0.7273668646812439,
0.034721389412879944,
0.6964576840400696,
-0.41538184881210327,
0.17168913781642914,
0.051748212426900864,
0.08075593411922455,
-0.33454740047454834,
-0.9946092367172241,
0.44225582480430603,
-0.21091018617153168,
-0.33263784646987915,
-0.09165045619010925,
0.500480592250824,
-0.3262431025505066,
-0.3429109752178192,
0.397186279296875,
0.501733660697937,
0.36944088339805603,
-0.1636224091053009,
-0.5038203001022339,
-0.00783286802470684,
0.10065565258264542,
-0.3061983287334442,
0.603751540184021,
0.026067310944199562,
-0.1347380429506302,
0.7832894921302795,
0.44282594323158264,
0.15382689237594604,
0.1977258324623108,
0.19932903349399567,
0.44753292202949524,
-0.5629245042800903,
-0.2244158387184143,
-1.1030149459838867,
0.2994813323020935,
-0.017997298389673233,
-0.36829090118408203,
0.45671942830085754,
0.338674396276474,
0.7388336062431335,
0.12066880613565445,
0.769716739654541,
0.32530373334884644,
0.4380768835544586,
-0.2891469895839691,
0.46309182047843933,
-0.4749240279197693,
0.3008473515510559,
-0.04799250140786171,
-1.208469033241272,
-0.3348730504512787,
0.4306500256061554,
-0.5876609086990356,
0.2634512782096863,
0.3918799161911011,
0.6713237166404724,
-0.06350061297416687,
0.0018192577408626676,
0.8788056969642639,
0.15709562599658966,
0.5232359170913696,
0.41327840089797974,
0.9442865252494812,
-0.1457735151052475,
0.5498203635215759,
-0.047486383467912674,
-0.27711978554725647,
-0.3212176263332367,
-0.9204949140548706,
-0.6142022609710693,
-0.33364787697792053,
-0.10906291753053665,
-0.11513950675725937,
-0.11038417369127274,
0.9227712750434875,
0.7209020853042603,
-0.7372840642929077,
-0.5431216359138489,
-0.1567612737417221,
0.1410887986421585,
-0.11600465327501297,
-0.173063263297081,
0.013207335025072098,
-0.31449902057647705,
-0.7226128578186035,
0.2573387324810028,
0.30064666271209717,
0.10800499469041824,
-0.3022356629371643,
-0.27362942695617676,
-0.03993488848209381,
-0.13809269666671753,
0.38467398285865784,
0.34326958656311035,
-0.9060853719711304,
-0.443905234336853,
-0.20697341859340668,
-0.41823509335517883,
0.14991208910942078,
0.743660032749176,
-0.4571502208709717,
0.2476317584514618,
0.21572469174861908,
0.7710242867469788,
0.28411203622817993,
0.006466969382017851,
0.860045850276947,
-0.5936626195907593,
-0.4474946856498718,
0.1369493305683136,
0.6461284756660461,
0.5375367403030396,
-0.2758544385433197,
0.5318268537521362,
0.03982791304588318,
-1.0424940586090088,
-0.6643046140670776,
0.21108566224575043,
-0.6722944378852844,
-0.02977817878127098,
1.1955859661102295,
-0.20081248879432678,
-0.08531634509563446,
-0.18888425827026367,
0.16070644557476044,
-0.044082481414079666,
-0.36416029930114746,
0.9394479393959045,
1.0258821249008179,
-0.10513319820165634,
0.10865741968154907,
-0.8038849830627441,
0.27290064096450806,
0.5383327603340149,
-0.7407095432281494,
0.3396129012107849,
0.35059937834739685,
0.539271891117096,
0.290105938911438,
0.5130660533905029,
0.15531004965305328,
0.2888430058956146,
-0.3511515259742737,
0.021672332659363747,
0.25995945930480957,
0.08278867602348328,
-0.6569394469261169,
-0.0047167628072202206,
0.4589167833328247,
0.26108524203300476
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.01375v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.01375v1
|
D-CPT Law: Domain-specific Continual Pre-Training Scaling Law for Large Language Models
| 2024-06-03T14:40:31 | 2024-06-03T14:40:31 |
Haoran Que, Jiaheng Liu, Ge Zhang, Chenchen Zhang, Xingwei Qu, Yinghao Ma, Feiyu Duan, Zhiqi Bai, Jiakai Wang, Yuanxing Zhang, Xu Tan, Jie Fu, Wenbo Su, Jiamang Wang, Lin Qu, Bo Zheng
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Continual Pre-Training (CPT) on Large Language Models (LLMs) has been widely
used to expand the model's fundamental understanding of specific downstream
domains (e.g., math and code). For the CPT on domain-specific LLMs, one
important question is how to choose the optimal mixture ratio between the
general-corpus (e.g., Dolma, Slim-pajama) and the downstream domain-corpus.
Existing methods usually adopt laborious human efforts by grid-searching on a
set of mixture ratios, which require high GPU training consumption costs.
Besides, we cannot guarantee the selected ratio is optimal for the specific
domain. To address the limitations of existing methods, inspired by the Scaling
Law for performance prediction, we propose to investigate the Scaling Law of
the Domain-specific Continual Pre-Training (D-CPT Law) to decide the optimal
mixture ratio with acceptable training costs for LLMs of different sizes.
Specifically, by fitting the D-CPT Law, we can easily predict the general and
downstream performance of arbitrary mixture ratios, model sizes, and dataset
sizes using small-scale training costs on limited experiments. Moreover, we
also extend our standard D-CPT Law on cross-domain settings and propose the
Cross-Domain D-CPT Law to predict the D-CPT law of target domains, where very
small training costs (about 1% of the normal training costs) are needed for the
target domains. Comprehensive experimental results on six downstream domains
demonstrate the effectiveness and generalizability of our proposed D-CPT Law
and Cross-Domain D-CPT Law.
|
[
-0.5745298862457275,
-0.7009101510047913,
0.6772364974021912,
0.3605353534221649,
-0.3527393937110901,
0.0803370550274849,
-0.43710559606552124,
-0.17419932782649994,
0.05345863848924637,
0.5715047121047974,
-0.6321093440055847,
0.10641273856163025,
-0.7392627000808716,
0.006454900838434696,
-0.29498764872550964,
0.8421171307563782,
-0.19888466596603394,
0.24461500346660614,
-0.26650112867355347,
0.24351589381694794,
-0.40574750304222107,
-0.8132651448249817,
-0.4727422297000885,
-0.14883685111999512,
0.5246544480323792,
0.10195635259151459,
0.45137059688568115,
0.7072014808654785,
0.5001974105834961,
0.1666564643383026,
-0.02851170115172863,
-0.2507142722606659,
-0.7230571508407593,
-0.03600265458226204,
-0.1803092062473297,
-0.3095315992832184,
-0.48116207122802734,
0.04901115968823433,
0.8113831281661987,
0.7188673615455627,
-0.19152753055095673,
-0.1303802877664566,
0.3518590033054352,
0.6014377474784851,
-0.6961516737937927,
-0.029566295444965363,
-0.7098920345306396,
-0.09247589111328125,
-0.33681875467300415,
-0.29519885778427124,
-0.35156822204589844,
-0.2296333760023117,
0.10348491370677948,
-0.6006650924682617,
0.23583462834358215,
0.2456749826669693,
0.502356767654419,
0.383920282125473,
-0.3814775347709656,
-0.06267488747835159,
-0.6553341746330261,
1.082727313041687,
-0.46856361627578735,
0.40476685762405396,
0.4324139952659607,
0.23995867371559143,
-0.07359136641025543,
-0.7879064679145813,
-0.7202316522598267,
-0.43938711285591125,
-0.02247081696987152,
-0.08787340670824051,
-0.19962437450885773,
0.05144131928682327,
0.0802483782172203,
0.5126822590827942,
-0.7682270407676697,
0.22569416463375092,
-0.25484421849250793,
0.0336969792842865,
0.5286740660667419,
0.2800236940383911,
0.34864455461502075,
0.6114462018013,
-0.4549926817417145,
0.010754432529211044,
-0.8978034257888794,
-0.32824069261550903,
0.24448460340499878,
0.2897428274154663,
-0.23128962516784668,
0.20070534944534302,
-0.011835015378892422,
0.644568145275116,
0.4885331988334656,
-0.18631137907505035,
0.12694890797138214,
-0.5201883316040039,
-0.2031145989894867,
0.08628565073013306,
0.6103398203849792,
0.0331769734621048,
0.5519388318061829,
-0.1560332328081131,
-0.30814504623413086,
-0.16959194839000702,
0.5047714710235596,
-0.8878344893455505,
-0.2672870457172394,
-0.13295666873455048,
-0.26282790303230286,
-0.1907867044210434,
-0.3091626465320587,
-0.6375284790992737,
-0.02192196622490883,
-0.7020137310028076,
0.5547250509262085,
-0.27695396542549133,
-0.4930228888988495,
0.04107242822647095,
0.2766895592212677,
0.11443431675434113,
0.252407431602478,
-1.0600184202194214,
0.5627012252807617,
0.5646482706069946,
0.6410140991210938,
-0.411440372467041,
-0.5253527164459229,
-0.6238652467727661,
-0.06796197593212128,
-0.16979865729808807,
0.5677736401557922,
-0.5466142892837524,
-0.39359235763549805,
-0.024043582379817963,
-0.1981252133846283,
-0.4636248052120209,
-0.608870267868042,
0.29753896594047546,
-0.7983585000038147,
-0.20529156923294067,
-0.1594260185956955,
-0.7373244762420654,
0.13634558022022247,
0.18154722452163696,
-0.6229872107505798,
0.6882016658782959,
0.3384372293949127,
-0.836542546749115,
0.5984575152397156,
-0.2967376112937927,
-0.4685194492340088,
0.3461502194404602,
-0.26669248938560486,
-0.5992811918258667,
0.06904605776071548,
0.030324755236506462,
0.5433037281036377,
-0.5063450932502747,
0.3562670052051544,
-0.5131439566612244,
-0.3993964195251465,
0.009727218188345432,
-0.38417911529541016,
0.7039273977279663,
0.24402445554733276,
-0.35940006375312805,
-0.13240684568881989,
-0.558993935585022,
-0.06631603837013245,
0.2744131088256836,
-0.3712187111377716,
-0.30585408210754395,
-0.06766318529844284,
-0.147889643907547,
0.10916660726070404,
0.4412066340446472,
-0.4181850850582123,
0.2744644284248352,
0.02582765370607376,
0.23668605089187622,
0.7512794733047485,
0.12090983986854553,
0.6221911907196045,
-0.3789089024066925,
0.7529468536376953,
0.017144275829195976,
0.1865430623292923,
0.2789052426815033,
-0.30096450448036194,
-0.30122026801109314,
-0.6662106513977051,
0.30465611815452576,
0.39043867588043213,
-0.47003260254859924,
0.44983232021331787,
-0.4164460599422455,
-0.4110735356807709,
0.0032589721959084272,
0.18722636997699738,
0.31632763147354126,
0.3960728347301483,
0.48708269000053406,
-0.4179665148258209,
-0.66780024766922,
-0.6031768321990967,
-0.042376816272735596,
-0.06542855501174927,
0.08762632310390472,
0.16954736411571503,
0.5690785646438599,
-0.12452888488769531,
1.046297550201416,
-0.5069226026535034,
-0.0891648679971695,
-0.44947436451911926,
-0.1294441521167755,
0.2138412743806839,
0.4539235234260559,
0.846027135848999,
-0.9370946288108826,
-0.9489131569862366,
-0.09206853806972504,
-0.2575604319572449,
-0.19575384259223938,
0.047264549881219864,
0.10919198393821716,
-0.1798035055398941,
0.28069257736206055,
-0.2990286350250244,
0.2910059988498688,
0.7237102389335632,
-0.0259539857506752,
0.8899569511413574,
-0.34184762835502625,
0.036760129034519196,
-0.6618108153343201,
-0.04557310789823532,
0.1979309767484665,
-0.22636069357395172,
-0.6890344023704529,
-0.141431987285614,
0.22101333737373352,
0.19537004828453064,
-0.43581315875053406,
0.5601818561553955,
-0.18753069639205933,
0.13053669035434723,
-0.39593204855918884,
-0.16985788941383362,
-0.2323545217514038,
0.6089697480201721,
0.23099038004875183,
1.0406732559204102,
0.6723352670669556,
-0.9707124829292297,
0.16349080204963684,
-0.054596785455942154,
-0.21807438135147095,
0.5770699381828308,
-0.45965924859046936,
-0.05907364562153816,
0.22141867876052856,
0.5381600260734558,
-0.7166457772254944,
0.04596664384007454,
-0.13250313699245453,
-0.20151670277118683,
0.4884878098964691,
-0.3637753427028656,
-0.595862627029419,
-0.20297378301620483,
-0.03566659241914749,
0.875541627407074,
0.8556278944015503,
-0.7637308835983276,
0.489336758852005,
0.4117402732372284,
-0.22071371972560883,
-0.5116687417030334,
-0.4030615985393524,
-0.2185068130493164,
-0.4065380394458771,
-0.6654118299484253,
0.4862186014652252,
-0.42299509048461914,
-0.15638817846775055,
-0.2327173948287964,
-0.10511518269777298,
-0.5496443510055542,
-0.04832996800541878,
0.0023556353989988565,
0.17009063065052032,
-0.3444863557815552,
-0.33570802211761475,
-0.07679929584264755,
0.1487259715795517,
0.13948626816272736,
-0.637904167175293,
0.8389784693717957,
0.05293944850564003,
-0.11664386093616486,
-0.22461844980716705,
0.14244869351387024,
0.2966647148132324,
-0.13055993616580963,
0.7257948517799377,
0.45551252365112305,
-0.11013588309288025,
-0.3181087374687195,
-0.5541364550590515,
-0.08293973654508591,
-0.4391859769821167,
0.35524627566337585,
-0.5321449637413025,
-0.8846787810325623,
0.4314311146736145,
-0.1627582460641861,
-0.27571070194244385,
0.6780268549919128,
1.049095869064331,
0.08090751618146896,
0.7902851104736328,
0.6669014096260071,
-0.20880843698978424,
0.5136711597442627,
-0.17555777728557587,
0.08785019814968109,
-0.7520869374275208,
0.13624237477779388,
-0.461980938911438,
-0.19791795313358307,
-0.5364521741867065,
-0.3834182322025299,
0.2523941397666931,
0.19206345081329346,
-0.4890994727611542,
0.4989738166332245,
-0.308358371257782,
0.6444551348686218,
0.37481436133384705,
-0.1389990746974945,
0.24404270946979523,
0.12452448159456253,
-0.32659679651260376,
-0.05507909879088402,
-0.6105038523674011,
-0.03103603981435299,
1.183176040649414,
0.2762821614742279,
0.7504485249519348,
-0.009356649592518806,
0.9562568068504333,
0.29659268260002136,
0.45721277594566345,
-0.633485734462738,
0.4454289376735687,
-0.400981605052948,
-0.6058655977249146,
-0.18128308653831482,
-0.7905444502830505,
-1.0369683504104614,
0.25149068236351013,
0.24770887196063995,
-0.5378142595291138,
0.1684727966785431,
0.23152121901512146,
-0.13775329291820526,
0.5918166041374207,
-0.32288146018981934,
0.779303252696991,
-0.255464106798172,
-0.17562559247016907,
-0.4552434980869293,
-0.5985867977142334,
0.24530254304409027,
-0.804265558719635,
0.12889795005321503,
0.04081983491778374,
-0.06205432489514351,
0.6302443146705627,
-0.6333231925964355,
0.9179792404174805,
-0.18535469472408295,
-0.25423043966293335,
0.49244725704193115,
0.14189031720161438,
0.49906760454177856,
-0.07459505647420883,
0.32889124751091003,
0.3437183201313019,
0.011308255605399609,
-0.4639872610569,
-0.3555600345134735,
0.6888229846954346,
-0.909222424030304,
-0.3239094913005829,
-0.3110293745994568,
-0.2247963398694992,
-0.34693947434425354,
0.1710710972547531,
0.4796105921268463,
0.1595095992088318,
-0.24996426701545715,
0.18081557750701904,
0.769141435623169,
0.004161256831139326,
0.12015662342309952,
0.7072701454162598,
0.02505439706146717,
-0.36974120140075684,
1.083132028579712,
0.06766413897275925,
0.3214462101459503,
0.5547784566879272,
0.4245615005493164,
-0.36083558201789856,
-0.8383828997612,
-0.2506721019744873,
0.29343265295028687,
-0.4622630476951599,
-0.17324838042259216,
-0.449092835187912,
-0.36412814259529114,
-0.3887932002544403,
-0.2717756927013397,
-0.44727352261543274,
-0.30210068821907043,
-0.23704315721988678,
0.3710624873638153,
0.16329175233840942,
0.42515063285827637,
-0.11991799622774124,
0.4125380516052246,
-0.8114100098609924,
0.08419999480247498,
0.3209100663661957,
0.49120819568634033,
-0.06466019153594971,
-1.003516435623169,
-0.3198258876800537,
-0.027406839653849602,
-0.4633013904094696,
-0.34854185581207275,
0.46024438738822937,
0.30259475111961365,
0.6084439754486084,
0.049221836030483246,
0.015167257748544216,
0.43762922286987305,
-0.8130502700805664,
0.690680205821991,
0.5518968105316162,
-0.6639387011528015,
0.3072737455368042,
-0.35537824034690857,
-0.09236369282007217,
0.34775564074516296,
0.47986799478530884,
-0.29029080271720886,
-0.27614107728004456,
-0.6570205092430115,
-0.8321272730827332,
0.5269679427146912,
0.2792302072048187,
0.18791553378105164,
0.016744492575526237,
0.4843739867210388,
0.24638645350933075,
-0.004033730365335941,
-0.6207686066627502,
-0.005558532662689686,
0.020725686103105545,
-0.23142358660697937,
-0.05863600969314575,
0.014499225653707981,
0.07027539610862732,
-0.22137880325317383,
0.5780372619628906,
0.01369442418217659,
0.12287697941064835,
-0.09719232469797134,
-0.16439670324325562,
-0.09830978512763977,
0.07647582143545151,
0.6807401776313782,
0.7399060130119324,
-0.27071449160575867,
-0.16286154091358185,
0.2500268518924713,
-1.0316036939620972,
0.4344886243343353,
0.0427657812833786,
0.134601891040802,
-0.422983318567276,
0.15181027352809906,
0.7146185040473938,
0.02887735888361931,
-0.7451309561729431,
0.6760658025741577,
-0.28098928928375244,
-0.6418527364730835,
-0.5750860571861267,
0.17666320502758026,
-0.22762227058410645,
0.19175168871879578,
0.3720219135284424,
-0.07471664994955063,
-0.17274627089500427,
-0.10826553404331207,
0.4242743253707886,
0.1043398305773735,
-0.18173442780971527,
-0.36472922563552856,
0.7488872408866882,
0.0564575158059597,
0.11665483564138412,
0.6008273959159851,
-0.2239912897348404,
-0.41339197754859924,
0.6844749450683594,
0.49654725193977356,
0.9394567012786865,
-0.36002248525619507,
-0.22215567529201508,
0.3164573907852173,
-0.041918497532606125,
-0.3968515396118164,
-0.08523672819137573,
0.02794739231467247,
-0.697461724281311,
-0.798937976360321,
-0.8181741833686829,
-0.4082441031932831,
0.18091890215873718,
-0.5228937864303589,
0.17915858328342438,
-0.5849276185035706,
-0.09543391317129135,
-0.2417156994342804,
0.2715708911418915,
-0.8484837412834167,
0.5234407186508179,
0.21671734750270844,
0.662746250629425,
-0.4692182242870331,
1.1302053928375244,
0.26219838857650757,
-0.3053246736526489,
-0.6746739745140076,
0.27988025546073914,
0.11915930360555649,
-0.9246997237205505,
1.0075454711914062,
-0.2408519685268402,
-0.18276551365852356,
-0.06502438336610794,
-0.3862229585647583,
-0.9116547703742981,
0.9927051067352295,
0.49311360716819763,
-0.9736597537994385,
0.07830557972192764,
0.07706208527088165,
0.4054175615310669,
-0.6930598020553589,
-0.22913138568401337,
0.73543781042099,
0.2408696711063385,
0.19824784994125366,
-1.2252470254898071,
0.05119055509567261,
0.09242797642946243,
-0.03380930796265602,
0.36520442366600037,
-0.5937564373016357,
1.1322591304779053,
-0.0807528868317604,
0.06903818249702454,
-0.12900948524475098,
0.5041124820709229,
0.4074719548225403,
0.17812779545783997,
0.8006748557090759,
0.6159618496894836,
0.45244601368904114,
0.1505778431892395,
1.2336429357528687,
-0.5000022053718567,
0.5560902953147888,
1.0092476606369019,
-0.42746633291244507,
0.8352912068367004,
0.27169522643089294,
-0.562150239944458,
0.18699108064174652,
0.8101904392242432,
-0.1039486825466156,
0.7222122550010681,
0.6569334268569946,
-0.4529283046722412,
-0.12454108893871307,
0.24176862835884094,
-0.4206271767616272,
0.0893130674958229,
0.19407911598682404,
-0.2917729318141937,
0.12280621379613876,
-0.1707640439271927,
0.003912138286978006,
-0.2227187603712082,
-0.44736188650131226,
0.6959046125411987,
0.1149907335639,
-0.554465651512146,
0.9890363216400146,
-0.15227057039737701,
0.7654221653938293,
-0.7013581395149231,
0.45306530594825745,
-0.2111632376909256,
0.36653581261634827,
0.15255200862884521,
-0.5704060196876526,
0.13556449115276337,
-0.01830308884382248,
-0.2136646807193756,
-0.24645498394966125,
0.4194645583629608,
-0.28863152861595154,
-0.21852658689022064,
0.46411600708961487,
0.33226919174194336,
0.10076826065778732,
-0.4186779856681824,
-0.654277503490448,
0.03221340477466583,
-0.06762804836034775,
-0.3357311189174652,
1.0251858234405518,
0.28823229670524597,
0.10442043840885162,
0.41053253412246704,
0.4411724805831909,
0.3718307912349701,
0.16120906174182892,
0.19832414388656616,
1.034097671508789,
-0.32931724190711975,
-0.6439972519874573,
-0.8218956589698792,
0.16763438284397125,
0.10256357491016388,
-0.07347214967012405,
0.34406527876853943,
0.5595045685768127,
1.0012867450714111,
0.03499240800738335,
1.0193067789077759,
0.0023348836693912745,
0.34083980321884155,
-0.5837110877037048,
0.46623632311820984,
-0.7627450227737427,
0.17128433287143707,
0.03637344762682915,
-1.357366919517517,
-0.12762676179409027,
0.4885028004646301,
-0.5041613578796387,
0.35589608550071716,
0.8171574473381042,
0.5309857130050659,
-0.28200191259384155,
-0.04387839883565903,
0.4122169613838196,
0.06490767002105713,
0.2400542050600052,
0.563481330871582,
0.5275181531906128,
0.09968972206115723,
0.700697124004364,
-0.1870442032814026,
-0.3395431935787201,
-0.24542118608951569,
-0.7238883972167969,
-0.6294488906860352,
-0.5522161722183228,
-0.4847419559955597,
-0.30756261944770813,
-0.2373650223016739,
0.7357479333877563,
0.832643449306488,
-0.5653228759765625,
-0.3277745842933655,
-0.17476630210876465,
-0.4996418058872223,
-0.44701090455055237,
-0.14010532200336456,
0.34155961871147156,
-0.6826828718185425,
-0.5948220491409302,
0.3031235635280609,
0.21501024067401886,
0.18543003499507904,
-0.2758159041404724,
-0.3504812717437744,
0.05260339006781578,
0.34868115186691284,
0.39885473251342773,
0.32367604970932007,
-0.4644947648048401,
0.04020044207572937,
-0.42380964756011963,
-0.2772573232650757,
0.22872914373874664,
1.4023396968841553,
-0.4092272222042084,
0.18518272042274475,
0.371905654668808,
0.8222119808197021,
0.7519544959068298,
-0.26793959736824036,
0.6133162975311279,
-1.0336978435516357,
0.06413782387971878,
0.4379878342151642,
0.46479108929634094,
-0.04509701207280159,
-0.32790663838386536,
0.42697134613990784,
0.38190731406211853,
-0.8552340865135193,
-0.5321429967880249,
0.29821375012397766,
-1.0390437841415405,
-0.34216877818107605,
1.0711106061935425,
-0.354135662317276,
-0.1184890940785408,
-0.08678741753101349,
-0.09311331808567047,
-0.005391342099756002,
-0.21485456824302673,
0.474018394947052,
0.5934993028640747,
-0.20954637229442596,
-0.2086634784936905,
-0.6135298609733582,
0.5404025316238403,
0.4239047169685364,
-0.5464968681335449,
0.34981298446655273,
0.2331092804670334,
0.6004989147186279,
-0.12152216583490372,
0.904193103313446,
-0.041366539895534515,
-0.05895213037729263,
0.10448191314935684,
-0.29650330543518066,
0.4210374653339386,
-0.20451755821704865,
-0.23516567051410675,
0.06523772329092026,
0.054670192301273346,
0.1362859308719635
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.01372v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.01372v2
|
Linguistic Analysis, Description, and Typological Exploration with Categorial Grammar (TheBench Guide)
| 2024-06-03T14:39:06 | 2024-06-04T05:52:20 |
Cem Bozsahin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
TheBench is a tool to study monadic structures in natural language. It is for
writing monadic grammars to explore analyses, compare diverse languages through
their categories, and to train models of grammar from form-meaning pairs where
syntax is latent variable.
Monadic structures are binary combinations of elements that employ semantics
of composition only. TheBench is essentially old-school categorial grammar to
syntacticize the idea, with the implication that although syntax is autonomous
(recall \emph{colorless green ideas sleep furiously}), the treasure is in the
baggage it carries at every step, viz. semantics, more narrowly,
predicate-argument structures indicating choice of categorial reference and its
consequent placeholders for decision in such structures.
There is some new thought in old school. Unlike traditional categorial
grammars, application is turned into composition in monadic analysis. Moreover,
every correspondence requires specifying two command relations, one on
syntactic command and the other on semantic command. A monadic grammar of
TheBench contains only synthetic elements (called `objects' in category theory
of mathematics) that are shaped by this analytic invariant, viz. composition.
Both ingredients (command relations) of any analytic step must therefore be
functions (`arrows' in category theory). TheBench is one implementation of the
idea for iterative development of such functions along with grammar of
synthetic elements.
|
[
-0.5881775617599487,
-1.1727979183197021,
0.49406909942626953,
0.11554200202226639,
-0.5422372817993164,
0.3805091381072998,
-0.10268163681030273,
-0.18250510096549988,
0.5827485918998718,
0.5374218225479126,
-0.8342076539993286,
-0.684357225894928,
-0.009700753726065159,
-0.0848550945520401,
-0.39398193359375,
0.9997777342796326,
-0.13465744256973267,
-0.06063767895102501,
-0.3115237355232239,
0.007826811634004116,
-0.3029884397983551,
-0.6772885918617249,
-0.5891086459159851,
-0.14231516420841217,
0.4021275043487549,
0.3530643880367279,
0.5806169509887695,
0.644351601600647,
0.6446016430854797,
0.4587736129760742,
-0.12178054451942444,
-0.4453979432582855,
-0.31424781680107117,
0.22287282347679138,
-0.6520085334777832,
-0.8477257490158081,
-0.26823461055755615,
-0.1820099800825119,
0.5750078558921814,
1.0770992040634155,
-0.4348814785480499,
0.27899253368377686,
-0.1865391880273819,
0.6928372979164124,
-0.46613839268684387,
0.5924999713897705,
-0.27180176973342896,
0.2866107225418091,
-0.7483402490615845,
-0.3782700002193451,
-0.30081096291542053,
-0.3229939937591553,
-0.09609473496675491,
-0.4454278349876404,
0.2573113441467285,
0.42549097537994385,
0.5467109680175781,
0.19028569757938385,
-0.278145968914032,
-0.10728823393583298,
-0.5570707321166992,
0.786740779876709,
-0.40758562088012695,
0.05410461500287056,
0.3732846677303314,
0.7454200387001038,
-0.34000763297080994,
-0.6698467135429382,
-0.35520389676094055,
-0.12180909514427185,
-0.2717081904411316,
0.15117716789245605,
-0.060214363038539886,
0.4250738322734833,
0.06592313945293427,
0.9237518310546875,
-0.808394193649292,
-0.050449080765247345,
-0.44882580637931824,
-0.3355153501033783,
0.3710087835788727,
0.3328096270561218,
0.45553892850875854,
-0.6936812996864319,
-0.3275500535964966,
-0.3454402685165405,
-0.3501863479614258,
0.28575465083122253,
0.34994909167289734,
0.19363653659820557,
-0.09106598049402237,
0.6821792125701904,
-0.32343050837516785,
0.9244076609611511,
0.018502945080399513,
-0.0377545990049839,
0.03349408134818077,
-0.5741021633148193,
-0.19062770903110504,
0.2734187841415405,
0.6458413600921631,
0.13117825984954834,
0.3616366982460022,
-0.5087055563926697,
0.33654677867889404,
0.43705853819847107,
0.5313114523887634,
-0.7065545916557312,
-0.3860180974006653,
0.06204484403133392,
-0.541447103023529,
-0.5273470282554626,
0.14480699598789215,
-0.879198431968689,
-0.11449252814054489,
-0.3093937039375305,
-0.12422069162130356,
-0.3514501750469208,
-0.4106285274028778,
0.11617067456245422,
-0.2527148723602295,
0.1973898559808731,
-0.032787926495075226,
-1.0076489448547363,
0.7421395778656006,
0.7968860268592834,
0.41454482078552246,
0.25861671566963196,
-0.24940459430217743,
-0.29573819041252136,
0.03865654021501541,
-0.3103421926498413,
1.0256199836730957,
-0.7245505452156067,
-0.3920210003852844,
-0.22446170449256897,
0.2063397467136383,
-0.022877831012010574,
-0.3041887581348419,
0.5678733587265015,
-0.478428453207016,
0.26512643694877625,
-0.06697069853544235,
-0.6041276454925537,
-0.8242141008377075,
0.2557336986064911,
-0.847100555896759,
1.0794757604599,
0.4680640995502472,
-0.4758567214012146,
0.3042879104614258,
-0.7398133277893066,
-0.3769945204257965,
0.17176207900047302,
-0.3706165850162506,
-0.1670141965150833,
0.27885177731513977,
-0.31598910689353943,
0.03540800139307976,
-0.5206286311149597,
0.40702199935913086,
-0.48848557472229004,
-0.036404307931661606,
0.3293386697769165,
0.29006248712539673,
1.0752583742141724,
-0.0031015335116535425,
-0.5218935012817383,
0.40604859590530396,
-0.9671029448509216,
0.3313923478126526,
-0.0010970854200422764,
-0.17017243802547455,
-0.2573132812976837,
0.42328885197639465,
-0.08782661706209183,
0.22291722893714905,
-0.10177897661924362,
-0.4999876916408539,
0.13804876804351807,
-0.7138875722885132,
0.4559673070907593,
0.7224560976028442,
0.18900366127490997,
0.723087728023529,
-0.22591793537139893,
0.8385319113731384,
-0.39448922872543335,
0.05726354196667671,
0.11809813231229782,
-0.21249377727508545,
-0.9516602754592896,
-0.014595179818570614,
0.5604223608970642,
0.6059609055519104,
-0.7252295017242432,
0.630064070224762,
-0.06357461214065552,
-0.532107412815094,
-0.20612524449825287,
0.1963651180267334,
0.4099104702472687,
0.22275622189044952,
0.1678614318370819,
-0.5046195983886719,
-0.9629076719284058,
-0.9770570993423462,
-0.0854627937078476,
-0.36361342668533325,
0.40681877732276917,
-0.059730444103479385,
0.4320313632488251,
0.17676213383674622,
0.8964484333992004,
-0.049087654799222946,
-0.23223881423473358,
-0.39798855781555176,
0.1451369822025299,
0.1749977171421051,
0.5012422800064087,
0.8268724083900452,
-0.5077226758003235,
-0.298199325799942,
-0.10108844190835953,
-0.7226827144622803,
-0.11579224467277527,
0.18376898765563965,
-0.7696284651756287,
0.18604153394699097,
0.5297116637229919,
-0.25504034757614136,
0.29379403591156006,
0.32832568883895874,
-0.4821316599845886,
0.4773477017879486,
0.21233434975147247,
-0.3156289756298065,
-1.1189079284667969,
0.03516855463385582,
-0.6920403242111206,
-0.17230547964572906,
-0.34255748987197876,
0.48344549536705017,
-0.2792031764984131,
-0.13645994663238525,
-0.236141175031662,
0.4349735975265503,
-0.43358075618743896,
-0.08881819993257523,
-0.15795662999153137,
0.03342773765325546,
-0.05351151525974274,
0.6261513233184814,
-0.06438447535037994,
0.2725007236003876,
0.6856992244720459,
-0.48884376883506775,
0.858805775642395,
0.24107655882835388,
-0.3031386137008667,
0.726454496383667,
-0.2801295518875122,
-0.05530013516545296,
0.03869524225592613,
0.1173110231757164,
-0.9553030729293823,
-0.37292367219924927,
0.5822097063064575,
-0.232933908700943,
0.21085220575332642,
0.27149319648742676,
-0.7431758642196655,
-0.4892701804637909,
-0.49137237668037415,
0.5028719902038574,
0.3402647376060486,
-0.18874388933181763,
0.9866759181022644,
0.2596507966518402,
-0.2878396809101105,
-0.44814109802246094,
-0.674006462097168,
0.04843483120203018,
-0.1721164584159851,
-0.6856809258460999,
0.14157503843307495,
-0.13466428220272064,
-0.5736148953437805,
0.5418082475662231,
-0.3451533019542694,
0.0019615953788161278,
0.39829620718955994,
0.32075580954551697,
0.2107660174369812,
-0.512383759021759,
0.23510979115962982,
-0.117965929210186,
-0.20782364904880524,
0.2627750039100647,
-0.04907215014100075,
0.7654638290405273,
-0.36743980646133423,
-0.1349082738161087,
-0.3031981289386749,
0.4041460454463959,
0.2247961014509201,
-0.3573698103427887,
0.6363607048988342,
0.1788204163312912,
0.06795407086610794,
-0.5516514778137207,
-0.42252033948898315,
-0.11857306212186813,
-0.4743969440460205,
0.1924954205751419,
-0.5584216117858887,
-0.6020187735557556,
0.5400920510292053,
0.16079281270503998,
-0.0810600146651268,
0.6428811550140381,
0.5104193091392517,
-0.14201372861862183,
0.41822823882102966,
0.7730545997619629,
0.06933338940143585,
0.5688387751579285,
-0.02622123807668686,
0.27743685245513916,
-0.5936571955680847,
-0.14592574536800385,
-0.5543850064277649,
-0.5403898358345032,
-0.7563737034797668,
-0.3066987693309784,
-0.0869627296924591,
0.04959052801132202,
-0.24651646614074707,
0.4773145616054535,
-0.3373997211456299,
0.41257378458976746,
0.7362275719642639,
-0.06824512779712677,
0.16472923755645752,
0.22750020027160645,
-0.4047614634037018,
-0.0027122749015688896,
-0.6591586470603943,
-0.4967012405395508,
1.0448025465011597,
-0.1360214799642563,
0.7346382141113281,
0.3624366521835327,
0.7589260935783386,
-0.02832995355129242,
0.0030534835532307625,
-1.0392088890075684,
1.0020720958709717,
-0.17120790481567383,
-1.023989200592041,
0.1217399314045906,
-0.19651614129543304,
-0.8088454604148865,
0.29911160469055176,
-0.015932979062199593,
-0.725210964679718,
0.3513492941856384,
0.004948434419929981,
-0.2877161204814911,
0.2482747733592987,
-0.5238304734230042,
1.2360461950302124,
-0.4103196859359741,
-0.48303818702697754,
-0.36684438586235046,
-0.7346058487892151,
0.34625282883644104,
0.07933641970157623,
0.24722935259342194,
0.08012304455041885,
0.22462345659732819,
0.6549113392829895,
-0.42778289318084717,
0.9732382297515869,
0.12742207944393158,
0.11633844673633575,
0.48268330097198486,
0.6888943910598755,
0.060616906732320786,
-0.34476083517074585,
-0.15454494953155518,
-0.27214646339416504,
0.3655754327774048,
-0.3582632839679718,
-0.6084438562393188,
0.2733052670955658,
-0.2978307902812958,
-0.6278964877128601,
-0.6018918752670288,
-0.4668917655944824,
-0.09092158079147339,
0.3712093234062195,
-0.11596959084272385,
0.6567462682723999,
-0.5576348900794983,
0.564815878868103,
0.24585874378681183,
-0.10615668445825577,
0.2578836977481842,
0.5217633843421936,
-0.4899338185787201,
-0.02228574827313423,
0.9067307710647583,
-0.17780373990535736,
0.265145868062973,
0.5739219188690186,
0.127786323428154,
-0.20019356906414032,
-0.19494104385375977,
-0.29406851530075073,
0.20151755213737488,
-0.9436002373695374,
0.10286831110715866,
-0.3127310574054718,
-0.14048658311367035,
0.003885809099301696,
-0.25858861207962036,
-0.02948734164237976,
-0.7474650144577026,
0.11925028264522552,
-0.2931370437145233,
0.22584189474582672,
0.34541645646095276,
-0.13081268966197968,
0.414419561624527,
-0.5310673713684082,
0.28370434045791626,
0.019832082092761993,
0.40436220169067383,
-0.2534499764442444,
0.15023022890090942,
0.09907397627830505,
-0.2256915122270584,
-0.20227716863155365,
-0.8659323453903198,
-0.13287697732448578,
0.21670982241630554,
0.7398603558540344,
0.6011133790016174,
-0.04625212028622627,
0.5651427507400513,
-0.40127062797546387,
0.5846189856529236,
-0.0943073183298111,
-0.9162057042121887,
0.5488240122795105,
-0.3244786262512207,
-0.04235446825623512,
0.6956099271774292,
-0.16181673109531403,
-0.49025464057922363,
-0.704059362411499,
-0.87819904088974,
-0.6034773588180542,
1.0054295063018799,
0.13945674896240234,
-0.20379315316677094,
0.19060339033603668,
0.08008518815040588,
-0.0642278641462326,
0.5489271283149719,
-0.8727129697799683,
-0.19252140820026398,
-0.2780231535434723,
-0.43213027715682983,
-0.2307080626487732,
-0.25061240792274475,
-0.3902909755706787,
-0.3231290578842163,
0.45949190855026245,
0.22185666859149933,
0.16986052691936493,
-0.33949005603790283,
-0.31084179878234863,
-0.2733636498451233,
0.5291718244552612,
0.23461385071277618,
0.7208382487297058,
-0.3447924852371216,
0.49292370676994324,
-0.5201498866081238,
-0.10436493903398514,
0.00287255784496665,
0.3125656247138977,
0.12167031317949295,
0.010673006065189838,
0.36445751786231995,
0.9272688627243042,
0.7202059626579285,
-0.764568030834198,
0.016761384904384613,
0.2934649586677551,
-0.17958149313926697,
-0.5147666335105896,
0.2987602651119232,
0.04150949418544769,
0.2593167722225189,
-0.2860339879989624,
-0.07601870596408844,
0.40689587593078613,
-1.1634880304336548,
0.017297372221946716,
0.400272935628891,
0.09367775917053223,
-0.36190083622932434,
0.3889080286026001,
0.023792527616024017,
-0.2088157832622528,
0.43879225850105286,
-0.326500803232193,
-0.6979806423187256,
0.9012591242790222,
0.39973682165145874,
0.9008030891418457,
-0.27479901909828186,
0.5401420593261719,
0.462355375289917,
0.4836490750312805,
0.24400876462459564,
0.3799283504486084,
-0.579596996307373,
-0.3905719518661499,
-0.1926153153181076,
-1.1132198572158813,
-0.3339598774909973,
-0.3700944185256958,
-0.6641998291015625,
0.08762684464454651,
-0.6612297892570496,
0.08226850628852844,
0.170863538980484,
-0.2106381058692932,
-0.27688661217689514,
-0.05649809166789055,
-0.002738694194704294,
0.6076317429542542,
-0.5119540095329285,
0.43811339139938354,
0.864956259727478,
-0.6419638991355896,
-0.9889993071556091,
-0.38695740699768066,
0.29286277294158936,
-0.543485164642334,
0.7038530111312866,
0.026627738028764725,
-0.14335766434669495,
0.059350524097681046,
-0.34604474902153015,
-0.9115254282951355,
0.6605193614959717,
0.1392689347267151,
-0.2334897667169571,
-0.2359168976545334,
0.25094032287597656,
0.7026463747024536,
-0.17929702997207642,
-0.1115688607096672,
0.704439103603363,
0.736694872379303,
0.07703232020139694,
-0.8443398475646973,
0.15714670717716217,
-0.5397182106971741,
0.022801760584115982,
0.577312707901001,
-0.2719550132751465,
1.0901012420654297,
0.30366045236587524,
-0.5678437948226929,
0.45750367641448975,
0.04089289531111717,
-0.060787785798311234,
-0.1450428068637848,
0.30217182636260986,
0.7420516014099121,
0.44504350423812866,
-0.3464314341545105,
1.4412161111831665,
-0.2154940664768219,
0.33991798758506775,
1.1149040460586548,
0.03408726677298546,
0.7104708552360535,
0.4679185450077057,
-0.4044060707092285,
1.226793646812439,
0.9011024832725525,
-0.2179858535528183,
0.48793965578079224,
0.47295621037483215,
-0.08510050177574158,
-0.30518221855163574,
0.04166242852807045,
-0.3506124019622803,
0.5804739594459534,
0.43450090289115906,
-0.30441221594810486,
-0.8854556083679199,
0.0020885728299617767,
-0.0934109315276146,
0.02419431135058403,
-0.3845336139202118,
0.8906393647193909,
-0.014037826098501682,
-0.6588506698608398,
0.594563364982605,
0.03911895304918289,
-0.043970562517642975,
-0.7234749794006348,
0.0741146132349968,
0.08479564636945724,
0.4165540039539337,
-0.24639055132865906,
-0.504420816898346,
0.5131984353065491,
-0.28315237164497375,
-0.16869202256202698,
-0.005708611570298672,
0.49914097785949707,
-0.2689727544784546,
-0.7000885009765625,
0.3072541058063507,
0.5691403150558472,
0.1740356683731079,
0.04638554900884628,
-0.5741791725158691,
-0.07931210845708847,
-0.25295695662498474,
-0.15719400346279144,
-0.1329636424779892,
0.39476022124290466,
-0.23080505430698395,
0.23254084587097168,
0.4208647310733795,
-0.09508831053972244,
0.3069555461406708,
-0.030743267387151718,
0.7413816452026367,
-0.9119012355804443,
-0.7222485542297363,
-0.8297907710075378,
0.44636964797973633,
0.04576074704527855,
0.08840521425008774,
0.7808316946029663,
0.49764132499694824,
0.7379484176635742,
-0.14991077780723572,
0.46234971284866333,
-0.5522085428237915,
0.5699595808982849,
-0.5943541526794434,
0.295890212059021,
-0.6627990007400513,
-0.2272343784570694,
-0.27733394503593445,
-1.2099024057388306,
-0.314151793718338,
0.8577848076820374,
-0.4976601004600525,
-0.11409323662519455,
1.40276300907135,
0.6375870704650879,
-0.10505889356136322,
0.15474402904510498,
-0.14013543725013733,
0.3756721317768097,
0.07754731923341751,
0.5262896418571472,
0.9195372462272644,
0.0768599882721901,
0.3091006278991699,
-0.49311286211013794,
-0.22823575139045715,
-0.30845704674720764,
-0.5015839338302612,
-1.1237218379974365,
-0.4533970057964325,
0.07562479376792908,
-0.2957501709461212,
-0.06449863314628601,
0.6825236678123474,
0.32887622714042664,
-0.8420615196228027,
-0.6704540848731995,
-0.6701388359069824,
-0.08674059063196182,
-0.2150985151529312,
-0.34333211183547974,
0.4464856684207916,
-0.6674889922142029,
-0.7040838599205017,
0.328277587890625,
0.3291797637939453,
-0.2301485389471054,
-0.3875032961368561,
0.48467519879341125,
-0.24251706898212433,
-0.01956750825047493,
0.5831936001777649,
0.43173640966415405,
-0.8324787616729736,
0.08028316497802734,
-0.0391354039311409,
0.060760632157325745,
0.05663600564002991,
0.8114950656890869,
-0.6047497987747192,
0.9336257576942444,
0.5233507752418518,
0.5998506546020508,
0.44388166069984436,
-0.04915804788470268,
0.4963996112346649,
-0.47447001934051514,
0.6245874166488647,
0.17921754717826843,
0.41140496730804443,
0.12089351564645767,
0.0932682678103447,
0.6485767364501953,
0.29639968276023865,
-0.08169815689325333,
-0.7274805903434753,
0.4469986855983734,
-1.39277184009552,
-0.45035508275032043,
0.8588739037513733,
0.4154885709285736,
-0.6958293318748474,
-0.11066480726003647,
-0.5254725217819214,
0.1501353234052658,
-0.10979995876550674,
0.6814329028129578,
1.2716280221939087,
-0.0620342381298542,
-0.12881091237068176,
-0.7089690566062927,
0.4300942122936249,
0.676616907119751,
-0.9936270713806152,
-0.36079108715057373,
0.7335271835327148,
0.2316320836544037,
0.4921911060810089,
0.46793636679649353,
-0.2551708519458771,
0.545662522315979,
-0.014942360110580921,
0.296157568693161,
0.1349571943283081,
-0.0792771503329277,
-0.08402756601572037,
0.411916047334671,
-0.020355379208922386,
-0.20336389541625977
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.01364v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.01364v1
|
BELLS: A Framework Towards Future Proof Benchmarks for the Evaluation of LLM Safeguards
| 2024-06-03T14:32:30 | 2024-06-03T14:32:30 |
Diego Dorn, Alexandre Variengien, Charbel-Raphaël Segerie, Vincent Corruble
|
cs.CR
|
cs.CR, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Input-output safeguards are used to detect anomalies in the traces produced
by Large Language Models (LLMs) systems. These detectors are at the core of
diverse safety-critical applications such as real-time monitoring, offline
evaluation of traces, and content moderation. However, there is no widely
recognized methodology to evaluate them. To fill this gap, we introduce the
Benchmarks for the Evaluation of LLM Safeguards (BELLS), a structured
collection of tests, organized into three categories: (1) established failure
tests, based on already-existing benchmarks for well-defined failure modes,
aiming to compare the performance of current input-output safeguards; (2)
emerging failure tests, to measure generalization to never-seen-before failure
modes and encourage the development of more general safeguards; (3) next-gen
architecture tests, for more complex scaffolding (such as LLM-agents and
multi-agent systems), aiming to foster the development of safeguards that could
adapt to future applications for which no safeguard currently exists.
Furthermore, we implement and share the first next-gen architecture test, using
the MACHIAVELLI environment, along with an interactive visualization of the
dataset.
|
[
-0.42367124557495117,
-0.5756910443305969,
0.4744192957878113,
0.0578787699341774,
0.16275817155838013,
0.18734298646450043,
0.2496013045310974,
-0.572728157043457,
-0.27645623683929443,
0.25236615538597107,
-0.6641504168510437,
-0.6325159668922424,
-0.4877541661262512,
0.28244253993034363,
-0.5513831973075867,
0.6538480520248413,
-0.1748235821723938,
-0.015881748870015144,
-0.19805581867694855,
0.061677031219005585,
-0.7118801474571228,
-0.595162570476532,
-0.6428685784339905,
-0.29804137349128723,
0.07207652181386948,
0.17908117175102234,
0.4000355005264282,
0.7395575642585754,
0.43385645747184753,
0.36263033747673035,
-0.05947897583246231,
-0.04179922118782997,
-0.15366019308567047,
0.344167023897171,
-0.06068715453147888,
-0.6009500026702881,
-0.5881101489067078,
-0.10039782524108887,
0.5040955543518066,
0.2678259313106537,
0.2716350257396698,
0.1344708651304245,
0.29970985651016235,
0.3083838224411011,
-0.7604033946990967,
0.497374564409256,
-0.6647377610206604,
0.2990173101425171,
-0.41555050015449524,
-0.653882622718811,
-0.3412627875804901,
-0.6906421780586243,
-0.23894380033016205,
-0.2509019076824188,
-0.1364208459854126,
0.1801689714193344,
0.8348079919815063,
0.1531422734260559,
-0.4122398793697357,
-0.19930045306682587,
-0.11918054521083832,
1.0864474773406982,
-0.6677255630493164,
0.6662381291389465,
0.4864409267902374,
0.6081446409225464,
-0.4881853461265564,
-0.5971434116363525,
-0.11702107638120651,
-0.23207002878189087,
0.17607653141021729,
0.1714349389076233,
-0.1750495433807373,
0.06593706458806992,
0.17021562159061432,
0.08706506341695786,
-0.5090804696083069,
0.043122146278619766,
0.023018529638648033,
-0.6174469590187073,
0.42219147086143494,
0.41635093092918396,
0.30386707186698914,
0.05623197555541992,
-0.5322318077087402,
-0.32109740376472473,
-1.053784728050232,
0.05793718621134758,
0.26671040058135986,
0.2779789865016937,
-0.2411801964044571,
0.25305259227752686,
-0.3076634705066681,
0.31509649753570557,
-0.08809734135866165,
-0.4715965688228607,
0.25091883540153503,
-0.5282066464424133,
-0.009841897524893284,
0.07302235066890717,
0.5206025838851929,
0.5868611931800842,
0.1729433834552765,
-0.32025015354156494,
-0.4713362753391266,
0.20130833983421326,
0.016461016610264778,
-0.9346248507499695,
-0.026380177587270737,
0.2332906723022461,
-0.6303630471229553,
-0.5575984120368958,
-0.26866745948791504,
-0.9298605918884277,
-0.5018841028213501,
-0.023588234558701515,
0.4284746050834656,
-0.41831833124160767,
-0.09303406625986099,
0.04690307006239891,
-0.09047499299049377,
0.43825793266296387,
-0.005922313779592514,
-0.8104763031005859,
0.3025458753108978,
1.0316616296768188,
0.9269397258758545,
-0.29778605699539185,
-0.2744125425815582,
-0.8025758862495422,
0.19287890195846558,
-0.4463639557361603,
0.9149410128593445,
-0.2651161849498749,
-0.5383108258247375,
0.5434388518333435,
0.08116072416305542,
-0.09037580341100693,
-0.6655489802360535,
1.1124335527420044,
-0.6929764151573181,
-0.35150641202926636,
-0.3815482556819916,
-0.3834802806377411,
-0.16797900199890137,
0.5683189630508423,
-0.29154983162879944,
0.8731989860534668,
0.03759511560201645,
-0.7663496732711792,
0.5323259234428406,
-0.4809727966785431,
-0.4812251031398773,
-0.03604727238416672,
-0.4759504497051239,
-0.49307432770729065,
-0.026924720034003258,
0.04518194496631622,
0.3841913938522339,
-0.4273090660572052,
0.2839573919773102,
-0.6062187552452087,
-0.5167434811592102,
0.4353868365287781,
-0.7790090441703796,
0.5874544382095337,
0.1779804229736328,
-0.6422241926193237,
0.2215321809053421,
-0.7307724356651306,
0.3915863335132599,
-0.20287951827049255,
-0.38786715269088745,
0.07385165244340897,
0.2352546900510788,
0.0031024732161313295,
0.006125345826148987,
0.34370067715644836,
-0.4888543486595154,
-0.3326653838157654,
0.009585617110133171,
0.5191492438316345,
0.9218956828117371,
-0.027359729632735252,
-0.022404542192816734,
-0.7681670188903809,
0.6828881502151489,
0.059721384197473526,
0.5816808342933655,
-0.5212312936782837,
-0.24976803362369537,
-0.7168515920639038,
-0.28235960006713867,
0.12293226271867752,
0.4996350407600403,
-0.4646497666835785,
0.7290838360786438,
-0.2205493152141571,
-0.24659015238285065,
0.05601983517408371,
-0.17367297410964966,
0.6622795462608337,
0.43998637795448303,
0.026735834777355194,
-0.4373888373374939,
-0.7233619689941406,
-0.9466819167137146,
-0.13822320103645325,
-0.5122442245483398,
0.11473455280065536,
-0.16071099042892456,
0.46316471695899963,
-0.37061211466789246,
0.957873523235321,
0.014553082175552845,
-0.12918831408023834,
0.0014194379327818751,
-0.021584179252386093,
0.08034456521272659,
0.3538653552532196,
0.5143948793411255,
-0.33577874302864075,
0.12534672021865845,
-0.030724385753273964,
-0.9778235554695129,
-0.37386733293533325,
0.3174624443054199,
0.01461922749876976,
0.18971870839595795,
0.6435683369636536,
-0.2587004601955414,
0.37740638852119446,
0.7087563276290894,
-0.14815208315849304,
1.0210238695144653,
0.20060989260673523,
0.46352994441986084,
-0.798250138759613,
-0.19569411873817444,
-0.31622982025146484,
-0.2790173292160034,
-0.39659303426742554,
0.14146631956100464,
0.2714594602584839,
-0.04977063834667206,
-0.5467263460159302,
0.404473215341568,
-0.27879586815834045,
-0.46808943152427673,
-0.13044406473636627,
-0.05299600213766098,
0.009294492192566395,
0.11854429543018341,
-0.3553113341331482,
1.0817142724990845,
0.689273476600647,
-0.7079995274543762,
0.03714631870388985,
0.055182989686727524,
-0.460807740688324,
0.803554356098175,
-0.7189180254936218,
0.08938879519701004,
0.4418414533138275,
0.12605063617229462,
-0.7219337821006775,
-0.16683262586593628,
0.14403851330280304,
-0.3244704604148865,
0.10655530542135239,
-0.25678837299346924,
-0.5141990780830383,
-0.1868005245923996,
-0.7271082401275635,
0.33957886695861816,
0.4373417794704437,
-0.705507218837738,
0.5559507012367249,
0.42209139466285706,
-0.07516782730817795,
-0.7383182048797607,
-0.807677686214447,
0.17209240794181824,
-0.554803729057312,
-0.7239110469818115,
0.2214267998933792,
-0.26575806736946106,
-0.40649327635765076,
-0.015501445159316063,
-0.24717634916305542,
-0.07291019707918167,
0.5541043281555176,
0.5413609743118286,
0.14690056443214417,
-0.24675258994102478,
-0.05589577555656433,
-0.002741309581324458,
-0.3793693482875824,
0.30931350588798523,
-0.295538067817688,
0.7329426407814026,
-0.42211616039276123,
-0.8587939143180847,
-0.5789302587509155,
0.20423376560211182,
0.7234381437301636,
-0.20205189287662506,
0.07955566048622131,
0.34054431319236755,
-0.4184798002243042,
-0.3459904193878174,
-0.5342395901679993,
-0.2545604705810547,
-0.5893954038619995,
0.5015586018562317,
-0.627117931842804,
-0.7867298126220703,
0.7309579849243164,
-0.2691119909286499,
0.30674147605895996,
0.11900001764297485,
0.4686873257160187,
0.2403889000415802,
0.7913272976875305,
0.48103097081184387,
-0.12870337069034576,
0.3316512107849121,
0.10253604501485825,
0.3289995789527893,
-0.73771071434021,
-0.04854395240545273,
-0.6844229698181152,
0.06734742224216461,
-0.4408785104751587,
-0.2516297996044159,
0.625504195690155,
0.2612312436103821,
-0.30808791518211365,
0.4041345715522766,
-0.25037023425102234,
0.2718961834907532,
0.49846354126930237,
-0.30787181854248047,
0.521237313747406,
-0.2514481842517853,
-0.25272074341773987,
0.13295097649097443,
-0.45127877593040466,
-1.0081526041030884,
1.3381669521331787,
0.5833759307861328,
0.7586512565612793,
0.010859635658562183,
1.043500304222107,
0.4498721957206726,
0.39520713686943054,
-0.6948642730712891,
0.8447643518447876,
0.34921571612358093,
-0.6086801886558533,
-0.12136641144752502,
-0.3693661689758301,
-0.9659574627876282,
0.09541501104831696,
0.0314219631254673,
-0.853010892868042,
0.18547780811786652,
0.05848871171474457,
-0.35887598991394043,
0.2840358018875122,
-0.5354315638542175,
0.6071749925613403,
-0.5072333812713623,
-0.4892914593219757,
-0.15560942888259888,
-0.000023456548660760745,
0.5708739161491394,
-0.14123499393463135,
0.4114910364151001,
-0.26441702246665955,
0.01018586941063404,
0.6194612383842468,
-0.17244869470596313,
0.7282012701034546,
0.009448892436921597,
-0.2794678807258606,
0.31580081582069397,
0.234270378947258,
0.4147719144821167,
0.18561476469039917,
-0.33978214859962463,
0.1232047900557518,
0.402852863073349,
0.03321271017193794,
-0.32590898871421814,
0.7276474833488464,
-0.49612805247306824,
-0.5116470456123352,
-0.5654649138450623,
-0.5936940908432007,
-0.4950951337814331,
0.23877660930156708,
0.058714281767606735,
0.8108177781105042,
-0.2309488207101822,
0.17118752002716064,
0.6361052393913269,
-0.19240552186965942,
0.73020339012146,
0.5750385522842407,
-0.17800943553447723,
-0.45106762647628784,
0.6825235486030579,
-0.020898208022117615,
0.17463158071041107,
0.19232524931430817,
0.0565665140748024,
-0.4709067940711975,
-0.9907119274139404,
-0.2674706280231476,
-0.34627631306648254,
-0.8081147074699402,
-0.4861040413379669,
-0.3372389078140259,
-0.35404279828071594,
-0.36823394894599915,
-0.1628396362066269,
-0.33361709117889404,
-0.06790071725845337,
0.1978563666343689,
-0.00023580847482662648,
0.2839886546134949,
0.5956715941429138,
-0.20485252141952515,
0.0117613784968853,
-0.8651977181434631,
-0.03501836210489273,
0.22837796807289124,
0.4692264497280121,
0.039140671491622925,
-0.33687376976013184,
-0.13829058408737183,
-0.3348938226699829,
-0.6749328374862671,
-0.7687143683433533,
0.1263142079114914,
-0.17471790313720703,
0.8282703161239624,
0.5996483564376831,
0.2519092261791229,
0.4610954821109772,
-0.502056360244751,
0.6711108088493347,
0.2196890115737915,
-1.026309609413147,
0.3347037136554718,
-0.47827982902526855,
-0.16356033086776733,
0.6907548308372498,
-0.18498240411281586,
-0.3116901218891144,
-0.12824077904224396,
-0.2614195942878723,
-0.7386866211891174,
0.25047165155410767,
-0.09635885804891586,
-0.16485969722270966,
-0.06293045729398727,
-0.03503264859318733,
0.10386721789836884,
0.05600385367870331,
-0.5714409351348877,
-0.006484732031822205,
0.19610363245010376,
-0.18650959432125092,
0.21547122299671173,
-0.28962698578834534,
-0.5530318021774292,
0.40328752994537354,
0.7135316133499146,
-0.14612330496311188,
0.2157030999660492,
0.03242650628089905,
-0.0040654828771948814,
0.07554063200950623,
0.522716224193573,
0.30873343348503113,
0.6074329018592834,
-0.2730588912963867,
0.27743491530418396,
0.38661274313926697,
-0.2975389063358307,
0.463928759098053,
0.25286445021629333,
-0.3859976828098297,
-0.18547871708869934,
0.6170269250869751,
0.29317551851272583,
0.38656145334243774,
-0.8083707094192505,
0.4643522799015045,
-0.1210833489894867,
-0.21242806315422058,
-0.41593658924102783,
0.05598243325948715,
-0.1516249030828476,
0.4968579411506653,
0.3870580494403839,
-0.08899951726198196,
0.2900537848472595,
-0.7706368565559387,
0.6767846941947937,
0.6016325354576111,
-0.3713161051273346,
-0.2785654366016388,
0.6148025989532471,
0.21666699647903442,
-0.3327200412750244,
-0.12438533455133438,
-0.4412540793418884,
-0.5606375932693481,
0.47500625252723694,
0.5636218786239624,
1.2739851474761963,
0.05896608904004097,
0.0905117392539978,
0.038393471390008926,
0.5290319919586182,
-0.11464861035346985,
0.33126625418663025,
-0.03614206612110138,
-0.5227874517440796,
-0.1900864988565445,
-0.7116739153862,
-0.6285302639007568,
0.22058281302452087,
-0.4344070553779602,
0.23742172122001648,
-0.5359609723091125,
-0.39490264654159546,
-0.6062394976615906,
0.156764954328537,
-0.5192123651504517,
0.0344122014939785,
-0.1282048374414444,
0.9563082456588745,
-0.7953715324401855,
0.48320189118385315,
0.32093337178230286,
-0.033747393637895584,
-0.5592805743217468,
0.17596638202667236,
0.2855580449104309,
-0.818759560585022,
0.5699803829193115,
0.3763810694217682,
-0.4507128596305847,
-0.5519840717315674,
0.023556800559163094,
-0.883888304233551,
1.2147630453109741,
0.4742281138896942,
-0.6185563206672668,
0.16392043232917786,
0.15667946636676788,
0.18789178133010864,
-0.08360176533460617,
0.47339898347854614,
0.7935271859169006,
0.6382368206977844,
-0.3592401444911957,
-0.7942354083061218,
0.1405733823776245,
-0.23066699504852295,
-0.11417979001998901,
-0.026881162077188492,
-0.6182287931442261,
0.8732811808586121,
0.22173626720905304,
-0.44016796350479126,
0.42787161469459534,
0.5169171690940857,
0.7591835260391235,
0.6449891328811646,
0.5281050205230713,
0.4863356649875641,
0.5723474025726318,
-0.5385388731956482,
1.0412991046905518,
-0.7292665839195251,
-0.009229744784533978,
0.9823853969573975,
-0.44754692912101746,
0.8042631149291992,
0.24339674413204193,
-0.28996509313583374,
0.24086393415927887,
0.7471099495887756,
0.22651906311511993,
0.4782806932926178,
0.45472073554992676,
-0.33627334237098694,
0.020535487681627274,
-0.4231894612312317,
-0.6933761239051819,
0.21930885314941406,
0.07068610936403275,
-0.08108894526958466,
-0.30834800004959106,
-0.30946028232574463,
0.11662493646144867,
0.09753615409135818,
-0.14738412201404572,
0.2577081024646759,
0.05868947505950928,
-0.49885672330856323,
0.5999670028686523,
-0.04634837061166763,
0.8418484330177307,
-0.7154332399368286,
0.08819880336523056,
-0.3411022424697876,
0.4558890163898468,
-0.15723152458667755,
-0.5623331665992737,
0.2247467190027237,
0.055824752897024155,
0.20003193616867065,
-0.2685820162296295,
0.6874915361404419,
0.033693183213472366,
-0.247691348195076,
0.5629366040229797,
0.40915438532829285,
0.02489469200372696,
0.311373770236969,
-0.3972274661064148,
0.676831066608429,
-0.38280197978019714,
-0.02379305101931095,
0.4783669114112854,
0.3931695818901062,
-0.22223982214927673,
0.8411552906036377,
0.5270627737045288,
0.07222044467926025,
0.3307410478591919,
0.24574822187423706,
0.7555215954780579,
-0.3918681740760803,
-0.44038674235343933,
-0.7370777726173401,
0.1820647120475769,
-0.008245806209743023,
-0.29810091853141785,
0.9720010757446289,
0.709688127040863,
0.6959027051925659,
0.16313500702381134,
1.0102888345718384,
0.21275725960731506,
0.23649774491786957,
-0.6639155149459839,
0.5433010458946228,
-0.2794734537601471,
0.44483625888824463,
-0.3762728273868561,
-0.7675213813781738,
-0.11435654014348984,
0.2621724605560303,
-0.09913395345211029,
0.03223079442977905,
0.7041881084442139,
1.0766726732254028,
0.19815579056739807,
0.1913086175918579,
0.47016823291778564,
-0.019598523154854774,
0.7461692094802856,
0.7774773836135864,
1.3524909019470215,
-0.541313886642456,
0.690338134765625,
-0.07678157836198807,
-0.39470770955085754,
0.027094541117548943,
-1.0939801931381226,
-1.0025264024734497,
-0.36607685685157776,
-0.31489649415016174,
-0.3305949866771698,
0.5908650159835815,
0.4670112729072571,
0.845228910446167,
-0.9859061241149902,
-0.37440991401672363,
-0.30635571479797363,
0.006679211277514696,
-0.3945179581642151,
-0.1969650387763977,
0.345862478017807,
-0.536573588848114,
-0.6152793169021606,
0.7074783444404602,
0.5518190264701843,
0.0373692661523819,
-0.40942806005477905,
-0.08496619760990143,
0.43588000535964966,
0.11207006126642227,
0.46896904706954956,
0.19973741471767426,
-0.5731804966926575,
-0.5863161087036133,
-0.22252391278743744,
0.1403816193342209,
-0.14082352817058563,
0.5462774038314819,
-0.4862527549266815,
0.10659245401620865,
0.5184629559516907,
0.8756853938102722,
-0.025280509144067764,
-0.21517552435398102,
0.6699981689453125,
-0.22214318811893463,
-0.020693879574537277,
0.07501636445522308,
0.6621512174606323,
0.2717125117778778,
0.04393478110432625,
0.5538651943206787,
-0.002375599229708314,
-0.5856629014015198,
-1.0628703832626343,
0.521988034248352,
-0.664121687412262,
0.22667428851127625,
0.8967463374137878,
-0.36429131031036377,
-0.02193775214254856,
-0.38193219900131226,
0.16944605112075806,
0.13888037204742432,
-0.2555689811706543,
1.001054048538208,
0.5613079071044922,
0.08710935711860657,
0.06659854203462601,
-0.7508079409599304,
0.5850988030433655,
0.5070981383323669,
-1.1419090032577515,
0.17612239718437195,
0.32489046454429626,
0.15967437624931335,
0.1745360940694809,
0.3782612085342407,
-0.7619310021400452,
0.21641193330287933,
0.09838496148586273,
-0.10196637362241745,
-0.13394616544246674,
-0.4335816204547882,
-0.3676033616065979,
0.3318750858306885,
0.07256690412759781,
-0.5381038188934326
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.01363v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.01363v1
|
Privacy in LLM-based Recommendation: Recent Advances and Future Directions
| 2024-06-03T14:31:47 | 2024-06-03T14:31:47 |
Sichun Luo, Wei Shao, Yuxuan Yao, Jian Xu, Mingyang Liu, Qintong Li, Bowei He, Maolin Wang, Guanzhi Deng, Hanxu Hou, Xinyi Zhang, Linqi Song
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IR
|
Nowadays, large language models (LLMs) have been integrated with conventional
recommendation models to improve recommendation performance. However, while
most of the existing works have focused on improving the model performance, the
privacy issue has only received comparatively less attention. In this paper, we
review recent advancements in privacy within LLM-based recommendation,
categorizing them into privacy attacks and protection mechanisms. Additionally,
we highlight several challenges and propose future directions for the community
to address these critical problems.
|
[
-0.20069535076618195,
-0.6981177926063538,
0.725165069103241,
0.007131866179406643,
0.039164017885923386,
0.14520947635173798,
-0.03615923598408699,
-1.1633720397949219,
0.20163188874721527,
1.0416535139083862,
-0.6451674103736877,
-0.7439473867416382,
-0.7023864388465881,
-0.25869113206863403,
-0.39692217111587524,
0.9978083372116089,
0.24805617332458496,
0.024985402822494507,
-0.2636137008666992,
-0.053925562649965286,
-0.4614545404911041,
-1.1799787282943726,
-0.3482415974140167,
-0.20434872806072235,
0.715632438659668,
0.27657511830329895,
0.6594247221946716,
0.5738363265991211,
0.8591458201408386,
0.40957531332969666,
-0.5824970602989197,
0.19669590890407562,
-0.38707399368286133,
0.5845827460289001,
-0.22314420342445374,
-0.4922265112400055,
-0.7390484809875488,
-0.09697391837835312,
0.743098258972168,
0.6480410695075989,
-0.15297329425811768,
0.1377442330121994,
0.027615917846560478,
0.8282447457313538,
-0.8177927136421204,
-0.0025196224451065063,
-0.24470433592796326,
0.07596500217914581,
-0.25486135482788086,
0.019518690183758736,
-0.34605103731155396,
-0.7558014988899231,
0.5716671347618103,
-0.2049408257007599,
-0.045043766498565674,
0.5846158266067505,
0.3309839069843292,
-0.07666382938623428,
-0.288887083530426,
-0.39775004982948303,
-0.9072481393814087,
0.8849315047264099,
-0.5825093388557434,
0.71207195520401,
0.7231101989746094,
0.3181777000427246,
-0.4532981216907501,
-0.749207079410553,
0.32655301690101624,
-0.4771888554096222,
0.06318699568510056,
-0.4282776713371277,
-0.44138196110725403,
-0.010517613962292671,
0.22068646550178528,
0.6444721817970276,
-0.2884500324726105,
0.4741462171077728,
-0.17330697178840637,
-0.2707216143608093,
0.8742896318435669,
0.19921517372131348,
0.010698716156184673,
0.20248591899871826,
-0.33878156542778015,
0.22267980873584747,
-0.814804196357727,
0.0425032414495945,
0.7159730792045593,
-0.018180320039391518,
-0.15415216982364655,
0.6794906258583069,
-0.3535015881061554,
0.7262007594108582,
0.09663908183574677,
-0.1275397539138794,
-0.13521741330623627,
-0.29091358184814453,
-0.17782631516456604,
0.14612576365470886,
0.6081247329711914,
0.48433786630630493,
0.4450709819793701,
-0.2140231430530548,
0.04376224800944328,
-0.4335092008113861,
0.012081746943295002,
-0.6091521382331848,
-0.06974823027849197,
0.2906484603881836,
-0.6420432329177856,
-0.48996537923812866,
0.2548617422580719,
-0.8223409652709961,
-1.0372676849365234,
0.1089433953166008,
-0.05622508004307747,
0.06579117476940155,
-0.1540144979953766,
0.22238589823246002,
0.05186862125992775,
-0.08252078294754028,
0.3693867027759552,
-0.9987075924873352,
0.6009241938591003,
0.9719492197036743,
0.643803596496582,
-0.25053197145462036,
-0.1241379976272583,
-0.3626859486103058,
0.45159679651260376,
-0.09181802719831467,
0.7459800839424133,
-0.6263166069984436,
-0.7934244871139526,
0.3243786692619324,
0.26088395714759827,
0.2740091383457184,
-0.6584293246269226,
0.041269440203905106,
-0.556821882724762,
0.23449839651584625,
-0.49705320596694946,
-0.7302318811416626,
-0.28363147377967834,
0.37180399894714355,
-0.37765806913375854,
0.511332631111145,
-0.16653557121753693,
-0.7950599789619446,
0.10006792098283768,
-0.7630131840705872,
-0.2959096431732178,
0.036262281239032745,
0.24127504229545593,
-0.3011018931865692,
0.010742700658738613,
0.13982249796390533,
0.5826531648635864,
-0.08446097373962402,
0.199591264128685,
-0.6798831224441528,
-0.6060138940811157,
0.7318633198738098,
-0.37305116653442383,
0.5554148554801941,
0.30608847737312317,
-0.09760066121816635,
0.29193243384361267,
-0.6783222556114197,
-0.22152526676654816,
-0.2515262961387634,
-0.012069067917764187,
-0.1567760854959488,
0.029886187985539436,
-0.23377598822116852,
-0.35349392890930176,
0.9287591576576233,
-0.4620945155620575,
-0.13232354819774628,
-0.5340483784675598,
0.661217987537384,
1.0035688877105713,
0.28128141164779663,
0.9209151864051819,
-0.31354576349258423,
0.5840797424316406,
-0.1979895532131195,
0.5146879553794861,
-0.07679589092731476,
-0.7250968813896179,
-0.2923688292503357,
-0.014719958417117596,
0.38553687930107117,
0.44020769000053406,
0.1294163316488266,
0.45361360907554626,
0.24252867698669434,
-0.34479737281799316,
-0.1622462123632431,
0.051194366067647934,
0.20470060408115387,
-0.2822752594947815,
-0.13776811957359314,
-0.3568282127380371,
-0.39281368255615234,
-0.8768108487129211,
-0.5321751832962036,
-0.16173675656318665,
0.377015620470047,
0.7062591314315796,
-0.16797566413879395,
-0.49598339200019836,
0.46623748540878296,
-0.707507312297821,
-0.3769027888774872,
-0.14518144726753235,
-0.5817119479179382,
0.051231708377599716,
0.5390649437904358,
0.2837061583995819,
-0.6064165830612183,
-0.381401389837265,
0.0027694276068359613,
-0.4800185263156891,
0.05742841213941574,
0.5673883557319641,
0.040365416556596756,
0.0011667588260024786,
0.562559962272644,
-0.30843228101730347,
0.2823273837566376,
0.708983302116394,
-0.3945137858390808,
0.1220090389251709,
-0.39816758036613464,
-0.1979091465473175,
-0.8379151225090027,
-0.5397246479988098,
0.0475102923810482,
-0.5663646459579468,
-0.560391902923584,
0.10394217073917389,
-0.19837243854999542,
-0.25592663884162903,
-0.6319220662117004,
0.7227760553359985,
-0.38048312067985535,
-0.18757441639900208,
-0.5667515993118286,
-0.0163789801299572,
-0.28281983733177185,
0.10693598538637161,
-0.3343532681465149,
0.4300535023212433,
0.8423945307731628,
-0.5817665457725525,
0.6274974942207336,
-0.005811696406453848,
-0.18965236842632294,
0.446437805891037,
-0.33327481150627136,
0.5679085850715637,
0.24188661575317383,
0.3018946945667267,
-0.6915212273597717,
-0.4376375079154968,
0.655504047870636,
-0.17304515838623047,
0.33073562383651733,
-0.18472982943058014,
-0.5066273808479309,
-0.10190580785274506,
-0.7473947405815125,
0.49294334650039673,
0.39221757650375366,
-0.5095027685165405,
0.5135492086410522,
0.5402371287345886,
-0.2717652916908264,
-0.8229992985725403,
-0.6182786226272583,
0.2881365120410919,
-0.2738037407398224,
-0.5871127843856812,
0.24427072703838348,
-0.26812082529067993,
-0.7677112817764282,
0.001292056287638843,
-0.02982105128467083,
-0.12516073882579803,
0.3772261142730713,
0.6923539042472839,
0.12033641338348389,
0.1447286605834961,
-0.3613767921924591,
-0.2849702835083008,
-0.2500081956386566,
0.16820493340492249,
-0.4188212454319,
0.44728225469589233,
-0.17293734848499298,
-0.14729760587215424,
-0.6175799369812012,
0.5035614967346191,
0.24841712415218353,
-0.24284400045871735,
0.7651737928390503,
0.44852590560913086,
-0.21248884499073029,
-0.08121825009584427,
-0.9519205093383789,
-0.18772122263908386,
-0.5690998435020447,
0.342134952545166,
0.22503487765789032,
-1.5633341073989868,
0.2731306552886963,
-0.15786387026309967,
0.06749933958053589,
-0.14193184673786163,
0.6356809735298157,
-0.20037654042243958,
0.7913002371788025,
1.2096192836761475,
-0.2981815040111542,
0.890227198600769,
0.14104150235652924,
0.44495609402656555,
-0.8167166113853455,
-0.40612682700157166,
-0.322848379611969,
-0.17135179042816162,
-1.3699537515640259,
0.09053907543420792,
-0.018801197409629822,
-0.2520838975906372,
0.03542047366499901,
0.2437659054994583,
-0.43120262026786804,
0.5334212779998779,
0.6598859429359436,
0.21982312202453613,
0.592707633972168,
-0.38170966506004333,
0.3916347920894623,
0.15891003608703613,
-0.33971336483955383,
-0.3843887150287628,
1.022327184677124,
0.6021737456321716,
0.966334342956543,
0.2954985797405243,
0.7855042219161987,
0.47689634561538696,
0.21325357258319855,
-0.4987841546535492,
0.8460310101509094,
-0.17105086147785187,
-0.7499037384986877,
-0.15102796256542206,
-0.10417139530181885,
-0.9108765721321106,
0.14448268711566925,
-0.10399143397808075,
-1.3067667484283447,
0.48027971386909485,
-0.1468406617641449,
-0.29765158891677856,
0.2893041968345642,
-0.5209543108940125,
0.34819555282592773,
-0.13897234201431274,
-0.572166383266449,
-0.13054488599300385,
-0.5576853156089783,
0.47006744146347046,
-0.2598803639411926,
0.3609251081943512,
-0.222438246011734,
0.12396693229675293,
0.785545825958252,
-0.262563556432724,
0.7895225286483765,
-0.18041430413722992,
-0.28957781195640564,
-0.021571172401309013,
0.04245315119624138,
0.8651648759841919,
0.22133199870586395,
-0.12323900312185287,
0.31289201974868774,
0.1732534021139145,
0.04108929634094238,
-0.16590140759944916,
1.1893514394760132,
-0.38418421149253845,
-1.1209428310394287,
-0.4489944875240326,
-0.7636498808860779,
-0.28940799832344055,
0.15224918723106384,
0.05220535025000572,
0.10706748068332672,
-0.16277794539928436,
0.4776293933391571,
0.8784357905387878,
-0.6366212964057922,
0.5727380514144897,
0.5820500254631042,
-0.5437126755714417,
-0.5742500424385071,
0.7014703154563904,
0.2098170816898346,
-0.21782411634922028,
0.11549431830644608,
0.24696315824985504,
-0.5430156588554382,
-0.9501538872718811,
0.03543580695986748,
0.32478752732276917,
-0.707420825958252,
0.061233945190906525,
-0.7119606733322144,
-0.17402251064777374,
-0.4834372103214264,
-0.11477266997098923,
-0.1252259910106659,
-0.25488919019699097,
-0.11756690591573715,
-0.2938857972621918,
0.5354567170143127,
1.0167365074157715,
0.033414117991924286,
0.46733203530311584,
-0.6076624989509583,
0.14895883202552795,
0.0879555344581604,
0.7933750748634338,
-0.05336063355207443,
-0.28273671865463257,
-0.44479626417160034,
-0.5708518028259277,
-0.1344883143901825,
-0.4833754897117615,
0.13082046806812286,
-0.3021450340747833,
0.3450070321559906,
0.5103172063827515,
-0.08420252054929733,
0.21795222163200378,
-0.4808565676212311,
1.016772985458374,
-0.06698822230100632,
-0.5112103223800659,
0.3631557524204254,
-0.2772238552570343,
-0.06807634979486465,
0.21750393509864807,
-0.06539057940244675,
-0.3191821873188019,
-0.38265180587768555,
-0.6188216805458069,
-0.6325861811637878,
0.49433353543281555,
-0.009384142234921455,
0.48145660758018494,
0.39838677644729614,
0.43231937289237976,
0.1328895539045334,
0.425342857837677,
-0.675386369228363,
-0.3710455894470215,
0.4825519919395447,
0.23549309372901917,
-0.27713242173194885,
-0.7172554135322571,
-0.057408709079027176,
-0.2285391390323639,
0.3758217692375183,
0.6403936743736267,
0.09970281273126602,
-0.21602307260036469,
0.35039132833480835,
-0.11233781278133392,
0.3912290930747986,
0.5339198708534241,
0.515139102935791,
-0.3882735073566437,
-0.2707156538963318,
0.07426922768354416,
-0.33825746178627014,
0.280583918094635,
0.2885623872280121,
-0.11329450458288193,
-0.2627107501029968,
0.033337924629449844,
0.428220272064209,
0.32387059926986694,
-0.30362844467163086,
0.5100582242012024,
-0.06702238321304321,
-0.3633301854133606,
-0.6502323150634766,
0.31257933378219604,
0.1308918446302414,
0.5048702359199524,
-0.14365795254707336,
-0.07946070283651352,
0.3199900984764099,
-0.5742238759994507,
-0.08854351192712784,
0.6509348750114441,
-0.5200384259223938,
-0.010678937658667564,
0.6867436170578003,
0.07087542861700058,
-0.6964311599731445,
0.08416193723678589,
0.6021731495857239,
-0.2091435343027115,
0.11787795275449753,
0.4013194739818573,
1.1553599834442139,
-0.3715202212333679,
-0.20150558650493622,
-0.47109025716781616,
0.10702642053365707,
-0.34169718623161316,
0.21450908482074738,
-0.4244840145111084,
-0.5609360337257385,
0.06993556767702103,
-0.49200597405433655,
-1.067236304283142,
-0.01984136924147606,
-0.6402417421340942,
-0.021842410787940025,
-1.0552685260772705,
-0.4827301502227783,
-0.2839801609516144,
0.3004109859466553,
-0.2910822331905365,
-0.013666932471096516,
0.2930142283439636,
0.428677499294281,
0.017843274399638176,
0.9586265683174133,
0.6783972978591919,
0.18019041419029236,
-0.1679299771785736,
-0.0957731083035469,
0.0031469506211578846,
-0.4779270589351654,
0.24715130031108856,
0.06552086770534515,
-0.4966321587562561,
-0.2541499733924866,
-0.5446855425834656,
-0.7461757063865662,
0.9471510052680969,
0.2757430076599121,
-0.9928609132766724,
0.10477367788553238,
0.38450369238853455,
0.6595029830932617,
-0.13822683691978455,
-0.3376358449459076,
0.20410799980163574,
0.7052691578865051,
-0.3649115562438965,
-0.6048339009284973,
-0.08916191011667252,
0.13548119366168976,
0.050739653408527374,
0.06373324990272522,
-1.0177538394927979,
0.6525881886482239,
0.07953279465436935,
0.06731585413217545,
0.19341930747032166,
0.599044919013977,
0.2076524943113327,
0.7260879874229431,
0.14488279819488525,
0.17944467067718506,
1.0525630712509155,
0.22804786264896393,
1.301853895187378,
-0.19086459279060364,
0.07068784534931183,
1.1272567510604858,
-0.8012906312942505,
0.5652161240577698,
0.2138396054506302,
-0.132784903049469,
0.5157708525657654,
0.8519169688224792,
-0.3746027648448944,
0.7130084037780762,
0.31761837005615234,
-0.40905946493148804,
0.04344275966286659,
-0.39748451113700867,
-0.6423290371894836,
0.10996878147125244,
0.1510162055492401,
-0.7316077947616577,
0.12899693846702576,
0.009859523735940456,
-0.02793245203793049,
0.06648087501525879,
-0.3130172789096832,
0.9593620896339417,
0.439842164516449,
-0.23823460936546326,
-0.0701284259557724,
0.4037953317165375,
0.9273820519447327,
-0.6849279403686523,
0.05013873428106308,
-0.059228233993053436,
0.28229793906211853,
-0.31248965859413147,
-0.6659316420555115,
0.1114727035164833,
0.11949808150529861,
-0.3774647116661072,
-0.1276165097951889,
0.9631462693214417,
-0.057766206562519073,
-0.296477735042572,
0.6028833985328674,
0.38518115878105164,
0.1827177256345749,
-0.15475407242774963,
-0.5764827728271484,
0.08850979059934616,
-0.18629159033298492,
-0.1413397639989853,
0.7293326258659363,
0.13371601700782776,
-0.13295361399650574,
0.9507368206977844,
0.8545461297035217,
0.18088261783123016,
0.19885173439979553,
-0.000014725540495419409,
0.5988575220108032,
-0.8933269381523132,
-0.7071851491928101,
-1.215060830116272,
-0.27428171038627625,
0.04023227468132973,
0.0090710474178195,
1.080088496208191,
0.2107560634613037,
0.7788991928100586,
0.27250656485557556,
0.60493403673172,
0.6083129644393921,
0.5898397564888,
-0.51157146692276,
0.8459981679916382,
-0.15762686729431152,
0.9805927276611328,
-0.13646844029426575,
-1.128003716468811,
-0.323681503534317,
0.054229166358709335,
-0.5272741913795471,
0.19471809267997742,
0.5305089354515076,
0.8978999853134155,
0.35805532336235046,
0.1889881193637848,
0.40698036551475525,
0.10636001825332642,
0.36592456698417664,
0.2841421663761139,
1.1096864938735962,
-0.07294965535402298,
0.1577746570110321,
-0.40620774030685425,
0.18471361696720123,
-0.33729174733161926,
-0.7967808842658997,
-0.9584094285964966,
-0.09764157235622406,
-0.2877565026283264,
-0.2827344834804535,
0.4934830665588379,
0.7926067113876343,
0.6825109720230103,
-0.9044182896614075,
-0.3746185302734375,
0.16296006739139557,
0.3781488239765167,
-0.06679414957761765,
-0.13539615273475647,
0.2794409692287445,
0.4027450978755951,
-0.6918050050735474,
0.7685346007347107,
0.5974165201187134,
0.12752439081668854,
-0.5052841305732727,
0.16720183193683624,
-0.00131329579744488,
0.08462841808795929,
0.4924998879432678,
0.07621379941701889,
-0.7960759401321411,
-0.13005883991718292,
-0.2451125532388687,
0.07820045948028564,
0.00010444223880767822,
0.7544326782226562,
-0.32521459460258484,
0.23431627452373505,
0.17222081124782562,
0.5610215663909912,
0.5084949135780334,
0.19910743832588196,
0.7306172251701355,
-0.37394100427627563,
0.08723725378513336,
0.022872285917401314,
0.3602403998374939,
0.3621045649051666,
-0.8362160921096802,
0.33477410674095154,
-0.10886023938655853,
-0.7425822019577026,
-1.1392806768417358,
0.2829323410987854,
-0.905986487865448,
-0.3093355596065521,
1.1769939661026,
-0.2077743262052536,
-0.24537216126918793,
-0.48254531621932983,
-0.18448424339294434,
-0.25302281975746155,
-0.47877877950668335,
0.6263605356216431,
0.8014216423034668,
-0.10498204082250595,
-0.1842469871044159,
-0.44227489829063416,
0.45814260840415955,
0.14996527135372162,
-0.4591841697692871,
0.3156445324420929,
0.296994149684906,
0.38309839367866516,
-0.30401524901390076,
0.5799001455307007,
-0.53976970911026,
0.05284051224589348,
-0.5919560194015503,
-0.636651337146759,
-0.34398213028907776,
-0.4631233811378479,
-0.5668386220932007,
0.41765573620796204,
0.4637983739376068,
-0.19604317843914032
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.01359v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.01359v2
|
R2C2-Coder: Enhancing and Benchmarking Real-world Repository-level Code Completion Abilities of Code Large Language Models
| 2024-06-03T14:24:29 | 2024-06-04T03:13:43 |
Ken Deng, Jiaheng Liu, He Zhu, Congnan Liu, Jingxin Li, Jiakai Wang, Peng Zhao, Chenchen Zhang, Yanan Wu, Xueqiao Yin, Yuanxing Zhang, Wenbo Su, Bangyu Xiang, Tiezheng Ge, Bo Zheng
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SE
|
Code completion models have made significant progress in recent years.
Recently, repository-level code completion has drawn more attention in modern
software development, and several baseline methods and benchmarks have been
proposed. However, existing repository-level code completion methods often fall
short of fully using the extensive context of a project repository, such as the
intricacies of relevant files and class hierarchies. Besides, the existing
benchmarks usually focus on limited code completion scenarios, which cannot
reflect the repository-level code completion abilities well of existing
methods. To address these limitations, we propose the R2C2-Coder to enhance and
benchmark the real-world repository-level code completion abilities of code
Large Language Models, where the R2C2-Coder includes a code prompt construction
method R2C2-Enhance and a well-designed benchmark R2C2-Bench. Specifically,
first, in R2C2-Enhance, we first construct the candidate retrieval pool and
then assemble the completion prompt by retrieving from the retrieval pool for
each completion cursor position. Second, based on R2C2 -Enhance, we can
construct a more challenging and diverse R2C2-Bench with training, validation
and test splits, where a context perturbation strategy is proposed to simulate
the real-world repository-level code completion well. Extensive results on
multiple benchmarks demonstrate the effectiveness of our R2C2-Coder.
|
[
-0.4664231240749359,
-0.5234338045120239,
0.2262284904718399,
0.1890273243188858,
-0.21570149064064026,
0.4132685661315918,
-0.4291520118713379,
-0.7344959378242493,
-0.19804927706718445,
0.4104312062263489,
-0.3026776909828186,
-0.28140050172805786,
-0.4227738082408905,
0.1690184473991394,
-0.1812528818845749,
0.6303468346595764,
-0.09169309586286545,
0.09468475729227066,
-0.28819188475608826,
0.00022199584054760635,
-0.9776232242584229,
-0.39848271012306213,
-0.24011631309986115,
-0.18597358465194702,
0.3828643560409546,
0.8745661377906799,
0.41577768325805664,
0.7298812866210938,
0.576104462146759,
0.1273244470357895,
-0.07035112380981445,
0.17366592586040497,
-0.3952762186527252,
0.4782705307006836,
0.04298153147101402,
-0.4654000699520111,
-0.3990148603916168,
-0.0922040194272995,
0.48426756262779236,
0.2280993014574051,
-0.04647553712129593,
0.2172141969203949,
0.19634495675563812,
0.675186038017273,
-0.9489176273345947,
0.12202998250722885,
-0.3290855288505554,
0.18526999652385712,
0.2074301838874817,
-0.3006128966808319,
-0.5101578235626221,
-0.3735082745552063,
0.02911682240664959,
-0.28433462977409363,
0.14083419740200043,
-0.1206430196762085,
0.6163740158081055,
0.3223731815814972,
-0.5047523379325867,
-0.24317330121994019,
-0.5612415075302124,
0.493034690618515,
-0.4501982033252716,
0.335612416267395,
0.37040695548057556,
0.42318156361579895,
0.1302414834499359,
-0.8258295655250549,
-0.1425722986459732,
-0.5805859565734863,
-0.3552877902984619,
0.0913136750459671,
0.23601476848125458,
-0.0567643903195858,
0.8435437679290771,
0.20268875360488892,
-0.663223147392273,
-0.030006427317857742,
-0.2858799993991852,
-0.13655804097652435,
0.2378808706998825,
0.028025440871715546,
0.24106131494045258,
-0.20969630777835846,
-0.4408784508705139,
-0.29503312706947327,
-0.6934424042701721,
0.2765333354473114,
0.16904868185520172,
0.1655491590499878,
-0.056619204580783844,
0.5506258010864258,
-0.3337644636631012,
0.6540412306785583,
-0.3611629605293274,
0.21313436329364777,
0.2221832275390625,
-0.4549406170845032,
0.2556267976760864,
-0.2822059392929077,
0.14858217537403107,
0.3712614178657532,
0.2718971073627472,
-0.08101043850183487,
-0.3413997292518616,
0.007924763485789299,
0.32668691873550415,
-1.1059045791625977,
-0.3381275236606598,
0.47539809346199036,
-0.4826701283454895,
-0.01788146235048771,
0.14846527576446533,
-0.793965756893158,
-0.41894516348838806,
-0.32823076844215393,
-0.025473779067397118,
-0.23893752694129944,
-0.45095598697662354,
-0.3140529990196228,
-0.2929486036300659,
0.44048285484313965,
0.23666448891162872,
-0.3936135470867157,
0.1905450075864792,
0.9609231948852539,
0.7503679394721985,
-0.10988257080316544,
-0.38182011246681213,
-0.9800247550010681,
0.04004574939608574,
-0.21777433156967163,
0.9554703235626221,
-0.6604030728340149,
-0.41023680567741394,
0.34052950143814087,
-0.2887296676635742,
0.398124635219574,
-0.8675746321678162,
0.3586917221546173,
-0.5420976877212524,
-0.0550663024187088,
-0.2877958416938782,
-0.5033298134803772,
0.14453057944774628,
0.4161936044692993,
-0.48708823323249817,
1.3026005029678345,
0.40450960397720337,
-0.6315595507621765,
0.31897810101509094,
-0.31257742643356323,
-0.387165367603302,
0.25669190287590027,
-0.3487480580806732,
-0.29353559017181396,
0.06745322048664093,
-0.06066954880952835,
0.15539582073688507,
-0.3571692407131195,
0.15012027323246002,
-0.1272079050540924,
-0.739352285861969,
0.14670272171497345,
0.07752934098243713,
0.4261144697666168,
0.21574155986309052,
-0.427617609500885,
-0.06261755526065826,
-0.70368891954422,
0.35880371928215027,
-0.2322489619255066,
-0.49005329608917236,
-0.09906311333179474,
-0.13168738782405853,
0.49101367592811584,
0.35695648193359375,
0.3331288695335388,
-0.11380457133054733,
0.4038078784942627,
-0.20528781414031982,
0.3964460492134094,
0.1900021731853485,
0.05519117787480354,
0.6232014298439026,
-0.1512901782989502,
0.7089657783508301,
-0.22821807861328125,
0.10234527289867401,
-0.2539547383785248,
-0.1778642237186432,
-0.5590483546257019,
-0.45978328585624695,
0.5433961153030396,
1.0114485025405884,
-0.6177451014518738,
0.5501996874809265,
-0.15312308073043823,
-0.49572229385375977,
-0.05895078554749489,
0.1133582815527916,
0.9116079211235046,
0.31678739190101624,
0.540742814540863,
-0.5466631650924683,
-0.7026597261428833,
-0.7400640845298767,
-0.3236905634403229,
-0.17710983753204346,
-0.3169609308242798,
0.506790041923523,
0.47805777192115784,
-0.13826222717761993,
1.0284533500671387,
-0.6345216035842896,
-0.2602114975452423,
-0.1752292513847351,
-0.13330090045928955,
0.06134665757417679,
0.8564735651016235,
0.2744995951652527,
-0.8192189931869507,
-0.3539305329322815,
-0.21160848438739777,
-0.7113861441612244,
0.01185785885900259,
0.027948278933763504,
0.13148607313632965,
0.09594666957855225,
0.7197661399841309,
-0.3624647259712219,
0.38287320733070374,
0.34338802099227905,
-0.35863834619522095,
0.6027235388755798,
-0.4403906762599945,
0.3137301802635193,
-0.8447526097297668,
0.27134212851524353,
-0.26667165756225586,
-0.12783470749855042,
-0.4428798258304596,
0.5115759968757629,
0.6671236157417297,
-0.2882949709892273,
-0.3710106909275055,
0.6080422401428223,
-0.8079771399497986,
-0.4050183594226837,
-0.3233417868614197,
0.20392850041389465,
-0.06776414066553116,
0.38087892532348633,
0.057583265006542206,
1.0244795083999634,
0.42533326148986816,
-0.3887389600276947,
0.2814476191997528,
0.19901178777217865,
-0.5757614970207214,
0.411384254693985,
-0.919647216796875,
0.2334442138671875,
0.01939886063337326,
0.5883122086524963,
-1.1781526803970337,
-0.25448358058929443,
-0.05412483215332031,
-0.5544164180755615,
0.5018892288208008,
-0.7049140334129333,
-0.5741757750511169,
-0.3314412832260132,
-0.1910334825515747,
0.6797736883163452,
0.8179632425308228,
-0.6029978394508362,
0.5247800350189209,
-0.029443850740790367,
-0.17249226570129395,
-0.662560760974884,
-0.823007345199585,
0.42348140478134155,
0.026825034990906715,
-0.45716771483421326,
0.2604143023490906,
-0.13443385064601898,
-0.1203952208161354,
-0.42950576543807983,
-0.1824922412633896,
-0.10854522138834,
0.1523473709821701,
0.40855899453163147,
0.4486238360404968,
-0.025127407163381577,
-0.24339258670806885,
-0.03915276378393173,
-0.5130335688591003,
0.005434305872768164,
-0.23711246252059937,
0.41946473717689514,
0.18895094096660614,
-0.24896195530891418,
-0.4353034794330597,
0.43491050601005554,
0.13355796039104462,
-0.5660711526870728,
0.28061461448669434,
0.23166511952877045,
-0.30822446942329407,
-0.24840469658374786,
-0.8177089095115662,
-0.41220349073410034,
-0.41357365250587463,
0.6004194021224976,
-0.6152298450469971,
-1.072561264038086,
0.5382915735244751,
-0.21597176790237427,
-0.012558202259242535,
-0.23738515377044678,
0.2759222984313965,
0.2677030861377716,
0.8137894868850708,
0.33801019191741943,
0.2426816076040268,
0.7922593355178833,
-0.5110464096069336,
-0.05309459567070007,
-1.026868462562561,
-0.3078102469444275,
-1.0062323808670044,
-0.035654615610837936,
-0.4655269980430603,
-0.706864595413208,
0.11614498496055603,
0.5453347563743591,
-0.3326480984687805,
0.9304227828979492,
-0.6643493175506592,
0.7305594682693481,
0.41637885570526123,
0.333559513092041,
0.1267109215259552,
0.03313939645886421,
0.04808763414621353,
0.049211714416742325,
-0.4602838456630707,
-0.380470871925354,
0.7432155013084412,
0.38092684745788574,
0.3601459860801697,
0.2056480497121811,
0.6154534220695496,
0.41211387515068054,
0.130660742521286,
-0.6264697909355164,
0.40058937668800354,
0.17846235632896423,
-0.47312429547309875,
0.09705859422683716,
-0.42835429310798645,
-0.39072734117507935,
0.12956379354000092,
-0.06136485934257507,
-0.5228251814842224,
0.41208624839782715,
0.35082733631134033,
-0.22476224601268768,
-0.33703386783599854,
-0.7007863521575928,
0.9131196737289429,
0.16124647855758667,
-0.5103381872177124,
-0.38082659244537354,
-0.769512414932251,
0.118379607796669,
0.2553464472293854,
0.23621967434883118,
0.21281921863555908,
-0.5827205181121826,
0.230059415102005,
-0.3305133283138275,
0.44566595554351807,
-0.6080943942070007,
-0.2649533450603485,
0.26419082283973694,
0.3462851047515869,
1.0052071809768677,
0.6762622594833374,
-0.16571573913097382,
-0.12139683961868286,
-0.2329976111650467,
-0.6762651205062866,
-0.6606088876724243,
0.6834411025047302,
-0.6328049898147583,
-0.3398197591304779,
-0.10348784178495407,
-0.29451993107795715,
-0.36239713430404663,
0.020102212205529213,
0.17313654720783234,
0.9648093581199646,
0.09768737852573395,
0.18775075674057007,
0.6970544457435608,
-0.20054589211940765,
0.390790194272995,
0.42165085673332214,
0.13194885849952698,
-0.7214328646659851,
0.637613832950592,
-0.1303519755601883,
0.39307767152786255,
0.540219783782959,
-0.3011557161808014,
-0.38488277792930603,
-0.6973364353179932,
-0.4503673315048218,
-0.14498163759708405,
-0.7390783429145813,
-0.527474582195282,
-0.8019368648529053,
-0.10111164301633835,
-0.4241659641265869,
-0.34139126539230347,
-0.2770923972129822,
-0.3864884078502655,
-0.04620908573269844,
0.12028581649065018,
0.26251450181007385,
0.36822348833084106,
-0.0039122807793319225,
-0.06516847759485245,
-0.8769659996032715,
0.2516360580921173,
0.3243298828601837,
0.6291963458061218,
0.11432896554470062,
-0.5855817794799805,
-0.27694466710090637,
-0.2085217833518982,
0.15637966990470886,
-0.5052831768989563,
-0.09182875603437424,
-0.23409314453601837,
0.3987483084201813,
-0.04673592373728752,
0.02324603870511055,
0.5786293148994446,
-0.4704493284225464,
0.7342472076416016,
0.13040457665920258,
-0.7240866422653198,
0.7993699312210083,
-0.32151511311531067,
0.3607437312602997,
0.9103240966796875,
-0.23637433350086212,
-0.2934533357620239,
-0.449888676404953,
-0.3396289348602295,
-1.0615812540054321,
0.5930689573287964,
0.24175414443016052,
0.052978698164224625,
-0.0870615541934967,
0.6675699949264526,
-0.16742831468582153,
-0.15399670600891113,
-0.4503653943538666,
-0.22801072895526886,
-0.23801952600479126,
0.3055157959461212,
0.0317123681306839,
-0.6292599439620972,
0.10543660819530487,
0.12995289266109467,
0.5955826640129089,
-0.17106157541275024,
0.17591595649719238,
0.32504552602767944,
-0.3690209686756134,
0.05056421458721161,
0.4106996953487396,
0.692827045917511,
0.8000437021255493,
-0.311707466840744,
-0.05926050618290901,
0.2566336989402771,
-0.39546868205070496,
0.0714106634259224,
0.1941356360912323,
-0.06353888660669327,
-0.2092932164669037,
0.50064617395401,
0.4434807300567627,
0.2538086473941803,
-0.9487245678901672,
0.5832561254501343,
-0.2621423900127411,
0.014559517614543438,
-0.4564906656742096,
0.31299179792404175,
0.03669820353388786,
0.41031235456466675,
0.6011695861816406,
0.19028472900390625,
0.28282687067985535,
-0.5157965421676636,
0.3250170946121216,
0.18853822350502014,
-0.6472516059875488,
0.32531511783599854,
0.47942784428596497,
0.2521556615829468,
-0.5434189438819885,
0.7440555691719055,
-0.20471224188804626,
-0.4939810335636139,
1.0690124034881592,
0.4891895353794098,
0.7622039914131165,
0.24080890417099,
-0.2856138348579407,
0.9228127002716064,
-0.05815527215600014,
-0.3824447989463806,
0.5160568356513977,
-0.36834320425987244,
-0.14464104175567627,
-0.6162170171737671,
-0.2576823830604553,
-0.3428365886211395,
-0.5061688423156738,
-0.9577293395996094,
0.45150208473205566,
-0.3779290020465851,
0.05036593973636627,
-0.47389596700668335,
0.46275126934051514,
-0.3861635625362396,
0.11313745379447937,
-0.07302465289831161,
1.527604103088379,
-0.31947100162506104,
0.9495954513549805,
0.7659498453140259,
-0.4068043828010559,
-0.8041982650756836,
0.07447639107704163,
-0.12966175377368927,
-0.4652429521083832,
0.3941602110862732,
0.39655929803848267,
0.11499045789241791,
0.07538814097642899,
-0.3488520383834839,
-0.5359891057014465,
1.3408375978469849,
-0.00782750453799963,
-0.7363221049308777,
0.06768740713596344,
-0.24239273369312286,
0.5003947019577026,
-0.4792843461036682,
0.6206167936325073,
0.34729018807411194,
0.558182418346405,
0.2305043637752533,
-0.7334967851638794,
0.2977089285850525,
-0.3149455189704895,
0.6381027102470398,
0.23779229819774628,
-0.48358240723609924,
0.3794114887714386,
-0.4782819449901581,
0.007269273046404123,
0.7631640434265137,
0.7888168692588806,
0.6508452892303467,
0.029679985716938972,
0.48648762702941895,
0.21405406296253204,
0.2971494793891907,
-0.08692701160907745,
0.9286242127418518,
-0.6435071229934692,
0.5678994059562683,
1.2793078422546387,
-0.37337568402290344,
1.0417876243591309,
0.23308144509792328,
-0.08732083439826965,
0.5126964449882507,
0.4187292754650116,
-0.27728694677352905,
0.3685551881790161,
0.4691930115222931,
-0.17665638029575348,
-0.2986319363117218,
-0.33135080337524414,
-0.7970966696739197,
0.17435820400714874,
0.0215804111212492,
-0.0294919703155756,
0.15358814597129822,
-0.17611703276634216,
-0.14425835013389587,
0.3736373782157898,
0.021230654790997505,
0.8139827847480774,
-0.11604012548923492,
-1.0411213636398315,
0.5247721672058105,
-0.1476428061723709,
0.7542099356651306,
-0.43490439653396606,
-0.21832045912742615,
-0.5743416547775269,
0.33118778467178345,
-0.2673243284225464,
-0.6750806570053101,
0.14453716576099396,
0.03351762890815735,
-0.3885832130908966,
-0.26404646039009094,
0.6582234501838684,
-0.4900586009025574,
-0.03881968557834625,
0.5997031331062317,
0.3309420347213745,
-0.1256583333015442,
-0.0032692370004951954,
-0.54911208152771,
0.12737658619880676,
-0.14414583146572113,
-0.11167801171541214,
0.44791972637176514,
0.15449798107147217,
0.27777916193008423,
0.3499956727027893,
0.3542693257331848,
-0.034202657639980316,
-0.5126341581344604,
0.3410714268684387,
0.7860473394393921,
-0.8303172588348389,
-0.2828719913959503,
-0.4900774359703064,
0.5476825833320618,
-0.2263171225786209,
-0.26506832242012024,
0.38203176856040955,
1.118752360343933,
0.8236016035079956,
-0.11178205907344818,
0.6133747696876526,
-0.5102579593658447,
0.5979316830635071,
-0.4003145098686218,
0.47263285517692566,
-0.47156932950019836,
0.3895130157470703,
-0.2170233428478241,
-1.1923248767852783,
-0.34318816661834717,
0.41273537278175354,
0.17230145633220673,
0.20165883004665375,
0.6983338594436646,
1.215783953666687,
0.09071892499923706,
-0.16668154299259186,
0.17567598819732666,
0.052835121750831604,
0.2010984718799591,
0.6361347436904907,
1.0660152435302734,
-0.6313204765319824,
0.8120895028114319,
-0.17703300714492798,
-0.5614842772483826,
-0.14074310660362244,
-0.8144758939743042,
-0.8638554215431213,
-0.3670758306980133,
-0.4183565080165863,
-0.8652166724205017,
0.20249846577644348,
1.0944474935531616,
0.8204300999641418,
-0.8239731192588806,
-0.2520575225353241,
-0.12761060893535614,
0.02082023024559021,
-0.35322245955467224,
-0.20818449556827545,
0.10662595182657242,
-0.6003570556640625,
-0.45584195852279663,
0.3601245880126953,
0.3662665784358978,
-0.12556396424770355,
-0.06241113692522049,
-0.24767452478408813,
-0.08377125859260559,
-0.5042610168457031,
0.42157161235809326,
0.34886762499809265,
-0.49656733870506287,
-0.23875568807125092,
0.07120498269796371,
-0.39474135637283325,
0.10131089389324188,
1.2939913272857666,
-0.9668545126914978,
0.061684947460889816,
0.6645849347114563,
0.5042492151260376,
0.1801512986421585,
0.05188440904021263,
0.439126580953598,
-0.6525353789329529,
0.20315022766590118,
0.15902839601039886,
0.2263934165239334,
0.12075785547494888,
-0.27614742517471313,
0.8392753601074219,
0.05520854890346527,
-0.5697938799858093,
-0.9231755137443542,
0.32820549607276917,
-1.0128785371780396,
-0.3779561221599579,
1.3416661024093628,
-0.20892100036144257,
0.31529340147972107,
-0.23711274564266205,
-0.33376142382621765,
0.18688376247882843,
-0.5056925415992737,
0.5798224806785583,
0.2525552809238434,
0.14101263880729675,
-0.15684454143047333,
-0.6467289924621582,
0.6033086180686951,
0.3024580776691437,
-0.8674736022949219,
0.4435510039329529,
0.8077431321144104,
0.3091670870780945,
0.0023364939261227846,
0.5162088871002197,
-0.21653036773204803,
0.7380405068397522,
-0.04465364292263985,
0.07407725602388382,
-0.09908660501241684,
-0.4655431807041168,
-0.3133699297904968,
0.39058253169059753,
0.38365837931632996,
0.3419177234172821
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.01333v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.01333v1
|
Probing Language Models for Pre-training Data Detection
| 2024-06-03T13:58:04 | 2024-06-03T13:58:04 |
Zhenhua Liu, Tong Zhu, Chuanyuan Tan, Haonan Lu, Bing Liu, Wenliang Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have shown their impressive capabilities, while
also raising concerns about the data contamination problems due to privacy
issues and leakage of benchmark datasets in the pre-training phase. Therefore,
it is vital to detect the contamination by checking whether an LLM has been
pre-trained on the target texts. Recent studies focus on the generated texts
and compute perplexities, which are superficial features and not reliable. In
this study, we propose to utilize the probing technique for pre-training data
detection by examining the model's internal activations. Our method is simple
and effective and leads to more trustworthy pre-training data detection.
Additionally, we propose ArxivMIA, a new challenging benchmark comprising arxiv
abstracts from Computer Science and Mathematics categories. Our experiments
demonstrate that our method outperforms all baselines, and achieves
state-of-the-art performance on both WikiMIA and ArxivMIA, with additional
experiments confirming its efficacy (Our code and dataset are available at
https://github.com/zhliu0106/probing-lm-data).
|
[
-0.5150015950202942,
-0.8271116018295288,
0.5664623379707336,
-0.07864397764205933,
-0.3829086720943451,
-0.01784197799861431,
-0.15505342185497284,
-0.2647278308868408,
-0.1669292449951172,
0.6076022982597351,
-0.5432413816452026,
-0.6521456837654114,
-0.7256143093109131,
0.1675010770559311,
-0.8596079349517822,
0.8056273460388184,
-0.1856849044561386,
-0.1815669983625412,
-0.41306477785110474,
-0.2271958589553833,
0.20423433184623718,
-0.5982916951179504,
-0.4459150731563568,
-0.36325258016586304,
0.4780595004558563,
0.17454686760902405,
0.292172372341156,
0.53890460729599,
0.38436976075172424,
0.3436533510684967,
-0.06146765127778053,
0.27198326587677,
-0.5895243287086487,
0.14450141787528992,
-0.010631170123815536,
-0.653476893901825,
-0.19931603968143463,
0.06877618283033371,
0.9667931795120239,
0.5374881625175476,
0.21258394420146942,
0.5076125860214233,
0.18792791664600372,
0.5867415070533752,
-0.7990357875823975,
-0.16192172467708588,
-0.8130629658699036,
-0.0863824412226677,
-0.47593867778778076,
-0.3934638500213623,
-0.44236645102500916,
-0.26620355248451233,
0.05758224427700043,
-0.24645239114761353,
0.147355318069458,
0.06233179196715355,
1.0091941356658936,
0.2711816132068634,
-0.5460081100463867,
-0.19418294727802277,
-0.5234298706054688,
0.6895095705986023,
-0.6735270023345947,
0.6023193597793579,
0.4829346239566803,
-0.08505652099847794,
-0.31864219903945923,
-0.7266110181808472,
-0.7927355766296387,
-0.4814213514328003,
-0.2656567394733429,
-0.35239338874816895,
-0.5248910784721375,
-0.325030654668808,
0.3524264097213745,
0.39730018377304077,
-0.6870006918907166,
0.1149803102016449,
0.01399269513785839,
-0.3258206248283386,
0.21875201165676117,
-0.15433160960674286,
0.508918821811676,
0.02145039476454258,
-0.3506704866886139,
-0.2642589807510376,
-1.012404203414917,
-0.07174285501241684,
0.822811484336853,
0.17836178839206696,
-0.12124308943748474,
0.5621414184570312,
-0.1384875476360321,
0.6111158728599548,
-0.335401326417923,
0.17117668688297272,
0.37745237350463867,
-0.47735515236854553,
-0.2919751703739166,
-0.11574474722146988,
0.9905254244804382,
-0.21386763453483582,
0.46648579835891724,
-0.09696251899003983,
-0.23089611530303955,
-0.10520517826080322,
-0.0035183525178581476,
-1.0181697607040405,
-0.2593754231929779,
0.3467528820037842,
-0.2535172402858734,
-0.5091481804847717,
-0.31063130497932434,
-0.45436394214630127,
-0.366427481174469,
-0.23708125948905945,
0.6102522611618042,
-0.4286050498485565,
-0.5386320352554321,
0.023723503574728966,
0.4957945942878723,
0.23532046377658844,
0.014886404387652874,
-0.6711146831512451,
0.05826130136847496,
0.6880158185958862,
0.5743662714958191,
-0.20830366015434265,
-0.3549870550632477,
-0.7218393683433533,
-0.2048778235912323,
-0.3298652768135071,
0.985951840877533,
-0.5263966917991638,
-0.2142835408449173,
0.147133469581604,
-0.1268216371536255,
0.010982166975736618,
-0.6720324158668518,
0.4406076967716217,
-0.6807779669761658,
0.06899403780698776,
-0.10527220368385315,
-0.7014715671539307,
0.04118956997990608,
0.7724992632865906,
-0.6717631816864014,
1.3910542726516724,
0.02280203439295292,
-1.0460925102233887,
0.22405840456485748,
-0.4447824954986572,
-0.17780378460884094,
0.030952254310250282,
-0.2744012176990509,
-0.6845795512199402,
-0.16169434785842896,
0.4347270429134369,
0.5366938710212708,
-0.13598710298538208,
0.23926329612731934,
-0.3487735986709595,
-0.4122482240200043,
0.5923901796340942,
-0.45831239223480225,
0.7457870244979858,
0.12373679876327515,
-0.14570307731628418,
0.16365967690944672,
-0.8522821664810181,
0.22921226918697357,
0.2521076798439026,
-0.33036860823631287,
-0.4957278072834015,
-0.1647653430700302,
-0.2720104455947876,
-0.21547693014144897,
0.28530851006507874,
-0.3562203347682953,
0.26102274656295776,
-0.3370223641395569,
0.047250330448150635,
0.6571207642555237,
-0.031868066638708115,
0.30154427886009216,
-0.07555525749921799,
0.6097238063812256,
0.24653659760951996,
0.006473470013588667,
-0.5417792201042175,
-0.17679370939731598,
-0.9097673296928406,
-0.20846830308437347,
0.47411873936653137,
0.3352920711040497,
-0.7842702865600586,
0.5716121196746826,
-0.38732293248176575,
-0.6024487018585205,
-0.5283541083335876,
0.2216380089521408,
0.5552477240562439,
0.5311924815177917,
0.3166370093822479,
-0.08772148936986923,
-0.34908974170684814,
-0.847719132900238,
-0.6736723780632019,
-0.13008487224578857,
-0.031248925253748894,
0.37909600138664246,
0.7417118549346924,
-0.4574151635169983,
0.7326262593269348,
-0.17544932663440704,
-0.09244255721569061,
-0.005862594582140446,
0.4297666549682617,
0.19027908146381378,
0.4312059283256531,
0.43972212076187134,
-0.7229637503623962,
-0.505639910697937,
-0.06680091470479965,
-0.5661623477935791,
-0.25089550018310547,
0.1690807044506073,
-0.1025816798210144,
-0.03959941491484642,
0.7455382347106934,
-0.25254735350608826,
0.41696226596832275,
0.7302699089050293,
-0.1114322766661644,
0.5073666572570801,
-0.05218915268778801,
0.326548308134079,
-0.9049423336982727,
0.3902612626552582,
-0.07557369023561478,
-0.2925342321395874,
-0.7428449988365173,
0.03472123667597771,
0.3935438394546509,
0.023322314023971558,
-0.5680372714996338,
0.5667067170143127,
-0.6263641119003296,
-0.10064329952001572,
-0.3423581123352051,
0.053224824368953705,
-0.09207779914140701,
0.15144440531730652,
-0.0699789896607399,
0.9358486533164978,
0.6323062181472778,
-0.5795401930809021,
0.05429365485906601,
0.007159413769841194,
-0.8353732228279114,
0.16242744028568268,
-0.5214239358901978,
0.48600834608078003,
-0.08661535382270813,
0.05875479057431221,
-1.1128746271133423,
0.03888345882296562,
0.3601655662059784,
-0.6795764565467834,
0.19463804364204407,
-0.4848773777484894,
-0.9417927861213684,
0.10518837720155716,
-0.11860881745815277,
0.710987389087677,
0.20816969871520996,
-0.6832311749458313,
0.5823739171028137,
0.21860364079475403,
0.09750017523765564,
-0.9254359006881714,
-0.26169636845588684,
-0.02147902175784111,
-0.2984045743942261,
-0.43054646253585815,
0.12942519783973694,
-0.041231121867895126,
-0.2584605813026428,
-0.09675101935863495,
-0.0647178590297699,
0.028129398822784424,
0.28489840030670166,
0.06984467804431915,
0.20621968805789948,
-0.23818819224834442,
-0.02315974049270153,
0.01587643474340439,
-0.0351751372218132,
0.2629817724227905,
0.022051941603422165,
1.0094646215438843,
-0.19192562997341156,
-0.49329936504364014,
-0.4963967204093933,
0.02726862207055092,
0.43329373002052307,
-0.7036398649215698,
0.6663196086883545,
0.6536287665367126,
-0.43803873658180237,
-0.2767590582370758,
-0.745901882648468,
-0.23974084854125977,
-0.5684978365898132,
0.4059273302555084,
-0.3354348838329315,
-0.6623275876045227,
0.484358012676239,
-0.3796701729297638,
-0.26213839650154114,
0.10604489594697952,
0.4388691782951355,
0.11231113225221634,
0.9164698123931885,
0.5914012789726257,
-0.17091113328933716,
0.48235878348350525,
-0.2815563976764679,
0.24571070075035095,
-0.7210134267807007,
-0.05534632131457329,
-0.8048319816589355,
-0.0521199069917202,
-0.3042815625667572,
-0.29681867361068726,
0.2734927833080292,
0.04613500460982323,
-0.10105415433645248,
0.26280346512794495,
-0.2429613620042801,
0.8455183506011963,
0.3745110034942627,
-0.014117219485342503,
0.41548267006874084,
0.02400769293308258,
-0.04124430939555168,
0.03728577494621277,
-0.20000192523002625,
-0.5664286613464355,
1.3335505723953247,
0.3648684620857239,
0.6398192048072815,
-0.1190502941608429,
0.8895366191864014,
-0.00012754861381836236,
0.5761496424674988,
-0.5758393406867981,
0.5901641249656677,
0.025308528915047646,
-0.6181545257568359,
-0.22747737169265747,
-0.6174052357673645,
-1.0888804197311401,
0.23933401703834534,
-0.3726460337638855,
-0.7156739234924316,
0.1239170953631401,
0.18400727212429047,
-0.07007117569446564,
0.3446853458881378,
-0.51924729347229,
0.8031714558601379,
-0.3944561183452606,
-0.45184773206710815,
0.045133236795663834,
-0.2627807855606079,
0.4723999500274658,
-0.30123576521873474,
0.2604249119758606,
-0.1546914279460907,
0.014510237611830235,
0.7801909446716309,
-0.050227295607328415,
0.6337707042694092,
0.08895467221736908,
-0.3936783969402313,
0.06768091022968292,
0.27614322304725647,
0.6631154417991638,
0.022403335198760033,
0.0808323472738266,
0.05893631651997566,
0.0640060156583786,
-0.23983977735042572,
-0.4523670971393585,
0.6963109374046326,
-0.6322733759880066,
-0.41002142429351807,
-0.48797401785850525,
-0.4048878252506256,
-0.35910725593566895,
0.5984053611755371,
0.38245639204978943,
0.24645094573497772,
-0.05531853437423706,
0.47016778588294983,
0.9636679887771606,
-0.13955114781856537,
0.13955242931842804,
0.7303244471549988,
-0.4218567907810211,
0.09902660548686981,
0.8179270029067993,
-0.14888229966163635,
0.08735182881355286,
0.4612113833427429,
0.23774923384189606,
-0.3152201771736145,
-1.0758795738220215,
-0.25040900707244873,
0.3075723648071289,
-0.6166912913322449,
-0.15424486994743347,
-0.6957504153251648,
-0.14941149950027466,
-0.4676567018032074,
0.5016717314720154,
-0.6188398599624634,
0.314289927482605,
-0.4387217164039612,
0.11986956000328064,
0.21806380152702332,
0.46049803495407104,
0.3112174868583679,
0.3890380561351776,
-0.8335428833961487,
0.17234645783901215,
0.12080444395542145,
0.21011130511760712,
-0.06938726454973221,
-0.542041540145874,
-0.17619004845619202,
0.0067882901057600975,
0.026584725826978683,
-0.7456725239753723,
0.4676966667175293,
-0.025887154042720795,
0.6466746926307678,
0.7478081583976746,
0.009809713810682297,
0.4235696494579315,
-0.4771239459514618,
0.38400647044181824,
-0.19712337851524353,
-0.9432647228240967,
0.6215211153030396,
-0.4517613351345062,
0.10506406426429749,
0.6834846138954163,
0.746186375617981,
-0.23418349027633667,
-0.35380256175994873,
-0.42891010642051697,
-0.7443192005157471,
0.45250967144966125,
0.1754426807165146,
0.28339001536369324,
0.26343122124671936,
0.5971832275390625,
-0.018902940675616264,
0.24718628823757172,
-0.9643756747245789,
-0.3863743841648102,
0.17790576815605164,
0.014070509001612663,
-0.10373616963624954,
-0.3897038996219635,
-0.15325698256492615,
-0.114238440990448,
0.4731162190437317,
-0.009719341062009335,
-0.03789588809013367,
-0.06394261866807938,
-0.3705434203147888,
0.16705702245235443,
0.22093814611434937,
0.4575221538543701,
0.6379671096801758,
-0.23906554281711578,
0.4101160764694214,
-0.0016831838293001056,
-0.6957302093505859,
0.20460781455039978,
0.08534146845340729,
0.06130369007587433,
-0.15181343257427216,
0.5878516435623169,
0.4384497106075287,
0.12012416869401932,
-0.8186584115028381,
0.6983643174171448,
-0.21903182566165924,
-0.13001765310764313,
-0.3893655836582184,
0.15833011269569397,
0.14303167164325714,
0.1347273290157318,
0.3303951025009155,
-0.2782241106033325,
0.09045598655939102,
-0.5875412821769714,
0.2738184630870819,
0.4233376979827881,
-0.17563217878341675,
-0.2949914038181305,
0.33783048391342163,
-0.026788365095853806,
-0.27220308780670166,
0.629451334476471,
-0.23570014536380768,
-0.7088677287101746,
0.4296453595161438,
0.440917044878006,
0.5516940355300903,
-0.31358686089515686,
-0.16633640229701996,
0.16251477599143982,
0.5248158574104309,
0.07672464102506638,
0.21959097683429718,
-0.13428346812725067,
-1.108689546585083,
-0.35135751962661743,
-0.4840984642505646,
-0.35568109154701233,
0.7344938516616821,
-0.7918004989624023,
0.3234489858150482,
-0.07201715558767319,
0.0549127459526062,
-0.02584206871688366,
0.058793481439352036,
-0.6901365518569946,
0.2623746693134308,
0.15489462018013,
0.827122151851654,
-0.9594472646713257,
1.1505346298217773,
0.4926767647266388,
-0.07196707278490067,
-0.49394360184669495,
0.22500663995742798,
-0.18660570681095123,
-1.0046802759170532,
0.7597001194953918,
0.3595990836620331,
-0.36281025409698486,
0.17148452997207642,
-0.6889708638191223,
-0.8346939086914062,
0.7957277297973633,
0.556319534778595,
-0.6091302633285522,
0.046557389199733734,
0.262735515832901,
0.3902963697910309,
-0.19217181205749512,
0.24786122143268585,
0.6899070143699646,
0.5009573101997375,
-0.33578699827194214,
-0.5306693315505981,
-0.06641394644975662,
-0.5188234448432922,
-0.4521578848361969,
0.2748695909976959,
-0.2047058790922165,
0.974186360836029,
0.07502491772174835,
-0.22863224148750305,
0.10917705297470093,
0.6772651076316833,
0.45325538516044617,
0.22815363109111786,
0.8658053278923035,
0.6097527742385864,
0.76384037733078,
-0.11081472039222717,
0.8336157202720642,
-0.4331941306591034,
0.3050779402256012,
1.0358248949050903,
-0.3121192455291748,
0.9429131746292114,
0.577339231967926,
-0.29102781414985657,
0.27889713644981384,
0.5831891894340515,
-0.05703703314065933,
0.36786454916000366,
0.5592702031135559,
-0.46706193685531616,
-0.31639420986175537,
0.05226485803723335,
-0.5527668595314026,
0.5152581334114075,
0.5142224431037903,
-0.3420783579349518,
-0.275604248046875,
0.0461045503616333,
0.29272395372390747,
0.10505186021327972,
-0.0924566462635994,
0.5961802005767822,
-0.15447084605693817,
-0.6502596735954285,
0.648780882358551,
-0.10616209357976913,
0.7221255898475647,
-0.6602420210838318,
0.08490249514579773,
-0.31197884678840637,
0.2989797294139862,
-0.050841402262449265,
-0.563376784324646,
-0.03970078006386757,
0.10450134426355362,
0.25532516837120056,
-0.13874894380569458,
0.8121681809425354,
-0.4888681471347809,
-0.4074327349662781,
0.39299827814102173,
0.5815855860710144,
0.276767760515213,
-0.48311084508895874,
-0.45643696188926697,
0.4256632626056671,
-0.0341692715883255,
-0.45399776101112366,
0.5532657504081726,
0.34277021884918213,
0.20648519694805145,
0.8028427362442017,
0.8086480498313904,
0.08307323604822159,
0.1029265895485878,
-0.011931069195270538,
1.0506768226623535,
-0.2020881474018097,
-0.30352509021759033,
-0.9387907385826111,
0.24546484649181366,
0.03288207948207855,
-0.38346657156944275,
0.872592568397522,
0.8092039823532104,
0.9317575097084045,
0.19043993949890137,
0.6353859901428223,
0.5648157596588135,
0.5757856965065002,
-0.5961626172065735,
1.1530377864837646,
-0.6146440505981445,
0.3899301290512085,
-0.11343161016702652,
-0.8205148577690125,
-0.30410557985305786,
0.46849390864372253,
-0.36767473816871643,
0.02814449556171894,
0.6217340230941772,
1.0012167692184448,
-0.35502541065216064,
-0.09520188719034195,
0.12264038622379303,
0.20150785148143768,
0.4790433943271637,
0.2250155210494995,
1.120287537574768,
-0.38390636444091797,
0.7725210785865784,
-0.3691522181034088,
-0.2573641538619995,
-0.0883004441857338,
-1.1837955713272095,
-1.3147907257080078,
-0.6056571006774902,
-0.3778076469898224,
-0.39426666498184204,
-0.09391957521438599,
0.4663912057876587,
0.5625436305999756,
-0.765034019947052,
-0.11275803297758102,
0.012311842292547226,
0.03846020996570587,
0.17936751246452332,
-0.13778004050254822,
0.6311100721359253,
-0.2887174189090729,
-0.8973476886749268,
0.6333379149436951,
-0.16437409818172455,
0.16166876256465912,
-0.4292590916156769,
0.3111233115196228,
-0.23755668103694916,
0.08634482324123383,
0.34669530391693115,
0.23822303116321564,
-0.31931212544441223,
-0.16663871705532074,
-0.003947526682168245,
-0.015067121013998985,
-0.09238379448652267,
0.980410635471344,
-0.7194398641586304,
0.3680115044116974,
0.5951976180076599,
0.7335827946662903,
0.6052625775337219,
-0.17223553359508514,
0.2229204922914505,
-0.8033244609832764,
0.2023453712463379,
0.2543955147266388,
0.465878963470459,
0.27690309286117554,
-0.2962532043457031,
0.24326424300670624,
-0.09450995177030563,
-0.5768762826919556,
-1.5042356252670288,
0.1572868525981903,
-0.6624296307563782,
-0.08237417787313461,
1.062794804573059,
-0.31701382994651794,
-0.31735485792160034,
0.032612577080726624,
0.12014255672693253,
0.2566681504249573,
0.07770398259162903,
0.7064083218574524,
0.7193905115127563,
0.10196137428283691,
-0.13595044612884521,
-0.5694394111633301,
0.49594512581825256,
0.42076319456100464,
-0.9998611807823181,
0.11457885801792145,
0.03156019747257233,
0.40432336926460266,
0.1212933212518692,
0.5160312056541443,
-0.2630190849304199,
0.044288765639066696,
-0.21379265189170837,
-0.06400036811828613,
-0.28413090109825134,
-0.29619985818862915,
-0.20633478462696075,
0.012908908538520336,
-0.06864139437675476,
-0.28976044058799744
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.06567v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.06567v1
|
DHA: Learning Decoupled-Head Attention from Transformer Checkpoints via Adaptive Heads Fusion
| 2024-06-03T13:28:43 | 2024-06-03T13:28:43 |
Yilong Chen, Linhao Zhang, Junyuan Shang, Zhenyu Zhang, Tingwen Liu, Shuohuan Wang, Yu Sun
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) with billions of parameters demonstrate
impressive performance. However, the widely used Multi-Head Attention (MHA) in
LLMs incurs substantial computational and memory costs during inference. While
some efforts have optimized attention mechanisms by pruning heads or sharing
parameters among heads, these methods often lead to performance degradation or
necessitate substantial continued pre-training costs to restore performance.
Based on the analysis of attention redundancy, we design a Decoupled-Head
Attention (DHA) mechanism. DHA adaptively configures group sharing for key
heads and value heads across various layers, achieving a better balance between
performance and efficiency. Inspired by the observation of clustering similar
heads, we propose to progressively transform the MHA checkpoint into the DHA
model through linear fusion of similar head parameters step by step, retaining
the parametric knowledge of the MHA checkpoint. We construct DHA models by
transforming various scales of MHA checkpoints given target head budgets. Our
experiments show that DHA remarkably requires a mere 0.25\% of the original
model's pre-training budgets to achieve 97.6\% of performance while saving 75\%
of KV cache. Compared to Group-Query Attention (GQA), DHA achieves a 5$\times$
training acceleration, a maximum of 13.93\% performance improvement under
0.01\% pre-training budget, and 4\% relative improvement under 0.05\%
pre-training budget.
|
[
-0.4355655312538147,
-0.4957423210144043,
0.5306504368782043,
0.012152494862675667,
-0.4692271947860718,
0.05346280336380005,
-0.10953684896230698,
-0.36056044697761536,
0.43645262718200684,
0.5786782503128052,
-0.8958402276039124,
-0.158405140042305,
-0.619651198387146,
-0.03654590621590614,
-0.1636822372674942,
0.8476275205612183,
0.16900046169757843,
-0.28698673844337463,
-0.008218116126954556,
-0.4865906834602356,
-0.8394573330879211,
-0.22775742411613464,
-0.8618613481521606,
-0.17960481345653534,
0.8938331604003906,
0.1364509016275406,
0.4355192482471466,
0.8404614329338074,
0.5293203592300415,
0.3261342942714691,
-0.1408465951681137,
0.1628056913614273,
-0.8160032033920288,
-0.0030401204712688923,
-0.4440782070159912,
-0.4338439404964447,
-0.5557631254196167,
-0.27032166719436646,
0.8340092301368713,
0.7130571007728577,
-0.2815774083137512,
0.050632622092962265,
0.19468289613723755,
1.0397698879241943,
-0.8924562335014343,
0.3532927632331848,
-1.0276095867156982,
-0.1579897403717041,
-0.04650310054421425,
0.009925531223416328,
-0.36473485827445984,
-0.20948003232479095,
0.3757326900959015,
-0.5000065565109253,
0.19024793803691864,
-0.25002506375312805,
0.725709855556488,
0.6037946343421936,
-0.13777686655521393,
0.3423689901828766,
-0.5756316184997559,
1.0631043910980225,
-0.3692465126514435,
0.4954279959201813,
0.09935654699802399,
0.3022550344467163,
-0.021253552287817,
-0.5671694874763489,
-0.6417839527130127,
0.40176165103912354,
0.032991111278533936,
0.15501521527767181,
-0.4782087206840515,
0.13512194156646729,
0.08620940893888474,
0.4678995609283447,
-0.30198338627815247,
-0.00247743958607316,
-0.3909214437007904,
-0.07510552555322647,
0.3461654782295227,
0.1342746615409851,
0.32231029868125916,
0.2212366759777069,
-0.40508079528808594,
-0.5061581134796143,
-0.7479081749916077,
-0.09657400846481323,
-0.36040714383125305,
0.47200122475624084,
-0.1768130511045456,
0.07174467295408249,
-0.47068506479263306,
0.8245242238044739,
0.515800952911377,
-0.2737811505794525,
0.32453733682632446,
-0.3662714958190918,
-0.48866337537765503,
0.02275388315320015,
0.4132487177848816,
0.22208040952682495,
0.12684357166290283,
-0.3777380585670471,
-0.1701134294271469,
0.31288382411003113,
0.6448709964752197,
-0.6442965865135193,
-0.21564613282680511,
0.29049667716026306,
-0.2824442684650421,
-0.04745011031627655,
-0.32660478353500366,
-0.8774256706237793,
-0.012244919314980507,
-0.4438256025314331,
0.5695352554321289,
-0.13905088603496552,
-0.31212812662124634,
0.07336326688528061,
0.0009837935212999582,
0.46414074301719666,
0.3083353638648987,
-1.0123313665390015,
-0.05691082403063774,
0.45525500178337097,
0.7557061314582825,
-0.4586219787597656,
-0.6434363722801208,
-0.6077044606208801,
0.47743940353393555,
-0.08800629526376724,
0.9455506205558777,
-0.4278363585472107,
-0.12084630876779556,
-0.07385207712650299,
0.05685165524482727,
-0.6280845403671265,
-0.7619733214378357,
0.3117700219154358,
-0.9969022870063782,
0.05381042882800102,
-0.7130066752433777,
-0.1235455647110939,
-0.552335798740387,
0.32268381118774414,
-0.8079955577850342,
0.4474236071109772,
0.3783048987388611,
-0.8430259227752686,
0.38241255283355713,
-0.6075572371482849,
-0.332475483417511,
0.14223428070545197,
-0.1251041293144226,
-0.5403853058815002,
-0.12317352741956711,
0.5242345929145813,
0.2371966689825058,
-0.2759929895401001,
0.13688695430755615,
-0.2936583161354065,
-0.340913861989975,
-0.13689622282981873,
0.029735198244452477,
0.8360301852226257,
-0.032698437571525574,
-0.4304673373699188,
0.49786487221717834,
-0.5768153667449951,
-0.19594158232212067,
0.02908606268465519,
-0.4527662396430969,
-0.0956847220659256,
-0.15795950591564178,
-0.24680279195308685,
0.2783260941505432,
0.07408220320940018,
-0.12134744226932526,
-0.13037146627902985,
-0.5519763827323914,
0.3916574716567993,
0.803590714931488,
0.14906224608421326,
0.34292009472846985,
-0.5408721566200256,
0.4388839304447174,
0.4198054373264313,
-0.203311949968338,
-0.3081232011318207,
-0.17552079260349274,
-1.0152124166488647,
-0.5327472686767578,
0.08912889659404755,
0.2946290969848633,
-0.6222990155220032,
0.6462696194648743,
-0.44582679867744446,
-0.24971401691436768,
-0.6783273220062256,
0.17548982799053192,
0.5612139105796814,
0.6251541972160339,
0.4664566218852997,
-0.4864397346973419,
-0.4630201756954193,
-1.0466607809066772,
-0.3258618712425232,
-0.1458621323108673,
-0.20959162712097168,
0.14030779898166656,
0.13264520466327667,
-0.5620205998420715,
0.8345971703529358,
-0.47194769978523254,
-0.6176621317863464,
-0.36386263370513916,
-0.043934423476457596,
-0.005803377833217382,
0.4177219569683075,
0.338601678609848,
-0.4761514365673065,
-0.3471595346927643,
0.02688414789736271,
-0.5726595520973206,
0.056322790682315826,
-0.1677394062280655,
-0.3880138099193573,
0.04382263869047165,
0.34103864431381226,
-0.7861873507499695,
0.07978816330432892,
0.5836924910545349,
-0.062205471098423004,
0.362403929233551,
0.045490946620702744,
0.1631413847208023,
-1.1284364461898804,
0.1793420910835266,
-0.09959465265274048,
-0.2183196097612381,
-0.6214956045150757,
0.4969475567340851,
0.07684749364852905,
-0.15691064298152924,
-0.5645797252655029,
0.3025793135166168,
-0.5854209065437317,
-0.08886396884918213,
-0.6915690898895264,
0.2673889398574829,
-0.07498253136873245,
1.215570092201233,
-0.11636722087860107,
0.7484131455421448,
0.7131617665290833,
-0.9387661218643188,
0.09952089190483093,
0.3690876364707947,
-0.24764905869960785,
0.6535411477088928,
-0.6251559853553772,
0.38288289308547974,
-0.2795144021511078,
0.3773067593574524,
-0.9949846863746643,
-0.3669404685497284,
0.19713261723518372,
-0.06516023725271225,
0.3547958433628082,
0.04086919128894806,
-0.10826089978218079,
-0.09523192793130875,
-0.26424312591552734,
0.8757238388061523,
0.6003822684288025,
-0.739128828048706,
0.848103404045105,
0.8927255272865295,
-0.14520448446273804,
-0.42249539494514465,
-0.3935575783252716,
0.013913121074438095,
-0.39186105132102966,
-0.4386986494064331,
0.6118568778038025,
0.26677533984184265,
-0.07977081835269928,
-0.10374505072832108,
-0.19538356363773346,
-0.17120316624641418,
-0.2247944325208664,
-0.016901660710573196,
0.11421257257461548,
-0.08943136036396027,
0.13894635438919067,
0.2645733952522278,
-0.21215194463729858,
0.10856854915618896,
-0.3753111958503723,
0.5146300196647644,
0.17054259777069092,
-0.12253786623477936,
-0.7007225155830383,
0.3690546154975891,
0.9700658917427063,
-0.4548937976360321,
0.9307728409767151,
0.3548811972141266,
-0.6339746713638306,
-0.02824748493731022,
-0.7326517701148987,
-0.45136427879333496,
-0.48864299058914185,
0.47758933901786804,
-0.27429020404815674,
-0.7913770079612732,
0.6227854490280151,
0.025967249646782875,
0.3071972131729126,
0.5711226463317871,
0.8711572289466858,
0.15531468391418457,
0.6499255299568176,
0.7639150023460388,
-0.4165361821651459,
0.5616006851196289,
0.062162380665540695,
0.08197009563446045,
-0.9292914867401123,
-0.15991583466529846,
-0.3000224828720093,
-0.47306033968925476,
-0.3086147904396057,
-0.6345382332801819,
0.5619314908981323,
-0.07275491207838058,
-0.2101612091064453,
0.4635884463787079,
-0.4384625256061554,
0.6314846873283386,
0.49323320388793945,
0.4268650412559509,
0.11101476103067398,
0.01573243737220764,
0.24839003384113312,
0.054839249700307846,
-0.6574772596359253,
0.06413428485393524,
0.8831543326377869,
0.34633058309555054,
0.6162199378013611,
-0.003260392928496003,
0.49544617533683777,
0.10455552488565445,
0.06887301057577133,
-0.7189365029335022,
0.5688856840133667,
0.09156418591737747,
-0.1957380175590515,
-0.362665593624115,
-0.40576785802841187,
-0.9867165088653564,
0.6586967706680298,
0.15044954419136047,
-0.633358895778656,
0.26997512578964233,
0.3175852596759796,
-0.5521888136863708,
0.19271859526634216,
-0.5607900023460388,
0.9178400635719299,
0.4296369254589081,
-0.21585845947265625,
-0.7735110521316528,
-0.7005472183227539,
0.5611655712127686,
-0.3570057153701782,
-0.14938277006149292,
-0.051161766052246094,
0.33287784457206726,
1.0252883434295654,
0.07524000108242035,
0.9454147815704346,
-0.21654635667800903,
-0.17052367329597473,
0.2713026702404022,
-0.2091166377067566,
0.7775759100914001,
-0.25751882791519165,
0.4609347879886627,
0.19511443376541138,
-0.2359297275543213,
-0.46595391631126404,
-0.512226402759552,
0.7427964210510254,
-0.6966823935508728,
-0.7975497245788574,
-0.09395116567611694,
-0.9111964702606201,
-0.3981475234031677,
0.39578548073768616,
-0.15199023485183716,
0.17305445671081543,
0.08221431821584702,
0.13909226655960083,
0.9813144207000732,
-0.07938248664140701,
0.34909185767173767,
0.41847363114356995,
0.10308458656072617,
-0.5560911893844604,
0.7633625864982605,
-0.14447569847106934,
0.5149024128913879,
0.6390335559844971,
0.0775788202881813,
-0.3318614363670349,
-0.4300650954246521,
-0.3563424050807953,
0.44151026010513306,
-0.7287051677703857,
-0.2663455605506897,
-1.1310304403305054,
-0.1797589808702469,
-0.44442883133888245,
-0.013722803443670273,
-0.4526001513004303,
-0.18440093100070953,
-0.1069512590765953,
0.03179017826914787,
0.10032008588314056,
-0.002402692334726453,
0.11357379704713821,
0.5251386761665344,
-0.8484084010124207,
0.6555669903755188,
0.7852954268455505,
0.0882626324892044,
0.3194297254085541,
-0.7031221985816956,
-0.30434709787368774,
0.09134076535701752,
-0.4695791006088257,
-0.776207685470581,
0.28831052780151367,
0.07060515880584717,
0.5123631358146667,
0.6196898221969604,
0.16432678699493408,
0.9766897559165955,
-0.4950907528400421,
0.3257175087928772,
0.15721267461776733,
-0.9327448606491089,
0.3605040907859802,
-0.4064766466617584,
0.7568826079368591,
0.7443310022354126,
0.09399694204330444,
-0.4250297546386719,
-0.5124865174293518,
-0.26459652185440063,
-0.6679753661155701,
0.9585273265838623,
0.06263861805200577,
-0.01820007711648941,
0.18272213637828827,
0.338188499212265,
-0.1405797302722931,
-0.018237564712762833,
-0.6747846603393555,
-0.07382392138242722,
0.22085654735565186,
-0.08383230119943619,
0.05332596227526665,
-0.3297373056411743,
-0.3896869122982025,
-0.2820380926132202,
0.5383533239364624,
-0.24111340939998627,
0.28305602073669434,
-0.06496381759643555,
-0.18376217782497406,
-0.23872770369052887,
-0.020680924877524376,
0.6224733591079712,
1.0425610542297363,
-0.15086732804775238,
0.08306749910116196,
0.4335821270942688,
-0.38283592462539673,
0.11690709739923477,
-0.15688994526863098,
-0.029112599790096283,
-0.38194119930267334,
0.26187849044799805,
0.9125833511352539,
0.48072904348373413,
-0.7299829125404358,
0.19713380932807922,
-0.002601091517135501,
-0.08994074910879135,
0.19351685047149658,
0.1051221489906311,
0.293337881565094,
0.2719298005104065,
0.2461874932050705,
0.028412114828824997,
-0.037225812673568726,
-0.3984023332595825,
0.43854936957359314,
0.5600979328155518,
-0.37410762906074524,
-0.46837514638900757,
0.6754705309867859,
0.40896886587142944,
-0.029449529945850372,
0.4868040382862091,
0.17099414765834808,
-0.5801023840904236,
0.3909682333469391,
0.5012224912643433,
1.4137358665466309,
-0.5605992674827576,
-0.12894457578659058,
0.45336124300956726,
0.29148975014686584,
0.015975123271346092,
-0.0782548263669014,
-0.25130924582481384,
-0.7359258532524109,
-0.5113254189491272,
-0.7161502838134766,
-0.37948739528656006,
0.22799263894557953,
-0.7703697681427002,
0.15512555837631226,
-0.3426301181316376,
0.15837576985359192,
-0.06160110980272293,
-0.3449433743953705,
-0.5526173114776611,
0.30585992336273193,
-0.1068592295050621,
0.4453745484352112,
-0.8094326257705688,
0.8995256423950195,
0.4706241190433502,
-0.20941996574401855,
-0.37585899233818054,
0.4292284846305847,
-0.15918630361557007,
-0.9828598499298096,
0.301205039024353,
0.4707805812358856,
-0.3801458179950714,
0.10789843648672104,
0.08721406012773514,
-0.9588730931282043,
1.003570795059204,
0.5967404842376709,
-0.7356977462768555,
-0.28965646028518677,
-0.02906401827931404,
0.2429182529449463,
-0.20992805063724518,
-0.21346868574619293,
0.8113783001899719,
0.07490643113851547,
0.15653644502162933,
-0.9024285078048706,
0.2538837790489197,
0.2938210666179657,
0.005009994376450777,
0.21827493607997894,
-0.9348389506340027,
0.9339079260826111,
-0.2677059471607208,
-0.8482538461685181,
-0.5560137629508972,
0.8291531205177307,
0.4650942087173462,
-0.023377440869808197,
0.7658160328865051,
0.8344060182571411,
0.4830065071582794,
0.19061149656772614,
0.7624168395996094,
-0.3925715684890747,
0.3184657096862793,
0.9767512083053589,
-0.3250179588794708,
0.8125633597373962,
0.7428585886955261,
-0.34348902106285095,
0.42973989248275757,
0.4678448438644409,
0.49918532371520996,
0.9656878113746643,
-0.017564665526151657,
-0.4310656785964966,
-0.31995388865470886,
0.0792110338807106,
-0.4168032109737396,
0.4091981053352356,
0.011315539479255676,
-0.24168284237384796,
-0.41827192902565,
0.04916955158114433,
-0.2125866413116455,
-0.15489669144153595,
-0.3935413360595703,
1.1374789476394653,
0.05571707338094711,
-1.0007268190383911,
0.8453968167304993,
0.006473267916589975,
0.3955209255218506,
-0.5426363945007324,
0.11825893074274063,
-0.4283466935157776,
0.6945379376411438,
0.14336100220680237,
-0.14310410618782043,
0.605962872505188,
-0.2775910198688507,
-0.6470916271209717,
0.054910048842430115,
0.47137731313705444,
-0.6718725562095642,
-0.32739949226379395,
0.2819594442844391,
0.19922633469104767,
-0.04849124699831009,
-0.5252519845962524,
-0.5670101046562195,
0.37511005997657776,
0.12154670804738998,
0.11907077580690384,
0.7196646332740784,
0.11459064483642578,
0.10335217416286469,
0.6441872119903564,
0.5397484302520752,
-0.26813840866088867,
0.005943063646554947,
-0.05130505561828613,
1.2149748802185059,
-0.7707400321960449,
-0.9069358110427856,
-0.8794789910316467,
0.27839037775993347,
0.33415886759757996,
0.012565763667225838,
0.38494250178337097,
0.16165867447853088,
0.877894401550293,
-0.1891138255596161,
0.5895547866821289,
0.4455069899559021,
0.5815352201461792,
-0.6875801682472229,
0.9050363898277283,
-0.42036494612693787,
-0.050547290593385696,
-0.19969318807125092,
-1.1535990238189697,
-0.10998617857694626,
0.4387553632259369,
0.2535189986228943,
0.09667035937309265,
0.7294354438781738,
0.721815824508667,
-0.1536986529827118,
-0.2394554316997528,
0.3332034647464752,
-0.035683728754520416,
0.4932316541671753,
1.1397221088409424,
0.35093945264816284,
-0.38969290256500244,
0.4584677219390869,
-0.13005836308002472,
-0.44183963537216187,
-0.08419603109359741,
-0.5635493397712708,
-0.9789228439331055,
-0.512807309627533,
-0.6588954329490662,
-0.1979004442691803,
-0.028649598360061646,
0.5228142738342285,
0.7547690868377686,
-0.9776265025138855,
-0.0770675465464592,
-0.20940515398979187,
0.05742271989583969,
-0.5929269790649414,
-0.23891665041446686,
0.6222057342529297,
-0.6313546299934387,
-0.9873552918434143,
0.5139286518096924,
0.5414629578590393,
-0.1895299106836319,
-0.48670321702957153,
0.17194022238254547,
-0.071046382188797,
0.14374206960201263,
0.6466281414031982,
0.38235414028167725,
-0.9771280288696289,
-0.29038745164871216,
-0.3775829076766968,
-0.024099359288811684,
0.11937665939331055,
0.7738640904426575,
-0.9245604276657104,
0.52996826171875,
0.40625637769699097,
1.3376879692077637,
0.36148861050605774,
0.18592843413352966,
0.6339343786239624,
-0.6264550089836121,
0.2022489756345749,
0.010070583783090115,
0.28927505016326904,
0.1404009610414505,
-0.3034822940826416,
0.047210972756147385,
0.3788738250732422,
-0.6093842387199402,
-0.9269279837608337,
0.15872570872306824,
-1.2529667615890503,
0.0325799398124218,
0.9224509000778198,
-0.19523225724697113,
-0.38533082604408264,
0.0038609278853982687,
-0.13548196852207184,
0.3599797189235687,
-0.17728331685066223,
1.3077365159988403,
0.4571615159511566,
0.09809398651123047,
-0.42476287484169006,
0.14585784077644348,
0.5116402506828308,
0.6829416155815125,
-1.0411187410354614,
0.6049072742462158,
0.2781347632408142,
0.1442006230354309,
0.28645938634872437,
0.5815988779067993,
-0.06887153536081314,
0.46779659390449524,
0.018714139237999916,
-0.04154704138636589,
0.3181454837322235,
-0.5870881676673889,
-0.5574091672897339,
0.3127574324607849,
-0.21847663819789886,
-0.8219478726387024
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.01311v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.01311v1
|
FactGenius: Combining Zero-Shot Prompting and Fuzzy Relation Mining to Improve Fact Verification with Knowledge Graphs
| 2024-06-03T13:24:37 | 2024-06-03T13:24:37 |
Sushant Gautam
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Fact-checking is a crucial natural language processing (NLP) task that
verifies the truthfulness of claims by considering reliable evidence.
Traditional methods are often limited by labour-intensive data curation and
rule-based approaches. In this paper, we present FactGenius, a novel method
that enhances fact-checking by combining zero-shot prompting of large language
models (LLMs) with fuzzy text matching on knowledge graphs (KGs). Leveraging
DBpedia, a structured linked data dataset derived from Wikipedia, FactGenius
refines LLM-generated connections using similarity measures to ensure accuracy.
The evaluation of FactGenius on the FactKG, a benchmark dataset for fact
verification, demonstrates that it significantly outperforms existing
baselines, particularly when fine-tuning RoBERTa as a classifier. The two-stage
approach of filtering and validating connections proves crucial, achieving
superior performance across various reasoning types and establishing FactGenius
as a promising tool for robust fact-checking. The code and materials are
available at https://github.com/SushantGautam/FactGenius.
|
[
-0.3486764132976532,
-0.8268409371376038,
0.8663524985313416,
-0.12659060955047607,
-0.3397006094455719,
-0.060122426599264145,
-0.15928368270397186,
-0.16798730194568634,
0.020468806847929955,
0.4756850004196167,
-0.797368049621582,
-0.879385232925415,
-0.36645692586898804,
0.42223334312438965,
-0.3275102376937866,
1.0597480535507202,
0.16780342161655426,
-0.14352013170719147,
-0.66999351978302,
-0.26675865054130554,
-0.2365970015525818,
-0.10859271883964539,
-0.3053273558616638,
-0.7166212797164917,
0.5637759566307068,
0.6664857268333435,
0.7346122860908508,
0.6909729838371277,
0.19310902059078217,
0.2898666560649872,
-0.019133174791932106,
0.7436197996139526,
-0.5429670810699463,
0.3205617666244507,
-0.04891661927103996,
-0.5285366773605347,
-0.16640625894069672,
0.009120434522628784,
0.4264894723892212,
0.21046294271945953,
0.11392202973365784,
0.3419926166534424,
-0.28116917610168457,
0.5894415974617004,
-0.47750383615493774,
0.4919174015522003,
-0.6484163999557495,
-0.24598939716815948,
-0.19162674248218536,
-0.2683119475841522,
-0.4060730040073395,
-0.7625659704208374,
-0.26012590527534485,
-0.569277822971344,
0.5512847900390625,
0.15617480874061584,
1.2010328769683838,
0.2788591682910919,
-0.4572451412677765,
-0.22569727897644043,
-0.6620186567306519,
0.3441695272922516,
-0.5112036466598511,
0.6844900846481323,
0.17590521275997162,
0.17613700032234192,
-0.22189339995384216,
-0.42772382497787476,
-1.014233946800232,
-0.19300439953804016,
-0.4462341368198395,
-0.09913907200098038,
-0.047596145421266556,
-0.04777270182967186,
0.5946972370147705,
0.10939077287912369,
-0.7659652829170227,
-0.2840272784233093,
-0.3996227979660034,
-0.22602693736553192,
0.6472904086112976,
-0.19226381182670593,
0.2952285706996918,
-0.5711145401000977,
-0.3876263499259949,
-0.09015659242868423,
-1.0037263631820679,
-0.2653590440750122,
0.37371355295181274,
0.38466981053352356,
-0.17714914679527283,
0.6183424592018127,
-0.6253442764282227,
1.0724291801452637,
0.10696697980165482,
-0.3187142014503479,
0.2504769563674927,
-0.4480880796909332,
0.03760140389204025,
0.3053034245967865,
0.7325519323348999,
0.4631165564060211,
0.3819606602191925,
-0.4520006477832794,
0.2020198404788971,
0.11506808549165726,
-0.15673686563968658,
-0.8026427626609802,
-0.29566311836242676,
0.4892100691795349,
-0.055721547454595566,
-0.3635271489620209,
0.1734512746334076,
-0.7149730324745178,
-0.640550971031189,
-0.20057223737239838,
0.31646716594696045,
-0.6888008713722229,
-0.31243452429771423,
-0.0471804179251194,
-0.2806912958621979,
0.2858538031578064,
0.16700373589992523,
-0.5756314992904663,
-0.22840476036071777,
1.0686750411987305,
1.0233359336853027,
0.34483903646469116,
-0.21609677374362946,
-0.8366467356681824,
0.11214125156402588,
-0.37836742401123047,
1.1498379707336426,
-0.2671799063682556,
0.14970391988754272,
0.015481716953217983,
-0.40478837490081787,
-0.008312046527862549,
-0.2884541153907776,
0.9073286652565002,
-0.7904103398323059,
0.11854656785726547,
-0.49663639068603516,
-0.7335451245307922,
-0.3755919933319092,
0.7375117540359497,
-0.6287108063697815,
1.069746971130371,
0.119818314909935,
-0.882193922996521,
0.48172757029533386,
-0.5346827507019043,
-0.5617753863334656,
0.2697131037712097,
-0.2535511255264282,
-0.3903283178806305,
-0.31572696566581726,
0.11400218307971954,
0.5012254118919373,
-0.28910180926322937,
0.4532106816768646,
-0.48856666684150696,
-0.16471274197101593,
0.1977650672197342,
0.06926864385604858,
0.7150506377220154,
0.12369291484355927,
-0.052972108125686646,
0.21924777328968048,
-1.1510300636291504,
-0.017768211662769318,
0.10095987468957901,
-0.12863481044769287,
-0.34910088777542114,
0.06068585440516472,
-0.3979763090610504,
0.3617335557937622,
0.09828690439462662,
-0.9848828315734863,
0.05545853078365326,
-0.27394962310791016,
0.22845163941383362,
0.20928584039211273,
0.2264752835035324,
0.03292093798518181,
-0.37216219305992126,
0.01720861904323101,
0.041209276765584946,
0.2986423075199127,
-0.06420695036649704,
-0.4293847382068634,
-0.9233857989311218,
-0.1872699111700058,
0.5867066383361816,
0.715329647064209,
-1.2964788675308228,
0.7406670451164246,
-0.5142902135848999,
-0.7984602451324463,
-0.1877821683883667,
0.29605039954185486,
0.0026244674809277058,
0.9522740840911865,
0.2095385193824768,
0.11034221202135086,
-0.4649670124053955,
-0.3769861161708832,
-0.07511734962463379,
-0.5451956391334534,
-0.07479684799909592,
0.156417578458786,
0.2924176752567291,
0.13245238363742828,
1.2419451475143433,
-0.7426257133483887,
-0.2907494008541107,
-0.28641945123672485,
0.3509090542793274,
0.5604259371757507,
-0.08776825666427612,
0.7708443999290466,
-0.8577869534492493,
-0.43631529808044434,
-0.3290312588214874,
-1.016301155090332,
-0.1450875699520111,
-0.21788589656352997,
-0.035530366003513336,
0.08453740179538727,
0.3118000626564026,
-0.8771827220916748,
0.013828697614371777,
0.46295276284217834,
-0.5577685236930847,
0.38190776109695435,
-0.003959945868700743,
0.44272539019584656,
-0.6914905905723572,
0.25007668137550354,
0.1855589896440506,
-0.4056113064289093,
-0.7830345630645752,
0.07881063967943192,
0.049850694835186005,
-0.06323854625225067,
-0.39163294434547424,
0.05787898600101471,
-0.2154666632413864,
0.3510437607765198,
-0.0487075038254261,
0.4670375883579254,
-0.09791494160890579,
0.40064847469329834,
-0.09047741442918777,
0.6374654769897461,
0.6747260093688965,
-0.6995726227760315,
0.8473208546638489,
0.5059800148010254,
-0.17069587111473083,
0.7503204345703125,
-0.40018996596336365,
0.0761655867099762,
-0.22101977467536926,
0.17022158205509186,
-1.2328404188156128,
-0.17722566425800323,
0.4344423711299896,
-0.5438078045845032,
0.061705999076366425,
-0.46445611119270325,
-0.7471907734870911,
-0.1661459356546402,
-0.6970472931861877,
-0.13581836223602295,
0.2169957011938095,
-0.6158737540245056,
0.803879976272583,
-0.0018751837778836489,
-0.03478593751788139,
-0.4499180316925049,
-0.21101561188697815,
0.32903429865837097,
0.1334739625453949,
-0.8410621285438538,
0.11857584118843079,
0.03824037313461304,
-0.1849343180656433,
0.12954625487327576,
-0.1785161942243576,
-0.15931102633476257,
0.07286257296800613,
0.29797741770744324,
0.6403452754020691,
-0.08661071956157684,
0.36982807517051697,
-0.17972376942634583,
-0.21389879286289215,
0.14175203442573547,
-0.058134350925683975,
0.38870301842689514,
0.2562180161476135,
-0.23308537900447845,
-0.14134640991687775,
-0.1315346658229828,
0.5145213603973389,
-0.10444148629903793,
0.8907206058502197,
0.664273202419281,
-0.14131656289100647,
-0.05350854992866516,
-0.6775292158126831,
-0.3217150568962097,
-0.43066826462745667,
-0.13090388476848602,
-0.14808858931064606,
-0.9034082889556885,
0.18276137113571167,
-0.324409157037735,
0.04494601488113403,
0.5164515972137451,
0.09539896249771118,
0.2425825446844101,
0.48466458916664124,
0.460178405046463,
-0.17373889684677124,
0.23670482635498047,
-0.10718811303377151,
0.6692280769348145,
-0.25567442178726196,
-0.3009222149848938,
-0.6578142046928406,
0.29029297828674316,
-0.6419533491134644,
-0.26183241605758667,
0.548620879650116,
-0.2153594046831131,
0.06386198848485947,
0.25671541690826416,
-0.1304987370967865,
0.5047475695610046,
0.4236956536769867,
0.22212737798690796,
0.5480698347091675,
-0.033264897763729095,
0.14297832548618317,
0.2078864574432373,
-0.901033341884613,
-0.2745402455329895,
0.8478544354438782,
-0.1729326844215393,
0.47015029191970825,
0.13955697417259216,
0.7363523244857788,
0.4609659016132355,
0.4149053990840912,
-0.911975622177124,
0.6860581040382385,
0.041999589651823044,
-0.6900234222412109,
-0.42792412638664246,
-0.7877673506736755,
-0.3761676549911499,
-0.01865231804549694,
-0.8580282926559448,
-0.3983604311943054,
0.019490107893943787,
0.23451830446720123,
-0.438181072473526,
0.44895288348197937,
-0.4444856345653534,
0.5228049755096436,
-0.1532370001077652,
-0.43891021609306335,
-0.32121920585632324,
-0.4608684182167053,
0.549688458442688,
0.08407160639762878,
0.27425092458724976,
-0.2929534614086151,
0.3491964042186737,
0.34898900985717773,
-0.35790395736694336,
0.630387544631958,
-0.17571479082107544,
-0.08083895593881607,
0.35658952593803406,
0.18445196747779846,
0.4898967742919922,
0.0972316637635231,
-0.11567844450473785,
0.3857056200504303,
0.07105402648448944,
0.013427706435322762,
-0.7997846007347107,
0.806794285774231,
-0.40920117497444153,
-0.6279448866844177,
-0.7082717418670654,
-0.3384198248386383,
-0.3884875178337097,
0.35491743683815,
-0.10011899471282959,
0.4050501585006714,
-0.2231261283159256,
0.07131623476743698,
0.9181993007659912,
0.13727426528930664,
0.03871994465589523,
0.7783944010734558,
0.01553252525627613,
-0.31853926181793213,
1.0020408630371094,
0.13869427144527435,
-0.20571750402450562,
0.42934688925743103,
0.10291767865419388,
-0.5088798403739929,
-0.3118450939655304,
-0.6267704367637634,
0.5886295437812805,
-0.5838540196418762,
-0.6016953587532043,
-0.5650873780250549,
-0.30245617032051086,
-0.6479673385620117,
0.35114428400993347,
-0.04058533161878586,
-0.6318901181221008,
0.015258561819791794,
-0.09199707955121994,
0.8900576829910278,
0.8184454441070557,
-0.3107762336730957,
-0.04975391924381256,
-0.8231984972953796,
0.6222963929176331,
0.48952019214630127,
0.6453410983085632,
-0.2916545569896698,
0.021163539960980415,
0.01622939296066761,
-0.19598254561424255,
-0.13301843404769897,
-0.9621497988700867,
-0.2309102565050125,
0.2909572124481201,
0.17430877685546875,
0.503010094165802,
0.5623357892036438,
0.20243464410305023,
-0.4236909747123718,
0.6341567039489746,
0.10292501002550125,
-0.7495663166046143,
0.4681952893733978,
-0.2803594172000885,
-0.10619591921567917,
0.5370228886604309,
0.4378804862499237,
-0.682021975517273,
-0.29866474866867065,
-0.6531697511672974,
-0.5564404129981995,
0.7817517518997192,
0.25219905376434326,
-0.22696919739246368,
0.02449156902730465,
0.6841946840286255,
-0.30664870142936707,
0.07276757061481476,
-0.31614363193511963,
-0.5483173727989197,
-0.13624604046344757,
-0.4380536377429962,
0.0020181990694254637,
-0.5393731594085693,
-0.47883856296539307,
-0.09426216781139374,
1.047081470489502,
-0.34408634901046753,
-0.054972779005765915,
0.3644503951072693,
-0.03597376495599747,
-0.18545196950435638,
0.4880605638027191,
0.3922007381916046,
0.7546533346176147,
-0.3466704189777374,
0.30934369564056396,
0.30571097135543823,
-0.2592373490333557,
0.21418409049510956,
0.3255983293056488,
-0.6764616966247559,
0.389489084482193,
0.37263381481170654,
0.4471648931503296,
0.037847962230443954,
-0.3481872081756592,
0.5599518418312073,
-0.1534646600484848,
-0.22566041350364685,
0.2294442057609558,
0.4542694687843323,
0.12132341414690018,
0.11993655562400818,
0.23093385994434357,
-0.08560850471258163,
0.1528187096118927,
-0.3657362163066864,
0.34201228618621826,
0.25460997223854065,
-0.10204420238733292,
-0.12778373062610626,
0.34352362155914307,
0.30974000692367554,
-0.014654415659606457,
0.6380760669708252,
-0.3268545866012573,
-0.6469950079917908,
0.2976088225841522,
0.20852841436862946,
0.4392796754837036,
0.07008697837591171,
0.7185619473457336,
0.6434153914451599,
0.2741173505783081,
-0.02364303730428219,
0.24442632496356964,
-0.4126899838447571,
-0.7915000319480896,
-0.564020037651062,
-0.3453826308250427,
-0.5995544791221619,
0.04768725112080574,
-0.302419513463974,
0.4104202687740326,
-0.4829924702644348,
-0.10125038027763367,
0.22854720056056976,
0.14111214876174927,
-0.45456576347351074,
0.21341663599014282,
0.06480441987514496,
1.2246590852737427,
-1.2762720584869385,
0.6742881536483765,
0.5496561527252197,
-0.37181398272514343,
-0.7782084941864014,
0.046050332486629486,
0.22340402007102966,
-0.4811241030693054,
0.36935195326805115,
0.06365040689706802,
-0.421030193567276,
-0.09610569477081299,
-0.6640946269035339,
-0.6540921330451965,
1.0358967781066895,
0.6709816455841064,
-0.4838836193084717,
0.3290814459323883,
0.21487495303153992,
0.3777247369289398,
0.15975019335746765,
0.022525310516357422,
0.5686067938804626,
0.6669111251831055,
0.5792708396911621,
-0.2874426245689392,
0.4088703393936157,
0.13200367987155914,
-0.4654771089553833,
0.2345379889011383,
-0.8171460032463074,
0.3949958384037018,
-0.3357519805431366,
-0.35179734230041504,
-0.051918573677539825,
0.7818942070007324,
0.383617103099823,
0.453347772359848,
0.7845694422721863,
0.5392587184906006,
0.9029369354248047,
-0.2990433871746063,
0.6936238408088684,
-0.8151432871818542,
0.5739195346832275,
0.8809098601341248,
-0.5134606957435608,
0.5368598103523254,
0.3119860589504242,
-0.08325104415416718,
0.7868912220001221,
0.3229183256626129,
-0.3787285387516022,
0.20300492644309998,
-0.2861608862876892,
-0.36745473742485046,
-0.6637322902679443,
-0.495709091424942,
-0.10171230137348175,
0.41409656405448914,
0.0834893137216568,
0.12341400235891342,
-0.6715620756149292,
-0.5863693952560425,
0.4959920644760132,
0.11039432883262634,
0.07390708476305008,
0.7163523435592651,
-0.3595108389854431,
-0.879098653793335,
0.4700542986392975,
0.03042537160217762,
0.34922340512275696,
-0.8918718695640564,
-0.418003112077713,
-0.10444798320531845,
-0.03114955872297287,
-0.4400022625923157,
-0.9708496928215027,
0.11931992322206497,
0.33407455682754517,
-0.14067400991916656,
0.17668263614177704,
1.080178141593933,
-0.5491757988929749,
-0.3670186400413513,
0.04331141337752342,
0.5419638156890869,
-0.21289479732513428,
-0.10567079484462738,
-0.51771479845047,
-0.07637263089418411,
-0.15161164104938507,
0.19596152007579803,
-0.20272992551326752,
0.4540819525718689,
0.16023877263069153,
0.6634629368782043,
0.6566928029060364,
0.20945395529270172,
-0.4885411858558655,
0.1626906841993332,
0.9356994032859802,
-0.3802313804626465,
-0.3394136428833008,
-1.014309048652649,
-0.00730347353965044,
-0.43679752945899963,
0.08874842524528503,
1.0298234224319458,
0.6338497996330261,
0.576959490776062,
0.08887603878974915,
0.6507440209388733,
-0.4684789478778839,
0.3643825054168701,
-0.5039687752723694,
0.8241159915924072,
-0.0012179560726508498,
-0.16810645163059235,
0.11129139363765717,
-0.6325123310089111,
-0.6420256495475769,
0.36051690578460693,
-0.23619575798511505,
-0.15602485835552216,
0.5535929203033447,
1.1803165674209595,
-0.12252771109342575,
0.22126244008541107,
0.30375170707702637,
0.3785601854324341,
0.21751227974891663,
0.10262253135442734,
0.6084374189376831,
-0.3038768172264099,
0.6369505524635315,
-0.10221825540065765,
-0.35395562648773193,
-0.1244242861866951,
-1.1105910539627075,
-0.980053722858429,
-0.4131809175014496,
-0.7178971767425537,
-0.5089078545570374,
0.1664605736732483,
0.8948453068733215,
0.8118011355400085,
-0.8250888586044312,
0.06854795664548874,
0.13827688992023468,
0.8332013487815857,
-0.11453168839216232,
-0.22140979766845703,
0.2541186809539795,
-0.4009553790092468,
-0.050893384963274,
0.2924080789089203,
0.3566941022872925,
-0.3400581479072571,
-0.23446111381053925,
0.1294041872024536,
-0.632882297039032,
0.23067590594291687,
0.5274093747138977,
0.2718701958656311,
-0.15856364369392395,
-0.4715292453765869,
-0.26323339343070984,
0.1935422420501709,
0.19912421703338623,
0.9960270524024963,
-0.8888901472091675,
0.3573792278766632,
0.8440132737159729,
0.1354520618915558,
0.3646989166736603,
0.04210887476801872,
0.20928865671157837,
-0.9175792336463928,
-0.12044684588909149,
-0.4384098947048187,
0.32923275232315063,
0.8187216520309448,
-0.7033024430274963,
0.6031860709190369,
0.5326906442642212,
-0.19133342802524567,
-0.6208155155181885,
0.35295069217681885,
-0.8787590265274048,
-0.06725208461284637,
1.0264019966125488,
-0.19301912188529968,
-0.438893586397171,
-0.19723953306674957,
-0.06979184597730637,
0.5120506286621094,
-0.36291825771331787,
0.9727329611778259,
0.7293268442153931,
-0.2752397656440735,
-0.04165192320942879,
-0.09483195841312408,
0.6863770484924316,
-0.20010796189308167,
-0.7466446161270142,
0.2545499801635742,
0.6018304228782654,
0.6836089491844177,
0.3814791738986969,
0.1932225078344345,
0.12860378623008728,
0.3465767204761505,
-0.16282527148723602,
-0.1988045573234558,
-0.4876919686794281,
-0.3687679171562195,
-0.07092400640249252,
0.3471762239933014,
0.13456448912620544,
0.048988115042448044
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.01306v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.01306v1
|
Unsupervised Distractor Generation via Large Language Model Distilling and Counterfactual Contrastive Decoding
| 2024-06-03T13:20:05 | 2024-06-03T13:20:05 |
Fanyi Qu, Hao Sun, Yunfang Wu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Within the context of reading comprehension, the task of Distractor
Generation (DG) aims to generate several incorrect options to confuse readers.
Traditional supervised methods for DG rely heavily on expensive human-annotated
distractor labels. In this paper, we propose an unsupervised DG framework,
leveraging Large Language Models (LLMs) as cost-effective annotators to enhance
the DG capability of smaller student models. Specially, to perform knowledge
distilling, we propose a dual task training strategy that integrates pseudo
distractors from LLMs and the original answer in-formation as the objective
targets with a two-stage training process. Moreover, we devise a counterfactual
contrastive decoding mechanism for increasing the distracting capability of the
DG model. Experiments show that our unsupervised generation method with
Bart-base greatly surpasses GPT-3.5-turbo performance with only 200 times fewer
model parameters. Our proposed unsupervised DG method offers a cost-effective
framework for practical reading comprehension applications, without the need of
laborious distractor annotation and costly large-size models
|
[
-0.45412352681159973,
-0.7330423593521118,
0.5510545969009399,
-0.21601766347885132,
-0.7524933218955994,
0.0007580340607091784,
-0.12560948729515076,
-0.4021921753883362,
-0.25038477778434753,
0.5961592197418213,
-0.5312609672546387,
-0.17445677518844604,
-0.5699067711830139,
0.04791197553277016,
-0.2377406358718872,
0.8710354566574097,
0.1480054408311844,
-0.0015310341259464622,
-0.3100820481777191,
0.22332510352134705,
-0.430122047662735,
-0.5813887119293213,
-0.6509148478507996,
-0.5502215027809143,
0.4492994546890259,
0.412861704826355,
0.1979701668024063,
0.4533803462982178,
0.20724837481975555,
0.28772905468940735,
-0.1825541853904724,
0.3211054503917694,
-0.45003610849380493,
0.13513515889644623,
-0.27165910601615906,
-0.4259769916534424,
0.06366981565952301,
-0.10910359025001526,
0.3817092776298523,
0.6287089586257935,
-0.03388584032654762,
-0.010339616797864437,
0.34673193097114563,
0.763177752494812,
-0.6113380789756775,
0.3093460202217102,
-0.658849835395813,
-0.2454298436641693,
-0.22506362199783325,
0.03139614313840866,
-0.4605310559272766,
0.03936693072319031,
0.17046134173870087,
-0.5823523998260498,
0.460791677236557,
-0.013693205080926418,
0.5151224732398987,
0.8298352360725403,
-0.48798543214797974,
-0.3351798355579376,
-0.5247529149055481,
0.8951446413993835,
-0.6598924398422241,
0.11888523399829865,
0.5164154171943665,
0.05768957734107971,
0.0006975422147661448,
-0.5977230072021484,
-0.80821293592453,
-0.11291342228651047,
-0.37249162793159485,
0.3125081956386566,
-0.2777263820171356,
-0.1218450516462326,
0.30540478229522705,
0.24605700373649597,
-0.47840386629104614,
0.08963565528392792,
-0.22686105966567993,
0.09524909406900406,
0.567665159702301,
-0.006664146203547716,
-0.02916506491601467,
-0.21747559309005737,
-0.4252459704875946,
-0.09921260923147202,
-0.5684795379638672,
-0.30632850527763367,
0.34794938564300537,
0.049907151609659195,
0.1825227290391922,
0.3740076422691345,
-0.15230204164981842,
0.5167247653007507,
0.4656364321708679,
-0.06857093423604965,
0.1040409728884697,
-0.2532864212989807,
-0.02016698755323887,
0.1317143589258194,
0.6902173161506653,
0.3357681930065155,
0.2824725806713104,
-0.10529844462871552,
-0.23009631037712097,
0.1729317456483841,
0.33028319478034973,
-1.0436617136001587,
-0.6143003702163696,
0.04364252835512161,
-0.23112116754055023,
-0.5055791735649109,
-0.3537454307079315,
-1.0022677183151245,
-0.40356865525245667,
-0.2608632445335388,
0.2564854025840759,
-0.3989671468734741,
-0.2504081130027771,
0.1296459585428238,
-0.048529818654060364,
-0.2929568886756897,
0.08803727477788925,
-0.9396336078643799,
-0.04644879326224327,
0.1273968666791916,
0.5645952224731445,
-0.0789259672164917,
-0.1522321254014969,
-0.38979268074035645,
0.18866591155529022,
-0.23675382137298584,
0.8205906748771667,
-0.2101951539516449,
-0.39208972454071045,
-0.03127812221646309,
-0.21885085105895996,
-0.17564305663108826,
-0.5768364071846008,
0.38123223185539246,
-0.576198160648346,
0.2858298718929291,
-0.3220069706439972,
-0.571975827217102,
-0.3928132951259613,
0.17867136001586914,
-0.7057399153709412,
1.2192398309707642,
0.16180013120174408,
-1.0514850616455078,
0.4059739410877228,
-0.6406289339065552,
-0.42283234000205994,
0.38856008648872375,
0.041649229824543,
-0.44364073872566223,
0.13621266186237335,
0.5272547006607056,
0.3895430266857147,
-0.3891684114933014,
0.5687968134880066,
0.08836681395769119,
-0.26966747641563416,
0.28323793411254883,
-0.5400633811950684,
0.5732064247131348,
0.20030485093593597,
-0.44592908024787903,
0.09493132680654526,
-0.8594735264778137,
-0.361789733171463,
0.2938842177391052,
-0.3598747253417969,
-0.6733235716819763,
0.1261529177427292,
0.09573687613010406,
0.33454734086990356,
0.20303279161453247,
-0.5967516899108887,
-0.1351710706949234,
-0.15010491013526917,
0.3499422073364258,
0.39746716618537903,
0.1647995412349701,
0.28903886675834656,
-0.25931262969970703,
0.28126999735832214,
0.38076433539390564,
-0.2598484754562378,
-0.33605992794036865,
-0.12734022736549377,
-0.8270451426506042,
-0.7122179269790649,
0.17559516429901123,
0.4572349488735199,
-1.110396146774292,
0.5958879590034485,
0.01682979054749012,
-0.3400633633136749,
-0.3058759868144989,
0.2178533971309662,
0.6266483664512634,
0.8733478784561157,
0.6123151779174805,
0.22546841204166412,
-0.36210015416145325,
-0.6492604613304138,
-0.00038595995283685625,
-0.15070436894893646,
-0.17777474224567413,
0.026015765964984894,
0.5359430909156799,
-0.22566989064216614,
0.759400486946106,
-0.7241296172142029,
-0.39536556601524353,
-0.4613165259361267,
0.37482357025146484,
-0.18262232840061188,
0.42134103178977966,
0.4195195138454437,
-0.9231366515159607,
-0.6150721907615662,
-0.30053260922431946,
-0.6055151224136353,
-0.40111979842185974,
-0.20809637010097504,
-0.026873694732785225,
0.35162222385406494,
0.9262644052505493,
-0.2804672420024872,
0.3512003421783447,
0.22309178113937378,
-0.22670885920524597,
0.49164068698883057,
-0.3354690372943878,
-0.12118928134441376,
-1.2370485067367554,
0.21439126133918762,
0.13872185349464417,
-0.14567941427230835,
-0.6079908609390259,
-0.03394633159041405,
0.13566438853740692,
0.11677175760269165,
-0.33637306094169617,
0.5170074105262756,
-0.5528914928436279,
0.596207320690155,
-0.6583277583122253,
0.23802107572555542,
0.11153014749288559,
0.5116264820098877,
0.4214200973510742,
0.4749644696712494,
0.37766969203948975,
-0.43470463156700134,
0.2492137849330902,
0.3543650507926941,
-0.3956962525844574,
0.5815043449401855,
-0.584114670753479,
-0.07376795262098312,
-0.3107122480869293,
0.3471531867980957,
-1.2049195766448975,
-0.11695633828639984,
0.18547388911247253,
0.04876608029007912,
0.4532853662967682,
-0.2655860185623169,
-0.542675256729126,
-0.5433209538459778,
-0.0650043785572052,
0.4701760709285736,
0.6923294067382812,
-0.9885498285293579,
0.28743910789489746,
0.1808582842350006,
-0.34363704919815063,
-0.5379385948181152,
-0.9554505348205566,
-0.14413921535015106,
-0.4897219240665436,
-0.27673259377479553,
0.13980732858181,
-0.1726461946964264,
-0.22161056101322174,
-0.09038929641246796,
-0.13872510194778442,
0.013571256771683693,
-0.050118785351514816,
0.2720257043838501,
0.4127644896507263,
-0.02309795282781124,
0.22654330730438232,
0.3012097179889679,
-0.28442129492759705,
0.07860424369573593,
-0.28274738788604736,
0.36390674114227295,
0.40098583698272705,
-0.3662266731262207,
-0.002145987469702959,
0.45062124729156494,
0.3154049515724182,
-0.3578478991985321,
0.6448546051979065,
0.5277459621429443,
-0.10463663190603256,
-0.4425083100795746,
-0.6306613683700562,
-0.299424409866333,
-0.46400293707847595,
0.6710647344589233,
-0.41156888008117676,
-0.8882893323898315,
0.386091947555542,
-0.2550975978374481,
0.09184981137514114,
0.22966019809246063,
0.4994313418865204,
0.12543469667434692,
0.8223801255226135,
0.4466390609741211,
0.11130846291780472,
0.5903928875923157,
0.06130323186516762,
0.25073954463005066,
-0.5817608833312988,
-0.28641223907470703,
-0.19534964859485626,
-0.24657604098320007,
-0.14623118937015533,
-0.5459302067756653,
0.09925138205289841,
0.5652449131011963,
0.10771248489618301,
-0.02476515807211399,
-0.6148456931114197,
0.7214425802230835,
0.8044060468673706,
0.019075213000178337,
0.3365577757358551,
0.06558376550674438,
-0.32127317786216736,
-0.019825004041194916,
-0.5290905237197876,
-0.5095490217208862,
1.1046686172485352,
0.07122790813446045,
0.6907093524932861,
0.016487088054418564,
0.7722592353820801,
0.09089859575033188,
0.26595115661621094,
-0.6942835450172424,
0.538316011428833,
-0.22728091478347778,
-0.5924152731895447,
-0.4410635828971863,
-0.5366116762161255,
-0.7351177930831909,
0.6876683235168457,
-0.1232442781329155,
-0.6217470169067383,
0.2806450426578522,
0.22603115439414978,
-0.2829754948616028,
0.2888622581958771,
-0.7084982991218567,
0.9461050629615784,
-0.08374597132205963,
-0.34843578934669495,
-0.09470394253730774,
-0.4911010265350342,
0.41604360938072205,
-0.4744243323802948,
-0.005255343858152628,
0.17437879741191864,
0.16632713377475739,
0.6451873779296875,
-0.3155767321586609,
0.973232626914978,
-0.23574070632457733,
-0.15242570638656616,
0.5193607807159424,
0.12283433228731155,
0.4759127199649811,
0.07853493094444275,
-0.01746245287358761,
0.11440963298082352,
-0.13485701382160187,
-0.35660073161125183,
-0.20864425599575043,
0.6015648245811462,
-0.5405582785606384,
-0.5152831077575684,
-0.466897577047348,
-1.0147600173950195,
-0.23225551843643188,
0.37095436453819275,
0.5062173008918762,
0.28662633895874023,
-0.2633378803730011,
-0.000499206013046205,
0.7347946166992188,
0.050608668476343155,
0.7951359748840332,
0.6735163331031799,
0.12580300867557526,
-0.29321521520614624,
0.8390231728553772,
-0.1309298574924469,
0.24206356704235077,
0.45458611845970154,
0.25116825103759766,
-0.7034108638763428,
-0.7673501372337341,
-0.4304426610469818,
0.26219403743743896,
-0.6055973172187805,
-0.040218204259872437,
-0.6023711562156677,
-0.053386759012937546,
-0.24762322008609772,
-0.11221552640199661,
-0.20918433368206024,
-0.09013240784406662,
-0.5368734002113342,
-0.1681167185306549,
0.2062368541955948,
0.6838503479957581,
-0.317026287317276,
0.5431097149848938,
-0.559261679649353,
0.36814963817596436,
0.43762096762657166,
-0.1460985392332077,
-0.008217121474444866,
-0.579190731048584,
-0.4632842242717743,
0.0710848793387413,
-0.43067049980163574,
-0.643297553062439,
0.4921146035194397,
-0.23828281462192535,
0.4479285180568695,
0.5311501026153564,
0.6374451518058777,
0.42817673087120056,
-0.46164974570274353,
0.6035286784172058,
0.36166805028915405,
-0.9174953103065491,
0.19739429652690887,
-0.26686254143714905,
0.4607480764389038,
0.5211632251739502,
0.1943558156490326,
-0.23694227635860443,
-0.4240529239177704,
-0.38585641980171204,
-0.975872278213501,
1.0119620561599731,
-0.12398352473974228,
-0.19272956252098083,
-0.20807521045207977,
0.1479337066411972,
0.17906595766544342,
0.06983352452516556,
-0.8105171322822571,
-0.04152126610279083,
-0.3979078233242035,
-0.3902948498725891,
-0.3675018846988678,
-0.6726735830307007,
-0.15688583254814148,
0.18046727776527405,
0.6870178580284119,
-0.2183924913406372,
-0.3788197338581085,
0.11542614549398422,
-0.39757052063941956,
-0.14071130752563477,
0.392518013715744,
0.4886360764503479,
0.45316779613494873,
-0.19149427115917206,
0.35142138600349426,
0.005016982089728117,
-0.4971931576728821,
0.05415822193026543,
0.5133523344993591,
-0.30391788482666016,
-0.16885043680667877,
0.26095056533813477,
0.6986234784126282,
0.1147407740354538,
-0.6574594974517822,
0.3117493689060211,
0.09177812188863754,
-0.5072295665740967,
-0.018906936049461365,
-0.04250359535217285,
0.3573124408721924,
0.48035165667533875,
0.41374510526657104,
-0.2383570373058319,
-0.11526437103748322,
-0.048984527587890625,
0.1798652708530426,
0.27453580498695374,
-0.1850060522556305,
-0.0794549509882927,
0.6363901495933533,
0.34453660249710083,
0.20153236389160156,
0.42349082231521606,
-0.4711748957633972,
-0.5195073485374451,
0.33768248558044434,
0.817261815071106,
0.6711214780807495,
-0.2889021635055542,
0.21566660702228546,
0.3725557327270508,
0.23236368596553802,
-0.33342817425727844,
0.012562154792249203,
-0.2755165696144104,
-0.5209240913391113,
-0.3117973506450653,
-0.616156280040741,
-0.1811181753873825,
0.4337959289550781,
-0.7060131430625916,
-0.13452591001987457,
-0.031166406348347664,
0.14793191850185394,
0.07742936909198761,
0.06579488515853882,
-0.2832942605018616,
0.3405269980430603,
0.3406398892402649,
0.32417285442352295,
-0.8446351289749146,
1.0098611116409302,
0.7545304894447327,
-0.4984748959541321,
-0.492766797542572,
0.3582778573036194,
-0.07232815772294998,
-0.4023057222366333,
0.7468920350074768,
0.08948297798633575,
-0.15438656508922577,
0.04577605426311493,
-0.12941506505012512,
-0.5590410828590393,
0.8917995691299438,
0.24459601938724518,
-1.0220037698745728,
-0.1275884509086609,
0.2695854902267456,
0.4956350028514862,
-0.1507721245288849,
0.2510009706020355,
0.5123007893562317,
0.28533512353897095,
0.45815107226371765,
-0.5258210897445679,
0.3314114511013031,
-0.00010373400436947122,
-0.007496712729334831,
0.1885899007320404,
-0.5060082077980042,
0.901777982711792,
-0.32131579518318176,
-0.2676737606525421,
0.02506246604025364,
0.36050382256507874,
0.313376784324646,
0.29642608761787415,
0.6368173956871033,
0.6223446726799011,
0.6804957389831543,
0.14814624190330505,
0.6423303484916687,
-0.24484069645404816,
0.21403245627880096,
1.304050087928772,
-0.3105821907520294,
0.6188036799430847,
0.6256706118583679,
0.1631758213043213,
0.2117370367050171,
0.3923722207546234,
-0.08363527804613113,
0.7979446053504944,
0.3755113184452057,
-0.3223341405391693,
-0.5267946124076843,
0.0994243174791336,
-0.09021008759737015,
0.27209049463272095,
0.18838931620121002,
-0.4049445390701294,
-0.3699118196964264,
0.11616230010986328,
0.023619605228304863,
0.27502599358558655,
-0.17411881685256958,
0.8591379523277283,
0.10599852353334427,
-0.8120502233505249,
0.7306286096572876,
-0.09618067741394043,
0.7623090744018555,
-0.5544479489326477,
0.14265096187591553,
-0.2626896798610687,
0.6953880786895752,
0.08239942044019699,
-0.5817237496376038,
0.14777107536792755,
0.16463567316532135,
-0.3765453100204468,
-0.20288780331611633,
0.6084384322166443,
-0.8644905686378479,
-0.48190590739250183,
0.4190548062324524,
0.5631208419799805,
0.039948638528585434,
-0.42565709352493286,
-0.4982021450996399,
-0.30115681886672974,
0.17037691175937653,
-0.44380342960357666,
0.4141564667224884,
0.6431539058685303,
-0.08009131252765656,
0.3329574763774872,
0.6659374237060547,
-0.1576567441225052,
0.013306575827300549,
0.25043243169784546,
0.8590440154075623,
-0.4901789128780365,
-0.6911953091621399,
-0.8933114409446716,
0.5848827958106995,
0.0692199319601059,
-0.17713488638401031,
0.774154782295227,
0.4079245626926422,
0.7766662240028381,
-0.15039147436618805,
0.9013969302177429,
0.15273042023181915,
0.6932376027107239,
-0.24769987165927887,
0.8599498867988586,
-0.6634382009506226,
0.19286350905895233,
-0.25799667835235596,
-0.7729800343513489,
-0.19210806488990784,
0.4700307548046112,
-0.4495987296104431,
-0.05436854064464569,
0.8841632008552551,
0.702721893787384,
-0.1418943703174591,
0.0698910728096962,
0.5996896028518677,
0.028742589056491852,
0.32422158122062683,
0.6850605010986328,
0.9037194848060608,
-0.07166145741939545,
0.790520429611206,
-0.22119450569152832,
-0.32079482078552246,
-0.2666713297367096,
-0.6967601180076599,
-1.679192304611206,
-0.5123527646064758,
-0.54743891954422,
-0.09416686743497849,
-0.05560750886797905,
0.4128359258174896,
0.6135674715042114,
-0.6727445125579834,
0.11468619108200073,
-0.3304942548274994,
-0.11386600881814957,
-0.0843098908662796,
-0.18306218087673187,
0.4866369664669037,
-0.3208427429199219,
-0.9551904797554016,
0.40653523802757263,
-0.10590072721242905,
0.10806775093078613,
-0.14354293048381805,
0.10358014702796936,
-0.3196726143360138,
0.26153144240379333,
0.4771444797515869,
0.10319674015045166,
-0.6730605363845825,
-0.04369990900158882,
-0.3755023777484894,
-0.1173756942152977,
-0.2740301191806793,
0.7311550378799438,
-0.7260489463806152,
0.36868545413017273,
0.24437814950942993,
0.469583123922348,
0.8269720673561096,
0.2048308104276657,
0.11395581066608429,
-0.8393751382827759,
0.3350684940814972,
0.07470215111970901,
0.2771994471549988,
0.401093453168869,
-0.3864343762397766,
0.24569617211818695,
0.21267589926719666,
-0.46675363183021545,
-0.8551383018493652,
0.30527374148368835,
-0.6243510842323303,
-0.7453816533088684,
1.2232006788253784,
-0.2941451966762543,
0.03932115063071251,
-0.31186819076538086,
-0.3495589792728424,
0.4427805542945862,
-0.37059637904167175,
0.8371562361717224,
0.5299157500267029,
-0.022189166396856308,
-0.26509901881217957,
-0.06314000487327576,
0.4949547052383423,
0.5672919154167175,
-0.834212064743042,
0.43477171659469604,
0.760603129863739,
0.32385891675949097,
0.29827311635017395,
0.3786502778530121,
0.034075286239385605,
0.041669461876153946,
0.6020451784133911,
0.2733406722545624,
-0.6713404655456543,
-0.21335133910179138,
-0.16815243661403656,
0.129805326461792,
-0.3005351424217224,
-0.4283468425273895
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.01304v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.01304v3
|
CodeR: Issue Resolving with Multi-Agent and Task Graphs
| 2024-06-03T13:13:35 | 2024-06-11T03:52:03 |
Dong Chen, Shaoxin Lin, Muhan Zeng, Daoguang Zan, Jian-Gang Wang, Anton Cheshkov, Jun Sun, Hao Yu, Guoliang Dong, Artem Aliev, Jie Wang, Xiao Cheng, Guangtai Liang, Yuchi Ma, Pan Bian, Tao Xie, Qianxiang Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.SE
|
GitHub issue resolving recently has attracted significant attention from
academia and industry. SWE-bench is proposed to measure the performance in
resolving issues. In this paper, we propose CodeR, which adopts a multi-agent
framework and pre-defined task graphs to Repair & Resolve reported bugs and add
new features within code Repository. On SWE-bench lite, CodeR is able to solve
28.33% of issues, when submitting only once for each issue. We examine the
performance impact of each design of CodeR and offer insights to advance this
research direction.
|
[
-0.48937907814979553,
-0.45188066363334656,
0.26927369832992554,
0.2081674337387085,
0.10314277559518814,
0.5574882626533508,
-0.06217295676469803,
-0.7222796082496643,
0.41679880023002625,
0.2843782603740692,
-0.3848140835762024,
-0.09406306594610214,
-0.5049502849578857,
-0.010499665513634682,
-0.31947511434555054,
0.9751631617546082,
-0.15710331499576569,
-0.11017633229494095,
-0.1642123907804489,
-0.462895005941391,
-0.7575198411941528,
-0.4938361942768097,
-0.7050173282623291,
-0.20093731582164764,
0.7073687314987183,
0.5500285029411316,
0.5975009799003601,
0.4207078814506531,
0.9175551533699036,
0.625917375087738,
0.4675590693950653,
-0.3098979890346527,
-0.4500064551830292,
0.41578203439712524,
-0.1870003342628479,
-0.5196205377578735,
-0.5233679413795471,
-0.509802520275116,
-0.008389852941036224,
0.13538417220115662,
0.017734933644533157,
0.42034029960632324,
-0.054236624389886856,
0.9977784156799316,
-0.46425676345825195,
0.22246313095092773,
-0.2099311649799347,
-0.23165500164031982,
-0.3811352550983429,
0.05325919762253761,
-0.37277767062187195,
-0.23607923090457916,
-0.31006065011024475,
-0.5172946453094482,
0.3675541281700134,
-0.2920856177806854,
0.7394351959228516,
0.4101202189922333,
-0.329860657453537,
-0.19965794682502747,
-0.6787973642349243,
0.23843908309936523,
-0.3240581452846527,
-0.14250019192695618,
-0.19984836876392365,
0.7210930585861206,
-0.15123552083969116,
-0.8179115653038025,
-0.07658182084560394,
0.2653738558292389,
-0.16265316307544708,
-0.10837607085704803,
-0.4278545379638672,
-0.2818911075592041,
0.15571361780166626,
0.2514243721961975,
-0.7715696096420288,
-0.10837168246507645,
-0.296639621257782,
-0.38619348406791687,
0.7186908721923828,
0.24425208568572998,
0.39344874024391174,
0.03851620480418205,
-0.21299037337303162,
-0.17678804695606232,
-0.04912570118904114,
0.2850574553012848,
-0.08365713059902191,
-0.0226760096848011,
0.2086809277534485,
0.33045798540115356,
0.02135036326944828,
0.6140755414962769,
0.014651334844529629,
-0.08017179369926453,
0.4826193153858185,
-0.2195347100496292,
0.24785937368869781,
-0.27752485871315,
0.4623720049858093,
0.24144230782985687,
0.15036740899085999,
-0.3156736493110657,
-0.5759923458099365,
0.3716460168361664,
0.6768636703491211,
-0.7605303525924683,
-0.2614774703979492,
0.5555773973464966,
-0.32961001992225647,
-0.1577562689781189,
0.12625731527805328,
-0.6764155030250549,
-0.717530369758606,
-0.13223066926002502,
0.31911152601242065,
-0.33305278420448303,
-0.8149580955505371,
-0.33187440037727356,
-0.5779338479042053,
-0.18710032105445862,
0.46435216069221497,
0.10812109708786011,
0.2181166708469391,
0.4846547544002533,
0.7222244739532471,
0.22753256559371948,
-0.5873422622680664,
-0.5499924421310425,
0.13857707381248474,
-0.3970295786857605,
1.2563395500183105,
-0.1921461671590805,
-0.28658196330070496,
-0.08065628260374069,
0.06867539137601852,
-0.17982234060764313,
-0.3220169246196747,
0.11167535185813904,
-0.5204374194145203,
-0.7143059372901917,
-0.37933728098869324,
-0.388920396566391,
0.1379031091928482,
0.5230992436408997,
-1.0529818534851074,
0.760443389415741,
0.45173200964927673,
-0.5394452214241028,
0.2713194787502289,
-1.1001192331314087,
-0.2562514543533325,
0.4473077952861786,
-0.1232258751988411,
-0.292041540145874,
0.0039333803579211235,
-0.043249115347862244,
0.003456748090684414,
-0.029542258009314537,
0.3228543698787689,
0.05620773509144783,
-0.7483831644058228,
0.3281308114528656,
0.39991340041160583,
0.20487773418426514,
0.333442360162735,
-0.6436142325401306,
0.644463837146759,
-0.7868114113807678,
0.2778509855270386,
0.32470569014549255,
-0.1109880656003952,
-0.1397033929824829,
0.036424651741981506,
0.2980245053768158,
0.24668030440807343,
0.2952779531478882,
-0.4728030860424042,
0.205107644200325,
-0.032591186463832855,
0.5096839666366577,
0.7319616079330444,
-0.19445428252220154,
0.23502753674983978,
-0.8265445232391357,
0.8032011389732361,
-0.03435460850596428,
0.09069637209177017,
-0.07906320691108704,
-0.16931481659412384,
-0.5119967460632324,
-0.3751589357852936,
0.31617507338523865,
0.44733527302742004,
-0.7478022575378418,
-0.22654888033866882,
-0.36395180225372314,
-0.6894960999488831,
-0.28283455967903137,
0.042697176337242126,
0.7508640289306641,
-0.03426206484436989,
0.3193780183792114,
-0.36222150921821594,
-0.5679140090942383,
-0.651545524597168,
-0.46177107095718384,
-0.2154286652803421,
0.13241590559482574,
0.26172664761543274,
0.515175461769104,
-0.3971351683139801,
1.080636978149414,
-0.5759868025779724,
-0.42582088708877563,
-0.11281302571296692,
0.575851559638977,
0.05496516451239586,
0.3368651866912842,
0.7349591255187988,
-0.832245409488678,
-0.6017553806304932,
-0.0425412654876709,
-0.5532185435295105,
-0.124290831387043,
0.3530270755290985,
0.030613262206315994,
0.5259101986885071,
0.3369426727294922,
-0.41898584365844727,
0.46799013018608093,
0.47627389430999756,
-0.2971198558807373,
0.5075434446334839,
-0.14749762415885925,
0.6909463405609131,
-0.95306396484375,
0.1147666946053505,
0.22794999182224274,
-0.1500464677810669,
-0.4070337414741516,
0.26499083638191223,
0.2797434628009796,
-0.664503276348114,
-0.27165690064430237,
0.39298713207244873,
-0.6819552779197693,
-0.18426014482975006,
-0.382781058549881,
0.06910020858049393,
0.1721993088722229,
0.3993469476699829,
-0.5037814974784851,
1.0517432689666748,
0.21724224090576172,
-0.4290366768836975,
0.3534793555736542,
0.02589765377342701,
-0.10404951125383377,
0.47870922088623047,
-0.8010401129722595,
0.3994240462779999,
-0.019622690975666046,
0.05595894530415535,
-1.3216654062271118,
-0.21158644556999207,
-0.033559463918209076,
-0.5824000239372253,
0.314125657081604,
-0.37785521149635315,
-0.5143213272094727,
-0.8432000279426575,
-0.394723117351532,
0.4103899896144867,
0.10836810618638992,
-0.29400715231895447,
0.49056103825569153,
0.44004127383232117,
-0.2615165114402771,
-0.5614134073257446,
-0.5412231087684631,
0.08812090754508972,
0.18704622983932495,
-0.9575305581092834,
0.47273221611976624,
-0.00880199670791626,
-0.30803367495536804,
0.3578275442123413,
-0.5320459604263306,
-0.49478381872177124,
-0.2385370135307312,
0.4375526010990143,
-0.010696828365325928,
-0.3729005753993988,
0.38824358582496643,
-0.5381492972373962,
-0.5294904708862305,
0.0850774273276329,
0.4806853234767914,
0.37876713275909424,
-0.5072298645973206,
-0.5182088017463684,
0.16120147705078125,
0.44907137751579285,
0.8914493322372437,
-0.6471701860427856,
0.42702245712280273,
0.48005175590515137,
-0.2129443734884262,
0.04607277363538742,
-0.8765119910240173,
0.03314032778143883,
-0.493828684091568,
0.4295739233493805,
-0.851576030254364,
-0.682304859161377,
0.8282995820045471,
-0.4052344262599945,
-0.11156995594501495,
0.29088249802589417,
0.1739954650402069,
0.05985190346837044,
0.8919641971588135,
0.6972890496253967,
-0.3690338730812073,
0.549432098865509,
-0.22106030583381653,
0.37485551834106445,
-0.34506675601005554,
-0.022622784599661827,
-1.122746229171753,
-0.27952268719673157,
-0.36268869042396545,
-0.31187745928764343,
0.36398616433143616,
0.22268694639205933,
-0.3545905649662018,
0.8382876515388489,
-1.0593653917312622,
0.4868815839290619,
0.1874682456254959,
0.14086510241031647,
0.1364872306585312,
-0.5960161685943604,
0.17586253583431244,
0.04236283525824547,
-0.5231238007545471,
-0.4063663184642792,
0.5817837715148926,
0.02176348678767681,
0.6570143699645996,
0.39022740721702576,
0.706432044506073,
0.35901421308517456,
0.35610613226890564,
-0.4036739468574524,
0.43746107816696167,
0.1948384791612625,
-0.7342265248298645,
-0.4280915856361389,
-0.34203240275382996,
-1.1617246866226196,
0.40778717398643494,
0.30123835802078247,
-0.6456319689750671,
0.1866191029548645,
-0.0012466220650821924,
0.23942530155181885,
0.07358831912279129,
-0.9198212623596191,
1.4420580863952637,
-0.25027552247047424,
-0.1409538984298706,
-0.49922215938568115,
-0.43529340624809265,
-0.011664225719869137,
0.09807034581899643,
0.5877835750579834,
-0.2457728236913681,
-0.023294586688280106,
0.6472700238227844,
-0.7770442366600037,
0.6218003630638123,
-0.5178744196891785,
0.11695805937051773,
0.21840326488018036,
0.10989892482757568,
0.7504532337188721,
0.12262268364429474,
-0.19224753975868225,
-0.1948593109846115,
0.2177688479423523,
-0.48650768399238586,
-0.4534982442855835,
0.6499881744384766,
-0.6478358507156372,
-0.47369101643562317,
-0.6703282594680786,
-0.626253604888916,
-0.09438937902450562,
0.3567439615726471,
0.03960610553622246,
0.5672005414962769,
-0.2836420238018036,
-0.0626390278339386,
0.09420842677354813,
0.13699154555797577,
0.7460374236106873,
0.949959933757782,
-0.22126002609729767,
-0.396872878074646,
0.8730807900428772,
0.3710647225379944,
-0.21323582530021667,
0.03630467504262924,
-0.3229968845844269,
0.16536012291908264,
-0.3089960515499115,
-0.6000977158546448,
-0.06784787774085999,
-0.6253553628921509,
-0.7877705693244934,
-0.4119318425655365,
-0.29337969422340393,
-0.1414317488670349,
-0.6071344017982483,
-0.6133649349212646,
-0.05365293100476265,
0.2594899833202362,
0.26336905360221863,
0.8234185576438904,
0.759173572063446,
0.22392000257968903,
0.1387072056531906,
-1.0050641298294067,
0.43024617433547974,
-0.015090669505298138,
0.5680542588233948,
-0.261849045753479,
0.12712205946445465,
-0.510181725025177,
-0.04730068892240524,
-0.3567694425582886,
-0.8550271391868591,
0.19565033912658691,
-0.24733322858810425,
0.6581924557685852,
-0.007912139408290386,
0.3841666281223297,
0.8163681030273438,
-0.19348149001598358,
0.5012175440788269,
0.2834918797016144,
-1.123305320739746,
0.7730346918106079,
-0.36321401596069336,
0.425486296415329,
0.8362948298454285,
0.0002362218510825187,
-0.29950618743896484,
-0.8105398416519165,
-0.3539930582046509,
-0.7619466781616211,
0.5835049748420715,
0.008344541303813457,
-0.15879033505916595,
-0.07544395327568054,
0.15108197927474976,
-0.2662351131439209,
0.20498640835285187,
-0.366265207529068,
-0.37263092398643494,
-0.2394896000623703,
0.209137424826622,
-0.06852303445339203,
-0.17214107513427734,
-0.24284523725509644,
-0.35757797956466675,
0.3391646444797516,
-0.3764008581638336,
0.3424752652645111,
0.05475872755050659,
-0.5673549175262451,
-0.5635566711425781,
0.7241194248199463,
0.34351006150245667,
1.3666679859161377,
-0.0909503772854805,
-0.23314589262008667,
-0.32350870966911316,
-0.18157625198364258,
0.3643540143966675,
0.5120643377304077,
0.42352524399757385,
0.05452415719628334,
0.4217063784599304,
0.31436705589294434,
0.43297451734542847,
-0.4684816896915436,
0.869786262512207,
0.10118118673563004,
-0.3298225700855255,
-0.1629045158624649,
0.15249137580394745,
0.18594497442245483,
0.47079676389694214,
0.6957948803901672,
0.5888655781745911,
0.16263580322265625,
-0.40013211965560913,
0.37764760851860046,
0.06654110550880432,
-0.48262202739715576,
0.07286304235458374,
0.5212356448173523,
0.44501474499702454,
-0.5908036828041077,
0.41890349984169006,
-0.2999769449234009,
-0.6668151021003723,
1.3100013732910156,
0.5028949975967407,
0.5415948033332825,
-0.132269948720932,
0.4730149209499359,
0.2094266265630722,
0.09923925995826721,
0.10878802835941315,
0.5199459195137024,
0.29658645391464233,
-0.6195389628410339,
-0.717719554901123,
0.09813495725393295,
-0.5135630965232849,
-0.4656505584716797,
-0.9012872576713562,
-0.006377856247127056,
0.03708663955330849,
-0.5245808362960815,
0.13226842880249023,
0.3385353088378906,
-0.38958272337913513,
-0.09421070665121078,
-0.6209622621536255,
0.8064625859260559,
-0.46830981969833374,
0.8195682168006897,
1.1674096584320068,
-0.8386654853820801,
-0.7207211256027222,
-0.23909905552864075,
0.13785861432552338,
-0.401807576417923,
0.3691844344139099,
0.26892584562301636,
-0.1108708307147026,
-0.028024235740303993,
-0.17897607386112213,
-0.6381053924560547,
1.2159318923950195,
0.46539101004600525,
-0.6263478994369507,
0.591992199420929,
-0.1934012621641159,
0.6424622535705566,
-0.05401729419827461,
0.3343298137187958,
0.28812581300735474,
0.7017502188682556,
-0.21884943544864655,
-1.1371649503707886,
0.08667828887701035,
-0.9408870339393616,
0.221445232629776,
0.8285855054855347,
-0.7660332322120667,
0.7934198975563049,
-0.2446446269750595,
0.0661059096455574,
-0.12182939797639847,
0.039617761969566345,
0.2988263964653015,
0.560904860496521,
0.6041206121444702,
0.38457030057907104,
0.6946760416030884,
-0.14702390134334564,
0.8909215331077576,
-0.6104575991630554,
0.33238717913627625,
0.8319984674453735,
-0.35166803002357483,
0.41004395484924316,
0.34980103373527527,
-0.3781418800354004,
0.6677467226982117,
0.3306751251220703,
0.07397330552339554,
0.29812169075012207,
0.39990949630737305,
-0.00829452183097601,
0.1811051070690155,
0.003543462138622999,
-0.881822407245636,
0.14177723228931427,
-0.10411735624074936,
0.1763596087694168,
-0.18610455095767975,
0.2977617383003235,
-0.1479351818561554,
0.15240924060344696,
-0.33114299178123474,
0.7908188700675964,
-0.26837843656539917,
-0.41796061396598816,
0.24862830340862274,
-0.11311006546020508,
0.487835168838501,
-0.5913392305374146,
-0.12343914806842804,
-0.17622792720794678,
0.4823966324329376,
-0.29225075244903564,
-0.5953359007835388,
0.50926274061203,
-0.0636897012591362,
-0.618358850479126,
-0.207674041390419,
1.1043329238891602,
0.12256211787462234,
-0.21998022496700287,
0.797943115234375,
0.697771430015564,
-0.07315436005592346,
-0.3707156777381897,
-0.7957550883293152,
0.31563299894332886,
-0.4274802505970001,
-0.27789345383644104,
0.5542245507240295,
0.7667359709739685,
0.09737417846918106,
0.6986997127532959,
0.1622660905122757,
-0.28328943252563477,
-0.06062822788953781,
0.23222823441028595,
1.322790265083313,
-0.7447177171707153,
-0.17476783692836761,
-0.3058776259422302,
0.9072238206863403,
-0.3714764416217804,
-0.2123449444770813,
0.5645942091941833,
0.7189601063728333,
0.4038238227367401,
-0.24442777037620544,
0.6321153044700623,
-0.5356143712997437,
0.5249277353286743,
0.20715005695819855,
0.5531059503555298,
-0.4383017420768738,
0.08158278465270996,
-0.742358386516571,
-0.5860412120819092,
-0.09582263976335526,
0.47506627440452576,
-0.029085272923111916,
-0.012698032893240452,
0.9761555194854736,
0.984800398349762,
0.32914745807647705,
-0.017358655110001564,
0.09368906915187836,
-0.009594831615686417,
0.22257409989833832,
0.5024583339691162,
0.6163796782493591,
-0.6401792168617249,
1.0339528322219849,
-0.3523440361022949,
-0.25076374411582947,
-0.24864117801189423,
-0.43343979120254517,
-0.5890382528305054,
-0.4723321795463562,
-0.4776347279548645,
-0.43989935517311096,
0.12994277477264404,
0.3634869456291199,
0.6698587536811829,
-0.7493680715560913,
-0.22051607072353363,
-0.1017165333032608,
0.3869990110397339,
-0.8072949647903442,
-0.2553379237651825,
0.14164860546588898,
-0.9446431994438171,
-0.08261284232139587,
0.393694669008255,
0.10703864693641663,
-0.6213574409484863,
0.25266581773757935,
-0.35682058334350586,
0.06307446956634521,
-0.3712635636329651,
0.3591807186603546,
0.33946681022644043,
-0.3634116053581238,
-0.35890620946884155,
-0.07217240333557129,
-0.5688181519508362,
0.31184858083724976,
1.379041075706482,
-0.44375893473625183,
0.26093730330467224,
0.3729037046432495,
0.6777154207229614,
0.9531674385070801,
-0.05447603389620781,
0.5680407285690308,
-0.6215333938598633,
0.07211298495531082,
0.10907701402902603,
0.39586955308914185,
-0.3380131423473358,
-0.5067851543426514,
1.0340487957000732,
0.0628725215792656,
-0.9394396543502808,
-0.693473219871521,
-0.13244400918483734,
-0.7262360453605652,
-0.6230461597442627,
0.39165571331977844,
-0.11621171236038208,
0.044909100979566574,
-0.6087127327919006,
-0.24502164125442505,
0.2206878364086151,
-0.4795529842376709,
0.3550676107406616,
0.6727370619773865,
-0.4166421592235565,
-0.5583733916282654,
-0.46618756651878357,
-0.07244732975959778,
0.23996783792972565,
-0.8578413724899292,
-0.2701840102672577,
0.84592604637146,
0.30334994196891785,
0.4168849289417267,
1.2598686218261719,
-0.12285879254341125,
0.566394031047821,
0.5203231573104858,
0.48820748925209045,
-0.3273496627807617,
-0.5101563930511475,
0.19142071902751923,
0.5835124254226685,
0.3981475234031677,
-0.2645513415336609
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.01297v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.01297v1
|
When Can LLMs Actually Correct Their Own Mistakes? A Critical Survey of Self-Correction of LLMs
| 2024-06-03T13:05:46 | 2024-06-03T13:05:46 |
Ryo Kamoi, Yusen Zhang, Nan Zhang, Jiawei Han, Rui Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Self-correction is an approach to improving responses from large language
models (LLMs) by refining the responses using LLMs during inference. Prior work
has proposed various self-correction frameworks using different sources of
feedback, including self-evaluation and external feedback. However, there is
still no consensus on the question of when LLMs can correct their own mistakes,
as recent studies also report negative results. In this work, we critically
survey broad papers and discuss the conditions required for successful
self-correction. We first find that prior studies often do not define their
research questions in detail and involve impractical frameworks or unfair
evaluations that over-evaluate self-correction. To tackle these issues, we
categorize research questions in self-correction research and provide a
checklist for designing appropriate experiments. Our critical survey based on
the newly categorized research questions shows that (1) no prior work
demonstrates successful self-correction with feedback from prompted LLMs in
general tasks, (2) self-correction works well in tasks that can use reliable
external feedback, and (3) large-scale fine-tuning enables self-correction.
|
[
-0.12192351371049881,
-0.7535319328308105,
0.6070325970649719,
0.153235524892807,
0.32304859161376953,
0.006864044349640608,
-0.3838309347629547,
-0.4457206130027771,
0.20698130130767822,
0.6056944131851196,
-0.5669446587562561,
-0.06324749439954758,
-0.4284229576587677,
0.6177258491516113,
-0.420369952917099,
1.0293021202087402,
-0.24662218987941742,
0.38925400376319885,
-0.1804036796092987,
-0.17171575129032135,
-0.6037178039550781,
-0.6108618378639221,
-0.5536450147628784,
-0.1469709873199463,
0.7985787987709045,
0.8498422503471375,
0.2223288118839264,
0.43694984912872314,
0.5587102770805359,
0.3728775084018707,
-0.03514759987592697,
0.32442212104797363,
-0.6508801579475403,
0.0988248735666275,
-0.5163577795028687,
-0.747763454914093,
-0.3757494390010834,
0.11975035071372986,
0.5307537913322449,
0.5632886290550232,
-0.2386443167924881,
0.3339855372905731,
0.38165801763534546,
0.8867683410644531,
-0.6450070738792419,
-0.2128283977508545,
-0.46658071875572205,
0.1465318351984024,
-0.308569997549057,
-0.07304362952709198,
-0.4263623058795929,
-0.22365917265415192,
-0.24830922484397888,
-0.18668793141841888,
0.5238869190216064,
-0.07451549172401428,
0.2318471521139145,
0.4902588427066803,
-0.37594687938690186,
-0.3121565878391266,
-1.1328094005584717,
0.6137390732765198,
-1.0354243516921997,
0.15238314867019653,
0.4416629672050476,
0.1291768103837967,
-0.3511890172958374,
-0.5913541913032532,
-0.4245492219924927,
-0.0859711766242981,
-0.09938593953847885,
0.0475902184844017,
0.03758252412080765,
0.013769351877272129,
0.5087400078773499,
0.36238911747932434,
-0.1715659499168396,
0.313218891620636,
-0.4929695725440979,
-0.2157510668039322,
0.6258319616317749,
0.24466829001903534,
-0.02682034857571125,
-0.10329145193099976,
-0.06745181232690811,
0.020324844866991043,
-0.8606631755828857,
-0.09880048781633377,
0.4125117063522339,
0.27084845304489136,
0.25467658042907715,
0.7248759865760803,
-0.30678319931030273,
0.5421165227890015,
0.5352560877799988,
-0.17506720125675201,
-0.025714144110679626,
-0.3471575677394867,
-0.24049422144889832,
-0.007903128862380981,
0.6135405898094177,
0.4697093963623047,
0.22398579120635986,
-0.11292009800672531,
-0.4435518682003021,
-0.2582446038722992,
0.3179454505443573,
-0.3810825049877167,
-0.10566999018192291,
0.23460450768470764,
-0.12312521785497665,
-0.022223124280571938,
-0.36881211400032043,
-0.4198131263256073,
-0.5687170624732971,
-0.40892913937568665,
0.5459474325180054,
0.16259059309959412,
-0.12224726378917694,
0.24885614216327667,
0.2989981472492218,
-0.15198048949241638,
0.7714372277259827,
-0.7041316032409668,
0.10198132693767548,
0.26364874839782715,
0.4691576361656189,
0.008249305188655853,
-0.5099211931228638,
-0.2560811936855316,
0.1792321652173996,
-0.6208078265190125,
1.08298659324646,
0.06129329651594162,
-0.37901821732521057,
0.14658862352371216,
0.06669589132070541,
-0.13079650700092316,
-0.5313126444816589,
0.5238827466964722,
-0.38962316513061523,
0.32958102226257324,
-0.8876577019691467,
-0.7089310884475708,
-0.01718996837735176,
0.366544246673584,
-0.34358078241348267,
0.7218185663223267,
-0.24389530718326569,
-1.0164109468460083,
0.17513160407543182,
-0.2279094010591507,
-0.31571313738822937,
-0.2761380672454834,
-0.15354344248771667,
-0.28527116775512695,
0.1717948615550995,
0.04057011008262634,
0.4065411686897278,
-0.05511479452252388,
0.16698718070983887,
-0.4464227855205536,
-0.15832939743995667,
0.4617655873298645,
-0.3131159543991089,
0.4092024862766266,
0.13874325156211853,
-0.5512467622756958,
0.22207383811473846,
-0.5761476159095764,
0.07767647504806519,
0.07767368853092194,
-0.21454055607318878,
-0.058148093521595,
-0.0929645374417305,
-0.3867058753967285,
0.21719440817832947,
0.2511657774448395,
-0.6555137634277344,
0.5120236277580261,
-0.24509377777576447,
0.5461863875389099,
0.9154993295669556,
-0.23013661801815033,
0.4668227732181549,
-0.4161914885044098,
0.39788320660591125,
-0.22033396363258362,
0.1657174825668335,
-0.12975092232227325,
-0.1028374582529068,
-1.1709989309310913,
0.32318150997161865,
0.4690331816673279,
0.4320993423461914,
-0.38730135560035706,
0.1439897119998932,
0.20802800357341766,
-0.595788836479187,
-0.3861459791660309,
0.39526551961898804,
0.41428130865097046,
0.6932350397109985,
0.45879262685775757,
-0.06998727470636368,
-0.6188892126083374,
-0.8083713054656982,
-0.439922958612442,
-0.3276742994785309,
0.4015580713748932,
0.09361211955547333,
0.48674991726875305,
-0.3099527955055237,
0.9133989810943604,
-0.36110642552375793,
-0.5607146620750427,
0.033413343131542206,
0.31663647294044495,
-0.17477403581142426,
0.44253090023994446,
0.2562207877635956,
-0.016255425289273262,
-0.13198745250701904,
-0.5351163744926453,
-0.613031804561615,
-0.30925020575523376,
-0.010642225854098797,
0.28766942024230957,
0.42820411920547485,
0.9363386631011963,
-0.3033756911754608,
0.18218427896499634,
0.6331363320350647,
-0.15103299915790558,
0.8035475015640259,
-0.49267008900642395,
0.29618483781814575,
-0.5367200374603271,
-0.11728605628013611,
-0.2846144735813141,
-0.1941598355770111,
-0.4248758852481842,
-0.16014070808887482,
0.19728916883468628,
0.5777012705802917,
-0.22292280197143555,
0.6484744548797607,
-0.6419709920883179,
0.12634782493114471,
-0.6535446047782898,
-0.06206060200929642,
-0.3354499638080597,
0.20078442990779877,
-0.46536722779273987,
0.7742598652839661,
0.20756582915782928,
-0.7417230606079102,
0.2150983065366745,
0.014696447178721428,
-0.15483030676841736,
0.6168790459632874,
-0.5815533399581909,
0.4311464726924896,
-0.2994476854801178,
0.28877103328704834,
-1.2803987264633179,
-0.35555869340896606,
0.4774915277957916,
-0.30171796679496765,
0.38142508268356323,
-0.07745932787656784,
-0.3714485764503479,
-0.6242998838424683,
-0.1086340919137001,
0.4624788463115692,
0.0901527851819992,
-0.5574533343315125,
0.27144232392311096,
0.24074594676494598,
-0.1728105992078781,
-0.8466430902481079,
-0.8318143486976624,
0.14308667182922363,
0.11750822514295578,
-0.5132195949554443,
-0.11573988199234009,
-0.39839839935302734,
-0.29610705375671387,
-0.017663056030869484,
-0.18012884259223938,
0.10862533748149872,
-0.1627204716205597,
0.1271231770515442,
-0.23384834825992584,
-0.09003385901451111,
0.34090954065322876,
-0.378522127866745,
0.015184231102466583,
0.10193891078233719,
0.18302476406097412,
0.2320317029953003,
-0.1977226436138153,
-0.7245422005653381,
-0.1373147964477539,
-0.11443916708230972,
0.23082152009010315,
-0.08167435973882675,
0.20304737985134125,
0.22502772510051727,
-0.17174285650253296,
-0.2202634960412979,
-1.3341634273529053,
-0.35698649287223816,
-0.4518204629421234,
0.11926814168691635,
-0.19021496176719666,
-1.2092010974884033,
0.5929473042488098,
0.23586809635162354,
0.10844297707080841,
0.7766926288604736,
0.6157423853874207,
-0.5804203748703003,
0.8977999687194824,
0.577777087688446,
0.08059185743331909,
0.1491289585828781,
-0.19224277138710022,
0.1905195564031601,
-0.8068714737892151,
-0.018411852419376373,
-0.7204380035400391,
-0.2926006615161896,
-0.5922892689704895,
-0.4249063730239868,
0.15143023431301117,
-0.05897672474384308,
-0.08130668103694916,
0.07534828037023544,
-0.26672133803367615,
0.31223610043525696,
0.4979361593723297,
0.07221922278404236,
0.39252686500549316,
-0.35518690943717957,
0.030017858371138573,
-0.38123205304145813,
-0.6831427812576294,
-0.4011649191379547,
1.0405923128128052,
0.4612152576446533,
1.3327088356018066,
-0.17958280444145203,
0.7611778378486633,
0.22385787963867188,
0.6229491829872131,
-0.668734073638916,
0.3751160204410553,
0.20641201734542847,
-0.8821720480918884,
-0.564360499382019,
-0.3157894015312195,
-0.9443203210830688,
0.10378549247980118,
0.02344139665365219,
-0.2860766053199768,
0.34651729464530945,
0.6379277110099792,
-0.45963817834854126,
0.35092782974243164,
-0.6057409644126892,
0.7634714841842651,
-0.5551929473876953,
-0.46072328090667725,
-0.29862701892852783,
-0.6455305218696594,
0.4846912920475006,
-0.16724470257759094,
0.3960549533367157,
-0.3483704626560211,
0.10534864664077759,
0.6789141893386841,
-0.2508220970630646,
1.1364814043045044,
-0.2156766802072525,
-0.6175870895385742,
0.4462684690952301,
0.2879237234592438,
0.4521954655647278,
-0.10782615840435028,
0.06629229336977005,
-0.0334053672850132,
0.14883722364902496,
-0.2225418984889984,
-0.8284584879875183,
0.5760295987129211,
-0.6096629500389099,
-1.0353039503097534,
-0.6654055118560791,
-0.09118089824914932,
-0.4344818890094757,
0.178462415933609,
0.3511926829814911,
0.20047543942928314,
-0.14103282988071442,
-0.004137573763728142,
0.4807652235031128,
0.17767992615699768,
0.3897947072982788,
1.055412769317627,
-0.3618452250957489,
-0.38282695412635803,
0.5335923433303833,
0.660534679889679,
0.13670742511749268,
0.00042257230961695313,
0.1667303889989853,
-0.34898534417152405,
-0.6957162618637085,
-0.4316876530647278,
0.5676241517066956,
-0.7871823906898499,
-0.29110395908355713,
-0.5013342499732971,
-0.033976249396800995,
-0.7131350636482239,
0.1667797714471817,
-0.7861085534095764,
-0.26811376214027405,
-0.33075428009033203,
0.03130627050995827,
-0.017755022272467613,
1.2340168952941895,
-0.5327576398849487,
0.18533477187156677,
-0.7851555347442627,
0.08430972695350647,
0.5126057863235474,
0.44251343607902527,
-0.018528182059526443,
-0.8063995838165283,
-0.24940532445907593,
0.21489429473876953,
-0.19404347240924835,
-0.7704973816871643,
0.12189173698425293,
-0.0819087103009224,
0.5573201775550842,
0.15539824962615967,
0.07974575459957123,
0.9326174259185791,
-0.651665210723877,
0.6797453165054321,
0.040534693747758865,
-0.7795836329460144,
0.6098250150680542,
-0.21750369668006897,
0.2242446392774582,
0.5682628154754639,
0.13911809027194977,
-0.8667740821838379,
-0.45885294675827026,
-0.6116496920585632,
-0.5957252383232117,
0.4538184404373169,
0.002647937275469303,
0.06124977394938469,
-0.011040177196264267,
0.7907229661941528,
-0.13769996166229248,
0.029140179976820946,
-0.718150794506073,
-0.28733721375465393,
0.007643287535756826,
0.18020641803741455,
-0.4610414505004883,
-0.6165284514427185,
-0.4948521554470062,
-0.19657643139362335,
0.757585346698761,
-0.4071079194545746,
0.04283544793725014,
0.7557991147041321,
-0.26471197605133057,
-0.591251015663147,
0.37459686398506165,
0.8084813952445984,
0.8404225707054138,
-0.02038862556219101,
0.21264074742794037,
0.4446485936641693,
0.0619284063577652,
0.45545467734336853,
-0.33744728565216064,
-0.06639963388442993,
-0.279913991689682,
0.24558775126934052,
0.2424219846725464,
0.19304674863815308,
-0.417860209941864,
0.5534968972206116,
-0.3659788966178894,
-0.07459770143032074,
-0.3988683223724365,
0.0637659952044487,
0.059901054948568344,
0.1930208057165146,
0.1922486126422882,
0.24498677253723145,
0.2435276210308075,
-0.4298330545425415,
0.09010964632034302,
0.44358670711517334,
-0.1999846249818802,
-0.2814734876155853,
0.4891136884689331,
0.15286563336849213,
-0.18926569819450378,
0.3669865131378174,
-0.1160765141248703,
-0.2640555799007416,
0.34709447622299194,
0.625198245048523,
0.7428423166275024,
-0.6261494159698486,
0.17224165797233582,
0.5241299867630005,
0.503862202167511,
-0.5489145517349243,
0.20558209717273712,
0.1663386970758438,
-0.8555481433868408,
-0.7449005246162415,
-0.36983415484428406,
-0.8111864924430847,
0.22202083468437195,
-0.517885148525238,
0.12225580960512161,
-0.5990496277809143,
-0.35540419816970825,
-0.2104378193616867,
-0.30397459864616394,
-0.4760795533657074,
0.5750991106033325,
-0.011409447528421879,
0.7109273672103882,
-0.6407827138900757,
0.475062757730484,
0.6367533802986145,
-0.29908299446105957,
-0.8841710090637207,
-0.03288509324193001,
0.06640946120023727,
-0.85952228307724,
0.5445759296417236,
-0.0999804362654686,
-0.3905099630355835,
-0.21390050649642944,
-0.8325891494750977,
-1.179745078086853,
0.4105575680732727,
0.4996071755886078,
-0.8226333856582642,
0.0025715178344398737,
0.06252121925354004,
0.7698761224746704,
0.1072499006986618,
0.30502328276634216,
0.3350033760070801,
0.4497647285461426,
0.0848580002784729,
-1.0563160181045532,
-0.0464676134288311,
0.09457438439130783,
-0.07547836750745773,
-0.05400193855166435,
-0.9344775676727295,
0.7340908646583557,
-0.5024499893188477,
0.018646106123924255,
0.17421911656856537,
0.7825964093208313,
-0.13075120747089386,
-0.03800978511571884,
0.5361384749412537,
0.6856062412261963,
0.7353670001029968,
-0.04142400994896889,
0.7808408141136169,
-0.28212934732437134,
0.5412189960479736,
1.3739889860153198,
-0.24103663861751556,
0.7557603120803833,
0.36391401290893555,
-0.24651403725147247,
0.22247986495494843,
0.7237931489944458,
-0.04684764891862869,
0.15545640885829926,
0.3047170042991638,
0.08429333567619324,
-0.3230215907096863,
0.18502509593963623,
-0.4886839985847473,
0.3860766887664795,
0.206107497215271,
-0.10877056419849396,
-0.06931690126657486,
-0.11115583032369614,
0.005280936602503061,
0.06181086227297783,
-0.34725579619407654,
0.7332792282104492,
0.05445939302444458,
-0.9381474256515503,
0.44943392276763916,
0.1440982222557068,
0.712152898311615,
-0.3889206051826477,
0.17232875525951385,
-0.5470055341720581,
0.36948874592781067,
-0.5251113772392273,
-0.840340256690979,
0.4356262683868408,
-0.12302372604608536,
-0.2611047029495239,
-0.31452304124832153,
0.81682950258255,
-0.3803395926952362,
-0.30188530683517456,
0.23139937222003937,
0.6670190691947937,
0.08693435788154602,
-0.13781701028347015,
-0.5188515782356262,
-0.05059008672833443,
-0.07600869238376617,
-0.1163702979683876,
0.08030629903078079,
0.4255613088607788,
0.33389219641685486,
0.8112711310386658,
0.28339314460754395,
0.25844791531562805,
0.2524167001247406,
0.20878663659095764,
0.3760805130004883,
-0.8950493335723877,
-0.01287717092782259,
-0.6993816494941711,
0.41829755902290344,
0.2153899073600769,
-0.47230660915374756,
1.1532224416732788,
0.39862048625946045,
1.1249936819076538,
-0.2518749535083771,
0.7891530990600586,
0.21780692040920258,
0.945379376411438,
-0.5818353891372681,
0.11671696603298187,
-0.5604726672172546,
0.07840488106012344,
-0.31282559037208557,
-0.6695200204849243,
-0.21926945447921753,
0.6643124222755432,
-0.3996092677116394,
0.23517851531505585,
0.7579541802406311,
0.8530089259147644,
0.36889636516571045,
-0.03599138557910919,
0.31159934401512146,
0.7573636174201965,
0.27090054750442505,
0.01401308923959732,
1.237381935119629,
-0.430467426776886,
0.3960370719432831,
-0.42299699783325195,
-0.02987085096538067,
-0.2781359553337097,
-0.7798523902893066,
-0.6333057284355164,
-0.3451126515865326,
-0.5439358949661255,
-0.5548052787780762,
0.2602395713329315,
0.9046846032142639,
0.40584415197372437,
-1.002094030380249,
-0.41060298681259155,
0.10665658861398697,
0.20718814432621002,
-0.007865739986300468,
-0.1093030571937561,
0.01505274698138237,
-0.8262302279472351,
-0.7128381133079529,
0.4192714989185333,
0.19160392880439758,
0.21933849155902863,
-0.4733366370201111,
0.06255269795656204,
0.10344245284795761,
-0.07429888844490051,
0.445965051651001,
0.5897212624549866,
-0.8282392621040344,
-0.49226200580596924,
0.14793989062309265,
-0.4649019241333008,
0.2943263351917267,
0.9979596734046936,
-0.2922196388244629,
0.5795477628707886,
0.4028834402561188,
0.5153250098228455,
0.3151845932006836,
-0.2138051837682724,
0.5524725317955017,
-0.4081186056137085,
-0.47178414463996887,
0.209553062915802,
0.5490102767944336,
0.5844411849975586,
-0.42007189989089966,
0.5697309374809265,
0.3765774965286255,
-1.1129690408706665,
-0.6768040060997009,
0.06023821607232094,
-0.6822540760040283,
-0.05932076275348663,
1.282078742980957,
-0.04339563846588135,
-0.10555476695299149,
0.01333350408822298,
-0.6419067978858948,
0.17835599184036255,
0.07276452332735062,
1.0226919651031494,
0.9136584401130676,
-0.44553446769714355,
-0.07258569449186325,
-0.29400625824928284,
0.5475108623504639,
0.7831737399101257,
-0.6181779503822327,
0.32697269320487976,
0.617289662361145,
0.6259670257568359,
0.20019832253456116,
0.946979820728302,
0.014488624408841133,
0.21253441274166107,
-0.3244430124759674,
0.13535262644290924,
0.45071277022361755,
-0.3724784553050995,
-0.6491551399230957,
-0.0010232549393549562,
0.5522315502166748,
0.2612946927547455
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.01288v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.01288v1
|
Improved Few-Shot Jailbreaking Can Circumvent Aligned Language Models and Their Defenses
| 2024-06-03T12:59:17 | 2024-06-03T12:59:17 |
Xiaosen Zheng, Tianyu Pang, Chao Du, Qian Liu, Jing Jiang, Min Lin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CR, cs.LG
|
Recently, Anil et al. (2024) show that many-shot (up to hundreds of)
demonstrations can jailbreak state-of-the-art LLMs by exploiting their
long-context capability. Nevertheless, is it possible to use few-shot
demonstrations to efficiently jailbreak LLMs within limited context sizes?
While the vanilla few-shot jailbreaking may be inefficient, we propose improved
techniques such as injecting special system tokens like [/INST] and employing
demo-level random search from a collected demo pool. These simple techniques
result in surprisingly effective jailbreaking against aligned LLMs (even with
advanced defenses). For examples, our method achieves >80% (mostly >95%) ASRs
on Llama-2-7B and Llama-3-8B without multiple restarts, even if the models are
enhanced by strong defenses such as perplexity detection and/or SmoothLLM,
which is challenging for suffix-based jailbreaking. In addition, we conduct
comprehensive and elaborate (e.g., making sure to use correct system prompts)
evaluations against other aligned LLMs and advanced defenses, where our method
consistently achieves nearly 100% ASRs. Our code is available at
https://github.com/sail-sg/I-FSJ.
|
[
-0.30412837862968445,
-0.6763026118278503,
0.572349488735199,
0.1462179571390152,
-0.43056634068489075,
0.37584730982780457,
-0.21422943472862244,
-0.48507925868034363,
0.23175084590911865,
0.49786368012428284,
-0.5170879364013672,
-0.5282062292098999,
-0.6208227276802063,
0.12295123934745789,
-0.35448840260505676,
0.9215423464775085,
-0.12017764896154404,
-0.04155081510543823,
0.14808838069438934,
-0.21052859723567963,
-0.36237582564353943,
-0.22590593993663788,
-0.09855694323778152,
-0.2389078289270401,
0.2639252841472626,
0.6729174256324768,
0.49102315306663513,
0.7566982507705688,
0.6813477277755737,
0.21198458969593048,
-0.47217291593551636,
0.072493776679039,
-0.5489851832389832,
0.026180321350693703,
0.08807611465454102,
-0.42243921756744385,
-0.3793933689594269,
-0.09741876274347305,
0.4896489381790161,
0.16109515726566315,
-0.21979357302188873,
-0.02948746271431446,
0.049320533871650696,
0.6609110832214355,
-0.8698658347129822,
-0.39787814021110535,
-0.948321521282196,
-0.10987398773431778,
-0.6520452499389648,
0.158246710896492,
-0.46340346336364746,
-0.007897662930190563,
-0.3150469958782196,
-0.6652191877365112,
-0.37788593769073486,
0.17166653275489807,
0.9270721673965454,
0.23532366752624512,
-0.38469046354293823,
-0.020377932116389275,
-0.43654870986938477,
0.7882592678070068,
-0.8635541796684265,
0.17390111088752747,
0.35477539896965027,
0.6252317428588867,
-0.5295540690422058,
-0.6122541427612305,
-0.41646769642829895,
-0.37532398104667664,
-0.022070128470659256,
-0.16021375358104706,
-0.43918755650520325,
0.19217410683631897,
0.4560813009738922,
0.023909181356430054,
-0.30721187591552734,
0.4193137586116791,
-0.38134530186653137,
-0.16245664656162262,
0.5915406346321106,
0.14267660677433014,
0.23188751935958862,
-0.4085521399974823,
-0.7264163494110107,
0.08144674450159073,
-1.3343693017959595,
0.16787885129451752,
0.527328372001648,
0.35209476947784424,
-0.23085683584213257,
0.6926895380020142,
-0.2841503322124481,
0.5710580945014954,
0.0716998502612114,
-0.46166935563087463,
-0.006075878161936998,
-0.33867359161376953,
-0.06720618158578873,
-0.0730743259191513,
0.7811354398727417,
0.28756117820739746,
0.021633513271808624,
-0.12477219849824905,
-0.3541945517063141,
-0.08572129160165787,
0.11984668672084808,
-0.7954971194267273,
-0.01550251618027687,
0.2501603364944458,
-0.41254884004592896,
-0.1855076551437378,
0.10178381949663162,
-0.5855789184570312,
-0.6158215403556824,
0.22023078799247742,
0.3502213954925537,
-0.7745595574378967,
0.1184363141655922,
0.013096329756081104,
-0.2920747995376587,
0.5099977850914001,
0.20268167555332184,
-0.7689809799194336,
0.444070428609848,
0.9794440865516663,
0.960089921951294,
-0.12475531548261642,
-0.2281927466392517,
-0.6695054173469543,
0.26187819242477417,
-0.011912930756807327,
0.77316814661026,
-0.46770167350769043,
-0.39901769161224365,
-0.2631252706050873,
-0.43935471773147583,
0.2089119553565979,
-0.5456165671348572,
0.28731751441955566,
-0.5817782878875732,
-0.4646052420139313,
-0.035566531121730804,
-0.7117635011672974,
0.2549121677875519,
0.4771166443824768,
-0.5177308320999146,
0.6155293583869934,
-0.24792520701885223,
-0.6051364541053772,
0.21696731448173523,
-0.4851500988006592,
-0.5527095794677734,
-0.16486287117004395,
-0.20110003650188446,
-0.498691201210022,
0.0500338189303875,
0.5053645372390747,
0.2692759931087494,
0.005607573315501213,
0.09120932966470718,
-0.50691157579422,
-0.7139015793800354,
0.15373922884464264,
-0.21638788282871246,
0.8334546685218811,
0.4263235926628113,
-0.41766300797462463,
-0.0062424661591649055,
-0.620431125164032,
-0.16698132455348969,
0.206096351146698,
-0.27749574184417725,
-0.3869728744029999,
-0.06599194556474686,
-0.33721739053726196,
-0.12056264281272888,
0.2450135350227356,
-0.7302604913711548,
0.5808445811271667,
-0.6262751817703247,
0.4047439396381378,
0.7967102527618408,
-0.05742458254098892,
0.618942379951477,
-0.22046953439712524,
0.7039788961410522,
-0.0016023063799366355,
0.16025136411190033,
-0.43121346831321716,
-0.2694810628890991,
-0.5168534517288208,
-0.8384770750999451,
0.09508558362722397,
0.5235722661018372,
-0.6931545734405518,
0.19115599989891052,
-0.10984282195568085,
-0.4906233847141266,
-0.6212248802185059,
0.5565225481987,
0.7927300930023193,
0.24081194400787354,
0.45226815342903137,
-0.23138010501861572,
-0.7333011627197266,
-0.7964291572570801,
-0.7486666440963745,
-0.203154519200325,
0.08714944869279861,
0.11130734533071518,
0.43391093611717224,
-0.07725247740745544,
0.9619558453559875,
-0.4354245066642761,
-0.15229958295822144,
-0.3458697199821472,
-0.16567111015319824,
0.27565354108810425,
0.47790151834487915,
0.6187655925750732,
-0.19640584290027618,
-0.4231193959712982,
-0.21204738318920135,
-0.6167643666267395,
-0.15426136553287506,
-0.019790321588516235,
0.06033451110124588,
0.008108030073344707,
0.7446478009223938,
-0.6564257740974426,
0.563240647315979,
0.3711683452129364,
-0.3458210527896881,
0.626339852809906,
0.1673581749200821,
-0.08078905194997787,
-0.8716492652893066,
-0.2688705027103424,
-0.020621197298169136,
-0.49166667461395264,
-0.5710238218307495,
0.5454156398773193,
0.1785399615764618,
0.22471939027309418,
-0.7116355895996094,
0.6491499543190002,
-0.5941842198371887,
0.0670672357082367,
-0.4974345862865448,
0.16303139925003052,
-0.30811601877212524,
0.07147271186113358,
-0.4989224374294281,
0.7071862816810608,
0.45802968740463257,
-0.24360132217407227,
0.1944602131843567,
0.28579631447792053,
-0.4590093493461609,
0.3698430359363556,
-0.513418436050415,
0.3022572994232178,
-0.19363687932491302,
0.5440995097160339,
-1.040304183959961,
-0.16659313440322876,
0.16348569095134735,
-0.06525089591741562,
0.3405633866786957,
-0.5541327595710754,
-0.3632930517196655,
-0.15790396928787231,
-0.6743370294570923,
0.1976337879896164,
0.5756146907806396,
-0.8942999243736267,
0.24654139578342438,
0.2804185450077057,
0.028949646279215813,
-0.9031831622123718,
-0.67242830991745,
0.3231094479560852,
-0.5895106196403503,
-0.7182369232177734,
0.4915199279785156,
0.11694321036338806,
-0.5091686844825745,
-0.3215498924255371,
-0.2729235291481018,
0.073558509349823,
0.45179757475852966,
0.3313497304916382,
0.3590626120567322,
-0.21505412459373474,
-0.3072519302368164,
0.14270882308483124,
-0.22977346181869507,
-0.4029000401496887,
-0.1594744324684143,
0.5014699101448059,
-0.3840373456478119,
-0.649583101272583,
-0.633682370185852,
0.10418929904699326,
0.43588992953300476,
-0.1256890892982483,
0.6004428267478943,
0.26850077509880066,
-0.264139324426651,
-0.031298935413360596,
-0.6632581353187561,
-0.37794730067253113,
-0.5160319209098816,
0.12543994188308716,
-0.5392224192619324,
-1.2942001819610596,
0.47200876474380493,
-0.22073715925216675,
0.2013140171766281,
-0.029335912317037582,
0.24401618540287018,
-0.17159950733184814,
0.8055826425552368,
0.665859043598175,
-0.4986315369606018,
0.6350806951522827,
-0.07380209863185883,
0.274036705493927,
-0.7842773795127869,
0.0987587422132492,
-0.39837023615837097,
-0.562339186668396,
-0.4961206614971161,
-0.17846541106700897,
0.4042693078517914,
0.6136521100997925,
-0.248304083943367,
0.6684098243713379,
-0.10612982511520386,
0.9200229048728943,
0.2259150743484497,
0.2229405790567398,
0.5322837233543396,
-0.0449846126139164,
-0.24785974621772766,
-0.009421960450708866,
-0.630032479763031,
-0.7534485459327698,
1.2554657459259033,
0.5276555418968201,
0.984663188457489,
0.3969012498855591,
1.2634260654449463,
-0.10383304953575134,
0.46410319209098816,
-0.733199954032898,
0.5570825338363647,
-0.24282877147197723,
-0.5998324155807495,
-0.10922453552484512,
-0.06287625432014465,
-0.6292134523391724,
0.2757502794265747,
-0.08718327432870865,
-1.227717638015747,
-0.10766132175922394,
0.3779270648956299,
-0.7294976115226746,
0.3119492530822754,
-0.6412219405174255,
0.7331083416938782,
-0.116044782102108,
-0.4155236780643463,
-0.2744218409061432,
-0.9304678440093994,
0.83748859167099,
0.11825507134199142,
0.1931174397468567,
-0.31646499037742615,
-0.09600000083446503,
0.5097379088401794,
-0.9163885712623596,
1.048751711845398,
-0.3598576784133911,
0.11171671748161316,
0.4117671251296997,
0.09825663268566132,
0.6984570026397705,
0.12402735650539398,
-0.009326853789389133,
-0.04575180262327194,
-0.1753566414117813,
-0.4282028079032898,
-0.5706593990325928,
0.6519537568092346,
-0.5952714085578918,
-0.885422945022583,
-0.04857921600341797,
-0.40601950883865356,
-0.05539761856198311,
-0.05675153061747551,
0.3120826184749603,
-0.04321220889687538,
-0.2223745435476303,
-0.08455915004014969,
0.2997678518295288,
0.0753098800778389,
0.6554619073867798,
0.35661065578460693,
-0.23122431337833405,
-0.3704566955566406,
0.5118250250816345,
-0.12126579135656357,
0.31381502747535706,
0.0779777243733406,
0.22081075608730316,
-0.028032289817929268,
-0.8149319887161255,
-0.48488104343414307,
0.11586317420005798,
-0.4910210072994232,
-0.7140161991119385,
-0.3679730296134949,
-0.12748563289642334,
-0.28449708223342896,
-0.4334068298339844,
-0.5210192799568176,
-0.8240433931350708,
0.011994668282568455,
-0.20871442556381226,
0.6348434686660767,
0.5556607246398926,
-0.19302183389663696,
0.9345611333847046,
-0.7657482624053955,
0.4334011375904083,
0.14048880338668823,
0.1588650941848755,
-0.14045390486717224,
-0.746155321598053,
0.031452011317014694,
-0.1264585703611374,
-0.4813742935657501,
-1.0084198713302612,
0.15440578758716583,
0.16840150952339172,
0.38696712255477905,
0.6525803804397583,
0.00731984619051218,
1.22795569896698,
-0.7357245087623596,
0.7114935517311096,
0.31145182251930237,
-1.123382568359375,
0.6713970899581909,
-0.25193652510643005,
0.10633450001478195,
0.7158321142196655,
-0.016989361494779587,
-0.27627894282341003,
-0.7858161330223083,
-0.4339558482170105,
-0.9727528095245361,
0.7339368462562561,
0.06386373192071915,
0.20944903790950775,
0.06038973480463028,
0.568545401096344,
-0.006005395203828812,
-0.03375852853059769,
-0.8618348240852356,
-0.19258178770542145,
0.05991552397608757,
-0.18164128065109253,
0.2729398310184479,
-0.25768807530403137,
-0.3563374876976013,
-0.3013158142566681,
0.6837723851203918,
-0.061892230063676834,
-0.15625672042369843,
0.013231771998107433,
-0.3976849615573883,
0.13049349188804626,
0.5823848247528076,
0.5752041935920715,
0.28085291385650635,
-0.03988169506192207,
0.32159605622291565,
0.38461798429489136,
-0.347711443901062,
0.5089720487594604,
0.07480546832084656,
-0.30976834893226624,
-0.2484772801399231,
0.3037671148777008,
0.7702581882476807,
0.06442397832870483,
-0.7949724197387695,
0.7769690155982971,
0.14071619510650635,
0.170502707362175,
-0.1400218904018402,
0.28823789954185486,
0.01284602377563715,
0.5453649163246155,
0.24622167646884918,
-0.14832793176174164,
-0.1788557916879654,
-0.397735059261322,
0.3843647241592407,
0.6159219145774841,
-0.3598717749118805,
-0.12969374656677246,
0.5673388242721558,
0.04866287112236023,
-0.16691134870052338,
0.5092772245407104,
-0.4145943820476532,
-0.4637482762336731,
0.5049967765808105,
0.9717706441879272,
0.8005315065383911,
-0.13687868416309357,
-0.13827675580978394,
0.15990394353866577,
0.5562747716903687,
-0.37607240676879883,
0.09230397641658783,
-0.05896721035242081,
-0.886269211769104,
-0.4277452230453491,
-0.3958173096179962,
-0.284549355506897,
-0.09985830634832382,
-0.3571056127548218,
0.5458658933639526,
-0.9206666946411133,
-0.11714308708906174,
-0.23501208424568176,
-0.33446529507637024,
-0.23998524248600006,
-0.44804027676582336,
0.21340078115463257,
1.2514945268630981,
-0.6975921988487244,
0.8401488065719604,
0.7162739634513855,
-0.1208924874663353,
-0.592987060546875,
-0.017140302807092667,
0.6899844408035278,
-0.8309320211410522,
0.45000171661376953,
0.3527008891105652,
-0.29977473616600037,
-0.13861379027366638,
-1.1191707849502563,
-0.7783396244049072,
1.1525993347167969,
0.5312275290489197,
-0.8690185546875,
0.22632749378681183,
-0.19435575604438782,
0.251076340675354,
-0.3325679898262024,
0.0950489342212677,
1.042815089225769,
0.5120949745178223,
-0.07669265568256378,
-0.9235754609107971,
0.05799626186490059,
-0.05284944549202919,
-0.22539260983467102,
0.22138386964797974,
-0.7411288022994995,
0.46923187375068665,
-0.6698118448257446,
-0.11112856864929199,
0.5611960291862488,
0.8510237336158752,
1.0013500452041626,
0.32608118653297424,
0.6321117877960205,
0.8448238372802734,
0.6642745137214661,
-0.04289267212152481,
0.982056200504303,
-0.17734543979167938,
0.08158977329730988,
1.2815971374511719,
-0.4768722951412201,
1.0574547052383423,
1.063481092453003,
-0.02444845624268055,
0.5142642855644226,
0.1248275488615036,
0.1607711762189865,
0.6346638798713684,
0.46240469813346863,
-0.42291203141212463,
-0.24761922657489777,
0.0387178473174572,
0.09240712225437164,
0.7521358132362366,
0.3182847201824188,
0.1131649762392044,
-0.30904334783554077,
0.15394270420074463,
0.5296047925949097,
0.23620270192623138,
-0.11079928278923035,
0.7998003363609314,
0.4109559953212738,
-0.4736091196537018,
0.6069053411483765,
0.4317398965358734,
1.0353389978408813,
-0.6071665287017822,
0.23095497488975525,
-0.26507091522216797,
0.08994507789611816,
-0.35076749324798584,
-0.5412619113922119,
0.1988973170518875,
0.7678148150444031,
0.2871890366077423,
-0.3022172152996063,
0.940670371055603,
-0.1263439804315567,
-0.056472573429346085,
0.23918698728084564,
0.48461440205574036,
0.10465704649686813,
0.08325185626745224,
-0.3905256688594818,
0.09711877256631851,
-0.051100559532642365,
-0.23099759221076965,
0.4509787857532501,
-0.06579618901014328,
-0.09465855360031128,
0.6701406836509705,
0.4808431565761566,
-0.10366661101579666,
0.27957579493522644,
-0.046584565192461014,
1.1240836381912231,
-0.8061573505401611,
-0.3488168716430664,
-1.3726686239242554,
0.6122376322746277,
-0.10315942019224167,
-0.15984807908535004,
0.81293123960495,
0.6116008758544922,
0.8034045696258545,
0.30074262619018555,
0.6762264966964722,
-0.04723130539059639,
0.19392156600952148,
-0.7366695404052734,
0.6897335052490234,
-0.39630362391471863,
0.8310640454292297,
-0.3384603261947632,
-0.6061233282089233,
-0.41992485523223877,
0.6656617522239685,
-0.30959072709083557,
-0.39139074087142944,
0.4836384654045105,
0.9291402101516724,
-0.22825035452842712,
-0.11076340079307556,
0.18316543102264404,
0.2649325430393219,
0.4022698700428009,
0.6805543303489685,
1.3234342336654663,
-0.47577351331710815,
0.6590928435325623,
-0.3396948277950287,
-0.18789048492908478,
-0.16044914722442627,
-1.0721931457519531,
-0.7936658263206482,
0.15724940598011017,
-0.19204802811145782,
-0.3458269238471985,
0.32746389508247375,
1.1647676229476929,
0.617876410484314,
-0.7868267297744751,
-0.373809814453125,
0.03859320282936096,
0.37368643283843994,
-0.09183359146118164,
-0.09495857357978821,
-0.09284060448408127,
-0.3768792450428009,
-0.38474681973457336,
1.0557447671890259,
0.48842108249664307,
0.15722139179706573,
0.04559757933020592,
-0.22043940424919128,
-0.1489619016647339,
-0.09841702878475189,
0.39936333894729614,
0.4873889088630676,
-0.8604602217674255,
-0.5550002455711365,
-0.05093370005488396,
-0.2865073084831238,
0.22632741928100586,
0.7070862650871277,
-0.842915952205658,
0.17084869742393494,
0.3903212249279022,
0.7393398284912109,
0.52439284324646,
0.18587280809879303,
0.41206464171409607,
-1.144352674484253,
0.5123818516731262,
0.06697080284357071,
0.6010258197784424,
0.23695823550224304,
-0.04495251178741455,
0.3316265344619751,
0.06370337307453156,
-0.17635151743888855,
-0.8919495940208435,
0.5166541337966919,
-0.811931848526001,
-0.3429912328720093,
1.2062911987304688,
-0.26909562945365906,
-0.31238818168640137,
0.03411657363176346,
-0.09670380502939224,
-0.004662349354475737,
-0.4551355540752411,
0.7174463868141174,
0.6283862590789795,
-0.18514670431613922,
0.020253963768482208,
-0.256285160779953,
0.39186424016952515,
0.6002150177955627,
-0.8130386471748352,
0.01968914270401001,
0.4114304482936859,
0.3318382203578949,
-0.08666249364614487,
0.5829417705535889,
-0.37077340483665466,
0.19585466384887695,
-0.2833940088748932,
-0.13833977282047272,
-0.05331087484955788,
-0.45807209610939026,
-0.7763368487358093,
-0.023148491978645325,
0.3123116195201874,
-0.1034231036901474
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.01283v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.01283v1
|
Focus on the Core: Efficient Attention via Pruned Token Compression for Document Classification
| 2024-06-03T12:51:52 | 2024-06-03T12:51:52 |
Jungmin Yun, Mihyeon Kim, Youngbin Kim
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Transformer-based models have achieved dominant performance in numerous NLP
tasks. Despite their remarkable successes, pre-trained transformers such as
BERT suffer from a computationally expensive self-attention mechanism that
interacts with all tokens, including the ones unfavorable to classification
performance. To overcome these challenges, we propose integrating two
strategies: token pruning and token combining. Token pruning eliminates less
important tokens in the attention mechanism's key and value as they pass
through the layers. Additionally, we adopt fuzzy logic to handle uncertainty
and alleviate potential mispruning risks arising from an imbalanced
distribution of each token's importance. Token combining, on the other hand,
condenses input sequences into smaller sizes in order to further compress the
model. By integrating these two approaches, we not only improve the model's
performance but also reduce its computational demands. Experiments with various
datasets demonstrate superior performance compared to baseline models,
especially with the best improvement over the existing BERT model, achieving
+5%p in accuracy and +5.6%p in F1 score. Additionally, memory cost is reduced
to 0.61x, and a speedup of 1.64x is achieved.
|
[
-0.3626953959465027,
-0.30568429827690125,
0.16850432753562927,
0.18262813985347748,
-0.502260684967041,
-0.058787036687135696,
-0.4539373815059662,
-0.42966803908348083,
0.015481626614928246,
0.4260045886039734,
-0.4763847589492798,
-0.09956294298171997,
-0.8005942106246948,
0.027255158871412277,
-0.6501875519752502,
1.0439883470535278,
0.3663381040096283,
-0.15195392072200775,
-0.2724577784538269,
0.042544588446617126,
-0.435069739818573,
-0.9377424716949463,
-0.6520771384239197,
-0.10959211736917496,
0.4879215955734253,
0.23002123832702637,
0.6494035124778748,
0.6587424278259277,
0.9567834734916687,
0.358405739068985,
-0.23743049800395966,
0.15214519202709198,
-0.3299770951271057,
0.004447590559720993,
-0.19654695689678192,
-0.6544247269630432,
-0.3061806857585907,
0.03133811801671982,
0.45687252283096313,
0.48234209418296814,
0.06351451575756073,
0.15160204470157623,
0.1598271280527115,
0.5230481624603271,
-0.5851518511772156,
0.19489002227783203,
-0.6204853057861328,
0.23216578364372253,
-0.0400020107626915,
-0.046188849955797195,
-0.6359280943870544,
0.05084718391299248,
0.06714785844087601,
-0.3320005238056183,
0.7776260375976562,
0.09511793404817581,
1.0452550649642944,
0.6304380297660828,
-0.08966720849275589,
0.07897776365280151,
-0.7138426899909973,
0.8647043704986572,
-0.6241551637649536,
0.4901977479457855,
0.07831642776727676,
0.033391810953617096,
0.21136213839054108,
-1.1956499814987183,
-0.6891524195671082,
0.21989330649375916,
-0.37121737003326416,
0.18320435285568237,
-0.338641494512558,
0.39036256074905396,
0.2051822990179062,
0.5549978017807007,
-0.3117683231830597,
0.0813063532114029,
-0.5144503116607666,
-0.3248964250087738,
0.4072168171405792,
-0.1582924723625183,
0.05278337746858597,
-0.3238738179206848,
-0.4448072612285614,
-0.5271046161651611,
-0.14955630898475647,
-0.0431310273706913,
0.2328101098537445,
0.4198656976222992,
0.38652411103248596,
0.47670429944992065,
0.20954179763793945,
0.7675309777259827,
0.417035847902298,
-0.1590106040239334,
0.26927870512008667,
-0.4476009011268616,
-0.36241427063941956,
-0.056664880365133286,
0.6395096182823181,
0.3222477436065674,
0.010554306209087372,
-0.466890811920166,
-0.27369022369384766,
0.2135237157344818,
0.8470917344093323,
-0.664835512638092,
-0.24778926372528076,
0.3855656385421753,
-0.7151175737380981,
-0.4010228216648102,
0.0693875104188919,
-0.6968140006065369,
0.07589180022478104,
-0.5695751309394836,
0.4663701355457306,
-0.45817455649375916,
-0.146556556224823,
0.06553596258163452,
-0.3485724627971649,
0.2618391513824463,
0.3913883566856384,
-0.8992388844490051,
0.32130327820777893,
1.1048331260681152,
0.8619720339775085,
-0.3277413845062256,
-0.15423844754695892,
-0.49595901370048523,
0.01877504587173462,
0.0007622718694619834,
0.75346839427948,
-0.2840626835823059,
-0.28691235184669495,
-0.11349014937877655,
-0.21717555820941925,
-0.23301437497138977,
-0.4231342375278473,
1.1967811584472656,
-0.34677237272262573,
0.30165669322013855,
0.15115004777908325,
-0.5312555432319641,
-0.2261553704738617,
0.3079906105995178,
-0.7023642659187317,
1.334538459777832,
0.31912529468536377,
-1.1157406568527222,
0.3092982769012451,
-0.6219332814216614,
-0.6092520356178284,
0.06517615914344788,
0.1771056354045868,
-0.5197436213493347,
0.324749618768692,
0.3887907862663269,
0.6728752851486206,
-0.30954545736312866,
0.47275546193122864,
0.21795105934143066,
-0.43108680844306946,
-0.06292740255594254,
-0.37639597058296204,
0.46758294105529785,
0.26893433928489685,
-0.3415255546569824,
0.31313401460647583,
-0.5813376307487488,
-0.09722741693258286,
0.068782277405262,
-0.3501726984977722,
-0.05373791232705116,
-0.11173222213983536,
0.408815860748291,
0.33461225032806396,
0.22980773448944092,
-0.35127678513526917,
0.25974953174591064,
-0.704767644405365,
0.6457273364067078,
0.7216733694076538,
-0.1660488247871399,
0.719379723072052,
-0.4606544077396393,
0.2579466700553894,
0.12668046355247498,
0.6277189254760742,
-0.2954826056957245,
-0.3289716839790344,
-1.1884738206863403,
-0.523610532283783,
0.7861033082008362,
0.24664324522018433,
-0.43453308939933777,
0.8749361038208008,
-0.5118403434753418,
-0.677280068397522,
-0.7985742688179016,
-0.015299102291464806,
0.12432125955820084,
0.6425238251686096,
0.5047221779823303,
-0.4455350339412689,
-0.34439343214035034,
-0.9997608065605164,
-0.20433562994003296,
-0.29367733001708984,
-0.2728188633918762,
0.2558829188346863,
0.20538070797920227,
-0.01806340552866459,
1.136440634727478,
-0.4686010181903839,
-0.6782801747322083,
-0.43873146176338196,
0.32160326838493347,
0.4434407949447632,
0.7239843010902405,
0.48697376251220703,
-1.0926275253295898,
-0.3207254707813263,
-0.25640109181404114,
-0.105588398873806,
0.004021935164928436,
-0.4258926510810852,
-0.010066330432891846,
0.015367326326668262,
0.32298916578292847,
-0.8846613764762878,
0.5569811463356018,
0.17326965928077698,
-0.031387656927108765,
0.40596330165863037,
-0.18969294428825378,
-0.15268631279468536,
-0.7230950593948364,
0.11726820468902588,
-0.12430677562952042,
-0.1527440845966339,
-0.7583800554275513,
0.14651130139827728,
0.33260881900787354,
-0.4027692675590515,
-0.48711007833480835,
0.3442137837409973,
-0.4084753692150116,
0.0239315927028656,
-0.24902161955833435,
-0.12620019912719727,
0.2379019409418106,
1.0102523565292358,
0.15181294083595276,
0.6782433986663818,
0.4183790683746338,
-0.6184493899345398,
0.012265636585652828,
0.22973905503749847,
-0.09079142659902573,
0.2570817768573761,
-0.5910961627960205,
0.31265395879745483,
-0.3114633560180664,
0.19678160548210144,
-0.9413153529167175,
0.040826305747032166,
0.2590436041355133,
-0.5960946679115295,
0.7879389524459839,
0.0701913982629776,
-0.9215601682662964,
-0.5383628010749817,
-0.4303421974182129,
0.15107110142707825,
0.5295442342758179,
-0.6391246318817139,
1.3218661546707153,
0.2114318311214447,
-0.09415844082832336,
-0.6242159605026245,
-0.6735974550247192,
0.10656636953353882,
-0.17416013777256012,
-0.6212003231048584,
0.7995705604553223,
0.19919271767139435,
0.2563643157482147,
0.17406520247459412,
-0.3322986960411072,
0.053647153079509735,
0.15794876217842102,
0.1569194793701172,
0.22799448668956757,
0.16144800186157227,
0.48260146379470825,
-0.12955224514007568,
-0.2039869874715805,
-0.18127088248729706,
-0.5868293046951294,
0.6524028778076172,
0.19836702942848206,
-0.24361126124858856,
-0.43084752559661865,
0.45356571674346924,
0.823848307132721,
-0.5758246779441833,
0.7951680421829224,
0.8298008441925049,
-0.2745863199234009,
-0.1976948380470276,
-0.8600577116012573,
-0.34808582067489624,
-0.47458815574645996,
0.19427713751792908,
-0.15227943658828735,
-0.7903626561164856,
0.35751062631607056,
-0.09371784329414368,
0.3905012607574463,
0.6663830876350403,
0.36323145031929016,
-0.08890212327241898,
0.8625859618186951,
0.8698759078979492,
-0.3915218710899353,
0.7926015853881836,
-0.32033881545066833,
0.608198344707489,
-0.8573552370071411,
-0.15827512741088867,
-0.7837009429931641,
-0.5933992266654968,
-0.20557579398155212,
-0.7680856585502625,
0.1934741735458374,
0.00380747951567173,
0.010394570417702198,
0.42688488960266113,
-1.2758655548095703,
0.2454739809036255,
0.9149689078330994,
0.07671206444501877,
-0.012429329566657543,
-0.09171420335769653,
0.07002013176679611,
-0.09255322813987732,
-1.087943196296692,
-0.10948482155799866,
1.1186609268188477,
0.47151899337768555,
0.499403178691864,
-0.14422185719013214,
0.7245728969573975,
0.28028231859207153,
0.4845832586288452,
-0.9900171756744385,
0.40862512588500977,
-0.2042086124420166,
-0.5242438316345215,
-0.1484055072069168,
-0.1909780204296112,
-0.830392599105835,
0.4904588758945465,
-0.22173014283180237,
-0.5312310457229614,
0.2265215367078781,
-0.030191652476787567,
-0.3246140778064728,
0.12746742367744446,
-1.032507061958313,
0.8194356560707092,
-0.2825125455856323,
-0.26000988483428955,
-0.2556508481502533,
-0.8256736397743225,
0.08892246335744858,
-0.2133040875196457,
0.1069420650601387,
0.2087840884923935,
-0.07942717522382736,
0.9577780961990356,
-0.42611366510391235,
0.9646145105361938,
-0.09472199529409409,
0.3513551354408264,
0.2997521758079529,
-0.3235777020454407,
0.632000207901001,
-0.46671509742736816,
0.154962420463562,
0.24591821432113647,
-0.29057809710502625,
-0.30191588401794434,
-0.7157261967658997,
0.3381933271884918,
-0.7852377891540527,
-0.7744587659835815,
-0.4336048364639282,
-0.41617551445961,
-0.09593113511800766,
0.2700445353984833,
0.15524069964885712,
0.2959197461605072,
0.28050339221954346,
0.33958786725997925,
0.5930843353271484,
0.11130394041538239,
0.587139904499054,
0.19396527111530304,
0.27152132987976074,
-0.4847216308116913,
0.7361064553260803,
0.26638713479042053,
-0.05770391598343849,
0.4736899733543396,
0.24531137943267822,
-0.46497029066085815,
-0.636654257774353,
0.1049080565571785,
0.3968399465084076,
-0.9019438624382019,
-0.6819337010383606,
-1.060442328453064,
-0.3482342064380646,
-0.7080745100975037,
-0.24977140128612518,
-0.171245738863945,
-0.5023841857910156,
-0.5893530249595642,
-0.1574019342660904,
0.10224251449108124,
0.13082100450992584,
0.09164901077747345,
0.6901781558990479,
-1.094171166419983,
0.2103957235813141,
0.17395877838134766,
0.22350500524044037,
0.3796398937702179,
-0.5527469515800476,
-0.199660986661911,
-0.6711456179618835,
-0.3023379147052765,
-0.7916127443313599,
0.5238826870918274,
0.30696770548820496,
0.6973673701286316,
0.4323810636997223,
0.36814117431640625,
0.655562698841095,
-0.4258439540863037,
0.623234212398529,
0.34283971786499023,
-1.0490063428878784,
0.461163729429245,
0.04145669937133789,
0.33238485455513,
0.7198119759559631,
0.1319589763879776,
-0.4483867585659027,
-0.47794225811958313,
-1.1151702404022217,
-1.1493785381317139,
1.0550951957702637,
0.3447556495666504,
0.09745460003614426,
-0.09615768492221832,
0.37585723400115967,
-0.1971447765827179,
0.3108328878879547,
-0.6138520836830139,
-0.0004322492750361562,
-0.23425233364105225,
-0.5841572880744934,
0.07472964376211166,
-0.31191909313201904,
-0.04844772070646286,
-0.4796237051486969,
0.4269794523715973,
-0.14015544950962067,
0.454774409532547,
0.528370201587677,
-0.266437828540802,
0.20016051828861237,
-0.08461400121450424,
0.17756927013397217,
0.13959857821464539,
-0.0911395475268364,
0.18931788206100464,
0.011468448676168919,
-0.5135998129844666,
-0.17127659916877747,
0.017491383478045464,
-0.07530365884304047,
0.21909001469612122,
0.47556424140930176,
0.6569747924804688,
0.5516567230224609,
-0.5531542897224426,
0.6644517183303833,
-0.2605534493923187,
-0.23427927494049072,
0.03763926401734352,
0.11715417355298996,
0.05295826494693756,
-0.023770824074745178,
0.48114728927612305,
0.439786821603775,
0.1859312802553177,
-0.19123606383800507,
0.21525995433330536,
0.25038817524909973,
-0.1692664921283722,
-0.0626983493566513,
0.5338780283927917,
0.5008726716041565,
-0.5126925706863403,
0.735505998134613,
0.24844861030578613,
-1.0306472778320312,
0.6899337768554688,
0.3555450141429901,
0.9809103012084961,
-0.0514214001595974,
-0.1786971390247345,
0.439064085483551,
0.446781188249588,
-0.11543387174606323,
-0.24468348920345306,
-0.7471999526023865,
-0.5710657238960266,
-0.4689502716064453,
-0.8492898941040039,
-0.37546467781066895,
-0.1643332540988922,
-0.5628666281700134,
0.3275447189807892,
-0.5240923166275024,
-0.4296255111694336,
0.2035990208387375,
0.058032918721437454,
-0.8566951155662537,
0.3244277238845825,
0.018299682065844536,
1.2544203996658325,
-0.6947388052940369,
0.7250121831893921,
0.37100446224212646,
-0.29703953862190247,
-0.8046228289604187,
0.05088755860924721,
-0.5048266053199768,
-0.38184115290641785,
0.6283220052719116,
0.5905078053474426,
0.17372876405715942,
0.210201233625412,
-0.35139143466949463,
-0.7773417830467224,
0.8123987913131714,
0.0686163529753685,
-0.6776202917098999,
-0.25781282782554626,
-0.15392367541790009,
0.5473003387451172,
-0.011042396537959576,
0.19401228427886963,
0.5758415460586548,
0.5555967092514038,
0.2198459953069687,
-0.8202773332595825,
-0.2664884030818939,
-0.1870826631784439,
-0.15677766501903534,
0.45676955580711365,
-0.88883376121521,
0.6355271339416504,
0.11273814737796783,
-0.5574778318405151,
-0.3972477316856384,
0.7709894776344299,
-0.3986043334007263,
-0.043802812695503235,
0.7607398629188538,
0.815648078918457,
0.8056898713111877,
-0.22956813871860504,
0.9993345737457275,
-0.5710964202880859,
0.5381235480308533,
0.75115966796875,
-0.12205871194601059,
0.7331687808036804,
0.6399881839752197,
-0.3412696421146393,
-0.07081790268421173,
0.6274833083152771,
-0.2672085762023926,
0.5741670727729797,
0.013815206475555897,
-0.13077929615974426,
-0.18310271203517914,
-0.17861071228981018,
-0.025595273822546005,
0.38917526602745056,
0.2509320080280304,
-0.3365526795387268,
-0.12339609861373901,
-0.042982276529073715,
-0.1780654788017273,
-0.010210463777184486,
-0.3039212226867676,
0.9812745451927185,
-0.14644750952720642,
-0.944822371006012,
0.21953478455543518,
0.19007939100265503,
1.0510920286178589,
-0.5571503043174744,
0.20491982996463776,
-0.07867462933063507,
0.40696436166763306,
-0.08439099043607712,
-0.5136452317237854,
0.5282300114631653,
-0.0018836489180102944,
-0.3193572163581848,
-0.5321884155273438,
1.088369369506836,
-0.2877873182296753,
-0.6201034188270569,
0.1665615439414978,
0.11505035310983658,
-0.1173696368932724,
-0.23568788170814514,
-0.5919547080993652,
0.14146479964256287,
-0.04909003525972366,
-0.0704428032040596,
0.35195156931877136,
0.3927772641181946,
0.09696979820728302,
0.55631023645401,
0.955138623714447,
-0.04697522893548012,
-0.009614206850528717,
-0.03429698944091797,
1.199508547782898,
-0.5585448145866394,
-0.7766376733779907,
-0.7829259634017944,
0.4443843364715576,
-0.3016014099121094,
-0.17818471789360046,
0.42909276485443115,
0.42551761865615845,
0.6557921171188354,
-0.16317297518253326,
0.4514208734035492,
0.05066828802227974,
0.3780446946620941,
-0.23341675102710724,
0.6612200736999512,
-0.43351781368255615,
-0.17853662371635437,
0.03445632383227348,
-0.8031431436538696,
-0.5604557394981384,
0.6266650557518005,
-0.07582853734493256,
-0.2572152316570282,
0.7026114463806152,
0.4076354503631592,
0.03789806738495827,
-0.1231105849146843,
0.19275328516960144,
-0.20548106729984283,
0.40248018503189087,
0.4515824317932129,
0.46316108107566833,
-0.3461531698703766,
0.6930549740791321,
-0.4694405198097229,
-0.12342341989278793,
-0.38110771775245667,
-0.7900373339653015,
-0.9118205904960632,
-0.4990096688270569,
-0.3431825339794159,
-0.013129020109772682,
-0.3031994104385376,
0.6853678822517395,
0.8753902912139893,
-0.6143566370010376,
0.4495293200016022,
-0.05232834443449974,
0.0999385267496109,
-0.35493797063827515,
-0.29453685879707336,
0.7006345391273499,
-0.7087005972862244,
-0.9644237160682678,
-0.09919928014278412,
0.4921542704105377,
-0.002580824540928006,
-0.18452952802181244,
0.3734418749809265,
-0.14517748355865479,
0.13501019775867462,
0.37289485335350037,
-0.08636454492807388,
-0.7481166124343872,
-0.11312441527843475,
0.06643010675907135,
-0.10143911838531494,
0.23363091051578522,
1.046857237815857,
-0.9335574507713318,
0.3697029948234558,
0.6290529370307922,
0.9992432594299316,
0.6824281215667725,
0.34980088472366333,
0.4770863950252533,
-0.9181947112083435,
0.49588561058044434,
0.7642274498939514,
0.28684523701667786,
0.43975117802619934,
-0.7075119018554688,
0.5294470191001892,
0.22369186580181122,
-0.4228672385215759,
-0.9798784255981445,
-0.1963357925415039,
-1.1379421949386597,
-0.34934738278388977,
0.6497755646705627,
-0.22594940662384033,
-0.6094520688056946,
0.05411142855882645,
-0.46324294805526733,
0.36300212144851685,
-0.29348498582839966,
0.7642067670822144,
0.9720187187194824,
0.0768943801522255,
-0.3618448078632355,
-0.0692305713891983,
0.3801725208759308,
0.7047871947288513,
-0.4264126121997833,
0.13968999683856964,
0.1813749521970749,
-0.17372778058052063,
0.6061819195747375,
0.41855916380882263,
-0.07267072796821594,
0.1962485909461975,
0.09960369020700455,
0.15110962092876434,
-0.16590516269207,
-0.5073027014732361,
-0.43334120512008667,
0.590198278427124,
-0.13517579436302185,
-0.32907313108444214
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.01276v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.01276v2
|
EduNLP: Towards a Unified and Modularized Library for Educational Resources
| 2024-06-03T12:45:40 | 2024-06-04T11:44:59 |
Zhenya Huang, Yuting Ning, Longhu Qin, Shiwei Tong, Shangzi Xue, Tong Xiao, Xin Lin, Jiayu Liu, Qi Liu, Enhong Chen, Shijing Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Educational resource understanding is vital to online learning platforms,
which have demonstrated growing applications recently. However, researchers and
developers always struggle with using existing general natural language
toolkits or domain-specific models. The issue raises a need to develop an
effective and easy-to-use one that benefits AI education-related research and
applications. To bridge this gap, we present a unified, modularized, and
extensive library, EduNLP, focusing on educational resource understanding. In
the library, we decouple the whole workflow to four key modules with consistent
interfaces including data configuration, processing, model implementation, and
model evaluation. We also provide a configurable pipeline to unify the data
usage and model usage in standard ways, where users can customize their own
needs. For the current version, we primarily provide 10 typical models from
four categories, and 5 common downstream-evaluation tasks in the education
domain on 8 subjects for users' usage. The project is released at:
https://github.com/bigdata-ustc/EduNLP.
|
[
-0.46697044372558594,
-0.6799201369285583,
0.2427748590707779,
-0.21279563009738922,
-0.1856488436460495,
0.16570815443992615,
-0.4742982089519501,
-0.23413801193237305,
-0.10485987365245819,
0.34708815813064575,
-0.548550009727478,
-0.448113352060318,
-0.22723166644573212,
0.06708788871765137,
-0.2845061421394348,
0.9691148400306702,
0.09033741056919098,
0.17066740989685059,
-0.4193264842033386,
-0.10236556828022003,
-0.3602321147918701,
-0.17910422384738922,
-0.6858640313148499,
-0.5362840294837952,
0.7719852924346924,
0.5145694613456726,
0.3897998332977295,
0.6929659247398376,
0.6853323578834534,
0.1344994306564331,
-0.33484187722206116,
-0.0026115390937775373,
-0.365171879529953,
0.0778542160987854,
-0.6719158887863159,
-0.09308409690856934,
-0.782267153263092,
-0.27988335490226746,
0.7101943492889404,
1.038455843925476,
-0.5543249845504761,
0.4809629023075104,
0.5352804064750671,
0.8897610306739807,
-0.6721030473709106,
0.19831496477127075,
-0.0904192253947258,
0.2517005503177643,
-0.07706000655889511,
0.17775730788707733,
-0.2923632264137268,
-0.025281859561800957,
0.48740869760513306,
-0.8917647004127502,
0.09851918369531631,
-0.24788308143615723,
0.3036160469055176,
0.4343821406364441,
-0.34454765915870667,
-0.29336312413215637,
-0.7074028849601746,
0.7461897134780884,
-0.5321078896522522,
0.6257619857788086,
0.4992798864841461,
0.4512910544872284,
0.06110803782939911,
-1.2410316467285156,
-0.5077323317527771,
0.38649046421051025,
-0.13808344304561615,
0.3006347119808197,
0.015089510008692741,
0.39885151386260986,
-0.07715337723493576,
0.6300681829452515,
-0.6575500965118408,
0.3192098140716553,
-0.7654215097427368,
-0.010100744664669037,
0.4393514096736908,
0.14599885046482086,
0.26260805130004883,
-0.22768612205982208,
-0.4352527856826782,
0.1016763299703598,
-0.49972984194755554,
-0.015704084187746048,
0.4509727954864502,
0.5637691020965576,
-0.04081789031624794,
0.40767326951026917,
0.10643164813518524,
0.996833324432373,
-0.20043133199214935,
0.10656878352165222,
0.18914563953876495,
-0.26257288455963135,
-0.4904494285583496,
-0.016689470037817955,
0.4800759553909302,
0.1301754117012024,
-0.28866589069366455,
-0.05825704336166382,
-0.1783793419599533,
-0.4170199930667877,
0.3425467312335968,
-0.7406478524208069,
-0.38436946272850037,
0.48319149017333984,
-0.3827572166919708,
0.04231443628668785,
0.04853375256061554,
-1.010084867477417,
-0.14587268233299255,
-0.8821647763252258,
0.19896864891052246,
-0.3882811963558197,
-0.4664453864097595,
0.2329859435558319,
0.04560432210564613,
-0.04681922867894173,
0.38393670320510864,
-0.7608245015144348,
0.3219631612300873,
0.9603638052940369,
0.8728591203689575,
-0.24492135643959045,
-0.21521936357021332,
-0.36667537689208984,
0.05843332037329674,
0.17853961884975433,
0.4682375490665436,
-0.7924093008041382,
-0.14743679761886597,
0.2127658724784851,
-0.2292824387550354,
-0.15923099219799042,
-0.319938063621521,
0.7834155559539795,
-0.44261693954467773,
0.5758145451545715,
-0.13822954893112183,
-0.7997812628746033,
-0.5665541887283325,
0.3574618101119995,
-0.9332253336906433,
0.8432853817939758,
0.07395175844430923,
-0.5474138855934143,
0.1272473931312561,
-1.2247774600982666,
-0.11187148839235306,
0.4550730586051941,
-0.10473541915416718,
-0.06361839920282364,
-0.10317517071962357,
0.025347884744405746,
0.31946468353271484,
-0.3229564428329468,
0.8709045648574829,
0.06859021633863449,
-0.4013008773326874,
-0.38614583015441895,
-0.30186259746551514,
1.1876715421676636,
0.5823031663894653,
-0.0029837661422789097,
0.12347380816936493,
-0.7237913012504578,
-0.07941953092813492,
-0.18646636605262756,
-0.7490736842155457,
-0.38822367787361145,
-0.006756873801350594,
0.37731170654296875,
-0.1687203198671341,
0.37448135018348694,
-0.37514543533325195,
0.35162803530693054,
-0.09814663976430893,
0.4335719645023346,
0.7709047198295593,
-0.4992319643497467,
0.5977264642715454,
0.14280064404010773,
0.3450104594230652,
-0.19852878153324127,
0.4691527485847473,
-0.11950438469648361,
-0.38634929060935974,
-0.6840433478355408,
-0.42018696665763855,
0.29756686091423035,
0.020237959921360016,
-0.6193497776985168,
0.5305127501487732,
-0.07034321874380112,
-0.2971516251564026,
-0.6989601850509644,
0.23662614822387695,
0.2662730813026428,
0.584108293056488,
0.48427286744117737,
-0.23966485261917114,
-0.5652353763580322,
-0.6688992381095886,
0.14121966063976288,
-0.19268858432769775,
-0.3083949089050293,
0.3803788125514984,
0.32211366295814514,
-0.5214182734489441,
0.9667990207672119,
-0.2397511750459671,
-0.48395195603370667,
-0.5169416666030884,
0.050924379378557205,
0.3425292670726776,
0.39321404695510864,
0.41337260603904724,
-1.011572003364563,
-0.21204230189323425,
-0.021690165624022484,
-0.5531463623046875,
-0.02736380137503147,
0.0569906048476696,
-0.3688824474811554,
-0.22626423835754395,
0.06123223528265953,
-0.27262598276138306,
0.06781294196844101,
0.3791595995426178,
-0.5830942988395691,
0.17813339829444885,
-0.10171027481555939,
-0.1365751475095749,
-1.1321213245391846,
0.3332260847091675,
-0.09377601742744446,
0.02356439270079136,
-0.6722317337989807,
0.5112538933753967,
0.048449523746967316,
-0.22404196858406067,
-0.38695546984672546,
0.4738513231277466,
-0.1575527787208557,
-0.004408655222505331,
0.04417102783918381,
0.4254702925682068,
0.35995420813560486,
0.392483651638031,
0.01667463406920433,
0.5561195611953735,
0.6501356363296509,
-0.48099565505981445,
0.5857358574867249,
0.40262171626091003,
-0.20176339149475098,
0.649078905582428,
-0.7652220726013184,
0.13997234404087067,
-0.17704160511493683,
0.06201973557472229,
-0.4020713269710541,
-0.42476311326026917,
0.3792644441127777,
-0.016841435804963112,
0.4833776652812958,
-0.40726566314697266,
-0.4815535545349121,
-0.2590201497077942,
-0.2959720194339752,
0.30338048934936523,
0.34092170000076294,
-1.0184088945388794,
0.9912324547767639,
0.5130635499954224,
-0.11063817888498306,
-0.8569996953010559,
-0.4360341429710388,
-0.07737644016742706,
-0.04828648641705513,
-0.333285391330719,
0.2296016812324524,
-0.4790187478065491,
-0.21683324873447418,
0.3176235258579254,
0.10132373869419098,
-0.6260842084884644,
0.24552983045578003,
0.16852118074893951,
0.5455183386802673,
-0.42649561166763306,
0.5781911015510559,
0.012869589030742645,
0.22600282728672028,
0.019121645018458366,
-0.3311690092086792,
0.35559162497520447,
-0.17643064260482788,
-0.6574108600616455,
-0.32069042325019836,
0.1522410809993744,
0.5160349011421204,
-0.1997901052236557,
0.6869181990623474,
0.6157881021499634,
-0.47111645340919495,
-0.3619389533996582,
-0.22015266120433807,
-0.18349693715572357,
-0.4775988757610321,
0.3738457262516022,
0.07288918644189835,
-0.7495155930519104,
0.2980518043041229,
0.045594003051519394,
0.6697378158569336,
0.25922513008117676,
0.3810917139053345,
-0.136295348405838,
0.32941389083862305,
0.7183796167373657,
0.16182944178581238,
0.27167803049087524,
-0.41426581144332886,
0.31823068857192993,
-1.1388373374938965,
-0.691618800163269,
-0.25378918647766113,
-0.5343573093414307,
0.052950575947761536,
-0.3001474142074585,
-0.1431855857372284,
0.16494952142238617,
-0.33148226141929626,
0.18885274231433868,
-0.842772901058197,
0.7611106038093567,
0.5000225305557251,
-0.16091060638427734,
0.5086359977722168,
0.13355308771133423,
0.14142203330993652,
0.12437613308429718,
-0.7775605916976929,
-0.684532880783081,
1.2747187614440918,
0.35981377959251404,
0.6114816069602966,
0.30273208022117615,
0.6735466122627258,
0.31630629301071167,
0.21258482336997986,
-0.7934386730194092,
0.5687767267227173,
-0.2268838733434677,
-0.838379442691803,
-0.2575523555278778,
-0.32713782787323,
-0.7496621608734131,
0.23971834778785706,
-0.03877881169319153,
-0.5572453737258911,
0.11491357535123825,
0.06776418536901474,
-0.49797919392585754,
0.7204768657684326,
-0.4224050045013428,
0.834893524646759,
-0.1932201087474823,
-0.5254127383232117,
-0.3646412789821625,
-0.2473946362733841,
0.20092163980007172,
-0.32456862926483154,
0.24640679359436035,
-0.11529309302568436,
0.06412835419178009,
1.0880783796310425,
-0.054920539259910583,
0.7504388093948364,
0.10523881763219833,
0.18851998448371887,
0.6081203818321228,
-0.3030696213245392,
-0.04466733708977699,
0.020251929759979248,
-0.3714582920074463,
0.21004442870616913,
-0.21624329686164856,
-0.2732274830341339,
-0.4274270236492157,
0.9302469491958618,
-0.8129399418830872,
-0.4180416166782379,
-0.29833492636680603,
-0.6540349125862122,
0.2786947190761566,
0.09342337399721146,
-0.07182106375694275,
0.7222343683242798,
-0.21884416043758392,
0.32124313712120056,
0.7817813754081726,
-0.2554710805416107,
0.38967642188072205,
0.6196726560592651,
-0.2711789906024933,
0.01049895491451025,
0.8876643776893616,
0.21111373603343964,
-0.02040080912411213,
0.1309320628643036,
0.23879852890968323,
-0.3622429370880127,
-0.36980316042900085,
-0.3526323139667511,
-0.14509181678295135,
-0.9681263566017151,
-0.1302400827407837,
-0.4382702708244324,
-0.2055201679468155,
-0.2613796293735504,
-0.26267799735069275,
-0.4512849450111389,
-0.6245865821838379,
-0.6131481528282166,
-0.43421033024787903,
0.3027016520500183,
1.1720530986785889,
-0.4149657189846039,
0.06533587723970413,
-0.801964282989502,
0.030746258795261383,
0.5662223696708679,
0.6803756356239319,
0.28724420070648193,
-0.7176527976989746,
-0.37494370341300964,
0.026605652645230293,
-0.2972029447555542,
-0.40132635831832886,
0.1002848818898201,
0.8139227628707886,
0.6653733849525452,
0.6805809736251831,
0.20985758304595947,
0.3270721435546875,
-0.4364567995071411,
0.6687878370285034,
0.16990183293819427,
-0.559650719165802,
0.6033386588096619,
-0.1654662787914276,
-0.2734302878379822,
0.5371957421302795,
0.46291685104370117,
-0.3264763057231903,
0.06758172065019608,
-0.5449414849281311,
-1.2702031135559082,
0.6188214421272278,
0.12999428808689117,
0.2540687024593353,
0.4414019286632538,
0.21139134466648102,
0.4211027920246124,
0.14665383100509644,
-0.5040987730026245,
-0.5612739324569702,
-0.31325629353523254,
-0.4279758334159851,
0.23915311694145203,
-0.3313966989517212,
-0.4761466383934021,
-0.4315685033798218,
0.6534116268157959,
0.2340618520975113,
-0.2754848003387451,
-0.21399489045143127,
-0.1527562439441681,
0.02770770527422428,
0.6068167686462402,
-0.10670313984155655,
1.0809063911437988,
-0.5628656148910522,
0.10034511983394623,
-0.22469507157802582,
-0.7543871998786926,
-0.097637839615345,
0.34714964032173157,
-0.17309825122356415,
0.03339666128158569,
0.31712472438812256,
0.5172105431556702,
0.34328755736351013,
-0.984281599521637,
0.22068968415260315,
-0.22538894414901733,
0.17785342037677765,
-0.327268123626709,
0.2743026614189148,
0.09147053211927414,
0.45549091696739197,
0.4013993442058563,
-0.2883197069168091,
0.4303576350212097,
-0.49031051993370056,
0.37105482816696167,
-0.19608654081821442,
-0.3634173572063446,
-0.454085111618042,
0.5512204170227051,
0.7315296530723572,
-0.36552074551582336,
1.050398826599121,
-0.21528342366218567,
-0.37249988317489624,
0.5788305997848511,
0.42728567123413086,
0.9682761430740356,
-0.1553015261888504,
0.545237123966217,
0.7396158576011658,
0.09821969270706177,
-0.06452872604131699,
0.29327723383903503,
-0.16569221019744873,
-0.4948783218860626,
-0.25443145632743835,
-0.7812789082527161,
-0.6305980682373047,
0.18819017708301544,
-1.1642906665802002,
0.17021797597408295,
-0.5851345062255859,
-0.03056810051202774,
0.013577837496995926,
-0.34223315119743347,
-0.8443776369094849,
-0.012330147437751293,
0.2639608383178711,
0.8132931590080261,
-0.8520379662513733,
0.7523463368415833,
1.176622986793518,
-0.4848499000072479,
-0.9446040987968445,
-0.4754077196121216,
-0.006242557428777218,
-0.32523074746131897,
0.8029718995094299,
0.09061410278081894,
0.27790942788124084,
0.057639237493276596,
-0.4041704833507538,
-0.5858561992645264,
1.1686551570892334,
0.19625167548656464,
-0.8816232085227966,
0.000856351456604898,
-0.06147506460547447,
0.5014086961746216,
-0.43512284755706787,
0.2520331144332886,
0.7011394500732422,
0.32716676592826843,
0.11911074072122574,
-0.7149860858917236,
-0.438629686832428,
-0.267895370721817,
-0.5008484125137329,
-0.11176443845033646,
-0.09960297495126724,
1.091863989830017,
-0.27723267674446106,
-0.34366554021835327,
-0.5410162806510925,
0.43043622374534607,
0.12063470482826233,
0.4303002953529358,
0.11152159422636032,
0.8436198830604553,
0.9486654996871948,
-0.1262662559747696,
0.6362588405609131,
-0.2938055694103241,
0.7310641407966614,
1.5264259576797485,
-0.018518589437007904,
0.9434624314308167,
0.32546764612197876,
-0.33321699500083923,
0.3982333540916443,
0.7080742120742798,
-0.06562983989715576,
0.44863200187683105,
-0.20754949748516083,
-0.4725726544857025,
-0.2523447275161743,
-0.4861583709716797,
-0.33183416724205017,
0.17378830909729004,
0.4775272607803345,
-0.21160145103931427,
-0.4709404408931732,
0.03983208164572716,
-0.36120474338531494,
0.11023040860891342,
-0.6713358163833618,
0.4958692789077759,
0.08951766788959503,
-0.11067119240760803,
0.17282621562480927,
-0.2811257243156433,
0.5209369659423828,
-0.424570769071579,
-0.16440850496292114,
-0.25453683733940125,
0.07496852427721024,
-0.4395165741443634,
-1.2379471063613892,
0.20753590762615204,
0.20706601440906525,
-0.10468970239162445,
0.009374826215207577,
0.5656819939613342,
-0.5981733202934265,
-0.40983206033706665,
0.4352700114250183,
0.4460560083389282,
0.23142318427562714,
0.36467233300209045,
-0.6706740260124207,
0.04140544310212135,
0.06883874535560608,
-0.3440472185611725,
0.25737348198890686,
0.2956560254096985,
0.5939568877220154,
0.761228621006012,
0.693101704120636,
0.028826186433434486,
-0.008272422477602959,
0.38042017817497253,
0.9342572093009949,
-0.12320936471223831,
-0.23624292016029358,
-0.6419931054115295,
0.6983646750450134,
-0.15774644911289215,
-0.30569711327552795,
0.3772324323654175,
0.4765027165412903,
1.0209976434707642,
0.14827179908752441,
0.7807704210281372,
-0.2343473583459854,
0.309815376996994,
-0.219802126288414,
0.9190679788589478,
-0.6734193563461304,
0.5282956957817078,
0.15532995760440826,
-1.1299008131027222,
-0.18497219681739807,
0.7459902763366699,
0.09912677854299545,
-0.3505389094352722,
0.35406720638275146,
0.08092178404331207,
-0.47442224621772766,
0.08365299552679062,
0.13324971497058868,
-0.04924030974507332,
0.3641003668308258,
0.36010411381721497,
0.5363374352455139,
-0.2561263144016266,
0.3456587493419647,
-0.3572846055030823,
-0.07606691122055054,
-0.22624178230762482,
-0.7587593197822571,
-1.1475529670715332,
-0.6732879877090454,
-0.508312463760376,
0.13457931578159332,
0.11775008589029312,
1.3437153100967407,
0.40275683999061584,
-0.755271315574646,
-0.15117380023002625,
0.12450889497995377,
0.34683728218078613,
0.11388690024614334,
-0.17218820750713348,
0.6133604049682617,
-0.1310393065214157,
-0.9518098831176758,
0.38802674412727356,
0.33726927638053894,
-0.17468981444835663,
-0.45944613218307495,
-0.18081890046596527,
-0.18827570974826813,
-0.11590272933244705,
0.49446794390678406,
0.4054045081138611,
-0.6045075058937073,
0.03903447464108467,
-0.2750786244869232,
-0.03544203191995621,
-0.14868932962417603,
0.6874954104423523,
-0.6015669107437134,
0.9799479842185974,
0.4957315921783447,
0.7965101003646851,
-0.20126661658287048,
-0.20765532553195953,
0.5360398888587952,
-0.635418176651001,
0.25935012102127075,
0.4528149962425232,
0.6168650388717651,
0.5445773601531982,
-0.3691040277481079,
0.8183779716491699,
-0.140594482421875,
-0.5380823612213135,
-1.0071115493774414,
0.18884067237377167,
-0.6883657574653625,
-0.38450881838798523,
0.6741321682929993,
-0.4706781804561615,
0.007083103526383638,
-0.3089018166065216,
0.10506577044725418,
0.35398346185684204,
-0.42798149585723877,
0.7844710946083069,
0.5245398879051208,
0.1332346498966217,
0.0034483978524804115,
-0.701043963432312,
0.1368274986743927,
-0.07241420447826385,
-0.6297934055328369,
0.04529755562543869,
0.49098145961761475,
0.17502106726169586,
0.26053541898727417,
0.20583339035511017,
0.22275209426879883,
0.13817918300628662,
-0.28511276841163635,
0.22167836129665375,
-0.5365777015686035,
-0.5575059056282043,
-0.25819820165634155,
-0.01644766330718994,
-0.16107630729675293,
-0.1701740026473999
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.01252v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.01252v1
|
Towards Scalable Automated Alignment of LLMs: A Survey
| 2024-06-03T12:10:26 | 2024-06-03T12:10:26 |
Boxi Cao, Keming Lu, Xinyu Lu, Jiawei Chen, Mengjie Ren, Hao Xiang, Peilin Liu, Yaojie Lu, Ben He, Xianpei Han, Le Sun, Hongyu Lin, Bowen Yu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, stat.ML
|
Alignment is the most critical step in building large language models (LLMs)
that meet human needs. With the rapid development of LLMs gradually surpassing
human capabilities, traditional alignment methods based on human-annotation are
increasingly unable to meet the scalability demands. Therefore, there is an
urgent need to explore new sources of automated alignment signals and technical
approaches. In this paper, we systematically review the recently emerging
methods of automated alignment, attempting to explore how to achieve effective,
scalable, automated alignment once the capabilities of LLMs exceed those of
humans. Specifically, we categorize existing automated alignment methods into 4
major categories based on the sources of alignment signals and discuss the
current status and potential development of each category. Additionally, we
explore the underlying mechanisms that enable automated alignment and discuss
the essential factors that make automated alignment technologies feasible and
effective from the fundamental role of alignment.
|
[
-0.5329765677452087,
-0.7000405192375183,
0.6275874376296997,
0.10901667922735214,
0.05184971168637276,
0.5972501635551453,
-0.16615094244480133,
-0.7445335388183594,
0.23983590304851532,
0.47883346676826477,
-0.5013269782066345,
-0.20168982446193695,
-0.6060352325439453,
0.2681165933609009,
-0.6636962890625,
0.6323928833007812,
-0.36260271072387695,
-0.1514245867729187,
-0.23853963613510132,
-0.3145885169506073,
-0.5776938796043396,
-0.4605100154876709,
-0.5195682048797607,
-0.175909623503685,
0.4334263205528259,
0.5633159875869751,
0.833153247833252,
1.3681658506393433,
0.8934981226921082,
0.3763437867164612,
0.11550626158714294,
0.16762389242649078,
0.031082650646567345,
0.23812320828437805,
0.16094395518302917,
-0.38437420129776,
-0.874657154083252,
0.015106817707419395,
1.0278960466384888,
0.8634729385375977,
-0.04411889612674713,
0.3388160467147827,
-0.019013935700058937,
0.5277140736579895,
-0.388356477022171,
-0.29195067286491394,
-0.5782703161239624,
-0.2067422717809677,
-0.6096857190132141,
-0.07328994572162628,
-0.10936670750379562,
-0.5340415239334106,
0.11705336719751358,
-0.3606835603713989,
-0.15197177231311798,
0.33059999346733093,
0.8632574677467346,
0.4938884973526001,
-0.5981753468513489,
-0.40646588802337646,
-0.7847472429275513,
0.8179848790168762,
-0.790200412273407,
0.46606582403182983,
0.11959351599216461,
0.5602006912231445,
-0.05470569059252739,
-0.4835343062877655,
-0.4801274836063385,
-0.2291449010372162,
0.0016988576389849186,
-0.3789967894554138,
0.10051483660936356,
-0.13741332292556763,
0.12710483372211456,
0.34817832708358765,
-0.5221610069274902,
0.6667987704277039,
0.08010909706354141,
-0.3524215519428253,
0.7516239881515503,
0.35893958806991577,
0.6034068465232849,
0.13118484616279602,
-0.13583140075206757,
0.22560293972492218,
-0.6726386547088623,
-0.38920167088508606,
0.47404804825782776,
0.3710262179374695,
0.08512331545352936,
0.7903535962104797,
-0.08148116618394852,
0.986615777015686,
0.3771823048591614,
-0.24850398302078247,
0.12229255586862564,
-0.7674064636230469,
0.12010736018419266,
0.17698360979557037,
0.8166853785514832,
0.14153851568698883,
0.1417665034532547,
0.0035177443642169237,
-0.3072850704193115,
-0.2381569743156433,
0.4035847783088684,
-0.2524971067905426,
0.2897004187107086,
0.48857545852661133,
-0.1763894259929657,
-0.4946591854095459,
-0.1509140431880951,
-0.5130330920219421,
-0.5124378800392151,
-0.730811595916748,
0.26964321732521057,
-0.18186300992965698,
-0.17698925733566284,
-0.13012751936912537,
0.25216129422187805,
0.5162588357925415,
0.4115000069141388,
-1.3060156106948853,
0.20730774104595184,
0.7119773626327515,
0.868995726108551,
-0.3710542917251587,
-0.2759902775287628,
-0.4527316689491272,
0.26995572447776794,
-0.4790947735309601,
0.9446314573287964,
-0.3062369227409363,
0.2254781275987625,
0.11008187383413315,
0.02880115993320942,
0.28739476203918457,
-0.2816968858242035,
0.3862331509590149,
-0.6628883481025696,
0.18688766658306122,
-0.32641392946243286,
-0.6266346573829651,
-0.15924164652824402,
0.24040526151657104,
-0.720812201499939,
0.8808004260063171,
-0.043489232659339905,
-0.6288808584213257,
0.3918444812297821,
-0.5648394823074341,
-0.46276864409446716,
0.11871051788330078,
-0.09941349923610687,
-0.5118598937988281,
-0.09212005138397217,
0.35966023802757263,
0.48802700638771057,
-0.41310757398605347,
0.27467215061187744,
-0.31054937839508057,
-0.15101762115955353,
0.35712334513664246,
-0.2823337912559509,
0.8914774060249329,
0.20100608468055725,
-0.5011598467826843,
0.3310942053794861,
-0.841170072555542,
-0.018666720017790794,
-0.10763721913099289,
-0.2547037899494171,
-0.04062800109386444,
0.20776249468326569,
-0.06014939025044441,
0.13425323367118835,
0.6581376791000366,
-0.2589207887649536,
0.4614637792110443,
-0.3752574026584625,
0.4750726521015167,
0.7788153886795044,
-0.3289376497268677,
0.9653950929641724,
-0.21894176304340363,
0.6284959316253662,
-0.4275512993335724,
0.11093518882989883,
-0.01940043456852436,
-0.20485110580921173,
-0.6299077868461609,
-0.588212251663208,
0.4605124592781067,
0.6287758350372314,
-0.13424639403820038,
0.9635934233665466,
-0.3695431649684906,
-0.702653169631958,
-0.7208508253097534,
0.3209594488143921,
0.1633332073688507,
0.5332451462745667,
0.10833241045475006,
-0.24992235004901886,
-0.7955363392829895,
-0.9667030572891235,
-0.17258436977863312,
0.021814746782183647,
0.061117883771657944,
-0.043931178748607635,
0.15604813396930695,
-0.47052037715911865,
1.2094571590423584,
-0.29954978823661804,
-0.1929127275943756,
-0.21296191215515137,
0.11423049122095108,
0.005665219854563475,
0.4175019860267639,
0.4689907729625702,
-0.5376038551330566,
-0.43960797786712646,
0.43037763237953186,
-0.7248575091362,
-0.5572975277900696,
-0.07831227779388428,
-0.027281254529953003,
0.3396766483783722,
0.806165337562561,
-0.3355558216571808,
-0.14299581944942474,
0.6370776295661926,
-0.0629919245839119,
0.3673623204231262,
0.022991754114627838,
0.0843665823340416,
-1.043016791343689,
0.050524722784757614,
-0.06109050661325455,
-0.45440301299095154,
-0.6726275682449341,
0.009789462201297283,
0.2778454124927521,
0.22626300156116486,
-0.1512313336133957,
0.4762844741344452,
-0.8576103448867798,
-0.48193997144699097,
-0.32268449664115906,
0.2978461682796478,
-0.414426326751709,
-0.06840207427740097,
-0.15770655870437622,
0.8227621912956238,
0.592136561870575,
-0.34797200560569763,
0.6646198034286499,
0.15188053250312805,
-0.09698935598134995,
0.6234388947486877,
-0.475453644990921,
-0.00016734447854105383,
-0.1090581938624382,
0.2947029173374176,
-1.1575771570205688,
-0.4252924919128418,
0.30615586042404175,
-0.3199497163295746,
0.5495208501815796,
0.06257574260234833,
-0.5147131085395813,
-0.27362626791000366,
-0.061861082911491394,
0.4908570349216461,
0.4254806935787201,
-0.3083430230617523,
0.785571813583374,
0.6695543527603149,
-0.40555188059806824,
-0.6144740581512451,
-0.5841151475906372,
0.382620632648468,
-0.5341516733169556,
-0.6475920081138611,
0.1796586513519287,
0.10679738223552704,
-0.4119563102722168,
-0.3106566369533539,
0.02369069494307041,
0.06563477963209152,
0.1769023984670639,
0.09488649666309357,
0.44205236434936523,
-0.19805893301963806,
-0.0012368852039799094,
-0.13681085407733917,
-0.269473671913147,
-0.24585691094398499,
-0.6398323774337769,
0.46867284178733826,
-0.220631942152977,
-0.5205756425857544,
-0.7371216416358948,
0.25334614515304565,
0.8032575845718384,
-0.42299607396125793,
0.44496843218803406,
0.579300045967102,
-0.38953524827957153,
0.15078644454479218,
-0.9929664134979248,
0.1185818761587143,
-0.46039870381355286,
0.3428308665752411,
-0.029836473986506462,
-1.0155868530273438,
0.49217861890792847,
-0.18891838192939758,
0.3514042794704437,
0.48281365633010864,
0.8355605602264404,
-0.24272103607654572,
1.2731200456619263,
0.7497504949569702,
-0.17165184020996094,
0.4326924681663513,
0.2876487374305725,
0.28311097621917725,
-0.7425764203071594,
0.06879087537527084,
-0.7677794098854065,
-0.33320745825767517,
-0.6982651352882385,
-0.32863906025886536,
0.0757080614566803,
-0.07558546215295792,
-0.15881459414958954,
0.7153179049491882,
-0.6190619468688965,
0.27545979619026184,
0.247514545917511,
-0.6054181456565857,
0.31620505452156067,
-0.14261190593242645,
0.11709154397249222,
0.03088030405342579,
-0.46149230003356934,
-0.8118696212768555,
1.0397523641586304,
0.5466725826263428,
0.5611084699630737,
0.10249222815036774,
0.638975977897644,
0.10314913094043732,
0.4600212275981903,
-0.893620491027832,
0.5012506246566772,
0.20300450921058655,
-0.6564977765083313,
-0.8330800533294678,
-0.015847470611333847,
-0.6990764141082764,
0.004252179991453886,
-0.23066973686218262,
-0.6732327938079834,
0.05983868986368179,
0.11156991869211197,
-0.3020687401294708,
0.06640792638063431,
-0.5122677087783813,
0.557269811630249,
-0.7332608699798584,
-0.045028235763311386,
0.14725351333618164,
-0.8824202418327332,
0.25908300280570984,
-0.5810627937316895,
0.4661629796028137,
-0.21513034403324127,
-0.4882711172103882,
0.6349627375602722,
-0.41188719868659973,
0.664335310459137,
0.16391494870185852,
-0.6779278516769409,
0.1862921565771103,
-0.2684095799922943,
0.5747954845428467,
-0.38635364174842834,
0.1161535233259201,
0.20406457781791687,
-0.03424474224448204,
-0.34860026836395264,
-0.4260050058364868,
0.4376877248287201,
-0.6448344588279724,
-0.5358091592788696,
-0.38704726099967957,
-0.752752423286438,
-0.381218820810318,
0.37471550703048706,
0.07801096141338348,
0.12619651854038239,
-0.023405637592077255,
-0.0394982285797596,
0.6996461749076843,
0.2357148975133896,
0.5284023880958557,
0.38830623030662537,
-0.2906467914581299,
-0.6472566723823547,
0.9604842066764832,
0.38026100397109985,
0.2705167829990387,
0.4554019570350647,
-0.026200903579592705,
-0.35505765676498413,
-0.9337155818939209,
-0.4180934727191925,
0.3766788840293884,
-0.6101729869842529,
-0.09300584346055984,
-0.6088903546333313,
-0.060155127197504044,
-0.6214988231658936,
-0.518162190914154,
-0.4981773793697357,
-0.6080024838447571,
-0.3035508096218109,
-0.031014245003461838,
0.1252983957529068,
0.7733219265937805,
0.020156439393758774,
0.32228440046310425,
-0.9274315237998962,
0.13122718036174774,
0.4100152552127838,
0.26665112376213074,
-0.16527159512043,
-0.4283803105354309,
-0.23327946662902832,
-0.1499323844909668,
-0.15205061435699463,
-0.596467137336731,
0.14066462218761444,
-0.0956297218799591,
0.5239737629890442,
0.5753459930419922,
-0.3163106143474579,
0.83040851354599,
-0.6318658590316772,
0.6423107385635376,
0.17938652634620667,
-1.0071301460266113,
0.391717791557312,
-0.5095879435539246,
0.12284287065267563,
0.47256121039390564,
0.5360174179077148,
-0.548243522644043,
-0.4223109185695648,
-0.27033111453056335,
-0.8805699348449707,
0.4240841865539551,
-0.0033691462595015764,
-0.17136670649051666,
0.22672754526138306,
0.3636844754219055,
0.14291799068450928,
-0.07014737278223038,
-0.5180761814117432,
0.04790090397000313,
0.33729276061058044,
-0.58651202917099,
-0.1825067698955536,
-0.08971186727285385,
-0.14813858270645142,
-0.08770378679037094,
0.6129906177520752,
-0.27544090151786804,
-0.12966467440128326,
-0.24525871872901917,
-0.18575067818164825,
-0.3172149956226349,
0.14594872295856476,
0.6737979650497437,
0.7473978996276855,
-0.06452935189008713,
-0.048223190009593964,
0.1589663326740265,
-0.3060402274131775,
0.4910300672054291,
-0.01612008735537529,
-0.18331724405288696,
-0.3352057933807373,
0.496102511882782,
0.41554874181747437,
0.08218418061733246,
-0.6250715851783752,
0.40753230452537537,
-0.008224544115364552,
-0.2498697191476822,
-0.5381779074668884,
0.0063598910346627235,
0.23859575390815735,
0.25635674595832825,
0.29339203238487244,
-0.12825915217399597,
-0.14640185236930847,
-0.3469336926937103,
0.15690048038959503,
0.7971931099891663,
-0.20510829985141754,
-0.16855499148368835,
0.8072832822799683,
0.3034897446632385,
-0.42911383509635925,
0.5599925518035889,
0.09742410480976105,
-0.29214173555374146,
0.2991601526737213,
0.2651761770248413,
0.9804299473762512,
-0.3185957372188568,
-0.15130473673343658,
0.2515881061553955,
0.43280601501464844,
-0.37860769033432007,
-0.08999459445476532,
-0.10959532111883163,
-0.7213109731674194,
-0.668085515499115,
-0.6913425326347351,
-0.5158708095550537,
-0.5056661367416382,
-0.5062806010246277,
0.46144774556159973,
-0.22284290194511414,
-0.1622035950422287,
0.1542593389749527,
0.014655082486569881,
-0.23053193092346191,
-0.011432514525949955,
0.30792859196662903,
0.7288132309913635,
-0.8866094946861267,
0.6267960667610168,
0.7750528454780579,
-0.24289989471435547,
-0.7373499870300293,
-0.02542870119214058,
0.4623011350631714,
-0.893121600151062,
0.5988609790802002,
-0.0886593759059906,
-0.06386628746986389,
0.1798013597726822,
-0.5878843069076538,
-1.5602245330810547,
1.2104284763336182,
0.26585420966148376,
-0.7144213914871216,
-0.24779054522514343,
0.33550000190734863,
0.4927006661891937,
-0.43619540333747864,
0.05028236657381058,
0.8381853103637695,
0.7253020405769348,
0.19809632003307343,
-1.0545845031738281,
0.13138099014759064,
0.10993799567222595,
0.16161125898361206,
0.42752861976623535,
-0.4891234338283539,
0.4388841390609741,
0.04226648062467575,
-0.0929621011018753,
0.1829223483800888,
0.763448178768158,
0.03397635743021965,
-0.127280130982399,
0.4545985162258148,
0.5920765399932861,
0.8555757999420166,
-0.05118531361222267,
0.611607015132904,
-0.2205357700586319,
0.05734087526798248,
0.8523132801055908,
-0.5525270104408264,
0.6989746689796448,
0.5260853171348572,
-0.27441415190696716,
0.21619893610477448,
0.6663716435432434,
-0.11273083835840225,
-0.01845598965883255,
0.14351147413253784,
-0.0392630510032177,
-0.3539116084575653,
0.032296523451805115,
-0.024355508387088776,
0.5877062678337097,
0.2588871121406555,
-0.02053273655474186,
-0.012710371054708958,
-0.06535714864730835,
-0.10664096474647522,
-0.03718750178813934,
-0.2094797044992447,
1.0272948741912842,
-0.3367127478122711,
-0.7997534871101379,
0.5996712446212769,
-0.1938420534133911,
0.7386387586593628,
-0.484180212020874,
0.23492130637168884,
0.014506595209240913,
-0.15042993426322937,
-0.472042977809906,
-0.619624137878418,
0.44856175780296326,
-0.0015709615545347333,
-0.049772877246141434,
-0.4432563781738281,
0.6219045519828796,
-0.3490174412727356,
-0.3225833773612976,
-0.03142547234892845,
0.5342608690261841,
-0.0386354885995388,
0.2865862250328064,
-0.47213855385780334,
0.19788821041584015,
-0.08508935570716858,
-0.11802095919847488,
0.4524957239627838,
0.37800028920173645,
-0.2651883363723755,
0.8725559115409851,
0.510093629360199,
0.25284016132354736,
0.2362418919801712,
-0.18561537563800812,
0.4560045599937439,
-0.6981080174446106,
-0.13973069190979004,
-0.7893887162208557,
0.6669782400131226,
-0.035467423498630524,
0.07642751187086105,
0.9497689008712769,
0.2408677637577057,
0.5583471059799194,
0.33511051535606384,
0.8176599144935608,
-0.0863291546702385,
0.42107412219047546,
-0.3293195366859436,
0.6586316227912903,
-0.5430201888084412,
0.3049927055835724,
-0.34308019280433655,
-1.1435534954071045,
-0.6676057577133179,
0.2932629883289337,
-0.10363350808620453,
-0.13090460002422333,
0.6256920695304871,
0.7790930867195129,
0.24815824627876282,
-0.1142742708325386,
0.15041066706180573,
0.0689573884010315,
0.4241431653499603,
-0.06046357378363609,
0.8576280474662781,
-0.10442498326301575,
0.4945470988750458,
0.028877800330519676,
-0.50508052110672,
-0.25644490122795105,
-1.1520074605941772,
-0.48460784554481506,
-0.7215948700904846,
-0.5951967239379883,
0.05128270015120506,
-0.21355563402175903,
0.9427155256271362,
0.5611764192581177,
-0.7927975058555603,
-0.38547709584236145,
-0.273978054523468,
0.06987813115119934,
-0.31919053196907043,
-0.14873230457305908,
0.26120704412460327,
-0.6949155330657959,
-0.8563380241394043,
0.16487643122673035,
0.6829379200935364,
0.25193360447883606,
-0.32237499952316284,
0.14054957032203674,
-0.2584436237812042,
0.03365436568856239,
0.3524119257926941,
0.5667576193809509,
-0.7996088266372681,
-0.3747778832912445,
0.0014848284190520644,
-0.38573431968688965,
0.03011018969118595,
0.661784827709198,
-0.4493911862373352,
0.20371684432029724,
0.5072238445281982,
1.043169379234314,
-0.2828172445297241,
0.11826526373624802,
0.8218644261360168,
-0.4565224349498749,
-0.21125131845474243,
0.23255054652690887,
0.36923590302467346,
0.3644489049911499,
-0.2440814971923828,
0.41149452328681946,
-0.06821536272764206,
-0.9804633855819702,
-0.8569940328598022,
0.25227782130241394,
-0.9643819332122803,
0.0403345488011837,
1.017738938331604,
0.3376888334751129,
-0.10178698599338531,
-0.2065577358007431,
-0.2848478853702545,
0.3379351496696472,
0.17450961470603943,
0.7254564762115479,
0.8273071050643921,
-0.24961596727371216,
-0.05861533060669899,
-0.23723608255386353,
0.37798231840133667,
0.31420260667800903,
-0.8488141894340515,
0.36915451288223267,
0.6654161214828491,
0.08532434701919556,
0.33834150433540344,
0.5687556862831116,
-0.28952670097351074,
0.1137736365199089,
-0.2985987365245819,
0.13136151432991028,
0.2919929325580597,
-0.11864965409040451,
-0.7018219232559204,
0.19606630504131317,
0.4797598719596863,
0.19005431234836578
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.01238v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.01238v1
|
EffiQA: Efficient Question-Answering with Strategic Multi-Model Collaboration on Knowledge Graphs
| 2024-06-03T11:56:07 | 2024-06-03T11:56:07 |
Zixuan Dong, Baoyun Peng, Yufei Wang, Jia Fu, Xiaodong Wang, Yongxue Shan, Xin Zhou
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
While large language models (LLMs) have shown remarkable capabilities in
natural language processing, they struggle with complex, multi-step reasoning
tasks involving knowledge graphs (KGs). Existing approaches that integrate LLMs
and KGs either underutilize the reasoning abilities of LLMs or suffer from
prohibitive computational costs due to tight coupling. To address these
limitations, we propose a novel collaborative framework named EffiQA that can
strike a balance between performance and efficiency via an iterative paradigm.
EffiQA consists of three stages: global planning, efficient KG exploration, and
self-reflection. Specifically, EffiQA leverages the commonsense capability of
LLMs to explore potential reasoning pathways through global planning. Then, it
offloads semantic pruning to a small plug-in model for efficient KG
exploration. Finally, the exploration results are fed to LLMs for
self-reflection to further improve the global planning and efficient KG
exploration. Empirical evidence on multiple KBQA benchmarks shows EffiQA's
effectiveness, achieving an optimal balance between reasoning accuracy and
computational costs. We hope the proposed new framework will pave the way for
efficient, knowledge-intensive querying by redefining the integration of LLMs
and KGs, fostering future research on knowledge-based question answering.
|
[
-0.4816438555717468,
-0.8285422325134277,
1.0009050369262695,
0.08551527559757233,
0.05958419293165207,
0.21765442192554474,
-0.03264790028333664,
-0.15716055035591125,
0.27881303429603577,
0.4761081635951996,
-0.7234945297241211,
-0.3467029929161072,
-0.34810957312583923,
0.06936690211296082,
-0.03390481323003769,
0.3679841160774231,
-0.2881513237953186,
-0.10742315649986267,
-0.5964385867118835,
-0.309621661901474,
-0.16944719851016998,
-0.2920475900173187,
-0.46314021944999695,
-0.3086121082305908,
0.6824097633361816,
0.7027501463890076,
0.8114295601844788,
0.24392157793045044,
0.18259303271770477,
0.3285207450389862,
0.048467203974723816,
0.6479235887527466,
-0.5936390161514282,
0.45392388105392456,
-0.1712564378976822,
-0.07928208261728287,
-0.2427247315645218,
-0.2166571170091629,
0.47909384965896606,
0.844062328338623,
-0.45781150460243225,
0.1963299959897995,
0.11039324104785919,
0.6289572715759277,
-0.7198094129562378,
0.12373765558004379,
-0.4873931109905243,
-0.3796497583389282,
0.20261776447296143,
0.024873530492186546,
-0.283630907535553,
-0.3987094759941101,
0.25684821605682373,
-1.013190507888794,
-0.2503487467765808,
0.32746633887290955,
0.5624257922172546,
0.4496617913246155,
-0.35792893171310425,
-0.37262415885925293,
-0.3884260654449463,
0.6386532187461853,
-0.3531986176967621,
0.6321208477020264,
0.09015621989965439,
0.5009784698486328,
-0.27053362131118774,
-1.0540508031845093,
-0.6860113739967346,
0.006520501803606749,
-0.0184361282736063,
0.20732343196868896,
-0.2792374789714813,
0.23084820806980133,
-0.004328670911490917,
0.15009504556655884,
-0.554390013217926,
-0.25389567017555237,
-0.3049722909927368,
-0.29497215151786804,
0.5382681488990784,
0.13607004284858704,
0.1288304179906845,
-0.06409161537885666,
-0.4188927412033081,
0.13277655839920044,
-0.5356273055076599,
-0.009527547284960747,
0.10032488405704498,
0.13491906225681305,
0.42326119542121887,
0.5807638168334961,
-0.7375036478042603,
0.8837376236915588,
-0.3205339312553406,
-0.047282636165618896,
-0.12639851868152618,
-0.6024526357650757,
-0.3628440201282501,
-0.28240641951560974,
0.6864038705825806,
0.2768876850605011,
0.05238144099712372,
-0.4514063894748688,
0.10778826475143433,
-0.21472881734371185,
0.20253273844718933,
-0.6931854486465454,
-0.46453946828842163,
0.37684401869773865,
-0.018152298405766487,
0.07427484542131424,
-0.41282615065574646,
-0.6391175389289856,
-0.17768126726150513,
-0.1809600442647934,
0.8398874402046204,
-0.2836519777774811,
-0.2537464499473572,
0.27703574299812317,
-0.20505763590335846,
0.019240912050008774,
0.4698048532009125,
-0.349057137966156,
0.4488000273704529,
0.6096299290657043,
0.7073869705200195,
0.1921389400959015,
-0.28905025124549866,
-0.662807822227478,
0.4882274270057678,
-0.14765144884586334,
0.7540723085403442,
-0.3295578956604004,
-0.13681919872760773,
-0.2022465616464615,
-0.28878310322761536,
-0.22386135160923004,
-0.2836970388889313,
0.7875495553016663,
-0.8517705202102661,
0.23122438788414001,
-0.6688949465751648,
-0.7282176613807678,
-0.5111452341079712,
0.5393853783607483,
-0.8046348094940186,
1.0862250328063965,
0.15171897411346436,
-0.7113936543464661,
0.2009279876947403,
-0.8472815155982971,
-0.15751740336418152,
0.23575715720653534,
-0.07551579177379608,
-0.06182818114757538,
-0.3423389196395874,
0.4656997323036194,
0.31767725944519043,
-0.7727619409561157,
0.47585242986679077,
-0.37737125158309937,
-0.2853061854839325,
-0.10243594646453857,
0.07263179868459702,
0.9162689447402954,
0.38397854566574097,
-0.049369413405656815,
0.11609090864658356,
-0.5289644598960876,
0.6072275042533875,
0.12133932113647461,
-0.31488028168678284,
-0.3518438935279846,
-0.09670652449131012,
-0.4523109197616577,
0.16723603010177612,
0.28741124272346497,
-0.5198470950126648,
0.11571454256772995,
-0.2737687826156616,
0.4834277927875519,
0.46669915318489075,
0.06600992381572723,
0.5995700359344482,
-0.5040067434310913,
0.4642629325389862,
-0.45944562554359436,
0.29795601963996887,
0.04044567793607712,
-0.5551022291183472,
-0.8823157548904419,
-0.3517916798591614,
0.0664929524064064,
0.4701887369155884,
-1.1323832273483276,
0.012638763524591923,
-0.23686659336090088,
-0.6388012170791626,
-0.5364081263542175,
0.21844078600406647,
0.2612066864967346,
0.6015856862068176,
0.5236817598342896,
0.034284841269254684,
-0.26129645109176636,
-0.8915529251098633,
-0.4786411225795746,
-0.37089428305625916,
0.12598571181297302,
0.4650597870349884,
0.3874472975730896,
0.18516381084918976,
0.9280286431312561,
-0.6102087497711182,
-0.11074570566415787,
-0.35652077198028564,
0.11208536475896835,
0.22191044688224792,
0.11226384341716766,
0.08471041172742844,
-0.9526898264884949,
-0.5483402013778687,
-0.45561960339546204,
-0.5832531452178955,
-0.153090700507164,
0.15879610180854797,
-0.650335967540741,
-0.24868686497211456,
0.44304710626602173,
-0.5376489758491516,
-0.04378754645586014,
0.4992206394672394,
-0.26461338996887207,
0.2583045959472656,
-0.09948485344648361,
0.23345845937728882,
-0.906517744064331,
-0.006523326504975557,
-0.3038937449455261,
-0.19613920152187347,
-0.7975234985351562,
0.37948593497276306,
0.10023442655801773,
0.18391844630241394,
-0.22326819598674774,
0.3864237666130066,
-0.5791200995445251,
-0.05586168169975281,
0.2186082899570465,
0.46386873722076416,
0.5071578621864319,
0.641520082950592,
-0.17896172404289246,
0.6861555576324463,
0.2676919996738434,
-0.6083117723464966,
0.39882782101631165,
0.4024035632610321,
-0.27125856280326843,
0.5430838465690613,
-0.5681451559066772,
0.34927573800086975,
0.051677536219358444,
0.239501491189003,
-1.0705931186676025,
-0.16855759918689728,
0.3089338541030884,
-0.34112152457237244,
-0.0646892562508583,
0.061152055859565735,
-0.7045265436172485,
-0.4515439569950104,
-0.3074776232242584,
0.3442622423171997,
0.0554889515042305,
-0.6913822293281555,
1.1352078914642334,
0.4742218554019928,
-0.1774289309978485,
-0.5870993137359619,
-0.3991508483886719,
0.12562884390354156,
-0.0703752189874649,
-1.1084232330322266,
0.4075666666030884,
-0.0966268852353096,
-0.24534562230110168,
0.19377925992012024,
0.04401746764779091,
-0.39537712931632996,
0.30900466442108154,
-0.16382506489753723,
0.10065378248691559,
0.09622557461261749,
0.2524220049381256,
0.046187981963157654,
0.1803339570760727,
0.007233841810375452,
-0.5527886152267456,
0.37430569529533386,
-0.1476149559020996,
-0.4079304337501526,
-0.09834049642086029,
0.5150125622749329,
0.5123791098594666,
-0.3028671145439148,
0.7401268482208252,
0.30288270115852356,
-0.3491553068161011,
-0.15556198358535767,
-0.795374870300293,
0.10511419922113419,
-0.496120423078537,
0.26544448733329773,
-0.5211780667304993,
-1.095321536064148,
0.3814428746700287,
-0.417642205953598,
0.1584775298833847,
0.33944350481033325,
0.35110145807266235,
-0.06188367307186127,
0.8275898098945618,
0.6383764147758484,
0.2189943939447403,
-0.15096159279346466,
-0.21068274974822998,
0.33892348408699036,
-0.8459038138389587,
-0.38202688097953796,
-0.5530087947845459,
-0.09058520197868347,
-0.24514269828796387,
-0.7541927695274353,
0.723875105381012,
0.2449968308210373,
-0.48093873262405396,
0.13406585156917572,
-0.4875294268131256,
0.49649327993392944,
0.6563535332679749,
0.04117114469408989,
0.5865514278411865,
-0.2704479694366455,
-0.5553659200668335,
0.0973735824227333,
-1.2255498170852661,
-0.26891928911209106,
0.9288648366928101,
0.0180817898362875,
0.511838436126709,
0.4391700029373169,
0.8565371036529541,
-0.16599802672863007,
0.24968498945236206,
-0.6484262943267822,
0.5911238193511963,
0.3464434742927551,
-0.6498521566390991,
-0.7203263640403748,
-0.6183270215988159,
-0.4190577268600464,
0.4604937434196472,
-0.07024189829826355,
-0.6423725485801697,
-0.03356797993183136,
0.008992087095975876,
-0.5155715346336365,
0.38478294014930725,
-0.7104867100715637,
0.8196532726287842,
-0.2953775227069855,
-0.7709735035896301,
-0.24961742758750916,
-0.5497255921363831,
0.4059407711029053,
-0.04864533990621567,
0.4135805666446686,
0.038653530180454254,
-0.19025228917598724,
0.6523063778877258,
-0.352966845035553,
0.3685075640678406,
-0.31832772493362427,
-0.053692739456892014,
0.5265461206436157,
0.251281201839447,
0.6183529496192932,
-0.11105954647064209,
-0.16754233837127686,
-0.22840601205825806,
0.06826121360063553,
-0.4274948537349701,
-0.6949899196624756,
0.5764347314834595,
-0.4158359169960022,
-0.7142247557640076,
-0.17258355021476746,
-0.6790819764137268,
-0.6129884719848633,
0.2776326537132263,
-0.0812164843082428,
0.3329178988933563,
-0.2913016378879547,
0.05841070041060448,
0.5006765723228455,
-0.1611679345369339,
0.23506151139736176,
0.4606418311595917,
-0.1874980926513672,
-0.6072850227355957,
0.6805922985076904,
0.32834163308143616,
0.47870853543281555,
0.3244503438472748,
0.1853453367948532,
-0.5551207065582275,
-0.44954007863998413,
-0.5981560945510864,
0.07047490775585175,
-0.9328696727752686,
-0.232260063290596,
-0.9096325039863586,
0.06145663931965828,
-0.23676972091197968,
-0.13652008771896362,
-0.2519542872905731,
-0.6075100302696228,
0.22776803374290466,
0.11641623079776764,
0.2159680873155594,
0.7285283803939819,
-0.1397067904472351,
0.057435326278209686,
-0.7669395804405212,
0.1894703507423401,
0.5785451531410217,
0.24822790920734406,
0.17114228010177612,
-0.1367458999156952,
-0.1692698895931244,
-0.115209199488163,
-0.31918570399284363,
-0.9727925062179565,
0.17303074896335602,
0.246488556265831,
0.9050244092941284,
-0.051494672894477844,
0.4232657253742218,
0.7230265736579895,
-0.24440063536167145,
0.6507630348205566,
0.151228129863739,
-0.9367601871490479,
0.05916018411517143,
-0.3048819601535797,
0.29385194182395935,
0.8737351894378662,
0.6119548678398132,
-0.5449984669685364,
-0.32618483901023865,
-0.43825408816337585,
-0.9375963807106018,
0.5115153789520264,
0.21295300126075745,
-0.365087628364563,
0.12239837646484375,
0.31444114446640015,
-0.10402384400367737,
0.3296184837818146,
-0.4370511770248413,
-0.20733150839805603,
0.013218218460679054,
-0.16706112027168274,
0.190348818898201,
-0.215251162648201,
-0.46385374665260315,
-0.47465211153030396,
0.6545673608779907,
-0.4291903078556061,
0.2241164594888687,
0.4273306429386139,
-0.22820690274238586,
-0.01068558543920517,
0.23128682374954224,
-0.02881685271859169,
0.6948280930519104,
0.16455282270908356,
0.20100246369838715,
0.46928897500038147,
0.08462554961442947,
0.07043967396020889,
0.12197765707969666,
-0.106940358877182,
-0.3225085735321045,
0.12815208733081818,
0.2588878273963928,
0.3257543742656708,
-0.5560663342475891,
0.4661067724227905,
-0.18003425002098083,
-0.5329630970954895,
-0.13990572094917297,
0.037914302200078964,
0.6583727598190308,
0.5657017827033997,
0.3128412067890167,
-0.2123350352048874,
0.36893463134765625,
-0.38126885890960693,
0.2036208063364029,
0.41884657740592957,
-0.11679698526859283,
0.22122496366500854,
0.588836133480072,
0.3076810836791992,
0.006229281425476074,
0.6115501523017883,
-0.4904361963272095,
-1.0104713439941406,
0.4964708089828491,
0.03816894069314003,
0.5875800251960754,
0.008762171491980553,
0.4678266942501068,
0.5297065377235413,
0.32779303193092346,
-0.13657698035240173,
0.5280259251594543,
-0.43116238713264465,
-0.8394495844841003,
-0.7428188920021057,
-0.4990081191062927,
-0.7208588123321533,
-0.3824709355831146,
-0.45469990372657776,
0.028923021629452705,
-0.15580642223358154,
0.18092495203018188,
-0.14747542142868042,
0.18901021778583527,
-0.6235629916191101,
0.024064118042588234,
-0.05693749710917473,
1.0059071779251099,
-0.4751206338405609,
0.5753874182701111,
0.5437761545181274,
-0.31984925270080566,
-1.2815221548080444,
-0.07254187017679214,
0.05713973194360733,
-0.7126835584640503,
0.5348907113075256,
0.24604444205760956,
-0.518409013748169,
0.324774831533432,
-0.5412203073501587,
-1.0199823379516602,
1.4841417074203491,
0.2528706192970276,
-0.48864156007766724,
-0.09649374336004257,
-0.03803730010986328,
0.1637648344039917,
-0.31640663743019104,
0.2673097550868988,
0.5465097427368164,
0.7425926327705383,
0.6006214618682861,
-0.9213119149208069,
0.1992255300283432,
-0.05379800871014595,
-0.559823751449585,
0.2657158076763153,
-0.9353744387626648,
0.7505449652671814,
-0.4262610375881195,
-0.3453119695186615,
0.23193921148777008,
0.485635370016098,
0.2079903781414032,
0.38430556654930115,
0.6899717450141907,
0.8539544939994812,
1.2453166246414185,
-0.03657901659607887,
0.7917107343673706,
-0.36911770701408386,
0.3199610114097595,
1.1435350179672241,
-0.4318367838859558,
0.6186447143554688,
0.33170390129089355,
-0.18755917251110077,
0.48919594287872314,
0.47841089963912964,
0.32611531019210815,
0.5822817087173462,
0.23709461092948914,
-0.38413771986961365,
-0.6860246062278748,
-0.2189953774213791,
-0.023988869041204453,
0.38416242599487305,
0.23979924619197845,
0.08393671363592148,
-0.44462475180625916,
-0.3275603652000427,
0.09969807416200638,
0.1189906969666481,
-0.2343163937330246,
0.7138579487800598,
-0.042731646448373795,
-1.0588189363479614,
0.3985608220100403,
-0.11910523474216461,
0.31301695108413696,
-0.430541455745697,
0.00551823154091835,
0.07557820528745651,
-0.07716153562068939,
0.043507881462574005,
-0.7351759672164917,
0.24311991035938263,
-0.2797739505767822,
0.18748413026332855,
-0.30250245332717896,
0.748211145401001,
-0.4438575804233551,
-0.29354432225227356,
0.6589168310165405,
1.1859123706817627,
-0.17183524370193481,
-0.25951841473579407,
-0.6746896505355835,
-0.2440723180770874,
-0.040715426206588745,
-0.2672613263130188,
0.027467016130685806,
0.581104040145874,
0.13072630763053894,
0.8661923408508301,
0.5289368629455566,
-0.2176954597234726,
-0.010355320759117603,
0.13698944449424744,
1.236999273300171,
-0.3867647051811218,
-0.5709630846977234,
-0.5405926704406738,
0.3179624080657959,
-0.3637964129447937,
-0.011006942950189114,
0.6601483225822449,
0.5662839412689209,
0.6982829570770264,
0.5578466653823853,
0.7016445398330688,
-0.1198764368891716,
0.5951166152954102,
-0.45671993494033813,
0.5424138903617859,
-0.6992148160934448,
0.15977917611598969,
-0.21230003237724304,
-0.772790253162384,
-0.15853703022003174,
0.45757144689559937,
-0.24588139355182648,
-0.034656181931495667,
0.7612692713737488,
0.772093653678894,
0.25239884853363037,
0.36803704500198364,
0.2790915369987488,
0.1248050406575203,
0.3246138393878937,
0.8252139687538147,
0.9845820069313049,
-0.14568835496902466,
0.8092218041419983,
-0.3007262349128723,
-0.23860661685466766,
0.18958641588687897,
-0.824210524559021,
-0.601151704788208,
-0.5765057802200317,
-0.049856215715408325,
-0.19394804537296295,
0.12636031210422516,
0.9563828706741333,
0.49499472975730896,
-0.31579703092575073,
-0.051501527428627014,
-0.18971946835517883,
0.20397335290908813,
-0.06472483277320862,
-0.17940209805965424,
0.26493707299232483,
-0.24251510202884674,
-0.5368778109550476,
0.4349730312824249,
0.2982257902622223,
-0.4747907817363739,
-0.5186548233032227,
-0.24357318878173828,
-0.5581579208374023,
0.20846079289913177,
0.395992636680603,
0.09983978420495987,
-0.4650888741016388,
-0.2269754856824875,
0.3987565040588379,
0.08872281014919281,
-0.1584545075893402,
0.7546228170394897,
-0.7356323599815369,
0.6658927202224731,
0.5534759163856506,
0.8788617849349976,
0.6028837561607361,
-0.10095080733299255,
0.6348596811294556,
-0.41232189536094666,
-0.3288056254386902,
0.32973355054855347,
0.31249600648880005,
0.4430088400840759,
-0.28368520736694336,
0.7165044546127319,
0.03857678174972534,
-0.7112677693367004,
-0.5676721334457397,
0.288519948720932,
-0.6464768052101135,
-0.39888104796409607,
1.1067512035369873,
-0.22005848586559296,
-0.19012200832366943,
-0.45320793986320496,
-0.10395373404026031,
0.2380361706018448,
-0.2241171896457672,
0.4464495778083801,
0.8522800207138062,
-0.4053538739681244,
-0.045202139765024185,
-0.6616487503051758,
0.3894190788269043,
0.5169969201087952,
-0.6725736260414124,
0.042549312114715576,
0.6767069697380066,
0.14922243356704712,
0.2631787359714508,
0.9412554502487183,
0.20645517110824585,
0.20708590745925903,
-0.011559019796550274,
-0.25312286615371704,
-0.3389958441257477,
-0.540255069732666,
0.1906140148639679,
0.500679612159729,
0.1884886771440506,
0.096268430352211
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.01233v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.01233v1
|
Multi-word Term Embeddings Improve Lexical Product Retrieval
| 2024-06-03T11:52:52 | 2024-06-03T11:52:52 |
Viktor Shcherbakov, Fedor Krasnov
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.CL
|
Product search is uniquely different from search for documents, Internet
resources or vacancies, therefore it requires the development of specialized
search systems. The present work describes the H1 embdedding model, designed
for an offline term indexing of product descriptions at e-commerce platforms.
The model is compared to other state-of-the-art (SoTA) embedding models within
a framework of hybrid product search system that incorporates the advantages of
lexical methods for product retrieval and semantic embedding-based methods. We
propose an approach to building semantically rich term vocabularies for search
indexes. Compared to other production semantic models, H1 paired with the
proposed approach stands out due to its ability to process multi-word product
terms as one token. As an example, for search queries "new balance shoes",
"gloria jeans kids wear" brand entity will be represented as one token - "new
balance", "gloria jeans". This results in an increased precision of the system
without affecting the recall. The hybrid search system with proposed model
scores mAP@12 = 56.1% and R@1k = 86.6% on the WANDS public dataset, beating
other SoTA analogues.
|
[
-0.29499614238739014,
-0.9145736694335938,
0.35170796513557434,
0.403097927570343,
-0.34973591566085815,
0.47251683473587036,
0.0557936392724514,
-0.5436364412307739,
0.9792934656143188,
0.35272181034088135,
-0.3242379426956177,
-0.6695420145988464,
-0.3014545142650604,
-0.0391630195081234,
-0.4694952368736267,
0.6066156029701233,
-0.23393294215202332,
-0.12371914833784103,
-0.012644758448004723,
-0.3588787913322449,
-0.2677594721317291,
-0.675182044506073,
0.074783094227314,
-0.04640788584947586,
0.31340304017066956,
0.1415579915046692,
0.9801976680755615,
0.4647986590862274,
0.5758229494094849,
0.23702023923397064,
-0.040245771408081055,
0.333204448223114,
-0.5097101926803589,
0.32728391885757446,
-0.03475627303123474,
-0.3371295928955078,
-0.44754037261009216,
-0.059958502650260925,
0.14810408651828766,
0.2931293547153473,
-0.5263072848320007,
0.06793396919965744,
0.08609528839588165,
0.13391713798046112,
-0.9961061477661133,
-0.01338458713144064,
-0.46668678522109985,
0.1414378434419632,
-0.10597596317529678,
-0.2795957922935486,
-0.3308871388435364,
-0.13995017111301422,
0.2968379855155945,
-1.094752311706543,
0.05307859182357788,
0.3482320308685303,
1.094125747680664,
-0.013112376444041729,
0.029753023758530617,
-0.37313535809516907,
-0.464076429605484,
0.6137274503707886,
-0.7396863102912903,
0.5801858901977539,
0.23165400326251984,
0.04168584570288658,
0.04366224259138107,
-0.5512914061546326,
-0.5225502252578735,
0.09405499696731567,
-0.10252222418785095,
0.23965507745742798,
-0.024762101471424103,
0.12702612578868866,
-0.14524292945861816,
0.30277520418167114,
-0.2598377764225006,
-0.1959383636713028,
-0.09728388488292694,
0.047511596232652664,
0.2860982120037079,
0.0912347212433815,
0.1433800607919693,
-0.33012691140174866,
-0.7072178721427917,
-0.00879914965480566,
-0.6276307106018066,
-0.37122416496276855,
0.14218099415302277,
0.49052542448043823,
0.15151718258857727,
0.9307444095611572,
-0.21689388155937195,
0.5279210209846497,
-0.07082260400056839,
-0.2141132354736328,
0.30473780632019043,
-0.7348273992538452,
-0.01664946787059307,
0.18234477937221527,
0.0628533810377121,
0.3026488125324249,
-0.5312166213989258,
-0.37873101234436035,
-0.5651286840438843,
0.12535648047924042,
0.1894884556531906,
-0.6888265609741211,
0.11887200176715851,
-0.15511129796504974,
-0.6267865896224976,
-0.1157887876033783,
0.7218477129936218,
-0.7579788565635681,
-0.2698805630207062,
-0.2184436172246933,
1.1831859350204468,
0.08138418197631836,
-0.03498854115605354,
0.5781315565109253,
-0.6514463424682617,
0.30897265672683716,
-0.2602846324443817,
-0.3104131817817688,
0.5103611946105957,
0.7929092049598694,
0.9055187106132507,
0.006363934837281704,
0.1408144235610962,
-0.25596097111701965,
0.33169931173324585,
-0.24804452061653137,
0.6184529662132263,
-0.7292237281799316,
-0.4678836762905121,
0.2555670142173767,
0.0026664112228900194,
0.08703286200761795,
-0.7495764493942261,
0.2200646698474884,
-0.8281477689743042,
-0.08134747296571732,
-0.4855841100215912,
-0.7309520244598389,
-0.13106876611709595,
0.3971710205078125,
-0.5144515037536621,
1.0503997802734375,
-0.12664176523685455,
-0.7686609029769897,
0.3982718586921692,
-0.7730235457420349,
-0.37734946608543396,
0.28864380717277527,
-0.14812320470809937,
-0.45227351784706116,
0.21041740477085114,
0.2189878672361374,
0.19778580963611603,
-0.3807784914970398,
-0.034831173717975616,
-0.5707324147224426,
-0.5449451208114624,
-0.2835068106651306,
0.3215261399745941,
0.1650703400373459,
0.007882043719291687,
-0.49554264545440674,
-0.3329576253890991,
-0.2631327509880066,
-0.059212859719991684,
0.33634936809539795,
-0.30366408824920654,
-0.8313457369804382,
-0.032534159719944,
0.4236798584461212,
0.26669755578041077,
0.5612465143203735,
-1.0252355337142944,
0.21621260046958923,
-0.5170341730117798,
0.34518682956695557,
0.37939053773880005,
-0.04947958141565323,
0.09974586218595505,
-0.25919318199157715,
0.5286811590194702,
-0.0178336501121521,
0.40370383858680725,
-0.38683000206947327,
-0.7127412557601929,
-0.8532614707946777,
-0.24882107973098755,
0.49082449078559875,
0.5071854591369629,
-0.824658989906311,
0.6814785599708557,
-0.3485078811645508,
-0.42902785539627075,
-0.6454210877418518,
-0.010486217215657234,
0.3216519057750702,
-0.06447076052427292,
0.6223320364952087,
-0.45876047015190125,
-0.4291470944881439,
-1.0246871709823608,
-0.10791759938001633,
0.27613565325737,
0.04902488365769386,
0.5775985717773438,
0.486619770526886,
-0.5053623914718628,
1.2337760925292969,
-0.9244477152824402,
-0.5591638684272766,
-0.09700750559568405,
0.3149023950099945,
0.1629432737827301,
0.20732435584068298,
0.1423492431640625,
-0.8945221304893494,
-0.2924755811691284,
-0.1484408676624298,
-0.4671277403831482,
0.08873843401670456,
0.21294188499450684,
-0.22292281687259674,
0.08079276978969574,
0.30782803893089294,
-0.488869845867157,
0.781916618347168,
0.45375385880470276,
-0.4025803208351135,
0.09362136572599411,
-0.6178337335586548,
-0.004980504512786865,
-1.3248580694198608,
0.04288933053612709,
0.2736567258834839,
-0.12600094079971313,
-0.17813049256801605,
0.5385462045669556,
0.08708735555410385,
-0.17583738267421722,
-0.7024359107017517,
0.3067748248577118,
-0.39939841628074646,
-0.3410954177379608,
-0.21405670046806335,
0.5138778686523438,
0.6038017272949219,
0.168758824467659,
-0.13716769218444824,
0.7145830988883972,
0.08440633863210678,
-0.7177438735961914,
0.3080371916294098,
0.6627883315086365,
-0.37691596150398254,
0.3399032950401306,
-0.8623853325843811,
-0.09778345376253128,
-0.14001508057117462,
0.35660794377326965,
-0.5930771827697754,
0.3300342559814453,
-0.2756224572658539,
-0.08520574867725372,
0.2055726796388626,
0.29101550579071045,
-1.101709246635437,
-0.5604968667030334,
-0.6839094161987305,
0.3516246974468231,
0.23801709711551666,
-0.8581397533416748,
0.551862359046936,
0.9379509687423706,
-0.02157621458172798,
-0.15414740145206451,
-0.8163645267486572,
0.23343868553638458,
-0.12489796429872513,
-0.7314687967300415,
1.1709774732589722,
0.13754327595233917,
0.15694989264011383,
0.22140751779079437,
-0.14865842461585999,
0.0801645815372467,
0.12516522407531738,
-0.18625526130199432,
0.4523865282535553,
-0.26018914580345154,
0.605911910533905,
0.021412335336208344,
-0.12395739555358887,
-0.4380682408809662,
-0.44761568307876587,
0.6426170468330383,
0.016251279041171074,
-0.23390331864356995,
-0.25691336393356323,
0.5131202936172485,
0.24395236372947693,
-0.34590521454811096,
0.8599650263786316,
0.37766650319099426,
-0.6956282258033752,
0.011619416996836662,
-0.607361376285553,
-0.4885564148426056,
-0.5074887871742249,
0.2111882120370865,
-0.3753814995288849,
-0.8000143766403198,
0.4795551002025604,
-0.008318229578435421,
-0.250238299369812,
0.3984050750732422,
0.4629819095134735,
-0.02633761242032051,
1.236701488494873,
0.8138860464096069,
0.2581061124801636,
0.2951802909374237,
-0.35855746269226074,
0.8144678473472595,
-0.8491261601448059,
-0.4492783844470978,
-0.41786378622055054,
-0.48785200715065,
-1.0252127647399902,
-0.6906810402870178,
0.5717740654945374,
0.05117611587047577,
-0.08752124756574631,
0.7882673740386963,
-0.5174481272697449,
0.2671301066875458,
0.6522911190986633,
0.6254433393478394,
0.08352311700582504,
0.21393588185310364,
-0.5267801880836487,
-0.03343820199370384,
-0.6883182525634766,
-0.11774703115224838,
1.0497570037841797,
0.3481760621070862,
1.0687403678894043,
0.18339060246944427,
0.7664124369621277,
0.19750575721263885,
-0.08658172935247421,
-0.7668845057487488,
0.07800339162349701,
-0.44885215163230896,
-0.9735569953918457,
-0.015006028115749359,
-0.05024753510951996,
-0.746379017829895,
0.24073223769664764,
-0.454784095287323,
-0.5820444226264954,
0.5104745030403137,
-0.16993938386440277,
-0.7922378182411194,
0.22409458458423615,
-0.5330272912979126,
0.6934873461723328,
-0.37959474325180054,
-0.7223811149597168,
-0.4815743863582611,
-0.3424556851387024,
-0.2900129556655884,
-0.14712844789028168,
0.16043022274971008,
0.11632045358419418,
-0.4596558213233948,
1.0044564008712769,
-0.36131957173347473,
0.30293458700180054,
-0.021399741992354393,
0.050628941506147385,
0.20808298885822296,
-0.12856782972812653,
0.44180503487586975,
-0.11321785300970078,
0.1495550572872162,
-0.08349771052598953,
0.2634938657283783,
-0.48769712448120117,
-0.46074435114860535,
0.6568427085876465,
-0.26264938712120056,
-0.5831241011619568,
-0.3052200973033905,
0.06532963365316391,
-0.11269443482160568,
0.11500749737024307,
0.0705709159374237,
0.32882192730903625,
-0.14722110331058502,
0.6837888956069946,
0.5403420329093933,
-0.5962903499603271,
0.40752527117729187,
0.28848278522491455,
-0.512604296207428,
-0.2314186692237854,
1.0449891090393066,
0.41784071922302246,
-0.12022271752357483,
0.5483882427215576,
0.5226369500160217,
-0.643242597579956,
0.22704622149467468,
-0.020135611295700073,
0.19191798567771912,
-0.7434187531471252,
-0.30502378940582275,
-0.8152855634689331,
0.07987198978662491,
-0.2802615165710449,
-0.05912499129772186,
-0.5382125973701477,
-0.3310166597366333,
-0.20157532393932343,
-0.10547900944948196,
0.3496309816837311,
1.0286924839019775,
0.13817815482616425,
0.3639987111091614,
-0.8952955603599548,
0.3914913833141327,
0.33096903562545776,
0.7381941080093384,
0.028096364811062813,
-0.3092525601387024,
-0.6396743059158325,
0.052955735474824905,
-0.548915684223175,
-0.8608187437057495,
0.45913222432136536,
0.32369279861450195,
0.5076528191566467,
0.4735701084136963,
0.08988809585571289,
0.780581533908844,
-0.16615749895572662,
0.5575205087661743,
0.0813712403178215,
-1.043426752090454,
0.2600349187850952,
-0.27215775847435,
0.0575578399002552,
0.5470146536827087,
0.41736719012260437,
-0.544320821762085,
0.1571805626153946,
-0.5119674205780029,
-1.1485201120376587,
0.5213457345962524,
0.19414596259593964,
0.3487332761287689,
-0.22158220410346985,
-0.009544660337269306,
0.29906049370765686,
0.5029735565185547,
-0.2585861384868622,
-0.21472680568695068,
0.0010074834572151303,
-0.0919497162103653,
0.02295740880072117,
-0.27461516857147217,
0.26552677154541016,
-0.4730863869190216,
0.6630904674530029,
-0.034588757902383804,
0.4036596119403839,
0.2040005773305893,
-0.18267907202243805,
0.2959766983985901,
-0.046106383204460144,
0.04727901890873909,
0.33617907762527466,
-0.3160049319267273,
-0.1328059285879135,
-0.045693449676036835,
-0.20227929949760437,
-0.0370175838470459,
0.012894943356513977,
-0.10928639769554138,
0.1886337250471115,
-0.34036001563072205,
0.5241116285324097,
0.642775297164917,
-0.6420374512672424,
0.6952509880065918,
0.13651226460933685,
0.17224857211112976,
0.06495644897222519,
-0.7340885996818542,
0.1839936226606369,
-0.0665355771780014,
0.364921897649765,
-0.29518821835517883,
0.6636626720428467,
-0.7041740417480469,
0.5791946053504944,
0.3636193573474884,
-0.2441151887178421,
-0.21674618124961853,
0.28343522548675537,
0.31366851925849915,
-0.164712056517601,
0.5031421184539795,
-0.3872397541999817,
-0.8871471881866455,
0.5287760496139526,
0.7545581459999084,
0.8399084806442261,
0.08385324478149414,
0.24277137219905853,
0.1800500452518463,
0.349570095539093,
-0.3322064280509949,
0.5939530730247498,
-0.06363128870725632,
-0.7056077718734741,
0.08314941823482513,
-0.7663688659667969,
-0.3892420530319214,
-0.41298967599868774,
-0.509595513343811,
0.6499549150466919,
-0.22209680080413818,
-0.6400882005691528,
-0.13697940111160278,
-0.1734430193901062,
-0.9003031849861145,
0.0023118173703551292,
0.264636367559433,
0.7426875829696655,
-0.7301625609397888,
0.3864710330963135,
0.4882008731365204,
-0.5597578287124634,
-0.36962294578552246,
0.03775027021765709,
-0.32625100016593933,
-0.6308066844940186,
0.4485194981098175,
0.6021264791488647,
-0.038104962557554245,
-0.06076262146234512,
0.1182432621717453,
-1.2175155878067017,
1.131799578666687,
-0.06151493266224861,
-0.5525032877922058,
-0.25115078687667847,
0.12387485057115555,
0.38726484775543213,
-0.5049782991409302,
0.43809664249420166,
0.5421285629272461,
0.4742293059825897,
-0.2989502549171448,
-0.9104258418083191,
-0.041739799082279205,
-0.18856406211853027,
0.3267446458339691,
0.11531514674425125,
-0.4349137246608734,
0.6633276343345642,
0.15999113023281097,
-0.5831374526023865,
0.2028912603855133,
0.02755304053425789,
0.07971737533807755,
0.3999375104904175,
0.23313523828983307,
1.0839003324508667,
0.38775941729545593,
-0.10596621036529541,
1.156008005142212,
-0.6343551874160767,
0.7178501486778259,
0.9032446146011353,
-0.38664510846138,
1.373370885848999,
0.5204460024833679,
-0.11289238184690475,
0.4918695390224457,
0.5174605846405029,
0.024445418268442154,
0.6926101446151733,
0.41780009865760803,
-0.0026966140139847994,
-0.3626389503479004,
-0.4448225200176239,
-0.3968564569950104,
0.5506863594055176,
0.39286574721336365,
-0.39220577478408813,
-0.23980005085468292,
-0.00022061214258428663,
-0.340750515460968,
-0.026439499109983444,
0.019320283085107803,
0.7240305542945862,
0.0903591588139534,
-0.06620854884386063,
0.37478458881378174,
0.43556687235832214,
1.1862530708312988,
-0.22654715180397034,
0.09165265411138535,
0.0071207573637366295,
0.19107678532600403,
-0.17170368134975433,
-0.29559576511383057,
0.18779680132865906,
-0.37994644045829773,
0.19287438690662384,
-0.025501839816570282,
0.378968209028244,
-0.2680527865886688,
-0.7132986783981323,
0.8208101987838745,
0.7377451062202454,
-0.4299945831298828,
-0.15762180089950562,
-0.798276960849762,
-0.16327139735221863,
-0.5547130703926086,
-0.4095315635204315,
0.037045929580926895,
0.013328623957931995,
0.0349225290119648,
0.3202090263366699,
0.4365254342556,
-0.311024934053421,
0.39396485686302185,
-0.12122518569231033,
0.8300945162773132,
-0.734343409538269,
-0.9098093509674072,
-0.5331977009773254,
0.1414038985967636,
-0.07826771587133408,
-0.10437905788421631,
0.6137930154800415,
0.884633481502533,
0.7739449739456177,
0.12241372466087341,
0.6311243772506714,
0.10438647121191025,
0.2745774984359741,
-0.1955125778913498,
0.6867142915725708,
-0.9545297026634216,
0.010680646635591984,
-0.20241273939609528,
-1.2489597797393799,
-0.27738818526268005,
0.5398565530776978,
0.14149069786071777,
-0.016276545822620392,
0.7569324374198914,
1.1920851469039917,
-0.15987887978553772,
0.15258826315402985,
0.3347202241420746,
0.07905934005975723,
-0.00507619883865118,
0.013022039085626602,
0.4706035554409027,
-0.7938185334205627,
0.06872821599245071,
-0.22097809612751007,
-0.22396275401115417,
-0.5160156488418579,
-0.6680073738098145,
-0.1833319365978241,
-0.42500895261764526,
-0.20037944614887238,
-0.2261505275964737,
0.21740685403347015,
1.2867653369903564,
0.871980607509613,
-0.6683376431465149,
-0.15330909192562103,
0.04656574875116348,
-0.29183223843574524,
0.02706880494952202,
-0.1961219608783722,
0.2534332275390625,
-0.1971946358680725,
-0.3365146517753601,
0.43437573313713074,
0.6519509553909302,
-0.12071415781974792,
-0.42042604088783264,
-0.09261368215084076,
-0.5101993680000305,
0.5194674134254456,
0.769603431224823,
-0.2180829644203186,
-0.7773486375808716,
-0.04924736171960831,
0.610760509967804,
0.0750853568315506,
0.1824989914894104,
0.6700530648231506,
-0.8138903975486755,
0.814020037651062,
0.722667932510376,
0.7910382151603699,
0.5871506333351135,
0.053803108632564545,
0.4782412350177765,
-0.49725162982940674,
0.12637992203235626,
0.25514641404151917,
0.5175356268882751,
0.42017483711242676,
-0.03545680642127991,
0.04490020498633385,
0.333639532327652,
0.014678229577839375,
-0.36766019463539124,
0.013341965153813362,
-0.5539438724517822,
-0.2685733735561371,
1.0582072734832764,
-0.12556186318397522,
-0.2844914197921753,
-0.08123628795146942,
0.022443387657403946,
0.2767176330089569,
-0.48050349950790405,
0.9530879259109497,
0.5840734839439392,
0.43641483783721924,
0.49219173192977905,
-0.19245418906211853,
-0.1690809279680252,
0.37467408180236816,
-0.41335949301719666,
-0.5054005980491638,
-0.12338405847549438,
-0.11506175249814987,
0.43234023451805115,
-0.04298163577914238,
-0.2340051829814911,
0.16944019496440887,
0.0050761280581355095,
0.18656672537326813,
0.12474444508552551,
-0.3181670308113098,
-0.018155762925744057,
0.2432299703359604,
-0.10611420124769211,
-0.44219517707824707
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.01224v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.01224v1
|
Demonstration Augmentation for Zero-shot In-context Learning
| 2024-06-03T11:46:42 | 2024-06-03T11:46:42 |
Yi Su, Yunpeng Tai, Yixin Ji, Juntao Li, Bowen Yan, Min Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated an impressive capability known
as In-context Learning (ICL), which enables them to acquire knowledge from
textual demonstrations without the need for parameter updates. However, many
studies have highlighted that the model's performance is sensitive to the
choice of demonstrations, presenting a significant challenge for practical
applications where we lack prior knowledge of user queries. Consequently, we
need to construct an extensive demonstration pool and incorporate external
databases to assist the model, leading to considerable time and financial
costs. In light of this, some recent research has shifted focus towards
zero-shot ICL, aiming to reduce the model's reliance on external information by
leveraging their inherent generative capabilities. Despite the effectiveness of
these approaches, the content generated by the model may be unreliable, and the
generation process is time-consuming. To address these issues, we propose
Demonstration Augmentation for In-context Learning (DAIL), which employs the
model's previously predicted historical samples as demonstrations for
subsequent ones. DAIL brings no additional inference cost and does not rely on
the model's generative capabilities. Our experiments reveal that DAIL can
significantly improve the model's performance over direct zero-shot inference
and can even outperform few-shot ICL without any external information.
|
[
-0.16343584656715393,
-0.9116953611373901,
0.6599087715148926,
0.14445683360099792,
-0.35345184803009033,
-0.10715856403112411,
-0.2458081841468811,
-0.4871041476726532,
-0.09705974161624908,
0.4150277078151703,
-0.4947090148925781,
-0.46683838963508606,
-0.23935098946094513,
0.01671154797077179,
-0.524986743927002,
0.8001437187194824,
0.019728681072592735,
-0.0797310546040535,
-0.5882980823516846,
-0.03685654699802399,
-0.47610270977020264,
-0.3464403748512268,
-0.5821471214294434,
-0.5251975059509277,
0.05525553226470947,
0.733648419380188,
0.15579402446746826,
0.44928863644599915,
-0.1285601109266281,
0.19480784237384796,
0.12594284117221832,
0.31946155428886414,
-0.4760383069515228,
0.2526478171348572,
-0.09721561521291733,
-0.4228832423686981,
-0.1061977967619896,
-0.14175410568714142,
0.8738837242126465,
0.912710964679718,
0.18662740290164948,
0.08356934785842896,
0.12531745433807373,
0.2954733073711395,
-0.7989678382873535,
0.20949707925319672,
-0.8906859755516052,
0.1762986183166504,
-0.016366276890039444,
-0.29250356554985046,
-0.7651050090789795,
-0.02412489801645279,
0.14350256323814392,
-0.6071780323982239,
0.18672092258930206,
-0.15243084728717804,
0.6675898432731628,
0.01584012061357498,
-0.5258519649505615,
0.02589741349220276,
-0.8113480806350708,
0.8163204193115234,
-0.9285757541656494,
0.2538611888885498,
0.30717626214027405,
0.282946914434433,
-0.1812518835067749,
-0.7604936957359314,
-0.7468490600585938,
-0.7647218704223633,
-0.05115757882595062,
0.2231973260641098,
0.10165485739707947,
-0.11029546707868576,
0.5213225483894348,
0.29270103573799133,
-0.25599128007888794,
0.4231322109699249,
-0.12277991324663162,
-0.12540186941623688,
0.4070761203765869,
0.20017509162425995,
0.07875630259513855,
-0.1202315166592598,
-0.786575198173523,
-0.09191377460956573,
-1.2566839456558228,
0.23836545646190643,
0.08552245795726776,
0.38839492201805115,
-0.20176024734973907,
0.7121261358261108,
-0.6575016379356384,
0.7736626863479614,
0.344184935092926,
-0.04933818429708481,
0.19481678307056427,
-0.16187897324562073,
-0.5691978335380554,
0.21399438381195068,
0.617881715297699,
0.02832208387553692,
-0.3705226182937622,
-0.13556921482086182,
-0.254952609539032,
-0.16499602794647217,
-0.09602091461420059,
-1.173460602760315,
0.029688481241464615,
0.20784008502960205,
0.06405925005674362,
-0.2331341952085495,
-0.03602064773440361,
-0.5854719281196594,
-0.3468150794506073,
-0.3315679132938385,
0.9255428314208984,
-0.623327910900116,
-0.02893463335931301,
-0.0783763900399208,
-0.08187012374401093,
0.264850378036499,
0.5878329277038574,
-0.5899040699005127,
0.018750343471765518,
0.42820292711257935,
0.969767153263092,
-0.028006762266159058,
-0.24507099390029907,
-0.9779564142227173,
0.40584737062454224,
-0.5037335157394409,
0.7647795677185059,
-0.3805027902126312,
-0.47565746307373047,
0.18154177069664001,
-0.09808532893657684,
0.03138066083192825,
-0.5531392693519592,
0.32562026381492615,
-0.493236780166626,
0.3824719190597534,
-0.06845743209123611,
-0.9665502905845642,
-0.15109111368656158,
0.2946375012397766,
-0.35838624835014343,
0.9228355288505554,
0.26199448108673096,
-0.4691183567047119,
0.5507111549377441,
-0.8041030764579773,
-0.5653771162033081,
0.40461641550064087,
-0.42095527052879333,
-0.443978488445282,
0.08295585960149765,
0.42347273230552673,
0.6819449067115784,
0.07026530802249908,
0.1618843376636505,
-0.39463862776756287,
-0.6774832606315613,
0.2942834496498108,
-0.5584347248077393,
0.755419909954071,
-0.05586256831884384,
-0.8535906076431274,
0.1040971651673317,
-0.8427567481994629,
-0.2703520953655243,
0.04578115791082382,
-0.21505357325077057,
-0.2831054925918579,
-0.11763864755630493,
-0.2833450734615326,
0.25935810804367065,
0.10664750635623932,
-0.6765804290771484,
0.24630148708820343,
-0.7233411073684692,
-0.009190291166305542,
0.7487348914146423,
0.12596091628074646,
0.6173710823059082,
-0.3395095765590668,
0.5051751732826233,
0.15178698301315308,
0.09299208223819733,
-0.8118928074836731,
-0.2894956171512604,
-0.8907170295715332,
-0.31676095724105835,
0.08244682848453522,
0.18398405611515045,
-1.1128606796264648,
0.14129199087619781,
-0.356797993183136,
-0.1731874793767929,
-0.22357507050037384,
0.1440240442752838,
0.4401243329048157,
1.0703306198120117,
0.37161192297935486,
-0.16119666397571564,
-0.3727419376373291,
-0.6919969320297241,
0.29048457741737366,
-0.23022623360157013,
-0.20252549648284912,
0.4427633583545685,
0.3409687876701355,
0.08223523199558258,
0.9537011384963989,
-0.3141164779663086,
-0.27381882071495056,
-0.3753541111946106,
0.15819424390792847,
0.09265775978565216,
0.23509828746318817,
0.45749008655548096,
-0.5145811438560486,
-0.5724161863327026,
0.22110560536384583,
-0.873405396938324,
-0.20450459420681,
-0.2729966342449188,
0.10126209259033203,
0.4189075529575348,
0.5110063552856445,
-0.341187059879303,
0.44586488604545593,
0.4477883279323578,
-0.15886986255645752,
0.7308985590934753,
-0.2546652853488922,
0.10984921455383301,
-0.9387646913528442,
-0.17140315473079681,
-0.14248916506767273,
-0.29381483793258667,
-0.6848088502883911,
0.21709893643856049,
0.372484028339386,
-0.2181665301322937,
-0.7979339957237244,
0.8585019111633301,
-0.3984469473361969,
0.03349156305193901,
-0.3822367489337921,
0.2383548766374588,
0.21149203181266785,
0.3674280643463135,
0.20322120189666748,
1.063077688217163,
0.7058258056640625,
-0.6583738923072815,
0.09499210864305496,
0.145289808511734,
-0.5054063200950623,
0.5826611518859863,
-0.3623754382133484,
0.00022069101396482438,
-0.07079299539327621,
0.4267723560333252,
-0.9509869813919067,
-0.42740896344184875,
0.139667347073555,
-0.23202387988567352,
0.48938536643981934,
-0.23939262330532074,
-0.3299805521965027,
0.08579081296920776,
-0.4850338101387024,
0.12362244725227356,
0.5918881297111511,
-0.9270363450050354,
0.3325272798538208,
0.028106000274419785,
0.10468543320894241,
-0.6421036720275879,
-0.7128897905349731,
0.2539346516132355,
-0.24276946485042572,
-0.3927253484725952,
0.4689365327358246,
-0.12865060567855835,
-0.12246130406856537,
-0.24002310633659363,
0.17358525097370148,
0.04885273054242134,
-0.03952892869710922,
0.44167622923851013,
0.3370096981525421,
-0.43838047981262207,
0.41482511162757874,
0.08621044456958771,
0.1173807755112648,
-0.2622395157814026,
-0.4115857481956482,
0.4277472198009491,
0.13239821791648865,
-0.7696011662483215,
-0.6290422677993774,
0.3218885064125061,
0.5104126930236816,
0.008730513043701649,
0.7876196503639221,
0.39555469155311584,
-0.25376951694488525,
-0.5537176728248596,
-0.6576247215270996,
-0.22122077643871307,
-0.4754861891269684,
0.24344149231910706,
-0.17993015050888062,
-0.9610346555709839,
0.19946198165416718,
-0.18453137576580048,
0.024862701073288918,
0.1699153482913971,
0.44052013754844666,
-0.11627301573753357,
0.7756016850471497,
0.48898112773895264,
0.10729235410690308,
0.7462067604064941,
-0.47931912541389465,
-0.04475728049874306,
-0.9383939504623413,
-0.23827718198299408,
-0.09589432924985886,
-0.04686511307954788,
0.060449760407209396,
-0.5032547116279602,
0.5724807977676392,
0.10453849285840988,
-0.2923419177532196,
0.1827184408903122,
-0.03058011457324028,
0.41070273518562317,
0.4872503876686096,
0.3205500841140747,
0.4506587088108063,
0.22639471292495728,
-0.19417554140090942,
0.06946149468421936,
-0.6521360278129578,
-0.41770756244659424,
1.144181251525879,
0.06069682538509369,
0.5968273282051086,
0.07969842851161957,
0.6170555949211121,
0.20302963256835938,
0.5566871762275696,
-0.6871190071105957,
0.6896416544914246,
-0.02646319568157196,
-0.30716633796691895,
-0.3893210291862488,
-0.3784071207046509,
-0.7102546095848083,
0.31971433758735657,
-0.15879297256469727,
-0.7103090286254883,
0.2282116860151291,
0.3465462625026703,
-0.48208579421043396,
0.3267187178134918,
-0.798213541507721,
0.6677162051200867,
-0.18405203521251678,
-0.6982620358467102,
-0.013360808603465557,
-0.31619998812675476,
0.640239953994751,
-0.09120422601699829,
-0.009601457975804806,
0.15318840742111206,
-0.015976285561919212,
0.17781375348567963,
-0.46005186438560486,
1.1593314409255981,
-0.3675656020641327,
-0.18259413540363312,
0.24549801647663116,
0.1895936131477356,
0.740698516368866,
0.04858116805553436,
-0.23475472629070282,
-0.18832266330718994,
-0.49861830472946167,
-0.2606036365032196,
-0.7256604433059692,
0.9074122309684753,
-0.3493831157684326,
-0.6218855381011963,
0.053217239677906036,
-0.5161601901054382,
-0.3807782530784607,
-0.09934502094984055,
0.1867242157459259,
0.9878405332565308,
-0.047664839774370193,
0.4834432601928711,
0.6711123585700989,
-0.3380844295024872,
0.6677120327949524,
0.5873148441314697,
-0.393161416053772,
-0.11633007973432541,
0.8389024138450623,
0.14551755785942078,
0.6774376034736633,
0.6064831614494324,
0.2859388291835785,
-0.5996286869049072,
-0.8160259127616882,
-0.7632061839103699,
-0.12159609794616699,
-0.7254562973976135,
-0.29964306950569153,
-0.6304314732551575,
-0.11880046874284744,
-0.41451990604400635,
-0.2840949296951294,
-0.12722152471542358,
-0.5646789073944092,
-0.4368135929107666,
-0.22965531051158905,
0.218264639377594,
0.44100579619407654,
0.14613062143325806,
0.5503365993499756,
-0.42724376916885376,
0.15572713315486908,
0.5946475863456726,
0.17107398808002472,
0.13014835119247437,
-0.8809401392936707,
-0.33183398842811584,
0.11202315986156464,
-0.4749140441417694,
-0.7281599640846252,
0.34520381689071655,
0.5156425833702087,
0.4856995940208435,
0.8414078950881958,
0.22122696042060852,
1.0334633588790894,
-0.49075400829315186,
1.0866632461547852,
0.0670837014913559,
-0.9603077173233032,
0.5832522511482239,
-0.3021809756755829,
0.2510404586791992,
0.3098847568035126,
0.2201974242925644,
-0.17177966237068176,
-0.4850645661354065,
-0.6088118553161621,
-0.8575680255889893,
0.7118113040924072,
-0.018315820023417473,
0.3637259006500244,
-0.03574170172214508,
0.22101303935050964,
0.28892970085144043,
0.06355749815702438,
-0.9161890745162964,
-0.0393868014216423,
-0.154719278216362,
0.0836549922823906,
0.004175716545432806,
-0.174652099609375,
0.03019888885319233,
-0.2356773316860199,
0.8422950506210327,
-0.39258548617362976,
-0.06344754993915558,
0.22477281093597412,
-0.40434667468070984,
-0.11586666107177734,
0.2905617952346802,
0.7408514618873596,
0.7696729898452759,
-0.17274434864521027,
0.15625639259815216,
0.5532780289649963,
-0.00794427003711462,
0.19105085730552673,
0.1332884281873703,
-0.5247282981872559,
0.10290703922510147,
0.48627734184265137,
1.0543599128723145,
0.5981715321540833,
-0.9167965054512024,
0.9076833128929138,
0.24440142512321472,
-0.061015382409095764,
-0.46587252616882324,
0.03542625904083252,
-0.17768196761608124,
0.38823074102401733,
0.4943762421607971,
-0.34370243549346924,
0.06644169241189957,
-0.6632750034332275,
0.3367466926574707,
0.640085756778717,
-0.5967599153518677,
-0.22398170828819275,
0.6050635576248169,
-0.034171801060438156,
-0.16603794693946838,
0.4295268952846527,
-0.30593234300613403,
-0.26325279474258423,
0.4720449447631836,
0.9920880794525146,
0.7253181338310242,
-0.19157160818576813,
0.4804442822933197,
0.26204368472099304,
-0.0763399749994278,
0.07316796481609344,
-0.11294609308242798,
-0.39004063606262207,
-0.6349957585334778,
-0.7092888951301575,
-0.5343265533447266,
-0.5709635615348816,
0.3574144244194031,
-0.39935240149497986,
0.36585739254951477,
-0.28215834498405457,
0.19336934387683868,
-0.2604369819164276,
-0.1525164395570755,
-0.5487436056137085,
0.05475867912173271,
0.23562218248844147,
0.9433702826499939,
-0.8677936792373657,
0.9073807001113892,
0.4689607322216034,
-0.4737694263458252,
-0.44523388147354126,
0.10032539069652557,
-0.24689309298992157,
-0.6740625500679016,
0.8599313497543335,
0.36062487959861755,
-0.14302808046340942,
0.02071918174624443,
-0.6379753351211548,
-0.3471921384334564,
1.2556753158569336,
0.7271208167076111,
-0.364394873380661,
0.15796585381031036,
0.08730395883321762,
0.376619428396225,
-0.6028292775154114,
0.41214269399642944,
-0.041351448744535446,
0.11167780309915543,
0.3448874056339264,
-0.5806918740272522,
-0.03519153594970703,
0.19296947121620178,
-0.07626408338546753,
-0.10622810572385788,
-0.4347710609436035,
0.8094958066940308,
-0.3002350330352783,
-0.5268384218215942,
0.08612135797739029,
0.8196961879730225,
0.3260337710380554,
0.5076727271080017,
0.5294130444526672,
0.43706271052360535,
0.4346339702606201,
0.13974174857139587,
1.2959110736846924,
0.02624274417757988,
0.11487855762243271,
1.4069385528564453,
-0.6599188446998596,
1.1278184652328491,
0.4951581358909607,
-0.10974538326263428,
0.5912864208221436,
0.32375943660736084,
0.28691670298576355,
0.4732457399368286,
-0.17249225080013275,
-0.9026156663894653,
-0.3458159267902374,
-0.42709270119667053,
-0.20104174315929413,
0.40342825651168823,
0.43249279260635376,
-0.279005765914917,
-0.4162665009498596,
0.21007105708122253,
-0.19698213040828705,
0.1280871331691742,
-0.24657878279685974,
0.8439252972602844,
-0.10180607438087463,
-0.49858346581459045,
0.5429841876029968,
-0.26662492752075195,
0.611477255821228,
-0.7832305431365967,
-0.40897583961486816,
-0.36209383606910706,
0.053313612937927246,
0.05113638937473297,
-0.5736229419708252,
0.06574258953332901,
-0.13795366883277893,
0.05136645585298538,
-0.2907341420650482,
0.5872700810432434,
-0.5973194241523743,
-0.4383544921875,
0.23733961582183838,
0.4706142544746399,
0.02841043844819069,
-0.10754811763763428,
-0.18937909603118896,
-0.28725510835647583,
-0.17946943640708923,
0.027298148721456528,
0.6141332983970642,
0.4048346281051636,
-0.08384031802415848,
0.6327271461486816,
0.8147168755531311,
0.045294713228940964,
0.1195157989859581,
0.1920367181301117,
0.9238702058792114,
-0.25953587889671326,
-0.29272493720054626,
-0.9799793362617493,
0.5755929350852966,
-0.31973809003829956,
-0.05721369385719299,
0.8683658838272095,
0.6387418508529663,
1.1279274225234985,
-0.25536370277404785,
0.771079957485199,
0.21188247203826904,
0.4273753762245178,
-0.7165493369102478,
0.5255617499351501,
-0.6327021718025208,
0.27562975883483887,
-0.10122276842594147,
-0.5163912773132324,
-0.33900225162506104,
0.34226134419441223,
-0.1465642750263214,
-0.2819085121154785,
0.5577985644340515,
0.8636683225631714,
-0.32452645897865295,
-0.11546587944030762,
0.8320709466934204,
0.18247000873088837,
0.40984949469566345,
0.5055766701698303,
1.1445902585983276,
-0.29852190613746643,
0.39671197533607483,
-0.5837755799293518,
-0.21634021401405334,
-0.29422008991241455,
-1.2384196519851685,
-0.8911722898483276,
-0.6094077229499817,
-0.28023701906204224,
0.049504559487104416,
0.0446140356361866,
1.0875178575515747,
0.8921113014221191,
-0.7474222183227539,
-0.25241532921791077,
0.11832373589277267,
-0.07350677251815796,
-0.2765878438949585,
-0.296210914850235,
0.4228942394256592,
-0.5575352907180786,
-0.8382810950279236,
0.9833554625511169,
0.5220990777015686,
0.12173360586166382,
-0.36167651414871216,
0.12871906161308289,
-0.14495880901813507,
-0.02357788383960724,
1.0159919261932373,
0.39247700572013855,
-0.7465121150016785,
-0.4086296558380127,
-0.23127807676792145,
0.29260513186454773,
0.18020780384540558,
0.7317202091217041,
-1.2714570760726929,
0.6766985058784485,
0.24984556436538696,
0.8698420524597168,
0.628484308719635,
0.04734431579709053,
0.5222086310386658,
-1.182983160018921,
0.3769974410533905,
0.06624934077262878,
0.48539993166923523,
0.5314041376113892,
-0.39865973591804504,
0.18935813009738922,
0.11944101750850677,
-0.32051804661750793,
-0.8744585514068604,
0.27657005190849304,
-0.7903074622154236,
-0.11382291465997696,
1.128403663635254,
-0.3425607979297638,
-0.09153801202774048,
-0.18336668610572815,
-0.19220414757728577,
0.13387563824653625,
-0.36216676235198975,
0.9225484132766724,
0.22956965863704681,
-0.1862872987985611,
-0.22282914817333221,
-0.7115319967269897,
0.2239944189786911,
0.24897031486034393,
-0.8736763596534729,
0.049824561923742294,
0.6702824831008911,
0.11330252140760422,
-0.1185450553894043,
0.5523326396942139,
-0.040270060300827026,
0.15132054686546326,
-0.24579881131649017,
-0.09113432466983795,
-0.4077116549015045,
-0.3209698498249054,
-0.599058985710144,
0.4457944333553314,
0.07378167659044266,
-0.22984227538108826
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.01213v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.01213v1
|
Improving Pseudo Labels with Global-Local Denoising Framework for Cross-lingual Named Entity Recognition
| 2024-06-03T11:29:19 | 2024-06-03T11:29:19 |
Zhuojun Ding, Wei Wei, Xiaoye Qu, Dangyang Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Cross-lingual named entity recognition (NER) aims to train an NER model for
the target language leveraging only labeled source language data and unlabeled
target language data. Prior approaches either perform label projection on
translated source language data or employ a source model to assign pseudo
labels for target language data and train a target model on these
pseudo-labeled data to generalize to the target language. However, these
automatic labeling procedures inevitably introduce noisy labels, thus leading
to a performance drop. In this paper, we propose a Global-Local Denoising
framework (GLoDe) for cross-lingual NER. Specifically, GLoDe introduces a
progressive denoising strategy to rectify incorrect pseudo labels by leveraging
both global and local distribution information in the semantic space. The
refined pseudo-labeled target language data significantly improves the model's
generalization ability. Moreover, previous methods only consider improving the
model with language-agnostic features, however, we argue that target
language-specific features are also important and should never be ignored. To
this end, we employ a simple auxiliary task to achieve this goal. Experimental
results on two benchmark datasets with six target languages demonstrate that
our proposed GLoDe significantly outperforms current state-of-the-art methods.
|
[
-0.4730541706085205,
-0.5358722805976868,
0.21835987269878387,
-0.10545504093170166,
-0.4622040390968323,
-0.06819216907024384,
-0.2246401309967041,
-0.8935253024101257,
0.4860037863254547,
0.4780730605125427,
-0.30687227845191956,
-0.5744197964668274,
-0.5416868329048157,
0.33083707094192505,
-0.4123344123363495,
1.1766624450683594,
-0.21245494484901428,
0.1286596804857254,
-0.005399413872510195,
-0.1583014875650406,
-0.22442543506622314,
-0.5540092587471008,
-0.887944221496582,
-0.1377798467874527,
0.4245815873146057,
0.20024551451206207,
0.553292989730835,
0.28778767585754395,
0.1706041693687439,
0.24505433440208435,
-0.13003858923912048,
0.026582250371575356,
-0.537222683429718,
-0.23442202806472778,
-0.2680422365665436,
-0.28231996297836304,
-0.5049195885658264,
-0.43187031149864197,
1.1186883449554443,
0.790656566619873,
0.001883937162347138,
-0.10138688236474991,
-0.15625454485416412,
0.3543879985809326,
-0.5704699158668518,
0.12713776528835297,
-0.4943448305130005,
0.16949230432510376,
-0.28396469354629517,
0.27440619468688965,
-0.1975635588169098,
-0.2776775360107422,
0.31778326630592346,
-0.7241383790969849,
0.32649609446525574,
0.0382518470287323,
1.1813650131225586,
-0.0847168117761612,
-0.2548477053642273,
-0.13629432022571564,
-0.8945845365524292,
0.910570502281189,
-0.6039674282073975,
0.8142945766448975,
0.37348195910453796,
0.09039454162120819,
-0.05125763267278671,
-0.7389922738075256,
-0.2628094255924225,
-0.1520383507013321,
-0.1794767677783966,
-0.03718531131744385,
-0.4502834975719452,
-0.0011268201051279902,
0.0633992925286293,
0.4141128957271576,
-0.550506591796875,
0.12604764103889465,
-0.3096414804458618,
-0.5660256743431091,
0.30050528049468994,
-0.384309321641922,
0.5399395823478699,
0.19234946370124817,
-0.4834766685962677,
0.042433589696884155,
-0.8289642333984375,
-0.10377831012010574,
0.4387526214122772,
0.2575101852416992,
0.003489630063995719,
0.26708224415779114,
-0.39229118824005127,
0.719078540802002,
0.2359510362148285,
-0.101064033806324,
0.6141592264175415,
-0.4941418766975403,
-0.07890552282333374,
0.39944779872894287,
0.48298338055610657,
0.20953375101089478,
0.2996126711368561,
-0.7843106389045715,
-0.34641316533088684,
0.041928019374608994,
0.0029890842270106077,
-0.7743998765945435,
-0.39832603931427,
-0.14905954897403717,
-0.2020989954471588,
0.12162826955318451,
-0.16178296506404877,
-0.7352041602134705,
0.04394722729921341,
-0.45622843503952026,
0.43988561630249023,
-0.15410400927066803,
-0.5043180584907532,
-0.10154331475496292,
0.13426683843135834,
0.07183913141489029,
0.16168348491191864,
-0.8254284858703613,
0.39661580324172974,
0.15752804279327393,
0.704698920249939,
-0.22375252842903137,
-0.12706606090068817,
-0.7776222229003906,
0.42175811529159546,
-0.42319294810295105,
0.8558297753334045,
-0.5945947766304016,
-0.4966176450252533,
-0.3397079110145569,
0.3215954601764679,
-0.15422286093235016,
-0.8241673111915588,
0.17872978746891022,
-0.5687345862388611,
0.3950507640838623,
-0.24030910432338715,
-0.4840446710586548,
-0.26528438925743103,
0.210109680891037,
-0.7580697536468506,
0.8825724720954895,
0.13420122861862183,
-0.9081559181213379,
0.41251036524772644,
-0.42347657680511475,
-0.5347277522087097,
-0.003650797065347433,
0.055322661995887756,
-0.5094404220581055,
0.07141224294900894,
0.3797094523906708,
0.11992333829402924,
-0.23575976490974426,
0.37944644689559937,
-0.001970886252820492,
-0.40807342529296875,
-0.3666817545890808,
-0.29509592056274414,
0.3875393569469452,
-0.0476529635488987,
-0.4616667330265045,
0.06369811296463013,
-0.7522151470184326,
0.1670958697795868,
0.0037110706325620413,
-0.15113697946071625,
-0.7416590452194214,
-0.23268760740756989,
-0.15361562371253967,
0.005485807545483112,
0.17069435119628906,
-0.4950045347213745,
0.15606388449668884,
-0.6851859092712402,
0.11182906478643417,
0.28769397735595703,
0.10320167243480682,
0.923176646232605,
-0.01733621582388878,
0.5150137543678284,
0.007918807677924633,
0.09463255852460861,
0.35676589608192444,
-0.7136983871459961,
-0.49578818678855896,
-0.495368093252182,
0.7342337369918823,
0.6917770504951477,
-0.9739630818367004,
0.12007108330726624,
-0.37681126594543457,
-0.41530925035476685,
-0.5150662064552307,
0.5199143290519714,
0.5093150734901428,
0.8263676762580872,
0.766278862953186,
-0.5490424036979675,
-0.6429471373558044,
-1.0898338556289673,
0.051569387316703796,
-0.20089472830295563,
-0.2189396321773529,
0.212296262383461,
0.22887732088565826,
-0.7161093354225159,
1.0421935319900513,
-0.11490003764629364,
-0.5981274247169495,
-0.25851762294769287,
0.4330354332923889,
-0.13442717492580414,
0.232042595744133,
0.5289468169212341,
-1.0293277502059937,
-0.5626715421676636,
0.14597104489803314,
-0.5405195355415344,
-0.33520516753196716,
0.002121572382748127,
-0.024061862379312515,
0.3470189571380615,
0.39462384581565857,
-0.3213450014591217,
0.3548717200756073,
0.56015944480896,
0.02913970872759819,
0.5019150376319885,
-0.3433503806591034,
0.026165256276726723,
-0.7044433951377869,
0.07903629541397095,
0.03993549570441246,
-0.0241880901157856,
-0.9272047281265259,
-0.379989355802536,
0.06986607611179352,
0.09420040249824524,
-0.6850885152816772,
1.080609679222107,
-0.9744904637336731,
-0.11900172382593155,
-0.2553580403327942,
0.146438330411911,
0.033447589725255966,
0.18439550697803497,
0.6631090641021729,
0.6423044204711914,
0.7045828700065613,
-0.6493205428123474,
0.22687749564647675,
-0.0575445182621479,
-0.3977634608745575,
0.53969407081604,
-0.5570926666259766,
-0.054652661085128784,
-0.2772601842880249,
0.23915913701057434,
-0.7260633707046509,
0.18929614126682281,
0.6869778037071228,
-0.12191241979598999,
0.5937787890434265,
-0.3062294125556946,
-0.23796314001083374,
-0.14128729701042175,
-0.032804619520902634,
0.5867180824279785,
0.2948801815509796,
-0.4609846770763397,
0.6330408453941345,
0.5606987476348877,
-0.21167562901973724,
-0.48330211639404297,
-0.7854388356208801,
0.24164322018623352,
-0.20710740983486176,
-0.5370067954063416,
0.8274040222167969,
0.013729536905884743,
-0.06272507458925247,
0.29792067408561707,
-0.2738063633441925,
-0.23384502530097961,
-0.32380256056785583,
-0.19049639999866486,
0.22789980471134186,
-0.21625284850597382,
0.15171633660793304,
-0.02238588221371174,
-0.33252424001693726,
-0.10873208194971085,
-0.2623078525066376,
0.18772689998149872,
-0.12675075232982635,
0.07594692707061768,
-0.08873603492975235,
0.3520348072052002,
0.051127851009368896,
-0.22787323594093323,
0.48412951827049255,
0.9404693245887756,
-0.4494462013244629,
-0.2554703950881958,
-0.37978124618530273,
-0.23317034542560577,
-0.4168528616428375,
0.477117121219635,
-0.4910401701927185,
-0.7149407267570496,
0.59028559923172,
-0.24630670249462128,
-0.30598294734954834,
0.26476043462753296,
0.2154606282711029,
0.21208716928958893,
0.6843907833099365,
0.8492140173912048,
-0.35743358731269836,
0.4510587155818939,
-0.37375959753990173,
0.6148040294647217,
-0.8887751698493958,
-0.09477193653583527,
-0.348565012216568,
-0.17103558778762817,
-0.3688696622848511,
-0.6043576598167419,
0.07891280204057693,
0.24083733558654785,
0.4433785378932953,
0.4824303686618805,
-0.6072523593902588,
0.28473010659217834,
0.4789882004261017,
-0.22251620888710022,
0.16670893132686615,
0.2661382555961609,
-0.28968432545661926,
-0.3067232370376587,
-0.705277144908905,
-0.1197986975312233,
0.6252958178520203,
0.07004953920841217,
0.5520040988922119,
-0.11537546664476395,
0.9498717188835144,
0.27626901865005493,
0.3729476034641266,
-0.45865398645401,
0.5761551260948181,
-0.13735583424568176,
-0.5869177579879761,
-0.42979344725608826,
-0.6896979212760925,
-1.0470645427703857,
0.29192256927490234,
0.07799626141786575,
-0.8732358813285828,
0.5459896326065063,
0.13052771985530853,
0.06631942838430405,
0.5510751605033875,
-0.8169079422950745,
1.0811632871627808,
-0.3159811496734619,
-0.1503964215517044,
0.08635076880455017,
-0.5011275410652161,
0.2571437358856201,
-0.28275254368782043,
0.5397581458091736,
0.11067291349172592,
-0.1446642130613327,
0.8341500759124756,
-0.14309370517730713,
0.9169626235961914,
-0.3554990887641907,
-0.44575443863868713,
0.480842649936676,
-0.09204215556383133,
0.7787013649940491,
0.005732515826821327,
0.06773468852043152,
0.6698311567306519,
-0.24737967550754547,
-0.09789470583200455,
-0.4067728519439697,
0.8449183106422424,
-0.49135106801986694,
-0.33816102147102356,
-0.30259257555007935,
-0.2981528043746948,
-0.1949124038219452,
0.30719712376594543,
0.5019726157188416,
0.47111472487449646,
-0.24954356253147125,
-0.13979098200798035,
0.6858331561088562,
-0.25938862562179565,
0.2970668077468872,
0.4394317865371704,
-0.25522011518478394,
-0.6982802152633667,
1.370932698249817,
0.541271448135376,
0.32041066884994507,
0.5047710537910461,
-0.1328841596841812,
-0.7079287171363831,
-0.4933677911758423,
-0.6076099872589111,
0.35386404395103455,
-0.8258702158927917,
-0.002782330382615328,
-0.5873416066169739,
-0.15501560270786285,
-0.3923589885234833,
-0.17475001513957977,
-0.3952544629573822,
-0.17404906451702118,
-0.23554235696792603,
0.1617332249879837,
0.08584729582071304,
0.40554502606391907,
-0.3405493199825287,
0.11410487443208694,
-0.7681901454925537,
0.891069769859314,
0.13220451772212982,
0.23384127020835876,
-0.14724238216876984,
-0.5352122783660889,
-0.241516575217247,
0.2592061460018158,
0.4056498110294342,
-0.8149937391281128,
0.4271254241466522,
0.41152361035346985,
0.904312789440155,
0.1696285754442215,
0.2686246335506439,
0.7253516912460327,
-0.5041976571083069,
0.3552968502044678,
0.28432372212409973,
-0.8040943741798401,
0.5651235580444336,
0.14517377316951752,
0.43948695063591003,
0.24295265972614288,
0.5402934551239014,
-0.5965089201927185,
-0.3948197066783905,
-0.6106273531913757,
-1.2612751722335815,
0.625220775604248,
0.09769472479820251,
0.006840013433247805,
-0.1734945923089981,
0.03833186253905296,
0.1218838095664978,
0.23739196360111237,
-0.883776068687439,
-0.25346070528030396,
-0.08830276131629944,
0.07596737891435623,
-0.08078757673501968,
-0.28373289108276367,
0.22578319907188416,
-0.28987908363342285,
0.8721632361412048,
-0.02042136713862419,
0.18187294900417328,
0.4073064625263214,
-0.36250388622283936,
-0.1737135946750641,
0.43175333738327026,
0.350716233253479,
0.29834383726119995,
-0.1380031853914261,
0.04387230426073074,
0.3793269991874695,
-0.5054803490638733,
0.26899757981300354,
0.23927433788776398,
-0.8099825978279114,
0.459007203578949,
0.03337448090314865,
0.744949460029602,
0.5034810900688171,
-0.3337855339050293,
0.11239223927259445,
0.09046434611082077,
-0.017318472266197205,
0.025468414649367332,
-0.07949959486722946,
0.07417920976877213,
-0.12942659854888916,
0.2664225399494171,
0.041919928044080734,
0.3450785279273987,
-0.3979801833629608,
0.37295281887054443,
0.369306355714798,
-0.32298770546913147,
-0.4267655909061432,
0.5196677446365356,
-0.05312914028763771,
-0.154193714261055,
0.43966925144195557,
-0.42925411462783813,
-0.5267651081085205,
0.5284300446510315,
0.6494950652122498,
0.8844824433326721,
-0.33891743421554565,
0.488953173160553,
0.5389724373817444,
0.3825942575931549,
-0.24240925908088684,
0.10056034475564957,
-0.20966434478759766,
-0.6861329078674316,
-0.5787380933761597,
-0.676179826259613,
-0.5639877319335938,
0.08759301155805588,
-0.339978963136673,
0.24602454900741577,
-0.2797988951206207,
-0.3479715585708618,
-0.18409039080142975,
-0.03407669439911842,
-0.4245380163192749,
0.5571573376655579,
0.37283068895339966,
0.3495672047138214,
-0.6581265330314636,
1.1250954866409302,
0.9639779925346375,
-0.16332201659679413,
-0.6189789175987244,
-0.14777250587940216,
-0.1655295491218567,
-0.32606199383735657,
0.7608727216720581,
0.08113949745893478,
-0.3574678897857666,
0.1964120715856552,
0.0880603939294815,
-1.2034064531326294,
0.5728291869163513,
0.42398130893707275,
-0.9062949419021606,
-0.022514093667268753,
0.27450254559516907,
0.5353530049324036,
-0.3236716389656067,
0.17243315279483795,
0.17457778751850128,
0.8238449692726135,
0.22387969493865967,
-1.0116413831710815,
-0.108441561460495,
-0.20544284582138062,
0.08388872444629669,
0.41966569423675537,
-0.21936792135238647,
0.481543630361557,
-0.3331843316555023,
-0.3859158158302307,
-0.14755867421627045,
0.597506046295166,
-0.03445633128285408,
0.2718595266342163,
0.6155910491943359,
0.6222959756851196,
0.823097825050354,
-0.17053158581256866,
0.7459208965301514,
-0.0897853672504425,
0.12502452731132507,
1.176379919052124,
-0.46100157499313354,
0.5635026097297668,
0.4281746745109558,
0.10084632784128189,
0.38166382908821106,
0.5253797173500061,
-0.293957382440567,
0.8706187605857849,
0.27756762504577637,
-0.14191655814647675,
-0.1598726511001587,
-0.22825589776039124,
-0.5917367339134216,
0.1459561288356781,
0.16336271166801453,
-0.09073695540428162,
-0.6102272272109985,
0.2575816810131073,
0.06856164336204529,
-0.2557545304298401,
-0.40497592091560364,
0.5693435072898865,
0.09398418664932251,
-0.2727609872817993,
0.8295502662658691,
0.10578214377164841,
0.8281848430633545,
-0.7199010848999023,
0.0351090133190155,
-0.2588980197906494,
0.22639018297195435,
-0.09756118804216385,
-0.31800442934036255,
0.4473194479942322,
-0.0727744847536087,
-0.23810122907161713,
-0.24908994138240814,
0.9432328939437866,
-0.6676196455955505,
-0.565095841884613,
0.9107118248939514,
0.25941240787506104,
0.30821749567985535,
-0.04753585532307625,
-0.6263277530670166,
0.0334191620349884,
0.0634647011756897,
-0.24646928906440735,
0.591438353061676,
0.5215149521827698,
-0.4605278968811035,
0.5273657441139221,
0.6085524559020996,
0.47237640619277954,
0.18247421085834503,
0.16159546375274658,
0.6100832223892212,
-0.4477381110191345,
-0.4257727861404419,
-0.4163602292537689,
0.38317397236824036,
0.003345143748447299,
-0.3356878459453583,
0.673788845539093,
0.5072131752967834,
1.3574965000152588,
-0.0004564257396850735,
0.4941387176513672,
-0.018405970185995102,
0.4311273694038391,
-0.3872087597846985,
0.5620692372322083,
-0.721671998500824,
0.3038250803947449,
-0.3374655842781067,
-1.296523928642273,
-0.548957109451294,
0.5232507586479187,
-0.6269636154174805,
0.10708259046077728,
0.35494372248649597,
0.845464825630188,
-0.22913455963134766,
-0.38112202286720276,
0.5360535979270935,
0.21483033895492554,
0.11709440499544144,
0.45503029227256775,
0.5553248524665833,
-0.5180198550224304,
0.8252484202384949,
-0.6173127889633179,
0.08022519946098328,
0.05930943787097931,
-0.7212117314338684,
-0.6992650032043457,
-0.16948182880878448,
-0.7359832525253296,
0.1261100023984909,
0.33366140723228455,
0.17871727049350739,
0.6394920945167542,
-1.0933029651641846,
0.026182420551776886,
-0.028893806040287018,
0.13266855478286743,
-0.1942363828420639,
-0.22070138156414032,
0.4356885850429535,
-0.3075870871543884,
-0.8356049656867981,
0.6402424573898315,
0.2703113257884979,
0.15023934841156006,
0.11069178581237793,
-0.34957462549209595,
-0.27611228823661804,
-0.2798384428024292,
0.350800096988678,
0.5868149995803833,
-0.6939545273780823,
-0.26521432399749756,
0.011494903825223446,
-0.08446189761161804,
0.044397253543138504,
0.31120556592941284,
-0.9262956976890564,
0.5236346125602722,
0.25876134634017944,
0.44781622290611267,
0.3772678077220917,
-0.16160352528095245,
0.49716001749038696,
-0.7080456018447876,
0.17816992104053497,
0.20369204878807068,
0.42930763959884644,
0.4823417365550995,
-0.25295770168304443,
0.5656704902648926,
0.48336467146873474,
-0.21557605266571045,
-0.786090075969696,
-0.10957884788513184,
-0.5552658438682556,
-0.30007895827293396,
1.0366449356079102,
-0.2323981523513794,
-0.2556789517402649,
-0.39239996671676636,
-0.12405165284872055,
0.22421914339065552,
-0.24187377095222473,
0.5572904348373413,
0.5483813881874084,
0.22837935388088226,
-0.17645326256752014,
-0.426868200302124,
0.3991435468196869,
0.39693522453308105,
-0.4513067603111267,
-0.08417144417762756,
0.6194420456886292,
0.46049201488494873,
0.27217280864715576,
0.790021538734436,
-0.08882912993431091,
0.15925167500972748,
-0.09801238030195236,
0.36261385679244995,
0.19199667870998383,
-0.6661791801452637,
-0.13808219134807587,
0.11141487210988998,
-0.22013823688030243,
-0.09436532855033875
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.01198v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.01198v1
|
Automatic Essay Multi-dimensional Scoring with Fine-tuning and Multiple Regression
| 2024-06-03T10:59:50 | 2024-06-03T10:59:50 |
Kun Sun, Rong Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Automated essay scoring (AES) involves predicting a score that reflects the
writing quality of an essay. Most existing AES systems produce only a single
overall score. However, users and L2 learners expect scores across different
dimensions (e.g., vocabulary, grammar, coherence) for English essays in
real-world applications. To address this need, we have developed two models
that automatically score English essays across multiple dimensions by employing
fine-tuning and other strategies on two large datasets. The results demonstrate
that our systems achieve impressive performance in evaluation using three
criteria: precision, F1 score, and Quadratic Weighted Kappa. Furthermore, our
system outperforms existing methods in overall scoring.
|
[
-0.6231157183647156,
-0.9936239123344421,
0.6824638843536377,
0.5267795324325562,
0.16735172271728516,
0.17864811420440674,
0.00981101393699646,
-0.7777844667434692,
0.438106894493103,
0.2797214984893799,
-0.3603705167770386,
-0.535368025302887,
-0.5046621561050415,
0.4094281494617462,
-0.29645827412605286,
0.9968908429145813,
-0.37559106945991516,
0.23381243646144867,
-0.41767239570617676,
-0.17048542201519012,
-0.46345558762550354,
-0.12243321537971497,
-1.0497291088104248,
-0.041777100414037704,
0.6485111117362976,
0.7501516342163086,
0.4693068861961365,
0.6535825729370117,
1.0593068599700928,
0.3252199590206146,
0.5793070793151855,
0.48621949553489685,
-0.004622173961251974,
0.3202444314956665,
0.11428984254598618,
-0.4300081431865692,
-0.5450145602226257,
0.3478623330593109,
0.7200350165367126,
0.4589270353317261,
0.2737518548965454,
0.46711450815200806,
0.40032151341438293,
0.3764651417732239,
-0.5888406038284302,
0.11576996743679047,
-0.23989228904247284,
0.1121399775147438,
0.09281638264656067,
-0.10196436941623688,
-0.40939873456954956,
-0.75098717212677,
-0.025931330397725105,
-0.7624066472053528,
0.054034385830163956,
0.16506294906139374,
0.6440324187278748,
0.11947021633386612,
-0.5742120742797852,
-0.3433154821395874,
-0.7896239161491394,
0.9388172030448914,
-0.16999393701553345,
0.21563471853733063,
0.265167236328125,
0.3220367729663849,
0.34110909700393677,
-0.7077987790107727,
-0.2616802155971527,
-0.09033168852329254,
-0.17040273547172546,
0.29979056119918823,
0.0625104010105133,
0.34143155813217163,
0.06358247250318527,
0.3228500783443451,
-0.5828853249549866,
0.22636733949184418,
-0.7214879393577576,
-0.3059750199317932,
1.0696622133255005,
0.5614135265350342,
-0.02156730182468891,
-0.03779977187514305,
-0.19497030973434448,
-0.12582774460315704,
-0.16460470855236053,
0.5470887422561646,
0.6164863109588623,
0.4432833194732666,
-0.012933197431266308,
0.5235101580619812,
0.08852033317089081,
0.5550258755683899,
0.2593352198600769,
-0.4409264922142029,
0.024995962157845497,
-0.21283835172653198,
-0.023681892082095146,
-0.061902083456516266,
0.7199997901916504,
0.6278672814369202,
0.28642165660858154,
0.07075357437133789,
-0.45902201533317566,
0.29328110814094543,
0.5973407626152039,
-0.5271577835083008,
-0.00278957886621356,
0.27045485377311707,
-0.681463360786438,
-0.45198580622673035,
0.17381855845451355,
-1.035703420639038,
-0.21711009740829468,
-0.7705428600311279,
0.9262976050376892,
-0.4127950966358185,
0.21370209753513336,
0.01787577010691166,
-0.3196142315864563,
0.10968712717294693,
0.3216186761856079,
-0.7585750222206116,
0.6599733829498291,
0.48444992303848267,
0.8690455555915833,
-0.3967868983745575,
-0.684233546257019,
-0.4791412353515625,
-0.2897065281867981,
-0.6460202932357788,
1.0966600179672241,
-0.9031352400779724,
-0.28216540813446045,
0.1630297750234604,
-0.25469470024108887,
-0.16329553723335266,
-0.1769842803478241,
0.71444171667099,
-0.24839664995670319,
0.3080151081085205,
-0.3988622725009918,
-0.7892601490020752,
-0.1713203340768814,
0.07123423367738724,
-0.5504810214042664,
1.023972749710083,
-0.009839422069489956,
-0.3325127363204956,
0.4608227610588074,
-0.6716713905334473,
-0.5860598087310791,
-0.16453951597213745,
0.019831374287605286,
-0.46581390500068665,
0.40360212326049805,
0.21365986764431,
0.5256685018539429,
-0.07099024951457977,
-0.3147405683994293,
-0.48173317313194275,
-0.6303554177284241,
-0.18865866959095,
-0.5374799966812134,
0.30632495880126953,
0.1540660560131073,
0.0005185003974474967,
-0.09030333161354065,
-0.9890000820159912,
0.42914965748786926,
-0.19287213683128357,
-0.5502874851226807,
-0.24139831960201263,
-0.10127652436494827,
0.13250097632408142,
0.025351589545607567,
0.4610251188278198,
-0.5045945048332214,
0.24385985732078552,
-0.3754502236843109,
0.12462104111909866,
0.6080199480056763,
0.2597901523113251,
0.3791801631450653,
-0.6595643758773804,
0.6523517370223999,
-0.3989650011062622,
0.21851953864097595,
-0.22109614312648773,
-0.6804686784744263,
-0.55232834815979,
-0.43827587366104126,
0.15718236565589905,
0.7825499176979065,
-0.038124509155750275,
0.5933859944343567,
0.1319284439086914,
-0.5479986667633057,
-0.7812314629554749,
0.14417551457881927,
0.2887808382511139,
0.09083901345729828,
0.5543869733810425,
0.0011001279344782233,
-0.4385036826133728,
-0.9203435182571411,
-0.3859159052371979,
-0.06665582954883575,
0.008946043439209461,
0.12443448603153229,
0.5668859481811523,
0.26315951347351074,
0.631725013256073,
-0.6875894665718079,
-0.7252034544944763,
-0.05157560855150223,
0.5061451196670532,
-0.37634629011154175,
0.42567119002342224,
0.7493172287940979,
-0.33153682947158813,
-0.8215093612670898,
-0.2615228295326233,
-0.566419243812561,
-0.17915168404579163,
-0.2408571094274521,
0.10009096562862396,
0.07099293172359467,
0.7075846195220947,
-0.4399352967739105,
0.5347889065742493,
0.42899051308631897,
-0.3270098567008972,
0.7368777990341187,
-0.46679311990737915,
0.5924546122550964,
-1.0150254964828491,
-0.26384618878364563,
0.38397860527038574,
-0.11993974447250366,
-0.40077218413352966,
0.1374886929988861,
-0.017716500908136368,
0.042126916348934174,
0.14780831336975098,
0.4782922565937042,
-0.08528777956962585,
-0.010993256233632565,
-0.15603528916835785,
0.022652721032500267,
0.6742199659347534,
0.31011274456977844,
-0.32106998562812805,
0.6998187899589539,
0.341348260641098,
-0.33626827597618103,
0.4678630232810974,
-0.024644896388053894,
-0.2652801275253296,
1.012959599494934,
-0.6768112778663635,
0.0698789432644844,
-0.2002224326133728,
0.15044431388378143,
-1.4641883373260498,
-0.3778983950614929,
-0.5116742849349976,
-0.4695839285850525,
0.3128111958503723,
0.40830713510513306,
-0.03680456429719925,
-0.5130079388618469,
-0.6687617897987366,
0.20770485699176788,
0.15498143434524536,
-0.22069448232650757,
0.7036224007606506,
0.3349418044090271,
-0.4663326144218445,
-0.32726845145225525,
-0.5359998345375061,
0.003780907951295376,
-0.34873178601264954,
-0.47728708386421204,
0.4580075740814209,
-0.1664232313632965,
-0.47060123085975647,
0.04890228435397148,
0.10181018710136414,
-0.133697047829628,
0.015036210417747498,
0.24587178230285645,
0.12528930604457855,
-0.3332518935203552,
0.2980087101459503,
0.4628117084503174,
-0.06054549664258957,
0.17132540047168732,
-0.4470785856246948,
0.09711916744709015,
-0.07355885952711105,
-0.5845826864242554,
-0.7467092871665955,
0.9638711214065552,
1.0128060579299927,
-0.3497675359249115,
0.7337311506271362,
0.6879329681396484,
-0.8257949948310852,
-0.2738504111766815,
-0.7465043067932129,
-0.18961118161678314,
-0.40405285358428955,
0.30607104301452637,
-0.6279919147491455,
-0.7227368354797363,
0.6476457715034485,
0.31765952706336975,
0.3287765383720398,
0.8212922215461731,
0.3245854079723358,
-0.38332313299179077,
1.6864423751831055,
0.7840257287025452,
0.011948580853641033,
0.044631242752075195,
-0.13677501678466797,
0.45561331510543823,
-0.43853262066841125,
-0.2511659562587738,
-0.9935175776481628,
-0.55597323179245,
-0.6498050093650818,
0.10444134473800659,
0.6835675835609436,
0.22359851002693176,
-0.4367476999759674,
-0.07757862657308578,
-0.7071458101272583,
0.7348790764808655,
0.6663868427276611,
-0.16499142348766327,
0.06438861042261124,
0.051168788224458694,
-0.5461208820343018,
-0.16600830852985382,
-0.04496384039521217,
-0.6979245543479919,
1.3155862092971802,
0.4741218388080597,
0.4470486640930176,
-0.05508848652243614,
0.7465136051177979,
0.5017369389533997,
0.10165990889072418,
-0.6042975187301636,
0.1856677085161209,
-0.4890824258327484,
-0.4955581724643707,
-0.6054284572601318,
-0.0057588908821344376,
-0.5012036561965942,
-0.08790697157382965,
-0.4075542688369751,
-0.7488834261894226,
-0.07165411114692688,
0.00031588616548106074,
-1.0493745803833008,
0.05685795098543167,
-0.9185947775840759,
0.5678672790527344,
-0.1386975198984146,
-0.4665016829967499,
-0.3345473110675812,
-0.17999720573425293,
0.07457884401082993,
-0.26296788454055786,
0.14936892688274384,
0.16720807552337646,
0.05350874736905098,
0.9298076033592224,
-0.0578036904335022,
0.6763366460800171,
-0.28444036841392517,
0.07597040385007858,
0.42332202196121216,
0.15737317502498627,
0.39173322916030884,
0.2789667546749115,
-0.3204418420791626,
0.055399224162101746,
0.3909400701522827,
-0.20859350264072418,
-0.4408765137195587,
0.9492253661155701,
-1.0198297500610352,
-0.32690906524658203,
-0.36270204186439514,
-0.299672931432724,
-0.2929062247276306,
0.18139135837554932,
0.30292990803718567,
0.4264032542705536,
-0.25323212146759033,
0.04191645607352257,
0.492681086063385,
-0.182426318526268,
0.38928738236427307,
0.3982482850551605,
-0.14974242448806763,
-0.5775347948074341,
0.848045289516449,
0.5071527361869812,
-0.16862505674362183,
0.3896913528442383,
0.18225517868995667,
-0.5104983448982239,
-0.39776092767715454,
-0.43636131286621094,
0.008020861074328423,
-0.7496517300605774,
-0.4250936210155487,
-0.6786633133888245,
-0.36341074109077454,
-0.6992990970611572,
-0.7574465274810791,
-0.35364454984664917,
-0.44378307461738586,
-0.30090972781181335,
-0.449211061000824,
0.19433251023292542,
1.2081862688064575,
-0.34799909591674805,
0.05358501523733139,
-0.9281582832336426,
0.5005923509597778,
0.41217339038848877,
0.7656942009925842,
-0.31831592321395874,
-0.5574299693107605,
-0.2711760997772217,
-0.11323658376932144,
-0.5473667979240417,
-0.6017785668373108,
0.08697239309549332,
0.35377317667007446,
0.48725247383117676,
0.6098251938819885,
-0.3709704279899597,
0.7282242774963379,
-0.543254017829895,
0.8886489272117615,
-0.11400645226240158,
-0.8526611328125,
0.49296140670776367,
-0.13569766283035278,
0.19319462776184082,
0.9111279845237732,
0.46514278650283813,
-0.19542637467384338,
-0.4197179973125458,
-0.16253362596035004,
-0.5465202331542969,
0.6088510751724243,
-0.2230396419763565,
0.16570694744586945,
0.16042397916316986,
0.7631295919418335,
0.3268585801124573,
-0.13978274166584015,
-0.46502310037612915,
-0.09976612776517868,
-0.07222598046064377,
-0.821683943271637,
-0.23945677280426025,
-0.2988399863243103,
0.1345244199037552,
-0.5536820888519287,
0.7005537748336792,
-0.14641828835010529,
0.34809035062789917,
0.14954344928264618,
0.32822513580322266,
-0.5444331765174866,
-0.23819932341575623,
0.6669589877128601,
0.416766494512558,
-0.1633601188659668,
-0.08112409710884094,
0.3668826222419739,
-0.6871042847633362,
0.3381332457065582,
0.15863534808158875,
-0.08310651779174805,
-0.2080696076154709,
0.6335569024085999,
0.5428966283798218,
-0.25991159677505493,
-0.10439720004796982,
0.49034926295280457,
-0.35093292593955994,
-0.5537364482879639,
-0.5402911305427551,
0.2013443112373352,
-0.12650075554847717,
0.05607593432068825,
0.3153687119483948,
0.4598747491836548,
0.2091354876756668,
-0.1175520271062851,
0.28715550899505615,
0.36513254046440125,
-0.4643841087818146,
-0.22662825882434845,
0.6608825922012329,
0.25441041588783264,
-0.5326839089393616,
0.46405112743377686,
-0.3439372777938843,
-0.19976262748241425,
0.6737181544303894,
0.3851759731769562,
0.9130507707595825,
-0.6947755813598633,
0.2529091238975525,
0.6925126910209656,
0.569882869720459,
-0.18330185115337372,
0.5869631171226501,
0.2871043384075165,
-0.5265555381774902,
-0.4148716628551483,
-1.185652732849121,
-0.2859622538089752,
0.29743656516075134,
-0.6627274751663208,
0.6393688917160034,
-0.4852603077888489,
-0.05120878666639328,
0.3979303538799286,
0.46087244153022766,
-0.8426146507263184,
0.6391384601593018,
0.1526082456111908,
0.9163990616798401,
-1.2057394981384277,
0.35003897547721863,
0.9732229709625244,
-0.28465667366981506,
-0.8426488041877747,
-0.14735060930252075,
0.1399775892496109,
-0.47834572196006775,
0.24711672961711884,
0.4675845205783844,
-0.37690767645835876,
-0.019612373784184456,
-0.0101759172976017,
-1.0649141073226929,
0.7764111161231995,
-0.05133475363254547,
-0.38946664333343506,
-0.06086989492177963,
0.5144910216331482,
0.8292213678359985,
-0.7006438374519348,
0.46037229895591736,
0.7118469476699829,
0.7111254334449768,
-0.5793017148971558,
-0.8560264110565186,
-0.4865953028202057,
-0.16169117391109467,
-0.39223647117614746,
0.03190796077251434,
-0.6770753860473633,
0.773279070854187,
-0.05683048069477081,
0.16367554664611816,
-0.13151191174983978,
0.43473923206329346,
-0.33083978295326233,
0.5154911279678345,
0.36629408597946167,
0.7674700617790222,
0.8800050616264343,
-0.18910685181617737,
0.8426894545555115,
-0.6327151656150818,
0.1252991110086441,
0.7158218026161194,
-0.4365960955619812,
0.7804427742958069,
0.0363934300839901,
-0.22863245010375977,
0.42823535203933716,
0.5691973567008972,
0.08702438324689865,
0.19919712841510773,
-0.035867445170879364,
-0.1396069973707199,
-0.33593982458114624,
0.1099127009510994,
0.0641072541475296,
1.1803288459777832,
0.6147385835647583,
-0.2452055960893631,
0.0704139694571495,
0.28700149059295654,
-0.2429283857345581,
0.39131540060043335,
-0.32974180579185486,
0.8592095375061035,
-0.0786798819899559,
-1.1747366189956665,
0.029775818809866905,
0.4664330780506134,
0.24196107685565948,
-0.4935666024684906,
-0.2635537087917328,
-0.2836223840713501,
0.33673444390296936,
-0.20967113971710205,
-0.7205594182014465,
0.570123553276062,
0.020832566544413567,
-0.31972572207450867,
-0.21808212995529175,
0.7000415921211243,
-0.16446229815483093,
-1.1018903255462646,
0.3218713700771332,
0.4692133665084839,
-0.18200619518756866,
0.22323797643184662,
-0.49315908551216125,
-0.10730551183223724,
-0.2594121992588043,
-0.4287150800228119,
0.16119341552257538,
0.39922258257865906,
-0.033389944583177567,
0.3501235246658325,
0.3693588972091675,
0.08003339171409607,
-0.1323121041059494,
0.025657782331109047,
0.19677749276161194,
-0.4250183701515198,
-0.5643835067749023,
-0.7426126003265381,
0.3336400091648102,
-0.13735084235668182,
-0.6698225736618042,
0.7244170904159546,
0.8030201196670532,
0.6274454593658447,
0.25544291734695435,
1.129070520401001,
0.34226691722869873,
0.8245832920074463,
-0.30690622329711914,
0.4306562840938568,
-0.6405290961265564,
0.005529994145035744,
-0.2463505119085312,
-1.0426114797592163,
-0.6346999406814575,
0.7872388958930969,
-0.13655172288417816,
0.08173768222332001,
0.8767231702804565,
0.6472620368003845,
-0.043177247047424316,
0.3089931011199951,
0.27219322323799133,
-0.043327897787094116,
0.26350128650665283,
0.27899476885795593,
0.5455998778343201,
-0.5513020157814026,
0.31417492032051086,
-0.37814807891845703,
-0.4216723144054413,
-0.21871162950992584,
-0.5929993391036987,
-0.7162444591522217,
-0.8010730743408203,
-0.3112764060497284,
-0.21546487510204315,
-0.08998092263936996,
0.8919620513916016,
0.44103655219078064,
-0.9160532355308533,
0.030548594892024994,
0.14909620583057404,
-0.16885975003242493,
-0.4352881610393524,
-0.31864944100379944,
0.43281885981559753,
-0.7265835404396057,
-0.8135824799537659,
0.22049351036548615,
0.6592162251472473,
-0.10411687940359116,
-0.5719299912452698,
0.18109716475009918,
0.049507368355989456,
0.8299316167831421,
0.48930495977401733,
-0.2769126296043396,
-0.30650269985198975,
-0.9328193664550781,
0.136735737323761,
-0.35105860233306885,
-0.15783429145812988,
0.6928740739822388,
-0.45871713757514954,
0.13889746367931366,
0.5082308650016785,
0.34665560722351074,
-0.08788195252418518,
-0.058734044432640076,
0.40511566400527954,
-0.6199671030044556,
-0.22493648529052734,
0.24944305419921875,
0.38038527965545654,
0.12710487842559814,
-0.6208291053771973,
-0.09868364036083221,
-0.06530553102493286,
-0.9067938923835754,
-0.6432697772979736,
-0.11357509344816208,
-0.402466356754303,
-0.4120267331600189,
0.793080747127533,
-0.14607468247413635,
0.3184007406234741,
-0.2633967399597168,
-0.15422193706035614,
0.12620100378990173,
-0.048596955835819244,
1.2037361860275269,
1.004089593887329,
-0.29537367820739746,
0.3636157512664795,
-0.5271545648574829,
0.6631273627281189,
0.28636661171913147,
-0.6771792769432068,
-0.2408931851387024,
0.4976961314678192,
0.07004928588867188,
0.4501250684261322,
0.46072348952293396,
0.15534718334674835,
0.3180472254753113,
0.31738436222076416,
-0.03908168897032738,
0.23257087171077728,
-0.9249282479286194,
-0.4272107481956482,
0.780972957611084,
0.06429119408130646,
-0.047302618622779846
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.01197v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.01197v2
|
A Survey of Generative Information Retrieval
| 2024-06-03T10:59:33 | 2024-06-04T04:12:39 |
Tzu-Lin Kuo, Tzu-Wei Chiu, Tzung-Sheng Lin, Sheng-Yang Wu, Chao-Wei Huang, Yun-Nung Chen
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.CL
|
Generative Retrieval (GR) is an emerging paradigm in information retrieval
that leverages generative models to directly map queries to relevant document
identifiers (DocIDs) without the need for traditional query processing or
document reranking. This survey provides a comprehensive overview of GR,
highlighting key developments, indexing and retrieval strategies, and
challenges. We discuss various document identifier strategies, including
numerical and string-based identifiers, and explore different document
representation methods. Our primary contribution lies in outlining future
research directions that could profoundly impact the field: improving the
quality of query generation, exploring learnable document identifiers,
enhancing scalability, and integrating GR with multi-task learning frameworks.
By examining state-of-the-art GR techniques and their applications, this survey
aims to provide a foundational understanding of GR and inspire further
innovations in this transformative approach to information retrieval. We also
make the complementary materials such as paper collection publicly available at
https://github.com/MiuLab/GenIR-Survey/
|
[
-0.5281404852867126,
-0.6325886249542236,
0.46936696767807007,
-0.15266047418117523,
-0.08783513307571411,
0.40426838397979736,
0.021800072863698006,
-0.20031259953975677,
0.1665084809064865,
0.15036270022392273,
-0.2720881700515747,
-0.6431319713592529,
-0.723214864730835,
-0.1478496789932251,
-0.5444969534873962,
0.9058088064193726,
0.30145758390426636,
0.0984184741973877,
-0.5584304928779602,
-0.2472984939813614,
0.06754659116268158,
-0.6571925282478333,
-0.47838935256004333,
-0.12975233793258667,
0.5577746629714966,
0.04912204667925835,
0.23789294064044952,
0.2531290352344513,
0.8985329270362854,
0.19345127046108246,
-0.23821227252483368,
0.17268496751785278,
-0.6744081377983093,
0.35406818985939026,
0.04775629937648773,
-0.49926313757896423,
-0.05680737644433975,
0.03680117428302765,
0.7952041029930115,
0.6653009653091431,
-0.3158290386199951,
0.19134308397769928,
0.07979917526245117,
0.7883948087692261,
-0.838290274143219,
0.26004692912101746,
-0.4803478419780731,
0.293306827545166,
-0.730749249458313,
-0.6330456137657166,
-0.495706170797348,
-0.7362521290779114,
-0.12195400893688202,
-0.6897598505020142,
0.9816321730613708,
0.052667826414108276,
0.5227306485176086,
-0.0791635736823082,
-0.4600580632686615,
-0.4911212623119354,
-0.7862827777862549,
0.3535645008087158,
-0.11572540551424026,
0.499292254447937,
0.34023213386535645,
0.5519397854804993,
-0.15447497367858887,
-1.1134427785873413,
-0.23749282956123352,
0.05844408646225929,
-0.13974842429161072,
0.3673493564128876,
0.05006401240825653,
0.0015041710576042533,
0.30071312189102173,
0.89166259765625,
-0.7438815832138062,
-0.23994401097297668,
-0.4008917212486267,
0.023325126618146896,
0.46272262930870056,
0.09984035789966583,
0.27132269740104675,
0.021478258073329926,
-0.25513970851898193,
-0.3587915003299713,
-0.495062917470932,
-0.28444868326187134,
0.4383353590965271,
0.148843914270401,
0.46102795004844666,
0.6458106637001038,
-0.2962942123413086,
0.9809588193893433,
-0.0209458339959383,
0.012400181964039803,
0.08520734310150146,
-0.424570769071579,
0.008458476513624191,
-0.3830539286136627,
0.7022149562835693,
0.2911929786205292,
-0.4689629077911377,
-0.41003134846687317,
-0.38851457834243774,
-0.1646493822336197,
0.2792209982872009,
-0.5755223631858826,
-0.1336146593093872,
-0.28634917736053467,
-0.5591558814048767,
-0.12222766131162643,
0.652459979057312,
-1.2548719644546509,
-0.5323531627655029,
-0.0032298159785568714,
0.21715599298477173,
-0.47402626276016235,
-0.2743827700614929,
-0.15261825919151306,
-0.6692889332771301,
0.502358615398407,
0.32925838232040405,
-1.0832464694976807,
0.08447905629873276,
0.789339542388916,
0.8341338634490967,
0.09058079123497009,
0.10409943014383316,
-0.20857320725917816,
0.1985103338956833,
-0.2500303387641907,
0.8082271218299866,
-0.7615325450897217,
-1.1799849271774292,
0.1725560873746872,
0.05487741529941559,
-0.25148385763168335,
-0.7432084679603577,
0.6323974132537842,
-0.8499041795730591,
0.25233063101768494,
-0.34688282012939453,
-0.5220716595649719,
-0.19317786395549774,
0.37819045782089233,
-0.8317128419876099,
1.0503151416778564,
0.4017043113708496,
-0.6890947222709656,
0.40939638018608093,
-0.5306060314178467,
-0.2304232120513916,
0.622282862663269,
-0.6386286020278931,
-0.20306561887264252,
0.34008559584617615,
-0.02199356071650982,
0.11726594716310501,
-0.6472916007041931,
0.26352956891059875,
0.09400174766778946,
-0.2626965045928955,
-0.35533440113067627,
-0.3040210008621216,
0.2694736123085022,
0.48562777042388916,
0.20248958468437195,
-0.12342116236686707,
-0.5938424468040466,
0.1723070740699768,
0.32926228642463684,
-0.3958163559436798,
-0.40132254362106323,
0.01689048856496811,
0.10926542431116104,
-0.13802698254585266,
0.33216363191604614,
-0.49835896492004395,
0.629073441028595,
0.3124856948852539,
0.2627497613430023,
0.3687843680381775,
0.11656993627548218,
0.47897157073020935,
-0.4888139069080353,
0.8336603045463562,
-0.35069915652275085,
0.13219989836215973,
-0.2837716042995453,
-0.5763751268386841,
-0.4783729314804077,
-0.09162351489067078,
0.4382493793964386,
0.2668699026107788,
-0.8491780757904053,
0.032676685601472855,
-0.5503426790237427,
-0.7679446339607239,
-0.49454614520072937,
-0.08874624967575073,
0.4185332655906677,
0.3572269678115845,
0.24388866126537323,
-0.19532431662082672,
-0.2246074080467224,
-0.4835974872112274,
-0.08635930716991425,
-0.5190880298614502,
-0.18287748098373413,
0.4951377511024475,
0.21033456921577454,
-0.1822870671749115,
0.7004685401916504,
-0.7682142853736877,
-0.3565175235271454,
-0.09738101065158844,
0.7824264168739319,
0.06209249421954155,
0.3220430016517639,
0.6045094132423401,
-1.3764183521270752,
-0.2585379183292389,
0.17683707177639008,
-0.9065150022506714,
0.19489574432373047,
0.17117929458618164,
-0.10875974595546722,
-0.10235694795846939,
0.6289384961128235,
-0.5744835138320923,
0.2760528028011322,
0.1710340827703476,
-0.16484633088111877,
0.2564070224761963,
-0.21948367357254028,
0.5843460559844971,
-0.724507749080658,
0.38554561138153076,
-0.09218115359544754,
0.1826208531856537,
-0.3141449987888336,
0.6379104852676392,
0.16460345685482025,
-0.31405168771743774,
0.08189797401428223,
0.28163793683052063,
-0.8531831502914429,
-0.15603739023208618,
0.13818815350532532,
-0.12644818425178528,
0.19777989387512207,
-0.11990046501159668,
-0.32324251532554626,
1.3066380023956299,
0.28187140822410583,
-0.4708806574344635,
0.2985309660434723,
0.4730823338031769,
-0.5041971206665039,
0.6118659377098083,
-0.4614851176738739,
0.2847132384777069,
-0.7910581827163696,
0.34355461597442627,
-0.8857676982879639,
-0.3389374017715454,
0.3420032560825348,
-0.4600483179092407,
0.4673203229904175,
-0.5987994074821472,
-0.7117092609405518,
-0.47017228603363037,
-0.294746994972229,
0.5553156137466431,
0.466959685087204,
-0.6115512847900391,
0.6940294504165649,
0.4065512418746948,
-0.29333463311195374,
-0.5116552114486694,
-0.4167369604110718,
0.18581059575080872,
-0.09966996312141418,
-0.3939538896083832,
0.7877459526062012,
-0.0655323937535286,
-0.08974643051624298,
0.007129768840968609,
-0.15395964682102203,
0.05770738422870636,
-0.15098421275615692,
-0.09658985584974289,
0.059336017817258835,
0.01483385544270277,
0.36848628520965576,
-0.27165740728378296,
0.01667785830795765,
-0.27934977412223816,
-0.26968300342559814,
0.609818160533905,
-0.04378463700413704,
-0.5984057188034058,
0.2715199589729309,
0.7405899167060852,
0.6605638861656189,
-0.4951690435409546,
0.3887988030910492,
0.6586160659790039,
-0.22184453904628754,
0.21232789754867554,
-0.6001356840133667,
0.1176098883152008,
-0.39675411581993103,
0.09029074758291245,
-0.6172118782997131,
-0.9048605561256409,
0.5297091603279114,
-0.22440636157989502,
-0.19974707067012787,
0.585654079914093,
0.21107038855552673,
-0.20954860746860504,
0.7386372685432434,
0.5471453666687012,
-0.07347847521305084,
0.5462042689323425,
-0.6145888566970825,
0.09316842257976532,
-1.0078470706939697,
-0.8449574112892151,
-0.8072109222412109,
0.05280960351228714,
-0.5446230173110962,
-0.6019795536994934,
0.5332480669021606,
0.27159029245376587,
0.20246116816997528,
0.010651343502104282,
-0.8064524531364441,
0.13194315135478973,
0.6154404282569885,
-0.050662118941545486,
0.2891700267791748,
-0.000588349939789623,
-0.1566922813653946,
0.27302736043930054,
-0.4584657549858093,
-0.30133411288261414,
1.0516128540039062,
-0.16602370142936707,
1.0562645196914673,
0.36248570680618286,
0.6419143080711365,
0.5744031071662903,
0.39559757709503174,
-0.6759097576141357,
0.5212683081626892,
-0.26292917132377625,
-0.5637151002883911,
-0.1497141718864441,
-0.4628838896751404,
-1.094202995300293,
0.4257470369338989,
0.02580047771334648,
-0.4442500174045563,
0.35648414492607117,
-0.22950851917266846,
-0.1571933478116989,
0.25355106592178345,
-0.6327186226844788,
0.6326959133148193,
-0.18296895921230316,
0.04244263470172882,
0.046754587441682816,
-0.6322941780090332,
-0.005113526247441769,
0.12896780669689178,
-0.17393165826797485,
0.03314094990491867,
0.08370816707611084,
0.6223520636558533,
0.036399636417627335,
0.2220514565706253,
-0.23748937249183655,
-0.013030964881181717,
0.37383562326431274,
-0.2733832597732544,
0.4672994315624237,
-0.042761314660310745,
-0.39773598313331604,
-0.011257564648985863,
0.08629287779331207,
-0.3410099446773529,
-0.8621096014976501,
0.6633188128471375,
-0.4847381114959717,
-0.792895495891571,
-0.5971452593803406,
-0.22369350492954254,
-0.0059221968986094,
0.3105110228061676,
0.6333065032958984,
0.42044395208358765,
-0.5202346444129944,
0.3113250732421875,
0.9003984332084656,
0.07515380531549454,
0.4457048773765564,
0.22396434843540192,
-0.19156643748283386,
-0.40160754323005676,
1.0904220342636108,
0.34580036997795105,
-0.07834740728139877,
0.7429847717285156,
-0.2554629147052765,
-0.4655646085739136,
-0.6210702061653137,
-0.5503538846969604,
0.07818672806024551,
-0.7288496494293213,
-0.17626279592514038,
-0.6715315580368042,
-0.24058905243873596,
-0.6730664968490601,
0.11816473305225372,
0.06888487190008163,
-0.12549757957458496,
-0.44703564047813416,
-0.21014009416103363,
0.16293589770793915,
0.7000238299369812,
0.3288143277168274,
0.15756455063819885,
-0.7958603501319885,
0.33539876341819763,
0.4927566945552826,
0.5367870330810547,
-0.08203282207250595,
-0.06442354619503021,
0.026080003008246422,
-0.4121760129928589,
-0.3617209494113922,
-0.8001901507377625,
0.3480505049228668,
0.3727456033229828,
0.924353301525116,
0.5688470602035522,
0.21146228909492493,
0.5229704976081848,
-0.3677559494972229,
0.6410998106002808,
0.03329500928521156,
-0.26568469405174255,
0.7125998735427856,
-0.6374375820159912,
0.13045193254947662,
0.9162181615829468,
0.721971869468689,
-0.5402997732162476,
0.1881842464208603,
-0.4408634901046753,
-0.9395440220832825,
0.23418375849723816,
0.03318267688155174,
0.16808271408081055,
-0.2624601125717163,
0.3578754961490631,
0.17696607112884521,
0.3076004981994629,
-0.13432946801185608,
-0.22374750673770905,
-0.005793461576104164,
-0.12155620008707047,
0.004207431338727474,
-0.46100911498069763,
-0.378681480884552,
0.0034302114509046078,
0.33311036229133606,
-0.2315995842218399,
0.8461093902587891,
0.19780611991882324,
-0.13784915208816528,
0.03536246716976166,
0.32811814546585083,
0.25839295983314514,
0.6619645953178406,
-0.5824686884880066,
0.08386726677417755,
-0.5499730706214905,
-0.6312850713729858,
0.2607523798942566,
0.49117764830589294,
-0.5073770880699158,
0.17131131887435913,
-0.10378900170326233,
0.5736307501792908,
-0.2675075829029083,
-0.37867486476898193,
0.4892216920852661,
-0.24401217699050903,
-0.1326272040605545,
-0.5386706590652466,
-0.11939579993486404,
-0.35713255405426025,
-0.0051545691676437855,
0.9037454128265381,
-0.24396349489688873,
0.4949891269207001,
-0.47855880856513977,
0.04839061200618744,
0.7842304110527039,
-0.39220502972602844,
-0.16827505826950073,
0.7181185483932495,
0.12541824579238892,
-0.2563934624195099,
0.8219332098960876,
-0.35291922092437744,
0.09874486923217773,
0.4488248825073242,
0.5808615684509277,
0.8067659735679626,
0.02886652573943138,
0.4066460430622101,
0.1655343621969223,
0.1030336320400238,
-0.21951298415660858,
0.298366904258728,
-0.3723847568035126,
-0.4541448652744293,
0.20871295034885406,
-0.5818008184432983,
-0.28401562571525574,
-0.04387279227375984,
-1.0474919080734253,
-0.06375149637460709,
-0.2857763171195984,
-0.5652561783790588,
0.02676337957382202,
-0.2508579194545746,
-0.4613739550113678,
0.1552967131137848,
-0.03420982509851456,
0.9580637216567993,
-0.46475788950920105,
0.42541906237602234,
1.0670667886734009,
-0.8325732350349426,
0.0747145488858223,
0.17716896533966064,
-0.04108182713389397,
-0.4786800444126129,
0.44692280888557434,
0.03841604292392731,
-0.05994602292776108,
0.3898977041244507,
-0.3322991132736206,
-0.7483024597167969,
1.412675380706787,
0.09347876906394958,
-0.1925409585237503,
-0.1916683465242386,
-0.006123689468950033,
0.481769859790802,
-0.005486477632075548,
0.5024012327194214,
0.29480165243148804,
0.4012671411037445,
0.2714085280895233,
-0.2878980338573456,
-0.22421739995479584,
-0.7310985922813416,
0.47793272137641907,
0.4915107786655426,
-0.7571001052856445,
0.5218342542648315,
-0.00033412600168958306,
-0.8376566767692566,
0.4833059012889862,
0.5042358040809631,
0.09171120822429657,
0.6663472056388855,
0.18925097584724426,
0.9800077080726624,
0.8936497569084167,
-0.5340783596038818,
1.4294596910476685,
-0.3739790916442871,
0.3816002905368805,
0.5330991744995117,
0.0846676230430603,
0.5148656368255615,
0.4368588626384735,
-0.3769370913505554,
0.21729114651679993,
0.6804521083831787,
-0.19271783530712128,
0.7232162356376648,
0.2602306008338928,
-0.9167559742927551,
0.05972546339035034,
-0.46704959869384766,
-0.7201661467552185,
0.05579996481537819,
0.6268852949142456,
-0.40297484397888184,
-0.3386419713497162,
0.10357675701379776,
-0.303197979927063,
0.049001000821590424,
-0.14295350015163422,
0.9445155262947083,
-0.2196052521467209,
-0.5362518429756165,
0.18714015185832977,
0.06977664679288864,
0.7272487878799438,
-0.6638188362121582,
-0.19032777845859528,
-0.49595895409584045,
-0.3874749541282654,
-0.06828057020902634,
-0.602742075920105,
0.030845116823911667,
-0.43294358253479004,
-0.482722669839859,
-0.3138396739959717,
0.7178733348846436,
-0.21731819212436676,
-0.37230822443962097,
0.21381115913391113,
0.5521217584609985,
0.011438393965363503,
0.061020102351903915,
-0.3930418789386749,
-0.2143954485654831,
-0.2561599314212799,
0.03415225073695183,
0.5826990008354187,
0.4215259850025177,
-0.04635574668645859,
0.6696052551269531,
0.6089673638343811,
-0.20834428071975708,
0.26192963123321533,
0.4562384784221649,
0.8798245191574097,
-0.8539710640907288,
-0.15310341119766235,
-0.28635790944099426,
0.1318342238664627,
-0.043686382472515106,
-0.21953214704990387,
0.6592333912849426,
0.6660027503967285,
1.0537892580032349,
-0.3053550124168396,
1.0493392944335938,
-0.4099741280078888,
0.2266605645418167,
-0.3413591682910919,
0.6232602000236511,
-0.4012393057346344,
0.010600986890494823,
-0.15044483542442322,
-0.9100711345672607,
-0.4813639521598816,
0.12313444912433624,
-0.026238296180963516,
-0.007580871693789959,
0.30808377265930176,
0.8582652807235718,
0.19293570518493652,
-0.09800465404987335,
0.3138938248157501,
-0.44529587030410767,
0.31282487511634827,
-0.03457494452595711,
1.0976592302322388,
-0.45096948742866516,
0.5728909373283386,
0.23864227533340454,
-0.10191293060779572,
-0.37543970346450806,
-0.35743433237075806,
-0.1320042461156845,
-0.8410723209381104,
-0.12890586256980896,
-0.009997846558690071,
0.40066906809806824,
0.43058088421821594,
0.38237014412879944,
-0.6237607002258301,
0.13054905831813812,
-0.2679038643836975,
0.10203314572572708,
-0.12026770412921906,
-0.2430877685546875,
0.2546951174736023,
-0.5506560206413269,
-0.8696107268333435,
0.38144513964653015,
0.2359684556722641,
0.2905629277229309,
0.002633104333654046,
0.10933686792850494,
-0.260127991437912,
-0.5331792235374451,
0.5506172180175781,
0.7687355279922485,
-0.5970645546913147,
-0.06806738674640656,
0.05689973011612892,
-0.36242759227752686,
0.13571731746196747,
1.0859822034835815,
-0.5314497947692871,
0.7561579346656799,
0.878688395023346,
0.9274919033050537,
0.6512766480445862,
0.46236419677734375,
0.40554293990135193,
-0.5961479544639587,
-0.2655330300331116,
0.23544470965862274,
0.009808509610593319,
0.3255685269832611,
-0.5926209092140198,
0.937199056148529,
0.524624764919281,
-0.4267486333847046,
-0.4829532206058502,
0.012254246510565281,
-0.9550620317459106,
0.06330125033855438,
0.9509625434875488,
-0.18823902308940887,
0.3293168842792511,
-0.05794382467865944,
0.04453631862998009,
0.05045405030250549,
-0.2526867091655731,
0.6996419429779053,
0.4551450312137604,
-0.09537242352962494,
-0.26121434569358826,
-0.5245054960250854,
0.25446197390556335,
0.06435208022594452,
-0.5881796479225159,
-0.2922319769859314,
0.6604226231575012,
-0.1326821744441986,
0.3560303747653961,
0.9024389386177063,
-0.6768166422843933,
-0.11675940454006195,
0.024474304169416428,
0.2413346916437149,
0.08578608930110931,
-0.3913519084453583,
-0.31728458404541016,
0.6330397129058838,
0.2165597826242447,
-0.2601134479045868
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.01179v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.01179v2
|
Are AI-Generated Text Detectors Robust to Adversarial Perturbations?
| 2024-06-03T10:21:48 | 2024-06-26T12:43:56 |
Guanhua Huang, Yuchen Zhang, Zhe Li, Yongjian You, Mingze Wang, Zhouwang Yang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The widespread use of large language models (LLMs) has sparked concerns about
the potential misuse of AI-generated text, as these models can produce content
that closely resembles human-generated text. Current detectors for AI-generated
text (AIGT) lack robustness against adversarial perturbations, with even minor
changes in characters or words causing a reversal in distinguishing between
human-created and AI-generated text. This paper investigates the robustness of
existing AIGT detection methods and introduces a novel detector, the Siamese
Calibrated Reconstruction Network (SCRN). The SCRN employs a reconstruction
network to add and remove noise from text, extracting a semantic representation
that is robust to local perturbations. We also propose a siamese calibration
technique to train the model to make equally confidence predictions under
different noise, which improves the model's robustness against adversarial
perturbations. Experiments on four publicly available datasets show that the
SCRN outperforms all baseline methods, achieving 6.5\%-18.25\% absolute
accuracy improvement over the best baseline method under adversarial attacks.
Moreover, it exhibits superior generalizability in cross-domain, cross-genre,
and mixed-source scenarios. The code is available at
\url{https://github.com/CarlanLark/Robust-AIGC-Detector}.
|
[
-0.26308563351631165,
-0.7811005711555481,
0.2108808308839798,
-0.3159710764884949,
-0.26506397128105164,
0.03993649408221245,
-0.3122359812259674,
-0.16317807137966156,
0.014830328524112701,
0.6369419097900391,
-0.23696301877498627,
-0.5368823409080505,
-0.6989010572433472,
0.2243233621120453,
-0.7308794260025024,
1.0562589168548584,
0.19537411630153656,
0.08161845058202744,
0.0661904364824295,
0.010072458535432816,
-0.1307889223098755,
-0.6520784497261047,
-0.6983229517936707,
-0.15390214323997498,
0.4048161804676056,
0.10726333409547806,
0.6899769306182861,
0.6911761164665222,
0.7037355303764343,
0.3179194927215576,
-0.17644943296909332,
0.264384925365448,
-0.49657994508743286,
0.5110794901847839,
0.3075163662433624,
-0.6086176037788391,
-0.3135809004306793,
-0.28459030389785767,
0.777469277381897,
-0.07518243789672852,
-0.07055719941854477,
-0.27075842022895813,
0.16064801812171936,
0.44184741377830505,
-0.6863194704055786,
-0.03895803540945053,
-1.193466067314148,
-0.222225159406662,
-0.2635544538497925,
-0.28199177980422974,
-0.4493970572948456,
-0.007513666525483131,
-0.15959744155406952,
-0.41801565885543823,
0.26359593868255615,
-0.26684650778770447,
0.9742794036865234,
0.6059874296188354,
-0.4643070697784424,
-0.4155503511428833,
-0.6341363787651062,
0.550886332988739,
-0.7351260781288147,
0.05625000596046448,
0.5625971555709839,
0.3504420518875122,
-0.4165900647640228,
-0.803770124912262,
-0.572809636592865,
-0.38270989060401917,
-0.07241342961788177,
0.16266155242919922,
-0.48601123690605164,
0.025415288284420967,
0.3585430383682251,
0.3574160039424896,
-0.7484318614006042,
0.1963755339384079,
0.04847478121519089,
-0.5766902565956116,
0.528500497341156,
0.12984390556812286,
0.4692702889442444,
-0.13877207040786743,
-0.3574760854244232,
-0.41081294417381287,
-0.9652164578437805,
-0.23280149698257446,
0.8982491493225098,
0.21386079490184784,
0.09539955109357834,
0.4992657005786896,
0.12699656188488007,
0.3804677426815033,
-0.02490225061774254,
0.05955597385764122,
-0.2538723349571228,
-0.3854238986968994,
-0.12994591891765594,
0.22529229521751404,
1.0307523012161255,
0.15034662187099457,
0.5229128003120422,
-0.07504985481500626,
-0.2928923964500427,
0.40717044472694397,
0.38401371240615845,
-0.7894434332847595,
-0.6915111541748047,
-0.3258630335330963,
-0.12868517637252808,
-0.7797374129295349,
0.06205864995718002,
-0.4362677335739136,
-0.6111593842506409,
0.08011356741189957,
0.22242842614650726,
-0.39647871255874634,
-0.09002538025379181,
0.01781778410077095,
0.16773143410682678,
-0.010455881245434284,
0.2423851042985916,
-0.5232956409454346,
-0.13175779581069946,
0.47711363434791565,
0.6451824903488159,
-0.06097739189863205,
-0.16564325988292694,
-0.6564276814460754,
-0.061701782047748566,
-0.23824557662010193,
0.8621616959571838,
-0.1571451872587204,
-0.4937717914581299,
-0.08285601437091827,
-0.12604080140590668,
0.09401588141918182,
-0.3805924355983734,
0.681603193283081,
-0.5706665515899658,
0.07417480647563934,
-0.04622523486614227,
-0.2800663709640503,
0.08632246404886246,
0.6434892416000366,
-0.7154863476753235,
0.763417661190033,
-0.27774733304977417,
-1.3538984060287476,
0.1753142923116684,
-0.12639518082141876,
-0.5092373490333557,
-0.11862368881702423,
-0.39265865087509155,
-0.8487493395805359,
-0.12654392421245575,
0.604046642780304,
0.25391194224357605,
0.0050462596118450165,
0.19579702615737915,
-0.35949015617370605,
-0.539870023727417,
0.4267660081386566,
-1.2282816171646118,
0.8065968751907349,
0.19411700963974,
-0.30029746890068054,
0.0946202427148819,
-0.904563844203949,
-0.17076170444488525,
0.19324921071529388,
-0.44445469975471497,
-0.3731754720211029,
0.041386522352695465,
-0.05114677548408508,
-0.21473930776119232,
0.06127552688121796,
-0.3909200429916382,
0.11869270354509354,
-0.46289491653442383,
0.48370227217674255,
0.9215205311775208,
0.05196093022823334,
0.23772190511226654,
-0.29466569423675537,
0.6077622771263123,
0.02420910634100437,
-0.46896469593048096,
-0.5358415246009827,
-0.14623644948005676,
-0.7693586349487305,
-0.3474774658679962,
0.3308948278427124,
0.4814884662628174,
-1.1972954273223877,
0.5515791773796082,
-0.3525771200656891,
-0.42809489369392395,
-0.1936376690864563,
-0.04485100507736206,
0.2889762818813324,
0.4165891408920288,
0.03828101605176926,
-0.227120503783226,
-0.5676801800727844,
-0.6573051810264587,
-0.49850350618362427,
-0.5198361277580261,
-0.2625995874404907,
0.2700810730457306,
0.5405014753341675,
-0.17914892733097076,
0.5748664140701294,
-0.18660274147987366,
-0.14697355031967163,
0.018472814932465553,
0.233960822224617,
-0.25303226709365845,
0.27707552909851074,
0.5462254285812378,
-0.8177793025970459,
-0.545086681842804,
-0.1093929260969162,
-0.7333903908729553,
-0.10097379237413406,
-0.1909913867712021,
0.08920881152153015,
0.1000666543841362,
0.5910382866859436,
-0.27117857336997986,
0.7392635941505432,
0.6016262173652649,
-0.22418498992919922,
0.772957980632782,
-0.2206215262413025,
0.1207287460565567,
-1.2394485473632812,
0.1622578352689743,
0.09141688793897629,
-0.5723124146461487,
-0.5830386877059937,
0.1202472597360611,
-0.056595705449581146,
-0.0018507539061829448,
-0.1892486810684204,
0.27795153856277466,
-0.1893126666545868,
-0.003332685912027955,
-0.5367467403411865,
0.1378173679113388,
0.05573143810033798,
0.13180331885814667,
-0.15925364196300507,
1.3136852979660034,
0.3200511634349823,
-0.4094529151916504,
0.3194811940193176,
0.16950136423110962,
-0.4116307497024536,
0.6996567249298096,
-0.6551187038421631,
0.2468593865633011,
-0.12613548338413239,
0.572426438331604,
-1.0242674350738525,
-0.22640739381313324,
0.25603678822517395,
-0.882827639579773,
0.40512359142303467,
-0.01905611716210842,
-0.5420462489128113,
-0.07929076999425888,
-0.28509587049484253,
0.2307966649532318,
-0.03651856631040573,
-0.6476945281028748,
0.5428601503372192,
0.19630487263202667,
0.03687280789017677,
-0.5838918089866638,
-1.0172008275985718,
0.5351120829582214,
-0.28319409489631653,
-0.5708123445510864,
-0.010104682296514511,
-0.054379381239414215,
-0.2350781410932541,
-0.09012845903635025,
0.10473321378231049,
0.05343436449766159,
0.3810187876224518,
0.1478937566280365,
0.28502941131591797,
-0.3978997468948364,
-0.06611365079879761,
-0.2982293665409088,
-0.21840961277484894,
0.08336642384529114,
-0.11139211058616638,
0.5495057106018066,
-0.11975250393152237,
-0.45626100897789,
-0.6517833471298218,
0.11306572705507278,
0.7724502086639404,
-0.20154345035552979,
0.3521476089954376,
0.916591227054596,
-0.5978127121925354,
0.01499003916978836,
-0.3090876042842865,
-0.39852437376976013,
-0.5200783610343933,
0.6340993642807007,
-0.3253210186958313,
-0.6272310018539429,
0.5074225664138794,
0.31744319200515747,
-0.2034962773323059,
0.455226331949234,
0.4687618911266327,
-0.05928432568907738,
1.3932178020477295,
0.3599280118942261,
-0.4670547544956207,
0.5877977013587952,
-0.24561218917369843,
0.15961524844169617,
-0.942528486251831,
0.2743004858493805,
-0.746326744556427,
-0.15945762395858765,
-0.8035117387771606,
0.03321201354265213,
0.35569247603416443,
-0.10030797123908997,
-0.6441545486450195,
0.44742265343666077,
-0.5932223200798035,
0.38724908232688904,
0.6300317645072937,
0.18059976398944855,
0.37284815311431885,
0.38280364871025085,
-0.08321505784988403,
-0.1630932092666626,
-0.5980650186538696,
-0.6791446805000305,
1.234117031097412,
0.2886498272418976,
1.0380100011825562,
-0.13056492805480957,
0.5313060283660889,
0.36620035767555237,
0.25606101751327515,
-0.5615208745002747,
0.5037986040115356,
-0.5166152715682983,
-0.33703139424324036,
0.05588795617222786,
-0.6024062037467957,
-0.871638834476471,
0.11326412856578827,
-0.3643621504306793,
-1.0071388483047485,
-0.09983426332473755,
0.07774025201797485,
-0.09913457930088043,
0.7864155173301697,
-0.3347032070159912,
0.296177476644516,
-0.23636683821678162,
-0.16736912727355957,
0.064935103058815,
-0.45031875371932983,
0.2589466869831085,
0.08386878669261932,
-0.12537236511707306,
0.1328522264957428,
0.30836573243141174,
0.40804988145828247,
-0.1986737996339798,
0.7649039626121521,
0.1405746340751648,
-0.31172093749046326,
0.37295275926589966,
0.3749717175960541,
0.8794136643409729,
0.1440441608428955,
-0.14718040823936462,
0.09578169882297516,
-0.2289058119058609,
-0.22162312269210815,
-0.42783457040786743,
0.9137711524963379,
-0.7353417277336121,
-0.5779333114624023,
-0.670615017414093,
-0.6065844893455505,
0.06945193558931351,
0.3053913712501526,
0.7777838110923767,
0.44815024733543396,
-0.1385548859834671,
0.3719053864479065,
0.510441243648529,
-0.14012545347213745,
0.2756211757659912,
0.12196037918329239,
0.16620221734046936,
-0.7341775298118591,
0.955011785030365,
-0.1649700254201889,
0.3111339211463928,
0.15357670187950134,
0.013277271762490273,
-0.1612057238817215,
-0.466962069272995,
-0.5865280628204346,
-0.08681251108646393,
-0.6436949372291565,
-0.5382285118103027,
-0.3993902802467346,
-0.6128522753715515,
-0.2677566111087799,
-0.3160799741744995,
-0.3027772605419159,
-0.16798274219036102,
-0.6386648416519165,
0.1506049782037735,
-0.04196697846055031,
0.6831352710723877,
0.1109771877527237,
0.4583624303340912,
-0.5545530915260315,
0.03894541785120964,
0.09988495707511902,
0.03758130967617035,
-0.09493250399827957,
-0.4409917891025543,
0.08837104588747025,
0.43289974331855774,
-0.3037928342819214,
-0.6106240749359131,
0.35366255044937134,
0.05236714705824852,
0.13725923001766205,
0.5059267282485962,
0.3236631751060486,
0.4012136161327362,
-0.14368349313735962,
0.8478055000305176,
0.13212113082408905,
-0.6150741577148438,
0.3567156493663788,
-0.538727343082428,
0.5385095477104187,
0.5237220525741577,
-0.11534872651100159,
-0.28809061646461487,
-0.6948575973510742,
-0.5131442546844482,
-0.6489976048469543,
0.4943588972091675,
0.3868873417377472,
0.1656375229358673,
0.23778733611106873,
0.5385040044784546,
-0.3045194149017334,
0.09508295357227325,
-0.7435658574104309,
-0.17000757157802582,
-0.27721652388572693,
-0.39773863554000854,
-0.12498245388269424,
-0.11274704337120056,
-0.054876357316970825,
0.35409530997276306,
0.6875637769699097,
-0.3420320749282837,
0.3406849205493927,
0.19104014337062836,
-0.036575112491846085,
-0.1088181808590889,
0.00688239885494113,
0.5517202615737915,
-0.018581172451376915,
0.053659290075302124,
0.4139101505279541,
0.024495398625731468,
-0.8104913830757141,
0.08295276015996933,
0.3111262619495392,
-0.5818102955818176,
-0.2044696807861328,
0.5935673713684082,
0.829643189907074,
-0.1724632978439331,
-0.42839938402175903,
0.6243250370025635,
-0.6480296850204468,
-0.12631343305110931,
-0.28819209337234497,
0.11865009367465973,
-0.41004514694213867,
0.18971030414104462,
0.28742483258247375,
0.32655981183052063,
0.0634705126285553,
-0.2050292044878006,
0.27394989132881165,
0.748319685459137,
-0.45903128385543823,
-0.3184409737586975,
0.9693116545677185,
-0.12818127870559692,
-0.34355294704437256,
0.6081447005271912,
0.0053728376515209675,
-1.1057692766189575,
0.7426384687423706,
0.7332642674446106,
0.8721497058868408,
0.004414621740579605,
0.053801652044057846,
0.29992571473121643,
0.5099684596061707,
0.17593424022197723,
-0.1013006642460823,
-0.07034062594175339,
-0.8544691801071167,
-0.04622483626008034,
-0.31559836864471436,
-0.24718162417411804,
0.3035186529159546,
-0.6283947229385376,
0.39616209268569946,
-0.32337436079978943,
-0.2160457819700241,
-0.20026862621307373,
0.10228947550058365,
-0.4449905753135681,
0.28421035408973694,
0.2614772617816925,
0.7051097750663757,
-0.6058311462402344,
0.7371459007263184,
0.7642116546630859,
-0.10311003029346466,
-0.6191108226776123,
0.5279877781867981,
0.28630614280700684,
-0.882691502571106,
0.13932496309280396,
0.23919892311096191,
-0.33009418845176697,
0.051067717373371124,
-0.6146297454833984,
-0.6417673826217651,
1.0004169940948486,
0.5699695348739624,
-0.32833370566368103,
-0.05819934234023094,
0.13425575196743011,
0.6448112726211548,
-0.011591823771595955,
0.2758423089981079,
0.3975856304168701,
0.30220869183540344,
0.14053773880004883,
-0.6357521414756775,
-0.009048400446772575,
-0.14990103244781494,
-0.011533746495842934,
0.13190516829490662,
-0.5520354509353638,
0.5980453491210938,
-0.01161206979304552,
-0.4738008677959442,
0.6306706666946411,
0.5580049157142639,
0.14805921912193298,
0.16379870474338531,
0.6404672265052795,
0.4915322959423065,
0.6602016091346741,
-0.34060001373291016,
0.994810938835144,
-0.4225473701953888,
0.2886175811290741,
0.993185818195343,
-0.014297435991466045,
0.6505107879638672,
0.26273858547210693,
-0.0170853640884161,
0.31030482053756714,
0.44480225443840027,
-0.030254190787672997,
0.3374316394329071,
0.18832559883594513,
-0.34139159321784973,
-0.2941853106021881,
-0.08530854433774948,
-0.34896403551101685,
0.8001424670219421,
0.39560115337371826,
-0.32864663004875183,
-0.23895575106143951,
0.02667415887117386,
0.1802365779876709,
0.3272037208080292,
-0.10467185825109482,
0.752879798412323,
-0.08830787241458893,
-0.6517934203147888,
0.5615923404693604,
-0.09859126061201096,
0.8245291709899902,
-0.5879988670349121,
0.16734424233436584,
-0.07245656847953796,
0.6171959638595581,
-0.0179844219237566,
-0.7183089256286621,
0.04800603911280632,
0.0676526352763176,
0.273529976606369,
0.15435805916786194,
1.262190580368042,
-0.5170687437057495,
-0.5129691362380981,
-0.0016022762283682823,
-0.06846883147954941,
-0.11244789510965347,
-0.04883996397256851,
-0.40048813819885254,
0.2594161033630371,
0.13323143124580383,
-0.22130565345287323,
0.34370696544647217,
0.17750100791454315,
0.17458368837833405,
0.6102034449577332,
0.699539840221405,
0.353262722492218,
0.0050907074473798275,
-0.17524750530719757,
0.8745660185813904,
-0.11170142143964767,
-0.4168294668197632,
-0.8162233233451843,
0.27922192215919495,
-0.08212132006883621,
-0.2505494952201843,
0.766154408454895,
0.38289114832878113,
0.8440812230110168,
0.5003804564476013,
0.9470580220222473,
0.32490074634552,
0.10006199032068253,
-0.41880181431770325,
1.0628259181976318,
-0.589610755443573,
0.5813454389572144,
-0.23084063827991486,
-0.6309027075767517,
-0.7170097827911377,
0.809103786945343,
-0.12775029242038727,
0.04568404331803322,
0.21613538265228271,
0.913536012172699,
0.02808142825961113,
0.15280404686927795,
0.29616594314575195,
0.2553892731666565,
0.8189026117324829,
0.32058796286582947,
0.7406154274940491,
-0.7547364234924316,
0.8500850200653076,
-0.19594570994377136,
0.03394996002316475,
-0.18435925245285034,
-0.9039417505264282,
-0.872083842754364,
-0.49962806701660156,
-0.24718941748142242,
-0.7894091010093689,
0.2772453725337982,
0.4173535108566284,
0.4367218613624573,
-0.8227232098579407,
0.13582995533943176,
-0.38381779193878174,
0.0228833369910717,
0.26837724447250366,
-0.23059412837028503,
0.5683615207672119,
-0.031351231038570404,
-0.7709816098213196,
0.3185865879058838,
0.15675531327724457,
0.3536355197429657,
-0.5565689206123352,
-0.012778550386428833,
-0.0955435037612915,
0.076282799243927,
0.088323675096035,
0.1891663819551468,
-0.554072380065918,
-0.49728891253471375,
0.04052865132689476,
-0.48594680428504944,
0.03470891714096069,
0.7753356695175171,
-0.6144124865531921,
0.7986316680908203,
0.40332549810409546,
0.8029289841651917,
0.39551910758018494,
0.059496745467185974,
0.5211042165756226,
-0.7688899040222168,
0.12701845169067383,
0.1729321926832199,
0.5004591941833496,
0.5420909523963928,
-0.6256989240646362,
0.2740905284881592,
0.12820664048194885,
-0.7953000068664551,
-1.0062172412872314,
0.344664603471756,
-0.3451349437236786,
-0.0037089535035192966,
1.2856245040893555,
-0.3813622295856476,
-0.11381594091653824,
0.2854194641113281,
-0.36292633414268494,
0.3802000880241394,
-0.24119068682193756,
0.8298174738883972,
0.7858895063400269,
0.3144380450248718,
0.11242450028657913,
-0.1012578159570694,
0.18971428275108337,
0.2778370976448059,
-0.5328298807144165,
0.023231737315654755,
0.38697996735572815,
0.15202248096466064,
0.056991416960954666,
0.3628286123275757,
-0.0211270060390234,
0.2275671809911728,
0.21708494424819946,
-0.4915115237236023,
-0.12451735138893127,
-0.38740044832229614,
-0.5136748552322388,
-0.03910359740257263,
0.09608177095651627,
-0.22464996576309204
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.01171v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.01171v2
|
Two Tales of Persona in LLMs: A Survey of Role-Playing and Personalization
| 2024-06-03T10:08:23 | 2024-06-26T09:37:48 |
Yu-Min Tseng, Yu-Chao Huang, Teng-Yun Hsiao, Wei-Lin Chen, Chao-Wei Huang, Yu Meng, Yun-Nung Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The concept of persona, originally adopted in dialogue literature, has
re-surged as a promising framework for tailoring large language models (LLMs)
to specific context (e.g., personalized search, LLM-as-a-judge). However, the
growing research on leveraging persona in LLMs is relatively disorganized and
lacks a systematic taxonomy. To close the gap, we present a comprehensive
survey to categorize the current state of the field. We identify two lines of
research, namely (1) LLM Role-Playing, where personas are assigned to LLMs, and
(2) LLM Personalization, where LLMs take care of user personas. Additionally,
we introduce existing methods for LLM personality evaluation. To the best of
our knowledge, we present the first survey for role-playing and personalization
in LLMs under the unified view of persona. We continuously maintain a paper
collection to foster future endeavors:
https://github.com/MiuLab/PersonaLLM-Survey
|
[
-0.4330492913722992,
-0.6378608345985413,
0.8073375225067139,
0.5044097304344177,
-0.07469944655895233,
0.3953218162059784,
-0.017504727467894554,
-0.4074391722679138,
0.49997323751449585,
0.8519324064254761,
-0.7320168614387512,
-0.404164582490921,
-0.4169251620769501,
-0.08661843836307526,
-0.12027008831501007,
0.7960203886032104,
0.4167303442955017,
0.35898807644844055,
-0.5896731019020081,
-0.15722185373306274,
-0.654233455657959,
-0.7584019899368286,
-0.753756582736969,
-0.40397197008132935,
0.9933494329452515,
0.24732846021652222,
0.08535736799240112,
0.18523631989955902,
0.42988327145576477,
0.3055926263332367,
-0.0984053760766983,
0.007154063321650028,
-0.45009908080101013,
0.5296633243560791,
-0.22842839360237122,
-0.5611512660980225,
-0.5096646547317505,
0.24064047634601593,
0.5236332416534424,
0.6784913539886475,
-0.03582419082522392,
0.3237539529800415,
-0.006165831815451384,
0.5798903107643127,
-0.45212000608444214,
0.11217635869979858,
-0.21536597609519958,
0.0009675087640061975,
-0.5620771050453186,
-0.43308568000793457,
-0.3396854102611542,
-0.35836756229400635,
0.22959835827350616,
-0.2992015480995178,
-0.13014093041419983,
0.2020069658756256,
0.050379443913698196,
-0.12686365842819214,
-0.8045910000801086,
-0.3469538390636444,
-0.9557872414588928,
0.7278576493263245,
-0.2653702199459076,
-0.01588178053498268,
0.3137086033821106,
0.5870780944824219,
0.07273565977811813,
-0.7042916417121887,
-0.15127156674861908,
-0.2295999825000763,
-0.15333694219589233,
0.24047985672950745,
-0.13390177488327026,
-0.1775645911693573,
-0.014807604253292084,
0.26368966698646545,
-0.5831205248832703,
0.5392129421234131,
-0.06498400866985321,
-0.18215876817703247,
0.7657544612884521,
0.437752366065979,
0.3550456762313843,
-0.039657045155763626,
-0.5544002056121826,
0.14565891027450562,
-0.8316636681556702,
0.38087648153305054,
0.5651593804359436,
-0.007641484960913658,
0.16354303061962128,
0.5468223094940186,
-0.034854188561439514,
0.4305872321128845,
0.06410638242959976,
-0.3664959967136383,
-0.24472995102405548,
-0.03803841397166252,
0.06316277384757996,
-0.021305343136191368,
0.857338011264801,
0.6069431900978088,
0.2038620561361313,
-0.2379380762577057,
-0.18309372663497925,
-0.23645643889904022,
0.2550009787082672,
-0.6228439807891846,
0.00043282221304252744,
0.1366550624370575,
-0.5537699460983276,
-0.4118293225765228,
0.07477490603923798,
-0.9524818658828735,
-1.0665358304977417,
-0.16785848140716553,
0.12322729080915451,
0.056732017546892166,
-0.15572446584701538,
-0.22197766602039337,
0.17219048738479614,
0.2848348021507263,
0.3861596882343292,
-0.9190208315849304,
0.49864938855171204,
0.9511098265647888,
0.6888965368270874,
-0.41343820095062256,
-0.26699650287628174,
-0.5677163600921631,
0.03309664502739906,
-0.19391827285289764,
1.0330277681350708,
-0.5923075079917908,
-0.6666651368141174,
0.33639729022979736,
-0.2503794729709625,
-0.01257536094635725,
-0.5395181775093079,
0.47000595927238464,
-0.5197601318359375,
0.443830281496048,
-0.6271449327468872,
-0.3899841606616974,
0.18914106488227844,
0.39397433400154114,
-0.31885555386543274,
0.862665593624115,
0.08888814598321915,
-0.6118308305740356,
0.30093106627464294,
-0.6159084439277649,
-0.22684580087661743,
0.23207353055477142,
-0.38450124859809875,
-0.0971168726682663,
0.20148499310016632,
-0.01728685200214386,
0.6152836084365845,
-0.646624743938446,
0.23231859505176544,
-0.20904679596424103,
-0.4934602379798889,
0.5404788255691528,
0.013269850984215736,
0.5780622959136963,
0.10571098327636719,
0.08106934279203415,
0.20074421167373657,
-0.37125715613365173,
-0.2492510974407196,
0.19315502047538757,
-0.23688369989395142,
-0.3660352826118469,
0.24652190506458282,
0.14842981100082397,
0.24151447415351868,
0.4665234386920929,
-0.5174312591552734,
0.3637414872646332,
-0.3171504735946655,
0.31231650710105896,
0.7261320352554321,
0.022911660373210907,
0.5438488721847534,
-0.5184822678565979,
0.6814112067222595,
-0.0721958726644516,
-0.05078960955142975,
-0.44106316566467285,
-0.45545297861099243,
-0.5211703777313232,
-0.20857354998588562,
0.18553388118743896,
0.5992253422737122,
-0.40368133783340454,
0.525258481502533,
-0.07859336584806442,
-0.5145564675331116,
-0.2531822919845581,
-0.10414595156908035,
0.4793813228607178,
0.36701446771621704,
-0.03891468420624733,
-0.5167287588119507,
-0.5771698355674744,
-1.0546971559524536,
-0.5675533413887024,
-0.5697166919708252,
-0.2896886467933655,
0.6801387071609497,
0.11176806688308716,
-0.3103310167789459,
0.9544801115989685,
-0.5596123337745667,
-0.6098345518112183,
-0.32824140787124634,
-0.055349428206682205,
-0.1600770503282547,
0.21620626747608185,
0.6876867413520813,
-0.5878652930259705,
-0.6412632465362549,
-0.21218422055244446,
-0.5795367956161499,
-0.3914426565170288,
0.04860078915953636,
0.06792158633470535,
-0.08679480105638504,
0.36754143238067627,
-0.5287132263183594,
0.1487765908241272,
0.35599803924560547,
-0.49015605449676514,
0.49788928031921387,
-0.09410319477319717,
0.21856778860092163,
-1.0192862749099731,
0.23413285613059998,
0.08734694123268127,
-0.3182010054588318,
-0.7273774147033691,
0.10547909885644913,
-0.3171592354774475,
0.1279871016740799,
-0.1478414237499237,
0.9403275847434998,
-0.37554940581321716,
-0.3230464458465576,
-0.2457359880208969,
0.3525036871433258,
-0.1224873811006546,
0.40063154697418213,
-0.1664060652256012,
0.6832244992256165,
0.6747646331787109,
-0.47127121686935425,
0.4700413942337036,
0.4756157398223877,
-0.33223193883895874,
0.8105388283729553,
-0.5243181586265564,
0.3280614912509918,
-0.17076672613620758,
0.49006253480911255,
-1.0866707563400269,
-0.4080820083618164,
0.3905125558376312,
-0.14435866475105286,
0.19589358568191528,
-0.36614394187927246,
-0.63222736120224,
-0.15044277906417847,
-0.4325181245803833,
0.1802286058664322,
0.6838423013687134,
-0.4727305769920349,
0.4219878315925598,
0.8388822078704834,
-0.6376125812530518,
-0.2961774170398712,
-0.6706955432891846,
0.1932714432477951,
-0.6240507364273071,
-0.44821521639823914,
0.45659977197647095,
-0.3905210793018341,
-0.5893371105194092,
-0.661013126373291,
-0.19828103482723236,
-0.13055989146232605,
0.13718727231025696,
0.10984973609447479,
-0.05647194758057594,
-0.0849190354347229,
0.003765576984733343,
-0.09025954455137253,
-0.09875671565532684,
0.21759375929832458,
0.12800276279449463,
0.8151645064353943,
-0.1722629964351654,
-0.4154518246650696,
-0.20802482962608337,
0.38890254497528076,
0.5227513313293457,
-0.3697337806224823,
0.40881025791168213,
0.44937294721603394,
-0.024006864055991173,
0.10055854171514511,
-0.873909056186676,
-0.07258550077676773,
-0.4185658395290375,
0.11880946159362793,
-0.23753774166107178,
-1.2245770692825317,
0.6990011930465698,
-0.3817819058895111,
0.12743285298347473,
0.04812387377023697,
0.574175238609314,
-0.5013932585716248,
0.8546328544616699,
0.757554292678833,
0.0467502661049366,
0.319941908121109,
0.19439001381397247,
0.2002578228712082,
-0.9977642297744751,
-0.6513518691062927,
-0.33824050426483154,
-0.5503224730491638,
-0.5994953513145447,
-0.2858465015888214,
0.25193825364112854,
-0.18299391865730286,
-0.04083145037293434,
0.1483060121536255,
-0.2080707997083664,
0.2794593870639801,
0.307345986366272,
-0.18311543762683868,
0.39641380310058594,
-0.23746967315673828,
0.052326004952192307,
-0.4502820074558258,
-0.3415008783340454,
-0.908757746219635,
0.8617411255836487,
0.5029399991035461,
0.5184947848320007,
0.5604730248451233,
0.8985143899917603,
0.2681211233139038,
0.4096114933490753,
-0.8587865233421326,
0.8103446960449219,
-0.06051725894212723,
-0.4430391490459442,
-0.251883327960968,
-0.18721690773963928,
-0.9880719780921936,
0.4830082654953003,
0.012358139269053936,
-1.1595450639724731,
-0.05556166172027588,
0.11022912710905075,
-0.44073331356048584,
0.11474309861660004,
-0.25899016857147217,
0.7912083864212036,
-0.3965621590614319,
-0.3361300528049469,
-0.0919109508395195,
-0.7425156235694885,
0.6604042053222656,
-0.12685440480709076,
0.1235063374042511,
-0.16639211773872375,
-0.3400978446006775,
0.618558406829834,
0.055763863027095795,
0.8119766712188721,
-0.33837634325027466,
-0.27255454659461975,
0.14465972781181335,
0.3417433798313141,
0.24718014895915985,
0.47380098700523376,
0.04834084212779999,
-0.24298560619354248,
0.31601765751838684,
-0.13712729513645172,
-0.5778363347053528,
0.9790219068527222,
-0.42247647047042847,
-0.8014800548553467,
-0.7776077389717102,
-0.17905089259147644,
-0.6748514771461487,
0.05003466457128525,
0.09010503441095352,
0.1025170162320137,
-0.9543861746788025,
0.23279863595962524,
0.9381686449050903,
-0.349746435880661,
0.48226988315582275,
0.654894232749939,
-0.6810049414634705,
-0.10295242071151733,
0.7479212284088135,
-0.20369595289230347,
-0.30417707562446594,
0.5207108855247498,
0.22934576869010925,
-0.30738377571105957,
-0.41191884875297546,
-0.09714972227811813,
0.26857224106788635,
-0.28513145446777344,
0.09036768972873688,
-0.7031394243240356,
0.029423609375953674,
-0.397320955991745,
0.06947410851716995,
-0.2354411780834198,
-0.16430629789829254,
-0.2910395860671997,
0.1717681586742401,
-0.1267050951719284,
0.8992511630058289,
0.44581252336502075,
0.5583853125572205,
-0.5026701092720032,
0.21959158778190613,
0.6395967602729797,
0.3910618722438812,
-0.2857682704925537,
-0.3306524455547333,
0.10158996284008026,
-0.23732790350914001,
-0.2774416506290436,
-0.8370621800422668,
0.22288566827774048,
-0.018022261559963226,
0.763041615486145,
0.5618059635162354,
-0.1773913949728012,
0.4616602659225464,
-0.606722891330719,
0.983688235282898,
0.23188389837741852,
-0.515885591506958,
0.397257536649704,
-0.5794910788536072,
0.14766515791416168,
0.6639485359191895,
0.28513583540916443,
-1.083465576171875,
-0.0016702305292710662,
-0.47680017352104187,
-0.5901349186897278,
0.8351821303367615,
0.004407488275319338,
0.4498412609100342,
0.12895828485488892,
0.33128228783607483,
0.14177335798740387,
0.4898037612438202,
-0.5848416686058044,
-0.3610057830810547,
0.28935524821281433,
0.11894397437572479,
-0.3681993782520294,
-0.6708942651748657,
-0.27522870898246765,
-0.09858447313308716,
0.2243501991033554,
-0.13107305765151978,
0.48251277208328247,
-0.10754693299531937,
-0.1326574683189392,
0.00399044482037425,
0.38053664565086365,
0.44619351625442505,
0.7423936128616333,
-0.09332402795553207,
0.11058475077152252,
-0.16341190040111542,
-0.261282742023468,
0.003904669778421521,
-0.0898999348282814,
-0.20142218470573425,
-0.15774479508399963,
0.19579286873340607,
0.6380515694618225,
0.6606050729751587,
-0.8313276767730713,
0.7421876788139343,
-0.11397018283605576,
-0.10847430676221848,
-0.5963405966758728,
0.18727466464042664,
0.4122885763645172,
0.33569079637527466,
0.21456557512283325,
-0.11318039894104004,
0.14017164707183838,
-0.8247388601303101,
-0.082607202231884,
0.48179206252098083,
-0.2402288168668747,
-0.485027015209198,
0.6412671804428101,
0.3309084177017212,
-0.5881755948066711,
0.2199307680130005,
-0.14076842367649078,
-0.034013811498880386,
0.384941965341568,
0.3448323905467987,
0.979570746421814,
-0.25537699460983276,
0.4271717667579651,
-0.014441883191466331,
-0.0023871739394962788,
-0.10596577823162079,
-0.09117226302623749,
-0.05996698886156082,
-0.5431108474731445,
0.0006264715339057148,
-0.6468746066093445,
-0.5145527124404907,
0.2987271547317505,
-0.593987762928009,
0.15929771959781647,
-0.5474557280540466,
-0.07697242498397827,
-0.1623341292142868,
0.38214364647865295,
-0.46592649817466736,
-0.13478603959083557,
0.2584243416786194,
0.6706152558326721,
-0.5735885500907898,
0.6304786205291748,
1.052546501159668,
-0.25038403272628784,
0.08182163536548615,
0.22443687915802002,
0.22211776673793793,
-0.40869995951652527,
0.3869166672229767,
0.12864342331886292,
0.08292312920093536,
-0.03458872064948082,
-0.330539733171463,
-0.5357348918914795,
1.4896955490112305,
0.24508827924728394,
-0.5306559205055237,
-0.1868855059146881,
0.20753300189971924,
0.828159511089325,
-0.6770904660224915,
0.1571362316608429,
0.7716284990310669,
0.3978484272956848,
0.11543703079223633,
-0.7251120805740356,
-0.4335387349128723,
-0.10683472454547882,
0.2549266815185547,
-0.23403188586235046,
-1.0980257987976074,
0.5897367000579834,
0.13884010910987854,
0.04133753478527069,
0.4760337769985199,
0.5692059993743896,
0.6012206673622131,
0.7228935360908508,
0.42135295271873474,
0.03876222297549248,
0.6910657286643982,
-0.07901511341333389,
0.8216607570648193,
-0.1830117404460907,
0.06381909549236298,
1.138978362083435,
-0.7962899804115295,
0.5030044317245483,
0.4417724609375,
-0.22887255251407623,
0.3912310004234314,
0.8591283559799194,
0.02024509757757187,
0.37187132239341736,
0.27939361333847046,
-0.4378207325935364,
-0.3182985484600067,
0.005347720347344875,
0.011973808519542217,
0.5958523154258728,
0.22969751060009003,
-0.30272337794303894,
-0.2045484483242035,
-0.011555840261280537,
0.1820804923772812,
0.4777047038078308,
-0.14560994505882263,
0.8946338295936584,
0.1838887631893158,
-0.9126259088516235,
-0.5606892704963684,
0.32881900668144226,
0.8178148865699768,
-0.7993199825286865,
0.13550084829330444,
-0.4760240316390991,
-0.1893727034330368,
0.004670500755310059,
-0.7514488697052002,
-0.00906334724277258,
0.1851925551891327,
-0.13261283934116364,
-0.8601806163787842,
0.9687381386756897,
-0.3055119812488556,
-0.19697462022304535,
0.27574923634529114,
1.0281713008880615,
0.32705461978912354,
-0.0016355648403987288,
-0.49378928542137146,
-0.11082286387681961,
-0.2826473116874695,
-0.32674744725227356,
0.9491564631462097,
0.1235823780298233,
-0.13695989549160004,
0.781575083732605,
0.3254576027393341,
-0.19346044957637787,
-0.09934617578983307,
0.26088836789131165,
0.8179395198822021,
-0.6004663705825806,
-0.5136861205101013,
-0.7945173382759094,
0.5883685350418091,
-0.061128586530685425,
-0.5931810736656189,
0.9623687267303467,
0.896940290927887,
0.5887112021446228,
-0.2426566630601883,
0.7137569785118103,
-0.13638539612293243,
0.7308857440948486,
-0.21760676801204681,
0.7329889535903931,
-0.3938083350658417,
0.4994764029979706,
-0.3166390359401703,
-0.9739610552787781,
-0.08665673434734344,
0.3113945722579956,
-0.15249145030975342,
0.2452242076396942,
0.3839876353740692,
0.6607303619384766,
-0.0033411779440939426,
-0.21334362030029297,
0.5277892351150513,
0.08287618309259415,
0.21286062896251678,
0.14836832880973816,
1.1201205253601074,
-0.015063047409057617,
0.0760917216539383,
-0.19914346933364868,
-0.25183382630348206,
-0.48671048879623413,
-0.647234320640564,
-1.1548378467559814,
-0.7146033644676208,
-0.3064029812812805,
0.12754090130329132,
-0.21352995932102203,
0.7806029915809631,
0.4296424984931946,
-0.4325845539569855,
-0.5675621628761292,
0.179508239030838,
0.057211823761463165,
0.03267279639840126,
-0.14829157292842865,
-0.23562735319137573,
-0.24419069290161133,
-0.8448188304901123,
0.7307582497596741,
0.3095378875732422,
-0.22818249464035034,
-0.858924925327301,
-0.06323743611574173,
-0.12610286474227905,
0.2908577620983124,
0.9104213118553162,
0.38228121399879456,
-0.8770349621772766,
-0.04649209976196289,
0.3408467769622803,
-0.25336894392967224,
0.05587371066212654,
1.319569706916809,
-0.6782218217849731,
0.3338046371936798,
0.3849473297595978,
0.3210510015487671,
0.49391648173332214,
0.0378098264336586,
0.49287137389183044,
-0.9187387824058533,
-0.14879725873470306,
0.4621906876564026,
0.19641000032424927,
0.22934462130069733,
-0.46697863936424255,
0.5062761306762695,
0.17372210323810577,
-0.5697070956230164,
-0.8808223009109497,
0.4782683253288269,
-1.18377685546875,
-0.12114596366882324,
1.1766319274902344,
-0.11071766912937164,
0.17433878779411316,
-0.0016759383725002408,
-0.39406993985176086,
-0.1624622642993927,
-0.1529737412929535,
0.6350878477096558,
0.7921000719070435,
-0.5225832462310791,
-0.22873280942440033,
-0.5101792216300964,
0.5088014006614685,
0.14987468719482422,
-0.8235575556755066,
-0.13238918781280518,
0.5376896858215332,
0.4450487792491913,
0.11089606583118439,
0.9748274087905884,
-0.21636752784252167,
-0.02300284244120121,
-0.5226070880889893,
-0.19024184346199036,
-0.02105553448200226,
-0.3817729949951172,
-0.5526144504547119,
0.24058453738689423,
0.28907543420791626,
0.3217396140098572
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.01145v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.01145v1
|
Explore then Determine: A GNN-LLM Synergy Framework for Reasoning over Knowledge Graph
| 2024-06-03T09:38:28 | 2024-06-03T09:38:28 |
Guangyi Liu, Yongqi Zhang, Yong Li, Quanming Yao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The task of reasoning over Knowledge Graphs (KGs) poses a significant
challenge for Large Language Models (LLMs) due to the complex structure and
large amounts of irrelevant information. Existing LLM reasoning methods
overlook the importance of compositional learning on KG to supply with precise
knowledge. Besides, the fine-tuning and frequent interaction with LLMs incur
substantial time and resource costs. This paper focuses on the Question
Answering over Knowledge Graph (KGQA) task and proposes an
Explore-then-Determine (EtD) framework that synergizes LLMs with graph neural
networks (GNNs) for reasoning over KGs. The Explore stage employs a lightweight
GNN to explore promising candidates and relevant fine-grained knowledge to the
questions, while the Determine stage utilizes the explored information to
construct a knowledge-enhanced multiple-choice prompt, guiding a frozen LLM to
determine the final answer. Extensive experiments on three benchmark KGQA
datasets demonstrate that EtD achieves state-of-the-art performance and
generates faithful reasoning results.
|
[
-0.4891616106033325,
-0.9601718187332153,
0.8655570149421692,
-0.25933656096458435,
0.05802220478653908,
0.32990819215774536,
-0.34894853830337524,
-0.49527958035469055,
0.2044955939054489,
0.29101961851119995,
-0.6067467331886292,
-0.38966578245162964,
-0.6096144318580627,
-0.01258604135364294,
0.04345063865184784,
0.398330420255661,
-0.39707887172698975,
-0.08274506777524948,
-0.5118270516395569,
-0.10520882159471512,
-0.3418217599391937,
-0.1283138245344162,
-1.0390232801437378,
-0.5606346726417542,
0.6802703738212585,
0.4693984389305115,
0.7185699343681335,
0.22782373428344727,
0.08232951909303665,
0.4026249051094055,
-0.3690793514251709,
0.6674941182136536,
-0.39276641607284546,
0.3762596547603607,
-0.2643282115459442,
-0.5025507211685181,
-0.15716829895973206,
-0.23665975034236908,
0.36132553219795227,
0.8335526585578918,
0.21701695024967194,
0.2600458860397339,
-0.05452483147382736,
0.40552112460136414,
-0.464681476354599,
0.2749749422073364,
-0.5886094570159912,
-0.008467188104987144,
0.023412736132740974,
-0.030968299135565758,
-0.2701697051525116,
-0.22491341829299927,
0.39396336674690247,
-0.6367192268371582,
-0.18714815378189087,
0.23859860002994537,
0.5379091501235962,
-0.005081947892904282,
-0.5762468576431274,
-0.1444845348596573,
-0.4357108771800995,
0.502464771270752,
-0.41082844138145447,
0.6156669855117798,
0.2013978660106659,
0.4374532997608185,
-0.24029916524887085,
-1.152501106262207,
-0.7173894643783569,
-0.20284375548362732,
-0.20882998406887054,
0.05162376910448074,
-0.21154733002185822,
0.06415974348783493,
0.21464888751506805,
0.15341754257678986,
-0.6836431622505188,
0.04217906668782234,
-0.15363746881484985,
-0.483243465423584,
0.5545474886894226,
0.20441514253616333,
0.38777559995651245,
-0.22605296969413757,
-0.2227327525615692,
0.033495549112558365,
-0.5340089797973633,
0.26668235659599304,
0.17077332735061646,
0.22810520231723785,
0.187762051820755,
0.8997900485992432,
-0.5214995741844177,
0.8502536416053772,
-0.03564925491809845,
0.12200076878070831,
-0.031916294246912,
-0.3896801173686981,
-0.2775639593601227,
0.08235947787761688,
0.7143769860267639,
0.39389851689338684,
0.1753556728363037,
-0.4722108840942383,
0.047508034855127335,
0.05185014382004738,
0.0676896795630455,
-0.6985394954681396,
-0.2766161262989044,
0.40764376521110535,
-0.31194785237312317,
-0.047474414110183716,
-0.3690136671066284,
-0.47478407621383667,
-0.4483035206794739,
-0.3776879608631134,
0.681918740272522,
-0.3595488369464874,
-0.4188801944255829,
0.16363544762134552,
-0.23111340403556824,
-0.016251880675554276,
0.3515094220638275,
-0.6047726273536682,
0.08460494130849838,
0.639632523059845,
0.5522280931472778,
-0.060829516500234604,
-0.11842215061187744,
-0.39066383242607117,
0.024755876511335373,
-0.35843542218208313,
0.5991308689117432,
-0.6113119125366211,
-0.3010740280151367,
-0.2673729360103607,
-0.10315578430891037,
-0.2486822009086609,
-0.40100520849227905,
0.49059543013572693,
-1.0566898584365845,
0.34695762395858765,
-0.49518877267837524,
-0.6819260716438293,
-0.5518106818199158,
0.8507140278816223,
-0.5986505150794983,
1.0418559312820435,
0.4724399149417877,
-1.0617620944976807,
0.26357540488243103,
-0.5696069002151489,
-0.45232105255126953,
0.1268511265516281,
-0.370678186416626,
-0.096821129322052,
-0.4035624563694,
0.31157344579696655,
0.3052949905395508,
-0.45908012986183167,
0.3933163285255432,
-0.41549327969551086,
-0.023961907252669334,
0.23333795368671417,
-0.0016854068962857127,
0.7073192596435547,
0.19387918710708618,
-0.2199021577835083,
0.348776251077652,
-0.5534935593605042,
0.6713269352912903,
0.4174100458621979,
-0.36810147762298584,
-0.11854474246501923,
-0.032087378203868866,
-0.6664801836013794,
0.17199204862117767,
0.2325998693704605,
-0.6020359396934509,
0.11955790966749191,
-0.4135333299636841,
0.4867108464241028,
0.6653024554252625,
-0.13693179190158844,
0.44635871052742004,
-0.32246914505958557,
0.6914200782775879,
-0.24586835503578186,
-0.044940318912267685,
0.16991513967514038,
-0.5848230719566345,
-0.8668376803398132,
0.3719539940357208,
0.4278717339038849,
0.5681665539741516,
-1.3095272779464722,
0.11583995074033737,
-0.2781689465045929,
-0.37220001220703125,
-0.5653120875358582,
0.12532305717468262,
0.23954220116138458,
0.8493872880935669,
0.4118320643901825,
0.1162363663315773,
-0.46928003430366516,
-0.7338150143623352,
-0.14144474267959595,
-0.36837780475616455,
0.028715984895825386,
0.7180930376052856,
0.21208439767360687,
-0.057465940713882446,
1.0614933967590332,
-0.5421319007873535,
0.018276872113347054,
-0.6512097120285034,
-0.029677100479602814,
0.1369703710079193,
0.08234281092882156,
0.2773471176624298,
-0.9443349242210388,
-0.35311102867126465,
0.17741374671459198,
-0.742976725101471,
-0.017022650688886642,
0.2385641634464264,
-0.4989057779312134,
-0.2394368201494217,
0.6631808876991272,
-0.74432373046875,
0.048370953649282455,
0.349118709564209,
-0.4003986120223999,
0.4081380069255829,
-0.050456851720809937,
0.05472829192876816,
-0.9092811346054077,
0.07653118669986725,
-0.3639117181301117,
-0.16244558990001678,
-0.3942427337169647,
0.12016709893941879,
-0.020165065303444862,
0.055450189858675,
-0.06625160574913025,
0.7100722789764404,
-0.3374803960323334,
-0.1357114315032959,
-0.046815913170576096,
0.51127028465271,
0.3181823492050171,
0.40372371673583984,
-0.02659890614449978,
0.6280043721199036,
0.5062386989593506,
-0.43148162961006165,
0.5610536932945251,
0.23043128848075867,
-0.2994278073310852,
0.1730637103319168,
-0.48856639862060547,
0.2720009684562683,
-0.14481908082962036,
0.21456529200077057,
-1.1486341953277588,
-0.019859815016388893,
0.30360740423202515,
-0.4888363778591156,
0.3203580379486084,
-0.08550510555505753,
-0.6126607060432434,
-0.7673503160476685,
0.05942269042134285,
0.48183968663215637,
0.24267737567424774,
-0.639725387096405,
1.1395796537399292,
0.36447063088417053,
-0.26694315671920776,
-0.5763655304908752,
-0.3553279936313629,
-0.028754230588674545,
-0.03840983286499977,
-1.1212034225463867,
0.27085205912590027,
-0.13309496641159058,
-0.2862756848335266,
0.23638315498828888,
-0.1459227204322815,
0.2733508050441742,
0.3153693675994873,
-0.13766083121299744,
0.1409308761358261,
-0.3050783574581146,
0.10395653545856476,
0.05570465698838234,
-0.24137018620967865,
0.2982809841632843,
-0.7291547060012817,
0.6972495913505554,
-0.0270929504185915,
-0.44353654980659485,
0.0915156900882721,
0.17323525249958038,
0.16905540227890015,
-0.256658136844635,
0.3630628287792206,
0.5724791884422302,
-0.2158752977848053,
-0.4524105489253998,
-0.3801114559173584,
-0.20323370397090912,
-0.4687686860561371,
0.32890668511390686,
-0.5350000858306885,
-1.2338932752609253,
0.5973027348518372,
-0.48406609892845154,
-0.3075866103172302,
0.47039374709129333,
0.37777161598205566,
-0.0011858083307743073,
1.0497710704803467,
0.20168718695640564,
0.08429361134767532,
-0.009234226308763027,
-0.47830629348754883,
0.31660231947898865,
-0.8437852263450623,
-0.6586717963218689,
-0.262508749961853,
-0.6057928204536438,
-0.35138383507728577,
-0.5247792601585388,
0.6042519807815552,
0.26619547605514526,
-0.08853064477443695,
0.04523111879825592,
-0.28478553891181946,
0.5946419835090637,
0.5262086987495422,
0.2961827218532562,
0.1579454243183136,
-0.39309510588645935,
-0.7907102704048157,
0.319009929895401,
-0.9506577849388123,
0.03289080411195755,
1.0781503915786743,
-0.0630163922905922,
0.4318958520889282,
0.1904696524143219,
0.49004560708999634,
-0.09689294546842575,
0.23944784700870514,
-0.6809970736503601,
0.8361313343048096,
0.10618124902248383,
-0.45847058296203613,
-0.4502730667591095,
-0.5942671895027161,
-0.927314043045044,
0.48124492168426514,
-0.09965679049491882,
-0.8925556540489197,
-0.16998691856861115,
-0.12461677193641663,
-0.37002357840538025,
0.504124104976654,
-0.6694764494895935,
0.9558799862861633,
-0.42348068952560425,
-0.3612142503261566,
-0.04468994587659836,
-0.911907434463501,
0.4240443706512451,
0.14262773096561432,
0.05540802329778671,
0.06936368346214294,
0.19591982662677765,
0.5633200407028198,
-0.3390773832798004,
0.5659497380256653,
-0.09750574827194214,
-0.005324046593159437,
0.6002481579780579,
0.38333654403686523,
0.6847867965698242,
0.015838202089071274,
-0.13516424596309662,
-0.36640286445617676,
-0.30515241622924805,
0.026144960895180702,
-0.9676907658576965,
0.6133727431297302,
-0.6058000922203064,
-0.7568086981773376,
0.06623200327157974,
-0.7072388529777527,
-0.49813440442085266,
0.4129472076892853,
0.06357961893081665,
0.4600584805011749,
0.07564356923103333,
-0.05670410394668579,
0.6346697211265564,
-0.05007757619023323,
0.33437782526016235,
0.42815539240837097,
-0.6047879457473755,
-0.4212820827960968,
0.7403901219367981,
0.23421989381313324,
0.48217397928237915,
0.442356139421463,
0.34785130620002747,
-0.682519793510437,
-0.45465347170829773,
-0.7592937350273132,
-0.14543649554252625,
-0.9980370402336121,
-0.19286523759365082,
-0.9327927231788635,
-0.3854987323284149,
-0.16336719691753387,
0.04628559574484825,
-0.07394857704639435,
-0.4813240170478821,
-0.10166902840137482,
-0.34979817271232605,
0.3437687158584595,
0.3708522617816925,
-0.018946463242173195,
-0.00458224443718791,
-0.5411537289619446,
0.42931342124938965,
0.5735787153244019,
0.1019873172044754,
0.22037772834300995,
-0.22488392889499664,
0.08443973958492279,
-0.0066324807703495026,
-0.2127540558576584,
-0.7040424942970276,
-0.03242968022823334,
-0.1144610196352005,
0.8282724022865295,
0.3760864734649658,
0.19165921211242676,
0.45108363032341003,
-0.15681785345077515,
0.5578954815864563,
0.08606282621622086,
-0.6869632005691528,
0.38377031683921814,
-0.19039805233478546,
0.1669122576713562,
0.4887442886829376,
0.5403133630752563,
-0.5255523324012756,
-0.2296651303768158,
-0.8727867007255554,
-0.8478167057037354,
0.6296144127845764,
0.08889314532279968,
-0.1893201470375061,
-0.02226829342544079,
0.23804177343845367,
-0.03427176550030708,
0.27408525347709656,
-0.4552628993988037,
-0.34070709347724915,
0.29890966415405273,
0.030450094491243362,
0.061618730425834656,
-0.12814541161060333,
-0.3206000328063965,
-0.29886820912361145,
0.4503428339958191,
-0.4688681960105896,
0.09039238095283508,
0.21034397184848785,
0.0548582561314106,
-0.11322843283414841,
0.3683151304721832,
0.040932297706604004,
0.7682068943977356,
0.009823200292885303,
0.6056264638900757,
0.3474522531032562,
0.04902929812669754,
0.052940767258405685,
0.36987945437431335,
-0.19497619569301605,
-0.3294472098350525,
0.32496213912963867,
0.7676217555999756,
0.18118590116500854,
-0.6166645884513855,
0.4702163636684418,
0.019837424159049988,
-0.18685083091259003,
0.0972796082496643,
0.28621044754981995,
0.5505644679069519,
0.6864154934883118,
0.07451580464839935,
0.038496606051921844,
0.07408902794122696,
-0.403469055891037,
0.2085132598876953,
0.6081084609031677,
-0.24730540812015533,
0.023876359686255455,
0.709699273109436,
-0.018796181306242943,
-0.10482653230428696,
0.7663103342056274,
-0.6982644200325012,
-1.0822564363479614,
0.8859726190567017,
0.49062037467956543,
0.5624388456344604,
0.07000374048948288,
0.4530635476112366,
0.23304292559623718,
0.13072308897972107,
0.15280678868293762,
0.826079785823822,
-0.1938798427581787,
-1.2492625713348389,
-0.7272204756736755,
-0.30909547209739685,
-0.17349164187908173,
0.09943350404500961,
-0.37208279967308044,
0.10038505494594574,
-0.248129740357399,
-0.14519651234149933,
-0.02578839845955372,
0.05770277604460716,
-0.6249425411224365,
0.27769526839256287,
0.2582123577594757,
0.9265212416648865,
-0.6050360202789307,
0.5597596764564514,
0.5084335207939148,
-0.1969514936208725,
-1.3015798330307007,
-0.2785066068172455,
-0.04604236036539078,
-1.0676356554031372,
0.84475177526474,
0.19861763715744019,
-0.07062361389398575,
0.3291161060333252,
-0.5283781886100769,
-0.8144141435623169,
1.3909815549850464,
0.3226340115070343,
-0.2924599349498749,
0.08960914611816406,
0.044389255344867706,
0.2746415436267853,
-0.2841409146785736,
0.617415726184845,
0.5762584805488586,
0.654483437538147,
0.6464961767196655,
-0.776468813419342,
0.21408937871456146,
-0.16473451256752014,
-0.32929423451423645,
0.2776937484741211,
-0.6993473172187805,
0.8114476203918457,
-0.7372563481330872,
-0.33196210861206055,
-0.09094660729169846,
0.6396844387054443,
0.4765929877758026,
0.4192570447921753,
0.6724424362182617,
0.8659584522247314,
1.0235978364944458,
-0.12584288418293,
1.0014392137527466,
-0.15776093304157257,
0.1671844720840454,
1.082617998123169,
-0.3710102140903473,
0.5608043670654297,
0.35105299949645996,
-0.282071590423584,
0.3942076861858368,
0.9405421614646912,
0.2876681387424469,
0.3926697373390198,
0.5061815977096558,
-0.2983083724975586,
-0.6742163896560669,
-0.3609098792076111,
-0.4145747721195221,
0.327237606048584,
0.25809013843536377,
-0.1722327023744583,
-0.5505341291427612,
-0.1644347906112671,
0.019220249727368355,
-0.19541870057582855,
-0.36956551671028137,
0.7444392442703247,
0.06699308007955551,
-0.8585737347602844,
0.23241300880908966,
0.07943642884492874,
0.0554339699447155,
-0.6163304448127747,
0.03580298274755478,
-0.07279479503631592,
-0.07792976498603821,
-0.07877954095602036,
-1.0720230340957642,
-0.1355716586112976,
-0.49500221014022827,
-0.11881661415100098,
-0.09691876173019409,
1.0483473539352417,
-0.5342056751251221,
-0.46258386969566345,
0.758082389831543,
0.9149179458618164,
-0.19426535069942474,
0.007840976119041443,
-0.6080909371376038,
-0.2511167824268341,
-0.003771236166357994,
-0.3086102604866028,
0.3253488838672638,
0.7209902405738831,
-0.061883777379989624,
0.9302281141281128,
0.6813595294952393,
-0.05649866908788681,
-0.03483763709664345,
0.30347132682800293,
1.3077538013458252,
-0.19717255234718323,
-0.6333391666412354,
-0.6749660968780518,
0.5475692749023438,
-0.052580825984478,
-0.008175748400390148,
0.5311068892478943,
0.6079602837562561,
0.8514081835746765,
0.353109210729599,
0.9193090796470642,
-0.36372944712638855,
0.36480069160461426,
-0.9336525201797485,
0.3829496204853058,
-0.5944289565086365,
0.12025253474712372,
0.022953176870942116,
-0.6615308523178101,
-0.14424867928028107,
0.3545342683792114,
-0.4905685782432556,
0.24694326519966125,
0.7457701563835144,
0.6992645263671875,
-0.08053917437791824,
0.4411267042160034,
0.02888965606689453,
0.21754160523414612,
0.22883309423923492,
0.7689613699913025,
1.195939302444458,
-0.10790178924798965,
0.5919865965843201,
-0.1885252296924591,
0.06314531713724136,
0.05335947126150131,
-0.8405789732933044,
-0.7485034465789795,
-0.3478063642978668,
-0.2163209468126297,
-0.533160924911499,
-0.31354767084121704,
0.80463707447052,
0.49207451939582825,
-0.5698991417884827,
0.19424310326576233,
-0.0869411826133728,
0.4919546842575073,
-0.13232292234897614,
-0.23810836672782898,
0.6143767237663269,
-0.2961536645889282,
-0.30894365906715393,
0.644453763961792,
0.03610628843307495,
-0.15011420845985413,
-0.1867171674966812,
-0.19994135200977325,
-0.2248462438583374,
-0.31203773617744446,
0.4313000440597534,
0.12675794959068298,
-0.5516616106033325,
-0.46171802282333374,
0.2818419635295868,
0.15558871626853943,
0.01991228386759758,
0.9651665091514587,
-0.852811336517334,
0.8637672662734985,
0.6938669085502625,
1.0376473665237427,
0.6208575963973999,
-0.08537901937961578,
0.4781235158443451,
-0.6871750354766846,
-0.16555263102054596,
0.1661008894443512,
0.41377609968185425,
0.09091217070817947,
-0.4123677909374237,
0.568709135055542,
0.20958757400512695,
-0.4694865345954895,
-0.3501476049423218,
0.2753969728946686,
-1.0717730522155762,
-0.36865127086639404,
1.1912388801574707,
-0.19926586747169495,
-0.06314712762832642,
-0.10787376016378403,
-0.2469012439250946,
0.22349847853183746,
0.01463182270526886,
0.36073896288871765,
0.7921266555786133,
-0.35904937982559204,
-0.19703054428100586,
-0.4518964886665344,
0.2905050814151764,
0.2761863172054291,
-0.7647468447685242,
-0.18612846732139587,
0.3407903015613556,
0.1379421204328537,
0.26778092980384827,
0.6519486904144287,
0.13827255368232727,
-0.041976217180490494,
-0.028202444314956665,
-0.34476640820503235,
-0.367917001247406,
-0.37894493341445923,
0.30341047048568726,
0.4604837894439697,
0.03272271156311035,
-0.07838856428861618
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.01126v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.01126v1
|
TCMBench: A Comprehensive Benchmark for Evaluating Large Language Models in Traditional Chinese Medicine
| 2024-06-03T09:11:13 | 2024-06-03T09:11:13 |
Wenjing Yue, Xiaoling Wang, Wei Zhu, Ming Guan, Huanran Zheng, Pengfei Wang, Changzhi Sun, Xin Ma
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large language models (LLMs) have performed remarkably well in various
natural language processing tasks by benchmarking, including in the Western
medical domain. However, the professional evaluation benchmarks for LLMs have
yet to be covered in the traditional Chinese medicine(TCM) domain, which has a
profound history and vast influence. To address this research gap, we introduce
TCM-Bench, an comprehensive benchmark for evaluating LLM performance in TCM. It
comprises the TCM-ED dataset, consisting of 5,473 questions sourced from the
TCM Licensing Exam (TCMLE), including 1,300 questions with authoritative
analysis. It covers the core components of TCMLE, including TCM basis and
clinical practice. To evaluate LLMs beyond accuracy of question answering, we
propose TCMScore, a metric tailored for evaluating the quality of answers
generated by LLMs for TCM related questions. It comprehensively considers the
consistency of TCM semantics and knowledge. After conducting comprehensive
experimental analyses from diverse perspectives, we can obtain the following
findings: (1) The unsatisfactory performance of LLMs on this benchmark
underscores their significant room for improvement in TCM. (2) Introducing
domain knowledge can enhance LLMs' performance. However, for in-domain models
like ZhongJing-TCM, the quality of generated analysis text has decreased, and
we hypothesize that their fine-tuning process affects the basic LLM
capabilities. (3) Traditional metrics for text generation quality like Rouge
and BertScore are susceptible to text length and surface semantic ambiguity,
while domain-specific metrics such as TCMScore can further supplement and
explain their evaluation results. These findings highlight the capabilities and
limitations of LLMs in the TCM and aim to provide a more profound assistance to
medical research.
|
[
0.028104182332754135,
-0.6287204027175903,
0.6916845440864563,
-0.051094673573970795,
-0.4252055585384369,
0.22574807703495026,
-0.6134833693504333,
-0.35570478439331055,
-0.1775028556585312,
0.4288278818130493,
-0.16491173207759857,
-0.7504855394363403,
-0.5324121713638306,
0.004861669614911079,
-0.13339348137378693,
0.7007026076316833,
-0.1653810292482376,
0.5124295353889465,
-0.15888187289237976,
0.024522148072719574,
-0.3742333650588989,
-0.4728791415691376,
-0.5209223031997681,
-0.5363084673881531,
0.4160296320915222,
0.25753676891326904,
0.3566979169845581,
0.6544265151023865,
0.7311102747917175,
0.17959026992321014,
-0.2930357754230499,
0.3741505444049835,
-0.5561099052429199,
0.15606018900871277,
-0.18100331723690033,
-0.3502921760082245,
-0.7239630222320557,
0.23382018506526947,
0.9484213590621948,
0.8686172366142273,
-0.2322038859128952,
0.15417999029159546,
0.2562377452850342,
0.5516649484634399,
-0.6548001170158386,
-0.21984870731830597,
-0.4716039299964905,
0.043242935091257095,
-0.2978229224681854,
-0.3401554524898529,
-0.3347538113594055,
-0.6271418333053589,
0.31129691004753113,
-0.23483489453792572,
0.19174155592918396,
0.050733812153339386,
0.9273610711097717,
-0.1327419877052307,
-0.5434568524360657,
-0.08784788846969604,
-0.48847073316574097,
0.8747165203094482,
-1.1821494102478027,
0.20284050703048706,
0.1471371203660965,
0.5112695097923279,
-0.31764426827430725,
-0.9518961310386658,
-0.39234012365341187,
-0.7349532842636108,
0.01581002026796341,
0.2432830035686493,
0.17368446290493011,
0.16600775718688965,
0.22424960136413574,
0.6748054027557373,
-0.647406280040741,
0.1811520755290985,
-0.24990205466747284,
-0.10140229016542435,
0.44784507155418396,
0.5449159145355225,
0.30449023842811584,
-0.22713401913642883,
-0.4278005361557007,
0.016509100794792175,
-0.720210611820221,
0.15828759968280792,
-0.27670562267303467,
0.08308839052915573,
0.09410817176103592,
0.36412766575813293,
-0.22819733619689941,
0.7275791168212891,
-0.08442168682813644,
-0.44121190905570984,
0.06284427642822266,
-0.27465349435806274,
-0.5036011338233948,
0.12412466108798981,
0.9249973893165588,
0.5458154678344727,
-0.024417100474238396,
-0.2762063145637512,
-0.17247870564460754,
-0.11996892839670181,
0.23426221311092377,
-0.9022378921508789,
-0.0328877717256546,
0.4505341947078705,
-0.5634486675262451,
-0.13922439515590668,
0.19247807562351227,
-0.4128890931606293,
-0.6038520932197571,
-0.1595747321844101,
0.1494448482990265,
-0.7086600065231323,
-0.36143410205841064,
0.07844407111406326,
-0.22971799969673157,
0.4148636758327484,
0.30066847801208496,
-0.5220122337341309,
0.5677377581596375,
1.1115894317626953,
1.1159855127334595,
-0.5431399941444397,
-0.35752373933792114,
-0.3844543397426605,
0.21884234249591827,
-0.6586224436759949,
0.8652363419532776,
-0.40053337812423706,
-0.33908945322036743,
-0.06820713728666306,
0.018800292164087296,
-0.12857912480831146,
-0.9432911276817322,
0.7753207683563232,
-0.09625086933374405,
0.010796393267810345,
-0.3749980330467224,
-0.7750165462493896,
-0.12876677513122559,
0.5823765993118286,
-0.3544733226299286,
0.8853585124015808,
0.210581436753273,
-0.6216844320297241,
0.33733972907066345,
-0.24165041744709015,
-0.2994301915168762,
0.16293206810951233,
-0.06085792928934097,
-0.2034541666507721,
0.24235188961029053,
-0.07406413555145264,
0.4547833204269409,
-1.0049890279769897,
0.6732524037361145,
-0.2900817394256592,
-0.528317391872406,
0.3651283085346222,
-0.23956982791423798,
0.7293413281440735,
0.2078557014465332,
-0.30596238374710083,
0.0789836049079895,
-0.5660670399665833,
0.42423492670059204,
-0.0009726581047289073,
-0.1464107185602188,
-0.38868919014930725,
0.09487602114677429,
-0.01541738398373127,
0.27164149284362793,
0.12368781119585037,
-0.5836251378059387,
-0.021833045408129692,
-0.3217785358428955,
0.6104652881622314,
0.6652004718780518,
-0.0046440791338682175,
-0.06212855875492096,
-0.63372802734375,
0.282736212015152,
0.10076077282428741,
-0.02135353535413742,
-0.09992852807044983,
-0.13272222876548767,
-0.6433334350585938,
-0.18431511521339417,
0.34730419516563416,
0.21322286128997803,
-0.488986611366272,
0.41620227694511414,
-0.3831668198108673,
-1.0016263723373413,
-0.46125179529190063,
-0.023160547018051147,
0.43437013030052185,
0.842443585395813,
0.23112228512763977,
-0.6164103746414185,
-0.05271870642900467,
-0.9006935954093933,
-0.348673552274704,
-0.11815916746854782,
-0.1675327867269516,
0.33247241377830505,
0.30504125356674194,
0.06629332154989243,
0.6243835687637329,
-0.407693088054657,
-0.3322516083717346,
-0.2760191559791565,
0.048082076013088226,
0.21760712563991547,
0.37312549352645874,
0.38491499423980713,
-0.3114704489707947,
-0.572149395942688,
0.21005268394947052,
-0.594173014163971,
-0.3456853926181793,
0.04215553030371666,
-0.18618404865264893,
0.09317976981401443,
0.131139874458313,
-0.39820802211761475,
-0.09664805978536606,
0.5347946286201477,
-0.05498989671468735,
0.8227851390838623,
-0.2592868208885193,
0.44045618176460266,
-0.9512673616409302,
0.40032872557640076,
0.13803313672542572,
-0.11155201494693756,
-0.7488507032394409,
0.17238545417785645,
0.4968439042568207,
0.1605175882577896,
-0.4328785538673401,
0.5496342182159424,
-0.48709389567375183,
0.12111669778823853,
-0.2868901193141937,
0.5721656680107117,
0.0037759062834084034,
0.2846527099609375,
0.20762693881988525,
0.5635776519775391,
0.5245455503463745,
-0.6168174147605896,
0.474772185087204,
-0.20882731676101685,
-0.6128612160682678,
0.8004485368728638,
-0.8264234066009521,
0.07635748386383057,
0.2441549003124237,
0.20335941016674042,
-0.9312804937362671,
-0.07194752246141434,
-0.09402567148208618,
-0.37387505173683167,
0.34240177273750305,
0.25424209237098694,
-0.5990375876426697,
-0.4213792383670807,
-0.5974187254905701,
0.16235867142677307,
0.42818683385849,
-0.34456682205200195,
0.19264890253543854,
0.3073473572731018,
0.022878799587488174,
-0.38465607166290283,
-0.5325992703437805,
0.25902634859085083,
-0.08297787606716156,
-0.6121631860733032,
0.42355456948280334,
-0.06216932088136673,
-0.18400165438652039,
-0.1459379941225052,
-0.2549873888492584,
-0.22214682400226593,
0.09479027986526489,
-0.02960740402340889,
0.310455858707428,
-0.6157416105270386,
0.17682482302188873,
-0.037078846246004105,
0.03412225469946861,
0.19676323235034943,
-0.13124336302280426,
0.5856087803840637,
0.006668824702501297,
-0.19936583936214447,
-0.4225486218929291,
-0.01029758621007204,
0.44624415040016174,
-0.2652130424976349,
0.4849380850791931,
0.24338778853416443,
-0.40744900703430176,
-0.34193214774131775,
-0.665873646736145,
-0.04236933961510658,
-0.41431301832199097,
0.48649126291275024,
-0.13014332950115204,
-0.7936309576034546,
0.19900579750537872,
-0.25189918279647827,
0.06692766398191452,
0.4760618209838867,
0.8429038524627686,
0.04097308591008186,
0.7247927188873291,
0.19999542832374573,
0.0018867586040869355,
0.09573013335466385,
-0.09479667246341705,
-0.05317455530166626,
-1.109675645828247,
-0.1811024397611618,
-0.5553065538406372,
-0.3312623202800751,
-0.5613828301429749,
-0.4220634996891022,
0.343879371881485,
-0.11521951109170914,
-0.368997722864151,
0.24027293920516968,
-0.5461897253990173,
0.19479519128799438,
0.42194294929504395,
0.29051506519317627,
0.47120994329452515,
-0.4077012240886688,
-0.2772863209247589,
-0.09841226786375046,
-0.6828157901763916,
-0.7252217531204224,
1.060524582862854,
0.2977788746356964,
0.6232431530952454,
-0.06218744441866875,
0.38549673557281494,
0.10036264359951019,
0.5583227276802063,
-0.8318375945091248,
0.6049201488494873,
-0.2907569408416748,
-0.5831639766693115,
-0.015641426667571068,
-0.639083743095398,
-0.7099904417991638,
0.30700206756591797,
-0.06816697120666504,
-0.6210804581642151,
-0.19901558756828308,
-0.14954985678195953,
-0.305531769990921,
0.46762117743492126,
-0.6001699566841125,
0.8906359076499939,
-0.49452680349349976,
-0.41726115345954895,
-0.2059621512889862,
-0.4313086271286011,
0.7563683986663818,
-0.2293274998664856,
-0.1777963489294052,
-0.3309905529022217,
-0.2820400297641754,
0.7633123993873596,
-0.41828256845474243,
0.5960098505020142,
0.0968613401055336,
-0.06334152072668076,
0.10300274193286896,
0.11320997029542923,
0.12077303975820541,
0.01622115634381771,
-0.3489864468574524,
0.21497629582881927,
0.45885688066482544,
-0.4188370406627655,
-0.43967634439468384,
0.897959291934967,
-0.673912763595581,
-0.7322492599487305,
-0.6994810700416565,
-0.34959498047828674,
-0.45815253257751465,
0.2857857048511505,
0.15451672673225403,
0.48239579796791077,
-0.5100401043891907,
0.2536405920982361,
0.43650880455970764,
-0.4582652449607849,
0.1546855866909027,
0.7891731858253479,
0.16011998057365417,
-0.43278905749320984,
0.5656855702400208,
0.2513967752456665,
0.45283541083335876,
0.38348305225372314,
0.4584285318851471,
-0.1382158398628235,
-0.7730981707572937,
-0.18086998164653778,
0.34801727533340454,
-0.509322464466095,
-0.22775335609912872,
-0.516353964805603,
-0.637669563293457,
-0.4183613359928131,
0.08334332704544067,
-0.29649510979652405,
-0.13507014513015747,
0.04024398326873779,
0.15423379838466644,
-0.008780986070632935,
0.5760759115219116,
0.22509710490703583,
0.23684555292129517,
-0.9001479148864746,
0.31431469321250916,
0.01800694689154625,
0.7269649505615234,
0.30841612815856934,
-0.6672707200050354,
-0.36122387647628784,
0.05022219568490982,
-0.5648123621940613,
-0.6752958297729492,
0.3257940709590912,
0.12057581543922424,
0.7898198366165161,
0.48601892590522766,
0.2414240837097168,
0.7258726954460144,
-0.5607561469078064,
1.0593879222869873,
0.2088618278503418,
-0.927881121635437,
0.4652699828147888,
-0.15357135236263275,
0.3973349332809448,
0.43578386306762695,
0.23192356526851654,
-1.0297261476516724,
-0.6694085597991943,
-0.41018566489219666,
-0.574596107006073,
0.7953384518623352,
-0.0036884043365716934,
0.024751834571361542,
-0.010628287680447102,
0.30937856435775757,
0.21570441126823425,
0.16000038385391235,
-0.3987864851951599,
-0.2523636817932129,
0.14825893938541412,
0.04530434310436249,
-0.1537788361310959,
-0.41283875703811646,
-0.027502184733748436,
-0.22564274072647095,
0.5522119402885437,
0.03790292143821716,
-0.022007308900356293,
0.3903515934944153,
-0.03971372917294502,
-0.2888500690460205,
0.36363160610198975,
0.5927432179450989,
1.0458003282546997,
-0.43159642815589905,
0.2399097979068756,
0.1972103863954544,
-0.6825554370880127,
-0.038704678416252136,
0.0035087373107671738,
0.013825288973748684,
0.033470652997493744,
0.5567936301231384,
0.3879689872264862,
0.03535471856594086,
-0.971301257610321,
0.36321306228637695,
0.052939318120479584,
-0.13123655319213867,
-0.08697343617677689,
0.20778267085552216,
0.09605854749679565,
-0.02013419009745121,
0.44325757026672363,
-0.4146413505077362,
0.14407846331596375,
-0.5860174894332886,
0.18848033249378204,
0.41998401284217834,
-0.6663323640823364,
-0.17932286858558655,
0.604962170124054,
0.027758726850152016,
-0.21336384117603302,
0.3811837434768677,
0.24446885287761688,
-0.49900850653648376,
0.7390461564064026,
0.43650850653648376,
0.9132468700408936,
-0.2491687834262848,
0.1393895447254181,
0.5294002890586853,
0.3343431055545807,
-0.3010869324207306,
-0.016645370051264763,
0.14359796047210693,
-0.3757384717464447,
-0.24837100505828857,
-0.3057185411453247,
-0.6356945037841797,
0.19096237421035767,
-0.5101463198661804,
0.47118857502937317,
-0.6113224029541016,
-0.2806588411331177,
-0.017912231385707855,
0.47896772623062134,
-0.2830275297164917,
0.32103899121284485,
0.10257598757743835,
1.1604663133621216,
-0.11356646567583084,
1.0144431591033936,
0.600317120552063,
-0.09518878161907196,
-0.6630793809890747,
0.1210721880197525,
0.05405464768409729,
-0.6903828978538513,
0.4024810791015625,
0.16234512627124786,
0.05888056382536888,
-0.3111417889595032,
-0.5029737949371338,
-0.4105047583580017,
1.4302747249603271,
0.2982027530670166,
-0.5992613434791565,
0.051467277109622955,
0.3114813566207886,
0.8346775770187378,
-0.28686293959617615,
0.6436555981636047,
0.8532127141952515,
0.30601614713668823,
0.08169841021299362,
-1.211525797843933,
0.27871406078338623,
-0.17442604899406433,
0.03580976650118828,
0.07427207380533218,
-0.9134573936462402,
0.8849999904632568,
-0.06772057712078094,
-0.3585173189640045,
0.34525975584983826,
0.24134279787540436,
0.4901812970638275,
0.43904849886894226,
0.1244133710861206,
0.2673250436782837,
0.7564690709114075,
-0.28269797563552856,
1.0470517873764038,
-0.47951364517211914,
0.3607611656188965,
1.0034106969833374,
-0.5063691139221191,
0.8478812575340271,
0.28276219964027405,
-0.12125969678163528,
0.194419726729393,
0.8899098634719849,
0.003223822917789221,
0.2632955312728882,
0.3986801505088806,
-0.059374332427978516,
-0.3057694137096405,
-0.31759512424468994,
-0.587610125541687,
0.16229833662509918,
0.17876078188419342,
-0.46241307258605957,
-0.2486254870891571,
-0.4426293969154358,
0.04152493551373482,
0.23148082196712494,
-0.2845827043056488,
0.6903673410415649,
0.45867085456848145,
-0.5591598153114319,
0.8159721493721008,
0.1540888398885727,
0.5341206789016724,
-0.8803308010101318,
0.07016508281230927,
-0.45976877212524414,
0.21391193568706512,
-0.09881427884101868,
-0.8411038517951965,
-0.05391368269920349,
0.025319747626781464,
0.20533396303653717,
0.0452437698841095,
0.565432071685791,
-0.2908357083797455,
-0.48160022497177124,
0.2720932960510254,
0.6014615297317505,
0.06942005455493927,
0.047266747802495956,
-0.4927199184894562,
-0.17566578090190887,
-0.32904770970344543,
-0.2815406918525696,
0.3172011077404022,
0.7845406532287598,
0.018463896587491035,
0.7782922983169556,
0.39416587352752686,
0.578098714351654,
-0.3382337987422943,
-0.09249678254127502,
0.8936794996261597,
-1.081675410270691,
-0.2631046175956726,
-0.9811621308326721,
0.1399805098772049,
-0.2597673535346985,
-0.47042158246040344,
0.727973461151123,
0.7304229140281677,
0.5838875770568848,
0.18961182236671448,
0.6661941409111023,
0.008234262466430664,
0.730171263217926,
-0.4216909408569336,
1.0446029901504517,
-0.7976768612861633,
0.33593541383743286,
-0.4247993528842926,
-0.8272437453269958,
-0.2949259579181671,
0.013009980320930481,
-0.43607771396636963,
-0.0441872663795948,
0.9677978157997131,
0.5470632314682007,
0.043474916368722916,
-0.08572986721992493,
0.5486546754837036,
0.3559550642967224,
0.3443357050418854,
0.9846978783607483,
0.9276328086853027,
-0.29967939853668213,
0.4349002540111542,
-0.38264575600624084,
-0.22066952288150787,
-0.03939184546470642,
-0.8029895424842834,
-1.0078215599060059,
-0.41712480783462524,
-0.15830668807029724,
-0.27834832668304443,
0.11403831094503403,
1.0205391645431519,
0.5430999994277954,
-0.8517003059387207,
-0.6140835285186768,
0.44889768958091736,
0.12251676619052887,
-0.5815293788909912,
-0.220065638422966,
0.6564707159996033,
-0.39031338691711426,
-0.7098004817962646,
-0.051671337336301804,
0.40299180150032043,
-0.30279046297073364,
-0.18066956102848053,
-0.09632696211338043,
0.042702171951532364,
0.010677799582481384,
0.5747761726379395,
-0.11574573814868927,
-0.7371149659156799,
-0.0888860672712326,
0.2763071358203888,
-0.7077513933181763,
0.32994362711906433,
1.078750491142273,
-0.553965151309967,
0.48153620958328247,
0.41349586844444275,
0.6044772267341614,
0.13674162328243256,
-0.09119340777397156,
0.7632637619972229,
-0.16674686968326569,
-0.1862930953502655,
0.4011560082435608,
0.2549110949039459,
0.21317943930625916,
-0.019057882949709892,
0.4933350682258606,
0.17885085940361023,
-0.470531702041626,
-0.9072420597076416,
-0.30021926760673523,
-1.1041698455810547,
-0.4330146908760071,
1.198603868484497,
-0.2020425647497177,
-0.33608514070510864,
-0.05091962218284607,
-0.45268332958221436,
0.25471386313438416,
-0.29524844884872437,
0.9965384006500244,
0.8305961489677429,
0.10371782630681992,
-0.28244748711586,
-0.7445208430290222,
0.43668994307518005,
0.3454590141773224,
-0.8040387630462646,
0.24855852127075195,
0.4145801067352295,
0.28565967082977295,
-0.20189660787582397,
0.744140088558197,
-0.2542960047721863,
0.5037958025932312,
-0.2589837610721588,
-0.1043010875582695,
-0.03322950005531311,
0.24366730451583862,
-0.0944434404373169,
0.12672051787376404,
0.35315898060798645,
0.08843501657247543
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.01124v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.01124v3
|
Latent Logic Tree Extraction for Event Sequence Explanation from LLMs
| 2024-06-03T09:10:42 | 2024-06-28T07:54:19 |
Zitao Song, Chao Yang, Chaojie Wang, Bo An, Shuang Li
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Modern high-stakes systems, such as healthcare or robotics, often generate
vast streaming event sequences. Our goal is to design an efficient,
plug-and-play tool to elicit logic tree-based explanations from Large Language
Models (LLMs) to provide customized insights into each observed event sequence.
Built on the temporal point process model for events, our method employs the
likelihood function as a score to evaluate generated logic trees. We propose an
amortized Expectation-Maximization (EM) learning framework and treat the logic
tree as latent variables. In the E-step, we evaluate the posterior distribution
over the latent logic trees using an LLM prior and the likelihood of the
observed event sequences. LLM provides a high-quality prior for the latent
logic trees, however, since the posterior is built over a discrete
combinatorial space, we cannot get the closed-form solution. We propose to
generate logic tree samples from the posterior using a learnable GFlowNet,
which is a diversity-seeking generator for structured discrete variables. The
M-step employs the generated logic rules to approximate marginalization over
the posterior, facilitating the learning of model parameters and refining the
tunable LLM prior parameters. In the online setting, our locally built,
lightweight model will iteratively extract the most relevant rules from LLMs
for each sequence using only a few iterations. Empirical demonstrations
showcase the promising performance and adaptability of our framework.
|
[
0.07255072146654129,
-0.9222236275672913,
0.9218224287033081,
-0.2547827661037445,
-0.40682703256607056,
0.037023842334747314,
0.07434917241334915,
-0.3299406170845032,
0.2288416624069214,
0.22888296842575073,
-0.919765055179596,
-0.5956565141677856,
-0.551324725151062,
-0.09654978662729263,
-0.29676783084869385,
1.0280706882476807,
0.08201241493225098,
-0.4561484158039093,
0.00016195095668081194,
0.20118053257465363,
0.20109054446220398,
-0.4377700686454773,
-0.8168291449546814,
-0.2894045114517212,
0.5361286997795105,
0.19155479967594147,
0.340817928314209,
0.5698001980781555,
0.4060807228088379,
0.20227636396884918,
-0.12163761258125305,
0.05700702592730522,
-0.32233646512031555,
0.07029525935649872,
-0.13789862394332886,
-0.4507627785205841,
-0.6823933720588684,
-0.04271275922656059,
0.46873509883880615,
0.5875939726829529,
-0.3601348102092743,
0.21123795211315155,
-0.1675412356853485,
0.3648732602596283,
-0.6824930906295776,
0.33092358708381653,
-0.8810522556304932,
0.3945540189743042,
-0.134221151471138,
-0.6636430621147156,
-0.4898667633533478,
-0.18528896570205688,
-0.08165457099676132,
-0.6500083804130554,
0.20587341487407684,
-0.013929587788879871,
0.7887389063835144,
0.16956105828285217,
-0.42596232891082764,
-0.005479777697473764,
-0.7517531514167786,
0.8294830322265625,
-0.6665374636650085,
0.11204309016466141,
0.005983226466923952,
0.48063623905181885,
-0.17935174703598022,
-0.7160027027130127,
-0.34963005781173706,
0.14581552147865295,
0.21032457053661346,
0.3248295485973358,
-0.30332207679748535,
0.2392258495092392,
0.3651203215122223,
0.262554407119751,
-0.6413924098014832,
0.05750315263867378,
-0.006749252788722515,
-0.0513123981654644,
0.6777002811431885,
0.38528311252593994,
0.08404751867055893,
-0.23248320817947388,
-0.054359070956707,
0.11333022266626358,
-0.7983474135398865,
0.19545066356658936,
0.42939990758895874,
0.16979126632213593,
-0.004573183599859476,
0.5149121880531311,
-0.18595534563064575,
0.6738089323043823,
-0.051919542253017426,
-0.3978849947452545,
0.18741004168987274,
-0.3274896442890167,
-0.4203561842441559,
-0.15115049481391907,
0.5715124607086182,
0.22641633450984955,
0.2183346301317215,
-0.06986457109451294,
-0.3174772560596466,
-0.23051945865154266,
-0.10594061017036438,
-0.9267078042030334,
-0.021387040615081787,
0.363192081451416,
-0.713428258895874,
-0.35719192028045654,
-0.028847305104136467,
-0.6776971817016602,
-0.1775258332490921,
-0.31920450925827026,
0.18677844107151031,
-0.2643517255783081,
-0.2569166123867035,
0.004466621205210686,
-0.12074824422597885,
0.3847450017929077,
0.6260905861854553,
-0.6830118894577026,
0.26435038447380066,
0.7136133313179016,
0.7554295063018799,
-0.200792133808136,
0.2627786695957184,
-1.136178731918335,
0.19263440370559692,
-0.11269588023424149,
0.5481829047203064,
-0.6117492318153381,
-0.046856995671987534,
-0.03913266584277153,
-0.019975630566477776,
-0.12781156599521637,
-0.4688670039176941,
0.5043947100639343,
-0.7446190118789673,
0.16735917329788208,
0.3668312430381775,
-0.7165540456771851,
-0.08274856954813004,
0.09754647314548492,
-0.29063111543655396,
0.5444313883781433,
-0.05629078298807144,
-0.8220470547676086,
0.5118119120597839,
-0.5894421339035034,
-0.4375280439853668,
0.19953499734401703,
-0.6443164944648743,
-0.45952650904655457,
0.28537288308143616,
0.4579503536224365,
0.6298099756240845,
-0.20773157477378845,
0.38788750767707825,
-0.4248414635658264,
0.016524769365787506,
0.011085756123065948,
-0.5744943618774414,
0.9053016304969788,
0.27497559785842896,
-0.261701762676239,
0.21831411123275757,
-0.8707196712493896,
-0.11176298558712006,
0.30156996846199036,
-0.41267502307891846,
0.0723617821931839,
0.7588552236557007,
-0.05824945494532585,
0.3709820806980133,
-0.048802562057971954,
-0.5867789387702942,
-0.031491007655858994,
-0.6401379108428955,
0.34257182478904724,
0.8410478830337524,
0.3343375027179718,
0.15047185122966766,
-0.22082921862602234,
0.764517068862915,
0.17212466895580292,
0.24024567008018494,
-0.4385058581829071,
-0.6220744848251343,
-0.21926386654376984,
-0.3424507677555084,
-0.12693935632705688,
0.7165359854698181,
-0.6306575536727905,
0.5831419825553894,
-0.2860390841960907,
-0.026939859613776207,
-0.14331912994384766,
0.08826958388090134,
-0.05475860834121704,
0.5703915953636169,
0.09622878581285477,
-0.10315506160259247,
-0.4944436252117157,
-0.6838260293006897,
-0.053315483033657074,
-0.3517426550388336,
-0.27137812972068787,
0.3125465214252472,
0.5195307731628418,
-0.005969256162643433,
1.144140601158142,
-0.44600486755371094,
-0.04146666079759598,
-0.25625354051589966,
0.038767945021390915,
0.6425117254257202,
0.18321993947029114,
0.29101917147636414,
-0.6049219369888306,
0.14340785145759583,
0.1312217116355896,
-0.6413486003875732,
-0.1468256711959839,
-0.26843810081481934,
0.08426469564437866,
0.2665060758590698,
0.6090986728668213,
-0.20636771619319916,
0.5427662134170532,
0.5520022511482239,
-0.5028465986251831,
0.5269427299499512,
-0.03545411303639412,
0.013340989127755165,
-1.1579951047897339,
-0.11288868635892868,
-0.04402425140142441,
-0.4190045893192291,
-0.18533281981945038,
-0.05926135927438736,
-0.26176589727401733,
0.04234238713979721,
-0.5623546838760376,
0.40017983317375183,
-0.23677434027194977,
-0.37378257513046265,
-0.09453713148832321,
0.22650262713432312,
0.02980375662446022,
0.4174092710018158,
0.14771150052547455,
0.059600602835416794,
0.3135763108730316,
-0.5588579773902893,
0.39559870958328247,
-0.3106882572174072,
-0.28968545794487,
0.39810845255851746,
-0.515435516834259,
-0.21724893152713776,
-0.09589975327253342,
0.17106936872005463,
-0.7054882645606995,
-0.08198682218790054,
0.17296606302261353,
-0.49044325947761536,
0.1328473687171936,
-0.5626879334449768,
-0.4529117941856384,
-0.21710357069969177,
-0.14300203323364258,
0.3275485038757324,
0.6302669048309326,
-0.6648907661437988,
0.9082951545715332,
0.277211993932724,
-0.28318142890930176,
-0.24929006397724152,
-0.4620545208454132,
-0.21886320412158966,
-0.2139848917722702,
-0.848587155342102,
0.31334611773490906,
0.014948109164834023,
-0.44012510776519775,
0.07652179151773453,
-0.16881325840950012,
0.09791882336139679,
0.48898473381996155,
0.317103773355484,
0.2115040272474289,
-0.4720411002635956,
0.16644084453582764,
0.2420511096715927,
-0.09203954041004181,
0.3180849254131317,
-0.7649133801460266,
0.1960957944393158,
-0.04006316885352135,
-0.8262684345245361,
-0.32982325553894043,
0.4428035020828247,
0.35834014415740967,
-0.11081715673208237,
0.6513596177101135,
0.5207018256187439,
-0.7128255367279053,
-0.21434006094932556,
-0.21340805292129517,
-0.2622119188308716,
-0.3729829788208008,
0.4909224212169647,
-0.36276566982269287,
-1.0278770923614502,
0.5178695917129517,
-0.17538057267665863,
0.3628671169281006,
0.7051199078559875,
0.6064771413803101,
-0.12201549112796783,
1.1870568990707397,
0.32517683506011963,
0.22002406418323517,
0.6619012355804443,
-0.02707715705037117,
0.07323520630598068,
-0.5241022109985352,
-0.1576659381389618,
-0.3918904662132263,
-0.12408710271120071,
-0.3701971471309662,
-0.5139063000679016,
0.3988751173019409,
0.1350962519645691,
-0.23841680586338043,
-0.32541272044181824,
-0.10493237525224686,
0.417214572429657,
0.3736191689968109,
-0.012113034725189209,
0.530363142490387,
0.2508910298347473,
-0.27094271779060364,
0.02107958123087883,
-0.8160573244094849,
-0.49159225821495056,
0.8708975911140442,
0.4198743402957916,
0.666297435760498,
0.14226621389389038,
0.9418771266937256,
0.12296919524669647,
0.20478485524654388,
-0.797764241695404,
0.3064134120941162,
0.023005615919828415,
-0.44399815797805786,
-0.2662227153778076,
-0.6736066341400146,
-1.0192586183547974,
0.30356815457344055,
-0.2518932819366455,
-1.2504950761795044,
0.03615415468811989,
0.09779467433691025,
-0.46562403440475464,
0.5451101064682007,
-0.4794909656047821,
0.7967510223388672,
-0.2134256213903427,
-0.3255942761898041,
-0.2549358308315277,
-0.49667367339134216,
0.46951767802238464,
-0.07203692942857742,
0.5551643371582031,
-0.2197389155626297,
-0.010215932503342628,
0.8421176671981812,
-0.5757256150245667,
0.8788918852806091,
-0.21609638631343842,
-0.04437261447310448,
0.365570068359375,
0.23102089762687683,
0.6393535733222961,
0.1985248476266861,
0.005019661039113998,
-0.15106956660747528,
-0.09071902185678482,
-0.38102707266807556,
-0.6133671998977661,
0.41013142466545105,
-0.6812487244606018,
-0.6034333109855652,
-0.27263906598091125,
-0.28890183568000793,
-0.03806573525071144,
-0.1975608766078949,
-0.0018820364493876696,
0.5900253653526306,
-0.12699510157108307,
0.11608576029539108,
0.5492587089538574,
-0.4087187945842743,
0.7700464129447937,
0.3876481354236603,
-0.3849360942840576,
-0.2581123113632202,
0.7617310285568237,
-0.13092683255672455,
0.2647741734981537,
0.7082623839378357,
0.34927356243133545,
-0.09552692621946335,
-0.6648826599121094,
-0.4008956253528595,
-0.06708414107561111,
-0.6389132142066956,
-0.029831763356924057,
-0.8080773949623108,
-0.27415838837623596,
-0.2382471263408661,
-0.23945988714694977,
-0.23130249977111816,
-0.6340795159339905,
-0.29984745383262634,
-0.33286505937576294,
0.39758917689323425,
0.5236803293228149,
-0.14270105957984924,
0.33770328760147095,
-0.9703935980796814,
0.197007417678833,
0.22683705389499664,
0.10313010215759277,
-0.14152011275291443,
-0.6916240453720093,
-0.08295778930187225,
-0.35803571343421936,
-0.35130053758621216,
-1.0405324697494507,
0.46908119320869446,
0.4200550615787506,
0.7905669212341309,
0.7191120386123657,
-0.10676079243421555,
0.28881558775901794,
-0.49171820282936096,
0.6459894776344299,
0.16095229983329773,
-0.8444004654884338,
1.0709022283554077,
-0.43286415934562683,
0.10938157886266708,
0.10236257314682007,
0.2506090998649597,
-0.3729269802570343,
-0.3709685504436493,
-1.073284387588501,
-1.173208475112915,
0.7920510768890381,
0.28224900364875793,
-0.3822060227394104,
0.005686261225491762,
0.43139851093292236,
-0.009703338146209717,
0.04112378507852554,
-0.797720193862915,
-0.20843149721622467,
0.20001445710659027,
-0.4411267340183258,
-0.06286682188510895,
0.013518773950636387,
-0.09456970542669296,
0.010570317506790161,
0.5726210474967957,
-0.303330659866333,
0.1733207255601883,
0.17729513347148895,
-0.20646315813064575,
-0.14791332185268402,
0.34078922867774963,
0.3428301513195038,
0.6572222709655762,
-0.2372579574584961,
0.19269032776355743,
-0.0006462406599894166,
-0.11482900381088257,
-0.04302703216671944,
0.25499236583709717,
-0.18325476348400116,
-0.08480752259492874,
0.6817731857299805,
0.649349570274353,
-0.013499259948730469,
-0.7229871153831482,
0.6129727959632874,
-0.14695824682712555,
-0.20851407945156097,
-0.2715248465538025,
0.03693203255534172,
0.172713041305542,
0.48215848207473755,
0.47765734791755676,
-0.2350470870733261,
0.20672161877155304,
-0.42499667406082153,
0.5037299394607544,
0.3759738802909851,
-0.18221721053123474,
-0.282275915145874,
0.6455528736114502,
0.15435068309307098,
-0.3115704655647278,
0.6139991879463196,
-0.4677722156047821,
-0.307466059923172,
0.8814980983734131,
0.44748353958129883,
0.8991369605064392,
0.16250362992286682,
0.2815793752670288,
0.3588617444038391,
0.4167633056640625,
0.46612873673439026,
0.3494061231613159,
-0.13094329833984375,
-0.6304384469985962,
-1.0116631984710693,
-0.9180880188941956,
-0.32701846957206726,
0.03575075790286064,
-0.43682345747947693,
0.10660234838724136,
-0.27407246828079224,
0.12074697762727737,
-0.05293311923742294,
-0.12264606356620789,
-0.7427070140838623,
0.1324036419391632,
0.3862171173095703,
0.6790770292282104,
-1.1378923654556274,
0.6992959976196289,
0.550786554813385,
-0.35154709219932556,
-0.8490855097770691,
-0.11857646703720093,
0.2710779905319214,
-0.7846306562423706,
0.5570999383926392,
-0.06636719405651093,
0.15892188251018524,
-0.05085933580994606,
-0.28136351704597473,
-0.7960399389266968,
1.1409269571304321,
0.38912200927734375,
-0.7119132280349731,
-0.02718183398246765,
-0.23142918944358826,
0.25411465764045715,
-0.6633796691894531,
0.6308227181434631,
0.3815321624279022,
0.1354750394821167,
0.40002861618995667,
-0.3759698271751404,
0.03637273237109184,
-0.16959866881370544,
-0.21604356169700623,
0.19931480288505554,
0.029029032215476036,
0.6752439737319946,
-0.3763892948627472,
-0.24029973149299622,
-0.3483230173587799,
0.697152316570282,
0.6155179738998413,
0.4662436544895172,
0.5487656593322754,
0.41382208466529846,
0.9051517844200134,
-0.042597655206918716,
1.158090591430664,
-0.09403598308563232,
0.31639379262924194,
1.1492035388946533,
-0.16637936234474182,
0.8335351943969727,
0.6237960457801819,
-0.19927002489566803,
0.5880225300788879,
0.9160356521606445,
0.4260715842247009,
0.29838308691978455,
0.5253986120223999,
-0.2888731360435486,
-0.5267757773399353,
0.020318711176514626,
-0.09788521379232407,
0.09643065929412842,
0.6652041077613831,
-0.47287896275520325,
-0.4723930060863495,
-0.12016098201274872,
-0.270362913608551,
-0.36962732672691345,
-0.48593008518218994,
0.6292320489883423,
0.15788447856903076,
-0.4077202379703522,
-0.08362212032079697,
-0.005079361144453287,
0.4204564690589905,
-0.43848296999931335,
-0.14058040082454681,
-0.06152505427598953,
0.16449065506458282,
-0.3266668915748596,
-0.5809894800186157,
0.47659751772880554,
-0.012203391641378403,
-0.15669631958007812,
-0.2722182869911194,
0.5615434050559998,
-0.17955893278121948,
-0.63062584400177,
0.47823309898376465,
0.9247971177101135,
0.35908305644989014,
-0.1190720647573471,
-0.6380491256713867,
-0.12580157816410065,
-0.08246897906064987,
-0.6125005483627319,
0.259843647480011,
0.6430888772010803,
-0.11597021669149399,
0.4169081747531891,
0.5035395622253418,
0.1825828105211258,
0.14156682789325714,
0.32802578806877136,
0.4614398777484894,
-0.5588861703872681,
-0.4081282317638397,
-1.0858025550842285,
0.5738579034805298,
0.014168843626976013,
-0.038167133927345276,
0.1510108858346939,
0.4285377264022827,
0.843046247959137,
0.15759895741939545,
0.7260554432868958,
-0.09203552454710007,
0.2046957015991211,
-0.7347332239151001,
0.25203248858451843,
-0.7802567481994629,
0.35261768102645874,
-0.19642312824726105,
-0.7144678831100464,
-0.29611310362815857,
0.5533551573753357,
-0.24815884232521057,
0.009238188154995441,
0.7881221175193787,
0.6597349643707275,
-0.05855323001742363,
0.03674328327178955,
0.499498575925827,
0.10043330490589142,
0.5382733941078186,
0.9221910834312439,
0.890211820602417,
-0.10126250982284546,
0.5725191235542297,
0.13152562081813812,
-0.5050891637802124,
-0.2621878683567047,
-1.2549166679382324,
-0.5624786019325256,
-0.4451844096183777,
-0.6669864058494568,
-0.2673276960849762,
0.20044279098510742,
1.1993722915649414,
0.7588701844215393,
-0.7790675759315491,
-0.11170828342437744,
-0.23808187246322632,
0.4678269922733307,
-0.15312126278877258,
-0.28841689229011536,
0.3159633278846741,
-0.40639013051986694,
-0.5007043480873108,
0.4909358322620392,
0.497987300157547,
-0.11222768574953079,
0.1880452185869217,
-0.015726381912827492,
-0.22553376853466034,
-0.012062443420290947,
0.6797558069229126,
0.09317565709352493,
-0.6689518094062805,
-0.3946582078933716,
-0.12513141334056854,
0.14945772290229797,
0.10277347266674042,
0.7998994588851929,
-0.7294979095458984,
0.20383107662200928,
0.539615273475647,
0.7839214205741882,
0.6599071621894836,
-0.28424009680747986,
0.669754147529602,
-0.8077976703643799,
-0.20429742336273193,
0.27956515550613403,
0.765450656414032,
-0.07539398223161697,
-0.2619215250015259,
0.49723634123802185,
0.6225534677505493,
-0.36329808831214905,
-0.35458797216415405,
0.42850711941719055,
-0.9905564188957214,
-0.19489425420761108,
1.2011228799819946,
-0.24385787546634674,
-0.374474436044693,
-0.08947915583848953,
0.1258394569158554,
0.31012213230133057,
-0.2944582402706146,
0.304126501083374,
0.4831998646259308,
-0.5149345397949219,
-0.19780030846595764,
-0.48192858695983887,
0.24502310156822205,
0.2280122935771942,
-1.006964921951294,
-0.22872985899448395,
0.605798065662384,
0.20007917284965515,
-0.11098574846982956,
0.7466044425964355,
-0.31318074464797974,
0.25077882409095764,
-0.056357476860284805,
0.12782606482505798,
0.17870524525642395,
-0.28643783926963806,
-0.624635636806488,
0.4653591513633728,
0.06683550775051117,
-0.07143045216798782
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.01096v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.01096v1
|
Synergizing Unsupervised and Supervised Learning: A Hybrid Approach for Accurate Natural Language Task Modeling
| 2024-06-03T08:31:35 | 2024-06-03T08:31:35 |
Wrick Talukdar, Anjanava Biswas
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
While supervised learning models have shown remarkable performance in various
natural language processing (NLP) tasks, their success heavily relies on the
availability of large-scale labeled datasets, which can be costly and
time-consuming to obtain. Conversely, unsupervised learning techniques can
leverage abundant unlabeled text data to learn rich representations, but they
do not directly optimize for specific NLP tasks. This paper presents a novel
hybrid approach that synergizes unsupervised and supervised learning to improve
the accuracy of NLP task modeling. While supervised models excel at specific
tasks, they rely on large labeled datasets. Unsupervised techniques can learn
rich representations from abundant unlabeled text but don't directly optimize
for tasks. Our methodology integrates an unsupervised module that learns
representations from unlabeled corpora (e.g., language models, word embeddings)
and a supervised module that leverages these representations to enhance
task-specific models. We evaluate our approach on text classification and named
entity recognition (NER), demonstrating consistent performance gains over
supervised baselines. For text classification, contextual word embeddings from
a language model pretrain a recurrent or transformer-based classifier. For NER,
word embeddings initialize a BiLSTM sequence labeler. By synergizing
techniques, our hybrid approach achieves SOTA results on benchmark datasets,
paving the way for more data-efficient and robust NLP systems.
|
[
0.055602848529815674,
-0.7279033064842224,
0.2606242895126343,
0.03443809598684311,
-0.23060578107833862,
0.4151375889778137,
-0.6096804738044739,
-0.3691273331642151,
0.18842713534832,
0.6057991981506348,
-0.43010446429252625,
-0.4776814579963684,
-0.5418311953544617,
0.08332665264606476,
-0.26981595158576965,
1.1234066486358643,
-0.046669214963912964,
0.27171212434768677,
-0.5855764150619507,
-0.22182892262935638,
-0.5869860649108887,
-0.4897893965244293,
-0.4329347014427185,
-0.6754921674728394,
0.08629953861236572,
0.19995005428791046,
0.37491291761398315,
0.1925385594367981,
0.25827378034591675,
0.3262069523334503,
0.16801580786705017,
0.38293957710266113,
-0.15432369709014893,
0.21781733632087708,
-0.48143208026885986,
-0.39443209767341614,
-0.2168017476797104,
-0.0803527981042862,
0.41913866996765137,
1.1206823587417603,
-0.16069892048835754,
0.09203509241342545,
0.3207889795303345,
0.3962585926055908,
-0.6287229657173157,
0.20609864592552185,
-0.5887064337730408,
-0.07615730911493301,
-0.30689501762390137,
-0.29148048162460327,
-0.4068200886249542,
0.29127776622772217,
0.2319626808166504,
-0.6897472143173218,
0.3012158274650574,
0.06032762676477432,
0.4309745132923126,
0.3312513828277588,
-0.5132126808166504,
-0.08691313117742538,
-0.8270924091339111,
1.065982460975647,
-0.5876526832580566,
0.5170716047286987,
0.17944996058940887,
-0.024413425475358963,
-0.2787340581417084,
-0.6855859756469727,
-0.5722814798355103,
-0.07746372371912003,
-0.23227941989898682,
0.29594886302948,
-0.2692945897579193,
0.20566487312316895,
0.19341960549354553,
0.3559173047542572,
-0.5277018547058105,
0.3639924228191376,
-0.04717109724879265,
-0.2284373790025711,
0.4770626723766327,
0.020995328202843666,
0.3773895800113678,
-0.12439791858196259,
-0.6661460399627686,
-0.1554252803325653,
-0.20483894646167755,
0.1849474459886551,
0.25174808502197266,
0.5547565221786499,
0.02814505808055401,
0.6724369525909424,
-0.344855397939682,
0.8808717131614685,
0.04856633022427559,
-0.1578376740217209,
0.2631226181983948,
-0.3766618072986603,
-0.29512226581573486,
0.020930102095007896,
0.8827752470970154,
0.1364196091890335,
-0.03157535195350647,
-0.6520399451255798,
-0.40863776206970215,
0.4837057590484619,
0.34211960434913635,
-0.3109016418457031,
-0.2751277983188629,
0.14289098978042603,
-0.26577261090278625,
-0.07935750484466553,
0.20926645398139954,
-0.7004963755607605,
-0.21422839164733887,
-0.5830199122428894,
0.5613934993743896,
-0.2833350896835327,
-0.17537467181682587,
0.2023160606622696,
-0.047092512249946594,
-0.35194188356399536,
0.011388794519007206,
-0.8552252650260925,
0.6542069911956787,
0.6310933828353882,
0.5215103030204773,
-0.45001542568206787,
-0.1784750521183014,
-0.6608797311782837,
0.26176854968070984,
0.04080840200185776,
0.6683733463287354,
-0.5851507186889648,
-0.04099405184388161,
-0.06836719810962677,
-0.09196195006370544,
-0.3761632442474365,
-0.6018738150596619,
0.4812663197517395,
-0.5123211145401001,
0.33049240708351135,
0.18785184621810913,
-0.764319658279419,
-0.2652779519557953,
0.13233211636543274,
-0.7725444436073303,
1.4473592042922974,
0.005660747643560171,
-1.123267412185669,
0.32874736189842224,
-0.7047948837280273,
-0.6627159118652344,
0.15600942075252533,
0.004817459266632795,
-0.3213615119457245,
0.1105632409453392,
0.29545068740844727,
0.7246236205101013,
-0.22351418435573578,
0.7021844387054443,
0.07199224084615707,
-0.1845080852508545,
-0.056275028735399246,
-0.0459749735891819,
0.626165509223938,
-0.14646513760089874,
-0.4048575460910797,
0.2789842188358307,
-0.8340743780136108,
-0.0746016874909401,
0.12277930974960327,
-0.42357462644577026,
-0.7298339009284973,
-0.05364660918712616,
0.34916430711746216,
0.006512111984193325,
0.4484386742115021,
-0.7807736992835999,
0.02171282283961773,
-0.6107892990112305,
0.20034950971603394,
0.2510978877544403,
-0.15269877016544342,
0.7431135773658752,
-0.09056995064020157,
0.3461604714393616,
-0.11560020595788956,
-0.26573967933654785,
-0.003017604583874345,
-0.3788515627384186,
-0.7818312048912048,
-0.03968911990523338,
0.5139020681381226,
0.6736433506011963,
-1.066794991493225,
0.8465909361839294,
-0.17494481801986694,
-0.44355353713035583,
-0.4153389632701874,
0.24214181303977966,
0.4713951051235199,
0.4241975247859955,
0.6217621564865112,
-0.372402161359787,
-0.7711424231529236,
-0.7473717927932739,
-0.5378247499465942,
0.1879013329744339,
-0.009842609986662865,
-0.2799643576145172,
0.5309149622917175,
-0.32537055015563965,
1.0184365510940552,
-0.20367632806301117,
-0.4716900587081909,
-0.6707741022109985,
0.5374553799629211,
0.07924658060073853,
0.5346810817718506,
-0.07751964032649994,
-0.9816477298736572,
-0.27653974294662476,
-0.016724154353141785,
-0.5411487817764282,
-0.08410019427537918,
-0.13740727305412292,
0.026727421209216118,
0.17056921124458313,
0.4082067608833313,
-0.536784827709198,
0.23794716596603394,
0.6599476933479309,
-0.11605139076709747,
0.43115946650505066,
-0.3793710768222809,
-0.25271475315093994,
-1.2798104286193848,
0.15388205647468567,
0.28545114398002625,
-0.31644415855407715,
-0.8139867782592773,
0.03144499659538269,
0.08196532726287842,
-0.05072649195790291,
-0.13948188722133636,
0.41581180691719055,
-0.6941947340965271,
-0.041858527809381485,
-0.40630292892456055,
0.005784479435533285,
-0.05030432716012001,
0.5566114783287048,
0.3022398054599762,
0.4396808445453644,
0.6803550124168396,
-0.4676167368888855,
0.5314908027648926,
0.13391649723052979,
-0.2715238332748413,
0.33703210949897766,
-0.45670342445373535,
0.014549147337675095,
-0.05350238084793091,
0.37292367219924927,
-0.5798691511154175,
-0.14184412360191345,
0.07446527481079102,
-0.087764210999012,
0.5571340322494507,
0.24798107147216797,
-0.9558785557746887,
-0.24602031707763672,
0.11379676312208176,
0.4054807424545288,
0.1920863389968872,
-0.6355108618736267,
0.7905335426330566,
0.6561343669891357,
0.06851796805858612,
-0.361483097076416,
-0.60216224193573,
0.07562801241874695,
0.10471408814191818,
-0.33541932702064514,
0.9687856435775757,
0.4031953811645508,
0.01998823881149292,
0.1354789435863495,
-0.3446005880832672,
0.005123141221702099,
-0.015050815418362617,
0.33430761098861694,
0.38749364018440247,
0.10029755532741547,
0.3288731873035431,
0.006827217526733875,
-0.3532237410545349,
-0.18161985278129578,
-0.4900064468383789,
0.5678260922431946,
0.08596079051494598,
-0.26074278354644775,
-0.33980923891067505,
0.4130347967147827,
0.14430762827396393,
-0.6090489029884338,
0.8200180530548096,
0.6452376842498779,
-0.7363052368164062,
-0.48191729187965393,
-0.4803175628185272,
-0.3707241714000702,
-0.3901180922985077,
0.23992446064949036,
-0.028876256197690964,
-1.0425901412963867,
0.027198880910873413,
-0.3070455491542816,
0.043074022978544235,
0.33149799704551697,
0.45022448897361755,
-0.020574185997247696,
0.8732829689979553,
0.9573174715042114,
-0.10002448409795761,
0.3514726161956787,
-0.25614842772483826,
0.6004652380943298,
-0.628662109375,
-0.5047906041145325,
-0.21305391192436218,
-0.35658079385757446,
-0.5106918215751648,
-0.6553038358688354,
0.20141087472438812,
0.03792209178209305,
0.26077571511268616,
0.6784851551055908,
-0.5060786604881287,
0.23750488460063934,
0.8237229585647583,
0.058682143688201904,
0.3906000256538391,
-0.040798842906951904,
-0.32038670778274536,
0.003691613208502531,
-0.8457037806510925,
-0.5105516314506531,
0.9538689851760864,
0.07460339367389679,
0.6114804148674011,
-0.4067727327346802,
0.8291090130805969,
0.039490122348070145,
-0.042777739465236664,
-0.5395663976669312,
0.6507012844085693,
-0.34882378578186035,
-0.47622618079185486,
-0.09364286065101624,
-0.4611203670501709,
-0.9714650511741638,
0.16565003991127014,
-0.7303879857063293,
-0.8988282084465027,
-0.11532324552536011,
0.11435627937316895,
-0.3248271644115448,
0.49313291907310486,
-0.5688890814781189,
1.0677087306976318,
-0.25940781831741333,
-0.14216995239257812,
-0.1849905401468277,
-0.6581796407699585,
0.19059516489505768,
-0.0911780446767807,
0.09850490093231201,
0.18266625702381134,
-0.06896907836198807,
1.090349793434143,
-0.21950148046016693,
0.9845556616783142,
-0.007658874616026878,
0.1639205366373062,
0.09198377281427383,
-0.09308149665594101,
0.617385745048523,
-0.21006597578525543,
0.22801212966442108,
0.011137450113892555,
-0.14902403950691223,
-0.3745616674423218,
-0.6482320427894592,
0.7322885990142822,
-0.3287043869495392,
-0.2768898010253906,
-0.44310900568962097,
-0.8226156234741211,
-0.5145494341850281,
0.0577472560107708,
0.3904706537723541,
0.4908151626586914,
-0.18574528396129608,
-0.04890194535255432,
0.631169319152832,
-0.1500071883201599,
0.36262282729148865,
0.326992928981781,
0.040033698081970215,
-0.08879895508289337,
0.9727250933647156,
-0.007170446682721376,
0.11696264892816544,
0.9238476157188416,
-0.1523120403289795,
-0.42267513275146484,
-0.5485804677009583,
-0.0762711614370346,
0.15460018813610077,
-0.42490848898887634,
-0.12936638295650482,
-0.9663605093955994,
-0.04070771858096123,
-0.4282890558242798,
0.061543893069028854,
-0.44684746861457825,
-0.33100438117980957,
-0.358818918466568,
-0.08271519094705582,
0.2310427725315094,
0.5703213214874268,
0.17012712359428406,
0.2611345648765564,
-0.6858547329902649,
0.41196581721305847,
0.1815415471792221,
0.16593220829963684,
-0.1779351532459259,
-0.171259805560112,
-0.32030409574508667,
-0.033874332904815674,
-0.12922245264053345,
-0.9848405718803406,
0.41725999116897583,
0.01270713284611702,
0.6549754738807678,
0.05831855535507202,
0.2678218185901642,
0.3691053092479706,
-0.3376571238040924,
0.464529812335968,
0.39625436067581177,
-0.908133327960968,
0.6362269520759583,
-0.1956070065498352,
0.267042875289917,
0.5355435013771057,
0.31310564279556274,
-0.3352409601211548,
-0.43927279114723206,
-0.7286252975463867,
-0.907439649105072,
0.6820427179336548,
0.1352510154247284,
-0.06347674131393433,
0.2182292342185974,
-0.16481736302375793,
0.3041841685771942,
0.22899742424488068,
-0.751151978969574,
-0.236674964427948,
0.11824842542409897,
-0.38405731320381165,
-0.30329588055610657,
0.035731278359889984,
0.15292766690254211,
-0.2178082913160324,
0.8315162062644958,
-0.122267946600914,
0.043530043214559555,
-0.06486988812685013,
-0.33525368571281433,
-0.0841800644993782,
0.39040708541870117,
-0.08528627455234528,
0.32795020937919617,
-0.02865944802761078,
0.27972137928009033,
0.17265841364860535,
-0.16532401740550995,
-0.03543046489357948,
0.5181344747543335,
-0.11536914110183716,
0.2710516154766083,
0.3345804214477539,
0.7572935223579407,
0.6928548216819763,
-0.8471022844314575,
0.5165877938270569,
0.20291879773139954,
0.1148129478096962,
0.06471405923366547,
-0.06096741929650307,
0.2412959635257721,
0.31986698508262634,
0.3035278022289276,
0.32781779766082764,
0.22222694754600525,
-0.4749641418457031,
0.2055080085992813,
0.4889577329158783,
-0.29107189178466797,
-0.34475943446159363,
0.67191481590271,
0.23106566071510315,
-0.1968938410282135,
0.3139267861843109,
-0.26941031217575073,
-0.699576735496521,
0.264840304851532,
0.7287883758544922,
0.5997914671897888,
-0.02398846298456192,
0.4502538740634918,
0.27130234241485596,
0.1264977604150772,
-0.39392247796058655,
0.04920080304145813,
-0.30302807688713074,
-0.7802302241325378,
-0.686069905757904,
-0.7710096836090088,
-0.3364057242870331,
0.14174799621105194,
-0.8261491656303406,
-0.0015026830369606614,
-0.239283949136734,
-0.1829429268836975,
0.22529201209545135,
0.10071874409914017,
-0.6676412224769592,
0.39239901304244995,
0.12160003185272217,
0.7475804686546326,
-1.0595823526382446,
0.848868191242218,
1.1820992231369019,
-0.1265936642885208,
-0.685188353061676,
-0.003501220140606165,
-0.13458795845508575,
-0.402321457862854,
0.6390928626060486,
0.39506176114082336,
0.16036169230937958,
0.1331542581319809,
-0.08391036838293076,
-0.6574726104736328,
0.8809587359428406,
0.2981998920440674,
-0.6448585987091064,
-0.0935441181063652,
0.13062423467636108,
0.6405978202819824,
-0.20248298346996307,
-0.14841081202030182,
0.4923580288887024,
0.15521962940692902,
-0.24368076026439667,
-0.9518270492553711,
0.08053320646286011,
-0.31476372480392456,
0.08403043448925018,
0.550499677658081,
-0.06689510494470596,
0.40052464604377747,
-0.12403113394975662,
-0.48270878195762634,
-0.06466010212898254,
0.8322787880897522,
0.20168441534042358,
0.4298464059829712,
0.6603726744651794,
0.9914443492889404,
0.685175895690918,
-0.18990153074264526,
0.9171141386032104,
-0.016158215701580048,
0.2626604735851288,
1.0793085098266602,
-0.31772562861442566,
0.8920195698738098,
0.6576404571533203,
-0.13685260713100433,
0.49471768736839294,
0.419749915599823,
-0.031311266124248505,
0.6133062243461609,
-0.07958980649709702,
-0.41276460886001587,
-0.4598110020160675,
-0.42031770944595337,
0.07355895638465881,
0.5079023241996765,
0.09003488719463348,
-0.21423093974590302,
-0.45783811807632446,
0.44690921902656555,
-0.22450707852840424,
0.547058641910553,
-0.14016348123550415,
0.6500643491744995,
0.05489635840058327,
-0.7939581871032715,
0.05976676940917969,
0.31943678855895996,
0.9830920100212097,
-0.3844050467014313,
0.017121605575084686,
0.3098198473453522,
0.2131866216659546,
-0.2265840619802475,
-0.5141505002975464,
0.1962577849626541,
0.08636026829481125,
-0.2016574889421463,
-0.5421265363693237,
0.9772840738296509,
-0.7551735639572144,
-0.5427210927009583,
0.5785754919052124,
0.4998382329940796,
-0.1774737685918808,
-0.13823410868644714,
-0.6829316020011902,
-0.3471742272377014,
-0.13053180277347565,
-0.06152821332216263,
0.4721828103065491,
0.1362655758857727,
-0.019157225266098976,
0.44011130928993225,
0.8238537907600403,
0.1114613264799118,
0.0026462103705853224,
0.11139204353094101,
0.8054335117340088,
-0.48488762974739075,
-0.5586514472961426,
-0.6217860579490662,
0.5892906785011292,
-0.1027769148349762,
-0.15117666125297546,
0.746993899345398,
0.6117637753486633,
1.1368467807769775,
-0.024903496727347374,
0.6964728236198425,
0.008394439704716206,
0.7311685085296631,
-0.6423357129096985,
0.22314175963401794,
-0.5490584969520569,
0.10345728695392609,
-0.18653321266174316,
-1.0442101955413818,
-0.37589243054389954,
0.4113779366016388,
-0.43905210494995117,
-0.03492728993296623,
0.6440291404724121,
0.6692687273025513,
-0.17423605918884277,
0.3247184753417969,
0.16149210929870605,
-0.137885183095932,
-0.2031632661819458,
0.5480825304985046,
0.6217178702354431,
-0.2933726906776428,
0.20122843980789185,
-0.7101063132286072,
-0.2573382258415222,
-0.03765098750591278,
-0.7545538544654846,
-1.0832077264785767,
-0.712302029132843,
-0.5394004583358765,
-0.019114334136247635,
0.1298624724149704,
0.9074137806892395,
0.6492672562599182,
-0.8855292201042175,
-0.09727021306753159,
-0.30668914318084717,
-0.19231455028057098,
-0.4595903754234314,
-0.25573989748954773,
0.35535895824432373,
-0.34765690565109253,
-0.7545092701911926,
0.6133168935775757,
0.4025517404079437,
-0.08327490836381912,
-0.09317333251237869,
0.17469309270381927,
-0.3874276280403137,
-0.37402090430259705,
0.3249968886375427,
0.2342313677072525,
-0.717361330986023,
0.30733615159988403,
-0.088164322078228,
-0.08877257257699966,
-0.32809391617774963,
0.7916388511657715,
-0.9880799651145935,
0.5409660935401917,
0.4512404203414917,
0.948716402053833,
0.39688780903816223,
-0.07009711116552353,
0.6209681034088135,
-0.9568581581115723,
0.09065018594264984,
0.41296279430389404,
0.47849905490875244,
0.5609626770019531,
-0.27574652433395386,
0.3302416205406189,
0.36834731698036194,
-0.31469789147377014,
-0.8284296989440918,
0.0509861595928669,
-1.1656458377838135,
-0.29710012674331665,
0.9037507176399231,
-0.01932743564248085,
-0.053632702678442,
-0.17646020650863647,
-0.01903456449508667,
0.6536572575569153,
-0.2032688558101654,
0.41460537910461426,
0.2913041114807129,
-0.043636489659547806,
0.05391055345535278,
-0.5038849115371704,
0.24185927212238312,
0.685834527015686,
-0.8122463822364807,
-0.07013079524040222,
0.15575870871543884,
0.04420991241931915,
0.36875119805336,
0.16887842118740082,
0.2411230057477951,
0.0034744313452392817,
-0.20553696155548096,
0.21028198301792145,
-0.07681967318058014,
-0.30262792110443115,
-0.11131632328033447,
0.08606275916099548,
-0.5576883554458618,
-0.31062671542167664
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.06566v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.06566v1
|
RAG Enabled Conversations about Household Electricity Monitoring
| 2024-06-03T07:44:32 | 2024-06-03T07:44:32 |
Carolina Fortuna, Vid Hanžel, Blaž Bertalanič
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
In this paper, we investigate the integration of Retrieval Augmented
Generation (RAG) with large language models (LLMs) such as ChatGPT, Gemini, and
Llama to enhance the accuracy and specificity of responses to complex questions
about electricity datasets. Recognizing the limitations of LLMs in generating
precise and contextually relevant answers due to their dependency on the
patterns in training data rather than factual understanding, we propose a
solution that leverages a specialized electricity knowledge graph. This
approach facilitates the retrieval of accurate, real-time data which is then
synthesized with the generative capabilities of LLMs. Our findings illustrate
that the RAG approach not only reduces the incidence of incorrect information
typically generated by LLMs but also significantly improves the quality of the
output by grounding responses in verifiable data. This paper details our
methodology, presents a comparative analysis of responses with and without RAG,
and discusses the implications of our findings for future applications of AI in
specialized sectors like energy data analysis.
|
[
-0.3679834306240082,
-0.787397563457489,
0.4757232964038849,
-0.07845770567655563,
0.06800469011068344,
0.5105754733085632,
-0.09325893968343735,
-0.511623740196228,
0.37003040313720703,
0.7467608451843262,
0.0006295570055954158,
-0.2732904255390167,
-0.3792225122451782,
0.032881319522857666,
-0.4997618496417999,
0.8100183010101318,
-0.03087615594267845,
-0.25771185755729675,
-0.19016408920288086,
-0.02598470449447632,
-0.2746310234069824,
-0.4107787609100342,
-0.5317969918251038,
-0.8626387715339661,
0.5127690434455872,
0.46133485436439514,
0.4696401059627533,
0.13943864405155182,
0.5260545015335083,
0.3341537117958069,
0.09640301018953323,
0.7812439203262329,
-0.5317809581756592,
0.27967923879623413,
-0.10069027543067932,
-0.577664315700531,
-0.6521360278129578,
0.11295223981142044,
0.35005825757980347,
0.5731936097145081,
-0.13228994607925415,
0.5526759624481201,
0.23350723087787628,
0.8099745512008667,
-0.6730793118476868,
0.3817736506462097,
-0.8985315561294556,
-0.07321474701166153,
0.024962875992059708,
-0.6382480263710022,
-0.548728346824646,
0.08075787127017975,
-0.1691282093524933,
-0.34655866026878357,
0.38738295435905457,
0.382565438747406,
1.1715452671051025,
0.47625333070755005,
-0.623012900352478,
-0.3739035129547119,
-1.1078712940216064,
0.7257816195487976,
-0.4557263255119324,
0.2641153931617737,
0.5710187554359436,
0.44750791788101196,
-0.0777047798037529,
-0.9858115315437317,
-0.47232264280319214,
-0.38329488039016724,
-0.5600353479385376,
0.3919498026371002,
0.03150850534439087,
-0.04182242974638939,
0.36700063943862915,
0.2755323052406311,
-0.08276718854904175,
-0.12338051199913025,
0.002124297898262739,
0.04848705977201462,
0.9178320169448853,
0.5959619879722595,
-0.1441735327243805,
-0.5773874521255493,
-0.10123787820339203,
0.24417050182819366,
-0.66486656665802,
-0.0667264312505722,
0.6527750492095947,
0.22619469463825226,
-0.1788196712732315,
0.7044358253479004,
0.14902479946613312,
0.776011049747467,
0.13414648175239563,
-0.09731592983007431,
0.11655093729496002,
-0.08610191941261292,
0.021145325154066086,
0.025041991844773293,
0.530402421951294,
0.2631532847881317,
0.24314981698989868,
-0.16390928626060486,
-0.1770780235528946,
-0.21778923273086548,
0.453657865524292,
-0.575258731842041,
-0.34019824862480164,
0.14487983286380768,
-0.345068097114563,
-0.39780393242836,
-0.03147241845726967,
-0.7699646353721619,
-0.7460101842880249,
-0.4911850094795227,
0.11212701350450516,
0.14812494814395905,
-0.42898961901664734,
-0.20583315193653107,
-0.14052210748195648,
0.22173967957496643,
0.04011506587266922,
-0.9378757476806641,
0.3680216372013092,
0.7852871417999268,
0.44240373373031616,
0.20287229120731354,
0.3594052195549011,
-0.48097726702690125,
0.2440037727355957,
-0.31700170040130615,
0.8538101315498352,
-0.4389519691467285,
-0.48802128434181213,
-0.16454842686653137,
-0.18545188009738922,
-0.022936727851629257,
-0.6281716227531433,
0.18566389381885529,
-0.8477242588996887,
-0.07201450318098068,
0.0270353052765131,
-0.48992258310317993,
0.03589773550629616,
0.4581419825553894,
-0.5000720024108887,
0.9355921149253845,
0.19243992865085602,
-1.3218430280685425,
0.15984651446342468,
-0.5264231562614441,
-0.23061154782772064,
-0.023265937343239784,
-0.09070342034101486,
-0.5710228681564331,
-0.2293231338262558,
0.10309918969869614,
0.5515144467353821,
-0.40686726570129395,
0.31801971793174744,
-0.0007480406202375889,
0.06518591940402985,
0.3488309681415558,
-0.5716000199317932,
0.38309091329574585,
0.46431970596313477,
-0.041448064148426056,
0.074339859187603,
-1.1746457815170288,
-0.23194345831871033,
0.18622536957263947,
-0.29523447155952454,
-0.5555983781814575,
0.3293432593345642,
-0.03918440267443657,
-0.3360286355018616,
0.5013636946678162,
-0.6626381874084473,
-0.09826384484767914,
-0.37813690304756165,
0.05616553872823715,
0.6357026100158691,
0.170603945851326,
0.210196852684021,
-0.5204663276672363,
0.5955896377563477,
-0.3633567988872528,
-0.17254647612571716,
-0.19530683755874634,
-0.45121127367019653,
-0.8817765116691589,
-0.05911113694310188,
0.3181750774383545,
0.804662823677063,
-0.8301995992660522,
0.417659729719162,
-0.3526972830295563,
-0.6392084360122681,
-0.3549095094203949,
0.12355770915746689,
0.2044547200202942,
0.9932610392570496,
0.26788175106048584,
0.2714637517929077,
-0.7694286108016968,
-0.5546441078186035,
-0.5598968267440796,
0.007963763549923897,
-0.4120440185070038,
0.8646275997161865,
0.0695003941655159,
-0.12074679136276245,
1.1667230129241943,
-0.8158560395240784,
0.08319050073623657,
-0.5215109586715698,
0.31502610445022583,
0.4353988766670227,
0.0851885974407196,
0.43476778268814087,
-1.0334773063659668,
-0.8839592933654785,
0.4634203016757965,
-0.8349397778511047,
-0.2496841996908188,
-0.15053081512451172,
0.18270789086818695,
-0.17818181216716766,
0.3777480721473694,
-0.2975212633609772,
0.3117319941520691,
0.5714699625968933,
-0.3051876723766327,
0.6763836145401001,
-0.06143506243824959,
0.25001662969589233,
-1.463127613067627,
0.2621394097805023,
-0.02415148913860321,
-0.5704503655433655,
-0.766774594783783,
-0.15814951062202454,
-0.07248172163963318,
-0.13373620808124542,
-0.26539677381515503,
0.6571530699729919,
-0.31895121932029724,
-0.1451086401939392,
-0.18492171168327332,
-0.11544812470674515,
0.1096079871058464,
0.3091508746147156,
-0.46892842650413513,
1.1829906702041626,
0.355422705411911,
-0.6781488656997681,
0.5773302316665649,
0.3899998366832733,
-0.23097729682922363,
0.37974873185157776,
-0.5067182183265686,
0.3676591217517853,
-0.21628332138061523,
0.016363579779863358,
-0.9741576910018921,
-0.5754432082176208,
0.027330195531249046,
-0.5128778219223022,
0.7321977615356445,
0.03238137066364288,
-0.4320700466632843,
-0.2689917981624603,
0.051943130791187286,
0.03434158116579056,
0.7531636953353882,
-0.7175616025924683,
1.0399037599563599,
0.7308796048164368,
-0.13030581176280975,
-0.5535427331924438,
-0.27601608633995056,
0.28865933418273926,
-0.3689419627189636,
-0.45737960934638977,
0.11357925087213516,
0.3299362063407898,
-0.7410987019538879,
-0.10637414455413818,
-0.07052657008171082,
0.05832786485552788,
0.14502128958702087,
0.1380382776260376,
0.17559847235679626,
0.13635164499282837,
0.270351380109787,
-0.30827030539512634,
-0.15771372616291046,
0.27946826815605164,
0.1920749545097351,
0.7082987427711487,
0.1656428426504135,
-0.3728872239589691,
-0.17337669432163239,
0.16998063027858734,
0.3338586390018463,
-0.1873016357421875,
0.5255390405654907,
0.3287786543369293,
-0.019838854670524597,
-0.2797155976295471,
-0.5410443544387817,
0.06979144364595413,
-0.5920316576957703,
-0.18082307279109955,
-0.2712254226207733,
-0.9528208374977112,
0.635727047920227,
-0.5050014853477478,
0.40144267678260803,
0.28608760237693787,
0.34861937165260315,
-0.4588487446308136,
1.1318607330322266,
0.4833794832229614,
0.0003565098450053483,
0.6281360983848572,
-0.4288751482963562,
0.5077045559883118,
-1.191793441772461,
-0.3564622402191162,
-0.7768729329109192,
-0.2358229160308838,
-0.7072705626487732,
-0.2751181423664093,
0.7318233847618103,
-0.2250799536705017,
-0.21247772872447968,
0.11391080170869827,
-0.4352068603038788,
0.017919989302754402,
0.017674950882792473,
0.31155651807785034,
0.27342531085014343,
0.04172283411026001,
0.43947920203208923,
0.009281935170292854,
-0.6323036551475525,
-0.5279621481895447,
1.1426819562911987,
0.19198209047317505,
1.043243408203125,
-0.1485707014799118,
0.5760051608085632,
0.46851855516433716,
0.8633040189743042,
-0.9109997153282166,
0.42762094736099243,
-0.3021545708179474,
-0.20663507282733917,
-0.25402480363845825,
-0.6565600037574768,
-1.547546625137329,
0.19274644553661346,
-0.07993301004171371,
-0.41397106647491455,
0.03960870951414108,
0.28471606969833374,
-0.05299863964319229,
0.46226900815963745,
-0.5646125674247742,
0.18647736310958862,
-0.13823935389518738,
-0.11390259116888046,
-0.3529897928237915,
-0.17199599742889404,
0.47939249873161316,
-0.09066290408372879,
0.46934422850608826,
-0.19611704349517822,
0.15117120742797852,
0.5472990870475769,
-0.6649942994117737,
0.7779970765113831,
-0.0879015102982521,
-0.24997244775295258,
0.8365749716758728,
-0.28810420632362366,
0.6304873824119568,
-0.05373406782746315,
-0.2674174904823303,
-0.017565937712788582,
-0.4677152931690216,
-0.379325270652771,
-0.4805963635444641,
0.5923894643783569,
-0.5596917867660522,
-0.9363460540771484,
-0.1934431940317154,
-0.6205706000328064,
-0.5993058681488037,
-0.0657583624124527,
0.05772174149751663,
0.5037912726402283,
0.08584292232990265,
0.21709871292114258,
0.7547352910041809,
-0.15688493847846985,
0.1789252609014511,
0.3249673545360565,
-0.19997596740722656,
-0.24628722667694092,
0.7808305025100708,
0.07553689181804657,
0.14744868874549866,
0.5247694849967957,
0.3288724720478058,
-0.184335395693779,
-0.12545236945152283,
-0.222465381026268,
0.09361045807600021,
-0.6602092385292053,
-0.5370601415634155,
-0.9781691431999207,
-0.17610178887844086,
-0.4954339861869812,
-0.07127032428979874,
-0.05804736912250519,
-0.28153568506240845,
-0.33949315547943115,
-0.4125167727470398,
0.7837445139884949,
0.741644561290741,
0.06649542599916458,
0.20846696197986603,
-1.1396970748901367,
0.9447156190872192,
0.7241201996803284,
0.2647012174129486,
-0.008946343325078487,
-0.2869884967803955,
-0.2885911464691162,
-0.0018207269022241235,
-0.2331872582435608,
-0.8564023971557617,
0.6029503345489502,
0.15004102885723114,
0.5101728439331055,
0.028326408937573433,
0.14856211841106415,
0.5734128355979919,
-0.5409191846847534,
0.920172393321991,
0.23731720447540283,
-0.679286003112793,
0.4287577271461487,
-0.4575991630554199,
0.0664554163813591,
0.12290824949741364,
0.06757508218288422,
-0.29910919070243835,
-0.4632839560508728,
-0.6411387324333191,
-1.074217438697815,
0.23020300269126892,
-0.09837830811738968,
0.46753737330436707,
-0.09509243816137314,
0.2827480733394623,
-0.18645086884498596,
0.24826347827911377,
0.09592270106077194,
-0.37812528014183044,
-0.12391028553247452,
0.04498288780450821,
0.18044079840183258,
-0.29550525546073914,
-0.31180253624916077,
-0.20505066215991974,
0.5833430886268616,
-0.10853999853134155,
-0.01946018822491169,
0.0701015368103981,
0.22482727468013763,
-0.29213565587997437,
0.29611262679100037,
-0.12624113261699677,
0.7495763897895813,
-0.023139169439673424,
0.07032939046621323,
0.4478299915790558,
-0.5865069031715393,
0.1106032282114029,
-0.20897209644317627,
-0.18191435933113098,
0.37052854895591736,
0.24429188668727875,
0.5287001729011536,
0.15135203301906586,
-0.5463156700134277,
0.05595359951257706,
-0.07669932395219803,
0.051368795335292816,
-0.5837547779083252,
0.2406449168920517,
0.08574826270341873,
0.02394276298582554,
0.44962278008461,
0.08680477738380432,
0.2241639792919159,
-0.43484175205230713,
0.27502864599227905,
0.4127369225025177,
-0.00883440487086773,
-0.1186043918132782,
0.8976830840110779,
0.31569796800613403,
-0.49776357412338257,
0.4448176920413971,
0.1811891347169876,
-0.3318929672241211,
1.0128726959228516,
0.30800220370292664,
0.8651186227798462,
-0.2523127496242523,
0.05898638442158699,
0.4403688609600067,
-0.08676493167877197,
0.40051397681236267,
0.5027427077293396,
-0.13708224892616272,
-0.7538902759552002,
-0.6520053148269653,
-0.8043032884597778,
-0.662557065486908,
0.00857495702803135,
-0.8491178154945374,
0.13393732905387878,
-0.4413488507270813,
-0.18807217478752136,
-0.03272358700633049,
-0.017769837751984596,
-0.9295441508293152,
0.15404190123081207,
-0.09984187036752701,
0.9104763269424438,
-0.7387123703956604,
0.6492016911506653,
0.7205443978309631,
0.028730077669024467,
-1.2391705513000488,
-0.05127100273966789,
-0.6466314792633057,
-0.767810583114624,
0.663379430770874,
-0.16635575890541077,
-0.34362268447875977,
0.27374276518821716,
-0.7919438481330872,
-0.9242749810218811,
1.1656516790390015,
0.07402689754962921,
-0.5959962606430054,
0.6032456755638123,
0.07282204926013947,
0.7378031015396118,
-0.04853126406669617,
0.07284973561763763,
0.7092876434326172,
0.7220503687858582,
-0.0019196168286725879,
-1.0293548107147217,
-0.3526712954044342,
-0.1957801729440689,
-0.062179237604141235,
0.5416826605796814,
-0.7844024896621704,
0.6287689208984375,
0.02398575469851494,
-0.22336198389530182,
-0.14597170054912567,
0.859173059463501,
0.18454863131046295,
0.7138015627861023,
0.51347416639328,
0.4497824013233185,
0.7937880754470825,
0.049452684819698334,
1.2423769235610962,
-0.5868315696716309,
0.4929332137107849,
1.0051853656768799,
-0.5260631442070007,
0.5818127393722534,
0.36596986651420593,
-0.4587520360946655,
0.5431165099143982,
0.2672744691371918,
0.1548818051815033,
0.4033397436141968,
0.12526990473270416,
-0.5723055005073547,
-0.24160254001617432,
-0.49440211057662964,
-0.169502392411232,
0.40587037801742554,
0.8977988362312317,
-0.02880934067070484,
-0.3312881588935852,
0.08701904118061066,
0.02457856759428978,
0.5057796835899353,
-0.4153847098350525,
1.010131597518921,
0.37544018030166626,
-0.5553920269012451,
0.5654287338256836,
-0.20051340758800507,
0.5809358358383179,
-0.5999274253845215,
-0.432670533657074,
-0.1970950812101364,
-0.10405655950307846,
-0.5301061272621155,
-0.7158554196357727,
0.6553570032119751,
0.4601192772388458,
-0.057656481862068176,
-0.48632559180259705,
0.9985941052436829,
-0.10859349370002747,
-0.3956746459007263,
-0.05869036912918091,
0.33295804262161255,
0.1826281100511551,
0.2630974352359772,
-0.32471829652786255,
-0.336906373500824,
-0.1353161484003067,
-0.43011152744293213,
0.3074718117713928,
0.35700032114982605,
-0.013950863853096962,
0.6675460934638977,
0.6787236332893372,
0.22536423802375793,
0.028894148766994476,
0.20776252448558807,
0.9790456295013428,
-0.21084702014923096,
-0.4121110737323761,
-0.33919259905815125,
0.4876825213432312,
-0.324351042509079,
0.028769895434379578,
0.8987914323806763,
0.31271880865097046,
0.5963565707206726,
0.05832989141345024,
1.1203871965408325,
-0.1751335710287094,
0.9575034379959106,
-0.38712844252586365,
0.5910437703132629,
-0.3697530925273895,
0.4699110686779022,
0.22312228381633759,
-0.760772705078125,
-0.010889449156820774,
0.23587103188037872,
-0.43431001901626587,
-0.3440510332584381,
0.25153055787086487,
0.6207070350646973,
-0.025201061740517616,
-0.3267878293991089,
0.47296783328056335,
0.31124866008758545,
0.6629696488380432,
-0.17746497690677643,
0.786863386631012,
-0.15427042543888092,
0.3892797529697418,
-0.26564282178878784,
-0.10298021882772446,
-0.21178008615970612,
-0.6904709935188293,
-0.7385576963424683,
-0.16138021647930145,
-0.12122427672147751,
-0.3457045257091522,
-0.17180047929286957,
0.8071799874305725,
0.27258461713790894,
-1.054206132888794,
-0.19073686003684998,
-0.08277137577533722,
0.18583711981773376,
-0.1492595225572586,
-0.2980632483959198,
0.4613609313964844,
-0.6582330465316772,
-0.7094618678092957,
0.4235805869102478,
0.1271347999572754,
-0.46068888902664185,
-0.37372151017189026,
0.1027291938662529,
0.09824167937040329,
0.2469049096107483,
0.6137099862098694,
0.12870316207408905,
-0.27447694540023804,
-0.4892476201057434,
-0.07707247138023376,
-0.04834321513772011,
0.06749800592660904,
0.8877695798873901,
-0.9157063961029053,
0.5184441804885864,
0.9356409311294556,
0.7196152210235596,
0.49461010098457336,
0.414119154214859,
0.3093004822731018,
-0.9825131893157959,
0.22047540545463562,
0.49458053708076477,
0.5393741130828857,
0.5740101933479309,
-0.9474548697471619,
0.4066764712333679,
0.02057698555290699,
-0.8421554565429688,
-0.5698148608207703,
0.49596482515335083,
-0.5850972533226013,
-0.12581034004688263,
1.1097722053527832,
-0.3443128764629364,
-0.16484124958515167,
-0.5278200507164001,
-0.3178599774837494,
0.3755493462085724,
-0.13565213978290558,
1.1115455627441406,
0.45661821961402893,
-0.44099923968315125,
-0.11959607154130936,
-0.7438387870788574,
0.21298350393772125,
0.1987442821264267,
-0.9067721962928772,
0.1887449026107788,
0.43938425183296204,
0.12135795503854752,
0.3009064793586731,
0.557196319103241,
0.25723475217819214,
-0.10040871798992157,
0.08177796006202698,
-0.18636606633663177,
-0.1597241908311844,
-0.29305556416511536,
0.07198361307382584,
0.18251831829547882,
0.0587739497423172,
-0.20109637081623077
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.01070v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.01070v1
|
Guiding ChatGPT to Generate Salient Domain Summaries
| 2024-06-03T07:42:45 | 2024-06-03T07:42:45 |
Jun Gao, Ziqiang Cao, Shaoyao Huang, Luozheng Qin, Chunhui Ai
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
ChatGPT is instruct-tuned to generate general and human-expected content to
align with human preference through Reinforcement Learning from Human Feedback
(RLHF), meanwhile resulting in generated responses not salient enough.
Therefore, in this case, ChatGPT may fail to satisfy domain requirements in
zero-shot settings, leading to poor ROUGE scores. Inspired by the In-Context
Learning (ICL) and retelling ability of ChatGPT, this paper proposes PADS, a
\textbf{P}ipeline for \textbf{A}ssisting ChatGPT in \textbf{D}omain
\textbf{S}ummarization. PADS consists of a retriever to retrieve similar
examples from corpora and a rank model to rerank the multiple candidate
summaries generated by ChatGPT. Specifically, given an inference document, we
first retrieve an in-context demonstration via the retriever. Then, we require
ChatGPT to generate $k$ candidate summaries for the inference document at a
time under the guidance of the retrieved demonstration. Finally, the rank model
independently scores the $k$ candidate summaries according to their quality and
selects the optimal one. We extensively explore dense and sparse retrieval
methods to select effective demonstrations for reference and efficiently train
the rank model to reflect the quality of candidate summaries for each given
summarized document. Additionally, PADS contains merely 400M trainable
parameters originating from the rank model and we merely collect 2.5k data to
train it. We evaluate PADS on five datasets from different domains, and the
result indicates that each module in PADS is committed to effectively guiding
ChatGPT to generate salient summaries fitting different domain requirements.
Specifically, in the popular summarization dataset Gigaword, PADS achieves over
+8 gain on ROUGE-L, compared with the naive ChatGPT in the zero-shot setting.
\footnote{Our code are available at \url{https://github.com/jungao1106/PADS}}
|
[
-0.35227859020233154,
-0.631894052028656,
0.3582698404788971,
0.4106105864048004,
-0.6140583753585815,
0.06189892441034317,
-0.10023380070924759,
-0.007379495073109865,
0.596493124961853,
0.46301504969596863,
-0.33229392766952515,
-0.5517029762268066,
-0.686625599861145,
-0.1322346031665802,
-0.42281052470207214,
1.6604318618774414,
0.13480795919895172,
-0.34955719113349915,
-0.0313546396791935,
-0.11773358285427094,
-0.4640372693538666,
-0.5838847160339355,
-0.5366570353507996,
-0.13891878724098206,
0.5028165578842163,
0.7850103378295898,
0.41277870535850525,
0.23503869771957397,
0.3919479250907898,
0.15178203582763672,
0.022585429251194,
0.3855285048484802,
-0.860252857208252,
0.3890341818332672,
0.19176949560642242,
-0.2011462301015854,
-0.7268767952919006,
0.05318767949938774,
0.5546122789382935,
0.6254541277885437,
0.03285497799515724,
-0.02629433013498783,
0.3099614381790161,
0.5171312093734741,
-0.6594762206077576,
0.2806057929992676,
-0.4667164385318756,
0.03752792626619339,
-0.08084241300821304,
-0.7066207528114319,
-0.6955313086509705,
-0.2922913730144501,
0.23546411097049713,
-0.552640438079834,
0.5780059099197388,
0.09911923110485077,
1.006309151649475,
0.027950569987297058,
-0.5059707164764404,
-0.11789476871490479,
-0.3585033416748047,
0.7158293724060059,
-0.39776408672332764,
0.011886396445333958,
0.49229171872138977,
0.3072163462638855,
-0.10086093842983246,
-0.7714715600013733,
-0.2780240476131439,
-0.20928993821144104,
-0.38190025091171265,
0.5810441970825195,
0.1456224024295807,
0.020931143313646317,
0.12474707514047623,
0.3622361421585083,
-0.6597608923912048,
-0.27176427841186523,
-0.38175177574157715,
-0.006666611880064011,
0.7451901435852051,
0.03476318344473839,
0.09502534568309784,
-0.2780333161354065,
-0.5617164373397827,
-0.24762430787086487,
-0.914406418800354,
-0.07110217958688736,
0.1743023842573166,
0.3860010504722595,
-0.2241629660129547,
0.41375091671943665,
-0.3310306966304779,
0.4948672652244568,
0.38389822840690613,
-0.24926923215389252,
0.10734030604362488,
-0.0388176292181015,
-0.1924285590648651,
0.05501771345734596,
0.502911388874054,
0.5659127235412598,
0.17969892919063568,
-0.2086106687784195,
-0.2364462912082672,
-0.39954978227615356,
0.3615705370903015,
-1.0713666677474976,
-0.442341148853302,
0.2110031694173813,
-0.38241785764694214,
-0.24540770053863525,
0.10404353588819504,
-1.0085207223892212,
-0.23083966970443726,
-0.4492930471897125,
0.44523581862449646,
-0.5652506351470947,
-0.17993776500225067,
-0.011257169768214226,
-0.342794269323349,
0.278307169675827,
0.5893844366073608,
-1.0800507068634033,
0.22777898609638214,
0.5585750937461853,
0.9471895694732666,
-0.30069205164909363,
-0.3284047842025757,
-0.6976785063743591,
0.11155156046152115,
-0.2531213164329529,
1.1583588123321533,
-0.4784751534461975,
-0.7891466617584229,
-0.00625720527023077,
-0.1010199785232544,
-0.3636924922466278,
-0.24389676749706268,
0.465168297290802,
-0.424419105052948,
0.36822497844696045,
-0.36710840463638306,
-0.6193479299545288,
0.02098129503428936,
0.03912048414349556,
-0.3005881905555725,
0.8342042565345764,
0.18323498964309692,
-0.6494047045707703,
0.6588512659072876,
-0.71904057264328,
-0.5278018712997437,
-0.02257228083908558,
-0.12885735929012299,
-0.7175688147544861,
-0.036499831825494766,
0.3385082185268402,
0.6407362222671509,
0.2652629315853119,
0.1440584659576416,
-0.052784428000450134,
-0.6318495273590088,
0.12096857279539108,
-0.42865896224975586,
0.5466967821121216,
-0.008196864277124405,
-0.4341852068901062,
0.1561223268508911,
-0.49141237139701843,
-0.04535146802663803,
-0.04758895933628082,
-0.17505447566509247,
-0.07862230390310287,
-0.2163248211145401,
0.05660358443856239,
-0.10557443648576736,
-0.23672786355018616,
-0.15172730386257172,
0.1622554510831833,
0.0426025390625,
0.12864746153354645,
0.6641446352005005,
0.54880291223526,
0.4714517593383789,
-0.3627338707447052,
0.6169482469558716,
-0.24281956255435944,
0.0720687285065651,
-0.5794756412506104,
-0.5930043458938599,
-0.6586435437202454,
-0.596622884273529,
0.4558897018432617,
0.29730188846588135,
-0.4968886077404022,
0.2590196132659912,
-0.43469181656837463,
-0.350673645734787,
-0.2717866897583008,
-0.23805789649486542,
0.631933331489563,
0.5883796215057373,
0.43270671367645264,
-0.4055490493774414,
-0.12338203936815262,
-0.8417578339576721,
0.0908404216170311,
-0.07209554314613342,
-0.1956593096256256,
0.46754834055900574,
0.4656849205493927,
0.2647881805896759,
0.9832582473754883,
-0.700276792049408,
-0.25444626808166504,
-0.44352245330810547,
0.32105398178100586,
-0.0840371698141098,
0.23845268785953522,
0.7180722951889038,
-1.025952935218811,
-0.7238731980323792,
-0.21092979609966278,
-0.5794669389724731,
-0.20584119856357574,
-0.10735675692558289,
-0.37722858786582947,
-0.051375869661569595,
0.43717676401138306,
-0.7008183598518372,
0.42308494448661804,
0.11937160044908524,
-0.3449523150920868,
0.6551984548568726,
-0.1631775200366974,
0.39831072092056274,
-1.1122195720672607,
0.2101932317018509,
0.009012127295136452,
-0.306388258934021,
-0.5689178109169006,
-0.005863875616341829,
0.0709308385848999,
-0.37317410111427307,
-0.1427774280309677,
0.7718658447265625,
-0.4533662796020508,
-0.14786745607852936,
-0.324001282453537,
0.6932991743087769,
0.2635139524936676,
0.9066042304039001,
0.1879906803369522,
0.8968558311462402,
0.22972258925437927,
-0.6456602811813354,
-0.11802958697080612,
0.45909640192985535,
0.11891468614339828,
0.7050536870956421,
-0.6640719175338745,
-0.1494280844926834,
-0.1972464621067047,
0.5611173510551453,
-1.0343375205993652,
-0.4138534963130951,
0.22100427746772766,
-0.6171503067016602,
0.6488974690437317,
-0.4575609862804413,
-0.0737539678812027,
0.13371221721172333,
-0.6009036302566528,
0.08936045318841934,
0.6252809166908264,
-0.5766528844833374,
0.22176037728786469,
0.5204331874847412,
-0.5266773104667664,
-0.8194778561592102,
-0.3380240499973297,
0.039841216057538986,
-0.38600975275039673,
-0.2613113224506378,
0.5540795922279358,
-0.005244932137429714,
-0.02528197132050991,
-0.165486142039299,
-0.029347669333219528,
0.0643327459692955,
-0.28915175795555115,
0.31354403495788574,
0.2567911744117737,
-0.1954008787870407,
0.23243239521980286,
0.06727747619152069,
-0.4171476364135742,
-0.3519565761089325,
-0.08570805937051773,
0.2823779582977295,
-0.09935256838798523,
-0.5300376415252686,
0.02137458324432373,
0.42359742522239685,
0.44488686323165894,
-0.2612948417663574,
0.3521527945995331,
0.631011962890625,
0.14088860154151917,
-0.48605674505233765,
-0.3014916181564331,
-0.420987069606781,
-0.36604198813438416,
0.3188028633594513,
-0.31028664112091064,
-0.7434151768684387,
0.5148207545280457,
-0.041086893528699875,
0.2497727870941162,
0.2947206497192383,
0.45985734462738037,
-0.037312060594558716,
0.5771816968917847,
0.6856156587600708,
-0.07527830451726913,
0.5804218649864197,
-0.44469699263572693,
0.4082928001880646,
-0.8271017670631409,
-0.07631228119134903,
-0.2780665159225464,
-0.29326510429382324,
-0.5109739303588867,
-0.3634386360645294,
0.6524324417114258,
0.17216147482395172,
-0.020927999168634415,
0.2352571189403534,
-0.51118403673172,
0.6799132227897644,
0.6884827017784119,
0.2299368530511856,
0.12870948016643524,
0.19552262127399445,
-0.028026659041643143,
-0.008318045176565647,
-0.6949703693389893,
-0.5315505862236023,
1.1811429262161255,
0.1232219859957695,
0.5408905744552612,
0.16029894351959229,
0.7518537640571594,
0.5191984176635742,
0.47994473576545715,
-0.586386501789093,
0.6071377396583557,
-0.2124522626399994,
-0.11228050291538239,
-0.4416622817516327,
-0.14958558976650238,
-0.9453269839286804,
0.7302406430244446,
0.15265479683876038,
-0.5973172187805176,
0.3436855375766754,
0.24208779633045197,
-0.45268821716308594,
-0.03896873816847801,
-0.9502196907997131,
0.8313649296760559,
0.11323275417089462,
-0.5217399001121521,
-0.1130049005150795,
-0.7247187495231628,
0.4686141312122345,
0.2761554718017578,
-0.4197455942630768,
-0.001261965837329626,
0.09708493202924728,
0.42519766092300415,
-0.44120466709136963,
1.1356648206710815,
-0.3597690761089325,
0.08938685059547424,
0.3415890336036682,
-0.006318040192127228,
0.3623405694961548,
0.18926909565925598,
0.0318206250667572,
-0.16695170104503632,
-0.4447610378265381,
-0.6435651183128357,
-0.6096242070198059,
0.5416824221611023,
-0.5603165030479431,
-0.5368453860282898,
-0.15689131617546082,
-0.38090261816978455,
-0.2823696434497833,
-0.025871336460113525,
0.3410837650299072,
0.8324394226074219,
-0.22056245803833008,
0.20638114213943481,
0.7918738722801208,
-0.1519574373960495,
0.3819088041782379,
0.5649627447128296,
-0.014303810894489288,
-0.185792475938797,
1.1822874546051025,
-0.08369644731283188,
0.30362668633461,
0.566265344619751,
-0.14847181737422943,
-0.3032160699367523,
-0.5004544258117676,
-0.6454505920410156,
0.09332792460918427,
-0.7779079675674438,
-0.4057186543941498,
-0.7220005989074707,
-0.5015972256660461,
-0.1610582023859024,
-0.3974120318889618,
-0.03319164738059044,
-0.7153819799423218,
0.0602743998169899,
-0.26925572752952576,
0.4149557948112488,
0.5609260201454163,
0.002574406797066331,
0.5331466197967529,
-0.4128953218460083,
0.35410723090171814,
0.3934363126754761,
0.1707029938697815,
-0.1526334583759308,
-0.7923945188522339,
-0.21718144416809082,
-0.1336444914340973,
-0.6236724853515625,
-0.7436745166778564,
0.4725988805294037,
0.20042990148067474,
0.6494284272193909,
0.5090942978858948,
0.14703476428985596,
0.689029335975647,
-0.36766546964645386,
0.8566697835922241,
-0.22777915000915527,
-0.5745819211006165,
0.709425687789917,
-0.5891256928443909,
-0.02378012426197529,
0.49176421761512756,
0.3071163296699524,
-0.5133534073829651,
-0.6681231260299683,
-0.9341561794281006,
-0.9864453077316284,
0.7485225200653076,
0.3527146875858307,
0.1746964305639267,
-0.13557884097099304,
0.34326812624931335,
0.2513695955276489,
0.32035884261131287,
-0.5147968530654907,
-0.18981657922267914,
-0.37265297770500183,
0.012834953144192696,
0.03176143765449524,
-0.4735630452632904,
-0.007351407781243324,
0.37311816215515137,
0.818553626537323,
-0.3244219124317169,
0.4377571642398834,
0.2841590940952301,
-0.13427849113941193,
0.22946268320083618,
0.12244638800621033,
0.9090694785118103,
0.6244572401046753,
-0.3790769577026367,
0.09011677652597427,
-0.009855951182544231,
-0.5480337738990784,
-0.14542452991008759,
0.06334751099348068,
-0.35442042350769043,
0.30814895033836365,
0.5343508720397949,
0.7665196061134338,
0.5874640345573425,
-0.4871031939983368,
0.8438230156898499,
0.012169089168310165,
-0.19734761118888855,
-0.014736741781234741,
0.1272195279598236,
-0.2656216621398926,
-0.04432302713394165,
0.33433857560157776,
0.05076834186911583,
0.20178993046283722,
-0.18943600356578827,
0.5094934701919556,
0.2474447786808014,
-0.34282296895980835,
-0.26167455315589905,
0.545898973941803,
0.3250148594379425,
0.020666291937232018,
0.4914182126522064,
-0.44607412815093994,
-0.5140219330787659,
0.5458133816719055,
0.4370114505290985,
0.8296379446983337,
-0.2401280552148819,
0.5884436368942261,
0.45492449402809143,
-0.10183870792388916,
0.004941124003380537,
-0.2230570763349533,
-0.41462770104408264,
-0.39093735814094543,
-0.21801269054412842,
-0.4260627329349518,
-0.7326536774635315,
-0.02114756405353546,
-0.4176163375377655,
0.3117544651031494,
-0.18645122647285461,
0.049549203366041183,
-0.17797252535820007,
0.002371113048866391,
-0.15040843188762665,
0.09427513927221298,
-0.22258177399635315,
0.5316848158836365,
-0.8317387700080872,
0.42896315455436707,
0.23568332195281982,
-0.7541736364364624,
-0.5257066488265991,
0.3956717550754547,
0.028239212930202484,
-0.9120668172836304,
0.6172552704811096,
-0.11631817370653152,
-0.10068660974502563,
-0.27320218086242676,
-0.27953994274139404,
-0.506216287612915,
1.2723859548568726,
0.3196501135826111,
-0.09177640825510025,
0.22523953020572662,
-0.14337103068828583,
0.4270757734775543,
-0.4219933748245239,
0.5604952573776245,
0.13677647709846497,
0.2684773802757263,
0.16982907056808472,
-0.8539413213729858,
-0.07162254303693771,
-0.33897432684898376,
-0.312225878238678,
0.031911756843328476,
-1.0179674625396729,
0.8558037877082825,
-0.3945938050746918,
-0.2285110205411911,
-0.11101751774549484,
0.3960567116737366,
0.6373972296714783,
0.42385226488113403,
0.057987090200185776,
0.2358734905719757,
0.674964964389801,
-0.07318297773599625,
1.3705413341522217,
-0.31972089409828186,
0.2062654346227646,
1.278947114944458,
-0.07857757806777954,
0.8654235005378723,
0.2333286702632904,
0.0382598452270031,
0.3695988059043884,
0.6721209287643433,
0.10599962621927261,
0.7096193432807922,
0.07645364105701447,
-0.45776715874671936,
-0.024675512686371803,
-0.07124631851911545,
-0.39865538477897644,
0.32053717970848083,
0.37281593680381775,
-0.33112218976020813,
-0.4741782248020172,
-0.23363693058490753,
0.18268948793411255,
-0.034855615347623825,
0.0012876426335424185,
0.6972281336784363,
0.1460423618555069,
-0.8014707565307617,
0.3565632700920105,
-0.09825354069471359,
0.3412715196609497,
-0.7347235083580017,
-0.45636653900146484,
-0.8181710839271545,
0.09961626678705215,
-0.09893413633108139,
-0.6788949966430664,
-0.00917775183916092,
-0.0851190909743309,
-0.14864781498908997,
-0.6054485440254211,
0.8132718801498413,
-0.5934026837348938,
-0.1904589831829071,
-0.020040975883603096,
0.6632856130599976,
0.4303075075149536,
-0.05826152116060257,
-0.4653775691986084,
-0.27960386872291565,
0.04055153951048851,
-0.47523170709609985,
0.5882352590560913,
0.8509257435798645,
-0.2520773410797119,
0.6684088706970215,
0.3937338888645172,
0.006208572071045637,
-0.3042003810405731,
0.36426809430122375,
0.830751895904541,
-0.30548304319381714,
-0.791653037071228,
-0.5823471546173096,
0.6003797650337219,
-0.46174633502960205,
-0.4023394286632538,
0.7904098629951477,
0.7282112836837769,
0.3727058172225952,
-0.22435809671878815,
0.7747626900672913,
-0.002875776495784521,
0.5807714462280273,
-0.600959837436676,
0.777987539768219,
-0.25186383724212646,
0.3400322496891022,
-0.21650457382202148,
-0.7802638411521912,
-0.2286807894706726,
0.6880401372909546,
-0.23101989924907684,
0.4154764711856842,
0.7216794490814209,
0.9222235083580017,
-0.3033941984176636,
0.0014454207848757505,
0.3963693678379059,
-0.01833135262131691,
0.3498203456401825,
0.39172181487083435,
0.50416499376297,
-0.5004679560661316,
0.5855473279953003,
-0.02247954159975052,
-0.35725563764572144,
-0.6697701215744019,
-0.7909520864486694,
-0.9611904621124268,
-0.7375335693359375,
-0.3696357011795044,
-0.14372654259204865,
0.290162593126297,
0.5098015069961548,
1.0532654523849487,
-0.7157776951789856,
-0.006719079799950123,
0.19179706275463104,
0.14135845005512238,
-0.17539820075035095,
-0.3319050669670105,
0.9540045857429504,
-0.7074651718139648,
-0.6694963574409485,
0.25726792216300964,
0.5377913117408752,
0.09257037192583084,
0.03113408200442791,
-0.1315998136997223,
0.24790121614933014,
-0.2001854032278061,
0.8879026770591736,
0.32917359471321106,
-0.4651307463645935,
-0.3239469826221466,
-0.031154245138168335,
-0.10500852018594742,
-0.041200194507837296,
1.1510621309280396,
-0.7687863707542419,
-0.015331803821027279,
0.09697122126817703,
0.5611311793327332,
0.6977531909942627,
0.26087555289268494,
0.6416900753974915,
-1.2271037101745605,
0.04648125544190407,
0.17453211545944214,
0.43311458826065063,
0.2658149003982544,
-0.30759671330451965,
0.6448001265525818,
0.11750521510839462,
-0.6025673747062683,
-0.5982734560966492,
-0.04246080666780472,
-1.114518404006958,
-0.16587163507938385,
1.098777413368225,
-0.319295197725296,
0.015078363940119743,
-0.21905797719955444,
-0.5003976225852966,
-0.07555071264505386,
-0.6490280628204346,
1.1851310729980469,
0.36359426379203796,
-0.41248276829719543,
-0.2626841068267822,
-0.7368879914283752,
0.7244560718536377,
0.3882768750190735,
-0.7015954256057739,
0.4632372558116913,
0.5008898377418518,
0.1409006267786026,
0.1421789675951004,
1.1890952587127686,
-0.19224946200847626,
0.386388897895813,
0.3442125618457794,
-0.11480235308408737,
0.01466093584895134,
-0.35020485520362854,
0.10930752009153366,
0.33274218440055847,
-0.05220046639442444,
-0.3102918565273285
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.01052v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.01052v1
|
MACT: Model-Agnostic Cross-Lingual Training for Discourse Representation Structure Parsing
| 2024-06-03T07:02:57 | 2024-06-03T07:02:57 |
Jiangming Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Discourse Representation Structure (DRS) is an innovative semantic
representation designed to capture the meaning of texts with arbitrary lengths
across languages. The semantic representation parsing is essential for
achieving natural language understanding through logical forms. Nevertheless,
the performance of DRS parsing models remains constrained when trained
exclusively on monolingual data. To tackle this issue, we introduce a
cross-lingual training strategy. The proposed method is model-agnostic yet
highly effective. It leverages cross-lingual training data and fully exploits
the alignments between languages encoded in pre-trained language models. The
experiments conducted on the standard benchmarks demonstrate that models
trained using the cross-lingual training method exhibit significant
improvements in DRS clause and graph parsing in English, German, Italian and
Dutch. Comparing our final models to previous works, we achieve
state-of-the-art results in the standard benchmarks. Furthermore, the detailed
analysis provides deep insights into the performance of the parsers, offering
inspiration for future research in DRS parsing. We keep updating new results on
benchmarks to the appendix.
|
[
-0.22709211707115173,
-0.6799317598342896,
0.4361695647239685,
0.10291815549135208,
-0.4907744228839874,
0.2614078223705292,
0.15963485836982727,
-0.3010129928588867,
0.4108424782752991,
0.4873528778553009,
-0.5490092635154724,
-0.4768437147140503,
-0.744218647480011,
0.28842422366142273,
-0.04797780513763428,
0.58449387550354,
-0.19455160200595856,
0.5032315254211426,
-0.04788075014948845,
-0.4465526342391968,
-0.22639192640781403,
-0.5736793875694275,
-0.6050699353218079,
-0.16575169563293457,
0.44502270221710205,
0.14951223134994507,
0.5530596375465393,
0.6588214635848999,
0.27643725275993347,
0.25099772214889526,
0.0019363800529390574,
0.34059545397758484,
-0.40104398131370544,
0.17039485275745392,
-0.4364076554775238,
-0.28696444630622864,
-0.4500805735588074,
-0.09134407341480255,
0.927578330039978,
1.0572504997253418,
-0.21304844319820404,
-0.08980070054531097,
-0.08536899089813232,
0.5584325194358826,
-0.37263405323028564,
0.18058009445667267,
-0.801685094833374,
0.4149479269981384,
-0.22713889181613922,
-0.2962852120399475,
-0.859723687171936,
-0.02278234250843525,
-0.0835813581943512,
-0.6299403309822083,
0.015507282689213753,
0.15314407646656036,
1.0278681516647339,
0.10343053191900253,
-0.7749015688896179,
0.049468617886304855,
-0.23296315968036652,
0.6705119013786316,
-0.6074438095092773,
0.8261005878448486,
-0.02838614583015442,
0.4389302134513855,
-0.11240079998970032,
-0.8350409865379333,
-0.2902892827987671,
-0.28156962990760803,
-0.2817791998386383,
0.10427829623222351,
-0.06816805154085159,
0.16309039294719696,
0.3203706443309784,
0.2662016749382019,
-0.6643530130386353,
-0.027504313737154007,
-0.01642930693924427,
-0.20610305666923523,
0.37028056383132935,
0.13114698231220245,
0.3914589583873749,
-0.461049884557724,
-0.6766031980514526,
-0.10188829153776169,
-0.5834360122680664,
0.24652481079101562,
0.22479282319545746,
0.43305686116218567,
-0.16947214305400848,
0.7039864659309387,
0.11423283070325851,
0.6891863346099854,
-0.0017473772168159485,
-0.06887336820363998,
0.21775484085083008,
-0.17037203907966614,
-0.2702828347682953,
0.12404531985521317,
0.940709114074707,
-0.11810331791639328,
0.16372470557689667,
-0.07451115548610687,
-0.18710942566394806,
0.11452987790107727,
0.21145731210708618,
-0.6700441837310791,
-0.1658659428358078,
-0.40426385402679443,
-0.40844520926475525,
-0.27347448468208313,
0.02428322657942772,
-0.41415250301361084,
-0.04835055395960808,
-0.37860724329948425,
-0.2668386399745941,
-0.6415742635726929,
-0.35050830245018005,
0.218702495098114,
-0.02125733532011509,
-0.029741983860731125,
0.05376145988702774,
-1.0156184434890747,
0.7304490208625793,
0.5540055632591248,
0.7290570139884949,
-0.05808591842651367,
-0.23329581320285797,
-0.7179320454597473,
0.5328635573387146,
-0.56610506772995,
0.680831789970398,
-0.7369862794876099,
-0.29163864254951477,
-0.18271873891353607,
0.0752563327550888,
-0.424314022064209,
-0.3351876437664032,
0.5694936513900757,
-0.4171198308467865,
0.3161722421646118,
-0.27648666501045227,
-0.4959883391857147,
-0.22719573974609375,
0.5724307894706726,
-0.5922794342041016,
1.2030116319656372,
0.27143794298171997,
-1.2116135358810425,
0.2573564648628235,
-0.6352795362472534,
-0.6009447574615479,
-0.19168958067893982,
-0.5803117156028748,
-0.2887105941772461,
0.008443108759820461,
0.5267118811607361,
0.26608163118362427,
-0.2592366635799408,
0.6925885677337646,
-0.27806800603866577,
0.18892380595207214,
-0.07509684562683105,
-0.518141508102417,
0.963074266910553,
0.08299423009157181,
-0.2838192284107208,
0.2663097679615021,
-0.8099414706230164,
0.07106619328260422,
0.17447738349437714,
-0.1025097519159317,
-0.6546533703804016,
-0.16625873744487762,
-0.1136404350399971,
0.38251039385795593,
-0.04516362026333809,
-0.7950130701065063,
0.17063410580158234,
-0.4607144594192505,
0.39233747124671936,
0.5696678161621094,
-0.1548374593257904,
0.1523686796426773,
0.1092948168516159,
0.7259014248847961,
0.35615718364715576,
-0.17423254251480103,
-0.28915467858314514,
-0.3366146981716156,
-0.47411635518074036,
-0.5540142059326172,
0.6444310545921326,
0.6138487458229065,
-0.8934473395347595,
0.21212409436702728,
-0.41175413131713867,
-0.2648278474807739,
-0.5719085931777954,
-0.2899005115032196,
0.5464199185371399,
0.925447404384613,
0.4583546817302704,
-0.6374377012252808,
-0.7863543629646301,
-1.1558020114898682,
-0.43238839507102966,
-0.21715453267097473,
0.2168656885623932,
0.1505742073059082,
0.3987759053707123,
-0.21058228611946106,
1.0850698947906494,
-0.3088694214820862,
-0.034035731106996536,
-0.44186148047447205,
0.2883744239807129,
-0.2783210575580597,
0.2831641733646393,
0.7247419953346252,
-0.7118194699287415,
-0.6130266785621643,
0.22892822325229645,
-0.679161012172699,
-0.10201937705278397,
0.10897260159254074,
-0.05430743843317032,
0.4252120554447174,
0.543962299823761,
-0.4982055425643921,
0.4280845820903778,
0.5309274196624756,
-0.2976464629173279,
0.4936557114124298,
-0.28644049167633057,
0.08764147758483887,
-1.13912832736969,
0.16834093630313873,
-0.08723786473274231,
-0.8003599643707275,
-0.4329760670661926,
-0.11135635524988174,
0.2570420801639557,
-0.32487577199935913,
-0.4263457655906677,
0.5265524387359619,
-0.5842382907867432,
-0.25224965810775757,
0.11699032038450241,
0.04114959388971329,
0.2249024659395218,
0.4009261727333069,
0.44213950634002686,
0.5943319797515869,
0.6338808536529541,
-0.16592241823673248,
-0.004692429210990667,
0.23853608965873718,
-0.14452393352985382,
0.5396189093589783,
-0.6627667546272278,
0.028197066858410835,
-0.019162697717547417,
0.5597174763679504,
-0.9815788269042969,
0.05482253059744835,
0.44967010617256165,
-0.21812930703163147,
0.5218989253044128,
-0.11457304656505585,
-0.4040360748767853,
-0.23491570353507996,
-0.0864216759800911,
0.5652593970298767,
-0.13352476060390472,
-0.4211293160915375,
0.7804428935050964,
0.6843211054801941,
-0.21959416568279266,
-0.8942309021949768,
-0.9302232265472412,
0.21944840252399445,
-0.00005266765583655797,
-0.865428626537323,
0.3820602595806122,
0.4068290591239929,
-0.018291747197508812,
-0.011800402775406837,
-0.19878019392490387,
-0.029603395611047745,
-0.2290089875459671,
-0.17245329916477203,
0.07776040583848953,
-0.481863409280777,
-0.1640564501285553,
0.39052021503448486,
-0.3655624985694885,
0.06340634077787399,
-0.39398136734962463,
0.551458477973938,
-0.01735578291118145,
-0.5147631168365479,
-0.46849244832992554,
0.5905199646949768,
0.4889959394931793,
-0.5061256885528564,
0.4642253518104553,
0.245086207985878,
-0.19280263781547546,
-0.28036263585090637,
-0.2475455105304718,
-0.025847995653748512,
-0.40615302324295044,
0.35268864035606384,
-0.84161376953125,
-0.8002025485038757,
0.5246626138687134,
-0.2113250344991684,
0.057135067880153656,
0.33006495237350464,
0.16993871331214905,
0.3368137776851654,
1.217147946357727,
0.7486615777015686,
-0.17002712190151215,
0.13337089121341705,
-0.007735321763902903,
0.38743963837623596,
-0.5464361906051636,
-0.09464587271213531,
-0.3805074095726013,
-0.1472913920879364,
-0.41800862550735474,
-0.5550056099891663,
0.1831471025943756,
-0.35512492060661316,
-0.2505563497543335,
0.2514600157737732,
-0.4235820472240448,
0.16570940613746643,
0.19631275534629822,
-0.2253112494945526,
0.30749350786209106,
0.12896767258644104,
-0.8666766881942749,
-0.3708385229110718,
-0.971917450428009,
-0.5061766505241394,
0.5838475823402405,
0.5793155431747437,
0.6550131440162659,
-0.19490094482898712,
0.660188615322113,
-0.01030673272907734,
-0.07796366512775421,
-0.6844901442527771,
0.7526711821556091,
-0.34191349148750305,
-0.36263400316238403,
-0.14948049187660217,
-0.7193939685821533,
-0.8336101770401001,
0.7290351986885071,
0.2826586067676544,
-0.4498162865638733,
0.3424690365791321,
-0.18209870159626007,
0.09272889792919159,
0.6125189065933228,
-0.515947699546814,
1.274606704711914,
-0.37982672452926636,
-0.006837495137006044,
-0.1294868290424347,
-1.0034435987472534,
0.3523244857788086,
0.331309050321579,
0.34552764892578125,
0.05205584689974785,
-0.07677947729825974,
0.7740830183029175,
-0.3901260495185852,
0.8754743337631226,
-0.27135512232780457,
-0.22158369421958923,
0.03987870365381241,
0.25586485862731934,
0.3651844263076782,
0.19192048907279968,
0.025976063683629036,
0.2925325930118561,
0.037611983716487885,
-0.4500653147697449,
-0.4886261522769928,
0.36422526836395264,
-0.5950608849525452,
-0.49115195870399475,
-0.7560041546821594,
-0.8457516431808472,
-0.38836154341697693,
0.3579413592815399,
0.040866367518901825,
0.4456278383731842,
-0.4945443868637085,
-0.2298126071691513,
0.6017436981201172,
0.07008948922157288,
0.031218554824590683,
0.3539491593837738,
-0.4028911888599396,
-0.5210797190666199,
0.5078973174095154,
0.0951550155878067,
0.3780347406864166,
0.533336877822876,
0.006878656335175037,
-0.22394366562366486,
-0.3114326596260071,
-0.7725445628166199,
0.47573813796043396,
-0.806639552116394,
-0.007740907836705446,
-0.8881937861442566,
-0.3163227438926697,
-0.5524035096168518,
-0.011891412548720837,
-0.6114046573638916,
-0.832900881767273,
-0.024584472179412842,
-0.32781559228897095,
-0.13054406642913818,
0.6209051609039307,
-0.027658242732286453,
-0.0637570172548294,
-0.6463952660560608,
0.5225956439971924,
-0.015253842808306217,
0.17280656099319458,
-0.19565261900424957,
-0.5016995072364807,
0.027229420840740204,
0.23400618135929108,
-0.37961456179618835,
-0.8072894215583801,
0.40569713711738586,
0.0026779682375490665,
0.5681476593017578,
0.4411560297012329,
-0.0676419734954834,
0.930442214012146,
-0.851808488368988,
0.7246299982070923,
0.39949697256088257,
-1.0101336240768433,
0.565531849861145,
-0.334901362657547,
0.13719922304153442,
0.6939933896064758,
0.47603878378868103,
-0.6409538984298706,
-0.42233002185821533,
-0.5958216190338135,
-0.6904894113540649,
0.8959804773330688,
-0.06410492956638336,
0.01303564291447401,
-0.04846428334712982,
0.06951365619897842,
0.39261820912361145,
0.12552325427532196,
-0.9799793362617493,
-0.16914553940296173,
-0.33396080136299133,
-0.20953473448753357,
0.1794425994157791,
-0.23948004841804504,
-0.3172704577445984,
-0.631249189376831,
0.8000526428222656,
-0.272590696811676,
-0.09384039044380188,
0.19704046845436096,
-0.08456575125455856,
-0.2577132284641266,
0.18061286211013794,
0.36824506521224976,
0.7301759719848633,
0.028587279841303825,
0.35952863097190857,
0.04392446205019951,
-0.3827986419200897,
0.26657333970069885,
0.3716796338558197,
-0.2014322727918625,
0.543091893196106,
0.18453073501586914,
0.9724493026733398,
0.4757957458496094,
-0.49227529764175415,
0.32380130887031555,
-0.2739449441432953,
-0.3463740050792694,
0.02579260990023613,
-0.37643954157829285,
0.06153402477502823,
-0.046838246285915375,
0.04212268814444542,
0.15378621220588684,
-0.047862909734249115,
-0.6797426342964172,
0.2962823212146759,
0.6128130555152893,
-0.49111488461494446,
-0.3175923228263855,
0.6071779727935791,
-0.07048536837100983,
-0.028320036828517914,
0.18814586102962494,
-0.13250353932380676,
-0.7310788631439209,
0.26864093542099,
0.6803051829338074,
0.6279439926147461,
-0.5023466348648071,
0.5691916346549988,
0.18163329362869263,
0.3320305645465851,
0.05251997336745262,
0.29727306962013245,
-0.04236576333642006,
-0.48404762148857117,
-0.3195880651473999,
-0.451344758272171,
-0.49694785475730896,
-0.2628259062767029,
-0.5446655750274658,
0.5196959376335144,
-0.2141866534948349,
0.07462941855192184,
-0.05578911304473877,
-0.14722739160060883,
-0.1559472382068634,
0.25966352224349976,
0.12290190905332565,
1.0476406812667847,
-0.7450268268585205,
1.0527433156967163,
0.8894454836845398,
-0.1822025328874588,
-1.0319958925247192,
-0.21783654391765594,
-0.04693344607949257,
-0.7489821314811707,
0.6948108673095703,
0.1350822150707245,
-0.22229164838790894,
-0.20296213030815125,
-0.10026924312114716,
-0.7807092070579529,
0.8441598415374756,
0.883127748966217,
-0.6007393002510071,
-0.3246687650680542,
0.6766497492790222,
0.4195762872695923,
-0.8241544365882874,
0.23783347010612488,
0.3692614436149597,
0.4045661687850952,
0.14044663310050964,
-0.9203464984893799,
0.15368954837322235,
-0.14614033699035645,
0.15548153221607208,
0.23948539793491364,
-0.3242749273777008,
0.8404154181480408,
0.20610851049423218,
-0.30208921432495117,
-0.18717263638973236,
0.6855936050415039,
0.39685267210006714,
0.2958522140979767,
0.6477943658828735,
0.9910190105438232,
0.9377024173736572,
0.058016952127218246,
1.014042854309082,
-0.32384055852890015,
0.22882793843746185,
1.1009509563446045,
-0.5036516785621643,
0.5797507762908936,
0.555556058883667,
0.08386188000440598,
0.9107459187507629,
0.6902077198028564,
0.4191186726093292,
0.7114357352256775,
0.04915342479944229,
0.052045147866010666,
-0.2039492130279541,
-0.09692911058664322,
-0.5733569860458374,
0.36817556619644165,
0.28361839056015015,
-0.51192307472229,
-0.6164455413818359,
0.17588739097118378,
0.17000338435173035,
0.1703486293554306,
-0.1355888694524765,
0.618877649307251,
0.47919750213623047,
-0.6461304426193237,
0.9506434202194214,
0.06125175952911377,
0.3184898793697357,
-1.0025871992111206,
0.08819928020238876,
0.06051655113697052,
0.1309797465801239,
-0.05800323188304901,
-0.4876052737236023,
0.43646010756492615,
-0.0423494428396225,
0.004222087096422911,
-0.49261507391929626,
0.7774994373321533,
-0.4116549789905548,
-0.6104081273078918,
0.5841114521026611,
0.5299063324928284,
0.007574410177767277,
0.3809329867362976,
-0.8923509120941162,
-0.07605835050344467,
0.07429555058479309,
-0.385098934173584,
0.3167743384838104,
0.9376682043075562,
-0.21617303788661957,
0.45731598138809204,
0.41328558325767517,
0.15096746385097504,
0.05402405932545662,
0.33201509714126587,
1.1204489469528198,
-0.6018780469894409,
-0.8793751001358032,
-0.6871415376663208,
0.6690984964370728,
-0.26358288526535034,
-0.275641530752182,
0.7135202288627625,
0.821752667427063,
0.9165315628051758,
0.2606176435947418,
0.7430704832077026,
0.015862390398979187,
0.6748539209365845,
-0.376516729593277,
0.5293132662773132,
-0.5600258708000183,
0.21261902153491974,
-0.2318941205739975,
-0.8206294178962708,
-0.3282264173030853,
0.5950220823287964,
-0.5741842985153198,
-0.16716982424259186,
1.06352698802948,
0.6021965146064758,
-0.6636933088302612,
0.3181610405445099,
0.2140376716852188,
0.14425309002399445,
0.3910059332847595,
0.2392105609178543,
0.6013959050178528,
-0.2114991545677185,
0.326355516910553,
-0.19663769006729126,
-0.10517264157533646,
0.18723496794700623,
-0.7590005993843079,
-0.9345567226409912,
-0.4491986036300659,
-0.20175398886203766,
-0.07563924044370651,
0.20367531478405,
0.48497211933135986,
0.6888415813446045,
-0.6877711415290833,
-0.37405532598495483,
-0.2223152220249176,
-0.1285405158996582,
-0.2336684614419937,
-0.19731903076171875,
0.4300311505794525,
-0.6903471350669861,
-0.34777021408081055,
0.6267703771591187,
0.4678635001182556,
-0.20510707795619965,
-0.29837730526924133,
-0.1370925009250641,
-0.6417890191078186,
0.23400558531284332,
0.5711286664009094,
0.1960287243127823,
-0.7365880608558655,
-0.23197603225708008,
0.03281078487634659,
-0.28324568271636963,
0.5270114541053772,
1.0394576787948608,
-0.7976163625717163,
0.4980086088180542,
0.37143075466156006,
0.7380073070526123,
0.6133797764778137,
-0.020819636061787605,
0.6301397681236267,
-0.8322693109512329,
0.4883875548839569,
0.49247244000434875,
0.711842954158783,
0.5773637890815735,
-0.09585780650377274,
0.5778297185897827,
0.28706252574920654,
-0.2940515875816345,
-1.0749380588531494,
0.4195944368839264,
-1.110023856163025,
-0.43600746989250183,
0.7860238552093506,
-0.4558391571044922,
-0.3470333218574524,
-0.19518490135669708,
-0.39511385560035706,
0.3476957678794861,
-0.21626904606819153,
0.4670269787311554,
0.6302340030670166,
-0.05570032447576523,
-0.1924472153186798,
-0.4249719977378845,
0.20961332321166992,
0.8312512636184692,
-0.6583203673362732,
0.28628280758857727,
0.2905658185482025,
0.1323523372411728,
0.1298830658197403,
0.776552140712738,
-0.3704606592655182,
0.09099587053060532,
-0.0013319972204044461,
-0.20838074386119843,
-0.06534390896558762,
-0.33921611309051514,
-0.1327025443315506,
0.25913700461387634,
-0.2590927481651306,
-0.011458564549684525
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.01045v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.01045v1
|
Decompose, Enrich, and Extract! Schema-aware Event Extraction using LLMs
| 2024-06-03T06:55:10 | 2024-06-03T06:55:10 |
Fatemeh Shiri, Van Nguyen, Farhad Moghimifar, John Yoo, Gholamreza Haffari, Yuan-Fang Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) demonstrate significant capabilities in
processing natural language data, promising efficient knowledge extraction from
diverse textual sources to enhance situational awareness and support
decision-making. However, concerns arise due to their susceptibility to
hallucination, resulting in contextually inaccurate content. This work focuses
on harnessing LLMs for automated Event Extraction, introducing a new method to
address hallucination by decomposing the task into Event Detection and Event
Argument Extraction. Moreover, the proposed method integrates dynamic
schema-aware augmented retrieval examples into prompts tailored for each
specific inquiry, thereby extending and adapting advanced prompting techniques
such as Retrieval-Augmented Generation. Evaluation findings on prominent event
extraction benchmarks and results from a synthesized benchmark illustrate the
method's superior performance compared to baseline approaches.
|
[
-0.21785299479961395,
-1.119344711303711,
0.7944625020027161,
0.05785837396979332,
-0.45064881443977356,
-0.0659806877374649,
-0.46874967217445374,
-0.5471254587173462,
0.3409636616706848,
0.48775777220726013,
-0.5206208825111389,
-0.4869533181190491,
-0.5170122981071472,
0.3749569356441498,
-0.5703056454658508,
0.5387535691261292,
-0.0653824508190155,
-0.2804274559020996,
-0.40227749943733215,
0.294158011674881,
-0.36749595403671265,
-0.561976432800293,
-0.5896738171577454,
-0.18796731531620026,
0.26389920711517334,
0.5669081211090088,
0.25944897532463074,
0.7338631749153137,
0.41115450859069824,
0.2303987741470337,
-0.006002809386700392,
0.6313559412956238,
-0.12221909314393997,
0.7918229103088379,
-0.17885448038578033,
0.010477205738425255,
-0.37040403485298157,
-0.01184945646673441,
0.5246469974517822,
0.5129724144935608,
-0.4375494718551636,
0.07695021480321884,
-0.052966922521591187,
0.15366815030574799,
-0.766446590423584,
0.4288382828235626,
-1.064544677734375,
0.004058344755321741,
-0.20417159795761108,
-0.6382034420967102,
-0.6304095983505249,
-0.3092851936817169,
0.06139393895864487,
-0.5962523221969604,
0.2510688602924347,
0.0028198338113725185,
0.7763931751251221,
0.34987083077430725,
-0.15724191069602966,
-0.687748908996582,
-0.5445809364318848,
0.6990475058555603,
-0.515130341053009,
0.5866482853889465,
0.45905154943466187,
0.18585462868213654,
-0.28034380078315735,
-0.9417622685432434,
-0.670400857925415,
-0.22554528713226318,
-0.11113099008798599,
-0.08785270899534225,
-0.1139661893248558,
-0.10832501947879791,
0.332798033952713,
0.22707638144493103,
-0.4336027204990387,
0.11896076798439026,
-0.1331794410943985,
-0.08903618156909943,
0.73689866065979,
0.3900168836116791,
0.3643777370452881,
-0.6968119144439697,
-0.06302017718553543,
0.18557555973529816,
-0.547270655632019,
-0.44961774349212646,
0.05609503388404846,
0.39385488629341125,
0.2138529121875763,
0.6641446352005005,
-0.23165318369865417,
0.495944082736969,
0.18854735791683197,
-0.13306567072868347,
0.04807833209633827,
-0.3550160825252533,
-0.3789727985858917,
0.29515978693962097,
0.6670887470245361,
0.2655453681945801,
0.17979875206947327,
-0.5506373643875122,
-0.06686670333147049,
0.02063504047691822,
0.19087181985378265,
-0.7858709692955017,
-0.19013220071792603,
0.415863037109375,
-0.4057064950466156,
-0.3846355378627777,
-0.09582732617855072,
-1.1862050294876099,
-0.7070900201797485,
-0.45861339569091797,
0.12965886294841766,
-0.363748162984848,
-0.14950507879257202,
0.20152084529399872,
-0.08732344955205917,
0.26848557591438293,
0.5243798494338989,
-0.974402129650116,
0.2980351448059082,
0.6943469643592834,
0.5385969281196594,
-0.82945716381073,
0.034563690423965454,
-0.9871010780334473,
0.4183526635169983,
-0.090935617685318,
0.9521182775497437,
-0.7847656011581421,
-0.29850512742996216,
0.03268251195549965,
0.2390710413455963,
0.12040863931179047,
-0.8510924577713013,
0.6839718818664551,
-0.476946085691452,
0.23634536564350128,
-0.26383644342422485,
-0.5042114853858948,
0.13017548620700836,
0.16547809541225433,
-0.506655752658844,
1.3115395307540894,
-0.1116422563791275,
-0.4173983633518219,
0.3456726372241974,
-0.6153402924537659,
-0.5550583600997925,
0.30151233077049255,
-0.402649849653244,
-0.08257908374071121,
0.1281973123550415,
0.5249321460723877,
0.5363069176673889,
-0.1755312830209732,
0.47750037908554077,
-0.06098971888422966,
-0.11306528747081757,
0.07435505092144012,
-0.30255478620529175,
0.5042130947113037,
0.1940062791109085,
-0.26906144618988037,
0.1616397351026535,
-1.158974289894104,
-0.4168074429035187,
0.335441529750824,
-0.33821749687194824,
-0.2797830402851105,
0.3306897282600403,
-0.2141600102186203,
0.14471624791622162,
0.3020438253879547,
-0.3433568477630615,
0.37715548276901245,
-0.5076183676719666,
0.19417648017406464,
0.7922877669334412,
0.36278632283210754,
0.6516382694244385,
0.22348374128341675,
0.4187779724597931,
-0.06547273695468903,
-0.11860491335391998,
-0.3124968111515045,
-0.07945934683084488,
-0.6183304190635681,
-0.5152433514595032,
-0.10525543987751007,
0.6818108558654785,
-0.8123574256896973,
0.7382447719573975,
-0.22249822318553925,
-0.11497808247804642,
-0.2506544291973114,
0.07525698840618134,
-0.21028152108192444,
0.6163926124572754,
0.2970004975795746,
0.06421259045600891,
-1.0746209621429443,
-0.3911612629890442,
-0.32535332441329956,
-0.1385922133922577,
-0.08025602996349335,
0.08603419363498688,
0.2764701545238495,
-0.29590168595314026,
0.831594705581665,
-0.5416139960289001,
-0.21218611299991608,
-0.4853092133998871,
0.0980132594704628,
-0.003923074807971716,
0.10916788876056671,
0.08752883225679398,
-0.34887856245040894,
-0.10703166574239731,
0.22279997169971466,
-1.1067849397659302,
-0.4536275267601013,
-0.30374908447265625,
-0.12781141698360443,
0.4947739839553833,
0.8028450608253479,
-0.8976355195045471,
0.549924910068512,
-0.051802054047584534,
-0.2554079294204712,
0.626509964466095,
0.1523669809103012,
-0.08910756558179855,
-1.0645153522491455,
-0.18738345801830292,
-0.37316346168518066,
-0.16832642257213593,
-0.5646352767944336,
-0.05828770622611046,
-0.09668922424316406,
0.0934695452451706,
-0.2502268850803375,
0.5675470232963562,
-0.6671919822692871,
-0.32732507586479187,
-0.37501609325408936,
0.6363047957420349,
0.1196780726313591,
-0.0005243904888629913,
0.3328627347946167,
0.39904671907424927,
0.36649009585380554,
-0.6733906269073486,
0.682217001914978,
0.49224311113357544,
-0.46140968799591064,
0.2228918820619583,
-0.2139282375574112,
0.04819837212562561,
-0.19138136506080627,
0.047775741666555405,
-0.5908941626548767,
-0.5498631000518799,
0.4584675431251526,
-0.19077490270137787,
0.204313725233078,
0.026767248287796974,
-0.7339608073234558,
0.029148457571864128,
-0.17543262243270874,
-0.05308675020933151,
0.2619040310382843,
-0.7251219153404236,
0.9743760228157043,
0.49574756622314453,
-0.4594261348247528,
-0.41942644119262695,
-0.4742835462093353,
0.3218601644039154,
-0.3228169083595276,
-0.3565639555454254,
0.24546700716018677,
0.13484196364879608,
-0.5500229001045227,
-0.13129326701164246,
-0.2660089433193207,
0.24815891683101654,
0.1600765585899353,
0.4019396901130676,
0.4139569103717804,
-0.09620412439107895,
0.32437899708747864,
0.10263852775096893,
-0.10775609314441681,
0.2632864713668823,
0.040669988840818405,
0.8048707842826843,
0.14892886579036713,
-0.44751396775245667,
-0.6837179064750671,
0.6721278429031372,
0.5343500375747681,
-0.26029711961746216,
0.565792977809906,
0.4623112678527832,
-0.8842113614082336,
-0.1723412573337555,
-0.8043557405471802,
-0.6056039333343506,
-0.4394761919975281,
0.323417067527771,
-0.312195360660553,
-0.6960737705230713,
0.6513047814369202,
-0.16522827744483948,
0.0321771465241909,
0.28216564655303955,
0.5997197031974792,
0.04059449955821037,
0.9804177284240723,
0.10789696127176285,
0.21138951182365417,
0.5653017163276672,
0.1263585239648819,
0.2839811444282532,
-0.7834748029708862,
-0.44303515553474426,
-0.5172854065895081,
0.10011851042509079,
-0.009494275785982609,
-0.3681604266166687,
0.009218486957252026,
0.13154295086860657,
0.014043894596397877,
0.13133184611797333,
-0.40886959433555603,
0.45025816559791565,
0.1408722847700119,
-0.1360379308462143,
0.6619657874107361,
0.26019152998924255,
0.30256056785583496,
-0.28973639011383057,
-0.43548858165740967,
-0.7195491194725037,
0.6317980885505676,
0.08865364640951157,
0.5192874073982239,
-0.07707589864730835,
0.9085620641708374,
0.30580562353134155,
0.2477831095457077,
-0.8187533020973206,
0.7037258744239807,
0.3427073359489441,
-0.3845587372779846,
-0.5126385688781738,
-0.26099011301994324,
-0.9971851110458374,
0.2976324260234833,
-0.34624096751213074,
-1.1895806789398193,
0.3553871512413025,
-0.30282026529312134,
-0.2843918800354004,
0.08846715837717056,
-0.3291204571723938,
0.5463573336601257,
0.03433256596326828,
-0.106710284948349,
0.05827900767326355,
-0.3331049382686615,
0.29149919748306274,
-0.09046351909637451,
0.44547149538993835,
-0.23017139732837677,
-0.03566349297761917,
0.5962451696395874,
-0.07697443664073944,
0.6117501854896545,
0.05795944482088089,
-0.242860347032547,
0.31067460775375366,
0.45929211378097534,
1.066907286643982,
0.25371527671813965,
-0.33317309617996216,
-0.15827763080596924,
-0.10171844065189362,
0.08032572269439697,
-0.7934214472770691,
0.5598614811897278,
-0.2573438882827759,
-0.6627629399299622,
-0.3009025752544403,
-0.5915811657905579,
-0.05879829451441765,
-0.0684465616941452,
0.21797725558280945,
0.4968293309211731,
-0.08982470631599426,
-0.008647117763757706,
0.5732487440109253,
-0.1392175853252411,
0.6181178689002991,
0.4962734282016754,
-0.3541291058063507,
-0.3779808282852173,
0.8531941175460815,
0.027546705678105354,
-0.0452096089720726,
0.10193758457899094,
0.041779011487960815,
-0.30599769949913025,
-0.6233609914779663,
-0.2851821184158325,
0.18561391532421112,
-1.0031861066818237,
-0.32597246766090393,
-1.2037936449050903,
-0.1464235484600067,
-0.6774380803108215,
-0.3132627010345459,
-0.1739933043718338,
-0.5073967576026917,
-0.7802075743675232,
-0.5770403742790222,
0.17725305259227753,
0.48924720287323,
-0.2020866423845291,
0.13586971163749695,
-0.8997859954833984,
0.4554772675037384,
0.12245406210422516,
-0.0669054239988327,
-0.06901969015598297,
-0.414772629737854,
0.09790606051683426,
-0.5610350966453552,
-0.22750569880008698,
-1.2468202114105225,
0.6821603178977966,
0.16782687604427338,
0.8243781924247742,
0.5224758982658386,
0.32917696237564087,
0.6790785789489746,
-0.31802332401275635,
0.932281494140625,
-0.10096709430217743,
-1.0312726497650146,
0.9617989659309387,
-0.14015012979507446,
-0.16079926490783691,
0.43638408184051514,
0.17860621213912964,
-0.4684368968009949,
-0.38045310974121094,
-0.6827800869941711,
-0.9678164124488831,
0.7150681614875793,
0.06990518420934677,
-0.21549482643604279,
-0.5257257223129272,
0.6173778772354126,
0.3511113226413727,
-0.06773832440376282,
-0.6475445032119751,
-0.023771198466420174,
0.2494868040084839,
-0.24540935456752777,
0.1894722580909729,
-0.45343443751335144,
-0.03166254237294197,
-0.31851086020469666,
0.41943326592445374,
-0.020953958854079247,
0.0023867287673056126,
0.2448895275592804,
-0.5586811900138855,
-0.21215809881687164,
0.19723021984100342,
0.3837777376174927,
0.7461434602737427,
-0.246564581990242,
0.4103652238845825,
0.6656923294067383,
-0.40670499205589294,
-0.1866561472415924,
0.1238589808344841,
-0.050231412053108215,
0.16426005959510803,
0.5276272296905518,
0.4508328437805176,
0.14320313930511475,
-0.905921459197998,
0.2562597393989563,
-0.1779841184616089,
-0.12161916494369507,
-0.24567651748657227,
-0.05054508522152901,
-0.058936260640621185,
0.4763897657394409,
0.5715430378913879,
-0.6361786723136902,
0.4471360146999359,
-0.5812874436378479,
0.4875491261482239,
0.3974820673465729,
-0.23622745275497437,
-0.1909276396036148,
0.5146096348762512,
0.19123223423957825,
-0.2887248396873474,
0.48894450068473816,
-0.28977760672569275,
-0.3447395861148834,
0.3971717357635498,
0.6379846334457397,
0.7879880666732788,
-0.20584818720817566,
0.07641960680484772,
0.38246315717697144,
0.3111608922481537,
0.051746346056461334,
0.43309369683265686,
-0.21750453114509583,
-0.6257490515708923,
-0.514018177986145,
-0.7139174342155457,
-0.3063005805015564,
0.2998179495334625,
-0.801393449306488,
0.37580594420433044,
-0.07191506028175354,
0.15948595106601715,
-0.04005078971385956,
-0.046080268919467926,
-0.25112399458885193,
-0.07738551497459412,
0.32817843556404114,
0.8116858601570129,
-0.7119651436805725,
0.6126103401184082,
0.39663565158843994,
-0.25967445969581604,
-0.31761181354522705,
-0.07584027945995331,
-0.06352567672729492,
-0.37673449516296387,
0.5984761714935303,
0.02518319897353649,
0.09340395033359528,
-0.1309787482023239,
-0.5062037706375122,
-0.7358951568603516,
1.0061661005020142,
0.4215035140514374,
-0.3218551278114319,
-0.17030058801174164,
0.1868167221546173,
0.2360975593328476,
-0.5636866688728333,
0.016838587820529938,
1.0137730836868286,
0.5238524675369263,
0.16974450647830963,
-0.5262423753738403,
0.3568035662174225,
0.08685503154993057,
-0.40944305062294006,
0.13141930103302002,
0.048194970935583115,
0.4968763291835785,
-0.09337244927883148,
-0.5574965476989746,
-0.044653940945863724,
0.8388112187385559,
0.46716102957725525,
0.6229879260063171,
0.3398112654685974,
0.1382293403148651,
1.0946000814437866,
-0.09048138558864594,
0.7156820297241211,
-0.12139759957790375,
0.040615491569042206,
1.306849479675293,
-0.5569745302200317,
0.791975736618042,
0.6495059728622437,
0.27046871185302734,
0.4511362910270691,
0.7705944180488586,
0.38885194063186646,
0.5239750742912292,
0.04788869619369507,
-0.4697861075401306,
-0.6077395081520081,
-0.09791538864374161,
-0.3745235204696655,
0.596486508846283,
0.8252784609794617,
-0.2701443135738373,
-0.3085402548313141,
0.07198639959096909,
0.0064091868698596954,
-0.07868174463510513,
-0.05183572322130203,
1.0729410648345947,
0.08536694198846817,
-0.6309514045715332,
0.36507317423820496,
-0.1932339370250702,
0.24097800254821777,
-0.2148999124765396,
-0.21775221824645996,
-0.18285898864269257,
-0.07314816862344742,
-0.18608969449996948,
-0.5230026245117188,
0.546981930732727,
0.01410805806517601,
-0.11725563555955887,
-0.1011820137500763,
1.0909992456436157,
-0.4210347533226013,
-0.2349933236837387,
0.29951319098472595,
0.5321842432022095,
0.31662681698799133,
-0.2665672302246094,
-0.14440901577472687,
0.5360518097877502,
-0.15642593801021576,
-0.4836865961551666,
0.2211124151945114,
0.6833349466323853,
-0.11517433822154999,
0.5641893148422241,
0.686334490776062,
0.15942643582820892,
0.05478590726852417,
0.11774272471666336,
0.8395552635192871,
-0.7951499223709106,
-0.1165243536233902,
-1.1258609294891357,
0.5032996535301208,
-0.577394425868988,
0.01631033793091774,
0.615239679813385,
0.6072668433189392,
0.3207184970378876,
0.13632869720458984,
0.8331044912338257,
0.24489238858222961,
0.37531083822250366,
-0.4306893050670624,
0.3700583577156067,
-0.41259244084358215,
0.46390780806541443,
-0.19112876057624817,
-0.81777024269104,
-0.40522125363349915,
0.6741834878921509,
-0.18021830916404724,
-0.5035446286201477,
0.5710518956184387,
0.7253457307815552,
0.14516839385032654,
0.32044658064842224,
0.1779717355966568,
0.020006202161312103,
0.4715409576892853,
0.12389889359474182,
1.095822811126709,
-0.21281249821186066,
0.4335216283798218,
0.09431251883506775,
-0.15821073949337006,
-0.6211023330688477,
-1.1266695261001587,
-0.852502703666687,
-0.7256475687026978,
-0.47077125310897827,
-0.388247549533844,
0.1716276854276657,
1.0262987613677979,
0.39516401290893555,
-0.8791903257369995,
0.06736933439970016,
0.07836772501468658,
0.3637952506542206,
0.0677666887640953,
-0.2703631818294525,
0.5218622088432312,
-0.6863887906074524,
-0.6426354646682739,
0.792769730091095,
0.47469159960746765,
-0.06386251747608185,
0.07573151588439941,
0.09049436450004578,
-0.13926802575588226,
0.31830111145973206,
0.9786989092826843,
0.08784158527851105,
-0.817333996295929,
-0.5528390407562256,
0.04296201840043068,
-0.03546832501888275,
-0.07998327165842056,
0.5604892373085022,
-0.7398761510848999,
0.2161899358034134,
0.7122383117675781,
0.6362695693969727,
0.5994141101837158,
-0.03122653253376484,
0.41376233100891113,
-0.6874514222145081,
0.07974867522716522,
0.17115962505340576,
0.40456587076187134,
0.16696490347385406,
-0.5699045062065125,
0.5503771305084229,
0.3529753088951111,
-0.44674521684646606,
-1.3688161373138428,
0.2439865618944168,
-1.1549603939056396,
-0.28190600872039795,
1.5449179410934448,
0.35881307721138,
-0.086177296936512,
-0.35116899013519287,
-0.3181614875793457,
0.44627270102500916,
-0.15676040947437286,
1.026350975036621,
0.7655084729194641,
-0.2929253876209259,
-0.3784724771976471,
-0.46982038021087646,
0.6869568824768066,
0.10430628061294556,
-1.1755986213684082,
0.6209126114845276,
0.5739325881004333,
-0.05688982456922531,
0.11730393022298813,
0.36590656638145447,
-0.2330332100391388,
0.12918218970298767,
-0.1370435506105423,
0.25857579708099365,
-0.0040505025535821915,
-0.40184536576271057,
-0.3262462019920349,
0.3571237325668335,
-0.36595675349235535,
-0.10981625318527222
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.01026v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.01026v2
|
Strengthened Symbol Binding Makes Large Language Models Reliable Multiple-Choice Selectors
| 2024-06-03T06:20:12 | 2024-06-06T06:32:45 |
Mengge Xue, Zhenyu Hu, Liqun Liu, Kuo Liao, Shuang Li, Honglin Han, Meng Zhao, Chengguo Yin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Multiple-Choice Questions (MCQs) constitute a critical area of research in
the study of Large Language Models (LLMs). Previous works have investigated the
selection bias problem in MCQs within few-shot scenarios, in which the LLM's
performance may be influenced by the presentation of answer choices, leaving
the selection bias during Supervised Fine-Tuning (SFT) unexplored. In this
paper, we reveal that selection bias persists in the SFT phase , primarily due
to the LLM's inadequate Multiple Choice Symbol Binding (MCSB) ability. This
limitation implies that the model struggles to associate the answer options
with their corresponding symbols (e.g., A/B/C/D) effectively. To enhance the
model's MCSB capability, we first incorporate option contents into the loss
function and subsequently adjust the weights of the option symbols and
contents, guiding the model to understand the option content of the current
symbol. Based on this, we introduce an efficient SFT algorithm for MCQs, termed
Point-wise Intelligent Feedback (PIF). PIF constructs negative instances by
randomly combining the incorrect option contents with all candidate symbols,
and proposes a point-wise loss to provide feedback on these negative samples
into LLMs. Our experimental results demonstrate that PIF significantly reduces
the model's selection bias by improving its MCSB capability. Remarkably, PIF
exhibits a substantial enhancement in the accuracy for MCQs.
|
[
-0.8083115816116333,
-0.8527689576148987,
0.603460431098938,
0.014652624726295471,
-0.19750788807868958,
0.013807718642055988,
-0.32600489258766174,
-0.33284205198287964,
0.04488498345017433,
0.6241828799247742,
-0.7489087581634521,
-0.25719204545021057,
-0.608034074306488,
0.2633436918258667,
-0.060074079781770706,
0.9403458833694458,
0.05591326579451561,
0.3916724920272827,
0.048642124980688095,
-0.1588592678308487,
-0.39661741256713867,
-0.6490979790687561,
-0.846135675907135,
-0.24468643963336945,
0.43145427107810974,
0.339071124792099,
0.858156144618988,
0.3852243721485138,
0.71079421043396,
0.2133750468492508,
-0.26767781376838684,
0.24614858627319336,
-0.4229041337966919,
-0.004008857998996973,
-0.29387494921684265,
-0.5602542757987976,
-0.37014105916023254,
0.061155762523412704,
0.7205415368080139,
0.5149836540222168,
0.14403367042541504,
0.25759437680244446,
-0.01859709434211254,
0.7000717520713806,
-0.6925480961799622,
0.08603320270776749,
-0.8115078806877136,
-0.163646399974823,
-0.15779563784599304,
-0.23025286197662354,
-0.7113470435142517,
-0.30192360281944275,
-0.2427709549665451,
-0.3624778091907501,
-0.10975108295679092,
0.14294449985027313,
0.7016106843948364,
0.5163601636886597,
-0.5875895023345947,
-0.10456861555576324,
-0.6353921890258789,
0.8640124201774597,
-0.6188775300979614,
0.5520989298820496,
0.5907151699066162,
0.24627640843391418,
-0.3782578706741333,
-0.04230175539851189,
-0.3943498432636261,
-0.37106800079345703,
0.1078767254948616,
0.005375013221055269,
0.14452798664569855,
0.3873085379600525,
0.3999311625957489,
-0.1288084238767624,
-0.04873960092663765,
0.10012978315353394,
-0.4742690920829773,
-0.3680911958217621,
0.5994370579719543,
-0.11089492589235306,
0.17811955511569977,
-0.09652484953403473,
-0.08648029714822769,
-0.08310101926326752,
-0.8994225263595581,
0.1679578274488449,
0.3986266255378723,
0.4101620614528656,
0.40778040885925293,
0.8552103638648987,
-0.20679914951324463,
1.0693821907043457,
0.4978374242782593,
-0.2151903212070465,
0.013049310073256493,
-0.14935940504074097,
-0.05275746062397957,
0.08041680604219437,
0.6088523864746094,
0.43385109305381775,
0.480943500995636,
0.28514495491981506,
-0.025005310773849487,
-0.21412259340286255,
0.11814330518245697,
-0.7947406768798828,
-0.08861716836690903,
0.2531891465187073,
-0.31304389238357544,
-0.07138960808515549,
0.1934361755847931,
-0.15151295065879822,
-0.23318195343017578,
-0.3466781973838806,
0.43319013714790344,
-0.45067286491394043,
-0.018963854759931564,
-0.07101859152317047,
-0.2007209062576294,
-0.009019115008413792,
0.44011688232421875,
-0.8609570860862732,
-0.09307706356048584,
0.503097414970398,
0.476627379655838,
-0.015898102894425392,
-0.2543993890285492,
-0.9095706939697266,
0.290322482585907,
-0.44692304730415344,
0.8878360986709595,
-0.9294981956481934,
-0.19995269179344177,
-0.4019142687320709,
-0.2180558741092682,
-0.07678350061178207,
-0.5818949341773987,
0.2379591166973114,
-0.5342217087745667,
-0.01045155804604292,
-0.6529337763786316,
-0.26633182168006897,
-0.13660980761051178,
0.3384001553058624,
-0.7091490626335144,
0.989643931388855,
-0.10191065073013306,
-0.9085320234298706,
0.5284160375595093,
-0.42239832878112793,
-0.26361697912216187,
-0.2969781458377838,
-0.3566470742225647,
-0.3249403238296509,
0.1369418054819107,
0.6249682307243347,
0.664829432964325,
0.0366823673248291,
0.0972924530506134,
-0.8554440140724182,
-0.5681312084197998,
0.44977042078971863,
-0.3192850351333618,
0.670504093170166,
0.02611810714006424,
-0.1789240539073944,
0.10172994434833527,
-0.6043408513069153,
0.15439510345458984,
-0.14330431818962097,
-0.3839264512062073,
-0.36543723940849304,
-0.02593214064836502,
-0.31420016288757324,
0.48637548089027405,
-0.23490795493125916,
-0.42642688751220703,
0.4063304662704468,
-0.1892250031232834,
0.41602128744125366,
0.8183761835098267,
0.08369749039411545,
0.4206175208091736,
-0.3508414924144745,
0.5773480534553528,
-0.10310929268598557,
0.10470103472471237,
0.2209688276052475,
-0.35727545619010925,
-0.5906897187232971,
-0.39036107063293457,
0.36958596110343933,
0.37899336218833923,
-1.012689471244812,
0.21869486570358276,
-0.02202918753027916,
-0.2820742726325989,
-0.74411940574646,
0.23639418184757233,
0.22942253947257996,
0.3145085871219635,
0.29348331689834595,
-0.10898256301879883,
-0.23998969793319702,
-0.9696256518363953,
-0.2058783769607544,
-0.39646726846694946,
0.0529666393995285,
0.27824369072914124,
0.2628094255924225,
-0.04863297939300537,
1.0407119989395142,
-0.3156770169734955,
-0.24256227910518646,
-0.3838771879673004,
-0.11375781893730164,
0.1062566339969635,
0.30724865198135376,
0.5913249850273132,
-0.6176654100418091,
-0.270163357257843,
-0.25311988592147827,
-0.04501844197511673,
-0.23948261141777039,
-0.30788034200668335,
-0.43315592408180237,
0.008229763247072697,
0.4576054811477661,
-0.569275438785553,
0.11337147653102875,
0.5073831081390381,
-0.3778002858161926,
0.6990680694580078,
0.1340690553188324,
0.2953101098537445,
-0.6434412598609924,
0.039348892867565155,
-0.06582573056221008,
-0.2165505737066269,
-0.31066569685935974,
0.0030525277834385633,
0.35155990719795227,
0.24519535899162292,
-0.7007189989089966,
0.7741443514823914,
-0.3618795573711395,
-0.029656706377863884,
-0.2170858532190323,
0.17623569071292877,
-0.10685023665428162,
0.5418415069580078,
0.10633725672960281,
0.7561943531036377,
0.2170918881893158,
-0.7480820417404175,
0.05701146274805069,
0.29489192366600037,
0.03895366191864014,
0.7525524497032166,
-0.3741166293621063,
0.019001182168722153,
-0.1705264151096344,
0.5066120028495789,
-0.8087261319160461,
-0.0723542720079422,
0.28286221623420715,
-0.3794530928134918,
0.3320455849170685,
-0.19143682718276978,
-0.5646648406982422,
-0.3654276430606842,
-0.3489741086959839,
0.3970790505409241,
0.05071680620312691,
-0.4707818925380707,
0.36348792910575867,
0.2908998131752014,
-0.247796431183815,
-0.6042174100875854,
-0.7607641220092773,
-0.27598774433135986,
0.13023722171783447,
-0.4280833601951599,
-0.09590352326631546,
-0.4406818151473999,
-0.09608189761638641,
-0.20635034143924713,
-0.31803110241889954,
0.08470813184976578,
0.13989776372909546,
0.023278702050447464,
0.2929835915565491,
0.06073153764009476,
0.41984307765960693,
0.5155778527259827,
-0.18865543603897095,
-0.06736258417367935,
-0.08261919021606445,
0.4887315332889557,
-0.23280096054077148,
-0.6564651727676392,
-0.26172810792922974,
0.1741342544555664,
0.5205021500587463,
-0.5056478381156921,
0.7033268809318542,
0.5432519316673279,
-0.13699385523796082,
-0.3811849057674408,
-0.7169055342674255,
-0.3532268702983856,
-0.43046894669532776,
0.4998915195465088,
-0.44971826672554016,
-1.3384689092636108,
0.3942461907863617,
0.013921027071774006,
-0.03019588440656662,
0.5911223888397217,
0.7138776779174805,
-0.035272616893053055,
1.414636254310608,
0.3840519189834595,
0.056631360203027725,
0.5751404166221619,
-0.0832810178399086,
0.12189535051584244,
-1.0683703422546387,
-0.030997851863503456,
-0.526445746421814,
-0.4364168345928192,
-0.3678234815597534,
-0.2810889482498169,
0.3734903335571289,
0.49763399362564087,
-0.4465184509754181,
0.04265322908759117,
-0.6324247717857361,
0.6164175271987915,
0.658970296382904,
0.2779217064380646,
0.2992341220378876,
-0.2107783406972885,
-0.49448055028915405,
-0.0880618467926979,
-0.8186565041542053,
-0.43431195616722107,
0.9967076182365417,
0.3612441420555115,
0.7751567959785461,
-0.052351802587509155,
0.6471513509750366,
-0.1724013388156891,
0.48492157459259033,
-0.6633457541465759,
0.629744827747345,
-0.11636832356452942,
-0.8019604086875916,
-0.4949905276298523,
-0.3766326904296875,
-0.4859950840473175,
0.467887818813324,
-0.29371336102485657,
-0.6422957181930542,
0.03061472438275814,
0.39407244324684143,
-0.7063940763473511,
0.2520560026168823,
-0.6358820796012878,
0.5961346626281738,
-0.41337069869041443,
-0.19980348646640778,
-0.1260695457458496,
-0.42454323172569275,
0.4532963037490845,
-0.05881759151816368,
0.2516017258167267,
-0.12796886265277863,
0.10856358706951141,
0.631982147693634,
-0.3446106016635895,
0.7620384097099304,
0.022951442748308182,
-0.16820107400417328,
0.2674963176250458,
0.16231109201908112,
0.5767645835876465,
0.2757715880870819,
-0.3667556941509247,
-0.02986316755414009,
0.19012854993343353,
-0.4031141400337219,
-0.6419649720191956,
0.5227018594741821,
-0.5913066267967224,
-0.6364994049072266,
-0.20370541512966156,
-0.34588077664375305,
-0.4971676766872406,
0.3108855187892914,
0.2602388560771942,
0.27861207723617554,
0.1619056612253189,
0.21319082379341125,
0.7425887584686279,
-0.29534921050071716,
0.25545528531074524,
0.21264766156673431,
-0.49631696939468384,
-0.4845426380634308,
0.6147846579551697,
0.36356234550476074,
0.5517359375953674,
0.4590495526790619,
0.1653551310300827,
-0.17182205617427826,
-0.5800496935844421,
-0.5303416848182678,
0.370283305644989,
-0.7656608819961548,
-0.3039466440677643,
-0.551546037197113,
-0.13050930202007294,
-0.2079409658908844,
-0.2566034197807312,
-0.3727138936519623,
-0.5659814476966858,
-0.23227405548095703,
-0.3061674237251282,
0.1973472535610199,
0.469814270734787,
0.1261584311723709,
0.2468712031841278,
-0.7924557328224182,
0.4310918152332306,
0.2848176956176758,
0.6841523051261902,
-0.054005932062864304,
-0.237169086933136,
-0.0836791843175888,
0.22343897819519043,
-0.21023771166801453,
-0.9099928140640259,
-0.07517853379249573,
0.06942469626665115,
0.5859884023666382,
0.36901894211769104,
0.2983487844467163,
0.6780975461006165,
-0.24416574835777283,
0.67084801197052,
0.05422654747962952,
-0.9150595664978027,
0.6379157304763794,
-0.3114702105522156,
0.7342033386230469,
0.7771594524383545,
0.08897275477647781,
-0.4499698877334595,
-0.8647110462188721,
-0.38422879576683044,
-0.5249118804931641,
0.780746340751648,
0.044285472482442856,
-0.0883832573890686,
-0.37249404191970825,
0.212829127907753,
0.0526859275996685,
0.2665099501609802,
-0.713858962059021,
-0.09811584651470184,
0.06227526068687439,
-0.10572170466184616,
0.07825023680925369,
-0.22366958856582642,
0.05525830760598183,
-0.26381221413612366,
0.8908732533454895,
-0.33537042140960693,
0.20587876439094543,
0.14730146527290344,
-0.2517876923084259,
-0.2775568962097168,
0.4771103262901306,
0.6600229144096375,
0.5234847664833069,
-0.25097718834877014,
0.19974654912948608,
0.31971198320388794,
-0.40052661299705505,
0.0063140615820884705,
0.005475927144289017,
-0.3895191252231598,
-0.03638102114200592,
0.24207822978496552,
0.7949528098106384,
0.17912742495536804,
-0.5973937511444092,
0.3285822570323944,
0.03826422989368439,
-0.09011401981115341,
0.11527643352746964,
0.3234105408191681,
-0.03528779000043869,
0.3120158910751343,
0.35167196393013,
0.23500511050224304,
-0.03781478479504585,
-0.35756173729896545,
0.22175884246826172,
0.7811083197593689,
-0.48863354325294495,
0.07909658551216125,
0.6086761355400085,
0.16582556068897247,
-0.05734739080071449,
0.6337598562240601,
-0.15372629463672638,
-0.8492201566696167,
0.5270459055900574,
0.2698397636413574,
0.5819985866546631,
-0.11567725241184235,
0.33218300342559814,
0.42220714688301086,
0.49071213603019714,
-0.3430258631706238,
0.32487380504608154,
0.0017389082349836826,
-0.5665428638458252,
-0.597250759601593,
-0.6237412691116333,
-0.3604353666305542,
-0.07946641743183136,
-0.5089219212532043,
0.3193912208080292,
-0.7004653811454773,
-0.4525696337223053,
-0.43212801218032837,
0.15135960280895233,
-0.6891952753067017,
0.35101354122161865,
0.05697651579976082,
0.8230190873146057,
-0.5094187259674072,
0.7424961924552917,
0.6455647349357605,
-0.40182390809059143,
-0.9895563721656799,
-0.08296846598386765,
0.03220286965370178,
-0.6891151666641235,
0.6305670738220215,
0.20439812541007996,
-0.12291327118873596,
0.057906512171030045,
-0.6622868776321411,
-1.1345683336257935,
0.8840214610099792,
0.6672577857971191,
-0.7813495993614197,
0.19682081043720245,
0.15466026961803436,
0.3885074853897095,
-0.11604851484298706,
0.6784051656723022,
0.4687487781047821,
0.6779441833496094,
0.3366469442844391,
-1.0614960193634033,
0.08250337094068527,
-0.08308080583810806,
-0.02349640242755413,
0.5243850946426392,
-0.8807417154312134,
0.5415811538696289,
-0.5336666703224182,
0.022801395505666733,
-0.23476746678352356,
0.5597879886627197,
0.6039934754371643,
-0.16787667572498322,
0.33152860403060913,
0.30942821502685547,
0.6882207989692688,
-0.1857927441596985,
0.9849187135696411,
-0.23808977007865906,
0.4121215343475342,
1.120463490486145,
-0.07137982547283173,
1.093715786933899,
0.7052704095840454,
-0.09798765182495117,
0.017965640872716904,
0.7733725309371948,
-0.1580882966518402,
0.4389231503009796,
0.33568114042282104,
0.19916868209838867,
-0.6674618124961853,
-0.05039170756936073,
-0.3691354990005493,
0.28020381927490234,
0.12218048423528671,
-0.24976351857185364,
-0.05538830906152725,
0.06347562372684479,
-0.009485702961683273,
-0.2342100590467453,
-0.5160197615623474,
0.6127720475196838,
0.12294378131628036,
-0.7708912491798401,
0.38209637999534607,
0.005057850386947393,
0.6934514045715332,
-0.6178420782089233,
0.026282235980033875,
-0.09626441448926926,
0.08071232587099075,
-0.2616761028766632,
-0.7154055833816528,
0.13355384767055511,
-0.24676959216594696,
-0.17191791534423828,
-0.21973668038845062,
0.5687052011489868,
-0.603803813457489,
-0.7361384034156799,
0.11944185942411423,
0.23626630008220673,
-0.29346078634262085,
-0.25307953357696533,
-0.6406930088996887,
0.2565142512321472,
0.02092946507036686,
-0.4033811092376709,
0.35571804642677307,
0.2792530953884125,
-0.2683185338973999,
0.9045730829238892,
0.6095057129859924,
0.2704981565475464,
0.04496603459119797,
0.02427794225513935,
0.6062705516815186,
-0.5853667259216309,
-0.5051087737083435,
-0.828233003616333,
0.5062636733055115,
0.10089214891195297,
-0.29634055495262146,
0.5271579027175903,
0.1919523924589157,
1.1804569959640503,
-0.07223358005285263,
0.9425522089004517,
0.16702871024608612,
0.3647031784057617,
-0.7230044603347778,
0.7728150486946106,
-0.4307219982147217,
0.4830949008464813,
-0.4430933892726898,
-1.0797319412231445,
-0.5945238471031189,
0.6513853073120117,
-0.5359526872634888,
0.29912522435188293,
0.711445689201355,
0.6525261998176575,
0.027508292347192764,
-0.29662537574768066,
0.29850777983665466,
0.08707699179649353,
0.2794119417667389,
0.5037031173706055,
0.6507511138916016,
-0.19976066052913666,
0.6365856528282166,
-0.2429046332836151,
-0.1354462057352066,
-0.3048255145549774,
-0.8590406775474548,
-1.109217643737793,
-0.38809576630592346,
-0.3603910505771637,
-0.18175211548805237,
-0.0392535999417305,
1.1785340309143066,
0.6751917004585266,
-0.9793577194213867,
0.06417188793420792,
0.3501940965652466,
0.3872126340866089,
-0.34542444348335266,
-0.1665935516357422,
0.4360409080982208,
-0.18250173330307007,
-0.5407447218894958,
-0.11598654836416245,
0.4547489285469055,
-0.01540290005505085,
-0.07933167368173599,
-0.1680154800415039,
-0.2698734402656555,
0.20409280061721802,
0.6450087428092957,
0.08073649555444717,
-0.8622595071792603,
-0.516096293926239,
-0.011254645884037018,
-0.14187563955783844,
-0.0566081739962101,
0.662489652633667,
-0.6289711594581604,
0.429862916469574,
0.34734830260276794,
0.8827310800552368,
0.1627856343984604,
-0.024617435410618782,
0.6728935241699219,
-0.5389742255210876,
-0.1955314427614212,
0.2072778046131134,
0.3381039500236511,
0.1570187211036682,
-0.338286429643631,
0.25426265597343445,
-0.015137032605707645,
-0.38627004623413086,
-0.5833273530006409,
0.3722932040691376,
-0.9412935376167297,
-0.47388821840286255,
1.4341884851455688,
0.46463456749916077,
0.04605121165513992,
0.18375660479068756,
-0.7348641753196716,
0.22494594752788544,
-0.5007643103599548,
0.7732301950454712,
1.1491562128067017,
-0.28393471240997314,
-0.41908082365989685,
-0.3910130560398102,
0.4820893704891205,
0.6209051609039307,
-0.538502037525177,
-0.08936664462089539,
0.6728878021240234,
0.17029821872711182,
-0.14819006621837616,
0.6084561347961426,
0.049466367810964584,
0.41359561681747437,
-0.4893929362297058,
-0.15350797772407532,
-0.35988694429397583,
-0.2766466438770294,
-0.32339584827423096,
0.25948479771614075,
0.4439360499382019,
0.11126240342855453
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.01021v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.01021v1
|
Combining Qualitative and Computational Approaches for Literary Analysis of Finnish Novels
| 2024-06-03T06:07:44 | 2024-06-03T06:07:44 |
Emily Ohman, Riikka Rossi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
What can we learn from the classics of Finnish literature by using
computational emotion analysis? This article tries to answer this question by
examining how computational methods of sentiment analysis can be used in the
study of literary works in conjunction with a qualitative or more 'traditional'
approach to literature and affect. We present and develop a simple but robust
computational approach of affect analysis that uses a carefully curated emotion
lexicon adapted to Finnish turn-of-the-century literary texts combined with
word embeddings to map out the semantic emotional spaces of seminal works of
Finnish literature. We focus our qualitative analysis on selected case studies:
four works by Juhani Aho, Minna Canth, Maria Jotuni, and F. E. Sillanp\"a\"a,
but provide emotion arcs for a total of 975 Finnish novels.
We argue that a computational analysis of a text's lexicon can be valuable in
evaluating the large distribution of the emotional valence in a text and
provide guidelines to help other researchers replicate our findings. We show
that computational approaches have a place in traditional studies on affect in
literature as a support tool for close-reading-based analyses, but also
allowing for large-scale comparison between, for example, genres or national
canons.
|
[
-0.32195791602134705,
-0.5501931309700012,
0.46375057101249695,
-0.03413879871368408,
-0.3202950358390808,
-0.1352614462375641,
-0.12341634929180145,
-0.5739299654960632,
0.6361040472984314,
0.32466426491737366,
-0.5882079005241394,
-0.3900592029094696,
-0.3474143445491791,
0.4454718828201294,
-0.1210947036743164,
0.8082372546195984,
-0.14451727271080017,
0.05927795171737671,
-0.6179536581039429,
-0.24782505631446838,
-0.10314217954874039,
-0.6529017090797424,
-0.008381498977541924,
-0.23873578011989594,
0.8775808215141296,
0.033027783036231995,
0.7796727418899536,
-0.34511232376098633,
0.667166531085968,
0.30195149779319763,
-0.2746039628982544,
-0.1619664579629898,
-0.6075117588043213,
0.554492175579071,
0.004575536586344242,
-0.5562474727630615,
0.06598731875419617,
-0.2815861999988556,
0.6593685150146484,
0.19825772941112518,
0.32678619027137756,
-0.07880637049674988,
-0.10126440972089767,
1.2590663433074951,
-0.9246104955673218,
-0.050433773547410965,
-0.0804005041718483,
0.5441635251045227,
-0.2956421971321106,
-0.1819266676902771,
-0.4222383499145508,
-0.6090746521949768,
-0.07384616136550903,
-0.502686619758606,
-0.2940311133861542,
-0.039149392396211624,
0.4554266035556793,
0.06533005088567734,
-0.41789740324020386,
-0.41644442081451416,
-0.6522010564804077,
1.05348539352417,
-0.5909641981124878,
-0.21396417915821075,
0.018337754532694817,
-0.04758326709270477,
-0.05567400902509689,
-0.24889177083969116,
-0.6280208826065063,
-0.2519153654575348,
-0.14708392322063446,
0.2665824294090271,
-0.14813268184661865,
-0.005861673038452864,
0.2080640196800232,
0.5667699575424194,
-0.6228494048118591,
-0.23815014958381653,
-0.43560636043548584,
0.20438449084758759,
0.8021151423454285,
0.3719121217727661,
0.5667583346366882,
-0.42232587933540344,
-0.2584330439567566,
-0.1110839918255806,
-0.5550408959388733,
0.15684489905834198,
0.5689877867698669,
0.08320119231939316,
-0.11455673724412918,
0.6722805500030518,
0.08031362295150757,
0.3858630061149597,
-0.37068790197372437,
0.12142644822597504,
0.30499574542045593,
-0.1440640538930893,
-0.06426770985126495,
0.13552026450634003,
1.1706286668777466,
0.35316982865333557,
0.3992166817188263,
0.25073978304862976,
-0.16200919449329376,
0.37091222405433655,
0.5939303636550903,
-0.5720120668411255,
-0.05052177235484123,
0.5968043208122253,
-0.617493212223053,
-0.53499835729599,
-0.36250218749046326,
-1.1758991479873657,
-0.7939531207084656,
-0.30572518706321716,
0.5199790596961975,
-0.3684459924697876,
-0.5054786801338196,
-0.025092897936701775,
-0.43962767720222473,
0.32297319173812866,
0.16476599872112274,
-0.780475378036499,
0.19645197689533234,
0.6633282899856567,
0.7678858041763306,
-0.14823506772518158,
-0.09556162357330322,
0.07460196316242218,
-0.5003208518028259,
-0.4189833700656891,
0.6736882328987122,
-0.6152509450912476,
-0.4355044364929199,
0.13673922419548035,
-0.36952903866767883,
-0.2907165586948395,
0.0033089446369558573,
0.7054631114006042,
-0.3189055025577545,
0.2843828499317169,
-0.22423921525478363,
-0.4326036870479584,
-0.12903302907943726,
0.3056934177875519,
-1.0040488243103027,
1.2049239873886108,
0.13409017026424408,
-1.2554582357406616,
-0.48080500960350037,
-0.5601000189781189,
-0.3777909576892853,
-0.1728937327861786,
-0.04360378533601761,
-0.22157344222068787,
0.7863129377365112,
-0.16380922496318817,
0.3821578323841095,
-0.4002878665924072,
-0.07963455468416214,
-0.45076674222946167,
-0.4937475621700287,
0.5720871090888977,
0.2717098891735077,
0.9294779300689697,
0.4147648513317108,
-0.27619287371635437,
0.052881307899951935,
-0.2453402727842331,
-0.12594401836395264,
0.09866444021463394,
0.4214532971382141,
-0.8253511190414429,
-0.005039770156145096,
0.4884151518344879,
0.024224255234003067,
0.28183016180992126,
-0.6634269952774048,
0.19555625319480896,
-0.4362822473049164,
0.1797802895307541,
0.2867831885814667,
0.02348800003528595,
0.47054973244667053,
-0.3009023666381836,
0.9756228923797607,
-0.20576508343219757,
0.16744175553321838,
-0.253888338804245,
-0.30822691321372986,
-0.5260241627693176,
-0.021242225542664528,
0.4764004945755005,
0.4741968810558319,
-0.8574089407920837,
0.36208757758140564,
0.1139335185289383,
-0.6785642504692078,
-0.693305253982544,
-0.4753631353378296,
0.16608649492263794,
0.19056639075279236,
-0.28991732001304626,
-0.23286297917366028,
-0.29923683404922485,
-0.4642871022224426,
-0.5381222367286682,
-0.29170355200767517,
0.29074203968048096,
0.14060044288635254,
0.4972464442253113,
0.015433835797011852,
0.810901403427124,
-0.5783080458641052,
-0.03832577168941498,
0.02717667818069458,
0.25239571928977966,
0.15554960072040558,
0.2956347167491913,
0.777198076248169,
-1.0482573509216309,
-0.4327874183654785,
0.2745562791824341,
-1.069868803024292,
-0.002509752754122019,
-0.14522068202495575,
-0.31450626254081726,
0.02038070559501648,
0.29273897409439087,
-0.42295601963996887,
0.40379637479782104,
0.31126996874809265,
-0.3583683371543884,
0.9195258617401123,
0.040138889104127884,
0.5416852831840515,
-0.898058295249939,
0.29582101106643677,
0.00399356335401535,
0.28712305426597595,
-0.7317508459091187,
0.48849600553512573,
0.08416479080915451,
-0.36134734749794006,
-0.6110134720802307,
0.7383995056152344,
-0.1885490119457245,
0.1677028387784958,
-0.02057660184800625,
-0.15104661881923676,
0.23896260559558868,
0.388611376285553,
0.14899864792823792,
0.14559084177017212,
0.24298155307769775,
-0.15619316697120667,
0.4386443495750427,
0.1114695817232132,
-0.29085537791252136,
0.7498225569725037,
-0.2820327579975128,
0.2433147430419922,
-0.4010445773601532,
-0.14750023186206818,
-1.2967066764831543,
-0.04766636714339256,
0.1704697608947754,
-0.5342451333999634,
0.1780846267938614,
-0.0561615452170372,
-0.3467658758163452,
-0.015309274196624756,
-0.7200649976730347,
0.4122406840324402,
0.410187304019928,
-0.042244426906108856,
0.9759258031845093,
0.32140544056892395,
-0.7606688141822815,
-0.3919980227947235,
-0.42838814854621887,
0.20589621365070343,
-0.5929862260818481,
-0.5055209994316101,
0.041440799832344055,
-0.3267330825328827,
-0.8002814054489136,
-0.030687347054481506,
0.4534641206264496,
-0.3304860591888428,
0.15462785959243774,
0.46467190980911255,
0.2758174538612366,
-0.04188477247953415,
0.18022622168064117,
0.41539737582206726,
0.009977694600820541,
0.12782342731952667,
0.09828457981348038,
0.01624700240790844,
-0.220379039645195,
0.17310498654842377,
-0.2797491252422333,
0.7939849495887756,
0.9742280840873718,
-0.10506158322095871,
0.5747021436691284,
0.4838869571685791,
-0.3696616590023041,
0.00825154222548008,
-0.1786668300628662,
0.1823691874742508,
-0.34077656269073486,
-0.1085829883813858,
-0.4703579843044281,
-0.9441993236541748,
0.4031923711299896,
0.0022615822963416576,
-0.11060838401317596,
0.8035427331924438,
0.6443197131156921,
-0.5520949363708496,
0.30609050393104553,
0.6196044087409973,
-0.4114156663417816,
0.6314693093299866,
-0.1054556593298912,
-0.012835727073252201,
-0.6369293332099915,
-0.04135146364569664,
-0.9891847372055054,
-0.5429367423057556,
-0.4966591000556946,
-0.06982415169477463,
0.5912094116210938,
-0.07953879237174988,
0.03114059753715992,
-0.267514705657959,
-0.28266391158103943,
0.5492058396339417,
0.09688345342874527,
-0.1281053125858307,
0.07208063453435898,
0.21322618424892426,
-0.26568877696990967,
-0.25462907552719116,
-0.43979859352111816,
-0.36839836835861206,
0.7979782819747925,
0.2688565254211426,
0.5222168564796448,
0.032174237072467804,
0.8605822920799255,
0.6923869848251343,
0.1028071716427803,
-1.0853490829467773,
0.24013788998126984,
-0.12091252952814102,
-0.5625808238983154,
-0.26263442635536194,
-0.41791969537734985,
-0.9123845100402832,
0.22615432739257812,
-0.46921366453170776,
-0.5206608176231384,
0.6369073390960693,
-0.20146414637565613,
-0.3850351870059967,
0.043282400816679,
-0.4924863278865814,
0.9691460728645325,
-0.1320696920156479,
-0.40914207696914673,
-0.3756283223628998,
-0.6163825988769531,
0.3876844346523285,
-0.05005105957388878,
0.5847498774528503,
0.1500449776649475,
0.22495876252651215,
0.7076053619384766,
-0.29214614629745483,
0.8556637763977051,
-0.04850116744637489,
-0.1911260187625885,
0.4919659495353699,
0.5178791880607605,
-0.000721992168109864,
-0.44167229533195496,
-0.676153838634491,
0.10214431583881378,
0.6451744437217712,
-0.410023957490921,
-0.6227785348892212,
0.8387932181358337,
-0.7540789842605591,
0.256054550409317,
-0.7427265048027039,
-0.23579655587673187,
-0.019725065678358078,
0.005803814623504877,
0.2957998216152191,
0.5089029669761658,
-0.6165432333946228,
-0.08023816347122192,
0.3447963297367096,
-0.1685403436422348,
0.3871798515319824,
0.034720949828624725,
-0.2195838838815689,
-0.6371230483055115,
0.67080157995224,
-0.08104104548692703,
0.08455841988325119,
0.5143530368804932,
0.5746628642082214,
-0.33696889877319336,
-0.26126158237457275,
-0.30097708106040955,
0.22552792727947235,
-0.4650501012802124,
-0.009832588024437428,
-0.3598085045814514,
0.16481490433216095,
-0.1226494163274765,
-0.4355359673500061,
-0.12282058596611023,
-0.4798305928707123,
-0.29460838437080383,
0.1840084046125412,
0.6664357781410217,
0.9337540864944458,
0.2508929967880249,
0.2699337303638458,
-0.8823288083076477,
0.17108482122421265,
-0.06851767003536224,
0.2644819915294647,
0.13978557288646698,
-0.21155425906181335,
-0.41654539108276367,
-0.3237987160682678,
-0.13258127868175507,
-1.1305603981018066,
0.7710884809494019,
0.14243368804454803,
-0.3913610279560089,
0.24673321843147278,
0.5410383939743042,
0.1691950112581253,
-0.20673049986362457,
0.9002973437309265,
0.385329931974411,
-0.8829289674758911,
0.3921859860420227,
-0.5832077264785767,
0.5085330009460449,
0.9234021902084351,
0.7768722176551819,
-0.7646317481994629,
-0.07614816725254059,
-0.6490793824195862,
-0.5775664448738098,
0.4518067538738251,
0.35585910081863403,
0.14192470908164978,
0.20269407331943512,
0.5170731544494629,
0.1764293611049652,
0.28872549533843994,
-0.3381045162677765,
-0.05322744697332382,
0.21682021021842957,
-0.6878966689109802,
-0.35219693183898926,
-0.39329326152801514,
0.12291966378688812,
0.08758919686079025,
0.2645009756088257,
-0.05975070968270302,
0.39472243189811707,
0.25531303882598877,
-0.2463768571615219,
-0.20408889651298523,
0.2872057557106018,
0.20324383676052094,
0.1974741816520691,
-0.25774484872817993,
0.10419891029596329,
-0.1576555073261261,
-0.5062887668609619,
0.08607832342386246,
-0.24979695677757263,
-0.26887258887290955,
0.1667003631591797,
0.43016502261161804,
0.7594256401062012,
0.24209800362586975,
-0.6132281422615051,
0.353331059217453,
-0.0850749984383583,
-0.015420842915773392,
-0.5095592141151428,
-0.22901321947574615,
0.008411397226154804,
0.26049646735191345,
0.1289590448141098,
-0.14209648966789246,
0.5044234395027161,
-0.6967674493789673,
-0.15624579787254333,
0.12760843336582184,
-0.6926546096801758,
-0.33604252338409424,
-0.06212747469544411,
0.31518375873565674,
-0.27396008372306824,
0.39314085245132446,
-0.06931312382221222,
-0.6673226952552795,
0.8412935137748718,
0.09700614959001541,
1.202653169631958,
-0.20172367990016937,
0.3470393121242523,
0.328373521566391,
0.16394518315792084,
0.01920332759618759,
0.5645391345024109,
0.11403141170740128,
-0.50514817237854,
-0.4581702649593353,
-0.8658756613731384,
-0.7111697196960449,
-0.3024227023124695,
-0.6164836883544922,
0.18735097348690033,
-0.3885688781738281,
-0.10310441255569458,
-0.032414861023426056,
0.20365864038467407,
-0.29529720544815063,
0.16573360562324524,
0.35826048254966736,
0.4171849489212036,
-1.174575924873352,
0.3351890444755554,
0.891426146030426,
-0.04179760441184044,
-0.15776345133781433,
-0.2947288453578949,
0.3356529772281647,
0.125277578830719,
0.1845857799053192,
0.03153933212161064,
-0.2110338658094406,
-0.15896053612232208,
-0.4028078317642212,
-0.4306198060512543,
0.5134807229042053,
-0.005900582764297724,
-0.5946005582809448,
0.3045762777328491,
-0.11971194297075272,
0.9394317269325256,
-0.3859160542488098,
0.6412973999977112,
0.4095309376716614,
0.42047205567359924,
0.0972047969698906,
-0.582087516784668,
-0.36802396178245544,
-0.8023719191551208,
-0.2045237272977829,
0.6456082463264465,
-0.5654004812240601,
0.47765421867370605,
0.11271795630455017,
-0.021884286776185036,
0.23977069556713104,
0.6393133401870728,
-0.008303605020046234,
0.7106861472129822,
0.41479718685150146,
0.3471165597438812,
0.8254786133766174,
0.07045770436525345,
1.3780962228775024,
0.019950883463025093,
0.4486902058124542,
0.5110498070716858,
-0.34119296073913574,
1.0542126893997192,
0.3635243773460388,
-0.47492852807044983,
0.7127721309661865,
0.7236410975456238,
0.3917318284511566,
0.24785006046295166,
0.4225604236125946,
-0.39189860224723816,
0.03716112673282623,
-0.11729465425014496,
-0.2399085909128189,
0.22417235374450684,
0.33164840936660767,
-0.018657462671399117,
0.20844478905200958,
0.31430384516716003,
-0.005098167806863785,
0.2127740979194641,
-0.3998852074146271,
0.7679853439331055,
0.3825410306453705,
-0.36405327916145325,
0.5097932815551758,
-0.15424391627311707,
0.526846170425415,
-0.6491884589195251,
0.0990586206316948,
-0.23054778575897217,
-0.019389836117625237,
-0.324442595243454,
-0.7556236982345581,
0.33331555128097534,
0.1726294606924057,
-0.35820475220680237,
-0.0493602491915226,
1.009325385093689,
-0.30069079995155334,
-0.8434170484542847,
0.15561836957931519,
0.17689667642116547,
0.48940223455429077,
-0.3583691120147705,
-0.4959774911403656,
0.4519346356391907,
0.025477314367890358,
-0.2536547780036926,
0.3990609645843506,
0.6681689620018005,
0.08998896926641464,
0.145321786403656,
0.23025710880756378,
0.10543347150087357,
-0.4006076753139496,
-0.023993689566850662,
0.600517213344574,
-1.0707683563232422,
-0.5793041586875916,
-0.8417108654975891,
0.8205108046531677,
0.21206966042518616,
-0.5736585855484009,
0.36619922518730164,
0.255292683839798,
-0.0007581649115309119,
-0.34649980068206787,
0.8838406205177307,
-0.11246267706155777,
0.22563807666301727,
-0.498061865568161,
0.7407048344612122,
-0.6049031019210815,
-0.21814587712287903,
-0.8078231811523438,
-0.9646164178848267,
-0.352994441986084,
0.6368589401245117,
-0.34687602519989014,
-0.4532422721385956,
0.8415666222572327,
0.4175661504268646,
0.1840025633573532,
0.4915599822998047,
0.1859320104122162,
0.26638126373291016,
-0.28435781598091125,
0.4141356945037842,
1.2477738857269287,
-0.34223705530166626,
-0.3550201952457428,
-0.07911759614944458,
-0.4768555164337158,
-0.2910419702529907,
-1.0873181819915771,
-0.6003575921058655,
-0.6827744841575623,
-0.37118300795555115,
-0.31098759174346924,
0.08258569240570068,
0.6896930932998657,
-0.2504298686981201,
-0.6280686259269714,
-0.5444285869598389,
0.5711008906364441,
0.3205748498439789,
-0.10196233540773392,
-0.17586511373519897,
0.45459556579589844,
-0.3368387818336487,
-0.6529942750930786,
0.12078037112951279,
0.3426459729671478,
-0.33017364144325256,
-0.3551325500011444,
0.08477721363306046,
0.03922925144433975,
0.20270796120166779,
0.745837390422821,
0.10487032681703568,
-0.20461998879909515,
0.22471722960472107,
-0.062367793172597885,
-0.0003863963356707245,
0.07100685685873032,
1.1052659749984741,
-0.72322016954422,
0.8753311038017273,
0.9409864544868469,
0.5251935124397278,
0.7419370412826538,
-0.28462257981300354,
0.6333205103874207,
-0.31355711817741394,
-0.03069949336349964,
0.5297534465789795,
0.31261637806892395,
0.2470293790102005,
-0.6813934445381165,
0.416008859872818,
0.13007798790931702,
-0.3592376112937927,
-0.6800361275672913,
-0.016932083293795586,
-1.0546971559524536,
-0.48025766015052795,
1.0286848545074463,
-0.1008259654045105,
-0.6661548018455505,
0.1269574761390686,
-0.4267594814300537,
-0.18135033547878265,
-0.19212032854557037,
0.6570800542831421,
0.9469689130783081,
-0.048790641129016876,
0.025480909273028374,
-0.3187541663646698,
0.3270421028137207,
0.5852906703948975,
-0.8420770764350891,
0.11617245525121689,
0.7650406956672668,
-0.2600504755973816,
0.35885265469551086,
0.4270360469818115,
-0.4530024826526642,
0.016493888571858406,
-0.026836518198251724,
0.5157061219215393,
0.38745346665382385,
-0.4021186828613281,
-1.0587633848190308,
0.41106587648391724,
-0.06903920322656631,
0.41056445240974426
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.01014v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.01014v1
|
Mobile-Agent-v2: Mobile Device Operation Assistant with Effective Navigation via Multi-Agent Collaboration
| 2024-06-03T05:50:00 | 2024-06-03T05:50:00 |
Junyang Wang, Haiyang Xu, Haitao Jia, Xi Zhang, Ming Yan, Weizhou Shen, Ji Zhang, Fei Huang, Jitao Sang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CV
|
Mobile device operation tasks are increasingly becoming a popular multi-modal
AI application scenario. Current Multi-modal Large Language Models (MLLMs),
constrained by their training data, lack the capability to function effectively
as operation assistants. Instead, MLLM-based agents, which enhance capabilities
through tool invocation, are gradually being applied to this scenario. However,
the two major navigation challenges in mobile device operation tasks, task
progress navigation and focus content navigation, are significantly complicated
under the single-agent architecture of existing work. This is due to the overly
long token sequences and the interleaved text-image data format, which limit
performance. To address these navigation challenges effectively, we propose
Mobile-Agent-v2, a multi-agent architecture for mobile device operation
assistance. The architecture comprises three agents: planning agent, decision
agent, and reflection agent. The planning agent generates task progress, making
the navigation of history operations more efficient. To retain focus content,
we design a memory unit that updates with task progress. Additionally, to
correct erroneous operations, the reflection agent observes the outcomes of
each operation and handles any mistakes accordingly. Experimental results
indicate that Mobile-Agent-v2 achieves over a 30% improvement in task
completion compared to the single-agent architecture of Mobile-Agent. The code
is open-sourced at https://github.com/X-PLUG/MobileAgent.
|
[
-0.279367595911026,
-0.45414382219314575,
0.6749289631843567,
0.36345699429512024,
-0.5127971768379211,
0.10248814523220062,
0.019972627982497215,
-0.40536805987358093,
0.32977378368377686,
0.5036119222640991,
-0.4175553619861603,
-0.3685626685619354,
-0.41364163160324097,
-0.29205432534217834,
-0.07437730580568314,
0.7507652044296265,
-0.09995568543672562,
-0.06505364924669266,
-0.4113749563694,
-0.36990928649902344,
-0.9831672310829163,
-0.35272613167762756,
-0.7380487322807312,
-0.30008870363235474,
0.5143518447875977,
0.6426096558570862,
0.9443528652191162,
0.5965756177902222,
0.4982593059539795,
0.36197805404663086,
0.3196888864040375,
0.700960636138916,
-0.2167339026927948,
0.39486128091812134,
-0.11459086835384369,
-0.22560524940490723,
-0.8651672005653381,
-0.34614700078964233,
0.3133966326713562,
0.014152580872178078,
-0.14331483840942383,
-0.20128239691257477,
-0.04753617197275162,
0.6921002864837646,
-0.46619242429733276,
0.20148234069347382,
-0.4283028841018677,
-0.22008484601974487,
0.04948846623301506,
-0.10619687288999557,
-0.3646456003189087,
0.013652498833835125,
0.06042936444282532,
-0.6027946472167969,
-0.24434621632099152,
-0.3243425488471985,
0.4290129244327545,
0.7486679553985596,
-0.7848313450813293,
-0.33375364542007446,
-0.8755102753639221,
0.4779581129550934,
0.014919073320925236,
0.5136576890945435,
0.5852156281471252,
0.16978801786899567,
-0.1119488924741745,
-0.7957971692085266,
-0.5039175152778625,
-0.1997401863336563,
0.004876600578427315,
0.11385289579629898,
0.04788899049162865,
-0.0076905507594347,
-0.2130012959241867,
-0.29639533162117004,
-0.5153663158416748,
-0.05523515120148659,
-0.27434322237968445,
-0.1631353348493576,
0.5929946303367615,
0.10420696437358856,
0.10486949235200882,
0.3662475049495697,
-0.7319169044494629,
0.17982102930545807,
-0.6413500308990479,
0.08964411169290543,
-0.17918460071086884,
0.0775832012295723,
-0.1816631406545639,
0.507384181022644,
-0.26287010312080383,
0.4296395778656006,
-0.1815742701292038,
-0.38700172305107117,
0.6602714657783508,
-0.767246663570404,
-0.17585070431232452,
0.019129257649183273,
0.6052267551422119,
0.5856407284736633,
-0.279262512922287,
-0.40953153371810913,
-0.32535919547080994,
-0.16013586521148682,
0.6311753988265991,
-0.7932184338569641,
0.15854881703853607,
0.4063401520252228,
-0.412477970123291,
-0.042820610105991364,
0.030123213306069374,
-0.31895318627357483,
-0.6046520471572876,
0.02202293463051319,
0.4370712637901306,
-0.23562386631965637,
-0.40911561250686646,
-0.014576896093785763,
-0.039034489542245865,
0.28723716735839844,
0.5799182057380676,
-0.35955649614334106,
0.2630167007446289,
0.6460322141647339,
1.0336275100708008,
-0.22951410710811615,
-0.4817562401294708,
-0.9350252747535706,
0.38965320587158203,
-0.07491248100996017,
0.6010632514953613,
-0.4275754392147064,
-0.7873128652572632,
-0.07248649001121521,
0.10159964114427567,
-0.17868773639202118,
-0.407205730676651,
0.8309823274612427,
-0.529267430305481,
-0.18129640817642212,
-0.23207102715969086,
-0.13795243203639984,
-0.5225332975387573,
0.289966344833374,
-0.7093830704689026,
0.9718927145004272,
0.006989183370023966,
0.008372164331376553,
0.05737632140517235,
-0.8907467722892761,
-0.8395621180534363,
-0.010902614332735538,
-0.18672125041484833,
-0.5541653633117676,
-0.12037956714630127,
-0.01367854792624712,
0.34376785159111023,
-0.4240582585334778,
-0.18074293434619904,
-0.025057749822735786,
-0.4817701280117035,
-0.0925971269607544,
-0.047737378627061844,
0.39769697189331055,
0.02728084847331047,
-0.6934086084365845,
0.1342114359140396,
-0.47895342111587524,
-0.018290715292096138,
-0.07652632147073746,
-0.335122287273407,
-0.3973269760608673,
0.3078169822692871,
-0.04940085858106613,
0.3916690945625305,
0.5189096927642822,
-0.3282720744609833,
0.6005114316940308,
0.20701225101947784,
0.18817348778247833,
0.25863176584243774,
-0.13938423991203308,
0.733679473400116,
-0.22123640775680542,
0.3220633864402771,
0.09936513751745224,
0.3322444260120392,
-0.3572826087474823,
-0.7782766222953796,
-0.4017601013183594,
-0.29927101731300354,
0.0003768442547880113,
0.8371879458427429,
-1.077364206314087,
-0.033754318952560425,
-0.2806262671947479,
-0.5739465951919556,
-0.248367577791214,
0.33955514430999756,
0.6578919291496277,
0.45405495166778564,
0.33828654885292053,
-0.3349185287952423,
-0.29910019040107727,
-0.5880406498908997,
0.1379128247499466,
-0.2512706518173218,
0.1666441559791565,
0.5378156900405884,
0.209565207362175,
-0.7032331824302673,
0.6917863488197327,
-0.09762503951787949,
-0.6887608766555786,
0.11926379054784775,
0.07934592664241791,
-0.26265913248062134,
0.6556049585342407,
0.34670326113700867,
-1.220112919807434,
-0.433788001537323,
0.5069074034690857,
-0.8182807564735413,
0.1666310727596283,
-0.12356548756361008,
-0.07167138159275055,
0.6047348976135254,
0.30865857005119324,
-1.0757044553756714,
0.3058694303035736,
0.3590069115161896,
-0.38931915163993835,
0.31424856185913086,
-0.40637877583503723,
0.09016504138708115,
-0.9499166011810303,
0.011004210449755192,
-0.31717973947525024,
-0.2805913984775543,
-0.6995435953140259,
0.20862743258476257,
0.1529487818479538,
0.09228625893592834,
-0.430090993642807,
0.4730592370033264,
-0.612095832824707,
-0.2013363093137741,
-0.6159994006156921,
0.3390796184539795,
-0.04799768328666687,
0.44090890884399414,
0.12668083608150482,
0.9855185747146606,
0.41025176644325256,
-0.6015838980674744,
0.3835255801677704,
0.14900337159633636,
0.37329089641571045,
0.48852425813674927,
-0.5022909641265869,
0.6217662692070007,
-0.04508863389492035,
0.1320151686668396,
-0.953271746635437,
-0.09564629197120667,
0.36549752950668335,
-0.36673980951309204,
-0.02665567211806774,
-0.2557169497013092,
-0.35132524371147156,
-0.022978609427809715,
-0.36513009667396545,
0.4383503198623657,
0.4361518621444702,
-0.38183048367500305,
1.2208189964294434,
0.4812506139278412,
-0.07356920838356018,
-0.7226738929748535,
-0.33675330877304077,
0.17672330141067505,
0.03828451409935951,
-0.817487359046936,
0.5177174210548401,
0.061421383172273636,
-0.13231432437896729,
0.1410377323627472,
-0.3290356695652008,
-0.2801594138145447,
-0.0730341449379921,
0.753122866153717,
0.33975929021835327,
-0.11403239518404007,
0.33340004086494446,
0.22272416949272156,
-0.11806672066450119,
-0.10704056918621063,
-0.1873481571674347,
0.5283433198928833,
-0.11075776070356369,
-0.12567639350891113,
-0.3798867464065552,
0.36019086837768555,
0.9824000000953674,
-0.6295676231384277,
0.472072035074234,
0.682115912437439,
-0.29546287655830383,
0.21270635724067688,
-0.4993375539779663,
-0.015889238566160202,
-0.48213231563568115,
0.4417947828769684,
-0.8227997422218323,
-0.36309194564819336,
0.3875977694988251,
-0.20364788174629211,
0.23959922790527344,
0.01976088434457779,
0.7419301867485046,
-0.1346108764410019,
1.0841753482818604,
0.4867098331451416,
-0.012307364493608475,
0.4961814284324646,
-0.25259047746658325,
-0.09316948056221008,
-0.7236958146095276,
-0.7829142808914185,
-0.31990766525268555,
-0.05037407949566841,
-0.3140850365161896,
-0.9145186543464661,
0.5585902333259583,
-0.10986126959323883,
0.0014114371733739972,
0.3487136662006378,
-0.20872020721435547,
0.13867244124412537,
0.571090817451477,
0.3150329291820526,
0.2846756875514984,
-0.04709285870194435,
0.28647923469543457,
0.4196101427078247,
-0.5736297965049744,
-0.5374215841293335,
1.0060011148452759,
0.3969942629337311,
0.6158963441848755,
0.3201638460159302,
0.6235406994819641,
0.4464011788368225,
-0.058277677744627,
-0.7950125336647034,
0.6242284774780273,
0.09929241985082626,
-0.2959281802177429,
-0.3975506126880646,
0.030557120218873024,
-0.8297907710075378,
0.7236319184303284,
0.07428854703903198,
-0.4575461745262146,
0.2785407602787018,
0.11851782351732254,
-0.2552727460861206,
-0.11214582622051239,
-0.9401931762695312,
0.956843376159668,
-0.2420274317264557,
-0.7626902461051941,
-0.5330783128738403,
-0.75428307056427,
0.12040157616138458,
-0.07175016403198242,
0.09568195790052414,
0.1772415190935135,
-0.6779709458351135,
0.20882396399974823,
-0.6025364995002747,
0.44771653413772583,
-0.5254702568054199,
-0.23458553850650787,
0.5120190382003784,
-0.008493644185364246,
1.0506809949874878,
0.14646732807159424,
-0.028208279982209206,
-0.21684414148330688,
-0.30302807688713074,
-0.3431699573993683,
-0.6594523787498474,
0.5506723523139954,
-0.544032871723175,
-0.25362059473991394,
-0.13153211772441864,
-0.4357776939868927,
-0.08766677230596542,
0.33055874705314636,
-0.13539966940879822,
0.570818305015564,
-0.10912609100341797,
0.12971970438957214,
0.44099605083465576,
0.21672162413597107,
0.6132351160049438,
0.3835826814174652,
-0.12986847758293152,
-0.23935948312282562,
1.1662174463272095,
0.008090437389910221,
0.029717357829213142,
0.2912624776363373,
-0.36572182178497314,
-0.5951170921325684,
-0.6564266681671143,
-0.9431551098823547,
-0.08392348885536194,
-0.24683377146720886,
-0.13320179283618927,
-0.7090921401977539,
0.17858396470546722,
-0.022275662049651146,
0.06332956254482269,
-0.6097888946533203,
-0.18654993176460266,
-0.2188514918088913,
0.3297679126262665,
-0.05779417231678963,
0.6227244138717651,
0.01485465932637453,
0.694196343421936,
-0.7387059330940247,
0.4967341125011444,
0.4453018009662628,
0.1467958688735962,
-0.15454871952533722,
0.01226920448243618,
-0.44203200936317444,
0.14040228724479675,
-0.3564198613166809,
-0.8263325691223145,
-0.2621680796146393,
-0.0072424933314323425,
0.47042927145957947,
0.5432827472686768,
-0.22307318449020386,
0.3957259953022003,
-0.3497687578201294,
0.5942074656486511,
0.10836917161941528,
-0.6578941941261292,
0.16956080496311188,
-0.23752504587173462,
0.19422473013401031,
0.39542850852012634,
-0.04895171895623207,
-0.28654757142066956,
-0.11386097222566605,
-0.17052224278450012,
-0.7206282615661621,
0.696651041507721,
0.2584078311920166,
-0.06618815660476685,
0.3760589361190796,
0.14503242075443268,
-0.07754139602184296,
0.4538542330265045,
-0.23356901109218597,
-0.40410029888153076,
-0.2704971134662628,
0.07216443866491318,
-0.017814483493566513,
-0.29426640272140503,
-0.04096509516239166,
0.05527648702263832,
0.6878296732902527,
-0.11268241703510284,
0.4199584126472473,
0.3666418492794037,
-0.5136770009994507,
0.16308903694152832,
0.05215882137417793,
1.2689505815505981,
0.4913106858730316,
-0.004426830448210239,
0.1304984986782074,
0.02535182423889637,
-0.8176056742668152,
0.3874761760234833,
0.40512946248054504,
-0.07223596423864365,
0.14323405921459198,
0.01745576038956642,
0.6332623362541199,
-0.268008291721344,
-0.670978844165802,
0.5358262062072754,
-0.08424131572246552,
0.03274315223097801,
-0.27134305238723755,
-0.03754639998078346,
0.10024251788854599,
0.7148986458778381,
0.5212308168411255,
0.30470970273017883,
0.40968799591064453,
-0.699405312538147,
0.1127268522977829,
0.42085400223731995,
-0.37412652373313904,
-0.18722665309906006,
0.558610200881958,
0.5632674694061279,
-0.7011157274246216,
0.23641729354858398,
-0.6359434723854065,
-0.5074886679649353,
0.8135077357292175,
0.3308119475841522,
0.7626835107803345,
-0.4215202331542969,
0.44628772139549255,
-0.07150642573833466,
0.4889009892940521,
-0.08572681248188019,
0.5655247569084167,
-0.14358706772327423,
-0.4170694649219513,
-0.39978063106536865,
0.07428373396396637,
-0.20753492414951324,
-0.206952303647995,
-0.22518348693847656,
0.14456817507743835,
-0.08509980142116547,
-0.2210778146982193,
-0.4032828211784363,
-0.19510625302791595,
-0.520571768283844,
0.26393160223960876,
-0.06052767112851143,
0.6945217847824097,
-0.06557255238294601,
1.0809742212295532,
1.094862699508667,
-0.31602486968040466,
-0.5782346725463867,
-0.06130708009004593,
-0.038531895726919174,
-0.4701220989227295,
0.24964919686317444,
0.2143978625535965,
-0.5503952503204346,
-0.1329360008239746,
0.09288156032562256,
-0.603908896446228,
1.2318947315216064,
0.031746163964271545,
-0.6004241704940796,
-0.09195873141288757,
0.03968515992164612,
0.29240110516548157,
-0.4773440361022949,
0.28789618611335754,
0.3372063636779785,
0.6081697344779968,
-0.008287169970571995,
-1.0964460372924805,
0.21194888651371002,
-0.24802806973457336,
-0.17390595376491547,
0.3557536005973816,
-0.8678373098373413,
0.6477929353713989,
-0.6142010688781738,
0.16274797916412354,
0.259596586227417,
0.3976860046386719,
0.09019793570041656,
0.8235039114952087,
0.6706625819206238,
0.2853722870349884,
0.6726651787757874,
0.12736310064792633,
0.5780407190322876,
-0.3337630033493042,
0.18074597418308258,
1.2235912084579468,
-0.4356624484062195,
0.6286200284957886,
0.45831498503685,
0.2387046366930008,
0.40012893080711365,
0.2821393311023712,
0.3106330633163452,
0.7529714703559875,
-0.448292076587677,
-0.5840039849281311,
0.015758134424686432,
-0.17717139422893524,
-0.43302327394485474,
0.7411589622497559,
0.12194803357124329,
-0.3160279393196106,
-0.05328768491744995,
0.28111493587493896,
0.10888403654098511,
-0.3173600733280182,
-0.5165795683860779,
0.8325080275535583,
-0.18510961532592773,
-0.7429014444351196,
0.35542887449264526,
0.1985274851322174,
0.2666265070438385,
-0.37970831990242004,
-0.29868414998054504,
-0.11763788014650345,
0.1547011137008667,
-0.2219172716140747,
-0.5230185389518738,
0.09700098633766174,
-0.415788471698761,
-0.2587893009185791,
0.18292856216430664,
1.0031771659851074,
-0.4915368854999542,
0.1369299292564392,
0.21555101871490479,
0.8219025135040283,
0.09813374280929565,
-0.4903446137905121,
-0.45679813623428345,
0.4355138838291168,
-0.1705164760351181,
-0.01837850920855999,
0.0164474043995142,
0.05840364098548889,
-0.20381924510002136,
0.7161321640014648,
0.35303938388824463,
-0.3651164174079895,
0.1315295696258545,
-0.19559843838214874,
0.8011642694473267,
-0.40786436200141907,
-0.4384375810623169,
-0.7903962135314941,
0.7180211544036865,
-0.3233274221420288,
-0.16586752235889435,
0.4487259089946747,
0.9128952622413635,
0.4704671800136566,
0.05676494911313057,
0.8157534599304199,
-0.3192998468875885,
-0.09114780277013779,
-0.28801366686820984,
0.5473111271858215,
-0.8306360244750977,
0.04424480348825455,
-0.027524344623088837,
-0.843477725982666,
0.15786316990852356,
0.4702706038951874,
0.1037348061800003,
0.08679120987653732,
0.5757826566696167,
0.8292474150657654,
-0.17262406647205353,
-0.18427930772304535,
0.2712768018245697,
-0.06951827555894852,
0.14997598528862,
0.5193579792976379,
0.6230579614639282,
-0.6077765822410583,
0.7191590070724487,
-0.185911625623703,
-0.162217915058136,
-0.4557667672634125,
-0.37865445017814636,
-0.7641434073448181,
-0.7903363108634949,
-0.03645063564181328,
-0.41381385922431946,
0.32283198833465576,
0.8903788924217224,
0.9069749712944031,
-0.022025054320693016,
-0.2925122380256653,
0.06153702363371849,
0.38173624873161316,
-0.33526819944381714,
-0.07615935057401657,
0.17391782999038696,
-0.09390141814947128,
-0.7481849193572998,
0.699588418006897,
0.5095281004905701,
-0.08363264799118042,
-0.25183337926864624,
-0.5767826437950134,
0.030988464131951332,
-0.1388804018497467,
1.0309051275253296,
0.34374675154685974,
-0.560665488243103,
-0.09645874053239822,
-0.058807067573070526,
-0.27501386404037476,
0.13252045214176178,
0.749927818775177,
-0.665691614151001,
0.5726878046989441,
0.13704733550548553,
0.7948167324066162,
0.5148015022277832,
0.09000536799430847,
0.32375895977020264,
-0.44910845160484314,
0.33687400817871094,
-0.10229845345020294,
0.10814695060253143,
-0.03037678264081478,
-0.3512762784957886,
0.7237277626991272,
0.10201709717512131,
-0.46968382596969604,
-0.8192340135574341,
0.21860657632350922,
-1.2110081911087036,
-0.05153457820415497,
1.1094944477081299,
-0.0630178302526474,
-0.08682148158550262,
-0.36560168862342834,
-0.8136239051818848,
0.14062488079071045,
-0.8334130048751831,
0.5091403722763062,
0.2393326610326767,
-0.2403932809829712,
-0.3643800616264343,
-0.5272314548492432,
0.2861490249633789,
0.3615645468235016,
-0.9378105401992798,
-0.3662106990814209,
0.40872153639793396,
-0.03825388848781586,
0.2708323299884796,
0.9067806005477905,
0.19538073241710663,
0.8499139547348022,
0.09658538550138474,
0.13119487464427948,
-0.4882882535457611,
-0.6825087070465088,
-0.08909671008586884,
0.3105411231517792,
0.09856816381216049,
-0.842877984046936
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.06565v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.06565v1
|
MixEval: Deriving Wisdom of the Crowd from LLM Benchmark Mixtures
| 2024-06-03T05:47:05 | 2024-06-03T05:47:05 |
Jinjie Ni, Fuzhao Xue, Xiang Yue, Yuntian Deng, Mahir Shah, Kabir Jain, Graham Neubig, Yang You
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Evaluating large language models (LLMs) is challenging. Traditional
ground-truth-based benchmarks fail to capture the comprehensiveness and nuance
of real-world queries, while LLM-as-judge benchmarks suffer from grading biases
and limited query quantity. Both of them may also become contaminated over
time. User-facing evaluation, such as Chatbot Arena, provides reliable signals
but is costly and slow. In this work, we propose MixEval, a new paradigm for
establishing efficient, gold-standard LLM evaluation by strategically mixing
off-the-shelf benchmarks. It bridges (1) comprehensive and well-distributed
real-world user queries and (2) efficient and fairly-graded ground-truth-based
benchmarks, by matching queries mined from the web with similar queries from
existing benchmarks. Based on MixEval, we further build MixEval-Hard, which
offers more room for model improvement. Our benchmarks' advantages lie in (1) a
0.96 model ranking correlation with Chatbot Arena arising from the highly
impartial query distribution and grading mechanism, (2) fast, cheap, and
reproducible execution (6% of the time and cost of MMLU), and (3) dynamic
evaluation enabled by the rapid and stable data update pipeline. We provide
extensive meta-evaluation and analysis for our and existing LLM benchmarks to
deepen the community's understanding of LLM evaluation and guide future
research directions.
|
[
-0.29351386427879333,
-0.604591429233551,
0.2774358093738556,
0.3532750904560089,
-0.13922260701656342,
0.42390918731689453,
-0.4877375066280365,
-0.40321415662765503,
0.07012797892093658,
0.48545151948928833,
-0.42899543046951294,
-0.451052725315094,
-0.46180686354637146,
-0.21272805333137512,
-0.4558131694793701,
0.6941739916801453,
0.24630089104175568,
0.10656355321407318,
-0.3396615982055664,
-0.4018109440803528,
-0.22121480107307434,
-0.6185723543167114,
-0.1354368031024933,
-0.3302678167819977,
0.2657232880592346,
0.3540613651275635,
0.8480026125907898,
0.40890392661094666,
0.4587123990058899,
0.3929273188114166,
-0.14077940583229065,
0.49118947982788086,
-0.8480560183525085,
0.1808859258890152,
-0.041941456496715546,
-0.26201683282852173,
-0.3950307369232178,
0.2510796785354614,
0.49255818128585815,
0.8653258085250854,
-0.6889387965202332,
0.10208286345005035,
0.1660587340593338,
0.7304019927978516,
-0.9152857065200806,
-0.12436188757419586,
-1.0672798156738281,
-0.2290084809064865,
-0.24429449439048767,
-0.2730277180671692,
-0.44328370690345764,
-0.49298739433288574,
0.10296444594860077,
-0.39799895882606506,
-0.12970519065856934,
0.13575203716754913,
0.5308285355567932,
0.14959858357906342,
-0.1624118834733963,
-0.31095200777053833,
-0.5637892484664917,
0.8901278376579285,
-0.6914335489273071,
0.586889386177063,
0.13068631291389465,
0.8747564554214478,
-0.3107004165649414,
-0.7421138882637024,
-0.6156117916107178,
-0.2418607771396637,
0.31558161973953247,
0.1556587815284729,
-0.21318316459655762,
-0.2955116629600525,
-0.23305785655975342,
0.3996601402759552,
-0.29542529582977295,
-0.12632447481155396,
-0.25688451528549194,
-0.06260122358798981,
0.7896513342857361,
0.23485067486763,
0.10598087310791016,
-0.08778035640716553,
-0.4642651677131653,
-0.125357985496521,
-0.779047429561615,
-0.32601398229599,
0.2152128666639328,
0.2499849796295166,
-0.008111312985420227,
0.5076113343238831,
-0.3252332806587219,
0.5804712772369385,
-0.006154158618301153,
-0.2555808424949646,
0.40733814239501953,
-0.302528977394104,
-0.2528596520423889,
-0.16704413294792175,
0.9828580021858215,
0.6514269709587097,
0.23426702618598938,
-0.3258054256439209,
-0.24542784690856934,
-0.026458123698830605,
0.051418423652648926,
-0.774964451789856,
-0.16069963574409485,
0.1698131561279297,
-0.4151979982852936,
-0.46726956963539124,
-0.134758859872818,
-0.7980798482894897,
-0.7137325406074524,
-0.28879064321517944,
0.3519546389579773,
-0.3270323872566223,
-0.32457131147384644,
0.056908704340457916,
0.02870502695441246,
0.28073444962501526,
0.683600127696991,
-0.5959635972976685,
0.5741975903511047,
1.0239028930664062,
0.7827183604240417,
-0.2836654484272003,
-0.2246643602848053,
-0.6831035614013672,
-0.1269015520811081,
-0.27002206444740295,
0.9386846423149109,
-0.6999193429946899,
-0.4380642771720886,
0.11834894120693207,
-0.4285948872566223,
-0.07524488866329193,
-1.1065711975097656,
0.6269428133964539,
-0.6692348718643188,
0.23431125283241272,
-0.15828517079353333,
-0.634405255317688,
0.05717378109693527,
0.3268555998802185,
-0.44443005323410034,
1.2320035696029663,
0.07863008975982666,
-0.5101853013038635,
0.5869982838630676,
-0.3029007315635681,
-0.2683548331260681,
0.3801172077655792,
-0.16564905643463135,
0.18478260934352875,
-0.00011621527664829046,
0.2923639118671417,
0.11778710782527924,
-0.44000035524368286,
0.4827421307563782,
-0.5865657329559326,
-0.35204949975013733,
0.4208104610443115,
-0.6233482360839844,
0.6886570453643799,
0.28576841950416565,
-0.1940504014492035,
0.15620040893554688,
-0.7233115434646606,
0.13794748485088348,
-0.19471056759357452,
-0.4320894777774811,
-0.43448805809020996,
0.35801899433135986,
0.33857181668281555,
0.254876971244812,
0.10882379114627838,
-0.2759832739830017,
0.06956018507480621,
-0.309095561504364,
0.22242994606494904,
0.8682096600532532,
-0.3122805953025818,
0.2570241093635559,
-0.4045713543891907,
0.37857967615127563,
-0.21549996733665466,
0.043087977916002274,
-0.016516637057065964,
-0.3755975067615509,
-0.9028605222702026,
-0.41196975111961365,
0.33087611198425293,
0.4769650995731354,
-0.5637186765670776,
0.5697144269943237,
-0.4361100196838379,
-0.8095434308052063,
-1.2529449462890625,
0.4047392010688782,
0.13651017844676971,
0.38721078634262085,
0.37128013372421265,
-0.08030224591493607,
-0.46116432547569275,
-0.6383956074714661,
-0.5169118642807007,
-0.2947487235069275,
-0.20661351084709167,
0.5590866804122925,
0.22494104504585266,
-0.19202624261379242,
0.9058420062065125,
-0.2840688228607178,
-0.07221008837223053,
-0.30844011902809143,
0.03151140362024307,
0.30120334029197693,
0.17649683356285095,
0.07917182147502899,
-0.5726701021194458,
-0.49842262268066406,
0.001100051449611783,
-0.7586187124252319,
-0.39317840337753296,
0.3189930319786072,
-0.21393248438835144,
-0.09882624447345734,
0.3733850419521332,
-0.37082695960998535,
0.0025231181643903255,
0.6313127279281616,
-0.23656806349754333,
0.40653958916664124,
-0.017632577568292618,
0.3014669716358185,
-0.888428807258606,
-0.13301610946655273,
-0.1346810907125473,
-0.5732027292251587,
-0.31884875893592834,
0.3419906198978424,
0.06056147813796997,
0.00353681156411767,
-0.5332070589065552,
0.6490354537963867,
-0.2734273374080658,
-0.05381130054593086,
-0.31933945417404175,
0.5950156450271606,
-0.046605389565229416,
0.13420435786247253,
-0.20203104615211487,
0.8633100390434265,
0.3704524040222168,
-0.5188835263252258,
0.45352664589881897,
-0.006397052202373743,
-0.5767097473144531,
0.6993353962898254,
-0.8197290301322937,
0.18256373703479767,
0.13303884863853455,
0.3811053931713104,
-0.9573501348495483,
-0.13661083579063416,
0.02087949402630329,
-0.30847445130348206,
-0.04485858231782913,
-0.20606794953346252,
-0.6095424294471741,
-0.05119303613901138,
-0.3942641615867615,
0.3114469647407532,
0.7053512930870056,
-0.8386987447738647,
0.523326575756073,
0.7123522162437439,
0.07747970521450043,
-0.5158339738845825,
-0.5457502603530884,
0.22079797089099884,
-0.15707352757453918,
-1.1207752227783203,
0.32303088903427124,
-0.2548939883708954,
-0.7937103509902954,
-0.2035869061946869,
-0.03149431198835373,
0.13435901701450348,
0.06644351035356522,
0.07065852731466293,
0.18848328292369843,
-0.2098429948091507,
-0.030254146084189415,
-0.3462107181549072,
-0.09787935018539429,
-0.20066654682159424,
-0.07149888575077057,
0.6571751832962036,
-0.4088349938392639,
-0.6640307307243347,
-0.13804319500923157,
0.011108708567917347,
0.6238590478897095,
-0.16246306896209717,
0.5077043175697327,
0.2762485146522522,
-0.1678192913532257,
-0.31250008940696716,
-1.0350273847579956,
-0.04029170796275139,
-0.5362536907196045,
0.25863662362098694,
-0.1365337073802948,
-0.8200303912162781,
0.4735819697380066,
-0.21293647587299347,
0.28581494092941284,
0.3480711877346039,
0.8827274441719055,
-0.002926559653133154,
0.7344814538955688,
0.19572007656097412,
-0.14852194488048553,
0.19212426245212555,
0.20382484793663025,
-0.21221034228801727,
-0.6952089667320251,
-0.23700985312461853,
-0.4246782660484314,
-0.32864636182785034,
-0.5689017176628113,
-0.8899813890457153,
0.3522608280181885,
-0.0018765762215480208,
0.17033645510673523,
-0.04757974296808243,
-0.10274241119623184,
0.6405186653137207,
0.3110213875770569,
0.03897013142704964,
0.6321057677268982,
-0.14507290720939636,
-0.15703845024108887,
-0.09594926983118057,
-0.5002803802490234,
-0.5934273600578308,
1.331571340560913,
0.2338607758283615,
0.8455354571342468,
0.28499799966812134,
0.7057178020477295,
0.5489009618759155,
0.6807815432548523,
-0.737866997718811,
0.6315487623214722,
0.01937120221555233,
-0.6954246759414673,
0.09976205974817276,
-0.5933011770248413,
-0.8247294425964355,
1.0291144847869873,
-0.22124895453453064,
-0.6391054391860962,
-0.00186910480260849,
-0.1650552600622177,
-0.014220836572349072,
0.11159408092498779,
-0.6716046929359436,
0.6856133341789246,
-0.2247571051120758,
-0.6589683294296265,
-0.36073189973831177,
-0.36939120292663574,
0.6071038246154785,
0.014486357569694519,
0.6046363115310669,
-0.3174613118171692,
-0.09839971363544464,
0.6905302405357361,
-0.7414589524269104,
0.5204557180404663,
-0.031913671642541885,
-0.03187868371605873,
0.33198413252830505,
-0.032430581748485565,
0.40466251969337463,
0.08555890619754791,
-0.38037610054016113,
0.037914685904979706,
-0.20372653007507324,
-0.3660142719745636,
-0.6000667810440063,
0.9235743284225464,
-0.8839228749275208,
-0.4637534022331238,
-0.3517310917377472,
-0.3985181152820587,
-0.38543981313705444,
-0.12137816101312637,
-0.17394116520881653,
0.40932178497314453,
-0.3905051052570343,
0.330984503030777,
0.5025568008422852,
-0.076533243060112,
0.3307982385158539,
0.8434022068977356,
-0.4846951365470886,
-0.6130051016807556,
0.7286840677261353,
-0.08286464214324951,
0.2999005615711212,
0.16976261138916016,
0.2672363817691803,
-0.2982993423938751,
-0.27746373414993286,
-0.4273279309272766,
0.022661078721284866,
-0.7488276958465576,
-0.08359640836715698,
-0.6023187637329102,
-0.1002102717757225,
-0.17446914315223694,
-0.04010602831840515,
-0.6541233062744141,
-0.21859069168567657,
0.16707929968833923,
0.11176013946533203,
0.13190610706806183,
0.4395267069339752,
0.14069963991641998,
0.24861176311969757,
-0.6953932046890259,
0.13007774949073792,
0.35587114095687866,
0.30494096875190735,
0.17554046213626862,
-0.5748211741447449,
0.11099891364574432,
-0.033826470375061035,
-0.26315227150917053,
-0.7568824291229248,
0.3034728169441223,
0.2154599130153656,
0.8413888216018677,
0.4115685820579529,
0.010864675045013428,
0.9956775903701782,
-0.5213778614997864,
0.5108740329742432,
0.0858064740896225,
-0.9198988080024719,
0.2940428555011749,
-0.26513856649398804,
0.11516988277435303,
1.107029914855957,
-0.026474501937627792,
-0.7204111218452454,
-0.36571526527404785,
-0.6171613931655884,
-0.9963175058364868,
0.5202910304069519,
0.2527151107788086,
0.19627442955970764,
-0.13095197081565857,
-0.10296492278575897,
0.20509588718414307,
0.33432313799858093,
-0.7702943086624146,
-0.1880589723587036,
0.08869637548923492,
-0.196434885263443,
0.0731939747929573,
-0.08853478729724884,
-0.13025733828544617,
-0.25354716181755066,
0.5772745609283447,
-0.05005282908678055,
-0.21207928657531738,
-0.12159955501556396,
-0.48532336950302124,
-0.08626759052276611,
0.46365147829055786,
0.26307740807533264,
0.8552500009536743,
-0.35049083828926086,
0.17041060328483582,
0.18969082832336426,
-0.21805772185325623,
-0.09906808286905289,
0.19190271198749542,
-0.08583581447601318,
0.003957211039960384,
0.4592936038970947,
0.4326151907444,
0.4128761887550354,
-1.1234365701675415,
0.772666335105896,
-0.041947219520807266,
-0.1313498169183731,
-0.08413758128881454,
0.06984210014343262,
0.274972140789032,
0.2657412588596344,
0.6870683431625366,
0.06597503274679184,
0.20002909004688263,
-0.6205743551254272,
0.3419604003429413,
0.5391244888305664,
-0.37247520685195923,
-0.15412399172782898,
0.43842682242393494,
0.4883398413658142,
-0.20666058361530304,
0.5482767224311829,
-0.16712963581085205,
-0.44362083077430725,
0.10757068544626236,
0.3662269115447998,
0.809492290019989,
-0.17462679743766785,
0.019773835316300392,
-0.01581399142742157,
0.3311424255371094,
-0.01894894242286682,
0.31656700372695923,
-0.04706300050020218,
-0.5962752103805542,
-0.4353317618370056,
-0.7899768948554993,
-0.6572396755218506,
0.03433515504002571,
-0.2841545045375824,
0.4098701477050781,
-0.3931159973144531,
0.21254853904247284,
-0.08511786162853241,
-0.007691818289458752,
-0.5930662155151367,
-0.03116518259048462,
0.1616203635931015,
0.9623017311096191,
-0.6324977278709412,
0.5778069496154785,
0.41614991426467896,
-0.15746095776557922,
-0.5612560510635376,
-0.010368339717388153,
0.22383591532707214,
-1.0944918394088745,
0.3955293595790863,
0.2083820402622223,
-0.07212407886981964,
-0.38222503662109375,
-0.5425082445144653,
-0.5556573867797852,
0.9980118870735168,
0.16761095821857452,
-0.687660813331604,
0.3846397399902344,
-0.030728980898857117,
0.6344876289367676,
-0.5222564935684204,
0.7487642765045166,
0.4488036632537842,
0.4189237654209137,
0.5530440211296082,
-0.8882354497909546,
0.026457959786057472,
-0.4456823766231537,
-0.35389894247055054,
0.11853571981191635,
-0.7199031710624695,
0.5583720803260803,
0.06788424402475357,
-0.09752671420574188,
-0.2424742728471756,
0.8002821207046509,
0.6442636251449585,
0.4985946714878082,
0.5134361982345581,
0.5262047648429871,
0.9813011884689331,
-0.04853874817490578,
0.9830639958381653,
-0.4286578297615051,
0.16747181117534637,
1.1347031593322754,
-0.6672872304916382,
1.3453209400177002,
0.4374304413795471,
-0.5162537097930908,
0.6232012510299683,
0.4696447253227234,
0.07539912313222885,
0.5465829968452454,
0.3158072531223297,
-0.3607032299041748,
-0.4090014100074768,
-0.0818265825510025,
-0.5056563019752502,
0.39988812804222107,
0.2653357982635498,
-0.14040197432041168,
-0.4585294723510742,
-0.45589780807495117,
0.0874386802315712,
0.17887216806411743,
-0.06264010816812515,
0.7830587029457092,
0.12652239203453064,
-0.7351187467575073,
0.7165094614028931,
0.08555634319782257,
0.9037200808525085,
-0.5650140643119812,
0.17777691781520844,
-0.37773966789245605,
0.34446442127227783,
-0.1828146129846573,
-0.5222290754318237,
0.07060955464839935,
0.11087379604578018,
0.27720361948013306,
-0.11718809604644775,
0.7333811521530151,
-0.46246790885925293,
-0.559466540813446,
0.312836229801178,
0.8157020807266235,
0.2703563868999481,
-0.11998137086629868,
-0.6863698363304138,
0.2067999392747879,
-0.26489871740341187,
-0.0818929448723793,
0.3888609707355499,
0.5298587083816528,
0.03444842994213104,
0.846129298210144,
0.8768858909606934,
0.02287459746003151,
0.050718002021312714,
0.4163462519645691,
1.0763534307479858,
-0.5362650752067566,
-0.43346500396728516,
-1.13617742061615,
0.4116625189781189,
-0.27047494053840637,
-0.2707193195819855,
0.7964336276054382,
0.7551173567771912,
0.46259063482284546,
0.44743743538856506,
0.7860087156295776,
0.17080536484718323,
0.39881834387779236,
-0.290195494890213,
0.7717404365539551,
-0.6896887421607971,
0.6374441385269165,
-0.39918890595436096,
-1.045652151107788,
-0.0071497587487101555,
0.3529897928237915,
-0.21467919647693634,
0.25525978207588196,
0.4271267354488373,
0.7099435329437256,
-0.15890172123908997,
0.09369498491287231,
0.2260187566280365,
-0.02967390976846218,
0.3644085228443146,
0.32754915952682495,
1.133022427558899,
-0.25401419401168823,
0.7519874572753906,
0.06154794618487358,
-0.5144699811935425,
-0.5839134454727173,
-0.8714224696159363,
-0.850082278251648,
-0.04256930574774742,
-0.28768038749694824,
-0.4473249316215515,
0.16131463646888733,
1.122406244277954,
0.8202186822891235,
-0.6233725547790527,
-0.5301049947738647,
0.1170431524515152,
0.21108844876289368,
-0.1630995273590088,
-0.24352025985717773,
0.13168461620807648,
-0.3992992043495178,
-0.5812244415283203,
0.729546070098877,
0.369426429271698,
-0.3523626923561096,
-0.4950128197669983,
-0.294856458902359,
-0.2153933346271515,
0.2836773991584778,
0.591575026512146,
-0.16756153106689453,
-0.8097418546676636,
0.08969505876302719,
0.011957898736000061,
-0.31680774688720703,
0.18424780666828156,
0.5618586540222168,
-0.8934230804443359,
0.5603988766670227,
0.5290650129318237,
0.6941401958465576,
0.466545045375824,
0.20798926055431366,
0.6556645631790161,
-0.5827516317367554,
-0.10011017322540283,
0.23429277539253235,
0.29837295413017273,
0.6846545934677124,
0.22217097878456116,
0.5865441560745239,
0.22108450531959534,
-0.488838255405426,
-0.727453351020813,
-0.04850342869758606,
-1.004852056503296,
-0.11692486703395844,
1.367629885673523,
0.02353537641465664,
-0.2541798949241638,
-0.025922153145074844,
-0.0551830418407917,
-0.21041259169578552,
-0.5973775386810303,
0.7811253666877747,
0.8042780756950378,
0.22336308658123016,
-0.07606436312198639,
-0.5394334197044373,
0.2645002007484436,
0.35393834114074707,
-0.8893998265266418,
0.2511672377586365,
0.6014796495437622,
0.308271586894989,
0.01794401742517948,
0.7440049052238464,
-0.3387601971626282,
0.008204838261008263,
-0.015922490507364273,
-0.14311137795448303,
0.1741257756948471,
-0.015433778055012226,
-0.019351830706000328,
0.32661327719688416,
0.21882864832878113,
0.15632949769496918
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.01013v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.01013v2
|
Scalable Ensembling For Mitigating Reward Overoptimisation
| 2024-06-03T05:46:53 | 2024-06-18T20:53:08 |
Ahmed M. Ahmed, Rafael Rafailov, Stepan Sharkov, Xuechen Li, Sanmi Koyejo
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Reinforcement Learning from Human Feedback (RLHF) has enabled significant
advancements within language modeling for powerful, instruction-following
models. However, the alignment of these models remains a pressing challenge as
the policy tends to overfit the learned ``proxy" reward model past an
inflection point of utility as measured by a ``gold" reward model that is more
performant -- a phenomenon known as overoptimisation. Prior work has mitigated
this issue by computing a pessimistic statistic over an ensemble of reward
models, which is common in Offline Reinforcement Learning but incredibly costly
for language models with high memory requirements, making such approaches
infeasible for sufficiently large models. To this end, we propose using a
shared encoder but separate linear heads. We find this leads to similar
performance as the full ensemble while allowing tremendous savings in memory
and time required for training for models of similar size.
|
[
-0.45488548278808594,
-0.46779918670654297,
0.27491143345832825,
0.13451306521892548,
-0.05205697938799858,
0.27299565076828003,
-0.3726345896720886,
-0.5215165019035339,
0.427885502576828,
0.7372609972953796,
-0.6653937697410583,
0.1751357913017273,
-0.6393225193023682,
-0.2399890422821045,
0.023035597056150436,
1.1798890829086304,
-0.14416393637657166,
-0.15516895055770874,
-0.4880821108818054,
-0.44443371891975403,
-0.2619284391403198,
-0.6807217597961426,
-0.8508903980255127,
-0.6376070976257324,
0.6079925894737244,
0.4405629634857178,
0.6902444958686829,
0.6842759847640991,
0.42674490809440613,
0.27913933992385864,
0.13917535543441772,
0.1910361498594284,
-0.601477861404419,
0.20191830396652222,
-0.2647707760334015,
-0.398771196603775,
-0.3692883253097534,
-0.1322041153907776,
0.697303056716919,
0.6340565085411072,
-0.5504202246665955,
-0.12840116024017334,
0.1878114640712738,
0.9310028553009033,
-1.1048153638839722,
0.12066768109798431,
-0.22505350410938263,
0.21147708594799042,
0.000749786093365401,
-0.3563207983970642,
-0.40013647079467773,
-0.5353268980979919,
0.2944411039352417,
-0.5296053886413574,
-0.20191164314746857,
-0.03589585795998573,
0.7747786045074463,
0.5226219892501831,
0.022619623690843582,
-0.25301679968833923,
-0.7016292214393616,
1.0562174320220947,
-0.6316075921058655,
0.37641841173171997,
0.4962734282016754,
0.27693724632263184,
0.1865418404340744,
-0.4903624951839447,
-0.3129481077194214,
-0.1038583517074585,
-0.00813094899058342,
0.2316901534795761,
-0.042220499366521835,
0.15685498714447021,
0.06720970571041107,
0.17822369933128357,
-0.5889402627944946,
0.14840345084667206,
-0.28501465916633606,
-0.023968489840626717,
0.6535130143165588,
0.08162675052881241,
0.1356130838394165,
0.37337416410446167,
-0.4730885326862335,
-0.47160080075263977,
-0.6222587823867798,
0.18080918490886688,
0.5169048309326172,
0.351828008890152,
0.02544594556093216,
0.2740043103694916,
-0.23192650079727173,
0.7124372124671936,
0.29397353529930115,
0.016445092856884003,
0.39902716875076294,
0.01487658265978098,
-0.07958988845348358,
0.31626519560813904,
0.5065112709999084,
0.2053971290588379,
0.2768710255622864,
-0.4206891655921936,
-0.5047919154167175,
0.06735255569219589,
0.5101442933082581,
-0.9568592309951782,
-0.08135407418012619,
0.2799597978591919,
-0.445095956325531,
-0.3199908137321472,
0.0853118821978569,
-0.779180109500885,
-0.42471936345100403,
-0.11522029340267181,
0.7194392085075378,
-0.10785043239593506,
-0.2946924865245819,
0.19042880833148956,
-0.28397586941719055,
0.0422007255256176,
0.0053994967602193356,
-1.2442582845687866,
0.572647213935852,
0.6632219552993774,
0.8636151552200317,
-0.4485722482204437,
-0.5966159105300903,
-0.7573958039283752,
0.08088675886392593,
-0.09700466692447662,
0.5934345722198486,
-0.5953577756881714,
-0.24085526168346405,
0.13573245704174042,
-0.04272221028804779,
-0.1841820627450943,
-0.6812673211097717,
0.2476838082075119,
-0.5644089579582214,
0.21774230897426605,
-0.31578516960144043,
-0.8194202780723572,
-0.10168036818504333,
0.3710955083370209,
-0.8393662571907043,
0.7397453784942627,
0.17699621617794037,
-0.7649911046028137,
0.320527583360672,
-0.6487973928451538,
-0.37449711561203003,
-0.0241585373878479,
-0.18331123888492584,
-0.6864128708839417,
-0.16536562144756317,
0.24935249984264374,
0.19626958668231964,
-0.04481373354792595,
0.12733781337738037,
-0.35523128509521484,
-0.5104047656059265,
0.25925037264823914,
-0.35225430130958557,
0.44725358486175537,
0.1572694480419159,
-0.4545101821422577,
0.3613189458847046,
-0.5891379117965698,
0.08195091038942337,
-0.011445717886090279,
-0.5454513430595398,
-0.3825213313102722,
0.1178533062338829,
-0.00513328006491065,
0.16470779478549957,
0.4336182177066803,
-0.6366797685623169,
0.15030236542224884,
-0.5093154907226562,
0.655059278011322,
0.7279439568519592,
-0.08737743645906448,
0.6877555847167969,
-0.5840068459510803,
0.6863824129104614,
-0.24189208447933197,
0.20121601223945618,
0.08648199588060379,
-0.16219042241573334,
-0.6997120976448059,
-0.34547159075737,
0.16726677119731903,
0.4496450126171112,
-0.6514802575111389,
0.3023262321949005,
-0.05226468667387962,
-0.22218649089336395,
-0.555098831653595,
-0.10193289071321487,
0.6746770143508911,
0.058654557913541794,
0.30811452865600586,
-0.48515549302101135,
-0.5638786554336548,
-0.7900882959365845,
-0.10128165781497955,
0.017328785732388496,
-0.07920069247484207,
0.2688308656215668,
0.4454258680343628,
-0.20692166686058044,
1.0484627485275269,
-0.4557883143424988,
-0.2755489945411682,
-0.4471731185913086,
0.3326323628425598,
-0.002121022902429104,
0.6708096861839294,
0.3575364351272583,
-0.629729688167572,
-0.37928712368011475,
-0.02572215348482132,
-0.4591740667819977,
0.048677943646907806,
-0.1889696717262268,
-0.17509149014949799,
0.42100444436073303,
0.5432990789413452,
-0.5796322822570801,
0.1997080296278,
0.6091264486312866,
-0.10655104368925095,
0.31062376499176025,
-0.5869245529174805,
0.051661230623722076,
-0.6337304711341858,
-0.017938921228051186,
-0.2714470624923706,
-0.3483145236968994,
-0.32060158252716064,
0.29561400413513184,
0.13145379722118378,
0.006724223960191011,
-0.3234695494174957,
0.34845879673957825,
-0.304334819316864,
-0.22864355146884918,
-0.49128976464271545,
-0.12435454875230789,
-0.054534535855054855,
0.9571573734283447,
0.43235594034194946,
0.6228112578392029,
0.3753344416618347,
-0.5080842971801758,
0.4245569109916687,
0.015337173826992512,
0.020363612100481987,
0.6110111474990845,
-0.8446285724639893,
0.03864935785531998,
-0.22740665078163147,
0.4573934078216553,
-0.5678970217704773,
-0.3848370909690857,
0.31653597950935364,
-0.41783449053764343,
0.43461906909942627,
0.025937145575881004,
0.013923363760113716,
-0.1341603398323059,
-0.5427595376968384,
0.712683916091919,
0.5682571530342102,
-0.8175172209739685,
0.4999673068523407,
0.7440199255943298,
-0.04975507780909538,
-0.6642360091209412,
-0.6352065205574036,
-0.3004724979400635,
-0.3811819553375244,
-0.4203399419784546,
0.5190069079399109,
0.061685193330049515,
-0.012722393497824669,
0.07785051316022873,
-0.04028264060616493,
-0.1520606279373169,
-0.12889933586120605,
0.2420201301574707,
0.1733071208000183,
-0.010867935605347157,
0.3191521465778351,
-0.27906134724617004,
-0.24834537506103516,
0.08487607538700104,
-0.6075072288513184,
0.5788634419441223,
-0.16181735694408417,
-0.4169705808162689,
-0.1051153764128685,
0.40021800994873047,
0.6559419631958008,
-0.4609352946281433,
1.0621305704116821,
0.427757203578949,
-0.5358949303627014,
-0.23571652173995972,
-0.3722814917564392,
-0.4071715772151947,
-0.46821320056915283,
0.523104190826416,
0.09940110892057419,
-0.9728218913078308,
0.5330079197883606,
0.22017811238765717,
0.25775524973869324,
0.004707771819084883,
0.46589359641075134,
0.035126473754644394,
1.133737564086914,
0.5951974391937256,
-0.1725558638572693,
0.6265473365783691,
-0.11986237019300461,
0.030804114416241646,
-0.5501951575279236,
-0.24086856842041016,
-0.3270394802093506,
-0.29748713970184326,
-0.48594388365745544,
-0.4148446023464203,
0.24387772381305695,
-0.07194285094738007,
-0.4175872802734375,
0.2823672890663147,
-0.4441862106323242,
0.617805540561676,
0.783991277217865,
0.33582666516304016,
-0.07217737287282944,
0.044060513377189636,
0.11612208187580109,
0.01374119147658348,
-0.9395014643669128,
0.05704807862639427,
0.9953709244728088,
0.39979088306427,
0.9626144766807556,
-0.02129301056265831,
0.8954434394836426,
0.18577037751674652,
-0.025344224646687508,
-0.6049841046333313,
0.11709065735340118,
-0.13365693390369415,
-0.406924843788147,
-0.7751711010932922,
-0.6614304780960083,
-1.003642201423645,
0.36565980315208435,
-0.15031097829341888,
-0.7998587489128113,
0.21696540713310242,
0.44067901372909546,
-0.864481508731842,
0.3067486584186554,
-0.4151686429977417,
1.0801841020584106,
-0.22361929714679718,
-0.5445809960365295,
-0.5038907527923584,
-0.6680369973182678,
0.184471994638443,
0.08133023232221603,
0.21015223860740662,
0.38045060634613037,
0.18244391679763794,
0.922899603843689,
-0.6377147436141968,
0.8139881491661072,
-0.12711942195892334,
0.08414607495069504,
0.12669123709201813,
-0.17938755452632904,
0.8525999784469604,
-0.18267707526683807,
0.3037334680557251,
-0.25008901953697205,
-0.1227881908416748,
-0.5552629828453064,
-0.7376541495323181,
0.6815068125724792,
-0.9766399264335632,
-0.24242156744003296,
-0.4960886538028717,
-0.7059040665626526,
-0.32544299960136414,
-0.21495656669139862,
0.26592397689819336,
0.5513463616371155,
0.04621779918670654,
0.18460536003112793,
1.0515257120132446,
-0.39343661069869995,
0.4234673082828522,
0.2877848744392395,
-0.167618989944458,
-0.5691680908203125,
1.332574725151062,
0.13033758103847504,
0.6214392185211182,
0.471829891204834,
0.2797310948371887,
-0.39698442816734314,
-0.11556217074394226,
-0.44872039556503296,
0.0937754213809967,
-0.463848352432251,
0.0434037409722805,
-0.4867245554924011,
-0.3236401379108429,
-0.11867121607065201,
-0.4242418110370636,
-0.787385880947113,
-0.4924677610397339,
0.012960701249539852,
0.018191002309322357,
0.2804661691188812,
0.6981309652328491,
-0.24900445342063904,
0.3668059706687927,
-0.7849757075309753,
-0.0704115703701973,
0.6397925019264221,
0.49318957328796387,
0.2802666425704956,
-0.5387731194496155,
-0.5754021406173706,
0.07714203000068665,
-0.1557326763868332,
-0.6429547071456909,
0.6347264051437378,
0.18630017340183258,
0.6812906861305237,
0.5719568133354187,
0.30058926343917847,
0.7680789232254028,
-0.35454678535461426,
0.3125188648700714,
0.36612141132354736,
-0.8084657788276672,
0.18059612810611725,
-0.06855427473783493,
0.45825257897377014,
0.48105165362358093,
0.4393270015716553,
-0.6748422980308533,
-0.3365449905395508,
-0.5483086109161377,
-1.068999171257019,
1.0390268564224243,
0.08482138812541962,
-0.2662845849990845,
0.1469915211200714,
-0.058976735919713974,
0.10380355268716812,
0.2748202085494995,
-0.6637426614761353,
0.12204702198505402,
-0.27240461111068726,
-0.13047777116298676,
-0.14605504274368286,
-0.21011438965797424,
-0.1876610666513443,
-0.050607405602931976,
0.812393844127655,
-0.03537251427769661,
0.1611577272415161,
-0.013437382876873016,
-0.1805979460477829,
-0.5154660940170288,
0.1867300271987915,
0.6400181651115417,
0.5153627395629883,
-0.4564034044742584,
0.1418376863002777,
0.17044568061828613,
-0.3031896650791168,
0.05402267724275589,
-0.13710685074329376,
-0.08758091926574707,
-0.28558796644210815,
0.28799566626548767,
1.0186938047409058,
0.5358694195747375,
-0.8528675436973572,
0.4763326346874237,
0.0821741446852684,
-0.18254192173480988,
-0.30968067049980164,
-0.05102992802858353,
0.1618206948041916,
0.4083828628063202,
0.11755090206861496,
0.18780049681663513,
-0.0670165866613388,
-0.556443989276886,
0.41293221712112427,
0.41766679286956787,
-0.6655528545379639,
-0.06390498578548431,
0.4750274121761322,
0.3155086040496826,
-0.4374363422393799,
0.5434632897377014,
-0.28081268072128296,
-0.7769665718078613,
0.6837846040725708,
0.4907868504524231,
0.7714836597442627,
-0.17705442011356354,
0.2821197807788849,
0.40743789076805115,
0.1781146079301834,
-0.5880270600318909,
0.010592405684292316,
-0.3153257369995117,
-0.8438940644264221,
-0.40861931443214417,
-0.5972824692726135,
-0.5456968545913696,
-0.14995208382606506,
-0.9720661640167236,
-0.28438714146614075,
-0.4213961958885193,
-0.021974865347146988,
-0.23879091441631317,
-0.26995527744293213,
-0.27940380573272705,
-0.06649267673492432,
0.2119738608598709,
0.35458123683929443,
-0.8869732618331909,
0.8731175065040588,
0.5576239228248596,
-0.5312883257865906,
-0.6754142045974731,
-0.03206416964530945,
-0.15589120984077454,
-0.7244172096252441,
0.6182433366775513,
0.24486097693443298,
-0.20839878916740417,
-0.14029796421527863,
-0.3129960298538208,
-0.9417848587036133,
0.8025428056716919,
0.32313022017478943,
-0.7128258943557739,
-0.08552952110767365,
0.042633093893527985,
0.30126428604125977,
-0.3287809193134308,
0.43448248505592346,
0.7047827243804932,
0.28968340158462524,
0.15476462244987488,
-1.0623174905776978,
-0.06198237091302872,
0.09094328433275223,
-0.08492580056190491,
0.41540253162384033,
-0.5894716382026672,
1.0908292531967163,
-0.04858674854040146,
-0.15717445313930511,
-0.21646365523338318,
0.5092917084693909,
0.565901517868042,
0.12171858549118042,
0.6694782376289368,
0.7237370610237122,
0.6319031715393066,
0.24006883800029755,
0.8980735540390015,
-0.05501608923077583,
0.5172640085220337,
1.0744179487228394,
-0.26822930574417114,
1.052531123161316,
0.6966508626937866,
-0.3279183804988861,
0.33380475640296936,
0.5329123139381409,
0.510806143283844,
0.9047794342041016,
0.31224915385246277,
-0.1826086789369583,
-0.6003001928329468,
0.005175173748284578,
-0.42285627126693726,
0.15448030829429626,
0.2069915235042572,
-0.0886618047952652,
-0.33748874068260193,
0.1797679364681244,
-0.2883259952068329,
0.17151810228824615,
-0.5605988502502441,
0.5969017744064331,
-0.04100188612937927,
-0.9749771356582642,
0.6313355565071106,
-0.10994766652584076,
1.0107263326644897,
-0.6129809617996216,
-0.09934347122907639,
-0.17025816440582275,
0.6151738166809082,
-0.21420949697494507,
-0.48514410853385925,
0.4095391631126404,
-0.29821985960006714,
-0.17113488912582397,
-0.47163525223731995,
0.39991483092308044,
-0.8374090790748596,
-0.2730739414691925,
0.4128221273422241,
0.23293434083461761,
0.03684714809060097,
-0.10725489258766174,
-0.48398932814598083,
0.057027991861104965,
-0.04615264758467674,
-0.22305899858474731,
0.6740221381187439,
0.16837924718856812,
-0.16751651465892792,
0.8406232595443726,
0.36625370383262634,
0.11199161410331726,
0.21004655957221985,
0.09842786937952042,
0.7005211114883423,
-0.3982307016849518,
-1.1445400714874268,
-0.8870934247970581,
0.15741416811943054,
-0.11343280225992203,
-0.20933522284030914,
0.5394555330276489,
0.3018549978733063,
1.1213480234146118,
-0.07400888949632645,
0.5823058485984802,
0.15461261570453644,
0.5096579194068909,
-0.39995715022087097,
0.8582959175109863,
-0.6358623504638672,
0.06812231987714767,
-0.17626126110553741,
-0.617067813873291,
0.006212157197296619,
0.9369223713874817,
-0.009865688160061836,
-0.13437071442604065,
0.5344799757003784,
0.7415638566017151,
0.054765354841947556,
0.06600973755121231,
0.4199746549129486,
-0.18231071531772614,
-0.03865955024957657,
0.9522449970245361,
0.9234326481819153,
0.013106039725244045,
0.5240215063095093,
-0.2612954080104828,
-0.34092414379119873,
-0.38284212350845337,
-0.6267886757850647,
-0.7876697778701782,
-0.37743380665779114,
-0.31966495513916016,
-0.11896814405918121,
0.49881497025489807,
1.1610393524169922,
0.8661479353904724,
-1.0846081972122192,
-0.485554575920105,
-0.3781347870826721,
0.023051466792821884,
-0.6552472114562988,
-0.20269064605236053,
0.24794481694698334,
-0.45441293716430664,
-0.6042787432670593,
0.14718936383724213,
0.34386956691741943,
-0.24296818673610687,
-0.6194477081298828,
-0.732926070690155,
-0.05442141741514206,
0.2231309860944748,
0.3295340836048126,
0.6540392637252808,
-0.5055779218673706,
-0.3835091292858124,
-0.23596538603305817,
-0.13854216039180756,
-0.08134055137634277,
0.8546132445335388,
-0.885912299156189,
0.35818812251091003,
0.6302249431610107,
1.1059932708740234,
0.6158370971679688,
-0.03718509152531624,
0.8057665228843689,
-0.8516116738319397,
0.2818402647972107,
0.3387323319911957,
0.44876548647880554,
0.15352500975131989,
-0.29307740926742554,
0.30684414505958557,
0.14425767958164215,
-0.8157472610473633,
-0.8815121054649353,
0.348052978515625,
-0.6892029643058777,
-0.4115108549594879,
0.8921258449554443,
-0.39293813705444336,
-0.24754266440868378,
0.02983350120484829,
-0.003598463488742709,
0.3168626129627228,
-0.557705819606781,
0.9523835778236389,
0.6803284883499146,
-0.14772318303585052,
-0.2170410454273224,
-0.3122153580188751,
0.5285414457321167,
0.7542499303817749,
-0.6929041147232056,
0.07280413806438446,
0.24139699339866638,
0.04122442752122879,
0.12385633587837219,
0.5514643788337708,
0.12707310914993286,
0.5209032297134399,
0.15009047091007233,
0.36166563630104065,
-0.1846301108598709,
-0.4609728157520294,
-0.49008694291114807,
0.36346468329429626,
0.050852030515670776,
-0.6040247678756714
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.06564v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.06564v1
|
Revolutionizing Large Language Model Training through Dynamic Parameter Adjustment
| 2024-06-03T05:40:34 | 2024-06-03T05:40:34 |
Kaiye Zhou, Shucheng Wang
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
In the era of large language models, the demand for efficient use of
computational resources has become critically important. Although
parameter-efficient fine-tuning techniques have achieved results comparable to
full fine-tuning, their application during the pre-training phase poses
significant challenges. Specifically, employing parameter-efficient strategies
at the onset of pre-training can severely compromise efficiency, especially in
larger models. In this paper, building upon the fine-tuning method LoRA, we
introduce a novel parameter-efficient training technique that frequently alters
trainable part of parameters, facilitating effective pre-training. Our method
not only achieves memory reductions and computational overhead comparable to
current state-of-the-art parameter-efficient algorithms during the pre-training
phase but also maintains accuracy levels comparable to those of full
pre-training. We provide both theoretical analyses and empirical evidence to
demonstrate the effectiveness of our approach.
|
[
-0.46147972345352173,
-0.9374961256980896,
0.3738659918308258,
-0.07494224607944489,
-0.437500923871994,
-0.006555458530783653,
-0.587297260761261,
-0.3101147711277008,
0.027804646641016006,
0.3964824378490448,
-0.5386060476303101,
-0.364554226398468,
-0.6224492788314819,
-0.3080171048641205,
-0.26804763078689575,
0.7368393540382385,
-0.1319514811038971,
-0.08611681312322617,
0.3983668088912964,
-0.33506935834884644,
-0.2507982552051544,
-0.4285738468170166,
-0.9198127388954163,
-0.20848728716373444,
1.1097999811172485,
0.33675095438957214,
0.6970338225364685,
0.7453518509864807,
0.3297809958457947,
0.36692044138908386,
-0.07576067000627518,
0.35416504740715027,
-0.8815633654594421,
0.20262321829795837,
-0.11801175773143768,
-0.4969847798347473,
-0.5675443410873413,
-0.17327310144901276,
1.1384248733520508,
0.8897300958633423,
-0.328511506319046,
0.2891945242881775,
0.11616210639476776,
0.7978782653808594,
-0.9646497964859009,
0.10918014496564865,
-1.0838186740875244,
-0.1676201969385147,
-0.389988511800766,
-0.553301990032196,
-0.3319934010505676,
-0.2047651708126068,
-0.07678697258234024,
-0.8512512445449829,
-0.06465379148721695,
-0.307902991771698,
1.0576094388961792,
0.5576804876327515,
-0.08616254478693008,
0.10162904113531113,
-0.9777641892433167,
0.7982093095779419,
-0.8239042162895203,
0.6357021927833557,
0.24205435812473297,
0.3209550976753235,
-0.26244381070137024,
-0.6854879260063171,
-0.3418915569782257,
-0.0310357678681612,
0.2893688380718231,
-0.39902958273887634,
-0.031453486531972885,
0.15080195665359497,
0.5036409497261047,
-0.02930319495499134,
-0.08466112613677979,
0.5746254324913025,
-0.19666297733783722,
0.04569269344210625,
0.35014209151268005,
0.15143734216690063,
0.09211128205060959,
0.533039391040802,
0.3293505311012268,
-0.211270272731781,
-0.763843297958374,
0.004456327296793461,
0.5916972756385803,
0.6711595058441162,
0.04559095948934555,
0.17140130698680878,
-0.3829355537891388,
1.026748538017273,
0.2390843629837036,
-0.27053096890449524,
0.09549573063850403,
-0.012793387286365032,
-0.2505928874015808,
-0.09073386341333389,
0.4847201406955719,
-0.1602819412946701,
0.332969605922699,
0.13112391531467438,
-0.17667730152606964,
-0.11788544803857803,
0.28608056902885437,
-1.1711480617523193,
-0.21591342985630035,
-0.040112316608428955,
-0.11836361140012741,
-0.4073132574558258,
-0.2406555563211441,
-0.6514539122581482,
-0.27350693941116333,
-0.50046306848526,
0.5537720322608948,
-0.33138009905815125,
-0.042281292378902435,
0.36746567487716675,
0.45751142501831055,
0.1152743250131607,
0.594764232635498,
-1.1040295362472534,
0.02736559323966503,
0.44570791721343994,
0.599777102470398,
0.14599576592445374,
-0.5050895810127258,
-1.137550711631775,
0.32635995745658875,
-0.5131985545158386,
0.6285857558250427,
-0.8045738935470581,
-0.02560528554022312,
-0.10434972494840622,
-0.2514260411262512,
-0.14577502012252808,
-0.5283135175704956,
0.13426342606544495,
-0.764531135559082,
-0.11357147991657257,
-0.2805776000022888,
-0.16922011971473694,
0.014590469188988209,
0.19384612143039703,
-0.6197640299797058,
0.9838029742240906,
0.0838298574090004,
-0.6152713894844055,
0.38155344128608704,
-0.6899728775024414,
-0.4835837781429291,
-0.3276274800300598,
0.019568869844079018,
-0.5273051261901855,
0.22775797545909882,
0.3526800572872162,
0.4385261833667755,
-0.19890166819095612,
-0.02780184894800186,
-0.2398676574230194,
-0.5172079801559448,
0.13518118858337402,
-0.33454248309135437,
0.4829210340976715,
0.16603419184684753,
-0.1985263079404831,
0.22794729471206665,
-1.0336946249008179,
0.23149079084396362,
0.0695403665304184,
-0.6420863270759583,
-0.38384249806404114,
0.04579580947756767,
-0.392904132604599,
-0.06421682983636856,
0.35962560772895813,
-0.11708736419677734,
0.42022696137428284,
-0.7637880444526672,
0.3886815309524536,
0.7638549208641052,
-0.17253999412059784,
0.35349389910697937,
0.10653215646743774,
0.5351666808128357,
-0.22738192975521088,
0.2551150918006897,
-0.20656108856201172,
0.1627252995967865,
-1.0239261388778687,
-0.488456130027771,
0.6566599011421204,
0.2988133132457733,
-0.5963595509529114,
0.47044482827186584,
-0.09920027107000351,
-0.6748461723327637,
-0.42160800099372864,
0.3233116865158081,
0.2326989471912384,
0.288695752620697,
0.40511175990104675,
-0.002466802252456546,
-0.566129744052887,
-0.5248083472251892,
-0.46855083107948303,
-0.05280853435397148,
0.2878837585449219,
-0.03856358677148819,
0.18415586650371552,
-0.08209285885095596,
0.5846219658851624,
-0.6452520489692688,
0.036138761788606644,
-0.16766200959682465,
0.29667389392852783,
0.263619989156723,
0.6106037497520447,
0.5594403743743896,
-0.4876481294631958,
-0.5931774973869324,
0.039866603910923004,
-0.2901654839515686,
-0.07602766901254654,
-0.08066099882125854,
-0.25811636447906494,
0.116876021027565,
0.8805265426635742,
-0.3512824773788452,
0.2714204490184784,
0.6322375535964966,
-0.1054408997297287,
0.47545352578163147,
-0.6255983114242554,
0.14658059179782867,
-0.8462531566619873,
0.16198627650737762,
-0.3835422396659851,
-0.20331917703151703,
-0.6657138466835022,
0.31091272830963135,
0.01579423062503338,
-0.04574021324515343,
-0.5169496536254883,
0.5879283547401428,
-0.6642820239067078,
0.24962672591209412,
-0.4841252565383911,
-0.1095246896147728,
-0.14313286542892456,
0.42944085597991943,
-0.3280172646045685,
0.7476618885993958,
0.7005914449691772,
-0.7870059013366699,
0.2013707309961319,
-0.014414503239095211,
-0.594306230545044,
0.278385192155838,
-0.5435083508491516,
0.3288515508174896,
-0.19952605664730072,
0.19967840611934662,
-0.6155856251716614,
-0.16785800457000732,
0.0913938581943512,
-0.039976902306079865,
0.3796323537826538,
-0.14090202748775482,
-0.6798518300056458,
0.005928940139710903,
-0.15156565606594086,
0.5737088322639465,
0.4588261544704437,
-0.6354378461837769,
0.8328907489776611,
0.14106157422065735,
-0.06058495491743088,
-0.585469126701355,
-0.30131301283836365,
-0.09299849718809128,
-0.40235254168510437,
-0.30839791893959045,
0.3079785704612732,
-0.06926438957452774,
-0.014432510361075401,
-0.4299187660217285,
-0.03532171621918678,
-0.16667687892913818,
0.42434948682785034,
-0.18422164022922516,
-0.08528084307909012,
-0.32148703932762146,
0.07309109717607498,
0.24863433837890625,
-0.31050172448158264,
-0.24897824227809906,
-0.11528696864843369,
1.0840035676956177,
0.06946403533220291,
-0.45229825377464294,
-0.6831862330436707,
0.03393861651420593,
0.6372119784355164,
-0.6664367318153381,
1.0475186109542847,
0.6240765452384949,
-0.3179938495159149,
-0.3843270540237427,
-0.6083685755729675,
-0.16716744005680084,
-0.5558677315711975,
0.8457798957824707,
-0.4621924161911011,
-0.7406713366508484,
0.6112813353538513,
-0.3157138526439667,
0.17552758753299713,
0.0935148298740387,
0.49852821230888367,
0.0700683668255806,
1.1955822706222534,
0.6579555869102478,
-0.022830376401543617,
0.9385223984718323,
-0.13904286921024323,
0.3253127634525299,
-0.6231797337532043,
0.11437280476093292,
-0.7904400825500488,
-0.4291037619113922,
-0.46755340695381165,
-0.6047831177711487,
0.3710343837738037,
0.33960357308387756,
-0.6273503303527832,
0.18108054995536804,
-0.026469524949789047,
0.6844578981399536,
0.37123268842697144,
0.19569918513298035,
0.1933777928352356,
0.0012548381928354502,
0.21743358671665192,
-0.006079365033656359,
-0.7366853952407837,
-0.2136775553226471,
0.8808128833770752,
0.28166162967681885,
0.8040593862533569,
-0.009132759645581245,
0.5709145665168762,
-0.16975019872188568,
-0.07051876932382584,
-0.6591160893440247,
0.7148098349571228,
-0.42479798197746277,
-0.24794965982437134,
-0.696088969707489,
-0.37220147252082825,
-1.0255781412124634,
0.2188112586736679,
-0.35413944721221924,
-0.7640565633773804,
0.13252511620521545,
0.6540838479995728,
-0.6815959215164185,
0.5993770956993103,
-0.6032248735427856,
0.8129034638404846,
-0.336300253868103,
-0.4851614236831665,
-0.618503987789154,
-0.37329909205436707,
-0.14115391671657562,
-0.609230101108551,
-0.03195439279079437,
-0.3073166310787201,
-0.19746483862400055,
0.673596978187561,
-0.4884721338748932,
0.7790092825889587,
-0.5716094970703125,
-0.3499091863632202,
-0.10119114816188812,
0.04665156453847885,
0.968095600605011,
-0.08242418617010117,
-0.4200817346572876,
0.01788948103785515,
-0.03715571388602257,
-0.6617969870567322,
-0.9788052439689636,
0.5330625176429749,
-0.6619528532028198,
-0.5090546607971191,
-0.10349402576684952,
-0.6792008876800537,
-0.677885115146637,
0.31443288922309875,
-0.017119111493229866,
0.5053601264953613,
-0.3209317624568939,
0.3503485321998596,
0.761637806892395,
-0.5646940469741821,
0.21746838092803955,
0.5826160907745361,
-0.2553507089614868,
-0.12619154155254364,
0.8572470545768738,
0.17018891870975494,
0.527384340763092,
0.39772558212280273,
0.3604147136211395,
-0.025153903290629387,
-0.9690960049629211,
-0.23188866674900055,
0.35059937834739685,
-0.49931415915489197,
-0.008397729136049747,
-0.4604519009590149,
-0.11317851394414902,
-0.09837858378887177,
-0.2878654897212982,
-0.7521524429321289,
-0.1396963894367218,
-0.38185805082321167,
0.1839814931154251,
0.22165217995643616,
0.09559275954961777,
0.18173757195472717,
0.8281461000442505,
-0.6436670422554016,
0.35492682456970215,
0.42339572310447693,
0.5775920152664185,
-0.01461759302765131,
-0.759503960609436,
-0.5533945560455322,
0.08114024251699448,
0.11476559191942215,
-0.31625089049339294,
0.1835249811410904,
0.5944252610206604,
0.4626729488372803,
0.5883368253707886,
-0.11987103521823883,
1.1465038061141968,
-0.6468395590782166,
0.5191080570220947,
0.09663088619709015,
-0.9854379296302795,
0.6588956117630005,
-0.6423832774162292,
0.5095037221908569,
0.8111909627914429,
0.11945603042840958,
-0.11403274536132812,
-0.13581500947475433,
-0.33691665530204773,
-0.8907822966575623,
0.6794278025627136,
-0.12423762679100037,
0.5163488984107971,
0.5249102711677551,
0.6135200262069702,
0.11092788726091385,
0.09881202131509781,
-0.2823367714881897,
-0.08694171905517578,
0.06588403135538101,
-0.16314895451068878,
-0.2267455905675888,
-0.31814831495285034,
0.011091568507254124,
-0.6996711492538452,
0.8646736145019531,
-0.3535533547401428,
-0.13516224920749664,
-0.619515597820282,
-0.10322705656290054,
-0.08869022876024246,
0.26840391755104065,
0.5924617052078247,
1.0745967626571655,
-0.18504080176353455,
-0.07288289815187454,
0.5804897546768188,
-0.3200419545173645,
0.09225431084632874,
0.19338379800319672,
-0.07391910254955292,
-0.29124078154563904,
0.15300311148166656,
1.2324914932250977,
0.519737720489502,
-0.7557254433631897,
0.10396896302700043,
0.05640455335378647,
-0.1962529420852661,
-0.19541774690151215,
0.5858517289161682,
-0.0003655264445114881,
0.24472126364707947,
0.07580375671386719,
-0.12510059773921967,
-0.44212523102760315,
-0.5515258312225342,
-0.05816884711384773,
0.40189629793167114,
-0.11394256353378296,
-0.31849318742752075,
0.5348016619682312,
0.11988292634487152,
-0.3270662724971771,
0.4814893901348114,
0.1992809772491455,
-0.1876661628484726,
0.18953704833984375,
0.47185033559799194,
0.5816596150398254,
-0.5839256048202515,
0.07147815078496933,
0.3894202411174774,
0.14107410609722137,
-0.20437094569206238,
0.2621050179004669,
0.17638196051120758,
-0.8340103626251221,
-0.7141310572624207,
-0.8608309030532837,
-0.2408902794122696,
0.43142232298851013,
-0.6693799495697021,
0.5236877202987671,
-0.7384644150733948,
-0.13183143734931946,
0.13322493433952332,
-0.1472853422164917,
-0.5607411861419678,
0.285867840051651,
-0.03553915023803711,
0.8604592084884644,
-0.5328207015991211,
1.2686954736709595,
0.7760681509971619,
-0.06466928124427795,
-0.9999463558197021,
0.14931733906269073,
-0.3528810143470764,
-0.8424263000488281,
0.5840193629264832,
-0.16285556554794312,
-0.44958654046058655,
0.252746045589447,
-0.5512415766716003,
-1.092935562133789,
0.66130530834198,
1.018969178199768,
-0.7778300642967224,
-0.20062658190727234,
0.2143075168132782,
0.6346431970596313,
-0.03375310078263283,
-0.07804308831691742,
0.7370306253433228,
0.6145976185798645,
-0.010833820328116417,
-0.850916862487793,
-0.0890779197216034,
-0.08772537857294083,
0.09404120594263077,
0.6132112145423889,
-0.6485101580619812,
0.765120804309845,
-0.04807749763131142,
0.021544188261032104,
0.06395455449819565,
0.8727282881736755,
0.11788547784090042,
-0.2570357024669647,
1.0100523233413696,
0.38178810477256775,
1.001479983329773,
0.03036930225789547,
0.6059156656265259,
-0.49710002541542053,
0.14007006585597992,
1.288598895072937,
-0.29694080352783203,
1.003745675086975,
0.5498462915420532,
-0.1730235069990158,
0.3952745795249939,
0.44798481464385986,
0.21217955648899078,
0.4196334183216095,
0.37045660614967346,
-0.26384806632995605,
-0.5474711060523987,
0.16037461161613464,
-0.32255104184150696,
0.7558488845825195,
0.301224946975708,
-0.053823214024305344,
-0.20364956557750702,
0.1155935525894165,
0.2246858924627304,
0.09857161343097687,
-0.3751908242702484,
0.6284176707267761,
-0.18009993433952332,
-0.5732203722000122,
1.1241952180862427,
0.15412653982639313,
0.570284903049469,
-1.0770267248153687,
0.13610665500164032,
-0.011887169443070889,
0.41542062163352966,
-0.04139493405818939,
-0.12906497716903687,
0.16102994978427887,
0.19702474772930145,
-0.00717770354822278,
-0.2045871913433075,
0.3536408543586731,
-0.3808017373085022,
-0.49615907669067383,
0.21811820566654205,
0.2939043939113617,
-0.060842107981443405,
-0.3569290339946747,
-0.6868425607681274,
0.4042291045188904,
-0.042666319757699966,
-0.3500714898109436,
0.5106368660926819,
0.45959171652793884,
0.1754976212978363,
0.5006554126739502,
0.6901147961616516,
0.45829343795776367,
0.014741956256330013,
0.34112176299095154,
1.057283878326416,
-0.6147136092185974,
-0.6996637582778931,
-0.7949109077453613,
0.4394257366657257,
0.09863763302564621,
-0.3804977834224701,
0.4237779378890991,
0.38617798686027527,
0.8079459071159363,
0.1257152557373047,
0.5414454936981201,
0.12636376917362213,
0.5835949778556824,
-0.8640096187591553,
0.8030287027359009,
-0.8029358386993408,
0.4128676950931549,
-0.4322558045387268,
-1.0088649988174438,
-0.3694894313812256,
0.617438793182373,
-0.35706034302711487,
0.14501391351222992,
0.5989390015602112,
1.0270991325378418,
-0.2595826983451843,
-0.3233065903186798,
0.40026986598968506,
0.5050012469291687,
0.42674145102500916,
0.17613333463668823,
0.7167574167251587,
-0.2487107515335083,
0.3401723802089691,
-0.17574390769004822,
-0.185639426112175,
-0.20659087598323822,
-1.0871704816818237,
-0.8645362854003906,
-0.5532197952270508,
-0.40271613001823425,
-0.253334105014801,
0.4557611048221588,
1.015481948852539,
0.9109662771224976,
-0.8219882845878601,
-0.16027376055717468,
0.17484749853610992,
-0.39190584421157837,
-0.20938773453235626,
-0.05449702963232994,
0.5451886057853699,
-0.5311430096626282,
-0.8208324909210205,
0.5758484601974487,
0.08892197161912918,
-0.1193629801273346,
-0.37522026896476746,
-0.02941671386361122,
-0.24164016544818878,
0.30981212854385376,
0.7259606719017029,
0.4667232632637024,
-0.4276907444000244,
-0.4198828339576721,
-0.4008098840713501,
0.18413177132606506,
0.26997676491737366,
0.8797869682312012,
-0.5487381815910339,
0.2978074550628662,
0.37446191906929016,
0.8392923474311829,
0.6459880471229553,
0.09844771772623062,
0.6200748085975647,
-0.6402249932289124,
0.5524653792381287,
-0.06511253863573074,
0.13054239749908447,
0.2874840199947357,
-0.16015625,
0.2595827579498291,
-0.012483901344239712,
-0.36910203099250793,
-1.1150528192520142,
0.2342257797718048,
-1.0064820051193237,
-0.3301903009414673,
0.9906198978424072,
0.08787912130355835,
-0.19742321968078613,
0.17962543666362762,
-0.33579471707344055,
0.38635221123695374,
-0.23418720066547394,
0.8391462564468384,
0.41390150785446167,
-0.032605674117803574,
-0.014635724946856499,
-0.48336702585220337,
0.5044491291046143,
0.6222622394561768,
-1.0845389366149902,
0.17486901581287384,
0.3233325183391571,
0.30220460891723633,
-0.2898622751235962,
0.517121434211731,
0.07323042303323746,
-0.004574430175125599,
-0.3007892668247223,
-0.09414463490247726,
-0.195434108376503,
-0.44538432359695435,
-0.2837875783443451,
0.1265423446893692,
0.4986068606376648,
-0.09252825379371643
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.01006v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.01006v1
|
SemCoder: Training Code Language Models with Comprehensive Semantics
| 2024-06-03T05:36:57 | 2024-06-03T05:36:57 |
Yangruibo Ding, Jinjun Peng, Marcus J. Min, Gail Kaiser, Junfeng Yang, Baishakhi Ray
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.SE
|
Code Large Language Models (Code LLMs) have excelled at tasks like code
completion but often miss deeper semantics such as execution effects and
dynamic states. This paper aims to bridge the gap between Code LLMs' reliance
on static text data and the need for thorough semantic understanding for
complex tasks like debugging and program repair. We introduce a novel strategy
to train Code LLMs with comprehensive semantics, encompassing high-level
functional descriptions, local execution effects of individual statements, and
overall input/output behavior, thereby linking static code text with dynamic
execution states. We begin by collecting PyX, a clean code corpus of fully
executable samples with functional descriptions and execution tracing. We
propose training Code LLMs to write code and represent and reason about
execution behaviors using natural language, mimicking human verbal debugging.
This approach led to the development of SemCoder, a Code LLM with only 6.7B
parameters, which shows competitive performance with GPT-3.5-turbo on code
generation and execution reasoning tasks. SemCoder achieves 81.1% on HumanEval
(GPT-3.5-turbo: 76.8%) and 54.5% on CRUXEval-I (GPT-3.5-turbo: 50.3%). We also
study the effectiveness of SemCoder's monologue-style execution reasoning
compared to concrete scratchpad reasoning, showing that our approach integrates
semantics from multiple dimensions more smoothly. Finally, we demonstrate the
potential of applying learned semantics to improve Code LLMs' debugging and
self-refining capabilities.
|
[
-0.10974612832069397,
-0.867883563041687,
0.7018090486526489,
0.06878818571567535,
-0.2470635026693344,
0.2119661122560501,
-0.44126763939857483,
-0.3635331392288208,
0.22080986201763153,
0.7955896258354187,
-0.49303385615348816,
-0.8471390008926392,
-0.5056445002555847,
-0.08142522722482681,
-0.28814050555229187,
0.9846982359886169,
-0.28675878047943115,
-0.21887029707431793,
-0.162125363945961,
0.09465541690587997,
-0.3874344527721405,
-0.6414337754249573,
-0.1838463991880417,
-0.19497497379779816,
0.5172332525253296,
0.5700958371162415,
0.5111843347549438,
0.6497990489006042,
0.49256932735443115,
0.33309847116470337,
0.09859386086463928,
0.09474965184926987,
-0.5682200193405151,
0.1590874344110489,
-0.0033305883407592773,
-0.3557549715042114,
-0.47520679235458374,
-0.3736952543258667,
0.05772547423839569,
0.6130568981170654,
-0.15155231952667236,
0.17014849185943604,
0.017739102244377136,
0.3818345367908478,
-0.6489554047584534,
0.08356338739395142,
-0.7290900349617004,
0.24698811769485474,
-0.15942662954330444,
-0.4886189103126526,
-0.2878306806087494,
-0.25358638167381287,
-0.2948478162288666,
-0.3894270360469818,
0.013133552856743336,
-0.38373202085494995,
0.626787543296814,
0.43464261293411255,
-0.512670636177063,
-0.5770127177238464,
-0.3504524827003479,
0.6512410044670105,
-0.9266642332077026,
-0.21292196214199066,
0.28964921832084656,
0.14511562883853912,
-0.05270018056035042,
-0.7522459626197815,
-0.3567731976509094,
-0.42846348881721497,
0.017282454296946526,
0.022324392572045326,
0.33745861053466797,
0.15914925932884216,
0.5589622855186462,
0.36935487389564514,
-0.3086346983909607,
0.0436943843960762,
-0.4454280436038971,
-0.1424584686756134,
0.5858988165855408,
0.40788859128952026,
0.5070602893829346,
-0.05568742752075195,
-0.6489715576171875,
0.3553139567375183,
-0.5695826411247253,
-0.23181186616420746,
0.3746137022972107,
0.0683681070804596,
-0.1486923098564148,
0.4245358109474182,
-0.10768574476242065,
0.5618019104003906,
-0.4448332190513611,
0.054231058806180954,
0.29513564705848694,
-0.05327104404568672,
-0.30770939588546753,
0.310991495847702,
0.40709930658340454,
0.1314546763896942,
0.11023011803627014,
-0.32305389642715454,
-0.1796879768371582,
0.30755048990249634,
0.5764839053153992,
-0.8390504717826843,
-0.20157687366008759,
0.1522124856710434,
-0.39666226506233215,
-0.5654190182685852,
-0.03677664324641228,
-0.584514319896698,
-0.4526048004627228,
-0.7810256481170654,
0.504084587097168,
-0.6171337366104126,
-0.3122097849845886,
0.4038918912410736,
0.1479237824678421,
0.5503754615783691,
0.3275909423828125,
-0.7736772894859314,
0.2808564603328705,
0.9895819425582886,
0.7173255681991577,
-0.2375156730413437,
-0.41356709599494934,
-0.5062174797058105,
0.37625107169151306,
-0.2564803957939148,
0.605776309967041,
-0.7216333746910095,
-0.26567399501800537,
-0.007159102708101273,
-0.014617236331105232,
-0.13843773305416107,
-0.5040385127067566,
0.4290824234485626,
-0.27201274037361145,
-0.32305049896240234,
-0.015595614910125732,
-0.6074076294898987,
0.006450268439948559,
0.2540251314640045,
-0.2262004166841507,
0.9650823473930359,
-0.0830623060464859,
-1.0022751092910767,
0.13046972453594208,
-0.6142401099205017,
-0.7309099435806274,
-0.1713344007730484,
-0.2433677613735199,
-0.18092671036720276,
0.4002380967140198,
-0.07774647325277328,
0.5201177597045898,
0.06539791822433472,
0.33757877349853516,
-0.501457929611206,
-0.7644540071487427,
0.2601786255836487,
-0.15004685521125793,
0.7459301352500916,
0.2846318185329437,
-0.6885865330696106,
0.14824385941028595,
-0.8280383348464966,
0.20625530183315277,
0.07197646051645279,
-0.29282090067863464,
-0.1960492879152298,
0.03932053595781326,
-0.29816097021102905,
0.13954900205135345,
0.4272129535675049,
-0.3074376583099365,
0.26473262906074524,
-0.4129631519317627,
0.5072835087776184,
0.8099527955055237,
-0.10137011855840683,
0.11019980162382126,
-0.026982372626662254,
0.5411978960037231,
0.02132495306432247,
0.0920577347278595,
-0.45309385657310486,
0.16645637154579163,
-1.1070696115493774,
-0.35507524013519287,
-0.11136981099843979,
0.5948556065559387,
-0.5996348857879639,
0.38142022490501404,
0.08927091211080551,
-0.3302362859249115,
-0.1151125580072403,
0.2990599572658539,
0.2855137288570404,
0.40742161870002747,
0.3056400716304779,
-0.20888476073741913,
-0.5969770550727844,
-0.8915550708770752,
-0.43772369623184204,
0.06879857182502747,
0.13375286757946014,
0.13250364363193512,
0.6376389265060425,
-0.5755425691604614,
0.5139702558517456,
-0.578646719455719,
-0.017117733135819435,
-0.40749040246009827,
0.19019751250743866,
0.4759788513183594,
0.4278118908405304,
0.036746855825185776,
-0.3011128008365631,
-0.16020119190216064,
-0.18954919278621674,
-0.6568595170974731,
-0.23074333369731903,
-0.16320501267910004,
-0.3644702136516571,
0.2668740153312683,
0.6181700825691223,
-0.21493256092071533,
0.3897355794906616,
0.5154716968536377,
-0.3328038156032562,
0.3299553692340851,
-0.5913234353065491,
-0.01030912809073925,
-1.0256212949752808,
0.16511234641075134,
-0.5296698212623596,
-0.1578938364982605,
-0.4156738817691803,
0.27659618854522705,
0.061787303537130356,
-0.338287889957428,
-0.2849048376083374,
0.1295069456100464,
-0.5306441187858582,
-0.24016816914081573,
-0.3390374779701233,
-0.06584195792675018,
-0.27836427092552185,
0.6113680005073547,
0.033682357519865036,
0.45010867714881897,
0.5259178280830383,
-0.5732323527336121,
0.31553319096565247,
-0.012987608090043068,
-0.43823665380477905,
0.18483082950115204,
-0.8259204030036926,
0.5226753354072571,
-0.046192750334739685,
-0.04684700444340706,
-0.8859310150146484,
-0.21112185716629028,
-0.19250410795211792,
-0.2761765420436859,
0.44006261229515076,
-0.15112197399139404,
-0.601356029510498,
-0.12224867194890976,
-0.29736924171447754,
0.09761643409729004,
0.4891173839569092,
-0.530457079410553,
0.32253894209861755,
0.42795008420944214,
-0.10245536267757416,
-0.4032812714576721,
-0.6217724680900574,
0.2779020667076111,
-0.25268781185150146,
-0.5478724241256714,
0.11415364593267441,
0.1333114057779312,
-0.08264826238155365,
-0.2401900589466095,
-0.3331388235092163,
-0.21108995378017426,
0.5239367485046387,
0.38254573941230774,
0.2802591919898987,
-0.040454499423503876,
0.19953468441963196,
0.005799084901809692,
-0.36132073402404785,
0.13013915717601776,
-0.10174031555652618,
0.5732412934303284,
-0.36788439750671387,
-0.469406396150589,
-0.18147946894168854,
0.11103478074073792,
0.34090420603752136,
-0.36459535360336304,
0.4850221872329712,
0.6188845634460449,
-0.06893328577280045,
-0.2676204741001129,
-0.35317978262901306,
-0.1460527926683426,
-0.45771485567092896,
0.38832786679267883,
-0.3286551237106323,
-1.0357577800750732,
0.26246732473373413,
-0.34271350502967834,
0.012209014967083931,
0.21269014477729797,
0.7139400243759155,
0.019846508279442787,
0.9986349940299988,
0.5804976224899292,
0.09833864867687225,
0.21476325392723083,
-0.40905916690826416,
0.3033891022205353,
-0.6594228744506836,
-0.17682063579559326,
-0.47579044103622437,
-0.3632303476333618,
-0.44495129585266113,
-0.7814825177192688,
0.16630561649799347,
0.28277647495269775,
-0.491849809885025,
0.3727252781391144,
-0.5247089266777039,
0.5959725379943848,
0.3035741448402405,
0.1456698626279831,
0.21928179264068604,
0.10142610222101212,
-0.2970907986164093,
-0.09390338510274887,
-0.516284167766571,
-0.6780064105987549,
0.7531948089599609,
0.5108059644699097,
1.1408259868621826,
0.0002520893176551908,
1.1694564819335938,
0.09598694741725922,
0.10022197663784027,
-0.6090440154075623,
0.5807238221168518,
-0.0318848118185997,
-0.3525983691215515,
0.07074201107025146,
-0.583570122718811,
-0.5797474980354309,
0.12922999262809753,
0.20509515702724457,
-0.5923422574996948,
-0.3054462969303131,
0.21762721240520477,
-0.08267561346292496,
0.1259227842092514,
-0.6213351488113403,
1.1989542245864868,
-0.6717303395271301,
-0.5260087251663208,
-0.5721077919006348,
-0.6689971089363098,
0.38099879026412964,
0.1910717785358429,
0.2580845057964325,
-0.37093299627304077,
-0.40115052461624146,
0.28367993235588074,
-0.6027753949165344,
1.130358338356018,
-0.28784751892089844,
-0.31182900071144104,
0.2312558889389038,
0.3711673617362976,
0.4932902753353119,
0.2668680250644684,
0.10049349814653397,
0.17247086763381958,
0.26036304235458374,
-0.4876002371311188,
-0.4084525406360626,
0.7720084190368652,
-0.6239043474197388,
-0.3388589322566986,
-0.4244554936885834,
-0.3936759829521179,
-0.2841581106185913,
0.09490877389907837,
0.05168376490473747,
0.7869709730148315,
0.025929803028702736,
0.08475808054208755,
0.7962379455566406,
-0.721020519733429,
0.15834295749664307,
0.5035826563835144,
-0.10793029516935349,
-0.2876722812652588,
0.7549129724502563,
-0.36013394594192505,
0.08990102261304855,
0.31983646750450134,
0.008455655537545681,
0.003092491999268532,
-0.33163192868232727,
-0.1956196129322052,
0.2330237627029419,
-0.7548421025276184,
-0.30461716651916504,
-0.7665655016899109,
0.003178612096235156,
-0.07627405226230621,
-0.37487003207206726,
-0.23106519877910614,
-0.43946966528892517,
0.00006160281918710098,
0.01793958805501461,
0.19776412844657898,
0.576601505279541,
0.12053581327199936,
-0.04086862504482269,
-0.8378991484642029,
0.2746365964412689,
0.12995198369026184,
0.4341137707233429,
-0.08335158973932266,
-0.4388100802898407,
-0.22385892271995544,
-0.09110534191131592,
-0.25465768575668335,
-0.7896425127983093,
0.21934270858764648,
0.07063009589910507,
0.5077551603317261,
0.023896586149930954,
0.12370937317609787,
0.8148643970489502,
-0.5205510258674622,
0.5742892026901245,
0.1756083071231842,
-1.1671404838562012,
0.893374502658844,
-0.3088271915912628,
0.42237263917922974,
0.7054778337478638,
0.04879464581608772,
-0.5188026428222656,
-0.636772632598877,
-0.6005280613899231,
-0.9786564111709595,
0.6217111945152283,
-0.06471004337072372,
0.6545800566673279,
-0.4951481521129608,
0.3309352993965149,
0.04824268817901611,
0.210927352309227,
-0.39224839210510254,
0.3102153241634369,
-0.03437519818544388,
-0.42538216710090637,
0.23307405412197113,
-0.3833048343658447,
-0.02639036439359188,
-0.3721465468406677,
0.5463119745254517,
-0.49195924401283264,
0.4926217794418335,
0.13767026364803314,
-0.5816679000854492,
0.3549824059009552,
0.3221100866794586,
0.7786890864372253,
0.8915925621986389,
0.005563534330576658,
0.4893300235271454,
0.4432694613933563,
-0.11423987150192261,
-0.11899768561124802,
-0.2930872440338135,
0.3332407772541046,
-0.11795442551374435,
0.6232237219810486,
0.7066994905471802,
0.6020748019218445,
-1.0062241554260254,
0.5496104955673218,
0.08472757041454315,
-0.12696225941181183,
-0.5139850378036499,
0.41263362765312195,
0.2879842519760132,
0.14936889708042145,
-0.21755830943584442,
-0.14100635051727295,
0.24771234393119812,
-0.7963476777076721,
0.20737579464912415,
0.13282272219657898,
-0.4807054400444031,
-0.23458801209926605,
0.5013399124145508,
0.16903157532215118,
0.2431471049785614,
0.6047316789627075,
-0.06016697362065315,
-0.7999007105827332,
0.8837383985519409,
0.6223549842834473,
0.7635666728019714,
0.12114997208118439,
0.1598755270242691,
0.42871788144111633,
0.13853345811367035,
0.08752717077732086,
0.5884103775024414,
-0.37418633699417114,
-0.3734991252422333,
-0.7091092467308044,
-0.7952746152877808,
-0.2809300422668457,
-0.18379667401313782,
-0.5030888319015503,
0.4641779065132141,
-0.6545899510383606,
0.25470513105392456,
-0.4482785165309906,
0.07794954627752304,
-0.2823813855648041,
-0.09638485312461853,
0.2268391102552414,
1.0818449258804321,
-0.31251367926597595,
0.9529696702957153,
0.8068719506263733,
-0.3346075117588043,
-0.8835142254829407,
-0.1354384571313858,
-0.1625632345676422,
-0.8638421893119812,
0.9483093023300171,
0.4435180425643921,
-0.08290363848209381,
-0.11906875669956207,
-0.6315414905548096,
-0.4960850775241852,
0.9679117798805237,
0.5292335748672485,
-0.5458464622497559,
0.11325554549694061,
0.07123806327581406,
0.4908452332019806,
-0.29541879892349243,
0.19530582427978516,
0.5272471308708191,
0.24028900265693665,
0.2513468563556671,
-0.5877308249473572,
0.06957390159368515,
-0.15098200738430023,
0.2681380808353424,
0.465302973985672,
-0.4453187584877014,
0.5749800801277161,
-0.5144299268722534,
0.016232619062066078,
0.13040626049041748,
0.31577757000923157,
0.21393251419067383,
0.2865011692047119,
0.32944586873054504,
0.65594482421875,
0.7116734385490417,
0.055665504187345505,
1.1535485982894897,
-0.6444874405860901,
0.5838865041732788,
1.2306108474731445,
-0.4348840117454529,
0.7584347724914551,
0.2784328758716583,
0.04158183932304382,
0.5803985595703125,
0.33183369040489197,
0.17986389994621277,
0.33296990394592285,
0.5630462169647217,
-0.18395371735095978,
-0.5185161828994751,
0.198341503739357,
-0.3707587420940399,
0.5429743528366089,
0.19536776840686798,
-0.42076051235198975,
-0.24430020153522491,
-0.15708264708518982,
0.4189109802246094,
0.10178879648447037,
-0.14705470204353333,
0.7756454944610596,
0.19140374660491943,
-0.3295838236808777,
0.6804720759391785,
-0.011866812594234943,
0.5391296744346619,
-0.6079781651496887,
-0.05908004567027092,
-0.34192270040512085,
0.578777015209198,
-0.35572028160095215,
-0.44865909218788147,
0.6588740348815918,
0.19660186767578125,
0.15703372657299042,
-0.2801017463207245,
0.9580195546150208,
-0.3722696900367737,
-0.3840036392211914,
0.26113033294677734,
-0.0051260958425700665,
0.21280115842819214,
0.10016116499900818,
-0.5939019322395325,
0.2798997461795807,
-0.13826484978199005,
0.02406241185963154,
0.24591641128063202,
0.5966064929962158,
0.2744302749633789,
0.3826259970664978,
0.412509560585022,
0.04154643416404724,
-0.03287817910313606,
0.08761005103588104,
0.8691579699516296,
-0.7856521606445312,
-0.35845428705215454,
-0.8869534730911255,
0.40602797269821167,
-0.32465702295303345,
-0.1502087265253067,
0.6040574312210083,
0.7092810869216919,
0.6445983648300171,
-0.06836400926113129,
0.6805805563926697,
-0.18931753933429718,
0.4430803656578064,
-0.8227159380912781,
0.39871716499328613,
-0.3414950966835022,
0.5037696361541748,
-0.16839471459388733,
-0.9091445207595825,
-0.20550546050071716,
0.9824442267417908,
-0.41082683205604553,
-0.009978527203202248,
0.6795124411582947,
0.7332596778869629,
-0.10474887490272522,
-0.06270869076251984,
0.39513975381851196,
0.4116511940956116,
0.24958522617816925,
0.9357344508171082,
1.1229348182678223,
-0.09477683901786804,
0.35288161039352417,
-0.1269957274198532,
-0.21315619349479675,
-0.28280308842658997,
-1.0306875705718994,
-0.9925251007080078,
-0.04785407707095146,
-0.4042576253414154,
-0.36126717925071716,
0.06584890186786652,
0.9930976629257202,
0.4377869963645935,
-0.6460134983062744,
-0.34537333250045776,
-0.19218190014362335,
-0.04740671068429947,
0.055872928351163864,
-0.18135808408260345,
0.06191229820251465,
-1.1049474477767944,
-0.2032211869955063,
0.18642254173755646,
0.5753480195999146,
-0.42117029428482056,
-0.16122886538505554,
-0.2657129168510437,
0.24121809005737305,
-0.01829143986105919,
0.7052438259124756,
-0.05815969035029411,
-0.43384280800819397,
-0.2933998107910156,
-0.04711151123046875,
-0.2972445785999298,
-0.1884976327419281,
1.3353261947631836,
-0.5928378105163574,
0.1888941079378128,
0.4831823706626892,
0.892238974571228,
0.5357152819633484,
-0.35903382301330566,
0.50751793384552,
-0.5003135204315186,
0.1524071842432022,
0.22488263249397278,
0.33892732858657837,
0.09014234691858292,
-0.23510096967220306,
0.6409537196159363,
0.18419940769672394,
-0.5840404033660889,
-0.7344895601272583,
0.3091806173324585,
-0.7321280241012573,
-0.4844515323638916,
1.2318024635314941,
-0.17626097798347473,
-0.2667236626148224,
0.054513756185770035,
-0.5019832253456116,
0.10021253675222397,
0.16665351390838623,
0.6923977732658386,
0.4115638732910156,
-0.05870874226093292,
-0.09826430678367615,
-0.8767986297607422,
0.30987250804901123,
0.34524405002593994,
-0.9942665100097656,
0.17520222067832947,
0.6426273584365845,
0.39143693447113037,
-0.1655338704586029,
0.770110011100769,
-0.3255203366279602,
0.17595155537128448,
-0.1238630935549736,
0.11255446076393127,
-0.3048468232154846,
-0.21533142030239105,
-0.4076386094093323,
0.030637750402092934,
0.2302941083908081,
0.12268537282943726
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00999v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00999v1
|
Seeing the Forest through the Trees: Data Leakage from Partial Transformer Gradients
| 2024-06-03T05:15:04 | 2024-06-03T05:15:04 |
Weijun Li, Qiongkai Xu, Mark Dras
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CR, I.2.7; I.2.11
|
Recent studies have shown that distributed machine learning is vulnerable to
gradient inversion attacks, where private training data can be reconstructed by
analyzing the gradients of the models shared in training. Previous attacks
established that such reconstructions are possible using gradients from all
parameters in the entire models. However, we hypothesize that most of the
involved modules, or even their sub-modules, are at risk of training data
leakage, and we validate such vulnerabilities in various intermediate layers of
language models. Our extensive experiments reveal that gradients from a single
Transformer layer, or even a single linear component with 0.54% parameters, are
susceptible to training data leakage. Additionally, we show that applying
differential privacy on gradients during training offers limited protection
against the novel vulnerability of data disclosure.
|
[
-0.10038840770721436,
-0.7562171816825867,
0.13002240657806396,
-0.03922303020954132,
0.18509703874588013,
0.2749289870262146,
0.2678018808364868,
-0.454895943403244,
-0.2480170577764511,
0.7287157773971558,
-0.7360159158706665,
-0.2689492404460907,
-0.8689188361167908,
-0.3467099666595459,
-0.838518500328064,
1.1999073028564453,
0.02826753631234169,
0.01752796396613121,
-0.08617816120386124,
-0.4896659553050995,
-0.11786720156669617,
-0.7460654377937317,
-0.5680803656578064,
-0.12876230478286743,
0.48709961771965027,
-0.002369566820561886,
0.5983516573905945,
0.46451708674430847,
0.6156197190284729,
0.3438853919506073,
0.10734224319458008,
-0.6894297003746033,
-0.6055129170417786,
0.39076241850852966,
-0.018176216632127762,
-1.1218619346618652,
-0.29871687293052673,
-0.06306687742471695,
0.7928057909011841,
0.6754050254821777,
-0.08480986952781677,
0.19603021442890167,
0.27923470735549927,
1.1819474697113037,
-0.5766295194625854,
-0.07696011662483215,
-0.8438073992729187,
0.42799997329711914,
-0.4000547230243683,
0.047309137880802155,
-0.3432247042655945,
-0.20893719792366028,
0.2612416446208954,
-0.3803178668022156,
0.6071043014526367,
-0.17425382137298584,
0.6929425597190857,
0.3788386881351471,
-0.21517828106880188,
-0.04629050940275192,
-0.8902774453163147,
0.7745069861412048,
-0.1358792930841446,
0.11253700405359268,
0.38659214973449707,
0.8545019626617432,
0.2441800832748413,
-0.7363443970680237,
-0.29582569003105164,
-0.2055087834596634,
-0.250737726688385,
-0.003401817986741662,
-0.6189470887184143,
0.13088180124759674,
0.5180479884147644,
0.6971097588539124,
-0.4020787477493286,
0.09835978597402573,
-0.20294612646102905,
-0.08311884105205536,
0.5750253796577454,
0.11927635222673416,
0.3148884177207947,
0.07160279154777527,
-0.4257352650165558,
-0.4686795175075531,
-0.7949686050415039,
0.19643177092075348,
0.9418873190879822,
0.021626286208629608,
-0.24179528653621674,
0.32662534713745117,
0.16735170781612396,
0.5254174470901489,
-0.3367235064506531,
0.2593335807323456,
0.012246960774064064,
-0.25327885150909424,
-0.6568444967269897,
-0.34599927067756653,
0.5511308312416077,
-0.10546199232339859,
0.18728338181972504,
-0.26625683903694153,
-0.3066219687461853,
-0.16166183352470398,
0.13038724660873413,
-0.5922209024429321,
-0.4819750487804413,
0.23977313935756683,
-0.3191168010234833,
-0.5445712804794312,
0.2005210667848587,
-0.9868453741073608,
-0.6862923502922058,
0.04017443209886551,
0.2567942142486572,
-0.0018602950731292367,
-0.5181980729103088,
0.04842112213373184,
-0.2740054428577423,
0.18855299055576324,
0.11331276595592499,
-0.7294588088989258,
0.6754451990127563,
0.7233023047447205,
0.665143609046936,
-0.005537673365324736,
-0.41158753633499146,
-0.29806026816368103,
0.17179326713085175,
0.028809798881411552,
0.20038513839244843,
-0.4955452084541321,
-0.39315053820610046,
0.1736784130334854,
0.2819803059101105,
-0.22381547093391418,
-0.4640512764453888,
0.25983119010925293,
-0.4550083875656128,
0.2651267349720001,
-0.06530516594648361,
-0.16072572767734528,
-0.051542818546295166,
0.1954212188720703,
-0.8864253759384155,
1.0712335109710693,
0.29308757185935974,
-1.2519651651382446,
-0.09635983407497406,
-0.52134770154953,
-0.18187656998634338,
-0.2559058666229248,
-0.362395316362381,
-0.7825028300285339,
-0.013751653954386711,
0.24743697047233582,
0.4753584861755371,
-0.061455149203538895,
0.10708494484424591,
-0.17942865192890167,
-0.1906389594078064,
0.4301539957523346,
-0.7300808429718018,
1.3459563255310059,
-0.11419288069009781,
-0.6307085752487183,
-0.14439573884010315,
-0.7541671991348267,
-0.1567770391702652,
0.12426827847957611,
-0.13549773395061493,
-0.2872830033302307,
-0.3320482075214386,
-0.27339866757392883,
0.057091955095529556,
-0.10477171838283539,
-0.615852952003479,
0.3211657702922821,
-0.19008450210094452,
0.4141489267349243,
1.1104522943496704,
0.04898633807897568,
0.704632043838501,
-0.24027642607688904,
0.9426789879798889,
0.39582520723342896,
0.4062133729457855,
-0.2799869179725647,
-0.33863162994384766,
-0.8798707127571106,
-0.4627036154270172,
0.3903602957725525,
0.43595656752586365,
-0.5685265064239502,
0.3553306758403778,
-0.1679694950580597,
-0.7197793126106262,
-0.6790181994438171,
-0.24466122686862946,
0.36742281913757324,
0.4581434428691864,
0.20461656153202057,
0.06513434648513794,
-0.37090152502059937,
-0.9988128542900085,
-0.4538877606391907,
0.01944422908127308,
-0.2685088813304901,
0.6638764142990112,
0.6604401469230652,
-0.19048438966274261,
0.9205942153930664,
-0.7035994529724121,
-0.26592302322387695,
0.009904158301651478,
-0.11806385964155197,
0.015298896469175816,
0.8107591271400452,
0.6767107248306274,
-0.479696661233902,
-0.49100592732429504,
-0.008226877078413963,
-0.7105165123939514,
0.2763684093952179,
-0.20138700306415558,
-0.29447638988494873,
-0.076461561024189,
0.2008165568113327,
-0.4679355323314667,
0.6869272589683533,
0.8443581461906433,
0.024024205282330513,
0.17708249390125275,
-0.2486046850681305,
-0.38019734621047974,
-1.0422695875167847,
0.16327117383480072,
0.014046875759959221,
-0.37189653515815735,
-0.6408872604370117,
0.10244371742010117,
-0.08822140097618103,
-0.31190094351768494,
-0.1456456035375595,
0.083308644592762,
-0.4519747495651245,
-0.17497651278972626,
0.09450077265501022,
-0.3704642057418823,
0.010809450410306454,
0.4170704185962677,
-0.3929716646671295,
0.5043855905532837,
1.519484281539917,
-0.3050239682197571,
0.3339236378669739,
-0.07801742851734161,
-0.24007675051689148,
0.2860202491283417,
-0.5700578689575195,
0.5897909998893738,
-0.4017328917980194,
0.5358253121376038,
-0.7907624840736389,
0.0581728033721447,
0.3138284981250763,
-0.322671115398407,
0.6288751363754272,
-0.3892117738723755,
-0.13207679986953735,
0.04009118676185608,
-0.5820575952529907,
0.26911216974258423,
0.5445277094841003,
-0.6187548041343689,
0.4206995368003845,
0.49167460203170776,
0.26201725006103516,
-1.0658453702926636,
-1.0380356311798096,
0.02170417085289955,
-0.4130180776119232,
-0.6347581744194031,
0.11894014477729797,
0.15613093972206116,
-0.03565095737576485,
-0.0682768002152443,
-0.1640738695859909,
-0.32492437958717346,
0.5675718784332275,
0.5331703424453735,
-0.04067585989832878,
-0.186904639005661,
-0.5290011763572693,
-0.07333125174045563,
-0.10371016710996628,
0.29990336298942566,
-0.32543447613716125,
0.35992640256881714,
0.04678820073604584,
-0.6638689041137695,
-0.6788448095321655,
0.5472663044929504,
0.41399481892585754,
-0.13263572752475739,
0.9958202838897705,
0.15310783684253693,
-0.5488370656967163,
-0.535892128944397,
-0.051269836723804474,
-0.3874925971031189,
-0.48457640409469604,
0.5656241774559021,
-0.3376438021659851,
-0.5767915844917297,
0.6245576739311218,
-0.03764650225639343,
-0.12742146849632263,
0.23524774610996246,
0.08897406607866287,
-0.2492091953754425,
0.9203453063964844,
1.2130568027496338,
-0.4272364377975464,
0.6202772855758667,
-0.7368630170822144,
0.19384397566318512,
-0.4762137830257416,
-0.3729962706565857,
-0.876865565776825,
-0.5012869238853455,
-0.9548325538635254,
-0.15310372412204742,
0.12244486063718796,
0.26166388392448425,
-0.19345174729824066,
0.2270016074180603,
-0.49896663427352905,
0.8561347126960754,
0.5924071073532104,
0.18240967392921448,
0.1577632576227188,
0.28641608357429504,
0.12054380029439926,
0.15760189294815063,
-0.5064330101013184,
-0.43728235363960266,
1.0351521968841553,
0.8872855305671692,
0.8300483822822571,
0.0005577157135121524,
0.7898015379905701,
0.09432962536811829,
0.3239053785800934,
-0.5002842545509338,
0.30722394585609436,
0.037866804748773575,
-0.7794957756996155,
-0.32446610927581787,
-0.4358977973461151,
-0.8894072771072388,
0.10857504606246948,
0.2744513154029846,
-0.7574971318244934,
0.46958568692207336,
-0.04512927308678627,
-0.057343896478414536,
0.40679582953453064,
-0.6098950505256653,
0.6289203763008118,
0.11027408391237259,
-0.1079632043838501,
0.1453319936990738,
-1.0396270751953125,
0.37565934658050537,
-0.2670256495475769,
0.06804507225751877,
0.10939575731754303,
0.26732951402664185,
0.7856845259666443,
-0.19248700141906738,
1.0795764923095703,
-0.5198016166687012,
0.10573645681142807,
0.0310148186981678,
0.3317229449748993,
0.5433680415153503,
0.1505468487739563,
0.048751991242170334,
0.5554628372192383,
-0.1673099845647812,
-0.6682060956954956,
-0.6793993711471558,
0.48551642894744873,
-0.9968036413192749,
-0.6664149761199951,
-0.742801308631897,
-0.2961488366127014,
-0.177973210811615,
-0.09849867224693298,
0.05532862991094589,
0.2570023536682129,
-0.03993161395192146,
0.3947567343711853,
0.5991055369377136,
-0.08140739053487778,
0.528478741645813,
0.38931381702423096,
0.05433925986289978,
-0.2818990647792816,
0.9251444339752197,
0.09437288343906403,
0.3975622355937958,
0.33441048860549927,
0.32276904582977295,
0.07196399569511414,
-0.770076334476471,
-0.16378842294216156,
0.027593055739998817,
-0.6808353662490845,
-0.3179461359977722,
-0.4761245846748352,
-0.5633535981178284,
-0.015383746474981308,
0.05681108310818672,
-0.32935234904289246,
-0.7466299533843994,
-0.07837918400764465,
-0.559548556804657,
0.19953718781471252,
0.9132158160209656,
0.026068517938256264,
0.5068731307983398,
-0.8066518902778625,
-0.17492137849330902,
0.14657709002494812,
0.2538277804851532,
0.0862010046839714,
-0.32496699690818787,
-0.15538904070854187,
0.18454036116600037,
-0.5006018280982971,
-0.7785488367080688,
0.2954108715057373,
0.07959955185651779,
0.6033912301063538,
0.3580917716026306,
-0.15634344518184662,
0.3379712700843811,
-0.5698770880699158,
0.9124067425727844,
0.1354934424161911,
-0.8916172385215759,
0.48330825567245483,
-0.18475517630577087,
-0.2537133991718292,
0.5689888000488281,
0.5500196218490601,
-0.23399920761585236,
-0.7112852931022644,
-0.8147419691085815,
-0.6590175628662109,
1.1231595277786255,
0.5385874509811401,
0.4447516202926636,
0.752842128276825,
0.2051704227924347,
0.4022004008293152,
0.23512403666973114,
-0.9364832639694214,
-0.721295952796936,
-0.4898836016654968,
-0.10484840720891953,
0.07390785962343216,
-0.13104575872421265,
-0.5547831058502197,
-0.3852382302284241,
0.1906198263168335,
0.09685245156288147,
0.059475962072610855,
-0.009255851618945599,
0.033919695764780045,
-0.07722841203212738,
-0.032397348433732986,
0.17502450942993164,
0.49912118911743164,
-0.030155569314956665,
0.43296143412590027,
-0.22081515192985535,
-0.706341564655304,
0.248497873544693,
0.04700404778122902,
-0.2737165689468384,
0.008633104152977467,
0.5390627980232239,
0.7616026997566223,
-0.2736954689025879,
-0.017231646925210953,
0.7397575974464417,
-0.2637987434864044,
-0.14665842056274414,
-0.044710032641887665,
-0.011489677242934704,
-0.1590193212032318,
0.054834652692079544,
0.20435689389705658,
0.5156249403953552,
-0.1419685333967209,
-0.4486236870288849,
0.19069218635559082,
0.43173521757125854,
-0.4226221442222595,
-0.7825927138328552,
0.4233194589614868,
0.10030515491962433,
-0.20008422434329987,
0.6802761554718018,
0.6796144843101501,
-0.5792579650878906,
0.623411238193512,
0.4137271046638489,
1.0262898206710815,
-0.6178261041641235,
0.2211666703224182,
0.014660526998341084,
0.4771188497543335,
0.1411888599395752,
-0.07828719913959503,
-0.36675140261650085,
-0.4571778178215027,
0.140841543674469,
-0.4622651934623718,
-0.18694506585597992,
0.056763384491205215,
-0.8775585889816284,
-0.051771827042102814,
-0.3677057921886444,
0.06703135371208191,
-0.10470961779356003,
-0.2694893181324005,
-0.5527491569519043,
0.10746533423662186,
-0.08463083207607269,
0.7421301007270813,
-1.049290418624878,
1.074459433555603,
0.3211664855480194,
-0.3614814281463623,
-0.4289197325706482,
0.4234451353549957,
-0.4389703869819641,
-0.9971720576286316,
0.80224609375,
0.1803218573331833,
0.09887810051441193,
-0.04045917093753815,
-0.49717187881469727,
-0.5937679409980774,
1.1426924467086792,
1.019141435623169,
-0.5132005214691162,
-0.20609620213508606,
0.7894613742828369,
0.36151114106178284,
0.24163515865802765,
0.329080194234848,
0.6829798817634583,
0.19450609385967255,
-0.07469425350427628,
-0.5038062334060669,
-0.10004475712776184,
0.2445591390132904,
-0.16267313063144684,
0.04515848681330681,
-0.5063819885253906,
0.9324809312820435,
0.26384034752845764,
-0.41453811526298523,
-0.43883180618286133,
0.25197654962539673,
-0.19406944513320923,
0.16102305054664612,
0.4632226228713989,
0.5148912668228149,
1.033784031867981,
0.0019566440023481846,
1.2485297918319702,
-0.13517126441001892,
0.379868745803833,
0.7842472791671753,
-0.11227117478847504,
0.5395511388778687,
0.49811315536499023,
-0.3865527808666229,
0.31314316391944885,
0.45767781138420105,
0.29211774468421936,
0.831748366355896,
0.5165783166885376,
-0.5596538782119751,
0.41587385535240173,
0.11576870828866959,
-0.4962655305862427,
0.06566782295703888,
0.04002353176474571,
-0.48099640011787415,
-0.1945890635251999,
-0.050606876611709595,
0.2203582376241684,
-0.19183453917503357,
-0.16619884967803955,
0.7313629984855652,
0.2564482092857361,
-0.23983356356620789,
0.4529753029346466,
-0.06468591094017029,
0.2685481607913971,
-0.6182817816734314,
0.10022436082363129,
-0.5813585519790649,
0.40387311577796936,
-0.5163368582725525,
-0.657805860042572,
0.5564526319503784,
0.042568136006593704,
0.010376988910138607,
-0.5137523412704468,
0.5087314248085022,
-0.11286461353302002,
-0.3269352614879608,
0.27588534355163574,
0.3334100842475891,
-0.06918567419052124,
-0.17319586873054504,
-0.7482708692550659,
0.019586585462093353,
0.006254310254007578,
-0.43711042404174805,
0.6336773633956909,
0.4121994972229004,
0.2321702390909195,
0.594545841217041,
0.43592676520347595,
0.11580083519220352,
0.6063069701194763,
0.1294223964214325,
1.197536826133728,
-0.3454260528087616,
-0.26204603910446167,
-1.173323154449463,
0.6410019397735596,
-0.2520703971385956,
0.042602259665727615,
1.156022071838379,
0.6245113015174866,
0.9159957766532898,
0.045719046145677567,
0.9178321957588196,
0.48340174555778503,
0.10454273223876953,
-0.47686606645584106,
0.9955199956893921,
-0.07269572466611862,
0.4135613441467285,
0.029357921332120895,
-0.9302533268928528,
-0.21687814593315125,
0.26630210876464844,
-0.011217148043215275,
-0.05289683863520622,
1.001876950263977,
0.8211716413497925,
-0.24415361881256104,
0.27882298827171326,
0.23072700202465057,
0.3697532117366791,
0.6579923629760742,
0.44597989320755005,
1.0013549327850342,
-0.4805446267127991,
0.28802040219306946,
-0.6223679780960083,
-0.3321579396724701,
0.361703485250473,
-0.8481300473213196,
-0.9361429810523987,
-0.5527652502059937,
-0.45203331112861633,
-0.4403396546840668,
0.006880488712340593,
-0.10670185834169388,
0.7916432023048401,
-0.8041850328445435,
-0.2686190903186798,
-0.6917433142662048,
0.11531399935483932,
-0.03085717186331749,
-0.2544257342815399,
0.5535300970077515,
0.2862944006919861,
-0.5677595138549805,
0.32906386256217957,
-0.1040562242269516,
0.21434779465198517,
-0.7988046407699585,
0.29094135761260986,
0.3827543556690216,
-0.024641063064336777,
-0.12200483679771423,
0.09435156732797623,
-0.3747493624687195,
-0.13386066257953644,
-0.2738465964794159,
-0.11549180001020432,
0.1527123600244522,
1.111880898475647,
-0.801529586315155,
0.18296131491661072,
0.5862638354301453,
1.0794881582260132,
0.6631794571876526,
-0.07825861126184464,
0.498638778924942,
-1.3009403944015503,
0.32395559549331665,
0.519110381603241,
0.2274549901485443,
0.41904371976852417,
-0.4867178201675415,
0.24097569286823273,
0.2980809509754181,
-0.4854751229286194,
-1.343051791191101,
0.2975802421569824,
-0.6188874840736389,
-0.028546232730150223,
0.7391871809959412,
-0.5259190797805786,
-0.60847008228302,
0.02817976288497448,
-0.15417306125164032,
0.10244537144899368,
-0.06408354640007019,
0.687677264213562,
0.6324307322502136,
0.07761391997337341,
0.07871662080287933,
-0.8647091388702393,
0.6550973653793335,
0.17383593320846558,
-0.801178514957428,
0.521278977394104,
-0.08670856803655624,
0.3229878842830658,
-0.11757180839776993,
0.44087180495262146,
-0.1666169911623001,
-0.34783053398132324,
0.11521223932504654,
-0.48888179659843445,
-0.06336910277605057,
-0.4755062162876129,
-1.028402328491211,
0.24980638921260834,
-0.11854586005210876,
-0.689568817615509
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00984v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00984v1
|
Predicting Drug-Gene Relations via Analogy Tasks with Word Embeddings
| 2024-06-03T04:36:38 | 2024-06-03T04:36:38 |
Hiroaki Yamagiwa, Ryoma Hashimoto, Kiwamu Arakane, Ken Murakami, Shou Soeda, Momose Oyama, Mariko Okada, Hidetoshi Shimodaira
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Natural language processing (NLP) is utilized in a wide range of fields,
where words in text are typically transformed into feature vectors called
embeddings. BioConceptVec is a specific example of embeddings tailored for
biology, trained on approximately 30 million PubMed abstracts using models such
as skip-gram. Generally, word embeddings are known to solve analogy tasks
through simple vector arithmetic. For instance, $\mathrm{\textit{king}} -
\mathrm{\textit{man}} + \mathrm{\textit{woman}}$ predicts
$\mathrm{\textit{queen}}$. In this study, we demonstrate that BioConceptVec
embeddings, along with our own embeddings trained on PubMed abstracts, contain
information about drug-gene relations and can predict target genes from a given
drug through analogy computations. We also show that categorizing drugs and
genes using biological pathways improves performance. Furthermore, we
illustrate that vectors derived from known relations in the past can predict
unknown future relations in datasets divided by year.
|
[
-0.23430070281028748,
-0.6068660616874695,
0.915442168712616,
-0.2384720742702484,
-0.15241095423698425,
0.07987850904464722,
0.07613544166088104,
-0.5838944911956787,
0.5842577219009399,
0.2685146629810333,
-0.4797351658344269,
-0.5207051038742065,
-0.8576745986938477,
0.3198801577091217,
-0.08387547731399536,
0.7308880090713501,
0.0565316304564476,
0.6910617351531982,
-0.7599945664405823,
-0.4082939624786377,
-0.46525704860687256,
-0.4989261329174042,
-0.20200574398040771,
-0.6102150678634644,
0.7497598528862,
-0.08702704310417175,
0.6446782350540161,
0.9115142226219177,
0.5455239415168762,
0.3034278154373169,
-0.08030065149068832,
-0.12470225244760513,
-0.21040202677249908,
0.11219418048858643,
-0.489194393157959,
-0.43804875016212463,
-0.14296887814998627,
0.24815426766872406,
0.023090213537216187,
1.146410346031189,
0.07535798102617264,
0.002341213170439005,
0.24010838568210602,
0.44277480244636536,
-0.7216513156890869,
0.34204527735710144,
-0.48419126868247986,
0.3280867040157318,
0.24432271718978882,
-0.4227522909641266,
-0.04927579313516617,
-0.3803100883960724,
0.36657199263572693,
-0.6127868890762329,
0.0892222449183464,
0.12866072356700897,
0.8075347542762756,
0.08900239318609238,
-0.2084416151046753,
-0.5332950949668884,
-0.6261568665504456,
0.5675047636032104,
-0.425468385219574,
0.4586796462535858,
0.37032678723335266,
0.2418776899576187,
-0.659773051738739,
-0.681428849697113,
-0.49000486731529236,
-0.2920079529285431,
-0.25274696946144104,
0.017710937187075615,
0.003261376405134797,
0.40341243147850037,
0.30905550718307495,
0.21265418827533722,
-0.27647656202316284,
-0.18736480176448822,
-0.7749348878860474,
-0.3340000510215759,
-0.019115308299660683,
0.19202308356761932,
0.3730963468551636,
-0.2125050574541092,
-0.5945664048194885,
-0.11053314059972763,
-0.7112997770309448,
0.14254318177700043,
-0.1411348283290863,
0.05461643636226654,
0.16822713613510132,
0.7643578052520752,
0.3371734321117401,
0.6981003880500793,
-0.1376636028289795,
0.1523752063512802,
0.3373776078224182,
-0.22563160955905914,
-0.2907576560974121,
0.318452924489975,
0.6445462107658386,
0.3954613208770752,
0.1649058759212494,
-0.3442172110080719,
0.17462007701396942,
0.49587562680244446,
0.3705228865146637,
-0.853809654712677,
-0.4129767119884491,
0.47007906436920166,
-0.678471565246582,
-0.34620803594589233,
-0.10195926576852798,
-0.8605655431747437,
-0.4037477374076843,
-0.3367556631565094,
0.910635769367218,
-0.7342185378074646,
0.39447274804115295,
0.1815910041332245,
-0.735956072807312,
0.4531186521053314,
-0.159434974193573,
-0.749563992023468,
0.49657049775123596,
0.7907375693321228,
1.0477789640426636,
-0.23119458556175232,
-0.2156318575143814,
-0.8201005458831787,
0.28101640939712524,
-0.23684629797935486,
0.9829424023628235,
-0.8136292695999146,
-0.524510383605957,
-0.01848561316728592,
0.12308640778064728,
0.02617068588733673,
-0.717099130153656,
0.3829646706581116,
0.009890393353998661,
-0.08724379539489746,
-0.4226164221763611,
-1.019823431968689,
-0.09498096257448196,
0.04420510306954384,
-0.6571352481842041,
0.1559898853302002,
-0.029398147016763687,
-1.0483757257461548,
0.28551891446113586,
-0.4045245051383972,
-0.29343998432159424,
-0.07742074877023697,
-0.5635170936584473,
-0.31969302892684937,
-0.024203160777688026,
0.05707953870296478,
0.593320906162262,
-0.0025379250291734934,
-0.024485021829605103,
-0.6645761132240295,
-0.4068198502063751,
0.4455168843269348,
0.3338467478752136,
0.6152489185333252,
0.18068000674247742,
-0.01735597848892212,
-0.019279303029179573,
-0.5824353098869324,
-0.3511468172073364,
-0.27312299609184265,
-0.1246558427810669,
-0.7797423601150513,
-0.0692456066608429,
-0.38543689250946045,
0.3404006063938141,
-0.02923230268061161,
-1.0542882680892944,
0.1368204653263092,
-0.5940198302268982,
0.4655454456806183,
0.6978898048400879,
0.3959951400756836,
0.4840623438358307,
-0.3339861333370209,
0.5556743144989014,
0.07674533128738403,
-0.15354500710964203,
-0.008127312175929546,
-0.7841669321060181,
-0.19028340280056,
-0.16884690523147583,
0.6026504635810852,
0.5902882218360901,
-0.7172583341598511,
0.3828541040420532,
-0.4932549297809601,
-0.24139584600925446,
-0.3910600543022156,
-0.02938830293715,
0.4110861122608185,
0.567004919052124,
0.7631738781929016,
-0.3782746195793152,
-0.5361019372940063,
-1.0504792928695679,
-0.6164977550506592,
0.08811888843774796,
-0.37339523434638977,
0.3186352252960205,
0.598221480846405,
-0.23630975186824799,
0.7819591164588928,
-0.9233317971229553,
-0.473743200302124,
0.01721937581896782,
0.22214604914188385,
0.17994524538516998,
0.40688446164131165,
0.3790261447429657,
-0.49922341108322144,
0.08362474292516708,
-0.35128337144851685,
-0.5019684433937073,
0.2195405662059784,
0.020083045586943626,
-0.4586203396320343,
-0.5314551591873169,
0.7491360306739807,
-0.303102970123291,
0.531539797782898,
0.6504250764846802,
-0.5246224403381348,
0.10414306074380875,
-0.49011844396591187,
0.16349615156650543,
-1.1910984516143799,
-0.08579075336456299,
0.30022144317626953,
-0.16845999658107758,
-0.6413010358810425,
-0.262427419424057,
-0.001907171099446714,
-0.08813808858394623,
-0.5065078139305115,
0.27209576964378357,
-0.3524962365627289,
-0.13482965528964996,
0.018923984840512276,
-0.10919711738824844,
0.07163158804178238,
0.43175792694091797,
0.26703956723213196,
0.38513410091400146,
0.32547372579574585,
-0.6773821115493774,
0.3478795289993286,
0.5070230960845947,
-0.355090469121933,
0.2777808606624603,
-0.7137961387634277,
-0.18409417569637299,
-0.02640286460518837,
0.2625519931316376,
-0.7614052295684814,
0.05319282039999962,
0.3098713159561157,
-0.6594091653823853,
0.28961479663848877,
-0.03955397382378578,
-0.09313096851110458,
-0.21464745700359344,
-0.6137702465057373,
0.18494334816932678,
0.6813960075378418,
-0.4624756872653961,
0.737628698348999,
0.49546170234680176,
0.007178146857768297,
-0.4721909761428833,
-1.0495054721832275,
-0.1417127400636673,
0.13973651826381683,
-0.018620125949382782,
0.6468421816825867,
0.19900834560394287,
0.0010496218455955386,
0.3805220127105713,
0.0715593546628952,
-0.0619463287293911,
-0.3457001745700836,
0.5424609780311584,
0.5014812350273132,
0.2180308848619461,
0.3835740089416504,
0.24139820039272308,
-0.038670677691698074,
0.4471313953399658,
-0.198896586894989,
0.21842551231384277,
0.4796680808067322,
-0.09777336567640305,
0.29308032989501953,
0.47388437390327454,
0.5086719393730164,
-0.16989140212535858,
1.0615429878234863,
0.34585070610046387,
-0.6805833578109741,
0.09195594489574432,
0.04161327704787254,
-0.40331047773361206,
-0.3925141990184784,
0.2837069630622864,
-0.20646779239177704,
-0.6299871206283569,
0.40938225388526917,
-0.4013214111328125,
-0.1943376511335373,
0.3720046579837799,
0.5413750410079956,
-0.15985354781150818,
0.748927116394043,
0.5476436018943787,
0.18061578273773193,
0.003010083455592394,
-0.2635563910007477,
0.2732155919075012,
-1.0622868537902832,
-0.5683367848396301,
-0.4792710244655609,
-0.4560060203075409,
-0.8695885539054871,
-0.8446277976036072,
0.5475230813026428,
-0.18562382459640503,
-0.18914687633514404,
0.6862926483154297,
-0.4193545877933502,
0.19292593002319336,
0.4115849733352661,
0.4409068524837494,
-0.04573231190443039,
0.10327652096748352,
-0.7818726897239685,
0.05268069729208946,
-0.753189206123352,
-0.15403977036476135,
1.3187931776046753,
0.361640989780426,
0.5465217232704163,
-0.27436530590057373,
0.8129012584686279,
0.05235988646745682,
0.3275317847728729,
-0.8840109705924988,
0.383791446685791,
-0.486633837223053,
-0.43093782663345337,
0.09871076047420502,
-0.267937034368515,
-1.093449354171753,
-0.0770164281129837,
-0.9698700904846191,
-0.6349512934684753,
0.9255581498146057,
0.12825055420398712,
-0.5855265259742737,
0.4826611280441284,
-0.5623149275779724,
0.8041223287582397,
0.11970142275094986,
-0.2601695656776428,
-0.3534645140171051,
-0.6233023405075073,
0.10937561839818954,
0.1011258140206337,
0.32594773173332214,
-0.11827143281698227,
-0.2188185453414917,
0.8374164700508118,
-0.5850318074226379,
0.44698044657707214,
0.008064118213951588,
0.37894245982170105,
-0.07767662405967712,
0.1143343597650528,
0.15737178921699524,
-0.26561468839645386,
0.07640675455331802,
0.2526564598083496,
0.35887816548347473,
-0.38810816407203674,
-0.5951684713363647,
1.070106863975525,
-0.47605907917022705,
-0.233171746134758,
-0.6355038285255432,
-0.1508510559797287,
-0.3371945321559906,
-0.3232700824737549,
0.4037000834941864,
0.576592206954956,
-0.22957701981067657,
0.17050543427467346,
0.7437848448753357,
-0.7912408709526062,
0.0912969559431076,
0.09618082642555237,
-0.15803714096546173,
-0.45649659633636475,
0.7201173901557922,
0.1344500333070755,
0.20560544729232788,
0.787914514541626,
0.4075268805027008,
-0.34326618909835815,
-0.2880323529243469,
-0.08997495472431183,
0.08057735115289688,
-0.5940426588058472,
-0.43281254172325134,
-1.0547579526901245,
-0.02732163667678833,
-0.48271065950393677,
-0.20233584940433502,
-0.06362050771713257,
-0.3428008556365967,
-0.06371735781431198,
-0.2331046164035797,
0.6490275859832764,
0.6450281143188477,
-0.19531026482582092,
-0.4341857135295868,
-0.9579556584358215,
0.8863159418106079,
0.4591207802295685,
0.5770049691200256,
-0.2653994858264923,
-0.24229566752910614,
-0.21117368340492249,
-0.0036805286072194576,
-0.1499043107032776,
-1.3531463146209717,
0.43601223826408386,
0.369880735874176,
0.6158597469329834,
0.12574639916419983,
-0.18508511781692505,
0.3608187735080719,
-0.8002892136573792,
0.6723832488059998,
0.18640348315238953,
-0.6982359290122986,
0.5463433265686035,
-0.1091993972659111,
0.15460774302482605,
0.4354347884654999,
0.7769176959991455,
-0.4324858784675598,
-0.2614571452140808,
-0.4754646420478821,
-0.7968657612800598,
0.05885198712348938,
0.36324912309646606,
-0.11024662107229233,
-0.2786017060279846,
0.4451783001422882,
0.10121852904558182,
0.13560350239276886,
-0.2384510487318039,
-0.590994656085968,
-0.21285970509052277,
-0.2924114763736725,
-0.050319042056798935,
-0.2423880696296692,
0.08843166381120682,
-0.6393905282020569,
0.3065386116504669,
0.19492922723293304,
0.7079234719276428,
0.39399483799934387,
0.14862996339797974,
0.11090416461229324,
0.3232063353061676,
0.17465879023075104,
0.501450777053833,
-0.5768093466758728,
0.18736803531646729,
0.10979462414979935,
-0.7928651571273804,
0.11894703656435013,
0.36654824018478394,
0.16905054450035095,
0.06614270061254501,
0.5544792413711548,
0.3034021258354187,
0.31919705867767334,
-0.7204951047897339,
0.5819666385650635,
0.0014356309548020363,
-0.1780613362789154,
-0.16662169992923737,
-0.03116656467318535,
0.32066115736961365,
0.2232104390859604,
0.10404040664434433,
0.3354235589504242,
0.6702277064323425,
-0.886672854423523,
0.3660336136817932,
0.41422343254089355,
-0.630537748336792,
0.1309402883052826,
0.8284266591072083,
0.13227888941764832,
-0.05279809236526489,
0.31091609597206116,
0.10573405027389526,
-0.5711002349853516,
0.6196432709693909,
0.21538642048835754,
0.9656530618667603,
-0.1928974688053131,
0.018322253599762917,
0.7396848201751709,
-0.12775932252407074,
0.08202476054430008,
0.03340298309922218,
0.08024139702320099,
-0.7182828187942505,
-0.41703060269355774,
-0.9877849817276001,
-0.3500136733055115,
-0.02663497067987919,
-0.5703538656234741,
0.2878214418888092,
-0.5112686157226562,
-0.14154835045337677,
0.4712018072605133,
-0.16989022493362427,
-0.8179283738136292,
0.001145603135228157,
0.06019778549671173,
0.820940375328064,
-1.241775631904602,
1.0307143926620483,
0.8970019817352295,
-0.41921836137771606,
-0.7994446158409119,
-0.023742694407701492,
-0.2158879190683365,
-0.3482406735420227,
0.5656576156616211,
0.10238207131624222,
-0.23792923986911774,
-0.4701111316680908,
-0.36892977356910706,
-0.6019624471664429,
1.199735403060913,
-0.0034099696204066277,
-0.6086127758026123,
0.05818723514676094,
0.04703160375356674,
0.6662890911102295,
-0.5603207945823669,
-0.12102802097797394,
0.7500563859939575,
0.1261581927537918,
0.08637195825576782,
-0.4768293797969818,
0.2401948869228363,
-0.24909986555576324,
0.1822633594274521,
0.17297479510307312,
0.3626236319541931,
0.7800702452659607,
-0.3378507196903229,
-0.022321239113807678,
0.05530717596411705,
0.5258022546768188,
0.24226702749729156,
0.17883016169071198,
0.6014606356620789,
0.30595237016677856,
0.24800020456314087,
-0.046189796179533005,
1.235512137413025,
-0.2969101369380951,
0.037869419902563095,
1.0192128419876099,
0.0923139750957489,
1.0160810947418213,
0.8064655065536499,
-0.4302014410495758,
0.9533812403678894,
0.5956830382347107,
-0.1896965205669403,
0.7708060145378113,
0.4485905170440674,
-0.11178360134363174,
-0.1829497367143631,
-0.10907262563705444,
-0.17386819422245026,
0.262343168258667,
0.7662345767021179,
-0.8625887632369995,
0.013437849469482899,
0.23354937136173248,
-0.18218429386615753,
0.3912595808506012,
-0.41088399291038513,
0.7554351091384888,
0.30655038356781006,
-0.4769710898399353,
0.2252182811498642,
-0.04194619879126549,
0.7662355899810791,
-0.6569092273712158,
-0.6727018356323242,
0.11212063580751419,
0.22979025542736053,
-0.13675247132778168,
-0.889491617679596,
0.19363732635974884,
-0.44204849004745483,
-0.005209648050367832,
0.28301751613616943,
0.797726035118103,
-0.7088777422904968,
-0.5919368267059326,
0.5231490135192871,
0.21598324179649353,
0.031972408294677734,
0.2083735466003418,
-0.5644978880882263,
-0.2533169686794281,
-0.05763823911547661,
0.16053077578544617,
0.37836018204689026,
0.15439672768115997,
0.328132688999176,
0.7183186411857605,
0.6256223917007446,
0.6376664638519287,
-0.20272958278656006,
-0.4993053078651428,
0.8684786558151245,
-0.631625771522522,
-0.4300960302352905,
-0.7344940304756165,
-0.11968681216239929,
0.043032459914684296,
0.11977843940258026,
0.4290575683116913,
0.559965968132019,
0.43662717938423157,
-0.42763638496398926,
0.5616955757141113,
0.2744399905204773,
0.7826086282730103,
-0.579378604888916,
0.5379006266593933,
-0.3079252541065216,
0.19228485226631165,
-0.4122035801410675,
-0.8873351216316223,
-0.23731471598148346,
0.5321170687675476,
-0.26191994547843933,
-0.038285091519355774,
1.0406525135040283,
0.6443058848381042,
0.009957990609109402,
-0.1893341988325119,
0.08166099339723587,
0.2711680233478546,
0.10086514800786972,
0.8192120790481567,
0.22115786373615265,
-0.29932522773742676,
0.3443796932697296,
-0.48949700593948364,
-0.149888813495636,
0.13346196711063385,
-0.9176989793777466,
-0.9682461023330688,
-0.6563905477523804,
-0.20112694799900055,
-0.7557544708251953,
0.2830283045768738,
1.4178096055984497,
0.24137485027313232,
-0.8942079544067383,
0.1045803353190422,
-0.09106346219778061,
0.0025986714754253626,
-0.32277166843414307,
-0.11660832911729813,
0.5958306193351746,
0.15967926383018494,
-0.5059642195701599,
0.06706030666828156,
0.36819911003112793,
0.1760602444410324,
-0.48777860403060913,
0.023882536217570305,
-0.566820502281189,
0.29137298464775085,
0.4515986144542694,
0.23926062881946564,
-0.460246741771698,
-0.35035958886146545,
-0.04059191793203354,
-0.19146758317947388,
0.00029350523254834116,
1.100964903831482,
-1.3964580297470093,
0.6754884123802185,
0.8074014782905579,
0.45135536789894104,
0.23279798030853271,
-0.07095237821340561,
1.1772868633270264,
-0.41458678245544434,
0.13601066172122955,
0.25451257824897766,
0.5571814775466919,
0.3106125593185425,
-0.5121172070503235,
0.2863115966320038,
0.08861924707889557,
-0.34280940890312195,
-0.19383402168750763,
0.006077266298234463,
-0.7750495076179504,
-0.8305534720420837,
1.076250433921814,
-0.1671467274427414,
-0.5955787897109985,
-0.35475990176200867,
0.001749761519022286,
0.43991583585739136,
-0.2136225551366806,
0.551852822303772,
0.3678436577320099,
-0.20458343625068665,
0.20771153271198273,
-0.691332221031189,
0.8925626873970032,
0.16375136375427246,
-0.5547322630882263,
-0.17641374468803406,
0.3212832510471344,
0.3213796317577362,
0.19844546914100647,
0.2844659388065338,
-0.29678329825401306,
0.09644974023103714,
0.026656612753868103,
0.018843062222003937,
0.04951098933815956,
0.13317914307117462,
-0.26950499415397644,
-0.0618300698697567,
-0.11843056976795197,
-0.6673648953437805
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00983v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00983v1
|
Take its Essence, Discard its Dross! Debiasing for Toxic Language Detection via Counterfactual Causal Effect
| 2024-06-03T04:34:30 | 2024-06-03T04:34:30 |
Junyu Lu, Bo Xu, Xiaokun Zhang, Kaiyuan Liu, Dongyu Zhang, Liang Yang, Hongfei Lin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Current methods of toxic language detection (TLD) typically rely on specific
tokens to conduct decisions, which makes them suffer from lexical bias, leading
to inferior performance and generalization. Lexical bias has both "useful" and
"misleading" impacts on understanding toxicity. Unfortunately, instead of
distinguishing between these impacts, current debiasing methods typically
eliminate them indiscriminately, resulting in a degradation in the detection
accuracy of the model. To this end, we propose a Counterfactual Causal
Debiasing Framework (CCDF) to mitigate lexical bias in TLD. It preserves the
"useful impact" of lexical bias and eliminates the "misleading impact".
Specifically, we first represent the total effect of the original sentence and
biased tokens on decisions from a causal view. We then conduct counterfactual
inference to exclude the direct causal effect of lexical bias from the total
effect. Empirical evaluations demonstrate that the debiased TLD model
incorporating CCDF achieves state-of-the-art performance in both accuracy and
fairness compared to competitive baselines applied on several vanilla models.
The generalization capability of our model outperforms current debiased models
for out-of-distribution data.
|
[
-0.028647873550653458,
-1.1030397415161133,
0.6178379058837891,
0.1580362766981125,
-0.4495261013507843,
-0.19789832830429077,
0.10608837008476257,
-0.2716951370239258,
0.0022880902979522943,
0.6146926283836365,
-0.30965039134025574,
-0.6551418304443359,
-0.7289448976516724,
-0.02197173982858658,
-0.4898758828639984,
0.7558775544166565,
0.4032025635242462,
-0.010925215668976307,
0.13015124201774597,
-0.28380170464515686,
-0.4835771322250366,
-0.42135730385780334,
-0.800098180770874,
-0.5952035784721375,
0.6978418827056885,
0.5626274943351746,
1.0821106433868408,
0.38402941823005676,
0.16659429669380188,
0.23100487887859344,
-0.14113375544548035,
-0.1317247599363327,
-0.683800458908081,
-0.012661081738770008,
-0.6832979917526245,
-0.22567327320575714,
-0.2085825502872467,
0.21383769810199738,
0.2361636459827423,
0.45676249265670776,
-0.24531541764736176,
-0.09336678683757782,
-0.1866224706172943,
0.5037090182304382,
-0.7848173379898071,
0.07511429488658905,
-0.5658483505249023,
0.09591595083475113,
-0.20788347721099854,
-0.18036815524101257,
-0.664418637752533,
-0.17305009067058563,
0.11274990439414978,
-0.531349778175354,
-0.041332609951496124,
-0.08116136491298676,
0.6068349480628967,
0.5326143503189087,
-0.6637090444564819,
-0.016843603923916817,
-0.6771653890609741,
0.8879086375236511,
-0.9250567555427551,
0.40580928325653076,
0.37825652956962585,
0.0009561841725371778,
-0.14525175094604492,
-0.5270429849624634,
-0.7077617645263672,
-0.23844721913337708,
-0.157221719622612,
0.11917083710432053,
-0.4288463890552521,
0.3168908953666687,
0.06772340089082718,
0.025332098826766014,
-0.6981198787689209,
0.2591467797756195,
-0.10753915458917618,
-0.4063105583190918,
0.3616730570793152,
0.0706414207816124,
0.7131699323654175,
-0.05416256561875343,
-0.4496949315071106,
-0.025872373953461647,
-0.9020887613296509,
-0.5424605011940002,
0.09114856272935867,
0.3132918179035187,
-0.013406004756689072,
0.19702084362506866,
-0.09886136651039124,
0.3487728238105774,
0.08114375919103622,
0.03849382326006889,
0.25254422426223755,
-0.2477569580078125,
-0.5314916968345642,
0.2517821192741394,
0.8321933150291443,
0.4100905954837799,
0.3049255907535553,
-0.30339255928993225,
0.06686533987522125,
0.4436241686344147,
0.06038421392440796,
-0.8528679013252258,
-0.2937956154346466,
0.32910850644111633,
-0.2964489758014679,
-0.8007982969284058,
-0.5078471899032593,
-0.9723154902458191,
-0.7002741694450378,
-0.12636317312717438,
0.34335023164749146,
-0.10604837536811829,
-0.8136441707611084,
0.04174579679965973,
-0.4123506546020508,
-0.34139737486839294,
-0.13281212747097015,
-0.6001949906349182,
0.3242494761943817,
0.2948276698589325,
0.6002814769744873,
-0.082124724984169,
-0.06280043721199036,
-0.7138288617134094,
0.24972261488437653,
-0.4562505781650543,
0.7603241205215454,
-0.916796088218689,
-0.5369100570678711,
-0.06672058254480362,
-0.32403725385665894,
0.0060951015911996365,
-0.6485280990600586,
0.6579465270042419,
-0.6077884435653687,
0.11271831393241882,
-0.5086255669593811,
-0.09690673649311066,
-0.2459467202425003,
-0.0016119664069265127,
-0.6492117643356323,
0.922160804271698,
0.2868482768535614,
-1.1241536140441895,
0.6868897676467896,
-0.23198063671588898,
-0.3068042993545532,
-0.14549395442008972,
0.07114122807979584,
-0.41933587193489075,
-0.07307587563991547,
0.022466439753770828,
-0.19130800664424896,
-0.3039822280406952,
0.776300311088562,
-0.7239155173301697,
-0.5215417146682739,
-0.1398247480392456,
-0.763126015663147,
1.1645300388336182,
0.5439213514328003,
-0.7795194387435913,
0.10540659725666046,
-0.5042917728424072,
-0.2668026387691498,
-0.10140661150217056,
-0.12084276229143143,
-0.7533804178237915,
0.08082273602485657,
0.20582346618175507,
0.6294312477111816,
-0.3671106994152069,
-0.7195590734481812,
-0.5038764476776123,
-0.5810593366622925,
0.20160815119743347,
0.6913607120513916,
0.1285000443458557,
0.4323999285697937,
-0.2953321635723114,
0.35444068908691406,
0.529236376285553,
0.28008514642715454,
0.4467810392379761,
-0.14784885942935944,
-0.5577738285064697,
-0.335997998714447,
-0.05529436096549034,
0.44839563965797424,
-0.8794900178909302,
0.28810808062553406,
-0.07644023001194,
-0.5427758097648621,
-0.012097703292965889,
-0.06972044706344604,
0.5390673875808716,
0.8487452268600464,
0.527195155620575,
-0.1539115160703659,
-0.41387829184532166,
-0.7503994703292847,
-0.2943260669708252,
-0.5597529411315918,
0.35836198925971985,
0.06488684564828873,
0.305838018655777,
-0.381274551153183,
1.1050161123275757,
-0.5192094445228577,
-0.45748278498649597,
-0.15583112835884094,
0.25177720189094543,
-0.02661849558353424,
0.27903807163238525,
0.9921957850456238,
-0.7400027513504028,
-0.332050621509552,
-0.38819602131843567,
-0.6676703095436096,
-0.8808318376541138,
-0.016568126156926155,
-0.0781102254986763,
0.2654659152030945,
0.6136632561683655,
-0.34521785378456116,
0.46896737813949585,
0.41533389687538147,
-0.6982707977294922,
0.5245581269264221,
-0.09867817908525467,
0.2221352458000183,
-0.4527352452278137,
0.23296155035495758,
-0.058635201305150986,
-0.0480419397354126,
-0.7670081853866577,
0.0640789270401001,
-0.00373285636305809,
0.0693284198641777,
-0.6309568881988525,
0.8709599375724792,
0.06628990918397903,
0.48544442653656006,
-0.2639908790588379,
0.4405338168144226,
0.18745703995227814,
0.33591529726982117,
0.13602767884731293,
0.6220196485519409,
0.3006366491317749,
-0.5733756422996521,
0.1797831952571869,
0.049206268042325974,
0.12098623812198639,
0.7006657719612122,
-0.6124835014343262,
-0.29120004177093506,
-0.35178399085998535,
0.23809652030467987,
-1.1591590642929077,
0.4206748902797699,
0.5717508792877197,
-0.16318102180957794,
0.2100423127412796,
0.07409683614969254,
-0.5996611714363098,
-0.34720078110694885,
-0.24928614497184753,
0.4856053292751312,
0.2584919333457947,
-0.5383843183517456,
0.3204897344112396,
0.5084520578384399,
0.13437174260616302,
-0.8554627895355225,
-1.0240181684494019,
0.18792998790740967,
-0.5014544129371643,
-0.2143666297197342,
0.12958942353725433,
-0.1149529442191124,
-0.5921546816825867,
0.026831205934286118,
-0.2971743643283844,
-0.3198389410972595,
0.14619235694408417,
-0.043343205004930496,
0.15581034123897552,
0.14000099897384644,
0.4866197407245636,
0.22003260254859924,
-0.2638469636440277,
0.3225463926792145,
-0.10744180530309677,
0.3963638246059418,
0.3613799512386322,
-0.0623641312122345,
-0.17522424459457397,
0.3190184533596039,
0.9006372094154358,
-0.15703818202018738,
0.6623537540435791,
0.4369772970676422,
-0.17813226580619812,
-0.2970026135444641,
-0.4529205858707428,
-0.14767976105213165,
-0.48696497082710266,
0.4628778398036957,
0.01936815306544304,
-0.36051300168037415,
0.3940373659133911,
0.1428947001695633,
-0.17280836403369904,
0.4959368109703064,
0.3346948027610779,
0.4386467933654785,
0.8621411919593811,
0.4213844835758209,
-0.5195412635803223,
0.4700051248073578,
0.0006521617178805172,
0.3860194683074951,
-0.30728840827941895,
0.10936608165502548,
-0.45967358350753784,
0.15767253935337067,
-0.4662736654281616,
-0.29332131147384644,
0.21639111638069153,
-0.12059053033590317,
-0.765863299369812,
0.22540739178657532,
-0.352926105260849,
0.4139878451824188,
0.16466699540615082,
0.431613951921463,
0.5396583676338196,
-0.2395256608724594,
-0.5202622413635254,
-0.08776027709245682,
-0.5328068733215332,
-0.4055841863155365,
0.8030188083648682,
0.2834676504135132,
0.5972208380699158,
0.3244973421096802,
0.5211218595504761,
0.5336970686912537,
0.533113956451416,
-0.393778532743454,
0.4535669684410095,
-0.340750515460968,
-0.995775043964386,
-0.30855831503868103,
-0.4987372159957886,
-0.40856653451919556,
0.5724971294403076,
0.01705116592347622,
-0.4535985589027405,
0.40511131286621094,
0.14538194239139557,
-0.046608492732048035,
0.4471791386604309,
-0.7334501147270203,
0.9875543117523193,
0.01699366420507431,
-0.5930138230323792,
-0.7202093005180359,
-0.2878526747226715,
0.5634890794754028,
-0.34660178422927856,
0.7021566033363342,
-0.18569888174533844,
0.10574372857809067,
0.5946981310844421,
-0.577312707901001,
1.229467511177063,
-0.5858297944068909,
-0.3077828884124756,
0.37060171365737915,
0.3195880949497223,
0.34946364164352417,
0.035033851861953735,
-0.4878302216529846,
0.2607180178165436,
0.053755633533000946,
-0.27929338812828064,
-0.1350584477186203,
0.796002209186554,
-0.5375931859016418,
-0.638181746006012,
-0.5565956234931946,
-0.5176184177398682,
-0.09970006346702576,
0.5666077733039856,
0.04463266581296921,
0.5244386792182922,
-0.5952996015548706,
-0.4391055405139923,
0.5779862999916077,
-0.7183753252029419,
0.43645718693733215,
0.8131001591682434,
-0.14504532516002655,
-0.13462717831134796,
0.6786205768585205,
-0.03989192843437195,
0.5007263422012329,
0.29839760065078735,
0.5827676057815552,
-0.4635173976421356,
-0.4490449130535126,
-0.3324672281742096,
0.3210655748844147,
-0.8822411298751831,
-0.19046929478645325,
-0.7332004904747009,
0.19964811205863953,
-0.47882288694381714,
0.1917749047279358,
-0.21324874460697174,
-0.02503664791584015,
-0.37521421909332275,
-0.23453488945960999,
0.10565649718046188,
0.7137308120727539,
-0.4387441873550415,
0.33537009358406067,
-0.6343299746513367,
0.2807084619998932,
0.2988019287586212,
0.3332069516181946,
0.1864539533853531,
-0.603033721446991,
0.20154345035552979,
0.4541659355163574,
-0.35964083671569824,
-0.8270474672317505,
0.5486306548118591,
0.11877328157424927,
0.6315683126449585,
0.6919196844100952,
0.6307510137557983,
0.6829819679260254,
-0.3434946537017822,
0.5755374431610107,
0.213799849152565,
-1.051082730293274,
0.2989914119243622,
-0.455172061920166,
0.1483069509267807,
0.5675376653671265,
0.248654305934906,
-0.7982496023178101,
-0.9974149465560913,
-0.4462025761604309,
-0.681456983089447,
0.6818422675132751,
0.007342309225350618,
0.13644908368587494,
-0.6299760341644287,
-0.07623974978923798,
-0.10679414123296738,
0.016163723543286324,
-0.6677117347717285,
-0.31123870611190796,
-0.3324244022369385,
-0.13664333522319794,
-0.1122967004776001,
-0.6526187658309937,
0.06726383417844772,
-0.1273629069328308,
0.6420256495475769,
0.2608020007610321,
-0.24794931709766388,
0.34675922989845276,
-0.519860029220581,
-0.4894339144229889,
0.36368003487586975,
0.5609453916549683,
0.6076605916023254,
-0.2534063756465912,
0.4186541438102722,
0.17677462100982666,
-0.5628964304924011,
0.13926148414611816,
-0.20777073502540588,
-0.2689022123813629,
0.10160009562969208,
0.36003419756889343,
0.19833634793758392,
0.48381277918815613,
-0.721748411655426,
0.7401054501533508,
0.15131829679012299,
0.06976763904094696,
-0.11404028534889221,
-0.07660486549139023,
0.027672823518514633,
0.06371438503265381,
0.11328567564487457,
0.028551457449793816,
0.3882375657558441,
-0.5374817252159119,
0.5777148008346558,
0.36042118072509766,
-0.6793590784072876,
-0.21007339656352997,
0.9506005048751831,
0.358346551656723,
0.4262392818927765,
0.5316056609153748,
-0.08532894402742386,
-0.7426270246505737,
0.6697972416877747,
0.6776198744773865,
0.8597381711006165,
-0.37157532572746277,
0.5855494737625122,
0.5750765204429626,
0.19207286834716797,
0.12718604505062103,
-0.004074639640748501,
0.20274288952350616,
-0.7850309610366821,
-0.20424598455429077,
-0.5611721277236938,
-0.03784075006842613,
-0.02492435835301876,
-0.2854955196380615,
0.21632376313209534,
-0.3405282199382782,
0.07487177848815918,
0.06338527053594589,
-0.17717625200748444,
-0.24403414130210876,
0.34836530685424805,
0.1323949098587036,
0.8672468662261963,
-1.360500454902649,
0.8471894860267639,
0.035302091389894485,
-0.638190746307373,
-0.4493986666202545,
0.030308369547128677,
0.5315556526184082,
-0.7904295921325684,
1.1467317342758179,
-0.04589323699474335,
-0.445230096578598,
-0.040245216339826584,
-0.24085712432861328,
-0.6525138020515442,
0.6969090700149536,
0.30584222078323364,
-0.44273141026496887,
0.13721947371959686,
0.29458966851234436,
0.5760552287101746,
0.0026651376392692327,
0.6765327453613281,
0.7185059785842896,
0.6518025398254395,
0.29335424304008484,
-0.9796132445335388,
0.3844562768936157,
0.01972370408475399,
-0.12327323853969574,
0.09186267107725143,
-0.4773252606391907,
0.541724681854248,
-0.22257116436958313,
-0.5653522610664368,
-0.28439342975616455,
0.0611734502017498,
-0.03894926235079765,
0.293082594871521,
0.7356100082397461,
0.6612743139266968,
0.4991580545902252,
0.10566604882478714,
0.7131774425506592,
0.07020345330238342,
0.3818776309490204,
1.0439735651016235,
-0.4375096261501312,
0.47010692954063416,
0.48704996705055237,
0.04223117232322693,
0.575722873210907,
0.42889565229415894,
0.25950372219085693,
1.078313946723938,
0.33211076259613037,
-0.3589041531085968,
-0.263929545879364,
-0.5331980586051941,
-0.09377282112836838,
0.3852229714393616,
0.37708738446235657,
-0.2687561810016632,
-0.8954800367355347,
0.08406820893287659,
0.39118361473083496,
0.3642590343952179,
-0.2679106593132019,
0.5157236456871033,
0.16124039888381958,
-0.4760359823703766,
0.7377889156341553,
-0.2636408507823944,
0.6679698824882507,
-0.253024160861969,
-0.10066341608762741,
-0.24816109240055084,
0.44546204805374146,
-0.1954428255558014,
-0.4784994423389435,
0.7718470692634583,
-0.3031061291694641,
-0.045036088675260544,
-0.15612998604774475,
0.668910026550293,
-0.5590208172798157,
-0.10092411935329437,
0.7735716700553894,
0.333761066198349,
-0.1794501692056656,
-0.16026049852371216,
-0.6131507754325867,
-0.004036935046315193,
-0.12423503398895264,
0.040471576154232025,
0.02743760123848915,
0.3269729018211365,
-0.13174915313720703,
0.5384055972099304,
0.38177618384361267,
0.1319533735513687,
-0.4736897051334381,
0.4239727854728699,
1.0023658275604248,
-0.5928396582603455,
-0.46842068433761597,
-1.0048787593841553,
0.30603402853012085,
-0.014133719727396965,
-0.054691653698682785,
0.41192227602005005,
0.19352276623249054,
0.6953166723251343,
0.12397533655166626,
0.6688918471336365,
-0.04386875033378601,
0.4026578366756439,
-0.09696553647518158,
1.1117011308670044,
-0.4384400546550751,
0.3940499424934387,
-0.6898846626281738,
-0.47372937202453613,
-0.6569848656654358,
0.3583812713623047,
-0.51180499792099,
-0.04262687638401985,
1.0654077529907227,
1.0161486864089966,
0.12958335876464844,
-0.007618491072207689,
0.47481852769851685,
0.5491172671318054,
0.5956227779388428,
0.5406385064125061,
0.4802108407020569,
-0.3101437985897064,
0.7291504144668579,
-0.25500836968421936,
-0.43501222133636475,
-0.0609382688999176,
-0.9773398637771606,
-1.1232941150665283,
-0.2567402422428131,
-0.3779599368572235,
-0.2686491012573242,
0.23813070356845856,
0.5600407719612122,
0.2769359350204468,
-0.8985522985458374,
0.22773055732250214,
-0.2211139053106308,
0.4833419620990753,
-0.31742483377456665,
-0.2942589521408081,
0.3610191345214844,
-0.4621303379535675,
-0.5764392614364624,
0.04907515272498131,
0.20121683180332184,
-0.22370047867298126,
-0.009072789922356606,
0.005418260116130114,
-0.3627135753631592,
0.21359513700008392,
0.7139605283737183,
0.01728544943034649,
-0.643052339553833,
-0.7328454256057739,
-0.1642829328775406,
-0.444318950176239,
-0.25851568579673767,
0.4731798470020294,
-0.858832597732544,
0.5323664546012878,
0.6164879202842712,
0.09100142866373062,
0.10089951753616333,
-0.26075857877731323,
0.5703677535057068,
-0.43819522857666016,
0.3953803777694702,
0.15498751401901245,
0.12196499854326248,
0.04097096249461174,
-0.4804208278656006,
0.5406887531280518,
0.44555559754371643,
-0.29848209023475647,
-0.7627699971199036,
0.3292432427406311,
-0.720740795135498,
-0.661037027835846,
1.3258862495422363,
0.023097746074199677,
-0.04182295873761177,
-0.6566089987754822,
-0.2742669880390167,
0.5026812553405762,
-0.43601998686790466,
0.8461573719978333,
0.5123322606086731,
0.31773069500923157,
0.03187539801001549,
-0.26953911781311035,
0.5282430052757263,
0.3836021423339844,
-0.41635680198669434,
0.5086447596549988,
0.7810496687889099,
0.6317417025566101,
-0.1242137998342514,
0.8335055112838745,
-0.4429047405719757,
0.3188878893852234,
0.1840197592973709,
-0.24854324758052826,
-0.06500069051980972,
-0.05907519906759262,
-0.10454846918582916,
-0.1760813593864441,
0.0160868801176548,
-0.0003330027684569359
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00980v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00980v1
|
Selectively Answering Visual Questions
| 2024-06-03T04:28:10 | 2024-06-03T04:28:10 |
Julian Martin Eisenschlos, Hernán Maina, Guido Ivetta, Luciana Benotti
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CV
|
Recently, large multi-modal models (LMMs) have emerged with the capacity to
perform vision tasks such as captioning and visual question answering (VQA)
with unprecedented accuracy. Applications such as helping the blind or visually
impaired have a critical need for precise answers. It is specially important
for models to be well calibrated and be able to quantify their uncertainty in
order to selectively decide when to answer and when to abstain or ask for
clarifications. We perform the first in-depth analysis of calibration methods
and metrics for VQA with in-context learning LMMs. Studying VQA on two
answerability benchmarks, we show that the likelihood score of visually
grounded models is better calibrated than in their text-only counterparts for
in-context learning, where sampling based methods are generally superior, but
no clear winner arises. We propose Avg BLEU, a calibration score combining the
benefits of both sampling and likelihood methods across modalities.
|
[
-0.47948363423347473,
-0.903933048248291,
0.7023199796676636,
0.041887085884809494,
-0.24921399354934692,
-0.2366897463798523,
0.08366265147924423,
-0.587424635887146,
-0.3153506815433502,
0.35555288195610046,
-0.471130907535553,
-0.14730238914489746,
-0.4557666778564453,
-0.027752207592129707,
0.015899477526545525,
0.39167889952659607,
-0.012786298990249634,
0.4597981870174408,
-0.5728731751441956,
-0.44218847155570984,
-0.9152320623397827,
-0.3096831738948822,
-0.21798725426197052,
-0.025745036080479622,
0.6321841478347778,
0.38130292296409607,
0.6061798930168152,
0.308513343334198,
0.5180118083953857,
0.2513824701309204,
0.025545688346028328,
0.31482216715812683,
-0.45825621485710144,
-0.058606959879398346,
-0.30947768688201904,
-0.7285420298576355,
-0.07694201171398163,
0.1592850238084793,
0.5703331232070923,
0.7673696875572205,
0.14066645503044128,
0.5703044533729553,
0.03513398393988609,
0.6125510334968567,
-0.9293540716171265,
0.0974699929356575,
-0.5271717309951782,
-0.1452631950378418,
0.22145622968673706,
-0.4125972390174866,
-0.452269047498703,
-0.3687610626220703,
0.4425954222679138,
-0.8320107460021973,
0.043938081711530685,
0.0759134590625763,
0.8861101269721985,
0.6710453629493713,
-0.6689723134040833,
0.06385946273803711,
-0.49697762727737427,
0.8759299516677856,
-0.3459232449531555,
0.5658838152885437,
0.6742829084396362,
0.8355530500411987,
0.26582956314086914,
-0.521909236907959,
-0.13335543870925903,
-0.07685598731040955,
0.05405065044760704,
0.4602587819099426,
0.03724454715847969,
0.15603035688400269,
0.358203649520874,
0.34657496213912964,
-0.5981531739234924,
-0.12598218023777008,
-0.577781617641449,
-0.27039381861686707,
0.4914235472679138,
-0.026824893429875374,
-0.08176050335168839,
-0.2973976731300354,
-0.5871891975402832,
-0.2731579840183258,
-0.43999743461608887,
0.5242618322372437,
0.03986695408821106,
-0.1673051416873932,
-0.10392269492149353,
0.7518916726112366,
-0.3634186387062073,
1.1619815826416016,
-0.012154617346823215,
0.03205333650112152,
-0.08077690750360489,
-0.5567790865898132,
-0.563179612159729,
-0.4393153786659241,
0.25319337844848633,
0.7577834725379944,
0.3256227672100067,
0.14130450785160065,
-0.2266351580619812,
-0.12334620952606201,
0.23237963020801544,
-0.6955530047416687,
-0.13219188153743744,
0.2965701222419739,
-0.4059603810310364,
-0.13147969543933868,
0.09062867611646652,
-0.7298544049263,
-0.36838972568511963,
-0.5218778252601624,
0.8517861366271973,
-0.14424672722816467,
0.07584969699382782,
-0.09123394638299942,
-0.35849690437316895,
0.514252245426178,
0.9938343167304993,
-0.41003841161727905,
-0.05963539332151413,
0.11165596544742584,
0.45340314507484436,
0.22096960246562958,
0.011526648886501789,
-0.8883152604103088,
0.07134474068880081,
-0.5681095719337463,
0.44364872574806213,
-0.36314642429351807,
-0.16237561404705048,
-0.0682157352566719,
0.03158619627356529,
-0.21051250398159027,
-0.4325290024280548,
0.3669101893901825,
-0.8226690292358398,
0.1543598622083664,
-0.8601272106170654,
-0.4520891606807709,
-0.8350743651390076,
0.5182253122329712,
-0.6918301582336426,
0.7463316321372986,
0.30927032232284546,
-0.5253411531448364,
0.7555038928985596,
0.011043311096727848,
0.2188214212656021,
0.2739503085613251,
-0.30275481939315796,
0.000555319944396615,
0.4042857587337494,
0.7251814603805542,
0.4623606503009796,
-0.29425737261772156,
0.06878417730331421,
-0.31049349904060364,
-0.3608531951904297,
0.3712735176086426,
-0.7483289837837219,
0.5686630010604858,
0.12124013900756836,
-0.009277699515223503,
0.36865854263305664,
-0.6688934564590454,
0.389019638299942,
-0.227442666888237,
-0.23087215423583984,
-0.3475281298160553,
0.00832982175052166,
0.17418618500232697,
0.1968362182378769,
0.13307234644889832,
-0.48211902379989624,
-0.3336889445781708,
-0.13725395500659943,
0.3855610191822052,
0.7485575675964355,
0.07673874497413635,
0.29249507188796997,
-0.6209706664085388,
0.46237412095069885,
-0.03402039781212807,
0.2082090824842453,
-0.4293534457683563,
-0.5117383599281311,
-0.6023523807525635,
-0.5632241368293762,
0.2278299629688263,
0.8024864196777344,
-0.8659080266952515,
0.07781225442886353,
-0.08072715997695923,
-0.5142525434494019,
-0.3692273199558258,
0.11202995479106903,
0.4708288908004761,
0.7135063409805298,
0.31490185856819153,
-0.34353482723236084,
-0.014837502501904964,
-0.8714199662208557,
-0.09254792332649231,
-0.279105544090271,
-0.013574007898569107,
0.7310389280319214,
0.4665004014968872,
0.2824253439903259,
0.7389857769012451,
-0.31958919763565063,
-0.11093531548976898,
0.06496734172105789,
-0.22943076491355896,
-0.01214038860052824,
0.11557479947805405,
0.6311772465705872,
-1.2079415321350098,
-0.31907495856285095,
0.13116362690925598,
-1.0056629180908203,
0.06404998153448105,
-0.05373377352952957,
-0.07516802847385406,
-0.00440192548558116,
0.4978054165840149,
-0.31994518637657166,
0.7322040796279907,
0.3681134581565857,
-0.0869344174861908,
0.4540883004665375,
-0.10878697037696838,
0.44030341506004333,
-0.6515018939971924,
0.16902121901512146,
0.370332270860672,
-0.6976108551025391,
-0.3559470772743225,
0.5581897497177124,
0.4251590371131897,
0.06106536090373993,
-0.6485416889190674,
0.8008140325546265,
-0.40456271171569824,
0.05733469873666763,
0.10213957726955414,
0.0464937686920166,
0.1535608470439911,
0.40804144740104675,
0.0853179544210434,
0.7532280087471008,
0.6218330264091492,
-0.6480449438095093,
0.3934924006462097,
0.2340102642774582,
-0.5075539350509644,
0.8829703330993652,
-0.8934910297393799,
-0.2556319832801819,
-0.39428389072418213,
-0.07686635851860046,
-1.4017410278320312,
-0.537519097328186,
0.09953850507736206,
-0.4566555917263031,
0.09712868183851242,
-0.3586813807487488,
-0.12010076642036438,
-0.29867395758628845,
-0.041483908891677856,
0.8117913007736206,
0.164397194981575,
-0.5799059271812439,
0.5783311128616333,
0.08086305856704712,
0.051375724375247955,
-0.6374921202659607,
-0.5972815752029419,
-0.29097646474838257,
-0.24783366918563843,
-0.5623024106025696,
-0.1287263184785843,
-0.40943312644958496,
-0.3346664011478424,
-0.38247165083885193,
-0.28670534491539,
-0.12942564487457275,
-0.16605351865291595,
0.30749988555908203,
0.33995959162712097,
-0.1880912184715271,
0.1312006264925003,
-0.16300387680530548,
0.025812402367591858,
-0.06375456601381302,
0.07323237508535385,
0.16332653164863586,
-0.168655663728714,
-0.6596555113792419,
-0.35979989171028137,
0.5297491550445557,
0.6782054901123047,
-0.6832528114318848,
0.2493775486946106,
0.4236849248409271,
-0.4932985305786133,
0.022375037893652916,
-0.8387980461120605,
-0.07243422418832779,
-0.44296348094940186,
0.46684810519218445,
-0.4993235766887665,
-0.737618088722229,
0.5575777292251587,
0.28309640288352966,
0.08492916077375412,
0.05547912046313286,
0.5691162347793579,
-0.13137193024158478,
0.9797728657722473,
0.7065906524658203,
0.2727905809879303,
0.5051100254058838,
0.012013118714094162,
-0.060710400342941284,
-0.5023203492164612,
-0.25241613388061523,
-0.21328310668468475,
-0.2941078841686249,
-0.3060655891895294,
-0.573823869228363,
0.6402776837348938,
0.3286585509777069,
-0.1681438535451889,
-0.1256479024887085,
-0.4612942337989807,
0.4666101932525635,
0.8665395379066467,
0.5467748045921326,
0.08077874779701233,
-0.03150831162929535,
-0.09188203513622284,
-0.15694117546081543,
-0.7082931399345398,
-0.35548704862594604,
1.0532411336898804,
0.3132554888725281,
0.7413017749786377,
0.007760433945804834,
0.22664900124073029,
-0.2344101518392563,
0.2961844801902771,
-0.8509243726730347,
0.4011228680610657,
0.30110377073287964,
-0.8432066440582275,
-0.520931601524353,
-0.3953743875026703,
-0.2791970372200012,
0.5443763732910156,
-0.14599016308784485,
-0.8057833909988403,
0.4562556743621826,
0.20231851935386658,
-0.45362529158592224,
-0.009169158525764942,
-0.781272292137146,
1.0074177980422974,
-0.29176414012908936,
-0.6472997665405273,
0.027593113481998444,
-0.8143213987350464,
0.4923901855945587,
-0.06905809044837952,
0.18624398112297058,
-0.026463963091373444,
-0.08337926119565964,
0.2432672381401062,
-0.09873685985803604,
0.7598345279693604,
-0.13581521809101105,
0.18080496788024902,
0.48489999771118164,
0.139778271317482,
0.09806413948535919,
0.4258955419063568,
-0.052128080278635025,
0.026039021089673042,
0.5233535766601562,
-0.5643935203552246,
-0.5676316618919373,
0.34408828616142273,
-0.48068180680274963,
-0.5641623735427856,
-0.4677315950393677,
-0.6943131685256958,
-0.24710510671138763,
0.09489955753087997,
0.4067273437976837,
0.5457924604415894,
0.0007945303223095834,
0.34780043363571167,
0.7172373533248901,
-0.3190804123878479,
0.5490292310714722,
0.1714869886636734,
-0.1611108034849167,
-0.6890088319778442,
0.551230788230896,
0.04657691717147827,
0.5333617925643921,
0.5506720542907715,
0.037781279534101486,
-0.3422411382198334,
-0.2449628859758377,
-0.9502787590026855,
0.16186192631721497,
-0.9692245125770569,
-0.1898900717496872,
-0.1744299829006195,
-0.1634025275707245,
0.1911344975233078,
-0.2935854196548462,
0.017608139663934708,
-0.22757555544376373,
-0.30249834060668945,
-0.287171334028244,
0.045094508677721024,
0.341776579618454,
0.09940280765295029,
0.1323910802602768,
-0.6807805895805359,
0.4813306927680969,
0.7375725507736206,
0.15928125381469727,
-0.22094842791557312,
-0.41247954964637756,
0.05008333921432495,
0.3839981257915497,
-0.20298521220684052,
-1.1588163375854492,
0.16431140899658203,
0.27223119139671326,
0.7086816430091858,
0.2424943596124649,
0.017214253544807434,
1.0224536657333374,
-0.34245139360427856,
0.7851839065551758,
0.21903488039970398,
-0.5878742933273315,
0.6071467399597168,
-0.20042304694652557,
0.3750627040863037,
0.8237630128860474,
0.44563910365104675,
-0.1944112479686737,
0.00530399102717638,
-0.06399498134851456,
-0.6313632726669312,
0.30422109365463257,
-0.030841538682579994,
0.23195672035217285,
0.27931076288223267,
0.35947883129119873,
0.032584499567747116,
0.3711739778518677,
-0.7719053626060486,
-0.12387733161449432,
-0.32145118713378906,
-0.08455881476402283,
-0.3652801513671875,
-0.12397485226392746,
-0.4437434673309326,
-0.6091356873512268,
0.3450752794742584,
-0.35684362053871155,
-0.010759727098047733,
0.4616919457912445,
-0.48699742555618286,
-0.4090462923049927,
-0.07872290164232254,
0.50091552734375,
1.174247145652771,
-0.2900795042514801,
0.05050766095519066,
0.19188548624515533,
-0.31438300013542175,
-0.030219467356801033,
0.11715765297412872,
-0.3774448335170746,
-0.20072442293167114,
0.2669233977794647,
0.7097505927085876,
0.0578836128115654,
-0.9120088815689087,
0.8985780477523804,
-0.13877232372760773,
-0.22185958921909332,
-0.16181573271751404,
0.08506465703248978,
-0.34936192631721497,
0.37546074390411377,
0.4758257567882538,
0.136377215385437,
0.11988057941198349,
-0.38723304867744446,
0.2611262798309326,
0.6904211640357971,
-0.9280651807785034,
0.04202013462781906,
1.0610792636871338,
-0.03067564219236374,
0.0345621332526207,
0.3141529858112335,
0.3108576834201813,
-0.2340744435787201,
0.6611891984939575,
0.15940406918525696,
0.5070671439170837,
-0.06861171126365662,
0.32471299171447754,
0.6259351372718811,
0.441649466753006,
0.13634131848812103,
0.627118706703186,
-0.3086613118648529,
-0.48588430881500244,
-0.3988787829875946,
-0.597154974937439,
-0.4741908311843872,
0.06462938338518143,
-0.7574821710586548,
0.2028510868549347,
-0.3588598668575287,
-0.17456427216529846,
-0.07074744254350662,
-0.14528876543045044,
-0.8713030219078064,
0.7384621500968933,
0.06618916243314743,
0.9340351819992065,
-0.8994726538658142,
0.26916566491127014,
0.8925895690917969,
-0.7356478571891785,
-0.8039451241493225,
-0.31207263469696045,
-0.06932909786701202,
-0.5866559743881226,
0.3823971748352051,
0.3460251986980438,
0.11800975352525711,
0.09745556116104126,
-0.7384647727012634,
-0.8823022246360779,
1.09260094165802,
0.4152194857597351,
-0.3373723328113556,
0.07122631371021271,
0.0076004378497600555,
0.24353548884391785,
-0.013780987821519375,
0.6734666228294373,
0.1056276336312294,
0.49331551790237427,
0.28629449009895325,
-0.9249570369720459,
-0.17744727432727814,
-0.21169829368591309,
-0.09897914528846741,
-0.22453823685646057,
-0.5892987251281738,
0.5270592570304871,
-0.21963979303836823,
0.0805772915482521,
0.34957388043403625,
0.655494213104248,
0.5050116777420044,
0.5521301031112671,
0.40043553709983826,
0.33475828170776367,
0.6764194965362549,
-0.24112831056118011,
1.1164199113845825,
-0.07708346843719482,
-0.01927570067346096,
0.8052002787590027,
0.15804710984230042,
0.7776241302490234,
0.6717668175697327,
0.07128559052944183,
-0.06583969295024872,
1.0126969814300537,
0.19719107449054718,
0.5258585214614868,
0.08296999335289001,
-0.1819380819797516,
-0.790446400642395,
0.17374452948570251,
-0.32353436946868896,
0.438077837228775,
0.2847815454006195,
-0.2558327615261078,
-0.2082446962594986,
0.06028904393315315,
-0.6361101269721985,
0.19333170354366302,
-0.5733363032341003,
0.5072964429855347,
0.24121885001659393,
-0.7905084490776062,
0.6157198548316956,
-0.11838114261627197,
0.12030584365129471,
-0.4791067838668823,
-0.12332573533058167,
-0.11460597813129425,
0.028805676847696304,
-0.06301769614219666,
-0.7082359790802002,
-0.26288095116615295,
-0.36317551136016846,
-0.28406375646591187,
0.023454269394278526,
0.3750019073486328,
-0.3120839595794678,
-0.7388906478881836,
-0.04208887740969658,
0.8116356134414673,
-0.029133714735507965,
-0.23778295516967773,
-0.3652690052986145,
-0.2792215049266815,
-0.27188995480537415,
-0.27324479818344116,
-0.007083416450768709,
0.37213262915611267,
-0.3573675751686096,
0.8423866629600525,
0.587455153465271,
-0.24319812655448914,
0.5657520294189453,
-0.035274259746074677,
0.5941724181175232,
-0.32831189036369324,
-0.6197825074195862,
-0.47043487429618835,
0.9158462882041931,
-0.008247468620538712,
-0.5539358854293823,
0.7926726937294006,
0.507167637348175,
0.8206376433372498,
-0.19449108839035034,
0.5051149129867554,
0.22487527132034302,
0.26188620924949646,
-0.5931328535079956,
0.5125191807746887,
-0.9795579314231873,
-0.0314754955470562,
-0.4599919617176056,
-1.2077592611312866,
-0.5298017263412476,
0.7802034616470337,
-0.3608756959438324,
0.15266704559326172,
0.5230244994163513,
0.78633052110672,
-0.2562769949436188,
-0.08298508822917938,
0.686674952507019,
-0.3018672466278076,
0.03880966082215309,
0.6631460189819336,
0.8777204155921936,
-0.5652100443840027,
0.2867882251739502,
-0.27201494574546814,
-0.45299476385116577,
-0.2415425181388855,
-0.6934274435043335,
-0.8582866787910461,
-0.5720403790473938,
-0.2571564316749573,
-0.11051657050848007,
-0.07674402743577957,
0.3887937664985657,
1.0923446416854858,
-0.5905424356460571,
-0.1278812736272812,
0.19911853969097137,
0.04056282341480255,
-0.4117644131183624,
-0.13043637573719025,
0.2441796064376831,
-0.03151826560497284,
-0.5818230509757996,
0.25041890144348145,
0.21929648518562317,
-0.013292800635099411,
-0.08703432232141495,
0.008291489444673061,
-0.10431820899248123,
0.40372171998023987,
0.6282951235771179,
0.26188230514526367,
-0.8576266765594482,
-0.5550575256347656,
0.19588862359523773,
-0.19125205278396606,
0.11976809054613113,
0.27064409852027893,
-0.8649250268936157,
0.9459158778190613,
0.6883038878440857,
0.6202853322029114,
0.5618236064910889,
0.4710620939731598,
0.44005799293518066,
-0.6040326952934265,
0.13382957875728607,
0.24704325199127197,
0.35976746678352356,
0.2998056411743164,
-0.15708491206169128,
0.43006131052970886,
0.039560068398714066,
-0.5576829314231873,
-0.850443959236145,
0.42233026027679443,
-1.3194652795791626,
-0.20991705358028412,
1.0416696071624756,
0.0584365576505661,
-0.2832123637199402,
0.02964370884001255,
-0.5494530200958252,
-0.022105049341917038,
0.15787486732006073,
0.2649823725223541,
0.7184323072433472,
0.2574786841869354,
-0.6539260745048523,
-1.01595139503479,
0.32320231199264526,
0.4026127755641937,
-0.5914334654808044,
-0.20412389934062958,
0.9738841652870178,
0.364996075630188,
-0.17949838936328888,
0.5091801881790161,
-0.10540669411420822,
0.8585506081581116,
-0.16314667463302612,
-0.2369096577167511,
-0.21141156554222107,
-0.5491641759872437,
-0.40338578820228577,
0.4355524182319641,
0.04280544072389603,
-0.2831084430217743
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00976v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00976v1
|
Generative Pre-trained Speech Language Model with Efficient Hierarchical Transformer
| 2024-06-03T04:16:30 | 2024-06-03T04:16:30 |
Yongxin Zhu, Dan Su, Liqiang He, Linli Xu, Dong Yu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
While recent advancements in speech language models have achieved significant
progress, they face remarkable challenges in modeling the long acoustic
sequences of neural audio codecs. In this paper, we introduce
\textbf{G}enerative \textbf{P}re-trained \textbf{S}peech \textbf{T}ransformer
(GPST), a hierarchical transformer designed for efficient speech language
modeling. GPST quantizes audio waveforms into two distinct types of discrete
speech representations and integrates them within a hierarchical transformer
architecture, allowing for a unified one-stage generation process and enhancing
Hi-Res audio generation capabilities. By training on large corpora of speeches
in an end-to-end unsupervised manner, GPST can generate syntactically
consistent speech with diverse speaker identities. Given a brief 3-second
prompt, GPST can produce natural and coherent personalized speech,
demonstrating in-context learning abilities. Moreover, our approach can be
easily extended to spoken cross-lingual speech generation by incorporating
multi-lingual semantic tokens and universal acoustic tokens. Experimental
results indicate that GPST significantly outperforms the existing speech
language models in terms of word error rate, speech quality, and speaker
similarity. See \url{https://youngsheen.github.io/GPST/demo} for demo samples.
|
[
-0.30034542083740234,
-0.6268232464790344,
0.3385520875453949,
0.1465558558702469,
-0.3580310344696045,
0.12189342826604843,
-0.4230140745639801,
-0.03170452639460564,
0.13206203281879425,
0.1935279369354248,
-0.6258983016014099,
-0.49115967750549316,
-0.40756961703300476,
-0.05723114684224129,
-0.5127592086791992,
1.2381577491760254,
0.21545758843421936,
0.1097816526889801,
0.1994367092847824,
0.20771797001361847,
-0.3126371204853058,
-0.6042752265930176,
-0.7432301044464111,
-0.584863543510437,
0.289713978767395,
0.12094273418188095,
0.6295941472053528,
0.24616292119026184,
0.1679074913263321,
0.33107447624206543,
-0.11134402453899384,
-0.28185462951660156,
-0.46200838685035706,
0.22237010300159454,
-0.15683113038539886,
0.06187885254621506,
-0.5116347670555115,
-0.32618191838264465,
0.7954091429710388,
0.7856329679489136,
-0.6228187680244446,
0.1654030829668045,
0.2745140790939331,
0.15734681487083435,
-0.25318625569343567,
0.22198735177516937,
-0.682705283164978,
0.10740786790847778,
-0.32182466983795166,
-0.3686346411705017,
-0.4611307382583618,
-0.21479420363903046,
0.39257991313934326,
-0.5867782831192017,
0.5584369897842407,
-0.2794664800167084,
0.6640644669532776,
0.33076176047325134,
-0.119398333132267,
-0.1016818955540657,
-0.981981635093689,
0.6024085283279419,
-0.577624499797821,
0.7885043621063232,
0.05238666012883186,
0.3906717300415039,
-0.22371309995651245,
-1.1661158800125122,
-0.2580789029598236,
-0.3602226674556732,
-0.009665154851973057,
0.2531197667121887,
-0.2845590114593506,
0.13496343791484833,
0.16121163964271545,
0.47304072976112366,
-0.8687926530838013,
-0.015858346596360207,
-0.053746141493320465,
-0.08171076327562332,
0.2171727567911148,
-0.15371489524841309,
0.2123488336801529,
-0.09729239344596863,
-0.3917544186115265,
-0.1347152441740036,
-0.6957645416259766,
-0.31315332651138306,
0.40627625584602356,
0.4440251290798187,
-0.09863924980163574,
0.2829093635082245,
-0.09639544039964676,
0.6506192088127136,
0.3392655551433563,
-0.338272362947464,
0.3610270023345947,
-0.14833153784275055,
-0.20688126981258392,
0.28728044033050537,
0.8856682777404785,
-0.4566662609577179,
0.415215402841568,
-0.3356926143169403,
-0.32879194617271423,
-0.11585451662540436,
0.3354220390319824,
-0.7652735114097595,
-0.4084729552268982,
-0.1460433006286621,
-0.1526387482881546,
-0.05973401665687561,
-0.02408403716981411,
-0.7330360412597656,
0.14527396857738495,
-0.1713685542345047,
0.3636436462402344,
-0.3023935854434967,
-0.35425418615341187,
0.26617807149887085,
0.09546662122011185,
0.12281505018472672,
-0.05006583780050278,
-1.2110483646392822,
0.38666725158691406,
0.6736647486686707,
0.7291087508201599,
-0.13466985523700714,
-0.44144847989082336,
-0.5437158346176147,
0.3385687470436096,
-0.182859405875206,
0.6589336395263672,
-0.3218685984611511,
-0.5891129374504089,
-0.019957546144723892,
-0.2872260510921478,
-0.29696863889694214,
-0.5123894810676575,
0.6601375341415405,
-0.39216628670692444,
0.5511429309844971,
0.23392143845558167,
-0.31028661131858826,
0.09376832097768784,
-0.0992053896188736,
-0.44079846143722534,
1.0831329822540283,
0.1498671919107437,
-0.8936058878898621,
0.45838627219200134,
-0.6736592650413513,
-0.5624122619628906,
0.4495576322078705,
-0.3140542507171631,
-0.6814853549003601,
0.111711286008358,
0.43206658959388733,
0.27564260363578796,
-0.292845755815506,
0.7517886161804199,
0.16799774765968323,
-0.3998606503009796,
-0.20535120368003845,
-0.7040013074874878,
0.4971045255661011,
0.10941298305988312,
-0.6188205480575562,
0.4322032630443573,
-0.7030187249183655,
0.08870288729667664,
0.28794151544570923,
-0.5049291849136353,
0.04227164760231972,
0.009431442245841026,
0.3425235450267792,
0.030698170885443687,
0.04603957012295723,
-0.4898979663848877,
-0.075760118663311,
-0.3049197494983673,
0.5148066282272339,
0.6768109798431396,
-0.16935668885707855,
0.3529646396636963,
-0.09173170477151871,
0.6816058158874512,
-0.31838980317115784,
0.013496951200067997,
-0.22359253466129303,
-0.4855462312698364,
-0.6109678745269775,
-0.48639360070228577,
0.36649763584136963,
0.5343782305717468,
-0.6175390481948853,
0.6674531102180481,
-0.8370295763015747,
-0.4296787977218628,
-0.34625598788261414,
-0.3173915147781372,
0.30155280232429504,
0.5749509930610657,
0.29390057921409607,
-0.24043606221675873,
-0.5678116083145142,
-0.7525948882102966,
-0.23324620723724365,
-0.34458380937576294,
-0.41700509190559387,
0.20138704776763916,
0.21234223246574402,
-0.28774353861808777,
0.9974030256271362,
-0.277626097202301,
-0.006379466503858566,
-0.4680691957473755,
0.2955370545387268,
0.1253228634595871,
0.46914851665496826,
0.34393203258514404,
-0.75606369972229,
-0.2480194866657257,
0.03015567734837532,
-0.41566789150238037,
-0.335027277469635,
-0.1488795131444931,
0.10151536762714386,
-0.057257845997810364,
0.3860226571559906,
-0.7129416465759277,
0.1754346787929535,
0.6884581446647644,
-0.045830465853214264,
0.6685962080955505,
-0.12400632351636887,
0.04935938119888306,
-1.2543848752975464,
-0.02956748567521572,
-0.26047834753990173,
-0.34384316205978394,
-0.757942795753479,
-0.184501513838768,
-0.26618003845214844,
-0.6656268835067749,
-0.4415847361087799,
0.180147185921669,
-0.3012823462486267,
-0.3603271245956421,
-0.20258532464504242,
0.06670477986335754,
-0.38623589277267456,
0.5107021927833557,
0.24934187531471252,
1.094068169593811,
0.6932942271232605,
-0.3718224763870239,
0.3429918587207794,
0.21116313338279724,
-0.39827799797058105,
0.4385017454624176,
-0.8733640313148499,
0.40952354669570923,
-0.028150063008069992,
0.45332664251327515,
-0.7389636039733887,
-0.23144106566905975,
0.13302432000637054,
-0.35125863552093506,
0.39125290513038635,
-0.2453484982252121,
-0.4657208323478699,
-0.3265495002269745,
0.24948197603225708,
0.6211725473403931,
0.5950404405593872,
-0.958339512348175,
0.7296038866043091,
0.4245557188987732,
-0.5667988657951355,
-0.2785208225250244,
-0.44984516501426697,
0.1808285266160965,
-0.35901814699172974,
-0.6962498426437378,
0.65120530128479,
0.12719322741031647,
0.2734505832195282,
-0.06150462105870247,
-0.0862654447555542,
0.052373118698596954,
-0.3117843270301819,
0.1255716234445572,
0.019745437428355217,
-0.3198809325695038,
0.23696322739124298,
-0.153196781873703,
-0.37534406781196594,
-0.09388895332813263,
-0.8060540556907654,
0.8608432412147522,
-0.4303355813026428,
-0.4618164300918579,
-0.3587782680988312,
0.4161265790462494,
0.4357505142688751,
-0.3085496127605438,
0.3205685317516327,
0.7352203726768494,
-0.32777366042137146,
-0.07048797607421875,
-0.29083019495010376,
-0.06238604709506035,
-0.48421233892440796,
0.7451378703117371,
-0.5707210898399353,
-1.102218508720398,
0.3477810323238373,
-0.11163240671157837,
-0.13174806535243988,
0.23221352696418762,
0.5950777530670166,
0.27779287099838257,
0.9135401248931885,
0.5794526934623718,
-0.21172790229320526,
0.7740894556045532,
-0.0019037723541259766,
0.425670862197876,
-0.4778999388217926,
-0.16834425926208496,
-0.4238837957382202,
0.21375003457069397,
-0.836281418800354,
-0.2520937919616699,
0.48097091913223267,
-0.1732085794210434,
-0.49569523334503174,
0.4125174582004547,
-0.36951059103012085,
0.26701048016548157,
0.6026095151901245,
-0.14170847833156586,
0.06511116772890091,
0.17399558424949646,
-0.09919416159391403,
-0.005791304167360067,
-0.9935351014137268,
-0.3654579818248749,
0.5938858985900879,
0.49161672592163086,
1.0262659788131714,
-0.09479142725467682,
0.7744427919387817,
-0.013851980678737164,
0.22257192432880402,
-0.8205022811889648,
0.5013301372528076,
-0.23145660758018494,
-0.3111288249492645,
-0.32565030455589294,
-0.6033790707588196,
-0.7033423781394958,
0.3574068248271942,
0.06841859966516495,
-0.5563808083534241,
-0.08421590924263,
0.2466064840555191,
-0.2612745761871338,
0.39520201086997986,
-0.5980095863342285,
0.8205138444900513,
-0.26163846254348755,
0.029013140127062798,
0.005823757965117693,
-0.4587436020374298,
0.06917040795087814,
-0.1262781322002411,
-0.16871711611747742,
0.2087070792913437,
0.3558465242385864,
0.9006553292274475,
-0.2207668274641037,
0.702629029750824,
-0.2974298894405365,
-0.22649134695529938,
0.1562328040599823,
-0.13359656929969788,
0.48925936222076416,
-0.006074852775782347,
0.2501593232154846,
0.3098781108856201,
-0.5356312394142151,
-0.2102736383676529,
-0.41666439175605774,
0.6294547915458679,
-0.49685096740722656,
-0.5907170176506042,
-0.29901885986328125,
-0.45993760228157043,
-0.32198894023895264,
0.2676367461681366,
0.6722686886787415,
0.5357887148857117,
-0.5073238611221313,
0.11751991510391235,
0.557000994682312,
-0.18517860770225525,
0.37916913628578186,
0.030215775594115257,
-0.04432259500026703,
-0.6397493481636047,
0.698846161365509,
-0.26201871037483215,
0.26298758387565613,
0.3698807954788208,
0.25202175974845886,
-0.4028633236885071,
-0.42973557114601135,
-0.45983079075813293,
0.15923196077346802,
-0.5397701263427734,
-0.09859368950128555,
-0.5113478302955627,
-0.4001845419406891,
-0.38091376423835754,
0.01577756553888321,
-0.7466557025909424,
-0.20015408098697662,
-0.15780337154865265,
-0.26524412631988525,
-0.044186070561409,
0.7751263976097107,
0.026964999735355377,
0.7763444185256958,
-0.5783325433731079,
0.5055481791496277,
0.6204484105110168,
0.35987213253974915,
-0.3212012052536011,
-0.6806841492652893,
-0.25763776898384094,
-0.10505592077970505,
-0.20237348973751068,
-0.6670048832893372,
0.47324857115745544,
0.4173189103603363,
0.6002510786056519,
0.2984638214111328,
-0.44507676362991333,
0.7602153420448303,
-0.9834505915641785,
0.7970486879348755,
0.20773951709270477,
-1.073128342628479,
0.5353816747665405,
-0.5535654425621033,
0.4858819246292114,
0.2544517517089844,
0.15987567603588104,
-0.6466795802116394,
-0.22501836717128754,
-0.5384172797203064,
-0.96305251121521,
0.49993234872817993,
0.2746965289115906,
0.11831795424222946,
-0.025733299553394318,
-0.030199812725186348,
0.05452164262533188,
0.1185445487499237,
-0.8393018245697021,
-0.12208709120750427,
-0.5787783861160278,
-0.14793400466442108,
-0.31941893696784973,
-0.24820227921009064,
0.013086387887597084,
-0.15658584237098694,
0.7483007907867432,
-0.07080983370542526,
0.44273489713668823,
-0.002438486088067293,
-0.0655871257185936,
-0.03896598145365715,
0.626099169254303,
0.5988524556159973,
0.569807231426239,
-0.23885473608970642,
0.21029578149318695,
0.09432348608970642,
-0.5601828694343567,
0.24039049446582794,
0.4897565245628357,
-0.09853093326091766,
0.2677646577358246,
0.3278666138648987,
1.118281364440918,
0.5277595520019531,
-0.23188172280788422,
0.4176709055900574,
-0.1216086819767952,
-0.2536589503288269,
-0.46683916449546814,
-0.3292567729949951,
0.06799165904521942,
-0.0015614144504070282,
0.3347192108631134,
0.004340951796621084,
0.07862026244401932,
-0.13929353654384613,
0.4365898370742798,
0.3205978572368622,
-0.3247360289096832,
-0.39705702662467957,
0.8356371521949768,
0.2552807033061981,
-0.45949190855026245,
0.730434238910675,
-0.029978614300489426,
-0.6873680353164673,
-0.036586422473192215,
0.984041690826416,
1.373465895652771,
-0.5479093790054321,
0.16179624199867249,
0.2160225361585617,
0.12981954216957092,
-0.07748562097549438,
-0.031721774488687515,
-0.32974088191986084,
-0.4963512122631073,
-0.581591010093689,
-0.6667822599411011,
-0.20399485528469086,
0.28578317165374756,
-0.5764872431755066,
-0.006301493383944035,
-0.11190687119960785,
-0.24062742292881012,
-0.20851875841617584,
-0.47728246450424194,
-0.4355711340904236,
0.14950236678123474,
0.28638750314712524,
0.6406193971633911,
-0.9466120600700378,
0.8837257623672485,
0.4973906874656677,
0.08818432688713074,
-0.6808376908302307,
0.46446454524993896,
-0.3313363492488861,
-0.5117114782333374,
0.6077515482902527,
0.026044068858027458,
-0.6598053574562073,
0.16030433773994446,
-0.220330610871315,
-0.7558701038360596,
0.7817304134368896,
0.5842819809913635,
-0.6085246205329895,
-0.17189615964889526,
0.2873609960079193,
0.510963499546051,
-0.45520398020744324,
-0.008645491674542427,
0.6167042255401611,
0.09454785287380219,
0.09869667887687683,
-1.1724117994308472,
-0.2744079828262329,
-0.18577614426612854,
0.26453089714050293,
0.26017871499061584,
-0.08117296546697617,
0.8367589116096497,
-0.16134771704673767,
-0.43777045607566833,
0.08680476993322372,
0.7811604738235474,
0.3998711109161377,
-0.10373242199420929,
0.7824996709823608,
0.6981831789016724,
0.6639381647109985,
-0.2830655872821808,
0.8583796620368958,
-0.18216991424560547,
0.5247955918312073,
1.2800837755203247,
-0.02729269303381443,
0.6151068806648254,
0.2976785898208618,
-0.0340094231069088,
0.47451117634773254,
0.5137627720832825,
0.3048873543739319,
0.8835588693618774,
0.28362688422203064,
-0.6851768493652344,
-0.30184945464134216,
0.08145273476839066,
-0.625486433506012,
0.7065749168395996,
0.22668689489364624,
-0.2117859572172165,
-0.3538452088832855,
0.08054931461811066,
-0.2289964109659195,
-0.11994209885597229,
-0.1478952318429947,
0.7123767137527466,
0.01655375398695469,
-0.5209155678749084,
0.6598584055900574,
-0.1376657634973526,
0.7835574150085449,
-0.7765953540802002,
0.038744937628507614,
-0.009211491793394089,
0.14253319799900055,
-0.06553392112255096,
-0.48900505900382996,
0.14075876772403717,
0.19588392972946167,
-0.05548384413123131,
-0.5610807538032532,
0.7328830361366272,
-0.6929160356521606,
-0.26298651099205017,
0.28823915123939514,
0.43989282846450806,
0.06751255691051483,
-0.11051654070615768,
-0.5411883592605591,
-0.20783717930316925,
-0.1535242348909378,
-0.35452353954315186,
-0.03298456594347954,
0.30433225631713867,
0.07306107878684998,
0.5227193236351013,
0.5745514035224915,
0.18922202289104462,
0.1800323724746704,
0.7105360627174377,
0.6938060522079468,
-0.561636745929718,
-0.8603927493095398,
-0.6253823637962341,
0.3190743327140808,
0.2061959058046341,
-0.19009727239608765,
0.47346922755241394,
0.7097364664077759,
1.0335311889648438,
-0.373884379863739,
0.7917589545249939,
0.15715715289115906,
0.5260370969772339,
-0.4216514229774475,
0.6128360629081726,
-0.09202490746974945,
0.07565553486347198,
-0.3286530673503876,
-0.9269018769264221,
-0.2491595447063446,
0.7072041034698486,
-0.24975161254405975,
0.5763387680053711,
0.5623524188995361,
0.6658281087875366,
-0.25044387578964233,
0.13684113323688507,
0.39167320728302,
-0.1020362377166748,
0.47374966740608215,
0.5798621773719788,
1.0017616748809814,
-0.3661317825317383,
0.5199218988418579,
-0.19183194637298584,
-0.25548285245895386,
0.04112207889556885,
-0.6812631487846375,
-0.6746383309364319,
-0.6244508624076843,
-0.14851082861423492,
-0.03189614787697792,
0.3074749708175659,
0.6814969778060913,
0.99637371301651,
-0.7459418773651123,
-0.4262857437133789,
-0.34086403250694275,
-0.29656514525413513,
-0.1264064759016037,
-0.22273585200309753,
0.36789947748184204,
-0.3033560812473297,
-0.7772132754325867,
0.6964731812477112,
0.2387378066778183,
0.2651924192905426,
-0.14027735590934753,
-0.16807134449481964,
0.21930159628391266,
-0.24861469864845276,
0.5174299478530884,
0.20875370502471924,
-0.5812053084373474,
-0.3543192148208618,
-0.1908002644777298,
0.04445313662290573,
0.12980084121227264,
1.0731781721115112,
-0.8557369709014893,
0.22877642512321472,
0.3112298250198364,
0.5850207209587097,
0.7682886123657227,
0.07095374166965485,
0.6717717051506042,
-1.0248844623565674,
0.21779906749725342,
0.3781206011772156,
0.46230417490005493,
0.5701309442520142,
-0.14730103313922882,
0.23544803261756897,
0.20201221108436584,
-0.6881559491157532,
-0.5517908334732056,
0.4168033301830292,
-0.891917884349823,
0.10504984110593796,
0.9867886304855347,
-0.11917957663536072,
0.08883969485759735,
0.07761476933956146,
-0.07770456373691559,
0.5526125431060791,
-0.2925058603286743,
0.5600268244743347,
0.2748282551765442,
-0.15352153778076172,
-0.06856502592563629,
-0.3131190538406372,
0.5758658051490784,
0.42763155698776245,
-0.7281561493873596,
0.15937434136867523,
0.37687256932258606,
0.3293650448322296,
0.17569640278816223,
0.7784689664840698,
-0.1384192407131195,
0.24553608894348145,
0.12648098170757294,
0.1627209335565567,
0.0449134036898613,
-0.609268307685852,
-0.5229185223579407,
0.243385449051857,
-0.08287332952022552,
-0.4611230492591858
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00975v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00975v2
|
Luna: An Evaluation Foundation Model to Catch Language Model Hallucinations with High Accuracy and Low Cost
| 2024-06-03T04:14:21 | 2024-06-05T15:45:04 |
Masha Belyi, Robert Friel, Shuai Shao, Atindriyo Sanyal
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Retriever Augmented Generation (RAG) systems have become pivotal in enhancing
the capabilities of language models by incorporating external knowledge
retrieval mechanisms. However, a significant challenge in deploying these
systems in industry applications is the detection and mitigation of
hallucinations: instances where the model generates information that is not
grounded in the retrieved context. Addressing this issue is crucial for
ensuring the reliability and accuracy of responses generated by large language
models (LLMs) in diverse industry settings. Current hallucination detection
techniques fail to deliver accuracy, low latency, and low cost simultaneously.
We introduce Luna: a DeBERTA-large (440M) encoder, finetuned for hallucination
detection in RAG settings. We demonstrate that Luna outperforms GPT-3.5 and
commercial evaluation frameworks on the hallucination detection task, with 97%
and 91% reduction in cost and latency, respectively. Luna is lightweight and
generalizes across multiple industry verticals and out-of-domain data, making
it an ideal candidate for industry LLM applications.
|
[
-0.3800124526023865,
-0.8496994972229004,
0.7388561367988586,
0.4005105793476105,
0.0761796161532402,
-0.022511446848511696,
-0.06433696299791336,
-0.672334611415863,
0.48170551657676697,
0.8080489635467529,
-0.18025563657283783,
-0.4444724917411804,
-0.49736225605010986,
0.11224398016929626,
-0.6596841812133789,
0.4547664523124695,
0.26475951075553894,
-0.13079702854156494,
0.2194444239139557,
0.1594868302345276,
-0.50765460729599,
-0.44211310148239136,
-0.7750411629676819,
-0.46410802006721497,
0.14247143268585205,
0.12206047028303146,
0.744951069355011,
0.2736945152282715,
0.4037380516529083,
0.24489626288414001,
-0.1292259395122528,
0.5405575633049011,
-0.37391582131385803,
0.09248416870832443,
0.0005666327197104692,
-0.22625818848609924,
-0.45988965034484863,
-0.2414323389530182,
0.309646874666214,
0.7372899651527405,
-0.2779702842235565,
-0.03455236181616783,
-0.060128103941679,
0.8443229794502258,
-0.8867305517196655,
-0.10531026124954224,
-0.869502067565918,
0.13369350135326385,
-0.057844266295433044,
-0.12508642673492432,
-0.7735946178436279,
-0.331991583108902,
-0.235539048910141,
-0.5511366128921509,
0.3118065595626831,
0.11529342085123062,
0.9629191756248474,
0.5561239123344421,
-0.06119374558329582,
-0.5221112370491028,
-0.9507598280906677,
0.4946710169315338,
-0.413627564907074,
0.8377089500427246,
0.5713750123977661,
0.36241865158081055,
-0.4558492600917816,
-0.6327378153800964,
-0.5060166120529175,
-0.4732281267642975,
0.02202724479138851,
0.06508474797010422,
-0.150040864944458,
-0.0030245031230151653,
0.24173501133918762,
0.405496209859848,
-0.5427123308181763,
0.11090391129255295,
-0.4078374207019806,
-0.18368153274059296,
0.31851842999458313,
0.24295708537101746,
-0.01844342239201069,
-0.3601405918598175,
-0.012459729798138142,
0.05423092842102051,
-0.5458366274833679,
-0.2994617521762848,
0.27305832505226135,
0.08145805448293686,
0.19717049598693848,
0.5755784511566162,
-0.4066965878009796,
0.5942832827568054,
0.40352579951286316,
0.032933078706264496,
0.21227210760116577,
0.2347279191017151,
-0.32856935262680054,
0.11235319823026657,
0.6047056317329407,
0.1999843418598175,
-0.02561137266457081,
-0.632891058921814,
-0.4634183645248413,
0.35975930094718933,
0.48294728994369507,
-0.6709024906158447,
-0.23411016166210175,
0.2601413428783417,
-0.39011216163635254,
-0.28524839878082275,
0.004527196288108826,
-1.0247976779937744,
-0.9406061768531799,
-0.14445531368255615,
0.6227393746376038,
-0.22276930510997772,
-0.36820587515830994,
0.6199443936347961,
-0.09276226907968521,
0.411252498626709,
0.2149588018655777,
-0.8880743980407715,
0.34660717844963074,
0.7966502904891968,
0.8504230976104736,
-0.3055175244808197,
-0.07929850369691849,
-0.8679383397102356,
0.12748755514621735,
-0.7622732520103455,
0.6193109750747681,
-0.221261665225029,
-0.29342129826545715,
-0.16531294584274292,
0.08348429948091507,
0.03561156243085861,
-1.013230562210083,
0.5341002941131592,
-0.5288082957267761,
-0.20249883830547333,
0.0935647040605545,
-0.19582165777683258,
-0.08524488657712936,
0.07447320967912674,
-0.8375133872032166,
1.0370699167251587,
0.29991671442985535,
-0.5906553268432617,
0.5422762036323547,
-0.39587053656578064,
-0.21187442541122437,
0.06710615009069443,
-0.22236765921115875,
-0.3359319269657135,
0.46196573972702026,
0.07405528426170349,
0.4375467300415039,
-0.4419051706790924,
0.19987526535987854,
-0.14509497582912445,
-0.7992489337921143,
0.2386326789855957,
-0.3934813141822815,
0.2883487045764923,
0.28853708505630493,
-0.5621412396430969,
-0.080931656062603,
-1.0229308605194092,
-0.3397800922393799,
0.14485327899456024,
-0.05613040551543236,
-0.5650588870048523,
-0.24940025806427002,
0.041225433349609375,
0.01947721093893051,
0.00730799650773406,
-0.4353162944316864,
-0.2005745768547058,
-0.5455452799797058,
-0.07109243422746658,
0.4875318706035614,
-0.12417203187942505,
0.30722758173942566,
-0.12971441447734833,
0.4283190667629242,
-0.23075805604457855,
0.1967725157737732,
0.24422389268875122,
-0.30200135707855225,
-1.082818627357483,
-0.42858240008354187,
-0.09986776113510132,
0.3739284574985504,
-0.753579318523407,
0.5541396141052246,
-0.0718168243765831,
-0.6083431243896484,
-0.7846720814704895,
-0.027936914935708046,
0.2682637572288513,
0.528145432472229,
0.3416992425918579,
0.05872485786676407,
-0.6667946577072144,
-0.8743061423301697,
-0.11839881539344788,
0.04556731507182121,
-0.13895584642887115,
0.07809510827064514,
0.39629191160202026,
-0.6771870851516724,
0.9924983978271484,
-0.3975505530834198,
-0.3435935080051422,
-0.18209342658519745,
0.2797469198703766,
0.3954140543937683,
0.2383120059967041,
0.33773621916770935,
-0.5965525507926941,
-0.35640448331832886,
0.2674624025821686,
-0.9800591468811035,
-0.33304834365844727,
0.018329378217458725,
0.0651097372174263,
0.5657037496566772,
0.30712568759918213,
-0.6814625859260559,
0.47841423749923706,
0.660984456539154,
-0.27727431058883667,
0.6326618194580078,
-0.18183086812496185,
0.35014718770980835,
-0.9075982570648193,
0.11326194554567337,
-0.2986319959163666,
-0.024417676031589508,
-0.5823323726654053,
-0.14804935455322266,
-0.02646607719361782,
-0.10953313857316971,
-0.26227620244026184,
0.6259983777999878,
-0.3272819221019745,
-0.2875642776489258,
-0.5531397461891174,
0.15339459478855133,
0.196847602725029,
0.09830342233181,
0.31478530168533325,
0.982204020023346,
0.2447344809770584,
-0.789910614490509,
0.331767201423645,
0.12891966104507446,
-0.42214182019233704,
0.35344716906547546,
-0.39492303133010864,
0.36532333493232727,
-0.13814347982406616,
-0.12414354085922241,
-0.5040430426597595,
-0.38833534717559814,
0.1964924931526184,
-0.37844857573509216,
0.004447164013981819,
0.14289848506450653,
-0.42260780930519104,
-0.4203803539276123,
-0.3613034784793854,
-0.18196937441825867,
0.6273003816604614,
-0.996140718460083,
0.7038686275482178,
0.43089812994003296,
0.3515433967113495,
-0.7872191667556763,
-0.7243675589561462,
0.06222081184387207,
-0.43141043186187744,
-0.5988332033157349,
0.062223710119724274,
0.1506289690732956,
-0.3657051920890808,
-0.12971319258213043,
-0.41933903098106384,
0.012236563488841057,
0.19763261079788208,
0.21230845153331757,
0.03488567844033241,
-0.21975570917129517,
0.11992696672677994,
-0.06026534363627434,
-0.36093369126319885,
0.03826669231057167,
-0.0784657746553421,
0.8600877523422241,
-0.10750981420278549,
-0.32241663336753845,
-0.2821081280708313,
0.07745714485645294,
0.7129510641098022,
0.15368790924549103,
0.8573790788650513,
0.4957597255706787,
-0.8411059975624084,
-0.526482105255127,
-0.9759035706520081,
-0.37342268228530884,
-0.5188995003700256,
0.5641087889671326,
-0.7566682696342468,
-0.5667555332183838,
0.6359826922416687,
-0.1615346074104309,
-0.4439503848552704,
0.3569907248020172,
0.45414212346076965,
0.442551851272583,
0.853599488735199,
0.6417906880378723,
0.11686541885137558,
0.034087009727954865,
-0.283101886510849,
0.48515817523002625,
-0.9656388163566589,
-0.22391211986541748,
-0.6065455079078674,
0.2684791386127472,
-0.18796879053115845,
-0.41349390149116516,
0.18069110810756683,
0.47136184573173523,
-0.05758066847920418,
0.4553670585155487,
-0.8188608884811401,
0.5773648619651794,
0.1960485577583313,
-0.04004524648189545,
0.7246573567390442,
-0.04417452588677406,
0.20682533085346222,
-0.13576996326446533,
-0.3640466034412384,
-0.803448498249054,
0.7828941345214844,
0.4237721264362335,
1.1377888917922974,
-0.16031163930892944,
0.5746976733207703,
0.2809138894081116,
0.38579773902893066,
-0.6946463584899902,
0.506666898727417,
-0.26533812284469604,
-0.43504542112350464,
-0.2939869463443756,
-0.43740397691726685,
-0.7708231210708618,
0.36192551255226135,
-0.1696450561285019,
-0.9606640338897705,
0.43456506729125977,
-0.06746840476989746,
-0.4152824282646179,
0.1912606954574585,
-0.5944570899009705,
0.6964870095252991,
-0.1212325468659401,
-0.4158582091331482,
-0.15002335608005524,
0.20878423750400543,
0.5540592074394226,
-0.7128775119781494,
0.11595311760902405,
-0.13838349282741547,
0.21752507984638214,
0.6071878671646118,
-0.14553532004356384,
0.46843695640563965,
-0.12267093360424042,
-0.2504151165485382,
0.09045425057411194,
0.2998795807361603,
0.6424595713615417,
0.10012395679950714,
-0.3464670479297638,
0.05321890488266945,
-0.2564219832420349,
0.3715113401412964,
-0.5985553860664368,
0.7518631219863892,
-0.4371297061443329,
-0.4784563183784485,
-0.34634822607040405,
-0.4622924029827118,
-0.2529563009738922,
-0.19549641013145447,
0.5475985407829285,
0.08866582065820694,
-0.1155659407377243,
0.30590176582336426,
0.6965859532356262,
-0.4180730879306793,
-0.016366589814424515,
0.5751095414161682,
-0.5944889187812805,
-0.49118220806121826,
0.9614816904067993,
0.055094193667173386,
0.05672050639986992,
-0.049965254962444305,
0.05951489135622978,
-0.290239155292511,
-0.4150415360927582,
-0.3297586739063263,
0.3625572621822357,
-0.7857815623283386,
-0.23431941866874695,
-0.9708390831947327,
-0.36460524797439575,
-0.2788297235965729,
-0.3561009168624878,
-0.801562488079071,
-0.2403676062822342,
-0.07109826058149338,
-0.047127414494752884,
0.57984858751297,
0.7551753520965576,
-0.08131034672260284,
0.47472018003463745,
-0.49973708391189575,
0.6570877432823181,
0.20962654054164886,
0.4080435335636139,
0.00480601005256176,
-0.489352285861969,
-0.4205772578716278,
-0.19423146545886993,
-0.11868523061275482,
-0.8570412993431091,
0.6010093092918396,
-0.18404744565486908,
0.42053595185279846,
0.3281782865524292,
0.13283833861351013,
0.7795838713645935,
-0.26503583788871765,
0.49761897325515747,
0.06419191509485245,
-1.0459810495376587,
0.4523993730545044,
-0.02686532400548458,
-0.16094402968883514,
0.4592823386192322,
0.15117226541042328,
-0.5371026396751404,
-0.6458984017372131,
-0.17998257279396057,
-0.8239484429359436,
0.7110434770584106,
0.06818508356809616,
-0.12699951231479645,
-0.12093198299407959,
0.4389888346195221,
0.36930134892463684,
0.06144233047962189,
-0.6409481167793274,
0.252270370721817,
0.13884446024894714,
-0.2865977883338928,
0.18185389041900635,
-0.14883360266685486,
0.11217641830444336,
0.10395924001932144,
0.7593829035758972,
0.02834063023328781,
0.11286047101020813,
0.21584941446781158,
-0.3484698235988617,
-0.14527729153633118,
0.08306675404310226,
0.2466810792684555,
0.47125840187072754,
-0.36107197403907776,
-0.024983203038573265,
0.30734241008758545,
-0.684583306312561,
0.11831982433795929,
0.025226179510354996,
-0.3807514011859894,
0.18435516953468323,
0.002827355172485113,
0.8073042035102844,
-0.0719309076666832,
-0.6952789425849915,
0.26683178544044495,
0.05286290869116783,
0.027464499697089195,
-0.5159953236579895,
0.043458614498376846,
-0.164934441447258,
0.4465869665145874,
0.47291260957717896,
-0.30541443824768066,
0.6612945795059204,
-0.1544049233198166,
0.21694114804267883,
0.4381762742996216,
-0.23332814872264862,
-0.1231357604265213,
0.8583488464355469,
0.005763868801295757,
-0.30643323063850403,
0.3685034513473511,
-0.2995848059654236,
-0.35205528140068054,
0.6632457971572876,
0.7303174734115601,
1.2928868532180786,
-0.19475606083869934,
0.10458957403898239,
0.20880652964115143,
0.6253159046173096,
-0.40755850076675415,
0.2269446849822998,
0.34230348467826843,
-0.6927024126052856,
-0.33673766255378723,
-0.9676840901374817,
-0.5760707259178162,
0.5633392930030823,
-0.43483778834342957,
0.5436631441116333,
-0.21005979180335999,
-0.31698256731033325,
-0.2806028425693512,
-0.2517634928226471,
-0.28846117854118347,
-0.0038500865921378136,
0.1632784754037857,
0.681363582611084,
-0.8394750952720642,
0.7173004150390625,
0.2007170170545578,
-0.4897248148918152,
-0.4898132383823395,
0.04456173628568649,
-0.34991973638534546,
-0.298326700925827,
0.8241429924964905,
0.5854065418243408,
-0.7189127206802368,
-0.14729586243629456,
-0.04311944916844368,
-0.5945378541946411,
0.9290465116500854,
0.525143027305603,
-0.4803391098976135,
0.006046046502888203,
0.20381204783916473,
0.4410615563392639,
-0.3311350345611572,
0.039616961032152176,
0.878639817237854,
0.4116569757461548,
0.0036143683828413486,
-1.040425181388855,
-0.006165445316582918,
0.01762852445244789,
0.004987651947885752,
0.217064768075943,
-0.3630901575088501,
0.7291309237480164,
0.16341564059257507,
-0.20356343686580658,
0.18095917999744415,
0.4485729932785034,
0.6888065934181213,
0.6294804215431213,
0.43124595284461975,
0.5044795870780945,
0.9241885542869568,
-0.21378479897975922,
0.722231924533844,
-0.29006558656692505,
0.23175019025802612,
0.8918337821960449,
-0.576041042804718,
0.7240347266197205,
0.4614752531051636,
0.23453374207019806,
0.09179462492465973,
0.42366570234298706,
0.06716297566890717,
0.5897411108016968,
0.19507765769958496,
-0.12141233682632446,
-0.07770536094903946,
-0.07627552002668381,
-0.5104008316993713,
0.30681946873664856,
0.6410725116729736,
-0.05388689786195755,
0.1370190978050232,
0.5074326992034912,
-0.11615578830242157,
0.1740829050540924,
-0.16789738833904266,
0.641981303691864,
0.08386209607124329,
-0.4746007025241852,
0.9062618017196655,
-0.09029829502105713,
0.9536387920379639,
-0.4585183560848236,
-0.18430191278457642,
-0.44341209530830383,
0.6293981075286865,
-0.29250356554985046,
-0.20585153996944427,
0.7100595831871033,
0.13584831357002258,
-0.11847778409719467,
0.2849922776222229,
0.7953240871429443,
-0.2057783156633377,
-0.22925736010074615,
0.8148311376571655,
0.22191213071346283,
0.3331388831138611,
-0.2935512661933899,
-0.07470136880874634,
0.5200501084327698,
-0.47472020983695984,
-0.28075122833251953,
-0.11347271502017975,
0.5678142309188843,
-0.15050694346427917,
0.6899062395095825,
0.40503430366516113,
0.10109223425388336,
0.25626569986343384,
0.07616624981164932,
0.687894344329834,
-0.604472279548645,
-0.28417330980300903,
-0.5229006409645081,
0.2913393974304199,
-0.1598229557275772,
-0.01898602768778801,
0.7259625792503357,
0.7190543413162231,
0.46463561058044434,
-0.4942840039730072,
0.38108086585998535,
0.15450724959373474,
0.577655017375946,
-0.7679421305656433,
0.9275556802749634,
-0.6681802868843079,
0.4322502017021179,
-0.38524994254112244,
-1.1079665422439575,
-0.3312920331954956,
0.9541362524032593,
-0.15583473443984985,
-0.06494005024433136,
0.8208364248275757,
1.176863670349121,
-0.03895922005176544,
-0.02439199574291706,
0.575357973575592,
0.19157923758029938,
0.12116507440805435,
0.4087189733982086,
1.125651240348816,
-0.4836914837360382,
0.3917011618614197,
-0.25064733624458313,
-0.26425105333328247,
-0.32155466079711914,
-0.5895094871520996,
-0.8184357285499573,
-0.5048880577087402,
-0.2245054692029953,
-0.6683276891708374,
0.2627546191215515,
0.8127038478851318,
0.6092124581336975,
-0.7975524663925171,
-0.3841441571712494,
-0.13260458409786224,
-0.06406094878911972,
-0.21793219447135925,
-0.24858136475086212,
0.4068026840686798,
-0.46051454544067383,
-0.8612473607063293,
0.7452727556228638,
0.4418630599975586,
-0.13897959887981415,
-0.39982908964157104,
-0.4545651972293854,
0.2211364209651947,
0.22632701694965363,
0.595298707485199,
0.062393415719270706,
-0.8835739493370056,
-0.2398887276649475,
0.41062378883361816,
-0.2574000060558319,
-0.1802009642124176,
0.36439430713653564,
-0.8110761642456055,
0.34040388464927673,
0.397053986787796,
0.8372015357017517,
0.5474783778190613,
-0.36227941513061523,
0.3248945474624634,
-0.3462291359901428,
0.47977498173713684,
0.1523609459400177,
0.26380422711372375,
0.36402350664138794,
-0.6836282014846802,
1.0265247821807861,
0.19367662072181702,
-0.5287190079689026,
-1.1114705801010132,
0.017334511503577232,
-0.726097583770752,
-0.10604870319366455,
0.9600525498390198,
0.4139227569103241,
-0.230178102850914,
-0.31249502301216125,
-0.2857174873352051,
0.051196515560150146,
-0.1815309077501297,
1.2783485651016235,
0.6050195097923279,
-0.02177416905760765,
0.020342467352747917,
-0.7610158324241638,
0.5448224544525146,
0.18993833661079407,
-0.8823394179344177,
0.2019585520029068,
0.5678189992904663,
-0.16303803026676178,
0.5767332911491394,
0.6921756863594055,
-0.18522143363952637,
0.379115492105484,
0.20454013347625732,
0.39855340123176575,
0.13823217153549194,
-0.5797392725944519,
-0.517398476600647,
0.08229558169841766,
0.27461621165275574,
-0.23577335476875305
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.06563v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.06563v1
|
Skywork-MoE: A Deep Dive into Training Techniques for Mixture-of-Experts Language Models
| 2024-06-03T03:58:41 | 2024-06-03T03:58:41 |
Tianwen Wei, Bo Zhu, Liang Zhao, Cheng Cheng, Biye Li, Weiwei Lü, Peng Cheng, Jianhao Zhang, Xiaoyu Zhang, Liang Zeng, Xiaokun Wang, Yutuan Ma, Rui Hu, Shuicheng Yan, Han Fang, Yahui Zhou
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
In this technical report, we introduce the training methodologies implemented
in the development of Skywork-MoE, a high-performance mixture-of-experts (MoE)
large language model (LLM) with 146 billion parameters and 16 experts. It is
initialized from the pre-existing dense checkpoints of our Skywork-13B model.
We explore the comparative effectiveness of upcycling versus training from
scratch initializations. Our findings suggest that the choice between these two
approaches should consider both the performance of the existing dense
checkpoints and the MoE training budget. We highlight two innovative
techniques: gating logit normalization, which improves expert diversification,
and adaptive auxiliary loss coefficients, allowing for layer-specific
adjustment of auxiliary loss coefficients. Our experimental results validate
the effectiveness of these methods. Leveraging these techniques and insights,
we trained our upcycled Skywork-MoE on a condensed subset of our SkyPile
corpus. The evaluation results demonstrate that our model delivers strong
performance across a wide range of benchmarks.
|
[
-0.36223870515823364,
-0.5152712464332581,
0.30155497789382935,
-0.057752471417188644,
-0.07813112437725067,
0.5092276930809021,
-0.4276978075504303,
-0.45504528284072876,
0.07956529408693314,
0.6792477965354919,
-0.5532066822052002,
-0.24777758121490479,
-0.4990842044353485,
-0.16053704917430878,
-0.38671138882637024,
0.755994439125061,
0.17012716829776764,
0.269542396068573,
-0.0018396337982267141,
0.014353382401168346,
-0.810897707939148,
-0.5618601441383362,
-0.507177472114563,
-0.27740055322647095,
0.25829941034317017,
0.6256170272827148,
0.49187543988227844,
0.7378650307655334,
0.22158655524253845,
0.29991599917411804,
-0.16706956923007965,
0.1209808886051178,
-0.6332635283470154,
0.006999767851084471,
-0.0347408764064312,
-0.5333669781684875,
-0.3386733829975128,
-0.021700771525502205,
0.5111692547798157,
0.9792287945747375,
-0.49630841612815857,
-0.1505201756954193,
0.038359127938747406,
0.6961914896965027,
-0.7547003626823425,
-0.08473607152700424,
-1.0056151151657104,
-0.10220693051815033,
-0.4126964211463928,
-0.09826462715864182,
-0.3306989371776581,
0.2551564574241638,
0.05846427381038666,
-0.6210060119628906,
0.16228535771369934,
0.1831449270248413,
0.45604395866394043,
0.27888408303260803,
-0.4168919324874878,
-0.2863296568393707,
-0.6787799596786499,
1.155685305595398,
-0.856711208820343,
0.5008488893508911,
0.28631117939949036,
0.37824147939682007,
-0.05945896729826927,
-0.3251115381717682,
-0.309203565120697,
-0.23354272544384003,
0.25082436203956604,
0.2010340690612793,
0.1637778878211975,
0.08809159696102142,
-0.1539800763130188,
0.5260980725288391,
-0.2789551317691803,
0.3828156292438507,
-0.5349122881889343,
-0.05433483049273491,
0.709553599357605,
0.3423028588294983,
0.17114005982875824,
-0.1151663213968277,
-0.34926626086235046,
-0.06352192163467407,
-0.6125977039337158,
-0.0689898133277893,
0.4041108191013336,
0.20552760362625122,
0.07891285419464111,
0.4364910125732422,
-0.6238616108894348,
0.7168815732002258,
0.111565500497818,
-0.17879930138587952,
0.16052763164043427,
-0.3148981034755707,
-0.27709707617759705,
0.047645267099142075,
0.3756646513938904,
0.3919067084789276,
0.2407439798116684,
-0.5188101530075073,
-0.18951880931854248,
-0.38009074330329895,
0.20824921131134033,
-0.6388354897499084,
-0.47703734040260315,
-0.039710741490125656,
-0.16529017686843872,
-0.5168942809104919,
-0.004503426607698202,
-0.4707215428352356,
-0.44939106702804565,
-0.7722650766372681,
0.310996949672699,
-0.6604871153831482,
-0.5195647478103638,
0.45195508003234863,
-0.1484076976776123,
-0.07932350039482117,
0.5134437084197998,
-0.9715287089347839,
0.16541658341884613,
0.7330487370491028,
0.38813862204551697,
-0.1514083743095398,
-0.37907689809799194,
-0.33652761578559875,
0.44487524032592773,
-0.3494865894317627,
0.6949288249015808,
-0.6723838448524475,
-0.30628740787506104,
-0.18805988132953644,
-0.47560399770736694,
-0.3016650080680847,
-0.6394011974334717,
0.2382914125919342,
-0.39229217171669006,
0.32777389883995056,
-0.2637471556663513,
-0.6433753371238708,
-0.5753183364868164,
0.2916654944419861,
-0.3379390835762024,
1.4769996404647827,
0.14553380012512207,
-0.7546064853668213,
0.5838596820831299,
-0.6280598044395447,
-0.03335817530751228,
0.27164581418037415,
-0.1702156811952591,
0.12782342731952667,
0.2781650722026825,
0.3412920832633972,
0.7653253078460693,
-0.2677142918109894,
0.3996181786060333,
-0.30562958121299744,
-0.2853853702545166,
0.15325292944908142,
-0.37008368968963623,
0.9875368475914001,
0.23555466532707214,
-0.25472456216812134,
-0.13366536796092987,
-0.9781543612480164,
0.06025415286421776,
-0.19559837877750397,
-0.6529536247253418,
-0.6188499927520752,
0.14186060428619385,
0.15403644740581512,
0.07517792284488678,
0.15017586946487427,
-0.4589572250843048,
0.28320446610450745,
-0.5008944869041443,
0.34522774815559387,
0.6568500399589539,
-0.11303474754095078,
0.4565233290195465,
-0.2320614457130432,
0.1910434365272522,
0.11113158613443375,
-0.06083887442946434,
-0.278129905462265,
-0.3451755940914154,
-0.9026979207992554,
-0.4562878906726837,
0.24671807885169983,
0.6457980275154114,
-0.6389277577400208,
0.6055701971054077,
-0.28467947244644165,
-0.6779236197471619,
-0.48009127378463745,
0.502345621585846,
0.4150158166885376,
0.35823243856430054,
0.3840680420398712,
-0.3175819218158722,
-0.564483642578125,
-0.6751057505607605,
-0.28767716884613037,
-0.11425377428531647,
0.02707486040890217,
0.2396485060453415,
0.3995731770992279,
-0.3568192422389984,
1.0450117588043213,
-0.20582932233810425,
0.11833687871694565,
-0.2134234607219696,
0.38029909133911133,
-0.029478896409273148,
0.7139325141906738,
0.7384855151176453,
-0.3651873469352722,
-0.47851717472076416,
0.20989598333835602,
-0.5590561628341675,
0.025029057636857033,
0.037456195801496506,
-0.10140595585107803,
0.08106232434511185,
0.6352236866950989,
-0.42974457144737244,
0.20141497254371643,
0.714870274066925,
-0.12362343072891235,
0.4260917007923126,
-0.25721174478530884,
0.1993073970079422,
-1.3395788669586182,
-0.032299887388944626,
-0.40213504433631897,
-0.13850584626197815,
-0.7403110265731812,
0.25447362661361694,
-0.02711980603635311,
-0.11918943375349045,
-0.5891059041023254,
0.45475903153419495,
-0.7321793437004089,
0.10434234887361526,
-0.361127108335495,
-0.2955307066440582,
-0.2719719707965851,
0.5524365305900574,
0.027243053540587425,
0.5803276300430298,
0.7238565683364868,
-0.5801089406013489,
0.49891936779022217,
-0.15664537250995636,
-0.46088942885398865,
0.6162741184234619,
-0.3822753429412842,
0.39443159103393555,
0.06957753002643585,
0.02934209629893303,
-1.0034099817276,
-0.48039159178733826,
0.15783283114433289,
-0.3630908131599426,
0.4186682105064392,
-0.1445375680923462,
-0.507194995880127,
-0.22160053253173828,
-0.28699567914009094,
0.41579127311706543,
0.4753510355949402,
-0.3095444440841675,
0.5852597951889038,
0.4410417973995209,
-0.3035217523574829,
-0.6407093405723572,
-0.7426021099090576,
0.42328542470932007,
-0.3451448976993561,
-0.7488808035850525,
0.3789920508861542,
-0.18585635721683502,
-0.3203858733177185,
-0.1417730450630188,
0.07443459331989288,
-0.4569106698036194,
0.4933391809463501,
0.0736052468419075,
-0.15973468124866486,
-0.2270554155111313,
-0.10188870131969452,
0.15702266991138458,
-0.22920750081539154,
-0.12988527119159698,
-0.24182912707328796,
0.5037075877189636,
-0.10369584709405899,
-0.4448750913143158,
-0.3086391091346741,
0.4322046637535095,
0.47103559970855713,
-0.128024160861969,
0.725215494632721,
0.5128763318061829,
-0.44144943356513977,
-0.13476845622062683,
-1.0304099321365356,
-0.08312660455703735,
-0.49779385328292847,
0.5128577351570129,
-0.08074519038200378,
-0.7845976948738098,
0.4907039701938629,
-0.09059631824493408,
0.19257257878780365,
0.22144253551959991,
0.8024351000785828,
-0.271064430475235,
0.8940865397453308,
0.9675790667533875,
-0.28783294558525085,
0.4992716908454895,
-0.22238148748874664,
-0.16463567316532135,
-0.6547975540161133,
-0.2833738625049591,
-0.459237277507782,
-0.1390150636434555,
-0.006319398060441017,
-0.6269362568855286,
0.2847540080547333,
0.4858737587928772,
-0.15029898285865784,
0.305033415555954,
-0.28235670924186707,
0.6852801442146301,
0.6310392022132874,
0.20954976975917816,
0.3473500907421112,
0.0301077738404274,
-0.20436573028564453,
0.11178253591060638,
-1.0711266994476318,
-0.28536665439605713,
1.2818753719329834,
0.30336716771125793,
0.6881405115127563,
-0.20947705209255219,
0.715052604675293,
-0.1406998187303543,
0.3661462068557739,
-0.645412266254425,
0.5803049802780151,
-0.07401691377162933,
-1.1184217929840088,
-0.4423438310623169,
-0.2491026371717453,
-0.6825186610221863,
0.29627853631973267,
-0.32917243242263794,
-0.5603488683700562,
0.07778222858905792,
0.19829995930194855,
-0.31983721256256104,
0.3989489674568176,
-0.5408117175102234,
0.6351808309555054,
-0.4114742577075958,
0.1581193059682846,
-0.5416654944419861,
-0.562458336353302,
0.3812400996685028,
-0.35348162055015564,
0.27666333317756653,
-0.11222626268863678,
-0.10757458209991455,
0.7840683460235596,
-0.28577104210853577,
0.9848064184188843,
-0.2438254952430725,
0.05544779822230339,
0.09530901908874512,
0.018746061250567436,
0.2497434765100479,
-0.08977996557950974,
-0.03635356202721596,
0.26789391040802,
-0.2469279021024704,
-0.6253839731216431,
-0.32741579413414,
0.3620285391807556,
-0.9144092798233032,
-0.3185453712940216,
0.078086718916893,
-0.8367041349411011,
-0.3477315902709961,
0.29542645812034607,
0.27386653423309326,
0.5752322673797607,
-0.07511680573225021,
0.9104323387145996,
0.5796251893043518,
0.011145206168293953,
0.4007214307785034,
0.6657217144966125,
-0.017747383564710617,
-0.6264796257019043,
0.6865365505218506,
0.273092120885849,
0.1240653544664383,
0.32585084438323975,
0.10627950727939606,
0.2644304037094116,
-1.005030870437622,
-0.5229600667953491,
-0.08634107559919357,
-0.7027438879013062,
-0.03086416982114315,
-0.5509437322616577,
-0.021730128675699234,
-0.21963001787662506,
-0.3776073157787323,
-0.8156607151031494,
-0.3357841372489929,
-0.10855402797460556,
-0.07238560914993286,
0.2328619360923767,
0.6271765828132629,
0.05573589727282524,
0.5117619037628174,
-0.7740500569343567,
-0.15423958003520966,
0.323940247297287,
0.14482338726520538,
-0.09589412808418274,
-0.5684682726860046,
-0.7544837594032288,
0.2859198749065399,
-0.1815413534641266,
-0.6598670482635498,
0.26627933979034424,
0.09194669872522354,
0.9606040120124817,
0.39972323179244995,
-0.0729081854224205,
0.8219212889671326,
-0.3627409338951111,
0.7318374514579773,
0.2538664638996124,
-0.7902033925056458,
0.2738959491252899,
-0.6984186172485352,
-0.0020220852456986904,
0.9096769094467163,
0.3152466416358948,
-0.37575864791870117,
-0.657269299030304,
-0.43983882665634155,
-0.9853413701057434,
0.6559123396873474,
0.2185276448726654,
0.3204866945743561,
0.2970748543739319,
0.3023937940597534,
0.36868202686309814,
0.1831483542919159,
-0.45081833004951477,
0.02127746492624283,
-0.09405896812677383,
-0.3306575417518616,
-0.16665999591350555,
-0.20703603327274323,
-0.2647852599620819,
-0.41971081495285034,
0.49701595306396484,
-0.06311920285224915,
-0.037853579968214035,
-0.28931015729904175,
-0.484154611825943,
-0.0850161761045456,
0.06556107848882675,
0.3901950716972351,
0.8419992923736572,
-0.2761654555797577,
-0.1679527461528778,
0.49763867259025574,
-0.46408727765083313,
0.009198665618896484,
0.010958408936858177,
-0.04479115083813667,
-0.1708034873008728,
0.45000994205474854,
0.8611441850662231,
0.7712920308113098,
-0.6444193720817566,
0.36843955516815186,
0.3514953553676605,
-0.46213802695274353,
-0.19682322442531586,
0.38105344772338867,
0.22956489026546478,
0.08009044080972672,
0.5996967554092407,
0.2584981918334961,
0.08001141995191574,
-0.4719381332397461,
0.017202103510499,
0.3568243086338043,
-0.14679351449012756,
-0.23636849224567413,
0.4823753237724304,
0.61800217628479,
-0.07224133610725403,
0.5529796481132507,
0.15076960623264313,
-0.40929707884788513,
0.5198511481285095,
-0.02002660185098648,
0.8035828471183777,
-0.33287420868873596,
-0.1781272143125534,
-0.10707079619169235,
0.3972409963607788,
-0.1689210832118988,
-0.0852392390370369,
-0.07336629927158356,
-0.7755370736122131,
-0.6984520554542542,
-0.29546883702278137,
-0.6622129082679749,
-0.018656698986887932,
-0.7317651510238647,
0.36623328924179077,
-0.27953341603279114,
0.17872987687587738,
-0.11547727882862091,
0.05876601114869118,
-0.7460530996322632,
0.3224025368690491,
0.33894407749176025,
1.0119379758834839,
-0.9082517623901367,
0.8549761772155762,
0.9837242960929871,
-0.13669921457767487,
-0.869636595249176,
-0.07606637477874756,
0.10103227943181992,
-0.8878999352455139,
0.7470110654830933,
0.29798510670661926,
0.09242507815361023,
0.17424923181533813,
-0.550952136516571,
-0.896796703338623,
1.308493733406067,
0.38792964816093445,
-0.4194805324077606,
-0.10299954563379288,
0.05163903906941414,
0.24171511828899384,
-0.35711434483528137,
0.4815560281276703,
0.4068894684314728,
0.3044712543487549,
-0.053798042237758636,
-1.064963936805725,
-0.3009941875934601,
-0.19807037711143494,
0.10799809545278549,
-0.1707213670015335,
-0.6227915287017822,
0.9083610773086548,
0.24037159979343414,
-0.018109358847141266,
0.13548734784126282,
0.7313256859779358,
0.36096733808517456,
0.2702212631702423,
0.6806629300117493,
0.7513487339019775,
0.7978919744491577,
0.0964263528585434,
0.8224695920944214,
-0.6409391760826111,
0.3237260580062866,
0.6435253024101257,
-0.10028036683797836,
0.8219074010848999,
0.40047815442085266,
-0.001798655022867024,
0.5363831520080566,
0.5634016394615173,
0.28178560733795166,
0.524573802947998,
-0.013794125989079475,
-0.10005244612693787,
-0.47404593229293823,
0.3936609625816345,
-0.5331588983535767,
0.39721107482910156,
0.26165804266929626,
0.07137581706047058,
-0.34051382541656494,
0.18490658700466156,
0.15117450058460236,
-0.09818863868713379,
-0.4138074219226837,
0.8175082206726074,
-0.12934157252311707,
-0.6390733122825623,
0.6091277599334717,
0.22073878347873688,
0.953026294708252,
-0.4023093283176422,
0.3532543480396271,
-0.27270951867103577,
0.2031388282775879,
-0.05828754976391792,
-0.6035323739051819,
0.19609525799751282,
0.025222448632121086,
-0.2602926194667816,
-0.27116769552230835,
0.5892090201377869,
-0.5097815990447998,
-0.5736909508705139,
0.10798106342554092,
0.41425588726997375,
0.27267134189605713,
-0.24452205002307892,
-0.9123738408088684,
-0.21388041973114014,
-0.16939981281757355,
-0.565696120262146,
0.4831622540950775,
0.6713996529579163,
0.10578653216362,
0.7671377658843994,
0.6329308748245239,
-0.10148559510707855,
0.38747239112854004,
-0.15146996080875397,
1.0951284170150757,
-0.5953757762908936,
-0.6093151569366455,
-0.6123311519622803,
0.9213219285011292,
-0.03620109334588051,
-0.3817862570285797,
0.8093186020851135,
0.5403075218200684,
1.0605194568634033,
-0.15427131950855255,
0.722678005695343,
0.15763695538043976,
0.685229480266571,
-0.8136693239212036,
0.5109264850616455,
-0.5117872357368469,
0.23601697385311127,
-0.3335796892642975,
-0.9272550344467163,
-0.13854742050170898,
0.4740793704986572,
-0.21468734741210938,
0.25546255707740784,
0.561358630657196,
0.8012147545814514,
-0.22550874948501587,
-0.18472634255886078,
0.27964603900909424,
0.04775940999388695,
0.2417767494916916,
0.6090278029441833,
0.9983224272727966,
-0.11602605134248734,
0.6352455615997314,
-0.47548356652259827,
-0.3310319483280182,
-0.6071654558181763,
-1.13448965549469,
-1.0132638216018677,
-0.26499655842781067,
-0.30498501658439636,
0.18132533133029938,
-0.01931309886276722,
0.8649390339851379,
1.2734105587005615,
-0.7266187071800232,
-0.459945946931839,
-0.30721819400787354,
-0.3293883204460144,
-0.14019151031970978,
-0.1708424836397171,
-0.14224860072135925,
-0.46402421593666077,
-0.572681725025177,
0.7272406816482544,
0.2448873370885849,
-0.18855899572372437,
-0.45747971534729004,
-0.414474219083786,
0.07776311784982681,
0.06336052715778351,
0.343273401260376,
0.05088222026824951,
-0.6717851758003235,
-0.08745013922452927,
0.0025031445547938347,
-0.02585875801742077,
-0.20955973863601685,
0.7939332127571106,
-0.5368209481239319,
0.45012277364730835,
0.6902145147323608,
0.8562021851539612,
0.35823214054107666,
0.06579170376062393,
0.7319874167442322,
-0.7835283875465393,
0.33160850405693054,
0.1307641565799713,
0.30643242597579956,
0.3379940092563629,
-0.18330131471157074,
0.48100903630256653,
0.5988731980323792,
-0.5176464319229126,
-1.0538597106933594,
-0.08961864560842514,
-0.9774120450019836,
-0.47831642627716064,
1.055038571357727,
0.008791984058916569,
0.17780041694641113,
-0.29469430446624756,
-0.45782119035720825,
-0.03766991198062897,
-0.23701703548431396,
0.6828126907348633,
1.0312238931655884,
0.17968477308750153,
-0.11393681168556213,
-0.8004927635192871,
0.07728368788957596,
0.64021897315979,
-0.633751630783081,
0.060882292687892914,
0.43728718161582947,
0.5792483687400818,
0.0562141090631485,
0.6109766960144043,
0.0983869880437851,
0.22217196226119995,
0.05778040736913681,
0.2543722689151764,
-0.48976898193359375,
-0.4503580927848816,
-0.2204785943031311,
-0.07351020723581314,
0.014678091742098331,
0.0843905583024025
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00969v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00969v1
|
Using RL to Identify Divisive Perspectives Improves LLMs Abilities to Identify Communities on Social Media
| 2024-06-03T03:45:31 | 2024-06-03T03:45:31 |
Nikhil Mehta, Dan Goldwasser
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The large scale usage of social media, combined with its significant impact,
has made it increasingly important to understand it. In particular, identifying
user communities, can be helpful for many downstream tasks. However,
particularly when models are trained on past data and tested on future, doing
this is difficult.
In this paper, we hypothesize to take advantage of Large Language Models
(LLMs), to better identify user communities. Due to the fact that many LLMs,
such as ChatGPT, are fixed and must be treated as black-boxes, we propose an
approach to better prompt them, by training a smaller LLM to do this. We devise
strategies to train this smaller model, showing how it can improve the larger
LLMs ability to detect communities. Experimental results show improvements on
Reddit and Twitter data, on the tasks of community detection, bot detection,
and news media profiling.
|
[
-0.795721173286438,
-0.7236526608467102,
0.7108650803565979,
-0.10766381770372391,
-0.5332342982292175,
0.6997717022895813,
-0.4363281726837158,
-0.2775990664958954,
0.4808955490589142,
0.25137272477149963,
-0.7631319165229797,
-0.3896635174751282,
-0.7931066155433655,
0.1137482225894928,
-0.4644841253757477,
0.7243245244026184,
0.17489446699619293,
-0.1949264109134674,
0.0561458021402359,
-0.23597152531147003,
-0.25383758544921875,
-0.5982636213302612,
-0.6470499038696289,
-0.2514794170856476,
1.0220085382461548,
0.4946109652519226,
0.4505254328250885,
0.439765602350235,
0.3576411008834839,
0.32304468750953674,
-0.35346245765686035,
0.3341258466243744,
-0.7657050490379333,
-0.15562056005001068,
-0.18238763511180878,
-0.3180360198020935,
0.02827761135995388,
0.10908053815364838,
0.41898536682128906,
0.6295661926269531,
-0.09461748600006104,
0.3292332887649536,
0.16230760514736176,
0.8359824419021606,
-0.2814738154411316,
-0.06311608105897903,
-0.8287169337272644,
0.021639885380864143,
-0.1394738405942917,
-0.0726298838853836,
-0.4970242381095886,
-0.4245050549507141,
-0.03004937805235386,
-0.20101317763328552,
0.44285792112350464,
0.0056459964253008366,
0.49961525201797485,
-0.03104112111032009,
-0.34730264544487,
-0.1916368007659912,
-0.7345578074455261,
0.8220446705818176,
-0.824317455291748,
0.3106920123100281,
-0.00028075891896151006,
0.3796848952770233,
-0.24343198537826538,
-0.3025253117084503,
-0.7588222622871399,
0.25942370295524597,
-0.2446875125169754,
-0.2268192619085312,
-0.18825559318065643,
-0.29223349690437317,
0.2353406399488449,
0.255614310503006,
-0.4384010434150696,
0.22932450473308563,
-0.6211202144622803,
-0.24540551006793976,
0.5915488600730896,
0.10013148933649063,
0.13102053105831146,
-0.34608739614486694,
-0.31453752517700195,
0.2792559862136841,
-0.74913489818573,
-0.14165711402893066,
0.3433125913143158,
0.5376960635185242,
-0.10600807517766953,
0.4353792071342468,
-0.12396026402711868,
0.628734290599823,
0.16461825370788574,
-0.4075024127960205,
0.280536413192749,
-0.03658534586429596,
-0.04215981066226959,
-0.43774956464767456,
0.6102587580680847,
0.3937351107597351,
0.4220125079154968,
0.1970764398574829,
-0.2732325494289398,
-0.07969758659601212,
0.19691680371761322,
-0.6720349788665771,
-0.23371849954128265,
0.10320352762937546,
-0.6338589191436768,
-0.3319263756275177,
0.2646096646785736,
-0.7370789647102356,
-1.0357906818389893,
-0.4424625337123871,
-0.06680402904748917,
-0.013118172064423561,
-0.8637087345123291,
-0.09111183881759644,
-0.1898203343153,
0.19052128493785858,
0.7149339318275452,
-0.7085270881652832,
0.05583171918988228,
0.931976318359375,
1.0623363256454468,
-0.2169966995716095,
-0.06133689731359482,
-0.5062713027000427,
-0.2213764786720276,
-0.1795990765094757,
0.7526097893714905,
-0.6167954206466675,
-0.08027897775173187,
0.39629948139190674,
-0.02914292737841606,
0.18197406828403473,
-0.841481626033783,
-0.1814330369234085,
-0.9413275718688965,
-0.05684594064950943,
-0.5801823735237122,
-0.25923505425453186,
-0.11917470395565033,
0.39221909642219543,
-0.6973938941955566,
0.7872992157936096,
0.04814434424042702,
-0.7851477861404419,
0.3821696937084198,
-0.3488696217536926,
-0.40032124519348145,
0.18900184333324432,
-0.2590258717536926,
-0.36276760697364807,
0.3246791660785675,
0.3578599691390991,
0.6385051012039185,
0.24335458874702454,
0.11954411119222641,
-0.7164580225944519,
-0.028436731547117233,
0.4172092378139496,
-0.3164308965206146,
0.6710647344589233,
0.24692043662071228,
0.05732668936252594,
0.01531306654214859,
-0.3556012511253357,
-0.4819158613681793,
0.08179456740617752,
-0.5056759119033813,
-0.5417194962501526,
0.23468860983848572,
-0.06594697386026382,
0.3711298108100891,
0.0864146277308464,
-0.5591283440589905,
0.13187889754772186,
-0.27781766653060913,
0.7710462212562561,
0.9172022342681885,
0.1723761111497879,
0.33664336800575256,
-0.04706425219774246,
0.4944237470626831,
0.3788221478462219,
0.15647059679031372,
0.13995957374572754,
-0.5417734980583191,
-0.8685302138328552,
-0.3967755138874054,
0.1950564831495285,
0.17112036049365997,
-1.0023467540740967,
0.40503591299057007,
-0.10950187593698502,
-0.4143069386482239,
-0.2792552411556244,
0.5969354510307312,
-0.07533000409603119,
0.28178513050079346,
0.05500734969973564,
-0.3208487629890442,
-0.5796688795089722,
-0.7675528526306152,
-0.07667183130979538,
-0.2051575779914856,
-0.03968027979135513,
0.280205100774765,
0.4197668135166168,
-0.25983375310897827,
1.0907667875289917,
-0.5355114936828613,
-0.14773575961589813,
-0.6602383852005005,
-0.0010479624615982175,
0.2757062017917633,
-0.2815355062484741,
0.1070304587483406,
-1.1426974534988403,
-0.8151614665985107,
0.020523792132735252,
-0.6044299602508545,
-0.03872543200850487,
0.05505561828613281,
0.09374982863664627,
0.028132300823926926,
0.5974661111831665,
-0.3808947801589966,
0.3165041506290436,
0.5599210858345032,
-0.11950451880693436,
-0.03548411279916763,
0.1990107297897339,
-0.009822589345276356,
-1.0615365505218506,
-0.44765299558639526,
0.4761326313018799,
-0.6772058010101318,
-0.691250205039978,
-0.1164812371134758,
0.06546032428741455,
-0.010905747301876545,
-0.623647153377533,
0.3742128014564514,
-0.6587027907371521,
-0.12724176049232483,
-0.4380455017089844,
0.5693590044975281,
-0.2532467246055603,
0.4059077501296997,
0.21944016218185425,
0.5549536943435669,
0.22953569889068604,
-0.240594744682312,
0.20410367846488953,
-0.11351826786994934,
-0.45772790908813477,
0.2085658311843872,
-0.25305119156837463,
0.4109680950641632,
-0.3769981563091278,
0.37787365913391113,
-1.3991435766220093,
-0.207545667886734,
0.08589091897010803,
-0.4213002026081085,
0.11434510350227356,
-0.4125104546546936,
-0.6360664963722229,
-0.6634095311164856,
-0.43209749460220337,
0.4035613238811493,
0.5065478086471558,
-0.8516009449958801,
0.646906316280365,
0.6805402636528015,
-0.027114246040582657,
-0.4491928815841675,
-0.4516263008117676,
-0.07159768044948578,
-0.6361286044120789,
-0.42449116706848145,
-0.315356582403183,
0.13340890407562256,
-0.4260720908641815,
-0.08847899734973907,
0.18451015651226044,
0.017391523346304893,
0.12210994958877563,
0.18569259345531464,
0.21963855624198914,
-0.10671641677618027,
0.14900396764278412,
-0.23984836041927338,
-0.08935336768627167,
-0.2681589424610138,
0.0666583999991417,
0.8102225661277771,
-0.034298691898584366,
-0.393242746591568,
-0.27278777956962585,
0.3656693398952484,
0.5667662024497986,
-0.3559819757938385,
0.7406848669052124,
0.36991769075393677,
-0.28288301825523376,
-0.5342963933944702,
-0.7589510083198547,
-0.1956969052553177,
-0.560894787311554,
0.411022424697876,
0.19752348959445953,
-1.4274890422821045,
0.5334827303886414,
-0.1242247074842453,
0.06290686130523682,
0.13193076848983765,
0.9311777949333191,
-0.010069689713418484,
0.6965904235839844,
0.883108377456665,
-0.6382123827934265,
0.647663950920105,
0.14884738624095917,
0.4541250169277191,
-0.6140152215957642,
0.13869325816631317,
-0.26956942677497864,
-0.3760662078857422,
-0.3938063383102417,
-0.6199201345443726,
0.33221328258514404,
-0.1430138647556305,
0.15372730791568756,
0.2984808683395386,
-0.5790349245071411,
0.7274113893508911,
0.22578981518745422,
0.24959464371204376,
0.4259510338306427,
0.0542459599673748,
0.5087106227874756,
-0.1565096527338028,
-0.6721104383468628,
-0.5954359173774719,
0.8439899682998657,
0.8412162661552429,
0.7855615615844727,
0.35639438033103943,
1.0095930099487305,
0.6041529774665833,
0.9030697345733643,
-0.9279720783233643,
0.5266660451889038,
-0.18137183785438538,
-0.6904525756835938,
-0.25838926434516907,
-0.26212701201438904,
-0.610398530960083,
0.2589337229728699,
0.03724991902709007,
-0.667095422744751,
0.308745801448822,
0.07626169174909592,
-0.6112169623374939,
0.31603696942329407,
-0.8127878308296204,
0.3957584500312805,
0.173751562833786,
-0.02564597688615322,
-0.2941792905330658,
-0.3010724186897278,
0.24710559844970703,
-0.375510573387146,
0.7126230001449585,
-0.08499346673488617,
0.039964158087968826,
0.6631354689598083,
-0.3366203308105469,
1.5606863498687744,
-0.3624842166900635,
-0.07417769730091095,
0.4371357858181,
-0.2519931495189667,
0.4607026278972626,
0.25425997376441956,
0.2020827978849411,
0.13130439817905426,
-0.38156524300575256,
-0.27187642455101013,
-0.5290476679801941,
0.7392750382423401,
-0.9098270535469055,
-0.8913623094558716,
-0.08996198326349258,
-0.2851656973361969,
-0.2317882627248764,
-0.031326837837696075,
-0.17619076371192932,
0.32654306292533875,
-0.04447757825255394,
0.27997228503227234,
0.9119887948036194,
-0.06760572642087936,
0.4949692487716675,
0.6168433427810669,
-0.530310332775116,
-0.21359023451805115,
0.5716006755828857,
0.12263929098844528,
0.4681105613708496,
0.160817489027977,
0.08398985117673874,
-0.30603429675102234,
-0.5316357612609863,
-0.39079543948173523,
0.41868987679481506,
-0.8356742858886719,
-0.24781161546707153,
-0.38966429233551025,
-0.21008552610874176,
-0.24728913605213165,
-0.10272026807069778,
-0.26025497913360596,
-0.012323793955147266,
-0.1646103411912918,
-0.24029475450515747,
0.3863009512424469,
0.9874019026756287,
-0.04521729424595833,
0.33306846022605896,
-0.45183032751083374,
0.4247235655784607,
0.530315101146698,
0.1250676065683365,
0.3310909569263458,
-0.663266122341156,
-0.21871618926525116,
-0.13463716208934784,
-0.0026574088260531425,
-0.9353476166725159,
0.18702897429466248,
-0.0877782478928566,
0.43891507387161255,
0.39020201563835144,
0.03231833875179291,
0.5611609816551208,
-0.6468133330345154,
0.45353445410728455,
0.04813739284873009,
-0.47937071323394775,
0.4820675551891327,
-0.20313386619091034,
-0.032601241022348404,
0.7047059535980225,
0.5513017177581787,
-0.6198362708091736,
-0.6023768186569214,
-0.30137765407562256,
-0.5095028877258301,
0.4527326226234436,
-0.06777974963188171,
0.6464651226997375,
-0.16613583266735077,
0.4827859103679657,
-0.011789720505475998,
0.20955774188041687,
-1.1507648229599,
-0.1768568456172943,
0.02595663070678711,
-0.14066046476364136,
-0.0718761458992958,
-0.38449645042419434,
-0.3225547969341278,
-0.39773473143577576,
0.4286290407180786,
-0.11395663022994995,
-0.07024987787008286,
0.069814033806324,
0.06407234817743301,
-0.3005763292312622,
0.14773344993591309,
0.2564118504524231,
0.918470561504364,
-0.014101448468863964,
0.2568069100379944,
0.049834635108709335,
-0.2857986390590668,
0.05517396703362465,
-0.20161403715610504,
-0.12891720235347748,
0.08958311378955841,
0.4507247805595398,
0.371537446975708,
-0.3008592128753662,
-0.5181947350502014,
0.7843968272209167,
-0.051732975989580154,
-0.23513363301753998,
-0.37960225343704224,
0.062136631458997726,
0.4912736117839813,
0.6901834011077881,
0.49995023012161255,
-0.13689292967319489,
-0.17359302937984467,
-0.8158201575279236,
0.24456429481506348,
0.5300224423408508,
-0.5951060652732849,
-0.08360137790441513,
0.13093268871307373,
0.3739384710788727,
-0.5806536674499512,
0.39456993341445923,
-0.155423104763031,
-0.884454071521759,
0.5412790775299072,
0.2512916028499603,
0.7777108550071716,
0.044067103415727615,
0.3316628932952881,
0.2188558727502823,
0.4320301115512848,
0.026018846780061722,
-0.2201789766550064,
0.020610099658370018,
-1.0952423810958862,
-0.46832093596458435,
-0.7593874931335449,
-0.18859460949897766,
0.2837783694267273,
-0.5863186717033386,
0.4305657744407654,
-0.7002983689308167,
-0.03723666071891785,
0.39950403571128845,
0.0018734955228865147,
-0.41290047764778137,
-0.027890658006072044,
0.5459424257278442,
0.9549115300178528,
-1.4711796045303345,
1.0854589939117432,
0.6246533393859863,
-0.1549483835697174,
-0.9674779772758484,
0.26039209961891174,
0.41439104080200195,
-0.7883362174034119,
0.45463621616363525,
0.36779099702835083,
-0.029669785872101784,
-0.11749296635389328,
-0.7072156071662903,
-0.4109753668308258,
0.955454409122467,
-0.1870812475681305,
-1.0501437187194824,
0.35760298371315,
0.15975312888622284,
0.8476700186729431,
-0.6125842332839966,
-0.060553643852472305,
0.2845292091369629,
0.231121227145195,
0.1558661013841629,
-0.607029914855957,
0.15016286075115204,
-0.025606613606214523,
0.1017952710390091,
0.3017325699329376,
-0.7634207606315613,
0.8284503817558289,
-0.013580556027591228,
-0.20781764388084412,
-0.4566499590873718,
0.7983412742614746,
0.5266398787498474,
0.3748813569545746,
1.042396903038025,
0.12240396440029144,
0.6386566758155823,
0.2078343629837036,
0.5792086124420166,
0.1733449548482895,
0.7041745781898499,
0.7406806945800781,
-0.377053827047348,
1.0845073461532593,
0.7032610774040222,
-0.2579442262649536,
0.5206025242805481,
0.775267481803894,
-0.10626117140054703,
0.7875164151191711,
0.27546319365501404,
-0.4120408296585083,
-0.5747074484825134,
0.1394936442375183,
-0.19992806017398834,
-0.03932235389947891,
0.36236920952796936,
-0.426583468914032,
-0.3714373707771301,
0.13776850700378418,
0.17471431195735931,
0.47138509154319763,
-0.3330748379230499,
0.8917588591575623,
0.3092452883720398,
-0.5087264180183411,
0.37876802682876587,
-0.003666248405352235,
0.9169610738754272,
-0.28831079602241516,
0.050307128578424454,
-0.5532987117767334,
0.30133503675460815,
-0.3450661897659302,
-0.8006531000137329,
0.31169968843460083,
0.08759672194719315,
-0.2918859124183655,
-0.0187908373773098,
0.947146475315094,
-0.31279948353767395,
-0.7382625341415405,
0.5342178344726562,
0.7173669934272766,
0.009503141045570374,
-0.12342226505279541,
-0.5971066951751709,
0.17394250631332397,
0.4240923225879669,
-0.29288190603256226,
0.43011680245399475,
0.7318692207336426,
-0.22125780582427979,
0.5336380004882812,
0.5555875301361084,
-0.026699146255850792,
-0.1524306982755661,
0.2193303406238556,
1.4055286645889282,
-0.6232471466064453,
-0.1955133080482483,
-1.2216986417770386,
0.3575059473514557,
-0.27678990364074707,
-0.08563033491373062,
0.7458980679512024,
0.4841688871383667,
0.9038244485855103,
0.12221183627843857,
1.031238079071045,
-0.2600286602973938,
1.0995945930480957,
-0.2261696606874466,
0.5517885684967041,
-0.6425890922546387,
0.5780001282691956,
-0.106425940990448,
-0.6671802401542664,
-0.1764647364616394,
0.4493788182735443,
-0.5977027416229248,
-0.05880714952945709,
0.30646803975105286,
1.1263686418533325,
-0.3556022644042969,
-0.0407402329146862,
0.25695571303367615,
0.15977133810520172,
0.5313882827758789,
0.454950213432312,
1.288090705871582,
0.12222486734390259,
0.47135600447654724,
-0.31547635793685913,
-0.511965274810791,
-0.2877005636692047,
-0.7022088170051575,
-1.5827996730804443,
-0.49420222640037537,
-0.2825571298599243,
-0.44144847989082336,
-0.1402665376663208,
0.8102635145187378,
0.7312442660331726,
-0.7132573127746582,
-0.1206088662147522,
0.3099474608898163,
0.27996912598609924,
0.22068238258361816,
-0.1671319603919983,
-0.04288438335061073,
-0.04388496279716492,
-0.46011656522750854,
0.09600663930177689,
0.2941308915615082,
-0.3601490557193756,
-0.8820258975028992,
-0.1168174296617508,
-0.3351469933986664,
0.043821047991514206,
0.7698851823806763,
0.25554072856903076,
-0.8835638165473938,
-0.6987993717193604,
-0.03524653986096382,
-0.09426629543304443,
0.2641688287258148,
0.8615977168083191,
-0.5282349586486816,
0.16561520099639893,
0.3339778780937195,
0.5138389468193054,
0.5367763638496399,
0.39825859665870667,
0.288492888212204,
-0.8666481971740723,
0.30256253480911255,
0.03801025077700615,
0.2362174093723297,
0.5924335718154907,
-0.3923506736755371,
0.3321722447872162,
0.28410330414772034,
-0.4844147861003876,
-0.6433696150779724,
0.22752423584461212,
-1.026206135749817,
-0.4888640344142914,
1.6418226957321167,
-0.03454558551311493,
-0.30056896805763245,
-0.556562602519989,
-0.2225630283355713,
-0.13504105806350708,
-0.461680144071579,
0.9400399327278137,
0.9871352910995483,
0.1646726131439209,
-0.48231005668640137,
-0.716336190700531,
0.30014654994010925,
0.028280315920710564,
-0.6359165906906128,
0.23649056255817413,
0.4815819561481476,
0.49183520674705505,
0.2658505141735077,
0.9736078381538391,
0.029551321640610695,
-0.11149834841489792,
-0.5211426615715027,
-0.29928967356681824,
0.17881806194782257,
-0.27789485454559326,
-0.29311904311180115,
0.25775882601737976,
0.276810884475708,
-0.054383955895900726
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.06562v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.06562v1
|
Achieving Sparse Activation in Small Language Models
| 2024-06-03T03:21:49 | 2024-06-03T03:21:49 |
Jifeng Song, Kai Huang, Xiangyu Yin, Boyuan Yang, Wei Gao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Sparse activation, which selectively activates only an input-dependent set of
neurons in inference, is a useful technique to reduce the computing cost of
Large Language Models (LLMs) without retraining or adaptation efforts. However,
whether it can be applied to the recently emerging Small Language Models (SLMs)
remains questionable, because SLMs are generally less over-parameterized than
LLMs. In this paper, we aim to achieve sparse activation in SLMs. We first show
that the existing sparse activation schemes in LLMs that build on neurons'
output magnitudes cannot be applied to SLMs, and activating neurons based on
their attribution scores is a better alternative. Further, we demonstrated and
quantified the large errors of existing attribution metrics when being used for
sparse activation, due to the interdependency among attribution scores of
neurons across different layers. Based on these observations, we proposed a new
attribution metric that can provably correct such errors and achieve precise
sparse activation. Experiments over multiple popular SLMs and datasets show
that our approach can achieve 80% sparsification ratio with <5% model accuracy
loss, comparable to the sparse activation achieved in LLMs. The source code is
available at: https://github.com/pittisl/Sparse-Activation.
|
[
0.0009681455558165908,
-0.6677631139755249,
0.6155049204826355,
0.4204414188861847,
-0.27659669518470764,
-0.1092146709561348,
-0.5867236256599426,
-0.2979600727558136,
0.4229755401611328,
-0.22757889330387115,
-0.3947989344596863,
-0.047750696539878845,
-0.511117160320282,
-0.10706755518913269,
-0.2545067369937897,
0.5635377168655396,
0.06554380059242249,
0.06494306772947311,
-0.20141297578811646,
-0.2391802966594696,
-0.2866419553756714,
-0.16586387157440186,
-0.8523902893066406,
-0.43081411719322205,
0.8236714601516724,
0.2720722258090973,
0.41454261541366577,
0.4695846438407898,
-0.04371444135904312,
0.33021336793899536,
-0.22444182634353638,
0.2121986299753189,
-0.6878225803375244,
-0.35028547048568726,
0.16477200388908386,
-0.2745702266693115,
-0.41984981298446655,
0.03071216121315956,
1.0559582710266113,
1.1421295404434204,
-0.18426667153835297,
0.24026936292648315,
0.6065969467163086,
0.20109783113002777,
-0.7426053285598755,
0.1620187908411026,
-1.0341156721115112,
-0.2860303819179535,
0.16701103746891022,
-0.15249839425086975,
-0.6281026005744934,
-0.24318508803844452,
-0.3217483460903168,
-0.373825341463089,
0.09751147031784058,
-0.16038179397583008,
0.6459434032440186,
0.38340112566947937,
0.08441964536905289,
-0.0855037048459053,
-0.5300245881080627,
1.128261923789978,
-0.5518631339073181,
0.26388317346572876,
0.46979451179504395,
-0.25060132145881653,
-0.04988453537225723,
-0.5123597979545593,
-0.202682763338089,
-0.49634718894958496,
-0.41519632935523987,
-0.3161107301712036,
-0.3024633824825287,
0.02815907448530197,
0.4246743619441986,
-0.04001074656844139,
-0.3533572554588318,
0.27855372428894043,
-0.2270488291978836,
0.05467170849442482,
0.2810792028903961,
0.1095859482884407,
0.006905763875693083,
-0.14142468571662903,
-0.24505515396595,
0.29934555292129517,
-0.8605185151100159,
-0.02985941804945469,
0.2923906445503235,
0.6892919540405273,
-0.1825806349515915,
0.498144268989563,
0.10392502695322037,
0.6092966198921204,
0.24883224070072174,
0.14398959279060364,
0.21687021851539612,
-0.2907693088054657,
-0.25045064091682434,
0.011002523824572563,
0.7842666506767273,
-0.15546363592147827,
-0.03281395882368088,
-0.22012005746364594,
-0.6603884696960449,
-0.10234659165143967,
0.3300333619117737,
-0.7265268564224243,
0.11847061663866043,
0.09412944316864014,
-0.46317464113235474,
-0.3287529945373535,
-0.4082508087158203,
-0.5812515616416931,
-0.3232625424861908,
-0.007420544978231192,
0.7469919323921204,
-0.15372169017791748,
-0.24885253608226776,
0.0513860285282135,
0.3307787775993347,
0.05221622437238693,
0.31446659564971924,
-1.2472164630889893,
0.651151180267334,
0.327729195356369,
1.0731149911880493,
-0.18216267228126526,
-0.40307149291038513,
-0.5901920199394226,
-0.16087606549263,
-0.48844724893569946,
0.7203999757766724,
-0.23403605818748474,
0.10973860323429108,
0.02968708612024784,
-0.016186390072107315,
-0.3426538407802582,
-0.578681468963623,
0.22296258807182312,
-0.4933536648750305,
-0.28841885924339294,
-0.036352913826704025,
-0.12468838691711426,
0.1585843712091446,
0.1021411120891571,
-0.8188981413841248,
1.0314841270446777,
0.24163639545440674,
-0.3565683662891388,
0.4150644838809967,
-0.4170970618724823,
-0.35675594210624695,
0.14447206258773804,
-0.24193653464317322,
-0.35139819979667664,
0.5654565691947937,
-0.09192120283842087,
0.38126295804977417,
-0.3146008551120758,
0.10089917480945587,
-0.2957143485546112,
-0.683116614818573,
0.3327447474002838,
-0.42892345786094666,
0.8553193807601929,
-0.08036529272794724,
-0.25166764855384827,
0.17811302840709686,
-0.6488129496574402,
0.21526655554771423,
0.27688443660736084,
-0.36292850971221924,
-0.4065859615802765,
0.13064876198768616,
-0.07090132683515549,
-0.1275351494550705,
0.12818382680416107,
-0.3899781107902527,
0.03786095231771469,
-0.6473423838615417,
0.4728662073612213,
0.59340500831604,
0.03771878033876419,
0.9389849901199341,
-0.1863720864057541,
0.33909720182418823,
-0.2988556921482086,
-0.28860047459602356,
0.26595500111579895,
-0.42492976784706116,
-0.7553533315658569,
-0.7145993113517761,
0.6153777837753296,
0.18796280026435852,
-0.5836486220359802,
0.54062819480896,
-0.5052356123924255,
-0.33623987436294556,
-0.49914929270744324,
0.37881162762641907,
0.237753763794899,
0.1170467734336853,
0.17620070278644562,
-0.28036248683929443,
-0.40078893303871155,
-0.5326253771781921,
-0.2019370198249817,
-0.11860866099596024,
-0.08367850631475449,
0.29862406849861145,
0.35175594687461853,
0.10353758931159973,
0.8407158255577087,
-0.2700972855091095,
-0.39637699723243713,
-0.5034192204475403,
0.24889960885047913,
0.15782839059829712,
0.7705058455467224,
0.4075191915035248,
-0.4120379686355591,
-0.44586053490638733,
-0.16463683545589447,
-0.3105684518814087,
-0.2287692278623581,
-0.38349708914756775,
0.32945486903190613,
-0.13665315508842468,
0.5302467942237854,
-0.8068757653236389,
0.3688579499721527,
0.3845500648021698,
0.21854104101657867,
0.2669156491756439,
-0.16715581715106964,
-0.06833512336015701,
-0.45079198479652405,
0.07282577455043793,
0.10714812576770782,
-0.294310986995697,
-0.8958779573440552,
-0.16545124351978302,
0.14972130954265594,
-0.24079878628253937,
-0.5106325149536133,
0.8737536072731018,
-0.5449392795562744,
-0.300106018781662,
-0.3711702227592468,
0.028064951300621033,
-0.28395646810531616,
0.9552314877510071,
-0.015874724835157394,
0.6975781321525574,
0.382005900144577,
-0.2715875208377838,
0.20670412480831146,
-0.08005882054567337,
-0.6100447773933411,
-0.16907958686351776,
-0.8887078166007996,
-0.19920893013477325,
0.007819438353180885,
-0.06372030079364777,
-1.21102774143219,
-0.2779778838157654,
0.44064778089523315,
-0.42651858925819397,
0.5218678712844849,
-0.35287877917289734,
-0.5868115425109863,
0.10625976324081421,
-0.40731632709503174,
0.7835951447486877,
0.5935758948326111,
-0.558987557888031,
0.6632686257362366,
0.26600930094718933,
-0.09996756166219711,
-0.36182212829589844,
-0.8601638078689575,
-0.16682720184326172,
-0.2636658549308777,
-0.38532063364982605,
0.1584617644548416,
0.10817384719848633,
-0.19644495844841003,
0.049126625061035156,
0.010293732397258282,
-0.036005157977342606,
0.2434665858745575,
0.14010661840438843,
0.06991998851299286,
-0.42695891857147217,
-0.08171192556619644,
0.07130905240774155,
-0.3536166846752167,
-0.1715368926525116,
-0.1567487120628357,
0.6024300456047058,
-0.03680408373475075,
-0.6324838399887085,
-0.4192372262477875,
0.3859586715698242,
0.3510192036628723,
0.09051232039928436,
0.8646752834320068,
0.31818652153015137,
-0.8613580465316772,
-0.4625539481639862,
-0.36044320464134216,
-0.4243505597114563,
-0.4858664572238922,
0.5032193064689636,
-0.3240552246570587,
-0.7347598075866699,
0.487984299659729,
-0.2285011261701584,
-0.18371973931789398,
0.29553043842315674,
0.839005708694458,
0.17986609041690826,
1.1973365545272827,
0.5591105818748474,
0.0030653823632746935,
0.6695524454116821,
-0.1840287446975708,
0.17273835837841034,
-0.6997789740562439,
0.1296456754207611,
-0.5021557211875916,
-0.342949241399765,
-0.10244723409414291,
-0.5581567883491516,
0.3078056871891022,
0.07690275460481644,
0.08483977615833282,
0.347704142332077,
-0.23481696844100952,
0.46104323863983154,
0.2453547567129135,
0.2539520859718323,
-0.10194660723209381,
0.585668683052063,
-0.003399861976504326,
-0.22759976983070374,
-1.0141246318817139,
-0.2747620642185211,
0.5509656667709351,
0.5057611465454102,
1.1997261047363281,
0.014449488371610641,
0.5153297185897827,
0.31827616691589355,
0.3639155626296997,
-1.0485024452209473,
0.5616920590400696,
-0.11803461611270905,
-0.3047797679901123,
-0.5398412942886353,
-0.40224596858024597,
-0.9084334969520569,
0.21337008476257324,
-0.2608160376548767,
-0.9756709933280945,
0.5735030770301819,
0.13659493625164032,
-0.7534511685371399,
-0.06422971934080124,
-1.0888700485229492,
1.1286276578903198,
-0.04188183322548866,
-0.7300137877464294,
-0.2987518608570099,
-0.1300697773694992,
0.32931414246559143,
-0.3794229030609131,
0.08696155995130539,
-0.0890224277973175,
-0.41792285442352295,
0.5417213439941406,
-0.383783757686615,
1.3995018005371094,
-0.2364218384027481,
-0.1445149928331375,
0.35374319553375244,
0.02133060060441494,
0.7228232026100159,
-0.03168719634413719,
-0.20500017702579498,
0.11241700500249863,
-0.45660898089408875,
-0.37817826867103577,
-0.6699374914169312,
0.9545745849609375,
-0.705040693283081,
-0.3171580135822296,
-0.2538473904132843,
-0.6117494106292725,
-0.2267514169216156,
0.11616433411836624,
-0.06249312311410904,
0.44113242626190186,
-0.046281564980745316,
0.02937442623078823,
0.629040539264679,
0.05055968090891838,
0.12160800397396088,
0.2952326238155365,
0.13066135346889496,
-0.3299456238746643,
1.385006308555603,
0.03861750662326813,
0.5386999249458313,
-0.0502200648188591,
-0.014780737459659576,
-0.17883162200450897,
-0.7748022675514221,
-0.49715742468833923,
0.40687429904937744,
-0.7384579181671143,
-0.25806593894958496,
-0.5879683494567871,
-0.3524118959903717,
-0.23451189696788788,
-0.22813478112220764,
-0.40203535556793213,
-0.43265941739082336,
-0.659641444683075,
0.2025572508573532,
-0.058479905128479004,
0.45608946681022644,
-0.3114897310733795,
0.5915862917900085,
-0.43904685974121094,
0.2589516341686249,
0.396287739276886,
0.25587233901023865,
0.232073575258255,
-0.8332950472831726,
-0.48813754320144653,
0.04579761251807213,
0.15506744384765625,
-0.8235521912574768,
0.33834871649742126,
0.46684545278549194,
0.6068593263626099,
0.29460424184799194,
-0.3219015300273895,
0.8517516851425171,
-0.6099890470504761,
0.5726213455200195,
0.32365816831588745,
-0.9266189932823181,
0.18515737354755402,
-0.021931570023298264,
0.07713305950164795,
0.4560370445251465,
0.37957659363746643,
-0.0762404203414917,
-0.43941062688827515,
-0.6502509713172913,
-0.6859949827194214,
1.013601303100586,
-0.10321217775344849,
0.4444243013858795,
0.08303330838680267,
0.44281530380249023,
-0.13325616717338562,
0.015374078415334225,
-1.1053824424743652,
-0.08108281344175339,
0.1938161551952362,
-0.3233993351459503,
-0.1253318041563034,
-0.6939402222633362,
-0.1243513897061348,
-0.22517076134681702,
0.697944164276123,
-0.3796370029449463,
0.4085824191570282,
-0.2724171280860901,
-0.2566277086734772,
-0.6262136697769165,
0.04212300479412079,
0.5218763947486877,
0.5060199499130249,
-0.08469747006893158,
0.34504714608192444,
0.6485466361045837,
-0.3314259946346283,
0.3227241635322571,
0.00470242602750659,
-0.41493502259254456,
0.09201772511005402,
0.3639727234840393,
0.7342345118522644,
0.5384218096733093,
-0.490989089012146,
0.801552414894104,
-0.022184504196047783,
-0.20924440026283264,
-0.021984832361340523,
0.13569925725460052,
-0.003232072340324521,
0.159131720662117,
0.23049107193946838,
0.24636486172676086,
-0.23687370121479034,
-0.2391481101512909,
0.1661624163389206,
0.7297552824020386,
-0.6860737204551697,
-0.24251095950603485,
0.5490649342536926,
-0.03603183850646019,
-0.048756103962659836,
0.2222532033920288,
-0.3967241048812866,
-0.30831894278526306,
0.33825546503067017,
0.7318291664123535,
0.86507648229599,
-0.005141557659953833,
-0.12154693156480789,
0.5875605344772339,
0.6500744223594666,
-0.24423237144947052,
0.10037250071763992,
-0.14508803188800812,
-0.8352481126785278,
-0.8141026496887207,
-0.7627503275871277,
0.10452648252248764,
0.21655960381031036,
-0.19482749700546265,
0.27608034014701843,
-0.6004546880722046,
-0.09525680541992188,
0.0023948056623339653,
0.0337420329451561,
-0.09129103273153305,
-0.016161927953362465,
0.1974390149116516,
0.8987244963645935,
-1.2576719522476196,
0.9935281276702881,
0.5656149983406067,
-0.39641350507736206,
-0.6532392501831055,
-0.09078695625066757,
-0.0850151851773262,
-0.8986281156539917,
0.8273764252662659,
-0.10092999041080475,
-0.24572694301605225,
0.31683775782585144,
-0.762385368347168,
-0.7852504253387451,
0.7914103865623474,
0.4654587507247925,
-0.16986273229122162,
-0.029487261548638344,
0.20761768519878387,
0.3879973292350769,
-0.5156939625740051,
0.20217427611351013,
0.5011071562767029,
0.21154984831809998,
0.26694393157958984,
-0.5776539444923401,
0.30043739080429077,
-0.06674753129482269,
0.13430720567703247,
0.0852353498339653,
-0.3098018169403076,
0.7664808034896851,
-0.17407996952533722,
-0.3394947946071625,
0.561719536781311,
0.9369387626647949,
0.22249822318553925,
-0.23982584476470947,
0.8832875490188599,
0.36348241567611694,
0.5358132719993591,
-0.08816631138324738,
0.6733095645904541,
-0.21783366799354553,
0.39841169118881226,
0.9232416749000549,
-0.18165987730026245,
0.782997190952301,
0.6608849763870239,
-0.05157824978232384,
0.18702884018421173,
0.5478359460830688,
-0.07927684485912323,
0.7192977666854858,
0.3554893434047699,
-0.6982671022415161,
-0.452671080827713,
-0.32312390208244324,
0.1281716376543045,
-0.04922667145729065,
0.8547166585922241,
-0.2107098400592804,
-0.24175046384334564,
0.057315725833177567,
-0.28352299332618713,
-0.09293927997350693,
-0.378312885761261,
0.6342346668243408,
0.24013979732990265,
-0.4242240786552429,
0.9019436240196228,
0.14227920770645142,
0.5403623580932617,
-0.9556060433387756,
0.057907577604055405,
-0.039224084466695786,
0.24540561437606812,
-0.3172178268432617,
-0.39974290132522583,
0.1932564228773117,
0.10869110375642776,
-0.22977042198181152,
-0.42987391352653503,
1.2336338758468628,
-0.6545121669769287,
-0.23816651105880737,
0.2528591454029083,
0.5455026626586914,
0.16541512310504913,
-0.03722524642944336,
-0.7274958491325378,
0.46314340829849243,
-0.008131571114063263,
-0.09720117598772049,
0.5078946352005005,
0.3764117956161499,
0.1355714201927185,
0.44992923736572266,
0.6348743438720703,
0.5038889646530151,
0.2624828815460205,
0.09133300930261612,
1.0855317115783691,
-0.26144084334373474,
-0.28282055258750916,
-0.653118908405304,
0.5019330978393555,
0.06893593072891235,
0.15447057783603668,
0.6216828227043152,
0.40408721566200256,
0.40815800428390503,
-0.04282182827591896,
0.5085877776145935,
-0.24305294454097748,
0.41605615615844727,
-0.43928155303001404,
0.7343780398368835,
-0.953248918056488,
0.420075923204422,
-0.0025615079794079065,
-0.8279961347579956,
-0.3925745189189911,
0.7671511173248291,
-0.3540585935115814,
0.17015773057937622,
0.6065203547477722,
1.241126298904419,
-0.3817698061466217,
-0.3714911639690399,
0.5649164915084839,
0.306857168674469,
-0.19745789468288422,
0.502138614654541,
1.090011715888977,
-0.4211175739765167,
0.5246637463569641,
-0.06769880652427673,
-0.5167036056518555,
-0.15643145143985748,
-0.7126907110214233,
-0.8361778259277344,
-0.33965662121772766,
-0.3767741024494171,
-0.49810221791267395,
-0.11992979049682617,
1.0687247514724731,
0.7325806021690369,
-0.8154330253601074,
-0.37191787362098694,
0.10006920993328094,
0.17416371405124664,
-0.35515493154525757,
-0.14897239208221436,
0.33029282093048096,
-0.8094072341918945,
-0.7806899547576904,
0.5596069693565369,
0.13670054078102112,
-0.03371679410338402,
-0.43492040038108826,
-0.2325577437877655,
-0.2651653289794922,
-0.024090472608804703,
0.4689529538154602,
0.5485068559646606,
-0.5279786586761475,
-0.29645341634750366,
-0.3518539369106293,
-0.6036638021469116,
-0.038842517882585526,
0.9417563080787659,
-0.7665218114852905,
-0.07979268580675125,
0.4863118529319763,
0.7609072327613831,
0.2537631094455719,
-0.21663790941238403,
0.19543713331222534,
-1.1141091585159302,
0.4936196208000183,
0.16489265859127045,
0.44434401392936707,
0.1799878478050232,
-0.01001888420432806,
0.20776832103729248,
0.44293612241744995,
-0.35299989581108093,
-0.9927446246147156,
-0.05512009561061859,
-0.9938639998435974,
-0.04341837763786316,
1.4287117719650269,
0.008010092191398144,
-0.636972963809967,
-0.18422122299671173,
0.048376455903053284,
-0.10761717706918716,
-0.1959841549396515,
0.418481707572937,
0.37790462374687195,
0.21478411555290222,
-0.046392589807510376,
-0.4719661474227905,
0.8144330382347107,
0.7492179274559021,
-0.5051458477973938,
0.41126054525375366,
0.5409042835235596,
0.0911022499203682,
0.28843915462493896,
0.8894268274307251,
0.0667477399110794,
0.3903277814388275,
0.2530767619609833,
-0.013194672763347626,
0.3796722888946533,
-0.37377649545669556,
-0.7105020880699158,
0.23201307654380798,
0.3927675485610962,
-0.08747000247240067
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00954v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00954v1
|
Annotation Guidelines-Based Knowledge Augmentation: Towards Enhancing Large Language Models for Educational Text Classification
| 2024-06-03T03:09:01 | 2024-06-03T03:09:01 |
Shiqi Liu, Sannyuya Liu, Lele Sha, Zijie Zeng, Dragan Gasevic, Zhi Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Various machine learning approaches have gained significant popularity for
the automated classification of educational text to identify indicators of
learning engagement -- i.e. learning engagement classification (LEC). LEC can
offer comprehensive insights into human learning processes, attracting
significant interest from diverse research communities, including Natural
Language Processing (NLP), Learning Analytics, and Educational Data Mining.
Recently, Large Language Models (LLMs), such as ChatGPT, have demonstrated
remarkable performance in various NLP tasks. However, their comprehensive
evaluation and improvement approaches in LEC tasks have not been thoroughly
investigated. In this study, we propose the Annotation Guidelines-based
Knowledge Augmentation (AGKA) approach to improve LLMs. AGKA employs GPT 4.0 to
retrieve label definition knowledge from annotation guidelines, and then
applies the random under-sampler to select a few typical examples.
Subsequently, we conduct a systematic evaluation benchmark of LEC, which
includes six LEC datasets covering behavior classification (question and
urgency level), emotion classification (binary and epistemic emotion), and
cognition classification (opinion and cognitive presence). The study results
demonstrate that AGKA can enhance non-fine-tuned LLMs, particularly GPT 4.0 and
Llama 3 70B. GPT 4.0 with AGKA few-shot outperforms full-shot fine-tuned models
such as BERT and RoBERTa on simple binary classification datasets. However, GPT
4.0 lags in multi-class tasks that require a deep understanding of complex
semantic information. Notably, Llama 3 70B with AGKA is a promising combination
based on open-source LLM, because its performance is on par with closed-source
GPT 4.0 with AGKA. In addition, LLMs struggle to distinguish between labels
with similar names in multi-class classification.
|
[
-0.5514881610870361,
-0.9196258783340454,
0.48811423778533936,
-0.28485092520713806,
-0.18029315769672394,
0.15260906517505646,
-0.4172084927558899,
-0.696448802947998,
-0.06753930449485779,
0.22900691628456116,
-0.5681492686271667,
-0.64280104637146,
-0.6229920387268066,
0.15774129331111908,
-0.0994991883635521,
1.0780272483825684,
-0.2109970897436142,
0.016926269978284836,
-0.31342318654060364,
-0.20123542845249176,
-0.5420900583267212,
-0.6667817831039429,
-0.676123857498169,
-0.32544612884521484,
0.38390877842903137,
0.4480791389942169,
0.3784291744232178,
0.3792814314365387,
0.4760371148586273,
0.31223592162132263,
-0.374988853931427,
0.46717244386672974,
-0.10539718717336655,
-0.016756128519773483,
0.003696174593642354,
-0.22324588894844055,
-0.5382227897644043,
0.11737744510173798,
0.45811840891838074,
0.4907795786857605,
-0.10217557102441788,
0.08540859073400497,
0.26861223578453064,
0.7614008188247681,
-0.7301110029220581,
0.5084932446479797,
-0.33575892448425293,
0.1670016497373581,
-0.06526561081409454,
-0.25454115867614746,
-0.3428534269332886,
-0.3352534770965576,
0.2709559500217438,
-0.9275540709495544,
-0.02444544807076454,
-0.2408984899520874,
0.7088586688041687,
0.41878533363342285,
-0.1936347782611847,
-0.5076295733451843,
-0.37572842836380005,
0.8051510453224182,
-0.7102500796318054,
0.43008023500442505,
0.6513624787330627,
0.22510719299316406,
-0.08243294060230255,
-0.42574307322502136,
-0.6587474346160889,
-0.1565832942724228,
-0.1462922841310501,
0.35257449746131897,
0.06735697388648987,
0.3321581184864044,
0.35177361965179443,
0.4380302429199219,
-0.18743474781513214,
0.11372217535972595,
-0.27538812160491943,
-0.23328523337841034,
0.5228111147880554,
-0.011413783766329288,
0.200030118227005,
-0.08231738954782486,
-0.11974382400512695,
-0.14096492528915405,
-0.5027622580528259,
0.11510591208934784,
0.5932665467262268,
0.2353917360305786,
0.08037368953227997,
0.4957071542739868,
-0.4029877483844757,
0.7753595113754272,
0.011619026772677898,
-0.16449996829032898,
0.4837550222873688,
-0.36418601870536804,
-0.1546739935874939,
0.11212580651044846,
0.5835459232330322,
0.5337277054786682,
0.3246409296989441,
0.013718103989958763,
0.12454816699028015,
0.3465908169746399,
0.12422823905944824,
-0.8873022198677063,
-0.2799023389816284,
-0.09218407422304153,
-0.12278839200735092,
-0.3213725686073303,
-0.19364799559116364,
-0.6199281215667725,
-0.2336765080690384,
-0.6160505414009094,
0.40888679027557373,
-0.5265435576438904,
-0.09381803870201111,
-0.06157331541180611,
0.29530465602874756,
0.2102942317724228,
0.7096296548843384,
-1.069860816001892,
0.09354670345783234,
0.7028316259384155,
0.7835519909858704,
-0.21190963685512543,
-0.09570329636335373,
-0.38251495361328125,
0.028202570974826813,
-0.2172834724187851,
0.7439771890640259,
-0.8714514374732971,
-0.2758680284023285,
0.197403222322464,
0.05493362247943878,
0.014664197340607643,
-0.20325054228305817,
0.6328811049461365,
-0.49774688482284546,
0.49173152446746826,
-0.1790107786655426,
-0.859586775302887,
-0.6304851770401001,
0.6270618438720703,
-0.47387218475341797,
0.9919152855873108,
-0.007249252870678902,
-0.6801989674568176,
0.5318635702133179,
-1.1413668394088745,
-0.3401544690132141,
0.15792316198349,
-0.19948139786720276,
-0.4453921616077423,
-0.28075486421585083,
0.4420730471611023,
0.7028704881668091,
-0.020747270435094833,
0.27243441343307495,
-0.17914654314517975,
-0.33887138962745667,
0.04413386434316635,
-0.33388903737068176,
0.3655807077884674,
0.16843067109584808,
-0.2927074134349823,
0.2980745732784271,
-0.6457077264785767,
-0.0006642198422923684,
-0.3010558784008026,
-0.49622607231140137,
-0.3883073329925537,
-0.09330333024263382,
-0.3102291524410248,
0.12837925553321838,
0.16114914417266846,
-0.28618165850639343,
0.3335154056549072,
-0.2851560711860657,
0.2479848861694336,
0.8201557993888855,
0.1913021206855774,
0.48886123299598694,
-0.13095898926258087,
0.33444610238075256,
-0.06230134889483452,
0.35600051283836365,
-0.3549247980117798,
-0.5312204957008362,
-0.8931712508201599,
-0.2589395046234131,
0.4633479416370392,
0.394114226102829,
-0.7349629402160645,
0.716948926448822,
-0.11424592137336731,
-0.36031168699264526,
-0.73035728931427,
0.3459410071372986,
0.07655540108680725,
0.6268064975738525,
0.6418611407279968,
-0.37078022956848145,
-0.5080094337463379,
-0.5621951818466187,
0.052835721522569656,
-0.2713184654712677,
0.12338424474000931,
0.36174383759498596,
0.2806147038936615,
-0.4395093619823456,
0.702812910079956,
-0.20929452776908875,
-0.5625193119049072,
-0.08816841244697571,
0.16332396864891052,
-0.006003699265420437,
0.20711876451969147,
0.25792571902275085,
-0.650411069393158,
-0.6569306254386902,
0.256448894739151,
-0.8050694465637207,
-0.1585294008255005,
0.07137343287467957,
-0.06644019484519958,
0.48482590913772583,
0.3853151798248291,
-0.2696326673030853,
0.5721939206123352,
0.2652783691883087,
-0.30543407797813416,
0.4048939645290375,
-0.016174552962183952,
0.41599637269973755,
-0.9099372625350952,
-0.12183618545532227,
0.21240295469760895,
-0.15944845974445343,
-0.626858115196228,
-0.10458853840827942,
0.06531522423028946,
0.3434883952140808,
-0.24744758009910583,
0.41673195362091064,
-0.23328962922096252,
0.20778623223304749,
-0.39773258566856384,
0.34277546405792236,
-0.11347480863332748,
0.4592304229736328,
0.24245834350585938,
0.7248470783233643,
0.488035649061203,
-0.7036274075508118,
0.2978437542915344,
0.4756084680557251,
-0.28281038999557495,
0.650275707244873,
-0.29523295164108276,
0.004305777605623007,
-0.035832054913043976,
0.24201925098896027,
-0.6946961879730225,
-0.4246850609779358,
0.22775410115718842,
-0.5911610126495361,
0.41201409697532654,
-0.1444435566663742,
-0.5726444721221924,
-0.03551430255174637,
-0.46407902240753174,
0.04527866467833519,
0.660219669342041,
-0.7487214803695679,
0.7521325945854187,
0.255906879901886,
-0.08501821756362915,
-0.7500651478767395,
-0.38317394256591797,
-0.08594423532485962,
-0.24130025506019592,
-0.4350025951862335,
0.02341899834573269,
-0.3038772940635681,
0.025454148650169373,
-0.0845201313495636,
-0.01765972375869751,
0.13964447379112244,
0.22685547173023224,
0.36617377400398254,
0.45635727047920227,
0.1314510554075241,
0.5190609693527222,
0.11460337042808533,
-0.07439599186182022,
-0.0516401082277298,
0.08131828159093857,
0.4113882780075073,
-0.2782822549343109,
-0.34310683608055115,
-0.370671808719635,
-0.025263013318181038,
0.26819565892219543,
-0.09373892843723297,
0.625119686126709,
0.9066882133483887,
-0.2214839905500412,
0.10002942383289337,
-0.8035900592803955,
-0.3180301785469055,
-0.4314117133617401,
0.30184388160705566,
-0.2025137096643448,
-1.1323872804641724,
0.4040448069572449,
-0.3660193681716919,
0.26741114258766174,
0.5985106825828552,
0.5717173218727112,
-0.012419824488461018,
0.8095902800559998,
0.7259957194328308,
-0.10912217199802399,
0.726460874080658,
-0.3102564513683319,
0.07296786457300186,
-1.1448402404785156,
-0.3641117215156555,
-0.19685569405555725,
-0.11912645399570465,
-0.4652632772922516,
-0.30653178691864014,
0.1747782826423645,
0.2273952066898346,
-0.07013995200395584,
-0.07703113555908203,
-0.7232383489608765,
0.520449697971344,
0.20961003005504608,
-0.026502737775444984,
0.43850257992744446,
0.20888225734233856,
-0.07926496863365173,
-0.06641363352537155,
-0.5769364237785339,
-0.5176742672920227,
1.1069694757461548,
0.5555747747421265,
0.4133341312408447,
0.11377185583114624,
0.6469589471817017,
0.3316693902015686,
0.6542123556137085,
-0.9213742017745972,
0.6578256487846375,
-0.0209690872579813,
-0.542966902256012,
-0.2695208787918091,
-0.4464578628540039,
-0.7100378274917603,
0.0437730997800827,
-0.475340336561203,
-0.8184820413589478,
-0.13343115150928497,
0.19328981637954712,
-0.21861566603183746,
0.2689966857433319,
-0.808536171913147,
0.6396186351776123,
-0.12702009081840515,
-0.4690021276473999,
-0.12880530953407288,
-0.53291916847229,
0.29453301429748535,
-0.36573857069015503,
0.3571012020111084,
-0.10378608107566833,
-0.003835444338619709,
0.9261001348495483,
-0.27013319730758667,
0.9473856091499329,
-0.3155190646648407,
-0.020036036148667336,
0.5055076479911804,
-0.46773001551628113,
0.5900143384933472,
-0.18568536639213562,
-0.04787244647741318,
0.15816019475460052,
-0.23016466200351715,
-0.039396047592163086,
-0.6073139309883118,
0.6800776720046997,
-0.8567054867744446,
-0.3239433169364929,
-0.34556329250335693,
-0.39086803793907166,
-0.2885245084762573,
-0.022509245201945305,
0.005823631305247545,
-0.018524909391999245,
0.05702099949121475,
0.2822267711162567,
0.6344613432884216,
-0.05825364962220192,
0.36806434392929077,
0.6578099727630615,
-0.21432384848594666,
-0.4493655264377594,
0.8438202142715454,
0.19747693836688995,
0.15497438609600067,
0.11564464867115021,
0.14009696245193481,
-0.47727757692337036,
-0.6397890448570251,
-0.4265514016151428,
-0.06480300426483154,
-1.0058739185333252,
-0.3701016306877136,
-0.700581967830658,
-0.2339857816696167,
-0.40948686003685,
-0.10970865190029144,
0.024946771562099457,
-0.3397159278392792,
-0.3025064170360565,
-0.31560492515563965,
0.8565940856933594,
0.6213363409042358,
-0.183524951338768,
0.6908577680587769,
-0.5827825665473938,
-0.009210624732077122,
0.35772573947906494,
0.5205144286155701,
-0.031454551964998245,
-0.6836292147636414,
-0.250191867351532,
-0.15698868036270142,
-0.25288599729537964,
-0.6840548515319824,
0.07612212002277374,
0.3416411578655243,
0.6297999620437622,
0.26670724153518677,
-0.09742578864097595,
0.7147767543792725,
-0.3672911822795868,
0.7447376251220703,
0.35754474997520447,
-0.8235795497894287,
0.6303912997245789,
-0.19292792677879333,
0.13738426566123962,
0.751721203327179,
0.3735455274581909,
-0.3788086771965027,
-0.17739595472812653,
-0.7041476368904114,
-1.0717782974243164,
0.6393244862556458,
0.21525567770004272,
-0.021272141486406326,
0.1121845543384552,
0.5622245669364929,
0.1401882767677307,
0.2500789165496826,
-0.8032705783843994,
-0.18811343610286713,
-0.1830342710018158,
-0.5623582601547241,
-0.005712135229259729,
-0.25249627232551575,
-0.013652920722961426,
-0.37053152918815613,
1.0941177606582642,
-0.32207193970680237,
-0.20682449638843536,
0.12785694003105164,
-0.16698621213436127,
-0.17100542783737183,
0.4770931005477905,
0.3327083885669708,
0.2900230288505554,
-0.1600818634033203,
-0.09193380177021027,
0.6283814907073975,
-0.6162431240081787,
0.08720577508211136,
0.3872075378894806,
-0.3040696084499359,
-0.21346575021743774,
0.3149592876434326,
0.8667758703231812,
0.09826259315013885,
-0.371620774269104,
0.30411991477012634,
-0.24206165969371796,
-0.19665579497814178,
-0.42527785897254944,
0.4042443037033081,
-0.2056417316198349,
0.3219439387321472,
0.24235986173152924,
-0.15953987836837769,
0.283385694026947,
-0.4130871891975403,
0.1728513091802597,
0.3631782829761505,
-0.3987651765346527,
-0.12152796983718872,
0.19855017960071564,
0.3006437420845032,
-0.03421849384903908,
0.23042282462120056,
-0.30715760588645935,
-0.6227883100509644,
0.14246436953544617,
0.18302394449710846,
0.6680498719215393,
-0.5087401866912842,
0.17552626132965088,
0.6350151896476746,
0.3346216082572937,
-0.1255357563495636,
0.0018151188269257545,
-0.3965087831020355,
-0.5328447222709656,
-0.8731216192245483,
-0.7453566193580627,
-0.5736333727836609,
0.24215304851531982,
-0.4103751480579376,
0.2669036388397217,
-0.43122103810310364,
-0.14175167679786682,
0.0790153369307518,
0.39327239990234375,
-0.5655050873756409,
0.26225557923316956,
0.16920095682144165,
0.579868495464325,
-0.8205028772354126,
0.7936715483665466,
1.0398948192596436,
-0.3000100255012512,
-0.9230881333351135,
-0.2729587256908417,
-0.17145724594593048,
-0.366028368473053,
0.36170682311058044,
0.439634770154953,
0.11397439241409302,
-0.07983231544494629,
-0.5753382444381714,
-0.4755115509033203,
1.108808159828186,
-0.08830829709768295,
-0.6426309943199158,
0.10900941491127014,
0.06493455916643143,
0.6653300523757935,
-0.457113653421402,
0.4328114688396454,
0.5863953232765198,
0.7139924764633179,
0.3419501483440399,
-0.7616651058197021,
-0.2729111611843109,
-0.3202340006828308,
-0.34938013553619385,
0.1137356385588646,
-0.5322175621986389,
0.3572559356689453,
-0.07561244815587997,
-0.01800641044974327,
-0.19625166058540344,
0.5810072422027588,
0.424033522605896,
0.45628225803375244,
0.610383927822113,
0.692554771900177,
0.8460448980331421,
-0.2889162302017212,
0.8167870044708252,
-0.12553434073925018,
0.40444526076316833,
1.0326298475265503,
-0.048309363424777985,
0.8404685258865356,
0.4219284951686859,
-0.20560218393802643,
0.48799994587898254,
0.8347413539886475,
-0.14257077872753143,
0.45950308442115784,
-0.04817349463701248,
-0.34039703011512756,
-0.28778496384620667,
-0.21790039539337158,
-0.35064414143562317,
0.28768229484558105,
0.7003922462463379,
-0.2361840456724167,
-0.11048177629709244,
0.04210430011153221,
0.07451219856739044,
-0.027903499081730843,
-0.4999007284641266,
1.1698858737945557,
-0.08453287929296494,
-0.5429201722145081,
0.3395789861679077,
-0.2634340226650238,
0.8626973032951355,
-0.5978960394859314,
-0.289061963558197,
0.05062422156333923,
0.10663177818059921,
-0.5177497863769531,
-0.8439074158668518,
0.07685735076665878,
0.2078193724155426,
-0.06396457552909851,
0.30064287781715393,
1.0402228832244873,
-0.6216985583305359,
-0.49733588099479675,
0.31492915749549866,
0.17625610530376434,
0.17596815526485443,
0.12306120246648788,
-0.6205933094024658,
0.23727339506149292,
0.1375323086977005,
-0.33714011311531067,
0.3051998019218445,
0.3994741439819336,
0.04924502968788147,
0.5296776294708252,
0.807671308517456,
-0.07442709803581238,
-0.10298235714435577,
0.1323590874671936,
0.8719074726104736,
-0.3450026214122772,
-0.41167816519737244,
-0.8311752080917358,
0.5825806260108948,
-0.3081371784210205,
0.017911391332745552,
0.6243048310279846,
0.26973044872283936,
0.8499281406402588,
0.193030446767807,
0.938397228717804,
0.14244502782821655,
0.48500683903694153,
-0.618297815322876,
0.5142080783843994,
-0.4892445504665375,
0.392273873090744,
-0.3263501226902008,
-1.0572080612182617,
-0.3826049864292145,
0.9796977043151855,
-0.5572693347930908,
0.28740498423576355,
0.3775530159473419,
0.24258151650428772,
0.11945516616106033,
0.24085529148578644,
0.3334258794784546,
-0.011078489944338799,
0.4960559904575348,
0.41177287697792053,
0.8872801065444946,
-0.3871554434299469,
0.4746647775173187,
-0.35298728942871094,
-0.36131325364112854,
-0.4165860116481781,
-0.8392395973205566,
-1.1219091415405273,
-0.5407798290252686,
-0.6013714671134949,
-0.05975774675607681,
0.21188940107822418,
0.9016735553741455,
0.6026286482810974,
-0.6612827777862549,
0.3313675820827484,
-0.1726144403219223,
0.015715546905994415,
0.14584234356880188,
-0.24221931397914886,
0.496918648481369,
-0.5775160789489746,
-0.675710141658783,
0.1346944272518158,
0.19126471877098083,
0.31737467646598816,
-0.24706359207630157,
-0.33463507890701294,
-0.2731955647468567,
-0.11193861067295074,
0.7703636884689331,
0.16184678673744202,
-0.7555468082427979,
-0.43485772609710693,
-0.18517223000526428,
0.2943717837333679,
0.0018416070379316807,
0.2774084210395813,
-0.8254102468490601,
0.6440035104751587,
0.15516245365142822,
0.7193024158477783,
0.4086042642593384,
0.0428076833486557,
0.07685268670320511,
-0.9101366996765137,
0.060806918889284134,
0.19097775220870972,
0.35744449496269226,
0.5515499114990234,
-0.3534680902957916,
0.9425964951515198,
-0.050606757402420044,
-0.74403977394104,
-0.7076146006584167,
-0.003414845559746027,
-0.9980188012123108,
0.04938124492764473,
1.1807364225387573,
-0.28660473227500916,
-0.22867214679718018,
-0.11814583837985992,
-0.3297685384750366,
0.44364532828330994,
-0.546327531337738,
0.9251459240913391,
0.9573877453804016,
-0.10015125572681427,
-0.25260838866233826,
-0.9062821269035339,
0.6049450039863586,
0.3997364044189453,
-1.1323262453079224,
0.20272575318813324,
0.5950221419334412,
0.10002926737070084,
0.512012779712677,
0.3012399971485138,
-0.21447400748729706,
0.19900763034820557,
-0.5653169751167297,
0.2537977993488312,
-0.4015094041824341,
-0.2478012889623642,
-0.21624240279197693,
-0.028887402266263962,
0.10441089421510696,
-0.03381039947271347
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00944v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00944v1
|
Unveil the Duality of Retrieval-Augmented Generation: Theoretical Analysis and Practical Solution
| 2024-06-03T02:56:14 | 2024-06-03T02:56:14 |
Shicheng Xu, Liang Pang, Huawei Shen, Xueqi Cheng
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR
|
Retrieval-augmented generation (RAG) utilizes retrieved texts to enhance
large language models (LLMs). However, studies show that RAG is not
consistently effective and can even mislead LLMs due to noisy or incorrect
retrieved texts. This suggests that RAG possesses a duality including both
benefit and detriment. Although many existing methods attempt to address this
issue, they lack a theoretical explanation for the duality in RAG. The benefit
and detriment within this duality remain a black box that cannot be quantified
or compared in an explainable manner. This paper takes the first step in
theoretically giving the essential explanation of benefit and detriment in RAG
by: (1) decoupling and formalizing them from RAG prediction, (2) approximating
the gap between their values by representation similarity and (3) establishing
the trade-off mechanism between them, to make them explainable, quantifiable,
and comparable. We demonstrate that the distribution difference between
retrieved texts and LLMs' knowledge acts as double-edged sword, bringing both
benefit and detriment. We also prove that the actual effect of RAG can be
predicted at token level. Based on our theory, we propose a practical novel
method, X-RAG, which achieves collaborative generation between pure LLM and RAG
at token level to preserve benefit and avoid detriment. Experiments in
real-world tasks based on LLMs including OPT, LLaMA-2, and Mistral show the
effectiveness of our method and support our theoretical results.
|
[
-0.3637675940990448,
-0.5425570011138916,
0.4111151099205017,
-0.21864603459835052,
-0.33813363313674927,
0.5948876738548279,
-0.21248476207256317,
-0.693287193775177,
0.38752275705337524,
0.645609974861145,
-0.25734201073646545,
0.07396765798330307,
-0.4598985016345978,
-0.06437626481056213,
-0.3783263564109802,
1.20158851146698,
0.03330861032009125,
-0.17626157402992249,
-0.2578480541706085,
-0.03956810012459755,
-0.41211849451065063,
-0.5219228267669678,
-0.7224615812301636,
-0.3844369649887085,
0.705173134803772,
0.2985900342464447,
0.663314938545227,
0.40758728981018066,
0.4995891749858856,
0.2736179828643799,
-0.20106784999370575,
0.33445069193840027,
-0.7691600918769836,
0.45452195405960083,
-0.20089782774448395,
-0.7411851286888123,
-0.060085590928792953,
0.06010405346751213,
0.8392590284347534,
0.5018901824951172,
0.13988454639911652,
0.2344229817390442,
0.19196875393390656,
0.8488799333572388,
-0.7381877303123474,
-0.2687390148639679,
-0.936470091342926,
0.021625498309731483,
-0.4242275357246399,
-0.351484090089798,
-0.3781312108039856,
-0.07202892750501633,
-0.1438748687505722,
-0.3573407828807831,
0.3536739945411682,
0.2024812400341034,
0.8520708680152893,
0.26864516735076904,
-0.6329134106636047,
-0.44612258672714233,
-1.0795551538467407,
0.9939389228820801,
-0.21263787150382996,
0.22361531853675842,
0.16781260073184967,
0.396765798330307,
-0.14072801172733307,
-0.6350908279418945,
-0.6647253036499023,
-0.4820418953895569,
-0.22809115052223206,
0.2533779740333557,
0.06806336343288422,
-0.12281405180692673,
0.20236985385417938,
0.8922306299209595,
-0.32504016160964966,
0.013940843753516674,
-0.3592331111431122,
0.11049319058656693,
0.6993367671966553,
0.03671196475625038,
0.45166143774986267,
-0.2842724621295929,
-0.8375062942504883,
-0.10684791207313538,
-0.7659669518470764,
-0.10918320715427399,
0.4857345223426819,
0.30892157554626465,
-0.002841966226696968,
0.6531038880348206,
0.3583705425262451,
0.15405917167663574,
0.07106426358222961,
-0.10339481383562088,
0.17673471570014954,
-0.5649489164352417,
0.06431224197149277,
-0.16925852000713348,
0.6482496857643127,
-0.04076805338263512,
-0.13842841982841492,
-0.4467327296733856,
-0.3893684446811676,
0.1657913625240326,
0.42367103695869446,
-0.4913703203201294,
0.28910771012306213,
0.11059495061635971,
-0.38122454285621643,
-0.6372838616371155,
-0.0229168813675642,
-1.0095933675765991,
-0.5053697824478149,
-0.35021474957466125,
0.4986056387424469,
-0.031157804653048515,
-0.7704991698265076,
-0.2478962540626526,
-0.40402644872665405,
0.06011561304330826,
-0.09520834684371948,
-0.7495917081832886,
0.5005483627319336,
0.9266732335090637,
0.6079453825950623,
-0.37596073746681213,
0.0636596828699112,
-0.5036327838897705,
0.2447587251663208,
-0.20025676488876343,
0.7622829079627991,
-0.4368511140346527,
-0.5161914229393005,
-0.10196073353290558,
-0.5363792777061462,
0.13943800330162048,
-0.7002517580986023,
0.7337270975112915,
-0.6733855605125427,
0.2821153402328491,
-0.37742024660110474,
-0.32013460993766785,
-0.06394267827272415,
-0.019246872514486313,
-0.826809287071228,
1.162644624710083,
0.0641736388206482,
-1.0129661560058594,
0.5717687606811523,
-0.2807048261165619,
-0.2746333181858063,
0.1250278353691101,
-0.3529118597507477,
-0.43066421151161194,
0.49394118785858154,
-0.4222683608531952,
0.0381157286465168,
-0.5721664428710938,
0.3567430377006531,
-0.11354126036167145,
-0.2982124090194702,
0.2997003197669983,
-0.5134474635124207,
0.7903602123260498,
0.21595916152000427,
-0.32022812962532043,
-0.16704319417476654,
-0.7407224774360657,
-0.16275356709957123,
0.26446518301963806,
-0.31560415029525757,
-0.750640869140625,
-0.10914270579814911,
-0.32942816615104675,
0.19583821296691895,
0.26265329122543335,
-0.5698177814483643,
0.08083602041006088,
-0.5436394810676575,
-0.37499096989631653,
0.8154076337814331,
-0.07683902978897095,
0.6582468748092651,
-0.5695496201515198,
0.6624937653541565,
-0.16110336780548096,
-0.20021359622478485,
0.17381492257118225,
-0.21094872057437897,
-0.6294538974761963,
-0.4093496799468994,
0.36083492636680603,
0.42719364166259766,
-0.884649932384491,
-0.03480268642306328,
-0.13663405179977417,
-0.13320298492908478,
-0.5637893676757812,
0.14559143781661987,
0.8243687748908997,
0.47673583030700684,
0.24476473033428192,
-0.19491812586784363,
-0.7831475138664246,
-0.7614187598228455,
-0.5556442737579346,
-0.1104753240942955,
0.20454594492912292,
0.3748095631599426,
0.3629780113697052,
-0.13646955788135529,
0.8113282322883606,
-0.2837968170642853,
-0.10096301883459091,
-0.29046109318733215,
0.08308608084917068,
0.09295020252466202,
0.22996476292610168,
0.39619264006614685,
-1.2551590204238892,
-0.6119989156723022,
0.023494485765695572,
-0.6211680173873901,
-0.2915794551372528,
-0.1956166923046112,
-0.32195812463760376,
0.30062130093574524,
0.11762465536594391,
-0.47578510642051697,
0.527277946472168,
0.6027069687843323,
-0.2892405688762665,
0.9857140183448792,
-0.21221484243869781,
0.06929057836532593,
-1.1439554691314697,
0.058576107025146484,
-0.24422720074653625,
-0.2046782523393631,
-0.6425663828849792,
0.3032015860080719,
-0.23164166510105133,
0.14766018092632294,
-0.04836638271808624,
0.8819645047187805,
-0.5873458385467529,
-0.268306165933609,
-0.5432969927787781,
0.2152440994977951,
0.13970154523849487,
0.23167428374290466,
-0.32263219356536865,
0.9429706335067749,
0.07695723325014114,
-0.532776951789856,
0.09697852283716202,
0.08030292391777039,
0.09791521728038788,
0.40443387627601624,
-0.48544418811798096,
-0.005061666015535593,
-0.22504621744155884,
0.048710983246564865,
-0.9188127517700195,
0.06145593523979187,
0.09758530557155609,
-0.5665627121925354,
0.8045060038566589,
-0.06767686456441879,
-0.4237288236618042,
-0.35766977071762085,
-0.4773798882961273,
0.4691881239414215,
0.6844877600669861,
-0.8487335443496704,
0.41281118988990784,
0.6154245138168335,
0.033287763595581055,
-0.8245262503623962,
-0.4830205738544464,
0.19809004664421082,
-0.4879316985607147,
-0.6135352253913879,
0.5543578267097473,
-0.1026611328125,
-0.6763348579406738,
0.06809861212968826,
-0.16164088249206543,
0.17446741461753845,
-0.03659648448228836,
0.3114491403102875,
0.4701121151447296,
0.011415996588766575,
0.21774524450302124,
0.18677785992622375,
-0.4602097272872925,
-0.03688063472509384,
-0.04883437976241112,
0.29522132873535156,
0.1394762247800827,
-0.1877695620059967,
0.04892633482813835,
0.4927816092967987,
0.24449419975280762,
-0.3542638123035431,
0.895907998085022,
0.6006453633308411,
-0.05244917795062065,
-0.368073433637619,
-0.6963592767715454,
-0.09257076680660248,
-0.5030487775802612,
0.049023326486349106,
-0.42936068773269653,
-0.7828536033630371,
0.42422738671302795,
-0.25408443808555603,
0.12374704331159592,
0.3955477178096771,
0.5593570470809937,
0.13138695061206818,
0.9356439709663391,
0.5394979119300842,
0.4706275463104248,
0.3883701264858246,
-0.42986711859703064,
0.10366558283567429,
-1.194985270500183,
-0.301225483417511,
-0.5696021318435669,
-0.146550253033638,
-0.6810398697853088,
-0.3682192862033844,
0.40259093046188354,
0.40029263496398926,
-0.07829251140356064,
0.04165620356798172,
-0.5427584648132324,
0.355564683675766,
0.7529174089431763,
-0.18810579180717468,
0.46256130933761597,
0.31503579020500183,
-0.3905072808265686,
-0.20941263437271118,
-0.4311544597148895,
-0.5797663331031799,
1.075529932975769,
0.05843455344438553,
0.5122639536857605,
0.36314478516578674,
1.1150552034378052,
0.16894462704658508,
0.16022120416164398,
-0.5322287082672119,
0.5743183493614197,
-0.38513579964637756,
-0.7694807052612305,
0.06597590446472168,
-0.731953501701355,
-1.1950093507766724,
0.583553671836853,
-0.4425468146800995,
-0.5611914992332458,
0.04043717309832573,
0.1543872356414795,
0.13948360085487366,
0.49088576436042786,
-0.7023745179176331,
0.40451955795288086,
-0.3702217936515808,
-0.8052678108215332,
-0.3583018481731415,
-0.546787440776825,
0.7024077773094177,
-0.33790385723114014,
0.479971319437027,
0.13349497318267822,
-0.26803141832351685,
0.732684314250946,
-0.24026010930538177,
0.551642894744873,
-0.16361957788467407,
-0.20017120242118835,
0.30593612790107727,
0.25357669591903687,
0.37047597765922546,
-0.060228146612644196,
-0.17888890206813812,
-0.12752464413642883,
0.0018188946414738894,
-0.2905372679233551,
-0.6286435723304749,
0.7850803732872009,
-0.6831933856010437,
-0.7633774876594543,
-0.35367393493652344,
-0.6754729747772217,
-0.10635706782341003,
0.3925105631351471,
0.1602509319782257,
0.5043121576309204,
-0.09731389582157135,
-0.14846171438694,
0.5322173833847046,
-0.39749979972839355,
0.2121252417564392,
0.39417359232902527,
-0.5344517230987549,
-0.4420434534549713,
1.049843192100525,
0.08349387347698212,
0.5105562806129456,
0.47880271077156067,
0.426896870136261,
-0.31426334381103516,
-0.35751938819885254,
-0.20651836693286896,
0.6456177830696106,
-0.39334696531295776,
-0.025854140520095825,
-0.4373382031917572,
-0.045853812247514725,
-0.15621526539325714,
-0.09278933703899384,
-0.264948308467865,
-0.6255242228507996,
-0.12924204766750336,
-0.06121394783258438,
0.054308097809553146,
1.0236324071884155,
-0.5577490329742432,
-0.08181560784578323,
-0.6784136891365051,
0.6264959573745728,
0.270794153213501,
0.1792512983083725,
0.17765875160694122,
-0.5147734880447388,
-0.2769045829772949,
0.29968851804733276,
-0.249482661485672,
-0.7668853402137756,
0.3938237726688385,
-0.14245252311229706,
0.6605381369590759,
0.17066526412963867,
0.2539806663990021,
0.5819738507270813,
-0.49980634450912476,
0.6240242123603821,
0.19951742887496948,
-0.5864555239677429,
0.28345969319343567,
-0.16447298228740692,
-0.2023671716451645,
0.4358886778354645,
0.13029637932777405,
-0.24603533744812012,
-0.4838075637817383,
-0.8166248202323914,
-0.8845753073692322,
0.6103650331497192,
0.2350597232580185,
0.15092717111110687,
-0.007721778936684132,
0.36721351742744446,
0.4404909014701843,
0.10987727344036102,
-0.5619487166404724,
-0.40461859107017517,
0.26670366525650024,
0.04910562187433243,
0.09247717261314392,
-0.7298575043678284,
-0.17275118827819824,
0.17176099121570587,
0.8099619746208191,
0.373623788356781,
0.3409390449523926,
0.010636229999363422,
0.05662280321121216,
-0.3072887361049652,
0.28982803225517273,
0.3791730999946594,
0.46173256635665894,
-0.07033848762512207,
0.45165354013442993,
-0.024344278499484062,
-0.4369049668312073,
0.2786201238632202,
0.032805126160383224,
-0.2127830684185028,
0.062398511916399,
0.3388601243495941,
0.6358412504196167,
0.025253189727663994,
-0.4165066182613373,
0.41792476177215576,
-0.008720960468053818,
0.05211642384529114,
-0.3993927836418152,
-0.05064396932721138,
-0.08533670753240585,
0.256720632314682,
0.5499025583267212,
0.12384457886219025,
0.09678849577903748,
-0.47465696930885315,
0.2089596539735794,
0.8239178657531738,
-0.03925495967268944,
-0.39364883303642273,
0.6360605359077454,
0.1471453458070755,
-0.45660024881362915,
0.07850595563650131,
-0.5495980978012085,
-0.5207603573799133,
0.5351594090461731,
0.7530956864356995,
0.8004501461982727,
-0.07615207135677338,
0.24826356768608093,
0.2969169318675995,
0.008879092521965504,
0.09186842292547226,
0.036516882479190826,
-0.1415737420320511,
-0.7198743224143982,
-0.5399488210678101,
-0.7027657628059387,
-0.2233857810497284,
-0.18380476534366608,
-0.9258837103843689,
0.03658505156636238,
0.054240334779024124,
-0.21177178621292114,
0.018598923459649086,
0.4276466369628906,
-0.361921489238739,
-0.1468462347984314,
0.216358944773674,
0.49070900678634644,
-0.49738961458206177,
0.5187222957611084,
0.39776358008384705,
-0.6633538603782654,
-0.7949572801589966,
0.11198493093252182,
0.10191909968852997,
-0.9468854069709778,
0.8491150736808777,
0.015704426914453506,
-0.3676375150680542,
-0.15230096876621246,
-0.22865402698516846,
-0.8624622225761414,
1.0242012739181519,
0.35973772406578064,
-0.34827616810798645,
-0.20566456019878387,
0.08299818634986877,
0.5686723589897156,
-0.09281238168478012,
0.14766673743724823,
0.2543044090270996,
0.31864938139915466,
0.39794912934303284,
-0.9749928712844849,
0.12144201248884201,
-0.053384553641080856,
0.15345923602581024,
0.6576746106147766,
-0.5119142532348633,
0.7798847556114197,
-0.3854482173919678,
-0.6386116743087769,
0.11635413765907288,
0.3900029957294464,
0.42103976011276245,
0.4279026389122009,
0.4528905749320984,
0.5878261923789978,
0.6245536804199219,
0.2873576879501343,
1.3317475318908691,
-0.1999361515045166,
0.37552592158317566,
0.9682949781417847,
-0.28474023938179016,
0.6722806096076965,
0.5831467509269714,
-0.36521708965301514,
0.6557917594909668,
-0.118024080991745,
0.3932490944862366,
0.4350039064884186,
0.1582600325345993,
-0.6388868093490601,
0.01497356966137886,
-0.37969961762428284,
-0.4270663559436798,
0.2691956162452698,
0.2915690541267395,
-0.435880184173584,
-0.2306279093027115,
0.07203155755996704,
0.18123148381710052,
0.25935256481170654,
-0.21334050595760345,
0.8352360725402832,
0.3138487935066223,
-0.743752658367157,
0.7837494611740112,
-0.19990697503089905,
0.7297484278678894,
-0.4662173092365265,
-0.23062235116958618,
-0.11039021611213684,
0.32448410987854004,
-0.23713937401771545,
-0.7694873809814453,
0.5657618641853333,
0.015241976827383041,
-0.3080826997756958,
-0.2391672283411026,
1.041056752204895,
-0.4530978202819824,
-0.3495672047138214,
0.5695981979370117,
0.6685776114463806,
0.07196003943681717,
0.29099956154823303,
-0.6505131125450134,
0.10470758378505707,
0.14741741120815277,
-0.10824155062437057,
0.5433990955352783,
0.4497535228729248,
0.09057477861642838,
0.45130324363708496,
0.7370173335075378,
0.4547540247440338,
-0.06877700239419937,
-0.09098321944475174,
0.8501495718955994,
-0.496888667345047,
-0.2686854898929596,
-0.7633301615715027,
0.5592073202133179,
-0.2089027762413025,
0.15174917876720428,
0.8709313273429871,
0.5965930819511414,
0.6474189162254333,
0.2554522156715393,
0.7262627482414246,
-0.02380591444671154,
1.0097993612289429,
-0.3488270938396454,
0.49940773844718933,
-0.8360837697982788,
0.5605242848396301,
-0.16220703721046448,
-0.7038540244102478,
-0.2329670637845993,
0.14158757030963898,
-0.2986905872821808,
0.08191405981779099,
0.7664348483085632,
0.9617090821266174,
0.030562294647097588,
-0.13726063072681427,
0.32482048869132996,
0.13041844964027405,
0.21494948863983154,
0.33815744519233704,
0.9851392507553101,
-0.20574894547462463,
0.8139548897743225,
-0.3149915337562561,
-0.46420302987098694,
0.037501975893974304,
-0.5327009558677673,
-0.9162930250167847,
-0.6443996429443359,
-0.06746682524681091,
-0.536806046962738,
0.119607113301754,
0.49070069193840027,
0.35432371497154236,
-0.3288564383983612,
-0.18861158192157745,
-0.08052073419094086,
0.3050629496574402,
0.05726755037903786,
-0.2659390866756439,
0.2713019847869873,
-0.3920329809188843,
-0.5580752491950989,
0.24444963037967682,
0.1200735941529274,
-0.04675426334142685,
-0.39292269945144653,
-0.05480681359767914,
-0.2015686333179474,
0.16439427435398102,
0.5537908673286438,
0.33032625913619995,
-0.6311993598937988,
-0.10685042291879654,
-0.2598695158958435,
-0.15669621527194977,
-0.019148923456668854,
0.9265533089637756,
-1.0034180879592896,
0.5230833292007446,
0.5673247575759888,
0.5591309666633606,
0.45778414607048035,
0.10346943885087967,
0.5659496784210205,
-0.8128714561462402,
0.17407380044460297,
0.21102012693881989,
0.07811340689659119,
0.2883088290691376,
-0.5436483025550842,
0.6128689050674438,
0.20757392048835754,
-0.7872579097747803,
-1.1021976470947266,
0.5914685130119324,
-0.7475932836532593,
-0.3101043105125427,
1.3515931367874146,
0.034706395119428635,
-0.060460206121206284,
-0.031022289767861366,
-0.4399656355381012,
0.5032477974891663,
-0.24631533026695251,
0.6918703317642212,
0.19647975265979767,
0.048175834119319916,
0.09814172238111496,
-0.4900537431240082,
0.46521300077438354,
0.48390325903892517,
-0.5792633295059204,
0.07621949166059494,
0.4047636389732361,
-0.002989821834489703,
0.38159871101379395,
0.591050386428833,
-0.14695300161838531,
0.04027988389134407,
0.31728458404541016,
-0.07684028893709183,
-0.24541425704956055,
-0.054626330733299255,
-0.34899765253067017,
0.08008983731269836,
0.14053718745708466,
-0.15843747556209564
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00083v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00083v2
|
BadRAG: Identifying Vulnerabilities in Retrieval Augmented Generation of Large Language Models
| 2024-06-03T02:25:33 | 2024-06-06T13:38:42 |
Jiaqi Xue, Mengxin Zheng, Yebowen Hu, Fei Liu, Xun Chen, Qian Lou
|
cs.CR
|
cs.CR, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.IR, cs.LG
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) are constrained by outdated information and a
tendency to generate incorrect data, commonly referred to as "hallucinations."
Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG) addresses these limitations by combining
the strengths of retrieval-based methods and generative models. This approach
involves retrieving relevant information from a large, up-to-date dataset and
using it to enhance the generation process, leading to more accurate and
contextually appropriate responses. Despite its benefits, RAG introduces a new
attack surface for LLMs, particularly because RAG databases are often sourced
from public data, such as the web. In this paper, we propose \TrojRAG{} to
identify the vulnerabilities and attacks on retrieval parts (RAG database) and
their indirect attacks on generative parts (LLMs). Specifically, we identify
that poisoning several customized content passages could achieve a retrieval
backdoor, where the retrieval works well for clean queries but always returns
customized poisoned adversarial queries. Triggers and poisoned passages can be
highly customized to implement various attacks. For example, a trigger could be
a semantic group like "The Republican Party, Donald Trump, etc." Adversarial
passages can be tailored to different contents, not only linked to the triggers
but also used to indirectly attack generative LLMs without modifying them.
These attacks can include denial-of-service attacks on RAG and semantic
steering attacks on LLM generations conditioned by the triggers. Our
experiments demonstrate that by just poisoning 10 adversarial passages can
induce 98.2\% success rate to retrieve the adversarial passages. Then, these
passages can increase the reject ratio of RAG-based GPT-4 from 0.01\% to 74.6\%
or increase the rate of negative responses from 0.22\% to 72\% for targeted
queries.
|
[
-0.4509170353412628,
-1.1648945808410645,
0.35097402334213257,
-0.13364975154399872,
-0.15682023763656616,
0.019952941685914993,
0.054611820727586746,
-0.43038052320480347,
0.14425787329673767,
0.9407597780227661,
-0.3001363277435303,
-0.4357166886329651,
-0.5239779949188232,
0.001921161194331944,
-0.7696279883384705,
1.305449366569519,
0.37652653455734253,
-0.3263062536716461,
0.08013211935758591,
0.06262771785259247,
-0.6194955110549927,
-0.7716840505599976,
-0.667228639125824,
0.01753731071949005,
0.6092059016227722,
0.11749178171157837,
0.6995638012886047,
0.2466568499803543,
0.7097092270851135,
0.2748188078403473,
-0.11204412579536438,
-0.11219648271799088,
-0.8465469479560852,
0.7142493724822998,
-0.45413631200790405,
-0.6673920154571533,
-0.3211389482021332,
-0.24088087677955627,
0.42579516768455505,
0.05954122915863991,
-0.28392401337623596,
0.11624781787395477,
-0.003190483432263136,
0.7005351185798645,
-0.9638945460319519,
-0.4525337517261505,
-1.327582836151123,
0.1145487055182457,
-0.9033293128013611,
-0.5881494283676147,
-0.7093052864074707,
-0.0784158781170845,
-0.38379010558128357,
-0.4673668444156647,
0.48947906494140625,
0.13617032766342163,
0.823778510093689,
0.45935654640197754,
-0.2214769423007965,
-0.4482521414756775,
-0.7431530356407166,
0.6820632219314575,
-0.46647828817367554,
0.2028823047876358,
0.5496244430541992,
0.553908109664917,
-0.6950963139533997,
-0.6877725124359131,
-0.6871335506439209,
-0.2524692416191101,
-0.05133688822388649,
0.034864019602537155,
-0.46966394782066345,
-0.017213303595781326,
0.42638030648231506,
0.435369610786438,
-0.9796964526176453,
0.10573343932628632,
-0.45225682854652405,
-0.16333141922950745,
0.6832449436187744,
0.3303612768650055,
0.5640179514884949,
-0.6021026968955994,
-0.5120249390602112,
-0.050079625099897385,
-1.1003857851028442,
-0.6220803260803223,
0.619802713394165,
0.2919308543205261,
0.009857228957116604,
0.830758810043335,
0.0899714007973671,
0.8688851594924927,
0.12660151720046997,
0.006773747969418764,
0.02109004743397236,
-0.24016524851322174,
-0.24288205802440643,
-0.0056261932477355,
0.7878713011741638,
0.0522584468126297,
0.046487826853990555,
-0.31184902787208557,
-0.2708547115325928,
-0.07868523895740509,
0.8594276905059814,
-0.7029429078102112,
-0.16406114399433136,
0.302564799785614,
-0.19500868022441864,
-0.6588347554206848,
-0.07507338374853134,
-1.159642219543457,
-0.7800426483154297,
0.3007863163948059,
0.5906020402908325,
-0.3453895151615143,
-0.026099175214767456,
-0.07005731016397476,
-0.25645312666893005,
0.38085436820983887,
0.015400501899421215,
-0.6022167205810547,
0.10709433257579803,
0.9408036470413208,
0.7370266318321228,
-0.21357133984565735,
-0.11863836646080017,
-1.0562338829040527,
0.33502864837646484,
-0.2793785035610199,
0.8573722839355469,
-0.4811285436153412,
-0.570391833782196,
0.041446153074502945,
-0.17748041450977325,
0.1233154907822609,
-0.8128389716148376,
0.8622806072235107,
-1.1562961339950562,
0.25124362111091614,
-0.027265500277280807,
-0.3831636905670166,
0.11688417196273804,
0.458965003490448,
-0.8920574188232422,
0.7905179858207703,
-0.05298438295722008,
-1.2547913789749146,
-0.12153500318527222,
-0.29100751876831055,
-0.4503903388977051,
0.06774744391441345,
-0.005545171909034252,
-0.4890897274017334,
0.18082252144813538,
-0.04682677984237671,
0.3357820510864258,
-0.3435435891151428,
0.021917102858424187,
-0.34714120626449585,
-0.33293983340263367,
0.4170520603656769,
-0.4379911422729492,
0.8420565128326416,
0.4239049553871155,
-0.07903851568698883,
0.0841187834739685,
-0.7078577876091003,
-0.005533160176128149,
0.2909432351589203,
-0.2123744636774063,
-0.6330217123031616,
-0.042914606630802155,
-0.13654734194278717,
0.02864982932806015,
0.04448449984192848,
-0.19873736798763275,
0.18695469200611115,
-0.654589056968689,
-0.07409953325986862,
0.8295809626579285,
0.562813937664032,
0.23107096552848816,
-0.3723619282245636,
0.8485401272773743,
-0.019150789827108383,
0.13534966111183167,
-0.021645596250891685,
-0.4184139668941498,
-0.5165509581565857,
-0.11682289838790894,
0.14666976034641266,
0.6382428407669067,
-1.224955439567566,
0.20634061098098755,
-0.03655840829014778,
-0.5989293456077576,
-0.3226376175880432,
0.0921827033162117,
0.6500334143638611,
0.6795026659965515,
0.5129340887069702,
-0.08709365129470825,
-0.5220432877540588,
-0.769895076751709,
-0.49554598331451416,
-0.11203441768884659,
-0.09554469585418701,
0.22395414113998413,
0.5179934501647949,
-0.3082186281681061,
0.5109819769859314,
-0.7297305464744568,
-0.3465370833873749,
-0.07958657294511795,
-0.031685858964920044,
0.25653278827667236,
0.189114511013031,
0.5661545991897583,
-0.854779839515686,
-0.3847983181476593,
-0.19500291347503662,
-0.6219544410705566,
-0.2707894742488861,
0.07716786861419678,
-0.35387495160102844,
0.27094924449920654,
0.39792656898498535,
-0.814858078956604,
0.42322853207588196,
0.5530074834823608,
-0.20430848002433777,
0.893334686756134,
0.03212301433086395,
-0.016299717128276825,
-1.2591924667358398,
0.17873923480510712,
-0.17742788791656494,
0.0000164067078003427,
-0.7807233929634094,
0.6362953782081604,
-0.0777742862701416,
-0.3046208322048187,
-0.5185647010803223,
0.6830452084541321,
-0.1527765989303589,
-0.0628301277756691,
-0.20054802298545837,
0.08884751051664352,
0.0010699257254600525,
0.12244629114866257,
-0.5778162479400635,
0.879278838634491,
0.28397876024246216,
-0.5607576370239258,
0.44390955567359924,
0.2602630853652954,
-0.17835916578769684,
0.6472805142402649,
-0.6946027874946594,
0.3355613350868225,
-0.1610627919435501,
0.36763954162597656,
-0.5931740999221802,
-0.6917558908462524,
0.5215885043144226,
-0.5517727732658386,
0.6602516770362854,
-0.3790692687034607,
-0.4444504678249359,
-0.1660776138305664,
-0.4740990996360779,
0.16728250682353973,
0.29269886016845703,
-0.6215334534645081,
0.49234187602996826,
0.4717746376991272,
-0.14085479080677032,
-0.995453417301178,
-0.5086082220077515,
0.3627343475818634,
-0.5263128876686096,
-0.65980064868927,
0.48952487111091614,
0.08532754331827164,
-0.3977722227573395,
0.07953565567731857,
0.17024420201778412,
-0.06747341901063919,
0.2635638415813446,
0.16162627935409546,
0.26749101281166077,
0.08901207149028778,
0.03758589178323746,
-0.08653198927640915,
-0.22031551599502563,
-0.03918473795056343,
0.11824523657560349,
0.7131447792053223,
0.2021498680114746,
-0.4876424968242645,
-0.09190982580184937,
0.44427940249443054,
0.37226229906082153,
-0.4833643138408661,
0.6830126643180847,
0.5876796841621399,
-0.2948230504989624,
-0.41277530789375305,
-0.4751618802547455,
-0.17736375331878662,
-0.5057112574577332,
0.43384408950805664,
-0.3716728985309601,
-0.6292673349380493,
0.5259173512458801,
0.42941370606422424,
-0.24297429621219635,
0.48850950598716736,
0.66740882396698,
0.05043952167034149,
0.7748444080352783,
0.13513579964637756,
-0.1856800615787506,
0.22540995478630066,
-0.3136601746082306,
0.09905809164047241,
-1.0036357641220093,
-0.15795551240444183,
-0.7006505131721497,
-0.12167713791131973,
-0.8427371382713318,
-0.5770034790039062,
0.5947100520133972,
0.21290689706802368,
-0.2849196493625641,
0.20137625932693481,
-0.4908493757247925,
0.5194513201713562,
0.45465078949928284,
-0.042574990540742874,
0.291482150554657,
0.004180106800049543,
-0.025301147252321243,
0.09393695741891861,
-0.37197592854499817,
-0.3632887303829193,
1.2626951932907104,
0.1020364835858345,
1.2336193323135376,
0.5226495265960693,
0.8639473915100098,
0.48106858134269714,
0.28411829471588135,
-0.5610858201980591,
0.5330035090446472,
-0.2603531777858734,
-1.0541582107543945,
-0.009327780455350876,
-0.566719114780426,
-1.2476407289505005,
0.22606812417507172,
-0.1649012714624405,
-0.6039610505104065,
0.0446055568754673,
0.05320905148983002,
-0.1393655687570572,
0.30949968099594116,
-0.6116883754730225,
0.6316269636154175,
-0.12245547771453857,
-0.4599476158618927,
-0.15890251100063324,
-0.4198816120624542,
0.7050822377204895,
-0.4028501510620117,
0.058139022439718246,
0.2642399072647095,
0.15775150060653687,
0.49743062257766724,
-0.3011086583137512,
0.7657284140586853,
-0.23402483761310577,
-0.1044183149933815,
0.3487964868545532,
0.4057120978832245,
0.8571456074714661,
-0.11512482166290283,
-0.14911644160747528,
-0.01317087933421135,
-0.2598784267902374,
-0.3596966862678528,
-0.7057405114173889,
0.9098110795021057,
-0.4770536720752716,
-0.9450426697731018,
-0.5542801022529602,
-0.1627272069454193,
-0.14269323647022247,
0.12334031611680984,
0.5457181930541992,
0.22185783088207245,
-0.1063539907336235,
0.07022842019796371,
0.6729682087898254,
-0.5696736574172974,
0.17583505809307098,
0.5214086771011353,
-0.2637254297733307,
-0.40695810317993164,
1.193434715270996,
0.08704076707363129,
0.30230987071990967,
0.247289776802063,
0.052990544587373734,
-0.10983831435441971,
-0.7469286322593689,
-0.38684144616127014,
0.2705939710140228,
-0.5033887028694153,
-0.6990509033203125,
-0.5061835050582886,
-0.34804365038871765,
-0.11135938763618469,
0.1367410272359848,
-0.15830691158771515,
-0.2075420469045639,
-0.302810400724411,
-0.01676568202674389,
0.24977827072143555,
0.7288153767585754,
0.10426675528287888,
0.1879957616329193,
-0.8938713073730469,
0.46398529410362244,
0.3323853015899658,
0.097089484333992,
0.09739281982183456,
-0.6070556044578552,
-0.039731964468955994,
-0.13146039843559265,
-0.7414786219596863,
-1.350995659828186,
0.5088412165641785,
0.018233390524983406,
0.4275432527065277,
0.2962770462036133,
0.22678104043006897,
0.5305051803588867,
-0.6355404257774353,
0.8157870769500732,
-0.09112992882728577,
-0.5947248339653015,
0.6344660520553589,
-0.5503121614456177,
-0.16494575142860413,
0.2603914737701416,
0.4935831129550934,
-0.43467095494270325,
-0.6211419701576233,
-0.6265928745269775,
-0.8402426242828369,
0.3763066828250885,
0.24004222452640533,
0.29802659153938293,
-0.28595027327537537,
0.35421866178512573,
0.006037077866494656,
-0.042954929172992706,
-0.3671187162399292,
-0.27508652210235596,
-0.02972526289522648,
0.08667708933353424,
0.17607200145721436,
-0.48351478576660156,
-0.19750875234603882,
0.2112686187028885,
0.7263092398643494,
0.2343771904706955,
0.1930932104587555,
0.010412855073809624,
-0.0317760594189167,
-0.13915129005908966,
0.4903087317943573,
0.5551478862762451,
0.34556251764297485,
-0.10089229792356491,
0.29231971502304077,
0.04662704095244408,
-0.5610553026199341,
0.2158224880695343,
0.29468798637390137,
-0.24180926382541656,
-0.12309093773365021,
0.5660325884819031,
0.525849461555481,
-0.10863536596298218,
-0.6573850512504578,
0.44381311535835266,
-0.09727785736322403,
0.4507894515991211,
-0.518608570098877,
0.3388466536998749,
-0.2255874127149582,
0.16210342943668365,
0.5948944091796875,
-0.15072204172611237,
0.22588050365447998,
-0.5332431197166443,
0.3569088876247406,
0.7167280912399292,
-0.22706621885299683,
-0.42003190517425537,
0.48175549507141113,
0.001631104969419539,
-0.385773241519928,
0.5217921137809753,
-0.3191903829574585,
-0.7130345106124878,
0.294592022895813,
0.7795294523239136,
0.8611546158790588,
-0.6225636005401611,
0.12744875252246857,
0.24844226241111755,
0.231805682182312,
0.33730679750442505,
0.050104156136512756,
0.37074482440948486,
-0.6770984530448914,
-0.40626490116119385,
-0.8890751004219055,
-0.20959626138210297,
0.47522395849227905,
-0.6663991212844849,
0.16472619771957397,
-0.16194285452365875,
-0.24720245599746704,
-0.010648274794220924,
-0.16411468386650085,
-0.28958192467689514,
-0.031953636556863785,
-0.11854352056980133,
0.519478440284729,
-0.5804541707038879,
0.5579907894134521,
0.3892875611782074,
-0.45914652943611145,
-0.5610103011131287,
0.31584441661834717,
0.10492778569459915,
-0.7254540324211121,
0.8319999575614929,
-0.2534266412258148,
0.07272332906723022,
-0.17344750463962555,
-0.3814116418361664,
-0.7058190703392029,
0.6668404340744019,
0.37516045570373535,
-0.39261433482170105,
-0.27384325861930847,
0.023224588483572006,
0.4902995824813843,
0.2428256720304489,
-0.15175695717334747,
0.2992951273918152,
0.3813856840133667,
0.09460031241178513,
-0.6405482292175293,
0.1682138592004776,
-0.20011822879314423,
-0.09080084413290024,
0.5638390779495239,
-0.30090025067329407,
0.8266539573669434,
-0.18764269351959229,
-0.4504714012145996,
0.06842970103025436,
0.34809547662734985,
0.5058735013008118,
0.3384915292263031,
0.2677440643310547,
1.0267667770385742,
0.7186254262924194,
0.1187775507569313,
1.5247688293457031,
-0.11846720427274704,
0.18456050753593445,
1.3447166681289673,
-0.22970308363437653,
1.1131881475448608,
0.409741073846817,
-0.12379258126020432,
0.3678863048553467,
0.14359158277511597,
0.030535608530044556,
0.6012064218521118,
0.385906457901001,
-0.47940319776535034,
0.17601993680000305,
-0.04021471366286278,
-0.5812437534332275,
0.4598182737827301,
0.5924184322357178,
-0.4613484740257263,
-0.2799462378025055,
0.14282971620559692,
0.3304131329059601,
-0.038750018924474716,
-0.04157889261841774,
0.7994034886360168,
0.1259506493806839,
-0.6357280015945435,
0.8577366471290588,
0.18186195194721222,
0.49902695417404175,
-0.45150765776634216,
-0.07435280829668045,
-0.2648102939128876,
0.08914951235055923,
-0.338580459356308,
-0.7898582816123962,
0.6245428323745728,
0.37853723764419556,
-0.10702914744615555,
0.32695385813713074,
1.0841704607009888,
-0.12241826206445694,
-0.24169662594795227,
0.21457014977931976,
0.2610030472278595,
-0.005226416047662497,
-0.3620283305644989,
-0.49893373250961304,
0.40153008699417114,
-0.012833469547331333,
-0.40986207127571106,
0.5439063310623169,
0.3451554477214813,
-0.11893925815820694,
0.6455796360969543,
0.7988041043281555,
0.34909382462501526,
0.20577654242515564,
-0.018090270459651947,
1.0342810153961182,
-0.6227409839630127,
-0.06260904669761658,
-0.9021976590156555,
0.30421677231788635,
-0.20795440673828125,
-0.0010601227404549718,
0.9826754927635193,
0.5631046295166016,
0.7940463423728943,
0.01768861897289753,
0.6517608165740967,
-0.0224419217556715,
0.6319350600242615,
-0.6535711884498596,
0.9926814436912537,
-0.4749334156513214,
0.5672906637191772,
-0.20431917905807495,
-0.9532283544540405,
-0.2476280778646469,
0.1957661658525467,
-0.4842302203178406,
0.002362725790590048,
0.5024266242980957,
1.1320616006851196,
0.013312430121004581,
-0.28340303897857666,
0.2105647772550583,
0.6619842052459717,
0.7157742977142334,
0.3184003531932831,
1.004282832145691,
-0.315523236989975,
0.6336917877197266,
-0.09699343889951706,
0.011592898517847061,
-0.28924232721328735,
-0.6174220442771912,
-0.8315041065216064,
-0.5176231861114502,
0.06427808105945587,
-0.786328136920929,
0.4872801601886749,
0.2681913673877716,
0.26474979519844055,
-0.54173344373703,
0.2541278004646301,
-0.06080261990427971,
0.25282275676727295,
0.4336315095424652,
-0.3627605438232422,
0.4064856171607971,
-0.44562405347824097,
-0.39861583709716797,
0.4201992154121399,
0.07103836536407471,
-0.026806572452187538,
-0.4835236370563507,
0.06483768671751022,
-0.0458870604634285,
0.08284813910722733,
0.4661794602870941,
0.3770277798175812,
-0.6350051164627075,
-0.27562984824180603,
-0.2321174293756485,
-0.19464461505413055,
-0.25535959005355835,
0.5416180491447449,
-0.7222859263420105,
0.450091689825058,
0.5756732225418091,
0.6569682359695435,
0.5878565311431885,
0.17479372024536133,
0.34607893228530884,
-0.9055193662643433,
0.13988633453845978,
0.5789389610290527,
0.11285313963890076,
0.37148022651672363,
-0.5078566074371338,
0.44625192880630493,
0.11964552104473114,
-0.657341480255127,
-1.1924247741699219,
0.5240305662155151,
-0.6996397972106934,
-0.3230873942375183,
1.1623733043670654,
-0.0005261353217065334,
-0.4455447793006897,
-0.10062146931886673,
-0.11984747648239136,
0.016253821551799774,
-0.09011244773864746,
1.003496527671814,
0.39430662989616394,
0.1467154622077942,
0.3295232355594635,
-0.9131919741630554,
0.6213581562042236,
0.058709729462862015,
-0.9865681529045105,
-0.0011065430007874966,
0.5462350845336914,
0.1836758553981781,
0.3095504939556122,
0.4200595021247864,
-0.350378155708313,
0.15232394635677338,
-0.052875958383083344,
-0.28095120191574097,
0.10538149625062943,
-0.28366103768348694,
-0.19830453395843506,
0.4472571015357971,
-0.007637420669198036,
0.023247597739100456
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00936v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00936v1
|
A Survey of Useful LLM Evaluation
| 2024-06-03T02:20:03 | 2024-06-03T02:20:03 |
Ji-Lun Peng, Sijia Cheng, Egil Diau, Yung-Yu Shih, Po-Heng Chen, Yen-Ting Lin, Yun-Nung Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
LLMs have gotten attention across various research domains due to their
exceptional performance on a wide range of complex tasks. Therefore, refined
methods to evaluate the capabilities of LLMs are needed to determine the tasks
and responsibility they should undertake. Our study mainly discussed how LLMs,
as useful tools, should be effectively assessed. We proposed the two-stage
framework: from ``core ability'' to ``agent'', clearly explaining how LLMs can
be applied based on their specific capabilities, along with the evaluation
methods in each stage. Core ability refers to the capabilities that LLMs need
in order to generate high-quality natural language texts. After confirming LLMs
possess core ability, they can solve real-world and complex tasks as agent. In
the "core ability" stage, we discussed the reasoning ability, societal impact,
and domain knowledge of LLMs. In the ``agent'' stage, we demonstrated embodied
action, planning, and tool learning of LLMs agent applications. Finally, we
examined the challenges currently confronting the evaluation methods for LLMs,
as well as the directions for future development.
|
[
-0.40522870421409607,
-0.7123928070068359,
0.6024925708770752,
0.14054034650325775,
-0.255033940076828,
0.37847715616226196,
-0.29391467571258545,
-0.5183118581771851,
-0.1554240882396698,
0.46392324566841125,
-0.44662073254585266,
-0.5258488059043884,
-0.6155651211738586,
0.43935883045196533,
-0.5110576152801514,
0.8269441723823547,
-0.04326002672314644,
0.23138141632080078,
-0.497052937746048,
0.010821406729519367,
-0.5640279054641724,
-0.36259883642196655,
-0.5925743579864502,
-0.6895788908004761,
0.506151020526886,
0.49186739325523376,
0.5490248203277588,
0.1728486716747284,
0.6770227551460266,
0.382076621055603,
-0.27793073654174805,
0.3343115746974945,
-0.5844826698303223,
0.15501710772514343,
-0.4379616975784302,
-0.477186381816864,
-0.8036136627197266,
0.27705511450767517,
0.6512818932533264,
0.6546700596809387,
0.20224668085575104,
0.3803117573261261,
0.45157942175865173,
0.5869027376174927,
-0.37329915165901184,
0.11084911972284317,
-0.3608824908733368,
0.020213961601257324,
0.0629906952381134,
-0.3156542181968689,
-0.27127790451049805,
-0.4104509949684143,
0.24948741495609283,
-0.4656394124031067,
-0.05129219591617584,
-0.024185072630643845,
0.47619593143463135,
0.05145992338657379,
-0.4737825393676758,
-0.6431083083152771,
-0.7935500741004944,
0.8961055874824524,
-0.5278885960578918,
-0.04165899008512497,
0.24078364670276642,
0.6103514432907104,
-0.28887853026390076,
-0.7586130499839783,
-0.34337735176086426,
-0.4544035792350769,
-0.025482259690761566,
0.18807773292064667,
-0.020331477746367455,
0.053001005202531815,
0.022546937689185143,
0.43910911679267883,
-0.23994004726409912,
0.3470557630062103,
-0.20263361930847168,
-0.4460132420063019,
0.7848465442657471,
0.5334228277206421,
0.3792167901992798,
-0.25768807530403137,
-0.45291686058044434,
0.040452465415000916,
-0.5146265029907227,
0.11007699370384216,
0.3200192451477051,
0.18322478234767914,
0.11218906939029694,
0.7691131234169006,
-0.10233676433563232,
0.45637139678001404,
-0.19184260070323944,
-0.5166159272193909,
-0.0013913365546613932,
-0.547640860080719,
-0.15930363535881042,
-0.4149850904941559,
0.49690285325050354,
0.5083305835723877,
0.20137155055999756,
-0.42777809500694275,
-0.476516991853714,
-0.05715647712349892,
0.5388481020927429,
-0.5589319467544556,
0.5998139381408691,
0.32746264338493347,
-0.5285409092903137,
-0.1533169448375702,
-0.22969165444374084,
-0.5689313411712646,
-0.5042758584022522,
-0.37031102180480957,
0.5839022397994995,
-0.33410894870758057,
-0.36856013536453247,
0.06239940971136093,
-0.21929246187210083,
0.40679362416267395,
0.42623940110206604,
-0.47419440746307373,
0.5289143323898315,
0.7874375581741333,
0.6311920881271362,
-0.5243982672691345,
-0.3423573076725006,
-0.05318572372198105,
-0.13042710721492767,
-0.1279790997505188,
0.9761708378791809,
-0.34970179200172424,
-0.6128113269805908,
0.09825675934553146,
-0.14181166887283325,
-0.021729061380028725,
-0.6735283136367798,
0.920904278755188,
-0.4752371609210968,
-0.1236158087849617,
-0.3683610260486603,
-0.5360418558120728,
-0.2634945213794708,
0.6359611749649048,
-0.6504199504852295,
1.0395230054855347,
0.3174588978290558,
-0.49804922938346863,
0.3186459243297577,
-0.7688551545143127,
-0.45716744661331177,
0.25155001878738403,
-0.03497340902686119,
-0.2292071431875229,
-0.09669163823127747,
0.03451485186815262,
0.7799798846244812,
-0.580572247505188,
0.2297857105731964,
0.09500531852245331,
-0.4563291668891907,
0.42142611742019653,
-0.3781006336212158,
0.6000354290008545,
0.16974346339702606,
-0.3270305097103119,
0.18550454080104828,
-0.7718644738197327,
0.23004961013793945,
0.008915340527892113,
-0.5304784774780273,
-0.03681068867444992,
0.041336316615343094,
-0.08123285323381424,
-0.08365128189325333,
0.3899405598640442,
-0.22685886919498444,
0.07891098409891129,
-0.49873387813568115,
0.3897869884967804,
0.6305937767028809,
0.09562939405441284,
0.6130125522613525,
-0.4654814302921295,
0.7819495797157288,
-0.47675180435180664,
0.18462598323822021,
0.13613423705101013,
-0.3461984097957611,
-0.755911648273468,
-0.22414691746234894,
0.06653190404176712,
0.49563249945640564,
-0.6947931051254272,
0.5443816781044006,
-0.077037014067173,
-0.9295908808708191,
-0.16603997349739075,
0.307417631149292,
0.5594779849052429,
0.22394147515296936,
0.1402525007724762,
-0.37097132205963135,
-0.4772602319717407,
-0.9083815813064575,
-0.377443790435791,
-0.3572080135345459,
0.1434762179851532,
0.25233301520347595,
0.6947051286697388,
-0.3716132938861847,
1.121288776397705,
-0.0810379758477211,
-0.16475719213485718,
-0.7311965227127075,
-0.0336901880800724,
0.05845819041132927,
0.13095858693122864,
0.3592227101325989,
-0.4808591604232788,
-0.013385524041950703,
-0.089470773935318,
-0.8066911697387695,
-0.3335769474506378,
0.03499157354235649,
-0.15780244767665863,
-0.1691325604915619,
0.08529414236545563,
-0.5801599621772766,
0.13356289267539978,
0.30539897084236145,
-0.3552722632884979,
0.8189744353294373,
-0.08407747000455856,
0.10668555647134781,
-0.7674102783203125,
0.15223561227321625,
-0.18906377255916595,
-0.26743751764297485,
-0.6509784460067749,
0.10362755507230759,
-0.12979237735271454,
0.004748035222291946,
-0.6097511649131775,
0.869585394859314,
-0.7297017574310303,
-0.4654463529586792,
-0.46322256326675415,
0.5418493747711182,
-0.02010837197303772,
0.04263541102409363,
-0.3199140131473541,
0.8207003474235535,
0.4005197286605835,
-0.9434781670570374,
0.5249258279800415,
0.029705317690968513,
-0.4293856918811798,
0.7347835302352905,
-0.5110836029052734,
0.17430540919303894,
0.008733431808650494,
-0.08296079933643341,
-0.8323540091514587,
0.14661617577075958,
0.17912337183952332,
-0.4055258333683014,
0.08914922922849655,
0.2972823679447174,
-0.4913603663444519,
-0.3007931411266327,
-0.41297489404678345,
0.10945703089237213,
0.1844843477010727,
-0.12658128142356873,
0.9488318562507629,
0.4680798649787903,
-0.010355993174016476,
-0.5314115285873413,
-0.4859488308429718,
0.22436100244522095,
-0.22592642903327942,
-0.5586221814155579,
0.13246965408325195,
-0.06009555235505104,
-0.48586952686309814,
0.09667398780584335,
-0.18215526640415192,
0.05209185928106308,
0.38251301646232605,
0.4115622043609619,
0.052461039274930954,
0.03826957568526268,
-0.00933117512613535,
-0.05138730630278587,
-0.39223596453666687,
0.22323471307754517,
0.3031689524650574,
0.33029550313949585,
-0.30137959122657776,
-0.5066033601760864,
0.06060854718089104,
0.12055294960737228,
0.3463608920574188,
-0.0756499394774437,
0.17413772642612457,
0.6310375928878784,
-0.4330728054046631,
-0.31296736001968384,
-0.6674361228942871,
-0.13828183710575104,
-0.41035106778144836,
0.4940004348754883,
-0.2009306401014328,
-1.0324121713638306,
0.42566120624542236,
-0.3429860770702362,
0.3036690354347229,
0.5308841466903687,
0.9127576351165771,
0.06825222074985504,
0.43329837918281555,
0.5445371866226196,
0.07271979004144669,
0.080197773873806,
-0.46933454275131226,
0.24960434436798096,
-0.9782238006591797,
-0.5089545249938965,
-0.5448378920555115,
-0.3303934931755066,
-0.1030125766992569,
-0.6677702069282532,
0.40510061383247375,
0.18439112603664398,
0.1502569168806076,
0.36679843068122864,
-0.35442739725112915,
0.3240291476249695,
0.1996334195137024,
0.031755607575178146,
0.5399344563484192,
-0.06931018084287643,
-0.23327131569385529,
0.07829317450523376,
-0.34792205691337585,
-1.4353396892547607,
1.0891737937927246,
0.6461904048919678,
0.7895787358283997,
-0.12646520137786865,
0.37646374106407166,
0.5951181650161743,
0.6043444871902466,
-1.184612512588501,
1.0643389225006104,
0.2739419937133789,
-0.6711298823356628,
-0.5176941156387329,
-0.09399691969156265,
-1.063187599182129,
0.4746433198451996,
-0.2423674613237381,
-0.589678168296814,
-0.34196001291275024,
-0.22593113780021667,
-0.15348729491233826,
-0.035008758306503296,
-0.6715629696846008,
0.5862158536911011,
-0.5971936583518982,
-0.12998104095458984,
-0.49518707394599915,
-0.29260870814323425,
0.1723032295703888,
0.12542183697223663,
0.1696309745311737,
-0.47086554765701294,
-0.43106508255004883,
0.8788649439811707,
-0.018556559458374977,
1.006576657295227,
-0.06424624472856522,
-0.12164417654275894,
0.656705915927887,
-0.02784193865954876,
0.1882636696100235,
0.2377975583076477,
-0.40313634276390076,
-0.04076199606060982,
0.023326361551880836,
-0.1349954605102539,
-0.7378911375999451,
0.4535195529460907,
-0.7993007898330688,
-0.788524329662323,
-0.3801291584968567,
-0.4417950510978699,
-0.4554378390312195,
0.3346816301345825,
-0.10650334507226944,
0.31445834040641785,
-0.76798015832901,
0.0015010182978585362,
0.24383772909641266,
0.019586898386478424,
0.5232054591178894,
0.7808769345283508,
-0.21725168824195862,
-0.46806976199150085,
0.6692829132080078,
0.18337246775627136,
0.22378619015216827,
0.2202567458152771,
0.1360367238521576,
-0.22044773399829865,
-0.8144963979721069,
-0.2549600899219513,
0.13964694738388062,
-0.926121175289154,
-0.23361562192440033,
-0.5491452813148499,
-0.20626144111156464,
-0.06128155067563057,
-0.17475733160972595,
-0.1768438220024109,
-0.3421315550804138,
-0.4329770803451538,
-0.3417968451976776,
-0.06311164051294327,
0.9501677751541138,
0.1847512274980545,
0.14951226115226746,
-0.7481873035430908,
0.19671793282032013,
0.40906137228012085,
0.11057902872562408,
0.09410662204027176,
-0.2201492339372635,
-0.4463786780834198,
-0.25811848044395447,
-0.5345462560653687,
-0.752334475517273,
0.12539246678352356,
0.05886581912636757,
1.2340774536132812,
0.20580506324768066,
0.014894580468535423,
0.32947421073913574,
-0.1467260718345642,
0.9320967197418213,
-0.1487378031015396,
-0.8944628834724426,
0.37355366349220276,
0.02329750545322895,
0.16421616077423096,
0.6114662885665894,
0.2904374301433563,
-0.21200869977474213,
-0.4962494671344757,
-0.37103021144866943,
-0.7292644381523132,
0.4990446865558624,
0.563859760761261,
0.2222287505865097,
0.14112523198127747,
0.5312103629112244,
0.2008783519268036,
0.30527132749557495,
-0.5154003500938416,
-0.13989529013633728,
0.13248996436595917,
0.1897093504667282,
-0.003242786740884185,
-0.5876011848449707,
-0.18804404139518738,
-0.01336382981389761,
0.5112662315368652,
-0.12850432097911835,
0.2863486409187317,
0.356095552444458,
-0.4248177111148834,
0.14800526201725006,
0.7603517174720764,
0.41117119789123535,
1.1572321653366089,
-0.04818183556199074,
0.19775374233722687,
0.4475540518760681,
-0.5886543989181519,
0.32753026485443115,
-0.22308887541294098,
-0.00866028480231762,
-0.2883274257183075,
0.7073405385017395,
0.38910219073295593,
0.27285051345825195,
-0.936418890953064,
0.42427295446395874,
0.0029513114131987095,
-0.15492086112499237,
-0.1339113712310791,
0.16249139606952667,
0.23525460064411163,
0.42287519574165344,
0.600938618183136,
-0.26117777824401855,
0.27184948325157166,
-0.6463475227355957,
-0.005871432367712259,
0.47207942605018616,
-0.3756921887397766,
-0.24772417545318604,
-0.050044674426317215,
0.5109627842903137,
-0.46774759888648987,
0.10722372680902481,
-0.34123361110687256,
-0.6495728492736816,
0.7261779308319092,
0.5731569528579712,
0.9683582186698914,
-0.10909169167280197,
0.2686612904071808,
0.07077453285455704,
0.7463617324829102,
0.033300869166851044,
0.3748345971107483,
0.06775686889886856,
-0.8743785619735718,
-0.3510047495365143,
-0.5791155695915222,
-0.6687860488891602,
-0.12837770581245422,
-0.41779467463493347,
0.23117125034332275,
-0.3686617314815521,
-0.6122444868087769,
-0.44680729508399963,
0.5051252841949463,
-0.7109972834587097,
0.26241251826286316,
-0.317441463470459,
0.9727544784545898,
-0.6088141202926636,
0.3430670201778412,
1.0321673154830933,
-0.18893642723560333,
-0.618026614189148,
-0.3200148642063141,
0.027288397774100304,
-0.8783339858055115,
0.6305937767028809,
0.22000272572040558,
-0.4171685576438904,
-0.24374334514141083,
-0.3361130952835083,
-0.5350285768508911,
1.5157649517059326,
0.36943745613098145,
-0.33912965655326843,
-0.07781441509723663,
0.22540736198425293,
0.779313325881958,
-0.6216009855270386,
0.6672930717468262,
0.734003484249115,
0.629887044429779,
-0.10019469261169434,
-1.0213767290115356,
0.06460396200418472,
-0.23603636026382446,
0.1510249823331833,
-0.31894445419311523,
-0.557437002658844,
0.3860396146774292,
-0.13569049537181854,
-0.4945431053638458,
0.037373483180999756,
0.6455396413803101,
0.25650307536125183,
0.49241212010383606,
0.5446190237998962,
0.23811133205890656,
0.6747514605522156,
0.0581410713493824,
0.9148023128509521,
-0.2677120566368103,
0.3361397087574005,
0.6049594879150391,
-0.2822049856185913,
0.6903290748596191,
0.2913799583911896,
-0.21573278307914734,
0.19435013830661774,
0.4207662343978882,
0.13118422031402588,
0.12969925999641418,
0.4338757395744324,
-0.14269880950450897,
-0.3214983642101288,
-0.3291468620300293,
-0.12946923077106476,
0.4024334251880646,
0.4594457149505615,
-0.1707778424024582,
-0.44475653767585754,
0.07339838147163391,
-0.0436185859143734,
0.3207581341266632,
-0.3776164650917053,
0.7211369872093201,
0.2535097897052765,
-0.5426969528198242,
0.22649694979190826,
0.1605205237865448,
0.563569962978363,
-0.5367235541343689,
-0.07566028088331223,
-0.04477641358971596,
-0.02705259993672371,
-0.4219169318675995,
-1.077602505683899,
0.3773132562637329,
0.19804199039936066,
-0.05776924639940262,
-0.30738985538482666,
1.2142175436019897,
0.10181599855422974,
-0.40445712208747864,
0.5409915447235107,
0.941663920879364,
0.27959874272346497,
0.05522216483950615,
-0.6136375069618225,
0.12384872138500214,
-0.416648268699646,
-0.5089084506034851,
0.21710379421710968,
0.35315021872520447,
0.040439359843730927,
0.9983197450637817,
0.37687957286834717,
0.22921070456504822,
-0.19372163712978363,
0.23714768886566162,
0.9487131237983704,
-0.7923330068588257,
0.020081952214241028,
-0.8110700845718384,
0.5739796757698059,
-0.06989055126905441,
-0.31695854663848877,
0.9310378432273865,
0.6149430871009827,
0.6014317274093628,
0.19065873324871063,
0.7912264466285706,
-0.10140746086835861,
0.5910735726356506,
-0.5295619964599609,
0.48210588097572327,
-0.3539595305919647,
0.5733920931816101,
-0.21259689331054688,
-1.067371129989624,
-0.10801437497138977,
0.41755610704421997,
-0.32199859619140625,
0.16890116035938263,
0.8879960179328918,
0.6356658339500427,
0.4539842903614044,
-0.10802069306373596,
0.5067154169082642,
-0.11616497486829758,
0.43863949179649353,
0.40663212537765503,
1.1242859363555908,
-0.29130882024765015,
0.5566290616989136,
-0.05176272243261337,
-0.338249534368515,
-0.15205880999565125,
-0.9974518418312073,
-1.29185950756073,
-0.42833858728408813,
-0.04615485295653343,
-0.2400239109992981,
0.00839682575315237,
0.8849973082542419,
0.4392886459827423,
-0.322224497795105,
-0.5791255235671997,
0.40847790241241455,
0.44736745953559875,
-0.3248375356197357,
-0.1939389407634735,
0.10921486467123032,
-0.4012390375137329,
-0.639408528804779,
0.5313652157783508,
0.535354495048523,
-0.08769851922988892,
-0.7230662107467651,
-0.3003844618797302,
0.0631205216050148,
-0.07768873125314713,
1.0065127611160278,
-0.0701342523097992,
-0.8128029704093933,
-0.19131654500961304,
0.11966194957494736,
-0.3683478832244873,
-0.18282179534435272,
1.1200952529907227,
-0.581831157207489,
0.417576402425766,
0.5009468793869019,
0.7503892183303833,
0.0875784307718277,
-0.05110813304781914,
0.6363210082054138,
-0.23162201046943665,
-0.2636123299598694,
0.5756340026855469,
0.2530684769153595,
0.30802351236343384,
-0.29134684801101685,
0.7479391098022461,
-0.0386522077023983,
-0.7039830088615417,
-0.6597847938537598,
0.04780644178390503,
-1.1651675701141357,
-0.06028659641742706,
1.382051706314087,
-0.2363717406988144,
0.014903132803738117,
-0.5211377739906311,
-0.5311924815177917,
0.3042464256286621,
-0.1988723874092102,
0.47885003685951233,
0.8298087120056152,
-0.1918293982744217,
-0.20407912135124207,
-0.4938223659992218,
0.31730151176452637,
0.19170518219470978,
-1.0140761137008667,
-0.3327708840370178,
0.21280981600284576,
0.2415066957473755,
0.24926947057247162,
0.8564043045043945,
-0.2807145118713379,
0.0007274480885826051,
-0.27518895268440247,
0.006777297705411911,
-0.1515866070985794,
-0.19223938882350922,
-0.28900203108787537,
0.27975037693977356,
0.7414030432701111,
0.22747904062271118
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00922v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00922v2
|
MEDIQ: Question-Asking LLMs for Adaptive and Reliable Clinical Reasoning
| 2024-06-03T01:32:52 | 2024-06-04T13:55:05 |
Shuyue Stella Li, Vidhisha Balachandran, Shangbin Feng, Jonathan Ilgen, Emma Pierson, Pang Wei Koh, Yulia Tsvetkov
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
In high-stakes domains like clinical reasoning, AI assistants powered by
large language models (LLMs) are yet to be reliable and safe. We identify a key
obstacle towards reliability: existing LLMs are trained to answer any question,
even with incomplete context in the prompt or insufficient parametric
knowledge. We propose to change this paradigm to develop more careful LLMs that
ask follow-up questions to gather necessary and sufficient information and
respond reliably. We introduce MEDIQ, a framework to simulate realistic
clinical interactions, which incorporates a Patient System and an adaptive
Expert System. The Patient may provide incomplete information in the beginning;
the Expert refrains from making diagnostic decisions when unconfident, and
instead elicits missing details from the Patient via follow-up questions. To
evaluate MEDIQ, we convert MEDQA and CRAFT-MD -- medical benchmarks for
diagnostic question answering -- into an interactive setup. We develop a
reliable Patient system and prototype several Expert systems, first showing
that directly prompting state-of-the-art LLMs to ask questions degrades the
quality of clinical reasoning, indicating that adapting LLMs to interactive
information-seeking settings is nontrivial. We then augment the Expert with a
novel abstention module to better estimate model confidence and decide whether
to ask more questions, thereby improving diagnostic accuracy by 20.3%; however,
performance still lags compared to an (unrealistic in practice) upper bound
when full information is given upfront. Further analyses reveal that
interactive performance can be improved by filtering irrelevant contexts and
reformatting conversations. Overall, our paper introduces a novel problem
towards LLM reliability, a novel MEDIQ framework, and highlights important
future directions to extend the information-seeking abilities of LLM assistants
in critical domains.
|
[
-0.2215496003627777,
-0.7423532605171204,
1.1255849599838257,
0.10307273268699646,
0.031092416495084763,
0.1728522926568985,
0.03314535692334175,
-0.30349311232566833,
0.2066057175397873,
0.5240412354469299,
-0.6159420609474182,
-0.1809343844652176,
-0.6672267317771912,
0.10296229273080826,
-0.09511711448431015,
0.6958348751068115,
-0.23035599291324615,
0.23660191893577576,
-0.5400180816650391,
-0.4537051320075989,
-0.5815494656562805,
-0.2853514850139618,
-0.94511878490448,
-0.1933298408985138,
0.569465160369873,
0.5115033388137817,
0.9828504323959351,
0.543032169342041,
0.5347988605499268,
0.2759864628314972,
0.20955811440944672,
0.5026965141296387,
-0.31798669695854187,
0.4723125398159027,
0.08786346018314362,
-0.6619566082954407,
-0.6776573657989502,
0.002399895805865526,
0.3285585343837738,
0.9245432019233704,
-0.29400062561035156,
-0.19589509069919586,
-0.340838223695755,
0.4502136707305908,
-0.5468421578407288,
-0.21199628710746765,
-0.46824073791503906,
-0.1451026201248169,
0.12641115486621857,
-0.5580023527145386,
-0.4522465467453003,
-0.27716490626335144,
0.20437736809253693,
-0.8252490758895874,
-0.16820581257343292,
0.15887214243412018,
0.4908537268638611,
0.6061832904815674,
-0.22706185281276703,
-0.3035847544670105,
-0.7858061790466309,
0.477639377117157,
-0.6269460916519165,
0.36703094840049744,
0.8192986249923706,
0.3338158428668976,
-0.30061352252960205,
-0.7115090489387512,
-0.3959880769252777,
-0.4612555503845215,
0.01611226424574852,
0.42568233609199524,
-0.058046068996191025,
0.04201482608914375,
0.12639835476875305,
-0.029103469103574753,
-0.48544466495513916,
-0.03103514015674591,
-0.31569069623947144,
0.046391576528549194,
0.6023976802825928,
0.5157606601715088,
0.38812047243118286,
0.3158430755138397,
-0.32486486434936523,
0.22707703709602356,
-0.8036551475524902,
-0.03919583186507225,
-0.23592239618301392,
-0.35951510071754456,
-0.015772920101881027,
0.4462861120700836,
-0.041428692638874054,
0.5703333616256714,
0.19147783517837524,
-0.2619263827800751,
-0.04120051488280296,
-0.15782436728477478,
-0.003618912771344185,
-0.21443268656730652,
0.4862593114376068,
0.4736982583999634,
0.3906889259815216,
-0.11048635840415955,
0.06154227629303932,
-0.31963464617729187,
0.5929521918296814,
-0.2695977985858917,
-0.2712683081626892,
0.8737683892250061,
-0.37115588784217834,
-0.11194388568401337,
-0.22619353234767914,
-0.3507589101791382,
-0.5153836607933044,
-0.31710419058799744,
0.37442874908447266,
-0.6443228721618652,
-0.15010245144367218,
0.23581463098526,
0.11702141910791397,
0.17640256881713867,
0.817190408706665,
-0.40564361214637756,
0.27747979760169983,
0.4110390543937683,
0.48181408643722534,
-0.29417020082473755,
-0.35415756702423096,
-0.6759862899780273,
0.34510278701782227,
-0.48965540528297424,
0.8085702061653137,
-0.43323981761932373,
-0.3056398630142212,
-0.21976622939109802,
0.12294454127550125,
-0.2500562071800232,
-0.7759836316108704,
0.2361569106578827,
-0.35975807905197144,
0.240146666765213,
-0.12118815630674362,
-0.5633403658866882,
0.19667087495326996,
0.5595700144767761,
-0.36102473735809326,
0.7686657905578613,
0.3203623592853546,
-0.4883832037448883,
0.254309743642807,
-0.5426506996154785,
-0.27274221181869507,
0.3763293921947479,
-0.3714183270931244,
-0.19098395109176636,
-0.12507350742816925,
0.3465016484260559,
0.32970303297042847,
-0.45644429326057434,
0.3581516742706299,
-0.3303777873516083,
-0.4308793246746063,
0.6521106362342834,
-0.4293738901615143,
0.5674801468849182,
0.1453186273574829,
-0.04276059940457344,
0.11207449436187744,
-0.8177505731582642,
0.06977756321430206,
-0.03136906772851944,
-0.2808763086795807,
-0.21456831693649292,
0.1507338136434555,
-0.4555458724498749,
-0.05233033001422882,
0.029105376452207565,
-0.4859636425971985,
0.005117551889270544,
-0.17295534908771515,
0.16154025495052338,
0.6820126175880432,
0.22669878602027893,
0.03922652080655098,
-0.9378161430358887,
0.8032402396202087,
0.052026327699422836,
0.39971494674682617,
-0.18637777864933014,
-0.5782366394996643,
-0.8318185210227966,
-0.2857319414615631,
-0.02794083021581173,
0.8193992376327515,
-0.9963892698287964,
-0.04971485212445259,
-0.06700726598501205,
-0.3626146614551544,
-0.8678217530250549,
-0.05940248444676399,
0.2666698098182678,
0.8120262622833252,
0.5676503777503967,
-0.0435030497610569,
-0.37546631693840027,
-0.6936926245689392,
-0.012496093288064003,
-0.5754367709159851,
-0.3362119197845459,
0.578567624092102,
0.19952097535133362,
-0.2797912657260895,
0.671280026435852,
-0.40234264731407166,
-0.08436357975006104,
-0.3501378297805786,
-0.04593094810843468,
0.09368289262056351,
0.3908996880054474,
0.2708956301212311,
-0.7494044303894043,
-0.16719062626361847,
-0.0851263478398323,
-0.9046828746795654,
-0.19341234862804413,
-0.335546612739563,
-0.041439156979322433,
-0.04715275019407272,
0.6453216671943665,
-0.6790243983268738,
0.5536426305770874,
0.25499239563941956,
-0.1705358624458313,
0.4523007869720459,
-0.41425222158432007,
0.3088982403278351,
-1.0189467668533325,
0.4250502288341522,
-0.3900534212589264,
-0.26390329003334045,
-0.7896627187728882,
0.0795474722981453,
-0.171556293964386,
-0.01550403144210577,
-0.3981699049472809,
0.7912099361419678,
-0.23959019780158997,
0.3628782629966736,
-0.23558400571346283,
0.07227591425180435,
0.06954038143157959,
0.3610459268093109,
-0.07955408841371536,
0.7799399495124817,
0.22612422704696655,
-0.6869435906410217,
0.5000909566879272,
0.2936832904815674,
-0.16138042509555817,
1.111845850944519,
-0.8178820610046387,
0.21540570259094238,
-0.20171305537223816,
0.05285929515957832,
-0.9378308057785034,
-0.4233013093471527,
0.25387486815452576,
-0.5989553928375244,
0.23789916932582855,
-0.043615661561489105,
-0.17231899499893188,
-0.22743800282478333,
-0.06290863454341888,
0.547583281993866,
0.4721556007862091,
-0.15103285014629364,
0.6727072596549988,
0.23537993431091309,
-0.6239790320396423,
-0.5140498876571655,
-0.507713258266449,
0.13643987476825714,
0.02357720211148262,
-0.5321758389472961,
-0.15506383776664734,
-0.37096062302589417,
-0.3648265302181244,
-0.06647361069917679,
0.13757437467575073,
-0.2259625345468521,
0.39432957768440247,
0.14720863103866577,
0.3580591082572937,
-0.13015899062156677,
0.29397448897361755,
0.1410086750984192,
-0.09991984814405441,
0.18454760313034058,
0.053413525223731995,
0.3039827048778534,
0.023213066160678864,
-0.8366422057151794,
-0.4562578797340393,
0.5910038948059082,
0.8724554777145386,
-0.09453568607568741,
0.5387092232704163,
0.2645663022994995,
-0.550264298915863,
0.16456522047519684,
-0.7717581391334534,
-0.20286597311496735,
-0.39810630679130554,
0.40460655093193054,
-0.42046040296554565,
-0.7276304364204407,
0.4876919388771057,
-0.09586045891046524,
0.06118202209472656,
0.1651126742362976,
0.6697344183921814,
-0.5688705444335938,
1.341343641281128,
0.3327316343784332,
0.15069277584552765,
-0.24435126781463623,
0.196241095662117,
-0.12983475625514984,
-0.7748112082481384,
-0.43027544021606445,
-0.26806512475013733,
-0.1659938395023346,
-0.07978971302509308,
-0.4011809825897217,
0.8396046161651611,
-0.1459999531507492,
-0.27749040722846985,
-0.2974666655063629,
-0.2530660033226013,
0.06200389564037323,
0.4934665262699127,
0.37740206718444824,
0.33823397755622864,
-0.3748912513256073,
-0.2451498806476593,
0.02570115216076374,
-0.8098992109298706,
-0.38307204842567444,
0.9174038171768188,
0.5009136199951172,
0.9498021602630615,
0.1250905692577362,
0.22393196821212769,
0.1807604283094406,
0.4859909117221832,
-0.6441775560379028,
0.3950607180595398,
0.3445604741573334,
-0.5080852508544922,
-0.25445249676704407,
-0.20828872919082642,
-0.8247354030609131,
-0.10477625578641891,
-0.14739571511745453,
-0.4505026638507843,
0.31625452637672424,
0.17814061045646667,
-0.6856557130813599,
0.2287604659795761,
-0.29535627365112305,
0.508277952671051,
-0.2629499137401581,
-0.32242608070373535,
0.22264352440834045,
-0.9774844646453857,
0.10888342559337616,
-0.08897142857313156,
0.15853635966777802,
-0.1257391721010208,
-0.3504255414009094,
0.4412994086742401,
-0.5730522871017456,
0.7259289026260376,
0.015889419242739677,
0.10772460699081421,
0.12415025383234024,
0.37739279866218567,
0.2978583872318268,
0.3160912096500397,
-0.09177955240011215,
-0.33273351192474365,
0.2849496901035309,
-0.6474791765213013,
-0.8450533151626587,
0.3740978538990021,
-0.7141473293304443,
-0.8832566142082214,
-0.3617221415042877,
-0.782734751701355,
-0.6967473030090332,
0.05779511481523514,
0.08391236513853073,
0.422218918800354,
-0.0300764050334692,
0.06157582998275757,
0.739439845085144,
-0.20402483642101288,
-0.24380290508270264,
0.6147278547286987,
0.15245972573757172,
-0.4007539749145508,
0.5404537320137024,
-0.1802201122045517,
0.4758492112159729,
0.2357434183359146,
0.004637479316443205,
-0.03490320220589638,
-0.8021838068962097,
-0.6676645874977112,
0.38254880905151367,
-0.6043452620506287,
-0.25129544734954834,
-0.7059951424598694,
-0.4279767870903015,
-0.17961373925209045,
-0.27313750982284546,
-0.3222365081310272,
-0.24838563799858093,
-0.42466190457344055,
-0.0012008447665721178,
0.43722519278526306,
0.5805279016494751,
0.1156114712357521,
0.04435517266392708,
-0.8154375553131104,
0.13970863819122314,
0.26597100496292114,
0.28189441561698914,
-0.1653852015733719,
-0.6458701491355896,
-0.018373064696788788,
0.1327497661113739,
-0.15361614525318146,
-0.7521705031394958,
0.18831078708171844,
0.04387741535902023,
0.6374419927597046,
0.39022296667099,
0.3393479585647583,
0.610733151435852,
-0.46207794547080994,
0.4750625193119049,
-0.06370414793491364,
-0.40638646483421326,
0.5930172204971313,
-0.3153725862503052,
0.3476424515247345,
0.8435561656951904,
0.6725046038627625,
-0.6367233991622925,
-0.7372932434082031,
-0.4801538288593292,
-0.4732650816440582,
0.4911361634731293,
-0.04729210585355759,
-0.11759316921234131,
-0.21019244194030762,
0.7381643056869507,
0.0014194202376529574,
0.03168828785419464,
-0.21308916807174683,
-0.12235993146896362,
0.21674352884292603,
-0.5596931576728821,
0.16284744441509247,
-0.23587751388549805,
-0.477506160736084,
-0.1881767064332962,
0.4077138602733612,
-0.36850109696388245,
0.37141162157058716,
0.6897199153900146,
0.06744908541440964,
-0.15147508680820465,
0.16809892654418945,
0.6765668392181396,
0.9760913848876953,
-0.3086162507534027,
0.11764474958181381,
0.36897012591362,
-0.6153303384780884,
0.29133370518684387,
0.08687862753868103,
-0.06100970134139061,
-0.2572903633117676,
0.4946483373641968,
0.5831266641616821,
0.007231622934341431,
-1.0747787952423096,
0.5408709049224854,
-0.2107609212398529,
-0.3510262072086334,
-0.44879940152168274,
0.06914158165454865,
0.07200606167316437,
0.19695165753364563,
0.26757124066352844,
0.22600224614143372,
-0.029074564576148987,
-0.5704582333564758,
0.4470372796058655,
0.1782815158367157,
-0.7860293984413147,
-0.11792036890983582,
0.829231321811676,
0.1022840365767479,
-0.3799359202384949,
0.6432905197143555,
0.19876591861248016,
-0.3509473204612732,
0.6368746757507324,
0.42048379778862,
0.3775406777858734,
-0.3186081349849701,
0.17168453335762024,
-0.10011731088161469,
0.3304859697818756,
0.008489951491355896,
0.6676833033561707,
0.2809693515300751,
-0.6089429259300232,
-0.4166065752506256,
0.11559216678142548,
-1.0266790390014648,
0.19862298667430878,
-0.5641416311264038,
0.0828307494521141,
-0.7036702036857605,
0.00507495878264308,
-0.475748747587204,
-0.3028225004673004,
-0.403415709733963,
0.4154636561870575,
-0.19260510802268982,
1.066748857498169,
-0.40644705295562744,
0.5603719353675842,
0.8089832067489624,
-0.1786780208349228,
-0.8506531715393066,
-0.14016667008399963,
-0.023069994524121284,
-1.036665916442871,
0.08364542573690414,
-0.19532014429569244,
0.04125221446156502,
-0.24193421006202698,
-0.611742377281189,
-0.8413088917732239,
1.1504056453704834,
0.2867763042449951,
-0.1113051027059555,
0.10318014770746231,
0.029850464314222336,
0.6381977200508118,
-0.4611223340034485,
0.5473073720932007,
0.44363901019096375,
0.2846716642379761,
0.4618869125843048,
-0.8948748111724854,
0.29580116271972656,
-0.43064671754837036,
-0.5023013353347778,
-0.05057789012789726,
-0.49681463837623596,
0.7255358099937439,
-0.6108009815216064,
0.08542606234550476,
0.6371073722839355,
0.22652234137058258,
0.5481183528900146,
0.6353879570960999,
0.3822239935398102,
0.44420334696769714,
1.032263994216919,
-0.014901570044457912,
1.2529710531234741,
-0.298866868019104,
-0.24687473475933075,
1.0647082328796387,
-0.49151480197906494,
0.765568733215332,
0.4478319585323334,
-0.12467039376497269,
0.30355727672576904,
0.5595818758010864,
0.20574738085269928,
0.15648917853832245,
-0.042637988924980164,
-0.35739749670028687,
-0.3809583783149719,
-0.18634241819381714,
-0.40185031294822693,
0.34695613384246826,
0.4853473901748657,
-0.15554580092430115,
0.2661828100681305,
0.09979918599128723,
0.08689383417367935,
-0.008865214884281158,
-0.06495189666748047,
0.7218952775001526,
0.0635170191526413,
-0.8775946497917175,
0.6254553198814392,
-0.19326628744602203,
0.03508087992668152,
-0.5505588054656982,
-0.04752052202820778,
-0.5285980105400085,
0.2058417797088623,
-0.008685986511409283,
-0.6373192071914673,
0.05190190672874451,
-0.34071147441864014,
-0.08409130573272705,
0.14166519045829773,
0.6115267872810364,
-0.35975372791290283,
-0.5808019638061523,
-0.04076183959841728,
0.8876044154167175,
0.30702996253967285,
0.2684650421142578,
-0.714785635471344,
-0.07890227437019348,
-0.1869143545627594,
-0.06245827302336693,
0.1845102459192276,
0.34783056378364563,
-0.03703591972589493,
1.240541696548462,
0.5455152988433838,
0.4042116105556488,
-0.1358434408903122,
0.06948588788509369,
0.8421679139137268,
-0.4060463607311249,
-0.11198799312114716,
-0.44585859775543213,
0.40091270208358765,
-0.0651472955942154,
-0.395188570022583,
0.22909410297870636,
0.039729051291942596,
0.42339882254600525,
0.20368176698684692,
0.6626195907592773,
0.3286195397377014,
0.8979661464691162,
-0.4821447730064392,
0.7835344076156616,
-0.7728534936904907,
0.45274481177330017,
-0.0024838235694915056,
-0.40451082587242126,
-0.5422614812850952,
0.4475161135196686,
-0.12543970346450806,
0.19004987180233002,
0.6708371043205261,
0.6136034727096558,
0.03564268350601196,
0.01707594282925129,
0.529947817325592,
0.4342155158519745,
0.329309344291687,
0.7717124819755554,
1.025383710861206,
-0.2999435365200043,
0.3803594708442688,
-0.058810941874980927,
-0.4844866096973419,
-0.07771030068397522,
-0.5073140263557434,
-0.6694647669792175,
-0.282592236995697,
-0.3194897174835205,
-0.29165345430374146,
0.28218525648117065,
0.9514331221580505,
0.7058225870132446,
-0.6764912009239197,
0.0751267820596695,
0.1937108039855957,
0.12931226193904877,
-0.058987103402614594,
-0.15636149048805237,
0.35168448090553284,
-0.2275424599647522,
-0.47292688488960266,
0.5213474035263062,
0.573536217212677,
0.1116238608956337,
-0.10698474198579788,
-0.20863090455532074,
-0.2439979612827301,
0.230460062623024,
0.2106436789035797,
0.5033470392227173,
-0.5330981612205505,
-0.40027302503585815,
0.3407382071018219,
-0.1635802686214447,
0.184474915266037,
0.6317350268363953,
-0.7083298563957214,
0.4607580006122589,
0.033184248954057693,
1.077538251876831,
-0.05152876675128937,
0.21922224760055542,
0.7510938048362732,
-0.3245564103126526,
-0.16936807334423065,
0.6369757652282715,
0.3155195713043213,
0.1725606471300125,
-0.4198155999183655,
0.3269548714160919,
0.21917352080345154,
-0.7382304668426514,
-0.6925800442695618,
0.18394267559051514,
-0.8132179975509644,
-0.15773969888687134,
1.0526317358016968,
-0.39788180589675903,
-0.02264532446861267,
-0.7431614995002747,
-0.4155259430408478,
-0.287404865026474,
-0.04637699946761131,
0.6341306567192078,
0.5547071099281311,
-0.5833811163902283,
-0.4509201943874359,
-0.5361551642417908,
0.5120581984519958,
0.9072083234786987,
-0.8536733388900757,
-0.31664520502090454,
0.2779298424720764,
0.3727947473526001,
0.010983007028698921,
1.068501591682434,
-0.218854159116745,
0.8294684290885925,
-0.2850879430770874,
-0.3701086640357971,
-0.15096290409564972,
-0.43741950392723083,
-0.015110033564269543,
0.09389600902795792,
0.39801618456840515,
-0.0431971400976181
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.01638v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.01638v3
|
TimeCMA: Towards LLM-Empowered Time Series Forecasting via Cross-Modality Alignment
| 2024-06-03T00:27:29 | 2024-06-14T01:39:29 |
Chenxi Liu, Qianxiong Xu, Hao Miao, Sun Yang, Lingzheng Zhang, Cheng Long, Ziyue Li, Rui Zhao
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
The widespread adoption of scalable mobile sensing has led to large amounts
of time series data for real-world applications. A fundamental application is
multivariate time series forecasting (MTSF), which aims to predict future time
series values based on historical observations. Existing MTSF methods suffer
from limited parameterization and small-scale training data. Recently, Large
language models (LLMs) have been introduced in time series, which achieve
promising forecasting performance but incur heavy computational costs. To solve
these challenges, we propose TimeCMA, an LLM-empowered framework for time
series forecasting with cross-modality alignment. We design a dual-modality
encoding module with two branches, where the time series encoding branch
extracts relatively low-quality yet pure embeddings of time series through an
inverted Transformer. In addition, the LLM-empowered encoding branch wraps the
same time series as prompts to obtain high-quality yet entangled prompt
embeddings via a Pre-trained LLM. Then, we design a cross-modality alignment
module to retrieve high-quality and pure time series embeddings from the prompt
embeddings. Moreover, we develop a time series forecasting module to decode the
aligned embeddings while capturing dependencies among multiple variables for
forecasting. Notably, we tailor the prompt to encode sufficient temporal
information into a last token and design the last token embedding storage to
reduce computational costs. Extensive experiments on real data offer insight
into the accuracy and efficiency of the proposed framework.
|
[
-0.0869341641664505,
-0.3735176920890808,
0.46836233139038086,
0.31024929881095886,
-0.5890763998031616,
0.3982967436313629,
0.016076676547527313,
-0.3481256663799286,
0.48093080520629883,
0.11402030289173126,
-0.7767625451087952,
-0.1832726150751114,
-0.4463246762752533,
-0.18098485469818115,
-0.00292652053758502,
0.4567079544067383,
-0.22797293961048126,
0.41829875111579895,
-0.027623720467090607,
-0.04743816703557968,
-0.6610524654388428,
-0.44085055589675903,
-0.05974782630801201,
-0.028743157163262367,
0.5966374278068542,
0.24359609186649323,
0.8136054873466492,
0.6996583342552185,
0.0967181846499443,
0.19197794795036316,
0.4254421293735504,
0.6643495559692383,
-0.17211318016052246,
0.21230578422546387,
0.198747456073761,
-0.3705413043498993,
-0.8346477746963501,
0.09194514155387878,
0.4867991507053375,
0.4696873128414154,
-0.23748476803302765,
0.44377556443214417,
0.09404289722442627,
0.30545148253440857,
-0.6042060852050781,
0.047579336911439896,
-0.5356923341751099,
0.19064754247665405,
-0.1886141002178192,
-0.562843918800354,
-0.2323857545852661,
0.08769677579402924,
-0.20392781496047974,
-0.5955860018730164,
-0.17599238455295563,
0.44237232208251953,
0.590869665145874,
0.4970328211784363,
-0.7115388512611389,
0.19061808288097382,
-0.8130234479904175,
1.220564603805542,
-0.6998791694641113,
0.6205583810806274,
0.19897477328777313,
0.6155452132225037,
0.05476517230272293,
-0.25325924158096313,
-0.40099599957466125,
0.4659323990345001,
0.1706504374742508,
0.33974140882492065,
-0.15797050297260284,
-0.43448442220687866,
0.01957833394408226,
0.1741916537284851,
-0.466905415058136,
0.15760794281959534,
-0.013989138416945934,
-0.05700904503464699,
0.4675942361354828,
0.5838804244995117,
-0.0072587113827466965,
-0.049963243305683136,
-0.6265795230865479,
0.24851661920547485,
-0.5685861110687256,
-0.05041452497243881,
0.45835161209106445,
0.5289738178253174,
-0.4507570266723633,
0.699806809425354,
0.194590762257576,
0.35699111223220825,
0.10354743897914886,
-0.32785508036613464,
0.22820945084095,
-0.41446179151535034,
-0.3630840480327606,
0.15308651328086853,
0.7081535458564758,
0.32868605852127075,
-0.09678713977336884,
-0.2804829180240631,
-0.08722095936536789,
-0.06788614392280579,
0.2044619619846344,
-0.7358058094978333,
0.43713730573654175,
0.3475987911224365,
-0.5795964002609253,
-0.2625444233417511,
-0.004884776659309864,
-0.9199353456497192,
-0.28763851523399353,
-0.8418258428573608,
0.4154297709465027,
-0.07788922637701035,
-0.23208820819854736,
-0.056596338748931885,
0.168148472905159,
0.20215757191181183,
0.28115078806877136,
-1.0370620489120483,
-0.03838669881224632,
0.7120789289474487,
0.7074512243270874,
-0.20551761984825134,
-0.3185238838195801,
-0.5251929759979248,
0.4283832013607025,
-0.12011829018592834,
0.41292470693588257,
-0.6491827368736267,
-0.4407097101211548,
-0.2347867339849472,
0.0707063227891922,
-0.05394440144300461,
-0.008712700568139553,
0.08699075132608414,
-0.6733609437942505,
0.2922878563404083,
-0.0324428491294384,
-0.15909339487552643,
-0.23588967323303223,
0.27514711022377014,
-0.5291426181793213,
1.0180484056472778,
0.06535258144140244,
-0.5454643368721008,
0.485027015209198,
-0.16635014116764069,
-0.22771112620830536,
-0.7032622694969177,
-0.12327280640602112,
-0.4513503313064575,
-0.12689372897148132,
0.8405516743659973,
0.7961651086807251,
-0.8504566550254822,
0.5519821643829346,
-0.569398045539856,
0.07782946527004242,
0.2635144889354706,
-1.0525439977645874,
0.45884379744529724,
0.36270466446876526,
-0.3280346393585205,
0.2723561227321625,
-0.7312504053115845,
-0.09483691304922104,
-0.12771956622600555,
0.12735003232955933,
-0.20777690410614014,
-0.02974807471036911,
0.16210509836673737,
0.2693040668964386,
0.3859908878803253,
-0.5703629851341248,
0.4640657901763916,
-0.0218680277466774,
0.38594433665275574,
0.8946190476417542,
-0.19535695016384125,
0.5612713694572449,
-0.4907872974872589,
0.9045785665512085,
0.3686235547065735,
0.5515814423561096,
-0.20139677822589874,
-0.24416287243366241,
-0.1507028043270111,
-0.5131043195724487,
0.15136271715164185,
0.668390691280365,
-0.6335417628288269,
0.3684540092945099,
-0.5765203237533569,
-0.7511681318283081,
-0.40584343671798706,
0.14930091798305511,
0.08142176270484924,
0.33692115545272827,
0.45313283801078796,
0.06641010195016861,
-0.655093789100647,
-0.5142756104469299,
-0.1438731700181961,
0.25990086793899536,
-0.06727335602045059,
0.2269938886165619,
-0.035745516419410706,
-0.3933869004249573,
0.9506480693817139,
-0.2777382433414459,
-0.14917531609535217,
-0.13042818009853363,
0.01855776272714138,
0.3910284638404846,
0.30973029136657715,
0.5063757300376892,
-0.7020764946937561,
-0.06647397577762604,
-0.11435820162296295,
-0.6659045219421387,
-0.05858619883656502,
-0.1977524310350418,
-0.1898922622203827,
0.09954364597797394,
0.24575400352478027,
-0.35084450244903564,
0.30550098419189453,
1.012385368347168,
-0.6161963939666748,
0.3433435559272766,
0.2055274099111557,
0.037314482033252716,
-1.7534679174423218,
0.06417159736156464,
-0.23959466814994812,
-0.3136070668697357,
-0.17417693138122559,
-0.6213943958282471,
0.058109134435653687,
-0.30012208223342896,
-0.26377370953559875,
0.5709370374679565,
-0.6202696561813354,
-0.16215932369232178,
0.05738937109708786,
-0.22657431662082672,
0.09781142324209213,
0.5462504029273987,
-0.07834126800298691,
0.6426624059677124,
0.1998438835144043,
-0.36442384123802185,
0.24358776211738586,
-0.08068528026342392,
-0.10059451311826706,
0.3045901656150818,
-0.24490119516849518,
-0.01985856331884861,
0.025084292516112328,
0.12395107001066208,
-0.6616090536117554,
0.2006157487630844,
0.238067165017128,
-0.11803459376096725,
0.5144986510276794,
-0.1756683737039566,
-0.13902267813682556,
0.062141407281160355,
-0.3305254578590393,
0.927969753742218,
0.20524908602237701,
-0.8283352255821228,
1.3073234558105469,
0.2761300504207611,
-0.03250306472182274,
-1.077848196029663,
-0.6035813689231873,
-0.09100118279457092,
-0.2582884728908539,
-0.4605292081832886,
0.4882510006427765,
-0.07638587057590485,
0.020019952207803726,
-0.12716995179653168,
-0.10029153525829315,
0.3368414044380188,
0.05460965260863304,
0.5470115542411804,
0.7389345169067383,
-0.26205721497535706,
-0.058704547584056854,
0.15407459437847137,
-0.2973425090312958,
-0.17107635736465454,
-0.4837222099304199,
0.6144248843193054,
0.15565243363380432,
-0.6480881571769714,
-0.3231538236141205,
0.30520808696746826,
0.7929226756095886,
-0.11394177377223969,
0.4834738075733185,
0.7984780669212341,
-0.3979099988937378,
-0.040738243609666824,
-0.48087942600250244,
0.19948315620422363,
-0.45902618765830994,
-0.006682504899799824,
-0.26033276319503784,
-0.7424631118774414,
0.46876758337020874,
0.11328651010990143,
0.19847215712070465,
0.26838448643684387,
0.5983836054801941,
0.27251362800598145,
1.2901941537857056,
0.3363567292690277,
-0.38797488808631897,
0.6078343391418457,
-0.15411315858364105,
0.21779051423072815,
-0.8225972056388855,
-0.43353158235549927,
-0.14720378816127777,
-0.5329725742340088,
-0.3758004307746887,
-0.7291579246520996,
0.3618731200695038,
-0.15485751628875732,
-0.43554913997650146,
0.18922202289104462,
-0.27233442664146423,
0.008182808756828308,
0.3135596811771393,
0.019058965146541595,
0.31892767548561096,
-0.002963957842439413,
0.06438679248094559,
-0.29611292481422424,
-0.6084926128387451,
-0.3807937800884247,
1.3341524600982666,
0.5080483555793762,
1.2132906913757324,
0.05593278631567955,
0.25137802958488464,
0.2718096971511841,
0.3162015676498413,
-0.9688603281974792,
0.27988362312316895,
-0.06246097758412361,
-0.24671633541584015,
-0.047536760568618774,
-0.45180845260620117,
-0.7473641633987427,
0.23281072080135345,
-0.30368152260780334,
-0.29687243700027466,
0.6360574960708618,
0.07028345763683319,
-0.20992352068424225,
0.6096221804618835,
-0.37102726101875305,
0.7292221784591675,
-0.7022589445114136,
-0.3930428922176361,
-0.2176850438117981,
-0.5305200815200806,
0.24741080403327942,
-0.08017276227474213,
0.1974221020936966,
-0.339647114276886,
-0.5752631425857544,
0.5826645493507385,
-0.4106975495815277,
1.0258440971374512,
-0.20475099980831146,
-0.20709608495235443,
-0.11581709235906601,
0.0970553532242775,
0.32060542702674866,
0.19177483022212982,
-0.09620580822229385,
0.34809911251068115,
0.27220478653907776,
-0.5381408929824829,
-0.5213363170623779,
0.5359123945236206,
-0.8955730199813843,
-0.37829312682151794,
-0.5430961847305298,
-0.6502028107643127,
-0.5239760875701904,
0.07741406559944153,
0.013767956756055355,
0.9154478311538696,
-0.15282900631427765,
-0.07371903210878372,
0.12743829190731049,
0.33497869968414307,
0.6927369832992554,
0.45832332968711853,
-0.44418758153915405,
-0.837573766708374,
0.9828748106956482,
0.07868240028619766,
0.14388200640678406,
0.7741329073905945,
0.18153800070285797,
-0.34474486112594604,
-0.3819572925567627,
-0.6812517046928406,
0.08419070392847061,
-0.4101581573486328,
-0.47639238834381104,
-0.4306660592556,
0.09447548538446426,
-0.3762994706630707,
-0.1523883044719696,
-0.45656782388687134,
-0.5951621532440186,
-0.6557179689407349,
0.0537857748568058,
0.15952326357364655,
0.4796581268310547,
0.044195547699928284,
0.2671622931957245,
-1.0555864572525024,
0.3344140946865082,
0.34406477212905884,
0.17719672620296478,
0.15196791291236877,
-0.32687604427337646,
-0.24190035462379456,
0.05329340323805809,
-0.43124598264694214,
-0.5003029108047485,
0.7848212718963623,
-0.11437878757715225,
0.3006989359855652,
0.7000507116317749,
-0.091148242354393,
0.9658641219139099,
-0.34861546754837036,
0.9114609360694885,
0.2904360294342041,
-0.9424031972885132,
0.053051091730594635,
-0.2994426190853119,
0.20277675986289978,
-0.017702270299196243,
0.3854510486125946,
-0.5442006587982178,
-0.0677221268415451,
-0.21591372787952423,
-0.6677051782608032,
0.5408372282981873,
-0.4157070219516754,
0.04783294349908829,
0.15575599670410156,
-0.1352095752954483,
0.6202684044837952,
0.3427242934703827,
-0.34068283438682556,
-0.2261555939912796,
-0.7069810032844543,
-0.5235046148300171,
-0.35726943612098694,
-0.36680173873901367,
-0.3039138615131378,
-0.14513225853443146,
0.68100506067276,
-0.4195803999900818,
0.35086095333099365,
0.21263505518436432,
0.03528676927089691,
-0.2960430681705475,
0.3029692471027374,
0.4830888509750366,
0.7823257446289062,
-0.08242154121398926,
-0.03754529356956482,
0.07553553581237793,
-0.36147740483283997,
0.22046686708927155,
0.3789248466491699,
0.11667508631944656,
-0.2544572651386261,
0.3379257917404175,
0.7235040664672852,
0.40626776218414307,
-0.4899475574493408,
0.346593976020813,
-0.1301702857017517,
0.28655850887298584,
-0.44291481375694275,
-0.4189440906047821,
-0.03686872124671936,
0.5043636560440063,
0.5983127355575562,
0.1990947276353836,
-0.3385668992996216,
-0.42235416173934937,
-0.3082446753978729,
0.5970158576965332,
-0.23202911019325256,
-0.5000889301300049,
0.9986887574195862,
0.20484960079193115,
0.11926709115505219,
0.25801122188568115,
0.39622893929481506,
-0.38689205050468445,
0.4117312431335449,
0.5767250061035156,
0.9285798668861389,
-0.317514032125473,
-0.07723797857761383,
-0.0363924466073513,
0.2427513301372528,
0.15669837594032288,
0.581534206867218,
-0.12658439576625824,
-0.6834694147109985,
-0.46954330801963806,
-0.6899005770683289,
-0.5155015587806702,
-0.18061554431915283,
-0.5394431948661804,
0.3842092454433441,
-0.5035008788108826,
-0.29582032561302185,
-0.28313174843788147,
0.03527701646089554,
-0.5737636089324951,
0.18096795678138733,
0.15245328843593597,
1.0265439748764038,
-0.7861896753311157,
0.723665714263916,
0.3974411189556122,
0.04834030568599701,
-0.8251051902770996,
-0.15793024003505707,
0.12593339383602142,
-0.9859859347343445,
0.316609263420105,
0.2745177447795868,
-0.2658786475658417,
-0.17809554934501648,
-0.27518776059150696,
-1.0207877159118652,
1.6756821870803833,
0.2999422550201416,
-0.6133469343185425,
-0.09141281247138977,
0.20672054588794708,
0.04541163519024849,
-0.7018851041793823,
0.14527837932109833,
0.026095375418663025,
0.46582287549972534,
-0.05707043409347534,
-0.6872891783714294,
0.32007649540901184,
-0.2688206136226654,
-0.08249271661043167,
0.521024227142334,
-0.6909827589988708,
0.6445134878158569,
-0.1024140790104866,
-0.10463918745517731,
0.17929880321025848,
0.9569640159606934,
-0.09106972068548203,
0.682611346244812,
0.4778938889503479,
0.3661332428455353,
0.5545970797538757,
-0.11713702976703644,
0.7826388478279114,
-0.37550628185272217,
0.024309881031513214,
0.8488688468933105,
-0.29371997714042664,
0.6766458749771118,
0.7396864891052246,
-0.17245200276374817,
0.5430190563201904,
0.679458737373352,
0.07747495174407959,
0.4358411133289337,
-0.5962814092636108,
-0.1715051680803299,
-0.6077513694763184,
-0.19170427322387695,
-0.38581764698028564,
0.43441927433013916,
0.4252578616142273,
-0.42398571968078613,
0.08470062166452408,
0.14153215289115906,
0.012961657717823982,
-0.1938391625881195,
-0.39735785126686096,
0.33487668633461,
0.22221478819847107,
-0.5630125403404236,
0.29075831174850464,
-0.17505745589733124,
0.7831246256828308,
-0.8132016062736511,
0.19172820448875427,
0.1471952646970749,
0.06707464158535004,
-0.263104647397995,
-0.3728577196598053,
0.23408189415931702,
-0.3030696213245392,
-0.36136263608932495,
-0.4071974456310272,
0.40225037932395935,
-0.5814422369003296,
-0.552009105682373,
0.37036368250846863,
0.6547036170959473,
-0.43622884154319763,
0.3389330208301544,
-0.43709126114845276,
-0.0202694833278656,
-0.2961066961288452,
-0.4071940779685974,
0.25042131543159485,
0.19082851707935333,
-0.0773065909743309,
0.7343812584877014,
0.855133056640625,
0.013628288172185421,
0.06146835908293724,
0.10877092182636261,
0.7901939153671265,
-0.8826132416725159,
-0.5067176222801208,
-0.7645459771156311,
0.4605911076068878,
0.40938228368759155,
-0.08317167311906815,
0.526340663433075,
0.5608786344528198,
0.21426168084144592,
0.023509688675403595,
0.5518249273300171,
0.20571114122867584,
0.5025859475135803,
-0.8430051803588867,
0.21849900484085083,
-0.7972032427787781,
0.4356549084186554,
0.1389806717634201,
-0.9610977172851562,
-0.24684475362300873,
-0.3276870846748352,
-0.42862412333488464,
-0.010158639401197433,
0.31749895215034485,
0.6961561441421509,
-0.4596691429615021,
0.30435433983802795,
0.2928674817085266,
0.001828906824812293,
0.18805049359798431,
0.4420119524002075,
0.8254958391189575,
-0.16398590803146362,
0.6444649696350098,
-0.3510698974132538,
-0.1592179536819458,
-0.22541357576847076,
-1.2287462949752808,
-0.8824823498725891,
-0.44648709893226624,
0.24175067245960236,
-0.2995808720588684,
-0.14893068373203278,
1.4183497428894043,
0.4971476197242737,
-0.6829301714897156,
-0.273246705532074,
0.4514233469963074,
0.07296030968427658,
-0.47183072566986084,
-0.24356716871261597,
0.38307619094848633,
0.007670308463275433,
-0.8248996138572693,
0.6531921625137329,
0.17221608757972717,
0.2896333932876587,
-0.5189784169197083,
-0.012238078750669956,
0.21000780165195465,
-0.026442542672157288,
0.44575145840644836,
0.1683274209499359,
-0.5810692310333252,
-0.10660462081432343,
0.12215188890695572,
0.009296292439103127,
0.025661423802375793,
1.0279743671417236,
-0.861151933670044,
0.3531268835067749,
0.47727352380752563,
0.73423832654953,
0.31298089027404785,
0.14486035704612732,
0.9264353513717651,
-0.6909317970275879,
0.024366943165659904,
0.15911123156547546,
0.5911205410957336,
0.300403356552124,
-0.5019286870956421,
0.23087520897388458,
0.22800269722938538,
-0.505822479724884,
-0.6874091625213623,
0.11273040622472763,
-1.3228193521499634,
0.029630834236741066,
0.8186890482902527,
0.19526569545269012,
-0.3101761043071747,
-0.11998464167118073,
-0.16958151757717133,
0.48994413018226624,
-0.5422871112823486,
0.6085806488990784,
0.3463268280029297,
0.03144895285367966,
-0.02901100553572178,
-0.27425363659858704,
0.07471182197332382,
0.47018882632255554,
-0.5123229622840881,
0.20862653851509094,
0.26308420300483704,
0.17837755382061005,
-0.0024333384353667498,
0.00905788503587246,
-0.25949788093566895,
0.16582906246185303,
-0.25682178139686584,
-0.23378495872020721,
-0.631103515625,
-0.33860087394714355,
-0.37045586109161377,
-0.03778466582298279,
-0.2853041887283325,
-0.28621888160705566
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00899v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00899v1
|
YODAS: Youtube-Oriented Dataset for Audio and Speech
| 2024-06-02T23:43:27 | 2024-06-02T23:43:27 |
Xinjian Li, Shinnosuke Takamichi, Takaaki Saeki, William Chen, Sayaka Shiota, Shinji Watanabe
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
In this study, we introduce YODAS (YouTube-Oriented Dataset for Audio and
Speech), a large-scale, multilingual dataset comprising currently over 500k
hours of speech data in more than 100 languages, sourced from both labeled and
unlabeled YouTube speech datasets. The labeled subsets, including manual or
automatic subtitles, facilitate supervised model training. Conversely, the
unlabeled subsets are apt for self-supervised learning applications. YODAS is
distinctive as the first publicly available dataset of its scale, and it is
distributed under a Creative Commons license. We introduce the collection
methodology utilized for YODAS, which contributes to the large-scale speech
dataset construction. Subsequently, we provide a comprehensive analysis of
speech, text contained within the dataset. Finally, we describe the speech
recognition baselines over the top-15 languages.
|
[
-0.3122124969959259,
-0.45546236634254456,
0.009447174146771431,
0.05699962377548218,
-0.3098117709159851,
0.09611550718545914,
-0.3080078065395355,
-0.19076010584831238,
0.6890143752098083,
0.4374862611293793,
-0.7643153071403503,
-0.364994078874588,
-0.5504163503646851,
-0.07764660567045212,
-0.7573139667510986,
1.127011775970459,
0.5550883412361145,
0.23931299149990082,
0.043402768671512604,
-0.37793710827827454,
-0.286159873008728,
-0.0023334426805377007,
-0.3292427957057953,
0.08697278052568436,
0.42203468084335327,
0.4770571291446686,
0.2761977016925812,
0.9767746925354004,
0.1089521199464798,
0.3695787191390991,
0.022343065589666367,
0.027378087863326073,
-0.39766645431518555,
0.43686944246292114,
-0.1265348196029663,
-0.04296573996543884,
-0.33762800693511963,
-0.023160163313150406,
0.6420605182647705,
0.6186595559120178,
-0.38417211174964905,
0.8501118421554565,
-0.18071924149990082,
0.41048330068588257,
-0.5892209410667419,
0.32147353887557983,
-0.533810555934906,
0.04960242658853531,
-0.5959712266921997,
-0.11538887768983841,
0.07953183352947235,
-0.2928316593170166,
0.356106162071228,
-0.6872938275337219,
0.0628579705953598,
-0.3566003143787384,
0.16028240323066711,
0.3542502224445343,
-0.10006684809923172,
-0.3156355023384094,
-0.7293156385421753,
0.9053148031234741,
-0.6178403496742249,
0.8110198974609375,
0.48774421215057373,
0.6363182663917542,
0.4876730144023895,
-0.6051399111747742,
-0.45716986060142517,
0.21171420812606812,
0.5992072820663452,
-0.06450509279966354,
-0.0591348335146904,
-0.3158155381679535,
0.18774433434009552,
0.4227399230003357,
-0.4656749963760376,
0.32630884647369385,
-0.7974761128425598,
-0.197714701294899,
0.7027930617332458,
-0.01183842122554779,
0.25813400745391846,
-0.37846213579177856,
-0.12489932030439377,
0.06320152431726456,
-0.5933904647827148,
0.2326270192861557,
0.5944200754165649,
0.647211492061615,
-0.17810285091400146,
0.7275407314300537,
-0.46026983857154846,
0.8048492670059204,
-0.15299440920352936,
-0.6901687383651733,
0.7566441297531128,
-0.2728079557418823,
-0.5602260231971741,
0.5176849961280823,
0.8846607208251953,
0.0414440743625164,
0.49352988600730896,
-0.12456908077001572,
0.039502471685409546,
-0.09043483436107635,
0.20667479932308197,
-0.46571940183639526,
-0.12657995522022247,
0.12196944653987885,
-0.18901997804641724,
-0.07205711305141449,
0.06817873567342758,
-0.8419982194900513,
-0.5094153881072998,
-0.7342947125434875,
0.27505767345428467,
-0.09673817455768585,
-0.4439193308353424,
0.10143398493528366,
0.06045234203338623,
0.07117443531751633,
0.055267103016376495,
-0.9519749879837036,
0.2549617886543274,
0.5492092370986938,
0.7418462634086609,
0.0714075043797493,
-0.28208670020103455,
-0.817264199256897,
0.18645204603672028,
-0.42343705892562866,
0.4077982008457184,
-0.32583364844322205,
-0.13498201966285706,
0.02343415655195713,
-0.07374195009469986,
0.3468310832977295,
-0.39524045586586,
0.48668068647384644,
-0.34517332911491394,
0.22340509295463562,
-0.06376329809427261,
-0.4233383238315582,
-0.05969769507646561,
-0.047534629702568054,
-0.7631191611289978,
0.9927375912666321,
-0.11460968106985092,
-0.4836951792240143,
0.32074376940727234,
-0.5638993382453918,
-0.5041705369949341,
0.18488161265850067,
-0.34838131070137024,
-0.3330182433128357,
-0.09634469449520111,
0.39571499824523926,
0.5594789981842041,
-0.44938650727272034,
0.6507812738418579,
-0.11006738990545273,
0.03070811741054058,
0.024203505367040634,
-0.4257400929927826,
0.9825417995452881,
0.459399938583374,
-0.3682546019554138,
0.038039255887269974,
-1.1967246532440186,
0.02553459443151951,
-0.04869323968887329,
-0.05799634009599686,
-0.3375299572944641,
0.15416699647903442,
0.18395812809467316,
0.051456794142723083,
0.07854420691728592,
-1.025213599205017,
-0.03090810216963291,
-0.2059081792831421,
0.8446699976921082,
0.8248311281204224,
-0.2816416323184967,
0.23223035037517548,
0.2417674958705902,
0.5987646579742432,
-0.004215160850435495,
0.23308472335338593,
-0.5117350816726685,
-0.559883713722229,
-0.28606024384498596,
-0.26946255564689636,
0.26388606429100037,
0.26546359062194824,
-0.5882965922355652,
0.2919518053531647,
-0.6122945547103882,
-0.502032458782196,
-0.8948543071746826,
0.5669476389884949,
0.4739949405193329,
1.058171272277832,
0.4218883216381073,
0.07334426790475845,
-0.714201807975769,
-1.1246271133422852,
0.33724188804626465,
-0.10505689680576324,
-0.2008543163537979,
0.055135585367679596,
0.07709416002035141,
-0.14201922714710236,
1.1266510486602783,
-0.38513922691345215,
-0.5054580569267273,
-0.15691374242305756,
0.04179338738322258,
0.11291337013244629,
0.28449374437332153,
0.6361095309257507,
-0.880519688129425,
-0.32264235615730286,
-0.09922154247760773,
-0.5676575303077698,
-0.11517917364835739,
0.2244148999452591,
0.295261025428772,
-0.2234327793121338,
0.5604386329650879,
0.14613258838653564,
0.09887775778770447,
0.8568570613861084,
0.13291391730308533,
0.23812849819660187,
0.0152461351826787,
-0.008598485961556435,
-1.227554440498352,
-0.20353515446186066,
0.2951098084449768,
-0.27997153997421265,
-0.5122954249382019,
-0.7016469240188599,
-0.022488653659820557,
-0.21394230425357819,
-0.7365778684616089,
0.21915744245052338,
-0.20638583600521088,
-0.52643221616745,
-0.05306188762187958,
0.1557127833366394,
-0.1776253581047058,
0.43115127086639404,
0.15865163505077362,
1.049778699874878,
1.036819338798523,
-0.5568987727165222,
0.8835726380348206,
0.34665238857269287,
-0.6955699920654297,
0.7341664433479309,
-0.69590163230896,
0.08075329661369324,
-0.21429398655891418,
-0.22845037281513214,
-0.8419674634933472,
-0.4684429466724396,
0.09662371128797531,
-0.5013423562049866,
0.10946840047836304,
-0.12170160561800003,
-0.2759934961795807,
-0.19973383843898773,
-0.3464932441711426,
0.3921595513820648,
0.20788933336734772,
-0.7158366441726685,
0.2519090473651886,
1.237815022468567,
-0.3654095232486725,
-0.732610285282135,
-0.7253085374832153,
0.003982278984040022,
-0.3136357367038727,
-0.27275070548057556,
-0.03272213786840439,
-0.057361144572496414,
-0.02153036557137966,
0.1425672471523285,
-0.17449955642223358,
-0.24116092920303345,
-0.359286367893219,
0.441275030374527,
0.09079418331384659,
-0.44143980741500854,
0.23528684675693512,
-0.1784011423587799,
0.005532962270081043,
0.05669271573424339,
-0.4294593930244446,
0.33618900179862976,
-0.11490729451179504,
-0.2979976534843445,
-0.6902405023574829,
0.35481134057044983,
0.5803751945495605,
-0.31607791781425476,
0.32695692777633667,
0.42044878005981445,
-0.41116464138031006,
-0.27382269501686096,
-0.5587167143821716,
0.46285590529441833,
-0.48423027992248535,
0.5892202854156494,
-0.15833145380020142,
-0.5887228846549988,
0.38351044058799744,
0.30022120475769043,
0.034730568528175354,
0.5007842183113098,
0.4783543348312378,
-0.37438419461250305,
0.74664306640625,
0.35511893033981323,
-0.7008917331695557,
0.7468259930610657,
-0.4036354422569275,
-0.09662555158138275,
-0.8342821598052979,
-0.5333110094070435,
-0.711648166179657,
-0.39749014377593994,
-0.4550153613090515,
-0.11768154054880142,
0.21359410881996155,
-0.5841216444969177,
-0.4715954065322876,
0.6486417651176453,
-0.3702903687953949,
0.6245985627174377,
0.7590097784996033,
-0.22281035780906677,
0.19843819737434387,
0.028303753584623337,
0.37195920944213867,
-0.2266155630350113,
-0.5870682597160339,
-0.1622721403837204,
1.2874841690063477,
0.31830281019210815,
0.9736919403076172,
0.14786288142204285,
0.2417653501033783,
0.47108691930770874,
-0.14978954195976257,
-0.8862099051475525,
0.4193575382232666,
-0.16200439631938934,
-0.7837216854095459,
-0.6047676205635071,
-0.5284169316291809,
-0.9144794940948486,
-0.2320614606142044,
0.06534837186336517,
-0.7324721217155457,
0.09890963137149811,
-0.13235877454280853,
-0.29772526025772095,
0.33260664343833923,
-0.8559128046035767,
0.46186593174934387,
-0.40447041392326355,
-0.005827315151691437,
0.06406349688768387,
-0.7070217728614807,
0.22331660985946655,
-0.1757267862558365,
0.3264278471469879,
-0.04489417001605034,
0.10935447365045547,
1.3660517930984497,
-0.040374480187892914,
0.7152490615844727,
-0.17466650903224945,
-0.06342393159866333,
0.48499828577041626,
-0.34515637159347534,
-0.1782774031162262,
0.24643757939338684,
0.232105553150177,
0.23723970353603363,
0.010067028924822807,
-0.12049423903226852,
-0.36780640482902527,
0.8303007483482361,
-0.8738687038421631,
-0.2100783735513687,
-0.3565835952758789,
-0.4036814272403717,
-0.632559061050415,
0.318136066198349,
0.018375303596258163,
0.9065741896629333,
-0.02378067746758461,
0.6575667262077332,
0.7661939263343811,
-0.3400963544845581,
0.35816338658332825,
0.40524548292160034,
-0.25216060876846313,
-0.6120758056640625,
1.0797477960586548,
0.4415743350982666,
0.025958798825740814,
-0.10846252739429474,
0.15116071701049805,
-0.6856458783149719,
-0.5842519998550415,
-0.6090076565742493,
0.1439339518547058,
-0.6830115914344788,
-0.26226386427879333,
-0.3508703112602234,
-0.39052847027778625,
-0.6914820671081543,
0.3037903904914856,
-0.9230750799179077,
-0.3537900447845459,
-0.21372418105602264,
-0.5040519833564758,
0.2759872376918793,
0.9870449900627136,
0.03132857754826546,
0.3145064413547516,
-0.5241451263427734,
1.0276744365692139,
0.5292755365371704,
0.8406513929367065,
-0.26461586356163025,
-0.5738164782524109,
-0.33200743794441223,
0.21753884851932526,
0.09303997457027435,
-0.8520066142082214,
0.4265877902507782,
0.4380764961242676,
0.7638898491859436,
0.675682783126831,
-0.2302071750164032,
0.8415314555168152,
-0.4666173756122589,
0.7006335854530334,
0.36159369349479675,
-0.91806560754776,
0.7671018838882446,
-0.4472246766090393,
0.1945759803056717,
0.5072139501571655,
0.3832310438156128,
-0.7138854265213013,
-0.12902258336544037,
-0.5993499755859375,
-0.6143056154251099,
0.9915343523025513,
0.07624662667512894,
0.311169296503067,
0.15078561007976532,
0.030030179768800735,
0.2586365342140198,
0.2938403785228729,
-0.3772916793823242,
-0.4788073003292084,
-0.5784551501274109,
-0.29448720812797546,
-0.46063363552093506,
0.01703326590359211,
-0.1600043624639511,
-0.45248034596443176,
0.7048270106315613,
-0.10882288217544556,
-0.04606795683503151,
-0.042249538004398346,
-0.2600286304950714,
-0.11200670152902603,
0.1893264502286911,
0.3927691876888275,
0.594184398651123,
-0.25083088874816895,
-0.1510239690542221,
-0.3087640404701233,
-0.862729012966156,
0.09317152202129364,
-0.011088017374277115,
-0.17471429705619812,
0.005919072311371565,
0.21597430109977722,
0.9280867576599121,
0.2864713668823242,
-1.0166805982589722,
0.2738970220088959,
0.10464200377464294,
-0.047541819512844086,
-0.38711467385292053,
-0.057411570101976395,
0.28655314445495605,
0.2362198531627655,
0.5172956585884094,
-0.2392968088388443,
0.2542797029018402,
-0.5523806810379028,
0.15528301894664764,
0.22703319787979126,
-0.3252095580101013,
-0.4424392580986023,
0.8319008350372314,
0.25778645277023315,
-0.4052555561065674,
0.65753573179245,
0.20331360399723053,
-0.031718309968709946,
0.6097919940948486,
0.26735594868659973,
0.7427619695663452,
-0.3195938169956207,
0.5026621222496033,
0.5788361430168152,
0.04341340810060501,
-0.07285439223051071,
0.09128908067941666,
-0.27054697275161743,
-0.44943955540657043,
-0.4928779900074005,
-0.6125599145889282,
-0.5756211876869202,
0.5888442397117615,
-1.0493074655532837,
0.26915085315704346,
-0.22557063400745392,
-0.11961894482374191,
0.4540022611618042,
-0.18349993228912354,
-0.5099487900733948,
0.4259520173072815,
0.5027297735214233,
0.5650321841239929,
-0.9816973209381104,
1.1271380186080933,
0.5576390624046326,
-0.25333547592163086,
-0.5442925095558167,
-0.46533912420272827,
0.33761367201805115,
-0.6423569321632385,
0.6014996767044067,
-0.06677921861410141,
-0.351675808429718,
0.0691094622015953,
-0.506040096282959,
-1.0710610151290894,
0.9264183640480042,
0.5539767742156982,
-0.6762085556983948,
0.024413615465164185,
0.383075475692749,
0.6021480560302734,
-0.24184320867061615,
-0.20708459615707397,
0.5379399061203003,
0.13574373722076416,
0.1215873584151268,
-1.0064846277236938,
-0.9350085854530334,
-0.3240037262439728,
-0.40550753474235535,
-0.02170654572546482,
-0.35125187039375305,
0.7282631397247314,
0.11094861477613449,
0.07844964414834976,
-0.2578916549682617,
0.8459111452102661,
-0.08506202697753906,
0.2445267140865326,
0.5186267495155334,
0.4329197406768799,
0.6991417407989502,
0.05953576788306236,
0.608828604221344,
0.25192350149154663,
0.24146714806556702,
1.4659761190414429,
-0.02683389000594616,
0.6590306162834167,
0.399118036031723,
-0.1997668445110321,
0.0004545161500573158,
0.3439483642578125,
0.03857569396495819,
0.7447080016136169,
-0.016160672530531883,
0.05173128470778465,
-0.0022457081358879805,
-0.2048521488904953,
-0.5510727763175964,
0.892699122428894,
0.37385013699531555,
-0.06367061287164688,
-0.3718843460083008,
0.3866749703884125,
-0.360139399766922,
0.03647540882229805,
-0.6021276116371155,
0.7685680389404297,
-0.2852534055709839,
-0.3242906332015991,
0.05972317233681679,
-0.38821640610694885,
0.6470621824264526,
-0.7948390245437622,
0.2998790442943573,
-0.060597117990255356,
0.05631125718355179,
-0.1722421944141388,
-1.037779450416565,
0.4196693003177643,
0.548949122428894,
-0.022290781140327454,
-0.4776872992515564,
0.34959620237350464,
-0.43552571535110474,
-0.5693593621253967,
0.14937780797481537,
0.3542763888835907,
0.07236038148403168,
0.23187635838985443,
-0.494463175535202,
0.10252304375171661,
-0.17250314354896545,
-0.39811012148857117,
0.3300504684448242,
0.4121064841747284,
-0.02065320685505867,
0.7761355638504028,
0.49197545647621155,
0.3437272310256958,
0.4953251779079437,
0.1882440596818924,
0.7954269647598267,
-0.5195680856704712,
-0.6619608998298645,
-0.39336615800857544,
0.28407979011535645,
0.0736297219991684,
-0.4998515844345093,
0.8974409699440002,
0.8144480586051941,
1.1475098133087158,
-0.11661887913942337,
0.861223578453064,
-0.13922759890556335,
0.8143051266670227,
-0.3203231692314148,
0.4583263695240021,
-0.5379365682601929,
0.04687274992465973,
-0.371598482131958,
-0.6808836460113525,
-0.16027799248695374,
0.5157666802406311,
-0.2210419923067093,
-0.23552502691745758,
0.04988589510321617,
0.3657285273075104,
-0.5015260577201843,
0.3094475269317627,
0.2192617505788803,
-0.031882598996162415,
0.29800793528556824,
0.1857781708240509,
0.629489004611969,
-0.31976622343063354,
0.557033360004425,
-0.6768944263458252,
0.04587164521217346,
0.11252401024103165,
-0.7185366153717041,
-0.7162200808525085,
-1.1558643579483032,
-0.44982871413230896,
0.08457697927951813,
-0.16238170862197876,
0.9182481169700623,
0.9886971116065979,
-0.961462140083313,
-0.37140506505966187,
0.2871292233467102,
-0.24873168766498566,
-0.2051694393157959,
-0.10152863711118698,
0.29926714301109314,
-0.004956102464348078,
-1.157021164894104,
0.7304319739341736,
0.23718029260635376,
-0.254839152097702,
-0.5602501034736633,
-0.16196981072425842,
-0.2692137658596039,
-0.10703133046627045,
0.3877129852771759,
0.6914244294166565,
-0.44055843353271484,
-0.014966183342039585,
0.11649118363857269,
0.07730111479759216,
0.4025782644748688,
0.7611451148986816,
-0.923617422580719,
0.9191737771034241,
0.4413969814777374,
0.8259596228599548,
0.5726854801177979,
0.0784694254398346,
0.18136155605316162,
-0.931397020816803,
0.4207969605922699,
0.33987554907798767,
0.3793618381023407,
0.38594794273376465,
0.1552577167749405,
0.43716758489608765,
-0.013588746078312397,
-0.2044868916273117,
-0.9890331625938416,
0.008593883365392685,
-1.3164445161819458,
0.15029700100421906,
1.0541343688964844,
-0.04122689738869667,
-0.1814480870962143,
-0.18451406061649323,
-0.15404653549194336,
0.40363404154777527,
-0.36774954199790955,
0.6528131365776062,
0.6452690958976746,
0.18046776950359344,
-0.13984842598438263,
-1.0018348693847656,
0.32289254665374756,
-0.020526280626654625,
-0.6797304749488831,
0.038551975041627884,
0.7181152105331421,
0.4465983211994171,
0.24446243047714233,
0.5738335251808167,
-0.11540532112121582,
0.16786891222000122,
-0.3191017210483551,
-0.24022190272808075,
-0.6297655701637268,
-0.6772438287734985,
-0.4468870460987091,
0.2996080815792084,
-0.551749587059021,
-0.7272299528121948
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00898v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00898v1
|
Phonetic Error Analysis of Raw Waveform Acoustic Models with Parametric and Non-Parametric CNNs
| 2024-06-02T23:39:15 | 2024-06-02T23:39:15 |
Erfan Loweimi, Andrea Carmantini, Peter Bell, Steve Renals, Zoran Cvetkovic
|
cs.SD
|
cs.SD, cs.CL, eess.AS
|
In this paper, we analyse the error patterns of the raw waveform acoustic
models in TIMIT's phone recognition task. Our analysis goes beyond the
conventional phone error rate (PER) metric. We categorise the phones into three
groups: {affricate, diphthong, fricative, nasal, plosive, semi-vowel, vowel,
silence}, {consonant, vowel+, silence}, and {voiced, unvoiced, silence} and,
compute the PER for each broad phonetic class in each category. We also
construct a confusion matrix for each category using the substitution errors
and compare the confusion patterns with those of the Filterbank and Wav2vec 2.0
systems. Our raw waveform acoustic models consists of parametric (Sinc2Net) or
non-parametric CNNs and Bidirectional LSTMs, achieving down to 13.7%/15.2% PERs
on TIMIT Dev/Test sets, outperforming reported PERs for raw waveform models in
the literature. We also investigate the impact of transfer learning from WSJ on
the phonetic error patterns and confusion matrices. It reduces the PER to
11.8%/13.7% on the Dev/Test sets.
|
[
0.019559431821107864,
-0.49316319823265076,
0.004290468990802765,
0.30706706643104553,
-0.1895100623369217,
-0.10432548820972443,
-0.15606364607810974,
-0.34536218643188477,
-0.04137654975056648,
0.3409857451915741,
-0.23509739339351654,
-0.7245073318481445,
-0.3189396262168884,
0.24490757286548615,
-0.2934894561767578,
0.3971754014492035,
0.1012926772236824,
0.5301461815834045,
0.37081319093704224,
-0.2923082113265991,
-0.6611387729644775,
-0.2854183316230774,
-0.7260401844978333,
0.1286226063966751,
0.5462363958358765,
0.6475401520729065,
0.33353158831596375,
0.12185836583375931,
0.40748754143714905,
0.21691463887691498,
-0.1682203859090805,
0.006884830072522163,
0.03436337783932686,
-0.10701284557580948,
0.2637540400028229,
-0.41717708110809326,
-0.48438629508018494,
0.2307845801115036,
0.6582179665565491,
0.8136222958564758,
-0.33095473051071167,
0.311617374420166,
0.18382614850997925,
0.42219799757003784,
-0.0946945995092392,
0.21050678193569183,
-0.6220676302909851,
0.45617637038230896,
-0.3222486674785614,
-0.3932059109210968,
-0.44794192910194397,
-0.2954447865486145,
0.3142760992050171,
-0.5529181957244873,
0.38496917486190796,
0.13162103295326233,
0.653571367263794,
0.16105441749095917,
-0.32575881481170654,
-0.27252906560897827,
-1.1063073873519897,
0.9554558992385864,
-0.8715175986289978,
0.895616352558136,
0.4995722770690918,
0.2324880063533783,
-0.3852003812789917,
-0.6607796549797058,
-0.5422470569610596,
-0.3439634144306183,
0.2546611428260803,
0.3880370855331421,
-0.2389535903930664,
0.34312447905540466,
0.2163696140050888,
0.32108941674232483,
-0.5455511808395386,
0.23043286800384521,
-0.6046279072761536,
-0.4664328396320343,
0.46455323696136475,
-0.15876729786396027,
0.32332420349121094,
-0.10085247457027435,
-0.4619475305080414,
-0.19011513888835907,
-0.4232368767261505,
0.37970027327537537,
0.5670467615127563,
0.6917508244514465,
-0.424090176820755,
0.5041606426239014,
0.05687616392970085,
0.7147305011749268,
-0.07773598283529282,
-0.5925430059432983,
0.23130811750888824,
-0.3335959315299988,
-0.3772032558917999,
0.3728473484516144,
0.9312986135482788,
0.12361117452383041,
0.16636016964912415,
-0.20655541121959686,
-0.310371994972229,
-0.4324411451816559,
-0.05521143600344658,
-0.46833691000938416,
-0.25381436944007874,
0.09932928532361984,
-0.8531447052955627,
-0.13996732234954834,
-0.053429581224918365,
-0.5789754390716553,
-0.279441237449646,
-0.2862621247768402,
0.43118515610694885,
-0.32748156785964966,
-0.5598182082176208,
0.19619715213775635,
-0.1694754809141159,
0.29285135865211487,
0.31071314215660095,
-0.4881671369075775,
0.3568577766418457,
-0.05131034180521965,
0.741087794303894,
0.26435378193855286,
-0.27518466114997864,
-0.2869392931461334,
-0.23048901557922363,
-0.40655359625816345,
0.7299531102180481,
-0.2055036872625351,
-0.7491559386253357,
-0.1876484900712967,
-0.3896026611328125,
-0.3760034143924713,
-0.7626131772994995,
0.8170595169067383,
-0.31546518206596375,
0.3170557916164398,
-0.28514233231544495,
-0.3763619661331177,
-0.43486714363098145,
-0.1625346541404724,
-0.8611853122711182,
1.0840667486190796,
0.17400209605693817,
-0.6354753971099854,
0.13429628312587738,
-0.7778108716011047,
-0.6065118312835693,
-0.21302379667758942,
0.1276317536830902,
-0.3812393844127655,
0.22565484046936035,
-0.08148445934057236,
0.3034948408603668,
-0.5431739091873169,
0.05708249658346176,
-0.24089379608631134,
-0.7222108840942383,
0.36067843437194824,
-0.6490612030029297,
1.147430181503296,
0.30820444226264954,
-0.4202784597873688,
-0.11668147891759872,
-1.1325160264968872,
0.001506177824921906,
-0.0018322288524359465,
-0.5819072127342224,
-0.17729318141937256,
-0.12650485336780548,
0.17850470542907715,
0.1239907294511795,
-0.24540206789970398,
-0.5770062208175659,
-0.13196058571338654,
-0.011141055263578892,
0.4979526996612549,
0.4004038870334625,
-0.04091472551226616,
0.25726568698883057,
-0.15590454638004303,
0.3379517197608948,
0.41173428297042847,
0.38243982195854187,
0.32028359174728394,
-0.609205961227417,
-0.5541245341300964,
-0.10111464560031891,
0.9117996096611023,
0.7707688808441162,
-0.4005334675312042,
0.23959675431251526,
-0.04376736283302307,
-0.5217288136482239,
-0.33772361278533936,
0.06933601945638657,
0.3898337781429291,
0.8515592813491821,
0.2567051351070404,
-0.4491509199142456,
-0.8293030858039856,
-0.7354800701141357,
-0.12221512198448181,
-0.6546046733856201,
0.009794317185878754,
0.1974543333053589,
-0.1363266408443451,
0.012863501906394958,
0.7720955014228821,
0.15409545600414276,
-0.4459485411643982,
-0.14338313043117523,
0.11491374671459198,
0.05029933899641037,
0.4589923918247223,
0.4189486503601074,
-0.8634760975837708,
-0.10515869408845901,
-0.1077047809958458,
-0.4817652702331543,
-0.10453268140554428,
0.04923420771956444,
0.33381739258766174,
0.053165141493082047,
0.5265050530433655,
-0.4423401951789856,
0.6151098608970642,
0.3672778010368347,
-0.04046013206243515,
0.6697020530700684,
0.07834061235189438,
0.04059095308184624,
-0.8709390759468079,
-0.12287043035030365,
0.47202637791633606,
0.037364400923252106,
-0.7560816407203674,
-0.5738134980201721,
0.06401602178812027,
-0.08845444768667221,
-0.6250726580619812,
0.1954597532749176,
-0.3352987766265869,
-0.49880343675613403,
0.023230861872434616,
-0.09698475897312164,
-0.13482767343521118,
0.5728136301040649,
-0.19177600741386414,
0.9700545072555542,
0.41788119077682495,
-0.7120677828788757,
0.34080395102500916,
0.08832831680774689,
-0.1257028579711914,
0.30959779024124146,
-0.655027449131012,
0.2758815586566925,
0.18640053272247314,
0.4094512164592743,
-1.395729899406433,
0.10157579183578491,
0.33774882555007935,
-0.6707373857498169,
0.21688655018806458,
-0.35280275344848633,
-0.6716786623001099,
-0.3133561611175537,
-0.16109874844551086,
0.5419095158576965,
0.4820955991744995,
-0.3751131296157837,
0.5978867411613464,
0.28832951188087463,
0.02261124551296234,
-0.6456183195114136,
-0.5251060128211975,
-0.0592292845249176,
-0.332580029964447,
-0.48521924018859863,
0.19656546413898468,
0.1871849149465561,
-0.24144406616687775,
-0.16600097715854645,
-0.4004027247428894,
-0.38187769055366516,
0.06644804775714874,
0.3590959310531616,
0.21448111534118652,
-0.5988614559173584,
-0.05249541997909546,
-0.18072058260440826,
0.05892157554626465,
-0.10453472286462784,
-0.5629557967185974,
0.4482831656932831,
-0.10495474934577942,
-0.07573115825653076,
-0.9776806235313416,
-0.10415256768465042,
0.64908367395401,
-0.2665962874889374,
0.10551202297210693,
0.7743012309074402,
-0.5363077521324158,
0.16287720203399658,
-0.6415168046951294,
0.17910833656787872,
-0.40513601899147034,
0.1758698672056198,
-0.5818939208984375,
-0.3202756941318512,
0.886112630367279,
0.08930756896734238,
0.05191490426659584,
0.4055083692073822,
0.115850530564785,
-0.38021036982536316,
0.6740626692771912,
0.4541189968585968,
0.00559775996953249,
0.5986993908882141,
-0.2713291645050049,
0.1490841805934906,
-0.8628242611885071,
-0.3225283622741699,
-0.6053715944290161,
-0.415933221578598,
-0.6625779271125793,
-0.12707211077213287,
0.19391465187072754,
0.28358471393585205,
-0.12945978343486786,
0.533156156539917,
-0.23565275967121124,
0.008526942692697048,
0.8798162341117859,
0.21306690573692322,
0.17237971723079681,
0.3378032445907593,
-0.3394192159175873,
-0.00984459463506937,
-0.5994189381599426,
-0.2947115898132324,
1.3344937562942505,
0.44928592443466187,
0.4723633825778961,
0.02844720147550106,
0.7486749291419983,
0.2594568431377411,
-0.06195205822587013,
-0.8759275674819946,
0.5889270901679993,
-0.45965713262557983,
-0.30509522557258606,
-0.3886633515357971,
-0.3870985805988312,
-0.737437903881073,
0.06436971575021744,
0.15037430822849274,
-0.4172402024269104,
0.5636839866638184,
-0.06979913264513016,
-0.5964787006378174,
0.6715290546417236,
-0.9083861708641052,
0.38962364196777344,
0.07824347168207169,
0.19561997056007385,
0.13104665279388428,
-0.5478214025497437,
0.41626158356666565,
-0.03726722672581673,
0.005409623496234417,
-0.1295986771583557,
0.2101740837097168,
1.175971269607544,
-0.20235085487365723,
0.9436512589454651,
-0.6435365676879883,
-0.33709731698036194,
0.7008218765258789,
-0.0027529222425073385,
0.2508358657360077,
-0.15590664744377136,
-0.3210301399230957,
0.469454288482666,
0.07721955329179764,
-0.30780428647994995,
-0.46283701062202454,
0.29042670130729675,
-0.8913607001304626,
-0.37969180941581726,
-0.07004207372665405,
-0.5612754821777344,
-0.36246800422668457,
0.10946889966726303,
0.4493975341320038,
0.7484108805656433,
-0.06090928614139557,
-0.07835005223751068,
0.5849477648735046,
-0.2205747812986374,
0.6046419143676758,
0.4325617253780365,
0.31600072979927063,
-0.37904852628707886,
0.824347198009491,
0.4386497139930725,
0.00855388306081295,
0.13276898860931396,
0.37175288796424866,
-0.6694259643554688,
-1.075892448425293,
-0.5157925486564636,
0.01589631289243698,
-0.6540156602859497,
-0.22688408195972443,
-0.4625270366668701,
-0.26311707496643066,
-0.4231036305427551,
0.5743870139122009,
-0.40468260645866394,
-0.4950365424156189,
-0.2813301384449005,
0.11435212939977646,
0.24850121140480042,
0.6436806917190552,
-0.10739908367395401,
0.3905861973762512,
-0.8603377938270569,
0.17371153831481934,
0.07699644565582275,
0.24481575191020966,
-0.008663419634103775,
-0.8348801732063293,
-0.02561059594154358,
0.1707877516746521,
-0.09575699269771576,
-0.9262337684631348,
-0.07227886468172073,
0.05721794441342354,
0.3591243624687195,
0.2915228307247162,
0.1463555544614792,
0.9713765978813171,
-0.30434608459472656,
0.8596769571304321,
0.3314211964607239,
-0.9157347679138184,
0.31000304222106934,
-0.2950232923030853,
-0.30274471640586853,
0.28436872363090515,
-0.29638734459877014,
-0.6099603176116943,
-0.16132043302059174,
-0.7447414994239807,
-0.4316970407962799,
0.6636387705802917,
0.1565268188714981,
0.0658208429813385,
0.19071979820728302,
0.5177240371704102,
-0.014115603640675545,
-0.09649670124053955,
-0.5422897338867188,
-0.39267587661743164,
-0.3816968500614166,
-0.357759952545166,
0.18658296763896942,
-0.2579439580440521,
0.029493365436792374,
-0.4906121790409088,
0.4991203248500824,
0.1831180900335312,
0.5820707678794861,
0.4125814437866211,
-0.1573513299226761,
-0.1831641048192978,
0.17359641194343567,
1.09780752658844,
0.519668698310852,
-0.35192379355430603,
0.2111465036869049,
0.44759681820869446,
-0.854973554611206,
0.33719515800476074,
0.22629669308662415,
0.22824664413928986,
0.3614554703235626,
0.2750478982925415,
0.7106261849403381,
0.18439030647277832,
-0.30599862337112427,
0.5180823802947998,
-0.3679763972759247,
-0.324588805437088,
-0.5375164747238159,
-0.16692574322223663,
-0.10295920819044113,
0.2592400014400482,
0.5978196859359741,
0.4146066904067993,
0.24904368817806244,
-0.11602862179279327,
0.06946391612291336,
0.2358955442905426,
-0.44105660915374756,
-0.5822754502296448,
0.6618657112121582,
0.23405548930168152,
-0.45248690247535706,
0.7623760104179382,
-0.23441173136234283,
-0.3263211250305176,
0.8196572065353394,
0.5731040835380554,
1.0075138807296753,
-0.6478272080421448,
0.03491125628352165,
0.30525678396224976,
0.25214678049087524,
-0.2018200010061264,
0.25104135274887085,
-0.07682062685489655,
-0.726807713508606,
-0.2875506579875946,
-0.49459266662597656,
-0.45479249954223633,
0.5819854140281677,
-0.712658166885376,
0.3482724726200104,
-0.737879753112793,
-0.11705488711595535,
0.2206345647573471,
0.04842061921954155,
-0.6828266382217407,
0.5161802172660828,
-0.07672220468521118,
0.9585279226303101,
-0.6172763705253601,
0.9689995646476746,
0.7477383017539978,
-0.270196795463562,
-1.360048532485962,
0.34079596400260925,
-0.1487611085176468,
-0.8043674230575562,
0.9974578022956848,
-0.025223489850759506,
-0.37234437465667725,
0.08969047665596008,
-0.0365334190428257,
-0.7292710542678833,
0.9813535213470459,
0.22421053051948547,
-0.7149263024330139,
-0.214042529463768,
0.22430793941020966,
0.36200132966041565,
-0.00942640658468008,
0.27406519651412964,
0.6033381819725037,
0.5017695426940918,
0.00225316290743649,
-1.2622040510177612,
-0.22936537861824036,
-0.12407448887825012,
0.08925584703683853,
-0.0002068042813334614,
-0.6061885356903076,
0.6243125796318054,
-0.313901424407959,
-0.3850705325603485,
0.09744055569171906,
0.5385394096374512,
-0.011094446294009686,
0.36676424741744995,
0.92521733045578,
0.44179970026016235,
0.7503653168678284,
-0.04255109652876854,
0.5856937170028687,
-0.12959401309490204,
0.14069393277168274,
0.7098668813705444,
-0.28463098406791687,
0.919403076171875,
0.349543958902359,
-0.5153439044952393,
0.21500636637210846,
1.0592211484909058,
-0.049511875957250595,
0.3016680181026459,
0.18380200862884521,
-0.2434399127960205,
0.2915099263191223,
0.19719183444976807,
-0.24637363851070404,
0.8898069858551025,
0.2673052251338959,
-0.1462179720401764,
-0.24851854145526886,
0.28408995270729065,
-0.21534383296966553,
-0.3549652099609375,
-0.17658354341983795,
0.4986382722854614,
0.011786370538175106,
-0.1887226402759552,
0.8476543426513672,
0.3228667080402374,
0.6450324058532715,
-0.13533328473567963,
0.10144156217575073,
-0.3636126220226288,
-0.09159893542528152,
-0.36258476972579956,
-0.33249253034591675,
0.25137171149253845,
-0.1332365870475769,
-0.16450238227844238,
0.1508994698524475,
0.6605655550956726,
-0.315929651260376,
-0.23395495116710663,
0.1714247465133667,
0.32540175318717957,
0.3384157419204712,
-0.006213379558175802,
-0.752238392829895,
0.09236662089824677,
0.16867852210998535,
-0.000352752220351249,
-0.22587284445762634,
0.3029634952545166,
-0.213397815823555,
0.23070065677165985,
0.7869064211845398,
0.07588476687669754,
0.4659319221973419,
0.36647871136665344,
0.1729445904493332,
-0.7701245546340942,
-0.3297957181930542,
-0.6018654108047485,
0.27259477972984314,
0.27601727843284607,
-0.3800369203090668,
0.5659497976303101,
0.727963387966156,
0.7779166102409363,
-0.06225190311670303,
0.6328340172767639,
0.2450619786977768,
0.5446816682815552,
-0.5943859219551086,
0.5244179964065552,
-0.34035053849220276,
0.5165923833847046,
-0.20493590831756592,
-1.0213440656661987,
-0.4094812870025635,
0.42215606570243835,
-0.09699469804763794,
0.05531555786728859,
0.49609920382499695,
0.7140883207321167,
-0.26020336151123047,
0.4659828841686249,
0.433828741312027,
0.11729998141527176,
0.10876696556806564,
0.2555699944496155,
0.9910538792610168,
-0.8877188563346863,
0.8528523445129395,
-0.3757580518722534,
-0.07059172540903091,
-0.15848039090633392,
-0.16472312808036804,
-0.643474280834198,
-0.8165289759635925,
-0.5227972865104675,
-0.5675845146179199,
-0.059644993394613266,
0.7685110569000244,
0.6924075484275818,
-0.7617385983467102,
-0.4519421458244324,
-0.14370350539684296,
0.11572683602571487,
-0.3898313045501709,
-0.217367485165596,
0.6612950563430786,
-0.34553635120391846,
-0.8720837831497192,
0.5006956458091736,
0.07050201296806335,
0.6117433309555054,
0.07900592684745789,
-0.05124330520629883,
0.2897069454193115,
0.05000712350010872,
0.4447147846221924,
0.44381222128868103,
-0.8961646556854248,
-0.26953816413879395,
0.20683763921260834,
-0.12772256135940552,
0.38892966508865356,
0.9080651998519897,
-0.4761076867580414,
0.2539323568344116,
0.250660240650177,
0.2726981043815613,
-0.01429749932140112,
-0.27428779006004333,
0.29989469051361084,
-0.7910546064376831,
0.4376431703567505,
0.17470955848693848,
0.48146411776542664,
0.26772770285606384,
-0.25722187757492065,
0.24238517880439758,
0.5435250997543335,
-0.15882235765457153,
-1.174246072769165,
0.15523572266101837,
-1.2438738346099854,
-0.0011330796405673027,
1.1420223712921143,
-0.08389940857887268,
-0.12906773388385773,
-0.44326525926589966,
-0.23560990393161774,
0.7541069984436035,
-0.23575249314308167,
0.43230170011520386,
0.5203903317451477,
-0.2197251319885254,
-0.3241076171398163,
-0.6621490120887756,
0.5609866976737976,
0.43197715282440186,
-0.32333454489707947,
-0.12638503313064575,
0.18877750635147095,
0.79068922996521,
0.26397860050201416,
0.5712274312973022,
-0.4465778172016144,
0.3840923011302948,
0.11919219046831131,
0.2559015452861786,
-0.12335709482431412,
-0.30438587069511414,
-0.32415246963500977,
0.011210598051548004,
0.12001828104257584,
-0.9984174370765686
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00894v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00894v1
|
Pretrained Hybrids with MAD Skills
| 2024-06-02T23:24:30 | 2024-06-02T23:24:30 |
Nicholas Roberts, Samuel Guo, Zhiqi Gao, Satya Sai Srinath Namburi GNVV, Sonia Cromp, Chengjun Wu, Chengyu Duan, Frederic Sala
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
While Transformers underpin modern large language models (LMs), there is a
growing list of alternative architectures with new capabilities, promises, and
tradeoffs. This makes choosing the right LM architecture challenging.
Recently-proposed $\textit{hybrid architectures}$ seek a best-of-all-worlds
approach that reaps the benefits of all architectures. Hybrid design is
difficult for two reasons: it requires manual expert-driven search, and new
hybrids must be trained from scratch. We propose $\textbf{Manticore}$, a
framework that addresses these challenges. Manticore $\textit{automates the
design of hybrid architectures}$ while reusing pretrained models to create
$\textit{pretrained}$ hybrids. Our approach augments ideas from differentiable
Neural Architecture Search (NAS) by incorporating simple projectors that
translate features between pretrained blocks from different architectures. We
then fine-tune hybrids that combine pretrained models from different
architecture families -- such as the GPT series and Mamba -- end-to-end. With
Manticore, we enable LM selection without training multiple models, the
construction of pretrained hybrids from existing pretrained models, and the
ability to $\textit{program}$ pretrained hybrids to have certain capabilities.
Manticore hybrids outperform existing manually-designed hybrids, achieve strong
performance on Long Range Arena (LRA) tasks, and can improve on pretrained
transformers and state space models.
|
[
-0.4445064067840576,
-0.13531765341758728,
0.35828667879104614,
0.20307959616184235,
-0.06791027635335922,
0.6869680285453796,
-0.2050483077764511,
-0.6121125221252441,
0.6557439565658569,
0.1333475112915039,
-0.4487994611263275,
-0.308917373418808,
-0.4083482325077057,
0.1000547930598259,
-0.33945775032043457,
0.7313447594642639,
-0.30060628056526184,
-0.03664442524313927,
-0.009095973335206509,
-0.08308933675289154,
-0.3642074763774872,
-0.4811326563358307,
-0.3600553274154663,
-0.3925454020500183,
0.5221049189567566,
0.1964249163866043,
0.7752153873443604,
0.39941152930259705,
-0.015473401173949242,
0.3911416232585907,
0.00500813452526927,
0.519966185092926,
-0.3100360631942749,
-0.15088105201721191,
-0.2197694331407547,
-0.5196698904037476,
-0.5794856548309326,
-0.07311736792325974,
0.25070124864578247,
0.5193879008293152,
-0.26186567544937134,
-0.16805927455425262,
-0.32357877492904663,
0.5933859348297119,
-0.6544126868247986,
-0.26868095993995667,
-0.5897145867347717,
0.37092286348342896,
-0.3701368570327759,
-0.46072930097579956,
-0.43125563859939575,
-0.05520752817392349,
0.05636303499341011,
-0.8257120251655579,
0.08440438657999039,
0.32345426082611084,
0.8899637460708618,
0.30551227927207947,
-0.19428099691867828,
0.25594112277030945,
-1.1090730428695679,
0.6363967061042786,
-0.46690648794174194,
0.6842197775840759,
0.21468935906887054,
0.5245769023895264,
-0.2239210158586502,
-0.3392675220966339,
-0.4908800721168518,
-0.37606507539749146,
0.03396330401301384,
0.33482345938682556,
-0.1616450697183609,
0.1515575349330902,
-0.08975681662559509,
0.626408040523529,
-0.5452551245689392,
0.35704877972602844,
-0.5640748143196106,
-0.5103126764297485,
0.5145019888877869,
0.015996726229786873,
0.3289860785007477,
-0.06391492486000061,
-0.3168905973434448,
-0.3630357086658478,
-0.5561575293540955,
-0.3596748113632202,
0.565278172492981,
-0.09010493755340576,
0.147997185587883,
0.5537694692611694,
-0.24785520136356354,
0.6032832860946655,
0.11836347728967667,
-0.058707285672426224,
0.2880921959877014,
-0.08672857284545898,
-0.16464966535568237,
-0.025745704770088196,
0.8086053729057312,
-0.27064016461372375,
0.3726591467857361,
-0.6506346464157104,
-0.49479979276657104,
0.1033763512969017,
0.4607675075531006,
-0.485363632440567,
-0.4572049379348755,
0.22776885330677032,
-0.2634460926055908,
-0.19490081071853638,
-0.19444985687732697,
-0.7009199857711792,
-0.04211273789405823,
-0.553726851940155,
0.6384071111679077,
-0.6226048469543457,
-0.7467378973960876,
0.43620243668556213,
-0.23002082109451294,
0.07259184122085571,
0.16812989115715027,
-0.9392136931419373,
0.33284252882003784,
0.40485236048698425,
0.9592640995979309,
-0.25051403045654297,
-0.6882094144821167,
-0.34819087386131287,
0.09834037721157074,
-0.45120036602020264,
0.9018464088439941,
-0.5776583552360535,
-0.40759703516960144,
-0.2966780364513397,
-0.42727571725845337,
-0.373762309551239,
-0.7611761689186096,
0.3950650691986084,
-0.6778887510299683,
0.22360840439796448,
0.15693721175193787,
-0.5045684576034546,
0.04017161577939987,
0.11643359065055847,
-0.6265907287597656,
0.9079080820083618,
0.42645880579948425,
-0.6963932514190674,
0.18205003440380096,
-0.94801265001297,
-0.7324590682983398,
-0.043288376182317734,
-0.4835086166858673,
-0.3204606771469116,
0.33777469396591187,
-0.06054490804672241,
0.27590784430503845,
-0.262859582901001,
0.07416593283414841,
0.0033225768711417913,
-0.22020402550697327,
-0.16353821754455566,
-0.11955652385950089,
0.5670974254608154,
0.3035297095775604,
-0.3890224099159241,
0.5977575182914734,
-0.7028743028640747,
-0.11347213387489319,
0.25789299607276917,
-0.4049285650253296,
-0.3477054536342621,
0.1509709656238556,
0.01745498925447464,
0.18612052500247955,
0.2691165804862976,
-0.33805710077285767,
0.038377486169338226,
-0.4573139250278473,
0.4036698639392853,
0.7790406942367554,
-0.5028305649757385,
0.6782538294792175,
-0.3143038749694824,
0.8050938844680786,
0.12864293158054352,
0.21567079424858093,
0.3310762643814087,
-0.24327398836612701,
-0.9002093076705933,
-0.36152422428131104,
0.09113115072250366,
0.5933023691177368,
-0.9508609175682068,
0.5981537699699402,
-0.034776218235492706,
-0.8581061959266663,
-0.6162393689155579,
0.24401329457759857,
0.36008894443511963,
0.035520829260349274,
0.536965012550354,
-0.21131983399391174,
-0.7208068370819092,
-1.216490626335144,
-0.1143200546503067,
0.2784363925457001,
0.18828009068965912,
0.11445311456918716,
0.5086764097213745,
-0.3683765232563019,
0.8441480398178101,
-0.611129641532898,
-0.20599119365215302,
-0.43371260166168213,
0.28536033630371094,
0.048229556530714035,
0.6611800789833069,
0.7243891358375549,
-0.7101453542709351,
-0.21473492681980133,
0.20385053753852844,
-0.4987362027168274,
0.3034989535808563,
-0.02690041996538639,
-0.47275298833847046,
-0.16367007791996002,
0.47787049412727356,
-1.0097771883010864,
-0.05168186500668526,
0.5464598536491394,
0.06824085861444473,
0.9478750228881836,
-0.525080680847168,
0.04255593195557594,
-1.5022556781768799,
0.13219554722309113,
-0.17136646807193756,
-0.01680842414498329,
-0.6635376214981079,
0.20975911617279053,
-0.0451781302690506,
-0.13133400678634644,
-0.5191515684127808,
0.47333672642707825,
-0.6680195927619934,
-0.2873658537864685,
-0.2654949128627777,
-0.19134394824504852,
-0.11692206561565399,
0.4932330548763275,
0.2300795614719391,
0.9739891290664673,
0.6061072945594788,
-0.6814831495285034,
0.27673089504241943,
0.19308534264564514,
-0.3682032525539398,
0.4544316828250885,
-0.6006115674972534,
0.1909381002187729,
-0.08662574738264084,
0.26243889331817627,
-0.5246408581733704,
-0.47123733162879944,
-0.061516813933849335,
-0.29802027344703674,
0.34276923537254333,
0.20747891068458557,
-0.6473938822746277,
-0.6854649782180786,
-0.09360823780298233,
0.5512930154800415,
0.36331361532211304,
-0.45669668912887573,
0.9619844555854797,
0.3644716739654541,
0.4157966673374176,
-0.30420470237731934,
-0.21610622107982635,
0.012012926861643791,
-0.05178774520754814,
-0.4778050184249878,
0.33829981088638306,
-0.1961817890405655,
-0.12924472987651825,
-0.2028682380914688,
-0.05924556031823158,
-0.10798833519220352,
0.3176780045032501,
0.01799989677965641,
0.3782171308994293,
-0.3829761743545532,
0.0027059002313762903,
0.26518765091896057,
-0.5044129490852356,
-0.29695820808410645,
-0.5979737639427185,
1.014786958694458,
-0.11506665498018265,
-0.46637871861457825,
-0.4591117203235626,
0.4312366843223572,
0.8362255692481995,
-0.8076003193855286,
0.5244870781898499,
0.6289536952972412,
-0.45519569516181946,
-0.2369115650653839,
-0.42849141359329224,
-0.2725108563899994,
-0.5212311744689941,
0.6180055737495422,
-0.5668255090713501,
-0.8415892720222473,
0.1485169678926468,
-0.15723809599876404,
0.32470807433128357,
0.4470084607601166,
0.6445749402046204,
-0.10785112529993057,
0.8944918513298035,
0.6369026899337769,
-0.31151843070983887,
0.4877777099609375,
-0.3037291169166565,
0.22992673516273499,
-0.6861392855644226,
-0.18235035240650177,
-0.3568401634693146,
-0.7415055632591248,
-0.3106054961681366,
-0.5014546513557434,
0.26626095175743103,
-0.11735571920871735,
-0.08911807090044022,
0.7741807103157043,
-0.5951228737831116,
0.8209295868873596,
0.7987757921218872,
0.09225676953792572,
0.27357321977615356,
-0.09377341717481613,
-0.20280788838863373,
0.028659449890255928,
-0.9279060363769531,
-0.21601161360740662,
0.9248287677764893,
0.17063592374324799,
0.6523638963699341,
0.04771099612116814,
0.8187066912651062,
0.05032055079936981,
0.3378675580024719,
-0.7344031929969788,
0.5720058679580688,
-0.237758070230484,
-0.8444646596908569,
0.03953969106078148,
-0.4543624520301819,
-0.8270666003227234,
0.10456029325723648,
-0.3719414472579956,
-0.6639939546585083,
0.2268080860376358,
0.4671628475189209,
-0.849297821521759,
0.8120557069778442,
-0.7911494970321655,
0.6997563242912292,
-0.6775779724121094,
-0.27102065086364746,
-0.4619975984096527,
-0.40780138969421387,
0.35023969411849976,
-0.010981796309351921,
-0.10258238017559052,
0.20158091187477112,
0.1873498260974884,
0.661758542060852,
-0.16402457654476166,
0.7228601574897766,
0.10579798370599747,
-0.09384557604789734,
0.03966844081878662,
0.541934072971344,
0.31250548362731934,
-0.5019542574882507,
0.12660066783428192,
-0.03989405557513237,
-0.17749682068824768,
-0.47750115394592285,
-0.2891151010990143,
0.7405586242675781,
-1.2982999086380005,
-0.600071370601654,
-0.1976466327905655,
-0.7890649437904358,
-0.37432458996772766,
0.2033829540014267,
0.4872867166996002,
0.3809453547000885,
-0.004391219932585955,
0.010780790820717812,
0.7123662829399109,
-0.18547075986862183,
0.22340741753578186,
0.1452995091676712,
-0.1080724224448204,
-0.25562554597854614,
1.1630685329437256,
-0.0727212205529213,
0.45795708894729614,
0.7050324082374573,
0.12021602690219879,
-0.24790482223033905,
-0.5534996390342712,
-0.6350586414337158,
0.12456246465444565,
-0.26909545063972473,
-0.04031702131032944,
-0.7538976669311523,
-0.3957286775112152,
-0.02223040536046028,
-0.3766176700592041,
-0.9547634720802307,
-0.15450073778629303,
-0.3522130846977234,
-0.10634928941726685,
0.18845264613628387,
0.6458896994590759,
-0.09593284130096436,
0.2909158766269684,
-0.7314238548278809,
0.18953795731067657,
0.3936956822872162,
0.3857298195362091,
0.19897305965423584,
-0.34088370203971863,
-0.2931845486164093,
-0.1290622502565384,
-0.3360174596309662,
-0.8005267977714539,
0.33451664447784424,
0.10195452719926834,
0.682653546333313,
0.43439576029777527,
-0.13180141150951385,
0.7317278981208801,
-0.5534549951553345,
0.1365891396999359,
0.37370315194129944,
-0.6109663844108582,
0.39075717329978943,
-0.47761300206184387,
-0.07304716855287552,
0.7395815849304199,
0.6916059255599976,
-0.229387104511261,
-0.1308690756559372,
-0.6016415953636169,
-0.6564021706581116,
0.4036523103713989,
0.2309858202934265,
-0.04781827703118324,
0.14001604914665222,
0.16838093101978302,
0.3496229350566864,
0.38115832209587097,
-0.5503193736076355,
-0.03491522744297981,
-0.2869521975517273,
-0.19727447628974915,
-0.17942839860916138,
0.2475084811449051,
-0.23102638125419617,
-0.4838312864303589,
0.4682944715023041,
-0.029746465384960175,
0.27694129943847656,
0.14163079857826233,
-0.3040882349014282,
-0.2351214587688446,
0.2240769863128662,
0.6928884983062744,
0.5257092118263245,
-0.1122143417596817,
0.11601786315441132,
0.07868858426809311,
-0.13545109331607819,
0.2192722111940384,
-0.0413225032389164,
-0.07614090293645859,
-0.1042935773730278,
0.11409595608711243,
0.9566581845283508,
0.5106546878814697,
-0.8767685294151306,
0.20811593532562256,
0.36575430631637573,
-0.5238027572631836,
-0.45717138051986694,
0.4163193106651306,
0.2892393469810486,
0.42173388600349426,
0.08785606920719147,
0.5212249755859375,
-0.0990261510014534,
-0.5539267063140869,
0.235905721783638,
0.3094348609447479,
-0.1608172506093979,
-0.7160497903823853,
0.8277650475502014,
0.4926484525203705,
-0.6354514956474304,
0.4045654833316803,
-0.46862438321113586,
-0.794883668422699,
0.2754085659980774,
0.6586838364601135,
1.0002849102020264,
-0.16609905660152435,
0.2664603888988495,
0.25630831718444824,
0.3708775043487549,
-0.31729212403297424,
0.035763733088970184,
-0.13832999765872955,
-0.9213772416114807,
-0.5019798874855042,
-0.7851473689079285,
-0.3179744482040405,
0.22562794387340546,
-0.30153918266296387,
0.061667781323194504,
-0.7073484063148499,
0.1258596032857895,
-0.3192351758480072,
-0.16549354791641235,
-0.5851661562919617,
-0.016440285369753838,
0.2131311148405075,
1.2090448141098022,
-0.8900713920593262,
0.7771102786064148,
0.8425816297531128,
-0.31615734100341797,
-0.732764720916748,
-0.21396423876285553,
-0.02640525810420513,
-0.8425192832946777,
0.48308372497558594,
-0.026952778920531273,
-0.22801262140274048,
0.3639061748981476,
-0.20051968097686768,
-0.5746894478797913,
1.224743366241455,
0.353177547454834,
-0.9285396933555603,
-0.4081047773361206,
0.025255413725972176,
0.4663907289505005,
-0.25411731004714966,
0.24402397871017456,
0.6365490555763245,
0.3841601312160492,
0.14145727455615997,
-1.062485933303833,
-0.32690197229385376,
-0.26935747265815735,
-0.30313846468925476,
0.4566012918949127,
-0.8336178660392761,
1.0517040491104126,
-0.343029648065567,
-0.06283296644687653,
0.25300833582878113,
0.7920857071876526,
0.28246039152145386,
-0.09323366731405258,
0.7276032567024231,
0.8737562894821167,
0.6717007756233215,
0.05604025349020958,
1.095564365386963,
-0.44866785407066345,
0.0029766925144940615,
1.1480964422225952,
-0.234517902135849,
1.1398032903671265,
0.4107673466205597,
-0.09205874055624008,
0.5165647268295288,
0.7838425636291504,
0.265016108751297,
0.3761950135231018,
0.13167215883731842,
-0.2999522089958191,
-0.7961283326148987,
0.19278958439826965,
-0.39090219140052795,
0.5029050707817078,
0.12172305583953857,
-0.0175758246332407,
-0.314834326505661,
-0.13753828406333923,
-0.00939883477985859,
0.16254326701164246,
-0.0937311053276062,
0.4100474715232849,
0.1275428980588913,
-0.6366056799888611,
0.4577236473560333,
-0.16583499312400818,
0.9888102412223816,
-0.8671801686286926,
0.3883475959300995,
-0.21921928226947784,
0.33687734603881836,
-0.21054261922836304,
-0.3891685903072357,
0.28828421235084534,
-0.22478222846984863,
-0.015987683087587357,
-0.015087930485606194,
0.6234808564186096,
-0.2204558551311493,
-0.3705126941204071,
0.45788657665252686,
0.8594496250152588,
-0.00609697587788105,
-0.32023149728775024,
-0.6328854560852051,
-0.23190036416053772,
-0.1453275829553604,
0.11247103661298752,
0.4507782459259033,
0.19449684023857117,
-0.1158323809504509,
0.6403226256370544,
0.8448737859725952,
0.2638265788555145,
0.13407911360263824,
0.13301989436149597,
0.9108183979988098,
-0.5938106179237366,
-0.5130795240402222,
-0.5775694251060486,
0.25539618730545044,
-0.06441646814346313,
-0.5768037438392639,
0.37210968136787415,
0.6759331822395325,
0.8648038506507874,
-0.1870359480381012,
0.5552648305892944,
-0.03174412623047829,
0.21366950869560242,
-0.3500910997390747,
0.8515360355377197,
-0.8962164521217346,
-0.10251956433057785,
-0.08719281852245331,
-1.0222234725952148,
-0.08795071393251419,
0.6247372031211853,
-0.4346504509449005,
-0.023866375908255577,
0.5730874538421631,
0.9255008101463318,
-0.4727087616920471,
-0.012633279897272587,
0.4247312545776367,
0.26958295702934265,
0.3432486951351166,
0.820460855960846,
1.0598902702331543,
-0.08276846259832382,
0.4542839229106903,
-0.17100055515766144,
-0.30941227078437805,
-0.34065377712249756,
-0.5735320448875427,
-0.9918898344039917,
-0.5779359936714172,
0.07748835533857346,
0.0901428610086441,
-0.01664873957633972,
1.2962888479232788,
1.0235121250152588,
-0.7161890268325806,
-0.4026676416397095,
-0.20636163651943207,
-0.2619515061378479,
-0.028296547010540962,
-0.1444929838180542,
0.18408800661563873,
-0.1387302130460739,
-0.6630715727806091,
0.7017744779586792,
0.4798549711704254,
0.2633586525917053,
-0.6221212148666382,
-0.3455456793308258,
-0.29820993542671204,
-0.0030846872832626104,
0.7134849429130554,
0.6022691130638123,
-0.351273775100708,
-0.2214272916316986,
0.3212265074253082,
0.06546231359243393,
0.17190249264240265,
0.9011714458465576,
-0.6543694138526917,
0.2405509054660797,
0.43528518080711365,
0.9840356707572937,
0.19431781768798828,
-0.3423076570034027,
0.7226638197898865,
-0.5846697092056274,
0.40995392203330994,
0.35476061701774597,
0.6349393725395203,
0.25188425183296204,
0.05919492617249489,
0.15364478528499603,
0.3460746109485626,
-0.21142002940177917,
-0.422487735748291,
0.3905297517776489,
-0.9009361267089844,
-0.27131417393684387,
1.0135048627853394,
0.3952926993370056,
-0.41647300124168396,
-0.16250814497470856,
-0.3918282091617584,
0.04504945129156113,
-0.1979561597108841,
0.9653332233428955,
0.3369345963001251,
-0.09866438060998917,
0.06397511065006256,
-0.53237384557724,
0.3395850658416748,
0.7740716934204102,
-0.9798240661621094,
-0.21427282691001892,
0.23893827199935913,
0.16175730526447296,
0.6098840236663818,
0.5534160733222961,
0.05522618070244789,
0.3643784821033478,
0.01426509115844965,
0.28414005041122437,
-0.21764898300170898,
-0.728672981262207,
0.4345455467700958,
0.021516816690564156,
0.16574183106422424,
-0.28583648800849915
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00888v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00888v1
|
Show, Don't Tell: Aligning Language Models with Demonstrated Feedback
| 2024-06-02T23:13:56 | 2024-06-02T23:13:56 |
Omar Shaikh, Michelle Lam, Joey Hejna, Yijia Shao, Michael Bernstein, Diyi Yang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.HC
|
Language models are aligned to emulate the collective voice of many,
resulting in outputs that align with no one in particular. Steering LLMs away
from generic output is possible through supervised finetuning or RLHF, but
requires prohibitively large datasets for new ad-hoc tasks. We argue that it is
instead possible to align an LLM to a specific setting by leveraging a very
small number ($<10$) of demonstrations as feedback. Our method, Demonstration
ITerated Task Optimization (DITTO), directly aligns language model outputs to a
user's demonstrated behaviors. Derived using ideas from online imitation
learning, DITTO cheaply generates online comparison data by treating users'
demonstrations as preferred over output from the LLM and its intermediate
checkpoints. We evaluate DITTO's ability to learn fine-grained style and task
alignment across domains such as news articles, emails, and blog posts.
Additionally, we conduct a user study soliciting a range of demonstrations from
participants ($N=16$). Across our benchmarks and user study, we find that
win-rates for DITTO outperform few-shot prompting, supervised fine-tuning, and
other self-play methods by an average of 19% points. By using demonstrations as
feedback directly, DITTO offers a novel method for effective customization of
LLMs.
|
[
-0.136703759431839,
-0.6989089846611023,
0.5419737100601196,
0.18633714318275452,
-0.15281179547309875,
0.22776424884796143,
-0.3805385231971741,
-0.0031228007283061743,
0.23702594637870789,
0.19360215961933136,
-0.8474470973014832,
-0.5016700625419617,
-0.5287708044052124,
-0.14504478871822357,
-0.576677143573761,
0.9237822890281677,
-0.0350264310836792,
0.026851437985897064,
-0.27296045422554016,
0.07149508595466614,
-0.26620057225227356,
-0.030421869829297066,
-0.4568588435649872,
-0.5330159068107605,
0.4487737715244293,
0.7547991871833801,
0.5022096633911133,
0.9049434065818787,
0.2586636543273926,
0.34128910303115845,
0.20150060951709747,
0.35654765367507935,
-0.8206632137298584,
0.014652920886874199,
-0.19569772481918335,
-0.5709788799285889,
-0.12293264269828796,
0.012269153259694576,
0.42209485173225403,
0.7999868392944336,
-0.26828426122665405,
0.17454738914966583,
0.39465197920799255,
0.5803783535957336,
-0.501552164554596,
0.06399289518594742,
-0.6579447984695435,
-0.1358070969581604,
-0.19202876091003418,
-0.08680263161659241,
-0.6618348360061646,
-0.43346428871154785,
-0.17172065377235413,
-0.6703459620475769,
0.1556439995765686,
0.033395543694496155,
0.7634499073028564,
0.4769553542137146,
0.005772577598690987,
-0.2565179169178009,
-0.9336985349655151,
1.0487273931503296,
-0.8219588994979858,
-0.06977764517068863,
0.23347286880016327,
0.4890762269496918,
-0.18434202671051025,
-0.5162784457206726,
-0.7169806361198425,
-0.39994776248931885,
-0.1172407865524292,
0.18433386087417603,
-0.4674251079559326,
-0.24050575494766235,
0.16408993303775787,
0.1328381448984146,
-0.48260512948036194,
0.5230370163917542,
-0.198237806558609,
-0.08822344988584518,
0.516670823097229,
0.1272791475057602,
0.2012435346841812,
0.2124946415424347,
-0.45748886466026306,
-0.3163897693157196,
-0.873542308807373,
0.16129080951213837,
0.39494335651397705,
0.45034700632095337,
-0.03861527517437935,
0.7591378688812256,
-0.3774677515029907,
0.8188243508338928,
0.7372801303863525,
-0.1460915356874466,
0.015612207353115082,
-0.1874053180217743,
-0.2410065233707428,
-0.05531846359372139,
1.0894023180007935,
0.5305359959602356,
0.007624386809766293,
-0.10209339112043381,
-0.34975457191467285,
0.2963223457336426,
0.21256032586097717,
-0.5420160293579102,
0.007409690413624048,
0.011429683305323124,
-0.3788314461708069,
-0.5258630514144897,
-0.04871571436524391,
-0.7970387935638428,
-0.5990195274353027,
-0.3579156994819641,
0.865827739238739,
-0.12225138396024704,
-0.17214606702327728,
-0.04284020513296127,
-0.011649643070995808,
-0.06534368544816971,
0.3633789122104645,
-1.0622755289077759,
0.6872526407241821,
0.8138741254806519,
0.633604109287262,
-0.19353283941745758,
-0.4044131636619568,
-0.7367900013923645,
0.04838459566235542,
-0.602313756942749,
0.5024875998497009,
-0.5453898310661316,
-0.19831499457359314,
0.03588179498910904,
-0.142461359500885,
-0.0376618392765522,
-0.6937148571014404,
0.0626792386174202,
-0.13244909048080444,
0.3675507605075836,
-0.318042516708374,
-0.6835095286369324,
0.19203336536884308,
0.10478103905916214,
-0.4517073631286621,
0.6831911206245422,
-0.03030247613787651,
-0.5629612803459167,
0.2661181390285492,
-0.49063608050346375,
-0.2741892337799072,
-0.16785301268100739,
-0.3788169324398041,
-0.30310511589050293,
0.15487171709537506,
0.39098790287971497,
0.4804454743862152,
0.012753111310303211,
0.1971224695444107,
-0.48053881525993347,
-0.6336802840232849,
0.32643160223960876,
-0.2455609291791916,
0.3155456483364105,
0.247475266456604,
-0.9411927461624146,
0.3004624843597412,
-0.49091583490371704,
-0.07147058099508286,
0.20884813368320465,
0.01842968352138996,
-0.12325062602758408,
0.0407562330365181,
-0.38570284843444824,
0.04121626541018486,
0.31765642762184143,
-0.5360696911811829,
0.33234483003616333,
-0.513694703578949,
0.3259318768978119,
0.744871199131012,
-0.4031587243080139,
0.6412603259086609,
-0.8886450529098511,
0.6720404028892517,
-0.14657391607761383,
0.2074216604232788,
0.04384006932377815,
-0.1485159993171692,
-0.8026692867279053,
-0.05065930262207985,
0.1534043252468109,
0.21695637702941895,
-0.7130077481269836,
0.0892169177532196,
-0.27164122462272644,
-0.5294504165649414,
-0.7993356585502625,
0.39058083295822144,
0.6879035234451294,
0.6841392517089844,
0.06323034316301346,
0.04166773334145546,
-0.43519654870033264,
-1.1592673063278198,
-0.2614559829235077,
-0.183629110455513,
0.036224886775016785,
0.025530919432640076,
0.09614630043506622,
0.22356562316417694,
0.6560810804367065,
-0.3523941934108734,
-0.2729565501213074,
-0.5230271220207214,
0.12500891089439392,
0.21768596768379211,
0.3036784827709198,
0.43013831973075867,
-0.449849933385849,
-0.6821624636650085,
0.12849770486354828,
-0.34848839044570923,
-0.42842456698417664,
-0.16190093755722046,
0.06149570643901825,
0.10040745884180069,
0.4190843999385834,
-0.21484343707561493,
0.3310614824295044,
0.7843172550201416,
-0.0072587281465530396,
0.175315260887146,
-0.15064668655395508,
0.08623428642749786,
-1.0153700113296509,
-0.11734890937805176,
0.03089914284646511,
-0.47393426299095154,
-0.4707735478878021,
-0.1977468878030777,
-0.06213875114917755,
0.06674111634492874,
-0.25623634457588196,
0.7597174644470215,
-0.35547763109207153,
-0.038814544677734375,
-0.482040673494339,
0.3293779194355011,
0.06888977438211441,
0.6203736662864685,
-0.012213247828185558,
0.7306376695632935,
0.4461118280887604,
-0.4720780849456787,
0.0680089071393013,
0.1279495656490326,
-0.4643281400203705,
0.42239150404930115,
-0.6137418746948242,
0.3298300802707672,
0.10667498409748077,
-0.06058388203382492,
-1.1752926111221313,
-0.15310786664485931,
0.36093270778656006,
-0.3630513846874237,
0.371785968542099,
-0.12817758321762085,
-0.5017839074134827,
-0.1482076793909073,
-0.5133610367774963,
-0.28168800473213196,
0.7714959383010864,
-0.73857182264328,
0.18190430104732513,
0.210123211145401,
0.015420290641486645,
-0.868527889251709,
-0.5440518260002136,
-0.2476619929075241,
-0.39808160066604614,
-0.2884766161441803,
0.3692638874053955,
-0.1954963356256485,
-0.4152369201183319,
-0.07476627081632614,
-0.2529445290565491,
0.007468252908438444,
0.23995177447795868,
0.4305839538574219,
0.05263463035225868,
-0.12082894891500473,
0.11187191307544708,
0.1695019155740738,
0.15578795969486237,
-0.3245437443256378,
-0.006900925654917955,
0.4907883107662201,
-0.09584129601716995,
-0.7952080965042114,
-0.8884484767913818,
0.2623147964477539,
0.4056603014469147,
0.17829780280590057,
0.6146383881568909,
0.4103523790836334,
-0.14130482077598572,
-0.5521230697631836,
-0.48923295736312866,
-0.3312873840332031,
-0.5395945906639099,
0.25241491198539734,
-0.14955419301986694,
-0.8135582804679871,
0.19593888521194458,
-0.23050613701343536,
0.3147197961807251,
0.09004415571689606,
0.6082010865211487,
-0.30647188425064087,
1.2185686826705933,
0.7165307998657227,
0.03416109085083008,
0.6222246289253235,
-0.08859964460134506,
0.0962015762925148,
-0.4814714789390564,
-0.14010009169578552,
-0.4042878746986389,
-0.7179767489433289,
-0.4407670497894287,
-0.29818254709243774,
-0.003034878522157669,
0.3400043547153473,
-0.05326466262340546,
0.4292912781238556,
-0.4778861999511719,
0.5234079360961914,
0.6673985719680786,
0.2619655430316925,
0.29511624574661255,
-0.05811643972992897,
-0.004462399519979954,
-0.2605012059211731,
-0.7093847990036011,
-0.8345236778259277,
1.0995429754257202,
0.21798384189605713,
1.1688430309295654,
0.20938228070735931,
1.0587666034698486,
0.18527045845985413,
0.4768062233924866,
-0.8274365067481995,
0.5695549845695496,
-0.39572203159332275,
-0.05492773279547691,
-0.40567001700401306,
-0.2640749514102936,
-0.8942611813545227,
-0.09019096940755844,
0.16458694636821747,
-0.7595731019973755,
-0.049805764108896255,
0.6229998469352722,
-0.28697288036346436,
0.16965751349925995,
-0.907573401927948,
0.7548445463180542,
-0.2843356430530548,
-0.378461092710495,
-0.20118345320224762,
-0.3592570722103119,
0.19573751091957092,
0.009117862209677696,
0.35085931420326233,
0.007177269551903009,
0.07513663172721863,
0.7037026882171631,
-0.6052699685096741,
1.3933484554290771,
-0.22320711612701416,
0.0374254509806633,
0.11542826890945435,
0.37815865874290466,
0.6074652671813965,
-0.2625771462917328,
0.07164198160171509,
-0.3470190763473511,
-0.1628197282552719,
-0.1789802610874176,
-0.8848336935043335,
1.0959904193878174,
-0.6827903389930725,
-0.9288756847381592,
0.1710515022277832,
-0.3867233097553253,
-0.29414838552474976,
0.09508946537971497,
0.23653718829154968,
0.46882423758506775,
-0.18211115896701813,
0.041047558188438416,
0.39498111605644226,
0.0877731442451477,
0.5561044216156006,
0.46128636598587036,
-0.3473252058029175,
-0.18579290807247162,
1.1002516746520996,
-0.19606511294841766,
0.6363440155982971,
0.630959689617157,
0.5703754425048828,
-0.47414630651474,
-0.5658480525016785,
-0.4967888295650482,
0.2376493513584137,
-0.7436692714691162,
-0.029787007719278336,
-0.29467710852622986,
0.31319156289100647,
-0.43052956461906433,
-0.1787341982126236,
-0.4773924946784973,
-0.6841118931770325,
-0.3733433485031128,
-0.0771648958325386,
0.11729037761688232,
1.1199899911880493,
-0.18728365004062653,
0.7284550666809082,
-0.34964069724082947,
0.02413625456392765,
0.4344421625137329,
0.08074866980314255,
0.023331990465521812,
-0.5415566563606262,
-0.00923692062497139,
0.17943748831748962,
-0.6337293982505798,
-0.8487023711204529,
0.32326722145080566,
0.3407032787799835,
0.7928017973899841,
0.6732736229896545,
0.25880706310272217,
0.924937903881073,
-0.4881986081600189,
0.6901202201843262,
0.26817402243614197,
-1.241393804550171,
0.6647365093231201,
-0.13861532509326935,
0.08793347328901291,
0.488599956035614,
0.3911193311214447,
-0.3661915957927704,
-0.6967710256576538,
-0.525950014591217,
-0.4030691087245941,
0.7284799814224243,
0.040982652455568314,
0.3200918734073639,
0.06549127399921417,
0.11058025807142258,
0.38606613874435425,
0.304370641708374,
-0.7678951621055603,
-0.3898469805717468,
-0.32125261425971985,
-0.4761140048503876,
-0.013527621515095234,
-0.01644081622362137,
-0.5824694037437439,
0.007747558411210775,
0.5266657471656799,
-0.3127407729625702,
0.13331833481788635,
-0.03233849257230759,
-0.17009375989437103,
-0.15399400889873505,
0.31627318263053894,
0.9898809790611267,
0.9690806865692139,
0.1614447981119156,
0.15014058351516724,
-0.23170726001262665,
0.14914806187152863,
0.12486275285482407,
-0.04918881133198738,
0.04589700698852539,
0.19325752556324005,
0.5117572546005249,
1.01377534866333,
0.25627365708351135,
-0.5232973098754883,
0.7518549561500549,
0.022598572075366974,
-0.36631524562835693,
-0.05320529267191887,
0.1769006997346878,
0.17492255568504333,
0.4023730158805847,
-0.001733702840283513,
-0.2622920870780945,
-0.09204310923814774,
-0.40814313292503357,
0.2057676464319229,
0.5016469359397888,
-0.5214412808418274,
-0.48000767827033997,
0.7416569590568542,
0.06920913606882095,
-0.533115804195404,
0.1974964141845703,
-0.09942031651735306,
-0.29391396045684814,
0.5864160656929016,
0.5906327366828918,
0.5948395133018494,
-0.08994339406490326,
0.6075156927108765,
0.20731863379478455,
0.12050257623195648,
-0.3333388864994049,
0.08661943674087524,
-0.22945456206798553,
-0.6693087220191956,
-0.538211464881897,
-0.29533398151397705,
-0.5959540009498596,
0.26689136028289795,
-0.8448123335838318,
0.3847139775753021,
-0.605923056602478,
0.01768491417169571,
0.2732604742050171,
-0.1466047763824463,
-0.41901111602783203,
-0.18056349456310272,
0.09847646206617355,
0.6305734515190125,
-1.1094822883605957,
0.7672396302223206,
0.476121723651886,
-0.2738672196865082,
-0.92510986328125,
0.08283320814371109,
0.26434558629989624,
-1.224868655204773,
0.7932148575782776,
0.16475623846054077,
-0.09509650617837906,
-0.042502183467149734,
-0.7649605870246887,
-0.5033905506134033,
0.8367617130279541,
0.5671682357788086,
-0.9838534593582153,
0.15439839661121368,
-0.017571426928043365,
0.5341044664382935,
-0.5126015543937683,
0.16823512315750122,
0.033682458102703094,
0.3459751307964325,
0.3024637699127197,
-1.0742743015289307,
0.05420670285820961,
0.07330700010061264,
-0.1943727433681488,
0.06644393503665924,
-0.6696242094039917,
0.4909362196922302,
-0.4470924735069275,
-0.34940123558044434,
0.14556337893009186,
0.35520139336586,
0.25149741768836975,
0.29499495029449463,
0.7301514744758606,
0.44622594118118286,
0.5971793532371521,
-0.062031880021095276,
0.9717345237731934,
0.03830145671963692,
0.3168829083442688,
1.5038957595825195,
-0.45448434352874756,
0.7562270164489746,
0.8709649443626404,
-0.10882217437028885,
0.45685023069381714,
0.5833248496055603,
0.13151605427265167,
0.9171101450920105,
0.4551942050457001,
-0.044793806970119476,
-0.4286985397338867,
-0.10391800105571747,
-0.0034294291399419308,
0.30015209317207336,
0.15502941608428955,
-0.18531738221645355,
-0.3025796115398407,
0.008582365699112415,
0.08980876952409744,
0.6696686148643494,
-0.025449877604842186,
0.9615570902824402,
0.005548983346670866,
-0.7386888265609741,
0.5682412385940552,
-0.3953731656074524,
0.6542155146598816,
-0.5755943059921265,
-0.26584592461586,
-0.40929239988327026,
0.36591866612434387,
-0.1164688840508461,
-0.6010895371437073,
0.2743775248527527,
-0.13819608092308044,
-0.1475682258605957,
-0.5574420094490051,
0.2031867653131485,
-0.474890798330307,
-0.32905808091163635,
0.30760622024536133,
0.4624757468700409,
0.12793558835983276,
0.31245294213294983,
-0.5589845180511475,
0.03670763596892357,
0.24909456074237823,
-0.11210207641124725,
0.5738450288772583,
0.17490573227405548,
-0.10531213879585266,
0.8447810411453247,
0.5456139445304871,
0.13217689096927643,
0.04243312403559685,
0.30566170811653137,
0.8242985606193542,
-0.31624290347099304,
-0.0207666028290987,
-1.0892772674560547,
0.36781883239746094,
-0.16411782801151276,
-0.1520729660987854,
0.7291519641876221,
0.37507110834121704,
1.1763232946395874,
-0.19786646962165833,
0.6778982281684875,
0.10409675538539886,
0.8300575017929077,
-0.44523191452026367,
0.4749744236469269,
-0.7335665822029114,
0.5010024905204773,
-0.18776549398899078,
-0.5031015276908875,
0.03841683268547058,
0.4377921223640442,
-0.09953741729259491,
-0.0993185043334961,
0.6328622102737427,
0.9809997081756592,
0.01828799396753311,
-0.43520137667655945,
0.5596370697021484,
0.15062391757965088,
0.30702829360961914,
0.42304712533950806,
1.1811476945877075,
-0.0046920874156057835,
0.660365641117096,
-0.7512760162353516,
-0.32790669798851013,
-0.18377454578876495,
-0.9400236010551453,
-0.9870238304138184,
-0.45296207070350647,
-0.5627382397651672,
-0.25815242528915405,
-0.10499017685651779,
0.7831718325614929,
0.8614774346351624,
-0.761972188949585,
-0.47739464044570923,
0.002948347246274352,
0.2708553671836853,
-0.5702412724494934,
-0.20200057327747345,
0.17908616364002228,
-0.39050906896591187,
-1.1012531518936157,
0.7080508470535278,
0.021535580977797508,
0.09110889583826065,
-0.26636868715286255,
-0.09934022277593613,
0.21349535882472992,
-0.19170896708965302,
0.05164741352200508,
0.2637365460395813,
-1.0517748594284058,
-0.1433417946100235,
0.28213098645210266,
-0.12872809171676636,
0.06466258317232132,
0.728812038898468,
-0.6020129919052124,
0.49926239252090454,
0.23221637308597565,
0.6418057680130005,
0.3831799626350403,
0.053582292050123215,
0.824089765548706,
-0.8719114065170288,
-0.017001941800117493,
0.06981997191905975,
0.21016742289066315,
0.3115013539791107,
-0.3321410119533539,
0.1882847547531128,
-0.09723261743783951,
-0.46683117747306824,
-0.8542555570602417,
0.17783479392528534,
-1.0157978534698486,
-0.20371729135513306,
1.0634613037109375,
-0.2963787615299225,
-0.20920711755752563,
0.21076306700706482,
-0.07866550236940384,
0.08643798530101776,
-0.46874290704727173,
0.875260055065155,
0.545930027961731,
-0.3114420175552368,
-0.20258232951164246,
-0.41039061546325684,
0.5203424692153931,
0.5935866832733154,
-0.7225120663642883,
0.08338876813650131,
0.28432905673980713,
0.5615524053573608,
-0.0062364498153328896,
0.5884636044502258,
0.024579722434282303,
0.05292107164859772,
-0.30419695377349854,
-0.05512944608926773,
-0.2250474989414215,
-0.12625275552272797,
-0.6316773295402527,
-0.12111116945743561,
0.477815181016922,
-0.7016237378120422
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00867v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00867v1
|
Formality Style Transfer in Persian
| 2024-06-02T20:57:27 | 2024-06-02T20:57:27 |
Parastoo Falakaflaki, Mehrnoush Shamsfard
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
This study explores the formality style transfer in Persian, particularly
relevant in the face of the increasing prevalence of informal language on
digital platforms, which poses challenges for existing Natural Language
Processing (NLP) tools. The aim is to transform informal text into formal while
retaining the original meaning, addressing both lexical and syntactic
differences. We introduce a novel model, Fa-BERT2BERT, based on the Fa-BERT
architecture, incorporating consistency learning and gradient-based dynamic
weighting. This approach improves the model's understanding of syntactic
variations, balancing loss components effectively during training. Our
evaluation of Fa-BERT2BERT against existing methods employs new metrics
designed to accurately measure syntactic and stylistic changes. Results
demonstrate our model's superior performance over traditional techniques across
various metrics, including BLEU, BERT score, Rouge-l, and proposed metrics
underscoring its ability to adeptly navigate the complexities of Persian
language style transfer. This study significantly contributes to Persian
language processing by enhancing the accuracy and functionality of NLP models
and thereby supports the development of more efficient and reliable NLP
applications, capable of handling language style transformation effectively,
thereby streamlining content moderation, enhancing data mining results, and
facilitating cross-cultural communication.
|
[
-0.13432031869888306,
-1.051269292831421,
0.2746952772140503,
0.364658385515213,
-0.16228404641151428,
0.31464487314224243,
-0.7283840179443359,
-0.6468526721000671,
0.18369315564632416,
0.19378532469272614,
-0.5506783127784729,
-0.3031529486179352,
-0.4307125210762024,
0.10163213312625885,
-0.6556247472763062,
1.0742055177688599,
-0.3736267685890198,
-0.020926883444190025,
0.4265986979007721,
0.11629629135131836,
-0.013824714347720146,
-0.39837872982025146,
-0.8601617217063904,
-0.02078632451593876,
0.03809158131480217,
0.4488575756549835,
1.0486960411071777,
0.23902341723442078,
0.5421255230903625,
0.2740974724292755,
0.182034432888031,
0.16603578627109528,
-0.2675701379776001,
0.19796137511730194,
-0.23545262217521667,
-0.34224268794059753,
-0.5178080201148987,
-0.04825962707400322,
0.8279349207878113,
0.44011548161506653,
-0.46506431698799133,
0.28545132279396057,
-0.07481051981449127,
1.2746459245681763,
-0.4060881733894348,
0.16815917193889618,
-0.5659712553024292,
0.08891046792268753,
-0.5691633820533752,
-0.11316682398319244,
-0.3191075623035431,
-0.585347592830658,
-0.04941357299685478,
-0.46913862228393555,
-0.11202400177717209,
0.007984733209013939,
1.3258213996887207,
0.03409198299050331,
-0.2637440860271454,
-0.10431387275457382,
-1.3269535303115845,
0.551142692565918,
-0.7529527544975281,
0.49132513999938965,
0.29465463757514954,
0.5762455463409424,
-0.038550324738025665,
-0.7244731187820435,
-0.6430896520614624,
-0.3894442021846771,
-0.025363851338624954,
-0.17541620135307312,
-0.1790386587381363,
-0.3304106295108795,
0.02738526463508606,
0.5036437511444092,
-0.46511250734329224,
-0.3711913824081421,
-0.24868887662887573,
0.08633729815483093,
0.8033859133720398,
-0.19561395049095154,
0.33348724246025085,
0.15455345809459686,
-0.42357775568962097,
-0.10888805240392685,
-0.3164067566394806,
0.2904442548751831,
0.35353851318359375,
0.0795540139079094,
-0.32196176052093506,
0.039821330457925797,
-0.5078939199447632,
0.34885087609291077,
0.49930915236473083,
-0.05885801091790199,
0.08030464500188828,
-0.7203161120414734,
0.0788489505648613,
-0.02715812437236309,
0.6430713534355164,
0.0731189101934433,
0.5201967358589172,
-0.1871863305568695,
-0.26440557837486267,
-0.3871338963508606,
0.27567392587661743,
-0.3924432396888733,
-0.6252302527427673,
-0.0432753823697567,
-0.49341386556625366,
-0.40184593200683594,
0.2824482321739197,
-0.6481130123138428,
-0.15582138299942017,
-0.5709658265113831,
0.3433031141757965,
-0.8250987529754639,
-0.15382952988147736,
0.12466442584991455,
0.05721185356378555,
0.6166976094245911,
0.8889936804771423,
-1.0001589059829712,
0.8857582807540894,
0.35697701573371887,
0.860154926776886,
-0.005882330238819122,
0.5043561458587646,
-0.10803575068712234,
0.07552620768547058,
-0.7731900215148926,
0.39273878931999207,
-0.35361599922180176,
0.06773075461387634,
-0.09586024284362793,
-0.1356734186410904,
-0.06830407679080963,
0.06927412003278732,
0.7238022089004517,
-0.3951190710067749,
0.32257142663002014,
0.09918223321437836,
-0.14487075805664062,
-0.20528185367584229,
-0.0948505848646164,
-0.4897772967815399,
1.4865723848342896,
0.2798188030719757,
-0.6245656609535217,
0.17809130251407623,
-0.5692717432975769,
-0.574517548084259,
0.09712915122509003,
0.1703735888004303,
-0.47313159704208374,
0.04659399017691612,
-0.013944797217845917,
0.3190425634384155,
-0.007960669696331024,
0.20256035029888153,
0.0018609793623909354,
-0.3674011528491974,
0.4299227297306061,
-0.005419834982603788,
0.49301037192344666,
0.3787548243999481,
-0.6482091546058655,
0.11315948516130447,
-0.9425891637802124,
0.13976916670799255,
0.1383940875530243,
-0.11155814677476883,
-0.45719507336616516,
0.14436151087284088,
0.45039260387420654,
0.607010006904602,
0.5829820036888123,
-0.36783167719841003,
0.14124682545661926,
-0.37972816824913025,
0.24415373802185059,
0.816099226474762,
-0.195909783244133,
0.7942869663238525,
-0.5806218981742859,
0.2966677248477936,
-0.6582486629486084,
0.09378355741500854,
0.41751548647880554,
-0.10407120734453201,
-1.0023014545440674,
-0.2017105221748352,
0.5295981764793396,
0.7004375457763672,
-0.784919798374176,
0.5316749811172485,
-0.29736509919166565,
-0.7451505661010742,
-0.23978778719902039,
0.094546377658844,
0.17808344960212708,
0.08813611418008804,
0.33435675501823425,
-0.6254426836967468,
-0.4715992510318756,
-0.967510461807251,
-0.3420771062374115,
-0.12084107100963593,
0.18460533022880554,
0.33830785751342773,
0.3243631422519684,
0.05123121291399002,
0.643815279006958,
0.012054851278662682,
-0.34490683674812317,
-0.519762396812439,
0.4836893379688263,
0.33796727657318115,
0.8449971675872803,
0.6619546413421631,
-0.5280418395996094,
-0.82329261302948,
0.22853684425354004,
-0.24231044948101044,
-0.26027244329452515,
-0.6651732921600342,
-0.3820774555206299,
0.6609726548194885,
0.563348114490509,
-0.12660878896713257,
0.4296668767929077,
0.6328140497207642,
-0.27339330315589905,
0.8852096199989319,
0.05719728022813797,
0.50417560338974,
-1.011997938156128,
0.4160977900028229,
0.10031609982252121,
-0.4955517053604126,
-0.9248092174530029,
0.3726167678833008,
0.03246258199214935,
0.14680340886116028,
-0.3069474697113037,
0.7654634118080139,
-0.3876911401748657,
0.21260331571102142,
0.008252466097474098,
-0.30650103092193604,
0.07186339795589447,
0.5934706330299377,
0.2625785171985626,
0.8558507561683655,
0.3264535367488861,
-0.45744583010673523,
0.248059943318367,
0.1854971945285797,
-0.2460978776216507,
0.4503726363182068,
-0.6090420484542847,
0.34482866525650024,
0.213766947388649,
0.5013896822929382,
-1.2157973051071167,
-0.13217882812023163,
0.5922231674194336,
-0.4274497628211975,
0.737615168094635,
-0.32400819659233093,
-0.9440907835960388,
0.23412679135799408,
-0.4668700397014618,
0.2108251005411148,
0.7734252214431763,
0.03443262353539467,
0.6295168399810791,
-0.17973248660564423,
-0.6404713988304138,
-0.10621221363544464,
-0.6445513963699341,
0.3006629943847656,
-0.0740131363272667,
-0.9457769393920898,
0.5947577357292175,
0.1768009513616562,
-0.4301619529724121,
-0.3066740036010742,
-0.2620086073875427,
-0.4397179186344147,
0.5567392110824585,
-0.107251837849617,
0.33943048119544983,
-0.2801706790924072,
0.024202648550271988,
0.23918773233890533,
0.3780812621116638,
0.09449748694896698,
-0.09272809326648712,
0.6701244115829468,
-0.2412765920162201,
0.07523790746927261,
-0.8998088240623474,
0.2104695588350296,
0.2379017174243927,
-0.2965601682662964,
1.0414632558822632,
1.0844814777374268,
-0.15011177957057953,
-0.2994194030761719,
-0.47612619400024414,
-0.24706943333148956,
-0.4780449867248535,
0.014845163561403751,
-0.29957643151283264,
-0.4482257664203644,
0.3484500050544739,
-0.19709733128547668,
0.2261718511581421,
0.5318710207939148,
0.43361589312553406,
-0.2299635410308838,
0.6218911409378052,
0.707588791847229,
0.0342666320502758,
0.9302483201026917,
0.11729630827903748,
0.12710152566432953,
-0.4725203812122345,
-0.06723260134458542,
-0.6307981610298157,
-0.36864450573921204,
-0.5353955626487732,
-0.4198239743709564,
0.24633294343948364,
0.14219866693019867,
-0.09509098529815674,
0.27736616134643555,
-0.03979461267590523,
0.04637938365340233,
0.44013211131095886,
0.29146260023117065,
0.31097742915153503,
0.32115593552589417,
0.014068623073399067,
-0.1541743129491806,
-0.39327704906463623,
-0.6527859568595886,
0.9214240312576294,
0.516061544418335,
0.8695999383926392,
0.784333348274231,
0.7155796885490417,
0.6863934397697449,
-0.3202999234199524,
-0.5261304974555969,
0.5021880865097046,
-0.34050583839416504,
-0.35437002778053284,
-0.39614346623420715,
-0.21317271888256073,
-0.5159862041473389,
-0.16475453972816467,
-0.7825253009796143,
-0.7489607930183411,
0.11784389615058899,
0.15474514663219452,
-0.17535078525543213,
0.16663436591625214,
-0.11952150613069534,
0.393198698759079,
-0.1881333738565445,
-0.7921650409698486,
-0.36647140979766846,
-0.9266522526741028,
0.5722209811210632,
-0.18757988512516022,
0.48422396183013916,
-0.20940770208835602,
0.02525421790778637,
0.6435654163360596,
-0.3532625436782837,
0.6196882128715515,
0.3884887993335724,
-0.31893351674079895,
-0.05895110219717026,
0.8355090022087097,
0.5998374819755554,
-0.007301495410501957,
-0.024898692965507507,
0.3222176432609558,
0.02187630906701088,
-0.35296717286109924,
-0.6572506427764893,
0.36096295714378357,
-0.774053156375885,
-0.3816218376159668,
-0.6921424865722656,
-0.44273650646209717,
-0.13890831172466278,
-0.06146781146526337,
-0.24588024616241455,
0.389070600271225,
-0.4053162932395935,
-0.06987213343381882,
0.6851077079772949,
0.0018667196854948997,
0.21759064495563507,
0.4454306960105896,
-0.1446157991886139,
0.02811632677912712,
0.5685021281242371,
-0.23970572650432587,
0.5004563927650452,
0.40731674432754517,
0.17793534696102142,
-0.21940182149410248,
-0.3570033013820648,
-0.8055418729782104,
0.12500742077827454,
-0.5235131978988647,
0.397050678730011,
-0.3647066056728363,
-0.5121601223945618,
-0.6612969636917114,
-0.4348509907722473,
-0.35339123010635376,
-1.1646804809570312,
-0.1860034316778183,
0.4763737916946411,
0.5292842984199524,
0.4816904366016388,
-0.1373966634273529,
0.07483876496553421,
-0.8292505145072937,
0.2149522453546524,
-0.03501634672284126,
0.1351822167634964,
-0.22517293691635132,
-1.0684759616851807,
-0.2077597677707672,
-0.08575566858053207,
-0.09887770563364029,
-0.8041164875030518,
0.41331854462623596,
0.8268393278121948,
0.14700670540332794,
0.23760102689266205,
-0.003946686163544655,
0.41703224182128906,
-0.7805880904197693,
0.7682983875274658,
-0.07572124898433685,
-1.241240382194519,
0.5944240689277649,
-0.5849593877792358,
0.1965852528810501,
0.7369382381439209,
0.3908661901950836,
-0.9364461302757263,
-0.37878626585006714,
-0.7520312666893005,
-0.9247443079948425,
0.7663798332214355,
0.5723296999931335,
0.08775949478149414,
0.35170453786849976,
0.45134416222572327,
0.08321141451597214,
0.168693408370018,
-0.7048271894454956,
-0.3631178140640259,
-0.09343934804201126,
-0.20234356820583344,
0.16102191805839539,
-0.03574143722653389,
-0.22146634757518768,
-0.28019803762435913,
0.7945970892906189,
0.10319572687149048,
0.3835609257221222,
0.16197353601455688,
-0.1993987113237381,
-0.15742915868759155,
0.752687394618988,
0.7999027371406555,
0.46389463543891907,
-0.27862876653671265,
-0.04689156264066696,
-0.045298021286726,
-0.2912881374359131,
-0.020210865885019302,
0.30000168085098267,
-0.09606724977493286,
0.22965086996555328,
0.16892772912979126,
0.34930750727653503,
0.29597654938697815,
-0.3152061402797699,
0.4426466226577759,
0.006556042470037937,
-0.18077094852924347,
-0.6409772038459778,
0.20144516229629517,
-0.4934910237789154,
-0.040694110095500946,
0.28006041049957275,
0.45829612016677856,
0.5350120067596436,
-0.8259292840957642,
0.31786394119262695,
0.33098214864730835,
-0.21622571349143982,
-0.3633632957935333,
0.5029392838478088,
0.29914188385009766,
-0.009086696431040764,
0.20000547170639038,
-0.2184404879808426,
-0.5559922456741333,
0.24681991338729858,
0.3200681507587433,
0.6932961344718933,
-0.2828398048877716,
0.4161331355571747,
0.4927425682544708,
0.19378364086151123,
-0.2668631970882416,
0.375963032245636,
-0.3826114535331726,
-0.4826368987560272,
-0.30383843183517456,
-0.7937261462211609,
-0.38155317306518555,
-0.3691309988498688,
-0.7249690294265747,
0.3536926805973053,
-1.0006440877914429,
0.047509972006082535,
-0.1970709264278412,
0.08813179284334183,
-0.3564175069332123,
-0.11233537644147873,
0.5111224055290222,
0.8959896564483643,
-0.969852089881897,
0.8667753338813782,
0.7377195954322815,
-0.23144985735416412,
-0.920187771320343,
0.01034372579306364,
0.20828701555728912,
-0.52790367603302,
0.8384162783622742,
-0.2775762677192688,
-0.3777051866054535,
-0.024542706087231636,
-0.6029264330863953,
-1.3245538473129272,
0.7801252603530884,
-0.16939124464988708,
-0.6625397801399231,
-0.09464570134878159,
-0.056648846715688705,
0.6583635807037354,
0.08590831607580185,
-0.01788986288011074,
0.5759193897247314,
0.4899900555610657,
0.10200929641723633,
-1.3163104057312012,
0.3153466284275055,
-0.3408512473106384,
0.014983774162828922,
0.4231205880641937,
-0.5224524736404419,
0.9379151463508606,
0.09735056757926941,
-0.6150718927383423,
0.6140167713165283,
0.6460146307945251,
-0.13334469497203827,
-0.04448222741484642,
0.1379699409008026,
0.24251888692378998,
0.49298450350761414,
-0.20191176235675812,
0.9308243989944458,
-0.5757377743721008,
0.04414357990026474,
0.9835785031318665,
-0.18837057054042816,
0.9497486352920532,
0.2952299118041992,
-0.3372194468975067,
1.3390089273452759,
0.28499117493629456,
0.0490749254822731,
0.367820143699646,
0.2779674828052521,
-0.08274263143539429,
-0.12645038962364197,
-0.22711767256259918,
-0.32768121361732483,
0.5596420764923096,
0.31466254591941833,
-0.37325456738471985,
-0.20200830698013306,
-0.5860857963562012,
0.5932241082191467,
0.524337649345398,
-0.286560982465744,
0.7712333798408508,
-0.1696244180202484,
-0.36235910654067993,
0.6095301508903503,
0.6031014919281006,
0.6235448718070984,
-0.8498755693435669,
-0.30922994017601013,
-0.06343679875135422,
-0.06014489009976387,
-0.33583885431289673,
-0.4368985593318939,
0.24763253331184387,
-0.32065507769584656,
0.030371056869626045,
-0.4350840747356415,
0.8458071351051331,
-0.624840259552002,
-0.7132670879364014,
-0.32743051648139954,
0.6307114362716675,
0.08607932180166245,
0.2777678072452545,
-0.9733894467353821,
-0.17192597687244415,
-0.16353031992912292,
0.15942871570587158,
0.2910260558128357,
0.5189658403396606,
-0.3730160593986511,
0.4123554825782776,
0.9345952868461609,
0.2674826681613922,
0.0008151419460773468,
0.0037191163282841444,
0.639804482460022,
-0.47283482551574707,
-0.5263633728027344,
-0.7100995182991028,
0.29550251364707947,
-0.06586368381977081,
-0.1400960087776184,
0.9441291689872742,
0.008004043251276016,
0.47131678462028503,
-0.07398293167352676,
0.4207402765750885,
-0.23530663549900055,
0.3154328167438507,
-0.9448729157447815,
0.7966321110725403,
-0.3334173858165741,
0.1461363136768341,
-0.6486286520957947,
-0.747908890247345,
-0.11755331605672836,
1.0330619812011719,
-0.16450269520282745,
0.07529456168413162,
0.6777986884117126,
0.4108903706073761,
0.20675891637802124,
-0.12380924820899963,
0.03229300677776337,
0.09839393198490143,
0.021028609946370125,
0.44061481952667236,
0.6030381321907043,
-0.4068889319896698,
0.019981857389211655,
-0.4613077640533447,
-0.39894548058509827,
-0.32979267835617065,
-0.8520157337188721,
-0.668483555316925,
-0.6444637179374695,
-0.48124805092811584,
-0.4906819462776184,
0.5090786814689636,
1.1933059692382812,
0.6748387813568115,
-0.6697446703910828,
-0.4305188059806824,
0.09985552728176117,
-0.2679655849933624,
-0.4685090184211731,
-0.334623783826828,
0.31764546036720276,
-0.4891201853752136,
-0.5346659421920776,
0.1740562617778778,
0.19443435966968536,
0.08762472122907639,
-0.11825849860906601,
0.23885376751422882,
-0.6183982491493225,
0.3779420554637909,
0.42118847370147705,
0.37719765305519104,
-0.6419625878334045,
-0.3126694858074188,
-0.10939782857894897,
-0.3203750550746918,
0.06743195652961731,
0.6392568349838257,
-0.6915978789329529,
0.14373601973056793,
0.31065496802330017,
0.3870445489883423,
0.17453633248806,
0.2586759924888611,
0.7520552277565002,
-0.9911026358604431,
-0.0017218758584931493,
0.09144642949104309,
0.23655816912651062,
0.2567121386528015,
-0.4841972887516022,
0.5804133415222168,
0.17139600217342377,
-0.36577850580215454,
-0.29856249690055847,
0.26591336727142334,
-1.1605942249298096,
-0.378741592168808,
1.4414818286895752,
-0.05522817745804787,
-0.090257428586483,
-0.34807491302490234,
-0.3378731310367584,
0.11244216561317444,
-0.8195538520812988,
0.89649498462677,
0.7615223526954651,
-0.12632696330547333,
-0.09288714826107025,
-0.39273154735565186,
0.9145811200141907,
0.4915297329425812,
-0.6440141797065735,
-0.18475989997386932,
0.5942948460578918,
0.3858714997768402,
0.13267861306667328,
0.5727950930595398,
-0.1780717968940735,
0.7324473857879639,
-0.4412100911140442,
0.3152656555175781,
0.05963439866900444,
-0.4075770080089569,
-0.3495520353317261,
-0.1895332634449005,
0.26810845732688904,
0.23203729093074799
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00842v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00842v1
|
The Power of Summary-Source Alignments
| 2024-06-02T19:35:19 | 2024-06-02T19:35:19 |
Ori Ernst, Ori Shapira, Aviv Slobodkin, Sharon Adar, Mohit Bansal, Jacob Goldberger, Ran Levy, Ido Dagan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Multi-document summarization (MDS) is a challenging task, often decomposed to
subtasks of salience and redundancy detection, followed by text generation. In
this context, alignment of corresponding sentences between a reference summary
and its source documents has been leveraged to generate training data for some
of the component tasks. Yet, this enabling alignment step has usually been
applied heuristically on the sentence level on a limited number of subtasks. In
this paper, we propose extending the summary-source alignment framework by (1)
applying it at the more fine-grained proposition span level, (2) annotating
alignment manually in a multi-document setup, and (3) revealing the great
potential of summary-source alignments to yield several datasets for at least
six different tasks. Specifically, for each of the tasks, we release a manually
annotated test set that was derived automatically from the alignment
annotation. We also release development and train sets in the same way, but
from automatically derived alignments. Using the datasets, each task is
demonstrated with baseline models and corresponding evaluation metrics to spur
future research on this broad challenge.
|
[
-0.3559257686138153,
-0.0752953439950943,
0.3687469959259033,
-0.14918312430381775,
-0.15744684636592865,
0.1068354994058609,
-0.04271561652421951,
-0.18952372670173645,
0.5343154072761536,
0.19844959676265717,
-0.8097216486930847,
-0.24941132962703705,
-0.6733179688453674,
0.4703662395477295,
-0.6158217191696167,
1.4241348505020142,
-0.3117825984954834,
-0.12808719277381897,
-0.2085452526807785,
-0.26577913761138916,
-0.45837467908859253,
-0.05020963028073311,
-0.033277321606874466,
-0.13402901589870453,
0.7273257970809937,
0.5185502767562866,
0.5107584595680237,
1.076382040977478,
0.8224013447761536,
0.22206436097621918,
0.23341484367847443,
0.567438006401062,
-0.18708781898021698,
0.25409170985221863,
-0.21537601947784424,
-0.1669338494539261,
-0.623096764087677,
0.15801949799060822,
0.6633828282356262,
0.7436323165893555,
-0.1143106147646904,
0.33159932494163513,
0.3386964499950409,
0.7029100656509399,
-0.6993616819381714,
0.04657094180583954,
-0.24215812981128693,
-0.16854390501976013,
-0.18398088216781616,
-0.017363646999001503,
-0.0994296669960022,
-0.27395105361938477,
0.23704108595848083,
-0.7974748015403748,
0.37890762090682983,
-0.11659684032201767,
1.0816776752471924,
0.5238316059112549,
-0.578518807888031,
-0.2426595389842987,
-0.18463419377803802,
0.5738518238067627,
-0.6600077748298645,
-0.011104466393589973,
0.11424042284488678,
0.5029637813568115,
0.272212952375412,
-0.34821805357933044,
-0.5744684338569641,
0.3691338002681732,
-0.4281612038612366,
0.28790366649627686,
0.1600351780653,
-0.08343837410211563,
0.03587709367275238,
0.48674333095550537,
-0.4306134283542633,
0.006904197856783867,
-0.5950304269790649,
-0.11304298788309097,
0.7334259748458862,
0.23905223608016968,
0.0843949243426323,
-0.45289772748947144,
-0.28518998622894287,
-0.037816330790519714,
-0.5398592948913574,
-0.34628593921661377,
0.3446959853172302,
0.7167216539382935,
-0.3488357365131378,
1.2574154138565063,
-0.267203152179718,
0.7677689790725708,
0.16380265355110168,
-0.3302112817764282,
0.4319785237312317,
-1.1440043449401855,
-0.1687828153371811,
0.15338821709156036,
0.7861282825469971,
0.5895407795906067,
0.1412593573331833,
-0.006451399531215429,
0.04035869613289833,
-0.05134768411517143,
0.5888760685920715,
-0.45225656032562256,
-0.03925393149256706,
0.38646405935287476,
-0.25972431898117065,
-0.35245591402053833,
0.20884962379932404,
-0.4845142662525177,
-0.5780376195907593,
-0.7997574806213379,
0.0734596997499466,
-0.5147992968559265,
0.029836531728506088,
-0.22138240933418274,
-0.47695043683052063,
0.24920956790447235,
0.35688790678977966,
-1.0728200674057007,
-0.06761098653078079,
0.6737465858459473,
0.9899969100952148,
-0.18705394864082336,
-0.6608226895332336,
-0.4985033869743347,
0.5893592238426208,
-0.4654299020767212,
0.9042741060256958,
-0.22953252494335175,
-0.09263135492801666,
-0.10901196300983429,
-0.1189940944314003,
-0.20215219259262085,
-0.10401909798383713,
0.42311209440231323,
0.14731405675411224,
0.6581642031669617,
-0.5749130845069885,
-0.4688945412635803,
0.19460327923297882,
0.38946446776390076,
-0.5211019515991211,
0.949417233467102,
0.34227454662323,
-0.9700344800949097,
0.42393526434898376,
-0.6362081170082092,
-0.8182775974273682,
-0.475321888923645,
-0.2319624274969101,
-0.4531629681587219,
0.19394969940185547,
0.5150450468063354,
0.5840821862220764,
-0.13514818251132965,
0.2849099934101105,
-0.132954940199852,
-0.20892587304115295,
-0.15708105266094208,
-0.05748956650495529,
0.5815679430961609,
0.17037242650985718,
-0.258733868598938,
0.3328677713871002,
-0.8568108081817627,
-0.37191298604011536,
-0.1993124783039093,
-0.2495848536491394,
-0.34772294759750366,
-0.12607848644256592,
-0.3301983177661896,
0.26450228691101074,
0.27315032482147217,
-0.27412790060043335,
0.4114401936531067,
-0.28586211800575256,
-0.014149011112749577,
0.5435993075370789,
0.03737987205386162,
0.6555472612380981,
-0.5055533051490784,
0.5490285158157349,
-0.14259222149848938,
-0.18200291693210602,
-0.769025981426239,
0.04194793105125427,
-0.47006335854530334,
-0.6660464406013489,
0.42890310287475586,
0.4926319420337677,
-0.6243221759796143,
0.7785656452178955,
-0.5874109864234924,
-0.5065995454788208,
-0.7576125860214233,
-0.006446679122745991,
0.550293505191803,
0.8626531958580017,
0.4976557493209839,
-0.03280997276306152,
-0.6595675945281982,
-1.1924625635147095,
-0.1220657005906105,
0.24287919700145721,
-0.2637656033039093,
-0.26396462321281433,
0.4126741886138916,
0.14253641664981842,
0.9791544079780579,
-0.6708745956420898,
-0.6084405183792114,
-0.25073784589767456,
0.240264430642128,
-0.01689857989549637,
0.5258329510688782,
0.609640896320343,
-0.5292744040489197,
-0.22833849489688873,
-0.12043193727731705,
-0.9289344549179077,
-0.31821194291114807,
-0.3557285666465759,
-0.17032736539840698,
-0.027342990040779114,
0.3772011995315552,
-0.40485644340515137,
-0.08991125226020813,
0.37907251715660095,
-0.1629113107919693,
0.536676287651062,
-0.2241140604019165,
0.3419222831726074,
-1.8447341918945312,
0.19889017939567566,
0.21895146369934082,
-0.13097605109214783,
-0.25615188479423523,
0.07860338687896729,
0.2340407818555832,
0.052504125982522964,
-0.10367738455533981,
0.12694691121578217,
-0.7273182272911072,
-0.26311740279197693,
-0.1886056810617447,
0.4493669867515564,
0.14720885455608368,
0.27151212096214294,
-0.07875064015388489,
0.8400580286979675,
0.2621285617351532,
-0.3122232258319855,
0.2126733660697937,
0.48985105752944946,
-0.06781236082315445,
1.06609308719635,
-0.4086090624332428,
-0.43757954239845276,
-0.4119793474674225,
0.4057871997356415,
-0.9466197490692139,
-0.5588085651397705,
0.09712408483028412,
-0.2837437391281128,
0.31519877910614014,
0.005182649474591017,
-0.4299818277359009,
0.06748597323894501,
-0.7104147672653198,
-0.03061635047197342,
-0.09409791976213455,
-0.3308647572994232,
0.6747936606407166,
0.3490358591079712,
-0.36574023962020874,
-1.0655341148376465,
-0.6261134147644043,
0.14446081221103668,
-0.4003121554851532,
-0.2728208303451538,
0.34569334983825684,
0.31229400634765625,
-0.0883755087852478,
-0.055236440151929855,
-0.38377827405929565,
0.3142099976539612,
0.06051173061132431,
0.20471204817295074,
0.44787701964378357,
-0.04692962393164635,
-0.08777863532304764,
0.5049008727073669,
-0.1554023176431656,
-0.21993957459926605,
-0.21040059626102448,
0.1514231115579605,
0.27587100863456726,
-0.3172900676727295,
-0.3049847185611725,
0.6680682897567749,
0.4540330767631531,
-0.3760843873023987,
0.5597089529037476,
0.3941117823123932,
-0.45782044529914856,
0.1901155710220337,
-0.14518578350543976,
0.3102990984916687,
-0.3269854485988617,
0.27303051948547363,
-0.44053885340690613,
-0.3809266686439514,
0.32969823479652405,
0.039141397923231125,
0.616825520992279,
0.8249499797821045,
0.39628615975379944,
-0.5164312720298767,
0.6837611794471741,
0.5467270016670227,
0.03617064654827118,
0.4597223699092865,
-0.3033045828342438,
0.12172245234251022,
-1.1211581230163574,
-0.2138994336128235,
-0.7323794960975647,
-0.4506606459617615,
-0.1738743633031845,
-0.2184573858976364,
0.28919702768325806,
0.22897207736968994,
-0.10632709413766861,
0.8394520878791809,
-0.5294302105903625,
0.6796848773956299,
0.42882660031318665,
-0.07452426850795746,
0.3911237418651581,
-0.098207987844944,
-0.07863841950893402,
-0.02531958930194378,
-0.3684990406036377,
-0.6458065509796143,
1.09239661693573,
0.07654155790805817,
0.45272573828697205,
0.2648850679397583,
0.9873186945915222,
0.24062612652778625,
0.3597165644168854,
-0.5852435231208801,
0.19736891984939575,
-0.11670558154582977,
-0.42706215381622314,
-0.38495853543281555,
-0.16688668727874756,
-0.6625633835792542,
0.3554171025753021,
-0.36315402388572693,
-0.5002046823501587,
0.21671995520591736,
0.10360946506261826,
-0.6374863982200623,
-0.26583048701286316,
-0.9807637333869934,
0.818940281867981,
-0.04204714670777321,
-0.00029319809982553124,
0.023828359320759773,
-0.9676311016082764,
0.5081750154495239,
-0.22049924731254578,
0.18301795423030853,
-0.13906611502170563,
-0.1435035765171051,
0.6730629801750183,
-0.5174801349639893,
0.803716242313385,
0.021310532465577126,
-0.3699975311756134,
-0.04728540778160095,
-0.26526060700416565,
0.42344051599502563,
-0.1582731008529663,
0.07212319225072861,
-0.16935794055461884,
0.1660986989736557,
-0.49068719148635864,
-0.46391257643699646,
0.3502304255962372,
-0.3416953384876251,
-0.24574200809001923,
-0.5922459363937378,
-0.789385199546814,
-0.2998235523700714,
0.4214906394481659,
0.22171713411808014,
0.35527467727661133,
-0.06659114360809326,
-0.1203790083527565,
0.24348096549510956,
0.21665118634700775,
0.5373581647872925,
0.14195439219474792,
0.06541317701339722,
-0.6671469807624817,
0.869862973690033,
0.07879526913166046,
0.3092687427997589,
0.48121947050094604,
-0.08997437357902527,
-0.3236822187900543,
-0.6783756017684937,
-0.7246269583702087,
0.1332518607378006,
-0.6308361291885376,
-0.49660295248031616,
-0.5146509408950806,
0.02360600046813488,
-0.6479545831680298,
-0.5894045829772949,
-0.3076372444629669,
-0.731532633304596,
-0.22155576944351196,
-0.42561376094818115,
-0.04061255231499672,
0.6881431937217712,
-0.17798559367656708,
0.3691294193267822,
-0.8155163526535034,
0.6831174492835999,
-0.08092014491558075,
0.054955314844846725,
-0.3648759722709656,
-0.2965608239173889,
-0.4546396732330322,
0.15670429170131683,
-0.29525384306907654,
-0.8349272608757019,
0.04619084298610687,
0.061219457536935806,
0.4342730939388275,
0.4406849443912506,
0.11341177672147751,
0.9622223377227783,
-0.47164687514305115,
0.7925915122032166,
0.42736509442329407,
-0.8396400213241577,
0.5455593466758728,
-0.5533454418182373,
0.2775660753250122,
0.8916083574295044,
0.33655598759651184,
-0.25364649295806885,
-0.493642121553421,
-0.5086222887039185,
-0.8717229962348938,
0.5602074265480042,
0.2406626045703888,
-0.18093274533748627,
0.13024576008319855,
0.25895020365715027,
0.3118424415588379,
0.37221693992614746,
-0.1929113119840622,
-0.18445397913455963,
-0.2374841421842575,
-0.8964001536369324,
-0.23610572516918182,
0.035997454077005386,
-0.6052574515342712,
-0.016110865399241447,
0.6909391283988953,
-0.5642557740211487,
-0.06976243108510971,
0.19912269711494446,
-0.26836708188056946,
0.15276522934436798,
0.2998121380805969,
0.7541525959968567,
0.8539862036705017,
-0.1251954436302185,
0.15572217106819153,
-0.06284518539905548,
-0.1972155123949051,
0.15757553279399872,
0.6206229329109192,
-0.09880009293556213,
-0.07065287977457047,
0.7877349853515625,
0.3659871220588684,
0.17649367451667786,
-0.5149099230766296,
0.5541707873344421,
0.14760451018810272,
-0.1146794930100441,
-0.015360955148935318,
-0.1076648011803627,
0.2010907232761383,
0.33238139748573303,
0.43225643038749695,
0.25993025302886963,
0.03935437276959419,
-0.3517240285873413,
0.3539525866508484,
0.37103745341300964,
-0.10886628180742264,
-0.026122434064745903,
0.6941598653793335,
0.17313137650489807,
0.141593337059021,
0.2286088615655899,
-0.16340476274490356,
-0.23762214183807373,
0.37496113777160645,
0.16292527318000793,
0.6663084626197815,
0.07847116887569427,
0.13585874438285828,
0.27891144156455994,
0.2677235007286072,
-0.2831580340862274,
0.08553895354270935,
-0.17427976429462433,
-0.4385908842086792,
-0.6493947505950928,
-0.43349382281303406,
-0.3616999387741089,
-0.517819881439209,
-0.7350289225578308,
0.32500630617141724,
0.042825572192668915,
0.21754224598407745,
0.4282476007938385,
-0.043945666402578354,
-0.1972508579492569,
0.12057654559612274,
-0.05038289725780487,
0.7242836356163025,
-1.0108003616333008,
0.5927844643592834,
0.5236287713050842,
-0.7225394248962402,
-0.6442943811416626,
0.20299112796783447,
0.4127383530139923,
-0.5527803301811218,
0.141464963555336,
0.05129300430417061,
0.006017249543219805,
-0.25066033005714417,
-0.11885906755924225,
-0.9195845723152161,
1.347482681274414,
0.6040944457054138,
-0.46346724033355713,
-0.44868990778923035,
-0.15874634683132172,
0.4800806939601898,
-0.5392557978630066,
-0.08022686839103699,
0.6650765538215637,
0.3765389025211334,
0.08397545665502548,
-1.124116063117981,
0.11765187233686447,
-0.20552514493465424,
-0.2939917743206024,
0.3275093138217926,
-0.39412721991539,
0.5789730548858643,
-0.44412529468536377,
-0.16855481266975403,
0.02307230792939663,
0.7204107046127319,
0.3815070390701294,
-0.006752950605005026,
0.22069312632083893,
0.5492202043533325,
0.8221041560173035,
-0.22472621500492096,
1.146990418434143,
-0.04226236417889595,
0.19293174147605896,
1.7053017616271973,
-0.20145127177238464,
0.5494967699050903,
0.5102860331535339,
-0.13526517152786255,
0.2272741049528122,
0.6781026721000671,
-0.07290540635585785,
0.5846618413925171,
0.07817539572715759,
0.07638589292764664,
0.25482237339019775,
-0.15503117442131042,
-0.4180663228034973,
0.28637808561325073,
0.0194077230989933,
-0.5160301327705383,
-0.5507626533508301,
-0.1354304999113083,
0.1355423629283905,
0.13966582715511322,
-0.08940280973911285,
0.9377637505531311,
-0.19338339567184448,
-0.8324095606803894,
0.16835246980190277,
-0.05736839398741722,
0.5909931063652039,
-0.6168940663337708,
-0.0013532619923353195,
-0.2129797786474228,
0.07930745929479599,
-0.4018287658691406,
-0.7860966920852661,
0.6708182096481323,
0.10813543200492859,
-0.37456467747688293,
-0.47792208194732666,
0.2963021397590637,
-0.5289510488510132,
-0.4892779290676117,
-0.22886456549167633,
0.5171277523040771,
-0.08565911650657654,
0.017745966091752052,
-0.3109523355960846,
-0.23196445405483246,
-0.07901742309331894,
-0.09281373769044876,
0.3677927851676941,
0.38454335927963257,
-0.008151333779096603,
0.12310392409563065,
0.4584387540817261,
0.1389995813369751,
-0.02315828576683998,
0.12249554693698883,
0.6985875964164734,
-0.6174507141113281,
-0.5578272938728333,
-0.721240222454071,
0.6754858493804932,
-0.5042538046836853,
-0.44234588742256165,
0.7694893479347229,
0.9680520296096802,
0.8332467675209045,
0.20144139230251312,
1.0613924264907837,
-0.2639143168926239,
0.5477873086929321,
-0.5393789410591125,
0.42568060755729675,
-0.4367537796497345,
0.22046802937984467,
-0.4788634479045868,
-0.7820369005203247,
-0.3442842364311218,
0.44760197401046753,
0.05292540788650513,
-0.33064505457878113,
1.0077887773513794,
0.3490188419818878,
-0.1445077806711197,
-0.07866482436656952,
-0.3146370053291321,
-0.29583024978637695,
0.3205312490463257,
0.28601232171058655,
0.37351343035697937,
-0.4930724501609802,
0.49567559361457825,
-0.2563246488571167,
-0.14501650631427765,
0.2208002209663391,
-1.0616865158081055,
-0.731054425239563,
-0.8822512030601501,
-0.4903598427772522,
-0.37217292189598083,
-0.04403651878237724,
0.9868366718292236,
0.49059295654296875,
-0.7813395261764526,
0.02540801279246807,
0.09922230988740921,
0.06073826923966408,
-0.6239171624183655,
-0.15272757411003113,
0.7098076343536377,
-0.41292983293533325,
-0.8154259324073792,
0.5433911085128784,
0.2812303900718689,
0.2884025573730469,
-0.04644356667995453,
0.19049493968486786,
-0.38391560316085815,
-0.24436572194099426,
0.3954566717147827,
0.17283812165260315,
-0.4629710018634796,
-0.3228404223918915,
-0.1806028187274933,
-0.19356465339660645,
-0.05276918783783913,
0.9855778813362122,
-0.46781009435653687,
0.12168370187282562,
0.4989098310470581,
0.8434562683105469,
0.26443687081336975,
0.6123298406600952,
0.8593687415122986,
-1.340433955192566,
-0.20620782673358917,
-0.12023424357175827,
0.6952482461929321,
0.40361419320106506,
-0.26248008012771606,
0.7137784361839294,
0.01215475145727396,
0.03597649186849594,
-0.881542444229126,
0.08065474778413773,
-1.133148193359375,
-0.33079206943511963,
0.8646320104598999,
-0.06291116029024124,
0.14824995398521423,
0.04867880046367645,
-0.3055340647697449,
0.5633925199508667,
-0.24066214263439178,
0.8545187711715698,
0.8932977914810181,
-0.32037943601608276,
-0.08470377326011658,
-0.2038770467042923,
0.4071112275123596,
0.23648037016391754,
-1.2276301383972168,
0.4712519943714142,
0.8596708178520203,
0.1043618693947792,
0.6103710532188416,
0.48279374837875366,
-0.1861785501241684,
0.11600048094987869,
-0.11081802099943161,
0.03468719497323036,
-0.38852807879447937,
-0.4314901530742645,
-0.4849171042442322,
0.41043323278427124,
-0.43282854557037354,
-0.5683758854866028
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10238v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10238v1
|
Early Detection of Misinformation for Infodemic Management: A Domain Adaptation Approach
| 2024-06-02T19:27:56 | 2024-06-02T19:27:56 |
Minjia Mao, Xiaohang Zhao, Xiao Fang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SI
|
An infodemic refers to an enormous amount of true information and
misinformation disseminated during a disease outbreak. Detecting misinformation
at the early stage of an infodemic is key to manage it and reduce its harm to
public health. An early stage infodemic is characterized by a large volume of
unlabeled information concerning a disease. As a result, conventional
misinformation detection methods are not suitable for this misinformation
detection task because they rely on labeled information in the infodemic domain
to train their models. To address the limitation of conventional methods,
state-of-the-art methods learn their models using labeled information in other
domains to detect misinformation in the infodemic domain. The efficacy of these
methods depends on their ability to mitigate both covariate shift and concept
shift between the infodemic domain and the domains from which they leverage
labeled information. These methods focus on mitigating covariate shift but
overlook concept shift, rendering them less effective for the task. In
response, we theoretically show the necessity of tackling both covariate shift
and concept shift as well as how to operationalize each of them. Built on the
theoretical analysis, we develop a novel misinformation detection method that
addresses both covariate shift and concept shift. Using two real-world
datasets, we conduct extensive empirical evaluations to demonstrate the
superior performance of our method over state-of-the-art misinformation
detection methods as well as prevalent domain adaptation methods that can be
tailored to solve the misinformation detection task.
|
[
-0.38567811250686646,
-0.9636171460151672,
0.2533445656299591,
0.06441367417573929,
-0.31885430216789246,
-0.04240885004401207,
0.08947410434484482,
-0.5722410082817078,
-0.06347323954105377,
0.2135182023048401,
-0.8110261559486389,
-0.5017604231834412,
-0.662133514881134,
-0.04245081543922424,
-0.3292423188686371,
1.1235712766647339,
0.10495705157518387,
-0.2638629674911499,
-0.2930811047554016,
0.24059824645519257,
-0.5168560743331909,
-0.4784352779388428,
-0.6758918762207031,
-0.3085475564002991,
0.2105444073677063,
0.7580873966217041,
0.448668897151947,
0.33702799677848816,
0.8148742914199829,
-0.0387360081076622,
0.14510440826416016,
0.18172724545001984,
-0.7933436632156372,
0.025284409523010254,
-0.16859394311904907,
-0.5083346366882324,
-0.2735516428947449,
0.09956827014684677,
0.15816029906272888,
0.5926862359046936,
-0.3145063519477844,
0.48852086067199707,
-0.14131487905979156,
0.5620600581169128,
-0.8059449791908264,
0.006009305827319622,
-0.712395191192627,
0.1662520319223404,
-0.47512057423591614,
-0.6008045673370361,
-0.6400188207626343,
-0.14796598255634308,
0.19784554839134216,
-1.0496352910995483,
0.14296652376651764,
0.11055298149585724,
0.7920004725456238,
0.14736740291118622,
-0.2660694122314453,
-0.23223894834518433,
-1.1596200466156006,
0.45985671877861023,
-0.40266379714012146,
0.2872079312801361,
0.27452802658081055,
0.3291049301624298,
-0.21131539344787598,
-0.46755218505859375,
-0.5846240520477295,
0.2520556151866913,
0.316361665725708,
0.047912657260894775,
-0.7663537263870239,
-0.4727987051010132,
0.2991085648536682,
-0.19463549554347992,
-0.6198855638504028,
0.1824408918619156,
-0.405329167842865,
-0.32847732305526733,
0.3889322578907013,
-0.06472049653530121,
0.21357956528663635,
0.14832265675067902,
-1.0479555130004883,
-0.2559144198894501,
-0.8435218334197998,
0.03197735548019409,
0.18067049980163574,
0.2218024879693985,
-0.2777993977069855,
0.12903791666030884,
0.03993343189358711,
0.6166365146636963,
0.6958329677581787,
-0.4456787109375,
0.026640605181455612,
-0.4881587028503418,
-0.18763580918312073,
0.4399816393852234,
0.220237597823143,
0.4254348874092102,
-0.012188558466732502,
0.10423602163791656,
0.028152626007795334,
0.020515309646725655,
0.4509822130203247,
-0.7465946674346924,
-0.44868582487106323,
0.0002598318096715957,
-0.6324211359024048,
-0.16693341732025146,
-0.05587751045823097,
-0.8627691268920898,
-0.663981556892395,
-0.16683754324913025,
0.5672131180763245,
-0.5557860732078552,
-0.48097485303878784,
0.04593547806143761,
-0.1825919896364212,
-0.0008790148422122002,
0.6280471682548523,
-0.3976784348487854,
0.2941344678401947,
0.45791396498680115,
0.7545889019966125,
-0.5290530920028687,
0.11672911792993546,
-0.246520534157753,
0.3050031363964081,
-0.36527717113494873,
1.0021148920059204,
-0.3824895918369293,
-0.10338778793811798,
-0.22125208377838135,
-0.09776554256677628,
-0.5139395594596863,
-0.7423455715179443,
0.4424109160900116,
-0.7545965909957886,
-0.05884372442960739,
0.021455887705087662,
-0.5936757326126099,
-0.36180001497268677,
0.1657252311706543,
-0.7633832097053528,
0.6975958347320557,
0.2490915060043335,
-1.0548231601715088,
0.5439022183418274,
-0.6803840398788452,
-0.29373928904533386,
0.058740757405757904,
0.29226094484329224,
-0.6814433932304382,
0.06662900000810623,
-0.027125578373670578,
0.3061501681804657,
-0.26513370871543884,
0.07331263273954391,
-0.3331599235534668,
-0.0814918801188469,
0.33762380480766296,
-0.26749345660209656,
0.5630455017089844,
0.34599390625953674,
-0.07784223556518555,
-0.20349526405334473,
-0.7338069677352905,
-0.0978139117360115,
0.10460903495550156,
-0.049139413982629776,
-0.8442880511283875,
-0.0012239087373018265,
-0.1584377884864807,
0.20412218570709229,
-0.059688765555620193,
-0.16816259920597076,
0.25063854455947876,
0.07278405129909515,
-0.2859601378440857,
0.5754633545875549,
0.5009418725967407,
0.33164218068122864,
-0.40550994873046875,
0.5401623845100403,
0.8481407165527344,
0.6016659736633301,
0.08539170026779175,
-0.31079357862472534,
-0.3677179515361786,
-0.2737654149532318,
0.24898868799209595,
0.7801148295402527,
-0.9588990211486816,
0.42105957865715027,
-0.3110560476779938,
-0.4388807415962219,
-0.45373597741127014,
-0.10300692170858383,
-0.011428164318203926,
0.6911826729774475,
0.5552504062652588,
-0.2148861289024353,
-0.6505302786827087,
-0.7411434650421143,
-0.47398534417152405,
-0.18547043204307556,
0.29042303562164307,
-0.3013133406639099,
0.4738534092903137,
-0.23153311014175415,
0.7186076641082764,
-0.6420902609825134,
-0.20881325006484985,
-0.12059558182954788,
0.40311214327812195,
0.2561536431312561,
0.2772596776485443,
0.5626943707466125,
-1.1523849964141846,
-0.2785871624946594,
-0.08136559277772903,
-0.5545468330383301,
0.13861455023288727,
-0.2457309365272522,
-0.08396691083908081,
-0.2453061193227768,
0.436514675617218,
-0.24670721590518951,
0.5842589735984802,
0.33042412996292114,
-0.4026532471179962,
0.4239928722381592,
-0.1685609519481659,
0.10471394658088684,
-1.0233958959579468,
-0.05558557063341141,
0.17050954699516296,
-0.12000080943107605,
-1.1927335262298584,
-0.32186824083328247,
0.2172829508781433,
0.19832409918308258,
-0.25330641865730286,
0.21565259993076324,
-0.3658183217048645,
0.23725520074367523,
-0.23655660450458527,
-0.1100764274597168,
-0.025668280199170113,
0.10066436976194382,
-0.15212678909301758,
0.5869746804237366,
0.43539053201675415,
-1.2024379968643188,
0.1469101756811142,
0.21389999985694885,
-0.5433744788169861,
0.9556862115859985,
-0.009731357917189598,
0.023736242204904556,
-0.1373349279165268,
0.23732012510299683,
-0.9100825190544128,
-0.014184597879648209,
0.7699472904205322,
-0.38921263813972473,
0.3522413372993469,
-0.1275729089975357,
-0.23111222684383392,
-0.3684101402759552,
-0.1506800502538681,
0.4188826084136963,
-0.011696887202560902,
-0.693742036819458,
0.05358098819851875,
0.5755305886268616,
-0.32981768250465393,
-0.32328712940216064,
-0.48497751355171204,
0.005442211404442787,
-0.38136282563209534,
-0.5223625898361206,
0.36997610330581665,
-0.1503271758556366,
-0.31777846813201904,
0.0777442678809166,
-0.5144765973091125,
-0.4602978527545929,
0.4234560430049896,
-0.03656948357820511,
0.39642950892448425,
-0.2969900667667389,
0.597196102142334,
-0.011493858881294727,
-0.21747028827667236,
-0.17030709981918335,
-0.45333898067474365,
0.22284212708473206,
0.4067540168762207,
-0.34282374382019043,
-0.6180658936500549,
0.33410340547561646,
0.3174475133419037,
0.10136885195970535,
0.902010977268219,
0.5160924196243286,
-0.5802288055419922,
-0.1659550964832306,
-0.17935198545455933,
-0.2988443076610565,
-0.30015501379966736,
0.5046179294586182,
-0.17015573382377625,
-0.20218800008296967,
0.1170341819524765,
-0.7657309174537659,
-0.38596630096435547,
0.5568872094154358,
0.13439930975437164,
-0.04540608078241348,
0.6792213916778564,
0.9695002436637878,
0.013496993109583855,
0.401504784822464,
-0.1327543556690216,
0.5585307478904724,
-0.6287367343902588,
-0.2656029462814331,
-0.46017566323280334,
-0.16212862730026245,
-0.4129634201526642,
-0.6669114828109741,
0.6874243021011353,
0.32276785373687744,
0.13316987454891205,
0.03194452449679375,
-0.2687436044216156,
0.06569398194551468,
0.09268030524253845,
0.32613807916641235,
0.41201719641685486,
0.17193713784217834,
0.19922220706939697,
-0.03593546897172928,
-1.001886248588562,
-0.31557223200798035,
1.2227660417556763,
0.2714957892894745,
1.1373636722564697,
0.16289132833480835,
0.3187536895275116,
0.8605750799179077,
0.2471153885126114,
-0.6608614325523376,
0.0812101885676384,
-0.0032393671572208405,
-0.43137457966804504,
-0.31699126958847046,
-0.2470952719449997,
-0.9246651530265808,
0.06738350540399551,
-0.45148128271102905,
-0.5457954406738281,
0.7376844882965088,
-0.001722010551020503,
-0.43699318170547485,
0.2767835259437561,
-0.674322783946991,
0.6496745944023132,
-0.05236921086907387,
-0.04099981114268303,
-0.26457491517066956,
-0.5412485599517822,
0.21794509887695312,
-0.4970906376838684,
0.7240800857543945,
-0.09239854663610458,
-0.05950801074504852,
0.9242407083511353,
0.006246466189622879,
1.0028754472732544,
-0.3056527078151703,
-0.2970680594444275,
0.27462300658226013,
-0.04111737012863159,
0.7061733603477478,
-0.1077784076333046,
-0.002824321622028947,
0.15297985076904297,
-0.026634659618139267,
-0.30248329043388367,
-0.35901254415512085,
0.2563289999961853,
-0.7511999011039734,
-0.38346585631370544,
-0.45546388626098633,
-0.37441086769104004,
-0.17750628292560577,
0.0650986060500145,
0.4564950168132782,
0.09260360896587372,
-0.5590320825576782,
-0.1355627477169037,
1.146958351135254,
0.05385999009013176,
0.15047936141490936,
0.6530076861381531,
0.02987568825483322,
0.060180120170116425,
0.7432447075843811,
0.1436382532119751,
0.3802555203437805,
0.5974718928337097,
0.25715717673301697,
-0.00026024007820524275,
-0.6439440250396729,
-0.12172037363052368,
-0.18789921700954437,
-0.8470795750617981,
-0.4273161292076111,
-0.493269145488739,
-0.16369614005088806,
-0.3928224742412567,
0.45647263526916504,
-0.05546221882104874,
-0.3552602529525757,
-0.39595675468444824,
0.02023291029036045,
0.44445037841796875,
0.7194573879241943,
-0.29400140047073364,
0.4358859956264496,
-0.6136199235916138,
0.6302530765533447,
0.14742620289325714,
-0.031174086034297943,
-0.24930532276630402,
-0.573782205581665,
-0.6171766519546509,
0.44697678089141846,
-0.3744969069957733,
-1.0219624042510986,
0.12937133014202118,
0.4466453194618225,
0.6577523946762085,
0.5721186399459839,
0.2741867005825043,
0.4796231687068939,
-0.08608601987361908,
0.3612976372241974,
0.3131921589374542,
-0.7357121109962463,
0.6246166825294495,
0.08633449673652649,
0.19099628925323486,
0.37351638078689575,
0.851169228553772,
-0.7424339056015015,
-0.004506711848080158,
-0.5273317098617554,
-0.6373134255409241,
0.9218966960906982,
-0.07882224023342133,
-0.45360830426216125,
0.23770634829998016,
0.24127615988254547,
0.5365663766860962,
0.2525104284286499,
-0.27739769220352173,
-0.31848788261413574,
0.0013388009974732995,
0.04204576835036278,
0.12819448113441467,
-0.1125241219997406,
-0.4576970338821411,
-0.15387892723083496,
0.7235202789306641,
-0.2695472240447998,
0.6134796738624573,
0.2757749557495117,
-0.4999866783618927,
-0.36816540360450745,
0.27940231561660767,
0.636149525642395,
0.8031994700431824,
-0.062159840017557144,
0.3469845652580261,
-0.19401060044765472,
-0.808725893497467,
0.38589930534362793,
0.10419236868619919,
-0.34850457310676575,
0.17495213449001312,
0.3471852242946625,
0.9831154942512512,
0.15989111363887787,
-0.1365206241607666,
0.8315056562423706,
0.02396925538778305,
0.04178301990032196,
-0.03896833583712578,
0.05618768557906151,
-0.24409835040569305,
0.2960643768310547,
0.5790971517562866,
0.6216882467269897,
0.0760984793305397,
-0.6274389624595642,
0.21024774014949799,
0.14581945538520813,
-0.23967058956623077,
-0.5664461851119995,
0.19520926475524902,
-0.042329803109169006,
-0.004548894241452217,
0.12400104850530624,
0.009690819308161736,
-0.2450057417154312,
0.6862661838531494,
0.8968058824539185,
0.765564501285553,
-0.7048389911651611,
0.5406709313392639,
0.1607571393251419,
0.36298638582229614,
-0.04857119917869568,
0.08529123663902283,
0.11189202964305878,
-0.8434707522392273,
-0.0689336434006691,
-0.0775994285941124,
-0.1124139279127121,
0.33874624967575073,
-0.9273988604545593,
0.15726156532764435,
-0.21766698360443115,
-0.41466209292411804,
0.29551106691360474,
-0.3699262738227844,
-0.8278402090072632,
0.2971731722354889,
0.2854806184768677,
0.97393798828125,
-1.0650237798690796,
0.5211964249610901,
0.7032492160797119,
0.011476458981633186,
-0.25769466161727905,
0.6755169034004211,
0.0291795264929533,
-0.8117774724960327,
0.7001218199729919,
-0.03147253021597862,
-0.09139472246170044,
-0.14677047729492188,
-0.8084256649017334,
-1.03609299659729,
0.9608351588249207,
0.3117068111896515,
-0.6784946918487549,
0.16652202606201172,
-0.045147329568862915,
0.3047661781311035,
-0.6592155694961548,
-0.009178089909255505,
0.44599834084510803,
0.6837384700775146,
0.04998033866286278,
-0.7222034931182861,
0.015309284441173077,
0.1303463876247406,
-0.0977407917380333,
0.08688192814588547,
-0.31208303570747375,
0.9184079766273499,
-0.48569104075431824,
-0.45929762721061707,
-0.4255169630050659,
0.4284326732158661,
-0.15548297762870789,
0.6709185242652893,
0.7005085349082947,
0.34156283736228943,
1.3729327917099,
0.0028541390784084797,
0.8932579755783081,
-0.18651126325130463,
0.3299190402030945,
1.0858268737792969,
-0.20143328607082367,
0.5931719541549683,
0.4941369593143463,
-0.11548753082752228,
0.5183554291725159,
0.8426342606544495,
0.18982674181461334,
0.9130377173423767,
0.23480281233787537,
-0.2839747667312622,
-0.4053773880004883,
-0.13134987652301788,
-0.7484707832336426,
0.3598429560661316,
0.7982429265975952,
-0.07097970694303513,
-0.37277549505233765,
0.4990784823894501,
-0.06620273739099503,
-0.24426785111427307,
-0.45268356800079346,
0.9633132219314575,
-0.21437184512615204,
-0.3332265019416809,
0.884684145450592,
0.0022208490408957005,
0.310578852891922,
-0.5740038752555847,
-0.06628008931875229,
0.13211137056350708,
0.38246336579322815,
-0.2001335769891739,
-0.3275110721588135,
0.07935761660337448,
-0.14123661816120148,
-0.5251360535621643,
0.07626152783632278,
1.2030407190322876,
-0.4236100912094116,
-0.32546180486679077,
0.3023645877838135,
0.7626091241836548,
-0.11319886893033981,
-0.1095273345708847,
-0.6106548309326172,
0.09480779618024826,
-0.0723898783326149,
-0.03520512580871582,
0.25199422240257263,
0.6496486067771912,
-0.3508206307888031,
0.5573564767837524,
0.5215622186660767,
0.20807430148124695,
0.058952897787094116,
-0.21189090609550476,
0.866428792476654,
-0.45257827639579773,
-0.639742374420166,
-0.6300941705703735,
0.01099093072116375,
-0.21324510872364044,
0.00044087867718189955,
0.6525934338569641,
0.5334292054176331,
0.7988413572311401,
-0.32003381848335266,
1.241451382637024,
0.06749007850885391,
0.6777399182319641,
-0.5430665016174316,
0.3869474530220032,
-0.31806135177612305,
0.2766396999359131,
-0.02379235439002514,
-0.6096516251564026,
-0.0765361487865448,
0.3137313425540924,
-0.2623102068901062,
-0.34518396854400635,
0.8109624981880188,
0.3647567629814148,
-0.1783338189125061,
0.29966726899147034,
0.20643602311611176,
0.5488938093185425,
0.20103426277637482,
0.4811262786388397,
0.9124165177345276,
-0.3961848318576813,
0.2876394987106323,
-0.007297071628272533,
-0.5239818096160889,
-0.7733823657035828,
-0.9033118486404419,
-0.49132922291755676,
-0.49138835072517395,
-0.7336952090263367,
-0.4394007921218872,
0.4889470040798187,
0.7475041151046753,
0.9264857172966003,
-0.9206864237785339,
0.19008095562458038,
0.1608913242816925,
0.3500528335571289,
-0.7349845767021179,
-0.24900922179222107,
0.1675393134355545,
-0.07597100734710693,
-0.15044906735420227,
0.4407617747783661,
0.3582489788532257,
0.2287304848432541,
0.07527033984661102,
0.3417048752307892,
-0.6710219979286194,
0.2908172607421875,
0.5668807625770569,
0.2884664237499237,
-0.04302630200982094,
-0.23824332654476166,
-0.25733688473701477,
-0.2087760865688324,
0.2484757900238037,
0.8043751120567322,
-0.6737063527107239,
0.5816957950592041,
0.23294512927532196,
0.5792401432991028,
0.38544610142707825,
-0.07096048444509506,
0.3266122043132782,
-0.681101381778717,
0.053337737917900085,
0.08283165097236633,
-0.3078596889972687,
0.35241979360580444,
-0.7628302574157715,
0.2936824858188629,
0.5975305438041687,
-0.07842390239238739,
-0.5598428249359131,
0.17721864581108093,
-0.7193379402160645,
-0.3033590018749237,
0.9679805040359497,
-0.04198973625898361,
-0.4237469732761383,
-0.5778141617774963,
-0.0640106275677681,
0.3867476284503937,
-0.37088197469711304,
1.0729721784591675,
0.6832774877548218,
-0.2708323895931244,
0.41285669803619385,
-0.44617441296577454,
0.63126140832901,
-0.13560126721858978,
-1.107686161994934,
-0.06322410702705383,
-0.025077560916543007,
0.5015169978141785,
0.2862493693828583,
0.5254518985748291,
0.09177426993846893,
0.5083551406860352,
-0.049192287027835846,
0.09136654436588287,
0.14502793550491333,
-0.5063878297805786,
-0.3211851716041565,
0.01947200298309326,
-0.22692017257213593,
-0.5315130352973938
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00839v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00839v1
|
FOCUS: Forging Originality through Contrastive Use in Self-Plagiarism for Language Models
| 2024-06-02T19:17:00 | 2024-06-02T19:17:00 |
Kaixin Lan, Tao Fang, Derek F. Wong, Yabo Xu, Lidia S. Chao, Cecilia G. Zhao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Pre-trained Language Models (PLMs) have shown impressive results in various
Natural Language Generation (NLG) tasks, such as powering chatbots and
generating stories. However, an ethical concern arises due to their potential
to produce verbatim copies of paragraphs from their training data. This is
problematic as PLMs are trained on corpora constructed by human authors. As
such, there is a pressing need for research to promote the generation of
original content by these models. In this study, we introduce a unique
"self-plagiarism" contrastive decoding strategy, aimed at boosting the
originality of text produced by PLMs. Our method entails modifying prompts in
LLMs to develop an amateur model and a professional model. Specifically, the
amateur model is urged to plagiarize using three plagiarism templates we have
designed, while the professional model maintains its standard language model
status. This strategy employs prompts to stimulate the model's capacity to
identify non-original candidate token combinations and subsequently impose
penalties. The application of this strategy is integrated prior to the model's
final layer, ensuring smooth integration with most existing PLMs (T5, GPT,
LLaMA) without necessitating further adjustments. Implementing our strategy, we
observe a significant decline in non-original sequences comprised of more than
three words in the academic AASC dataset and the story-based ROCStories
dataset.
|
[
-0.28054580092430115,
-0.4754125475883484,
0.30022457242012024,
0.29456937313079834,
-0.7641472816467285,
-0.06296422332525253,
0.09790566563606262,
-0.06753619760274887,
0.10525129735469818,
1.0294278860092163,
-0.4266375005245209,
-0.4525955617427826,
-0.2495540827512741,
0.5936259627342224,
-0.47874411940574646,
1.1062655448913574,
0.038188956677913666,
0.009982380084693432,
-0.30047309398651123,
-0.30460935831069946,
-0.16715191304683685,
-0.552121639251709,
-0.5608729720115662,
-0.10578533262014389,
0.3860105276107788,
0.24364586174488068,
0.4479686915874481,
0.955567479133606,
0.34023910760879517,
0.24648930132389069,
-0.03919246420264244,
0.08116485178470612,
-0.5874068737030029,
0.041943278163671494,
-0.27641603350639343,
-0.28933703899383545,
-0.13759835064411163,
0.16587787866592407,
0.5706129670143127,
0.35198429226875305,
0.01661740057170391,
-0.026191547513008118,
0.4377966821193695,
0.5462582111358643,
-0.6124830842018127,
-0.11856818944215775,
-0.738188624382019,
-0.0008575269021093845,
-0.14680461585521698,
-0.587936282157898,
-0.4682551920413971,
-0.2149764746427536,
-0.11056667566299438,
-0.47541990876197815,
0.5469275116920471,
-0.13624107837677002,
0.5429883003234863,
0.07650228589773178,
-0.0751725435256958,
-0.6104263663291931,
-0.34255191683769226,
0.7190455794334412,
-1.0394353866577148,
-0.09595226496458054,
-0.013490079902112484,
-0.23647983372211456,
0.03919510543346405,
-0.8616729974746704,
-0.853257417678833,
-0.12849834561347961,
-0.3094131052494049,
0.20661984384059906,
-0.1788852959871292,
-0.27889057993888855,
-0.2040298879146576,
0.7123764753341675,
-0.3453631103038788,
0.2683272063732147,
-0.275942862033844,
-0.07860321551561356,
0.5022839307785034,
0.2744196355342865,
0.18764671683311462,
-0.4511256515979767,
-0.6719680428504944,
-0.08010701835155487,
-0.8684388995170593,
-0.12697263062000275,
0.7191353440284729,
0.4666955769062042,
-0.1714356690645218,
0.38004186749458313,
-0.09112667292356491,
0.30927374958992004,
0.05500061437487602,
0.14469584822654724,
0.3795849084854126,
-0.5983125567436218,
-0.07154883444309235,
-0.09213606268167496,
1.0097099542617798,
0.44028574228286743,
-0.019295597448945045,
-0.0601741187274456,
-0.3607017397880554,
0.059652481228113174,
0.17315058410167694,
-0.6917830109596252,
-0.5950626730918884,
-0.140485480427742,
-0.5956418514251709,
-0.5693289041519165,
-0.16493649780750275,
-0.7583299279212952,
-0.4287814795970917,
-0.414832204580307,
0.5115408897399902,
-0.3983358144760132,
-0.22944767773151398,
0.1282864660024643,
-0.02742670103907585,
0.20967519283294678,
0.010493072681128979,
-0.7192660570144653,
0.318264901638031,
0.5043618083000183,
0.7835034132003784,
-0.30978822708129883,
-0.5018831491470337,
-0.31541872024536133,
0.08993630111217499,
-0.3883190453052521,
0.5810607075691223,
-0.1609160155057907,
-0.6921968460083008,
-0.11799504607915878,
-0.23182256519794464,
0.24835602939128876,
-0.6783291101455688,
0.709023118019104,
-0.4002552330493927,
0.45987391471862793,
-0.18329478800296783,
-0.6250210404396057,
0.07206933200359344,
-0.051820237189531326,
-0.6925593018531799,
0.7805051207542419,
-0.27328863739967346,
-1.0417776107788086,
0.024498339742422104,
-0.530194878578186,
-0.304008811712265,
0.22352683544158936,
-0.39553847908973694,
-0.5791592597961426,
0.19389411807060242,
0.34175169467926025,
0.2441462278366089,
-0.14735041558742523,
0.006922566331923008,
0.0024288108106702566,
-0.2887268662452698,
0.16155748069286346,
-0.4144056439399719,
0.7688931822776794,
0.3561267852783203,
-0.25147753953933716,
-0.01470896415412426,
-0.6904069185256958,
-0.2890399098396301,
0.5608310699462891,
-0.3331121504306793,
-0.5609330534934998,
-0.1698603332042694,
-0.2738077640533447,
0.3373159170150757,
0.24627141654491425,
-0.46009036898612976,
-0.19643422961235046,
-0.4673589766025543,
0.25694236159324646,
0.8445594310760498,
0.0539681613445282,
0.38077297806739807,
-0.6790575981140137,
0.5950065851211548,
0.12966954708099365,
-0.11290913820266724,
-0.6008486747741699,
-0.1071876659989357,
-0.7587350606918335,
-0.40443161129951477,
0.2027895301580429,
0.32476556301116943,
-0.9132052063941956,
0.4834456741809845,
-0.13530723750591278,
-0.302161306142807,
-1.1718955039978027,
0.38616111874580383,
0.5792480707168579,
0.8477468490600586,
0.5420344471931458,
-0.2933351993560791,
-0.5966216921806335,
-1.0551027059555054,
-0.5216740369796753,
0.14317233860492706,
-0.17393858730793,
0.14719544351100922,
0.3969416320323944,
0.07283038645982742,
0.9899061918258667,
-0.12807287275791168,
-0.41098031401634216,
-0.291113942861557,
0.4838172495365143,
0.09562835097312927,
0.8015175461769104,
0.49876973032951355,
-0.6593117713928223,
-0.481594055891037,
-0.5468047857284546,
-0.8275136947631836,
-0.47960802912712097,
-0.2775927782058716,
-0.042087920010089874,
0.18385156989097595,
0.6233447790145874,
-0.18478283286094666,
0.1872027963399887,
0.5547218918800354,
-0.1529851257801056,
0.5837254524230957,
-0.3458825945854187,
0.035566993057727814,
-1.0157243013381958,
0.32326987385749817,
-0.20995661616325378,
-0.037726990878582,
-0.4290353059768677,
0.3148447275161743,
-0.14647945761680603,
-0.09837272763252258,
-0.4677703082561493,
0.7550849318504333,
-0.5107839107513428,
0.1985550969839096,
-0.5141758322715759,
0.22551275789737701,
0.04495060071349144,
0.25912851095199585,
0.07466910034418106,
0.7500617504119873,
0.3101640045642853,
-0.5160729885101318,
-0.17627304792404175,
0.509036660194397,
-0.1985676884651184,
0.5775520205497742,
-0.6470694541931152,
0.4985188841819763,
-0.4107069671154022,
0.075429767370224,
-0.8757226467132568,
0.3909325897693634,
0.32657021284103394,
-0.31663212180137634,
-0.00779560673981905,
-0.10023682564496994,
-0.46371591091156006,
0.015929222106933594,
-0.5464081168174744,
0.3054409921169281,
0.7035203576087952,
-0.777320146560669,
0.5837979316711426,
0.08575262129306793,
-0.5305479168891907,
-0.5299573540687561,
-0.8030607104301453,
0.32943418622016907,
-0.21535228192806244,
-0.42268484830856323,
0.5194623470306396,
-0.2750891149044037,
-0.1504664421081543,
0.12708446383476257,
-0.06453615427017212,
0.2970910966396332,
0.1995151937007904,
-0.16429001092910767,
0.21071188151836395,
-0.1522255539894104,
-0.26332125067710876,
0.010392536409199238,
-0.04421963915228844,
0.11041731387376785,
0.0244473684579134,
0.6016775965690613,
-0.005437759682536125,
-0.0477173812687397,
-0.5227931141853333,
0.5753684043884277,
0.15958645939826965,
-0.34727346897125244,
0.5639101266860962,
0.33296218514442444,
0.11858446896076202,
-0.44866251945495605,
-0.5324188470840454,
-0.41615816950798035,
-0.5198478698730469,
0.02403438463807106,
-0.3680604100227356,
-0.7107952237129211,
0.4347606897354126,
0.1914166510105133,
0.2413686215877533,
0.2614947259426117,
0.43420863151550293,
-0.0867658406496048,
0.6285302042961121,
0.42764368653297424,
0.10364373028278351,
0.478787899017334,
-0.0534515306353569,
0.11001832783222198,
-0.6494392156600952,
-0.08732926845550537,
-0.39307114481925964,
-0.15845952928066254,
-0.5361243486404419,
-0.3915097117424011,
-0.016638148576021194,
0.2144976705312729,
0.07004491984844208,
0.011170838959515095,
-0.49658915400505066,
0.5898126363754272,
0.7852476835250854,
0.2149009108543396,
0.5736215710639954,
0.11609333753585815,
-0.32160601019859314,
-0.22930429875850677,
-0.7537671327590942,
-0.7744602560997009,
0.9908085465431213,
0.15329334139823914,
0.7210784554481506,
-0.11143698543310165,
1.317807674407959,
0.3463749587535858,
0.31257742643356323,
-0.2639694809913635,
0.7107282876968384,
-0.4914878308773041,
-0.2434338927268982,
0.030120184645056725,
-0.6213213801383972,
-1.0531669855117798,
0.4090767204761505,
-0.19231143593788147,
-0.045262936502695084,
0.054433293640613556,
0.40424099564552307,
-0.221973717212677,
0.15780052542686462,
-0.4320579171180725,
0.8473260402679443,
-0.11316639184951782,
-0.5037621259689331,
-0.15339575707912445,
-0.6655362844467163,
0.3155386745929718,
-0.05196065455675125,
0.2638820707798004,
0.08951632678508759,
-0.13365812599658966,
0.665917694568634,
-0.328133761882782,
0.9267503023147583,
-0.000625558546744287,
-0.004650280345231295,
0.2923021912574768,
0.4620087444782257,
0.3738844394683838,
-0.18972136080265045,
0.0009536762372590601,
0.023769205436110497,
-0.323845773935318,
-0.531488835811615,
-0.23515331745147705,
0.7378136515617371,
-0.6791236400604248,
-0.8258312344551086,
-0.2744583189487457,
-0.39646854996681213,
0.16768920421600342,
0.36894461512565613,
0.3747088611125946,
0.3050750195980072,
-0.3071643114089966,
0.2924419641494751,
0.3422195315361023,
-0.2009841799736023,
0.5471034646034241,
0.7026878595352173,
0.11316143721342087,
-0.4817153811454773,
0.9251703023910522,
-0.311506986618042,
0.27806606888771057,
0.13055776059627533,
0.5089436769485474,
-0.3946918547153473,
-0.867361843585968,
-0.09312068670988083,
0.41291600465774536,
-0.9712119102478027,
-0.10038583725690842,
-0.7099103927612305,
-0.24183931946754456,
-0.4709431231021881,
-0.43208834528923035,
-0.2581949830055237,
0.03325210511684418,
-0.663739800453186,
0.006519588641822338,
0.10453756153583527,
0.6276779174804688,
-0.27686744928359985,
0.2972833216190338,
-0.8070031404495239,
0.34057852625846863,
0.25652509927749634,
0.04061334952712059,
-0.03818710520863533,
-0.7177966833114624,
0.12611916661262512,
-0.06695591658353806,
-0.2280680239200592,
-0.7178207039833069,
0.662503719329834,
0.08889204263687134,
0.8662681579589844,
0.1008099690079689,
0.33652424812316895,
0.23891928791999817,
-0.3166000545024872,
0.780442476272583,
0.20843996107578278,
-1.1267483234405518,
0.2870747148990631,
-0.3732789158821106,
0.26086217164993286,
0.7280842661857605,
0.3105347752571106,
-0.2884868383407593,
-0.5506787896156311,
-0.8065237998962402,
-0.8807287216186523,
0.5557882189750671,
0.410250186920166,
0.4698773920536041,
-0.24594993889331818,
0.3135896325111389,
0.417694091796875,
0.4314591884613037,
-1.1680864095687866,
-0.09982813149690628,
-0.44586601853370667,
-0.5672944784164429,
0.0287640243768692,
-0.37983715534210205,
-0.14635546505451202,
0.25559309124946594,
0.5115656852722168,
-0.18181166052818298,
-0.11490895599126816,
0.30560770630836487,
-0.22577057778835297,
0.39309409260749817,
0.2909342348575592,
0.2677224278450012,
0.25679975748062134,
0.04344891011714935,
0.47388002276420593,
0.006165390368551016,
-0.04896748811006546,
0.009516560472548008,
0.010843399912118912,
-0.3570273518562317,
0.1228671595454216,
0.18541443347930908,
0.47348684072494507,
0.2683044373989105,
-0.5987780690193176,
0.5774062275886536,
0.14928358793258667,
-0.04489521309733391,
-0.08574571460485458,
-0.18557311594486237,
0.08311253786087036,
0.009637259878218174,
0.08106782287359238,
-0.026354024186730385,
0.13970652222633362,
-0.4896203577518463,
0.25428077578544617,
0.2093232423067093,
0.3315007984638214,
-0.30128905177116394,
0.65238356590271,
0.4528156816959381,
-0.3659162223339081,
0.46678078174591064,
-0.2834908366203308,
-0.3337184488773346,
0.31703487038612366,
0.7442575693130493,
0.7172626256942749,
-0.41556215286254883,
0.09873465448617935,
0.2906832993030548,
0.14086587727069855,
-0.35870257019996643,
0.22178316116333008,
-0.0044352468103170395,
-0.7747008800506592,
0.028668902814388275,
-0.4447581171989441,
-0.28291377425193787,
0.31718364357948303,
-0.646618127822876,
0.33961954712867737,
-0.5702810287475586,
0.2931448221206665,
-0.15440823137760162,
-0.29146260023117065,
-0.5857440829277039,
0.16412775218486786,
0.16709041595458984,
0.5373354554176331,
-0.8676435947418213,
0.5933353900909424,
0.20753858983516693,
-0.6367997527122498,
-0.32654139399528503,
0.015100840479135513,
-0.21206101775169373,
-0.7764729857444763,
0.4604671597480774,
0.11484420299530029,
-0.23138263821601868,
0.16832709312438965,
-0.5781781673431396,
-0.3768433928489685,
0.8490027189254761,
0.38055849075317383,
-0.46331191062927246,
-0.3028435707092285,
0.09343995898962021,
0.5908175110816956,
-0.5479605197906494,
-0.27680251002311707,
0.5517314076423645,
-0.11206923425197601,
0.06089865416288376,
-0.4549383521080017,
0.30105116963386536,
-0.3573278784751892,
-0.00010315526742488146,
-0.25700733065605164,
-0.46042636036872864,
1.136781096458435,
-0.06470752507448196,
-0.3521176278591156,
0.5088103413581848,
0.42183732986450195,
0.5112584233283997,
0.00967406015843153,
0.47603926062583923,
0.4882969856262207,
0.4459957182407379,
0.41799235343933105,
0.9771131873130798,
-0.3495652675628662,
0.08745872229337692,
1.4890674352645874,
-0.1284860372543335,
0.7940049767494202,
0.5154222249984741,
0.36031025648117065,
0.4876417815685272,
0.10774476081132889,
-0.42766308784484863,
0.8241307139396667,
0.3202860355377197,
-0.2868587374687195,
-0.1718423068523407,
-0.005352085921913385,
-0.14140377938747406,
0.341395765542984,
0.10781199485063553,
-0.864432156085968,
-0.2504841983318329,
-0.17698659002780914,
0.21674327552318573,
0.6587177515029907,
-0.2250935137271881,
0.8393422365188599,
0.14962375164031982,
-0.6054168343544006,
0.4686906337738037,
-0.03246686980128288,
0.905709445476532,
-0.512891411781311,
0.08594010770320892,
-0.5068419575691223,
0.24740546941757202,
0.019205274060368538,
-0.57982337474823,
0.20836575329303741,
-0.013593664392828941,
0.09705885499715805,
-0.476228803396225,
0.472533643245697,
-0.599195659160614,
-0.2999928593635559,
0.27610349655151367,
0.6189547777175903,
0.08636461198329926,
0.13375504314899445,
-0.751569390296936,
0.022163020446896553,
0.05721139907836914,
0.07306104153394699,
0.292859822511673,
0.37768474221229553,
0.4140207767486572,
0.42393794655799866,
0.6093893051147461,
0.1391095519065857,
-0.11927998065948486,
-0.09014798700809479,
0.8452214002609253,
-0.6576686501502991,
-0.9619338512420654,
-1.0009961128234863,
0.4994686245918274,
-0.22189173102378845,
-0.44455015659332275,
0.9718422293663025,
0.5822126269340515,
0.8400208353996277,
-0.19943495094776154,
0.9527851939201355,
0.48600760102272034,
0.566489040851593,
-0.6777489185333252,
0.5537362694740295,
-0.5691605806350708,
0.5126737356185913,
-0.341830849647522,
-0.3505975008010864,
-0.12620088458061218,
0.6432635188102722,
-0.07198522984981537,
-0.027982337400317192,
0.6173761487007141,
0.87940913438797,
0.10842034220695496,
0.06749322265386581,
0.1913404017686844,
0.0708397924900055,
0.38163068890571594,
0.22052299976348877,
0.8829185962677002,
-0.18996961414813995,
0.7281951308250427,
-0.26010850071907043,
-0.06698974967002869,
-0.18199248611927032,
-1.070655107498169,
-0.9984311461448669,
-0.34450626373291016,
-0.4991343319416046,
-0.48017415404319763,
0.16316507756710052,
0.796463668346405,
0.28596067428588867,
-0.6854726672172546,
-0.1771264523267746,
-0.23095771670341492,
-0.2519418001174927,
-0.0452292338013649,
-0.20921801030635834,
0.3202591836452484,
-0.4297037422657013,
-0.5634920597076416,
0.5447283387184143,
-0.0021522631868720055,
0.4799805283546448,
-0.28590530157089233,
0.14492982625961304,
-0.02334725856781006,
0.31252598762512207,
0.25713956356048584,
0.20411406457424164,
-0.6432338953018188,
0.03787880763411522,
-0.06808602064847946,
-0.29835882782936096,
0.2664373517036438,
1.1224052906036377,
-0.7239949107170105,
0.47848716378211975,
0.3935430943965912,
0.6671526432037354,
0.2822202146053314,
0.18948666751384735,
0.7198621034622192,
-0.9697057008743286,
0.11689775437116623,
0.6274204254150391,
0.42784756422042847,
0.8305292725563049,
-0.13866151869297028,
0.22147947549819946,
0.4103805124759674,
-0.3507750630378723,
-0.7262925505638123,
0.18051785230636597,
-0.6534430384635925,
-0.7179006338119507,
1.0843359231948853,
-0.4315947890281677,
0.004242732655256987,
-0.09162046015262604,
-0.3628872036933899,
0.13947728276252747,
-0.3130108416080475,
1.1974281072616577,
0.3103249669075012,
0.14084352552890778,
-0.3810243308544159,
0.15131567418575287,
0.6401689648628235,
0.6157424449920654,
-0.7403421401977539,
0.28411486744880676,
0.4095643162727356,
0.5824241042137146,
0.011941790580749512,
0.6736776828765869,
-0.36108866333961487,
0.11561164259910583,
0.3539809584617615,
0.21049576997756958,
-0.41088658571243286,
0.03040352649986744,
-0.6794335246086121,
0.3212374448776245,
0.04195917025208473,
-0.23354093730449677
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00832v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00832v2
|
BoNBoN Alignment for Large Language Models and the Sweetness of Best-of-n Sampling
| 2024-06-02T18:42:57 | 2024-06-05T05:23:40 |
Lin Gui, Cristina Gârbacea, Victor Veitch
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
This paper concerns the problem of aligning samples from large language
models to human preferences using best-of-$n$ sampling, where we draw $n$
samples, rank them, and return the best one. We consider two fundamental
problems. First: what is the relationship between best-of-$n$ and approaches to
alignment that train LLMs to output samples with a high expected reward (e.g.,
RLHF or DPO)? To answer this, we embed both the best-of-$n$ distribution and
the sampling distributions learned by alignment procedures in a common class of
tiltings of the base LLM distribution. We then show that, within this class,
best-of-$n$ is essentially optimal in terms of the trade-off between win-rate
against the base model vs KL distance from the base model. That is, best-of-$n$
is the best choice of alignment distribution if the goal is to maximize win
rate. However, best-of-$n$ requires drawing $n$ samples for each inference, a
substantial cost. To avoid this, the second problem we consider is how to
fine-tune a LLM to mimic the best-of-$n$ sampling distribution. We derive
BoNBoN Alignment to achieve this by exploiting the special structure of the
best-of-$n$ distribution. Experiments show that BoNBoN alignment yields
substantial improvements in producing a model that is preferred to the base
policy while minimally affecting off-target aspects.
|
[
-0.4324849545955658,
-0.27578291296958923,
0.2882770597934723,
0.3551412522792816,
-0.15848363935947418,
0.03598850220441818,
-0.433199018239975,
-0.44607090950012207,
0.3755052983760834,
0.475890189409256,
-0.33388248085975647,
-0.3954703211784363,
-0.5299382209777832,
-0.00295269931666553,
-0.27545392513275146,
1.167757272720337,
0.08590341359376907,
0.07945464551448822,
-0.1746898889541626,
0.07974863052368164,
-0.1815476417541504,
-0.3989122211933136,
-0.4818534255027771,
-0.3480958938598633,
0.606630802154541,
0.3107181787490845,
0.7055650949478149,
0.9716659784317017,
0.8015101552009583,
0.206363245844841,
-0.07615499943494797,
-0.028750304132699966,
-0.9125217199325562,
0.0872163474559784,
-0.11846502870321274,
-0.6358110904693604,
-0.589036226272583,
-0.1796932965517044,
0.4882924258708954,
0.6696341633796692,
-0.2027609646320343,
-0.1709519326686859,
0.08576643466949463,
0.7216014266014099,
-0.5549070239067078,
-0.023943975567817688,
-0.6437320113182068,
-0.32680028676986694,
-0.5795527100563049,
-0.5928477644920349,
-0.36858123540878296,
-0.7079769372940063,
0.07722951471805573,
-0.4081139862537384,
0.20326220989227295,
0.1456884741783142,
1.143399953842163,
0.2818547189235687,
-0.4082096815109253,
-0.19950224459171295,
-0.5711281895637512,
1.0516618490219116,
-0.738706111907959,
0.3246069848537445,
0.20206710696220398,
0.536933958530426,
-0.6086995005607605,
0.08379485458135605,
-0.45078620314598083,
0.1373567283153534,
0.3832313120365143,
0.13667187094688416,
0.15535256266593933,
0.05630682781338692,
-0.08265448361635208,
0.5247199535369873,
-0.5832552313804626,
0.6175144910812378,
-0.23032350838184357,
-0.20011213421821594,
0.9870075583457947,
0.08870317041873932,
-0.0008061061962507665,
0.0029209484346210957,
-0.7225010991096497,
-0.2969519793987274,
-0.9143706560134888,
0.16586904227733612,
0.8996149897575378,
0.45098525285720825,
0.03858571499586105,
0.5853146910667419,
-0.11601676791906357,
1.0456641912460327,
0.3425033986568451,
-0.5016149282455444,
0.05078183487057686,
-0.3009023070335388,
-0.16324999928474426,
0.2478805035352707,
0.8294769525527954,
0.7367259860038757,
0.39513617753982544,
-0.020302316173911095,
-0.43790555000305176,
0.0012786532752215862,
-0.04346911609172821,
-0.4955851137638092,
-0.40739694237709045,
0.20302338898181915,
-0.1773516833782196,
-0.6515406966209412,
-0.003538918448612094,
-0.9607131481170654,
-0.3711683452129364,
-0.36681967973709106,
0.1912117898464203,
-0.21899303793907166,
-0.045053862035274506,
0.26775458455085754,
-0.008358782157301903,
0.4889642000198364,
0.2968154549598694,
-1.6127197742462158,
0.23555819690227509,
0.8170852065086365,
0.612808346748352,
-0.34644049406051636,
-0.055597878992557526,
-0.5348853468894958,
0.21469712257385254,
-0.4810815155506134,
0.9451035857200623,
-0.47083762288093567,
-0.17116956412792206,
-0.11764031648635864,
-0.3024453818798065,
0.05804099887609482,
-0.5748889446258545,
0.5454559326171875,
-0.5038838982582092,
0.08170214295387268,
-0.5425404906272888,
-0.8548960089683533,
0.08968266099691391,
0.2632844150066376,
-0.6256819367408752,
0.8812558054924011,
-0.07758578658103943,
-0.7131586074829102,
0.4486699104309082,
-0.4485434293746948,
-0.23949965834617615,
-0.22290340065956116,
-0.32692667841911316,
-0.16588285565376282,
-0.023820193484425545,
0.3051941990852356,
0.39474573731422424,
-0.21133825182914734,
0.20484061539173126,
-0.5373808145523071,
-0.3339882493019104,
0.31698548793792725,
-0.37707871198654175,
1.207342267036438,
0.2599636912345886,
-0.31550097465515137,
0.03587725758552551,
-0.4244016706943512,
-0.22711916267871857,
0.20828552544116974,
-0.601970374584198,
-0.14960694313049316,
-0.06976323574781418,
0.045210547745227814,
-0.20344635844230652,
0.3040885329246521,
-0.5407423377037048,
0.7029717564582825,
-0.7148624062538147,
0.36049309372901917,
1.1280204057693481,
-0.08434225618839264,
0.6597963571548462,
-0.4974484443664551,
0.5299342274665833,
-0.12705887854099274,
0.21429090201854706,
0.31196609139442444,
-0.39335137605667114,
-0.2251652628183365,
-0.3435305058956146,
0.8608434796333313,
0.4035663604736328,
-0.12330740690231323,
0.7024520635604858,
-0.40661731362342834,
-0.32978299260139465,
-0.5782176852226257,
0.2918466329574585,
0.16034287214279175,
0.4715088903903961,
0.12330174446105957,
-0.3521628975868225,
-0.3965918719768524,
-1.0774896144866943,
0.07172861695289612,
-0.0716172307729721,
0.34229427576065063,
-0.08049292117357254,
-0.06860829889774323,
0.15623308718204498,
1.0043143033981323,
-0.4123518168926239,
-0.2804003953933716,
-0.17358148097991943,
-0.10191978514194489,
0.11922932416200638,
0.5444898009300232,
0.899570882320404,
-0.7314212918281555,
-0.45309802889823914,
0.009392092004418373,
-0.14346933364868164,
-0.30064210295677185,
-0.03896129131317139,
-0.7433137893676758,
0.47739550471305847,
0.14169035851955414,
-0.38442328572273254,
0.29870104789733887,
0.6760828495025635,
0.24314045906066895,
0.3834216892719269,
0.11248385906219482,
0.03272304683923721,
-1.182769536972046,
-0.08026891946792603,
-0.04004829749464989,
-0.3808116614818573,
-0.49106135964393616,
0.01388603262603283,
-0.0871933251619339,
0.44477149844169617,
-0.12621423602104187,
0.45068806409835815,
-0.45565065741539,
-0.30203938484191895,
-0.3253188133239746,
0.4714968204498291,
0.13247054815292358,
0.38597264885902405,
-0.05356907844543457,
0.44560423493385315,
0.4591783881187439,
-0.6789129376411438,
0.5228530168533325,
0.392734169960022,
-0.423111230134964,
0.614485502243042,
-0.3855048418045044,
-0.015998803079128265,
-0.20878860354423523,
0.4671994149684906,
-1.4479806423187256,
-0.2622429430484772,
0.24227017164230347,
-0.4676477611064911,
0.6141000390052795,
0.02997831255197525,
-0.3178679347038269,
-0.06923157721757889,
-0.29293951392173767,
0.469402015209198,
0.5658591389656067,
-0.637931227684021,
0.05848017707467079,
0.5722787380218506,
-0.10152389109134674,
-1.2041380405426025,
-0.7127913236618042,
-0.1456485241651535,
-0.39308860898017883,
-0.3596109449863434,
0.48802101612091064,
-0.01627880148589611,
-0.12816809117794037,
-0.20159024000167847,
-0.2104712575674057,
0.3880839943885803,
-0.039567865431308746,
-0.09339489787817001,
0.3279566466808319,
-0.18182231485843658,
-0.0896298810839653,
-0.1770278960466385,
-0.22971361875534058,
-0.38374635577201843,
-0.3491787016391754,
0.7290474772453308,
0.06453162431716919,
-0.5030947327613831,
-0.34885475039482117,
0.1416209489107132,
0.3336227834224701,
-0.27156391739845276,
0.4081614315509796,
0.27409130334854126,
-0.33935630321502686,
0.10234438627958298,
-0.5615445375442505,
-0.04777469485998154,
-0.39753857254981995,
0.1505638211965561,
-0.3492904007434845,
-0.4312659502029419,
0.37837687134742737,
0.19375433027744293,
0.6395017504692078,
0.3895221948623657,
0.8103234767913818,
-0.3162735402584076,
1.1547640562057495,
0.6940680146217346,
-0.4652640223503113,
0.5005378723144531,
-0.20397186279296875,
0.4079165756702423,
-0.7966575026512146,
-0.07453111559152603,
-0.5909216403961182,
-0.9181795716285706,
-0.452042818069458,
-0.2292676568031311,
0.09343321621417999,
0.4646760821342468,
0.021721698343753815,
0.540945827960968,
-0.5427036285400391,
0.47037070989608765,
0.6825475096702576,
-0.09472821652889252,
0.21821355819702148,
0.10765983909368515,
-0.1661192774772644,
-0.11932232975959778,
-0.7491835951805115,
-0.6488481760025024,
1.1318033933639526,
0.14411163330078125,
0.9091350436210632,
0.47217050194740295,
1.2703851461410522,
-0.331554651260376,
0.32645753026008606,
-0.9049421548843384,
0.47590896487236023,
0.008738934062421322,
-0.6165135502815247,
-0.42710405588150024,
-0.4301460385322571,
-1.2206798791885376,
-0.03322240337729454,
-0.11231821030378342,
-0.8665168285369873,
0.34256961941719055,
0.5311467051506042,
-0.4058676064014435,
0.40505334734916687,
-0.41332823038101196,
0.8853042125701904,
-0.5906370878219604,
-0.18194958567619324,
0.17588479816913605,
-0.8152207136154175,
0.6810965538024902,
0.1939184069633484,
0.02534853108227253,
-0.16807137429714203,
-0.005239174701273441,
0.5264363884925842,
-0.17028272151947021,
0.5246129035949707,
-0.13540437817573547,
-0.4120277762413025,
0.1349160224199295,
0.14757400751113892,
0.5195585489273071,
-0.31111693382263184,
-0.12967561185359955,
-0.09188959747552872,
0.2585110366344452,
-0.6579399108886719,
-0.7143648266792297,
0.7482127547264099,
-0.6917067170143127,
-0.6588189005851746,
-0.32806408405303955,
-0.7449015974998474,
-0.15618428587913513,
0.038459938019514084,
0.4770742654800415,
0.6894934773445129,
-0.06352594494819641,
0.29630419611930847,
0.5439304709434509,
-0.041405089199543,
0.22056972980499268,
-0.16015581786632538,
-0.6204089522361755,
-0.2618550956249237,
1.0549520254135132,
0.016496071591973305,
0.7216820120811462,
0.8300600051879883,
0.32670608162879944,
-0.8017536401748657,
-0.6176022887229919,
-0.6117696762084961,
0.29475167393684387,
-0.7718145847320557,
-0.18658241629600525,
-0.4260014295578003,
0.11065723747015,
-0.550735592842102,
-0.2528742551803589,
-0.29141682386398315,
-0.49063026905059814,
-0.2476235330104828,
-0.031090134754776955,
0.26785582304000854,
0.4841122329235077,
-0.20952832698822021,
0.0720117837190628,
-0.4422816336154938,
0.04468517005443573,
-0.022602921351790428,
0.1918320506811142,
-0.051825616508722305,
-0.5183512568473816,
0.2130110263824463,
0.07914314419031143,
-0.40537312626838684,
-0.9668394327163696,
0.09300681203603745,
0.007078306749463081,
0.6321500539779663,
0.7554402351379395,
0.17166762053966522,
0.874613881111145,
-0.3248020112514496,
0.5859497785568237,
0.3142101466655731,
-0.418561726808548,
0.09513560682535172,
-0.3797617256641388,
-0.0817534327507019,
0.8289459943771362,
0.5757327675819397,
-0.4176480770111084,
-0.40572816133499146,
-0.576729416847229,
-0.6921746730804443,
0.2904817759990692,
0.020159266889095306,
-0.10918183624744415,
-0.06012186408042908,
0.17608298361301422,
0.28039267659187317,
0.10164076834917068,
-0.48400768637657166,
-0.1641261875629425,
-0.09481222927570343,
-0.830193281173706,
-0.22283922135829926,
0.13465456664562225,
-0.4120461344718933,
-0.009986366145312786,
0.7650334239006042,
-0.24107709527015686,
0.33050259947776794,
-0.14130395650863647,
0.003115515224635601,
-0.2188979685306549,
0.07170797884464264,
0.8734703063964844,
0.8333582878112793,
-0.3542134165763855,
0.2147866189479828,
-0.24775443971157074,
-0.04885530844330788,
0.17803284525871277,
-0.16540905833244324,
-0.16570258140563965,
-0.27088841795921326,
0.040103260427713394,
0.8413493037223816,
0.3700752556324005,
-0.5169225335121155,
0.48061010241508484,
0.28114157915115356,
-0.3169836699962616,
0.10967512428760529,
0.22186321020126343,
0.47336962819099426,
0.2359115332365036,
0.056983832269907,
0.06369929015636444,
-0.02962932363152504,
-0.46430715918540955,
0.21193523705005646,
0.846764326095581,
-0.11435577273368835,
-0.08717997372150421,
0.702369749546051,
-0.04655902832746506,
-0.5097630620002747,
0.38199859857559204,
-0.17736048996448517,
-0.5608760714530945,
0.5335015058517456,
0.5749332904815674,
0.45462000370025635,
-0.16143663227558136,
0.07439444959163666,
0.28609609603881836,
0.10220148414373398,
-0.17251038551330566,
0.2160203903913498,
0.042834166437387466,
-0.7201605439186096,
-0.23676861822605133,
-0.7527121901512146,
-0.3850720524787903,
-0.07710517197847366,
-0.7486414909362793,
0.4371037483215332,
-0.36931490898132324,
-0.12283831834793091,
0.06477463245391846,
-0.057667311280965805,
-0.4553626775741577,
-0.13759203255176544,
0.10128214210271835,
0.7215734720230103,
-0.5693713426589966,
0.6663448214530945,
0.47622954845428467,
-0.17303720116615295,
-0.8556894659996033,
0.034813523292541504,
0.33295008540153503,
-0.9544124603271484,
0.5874666571617126,
-0.05857608839869499,
-0.06622545421123505,
0.3010595142841339,
-0.5583596229553223,
-1.1004273891448975,
1.0008633136749268,
0.6002060174942017,
-0.8071330785751343,
0.057284217327833176,
-0.16700659692287445,
0.2800449728965759,
-0.33184751868247986,
0.08806838095188141,
0.49206820130348206,
0.42608997225761414,
0.3239661157131195,
-0.9075711369514465,
-0.27836161851882935,
0.18896667659282684,
-0.14000235497951508,
0.6371915936470032,
-0.7626965641975403,
0.5495948195457458,
-0.18340030312538147,
-0.21188974380493164,
0.2106003761291504,
0.6265897154808044,
0.6095210909843445,
-0.1596374660730362,
0.7345752120018005,
0.588220477104187,
0.9734339118003845,
-0.17984773218631744,
1.038029432296753,
-0.32287487387657166,
0.4346808195114136,
0.9673079252243042,
-0.33384063839912415,
0.9655453562736511,
0.6356868147850037,
-0.3433164358139038,
0.2613236606121063,
1.084764838218689,
0.13079769909381866,
0.5387448668479919,
0.3720305562019348,
-0.009322226978838444,
-0.1696358323097229,
0.1050393283367157,
-0.3342917561531067,
0.41611814498901367,
0.014601354487240314,
-0.01354652363806963,
-0.3894461989402771,
-0.35757237672805786,
-0.26471245288848877,
0.12205252051353455,
-0.031470924615859985,
0.6473098993301392,
-0.06580460071563721,
-0.7264365553855896,
0.8387792706489563,
-0.04666587710380554,
0.7552220821380615,
-0.36574167013168335,
0.2152780294418335,
-0.23343335092067719,
0.19147343933582306,
-0.2936883568763733,
-0.8018773794174194,
-0.01249403040856123,
-0.1581336110830307,
-0.024281524121761322,
-0.04959668964147568,
0.27951064705848694,
-0.77190101146698,
-0.35273435711860657,
0.015355299226939678,
-0.005550185218453407,
0.6403910517692566,
0.45029619336128235,
-0.7303180694580078,
0.04957722872495651,
0.05676749721169472,
-0.35409069061279297,
0.5808863639831543,
0.1732340306043625,
-0.14013449847698212,
0.3624781668186188,
0.5836275219917297,
0.3212406039237976,
0.4072681665420532,
0.13393637537956238,
0.28884440660476685,
-0.42169812321662903,
-0.5840028524398804,
-0.8701508641242981,
0.27346840500831604,
0.00239114323630929,
-0.28433504700660706,
0.41850408911705017,
0.4748288691043854,
0.8483499884605408,
0.18416304886341095,
0.6555556654930115,
0.005522225983440876,
0.3179306387901306,
-0.6466789245605469,
0.16874362528324127,
-0.7086767554283142,
-0.01199094858020544,
-0.23271898925304413,
-1.3178595304489136,
-0.3078826069831848,
0.8215593695640564,
-0.3652137517929077,
-0.024564102292060852,
0.4344537854194641,
0.9254351854324341,
-0.2008022665977478,
0.035758499056100845,
0.1312384009361267,
-0.2114807367324829,
0.44930827617645264,
1.0187016725540161,
0.6891418695449829,
-0.3362136781215668,
0.3933834135532379,
-0.29613426327705383,
-0.32944154739379883,
-0.559568464756012,
-1.0437685251235962,
-0.563736617565155,
-0.5076964497566223,
-0.15243978798389435,
-0.22677011787891388,
-0.36874040961265564,
1.2581206560134888,
0.5921574831008911,
-0.8489474058151245,
-0.3511207103729248,
0.0248105488717556,
-0.040854744613170624,
-0.4596637487411499,
-0.21874237060546875,
0.2948759198188782,
-0.3661632537841797,
-1.1598615646362305,
0.1850830316543579,
0.3072495758533478,
0.27431732416152954,
-0.40061137080192566,
-0.23258067667484283,
-0.48794540762901306,
-0.07492896914482117,
0.13444744050502777,
0.42175278067588806,
-0.8777363896369934,
-0.43587979674339294,
0.2097337245941162,
-0.438776433467865,
0.3843226432800293,
0.6285529732704163,
-0.1278199553489685,
0.5059745907783508,
0.5432218313217163,
1.1361830234527588,
0.293666273355484,
0.5929048657417297,
0.8279767632484436,
-0.5958764553070068,
-0.06927530467510223,
0.13850024342536926,
0.3227103352546692,
0.4190713167190552,
-0.4597032964229584,
0.3436785638332367,
0.028720393776893616,
-0.816673994064331,
-1.109270691871643,
0.4689917266368866,
-1.2503511905670166,
0.13645599782466888,
1.082789421081543,
0.18454492092132568,
-0.41189801692962646,
0.0575668029487133,
-0.3835323750972748,
0.37744593620300293,
-0.13068784773349762,
0.7050012946128845,
1.0334311723709106,
-0.45748773217201233,
-0.05518684536218643,
-0.5049051642417908,
0.4656660556793213,
0.7317941784858704,
-0.42767906188964844,
0.08549647033214569,
0.259827584028244,
0.3426724970340729,
0.24758949875831604,
0.6529353857040405,
-0.22633495926856995,
-0.11316584795713425,
-0.4754338562488556,
0.18884706497192383,
0.18315909802913666,
-0.36653316020965576,
-0.4287085235118866,
-0.03354785963892937,
0.30383220314979553,
-0.32149189710617065
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16903v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16903v1
|
Towards a copilot in BIM authoring tool using a large language model-based agent for intelligent human-machine interaction
| 2024-06-02T17:47:57 | 2024-06-02T17:47:57 |
Changyu Du, Stavros Nousias, André Borrmann
|
cs.HC
|
cs.HC, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Facing increasingly complex BIM authoring software and the accompanying
expensive learning costs, designers often seek to interact with the software in
a more intelligent and lightweight manner. They aim to automate modeling
workflows, avoiding obstacles and difficulties caused by software usage,
thereby focusing on the design process itself. To address this issue, we
proposed an LLM-based autonomous agent framework that can function as a copilot
in the BIM authoring tool, answering software usage questions, understanding
the user's design intentions from natural language, and autonomously executing
modeling tasks by invoking the appropriate tools. In a case study based on the
BIM authoring software Vectorworks, we implemented a software prototype to
integrate the proposed framework seamlessly into the BIM authoring scenario. We
evaluated the planning and reasoning capabilities of different LLMs within this
framework when faced with complex instructions. Our work demonstrates the
significant potential of LLM-based agents in design automation and intelligent
interaction.
|
[
-0.4417949914932251,
-0.7245967388153076,
0.8841925859451294,
0.20161955058574677,
-0.4242348372936249,
0.4142081141471863,
0.18620438873767853,
-0.6995129585266113,
0.26720190048217773,
0.48764094710350037,
-0.6003692746162415,
-0.4313317835330963,
-0.024378396570682526,
-0.008233383297920227,
-0.10746908187866211,
0.33932602405548096,
-0.2784980535507202,
0.15547898411750793,
-0.4008852541446686,
0.3156607151031494,
-0.4771919846534729,
-0.608161985874176,
-0.505653440952301,
-0.5258278250694275,
0.7394527196884155,
0.3573719263076782,
0.7892451286315918,
0.42665261030197144,
0.3091371953487396,
0.35174858570098877,
0.2683413624763489,
0.38567033410072327,
0.10354392975568771,
-0.032948337495326996,
-0.5348687767982483,
-0.5379047989845276,
-1.039976716041565,
0.07702678442001343,
0.1970420628786087,
0.5438856482505798,
0.24128051102161407,
0.053267646580934525,
0.13332654535770416,
0.4562705159187317,
-0.13349653780460358,
0.48787838220596313,
-0.2085917890071869,
-0.17278510332107544,
0.0203449334949255,
-0.4128386080265045,
-0.28271573781967163,
0.0390281081199646,
-0.14315977692604065,
-0.6093950271606445,
-0.25277459621429443,
0.37962913513183594,
0.5730593800544739,
0.5577778220176697,
-0.32294440269470215,
-0.48319265246391296,
-0.8052353858947754,
0.43788185715675354,
-0.7759357690811157,
0.2918621003627777,
0.2364492267370224,
0.2603232264518738,
-0.5408204793930054,
-0.4303324520587921,
-0.44457295536994934,
-0.22725452482700348,
-0.14099879562854767,
0.2045384645462036,
0.20821811258792877,
0.18753990530967712,
0.04301717132329941,
0.02522624470293522,
-0.6368659734725952,
0.24441955983638763,
-0.1846250295639038,
-0.2681288719177246,
0.9413231611251831,
0.3406544625759125,
0.3928830325603485,
-0.04311325401067734,
-0.7167914509773254,
0.18401099741458893,
-0.4840935170650482,
0.19172023236751556,
0.633898138999939,
0.28642162680625916,
-0.22362825274467468,
0.631726086139679,
-0.11409111320972443,
0.7117373943328857,
-0.21695241332054138,
0.08571094274520874,
0.09439735114574432,
-0.013122119009494781,
-0.26792338490486145,
-0.013685453683137894,
0.6835670471191406,
0.1295405775308609,
0.33242368698120117,
-0.39939993619918823,
-0.4872209131717682,
-0.18910950422286987,
0.31630179286003113,
-0.5461427569389343,
-0.20614850521087646,
0.5251761674880981,
-0.19881515204906464,
-0.34080907702445984,
0.32060128450393677,
-0.30438485741615295,
-0.7198055386543274,
-0.835406482219696,
0.4322865903377533,
-0.1085214838385582,
-0.33315709233283997,
0.17700903117656708,
-0.11717280745506287,
0.5268918871879578,
0.4438392221927643,
-0.19218289852142334,
0.05746692046523094,
0.6684594750404358,
0.5872237682342529,
-0.1980120986700058,
-0.417683869600296,
-0.7821943163871765,
0.4360198974609375,
-0.541044294834137,
1.091383934020996,
-0.22499918937683105,
-0.5962055325508118,
-0.4369159936904907,
0.10962831228971481,
0.11849778890609741,
-0.25630617141723633,
0.5095563530921936,
-0.5360519886016846,
-0.08016462624073029,
0.05978187918663025,
-0.29778730869293213,
-0.3703606426715851,
0.29552409052848816,
-0.6322586536407471,
0.569123387336731,
0.16125960648059845,
-0.49115484952926636,
0.06786326318979263,
-0.7829612493515015,
-0.511582612991333,
0.6302079558372498,
-0.556414008140564,
-0.32679879665374756,
-0.1290634274482727,
-0.16349869966506958,
0.4870980978012085,
-0.36393025517463684,
0.5297240018844604,
-0.4517468810081482,
-0.3010540306568146,
0.25573721528053284,
-0.22129976749420166,
1.0620723962783813,
0.16442829370498657,
-0.42504966259002686,
0.4971838891506195,
-0.6628416776657104,
-0.03685852512717247,
0.17219963669776917,
-0.5713567137718201,
0.035015564411878586,
0.16130778193473816,
0.11079538613557816,
0.29479601979255676,
0.5226383209228516,
-0.5940403342247009,
0.35767388343811035,
-0.4587082266807556,
0.029739798977971077,
0.8172167539596558,
0.013886119239032269,
0.6948097944259644,
-0.7942768931388855,
0.6820780038833618,
-0.478380024433136,
0.07365120947360992,
0.2531295120716095,
-0.4266984462738037,
-0.6240425705909729,
-0.6411603093147278,
0.0033077618572860956,
0.6883605122566223,
-0.7127623558044434,
0.5449870824813843,
-0.08190492540597916,
-0.6976380944252014,
-0.28171637654304504,
0.48556503653526306,
0.17060892283916473,
0.28775838017463684,
-0.1401067078113556,
-0.07979492098093033,
-0.46094685792922974,
-0.8774986267089844,
-0.009861246682703495,
-0.3730526864528656,
-0.3421417474746704,
0.33564165234565735,
0.40313324332237244,
-0.4364439845085144,
1.252191424369812,
-0.23565791547298431,
-0.3499930500984192,
-0.3915991485118866,
0.3120848834514618,
0.05370422452688217,
0.39771148562431335,
0.6973881125450134,
-0.9250871539115906,
-0.4485919177532196,
0.0006196661270223558,
-0.715341329574585,
-0.3921426236629486,
-0.3929063379764557,
-0.5184865593910217,
0.36687520146369934,
0.6217595934867859,
-0.7190317511558533,
0.5395703315734863,
0.1442217379808426,
-0.3246684670448303,
0.6949394345283508,
-0.2340800017118454,
-0.33648309111595154,
-0.9846006035804749,
0.16730114817619324,
-0.5996980667114258,
-0.16919346153736115,
-0.4562881886959076,
-0.1402488648891449,
-0.02528420276939869,
-0.10347529500722885,
-0.7169655561447144,
0.9733926653862,
-0.7505835890769958,
-0.19809333980083466,
-0.6573574542999268,
0.16116733849048615,
0.37814825773239136,
0.8231990337371826,
0.3348401188850403,
0.5079931616783142,
0.44577017426490784,
-0.5508758425712585,
0.6035555005073547,
0.1524672955274582,
-0.2460038810968399,
0.5079778432846069,
-0.6319101452827454,
0.33165237307548523,
-0.001212672796100378,
-0.015754198655486107,
-0.732903242111206,
-0.14026620984077454,
0.7111020088195801,
-0.34053468704223633,
0.09520958364009857,
-0.11405112594366074,
-1.0272436141967773,
-0.3231513202190399,
-0.17140980064868927,
-0.072061687707901,
-0.005913513246923685,
-0.4168330729007721,
1.4300309419631958,
0.25739389657974243,
-0.5197064280509949,
-0.012719763442873955,
-0.5189509987831116,
0.12480811774730682,
0.07025463134050369,
-0.827890157699585,
0.22377701103687286,
-0.6387345790863037,
-0.4812479317188263,
-0.04280936345458031,
0.17349818348884583,
0.10928429663181305,
0.3759203851222992,
0.3889462649822235,
0.5886190533638,
0.1490326225757599,
0.20182622969150543,
-0.08414672315120697,
-0.2675575315952301,
0.3025531470775604,
-0.06632409989833832,
0.48043736815452576,
-0.32511618733406067,
-0.5928318500518799,
-0.3946644961833954,
0.470718115568161,
0.8862660527229309,
-0.5510863661766052,
0.31228217482566833,
0.3065135180950165,
-0.294222891330719,
-0.32119467854499817,
-0.23854461312294006,
0.06350885331630707,
-0.5576739311218262,
0.20088867843151093,
-0.6711717844009399,
-0.1876947581768036,
0.5585647821426392,
-0.2930491268634796,
0.5128175616264343,
-0.08117220550775528,
0.8325238227844238,
-0.431892991065979,
0.9132475852966309,
0.6710835695266724,
-0.0318274199962616,
0.4566391110420227,
-0.27375879883766174,
0.1806810349225998,
-0.7345799803733826,
-0.22404493391513824,
-0.17795859277248383,
-0.3947749435901642,
-0.18891802430152893,
-0.42838916182518005,
0.1391792595386505,
-0.07132182270288467,
-0.13505229353904724,
0.19045087695121765,
-0.5154906511306763,
0.016437426209449768,
0.7060121893882751,
-0.018990740180015564,
0.3689376711845398,
-0.4478282332420349,
-0.14369569718837738,
0.667482316493988,
-0.8011979460716248,
-0.8595423102378845,
0.6140847206115723,
0.07901972532272339,
0.9050991535186768,
0.2140895277261734,
0.5443528890609741,
0.2712295651435852,
0.4899342656135559,
-0.9988548755645752,
0.6524096131324768,
0.6815729737281799,
-0.7411195635795593,
-0.4571969211101532,
0.12249583005905151,
-0.8849682807922363,
0.1550913006067276,
-0.3209039866924286,
-0.42664313316345215,
0.3894699513912201,
0.08165957778692245,
-0.2124473601579666,
0.48777446150779724,
-0.7380833029747009,
0.6932138800621033,
-1.007599115371704,
-0.44752293825149536,
0.0696239098906517,
-0.5671246647834778,
-0.00037086009979248047,
-0.15745215117931366,
0.5809022784233093,
-0.3069438636302948,
-0.2547955811023712,
0.2644999623298645,
-0.36365529894828796,
0.8375458717346191,
0.011945603415369987,
-0.359779953956604,
0.5983568429946899,
0.3402206003665924,
0.7146508097648621,
-0.11555227637290955,
-0.31211915612220764,
-0.008602543734014034,
-0.03553498908877373,
-0.39894866943359375,
-0.6025647521018982,
0.373281866312027,
-0.6326476335525513,
-0.8543673157691956,
-0.3490734398365021,
-0.8821407556533813,
-0.18180370330810547,
0.26106366515159607,
0.02475780062377453,
0.31275418400764465,
-0.3015875518321991,
-0.007550278212875128,
0.10137512534856796,
-0.1502869874238968,
0.49371203780174255,
0.7342554926872253,
-0.25219595432281494,
-0.08940385282039642,
0.961545467376709,
0.07556235045194626,
0.11915133148431778,
0.4479122459888458,
0.2209174782037735,
0.006277610547840595,
-0.38300415873527527,
-0.5991981029510498,
0.05233287811279297,
-0.3442317545413971,
-0.1070840135216713,
-0.4207763075828552,
-0.26078903675079346,
-0.19826413691043854,
-0.6894711852073669,
-0.07228617370128632,
-0.11652931571006775,
-0.19161731004714966,
-0.05933684483170509,
0.14997045695781708,
0.7534396052360535,
0.07096733897924423,
0.006152378860861063,
-0.601999819278717,
0.26381510496139526,
0.35715073347091675,
0.3709413707256317,
0.0011822382220998406,
0.020640654489398003,
-0.3298412561416626,
-0.046998944133520126,
-0.18491174280643463,
-0.5956435203552246,
0.22294682264328003,
-0.32579126954078674,
0.9122563600540161,
0.46499335765838623,
0.5100216269493103,
-0.17268137633800507,
-0.2365291565656662,
0.20733040571212769,
-0.2548983097076416,
-0.5117194056510925,
0.363969624042511,
-0.573378324508667,
0.3479502499103546,
0.005899763200432062,
0.06821335852146149,
-0.2110612839460373,
-0.586184561252594,
-0.5062362551689148,
-0.7212545871734619,
0.5806739330291748,
0.09472782909870148,
-0.24892032146453857,
0.37424954771995544,
0.1618669182062149,
0.04819905385375023,
0.19790518283843994,
-0.6094352602958679,
0.09931551665067673,
-0.06507882475852966,
-0.2667083442211151,
-0.04517567902803421,
-0.11024253070354462,
-0.20007175207138062,
0.011873731389641762,
0.8715859055519104,
-0.24315015971660614,
0.1749556064605713,
0.13784612715244293,
-0.2517988979816437,
0.028750786557793617,
0.31295886635780334,
0.44822603464126587,
0.6345758438110352,
-0.16678528487682343,
0.127557173371315,
-0.11250738799571991,
-0.1524599939584732,
0.005834655370563269,
0.3442935049533844,
-0.3766992688179016,
-0.3120265603065491,
0.2444574534893036,
0.2721286118030548,
0.0008763980004005134,
-1.0300016403198242,
0.33507078886032104,
0.12610770761966705,
-0.2123718410730362,
-0.5642014741897583,
0.15365800261497498,
0.5871902704238892,
0.6084046363830566,
0.2879627048969269,
-0.11345693469047546,
0.06594482809305191,
-0.432414174079895,
-0.1024448424577713,
0.6101637482643127,
-0.17246080935001373,
-0.25938165187835693,
0.8222138285636902,
0.6934072971343994,
-1.0380772352218628,
0.1431596279144287,
-0.3143695592880249,
-0.58350670337677,
0.8434486389160156,
0.006580422166734934,
0.9354296326637268,
0.13628822565078735,
-0.04746989905834198,
-0.2183542102575302,
0.43546438217163086,
0.6364219784736633,
0.5322697758674622,
-0.2889874279499054,
-0.624722421169281,
-0.20475919544696808,
-0.3574049174785614,
-0.7688953876495361,
-0.2224266231060028,
0.03579428791999817,
0.5424814224243164,
-0.5447279214859009,
0.0032080758828669786,
-0.13638600707054138,
0.27415502071380615,
-0.6270838379859924,
0.007049626670777798,
0.22787927091121674,
0.7073255181312561,
-0.2851346731185913,
0.7552022337913513,
1.143651008605957,
-0.5444492101669312,
-0.7126120924949646,
-0.23982079327106476,
0.26517075300216675,
-0.4141583740711212,
0.5127667784690857,
-0.0148509806022048,
-0.7695001363754272,
0.0973147600889206,
-0.5235632061958313,
-0.4657934010028839,
1.3392360210418701,
0.45795756578445435,
-0.34194323420524597,
-0.0006119858007878065,
0.3334295153617859,
0.346144437789917,
-0.4730854332447052,
-0.32858502864837646,
-0.10180584341287613,
0.5673046112060547,
0.058750420808792114,
-0.6292560696601868,
-0.06365706771612167,
-0.5132988095283508,
-0.32901087403297424,
-0.10288939625024796,
-0.873885989189148,
0.6332321166992188,
-0.13249389827251434,
-0.20706184208393097,
0.37717828154563904,
0.5207291841506958,
0.2590656280517578,
0.37311679124832153,
0.6147476434707642,
-0.09774916619062424,
0.6993156671524048,
0.39138534665107727,
0.8760489821434021,
-0.5734291672706604,
-0.2057761251926422,
1.2666492462158203,
-0.2734615206718445,
0.48921120166778564,
0.3987022340297699,
0.18167972564697266,
0.5014558434486389,
0.5255394577980042,
0.06572099030017853,
0.018800241872668266,
0.1102190688252449,
-0.3871975541114807,
-0.3873075544834137,
-0.09361467510461807,
0.18302595615386963,
0.391216903924942,
0.14029361307621002,
0.12688550353050232,
-0.028469111770391464,
0.08912745118141174,
-0.02101566642522812,
0.07460310310125351,
-0.2108747959136963,
0.6498681902885437,
0.1289469599723816,
-0.3840683400630951,
0.014087161980569363,
0.08959273993968964,
0.36312103271484375,
-0.45831581950187683,
0.06830602884292603,
0.1089724749326706,
0.2519899308681488,
-0.07952564209699631,
-0.7472431659698486,
0.21902775764465332,
-0.27650535106658936,
-0.2561473250389099,
-0.5468659996986389,
0.743686318397522,
-0.2816125154495239,
-0.5783653855323792,
0.4176214039325714,
0.8554129004478455,
0.22704392671585083,
-0.24735993146896362,
-0.6969799399375916,
-0.03879762440919876,
-0.4171813130378723,
-0.23259487748146057,
0.11867400258779526,
0.6313591599464417,
-0.19661042094230652,
1.0207594633102417,
0.6756993532180786,
-0.10374455899000168,
-0.22513340413570404,
0.12709705531597137,
0.7528226971626282,
-0.3918858468532562,
-0.5619878768920898,
-0.4201941192150116,
0.5747461318969727,
0.042270477861166,
0.21975520253181458,
0.4620022475719452,
0.7579658627510071,
0.6701292395591736,
0.03862791880965233,
0.7876691818237305,
-0.03685387596487999,
0.5741072297096252,
-0.11745364964008331,
0.787521243095398,
-0.6026617288589478,
0.4463190734386444,
-0.27646467089653015,
-0.7353557348251343,
-0.062194328755140305,
0.3955390155315399,
-0.33306100964546204,
-0.12804405391216278,
0.12398721277713776,
1.016890525817871,
0.0076154014095664024,
-0.20165888965129852,
0.49617496132850647,
-0.01024912390857935,
0.6240701079368591,
0.4668143391609192,
0.6280295848846436,
0.19378414750099182,
0.8307417035102844,
-0.2503814399242401,
-0.32844287157058716,
-0.40340372920036316,
-0.8864738345146179,
-1.1667101383209229,
-0.5892663598060608,
-0.07646089047193527,
0.16687452793121338,
-0.19437508285045624,
1.144018292427063,
0.5705707669258118,
-0.302483469247818,
-0.4236791431903839,
-0.016042916104197502,
0.36568522453308105,
-0.24090690910816193,
-0.22504018247127533,
0.3086211681365967,
0.045571427792310715,
-0.9474456906318665,
0.3322625458240509,
0.5732609629631042,
0.2597072422504425,
-0.6132983565330505,
-0.5054125189781189,
-0.4134235680103302,
0.48374149203300476,
0.5122959017753601,
0.36731696128845215,
-0.5413959622383118,
-0.1948489099740982,
0.20724798738956451,
-0.32951855659484863,
0.10456515848636627,
0.7242079377174377,
-0.7072533965110779,
0.588291347026825,
0.4515746235847473,
0.6660780310630798,
0.27085235714912415,
0.10088102519512177,
0.7587231993675232,
-0.1712103635072708,
0.20806045830249786,
0.1698284149169922,
0.37523260712623596,
0.2992134690284729,
-0.6058616042137146,
0.5586414933204651,
0.16110894083976746,
-0.39947569370269775,
-0.34145164489746094,
0.36434563994407654,
-1.122338891029358,
-0.47764700651168823,
0.864779531955719,
0.1725335568189621,
-0.24687938392162323,
-0.6944666504859924,
-0.8378329873085022,
0.1591119021177292,
-0.0942687913775444,
0.6112107634544373,
0.6236161589622498,
-0.5966437458992004,
-0.03518736734986305,
-0.41355815529823303,
0.052346765995025635,
0.025400586426258087,
-0.9572802186012268,
0.12105420976877213,
0.41918861865997314,
0.10482253134250641,
0.02835480123758316,
0.6608137488365173,
0.15171124041080475,
0.489427775144577,
-0.06503403186798096,
0.5238423943519592,
-0.6657490134239197,
-0.24147260189056396,
0.34074512124061584,
-0.03640071675181389,
0.34765270352363586,
-0.15370790660381317
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10237v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10237v1
|
Towards commands recommender system in BIM authoring tool using transformers
| 2024-06-02T17:47:06 | 2024-06-02T17:47:06 |
Changyu Du, Zihan Deng, Stavros Nousias, André Borrmann
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.CE, cs.CL, cs.HC, cs.LG
|
The complexity of BIM software presents significant barriers to the
widespread adoption of BIM and model-based design within the Architecture,
Engineering, and Construction (AEC) sector. End-users frequently express
concerns regarding the additional effort required to create a sufficiently
detailed BIM model when compared with conventional 2D drafting. This study
explores the potential of sequential recommendation systems to accelerate the
BIM modeling process. By treating BIM software commands as recommendable items,
we introduce a novel end-to-end approach that predicts the next-best command
based on user historical interactions. Our framework extensively preprocesses
real-world, large-scale BIM log data, utilizes the transformer architectures
from the latest large language models as the backbone network, and ultimately
results in a prototype that provides real-time command suggestions within the
BIM authoring tool Vectorworks. Subsequent experiments validated that our
proposed model outperforms the previous study, demonstrating the immense
potential of the recommendation system in enhancing design efficiency.
|
[
-0.7889751195907593,
-0.4179079532623291,
0.6024186611175537,
0.4487422704696655,
-0.27074387669563293,
0.25238820910453796,
0.21628722548484802,
-0.3169765770435333,
0.17568270862102509,
0.47550880908966064,
-0.4806535542011261,
-0.5272631645202637,
-0.35645124316215515,
-0.027628149837255478,
-0.34142985939979553,
0.7872493863105774,
-0.20305436849594116,
0.014742434024810791,
-0.22739212214946747,
0.03292768448591232,
-0.8539669513702393,
-0.29356294870376587,
-0.6446318030357361,
-0.38436445593833923,
0.9162967801094055,
0.552913248538971,
0.9417529702186584,
0.5275478959083557,
0.5741938352584839,
0.3764289617538452,
0.023583542555570602,
0.33003923296928406,
-0.27217021584510803,
0.12695130705833435,
-0.537852942943573,
-0.3523770868778229,
-0.6590079069137573,
-0.22396327555179596,
0.219434916973114,
0.7148127555847168,
0.14573918282985687,
0.2303583323955536,
-0.03099539689719677,
0.6073535084724426,
-0.3144739270210266,
0.2308865636587143,
-0.2687915861606598,
-0.11393404752016068,
-0.13203094899654388,
-0.466361939907074,
-0.5573384165763855,
-0.12468697130680084,
0.5009234547615051,
-0.42509472370147705,
0.17589806020259857,
0.8146179914474487,
0.5152409076690674,
-0.08073241263628006,
-0.2620714604854584,
-0.2703763246536255,
-0.9352610111236572,
0.33198726177215576,
-0.6669448614120483,
0.7589680552482605,
0.26707494258880615,
0.3676309883594513,
-0.22798389196395874,
-0.8402244448661804,
-0.16200360655784607,
-0.3657802641391754,
-0.08669589459896088,
0.17308475077152252,
0.011219934560358524,
0.13216693699359894,
0.24399414658546448,
0.12983380258083344,
-0.7745780944824219,
0.30498549342155457,
-0.6332573890686035,
-0.16289500892162323,
0.3471955955028534,
0.4455066919326782,
0.14632798731327057,
-0.03301992639899254,
-0.7196829319000244,
-0.06266944110393524,
-0.649981677532196,
0.21914318203926086,
0.637601912021637,
0.12640422582626343,
0.01916383020579815,
0.5855549573898315,
-0.24575239419937134,
0.5213180184364319,
0.07051974534988403,
0.5600592494010925,
0.16698729991912842,
-0.2628319263458252,
-0.12960179150104523,
-0.02583376131951809,
0.6597534418106079,
0.5107502341270447,
0.22043441236019135,
-0.5018036961555481,
-0.2789764106273651,
-0.07288580387830734,
0.7295327186584473,
-0.7612144351005554,
-0.5070960521697998,
0.005203528329730034,
-0.5204557776451111,
-0.21474164724349976,
0.4011538326740265,
-0.4328252077102661,
-0.5501387119293213,
-0.4906086325645447,
0.09992380440235138,
-0.16314327716827393,
-0.10995081067085266,
0.09723933786153793,
-0.4328864812850952,
0.20054584741592407,
0.3484654128551483,
-0.5153911709785461,
0.10456215590238571,
0.43126216530799866,
0.8749801516532898,
-0.11624813824892044,
-0.19645404815673828,
-0.3513525128364563,
0.21119938790798187,
-0.7515701651573181,
1.0963784456253052,
-0.5676451325416565,
-1.1579161882400513,
-0.26378297805786133,
0.19525183737277985,
0.5358337163925171,
-0.4219754934310913,
0.6746714115142822,
-0.8486219048500061,
0.18450306355953217,
0.0767543613910675,
-0.2903289794921875,
-0.24290725588798523,
-0.09637241810560226,
-0.5716831088066101,
0.9113072752952576,
0.36266428232192993,
-0.5317105650901794,
0.41526275873184204,
-0.43338751792907715,
-0.5101414918899536,
0.31483766436576843,
-0.1990196257829666,
-0.5267313718795776,
0.16411559283733368,
0.056819844990968704,
0.5601772665977478,
-0.5437850952148438,
0.4449569284915924,
-0.5961963534355164,
-0.2328667789697647,
-0.38309547305107117,
-0.13046686351299286,
0.3761429190635681,
0.18126031756401062,
-0.33710092306137085,
0.6451843976974487,
-0.5799010396003723,
-0.1791309118270874,
-0.05845152586698532,
-0.18711715936660767,
-0.16091415286064148,
0.23203814029693604,
-0.06319963186979294,
0.21879366040229797,
0.24489347636699677,
-0.23131291568279266,
0.27753180265426636,
-0.6769127249717712,
-0.17112991213798523,
1.090035080909729,
0.01610971800982952,
0.8613614439964294,
-0.718614935874939,
0.5913095474243164,
-0.2756783962249756,
-0.13209478557109833,
-0.39799293875694275,
-0.4862632155418396,
-0.7726119160652161,
0.031227732077240944,
0.16010122001171112,
0.7030870914459229,
-0.5716288685798645,
0.6523533463478088,
-0.4928293824195862,
-0.9127277731895447,
-0.11802688986063004,
0.128321573138237,
0.17801141738891602,
0.24459831416606903,
0.19218046963214874,
-0.5116128921508789,
-0.8519327640533447,
-1.0217761993408203,
-0.14569403231143951,
-0.3746916949748993,
-0.443212628364563,
0.44640374183654785,
0.1241382285952568,
-0.34963858127593994,
0.7354671955108643,
-0.48667827248573303,
-0.17926685512065887,
-0.1714949905872345,
0.22852560877799988,
0.44818660616874695,
0.1674729436635971,
0.5993359088897705,
-0.5035245418548584,
-0.5115025043487549,
-0.12287391722202301,
-0.4015589952468872,
-0.1886196881532669,
-0.47628748416900635,
-0.5479209423065186,
-0.27027031779289246,
0.6520516276359558,
-0.37802955508232117,
0.4416491985321045,
-0.0008523687720298767,
-0.49231916666030884,
0.4851028025150299,
-0.2865563929080963,
-0.19012168049812317,
-1.1141881942749023,
-0.08759380877017975,
-0.23220178484916687,
-0.2217794507741928,
-0.18044531345367432,
-0.36968401074409485,
0.0007236999808810651,
0.18305808305740356,
-0.059187985956668854,
0.6154614686965942,
-0.6065414547920227,
0.13919086754322052,
-0.29192718863487244,
-0.00015926154446788132,
0.02329428307712078,
0.6861125826835632,
0.08633189648389816,
0.15069323778152466,
0.6387374997138977,
-0.679511308670044,
0.5340641736984253,
0.3695305287837982,
-0.6766648292541504,
0.2927938997745514,
-0.7988852858543396,
0.22504332661628723,
-0.22333666682243347,
0.19735610485076904,
-1.1176637411117554,
0.36412185430526733,
0.2392677366733551,
-0.26654860377311707,
0.27487388253211975,
-0.23703476786613464,
-0.4776705205440521,
-0.5629199743270874,
-0.3989919126033783,
-0.08766438066959381,
0.3887866735458374,
-0.5639929175376892,
0.9327326416969299,
-0.02454226091504097,
-0.5362277626991272,
-0.19119274616241455,
-0.2804366648197174,
0.11743799597024918,
0.1547676920890808,
-0.7326855063438416,
0.6673339009284973,
-0.45081788301467896,
0.08051985502243042,
0.01047772541642189,
-0.20717886090278625,
0.4667387008666992,
0.013062667101621628,
0.8218508958816528,
0.7014891505241394,
0.07540836185216904,
-0.10330341756343842,
-0.17841988801956177,
-0.2645152509212494,
0.2322394996881485,
-0.3801977038383484,
0.42989861965179443,
-0.11696954816579819,
-0.41834431886672974,
-0.036514896899461746,
0.25888189673423767,
0.8680792450904846,
-0.35034942626953125,
0.5048810839653015,
0.5683837532997131,
-0.1096818596124649,
-0.3379281759262085,
-0.5009550452232361,
-0.10582471638917923,
-0.4948132336139679,
0.45639973878860474,
-0.49856483936309814,
-0.3242570757865906,
0.4263364374637604,
-0.6079133152961731,
0.6934574842453003,
0.28857019543647766,
0.8162240386009216,
-0.26900506019592285,
1.1398921012878418,
0.6324909925460815,
-0.3789657950401306,
0.8774319887161255,
-0.6717327237129211,
0.4366276264190674,
-0.7544251680374146,
-0.2741895318031311,
-0.2767007350921631,
-0.6372455358505249,
-0.4101177155971527,
-0.15989142656326294,
0.41633039712905884,
0.12020329385995865,
-0.1141274943947792,
0.5407626032829285,
-0.4092656672000885,
-0.004706260282546282,
0.6974568367004395,
0.03323525935411453,
0.05681052431464195,
-0.06801050901412964,
-0.4540214240550995,
0.51959228515625,
-0.7832586765289307,
-0.45601773262023926,
0.895008385181427,
0.21983398497104645,
0.6417526006698608,
0.02364208549261093,
0.38198256492614746,
0.5268994569778442,
0.4322841167449951,
-0.9138512015342712,
0.4347054660320282,
0.27038320899009705,
-0.48971250653266907,
-0.3708765208721161,
0.0344824381172657,
-0.9909476637840271,
-0.05624977871775627,
-0.27678197622299194,
-0.11544059962034225,
0.3947880268096924,
-0.04066205024719238,
-0.44897156953811646,
0.49815770983695984,
-0.5971798300743103,
0.5360717177391052,
-0.300200492143631,
-0.42008763551712036,
-0.3075311481952667,
-0.7506572008132935,
-0.18011818826198578,
-0.08975431323051453,
0.5076148509979248,
-0.11297886818647385,
0.004215503577142954,
0.5900260806083679,
-0.4124593734741211,
0.47901642322540283,
-0.18665245175361633,
0.0456906296312809,
0.4047011137008667,
0.360712468624115,
0.9597659111022949,
-0.0031036061700433493,
-0.1747758984565735,
0.09843720495700836,
-0.21309830248355865,
0.12833063304424286,
-0.8010185360908508,
0.5763299465179443,
-0.5346415042877197,
-0.7533150911331177,
0.029741764068603516,
-0.2764812707901001,
-0.11441327631473541,
0.27233654260635376,
0.3434411287307739,
0.8407647013664246,
-0.08274045586585999,
0.42114201188087463,
0.07211007177829742,
-0.048970699310302734,
0.3944963216781616,
0.5737051367759705,
-0.23828232288360596,
-0.3801443874835968,
0.847048819065094,
0.09283493459224701,
-0.23690825700759888,
0.5652149319648743,
0.14871273934841156,
-0.2635214030742645,
-0.736111044883728,
-0.8215774297714233,
-0.10923078656196594,
-0.2803865969181061,
-0.3541002571582794,
-0.4723585546016693,
0.0006869799690321088,
-0.29473766684532166,
-0.6507310271263123,
-0.10762891173362732,
-0.3669854998588562,
-0.1267421990633011,
-0.2994726896286011,
0.09175924956798553,
0.893770158290863,
0.3159753978252411,
0.1528407335281372,
-0.8540146946907043,
0.6171321868896484,
-0.05004561319947243,
0.8746663331985474,
0.0933564230799675,
-0.5216699242591858,
-0.5537523627281189,
-0.1729787141084671,
-0.4569748342037201,
-0.6627950072288513,
0.11800029873847961,
-0.13964064419269562,
0.8714155554771423,
0.56480473279953,
0.15149956941604614,
0.10974454879760742,
-0.8970777988433838,
0.44062188267707825,
0.04478396847844124,
-0.11863207072019577,
0.34594205021858215,
-0.34188881516456604,
0.4512971341609955,
0.11546426266431808,
0.5773990154266357,
-0.380685031414032,
-0.30462124943733215,
-0.5859456062316895,
-1.0714415311813354,
0.629795491695404,
-0.08232199400663376,
0.008254683576524258,
0.15704336762428284,
-0.05148589238524437,
0.08679619431495667,
-0.0034225801937282085,
0.07779504358768463,
-0.4086950421333313,
-0.10330769419670105,
-0.09376007318496704,
0.016429373994469643,
-0.42494940757751465,
0.2714124619960785,
-0.012809417210519314,
0.8787336945533752,
0.21313470602035522,
0.15823164582252502,
0.16009829938411713,
0.1248384341597557,
-0.1919231414794922,
0.2664884328842163,
0.11411866545677185,
0.7699946761131287,
-0.10113520920276642,
-0.16564138233661652,
0.27369463443756104,
-0.12243466079235077,
-0.0798930674791336,
0.1258528083562851,
-0.08041010797023773,
0.10118966549634933,
0.24379880726337433,
0.848257303237915,
0.4321363866329193,
-0.3944753408432007,
0.30995726585388184,
0.171302929520607,
-0.22293443977832794,
-0.4597540497779846,
-0.154694065451622,
0.2378080189228058,
0.47330164909362793,
0.12035784125328064,
0.4935338497161865,
0.3665992319583893,
-0.20891554653644562,
0.07857032865285873,
0.47712403535842896,
-0.2452365756034851,
-0.3118816614151001,
0.655526340007782,
0.5124380588531494,
-0.7208958268165588,
0.5837447047233582,
0.293550580739975,
-0.5072676539421082,
0.40704238414764404,
0.061737269163131714,
1.0060175657272339,
-0.11024188995361328,
-0.1379232555627823,
0.2471071183681488,
0.2502501606941223,
0.0335792638361454,
0.060156259685754776,
-0.45927631855010986,
-0.6528987884521484,
-0.02547430247068405,
-0.5326873064041138,
-0.4312458038330078,
-0.36470386385917664,
-0.3702232539653778,
0.9270130395889282,
-0.7085918188095093,
-0.4676078259944916,
-0.016496965661644936,
-0.16851499676704407,
-0.9063279628753662,
-0.011249951086938381,
0.17021314799785614,
0.9763768315315247,
-0.012871094048023224,
0.3661947250366211,
0.8153758645057678,
-0.1602039486169815,
-0.6512055397033691,
-0.6267380118370056,
-0.035759761929512024,
-0.4255061447620392,
0.38309821486473083,
-0.14940385520458221,
-0.6096686720848083,
0.10336094349622726,
-0.14229056239128113,
-0.48475420475006104,
1.0772812366485596,
0.06217481940984726,
-0.6330606937408447,
-0.5926983952522278,
-0.12424895167350769,
0.4527759552001953,
-0.12382212281227112,
0.464775413274765,
-0.004296198021620512,
0.4571981728076935,
0.20677432417869568,
-0.8490433692932129,
-0.11524806171655655,
-0.499210387468338,
0.07511412352323532,
0.4038078188896179,
-0.5216250419616699,
0.19379834830760956,
-0.4944946765899658,
-0.38480299711227417,
0.19103653728961945,
0.8234490156173706,
-0.004453249741345644,
0.3490997850894928,
0.8330268859863281,
0.15960779786109924,
0.2319323569536209,
0.27193084359169006,
1.0206069946289062,
-0.6657426357269287,
-0.24099047482013702,
1.2439438104629517,
0.09125448763370514,
0.7160376906394958,
0.07188607007265091,
-0.30702096223831177,
0.9155394434928894,
0.6928924322128296,
-0.3411673903465271,
0.4607238471508026,
0.08516880869865417,
0.12986721098423004,
-0.14777816832065582,
0.009292202070355415,
-0.33697906136512756,
0.1338770091533661,
0.13756555318832397,
-0.5219566226005554,
-0.10386533290147781,
-0.18309634923934937,
-0.21174035966396332,
-0.2634100615978241,
-0.15320461988449097,
0.815083384513855,
0.01299983263015747,
-0.5039341449737549,
0.31919753551483154,
0.13262967765331268,
0.6179514527320862,
-0.7031242251396179,
-0.1197713315486908,
0.0252027940005064,
0.059647850692272186,
-0.25824934244155884,
-0.738968014717102,
0.1456765979528427,
-0.3860767185688019,
-0.5927000641822815,
-0.6803870797157288,
0.6578416228294373,
-0.393785297870636,
-0.5365561842918396,
0.3425593674182892,
0.5899839997291565,
-0.02643659897148609,
-0.12190834432840347,
-0.13446615636348724,
-0.34027838706970215,
-0.1391303688287735,
-0.21369445323944092,
-0.05774569883942604,
0.24169006943702698,
-0.21609507501125336,
0.9394558668136597,
0.816422164440155,
0.2081516534090042,
-0.07908596098423004,
0.22972853481769562,
0.8724213242530823,
-0.4136030375957489,
-0.6466279029846191,
-0.648906946182251,
0.5412477254867554,
0.1614825278520584,
0.06109972670674324,
0.7679542899131775,
0.8396168351173401,
1.148011565208435,
-0.16868557035923004,
0.6853246092796326,
0.20535336434841156,
0.5330471396446228,
-0.014510877430438995,
0.445385605096817,
-0.3167586922645569,
0.5621800422668457,
-0.32428091764450073,
-1.0873433351516724,
0.015476571395993233,
-0.035370972007513046,
-0.33507615327835083,
0.13799883425235748,
0.22233173251152039,
0.9570189118385315,
-0.09875956177711487,
0.2665782570838928,
0.2950255274772644,
-0.016071610152721405,
0.4846404492855072,
0.3201580047607422,
0.6217190027236938,
-0.01942596770823002,
0.7977682948112488,
-0.2705025374889374,
-0.11379991471767426,
-0.3158378005027771,
-0.639087975025177,
-0.9537591338157654,
-0.7851735353469849,
0.10098876804113388,
-0.023557186126708984,
-0.3009759783744812,
1.0205655097961426,
0.7679884433746338,
-0.7380816340446472,
-0.22383655607700348,
-0.07251939177513123,
0.1676073968410492,
-0.19498592615127563,
-0.23460732400417328,
0.5227819085121155,
-0.021851910278201103,
-0.5726468563079834,
0.5422470569610596,
0.46766629815101624,
0.08061420172452927,
-0.36342090368270874,
-0.158543661236763,
-0.016819309443235397,
0.13232320547103882,
0.6805770993232727,
-0.24620872735977173,
-0.6222088932991028,
-0.11779170483350754,
0.18298862874507904,
0.04620271548628807,
-0.054289717227220535,
1.2079216241836548,
-1.0351492166519165,
0.8534789085388184,
0.9565232396125793,
0.6093347072601318,
0.29628828167915344,
0.03323092684149742,
0.8781333565711975,
-0.26468729972839355,
-0.3476232886314392,
-0.06255758553743362,
0.5689109563827515,
0.20123349130153656,
-0.3544422686100006,
0.5045045614242554,
0.23855513334274292,
-0.35889530181884766,
-0.3474595248699188,
-0.02052994817495346,
-0.820444643497467,
0.03480031341314316,
0.663692831993103,
0.0525040440261364,
0.3068915903568268,
-0.44549161195755005,
-0.8114939332008362,
0.3330257534980774,
-0.4820646047592163,
0.643448531627655,
0.5692729353904724,
-0.23404771089553833,
0.05457546189427376,
-0.26289960741996765,
0.08322354406118393,
0.2574011981487274,
-0.30363979935646057,
0.03883272036910057,
0.5217083096504211,
0.011546004563570023,
0.06858553737401962,
0.28137683868408203,
0.08071093261241913,
0.14303308725357056,
-0.1902133971452713,
-0.03958875685930252,
-0.6539269685745239,
-0.6634268760681152,
0.32572975754737854,
0.11893323808908463,
0.05342990532517433,
-0.011638020165264606
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00799v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00799v3
|
Are you still on track!? Catching LLM Task Drift with Activations
| 2024-06-02T16:53:21 | 2024-06-20T13:33:08 |
Sahar Abdelnabi, Aideen Fay, Giovanni Cherubin, Ahmed Salem, Mario Fritz, Andrew Paverd
|
cs.CR
|
cs.CR, cs.CL, cs.CY
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) are routinely used in retrieval-augmented
applications to orchestrate tasks and process inputs from users and other
sources. These inputs, even in a single LLM interaction, can come from a
variety of sources, of varying trustworthiness and provenance. This opens the
door to prompt injection attacks, where the LLM receives and acts upon
instructions from supposedly data-only sources, thus deviating from the user's
original instructions. We define this as task drift, and we propose to catch it
by scanning and analyzing the LLM's activations. We compare the LLM's
activations before and after processing the external input in order to detect
whether this input caused instruction drift. We develop two probing methods and
find that simply using a linear classifier can detect drift with near perfect
ROC AUC on an out-of-distribution test set. We show that this approach
generalizes surprisingly well to unseen task domains, such as prompt
injections, jailbreaks, and malicious instructions, without being trained on
any of these attacks. Our setup does not require any modification of the LLM
(e.g., fine-tuning) or any text generation, thus maximizing deployability and
cost efficiency and avoiding reliance on unreliable model output. To foster
future research on activation-based task inspection, decoding, and
interpretability, we will release our large-scale TaskTracker toolkit,
comprising a dataset of over 500K instances, representations from 4 SoTA
language models, and inspection tools.
|
[
0.03879721835255623,
-0.8974454402923584,
0.8421995043754578,
-0.09371888637542725,
-0.06302200257778168,
0.10019156336784363,
-0.030527206137776375,
-0.23840883374214172,
-0.06685240566730499,
0.6796149015426636,
-0.8596158623695374,
-0.5244706869125366,
-0.6226094365119934,
-0.07205875217914581,
-0.7043885588645935,
0.7577747106552124,
-0.09650121629238129,
-0.13927018642425537,
-0.38838234543800354,
-0.10591035336256027,
-0.5301132798194885,
-0.47047844529151917,
-0.6223214268684387,
-0.44162845611572266,
0.35366690158843994,
0.23789182305335999,
0.08802296966314316,
0.5202221274375916,
0.5519008636474609,
0.23662252724170685,
-0.23473457992076874,
0.17357532680034637,
-0.48071444034576416,
0.21420365571975708,
-0.08845598250627518,
-0.8991073966026306,
-0.3322260081768036,
-0.15231607854366302,
0.3611610531806946,
0.40160274505615234,
-0.25194042921066284,
0.22717273235321045,
0.02407529205083847,
0.42680999636650085,
-0.9546158909797668,
-0.08083006739616394,
-0.5835229754447937,
-0.06267638504505157,
-0.5901449918746948,
-0.4123522937297821,
-0.8065072894096375,
0.004074625205248594,
-0.43596017360687256,
-0.3633553981781006,
0.04687023535370827,
-0.2162240445613861,
0.5166137218475342,
0.5713117718696594,
-0.3860721290111542,
-0.5613150596618652,
-0.5736702084541321,
0.7162919640541077,
-0.6763607859611511,
0.36787301301956177,
0.40426695346832275,
-0.02486395090818405,
-0.38781341910362244,
-0.7004367113113403,
-0.5175060629844666,
-0.47864997386932373,
0.2182590663433075,
0.137956440448761,
-0.07062724232673645,
-0.06547573953866959,
0.4978117346763611,
0.025999899953603745,
-0.41128793358802795,
0.32060742378234863,
0.045200955122709274,
-0.22489401698112488,
0.3762946128845215,
0.3152346909046173,
0.44715574383735657,
0.2859523296356201,
-0.6273396015167236,
0.22084803879261017,
-1.063728928565979,
0.06885033845901489,
0.34299802780151367,
0.08142352104187012,
-0.03227399289608002,
0.5515455007553101,
-0.049246832728385925,
0.7569730281829834,
0.29018890857696533,
0.12997370958328247,
0.09053986519575119,
-0.3237016201019287,
-0.09471996873617172,
0.0057488130405545235,
0.640346348285675,
-0.017668284475803375,
-0.20732958614826202,
-0.13435828685760498,
-0.3912228047847748,
0.09957395493984222,
0.35810375213623047,
-0.43276768922805786,
0.025003310292959213,
0.2783399224281311,
-0.32666534185409546,
-0.342928022146225,
-0.2961778938770294,
-0.313524067401886,
-0.5645257234573364,
0.039285022765398026,
0.23566992580890656,
-0.30799221992492676,
-0.24792970716953278,
-0.04879489168524742,
-0.05348818004131317,
0.4373351037502289,
0.22010642290115356,
-0.9547793865203857,
0.1734025925397873,
0.9389849901199341,
0.847659170627594,
-0.5226306915283203,
-0.15553531050682068,
-0.8180975914001465,
-0.15037085115909576,
-0.28692781925201416,
0.8295444846153259,
-0.5022463798522949,
-0.2663611173629761,
0.2716522216796875,
0.020015841349959373,
-0.18239456415176392,
-0.7790863513946533,
0.3582725524902344,
-1.0329132080078125,
-0.14339768886566162,
-0.17931629717350006,
-0.6312153935432434,
0.19559094309806824,
0.33880332112312317,
-0.5225694179534912,
1.3486899137496948,
-0.046572234481573105,
-0.5765626430511475,
0.2191982865333557,
-0.7719271779060364,
-0.36485692858695984,
0.21472245454788208,
-0.16808998584747314,
-0.0851987674832344,
0.21817952394485474,
-0.07353821396827698,
0.32707956433296204,
-0.01719595491886139,
0.06726489216089249,
-0.16009047627449036,
-0.3760559856891632,
0.36132121086120605,
-0.22906003892421722,
0.9794029593467712,
0.1461048126220703,
-0.5164284706115723,
-0.0279917623847723,
-0.5344201922416687,
-0.1870047152042389,
-0.0913250520825386,
-0.5419837236404419,
-0.2615414261817932,
0.18623092770576477,
-0.23647820949554443,
0.10433374345302582,
0.46319037675857544,
-0.6447455286979675,
0.3081665635108948,
-0.11042196303606033,
0.24581830203533173,
0.7061917185783386,
0.2135365754365921,
0.27457574009895325,
-0.12724870443344116,
0.7083894610404968,
0.2535344660282135,
0.03302187845110893,
-0.395614355802536,
-0.48367786407470703,
-0.6123054623603821,
-0.06589704006910324,
0.12658734619617462,
0.7734058499336243,
-0.9858734607696533,
0.3708707392215729,
-0.16905580461025238,
-0.22203077375888824,
-0.24706131219863892,
0.46672898530960083,
0.42505866289138794,
0.5870007276535034,
0.16056303679943085,
-0.1477288007736206,
-0.09837783128023148,
-0.5526834726333618,
-0.37577059864997864,
-0.026791756972670555,
-0.20334571599960327,
-0.06609133630990982,
0.5352006554603577,
-0.4500257968902588,
0.857576310634613,
-0.3721567690372467,
-0.2099345326423645,
-0.3339979946613312,
0.2703678011894226,
0.1664579212665558,
0.44934356212615967,
0.2569386661052704,
-0.4752081036567688,
-0.16802668571472168,
-0.08141512423753738,
-0.8377745151519775,
-0.32751044631004333,
-0.31382662057876587,
-0.1283516138792038,
0.12956054508686066,
0.9218154549598694,
-0.627765417098999,
0.22092267870903015,
0.5083075165748596,
-0.26881515979766846,
0.3248375952243805,
-0.035971302539110184,
-0.18600450456142426,
-0.8893800377845764,
0.08235660195350647,
-0.00672578951343894,
-0.4078798294067383,
-0.8048480153083801,
0.24956315755844116,
0.38551369309425354,
0.021450212225317955,
-0.6876246929168701,
0.3271480202674866,
-0.4253852665424347,
0.2516368329524994,
-0.4101136028766632,
0.0062971580773591995,
-0.2521526515483856,
0.37621450424194336,
-0.06592585891485214,
0.798566460609436,
0.4992050528526306,
-0.5559307932853699,
0.34250620007514954,
0.09255779534578323,
-0.6179969310760498,
0.4319421648979187,
-0.3461509346961975,
0.5408982038497925,
-0.11612476408481598,
0.2769067585468292,
-0.796670138835907,
-0.09715340286493301,
0.3818525969982147,
-0.24142329394817352,
0.5599119663238525,
-0.23437412083148956,
-0.37324845790863037,
-0.027187487110495567,
-0.2370615452528,
0.2986917793750763,
0.5905357003211975,
-0.5382328033447266,
0.6484416127204895,
0.33253517746925354,
0.04110127314925194,
-0.9065098166465759,
-0.7705904245376587,
0.07546095550060272,
-0.14367985725402832,
-0.36716702580451965,
0.06591515988111496,
-0.02093595452606678,
-0.1930442601442337,
-0.1313498318195343,
-0.43240687251091003,
0.0050901989452540874,
0.4391351640224457,
0.398115336894989,
0.2133074253797531,
-0.22639498114585876,
-0.18112944066524506,
-0.004327442962676287,
-0.0893743708729744,
0.40304258465766907,
-0.28887489438056946,
0.5231395363807678,
0.33380192518234253,
-0.6801902055740356,
-0.61906898021698,
0.08982948213815689,
0.6727669835090637,
-0.07138588279485703,
0.40262770652770996,
0.3727632462978363,
-0.18977536261081696,
-0.3392743170261383,
-0.559218168258667,
-0.19250012934207916,
-0.5308839082717896,
0.37136662006378174,
-0.2792210876941681,
-0.6944192051887512,
0.5781388282775879,
-0.46151304244995117,
0.23598513007164001,
0.11834089457988739,
0.6676439046859741,
-0.2697693109512329,
0.84860759973526,
0.7255595922470093,
-0.10832946747541428,
0.7973411679267883,
-0.275921106338501,
0.03205828741192818,
-0.9065048694610596,
-0.1710198074579239,
-0.17548462748527527,
-0.4169282615184784,
-0.14385183155536652,
-0.4907854497432709,
0.2765321731567383,
-0.11155311018228531,
0.2259477823972702,
0.16545376181602478,
-0.09672113507986069,
0.5222725868225098,
0.4379526674747467,
0.3574186861515045,
0.10234468430280685,
-0.2976285219192505,
0.02308340184390545,
0.38608407974243164,
-0.4888592064380646,
-0.33911561965942383,
1.25242018699646,
0.39951321482658386,
0.9682320356369019,
-0.21751894056797028,
0.9342705607414246,
0.6389636397361755,
0.5649272203445435,
-0.6869575381278992,
0.7199852466583252,
0.0907016322016716,
-0.5922223329544067,
-0.045063577592372894,
-0.3398474454879761,
-0.8960785269737244,
-0.05151161924004555,
0.17221711575984955,
-0.7532210350036621,
0.2551285922527313,
0.3383353054523468,
-0.29322806000709534,
0.15452006459236145,
-0.5240880846977234,
0.9541700482368469,
-0.35347485542297363,
-0.2904723286628723,
-0.06081189587712288,
-0.4716593027114868,
0.5459656715393066,
-0.14075011014938354,
0.24453721940517426,
-0.2984653115272522,
-0.321930855512619,
0.6718791127204895,
-0.4019303023815155,
1.0190179347991943,
-0.3694744408130646,
-0.4463741183280945,
0.419347882270813,
0.1316162645816803,
0.7803483009338379,
-0.1882910132408142,
0.052955955266952515,
0.07231597602367401,
-0.26549866795539856,
-0.31820446252822876,
-0.678009033203125,
0.6822508573532104,
-0.41796988248825073,
-0.6085973978042603,
-0.2872248589992523,
-0.6553951501846313,
-0.061328597366809845,
0.14216914772987366,
0.4567806124687195,
0.506131649017334,
0.05432595685124397,
-0.172040194272995,
0.8547455668449402,
0.25759971141815186,
0.4218297302722931,
0.4746478199958801,
0.13053028285503387,
0.22023038566112518,
1.0157753229141235,
-0.14630575478076935,
0.4854833781719208,
0.49145251512527466,
-0.013891628012061119,
-0.1890125870704651,
-1.0420469045639038,
-0.5760263204574585,
-0.008986067958176136,
-0.8086932301521301,
-0.24465204775333405,
-0.48879534006118774,
0.18656659126281738,
-0.14580178260803223,
0.15106138586997986,
-0.25411736965179443,
-0.22575786709785461,
-0.4376457631587982,
0.024572711437940598,
0.23067966103553772,
0.7817989587783813,
0.22822019457817078,
0.47300875186920166,
-0.7385919094085693,
0.2187010794878006,
0.1870032548904419,
0.006340592633932829,
-0.2655421793460846,
-0.6501700282096863,
-0.3214886486530304,
0.09329792112112045,
-0.4235284626483917,
-1.1076266765594482,
0.19488266110420227,
0.16175338625907898,
0.46335771679878235,
0.609205961227417,
0.09282352775335312,
0.320121705532074,
-0.5498195290565491,
0.898087739944458,
-0.04331669956445694,
-1.0176416635513306,
0.4722544848918915,
-0.28176724910736084,
0.532172679901123,
0.6022612452507019,
0.3947114050388336,
-0.3560698330402374,
-0.8515396118164062,
-0.2776328921318054,
-0.7067132592201233,
0.7966558933258057,
-0.140211284160614,
0.1660299003124237,
0.04647482559084892,
0.5040287971496582,
-0.11196179687976837,
0.11441518366336823,
-0.6813085675239563,
-0.28093940019607544,
0.2133096307516098,
-0.36784228682518005,
0.16090643405914307,
-0.28241753578186035,
-0.11030448973178864,
0.2873571217060089,
0.4914605915546417,
-0.11737755686044693,
0.15317398309707642,
-0.10729839652776718,
-0.4989662766456604,
-0.0852968841791153,
0.2348165512084961,
0.5703291893005371,
0.6442686915397644,
0.022765619680285454,
0.34175002574920654,
0.4041244685649872,
-0.8533135056495667,
0.2864817678928375,
-0.17759865522384644,
-0.4387555718421936,
0.04228462278842926,
0.527892529964447,
0.3459971845149994,
0.2736775875091553,
-1.0130213499069214,
0.49482133984565735,
0.04757443815469742,
0.07770010083913803,
-0.20519253611564636,
0.2743701934814453,
0.056038111448287964,
0.21999841928482056,
0.43294596672058105,
0.0993296280503273,
0.07594600319862366,
-0.5787850022315979,
0.1585225611925125,
0.5734996795654297,
-0.5019188523292542,
-0.40244147181510925,
0.5010815262794495,
0.22935263812541962,
-0.344100683927536,
0.684408962726593,
-0.2894546687602997,
-0.5855879187583923,
0.5656900405883789,
0.5146726369857788,
1.035115122795105,
-0.38909095525741577,
-0.11651161313056946,
-0.13798393309116364,
0.4192267954349518,
-0.13102300465106964,
0.42496228218078613,
-0.30201777815818787,
-0.6852850914001465,
-0.5705784559249878,
-0.4185050129890442,
-0.4536677896976471,
0.12226781249046326,
-0.7836674451828003,
0.1635468453168869,
-0.2760043144226074,
-0.19750957190990448,
-0.1509760618209839,
-0.501194417476654,
-0.5074386596679688,
-0.25563278794288635,
0.3595256507396698,
1.03729248046875,
-1.0281391143798828,
0.8804264068603516,
0.7855645418167114,
-0.01445698831230402,
-0.15777556598186493,
0.2097012847661972,
0.19535768032073975,
-1.0455187559127808,
0.9154069423675537,
0.22202298045158386,
-0.2571026682853699,
-0.06091909855604172,
-0.5743269920349121,
-0.8473129272460938,
0.9384394288063049,
0.2908909320831299,
-0.550771951675415,
-0.13207247853279114,
0.07458530366420746,
0.25464707612991333,
-0.06530233472585678,
0.23303033411502838,
0.8600823879241943,
0.22134222090244293,
-0.21779485046863556,
-0.5671073794364929,
0.26588985323905945,
-0.20595407485961914,
-0.37289050221443176,
0.4823281168937683,
-0.2707243859767914,
0.6353022456169128,
-0.16562509536743164,
-0.44860708713531494,
0.004581626504659653,
0.4733862578868866,
0.10408483445644379,
0.5150026679039001,
0.5041313171386719,
0.7448140382766724,
0.5886985063552856,
-0.0660698413848877,
0.9613368511199951,
-0.35611197352409363,
0.16695961356163025,
1.0245110988616943,
-0.5642048120498657,
1.069783091545105,
0.4546370208263397,
-0.025964561849832535,
0.6223379969596863,
0.46934211254119873,
0.12328487634658813,
0.6089454889297485,
0.16866496205329895,
-0.5294181108474731,
-0.35406768321990967,
-0.08849231898784637,
-0.06180001422762871,
0.2464357614517212,
0.6244585514068604,
-0.1593436896800995,
-0.28088653087615967,
0.31416183710098267,
-0.0007931303698569536,
-0.16181239485740662,
-0.27489373087882996,
0.9124190211296082,
0.0877433642745018,
-0.6552457213401794,
0.6981621384620667,
-0.2079174965620041,
0.7550447583198547,
-0.7267592549324036,
0.12603962421417236,
-0.18087120354175568,
0.3226517140865326,
-0.18390031158924103,
-0.6310898661613464,
0.09556795656681061,
0.12805694341659546,
-0.017374657094478607,
-0.46589264273643494,
0.6185613870620728,
-0.35191985964775085,
-0.2322881817817688,
0.03408638760447502,
0.3802972435951233,
0.06514424085617065,
-0.09300929307937622,
-0.4911693036556244,
0.43945032358169556,
-0.04671607166528702,
-0.3781295120716095,
0.5500272512435913,
0.27541419863700867,
0.034521978348493576,
0.8603639006614685,
0.679199755191803,
-0.05321260169148445,
0.37747421860694885,
-0.22466658055782318,
0.8638439774513245,
-0.46094048023223877,
-0.30250805616378784,
-1.004394292831421,
0.460027277469635,
0.21553587913513184,
-0.26820024847984314,
0.8684216141700745,
0.5846530795097351,
0.6492491960525513,
-0.06194636598229408,
0.70604407787323,
0.1281191110610962,
0.23552453517913818,
-0.7571477293968201,
0.470375657081604,
-0.4031393527984619,
0.4734337031841278,
0.14721518754959106,
-0.5531697869300842,
0.006590805947780609,
0.15005570650100708,
-0.3244933784008026,
-0.23319615423679352,
0.694004237651825,
0.8256341218948364,
-0.11042367666959763,
-0.1452045440673828,
0.007264460902661085,
0.14824853837490082,
0.3238740861415863,
0.6260769367218018,
1.3620905876159668,
-0.06364620476961136,
0.5523354411125183,
0.013436343520879745,
-0.45421701669692993,
-0.3156037926673889,
-0.8168573975563049,
-0.9923806190490723,
-0.2583276033401489,
-0.5321167707443237,
-0.37266847491264343,
0.18987290561199188,
0.5757739543914795,
0.6022427678108215,
-0.8347534537315369,
-0.2967475354671478,
-0.32953640818595886,
0.24973461031913757,
-0.516482949256897,
-0.16974703967571259,
0.14328670501708984,
-0.7316970229148865,
-0.625532865524292,
0.8761256337165833,
0.15958644449710846,
-0.16816236078739166,
-0.22125746309757233,
0.2345885932445526,
-0.21752484142780304,
-0.13146185874938965,
0.43858546018600464,
0.5021311044692993,
-0.6164681315422058,
-0.17928284406661987,
0.16332386434078217,
0.01849251799285412,
-0.12541136145591736,
1.087221384048462,
-0.6275314688682556,
0.4516453742980957,
0.5833176970481873,
0.8768218159675598,
0.41226276755332947,
-0.020736850798130035,
0.45627835392951965,
-0.8833925127983093,
-0.01595485769212246,
0.4162900149822235,
0.2718927264213562,
-0.03840342536568642,
-0.48926401138305664,
0.1846407949924469,
0.07383942604064941,
-0.6575084328651428,
-1.1138789653778076,
0.422690749168396,
-0.8656652569770813,
-0.04177149385213852,
0.9826404452323914,
-0.2566326856613159,
-0.4266318082809448,
-0.4154345393180847,
0.1573026180267334,
-0.08537312597036362,
-0.23660345375537872,
0.6098508238792419,
0.45045900344848633,
-0.4158867299556732,
-0.009815938770771027,
-0.7017008662223816,
0.5642572045326233,
0.4581844210624695,
-0.8742768168449402,
0.32880669832229614,
0.39540132880210876,
0.35620084404945374,
0.4269695580005646,
0.48356932401657104,
0.15156106650829315,
0.5213210582733154,
-0.0678430050611496,
-0.03268849849700928,
-0.12769660353660583,
-0.15129442512989044,
-0.5510890483856201,
0.11717768013477325,
0.045601096004247665,
-0.5970053672790527
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00789v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00789v1
|
Developing an efficient corpus using Ensemble Data cleaning approach
| 2024-06-02T16:03:31 | 2024-06-02T16:03:31 |
Md Taimur Ahad
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CV
|
Despite the observable benefit of Natural Language Processing (NLP) in
processing a large amount of textual medical data within a limited time for
information retrieval, a handful of research efforts have been devoted to
uncovering novel data-cleaning methods. Data cleaning in NLP is at the centre
point for extracting validated information. Another observed limitation in the
NLP domain is having limited medical corpora that provide answers to a given
medical question. Realising the limitations and challenges from two
perspectives, this research aims to clean a medical dataset using ensemble
techniques and to develop a corpus. The corpora expect that it will answer the
question based on the semantic relationship of corpus sequences. However, the
data cleaning method in this research suggests that the ensemble technique
provides the highest accuracy (94%) compared to the single process, which
includes vectorisation, exploratory data analysis, and feeding the vectorised
data. The second aim of having an adequate corpus was realised by extracting
answers from the dataset. This research is significant in machine learning,
specifically data cleaning and the medical sector, but it also underscores the
importance of NLP in the medical field, where accurate and timely information
extraction can be a matter of life and death. It establishes text data
processing using NLP as a powerful tool for extracting valuable information
like image data.
|
[
-0.35575515031814575,
-0.5415055155754089,
0.26399657130241394,
0.029055029153823853,
-0.21423204243183136,
0.19049035012722015,
-0.18882088363170624,
-0.7513202428817749,
0.2897288501262665,
0.4744323790073395,
-0.2608150541782379,
-0.5087752342224121,
-0.5143946409225464,
0.3247908055782318,
-0.6363286972045898,
1.1213172674179077,
0.17148977518081665,
0.17844738066196442,
-0.35968926548957825,
-0.254179447889328,
-0.3825751841068268,
-0.43124884366989136,
-0.9943755865097046,
-0.0381179004907608,
0.3032730519771576,
0.3563618063926697,
0.6739445924758911,
1.0066490173339844,
0.8110206723213196,
0.2866095304489136,
-0.10533846914768219,
0.39798974990844727,
-0.4301314055919647,
0.5462682247161865,
-0.18877671658992767,
-0.2636449337005615,
0.06473236531019211,
-0.2833751440048218,
0.563549280166626,
0.8939312100410461,
-0.22348178923130035,
0.05478215962648392,
0.162906214594841,
0.7067080736160278,
-0.5323256850242615,
0.042668502777814865,
-0.7233037352561951,
0.17475610971450806,
-0.28110456466674805,
-0.4879033863544464,
-0.2039572149515152,
-0.1373223513364792,
-0.07436087727546692,
-0.7559844851493835,
0.22168762981891632,
0.007615106645971537,
0.8945001363754272,
0.5129184722900391,
0.04734319821000099,
-0.4610931873321533,
-0.7661099433898926,
0.8708884716033936,
-0.5734025835990906,
-0.010268878191709518,
0.507360577583313,
0.17277491092681885,
-0.11656174063682556,
-0.7317970991134644,
-0.32045936584472656,
0.4216150939464569,
-0.171553373336792,
0.22079157829284668,
-0.20947369933128357,
-0.2917633652687073,
0.029228854924440384,
0.4038415551185608,
-0.603339672088623,
0.2483844757080078,
-0.7623940110206604,
-0.22622385621070862,
0.6517003774642944,
0.15395934879779816,
0.5049002170562744,
-0.21870791912078857,
-0.6638102531433105,
-0.08448822796344757,
-0.3431363105773926,
-0.16051870584487915,
0.2365092933177948,
0.10738249868154526,
0.23891162872314453,
0.6222848892211914,
-0.1327674388885498,
0.5539162755012512,
-0.22695167362689972,
-0.16173464059829712,
0.2892354428768158,
-0.2777548134326935,
-0.2536698579788208,
0.3307989537715912,
0.7616021037101746,
0.2854520380496979,
0.1403602808713913,
-0.14774884283542633,
-0.23538507521152496,
0.2920877933502197,
0.6083999872207642,
-0.5472919344902039,
-0.16025452315807343,
0.8279733061790466,
-0.5661624670028687,
-0.5679635405540466,
-0.31323957443237305,
-1.1163580417633057,
-0.4500638544559479,
-0.3924674987792969,
0.0739007294178009,
-1.0054900646209717,
-0.17330576479434967,
0.008475634269416332,
-0.16587316989898682,
0.361516535282135,
0.5017070770263672,
-1.0083088874816895,
0.5249961018562317,
1.0008240938186646,
0.6280604600906372,
-0.37894201278686523,
0.3100627362728119,
-0.4671289026737213,
-0.011595379561185837,
-0.4744565784931183,
0.8906278014183044,
-0.5944467186927795,
-0.4306658208370209,
-0.0319315642118454,
-0.37060022354125977,
-0.24167273938655853,
-0.8715088367462158,
0.9838868379592896,
-0.3710109293460846,
0.31107228994369507,
0.18687884509563446,
-0.991330623626709,
-0.22813189029693604,
0.11011062562465668,
-0.730109691619873,
0.9101820588111877,
-0.08660461008548737,
-0.8742935061454773,
0.4693318009376526,
-0.5711763501167297,
-0.41800761222839355,
0.47306713461875916,
-0.3396283686161041,
-0.35105255246162415,
-0.06818542629480362,
0.3629826605319977,
0.5146051645278931,
0.03985291346907616,
0.19720013439655304,
-0.25447583198547363,
-0.2995503842830658,
-0.13782109320163727,
-0.2874150574207306,
0.8859823346138,
0.5550490021705627,
-0.03547684848308563,
-0.1995566487312317,
-0.8232355713844299,
0.28124627470970154,
-0.19569715857505798,
-0.09114521741867065,
-0.4791007339954376,
0.0033937215339392424,
0.12445048242807388,
0.08586519956588745,
0.08459176123142242,
-0.4687931537628174,
0.23651809990406036,
-0.44108930230140686,
0.2287706583738327,
0.5758313536643982,
0.173321932554245,
0.2860298752784729,
-0.7195684909820557,
0.5082203149795532,
-0.09717174619436264,
-0.030577611178159714,
-0.18745455145835876,
-0.6746420860290527,
-0.0532618947327137,
-0.8041283488273621,
0.6541875004768372,
0.7985226511955261,
-0.8934609293937683,
0.5677971839904785,
-0.10430285334587097,
-0.534546434879303,
-0.9762816429138184,
0.11053188890218735,
0.28542831540107727,
0.7511789798736572,
0.4742012619972229,
-0.22277529537677765,
-0.7749407887458801,
-0.8699343800544739,
-0.08495685458183289,
-0.10764673352241516,
-0.055679820477962494,
0.03198223188519478,
0.48415571451187134,
-0.13695837557315826,
0.7994300723075867,
-0.42044597864151,
-0.2986941635608673,
-0.17511312663555145,
0.036394648253917694,
0.23971699178218842,
0.7421248555183411,
0.2743062674999237,
-1.0199193954467773,
-0.12966562807559967,
0.1455192267894745,
-1.0420526266098022,
-0.07734071463346481,
-0.0019301720894873142,
-0.2280522733926773,
0.2717336416244507,
0.35140010714530945,
-0.44637957215309143,
0.5215675234794617,
0.38770943880081177,
0.007136608939617872,
0.3889620006084442,
-0.3123399615287781,
0.3613449037075043,
-1.1059255599975586,
0.48728474974632263,
0.05224879831075668,
-0.3070155084133148,
-0.7731648683547974,
0.08700262010097504,
-0.14283137023448944,
-0.03718971088528633,
-0.3743327856063843,
0.4492033123970032,
-0.1982087343931198,
0.14326518774032593,
-0.24508841335773468,
-0.06905198097229004,
-0.018567340448498726,
0.2558978796005249,
0.27785396575927734,
0.30021825432777405,
0.4258195459842682,
-0.6904863715171814,
0.042215898633003235,
0.4176221489906311,
-0.23795752227306366,
0.5145699381828308,
-0.5867862701416016,
-0.16136491298675537,
-0.042761143296957016,
-0.051432058215141296,
-0.8849695324897766,
-0.364206999540329,
0.2520378530025482,
-0.45265495777130127,
0.4314958155155182,
0.07932239025831223,
-0.7451207041740417,
-0.18599510192871094,
-0.3250904083251953,
0.2531817853450775,
0.6020046472549438,
-0.5452540516853333,
0.20858533680438995,
0.6215343475341797,
-0.25340309739112854,
-0.803528904914856,
-0.4147070646286011,
-0.06074274703860283,
-0.45633620023727417,
-0.8214808106422424,
0.4852818548679352,
0.29530972242355347,
-0.5790039896965027,
0.06857866793870926,
-0.1832423359155655,
-0.35983383655548096,
0.20812804996967316,
0.05756284296512604,
0.5550761222839355,
0.019877320155501366,
0.6644383668899536,
0.1285979002714157,
-0.1435120403766632,
-0.12998522818088531,
0.005933863576501608,
0.5849294662475586,
0.16579894721508026,
-0.23584559559822083,
-0.4069608449935913,
0.4750760793685913,
0.24057026207447052,
-0.20662984251976013,
0.5853958129882812,
0.6851379871368408,
-0.8560388684272766,
0.04570326209068298,
-0.45084089040756226,
-0.020097127184271812,
-0.3779606819152832,
0.18092063069343567,
0.010237361304461956,
-0.4477742910385132,
0.6429702043533325,
-0.013689502142369747,
0.28806453943252563,
0.7344882488250732,
0.4691828191280365,
-0.4583298861980438,
0.7671493887901306,
0.2776026725769043,
-0.09506236761808395,
0.07513728737831116,
-0.21755926311016083,
-0.02853570133447647,
-0.6511564254760742,
-0.11147867143154144,
-0.6848471760749817,
-0.2093903124332428,
-0.6627552509307861,
-0.1982163041830063,
0.3291972279548645,
0.03340921178460121,
0.20695078372955322,
0.23412001132965088,
-0.8476421236991882,
0.16110482811927795,
0.6375547051429749,
0.24731412529945374,
0.3250226378440857,
-0.07380051165819168,
-0.106200210750103,
0.3068867325782776,
-0.6644468903541565,
-0.887603223323822,
1.3051191568374634,
0.18026554584503174,
0.38372182846069336,
-0.21536897122859955,
0.997209906578064,
0.13918139040470123,
-0.14103223383426666,
-0.4351530969142914,
0.3470437526702881,
-0.2715727388858795,
-0.6148877143859863,
-0.3737943768501282,
-0.3336373269557953,
-1.3951683044433594,
0.14203514158725739,
-0.5352353453636169,
-0.6398831009864807,
0.06702037900686264,
-0.04684718698263168,
-0.46052828431129456,
0.49133920669555664,
-0.7241167426109314,
0.5526842474937439,
0.07203283160924911,
-0.39368754625320435,
-0.03707896173000336,
-1.044995903968811,
0.35683953762054443,
-0.364365816116333,
0.37458378076553345,
0.05076052248477936,
-0.12165701389312744,
0.8583551049232483,
-0.5548728108406067,
0.5563808083534241,
-0.05730937048792839,
-0.07543681561946869,
0.30563288927078247,
-0.20045310258865356,
0.11686361581087112,
0.12943026423454285,
-0.1201736330986023,
0.16398635506629944,
0.47209304571151733,
-0.5636075735092163,
-0.3947511315345764,
0.45033374428749084,
-0.41026464104652405,
-0.140926331281662,
-0.4981156587600708,
-0.545205295085907,
-0.12254638969898224,
-0.04338829591870308,
0.21594180166721344,
0.5979891419410706,
-0.142937570810318,
0.14846573770046234,
0.7586593627929688,
-0.4613180458545685,
0.5731078386306763,
0.03081103041768074,
-0.1648784577846527,
-0.2868824601173401,
0.6462807655334473,
-0.08515632152557373,
0.12415647506713867,
0.6015744209289551,
0.03723643720149994,
-0.2662750780582428,
-0.4909727871417999,
-0.5288438200950623,
-0.07778280973434448,
-0.42368069291114807,
-0.21497246623039246,
-0.6889923214912415,
-0.04120548069477081,
-0.5044965147972107,
-0.019506363198161125,
-0.09130814671516418,
-0.6227201819419861,
-0.39527037739753723,
0.14833998680114746,
0.512988269329071,
0.38167425990104675,
-0.13676874339580536,
-0.1020311787724495,
-1.0069679021835327,
0.4802931547164917,
-0.20443883538246155,
0.15598011016845703,
-0.4172521233558655,
0.03813301399350166,
-0.0011651137610897422,
-0.05019701272249222,
-0.0811978280544281,
-0.7685028910636902,
0.7699577808380127,
0.06081349402666092,
0.5398397445678711,
0.42024627327919006,
0.048968639224767685,
0.5216384530067444,
-0.3714829087257385,
0.6129939556121826,
-0.05515121668577194,
-0.4480595588684082,
0.5394927263259888,
-0.35472166538238525,
0.14120477437973022,
0.9567229151725769,
0.3759077787399292,
-0.564728856086731,
-0.5876988172531128,
-1.0612107515335083,
-1.0876414775848389,
0.27158308029174805,
0.42269954085350037,
-0.507258951663971,
-0.0666593462228775,
0.35059598088264465,
0.47383546829223633,
0.3392784297466278,
0.1924149990081787,
-0.2434033751487732,
0.29008927941322327,
-0.64857017993927,
0.014913203194737434,
0.24792221188545227,
-0.2559328079223633,
-0.1261596530675888,
0.9522263407707214,
0.06690184026956558,
0.38428735733032227,
0.3821905851364136,
-0.0005112931248731911,
0.16230133175849915,
0.3381238579750061,
0.4728352129459381,
0.35117554664611816,
-0.005874236114323139,
0.010323168709874153,
0.07857757061719894,
-0.7683326005935669,
-0.02247663401067257,
0.16035984456539154,
-0.030606405809521675,
0.07982610911130905,
0.5332525372505188,
0.14783872663974762,
-0.051880843937397,
-0.9734838008880615,
0.34152594208717346,
-0.003542687278240919,
-0.20701070129871368,
-0.30283859372138977,
0.019913753494620323,
0.02922818623483181,
-0.2085411548614502,
0.4433193802833557,
0.6248788237571716,
0.4376918375492096,
-0.3159625828266144,
0.7584824562072754,
0.28660449385643005,
-0.25633272528648376,
0.23046588897705078,
0.47400808334350586,
-0.10010003298521042,
-0.1599443107843399,
0.7617441415786743,
-0.1475120484828949,
-0.15012381970882416,
0.7961834669113159,
0.22614708542823792,
0.41802483797073364,
-0.06461356580257416,
0.07002557814121246,
0.31905895471572876,
-0.07988744229078293,
-0.023461921140551567,
0.28874731063842773,
0.1571495532989502,
-0.6097906827926636,
-0.6379549503326416,
-0.5865252614021301,
-0.4375286400318146,
0.08321630209684372,
-0.9468846917152405,
0.388796329498291,
-0.14946717023849487,
0.12619665265083313,
0.3338896334171295,
0.175237774848938,
-0.4768582880496979,
0.5710147619247437,
-0.09072993695735931,
0.8264877200126648,
-0.5159508585929871,
0.5678920745849609,
0.452354371547699,
-0.1944306492805481,
-0.8544199466705322,
-0.38896065950393677,
0.011987064965069294,
-1.0474636554718018,
0.319446325302124,
0.22505302727222443,
0.33524593710899353,
-0.2942880392074585,
-0.47954222559928894,
-0.550881564617157,
0.7414983510971069,
0.048910241574048996,
-0.5741732120513916,
0.009732594713568687,
-0.2322475165128708,
0.8381111025810242,
-0.08883216232061386,
0.13321971893310547,
0.430255264043808,
0.4583030045032501,
0.08505332469940186,
-0.8352948427200317,
-0.07134735584259033,
-0.7894721031188965,
-0.38202357292175293,
0.4078199565410614,
-0.10528836399316788,
0.4414936304092407,
-0.0964261144399643,
-0.3014252781867981,
0.2882201373577118,
0.4880966246128082,
0.1959685981273651,
0.5126395225524902,
0.6519753336906433,
0.8267211318016052,
1.2415969371795654,
-0.1386355459690094,
1.2628326416015625,
-0.4976033866405487,
0.17706704139709473,
0.9235638380050659,
-0.4375212490558624,
0.8143211603164673,
0.6491145491600037,
-0.025346217676997185,
0.2453938126564026,
0.6257508397102356,
-0.17268742620944977,
0.41184744238853455,
0.3306668698787689,
-0.43811431527137756,
0.11956357955932617,
0.015925148501992226,
-0.2962609827518463,
0.753462553024292,
0.350363165140152,
-0.5859397053718567,
-0.20598624646663666,
0.1680174618959427,
-0.0015784979332238436,
0.2504480481147766,
-0.4077224135398865,
1.1357039213180542,
-0.2340298742055893,
-0.8480815887451172,
0.2921682298183441,
-0.2564319670200348,
0.5230739116668701,
-0.3532865345478058,
-0.26360583305358887,
0.41885966062545776,
0.14510026574134827,
-0.47356775403022766,
-0.7568413615226746,
0.7001551985740662,
-0.031481366604566574,
-0.0015591038390994072,
-0.22167307138442993,
0.9580373764038086,
-0.36754506826400757,
-0.43763378262519836,
-0.09162800759077072,
0.6741012334823608,
0.6089910268783569,
0.14305156469345093,
-0.440927654504776,
-0.2510857582092285,
-0.05421258509159088,
0.013996000401675701,
0.33825504779815674,
0.3651488721370697,
0.1275697946548462,
0.5629643797874451,
0.6751988530158997,
0.36333349347114563,
-0.11960506439208984,
-0.1738038957118988,
0.49977394938468933,
-0.44123515486717224,
-0.28117606043815613,
-0.8240199685096741,
0.334817111492157,
-0.3555619716644287,
-0.2700125575065613,
0.3191474676132202,
0.9529172778129578,
0.5877358317375183,
0.12634362280368805,
0.8673493266105652,
-0.026080496609210968,
1.0413404703140259,
-0.6036359071731567,
0.7193178534507751,
-0.21506410837173462,
0.26916927099227905,
-0.23543985188007355,
-0.3008143901824951,
-0.4098598062992096,
0.644275426864624,
-0.014133777469396591,
0.009693227708339691,
0.773426353931427,
0.5486263036727905,
0.2901381552219391,
0.8080534338951111,
0.05448262393474579,
-0.09029952436685562,
0.17632170021533966,
0.39706024527549744,
0.3807060122489929,
-0.3311309814453125,
0.39470988512039185,
-0.5132961273193359,
-0.3498972952365875,
0.05885907635092735,
-0.6722882390022278,
-0.23316383361816406,
-0.6136184930801392,
-0.37593787908554077,
-0.28654026985168457,
0.09669390320777893,
1.024851679801941,
0.4302474558353424,
-0.7920923233032227,
0.1420373171567917,
-0.08841871470212936,
-0.12959200143814087,
-0.8504943251609802,
-0.29129305481910706,
0.6398407220840454,
-0.7437522411346436,
-0.8271026015281677,
0.26785507798194885,
0.20971736311912537,
-0.23539556562900543,
0.14712683856487274,
0.45974835753440857,
-0.42028889060020447,
-0.2165193259716034,
0.30050384998321533,
0.23391780257225037,
-0.08507645130157471,
-0.22450408339500427,
-0.050909098237752914,
-0.32027769088745117,
0.3992326259613037,
0.5089986324310303,
-0.7913718819618225,
0.40741822123527527,
0.32674136757850647,
0.814062774181366,
0.4104178547859192,
0.0711749717593193,
0.6596981883049011,
-0.7200679183006287,
-0.33902135491371155,
0.62442547082901,
0.4747169613838196,
0.29398709535598755,
-0.6380917429924011,
0.9886293411254883,
0.022171050310134888,
-0.675635039806366,
-0.7993488311767578,
-0.18087898194789886,
-1.271622896194458,
-0.4730473756790161,
1.1678485870361328,
0.11508865654468536,
-0.3723456859588623,
-0.39790546894073486,
-0.5039686560630798,
0.5052515864372253,
-0.3681083023548126,
0.7746953964233398,
0.49076664447784424,
-0.39552491903305054,
0.4892396032810211,
-0.5278542637825012,
0.4837709665298462,
0.4088161289691925,
-1.1418870687484741,
-0.3249616324901581,
0.11894092708826065,
0.12129222601652145,
0.3940615653991699,
0.6939982175827026,
-0.4599245488643646,
0.20992954075336456,
-0.07722973823547363,
0.09822908043861389,
0.29678601026535034,
-0.08577846735715866,
-0.3640560209751129,
0.7274805903434753,
-0.6114163398742676,
-0.47516125440597534
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.00787v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.00787v1
|
Applying Intrinsic Debiasing on Downstream Tasks: Challenges and Considerations for Machine Translation
| 2024-06-02T15:57:29 | 2024-06-02T15:57:29 |
Bar Iluz, Yanai Elazar, Asaf Yehudai, Gabriel Stanovsky
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Most works on gender bias focus on intrinsic bias -- removing traces of
information about a protected group from the model's internal representation.
However, these works are often disconnected from the impact of such debiasing
on downstream applications, which is the main motivation for debiasing in the
first place. In this work, we systematically test how methods for intrinsic
debiasing affect neural machine translation models, by measuring the extrinsic
bias of such systems under different design choices. We highlight three
challenges and mismatches between the debiasing techniques and their end-goal
usage, including the choice of embeddings to debias, the mismatch between words
and sub-word tokens debiasing, and the effect on different target languages. We
find that these considerations have a significant impact on downstream
performance and the success of debiasing.
|
[
-0.29462167620658875,
-0.6654329895973206,
0.4454366862773895,
0.14567531645298004,
-0.3329402506351471,
-0.03931979462504387,
-0.10884762555360794,
-0.5131965279579163,
-0.2525566518306732,
0.2712661921977997,
-0.5626984238624573,
-0.2148646116256714,
-1.1111103296279907,
0.4130338430404663,
-0.4954051673412323,
0.8724623322486877,
-0.3922845125198364,
0.2737536132335663,
0.13902418315410614,
-0.24191860854625702,
-0.7293331027030945,
-0.755440890789032,
-0.4533264935016632,
-0.4613918364048004,
0.4640901982784271,
0.21517066657543182,
0.7694478631019592,
0.434394508600235,
0.7199978828430176,
0.21350230276584625,
-0.5055440664291382,
-0.15916724503040314,
-0.22586052119731903,
0.623744785785675,
-0.2960444986820221,
-0.6373197436332703,
-0.02074577286839485,
0.2682730257511139,
0.44573211669921875,
0.7394389510154724,
0.3535802662372589,
0.3073955774307251,
0.32467585802078247,
0.7981006503105164,
-0.725692093372345,
-0.006980342790484428,
-0.6519081592559814,
0.289703369140625,
0.0570199079811573,
0.2532060444355011,
-0.22144635021686554,
-0.2622753977775574,
0.42211785912513733,
0.008434832096099854,
0.12934623658657074,
0.12253687530755997,
0.7883634567260742,
0.7506799101829529,
-0.5936883091926575,
-0.3849247992038727,
-0.7941312789916992,
0.8861576914787292,
-0.7332921624183655,
0.15776313841342926,
0.5227965116500854,
0.006694272626191378,
0.17290903627872467,
-0.1070064976811409,
-0.23683327436447144,
-0.20091195404529572,
-0.1029018685221672,
-0.03541180491447449,
-0.43456006050109863,
0.012602376751601696,
0.41330814361572266,
0.3264510929584503,
-0.148352712392807,
0.09542418271303177,
-0.44105181097984314,
0.28488799929618835,
0.23487894237041473,
-0.19375498592853546,
0.24528640508651733,
-0.1550048440694809,
-0.3533538579940796,
-0.014776747673749924,
-0.8959286212921143,
0.006026841700077057,
0.7175701260566711,
0.30801454186439514,
-0.062352199107408524,
0.7185375094413757,
-0.1470324844121933,
0.36251747608184814,
0.22016578912734985,
0.5311079025268555,
0.31891536712646484,
-0.2115737944841385,
-0.1984681338071823,
0.2153286188840866,
0.4136793315410614,
0.319499135017395,
0.10024494677782059,
-0.23564808070659637,
-0.40301215648651123,
-0.04605315625667572,
0.3691967725753784,
-0.4865249693393707,
0.33088579773902893,
0.3181959092617035,
-0.5037094950675964,
-0.4404517412185669,
-0.24048852920532227,
-0.33629217743873596,
-0.30781617760658264,
-0.7309049963951111,
0.43598100543022156,
-0.351005882024765,
-0.1047164797782898,
-0.37146374583244324,
-0.5743358135223389,
0.08137378096580505,
0.10806316882371902,
-0.9709351658821106,
0.030894553288817406,
0.5861119627952576,
0.9133281111717224,
-0.17441211640834808,
-0.09092780947685242,
-0.5794795751571655,
0.0027781554963439703,
-0.36063119769096375,
0.40643689036369324,
-0.5296007990837097,
-0.31602486968040466,
-0.2680360674858093,
-0.3000917136669159,
-0.16926415264606476,
-0.7396538853645325,
0.6668552756309509,
-0.18581730127334595,
-0.289711058139801,
-0.6991198658943176,
-0.19770580530166626,
-0.45037952065467834,
0.23828494548797607,
-0.39536619186401367,
0.860339879989624,
0.21601587533950806,
-0.5514544248580933,
0.6262126564979553,
-0.33365294337272644,
-0.46205762028694153,
-0.5055713653564453,
-0.13848130404949188,
-0.12678690254688263,
0.8906059265136719,
0.1485791653394699,
0.19624800980091095,
-0.40425631403923035,
0.4152200222015381,
-0.2835613787174225,
-0.32485440373420715,
0.2886250913143158,
-0.47815918922424316,
0.6810025572776794,
0.17500503361225128,
-1.063735842704773,
0.15827201306819916,
-0.1703636199235916,
-0.23493057489395142,
-0.2776986062526703,
0.02857024036347866,
-0.6487987637519836,
0.4163329303264618,
-0.2569087743759155,
0.49672731757164,
-0.2168361395597458,
-0.48512884974479675,
0.19261066615581512,
-0.18713746964931488,
0.5689805746078491,
1.0766220092773438,
-0.2461891770362854,
0.6379099488258362,
-0.0012667762348428369,
0.4124501943588257,
0.3235801160335541,
0.35930514335632324,
0.1991482377052307,
-0.6346059441566467,
-0.7810385823249817,
-0.16866743564605713,
0.449114054441452,
0.4530183970928192,
-0.6434975266456604,
0.36670565605163574,
-0.1873898059129715,
-0.252871572971344,
-0.5953289866447449,
0.15927006304264069,
0.45360836386680603,
0.4370517432689667,
0.4031310975551605,
-0.03109339438378811,
-0.36146020889282227,
-1.338649868965149,
-0.46747633814811707,
-0.057256534695625305,
0.08090361207723618,
0.007175015285611153,
0.8656335473060608,
-0.457285612821579,
0.6958515644073486,
-0.29572543501853943,
-0.4295611083507538,
-0.14272712171077728,
0.48917338252067566,
0.2568920850753784,
0.684514582157135,
0.590675950050354,
-0.8156381249427795,
-0.36787357926368713,
-0.009810216724872589,
-0.8100351691246033,
-0.42457690834999084,
-0.08976752310991287,
-0.3505203425884247,
0.24024264514446259,
0.3396153450012207,
-0.6322049498558044,
0.7364799380302429,
0.504423201084137,
-0.26157745718955994,
0.39713871479034424,
-0.03081418015062809,
0.19852103292942047,
-0.4862264394760132,
0.1407366245985031,
0.01570245809853077,
0.0547989122569561,
-0.44539666175842285,
0.3867748975753784,
0.032814960926771164,
0.2051403522491455,
-0.5417253971099854,
0.158596009016037,
-0.5297757983207703,
-0.021279335021972656,
-0.289171040058136,
-0.028736623004078865,
-0.04464426636695862,
0.3224514424800873,
-0.05375253036618233,
0.5351988673210144,
0.302388459444046,
-0.818530797958374,
-0.05229844152927399,
0.2265397310256958,
-0.0795898586511612,
0.4979405105113983,
-0.8196534514427185,
0.17123033106327057,
-0.30840829014778137,
-0.04857272282242775,
-0.7904014587402344,
0.3335376977920532,
0.5866246819496155,
-0.5241739749908447,
0.4181247055530548,
-0.3601681888103485,
-0.32276538014411926,
-0.15219949185848236,
-0.34126392006874084,
0.3251176178455353,
0.48223742842674255,
-0.21627461910247803,
0.49760618805885315,
0.20665545761585236,
-0.10916942358016968,
-0.654655396938324,
-1.192635178565979,
0.21159547567367554,
-0.34397992491722107,
-0.36449334025382996,
0.5868037343025208,
0.23308421671390533,
-0.5102816820144653,
0.09716378897428513,
-0.3981514871120453,
0.15732277929782867,
0.31803980469703674,
0.2994815409183502,
0.10025027394294739,
0.18718291819095612,
-0.09555863589048386,
0.6325092315673828,
-0.21400922536849976,
0.13937817513942719,
-0.47620365023612976,
0.33703625202178955,
0.10930255800485611,
-0.48324933648109436,
-0.2517503798007965,
0.7192404866218567,
0.5702956318855286,
-0.043265510350465775,
0.7788791656494141,
0.40786924958229065,
-0.5054075717926025,
-0.12796296179294586,
-0.40323638916015625,
-0.16235338151454926,
-0.40509286522865295,
0.24242143332958221,
-0.34045085310935974,
-0.6335236430168152,
0.5296626687049866,
0.3483189642429352,
0.09261122345924377,
0.5047657489776611,
0.5779513716697693,
-0.12933441996574402,
1.2980884313583374,
0.2923595607280731,
-0.2126600742340088,
0.2424623817205429,
-0.20204631984233856,
0.4854808747768402,
-1.303540587425232,
-0.02463761903345585,
-0.8953392505645752,
-1.0303338766098022,
-0.40889105200767517,
-0.3047056794166565,
0.2994900643825531,
0.2988470494747162,
-0.24258635938167572,
0.4574713408946991,
-0.5159973502159119,
0.11769876629114151,
0.9209216237068176,
-0.07344646006822586,
0.25428110361099243,
0.047254275530576706,
-0.1988719254732132,
-0.3161669671535492,
-0.25869715213775635,
-0.5890809893608093,
0.8807690739631653,
0.28291791677474976,
0.777608335018158,
0.35087671875953674,
0.3750615417957306,
0.46356630325317383,
0.4227586090564728,
-0.8268049359321594,
0.21828292310237885,
-0.29102206230163574,
-0.9863213896751404,
0.08951699733734131,
-0.5206816792488098,
-0.5506259202957153,
0.561462938785553,
0.18645168840885162,
-0.7238475680351257,
0.504543125629425,
0.17813877761363983,
-0.12858492136001587,
0.2936326563358307,
-0.7906613349914551,
0.5830352306365967,
-0.41128191351890564,
-0.3579815626144409,
-0.08270957320928574,
-0.614608883857727,
0.285299152135849,
-0.0707663744688034,
-0.053113311529159546,
-0.14640797674655914,
0.024056099355220795,
0.48863956332206726,
-0.06784874945878983,
0.9136946797370911,
-0.2970469295978546,
-0.2533347010612488,
0.25460514426231384,
0.27623996138572693,
0.3961600065231323,
-0.04781690239906311,
-0.2706277668476105,
0.5790996551513672,
-0.11093657463788986,
-0.06349918991327286,
-0.3697762191295624,
0.608049213886261,
-0.7095199227333069,
-0.8567802309989929,
-0.5754434466362,
-0.48361051082611084,
-0.09267420321702957,
0.15030847489833832,
0.4701429307460785,
0.1565784215927124,
0.21076779067516327,
0.3476927578449249,
0.40301182866096497,
-0.3161557614803314,
0.41130951046943665,
0.32193896174430847,
-0.056094471365213394,
-0.22834163904190063,
0.589198648929596,
0.33067241311073303,
0.3761312961578369,
0.44611844420433044,
0.2729797959327698,
-0.38121703267097473,
-0.7336695194244385,
-0.7173357009887695,
-0.3124755024909973,
-0.710738480091095,
-0.08235921710729599,
-0.6967359185218811,
0.20380257070064545,
-0.5193678736686707,
0.17402392625808716,
-0.31940460205078125,
-0.4331341087818146,
-0.3119736611843109,
-0.15318424999713898,
-0.21059028804302216,
0.6202763915061951,
-0.09837117791175842,
0.18710780143737793,
-0.9565737843513489,
0.35211992263793945,
0.02686951868236065,
-0.09073933959007263,
-0.1351531744003296,
-0.6822627186775208,
-0.1290794461965561,
0.4304393529891968,
-0.5182533860206604,
-1.1033023595809937,
0.42525896430015564,
0.004965754225850105,
0.718479573726654,
0.27696165442466736,
0.11170578002929688,
0.3526883125305176,
-0.47104474902153015,
0.7841355204582214,
-0.08088397234678268,
-1.3640986680984497,
0.6068455576896667,
-0.40679100155830383,
0.1626068353652954,
0.7690188884735107,
0.5290476679801941,
-0.6725564002990723,
-0.341382771730423,
-0.10211780667304993,
-1.152241826057434,
0.6202141642570496,
0.6673955321311951,
0.1725059151649475,
-0.11625022441148758,
0.4134860038757324,
0.2721879780292511,
0.6187154650688171,
-0.5181698203086853,
-0.3198707401752472,
0.21580441296100616,
-0.07754280418157578,
0.10916280001401901,
-0.1270495504140854,
0.06356369704008102,
-0.34037867188453674,
0.793444812297821,
-0.12827327847480774,
0.31505537033081055,
0.407515287399292,
-0.5482084155082703,
-0.016803985461592674,
0.1884436160326004,
0.7038189768791199,
0.3047454059123993,
-0.15974409878253937,
0.13560961186885834,
0.054147254675626755,
-0.36022233963012695,
0.37610316276550293,
-0.17976294457912445,
-0.8492595553398132,
0.2088855355978012,
0.1269819289445877,
0.9098363518714905,
-0.025273747742176056,
-0.48952600359916687,
0.22634460031986237,
0.01539742574095726,
-0.09811505675315857,
-0.0005097053945064545,
-0.2882336378097534,
-0.21262532472610474,
0.07637093216180801,
0.5040141940116882,
0.5283975005149841,
0.2117590308189392,
-0.47767987847328186,
-0.2142629474401474,
0.40377774834632874,
-0.8981590270996094,
-0.5099492073059082,
0.6665506958961487,
0.24958962202072144,
0.08477094024419785,
0.6934942603111267,
-0.21294772624969482,
-0.9145798683166504,
0.658721387386322,
0.29326513409614563,
1.3978595733642578,
-0.20743858814239502,
0.06209978461265564,
0.169297993183136,
0.9242444634437561,
-0.008812430314719677,
0.069219671189785,
-0.0009884076425805688,
-0.4520179033279419,
-0.5488356351852417,
-0.24507366120815277,
-0.42974862456321716,
-0.279954195022583,
-0.6435075402259827,
0.1705566793680191,
-0.08356230705976486,
-0.6024702787399292,
-0.37041282653808594,
-0.6808964610099792,
-0.593112051486969,
0.08762510865926743,
0.3740694522857666,
0.6576747298240662,
-0.6005408763885498,
0.32439011335372925,
0.6850216388702393,
-0.5336086750030518,
-0.26963695883750916,
-0.038816750049591064,
0.22180615365505219,
-0.424252986907959,
1.3471404314041138,
0.26469144225120544,
-0.15862034261226654,
-0.31401410698890686,
-0.27257564663887024,
-0.9709998965263367,
0.6720076203346252,
0.5433022379875183,
-0.4330388605594635,
-0.25991031527519226,
0.3341165781021118,
0.23545686900615692,
-0.1556522101163864,
0.39197859168052673,
0.6496279239654541,
0.631074845790863,
-0.5577529668807983,
-0.727820098400116,
0.14904431998729706,
-0.3636806011199951,
0.0011099850526079535,
0.22670722007751465,
-0.49833378195762634,
1.0108206272125244,
0.08637934923171997,
-0.14473192393779755,
-0.33145785331726074,
0.18087440729141235,
-0.13504712283611298,
-0.005189700052142143,
0.5928299427032471,
0.5917730331420898,
0.40589895844459534,
-0.33306750655174255,
1.1056329011917114,
-0.14672918617725372,
0.14004850387573242,
1.1971372365951538,
-0.5853963494300842,
0.5474711060523987,
0.864058256149292,
-0.06308923661708832,
0.2530268132686615,
0.5764200091362,
0.2666999399662018,
0.5596876740455627,
0.41810548305511475,
-0.034804172813892365,
0.15175367891788483,
-0.2175045609474182,
-0.5321333408355713,
0.3890354335308075,
0.32400596141815186,
-0.7078790068626404,
-0.1163613498210907,
0.07546587288379669,
-0.094797283411026,
-0.36628639698028564,
-0.04864716902375221,
0.49369558691978455,
0.3451182544231415,
-0.9568960070610046,
0.4439062774181366,
0.33000078797340393,
0.7635825276374817,
-0.5245445966720581,
0.11813519150018692,
-0.2788262665271759,
0.4029480218887329,
-0.07702130824327469,
-0.3908670246601105,
0.7761653065681458,
0.15424294769763947,
-0.2809165418148041,
-0.5824698805809021,
0.7048954367637634,
-0.026839852333068848,
-0.29445770382881165,
0.5555770397186279,
0.5610367655754089,
-0.2946554124355316,
-0.8309817314147949,
-0.5889641046524048,
0.13704246282577515,
0.16501682996749878,
-0.4883362352848053,
0.1949138641357422,
0.21390379965305328,
0.01788926310837269,
0.6296629905700684,
0.5960687398910522,
0.1373228132724762,
0.1971241980791092,
0.04324403777718544,
0.7252130508422852,
-0.7216137051582336,
-0.3587862551212311,
-1.2549629211425781,
0.44804492592811584,
-0.024067861959338188,
-0.6174374222755432,
0.7816452383995056,
0.32257989048957825,
0.7292769551277161,
-0.2266426682472229,
0.9227967262268066,
-0.19623607397079468,
0.03406893089413643,
-0.39169761538505554,
0.7448100447654724,
-0.36717507243156433,
0.252802312374115,
-0.4823208153247833,
-1.17689847946167,
-0.05193892493844032,
0.5665623545646667,
-0.4038725793361664,
0.007818778045475483,
0.9759537577629089,
0.38339686393737793,
0.18863140046596527,
0.15433143079280853,
0.1258193701505661,
-0.08601248264312744,
0.4152114689350128,
0.5378116369247437,
1.1169040203094482,
-0.6242850422859192,
0.3662317991256714,
-0.46979066729545593,
-0.17696566879749298,
0.0307123064994812,
-0.9749920964241028,
-0.7439611554145813,
-0.32120516896247864,
-0.5038658976554871,
-0.1713670939207077,
0.04478692635893822,
0.9168705940246582,
0.7135615348815918,
-0.7291603684425354,
0.06777023524045944,
-0.13113068044185638,
0.3219994604587555,
-0.5267151594161987,
-0.14992718398571014,
0.04785362258553505,
-0.3552345037460327,
-1.0010019540786743,
0.11914795637130737,
0.18980558216571808,
-0.0482429675757885,
-0.27991974353790283,
0.15959282219409943,
-0.2676953375339508,
-0.23735709488391876,
0.6257757544517517,
-0.29181304574012756,
-0.5205356478691101,
-0.31397077441215515,
0.21370245516300201,
-0.07502829283475876,
-0.12407229095697403,
1.066762924194336,
-0.5934895873069763,
0.19707275927066803,
0.800345242023468,
0.7714457511901855,
0.17861776053905487,
-0.036084871739149094,
0.7753129005432129,
-0.686438262462616,
0.10449739545583725,
0.2950012683868408,
0.3144342601299286,
0.23807145655155182,
-0.48642516136169434,
0.6640353798866272,
0.27805039286613464,
-0.30620864033699036,
-0.8384260535240173,
0.2998121976852417,
-0.4387322962284088,
-0.2939054071903229,
1.2198420763015747,
-0.11323726922273636,
-0.22460085153579712,
-0.23275260627269745,
-0.33414924144744873,
0.29620543122291565,
-0.3595406115055084,
0.5658373236656189,
0.9150717854499817,
0.1665176898241043,
0.2556127905845642,
-0.6812922954559326,
0.08808388561010361,
0.8558809161186218,
-0.39185425639152527,
0.05243075266480446,
0.32296493649482727,
-0.1276690661907196,
0.11319821327924728,
0.16290749609470367,
-0.23214399814605713,
-0.09275948256254196,
-0.17045819759368896,
0.024021731689572334,
0.10767299681901932,
-0.06934231519699097,
-0.4897542893886566,
-0.23090963065624237,
-0.10219871997833252,
-0.2096603363752365
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.