id
stringlengths 33
33
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
33
| title
stringlengths 13
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 6
16.6k
| category_primary
stringclasses 60
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
132
| abstract
stringlengths 123
1.99k
| embeddings
listlengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.02818v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.02818v1
|
Chain of Agents: Large Language Models Collaborating on Long-Context Tasks
| 2024-06-04T23:36:08 | 2024-06-04T23:36:08 |
Yusen Zhang, Ruoxi Sun, Yanfei Chen, Tomas Pfister, Rui Zhang, Sercan Ö. Arik
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Addressing the challenge of effectively processing long contexts has become a
critical issue for Large Language Models (LLMs). Two common strategies have
emerged: 1) reducing the input length, such as retrieving relevant chunks by
Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG), and 2) expanding the context window limit
of LLMs. However, both strategies have drawbacks: input reduction has no
guarantee of covering the part with needed information, while window extension
struggles with focusing on the pertinent information for solving the task. To
mitigate these limitations, we propose Chain-of-Agents (CoA), a novel framework
that harnesses multi-agent collaboration through natural language to enable
information aggregation and context reasoning across various LLMs over
long-context tasks. CoA consists of multiple worker agents who sequentially
communicate to handle different segmented portions of the text, followed by a
manager agent who synthesizes these contributions into a coherent final output.
CoA processes the entire input by interleaving reading and reasoning, and it
mitigates long context focus issues by assigning each agent a short context. We
perform comprehensive evaluation of CoA on a wide range of long-context tasks
in question answering, summarization, and code completion, demonstrating
significant improvements by up to 10% over strong baselines of RAG,
Full-Context, and multi-agent LLMs.
|
[
-0.6763684153556824,
-0.9692966341972351,
0.8463850617408752,
0.23515181243419647,
-0.07898179441690445,
0.30237606167793274,
-0.5252065062522888,
-0.7466700673103333,
0.2530566155910492,
0.7860088348388672,
-0.4977611303329468,
-0.2512909173965454,
-0.4001575708389282,
0.28624483942985535,
-0.373578280210495,
1.0788731575012207,
-0.059856828302145004,
-0.4569022059440613,
-0.4093097150325775,
-0.1091047078371048,
-0.5069769024848938,
-0.532427191734314,
-0.8462061882019043,
-0.289393812417984,
0.8495942950248718,
0.3153373897075653,
0.6936233043670654,
0.6211708188056946,
0.3476390540599823,
0.3221815228462219,
-0.03556346520781517,
0.722288191318512,
-0.565002977848053,
0.4133974313735962,
-0.5142890214920044,
-0.03611164540052414,
-0.8320569396018982,
-0.3245835602283478,
0.7403885126113892,
0.7451024651527405,
0.09179216623306274,
0.0960746631026268,
0.21376372873783112,
0.766808271408081,
-0.8397496938705444,
0.06578156352043152,
-0.4073195159435272,
-0.4128168225288391,
0.012916725128889084,
-0.3825471103191376,
-0.6467992663383484,
0.2662115693092346,
0.25186556577682495,
-0.47842857241630554,
-0.39225658774375916,
0.04683578759431839,
0.44322270154953003,
0.18650077283382416,
-0.8012132048606873,
-0.4418182671070099,
-0.7932702898979187,
0.6716762185096741,
-0.42789462208747864,
0.028985291719436646,
0.46000543236732483,
0.10469947010278702,
-0.43340110778808594,
-0.7144749164581299,
-0.5586495995521545,
-0.08589054644107819,
-0.0454815998673439,
-0.06933601945638657,
-0.06963932514190674,
0.26856765151023865,
-0.014094175770878792,
0.09406405687332153,
-0.3700887858867645,
0.014986091293394566,
-0.26761409640312195,
0.06666312366724014,
0.6244925260543823,
0.08220994472503662,
0.20868593454360962,
0.24379786849021912,
-0.6401678919792175,
0.1266259402036667,
-0.5347113609313965,
-0.08135638386011124,
-0.1164279580116272,
0.3972940146923065,
-0.08259208500385284,
0.3346831798553467,
-0.2601027190685272,
0.9483129382133484,
-0.14539304375648499,
-0.23328080773353577,
-0.005700645036995411,
-0.4226361811161041,
-0.3456437885761261,
-0.1135890781879425,
0.6516050100326538,
0.2558737099170685,
0.051317282021045685,
-0.33950915932655334,
-0.21712978184223175,
-0.24540387094020844,
0.12607091665267944,
-0.5660694241523743,
0.5067905187606812,
0.22551178932189941,
-0.06722275167703629,
-0.04735379293560982,
0.04416384920477867,
-0.4966874420642853,
-0.23615358769893646,
-0.45675987005233765,
0.2890731692314148,
-0.136782705783844,
-0.08161772042512894,
0.03570318594574928,
-0.13599002361297607,
0.13295310735702515,
0.3890439569950104,
-0.443837434053421,
0.571280300617218,
0.8562288880348206,
0.8714625239372253,
-0.2847040295600891,
-0.6534891128540039,
-0.9410997033119202,
0.6660430431365967,
-0.30056363344192505,
0.5488998889923096,
-0.5235841274261475,
-0.06555067002773285,
-0.025026999413967133,
0.14966827630996704,
-0.020992320030927658,
-0.2677902281284332,
0.16389501094818115,
-0.6652650237083435,
0.02763551101088524,
-0.2079387754201889,
-0.4832448363304138,
0.0465642474591732,
0.4364359676837921,
-0.8326314687728882,
0.837377667427063,
0.1158592626452446,
-0.509990394115448,
0.10131664574146271,
-0.7332380414009094,
-0.6984631419181824,
-0.09509549289941788,
-0.05087438225746155,
0.05361361429095268,
-0.03338172659277916,
0.15830156207084656,
0.5265092849731445,
-0.6031990051269531,
0.4327855408191681,
-0.18773332238197327,
-0.4140687584877014,
0.2969101071357727,
-0.3254382610321045,
0.42107561230659485,
0.234329953789711,
-0.25288254022598267,
0.333479642868042,
-0.5843013525009155,
-0.14408226311206818,
-0.1401432454586029,
-0.4499920904636383,
-0.6443310976028442,
0.05417107790708542,
-0.13321389257907867,
0.4542563855648041,
0.32013410329818726,
-0.15251822769641876,
0.4991132318973541,
-0.19002535939216614,
0.49144619703292847,
0.7116343975067139,
-0.037798695266246796,
0.7364357113838196,
-0.4129057228565216,
0.43446967005729675,
-0.13102108240127563,
0.0823274701833725,
-0.1449446678161621,
-0.10315940529108047,
-0.6684010624885559,
-0.4684830605983734,
-0.1391122043132782,
0.22931641340255737,
-1.3027029037475586,
0.5017077326774597,
-0.3937511146068573,
-0.1489299237728119,
0.0163855142891407,
0.17872676253318787,
0.3939749598503113,
0.43169084191322327,
0.2443147897720337,
-0.3381595313549042,
-0.43402114510536194,
-0.6509274840354919,
0.02436636947095394,
-0.10809480398893356,
0.0672307163476944,
0.10228989273309708,
0.6053563952445984,
-0.43512606620788574,
1.2424262762069702,
-0.34602686762809753,
-0.2768535614013672,
-0.4135226607322693,
-0.05353507399559021,
0.15338458120822906,
0.2649385929107666,
0.18183934688568115,
-0.793907105922699,
-0.5097057819366455,
0.14263898134231567,
-0.5835515260696411,
0.03723687306046486,
-0.08885622769594193,
-0.35549360513687134,
0.4583205282688141,
0.5562938451766968,
-0.7054605484008789,
0.3310629725456238,
0.7365537881851196,
-0.3930632770061493,
0.533510148525238,
-0.20362867414951324,
-0.07144581526517868,
-1.2616565227508545,
0.1519700288772583,
-0.3153305947780609,
-0.6533555388450623,
-0.7163098454475403,
0.2565610706806183,
-0.24820977449417114,
0.00352349947206676,
-0.4141198396682739,
0.7923718690872192,
-0.699016273021698,
-0.1352127194404602,
-0.6078428626060486,
0.38586440682411194,
0.3534378111362457,
0.5558969378471375,
0.024217944592237473,
0.8215417265892029,
0.4853385388851166,
-0.8473474979400635,
0.37243446707725525,
-0.027540653944015503,
-0.1340898722410202,
0.5153293013572693,
-0.3488946259021759,
0.4171410799026489,
-0.20878903567790985,
0.8553472757339478,
-0.6780344247817993,
-0.29814326763153076,
0.03926137834787369,
-0.13058942556381226,
-0.009790059179067612,
0.05689939484000206,
-0.5949715375900269,
-0.36974456906318665,
-0.20811499655246735,
0.6844184398651123,
0.08902761340141296,
-0.6529030799865723,
0.7833064198493958,
0.43591102957725525,
0.017603587359189987,
-0.8398571610450745,
-0.6414814591407776,
0.27954307198524475,
-0.099431611597538,
-0.7821651101112366,
0.38291478157043457,
0.014360698871314526,
-0.3924562633037567,
-0.01575985550880432,
-0.13763593137264252,
-0.41323190927505493,
0.08561540395021439,
0.03390383720397949,
0.09015496075153351,
0.024615630507469177,
0.5198631286621094,
0.0363827645778656,
0.10640442371368408,
-0.004489349201321602,
-0.37150317430496216,
0.7683240175247192,
-0.23188304901123047,
-0.0997449979186058,
0.015688598155975342,
0.5552064776420593,
0.8003409504890442,
-0.4682549238204956,
0.9745429754257202,
0.32530477643013,
-0.32633543014526367,
-0.5863274335861206,
-0.48390236496925354,
-0.03459284082055092,
-0.44989731907844543,
0.35702142119407654,
-0.42817026376724243,
-1.181416392326355,
0.4578786790370941,
-0.2456798404455185,
-0.08778226375579834,
0.1803944855928421,
0.4836038053035736,
0.13048696517944336,
0.7284498810768127,
0.6686545610427856,
-0.42662402987480164,
0.41083964705467224,
-0.26730266213417053,
0.21526996791362762,
-0.9158437848091125,
0.05854091793298721,
-0.24697647988796234,
0.031288452446460724,
-0.18419788777828217,
-0.8223316073417664,
0.4294757544994354,
0.12969596683979034,
-0.13617080450057983,
0.34754109382629395,
-0.3256501853466034,
0.6214913129806519,
0.2954052984714508,
0.05988401547074318,
0.5158252120018005,
-0.12778738141059875,
0.17352890968322754,
0.7833738923072815,
-0.6661611199378967,
-0.5325895547866821,
0.6857233643531799,
0.37999773025512695,
0.6402636170387268,
0.2520889937877655,
0.6566299200057983,
0.361413836479187,
0.157403826713562,
-0.8155573606491089,
0.7436178922653198,
0.019055506214499474,
-0.6167424321174622,
-0.6412480473518372,
-0.447578489780426,
-1.083591341972351,
0.38706839084625244,
0.09435168653726578,
-0.7571195960044861,
-0.030210847035050392,
-0.12800653278827667,
-0.1773194968700409,
0.26124680042266846,
-0.354908287525177,
0.6318768858909607,
-0.11632561683654785,
-0.76167231798172,
-0.2646670341491699,
-0.7918033003807068,
0.27880990505218506,
-0.06278090924024582,
0.505905270576477,
-0.02232358045876026,
-0.20613008737564087,
0.5181217789649963,
-0.760371208190918,
0.7899251580238342,
0.2758587896823883,
-0.4125867486000061,
0.7893750071525574,
-0.009450952522456646,
0.8066865801811218,
-0.013668706640601158,
-0.11887742578983307,
-0.19942231476306915,
-0.10705961287021637,
-0.3906996250152588,
-0.660175085067749,
0.6090455651283264,
-0.41485705971717834,
-0.4534473121166229,
-0.3884621560573578,
-0.8491434454917908,
-0.14289626479148865,
0.25308266282081604,
-0.10747014731168747,
0.5646035075187683,
-0.19560402631759644,
0.2369662970304489,
0.11649510264396667,
0.09781619906425476,
0.7151109576225281,
0.468566358089447,
-0.29802680015563965,
-0.3762025237083435,
0.7369990944862366,
-0.07713662832975388,
0.6522626876831055,
0.5265958905220032,
0.04116426408290863,
-0.1690327227115631,
-0.08991073071956635,
-0.1790337860584259,
0.16965939104557037,
-0.7661076784133911,
-0.09838887304067612,
-0.3998003602027893,
-0.13428963720798492,
-0.35742953419685364,
-0.2372198849916458,
-0.24170902371406555,
-0.03747700899839401,
-0.03821338340640068,
0.0681753158569336,
0.17791715264320374,
0.7685154676437378,
0.07612591236829758,
0.33725786209106445,
-0.7007163763046265,
0.21999721229076385,
0.30319416522979736,
0.3310790956020355,
0.2441946417093277,
0.0026438503991812468,
-0.558574914932251,
-0.012418117374181747,
-0.1608784943819046,
-0.7470635771751404,
0.35140636563301086,
-0.023200659081339836,
0.17311450839042664,
0.15104861557483673,
0.23891714215278625,
0.8532368540763855,
-0.4541144073009491,
0.6363763213157654,
0.20634567737579346,
-1.1946485042572021,
0.2105819582939148,
-0.43956995010375977,
0.4241505265235901,
0.5746344327926636,
0.1551821380853653,
-0.5517097115516663,
-0.5429736375808716,
-0.14927196502685547,
-1.0870352983474731,
0.6584084033966064,
0.29883429408073425,
-0.21995830535888672,
-0.3227942883968353,
0.15766005218029022,
-0.02022550068795681,
0.35642898082733154,
-0.6957642436027527,
-0.05084820091724396,
0.5326902866363525,
-0.013193848542869091,
-0.17748646438121796,
-0.18879365921020508,
-0.2295178920030594,
-0.20981189608573914,
0.5122938752174377,
-0.3925964832305908,
0.026010500267148018,
0.5174654722213745,
-0.3518790304660797,
0.04881065711379051,
0.5440469980239868,
0.7040103077888489,
1.2132213115692139,
-0.006081097759306431,
0.45503464341163635,
0.1495819091796875,
-0.13876588642597198,
0.11575610190629959,
-0.23033908009529114,
0.21863748133182526,
-0.17054182291030884,
0.6175068020820618,
0.7906500697135925,
-0.10432857275009155,
-0.7929041981697083,
0.4593496322631836,
-0.01200562622398138,
-0.048906680196523666,
-0.4189797341823578,
-0.17461475729942322,
0.07325820624828339,
0.36712557077407837,
0.5169682502746582,
-0.12181489169597626,
0.19641222059726715,
-0.9720093011856079,
0.34344491362571716,
0.32794517278671265,
-0.2912837862968445,
-0.062110017985105515,
0.15461741387844086,
0.4583021104335785,
-0.26653212308883667,
0.373282253742218,
-0.2995398938655853,
-0.5116521716117859,
0.8646363615989685,
0.6641786694526672,
0.7610485553741455,
0.03032727912068367,
0.07632441073656082,
-0.05952959507703781,
0.21624261140823364,
-0.33324387669563293,
-0.056568827480077744,
-0.23034028708934784,
-0.5730225443840027,
-0.956634521484375,
-0.40698012709617615,
-0.40293270349502563,
0.16530606150627136,
-0.5698832869529724,
0.15678510069847107,
-0.1513504981994629,
-0.28835850954055786,
-0.4106270968914032,
0.006157463416457176,
-0.509268581867218,
0.09446321427822113,
0.1534421294927597,
0.7451608777046204,
-0.4773581027984619,
0.9948583841323853,
0.5515144467353821,
-0.378438264131546,
-0.6781553030014038,
0.18566769361495972,
-0.3142770230770111,
-0.34755459427833557,
0.6024948954582214,
0.42667055130004883,
-0.4530159831047058,
-0.12016303092241287,
-0.4911559522151947,
-0.9340975284576416,
1.157383918762207,
0.243043914437294,
-0.7196761965751648,
-0.2228696644306183,
0.14244160056114197,
0.6342318058013916,
-0.7589966654777527,
0.16756059229373932,
0.6025956273078918,
0.4991872012615204,
0.11888895183801651,
-1.204928994178772,
0.340351939201355,
-0.0592196024954319,
-0.1779685765504837,
0.29961472749710083,
-0.7633971571922302,
1.0164604187011719,
-0.010752199217677116,
-0.14202971756458282,
0.14838221669197083,
0.5742563009262085,
0.3701898157596588,
0.6482722759246826,
0.7549813389778137,
0.19114647805690765,
0.8071736693382263,
0.2455584555864334,
1.151424527168274,
-0.38351237773895264,
0.24164699018001556,
1.4555641412734985,
-0.6269724369049072,
0.7706162929534912,
0.6890396475791931,
0.09434586763381958,
0.6254807710647583,
0.12643097341060638,
0.4660203456878662,
0.22333860397338867,
0.37216198444366455,
-0.5005583167076111,
-0.16541849076747894,
-0.38243696093559265,
-0.15779586136341095,
0.45844152569770813,
0.2444460690021515,
-0.22240279614925385,
-0.03658184036612511,
0.11572645604610443,
0.08146762102842331,
0.12042811512947083,
-0.36924877762794495,
0.7517672181129456,
0.250672310590744,
-1.0515655279159546,
0.5403318405151367,
-0.0631609708070755,
0.5576122403144836,
-0.5240347385406494,
-0.03254774585366249,
0.06623924523591995,
0.2830343544483185,
-0.06669393181800842,
-0.645327627658844,
0.290299654006958,
-0.06348752230405807,
-0.3918459117412567,
-0.1714911311864853,
0.8008325099945068,
-0.7615759968757629,
-0.1688317507505417,
0.8287153244018555,
0.4720134139060974,
0.04016947001218796,
-0.3326186239719391,
-0.19990186393260956,
0.255817711353302,
-0.5196830034255981,
-0.20628073811531067,
0.20862136781215668,
0.4889090061187744,
-0.3651750683784485,
0.7841432094573975,
0.5276095867156982,
-0.025173114612698555,
-0.2020045667886734,
0.11292533576488495,
1.1073094606399536,
-0.6849931478500366,
-0.6361042261123657,
-1.0602349042892456,
0.5172050595283508,
-0.3224162459373474,
-0.01634669117629528,
0.5096869468688965,
0.5958893299102783,
0.7527948617935181,
-0.015415916219353676,
0.6991769075393677,
-0.09896059334278107,
0.21066193282604218,
-0.4681040048599243,
0.6333699822425842,
-0.6747239232063293,
0.27057167887687683,
-0.2749366760253906,
-0.9433591365814209,
-0.05985746532678604,
0.2573905885219574,
-0.19802385568618774,
-0.053203850984573364,
0.9936312437057495,
0.34165629744529724,
0.14070285856723785,
-0.4017418324947357,
0.21327432990074158,
0.09175591915845871,
0.5747559666633606,
0.8442068099975586,
0.8353810906410217,
-0.22582264244556427,
0.5785295963287354,
-0.08726920932531357,
-0.18338972330093384,
-0.12635613977909088,
-0.8734839558601379,
-1.1210565567016602,
-0.6541097164154053,
-0.0030879564583301544,
-0.3116069734096527,
0.20848369598388672,
1.0744549036026,
0.7739441990852356,
-0.25266125798225403,
-0.691912829875946,
-0.17543445527553558,
0.48419466614723206,
-0.33285605907440186,
-0.23489609360694885,
0.24031682312488556,
-0.3461161255836487,
-0.673968493938446,
0.6605185270309448,
0.4380526542663574,
-0.3385533094406128,
-0.2729025185108185,
-0.4227721691131592,
-0.46554893255233765,
0.2184702754020691,
1.1027476787567139,
0.1995546817779541,
-0.7172066569328308,
-0.3364546000957489,
-0.1801103800535202,
-0.2752232253551483,
-0.16288092732429504,
0.7236415147781372,
-0.773345947265625,
0.38159555196762085,
0.617870032787323,
0.7047444581985474,
0.42771685123443604,
0.19561156630516052,
0.8277996778488159,
-0.949890673160553,
0.3244115114212036,
0.11263814568519592,
0.22137759625911713,
0.053155262023210526,
-0.25270548462867737,
0.7430868744850159,
-0.12650030851364136,
-0.6658245325088501,
-0.9344423413276672,
0.2831535339355469,
-1.1896653175354004,
-0.6105450987815857,
1.2869709730148315,
0.0073387413285672665,
-0.579268753528595,
-0.12845544517040253,
-0.22595708072185516,
0.3163219690322876,
-0.5788827538490295,
0.34638655185699463,
0.768516480922699,
0.009873095899820328,
0.07744188606739044,
-0.2494552582502365,
0.2662239670753479,
0.17374373972415924,
-1.0545402765274048,
0.13827396929264069,
0.5349367260932922,
-0.053535714745521545,
0.3637036085128784,
0.9302150011062622,
0.2895503640174866,
0.07323624193668365,
-0.44361722469329834,
0.027371149510145187,
-0.2505289316177368,
-0.8387730121612549,
-0.12737974524497986,
0.21266241371631622,
-0.030099771916866302,
-0.0536438450217247
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.02804v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.02804v1
|
$\texttt{ACCORD}$: Closing the Commonsense Measurability Gap
| 2024-06-04T22:08:24 | 2024-06-04T22:08:24 |
François Roewer-Després, Jinyue Feng, Zining Zhu, Frank Rudzicz
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, I.2.0; I.2.7
|
We present $\texttt{ACCORD}$, a framework and benchmark suite for
disentangling the commonsense grounding and reasoning abilities of large
language models (LLMs) through controlled, multi-hop counterfactuals.
$\texttt{ACCORD}$ introduces formal elements to commonsense reasoning to
explicitly control and quantify reasoning complexity beyond the typical 1 or 2
hops. Uniquely, $\texttt{ACCORD}$ can automatically generate benchmarks of
arbitrary reasoning complexity, and so it scales with future LLM improvements.
Benchmarking state-of-the-art LLMs -- including GPT-4o (2024-05-13),
Llama-3-70B-Instruct, and Mixtral-8x22B-Instruct-v0.1 -- shows performance
degrading to random chance with only moderate scaling, leaving substantial
headroom for improvement. We release a leaderboard of the benchmark suite
tested in this work, as well as code for automatically generating more complex
benchmarks.
|
[
-0.35214248299598694,
-0.9711642265319824,
0.7891185879707336,
0.15391646325588226,
-0.1079697236418724,
-0.11367464810609818,
-0.2616824805736542,
-0.27344444394111633,
-0.3844072222709656,
0.20729924738407135,
-0.5406827330589294,
-0.361235648393631,
-0.7439517378807068,
0.07721199840307236,
-0.16250403225421906,
0.4079642593860626,
-0.13104791939258575,
-0.21016544103622437,
-0.44681984186172485,
-0.47930908203125,
-0.522777259349823,
-0.47692787647247314,
-0.5201439261436462,
-0.3104099631309509,
0.4193204939365387,
0.5718128085136414,
0.7669899463653564,
0.33903196454048157,
0.41430187225341797,
0.4180006682872772,
0.027526002377271652,
0.2514539659023285,
-0.5110724568367004,
-0.057298749685287476,
-0.43315574526786804,
-0.41144177317619324,
-0.6862547993659973,
0.37800896167755127,
0.5795129537582397,
0.5425703525543213,
-0.24236607551574707,
-0.051809944212436676,
-0.14508472383022308,
0.6131711602210999,
-0.7402659058570862,
0.2038862705230713,
-0.7571516036987305,
-0.29239732027053833,
-0.2707587778568268,
-0.12734544277191162,
-0.4746895432472229,
0.023586390540003777,
-0.30431368947029114,
-0.9122785329818726,
-0.0881880596280098,
0.28585827350616455,
0.9440298080444336,
0.7527632713317871,
-0.3594752252101898,
0.009681334719061852,
-0.2646063268184662,
1.146255373954773,
-1.0365536212921143,
0.4486118257045746,
0.2706184387207031,
0.637856125831604,
-0.3561239540576935,
-0.8210116028785706,
-1.0423779487609863,
-0.3112650215625763,
-0.14579354226589203,
0.18425080180168152,
-0.47908249497413635,
0.08715445548295975,
0.3548484742641449,
0.41482964158058167,
-0.5686907768249512,
0.20617415010929108,
-0.027227068319916725,
-0.18954072892665863,
0.7090317010879517,
0.11544312536716461,
0.2724498212337494,
0.22805549204349518,
-0.30394646525382996,
-0.11417148262262344,
-0.7101781964302063,
-0.17718257009983063,
0.2333494871854782,
0.13880306482315063,
-0.28751707077026367,
0.3173702359199524,
-0.7168033719062805,
0.6495051383972168,
-0.1348026692867279,
-0.018820958212018013,
0.42382100224494934,
-0.16395166516304016,
-0.34816235303878784,
-0.32138073444366455,
0.7687336802482605,
0.31613948941230774,
0.1678619086742401,
-0.08363653719425201,
-0.2835158705711365,
0.25790277123451233,
0.025473402813076973,
-0.5133523941040039,
-0.2985568344593048,
0.6118345856666565,
-0.4236160218715668,
-0.06329619139432907,
-0.31203967332839966,
-0.6928321123123169,
-0.07696525752544403,
-0.6738542914390564,
0.47318801283836365,
-0.18665683269500732,
-0.5068254470825195,
0.1330641359090805,
-0.11851363629102707,
0.19621682167053223,
0.5868493914604187,
-0.6232447624206543,
0.3479476869106293,
0.9220783114433289,
0.9442022442817688,
0.026166241616010666,
-0.5946725606918335,
-0.8479921817779541,
-0.03196750953793526,
-0.31305989623069763,
0.7908052206039429,
-0.9462758302688599,
-0.14320847392082214,
-0.19512882828712463,
-0.21561618149280548,
-0.07903997600078583,
-0.6740714311599731,
0.557072639465332,
-0.46399828791618347,
-0.29786577820777893,
-0.4104316830635071,
-0.7232108116149902,
-0.04702509567141533,
0.5086552500724792,
-0.7056293487548828,
0.7712393999099731,
0.09701695293188095,
-0.28027886152267456,
0.4401785731315613,
-0.7885748147964478,
-0.24963533878326416,
0.014103739522397518,
-0.28962308168411255,
-0.2678540050983429,
-0.12562377750873566,
0.1079687848687172,
0.4245719611644745,
-0.4078714847564697,
0.47328636050224304,
-0.4402081370353699,
-0.3776046931743622,
0.14849328994750977,
-0.9241349101066589,
0.7409877181053162,
0.5326761603355408,
-0.3858860433101654,
0.06063368171453476,
-0.7646820545196533,
-0.1504581719636917,
0.07548341155052185,
-0.20560532808303833,
-0.2116210013628006,
0.014260956086218357,
-0.09082628786563873,
0.26828455924987793,
0.28254926204681396,
-0.33038100600242615,
-0.023763153702020645,
0.26356974244117737,
0.46964308619499207,
0.8875851631164551,
-0.20376116037368774,
0.3233973979949951,
-0.5767231583595276,
0.2621304988861084,
0.29487064480781555,
0.09094811975955963,
-0.09938560426235199,
-0.569989800453186,
-0.6873352527618408,
-0.5111314058303833,
0.026365509256720543,
0.4139883816242218,
-0.5242546200752258,
0.5621936917304993,
-0.17409925162792206,
-0.7162607312202454,
-0.37909355759620667,
0.17162099480628967,
0.6051813364028931,
0.6308479905128479,
0.8561951518058777,
0.023993980139493942,
0.22212906181812286,
-0.8177270889282227,
-0.5578927993774414,
-0.10480477660894394,
0.01818878948688507,
0.4669758677482605,
0.40462416410446167,
-0.22110587358474731,
0.6154436469078064,
-0.2435421496629715,
-0.12581400573253632,
-0.1766449213027954,
0.5670866370201111,
0.07798229157924652,
0.8367748856544495,
0.344755619764328,
-0.9173192977905273,
-0.17073717713356018,
-0.15334969758987427,
-0.6902519464492798,
-0.4895617365837097,
-0.2814663052558899,
-0.1965421438217163,
0.15684185922145844,
0.8987658023834229,
-0.5671231746673584,
0.4179033935070038,
0.6914215683937073,
-0.422292023897171,
0.6622053980827332,
-0.16952551901340485,
0.5252625346183777,
-0.6499416828155518,
-0.030758781358599663,
-0.06343724578619003,
-0.07049310207366943,
-0.4365184009075165,
0.12975375354290009,
0.08787378668785095,
0.1860867440700531,
-0.47395122051239014,
0.686771810054779,
-0.32148316502571106,
-0.04424573481082916,
0.03975893557071686,
0.3323124349117279,
0.1371898502111435,
0.6795544028282166,
-0.021692298352718353,
0.9575899839401245,
0.48238879442214966,
-0.8378533124923706,
0.1703845113515854,
0.201156347990036,
-0.2911550998687744,
0.8767881393432617,
-0.7618135213851929,
-0.14443838596343994,
0.20694436132907867,
0.43341776728630066,
-1.1347144842147827,
-0.195770725607872,
0.05519198253750801,
-0.20926503837108612,
0.20775675773620605,
-0.09052417427301407,
-0.6825605034828186,
-0.11236399412155151,
0.06774623692035675,
0.8958117961883545,
0.5310002565383911,
-0.7721798419952393,
0.6705384850502014,
0.1702793389558792,
0.03322918340563774,
-0.611481249332428,
-0.7488770484924316,
0.21275894343852997,
-0.17503485083580017,
-0.384485125541687,
-0.09729132056236267,
-0.41001471877098083,
-0.716771125793457,
-0.14401908218860626,
0.01344239804893732,
-0.07784783095121384,
0.30459195375442505,
-0.06207386776804924,
-0.006320907734334469,
-0.169246107339859,
0.36797648668289185,
0.40775415301322937,
-0.39239048957824707,
-0.08227083086967468,
-0.034261319786310196,
0.49954405426979065,
-0.432949036359787,
-0.8622034788131714,
-0.3904678523540497,
0.1654956340789795,
0.6896642446517944,
-0.3997584283351898,
0.34057167172431946,
0.17946597933769226,
-0.1549805998802185,
-0.3823944926261902,
-0.5878058671951294,
0.10656198114156723,
-0.543201208114624,
0.1738087683916092,
-0.5545206069946289,
-0.8892917633056641,
0.4259953200817108,
-0.5199856162071228,
0.29698485136032104,
0.43730005621910095,
0.5317236185073853,
0.18850979208946228,
0.6882480382919312,
-0.08931183815002441,
-0.06834818422794342,
0.04258398339152336,
-0.06024312227964401,
0.28299644589424133,
-0.7759063839912415,
0.036498505622148514,
-0.5793865323066711,
-0.47710302472114563,
-0.6081399321556091,
-0.7915351390838623,
0.2035680115222931,
0.03144164755940437,
-0.5442889332771301,
0.16226975619792938,
-0.31486302614212036,
0.740555465221405,
0.6705939173698425,
-0.022127870470285416,
0.629910409450531,
-0.7046601176261902,
0.034718018025159836,
0.19038043916225433,
-0.5359536409378052,
-0.622882068157196,
1.0951759815216064,
0.27386724948883057,
0.7090452909469604,
0.4798678755760193,
0.5316747426986694,
0.4341149628162384,
0.28721654415130615,
-0.5660146474838257,
0.6996141672134399,
-0.18282170593738556,
-0.4807538390159607,
-0.5992149114608765,
-0.6205930113792419,
-0.6500910520553589,
0.33638885617256165,
-0.02223481982946396,
-0.6139918565750122,
0.128256157040596,
0.4801846742630005,
-0.019608598202466965,
0.43908238410949707,
-0.6119686961174011,
0.9090914726257324,
-0.07644738256931305,
-0.6064348816871643,
-0.5236881971359253,
-0.591609537601471,
0.536715030670166,
0.1021040827035904,
0.3210250735282898,
-0.3501185178756714,
0.04167575016617775,
0.4952121376991272,
-0.48684367537498474,
0.8292257189750671,
-0.25305673480033875,
-0.2748887538909912,
0.2306416779756546,
0.19887296855449677,
0.427042156457901,
0.09642017632722855,
0.06714947521686554,
0.7003428339958191,
-0.30884769558906555,
-0.6489068865776062,
-0.538982093334198,
0.905802309513092,
-0.6735309362411499,
-0.5638750195503235,
-0.33354514837265015,
-0.8123781085014343,
-0.38120710849761963,
0.3873058557510376,
0.0763634592294693,
0.7505030632019043,
-0.25859230756759644,
0.014495998620986938,
0.8730629086494446,
-0.2566850781440735,
0.4067751467227936,
0.47365057468414307,
0.3374370038509369,
-0.16861401498317719,
0.9327714443206787,
0.0020979573018848896,
0.5263705849647522,
0.6274999380111694,
0.2067420482635498,
-0.46015843749046326,
-0.5393925309181213,
-0.38803184032440186,
-0.029392478987574577,
-0.7961418628692627,
-0.21026962995529175,
-0.4404209554195404,
0.08575735986232758,
-0.27146947383880615,
-0.3633075952529907,
-0.41083747148513794,
-0.5191166996955872,
-0.08653471618890762,
-0.0709323137998581,
0.20209914445877075,
0.5805625319480896,
-0.36598873138427734,
0.30010831356048584,
-0.6140238046646118,
0.45006102323532104,
0.5023391246795654,
0.5443167686462402,
0.15510331094264984,
-0.5375357866287231,
0.12938131392002106,
-0.0711866095662117,
-0.2560494542121887,
-0.25438863039016724,
-0.11217935383319855,
-0.013324798084795475,
0.8360500931739807,
0.5831143856048584,
0.32007530331611633,
0.6808640956878662,
-0.6899757981300354,
0.9872308969497681,
0.24151663482189178,
-1.179869294166565,
0.3935067653656006,
-0.4264514744281769,
0.27694565057754517,
0.7491070628166199,
-0.004185554571449757,
-0.24236030876636505,
-0.8364124894142151,
-0.9029286503791809,
-0.7763376832008362,
0.34351423382759094,
0.22776971757411957,
-0.013266502879559994,
-0.29071781039237976,
-0.047167371958494186,
0.06786856800317764,
0.29093292355537415,
-0.5050179362297058,
-0.29952767491340637,
-0.2658926248550415,
-0.28788360953330994,
-0.30068278312683105,
-0.04489913210272789,
-0.3820779621601105,
-0.04129328206181526,
0.728360652923584,
-0.1856655329465866,
0.0026075500063598156,
0.16123180091381073,
-0.17586064338684082,
-0.11161191016435623,
0.4982486069202423,
0.724137544631958,
0.8038363456726074,
-0.013949601911008358,
0.2827293872833252,
0.0182806309312582,
-0.05008191987872124,
0.14517803490161896,
0.08178626745939255,
0.07399000227451324,
-0.22705943882465363,
0.6271962523460388,
0.4069211483001709,
0.35724058747291565,
-0.9907798171043396,
0.6400249004364014,
-0.0068532610312104225,
-0.435442715883255,
-0.013871423900127411,
0.38143932819366455,
-0.05741557851433754,
0.373039573431015,
0.06339381635189056,
0.052444081753492355,
0.36153408885002136,
-0.3612464964389801,
0.4829827845096588,
0.5291855335235596,
0.04560982063412666,
-0.051032762974500656,
0.8254032135009766,
0.4168282747268677,
-0.01893053576350212,
0.5566836595535278,
-0.33896034955978394,
-0.3089706301689148,
0.6387296319007874,
0.3603491187095642,
0.8154675960540771,
0.07679352909326553,
0.1023360937833786,
0.6113702654838562,
0.35717877745628357,
-0.13992054760456085,
-0.07257872819900513,
-0.38911327719688416,
-0.8090076446533203,
-0.2583058476448059,
-0.27435946464538574,
-0.7376753091812134,
0.29810744524002075,
-0.5893306732177734,
0.016970964148640633,
-0.5362535715103149,
0.42920780181884766,
-0.32992303371429443,
-0.019487760961055756,
-0.5490361452102661,
0.3938866853713989,
-0.0796932578086853,
1.3025425672531128,
-1.0916622877120972,
0.3762701153755188,
0.29482436180114746,
-0.4471687376499176,
-0.8315378427505493,
0.15751561522483826,
0.29354408383369446,
-0.8672899007797241,
0.2629469633102417,
0.15790152549743652,
-0.1460862010717392,
-0.11448714137077332,
-1.0066508054733276,
-0.4721655547618866,
1.3540574312210083,
0.07698235660791397,
-0.9780336022377014,
0.5053988099098206,
-0.03785768896341324,
0.258933424949646,
-0.18495482206344604,
0.26672253012657166,
1.027788519859314,
0.8427371978759766,
0.22698181867599487,
-0.9418965578079224,
0.25219717621803284,
-0.2937343120574951,
-0.37877383828163147,
0.02919284626841545,
-1.1533719301223755,
1.0203378200531006,
-0.17822977900505066,
-0.04006374254822731,
0.14199985563755035,
0.6040747761726379,
0.7384950518608093,
0.7062274813652039,
0.6441992521286011,
1.0992792844772339,
1.0941145420074463,
-0.1935100257396698,
0.9177585244178772,
-0.02004227042198181,
0.1306779980659485,
1.597826361656189,
-0.2964742183685303,
0.804505467414856,
0.5092915892601013,
-0.29350560903549194,
0.480826199054718,
0.35479095578193665,
0.10521043092012405,
0.5458605885505676,
0.11667612195014954,
-0.3050902485847473,
-0.4952269494533539,
0.11395945399999619,
-0.31209954619407654,
0.2854727804660797,
0.3670099973678589,
0.12961596250534058,
-0.3273445963859558,
-0.4987325668334961,
0.24998369812965393,
0.4084766209125519,
-0.28590941429138184,
0.8003726601600647,
0.023463867604732513,
-0.7429934144020081,
0.5494674444198608,
-0.43235379457473755,
0.47059980034828186,
-0.5798811912536621,
-0.4598391652107239,
-0.3519594073295593,
0.06813519448041916,
0.03279648348689079,
-0.7310536503791809,
0.0003672928432933986,
-0.22637319564819336,
0.0750265046954155,
-0.008533168584108353,
0.4219733774662018,
-0.41959673166275024,
-0.28659725189208984,
0.30584901571273804,
0.5442437529563904,
0.2671183943748474,
0.2708219587802887,
-0.7740284204483032,
0.269328236579895,
-0.32323357462882996,
-0.29521897435188293,
0.24278344213962555,
0.9879069328308105,
-0.0010794842382892966,
0.8222100138664246,
0.7679539322853088,
0.10890384763479233,
-0.1344567835330963,
0.383126825094223,
1.018687129020691,
-0.370057612657547,
-0.5645610690116882,
-0.5754141211509705,
0.6305525302886963,
-0.2232101708650589,
-0.5251057744026184,
0.4771149754524231,
0.32647958397865295,
0.887985348701477,
0.18889252841472626,
0.9701278209686279,
-0.13777688145637512,
0.35476234555244446,
-0.7975622415542603,
0.6199649572372437,
-0.8662906885147095,
0.47595474123954773,
-0.46863919496536255,
-0.5641268491744995,
-0.2462281435728073,
0.44040176272392273,
-0.29702824354171753,
0.16301332414150238,
0.6364630460739136,
0.9256141781806946,
-0.2421441227197647,
-0.22446849942207336,
0.6767257452011108,
0.36827147006988525,
0.7740136384963989,
0.5723952054977417,
0.7449437379837036,
-0.21978162229061127,
0.2662285268306732,
0.06718101352453232,
-0.7820310592651367,
-0.14963021874427795,
-1.0894556045532227,
-0.8418473601341248,
-0.5277479290962219,
-0.3146131634712219,
-0.13791926205158234,
-0.15744616091251373,
0.7324310541152954,
0.4446200430393219,
-0.9435336589813232,
0.11935359984636307,
-0.6449814438819885,
0.17689034342765808,
-0.4653349816799164,
-0.2509971261024475,
0.26514318585395813,
-0.7617136240005493,
-0.8444225192070007,
0.36135655641555786,
0.278047114610672,
-0.13894332945346832,
-0.07150428742170334,
-0.4784277379512787,
-0.2854170501232147,
0.4011843800544739,
0.3569559156894684,
0.36187249422073364,
-0.9189646244049072,
-0.34463033080101013,
-0.4856644868850708,
0.1094173938035965,
-0.0967424288392067,
0.7786556482315063,
-0.6102659702301025,
0.5410852432250977,
0.24891814589500427,
0.6962133049964905,
-0.174641951918602,
0.1732630580663681,
0.53048175573349,
-0.5504229068756104,
0.24382252991199493,
0.17593158781528473,
0.592350423336029,
0.1420232206583023,
-0.24707378447055817,
0.6589788198471069,
0.18964171409606934,
-0.8140653967857361,
-0.7651211619377136,
0.3103701174259186,
-1.2083024978637695,
-0.35356053709983826,
1.1855363845825195,
-0.2510777413845062,
-0.0403435193002224,
-0.32787030935287476,
0.1291825920343399,
0.0505378432571888,
-0.5714460611343384,
0.7195860147476196,
0.6689260601997375,
-0.08541757613420486,
-0.09248564392328262,
-0.3458369970321655,
0.5166271924972534,
0.39092814922332764,
-0.9639875888824463,
0.5875106453895569,
0.8454697132110596,
0.11008093506097794,
0.2580455243587494,
0.9115599393844604,
-0.1732596755027771,
0.4942457377910614,
0.34040459990501404,
-0.2894381582736969,
-0.14382828772068024,
-0.4576795697212219,
-0.15846417844295502,
-0.19413287937641144,
0.08428429067134857,
-0.13316412270069122
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.02798v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.02798v2
|
Promotional Language and the Adoption of Innovative Ideas in Science
| 2024-06-04T21:54:36 | 2024-06-07T20:56:35 |
Hao Peng, Huilian Sophie Qiu, Henrik Barslund Fosse, Brian Uzzi
|
cs.DL
|
cs.DL, cs.CL, cs.CY
|
How are the merits of innovative ideas communicated in science? Here we
conduct semantic analyses of grant application success with a focus on
scientific promotional language, which has been growing in frequency in many
contexts and purportedly may convey an innovative idea's originality and
significance. Our analysis attempts to surmount limitations of prior studies by
examining the full text of tens of thousands of both funded and unfunded grants
from three leading public and private funding agencies: the NIH, the NSF, and
the Novo Nordisk Foundation, one of the world's largest private science
foundations. We find a robust association between promotional language and the
support and adoption of innovative ideas by funders and other scientists.
First, the percentage of promotional language in a grant proposal is associated
with up to a doubling of the grant's probability of being funded. Second, a
grant's promotional language reflects its intrinsic level of innovativeness.
Third, the percentage of promotional language predicts the expected citation
and productivity impact of publications that are supported by funded grants.
Lastly, a computer-assisted experiment that manipulates the promotional
language in our data demonstrates how promotional language can communicate the
merit of ideas through cognitive activation. With the incidence of promotional
language in science steeply rising, and the pivotal role of grants in
converting promising and aspirational ideas into solutions, our analysis
provides empirical evidence that promotional language is associated with
effectively communicating the merits of innovative scientific ideas.
|
[
-0.06606671214103699,
-0.5814586281776428,
0.9155903458595276,
0.6860119104385376,
-0.32868316769599915,
0.27821505069732666,
-0.30820491909980774,
-0.36087366938591003,
0.5920613408088684,
0.38953065872192383,
0.041075143963098526,
-0.3569779694080353,
-0.7332791686058044,
0.007121989969164133,
-0.5498132109642029,
1.0337616205215454,
0.15549716353416443,
0.22876501083374023,
-0.47909310460090637,
0.15244793891906738,
0.11614818125963211,
-0.13141433894634247,
-0.2937212586402893,
-0.35700154304504395,
0.4890173673629761,
0.2884275019168854,
0.354587197303772,
0.49203115701675415,
0.6916906237602234,
0.306806355714798,
-0.34996384382247925,
-0.4983382225036621,
-0.4234543442726135,
-0.17080385982990265,
-0.4089061915874481,
-0.4682583212852478,
-0.2317577302455902,
0.14201383292675018,
0.7033873796463013,
0.935096025466919,
-0.22345328330993652,
0.022991513833403587,
0.19108927249908447,
0.6985114812850952,
-0.5515774488449097,
0.2998896837234497,
-0.6831530928611755,
-0.3199009895324707,
-0.37763309478759766,
-0.2943978011608124,
-0.2245725393295288,
-0.7636302709579468,
0.43945056200027466,
-0.9031935930252075,
0.1298290342092514,
-0.16941188275814056,
0.5261332988739014,
-0.31511545181274414,
-0.08213641494512558,
-0.8554611206054688,
-0.3325188457965851,
0.5986135601997375,
-0.3434768319129944,
-0.22573544085025787,
0.12588143348693848,
0.03315664827823639,
-0.5442044138908386,
-0.8961661458015442,
-0.7353131771087646,
-0.5781377553939819,
0.2062615156173706,
0.009205250069499016,
-0.5034068822860718,
0.10338573902845383,
-0.08721376955509186,
0.23982644081115723,
-0.41748058795928955,
-0.22941510379314423,
-0.6454624533653259,
-0.06254719197750092,
0.44073253870010376,
-0.44473573565483093,
0.14705069363117218,
-0.04447280615568161,
-0.47376376390457153,
-0.21710485219955444,
-0.43622657656669617,
0.2987026870250702,
0.07853125780820847,
0.27680346369743347,
0.30277949571609497,
0.7584191560745239,
-0.649118959903717,
0.287901371717453,
-0.19440621137619019,
0.3562799394130707,
0.32221168279647827,
-0.8078374862670898,
-0.044175587594509125,
0.4005712568759918,
0.7371228933334351,
0.15131789445877075,
0.2943580746650696,
-0.2914998233318329,
-0.015587005764245987,
0.47692111134529114,
-0.08675675839185715,
-0.5003300309181213,
-0.008580495603382587,
0.03399084135890007,
-0.24404093623161316,
-0.43957164883613586,
0.2840304374694824,
-0.19683721661567688,
-0.6918537616729736,
0.21985644102096558,
0.3043690621852875,
-0.07102815061807632,
-0.39685505628585815,
0.4760868549346924,
-0.8504074215888977,
0.033784449100494385,
0.08355998247861862,
-0.5895127058029175,
0.030691005289554596,
0.9033700227737427,
0.3973201513290405,
0.2762846052646637,
-0.40087053179740906,
-0.010994465090334415,
0.1703709363937378,
-0.44927191734313965,
1.0408183336257935,
-0.534170925617218,
-0.665393054485321,
-0.17420484125614166,
-0.03755302354693413,
-0.1434142291545868,
-0.3693608045578003,
0.298030287027359,
-0.6363537907600403,
0.06981439143419266,
-0.21243217587471008,
-0.2998043894767761,
-0.2478085160255432,
-0.2973630130290985,
-0.2570636570453644,
0.3761145770549774,
-0.04001639410853386,
-0.29934951663017273,
0.967179000377655,
-0.9375126361846924,
-0.43400004506111145,
0.5074613690376282,
0.045977115631103516,
-0.06861039996147156,
0.598320484161377,
-0.4945666790008545,
-0.04642682150006294,
-0.44546741247177124,
0.6111582517623901,
-0.21142393350601196,
-0.011993703432381153,
0.6929370760917664,
-0.1077311635017395,
0.5655181407928467,
0.20664982497692108,
-0.5972679853439331,
0.19837048649787903,
-0.554692268371582,
0.08913451433181763,
0.17198383808135986,
-0.1437552571296692,
-0.43003079295158386,
-0.23751451075077057,
-0.00666547566652298,
-0.04342404752969742,
0.22510738670825958,
-0.8971753120422363,
0.2971563935279846,
-0.4811609983444214,
0.39962273836135864,
0.3537556231021881,
0.12398470193147659,
0.32449257373809814,
0.03847020864486694,
0.6102060675621033,
-0.4903585910797119,
0.209344282746315,
0.16606952250003815,
-0.8834989070892334,
-0.0928686186671257,
-0.21155498921871185,
0.17990383505821228,
0.0014025233685970306,
-0.33376285433769226,
-0.2282218039035797,
-0.05031922832131386,
-0.4955058991909027,
-0.6717731952667236,
0.13413384556770325,
0.3684431314468384,
0.43115234375,
-0.13773693144321442,
-0.42059335112571716,
-0.23433341085910797,
-1.0710244178771973,
-0.731939971446991,
-0.4044026732444763,
0.1436133086681366,
0.30961886048316956,
0.5888630747795105,
0.17073370516300201,
1.0294493436813354,
-0.6125681400299072,
-0.19119630753993988,
-0.1407560110092163,
0.6258669495582581,
0.3751572370529175,
0.2840938866138458,
0.5947226881980896,
-1.0479841232299805,
-0.2839815318584442,
0.33228451013565063,
-0.42073550820350647,
-0.17568530142307281,
0.20317809283733368,
0.0032558913808315992,
-0.39876291155815125,
0.045772843062877655,
-0.6027988195419312,
0.35571861267089844,
0.14328308403491974,
-0.7437708973884583,
0.4182549715042114,
-0.09863004833459854,
0.37645623087882996,
-0.5500389337539673,
0.14313842356204987,
-0.1833430379629135,
0.6290057897567749,
-0.3950282633304596,
-0.27245622873306274,
-0.14155277609825134,
0.032861772924661636,
-0.4526856243610382,
0.5631749033927917,
-0.429363876581192,
0.4184252619743347,
-0.5694590210914612,
0.5770276784896851,
0.03164498507976532,
-0.2553704082965851,
-0.057550352066755295,
0.3534664809703827,
0.722369372844696,
-0.559099018573761,
0.5830489993095398,
0.24427096545696259,
-0.4247741401195526,
0.41381600499153137,
-0.8484118580818176,
-0.22665150463581085,
-0.3190920650959015,
0.3067534863948822,
-0.9848455190658569,
-0.2165866196155548,
0.011125230230391026,
-0.7457948327064514,
-0.15095879137516022,
0.0609002485871315,
-0.05089999735355377,
-0.4950307309627533,
-0.25786125659942627,
-0.04669487476348877,
0.176458477973938,
-0.28871235251426697,
-0.023264635354280472,
0.455626517534256,
-0.19394922256469727,
-0.44654372334480286,
-0.587676465511322,
0.22376960515975952,
-0.2526024580001831,
-0.6578054428100586,
0.23377148807048798,
0.03702401742339134,
-0.2892798185348511,
0.5160664319992065,
0.0035804177168756723,
0.10686025023460388,
0.26324769854545593,
0.08176280558109283,
-0.08660916239023209,
-0.2498125582933426,
-0.07442038506269455,
-0.18820472061634064,
-0.3046872019767761,
0.29206401109695435,
-0.6622055768966675,
0.11465205252170563,
-0.2862411141395569,
-0.09079991281032562,
-0.18835966289043427,
0.26460835337638855,
0.8015440702438354,
0.13474370539188385,
0.8531643748283386,
0.5162761211395264,
0.0030475344974547625,
-0.0224322360008955,
-0.223066508769989,
-0.19553399085998535,
-0.4190428853034973,
0.38350602984428406,
-0.22551919519901276,
-0.5012007355690002,
-0.10354981571435928,
-0.19180472195148468,
-0.2417217493057251,
0.47533613443374634,
0.22030729055404663,
-0.01605246774852276,
0.6497686505317688,
0.8224198818206787,
0.4248462915420532,
0.69368976354599,
-0.3484179973602295,
0.09984684735536575,
-0.6749950051307678,
-0.6453602910041809,
-0.6327987909317017,
-0.06895414739847183,
-0.3200523853302002,
-0.3035215139389038,
0.19926349818706512,
0.5735270380973816,
0.3635927736759186,
0.4827822148799896,
-0.8368473649024963,
0.27120915055274963,
0.5405526161193848,
-0.549079954624176,
0.31303834915161133,
0.17017629742622375,
-0.020070040598511696,
0.04090479388833046,
-0.6689324378967285,
-0.5758389234542847,
0.9594873785972595,
0.14914517104625702,
0.6950054168701172,
0.12073981761932373,
0.6040918827056885,
0.27471092343330383,
0.5892028212547302,
-0.6979807019233704,
0.6532230973243713,
-0.027851948514580727,
-0.3617415428161621,
-0.13177084922790527,
-0.3260982930660248,
-1.0931581258773804,
0.20451019704341888,
-0.24206046760082245,
-0.6963673233985901,
0.5451732873916626,
0.07575533539056778,
0.022535324096679688,
-0.12827986478805542,
-0.9172923564910889,
0.6194378137588501,
-0.36185315251350403,
-0.1702377051115036,
-0.6884844303131104,
-0.37160754203796387,
0.03124864771962166,
-0.2649434804916382,
0.2385411411523819,
-0.2963547110557556,
0.20365740358829498,
0.9988569617271423,
0.1329784244298935,
0.50652676820755,
-0.23707374930381775,
0.09951115399599075,
0.5257367491722107,
-0.2389432042837143,
0.29740312695503235,
0.08843059092760086,
-0.04858659952878952,
-0.11149822920560837,
-0.16847676038742065,
-0.3904125988483429,
-0.6321247220039368,
0.7319780588150024,
-0.22745978832244873,
-0.9110805988311768,
-0.38023340702056885,
-0.4663725197315216,
0.03551860153675079,
0.3422684669494629,
0.1359422206878662,
0.3037872910499573,
-0.48408862948417664,
0.5401763916015625,
0.18428625166416168,
0.07328753918409348,
0.21789203584194183,
0.7460075616836548,
-0.2425200343132019,
-0.47463274002075195,
0.9337689280509949,
-0.08209840953350067,
0.5505566596984863,
0.13837462663650513,
0.5380554795265198,
-0.6359891295433044,
-0.7120996117591858,
-0.08812189847230911,
0.4013371467590332,
-0.5946091413497925,
0.12737534940242767,
-0.895524263381958,
0.23323892056941986,
-0.7921351790428162,
-0.3047013580799103,
-0.17884932458400726,
-0.9164444208145142,
0.16120386123657227,
-0.06185857206583023,
0.601169764995575,
1.1082360744476318,
-0.34863895177841187,
0.07502634078264236,
-0.2232847362756729,
-0.028854960575699806,
0.042918477207422256,
0.14611436426639557,
-0.13926905393600464,
-0.0051573533564805984,
-0.27099311351776123,
-0.02176874689757824,
-0.1916605830192566,
-0.671456515789032,
-0.05589297041296959,
0.22490961849689484,
0.8484649062156677,
0.4554155766963959,
-0.25714847445487976,
0.07839275151491165,
0.004075451288372278,
0.6880521178245544,
0.47631147503852844,
-0.5141662955284119,
0.6865279674530029,
-0.29876330494880676,
0.09812308102846146,
0.4941224753856659,
0.20533914864063263,
-0.3580741882324219,
-0.5843839049339294,
-0.9049603343009949,
-0.9403595924377441,
0.5894175171852112,
0.09276000410318375,
0.017434265464544296,
-0.3620241582393646,
-0.18853551149368286,
-0.05393559858202934,
0.7069218158721924,
-0.48136311769485474,
0.011872333474457264,
-0.22373206913471222,
-0.017701733857393265,
0.13654853403568268,
-0.03956938907504082,
-0.6085878610610962,
0.2254091203212738,
0.6359339952468872,
-0.11260336637496948,
-0.06567404419183731,
0.20151300728321075,
0.11055939644575119,
0.0979534462094307,
0.6229917407035828,
0.626011848449707,
0.7090537548065186,
-0.06781667470932007,
-0.11764571070671082,
-0.5090209245681763,
-0.7901838421821594,
-0.04382641986012459,
0.135466068983078,
-0.30039528012275696,
0.05965608358383179,
-0.024431932717561722,
0.6406009793281555,
0.02261260896921158,
-0.5269203186035156,
0.3730735778808594,
0.16203461587429047,
-0.1898222714662552,
0.26288673281669617,
-0.12015077471733093,
0.25009462237358093,
0.185632586479187,
0.6523756980895996,
0.28492099046707153,
0.3290582597255707,
-0.6529545187950134,
-0.004791147541254759,
0.8881027102470398,
-0.2599223256111145,
-0.4387558400630951,
0.7757967710494995,
0.25445422530174255,
-0.16279183328151703,
0.12296442687511444,
-0.1485120952129364,
-0.48994410037994385,
0.8241283893585205,
0.9550318717956543,
0.9334297776222229,
0.31795424222946167,
0.6864089965820312,
0.04639357700943947,
0.23992842435836792,
0.028030607849359512,
0.028092361986637115,
-0.14427776634693146,
-0.4018509089946747,
0.03640935942530632,
-0.7856791615486145,
-0.27427372336387634,
-0.2970600724220276,
-0.33705082535743713,
0.11565949022769928,
-0.15840652585029602,
-0.5538612008094788,
0.5649125576019287,
-0.2166581004858017,
-0.45124122500419617,
-0.1705077439546585,
-0.05880258232355118,
0.9847805500030518,
-0.7431616187095642,
0.46388089656829834,
1.0386371612548828,
-0.4887903928756714,
-0.5509162545204163,
-0.44012004137039185,
0.07580640912055969,
-0.6471987962722778,
1.0244711637496948,
-0.29975104331970215,
-0.6519641280174255,
0.10110675543546677,
-0.3878736197948456,
-1.0465874671936035,
0.8512256741523743,
0.09697116911411285,
0.056195758283138275,
0.34473374485969543,
-0.036104172468185425,
0.4683609902858734,
-0.7500295042991638,
-0.001570063061080873,
0.5049048066139221,
0.8064451813697815,
0.2832525670528412,
-0.9157557487487793,
-0.12166769802570343,
-0.2009207159280777,
-0.059765271842479706,
0.16258342564105988,
-0.24549701809883118,
0.23953622579574585,
-0.694662868976593,
-0.3614579439163208,
0.25624778866767883,
0.5691806077957153,
0.45677879452705383,
0.7731078863143921,
0.2669375538825989,
-0.021072668954730034,
0.7052037715911865,
-0.1456822007894516,
1.1323087215423584,
-0.26331040263175964,
0.0994638130068779,
0.24726921319961548,
-0.16439424455165863,
0.5001705288887024,
0.7240309119224548,
-0.041185133159160614,
0.5411782264709473,
-0.08992919325828552,
-0.020913468673825264,
0.6832098364830017,
0.44847390055656433,
-0.33065006136894226,
0.4416213035583496,
-0.9845808148384094,
-0.396560400724411,
0.3053491413593292,
0.6608507037162781,
-0.36348283290863037,
-0.1838679164648056,
0.5728503465652466,
-0.08922068029642105,
0.2773630619049072,
-0.05533626303076744,
0.5808674097061157,
0.2793167531490326,
-0.6909228563308716,
0.2695564329624176,
-0.3297857642173767,
0.49136224389076233,
-1.0243061780929565,
0.0181950144469738,
0.21567265689373016,
0.4095875322818756,
-0.40560635924339294,
-1.1055195331573486,
0.15584371984004974,
-0.06550093740224838,
-0.2851090729236603,
-0.25699523091316223,
0.4548208713531494,
-0.40836790204048157,
0.002368522807955742,
0.30043336749076843,
0.3124583959579468,
0.4412243664264679,
0.2536792457103729,
-0.5028283596038818,
0.0499977245926857,
0.026066267862915993,
-0.19081012904644012,
0.13448941707611084,
0.43206050992012024,
-0.174009770154953,
0.5339487791061401,
1.0094578266143799,
0.7965923547744751,
0.027767514809966087,
0.18179552257061005,
0.7132517099380493,
-0.6581374406814575,
-0.44859641790390015,
-0.41105273365974426,
0.34545180201530457,
-0.2015426605939865,
-0.5792818069458008,
1.0860488414764404,
0.3576492369174957,
0.37179410457611084,
-0.12751036882400513,
0.5689871311187744,
-0.28948718309402466,
-0.05382034182548523,
-0.14092183113098145,
0.7580730319023132,
-0.4339534342288971,
0.32804080843925476,
-0.5510117411613464,
-0.7936990261077881,
-0.20376402139663696,
0.2421460598707199,
-0.5915737748146057,
-0.08910684287548065,
0.6064011454582214,
0.6470584273338318,
0.4254448711872101,
0.20927777886390686,
-0.11635768413543701,
0.12886027991771698,
0.3087709844112396,
0.25009116530418396,
1.1830040216445923,
0.16396299004554749,
0.522563099861145,
-0.012247675098478794,
-0.7846655249595642,
-0.21719183027744293,
-0.7998729944229126,
-0.14284205436706543,
-0.5032378435134888,
-0.6013591885566711,
-0.6159095764160156,
0.12943002581596375,
0.6055952310562134,
0.3365125358104706,
-0.7342593669891357,
-0.2984578609466553,
-0.18371707201004028,
0.22423571348190308,
-0.4151725471019745,
-0.30854448676109314,
0.33844539523124695,
-0.10032732784748077,
-0.5170702338218689,
0.754730761051178,
0.5298982262611389,
-0.17149309813976288,
-0.027781611308455467,
0.12547844648361206,
-0.14780110120773315,
0.2978355288505554,
0.4308353066444397,
0.7855144143104553,
-0.5625506043434143,
0.2632916271686554,
0.36189335584640503,
-0.37706220149993896,
-0.3373657763004303,
1.1079283952713013,
-0.927582323551178,
0.6914079189300537,
0.5632340908050537,
0.49421024322509766,
0.22770825028419495,
-0.1376936137676239,
0.5639554262161255,
-0.05709277465939522,
0.14858216047286987,
0.3558911979198456,
0.01797887124121189,
0.39324843883514404,
-0.38309556245803833,
0.4833943247795105,
0.41671669483184814,
-0.3586275577545166,
-0.895913302898407,
-0.006022414192557335,
-0.6386501789093018,
-0.34327709674835205,
0.9409036040306091,
0.25887736678123474,
-0.5128545761108398,
-0.16400912404060364,
-0.23720136284828186,
-0.2830822765827179,
-0.5276322960853577,
0.6964940428733826,
0.7844433188438416,
-0.37634119391441345,
0.47459012269973755,
-0.31444814801216125,
0.6372860074043274,
0.4747161269187927,
-0.20002532005310059,
0.08187403529882431,
-0.015628540888428688,
0.17310507595539093,
0.7636358141899109,
0.9968714118003845,
-0.3791787624359131,
0.38611212372779846,
0.1858672797679901,
0.06796910613775253,
-0.026095768436789513,
-0.0615389421582222,
-0.06337667256593704,
0.12196198850870132,
0.3778401017189026,
-0.22656850516796112
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.02795v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.02795v2
|
ArguMentor: Augmenting User Experiences with Counter-Perspectives
| 2024-06-04T21:43:56 | 2024-06-13T12:33:58 |
Priya Pitre, Kurt Luther
|
cs.HC
|
cs.HC, cs.CL
|
Opinion pieces (or op-eds) can provide valuable perspectives, but they often
represent only one side of a story, which can make readers susceptible to
confirmation bias and echo chambers. Exposure to different perspectives can
help readers overcome these obstacles and form more robust, nuanced views on
important societal issues. We designed ArguMentor, a human-AI collaboration
system that highlights claims in opinion pieces, identifies counter-arguments
for them using a LLM, and generates a context-based summary of based on current
events. It further enhances user understanding through additional features like
a Q&A bot (that answers user questions pertaining to the text), DebateMe (an
agent that users can argue any side of the piece with) and highlighting (where
users can highlight a word or passage to get its definition or context). Our
evaluation shows that participants can generate more arguments and
counter-arguments and have, on average, have more moderate views after engaging
with the system.
|
[
-0.9655085206031799,
-0.7260518670082092,
0.6160059571266174,
-0.2305879294872284,
-0.49688825011253357,
0.13390889763832092,
0.16427485644817352,
-0.5348380208015442,
0.5033242106437683,
0.5986758470535278,
-0.2461351752281189,
-0.07038784772157669,
-0.36872318387031555,
0.044911544770002365,
-0.2715705931186676,
1.2766553163528442,
0.055777277797460556,
-0.2573990523815155,
-0.6183567643165588,
-0.5295979380607605,
-0.40994054079055786,
-0.5821089148521423,
-0.6346878409385681,
-0.5187010169029236,
0.7758888602256775,
0.6400936245918274,
0.8366652131080627,
0.36148035526275635,
0.37639203667640686,
0.4725862145423889,
0.10216612368822098,
-0.03006078116595745,
-0.1634589433670044,
0.17905917763710022,
-0.7462329268455505,
-0.42560356855392456,
-0.5392898917198181,
0.026024196296930313,
0.053165994584560394,
0.3456564247608185,
0.08002544939517975,
0.005331054329872131,
0.04047812893986702,
0.6218239665031433,
-0.502475917339325,
-0.31780409812927246,
-0.5234531760215759,
0.2220345437526703,
0.08609788119792938,
-0.1421748548746109,
-0.2587730586528778,
-0.3039201498031616,
0.6475153565406799,
-0.6218674778938293,
0.016246655955910683,
0.022196240723133087,
0.7836872339248657,
0.4448970556259155,
-0.4526468515396118,
-0.3496987521648407,
-0.6905203461647034,
0.6845637559890747,
-0.5501284599304199,
-0.08962225914001465,
-0.29280582070350647,
0.20320473611354828,
0.055724553763866425,
-0.695529043674469,
-0.9394848346710205,
0.23290200531482697,
-0.30542701482772827,
0.6710166931152344,
-0.5979520082473755,
0.17667412757873535,
-0.030846210196614265,
0.275448203086853,
-0.39506596326828003,
-0.13475029170513153,
-0.2824254333972931,
-0.036626920104026794,
0.7482468485832214,
0.20843063294887543,
0.45137104392051697,
-0.2916845381259918,
-0.6590679287910461,
-0.1584794819355011,
-0.550998330116272,
0.23412185907363892,
0.527906060218811,
-0.21778403222560883,
-0.03502534702420235,
0.4802931547164917,
0.10198387503623962,
0.7117938995361328,
0.3248557150363922,
0.2372976541519165,
-0.008913368918001652,
0.057708024978637695,
-0.21640053391456604,
0.19492284953594208,
0.8297170996665955,
0.7815893292427063,
-0.21033765375614166,
0.06111229211091995,
0.21317923069000244,
0.07115556299686432,
0.6020269989967346,
-0.9126676321029663,
-0.24349737167358398,
0.5481103658676147,
-0.6931814551353455,
-0.5033470392227173,
0.427827924489975,
-1.027955412864685,
-0.9953781366348267,
-0.2921283543109894,
0.5181297063827515,
-0.08107917010784149,
-0.3151923418045044,
-0.1622336506843567,
-0.5005568265914917,
0.08955713361501694,
0.5404688119888306,
-0.3516913652420044,
0.3398057222366333,
0.5967950224876404,
0.7316440939903259,
-0.2681785523891449,
-0.19474762678146362,
-0.4594799280166626,
0.008456961251795292,
-0.2803683578968048,
1.3603949546813965,
-0.7448580265045166,
-0.5834563374519348,
-0.07897617667913437,
-0.06154850125312805,
0.08571964502334595,
-0.6246083378791809,
0.7549070715904236,
-0.4640920162200928,
0.707781195640564,
-0.49642038345336914,
-0.6524220108985901,
-0.3861583173274994,
0.49948152899742126,
-0.7601279020309448,
0.669268786907196,
-0.21805569529533386,
-0.8766522407531738,
0.5343137979507446,
-1.1403840780258179,
-0.5089706182479858,
0.1657438427209854,
-0.5491549372673035,
-0.24334077537059784,
0.16300544142723083,
0.29333290457725525,
0.20569735765457153,
-0.11045650392770767,
-0.020753275603055954,
0.08121439814567566,
-0.12663210928440094,
0.27963483333587646,
-0.12091409415006638,
0.5228983163833618,
0.38470086455345154,
-0.28817683458328247,
0.5538840293884277,
-0.23596978187561035,
-0.2962007522583008,
-0.005933399777859449,
-0.3112512528896332,
-0.33313223719596863,
0.359039306640625,
0.049915507435798645,
0.39310529828071594,
0.26625514030456543,
-0.535662829875946,
0.12573684751987457,
-0.4966493248939514,
0.4894435703754425,
0.6683545708656311,
0.1325526237487793,
0.34581243991851807,
-0.6957387924194336,
0.8000752329826355,
0.28469666838645935,
-0.11722427606582642,
-0.5523978471755981,
-0.5661898255348206,
-0.8231143951416016,
-0.007999722845852375,
0.08125989884138107,
0.8330531716346741,
-0.7858707308769226,
0.5162721872329712,
0.0037475761491805315,
-0.4343636631965637,
-0.5177565813064575,
0.24260927736759186,
0.20139248669147491,
0.8186537027359009,
0.3926461935043335,
-0.5400444269180298,
-0.7305505871772766,
-0.9560425877571106,
-0.4526553452014923,
-0.5496747493743896,
-0.08670736104249954,
0.5813191533088684,
0.38857561349868774,
-0.06077095493674278,
1.3941941261291504,
-0.3213918209075928,
-0.2092028111219406,
-0.6267959475517273,
0.4086357057094574,
0.12149560451507568,
0.32027289271354675,
0.38623955845832825,
-0.8891102075576782,
-0.5277217030525208,
0.1255146861076355,
-0.8807291388511658,
-0.21807362139225006,
-0.473183810710907,
-0.1691552698612213,
0.21751971542835236,
0.6012676954269409,
-0.30133381485939026,
0.4263324737548828,
0.14661568403244019,
-0.38455730676651,
0.11343251913785934,
-0.05300959199666977,
0.29478636384010315,
-1.4988151788711548,
0.15991419553756714,
0.044071778655052185,
-0.3400578200817108,
-0.4729888439178467,
-0.21396669745445251,
-0.5598627328872681,
0.014905030839145184,
-0.5183831453323364,
0.5519887804985046,
0.19598276913166046,
0.37971577048301697,
-0.6177880764007568,
0.4283788502216339,
0.4566345512866974,
0.05188910290598869,
0.4207744896411896,
0.6286125779151917,
0.05751902237534523,
0.10389949381351471,
0.228359192609787,
0.12308759987354279,
-0.19411636888980865,
1.112265944480896,
-0.9938883185386658,
0.33313921093940735,
-0.14680011570453644,
0.38299378752708435,
-0.9573386311531067,
-0.2638879418373108,
0.3187062442302704,
-0.3175564408302307,
-0.2331717312335968,
-0.1968739777803421,
-0.11875852942466736,
-0.3112618923187256,
-0.4506627321243286,
0.11629319936037064,
0.14752356708049774,
-0.5785179138183594,
1.0550562143325806,
0.7316951155662537,
-0.35119161009788513,
-0.7192887663841248,
-0.420989990234375,
0.5356075167655945,
-0.5932244658470154,
-0.4600399136543274,
0.4153275191783905,
-0.07401982694864273,
-0.7190125584602356,
0.33810320496559143,
0.16619320213794708,
0.1606900691986084,
-0.07553157955408096,
0.4997550845146179,
0.1161859855055809,
-0.08449284732341766,
0.117449551820755,
0.20105727016925812,
-0.18411345779895782,
0.18868958950042725,
0.11940278857946396,
0.2940824031829834,
-0.38075006008148193,
-0.42977219820022583,
-0.2997005879878998,
0.7010500431060791,
0.45338505506515503,
0.019302111119031906,
0.4359942376613617,
0.37453991174697876,
-0.2729114890098572,
-0.02365976758301258,
-0.5877951383590698,
-0.09525319933891296,
-0.4693027436733246,
0.4037711024284363,
-0.23639093339443207,
-0.721219003200531,
0.5256969332695007,
-0.18261292576789856,
0.35517680644989014,
0.4825160801410675,
0.670337975025177,
-0.20955972373485565,
0.8648021221160889,
0.42583417892456055,
-0.3891605734825134,
0.5540085434913635,
-0.0035487397108227015,
0.24989591538906097,
-0.5928977727890015,
0.03734332323074341,
-0.28176018595695496,
-0.5561147928237915,
-0.16135255992412567,
-0.19483818113803864,
0.2532902956008911,
-0.011760484427213669,
-0.058978546410799026,
0.12730103731155396,
-0.7329260110855103,
0.7772536873817444,
0.5630013942718506,
0.10247281193733215,
0.32344019412994385,
-0.3003351092338562,
0.08532961457967758,
-0.12772826850414276,
-0.5951322317123413,
-1.090074062347412,
0.6711285710334778,
0.0864596888422966,
0.4247925877571106,
0.1828840672969818,
0.5598766207695007,
0.7992472052574158,
0.7656150460243225,
-0.8827916383743286,
0.558668851852417,
0.1745661348104477,
-0.8718417882919312,
0.0663178414106369,
-0.07785345613956451,
-0.772671639919281,
0.5395285487174988,
-0.39556461572647095,
-0.7089036703109741,
0.33027535676956177,
0.2876119315624237,
-0.48256465792655945,
0.511319100856781,
-0.8974337577819824,
0.9669108986854553,
-0.20866695046424866,
-0.7248579263687134,
-0.40371444821357727,
-0.6964488625526428,
-0.03057275339961052,
0.3583056330680847,
0.04303276911377907,
0.38770782947540283,
0.006427651271224022,
0.8432297110557556,
-0.5606716871261597,
0.886140763759613,
-0.20780332386493683,
0.07382065802812576,
0.7387247085571289,
-0.05880354344844818,
0.16439789533615112,
0.10761845111846924,
-0.19775068759918213,
-0.04424327239394188,
-0.24766333401203156,
-0.13549990952014923,
-0.4607568383216858,
0.648859977722168,
-0.8780723810195923,
-1.01288902759552,
-0.5598505139350891,
-0.47020092606544495,
0.11222682148218155,
0.1708517223596573,
0.10352762788534164,
0.1667618453502655,
-0.6855082511901855,
0.3130338788032532,
0.2597290575504303,
-0.22236409783363342,
0.5989754796028137,
0.1845158189535141,
0.030945468693971634,
-0.6705306768417358,
0.7114484906196594,
0.0045373993925750256,
-0.10815748572349548,
0.25244224071502686,
0.5013981461524963,
-0.2943843603134155,
-0.46535176038742065,
-0.7408375144004822,
-0.3589169681072235,
-0.7463536858558655,
-0.1470426321029663,
-0.7938477396965027,
0.10287902504205704,
0.03215153142809868,
-0.7174733281135559,
-0.2125229835510254,
-0.37263748049736023,
-0.03713449835777283,
-0.2939278185367584,
0.340489000082016,
0.7953497767448425,
-0.10174497961997986,
0.5186998844146729,
-0.4755859673023224,
0.19083191454410553,
0.636533796787262,
-0.147038072347641,
-0.06899958848953247,
-0.22300158441066742,
-0.23674644529819489,
-0.1550590842962265,
-0.8095188736915588,
-0.7089396119117737,
0.1989692896604538,
-0.10166148096323013,
0.5565362572669983,
0.8965743184089661,
0.448361873626709,
0.5903767347335815,
-0.3030130863189697,
1.0825281143188477,
0.0846005231142044,
-1.0244574546813965,
0.6469132304191589,
-0.24242274463176727,
0.050971221178770065,
0.7702304720878601,
0.29524514079093933,
-0.45175501704216003,
-0.22991666197776794,
-0.6542125344276428,
-0.8860768675804138,
0.584743857383728,
-0.024145234376192093,
0.10845740139484406,
0.05347726121544838,
0.07343018800020218,
0.24322471022605896,
0.18259477615356445,
-0.7644278407096863,
-0.0440136194229126,
-0.7668120265007019,
-0.28608280420303345,
0.10528288781642914,
-0.14071466028690338,
-0.6187564730644226,
-0.03303069248795509,
0.4412418007850647,
-0.1382092535495758,
-0.0825684666633606,
0.5852840542793274,
-0.07046949863433838,
-0.15709833800792694,
0.5514962077140808,
0.5235409736633301,
0.7992791533470154,
-0.18733057379722595,
0.46309518814086914,
0.33027786016464233,
-0.31077060103416443,
-0.1891937255859375,
0.3431949019432068,
-0.03145032376050949,
-0.16148249804973602,
0.3900359570980072,
0.5330896377563477,
-0.43159380555152893,
-0.7376017570495605,
0.48272937536239624,
-0.2436922788619995,
-0.10743885487318039,
-0.2894775867462158,
0.16541825234889984,
0.26902100443840027,
0.49806830286979675,
0.2939215898513794,
0.35633739829063416,
0.15072478353977203,
-0.6900216937065125,
0.08555732667446136,
0.3143996000289917,
-0.6383122205734253,
-0.36793437600135803,
0.8626809120178223,
0.6978626847267151,
-0.5205195546150208,
-0.16613946855068207,
0.08567260205745697,
-0.7011597156524658,
0.6696540117263794,
0.3167440891265869,
0.7068070769309998,
0.08091253787279129,
0.1668582260608673,
-0.011766734533011913,
0.2245032638311386,
0.3672804534435272,
0.20570026338100433,
-0.13650113344192505,
-0.7360556125640869,
-0.2090068757534027,
-0.019229097291827202,
-1.021281361579895,
0.11903326958417892,
-0.5061612129211426,
0.18877434730529785,
-0.3519323468208313,
-0.18664933741092682,
0.06727618724107742,
0.16808950901031494,
-0.3225744366645813,
0.14025437831878662,
-0.047070205211639404,
0.5097726583480835,
-0.9355244040489197,
0.4067543148994446,
1.2213678359985352,
-0.5490515232086182,
-0.03709479793906212,
0.054220374673604965,
0.20739935338497162,
-0.10024192184209824,
0.11433818191289902,
0.16164539754390717,
-0.532437801361084,
-0.5539401769638062,
-0.4043733775615692,
0.023511137813329697,
0.8543910384178162,
0.2646726667881012,
-0.36186113953590393,
0.6752305626869202,
0.2815471291542053,
0.7591689229011536,
-0.7495704889297485,
0.526580810546875,
0.0034394897520542145,
0.4090379476547241,
-0.0859534740447998,
-0.3866910934448242,
0.12749572098255157,
-0.49235203862190247,
-0.5225012302398682,
-0.21014371514320374,
-0.7082070708274841,
0.6323327422142029,
-0.12661059200763702,
0.02831997163593769,
-0.1709764152765274,
0.6139458417892456,
0.16745005548000336,
0.7537351846694946,
0.9350323677062988,
0.5737559199333191,
0.5268114805221558,
0.261275976896286,
0.8481318354606628,
-0.39639899134635925,
-0.008817197754979134,
1.3714008331298828,
-0.49769026041030884,
0.9356855750083923,
0.7504863142967224,
0.05184607207775116,
0.8494599461555481,
0.29893654584884644,
0.23815865814685822,
0.2418489009141922,
-0.004511083476245403,
-0.4927462935447693,
-0.5021919012069702,
-0.47489097714424133,
-0.3833255171775818,
0.35945263504981995,
0.33861589431762695,
-0.40985631942749023,
-0.0006117581506259739,
-0.23683398962020874,
0.3369956910610199,
0.5640390515327454,
0.06642718613147736,
1.0256787538528442,
0.04137575626373291,
-0.820587694644928,
-0.272099107503891,
-0.3576003313064575,
0.5471321940422058,
0.014752128161489964,
-0.2561350166797638,
-0.13032114505767822,
0.246308371424675,
-0.38769280910491943,
-0.9241043925285339,
0.3331669569015503,
0.19897638261318207,
-0.3182581663131714,
-0.2007453441619873,
0.8955918550491333,
0.13051243126392365,
-0.5186258554458618,
0.07256732136011124,
0.8462452292442322,
-0.010762938298285007,
0.05039719119668007,
-0.6039873957633972,
-0.12225117534399033,
-0.21412435173988342,
-0.4267754554748535,
-0.024781862273812294,
0.33356261253356934,
0.07388917356729507,
0.3283897042274475,
0.5219074487686157,
-0.18163657188415527,
-0.5389552712440491,
-0.005131032783538103,
1.1169226169586182,
-0.6629824638366699,
-0.4547461271286011,
-1.0552616119384766,
0.6967426538467407,
-0.6622371077537537,
-0.5376185178756714,
0.6351379752159119,
0.7602320909500122,
0.7145422697067261,
0.1529417783021927,
1.2028367519378662,
-0.3276301920413971,
0.622948169708252,
0.18034876883029938,
0.8657870888710022,
-0.6549520492553711,
0.27566319704055786,
-0.48784929513931274,
-0.5861344933509827,
-0.16077782213687897,
0.7564994096755981,
-0.39793166518211365,
-0.21287895739078522,
0.34449297189712524,
0.4544585645198822,
-0.0187638308852911,
0.1379186362028122,
0.019587310031056404,
0.0007680971175432205,
0.581788182258606,
0.40395450592041016,
1.2915513515472412,
-0.29605916142463684,
0.7403431534767151,
-0.06955314427614212,
-0.11062148213386536,
-0.28066712617874146,
-0.9576225280761719,
-1.2618900537490845,
-0.37008538842201233,
-0.3830745816230774,
-0.18805372714996338,
-0.08810579031705856,
1.0645583868026733,
0.7373002171516418,
-0.7938722372055054,
-0.2633701264858246,
-0.17591018974781036,
0.49380770325660706,
0.07999187707901001,
-0.24424080550670624,
0.2617524266242981,
0.07947973161935806,
-0.7899459600448608,
0.27727916836738586,
0.21939559280872345,
-0.48412731289863586,
-0.2408045530319214,
-0.05913306772708893,
-0.1997351050376892,
0.5257237553596497,
0.6920963525772095,
0.41690051555633545,
-0.6972826719284058,
-0.661152184009552,
-0.2047674059867859,
0.2671400010585785,
0.3983692526817322,
0.8078117966651917,
-1.0691556930541992,
0.7758904695510864,
0.6643056273460388,
0.5827152132987976,
0.16330239176750183,
0.530860185623169,
0.7045139074325562,
-0.4205501675605774,
0.25746750831604004,
0.20670755207538605,
0.4630610942840576,
0.20423220098018646,
-0.24085910618305206,
0.3766672909259796,
0.03956927731633186,
-0.6695314049720764,
-0.6236786842346191,
0.1727568656206131,
-1.0661953687667847,
-0.3468528091907501,
0.5470174551010132,
-0.27075403928756714,
0.07555433362722397,
-0.44250115752220154,
-0.7026544213294983,
-0.003433064790442586,
-0.7145527005195618,
1.1783747673034668,
0.769578218460083,
-0.5252106189727783,
-0.19189982116222382,
-0.2516978085041046,
0.3122915029525757,
0.5470080971717834,
-1.1872737407684326,
-0.25830501317977905,
0.4554578959941864,
-0.14106756448745728,
0.4503295421600342,
0.43228650093078613,
0.08086796849966049,
0.10726651549339294,
-0.0014028851874172688,
0.10745762288570404,
-0.02588212676346302,
-0.19479377567768097,
-0.12130958586931229,
0.5436811447143555,
-0.06735407561063766,
-0.2003350555896759
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.02791v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.02791v1
|
Language Models can Infer Action Semantics for Classical Planners from Environment Feedback
| 2024-06-04T21:29:56 | 2024-06-04T21:29:56 |
Wang Zhu, Ishika Singh, Robin Jia, Jesse Thomason
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.RO
|
Classical planning approaches guarantee finding a set of actions that can
achieve a given goal state when possible, but require an expert to specify
logical action semantics that govern the dynamics of the environment.
Researchers have shown that Large Language Models (LLMs) can be used to
directly infer planning steps based on commonsense knowledge and minimal domain
information alone, but such plans often fail on execution. We bring together
the strengths of classical planning and LLM commonsense inference to perform
domain induction, learning and validating action pre- and post-conditions based
on closed-loop interactions with the environment itself. We propose PSALM,
which leverages LLM inference to heuristically complete partial plans emitted
by a classical planner given partial domain knowledge, as well as to infer the
semantic rules of the domain in a logical language based on environment
feedback after execution. Our analysis on 7 environments shows that with just
one expert-curated example plans, using LLMs as heuristic planners and rule
predictors achieves lower environment execution steps and environment resets
than random exploration while simultaneously recovering the underlying ground
truth action semantics of the domain.
|
[
-0.2511570155620575,
-0.6097191572189331,
0.8761081695556641,
0.3556560277938843,
0.14459268748760223,
-0.543451726436615,
-0.6007218956947327,
-0.13573220372200012,
0.17716318368911743,
0.8581148982048035,
-1.0478425025939941,
-0.5888691544532776,
-0.3158363103866577,
-0.1162618026137352,
-0.37356412410736084,
0.599363386631012,
-0.12762366235256195,
-0.1201423704624176,
-0.04312983155250549,
0.16404780745506287,
-0.24754691123962402,
-0.21721982955932617,
-0.41927647590637207,
-0.7056950330734253,
0.21288277208805084,
0.37169888615608215,
0.6565237641334534,
0.3238590359687805,
0.21281591057777405,
0.3529947102069855,
-0.185248464345932,
0.2560504376888275,
-0.6009921431541443,
-0.03202332928776741,
-0.42601528763771057,
-0.06535331159830093,
-0.31871941685676575,
-0.02460385486483574,
0.44385987520217896,
0.661453902721405,
-0.524574875831604,
-0.0870961993932724,
-0.10340340435504913,
0.3254315257072449,
-0.8573930859565735,
0.611400306224823,
-0.745667576789856,
0.2683224678039551,
0.2805761694908142,
-0.506186306476593,
-0.5944222211837769,
-0.06120465323328972,
0.2712237238883972,
-0.839377760887146,
-0.2356635332107544,
0.2304089218378067,
0.6798915266990662,
0.3833616375923157,
-0.011681737378239632,
-0.6616221070289612,
-1.107589602470398,
1.0438100099563599,
-0.8760004043579102,
0.30384641885757446,
0.7353549599647522,
0.24357390403747559,
-0.6310800909996033,
-0.7595014572143555,
-0.8702082633972168,
-0.14405138790607452,
-0.35244590044021606,
0.3183251619338989,
-0.13748806715011597,
0.06916818022727966,
0.5177224278450012,
-0.04040597379207611,
-0.22283214330673218,
0.1185111328959465,
-0.5152326226234436,
0.06321839243173599,
0.5125854015350342,
0.24936197698116302,
0.14373964071273804,
-0.3051196336746216,
-0.3974328637123108,
-0.07220518589019775,
-0.8871386647224426,
0.07467277348041534,
0.12379632145166397,
0.38370829820632935,
-0.1909312605857849,
0.5406350493431091,
-0.29801830649375916,
0.7125211954116821,
-0.05291597172617912,
-0.26454034447669983,
-0.5177015662193298,
-0.12573057413101196,
-0.5207517147064209,
0.15201768279075623,
0.572751522064209,
0.22096575796604156,
0.29506632685661316,
-0.31504759192466736,
-0.42863813042640686,
0.17182719707489014,
0.28600868582725525,
-0.5083884000778198,
-0.28054243326187134,
0.1920112520456314,
-0.20022214949131012,
0.12929174304008484,
-0.13689449429512024,
-0.7028355598449707,
-0.2878934442996979,
-0.753864586353302,
0.2649841904640198,
-0.5227491855621338,
-0.3216891884803772,
0.5435755252838135,
-0.008599783293902874,
0.589380145072937,
0.5854117274284363,
-0.7352874279022217,
0.5809171795845032,
1.016767144203186,
0.3527661859989166,
0.31567004323005676,
-0.611591637134552,
-0.6418912410736084,
0.5301186442375183,
-0.5499937534332275,
1.0354278087615967,
-0.6356865167617798,
-0.4699035882949829,
0.2520803213119507,
-0.2127181738615036,
-0.09948646277189255,
-0.2856387495994568,
0.7736139893531799,
-0.8323016166687012,
0.22608548402786255,
-0.31922101974487305,
-0.6496348977088928,
-0.39534246921539307,
0.15906094014644623,
-0.4454769492149353,
0.4955444037914276,
-0.1407092660665512,
-0.528042733669281,
0.6177331209182739,
-0.7201986908912659,
-0.5872250199317932,
-0.07715500146150589,
-0.25128570199012756,
-0.042891524732112885,
0.05464690178632736,
0.2392231523990631,
0.3642771244049072,
-0.12150021642446518,
0.3450314998626709,
-0.46711036562919617,
-0.07666540145874023,
0.03866549953818321,
0.058518532663583755,
0.5762168765068054,
0.12297022342681885,
-0.37956687808036804,
0.47395849227905273,
-0.4531562924385071,
0.22901925444602966,
-0.02712344564497471,
-0.3485005795955658,
-0.009228291921317577,
0.5881792902946472,
-0.17884986102581024,
0.31939584016799927,
-0.03753843158483505,
-0.30487576127052307,
0.019379764795303345,
-0.27283769845962524,
0.3814319670200348,
0.8768913149833679,
0.03945072740316391,
0.6049347519874573,
-0.3295019268989563,
0.4222119450569153,
-0.4606945812702179,
-0.12301170825958252,
-0.06734811514616013,
-0.3412286639213562,
-0.5759602189064026,
-0.08543708175420761,
-0.12511713802814484,
0.48628121614456177,
-0.42763277888298035,
0.4881912171840668,
-0.46125420928001404,
-0.2199532389640808,
0.07757063210010529,
0.01063261553645134,
0.4615969657897949,
0.34853866696357727,
0.18012171983718872,
-0.00038086436688899994,
-0.5716575980186462,
-0.5526329874992371,
-0.17062117159366608,
-0.18197612464427948,
0.21657001972198486,
0.28098365664482117,
0.43766894936561584,
0.07241138815879822,
1.010027289390564,
-0.47224220633506775,
-0.06952204555273056,
-0.6304376125335693,
0.06211257353425026,
0.22395938634872437,
0.24329836666584015,
0.28422531485557556,
-0.5993862748146057,
-0.18897530436515808,
-0.11792121082544327,
-0.7730428576469421,
-0.04295330494642258,
-0.2300601750612259,
-0.46634888648986816,
-0.20549626648426056,
0.5106896758079529,
-0.6019929051399231,
0.53627610206604,
0.43236473202705383,
-0.22959572076797485,
0.5977802276611328,
-0.22412168979644775,
-0.17012232542037964,
-0.7395359873771667,
-0.06999809294939041,
-0.04658111557364464,
-0.17005564272403717,
-0.62480229139328,
0.23915021121501923,
-0.0015946083003655076,
-0.15076413750648499,
-0.46163052320480347,
0.5982033014297485,
-0.376533567905426,
-0.5188139081001282,
-0.3468492925167084,
-0.00022611537133343518,
-0.33337026834487915,
0.6623230576515198,
0.7035137414932251,
0.5716148018836975,
0.4803929626941681,
-1.0370479822158813,
0.02920999750494957,
0.6433997750282288,
-0.5599156022071838,
0.3838946521282196,
-0.5628530383110046,
-0.05449466407299042,
-0.15888985991477966,
0.6158030033111572,
-0.44674384593963623,
-0.49324458837509155,
-0.058302924036979675,
-0.09192313998937607,
0.15569010376930237,
-0.3327520787715912,
-0.659064531326294,
-0.4142684042453766,
0.001877021393738687,
-0.3007199168205261,
0.5667018294334412,
-0.539592444896698,
0.7267991304397583,
0.20019519329071045,
0.020768163725733757,
-0.27824413776397705,
-0.6106247901916504,
0.042795196175575256,
-0.14698506891727448,
-0.581051230430603,
0.07441965490579605,
0.08561466634273529,
-0.6643540859222412,
0.12872087955474854,
-0.05052651837468147,
-0.07537777721881866,
0.03434918448328972,
0.5291646122932434,
0.08775065839290619,
-0.1515798419713974,
-0.24279041588306427,
-0.06160958483815193,
-0.27403533458709717,
0.2573987543582916,
-0.3648216128349304,
0.5617581605911255,
-0.020915955305099487,
-0.5206621885299683,
-0.6001017689704895,
0.35082486271858215,
0.7579463720321655,
-0.40529268980026245,
0.5040016174316406,
-0.07007835805416107,
-0.5279175043106079,
-0.4370232820510864,
-0.1288207322359085,
-0.38432198762893677,
-0.46102800965309143,
-0.0761716440320015,
-0.34075504541397095,
-0.43473270535469055,
0.1399160474538803,
-0.5799247026443481,
0.5261768102645874,
0.3053809702396393,
0.49074360728263855,
-0.0331362709403038,
0.6287865042686462,
0.6427561044692993,
0.3017224967479706,
0.19289596378803253,
-0.5040491223335266,
0.24685554206371307,
-0.8339073061943054,
0.006158101372420788,
-0.3488750159740448,
-0.4656311571598053,
-0.32606905698776245,
-0.337758868932724,
0.3542481064796448,
0.23288588225841522,
-0.37456947565078735,
0.2954378128051758,
0.022708594799041748,
0.296480268239975,
0.6871715784072876,
-0.0286796223372221,
0.14130103588104248,
0.17778383195400238,
-0.1856674700975418,
-0.06719695776700974,
-0.6003338694572449,
-0.8492458462715149,
0.6863083243370056,
-0.04708772525191307,
0.866278886795044,
0.32606372237205505,
0.7615500688552856,
0.05224234238266945,
0.4692191779613495,
-0.6902621388435364,
0.6578184962272644,
0.269795298576355,
-0.42638516426086426,
-0.31080392003059387,
-0.10488523542881012,
-0.7708802223205566,
0.23369675874710083,
-0.3623400032520294,
-0.7932031154632568,
0.1376107931137085,
0.21327108144760132,
-0.7035314440727234,
0.3649011552333832,
-0.5203519463539124,
0.7793360948562622,
-0.15020860731601715,
-0.4270564913749695,
-0.746983528137207,
-0.3322840929031372,
0.42452773451805115,
0.00037746087764389813,
0.3896145522594452,
-0.1231686994433403,
0.07266434282064438,
0.3778488039970398,
-0.6371344327926636,
1.0563743114471436,
-0.19768336415290833,
-0.14628657698631287,
0.3194865584373474,
0.35848090052604675,
0.9647423028945923,
-0.038282256573438644,
-0.22386758029460907,
-0.46323665976524353,
-0.2535753846168518,
-0.4801423251628876,
-0.5836630463600159,
0.8852000832557678,
-0.6394945383071899,
-0.6034242510795593,
-0.1530342847108841,
-0.2789480686187744,
-0.4027945399284363,
0.19446039199829102,
0.11475396901369095,
0.5296569466590881,
-0.17448891699314117,
-0.31406980752944946,
0.48426881432533264,
-0.3782642185688019,
0.588456928730011,
0.8844268321990967,
-0.3872496485710144,
-0.32641613483428955,
0.46017932891845703,
-0.2696758508682251,
0.3138824999332428,
0.3132883608341217,
0.3971722722053528,
-0.29429924488067627,
-0.6702423095703125,
-0.22993426024913788,
0.23117145895957947,
-0.7341206073760986,
0.11820977181196213,
-0.6203765869140625,
-0.007235514000058174,
-0.18284469842910767,
-0.5778633952140808,
-0.19469979405403137,
-0.2819514870643616,
0.19870498776435852,
-0.21683189272880554,
0.3004867434501648,
1.0783259868621826,
-0.2985827624797821,
0.32789283990859985,
-0.5971881747245789,
0.05786186456680298,
0.2324949949979782,
0.0440065972507,
-0.04145833104848862,
-0.24630801379680634,
0.04902658611536026,
-0.10520783811807632,
-0.27065974473953247,
-0.7231767773628235,
0.44172704219818115,
0.2635291814804077,
0.4655416011810303,
0.5867119431495667,
0.29670459032058716,
0.7953442335128784,
-0.6917963624000549,
0.7260437607765198,
-0.06618408113718033,
-0.5925572514533997,
0.8139641880989075,
-0.36757364869117737,
0.21828901767730713,
0.355741947889328,
0.24074625968933105,
-0.4939707815647125,
-0.28877705335617065,
-0.8012712001800537,
-0.6537699699401855,
0.7563218474388123,
0.023456865921616554,
-0.00533440662547946,
-0.12744487822055817,
0.1559874415397644,
0.09322767704725266,
0.25624459981918335,
-0.5731585621833801,
0.14177358150482178,
0.09442214667797089,
0.2829996347427368,
0.05760122835636139,
-0.14915834367275238,
-0.3649211823940277,
-0.12726540863513947,
0.6031296849250793,
-0.03593027591705322,
0.14774158596992493,
0.13434071838855743,
-0.15219923853874207,
-0.4147544801235199,
0.4462692439556122,
1.027226448059082,
0.8768909573554993,
-0.08361872285604477,
0.3404659926891327,
0.26390764117240906,
0.1266045719385147,
-0.15895409882068634,
-0.1327494978904724,
-0.29570579528808594,
-0.3495441973209381,
0.9201000332832336,
0.6750739812850952,
0.67559415102005,
-0.742543637752533,
0.30225956439971924,
-0.007476178929209709,
-0.17622464895248413,
-0.7014968991279602,
0.011962493881583214,
0.17870944738388062,
0.2500692903995514,
-0.16369040310382843,
0.21442869305610657,
-0.1527554988861084,
-0.5009838938713074,
0.3735596835613251,
0.189524844288826,
-0.4225078225135803,
-0.5639510750770569,
0.3369891941547394,
-0.017700141295790672,
-0.10593639314174652,
0.5805193781852722,
-0.4580343961715698,
-0.7178681492805481,
0.41512539982795715,
0.62103670835495,
0.815950870513916,
0.139234259724617,
0.028588946908712387,
0.5476749539375305,
0.19413477182388306,
-0.15664274990558624,
0.7479357719421387,
-0.13439884781837463,
-0.6722644567489624,
-0.8234959840774536,
-0.9420086741447449,
-0.30841273069381714,
0.20457932353019714,
-0.37503328919410706,
0.10477431118488312,
-0.8851429224014282,
0.3224520981311798,
-0.24435998499393463,
-0.0984060987830162,
-0.7658818960189819,
-0.01779073290526867,
-0.03974964842200279,
1.0929104089736938,
-0.6626793742179871,
0.5618323683738708,
0.9796780347824097,
-0.2787160575389862,
-0.9250367283821106,
0.1917417049407959,
0.344056636095047,
-0.8743239045143127,
1.0503324270248413,
-0.09571098536252975,
-0.3214103579521179,
-0.24821804463863373,
-0.4804304242134094,
-0.8753671050071716,
0.8925544023513794,
0.06045091524720192,
-0.618528425693512,
0.0757674053311348,
-0.21667924523353577,
0.3879966139793396,
-0.16519899666309357,
-0.10528144240379333,
0.4285458028316498,
0.9245244860649109,
0.32121965289115906,
-0.8783758878707886,
-0.02015823870897293,
0.1991136223077774,
-0.27479878067970276,
0.3322312831878662,
-0.14716178178787231,
0.46912771463394165,
-0.47046583890914917,
-0.4636648893356323,
0.17018695175647736,
1.036179780960083,
0.2563657760620117,
0.2567793130874634,
0.5382380485534668,
1.013488531112671,
0.6632254719734192,
0.07840961962938309,
1.4233349561691284,
-0.6132017374038696,
0.14007434248924255,
1.221934199333191,
-0.45988476276397705,
1.2565618753433228,
0.06813833117485046,
-0.23929904401302338,
0.5372465252876282,
0.5656074285507202,
0.5925751328468323,
1.0314760208129883,
0.2215786725282669,
-0.42114269733428955,
-0.4851882755756378,
-0.03752106428146362,
0.11354731768369675,
0.5333471298217773,
0.696133553981781,
0.0375262089073658,
-0.64894038438797,
-0.25626763701438904,
0.2116970419883728,
0.37461057305336,
-0.37880590558052063,
0.7928993701934814,
0.02871752716600895,
-1.05909264087677,
0.2702834904193878,
-0.01245332695543766,
0.39857250452041626,
-0.6276244521141052,
0.02341860719025135,
-0.02278318628668785,
0.4311128854751587,
-0.2511112093925476,
-0.7971215844154358,
0.4798600673675537,
-0.1560126692056656,
-0.03614223003387451,
-0.4538334906101227,
0.5691689252853394,
-0.28298360109329224,
-0.22971075773239136,
0.3306882977485657,
0.3877670466899872,
0.009658650495111942,
0.05904502421617508,
-0.4005948305130005,
-0.1519140601158142,
-0.19888070225715637,
-0.03888941928744316,
0.04073026403784752,
0.5871536731719971,
-0.15129120647907257,
0.4800364077091217,
0.673330545425415,
0.27107274532318115,
0.10785839706659317,
-0.21494878828525543,
0.6961575746536255,
-0.6760516166687012,
-0.5275744795799255,
-0.6419566869735718,
0.13777543604373932,
-0.20995619893074036,
-0.211372509598732,
0.4921751320362091,
0.3878220319747925,
0.7792306542396545,
0.006691808812320232,
0.8116601705551147,
0.10263560712337494,
0.3146198093891144,
-0.8131294846534729,
0.2433347851037979,
-0.1641894429922104,
0.3498311936855316,
0.02293882705271244,
-0.6818721890449524,
-0.016582066193223,
0.6989567875862122,
-0.8362393975257874,
-0.12565435469150543,
0.604468047618866,
0.7620322108268738,
-0.33803731203079224,
0.12958401441574097,
0.25486359000205994,
0.10124412924051285,
0.4804709851741791,
0.5865530371665955,
1.074589490890503,
0.3378938138484955,
0.08030357211828232,
-0.18271753191947937,
-0.4351421594619751,
-0.07556741684675217,
-0.929110050201416,
-0.709296703338623,
-0.45558634400367737,
0.01607062853872776,
-0.21248309314250946,
-0.016503944993019104,
1.168125867843628,
0.8786262273788452,
-0.7334599494934082,
-0.37511685490608215,
-0.36491072177886963,
0.022600781172513962,
-0.33061477541923523,
-0.17916566133499146,
0.4326819181442261,
-0.5187940001487732,
-0.4388468265533447,
0.8455965518951416,
0.49100446701049805,
-0.2491413801908493,
-0.39693519473075867,
-0.5375445485115051,
-0.017473934218287468,
0.28025949001312256,
0.6582527756690979,
0.6768010854721069,
-1.175647258758545,
-0.12545545399188995,
-0.31938040256500244,
-0.046637244522571564,
-0.3235710859298706,
1.1723973751068115,
-0.7725045084953308,
0.11073389649391174,
0.34478113055229187,
0.4344431161880493,
0.4764341413974762,
-0.4061364233493805,
0.8916107416152954,
-0.570417046546936,
0.09349081665277481,
0.17154942452907562,
0.7188840508460999,
0.18003542721271515,
0.04850488156080246,
0.5826686024665833,
-0.0719323456287384,
-0.38222378492355347,
-0.34252896904945374,
0.6528040766716003,
-0.730935275554657,
-0.3644886016845703,
1.3320908546447754,
-0.16515260934829712,
-0.4488475024700165,
0.13002601265907288,
-0.196248397231102,
-0.25828269124031067,
-0.29023420810699463,
0.6802332401275635,
0.5800701975822449,
-0.2680920958518982,
-0.2176397144794464,
-0.6468933820724487,
0.8575658202171326,
0.19163914024829865,
-0.7502740025520325,
0.41295325756073,
0.791049599647522,
-0.08531869202852249,
0.31800419092178345,
0.6648627519607544,
0.1866942197084427,
0.2970117926597595,
-0.10719583183526993,
-0.11700310558080673,
0.12039241939783096,
-0.2052394598722458,
0.08822110295295715,
0.09409596771001816,
0.2898595631122589,
0.2496359944343567
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.02787v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.02787v1
|
Disentangling Logic: The Role of Context in Large Language Model Reasoning Capabilities
| 2024-06-04T21:25:06 | 2024-06-04T21:25:06 |
Wenyue Hua, Kaijie Zhu, Lingyao Li, Lizhou Fan, Shuhang Lin, Mingyu Jin, Haochen Xue, Zelong Li, JinDong Wang, Yongfeng Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
This study intends to systematically disentangle pure logic reasoning and
text understanding by investigating the contrast across abstract and
contextualized logical problems from a comprehensive set of domains. We explore
whether LLMs demonstrate genuine reasoning capabilities across various domains
when the underlying logical structure remains constant. We focus on two main
questions (1) Can abstract logical problems alone accurately benchmark an LLM's
reasoning ability in real-world scenarios, disentangled from contextual support
in practical settings? (2) Does fine-tuning LLMs on abstract logic problem
generalize to contextualized logic problems and vice versa? To investigate
these questions, we focus on standard propositional logic, specifically
propositional deductive and abductive logic reasoning. In particular, we
construct instantiated datasets for deductive and abductive reasoning with 4
levels of difficulty, encompassing 12 distinct categories or domains based on
the categorization of Wikipedia. Our experiments aim to provide insights into
disentangling context in logical reasoning and the true reasoning capabilities
of LLMs and their generalization potential. The code and dataset are available
at: https://github.com/agiresearch/ContextHub.
|
[
-0.3952741324901581,
-1.1723480224609375,
0.7966646552085876,
-0.1004105806350708,
-0.26052364706993103,
0.13335905969142914,
-0.28424331545829773,
-0.5530194044113159,
-0.39459317922592163,
0.25472715497016907,
-0.5861117839813232,
-0.3093855381011963,
-0.7138376235961914,
0.42172592878341675,
-0.3998419940471649,
0.7089769840240479,
-0.14201956987380981,
-0.11195474863052368,
-0.6864312291145325,
-0.1951780915260315,
-0.6166711449623108,
-0.6045734286308289,
-0.40266746282577515,
-0.43399253487586975,
0.34767740964889526,
0.22095046937465668,
0.41010990738868713,
0.5522109270095825,
0.5070945024490356,
0.38412052392959595,
-0.34054645895957947,
0.22492891550064087,
-0.4070870280265808,
0.3768455982208252,
-0.7652955651283264,
-0.3530009388923645,
-0.1959916055202484,
-0.060259122401475906,
0.5551376938819885,
0.8673063516616821,
-0.052497852593660355,
0.052406005561351776,
0.06971164047718048,
0.8206050992012024,
-0.6244780421257019,
0.09318829327821732,
-0.9933379888534546,
-0.03870299085974693,
0.026198003441095352,
-0.11643895506858826,
-0.422585666179657,
0.03144111484289169,
0.26080742478370667,
-0.6500610113143921,
0.03322891891002655,
0.11855215579271317,
0.6189707517623901,
0.7054834365844727,
-0.8618118762969971,
-0.3452655076980591,
-0.7720099091529846,
0.8601335287094116,
-0.5926868915557861,
0.059242457151412964,
0.10865160077810287,
0.3797629475593567,
-0.2186993658542633,
-0.6545943021774292,
-0.7420170903205872,
0.1795467883348465,
-0.23504972457885742,
-0.001837631338275969,
-0.35153165459632874,
-0.08495251089334488,
0.48589658737182617,
0.5096523761749268,
-0.4687621593475342,
0.06694405525922775,
-0.1599976271390915,
-0.03794044628739357,
0.5597432255744934,
0.14826971292495728,
0.3182162940502167,
-0.12683966755867004,
-0.31317147612571716,
0.14254100620746613,
-0.883305013179779,
0.05491602048277855,
0.021763570606708527,
-0.08765052258968353,
0.053693387657403946,
0.4219307601451874,
-0.2697497010231018,
0.9300973415374756,
-0.07242807000875473,
-0.11425646394491196,
0.042903393507003784,
-0.24189265072345734,
-0.2934783697128296,
0.19564104080200195,
0.303681880235672,
0.22700336575508118,
0.3522125780582428,
0.045608099550008774,
-0.22176557779312134,
0.14856185019016266,
0.15889005362987518,
-0.585557222366333,
-0.048892296850681305,
0.19937466084957123,
-0.3791334927082062,
-0.0856311097741127,
-0.013461041264235973,
-0.2734616994857788,
-0.5067213773727417,
-0.6807651519775391,
0.4108760356903076,
-0.34980934858322144,
-0.34825852513313293,
0.35972312092781067,
-0.19443979859352112,
0.35455968976020813,
0.37944620847702026,
-0.7985798716545105,
0.3220226764678955,
0.8740650415420532,
0.5332686305046082,
-0.38645750284194946,
-0.1563606560230255,
-0.3833424746990204,
0.08531064540147781,
-0.22369664907455444,
0.6154114603996277,
-0.4383118450641632,
-0.05184440314769745,
0.011411895975470543,
0.10574930161237717,
-0.17015017569065094,
-0.7624582052230835,
0.4356723129749298,
-0.6904954314231873,
-0.001955063547939062,
-0.3331875503063202,
-0.7173119783401489,
-0.21676063537597656,
0.6283777952194214,
-0.6280251145362854,
0.5988888144493103,
-0.08101411908864975,
-0.7680104970932007,
0.14161242544651031,
-0.3311392068862915,
-0.5374985337257385,
-0.09288551658391953,
-0.5514447689056396,
0.05929059162735939,
0.1946699470281601,
0.1169014722108841,
0.40711313486099243,
-0.3106369078159332,
0.4464404881000519,
-0.07070057094097137,
-0.4322863221168518,
0.5105636715888977,
-0.4790220260620117,
0.7742562294006348,
0.2318122535943985,
-0.6072565317153931,
-0.05975974723696709,
-0.8157317042350769,
-0.18583552539348602,
0.27927374839782715,
-0.2244056910276413,
-0.6207686066627502,
0.3457147479057312,
-0.3572676479816437,
0.35864579677581787,
0.24483756721019745,
-0.3324522376060486,
0.21799902617931366,
-0.5384476184844971,
0.7294994592666626,
0.6870054006576538,
-0.045195531100034714,
0.3641548752784729,
-0.037502601742744446,
0.11260918527841568,
0.4375153183937073,
-0.3540898263454437,
-0.11600220203399658,
-0.40818431973457336,
-0.5515604019165039,
-0.3149147033691406,
0.27997416257858276,
0.5684990286827087,
-0.6930208206176758,
0.6319683790206909,
-0.11844804883003235,
0.0857592448592186,
-0.10809113085269928,
0.018707482144236565,
0.43276190757751465,
1.1102640628814697,
0.32820582389831543,
0.26373177766799927,
-0.2771677076816559,
-1.032821536064148,
-0.2196284681558609,
0.15184080600738525,
-0.24693886935710907,
0.20466063916683197,
0.7684109807014465,
-0.3795534670352936,
1.0442737340927124,
-0.6949352622032166,
-0.1626204401254654,
-0.31191104650497437,
-0.1682223230600357,
0.21977359056472778,
0.3371164798736572,
0.23738807439804077,
-1.0938777923583984,
-0.3038700520992279,
0.07838883996009827,
-1.0367710590362549,
-0.11529169976711273,
-0.006870047189295292,
-0.11401550471782684,
0.3028465211391449,
0.6939119696617126,
-0.6019861698150635,
0.5580166578292847,
0.17656415700912476,
-0.4725894033908844,
0.44024914503097534,
-0.28926676511764526,
0.06108086183667183,
-0.9052706956863403,
0.0301585104316473,
-0.11488501727581024,
-0.1722613275051117,
-0.5667729377746582,
-0.025577234104275703,
0.04095514118671417,
0.1000729501247406,
-0.42529353499412537,
0.5573453903198242,
-0.36582207679748535,
0.011139514856040478,
-0.34943652153015137,
0.5150893926620483,
0.3339841067790985,
0.3404882848262787,
0.21398529410362244,
0.6403749585151672,
0.5482263565063477,
-0.7961928248405457,
0.30652809143066406,
0.1601325124502182,
-0.42373645305633545,
0.5650701522827148,
-0.6752203106880188,
-0.12972413003444672,
-0.21054089069366455,
0.3976086974143982,
-1.2105966806411743,
-0.16536162793636322,
0.11176133900880814,
-0.22045722603797913,
0.038203079253435135,
0.0862044095993042,
-0.5325560569763184,
-0.014334674924612045,
-0.013717537745833397,
0.6600801944732666,
0.4725654721260071,
-0.6266060471534729,
0.4173758625984192,
0.2999592423439026,
0.04037141799926758,
-0.610751211643219,
-0.6874821186065674,
-0.14862637221813202,
-0.40994131565093994,
-0.6206583976745605,
0.7402189373970032,
-0.07549405843019485,
-0.7946441769599915,
0.12346760183572769,
-0.5253642201423645,
-0.08648239076137543,
0.28631454706192017,
0.12059993296861649,
0.16898804903030396,
-0.0538276843726635,
0.4062159061431885,
0.35926929116249084,
-0.1704021394252777,
0.2610310912132263,
-0.3008972704410553,
0.17140766978263855,
-0.39000916481018066,
-0.5202777981758118,
-0.15159741044044495,
0.30657070875167847,
0.32767656445503235,
-0.19025379419326782,
0.8221859931945801,
0.2239358276128769,
-0.6458480358123779,
-0.35648488998413086,
-0.3949681520462036,
-0.16185182332992554,
-0.48767605423927307,
0.13070176541805267,
-0.6284772157669067,
-1.190685510635376,
0.7234274744987488,
-0.3454136848449707,
-0.03381821885704994,
0.47434842586517334,
0.592657208442688,
-0.044439975172281265,
0.9636629223823547,
0.4509771168231964,
0.08189374208450317,
-0.003663232084363699,
-0.2743518650531769,
0.33887189626693726,
-0.7892458438873291,
-0.23731356859207153,
-0.31590718030929565,
-0.4250076413154602,
-0.49360936880111694,
-0.21425338089466095,
0.1692783534526825,
0.38413915038108826,
-0.24627476930618286,
-0.016005685552954674,
-0.6491925716400146,
0.8085125684738159,
0.2702547609806061,
-0.07527176290750504,
0.6488091945648193,
-0.026441793888807297,
-0.21393440663814545,
-0.009212889708578587,
-0.4672262370586395,
-0.6499176621437073,
0.7847709059715271,
0.27773845195770264,
0.4918566942214966,
0.3464342951774597,
0.44128167629241943,
0.2009020447731018,
-0.06800708919763565,
-0.7074525356292725,
0.547187328338623,
-0.05035516619682312,
-0.8430019021034241,
-0.33169254660606384,
-0.5464297533035278,
-0.8993425369262695,
0.6247540712356567,
0.022280002012848854,
-0.876132607460022,
0.03765180706977844,
0.09412188827991486,
-0.017547044903039932,
0.20674178004264832,
-0.5027549862861633,
0.9019013047218323,
-0.08191265165805817,
-0.314004510641098,
-0.28245869278907776,
-0.7777372002601624,
0.5477524995803833,
0.07639682292938232,
0.29989922046661377,
-0.24615132808685303,
0.041882701218128204,
0.45936712622642517,
-0.17164556682109833,
0.6623586416244507,
0.012409958057105541,
-0.39309775829315186,
0.33088919520378113,
0.20040568709373474,
0.06759621948003769,
0.47738900780677795,
0.08006662130355835,
0.2220969945192337,
0.25142624974250793,
-0.24610941112041473,
-0.680073618888855,
0.9329105615615845,
-0.5647295117378235,
-0.935760498046875,
-0.5263735055923462,
-0.5630985498428345,
-0.39252015948295593,
0.19483479857444763,
0.17011283338069916,
0.5703954100608826,
-0.09073583036661148,
0.3021228611469269,
1.1829739809036255,
-0.10866692662239075,
0.3991192579269409,
0.47293081879615784,
0.045232824981212616,
0.005411076359450817,
0.7512466311454773,
-0.18286648392677307,
0.1550416201353073,
0.6541481018066406,
0.2723689079284668,
-0.4863699674606323,
-0.3861474394798279,
-0.37204185128211975,
0.05639094486832619,
-1.0294466018676758,
-0.08742237091064453,
-0.24507811665534973,
-0.2738136947154999,
-0.18990686535835266,
-0.06859695911407471,
-0.1538504809141159,
-0.5268970727920532,
-0.30848270654678345,
-0.15934604406356812,
0.1435651332139969,
0.5628697276115417,
0.13668952882289886,
-0.16597047448158264,
-0.5700405836105347,
0.4277842938899994,
0.3449043929576874,
0.13321730494499207,
0.02512158639729023,
-0.485117107629776,
-0.03239309787750244,
-0.010427350178360939,
-0.3232513964176178,
-0.7290152907371521,
0.03267716243863106,
-0.029739269986748695,
0.6447152495384216,
0.48412182927131653,
0.3622293770313263,
0.48505470156669617,
-0.6714407801628113,
0.6615275144577026,
0.0029180406127125025,
-0.9750173091888428,
0.7023166418075562,
-0.386771023273468,
0.46313875913619995,
0.5554578304290771,
0.39060208201408386,
-0.37218910455703735,
-0.19052071869373322,
-0.3960864245891571,
-0.7905580997467041,
0.5602888464927673,
0.24241094291210175,
0.0003627886180765927,
-0.14564886689186096,
0.6134613156318665,
0.13352082669734955,
0.357994019985199,
-0.7323362827301025,
-0.32607802748680115,
0.0643564835190773,
-0.243770033121109,
-0.026280632242560387,
-0.17685824632644653,
-0.5317019820213318,
-0.6326877474784851,
0.25662338733673096,
-0.031476762145757675,
0.0861520767211914,
0.30751219391822815,
-0.3871569335460663,
0.2627718448638916,
0.2996378242969513,
0.7049064636230469,
1.12532377243042,
-0.06854650378227234,
0.5136547684669495,
0.09792432188987732,
-0.19479583203792572,
0.3364226818084717,
0.08536755293607712,
0.07189009338617325,
-0.2634849548339844,
0.5706391930580139,
0.4803534746170044,
0.15517409145832062,
-0.9254009127616882,
0.39076244831085205,
-0.09716269373893738,
-0.5418410301208496,
-0.27414605021476746,
0.18879321217536926,
0.20589101314544678,
0.3067399561405182,
0.5204135775566101,
-0.32037514448165894,
0.19788478314876556,
-0.5013352036476135,
0.12716850638389587,
0.44856518507003784,
0.0076735480688512325,
-0.1568254679441452,
0.5000525116920471,
0.21498598158359528,
-0.04831450432538986,
0.6796811819076538,
-0.19124658405780792,
-0.46083229780197144,
0.7117621302604675,
0.7277299165725708,
0.5439895391464233,
0.26905322074890137,
-0.09533742815256119,
0.13677510619163513,
0.1252763867378235,
0.07598002254962921,
-0.14987784624099731,
-0.2660152316093445,
-0.930499792098999,
-0.5065186023712158,
-0.3646273612976074,
-0.4363289773464203,
0.33874645829200745,
-0.5446994304656982,
-0.2618807256221771,
-0.2911550998687744,
0.1339726597070694,
-0.05398695543408394,
0.10739836096763611,
-0.3199239671230316,
0.256777286529541,
0.005772466771304607,
0.7777307629585266,
-0.6340137124061584,
0.6857674717903137,
0.7898716330528259,
-0.07945197075605392,
-0.36541104316711426,
0.1104392483830452,
0.2216949611902237,
-0.3193664252758026,
0.8705185651779175,
0.4350947439670563,
-0.4696892499923706,
-0.11438585817813873,
-0.5020233392715454,
-0.6070393323898315,
1.202935814857483,
0.37948939204216003,
-0.5783791542053223,
0.21538026630878448,
0.16737014055252075,
0.48103785514831543,
-0.4631820619106293,
-0.19286367297172546,
0.7607999444007874,
0.3413361608982086,
0.10157924890518188,
-0.5990913510322571,
0.1760997623205185,
-0.12761878967285156,
-0.03922842815518379,
0.02525441348552704,
-0.3170017898082733,
0.8411281704902649,
0.1706513613462448,
-0.3900257647037506,
-0.35608503222465515,
0.4849512577056885,
0.5074698328971863,
0.5410268902778625,
0.5212316513061523,
0.6371836066246033,
0.7219482064247131,
-0.21248574554920197,
0.6845237612724304,
-0.2599683105945587,
0.14069612324237823,
1.0290931463241577,
-0.5105895400047302,
0.7282910346984863,
0.6450576782226562,
0.07849632203578949,
0.6132717728614807,
0.4987300932407379,
0.5153774619102478,
0.6331659555435181,
0.4551999270915985,
-0.45297113060951233,
-0.39184144139289856,
0.24272824823856354,
-0.4866108298301697,
0.35120680928230286,
0.5023176074028015,
-0.05028104782104492,
-0.2775307297706604,
0.1198032945394516,
-0.2536012828350067,
0.43783777952194214,
-0.12678200006484985,
0.7147497534751892,
0.25013795495033264,
-0.6732293963432312,
0.6607459783554077,
0.1687733381986618,
0.5143314003944397,
-0.3967413604259491,
-0.18470922112464905,
-0.2147650420665741,
0.44174402952194214,
-0.2139863669872284,
-0.778375506401062,
0.5568913817405701,
-0.09789831936359406,
-0.27230778336524963,
-0.21336188912391663,
1.013738751411438,
-0.1444736123085022,
-0.23135890066623688,
0.32250845432281494,
0.6948924660682678,
-0.046226441860198975,
-0.09024751931428909,
-0.6100891828536987,
0.24514296650886536,
-0.21309800446033478,
-0.3580820560455322,
0.5939533710479736,
0.7107029557228088,
-0.08772924542427063,
0.7665586471557617,
0.3917090892791748,
-0.3143841326236725,
-0.29481810331344604,
-0.05254319682717323,
0.9786688089370728,
-0.723743200302124,
-0.2599954903125763,
-1.1385948657989502,
0.5157424807548523,
-0.09852106124162674,
-0.17580895125865936,
0.759122371673584,
0.3274284303188324,
0.8799143433570862,
-0.10818897932767868,
0.48770248889923096,
-0.11259490996599197,
0.2831381559371948,
-0.5762423276901245,
0.5136143565177917,
-0.7203452587127686,
0.4437091052532196,
-0.040077369660139084,
-0.8159831166267395,
-0.26696300506591797,
0.8382475972175598,
-0.42815232276916504,
-0.17895211279392242,
0.7895811200141907,
0.48095446825027466,
-0.1929149627685547,
-0.1654045283794403,
0.3188590109348297,
0.008874206803739071,
0.34553074836730957,
0.604591429233551,
0.973301112651825,
-0.09051220118999481,
0.3069653809070587,
-0.02217566967010498,
-0.3817909061908722,
-0.06363198906183243,
-1.045124888420105,
-0.9856151342391968,
-0.7232196927070618,
-0.29967397451400757,
-0.06802219897508621,
-0.048917073756456375,
0.4893086552619934,
0.37009814381599426,
-0.6124404668807983,
-0.059162918478250504,
-0.4557350277900696,
0.6686532497406006,
-0.17496584355831146,
-0.27868765592575073,
0.2864251434803009,
-0.40696626901626587,
-0.6302289962768555,
0.49629542231559753,
0.36199450492858887,
-0.21778088808059692,
-0.2244422882795334,
0.057802747935056686,
-0.28374791145324707,
0.17938674986362457,
0.8695071935653687,
0.08483517169952393,
-0.8138593435287476,
-0.355795294046402,
-0.06198331341147423,
-0.10492116212844849,
-0.08828001469373703,
0.7468509674072266,
-0.7589699029922485,
0.18093611299991608,
0.5577291250228882,
0.7011160254478455,
0.28978589177131653,
0.20054396986961365,
0.3805100917816162,
-0.6999331116676331,
0.2985561490058899,
0.05514739081263542,
0.34703201055526733,
0.07398022711277008,
-0.2428874522447586,
0.5065978169441223,
0.2566540539264679,
-0.5550656914710999,
-0.8581178188323975,
0.5673828125,
-0.8083876967430115,
-0.8172854781150818,
1.0676969289779663,
-0.011617831885814667,
-0.10206151753664017,
-0.09486899524927139,
-0.11848030984401703,
0.07697176188230515,
0.08886134624481201,
0.6012869477272034,
0.9736605882644653,
-0.4518473744392395,
0.08066253364086151,
-0.5571854710578918,
0.5116620063781738,
0.31612032651901245,
-0.8662834167480469,
0.09570677578449249,
0.759891927242279,
0.31187430024147034,
0.15727141499519348,
0.5768394470214844,
-0.05222398415207863,
0.06354706734418869,
-0.1599280685186386,
-0.5026940703392029,
-0.07066259533166885,
-0.4632895886898041,
-0.4901686906814575,
0.006421665195375681,
-0.04328625649213791,
-0.006987206172198057
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.02756v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.02756v1
|
Aligning Large Language Models via Fine-grained Supervision
| 2024-06-04T20:21:45 | 2024-06-04T20:21:45 |
Dehong Xu, Liang Qiu, Minseok Kim, Faisal Ladhak, Jaeyoung Do
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Pre-trained large-scale language models (LLMs) excel at producing coherent
articles, yet their outputs may be untruthful, toxic, or fail to align with
user expectations. Current approaches focus on using reinforcement learning
with human feedback (RLHF) to improve model alignment, which works by
transforming coarse human preferences of LLM outputs into a feedback signal
that guides the model learning process. However, because this approach operates
on sequence-level feedback, it lacks the precision to identify the exact parts
of the output affecting user preferences. To address this gap, we propose a
method to enhance LLM alignment through fine-grained token-level supervision.
Specifically, we ask annotators to minimally edit less preferred responses
within the standard reward modeling dataset to make them more favorable,
ensuring changes are made only where necessary while retaining most of the
original content. The refined dataset is used to train a token-level reward
model, which is then used for training our fine-grained Proximal Policy
Optimization (PPO) model. Our experiment results demonstrate that this approach
can achieve up to an absolute improvement of $5.1\%$ in LLM performance, in
terms of win rate against the reference model, compared with the traditional
PPO model.
|
[
-0.3228221833705902,
-0.49665895104408264,
0.44428518414497375,
-0.09688364714384079,
-0.1522030085325241,
-0.124127097427845,
-0.6060189008712769,
-0.30039769411087036,
0.059623125940561295,
0.6121992468833923,
-0.4342517852783203,
-0.534783124923706,
-0.5872737169265747,
-0.050058942288160324,
0.03517124801874161,
1.225035309791565,
-0.07627961784601212,
-0.01893824338912964,
-0.1803513765335083,
0.11911877989768982,
-0.38757652044296265,
-0.5380151867866516,
-0.8420996069908142,
-0.6788452863693237,
0.8118349313735962,
0.49323782324790955,
0.8550450801849365,
0.8844006657600403,
0.48612868785858154,
0.2957550287246704,
-0.20063531398773193,
0.5249597430229187,
-0.5344096422195435,
-0.3435991406440735,
-0.452901154756546,
-0.37557125091552734,
-0.7688279151916504,
-0.0686798244714737,
0.3629911541938782,
0.461161732673645,
-0.2930505573749542,
0.031840305775403976,
0.33114194869995117,
0.5324562788009644,
-0.6756810545921326,
0.26460617780685425,
-0.4754962921142578,
0.07149865478277206,
-0.1177431270480156,
-0.2434924989938736,
-0.632003903388977,
-0.39331769943237305,
0.04452452436089516,
-0.8121861815452576,
-0.22280636429786682,
0.10005101561546326,
1.0724188089370728,
0.24905617535114288,
-0.30774274468421936,
-0.0677499771118164,
-0.6368564367294312,
0.8505879044532776,
-1.0894521474838257,
-0.02533830516040325,
0.4051649272441864,
0.0869918093085289,
-0.3345639109611511,
-0.34130123257637024,
-0.43338072299957275,
-0.1611371785402298,
-0.31253188848495483,
-0.03494543582201004,
0.0715847760438919,
0.33635327219963074,
-0.015865951776504517,
0.1741630882024765,
-0.184783473610878,
0.6916377544403076,
-0.07893715798854828,
-0.28710266947746277,
0.7028729915618896,
0.3270212411880493,
0.011436749249696732,
-0.07492424547672272,
-0.3153718113899231,
-0.32223692536354065,
-0.5859145522117615,
0.3807152211666107,
0.5351241827011108,
0.8065028190612793,
0.007361029740422964,
0.6480507850646973,
-0.25481605529785156,
0.7159255146980286,
0.4017634391784668,
-0.2227684110403061,
0.19572152197360992,
-0.20070558786392212,
-0.11255704611539841,
0.3134661316871643,
0.9024361371994019,
0.6200991272926331,
0.3745664358139038,
-0.20246104896068573,
-0.5940182209014893,
-0.10568370670080185,
0.46695059537887573,
-0.7624967694282532,
-0.0171138197183609,
0.11299710720777512,
-0.322569340467453,
-0.6081647872924805,
0.1704905480146408,
-0.5036479234695435,
-0.47658872604370117,
-0.7135960459709167,
0.4672762453556061,
-0.21187740564346313,
-0.025080718100070953,
0.18570975959300995,
0.2228475660085678,
0.29424089193344116,
0.4369555711746216,
-1.2989416122436523,
0.24685364961624146,
1.0837533473968506,
0.6731885671615601,
-0.22788946330547333,
-0.3754246234893799,
-0.9690494537353516,
0.28146132826805115,
-0.46010878682136536,
0.604965329170227,
-0.6823937296867371,
-0.11803217977285385,
0.17469953000545502,
0.13464273512363434,
0.13471311330795288,
-0.6320260167121887,
0.560471773147583,
-0.4753669798374176,
0.16690362989902496,
-0.24120023846626282,
-0.5782160758972168,
0.3339143991470337,
0.4864615201950073,
-0.21106424927711487,
0.9950785636901855,
0.04805129021406174,
-0.793859601020813,
0.4417365491390228,
-0.48815590143203735,
-0.2234451323747635,
-0.3321993350982666,
-0.08682148158550262,
-0.47963762283325195,
0.1729627549648285,
0.4948890805244446,
0.42928844690322876,
0.08470919728279114,
0.6858652234077454,
-0.3670255243778229,
-0.5018991827964783,
0.1972418874502182,
-0.24512732028961182,
0.10171797126531601,
0.09638968855142593,
-0.2753485441207886,
0.7708872556686401,
-0.5408236980438232,
-0.20193441212177277,
-0.08780702948570251,
-0.650412917137146,
-0.37954381108283997,
0.041510675102472305,
0.022424254566431046,
0.2773313522338867,
0.3845336139202118,
-0.4791543483734131,
0.6267505288124084,
-0.5720511078834534,
0.3094795346260071,
1.2996255159378052,
-0.3137354850769043,
0.7939621210098267,
-0.3683082163333893,
0.3485214114189148,
0.0667324960231781,
0.3043217360973358,
0.08012364059686661,
0.13429397344589233,
-0.7765436768531799,
-0.10169807076454163,
0.5579281449317932,
0.33596011996269226,
-0.38849392533302307,
0.6230167746543884,
-0.3677123785018921,
-0.21147212386131287,
-0.6134793162345886,
0.30034270882606506,
0.6020460724830627,
0.7011635899543762,
0.339426726102829,
-0.43910765647888184,
-0.4011676609516144,
-0.8521464467048645,
-0.27935007214546204,
-0.13874024152755737,
-0.10970452427864075,
0.377511203289032,
0.14088349044322968,
-0.32821226119995117,
1.0026986598968506,
-0.41220226883888245,
-0.46491625905036926,
-0.21580158174037933,
0.23329795897006989,
0.14262425899505615,
0.7115102410316467,
0.15890555083751678,
-0.34285151958465576,
-0.36661019921302795,
0.2910974621772766,
-0.41797298192977905,
-0.3250042796134949,
-0.026634616777300835,
-0.2576221227645874,
0.2276988923549652,
0.637180507183075,
-0.40595269203186035,
-0.06266769021749496,
0.4597565829753876,
-0.35593661665916443,
0.49641114473342896,
-0.320437490940094,
-0.04829006642103195,
-1.016392707824707,
0.028283070772886276,
0.021902453154325485,
-0.49295517802238464,
-0.3906245231628418,
-0.16020289063453674,
0.04572451114654541,
0.2192329317331314,
-0.41382625699043274,
0.6703201532363892,
-0.07970011979341507,
0.03727228567004204,
-0.43822968006134033,
0.21072007715702057,
-0.04226687550544739,
0.7276697754859924,
0.16444286704063416,
0.8446784019470215,
0.14743322134017944,
-0.40206417441368103,
0.08033695071935654,
0.2442389279603958,
-0.25992971658706665,
0.42962026596069336,
-0.6285818815231323,
0.08483316749334335,
-0.1324150413274765,
0.311391681432724,
-0.7636665105819702,
-0.46388986706733704,
0.12727850675582886,
-0.16324882209300995,
0.4725269675254822,
-0.11040933430194855,
-0.47397470474243164,
-0.026655927300453186,
-0.37065401673316956,
0.14244598150253296,
0.335592120885849,
-0.6544827818870544,
0.4533613622188568,
0.2701623737812042,
-0.1402679681777954,
-0.7728425860404968,
-0.4493798613548279,
-0.0977703109383583,
-0.2587072551250458,
-0.1287239044904709,
0.44521063566207886,
0.2937752902507782,
-0.127946138381958,
-0.11631165444850922,
-0.21451260149478912,
0.21384263038635254,
0.0829213559627533,
0.22378979623317719,
0.4003462493419647,
-0.09698802977800369,
0.10769626498222351,
-0.08471276611089706,
-0.2409852296113968,
-0.07564032077789307,
-0.42396342754364014,
0.678979218006134,
-0.1726035326719284,
-0.27498289942741394,
-0.6463477611541748,
-0.06267987191677094,
0.31225892901420593,
-0.323409765958786,
0.6947357654571533,
0.6744117140769958,
-0.0841861292719841,
-0.007844777777791023,
-0.36569589376449585,
-0.25968998670578003,
-0.4920053482055664,
0.3526771068572998,
-0.11239650100469589,
-1.1113032102584839,
0.31945881247520447,
-0.11677069216966629,
0.09959978610277176,
0.2666857838630676,
0.4286384582519531,
-0.06761574000120163,
1.3126635551452637,
0.6848575472831726,
-0.43867024779319763,
0.7300337553024292,
0.040304142981767654,
0.15224802494049072,
-0.9185248017311096,
-0.3501988649368286,
-0.3014414310455322,
-0.5360995531082153,
-0.4740850031375885,
-0.22063758969306946,
-0.053790703415870667,
0.425315797328949,
-0.5878490209579468,
0.2648490071296692,
-0.4189997613430023,
0.5638737082481384,
0.7130011320114136,
0.2066928744316101,
0.18214455246925354,
-0.2441965937614441,
-0.05136863887310028,
-0.00646562734618783,
-0.6310773491859436,
-0.8393018841743469,
0.9191072583198547,
0.48714715242385864,
1.006369948387146,
-0.03157597407698631,
0.9078916907310486,
0.15736302733421326,
0.4151923358440399,
-0.7120084762573242,
0.33041366934776306,
-0.24048516154289246,
-0.12183398753404617,
-0.4684060215950012,
-0.40659621357917786,
-0.8004419207572937,
0.10719840973615646,
-0.2712971270084381,
-0.9002445340156555,
0.082025445997715,
0.49105823040008545,
-0.6440370678901672,
0.2448844164609909,
-0.6936687231063843,
1.147995948791504,
-0.2893281877040863,
-0.4928230345249176,
0.03872125968337059,
-0.6065593361854553,
0.3237941563129425,
0.010712750256061554,
0.2370317429304123,
-0.10928666591644287,
0.041867323219776154,
0.596802830696106,
-0.716825008392334,
1.0817006826400757,
-0.28307777643203735,
-0.2767118215560913,
-0.0014531093183904886,
-0.0458383783698082,
0.9367129802703857,
0.03923235088586807,
0.14936375617980957,
-0.1757006049156189,
-0.06063640117645264,
-0.4746396541595459,
-0.405549556016922,
0.6788668036460876,
-0.942560076713562,
-0.6127492189407349,
-0.18839909136295319,
-0.7563071250915527,
-0.41850757598876953,
0.166853666305542,
-0.04478783160448074,
0.23843130469322205,
-0.05177731439471245,
0.023384446278214455,
0.6059395670890808,
-0.3053526282310486,
0.38844332098960876,
0.3665761351585388,
-0.45078808069229126,
-0.371890127658844,
0.8694952130317688,
-0.28431257605552673,
0.38168206810951233,
0.5238407254219055,
0.4380422532558441,
-0.31997790932655334,
-0.41667991876602173,
-0.18394708633422852,
0.03516628220677376,
-0.3929775059223175,
-0.36795443296432495,
-0.4004432260990143,
0.051436346024274826,
-0.427762895822525,
-0.39129966497421265,
-0.5234405994415283,
-0.126433864235878,
-0.3969736099243164,
-0.02964915707707405,
0.1560118943452835,
0.48766064643859863,
-0.0026421258226037025,
0.8249433040618896,
-0.7427487373352051,
-0.0009117592708207667,
0.3725988566875458,
0.457157164812088,
0.06510040163993835,
-0.7332329154014587,
-0.2778204679489136,
0.02074727602303028,
-0.28125202655792236,
-0.23772215843200684,
0.3008670210838318,
0.032539501786231995,
0.13510483503341675,
0.6602119207382202,
0.030136005952954292,
1.0602867603302002,
-0.582599401473999,
0.6040611863136292,
0.3307477831840515,
-0.9697057008743286,
0.4529556632041931,
-0.42287445068359375,
0.2828471064567566,
0.7091578841209412,
-0.018538320437073708,
-0.5297402739524841,
-0.3529481589794159,
-0.3564240336418152,
-0.8515205979347229,
0.9861789345741272,
-0.2919846475124359,
0.2831703722476959,
0.028363574296236038,
0.30093052983283997,
-0.03948763385415077,
0.13158629834651947,
-0.7039772868156433,
0.24240903556346893,
0.014649774879217148,
-0.43314915895462036,
-0.19750669598579407,
-0.30217209458351135,
-0.25535848736763,
-0.16697856783866882,
0.855133593082428,
-0.34803348779678345,
-0.2309008687734604,
-0.033225201070308685,
0.013309791684150696,
-0.21070174872875214,
0.4501650929450989,
0.6587262749671936,
0.5807154178619385,
-0.3654404580593109,
0.2942355275154114,
0.025751598179340363,
-0.0524810254573822,
0.1734524667263031,
0.007828271016478539,
-0.009790195152163506,
-0.3304861783981323,
0.3820934593677521,
0.8659243583679199,
0.3668830692768097,
-0.7705549597740173,
0.7464019656181335,
0.035039253532886505,
-0.11876230686903,
-0.009805002249777317,
0.24209994077682495,
0.18401658535003662,
0.5059158802032471,
-0.03622528165578842,
-0.07039881497621536,
-0.32130035758018494,
-0.47781243920326233,
0.18843883275985718,
0.5084523558616638,
-0.5439838171005249,
-0.18278613686561584,
0.7543131709098816,
0.14887264370918274,
-0.4135183095932007,
0.5728660225868225,
-0.09723325073719025,
-0.4379280209541321,
0.4006367623806,
0.59740149974823,
0.5498771667480469,
-0.03862079232931137,
0.189073845744133,
0.30608803033828735,
0.130136638879776,
-0.4445253908634186,
-0.08155816048383713,
0.03868675231933594,
-0.6983083486557007,
-0.7047337293624878,
-0.8919571042060852,
-0.34930890798568726,
0.17915768921375275,
-0.7180479168891907,
0.36585432291030884,
-0.5126286149024963,
-0.18376904726028442,
0.01997566968202591,
-0.04597330093383789,
-0.3567392826080322,
0.08542715013027191,
0.20380061864852905,
0.750177800655365,
-0.905302107334137,
0.9970002770423889,
0.4701845049858093,
-0.5034170746803284,
-1.1212882995605469,
-0.0563277043402195,
-0.11811254173517227,
-0.7809372544288635,
0.7052520513534546,
0.15943805873394012,
0.06020605191588402,
-0.04437320679426193,
-0.5851686000823975,
-0.6876839995384216,
0.8904088139533997,
0.47777947783470154,
-0.9377687573432922,
-0.2011832445859909,
0.17091207206249237,
0.5695189833641052,
-0.4284990727901459,
0.10484859347343445,
0.5980703830718994,
0.4534986615180969,
-0.03137899935245514,
-0.9385438561439514,
-0.13862241804599762,
0.09823425859212875,
0.16108232736587524,
0.4806983172893524,
-0.5849483013153076,
0.5386523604393005,
-0.11430280655622482,
0.19636337459087372,
-0.09114853292703629,
0.6608853340148926,
0.28682541847229004,
0.12446805089712143,
0.5330111980438232,
0.7894220948219299,
0.6478384137153625,
-0.1692003756761551,
1.0006215572357178,
-0.16070950031280518,
0.4097690284252167,
1.55758798122406,
-0.26319101452827454,
0.9620665311813354,
0.8554709553718567,
-0.0811820924282074,
0.3373008668422699,
0.9032657742500305,
0.08340571820735931,
0.5906153321266174,
0.26282286643981934,
-0.009128044359385967,
-0.42956429719924927,
-0.4646868407726288,
0.006459859199821949,
0.374201238155365,
-0.14504291117191315,
-0.36390551924705505,
-0.146434023976326,
-0.2144821286201477,
0.13538271188735962,
0.36989882588386536,
-0.5341299176216125,
1.0675430297851562,
-0.08965291827917099,
-0.8417593240737915,
0.4767102897167206,
0.12205629050731659,
0.9059543609619141,
-0.589699923992157,
0.08435602486133575,
-0.38488855957984924,
0.41421690583229065,
-0.36456263065338135,
-0.6050052642822266,
0.23719151318073273,
0.1917291283607483,
-0.20710958540439606,
-0.29913055896759033,
0.3741871416568756,
-0.669258177280426,
-0.3162658214569092,
0.13793571293354034,
-0.061613231897354126,
-0.1733236312866211,
0.06284351646900177,
-0.4788077473640442,
0.12416339665651321,
-0.11759016662836075,
-0.2019530087709427,
0.6482040286064148,
0.32482782006263733,
-0.24266663193702698,
0.3463839888572693,
0.6214743256568909,
0.20006807148456573,
-0.08882082253694534,
0.17224566638469696,
0.7853097915649414,
-0.5100146532058716,
-0.4174419343471527,
-1.1002999544143677,
0.37039676308631897,
-0.1489599347114563,
-0.3257245123386383,
0.4424910843372345,
0.6468704342842102,
1.27427339553833,
-0.01603514701128006,
0.4744967520236969,
0.1754317283630371,
0.1419709026813507,
-0.5292850732803345,
0.3448513448238373,
-0.5598591566085815,
0.24786439538002014,
-0.29406172037124634,
-0.8891890048980713,
-0.2183656245470047,
0.4754753112792969,
-0.4659944474697113,
-0.2829347252845764,
0.21368996798992157,
0.9469229578971863,
-0.27719002962112427,
-0.42123982310295105,
0.1732318103313446,
-0.02881932444870472,
0.33227449655532837,
0.6017079949378967,
0.8295316100120544,
-0.06751445680856705,
0.4345923364162445,
-0.2504323720932007,
-0.0037712003104388714,
-0.26932430267333984,
-0.9799090623855591,
-0.7904233336448669,
-0.1464102417230606,
-0.21404211223125458,
-0.2719108760356903,
0.04747651889920235,
1.3397740125656128,
0.6902027726173401,
-0.9162551760673523,
-0.250948429107666,
-0.29926878213882446,
-0.05675908923149109,
-0.24917611479759216,
-0.2203816920518875,
0.4860730469226837,
-0.8433863520622253,
-0.8885753154754639,
0.07807916402816772,
0.31581345200538635,
-0.00939647201448679,
-0.031757332384586334,
-0.4665389358997345,
-0.11515303701162338,
0.07497046887874603,
0.4308861494064331,
0.1399799883365631,
-1.0031020641326904,
-0.5101342797279358,
-0.22139298915863037,
-0.39543527364730835,
0.14578038454055786,
0.7416667342185974,
-0.4987480044364929,
0.38201454281806946,
0.28567901253700256,
0.9786061644554138,
0.33001402020454407,
0.4890310764312744,
0.6273219585418701,
-0.8671185970306396,
0.09349028021097183,
0.06956559419631958,
0.27177298069000244,
0.3130698800086975,
-0.3393477201461792,
0.23415210843086243,
-0.2825991213321686,
-0.6639713644981384,
-0.8452542424201965,
0.11574043333530426,
-0.9617741107940674,
-0.21995560824871063,
1.216497540473938,
-0.22165878117084503,
-0.3247681260108948,
0.3703078627586365,
-0.4368918538093567,
0.3958950936794281,
-0.5049145817756653,
0.9629963636398315,
0.6509199738502502,
-0.02430415153503418,
0.012107263319194317,
-0.3089050352573395,
0.6481269001960754,
0.6583206653594971,
-0.787186324596405,
0.4122239053249359,
0.470943808555603,
0.11989989131689072,
-0.03564533591270447,
0.5320249795913696,
-0.13470369577407837,
-0.08788560330867767,
-0.5244321823120117,
0.19037874042987823,
-0.1862906515598297,
-0.26609453558921814,
-0.6131490468978882,
-0.007112249732017517,
0.5513554215431213,
-0.2359713912010193
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.06582v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.06582v2
|
Discrete Multimodal Transformers with a Pretrained Large Language Model for Mixed-Supervision Speech Processing
| 2024-06-04T20:08:25 | 2024-06-25T17:44:00 |
Viet Anh Trinh, Rosy Southwell, Yiwen Guan, Xinlu He, Zhiyong Wang, Jacob Whitehill
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG, eess.AS
|
Recent work on discrete speech tokenization has paved the way for models that
can seamlessly perform multiple tasks across modalities, e.g., speech
recognition, text to speech, speech to speech translation. Moreover, large
language models (LLMs) pretrained from vast text corpora contain rich
linguistic information that can improve accuracy in a variety of tasks. In this
paper, we present a decoder-only Discrete Multimodal Language Model (DMLM),
which can be flexibly applied to multiple tasks (ASR, T2S, S2TT, etc.) and
modalities (text, speech, vision). We explore several critical aspects of
discrete multi-modal models, including the loss function, weight
initialization, mixed training supervision, and codebook. Our results show that
DMLM benefits significantly, across multiple tasks and datasets, from a
combination of supervised and unsupervised training. Moreover, for ASR, it
benefits from initializing DMLM from a pretrained LLM, and from a codebook
derived from Whisper activations.
|
[
-0.19288302958011627,
-0.4140518605709076,
0.4834538698196411,
0.3191320598125458,
-0.357421875,
-0.020631732419133186,
-0.6080914735794067,
-0.21528509259223938,
-0.18188874423503876,
0.4070274531841278,
-0.5711798071861267,
-0.3964083790779114,
-0.6506229043006897,
0.1073751449584961,
-0.5263922810554504,
1.041587471961975,
0.030893435701727867,
0.30360451340675354,
-0.2962160110473633,
0.23459303379058838,
-0.44413724541664124,
-0.6865588426589966,
-0.375232070684433,
-0.4562170207500458,
0.7131519317626953,
0.09489894658327103,
0.5289453268051147,
0.37313640117645264,
0.38562408089637756,
0.36777883768081665,
0.15165674686431885,
0.17644092440605164,
-0.2994542419910431,
-0.043384525924921036,
0.05407203361392021,
-0.3713427186012268,
-0.6170859336853027,
0.0026395758613944054,
0.8661287426948547,
0.6882920265197754,
-0.38295677304267883,
-0.012985717505216599,
0.05572664365172386,
-0.032984744757413864,
-0.5756111741065979,
0.47454288601875305,
-0.546187698841095,
-0.10932863503694534,
-0.27088621258735657,
-0.17480270564556122,
-0.6676504611968994,
0.06698573380708694,
-0.059177301824092865,
-0.5339465737342834,
0.011234046891331673,
-0.4437137246131897,
0.22234445810317993,
0.6058696508407593,
-0.8198265433311462,
-0.09858379513025284,
-1.135743498802185,
0.9672091007232666,
-0.5270418524742126,
0.7867805361747742,
0.41697242856025696,
0.3004119396209717,
0.20954985916614532,
-1.0102951526641846,
-0.6876130700111389,
-0.15105682611465454,
-0.19327184557914734,
0.32298600673675537,
-0.030282439664006233,
0.38747403025627136,
0.28430861234664917,
0.32471808791160583,
-0.294399619102478,
0.13995231688022614,
-0.15340520441532135,
-0.16279491782188416,
0.42417678236961365,
0.12990237772464752,
0.14922195672988892,
0.015858948230743408,
-0.5840327143669128,
-0.42075157165527344,
-0.30616918206214905,
-0.0473799966275692,
0.08008166402578354,
0.198777973651886,
-0.4316115975379944,
0.4436471164226532,
0.10382837802171707,
0.67626953125,
-0.21111531555652618,
-0.5171135067939758,
0.3167848289012909,
-0.4914785921573639,
-0.19317254424095154,
0.06894638389348984,
0.685884416103363,
-0.02053029090166092,
0.23631374537944794,
-0.321551650762558,
-0.5034123063087463,
0.541709840297699,
0.3998386859893799,
-0.7698079347610474,
-0.3056923449039459,
0.11582004278898239,
-0.4823867976665497,
-0.04433480277657509,
-0.009877830743789673,
-0.4466537535190582,
-0.21787545084953308,
-0.6425583362579346,
0.4305442273616791,
-0.3726772367954254,
-0.6002631187438965,
0.2668723464012146,
-0.04620916023850441,
0.11830965429544449,
0.3127204477787018,
-1.0067535638809204,
0.3662891089916229,
0.5746846795082092,
0.626807689666748,
-0.2139410823583603,
-0.4187639057636261,
-0.7174555659294128,
0.34357497096061707,
-0.16843411326408386,
0.4911956787109375,
-0.7517469525337219,
-0.4096609354019165,
-0.07137785106897354,
-0.18303143978118896,
-0.6232222318649292,
-0.3154223561286926,
0.5645328760147095,
-0.49197161197662354,
-0.016311125829815865,
0.2953484058380127,
-0.3154081404209137,
-0.09851625561714172,
0.12184251844882965,
-0.6208475828170776,
0.9349930286407471,
-0.08815354853868484,
-0.6265062093734741,
0.26499873399734497,
-0.5581517219543457,
-0.5369059443473816,
0.039925266057252884,
-0.39843863248825073,
-0.1773521453142166,
0.2225167453289032,
0.19591526687145233,
0.47634822130203247,
-0.14182959496974945,
0.5717602968215942,
-0.030959485098719597,
-0.23790307343006134,
0.45169755816459656,
-0.8112372159957886,
0.3431037664413452,
0.11346842348575592,
-0.22781793773174286,
0.5451317429542542,
-0.8423082232475281,
-0.04405727609992027,
-0.32178494334220886,
-0.7039543390274048,
-0.2158140242099762,
0.20359493792057037,
0.6561513543128967,
0.47464850544929504,
0.12786230444908142,
-0.6153558492660522,
0.06274648755788803,
-0.08180402964353561,
0.3585340976715088,
0.6431841850280762,
-0.4560736119747162,
0.429813951253891,
-0.3925330638885498,
0.4019060432910919,
0.30238988995552063,
0.22880452871322632,
-0.37459856271743774,
-0.3272187411785126,
-0.8391844034194946,
-0.8292657732963562,
0.36087584495544434,
0.44990912079811096,
-1.1349362134933472,
0.3184818625450134,
-0.5177422761917114,
-0.3446187973022461,
-0.4816071093082428,
-0.03997403755784035,
0.3708449900150299,
0.18499498069286346,
0.3798036277294159,
-0.3122406303882599,
-0.4728277623653412,
-0.6796936988830566,
0.08583994954824448,
0.13015125691890717,
-0.2058887481689453,
0.009428833611309528,
0.2675855755805969,
-0.6822489500045776,
0.7944466471672058,
-0.31519290804862976,
-0.39964500069618225,
-0.3225685656070709,
0.20569559931755066,
0.15249913930892944,
0.4490845501422882,
0.328003466129303,
-1.0523303747177124,
-0.419496089220047,
-0.026737317442893982,
-0.4771076738834381,
-0.10243286937475204,
-0.3038511276245117,
0.23274041712284088,
-0.011245040223002434,
0.5242387056350708,
-0.8321335315704346,
0.2227144092321396,
0.8425771594047546,
-0.014415520243346691,
0.49473878741264343,
-0.2527114450931549,
-0.001754407654516399,
-1.0953481197357178,
0.016239473596215248,
-0.19977755844593048,
-0.49314701557159424,
-1.0327208042144775,
-0.12604592740535736,
0.22966395318508148,
-0.17605817317962646,
-0.4191606640815735,
0.27686333656311035,
-0.3743429183959961,
-0.13706271350383759,
-0.3186451494693756,
-0.005777842365205288,
-0.22749753296375275,
0.5773173570632935,
0.33312365412712097,
0.6176725029945374,
0.8008037209510803,
-0.5768435597419739,
0.4557003676891327,
0.32143038511276245,
-0.3359817862510681,
0.3965485692024231,
-0.5787838697433472,
0.23739135265350342,
-0.15960976481437683,
0.20214548707008362,
-0.8370888829231262,
-0.09283468872308731,
-0.002686461666598916,
-0.1858062446117401,
0.40498825907707214,
0.002994075184687972,
-0.7481403350830078,
-0.0945909172296524,
-0.09014661610126495,
0.655328094959259,
0.22635993361473083,
-0.6015406847000122,
0.9943311214447021,
0.3339017927646637,
-0.13862931728363037,
-0.35366469621658325,
-0.6257852911949158,
0.09439925104379654,
-0.028392240405082703,
-0.5193699598312378,
0.6417571306228638,
-0.26745232939720154,
-0.09643583744764328,
-0.08299346268177032,
-0.17918361723423004,
-0.30355706810951233,
-0.13289006054401398,
0.44536253809928894,
0.29336124658584595,
-0.015640659257769585,
0.2280655801296234,
-0.1795986443758011,
-0.3590750992298126,
-0.05130701884627342,
-0.1586599051952362,
0.7418367266654968,
0.04627358540892601,
-0.4635111689567566,
-0.29681268334388733,
0.40193673968315125,
0.632879912853241,
-0.594663143157959,
0.6433687806129456,
0.8908276557922363,
-0.2549624741077423,
-0.24669207632541656,
-0.4692898988723755,
-0.23873332142829895,
-0.4962707459926605,
0.42392897605895996,
-0.5593456625938416,
-0.9595862030982971,
0.3181259036064148,
-0.008499921299517155,
-0.0447499044239521,
0.23599644005298615,
0.8148395419120789,
0.19503840804100037,
1.1195932626724243,
0.8834911584854126,
-0.0755915641784668,
0.7197433114051819,
-0.06743978708982468,
0.06569571048021317,
-0.6216788291931152,
-0.40209606289863586,
-0.13538014888763428,
-0.19256591796875,
-0.44297781586647034,
-0.7124155163764954,
0.6010540127754211,
-0.14139746129512787,
-0.007623017765581608,
0.16456565260887146,
-0.1918872445821762,
0.2260684072971344,
0.73293536901474,
0.1485169380903244,
0.4865427017211914,
-0.09110066294670105,
0.0138741135597229,
0.10651633888483047,
-0.7982766032218933,
-0.2826555073261261,
1.0321263074874878,
0.3734055459499359,
1.0669759511947632,
0.1015399619936943,
0.4168017506599426,
0.06640474498271942,
0.1188870295882225,
-0.9833415746688843,
0.42129117250442505,
-0.3574708104133606,
-0.48900946974754333,
-0.10944127291440964,
-0.6320417523384094,
-0.693419337272644,
0.5688052177429199,
-0.3495836555957794,
-0.3104199767112732,
0.20168828964233398,
0.00048070185584947467,
-0.22669187188148499,
0.1819726675748825,
-0.5608277320861816,
0.8007084131240845,
-0.35116782784461975,
0.10275939851999283,
-0.5680447220802307,
-0.5818980932235718,
0.3908713161945343,
-0.44280269742012024,
0.24924983084201813,
0.11066409200429916,
-0.01697704754769802,
0.5497403144836426,
-0.1017293706536293,
1.0156285762786865,
-0.18233145773410797,
-0.1712060421705246,
-0.05179600790143013,
-0.18560931086540222,
0.28631410002708435,
-0.0904024988412857,
0.17708174884319305,
0.2632659673690796,
0.29989466071128845,
-0.03870825842022896,
-0.40366795659065247,
0.5296931862831116,
-0.8329333662986755,
-0.2111608386039734,
-0.44494080543518066,
-0.9691452980041504,
-0.17989404499530792,
0.3773123025894165,
-0.08627373725175858,
0.8887448310852051,
0.08006814867258072,
0.4511524736881256,
0.6653974652290344,
-0.17603935301303864,
0.7798981666564941,
0.5818285346031189,
-0.11950945109128952,
-0.3874756693840027,
0.6652881503105164,
-0.09253425151109695,
0.3961586058139801,
0.533459484577179,
0.018429525196552277,
-0.46601083874702454,
-0.523678719997406,
-0.38234370946884155,
0.06942695379257202,
-0.7253631949424744,
-0.09832717478275299,
-0.707550048828125,
-0.28766924142837524,
-0.35481396317481995,
0.24770089983940125,
-0.5788487195968628,
-0.2012992799282074,
-0.3320517838001251,
0.0847141221165657,
0.12897548079490662,
0.7085692286491394,
-0.11981163918972015,
0.561949610710144,
-0.9530444741249084,
0.7127596139907837,
0.6021827459335327,
0.413464218378067,
-0.11098744720220566,
-0.4233803451061249,
-0.4210372269153595,
0.199904665350914,
-0.08857240527868271,
-0.6065623760223389,
0.34300926327705383,
0.4075419008731842,
0.6656361222267151,
0.3995504081249237,
0.057941656559705734,
0.5331746339797974,
-0.7653050422668457,
0.38353386521339417,
0.45999377965927124,
-0.9142103791236877,
0.047066111117601395,
-0.4924388527870178,
0.3654433488845825,
0.18107105791568756,
0.26019591093063354,
-0.6453292369842529,
-0.03183382749557495,
-0.05604911595582962,
-0.6929458379745483,
0.9428862929344177,
0.13723881542682648,
0.2805621922016144,
-0.007375526707619429,
-0.04162529855966568,
-0.05493428558111191,
0.3814569115638733,
-0.8736606240272522,
-0.1291443556547165,
-0.5276775360107422,
-0.46256962418556213,
-0.31941500306129456,
-0.38429537415504456,
-0.3436315655708313,
-0.28764691948890686,
0.304375559091568,
-0.17983880639076233,
0.23146364092826843,
-0.05471425503492355,
-0.39429914951324463,
0.1137118935585022,
0.44325047731399536,
0.6794677972793579,
0.5872990489006042,
-0.06432820856571198,
0.5648620128631592,
0.02397029846906662,
-0.5559893250465393,
0.17824779450893402,
0.3612668514251709,
0.16594257950782776,
-0.05344657599925995,
0.4270780086517334,
1.0427342653274536,
0.6599069237709045,
-0.6797638535499573,
0.6564247608184814,
-0.17900869250297546,
-0.10286244004964828,
-0.43388837575912476,
-0.11792737245559692,
0.06810934096574783,
0.4682067930698395,
0.36135509610176086,
0.0645679160952568,
-0.11858886480331421,
-0.4195747673511505,
0.33457374572753906,
0.30776137113571167,
-0.26539772748947144,
-0.5251352190971375,
0.8853484392166138,
0.2540125548839569,
-0.03991328924894333,
0.6055373549461365,
0.03511090204119682,
-0.327443391084671,
0.1853093057870865,
0.7250206470489502,
0.7035999894142151,
-0.4002774953842163,
0.09811632335186005,
-0.13051661849021912,
0.34042760729789734,
-0.15611398220062256,
0.1960098296403885,
-0.23855800926685333,
-0.8745440244674683,
-0.8854081034660339,
-0.9136604070663452,
-0.2834952175617218,
0.024233534932136536,
-0.6739644408226013,
0.24855947494506836,
-0.20525504648685455,
-0.2180229276418686,
0.02635127492249012,
-0.4715626537799835,
-0.644401490688324,
0.33525586128234863,
0.46932610869407654,
0.5434952974319458,
-0.7058594822883606,
1.4035531282424927,
0.6409491896629333,
-0.21020151674747467,
-0.7154378294944763,
-0.16490653157234192,
-0.1472807377576828,
-0.5773861408233643,
0.7261708378791809,
0.14663897454738617,
-0.27966073155403137,
0.3366660475730896,
0.00034082826459780335,
-0.8142389059066772,
0.9604793190956116,
0.4427899420261383,
-0.7446953654289246,
-0.105200856924057,
0.3808858394622803,
0.3570384979248047,
-0.20679573714733124,
0.2448749989271164,
0.4897203743457794,
0.3105679750442505,
0.17059139907360077,
-1.3138459920883179,
-0.2885820269584656,
-0.23715682327747345,
0.19195178151130676,
0.2184744030237198,
-0.3149343729019165,
1.1164096593856812,
0.15543745458126068,
-0.2596832811832428,
-0.1822107881307602,
0.42713722586631775,
-0.011719681322574615,
0.03786173835396767,
0.8126712441444397,
0.5016562342643738,
0.4396859109401703,
-0.08055610954761505,
1.1942062377929688,
-0.3434668183326721,
0.2063821703195572,
1.163335919380188,
-0.1450578272342682,
0.8349759578704834,
0.4182552397251129,
-0.04296499863266945,
0.29670488834381104,
0.3724365830421448,
0.1307206004858017,
0.8057645559310913,
-0.10695453733205795,
-0.6312856078147888,
-0.5171576738357544,
-0.20687256753444672,
-0.2888652980327606,
0.8697159290313721,
0.14600564539432526,
-0.14467211067676544,
-0.24697460234165192,
0.2927551567554474,
-0.20094749331474304,
0.005078965798020363,
-0.4331192672252655,
0.7916210889816284,
0.2939845621585846,
-0.2971636652946472,
0.5464813709259033,
0.1530698537826538,
0.9108651876449585,
-0.7890981435775757,
0.11844697594642639,
0.19039364159107208,
0.422617107629776,
-0.25914984941482544,
-0.38001540303230286,
0.3428584337234497,
-0.05145569518208504,
-0.4864192605018616,
-0.6451410055160522,
0.7180421948432922,
-0.8314177989959717,
-0.5478531122207642,
0.4219878017902374,
0.3814783990383148,
-0.008811363019049168,
-0.38374239206314087,
-0.3770555853843689,
0.2329946607351303,
-0.2798636257648468,
-0.12788201868534088,
0.35087522864341736,
0.1541922390460968,
0.05520427227020264,
0.5695988535881042,
0.7731598615646362,
-0.016067206859588623,
0.40951424837112427,
0.4601414203643799,
1.1097668409347534,
-0.5291589498519897,
-0.4107953906059265,
-0.8512516021728516,
0.6896852850914001,
0.23792578279972076,
0.09289345145225525,
0.8513862490653992,
0.5294148921966553,
0.858173668384552,
-0.26262420415878296,
0.6587674021720886,
0.05858682468533516,
0.31633445620536804,
-0.6135748624801636,
0.6009222865104675,
-0.35329315066337585,
0.01427314430475235,
-0.2245563119649887,
-1.0089232921600342,
-0.30683645606040955,
0.6387966275215149,
-0.21399344503879547,
0.09640957415103912,
0.6321597099304199,
0.6950520277023315,
-0.27551788091659546,
-0.06899760663509369,
0.5489267706871033,
0.04411439225077629,
0.40478354692459106,
0.4535253047943115,
0.9746282696723938,
-0.1698969453573227,
0.6502254009246826,
-0.227283775806427,
-0.19043821096420288,
0.10224056988954544,
-0.72722989320755,
-0.9732674956321716,
-0.5805016160011292,
-0.15425065159797668,
0.1866990029811859,
-0.3992682993412018,
0.8034661412239075,
0.9244717955589294,
-0.6388126015663147,
-0.36947935819625854,
0.1899309903383255,
-0.23382426798343658,
-0.14999286830425262,
-0.12025640904903412,
0.041331954300403595,
-0.39014431834220886,
-0.9161115884780884,
0.8124797344207764,
0.24740155041217804,
-0.10123967379331589,
-0.22768498957157135,
-0.115343376994133,
-0.13188374042510986,
-0.14004909992218018,
0.9224751591682434,
-0.3291589021682739,
-0.6075426936149597,
-0.24239423871040344,
-0.11850354820489883,
-0.059159714728593826,
-0.0031819958239793777,
0.9187085032463074,
-0.6123074889183044,
0.6005997061729431,
0.20356371998786926,
0.5824583768844604,
0.913700520992279,
-0.06478417664766312,
0.5370703339576721,
-1.1093592643737793,
0.5093444585800171,
0.3147127032279968,
0.2704930901527405,
0.36990174651145935,
0.10139212757349014,
0.209261953830719,
0.22813168168067932,
-0.4991163909435272,
-0.8307616710662842,
0.3707856237888336,
-1.1048619747161865,
-0.21318797767162323,
1.1783900260925293,
0.002408344531431794,
0.1090632900595665,
-0.1346127837896347,
-0.14471130073070526,
0.4607039988040924,
-0.13903915882110596,
0.469247043132782,
0.4415123462677002,
0.043201155960559845,
-0.4662821292877197,
-0.5679281949996948,
0.49733930826187134,
0.2090388685464859,
-0.7793494462966919,
0.029016127809882164,
0.5997895002365112,
0.14982078969478607,
0.11777433007955551,
0.7751674652099609,
-0.023643534630537033,
0.05543292313814163,
0.13475477695465088,
0.32209303975105286,
-0.24409285187721252,
-0.6396635174751282,
-0.45874956250190735,
0.009632749482989311,
0.003952420316636562,
-0.410368949174881
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.02746v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.02746v2
|
RATT: A Thought Structure for Coherent and Correct LLM Reasoning
| 2024-06-04T20:02:52 | 2024-06-09T05:37:26 |
Jinghan Zhang, Xiting Wang, Weijieying Ren, Lu Jiang, Dongjie Wang, Kunpeng Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) gain substantial reasoning and decision-making
capabilities from thought structures. However, existing methods such as Tree of
Thought and Retrieval Augmented Thoughts often fall short in complex tasks due
to the limitations of insufficient local retrieval of factual knowledge and
inadequate global selection of strategies. These limitations make it
challenging for these methods to balance factual accuracy and comprehensive
logical optimization effectively. To address these limitations, we introduce
the Retrieval Augmented Thought Tree (RATT), a novel thought structure that
considers both overall logical soundness and factual correctness at each step
of the thinking process. Specifically, at every point of a thought branch, RATT
performs planning and lookahead to explore and evaluate multiple potential
reasoning steps, and integrate the fact-checking ability of Retrieval-Augmented
Generation (RAG) with LLM's ability to assess overall strategy. Through this
combination of factual knowledge and strategic feasibility, the RATT adjusts
and integrates the thought tree structure to search for the most promising
branches within the search space. This thought structure significantly enhances
the model's coherence in logical inference and efficiency in decision-making,
and thus increases the limit of the capacity of LLM to generate reliable
inferences and decisions based on thought structures. A broad range of
experiments on different types of tasks showcases that the RATT structure
significantly outperforms existing methods in factual correctness and logical
coherence.
|
[
-0.3118622601032257,
-1.080769419670105,
0.6290003061294556,
0.056507665663957596,
-0.2868146598339081,
0.5087051391601562,
-0.21029087901115417,
-0.6250146627426147,
0.3390313386917114,
0.14476682245731354,
-0.443785160779953,
-0.15917377173900604,
-0.28563547134399414,
0.08624167740345001,
-0.31379812955856323,
1.1680333614349365,
0.012521062977612019,
-0.034307971596717834,
0.11251520365476608,
0.027071766555309296,
-0.7694637775421143,
-0.3063198924064636,
-0.5675342679023743,
-0.42578834295272827,
0.5100380182266235,
0.20330141484737396,
0.9695643782615662,
0.27441534399986267,
0.5095738172531128,
0.2485353648662567,
-0.26304855942726135,
0.4596897065639496,
-0.6257398724555969,
0.34593433141708374,
-0.6442182064056396,
-0.4586459994316101,
-0.8210447430610657,
-0.20534676313400269,
0.49792101979255676,
0.5268136858940125,
-0.0885336697101593,
-0.019103797152638435,
0.00035178783582523465,
0.723762035369873,
-0.4796726107597351,
0.06460114568471909,
-0.942713737487793,
0.0005795721081085503,
-0.013883893378078938,
-0.41489699482917786,
-0.442901611328125,
-0.3904349207878113,
0.26071348786354065,
-0.4840935170650482,
0.18235866725444794,
0.20181064307689667,
0.7215002775192261,
0.2880227267742157,
-0.3245791792869568,
-0.3459952771663666,
-0.7124210596084595,
0.5819904804229736,
-0.33636873960494995,
0.45449408888816833,
0.33693426847457886,
0.2885248363018036,
-0.3498164713382721,
-0.38051900267601013,
-0.43428733944892883,
-0.2703823149204254,
0.04525322839617729,
0.2919522523880005,
0.1506381332874298,
0.25536400079727173,
0.17179259657859802,
0.4276120066642761,
-0.600588858127594,
-0.5761486291885376,
-0.15054664015769958,
-0.08451960235834122,
0.3672415316104889,
-0.10532086342573166,
0.26767498254776,
-0.40088146924972534,
-0.5980566143989563,
0.06470350176095963,
-0.5822965502738953,
-0.3300115764141083,
-0.0774223580956459,
0.3680718243122101,
0.21690645813941956,
0.6996264457702637,
-0.23355282843112946,
0.47806262969970703,
0.04981570318341255,
-0.18455906212329865,
-0.08701108396053314,
-0.4305771291255951,
-0.274040549993515,
0.17303168773651123,
0.23369011282920837,
-0.10057104378938675,
0.2586820721626282,
-0.0979958027601242,
-0.6493905186653137,
0.17315922677516937,
0.36597564816474915,
-0.48833122849464417,
-0.30093270540237427,
0.2532338798046112,
-0.2906999886035919,
-0.24625174701213837,
-0.16211818158626556,
-0.2547694742679596,
-0.0799303725361824,
-0.38925835490226746,
0.5439145565032959,
-0.8101283311843872,
-0.4447364807128906,
0.3327866792678833,
-0.041362740099430084,
0.28446680307388306,
0.8249106407165527,
-0.6392453908920288,
0.3431364595890045,
0.887736976146698,
0.7851896286010742,
-0.29462385177612305,
0.06985736638307571,
-0.2621042728424072,
0.2435707151889801,
-0.6722414493560791,
0.9717965722084045,
-0.5663403272628784,
-0.14898893237113953,
-0.29896870255470276,
-0.599755048751831,
-0.11616355925798416,
-0.360769122838974,
0.8458235859870911,
-0.9442082047462463,
0.11681710183620453,
-0.44378846883773804,
-0.7462885975837708,
-0.3243880569934845,
0.9217380285263062,
-0.5967679023742676,
1.1114054918289185,
-0.08798202872276306,
-1.1707994937896729,
0.37767288088798523,
-0.7494332790374756,
-0.35807809233665466,
0.42258045077323914,
-0.5028132796287537,
-0.23504379391670227,
0.10413959622383118,
0.026593107730150223,
0.11168176680803299,
-0.24968205392360687,
0.5388591289520264,
-0.1530219316482544,
-0.2566858232021332,
0.24772679805755615,
-0.4888816773891449,
0.8349376320838928,
0.3532285988330841,
-0.39792704582214355,
0.1302425116300583,
-0.5332580804824829,
0.27871331572532654,
0.1241307258605957,
-0.6705597043037415,
-0.3656747341156006,
0.17423762381076813,
-0.15756064653396606,
0.09554649889469147,
0.2945082187652588,
-0.48277220129966736,
0.3541528284549713,
-0.4474199712276459,
0.09058231115341187,
0.6254739165306091,
0.1353548914194107,
0.14969968795776367,
-0.4474639296531677,
0.384235143661499,
-0.22071462869644165,
0.05008547008037567,
0.10480838268995285,
-0.39161190390586853,
-0.7838877439498901,
-0.3258664608001709,
0.21485137939453125,
0.6948230862617493,
-0.8565597534179688,
0.41679248213768005,
-0.28365886211395264,
-0.20833608508110046,
-0.32212525606155396,
-0.30067044496536255,
0.47386184334754944,
0.4725182056427002,
0.2682371735572815,
0.056878939270973206,
-0.6795109510421753,
-0.8311774730682373,
-0.30902984738349915,
-0.4123668372631073,
0.46086385846138,
-0.1254793256521225,
0.8181084990501404,
-0.04659748449921608,
0.9246875643730164,
-0.3191632628440857,
0.12951470911502838,
-0.4343629479408264,
0.009189724922180176,
0.4298933446407318,
0.27310630679130554,
-0.14283399283885956,
-0.8343860507011414,
-0.32218998670578003,
0.23772293329238892,
-0.6959978342056274,
0.18800754845142365,
-0.20326854288578033,
-0.41696399450302124,
0.15488968789577484,
0.1302090883255005,
-1.1040667295455933,
0.4400399923324585,
0.04450620338320732,
-0.4082140326499939,
0.6942727565765381,
-0.17795416712760925,
0.18837964534759521,
-1.0163787603378296,
-0.016713086515665054,
-0.6814947724342346,
-0.38722294569015503,
-0.314505010843277,
0.23359304666519165,
0.14386539161205292,
0.20310796797275543,
-0.11355003714561462,
0.3706144392490387,
-0.5161105394363403,
-0.27085357904434204,
-0.4135308861732483,
0.29263725876808167,
0.11347027868032455,
0.46989673376083374,
-0.11229997128248215,
0.9025478363037109,
0.23078398406505585,
-0.3069518506526947,
0.15898603200912476,
0.37621551752090454,
-0.46696755290031433,
0.6678760647773743,
-0.37223607301712036,
0.12732018530368805,
-0.015541506931185722,
0.3825962543487549,
-0.8171477913856506,
-0.14166982471942902,
-0.011777331121265888,
-0.5675277709960938,
0.21161876618862152,
0.2708251476287842,
-0.6246048808097839,
-0.1235153079032898,
-0.3433016836643219,
0.5405619144439697,
0.26456141471862793,
-0.5559380054473877,
0.6519101858139038,
0.1674528568983078,
0.07363428175449371,
-0.7589259147644043,
-0.5438696146011353,
0.10470222681760788,
0.0645054280757904,
-0.7809311747550964,
0.3499854803085327,
0.002100016688928008,
-0.3776334524154663,
0.21745441854000092,
-0.38131004571914673,
0.15836173295974731,
-0.08611737191677094,
-0.23516708612442017,
0.39036592841148376,
-0.2760288417339325,
0.47126367688179016,
-0.24198861420154572,
0.09559059143066406,
0.038063134998083115,
-0.42074576020240784,
0.2922954261302948,
-0.31051501631736755,
-0.41166579723358154,
-0.06093084067106247,
0.13418824970722198,
0.43056410551071167,
-0.5115708708763123,
0.40771806240081787,
0.2850760817527771,
-0.39252176880836487,
-0.5775915384292603,
-0.6273147463798523,
-0.0973377600312233,
-0.38893380761146545,
0.5369859337806702,
-0.6744287610054016,
-0.8819746375083923,
0.4042527675628662,
-0.1099114865064621,
0.21996232867240906,
0.34575048089027405,
0.7091471552848816,
-0.18075016140937805,
0.7560144662857056,
0.3733859658241272,
0.27926963567733765,
0.22552631795406342,
-0.25110238790512085,
0.39141038060188293,
-0.9492558836936951,
-0.309883177280426,
-0.1934651881456375,
-0.24807950854301453,
-0.3759266436100006,
-0.8043114542961121,
0.4097173511981964,
0.15065595507621765,
-0.3498575985431671,
-0.06286497414112091,
-0.6207883954048157,
0.5650715231895447,
0.44315117597579956,
0.2653733193874359,
0.6378414630889893,
-0.05683741718530655,
-0.44900181889533997,
0.19105857610702515,
-0.7224858403205872,
-0.5630112290382385,
0.7071593403816223,
0.17386497557163239,
0.7138028740882874,
0.2294345200061798,
0.6208003759384155,
0.3682183623313904,
0.26703691482543945,
-0.896465539932251,
0.7034600973129272,
0.3546085059642792,
-1.128043532371521,
-0.2932412922382355,
-0.26974642276763916,
-0.8735694885253906,
0.6681562066078186,
-0.22357596457004547,
-0.5395814180374146,
-0.014946604147553444,
0.08581367135047913,
-0.33509132266044617,
0.5816227793693542,
-0.5468090176582336,
0.5249569416046143,
-0.407980740070343,
-0.4244341552257538,
-0.6063559055328369,
-0.5781488418579102,
0.7175348401069641,
-0.15613271296024323,
0.08485658466815948,
-0.0078717777505517,
-0.24627132713794708,
0.5873426795005798,
-0.4356785714626312,
0.564887523651123,
0.2224382609128952,
-0.07350655645132065,
0.5896247625350952,
0.45148950815200806,
0.8331824541091919,
-0.10340248793363571,
-0.043405160307884216,
-0.3813052177429199,
-0.04220394045114517,
-0.36211150884628296,
-0.6767911314964294,
0.33604636788368225,
-0.7254220843315125,
-0.9164505004882812,
-0.6185519695281982,
-0.749261200428009,
-0.3246538043022156,
0.35852327942848206,
-0.09435897320508957,
0.3096327483654022,
-0.40163150429725647,
0.17474643886089325,
0.784867525100708,
-0.07704421132802963,
0.1105421930551529,
0.3239252269268036,
-0.5030403733253479,
-0.5905075073242188,
0.5982334613800049,
0.06760361790657043,
0.46584177017211914,
0.7736745476722717,
0.17764559388160706,
-0.3202757239341736,
-0.6942145824432373,
0.021165627986192703,
0.27951955795288086,
-0.906525194644928,
-0.4241042733192444,
-0.5701361894607544,
-0.38034966588020325,
0.15955957770347595,
0.02028157003223896,
-0.4543284773826599,
-0.6338385343551636,
0.5178716778755188,
-0.4361770749092102,
0.3280112147331238,
0.9437285661697388,
0.02763167954981327,
-0.22112657129764557,
-0.4132758677005768,
0.4014177620410919,
0.3758910000324249,
0.2666955292224884,
0.09838863462209702,
-0.30035585165023804,
-0.3511723279953003,
-0.10689627379179001,
-0.5335472226142883,
-0.7760093808174133,
0.01828308030962944,
-0.09282902628183365,
0.3129684627056122,
0.08734878152608871,
0.030848409980535507,
0.6365883350372314,
-0.5046220421791077,
0.3100993037223816,
0.028804190456867218,
-0.7100467681884766,
0.7106904983520508,
-0.5676336884498596,
0.3875384032726288,
0.43152889609336853,
-0.11051833629608154,
-0.2501333951950073,
-0.4319397211074829,
-0.660398006439209,
-0.4692469835281372,
0.5408248901367188,
0.5211741328239441,
-0.33184099197387695,
-0.2630590498447418,
0.22761306166648865,
-0.08271533250808716,
-0.029899299144744873,
-0.6859339475631714,
0.18848177790641785,
0.07400043308734894,
-0.0642317458987236,
0.5726445317268372,
-0.2108270525932312,
-0.16646014153957367,
-0.44133859872817993,
0.7906978130340576,
-0.05359543487429619,
0.19527152180671692,
0.5740665197372437,
0.01028931699693203,
-0.38776078820228577,
0.43746742606163025,
0.38766902685165405,
0.8436570763587952,
-0.44665998220443726,
0.4551164507865906,
0.39172446727752686,
-0.38058993220329285,
0.07200188934803009,
-0.28937169909477234,
-0.2583465576171875,
-0.031812604516744614,
0.5617619752883911,
0.5715659856796265,
0.36616286635398865,
-0.5939485430717468,
0.3896494209766388,
0.11338447034358978,
-0.18256567418575287,
-0.33126887679100037,
0.03532407805323601,
0.3331511914730072,
0.6204193830490112,
0.227608323097229,
0.5062128901481628,
0.1939518302679062,
-0.6757710576057434,
0.3074270784854889,
0.6588180065155029,
0.0003013804671354592,
-0.23833264410495758,
0.43728482723236084,
0.20572726428508759,
-0.31816768646240234,
0.6038092970848083,
-0.20173239707946777,
-0.839572012424469,
0.4091620445251465,
0.5633308291435242,
1.0964733362197876,
-0.072233647108078,
0.2110005021095276,
0.3475634455680847,
0.5599538683891296,
-0.17545847594738007,
0.557854175567627,
-0.22871732711791992,
-0.9570592641830444,
-0.9350425601005554,
-0.6235660910606384,
-0.3835411071777344,
-0.04516349360346794,
-0.20341280102729797,
0.28384920954704285,
-0.4844987690448761,
-0.2324601262807846,
-0.37465423345565796,
0.2896029055118561,
-0.43528488278388977,
0.250661700963974,
0.08118684589862823,
1.1534655094146729,
-0.28797927498817444,
1.0633645057678223,
0.5656801462173462,
-0.24029545485973358,
-1.1035914421081543,
-0.007437621708959341,
-0.07194387912750244,
-0.8452416062355042,
0.8615060448646545,
-0.050922855734825134,
-0.6781537532806396,
-0.30207914113998413,
-0.3660723567008972,
-1.1443995237350464,
0.9777425527572632,
0.3735627830028534,
-0.4997422695159912,
-0.2245107889175415,
-0.2649487257003784,
0.49141332507133484,
-0.27323463559150696,
0.07691249251365662,
0.48005226254463196,
0.5363195538520813,
0.5760191679000854,
-0.9285433292388916,
0.12409639358520508,
-0.14288602769374847,
-0.20643337070941925,
0.38651058077812195,
-0.5790624022483826,
0.9250430464744568,
-0.48129117488861084,
-0.3839297592639923,
-0.09372562170028687,
0.5643454790115356,
0.6974000334739685,
-0.039254315197467804,
0.4612679183483124,
0.7579552531242371,
0.9542848467826843,
0.11285114288330078,
1.0984612703323364,
-0.1698412299156189,
0.3213191628456116,
1.1956943273544312,
-0.14864540100097656,
1.0719531774520874,
0.27402442693710327,
-0.1762680858373642,
0.42479950189590454,
0.7218336462974548,
0.3569066822528839,
0.4462340772151947,
0.004291655030101538,
-0.28530073165893555,
-0.5054126381874084,
-0.013621040619909763,
-0.30988818407058716,
0.26373085379600525,
0.49962955713272095,
0.029052862897515297,
-0.22338055074214935,
-0.35300788283348083,
0.010151983238756657,
0.09924177080392838,
-0.16866055130958557,
0.5614759922027588,
0.10167383402585983,
-0.9219968914985657,
0.785045325756073,
-0.26022008061408997,
0.41896551847457886,
-0.4000677764415741,
-0.2155817449092865,
-0.10151053965091705,
0.3343994617462158,
-0.3180566728115082,
-0.8985792398452759,
0.37041983008384705,
-0.024169599637389183,
-0.08157512545585632,
-0.2699994444847107,
0.8826243281364441,
-0.3767198920249939,
-0.47766318917274475,
0.3743084967136383,
0.8157428503036499,
0.09794027358293533,
0.030418207868933678,
-0.8889764547348022,
0.29401251673698425,
0.11412715911865234,
-0.43681764602661133,
-0.1813431680202484,
0.9863525629043579,
-0.16829587519168854,
0.6337917447090149,
0.3923254609107971,
0.29647308588027954,
-0.065512515604496,
-0.02292473614215851,
0.9622456431388855,
-0.8121516704559326,
-0.5253663659095764,
-0.8672595024108887,
0.31487032771110535,
-0.12273489683866501,
0.06382325291633606,
0.5874114036560059,
0.7749481797218323,
0.8030152320861816,
0.25314581394195557,
0.6862713098526001,
-0.1282062530517578,
0.6060046553611755,
-0.5484561920166016,
0.3395305275917053,
-0.3647404909133911,
0.418607234954834,
-0.25127559900283813,
-1.234679937362671,
-0.2489004135131836,
0.8085131049156189,
-0.5980304479598999,
0.21349754929542542,
1.134256362915039,
0.6589457988739014,
-0.13967518508434296,
0.3548739552497864,
0.46090903878211975,
0.46227407455444336,
0.3758648931980133,
0.6072545051574707,
1.1535546779632568,
-0.15774723887443542,
0.5101205706596375,
0.23717112839221954,
-0.2467353492975235,
-0.035332147032022476,
-0.5421908497810364,
-0.9453126788139343,
-0.4447781443595886,
-0.1427924633026123,
-0.1740313321352005,
0.22494369745254517,
1.2102153301239014,
0.661803126335144,
-0.660761833190918,
-0.3257581889629364,
-0.3862086832523346,
0.35099780559539795,
0.03150205314159393,
-0.2500873804092407,
0.5925145149230957,
-0.7028601169586182,
-0.23713518679141998,
0.39150092005729675,
0.6080013513565063,
-0.22343821823596954,
-0.1824793666601181,
-0.18271611630916595,
-0.7244911193847656,
0.39898282289505005,
0.9005021452903748,
-0.06780578196048737,
-0.9723889231681824,
-0.5512029528617859,
-0.11922004818916321,
-0.171594500541687,
0.21171104907989502,
0.7573506832122803,
-0.6791005730628967,
0.6978541612625122,
0.6294690370559692,
0.8360962271690369,
0.5553224086761475,
0.037177376449108124,
0.48732128739356995,
-0.44903430342674255,
-0.10125330835580826,
0.6100765466690063,
0.4586176574230194,
0.3693845272064209,
-0.18787570297718048,
0.7893308401107788,
0.0667148157954216,
-0.5604647397994995,
-0.6070227026939392,
0.40655016899108887,
-0.9193457365036011,
-0.5749859809875488,
0.7984625101089478,
0.17453153431415558,
-0.33061644434928894,
-0.23299197852611542,
-0.6003085970878601,
0.36920976638793945,
-0.31212925910949707,
0.7606577277183533,
0.8150729537010193,
-0.5324697494506836,
-0.1265021711587906,
-0.6524139642715454,
0.6192477345466614,
0.6175522804260254,
-0.7908507585525513,
0.19996754825115204,
0.42465224862098694,
0.026732314378023148,
0.2644799053668976,
0.7060059309005737,
-0.20733174681663513,
0.2220296561717987,
0.06445997208356857,
-0.02888832986354828,
0.3253546357154846,
-0.3715997040271759,
0.24228759109973907,
0.2553166449069977,
0.3933601975440979,
-0.053215064108371735
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.02733v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.02733v1
|
Textless Acoustic Model with Self-Supervised Distillation for Noise-Robust Expressive Speech-to-Speech Translation
| 2024-06-04T19:22:13 | 2024-06-04T19:22:13 |
Min-Jae Hwang, Ilia Kulikov, Benjamin Peloquin, Hongyu Gong, Peng-Jen Chen, Ann Lee
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
In this paper, we propose a textless acoustic model with a self-supervised
distillation strategy for noise-robust expressive speech-to-speech translation
(S2ST). Recently proposed expressive S2ST systems have achieved impressive
expressivity preservation performances by cascading unit-to-speech (U2S)
generator to the speech-to-unit translation model. However, these systems are
vulnerable to the presence of noise in input speech, which is an assumption in
real-world translation scenarios. To address this limitation, we propose a U2S
generator that incorporates a distillation with no label (DINO) self-supervised
training strategy into it's pretraining process. Because the proposed method
captures noise-agnostic expressivity representation, it can generate qualified
speech even in noisy environment. Objective and subjective evaluation results
verified that the proposed method significantly improved the performance of the
expressive S2ST system in noisy environments while maintaining competitive
performance in clean environments.
|
[
-0.06835336983203888,
-0.48726069927215576,
0.4411810636520386,
0.30698439478874207,
-0.5579277276992798,
-0.06697297096252441,
-0.3664265275001526,
-0.36256465315818787,
0.09875201433897018,
0.2410377413034439,
-0.574417233467102,
-0.2988787293434143,
-0.7070595026016235,
0.4294983446598053,
-0.6268726587295532,
1.1431539058685303,
0.2130245417356491,
0.0739668682217598,
-0.07002857327461243,
0.11589333415031433,
-0.08095531910657883,
-0.38358554244041443,
-0.6078283190727234,
-0.16413173079490662,
0.2633078098297119,
-0.11791685968637466,
0.20735932886600494,
0.7927941679954529,
-0.0014969126787036657,
0.34797629714012146,
-0.3488161265850067,
0.022558199241757393,
-0.3988066613674164,
0.588880181312561,
-0.08723628520965576,
-0.11242944747209549,
-0.440185546875,
-0.010156800039112568,
0.47546491026878357,
0.3354560434818268,
-0.3880051076412201,
0.1575470119714737,
0.3365922272205353,
0.3092629015445709,
-0.4601595103740692,
0.46073415875434875,
-0.6576681733131409,
-0.01752665266394615,
-0.2532302737236023,
0.07132329791784286,
-0.38480761647224426,
-0.27145835757255554,
-0.16328592598438263,
-0.5729114413261414,
-0.1766352355480194,
-0.4779316484928131,
0.49917638301849365,
0.9052908420562744,
-0.4127773940563202,
-0.2888071537017822,
-1.0322316884994507,
0.6906275153160095,
-0.7222004532814026,
0.42789116501808167,
0.4226285517215729,
0.22984471917152405,
-0.03955618292093277,
-0.816758930683136,
-0.4839065372943878,
0.0042382292449474335,
-0.00019909071852453053,
0.523042619228363,
-0.4903285503387451,
0.09931862354278564,
-0.011015058495104313,
0.334963321685791,
-0.2823162078857422,
0.13903799653053284,
-0.19696952402591705,
-0.2966405749320984,
0.6953466534614563,
-0.34107837080955505,
-0.07095873355865479,
-0.1295986771583557,
-0.4857911169528961,
0.17312689125537872,
-0.416659951210022,
-0.01771608553826809,
0.34565386176109314,
0.576990008354187,
-0.04434620589017868,
0.31236401200294495,
-0.3061050772666931,
0.29608210921287537,
0.31381914019584656,
-0.3877059817314148,
0.25097063183784485,
-0.3206399083137512,
-0.026593133807182312,
0.45807763934135437,
1.0586620569229126,
-0.06318631023168564,
0.03459116443991661,
-0.3513500988483429,
-0.5774857997894287,
-0.0035300080198794603,
-0.006695034448057413,
-1.158753514289856,
-0.1992173194885254,
0.036870747804641724,
-0.29464486241340637,
-0.7558225989341736,
-0.6145486831665039,
-0.5957257747650146,
0.10301229357719421,
-0.3143344819545746,
0.5460691452026367,
-0.24518682062625885,
-0.7966048717498779,
-0.3003857135772705,
0.13034731149673462,
-0.3748927414417267,
0.2594945430755615,
-1.1244421005249023,
0.3284100890159607,
0.25515124201774597,
0.7650325894355774,
-0.10027334094047546,
0.08150092512369156,
-0.629471480846405,
0.2563383877277374,
-0.2265564501285553,
0.6420250535011292,
0.006048659328371286,
-0.6325546503067017,
-0.2475399374961853,
-0.3822513222694397,
-0.016420042142271996,
-0.6092285513877869,
0.7843563556671143,
-0.013169337064027786,
0.09289118647575378,
0.10086260735988617,
-0.5421935319900513,
0.3306458592414856,
-0.24133628606796265,
-0.40578213334083557,
1.2098509073257446,
0.11082249134778976,
-0.38744255900382996,
0.16254064440727234,
-0.6094343066215515,
-0.5245499014854431,
0.06590648740530014,
-0.21478503942489624,
-0.6360357999801636,
0.33648404479026794,
0.16829557716846466,
0.2613069415092468,
0.16361790895462036,
0.4693600833415985,
-0.009755412116646767,
-0.19504959881305695,
0.2444980889558792,
-0.6933329701423645,
0.7792196273803711,
0.5840385556221008,
-0.5282710790634155,
-0.09219542145729065,
-0.8592850565910339,
0.0029037026688456535,
-0.09202039986848831,
-0.39300423860549927,
-0.21208110451698303,
-0.06504728645086288,
0.0653504803776741,
0.36568203568458557,
0.42694833874702454,
-0.5880689024925232,
0.07328508794307709,
-0.3294282853603363,
0.6270409822463989,
0.7254798412322998,
-0.34392622113227844,
0.47847431898117065,
0.07228777557611465,
0.3986561894416809,
0.03657541424036026,
-0.10802973806858063,
-0.10379906743764877,
-0.37291932106018066,
-0.5717734098434448,
-0.7581716179847717,
0.35057148337364197,
0.5292564034461975,
-0.6330057382583618,
0.5168229341506958,
-0.2739318609237671,
-0.49456262588500977,
-0.6328476667404175,
0.10127747058868408,
0.4547346532344818,
0.9445604681968689,
0.5567048192024231,
0.024961592629551888,
-0.456794410943985,
-0.681816577911377,
-0.1710476279258728,
-0.34700238704681396,
-0.1484052836894989,
0.15178978443145752,
0.228412464261055,
-0.12416402250528336,
0.754715621471405,
-0.015140892937779427,
-0.6952150464057922,
-0.2055290788412094,
0.3861669898033142,
0.08208011835813522,
0.6199827790260315,
0.5297467112541199,
-0.4560663104057312,
-0.340895414352417,
-0.18210875988006592,
-0.704300045967102,
-0.6295784711837769,
0.14459295570850372,
0.07942958921194077,
0.39025697112083435,
0.6470139622688293,
-0.6721697449684143,
0.710551381111145,
0.6918309330940247,
0.11745280772447586,
0.43894684314727783,
-0.12146946787834167,
-0.106160968542099,
-1.3537613153457642,
0.26379090547561646,
-0.12281578779220581,
-0.4322926998138428,
-0.674850583076477,
-0.2965356409549713,
-0.13007840514183044,
-0.2537439465522766,
-0.41556236147880554,
0.23645666241645813,
-0.3893224000930786,
0.048225436359643936,
-0.5196067690849304,
0.08630026131868362,
-0.017393656075000763,
0.34450197219848633,
0.40268707275390625,
0.9057999849319458,
0.5705845355987549,
-0.5319916605949402,
0.06563615053892136,
0.3119400143623352,
-0.17019100487232208,
0.6858888864517212,
-0.5663045644760132,
0.22417278587818146,
0.034394510090351105,
0.3382618725299835,
-1.0057785511016846,
0.0046464744955301285,
0.15532316267490387,
-0.5908656716346741,
0.5472613573074341,
-0.31027013063430786,
-0.3714632987976074,
-0.02531977742910385,
0.27849364280700684,
0.34896254539489746,
0.5905178189277649,
-0.44165846705436707,
0.4892592430114746,
0.20227429270744324,
-0.5957435965538025,
-0.3480214774608612,
-0.8668293952941895,
0.21096356213092804,
-0.402762234210968,
-0.4329742193222046,
0.37822747230529785,
0.0005088013713248074,
0.18250037729740143,
-0.09063775837421417,
-0.5079532861709595,
-0.31075024604797363,
0.1911575049161911,
0.21338552236557007,
0.13894222676753998,
-0.13432054221630096,
0.21360819041728973,
0.4398741126060486,
-0.27199068665504456,
0.13500669598579407,
-0.3291798532009125,
0.1129382774233818,
0.008871757425367832,
0.24200521409511566,
-1.142703652381897,
0.40891122817993164,
0.27897897362709045,
-0.0859653502702713,
0.3164716958999634,
0.5508825778961182,
-0.2059326171875,
-0.10007676482200623,
-0.1807432770729065,
-0.4169943630695343,
-0.4895981252193451,
0.4099980890750885,
-0.49990540742874146,
-0.7648822069168091,
0.28487643599510193,
-0.655878484249115,
-0.31755760312080383,
0.47752636671066284,
0.4196544587612152,
-0.3927147686481476,
0.9081907868385315,
0.25569015741348267,
0.008710112422704697,
0.44010889530181885,
-0.1386817991733551,
0.21679966151714325,
-0.8167378306388855,
-0.21576732397079468,
-0.6537739038467407,
-0.2438507080078125,
-0.5735076665878296,
-0.06679341197013855,
0.273658812046051,
0.16806943714618683,
-0.086294986307621,
0.479065865278244,
-0.6875847578048706,
0.23860114812850952,
0.4210793375968933,
-0.34595105051994324,
0.39863574504852295,
0.3159388303756714,
-0.03400278463959694,
-0.3466458320617676,
-0.4463762044906616,
-0.4302555322647095,
0.8783445954322815,
0.10238943248987198,
0.7204639315605164,
0.2015058547258377,
1.179207444190979,
0.17199929058551788,
0.24743932485580444,
-0.67766934633255,
0.3399466872215271,
-0.2913219630718231,
-0.6376593112945557,
-0.6248233318328857,
-0.769909143447876,
-0.9226565361022949,
0.18131788074970245,
-0.1441889852285385,
-0.9253644943237305,
0.19658973813056946,
0.2947925925254822,
-0.2983357012271881,
0.1765768975019455,
-0.37377291917800903,
0.6329622864723206,
-0.30800825357437134,
-0.3734396696090698,
0.06122090294957161,
-0.618657112121582,
0.15058787167072296,
-0.17958201467990875,
0.3534519672393799,
-0.05967027321457863,
0.18157023191452026,
0.47290119528770447,
-0.3899971544742584,
0.7472779154777527,
-0.3964862525463104,
-0.5268505811691284,
0.250207781791687,
0.3534570336341858,
0.7245938181877136,
-0.08250882476568222,
-0.28432410955429077,
0.4665880799293518,
-0.03338240832090378,
0.050406258553266525,
-0.5345303416252136,
0.6804026961326599,
-0.8786206245422363,
-0.5432963371276855,
-0.3895597457885742,
-0.312282532453537,
0.037277672439813614,
0.4075644612312317,
0.648675262928009,
0.18431545794010162,
-0.33961862325668335,
0.12785622477531433,
0.5910544395446777,
0.31685179471969604,
0.6906725764274597,
0.4041879177093506,
-0.28391849994659424,
-0.5205971002578735,
1.0357682704925537,
0.3118097186088562,
0.2881368398666382,
0.14697325229644775,
0.23896829783916473,
-0.970055878162384,
-0.6256558299064636,
-0.7098907232284546,
-0.14194351434707642,
-0.272249698638916,
-0.3557983934879303,
-0.5657654404640198,
-0.299758642911911,
-0.718285322189331,
0.2720120847225189,
-0.8620251417160034,
-0.7950937747955322,
-0.6406369805335999,
-0.09626596421003342,
0.23534856736660004,
0.7435750961303711,
-0.6286647915840149,
0.41567251086235046,
-0.3953731060028076,
0.4823177456855774,
0.4280188977718353,
0.20685024559497833,
-0.5101882219314575,
-0.8339659571647644,
-0.21299131214618683,
0.3906964063644409,
-0.49108728766441345,
-0.7571713924407959,
0.5780319571495056,
0.6345077157020569,
0.33995240926742554,
0.2535442113876343,
0.4774845838546753,
0.7016506195068359,
-0.3957374691963196,
0.5934364199638367,
0.28350213170051575,
-1.250093698501587,
0.7990462779998779,
-0.48256683349609375,
0.15895895659923553,
0.6294856071472168,
0.024790238589048386,
-0.1320694088935852,
-0.524970293045044,
-0.42360562086105347,
-0.9798012375831604,
0.6501770615577698,
0.6703405976295471,
0.24099725484848022,
0.1061326116323471,
0.23017683625221252,
0.0013728010235354304,
0.3853452503681183,
-0.892471969127655,
-0.33041226863861084,
-0.8154626488685608,
-0.1466241329908371,
-0.013748634606599808,
0.016358699649572372,
-0.09705066680908203,
-0.24468941986560822,
0.7782007455825806,
0.005636875983327627,
0.10549766570329666,
0.3236362636089325,
0.03204980865120888,
-0.07808106392621994,
0.3709704279899597,
0.47742384672164917,
-0.2009839117527008,
-0.18660639226436615,
0.08368019014596939,
-0.029411014169454575,
-0.3190109133720398,
0.5084963440895081,
0.48213523626327515,
-0.3622173070907593,
0.13038519024848938,
-0.15632225573062897,
0.8152174353599548,
0.10079152137041092,
-0.18880586326122284,
0.7780595421791077,
-0.1651218682527542,
-0.40376508235931396,
-0.4412606954574585,
-0.09579672664403915,
0.21742628514766693,
0.08500607311725616,
0.3175053298473358,
0.33796048164367676,
0.4944523870944977,
-0.1885492503643036,
0.08951413631439209,
0.05176854878664017,
-0.6304791569709778,
-0.3492838442325592,
1.2066833972930908,
0.43903326988220215,
-0.14047208428382874,
0.5984172821044922,
-0.34971049427986145,
0.02252299152314663,
0.16393882036209106,
0.673198401927948,
1.203097939491272,
-0.6977663636207581,
0.15115424990653992,
0.29246383905410767,
0.069077268242836,
0.016329217702150345,
0.10322712361812592,
-0.5329371094703674,
-0.33046776056289673,
-0.5141491293907166,
-0.7080869078636169,
-0.16132116317749023,
0.18427741527557373,
-0.9369738101959229,
0.023112311959266663,
-0.08495517075061798,
-0.3015473186969757,
-0.028217077255249023,
-0.48434069752693176,
-0.1417180448770523,
0.4166995882987976,
0.2948724329471588,
0.4237731695175171,
-0.7364280223846436,
1.0657744407653809,
0.24564974009990692,
-0.15020762383937836,
-0.897524893283844,
-0.11206748336553574,
0.01744147017598152,
-0.37790703773498535,
0.7344765067100525,
0.13047455251216888,
-0.5140048861503601,
0.28600239753723145,
-0.48924878239631653,
-0.8888458013534546,
1.1313421726226807,
0.9468296766281128,
-0.694425642490387,
0.3819397985935211,
0.4012277126312256,
0.6444445252418518,
-0.2521904706954956,
-0.03315228968858719,
0.2734748423099518,
0.33341673016548157,
0.3110097348690033,
-1.1804746389389038,
-0.12384290993213654,
-0.3996106684207916,
-0.040514878928661346,
-0.07455245405435562,
-0.7199814915657043,
0.5925472378730774,
-0.011497695930302143,
-0.42786139249801636,
0.5275947451591492,
0.7194287180900574,
0.16043654084205627,
0.33737727999687195,
0.42008697986602783,
0.827976405620575,
0.7040093541145325,
-0.3116303086280823,
0.5260279178619385,
-0.3815760016441345,
0.24888722598552704,
1.5354782342910767,
-0.36722689867019653,
0.871567964553833,
0.5736570358276367,
-0.08289589732885361,
0.32422515749931335,
0.3327670693397522,
0.3286603093147278,
0.8872097730636597,
0.28011468052864075,
-0.7413057088851929,
-0.40670308470726013,
-0.3183204233646393,
-0.6778525710105896,
0.8902928233146667,
0.22927157580852509,
-0.3672396242618561,
-0.21291227638721466,
-0.15608181059360504,
0.009967162273824215,
0.2036924511194229,
-0.056118469685316086,
1.1538300514221191,
0.16124461591243744,
-0.48712554574012756,
0.6972840428352356,
-0.3020418882369995,
0.6642125844955444,
-0.4910857081413269,
0.1298985481262207,
-0.253909707069397,
-0.04202769696712494,
-0.19373364746570587,
-0.3633778393268585,
0.46824464201927185,
0.11528170108795166,
-0.04289519414305687,
-0.7320631742477417,
0.5261812210083008,
-0.6881582140922546,
-0.5317830443382263,
0.25905606150627136,
0.4711809754371643,
0.4774248003959656,
-0.12784142792224884,
-0.31579872965812683,
-0.08599689602851868,
-0.011025960557162762,
-0.3221780061721802,
0.33327481150627136,
0.7644993662834167,
0.33480867743492126,
0.520579993724823,
0.7380396723747253,
0.2374720275402069,
0.004237702582031488,
0.00674214493483305,
0.8219850063323975,
-0.23330695927143097,
-0.5304301381111145,
-0.756213903427124,
0.4845964312553406,
0.008975880220532417,
-0.31060123443603516,
0.6122182011604309,
0.7979968786239624,
0.4884010851383209,
-0.031559668481349945,
1.046276569366455,
0.1944221407175064,
0.5705426931381226,
-0.24574749171733856,
1.0501971244812012,
-0.4859594702720642,
0.14538991451263428,
-0.43089401721954346,
-0.7122887372970581,
0.018708882853388786,
0.8147650957107544,
0.07934265583753586,
-0.057155970484018326,
0.23165510594844818,
0.7068586349487305,
0.022054046392440796,
0.07207111269235611,
0.5972336530685425,
0.4008904993534088,
0.13957546651363373,
0.09062854200601578,
0.6788259148597717,
-0.5838757157325745,
0.9116601943969727,
-0.16868028044700623,
-0.17562748491764069,
0.02665015496313572,
-0.9578886032104492,
-0.47329968214035034,
-0.48568442463874817,
-0.646264374256134,
-0.4220496416091919,
0.10154146701097488,
0.5172045826911926,
0.8421542644500732,
-0.6889147758483887,
-0.1855190098285675,
-0.3124437928199768,
-0.272930771112442,
-0.26277998089790344,
-0.15252585709095,
0.22382758557796478,
-0.3163982927799225,
-0.9950742721557617,
0.8795292973518372,
0.3522891700267792,
0.5833221673965454,
-0.09100893139839172,
-0.20318184792995453,
0.23899945616722107,
0.04499785974621773,
0.42646676301956177,
0.33981409668922424,
-0.6213491559028625,
0.02771618217229843,
-0.19447141885757446,
0.02486364170908928,
0.08202258497476578,
0.27910128235816956,
-0.790138304233551,
0.6343867182731628,
0.017405085265636444,
0.2854045331478119,
0.8747016191482544,
-0.19139687716960907,
0.32614001631736755,
-1.033453345298767,
0.44777238368988037,
0.25139501690864563,
0.2056044340133667,
0.24020977318286896,
-0.28547754883766174,
0.38732752203941345,
0.2316662222146988,
-0.6806204319000244,
-0.8656980991363525,
0.2568691372871399,
-1.043683648109436,
0.07340209186077118,
1.0582224130630493,
-0.39754733443260193,
0.06385305523872375,
-0.02688533253967762,
-0.21343128383159637,
0.7311525344848633,
-0.8235630989074707,
1.0841299295425415,
0.4125556945800781,
-0.12128491699695587,
-0.14788399636745453,
-0.19673000276088715,
0.722554624080658,
0.31846415996551514,
-0.5422531366348267,
0.12469083815813065,
0.32664528489112854,
0.2578345239162445,
0.15297792851924896,
0.637237012386322,
-0.15573182702064514,
0.05276649445295334,
0.01437983475625515,
0.1333944946527481,
-0.1923174411058426,
-0.005457025021314621,
-0.21046094596385956,
-0.0732889324426651,
-0.075507253408432,
-0.29117220640182495
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.02721v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.02721v2
|
Self-Control of LLM Behaviors by Compressing Suffix Gradient into Prefix Controller
| 2024-06-04T19:05:10 | 2024-06-18T15:58:38 |
Min Cai, Yuchen Zhang, Shichang Zhang, Fan Yin, Difan Zou, Yisong Yue, Ziniu Hu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
We propose Self-Control, a novel method utilizing suffix gradients to control
the behavior of large language models (LLMs) without explicit human
annotations. Given a guideline expressed in suffix string and the model's
self-assessment of adherence, Self-Control computes the gradient of this
self-judgment concerning the model's hidden states, directly influencing the
auto-regressive generation process towards desired behaviors. To enhance
efficiency, we introduce Self-Control_{prefix}, a compact module that
encapsulates the learned representations from suffix gradients into a Prefix
Controller, facilitating inference-time control for various LLM behaviors. Our
experiments demonstrate Self-Control's efficacy across multiple domains,
including emotional modulation, ensuring harmlessness, and enhancing complex
reasoning. Especially, Self-Control_{prefix} enables a plug-and-play control
and jointly controls multiple attributes, improving model outputs without
altering model parameters or increasing inference-time costs.
|
[
-0.37787726521492004,
-0.8768510222434998,
0.23610034584999084,
0.5513991117477417,
0.03593314811587334,
0.1276378482580185,
-0.010225576348602772,
0.0008446899009868503,
0.4562682509422302,
0.3993833661079407,
-0.8471236824989319,
-0.2871115207672119,
-0.5132242441177368,
0.13183927536010742,
-0.12727433443069458,
0.8343848586082458,
-0.1063552275300026,
-0.06721340864896774,
-0.0442173071205616,
0.23742516338825226,
-0.4563879072666168,
-0.49190688133239746,
-0.6744896173477173,
-0.49728813767433167,
0.8898489475250244,
0.3338058292865753,
0.525492787361145,
0.9070637226104736,
0.4556206464767456,
0.30447059869766235,
0.14723257720470428,
0.19647684693336487,
-0.28126260638237,
0.13605926930904388,
-0.3298663794994354,
-0.31306251883506775,
-0.8895077705383301,
0.12216483056545258,
0.6437487602233887,
0.30381160974502563,
-0.4831226170063019,
0.2419099360704422,
0.04763147234916687,
0.5207722783088684,
-0.4625433683395386,
0.037590764462947845,
-0.31556570529937744,
-0.1563471555709839,
-0.04599118232727051,
-0.38556158542633057,
-0.25491607189178467,
-0.17023028433322906,
-0.6419515609741211,
-0.45215487480163574,
-0.13036851584911346,
0.24552467465400696,
0.6508076190948486,
0.5879020094871521,
-0.5072222948074341,
-0.0912553071975708,
-0.9322496652603149,
0.5855572819709778,
-0.4785045385360718,
0.398125022649765,
0.6947042346000671,
-0.004197686444967985,
-0.48995858430862427,
-0.514580249786377,
-0.24963952600955963,
-0.23164105415344238,
-0.08212064951658249,
0.14445407688617706,
-0.004145842511206865,
0.12075662612915039,
0.2757127583026886,
0.07611068338155746,
-0.15886275470256805,
0.42672643065452576,
-0.39023110270500183,
-0.5630317330360413,
0.6283701658248901,
0.32576993107795715,
0.427446186542511,
-0.3042885661125183,
-0.5529053807258606,
0.2964072823524475,
-0.9258450269699097,
0.09241633862257004,
0.2657206058502197,
0.20864081382751465,
0.10151631385087967,
0.7407036423683167,
-0.351253479719162,
0.205606609582901,
0.3491811752319336,
-0.26364853978157043,
0.007974065840244293,
-0.014802147634327412,
-0.16928666830062866,
-0.08761970698833466,
0.8493931293487549,
0.3266242742538452,
0.3159642517566681,
-0.2775254547595978,
-0.33876287937164307,
-0.057625748217105865,
0.21292829513549805,
-0.4936288893222809,
0.11771740019321442,
0.13504692912101746,
-0.4198526442050934,
0.018032046034932137,
-0.4059330224990845,
-0.7107858657836914,
-0.09271728992462158,
-0.6096869707107544,
0.4512781798839569,
-0.3476736545562744,
-0.2621861398220062,
0.039626866579055786,
0.1009700745344162,
0.39827898144721985,
0.1923842877149582,
-1.2137843370437622,
0.8986446857452393,
0.5686651468276978,
1.0124469995498657,
-0.5541691184043884,
-0.6425778269767761,
-0.6541457772254944,
0.5059643387794495,
-0.2964085638523102,
0.15122127532958984,
-0.5329638719558716,
-0.32030540704727173,
-0.21812152862548828,
-0.06901653110980988,
-0.03089147061109543,
-0.16344378888607025,
0.17069675028324127,
-0.6117556691169739,
-0.13753820955753326,
0.3418853282928467,
-0.7574524283409119,
0.14007185399532318,
-0.12052597850561142,
-0.4605236351490021,
1.0577764511108398,
-0.07780696451663971,
-0.3310704827308655,
0.12417838722467422,
-0.30127620697021484,
-0.3935586214065552,
-0.03745398670434952,
-0.03269149735569954,
-0.09035038948059082,
0.18917004764080048,
0.0935823917388916,
0.6143831610679626,
-0.029705114662647247,
0.3266240060329437,
-0.21768975257873535,
-0.16505680978298187,
0.11165986955165863,
-0.286747545003891,
0.25797685980796814,
0.02631879411637783,
-0.29654696583747864,
0.33195632696151733,
-0.5524230003356934,
-0.04204371199011803,
-0.019520806148648262,
-0.12869931757450104,
-0.5044807195663452,
-0.14921630918979645,
-0.408071905374527,
0.3829243779182434,
0.3568110167980194,
-0.33039215207099915,
0.6796417236328125,
0.17803902924060822,
0.20455200970172882,
0.9918369054794312,
0.02817538194358349,
0.7215887308120728,
-0.31204086542129517,
0.8566501140594482,
-0.35196661949157715,
0.3066798150539398,
-0.1526053249835968,
-0.17044341564178467,
-0.935480535030365,
-0.6012633442878723,
0.3571472764015198,
0.3356698155403137,
-0.549837589263916,
0.651530385017395,
0.043441291898489,
-0.30941206216812134,
-0.5557605028152466,
0.4408450126647949,
0.45541489124298096,
0.3558933138847351,
0.5758107900619507,
-0.1459420919418335,
0.03546972945332527,
-0.8598517179489136,
-0.26218870282173157,
0.16790863871574402,
0.14758101105690002,
0.21787570416927338,
0.5412906408309937,
0.13930825889110565,
0.783086895942688,
-0.5469263195991516,
-0.4308778941631317,
-0.11602422595024109,
0.47871607542037964,
-0.21322216093540192,
0.9254347681999207,
0.20092575252056122,
-0.5166782736778259,
-0.15162226557731628,
-0.6445460319519043,
-0.2527104914188385,
-0.4451049566268921,
-0.35298073291778564,
-0.508659839630127,
0.24089685082435608,
1.0744590759277344,
-0.6173766851425171,
0.514533519744873,
0.3597947657108307,
-0.48910677433013916,
0.5751383304595947,
-0.41036713123321533,
-0.18680374324321747,
-0.6192576289176941,
-0.05902755260467529,
0.1255553960800171,
-0.38961705565452576,
-0.6319416165351868,
0.014459671452641487,
0.2054011970758438,
0.638852059841156,
-0.3595593571662903,
0.6621490716934204,
-0.6097943782806396,
0.21598780155181885,
-0.21534612774848938,
-0.28202372789382935,
-0.18638241291046143,
0.9009337425231934,
0.12747769057750702,
0.8972228765487671,
0.7475934624671936,
-0.9920036196708679,
0.16995257139205933,
0.10689668357372284,
0.02666156366467476,
0.19115187227725983,
-0.6772738695144653,
-0.004642818123102188,
-0.30216604471206665,
0.14449769258499146,
-0.862165629863739,
-0.176371231675148,
0.36641255021095276,
-0.25772324204444885,
0.6015655398368835,
-0.30649298429489136,
-0.3266233503818512,
-0.16379742324352264,
-0.07196815311908722,
-0.11253147572278976,
0.948350727558136,
-0.3871167004108429,
0.9449909925460815,
0.09643153101205826,
-0.25707316398620605,
-0.447808176279068,
-0.9217557311058044,
-0.07844472676515579,
-0.4942045509815216,
0.16994163393974304,
0.38959434628486633,
-0.4752272963523865,
0.06925124675035477,
-0.2324226200580597,
-0.03767453879117966,
0.10380289703607559,
0.3493792414665222,
0.41995686292648315,
0.3150322437286377,
0.2324414700269699,
0.515579342842102,
0.41016486287117004,
-0.2582074701786041,
0.28304845094680786,
-0.09999371320009232,
0.6996362805366516,
0.2708045244216919,
-0.510120153427124,
-0.6295555830001831,
0.19697344303131104,
0.5975201725959778,
-0.32924991846084595,
0.3785710036754608,
0.309354692697525,
0.06999807804822922,
-0.5220628976821899,
-0.6863971948623657,
-0.4706709086894989,
-0.5440039038658142,
-0.018603073433041573,
-0.4841676652431488,
-1.0426421165466309,
0.5553550720214844,
-0.393191933631897,
-0.3343990743160248,
0.3004259169101715,
0.6199237704277039,
0.015164702199399471,
1.1153860092163086,
0.707318127155304,
-0.10940352082252502,
0.3924226462841034,
-0.016973547637462616,
-0.18836279213428497,
-1.0811173915863037,
-0.3287304937839508,
-0.15843144059181213,
-0.3604544699192047,
-0.6796526908874512,
-0.3059713840484619,
0.07982872426509857,
0.3145771622657776,
-0.6230980753898621,
-0.01922951079905033,
-0.3308611214160919,
0.34542280435562134,
0.5799626708030701,
-0.11148393154144287,
0.3324686884880066,
-0.22802387177944183,
-0.2785376012325287,
-0.06325653940439224,
-0.6205434799194336,
-0.4193066656589508,
0.6333097219467163,
0.4358615577220917,
1.35225510597229,
0.3024630844593048,
0.7271549701690674,
0.4081461429595947,
0.2475779801607132,
-0.8293517827987671,
0.5608689188957214,
0.1339753121137619,
-0.36959823966026306,
-0.24812224507331848,
-0.4764867126941681,
-0.6750212907791138,
0.1280621439218521,
0.1985829919576645,
-1.0831612348556519,
0.05703732371330261,
0.368161141872406,
-0.5972424745559692,
0.22299127280712128,
-0.5521739721298218,
0.5503272414207458,
-0.37640535831451416,
-0.6601515412330627,
-0.057152148336172104,
-0.5879853963851929,
0.4009130299091339,
-0.1448172628879547,
0.07627695053815842,
-0.507210373878479,
-0.6118322610855103,
0.4883165657520294,
-0.22876527905464172,
1.2254081964492798,
0.08009129017591476,
-0.22920167446136475,
0.17878146469593048,
0.7061755061149597,
0.5451747179031372,
-0.021584030240774155,
-0.01988156884908676,
0.11984847486019135,
-0.37045523524284363,
-0.22165325284004211,
-0.8297964334487915,
0.8259480595588684,
-0.6369876265525818,
-0.9481571912765503,
-0.3379122018814087,
-0.3149324059486389,
-0.10374552011489868,
0.3412005305290222,
-0.04763287678360939,
0.4807604253292084,
-0.0791880190372467,
-0.3415517807006836,
0.4117010533809662,
0.054970044642686844,
0.8695502877235413,
0.8253622055053711,
-0.6942068338394165,
-0.4122629165649414,
0.903244137763977,
0.22963595390319824,
0.6137810945510864,
0.13978040218353271,
0.37110498547554016,
-0.3357861340045929,
-0.21490232646465302,
-0.4677853584289551,
0.41415393352508545,
-0.4291307032108307,
-0.4024936258792877,
-0.5644693374633789,
-0.15740136802196503,
-0.39548036456108093,
0.0302533358335495,
-0.2900087535381317,
-0.5090060234069824,
-0.37795117497444153,
-0.056949421763420105,
0.5961298942565918,
1.1580440998077393,
-0.4185619354248047,
0.47448137402534485,
-0.5337900519371033,
0.2414862960577011,
0.28558599948883057,
0.6183329224586487,
0.06191965937614441,
-0.47537708282470703,
0.04612105339765549,
-0.4381873309612274,
-0.027941236272454262,
-0.7163125872612,
0.748807430267334,
0.24819315969944,
0.2384663224220276,
0.18600106239318848,
-0.19334642589092255,
0.5260395407676697,
-0.7942723035812378,
0.704867422580719,
0.14610493183135986,
-1.3548271656036377,
0.4847968816757202,
-0.34640857577323914,
0.3598185181617737,
0.08024448901414871,
0.6453942656517029,
-0.44596627354621887,
-0.44386619329452515,
-0.5255951285362244,
-0.6558400988578796,
0.7596044540405273,
0.07406028360128403,
0.40876346826553345,
-0.0037666838616132736,
0.7484496235847473,
-0.05436679348349571,
0.23673942685127258,
-0.5143781900405884,
-0.5619935393333435,
-0.15563936531543732,
0.008700714446604252,
0.1257835030555725,
-0.4279690086841583,
-0.1419331580400467,
-0.3102361261844635,
0.628433346748352,
-0.4297010004520416,
-0.07999514043331146,
0.38684314489364624,
0.21469852328300476,
-0.11375050991773605,
0.15490466356277466,
0.5415781736373901,
0.21298843622207642,
0.01676514744758606,
0.533577561378479,
0.2856281101703644,
-0.3398262858390808,
0.36770182847976685,
-0.20304462313652039,
-0.17319656908512115,
-0.5588228106498718,
0.13736552000045776,
0.5502004027366638,
-0.1412941813468933,
-0.11009079962968826,
0.3077862858772278,
-0.11317070573568344,
0.009377575479447842,
-0.16721835732460022,
0.3697833716869354,
0.0325196348130703,
-0.05661303922533989,
0.09054155647754669,
-0.019322508946061134,
0.08636943995952606,
-0.09481070190668106,
0.22054427862167358,
0.4006207585334778,
-0.562703013420105,
-0.35325634479522705,
0.6858336329460144,
0.09975195676088333,
-0.1987067461013794,
0.388945996761322,
-0.3647323548793793,
-0.49803876876831055,
0.704690158367157,
0.9500327706336975,
0.7869127988815308,
-0.6051270365715027,
0.13765250146389008,
0.32261893153190613,
0.2739431858062744,
-0.09783880412578583,
0.3051234185695648,
-0.06086752936244011,
-0.7979854941368103,
-0.7931551337242126,
-0.48849043250083923,
-0.05524452403187752,
0.09421585500240326,
-0.6484299302101135,
0.16207851469516754,
-0.719809353351593,
-0.2926521599292755,
-0.12174812704324722,
-0.35809192061424255,
-0.26613131165504456,
0.13233551383018494,
0.1978110671043396,
1.2433693408966064,
-0.7579540014266968,
0.819060206413269,
0.3302195370197296,
-0.6321183443069458,
-0.9969797730445862,
-0.046400051563978195,
0.0025866099167615175,
-0.774044394493103,
1.124337911605835,
-0.05075046420097351,
-0.8442716002464294,
0.40990346670150757,
-0.7855331897735596,
-1.2698628902435303,
0.9560500383377075,
0.024813110008835793,
-0.4829365611076355,
0.09861098229885101,
-0.19852270185947418,
0.47358646988868713,
-0.36385565996170044,
0.3004637360572815,
0.7847688794136047,
0.6274099946022034,
0.27640411257743835,
-0.8861477971076965,
0.23025812208652496,
-0.14245076477527618,
-0.1432902216911316,
0.38022127747535706,
-1.1851624250411987,
0.5865722298622131,
-0.18618446588516235,
-0.244034543633461,
0.05758998915553093,
0.9922469258308411,
-0.18465547263622284,
-0.2946564555168152,
0.4206819534301758,
0.3866349756717682,
0.6268737316131592,
0.102354995906353,
1.009586215019226,
-0.7234611511230469,
0.26904845237731934,
1.3892295360565186,
-0.33894082903862,
0.5451495051383972,
0.5284796357154846,
0.15458367764949799,
0.5212106704711914,
0.37640121579170227,
-0.0039564077742397785,
0.29026326537132263,
0.48562923073768616,
-0.17878912389278412,
-0.6099181771278381,
-0.5451172590255737,
0.16088080406188965,
0.5524774193763733,
0.6189747452735901,
-0.0800141766667366,
0.07080888748168945,
-0.10685845464468002,
0.34846529364585876,
-0.04918508231639862,
-0.5431127548217773,
0.8765268921852112,
0.07837559282779694,
-0.9029095768928528,
0.38312190771102905,
-0.07538878172636032,
0.7384257912635803,
-0.9852206110954285,
-0.17642100155353546,
-0.29364877939224243,
-0.029835326597094536,
-0.1942077875137329,
-0.6217759251594543,
0.06371533870697021,
-0.12375006824731827,
0.08633855730295181,
-0.504524827003479,
0.8859490752220154,
-0.7405837178230286,
-0.34308257699012756,
0.5094156265258789,
0.7665777206420898,
0.04444679990410805,
0.3752712905406952,
-0.5755742788314819,
-0.15792454779148102,
-0.2379300594329834,
-0.48534733057022095,
0.13453875482082367,
0.230032280087471,
-0.17502877116203308,
1.0677387714385986,
0.563479483127594,
0.46373042464256287,
0.28953319787979126,
0.0347706601023674,
0.9579901695251465,
-0.7169406414031982,
-0.16828851401805878,
-1.0508610010147095,
0.16015386581420898,
0.05250808596611023,
-0.3898964822292328,
0.9275421500205994,
0.2888754606246948,
0.4917164742946625,
0.0628393143415451,
0.7214888334274292,
-0.15812809765338898,
0.30085489153862,
-0.7040638327598572,
0.5391021370887756,
-0.7004825472831726,
-0.03461018204689026,
0.18950192630290985,
-0.46802544593811035,
-0.42866435647010803,
0.20120902359485626,
-0.14274105429649353,
0.2834169566631317,
0.6012108325958252,
1.0007688999176025,
-0.03766246512532234,
-0.4425365626811981,
0.4359300434589386,
0.19351351261138916,
0.2227395623922348,
0.07593394815921783,
1.0092097520828247,
0.30476781725883484,
-0.14247074723243713,
-0.37757349014282227,
-0.2485991269350052,
0.10939062386751175,
-1.2377934455871582,
-0.8847797513008118,
-0.25986534357070923,
-0.3276559114456177,
-0.3496483862400055,
-0.11224322766065598,
1.3436639308929443,
0.7586615085601807,
-0.6389057636260986,
-0.23098692297935486,
-0.20904774963855743,
0.25013768672943115,
-0.18447881937026978,
-0.15869131684303284,
0.42610323429107666,
-0.8063226938247681,
-0.8468663096427917,
0.5636751055717468,
0.3585079312324524,
0.3884936571121216,
-0.8981006741523743,
-0.10190555453300476,
-0.3261295258998871,
0.34131669998168945,
0.17945991456508636,
0.33568045496940613,
-0.7661004662513733,
-0.07036665827035904,
0.04297706484794617,
-0.4605244994163513,
0.021790895611047745,
1.1784812211990356,
-0.6395939588546753,
0.40443000197410583,
0.36361438035964966,
0.11599227786064148,
0.1570112258195877,
0.3813011646270752,
0.7489968538284302,
-0.7385140657424927,
-0.23554040491580963,
-0.11074934154748917,
0.3802281320095062,
0.24078255891799927,
-0.6309149265289307,
0.4313828647136688,
-0.01806294359266758,
-0.6990306377410889,
-0.12519995868206024,
0.4726560413837433,
-0.6860299706459045,
-0.29274076223373413,
1.3247281312942505,
-0.14009441435337067,
-0.45866578817367554,
0.034375905990600586,
-0.321805477142334,
0.26163265109062195,
-0.8005478382110596,
0.6404145359992981,
0.49619969725608826,
-0.45882007479667664,
-0.015850648283958435,
-0.43770331144332886,
1.0098439455032349,
0.5671826004981995,
-0.6210514307022095,
0.32187673449516296,
0.4329652488231659,
0.26011061668395996,
0.1369795799255371,
0.6496723294258118,
0.18216203153133392,
-0.3011176586151123,
-0.599408745765686,
0.618712306022644,
-0.1515970230102539,
-0.6376394033432007,
-0.854715883731842,
-0.06267727166414261,
0.036602411419153214,
0.11815541982650757
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.02543v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.02543v1
|
To Believe or Not to Believe Your LLM
| 2024-06-04T17:58:18 | 2024-06-04T17:58:18 |
Yasin Abbasi Yadkori, Ilja Kuzborskij, András György, Csaba Szepesvári
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
We explore uncertainty quantification in large language models (LLMs), with
the goal to identify when uncertainty in responses given a query is large. We
simultaneously consider both epistemic and aleatoric uncertainties, where the
former comes from the lack of knowledge about the ground truth (such as about
facts or the language), and the latter comes from irreducible randomness (such
as multiple possible answers). In particular, we derive an
information-theoretic metric that allows to reliably detect when only epistemic
uncertainty is large, in which case the output of the model is unreliable. This
condition can be computed based solely on the output of the model obtained
simply by some special iterative prompting based on the previous responses.
Such quantification, for instance, allows to detect hallucinations (cases when
epistemic uncertainty is high) in both single- and multi-answer responses. This
is in contrast to many standard uncertainty quantification strategies (such as
thresholding the log-likelihood of a response) where hallucinations in the
multi-answer case cannot be detected. We conduct a series of experiments which
demonstrate the advantage of our formulation. Further, our investigations shed
some light on how the probabilities assigned to a given output by an LLM can be
amplified by iterative prompting, which might be of independent interest.
|
[
-0.4118685722351074,
-1.1199061870574951,
1.127879023551941,
0.2327941507101059,
0.03822130709886551,
0.0896364375948906,
-0.3300645649433136,
-0.2905583083629608,
0.311588853597641,
0.2953277826309204,
-0.4804587960243225,
-0.4705462157726288,
-0.8531307578086853,
-0.005267252679914236,
-0.4553373157978058,
0.6252830028533936,
0.07928863167762756,
-0.06874258071184158,
-0.2586852014064789,
0.0454646535217762,
-0.09557737410068512,
-0.5548602938652039,
-0.6888903379440308,
-0.06675540655851364,
0.5326226353645325,
0.2685386836528778,
0.8045734763145447,
0.5444847941398621,
0.3907938599586487,
0.24638044834136963,
-0.11410949379205704,
0.08456649631261826,
-0.3415984511375427,
0.26262107491493225,
-0.1034894809126854,
-0.7705388069152832,
-0.049076683819293976,
-0.14500178396701813,
0.5506120920181274,
0.6926043629646301,
-0.5775405168533325,
0.20011326670646667,
-0.32318052649497986,
0.32651999592781067,
-0.7766525745391846,
0.0039458125829696655,
-0.9358444213867188,
0.3016136586666107,
-0.031136199831962585,
-0.3864746689796448,
-0.5363752245903015,
-0.526339054107666,
0.04688182845711708,
-0.35377851128578186,
0.09741261601448059,
0.43653133511543274,
0.8145761489868164,
0.5577926635742188,
-0.33333659172058105,
-0.548265814781189,
-0.9791611433029175,
0.8024955987930298,
-0.5915159583091736,
0.4857926368713379,
0.7877079844474792,
0.35207197070121765,
-0.10952990502119064,
-0.41363686323165894,
-0.7266178131103516,
-0.38062649965286255,
0.18034277856349945,
0.16358262300491333,
-0.261985719203949,
0.03776796534657478,
0.18720197677612305,
0.5104864835739136,
-0.5344039797782898,
0.13392700254917145,
-0.054947517812252045,
-0.4050385355949402,
0.30890315771102905,
0.0638723224401474,
-0.0070223333314061165,
0.181552454829216,
-0.3587861955165863,
-0.05559072270989418,
-0.6704980134963989,
-0.04262341558933258,
0.7538428902626038,
-0.10424996167421341,
0.23055876791477203,
0.9587365984916687,
-0.09618695080280304,
0.49804699420928955,
0.19019892811775208,
-0.1745573878288269,
-0.16395525634288788,
-0.12202624976634979,
-0.22048506140708923,
0.12952497601509094,
0.7662153840065002,
0.01022719033062458,
0.12184816598892212,
-0.21282801032066345,
-0.2831280827522278,
0.1877291202545166,
0.2663656175136566,
-0.5061861872673035,
-0.0410916730761528,
0.5520056486129761,
-0.13338181376457214,
-0.24451039731502533,
-0.0737561360001564,
-0.5366036295890808,
-0.5159785151481628,
0.06056565046310425,
0.5413853526115417,
-0.49837741255760193,
-0.28958091139793396,
0.28239402174949646,
0.06710006296634674,
-0.07285960018634796,
0.47729599475860596,
-0.724375307559967,
0.2285035252571106,
0.4824632406234741,
0.5591534376144409,
-0.1326163113117218,
-0.29835665225982666,
-0.4201383590698242,
0.06493350863456726,
-0.7362545132637024,
0.8251619338989258,
-0.4482775926589966,
-0.1817196011543274,
0.07323969155550003,
-0.17297044396400452,
0.09054895490407944,
-0.5828859806060791,
0.5395317077636719,
-0.5727910995483398,
0.12023220956325531,
-0.25612708926200867,
-0.830151379108429,
-0.19927093386650085,
0.3332747220993042,
-0.600284993648529,
0.7800123691558838,
0.042588263750076294,
-0.6928709149360657,
0.42974263429641724,
-0.18039514124393463,
-0.10804901272058487,
-0.22003713250160217,
-0.2607887089252472,
-0.36904236674308777,
0.5099018216133118,
-0.07242680341005325,
0.2349158078432083,
-0.3970397114753723,
0.39076724648475647,
-0.5525741577148438,
-0.1891442835330963,
0.8218808770179749,
-0.8884313702583313,
0.4568610191345215,
0.22793568670749664,
-0.17893154919147491,
-0.0818590596318245,
-0.7070927023887634,
0.3083503246307373,
-0.02221084199845791,
-0.3995567858219147,
-0.17398150265216827,
0.14075957238674164,
-0.3563152253627777,
0.0008527509635314345,
0.2920132279396057,
-0.5415647029876709,
-0.05016528442502022,
-0.43278083205223083,
0.15607815980911255,
0.7547481060028076,
0.23387999832630157,
0.2629586160182953,
-0.4371257722377777,
0.426824152469635,
0.24691921472549438,
-0.06630456447601318,
-0.007814736105501652,
-0.5785933136940002,
-0.8362782001495361,
-0.08787094056606293,
0.3005715012550354,
0.5713630318641663,
-0.5942651629447937,
0.5478116869926453,
-0.0071074748411774635,
-0.3265411853790283,
-0.7835586071014404,
-0.04402635991573334,
0.2838192582130432,
0.28896471858024597,
0.22966593503952026,
-0.03499552607536316,
-0.5245832204818726,
-0.8516601920127869,
-0.33160364627838135,
-0.7497494220733643,
-0.21205197274684906,
0.057253461331129074,
0.4361632764339447,
-0.0018740547820925713,
0.7724958062171936,
-0.4414493143558502,
-0.0342729352414608,
0.09224747866392136,
0.24647559225559235,
0.22900404036045074,
0.05020703002810478,
0.1220800131559372,
-0.7161044478416443,
-0.21968230605125427,
0.035435229539871216,
-0.9328702688217163,
0.10029760003089905,
-0.1365201473236084,
0.2948457896709442,
0.34024274349212646,
0.16622188687324524,
-0.7175349593162537,
0.6850079894065857,
0.5720385909080505,
-0.3702964782714844,
0.48395785689353943,
-0.33470237255096436,
0.3353314697742462,
-0.9121942520141602,
-0.40102124214172363,
0.05126115307211876,
-0.22920837998390198,
-0.312948077917099,
0.06881853193044662,
0.0200960710644722,
0.3614523708820343,
-0.17637066543102264,
0.3394753038883209,
-0.2914164960384369,
-0.07830143719911575,
-0.15839439630508423,
0.07608313113451004,
-0.15484637022018433,
0.2486676275730133,
0.1714983582496643,
0.7815576195716858,
0.6632530093193054,
-0.603790283203125,
0.30077511072158813,
0.10724751651287079,
-0.5318350791931152,
0.537553608417511,
-0.43163931369781494,
0.150337815284729,
-0.10330861806869507,
-0.0770612582564354,
-1.0608880519866943,
-0.39225494861602783,
0.17863887548446655,
-0.8113523125648499,
0.14599305391311646,
0.10765189677476883,
-0.5817670822143555,
-0.3267154097557068,
-0.20313364267349243,
-0.003935355227440596,
0.38779133558273315,
-0.5062757134437561,
0.5481618642807007,
0.20027486979961395,
-0.19603289663791656,
-0.6775920391082764,
-0.8756669759750366,
0.08154723793268204,
-0.255095899105072,
-0.46676310896873474,
0.013471356593072414,
-0.3332112431526184,
-0.8008720874786377,
0.07498195767402649,
-0.2414291650056839,
-0.24285224080085754,
0.2219860851764679,
0.3584549129009247,
0.08968685567378998,
-0.38817915320396423,
0.28020933270454407,
0.16552461683750153,
-0.009212792851030827,
0.3076070547103882,
-0.3290351927280426,
0.4347553849220276,
-0.18227729201316833,
-0.9243518114089966,
-0.43503230810165405,
0.26640406250953674,
0.3741168677806854,
0.2263672798871994,
0.9277583956718445,
0.416300505399704,
-0.5733528733253479,
-0.23815308511257172,
-0.81470787525177,
-0.27550169825553894,
-0.4444134831428528,
0.21051143109798431,
-0.5157375931739807,
-1.0088937282562256,
0.7022314071655273,
0.038361288607120514,
-0.22270654141902924,
0.32695817947387695,
0.8456217646598816,
-0.25607895851135254,
0.9556438326835632,
0.52838134765625,
0.1265716403722763,
-0.037798479199409485,
0.17051765322685242,
0.42647257447242737,
-0.43437430262565613,
-0.16013073921203613,
-0.5364447236061096,
0.08252567052841187,
-0.5188518166542053,
-0.548186182975769,
0.4416440427303314,
0.15031954646110535,
-0.193935826420784,
-0.26130491495132446,
-0.19645395874977112,
0.4461168646812439,
0.47607606649398804,
0.17276373505592346,
0.4949720501899719,
-0.007868753746151924,
0.04834776371717453,
-0.13285431265830994,
-0.5394679307937622,
-0.5852838754653931,
1.1124916076660156,
0.46835461258888245,
0.9540905952453613,
0.5055477619171143,
0.5567476749420166,
0.3138555884361267,
0.22160334885120392,
-1.0913535356521606,
0.34138739109039307,
0.46128877997398376,
-0.7810314297676086,
-0.5718472599983215,
-0.5485754609107971,
-0.658436119556427,
0.1481131911277771,
-0.3446047604084015,
-1.0078198909759521,
0.13382136821746826,
0.04485822841525078,
-0.594120442867279,
0.5441277623176575,
-0.4604793190956116,
0.2713344991207123,
-0.16454531252384186,
-0.12343470007181168,
-0.061187658458948135,
-0.5058204531669617,
0.3445771038532257,
-0.4701981544494629,
0.12106508016586304,
0.07205361127853394,
-0.20666804909706116,
0.5344286561012268,
-0.26207613945007324,
0.8240019083023071,
0.2141796350479126,
-0.2898657023906708,
0.48513734340667725,
0.27086350321769714,
0.689617931842804,
0.4631752669811249,
-0.2633450925350189,
0.12674158811569214,
0.014771820046007633,
-0.21221235394477844,
-0.6256987452507019,
0.5309146046638489,
-0.7757939696311951,
-0.9668186902999878,
-0.4945264458656311,
-0.5601031184196472,
-0.34960439801216125,
-0.050554804503917694,
0.6275794506072998,
-0.14549970626831055,
-0.20356231927871704,
0.18061219155788422,
1.1071211099624634,
-0.42333468794822693,
0.2775653600692749,
0.4834699034690857,
-0.3330760896205902,
-0.3899328112602234,
0.6496543884277344,
0.27067628502845764,
0.44526657462120056,
0.5126734375953674,
0.2611539959907532,
-0.3911522924900055,
-0.7983192205429077,
-0.2841237485408783,
0.13594333827495575,
-0.9425799250602722,
-0.05678950995206833,
-0.6240273714065552,
-0.2999110519886017,
-0.39247021079063416,
0.16189052164554596,
-0.45385777950286865,
-0.3376421630382538,
-0.21030718088150024,
-0.4816352128982544,
0.40278029441833496,
0.8149226307868958,
-0.06751883774995804,
0.26164379715919495,
-0.5391329526901245,
0.19790425896644592,
0.3429707884788513,
0.08413225412368774,
-0.20599472522735596,
-0.8045750260353088,
-0.11409278213977814,
0.09044435620307922,
-0.2175416797399521,
-0.9541155099868774,
0.42915645241737366,
0.057185277342796326,
0.5826606154441833,
0.6153088212013245,
0.3147982060909271,
0.642314612865448,
-0.3828912079334259,
0.7298455238342285,
0.10546521097421646,
-1.0258450508117676,
0.46565699577331543,
-0.18330314755439758,
-0.06867809593677521,
0.49166905879974365,
0.6705011129379272,
-0.3063482344150543,
-0.8923524618148804,
-0.7864164113998413,
-0.6414960026741028,
0.26494187116622925,
0.15792791545391083,
0.058558035641908646,
-0.07269337028265,
0.4291173219680786,
0.16887345910072327,
0.4841058850288391,
-0.6734300255775452,
-0.34190115332603455,
0.15917746722698212,
-0.05921827629208565,
-0.0010172838810831308,
-0.4757881760597229,
-0.44044286012649536,
0.005335943307727575,
0.5460251569747925,
-0.2541806697845459,
0.6165380477905273,
0.18098263442516327,
-0.009673168882727623,
-0.5727202892303467,
0.259586364030838,
0.6648641228675842,
0.9125576615333557,
-0.2342434972524643,
0.3914177417755127,
0.3344460725784302,
-0.22004155814647675,
0.11570112407207489,
-0.234184131026268,
-0.09248422086238861,
0.20025312900543213,
0.5284721255302429,
0.8355560898780823,
-0.12131639569997787,
-0.6351802945137024,
0.5581045150756836,
-0.15497055649757385,
-0.24055759608745575,
-0.8032101988792419,
-0.2039055973291397,
0.05759478360414505,
0.33785900473594666,
0.46531566977500916,
0.1902196854352951,
0.0950954258441925,
-0.656644344329834,
0.27901706099510193,
0.3459731340408325,
-0.32899272441864014,
-0.393252432346344,
0.7004229426383972,
-0.5543937087059021,
-0.38344913721084595,
0.42542368173599243,
-0.33238622546195984,
-0.4223015010356903,
0.5536816716194153,
0.5800940990447998,
0.7116165161132812,
-0.2986932396888733,
0.3964345455169678,
0.19063815474510193,
0.5768305659294128,
-0.3524782359600067,
0.4133475720882416,
0.3473217487335205,
-1.0457537174224854,
-0.445511132478714,
-0.6576924920082092,
-0.6441662907600403,
0.18966427445411682,
-0.8756203055381775,
-0.0577460378408432,
-0.5991756916046143,
-0.2428354173898697,
-0.13720005750656128,
-0.17438188195228577,
-0.42059603333473206,
0.250213086605072,
0.13498705625534058,
0.7985184788703918,
-0.9925122261047363,
0.8200289607048035,
0.38412338495254517,
-0.29928961396217346,
-0.8881914019584656,
0.3820347189903259,
0.22764858603477478,
-0.935106098651886,
0.4464024007320404,
-0.21941134333610535,
-0.03356926515698433,
-0.132033571600914,
-0.620726466178894,
-1.008138656616211,
0.8812424540519714,
0.4434649348258972,
-0.5575981736183167,
0.11587353050708771,
0.05221913382411003,
0.455461710691452,
-0.34537988901138306,
0.27423304319381714,
0.5346804261207581,
0.6688034534454346,
0.42730793356895447,
-0.8193233609199524,
-0.08222128450870514,
0.2218390703201294,
-0.0921878069639206,
0.10474032908678055,
-0.44237303733825684,
1.0162246227264404,
-0.5452902317047119,
-0.19344176352024078,
0.2584038972854614,
0.8012427091598511,
0.4086260497570038,
0.4817239046096802,
0.3356781005859375,
0.7028382420539856,
1.332314372062683,
-0.3133011758327484,
1.2368841171264648,
-0.27372580766677856,
0.5156920552253723,
1.1599278450012207,
-0.3292554020881653,
1.0538980960845947,
0.7870038151741028,
-0.3681681156158447,
0.15375183522701263,
1.018539547920227,
0.14861156046390533,
0.4294848144054413,
0.2808782458305359,
-0.36211222410202026,
-0.5264694690704346,
-0.08409091085195541,
-0.2606099843978882,
0.18867166340351105,
0.6672097444534302,
-0.3215683400630951,
0.04898152872920036,
0.00822350475937128,
0.009797475300729275,
0.11420625448226929,
-0.015457254834473133,
0.6594381928443909,
0.28682881593704224,
-0.5771987438201904,
0.5334980487823486,
-0.11791453510522842,
0.47275879979133606,
-0.5287263989448547,
0.08843662589788437,
-0.12169930338859558,
0.03874410316348076,
-0.15656693279743195,
-0.9635286331176758,
0.4333283603191376,
-0.2762455344200134,
-0.19618628919124603,
-0.05084226280450821,
0.559606671333313,
-0.41125229001045227,
-0.5401760339736938,
0.2564631700515747,
0.7818629741668701,
0.2682346701622009,
-0.1617414802312851,
-0.4133986830711365,
0.2037232369184494,
0.06676427274942398,
-0.547784149646759,
0.2550280690193176,
1.0114412307739258,
0.11834687739610672,
1.0369820594787598,
0.39735135436058044,
0.4655769169330597,
0.1234305277466774,
-0.2746809124946594,
0.5681145191192627,
-0.47389721870422363,
-0.15451973676681519,
-0.9868992567062378,
0.21503441035747528,
0.05258610099554062,
-0.3972998857498169,
0.9052239656448364,
0.37371015548706055,
0.7936747074127197,
0.012592182494699955,
1.015967845916748,
0.09692750126123428,
0.44867879152297974,
-0.7299511432647705,
0.5975387692451477,
-0.4202527701854706,
0.7304633855819702,
0.09157921373844147,
-0.9155163764953613,
-0.3052259087562561,
0.8014901280403137,
-0.40672141313552856,
-0.11927497386932373,
0.9716274738311768,
0.813772439956665,
0.2875571846961975,
0.1708543598651886,
0.7904633283615112,
0.5156176686286926,
0.011512545868754387,
0.46980002522468567,
1.1785310506820679,
-0.19606934487819672,
0.4337378740310669,
-0.09458296000957489,
-0.16857251524925232,
-0.10110895335674286,
-0.8231464624404907,
-0.6920946836471558,
-0.5659046769142151,
-0.43051427602767944,
-0.7230789065361023,
-0.06977276504039764,
0.8986384868621826,
0.4309036135673523,
-0.9407526254653931,
-0.1633780151605606,
0.07018867880105972,
0.43460002541542053,
-0.11962997168302536,
-0.1671617329120636,
0.06512147188186646,
-0.18887372314929962,
-0.562900960445404,
0.4289328157901764,
0.3815324604511261,
0.18318797647953033,
-0.4529465138912201,
-0.05372099578380585,
-0.09635733813047409,
0.44673481583595276,
0.31011366844177246,
0.09618577361106873,
-1.0289005041122437,
-0.5850643515586853,
-0.008334578946232796,
-0.020492173731327057,
0.05775734782218933,
0.36504343152046204,
-0.4490474462509155,
0.36764848232269287,
0.20799840986728668,
0.7403771877288818,
0.35207560658454895,
-0.21222496032714844,
0.5604042410850525,
-0.6509050726890564,
-0.08662199229001999,
0.3948556184768677,
0.35650917887687683,
0.11115004867315292,
-0.616887629032135,
0.5593924522399902,
0.16358694434165955,
-0.5774810910224915,
-1.0122567415237427,
0.44117751717567444,
-0.8337099552154541,
-0.19850996136665344,
1.2205075025558472,
-0.3545983135700226,
-0.3208094835281372,
-0.17058280110359192,
0.1948731541633606,
-0.0865425243973732,
-0.3755582869052887,
0.9927257299423218,
1.097804069519043,
-0.01923367753624916,
-0.14904533326625824,
-0.7524905204772949,
0.3225402235984802,
0.30375218391418457,
-0.6452344059944153,
-0.0720728188753128,
0.3248971402645111,
0.23241834342479706,
0.5587044358253479,
0.4747835397720337,
0.1962788999080658,
0.06167090684175491,
0.21905671060085297,
-0.07919533550739288,
0.3616586923599243,
-0.372098445892334,
-0.3225090801715851,
0.4142599105834961,
0.4632575213909149,
0.022884083911776543
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.02539v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.02539v1
|
Parrot: Multilingual Visual Instruction Tuning
| 2024-06-04T17:56:28 | 2024-06-04T17:56:28 |
Hai-Long Sun, Da-Wei Zhou, Yang Li, Shiyin Lu, Chao Yi, Qing-Guo Chen, Zhao Xu, Weihua Luo, Kaifu Zhang, De-Chuan Zhan, Han-Jia Ye
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
The rapid development of Multimodal Large Language Models (MLLMs) like GPT-4V
has marked a significant step towards artificial general intelligence. Existing
methods mainly focus on aligning vision encoders with LLMs through supervised
fine-tuning (SFT) to endow LLMs with multimodal abilities, making MLLMs'
inherent ability to react to multiple languages progressively deteriorate as
the training process evolves. We empirically find that the imbalanced SFT
datasets, primarily composed of English-centric image-text pairs, lead to
significantly reduced performance in non-English languages. This is due to the
failure of aligning the vision encoder and LLM with multilingual tokens during
the SFT process. In this paper, we introduce Parrot, a novel method that
utilizes textual guidance to drive visual token alignment at the language
level. Parrot makes the visual tokens condition on diverse language inputs and
uses Mixture-of-Experts (MoE) to promote the alignment of multilingual tokens.
Specifically, to enhance non-English visual tokens alignment, we compute the
cross-attention using the initial visual features and textual embeddings, the
result of which is then fed into the MoE router to select the most relevant
experts. The selected experts subsequently convert the initial visual tokens
into language-specific visual tokens. Moreover, considering the current lack of
benchmarks for evaluating multilingual capabilities within the field, we
collect and make available a Massive Multilingual Multimodal Benchmark which
includes 6 languages, 15 categories, and 12,000 questions, named as MMMB. Our
method not only demonstrates state-of-the-art performance on multilingual
MMBench and MMMB, but also excels across a broad range of multimodal tasks.
Both the source code and the training dataset of Parrot will be made publicly
available.
|
[
-0.4131563901901245,
-1.0001553297042847,
-0.01325682271271944,
0.36351051926612854,
-0.25650137662887573,
0.06383607536554337,
-0.5546354651451111,
-0.41611000895500183,
0.06291878968477249,
0.22790101170539856,
-0.6283262372016907,
-0.41938355565071106,
-0.4893524944782257,
0.21434815227985382,
0.04050109162926674,
0.8390696048736572,
0.1624702364206314,
0.2559625804424286,
-0.21312464773654938,
-0.4883946478366852,
-0.7150704860687256,
-0.3510238528251648,
-0.6142708659172058,
0.09291394799947739,
0.611997663974762,
0.43126046657562256,
0.6782978773117065,
0.7970541715621948,
0.6173602938652039,
0.3851483166217804,
0.19078604876995087,
0.6422175765037537,
-0.4350568354129791,
-0.11518064141273499,
-0.35964542627334595,
-0.354829341173172,
-0.3520434498786926,
-0.17335718870162964,
0.5157053470611572,
0.2359817773103714,
-0.03803999349474907,
0.17423754930496216,
0.09249228239059448,
0.5394734144210815,
-0.609557032585144,
0.36593014001846313,
-0.717256486415863,
0.09151358902454376,
-0.45558443665504456,
-0.6360765099525452,
-0.3812428414821625,
0.08683928102254868,
-0.05448174476623535,
-0.9259687066078186,
0.12754012644290924,
0.2095002830028534,
0.693697988986969,
0.3812292218208313,
-0.5607528686523438,
-0.0466337725520134,
-0.13213466107845306,
1.09203040599823,
-0.538101077079773,
0.5352411270141602,
0.21277692914009094,
0.3548624515533447,
-0.07895007729530334,
-0.4223465621471405,
-0.5276052355766296,
-0.005620548967272043,
0.09585887938737869,
0.15308687090873718,
0.09147881716489792,
0.09026096016168594,
0.07296580076217651,
0.304533988237381,
-0.6862549185752869,
0.16867059469223022,
-0.32524576783180237,
-0.4161781072616577,
0.5367539525032043,
0.024341000244021416,
0.39832478761672974,
0.08166534453630447,
-0.33966803550720215,
-0.0876188799738884,
-0.425967276096344,
0.23249170184135437,
0.2129301130771637,
0.44161197543144226,
-0.18267208337783813,
0.7222270369529724,
-0.07080107927322388,
0.8976171016693115,
0.16972710192203522,
-0.34654200077056885,
0.40158459544181824,
-0.5491520762443542,
-0.17181570827960968,
0.05389248579740524,
0.8181701302528381,
0.7068685293197632,
0.6003206968307495,
0.08776628226041794,
0.07865393161773682,
0.008045623078942299,
0.17691412568092346,
-0.5428965091705322,
-0.011797755025327206,
-0.05023925006389618,
-0.3376947045326233,
-0.19555510580539703,
-0.12704907357692719,
-0.6303285956382751,
-0.35833102464675903,
-0.4119139313697815,
0.26707541942596436,
-0.627570390701294,
-0.16678979992866516,
-0.18384476006031036,
-0.2086128294467926,
0.3646511435508728,
0.35575246810913086,
-1.2793395519256592,
-0.20873820781707764,
0.6760817766189575,
0.7008239030838013,
0.007113402709364891,
-0.7181166410446167,
-0.9330617785453796,
0.41514748334884644,
-0.5154131650924683,
0.6576506495475769,
-0.8487796783447266,
0.007993391714990139,
0.00020244013285264373,
0.261496365070343,
-0.21608133614063263,
-0.10704707354307175,
0.13277237117290497,
-0.14232632517814636,
0.41302940249443054,
-0.2981639504432678,
-0.32570797204971313,
-0.318411648273468,
0.5858799815177917,
-0.3109818398952484,
0.9969262480735779,
-0.12113910168409348,
-0.776604175567627,
0.4561755955219269,
-0.49101778864860535,
-0.6133613586425781,
-0.028594721108675003,
-0.4988499581813812,
-0.2862635850906372,
-0.07534965127706528,
0.932270884513855,
0.5362228155136108,
-0.06860387325286865,
0.0948839783668518,
-0.2539840638637543,
-0.5685235261917114,
-0.1257638931274414,
-0.6586775779724121,
0.6734477877616882,
0.04059535637497902,
-0.4188085198402405,
0.4817206859588623,
-0.6086347699165344,
0.15214192867279053,
-0.0658242404460907,
-0.3222793638706207,
-0.26340144872665405,
0.09667222946882248,
0.2777842879295349,
0.1820484697818756,
0.29127591848373413,
-0.3906409442424774,
0.3251609206199646,
-0.41626057028770447,
0.6961790919303894,
0.856152355670929,
-0.16722643375396729,
0.28681236505508423,
-0.10564827173948288,
0.5926620960235596,
0.10403411835432053,
0.44074398279190063,
-0.5328119397163391,
-0.8377829790115356,
-0.7786429524421692,
-0.3191956579685211,
0.09282417595386505,
0.6561905145645142,
-0.9375666975975037,
0.16939397156238556,
-0.336700975894928,
-0.08993467688560486,
-0.8456196188926697,
0.4817405343055725,
0.5966683626174927,
0.43689432740211487,
0.38656899333000183,
-0.15343235433101654,
-0.3321771025657654,
-1.0349633693695068,
-0.27764442563056946,
0.003173636505380273,
0.24725541472434998,
0.24627463519573212,
0.10401015728712082,
-0.23230844736099243,
0.5640616416931152,
0.0915268138051033,
-0.5640337467193604,
0.04511316493153572,
0.09261356294155121,
-0.0786070004105568,
0.555487871170044,
0.7251853942871094,
-0.846813976764679,
-0.46878066658973694,
0.6328538060188293,
-0.744545042514801,
0.11674797534942627,
-0.1863950788974762,
-0.2710050344467163,
0.3835718333721161,
0.6895807385444641,
-0.19172227382659912,
0.18081063032150269,
0.5547656416893005,
-0.19602546095848083,
0.30473899841308594,
-0.3553978204727173,
0.42354151606559753,
-0.9647095799446106,
-0.09802406281232834,
0.035283785313367844,
-0.3024531304836273,
-0.12922132015228271,
0.34848400950431824,
0.42504388093948364,
-0.06144722178578377,
-0.6203659772872925,
0.5417485237121582,
-0.5907601118087769,
0.1782064586877823,
0.0017274804413318634,
0.03606576472520828,
0.022546108812093735,
0.7963399291038513,
-0.08426884561777115,
1.0141408443450928,
0.6274192333221436,
-0.2985639274120331,
0.5100239515304565,
0.2533542215824127,
-0.1637895405292511,
0.8971880674362183,
-0.32410573959350586,
-0.026301050558686256,
-0.062142081558704376,
-0.12359625101089478,
-0.8220481872558594,
-0.15927019715309143,
0.1979232132434845,
-0.2851198613643646,
0.43209633231163025,
-0.15896885097026825,
-0.38581183552742004,
-0.32110142707824707,
-0.33757057785987854,
0.5004085302352905,
0.16851966083049774,
-0.5582617521286011,
0.6353714466094971,
0.09937109798192978,
-0.2081388533115387,
-1.0057401657104492,
-0.8914969563484192,
0.38783982396125793,
-0.11259865015745163,
-0.7010537981987,
0.07985856384038925,
-0.12188958376646042,
0.1343243271112442,
-0.06779983639717102,
0.14065121114253998,
0.09845077991485596,
-0.17473027110099792,
0.0220956951379776,
-0.05902722477912903,
-0.48510006070137024,
0.23129023611545563,
0.21093225479125977,
-0.008760499767959118,
-0.3036123812198639,
-0.4365914762020111,
0.2569478750228882,
-0.38963302969932556,
-0.5793218016624451,
-0.5111196041107178,
0.32195091247558594,
0.6957805156707764,
-0.8889597058296204,
0.5309918522834778,
0.9796610474586487,
0.09865206480026245,
-0.06772584468126297,
-0.6872110962867737,
0.22495800256729126,
-0.5127208232879639,
0.6323628425598145,
-0.4385816156864166,
-0.7390425205230713,
0.2848466634750366,
0.09169267117977142,
0.16667014360427856,
0.3036585748195648,
0.6808216571807861,
-0.0602974109351635,
1.2583774328231812,
0.7821053266525269,
-0.2292657196521759,
0.7846466302871704,
-0.0970456525683403,
-0.019713470712304115,
-0.6697096228599548,
-0.27854371070861816,
-0.08940459787845612,
-0.5241000652313232,
-0.6061499118804932,
-0.6332889199256897,
0.36871781945228577,
-0.034882642328739166,
-0.14210471510887146,
-0.09865069389343262,
-0.63621985912323,
0.7897510528564453,
0.7965242266654968,
0.05960167199373245,
0.08195678889751434,
0.14905239641666412,
-0.38936710357666016,
-0.11252371966838837,
-0.7592200636863708,
-0.21495871245861053,
1.0964436531066895,
0.03657440096139908,
0.596024215221405,
0.07499293237924576,
0.2533062994480133,
0.15875637531280518,
-0.04781905934214592,
-0.6613884568214417,
0.363015741109848,
-0.33436623215675354,
-0.2862373888492584,
-0.3815803825855255,
-0.11951924115419388,
-0.8186296820640564,
0.442901611328125,
-0.20764514803886414,
-0.41543543338775635,
0.005200002808123827,
0.24643352627754211,
-0.00755681237205863,
0.04783950001001358,
-0.8765882849693298,
1.1042487621307373,
-0.6659192442893982,
-0.633251965045929,
-0.30875474214553833,
-0.7969775199890137,
0.33562082052230835,
-0.07518821209669113,
0.3144457936286926,
-0.033065348863601685,
-0.11868862807750702,
0.41105759143829346,
-0.3850124478340149,
0.9016725420951843,
-0.2656121850013733,
-0.19115304946899414,
0.03476027026772499,
-0.3303326964378357,
0.4505678117275238,
-0.04436303302645683,
-0.10331595689058304,
0.18436577916145325,
0.0364546924829483,
-0.7448784112930298,
-0.5483308434486389,
0.7396318316459656,
-0.7940679788589478,
-0.5173725485801697,
-0.1611042320728302,
-0.6741148233413696,
-0.3442891538143158,
0.3981815576553345,
0.1816166490316391,
0.5009701251983643,
-0.19899272918701172,
0.302409827709198,
0.25573810935020447,
-0.44344574213027954,
0.403749018907547,
0.5023190379142761,
-0.17719776928424835,
-0.5971952080726624,
1.1187406778335571,
0.051790524274110794,
0.038584694266319275,
0.5643160939216614,
0.1750306487083435,
-0.31517258286476135,
-0.48950251936912537,
-0.8761806488037109,
0.022037776187062263,
-0.6926689743995667,
-0.15137921273708344,
-0.2859479784965515,
0.13888932764530182,
-0.3955084979534149,
-0.2779298424720764,
-0.20850928127765656,
-0.3348314166069031,
-0.21327874064445496,
0.11552835255861282,
0.42945751547813416,
0.40760913491249084,
0.2391166239976883,
0.22278434038162231,
-0.6152918338775635,
0.3767295479774475,
0.3449123501777649,
0.3690882921218872,
-0.12146517634391785,
-0.23138679563999176,
-0.39064574241638184,
0.36388200521469116,
-0.3744060695171356,
-0.4030984938144684,
0.1438497006893158,
0.7436655163764954,
0.6769609451293945,
0.6763583421707153,
-0.19330276548862457,
1.274871826171875,
-0.6617047190666199,
0.8827217221260071,
0.19443631172180176,
-0.9610100388526917,
0.708459734916687,
-0.6013135313987732,
0.37248513102531433,
0.4192405939102173,
-0.08926920592784882,
-0.5653777718544006,
-0.6277929544448853,
-0.03608270362019539,
-0.6981028914451599,
0.6369016170501709,
0.015087427571415901,
0.08502020686864853,
-0.10776753723621368,
0.0002476773806847632,
0.1592816263437271,
0.24701903760433197,
-0.4779086410999298,
0.08945368975400925,
-0.5945412516593933,
-0.5347707271575928,
-0.3865117132663727,
0.04090820997953415,
-0.16308552026748657,
-0.5674923658370972,
0.5147806406021118,
-0.5549829602241516,
-0.05556962639093399,
-0.032058075070381165,
-0.3310708701610565,
-0.12170005589723587,
0.06891002506017685,
0.8802620768547058,
0.7057013511657715,
0.09455141425132751,
-0.04276026412844658,
0.02166914753615856,
-0.2980373203754425,
0.04099513962864876,
-0.09811025857925415,
0.16900737583637238,
-0.3237389922142029,
0.5698012709617615,
0.9000147581100464,
0.39089903235435486,
-0.7532632350921631,
0.7581318616867065,
-0.07415607571601868,
-0.2931203246116638,
0.05299556627869606,
0.17100317776203156,
-0.025175796821713448,
0.3508791923522949,
0.25814568996429443,
0.19923974573612213,
-0.23416472971439362,
-0.41005802154541016,
0.07288279384374619,
0.6969897150993347,
-0.22391065955162048,
-0.11413253843784332,
0.9088320136070251,
0.5717082023620605,
-0.22060400247573853,
0.6846495866775513,
0.11529608070850372,
-0.3929184675216675,
0.6153688430786133,
0.4635714888572693,
0.6105137467384338,
-0.13491709530353546,
0.06975862383842468,
0.05443723127245903,
0.6034541130065918,
0.1400241106748581,
0.32778462767601013,
-0.2408435344696045,
-0.4927501976490021,
-0.5929314494132996,
-0.5221611261367798,
-0.21224814653396606,
-0.09922518581151962,
-0.5081575512886047,
0.343351274728775,
-0.32570651173591614,
0.020691990852355957,
-0.07185496389865875,
-0.10232654958963394,
-0.7711204886436462,
0.16166016459465027,
0.2600891888141632,
0.7247331142425537,
-0.7419074773788452,
0.9355372190475464,
0.9269841909408569,
-0.44296348094940186,
-0.6319499611854553,
-0.20281027257442474,
0.17649821937084198,
-1.1539674997329712,
0.4879988133907318,
0.35311049222946167,
-0.1882576048374176,
0.08984749019145966,
-0.3740013837814331,
-0.6590632796287537,
0.8715421557426453,
0.545917272567749,
-0.7458081841468811,
0.19345532357692719,
0.3003963232040405,
0.5815733075141907,
-0.208456352353096,
0.26155948638916016,
0.14326894283294678,
0.6468715667724609,
-0.10071242600679398,
-1.0819042921066284,
-0.2565945088863373,
-0.7019058465957642,
0.04827529191970825,
0.13034014403820038,
-1.0143332481384277,
0.7014676928520203,
-0.1878504753112793,
0.10513480007648468,
-0.03730436787009239,
0.5134955048561096,
-0.011670580133795738,
0.16582101583480835,
0.29853615164756775,
0.4038708806037903,
0.9520263671875,
-0.010931413620710373,
0.9088127017021179,
-0.4786613881587982,
-0.021534617990255356,
0.7898352742195129,
0.0011772509897127748,
0.8611509799957275,
0.8148191571235657,
0.07120348513126373,
0.2646520137786865,
0.7556692361831665,
-0.24246472120285034,
0.5502439141273499,
-0.20448046922683716,
0.17690010368824005,
-0.3014034032821655,
0.050066929310560226,
-0.5550124645233154,
0.6407060623168945,
0.2817416489124298,
-0.28371188044548035,
0.03145410865545273,
0.425384521484375,
-0.4693349003791809,
0.04358367994427681,
-0.42607277631759644,
0.8383738994598389,
-0.23668643832206726,
-0.5827831029891968,
0.9094661474227905,
-0.07885756343603134,
0.9380638599395752,
-0.6325152516365051,
-0.05334041267633438,
-0.26821741461753845,
0.3812100887298584,
-0.17562483251094818,
-0.5679612755775452,
-0.027760235592722893,
-0.033726561814546585,
-0.22494779527187347,
-0.1871228963136673,
0.1524009257555008,
-0.7221192717552185,
-0.8456180691719055,
0.23100924491882324,
0.2552662491798401,
0.06371038407087326,
-0.031048454344272614,
-0.8029772639274597,
0.06339126080274582,
0.16509898006916046,
-0.10965356230735779,
0.3212421238422394,
0.81976318359375,
-0.41382503509521484,
0.7510598301887512,
0.6489460468292236,
0.08308543264865875,
0.3608991503715515,
0.28556177020072937,
0.6229365468025208,
-0.6059004664421082,
-0.6789348125457764,
-0.8204882740974426,
0.4472484886646271,
0.030746780335903168,
-0.4573585093021393,
0.9345223307609558,
0.5920259952545166,
0.9711018204689026,
-0.1532714068889618,
0.7558139562606812,
0.2868801951408386,
0.022266101092100143,
-0.6850425004959106,
0.6987866759300232,
-0.9974715113639832,
0.06422895193099976,
-0.3387918770313263,
-0.8130154013633728,
-0.3715246617794037,
0.5772136449813843,
-0.14038509130477905,
-0.1337757408618927,
0.5720389485359192,
0.8368187546730042,
-0.2883289158344269,
-0.06384345889091492,
0.37626418471336365,
-0.06253425031900406,
0.3864496946334839,
0.4876400828361511,
0.728962242603302,
-0.33516228199005127,
0.656410276889801,
-0.17383381724357605,
-0.13166604936122894,
-0.3478929102420807,
-0.8549347519874573,
-1.0571376085281372,
-0.4227963089942932,
-0.25380709767341614,
0.3700908422470093,
0.2805689573287964,
0.7374831438064575,
0.8462262153625488,
-0.785246729850769,
-0.0354786291718483,
-0.00773965660482645,
-0.027714401483535767,
-0.6587979197502136,
-0.20467683672904968,
0.32127243280410767,
-0.6805886030197144,
-0.8532798290252686,
0.536824643611908,
0.4952676296234131,
-0.05391747131943703,
-0.1813669502735138,
-0.2385861724615097,
-0.1511228233575821,
-0.16810652613639832,
0.6633275747299194,
0.13162942230701447,
-1.1149519681930542,
-0.2561422288417816,
-0.13569992780685425,
-0.06712507456541061,
0.14542962610721588,
0.49269023537635803,
-0.5945062041282654,
0.8882616758346558,
0.25450366735458374,
0.6744556427001953,
0.31957608461380005,
0.21958407759666443,
0.7458215951919556,
-1.0482385158538818,
0.6458710432052612,
-0.06438017636537552,
0.3297874331474304,
0.4137152135372162,
-0.3731222450733185,
0.3225025236606598,
0.039807673543691635,
-0.45526769757270813,
-0.5454353094100952,
-0.12849284708499908,
-0.9458217620849609,
-0.3047802448272705,
0.8763829469680786,
0.10761946439743042,
-0.27183815836906433,
-0.011744889430701733,
-0.6254100203514099,
0.1344933956861496,
-0.2991911768913269,
0.5226641893386841,
0.7279054522514343,
0.028561199083924294,
-0.41021886467933655,
-0.42890465259552,
0.2946026623249054,
0.5486374497413635,
-0.4501940608024597,
0.08217191696166992,
0.4703153371810913,
0.15184864401817322,
-0.07887426018714905,
0.44832539558410645,
0.021981367841362953,
0.39987894892692566,
-0.09257727116346359,
0.0712524950504303,
-0.5390424728393555,
-0.2361147105693817,
-0.26576489210128784,
0.03802104294300079,
-0.0473729707300663,
-0.4722003638744354
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.02537v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.02537v1
|
TopViewRS: Vision-Language Models as Top-View Spatial Reasoners
| 2024-06-04T17:55:43 | 2024-06-04T17:55:43 |
Chengzu Li, Caiqi Zhang, Han Zhou, Nigel Collier, Anna Korhonen, Ivan Vulić
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.LG
|
Top-view perspective denotes a typical way in which humans read and reason
over different types of maps, and it is vital for localization and navigation
of humans as well as of `non-human' agents, such as the ones backed by large
Vision-Language Models (VLMs). Nonetheless, spatial reasoning capabilities of
modern VLMs remain unattested and underexplored. In this work, we thus study
their capability to understand and reason over spatial relations from the top
view. The focus on top view also enables controlled evaluations at different
granularity of spatial reasoning; we clearly disentangle different abilities
(e.g., recognizing particular objects versus understanding their relative
positions). We introduce the TopViewRS (Top-View Reasoning in Space) dataset,
consisting of 11,384 multiple-choice questions with either realistic or
semantic top-view map as visual input. We then use it to study and evaluate
VLMs across 4 perception and reasoning tasks with different levels of
complexity. Evaluation of 10 representative open- and closed-source VLMs
reveals the gap of more than 50% compared to average human performance, and it
is even lower than the random baseline in some cases. Although additional
experiments show that Chain-of-Thought reasoning can boost model capabilities
by 5.82% on average, the overall performance of VLMs remains limited. Our
findings underscore the critical need for enhanced model capability in top-view
spatial reasoning and set a foundation for further research towards human-level
proficiency of VLMs in real-world multimodal tasks.
|
[
-0.7479243278503418,
-0.5184770226478577,
0.9587418437004089,
-0.014001374132931232,
-0.13616913557052612,
-0.219187930226326,
-0.1052323430776596,
-0.4678996503353119,
-0.167912557721138,
0.6365769505500793,
-0.22695639729499817,
-0.38711413741111755,
-0.7065313458442688,
-0.20475904643535614,
-0.27676916122436523,
0.5286762118339539,
0.011284299194812775,
-0.07813551276922226,
-0.581178605556488,
-0.17410212755203247,
-0.4141559302806854,
-0.8327536582946777,
0.040686774998903275,
-0.280468225479126,
0.6971853971481323,
0.17215105891227722,
0.7714416980743408,
0.3719896376132965,
0.5532388091087341,
0.4218665063381195,
-0.3407805263996124,
0.35453540086746216,
-0.4165903329849243,
-0.08308161050081253,
-0.624310314655304,
-0.44220587611198425,
-0.35024601221084595,
-0.035632237792015076,
0.20057478547096252,
0.8174700736999512,
-0.12520207464694977,
-0.05716883763670921,
-0.18589596450328827,
0.7966444492340088,
-0.7313348650932312,
0.1152244508266449,
-0.5031406283378601,
0.22263674437999725,
0.10897812247276306,
-0.1873445361852646,
-0.26617005467414856,
-0.1451222002506256,
0.47619083523750305,
-0.9401835799217224,
0.07721602916717529,
0.40310582518577576,
1.0211703777313232,
0.5439620614051819,
-0.35260722041130066,
0.16155396401882172,
-1.0188722610473633,
0.8995894193649292,
-0.2451750785112381,
0.8300576210021973,
0.6657941341400146,
0.6095781326293945,
0.23934702575206757,
-0.22212396562099457,
-0.41426992416381836,
-0.30807971954345703,
-0.3102053105831146,
0.1512163281440735,
-0.3398226797580719,
-0.11487425118684769,
0.5574026703834534,
0.22163709998130798,
-0.6816630363464355,
-0.23490393161773682,
-0.42341840267181396,
-0.05873296782374382,
0.349019855260849,
0.13867835700511932,
0.14059686660766602,
0.0017229322111234069,
-0.48613592982292175,
0.10864941775798798,
-0.4356379806995392,
-0.13669340312480927,
-0.3544238805770874,
-0.1814679354429245,
-0.05570095032453537,
0.7281522750854492,
-0.41530269384384155,
0.9344696402549744,
0.06610345095396042,
0.16572272777557373,
-0.12723924219608307,
-0.5583394169807434,
-0.4942739009857178,
-0.6943008899688721,
0.0951773151755333,
0.5847072005271912,
0.7158025503158569,
-0.26962515711784363,
0.0012511475943028927,
0.16311421990394592,
0.4620859622955322,
-0.3835308849811554,
-0.2503564953804016,
0.22239874303340912,
-0.4526917636394501,
-0.046065110713243484,
-0.19482116401195526,
-0.5027332305908203,
-0.710354208946228,
-0.6560409069061279,
0.4797782003879547,
-0.268222451210022,
-0.4554295241832733,
0.3099724352359772,
-0.283345490694046,
0.569388747215271,
0.7862697243690491,
-0.5470396280288696,
0.27735453844070435,
0.5665875673294067,
0.6264217495918274,
0.014263086020946503,
-0.5873326659202576,
-0.019467618316411972,
0.12147628515958786,
-0.5139189958572388,
1.1144598722457886,
-0.4184516668319702,
-0.15883225202560425,
-0.4663040041923523,
-0.27032727003097534,
-0.3069433569908142,
-0.6299302577972412,
0.20151114463806152,
-0.22829698026180267,
0.493511825799942,
-0.8302822709083557,
-0.09236015379428864,
-0.19590513408184052,
0.8440530896186829,
-0.5013852715492249,
0.9173628091812134,
0.07244326919317245,
-0.6727887392044067,
0.7404789328575134,
-0.5219987630844116,
-0.007441987749189138,
0.1726614087820053,
-0.32453620433807373,
0.10513710975646973,
0.24798250198364258,
0.6959014534950256,
0.05891179293394089,
-0.26982581615448,
0.18536393344402313,
-0.08007468283176422,
-0.030230512842535973,
0.24868646264076233,
-0.15617863833904266,
0.5007522106170654,
0.24241727590560913,
-0.14365248382091522,
0.5328072905540466,
-0.6113154888153076,
0.08560841530561447,
0.20141778886318207,
-0.17991594970226288,
-0.6721485257148743,
0.49986252188682556,
-0.038531433790922165,
0.44593748450279236,
0.16109560430049896,
-0.5616711378097534,
0.2049657702445984,
-0.24654895067214966,
0.15812988579273224,
0.49035775661468506,
-0.27897733449935913,
0.3545275926589966,
-0.2796677350997925,
0.17142543196678162,
0.37805822491645813,
0.4144617021083832,
-0.011668945662677288,
-0.5482122898101807,
-0.9170902371406555,
-0.05190078541636467,
-0.32128557562828064,
0.8531912565231323,
-0.9158520698547363,
0.07049593329429626,
-0.20474080741405487,
-0.5706276297569275,
-0.009140177629888058,
-0.09610234200954437,
0.5346808433532715,
0.43971383571624756,
0.4210461974143982,
-0.15530739724636078,
-0.5227362513542175,
-0.6185297966003418,
-0.19539345800876617,
-0.19038544595241547,
0.012769825756549835,
0.5720735788345337,
0.5620865225791931,
-0.04252652823925018,
0.8564151525497437,
-0.4065837562084198,
-0.21889139711856842,
-0.6524118185043335,
-0.48897019028663635,
0.0075826337561011314,
0.20801302790641785,
0.8763642907142639,
-0.9061798453330994,
0.058943621814250946,
0.187813401222229,
-1.1159143447875977,
-0.11212527006864548,
-0.03951750323176384,
-0.5895333290100098,
-0.006654967088252306,
0.3445117473602295,
-0.7994132041931152,
0.5863670706748962,
0.19046898186206818,
-0.8536909222602844,
0.3357599675655365,
-0.5145056247711182,
0.098844513297081,
-0.5546548962593079,
-0.04208395257592201,
0.3939671814441681,
0.04119596257805824,
-0.7536991238594055,
0.4019959568977356,
-0.3598003685474396,
-0.014874767512083054,
-0.4223800599575043,
0.6161235570907593,
-0.4728200435638428,
-0.5317209959030151,
-0.05343536287546158,
0.2920131981372833,
0.021970050409436226,
0.551743745803833,
0.4080196022987366,
0.49157002568244934,
0.6515869498252869,
-0.5807332396507263,
0.1752241849899292,
0.28208082914352417,
-0.479510098695755,
0.6152116060256958,
-0.6037229299545288,
-0.11792141944169998,
-0.2854010760784149,
-0.012146422639489174,
-1.170117974281311,
-0.3064577579498291,
0.05742507800459862,
-0.2994140386581421,
-0.27076321840286255,
-0.09292900562286377,
-0.2856403887271881,
-0.43315786123275757,
0.28686410188674927,
0.4067625403404236,
0.23431260883808136,
-0.4665464758872986,
0.6743152141571045,
0.5059396028518677,
0.14443553984165192,
-0.36094024777412415,
-0.7360866665840149,
0.1388024538755417,
-0.03239782899618149,
-0.6826584935188293,
-0.1133439764380455,
0.08509271591901779,
-0.6020430326461792,
-0.06987487524747849,
-0.1296950727701187,
-0.10014238953590393,
-0.04931573197245598,
0.22239531576633453,
0.19328254461288452,
-0.22978879511356354,
-0.25393015146255493,
-0.3689151108264923,
-0.36534741520881653,
-0.11818141490221024,
-0.5549521446228027,
0.30553582310676575,
-0.5324382781982422,
-0.5643509030342102,
-0.14588630199432373,
0.35729071497917175,
0.9366264343261719,
-0.5033861398696899,
0.7154769897460938,
0.12553082406520844,
-0.608687698841095,
0.221647709608078,
-0.5529254674911499,
0.1351781040430069,
-0.3848142921924591,
0.20840810239315033,
-0.41050633788108826,
-0.7129390835762024,
0.4426112771034241,
0.017002655193209648,
0.04252594709396362,
0.08351268619298935,
0.6166897416114807,
-0.20678450167179108,
1.026365041732788,
0.43397194147109985,
0.12299216538667679,
0.23193298280239105,
-0.34420540928840637,
0.35090330243110657,
-0.5645300149917603,
-0.616860032081604,
-0.3309725522994995,
-0.325179785490036,
-0.2864060401916504,
-0.7427656054496765,
0.4746221899986267,
-0.009946542792022228,
-0.2513291537761688,
0.1780804991722107,
-0.5184161067008972,
0.6606055498123169,
0.4015236496925354,
-0.05798329785466194,
0.1426744908094406,
0.045164141803979874,
-0.5665373206138611,
-0.15642420947551727,
-0.5690642595291138,
-0.3335694670677185,
0.44572553038597107,
0.28105628490448,
0.7712171673774719,
0.14289000630378723,
0.1396722048521042,
0.1246982216835022,
-0.07169660180807114,
-0.733542799949646,
0.9026309251785278,
-0.19189275801181793,
-0.5337607860565186,
-0.2657237648963928,
-0.15612758696079254,
-0.5862159132957458,
1.0935795307159424,
-0.1704467236995697,
-0.8298424482345581,
0.36405250430107117,
0.4759052097797394,
-0.2762644588947296,
0.5214406251907349,
-0.5650523900985718,
0.9162530899047852,
-0.5614745020866394,
-0.39099904894828796,
0.021470269188284874,
-0.5020986795425415,
0.07048789411783218,
0.5583903193473816,
0.40556734800338745,
0.23967915773391724,
0.12782229483127594,
0.15139272809028625,
-0.4045492112636566,
0.6436781287193298,
-0.5542770624160767,
-0.1265072375535965,
0.12075726687908173,
0.21137474477291107,
-0.12211134284734726,
-0.5220462083816528,
0.31503379344940186,
0.4622311294078827,
-0.13341347873210907,
-0.36158105731010437,
-0.5078352093696594,
0.22325453162193298,
-0.7259015440940857,
-0.7773072719573975,
-0.45216670632362366,
-0.5717093348503113,
-0.15467366576194763,
0.213674858212471,
0.3511006534099579,
0.424929678440094,
0.11654273420572281,
-0.04413964971899986,
0.7116679549217224,
-0.27530601620674133,
0.025404104962944984,
0.15626160800457,
-0.8072212934494019,
-0.24376538395881653,
0.872420072555542,
0.04916943982243538,
0.15980049967765808,
0.6009371876716614,
0.30955520272254944,
-0.18628506362438202,
-0.7510746121406555,
-0.7272266745567322,
0.13022129237651825,
-0.5836433172225952,
0.2848220765590668,
-0.45447343587875366,
-0.3049774765968323,
0.10052867978811264,
-0.31141170859336853,
-0.33981284499168396,
-0.6035163402557373,
0.2753369212150574,
-0.2941807210445404,
-0.19181104004383087,
0.7710294127464294,
-0.05059663578867912,
0.08351068943738937,
-0.4516628682613373,
0.5239828824996948,
0.23892837762832642,
0.25786349177360535,
-0.028270665556192398,
-0.16045205295085907,
-0.25212448835372925,
-0.16774454712867737,
-0.10349895060062408,
-0.6835302114486694,
0.38586390018463135,
-0.28135842084884644,
0.8137093782424927,
0.3453707695007324,
-0.39906445145606995,
0.6956808567047119,
-0.32509204745292664,
0.9438471794128418,
-0.19392865896224976,
-0.7519343495368958,
0.8183018565177917,
-0.37845200300216675,
0.5106834173202515,
0.003862821264192462,
0.19006387889385223,
-0.3548879623413086,
-0.4867742359638214,
0.11788918077945709,
-0.5943435430526733,
0.546833872795105,
0.4324338436126709,
-0.44465628266334534,
0.14047937095165253,
0.18150685727596283,
-0.043896276503801346,
-0.0177242960780859,
-0.5704818964004517,
0.03724114969372749,
-0.5157727003097534,
0.23088549077510834,
0.05402453988790512,
-0.06117325648665428,
-0.0971808210015297,
-0.468193918466568,
0.037763819098472595,
-0.015159913338720798,
0.5502599477767944,
0.455630898475647,
-0.32138165831565857,
-0.2995601296424866,
0.48817363381385803,
0.9040634632110596,
1.088836669921875,
-0.037117552012205124,
0.2082185596227646,
0.12475306540727615,
-0.31945550441741943,
-0.0820496454834938,
-0.13356967270374298,
-0.33653613924980164,
-0.36421024799346924,
0.49497896432876587,
1.0015699863433838,
0.33124059438705444,
-0.3914099931716919,
0.41269615292549133,
-0.08417996764183044,
-0.318459689617157,
-0.25042733550071716,
0.1194685846567154,
-0.0739888995885849,
0.5186628103256226,
0.31527239084243774,
0.4395607113838196,
-0.02759118564426899,
-0.3258419334888458,
0.0020188544876873493,
0.38840314745903015,
-0.2523692846298218,
-0.27110323309898376,
0.7648945450782776,
-0.03147121146321297,
0.04077473655343056,
0.4101927876472473,
0.01656634360551834,
-0.8917407989501953,
0.679206132888794,
0.25064441561698914,
0.6246218085289001,
0.001947965589351952,
0.09335532039403915,
0.4428563416004181,
0.5810695290565491,
0.10700807720422745,
0.6250571608543396,
-0.30113887786865234,
-0.9820904731750488,
-0.515938401222229,
-0.4353148937225342,
-0.5662416219711304,
-0.0009161054622381926,
-0.6245936751365662,
-0.369182825088501,
-0.48045268654823303,
-0.27086421847343445,
-0.11587526649236679,
-0.4024052321910858,
-0.7026348114013672,
0.2717837393283844,
0.6228708624839783,
0.9816501140594482,
-0.5861957669258118,
0.6072010397911072,
1.0681517124176025,
-0.2509075701236725,
-0.2164507359266281,
-0.026027893647551537,
0.1389234960079193,
-0.5701165199279785,
0.7665603160858154,
0.04434146359562874,
-0.43961814045906067,
-0.37792351841926575,
-0.6033160090446472,
-1.0008845329284668,
0.8595182299613953,
0.09090432524681091,
-0.5789567828178406,
-0.5887375473976135,
0.1673945039510727,
0.8339589238166809,
-0.2768775224685669,
0.3618241846561432,
0.33528566360473633,
0.468008428812027,
0.22454199194908142,
-1.1862798929214478,
-0.15935789048671722,
-0.29202163219451904,
0.19070184230804443,
0.2667050063610077,
-0.6345301866531372,
0.7699939608573914,
-0.7748972773551941,
-0.0002297398605151102,
0.021822351962327957,
0.4429449141025543,
0.5911558866500854,
0.5392449498176575,
0.62332683801651,
0.6868070363998413,
0.4595676362514496,
-0.32086047530174255,
1.171411395072937,
0.03458995744585991,
0.2665536403656006,
0.7966873645782471,
-0.42987343668937683,
0.83845454454422,
0.45343509316444397,
-0.05532548949122429,
0.6855634450912476,
0.20585103332996368,
0.18035821616649628,
0.7734245657920837,
-0.038246914744377136,
0.2522444725036621,
-0.8649097681045532,
0.2035161405801773,
-0.06875240057706833,
0.6626092791557312,
0.6902638077735901,
-0.07700204104185104,
-0.42082881927490234,
0.17729341983795166,
-0.4126390516757965,
0.15776154398918152,
-0.4954237639904022,
0.6658622026443481,
-0.0006875387043692172,
-0.7854266166687012,
0.3538285791873932,
-0.30297717452049255,
0.23437152802944183,
-0.3157753348350525,
-0.0004902280052192509,
-0.1257832944393158,
0.4808747470378876,
-0.1588803231716156,
-1.045310616493225,
0.3712906837463379,
0.18895845115184784,
-0.1700548380613327,
-0.4164336919784546,
0.97811359167099,
-0.19133524596691132,
-0.2754237651824951,
0.45557141304016113,
0.9812523126602173,
0.21225664019584656,
0.028962114825844765,
-0.45560652017593384,
0.016931304708123207,
-0.1717674285173416,
-0.28364965319633484,
0.2246200442314148,
0.37933745980262756,
-0.4126589298248291,
0.9023723602294922,
0.5384134650230408,
0.20962034165859222,
0.36788058280944824,
0.2162093222141266,
0.8009445667266846,
-0.9766066074371338,
-0.5448045134544373,
-0.6932622790336609,
0.5929568409919739,
-0.036343131214380264,
-0.33147454261779785,
0.3988949954509735,
0.5240705609321594,
1.0907925367355347,
-0.19053137302398682,
0.763609766960144,
-0.059169791638851166,
0.5600861310958862,
-0.5293116569519043,
0.6704979538917542,
-0.6921910047531128,
0.1205352321267128,
-0.2324134111404419,
-0.6485718488693237,
-0.3363540768623352,
1.0572283267974854,
-0.7361246943473816,
0.17844127118587494,
0.5678218603134155,
0.3856125473976135,
-0.21061460673809052,
-0.07039479166269302,
0.7652958631515503,
0.25468769669532776,
0.2560645639896393,
0.959031343460083,
1.2063875198364258,
-0.0514003224670887,
0.45371392369270325,
-0.26556500792503357,
-0.25413978099823,
0.009195918217301369,
-0.6886767745018005,
-1.0226184129714966,
-0.5977503061294556,
-0.09239757806062698,
0.1056244969367981,
-0.06826137006282806,
0.5379995703697205,
0.8000108599662781,
-0.564953625202179,
-0.12648168206214905,
-0.20466965436935425,
0.10016585886478424,
-0.22901418805122375,
-0.17271853983402252,
-0.0381876565515995,
0.21755866706371307,
-0.26953360438346863,
0.31737688183784485,
0.519769012928009,
-0.15211626887321472,
-0.416446328163147,
-0.14162743091583252,
-0.04033278301358223,
0.23515214025974274,
1.0850824117660522,
0.20020678639411926,
-1.2775088548660278,
-0.4439861476421356,
0.13347530364990234,
-0.13703791797161102,
0.11504622548818588,
0.8483376502990723,
-1.0388935804367065,
0.4566132724285126,
0.6048333644866943,
0.29369279742240906,
0.5248642563819885,
0.15037328004837036,
0.2454688400030136,
-0.42316725850105286,
0.042808085680007935,
-0.20304161310195923,
0.6469382047653198,
0.4584916830062866,
-0.1603037565946579,
0.5211753845214844,
0.3983789384365082,
-0.6284406781196594,
-0.428691029548645,
0.29770132899284363,
-1.1266387701034546,
-0.16283336281776428,
1.084875464439392,
-0.10340568423271179,
-0.10730349272489548,
-0.13081683218479156,
-0.6091869473457336,
-0.10580799728631973,
0.038597412407398224,
0.5136137008666992,
0.8417125344276428,
-0.5876224637031555,
-0.5924718976020813,
-0.5630780458450317,
0.1780262440443039,
0.2218070924282074,
-1.1532726287841797,
0.08825180679559708,
0.9330804347991943,
0.20507650077342987,
0.5045140981674194,
0.6425375938415527,
-0.04064785689115524,
0.3951434791088104,
0.08204454183578491,
-0.40597543120384216,
-0.20448006689548492,
-0.8064790964126587,
0.020525189116597176,
0.32457825541496277,
-0.039034824818372726,
-0.1646338850259781
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.02536v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.02536v1
|
Mitigate Position Bias in Large Language Models via Scaling a Single Dimension
| 2024-06-04T17:55:38 | 2024-06-04T17:55:38 |
Yijiong Yu, Huiqiang Jiang, Xufang Luo, Qianhui Wu, Chin-Yew Lin, Dongsheng Li, Yuqing Yang, Yongfeng Huang, Lili Qiu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) are increasingly applied in various real-world
scenarios due to their excellent generalization capabilities and robust
generative abilities. However, they exhibit position bias, also known as "lost
in the middle", a phenomenon that is especially pronounced in long-context
scenarios, which indicates the placement of the key information in different
positions of a prompt can significantly affect accuracy. This paper first
explores the micro-level manifestations of position bias, concluding that
attention weights are a micro-level expression of position bias. It further
identifies that, in addition to position embeddings, causal attention mask also
contributes to position bias by creating position-specific hidden states. Based
on these insights, we propose a method to mitigate position bias by scaling
this positional hidden states. Experiments on the NaturalQuestions
Multi-document QA, KV retrieval, LongBench and timeline reorder tasks, using
various models including RoPE models, context windowextended models, and Alibi
models, demonstrate the effectiveness and generalizability of our approach. Our
method can improve performance by up to 15.2% by modifying just one dimension
of hidden states. Our code is available at https://aka.ms/PositionalHidden.
|
[
-0.28993120789527893,
-0.6781744956970215,
0.6841980814933777,
0.37846502661705017,
-0.10895756632089615,
-0.17716045677661896,
-0.15525846183300018,
-0.06930254399776459,
0.35018718242645264,
0.5711489319801331,
-0.6553184390068054,
-0.5402446389198303,
-0.6479986906051636,
-0.32458001375198364,
-0.2897699773311615,
0.6900290250778198,
-0.06602396816015244,
-0.008345340378582478,
-0.42305755615234375,
-0.29111093282699585,
-0.4847595691680908,
-0.6895226240158081,
-0.6983829736709595,
-0.17762550711631775,
0.6423194408416748,
0.5134968161582947,
0.6197264194488525,
0.6012560129165649,
0.31812307238578796,
0.1962631195783615,
-0.2820879817008972,
-0.03809378296136856,
-0.5676044225692749,
0.17122012376785278,
-0.2600572407245636,
-0.6994343400001526,
-0.47444266080856323,
0.05131223052740097,
1.1660943031311035,
0.8132932186126709,
-0.16099518537521362,
0.25739288330078125,
0.14693614840507507,
0.8086695075035095,
-0.7338492274284363,
0.03974204137921333,
-0.4112633764743805,
0.11609435081481934,
-0.2878834009170532,
-0.13464303314685822,
-0.4753726124763489,
-0.33048364520072937,
0.14372271299362183,
-0.421813428401947,
0.4754329323768616,
-0.00132568902336061,
0.6864390969276428,
0.553425133228302,
-0.6953938603401184,
0.1672789603471756,
-0.7845059633255005,
0.9031034111976624,
-0.8845188617706299,
0.4502033293247223,
0.3628080487251282,
0.1935291886329651,
-0.2083045244216919,
-0.1951252669095993,
-0.40292486548423767,
0.017376940697431564,
-0.025696072727441788,
-0.05218916013836861,
-0.1206837072968483,
0.054290298372507095,
0.5676323771476746,
0.006608411204069853,
-0.32618027925491333,
0.3933130204677582,
0.10428082942962646,
-0.19123098254203796,
0.3762322962284088,
0.11675447970628738,
0.24601393938064575,
0.14861313998699188,
-0.15655699372291565,
-0.21777664124965668,
-1.036458134651184,
0.2742621600627899,
0.47230401635169983,
0.4482074975967407,
-0.011363660916686058,
0.49094507098197937,
-0.11687745153903961,
0.5773529410362244,
0.39009663462638855,
-0.14159971475601196,
0.0013925591483712196,
-0.3011680841445923,
-0.15720899403095245,
0.09746603667736053,
0.38485053181648254,
0.21179711818695068,
-0.1764461249113083,
0.10281943529844284,
-0.12039391696453094,
-0.13601763546466827,
0.3566235303878784,
-0.8111974596977234,
0.1262875646352768,
0.13411442935466766,
-0.41104674339294434,
-0.10183993726968765,
-0.2098735123872757,
-0.6040930151939392,
-0.6291707158088684,
-0.2045760601758957,
0.21712544560432434,
-0.03752553462982178,
-0.05476967245340347,
-0.006309713702648878,
0.2618800401687622,
0.25829875469207764,
0.218070849776268,
-0.9140013456344604,
0.18437916040420532,
0.5583335161209106,
0.7391282916069031,
-0.029833078384399414,
-0.14606399834156036,
-0.6033629775047302,
0.23884199559688568,
-0.37034133076667786,
0.5859438180923462,
-0.5261844396591187,
-0.12434399873018265,
0.04680575802922249,
-0.043707530945539474,
-0.04695194587111473,
-0.5467339158058167,
0.6349448561668396,
-0.6865768432617188,
0.3093564808368683,
-0.4557924270629883,
-0.4434394836425781,
-0.03114255703985691,
0.32210177183151245,
-0.8069401979446411,
0.9207341074943542,
-0.2107113003730774,
-0.8735636472702026,
0.2698719799518585,
-0.3858911395072937,
-0.46503496170043945,
-0.5581691861152649,
-0.09676173329353333,
-0.6110225319862366,
0.1567523330450058,
0.6291083693504333,
0.38348719477653503,
-0.08497492969036102,
0.005746710114181042,
-0.2918808162212372,
-0.3841135501861572,
0.2673170864582062,
-0.43525704741477966,
0.536149799823761,
-0.25455495715141296,
-0.39211010932922363,
0.16484902799129486,
-0.6256561875343323,
-0.07465679198503494,
0.021323204040527344,
-0.4965211749076843,
-0.7011418342590332,
0.15101732313632965,
-0.1494344174861908,
0.3991268575191498,
0.21852406859397888,
-0.4946136474609375,
0.32107582688331604,
-0.5289111733436584,
0.16124559938907623,
0.7412858605384827,
0.1368778795003891,
0.9879443049430847,
0.07698804885149002,
0.6802489161491394,
0.25706788897514343,
0.23852166533470154,
-0.019050104543566704,
-0.12603938579559326,
-0.6568067669868469,
-0.2037753164768219,
0.2906860411167145,
0.38362348079681396,
-0.6109020113945007,
0.42565906047821045,
-0.3270251750946045,
-0.16534994542598724,
-0.6858111023902893,
-0.04585888981819153,
0.2888264060020447,
0.5117314457893372,
0.1300051361322403,
-0.14116142690181732,
-0.09334710240364075,
-1.1334203481674194,
-0.3971501290798187,
0.12264900654554367,
-0.27282458543777466,
-0.08663465082645416,
0.059771813452243805,
-0.1247146725654602,
0.8923389315605164,
-0.5568749308586121,
-0.5254982113838196,
-0.11678881198167801,
-0.12694115936756134,
0.3594074547290802,
0.4344557821750641,
0.20555219054222107,
-0.8008148074150085,
-0.21692849695682526,
-0.46095776557922363,
-0.4595978558063507,
-0.19197994470596313,
-0.22876760363578796,
-0.06810919940471649,
0.29725754261016846,
0.6105474233627319,
-0.7791396975517273,
0.47239431738853455,
0.5984740853309631,
-0.4117000102996826,
0.3538490831851959,
-0.23779720067977905,
-0.15850971639156342,
-1.0506738424301147,
0.011478273198008537,
0.17540165781974792,
-0.12291174381971359,
-0.6448497772216797,
0.13697852194309235,
0.45246508717536926,
-0.09015664458274841,
-0.21996012330055237,
0.5156770944595337,
-0.7364401817321777,
-0.11264695227146149,
-0.3436623811721802,
0.45143526792526245,
0.15437430143356323,
0.6002482771873474,
-0.278678297996521,
0.6211939454078674,
0.38748982548713684,
-0.4702832102775574,
-0.12946829199790955,
-0.07742003351449966,
-0.2922438085079193,
0.5610378384590149,
-0.4649200141429901,
0.1787153035402298,
-0.32760757207870483,
0.6138070225715637,
-1.041055679321289,
0.09575352072715759,
0.0715855285525322,
-0.28789886832237244,
0.6870909929275513,
-0.34340783953666687,
-0.6152114868164062,
-0.3321593999862671,
-0.4527002274990082,
0.4881885051727295,
0.029862890020012856,
-0.30375009775161743,
0.3204745948314667,
0.5180279612541199,
-0.31841742992401123,
-0.9030347466468811,
-0.5533736348152161,
-0.10306180268526077,
-0.18494100868701935,
-0.4564209282398224,
0.366929829120636,
-0.015235597267746925,
-0.022253267467021942,
-0.20408649742603302,
-0.5615049600601196,
0.18399299681186676,
0.02605414390563965,
0.23429539799690247,
0.0510476715862751,
-0.07907987385988235,
0.4301033616065979,
0.2370854616165161,
-0.2042948454618454,
0.14378194510936737,
-0.5489012002944946,
0.5196323990821838,
-0.041600294411182404,
-0.5704896450042725,
-0.21992596983909607,
0.4653470814228058,
0.8374180197715759,
-0.28327155113220215,
0.7892851233482361,
0.5261339545249939,
-0.41306743025779724,
-0.24343974888324738,
-0.6176701784133911,
-0.28081226348876953,
-0.4199204742908478,
0.5018745064735413,
-0.11383910477161407,
-0.9436873197555542,
0.7312293648719788,
0.003194998949766159,
-0.012706751003861427,
0.24687111377716064,
0.5187968611717224,
0.03485487774014473,
1.3743882179260254,
0.9822834730148315,
-0.554505467414856,
0.686043381690979,
-0.1477813571691513,
0.6231269240379333,
-1.1140466928482056,
-0.003646252444013953,
-0.5238828659057617,
-0.6751233339309692,
-0.5431857109069824,
-0.6036885380744934,
0.7274370789527893,
0.07795843482017517,
-0.2390342652797699,
-0.08937831223011017,
-0.3096364736557007,
0.5628747940063477,
0.7410913109779358,
0.2114187777042389,
0.06255955994129181,
-0.01034938357770443,
-0.39696651697158813,
-0.18829721212387085,
-0.91962069272995,
-0.435319185256958,
0.8489324450492859,
0.588259220123291,
0.889238178730011,
0.1467955857515335,
0.541081964969635,
-0.0023821876384317875,
0.03981032222509384,
-0.8026993274688721,
0.49815455079078674,
0.059083614498376846,
-0.5800341963768005,
-0.7799893617630005,
-0.3435715138912201,
-0.8842475414276123,
0.45915067195892334,
0.045795802026987076,
-0.7104665637016296,
0.26483094692230225,
0.047856103628873825,
-0.6045559048652649,
0.42240646481513977,
-0.653715193271637,
0.7699126601219177,
0.03216755762696266,
-0.6300938129425049,
-0.24536344408988953,
-0.7408788204193115,
0.14817455410957336,
0.0342140831053257,
0.22896914184093475,
-0.14829722046852112,
-0.012442351318895817,
0.6822285652160645,
-0.36365577578544617,
1.0893062353134155,
-0.4523719251155853,
-0.3794883191585541,
0.02438274957239628,
0.17747186124324799,
0.8667349219322205,
0.06229504197835922,
0.022332483902573586,
-0.020231682807207108,
-0.2043098360300064,
-0.7272675037384033,
-0.6480122208595276,
0.925597608089447,
-0.6829304695129395,
-0.7391923069953918,
-0.22011975944042206,
-0.7888562083244324,
-0.3931334316730499,
0.3220268487930298,
0.2072969377040863,
0.3850047290325165,
-0.027097711339592934,
-0.04035701975226402,
1.1487995386123657,
-0.3930889070034027,
0.44452551007270813,
0.5402788519859314,
-0.024266311898827553,
0.06753156334161758,
0.49148815870285034,
0.3736199736595154,
0.07521916925907135,
0.6898698210716248,
0.23664450645446777,
-0.3454933762550354,
-0.3451443612575531,
-0.27148860692977905,
0.44229331612586975,
-0.752857506275177,
-0.18326787650585175,
-0.5933986306190491,
0.030775537714362144,
-0.5931382179260254,
-0.13759954273700714,
-0.5537406206130981,
-0.43864262104034424,
-0.28466957807540894,
-0.2175370454788208,
-0.1440955400466919,
0.38190558552742004,
0.18423782289028168,
0.3802986145019531,
-0.6468282341957092,
0.12771421670913696,
0.26158133149147034,
0.5126025676727295,
0.22881700098514557,
-0.6549618244171143,
-0.44705480337142944,
0.01585777848958969,
-0.19267098605632782,
-0.6296972036361694,
0.407810240983963,
-0.2353733479976654,
0.6397066116333008,
0.42670193314552307,
0.0714159905910492,
0.4504494071006775,
-0.5475326180458069,
0.6666860580444336,
0.09820695966482162,
-0.8195104002952576,
0.5182573199272156,
-0.4165535569190979,
0.9695384502410889,
0.333076536655426,
0.25160178542137146,
-0.6068002581596375,
-0.40172818303108215,
-0.44545987248420715,
-0.9839100241661072,
0.6571233868598938,
-0.08711019903421402,
-0.025614188984036446,
0.20791611075401306,
0.22153128683567047,
-0.2316276580095291,
0.14817066490650177,
-0.7544131875038147,
-0.22300653159618378,
0.2882188856601715,
-0.15780414640903473,
-0.02911108173429966,
-0.561578094959259,
-0.14469856023788452,
-0.0841001644730568,
0.5910003781318665,
-0.11101090908050537,
0.26580682396888733,
0.21942771971225739,
-0.1334763616323471,
-0.2811683118343353,
0.4405701458454132,
0.7940370440483093,
0.707477867603302,
-0.17266303300857544,
0.34072789549827576,
0.03287216275930405,
-0.4074065685272217,
0.2246055006980896,
0.08580988645553589,
-0.3948047459125519,
-0.07071623206138611,
0.3314575254917145,
0.6159059405326843,
0.4895927608013153,
-0.18908537924289703,
0.5655940771102905,
0.15084043145179749,
0.39510589838027954,
-0.1923067420721054,
-0.41299885511398315,
0.1985778659582138,
0.4005338251590729,
0.42574343085289,
-0.03270707279443741,
0.03770126402378082,
-0.43103793263435364,
-0.004624676890671253,
0.32173389196395874,
-0.4695151746273041,
-0.234017014503479,
0.6932315826416016,
0.07961257547140121,
-0.047488849610090256,
0.6337499022483826,
0.059989359229803085,
-0.5791525840759277,
0.531952977180481,
0.5880418419837952,
0.8648712635040283,
-0.48718759417533875,
0.16338829696178436,
0.26396629214286804,
0.6199014782905579,
-0.16240030527114868,
-0.05368977040052414,
0.1527518928050995,
-0.6692861914634705,
-0.36780253052711487,
-0.398685485124588,
-0.19889342784881592,
-0.1011107861995697,
-0.6146174073219299,
0.015444502234458923,
-0.3565106987953186,
-0.3429718613624573,
-0.1526264250278473,
0.09551694989204407,
-0.6664677262306213,
-0.09546040743589401,
0.25144073367118835,
0.8631937503814697,
-0.7969515919685364,
1.0201548337936401,
0.6907727718353271,
-0.19982200860977173,
-0.6478013396263123,
0.3111329972743988,
0.09655170142650604,
-0.5458311438560486,
0.5196234583854675,
0.11250336468219757,
-0.2123684287071228,
-0.1706009805202484,
-0.6259263157844543,
-1.2888586521148682,
1.061543345451355,
0.2982965111732483,
-0.7220420837402344,
-0.18298952281475067,
0.07624658942222595,
0.5588454008102417,
-0.17522840201854706,
-0.07937999069690704,
0.4543232023715973,
0.23638132214546204,
-0.2409188151359558,
-0.7671169638633728,
0.3050500750541687,
0.08484169095754623,
0.20286251604557037,
0.43650907278060913,
-0.8128302097320557,
0.7683846354484558,
-0.23553353548049927,
-0.25902363657951355,
-0.36044633388519287,
0.46777793765068054,
0.266390323638916,
0.30225780606269836,
0.4420643448829651,
0.5954611897468567,
0.8990257382392883,
0.12166491150856018,
1.1161729097366333,
-0.07022635638713837,
0.37680575251579285,
1.2355626821517944,
-0.4695809483528137,
0.7927551865577698,
0.7047033309936523,
0.018747597932815552,
0.31976184248924255,
0.5081392526626587,
0.38935455679893494,
0.6382803916931152,
0.3818560242652893,
-0.20845745503902435,
-0.131564661860466,
-0.011644214391708374,
-0.11290048807859421,
0.05516401305794716,
0.42355775833129883,
-0.26227155327796936,
-0.14880511164665222,
0.1244979053735733,
0.24779130518436432,
0.09098845720291138,
-0.5019163489341736,
0.3950757086277008,
0.10227733105421066,
-0.5629676580429077,
0.4829064905643463,
0.14312253892421722,
0.6082295179367065,
-0.5035938024520874,
0.061757948249578476,
-0.723610520362854,
0.3210418224334717,
0.07180371880531311,
-0.6547499299049377,
0.06782358884811401,
-0.3157159090042114,
-0.7217954397201538,
-0.3307214081287384,
0.7620774507522583,
-0.5823240876197815,
-0.442865788936615,
0.28758862614631653,
0.2559402585029602,
-0.22429455816745758,
-0.4863464832305908,
-0.39495664834976196,
0.019961798563599586,
-0.14620375633239746,
-0.36097803711891174,
0.5250868797302246,
0.4829496443271637,
-0.5052204728126526,
0.8207674026489258,
0.3962577283382416,
0.08127446472644806,
0.1970970630645752,
0.1913817971944809,
0.7512466907501221,
-0.6346089243888855,
-0.6660210490226746,
-0.7284354567527771,
0.16976991295814514,
-0.20673325657844543,
0.10384199023246765,
0.9757373929023743,
0.3422095775604248,
0.8292549252510071,
-0.17372772097587585,
0.4209410548210144,
0.431450217962265,
0.677733838558197,
-0.4530843496322632,
0.9119606614112854,
-0.360385000705719,
0.41484659910202026,
-0.2893652617931366,
-1.0392825603485107,
-0.5587499141693115,
0.26916056871414185,
-0.4920455515384674,
-0.1461789309978485,
0.6470642685890198,
0.8223610520362854,
-0.09051897376775742,
-0.6160444021224976,
0.4690445065498352,
0.4519887864589691,
0.3524876534938812,
0.6485533118247986,
0.6215553879737854,
-0.40528854727745056,
0.2972082793712616,
-0.16300204396247864,
-0.24141182005405426,
-0.3942919373512268,
-0.6929738521575928,
-0.6601449847221375,
-0.4482925236225128,
-0.30458253622055054,
-0.17521026730537415,
-0.1907852292060852,
0.628316342830658,
0.7599557042121887,
-0.6552132964134216,
-0.11295512318611145,
0.38927915692329407,
0.5786054134368896,
-0.2675076127052307,
-0.23238471150398254,
0.6711270809173584,
-0.1775129735469818,
-0.7062714099884033,
0.3847632110118866,
0.3984229266643524,
-0.06995585560798645,
-0.35472339391708374,
0.28879326581954956,
-0.48196056485176086,
0.1376313865184784,
0.8073794841766357,
0.18091504275798798,
-0.8065672516822815,
-0.5412588715553284,
-0.012273128144443035,
-0.37276458740234375,
-0.09096894413232803,
0.8890978693962097,
-0.655482828617096,
0.3855932354927063,
0.5112937092781067,
0.5324742197990417,
0.3602589964866638,
0.035786278545856476,
0.5681290626525879,
-1.409568428993225,
0.21533501148223877,
0.1590862274169922,
0.26636871695518494,
0.37335485219955444,
-0.5327054262161255,
0.3744097948074341,
-0.013038959354162216,
-0.5827118754386902,
-0.6446585655212402,
0.18441615998744965,
-0.9849439859390259,
-0.2995341420173645,
1.1026580333709717,
-0.03610322251915932,
-0.19420336186885834,
0.23349858820438385,
-0.16843682527542114,
0.40859654545783997,
-0.2557459771633148,
1.0543186664581299,
0.7989295125007629,
0.12910552322864532,
-0.1619710922241211,
-0.6675972938537598,
0.40889492630958557,
0.726887047290802,
-0.48400866985321045,
0.2713310718536377,
0.6818994283676147,
0.3061501681804657,
0.2302592694759369,
0.5818454027175903,
-0.13459816575050354,
-0.12348346412181854,
-0.15384119749069214,
0.23494412004947662,
0.3457452356815338,
-0.440408855676651,
-0.7288271188735962,
0.27160418033599854,
0.05850007385015488,
-0.3208986818790436
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.02532v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.02532v2
|
SpecExec: Massively Parallel Speculative Decoding for Interactive LLM Inference on Consumer Devices
| 2024-06-04T17:53:36 | 2024-06-25T19:35:06 |
Ruslan Svirschevski, Avner May, Zhuoming Chen, Beidi Chen, Zhihao Jia, Max Ryabinin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
As large language models gain widespread adoption, running them efficiently
becomes crucial. Recent works on LLM inference use speculative decoding to
achieve extreme speedups. However, most of these works implicitly design their
algorithms for high-end datacenter hardware. In this work, we ask the opposite
question: how fast can we run LLMs on consumer machines? Consumer GPUs can no
longer fit the largest available models (50B+ parameters) and must offload them
to RAM or SSD. When running with offloaded parameters, the inference engine can
process batches of hundreds or thousands of tokens at the same time as just one
token, making it a natural fit for speculative decoding. We propose SpecExec
(Speculative Execution), a simple parallel decoding method that can generate up
to 20 tokens per target model iteration for popular LLM families. It utilizes
the high spikiness of the token probabilities distribution in modern LLMs and a
high degree of alignment between model output probabilities. SpecExec takes the
most probable tokens continuation from the draft model to build a "cache" tree
for the target model, which then gets validated in a single pass. Using
SpecExec, we demonstrate inference of 50B+ parameter LLMs on consumer GPUs with
RAM offloading at 4-6 tokens per second with 4-bit quantization or 2-3 tokens
per second with 16-bit weights.
|
[
-0.32216471433639526,
-0.46380820870399475,
0.7859176397323608,
0.13763940334320068,
-0.5256029963493347,
0.3912472128868103,
-0.36784014105796814,
-0.5372105240821838,
0.33746999502182007,
0.670634388923645,
-0.5585784316062927,
-0.5561033487319946,
-0.47960466146469116,
-0.007047232706099749,
-0.5242141485214233,
0.6284229755401611,
-0.10197973996400833,
-0.27812260389328003,
-0.0895456001162529,
0.21482688188552856,
0.2055828869342804,
-0.687315046787262,
-0.5140417814254761,
0.5435482859611511,
0.22961737215518951,
0.6380438804626465,
0.45339474081993103,
0.8787306547164917,
0.2144733965396881,
0.27497419714927673,
-0.18815408647060394,
0.3572138249874115,
-0.5893665552139282,
0.11303507536649704,
0.04366351664066315,
-0.7158688902854919,
-0.44655582308769226,
-0.13474684953689575,
0.6958795785903931,
0.47280585765838623,
-0.262491375207901,
0.2923088073730469,
-0.13241080939769745,
0.3195294141769409,
-0.9512563943862915,
-0.1001252830028534,
-0.6871839165687561,
-0.0316556952893734,
-0.5611301064491272,
-0.2531634569168091,
-0.8796248435974121,
-0.26378899812698364,
-0.350564181804657,
-0.6554323434829712,
0.43557292222976685,
0.6581898331642151,
0.5381532311439514,
0.22168414294719696,
-0.24034850299358368,
0.09665465354919434,
-0.8480327725410461,
0.8056724667549133,
-0.7570083737373352,
0.3745581805706024,
0.17075148224830627,
0.2685011625289917,
-0.09380625933408737,
-0.9863422513008118,
-0.4691498875617981,
-0.16098059713840485,
0.17830650508403778,
0.15026289224624634,
-0.13523052632808685,
0.24263934791088104,
0.5353419780731201,
0.47962769865989685,
-0.37509629130363464,
0.2008194625377655,
-0.07779036462306976,
-0.15410363674163818,
0.3444150388240814,
0.6175288558006287,
0.005256606265902519,
0.03905116394162178,
-0.7034083604812622,
0.08391159027814865,
-0.5489816665649414,
-0.14970648288726807,
0.4783795177936554,
-0.03697969764471054,
-0.020823368802666664,
0.28346118330955505,
-0.24665705859661102,
0.38622748851776123,
-0.029962208122015,
0.10841446369886398,
-0.21376203000545502,
-0.3865068256855011,
-0.15584439039230347,
0.06026589870452881,
0.5834454298019409,
0.4757836163043976,
-0.12533389031887054,
-0.49536648392677307,
-0.13215087354183197,
0.30779844522476196,
0.1264163851737976,
-0.9422343969345093,
0.07747472077608109,
0.34856536984443665,
-0.4637658894062042,
-0.08784662932157516,
-0.07324331253767014,
-0.9740674495697021,
-0.16801483929157257,
0.050189610570669174,
-0.21175196766853333,
-0.15534710884094238,
-0.0549478605389595,
0.4872155785560608,
-0.250970721244812,
0.08796722441911697,
-0.0059364368207752705,
-1.2318111658096313,
1.0457082986831665,
0.7833483815193176,
0.6089783906936646,
-0.46478718519210815,
-0.20785552263259888,
-0.5943253040313721,
0.37264299392700195,
-0.3473108112812042,
1.027571678161621,
-0.5931800603866577,
-0.4107853174209595,
-0.33170387148857117,
-0.015569325536489487,
-0.09963227063417435,
-0.39496687054634094,
0.7805540561676025,
-0.8236724734306335,
-0.41379767656326294,
-0.35708925127983093,
-0.9429289102554321,
-0.01466902531683445,
0.1254119724035263,
-0.6899053454399109,
0.7698432803153992,
-0.3077597916126251,
-0.8253868818283081,
0.46748894453048706,
-0.17499534785747528,
-0.3556959629058838,
0.2240840643644333,
-0.058329738676548004,
0.10132899880409241,
0.32947495579719543,
0.24538862705230713,
0.43661361932754517,
-0.6110652089118958,
-0.2106027603149414,
-0.4695582687854767,
-0.8372902274131775,
0.09947500377893448,
-0.6677758693695068,
0.22291713953018188,
0.3497156500816345,
-0.3885391652584076,
-0.10637091100215912,
-0.5605624318122864,
0.0016254845540970564,
-0.11767089366912842,
-0.346794992685318,
0.03241439163684845,
0.3690202236175537,
0.13166940212249756,
-0.15853340923786163,
0.2394191473722458,
-0.8541670441627502,
0.1592915654182434,
-0.25892946124076843,
0.5435956716537476,
0.7277441620826721,
-0.1241322010755539,
0.22098417580127716,
-0.11810678243637085,
0.6142102479934692,
-0.34876149892807007,
0.3046092987060547,
-0.2222898006439209,
-0.4966544806957245,
-0.5379836559295654,
-0.48700398206710815,
0.10805542021989822,
0.4123322665691376,
-0.348005473613739,
0.06385713070631027,
-0.07982724905014038,
-0.36913853883743286,
-0.17362943291664124,
0.025776583701372147,
0.31598106026649475,
0.28152087330818176,
0.13745816051959991,
-0.06431412696838379,
-0.6719896793365479,
-0.860447883605957,
-0.5245024561882019,
-0.08832725882530212,
0.07251287251710892,
0.6438171863555908,
-0.11868838220834732,
-0.10097227245569229,
0.4692533314228058,
-0.5273061990737915,
0.26473698019981384,
-0.19275616109371185,
-0.03543916344642639,
0.5953670740127563,
0.3075861632823944,
0.36004310846328735,
-0.24316425621509552,
-0.4199908971786499,
0.11979170888662338,
-0.3626219928264618,
0.030009489506483078,
-0.12136465311050415,
-0.14785178005695343,
0.3268732726573944,
0.7642400860786438,
-0.7071369290351868,
0.00382233876734972,
0.6814036965370178,
-0.3649264872074127,
0.9219759106636047,
-0.38636553287506104,
0.23696714639663696,
-1.0230506658554077,
0.036041099578142166,
-0.16479499638080597,
-0.3120875656604767,
-0.38244426250457764,
0.30658769607543945,
0.11783082038164139,
0.11624954640865326,
-0.5880693197250366,
0.3852025866508484,
-0.41535112261772156,
-0.1976880133152008,
-0.27825602889060974,
-0.25692740082740784,
0.09522075206041336,
0.23851457238197327,
0.020734047517180443,
0.9636405110359192,
0.6093744039535522,
-0.40788182616233826,
0.3405655026435852,
-0.18493516743183136,
-0.5426561236381531,
-0.06433604657649994,
-0.4653531312942505,
0.2923268675804138,
0.2210177779197693,
0.4560449421405792,
-0.9767152667045593,
-0.19154991209506989,
-0.10104071348905563,
0.08435052633285522,
0.0029358649626374245,
-0.04358963295817375,
-0.9279109239578247,
-0.5818231701850891,
-0.10126332938671112,
0.5286299586296082,
0.6853995323181152,
-0.8658893704414368,
0.6708424091339111,
0.1182686910033226,
0.1834603250026703,
-0.6717637777328491,
-0.7710080146789551,
0.282293438911438,
-0.09477099031209946,
-0.7239679098129272,
0.5426895022392273,
-0.10709026455879211,
-0.12100790441036224,
-0.022449329495429993,
-0.1724131852388382,
0.062146950513124466,
0.13633498549461365,
0.20893272757530212,
0.4039541184902191,
-0.32470157742500305,
-0.3592401444911957,
0.029843267053365707,
-0.2765202522277832,
0.21076443791389465,
-0.5208898782730103,
0.536647617816925,
-0.2150212973356247,
-0.3124752640724182,
-0.5861160159111023,
0.4956284165382385,
0.7403639554977417,
0.2135714739561081,
0.3608172833919525,
0.17351585626602173,
-0.2238648682832718,
-0.4317129850387573,
-0.8007080554962158,
-0.305061936378479,
-0.559594988822937,
0.28184401988983154,
-0.4665643274784088,
-0.6455940008163452,
0.7492988705635071,
-0.2642544209957123,
0.06349688768386841,
0.15794430673122406,
0.5831910371780396,
-0.029439739882946014,
1.1044931411743164,
0.40540093183517456,
-0.050480663776397705,
0.048047494143247604,
-0.11253097653388977,
-0.06916167587041855,
-0.5219352841377258,
-0.299119770526886,
-0.22548994421958923,
-0.5322933197021484,
-0.3509155809879303,
-0.8208638429641724,
-0.029885578900575638,
-0.0728769302368164,
0.0419439934194088,
0.25592008233070374,
-0.37613821029663086,
0.8176436424255371,
0.5907336473464966,
0.2504747807979584,
0.4741387963294983,
0.08508940786123276,
-0.4116518497467041,
0.11842036992311478,
-0.5399607419967651,
-0.4189262092113495,
1.032088279724121,
0.3032691180706024,
0.9845266938209534,
-0.2834734320640564,
0.5163337588310242,
0.3391333520412445,
0.29243776202201843,
-0.64915931224823,
0.7049849629402161,
-0.737027108669281,
-0.7951348423957825,
0.26409342885017395,
-0.13052891194820404,
-0.43003758788108826,
0.015886347740888596,
0.045754119753837585,
-0.7642050981521606,
0.31607669591903687,
0.11096931248903275,
-0.6138387322425842,
0.8202627897262573,
-0.7572041153907776,
0.5958868265151978,
0.016905369237065315,
-0.374036580324173,
-0.5426163077354431,
-0.26134365797042847,
0.7325549721717834,
0.0008652385440655053,
-0.09988367557525635,
-0.24950933456420898,
-0.344664603471756,
0.6278698444366455,
-0.5952184796333313,
0.7852142453193665,
-0.08298081904649734,
0.05858467146754265,
0.29631590843200684,
0.17288529872894287,
0.8671549558639526,
0.1332288682460785,
-0.3430151045322418,
0.14861930906772614,
0.25745707750320435,
-0.6416888236999512,
-0.42587727308273315,
0.6593091487884521,
-0.6863073706626892,
-0.793277382850647,
-0.053061459213495255,
-0.5602150559425354,
-0.370262086391449,
-0.17166230082511902,
0.46740055084228516,
0.24938218295574188,
-0.19185397028923035,
-0.1297633796930313,
0.48398423194885254,
0.11838096380233765,
0.45550450682640076,
0.4870775640010834,
0.08783756196498871,
-0.13499321043491364,
0.9159187078475952,
-0.2386411726474762,
0.2728097438812256,
0.18339082598686218,
-0.03627980500459671,
-0.2626393437385559,
-0.8635408878326416,
-0.47153130173683167,
0.08606816828250885,
-0.5835778117179871,
0.08671785891056061,
-0.6863335967063904,
-0.021896332502365112,
0.03412260860204697,
-0.3692949712276459,
-0.6060444116592407,
-0.33725881576538086,
-0.32978683710098267,
-0.13691161572933197,
0.4919971823692322,
0.5312860608100891,
-0.021431932225823402,
0.44748958945274353,
-0.7040757536888123,
0.29964062571525574,
0.16532626748085022,
0.3971205949783325,
-0.018637172877788544,
-0.5688157081604004,
-0.11734231561422348,
-0.2976820766925812,
0.22802121937274933,
-0.5223684310913086,
0.22188310325145721,
-0.029579391703009605,
0.5057650208473206,
0.9548315405845642,
0.18109288811683655,
0.59145587682724,
-0.572929322719574,
0.584669291973114,
-0.03837132453918457,
-0.9496579170227051,
0.039190102368593216,
-0.14023134112358093,
0.030771736055612564,
0.549302875995636,
0.3229583501815796,
-0.5345225930213928,
-0.26518893241882324,
-0.5122517347335815,
-0.67658931016922,
0.862808346748352,
-0.2198534905910492,
0.25752395391464233,
-0.28510022163391113,
0.45100048184394836,
0.4559960961341858,
-0.18763555586338043,
0.19028617441654205,
-0.3004557192325592,
0.16181498765945435,
0.08370530605316162,
-0.04014696925878525,
-0.6178513765335083,
-0.019864404574036598,
-0.09908708930015564,
0.23255284130573273,
-0.16323746740818024,
0.2068375200033188,
-0.07567835599184036,
0.1768433153629303,
0.015256891027092934,
0.1384349912405014,
0.4010975956916809,
0.2347598522901535,
-0.5183478593826294,
0.42562630772590637,
0.37957364320755005,
-0.5624793171882629,
0.0969027429819107,
0.012034870684146881,
0.13489677011966705,
-0.11157355457544327,
-0.050897300243377686,
0.8103547692298889,
0.38435277342796326,
-0.9346017837524414,
0.3270658254623413,
-0.5139198899269104,
-0.4179536998271942,
-0.08652694523334503,
0.12177539616823196,
0.17291845381259918,
0.22677992284297943,
0.3861210346221924,
0.32787996530532837,
0.24651271104812622,
-0.2900357246398926,
0.3777778744697571,
0.31524550914764404,
-0.02311767265200615,
-0.4787859320640564,
0.9991773962974548,
0.14594769477844238,
0.20945274829864502,
0.6863756775856018,
-0.21245034039020538,
-0.24421025812625885,
1.0026274919509888,
0.6731517910957336,
0.9866970777511597,
0.13629142940044403,
-0.0924646332859993,
0.27807021141052246,
0.14829659461975098,
-0.32868775725364685,
0.5224224328994751,
-0.22782912850379944,
-0.5905053615570068,
-0.8226768970489502,
-0.7667460441589355,
-0.7472420334815979,
-0.361921101808548,
-0.5998450517654419,
0.11558184027671814,
-0.8476901650428772,
-0.04699879512190819,
-0.048768505454063416,
-0.18814986944198608,
-0.5822358131408691,
-0.09749092161655426,
0.6338575482368469,
1.3731281757354736,
-0.6934396028518677,
0.9096205830574036,
0.29127830266952515,
0.4203782379627228,
-0.8614462018013,
0.030529972165822983,
-0.1457596719264984,
-0.934063196182251,
0.5938767194747925,
0.1303393542766571,
-0.10056157410144806,
0.32894167304039,
-0.3904428780078888,
-0.9686285257339478,
0.9324885606765747,
0.5408651232719421,
-0.9557383060455322,
-0.1079837828874588,
0.13119986653327942,
0.270595520734787,
-0.2765514850616455,
0.6640881299972534,
0.8506978750228882,
0.5982407331466675,
0.3319181799888611,
-0.3849850594997406,
0.5758010745048523,
-0.13991232216358185,
-0.14551132917404175,
-0.1462210714817047,
-0.7782954573631287,
0.837902307510376,
-0.4172384738922119,
-0.4854902923107147,
0.30048060417175293,
0.6022708415985107,
0.4262174069881439,
0.04613160341978073,
0.5663565993309021,
0.6585237979888916,
0.825416624546051,
0.1462303102016449,
1.4287787675857544,
-0.8187567591667175,
0.023341819643974304,
0.8126984238624573,
-0.42814359068870544,
1.0138444900512695,
0.46971261501312256,
-0.3294179141521454,
0.5811006426811218,
0.7929777503013611,
-0.07496717572212219,
0.35654160380363464,
0.16157439351081848,
-0.5737298727035522,
-0.6554955244064331,
-0.19368228316307068,
-0.09164577722549438,
0.19099217653274536,
0.6366521716117859,
-0.2951556146144867,
-0.21490858495235443,
-0.22320005297660828,
-0.22610919177532196,
-0.23272456228733063,
-0.23711977899074554,
0.338259220123291,
0.13549019396305084,
-0.5999701619148254,
0.8025538325309753,
0.10018102824687958,
0.8491194248199463,
-0.3562280833721161,
0.5028372406959534,
-0.3578721284866333,
0.2902982831001282,
-0.1500987410545349,
-0.5298837423324585,
0.30756309628486633,
-0.036779191344976425,
-0.4135247766971588,
-0.11335226893424988,
0.4829106330871582,
0.10901323705911636,
-0.45688968896865845,
0.4286501109600067,
0.09171925485134125,
0.4682668447494507,
-0.29409828782081604,
-0.28170710802078247,
0.3947395086288452,
-0.24848484992980957,
-0.3792908191680908,
0.20070424675941467,
0.17647399008274078,
0.016581842675805092,
0.6194817423820496,
0.8500249981880188,
0.0747113972902298,
0.42787861824035645,
0.10414239019155502,
1.084920883178711,
-0.7933995127677917,
-0.5330536365509033,
-0.96599942445755,
0.13032636046409607,
0.1671455353498459,
-0.10112914443016052,
0.8495081663131714,
0.7108901739120483,
0.36563870310783386,
-0.05224964767694473,
0.6411719918251038,
0.23715178668498993,
0.051183827221393585,
-0.4662770628929138,
0.30072325468063354,
-0.32734403014183044,
0.38203153014183044,
0.27838999032974243,
-0.8161568641662598,
-0.027759399265050888,
-0.4122031629085541,
-0.10061652213335037,
-0.32946017384529114,
0.8594599366188049,
0.8316031098365784,
-0.05338018015027046,
0.41442275047302246,
0.4712752103805542,
0.2885276675224304,
0.008121909573674202,
0.8688156604766846,
0.9501636028289795,
-0.13805654644966125,
0.8824546933174133,
-0.23428183794021606,
-0.342157244682312,
-0.29998505115509033,
-0.7275922298431396,
-0.7037242650985718,
0.12321498990058899,
-0.11590957641601562,
-0.1773417443037033,
0.1304486244916916,
0.6347009539604187,
0.9251241087913513,
-0.721542477607727,
-0.3084254562854767,
-0.4091194272041321,
-0.13083960115909576,
-0.4761383831501007,
-0.17205026745796204,
0.3337923586368561,
-0.4624786376953125,
-1.0843831300735474,
0.7165831923484802,
0.35068854689598083,
-0.2821844220161438,
-0.29915422201156616,
0.005472889170050621,
0.24027815461158752,
0.3774268925189972,
0.3099760413169861,
0.41338199377059937,
-0.7663925290107727,
0.10684005171060562,
0.2585449814796448,
-0.17432917654514313,
-0.10571329295635223,
1.0757957696914673,
-0.8131629824638367,
0.18325386941432953,
0.738503098487854,
0.7344942688941956,
1.0014359951019287,
0.0704403668642044,
0.5675461888313293,
-0.5291997194290161,
0.29870709776878357,
0.23552335798740387,
0.3906506299972534,
-0.3884214460849762,
-0.6221217513084412,
-0.12982220947742462,
0.48058566451072693,
-0.4162599742412567,
-0.6782279014587402,
0.10273376107215881,
-1.0803675651550293,
-0.5100701451301575,
1.2079652547836304,
-0.17102216184139252,
-0.6991225481033325,
-0.13568928837776184,
-0.07796721905469894,
-0.09898684918880463,
-0.5554010272026062,
0.5565404295921326,
0.34596073627471924,
-0.13588280975818634,
-0.15732918679714203,
-0.5451241135597229,
0.3871135413646698,
0.6990041732788086,
-0.6249322295188904,
0.5314813256263733,
0.06398984044790268,
0.2491695135831833,
-0.17425724864006042,
0.469387412071228,
0.056825343519449234,
0.33068332076072693,
0.5812477469444275,
0.28793129324913025,
0.05379717797040939,
-0.05076402798295021,
0.22483903169631958,
0.29776570200920105,
-0.029138650745153427,
-0.24559786915779114
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.02528v5
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.02528v5
|
Scalable MatMul-free Language Modeling
| 2024-06-04T17:50:34 | 2024-06-18T17:30:06 |
Rui-Jie Zhu, Yu Zhang, Ethan Sifferman, Tyler Sheaves, Yiqiao Wang, Dustin Richmond, Peng Zhou, Jason K. Eshraghian
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Matrix multiplication (MatMul) typically dominates the overall computational
cost of large language models (LLMs). This cost only grows as LLMs scale to
larger embedding dimensions and context lengths. In this work, we show that
MatMul operations can be completely eliminated from LLMs while maintaining
strong performance at billion-parameter scales. Our experiments show that our
proposed MatMul-free models achieve performance on-par with state-of-the-art
Transformers that require far more memory during inference at a scale up to at
least 2.7B parameters. We investigate the scaling laws and find that the
performance gap between our MatMul-free models and full precision Transformers
narrows as the model size increases. We also provide a GPU-efficient
implementation of this model which reduces memory usage by up to 61% over an
unoptimized baseline during training. By utilizing an optimized kernel during
inference, our model's memory consumption can be reduced by more than 10x
compared to unoptimized models. To properly quantify the efficiency of our
architecture, we build a custom hardware solution on an FPGA which exploits
lightweight operations beyond what GPUs are capable of. We processed
billion-parameter scale models at 13W beyond human readable throughput, moving
LLMs closer to brain-like efficiency. This work not only shows how far LLMs can
be stripped back while still performing effectively, but also points at the
types of operations future accelerators should be optimized for in processing
the next generation of lightweight LLMs. Our code implementation is available
at https://github.com/ridgerchu/matmulfreellm.
|
[
-0.4549712836742401,
-0.8325325846672058,
0.47836869955062866,
0.3176141679286957,
-0.2973509132862091,
0.16852369904518127,
-0.43514424562454224,
-0.3574650287628174,
-0.0981849953532219,
0.6402010321617126,
-0.06085827946662903,
-0.189886212348938,
-0.68766850233078,
-0.42124003171920776,
-0.2768152058124542,
0.708474338054657,
-0.02723856270313263,
0.16178523004055023,
-0.446013480424881,
-0.4090285301208496,
-0.027652379125356674,
-0.32455873489379883,
-0.6848225593566895,
-0.41863688826560974,
0.5306505560874939,
0.39155474305152893,
0.8796523809432983,
0.9824192523956299,
0.5310891270637512,
0.2519192099571228,
-0.26367953419685364,
-0.014396191574633121,
-0.6492372155189514,
-0.18919876217842102,
0.18404479324817657,
-0.6207432746887207,
-0.792908251285553,
0.03434959426522255,
0.9185550808906555,
0.9257787466049194,
-0.4442979395389557,
0.36897602677345276,
-0.03278881311416626,
0.4554728865623474,
-0.5920625925064087,
0.15577800571918488,
-0.5801956057548523,
-0.1286555975675583,
-0.12510089576244354,
0.0750749483704567,
-0.7315447926521301,
-0.10856642574071884,
-0.49203234910964966,
-0.4040292501449585,
0.1343647837638855,
0.09051686525344849,
0.6235715746879578,
0.4095088243484497,
-0.5105186700820923,
0.12058603763580322,
-0.8298967480659485,
0.9872015118598938,
-0.6252022981643677,
0.74171382188797,
0.268925279378891,
0.3599056601524353,
-0.09202858060598373,
-0.621028482913971,
-0.18344555795192719,
-0.315949410200119,
-0.06295584887266159,
-0.17878304421901703,
-0.5139893293380737,
0.2578418254852295,
0.6291956901550293,
0.40998753905296326,
-0.4089435935020447,
0.17468270659446716,
-0.43599310517311096,
0.09209802001714706,
0.40117964148521423,
0.21880488097667694,
0.05134391412138939,
0.2624382972717285,
-0.25942713022232056,
0.1222931295633316,
-0.9925073981285095,
-0.01590447872877121,
0.15161211788654327,
-0.04400121420621872,
-0.11283154785633087,
0.5018617510795593,
0.10669112950563431,
0.43307313323020935,
-0.018693439662456512,
-0.1981300264596939,
-0.05262187868356705,
0.11422059684991837,
-0.4454282224178314,
-0.31460851430892944,
0.6876053810119629,
0.11015963554382324,
0.18501949310302734,
-0.5469557046890259,
-0.3651939928531647,
0.14637652039527893,
0.32332655787467957,
-1.3123867511749268,
-0.06101212650537491,
0.1547151654958725,
-0.45891591906547546,
-0.0982091873884201,
-0.6300618648529053,
-0.5593551993370056,
-0.24003875255584717,
-0.16997674107551575,
0.3873803913593292,
-0.5522048473358154,
-0.28199630975723267,
0.023367473855614662,
0.27514147758483887,
-0.005158557556569576,
0.18490087985992432,
-1.018512487411499,
0.6824490427970886,
0.7005541920661926,
0.8302096128463745,
-0.09323389828205109,
0.10471373051404953,
-0.685962975025177,
0.30133870244026184,
-0.429838091135025,
0.24438638985157013,
-0.6606312990188599,
-0.5750700235366821,
-0.6211243271827698,
-0.24420437216758728,
0.09347794950008392,
-0.7261183857917786,
0.33138933777809143,
-0.5838695168495178,
-0.2900058627128601,
0.006788775324821472,
-0.5554047226905823,
-0.1585756242275238,
-0.13057412207126617,
-0.7210268378257751,
0.8752349019050598,
0.1948770135641098,
-0.49912407994270325,
0.18829956650733948,
-0.5563496947288513,
-0.437958300113678,
0.07301979511976242,
-0.04215399920940399,
-0.5266029238700867,
0.5006954073905945,
0.318852037191391,
0.5256162285804749,
-0.7178786396980286,
0.5044360756874084,
-0.4699004590511322,
-0.5346036553382874,
-0.003094961168244481,
-0.5047564506530762,
0.7414739727973938,
0.37114542722702026,
-0.2627115845680237,
0.22417758405208588,
-0.9371629953384399,
-0.135986790060997,
0.12915393710136414,
-0.4301176965236664,
-0.029099825769662857,
0.06448090076446533,
-0.24297821521759033,
0.12251637876033783,
0.22092676162719727,
-0.6499049067497253,
0.2168002724647522,
-0.04184269532561302,
0.4467965066432953,
0.48764994740486145,
-0.5362721085548401,
0.7686358690261841,
-0.09366707503795624,
0.6506510376930237,
0.04275253415107727,
0.14189602434635162,
-0.07857536524534225,
-0.4703052341938019,
-0.9413223266601562,
-0.8116244077682495,
0.1305277794599533,
0.25265681743621826,
-0.5267059206962585,
-0.19773060083389282,
-0.4885680675506592,
-0.6497892141342163,
-0.5730454921722412,
0.18854054808616638,
0.3344948887825012,
0.571241021156311,
0.43220049142837524,
0.16859225928783417,
-0.4908488094806671,
-1.0222059488296509,
-0.14091496169567108,
-0.04040684551000595,
-0.4451765716075897,
0.5197772979736328,
0.1462179720401764,
-0.1931852102279663,
0.7705581784248352,
-0.4971469044685364,
0.11927520483732224,
-0.3339269459247589,
0.03180066868662834,
0.1374099999666214,
0.6194918155670166,
0.5532081723213196,
-0.42358797788619995,
-0.20288506150245667,
0.09120824933052063,
-0.5321921706199646,
-0.26720649003982544,
0.09641317278146744,
0.18637202680110931,
0.23665951192378998,
0.6519758701324463,
-0.846172034740448,
0.0689370259642601,
0.6292092800140381,
0.00894774030894041,
0.3104027211666107,
-0.5624771118164062,
-0.24531157314777374,
-0.8888022899627686,
0.18014857172966003,
-0.10593116283416748,
-0.2976408004760742,
-0.6645063161849976,
0.35188183188438416,
0.5519765615463257,
-0.07043483853340149,
-0.2705565392971039,
0.5455818772315979,
-0.5585016012191772,
-0.23159411549568176,
-0.12881550192832947,
-0.10801722854375839,
-0.09597816318273544,
0.5077461004257202,
-0.13997580111026764,
0.9593327641487122,
0.4846970736980438,
-0.44374698400497437,
-0.01653902791440487,
-0.3245534300804138,
-0.0570223405957222,
0.31499630212783813,
-0.4531189203262329,
-0.08293094485998154,
-0.21988388895988464,
0.29499271512031555,
-1.0697613954544067,
0.19807013869285583,
-0.2384551614522934,
-0.17806504666805267,
0.5013700127601624,
-0.25522515177726746,
-0.4062208831310272,
-0.3621644079685211,
-0.11309316754341125,
0.5126636028289795,
0.7307161688804626,
-0.58002769947052,
0.8772357702255249,
0.3517799377441406,
0.08488032966852188,
-0.44350919127464294,
-0.8454977869987488,
0.18923771381378174,
-0.17444416880607605,
-0.5285581350326538,
0.1449805349111557,
-0.21942518651485443,
-0.21908488869667053,
-0.1330753117799759,
0.09978054463863373,
-0.03256978839635849,
0.27899065613746643,
0.2831154465675354,
0.37959063053131104,
-0.5532433390617371,
0.07844869792461395,
0.13407760858535767,
-0.25112324953079224,
0.005470938514918089,
-0.346981942653656,
0.7039141654968262,
-0.38995030522346497,
-0.16864363849163055,
-0.04338419437408447,
0.18725335597991943,
0.8014580011367798,
-0.2973460853099823,
0.7539293766021729,
0.8590599298477173,
-0.3540211617946625,
-0.09365849196910858,
-0.7072364687919617,
0.0037659103982150555,
-0.5266014337539673,
0.36593058705329895,
-0.5349134802818298,
-1.0979390144348145,
0.5869641304016113,
-0.03521912544965744,
0.23535282909870148,
0.3732546865940094,
0.6801386475563049,
0.19987095892429352,
1.1184340715408325,
0.5035062432289124,
-0.043535757809877396,
0.2963135242462158,
-0.3344588279724121,
0.217651829123497,
-1.0468580722808838,
-0.03718266263604164,
-0.2863910496234894,
-0.5473448634147644,
-0.6494523882865906,
-0.9611136317253113,
0.10919031500816345,
0.09095558524131775,
-0.2895880937576294,
0.31394410133361816,
-0.24740926921367645,
0.6024119257926941,
0.3173392117023468,
-0.23470859229564667,
0.30773961544036865,
0.003598653245717287,
-0.4285829961299896,
-0.016319820657372475,
-0.6501467227935791,
-0.44703540205955505,
1.2914916276931763,
0.3443860113620758,
0.8716076016426086,
0.06307611614465714,
0.4284118413925171,
-0.12667451798915863,
0.7338430881500244,
-0.6353898048400879,
0.9626692533493042,
-0.19814054667949677,
-0.30596229434013367,
-0.11994338780641556,
-0.8331145644187927,
-0.8125643134117126,
0.7321314811706543,
0.026678601279854774,
-0.8148937821388245,
-0.2798469364643097,
-0.004408621694892645,
-0.20363911986351013,
0.9985365271568298,
-0.7911325693130493,
0.42450520396232605,
0.03861816227436066,
-0.4997927248477936,
-0.6731830835342407,
-0.2609458565711975,
0.653766393661499,
-0.09558927267789841,
0.11982911080121994,
-0.23608654737472534,
-0.4875130355358124,
0.3389374315738678,
-0.38506370782852173,
0.37133097648620605,
-0.14837391674518585,
-0.201598659157753,
-0.018336700275540352,
0.3537229895591736,
0.45763787627220154,
0.07261823862791061,
-0.1141895055770874,
0.3843626379966736,
-0.2655421793460846,
-0.5338730216026306,
-0.44515460729599,
0.9785834550857544,
-0.7213627696037292,
-0.7295568585395813,
0.21007198095321655,
-1.0699808597564697,
-0.3175814151763916,
0.09833943843841553,
-0.19459305703639984,
0.4299856424331665,
-0.11049304157495499,
0.4017986059188843,
0.6532271504402161,
-0.15935954451560974,
0.683635413646698,
0.6210206747055054,
-0.4396614730358124,
-0.3685976266860962,
0.9810490012168884,
0.2884262502193451,
0.4754374027252197,
0.4738978147506714,
0.234156534075737,
-0.11157400161027908,
-0.6686285138130188,
-0.6208121180534363,
0.2825668752193451,
-0.25725093483924866,
-0.07772856205701828,
-0.9598659873008728,
-0.06861282140016556,
-0.23764550685882568,
-0.28181692957878113,
-0.5227062702178955,
-0.7705066204071045,
-0.26056739687919617,
-0.0918736681342125,
0.172891765832901,
0.3997286856174469,
-0.1196707934141159,
0.49585482478141785,
-0.5152779817581177,
0.4493023455142975,
0.12687881290912628,
0.6247971057891846,
0.40264636278152466,
-0.35141733288764954,
-0.2619713544845581,
-0.04335525259375572,
-0.24671481549739838,
-0.1353839933872223,
0.42250439524650574,
0.008373044431209564,
0.3206999599933624,
0.6328864693641663,
-0.32022663950920105,
0.7804147005081177,
-0.6454365849494934,
0.45879873633384705,
0.06255382299423218,
-0.80647212266922,
-0.13592326641082764,
-0.4059107005596161,
0.4825401306152344,
0.042053043842315674,
0.23918655514717102,
-0.4392465353012085,
-0.49629658460617065,
-0.6192604303359985,
-0.651512622833252,
0.6704097390174866,
0.03448347747325897,
-0.007027715910226107,
0.09641606360673904,
0.2491653710603714,
-0.06360498815774918,
0.13618828356266022,
-0.44188541173934937,
-0.24408115446567535,
0.1817154437303543,
-0.00650660740211606,
-0.342347651720047,
-0.42922472953796387,
0.14138281345367432,
-0.49238839745521545,
0.6081216931343079,
-0.007877548225224018,
0.26175493001937866,
-0.48859915137290955,
-0.3549959361553192,
-0.1800408661365509,
0.23938220739364624,
0.861241340637207,
0.5481759309768677,
-0.2805827558040619,
0.29635143280029297,
0.5958002209663391,
-0.5915811061859131,
0.19255948066711426,
0.0468420572578907,
-0.15684844553470612,
-0.25647369027137756,
-0.14692987501621246,
0.7570711374282837,
0.5627040863037109,
-0.6323564648628235,
0.22248175740242004,
-0.19382795691490173,
-0.1340450942516327,
0.0586061030626297,
0.06729704141616821,
0.7302191257476807,
0.272392600774765,
0.18062296509742737,
0.06240259110927582,
-0.20028427243232727,
0.09531938284635544,
0.2671818435192108,
0.6584444046020508,
-0.17221203446388245,
-0.3180968165397644,
1.1083664894104004,
-0.13781310617923737,
-0.16122333705425262,
0.5702017545700073,
-0.09502384811639786,
-0.008838786743581295,
0.4389432668685913,
0.7218429446220398,
0.6938416957855225,
-0.39917710423469543,
0.04792138561606407,
0.26812684535980225,
0.4854929745197296,
0.1442297101020813,
-0.044135089963674545,
-0.2813608944416046,
-0.411994993686676,
-0.4900766909122467,
-0.8377029895782471,
-0.43276768922805786,
0.13269571959972382,
-0.3264461159706116,
0.12038639187812805,
-0.9822600483894348,
0.014494368806481361,
-0.1243208721280098,
0.1253463625907898,
-0.36684519052505493,
0.09904751926660538,
0.24441160261631012,
0.7594813108444214,
-0.3216375708580017,
1.173336386680603,
0.16344912350177765,
-0.10623767971992493,
-0.735365629196167,
-0.782694399356842,
-0.11145786941051483,
-0.8320921063423157,
0.40537863969802856,
0.1808297485113144,
-0.2727481722831726,
0.0920417532324791,
-0.2780706584453583,
-0.9955933690071106,
1.0711219310760498,
0.9658495187759399,
-0.47018852829933167,
-0.07027027755975723,
0.5117059946060181,
0.3715394139289856,
-0.2702579200267792,
0.5518542528152466,
0.581835925579071,
0.25696125626564026,
0.3394632041454315,
-0.6283486485481262,
0.15851153433322906,
-0.030852515250444412,
0.07190404087305069,
0.6167342066764832,
-0.7719637751579285,
1.2790786027908325,
-0.34819844365119934,
-0.1354927122592926,
0.05255629122257233,
0.7071905136108398,
0.05498374253511429,
-0.1292080134153366,
0.3907895088195801,
0.9250025153160095,
0.8233576416969299,
-0.013531329110264778,
1.0876768827438354,
-0.5083160996437073,
0.31166577339172363,
0.8772754073143005,
-0.18119142949581146,
0.8289887309074402,
0.4439105987548828,
-0.1467965692281723,
0.22599323093891144,
0.15778568387031555,
0.007814005017280579,
-0.16112343966960907,
0.3169346749782562,
-0.3184983432292938,
-0.47043830156326294,
0.04646153375506401,
-0.010976159945130348,
0.2317056506872177,
0.4333251714706421,
-0.3226976990699768,
-0.48350903391838074,
0.004639090970158577,
0.3844465911388397,
-0.39295294880867004,
-0.4444817006587982,
0.25195959210395813,
0.16101309657096863,
-0.4218175709247589,
0.8269773125648499,
0.21547874808311462,
0.626111626625061,
-0.6172008514404297,
0.3729434013366699,
-0.37237635254859924,
0.4851405918598175,
-0.049392808228731155,
-0.21196846663951874,
0.33922144770622253,
-0.036699529737234116,
-0.10305073112249374,
-0.46783512830734253,
0.5997111797332764,
-0.6067565083503723,
-0.7616942524909973,
0.28894785046577454,
0.4348393976688385,
0.16637884080410004,
-0.1323043704032898,
-0.31834056973457336,
-0.04811513423919678,
-0.26900944113731384,
-0.37991490960121155,
0.6159464716911316,
0.09402013570070267,
-0.26595568656921387,
1.0894722938537598,
0.785362720489502,
0.17069555819034576,
0.2778518795967102,
0.007168404292315245,
0.8044454455375671,
-0.5310142040252686,
-0.23310843110084534,
-0.8650433421134949,
0.12555786967277527,
0.13157637417316437,
0.14637985825538635,
0.6678193211555481,
0.9595245718955994,
0.4821356534957886,
0.06775794178247452,
0.1990535408258438,
0.32954487204551697,
0.1175847202539444,
-0.1714068204164505,
0.9524061679840088,
-0.7012020349502563,
0.16129416227340698,
-0.0858888253569603,
-0.8407295346260071,
-0.4194141924381256,
0.21885959804058075,
-0.2680196166038513,
0.022840434685349464,
0.4536827504634857,
0.9279593825340271,
-0.3931373953819275,
0.10710255801677704,
0.8829008340835571,
0.3232415020465851,
0.6047256588935852,
0.6295573711395264,
0.3579566776752472,
-0.20323094725608826,
0.6403769254684448,
-0.13545821607112885,
-0.11294203251600266,
-0.20216304063796997,
-0.7484909296035767,
-0.6910306811332703,
-0.22547192871570587,
-0.14867492020130157,
-0.10735481977462769,
-0.3356740474700928,
0.6448182463645935,
0.5742276310920715,
-0.4989122450351715,
-0.5832246541976929,
0.021265383809804916,
0.09883752465248108,
-0.17305652797222137,
-0.16211354732513428,
0.29315266013145447,
-0.3733046352863312,
-0.819627046585083,
0.4185757637023926,
0.5412996411323547,
-0.019716311246156693,
-0.42453089356422424,
-0.10148179531097412,
-0.03068115934729576,
0.428740918636322,
0.8862800002098083,
0.10075648874044418,
-0.6829199194908142,
-0.1497834473848343,
0.03733903169631958,
-0.23929613828659058,
0.3836674392223358,
0.9087903499603271,
-0.8478389978408813,
0.19122835993766785,
0.19908180832862854,
0.7970271706581116,
0.9073886275291443,
-0.36895638704299927,
0.44570428133010864,
-0.5312022566795349,
0.2681526243686676,
0.09437917172908783,
0.6023268103599548,
0.34776538610458374,
-0.07718684524297714,
0.43810299038887024,
0.07393775135278702,
-0.3493477702140808,
-0.6699036359786987,
0.16047360002994537,
-0.9195877313613892,
-0.11110767722129822,
1.1733242273330688,
-0.08679357916116714,
-0.4209936559200287,
0.30756518244743347,
-0.10991021990776062,
0.19637426733970642,
-0.21062004566192627,
0.44739189743995667,
0.65134596824646,
0.04913957789540291,
-0.3516108989715576,
-0.5316776037216187,
0.1801198571920395,
0.6011796593666077,
-0.4889337122440338,
0.4061986207962036,
0.47121497988700867,
0.33952757716178894,
-0.18122628331184387,
0.5011945962905884,
-0.14115507900714874,
0.05804998800158501,
0.14948932826519012,
0.1397877037525177,
-0.37405794858932495,
-0.13359995186328888,
-0.32547736167907715,
0.47057971358299255,
-0.0592808835208416,
0.03775219991803169
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.02657v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.02657v1
|
Block Transformer: Global-to-Local Language Modeling for Fast Inference
| 2024-06-04T17:45:26 | 2024-06-04T17:45:26 |
Namgyu Ho, Sangmin Bae, Taehyeon Kim, Hyunjik Jo, Yireun Kim, Tal Schuster, Adam Fisch, James Thorne, Se-Young Yun
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
This paper presents the Block Transformer architecture which adopts
hierarchical global-to-local modeling to autoregressive transformers to
mitigate the inference bottlenecks of self-attention. To apply self-attention,
the key-value (KV) cache of all previous sequences must be retrieved from
memory at every decoding step. Thereby, this KV cache IO becomes a significant
bottleneck in batch inference. We notice that these costs stem from applying
self-attention on the global context, therefore we isolate the expensive
bottlenecks of global modeling to lower layers and apply fast local modeling in
upper layers. To mitigate the remaining costs in the lower layers, we aggregate
input tokens into fixed size blocks and then apply self-attention at this
coarse level. Context information is aggregated into a single embedding to
enable upper layers to decode the next block of tokens, without global
attention. Free of global attention bottlenecks, the upper layers can fully
utilize the compute hardware to maximize inference throughput. By leveraging
global and local modules, the Block Transformer architecture demonstrates
10-20x gains in inference throughput compared to vanilla transformers with
equivalent perplexity. Our work introduces a new approach to optimize language
model inference through novel application of global-to-local modeling. Code is
available at https://github.com/itsnamgyu/block-transformer.
|
[
-0.35791975259780884,
-1.0582464933395386,
0.45938074588775635,
0.31665942072868347,
-0.06864731013774872,
-0.07995547354221344,
-0.06753765046596527,
-0.42967522144317627,
0.009944193065166473,
0.7151172161102295,
-0.2949443459510803,
-0.03616897761821747,
-0.4866912066936493,
-0.16170428693294525,
-0.5808658003807068,
0.6149256825447083,
0.032994888722896576,
-0.2919509708881378,
-0.06314939260482788,
0.35771554708480835,
-0.5482479333877563,
-0.3345637917518616,
-0.7740598320960999,
-0.2843630015850067,
0.09642397612333298,
0.4124652147293091,
0.5546594262123108,
1.0156806707382202,
0.2250385880470276,
0.3912580609321594,
0.15910448133945465,
-0.2130308598279953,
-0.3827643394470215,
0.22946004569530487,
-0.49556949734687805,
-0.3738501965999603,
-0.37191587686538696,
-0.35291627049446106,
0.5834665298461914,
0.30867525935173035,
-0.01309062447398901,
0.2454594224691391,
-0.26057443022727966,
0.4407118260860443,
-0.7250575423240662,
0.11507086455821991,
-0.8434967398643494,
0.07630828768014908,
-0.10458094626665115,
0.23800629377365112,
-0.5841696262359619,
-0.0021945908665657043,
0.14100611209869385,
-0.15108320116996765,
0.7155168652534485,
0.21178871393203735,
0.6431400775909424,
0.4719419777393341,
-0.3871482312679291,
0.08891383558511734,
-0.8678119778633118,
0.7482531070709229,
-0.5139692425727844,
0.41015300154685974,
0.25644636154174805,
0.48594650626182556,
0.018166841939091682,
-0.990230917930603,
-0.48710259795188904,
0.06331581622362137,
-0.31124797463417053,
0.010880231857299805,
-0.35510775446891785,
-0.010139415971934795,
-0.1521511822938919,
0.7434051632881165,
-0.3224979043006897,
-0.008572131395339966,
-0.2687152326107025,
-0.2540096044540405,
0.4986480176448822,
0.1451072096824646,
-0.0092058340087533,
-0.3899439573287964,
-0.5081295371055603,
0.053053583949804306,
-0.4839559495449066,
-0.0024849597830325365,
0.13554437458515167,
0.3166722059249878,
-0.12391548603773117,
-0.07187043130397797,
-0.3804074823856354,
0.6937921047210693,
0.37001609802246094,
0.05775116756558418,
-0.03850269317626953,
-0.3743544816970825,
-0.39411458373069763,
0.17407529056072235,
0.8966355323791504,
-0.1910555064678192,
0.2695326507091522,
-0.39435386657714844,
-0.09886636584997177,
0.00921679474413395,
0.6104331016540527,
-0.9224246144294739,
-0.2493780255317688,
0.2629661560058594,
-0.437847375869751,
-0.21232716739177704,
-0.18208345770835876,
-1.1105797290802002,
-0.09253375977277756,
-0.20164966583251953,
0.4848001301288605,
0.05861828103661537,
-0.28152671456336975,
0.15231314301490784,
0.2976161241531372,
0.07811187207698822,
0.015559354797005653,
-1.0661754608154297,
0.6388563513755798,
0.3147185742855072,
0.7962523698806763,
-0.38869404792785645,
-0.1341562569141388,
-0.41913697123527527,
0.07305608689785004,
-0.041627660393714905,
1.0411708354949951,
-0.3613610565662384,
-0.30964305996894836,
-0.3289921283721924,
0.1733185052871704,
-0.2681559920310974,
-0.6197243928909302,
0.3562037944793701,
-0.4473368227481842,
0.07301544398069382,
0.3017268776893616,
-0.269405722618103,
0.02603449486196041,
-0.16664695739746094,
-0.8110284805297852,
1.263462781906128,
0.1325027197599411,
-0.6897681951522827,
-0.21305635571479797,
-0.5452529191970825,
-0.7127906084060669,
-0.15957443416118622,
-0.027477798983454704,
-0.457364022731781,
0.2633361220359802,
0.5550488233566284,
0.6292733550071716,
-0.7083146572113037,
0.7110979557037354,
0.09888407588005066,
-0.3844854235649109,
-0.18595322966575623,
-0.6446337103843689,
0.47192803025245667,
0.3312985301017761,
-0.7398941516876221,
0.3533306121826172,
-0.8305549621582031,
-0.3120987117290497,
0.26917892694473267,
0.08312702924013138,
-0.03370640426874161,
0.09858352690935135,
-0.08086077123880386,
0.45336341857910156,
0.0065500568598508835,
-0.4512578248977661,
0.19764411449432373,
-0.17640981078147888,
0.4939343333244324,
0.6364548206329346,
-0.03834543749690056,
0.6339428424835205,
0.1361677497625351,
0.5202191472053528,
-0.0600191093981266,
0.2527318000793457,
-0.39298537373542786,
-0.3917059004306793,
-0.8760807514190674,
-0.513778805732727,
0.2622881233692169,
0.5425383448600769,
-0.39798253774642944,
0.3132348954677582,
-0.40626659989356995,
-0.44359198212623596,
-0.9370903372764587,
-0.01403969619423151,
0.3956649601459503,
0.6575043201446533,
0.5625031590461731,
-0.3224174678325653,
-0.4383711516857147,
-1.030896544456482,
-0.2097330242395401,
0.20760731399059296,
-0.11820151656866074,
0.11933872103691101,
0.38667985796928406,
-0.20674628019332886,
1.0554943084716797,
-0.3909371793270111,
-0.15037712454795837,
-0.4277230501174927,
0.15892721712589264,
0.13370375335216522,
0.4743959605693817,
0.009971694089472294,
-0.4914129972457886,
-0.45270779728889465,
0.04225529357790947,
-0.27895036339759827,
-0.2486305981874466,
-0.39217865467071533,
-0.4170266091823578,
0.08168680220842361,
0.5620853304862976,
-0.47173213958740234,
0.5059704780578613,
0.6463172435760498,
-0.3541131615638733,
0.5004161596298218,
-0.05250494182109833,
-0.0652645081281662,
-1.1379457712173462,
0.13826565444469452,
-0.016196804121136665,
-0.42483046650886536,
-0.7903490662574768,
0.09985461086034775,
0.24648866057395935,
0.04891829565167427,
-0.3208819031715393,
0.961226224899292,
-0.5853534936904907,
-0.1893475353717804,
-0.37117066979408264,
0.1748967170715332,
0.1117432564496994,
0.6609481573104858,
0.1244330108165741,
0.9631451964378357,
0.5985684394836426,
-0.5489307045936584,
0.23704300820827484,
0.017484677955508232,
-0.425302118062973,
0.2065601944923401,
-0.6071053743362427,
0.12605948746204376,
-0.0230767372995615,
0.19075550138950348,
-1.0017657279968262,
-0.013536836951971054,
0.04926396906375885,
-0.06225483492016792,
0.5864332318305969,
-0.22446444630622864,
-0.2696477770805359,
-0.6182339787483215,
-0.024328725412487984,
0.6154342293739319,
0.5248109102249146,
-0.6893342733383179,
0.9171982407569885,
0.3708544373512268,
-0.023997073993086815,
-0.5805000066757202,
-0.7362993359565735,
-0.10832863301038742,
0.027524417266249657,
-0.49503690004348755,
0.41196003556251526,
0.0924178883433342,
-0.11574064195156097,
-0.1228589341044426,
-0.4557618498802185,
-0.17442280054092407,
-0.08648335188627243,
0.14702008664608002,
0.034455347806215286,
-0.3548206090927124,
0.013777527958154678,
-0.07458537817001343,
-0.41835421323776245,
0.12127095460891724,
-0.5860081315040588,
0.6471668481826782,
-0.2044847309589386,
-0.1469208151102066,
-0.5204216241836548,
0.3625065088272095,
0.5235468149185181,
-0.44811561703681946,
0.5567674040794373,
0.41658732295036316,
-0.10924161225557327,
-0.3168017864227295,
-0.8992709517478943,
-0.2989194691181183,
-0.4989144504070282,
0.46513983607292175,
-0.5430382490158081,
-0.8437714576721191,
0.6397658586502075,
-0.11273079365491867,
-0.5239912867546082,
0.4892713129520416,
0.6856722235679626,
0.3750675916671753,
0.6351627707481384,
0.4304778277873993,
-0.5239899158477783,
0.49375325441360474,
-0.3186773359775543,
0.6834943890571594,
-0.8437436819076538,
0.021562887355685234,
-0.4581564664840698,
-0.18100804090499878,
-0.40439867973327637,
-0.8311102986335754,
0.00982870627194643,
0.08418403565883636,
-0.3429226279258728,
0.3445053994655609,
-0.6101487278938293,
0.5601001381874084,
0.6243656873703003,
-0.1994088590145111,
0.3741844594478607,
0.0043932050466537476,
-0.14308792352676392,
0.11320953071117401,
-0.7270757555961609,
-0.13435788452625275,
0.7557256817817688,
0.4254041612148285,
0.8760653138160706,
-0.35032013058662415,
0.3066040873527527,
0.12730593979358673,
0.3903345763683319,
-0.6476660966873169,
0.4005289673805237,
0.14558331668376923,
-0.8733710646629333,
-0.21006880700588226,
-0.4388401508331299,
-0.879846453666687,
0.5135748982429504,
0.28973308205604553,
-1.106289267539978,
0.1783003956079483,
0.3833589255809784,
-0.126682847738266,
0.6902754902839661,
-0.7323715090751648,
1.3793026208877563,
-0.015271521173417568,
-0.47615915536880493,
-0.2605092525482178,
-0.7665573358535767,
0.5035391449928284,
-0.09272833168506622,
0.3060719966888428,
-0.08301583677530289,
0.37735646963119507,
0.1462138146162033,
-0.17449826002120972,
0.9883401393890381,
0.020263323560357094,
-0.2034064531326294,
0.5589170455932617,
0.3276992738246918,
0.5978758335113525,
-0.09089921414852142,
-0.07389737665653229,
0.390437513589859,
-0.5317923426628113,
-0.44344809651374817,
-0.4726439118385315,
0.7807925343513489,
-0.6040567755699158,
-0.671362578868866,
-0.07800114899873734,
-0.7780526280403137,
0.1281101405620575,
0.23118725419044495,
0.17972007393836975,
0.6197529435157776,
0.05751457437872887,
0.0009509167284704745,
0.5914396643638611,
0.057670220732688904,
0.6167259216308594,
0.382159560918808,
-0.14504140615463257,
-0.37081244587898254,
0.9425123333930969,
-0.14039888978004456,
0.6965420246124268,
0.8455632925033569,
0.22217847406864166,
-0.30197712779045105,
-0.31195881962776184,
-0.3645743727684021,
0.26153314113616943,
-0.749774694442749,
-0.35346347093582153,
-0.7310724854469299,
-0.22338013350963593,
-0.3675030767917633,
-0.1207079365849495,
-0.7711095809936523,
-0.32124102115631104,
0.1487923115491867,
0.0151993278414011,
0.17976051568984985,
0.6203303337097168,
0.13353557884693146,
0.6492130160331726,
-0.41424113512039185,
0.5263198018074036,
0.2896885275840759,
0.444917231798172,
0.30919671058654785,
-0.6305724382400513,
-0.4554941654205322,
-0.557641863822937,
-0.3418079614639282,
-0.7057399749755859,
0.4311099648475647,
-0.09103354811668396,
0.48842281103134155,
0.38744646310806274,
0.04446681588888168,
0.6877163052558899,
-0.7022196650505066,
0.5267072319984436,
-0.2595348358154297,
-1.3655513525009155,
0.43158286809921265,
-0.07619721442461014,
0.7241971492767334,
0.3308719992637634,
0.24972014129161835,
-0.5790334343910217,
-0.5942191481590271,
-0.4313333332538605,
-1.0111970901489258,
0.6751469969749451,
0.03465588763356209,
0.030227603390812874,
-0.2617895007133484,
0.34275779128074646,
0.06543538719415665,
0.0438886322081089,
-0.8453848958015442,
-0.4928722381591797,
-0.2909645736217499,
-0.24164722859859467,
0.04376540333032608,
-0.15817852318286896,
0.47012269496917725,
-0.4903862476348877,
0.7278550267219543,
-0.32432281970977783,
0.6257187724113464,
0.37020614743232727,
-0.26207607984542847,
-0.1294257789850235,
0.23927898705005646,
0.42366528511047363,
0.4255813658237457,
0.008781311102211475,
0.3858388066291809,
0.37200042605400085,
-0.4710679352283478,
0.053525976836681366,
0.11223907023668289,
-0.16055984795093536,
-0.11101428419351578,
0.2325979620218277,
1.05996835231781,
0.6001051068305969,
-0.31305357813835144,
0.29338979721069336,
-0.2315070480108261,
0.11203644424676895,
0.08034896105527878,
-0.10558781772851944,
0.22871734201908112,
0.19138216972351074,
0.28304845094680786,
0.15029452741146088,
0.17447321116924286,
-0.2105146050453186,
0.10823800414800644,
0.2731737494468689,
-0.22290246188640594,
-0.2645401656627655,
0.8549507856369019,
0.10479050874710083,
-0.2678539454936981,
0.4611721336841583,
0.008104504086077213,
-0.49479466676712036,
0.545137345790863,
0.9382982850074768,
1.0216213464736938,
-0.781880259513855,
-0.051726508885622025,
0.4349011182785034,
0.3046962022781372,
0.000028305496016400866,
-0.0409177802503109,
-0.385250985622406,
-0.5292567610740662,
-0.814131498336792,
-0.6772192120552063,
-0.1846417933702469,
0.15023310482501984,
-0.5073398947715759,
-0.05711349472403526,
-0.14281238615512848,
0.1234334260225296,
-0.26867935061454773,
-0.14485259354114532,
-0.5993695259094238,
0.3567412793636322,
0.1112758070230484,
0.8250249028205872,
-0.654103696346283,
1.2838330268859863,
0.028800955042243004,
-0.00745360367000103,
-0.5287388563156128,
0.042181845754384995,
-0.3193238079547882,
-0.7679031491279602,
0.5384233593940735,
0.44250115752220154,
-0.3575464189052582,
0.19899819791316986,
-0.16906945407390594,
-1.1590088605880737,
0.9561957716941833,
0.35564059019088745,
-0.5098012685775757,
-0.04145067185163498,
0.07961934059858322,
0.19072197377681732,
-0.33688727021217346,
0.5106484889984131,
0.8592973947525024,
0.3408731520175934,
-0.0335603728890419,
-0.8348334431648254,
0.245744988322258,
-0.15046840906143188,
0.21515676379203796,
0.5421231985092163,
-0.5300593972206116,
0.9062186479568481,
-0.10670274496078491,
-0.12487004697322845,
-0.12557412683963776,
0.8390985131263733,
-0.28439339995384216,
-0.15644292533397675,
0.3549448549747467,
0.4375034272670746,
0.5320490002632141,
-0.09115948528051376,
1.2659378051757812,
-0.590904712677002,
0.47690021991729736,
1.3066132068634033,
0.0059404438361525536,
0.8135051727294922,
0.4402228891849518,
0.019631028175354004,
0.6058673858642578,
0.24403022229671478,
0.08553297072649002,
0.6817560791969299,
0.25981906056404114,
-0.3204253613948822,
-0.16675281524658203,
0.1267809271812439,
-0.0792168527841568,
0.2968410551548004,
0.2807646095752716,
-0.18204227089881897,
-0.23525863885879517,
-0.24735219776630402,
-0.03572651743888855,
-0.16000895202159882,
-0.33673396706581116,
0.47003233432769775,
-0.07256309688091278,
-0.7830931544303894,
0.569675624370575,
0.0674733817577362,
0.6396622061729431,
-0.6540175676345825,
0.24331893026828766,
-0.47227978706359863,
0.49008724093437195,
0.1322973370552063,
-0.19962811470031738,
0.4379984736442566,
-0.18380296230316162,
-0.4023188352584839,
-0.3405158817768097,
0.8771020770072937,
-0.4604738652706146,
-0.46224337816238403,
0.5277631878852844,
0.24656374752521515,
0.045157015323638916,
-0.35768720507621765,
-0.3903590142726898,
0.0975482240319252,
-0.18656505644321442,
-0.5636299848556519,
0.13615460693836212,
0.4087807238101959,
-0.2721001207828522,
0.7093902230262756,
0.39919885993003845,
-0.14356788992881775,
0.3076958954334259,
0.12980353832244873,
0.5912063121795654,
-0.7866219282150269,
-0.4601358473300934,
-0.9721375703811646,
0.7288451790809631,
-0.07728725671768188,
-0.15067115426063538,
0.63328617811203,
0.42256420850753784,
0.8128511905670166,
-0.22681431472301483,
0.5937710404396057,
0.13035278022289276,
0.13060083985328674,
-0.40112295746803284,
0.5300484895706177,
-0.23389844596385956,
-0.14162971079349518,
-0.043963149189949036,
-0.7925965785980225,
-0.31634506583213806,
0.7203145623207092,
-0.47061607241630554,
-0.009712102822959423,
0.9257000088691711,
0.6843923330307007,
-0.32342857122421265,
-0.030384493991732597,
0.3937162458896637,
0.4492327570915222,
0.24963465332984924,
0.5218139290809631,
0.3428305685520172,
-0.6708770990371704,
0.38218846917152405,
-0.35992854833602905,
0.05074072256684303,
-0.15627549588680267,
-0.9851375222206116,
-1.042791485786438,
-0.3662998080253601,
-0.18798325955867767,
-0.0610995888710022,
-0.16063854098320007,
0.7614111304283142,
1.0095412731170654,
-1.062723159790039,
-0.4805135726928711,
-0.40790051221847534,
0.23636242747306824,
-0.24647186696529388,
-0.3272853195667267,
0.4004320502281189,
-0.6494080424308777,
-0.8230034112930298,
0.6255483627319336,
0.30842679738998413,
-0.1264544278383255,
-0.4373667538166046,
0.1262447088956833,
-0.23720620572566986,
0.15302534401416779,
0.5160709619522095,
0.2195241004228592,
-0.9948169589042664,
-0.09277505427598953,
-0.14297457039356232,
-0.09926597774028778,
0.49236029386520386,
1.0220253467559814,
-1.1561903953552246,
0.6146318316459656,
0.21782249212265015,
0.9131651520729065,
1.0642940998077393,
-0.00447359774261713,
0.7749139666557312,
-0.904425323009491,
0.30097272992134094,
-0.17532525956630707,
0.4186228811740875,
0.46943169832229614,
-0.4592134952545166,
0.37937575578689575,
0.2513100802898407,
-0.6930417418479919,
-0.5447061061859131,
0.24087975919246674,
-0.506783664226532,
-0.33143121004104614,
0.768393337726593,
0.09567610174417496,
-0.5339108109474182,
-0.1172647550702095,
-0.24933932721614838,
0.34697699546813965,
-0.24102182686328888,
0.8073132634162903,
0.4777778387069702,
0.15429560840129852,
-0.23812082409858704,
-0.8155642747879028,
0.40217599272727966,
0.4451199471950531,
-0.9228733777999878,
0.3342136740684509,
0.11881309002637863,
0.20166334509849548,
0.2550937533378601,
0.6646468639373779,
0.1616281121969223,
-0.006371242459863424,
0.03676282986998558,
0.4719700515270233,
0.14206789433956146,
-0.6645736694335938,
-0.44918009638786316,
0.11139746010303497,
-0.379991352558136,
-0.12891510128974915
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.02524v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.02524v2
|
CheckEmbed: Effective Verification of LLM Solutions to Open-Ended Tasks
| 2024-06-04T17:42:21 | 2024-06-07T17:58:22 |
Maciej Besta, Lorenzo Paleari, Ales Kubicek, Piotr Nyczyk, Robert Gerstenberger, Patrick Iff, Tomasz Lehmann, Hubert Niewiadomski, Torsten Hoefler
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) are revolutionizing various domains, yet
verifying their answers remains a significant challenge, especially for
intricate open-ended tasks such as consolidation, summarization, and extraction
of knowledge. In this work, we propose CheckEmbed: an accurate, scalable, and
simple LLM verification approach. CheckEmbed is driven by a straightforward yet
powerful idea: in order to compare LLM solutions to one another or to the
ground-truth, compare their corresponding answer-level embeddings obtained with
a model such as GPT Text Embedding Large. This reduces a complex textual answer
to a single embedding, facilitating straightforward, fast, and meaningful
verification. We develop a comprehensive verification pipeline implementing the
CheckEmbed methodology. The CheckEmbed pipeline also comes with metrics for
assessing the truthfulness of the LLM answers, such as embedding heatmaps and
their summaries. We show how to use these metrics for deploying practical
engines that decide whether an LLM answer is satisfactory or not. We apply the
pipeline to real-world document analysis tasks, including term extraction and
document summarization, showcasing significant improvements in accuracy,
cost-effectiveness, and runtime performance compared to existing token-,
sentence-, and fact-level schemes such as BERTScore or SelfCheckGPT.
|
[
-0.2838993966579437,
-0.8682439923286438,
0.8892008662223816,
0.179875910282135,
-0.19050835072994232,
0.4008975625038147,
-0.194630429148674,
-0.16483446955680847,
-0.02057633548974991,
0.610252320766449,
-0.29611140489578247,
-0.8628155589103699,
-0.7940788865089417,
-0.13298681378364563,
-0.5906947255134583,
0.6006982326507568,
-0.6455696821212769,
-0.28323084115982056,
-0.9686979055404663,
-0.17584121227264404,
-0.22870005667209625,
-0.25431177020072937,
-0.49373358488082886,
-0.4727160930633545,
0.05498956888914108,
0.22022999823093414,
0.5366050004959106,
0.7332373261451721,
0.6786105036735535,
0.31612902879714966,
-0.039709076285362244,
0.7160708904266357,
-0.4534139335155487,
0.21860827505588531,
-0.11411026120185852,
-0.5111953020095825,
-0.37921541929244995,
0.12258283793926239,
0.4320331811904907,
0.3293510377407074,
-0.0520181767642498,
0.4028043746948242,
0.009173251688480377,
0.27894219756126404,
-0.695327877998352,
0.17170239984989166,
-0.3788717985153198,
-0.09421182423830032,
0.08721110224723816,
-0.20886152982711792,
-0.32543104887008667,
-0.6668166518211365,
-0.24531711637973785,
-0.27045100927352905,
0.111723892390728,
0.07743509113788605,
0.9287706017494202,
0.6859689950942993,
-0.476656973361969,
-0.5282243490219116,
-0.6493958234786987,
0.6384819746017456,
-0.8025955557823181,
0.31389257311820984,
0.46274423599243164,
0.2806556820869446,
-0.048896629363298416,
-0.7237393856048584,
-0.6023111939430237,
-0.11623509973287582,
-0.02322271093726158,
0.4336462914943695,
-0.1862969547510147,
-0.15220797061920166,
0.24267859756946564,
0.634486973285675,
-0.7723467350006104,
0.1912732720375061,
0.15568839013576508,
-0.534503698348999,
0.4245169758796692,
0.07102056592702866,
0.36707180738449097,
0.1616387516260147,
-0.45396578311920166,
0.054783523082733154,
-0.7388190031051636,
-0.020502734929323196,
0.2846814692020416,
-0.16779741644859314,
-0.054361406713724136,
0.9017603993415833,
-0.18958833813667297,
0.37607741355895996,
-0.19732216000556946,
-0.2543913424015045,
-0.07896330207586288,
-0.4369351267814636,
-0.287396103143692,
-0.13209785521030426,
0.5644633173942566,
0.3422999680042267,
-0.050705451518297195,
-0.20605039596557617,
-0.5530495643615723,
0.15050391852855682,
0.1014261394739151,
-0.8808635473251343,
0.06807281076908112,
0.7166235446929932,
-0.18267661333084106,
-0.248569056391716,
-0.18353790044784546,
-0.3906913995742798,
-0.29250290989875793,
-0.23661400377750397,
0.4956281781196594,
-0.36608707904815674,
-0.013540222309529781,
0.4046744704246521,
0.11639442294836044,
0.48434188961982727,
0.5798135995864868,
-0.1577806919813156,
0.17670728266239166,
1.02732515335083,
1.1309430599212646,
-0.08706677705049515,
0.03751789778470993,
-0.8222153186798096,
-0.10292011499404907,
-0.4014895558357239,
0.8664323091506958,
-0.2740124464035034,
-0.2272815853357315,
0.2942017912864685,
-0.3252706229686737,
0.2818444073200226,
-0.47882527112960815,
0.5838219523429871,
-0.6262956261634827,
0.3745597004890442,
-0.10660267621278763,
-1.0406737327575684,
-0.10689838975667953,
0.8797189593315125,
-0.3943907916545868,
1.1329814195632935,
0.01910235919058323,
-0.7009363770484924,
0.06004691496491432,
-0.7199289202690125,
-0.18130002915859222,
0.12260646373033524,
0.02412584237754345,
-0.4950268864631653,
-0.08226943761110306,
0.43060943484306335,
0.636857271194458,
-0.30940917134284973,
-0.051496654748916626,
-0.2765563428401947,
-0.25922876596450806,
0.21749462187290192,
-0.15816424787044525,
0.7855340242385864,
0.32477936148643494,
-0.3284968435764313,
0.1271536499261856,
-0.685842752456665,
0.21590988337993622,
0.23028644919395447,
-0.4922749996185303,
-0.27544593811035156,
-0.023968316614627838,
-0.2891901433467865,
-0.10245224833488464,
0.5392313003540039,
-0.7907570004463196,
0.32635971903800964,
-0.027804013341665268,
0.35360419750213623,
0.5268767476081848,
-0.0033621250186115503,
0.031304679811000824,
-0.3435955047607422,
0.672643780708313,
-0.13280940055847168,
-0.115249864757061,
-0.5005894303321838,
-0.3108588755130768,
-0.9133543372154236,
-0.6752058863639832,
0.5662539601325989,
0.7127835154533386,
-0.7785384058952332,
0.6238537430763245,
-0.22556740045547485,
-0.6634975671768188,
-0.5957335233688354,
0.14858756959438324,
0.5369992256164551,
0.30793535709381104,
0.3546166718006134,
-0.08665600419044495,
-0.3345259130001068,
-0.7645979523658752,
-0.14051802456378937,
-0.2171991467475891,
-0.14154791831970215,
0.1983007937669754,
0.62184077501297,
-0.40247201919555664,
0.976858377456665,
-0.6714016199111938,
-0.07069827616214752,
-0.12102921307086945,
0.2687448561191559,
0.24312008917331696,
0.15669184923171997,
0.34522324800491333,
-0.2858400344848633,
-0.26140788197517395,
0.12462040781974792,
-0.9771473407745361,
-0.3194163739681244,
-0.21274355053901672,
0.0006097477744333446,
-0.21052102744579315,
0.610313355922699,
-0.6184465289115906,
0.18050004541873932,
0.744177520275116,
-0.3626852035522461,
0.3628588318824768,
-0.3241083323955536,
0.16366665065288544,
-0.9713508486747742,
0.1263429820537567,
-0.25409552454948425,
-0.9277620911598206,
-0.04226299747824669,
0.704681396484375,
0.2999846637248993,
-0.03889438137412071,
-0.3164275884628296,
0.48980721831321716,
-0.408430278301239,
-0.04151143133640289,
-0.13319242000579834,
0.5485880970954895,
-0.06345862150192261,
0.1942630559206009,
-0.35391563177108765,
1.0046156644821167,
0.39311373233795166,
-0.40882864594459534,
0.4657006859779358,
0.28256112337112427,
-0.5863253474235535,
0.656964898109436,
-0.7917398810386658,
0.5300402641296387,
-0.15304461121559143,
0.24934686720371246,
-1.153745174407959,
-0.005455167032778263,
-0.19529053568840027,
-0.2990938127040863,
0.1589876264333725,
-0.12055608630180359,
-0.8294482827186584,
-0.23836944997310638,
-0.31488871574401855,
0.025994718074798584,
0.6025237441062927,
-0.6831039786338806,
0.6730329990386963,
0.3351585566997528,
-0.0695248544216156,
-0.62481689453125,
-0.3059190809726715,
0.19919739663600922,
0.22435054183006287,
-0.6413438320159912,
0.09245751798152924,
-0.2806863486766815,
-0.3930320739746094,
-0.046349748969078064,
-0.24771863222122192,
0.03361714258790016,
0.31021034717559814,
0.19948118925094604,
0.16110502183437347,
-0.29511624574661255,
-0.08250389248132706,
0.056460488587617874,
-0.13527776300907135,
0.06854169815778732,
-0.47611379623413086,
0.4184431731700897,
-0.35325342416763306,
-0.818934977054596,
0.1029185876250267,
0.2040511965751648,
0.8157543540000916,
-0.629619836807251,
0.2830962538719177,
0.7416366338729858,
-0.4624605178833008,
-0.31191596388816833,
-0.775075376033783,
0.05278424918651581,
-0.3951515257358551,
0.11280182003974915,
-0.23501694202423096,
-1.2237533330917358,
0.6177918910980225,
-0.2950338125228882,
0.4953431487083435,
0.28631168603897095,
0.7518109679222107,
-0.1339312642812729,
0.6999832391738892,
0.4326247572898865,
0.15729683637619019,
-0.1288507878780365,
-0.31098660826683044,
0.188119575381279,
-0.6634820103645325,
-0.2745913565158844,
-0.7393550872802734,
-0.2180149257183075,
-0.22721661627292633,
-0.794372022151947,
0.1001003235578537,
0.06725145876407623,
0.08387991786003113,
0.36767083406448364,
-0.23001760244369507,
0.8266106843948364,
0.3211655020713806,
0.042902860790491104,
0.4862546920776367,
-0.4380822777748108,
-0.3992871940135956,
0.19483962655067444,
-0.314016193151474,
-0.8036077618598938,
0.9061204195022583,
0.5372598171234131,
0.5787150263786316,
0.23088310658931732,
0.9411328434944153,
0.44881346821784973,
0.4404935836791992,
-0.806452214717865,
0.648780107498169,
-0.001052727922797203,
-0.39496272802352905,
-0.2825581431388855,
-0.34633222222328186,
-0.5763028264045715,
0.27862247824668884,
-0.14429868757724762,
-0.3843246102333069,
-0.22001025080680847,
0.04721219465136528,
-0.11047852784395218,
0.30297768115997314,
-0.45425644516944885,
0.5975801348686218,
-0.194951593875885,
-0.39781343936920166,
-0.02727440930902958,
-0.14696359634399414,
0.3264559805393219,
-0.11788330972194672,
0.21937383711338043,
-0.10200933367013931,
-0.36962199211120605,
0.5044317841529846,
-0.5210243463516235,
0.7135561108589172,
0.029508164152503014,
-0.5359540581703186,
0.39986687898635864,
0.35040372610092163,
0.9193800687789917,
0.09864108264446259,
0.0652349591255188,
0.19327911734580994,
-0.04367999732494354,
-0.44422855973243713,
-0.6631234288215637,
0.6768682599067688,
-0.6997451782226562,
-0.4492236077785492,
-0.1712644249200821,
-0.2655133605003357,
-0.3000340461730957,
0.4523569643497467,
0.07344051450490952,
0.3703038990497589,
-0.2455325871706009,
0.324950248003006,
1.090449571609497,
-0.04717395827174187,
0.3446720242500305,
0.5742065906524658,
-0.5485935211181641,
-0.31301090121269226,
0.6673936247825623,
-0.19614490866661072,
-0.0006326684961095452,
0.663818895816803,
0.1874210685491562,
-0.34248942136764526,
-0.8859541416168213,
-0.3121091425418854,
0.23254191875457764,
-0.874530553817749,
-0.3610173761844635,
-0.7218222618103027,
-0.08528583496809006,
-0.06669571995735168,
-0.13821429014205933,
-0.5859785079956055,
-0.2788776457309723,
0.07270272821187973,
-0.2756568193435669,
-0.05272766202688217,
0.7373173236846924,
0.1522703617811203,
-0.01685778796672821,
-0.8820039629936218,
0.11332916468381882,
0.5170462727546692,
0.43291738629341125,
-0.4274376630783081,
-0.38898563385009766,
-0.2417435646057129,
-0.1463756114244461,
-0.20294973254203796,
-0.5746591687202454,
-0.07133522629737854,
-0.11675384640693665,
0.5634965896606445,
0.22848130762577057,
-0.030110571533441544,
0.373070627450943,
-0.4567469656467438,
0.9189550876617432,
-0.05154626443982124,
-1.157513976097107,
0.5432639122009277,
-0.25073665380477905,
0.4366365373134613,
0.46803849935531616,
0.3190194368362427,
-0.39205655455589294,
-0.7514330744743347,
-0.6142113208770752,
-0.7375862002372742,
-0.019410137087106705,
0.47527796030044556,
-0.010175850242376328,
0.12903082370758057,
0.34314262866973877,
0.07697317749261856,
0.11988604068756104,
-0.44021308422088623,
-0.15311367809772491,
-0.16367308795452118,
-0.23710374534130096,
-0.08954376727342606,
-0.32068365812301636,
-0.170912966132164,
0.4999537467956543,
0.6974242329597473,
-0.28508859872817993,
0.33331605792045593,
0.21110722422599792,
-0.34993335604667664,
0.09485580027103424,
0.3813204765319824,
0.8488549590110779,
0.6901086568832397,
-0.44455403089523315,
0.5440492630004883,
0.12016590684652328,
-0.3731321394443512,
0.15073472261428833,
-0.19389036297798157,
-0.2010260671377182,
0.2689116895198822,
0.8527792692184448,
0.4329074025154114,
0.04366203397512436,
-0.6765753030776978,
0.78200763463974,
-0.12622563540935516,
-0.4145592451095581,
-0.01896955817937851,
-0.010521112009882927,
0.22669842839241028,
0.3286464810371399,
-0.19301891326904297,
-0.1733935922384262,
0.04659668728709221,
-0.2471126765012741,
0.1771717667579651,
0.4952008128166199,
-0.42743781208992004,
0.02804275043308735,
0.4349319636821747,
0.24610354006290436,
-0.382282018661499,
0.5208997130393982,
-0.17252779006958008,
-0.6388656497001648,
0.5119853019714355,
0.5276432037353516,
1.111016035079956,
0.0680723637342453,
0.2012312114238739,
0.2860393822193146,
0.6147037148475647,
-0.03364679217338562,
0.30059248208999634,
-0.13759274780750275,
-0.6434478163719177,
-0.821123480796814,
-0.5306372046470642,
-0.9128856658935547,
0.010213288478553295,
-0.5292691588401794,
0.1126457080245018,
-0.45038414001464844,
0.10079353302717209,
-0.19713366031646729,
-0.11352507770061493,
-0.7866230607032776,
0.11961864680051804,
0.1489700824022293,
1.1542470455169678,
-0.6217313408851624,
0.5823423862457275,
0.8618403673171997,
-0.3387940227985382,
-0.6028869152069092,
-0.0679243728518486,
-0.06376578658819199,
-1.1736106872558594,
0.4302217662334442,
0.08581297099590302,
-0.3265219032764435,
-0.024329490959644318,
-0.742537260055542,
-0.6817517876625061,
1.184178352355957,
0.48127445578575134,
-0.7020827531814575,
0.23626914620399475,
-0.08632912486791611,
0.5625367760658264,
-0.2080613076686859,
0.40453851222991943,
0.16328886151313782,
0.5058203935623169,
0.10762836039066315,
-0.6468932628631592,
0.20455104112625122,
-0.03396321460604668,
-0.22950606048107147,
0.20849144458770752,
-0.41708046197891235,
0.430507630109787,
-0.2417176514863968,
-0.14884081482887268,
-0.15952463448047638,
0.6355336904525757,
0.0042603290639817715,
0.26134124398231506,
0.506173849105835,
0.8253344297409058,
1.0263806581497192,
-0.23050343990325928,
1.1611249446868896,
-0.2901959717273712,
0.7101030349731445,
1.1046696901321411,
-0.2709895074367523,
1.0111949443817139,
0.3148503601551056,
-0.3320205807685852,
0.4033219516277313,
0.4659484624862671,
0.04989640787243843,
0.3176809251308441,
0.24856916069984436,
-0.10422815382480621,
-0.6579754948616028,
-0.08401744067668915,
-0.16740621626377106,
0.4557577967643738,
0.1443699151277542,
-0.05193229764699936,
-0.3467910885810852,
-0.24410857260227203,
0.202558234333992,
0.12459633499383926,
-0.10645090043544769,
0.7777131199836731,
-0.006479443516582251,
-0.6646118760108948,
0.3696809411048889,
0.08189316838979721,
0.3754064738750458,
-0.5667598247528076,
-0.0744699239730835,
-0.3745218813419342,
0.2908848822116852,
-0.21293501555919647,
-1.0242552757263184,
0.2033786177635193,
0.1071067526936531,
0.02087867632508278,
-0.37182241678237915,
0.6945489645004272,
-0.46304139494895935,
-0.23675084114074707,
0.0051348526030778885,
0.6681326627731323,
0.012418272905051708,
-0.05993654951453209,
-0.3633440136909485,
0.06664659827947617,
0.05578745901584625,
-0.04390193894505501,
0.023489275947213173,
0.3296489119529724,
0.29335418343544006,
0.8117807507514954,
0.8666170239448547,
0.05742182955145836,
-0.17706038057804108,
-0.1717630922794342,
0.6759406328201294,
-0.22480212152004242,
-0.4664933681488037,
-0.8911024332046509,
0.5806717872619629,
-0.23355479538440704,
-0.17977096140384674,
0.864524781703949,
0.6259127855300903,
0.756560206413269,
0.058105748146772385,
0.7736263275146484,
0.2371855080127716,
0.41261836886405945,
-0.8204213976860046,
0.5155621767044067,
-0.54947429895401,
0.42800039052963257,
0.007817965000867844,
-1.0493420362472534,
-0.4917065501213074,
0.5780946016311646,
-0.1710091084241867,
-0.25932058691978455,
0.9381028413772583,
0.6849377751350403,
-0.1100085899233818,
-0.06686331331729889,
0.40858274698257446,
0.17415650188922882,
0.6270059943199158,
0.38148969411849976,
0.9289665222167969,
-0.2896812856197357,
0.49279463291168213,
-0.023599227890372276,
-0.42537757754325867,
-0.2247331440448761,
-1.353293776512146,
-1.0156625509262085,
-0.2849286198616028,
-0.749635636806488,
-0.532941460609436,
-0.06385986506938934,
0.7193703651428223,
0.4564341902732849,
-0.7654634714126587,
-0.0030803941190242767,
0.23312589526176453,
0.3733377158641815,
-0.2633284628391266,
-0.0927133858203888,
0.4097464382648468,
-0.37543177604675293,
-0.4895152747631073,
0.3025626540184021,
0.6689764261245728,
-0.05280068889260292,
-0.5208550095558167,
0.07269512861967087,
-0.0023042545653879642,
0.4950808882713318,
0.6454799771308899,
0.08597154915332794,
-0.6251055002212524,
-0.4220479130744934,
0.025107374414801598,
-0.40832817554473877,
-0.02300170250236988,
0.9145480990409851,
-0.3569815456867218,
0.46978291869163513,
0.5830317139625549,
1.190847396850586,
0.4785251021385193,
-0.3247753977775574,
0.33625438809394836,
-0.7924002408981323,
-0.43366414308547974,
0.07398444414138794,
0.7400246858596802,
0.31424811482429504,
-0.2337207794189453,
0.7665035128593445,
-0.006146470084786415,
-0.617566704750061,
-0.8216142058372498,
0.19433842599391937,
-1.1070128679275513,
0.022875599563121796,
1.0925614833831787,
-0.7106091380119324,
-0.06345012038946152,
-0.1097264215350151,
-0.27575749158859253,
0.06121627613902092,
-0.07720121741294861,
0.6899774670600891,
0.9486768245697021,
0.3165929615497589,
-0.1072516217827797,
-0.25352898240089417,
-0.1325761377811432,
0.25322529673576355,
-1.1104001998901367,
0.16705931723117828,
0.35930368304252625,
0.23978713154792786,
0.4338286817073822,
0.32843419909477234,
-0.10424168407917023,
0.021460890769958496,
-0.10755728930234909,
0.04765108972787857,
-0.5407567024230957,
0.028622953221201897,
-0.08682414144277573,
0.4156683087348938,
0.24336114525794983,
-0.27438098192214966
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.02517v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.02517v1
|
Deterministic Reversible Data Augmentation for Neural Machine Translation
| 2024-06-04T17:39:23 | 2024-06-04T17:39:23 |
Jiashu Yao, Heyan Huang, Zeming Liu, Yuhang Guo
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Data augmentation is an effective way to diversify corpora in machine
translation, but previous methods may introduce semantic inconsistency between
original and augmented data because of irreversible operations and random
subword sampling procedures. To generate both symbolically diverse and
semantically consistent augmentation data, we propose Deterministic Reversible
Data Augmentation (DRDA), a simple but effective data augmentation method for
neural machine translation. DRDA adopts deterministic segmentations and
reversible operations to generate multi-granularity subword representations and
pulls them closer together with multi-view techniques. With no extra corpora or
model changes required, DRDA outperforms strong baselines on several
translation tasks with a clear margin (up to 4.3 BLEU gain over Transformer)
and exhibits good robustness in noisy, low-resource, and cross-domain datasets.
|
[
-0.24750640988349915,
-0.7469666600227356,
0.2403857409954071,
0.2430374175310135,
-0.439912348985672,
0.11979250609874725,
-0.1164238378405571,
-0.29181966185569763,
0.4830198585987091,
0.42663559317588806,
-1.032630205154419,
-0.5363410711288452,
-0.5874617099761963,
0.13478001952171326,
-0.5763227939605713,
0.7020204067230225,
-0.03959193453192711,
0.15720772743225098,
0.07954103499650955,
-0.267909973859787,
-0.750177800655365,
-0.34648236632347107,
-0.46024906635284424,
-0.5187281966209412,
0.477295458316803,
0.3453071713447571,
0.9219189882278442,
0.9123243689537048,
0.37435251474380493,
0.3664840757846832,
0.15070608258247375,
0.7413185834884644,
-0.3464331030845642,
0.582292914390564,
-0.2307855784893036,
-0.6757210493087769,
-0.38447701930999756,
-0.13377021253108978,
0.7148442268371582,
0.9835718870162964,
-0.33402150869369507,
-0.13814134895801544,
-0.3083585202693939,
0.9464059472084045,
-0.16793957352638245,
-0.07601838558912277,
-0.6634592413902283,
0.28130725026130676,
-0.16486915946006775,
-0.20155902206897736,
-0.17863278090953827,
-0.3222491443157196,
-0.1835416704416275,
-0.5828301906585693,
0.1345456838607788,
-0.26089051365852356,
0.6214884519577026,
0.6222562789916992,
-0.09908239543437958,
0.009570191614329815,
-0.7408536076545715,
0.8887532353401184,
-0.8448445796966553,
0.7716463804244995,
0.10647773742675781,
0.16663070023059845,
-0.25189003348350525,
-1.0164657831192017,
-0.6755309104919434,
-0.017518887296319008,
0.06427744030952454,
0.15295079350471497,
-0.1983102709054947,
-0.2411930412054062,
0.1907324641942978,
0.4600583612918854,
-0.47708311676979065,
0.2880338132381439,
-0.12282001972198486,
-0.06044139713048935,
0.6062407493591309,
0.37549781799316406,
0.2863613963127136,
-0.009998529218137264,
-0.5222878456115723,
-0.38382652401924133,
-0.5716399550437927,
-0.3737014830112457,
0.7193186283111572,
0.31353703141212463,
-0.04218481108546257,
0.5579276084899902,
-0.26162564754486084,
0.642777144908905,
0.29565367102622986,
-0.05961495637893677,
0.717914342880249,
-0.7222418785095215,
-0.38533493876457214,
0.07110728323459625,
0.6339131593704224,
0.14354045689105988,
-0.004463555756956339,
-0.32091861963272095,
-0.40338557958602905,
-0.18192797899246216,
0.48718202114105225,
-0.7661048769950867,
-0.36110830307006836,
0.3754834830760956,
-0.39030784368515015,
-0.4777922034263611,
-0.15110093355178833,
-0.6665583848953247,
-0.27378049492836,
-0.44803139567375183,
0.054879337549209595,
-0.5622193217277527,
-0.1806800663471222,
0.02204294688999653,
0.059974685311317444,
-0.05211295187473297,
0.23451115190982819,
-0.7743969559669495,
0.08170849829912186,
0.5021584630012512,
0.7021167874336243,
-0.2520490288734436,
-0.46037745475769043,
-0.3341786563396454,
-0.22867488861083984,
-0.8801640272140503,
0.4472399950027466,
-0.4509288966655731,
-0.25731661915779114,
-0.3761714994907379,
0.036777645349502563,
-0.2232111394405365,
-0.5492381453514099,
0.47058457136154175,
-0.814726710319519,
0.22259309887886047,
-0.011429754085838795,
-0.29359930753707886,
-0.4395512342453003,
0.1826397031545639,
-0.6849979162216187,
0.8466932773590088,
0.3364415168762207,
-0.5359675884246826,
0.6160916090011597,
-0.4161892831325531,
-0.5397555232048035,
-0.14023412764072418,
-0.17254391312599182,
-0.5211270451545715,
0.2272474765777588,
0.43884748220443726,
-0.14039821922779083,
-0.07224490493535995,
0.384251207113266,
0.04630758613348007,
-0.06526412814855576,
0.5028626918792725,
-1.087813377380371,
0.6069575548171997,
0.3481104373931885,
-0.20686396956443787,
0.3318878710269928,
-0.8150372505187988,
0.04352734610438347,
0.02067079208791256,
-0.322279155254364,
-0.4506917893886566,
-0.07560842484235764,
-0.10854798555374146,
0.27210840582847595,
0.3322592079639435,
-0.5033249855041504,
0.5451050400733948,
-0.6472592353820801,
0.23818975687026978,
0.6410049796104431,
-0.037530601024627686,
0.6018191576004028,
0.007962001487612724,
0.4481669068336487,
0.5198721289634705,
-0.07224614918231964,
-0.2845688760280609,
-0.4381028115749359,
-0.5828415155410767,
-0.6678305864334106,
0.5671922564506531,
0.5759887099266052,
-0.9634818434715271,
0.4283256530761719,
-0.44260403513908386,
-0.33094316720962524,
-0.9945892691612244,
0.24618065357208252,
0.12806908786296844,
0.7415148615837097,
0.6329716444015503,
-0.48961490392684937,
-0.7154373526573181,
-1.0884156227111816,
0.13889317214488983,
0.23408867418766022,
0.07823940366506577,
0.040188368409872055,
0.2254590541124344,
-0.7724261283874512,
0.532555878162384,
-0.49627965688705444,
-0.2551061511039734,
-0.0872572734951973,
0.4844556450843811,
0.42167893052101135,
0.6237960457801819,
0.1506805419921875,
-0.8431299328804016,
-0.01377024594694376,
0.030381761491298676,
-0.7590486407279968,
-0.16918952763080597,
-0.6707751750946045,
0.07417085021734238,
0.29504716396331787,
0.5421959161758423,
-0.5186903476715088,
0.4007401168346405,
0.5471245646476746,
0.10696239769458771,
0.33570507168769836,
-0.4734139144420624,
0.36063170433044434,
-1.271302580833435,
0.0008152921800501645,
-0.6517624855041504,
-0.47642239928245544,
-0.6288514733314514,
0.16514824330806732,
0.16983871161937714,
0.2243136614561081,
-0.3319686949253082,
0.0260812696069479,
-0.35131144523620605,
-0.10045921802520752,
-0.5325093865394592,
0.08243807405233383,
-0.10162277519702911,
0.05321071669459343,
0.0533972829580307,
1.0117363929748535,
0.4575031101703644,
-0.5199021100997925,
0.4417678713798523,
0.2689689099788666,
-0.33221641182899475,
0.5560294985771179,
-0.6624944806098938,
0.05242959037423134,
-0.23187442123889923,
0.17617905139923096,
-0.8179179430007935,
0.0515030100941658,
0.21621160209178925,
-0.49179649353027344,
0.42491447925567627,
0.028960345312952995,
-0.316116601228714,
-0.12066596001386642,
-0.1714659184217453,
0.46949559450149536,
0.22025734186172485,
-0.6958487033843994,
0.32322776317596436,
0.3032105267047882,
-0.06910881400108337,
-0.8704950213432312,
-1.1754480600357056,
0.509573757648468,
0.010441839694976807,
-0.5608475804328918,
0.5820496678352356,
0.11065086722373962,
-0.1017833799123764,
0.03828754276037216,
-0.12089426070451736,
0.012573466636240482,
-0.04990477114915848,
0.2310018092393875,
0.26111531257629395,
-0.03291446343064308,
0.10777711123228073,
0.31603091955184937,
-0.3272583782672882,
-0.1926906555891037,
-0.6210618615150452,
0.803167462348938,
0.13814479112625122,
-0.4324378967285156,
-0.24109402298927307,
0.40321531891822815,
0.5533822178840637,
-0.0936310887336731,
0.6646142601966858,
0.8982269167900085,
-0.4824368357658386,
-0.43259772658348083,
-0.0863790512084961,
-0.3978242576122284,
-0.42710214853286743,
0.6797313094139099,
-0.6460894346237183,
-0.4423478841781616,
0.5487407445907593,
0.17822229862213135,
0.16233552992343903,
0.5064441561698914,
0.5851248502731323,
-0.05630087852478027,
1.0948410034179688,
0.5390411615371704,
0.07712191343307495,
0.36393633484840393,
-0.28271999955177307,
0.2541543245315552,
-0.8829452395439148,
-0.28021201491355896,
-0.21920740604400635,
-0.7497860193252563,
-0.7466980218887329,
-0.6470054388046265,
-0.07179893553256989,
-0.028544720262289047,
0.16600145399570465,
0.7652570009231567,
-0.58790522813797,
-0.08395274728536606,
0.7083595991134644,
-0.0022184813860803843,
0.434468150138855,
0.17419306933879852,
-0.16190655529499054,
-0.3930269479751587,
-0.6133860945701599,
-0.2137000858783722,
0.8518781661987305,
0.3991696536540985,
1.216293454170227,
0.00624898262321949,
0.8357268571853638,
0.29443949460983276,
0.18008656799793243,
-0.8058122992515564,
0.4437497854232788,
-0.24152772128582,
-0.2948627173900604,
-0.16371382772922516,
-0.5521500706672668,
-0.834385097026825,
0.2254798412322998,
-0.1304289698600769,
-0.19397681951522827,
0.7421005964279175,
-0.28518930077552795,
-0.014397473074495792,
0.4194868505001068,
-0.42363473773002625,
0.43000882863998413,
-0.12826471030712128,
-0.06553492695093155,
-0.3116544783115387,
-0.6256109476089478,
0.19274049997329712,
-0.4751334488391876,
-0.11104785650968552,
0.35551920533180237,
-0.3792951703071594,
0.7178362607955933,
-0.5853019952774048,
0.5707384347915649,
-0.0016462814528495073,
-0.2975902259349823,
0.11217646300792694,
0.08979335427284241,
0.608264684677124,
0.34793147444725037,
0.12836648523807526,
0.4382926821708679,
-0.23803940415382385,
-0.05903081223368645,
-0.621761679649353,
1.0296225547790527,
-0.6089307069778442,
-0.3714863359928131,
-0.4485190510749817,
-1.2536630630493164,
-0.04751579463481903,
0.37414512038230896,
0.05518817901611328,
0.054243724793195724,
0.04595020413398743,
0.005784530192613602,
0.7295519709587097,
-0.04552196338772774,
0.40222886204719543,
0.5481736660003662,
-0.1262781172990799,
-0.7879619002342224,
0.8344871401786804,
0.2709404528141022,
0.13088122010231018,
0.5195905566215515,
-0.33010923862457275,
-0.4298190176486969,
-0.8455238938331604,
-0.8973952531814575,
-0.022865647450089455,
-0.5025152564048767,
-0.2869669795036316,
-0.6441181898117065,
-0.23393821716308594,
-0.27757152915000916,
0.0649409368634224,
-0.7798157334327698,
-0.9580399990081787,
-0.08769281208515167,
-0.3353010416030884,
0.3046724796295166,
0.37644723057746887,
-0.44794976711273193,
0.20427609980106354,
-0.7201547622680664,
0.5367587804794312,
0.3003445565700531,
0.16872242093086243,
-0.45311206579208374,
-0.6276935338973999,
-0.18352948129177094,
0.39555415511131287,
0.025923410430550575,
-0.7810937762260437,
0.7534149885177612,
-0.05085405707359314,
0.5015041828155518,
0.37937355041503906,
-0.19605056941509247,
0.8216038942337036,
-0.5660360455513,
0.5362028479576111,
0.2501719892024994,
-0.4153493344783783,
0.22160647809505463,
-0.055103499442338943,
0.33815690875053406,
0.8001908659934998,
0.10806197673082352,
-0.2901761531829834,
-0.09614603221416473,
-0.4088667333126068,
-1.1285731792449951,
0.43202897906303406,
0.0020043032709509134,
0.22399607300758362,
-0.06987159699201584,
0.11698967963457108,
0.4122391939163208,
0.4711182117462158,
-0.20724521577358246,
-0.46659570932388306,
-0.3257339596748352,
-0.25234267115592957,
0.1052212044596672,
0.15320613980293274,
-0.24205628037452698,
0.06568247079849243,
0.6663627028465271,
0.061962150037288666,
0.21776340901851654,
0.35716795921325684,
-0.12028525769710541,
-0.10568885505199432,
0.34515804052352905,
0.7206964492797852,
0.5767022371292114,
-0.28758329153060913,
0.25557413697242737,
0.11999790370464325,
-0.9551509022712708,
0.008623289875686169,
0.520026445388794,
-0.6878957748413086,
0.15584434568881989,
0.1301259696483612,
0.6296204924583435,
-0.15945778787136078,
-0.37288546562194824,
-0.03665163367986679,
-0.06491214781999588,
-0.16519509255886078,
0.05283922702074051,
-0.3020058870315552,
0.08564414829015732,
0.32417500019073486,
0.4435810148715973,
0.5222896337509155,
0.0327492356300354,
-0.3362099826335907,
0.6828346848487854,
0.39239057898521423,
-0.49377623200416565,
-0.1885954588651657,
0.6583951115608215,
-0.10768446326255798,
-0.09449859708547592,
0.911374568939209,
-0.1539876013994217,
-0.1650925576686859,
0.35264497995376587,
0.688959538936615,
1.0974498987197876,
-0.28149205446243286,
0.23536725342273712,
0.2543244957923889,
0.6894522309303284,
0.022290632128715515,
0.4941561222076416,
0.15676820278167725,
-0.6327362060546875,
-0.5581085681915283,
-0.45388099551200867,
-0.1772802770137787,
-0.011830884031951427,
-0.42596435546875,
-0.12143883854150772,
-0.14379902184009552,
-0.1881261169910431,
-0.09910811483860016,
-0.23617157340049744,
-0.5715173482894897,
0.48752084374427795,
-0.03358190879225731,
0.9876671433448792,
-0.6139926314353943,
0.9737706780433655,
0.6636826992034912,
-0.67000412940979,
-0.46962183713912964,
-0.03340307995676994,
-0.30672764778137207,
-0.8534654974937439,
0.6516757011413574,
-0.21629178524017334,
-0.1625342220067978,
-0.06848356872797012,
-0.2891550064086914,
-0.6100644469261169,
1.1249895095825195,
0.20784002542495728,
-0.7538087368011475,
0.04439722001552582,
0.3666412830352783,
0.4148426353931427,
-0.4958502948284149,
0.02422516979277134,
0.3730963170528412,
0.5481863021850586,
-0.12177553027868271,
-0.5125442147254944,
0.129429891705513,
0.0158759243786335,
0.015544231981039047,
0.16184405982494354,
-0.09613227844238281,
0.8357646465301514,
-0.30244606733322144,
-0.26007211208343506,
-0.059790633618831635,
0.9068577289581299,
-0.04524536803364754,
0.10864723473787308,
0.4812382757663727,
1.1109813451766968,
0.822520911693573,
-0.18288137018680573,
0.9520553350448608,
-0.30596375465393066,
0.01126851886510849,
1.288519263267517,
0.06023380160331726,
0.5218504667282104,
0.746023952960968,
-0.15911242365837097,
0.48133596777915955,
0.48207390308380127,
0.11497056484222412,
0.8123530149459839,
-0.05414484813809395,
-0.13891363143920898,
-0.1836061328649521,
-0.20788989961147308,
-0.5525711178779602,
0.4020147919654846,
0.2751072943210602,
-0.6827194094657898,
-0.2724469006061554,
-0.06152940168976784,
-0.07067886739969254,
0.22568204998970032,
-0.09348277747631073,
0.5541786551475525,
0.226509228348732,
-0.5838163495063782,
0.7193015813827515,
0.32685980200767517,
0.639161229133606,
-0.6442241072654724,
-0.25478363037109375,
-0.5758205652236938,
0.34630462527275085,
-0.39180856943130493,
-0.8804659247398376,
0.5884355902671814,
-0.2807828187942505,
-0.3606356680393219,
-0.21157406270503998,
0.7040703892707825,
-0.7037618160247803,
-0.6082463264465332,
-0.05984662473201752,
0.6341522932052612,
-0.09584186226129532,
0.19677864015102386,
-0.7498987913131714,
0.02037523314356804,
0.12201610207557678,
-0.17671844363212585,
0.2731492817401886,
0.25615575909614563,
-0.13870754837989807,
0.7569935321807861,
0.8278194665908813,
0.3758598864078522,
0.06984642148017883,
0.41228851675987244,
0.991870105266571,
-0.4509773254394531,
-0.288664847612381,
-0.6126379370689392,
0.446466863155365,
-0.14234815537929535,
-0.1654597669839859,
0.9222676157951355,
0.47130462527275085,
0.6939629316329956,
-0.17446036636829376,
0.7296434044837952,
-0.0885845422744751,
0.25317254662513733,
-0.3149411380290985,
0.6923960447311401,
-0.13582496345043182,
0.3257768750190735,
0.003480598097667098,
-0.9974033832550049,
-0.21603214740753174,
0.5144541263580322,
-0.32782498002052307,
0.028345389291644096,
0.5871349573135376,
1.010453224182129,
-0.2458554059267044,
-0.15154381096363068,
0.23781025409698486,
0.1372791975736618,
0.25532710552215576,
0.3871929347515106,
0.4284818768501282,
-0.7870301604270935,
0.43001309037208557,
-0.3205257058143616,
-0.3098467290401459,
0.18855495750904083,
-0.6778632998466492,
-0.31831154227256775,
-0.5427857637405396,
-0.4252212643623352,
-0.22605681419372559,
0.09453365951776505,
0.7105175852775574,
0.694411039352417,
-0.9001723527908325,
0.2093830704689026,
-0.30486389994621277,
0.3712550401687622,
-0.794725775718689,
-0.22306495904922485,
0.311042845249176,
-0.46286287903785706,
-1.0949313640594482,
1.0211783647537231,
0.2942071557044983,
-0.1993633210659027,
-0.38248077034950256,
-0.10516606271266937,
-0.38186386227607727,
0.20124614238739014,
0.35488390922546387,
0.24670226871967316,
-0.18068811297416687,
0.06036558747291565,
0.12951581180095673,
-0.1568230241537094,
0.1015777513384819,
0.4124565124511719,
-0.9938172101974487,
0.7318710088729858,
0.8816929459571838,
0.910819947719574,
0.3610020577907562,
0.36265212297439575,
0.5013623833656311,
-0.8363878726959229,
0.19596035778522491,
0.17918677628040314,
0.24804897606372833,
0.5550218224525452,
-0.1892811506986618,
0.6227876543998718,
0.18137933313846588,
-0.44146183133125305,
-0.6800798773765564,
0.44888755679130554,
-0.9605829119682312,
-0.1607716828584671,
0.760182797908783,
0.025174543261528015,
-0.020114552229642868,
-0.037960201501846313,
-0.1366666853427887,
0.235995352268219,
-0.37519320845603943,
0.7336255311965942,
0.1989450305700302,
0.03387676924467087,
-0.026617130264639854,
-0.5224407315254211,
0.23287159204483032,
0.3625365197658539,
-0.6359282732009888,
0.0661139041185379,
0.5615226030349731,
0.19012713432312012,
0.44313371181488037,
0.3231823146343231,
-0.6712911128997803,
0.07864736765623093,
0.22840499877929688,
-0.022563161328434944,
-0.6047284007072449,
-0.3557654321193695,
-0.39777517318725586,
0.05145807936787605,
-0.26550087332725525,
-0.6590778231620789
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.02488v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.02488v1
|
Language-Universal Speech Attributes Modeling for Zero-Shot Multilingual Spoken Keyword Recognition
| 2024-06-04T16:59:11 | 2024-06-04T16:59:11 |
Hao Yen, Pin-Jui Ku, Sabato Marco Siniscalchi, Chin-Hui Lee
|
eess.AS
|
eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.SD
|
We propose a novel language-universal approach to end-to-end automatic spoken
keyword recognition (SKR) leveraging upon (i) a self-supervised pre-trained
model, and (ii) a set of universal speech attributes (manner and place of
articulation). Specifically, Wav2Vec2.0 is used to generate robust speech
representations, followed by a linear output layer to produce attribute
sequences. A non-trainable pronunciation model then maps sequences of
attributes into spoken keywords in a multilingual setting. Experiments on the
Multilingual Spoken Words Corpus show comparable performances to character- and
phoneme-based SKR in seen languages. The inclusion of domain adversarial
training (DAT) improves the proposed framework, outperforming both character-
and phoneme-based SKR approaches with 13.73% and 17.22% relative word error
rate (WER) reduction in seen languages, and achieves 32.14% and 19.92% WER
reduction for unseen languages in zero-shot settings.
|
[
-0.09235198050737381,
-0.3676658868789673,
0.17203569412231445,
-0.16637255251407623,
-0.2483285665512085,
0.2508825659751892,
-0.2896396815776825,
-0.5054398775100708,
0.046204373240470886,
0.6731991767883301,
-0.3304527699947357,
-0.7086164355278015,
-0.40695685148239136,
-0.09045185893774033,
-0.09649890661239624,
0.7659918665885925,
0.3916168808937073,
0.4017336666584015,
-0.09215309470891953,
-0.511693000793457,
-0.38786646723747253,
-0.9988500475883484,
-0.5518366098403931,
-0.39676401019096375,
0.44962963461875916,
0.40925538539886475,
0.6984174847602844,
0.5360934138298035,
0.3810616731643677,
0.289865642786026,
-0.042269278317689896,
-0.2794516682624817,
-0.12691567838191986,
0.3448787033557892,
-0.13657835125923157,
-0.3104690909385681,
-0.5873734354972839,
0.13699643313884735,
0.4424431324005127,
0.6185615062713623,
-0.17380402982234955,
0.09163060784339905,
-0.22105315327644348,
0.37589141726493835,
-0.5810830593109131,
0.17796513438224792,
-0.9708665609359741,
-0.015057743526995182,
-0.3461025357246399,
-0.192938432097435,
-0.11642199009656906,
-0.00441540265455842,
0.19888503849506378,
-0.4809182584285736,
0.45316100120544434,
-0.36185675859451294,
0.6281591057777405,
-0.052980177104473114,
-0.48564454913139343,
-0.3828495740890503,
-0.8537704944610596,
0.7862021327018738,
-0.7953522801399231,
0.7186956405639648,
0.3443130552768707,
0.19136977195739746,
0.0519675612449646,
-0.48453855514526367,
-0.7932906746864319,
-0.3737771511077881,
0.2506754994392395,
0.1864677518606186,
-0.21440093219280243,
0.3474717140197754,
-0.03684331476688385,
0.20921802520751953,
-0.828268826007843,
0.24939846992492676,
-0.4977259933948517,
-0.5480663776397705,
0.8583497405052185,
-0.05006831884384155,
0.10300203412771225,
-0.07067789882421494,
-0.12846845388412476,
-0.31076377630233765,
-0.714521586894989,
0.3102824091911316,
0.4235314130783081,
0.6866885423660278,
-0.04540485888719559,
0.4880419075489044,
-0.2546965479850769,
0.5189509987831116,
-0.30549120903015137,
-0.25368329882621765,
0.37630563974380493,
-0.12079446017742157,
0.016528068110346794,
0.30489856004714966,
0.8955642580986023,
0.13908636569976807,
0.24087506532669067,
-0.5069971084594727,
0.0053437198512256145,
0.24403604865074158,
0.05756288021802902,
-0.6266819834709167,
-0.3745655119419098,
0.16906170547008514,
-0.12399575114250183,
-0.5136166214942932,
-0.06852591782808304,
-0.4858473539352417,
-0.3315989077091217,
-0.22421810030937195,
0.7016804218292236,
-0.3952310085296631,
-0.30160123109817505,
0.0002941461279988289,
-0.08627896755933762,
0.7202773094177246,
0.05364692583680153,
-0.504841148853302,
0.1485355943441391,
0.4239223599433899,
0.5970642566680908,
-0.024642540141940117,
-0.1716342717409134,
-0.48576033115386963,
0.22064431011676788,
-0.38064539432525635,
0.6600196361541748,
-0.6472260355949402,
-0.7159465551376343,
-0.07654818147420883,
-0.12373321503400803,
0.03137707710266113,
-0.44854113459587097,
0.6701169013977051,
-0.3572453558444977,
0.2444404810667038,
-0.008919554762542248,
-0.45513877272605896,
-0.3297421932220459,
-0.019923217594623566,
-0.6237190961837769,
0.8490619659423828,
-0.045540619641542435,
-0.23776909708976746,
0.2644723355770111,
-0.7726929783821106,
-0.6612001061439514,
0.3876352608203888,
-0.1753125786781311,
-0.4104727804660797,
0.196499302983284,
0.1750737577676773,
0.5362417101860046,
-0.1339162439107895,
-0.0925932377576828,
-0.4538896083831787,
-0.038128167390823364,
0.3897193968296051,
-0.7461880445480347,
0.6145638823509216,
0.3473404049873352,
-0.17639808356761932,
0.13565926253795624,
-1.120347261428833,
0.3701607882976532,
0.29241353273391724,
-0.0950426235795021,
-0.4126594364643097,
-0.0643574669957161,
0.36972111463546753,
0.35587188601493835,
0.20344536006450653,
-0.9013156890869141,
0.20873580873012543,
-0.3836110830307007,
0.47211211919784546,
0.511387050151825,
-0.2775575816631317,
0.5251010060310364,
0.2371707707643509,
0.4529684782028198,
-0.06381534039974213,
-0.06167672574520111,
-0.19051745533943176,
-0.44383901357650757,
-0.6191492676734924,
-0.3060445785522461,
0.43705347180366516,
0.7151346206665039,
-0.48327529430389404,
0.4610491394996643,
-0.3354620039463043,
-0.3091622292995453,
-0.6198490858078003,
0.06365114450454712,
0.7747206091880798,
0.3440486490726471,
0.050873953849077225,
-0.5281086564064026,
-0.5481431484222412,
-0.6725811958312988,
-0.16367946565151215,
-0.3535418212413788,
-0.16481003165245056,
0.2818407416343689,
0.27039018273353577,
0.08174223452806473,
0.964872419834137,
-0.47273650765419006,
-0.6590580940246582,
-0.5462741851806641,
0.33376404643058777,
-0.09408588707447052,
0.28659167885780334,
0.5318762063980103,
-0.8391373753547668,
-0.5135149359703064,
0.07492320239543915,
-0.6491420269012451,
-0.019214197993278503,
0.17495696246623993,
0.2687201499938965,
0.2929464876651764,
0.3476068079471588,
-0.41972148418426514,
0.4440510869026184,
0.49530279636383057,
-0.11435341835021973,
0.41065752506256104,
-0.32089149951934814,
0.020333971828222275,
-1.2407253980636597,
0.006147623527795076,
-0.08156152814626694,
-0.10132463276386261,
-1.1161795854568481,
0.07774185389280319,
-0.02777145989239216,
-0.541048526763916,
-0.7188190817832947,
0.6726912260055542,
-0.46043094992637634,
-0.11362066119909286,
-0.39340075850486755,
0.14482298493385315,
-0.09790422767400742,
0.6239340901374817,
0.306192547082901,
1.0031495094299316,
0.857890248298645,
-0.719478189945221,
0.5096964240074158,
0.18178260326385498,
-0.05577639490365982,
0.9056258797645569,
-0.7264025807380676,
0.42983177304267883,
-0.09486378729343414,
0.03953075408935547,
-1.137237787246704,
-0.1566399484872818,
-0.051972661167383194,
-0.9854000210762024,
0.683807909488678,
0.005279493983834982,
-0.19554908573627472,
-0.4165221154689789,
-0.217143252491951,
0.2200564593076706,
0.3311614394187927,
-0.4438062310218811,
0.5486320853233337,
0.5449488162994385,
-0.3699275255203247,
-0.4341452121734619,
-0.49047407507896423,
0.3702003061771393,
-0.0319054089486599,
-0.4023783504962921,
0.41185906529426575,
-0.021601855754852295,
0.17153368890285492,
-0.17766493558883667,
-0.19985376298427582,
-0.41806089878082275,
0.002625706372782588,
0.2424323409795761,
0.10300161689519882,
-0.1184043362736702,
-0.021371882408857346,
-0.3515254259109497,
-0.18714956939220428,
-0.2360565960407257,
-0.3552543520927429,
0.5587249994277954,
-0.15594452619552612,
-0.2539820373058319,
-0.5606659650802612,
0.4429871141910553,
0.751836359500885,
-0.631782591342926,
0.3995956778526306,
0.8161263465881348,
-0.2982616424560547,
0.30358952283859253,
-0.5507726669311523,
0.13078778982162476,
-0.4530631899833679,
0.676597535610199,
-0.6701128482818604,
-0.9063188433647156,
0.7685959339141846,
0.21091336011886597,
-0.14550510048866272,
0.439778596162796,
0.41983211040496826,
-0.1505737155675888,
1.1607654094696045,
0.7128609418869019,
-0.5024296045303345,
0.288059264421463,
-0.44941744208335876,
0.3516533076763153,
-0.8246785402297974,
-0.2544412314891815,
-0.5532281398773193,
-0.08726376295089722,
-0.696613073348999,
-0.23455113172531128,
0.4257458448410034,
0.15080809593200684,
0.023739425465464592,
0.5246837735176086,
-0.42960405349731445,
0.31006771326065063,
0.7034386396408081,
-0.20540601015090942,
0.024950234219431877,
-0.00806887075304985,
-0.24895928800106049,
-0.11681593954563141,
-0.44345682859420776,
-0.3078623116016388,
1.406878113746643,
0.074606753885746,
0.9035549759864807,
0.01625647395849228,
0.5928153395652771,
0.3775802552700043,
-0.10649987310171127,
-0.8640173673629761,
0.5995378494262695,
-0.3388514220714569,
-0.6244556307792664,
-0.41248470544815063,
-0.2651495337486267,
-0.8486887812614441,
0.2798807621002197,
0.03420168161392212,
-0.9110814929008484,
0.05102614313364029,
0.06558291614055634,
-0.3239123821258545,
0.404916375875473,
-0.29441818594932556,
0.6917508244514465,
-0.42177507281303406,
0.20259834825992584,
-0.1596541404724121,
-0.7752904295921326,
0.0387139692902565,
0.042738933116197586,
0.05352194234728813,
-0.17478296160697937,
0.17429092526435852,
0.645054817199707,
-0.16464178264141083,
0.5512213706970215,
-0.23633049428462982,
-0.23004236817359924,
0.20753708481788635,
-0.10889071971178055,
0.35934579372406006,
-0.3507173955440521,
-0.02988649159669876,
0.6789172887802124,
-0.045320384204387665,
-0.1351214200258255,
-0.4697253406047821,
0.5348851680755615,
-0.7200183868408203,
-0.23017992079257965,
-0.607592761516571,
-0.5390675663948059,
-0.25577792525291443,
-0.013978403992950916,
0.4924622178077698,
0.6285686492919922,
-0.6599612236022949,
0.376665323972702,
0.6030491590499878,
-0.2830929756164551,
0.4155541956424713,
1.0406873226165771,
0.1527496725320816,
-0.756991446018219,
1.257747769355774,
0.17613822221755981,
0.24952206015586853,
0.5803126692771912,
0.1112254410982132,
-0.6335306167602539,
-0.42280858755111694,
-0.309421569108963,
0.0586649514734745,
-0.4373571574687958,
-0.303936243057251,
-0.6889862418174744,
-0.5288475751876831,
-0.9107538461685181,
-0.05744859576225281,
-0.40761083364486694,
-0.6998594403266907,
-0.20742297172546387,
0.11486933380365372,
0.37983429431915283,
0.5752376317977905,
-0.41108599305152893,
0.7245250940322876,
-0.6731467843055725,
0.48837921023368835,
0.35988324880599976,
0.38111773133277893,
-0.21561524271965027,
-0.8450878262519836,
-0.30601856112480164,
0.14805564284324646,
-0.4712962806224823,
-0.801910936832428,
0.6766117811203003,
0.9414811730384827,
0.7145611643791199,
0.5951604247093201,
0.04810858517885208,
0.5481102466583252,
-0.719617486000061,
0.9789472818374634,
0.37530797719955444,
-0.8964021801948547,
0.5353078246116638,
-0.1403285264968872,
0.3318227231502533,
0.2999279499053955,
0.21328136324882507,
-0.7872116565704346,
-0.543495237827301,
-0.508190393447876,
-0.8597468733787537,
0.7077656984329224,
0.18821579217910767,
0.3285234868526459,
0.14343984425067902,
0.24816790223121643,
-0.06144968792796135,
0.3296651542186737,
-0.6280765533447266,
-0.49812230467796326,
-0.28030264377593994,
-0.21579580008983612,
-0.11012416332960129,
-0.2765295207500458,
0.17701932787895203,
-0.27384185791015625,
0.6530963182449341,
-0.11935460567474365,
0.3418114483356476,
0.014547117054462433,
-0.2794843316078186,
0.08411435037851334,
0.7993853688240051,
0.6086374521255493,
0.1714918613433838,
-0.3161534368991852,
-0.07090819627046585,
0.05605711042881012,
-0.7650619745254517,
0.32472559809684753,
0.2578166723251343,
-0.1043599545955658,
0.17346066236495972,
0.13256512582302094,
0.9019380807876587,
0.18391096591949463,
-0.3697349429130554,
0.6339727640151978,
0.03261052817106247,
-0.4122641682624817,
-0.33099353313446045,
-0.11121412366628647,
-0.2508242726325989,
0.154469832777977,
0.5584020614624023,
-0.16688133776187897,
0.20878145098686218,
-0.5614316463470459,
0.30578145384788513,
0.9130256175994873,
-0.5814013481140137,
-0.6069276332855225,
0.8745604753494263,
0.14519387483596802,
-0.32534629106521606,
0.3808572292327881,
-0.29952171444892883,
-0.9308550357818604,
0.3295513391494751,
0.6206365823745728,
1.2447823286056519,
-0.8656632900238037,
0.23160512745380402,
0.22386789321899414,
0.13371342420578003,
0.3639872968196869,
0.5062546730041504,
-0.2999788224697113,
-0.7540820240974426,
-0.051199592649936676,
-0.6574744582176208,
-0.4651806354522705,
0.5615385174751282,
-0.8720040917396545,
0.06325194239616394,
-0.2008865773677826,
-0.12431978434324265,
0.234252467751503,
0.03253030404448509,
-0.8002515435218811,
0.3614397346973419,
0.4117845892906189,
0.3771221935749054,
-0.765688955783844,
1.06891930103302,
0.7101196646690369,
-0.5966940522193909,
-0.5574772357940674,
-0.1862877905368805,
0.20741596817970276,
-0.8199895620346069,
0.6917542815208435,
0.09318720549345016,
-0.2235661745071411,
0.11934208869934082,
-0.5938292741775513,
-1.0687118768692017,
0.9982900023460388,
0.28999337553977966,
-0.3955383896827698,
0.028298394754529,
0.5257588624954224,
0.5158510208129883,
-0.25539514422416687,
0.061107978224754333,
0.3517669141292572,
0.021138688549399376,
0.4967568516731262,
-1.1244348287582397,
-0.5916789174079895,
-0.17597977817058563,
0.24806049466133118,
0.06388203799724579,
-0.3823687732219696,
0.6273345351219177,
-0.3454951047897339,
-0.2524227499961853,
0.32784897089004517,
0.9277014136314392,
-0.08345741778612137,
0.2743014693260193,
0.2405829131603241,
0.6937940120697021,
0.6240284442901611,
-0.04630252346396446,
0.6309183835983276,
-0.516247034072876,
0.23346342146396637,
1.1604726314544678,
-0.6783493757247925,
1.0777504444122314,
0.09849158674478531,
-0.3441091477870941,
0.16238082945346832,
0.19188472628593445,
0.11006247252225876,
0.8320027589797974,
-0.000041499544749967754,
-0.6021705269813538,
-0.10228926688432693,
-0.2581285238265991,
-0.3691496253013611,
1.036550760269165,
0.3275209069252014,
0.012767852284014225,
-0.27795207500457764,
0.3952007293701172,
-0.024379562586545944,
-0.11744856834411621,
-0.3399692475795746,
0.9981558918952942,
-0.0043229334987699986,
-0.06938638538122177,
0.4691193699836731,
0.04053330793976784,
0.9233714938163757,
-0.904475212097168,
-0.047074321657419205,
0.05851293355226517,
0.3033895194530487,
0.10889621824026108,
-0.7963730096817017,
-0.028804011642932892,
0.13049927353858948,
-0.177471324801445,
0.011939981952309608,
0.8036826848983765,
-0.8460208773612976,
-0.5943821668624878,
0.1672360748052597,
0.2563924491405487,
0.4162684679031372,
-0.34025123715400696,
-0.7349575161933899,
-0.18469557166099548,
-0.24373069405555725,
0.011399521492421627,
0.3766516447067261,
0.30024254322052,
0.10956664383411407,
0.5361903309822083,
0.7600780129432678,
0.42398911714553833,
0.02511652745306492,
0.4328080415725708,
0.4934084713459015,
-0.7132589817047119,
-0.5030755400657654,
-0.4427071511745453,
0.2993399202823639,
0.03808636590838432,
-0.2750702500343323,
0.6814292073249817,
0.6456252336502075,
1.0738211870193481,
0.0030825661960989237,
1.0134392976760864,
-0.01990029402077198,
0.5774526596069336,
-0.2671454846858978,
0.951946496963501,
-0.6056795120239258,
-0.22028498351573944,
-0.39496996998786926,
-0.7394819259643555,
-0.37947219610214233,
0.7133644819259644,
0.1688913255929947,
-0.08958173543214798,
0.22012147307395935,
0.930798351764679,
0.10757249593734741,
-0.2939472198486328,
0.9133473038673401,
0.003838132368400693,
0.43217769265174866,
0.353031188249588,
0.2767857313156128,
-0.6850499510765076,
0.6849479675292969,
-0.26880940794944763,
-0.046220362186431885,
0.012691564857959747,
-0.7038804888725281,
-0.6119179129600525,
-0.8546346426010132,
-0.2983836829662323,
-0.2665081024169922,
0.1692797690629959,
0.9051936864852905,
0.6422960758209229,
-1.0805095434188843,
-0.3356476128101349,
0.24680759012699127,
-0.27210181951522827,
-0.15953832864761353,
-0.22581538558006287,
0.30974772572517395,
-0.22615958750247955,
-0.39723366498947144,
0.5684370398521423,
0.43129292130470276,
0.04166198894381523,
-0.357003778219223,
-0.3225500285625458,
-0.029364582151174545,
0.18817806243896484,
0.7491063475608826,
0.6214888691902161,
-0.9760245084762573,
-0.22463013231754303,
0.11959999054670334,
-0.10648465156555176,
0.05106005445122719,
0.812459409236908,
-0.671890914440155,
0.7416824698448181,
0.2707487642765045,
0.25913408398628235,
0.11219388991594315,
-0.26343756914138794,
0.6779935956001282,
-0.9776095747947693,
0.29774314165115356,
0.23325467109680176,
0.21552647650241852,
0.5009382367134094,
-0.17710109055042267,
0.30887284874916077,
0.3648984730243683,
-0.39906150102615356,
-0.7618089914321899,
0.41633141040802,
-1.0678091049194336,
0.04969258978962898,
1.0495377779006958,
-0.13816320896148682,
0.016374660655856133,
-0.08877920359373093,
-0.16035738587379456,
0.4414623975753784,
-0.3818736970424652,
0.5177595615386963,
0.5131006836891174,
0.009321894496679306,
-0.20829996466636658,
-0.2910825312137604,
0.3889656662940979,
-0.021286290138959885,
-0.39063844084739685,
0.1332881897687912,
0.4908565878868103,
0.38601061701774597,
0.17159046232700348,
0.6999624967575073,
-0.3271719217300415,
0.30824002623558044,
-0.21540780365467072,
0.5940038561820984,
-0.12966369092464447,
-0.5062182545661926,
-0.7477723956108093,
-0.1421351283788681,
0.0022592036984860897,
-0.48525986075401306
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.02481v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.02481v1
|
Hiding Text in Large Language Models: Introducing Unconditional Token Forcing Confusion
| 2024-06-04T16:49:06 | 2024-06-04T16:49:06 |
Jakub Hoscilowicz, Pawel Popiolek, Jan Rudkowski, Jedrzej Bieniasz, Artur Janicki
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CR
|
With the help of simple fine-tuning, one can artificially embed hidden text
into large language models (LLMs). This text is revealed only when triggered by
a specific query to the LLM. Two primary applications are LLM fingerprinting
and steganography. In the context of LLM fingerprinting, a unique text
identifier (fingerprint) is embedded within the model to verify licensing
compliance. In the context of steganography, the LLM serves as a carrier for
hidden messages that can be disclosed through a designated trigger.
Our work demonstrates that embedding hidden text in the LLM via fine-tuning,
though seemingly secure due to the vast number of potential triggers (any
sequence of characters or tokens could serve as a trigger), is susceptible to
extraction through analysis of the LLM's output decoding process. We propose a
novel approach to extraction called Unconditional Token Forcing. It is premised
on the hypothesis that iteratively feeding each token from the LLM's vocabulary
into the model should reveal sequences with abnormally high token
probabilities, indicating potential embedded text candidates. Additionally, our
experiments show that when the first token of a hidden fingerprint is used as
an input, the LLM not only produces an output sequence with high token
probabilities, but also repetitively generates the fingerprint itself. We also
present a method to hide text in such a way that it is resistant to
Unconditional Token Forcing, which we named Unconditional Token Forcing
Confusion.
|
[
-0.08342716097831726,
-0.7993993759155273,
0.5701679587364197,
0.1347794383764267,
-0.6297305226325989,
0.36715394258499146,
-0.21593669056892395,
-0.5304194092750549,
0.029731476679444313,
0.8870484828948975,
-0.23409675061702728,
-0.5862300992012024,
-0.7228022813796997,
-0.09560079872608185,
-0.582333505153656,
0.9015669226646423,
-0.09426958858966827,
0.023685436695814133,
-0.015357829630374908,
-0.12815861403942108,
-0.20027869939804077,
-0.955953061580658,
-0.4196736216545105,
-0.4359317421913147,
0.4418138563632965,
0.18519417941570282,
0.6126357913017273,
1.1106854677200317,
0.2704833745956421,
0.2577184736728668,
-0.4563370943069458,
0.1802687644958496,
-0.27654123306274414,
0.08446458727121353,
-0.3594738245010376,
-0.5368909239768982,
0.031294140964746475,
-0.0759422555565834,
0.7698661088943481,
0.5493081212043762,
0.018666613847017288,
0.09686746448278427,
0.15322649478912354,
0.4986497461795807,
-0.7027067542076111,
0.13847675919532776,
-0.8236572742462158,
-0.10190097242593765,
-0.5404513478279114,
-0.22832995653152466,
-0.6535147428512573,
-0.031458038836717606,
-0.3055969476699829,
-0.19545233249664307,
0.11660274118185043,
0.3486720323562622,
0.8154141306877136,
0.14138686656951904,
-0.5727751851081848,
-0.457208514213562,
-0.794672966003418,
0.5782063007354736,
-0.7632653117179871,
0.18614044785499573,
0.38874661922454834,
-0.1462167352437973,
-0.26582393050193787,
-0.6570485830307007,
-0.6760072112083435,
-0.20054836571216583,
-0.10342875123023987,
-0.1568879783153534,
-0.16614171862602234,
0.27511465549468994,
0.22189529240131378,
0.4329041540622711,
-0.10256902128458023,
0.45283517241477966,
-0.16681897640228271,
-0.4017041027545929,
0.3762761354446411,
0.027451856061816216,
0.3730567693710327,
-0.07490839064121246,
-0.46766793727874756,
-0.06234735995531082,
-0.9532507061958313,
0.02704133279621601,
0.47874557971954346,
0.39109012484550476,
0.026526013389229774,
0.7228623628616333,
0.13511011004447937,
0.29798707365989685,
0.1004749983549118,
0.19231019914150238,
-0.013554870150983334,
-0.15471641719341278,
-0.2784557640552521,
0.11464054137468338,
0.936195969581604,
-0.03694823011755943,
0.011929637752473354,
-0.21266542375087738,
-0.5487866997718811,
0.05238577350974083,
-0.08866491168737411,
-0.5625356435775757,
0.2977199852466583,
0.10429559648036957,
-0.49932217597961426,
-0.5340818166732788,
0.27715715765953064,
-0.745976984500885,
-0.7856760621070862,
-0.027443623170256615,
0.46048417687416077,
-0.1386597901582718,
-0.1289866715669632,
0.15070904791355133,
-0.18970459699630737,
0.17112836241722107,
0.01853598840534687,
-1.1655769348144531,
0.294662743806839,
0.8984113931655884,
0.7141116261482239,
-0.14650362730026245,
-0.11717499792575836,
-0.6376245021820068,
0.3073839247226715,
-0.44690510630607605,
0.4189397990703583,
-0.7320457696914673,
-0.4968418478965759,
0.17131082713603973,
0.16803914308547974,
0.130022794008255,
-0.6122930645942688,
0.42696574330329895,
-0.8425531983375549,
-0.015938319265842438,
-0.13664402067661285,
-0.6957550644874573,
-0.07246194779872894,
-0.2667243778705597,
-0.8319578170776367,
1.1338143348693848,
-0.23038284480571747,
-0.7021294832229614,
0.28054893016815186,
-0.5017634034156799,
-0.4722138047218323,
0.11870680749416351,
-0.20699602365493774,
-0.3711004853248596,
0.27745309472084045,
0.0880431979894638,
0.4014466404914856,
-0.08896531164646149,
0.37838852405548096,
-0.4576561748981476,
-0.4582236409187317,
0.41154465079307556,
-0.7818699479103088,
0.8856872320175171,
0.10566942393779755,
-0.7089816927909851,
0.08543436974287033,
-0.7187996506690979,
-0.299572616815567,
-0.012161726132035255,
-0.567268967628479,
-0.3983602821826935,
-0.10224878042936325,
0.029901737347245216,
0.014977158978581429,
0.38795220851898193,
-0.7147366404533386,
0.21648885309696198,
-0.5563834309577942,
0.46452420949935913,
0.9149996638298035,
0.10382533073425293,
0.6839460730552673,
-0.10716839879751205,
0.340026319026947,
0.10113537311553955,
0.12641404569149017,
-0.2638254761695862,
-0.4008063077926636,
-0.5811351537704468,
-0.22724933922290802,
0.6913109421730042,
0.4555765688419342,
-0.5699929594993591,
0.2363494336605072,
0.15838158130645752,
-0.2217893898487091,
-0.5757431387901306,
0.42342841625213623,
0.6874683499336243,
0.212956041097641,
-0.09786892682313919,
-0.26647600531578064,
-0.5388570427894592,
-0.8429228663444519,
-0.5457661747932434,
-0.06171043962240219,
0.07044132798910141,
-0.015482360497117043,
0.5243815779685974,
-0.08956459164619446,
0.7210727334022522,
-0.19309081137180328,
-0.20073926448822021,
-0.31667426228523254,
0.3319684863090515,
0.2460547387599945,
0.5763232707977295,
0.16880856454372406,
-0.9839643836021423,
-0.31009697914123535,
0.13834230601787567,
-0.47597572207450867,
-0.01982218399643898,
-0.2967166304588318,
0.17812566459178925,
0.553045928478241,
0.9676862955093384,
-0.639064371585846,
0.7842814326286316,
0.525117814540863,
-0.5757991075515747,
0.46114566922187805,
-0.5705721378326416,
-0.1608557105064392,
-0.8907858729362488,
0.11703724414110184,
-0.26711902022361755,
-0.32385173439979553,
-0.47342222929000854,
0.37787386775016785,
0.25305140018463135,
0.04074564203619957,
-0.4113263189792633,
0.8742709159851074,
-0.7962831258773804,
-0.007898134179413319,
-0.3467533588409424,
-0.20452910661697388,
-0.10045761615037918,
0.44726255536079407,
-0.18644389510154724,
0.6324631571769714,
0.5105105042457581,
-0.48254552483558655,
0.122125044465065,
0.03398698568344116,
-0.41276952624320984,
-0.2226974368095398,
-0.4781970679759979,
0.3261553943157196,
-0.25130027532577515,
0.1563217043876648,
-0.9885243773460388,
-0.1734127253293991,
0.3202503025531769,
-0.27304062247276306,
0.568612813949585,
-0.3985195457935333,
-1.0266402959823608,
-0.17614655196666718,
-0.23872463405132294,
0.16067852079868317,
0.5106574296951294,
-0.6205357313156128,
0.5034875273704529,
0.4198535084724426,
0.11871764808893204,
-0.6744319796562195,
-0.70659339427948,
0.26713496446609497,
-0.17828145623207092,
-0.09878218173980713,
0.4249769151210785,
-0.115544892847538,
-0.31588438153266907,
-0.11824896931648254,
-0.19385094940662384,
-0.12499096244573593,
0.380450576543808,
0.7283489108085632,
0.27698177099227905,
-0.09891968220472336,
0.22001351416110992,
0.214657723903656,
-0.13984842598438263,
0.11043736338615417,
-0.2623060345649719,
0.5143357515335083,
-0.04951445385813713,
-0.5123562812805176,
-0.3698103129863739,
0.5785127878189087,
0.8748462200164795,
-0.31609615683555603,
0.9265400171279907,
0.5240530371665955,
-0.37815025448799133,
-0.250981867313385,
-0.33752718567848206,
-0.1382705271244049,
-0.5707894563674927,
0.09824994206428528,
-0.16715791821479797,
-1.115402340888977,
0.7479069828987122,
-0.19220487773418427,
0.08354027569293976,
0.3562375009059906,
0.6071243286132812,
0.05412644147872925,
1.2387990951538086,
0.9024022817611694,
-0.11672838032245636,
0.4976293742656708,
0.34593334794044495,
0.1641678810119629,
-0.5390321016311646,
-0.35162582993507385,
-0.4886234402656555,
-0.09455644339323044,
-0.6323143243789673,
-0.4037451446056366,
-0.028712142258882523,
0.4143331050872803,
-0.10536366701126099,
0.0072977435775101185,
-0.4035089313983917,
0.8751496076583862,
0.8569772839546204,
0.12093419581651688,
0.4208239018917084,
-0.13090194761753082,
-0.5763132572174072,
0.22591817378997803,
-0.36325138807296753,
-0.7024368047714233,
1.0770072937011719,
0.426659494638443,
0.6214908361434937,
0.09959886223077774,
0.8280278444290161,
0.25408101081848145,
0.23970352113246918,
-0.5049673318862915,
0.5004709959030151,
-0.35765787959098816,
-0.9432932734489441,
-0.4412796199321747,
-0.2124093621969223,
-0.9163071513175964,
0.10566973686218262,
-0.31513962149620056,
-0.9874353408813477,
0.16484937071800232,
0.15155449509620667,
-0.30318135023117065,
0.639691948890686,
-0.6525534391403198,
0.557615339756012,
-0.13963140547275543,
-0.3821532130241394,
0.09160511195659637,
-0.5646247863769531,
0.24117662012577057,
-0.3872847855091095,
0.38262680172920227,
0.02123495377600193,
-0.0563843697309494,
0.7650954127311707,
-0.46581536531448364,
1.3753048181533813,
-0.2142399102449417,
-0.41972559690475464,
0.10356369614601135,
0.2911872863769531,
0.9175677299499512,
0.1330760270357132,
-0.21410015225410461,
0.120627261698246,
0.0037810036446899176,
-0.22586356103420258,
-0.423982709646225,
0.6756051182746887,
-0.4027070701122284,
-0.9424033164978027,
-0.16354824602603912,
-0.2310332953929901,
-0.05061620846390724,
0.6979516744613647,
0.5310274362564087,
0.4322383403778076,
0.12406367063522339,
0.2560649812221527,
0.7973322868347168,
-0.3079732656478882,
0.8035433888435364,
0.4319636821746826,
-0.28145262598991394,
-0.13359461724758148,
0.7569496631622314,
-0.015062883496284485,
0.10182817280292511,
0.4557251036167145,
0.4928954243659973,
-0.49321800470352173,
-0.7924039363861084,
-0.47885626554489136,
0.305118203163147,
-0.8634395599365234,
-0.022240789607167244,
-0.404183954000473,
-0.07709132879972458,
-0.30984675884246826,
-0.03204617649316788,
-0.31554096937179565,
-0.3643916845321655,
-0.7520760297775269,
-0.1808081567287445,
0.277029812335968,
1.014617681503296,
-0.09320550411939621,
0.3099335730075836,
-0.7835547924041748,
0.21966417133808136,
0.18416880071163177,
0.6193919777870178,
-0.023404249921441078,
-0.5725957155227661,
-0.10606367886066437,
-0.02128511480987072,
-0.043077677488327026,
-0.8940454721450806,
0.2807053327560425,
0.04939724877476692,
0.4993206858634949,
0.563660204410553,
0.18723100423812866,
0.430855929851532,
-0.604244589805603,
0.668210506439209,
0.07775240391492844,
-1.3442360162734985,
0.23573650419712067,
-0.5175696611404419,
0.024050554260611534,
0.4083280861377716,
0.10296671837568283,
-0.4671659469604492,
-0.6917353868484497,
-0.6410138010978699,
-1.002307415008545,
0.48199981451034546,
-0.1601306051015854,
0.5455346703529358,
0.08114038407802582,
0.6754518151283264,
0.17644326388835907,
0.2769010663032532,
-1.0218828916549683,
-0.44099271297454834,
0.07431391626596451,
-0.23117996752262115,
-0.036733414977788925,
-0.5593189597129822,
-0.24324889481067657,
-0.20597806572914124,
0.2778680920600891,
0.053138792514801025,
0.08415883779525757,
0.10579023510217667,
-0.14679573476314545,
-0.12402626127004623,
0.27085432410240173,
0.6557722091674805,
0.3790484070777893,
0.04350657016038895,
0.45932015776634216,
-0.09884636849164963,
-0.3652243912220001,
-0.011384660378098488,
-0.35891905426979065,
-0.19515171647071838,
0.1788811832666397,
0.4934128224849701,
0.7673061490058899,
0.3644966185092926,
-0.6094679832458496,
0.6349517703056335,
0.19245904684066772,
-0.39770814776420593,
-0.12959034740924835,
-0.05189887061715126,
0.18789106607437134,
0.23024210333824158,
0.5543179512023926,
-0.140428826212883,
-0.1306590437889099,
-0.5881358981132507,
0.389365553855896,
0.4923611879348755,
-0.522903561592102,
-0.41975805163383484,
0.8725038170814514,
-0.06053344905376434,
-0.267376184463501,
0.2579905688762665,
-0.27535220980644226,
-0.6401515007019043,
0.4627722501754761,
0.7781059145927429,
0.6646510362625122,
-0.10852714627981186,
0.2109878957271576,
-0.029879508540034294,
0.5520163178443909,
-0.24601419270038605,
0.18594062328338623,
0.0015800254186615348,
-0.5960339903831482,
-0.2599530816078186,
-0.5744309425354004,
-0.3305847942829132,
0.1647348254919052,
-0.6297627091407776,
0.10786449909210205,
-0.9139633774757385,
0.10854870080947876,
0.09246106445789337,
-0.21557892858982086,
-0.3626460134983063,
-0.03238189220428467,
0.34728360176086426,
0.8727388978004456,
-0.8018919229507446,
0.990267813205719,
0.3802870213985443,
-0.09497842192649841,
-0.8509432077407837,
-0.03263672813773155,
0.16769471764564514,
-1.1199790239334106,
0.6995335817337036,
0.12492865324020386,
-0.028852224349975586,
0.030487364158034325,
-0.7839881181716919,
-0.7805485725402832,
0.7138645648956299,
0.5747355222702026,
-0.6378881335258484,
0.05285071209073067,
0.23166148364543915,
0.4660274088382721,
-0.16882704198360443,
-0.21845699846744537,
0.31311818957328796,
0.6157029867172241,
0.10392332822084427,
-0.6852067708969116,
0.5460952520370483,
-0.09061592072248459,
-0.1627093255519867,
0.4011727571487427,
-0.546554684638977,
0.9740785360336304,
-0.2940274178981781,
-0.7138396501541138,
0.04397789016366005,
0.3397044241428375,
0.009779367595911026,
0.3013732433319092,
0.2622797191143036,
0.22323811054229736,
0.9563127160072327,
0.06463315337896347,
0.8022005558013916,
-0.12296026945114136,
0.30511319637298584,
0.9659285545349121,
-0.3110707104206085,
0.9936204552650452,
0.760614275932312,
0.19709955155849457,
0.6463333964347839,
0.6030082106590271,
-0.08734505623579025,
0.4001319110393524,
0.3987828195095062,
-0.31581002473831177,
-0.23215337097644806,
-0.08021894842386246,
0.014872927218675613,
0.6164602041244507,
0.3216279149055481,
-0.6155693531036377,
-0.12208095192909241,
0.048948030918836594,
0.18266093730926514,
0.04553039371967316,
-0.3732079267501831,
0.7775838375091553,
0.13693928718566895,
-0.40525177121162415,
0.5238723158836365,
0.1999058872461319,
0.7405048608779907,
-0.4084444046020508,
0.04592742398381233,
-0.2630423307418823,
0.052218854427337646,
-0.16531705856323242,
-0.6513441205024719,
0.25005412101745605,
0.03366677090525627,
-0.2699185609817505,
-0.5125986933708191,
0.7023226618766785,
-0.31021419167518616,
-0.31208065152168274,
0.38125815987586975,
0.20852455496788025,
-0.025419848039746284,
-0.25663989782333374,
-0.5011098980903625,
0.16289208829402924,
0.15857455134391785,
-0.3508356213569641,
0.47711601853370667,
0.6779941320419312,
-0.20834112167358398,
0.6264187693595886,
1.0195937156677246,
0.22719809412956238,
0.12077561020851135,
-0.0023240926675498486,
0.8278531432151794,
-0.9092909097671509,
-0.524462878704071,
-1.2546411752700806,
0.2719467878341675,
0.07842250168323517,
-0.22165976464748383,
0.8618325591087341,
0.35229015350341797,
0.4654082655906677,
0.12269686907529831,
0.6698740124702454,
0.41345587372779846,
0.25005343556404114,
-0.6859774589538574,
1.027703046798706,
-0.54851233959198,
0.6229813694953918,
-0.27898380160331726,
-0.4795440435409546,
-0.46498018503189087,
-0.08104368299245834,
0.08697938174009323,
-0.3714497983455658,
0.6399062275886536,
0.8297658562660217,
0.19576610624790192,
-0.1196351945400238,
0.49366357922554016,
0.1445605456829071,
0.19798393547534943,
0.42427533864974976,
0.7390344142913818,
-0.15109314024448395,
0.6114751100540161,
0.04365197941660881,
-0.20394685864448547,
-0.2897733449935913,
-0.9791455864906311,
-0.9903968572616577,
-0.7272836565971375,
-0.06830514967441559,
-0.43200355768203735,
-0.07372865080833435,
0.6082390546798706,
0.43423914909362793,
-0.7408446073532104,
0.005971468053758144,
-0.27267393469810486,
0.3956257402896881,
0.028202319517731667,
-0.17516730725765228,
0.38754794001579285,
0.06250864267349243,
-0.6510457992553711,
0.4667600989341736,
0.37485721707344055,
0.5225085616111755,
-0.34097057580947876,
0.16829898953437805,
0.11316235363483429,
0.19435720145702362,
0.1933039128780365,
0.47627249360084534,
-0.8226577043533325,
-0.37512245774269104,
-0.1537390500307083,
-0.15084463357925415,
-0.09643721580505371,
0.9970545172691345,
-0.5540736317634583,
0.39252007007598877,
0.26252228021621704,
0.6098595261573792,
0.38213956356048584,
-0.2683371305465698,
0.666172206401825,
-1.0211987495422363,
0.23088011145591736,
0.1121649518609047,
0.23608176410198212,
0.03411341831088066,
-0.6288868188858032,
-0.01998118683695793,
0.2587759494781494,
-0.17655068635940552,
-1.1795207262039185,
0.2542232871055603,
-0.7188943028450012,
-0.7257260084152222,
1.3747448921203613,
-0.042539071291685104,
-0.45085474848747253,
-0.32508325576782227,
-0.05091745778918266,
0.2637522220611572,
-0.3061659336090088,
0.7707116603851318,
0.8010676503181458,
0.27104446291923523,
-0.06305275112390518,
-0.3092006742954254,
0.6992762684822083,
0.41739732027053833,
-0.44319310784339905,
0.5053606629371643,
0.016897447407245636,
0.32108116149902344,
0.07201846688985825,
0.47178739309310913,
-0.3119165897369385,
0.009060617536306381,
0.122531957924366,
-0.08367079496383667,
-0.21129339933395386,
-0.14715664088726044,
-0.6857277750968933,
0.3528718054294586,
0.09509727358818054,
-0.22613389790058136
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.02472v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.02472v1
|
Analyzing Temporal Complex Events with Large Language Models? A Benchmark towards Temporal, Long Context Understanding
| 2024-06-04T16:42:17 | 2024-06-04T16:42:17 |
Zhihan Zhang, Yixin Cao, Chenchen Ye, Yunshan Ma, Lizi Liao, Tat-Seng Chua
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The digital landscape is rapidly evolving with an ever-increasing volume of
online news, emphasizing the need for swift and precise analysis of complex
events. We refer to the complex events composed of many news articles over an
extended period as Temporal Complex Event (TCE). This paper proposes a novel
approach using Large Language Models (LLMs) to systematically extract and
analyze the event chain within TCE, characterized by their key points and
timestamps. We establish a benchmark, named TCELongBench, to evaluate the
proficiency of LLMs in handling temporal dynamics and understanding extensive
text. This benchmark encompasses three distinct tasks - reading comprehension,
temporal sequencing, and future event forecasting. In the experiment, we
leverage retrieval-augmented generation (RAG) method and LLMs with long context
window to deal with lengthy news articles of TCE. Our findings indicate that
models with suitable retrievers exhibit comparable performance with those
utilizing long context window.
|
[
-0.25458770990371704,
-1.1275599002838135,
0.7393967509269714,
0.34597131609916687,
-0.41331738233566284,
0.4028491973876953,
-0.3901265263557434,
-0.8876108527183533,
0.043221764266490936,
0.15479165315628052,
-0.716266930103302,
-0.4556012451648712,
-0.37144142389297485,
-0.14661738276481628,
-0.6396211981773376,
0.759791374206543,
-0.23161646723747253,
-0.10283246636390686,
0.34722596406936646,
0.04390053451061249,
-0.1935053914785385,
-0.589425802230835,
-0.8766810894012451,
-0.32251569628715515,
0.4734448194503784,
0.023414889350533485,
0.18534651398658752,
0.504683792591095,
0.29675447940826416,
0.1944383680820465,
-0.42199352383613586,
0.16555199027061462,
-0.6297531127929688,
0.1840064525604248,
-0.4428419768810272,
-0.2081424593925476,
-0.5664926171302795,
-0.04311714693903923,
0.7864608764648438,
0.7506652474403381,
-0.04655837267637253,
0.3465733528137207,
-0.04313769191503525,
0.4794033169746399,
-0.6570785045623779,
0.19875505566596985,
-0.5160233378410339,
0.23220421373844147,
-0.3974485993385315,
-0.4767300486564636,
-0.48417916893959045,
-0.03005949780344963,
0.21869181096553802,
-0.3735484778881073,
0.1955326497554779,
0.0336848683655262,
0.7603286504745483,
-0.14780770242214203,
-0.8535987138748169,
-0.11459748446941376,
-0.9271288514137268,
0.8746249079704285,
-0.5718140006065369,
0.5510715246200562,
0.019491400569677353,
0.49983325600624084,
-0.2951810956001282,
-1.0016560554504395,
-0.6895590424537659,
-0.3603191375732422,
0.33748847246170044,
0.1812048852443695,
-0.07311567664146423,
-0.15361617505550385,
0.3848775327205658,
0.08635764569044113,
-0.4472375214099884,
0.1931476891040802,
0.03411261737346649,
0.11262042075395584,
0.3266172409057617,
0.2829468548297882,
0.21603275835514069,
-0.23058673739433289,
-0.34489932656288147,
0.19776885211467743,
-0.39178481698036194,
0.06096803396940231,
0.11625004559755325,
-0.0659780353307724,
-0.20630525052547455,
0.6399348378181458,
-0.334107905626297,
0.6527283787727356,
-0.004987004678696394,
-0.2131161093711853,
0.025169553235173225,
-0.32335135340690613,
-0.1626659333705902,
0.02996024675667286,
0.41133663058280945,
0.4127189517021179,
0.30419525504112244,
-0.49868693947792053,
-0.06759334355592728,
-0.24006527662277222,
0.045615196228027344,
-0.8242532014846802,
0.3356007933616638,
0.3745051622390747,
-0.46170395612716675,
-0.23859938979148865,
-0.006739732343703508,
-1.0065516233444214,
-0.28117653727531433,
-0.5595725774765015,
0.10396040976047516,
-0.0708317831158638,
-0.12243165075778961,
0.11654731631278992,
-0.17490530014038086,
0.40819695591926575,
0.4172010123729706,
-0.2638539671897888,
0.229132279753685,
0.9800949692726135,
0.9215825200080872,
-0.506589412689209,
-0.19716928899288177,
-0.9486356377601624,
0.6393904089927673,
-0.27434757351875305,
0.8032527565956116,
-0.5037757158279419,
-0.12593533098697662,
-0.006815226748585701,
0.13666503131389618,
0.08990352600812912,
-0.31959930062294006,
0.6465651988983154,
-0.9990447759628296,
0.04551682248711586,
0.18659934401512146,
-0.6646034717559814,
-0.046746931970119476,
0.5781129002571106,
-0.7138422727584839,
0.7688702940940857,
-0.17409776151180267,
-0.7619143128395081,
0.18426550924777985,
-0.40843120217323303,
-0.3923611640930176,
-0.14998608827590942,
-0.059862859547138214,
-0.3474012613296509,
0.04147166758775711,
0.23543871939182281,
0.5254239439964294,
-0.4581466019153595,
0.8467381000518799,
-0.410626620054245,
-0.11698497086763382,
0.2923162281513214,
-0.45802003145217896,
0.4755572974681854,
0.13425621390342712,
-0.5013141632080078,
0.06131312996149063,
-0.9220532774925232,
-0.08129005879163742,
0.031544409692287445,
-0.3532402813434601,
-0.22842761874198914,
0.37059101462364197,
0.4211657643318176,
0.17390555143356323,
0.29492488503456116,
-0.46101638674736023,
0.39478904008865356,
-0.09476619213819504,
0.42370107769966125,
0.7135769724845886,
0.2643383741378784,
0.367015540599823,
-0.07645128667354584,
0.4292009472846985,
0.23490984737873077,
0.05480967089533806,
-0.1905156970024109,
0.1958828717470169,
-0.4943067133426666,
0.07649548351764679,
0.2366376519203186,
0.45557302236557007,
-0.8515449166297913,
0.26021167635917664,
-0.5642238855361938,
-0.3556220233440399,
0.35457032918930054,
-0.21558645367622375,
0.19418981671333313,
0.41386276483535767,
0.2063494324684143,
0.016169071197509766,
-0.5396314859390259,
-0.5969247817993164,
-0.5553894639015198,
0.07393445074558258,
-0.16671866178512573,
0.0861716940999031,
0.5225015878677368,
-0.3367900252342224,
0.8646793365478516,
-0.4888571500778198,
0.15240693092346191,
-0.24850955605506897,
0.5491810441017151,
0.10295949876308441,
0.266274631023407,
0.3912646472454071,
-0.8336929678916931,
-0.19374686479568481,
0.18643847107887268,
-0.6010974645614624,
-0.20948344469070435,
-0.31721433997154236,
0.008556687273085117,
0.45838692784309387,
0.8711308240890503,
-0.3080781400203705,
0.18822528421878815,
0.6157832741737366,
-0.4621613323688507,
0.8851627111434937,
0.139237180352211,
0.16788548231124878,
-1.1378003358840942,
0.3694218397140503,
0.11701356619596481,
-0.5535697340965271,
-0.6364628672599792,
0.11708331108093262,
0.26070064306259155,
-0.1711196005344391,
-0.44766613841056824,
0.9870447516441345,
-0.5859144330024719,
-0.2885405421257019,
-0.24313905835151672,
0.33584120869636536,
-0.09744632244110107,
0.386861115694046,
0.24150577187538147,
0.39036184549331665,
0.035668741911649704,
-0.540590226650238,
0.30732953548431396,
-0.36152392625808716,
-0.7722657918930054,
0.2665483057498932,
-0.6243332624435425,
0.06666409969329834,
-0.2786533534526825,
0.4572904407978058,
-0.41276833415031433,
-0.19988474249839783,
-0.21935273706912994,
-0.17895227670669556,
0.43047937750816345,
-0.2058938443660736,
-0.7477756142616272,
-0.2964547574520111,
-0.15605808794498444,
0.48386260867118835,
-0.07402533292770386,
-0.47327277064323425,
0.9739526510238647,
0.4041817784309387,
-0.21630023419857025,
-0.6699990034103394,
-0.28612416982650757,
0.3315381407737732,
-0.1529093086719513,
-0.6041900515556335,
0.35888561606407166,
-0.12116529047489166,
-0.5220193266868591,
-0.09839195758104324,
-0.38289913535118103,
-0.335369735956192,
0.17344307899475098,
-0.14863631129264832,
0.06036706268787384,
-0.32712286710739136,
0.12284491956233978,
-0.02616090327501297,
-0.05495829880237579,
-0.04487760365009308,
-0.13644899427890778,
0.8393692374229431,
-0.06662173569202423,
-0.05195288360118866,
-0.41453123092651367,
0.4444107413291931,
0.7320446372032166,
-0.4120246469974518,
0.8041552901268005,
0.6302624940872192,
-0.4848051369190216,
-0.16257335245609283,
-0.8586461544036865,
-0.059578947722911835,
-0.37643951177597046,
0.6050634980201721,
-0.34711340069770813,
-0.8549964427947998,
0.7571404576301575,
-0.3882302939891815,
-0.00527801550924778,
0.4451521039009094,
0.4164748787879944,
-0.004631164949387312,
1.0625646114349365,
0.5058451294898987,
-0.19178065657615662,
0.7627428770065308,
-0.20303389430046082,
-0.07956255972385406,
-0.7758303284645081,
-0.30221816897392273,
-0.4233388602733612,
-0.21959617733955383,
-0.28304505348205566,
-0.41777145862579346,
0.43015506863594055,
0.3897835910320282,
-0.3857916295528412,
-0.08480086922645569,
0.16912700235843658,
0.5788205862045288,
0.2172831892967224,
-0.00038182048592716455,
0.6248406171798706,
-0.18328139185905457,
0.2653464078903198,
0.1232009306550026,
-0.37186670303344727,
-0.48665353655815125,
0.6200288534164429,
0.367754727602005,
0.5941352844238281,
0.1968505084514618,
0.1198151484131813,
0.12245706468820572,
0.08150887489318848,
-0.7356272339820862,
0.4639721214771271,
-0.12352511286735535,
-0.5735912919044495,
-0.09267544001340866,
-0.5266762971878052,
-1.0108822584152222,
-0.0037067211233079433,
-0.2590113878250122,
-0.7851439714431763,
0.19208119809627533,
-0.36730507016181946,
-0.09660153836011887,
0.4693855047225952,
-0.31886863708496094,
0.7768641710281372,
-0.21996505558490753,
-0.40429261326789856,
-0.4635324478149414,
-0.6120786070823669,
0.3518308103084564,
-0.267295241355896,
0.29678183794021606,
-0.27645790576934814,
-0.3119818866252899,
0.7411836981773376,
0.018418684601783752,
0.7165403962135315,
0.15096566081047058,
0.06783624738454819,
0.0673823282122612,
0.29834944009780884,
0.7948329448699951,
0.2189103662967682,
-0.22221462428569794,
-0.06432057917118073,
0.21549752354621887,
-0.49805206060409546,
-0.39336082339286804,
0.6877099275588989,
-0.6492855548858643,
-0.38603100180625916,
-0.5111316442489624,
-0.5441864132881165,
-0.29189708828926086,
0.20306240022182465,
-0.02731809765100479,
0.8554346561431885,
-0.3672252893447876,
0.2959628701210022,
0.47187578678131104,
-0.19338835775852203,
0.7175147533416748,
0.9649129509925842,
-0.0735296681523323,
0.0384729839861393,
0.3452887535095215,
0.13957619667053223,
0.14634133875370026,
0.5973417162895203,
0.302845299243927,
-0.09311819076538086,
-0.6010257601737976,
-0.15150129795074463,
0.2631279528141022,
-0.48939064145088196,
-0.09073416143655777,
-0.930347740650177,
-0.2147391438484192,
-0.16550575196743011,
-0.13423658907413483,
-0.19476239383220673,
-0.29774704575538635,
-0.3583650588989258,
-0.009854347445070744,
0.08387215435504913,
0.5597975254058838,
0.27513471245765686,
0.3682984709739685,
-1.141771912574768,
0.5272676944732666,
0.1400630623102188,
0.5264440774917603,
0.23482394218444824,
-0.23641322553157806,
-0.24810336530208588,
-0.17155088484287262,
-0.36748620867729187,
-0.839051365852356,
0.3622429668903351,
0.07718408852815628,
0.5185576677322388,
0.16949214041233063,
0.08726130425930023,
0.8639333248138428,
-0.7221325635910034,
0.7926172018051147,
-0.11983149498701096,
-1.1279528141021729,
0.5275039076805115,
-0.6169822216033936,
0.5614992380142212,
0.2349218726158142,
0.32242488861083984,
-0.8668057322502136,
-0.39276251196861267,
-0.5317720770835876,
-0.8843751549720764,
0.6313976645469666,
0.0671565905213356,
-0.20207074284553528,
-0.17281420528888702,
0.5558456182479858,
-0.059269919991493225,
0.17448942363262177,
-0.8193919658660889,
0.13580645620822906,
0.4495472311973572,
-0.026408616453409195,
-0.15521195530891418,
-0.6466923356056213,
0.07555627822875977,
0.18098057806491852,
0.498028963804245,
-0.03768534958362579,
-0.15385399758815765,
0.2271650731563568,
-0.2903789281845093,
-0.14025458693504333,
0.47232866287231445,
0.6186643242835999,
1.0712189674377441,
-0.2261916846036911,
0.060767896473407745,
0.2108718454837799,
-0.40819838643074036,
-0.19972270727157593,
0.15316294133663177,
0.22692832350730896,
-0.07538899779319763,
0.7339486479759216,
0.4452231526374817,
0.24578486382961273,
-1.0188276767730713,
0.44709569215774536,
-0.23057803511619568,
0.34261634945869446,
-0.5479117035865784,
-0.37876951694488525,
0.019457735121250153,
0.5955339074134827,
0.7428557276725769,
-0.5062001943588257,
0.23133769631385803,
-0.8988412618637085,
0.2936294376850128,
0.18445898592472076,
-0.2680057883262634,
-0.32369130849838257,
0.6551958322525024,
0.26901763677597046,
0.06693083792924881,
0.5069468021392822,
-0.11299432069063187,
-0.527104914188385,
0.9178034663200378,
0.5422462821006775,
0.8288495540618896,
-0.013589689508080482,
-0.04319664463400841,
0.3177500069141388,
0.1483260989189148,
-0.27506306767463684,
0.2903556823730469,
0.1702401041984558,
-0.32932284474372864,
-1.0122714042663574,
-0.7815624475479126,
-0.25758227705955505,
0.17208245396614075,
-0.6431904435157776,
0.31820499897003174,
-0.0023416406475007534,
-0.08333905041217804,
0.10176193714141846,
0.3520270884037018,
-0.596381425857544,
0.06256967782974243,
0.15129469335079193,
1.088789701461792,
-0.5600577592849731,
0.8281294703483582,
0.33102428913116455,
0.08062951266765594,
-0.5000647306442261,
0.31642431020736694,
0.04798520356416702,
-0.4527868926525116,
0.866945207118988,
0.08607689291238785,
-0.0937567800283432,
0.02405901998281479,
-0.36936765909194946,
-0.6730533242225647,
1.038589358329773,
0.18008048832416534,
-1.0018725395202637,
-0.26273590326309204,
-0.13175661861896515,
0.6496456861495972,
-0.2106115072965622,
0.07639622688293457,
0.6354881525039673,
0.4750520884990692,
-0.016646184027194977,
-1.0171183347702026,
-0.18235720694065094,
-0.0743311196565628,
-0.12747877836227417,
0.5295844078063965,
-0.5726503729820251,
0.6669149398803711,
0.046342022716999054,
-0.5465555787086487,
0.08629737794399261,
0.7429646849632263,
0.022217141464352608,
0.6863925457000732,
0.4858857989311218,
0.22513936460018158,
0.5689676403999329,
-0.04126369580626488,
1.204140543937683,
-0.4232557713985443,
0.4789736866950989,
1.3982384204864502,
-0.15332281589508057,
0.9445194602012634,
0.2774449288845062,
0.08588909357786179,
0.37295103073120117,
0.5005840063095093,
0.3276660144329071,
0.1935654729604721,
0.06599103659391403,
-0.39950546622276306,
-0.27819034457206726,
-0.17537571489810944,
-0.25030940771102905,
0.37642934918403625,
0.34936633706092834,
-0.10356065630912781,
-0.5301938652992249,
0.11270736157894135,
0.0807509571313858,
0.052974723279476166,
-0.7030575275421143,
0.8557354807853699,
0.11555550992488861,
-0.560017466545105,
0.11595800518989563,
0.10255568474531174,
0.3664591610431671,
-0.6159460544586182,
0.2193959504365921,
0.0025300909765064716,
0.29277849197387695,
0.10475173592567444,
-1.007018804550171,
0.36921751499176025,
0.10022345185279846,
-0.30226364731788635,
0.20919157564640045,
0.39838892221450806,
-0.45563703775405884,
-0.5804651975631714,
0.4925636947154999,
0.5723627805709839,
-0.20993515849113464,
-0.16651538014411926,
-0.44342219829559326,
0.28985628485679626,
-0.36559996008872986,
-0.5534719824790955,
0.19462886452674866,
0.710382878780365,
-0.2979068458080292,
0.7193999886512756,
0.48935508728027344,
-0.02575233206152916,
0.05323219299316406,
0.20002681016921997,
0.5975481867790222,
-1.0538756847381592,
-0.41451457142829895,
-0.9795951843261719,
0.24789050221443176,
-0.235975980758667,
-0.127403125166893,
0.5251511335372925,
0.7432464957237244,
0.6173363924026489,
0.11292759329080582,
0.3384338617324829,
0.1557861715555191,
0.6416314244270325,
-0.623153567314148,
0.3909450173377991,
-0.7120474576950073,
0.2276456207036972,
-0.07134098559617996,
-0.9379704594612122,
-0.3171902894973755,
-0.123880535364151,
-0.2717585563659668,
-0.25260308384895325,
0.749940037727356,
0.29854825139045715,
-0.19277629256248474,
-0.031062938272953033,
0.03625889867544174,
0.542317807674408,
0.6687145829200745,
0.4846590459346771,
0.929175615310669,
-0.03755338862538338,
0.48860853910446167,
-0.13742448389530182,
-0.22546212375164032,
-0.32266858220100403,
-1.2464091777801514,
-0.9975383281707764,
-0.621647298336029,
-0.0881933718919754,
-0.2793165445327759,
0.3328750431537628,
0.9679791331291199,
0.39327529072761536,
-0.6138185858726501,
-0.2820398211479187,
0.2424020618200302,
-0.08941483497619629,
-0.17463621497154236,
-0.27016711235046387,
0.624395489692688,
-0.30486321449279785,
-0.9696223139762878,
0.2696722149848938,
0.23578466475009918,
0.10345317423343658,
0.02454066090285778,
0.4597984552383423,
-0.1861596405506134,
-0.06015606224536896,
1.1487834453582764,
0.28491586446762085,
-0.5841542482376099,
-0.45121505856513977,
0.023937059566378593,
-0.10810177773237228,
-0.19809246063232422,
1.0441548824310303,
-0.6169911623001099,
0.4760857820510864,
0.7165371179580688,
0.584341287612915,
0.933205246925354,
-0.01770191080868244,
0.6809174418449402,
-0.6905565857887268,
0.21419231593608856,
0.3396184742450714,
0.36965706944465637,
-0.12665754556655884,
-0.17401845753192902,
0.5712187886238098,
-0.06057945638895035,
-0.674136221408844,
-0.9065389633178711,
0.2113247662782669,
-1.4902666807174683,
-0.719402015209198,
1.2906553745269775,
0.2376631647348404,
-0.4035464823246002,
-0.24099746346473694,
-0.06030415743589401,
0.4824029803276062,
-0.14015451073646545,
0.8747983574867249,
0.6981843709945679,
0.10399945080280304,
-0.08283928036689758,
-0.8259788751602173,
0.07116451859474182,
-0.06820108741521835,
-0.8932176232337952,
0.18078985810279846,
0.513261079788208,
0.25124162435531616,
0.013268728740513325,
0.282905250787735,
-0.10380737483501434,
0.297096312046051,
-0.4114493131637573,
-0.1582089513540268,
0.010920965112745762,
-0.4551178514957428,
-0.18305715918540955,
0.2519219219684601,
-0.21068407595157623,
0.4225755035877228
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.02469v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.02469v1
|
Landscape-Aware Growing: The Power of a Little LAG
| 2024-06-04T16:38:57 | 2024-06-04T16:38:57 |
Stefani Karp, Nikunj Saunshi, Sobhan Miryoosefi, Sashank J. Reddi, Sanjiv Kumar
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Recently, there has been increasing interest in efficient pretraining
paradigms for training Transformer-based models. Several recent approaches use
smaller models to initialize larger models in order to save computation (e.g.,
stacking and fusion). In this work, we study the fundamental question of how to
select the best growing strategy from a given pool of growing strategies. Prior
works have extensively focused on loss- and/or function-preserving behavior at
initialization or simply performance at the end of training. Instead, we
identify that behavior at initialization can be misleading as a predictor of
final performance and present an alternative perspective based on early
training dynamics, which we call "landscape-aware growing (LAG)". We perform
extensive analysis of correlation of the final performance with performance in
the initial steps of training and find early and more accurate predictions of
the optimal growing strategy (i.e., with only a small "lag" after
initialization). This perspective also motivates an adaptive strategy for
gradual stacking.
|
[
-0.5240594744682312,
-0.7903236150741577,
0.18144455552101135,
0.30678853392601013,
-0.265872061252594,
0.2532455623149872,
0.1522994041442871,
-0.5713573694229126,
0.2224443107843399,
0.35971760749816895,
-0.965674877166748,
0.07030780613422394,
-0.7701743245124817,
-0.19856593012809753,
-0.11259675770998001,
1.067989706993103,
0.2850792109966278,
-0.08211299031972885,
-0.24226264655590057,
-0.31124749779701233,
-0.78937166929245,
-0.08451789617538452,
-0.922766387462616,
-0.5575089454650879,
0.36595797538757324,
0.22531434893608093,
0.8553686141967773,
1.123475193977356,
0.5837309956550598,
0.21445178985595703,
-0.40998730063438416,
-0.12548193335533142,
-0.6338514685630798,
0.22388409078121185,
0.3386712372303009,
-0.6760022044181824,
-0.1368330717086792,
-0.14516665041446686,
0.697637140750885,
0.7403267025947571,
-0.2239832878112793,
0.47864845395088196,
-0.04674683138728142,
0.6839962601661682,
-0.46190229058265686,
-0.13643778860569,
-0.6055833101272583,
0.5542693138122559,
-0.47962695360183716,
-0.4649443030357361,
-0.45063257217407227,
-0.06236770376563072,
0.3582029640674591,
-0.5573118925094604,
0.5086447596549988,
0.25328096747398376,
0.8569980263710022,
0.6638509035110474,
-0.317865788936615,
0.21265433728694916,
-0.980461061000824,
0.4751412570476532,
-0.22433653473854065,
0.16307418048381805,
-0.12521372735500336,
0.5716355443000793,
-0.0925191193819046,
-0.575147807598114,
-0.3040394186973572,
0.07322714477777481,
-0.051354777067899704,
0.29475924372673035,
-0.36169105768203735,
-0.07460486143827438,
0.5758722424507141,
0.48498743772506714,
-0.3883393108844757,
0.26251742243766785,
-0.2560473680496216,
-0.002600767184048891,
0.4128921926021576,
0.06037018075585365,
0.10329544544219971,
0.030523652210831642,
-0.49539873003959656,
-0.4806493818759918,
-0.9014448523521423,
0.6611696481704712,
-0.008471645414829254,
0.3673671782016754,
-0.1121254488825798,
0.34525159001350403,
0.3177105486392975,
0.5594183206558228,
0.5024032592773438,
0.2261841744184494,
0.032906901091337204,
-0.0919952243566513,
-0.28090086579322815,
0.000855404359754175,
0.34043028950691223,
0.2570447623729706,
-0.3271940052509308,
-0.10424583405256271,
-0.22357657551765442,
0.2267669141292572,
0.4889971613883972,
-0.862698495388031,
-0.43104085326194763,
0.0021510645747184753,
-0.5586835741996765,
-0.5514419674873352,
-0.2891087234020233,
-0.902287483215332,
-0.472746878862381,
0.16633877158164978,
0.3738146722316742,
-0.16206422448158264,
-0.3627595007419586,
-0.3228519856929779,
-0.09743653237819672,
0.39663198590278625,
0.11996499449014664,
-0.954898476600647,
0.24639049172401428,
0.4654427468776703,
1.0767029523849487,
-0.2889598309993744,
0.0055716014467179775,
-0.6328097581863403,
-0.2177191823720932,
-0.7784671187400818,
0.5649049282073975,
-0.042336929589509964,
-0.8025278449058533,
-0.016071707010269165,
-0.06419343501329422,
-0.08421474695205688,
-0.5153458714485168,
0.3426618278026581,
-1.032206416130066,
0.33772173523902893,
-0.4232143461704254,
-0.18586766719818115,
-0.06249295920133591,
0.15276440978050232,
-0.782760739326477,
1.1334792375564575,
0.23190025985240936,
-0.9067362546920776,
0.9696138501167297,
-1.1387975215911865,
-0.36599835753440857,
0.3236241042613983,
-0.10782681405544281,
-0.7265415191650391,
0.21022149920463562,
0.02058633230626583,
0.34261563420295715,
0.034737277776002884,
-0.3785128891468048,
-0.11775748431682587,
0.0990288183093071,
-0.27730974555015564,
-0.12071634829044342,
0.7321327924728394,
0.18624302744865417,
-0.4505092203617096,
0.009665864519774914,
-0.5326667428016663,
0.20587526261806488,
0.15960285067558289,
-0.08272053301334381,
-0.28660136461257935,
0.2253892868757248,
-0.40174490213394165,
-0.026123952120542526,
0.04696562513709068,
-0.36437973380088806,
0.1942032128572464,
-0.6244245767593384,
0.21842552721500397,
0.5641301870346069,
0.25342366099357605,
0.8247227072715759,
-0.5433726906776428,
0.6811560988426208,
0.23590348660945892,
0.20571556687355042,
-0.5073157548904419,
-0.2772172689437866,
-0.8742810487747192,
-0.05539179965853691,
0.30257153511047363,
0.3485066294670105,
-0.7214793562889099,
0.20564937591552734,
-0.6061676144599915,
-0.786283552646637,
-0.10694073140621185,
0.11390264332294464,
0.08053149282932281,
0.4372314512729645,
0.4488266408443451,
-0.5463640093803406,
-0.4720284342765808,
-0.6747413873672485,
0.1015220433473587,
0.1180078461766243,
0.03759273514151573,
0.3507723808288574,
0.28254419565200806,
-0.30882126092910767,
1.2546539306640625,
-0.6357147097587585,
-0.13481120765209198,
-0.08646395057439804,
0.3223583698272705,
0.3765769898891449,
0.5113340020179749,
1.19212806224823,
-0.9403772354125977,
-0.7245984077453613,
0.15873418748378754,
-0.4856998026371002,
0.17376215755939484,
-0.2453252524137497,
-0.07476997375488281,
-0.29050931334495544,
0.28998568654060364,
-0.7990431189537048,
0.3215978741645813,
0.6411154866218567,
-0.12062092870473862,
0.28476759791374207,
-0.40093255043029785,
-0.12333200126886368,
-0.7310724258422852,
-0.2856917083263397,
0.30239585041999817,
-0.24763481318950653,
-0.7532778978347778,
0.1776934713125229,
-0.20074094831943512,
0.08427475392818451,
-0.2223433256149292,
0.17244018614292145,
-0.31492576003074646,
-0.14716574549674988,
-0.44568780064582825,
-0.2694384753704071,
-0.20679901540279388,
0.1767732948064804,
-0.19626300036907196,
1.042657732963562,
0.891320526599884,
-1.0503064393997192,
-0.13889247179031372,
-0.02141571044921875,
-0.04217043146491051,
0.2556931674480438,
-0.48727887868881226,
-0.10297960042953491,
-0.24894680082798004,
0.46236252784729004,
-0.5802131295204163,
-0.19881199300289154,
-0.09302729368209839,
-0.45686784386634827,
0.3178784251213074,
-0.1666899472475052,
-0.20634496212005615,
-0.8017522692680359,
-0.30606910586357117,
0.3961833119392395,
0.6828486323356628,
-0.8762553930282593,
0.7712626457214355,
0.33137205243110657,
0.2628030478954315,
-0.2405584305524826,
-0.3316026031970978,
-0.28657442331314087,
-0.7030397057533264,
-0.6472715139389038,
0.6212581396102905,
0.004794278182089329,
0.0028768484480679035,
-0.4185769557952881,
-0.26801544427871704,
-0.010267721489071846,
0.22946177423000336,
0.3919340968132019,
0.17057070136070251,
-0.41094574332237244,
-0.055465638637542725,
-0.04146534204483032,
-0.2070370763540268,
0.2861727178096771,
-0.4240742623806,
0.41982388496398926,
-0.38381555676460266,
-0.17034600675106049,
-0.025760386139154434,
-0.08735194057226181,
0.7561740279197693,
-0.08505208045244217,
0.5736767053604126,
0.6585698127746582,
-0.31058046221733093,
-0.3965699374675751,
-0.1640719473361969,
-0.13054268062114716,
-0.5694743394851685,
0.20922325551509857,
-0.1654559224843979,
-0.5587055087089539,
0.3900757431983948,
-0.7272080779075623,
0.47767874598503113,
0.792535126209259,
0.25451359152793884,
-0.6183772087097168,
0.9948309063911438,
1.3660997152328491,
0.2667779326438904,
0.6840736269950867,
-0.8569298386573792,
0.21153424680233002,
-0.8545477986335754,
-0.3668162524700165,
-0.31835001707077026,
-0.5354782342910767,
-0.8340363502502441,
-0.5828732848167419,
0.4549580216407776,
0.12291967868804932,
-0.2722298204898834,
0.4475782513618469,
-0.7711271643638611,
0.47175806760787964,
0.4295971691608429,
-0.1283816248178482,
-0.20035414397716522,
0.004864130634814501,
0.048340942710638046,
-0.32957199215888977,
-1.212809681892395,
-0.21878086030483246,
0.846098005771637,
0.489811509847641,
0.3665952682495117,
0.20596455037593842,
0.4548112452030182,
0.5663851499557495,
0.5048254132270813,
-0.8235708475112915,
0.38137540221214294,
-0.10358176380395889,
-0.21230414509773254,
-0.40731802582740784,
-0.3311799168586731,
-1.496193528175354,
0.4547998309135437,
-0.6394811868667603,
-0.6587156057357788,
-0.06467413902282715,
0.6883095502853394,
-0.8818012475967407,
0.5108038187026978,
-0.5199745297431946,
0.6694316267967224,
-0.6465834975242615,
-0.3807627260684967,
-0.2739786207675934,
-0.6540257334709167,
0.1747020035982132,
-0.09083891659975052,
0.31104373931884766,
0.27628394961357117,
0.1313609629869461,
0.9500318169593811,
-0.28916171193122864,
0.5421765446662903,
-0.5114299654960632,
0.292019784450531,
0.41541793942451477,
0.10153591632843018,
0.45449504256248474,
-0.22994504868984222,
0.6323017477989197,
0.06344067305326462,
0.062037475407123566,
-0.4439583122730255,
-0.5753474831581116,
0.5258515477180481,
-1.0586756467819214,
-0.7041902542114258,
-0.4579697549343109,
0.0277837086468935,
-0.3746430277824402,
0.23380187153816223,
0.5705995559692383,
-0.21550312638282776,
-0.3883056640625,
0.5055920481681824,
1.0188406705856323,
0.2885681986808777,
0.7296168208122253,
0.1559358835220337,
-0.546072244644165,
-0.22231610119342804,
0.6481953859329224,
0.2629172205924988,
0.13092422485351562,
0.25610265135765076,
0.5558183789253235,
-0.05131854861974716,
-0.5047173500061035,
-0.47028017044067383,
-0.08860079944133759,
-0.16045503318309784,
-0.12669602036476135,
-0.33903124928474426,
-0.3627830147743225,
0.1674942672252655,
-0.27679234743118286,
-0.4766766428947449,
0.07577574998140335,
-0.10754222422838211,
-0.14620018005371094,
0.25637808442115784,
0.7545613646507263,
-0.09428144246339798,
1.3630093336105347,
-0.49179014563560486,
-0.05667944997549057,
0.4519973397254944,
0.12274305522441864,
0.08809970319271088,
-0.3214018940925598,
-0.4180428683757782,
0.20067739486694336,
-0.8369923830032349,
-0.7918442487716675,
0.3731847405433655,
0.16372349858283997,
0.4628899097442627,
0.7492138147354126,
-0.3726058006286621,
0.5547450184822083,
-0.36532559990882874,
1.090648889541626,
0.7692390084266663,
-0.5090287327766418,
0.7806286215782166,
-0.4012756943702698,
0.4017791152000427,
0.3033897876739502,
0.2588740289211273,
-0.19589410722255707,
0.36683717370033264,
-1.043748140335083,
-0.9678213000297546,
0.46717390418052673,
0.09842284023761749,
0.24797378480434418,
0.32266804575920105,
0.3293192684650421,
0.04406321421265602,
0.14941023290157318,
-0.9793912172317505,
-0.18178239464759827,
-0.31043410301208496,
0.6402882933616638,
0.01707020029425621,
0.09791376441717148,
-0.5249366164207458,
-0.4711434543132782,
0.4424847960472107,
-0.2873854637145996,
0.242452010512352,
-0.238080695271492,
0.04136527702212334,
-0.49716266989707947,
-0.2515886425971985,
0.29231715202331543,
0.15847206115722656,
0.0073385089635849,
-0.14891858398914337,
0.5991045236587524,
-0.2549372613430023,
0.1672598123550415,
-0.39910024404525757,
-0.5422965288162231,
-0.042722780257463455,
0.24411556124687195,
1.075984001159668,
0.49051132798194885,
-0.16011273860931396,
0.6647891998291016,
0.10230108350515366,
-0.21991290152072906,
-0.18324710428714752,
0.45075294375419617,
-0.3170771300792694,
0.41444525122642517,
0.6232312321662903,
0.8722296357154846,
-0.1932763010263443,
-0.04377969726920128,
0.0632910504937172,
0.6355029940605164,
-0.39385443925857544,
-0.3785570561885834,
0.7834511995315552,
0.2505910396575928,
-0.6455746293067932,
0.32538390159606934,
-0.01915244199335575,
-0.4464065432548523,
0.9134820699691772,
0.4330565333366394,
0.8513264060020447,
-0.08590833842754364,
0.21642978489398956,
0.554643988609314,
0.30948543548583984,
-0.18933513760566711,
-0.3853938579559326,
-0.23087139427661896,
-0.7141836285591125,
-0.3291371464729309,
-0.5277299284934998,
-0.10391540080308914,
0.1361657828092575,
-0.6049718856811523,
0.2023855447769165,
-0.7688497304916382,
-0.9754852056503296,
-0.027091320604085922,
0.15777574479579926,
-0.9919562935829163,
0.3623116612434387,
-0.014238232746720314,
1.1728767156600952,
-0.9413867592811584,
0.35986489057540894,
0.74869304895401,
0.08237892389297485,
-0.5605804920196533,
0.04085994139313698,
-0.11803717166185379,
-0.5107744932174683,
0.5928085446357727,
0.29643651843070984,
-0.4778463840484619,
-0.0362883135676384,
-0.6588239669799805,
-1.2029695510864258,
1.5826280117034912,
-0.0829920545220375,
-0.4816703796386719,
0.036322660744190216,
-0.2926006317138672,
0.7502769827842712,
-0.6202877163887024,
0.15420879423618317,
0.27384406328201294,
0.12185541540384293,
0.5801329016685486,
-0.5401259064674377,
-0.48176032304763794,
-0.00952629279345274,
0.4224104583263397,
0.2067813128232956,
-0.8394257426261902,
0.800053060054779,
-0.42305782437324524,
-0.6122803092002869,
-0.17848002910614014,
0.9530186057090759,
0.05711716413497925,
0.2930038869380951,
0.9806748628616333,
0.5358706712722778,
0.808402419090271,
-0.2618759572505951,
1.0025949478149414,
-0.814388632774353,
0.2557244896888733,
0.8479461669921875,
0.3449382781982422,
0.9444058537483215,
0.45376357436180115,
-0.3563109338283539,
0.5044541358947754,
1.1885274648666382,
-0.16783758997917175,
0.9843019247055054,
0.05807333439588547,
-0.04297935217618942,
-0.22698651254177094,
0.14215846359729767,
-0.6007550358772278,
0.3912498950958252,
0.11316656321287155,
-0.3041772246360779,
-0.3121861517429352,
-0.1406749188899994,
-0.12818560004234314,
-0.2074166238307953,
-0.5011512637138367,
0.5739092230796814,
-0.21315357089042664,
-0.7738111615180969,
0.11233074218034744,
-0.05819454416632652,
0.8226141333580017,
-0.7920058965682983,
0.25381407141685486,
-0.04063672572374344,
-0.12029687315225601,
-0.4251090884208679,
-0.42345380783081055,
0.33630409836769104,
-0.24609889090061188,
-0.30278444290161133,
-0.5972913503646851,
0.4076841175556183,
0.06832578033208847,
-0.09821885824203491,
0.16705407202243805,
0.6712104082107544,
-0.33127373456954956,
0.5103100538253784,
-0.4260886013507843,
-0.2366461306810379,
-0.1295837163925171,
-0.3116324841976166,
0.5544261932373047,
0.27402183413505554,
-0.08969444781541824,
0.8996184468269348,
0.8853707909584045,
0.16037997603416443,
0.22839704155921936,
-0.455277681350708,
0.9806955456733704,
-0.06192847713828087,
-0.6808374524116516,
-0.7179654836654663,
0.478245347738266,
-0.4068054258823395,
-0.3396773636341095,
0.6487556099891663,
0.614321768283844,
0.4969671666622162,
0.05089676380157471,
0.6408073306083679,
-0.011206457391381264,
0.029608046635985374,
-0.17139680683612823,
0.6836929321289062,
-0.3631138205528259,
0.26277342438697815,
0.1750059872865677,
-0.9282246232032776,
-0.01240946538746357,
0.8903408646583557,
-0.5363803505897522,
0.09432325512170792,
0.4242517054080963,
0.5962348580360413,
-0.08064062148332596,
0.15781331062316895,
0.2081480473279953,
0.3137018382549286,
0.30333858728408813,
0.06711560487747192,
0.43557316064834595,
-0.22901400923728943,
0.09817041456699371,
-0.11682933568954468,
-0.6838164329528809,
-0.14010761678218842,
-1.0106585025787354,
-0.4354090094566345,
-0.29997068643569946,
-0.402216374874115,
-0.41172128915786743,
-0.41617366671562195,
0.7307038307189941,
1.150810956954956,
-0.5284312963485718,
-0.06378958374261856,
-0.22522976994514465,
-0.18352484703063965,
-0.5745702385902405,
-0.20938833057880402,
0.10819131880998611,
-0.0646892562508583,
-0.026024049147963524,
0.40674614906311035,
0.2468462884426117,
0.3542390763759613,
-0.5679684281349182,
-0.2820263206958771,
0.22999952733516693,
0.25574466586112976,
0.6676265597343445,
0.7961181998252869,
-0.3958871364593506,
-0.20077554881572723,
-0.07299812883138657,
0.24957430362701416,
0.30024150013923645,
0.7447450757026672,
-1.033190369606018,
0.5337420105934143,
0.029947848990559578,
0.7247886061668396,
0.948198139667511,
0.014260604046285152,
0.5617284178733826,
-0.7644132375717163,
-0.15997634828090668,
0.1597987860441208,
0.15850281715393066,
0.29622596502304077,
-0.46757772564888,
0.4585115611553192,
0.2883736193180084,
-0.5268853902816772,
-0.7374765276908875,
0.2638779580593109,
-0.6792280077934265,
0.17181085050106049,
0.469637006521225,
-0.0025141346268355846,
-0.45759040117263794,
0.5662760138511658,
0.017045779153704643,
0.06373660266399384,
0.05037469416856766,
1.0776666402816772,
0.46736934781074524,
-0.6030048131942749,
-0.20000812411308289,
-0.43966227769851685,
0.8183537721633911,
0.30053240060806274,
-0.7428154349327087,
-0.21919023990631104,
0.2885206639766693,
0.16819274425506592,
0.8320030570030212,
0.4873740077018738,
0.46751731634140015,
0.2600082755088806,
0.38660165667533875,
-0.5799345970153809,
0.08705133944749832,
-0.40702348947525024,
-0.17096969485282898,
0.5533245801925659,
0.1627628654241562,
-0.43534523248672485
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.02449v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.02449v1
|
Representations as Language: An Information-Theoretic Framework for Interpretability
| 2024-06-04T16:14:00 | 2024-06-04T16:14:00 |
Henry Conklin, Kenny Smith
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large scale neural models show impressive performance across a wide array of
linguistic tasks. Despite this they remain, largely, black-boxes - inducing
vector-representations of their input that prove difficult to interpret. This
limits our ability to understand what they learn, and when the learn it, or
describe what kinds of representations generalise well out of distribution. To
address this we introduce a novel approach to interpretability that looks at
the mapping a model learns from sentences to representations as a kind of
language in its own right. In doing so we introduce a set of
information-theoretic measures that quantify how structured a model's
representations are with respect to its input, and when during training that
structure arises. Our measures are fast to compute, grounded in linguistic
theory, and can predict which models will generalise best based on their
representations. We use these measures to describe two distinct phases of
training a transformer: an initial phase of in-distribution learning which
reduces task loss, then a second stage where representations becoming robust to
noise. Generalisation performance begins to increase during this second phase,
drawing a link between generalisation and robustness to noise. Finally we look
at how model size affects the structure of the representational space, showing
that larger models ultimately compress their representations more than their
smaller counterparts.
|
[
-0.2144259661436081,
-0.2725194990634918,
0.5556586384773254,
0.37526848912239075,
-0.1656072437763214,
-0.13660664856433868,
-0.48972535133361816,
-0.43795615434646606,
0.040882498025894165,
0.3806750774383545,
-0.137285053730011,
-0.10438846796751022,
-1.0398443937301636,
-0.23761296272277832,
-0.7105426788330078,
0.7678775787353516,
0.0007501460495404899,
0.11479191482067108,
-0.08251006156206131,
-0.29731202125549316,
-0.3491721451282501,
-0.5576003193855286,
-0.5259402990341187,
-0.5754988193511963,
0.36501431465148926,
-0.15945860743522644,
1.0023945569992065,
0.846829891204834,
0.3016349971294403,
0.27490589022636414,
-0.2814730107784271,
-0.3321910798549652,
-0.5236215591430664,
0.2510473132133484,
-0.32596394419670105,
-1.0011545419692993,
0.06949403882026672,
-0.030112015083432198,
0.843315601348877,
1.0932648181915283,
-0.2968617081642151,
-0.016617698594927788,
0.4072980284690857,
0.36167946457862854,
-0.5546302199363708,
0.806584358215332,
-0.5161681175231934,
0.08704454451799393,
0.20119185745716095,
-0.21234853565692902,
-0.8594897985458374,
-0.017379065975546837,
0.09199117124080658,
-0.7697247862815857,
0.28449195623397827,
-0.018496893346309662,
0.6839326620101929,
0.22345943748950958,
-0.38014543056488037,
-0.46453437209129333,
-0.9231776595115662,
0.7795558571815491,
-0.4438733458518982,
0.6031225323677063,
0.34810590744018555,
0.5722783803939819,
0.047638021409511566,
-0.8393532633781433,
-0.4958059787750244,
-0.1878589391708374,
-0.5355522036552429,
-0.02401837706565857,
-0.44145601987838745,
0.2051672488451004,
0.41826534271240234,
0.3215457499027252,
-0.39276090264320374,
-0.12537842988967896,
-0.21693293750286102,
-0.07419072836637497,
0.4888521730899811,
-0.004937260877341032,
0.5014504194259644,
-0.1702193170785904,
0.027546772733330727,
-0.2572375237941742,
-0.6179513335227966,
-0.042945269495248795,
0.3634549081325531,
0.2602536380290985,
-0.0364706814289093,
0.4547254145145416,
0.248003289103508,
0.5895098447799683,
0.041290394961833954,
0.23987960815429688,
-0.16707895696163177,
-0.036906931549310684,
-0.18765424191951752,
-0.12535467743873596,
0.5520392656326294,
-0.1127246618270874,
0.41355207562446594,
-0.36768022179603577,
-0.19824111461639404,
0.1655222624540329,
0.5978589057922363,
-0.8052409887313843,
-0.3862013816833496,
-0.017014801502227783,
-0.7690346837043762,
-0.43009862303733826,
0.14549902081489563,
-0.44471657276153564,
-0.5920491218566895,
-0.3117498457431793,
0.5278105139732361,
-0.5462332367897034,
-0.6610892415046692,
0.1792614907026291,
-0.11092457175254822,
0.1915706843137741,
0.0786774680018425,
-1.3517128229141235,
0.5249848961830139,
0.6580295562744141,
0.7256999015808105,
0.11343197524547577,
-0.2928573787212372,
-0.24828499555587769,
0.1325470507144928,
-0.5051116347312927,
0.49990081787109375,
-0.7007066607475281,
-0.16201677918434143,
0.14591075479984283,
-0.06504081934690475,
-0.25676631927490234,
-0.6371999979019165,
0.2086327075958252,
-0.6616119146347046,
-0.15492315590381622,
-0.0628482848405838,
-0.6243414878845215,
-0.4450109899044037,
-0.054592035710811615,
-0.9540748000144958,
0.540111780166626,
0.4280269145965576,
-0.5843355059623718,
0.39557555317878723,
-0.7418640851974487,
-0.40755176544189453,
0.039427611976861954,
-0.22376325726509094,
-0.002577906008809805,
0.6374160647392273,
-0.04064154997467995,
0.5632128119468689,
-0.12093820422887802,
0.3088380992412567,
-0.023845123127102852,
-0.4229583144187927,
0.2718472182750702,
-0.4913884103298187,
0.576878011226654,
0.23412102460861206,
-0.27810415625572205,
-0.06585041433572769,
-0.7929244041442871,
-0.06209501996636391,
0.17786550521850586,
-0.32449862360954285,
-0.2468305379152298,
0.3772275149822235,
0.10998547077178955,
0.011611459776759148,
0.002652678871527314,
-0.2784561812877655,
0.009931694716215134,
-0.714121401309967,
0.9246723055839539,
0.5901761054992676,
-0.3080660104751587,
0.9628250598907471,
0.13552114367485046,
0.6085575819015503,
0.2587781548500061,
0.05455152690410614,
-0.29662105441093445,
-0.29903820157051086,
-0.7823408246040344,
-0.056616853922605515,
0.46956783533096313,
0.15067048370838165,
-0.7506282925605774,
0.30867353081703186,
-0.35686635971069336,
-0.31504344940185547,
-0.5333979725837708,
0.06814192235469818,
0.09719933569431305,
-0.01209903322160244,
0.1311129480600357,
-0.22263942658901215,
-0.46747341752052307,
-0.8217980265617371,
-0.4266712963581085,
-0.3640490174293518,
-0.06728032231330872,
-0.03768469765782356,
0.5122365355491638,
-0.2868500351905823,
0.6180294752120972,
-0.36322444677352905,
0.07284875959157944,
-0.5037201642990112,
0.22036431729793549,
0.33117467164993286,
0.27164754271507263,
0.5274406671524048,
-0.9314716458320618,
-0.18725071847438812,
0.13587498664855957,
-0.96834796667099,
0.22870059311389923,
-0.20437666773796082,
0.12595157325267792,
-0.2880876660346985,
0.397381067276001,
-0.6259995102882385,
0.628982424736023,
0.5595880150794983,
-0.48408907651901245,
0.26023373007774353,
-0.3655861020088196,
-0.3498016893863678,
-0.8411433696746826,
-0.07859237492084503,
-0.13345465064048767,
-0.2937719225883484,
-0.6984509229660034,
0.3314875066280365,
0.12589845061302185,
-0.20514707267284393,
-0.20446060597896576,
0.47982504963874817,
-0.44820302724838257,
-0.21592894196510315,
-0.37006688117980957,
-0.09567473083734512,
0.15711669623851776,
0.38216471672058105,
-0.15260621905326843,
0.5612687468528748,
0.6687293648719788,
-0.5053011178970337,
0.0787753015756607,
0.15877923369407654,
-0.5133146643638611,
0.6922944784164429,
-0.6714687347412109,
-0.21510125696659088,
-0.6103842854499817,
-0.03206394612789154,
-0.9914278984069824,
-0.2783469557762146,
0.08535761386156082,
-0.37606701254844666,
0.5488157868385315,
-0.17453008890151978,
-0.47627580165863037,
0.03624933585524559,
0.3250455856323242,
0.4990617036819458,
0.4333235025405884,
-0.6918396353721619,
1.0546190738677979,
0.17427416145801544,
0.1287548989057541,
-0.5426301956176758,
-0.8471401333808899,
-0.07545287162065506,
-0.0648188367486,
-0.5307835340499878,
0.03791692852973938,
0.048551760613918304,
-0.4054485261440277,
0.21829135715961456,
-0.011199954897165298,
-0.3565335273742676,
0.24047569930553436,
0.41606149077415466,
-0.17252548038959503,
-0.3570839464664459,
0.3918974995613098,
-0.039306677877902985,
-0.17429803311824799,
0.2827564477920532,
-0.519866406917572,
0.5111793279647827,
-0.1310148984193802,
-0.34378498792648315,
-0.16984295845031738,
0.40408751368522644,
0.4995378255844116,
-0.00007032786379568279,
1.0132458209991455,
0.44202151894569397,
-0.36835893988609314,
-0.4479494094848633,
-0.003091241931542754,
-0.09547971189022064,
-0.447302907705307,
0.48798811435699463,
-0.5315081477165222,
-0.5699165463447571,
0.5450555682182312,
0.07740500569343567,
-0.13526441156864166,
0.7129733562469482,
0.42751988768577576,
-0.1419512778520584,
1.175858497619629,
0.9602116942405701,
0.03130757436156273,
0.5401402115821838,
-0.48689398169517517,
0.40684932470321655,
-0.5399413108825684,
-0.17133595049381256,
-0.26464346051216125,
-0.3391844928264618,
-0.44125115871429443,
-0.4359031021595001,
0.09300704300403595,
0.34405574202537537,
-0.26748883724212646,
0.41563501954078674,
-0.5790574550628662,
0.5886774063110352,
0.22787600755691528,
-0.10842464119195938,
0.22270633280277252,
-0.09091067314147949,
0.09471862018108368,
-0.13101135194301605,
-0.8215034604072571,
-0.5612756609916687,
1.1105109453201294,
0.5910213589668274,
0.8613349795341492,
0.030264345929026604,
0.3384571671485901,
0.12840169668197632,
0.4457654058933258,
-1.0653486251831055,
0.1632155030965805,
-0.08660778403282166,
-0.44718995690345764,
-0.13097535073757172,
-0.3731246590614319,
-1.068021297454834,
0.40377408266067505,
-0.11976811289787292,
-0.6474421620368958,
0.43225306272506714,
0.16667960584163666,
0.01638534851372242,
0.5051522254943848,
-0.8739827275276184,
0.7323035001754761,
-0.10384999215602875,
0.19362270832061768,
-0.2645268738269806,
-0.5056895017623901,
0.14306515455245972,
0.05690877512097359,
0.33013206720352173,
0.3619287312030792,
-0.010104577988386154,
0.7815150022506714,
-0.09332631528377533,
0.8625988364219666,
-0.2997693419456482,
0.0477910153567791,
0.018046462908387184,
0.23489561676979065,
0.2791755199432373,
-0.20817875862121582,
-0.09683673083782196,
0.1849088966846466,
0.2911268174648285,
-0.49739307165145874,
-1.2299072742462158,
0.19223186373710632,
-0.8853761553764343,
-0.23808372020721436,
-0.2578079402446747,
-0.8495217561721802,
-0.0795247033238411,
0.0688445046544075,
0.545950710773468,
0.5761860609054565,
-0.21305978298187256,
0.2046574354171753,
0.7157195210456848,
-0.09761790186166763,
0.20189960300922394,
0.1273994743824005,
-0.4603836238384247,
-0.07191343605518341,
0.9541836977005005,
0.3182527422904968,
0.3124917149543762,
0.6078718304634094,
0.23437641561031342,
-0.34575024247169495,
-0.7207404375076294,
-0.04438621550798416,
0.1836933046579361,
-1.2229102849960327,
0.2250312715768814,
-0.5055786967277527,
-0.4376801550388336,
-0.041589777916669846,
0.09754882007837296,
-0.22252687811851501,
-0.41715654730796814,
-0.3606068193912506,
-0.21548092365264893,
-0.17283588647842407,
1.5328978300094604,
-0.10807136446237564,
0.8497062921524048,
-0.22841110825538635,
0.23791798949241638,
0.369425505399704,
0.5229611396789551,
0.1953476220369339,
-0.7245711088180542,
-0.5538514256477356,
-0.07754837721586227,
-0.16833391785621643,
-0.847229540348053,
0.36360153555870056,
0.24230849742889404,
0.6179345846176147,
0.5947073101997375,
-0.35966169834136963,
0.3171044886112213,
-0.44242990016937256,
0.6789833903312683,
0.22653357684612274,
-1.0696864128112793,
0.42746254801750183,
-0.05698363855481148,
0.012964737601578236,
0.2085098773241043,
0.26704779267311096,
-0.4078332185745239,
-0.4254973232746124,
-0.9142802357673645,
-0.5908052921295166,
0.4539583623409271,
0.2304004579782486,
0.4116479754447937,
0.14841674268245697,
0.48370084166526794,
0.1298741102218628,
0.27898386120796204,
-0.7522644996643066,
-0.26316359639167786,
-0.542580783367157,
-0.3693197965621948,
-0.4905068278312683,
-0.5635333061218262,
-0.06591808050870895,
-0.254835844039917,
0.22488731145858765,
-0.19716186821460724,
0.6764209866523743,
-0.1634805053472519,
-0.5657952427864075,
0.015532649122178555,
0.34451737999916077,
0.3458906412124634,
0.9916428327560425,
-0.02676183544099331,
0.5167946219444275,
-0.22135117650032043,
-0.3802884817123413,
0.23666849732398987,
-0.044128626585006714,
-0.03949868679046631,
0.16337598860263824,
0.8397121429443359,
1.0522186756134033,
0.44579219818115234,
-0.34823885560035706,
0.6332799792289734,
-0.08491997420787811,
-0.1082669124007225,
-0.2294844537973404,
0.07215788960456848,
0.10699562728404999,
0.3791291117668152,
0.26448383927345276,
0.2538437247276306,
0.1809387505054474,
-0.775387167930603,
0.08780216425657272,
0.2011762112379074,
-0.7540715336799622,
-0.6719196438789368,
0.742376446723938,
-0.2872012257575989,
-0.3488062024116516,
0.3835398852825165,
-0.09294547885656357,
-0.4410768449306488,
0.48490309715270996,
0.5800302028656006,
0.7777514457702637,
-0.31222057342529297,
0.2986421287059784,
0.2566920518875122,
0.49900978803634644,
-0.25729063153266907,
0.128840371966362,
0.007166068535298109,
-0.9606100916862488,
-0.4968664050102234,
-0.5550405383110046,
-0.22730077803134918,
-0.01414803508669138,
-1.0462095737457275,
-0.21752530336380005,
-0.3803829848766327,
-0.015302831307053566,
0.28819409012794495,
-0.39811965823173523,
-0.897186815738678,
0.21779043972492218,
0.050695426762104034,
0.9883667230606079,
-1.1176773309707642,
0.7073549032211304,
0.5178143978118896,
-0.42244693636894226,
-0.9996791481971741,
-0.11636197566986084,
-0.3782762289047241,
-0.9141339063644409,
0.7502063512802124,
0.18001464009284973,
0.23211181163787842,
-0.13799771666526794,
-0.678761899471283,
-0.6635692715644836,
0.8673629760742188,
0.9752690196037292,
-0.388292521238327,
-0.2155754417181015,
0.19188030064105988,
0.7256339192390442,
-0.47381526231765747,
0.49935486912727356,
0.8744869232177734,
0.4785052239894867,
0.00004031520074931905,
-0.6041553616523743,
-0.08513069152832031,
-0.23622703552246094,
0.2405162751674652,
0.09904289245605469,
-0.10038682818412781,
0.8108243942260742,
0.06332116574048996,
-0.3596086800098419,
-0.18634529411792755,
0.6548970937728882,
-0.35564684867858887,
-0.062410127371549606,
0.5636059045791626,
0.4264659881591797,
0.8721153736114502,
-0.193266361951828,
1.428922414779663,
-0.22189559042453766,
0.44189339876174927,
0.9462628364562988,
0.32604092359542847,
0.798068642616272,
0.577755331993103,
-0.21644297242164612,
0.5648679733276367,
0.1814640760421753,
0.2163258045911789,
0.5444799065589905,
0.4065397381782532,
0.01825677417218685,
-0.25465407967567444,
0.032421182841062546,
-0.03804408758878708,
0.4661006033420563,
0.44202712178230286,
-0.8196830749511719,
-0.22942805290222168,
0.3546675741672516,
-0.3076895773410797,
0.289113849401474,
-0.2683055102825165,
0.7251580357551575,
0.2884563207626343,
-0.355520635843277,
0.5758012533187866,
-0.28960779309272766,
0.31891247630119324,
-0.6323138475418091,
-0.14556288719177246,
0.07937441021203995,
0.1846865713596344,
-0.17324082553386688,
-0.9928117990493774,
0.6020020246505737,
-0.5466853976249695,
-0.5335243940353394,
-0.37691983580589294,
0.5788294076919556,
-0.43190377950668335,
-0.5060573816299438,
0.5472416281700134,
0.3449338972568512,
0.17080281674861908,
-0.2871982753276825,
-0.42640259861946106,
0.24652281403541565,
-0.18880362808704376,
-0.30999088287353516,
0.3023979365825653,
0.4531348943710327,
0.1921410858631134,
0.7861860394477844,
0.07598306983709335,
0.486538827419281,
0.11344366520643234,
0.06166369095444679,
0.7381095290184021,
-0.6597853899002075,
-0.46849966049194336,
-0.8498613834381104,
0.41327887773513794,
0.12537327408790588,
-0.001776594202965498,
0.3485853374004364,
0.2364511638879776,
0.6379444599151611,
0.005005116108804941,
0.93438321352005,
-0.06653382629156113,
0.1419246941804886,
-0.37493157386779785,
0.8756643533706665,
-0.35048070549964905,
0.161207914352417,
0.14588424563407898,
-0.956386387348175,
-0.23732690513134003,
0.8800301551818848,
-0.4224880635738373,
-0.18359462916851044,
0.6586195826530457,
0.6521507501602173,
-0.2960798740386963,
0.17471584677696228,
0.6527421474456787,
0.5179154872894287,
0.3050421178340912,
0.4761565923690796,
1.193718671798706,
-0.5308542251586914,
0.6173760294914246,
-0.09101056307554245,
-0.026925625279545784,
0.07664461433887482,
-0.55061274766922,
-0.8330532312393188,
-0.8987141251564026,
-0.037743840366601944,
-0.46580296754837036,
-0.37589481472969055,
0.4445827901363373,
0.9843007922172546,
-0.7660698294639587,
-0.3089715242385864,
-0.026770958676934242,
0.22270344197750092,
-0.4676031172275543,
-0.1992897093296051,
0.3128054440021515,
-0.47598201036453247,
-0.5362261533737183,
0.32656919956207275,
0.30200472474098206,
-0.1180066391825676,
-0.5461757779121399,
-0.1317061483860016,
0.4154554605484009,
0.1269090324640274,
0.8549964427947998,
0.12903402745723724,
-0.6253679394721985,
-0.3907804489135742,
-0.35932403802871704,
0.05549490451812744,
0.29179733991622925,
0.9918164014816284,
-0.5593447089195251,
0.8598163723945618,
0.40049850940704346,
0.6821363568305969,
0.6965138912200928,
-0.47914958000183105,
0.8783740997314453,
-0.6505611538887024,
0.326127827167511,
0.21525011956691742,
0.5757717490196228,
0.34762704372406006,
-0.3623009920120239,
0.5314990878105164,
0.015020346269011497,
-0.2825198471546173,
-0.7668863534927368,
0.44671475887298584,
-0.8202025294303894,
-0.19117622077465057,
0.9497404098510742,
-0.31698742508888245,
-0.31868118047714233,
-0.1503470540046692,
0.05091458559036255,
0.21208354830741882,
-0.027430454269051552,
0.44576603174209595,
0.9136130809783936,
0.19037306308746338,
-0.3783137798309326,
-0.8280342221260071,
0.4232761859893799,
0.22595001757144928,
-0.43764087557792664,
0.1015806645154953,
0.013845179229974747,
0.3758207857608795,
0.4618801474571228,
0.36235150694847107,
-0.012894146144390106,
0.032437730580568314,
0.08519185334444046,
-0.15599870681762695,
0.11212742328643799,
-0.30829212069511414,
-0.7407266497612,
0.3978448808193207,
0.35362109541893005,
0.009048241190612316
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.06581v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.06581v2
|
Set-Based Prompting: Provably Solving the Language Model Order Dependency Problem
| 2024-06-04T16:09:13 | 2024-06-12T13:59:13 |
Reid McIlroy-Young, Katrina Brown, Conlan Olson, Linjun Zhang, Cynthia Dwork
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
The development of generative language models that can create long and
coherent textual outputs via autoregression has lead to a proliferation of uses
and a corresponding sweep of analyses as researches work to determine the
limitations of this new paradigm. Unlike humans, these 'Large Language Models'
(LLMs) are highly sensitive to small changes in their inputs, leading to
unwanted inconsistency in their behavior. One problematic inconsistency when
LLMs are used to answer multiple-choice questions or analyze multiple inputs is
order dependency: the output of an LLM can (and often does) change
significantly when sub-sequences are swapped, despite both orderings being
semantically identical. In this paper we present Set-Based Prompting, a
technique that guarantees the output of an LLM will not have order dependence
on a specified set of sub-sequences. We show that this method provably
eliminates order dependency, and that it can be applied to any
transformer-based LLM to enable text generation that is unaffected by
re-orderings. Delving into the implications of our method, we show that,
despite our inputs being out of distribution, the impact on expected accuracy
is small, where the expectation is over the order of uniformly chosen shuffling
of the candidate responses, and usually significantly less in practice. Thus,
Set-Based Prompting can be used as a 'dropped-in' method on fully trained
models. Finally, we discuss how our method's success suggests that other strong
guarantees can be obtained on LLM performance via modifying the input
representations.
|
[
-0.28246569633483887,
-0.7278585433959961,
0.4865756630897522,
0.4140738546848297,
0.0003773817152250558,
-0.19785921275615692,
-0.2028813660144806,
-0.3681234121322632,
0.042133405804634094,
0.5476416349411011,
-0.6702132225036621,
-0.10954643040895462,
-0.7184237241744995,
0.32589781284332275,
-0.526905357837677,
0.6598926782608032,
0.023200785741209984,
0.04871060326695442,
-0.2648547887802124,
-0.15053914487361908,
-0.7169815897941589,
-0.35057634115219116,
-0.5134199857711792,
-0.6176846623420715,
0.6649032235145569,
0.4619525372982025,
0.8868829607963562,
0.8095932006835938,
0.4487913250923157,
0.2569870948791504,
-0.2692568600177765,
0.20843401551246643,
-0.40387752652168274,
0.6281254291534424,
-0.08974450081586838,
-0.4797365963459015,
-0.05198513716459274,
0.1142774298787117,
0.7014707326889038,
0.705576479434967,
-0.15826457738876343,
-0.04148922860622406,
0.14360438287258148,
0.4767075479030609,
-0.7358523011207581,
0.026673374697566032,
-0.5956127047538757,
0.08394166827201843,
0.013178708031773567,
-0.28954851627349854,
-0.9362562894821167,
-0.08861082047224045,
0.0706687793135643,
-0.3069247901439667,
0.3122885227203369,
-0.041696980595588684,
0.7490332126617432,
0.4841196835041046,
-0.08289515972137451,
-0.24439918994903564,
-0.8930534720420837,
0.699751615524292,
-0.7257000207901001,
0.47761180996894836,
0.6149248480796814,
-0.03596845641732216,
-0.4026603698730469,
-0.560674250125885,
-0.5109909176826477,
-0.29965731501579285,
-0.004402818623930216,
0.3103190064430237,
0.28916749358177185,
0.013710767962038517,
0.6070642471313477,
0.3585507869720459,
-0.3930504620075226,
0.39409348368644714,
-0.0563860647380352,
0.22919315099716187,
0.22315388917922974,
0.1835297793149948,
0.33965057134628296,
-0.16129851341247559,
0.09849414229393005,
-0.1283598691225052,
-1.1226633787155151,
0.10221555829048157,
0.24838921427726746,
0.5376700162887573,
0.10749764740467072,
0.7540996074676514,
-0.14938601851463318,
0.8419711589813232,
0.578917384147644,
0.2049589902162552,
-0.05764973536133766,
-0.050308603793382645,
-0.2658780515193939,
-0.2274257093667984,
0.8599815368652344,
0.09245795756578445,
0.3537399470806122,
0.31587740778923035,
-0.43611255288124084,
-0.1814984530210495,
0.09279593825340271,
-0.5446050763130188,
-0.28237348794937134,
0.3898542821407318,
-0.3853413164615631,
-0.34839922189712524,
-0.08601651340723038,
-0.5384542942047119,
-0.4383934438228607,
-0.26460546255111694,
0.4189686179161072,
-0.30260327458381653,
-0.07135485112667084,
-0.14879609644412994,
0.1612856537103653,
0.05849900469183922,
0.29914599657058716,
-1.3390568494796753,
0.00102652283385396,
0.46474629640579224,
0.6185221076011658,
-0.029520124197006226,
-0.44817495346069336,
-0.8852061629295349,
0.12487050145864487,
-0.5423633456230164,
0.7434318661689758,
-0.7203303575515747,
-0.6741563081741333,
0.23726528882980347,
-0.07831695675849915,
0.06002957001328468,
-0.8333714008331299,
0.0826520025730133,
-0.5225821733474731,
0.5512140393257141,
-0.46024271845817566,
-0.6801337003707886,
0.5081088542938232,
0.13543392717838287,
-0.7056806683540344,
1.1602011919021606,
-0.11802130192518234,
-0.5729311108589172,
0.41768738627433777,
-0.2664647102355957,
-0.5802177786827087,
0.04978721961379051,
-0.3774982690811157,
-0.24296234548091888,
0.16881947219371796,
0.3627203404903412,
0.30634069442749023,
-0.11394146829843521,
0.36063772439956665,
-0.17956790328025818,
-0.37778547406196594,
0.15602460503578186,
-0.5901225209236145,
0.9107720851898193,
-0.23536890745162964,
-0.2283119410276413,
0.19416171312332153,
-0.7064725756645203,
0.0466507226228714,
0.06865194439888,
-0.5145208835601807,
-0.1994030922651291,
0.18238069117069244,
-0.43792203068733215,
0.3382109999656677,
0.2237095683813095,
-0.30309024453163147,
0.26914268732070923,
-0.5367102026939392,
0.24835693836212158,
1.0138466358184814,
-0.03352849557995796,
0.5038244724273682,
-0.33232271671295166,
0.4532267451286316,
0.09367185831069946,
0.20098118484020233,
-0.45595619082450867,
-0.5930522680282593,
-0.8902053833007812,
0.030688263475894928,
0.2507423758506775,
0.6689865589141846,
-0.8755783438682556,
0.44321557879447937,
0.01849960722029209,
-0.04571531340479851,
-0.3222421407699585,
-0.10766836255788803,
0.3771323561668396,
0.5181087851524353,
0.26378899812698364,
0.015312985517084599,
-0.455837607383728,
-0.6711797714233398,
-0.14072048664093018,
-0.45194193720817566,
0.07169980555772781,
-0.02396811917424202,
0.20252268016338348,
0.20076705515384674,
1.027770757675171,
-0.5295953154563904,
0.2812340557575226,
-0.2590568959712982,
0.19286060333251953,
0.2907713055610657,
0.45865699648857117,
0.03327621892094612,
-0.59708571434021,
-0.4758158326148987,
-0.2488669902086258,
-0.740180253982544,
-0.39294907450675964,
-0.12305422872304916,
0.026399891823530197,
0.21731612086296082,
0.5999935269355774,
-0.6342259645462036,
0.5338645577430725,
0.47487306594848633,
-0.0030676403548568487,
0.7831563353538513,
-0.40979889035224915,
-0.08783623576164246,
-1.1048543453216553,
-0.19302533566951752,
-0.2490069717168808,
-0.07996769994497299,
-0.6978760957717896,
-0.2467925101518631,
0.1581534892320633,
-0.006313602905720472,
-0.33753782510757446,
0.7084078192710876,
-0.31191378831863403,
0.034554630517959595,
-0.29176297783851624,
-0.2486891895532608,
0.06262204796075821,
0.3262404501438141,
0.1541627049446106,
0.864478349685669,
0.3447709381580353,
-0.7873218655586243,
0.17645147442817688,
0.6700353622436523,
-0.1645752489566803,
0.6127191185951233,
-0.7020658254623413,
0.10378657281398773,
-0.1540287733078003,
0.18088750541210175,
-0.835773766040802,
-0.2325153350830078,
0.48787838220596313,
-0.31562134623527527,
0.24433434009552002,
-0.2525768280029297,
-0.5726675987243652,
-0.36697107553482056,
0.023746909573674202,
0.17169243097305298,
0.5592024922370911,
-0.8324177265167236,
0.36174681782722473,
-0.1586945652961731,
-0.1002943143248558,
-0.9646440744400024,
-0.5719143152236938,
0.04511075094342232,
0.17918606102466583,
-0.3624300956726074,
0.20502471923828125,
-0.48417189717292786,
-0.4236481785774231,
-0.3058992624282837,
-0.13007687032222748,
-0.1036837175488472,
-0.19797080755233765,
0.18410860002040863,
0.4413905143737793,
-0.09940163791179657,
0.3076515197753906,
0.06312109529972076,
-0.20103852450847626,
-0.00407192949205637,
-0.36815178394317627,
0.5212491154670715,
0.35801512002944946,
-0.6288110613822937,
-0.17527015507221222,
0.4954444468021393,
0.5664806365966797,
-0.2005457729101181,
0.7978007793426514,
0.011532661505043507,
-0.30517783761024475,
-0.5189332962036133,
-0.5257327556610107,
-0.2833452820777893,
-0.560833215713501,
0.17270074784755707,
-0.3961142897605896,
-0.7534549832344055,
0.6238306760787964,
0.3197469115257263,
0.4596122205257416,
0.21484188735485077,
0.6282510757446289,
-0.2579331696033478,
1.0180411338806152,
0.4611898362636566,
0.07038647681474686,
0.9458143711090088,
0.15187042951583862,
0.272758424282074,
-0.4935261905193329,
0.04247738793492317,
-0.4771389365196228,
-0.04675287753343582,
-0.47014668583869934,
-0.00673394650220871,
0.0882161557674408,
0.005046040751039982,
-0.16074064373970032,
0.09981995075941086,
-0.5126821994781494,
0.7868920564651489,
0.6398317217826843,
0.03367334604263306,
0.38724759221076965,
-0.11009249836206436,
-0.07776802033185959,
0.05678878724575043,
-0.759043276309967,
-0.24321241676807404,
0.8048067092895508,
-0.12279143929481506,
0.76481693983078,
-0.13205742835998535,
0.8510208129882812,
0.31391796469688416,
0.28721195459365845,
-0.8121771216392517,
0.6779622435569763,
-0.27456289529800415,
-0.30635619163513184,
-0.40923410654067993,
-0.39848002791404724,
-1.0823853015899658,
0.2094460278749466,
0.000246823561610654,
-0.5632533431053162,
0.35846301913261414,
0.42862245440483093,
-0.3057294189929962,
0.13804082572460175,
-0.5939438343048096,
0.39422643184661865,
0.029553497210144997,
-0.21733371913433075,
0.2345028817653656,
-0.630365788936615,
0.20583310723304749,
0.2050207406282425,
-0.1608257293701172,
-0.057064250111579895,
0.2853599488735199,
0.5589410066604614,
-0.7247560024261475,
0.9385563135147095,
0.01943862810730934,
-0.5087016224861145,
0.2714936435222626,
0.28140953183174133,
0.8342631459236145,
-0.06256432086229324,
-0.03359843045473099,
-0.19514337182044983,
-0.24005569517612457,
-0.28597208857536316,
-0.7870775461196899,
0.5948383808135986,
-0.5684639811515808,
-0.8528676629066467,
-0.17428161203861237,
-0.712542712688446,
-0.33659854531288147,
0.2942062020301819,
0.7759448885917664,
0.8256173729896545,
-0.00016929027333389968,
-0.30181676149368286,
1.0275652408599854,
-0.08451027423143387,
0.7711047530174255,
0.29070162773132324,
-0.44015446305274963,
-0.4721561074256897,
0.821980893611908,
0.3771773874759674,
0.6654278039932251,
0.36995235085487366,
0.21128219366073608,
-0.300525426864624,
-0.48939961194992065,
-0.6274421811103821,
0.20456409454345703,
-1.0950859785079956,
-0.0436384417116642,
-0.47347721457481384,
-0.32693248987197876,
-0.430954247713089,
-0.26381808519363403,
-0.25614842772483826,
-0.45958155393600464,
-0.34537285566329956,
-0.07382847368717194,
0.29281964898109436,
1.0683414936065674,
0.07964276522397995,
0.3483352065086365,
-0.7940301895141602,
0.32237672805786133,
0.5145665407180786,
0.5050572156906128,
0.0002790129801724106,
-0.6236533522605896,
-0.10074733942747116,
-0.15948385000228882,
-0.15536761283874512,
-0.9222415685653687,
0.3245457112789154,
-0.14152036607265472,
0.38005638122558594,
0.37570279836654663,
-0.013436584733426571,
0.5552164316177368,
-0.6460964679718018,
0.742289125919342,
0.07467726618051529,
-0.8968169689178467,
0.5621641874313354,
-0.647057294845581,
0.6308873891830444,
0.39023518562316895,
-0.1874634176492691,
-0.7869504690170288,
-0.7481130361557007,
-0.8356613516807556,
-0.7148296236991882,
0.8118649125099182,
0.1999705284833908,
0.08694719523191452,
-0.30439138412475586,
0.4047965407371521,
0.08892158418893814,
0.1611013114452362,
-0.6715160608291626,
-0.2681809067726135,
-0.14953452348709106,
-0.2922891676425934,
0.2184670865535736,
-0.28078848123550415,
0.09217064827680588,
0.1474124938249588,
0.7709112167358398,
-0.03345602750778198,
0.14165127277374268,
0.00432664155960083,
-0.17245721817016602,
-0.15080568194389343,
0.29942402243614197,
0.6666596531867981,
0.764180064201355,
0.13294364511966705,
0.195996955037117,
0.06535656750202179,
-0.35222098231315613,
0.3880467414855957,
-0.20096567273139954,
-0.6352454423904419,
0.16055837273597717,
0.2776145040988922,
0.506337583065033,
0.029409781098365784,
-0.5247676372528076,
0.2907513976097107,
0.19643309712409973,
0.005093269050121307,
-0.157182514667511,
0.01893160678446293,
0.01548873819410801,
-0.0954904705286026,
0.23124317824840546,
0.11933895200490952,
-0.22182083129882812,
-0.08602991700172424,
0.2561313211917877,
0.23418952524662018,
-0.45916828513145447,
-0.13459767401218414,
0.3131903111934662,
0.1079738512635231,
-0.7325087189674377,
0.8677769303321838,
-0.01495619211345911,
-0.30210191011428833,
0.8183688521385193,
0.813679039478302,
0.861785352230072,
-0.6418518424034119,
0.21265213191509247,
0.17296819388866425,
0.29443803429603577,
-0.7535629272460938,
0.4441329538822174,
0.2509288191795349,
-0.9884002208709717,
-0.6669983863830566,
-0.1950100064277649,
-0.6177995800971985,
0.29228320717811584,
-0.7017514109611511,
0.267997145652771,
-0.7886603474617004,
-0.03836711496114731,
-0.2738381028175354,
-0.6463416218757629,
-0.22235330939292908,
0.1625542938709259,
0.015938106924295425,
0.6822731494903564,
-0.8575348258018494,
0.5142459273338318,
0.4793532192707062,
-0.4193370044231415,
-0.7928324341773987,
0.2452635020017624,
-0.0886094942688942,
-0.7923381328582764,
0.5499442219734192,
0.18955297768115997,
-0.19672372937202454,
0.0510227270424366,
-0.7364738583564758,
-0.9093340635299683,
0.4332956373691559,
0.2417619228363037,
-0.4582049250602722,
0.14137904345989227,
0.10558600723743439,
0.41343754529953003,
-0.169462651014328,
0.2532061040401459,
0.30906420946121216,
0.43877196311950684,
0.20831800997257233,
-0.7821545600891113,
0.07091208547353745,
-0.34781306982040405,
0.060852766036987305,
0.5690670013427734,
-0.5002782344818115,
0.7434002161026001,
-0.1631775200366974,
-0.1001746729016304,
0.11301987618207932,
0.7359718680381775,
0.4750194549560547,
-0.026773614808917046,
0.44711634516716003,
0.3102308213710785,
0.8486927151679993,
0.03902646526694298,
0.7900744080543518,
-0.08847706764936447,
0.266838937997818,
1.458173155784607,
-0.5871908664703369,
0.9160073399543762,
0.56828773021698,
-0.1538264900445938,
0.3414989709854126,
0.6847583651542664,
-0.03358185663819313,
0.3302370309829712,
0.13246452808380127,
-0.4071236252784729,
-0.30422210693359375,
-0.17061668634414673,
-0.1594756841659546,
0.046064313501119614,
0.30086764693260193,
-0.4609904885292053,
-0.08253613114356995,
0.030481919646263123,
-0.14758798480033875,
-0.06998468190431595,
-0.16691666841506958,
0.6581345796585083,
0.1378137767314911,
-1.0678000450134277,
0.6533466577529907,
-0.3836587071418762,
0.5132627487182617,
-0.5182178616523743,
-0.1504928022623062,
-0.3524344265460968,
-0.027727682143449783,
-0.14513379335403442,
-0.7521485090255737,
0.17429021000862122,
-0.18467852473258972,
-0.7847666144371033,
-0.5666916370391846,
0.5416462421417236,
-0.4715709090232849,
-0.4656369388103485,
0.17284736037254333,
0.8036156892776489,
-0.15720084309577942,
0.321952223777771,
-0.4373129904270172,
-0.18886138498783112,
-0.04953068122267723,
-0.374920129776001,
0.32784974575042725,
0.29670384526252747,
-0.20797070860862732,
0.7067740559577942,
0.5894434452056885,
-0.08675111830234528,
0.10037778317928314,
0.4805672764778137,
0.48844510316848755,
-0.4564255475997925,
-0.536689043045044,
-1.0013729333877563,
0.32724398374557495,
0.04282979667186737,
-0.2632173001766205,
0.40687230229377747,
0.11245327442884445,
0.6678603291511536,
-0.08780518174171448,
0.9370951056480408,
-0.14976339042186737,
0.2888559401035309,
-0.5631232857704163,
0.43896251916885376,
-0.2274264395236969,
0.4711803197860718,
-0.03838063031435013,
-0.8347530961036682,
-0.39286428689956665,
0.349143922328949,
-0.41300109028816223,
0.16361604630947113,
0.8278167247772217,
0.8768362402915955,
0.06518926471471786,
0.22208532691001892,
0.47823888063430786,
0.09783054143190384,
0.27588993310928345,
0.22486214339733124,
1.2364493608474731,
-0.0753941461443901,
0.5966914892196655,
-0.03133976459503174,
-0.08091763406991959,
0.004197452217340469,
-0.7457039952278137,
-0.8336642980575562,
-0.5112044811248779,
-0.20626361668109894,
-0.7414814829826355,
0.10498932749032974,
1.0144325494766235,
0.4149501621723175,
-0.7737834453582764,
-0.2283381223678589,
-0.21711081266403198,
0.36896654963493347,
-0.3960384130477905,
-0.20161914825439453,
0.2908784747123718,
-0.472641259431839,
-0.7753933668136597,
0.5657441020011902,
0.3159947991371155,
0.2981155216693878,
-0.12667976319789886,
0.030223391950130463,
-0.19318069517612457,
0.23147694766521454,
0.3782288730144501,
0.38912737369537354,
-0.8683065176010132,
-0.4924665689468384,
0.23339873552322388,
-0.17641496658325195,
0.493346244096756,
0.8594743013381958,
-0.7605783939361572,
0.29959630966186523,
0.7732322812080383,
0.4578583538532257,
0.04391276463866234,
-0.16909901797771454,
0.8694469332695007,
-0.9522085189819336,
-0.11163409054279327,
0.054942723363637924,
0.4235924184322357,
0.3239145576953888,
-0.6172050833702087,
0.35331326723098755,
0.1997499167919159,
-0.5401747226715088,
-0.6676968336105347,
0.7497907876968384,
-0.6099761128425598,
-0.15419889986515045,
1.1689649820327759,
-0.16445289552211761,
-0.00994095392525196,
-0.25123584270477295,
-0.08345333486795425,
0.2150200605392456,
-0.43233126401901245,
0.7976805567741394,
0.8611554503440857,
-0.14115405082702637,
-0.3524762988090515,
-0.2661416232585907,
0.33383285999298096,
0.9494002461433411,
-0.7530217170715332,
0.48742079734802246,
0.6334238052368164,
0.13569405674934387,
0.1947994977235794,
0.7179837822914124,
0.1458481401205063,
0.2766832113265991,
-0.2753717005252838,
-0.03839902579784393,
0.016084536910057068,
-0.4402432441711426,
-0.6050580739974976,
0.19619028270244598,
0.06418506056070328,
-0.08285406231880188
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.02396v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.02396v1
|
The Scandinavian Embedding Benchmarks: Comprehensive Assessment of Multilingual and Monolingual Text Embedding
| 2024-06-04T15:11:27 | 2024-06-04T15:11:27 |
Kenneth Enevoldsen, Márton Kardos, Niklas Muennighoff, Kristoffer Laigaard Nielbo
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The evaluation of English text embeddings has transitioned from evaluating a
handful of datasets to broad coverage across many tasks through benchmarks such
as MTEB. However, this is not the case for multilingual text embeddings due to
a lack of available benchmarks. To address this problem, we introduce the
Scandinavian Embedding Benchmark (SEB). SEB is a comprehensive framework that
enables text embedding evaluation for Scandinavian languages across 24 tasks,
10 subtasks, and 4 task categories. Building on SEB, we evaluate more than 26
models, uncovering significant performance disparities between public and
commercial solutions not previously captured by MTEB. We open-source SEB and
integrate it with MTEB, thus bridging the text embedding evaluation gap for
Scandinavian languages.
|
[
-0.6106382608413696,
-0.555620014667511,
0.43978846073150635,
0.7155181169509888,
-0.38795825839042664,
0.19900789856910706,
-0.21077686548233032,
-0.39450931549072266,
0.32896900177001953,
0.3008500635623932,
-0.22895509004592896,
-0.8501937389373779,
-0.554593563079834,
0.24365153908729553,
-0.010035286657512188,
0.4738512635231018,
-0.34283196926116943,
0.3208029270172119,
-0.7377418279647827,
-0.5507116913795471,
-0.7065622210502625,
-0.4951268434524536,
-0.0639190599322319,
0.017012037336826324,
0.28130701184272766,
0.24327822029590607,
0.3828582763671875,
0.44046658277511597,
0.6112125515937805,
0.21623022854328156,
-0.16260509192943573,
0.004536331165581942,
-0.46343907713890076,
0.19094720482826233,
-0.4472486078739166,
-0.1394467055797577,
-0.2688835561275482,
-0.281570702791214,
0.7992976903915405,
0.6310253143310547,
-0.08389673382043839,
0.4282659888267517,
0.24044758081436157,
0.5900697708129883,
-0.7916778326034546,
0.006399651523679495,
-0.1275695562362671,
0.017000291496515274,
-0.36743301153182983,
0.15458069741725922,
-0.40255245566368103,
-0.4592719078063965,
0.008605335839092731,
-0.14288175106048584,
-0.0010155277559533715,
0.05381760373711586,
0.4362207353115082,
0.1708485335111618,
-0.6886629462242126,
-0.20604442059993744,
-0.2050165832042694,
0.921714186668396,
-0.4394705891609192,
0.8918657302856445,
0.14815129339694977,
0.1420111358165741,
0.12328958511352539,
-0.331657737493515,
0.04907739534974098,
0.1122673824429512,
0.10832467675209045,
0.04637809097766876,
0.0043409732170403,
-0.1259743571281433,
-0.018974296748638153,
0.28264734148979187,
-0.6712278723716736,
-0.12900330126285553,
-0.2722693383693695,
-0.052566591650247574,
0.5372726917266846,
0.14385510981082916,
0.21026146411895752,
-0.44384774565696716,
-0.5624426603317261,
-0.20684446394443512,
-0.6325685381889343,
-0.1161971166729927,
0.4780990183353424,
0.27711978554725647,
-0.3320184350013733,
0.48648586869239807,
0.2851376235485077,
0.22548186779022217,
-0.49537861347198486,
0.31959763169288635,
0.71587735414505,
-0.45955657958984375,
-0.15800747275352478,
0.12658695876598358,
0.4697476923465729,
0.37969762086868286,
-0.21034835278987885,
-0.20689977705478668,
-0.3196917176246643,
0.2552219033241272,
0.3092935383319855,
-0.5961119532585144,
0.0350298248231411,
0.21092994511127472,
-0.5858430862426758,
0.07594537734985352,
-0.08425262570381165,
-0.7556791305541992,
-0.4248627722263336,
-0.0493692122399807,
0.3363291919231415,
-0.19665277004241943,
-0.5650210380554199,
0.08590211719274521,
-0.4776301383972168,
0.2253895103931427,
0.08872679620981216,
-0.4099838137626648,
0.369607150554657,
0.8048862814903259,
0.8352072238922119,
-0.4112647771835327,
-0.33199527859687805,
-0.06937464326620102,
-0.0023449778091162443,
-0.5715939402580261,
0.9778979420661926,
-0.5583988428115845,
-0.6345803737640381,
0.1666254699230194,
0.07932846993207932,
-0.01833704300224781,
-0.5262267589569092,
0.6150931119918823,
-0.09654992073774338,
-0.01653425768017769,
-0.45913732051849365,
-0.6901422739028931,
-0.10462728142738342,
0.36137065291404724,
-0.9024451375007629,
1.5138591527938843,
0.06369005143642426,
-0.8283271789550781,
0.46974244713783264,
-0.7136387825012207,
-0.34933310747146606,
0.23663781583309174,
-0.26928141713142395,
-0.030193548649549484,
0.36589986085891724,
0.23320870101451874,
0.5316826105117798,
-0.5485466122627258,
0.41101428866386414,
-0.6042184233665466,
-0.29979199171066284,
-0.24320220947265625,
-0.16750666499137878,
0.6671252250671387,
0.128045916557312,
-0.1459200233221054,
-0.022065985947847366,
-0.5203835964202881,
0.2359214574098587,
0.005219792015850544,
-0.36540383100509644,
-0.856468141078949,
-0.16409438848495483,
0.4573919177055359,
0.11796113103628159,
0.5628500580787659,
-0.7837366461753845,
-0.11561792343854904,
-0.2569689154624939,
0.034854378551244736,
0.8808313608169556,
-0.12781105935573578,
0.2541551887989044,
-0.25402817130088806,
0.6354586482048035,
0.0397864505648613,
-0.011430670507252216,
-0.1310465782880783,
-0.3943468928337097,
-0.3974723517894745,
-0.4657957851886749,
0.6724323034286499,
0.4409576654434204,
-0.7298727631568909,
0.25544464588165283,
-0.39559030532836914,
-0.6372901797294617,
-0.9945542216300964,
0.2559552490711212,
0.6328670978546143,
-0.3367983102798462,
0.27710551023483276,
-0.3207142651081085,
-0.6077165603637695,
-1.1147526502609253,
-0.6114263534545898,
0.11296357214450836,
0.11148889362812042,
0.34400317072868347,
0.7362639904022217,
-0.17679177224636078,
0.4257287085056305,
-0.12149375677108765,
-0.18023249506950378,
-0.32838404178619385,
0.179738387465477,
0.43342727422714233,
0.5788550972938538,
0.5447669625282288,
-0.7546699047088623,
-0.8842927813529968,
0.07742343842983246,
-0.6595500707626343,
0.051214639097452164,
0.1095639243721962,
-0.0582314170897007,
0.2974085807800293,
0.5998729467391968,
-0.03603264316916466,
0.19992759823799133,
1.1364260911941528,
-0.7015553712844849,
0.5274109244346619,
-0.2348002940416336,
0.3155953884124756,
-1.1736427545547485,
0.15730321407318115,
-0.23709487915039062,
-0.5016717314720154,
-0.14724184572696686,
0.19790178537368774,
0.5063655376434326,
-0.03372346982359886,
-0.5922399759292603,
0.8640352487564087,
-0.5687406659126282,
-0.3056759536266327,
0.2699384093284607,
0.17677311599254608,
0.00469251861795783,
0.26824989914894104,
-0.32709142565727234,
0.7279298901557922,
0.4857724905014038,
-0.3472451865673065,
0.042302206158638,
0.2577933669090271,
-0.777082622051239,
0.8939622044563293,
-0.7098960876464844,
0.05206139013171196,
-0.045906078070402145,
-0.10953520983457565,
-1.0391165018081665,
0.29029327630996704,
-0.3675900995731354,
-0.19196438789367676,
0.15542471408843994,
-0.11081815510988235,
-0.6947318911552429,
-0.31778985261917114,
-0.5966168642044067,
0.43300697207450867,
0.3026290237903595,
-0.5984876155853271,
0.693909227848053,
0.7190895080566406,
-0.48331451416015625,
-0.6006086468696594,
-0.7132306098937988,
0.11118026822805405,
0.14412805438041687,
-0.7087157964706421,
0.4275447726249695,
-0.05484592914581299,
-0.036939915269613266,
0.4590284824371338,
-0.45517978072166443,
-0.07438375800848007,
0.18903768062591553,
0.17571234703063965,
0.07298887521028519,
-0.3446294665336609,
0.1807965338230133,
0.4058777093887329,
-0.12160274386405945,
-0.11589470505714417,
0.0660712793469429,
0.46508049964904785,
-0.26172342896461487,
-0.6685109734535217,
-0.00603226013481617,
0.6542121171951294,
0.4819740056991577,
-0.4066498875617981,
0.6624605059623718,
0.41131529211997986,
-0.4210277795791626,
-0.25959452986717224,
-0.6618613600730896,
0.22243987023830414,
-0.42078492045402527,
0.46730124950408936,
-0.7854636907577515,
-0.8649924993515015,
0.4025942087173462,
-0.30695873498916626,
0.3980717957019806,
0.4291277527809143,
0.39464661478996277,
-0.0480516254901886,
1.0530476570129395,
0.7826268076896667,
0.2528439462184906,
0.260028213262558,
-0.04706033691763878,
-0.16263245046138763,
-0.8070005774497986,
-0.3032054603099823,
-0.7059634327888489,
-0.4148217737674713,
-0.7356275916099548,
-0.7040306329727173,
0.17133331298828125,
0.07111386209726334,
-0.05669784918427467,
0.5497254133224487,
-0.28268927335739136,
0.6362783312797546,
0.45450952649116516,
-0.07874558866024017,
-0.009359725750982761,
-0.16031989455223083,
-0.8783172369003296,
-0.22138431668281555,
-0.6795670986175537,
-0.6256983280181885,
1.1890019178390503,
0.5369288325309753,
0.7380836606025696,
0.23560959100723267,
0.9465129971504211,
0.5015007853507996,
0.37650614976882935,
-0.36925309896469116,
0.3247946500778198,
-0.5961138606071472,
-0.9962648749351501,
-0.17650078237056732,
-0.38511669635772705,
-0.7263444066047668,
0.6961531639099121,
-0.17837734520435333,
-0.5948780179023743,
0.2864813804626465,
-0.13190391659736633,
0.20388786494731903,
0.18624038994312286,
-0.838085949420929,
1.3007892370224,
-0.07685908675193787,
-0.3699663579463959,
-0.3798133432865143,
-0.12771137058734894,
-0.2881658673286438,
0.026203623041510582,
0.5398941040039062,
-0.3329205811023712,
-0.18809516727924347,
1.0042890310287476,
0.22756868600845337,
0.7224060893058777,
-0.5098973512649536,
-0.06954602152109146,
-0.11951407790184021,
0.1474979817867279,
0.3819686770439148,
-0.03250253573060036,
-0.14534200727939606,
0.48323962092399597,
0.4662186801433563,
-0.5920281410217285,
-0.12229766696691513,
0.8549243211746216,
-0.44326817989349365,
-0.21016524732112885,
-0.43993860483169556,
-0.06966682523488998,
-0.4291110634803772,
0.4011599123477936,
-0.09270112961530685,
0.41630104184150696,
-0.9282176494598389,
0.7813279032707214,
0.5918675065040588,
-0.4252011477947235,
0.3248293697834015,
0.4368259906768799,
-0.36664512753486633,
-0.7761209607124329,
0.6470178961753845,
-0.10172966122627258,
-0.09731650352478027,
0.35155412554740906,
-0.045824404805898666,
-0.78080815076828,
-0.2803659737110138,
-0.4268054664134979,
0.336532860994339,
-0.935335099697113,
-0.1325976848602295,
-0.6952206492424011,
0.32595258951187134,
-0.46756020188331604,
-0.3980642557144165,
-0.8319495320320129,
-0.19175101816654205,
0.14557893574237823,
-0.19872218370437622,
-0.23548060655593872,
1.0081782341003418,
-0.04594618082046509,
-0.14240685105323792,
-0.822002649307251,
0.30810290575027466,
-0.1805158257484436,
0.810469925403595,
-0.17206202447414398,
-0.08264408260583878,
-0.4258347451686859,
-0.18476206064224243,
-0.2590712010860443,
-0.8018225431442261,
-0.01779397949576378,
-0.07297827303409576,
0.9314601421356201,
0.08158368617296219,
-0.022711746394634247,
0.6194869875907898,
-0.7213196158409119,
0.8274995684623718,
0.30546239018440247,
-1.3032557964324951,
0.15906023979187012,
-0.01122399140149355,
0.6062029004096985,
0.6951127648353577,
0.5159241557121277,
-0.7330026030540466,
-0.3961905539035797,
-0.4772421419620514,
-1.0284364223480225,
0.4614505469799042,
0.0032462787348777056,
0.19893881678581238,
-0.05511130020022392,
-0.4226389527320862,
0.38725703954696655,
0.2990463972091675,
-0.5172089338302612,
-0.1507706195116043,
-0.033355362713336945,
-0.29327383637428284,
-0.4652946889400482,
-0.42762309312820435,
-0.020043037831783295,
-0.040428340435028076,
0.5346934199333191,
0.03244892507791519,
0.3343493938446045,
0.16288837790489197,
-0.5189636945724487,
0.12316270172595978,
0.4838050305843353,
0.22418347001075745,
0.7169159650802612,
-0.20008933544158936,
0.1552949845790863,
0.3914560377597809,
-0.4106846749782562,
0.06236343830823898,
0.05643726885318756,
0.20361202955245972,
0.47591432929039,
0.4102734327316284,
0.818141520023346,
0.5838711857795715,
-0.7183732986450195,
0.7218522429466248,
-0.22592727839946747,
-0.2721022069454193,
-0.10012702643871307,
-0.44401246309280396,
0.39249807596206665,
0.2469213455915451,
0.09625017642974854,
-0.18348582088947296,
0.08915798366069794,
-0.2632649540901184,
0.2060534507036209,
0.31761783361434937,
-0.6295322775840759,
-0.2215815782546997,
0.41075512766838074,
0.5731876492500305,
-0.03663479536771774,
0.25077906250953674,
-0.05323297157883644,
-0.4927707314491272,
0.6036844253540039,
0.5602012872695923,
1.040297031402588,
-0.40937885642051697,
0.4062056541442871,
0.41432470083236694,
0.7847321033477783,
-0.051009152084589005,
1.0355052947998047,
0.03531964123249054,
-0.3069498538970947,
-0.42843204736709595,
-0.8331931829452515,
-0.44235533475875854,
-0.3845396339893341,
-0.804949164390564,
0.4480831027030945,
-0.219730943441391,
-0.18368229269981384,
-0.03654985874891281,
-0.05157128721475601,
-1.115078330039978,
-0.08989199250936508,
0.08085563778877258,
1.3438937664031982,
-0.9137171506881714,
0.5414378046989441,
1.129696011543274,
0.1734819859266281,
-0.10797923058271408,
-0.4718073606491089,
-0.0919344574213028,
-0.48430442810058594,
0.4512333869934082,
0.5618943572044373,
0.02341279946267605,
-0.21446986496448517,
-0.022011270746588707,
-0.775719940662384,
0.8648650646209717,
0.43638095259666443,
-0.5510616898536682,
0.10592653602361679,
0.11080152541399002,
0.5384215712547302,
-0.2933099865913391,
0.15703432261943817,
0.27448511123657227,
0.7357065677642822,
-0.4856494665145874,
-1.016583800315857,
0.14578062295913696,
-0.4132351279258728,
0.17555677890777588,
0.6111092567443848,
-0.24823226034641266,
0.5719918012619019,
0.19406983256340027,
-0.5541410446166992,
-0.07251893728971481,
0.2241920679807663,
-0.15926192700862885,
0.322120726108551,
0.4387005567550659,
0.849168598651886,
0.6410361528396606,
-0.1432441920042038,
1.1523958444595337,
-0.3061423599720001,
0.47903233766555786,
1.128412127494812,
-0.37115734815597534,
1.1143693923950195,
0.5574449300765991,
-0.1887153536081314,
0.38121405243873596,
0.37411734461784363,
-0.023066673427820206,
0.6424843072891235,
0.06875647604465485,
0.06893598288297653,
-0.3135927617549896,
-0.18454231321811676,
-0.610787570476532,
0.28364673256874084,
0.3632213771343231,
-0.1328296661376953,
-0.5109990835189819,
0.17508020997047424,
-0.16860024631023407,
0.026547644287347794,
-0.05307752266526222,
0.8279594779014587,
0.10983508080244064,
-0.4968348443508148,
0.6034196615219116,
0.015473357401788235,
0.76536625623703,
-0.6667383313179016,
-0.0562824122607708,
-0.16407056152820587,
0.2325565218925476,
0.09515433013439178,
-0.8749096393585205,
0.3816951811313629,
0.04676700383424759,
0.07255301624536514,
-0.5201058387756348,
0.5418930649757385,
-0.39372971653938293,
-0.23926226794719696,
0.7808634042739868,
0.6223083138465881,
0.13347560167312622,
0.05444629117846489,
-0.8142653107643127,
0.30781468749046326,
-0.0045912303030490875,
-0.2649509906768799,
0.13630275428295135,
0.47252392768859863,
0.1242843046784401,
0.3699573278427124,
0.642888069152832,
-0.05718323960900307,
-0.011863503605127335,
-0.056798070669174194,
0.7676241993904114,
-0.8570352792739868,
-0.7793576121330261,
-0.6831240653991699,
0.7195049524307251,
-0.1932286024093628,
-0.5358732342720032,
0.9442213177680969,
0.9490769505500793,
1.0506634712219238,
-0.2479250580072403,
0.8129349946975708,
-0.29063674807548523,
0.6372848153114319,
-0.2706350088119507,
0.7872013449668884,
-0.9687972664833069,
-0.06209464371204376,
-0.4263269603252411,
-1.2346512079238892,
-0.13839970529079437,
0.2459937036037445,
-0.14692264795303345,
-0.2291983813047409,
1.097551941871643,
0.45990413427352905,
-0.22676220536231995,
0.060565102845430374,
0.7197596430778503,
0.16095265746116638,
0.09778903424739838,
0.27212485671043396,
0.7025848031044006,
-0.32322508096694946,
0.34539082646369934,
-0.14667321741580963,
-0.316476047039032,
-0.22305387258529663,
-1.2014497518539429,
-1.1817127466201782,
-0.7272924184799194,
-0.12890315055847168,
0.0005741440691053867,
0.22458919882774353,
0.9667940735816956,
0.5244203805923462,
-1.03444504737854,
-0.3614492416381836,
0.26781967282295227,
0.2061871439218521,
-0.35751283168792725,
-0.15872855484485626,
0.3596549332141876,
-0.3358139097690582,
-0.6174143552780151,
0.34124407172203064,
0.4001595079898834,
-0.0755307525396347,
-0.3439529836177826,
-0.01700470969080925,
-0.32470378279685974,
0.20203427970409393,
0.525355339050293,
-0.13847164809703827,
-0.36173292994499207,
0.2081480771303177,
0.1645461767911911,
-0.19040487706661224,
-0.07085112482309341,
0.7204784750938416,
-0.339656800031662,
0.6131355166435242,
0.8308604955673218,
1.0044658184051514,
0.41705626249313354,
-0.44844892621040344,
0.5072890520095825,
-0.8689528703689575,
0.054509487003088,
0.28275230526924133,
0.4538699984550476,
0.33070001006126404,
0.1299387365579605,
0.553941547870636,
-0.01883554644882679,
-0.3387347459793091,
-1.2001417875289917,
-0.2072799801826477,
-0.5228441953659058,
-0.4844929277896881,
0.8380277156829834,
-0.39983242750167847,
-0.3052668571472168,
-0.2015429139137268,
-0.010493825189769268,
-0.2373218983411789,
-0.40655285120010376,
0.34695154428482056,
1.0341699123382568,
0.44452565908432007,
0.18626128137111664,
-0.609997034072876,
0.09630859643220901,
0.5216349363327026,
-0.7474370002746582,
0.10711514949798584,
0.30966484546661377,
0.13631300628185272,
0.2453259825706482,
0.4351824223995209,
-0.3683665692806244,
0.38872936367988586,
0.3717348277568817,
0.3803410828113556,
0.08048795163631439,
-0.6585460901260376,
-0.35905441641807556,
0.07551992684602737,
-0.07212662696838379,
-0.22084295749664307
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.02394v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.02394v1
|
Multiple Choice Questions and Large Languages Models: A Case Study with Fictional Medical Data
| 2024-06-04T15:08:56 | 2024-06-04T15:08:56 |
Maxime Griot, Jean Vanderdonckt, Demet Yuksel, Coralie Hemptinne
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) like ChatGPT demonstrate significant potential
in the medical field, often evaluated using multiple-choice questions (MCQs)
similar to those found on the USMLE. Despite their prevalence in medical
education, MCQs have limitations that might be exacerbated when assessing LLMs.
To evaluate the effectiveness of MCQs in assessing the performance of LLMs, we
developed a fictional medical benchmark focused on a non-existent gland, the
Glianorex. This approach allowed us to isolate the knowledge of the LLM from
its test-taking abilities. We used GPT-4 to generate a comprehensive textbook
on the Glianorex in both English and French and developed corresponding
multiple-choice questions in both languages. We evaluated various open-source,
proprietary, and domain-specific LLMs using these questions in a zero-shot
setting. The models achieved average scores around 67%, with minor performance
differences between larger and smaller models. Performance was slightly higher
in English than in French. Fine-tuned medical models showed some improvement
over their base versions in English but not in French. The uniformly high
performance across models suggests that traditional MCQ-based benchmarks may
not accurately measure LLMs' clinical knowledge and reasoning abilities,
instead highlighting their pattern recognition skills. This study underscores
the need for more robust evaluation methods to better assess the true
capabilities of LLMs in medical contexts.
|
[
-0.3110072910785675,
-0.8415002822875977,
0.9679350256919861,
-0.18950404226779938,
-0.05250536650419235,
0.15650177001953125,
-0.31370043754577637,
-0.6340816020965576,
0.09787782281637192,
0.509942889213562,
-0.3381868302822113,
-0.3892022669315338,
-0.6152781844139099,
0.22191070020198822,
-0.06645533442497253,
0.6613120436668396,
-0.19955137372016907,
0.5500430464744568,
-0.43782228231430054,
-0.28887465596199036,
-0.2553446292877197,
-0.7608185410499573,
-0.7304330468177795,
-0.2909444272518158,
0.4769853353500366,
0.14378799498081207,
0.7284026145935059,
0.3547680079936981,
0.46925589442253113,
0.22804878652095795,
-0.02321944385766983,
0.2591738700866699,
-0.3228028416633606,
0.09201377630233765,
-0.29572752118110657,
-0.509698212146759,
-0.2095782607793808,
0.25918909907341003,
0.5962883830070496,
0.7279421091079712,
-0.16148988902568817,
0.11358053237199783,
-0.06943414360284805,
0.42097046971321106,
-0.3184538185596466,
-0.08745035529136658,
-0.33380943536758423,
-0.06528782099485397,
-0.052311915904283524,
-0.011116462759673595,
-0.33123883605003357,
-0.46829092502593994,
0.12601543962955475,
-0.24157682061195374,
-0.0162351094186306,
-0.018068602308630943,
0.8088660836219788,
-0.05203680694103241,
-0.6535322070121765,
-0.5496591329574585,
-0.6294596791267395,
0.8268951177597046,
-0.6669042706489563,
0.4762417674064636,
0.38149839639663696,
0.4685940146446228,
-0.20467917621135712,
-0.5922443866729736,
-0.2795224189758301,
-0.730449914932251,
0.014350487850606441,
0.2961362600326538,
-0.07390700280666351,
-0.132608562707901,
0.3107507526874542,
0.42525410652160645,
-0.8268495798110962,
0.1615029275417328,
-0.4255037009716034,
-0.2523099482059479,
0.49222052097320557,
0.2713644206523895,
0.523783802986145,
-0.04313335940241814,
-0.256003737449646,
0.1250249445438385,
-0.7047796249389648,
-0.05600258708000183,
0.2475844770669937,
-0.0026781675405800343,
0.14710189402103424,
0.7215589284896851,
0.05776939541101456,
0.7191454172134399,
-0.4107109308242798,
-0.39524030685424805,
0.08465675264596939,
-0.2352067083120346,
-0.15041473507881165,
-0.33339619636535645,
0.8518396615982056,
0.26201748847961426,
0.5001250505447388,
-0.04982120171189308,
0.027028953656554222,
0.08356838673353195,
0.19630031287670135,
-0.7537994384765625,
0.03335835039615631,
0.5424906015396118,
-0.37792545557022095,
-0.1451244056224823,
-0.4916349947452545,
-0.671601414680481,
-0.3994642198085785,
-0.3015041947364807,
0.542896032333374,
-0.592978298664093,
-0.2208135575056076,
0.10873545706272125,
0.02281065471470356,
0.20390626788139343,
0.40873637795448303,
-0.8450644612312317,
0.4978295564651489,
0.3455423414707184,
0.8005425333976746,
-0.30806711316108704,
-0.139689102768898,
-0.22899019718170166,
0.060257960110902786,
-0.401283860206604,
0.829364001750946,
-0.7472022175788879,
-0.7018876075744629,
-0.10633422434329987,
0.06424122303724289,
-0.5584948658943176,
-0.8156346082687378,
0.4654085338115692,
-0.32018613815307617,
0.42555561661720276,
-0.21889105439186096,
-0.8896506428718567,
-0.18145553767681122,
0.47099798917770386,
-0.4890107810497284,
0.6930886507034302,
0.202448308467865,
-0.42965492606163025,
0.19885993003845215,
-0.4638744294643402,
-0.34240683913230896,
0.039884455502033234,
-0.71766197681427,
-0.1598837971687317,
0.007833397947251797,
0.3662802577018738,
0.43504106998443604,
-0.6015339493751526,
0.2722545862197876,
-0.26676326990127563,
-0.21873784065246582,
0.4759763181209564,
-0.700201690196991,
0.7526184320449829,
0.10195740312337875,
-0.07446840405464172,
-0.22334574162960052,
-0.5277896523475647,
0.33760568499565125,
0.13065969944000244,
-0.49604901671409607,
-0.20906929671764374,
-0.05414144694805145,
-0.19131845235824585,
0.22802014648914337,
0.129595547914505,
-0.41435906291007996,
0.3689092993736267,
-0.14274848997592926,
0.4032121002674103,
0.3370012044906616,
0.2389833778142929,
-0.1087552160024643,
-0.5731451511383057,
0.7575790882110596,
-0.26971879601478577,
0.3667141795158386,
0.20730048418045044,
-0.8627822399139404,
-0.4513813853263855,
-0.5250784754753113,
0.38185977935791016,
0.714236855506897,
-0.7206540703773499,
-0.20152217149734497,
0.020295456051826477,
-0.6874499320983887,
-0.4110817313194275,
0.04374123737215996,
0.24329575896263123,
0.5188889503479004,
0.33362361788749695,
-0.2401653379201889,
-0.09667082130908966,
-1.0262858867645264,
-0.330619215965271,
-0.14463207125663757,
-0.1889682561159134,
0.8387749791145325,
0.7779366970062256,
-0.30322596430778503,
0.4560793936252594,
-0.5230567455291748,
-0.053095877170562744,
-0.14346987009048462,
-0.014132440090179443,
0.3746226727962494,
0.2845596671104431,
0.6399043202400208,
-0.6344873905181885,
-0.40291163325309753,
0.1637750267982483,
-0.741571307182312,
0.055182136595249176,
0.13295182585716248,
-0.004280938301235437,
-0.010688155889511108,
0.40397465229034424,
-0.661186158657074,
0.1041831523180008,
0.686225414276123,
-0.020419379696249962,
1.0761128664016724,
-0.4269557297229767,
0.49252140522003174,
-0.8469175100326538,
0.13878634572029114,
-0.15902827680110931,
-0.20993712544441223,
-0.563014030456543,
-0.0187842920422554,
0.3598371148109436,
-0.14569877088069916,
-0.6222729086875916,
0.8400404453277588,
-0.43262699246406555,
0.15765896439552307,
0.08748086541891098,
0.08801991492509842,
-0.15305674076080322,
0.24208301305770874,
0.07556577026844025,
0.9798685312271118,
0.6137127876281738,
-0.6315066814422607,
0.2707378566265106,
-0.00011805081157945096,
-0.5307376384735107,
0.6642977595329285,
-0.574800968170166,
0.01650228165090084,
0.1694997400045395,
-0.10723622888326645,
-0.9988405108451843,
-0.42572176456451416,
0.014068839140236378,
-0.3561573326587677,
0.25808000564575195,
-0.2654198110103607,
-0.34178414940834045,
-0.5386508703231812,
-0.02019539475440979,
0.29864004254341125,
0.5743171572685242,
-0.2541734576225281,
0.39494603872299194,
0.3076092004776001,
-0.2828366458415985,
-0.4720296263694763,
-0.506121039390564,
0.00666400883346796,
-0.16262519359588623,
-0.476134717464447,
-0.10138792544603348,
-0.30513083934783936,
-0.2200484722852707,
-0.1726531833410263,
-0.17293284833431244,
-0.3416327238082886,
-0.10556236654520035,
-0.15415740013122559,
0.5082600712776184,
-0.32074153423309326,
0.26101112365722656,
-0.06757547706365585,
0.18937456607818604,
0.014012446627020836,
-0.14756490290164948,
0.4634546637535095,
-0.1288405805826187,
-0.6845382452011108,
-0.008246265351772308,
0.42691415548324585,
0.8219436407089233,
-0.13567976653575897,
0.4668968915939331,
0.30883845686912537,
-0.4313865303993225,
0.028965521603822708,
-0.7940212488174438,
-0.0008554130326956511,
-0.3937152922153473,
0.35485702753067017,
-0.266149640083313,
-1.0450465679168701,
0.552463710308075,
-0.12785671651363373,
-0.10955701768398285,
0.46890899538993835,
0.8972498178482056,
-0.12570790946483612,
1.0475224256515503,
0.10559358447790146,
0.11581125855445862,
0.07924580574035645,
-0.0730002224445343,
-0.06452983617782593,
-0.8834477663040161,
0.01936768740415573,
-0.39925992488861084,
-0.03852701559662819,
-0.5695176124572754,
-0.7321844696998596,
0.6386741995811462,
-0.1165548712015152,
-0.10650286823511124,
0.06360563635826111,
-0.24454447627067566,
0.6223236918449402,
0.2601245045661926,
0.17023371160030365,
0.3719117343425751,
-0.060642682015895844,
-0.7447898983955383,
-0.029422197490930557,
-0.6551017165184021,
-0.7712351083755493,
1.472365379333496,
0.2753960192203522,
0.6589843034744263,
0.27262115478515625,
0.45899713039398193,
0.012488049454987049,
0.4784310758113861,
-0.7976445555686951,
0.4803388714790344,
-0.26176539063453674,
-0.9731579422950745,
-0.3245551586151123,
-0.5410282015800476,
-1.0186045169830322,
0.5626923441886902,
-0.060779720544815063,
-1.0105794668197632,
0.006815456785261631,
-0.19218739867210388,
-0.6007300019264221,
0.3213444948196411,
-0.9366481304168701,
0.8385039567947388,
-0.5593469738960266,
-0.43062204122543335,
0.0017199015710502863,
-0.28576651215553284,
0.5154881477355957,
-0.23341970145702362,
0.4154123365879059,
-0.20902054011821747,
-0.22242678701877594,
0.5913259387016296,
-0.1713334321975708,
0.6318425536155701,
0.18035198748111725,
-0.056919440627098083,
0.296909898519516,
0.15184539556503296,
0.14393946528434753,
0.4544747769832611,
-0.24592851102352142,
0.1189844086766243,
0.4012441635131836,
-0.412625789642334,
-0.5155655145645142,
0.6923611760139465,
-0.8393664956092834,
-0.7046893835067749,
-0.5444470047950745,
-0.4533824026584625,
-0.7595060467720032,
0.2017730325460434,
0.14429233968257904,
0.6714101433753967,
-0.49985992908477783,
-0.01667937822639942,
0.6280710101127625,
-0.5454060435295105,
0.11455056816339493,
0.7985087037086487,
-0.3985758125782013,
-0.5352333188056946,
0.7061305642127991,
0.27727457880973816,
0.6387768983840942,
0.18960198760032654,
0.32047730684280396,
-0.5311629772186279,
-0.5728194713592529,
-0.5994919538497925,
0.5711323022842407,
-0.6438475847244263,
0.1509784609079361,
-0.552794337272644,
-0.46891069412231445,
-0.24475668370723724,
0.11426267772912979,
-0.260021448135376,
-0.15940232574939728,
-0.17306067049503326,
0.21311570703983307,
0.051790595054626465,
0.7911637425422668,
0.1561133712530136,
-0.24055233597755432,
-0.7858641743659973,
0.2975430488586426,
0.5625966787338257,
0.4860650300979614,
-0.23259389400482178,
-0.4269639253616333,
0.03949397802352905,
0.030619772151112556,
-0.23683851957321167,
-0.8756980299949646,
0.31076565384864807,
0.03920409455895424,
0.8781683444976807,
0.2491847276687622,
-0.2980722486972809,
0.5346094965934753,
-0.741500198841095,
0.8562365174293518,
0.19183377921581268,
-0.5473031997680664,
0.33122000098228455,
-0.47424647212028503,
0.3888953924179077,
0.4113363027572632,
0.8013534545898438,
-0.6660347580909729,
-0.5127832889556885,
-0.5700278878211975,
-0.540897786617279,
0.30840522050857544,
0.2678479850292206,
0.03105921857059002,
-0.21115362644195557,
0.27643513679504395,
0.22999097406864166,
0.24134516716003418,
-0.4714488983154297,
-0.012590198777616024,
0.3735833466053009,
0.021868925541639328,
-0.3789072334766388,
-0.18828696012496948,
-0.3015778064727783,
-0.3340356647968292,
0.5204824805259705,
-0.11206712573766708,
0.3626132011413574,
0.3931169807910919,
-0.11190219223499298,
0.13863253593444824,
0.6372649669647217,
0.8675750494003296,
0.9344467520713806,
-0.19671744108200073,
0.06467198580503464,
0.3755246698856354,
-0.8434394001960754,
0.2707419991493225,
-0.05163479968905449,
0.09552037715911865,
-0.02098979242146015,
0.3031209111213684,
0.41059255599975586,
0.021028919145464897,
-0.951500654220581,
0.3888923227787018,
-0.242763951420784,
-0.4322289228439331,
-0.1607600748538971,
0.14577354490756989,
0.35946914553642273,
0.2556796669960022,
0.10446672886610031,
0.028004199266433716,
0.010683039203286171,
-0.5653758645057678,
0.24136444926261902,
0.4711969196796417,
-0.34354957938194275,
0.09391210228204727,
0.6016953587532043,
-0.06679218262434006,
-0.038844313472509384,
0.4550544023513794,
-0.12187480926513672,
-0.2815499007701874,
0.7793256640434265,
0.504436194896698,
0.43446946144104004,
-0.357596755027771,
0.34988507628440857,
0.42928701639175415,
0.4687894284725189,
-0.23428034782409668,
0.39154449105262756,
0.4474073648452759,
-0.6317079663276672,
-0.5399591326713562,
-0.4681894779205322,
-0.7897477149963379,
0.5274662971496582,
-0.4114193916320801,
0.2564432621002197,
-0.40525639057159424,
-0.3470747768878937,
0.07656784355640411,
0.030615465715527534,
-0.7444453239440918,
0.39076748490333557,
0.2007099688053131,
0.8759162425994873,
-0.5618902444839478,
0.7985343337059021,
0.8194908499717712,
-0.4569621682167053,
-0.854729950428009,
-0.17898854613304138,
0.0034026005305349827,
-1.0607059001922607,
0.18027344346046448,
-0.020687319338321686,
0.21288101375102997,
-0.1961337924003601,
-0.3541475534439087,
-0.9726176261901855,
0.9717812538146973,
0.6091172695159912,
-0.5270289778709412,
0.16151723265647888,
0.32093361020088196,
0.6892722249031067,
-0.3051070272922516,
0.8117425441741943,
0.6320902109146118,
0.3462596535682678,
0.13382485508918762,
-1.2242214679718018,
-0.1313479244709015,
-0.1569252461194992,
-0.20133237540721893,
0.09216303378343582,
-0.5826742649078369,
0.9555992484092712,
-0.26415205001831055,
-0.02869473397731781,
0.11589046567678452,
-0.18094797432422638,
0.31345614790916443,
-0.023945292457938194,
0.1215449720621109,
0.32017695903778076,
1.1270267963409424,
-0.2056780904531479,
1.3527116775512695,
-0.19191987812519073,
0.475061297416687,
0.8367547988891602,
-0.5104566216468811,
0.950330376625061,
0.4710790812969208,
-0.41326799988746643,
0.2412007600069046,
0.6870589256286621,
-0.03789952024817467,
0.062081821262836456,
0.37456560134887695,
-0.328840047121048,
-0.46945759654045105,
0.014800820499658585,
-0.664526641368866,
0.3193657100200653,
0.4892176389694214,
-0.37967032194137573,
-0.12041871249675751,
0.039373498409986496,
0.14836233854293823,
-0.16782021522521973,
-0.26967254281044006,
0.4473404586315155,
0.19281408190727234,
-0.60649573802948,
0.7636539936065674,
-0.2505432963371277,
0.24068082869052887,
-0.853710949420929,
0.15006832778453827,
-0.24609927833080292,
0.1187291368842125,
-0.043311070650815964,
-0.8260763883590698,
0.04947425425052643,
0.032366685569286346,
0.07383652031421661,
0.04350793734192848,
0.6720831990242004,
-0.3565605580806732,
-0.839309573173523,
0.1752176135778427,
0.9771848320960999,
0.45954400300979614,
0.07596249878406525,
-0.6582619547843933,
-0.09601501375436783,
-0.11375608295202255,
-0.35096490383148193,
0.4417078197002411,
0.19961750507354736,
-0.12417993694543839,
0.8738530278205872,
0.668082594871521,
0.3301704227924347,
-0.1717076301574707,
0.19738991558551788,
0.6635100841522217,
-0.5541078448295593,
-0.2702382802963257,
-0.9486894607543945,
0.22800493240356445,
-0.11302533000707626,
-0.27206042408943176,
0.6317752599716187,
0.6221523880958557,
0.5810128450393677,
-0.3351961374282837,
0.9827620983123779,
0.14431065320968628,
0.694143533706665,
-0.6199941039085388,
0.8166259527206421,
-0.7181137204170227,
0.15781359374523163,
-0.2583187222480774,
-0.7213326096534729,
-0.4094570279121399,
0.4377456307411194,
-0.6745414137840271,
0.27808529138565063,
1.1680781841278076,
0.6261915564537048,
-0.026615779846906662,
0.0852353423833847,
0.7934052348136902,
0.278155654668808,
0.2827904224395752,
0.7735826969146729,
1.0436501502990723,
-0.27760007977485657,
0.4967319667339325,
0.11994858086109161,
-0.3209892511367798,
0.027559539303183556,
-0.7478148341178894,
-1.074974536895752,
-0.18013368546962738,
-0.2893601655960083,
-0.14204199612140656,
0.11371690034866333,
0.8828668594360352,
0.4758920669555664,
-0.8762254118919373,
-0.46624740958213806,
0.44604846835136414,
0.07312409579753876,
-0.24933716654777527,
-0.14442285895347595,
0.3423956036567688,
-0.2184813916683197,
-0.5779718160629272,
0.45928439497947693,
0.3130199909210205,
0.25433769822120667,
-0.13394597172737122,
0.10343247652053833,
-0.3623430132865906,
0.26006820797920227,
0.6406461000442505,
0.20843251049518585,
-0.6311840415000916,
-0.36246052384376526,
0.25158581137657166,
-0.26640772819519043,
0.08827434480190277,
0.729694128036499,
-0.5630664229393005,
0.4232361912727356,
0.09574215114116669,
0.5343125462532043,
0.3190067410469055,
-0.25657984614372253,
0.5831862688064575,
-0.27675071358680725,
-0.18706078827381134,
0.43256697058677673,
0.5045783519744873,
0.13109076023101807,
-0.15597032010555267,
0.5058506727218628,
0.29847991466522217,
-0.763933002948761,
-0.5534781217575073,
0.14030204713344574,
-0.7872098088264465,
-0.4106978178024292,
1.4806393384933472,
-0.01108853705227375,
-0.04512235149741173,
-0.25144660472869873,
-0.5735486745834351,
-0.06306880712509155,
-0.08767957240343094,
0.5213919281959534,
1.0900861024856567,
-0.4158842861652374,
0.016518419608473778,
-1.4612228870391846,
0.4348588287830353,
0.3558953106403351,
-0.8393099904060364,
-0.22807876765727997,
0.4808965027332306,
0.6694250702857971,
-0.052451007068157196,
0.839515745639801,
-0.47667571902275085,
0.2995182275772095,
-0.1262584924697876,
-0.18255189061164856,
0.23158001899719238,
0.038519419729709625,
-0.16671188175678253,
0.2087700217962265,
0.15079431235790253,
0.005805926863104105
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.02378v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.02378v1
|
On the Intrinsic Self-Correction Capability of LLMs: Uncertainty and Latent Concept
| 2024-06-04T14:55:43 | 2024-06-04T14:55:43 |
Guangliang Liu, Haitao Mao, Bochuan Cao, Zhiyu Xue, Kristen Johnson, Jiliang Tang, Rongrong Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) can improve their responses when instructed to
do so, a capability known as self-correction. When these instructions lack
specific details about the issues in the response, this is referred to as
leveraging the intrinsic self-correction capability. The empirical success of
self-correction can be found in various applications, e.g., text detoxification
and social bias mitigation. However, leveraging this self-correction capability
may not always be effective, as it has the potential to revise an initially
correct response into an incorrect one. In this paper, we endeavor to
understand how and why leveraging the self-correction capability is effective.
We identify that appropriate instructions can guide LLMs to a convergence
state, wherein additional self-correction steps do not yield further
performance improvements. We empirically demonstrate that model uncertainty and
activated latent concepts jointly characterize the effectiveness of
self-correction. Furthermore, we provide a mathematical formulation indicating
that the activated latent concept drives the convergence of the model
uncertainty and self-correction performance. Our analysis can also be
generalized to the self-correction behaviors observed in Vision-Language Models
(VLMs). Moreover, we highlight that task-agnostic debiasing can benefit from
our principle in terms of selecting effective fine-tuning samples. Such initial
success demonstrates the potential extensibility for better instruction tuning
and safety alignment.
|
[
0.14086955785751343,
-0.866853654384613,
0.5794686675071716,
-0.0033513172529637814,
0.02007404714822769,
0.21627408266067505,
-0.31885021924972534,
-0.28245484828948975,
-0.14379049837589264,
0.41387832164764404,
-0.2918795049190521,
-0.12822744250297546,
-0.5970720052719116,
0.19536970555782318,
-0.48362067341804504,
0.9344381093978882,
-0.09436746686697006,
0.04326775670051575,
0.0028698109090328217,
-0.06266027688980103,
-0.42068132758140564,
-0.6312292814254761,
-0.44426077604293823,
-0.2204897105693817,
0.6645903587341309,
0.559688150882721,
0.4961656332015991,
0.7030521631240845,
0.6970518231391907,
0.3406338393688202,
0.02185196243226528,
0.05950969457626343,
-0.5797678232192993,
0.14611512422561646,
-0.4296865165233612,
-0.8466959595680237,
-0.6077565550804138,
0.035848405212163925,
0.8490018844604492,
0.5407828688621521,
-0.28846439719200134,
-0.038886044174432755,
0.42836102843284607,
0.8758139610290527,
-0.8409711718559265,
-0.26928210258483887,
-0.7930421829223633,
-0.01666002720594406,
-0.11315203458070755,
-0.20961488783359528,
-0.10996285825967789,
0.01277322880923748,
0.12247002124786377,
-0.39799171686172485,
0.28947684168815613,
-0.09344272315502167,
0.5408524870872498,
0.9102073311805725,
-0.24912422895431519,
-0.28272920846939087,
-1.0681421756744385,
0.6595403552055359,
-0.8933098316192627,
0.1449819952249527,
0.4658294916152954,
-0.05329113453626633,
-0.03860580548644066,
-0.36148297786712646,
-0.5127844214439392,
-0.024872535839676857,
0.12703587114810944,
0.02885470539331436,
-0.11969985067844391,
0.25074493885040283,
0.3133997321128845,
0.4824933409690857,
0.019045263528823853,
0.4671292304992676,
-0.28518223762512207,
-0.262362003326416,
0.4451395869255066,
0.11233772337436676,
0.0020053137559443712,
-0.12118469178676605,
-0.3667902946472168,
-0.021344367414712906,
-0.8067761063575745,
0.0016121207736432552,
0.3770362436771393,
0.3066016137599945,
0.03224697336554527,
0.7746616005897522,
-0.2447526901960373,
0.5302233695983887,
0.4427664875984192,
-0.34669235348701477,
-0.005108729470521212,
-0.2848778963088989,
-0.10290135443210602,
0.05102740600705147,
0.42188531160354614,
0.28822869062423706,
-0.053717926144599915,
-0.16055499017238617,
-0.528130054473877,
-0.0372842513024807,
0.5444962382316589,
-0.5846512317657471,
0.033196330070495605,
0.286185085773468,
-0.1800583004951477,
-0.15845632553100586,
-0.22027947008609772,
-0.26660090684890747,
-0.1121000275015831,
-0.6081469058990479,
0.5994476675987244,
-0.32708802819252014,
0.014407654292881489,
0.08701695501804352,
0.1693020612001419,
-0.01597626693546772,
0.5493103861808777,
-1.0357005596160889,
-0.0146735655143857,
0.5177003741264343,
0.7298282980918884,
-0.2865274250507355,
-0.2325204610824585,
-0.3342660367488861,
0.3441503942012787,
-0.5052281022071838,
0.777717649936676,
-0.3733316659927368,
-0.3732497990131378,
-0.23952722549438477,
-0.1419530212879181,
-0.09308074414730072,
-0.432047039270401,
0.2630525231361389,
-0.40085387229919434,
-0.18036878108978271,
-0.5179254412651062,
-0.6409181952476501,
-0.049772948026657104,
0.17308366298675537,
-0.3468130826950073,
1.0517523288726807,
-0.04930165410041809,
-0.6956321001052856,
0.18829871714115143,
-0.22979800403118134,
-0.17256592214107513,
-0.15804913640022278,
-0.1893545538187027,
-0.2674570381641388,
0.4872157871723175,
0.005017517600208521,
0.5234641432762146,
0.020808696746826172,
0.154004767537117,
-0.3728179335594177,
-0.24102818965911865,
0.3850947916507721,
-0.6047216653823853,
0.2689627707004547,
0.19830623269081116,
-0.6239473223686218,
0.18044322729110718,
-0.5139507055282593,
-0.15008601546287537,
-0.10588379949331284,
-0.24165351688861847,
-0.4924350678920746,
0.09346920251846313,
-0.6713497638702393,
-0.013975871726870537,
0.30243736505508423,
-0.24923329055309296,
0.34674501419067383,
-0.3562304675579071,
0.4020877778530121,
1.082562804222107,
-0.16352194547653198,
0.6042178869247437,
-0.2056128978729248,
0.4462014138698578,
-0.10337845236063004,
0.01920435018837452,
-0.2633090913295746,
-0.08886869996786118,
-0.9260745644569397,
-0.09626302868127823,
0.34888654947280884,
0.7996814250946045,
-0.6975353360176086,
0.44186773896217346,
-0.0024410157930105925,
-0.3814608156681061,
-0.40688222646713257,
0.5022229552268982,
0.6097058057785034,
0.8033802509307861,
0.27926957607269287,
-0.2720077335834503,
-0.18583863973617554,
-0.7113249897956848,
-0.23773278295993805,
-0.29866909980773926,
0.3612546920776367,
0.10567807406187057,
0.4698145389556885,
-0.13845473527908325,
0.9020681977272034,
-0.31772005558013916,
-0.3039652109146118,
0.10786749422550201,
0.2355017364025116,
-0.04720667377114296,
0.4390667974948883,
0.3466225266456604,
-0.5385777950286865,
-0.26218587160110474,
-0.29803580045700073,
-0.9310251474380493,
-0.2547387182712555,
-0.2292473018169403,
0.07330760359764099,
0.5195972919464111,
0.6790800094604492,
-0.16534577310085297,
0.5501502156257629,
0.359971821308136,
-0.1136615052819252,
0.7217729091644287,
-0.6936108469963074,
0.14879809319972992,
-0.645439624786377,
-0.18790608644485474,
-0.05694759264588356,
-0.08265170454978943,
-0.4573862850666046,
0.11900702118873596,
0.2067800760269165,
0.3847581446170807,
-0.3372270464897156,
0.49177002906799316,
-0.6454622149467468,
-0.026061177253723145,
-0.6660526394844055,
0.15436358749866486,
-0.3323431611061096,
0.17835350334644318,
-0.15839587152004242,
1.0578782558441162,
0.5220350623130798,
-1.0327210426330566,
0.2121771275997162,
-0.0441196970641613,
-0.11916179955005646,
0.8840802907943726,
-0.7488290667533875,
0.15480035543441772,
-0.1448085755109787,
-0.16411040723323822,
-0.9773001670837402,
-0.009436382912099361,
0.20627199113368988,
-0.20788615942001343,
0.6521874070167542,
0.09370150417089462,
-0.33966007828712463,
-0.4122677445411682,
-0.13163727521896362,
0.22536209225654602,
0.2575088143348694,
-0.4243975579738617,
0.5522676706314087,
0.3151613175868988,
-0.14988404512405396,
-0.9875599145889282,
-0.7165660858154297,
0.14978742599487305,
-0.14189079403877258,
-0.2868501543998718,
0.360429972410202,
-0.24031199514865875,
-0.27709269523620605,
0.1397441178560257,
-0.3006930649280548,
0.32999441027641296,
0.24540188908576965,
0.17353534698486328,
0.14262787997722626,
0.010202961042523384,
0.5881905555725098,
0.03430032357573509,
-0.27838584780693054,
-0.05989059805870056,
-0.31215283274650574,
0.2100886106491089,
-0.28486311435699463,
-0.695067286491394,
-0.2334095984697342,
-0.09400250017642975,
0.14853914082050323,
-0.09536787122488022,
0.5806663632392883,
0.5024930238723755,
-0.19589264690876007,
-0.1254262775182724,
-0.8098337054252625,
-0.45853495597839355,
-0.49420592188835144,
0.3125143349170685,
-0.35298123955726624,
-1.2028192281723022,
0.5265465378761292,
0.0922871008515358,
-0.11557184904813766,
0.5440190434455872,
0.7536122798919678,
-0.3377882242202759,
0.5963922142982483,
0.7553138136863708,
0.03391609713435173,
0.46679678559303284,
-0.24177095293998718,
0.32335522770881653,
-1.173529863357544,
-0.03940388932824135,
-0.6177387237548828,
-0.3523089587688446,
-0.5134703516960144,
-0.6263937950134277,
0.3585856556892395,
0.17198015749454498,
-0.10771268606185913,
0.06826455891132355,
-0.5066342949867249,
0.23686635494232178,
0.7226956486701965,
0.2716231942176819,
0.39915406703948975,
0.06484569609165192,
-0.16813719272613525,
-0.41184476017951965,
-0.7246055006980896,
-0.5966378450393677,
1.1001321077346802,
0.4751746654510498,
1.4478273391723633,
-0.025383256375789642,
0.5709021091461182,
0.2804962694644928,
0.15234293043613434,
-0.756729006767273,
0.3779255747795105,
-0.15589827299118042,
-0.6690520644187927,
-0.5398321747779846,
-0.3103616535663605,
-0.6701733469963074,
0.010828452184796333,
-0.2609836459159851,
-0.6556926369667053,
0.29046431183815,
0.5497979521751404,
-0.523568868637085,
0.48862484097480774,
-0.6770384907722473,
0.6258922815322876,
-0.7018023133277893,
-0.68348228931427,
-0.4647846221923828,
-0.5971956253051758,
0.07446000725030899,
-0.4063453674316406,
0.044799111783504486,
-0.2310071885585785,
-0.3831840753555298,
0.437060683965683,
-0.15605385601520538,
1.4123080968856812,
-0.020159846171736717,
-0.6125065684318542,
0.3920603096485138,
0.04023893550038338,
0.3820546269416809,
-0.1384097933769226,
0.009467742405831814,
0.20368853211402893,
-0.2228660136461258,
-0.20350678265094757,
-0.8045641779899597,
0.494745135307312,
-0.7846320271492004,
-1.091957688331604,
-0.4717736542224884,
-0.4891104996204376,
-0.10207012295722961,
0.19455690681934357,
0.16218125820159912,
0.24434562027454376,
-0.02392435446381569,
0.24559061229228973,
0.8967934250831604,
-0.07372593879699707,
0.5499795079231262,
0.8244591951370239,
-0.2041921764612198,
-0.22621211409568787,
0.8276503682136536,
0.5573848485946655,
0.5664130449295044,
0.41560542583465576,
0.18725010752677917,
-0.4086019992828369,
-0.6712841987609863,
-0.31510552763938904,
0.257758229970932,
-0.7985671162605286,
-0.18130823969841003,
-0.72630774974823,
-0.12049712240695953,
-0.5020052194595337,
-0.151038259267807,
-0.4343074858188629,
-0.4598820209503174,
-0.4539395570755005,
-0.10822649300098419,
0.1547621786594391,
0.7797994613647461,
-0.5170184373855591,
0.5892952084541321,
-0.7324411869049072,
0.29192301630973816,
0.5592288374900818,
0.3457864820957184,
0.021547799929976463,
-0.9426916837692261,
-0.21591079235076904,
0.22215111553668976,
-0.3883715569972992,
-0.7626665234565735,
0.10392895340919495,
0.32063421607017517,
0.9125842452049255,
0.3307618796825409,
0.12995831668376923,
0.7057169675827026,
-0.43874815106391907,
0.5350528359413147,
-0.1199561282992363,
-1.166833758354187,
0.7661290764808655,
-0.19841858744621277,
0.2302883267402649,
0.42533639073371887,
0.1793062537908554,
-0.3579721748828888,
-0.465419739484787,
-0.49455103278160095,
-0.7764187455177307,
0.5799228549003601,
0.24985308945178986,
0.3808678686618805,
0.03392711281776428,
0.8140310049057007,
-0.18907661736011505,
0.27267521619796753,
-0.5238288044929504,
-0.282366544008255,
-0.10237394273281097,
-0.05872407183051109,
-0.18081329762935638,
-0.6128633618354797,
-0.20640185475349426,
-0.18473634123802185,
0.8480180501937866,
-0.4552682936191559,
0.2192230522632599,
0.5775259733200073,
-0.14927300810813904,
-0.3153770864009857,
0.3259972929954529,
0.7019444704055786,
0.5591338276863098,
-0.09789185225963593,
0.1813422441482544,
0.40146052837371826,
-0.3152734041213989,
0.2837810218334198,
-0.1973823606967926,
-0.2844337522983551,
-0.47496604919433594,
0.2874210476875305,
0.7036056518554688,
0.2377258986234665,
-0.4026176333427429,
0.3396323025226593,
0.0034318706020712852,
0.18767771124839783,
-0.060133934020996094,
0.36391618847846985,
-0.12291988730430603,
0.24691306054592133,
0.5520536303520203,
0.1276463121175766,
0.13136841356754303,
-0.48271650075912476,
0.30308082699775696,
0.605891764163971,
-0.3521654009819031,
-0.20184394717216492,
0.6903944611549377,
0.14994168281555176,
-0.17062921822071075,
0.41702914237976074,
-0.23681515455245972,
-0.5561113357543945,
0.5126414895057678,
0.7127605676651001,
0.7607216238975525,
-0.5849229097366333,
0.12312675267457962,
0.43555763363838196,
0.5580298900604248,
-0.2137499749660492,
0.020291082561016083,
0.024676760658621788,
-0.9619775414466858,
-0.7071554064750671,
-0.4962860345840454,
-0.477255642414093,
-0.25537413358688354,
-0.6935533881187439,
0.03569436073303223,
-0.5039888620376587,
-0.3544970154762268,
-0.34027281403541565,
-0.20835071802139282,
-0.3628363013267517,
0.38899457454681396,
0.0015341260004788637,
0.6250631213188171,
-0.51627516746521,
0.6577088236808777,
0.6338649392127991,
-0.18298950791358948,
-0.9787907004356384,
0.06344688683748245,
0.18341736495494843,
-1.0843690633773804,
0.688007116317749,
0.060760997235774994,
-0.4250200390815735,
-0.06435352563858032,
-0.6507733464241028,
-1.103609561920166,
0.8336377143859863,
0.46489107608795166,
-0.8632972240447998,
-0.06564650684595108,
-0.06575660407543182,
0.6921310424804688,
-0.3168694078922272,
0.11425869911909103,
0.4051288664340973,
0.22864635288715363,
0.37122291326522827,
-0.9484421610832214,
-0.014117906801402569,
0.06054205074906349,
0.16876494884490967,
0.05967438966035843,
-0.6431686878204346,
0.657986581325531,
-0.6910218596458435,
-0.03270076960325241,
-0.13348157703876495,
0.8602817058563232,
-0.049118634313344955,
-0.011859532445669174,
0.4332500696182251,
0.7848077416419983,
0.7914789915084839,
-0.10302276909351349,
0.9948412775993347,
-0.5519915819168091,
0.3613755404949188,
1.2878239154815674,
-0.19567985832691193,
0.7662355303764343,
0.44331973791122437,
-0.14271706342697144,
0.36712220311164856,
0.5293331146240234,
0.07785709947347641,
0.3888341784477234,
-0.140815868973732,
-0.08386078476905823,
-0.4170563220977783,
-0.11945874243974686,
-0.31966397166252136,
0.5110070109367371,
0.6084867715835571,
-0.27744898200035095,
-0.06277692317962646,
-0.0682126134634018,
-0.06104636937379837,
0.05426030978560448,
-0.39242199063301086,
0.7828216552734375,
0.19845078885555267,
-0.6479879021644592,
0.40298935770988464,
-0.1468612104654312,
0.6929613947868347,
-0.3791920244693756,
0.06224142014980316,
0.01699828915297985,
0.3365313708782196,
-0.22391250729560852,
-0.9553762078285217,
0.5175057649612427,
-0.16976626217365265,
-0.2440841794013977,
-0.13254058361053467,
0.8757278919219971,
-0.3042934536933899,
-0.39633822441101074,
0.22559282183647156,
0.5693663954734802,
-0.076673723757267,
-0.13872596621513367,
-0.8407498598098755,
-0.011117479763925076,
0.04145657271146774,
-0.012845770455896854,
0.03817593306303024,
0.6172699928283691,
0.16703279316425323,
0.9807117581367493,
0.46190622448921204,
0.3526817858219147,
0.022803109139204025,
-0.05947555974125862,
0.5824750065803528,
-0.6358925700187683,
-0.2892068326473236,
-0.8938424587249756,
0.5686335563659668,
0.19374318420886993,
-0.3078436255455017,
0.9270007014274597,
0.27947571873664856,
0.8376230001449585,
0.05446171015501022,
0.8267325758934021,
0.01205718144774437,
0.5745335221290588,
-0.7346956133842468,
0.22688403725624084,
-0.6546626687049866,
0.6233006119728088,
-0.1578691452741623,
-0.7988592386245728,
-0.1245487630367279,
0.8127875924110413,
-0.5833652019500732,
0.24049167335033417,
0.6542234420776367,
0.8137684464454651,
0.3050927519798279,
-0.32477182149887085,
0.4490741491317749,
0.4123905599117279,
0.22941023111343384,
0.12449927628040314,
0.7484250068664551,
-0.24741210043430328,
0.19711756706237793,
-0.37683695554733276,
-0.32184508442878723,
-0.23879274725914001,
-1.0088087320327759,
-0.9376059770584106,
-0.46881482005119324,
-0.4201224446296692,
-0.4756026864051819,
0.19559960067272186,
0.7419870495796204,
0.7047725915908813,
-0.6502410173416138,
-0.06562468409538269,
0.05313703045248985,
0.24049989879131317,
-0.07683756202459335,
-0.10235444456338882,
0.1435701549053192,
-0.8496338725090027,
-0.6509174704551697,
0.11935307085514069,
0.6491381525993347,
0.4088326394557953,
-0.47892874479293823,
0.005452001467347145,
-0.01723041757941246,
0.0924583151936531,
0.48554450273513794,
0.263468861579895,
-0.8685246706008911,
-0.33413824439048767,
0.20411261916160583,
-0.4737553298473358,
0.09256350994110107,
0.7411350011825562,
-0.5073364973068237,
0.691758394241333,
0.09146265685558319,
0.7311695218086243,
0.19408957660198212,
0.02344389818608761,
0.6748737692832947,
-0.5780755877494812,
-0.086842380464077,
0.07918073982000351,
0.3308393955230713,
0.5432939529418945,
-0.6262219548225403,
0.7036266922950745,
0.42511236667633057,
-0.808163046836853,
-0.5266813039779663,
0.16411465406417847,
-0.7750700116157532,
-0.21598851680755615,
1.2980393171310425,
-0.09092311561107635,
-0.37626203894615173,
-0.05195365846157074,
-0.3726402521133423,
0.26489484310150146,
-0.27377891540527344,
1.035190463066101,
0.7153699398040771,
-0.14463406801223755,
-0.27813759446144104,
-0.27089738845825195,
0.2291642278432846,
0.7550121545791626,
-0.6739057302474976,
0.06757183372974396,
0.3480677306652069,
0.3258335590362549,
0.2458629161119461,
0.6585908532142639,
0.07785684615373611,
0.014434067532420158,
-0.17822489142417908,
0.1214577704668045,
0.2477351427078247,
-0.3969660997390747,
-0.5933939218521118,
-0.2408987432718277,
0.29987823963165283,
0.17682860791683197
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.02377v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.02377v1
|
XRec: Large Language Models for Explainable Recommendation
| 2024-06-04T14:55:14 | 2024-06-04T14:55:14 |
Qiyao Ma, Xubin Ren, Chao Huang
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Recommender systems help users navigate information overload by providing
personalized recommendations aligned with their preferences. Collaborative
Filtering (CF) is a widely adopted approach, but while advanced techniques like
graph neural networks (GNNs) and self-supervised learning (SSL) have enhanced
CF models for better user representations, they often lack the ability to
provide explanations for the recommended items. Explainable recommendations aim
to address this gap by offering transparency and insights into the
recommendation decision-making process, enhancing users' understanding. This
work leverages the language capabilities of Large Language Models (LLMs) to
push the boundaries of explainable recommender systems. We introduce a
model-agnostic framework called XRec, which enables LLMs to provide
comprehensive explanations for user behaviors in recommender systems. By
integrating collaborative signals and designing a lightweight collaborative
adaptor, the framework empowers LLMs to understand complex patterns in
user-item interactions and gain a deeper understanding of user preferences. Our
extensive experiments demonstrate the effectiveness of XRec, showcasing its
ability to generate comprehensive and meaningful explanations that outperform
baseline approaches in explainable recommender systems. We open-source our
model implementation at https://github.com/HKUDS/XRec.
|
[
-0.3840095102787018,
-0.3560307025909424,
0.8486549854278564,
0.027579257264733315,
-0.04253074899315834,
0.02733718231320381,
-0.31395548582077026,
-0.4533253312110901,
0.1654135137796402,
0.6607535481452942,
-1.0639663934707642,
-0.5456006526947021,
-0.3269517719745636,
-0.25319579243659973,
-0.5871113538742065,
1.1863311529159546,
-0.0888771265745163,
-0.09054987877607346,
-0.17693546414375305,
-0.32033297419548035,
-0.40874096751213074,
-0.40012139081954956,
-0.7685338258743286,
-0.7723575234413147,
0.7032371759414673,
0.5736061930656433,
0.845937967300415,
0.5689045190811157,
0.18371635675430298,
0.2991074323654175,
0.016498418524861336,
0.13355952501296997,
-0.7000821232795715,
0.15318800508975983,
-0.4820916950702667,
-0.41365236043930054,
-0.38552048802375793,
-0.3648144602775574,
0.29858389496803284,
0.8004236221313477,
-0.4256353974342346,
-0.044662170112133026,
-0.0188691858202219,
0.764595627784729,
-0.4469600319862366,
0.31682640314102173,
-0.3866198658943176,
-0.17573174834251404,
0.17892391979694366,
0.014276929199695587,
-0.3329823315143585,
-0.16801640391349792,
0.4095187187194824,
-0.7342491149902344,
0.27922430634498596,
0.5086724162101746,
0.42805594205856323,
-0.21805238723754883,
-0.27632439136505127,
-0.5443339943885803,
-0.9515965580940247,
0.7817004323005676,
-0.37525829672813416,
0.7066541910171509,
0.5305794477462769,
0.57490074634552,
-0.24892885982990265,
-0.8781610727310181,
-0.4341380298137665,
-0.3389802873134613,
-0.27286267280578613,
0.036298155784606934,
-0.44002848863601685,
-0.0036910581402480602,
-0.06648162007331848,
0.595575213432312,
-0.8320334553718567,
0.0819481611251831,
0.13491617143154144,
0.11855665594339371,
0.4355270266532898,
0.2583637237548828,
0.31830987334251404,
-0.012257790192961693,
-0.33624643087387085,
0.12843738496303558,
-0.4206695556640625,
0.13678742945194244,
0.1766899824142456,
0.24009640514850616,
-0.254824161529541,
0.3423768877983093,
-0.18474958837032318,
0.6654933094978333,
0.15047185122966766,
0.30828920006752014,
-0.24001429975032806,
-0.49990200996398926,
-0.10946454107761383,
0.19663670659065247,
0.7545768022537231,
0.35630160570144653,
0.3134624660015106,
-0.24660733342170715,
-0.0966782346367836,
-0.17437240481376648,
0.05505257099866867,
-0.6763589978218079,
-0.3487253487110138,
0.1609882414340973,
-0.7496174573898315,
-0.3253195285797119,
0.05296792834997177,
-0.43569743633270264,
-0.6621154546737671,
-0.27102428674697876,
0.3041525185108185,
-0.1718493103981018,
-0.22361209988594055,
0.41645702719688416,
0.04393849894404411,
-0.3014101982116699,
0.24706803262233734,
-1.1134388446807861,
0.6948957443237305,
0.4905844032764435,
0.7868926525115967,
-0.04618559405207634,
-0.13145007193088531,
-0.36701157689094543,
0.164835125207901,
0.0023426946718245745,
0.7774575352668762,
-0.5500134229660034,
-0.4797561466693878,
-0.06593829393386841,
0.19497519731521606,
0.26967692375183105,
-0.18780721724033356,
0.3843783438205719,
-0.6308633089065552,
0.26812198758125305,
-0.29532235860824585,
-0.5801310539245605,
-0.7049651145935059,
0.09002315253019333,
-0.6867777109146118,
0.45634719729423523,
0.3293689787387848,
-0.4761442244052887,
0.41832104325294495,
-0.7658534646034241,
-0.21480633318424225,
0.15806499123573303,
0.05727070942521095,
-0.04299650341272354,
0.022157495841383934,
0.3111139237880707,
0.5616225004196167,
-0.6480470299720764,
0.39328280091285706,
-0.6776504516601562,
-0.3080347776412964,
0.3823547065258026,
-0.36211761832237244,
0.6466845273971558,
0.32935720682144165,
-0.10798677057027817,
0.734535276889801,
-0.57444167137146,
-0.04083875194191933,
0.1986859291791916,
0.06644191592931747,
-0.3748799264431,
0.07702922821044922,
0.20698215067386627,
0.183250293135643,
0.17083041369915009,
-0.2831185758113861,
-0.09305419772863388,
-0.3508381247520447,
0.7284764647483826,
0.6755973696708679,
-0.23955753445625305,
0.5512917637825012,
-0.4083833396434784,
0.5918519496917725,
-0.45643600821495056,
0.09068144112825394,
-0.629241406917572,
-0.2519175112247467,
-0.491742342710495,
-0.2769688367843628,
-0.00880961399525404,
0.17773133516311646,
-0.3181503415107727,
0.47110146284103394,
-0.1981567144393921,
-0.36894652247428894,
-0.18903233110904694,
0.42844516038894653,
0.2651461958885193,
0.35810524225234985,
0.18663617968559265,
-0.14825063943862915,
-0.805810272693634,
-0.7842523455619812,
-0.15354527533054352,
-0.4288831055164337,
-0.07459050416946411,
0.6376760005950928,
0.20352782309055328,
-0.4257718026638031,
0.8078134655952454,
-0.5824118852615356,
-0.23356349766254425,
-0.5972970128059387,
-0.1949431300163269,
0.2831287980079651,
-0.07480008900165558,
0.34978485107421875,
-0.7701066136360168,
-0.2759438157081604,
0.24835205078125,
-0.6401558518409729,
-0.2166564166545868,
-0.23472459614276886,
-0.04226742684841156,
-0.1980748325586319,
0.36014628410339355,
0.03064689226448536,
0.1444912701845169,
0.8202212452888489,
-0.5237133502960205,
0.5074810981750488,
-0.6841702461242676,
0.052545174956321716,
-0.8660385608673096,
-0.044316574931144714,
0.34697502851486206,
-0.703092098236084,
-0.2819743752479553,
-0.04435364529490471,
-0.18792708218097687,
-0.11223608255386353,
0.03367915749549866,
0.7530429363250732,
-0.325591117143631,
0.09074116498231888,
-0.4793565273284912,
0.40306317806243896,
0.35514914989471436,
0.26295706629753113,
0.07389672845602036,
0.2597964406013489,
0.3748326003551483,
-0.34769970178604126,
0.3419303297996521,
0.30510661005973816,
-0.5025404095649719,
0.34839969873428345,
-0.6915091872215271,
-0.19453680515289307,
0.16934973001480103,
0.52846759557724,
-1.094702959060669,
-0.12539173662662506,
0.28171658515930176,
-0.01651654951274395,
-0.14450687170028687,
-0.3548014163970947,
-0.23197588324546814,
-0.3584580719470978,
-0.07550555467605591,
0.2680458426475525,
0.3521551489830017,
-1.0062915086746216,
0.781450092792511,
0.16635985672473907,
-0.031978655606508255,
-0.28297102451324463,
-0.39904341101646423,
0.05314679071307182,
-0.06676196306943893,
-0.8198289275169373,
0.4166543781757355,
-0.5114050507545471,
-0.3209001123905182,
0.06994109600782394,
-0.05767050012946129,
-0.09499411284923553,
0.09389488399028778,
0.8145496845245361,
0.37074142694473267,
-0.22967836260795593,
0.056700415909290314,
-0.17227676510810852,
-0.31199321150779724,
0.09047690778970718,
-0.5856022238731384,
0.5499246120452881,
-0.2852151691913605,
-0.28039008378982544,
-0.506305456161499,
0.36629971861839294,
0.6943578124046326,
-0.004964593797922134,
0.5979598164558411,
0.6589743494987488,
-0.0028475436847656965,
-0.25574615597724915,
-0.5104668140411377,
-0.27258768677711487,
-0.5047647953033447,
0.4199303388595581,
-0.33483272790908813,
-1.1998547315597534,
0.6968275308609009,
0.056685883551836014,
-0.2524867653846741,
-0.0033777731005102396,
0.7088859677314758,
0.12908044457435608,
1.4402482509613037,
0.9065175652503967,
-0.06142106652259827,
0.638737678527832,
-0.21155394613742828,
0.3352319896221161,
-0.5900129079818726,
-0.3290248513221741,
-0.3213077187538147,
-0.06288733333349228,
-0.4073004126548767,
-0.08376281708478928,
-0.15599624812602997,
0.004424644634127617,
-0.03751851245760918,
0.25957992672920227,
-0.370034784078598,
0.34004002809524536,
0.4747489392757416,
0.13991014659404755,
0.41804420948028564,
0.04424367845058441,
-0.09136192500591278,
0.1976328194141388,
-0.7108567357063293,
-0.3247305452823639,
0.5844328999519348,
0.38740912079811096,
1.1350560188293457,
-0.03351400047540665,
0.2252887785434723,
0.4082756042480469,
0.007779806852340698,
-0.96385258436203,
0.34958744049072266,
-0.45285671949386597,
-0.6751402616500854,
-0.1396554857492447,
-0.23604294657707214,
-0.8123607635498047,
0.07589571177959442,
-0.4064454436302185,
-0.898371160030365,
0.2988530099391937,
0.21878431737422943,
-0.40260419249534607,
0.4141588509082794,
-0.5682274103164673,
0.7625752687454224,
-0.5237753987312317,
-0.3941745162010193,
-0.7095720767974854,
-0.2448304146528244,
0.322719931602478,
-0.32848992943763733,
0.3170362114906311,
-0.00801991205662489,
0.16014879941940308,
0.6688314080238342,
-0.46191084384918213,
0.7154550552368164,
0.04843062907457352,
-0.04418531432747841,
0.12470921874046326,
0.38481709361076355,
0.6253160834312439,
0.130257710814476,
-0.41692906618118286,
0.2283121943473816,
0.015362739562988281,
-0.05498548224568367,
-0.990817666053772,
1.2717607021331787,
-0.5821996927261353,
-0.5588402152061462,
0.10923370718955994,
-0.7755973935127258,
0.11103331297636032,
0.26701489090919495,
-0.1053294762969017,
0.4777287542819977,
-0.22921033203601837,
0.22801968455314636,
0.4208565950393677,
-0.06776438653469086,
0.036067403852939606,
0.8002955913543701,
-0.711337685585022,
-0.43312421441078186,
0.8946653604507446,
0.12180927395820618,
-0.0966021865606308,
0.43250539898872375,
0.5043257474899292,
-0.48837780952453613,
-0.6888404488563538,
-0.3475600481033325,
0.21128441393375397,
-0.7784436941146851,
0.36325767636299133,
-0.7090619206428528,
0.20560728013515472,
-0.20169639587402344,
-0.5982595682144165,
0.10440527647733688,
-0.48539838194847107,
-0.18682289123535156,
-0.12202875316143036,
0.4329875409603119,
1.031402587890625,
-0.032822150737047195,
0.6835170984268188,
-0.5883275270462036,
0.4893985390663147,
0.2783571779727936,
0.6778337359428406,
0.3030878007411957,
-0.6524878740310669,
-0.5432811975479126,
-0.07041776180267334,
0.1821216195821762,
-0.4464665353298187,
0.3169293999671936,
-0.027488576248288155,
0.6204988360404968,
0.9418428540229797,
0.1456555724143982,
0.5767887830734253,
-0.2577114403247833,
0.5800537467002869,
0.3907357156276703,
-1.0139212608337402,
0.39115142822265625,
-0.3654875159263611,
0.3071829378604889,
0.3808368146419525,
0.4486682713031769,
-0.6930875778198242,
0.09816120564937592,
-0.4508969485759735,
-0.989399254322052,
0.7974363565444946,
0.03499959409236908,
-0.04268292710185051,
0.1694379448890686,
0.6456121206283569,
0.521990954875946,
-0.07584939152002335,
-0.5416227579116821,
-0.3295876681804657,
-0.1954679787158966,
-0.20868071913719177,
-0.41556838154792786,
-0.5763083696365356,
-0.009836600162088871,
0.1683225780725479,
0.8041726350784302,
-0.06550399214029312,
-0.19846436381340027,
-0.05380091443657875,
-0.10220829397439957,
-0.3087391257286072,
0.2120141237974167,
0.43989840149879456,
0.7948682904243469,
-0.3804472088813782,
0.002337092300876975,
0.08441038429737091,
-0.039940331131219864,
0.10316202789545059,
0.10486718267202377,
0.17184719443321228,
-0.3529027998447418,
0.37348562479019165,
0.9002060890197754,
0.3380064368247986,
-0.6376230716705322,
0.323078989982605,
-0.4928448498249054,
-0.11995798349380493,
-0.4380638301372528,
0.29213616251945496,
0.1943851262331009,
0.17567658424377441,
0.046974871307611465,
0.07807493209838867,
0.30947065353393555,
-0.4749353229999542,
0.07906293869018555,
0.43518877029418945,
-1.065638542175293,
-0.45467013120651245,
0.596520185470581,
0.19176004827022552,
-0.20226001739501953,
0.4014202654361725,
0.2856587767601013,
-0.16578885912895203,
0.17849013209342957,
0.6960475444793701,
0.9362942576408386,
0.08779684454202652,
0.32059386372566223,
0.05845744162797928,
0.062027156352996826,
-0.24085864424705505,
-0.07748730480670929,
-0.4896770417690277,
-0.7430672645568848,
-0.5608695149421692,
-0.26033663749694824,
-0.5431249141693115,
-0.011118240654468536,
-0.7945417761802673,
0.3016302287578583,
-0.5339391231536865,
0.04448193311691284,
0.4631040394306183,
-0.18049204349517822,
-0.496380090713501,
0.13922123610973358,
0.1655678004026413,
0.9418738484382629,
-0.8760626912117004,
0.6526705026626587,
0.6818593144416809,
-0.38736405968666077,
-0.8803732991218567,
-0.4545400142669678,
0.1479918211698532,
-1.005038857460022,
0.5279665589332581,
-0.07223102450370789,
-0.6113451719284058,
-0.13497619330883026,
-0.36459076404571533,
-0.5550230741500854,
0.916786253452301,
0.43660032749176025,
-0.7720482349395752,
0.16405335068702698,
-0.22138653695583344,
0.5890187621116638,
-0.6567509770393372,
0.5979629755020142,
0.35616880655288696,
0.7321601510047913,
0.20006786286830902,
-0.4932696521282196,
0.2995088994503021,
-0.1682182401418686,
-0.14207369089126587,
0.0755249559879303,
-0.3406985104084015,
0.27726736664772034,
-0.5462517738342285,
0.16707278788089752,
0.3367917239665985,
0.36559849977493286,
0.14270421862602234,
0.4928540587425232,
0.7990778684616089,
0.2169215977191925,
0.7512465119361877,
0.16279037296772003,
1.3026336431503296,
-0.200519859790802,
0.020150719210505486,
1.443795084953308,
-0.42414143681526184,
0.4298267960548401,
0.25221341848373413,
0.062014561146497726,
1.1765718460083008,
0.507171094417572,
-0.1496466100215912,
0.24371279776096344,
0.15289486944675446,
-0.2984505593776703,
-0.7013413310050964,
-0.43188026547431946,
0.03166057541966438,
0.3147468864917755,
0.31745678186416626,
-0.7489397525787354,
-0.20959119498729706,
0.24011942744255066,
-0.17887070775032043,
0.09877900779247284,
-0.34128910303115845,
0.855415403842926,
0.2770915627479553,
-0.3659510910511017,
0.47701889276504517,
-0.12472305446863174,
0.3377174139022827,
-0.9369643330574036,
-0.13108012080192566,
0.10458920150995255,
0.4583687484264374,
-0.46235835552215576,
-0.9712035059928894,
-0.1416996419429779,
-0.24655021727085114,
-1.0682412385940552,
-0.31569504737854004,
0.8275569081306458,
-0.22650422155857086,
-0.40515589714050293,
0.9164312481880188,
0.39898553490638733,
0.15637189149856567,
-0.18107707798480988,
-0.8591869473457336,
-0.04376276209950447,
0.3778245151042938,
-0.09703606367111206,
0.3441753387451172,
0.30385977029800415,
-0.48232224583625793,
1.4466897249221802,
0.8845568299293518,
0.08400976657867432,
-0.5346556305885315,
0.4178013503551483,
0.6482717990875244,
-0.5879519581794739,
-0.6827365159988403,
-0.7312115430831909,
0.3728727102279663,
0.26064419746398926,
0.23571814596652985,
0.7918832302093506,
0.23269625008106232,
0.5200432538986206,
0.06852857023477554,
0.8308029174804688,
0.1587449312210083,
0.2865453362464905,
-0.2102096825838089,
0.7758037447929382,
-0.5943942666053772,
0.7442248463630676,
-0.044751718640327454,
-0.7989778518676758,
-0.4225415885448456,
0.3424082398414612,
-0.40524575114250183,
0.3645067512989044,
0.5649205446243286,
0.8636053800582886,
-0.21975713968276978,
0.22713106870651245,
0.5329051613807678,
0.40374383330345154,
0.37752488255500793,
0.11493277549743652,
0.8508739471435547,
-0.014274613000452518,
1.0525288581848145,
-0.24948091804981232,
-0.21681663393974304,
-0.4503139555454254,
-0.8811929821968079,
-0.916340708732605,
-0.53519606590271,
-0.35844433307647705,
-0.5513426065444946,
0.22352248430252075,
1.0411863327026367,
1.2276474237442017,
-0.9421980977058411,
-0.5282315015792847,
-0.1202922910451889,
0.4558960795402527,
-0.36056673526763916,
-0.1893434226512909,
0.329060822725296,
0.13582125306129456,
-0.3488686680793762,
0.6462580561637878,
0.18463298678398132,
-0.10042507201433182,
-0.5313687324523926,
-0.39262858033180237,
0.2236950546503067,
-0.02571760304272175,
0.46052470803260803,
0.2775147259235382,
-0.8407495617866516,
-0.12493107467889786,
-0.07287321984767914,
0.38304784893989563,
-0.14003340899944305,
1.1553467512130737,
-0.9441749453544617,
0.8146207928657532,
0.6245490908622742,
0.023380471393465996,
0.5090199708938599,
-0.1416192501783371,
1.028437614440918,
-0.12466783076524734,
-0.2576010227203369,
-0.3322950005531311,
0.6322062611579895,
0.3482212424278259,
-0.4604159891605377,
0.306410551071167,
-0.3614276349544525,
-0.7562874555587769,
-0.645530641078949,
0.14818905293941498,
-1.2078408002853394,
-0.4618261456489563,
0.8838762044906616,
-0.36607658863067627,
-0.17833799123764038,
-0.4224937856197357,
-0.42899203300476074,
0.044683102518320084,
-0.6992213129997253,
0.5821014642715454,
0.47188815474510193,
-0.10055304318666458,
-0.1996583491563797,
-0.22066670656204224,
0.02291514165699482,
0.23520556092262268,
-0.3002892732620239,
0.5906388163566589,
0.35329940915107727,
0.4443497657775879,
-0.061129096895456314,
0.3454802334308624,
0.03912539780139923,
0.20634210109710693,
-0.4156213104724884,
0.24077098071575165,
-0.39340683817863464,
-0.09881122410297394,
-0.672366738319397,
0.2084331065416336,
0.38130176067352295,
0.3096131980419159
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.02376v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.02376v2
|
Retaining Key Information under High Compression Ratios: Query-Guided Compressor for LLMs
| 2024-06-04T14:53:24 | 2024-06-17T15:02:11 |
Zhiwei Cao, Qian Cao, Yu Lu, Ningxin Peng, Luyang Huang, Shanbo Cheng, Jinsong Su
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The growing popularity of Large Language Models has sparked interest in
context compression for Large Language Models (LLMs). However, the performance
of previous methods degrades dramatically as compression ratios increase,
sometimes even falling to the closed-book level. This decline can be attributed
to the loss of key information during the compression process. Our preliminary
study supports this hypothesis, emphasizing the significance of retaining key
information to maintain model performance under high compression ratios. As a
result, we introduce Query-Guided Compressor (QGC), which leverages queries to
guide the context compression process, effectively preserving key information
within the compressed context. Additionally, we employ a dynamic compression
strategy. We validate the effectiveness of our proposed QGC on the Question
Answering task, including NaturalQuestions, TriviaQA, and HotpotQA datasets.
Experimental results show that QGC can consistently perform well even at high
compression ratios, which also offers significant benefits in terms of
inference cost and throughput.
|
[
-0.39013931155204773,
-0.6752328872680664,
0.6263148188591003,
0.013227746821939945,
-0.27525150775909424,
0.14005112648010254,
-0.3213645815849304,
0.006934032309800386,
-0.037593256682157516,
0.48707297444343567,
-0.6563621163368225,
-0.46064668893814087,
-0.4176732003688812,
0.06323020905256271,
-0.5844799876213074,
0.5489839911460876,
0.18327893316745758,
-0.048033323138952255,
-0.5860305428504944,
0.15657566487789154,
-0.6440379023551941,
-0.8620102405548096,
-0.7856922149658203,
0.10264918953180313,
0.42767763137817383,
0.2992798089981079,
0.7952951788902283,
0.7554274201393127,
0.37235116958618164,
0.19543181359767914,
-0.5699926614761353,
0.2839142978191376,
-0.7041317820549011,
0.6790164113044739,
0.19625402987003326,
-0.6118538975715637,
-0.13175712525844574,
-0.30902761220932007,
0.951779305934906,
0.6132671236991882,
-0.5629885792732239,
0.1432776004076004,
0.15286244451999664,
0.6928355693817139,
-0.678085207939148,
0.16481129825115204,
-0.6147283315658569,
-0.017467141151428223,
-0.11914903670549393,
-0.5482795834541321,
-0.47333717346191406,
-0.3925217092037201,
-0.22390376031398773,
-0.567058265209198,
0.17141278088092804,
0.24957668781280518,
0.6604427099227905,
0.816520631313324,
-0.4612235128879547,
-0.09085278958082199,
-0.6259719133377075,
0.6249226331710815,
-0.6291231513023376,
0.5302149653434753,
0.39511945843696594,
0.20832042396068573,
-0.31937405467033386,
-0.6410072445869446,
-0.5179301500320435,
0.23290374875068665,
0.04433269798755646,
0.00619484344497323,
-0.06033942475914955,
0.17760974168777466,
0.4998447597026825,
0.5537943840026855,
-0.5171722769737244,
-0.10292837768793106,
-0.20318038761615753,
-0.37275010347366333,
0.3466610908508301,
0.14576809108257294,
0.23024272918701172,
-0.1973201185464859,
-0.2410770058631897,
-0.20926512777805328,
-1.1160002946853638,
0.09196720272302628,
0.27735474705696106,
0.2351355254650116,
0.28419023752212524,
0.3460973799228668,
-0.37907564640045166,
0.9634022116661072,
0.008700169622898102,
-0.31622087955474854,
-0.052466753870248795,
-0.3784623146057129,
-0.19561636447906494,
-0.09740908443927765,
0.40080299973487854,
0.3174104690551758,
0.08477631956338882,
-0.3498837947845459,
-0.05573051795363426,
-0.26909029483795166,
0.16990548372268677,
-1.0184353590011597,
-0.07908298075199127,
0.11996041238307953,
-0.2802513837814331,
-0.09616316109895706,
0.04538055509328842,
-0.5720987319946289,
-0.3364609181880951,
-0.19678476452827454,
0.18887506425380707,
-0.02495863102376461,
0.016376759856939316,
0.23206713795661926,
-0.2457222044467926,
0.25370705127716064,
0.4175876975059509,
-0.6522006392478943,
0.09222331643104553,
0.6375263929367065,
0.9170089960098267,
-0.10105997323989868,
0.24336941540241241,
-0.9466965794563293,
0.2640033960342407,
-0.16662727296352386,
0.6857171654701233,
-0.6779187917709351,
-0.4626642167568207,
0.2337569296360016,
0.0718257874250412,
0.11412829905748367,
-0.701326847076416,
0.9369170665740967,
-0.9264401793479919,
0.17971988022327423,
-0.5977088809013367,
-0.6427254676818848,
0.130605086684227,
0.41175588965415955,
-0.7345636487007141,
1.0912851095199585,
0.029744058847427368,
-0.47073397040367126,
0.012559764087200165,
0.06120145320892334,
-0.28038665652275085,
0.12229023873806,
-0.15184751152992249,
-0.0904558002948761,
0.3003385663032532,
0.49065202474594116,
0.31504079699516296,
-0.6275290250778198,
0.11238335072994232,
-0.13028782606124878,
-0.5224303603172302,
0.12533824145793915,
-0.48810383677482605,
0.5364986658096313,
0.18875433504581451,
0.22322125732898712,
-0.12938115000724792,
-0.4575422406196594,
0.135443776845932,
-0.05439186096191406,
-0.8592660427093506,
-0.25720882415771484,
0.14461208879947662,
-0.41931867599487305,
0.23927156627178192,
0.07467502355575562,
-0.4781676232814789,
0.6697012782096863,
-0.2603323757648468,
0.5900550484657288,
0.5239899158477783,
0.40426957607269287,
0.33669334650039673,
-0.20546512305736542,
0.8617093563079834,
-0.20239406824111938,
0.10657362639904022,
-0.042477142065763474,
-0.28608787059783936,
-0.7197955250740051,
-0.07093159109354019,
0.489616334438324,
0.43417736887931824,
-1.0177949666976929,
0.30962055921554565,
-0.426813006401062,
-0.2799873948097229,
-0.4538145959377289,
-0.04027389734983444,
0.08192235231399536,
0.6723896265029907,
0.198583722114563,
-0.057376109063625336,
-0.2738092839717865,
-0.7168337106704712,
-0.30312708020210266,
-0.24503688514232635,
-0.327173113822937,
0.500026524066925,
-0.24443860352039337,
0.10220656543970108,
0.7521408796310425,
-0.7904137372970581,
-0.06469117850065231,
-0.019007496535778046,
0.12976953387260437,
0.27051466703414917,
0.36714667081832886,
0.32585251331329346,
-0.8618480563163757,
-0.1978837251663208,
-0.6893913745880127,
-0.2534365653991699,
-0.49399200081825256,
-0.006514751352369785,
-0.3778468668460846,
-0.04511748254299164,
0.7712135910987854,
-0.769690990447998,
0.28476396203041077,
0.7656875848770142,
-0.13024309277534485,
0.35017502307891846,
0.1382247805595398,
0.2668013870716095,
-1.105408787727356,
-0.11829215288162231,
-0.3110823929309845,
-0.3652065396308899,
-0.4766222834587097,
0.04504336789250374,
0.18793794512748718,
-0.23386025428771973,
-0.4229978919029236,
0.42794594168663025,
-0.6063218712806702,
0.07119956612586975,
-0.24939344823360443,
0.08238416165113449,
0.2074962854385376,
0.5747504234313965,
0.07174830883741379,
1.197827696800232,
0.3995409309864044,
-0.712349534034729,
0.3717954754829407,
0.36109459400177,
-0.5340514183044434,
0.1737893521785736,
-0.6216713786125183,
0.46851256489753723,
-0.34340208768844604,
0.3842524588108063,
-0.993486762046814,
-0.13662080466747284,
-0.09201325476169586,
-0.36683276295661926,
0.4830036759376526,
-0.4428098499774933,
-0.8367667198181152,
-0.26954928040504456,
-0.26949793100357056,
0.5197882652282715,
0.6586331129074097,
-0.5514394044876099,
0.3634113669395447,
0.4293624460697174,
-0.28878313302993774,
-0.5265961289405823,
-0.697380542755127,
0.08382957428693771,
-0.2441863864660263,
-0.5866297483444214,
0.6041404008865356,
-0.371788889169693,
0.1626834124326706,
-0.05451711639761925,
-0.4672884941101074,
-0.046991731971502304,
0.12680871784687042,
0.19188325107097626,
0.18974536657333374,
-0.00849925447255373,
0.6179146766662598,
-0.0022239750251173973,
0.25305309891700745,
0.11410313099622726,
-0.42145034670829773,
0.7924872636795044,
0.028608478605747223,
-0.1179051473736763,
-0.13963311910629272,
0.30355942249298096,
0.4382491409778595,
-0.1672331541776657,
0.923907995223999,
0.1877240091562271,
-0.38105952739715576,
-0.06027260050177574,
-0.5468254089355469,
-0.14148633182048798,
-0.487566739320755,
0.17235220968723297,
-0.2588001489639282,
-1.2025693655014038,
0.44010618329048157,
-0.2948708236217499,
-0.15687261521816254,
0.31666046380996704,
0.562632143497467,
0.014686079695820808,
1.0033122301101685,
0.5392791032791138,
-0.1636330932378769,
0.5929049849510193,
-0.12801609933376312,
0.30961236357688904,
-0.8518940210342407,
-0.16177445650100708,
-0.6483758091926575,
-0.29564574360847473,
-0.4278608560562134,
-0.5297914147377014,
0.7187017202377319,
0.45717376470565796,
-0.1069178357720375,
0.047510527074337006,
-0.5592479705810547,
0.627336323261261,
0.5259604454040527,
0.04122849926352501,
0.2923854887485504,
0.05403679236769676,
0.12250542640686035,
0.2118363380432129,
-1.0582263469696045,
-0.3828192353248596,
0.7449233531951904,
0.1464996188879013,
0.9902819395065308,
0.40512603521347046,
0.5267693400382996,
0.09026127308607101,
0.07412315160036087,
-0.9661035537719727,
0.5698242783546448,
0.20375755429267883,
-0.5551120042800903,
-0.35723450779914856,
-0.6147428154945374,
-0.8017386198043823,
0.05862659588456154,
-0.11936976760625839,
-0.5174019932746887,
0.23791509866714478,
0.277713418006897,
-0.647249698638916,
0.1399000883102417,
-0.43301886320114136,
0.552634060382843,
-0.052950020879507065,
-0.4698770046234131,
-0.012798264622688293,
-0.5990973711013794,
0.2363622486591339,
0.05230972543358803,
-0.093806691467762,
-0.0030993768014013767,
-0.2539482116699219,
0.742021381855011,
-0.5589017271995544,
0.4717126488685608,
-0.14667916297912598,
-0.04382126033306122,
0.28613561391830444,
0.08658041059970856,
0.5670254230499268,
0.279880166053772,
-0.18718430399894714,
-0.08037286251783371,
0.24938717484474182,
-0.35614272952079773,
-1.0676758289337158,
0.7258819341659546,
-0.4086178243160248,
-1.050519585609436,
-0.26240187883377075,
-0.7328033447265625,
-0.5257234573364258,
0.08611879497766495,
0.16982753574848175,
0.5391303300857544,
0.16758662462234497,
0.6621091365814209,
0.843745768070221,
-0.23448097705841064,
0.3664032518863678,
0.35690855979919434,
0.10278350114822388,
-0.3888496458530426,
0.3790503144264221,
0.010812388733029366,
0.3502295911312103,
0.4825900197029114,
0.26446306705474854,
-0.38077130913734436,
-0.6378023624420166,
-0.37419745326042175,
0.17328469455242157,
-0.6746715903282166,
-0.630355715751648,
-0.33679232001304626,
-0.2391752302646637,
-0.6227055788040161,
0.16955700516700745,
-0.08862509578466415,
-0.5720508694648743,
-0.22719207406044006,
0.1094784289598465,
0.18053792417049408,
0.29133227467536926,
0.3527606427669525,
0.43606388568878174,
-0.9891510605812073,
0.09553474187850952,
0.2560447156429291,
0.1611434519290924,
-0.016942298039793968,
-0.6010618209838867,
-0.2723621726036072,
-0.11151419579982758,
-0.1576927900314331,
-0.9678081274032593,
0.5370444655418396,
0.33902865648269653,
0.40036940574645996,
0.36461973190307617,
0.5835622549057007,
0.7610872387886047,
-0.3356357216835022,
1.0312227010726929,
-0.16344867646694183,
-0.6261852979660034,
0.3727622926235199,
-0.15478773415088654,
0.8037828803062439,
0.5575472116470337,
0.4996248781681061,
-0.8002827167510986,
-0.17873303592205048,
-0.39449435472488403,
-0.93519127368927,
0.536899745464325,
0.06875032931566238,
0.13446037471294403,
-0.09991627931594849,
0.7713878154754639,
-0.33613353967666626,
0.573971152305603,
-0.5080183744430542,
-0.08778509497642517,
0.13769574463367462,
-0.2794989049434662,
0.19236817955970764,
-0.4707450568675995,
-0.2280392050743103,
-0.285631000995636,
0.6148152947425842,
-0.2584625482559204,
0.3532695174217224,
0.29035520553588867,
-0.07634971290826797,
-0.0200573168694973,
0.35150840878486633,
0.4028303027153015,
0.3240976929664612,
-0.21806281805038452,
0.23764829337596893,
0.07224779576063156,
-0.37842583656311035,
0.04069863632321358,
0.01324949599802494,
-0.273502379655838,
-0.2875746190547943,
0.18126945197582245,
0.7859767079353333,
-0.028423063457012177,
-0.8266384601593018,
0.48997077345848083,
-0.38511863350868225,
-0.04266147315502167,
-0.12984907627105713,
0.20972475409507751,
0.10981635004281998,
0.1333874762058258,
0.42274636030197144,
-0.2903696298599243,
0.1472269892692566,
-0.6768862009048462,
-0.16934609413146973,
0.542281448841095,
-0.10256075859069824,
0.054718952625989914,
0.5004044771194458,
0.07716847211122513,
-0.0868469849228859,
0.9821378588676453,
0.02351609617471695,
-0.7776169776916504,
0.2955833673477173,
0.3452247679233551,
0.7091657519340515,
-0.09033828973770142,
-0.2957112193107605,
0.4104319214820862,
0.21335823833942413,
-0.3137207329273224,
0.31027737259864807,
-0.4791187644004822,
-0.41615504026412964,
-0.5835882425308228,
-0.6998198628425598,
-0.43546390533447266,
0.22988852858543396,
-0.663894772529602,
0.14031828939914703,
-0.20882001519203186,
-0.18072821199893951,
-0.4684041738510132,
0.01656069979071617,
-0.6075488924980164,
0.17943105101585388,
0.09702278673648834,
1.2020058631896973,
-0.3855516314506531,
0.8816160559654236,
0.2602635622024536,
-0.33571016788482666,
-1.001650333404541,
0.3263821303844452,
-0.014841937460005283,
-0.703060507774353,
0.6786848902702332,
-0.01681402325630188,
-0.13646449148654938,
0.1176459789276123,
-0.6801967620849609,
-1.4052777290344238,
1.1048177480697632,
0.5673145651817322,
-0.6680946946144104,
-0.42441606521606445,
0.026878533884882927,
0.42911890149116516,
-0.16986067593097687,
-0.10796470195055008,
0.5679316520690918,
0.4336417019367218,
0.496988445520401,
-0.757003128528595,
0.1871543973684311,
-0.1981222778558731,
-0.07182713598012924,
0.4462308883666992,
-0.6138592958450317,
0.5724464058876038,
0.1543988436460495,
-0.6421071887016296,
0.16534645855426788,
0.5641084313392639,
-0.02335629053413868,
-0.1372871994972229,
0.5154744386672974,
0.6167595386505127,
0.9252593517303467,
-0.319959819316864,
1.2537416219711304,
-0.6758108139038086,
0.22668971121311188,
0.92889404296875,
0.09300439059734344,
1.0447473526000977,
0.48404014110565186,
0.06583748757839203,
0.2717641294002533,
0.7779399752616882,
0.2427220642566681,
0.586564302444458,
0.32137420773506165,
-0.4302619993686676,
-0.37949565052986145,
-0.3323212265968323,
-0.25367456674575806,
0.13839216530323029,
0.22445450723171234,
-0.23685280978679657,
0.15866246819496155,
-0.3430851101875305,
0.02296694740653038,
-0.1828407347202301,
-0.2597317695617676,
0.6805249452590942,
0.03449525684118271,
-1.102372646331787,
0.9553060531616211,
-0.1457580029964447,
0.3956928849220276,
-0.48810678720474243,
0.1012108325958252,
-0.3401225507259369,
-0.2559826374053955,
-0.1298278272151947,
-0.6886897087097168,
0.26268017292022705,
-0.1135597825050354,
-0.30137917399406433,
-0.523914635181427,
0.7521382570266724,
-0.8574596047401428,
-0.1279771327972412,
-0.3032206594944,
0.4546051025390625,
0.19184719026088715,
-0.3359716832637787,
-0.2691589295864105,
0.2614261209964752,
-0.18126477301120758,
-0.30583685636520386,
0.2620203495025635,
0.27336251735687256,
0.0760490670800209,
0.5899454951286316,
0.5190455913543701,
0.31559863686561584,
0.11294656246900558,
0.14522404968738556,
1.1227940320968628,
-0.6948891282081604,
-0.3396627604961395,
-0.5929999351501465,
0.07208087295293808,
-0.19812726974487305,
-0.03160151466727257,
0.7614870071411133,
0.5598562359809875,
0.7131907343864441,
0.1581268012523651,
0.5948858261108398,
0.3083747625350952,
0.4396582543849945,
-0.8828654289245605,
0.44414928555488586,
-0.6674237251281738,
0.46445977687835693,
0.10035412013530731,
-0.9925497174263,
-0.31298479437828064,
0.24846117198467255,
-0.1064225509762764,
-0.13391271233558655,
0.6700513362884521,
0.9639459252357483,
0.16657070815563202,
-0.25708064436912537,
0.306629478931427,
0.03101520799100399,
0.46858730912208557,
0.7257875800132751,
0.8489985466003418,
-0.2349938154220581,
0.8975875973701477,
-0.016894305124878883,
-0.1050916314125061,
-0.14138862490653992,
-1.0803427696228027,
-0.6301015019416809,
-0.48264366388320923,
-0.39475521445274353,
-0.3418445885181427,
0.004043423105031252,
0.8216891288757324,
0.8646609783172607,
-0.3685169219970703,
-0.0050255050882697105,
-0.07168164849281311,
-0.003067298559471965,
-0.07267460972070694,
-0.21171095967292786,
0.3745138645172119,
-0.2628661096096039,
-0.8260319232940674,
0.5859866738319397,
0.25865310430526733,
-0.03688044100999832,
-0.3594037890434265,
0.0455172061920166,
-0.03790019080042839,
0.2658783495426178,
0.502507209777832,
0.27484259009361267,
-0.683552086353302,
-0.19908441603183746,
0.21354229748249054,
0.014805967919528484,
0.001148949726484716,
0.9977169632911682,
-1.10722017288208,
0.36979299783706665,
0.9071149230003357,
0.9504721760749817,
0.5424478054046631,
0.42852139472961426,
0.7272778153419495,
-1.0263959169387817,
0.025104831904172897,
0.3131433427333832,
0.4206387400627136,
0.4139370322227478,
-0.5519900321960449,
0.5514114499092102,
0.13191130757331848,
-0.8093276023864746,
-0.9049488306045532,
0.2649855613708496,
-0.9495384693145752,
-0.32774192094802856,
1.4063729047775269,
0.017281141132116318,
-0.24239054322242737,
0.2764362692832947,
-0.3067476153373718,
0.3846144378185272,
-0.468280166387558,
0.7095444798469543,
1.0566649436950684,
-0.29965779185295105,
-0.5335808396339417,
-0.4863458573818207,
0.8007981777191162,
0.49893704056739807,
-0.6148675084114075,
0.31205490231513977,
0.7931951880455017,
-0.05553881451487541,
0.03944295644760132,
0.3073679208755493,
-0.0443553626537323,
0.040973126888275146,
-0.3560541272163391,
-0.21908296644687653,
-0.09327854216098785,
-0.2348727583885193,
-0.5571758151054382,
0.5471166968345642,
0.29235291481018066,
-0.04550568014383316
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.02368v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.02368v1
|
Large Language Models Make Sample-Efficient Recommender Systems
| 2024-06-04T14:46:25 | 2024-06-04T14:46:25 |
Jianghao Lin, Xinyi Dai, Rong Shan, Bo Chen, Ruiming Tang, Yong Yu, Weinan Zhang
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) have achieved remarkable progress in the field
of natural language processing (NLP), demonstrating remarkable abilities in
producing text that resembles human language for various tasks. This opens up
new opportunities for employing them in recommender systems (RSs). In this
paper, we specifically examine the sample efficiency of LLM-enhanced
recommender systems, which pertains to the model's capacity to attain superior
performance with a limited quantity of training data. Conventional
recommendation models (CRMs) often need a large amount of training data because
of the sparsity of features and interactions. Hence, we propose and verify our
core viewpoint: Large Language Models Make Sample-Efficient Recommender
Systems. We propose a simple yet effective framework (i.e., Laser) to validate
the viewpoint from two aspects: (1) LLMs themselves are sample-efficient
recommenders; and (2) LLMs, as feature generators and encoders, make CRMs more
sample-efficient. Extensive experiments on two public datasets show that Laser
requires only a small fraction of training samples to match or even surpass
CRMs that are trained on the entire training set, demonstrating superior sample
efficiency.
|
[
-0.32343485951423645,
-0.24190747737884521,
0.5967090725898743,
-0.061311278492212296,
-0.22025291621685028,
-0.15179269015789032,
-0.4813237488269806,
-0.46651050448417664,
-0.0328948050737381,
0.6897408366203308,
-0.35690852999687195,
-0.5129607915878296,
-0.5029401779174805,
0.19789360463619232,
-0.6158033609390259,
1.003476619720459,
0.34322041273117065,
0.4226154685020447,
-0.04710829630494118,
-0.04083359241485596,
-0.0773623064160347,
-0.5611172914505005,
-0.5620821118354797,
-0.5407953262329102,
0.40319350361824036,
0.183785080909729,
0.6038564443588257,
0.7689834833145142,
0.7386743426322937,
0.26919782161712646,
-0.2504326105117798,
0.34056952595710754,
-0.6341684460639954,
0.18699517846107483,
-0.07358861714601517,
-0.4878236949443817,
-0.3102957308292389,
-0.2695983648300171,
0.6878530979156494,
0.8539818525314331,
-0.1987295150756836,
0.06251750141382217,
0.3508267402648926,
0.8192498683929443,
-0.5761160850524902,
-0.15079233050346375,
-0.8435873985290527,
-0.0749821811914444,
-0.08978153020143509,
-0.03209112584590912,
-0.5440869331359863,
-0.5636996626853943,
0.2741657495498657,
-0.5938332080841064,
0.41504180431365967,
0.2476903796195984,
0.5091004371643066,
0.06574498116970062,
-0.18179607391357422,
-0.4777240455150604,
-1.0472568273544312,
0.8260899186134338,
-0.7309309244155884,
0.6448990106582642,
0.3397027850151062,
0.497270792722702,
-0.24791012704372406,
-0.5108805894851685,
-0.39424794912338257,
-0.46307164430618286,
0.13260138034820557,
-0.24470271170139313,
-0.05122462660074234,
0.06494642794132233,
0.4386555254459381,
0.47833767533302307,
-0.3952412009239197,
0.20807421207427979,
-0.06394468992948532,
-0.02656264416873455,
0.34689441323280334,
0.19710391759872437,
0.15112654864788055,
0.05469699949026108,
-0.2478841245174408,
-0.3105979561805725,
-0.8609230518341064,
0.022017084062099457,
0.2753966152667999,
0.5606513023376465,
0.17587293684482574,
0.8428094387054443,
-0.14815445244312286,
0.8258448839187622,
-0.07167807221412659,
-0.2853538990020752,
-0.07405522465705872,
-0.6740645170211792,
-0.22185802459716797,
-0.11226406693458557,
0.6439904570579529,
0.416761189699173,
0.39355698227882385,
-0.13697119057178497,
-0.31344372034072876,
-0.059923205524683,
0.14424079656600952,
-1.104475498199463,
-0.19275671243667603,
-0.010630100965499878,
-0.3386201560497284,
-0.06758500635623932,
0.053206782788038254,
-0.3885861039161682,
-0.5820206999778748,
0.049948811531066895,
0.00999394804239273,
-0.5691919922828674,
0.03655707836151123,
0.4238000810146332,
-0.4836477041244507,
-0.07377403974533081,
0.36317721009254456,
-1.031600832939148,
0.2763737738132477,
0.7849944829940796,
0.6697057485580444,
0.002928229048848152,
-0.10924071818590164,
-0.4567544460296631,
0.14138151705265045,
-0.5341183543205261,
1.0089672803878784,
-0.6475124955177307,
-0.4959869384765625,
0.24884021282196045,
-0.27655380964279175,
0.4263972043991089,
-1.0263911485671997,
0.3967474102973938,
-0.6459500789642334,
-0.1182524561882019,
-0.4493594169616699,
-0.8480304479598999,
-0.16865962743759155,
0.05164673924446106,
-0.683626115322113,
1.0065497159957886,
0.1384783685207367,
-0.15643656253814697,
0.8480595946311951,
-0.43261948227882385,
-0.26416826248168945,
0.22665855288505554,
0.21524161100387573,
-0.14749088883399963,
0.15034396946430206,
0.22269688546657562,
0.6814669370651245,
-0.45872965455055237,
0.20204511284828186,
-0.728054940700531,
-0.5905396342277527,
0.34894439578056335,
-0.31369075179100037,
0.3085767924785614,
0.2809358835220337,
-0.013246115297079086,
-0.08910831809043884,
-0.7475046515464783,
-0.06855736672878265,
-0.10077349096536636,
-0.751579225063324,
-0.5533385872840881,
0.06929253041744232,
0.3418167233467102,
-0.187020942568779,
0.20549270510673523,
-0.47040727734565735,
0.20614930987358093,
-0.7165676951408386,
0.3147255778312683,
0.6217833161354065,
-0.2782615125179291,
0.7603296041488647,
-0.43201351165771484,
0.21168673038482666,
-0.3356422781944275,
-0.2206098437309265,
-0.32990896701812744,
-0.007841772399842739,
-0.7862928509712219,
-0.42576372623443604,
0.2984941303730011,
0.19937582314014435,
-0.6936199069023132,
0.8380386829376221,
-0.2728729844093323,
-0.5899432897567749,
-0.3382430076599121,
0.6558880805969238,
0.3622027635574341,
-0.1319212168455124,
0.10495002567768097,
-0.20917735993862152,
-0.608525812625885,
-0.8223154544830322,
-0.2794680893421173,
0.18555258214473724,
-0.3079979717731476,
0.37778449058532715,
0.24259930849075317,
0.07441432774066925,
0.8885279893875122,
-0.3793191611766815,
-0.22918827831745148,
-0.6624730825424194,
-0.6372030377388,
0.46955353021621704,
0.2578485608100891,
0.5393822193145752,
-0.4506056010723114,
-0.4273993968963623,
-0.14645986258983612,
-0.6758255958557129,
-0.1492869257926941,
-0.05671416595578194,
0.02371363341808319,
-0.08069518953561783,
0.19636957347393036,
-0.30678707361221313,
-0.06556965410709381,
0.32119452953338623,
-0.2809423506259918,
0.2855653166770935,
-0.4468209743499756,
-0.04008408263325691,
-0.9725251793861389,
-0.11380855739116669,
0.5166662931442261,
-0.4194522798061371,
-0.5615746974945068,
-0.06717370450496674,
-0.12498867511749268,
-0.11298037320375443,
-0.2735828757286072,
0.5118535161018372,
-0.4241279065608978,
-0.25353676080703735,
-0.7307226061820984,
0.2269839197397232,
0.047613851726055145,
0.25907811522483826,
-0.06304752081632614,
0.741242527961731,
0.279653400182724,
-0.8301706910133362,
0.39257100224494934,
-0.022852255031466484,
-0.9061896800994873,
0.40818509459495544,
-0.599619448184967,
-0.03253448009490967,
0.12257474660873413,
0.4429936707019806,
-0.73697829246521,
0.0013795732520520687,
-0.07165371626615524,
0.10791008919477463,
-0.0397648960351944,
0.12600886821746826,
-0.6436111927032471,
-0.263522207736969,
-0.28366151452064514,
0.19746577739715576,
0.5763660669326782,
-0.7668118476867676,
0.4903565049171448,
0.40467172861099243,
0.06483641266822815,
-0.5808674097061157,
-0.3269103467464447,
-0.030307652428746223,
0.038612689822912216,
-0.32622209191322327,
0.15667614340782166,
-0.04495953768491745,
-0.2863849401473999,
0.054043158888816833,
0.10645144432783127,
0.05446308106184006,
0.19340106844902039,
0.21942538022994995,
0.28217074275016785,
-0.15700219571590424,
0.40079203248023987,
-0.2544633150100708,
-0.07074448466300964,
-0.19958661496639252,
-0.45095691084861755,
0.9100669622421265,
-0.027576994150877,
-0.5460138916969299,
-0.46441417932510376,
0.10270566493272781,
0.3688898980617523,
0.07815830409526825,
0.6148784756660461,
0.38362038135528564,
-0.17188246548175812,
-0.6882166266441345,
-0.7345325350761414,
-0.4122781455516815,
-0.5034925937652588,
0.7441773414611816,
-0.24205546081066132,
-1.01533842086792,
0.22203019261360168,
-0.04844510927796364,
0.23000472784042358,
0.29058700799942017,
0.5936259031295776,
-0.05317806079983711,
0.878711998462677,
0.6194905638694763,
-0.2635138928890228,
0.6673192381858826,
-0.29731592535972595,
0.20278114080429077,
-0.8106216788291931,
-0.03041076473891735,
-0.7517471313476562,
-0.1513909250497818,
-0.3434477150440216,
-0.4893498718738556,
0.2597702741622925,
0.2040334939956665,
-0.19512811303138733,
0.30596035718917847,
-0.48696133494377136,
0.5885230302810669,
0.6407075524330139,
0.19969645142555237,
0.3919411897659302,
-0.007223227992653847,
0.05291982740163803,
-0.007422029972076416,
-0.8043981194496155,
-0.6914165616035461,
1.093690276145935,
0.25393903255462646,
0.8038376569747925,
-0.043054163455963135,
0.35992440581321716,
0.1390734165906906,
0.2528113126754761,
-0.9233074188232422,
0.7610743641853333,
-0.6554524898529053,
-0.6392374634742737,
-0.3222799003124237,
-0.18172158300876617,
-0.7119481563568115,
0.16792477667331696,
-0.704865038394928,
-0.15704236924648285,
0.10553144663572311,
0.09424781054258347,
-0.35337528586387634,
0.5597034692764282,
-0.3803173303604126,
0.2448086440563202,
-0.14719465374946594,
-0.2896411418914795,
-0.5283291339874268,
0.13347989320755005,
0.28265872597694397,
-0.22233988344669342,
0.009744950570166111,
-0.2610810101032257,
0.01896512880921364,
0.7933068871498108,
-0.4502512216567993,
0.6918236017227173,
-0.2789544463157654,
0.03225798159837723,
0.04710814356803894,
-0.04913962632417679,
0.44778624176979065,
-0.19553570449352264,
-0.43535855412483215,
0.08811719715595245,
-0.23876193165779114,
-0.1429455727338791,
-0.745297908782959,
0.6114069223403931,
-0.4902123808860779,
-0.5536164045333862,
-0.0741662085056305,
-0.45363467931747437,
-0.09398949146270752,
0.17973816394805908,
-0.08121377229690552,
0.600023627281189,
-0.2061692327260971,
0.751141369342804,
0.555329442024231,
-0.31087633967399597,
0.30672556161880493,
0.6414064764976501,
-0.5222311019897461,
-0.35722383856773376,
0.7827180027961731,
0.10376481711864471,
0.16934680938720703,
0.3149670362472534,
0.22914263606071472,
-0.3310454189777374,
-1.044081687927246,
-0.49030354619026184,
0.2771778106689453,
-0.7146264314651489,
0.02917625568807125,
-0.5336967706680298,
-0.036487728357315063,
-0.40462127327919006,
-0.21797491610050201,
-0.31914496421813965,
-0.0854637399315834,
-0.05855909362435341,
-0.08966351300477982,
0.40646567940711975,
0.9338072538375854,
0.1920531839132309,
0.45988452434539795,
-0.9354425072669983,
0.21755702793598175,
0.22488054633140564,
0.41329240798950195,
0.09509618580341339,
-0.45758265256881714,
-0.6289369463920593,
-0.08400782942771912,
0.016449986025691032,
-0.4269488453865051,
0.3901086151599884,
0.2447134554386139,
0.6840957403182983,
0.5297996401786804,
-0.10632835328578949,
0.44742411375045776,
-0.7017682194709778,
0.8612797260284424,
0.06474408507347107,
-0.6936511397361755,
0.2312338799238205,
-0.3177553713321686,
0.23935553431510925,
0.6092817187309265,
0.16083748638629913,
-0.34945404529571533,
-0.4488316774368286,
-0.18889248371124268,
-0.7378752827644348,
0.5562155246734619,
-0.07548125833272934,
0.25369444489479065,
0.2431086003780365,
0.5556254386901855,
0.12454937398433685,
0.09149564802646637,
-0.5689881443977356,
-0.1597110629081726,
0.14590328931808472,
-0.2481730431318283,
-0.4627532660961151,
-0.5488923192024231,
0.011024716310203075,
0.1496438980102539,
0.7781051397323608,
-0.011607425287365913,
-0.06205964833498001,
0.028804820030927658,
-0.02882055751979351,
0.09872023016214371,
0.3241305351257324,
0.3611327111721039,
0.40656834840774536,
-0.3546951413154602,
0.029547259211540222,
0.38781315088272095,
-0.2669650912284851,
0.2584783136844635,
-0.1339876502752304,
-0.12441708892583847,
0.020274024456739426,
0.39323100447654724,
0.8491045236587524,
0.3970014750957489,
-0.7578235864639282,
0.36760663986206055,
0.060067906975746155,
-0.029029637575149536,
-0.15763835608959198,
0.48368340730667114,
0.30737146735191345,
0.350576251745224,
0.49468448758125305,
0.08055315911769867,
0.3037266731262207,
-0.4042108356952667,
0.1268109828233719,
0.7888646721839905,
-0.22220608592033386,
0.08830563724040985,
0.19190844893455505,
0.3559024930000305,
-0.5160990357398987,
0.2441236972808838,
0.16229309141635895,
-0.33398500084877014,
0.43743622303009033,
0.5473592281341553,
0.7651076316833496,
0.2089030146598816,
-0.16448572278022766,
0.30040761828422546,
0.12857982516288757,
-0.522619366645813,
-0.26018238067626953,
-0.38781309127807617,
-1.0782936811447144,
-0.4196232557296753,
-0.882871150970459,
-0.6883630752563477,
-0.045492421835660934,
-0.6470290422439575,
0.3706039488315582,
-0.6540026664733887,
-0.19051365554332733,
0.1226436197757721,
0.007592799142003059,
-0.6455517411231995,
0.18807482719421387,
0.02434021420776844,
0.9915037751197815,
-0.5727710723876953,
1.0180697441101074,
0.38943418860435486,
0.21259674429893494,
-0.8143254518508911,
-0.2730175256729126,
-0.26389196515083313,
-0.8664933443069458,
0.888762891292572,
0.12116539478302002,
-0.4656384587287903,
-0.3171117305755615,
-0.307582825422287,
-0.5997099280357361,
0.7649340629577637,
0.39564642310142517,
-0.844750702381134,
0.013992168940603733,
0.038491759449243546,
0.6982715129852295,
-0.5471351146697998,
0.38225480914115906,
0.3257679045200348,
0.25645682215690613,
0.11275172233581543,
-0.8137714862823486,
0.0015002815052866936,
-0.2525336742401123,
0.4195549190044403,
0.14674322307109833,
-0.31034624576568604,
0.4013770818710327,
-0.17851009964942932,
-0.12267529219388962,
0.050416626036167145,
0.7122045159339905,
0.489161878824234,
0.17731808125972748,
0.7062802910804749,
0.38780659437179565,
0.6252831220626831,
-0.05951966345310211,
1.310573935508728,
-0.5148935317993164,
-0.005958865396678448,
1.020893931388855,
-0.6635337471961975,
1.126728892326355,
0.16873572766780853,
-0.3804963231086731,
0.32748353481292725,
0.46197274327278137,
-0.4198504090309143,
0.4253852367401123,
0.13430316746234894,
-0.2841329872608185,
-0.5652952790260315,
-0.21109715104103088,
-0.3590400218963623,
0.513835608959198,
0.006211672909557819,
-0.616000771522522,
-0.2202426791191101,
0.17746451497077942,
-0.3217921853065491,
0.2863505780696869,
-0.18668369948863983,
1.049665927886963,
0.08913823962211609,
-0.47109881043434143,
0.4696701765060425,
-0.003629744052886963,
1.1244148015975952,
-0.8578217625617981,
0.02133595570921898,
0.17890331149101257,
0.3541749119758606,
0.01651809737086296,
-0.6091961860656738,
-0.021735357120633125,
0.20149871706962585,
-0.5045445561408997,
-0.22150614857673645,
0.7381066083908081,
-0.3459491431713104,
-0.7085121273994446,
0.32252857089042664,
0.4311283528804779,
0.18973596394062042,
0.16616888344287872,
-0.3507397472858429,
-0.18648435175418854,
0.07154203206300735,
-0.2879491448402405,
0.5134207606315613,
0.13160337507724762,
0.49905019998550415,
0.9101753234863281,
1.1344529390335083,
0.723435640335083,
-0.26031801104545593,
0.12074722349643707,
0.7243614792823792,
-0.6672898530960083,
-0.4217953383922577,
-1.066821813583374,
-0.029540037736296654,
-0.15667948126792908,
-0.136450856924057,
1.0011122226715088,
0.7082186937332153,
0.9231228232383728,
0.09505480527877808,
0.8379396200180054,
0.5126454830169678,
0.8060534000396729,
-0.7218953967094421,
0.6766588091850281,
-0.41632744669914246,
0.8228796720504761,
0.09583640843629837,
-1.1316282749176025,
-0.2393186241388321,
0.571072518825531,
-0.3850737512111664,
0.36851879954338074,
0.3916968107223511,
1.036278247833252,
0.2912575900554657,
0.13938188552856445,
0.5315771698951721,
-0.09160535037517548,
0.42030295729637146,
0.6078073978424072,
0.772125780582428,
-0.08244279026985168,
0.5379030704498291,
-0.3046148121356964,
-0.06088406592607498,
-0.39751726388931274,
-0.7130132913589478,
-0.9313045740127563,
-0.3804177939891815,
0.2412940114736557,
-0.5647677779197693,
0.0568542554974556,
1.3556039333343506,
0.8048222064971924,
-0.7501633763313293,
-0.5599157214164734,
0.12955878674983978,
0.04582710564136505,
-0.14906829595565796,
-0.15948094427585602,
0.23302985727787018,
-0.2575320601463318,
-1.1265943050384521,
0.6351155638694763,
0.26046672463417053,
0.08371421694755554,
-0.5056067705154419,
0.002758776769042015,
0.295756071805954,
-0.06799478083848953,
0.5206738114356995,
-0.21226374804973602,
-0.6385452747344971,
-0.13720571994781494,
-0.017727475613355637,
-0.4498576819896698,
-0.036682236939668655,
1.0430022478103638,
-0.781240701675415,
0.3569658100605011,
0.3936478793621063,
0.7242839932441711,
0.33364829421043396,
-0.17110683023929596,
0.8484830260276794,
-0.08077553659677505,
0.04452821984887123,
0.1948278546333313,
0.539569079875946,
0.43672987818717957,
-0.16577178239822388,
0.2667931616306305,
0.020768387243151665,
-0.606859028339386,
-1.0497241020202637,
0.0668385922908783,
-0.8710598945617676,
-0.4088282585144043,
1.4213809967041016,
-0.12974482774734497,
-0.1957714706659317,
-0.1341678500175476,
-0.24223613739013672,
0.23353815078735352,
-0.6673474907875061,
0.6586705446243286,
0.7271484136581421,
0.06481996923685074,
0.15161022543907166,
-0.4162682592868805,
0.5563971996307373,
0.5356706380844116,
-0.5810791850090027,
0.2018355280160904,
0.4418770968914032,
0.34897589683532715,
0.056623250246047974,
0.5672339200973511,
0.23982706665992737,
0.12240305542945862,
-0.02281813882291317,
0.11244049668312073,
-0.3644804358482361,
-0.1796153485774994,
-0.6160566806793213,
0.5552837252616882,
0.4224422872066498,
0.1767950803041458
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.02356v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.02356v1
|
Language Models Do Hard Arithmetic Tasks Easily and Hardly Do Easy Arithmetic Tasks
| 2024-06-04T14:34:39 | 2024-06-04T14:34:39 |
Andrew Gambardella, Yusuke Iwasawa, Yutaka Matsuo
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
The ability (and inability) of large language models (LLMs) to perform
arithmetic tasks has been the subject of much theoretical and practical debate.
We show that LLMs are frequently able to correctly and confidently predict the
first digit of n-digit by m-digit multiplication tasks without using chain of
thought reasoning, despite these tasks require compounding operations to solve.
Simultaneously, LLMs in practice often fail to correctly or confidently predict
the last digit of an n-digit by m-digit multiplication, a task equivalent to
1-digit by 1-digit multiplication which can be easily learned or memorized. We
show that the latter task can be solved more robustly when the LLM is
conditioned on all of the correct higher-order digits, which on average
increases the confidence of the correct last digit on 5-digit by 5-digit
multiplication tasks using Llama 2-13B by over 230% (0.13 to 0.43) and
Mistral-7B by 150% (0.22 to 0.55).
|
[
-0.3101107180118561,
-0.8293160200119019,
0.7042698264122009,
0.5649569630622864,
-0.2395045906305313,
0.08493806421756744,
-0.3349365293979645,
-0.513825535774231,
0.009251078590750694,
0.36648133397102356,
-0.43739160895347595,
-0.1550908237695694,
-0.8894175887107849,
0.12157035619020462,
-0.244832843542099,
0.7292149662971497,
0.051307518035173416,
0.23185695707798004,
-0.2653709948062897,
0.028997007757425308,
-0.09452130645513535,
-1.0476820468902588,
-0.5678285956382751,
-0.5564306974411011,
0.46930333971977234,
0.407344251871109,
0.8232780694961548,
0.6014880537986755,
0.8296132683753967,
0.4191037714481354,
-0.09961556643247604,
0.19716273248195648,
-0.4791679084300995,
-0.06650077551603317,
0.18804967403411865,
-0.8249225616455078,
-0.6736385226249695,
-0.10324867814779282,
0.42586612701416016,
1.1460233926773071,
-0.3572571277618408,
0.05147024244070053,
-0.3618720471858978,
0.8971539735794067,
-0.3740096092224121,
0.45317062735557556,
-0.6936869621276855,
-0.34150153398513794,
-0.07238613814115524,
-0.13364370167255402,
-0.6091074347496033,
-0.3233790993690491,
-0.3659646809101105,
-0.6381525993347168,
-0.10207290202379227,
0.17709839344024658,
0.38621681928634644,
0.3008311688899994,
-0.38806042075157166,
-0.35579416155815125,
-0.9264068603515625,
0.8541541695594788,
-0.5731593370437622,
0.3914046585559845,
0.7185770869255066,
0.03334317356348038,
-0.26371076703071594,
-0.3774290084838867,
-0.6145095229148865,
-0.356957346200943,
0.09641856700181961,
-0.35556134581565857,
-0.24268952012062073,
0.2426050752401352,
0.7451731562614441,
0.36630934476852417,
-0.020688463002443314,
0.08815113455057144,
-0.49581632018089294,
-0.09766139090061188,
0.6328333020210266,
0.39534392952919006,
0.21480251848697662,
0.09035976976156235,
-0.1808851659297943,
-0.17835919559001923,
-1.0629794597625732,
0.13516022264957428,
0.21570098400115967,
0.19557435810565948,
0.031511854380369186,
0.8248264193534851,
-0.20739999413490295,
0.6766229271888733,
0.00724641652777791,
-0.4705868661403656,
0.2625029981136322,
-0.05633879452943802,
-0.5025569200515747,
-0.20156380534172058,
0.4238499701023102,
0.21437181532382965,
0.6514939069747925,
0.1074085608124733,
-0.6118705868721008,
0.44180265069007874,
0.041819941252470016,
-0.814119279384613,
-0.017307134345173836,
0.042656075209379196,
0.02778124436736107,
-0.20459897816181183,
-0.05192055553197861,
-0.025650950148701668,
-0.21230359375476837,
-0.4355800151824951,
0.7213932871818542,
-0.3015930652618408,
-0.008676883764564991,
0.37421682476997375,
0.14118866622447968,
-0.21306659281253815,
0.6229193806648254,
-0.976451575756073,
0.56208735704422,
1.1693931818008423,
0.5928710103034973,
0.08602619916200638,
-0.28564536571502686,
-0.3794323801994324,
-0.28806549310684204,
-0.8131488561630249,
0.3325360119342804,
-0.4473526179790497,
-0.38260453939437866,
-0.24172411859035492,
-0.033037662506103516,
-0.19321465492248535,
-0.594832718372345,
0.48257797956466675,
-0.6831353306770325,
-0.0638088807463646,
-0.19811730086803436,
-0.6000133752822876,
-0.17993687093257904,
0.0727553591132164,
-0.7518680691719055,
0.6457653641700745,
0.07365719228982925,
-0.4998929798603058,
0.004400176461786032,
0.052248887717723846,
-0.5161623954772949,
-0.2706860899925232,
0.03629627451300621,
-0.16365019977092743,
0.5106309056282043,
0.13422276079654694,
0.49720996618270874,
-0.4248664379119873,
0.24921393394470215,
-0.5789783596992493,
-0.5793458819389343,
0.36770251393318176,
-0.8209277391433716,
0.7760621309280396,
-0.03025531955063343,
-0.15946711599826813,
-0.26143309473991394,
-0.679989218711853,
-0.05644107609987259,
-0.011485612019896507,
-0.46889495849609375,
-0.28594642877578735,
-0.00850207544863224,
-0.581315815448761,
0.43632635474205017,
0.2927911877632141,
-0.5187473893165588,
0.3991706371307373,
-0.6498321294784546,
0.19023241102695465,
0.8612914681434631,
-0.25637632608413696,
0.5042125582695007,
-0.5390223264694214,
0.4596289098262787,
0.07918155938386917,
-0.038117337971925735,
-0.368594229221344,
-0.5999636054039001,
-1.0625087022781372,
-0.10775256156921387,
0.21644210815429688,
0.6785281300544739,
-0.9971103668212891,
-0.0251762717962265,
-0.5119355916976929,
-0.6484447717666626,
-0.24068303406238556,
0.4383765757083893,
0.6735210418701172,
0.4670848846435547,
0.17907817661762238,
-0.13345371186733246,
-0.34755992889404297,
-0.8318271636962891,
-0.13093046844005585,
-0.3233708441257477,
0.025039395317435265,
0.12419755756855011,
0.3481850028038025,
0.11672008037567139,
0.19844003021717072,
-0.4837827682495117,
-0.10431601107120514,
-0.12288215011358261,
0.2878120243549347,
0.6652548909187317,
0.4485947787761688,
0.04319338873028755,
-0.7762426137924194,
-0.31264394521713257,
-0.03992227092385292,
-0.6086059212684631,
0.025951141491532326,
0.02702648751437664,
0.4065714478492737,
0.6254740953445435,
0.35981082916259766,
-1.0359525680541992,
0.4171881675720215,
0.5831767320632935,
-0.3010346591472626,
0.4197666645050049,
-0.5374701619148254,
-0.08329270035028458,
-0.629185676574707,
-0.37972292304039,
0.14057807624340057,
-0.31956619024276733,
-0.9584217071533203,
0.022542878985404968,
0.2429029643535614,
0.2550891041755676,
-0.3144637644290924,
0.36139270663261414,
-0.3566685616970062,
-0.053132981061935425,
-0.34418562054634094,
-0.48121196031570435,
-0.13662369549274445,
0.652929961681366,
0.049853622913360596,
0.745193362236023,
0.4009415805339813,
-0.5682942271232605,
0.16585169732570648,
-0.38084104657173157,
-0.580633282661438,
0.24164322018623352,
-0.8090044856071472,
0.1252494603395462,
-0.13802854716777802,
0.011248825117945671,
-0.7654797434806824,
-0.21472911536693573,
-0.20457062125205994,
-0.4659941792488098,
0.31784507632255554,
0.09400494396686554,
-0.5564850568771362,
-0.3684055209159851,
-0.07681552320718765,
0.5211261510848999,
0.780782163143158,
-0.3054363429546356,
0.635769784450531,
0.24147741496562958,
-0.4194219410419464,
-0.6481574177742004,
-0.6480417251586914,
-0.16701428592205048,
-0.06672139465808868,
-0.6018186211585999,
0.09956809133291245,
-0.06556819379329681,
-0.7259015440940857,
-0.316543847322464,
-0.12317627668380737,
-0.12395558506250381,
0.20827598869800568,
0.5797996520996094,
0.6606865525245667,
-0.060154981911182404,
0.17055653035640717,
-0.36378246545791626,
-0.3240218758583069,
0.27802738547325134,
0.06350787729024887,
0.5360724329948425,
-0.13823215663433075,
-0.6942449808120728,
-0.22039325535297394,
0.11906280368566513,
0.8039324879646301,
0.13526755571365356,
0.5857987403869629,
0.17579463124275208,
-0.6399142146110535,
-0.03774324059486389,
-0.698035717010498,
-0.013846238143742085,
-0.4995781481266022,
0.24645307660102844,
-0.7520366311073303,
-0.918549656867981,
0.1765020191669464,
0.2590161859989166,
0.07229544222354889,
0.5018181204795837,
0.8244736790657043,
-0.13537824153900146,
1.3437330722808838,
0.5408465266227722,
-0.028073012828826904,
0.01469141710549593,
-0.016803229227662086,
0.29744380712509155,
-0.5680716633796692,
-0.2125655561685562,
-0.3728983402252197,
-0.02948611043393612,
-0.7087300419807434,
-0.7493821382522583,
0.3653643727302551,
0.22699853777885437,
-0.3967767357826233,
0.15312406420707703,
-0.10425262898206711,
0.543531060218811,
0.7769969701766968,
0.17719332873821259,
0.38097020983695984,
0.12234177440404892,
0.035759177058935165,
-0.07258172333240509,
-0.35021352767944336,
-0.33376413583755493,
1.1490105390548706,
0.41449400782585144,
1.0368151664733887,
0.11998159438371658,
0.6884713768959045,
0.18561336398124695,
0.5972661375999451,
-0.8987398147583008,
0.5386872887611389,
-0.3296146094799042,
-0.650311291217804,
-0.4438263773918152,
-0.5821087956428528,
-0.5664336681365967,
0.316943883895874,
-0.11180673539638519,
-0.6167240142822266,
0.32136934995651245,
0.1539512723684311,
-0.2744150757789612,
0.3304973244667053,
-0.7787843942642212,
0.1140863299369812,
-0.24033388495445251,
-0.19641049206256866,
-0.36926960945129395,
-0.3185296356678009,
0.6249567866325378,
-0.4245277941226959,
0.7053853869438171,
-0.3768068850040436,
-0.2198074609041214,
0.47036781907081604,
-0.6875974535942078,
0.8887954354286194,
-0.06184462085366249,
-0.1795119196176529,
0.13318294286727905,
0.5253345966339111,
0.7126008868217468,
-0.2823542356491089,
-0.31720179319381714,
0.02868380770087242,
-0.18460699915885925,
-0.39251333475112915,
-0.9023357033729553,
0.5689747333526611,
-0.780490517616272,
-1.041657567024231,
-0.462776243686676,
-0.5851567983627319,
-0.27832797169685364,
-0.07664769887924194,
-0.05239807814359665,
0.5621145963668823,
0.17870786786079407,
0.280238538980484,
0.5153969526290894,
0.3640764057636261,
0.5997077822685242,
0.28850623965263367,
-0.3449305593967438,
-0.6093006730079651,
1.0541430711746216,
0.34423208236694336,
0.6441472768783569,
0.3823557496070862,
0.055152006447315216,
-0.18674850463867188,
-0.3773375451564789,
-0.33867865800857544,
0.1582493782043457,
-0.8138664364814758,
-0.07627124339342117,
-0.43444663286209106,
-0.07602834701538086,
-0.039094019681215286,
-0.04016687721014023,
-0.11890601366758347,
-0.9745311737060547,
-0.08621598780155182,
-0.26395758986473083,
0.0945778489112854,
0.8831357359886169,
-0.18486388027668,
0.2337932288646698,
-0.667824387550354,
0.47898826003074646,
0.6058644652366638,
0.10280325263738632,
0.06311268359422684,
-0.7407097220420837,
-0.13301096856594086,
0.20656010508537292,
-0.01503775455057621,
-0.6426510810852051,
0.4794953763484955,
0.1919940859079361,
0.19482837617397308,
0.3973596394062042,
-0.2598381042480469,
0.7664883732795715,
-0.5167185664176941,
0.45824334025382996,
0.3575456142425537,
-1.0324747562408447,
-0.1572795808315277,
-0.1586546003818512,
0.0004162825644016266,
0.24296200275421143,
0.5094071626663208,
-0.29266998171806335,
-0.0062836236320436,
-0.696873664855957,
-0.6043518781661987,
0.6535755395889282,
0.1484421044588089,
0.3275224268436432,
-0.037834882736206055,
0.23532238602638245,
-0.11047107726335526,
0.3765794634819031,
-0.7030506730079651,
-0.3499084413051605,
0.1471889466047287,
-0.033947985619306564,
-0.5072419047355652,
-0.5217249989509583,
-0.018070027232170105,
-0.40498870611190796,
0.6894096732139587,
-0.00401259632781148,
0.16006231307983398,
-0.043792810291051865,
-0.12447177618741989,
-0.24983921647071838,
0.23904399573802948,
0.8585376143455505,
0.775641918182373,
-0.1813286542892456,
0.3663230836391449,
0.3526652753353119,
-0.3128209114074707,
0.47481030225753784,
-0.06904739141464233,
-0.11382464319467545,
-0.1936737298965454,
0.7742470502853394,
0.8867383599281311,
0.3583572804927826,
-0.5569013357162476,
0.5626822710037231,
0.13813461363315582,
-0.3490237891674042,
-0.3179275691509247,
0.20759476721286774,
0.4699682891368866,
-0.08975295722484589,
0.5071524977684021,
0.005889777559787035,
-0.20956873893737793,
-0.5853043794631958,
0.012551904655992985,
0.4979671835899353,
-0.19939756393432617,
-0.36995312571525574,
0.28983011841773987,
-0.014424500986933708,
-0.6667097806930542,
0.6971337199211121,
-0.22396400570869446,
-0.6120792031288147,
0.892983615398407,
0.7744553685188293,
0.4821240305900574,
-0.2699817419052124,
-0.05201616883277893,
0.281438410282135,
0.48432499170303345,
-0.39172491431236267,
0.47086629271507263,
0.11040695756673813,
-0.8425494432449341,
-0.751975417137146,
-0.768379271030426,
-0.5951500535011292,
-0.371901273727417,
-0.49087458848953247,
-0.015421825461089611,
-0.6705233454704285,
-0.2590695321559906,
0.1771327257156372,
0.049239106476306915,
-0.7395421862602234,
0.5902424454689026,
0.23898841440677643,
1.0808274745941162,
-0.8418436646461487,
0.8726869821548462,
0.44932642579078674,
-0.13396169245243073,
-1.0987415313720703,
-0.7226154208183289,
-0.02942059002816677,
-1.309017539024353,
0.9298677444458008,
0.21537859737873077,
-0.09802541881799698,
-0.12269067019224167,
-0.4306982159614563,
-0.9147963523864746,
0.7786175012588501,
0.41385534405708313,
-0.8482402563095093,
-0.17765864729881287,
0.47412678599357605,
0.6499185562133789,
-0.4380507469177246,
0.38960814476013184,
0.3817121684551239,
0.545483410358429,
0.31430119276046753,
-1.0950944423675537,
-0.009377683512866497,
-0.3022926151752472,
-0.12059345096349716,
0.3931747078895569,
-0.5941504836082458,
1.4207252264022827,
-0.628727912902832,
0.007249854505062103,
-0.10433381795883179,
0.4682014584541321,
0.2904788553714752,
0.3745717406272888,
0.7383989691734314,
0.8499869108200073,
0.7311998605728149,
-0.3631353974342346,
1.365391731262207,
-0.3934824466705322,
0.13108713924884796,
0.9591479897499084,
-0.14055606722831726,
1.0846633911132812,
0.5056424736976624,
-0.518005907535553,
0.46336206793785095,
0.41114068031311035,
0.27960655093193054,
0.08154509961605072,
0.20080988109111786,
-0.3740155100822449,
-0.8610677123069763,
0.0876537337899208,
-0.027295084670186043,
0.48971468210220337,
0.5690279603004456,
-0.15920625627040863,
0.20734548568725586,
-0.2552673816680908,
0.0584370493888855,
-0.05551346018910408,
-0.48172953724861145,
0.745897650718689,
0.597406804561615,
-0.7868285775184631,
0.7085328698158264,
0.14501440525054932,
0.5510250926017761,
-0.4274226725101471,
-0.06583075225353241,
-0.2420692890882492,
0.17765210568904877,
-0.26573723554611206,
-0.64260333776474,
0.18919774889945984,
-0.17631275951862335,
-0.22138653695583344,
-0.07329710572957993,
0.7098842263221741,
-0.2565179765224457,
-1.1350430250167847,
0.013991155661642551,
0.6950596570968628,
-0.02236425317823887,
-0.22467179596424103,
-0.3419516682624817,
0.0933389887213707,
-0.05053282901644707,
-0.4455278813838959,
0.30280715227127075,
0.3871188461780548,
-0.28108853101730347,
1.1699022054672241,
0.9413620829582214,
0.3278892934322357,
0.1665312796831131,
-0.07216161489486694,
0.6931557655334473,
-0.8922009468078613,
-0.12670090794563293,
-1.2197803258895874,
0.10151006281375885,
0.16248464584350586,
0.05849912390112877,
0.4897749125957489,
0.31597432494163513,
0.7122320532798767,
0.02365514636039734,
0.48151543736457825,
0.2601427137851715,
0.3073081374168396,
-0.4839874804019928,
0.18809673190116882,
-0.44298967719078064,
0.3682897388935089,
0.18302883207798004,
-0.8772791028022766,
-0.31566280126571655,
0.43997645378112793,
-0.3941292464733124,
0.17718824744224548,
0.6050904989242554,
0.7409828305244446,
0.14316987991333008,
-0.01064095739275217,
0.5968407392501831,
0.21988435089588165,
0.11029122024774551,
0.8937007188796997,
0.7341791987419128,
-0.21020419895648956,
0.2650778591632843,
-0.6742955446243286,
-0.14898525178432465,
-0.11462424695491791,
-0.7898883819580078,
-0.826178252696991,
-0.31330782175064087,
0.11234217882156372,
-0.2929040491580963,
-0.1036665216088295,
1.3023360967636108,
0.5848972201347351,
-0.6592861413955688,
-0.32753077149391174,
-0.041707005351781845,
0.3760203719139099,
0.011533032171428204,
-0.09588209539651871,
0.27770596742630005,
-0.23631231486797333,
-0.9521818161010742,
0.2823266088962555,
0.33161571621894836,
0.22531983256340027,
-0.2920057773590088,
-0.12422183901071548,
0.16774189472198486,
0.34209945797920227,
0.6873375773429871,
0.18610510230064392,
-0.7965862154960632,
-0.049152012914419174,
0.13959212601184845,
-0.3081732392311096,
0.07900996506214142,
0.7514322400093079,
-0.6947975754737854,
0.2693784236907959,
0.46303635835647583,
0.6260955929756165,
0.36319082975387573,
0.2653731405735016,
0.6291952729225159,
-0.2727851867675781,
0.14267699420452118,
0.07491029053926468,
0.5461642146110535,
0.4562816619873047,
-0.15495161712169647,
0.4584085941314697,
0.22092020511627197,
-0.44252413511276245,
-0.8162623643875122,
0.16734685003757477,
-0.70315021276474,
0.005160718224942684,
1.2007232904434204,
-0.2558523416519165,
-0.48494574427604675,
0.025733618065714836,
0.02028527855873108,
-0.17129433155059814,
-0.17068235576152802,
0.6904929280281067,
0.8654729723930359,
-0.01521782111376524,
-0.07809863239526749,
-0.4034770131111145,
0.4898178279399872,
0.7554346919059753,
-0.49434682726860046,
0.04818364977836609,
0.4049416184425354,
0.14199534058570862,
0.348597913980484,
0.7839898467063904,
0.10445185005664825,
0.45135265588760376,
0.10989142954349518,
-0.28810325264930725,
-0.3362177312374115,
-0.4876100718975067,
-0.3823709487915039,
0.299068421125412,
0.5576881170272827,
0.35024499893188477
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.02350v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.02350v2
|
LlamaCare: A Large Medical Language Model for Enhancing Healthcare Knowledge Sharing
| 2024-06-04T14:24:53 | 2024-06-05T15:08:42 |
Maojun Sun
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large language models (LLMs) have shown amazing capabilities in knowledge
memorization and the present. However, when it comes to domain-specific
knowledge and downstream tasks like medical, general LLMs are often unable to
give precise answers. In addition, when people want LLMs to answer
classification questions, they usually go through instruction tuning first.
However, LLMs do not always give a direct index of the categorization after
instruction tuning. In this paper, we proposed LlamaCare, a fine-tuned medical
language model, and Extended Classification Integration(ECI), a module to
handle classification problems of LLMs. Our contributions are : (i) We
fine-tuned a large language model of medical knowledge with very low carbon
emissions and achieved similar performance with ChatGPT by a 24G GPU. (ii) We
solved the problem of redundant categorical answers and improved the
performance of LLMs by proposing a new module called Extended Classification
Integration. (iii) We released our processed data for one-shot and few-shot
training for some benchmarks such as PubMedQA and USMLE 1-3 step. Our method
achieves a close performance comparable to some state-of-the-art models with
the same quantity of parameters on benchmarks, while being more environmentally
friendly by using less GPU computation time. Our models, codes, and datasets
can be found at \url{https://github.com/Stephen-SMJ/LLamaCare}.
|
[
0.02621224895119667,
-0.5669146180152893,
0.834815263748169,
-0.1703014224767685,
-0.3907601237297058,
0.019439104944467545,
-0.26077425479888916,
-0.7611687779426575,
0.12583117187023163,
0.634956955909729,
-0.40293702483177185,
-0.8406639099121094,
-0.786272406578064,
-0.13800597190856934,
-0.19640232622623444,
0.9169477820396423,
-0.22290126979351044,
0.08829135447740555,
-0.31758758425712585,
-0.21945150196552277,
0.005418260581791401,
-0.612118124961853,
-0.6794859766960144,
-0.4611988067626953,
0.7461478114128113,
0.3378886878490448,
0.4500075876712799,
0.8730596303939819,
0.6940959095954895,
0.2818897068500519,
-0.3348180055618286,
0.3428225517272949,
-0.41078171133995056,
-0.06719984114170074,
-0.0995188057422638,
-0.7062299251556396,
-0.6745827198028564,
-0.22802525758743286,
0.5190529227256775,
0.7524009943008423,
-0.5916639566421509,
0.11693494766950607,
0.03861594945192337,
0.5284888744354248,
-0.42095714807510376,
0.3297390043735504,
-0.4950624704360962,
-0.016345253214240074,
-0.09411296993494034,
-0.4217263460159302,
-0.11884921044111252,
-0.3523139953613281,
0.099591463804245,
-0.6521816849708557,
0.033551353961229324,
0.005996345076709986,
0.692716658115387,
0.6897119879722595,
-0.38211241364479065,
-0.25264957547187805,
-0.4674478769302368,
0.7234833240509033,
-0.9357085824012756,
0.10126036405563354,
0.27941569685935974,
0.26609110832214355,
-0.13096404075622559,
-0.8461065292358398,
-0.41701847314834595,
-0.12248869240283966,
-0.04792411997914314,
0.14442072808742523,
-0.41447994112968445,
0.3991827070713043,
-0.06911967694759369,
0.3314601480960846,
-0.34191080927848816,
0.5596404075622559,
-0.41490286588668823,
-0.0042991372756659985,
0.6187969446182251,
0.42306840419769287,
0.2906144857406616,
0.14065736532211304,
-0.2849784195423126,
0.1495165079832077,
-0.8938316106796265,
-0.04798075556755066,
-0.07525759935379028,
-0.007956133224070072,
-0.11467297375202179,
0.5678580403327942,
-0.45967239141464233,
0.6025267243385315,
-0.3351741135120392,
-0.5432320833206177,
0.34675830602645874,
0.0858369842171669,
-0.4418866038322449,
0.1600128561258316,
0.47722646594047546,
0.2133289873600006,
0.008358805440366268,
-0.02992488257586956,
0.05112268403172493,
0.2860078811645508,
0.1780414581298828,
-0.9590415954589844,
-0.24920566380023956,
0.25889283418655396,
-0.36773180961608887,
-0.330403208732605,
-0.3609529733657837,
-0.3206997811794281,
-0.3221839964389801,
-0.5007442831993103,
0.2569205164909363,
-0.2912249267101288,
-0.09235074371099472,
0.5605831146240234,
0.36800625920295715,
-0.09625964611768723,
0.5917109251022339,
-0.8062710165977478,
0.41233697533607483,
0.9167153239250183,
0.6595249176025391,
-0.345672070980072,
0.03235188126564026,
-0.2358073741197586,
0.32282382249832153,
-0.07370506972074509,
0.9699127078056335,
-0.7192026376724243,
-0.37136125564575195,
-0.02496504783630371,
0.19398458302021027,
-0.09796731919050217,
-0.7268407344818115,
0.34170690178871155,
-0.44897595047950745,
0.00070929154753685,
0.03278672695159912,
-0.8440768718719482,
-0.37580612301826477,
0.2879458963871002,
-0.39599552750587463,
0.6136846542358398,
0.047862403094768524,
-0.5986531376838684,
0.1953718513250351,
-0.7232256531715393,
-0.3717319965362549,
0.317268431186676,
-0.15012262761592865,
-0.5164944529533386,
0.12312714755535126,
0.15999282896518707,
0.5501037240028381,
-0.38394874334335327,
0.47422510385513306,
-0.3047667145729065,
-0.3602065443992615,
0.16811326146125793,
-0.41061148047447205,
0.45190539956092834,
0.15598545968532562,
-0.031737711280584335,
0.19797535240650177,
-0.7114325761795044,
0.07677078247070312,
-0.06420516222715378,
-0.639273464679718,
-0.37505096197128296,
-0.029759876430034637,
-0.1204831525683403,
0.04978860542178154,
0.3142143487930298,
-0.4602431058883667,
0.35614484548568726,
-0.3634677231311798,
0.5125681757926941,
0.6137391328811646,
0.1734265834093094,
0.24102452397346497,
-0.6829755306243896,
0.5866232514381409,
0.01099206693470478,
0.4974632263183594,
0.04780779406428337,
-0.736681342124939,
-0.8240578770637512,
-0.4629635512828827,
0.07509306073188782,
0.5569450259208679,
-0.5019224286079407,
0.25206953287124634,
-0.3507901430130005,
-0.6055261492729187,
-0.8822594881057739,
0.30661746859550476,
0.30854320526123047,
0.5125881433486938,
0.4770796298980713,
-0.2890532314777374,
-0.3546392023563385,
-0.8154653310775757,
0.07705502957105637,
-0.23257789015769958,
0.05442747101187706,
0.7350941300392151,
0.2826186418533325,
-0.7479591965675354,
0.3474525511264801,
-0.654283881187439,
-0.3410917818546295,
-0.06375369429588318,
-0.19863221049308777,
0.3039577901363373,
0.37944284081459045,
0.18561513721942902,
-0.45824122428894043,
-0.22339777648448944,
0.3641354441642761,
-0.513435423374176,
-0.13558852672576904,
0.4359893798828125,
-0.16350439190864563,
0.043477024883031845,
0.4205867052078247,
-0.43306830525398254,
0.26376503705978394,
0.8243553638458252,
-0.0549141950905323,
0.09742417186498642,
-0.4532153606414795,
0.003243186278268695,
-1.2083334922790527,
0.127364382147789,
-0.14130453765392303,
-0.2535250782966614,
-0.5052094459533691,
0.156522735953331,
-0.05509328842163086,
0.16455385088920593,
-0.6114140748977661,
0.4882965087890625,
-0.08862330764532089,
0.30701205134391785,
-0.4571276903152466,
-0.2108062356710434,
-0.0810583159327507,
0.4179268181324005,
0.1359037309885025,
0.5827621221542358,
0.6796535849571228,
-0.7966399192810059,
0.36183884739875793,
0.24917954206466675,
-0.4349839687347412,
0.5247536301612854,
-0.703917384147644,
0.0862182006239891,
-0.08440081775188446,
0.2816140651702881,
-0.561445951461792,
-0.43408864736557007,
0.11839254200458527,
-0.03572697564959526,
0.36536097526550293,
-0.07412142306566238,
-0.48436638712882996,
-0.20817993581295013,
0.10392414033412933,
0.44272658228874207,
0.6271807551383972,
-0.7951183915138245,
0.38783931732177734,
0.6755753755569458,
-0.33072057366371155,
-0.36319759488105774,
-0.6573368906974792,
-0.09748509526252747,
-0.3657269775867462,
-0.3978773057460785,
0.44837918877601624,
-0.08363581448793411,
-0.040316127240657806,
0.14229744672775269,
-0.04754186421632767,
-0.2911973297595978,
0.10933687537908554,
0.2687240540981293,
0.43808797001838684,
-0.20482081174850464,
0.6689757704734802,
0.3481683135032654,
-0.2205667495727539,
-0.15168341994285583,
-0.31273481249809265,
0.46171241998672485,
0.0020639519207179546,
-0.5627800822257996,
-0.7014651894569397,
0.45475882291793823,
0.4787369966506958,
-0.13516642153263092,
0.645185649394989,
0.2893282473087311,
-0.4630779027938843,
-0.15128996968269348,
-0.6222318410873413,
-0.018724115565419197,
-0.476055771112442,
0.5702709555625916,
0.05645716190338135,
-1.2875736951828003,
0.2132066935300827,
-0.5216617584228516,
0.18461759388446808,
0.24573713541030884,
0.7679422497749329,
-0.20921002328395844,
0.9767425656318665,
0.8407784104347229,
-0.17308740317821503,
0.17457260191440582,
-0.19485075771808624,
0.10904717445373535,
-0.9234542846679688,
-0.5063461661338806,
-0.4641626179218292,
-0.33799445629119873,
-0.6250464916229248,
-0.6195553541183472,
0.6144540309906006,
-0.07321987301111221,
-0.2446347028017044,
0.06801377981901169,
-0.547919750213623,
0.3205089569091797,
0.3582814633846283,
0.6045373678207397,
0.5522763133049011,
-0.09559604525566101,
0.04520713910460472,
0.2058195322751999,
-0.9066745638847351,
-0.49743372201919556,
0.9466025829315186,
0.42349812388420105,
1.1038882732391357,
0.08267567306756973,
0.8052501082420349,
-0.19085051119327545,
0.7203449010848999,
-0.8058014512062073,
0.29275307059288025,
-0.4113596975803375,
-0.2858603298664093,
0.050833698362112045,
-0.4792190492153168,
-0.9827978014945984,
0.049959562718868256,
-0.11658729612827301,
-0.5616575479507446,
-0.029192429035902023,
0.21794047951698303,
-0.4703197181224823,
0.3246332108974457,
-0.4968460500240326,
0.47049933671951294,
-0.3421574831008911,
-0.1880687177181244,
-0.5165119171142578,
-0.3266094923019409,
0.36987975239753723,
-0.12067687511444092,
0.09936008602380753,
-0.2900840640068054,
-0.33031317591667175,
0.559880256652832,
-0.4908939599990845,
0.9882227778434753,
0.0786486268043518,
-0.18474547564983368,
0.09375414252281189,
-0.31701335310935974,
0.31853583455085754,
0.06908220797777176,
0.07383700460195541,
0.3356775641441345,
0.08265269547700882,
-0.3705303966999054,
-0.4133174419403076,
0.8832868933677673,
-0.8194684386253357,
-0.7073072195053101,
-0.19215871393680573,
-0.48644715547561646,
-0.3277001678943634,
-0.12323271483182907,
0.1914803683757782,
0.29540887475013733,
-0.04643724486231804,
0.11345496773719788,
0.8536198139190674,
-0.4459713399410248,
0.007481275126338005,
0.7347873449325562,
-0.11123929172754288,
-0.1524379700422287,
0.6344905495643616,
-0.010918058454990387,
0.19824746251106262,
0.40133363008499146,
0.23896349966526031,
-0.1763695627450943,
-0.546599268913269,
-0.18985292315483093,
0.4407178461551666,
-0.6981697678565979,
-0.5488744974136353,
-0.7773828506469727,
-0.49122220277786255,
-0.02297166734933853,
-0.020046357065439224,
-0.20156840980052948,
-0.2820304334163666,
-0.5537145733833313,
-0.2533009350299835,
0.7227688431739807,
0.9143542051315308,
0.07790806144475937,
0.4757167100906372,
-0.8247104287147522,
0.14102789759635925,
0.3594356179237366,
0.6969274878501892,
0.03940156102180481,
-0.5256027579307556,
-0.3009095788002014,
-0.19311749935150146,
-0.10895399004220963,
-0.4937603771686554,
0.364175409078598,
0.2587892413139343,
0.6538842916488647,
0.4100921154022217,
-0.17099788784980774,
0.8250046968460083,
-0.6764146089553833,
0.34495630860328674,
0.2916713356971741,
-0.6161577701568604,
0.5463957190513611,
0.06530161947011948,
0.0999714657664299,
0.5392783880233765,
0.2835678160190582,
-0.6007702946662903,
-0.3491955101490021,
-0.5708600282669067,
-0.8307240605354309,
0.334131121635437,
-0.2697179317474365,
0.1767980307340622,
-0.047425296157598495,
0.5115522742271423,
0.06160992011427879,
0.10429100692272186,
-0.3073267638683319,
-0.16086870431900024,
0.4406226873397827,
-0.46570199728012085,
-0.14261074364185333,
-0.18687117099761963,
-0.2834402620792389,
-0.4448226988315582,
0.7288349866867065,
-0.17195487022399902,
0.12741778790950775,
0.26244884729385376,
-0.044591274112463,
-0.1857263743877411,
0.3487636148929596,
0.3712092638015747,
0.2563142478466034,
0.1346607804298401,
0.13121388852596283,
0.3877870440483093,
-0.54517662525177,
0.05587785691022873,
0.029407911002635956,
0.10413695871829987,
-0.13848876953125,
0.327770859003067,
0.8420950174331665,
0.37962275743484497,
-0.7965077757835388,
0.4180988669395447,
-0.13010083138942719,
-0.13576838374137878,
-0.14235824346542358,
0.5467367172241211,
0.3245498239994049,
0.310801237821579,
-0.17086637020111084,
0.2035796195268631,
0.1797880381345749,
-0.36998629570007324,
0.2539084255695343,
0.409760057926178,
-0.39657071232795715,
-0.08969255536794662,
0.6651468873023987,
0.17756891250610352,
-0.16648449003696442,
0.34811288118362427,
0.1934192180633545,
-0.3754783868789673,
0.5588453412055969,
0.5591150522232056,
0.40929895639419556,
-0.4128212630748749,
0.08144283294677734,
0.2148193120956421,
0.10842873156070709,
-0.19678756594657898,
0.2522743344306946,
0.011503896676003933,
-0.5239344239234924,
-0.6981613636016846,
-0.6850107908248901,
-0.655413806438446,
0.05054961144924164,
-0.5692185163497925,
0.27384158968925476,
-0.4499114453792572,
-0.02103359065949917,
-0.14434640109539032,
0.0880984365940094,
-0.8982061147689819,
0.17476697266101837,
0.16253896057605743,
0.8996406197547913,
-0.7538565397262573,
1.143522024154663,
0.7229045033454895,
-0.024615438655018806,
-0.9865148663520813,
-0.29388174414634705,
-0.13550123572349548,
-1.2504677772521973,
0.29339882731437683,
0.1939346045255661,
-0.021530522033572197,
0.009840748272836208,
-0.5906318426132202,
-0.8652041554450989,
1.3451277017593384,
0.33509066700935364,
-1.006299614906311,
0.023436784744262695,
0.18561865389347076,
0.6700097322463989,
-0.46872225403785706,
-0.018190300092101097,
0.7787363529205322,
0.2948946952819824,
0.17788100242614746,
-0.9626898169517517,
-0.02234523743391037,
-0.27381232380867004,
-0.02988511696457863,
-0.0126349413767457,
-0.6187989711761475,
0.5112766027450562,
-0.44477221369743347,
-0.16342894732952118,
0.3701477646827698,
0.11334002763032913,
0.35421785712242126,
0.3552429676055908,
0.2749168276786804,
0.9582652449607849,
1.3488551378250122,
-0.044211070984601974,
1.3439971208572388,
-0.39312872290611267,
0.3677545487880707,
0.8201248049736023,
-0.33317169547080994,
0.97036212682724,
0.37447234988212585,
-0.18471136689186096,
0.37546783685684204,
0.5248759984970093,
0.12065587937831879,
0.5571656823158264,
0.3837333619594574,
-0.6964118480682373,
-0.3057693541049957,
-0.3493048846721649,
-0.4575095474720001,
0.3521031439304352,
0.5738630890846252,
-0.38197579979896545,
-0.04486902058124542,
0.09864481538534164,
0.09477820992469788,
-0.0628766193985939,
-0.4550645649433136,
1.066758394241333,
0.3592268228530884,
-0.45111849904060364,
0.4718053638935089,
-0.016781127080321312,
0.7750189900398254,
-0.5918136835098267,
-0.20233146846294403,
-0.1221570372581482,
0.2827049195766449,
-0.41859978437423706,
-0.5928912162780762,
0.1999831199645996,
0.10777988284826279,
-0.019271990284323692,
0.16882379353046417,
0.5831745862960815,
-0.5437772870063782,
-0.6550048589706421,
0.25462105870246887,
0.4689023494720459,
0.2311115860939026,
0.279053270816803,
-0.46109840273857117,
0.0010738788405433297,
-0.030368536710739136,
0.05173405632376671,
0.308982789516449,
0.3758740723133087,
0.1194051206111908,
0.7785555124282837,
0.8686202168464661,
0.4191192388534546,
-0.01907820999622345,
0.23131121695041656,
1.0492095947265625,
-0.40299132466316223,
-0.36156541109085083,
-0.7041977643966675,
0.165865957736969,
0.1498294472694397,
-0.3443087637424469,
0.06522990763187408,
0.36040398478507996,
0.5248630046844482,
0.19669310748577118,
0.7598803043365479,
0.43408674001693726,
0.6562092900276184,
-0.6355791091918945,
0.8448202013969421,
-0.6602019667625427,
0.49141010642051697,
0.12919685244560242,
-0.5954563021659851,
-0.7194997072219849,
0.6244319081306458,
-0.18497072160243988,
-0.2544408142566681,
0.5504935383796692,
0.7696037888526917,
-0.035169243812561035,
-0.032068442553281784,
0.4696029722690582,
0.26372548937797546,
0.3571317195892334,
0.8825472593307495,
0.8075879812240601,
-0.0683973878622055,
0.43510037660598755,
-0.3693960905075073,
-0.39198175072669983,
-0.34281453490257263,
-0.6344842910766602,
-0.675961434841156,
-0.23781225085258484,
-0.4663279950618744,
-0.03417292609810829,
0.16707375645637512,
0.9242725968360901,
0.894551694393158,
-0.6459628939628601,
0.14029499888420105,
-0.17548684775829315,
-0.06227930635213852,
-0.07803979516029358,
-0.08571256697177887,
0.5198161602020264,
-0.21638056635856628,
-0.6467052698135376,
0.17469213902950287,
0.4824945032596588,
-0.03328412026166916,
-0.03616956248879433,
-0.23245231807231903,
0.2672500014305115,
0.08415120095014572,
0.4490949809551239,
0.08205713331699371,
-0.6885095834732056,
-0.23706670105457306,
0.048753250390291214,
-0.20255595445632935,
0.3680707514286041,
0.697262704372406,
-0.7984859943389893,
0.26345422863960266,
-0.07176604866981506,
0.8848017454147339,
0.44156521558761597,
-0.1457265317440033,
0.1939367800951004,
-0.4330286383628845,
0.07807712256908417,
0.4396393597126007,
0.6664086580276489,
0.36185717582702637,
-0.6270716190338135,
0.40388917922973633,
-0.025878431275486946,
-0.7123865485191345,
-0.46157771348953247,
0.21134792268276215,
-1.132574439048767,
-0.19847339391708374,
1.1595776081085205,
-0.20320925116539001,
-0.3551519215106964,
-0.019672220572829247,
-0.3895953893661499,
0.3561055362224579,
-0.19329407811164856,
0.928717851638794,
0.30832022428512573,
-0.2816579341888428,
-0.19766651093959808,
-0.5886983871459961,
0.23795874416828156,
0.3764510154724121,
-1.1905543804168701,
-0.23721089959144592,
0.2216964215040207,
0.5878112316131592,
-0.08157073706388474,
0.6217915415763855,
-0.2983970642089844,
0.2803780138492584,
-0.4226665198802948,
0.055766522884368896,
0.0614812858402729,
-0.13816222548484802,
-0.48449867963790894,
-0.11555951833724976,
0.2622687816619873,
-0.1491849720478058
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.02338v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.02338v1
|
Linguistic Fingerprint in Transformer Models: How Language Variation Influences Parameter Selection in Irony Detection
| 2024-06-04T14:09:36 | 2024-06-04T14:09:36 |
Michele Mastromattei, Fabio Massimo Zanzotto
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
This paper explores the correlation between linguistic diversity, sentiment
analysis and transformer model architectures. We aim to investigate how
different English variations impact transformer-based models for irony
detection. To conduct our study, we used the EPIC corpus to extract five
diverse English variation-specific datasets and applied the KEN pruning
algorithm on five different architectures. Our results reveal several
similarities between optimal subnetworks, which provide insights into the
linguistic variations that share strong resemblances and those that exhibit
greater dissimilarities. We discovered that optimal subnetworks across models
share at least 60% of their parameters, emphasizing the significance of
parameter values in capturing and interpreting linguistic variations. This
study highlights the inherent structural similarities between models trained on
different variants of the same language and also the critical role of parameter
values in capturing these nuances.
|
[
-0.6198104619979858,
-0.35479435324668884,
0.3268594443798065,
0.21808628737926483,
-0.26002246141433716,
0.10450109094381332,
0.13257282972335815,
-0.5936716794967651,
0.3737269639968872,
0.3690284788608551,
-0.453496515750885,
-0.3518015742301941,
-0.5901330709457397,
0.3941660523414612,
-0.21293823421001434,
0.8905319571495056,
0.05464894324541092,
-0.04793442413210869,
0.11778084933757782,
-0.41956692934036255,
-0.049055710434913635,
-0.33089679479599,
-0.49447908997535706,
-0.29181525111198425,
0.741222620010376,
0.31170153617858887,
0.7810761332511902,
0.5010285973548889,
0.5418658256530762,
0.30853500962257385,
-0.2783127725124359,
-0.24518367648124695,
-0.18627552688121796,
0.2829682528972626,
-0.23668256402015686,
-0.8706883788108826,
0.03470746427774429,
-0.008135172538459301,
0.5121706128120422,
0.6320120692253113,
0.14777369797229767,
0.27350470423698425,
-0.12806054949760437,
0.6251426339149475,
-0.7846761345863342,
-0.10737134516239166,
-0.6381950378417969,
0.048490412533283234,
-0.3741775453090668,
0.009498506784439087,
-0.3587559163570404,
-0.3038860559463501,
0.0063617173582315445,
-0.18872474133968353,
0.5654345750808716,
0.09743815660476685,
1.060416579246521,
0.4909411668777466,
-0.37946879863739014,
-0.029308676719665527,
-0.9431924819946289,
1.0383596420288086,
-0.9418123364448547,
0.34865325689315796,
-0.06837388873100281,
0.2879638373851776,
0.3113406002521515,
-0.7623823881149292,
-0.7115445137023926,
-0.14445804059505463,
-0.36247795820236206,
0.19069235026836395,
-0.4569130539894104,
0.03052203543484211,
0.2722771465778351,
0.558312714099884,
-0.36183539032936096,
0.31080570816993713,
-0.19884343445301056,
-0.008658487349748611,
0.4828309714794159,
0.3108985424041748,
0.2512907385826111,
-0.5212904214859009,
-0.20543478429317474,
-0.2675662934780121,
-0.46555978059768677,
0.43144360184669495,
1.0117566585540771,
0.05328977108001709,
-0.04357748478651047,
0.0433461032807827,
-0.19289912283420563,
0.2442058026790619,
-0.14747966825962067,
0.09040128439664841,
0.4184150993824005,
0.2643895149230957,
-0.08489783108234406,
-0.366029292345047,
0.8882667422294617,
0.1965755969285965,
0.31089022755622864,
0.013753226958215237,
-0.2510916590690613,
0.009346811100840569,
0.33311542868614197,
-0.4398702383041382,
-0.3702474534511566,
0.15388797223567963,
-0.5362838506698608,
-0.4897861182689667,
0.2692112326622009,
-0.9735389947891235,
-0.40425798296928406,
-0.03940693289041519,
-0.02307477407157421,
-0.413745641708374,
-0.5249120593070984,
0.020587734878063202,
-0.5892897248268127,
0.4251005947589874,
-0.03693472594022751,
-0.7411061525344849,
0.13622833788394928,
0.7503001689910889,
0.5101161599159241,
0.030832897871732712,
-0.3870762288570404,
-0.009498104453086853,
-0.34486278891563416,
-0.250039666891098,
0.8402607440948486,
-0.82682204246521,
-0.32284173369407654,
-0.09410272538661957,
-0.06775370985269547,
-0.3878548741340637,
-0.7054689526557922,
0.8073230385780334,
-0.5466310977935791,
0.06352619081735611,
-0.22896504402160645,
-0.5354630351066589,
-0.45528027415275574,
0.08887577801942825,
-1.4676544666290283,
1.337073802947998,
0.2803833782672882,
-1.4285790920257568,
0.17106999456882477,
-0.6064064502716064,
-0.6042317748069763,
0.29085803031921387,
-0.3803873360157013,
-0.6854618787765503,
0.638688862323761,
0.04960284382104874,
0.3470197021961212,
-0.40365225076675415,
-0.08823004364967346,
-0.2880653440952301,
-0.3213363289833069,
0.4358137845993042,
-0.43471792340278625,
0.9486207962036133,
0.16694536805152893,
-0.6999968886375427,
-0.26835545897483826,
-0.7657293081283569,
-0.1857825070619583,
0.2743558883666992,
-0.14005164802074432,
-0.5387270450592041,
0.27131935954093933,
0.18536217510700226,
0.15389908850193024,
0.1026795506477356,
-0.6535596251487732,
-0.20458921790122986,
-0.5153540372848511,
0.24440720677375793,
0.522379457950592,
0.09376418590545654,
-0.057790640741586685,
-0.33091557025909424,
1.001857876777649,
0.34906721115112305,
0.48431506752967834,
0.0291848573833704,
-0.619584321975708,
-0.7947555184364319,
-0.3586116433143616,
0.32686179876327515,
0.7742322087287903,
-0.5716212391853333,
0.39834359288215637,
-0.3043265640735626,
-0.5385453701019287,
-1.1116150617599487,
-0.16778530180454254,
0.38853198289871216,
0.2766771912574768,
0.10973825305700302,
-0.342297226190567,
-0.6115480065345764,
-1.4318064451217651,
-0.7101898193359375,
-0.21600618958473206,
0.02237960509955883,
0.5164410471916199,
0.5036052465438843,
0.21251721680164337,
1.1088775396347046,
-0.2698574662208557,
0.0556812584400177,
-0.5212440490722656,
0.4373438358306885,
0.4484160840511322,
0.1674559861421585,
0.8901649713516235,
-1.1661772727966309,
-0.8664079308509827,
0.04735686630010605,
-0.3793914318084717,
-0.14392191171646118,
0.09094060957431793,
0.31489017605781555,
0.044776324182748795,
0.39821717143058777,
-0.43973687291145325,
0.5021340250968933,
0.5752773284912109,
0.04815596714615822,
0.7646504044532776,
0.41226547956466675,
0.34812474250793457,
-1.1945523023605347,
0.18418730795383453,
-0.22211432456970215,
0.09402783215045929,
-0.7463909387588501,
0.2653488516807556,
-0.06417550146579742,
0.33383309841156006,
-0.5989671349525452,
0.26418760418891907,
-0.1562460958957672,
0.15220259130001068,
-0.05360611155629158,
-0.4528123438358307,
0.03024235926568508,
0.3822621703147888,
-0.24275948107242584,
0.5626751184463501,
0.38109177350997925,
0.00310501828789711,
0.22129535675048828,
-0.23057572543621063,
-0.4370747208595276,
0.5773715376853943,
-0.7663268446922302,
0.12540218234062195,
-0.17236413061618805,
0.07907994836568832,
-1.43017578125,
-0.050525564700365067,
-0.05543006956577301,
-0.490601509809494,
0.1064663678407669,
-0.2930300831794739,
-0.42208006978034973,
-0.4701716899871826,
-0.559933066368103,
0.3378148674964905,
0.6287052631378174,
-0.42315882444381714,
1.112325668334961,
-0.029422923922538757,
-0.22457392513751984,
-0.9184891581535339,
-0.5238840579986572,
-0.1612040251493454,
-0.46603137254714966,
-0.4875347912311554,
0.11885648220777512,
0.00890291202813387,
-0.34295955300331116,
-0.03143146261572838,
0.04250485822558403,
0.036981094628572464,
0.2132989764213562,
0.3403628170490265,
0.029585933312773705,
-0.45158177614212036,
-0.20835794508457184,
0.2077757865190506,
-0.12341314554214478,
0.11282044649124146,
-0.02886315807700157,
0.5226580500602722,
-0.028315585106611252,
-0.23970942199230194,
-0.5725452303886414,
0.8528183102607727,
0.8036383986473083,
-0.2945398688316345,
0.9438084959983826,
0.590964674949646,
0.08209241926670074,
-0.3828354775905609,
-0.6674948930740356,
-0.23503033816814423,
-0.5068334341049194,
0.30643749237060547,
-0.6169258952140808,
-0.9780263900756836,
1.0993013381958008,
-0.1387978196144104,
0.05023080110549927,
0.7512015104293823,
0.3780229985713959,
-0.3927169740200043,
1.0568143129348755,
0.913834273815155,
-0.41080695390701294,
0.4973488450050354,
-0.06243383511900902,
0.39920946955680847,
-0.8043365478515625,
0.2876000702381134,
-0.8911150693893433,
-0.8147631883621216,
-0.8793203830718994,
0.08350635319948196,
0.1756742000579834,
-0.04754091054201126,
0.0013425803044810891,
0.049358006566762924,
-0.4273284673690796,
0.7008439302444458,
0.6636666059494019,
-0.12090768665075302,
-0.010609319433569908,
-0.04763885587453842,
-0.4705148935317993,
-0.34946736693382263,
-0.5633848309516907,
-0.44922563433647156,
0.9100767970085144,
0.33355921506881714,
0.49700653553009033,
0.004585699178278446,
0.6883951425552368,
0.07432682812213898,
0.4125990867614746,
-0.5713540315628052,
0.334059476852417,
-0.5857033729553223,
-0.717816174030304,
0.030091239139437675,
-0.4508325457572937,
-0.860567569732666,
0.0764252245426178,
0.23940065503120422,
-0.7416555881500244,
0.4745408296585083,
0.1797831952571869,
-0.16830475628376007,
0.5303429365158081,
-0.6481125950813293,
0.7867656946182251,
0.2870801091194153,
0.25374847650527954,
0.13756734132766724,
-1.0647542476654053,
0.14881423115730286,
0.07957540452480316,
0.3387681245803833,
0.035225581377744675,
0.28449127078056335,
0.6115211248397827,
0.014021511189639568,
1.1389003992080688,
-0.08923306316137314,
-0.06322837620973587,
0.16628290712833405,
0.2742394208908081,
0.6165095567703247,
-0.2993339002132416,
-0.25112977623939514,
0.45267683267593384,
-0.3506241738796234,
-0.25687992572784424,
-0.507442057132721,
0.3542480170726776,
-1.0408365726470947,
-0.5865710377693176,
0.13249647617340088,
-0.567730188369751,
-0.03185870125889778,
-0.12805995345115662,
0.7546098828315735,
0.18130908906459808,
0.02162831835448742,
0.40412551164627075,
0.6797246336936951,
-0.09235374629497528,
0.680851936340332,
0.5468241572380066,
0.38079211115837097,
-0.3360733985900879,
0.5384125113487244,
0.09819527715444565,
0.2945921719074249,
0.6967100501060486,
0.32315710186958313,
-0.006519712042063475,
-0.3899870812892914,
0.025501389056444168,
0.3609091341495514,
-1.0558356046676636,
-0.046124137938022614,
-0.7742010354995728,
-0.19928836822509766,
-0.24551056325435638,
-0.23814423382282257,
-0.5436142086982727,
-0.3337266743183136,
-0.04657208174467087,
-0.12750327587127686,
0.43739253282546997,
0.6777918934822083,
0.22467321157455444,
0.45922529697418213,
-0.571291983127594,
0.028039325028657913,
0.32158398628234863,
0.3547951579093933,
0.0061047677882015705,
-0.6860321164131165,
-0.15240789949893951,
-0.39444398880004883,
-0.10696405172348022,
-1.2197151184082031,
0.10318177938461304,
0.10975245386362076,
0.6425474286079407,
0.2806028127670288,
0.21800288558006287,
0.009823624044656754,
-0.4940907657146454,
1.1486458778381348,
-0.008683540858328342,
-0.8226439952850342,
0.2858697474002838,
-0.24533917009830475,
0.27178245782852173,
0.5861701369285583,
0.5133946537971497,
-0.5359329581260681,
-0.9576375484466553,
-0.9989868998527527,
-1.1508774757385254,
0.4510175883769989,
0.1233033761382103,
0.2884824275970459,
0.1492224633693695,
0.2850435674190521,
0.36819177865982056,
0.04942138120532036,
-0.8429629802703857,
-0.5895511507987976,
-0.18554937839508057,
-0.6276103258132935,
0.04902488365769386,
-0.23420341312885284,
-0.3117579221725464,
-0.10021096467971802,
0.4461840093135834,
-0.029281752184033394,
0.21558091044425964,
0.02567809447646141,
-0.009175130166113377,
0.008809213526546955,
0.4110484719276428,
0.5724778771400452,
0.3255566954612732,
0.1961989402770996,
0.4788455665111542,
0.13954561948776245,
-0.7347865104675293,
-0.21049638092517853,
-0.0034766842145472765,
-0.1767822951078415,
0.6018668413162231,
0.4944705665111542,
1.0050722360610962,
0.0777554139494896,
-0.358434796333313,
0.4533916711807251,
0.02138786017894745,
-0.3181743919849396,
-0.1128067895770073,
0.07418693602085114,
0.16897200047969818,
0.4475630223751068,
0.5535852313041687,
0.013778520748019218,
0.36121654510498047,
0.021532472223043442,
0.12388469278812408,
0.31252723932266235,
-0.23446771502494812,
-0.6329819560050964,
0.4944704473018646,
-0.0680164024233818,
-0.5890410542488098,
0.5091148614883423,
-0.07257045060396194,
-0.9825766086578369,
0.8816161155700684,
0.17128333449363708,
1.3729112148284912,
-0.7270556688308716,
0.17660671472549438,
-0.11808823049068451,
0.6705371737480164,
0.3297273516654968,
0.524359405040741,
0.052979279309511185,
-0.7380300760269165,
-0.27791187167167664,
-0.659852147102356,
-0.4117404818534851,
0.22380103170871735,
-0.7780427932739258,
0.21357440948486328,
-0.19223906099796295,
-0.04667375981807709,
0.24212877452373505,
-0.3216467797756195,
-0.7732893824577332,
0.2617471516132355,
-0.036065537482500076,
0.5791438221931458,
-1.380881428718567,
0.660514235496521,
0.8686538338661194,
-0.22444595396518707,
-1.3788461685180664,
0.1330118179321289,
-0.11091358959674835,
-0.5386202931404114,
0.6333608627319336,
0.1286928951740265,
-0.15126143395900726,
0.2337261140346527,
-0.5528099536895752,
-0.6013364791870117,
0.7982343435287476,
0.563789427280426,
-0.431118369102478,
0.3566221296787262,
0.5657554864883423,
0.6411212086677551,
-0.2703511118888855,
0.5620702505111694,
0.70827716588974,
0.33370763063430786,
0.11360639333724976,
-0.9777592420578003,
-0.16656631231307983,
-0.48698869347572327,
0.11803010106086731,
0.5818695425987244,
-0.5465702414512634,
1.151540756225586,
0.3236837685108185,
-0.04804028198122978,
-0.2432519495487213,
0.26117217540740967,
0.06899639219045639,
0.1374249905347824,
0.8075503706932068,
0.7851855158805847,
0.30577629804611206,
0.07340320199728012,
1.0714781284332275,
-0.48814812302589417,
0.72752445936203,
0.9407551288604736,
-0.2241850048303604,
0.9567583799362183,
0.6425747871398926,
-0.3478752672672272,
0.9239959120750427,
0.4432685077190399,
0.009862350299954414,
0.24160872399806976,
-0.18354736268520355,
-0.2544553279876709,
-0.05513262748718262,
-0.041342511773109436,
-0.21853141486644745,
0.4563215970993042,
0.2009642869234085,
-0.68516606092453,
-0.18389755487442017,
-0.09172312915325165,
0.15954123437404633,
-0.09855441749095917,
0.140204057097435,
0.7271106839179993,
-0.1079251691699028,
-0.47069603204727173,
0.40620630979537964,
-0.10645321011543274,
0.7193724513053894,
-0.4677866995334625,
0.27798283100128174,
-0.6774272322654724,
0.03155607357621193,
-0.2365056276321411,
-0.584973156452179,
0.17756211757659912,
-0.19513410329818726,
-0.5472032427787781,
0.036679696291685104,
0.45301851630210876,
-0.09606742113828659,
-0.4766358435153961,
0.30086749792099,
0.13458256423473358,
0.15347401797771454,
-0.01424641627818346,
-0.7350385785102844,
0.14082030951976776,
0.021347085013985634,
-0.6734996438026428,
-0.11211638897657394,
0.5630679130554199,
-0.00219585164450109,
0.213410422205925,
0.41383805871009827,
0.07178101688623428,
0.38977688550949097,
0.35916146636009216,
0.6355746984481812,
-0.4703448712825775,
-0.8448491096496582,
-0.9158105850219727,
0.8586456775665283,
-0.2506609559059143,
-0.4627459943294525,
0.6129013299942017,
0.43682992458343506,
0.6995075941085815,
-0.32605546712875366,
0.8310643434524536,
-0.09784109145402908,
0.7096729874610901,
-0.11117342859506607,
0.5334023833274841,
-0.564384400844574,
0.2461654543876648,
-0.3598833680152893,
-0.979093074798584,
-0.26230916380882263,
0.36133649945259094,
-0.2547694444656372,
0.15853673219680786,
0.8959792256355286,
0.8786187171936035,
-0.19009007513523102,
0.20281437039375305,
0.22717301547527313,
0.1836659163236618,
0.32573676109313965,
0.36883723735809326,
0.8101229071617126,
-0.5147192478179932,
0.3480794429779053,
-0.19999246299266815,
-0.219077005982399,
-0.3332940638065338,
-0.7713147401809692,
-0.6625680923461914,
-0.6871742010116577,
-0.37249287962913513,
-0.014361237175762653,
-0.31981921195983887,
0.38577067852020264,
0.49897652864456177,
-0.8240719437599182,
-0.09291427582502365,
-0.021375400945544243,
0.17527374625205994,
-0.4658415615558624,
-0.3603206276893616,
0.29367491602897644,
-0.16920702159404755,
-0.6286084651947021,
-0.03420187905430794,
0.3642779588699341,
-0.2079814374446869,
-0.25437024235725403,
0.3006495237350464,
-0.11812416464090347,
0.5910890698432922,
0.12641781568527222,
0.21960915625095367,
-0.8566715121269226,
-0.5266513824462891,
0.15592655539512634,
-0.09608305245637894,
0.17666436731815338,
1.144677996635437,
-0.3856590688228607,
0.3311746418476105,
0.5914651155471802,
0.6826308369636536,
0.05842036381363869,
-0.21006575226783752,
0.28267908096313477,
-1.3018250465393066,
0.3849881887435913,
0.44649702310562134,
0.34805020689964294,
0.33333921432495117,
-0.49331021308898926,
0.1851271092891693,
0.5480719804763794,
-0.4136938750743866,
-0.8041924238204956,
0.5430399179458618,
-0.6997529864311218,
-0.2279316633939743,
0.9775570034980774,
-0.2643772065639496,
-0.14128337800502777,
-0.26705244183540344,
0.02515689842402935,
0.10376379638910294,
-0.011771367862820625,
0.8682531118392944,
0.8182957172393799,
-0.011440692469477654,
-0.4329363703727722,
-0.5189599394798279,
0.4656195044517517,
0.8129639625549316,
-0.5059215426445007,
-0.15040184557437897,
-0.0011328267864882946,
0.4259694814682007,
0.35327067971229553,
0.15663377940654755,
0.06315841525793076,
0.3116683065891266,
0.02108011208474636,
0.3491658866405487,
0.325775682926178,
-0.19616122543811798,
-0.32401445508003235,
0.6108323931694031,
0.02014094591140747,
-0.18812589347362518
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.02335v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.02335v1
|
Probing the Category of Verbal Aspect in Transformer Language Models
| 2024-06-04T14:06:03 | 2024-06-04T14:06:03 |
Anisia Katinskaia, Roman Yangarber
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We investigate how pretrained language models (PLM) encode the grammatical
category of verbal aspect in Russian. Encoding of aspect in transformer LMs has
not been studied previously in any language. A particular challenge is posed by
"alternative contexts": where either the perfective or the imperfective aspect
is suitable grammatically and semantically. We perform probing using BERT and
RoBERTa on alternative and non-alternative contexts. First, we assess the
models' performance on aspect prediction, via behavioral probing. Next, we
examine the models' performance when their contextual representations are
substituted with counterfactual representations, via causal probing. These
counterfactuals alter the value of the "boundedness" feature--a semantic
feature, which characterizes the action in the context. Experiments show that
BERT and RoBERTa do encode aspect--mostly in their final layers. The
counterfactual interventions affect perfective and imperfective in opposite
ways, which is consistent with grammar: perfective is positively affected by
adding the meaning of boundedness, and vice versa. The practical implications
of our probing results are that fine-tuning only the last layers of BERT on
predicting aspect is faster and more effective than fine-tuning the whole
model. The model has high predictive uncertainty about aspect in alternative
contexts, which tend to lack explicit hints about the boundedness of the
described action.
|
[
-0.323405921459198,
-1.0306010246276855,
0.5735329389572144,
0.03603455796837807,
-0.12831711769104004,
-0.249334454536438,
-0.24187105894088745,
-0.2165808230638504,
0.1809600591659546,
0.5163251161575317,
-0.8152955174446106,
-0.1303408145904541,
-0.4601585566997528,
-0.12085502594709396,
-0.4476455748081207,
1.0431376695632935,
-0.12974080443382263,
0.25605496764183044,
-0.4418049156665802,
0.0030159580055624247,
-0.4874217212200165,
-0.989734947681427,
-0.2738092839717865,
-0.7719197869300842,
0.19649100303649902,
0.19380271434783936,
0.8597851991653442,
0.2549012005329132,
0.4047251343727112,
0.421989381313324,
-0.11747918277978897,
-0.30663466453552246,
-0.22325704991817474,
0.40115541219711304,
-0.3638911545276642,
-0.5864933729171753,
-0.5550015568733215,
0.2618466317653656,
0.7124267220497131,
0.7467362880706787,
0.020663969218730927,
0.1759730875492096,
0.06347836554050446,
0.5081862211227417,
-0.28004661202430725,
0.023357341066002846,
-0.6265892386436462,
-0.06878989934921265,
0.00501754367724061,
0.023190081119537354,
-0.5502838492393494,
0.06761502474546432,
0.19005915522575378,
-0.3894575834274292,
0.4437907338142395,
-0.09113478660583496,
1.234963059425354,
0.06135660409927368,
-0.4592542350292206,
-0.12422273308038712,
-1.0085408687591553,
0.7051000595092773,
-0.6107208728790283,
0.5841915607452393,
0.5605525374412537,
0.07994455844163895,
-0.17403928935527802,
-0.7378324270248413,
-0.7744958400726318,
-0.28145381808280945,
-0.5593635439872742,
0.09883653372526169,
-0.373884379863739,
0.3180801272392273,
0.045863255858421326,
0.40292441844940186,
-0.6196666955947876,
0.007005954626947641,
-0.20772847533226013,
-0.25502297282218933,
0.40647053718566895,
0.07713253051042557,
0.05336981639266014,
-0.4810863733291626,
0.08213362842798233,
-0.12455005198717117,
-0.6069501042366028,
0.3900347054004669,
0.47032439708709717,
0.22804318368434906,
-0.07739812880754471,
0.6421693563461304,
-0.25332605838775635,
0.7270287871360779,
0.32988014817237854,
0.2995534837245941,
0.1337413340806961,
-0.3503629267215729,
-0.34440961480140686,
-0.24641583859920502,
0.5699158906936646,
-0.0731201022863388,
-0.048233065754175186,
0.013823560439050198,
-0.2729332745075226,
0.034282136708498,
0.6522507667541504,
-0.431688517332077,
-0.08489403873682022,
0.44979149103164673,
-0.2274431437253952,
-0.040727708488702774,
0.19415469467639923,
-0.3955819308757782,
0.24548350274562836,
-0.4995705485343933,
0.7028628587722778,
-0.6920737624168396,
-0.14485716819763184,
-0.012155684642493725,
0.24853965640068054,
0.5872377157211304,
0.12573902308940887,
-0.874805748462677,
0.3098711669445038,
1.0907893180847168,
0.5017091035842896,
0.3480733633041382,
-0.5010325312614441,
-0.5276747941970825,
-0.31015169620513916,
-0.35873347520828247,
0.6949592232704163,
-0.8922603130340576,
-0.13132521510124207,
0.21987022459506989,
0.3537542223930359,
-0.11531487852334976,
-0.32250741124153137,
0.46652165055274963,
-0.5935853123664856,
0.45483362674713135,
-0.23298339545726776,
-0.5336889028549194,
-0.49615588784217834,
0.4540749788284302,
-0.4763593077659607,
1.149152398109436,
0.29232364892959595,
-0.37604281306266785,
0.46708646416664124,
-0.46813279390335083,
-0.4194694459438324,
-0.01525788102298975,
-0.08627023547887802,
-0.5874934792518616,
0.5194333791732788,
0.08141262084245682,
0.5037965774536133,
0.1103219985961914,
0.543402373790741,
0.028044443577528,
-0.06923302263021469,
0.8291885256767273,
-0.2982565760612488,
0.25652846693992615,
-0.10734447836875916,
-0.16822317242622375,
0.6007750630378723,
-0.651570737361908,
0.062091801315546036,
-0.027330119162797928,
-0.08670926094055176,
-0.3784600496292114,
0.046215057373046875,
-0.02850324660539627,
0.30989426374435425,
0.2307586669921875,
-0.7891023755073547,
0.0012879014248028398,
-0.5967851281166077,
0.4436957538127899,
0.623297393321991,
-0.12467189878225327,
0.7226560115814209,
-0.2813056409358978,
0.62884122133255,
0.1535222828388214,
0.5674790740013123,
-0.18973061442375183,
-0.3231130540370941,
-1.3732575178146362,
0.19629889726638794,
0.4446185529232025,
0.3615303635597229,
-0.8267180919647217,
0.47686710953712463,
-0.20469895005226135,
-0.3544267416000366,
-0.8411406874656677,
-0.2867836058139801,
0.5587044358253479,
0.19210989773273468,
0.1612175703048706,
-0.309513658285141,
-0.5630521178245544,
-1.127530574798584,
-0.23748590052127838,
-0.1788548231124878,
0.16044753789901733,
0.26923853158950806,
0.7813292145729065,
0.03436652943491936,
1.069930911064148,
-0.24544598162174225,
-0.13793861865997314,
-0.4357093572616577,
0.2905711829662323,
0.3417190611362457,
0.5094570517539978,
0.40078556537628174,
-0.9728228449821472,
-0.347441703081131,
-0.06530679017305374,
-0.4071004390716553,
0.07295406609773636,
-0.1699163019657135,
0.16615301370620728,
0.40208297967910767,
0.18576867878437042,
-0.627324640750885,
0.40559765696525574,
0.7011331915855408,
-0.5375381112098694,
0.4492632746696472,
-0.47867199778556824,
0.1006958931684494,
-0.6614851951599121,
-0.1336473673582077,
-0.21261952817440033,
-0.2993190884590149,
-1.2961812019348145,
0.4047824442386627,
0.2951032221317291,
-0.15871547162532806,
-0.5429338812828064,
0.2422533482313156,
-0.3341095745563507,
-0.16879278421401978,
-0.20279820263385773,
-0.036292172968387604,
-0.008906708098948002,
0.5302048921585083,
0.317666620016098,
0.5530067682266235,
0.6102696657180786,
-0.48138627409935,
-0.047624047845602036,
0.01867837831377983,
-0.18483084440231323,
0.609394907951355,
-0.6296151280403137,
0.36462920904159546,
-0.43513596057891846,
0.134515181183815,
-0.9774418473243713,
-0.1437312215566635,
0.06683077663183212,
-0.6225871443748474,
0.5267671942710876,
-0.1052369549870491,
-0.3695598542690277,
-0.22303345799446106,
-0.22822901606559753,
0.37124013900756836,
0.6406494975090027,
-0.2768803536891937,
0.8633123636245728,
0.009115459397435188,
0.020650459453463554,
-0.44962772727012634,
-0.6431421637535095,
-0.07148768752813339,
-0.1741405725479126,
-0.5532484650611877,
0.451943963766098,
0.15007558465003967,
-0.2543717920780182,
0.09854146838188171,
-0.16393162310123444,
-0.12940065562725067,
-0.1559380292892456,
0.3445947468280792,
0.3401898741722107,
-0.34585514664649963,
-0.17637179791927338,
0.07819018512964249,
-0.04743904992938042,
0.07653667777776718,
-0.1244644969701767,
0.8116962909698486,
-0.3314209580421448,
-0.4029591977596283,
-0.28494957089424133,
0.3678160607814789,
0.2706160545349121,
-0.2875426411628723,
0.8584613800048828,
0.4712505340576172,
-0.2585524916648865,
0.07307184487581253,
-0.7269805669784546,
-0.17010749876499176,
-0.5334345698356628,
0.3883242905139923,
-0.575257420539856,
-0.9854906797409058,
0.8304011225700378,
0.39331671595573425,
-0.37882697582244873,
0.5066702365875244,
0.20890392363071442,
-0.09520542621612549,
0.7197195887565613,
0.8400405645370483,
0.29707059264183044,
0.4310210049152374,
-0.37011560797691345,
0.2624298334121704,
-1.0348989963531494,
-0.29864776134490967,
-0.484715074300766,
-0.18660753965377808,
-0.7150477170944214,
-0.38241344690322876,
0.4018879532814026,
0.12175300717353821,
-0.09631854295730591,
0.5238056778907776,
-0.30276110768318176,
0.3869899809360504,
0.5660074949264526,
0.1407095342874527,
0.1528007686138153,
-0.42811304330825806,
0.05995327606797218,
-0.46336960792541504,
-0.7217404842376709,
-0.43011564016342163,
0.8702489137649536,
0.42548608779907227,
0.5319566130638123,
0.12201841920614243,
0.45238205790519714,
-0.24393139779567719,
0.37403300404548645,
-0.9863846302032471,
0.5313609838485718,
-0.3540636897087097,
-0.8095602989196777,
-0.22750738263130188,
-0.06794267892837524,
-0.7972598671913147,
0.37187233567237854,
-0.14645111560821533,
-0.6994993686676025,
0.3247356712818146,
0.16746971011161804,
-0.17207513749599457,
0.11752381175756454,
-0.5087488889694214,
0.8127338886260986,
-0.09658203274011612,
-0.3554612994194031,
-0.27730369567871094,
-0.6106339693069458,
0.10237302631139755,
-0.04439634084701538,
0.2913493812084198,
0.27306613326072693,
0.09656184911727905,
0.5657311081886292,
-0.41867274045944214,
1.109148383140564,
-0.03312002867460251,
-0.0947984829545021,
0.1484212875366211,
0.40286147594451904,
0.4691845178604126,
-0.08078200370073318,
0.22426550090312958,
0.22119766473770142,
0.04236825555562973,
-0.31419679522514343,
-0.7112371325492859,
0.5634651780128479,
-0.7668774127960205,
-0.9112196564674377,
-0.670617938041687,
-0.5188322067260742,
-0.22509418427944183,
0.021337386220693588,
0.35134372115135193,
0.5068255662918091,
-0.3320150077342987,
0.12406938523054123,
0.4065079391002655,
-0.2500244677066803,
0.5895633101463318,
1.0912268161773682,
-0.2093632072210312,
-0.13289546966552734,
0.5902085304260254,
0.2419523298740387,
0.42916497588157654,
0.7029154300689697,
0.16676650941371918,
-0.21902188658714294,
-0.5322791337966919,
-0.1628698706626892,
0.3162892460823059,
-0.6847278475761414,
-0.004471719730645418,
-0.4355456531047821,
-0.595999538898468,
-0.4424026906490326,
-0.038577280938625336,
-0.6493726968765259,
-0.3821635842323303,
-0.18773365020751953,
-0.03847052529454231,
0.19233956933021545,
1.0537551641464233,
0.026967382058501244,
0.46408697962760925,
-0.5221476554870605,
-0.169960156083107,
0.2989603877067566,
0.40438514947891235,
-0.15010227262973785,
-0.9468188881874084,
-0.10508210957050323,
-0.018012240529060364,
-0.447138249874115,
-0.7112629413604736,
0.37215515971183777,
0.3529382050037384,
0.4738289713859558,
0.1568949818611145,
-0.010943141765892506,
0.5725180506706238,
-0.7323789000511169,
1.1550683975219727,
-0.15128174424171448,
-1.3038263320922852,
0.6709168553352356,
-0.2512083351612091,
0.4023573100566864,
0.20694082975387573,
0.42262279987335205,
-0.6646842956542969,
-0.6161575317382812,
-0.753422737121582,
-0.6609479784965515,
1.008280634880066,
0.4111742079257965,
0.5112433433532715,
0.087614044547081,
0.49045103788375854,
0.41426512598991394,
0.008745985105633736,
-1.0216073989868164,
-0.37807580828666687,
-0.5153948664665222,
0.11306740343570709,
-0.2894629240036011,
-0.6272711753845215,
0.12859220802783966,
-0.3759942054748535,
0.6031006574630737,
0.20282402634620667,
0.2668260633945465,
0.38127270340919495,
-0.13583265244960785,
0.03484674543142319,
0.6630935668945312,
0.9557708501815796,
0.648235559463501,
-0.23430193960666656,
0.3020012676715851,
0.10888832062482834,
-0.4655766487121582,
0.22348593175411224,
-0.017061574384570122,
-0.14157751202583313,
0.2071521133184433,
0.5791260004043579,
1.0153026580810547,
0.214887335896492,
-0.26643314957618713,
0.5619519352912903,
0.11921913176774979,
-0.2984514534473419,
-0.5654425024986267,
-0.19075146317481995,
-0.25687113404273987,
0.24551349878311157,
0.1816289722919464,
-0.13604897260665894,
-0.014710755087435246,
-0.7584249973297119,
0.09416818618774414,
0.4574400782585144,
-0.6643291711807251,
-0.9602228403091431,
0.3699319660663605,
-0.0194232277572155,
-0.6205592155456543,
0.3560043275356293,
-0.34874388575553894,
-0.8965075016021729,
0.41615647077560425,
0.741146981716156,
0.8437080383300781,
-0.6243907809257507,
0.3262546956539154,
0.205112487077713,
0.5453658103942871,
0.23278769850730896,
0.38426145911216736,
0.05294908955693245,
-0.944567859172821,
-0.6678751707077026,
-0.6143067479133606,
-0.27752846479415894,
0.5478224158287048,
-0.9049522876739502,
0.13594603538513184,
-0.14989474415779114,
-0.1415918469429016,
-0.1268230825662613,
-0.4325770437717438,
-0.6597920656204224,
0.3351731300354004,
-0.21163572371006012,
0.3956519067287445,
-0.9201096892356873,
1.0356773138046265,
0.993621826171875,
-0.30913543701171875,
-0.5318368077278137,
0.034728843718767166,
-0.23610804975032806,
-0.7758297920227051,
0.8009881973266602,
-0.017623472958803177,
0.11815986782312393,
-0.3524831235408783,
-0.19332343339920044,
-1.1201567649841309,
0.6037283539772034,
0.2503388524055481,
-0.38401755690574646,
0.04235588014125824,
0.5438850522041321,
0.7411354184150696,
-0.26325321197509766,
0.3378106355667114,
0.6130067110061646,
0.3595450818538666,
0.019316423684358597,
-1.2318525314331055,
0.11448239535093307,
-0.21775904297828674,
0.1880621314048767,
0.4293423295021057,
-0.6094644069671631,
0.9763522148132324,
0.22991514205932617,
-0.07303456962108612,
-0.011334113776683807,
0.6446405649185181,
-0.48000234365463257,
0.04322592914104462,
0.4092540144920349,
0.3583832383155823,
0.16255338490009308,
-0.2669857442378998,
1.0376598834991455,
-0.1767788827419281,
0.48140832781791687,
1.0570496320724487,
0.04768626019358635,
0.9653406739234924,
0.615851640701294,
-0.4176066815853119,
0.5247213244438171,
0.5795276761054993,
0.2975786030292511,
0.6448900699615479,
0.027961933985352516,
-0.08760766685009003,
-0.2447439581155777,
-0.17130804061889648,
-0.23612026870250702,
0.7839850187301636,
0.49833711981773376,
-0.3058865964412689,
-0.019858919084072113,
0.2398519515991211,
0.09923890233039856,
0.17148549854755402,
-0.310612291097641,
0.850990891456604,
0.007626629900187254,
-0.9655215740203857,
0.5282655358314514,
0.13717959821224213,
0.6286863684654236,
-0.6928901672363281,
0.1275329291820526,
-0.4025365114212036,
0.10624098777770996,
-0.15113578736782074,
-0.8543373942375183,
0.5712026953697205,
-0.2365400642156601,
-0.1592339277267456,
-0.4068313539028168,
0.6334263682365417,
-0.5950695276260376,
-0.4275161623954773,
0.1416935920715332,
0.3185102939605713,
0.16213524341583252,
-0.038483209908008575,
-0.3935864567756653,
-0.07254818826913834,
-0.10486412793397903,
-0.27175047993659973,
0.2978559136390686,
0.4111551344394684,
0.1356087028980255,
0.41572850942611694,
0.10137597471475601,
0.12115413695573807,
-0.06925927847623825,
0.21790510416030884,
0.7621644735336304,
-0.6571032404899597,
-0.511221706867218,
-0.9042526483535767,
0.7327823042869568,
0.253274530172348,
-0.36410579085350037,
0.7130326628684998,
0.40146350860595703,
0.9829347729682922,
-0.09482021629810333,
0.27948904037475586,
-0.06765727698802948,
0.13862670958042145,
-0.800243079662323,
0.543429970741272,
-0.3373664617538452,
-0.011411072686314583,
-0.11373016238212585,
-0.8250213861465454,
-0.040581557899713516,
0.5312038660049438,
-0.5375276207923889,
-0.018574941903352737,
1.005741834640503,
0.7050079703330994,
-0.25928613543510437,
0.1284082680940628,
0.547080934047699,
0.33194994926452637,
0.23698246479034424,
0.3533998429775238,
0.9691244959831238,
-0.5631481409072876,
0.21626466512680054,
-0.6023225784301758,
-0.21034808456897736,
0.07708144932985306,
-0.8019453287124634,
-1.0322489738464355,
-1.149121880531311,
-0.2611834704875946,
-0.17402303218841553,
-0.07359321415424347,
0.6895862817764282,
0.7770423889160156,
-0.8907385468482971,
-0.16719810664653778,
-0.055549606680870056,
-0.16727565228939056,
-0.14341667294502258,
-0.24572190642356873,
0.28407081961631775,
-0.45869502425193787,
-0.660609781742096,
0.275927871465683,
0.10385759174823761,
0.09655731916427612,
-0.413521945476532,
0.18099148571491241,
-0.16485261917114258,
0.13032279908657074,
0.6463826894760132,
-0.15359719097614288,
-1.0807255506515503,
-0.8301638960838318,
0.19654150307178497,
0.4064032733440399,
0.11746224761009216,
0.9901503920555115,
-0.551071047782898,
0.49868088960647583,
0.3410066068172455,
0.27252185344696045,
0.7055141925811768,
-0.14802736043930054,
0.7699502110481262,
-1.1632102727890015,
0.3922683596611023,
0.21756218373775482,
0.4141859710216522,
0.34903693199157715,
-0.4303651452064514,
0.14768695831298828,
0.001183980144560337,
-0.5261340141296387,
-0.6517791748046875,
0.48978835344314575,
-0.7410533428192139,
-0.3986157178878784,
1.0867869853973389,
-0.20023082196712494,
-0.25508445501327515,
-0.04537653177976608,
0.06171858683228493,
0.16466981172561646,
-0.20576393604278564,
0.5174712538719177,
1.1643255949020386,
-0.40937861800193787,
-0.08506553620100021,
-0.6051530838012695,
0.4434936046600342,
0.8602696657180786,
-0.3542540967464447,
-0.09738118201494217,
0.21466273069381714,
0.16227968037128448,
0.2630659341812134,
0.33508530259132385,
0.0723985806107521,
0.10879956930875778,
-0.04691934585571289,
-0.0649782344698906,
-0.011160393245518208,
-0.2520759105682373,
-0.7571226358413696,
-0.07212955504655838,
0.13931891322135925,
-0.21672114729881287
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.06580v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.06580v1
|
Break the Chain: Large Language Models Can be Shortcut Reasoners
| 2024-06-04T14:02:53 | 2024-06-04T14:02:53 |
Mengru Ding, Hanmeng Liu, Zhizhang Fu, Jian Song, Wenbo Xie, Yue Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Recent advancements in Chain-of-Thought (CoT) reasoning utilize complex
modules but are hampered by high token consumption, limited applicability, and
challenges in reproducibility. This paper conducts a critical evaluation of CoT
prompting, extending beyond arithmetic to include complex logical and
commonsense reasoning tasks, areas where standard CoT methods fall short. We
propose the integration of human-like heuristics and shortcuts into language
models (LMs) through "break the chain" strategies. These strategies disrupt
traditional CoT processes using controlled variables to assess their efficacy.
Additionally, we develop innovative zero-shot prompting strategies that
encourage the use of shortcuts, enabling LMs to quickly exploit reasoning clues
and bypass detailed procedural steps. Our comprehensive experiments across
various LMs, both commercial and open-source, reveal that LMs maintain
effective performance with "break the chain" strategies. We also introduce
ShortcutQA, a dataset specifically designed to evaluate reasoning through
shortcuts, compiled from competitive tests optimized for heuristic reasoning
tasks such as forward/backward reasoning and simplification. Our analysis
confirms that ShortcutQA not only poses a robust challenge to LMs but also
serves as an essential benchmark for enhancing reasoning efficiency in AI.
|
[
-0.41873958706855774,
-0.9398489594459534,
1.007824420928955,
-0.16706611216068268,
-0.2717750668525696,
0.5005272030830383,
-0.3076203763484955,
-0.27024492621421814,
-0.21734832227230072,
0.45800989866256714,
-0.6532851457595825,
-0.29423120617866516,
-0.42362913489341736,
0.200484037399292,
-0.38559481501579285,
0.8097707629203796,
-0.2301393300294876,
-0.2580595314502716,
-0.08118017017841339,
-0.16549009084701538,
-0.7405951619148254,
-0.591703474521637,
-0.5383179187774658,
-0.2825811803340912,
0.9459971785545349,
0.5614048838615417,
1.0661406517028809,
0.5692422986030579,
0.29018840193748474,
0.21656115353107452,
-0.3731606900691986,
0.3022401034832001,
-0.2792344093322754,
-0.020021893084049225,
-0.7252480387687683,
-0.5316900014877319,
-0.22797800600528717,
-0.08830160647630692,
0.24510835111141205,
0.7990996241569519,
-0.08286835253238678,
0.12050329893827438,
-0.21140506863594055,
0.7306984663009644,
-0.9139710068702698,
-0.25296032428741455,
-0.7546643614768982,
-0.29512184858322144,
-0.1709892302751541,
-0.002780043287202716,
-0.5649953484535217,
-0.4746687114238739,
0.07063900679349899,
-0.09127452969551086,
-0.13107068836688995,
0.16634102165699005,
0.7162337899208069,
0.15460914373397827,
-0.46115365624427795,
-0.485315203666687,
-0.6891480684280396,
0.8428515791893005,
-0.6940798163414001,
0.3441150486469269,
0.24118030071258545,
0.3824493885040283,
-0.2736159861087799,
-0.45013415813446045,
-0.6771446466445923,
-0.44924187660217285,
0.1680786907672882,
-0.5061036348342896,
-0.23450587689876556,
0.1600136011838913,
0.39799049496650696,
0.11929772049188614,
-0.3238144814968109,
-0.03191828355193138,
-0.5941002368927002,
0.20370596647262573,
0.4674311876296997,
0.17467373609542847,
0.5690639019012451,
-0.04309019446372986,
-0.1821984201669693,
-0.10265719145536423,
-0.8593952655792236,
0.0436662957072258,
0.21124151349067688,
0.34301310777664185,
0.2313755750656128,
0.5265942811965942,
-0.06489760428667068,
0.7815781235694885,
-0.28484416007995605,
0.044976409524679184,
-0.14290958642959595,
-0.3073645532131195,
-0.15739315748214722,
0.02511371672153473,
0.8271443247795105,
0.10478701442480087,
0.6596440672874451,
-0.16021214425563812,
-0.20033715665340424,
0.1561596393585205,
0.1295628696680069,
-0.3787035048007965,
-0.1850118488073349,
0.3978806138038635,
-0.11932893842458725,
-0.42915287613868713,
-0.29797041416168213,
-0.5709347128868103,
-0.1171342059969902,
-0.21234841644763947,
0.4522897005081177,
-0.3535608947277069,
-0.1688060611486435,
0.2899993658065796,
-0.28102585673332214,
0.04092370346188545,
0.19287678599357605,
-0.6001652479171753,
0.3215358853340149,
0.8507211208343506,
0.9277762174606323,
0.005772549659013748,
-0.30501437187194824,
-0.6488204598426819,
0.02020019106566906,
-0.5080264806747437,
0.6902157068252563,
-0.4817078411579132,
-0.3572901487350464,
-0.1402900516986847,
-0.19631031155586243,
-0.09517619013786316,
-0.6207725405693054,
0.5804953575134277,
-0.2960047721862793,
0.05568287521600723,
-0.4630100131034851,
-0.3477495312690735,
-0.0871901884675026,
0.5143886804580688,
-0.8114671111106873,
0.6781706213951111,
-0.1725449562072754,
-0.34800270199775696,
0.08211886882781982,
-0.7281633019447327,
-0.5742551684379578,
-0.13960428535938263,
-0.3238164186477661,
-0.07932350784540176,
0.14180302619934082,
0.3950001001358032,
-0.014811530709266663,
-0.8721502423286438,
0.3428455889225006,
-0.4285847246646881,
-0.2580685019493103,
0.4425268769264221,
-0.707308828830719,
0.8551086187362671,
0.11094368249177933,
-0.5364817380905151,
0.13949772715568542,
-0.5480160117149353,
0.218373104929924,
0.3131544291973114,
-0.005591961555182934,
-0.3405918776988983,
0.041515931487083435,
-0.3778621554374695,
0.6320347189903259,
-0.03004005178809166,
-0.10997661203145981,
0.396074503660202,
-0.3625905513763428,
0.6279478669166565,
0.8930943012237549,
0.1043953001499176,
0.2072562575340271,
-0.15159104764461517,
0.7173842787742615,
-0.04225875809788704,
0.422922283411026,
-0.13605007529258728,
-0.40321990847587585,
-0.744472324848175,
-0.18631723523139954,
0.30828872323036194,
0.40476417541503906,
-0.8399438261985779,
0.262091726064682,
0.07242271304130554,
-0.5074625015258789,
-0.5922404527664185,
0.20565997064113617,
0.681158185005188,
0.5439819693565369,
0.47020676732063293,
-0.013346339575946331,
-0.09549589455127716,
-0.6180056929588318,
-0.6714615821838379,
-0.2172626405954361,
0.1728476583957672,
0.09416552633047104,
0.5610244870185852,
-0.025470644235610962,
0.8202709555625916,
-0.6351568102836609,
0.3159681260585785,
-0.7429388165473938,
0.3030746281147003,
0.3521782159805298,
0.24177345633506775,
0.0936347022652626,
-0.469480037689209,
-0.11812550574541092,
-0.3451385796070099,
-0.6562758088111877,
0.09014109522104263,
-0.2782907485961914,
-0.36406975984573364,
-0.09115595370531082,
0.47694090008735657,
-0.8530256748199463,
0.7245073914527893,
0.11190512031316757,
-0.5512219071388245,
0.9636605381965637,
-0.11993162333965302,
-0.023471703752875328,
-0.5176860690116882,
-0.012544989585876465,
-0.23390156030654907,
-0.1428479552268982,
-0.43852460384368896,
0.2093615084886551,
-0.1850317418575287,
-0.14818336069583893,
-0.6394842863082886,
0.45634615421295166,
-0.5443369746208191,
-0.044939786195755005,
-0.19821195304393768,
0.2935889959335327,
0.31157949566841125,
0.4914941191673279,
-0.05509982630610466,
0.6850323677062988,
0.38877904415130615,
-0.6554315686225891,
0.22532150149345398,
0.14579474925994873,
-0.463785856962204,
0.12913009524345398,
-0.9283627867698669,
0.4299989938735962,
0.05430837348103523,
0.36191603541374207,
-0.7268450856208801,
0.06897126138210297,
0.2038290798664093,
-0.0022849258966743946,
-0.24422825872898102,
0.02236948162317276,
-0.6452886462211609,
-0.5948939919471741,
-0.29595306515693665,
0.7800731062889099,
0.7023516893386841,
-0.7635045051574707,
0.3041492998600006,
-0.08604291826486588,
0.1550942361354828,
-0.3739214539527893,
-0.45519348978996277,
0.21698418259620667,
-0.13868559896945953,
-0.4853322505950928,
-0.07954603433609009,
-0.06409730762243271,
-0.40481483936309814,
-0.17051540315151215,
-0.23757171630859375,
0.06898321211338043,
0.15528281033039093,
-0.14647334814071655,
0.4126579165458679,
-0.05137654021382332,
0.09351936727762222,
0.1435503214597702,
-0.06929989159107208,
0.17840026319026947,
-0.2614189386367798,
0.599471390247345,
-0.29850178956985474,
-0.41618528962135315,
-0.5738627314567566,
0.2544104754924774,
0.9498724341392517,
-0.38619592785835266,
0.7710678577423096,
-0.07797975838184357,
-0.2313266545534134,
-0.24810218811035156,
-0.4077969491481781,
-0.2853991687297821,
-0.4769229590892792,
-0.05308710038661957,
-0.44531771540641785,
-0.5081964731216431,
0.1399444192647934,
-0.5557441711425781,
-0.189434215426445,
0.1668490767478943,
0.4404592216014862,
-0.04824145883321762,
1.2526354789733887,
0.19061166048049927,
0.028704658150672913,
0.09980996698141098,
-0.35640743374824524,
0.7267168760299683,
-0.6874372959136963,
-0.08615685254335403,
-0.5709285736083984,
-0.21743962168693542,
-0.25867512822151184,
-0.6608028411865234,
0.3739863336086273,
0.6069150567054749,
-0.39813631772994995,
0.33226388692855835,
-0.42586830258369446,
0.9639896154403687,
0.3405035734176636,
-0.0208321213722229,
0.31796640157699585,
-0.43241050839424133,
-0.4378614127635956,
0.44391709566116333,
-0.8835816979408264,
-0.5987069010734558,
0.7086065411567688,
0.3958810865879059,
0.7841924428939819,
0.10437741875648499,
0.5951864719390869,
0.3062182664871216,
0.01789741776883602,
-0.8832983374595642,
0.6562084555625916,
0.009800378233194351,
-0.5838195085525513,
-0.35119450092315674,
-0.39066436886787415,
-0.6600192785263062,
0.06623934954404831,
0.1708824187517166,
-1.042258858680725,
0.23898275196552277,
0.33854058384895325,
-0.4614517390727997,
0.3910105526447296,
-0.6210353970527649,
0.9711768627166748,
-0.6072278022766113,
-0.41212859749794006,
-0.24420103430747986,
-0.5917732119560242,
0.5396430492401123,
0.2611798346042633,
0.5175405740737915,
-0.2428038865327835,
0.2146017849445343,
0.6072643995285034,
-1.118016004562378,
0.708764374256134,
0.08616770058870316,
-0.09870802611112595,
0.6761099696159363,
0.44483447074890137,
0.779404878616333,
-0.33383113145828247,
0.09536615759134293,
0.10339270532131195,
0.016249999403953552,
-0.4329671859741211,
-0.9018464088439941,
0.4526766240596771,
-0.5182738304138184,
-0.6574190258979797,
-0.33212944865226746,
-0.3271379768848419,
-0.3417496085166931,
0.05850060284137726,
0.24251067638397217,
0.5157449841499329,
0.12535429000854492,
-0.1792164444923401,
0.4007309675216675,
-0.17570410668849945,
0.45277103781700134,
-0.05914312228560448,
-0.25678107142448425,
-0.49608179926872253,
0.9875602722167969,
-0.06915666908025742,
0.779995858669281,
0.07958914339542389,
0.5871399641036987,
-0.41849857568740845,
-0.10003195703029633,
-0.5228033065795898,
0.23967091739177704,
-0.9077584743499756,
-0.12411424517631531,
-0.38314110040664673,
-0.17454203963279724,
0.025126514956355095,
-0.4292430281639099,
-0.47844424843788147,
-0.6016753911972046,
-0.06713061779737473,
-0.22536779940128326,
0.1899069994688034,
0.7313596606254578,
0.09784707427024841,
0.15994131565093994,
-0.8228471875190735,
0.38751739263534546,
0.4683931767940521,
0.07226758450269699,
0.5101436376571655,
-0.0186461228877306,
-0.19533118605613708,
-0.14301525056362152,
-0.3245414197444916,
-1.1027878522872925,
0.15250496566295624,
-0.23733389377593994,
0.29030048847198486,
0.4553915560245514,
0.21756622195243835,
0.8307832479476929,
-0.5191776156425476,
0.8947100043296814,
0.5679858922958374,
-1.455095887184143,
0.7289242148399353,
-0.2351710945367813,
0.5036197304725647,
0.7022581696510315,
0.4329442083835602,
-0.5242521166801453,
-0.38445526361465454,
-0.5570030808448792,
-0.9581092596054077,
0.44377371668815613,
0.2352386862039566,
-0.3412594497203827,
-0.4532369077205658,
0.16971369087696075,
-0.0673927515745163,
0.1901455819606781,
-0.37202656269073486,
0.11000629514455795,
0.24933446943759918,
-0.15770405530929565,
0.23192591965198517,
-0.20075435936450958,
-0.06373099237680435,
-0.4026196300983429,
0.41479429602622986,
-0.12426283210515976,
-0.13534805178642273,
0.06252660602331161,
-0.27579930424690247,
-0.04432011395692825,
0.6653090715408325,
0.5732282400131226,
0.9474327564239502,
-0.1259360909461975,
0.24423512816429138,
0.1734737604856491,
0.01308449637144804,
0.3676503896713257,
-0.6582112312316895,
-0.13490869104862213,
0.0109400087967515,
0.5613133311271667,
0.8147440552711487,
0.23041565716266632,
-1.0518258810043335,
0.36877983808517456,
-0.02706395834684372,
-0.08091773092746735,
0.0888453871011734,
0.24715909361839294,
-0.07387834787368774,
0.11872538179159164,
0.10234189033508301,
-0.03833099082112312,
0.051302745938301086,
-0.8934391736984253,
0.06963586807250977,
0.1923987865447998,
-0.4918823838233948,
-0.2935590147972107,
0.5166904926300049,
0.3371518850326538,
-0.6707873344421387,
0.7433896660804749,
-0.14808669686317444,
-0.8199909329414368,
0.630692183971405,
0.39437785744667053,
1.0583504438400269,
-0.024032924324274063,
0.27712535858154297,
0.17583052814006805,
0.4929492473602295,
-0.3884356617927551,
0.3385099470615387,
-0.3247295320034027,
-0.5488765835762024,
-0.5952289700508118,
-0.12588955461978912,
-0.6027066111564636,
-0.03778054565191269,
-0.7707815170288086,
0.5471488237380981,
-0.7609307169914246,
-0.07399433106184006,
-0.1302732676267624,
-0.41920897364616394,
-0.6874839663505554,
0.20806001126766205,
0.031279005110263824,
1.1945180892944336,
-0.5730195641517639,
0.7668565511703491,
0.13749562203884125,
-0.754953920841217,
-0.9209740161895752,
0.30543774366378784,
0.04688388481736183,
-0.5460901260375977,
0.63298100233078,
0.213233083486557,
-0.41354674100875854,
-0.3878689110279083,
-0.6034194827079773,
-0.4844537079334259,
0.7977012395858765,
0.29106420278549194,
-1.0501863956451416,
-0.38220465183258057,
0.2014203667640686,
0.21378658711910248,
-0.24096113443374634,
0.3966343104839325,
1.1858686208724976,
0.37301892042160034,
0.28499123454093933,
-0.9267493486404419,
0.36782535910606384,
0.09225933998823166,
-0.0921287089586258,
0.4585067927837372,
-0.5649616718292236,
0.7703554630279541,
-0.6146634221076965,
0.0003297949442639947,
0.048856351524591446,
0.23693251609802246,
0.6771435737609863,
0.3890949785709381,
0.7883377075195312,
0.46242204308509827,
0.8475765585899353,
0.18619050085544586,
1.0100914239883423,
-0.11052291095256805,
0.1637369841337204,
1.317611813545227,
-0.41046905517578125,
1.0194588899612427,
0.5718413591384888,
0.07895509153604507,
0.9446430206298828,
0.17805887758731842,
0.38852450251579285,
0.6094398498535156,
0.5892522931098938,
-0.3938606083393097,
-0.5473238229751587,
-0.12054116278886795,
-0.19790148735046387,
0.4598000645637512,
0.42653730511665344,
-0.22183848917484283,
-0.26670336723327637,
-0.0037522753700613976,
0.348795086145401,
-0.03211534768342972,
-0.2767927050590515,
0.6880359649658203,
0.30295896530151367,
-0.9534128308296204,
0.9640758037567139,
-0.09977569431066513,
0.08831421285867691,
-0.3026256561279297,
-0.13119396567344666,
0.015212730504572392,
0.2012190818786621,
0.06370390206575394,
-0.5970706343650818,
0.2836768329143524,
0.41653379797935486,
0.02336340956389904,
-0.13784630596637726,
0.6568415760993958,
-0.27908992767333984,
-0.4837966561317444,
0.4109992980957031,
0.44780972599983215,
0.16626568138599396,
-0.07339619100093842,
-0.7771255373954773,
0.4029647707939148,
-0.08587136119604111,
-0.07563603669404984,
0.0761709064245224,
0.5264705419540405,
-0.31571316719055176,
0.7043655514717102,
0.808246910572052,
-0.004075274337083101,
-0.2396758645772934,
0.30476871132850647,
1.0964469909667969,
-1.228952407836914,
-0.4186019003391266,
-1.2053868770599365,
0.6439945101737976,
-0.0742419958114624,
-0.3507349491119385,
0.3547195494174957,
0.1732633262872696,
0.5320070385932922,
0.11486870050430298,
0.8430765271186829,
0.29397979378700256,
0.1286030262708664,
-0.5690949559211731,
0.5331580638885498,
-0.4574786424636841,
0.5375322699546814,
-0.3029019832611084,
-0.5968182682991028,
-0.04040532559156418,
0.29859960079193115,
-0.6316826343536377,
-0.07450060546398163,
1.075976848602295,
0.3669408857822418,
0.11244098842144012,
0.04420868679881096,
0.36355194449424744,
0.20826873183250427,
0.6854279637336731,
0.8146799206733704,
1.1002779006958008,
-0.22563660144805908,
0.7124596238136292,
-0.14735865592956543,
-0.23759905993938446,
-0.19167841970920563,
-0.9320617318153381,
-1.1566647291183472,
-0.1439153552055359,
-0.4326147735118866,
-0.5037580728530884,
0.25974899530410767,
1.2011691331863403,
0.534152626991272,
-0.5891438126564026,
-0.2644926905632019,
-0.6057286262512207,
0.7142000198364258,
-0.33022502064704895,
-0.20767293870449066,
0.2612927258014679,
-0.4562339782714844,
-0.2512754797935486,
0.5811012983322144,
0.5133402347564697,
-0.32596802711486816,
-0.43145161867141724,
-0.045684222131967545,
-0.33166760206222534,
0.6620917916297913,
0.6331698298454285,
0.5252885818481445,
-0.9521689414978027,
-0.22871577739715576,
-0.12538640201091766,
0.16804054379463196,
-0.21054691076278687,
1.1072818040847778,
-0.9418045282363892,
0.44334450364112854,
0.5745190382003784,
0.40939027070999146,
0.1292758733034134,
-0.05906921625137329,
0.7441256642341614,
-0.5437626838684082,
0.12763868272304535,
0.3954145610332489,
0.29384931921958923,
0.1709536761045456,
-0.2641508877277374,
0.41159677505493164,
0.15056343376636505,
-0.43737199902534485,
-1.113630771636963,
0.3810946047306061,
-0.6571699976921082,
-0.599189281463623,
1.0597621202468872,
-0.05412815883755684,
-0.6735230088233948,
-0.062386687844991684,
-0.21081103384494781,
0.0153420465067029,
-0.2807643711566925,
0.7091189026832581,
0.7347077131271362,
-0.17790204286575317,
-0.2966628074645996,
-0.21750231087207794,
0.41060343384742737,
0.43549519777297974,
-0.8973783850669861,
0.12400557845830917,
0.1911865472793579,
0.07054667174816132,
0.1959332525730133,
0.48538917303085327,
-0.030056875199079514,
0.4327700734138489,
-0.13151519000530243,
-0.09716925770044327,
0.04935983940958977,
-0.7702406048774719,
-0.19578078389167786,
0.13061513006687164,
0.3095184862613678,
-0.21480146050453186
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.02332v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.02332v1
|
Extended Mind Transformers
| 2024-06-04T14:00:25 | 2024-06-04T14:00:25 |
Phoebe Klett, Thomas Ahle
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Pre-trained language models demonstrate general intelligence and common
sense, but long inputs quickly become a bottleneck for memorizing information
at inference time. We resurface a simple method, Memorizing Transformers (Wu et
al., 2022), that gives the model access to a bank of pre-computed memories. We
show that it is possible to fix many of the shortcomings of the original
method, such as the need for fine-tuning, by critically assessing how
positional encodings should be updated for the keys and values retrieved. This
intuitive method uses the model's own key/query system to select and attend to
the most relevant memories at each generation step, rather than using external
embeddings. We demonstrate the importance of external information being
retrieved in a majority of decoder layers, contrary to previous work. We open
source a new counterfactual long-range retrieval benchmark, and show that
Extended Mind Transformers outperform today's state of the art by 6% on
average.
|
[
-0.6893376708030701,
-0.5668201446533203,
0.6721250414848328,
-0.3234702944755554,
-0.12478518486022949,
-0.17887915670871735,
-0.4291793704032898,
-0.44328099489212036,
0.0820022001862526,
0.738989531993866,
-0.6925057172775269,
-0.05336697772145271,
-0.5773029923439026,
-0.2618497312068939,
-0.6186770796775818,
0.8956314325332642,
0.11972598731517792,
-0.3884415924549103,
-0.18829964101314545,
-0.2739255428314209,
-0.23223425447940826,
-0.7595802545547485,
-0.5573971271514893,
-0.4685908257961273,
0.3500349521636963,
0.2610681653022766,
0.8325483798980713,
0.4047599136829376,
0.44169917702674866,
0.3005501925945282,
0.08972950279712677,
0.02486269734799862,
-0.4671132564544678,
0.00450309831649065,
-0.5277442336082458,
-0.6736992001533508,
-0.5139278173446655,
0.02127082273364067,
0.3124220371246338,
0.6523657441139221,
-0.17622579634189606,
0.11713359504938126,
-0.23769330978393555,
1.004745364189148,
-0.6583549380302429,
0.19823221862316132,
-0.7470288872718811,
0.09010060876607895,
-0.04815066605806351,
-0.12171044945716858,
-0.6739547252655029,
-0.23630815744400024,
0.3927555978298187,
-0.6079246997833252,
0.44934362173080444,
-0.02785765565931797,
0.6838245391845703,
0.4968206584453583,
-0.21380044519901276,
-0.35089388489723206,
-1.0396780967712402,
0.8717126846313477,
-0.1553024798631668,
0.6584436297416687,
0.4340377449989319,
0.5315871834754944,
-0.10216312855482101,
-1.118200421333313,
-0.6095922589302063,
-0.1577126383781433,
-0.049593351781368256,
0.3253512978553772,
-0.5210838317871094,
-0.007076209876686335,
0.577055037021637,
0.46287834644317627,
-0.12006032466888428,
-0.1922990083694458,
-0.4318666160106659,
-0.11971548199653625,
0.3124886155128479,
-0.041137609630823135,
0.1948654055595398,
0.23173928260803223,
-0.07955332845449448,
-0.46286439895629883,
-0.6910535097122192,
0.027527043595910072,
0.22875317931175232,
-0.0630561038851738,
0.2855244576931,
0.42747077345848083,
-0.2650240659713745,
0.5169913172721863,
0.2286335825920105,
0.3717697858810425,
0.2084909826517105,
-0.06669332087039948,
-0.06598125398159027,
-0.24206359684467316,
0.4260805547237396,
0.23484662175178528,
0.8228273987770081,
-0.2509309649467468,
-0.14740563929080963,
-0.1989772468805313,
0.625492513179779,
-0.716471791267395,
-0.599692165851593,
0.00885972660034895,
-0.24937741458415985,
0.4395061433315277,
-0.11935500055551529,
-0.6773614287376404,
-0.009633411653339863,
-0.4238690435886383,
0.4939640760421753,
-0.707496702671051,
-0.1915987730026245,
0.17049795389175415,
-0.2981254458427429,
0.2539603114128113,
0.271782785654068,
-1.0632097721099854,
0.31277886033058167,
0.59903883934021,
0.39918941259384155,
-0.019711529836058617,
-0.27860692143440247,
-0.2593843936920166,
0.2103351354598999,
-0.1897962987422943,
0.9944512248039246,
-0.6200372576713562,
-0.3415937125682831,
-0.20299211144447327,
-0.0473574735224247,
-0.09999839216470718,
-0.6468198299407959,
0.43150490522384644,
-0.7243440747261047,
0.355357825756073,
-0.38102173805236816,
-0.5475566387176514,
-0.26417428255081177,
0.1274622678756714,
-0.8669873476028442,
0.9363684058189392,
0.2575920522212982,
-0.5825293660163879,
0.14868564903736115,
-0.5860832333564758,
-0.43633565306663513,
-0.1850820779800415,
-0.19734670221805573,
-0.21246932446956635,
0.48220738768577576,
0.49816805124282837,
0.28440216183662415,
-0.24051594734191895,
0.2764172852039337,
-0.09119059890508652,
-0.5658058524131775,
0.22500385344028473,
-0.6273236870765686,
0.7218507528305054,
0.04174864664673805,
-0.05220508202910423,
0.0026355416048318148,
-0.7654248476028442,
0.08477763831615448,
0.11644679307937622,
-0.15616144239902496,
-0.3619329631328583,
0.13438156247138977,
-0.5327906012535095,
0.16757212579250336,
0.24589858949184418,
-0.35711371898651123,
0.17068767547607422,
-0.42038655281066895,
0.4687119126319885,
0.5585471987724304,
-0.22565707564353943,
0.48834171891212463,
-0.2709704041481018,
0.22845083475112915,
0.16467177867889404,
0.22345483303070068,
-0.5054805874824524,
-0.27048689126968384,
-1.1486554145812988,
-0.09198925644159317,
-0.026679016649723053,
0.44417476654052734,
-0.5994278192520142,
0.5193080306053162,
-0.6665819883346558,
-0.39252567291259766,
-0.6087757349014282,
0.017708268016576767,
0.16428029537200928,
0.4998500645160675,
0.8012839555740356,
-0.37483301758766174,
-0.5652011036872864,
-1.1037085056304932,
-0.5049139261245728,
-0.08771456032991409,
-0.3722778558731079,
0.34647566080093384,
0.5043895840644836,
-0.26969820261001587,
0.9636489748954773,
-0.647170901298523,
0.05611357465386391,
-0.2644726634025574,
0.01008659414947033,
0.2207966446876526,
0.34751683473587036,
0.23190130293369293,
-0.7307924628257751,
-0.07152026891708374,
-0.22604110836982727,
-0.5035300254821777,
0.39096835255622864,
-0.05857215076684952,
-0.08114266395568848,
-0.0437505841255188,
0.7311736345291138,
-1.2259513139724731,
0.3218597173690796,
0.1704007238149643,
0.03092297725379467,
0.3596598207950592,
-0.3544798791408539,
-0.15267238020896912,
-0.8283651471138,
0.20817288756370544,
-0.4642339050769806,
-0.047543060034513474,
-0.5893422365188599,
0.2902902364730835,
0.3757668733596802,
-0.038012370467185974,
-0.2900441586971283,
0.5175786018371582,
-0.4976368248462677,
0.007880671881139278,
-0.18999506533145905,
0.08647461235523224,
-0.021694231778383255,
0.7460795640945435,
0.05268937721848488,
0.7794423699378967,
0.2775748670101166,
-0.6776222586631775,
0.5233487486839294,
-0.036039065569639206,
-0.527072012424469,
0.42054733633995056,
-0.39943715929985046,
0.7355017066001892,
-0.4624369740486145,
0.3814850449562073,
-0.7626678943634033,
-0.06729362905025482,
-0.03911446034908295,
-0.34954237937927246,
0.5480542182922363,
0.053490858525037766,
-0.33134710788726807,
-0.6318149566650391,
-0.016125908121466637,
0.23720310628414154,
0.8183833956718445,
-0.7297906875610352,
0.9758836030960083,
0.27396368980407715,
0.09115628898143768,
-0.7875539064407349,
-0.4501885175704956,
-0.05441341921687126,
-0.03635866940021515,
-0.2725226581096649,
0.3600844144821167,
-0.13456399738788605,
-0.13308526575565338,
-0.06419473886489868,
-0.2920210659503937,
-0.04772081971168518,
0.07528306543827057,
0.03013540990650654,
-0.015077141113579273,
-0.18439646065235138,
0.29653722047805786,
-0.11783330142498016,
-0.24892264604568481,
0.1761416792869568,
-0.30111798644065857,
0.6893409490585327,
-0.19927872717380524,
-0.45847705006599426,
0.15509164333343506,
0.3381114900112152,
0.46358272433280945,
-0.3718680143356323,
0.5255358219146729,
0.5197142362594604,
-0.3803645074367523,
-0.24253180623054504,
-0.8456999659538269,
-0.2440505027770996,
-0.5134261846542358,
0.8251370191574097,
-0.5768907070159912,
-0.6675292253494263,
0.5112295746803284,
-0.18276380002498627,
-0.018463630229234695,
0.4717583954334259,
0.235160231590271,
-0.08116306364536285,
0.9250265955924988,
0.8966771364212036,
-0.09417839348316193,
0.43008726835250854,
-0.22396183013916016,
0.31160402297973633,
-0.8857050538063049,
-0.20012347400188446,
-0.23802904784679413,
-0.21403540670871735,
-0.2962508499622345,
-0.37245550751686096,
-0.1223595067858696,
0.26276353001594543,
-0.20139333605766296,
0.5004782676696777,
-0.3343965411186218,
0.6791620850563049,
0.7409748435020447,
0.2403317093849182,
0.3352428078651428,
-0.07196259498596191,
-0.23648978769779205,
0.014706983231008053,
-0.4352237284183502,
-0.14270180463790894,
1.206863284111023,
0.3019706904888153,
0.6643363237380981,
-0.03378107026219368,
0.4887688457965851,
-0.22545389831066132,
0.5992528200149536,
-0.9297212362289429,
0.6901319622993469,
-0.2632492184638977,
-0.7862803936004639,
-0.19017137587070465,
-0.10457474738359451,
-0.7036921977996826,
0.03164532035589218,
0.1838647872209549,
-0.6871849298477173,
0.026334570720791817,
0.3032684922218323,
-0.5900286436080933,
0.2655979096889496,
-0.9480478167533875,
0.5327872037887573,
-0.21541526913642883,
-0.20037364959716797,
-0.5376687049865723,
-0.5619660019874573,
0.24986571073532104,
-0.26525187492370605,
-0.18627476692199707,
0.149806946516037,
0.07114428281784058,
0.5856621265411377,
-0.020795755088329315,
0.559174120426178,
-0.11733996868133545,
0.013926410116255283,
0.20077580213546753,
-0.16956409811973572,
0.49303796887397766,
-0.3087271749973297,
-0.07792702317237854,
0.07764265686273575,
-0.2250785529613495,
-0.24578887224197388,
-1.0054726600646973,
0.48865416646003723,
-0.6083660125732422,
-1.1149682998657227,
-0.04269251599907875,
-0.7586214542388916,
-0.32526662945747375,
0.4495184123516083,
0.3588503301143646,
0.3657543659210205,
-0.4032890796661377,
0.5163664221763611,
0.9637355208396912,
-0.3903636932373047,
0.5315868854522705,
0.586783230304718,
-0.04212673008441925,
-0.16662321984767914,
0.6161118745803833,
0.21874092519283295,
0.22468343377113342,
0.6923062801361084,
0.030394665896892548,
-0.37276607751846313,
-0.432679146528244,
-0.1924925297498703,
-0.12132826447486877,
-1.0243678092956543,
0.059288203716278076,
-0.9080899953842163,
-0.4053249955177307,
-0.2614695727825165,
0.08090461045503616,
-0.6459590792655945,
-0.48354193568229675,
0.020869575440883636,
-0.25016969442367554,
0.312004417181015,
0.5857475996017456,
0.012527544051408768,
0.3106110692024231,
-0.7137614488601685,
0.5832544565200806,
0.6401951313018799,
0.5359076857566833,
0.1688677817583084,
-0.45806461572647095,
-0.4537545442581177,
0.03454718738794327,
-0.3417215049266815,
-0.7036423683166504,
0.2756800353527069,
0.20102709531784058,
0.6985238790512085,
0.34890905022621155,
-0.08065585792064667,
0.8458128571510315,
-0.7186073064804077,
0.4363563060760498,
-0.03154071047902107,
-0.749474823474884,
0.40474802255630493,
-0.06037863716483116,
0.6599611639976501,
0.5045995116233826,
0.40573543310165405,
-0.44219619035720825,
-0.09217537194490433,
-0.6376925706863403,
-0.8003061413764954,
0.4727664291858673,
-0.10470861196517944,
0.34801387786865234,
-0.34456220269203186,
0.3455553650856018,
0.07650168240070343,
0.06458857655525208,
-0.5084162354469299,
-0.2744981348514557,
-0.44156521558761597,
-0.34359011054039,
-0.2816799283027649,
-0.2188737690448761,
-0.05373544618487358,
-0.5130259990692139,
0.269834965467453,
-0.0925142765045166,
0.6089750528335571,
0.19785462319850922,
-0.4643370807170868,
0.009782323613762856,
0.5160567164421082,
0.5312670469284058,
0.7452211976051331,
-0.32904425263404846,
0.33732718229293823,
0.4516887664794922,
-0.7015823125839233,
-0.0062656402587890625,
0.1968383640050888,
-0.00775030767545104,
-0.19279690086841583,
0.11252744495868683,
0.7886878848075867,
0.4212040901184082,
-0.5768032670021057,
0.3975786864757538,
-0.12019624561071396,
0.042515937238931656,
-0.7233617305755615,
0.3008577525615692,
0.25527656078338623,
0.247537299990654,
0.6277905702590942,
0.3942626118659973,
0.003708022413775325,
-0.7551938891410828,
0.5078004002571106,
0.4824362099170685,
-0.4945529103279114,
-0.5493923425674438,
0.4053517282009125,
0.0004642990534193814,
-0.3788120448589325,
0.9781535863876343,
0.06930866837501526,
-0.5791544914245605,
0.445603609085083,
0.6389530301094055,
1.0786927938461304,
-0.2858339548110962,
-0.3621368110179901,
0.30565619468688965,
0.5487927198410034,
-0.43709251284599304,
0.15223759412765503,
-0.23390772938728333,
-0.9239184856414795,
-0.48789623379707336,
-0.19311752915382385,
-0.3213869631290436,
0.4007544219493866,
-0.8422273993492126,
0.13294239342212677,
-0.4904637932777405,
-0.2566174864768982,
-0.38364797830581665,
-0.025805572047829628,
-1.206400752067566,
0.30588123202323914,
0.137607604265213,
1.162231206893921,
-0.4596256613731384,
1.1660455465316772,
0.41154250502586365,
-0.23486024141311646,
-0.5393176078796387,
-0.013787484727799892,
-0.5285873413085938,
-1.049599289894104,
0.5483711957931519,
0.5166549682617188,
-0.24220070242881775,
0.32354941964149475,
-0.4695560336112976,
-1.1281232833862305,
1.0305705070495605,
0.4180104434490204,
-0.6740665435791016,
-0.4401692748069763,
-0.0442388653755188,
0.7345538139343262,
-0.19976677000522614,
0.7982874512672424,
0.8815054297447205,
0.31154772639274597,
-0.18629248440265656,
-0.6394970417022705,
0.05441006273031235,
-0.38992854952812195,
-0.36334797739982605,
0.37746450304985046,
-0.5741646885871887,
0.7812268733978271,
-0.38434356451034546,
-0.46088576316833496,
-0.07739147543907166,
0.9398517608642578,
-0.13586343824863434,
0.02005281113088131,
0.3558296859264374,
0.8820910453796387,
0.7107813358306885,
-0.03180963173508644,
1.0598058700561523,
-0.316928893327713,
0.04019453376531601,
1.4814064502716064,
-0.0373825840651989,
1.0729986429214478,
0.4966391623020172,
-0.15776024758815765,
0.5425382852554321,
-0.00019247249292675406,
0.009103850461542606,
0.5970823168754578,
0.007820876315236092,
0.012288249097764492,
-0.2176450490951538,
0.2272200584411621,
-0.3556596040725708,
0.4131432771682739,
0.6359416842460632,
-0.38117071986198425,
-0.195062056183815,
-0.11196751892566681,
-0.26280102133750916,
-0.02157771959900856,
-0.22553686797618866,
0.6425058245658875,
0.278070867061615,
-1.1447665691375732,
0.455799400806427,
-0.3417283892631531,
0.6600710153579712,
-0.5300765633583069,
-0.011392340064048767,
-0.300155371427536,
0.5720048546791077,
0.18861058354377747,
-0.7487923502922058,
0.3372688591480255,
-0.29558148980140686,
-0.19666145741939545,
-0.28457581996917725,
0.7295747995376587,
-0.31959423422813416,
-0.23477961122989655,
0.45228633284568787,
0.5270390510559082,
0.04366295039653778,
-0.28429171442985535,
-0.5588914752006531,
-0.36450454592704773,
-0.11188264191150665,
-0.5165010094642639,
0.2607576847076416,
0.3797295391559601,
-0.011903895065188408,
0.9491002559661865,
0.46256789565086365,
-0.1662037968635559,
0.15399740636348724,
0.281366229057312,
0.8043488264083862,
-1.1325081586837769,
-0.3393296003341675,
-0.8878535628318787,
0.24374806880950928,
-0.06816290318965912,
-0.3041681945323944,
0.6642739772796631,
0.3272901773452759,
1.1566107273101807,
-0.19956427812576294,
0.5921280980110168,
0.3639321029186249,
0.6190480589866638,
-0.4936096966266632,
0.6152896285057068,
-0.07282450795173645,
0.08018230646848679,
0.015325925312936306,
-0.9941678643226624,
0.016303490847349167,
0.5320211052894592,
-0.4227987229824066,
0.09196862578392029,
0.8814310431480408,
0.6108632683753967,
-0.272004097700119,
0.2574811279773712,
0.33190956711769104,
0.10246898233890533,
0.2331685721874237,
0.9487948417663574,
1.053154706954956,
-0.5179275274276733,
0.7290341258049011,
-0.34315773844718933,
0.08782799541950226,
0.09156879037618637,
-0.6946829557418823,
-1.1046276092529297,
-0.4354162812232971,
0.03155387192964554,
0.15823987126350403,
0.03660322353243828,
0.798679530620575,
0.5824826955795288,
-0.6714584231376648,
0.04174753278493881,
-0.13237451016902924,
-0.10195740312337875,
-0.22070187330245972,
-0.17378069460391998,
0.30507931113243103,
-0.11888762563467026,
-0.6637795567512512,
0.448809415102005,
0.33638614416122437,
0.09298855066299438,
-0.17800292372703552,
0.171936497092247,
0.0397133007645607,
0.18380948901176453,
0.618511438369751,
0.4044528603553772,
-0.6986909508705139,
-0.6409191489219666,
0.24591262638568878,
0.033413536846637726,
0.15551729500293732,
0.9359390139579773,
-1.1514496803283691,
0.44314461946487427,
0.5159761905670166,
0.6225862503051758,
0.6377286314964294,
-0.04139763489365578,
0.8545013070106506,
-0.6247330904006958,
0.21999113261699677,
0.14605051279067993,
0.37734076380729675,
0.2833998501300812,
-0.21303300559520721,
0.21729621291160583,
-0.1342313438653946,
-0.2776413857936859,
-0.5514804124832153,
0.4304475486278534,
-0.5508043766021729,
-0.34393879771232605,
0.6274259090423584,
-0.19262918829917908,
-0.30621159076690674,
-0.25821489095687866,
0.1604771465063095,
0.45321083068847656,
-0.1320120245218277,
0.8463792204856873,
0.9167921543121338,
0.005025367718189955,
-0.4689362943172455,
-0.475629597902298,
0.5866606831550598,
0.6764926314353943,
-0.541439950466156,
0.03315182402729988,
0.31523439288139343,
0.2167772501707077,
0.3732326626777649,
0.7391908168792725,
-0.22665272653102875,
0.12404407560825348,
-0.008328178897500038,
0.005455832928419113,
-0.05295206233859062,
-0.6097196936607361,
-0.2586643099784851,
0.07463272660970688,
-0.11137474328279495,
0.13057926297187805
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.02331v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.02331v1
|
Translation Deserves Better: Analyzing Translation Artifacts in Cross-lingual Visual Question Answering
| 2024-06-04T14:00:02 | 2024-06-04T14:00:02 |
ChaeHun Park, Koanho Lee, Hyesu Lim, Jaeseok Kim, Junmo Park, Yu-Jung Heo, Du-Seong Chang, Jaegul Choo
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Building a reliable visual question answering~(VQA) system across different
languages is a challenging problem, primarily due to the lack of abundant
samples for training. To address this challenge, recent studies have employed
machine translation systems for the cross-lingual VQA task. This involves
translating the evaluation samples into a source language (usually English) and
using monolingual models (i.e., translate-test). However, our analysis reveals
that translated texts contain unique characteristics distinct from
human-written ones, referred to as translation artifacts. We find that these
artifacts can significantly affect the models, confirmed by extensive
experiments across diverse models, languages, and translation processes. In
light of this, we present a simple data augmentation strategy that can
alleviate the adverse impacts of translation artifacts.
|
[
-0.37106144428253174,
-0.6913454532623291,
0.3602787256240845,
0.10083311051130295,
-0.5948032140731812,
0.2022966593503952,
0.11751726269721985,
-0.8245835900306702,
0.07213977724313736,
0.8083993196487427,
-0.6421265602111816,
-0.3420431911945343,
-0.6382465362548828,
0.30267274379730225,
-0.5499972701072693,
1.0023505687713623,
-0.28299272060394287,
0.6217254400253296,
-0.6242051124572754,
-0.39195042848587036,
-0.7293840050697327,
-0.2162376195192337,
-0.3668566942214966,
-0.14146427810192108,
0.18616034090518951,
0.4065246284008026,
0.934130072593689,
0.567252516746521,
0.7243618965148926,
0.3116294741630554,
0.09681124240159988,
0.5943632125854492,
-0.5620661973953247,
-0.03572174161672592,
-0.05610615387558937,
-0.5389186143875122,
-0.4774209260940552,
-0.18442988395690918,
0.5300420522689819,
0.7976086139678955,
0.41396376490592957,
0.47333741188049316,
0.03874773159623146,
0.44199079275131226,
-0.29534730315208435,
-0.11216078698635101,
-0.2942619025707245,
0.11180993169546127,
-0.03405145928263664,
-0.35344740748405457,
-0.29963380098342896,
-0.32693156599998474,
0.2715744078159332,
-1.0477079153060913,
0.14500047266483307,
-0.01135083194822073,
1.0888975858688354,
0.44035229086875916,
-0.5757051110267639,
0.13512468338012695,
-0.5653010606765747,
0.7689205408096313,
-0.4931541979312897,
0.40960097312927246,
0.23210100829601288,
0.1613895744085312,
0.14738164842128754,
-0.7985125780105591,
-0.485351026058197,
0.16246184706687927,
-0.28055649995803833,
0.1763724833726883,
-0.07542892545461655,
-0.2557061016559601,
0.08316051959991455,
0.6386837959289551,
-0.712242066860199,
-0.1733637899160385,
-0.5727260708808899,
-0.44038766622543335,
0.530693769454956,
0.30715012550354004,
0.9295617938041687,
-0.24479444324970245,
-0.5157331228256226,
-0.3800645172595978,
-0.5664279460906982,
0.13305474817752838,
0.04886840283870697,
0.18076537549495697,
0.009387942962348461,
0.8540016412734985,
-0.41544970870018005,
0.5905876159667969,
-0.13653674721717834,
0.12767501175403595,
0.619724452495575,
-0.7821519374847412,
-0.3126090466976166,
-0.24891230463981628,
0.4621974527835846,
0.6153444051742554,
0.26636964082717896,
-0.11090993881225586,
-0.07654037326574326,
-0.1025923565030098,
0.38548824191093445,
-0.7354990243911743,
-0.07398462295532227,
0.18517020344734192,
-0.41378822922706604,
-0.24185636639595032,
-0.21352538466453552,
-0.5073271989822388,
-0.3354426622390747,
-0.49149319529533386,
0.562254011631012,
-0.2974502742290497,
-0.035049788653850555,
0.053647108376026154,
-0.3635144531726837,
0.3890649974346161,
0.604800283908844,
-0.46732333302497864,
0.00426065269857645,
0.49814218282699585,
0.5468240976333618,
-0.3570263981819153,
-0.4431559443473816,
-0.8423183560371399,
-0.1573013812303543,
-0.8249321579933167,
0.8328571319580078,
-0.347064733505249,
-0.27310311794281006,
0.06345341354608536,
0.22443723678588867,
0.33891600370407104,
-0.6580012440681458,
0.6457310318946838,
-0.6444604992866516,
0.6437271237373352,
-0.7823002338409424,
-0.14455774426460266,
-0.24980607628822327,
0.23289738595485687,
-0.8031052350997925,
1.116237998008728,
0.28258997201919556,
-0.6858186721801758,
0.6300011873245239,
-0.3931838572025299,
-0.3917817175388336,
0.3506764769554138,
-0.05746830999851227,
-0.36378031969070435,
0.24439987540245056,
0.8437554836273193,
0.17587794363498688,
-0.27877795696258545,
0.027590353041887283,
-0.16525954008102417,
-0.4032179117202759,
0.21423281729221344,
-0.3706181049346924,
0.7796823382377625,
0.22804179787635803,
-0.34365779161453247,
0.19376111030578613,
-0.5047487020492554,
-0.004523879382759333,
0.026628760620951653,
-0.43476903438568115,
-0.6782711148262024,
-0.2601151466369629,
0.3231867253780365,
0.3375805616378784,
0.379602313041687,
-0.5496447682380676,
0.16291922330856323,
-0.3319966793060303,
-0.3047769069671631,
0.5980584621429443,
-0.03569560870528221,
0.706404447555542,
-0.16032691299915314,
0.5983133912086487,
0.22887325286865234,
0.21526797115802765,
-0.15638048946857452,
-0.5357435941696167,
-0.879710853099823,
-0.1595967710018158,
0.22490406036376953,
0.6536085605621338,
-1.606046199798584,
-0.33184874057769775,
-0.7409937381744385,
-0.2586043179035187,
-0.9527163505554199,
0.4210798442363739,
0.5818660855293274,
0.5133417844772339,
0.7149766683578491,
-0.7035890817642212,
-0.4706399142742157,
-0.9027544260025024,
-0.2773975431919098,
-0.2788347005844116,
-0.2150406539440155,
0.0635560154914856,
0.31082797050476074,
-0.03648044168949127,
0.42125558853149414,
-0.25156837701797485,
-0.327158659696579,
-0.09926728159189224,
0.14450456202030182,
-0.14655940234661102,
0.393589049577713,
0.6051118969917297,
-0.9709939360618591,
-0.4598132371902466,
0.33927643299102783,
-0.9336978793144226,
-0.2742854058742523,
-0.36281469464302063,
-0.49996790289878845,
0.00004407610322232358,
0.5172978639602661,
-0.2809780538082123,
0.46794724464416504,
0.5238779783248901,
-0.43948328495025635,
0.2873792052268982,
-0.014784562401473522,
0.7038413882255554,
-1.017143726348877,
-0.08635585010051727,
-0.20591486990451813,
-0.5176304578781128,
-0.6880768537521362,
0.3777312934398651,
0.15409395098686218,
0.08960486203432083,
-0.566868245601654,
0.6293712258338928,
-0.6026492118835449,
-0.048406850546598434,
-0.1265147179365158,
0.0006892436067573726,
0.32924965023994446,
0.27730685472488403,
0.2369832545518875,
0.7939205765724182,
0.39558643102645874,
-0.2584476172924042,
0.28297239542007446,
0.6514579653739929,
-0.5016287565231323,
0.8327854871749878,
-0.6637538075447083,
0.025265274569392204,
-0.33066996932029724,
-0.27373847365379333,
-1.1692250967025757,
-0.249772310256958,
0.37929919362068176,
-0.6625031232833862,
0.2386239618062973,
-0.07222628593444824,
-0.19052287936210632,
-0.042317699640989304,
-0.18526078760623932,
0.5476175546646118,
0.4620629549026489,
-0.6690800189971924,
0.5883620381355286,
0.21877384185791016,
-0.38525858521461487,
-0.8288024663925171,
-1.0121387243270874,
0.37752673029899597,
-0.11238681524991989,
-0.7791438698768616,
0.1691640019416809,
-0.18521536886692047,
-0.09439905732870102,
0.25894930958747864,
0.005005163606256247,
-0.28925859928131104,
-0.0033352398313581944,
-0.09236568212509155,
0.4708682596683502,
-0.517681896686554,
0.08245327323675156,
0.15668104588985443,
0.04910627007484436,
-0.011931543238461018,
-0.30090218782424927,
0.09022229164838791,
0.07889702916145325,
-0.4497605264186859,
-0.07721468806266785,
0.658295750617981,
0.8291966915130615,
-0.5751358866691589,
0.45040497183799744,
0.793097198009491,
-0.18479378521442413,
-0.041371602565050125,
-0.4083917737007141,
-0.028732528910040855,
-0.41218671202659607,
0.6681005954742432,
-0.38167545199394226,
-0.6164369583129883,
0.37602394819259644,
0.25645771622657776,
0.19699275493621826,
0.3278702199459076,
0.46443817019462585,
-0.1797301322221756,
1.0044949054718018,
0.6883398294448853,
-0.06189410760998726,
0.46977025270462036,
-0.049100808799266815,
-0.10460686683654785,
-0.8008266091346741,
-0.10306522995233536,
-0.15648727118968964,
-0.23196429014205933,
-0.2878156304359436,
-0.8031591773033142,
0.43275076150894165,
-0.2196921855211258,
0.23738329112529755,
0.19956588745117188,
-0.4727301001548767,
0.3351293206214905,
0.4619249999523163,
0.18297483026981354,
0.4888189136981964,
0.35556846857070923,
0.012173390947282314,
-0.3387414515018463,
-0.6518694162368774,
-0.41544651985168457,
0.9819228053092957,
0.2954978048801422,
0.5159268379211426,
0.12385031580924988,
0.4052073061466217,
0.17793583869934082,
0.418133020401001,
-0.4837561845779419,
0.33434611558914185,
-0.19972166419029236,
-0.677832305431366,
-0.35661211609840393,
-0.41386139392852783,
-0.8881728649139404,
0.49443137645721436,
-0.45190751552581787,
-0.30394822359085083,
0.4394697844982147,
0.1508849859237671,
-0.06068533658981323,
0.08388199657201767,
-0.5737743973731995,
1.046158790588379,
-0.5235182642936707,
-0.37796202301979065,
0.08936940133571625,
-0.4688751697540283,
0.3424995541572571,
-0.06244710832834244,
0.29376474022865295,
0.4067460000514984,
-0.2388610690832138,
0.3589783012866974,
-0.32663780450820923,
0.5486586093902588,
0.012104290537536144,
-0.1667121946811676,
0.23798388242721558,
0.2297372817993164,
0.3874203562736511,
-0.05968468263745308,
0.19086602330207825,
0.16459223628044128,
0.0958189144730568,
-0.9118596315383911,
-0.7345903515815735,
0.24416357278823853,
-0.6831334829330444,
-0.5133557319641113,
-0.11998320370912552,
-0.618641197681427,
-0.1615523248910904,
0.057068802416324615,
0.3676316738128662,
0.309844046831131,
-0.12367846816778183,
0.1811266541481018,
0.7195104956626892,
-0.4128641188144684,
0.027074212208390236,
0.3372606635093689,
-0.3939771056175232,
-0.44438987970352173,
0.8784219622612,
0.042546819895505905,
0.5319787263870239,
0.2733013331890106,
-0.08916620910167694,
-0.2697330713272095,
-0.7901442050933838,
-1.0908010005950928,
0.13187070190906525,
-0.9971964955329895,
0.09001252800226212,
-0.4007497727870941,
0.17417581379413605,
-0.4909634292125702,
0.09438862651586533,
-0.3004675805568695,
-0.25464633107185364,
-0.16487176716327667,
-0.21605855226516724,
0.2042466253042221,
0.5512981414794922,
0.1130809336900711,
0.06194743141531944,
-1.0736186504364014,
0.6494060754776001,
0.4029568135738373,
0.04594140872359276,
-0.34324580430984497,
-0.750038743019104,
-0.39543238282203674,
0.24864210188388824,
0.08954549580812454,
-0.8285353183746338,
0.47155600786209106,
0.08210830390453339,
0.6426241397857666,
-0.16313451528549194,
-0.05665154755115509,
1.0673372745513916,
-0.403690367937088,
1.0299829244613647,
-0.02099536918103695,
-0.7377287149429321,
0.2559196949005127,
-0.12353040277957916,
0.6813051700592041,
0.6397139430046082,
0.27057215571403503,
-0.7886742949485779,
-0.3864283859729767,
-0.24783039093017578,
-1.0348193645477295,
0.43128475546836853,
0.29404881596565247,
0.36763763427734375,
0.19362758100032806,
0.04926947504281998,
0.060345280915498734,
0.17577555775642395,
-0.8699789047241211,
-0.09184420853853226,
-0.23547160625457764,
-0.16344551742076874,
-0.09958123415708542,
0.003444160334765911,
-0.04780925065279007,
-0.23288433253765106,
0.6347860097885132,
-0.17943072319030762,
-0.15517878532409668,
0.5271050333976746,
-0.5293179154396057,
-0.21524180471897125,
-0.03283851221203804,
0.3100457191467285,
0.4693356454372406,
0.2747378349304199,
-0.08299000561237335,
0.5406014323234558,
-0.5448657274246216,
-0.04983634874224663,
-0.06281624734401703,
-0.45136135816574097,
0.2552884519100189,
0.5579144954681396,
0.7566323280334473,
-0.16024035215377808,
-0.656479001045227,
0.5483954548835754,
-0.23588036000728607,
0.028091702610254288,
-0.0015706580597907305,
-0.3726362884044647,
-0.09785817563533783,
0.23024551570415497,
0.3989322781562805,
0.18067054450511932,
0.42841464281082153,
-0.5260247588157654,
0.307829350233078,
0.32826751470565796,
-0.7829467058181763,
-0.02368866465985775,
0.5226248502731323,
0.2522379755973816,
-0.07693305611610413,
0.5097439289093018,
0.034458521753549576,
-0.6669484376907349,
0.3878343999385834,
0.0138549180701375,
0.5782480835914612,
-0.17539478838443756,
0.416748046875,
0.3593490719795227,
0.7562344074249268,
0.06488942354917526,
0.4616868793964386,
-0.13564786314964294,
-0.36121582984924316,
-0.751648485660553,
-0.3994249105453491,
-0.19269077479839325,
-0.08127308636903763,
-0.5270498991012573,
0.16958758234977722,
0.3181672692298889,
0.1822582185268402,
-0.2898648977279663,
-0.3342612683773041,
-0.8294732570648193,
0.46397238969802856,
0.33814704418182373,
0.6062918305397034,
-1.0673913955688477,
0.5898666977882385,
0.872869074344635,
-0.63692307472229,
-0.6460375785827637,
-0.34338781237602234,
-0.09165634214878082,
-0.6537429690361023,
0.6516440510749817,
-0.3269732594490051,
0.035604190081357956,
-0.267971009016037,
-0.41290920972824097,
-0.8480827212333679,
0.6446558237075806,
0.47679072618484497,
-0.016639344394207,
0.02111886627972126,
0.6327491402626038,
0.8083646893501282,
-0.1468697190284729,
0.14059121906757355,
0.21862849593162537,
0.4983866810798645,
-0.10598227381706238,
-0.8403329253196716,
0.11646950989961624,
-0.6678556203842163,
-0.013541837222874165,
0.07355356961488724,
-0.054173290729522705,
0.6278116703033447,
-0.10129956156015396,
-0.3288670778274536,
0.2335137128829956,
0.6041022539138794,
-0.20490765571594238,
0.30586686730384827,
0.3321833312511444,
0.47392112016677856,
0.5665167570114136,
-0.142954483628273,
1.434268593788147,
0.09892331063747406,
0.034681566059589386,
1.2661411762237549,
0.3010796308517456,
0.7401162385940552,
0.8551626801490784,
0.10821427404880524,
0.2900831699371338,
0.8587778806686401,
0.07032149285078049,
0.3534232974052429,
-0.08705541491508484,
0.043921343982219696,
-0.5827950239181519,
-0.2369997352361679,
-0.4453679621219635,
0.38637837767601013,
0.0017311382107436657,
-0.4485335350036621,
-0.023308007046580315,
0.06923142820596695,
-0.21010583639144897,
0.2195882797241211,
-0.1782112568616867,
0.8594205379486084,
0.029010947793722153,
-0.8642744421958923,
0.7268606424331665,
-0.35429978370666504,
0.40107861161231995,
-0.3081997334957123,
-0.2568369209766388,
-0.4935971796512604,
-0.2127971351146698,
-0.3011319041252136,
-0.7669632434844971,
0.31731805205345154,
0.020864024758338928,
0.032594576478004456,
-0.1767650544643402,
0.3912186920642853,
-0.6710105538368225,
-0.7617748379707336,
0.16721920669078827,
0.9820217490196228,
0.16993746161460876,
0.08366935700178146,
-0.539734959602356,
-0.16416044533252716,
0.13831108808517456,
-0.1813727468252182,
0.1136016771197319,
0.5852627754211426,
-0.36965200304985046,
0.4071878492832184,
0.8416544795036316,
0.13880448043346405,
0.39260104298591614,
0.05411254242062569,
0.6491000056266785,
-0.18550659716129303,
-0.2290228009223938,
-0.5718274116516113,
1.1080400943756104,
-0.3927329480648041,
-0.5804662108421326,
0.8621341586112976,
0.5214712023735046,
1.0649718046188354,
-0.3150363862514496,
0.6986920237541199,
0.23626233637332916,
0.2538818120956421,
-0.5094565153121948,
0.6678264737129211,
-1.1076802015304565,
0.41094282269477844,
-0.5721423625946045,
-0.8111603856086731,
-0.29296746850013733,
0.21612365543842316,
-0.21607674658298492,
-0.4270016849040985,
0.6266924738883972,
0.7207769155502319,
-0.14422984421253204,
-0.39818063378334045,
0.5455974340438843,
-0.1700960248708725,
0.1557798534631729,
0.581213116645813,
0.9415068626403809,
-0.9263835549354553,
0.9132048487663269,
-0.21775338053703308,
0.028288692235946655,
0.019535472616553307,
-0.6177915930747986,
-0.6902700066566467,
-0.7254841923713684,
-0.5047446489334106,
-0.22297221422195435,
-0.15152080357074738,
0.5032277703285217,
0.6704047322273254,
-0.740140974521637,
-0.06172169744968414,
0.3079586625099182,
0.13502469658851624,
-0.325725793838501,
-0.146121546626091,
0.1533137559890747,
-0.3839283883571625,
-0.9746243953704834,
0.24507170915603638,
0.20760080218315125,
0.10778927057981491,
-0.13843493163585663,
-0.146375834941864,
0.03455663099884987,
0.17752878367900848,
0.6956090331077576,
0.08888151496648788,
-0.6459583640098572,
-0.48378121852874756,
0.45499372482299805,
-0.3728870451450348,
0.35050010681152344,
0.5311035513877869,
-0.6462095975875854,
1.094046950340271,
0.8371089100837708,
1.2089742422103882,
0.5152509212493896,
0.1406981498003006,
0.8299108147621155,
-0.6690933108329773,
-0.0032864653039723635,
0.12572632730007172,
0.4058036208152771,
0.7069395780563354,
-0.4767753481864929,
0.5992457270622253,
0.12105371803045273,
-0.2541153132915497,
-0.801972508430481,
0.24231493473052979,
-0.9064285755157471,
-0.4725201427936554,
0.9024584293365479,
-0.24336886405944824,
-0.30233436822891235,
-0.23101454973220825,
-0.5490652322769165,
0.3150741457939148,
0.11330486088991165,
0.7480959892272949,
0.8141118288040161,
0.27892962098121643,
-0.2772286832332611,
-0.690839946269989,
0.4336698353290558,
0.7723671793937683,
-0.9945038557052612,
-0.24870629608631134,
0.679405152797699,
0.18347357213497162,
0.32180097699165344,
0.45648449659347534,
-0.3763315677642822,
0.8362219929695129,
0.011154787614941597,
0.145938441157341,
0.03261609002947807,
-0.11652623116970062,
-0.4092904329299927,
0.006219836417585611,
0.131241112947464,
-0.42766767740249634
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.02329v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.02329v1
|
On Affine Homotopy between Language Encoders
| 2024-06-04T13:58:28 | 2024-06-04T13:58:28 |
Robin SM Chan, Reda Boumasmoud, Anej Svete, Yuxin Ren, Qipeng Guo, Zhijing Jin, Shauli Ravfogel, Mrinmaya Sachan, Bernhard Schölkopf, Mennatallah El-Assady, Ryan Cotterell
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Pre-trained language encoders -- functions that represent text as vectors --
are an integral component of many NLP tasks. We tackle a natural question in
language encoder analysis: What does it mean for two encoders to be similar? We
contend that a faithful measure of similarity needs to be \emph{intrinsic},
that is, task-independent, yet still be informative of \emph{extrinsic}
similarity -- the performance on downstream tasks. It is common to consider two
encoders similar if they are \emph{homotopic}, i.e., if they can be aligned
through some transformation. In this spirit, we study the properties of
\emph{affine} alignment of language encoders and its implications on extrinsic
similarity. We find that while affine alignment is fundamentally an asymmetric
notion of similarity, it is still informative of extrinsic similarity. We
confirm this on datasets of natural language representations. Beyond providing
useful bounds on extrinsic similarity, affine intrinsic similarity also allows
us to begin uncovering the structure of the space of pre-trained encoders by
defining an order over them.
|
[
-0.46861395239830017,
-0.6385707259178162,
0.16070958971977234,
0.12094375491142273,
-0.09573575109243393,
-0.11997883766889572,
-0.5022424459457397,
-0.5710278153419495,
0.3250381648540497,
0.23939450085163116,
-0.36460158228874207,
-0.12365243583917618,
-0.7166150808334351,
0.22106873989105225,
-0.855179488658905,
0.7515935897827148,
-0.29228171706199646,
-0.11692420393228531,
-0.5752087235450745,
-0.41686615347862244,
0.002980112563818693,
-0.5942671895027161,
-0.5576612949371338,
-0.31472018361091614,
0.08146185427904129,
-0.22064417600631714,
1.0564916133880615,
1.1356782913208008,
0.8263038992881775,
0.33865341544151306,
0.054119210690259933,
-0.3549770712852478,
-0.23395387828350067,
0.4239751994609833,
-0.08460314571857452,
-0.3550121784210205,
0.024588987231254578,
-0.04214366897940636,
0.523068904876709,
0.9351121783256531,
0.14806555211544037,
0.10328618437051773,
0.47264015674591064,
0.7204814553260803,
-0.38203638792037964,
-0.19586052000522614,
-0.7886812090873718,
0.1250120848417282,
-0.15809215605258942,
-0.18679675459861755,
0.22850680351257324,
-0.5449935793876648,
0.1407928317785263,
-0.3883519172668457,
0.38833919167518616,
0.10780925303697586,
1.2459192276000977,
0.7160472869873047,
-0.2470417469739914,
-0.6836440563201904,
-0.5957871079444885,
0.4431321620941162,
-0.41906702518463135,
0.6828113198280334,
0.09229173511266708,
0.14792214334011078,
0.11518299579620361,
-0.4874996542930603,
-0.8597421646118164,
0.0003093026753049344,
-0.3590930998325348,
-0.11261551082134247,
-0.34558844566345215,
0.014587844721972942,
0.3380875587463379,
0.7571324110031128,
-0.7667380571365356,
-0.11287669837474823,
-0.21646995842456818,
-0.02617551200091839,
0.36872991919517517,
-0.2224203199148178,
0.3138654828071594,
0.15682245790958405,
-0.6228751540184021,
-0.030945831909775734,
-0.6928107142448425,
0.10351374000310898,
0.391891747713089,
0.2019365429878235,
-0.10246202349662781,
0.5987769365310669,
0.02084946632385254,
0.6631372570991516,
0.191353902220726,
0.25616273283958435,
0.271781861782074,
-0.2665422260761261,
-0.1047423928976059,
0.09006845206022263,
0.8668433427810669,
0.274183064699173,
0.7447924613952637,
-0.39401963353157043,
-0.14377178251743317,
0.39532554149627686,
0.45858699083328247,
-0.5455809831619263,
-0.1280958354473114,
-0.005239556077867746,
-0.5073932409286499,
0.19108383357524872,
0.4332595765590668,
-0.19011284410953522,
-0.1704697459936142,
-0.6906861066818237,
0.5147706866264343,
-0.6004269123077393,
0.09621160477399826,
-0.11469417810440063,
0.03428571671247482,
0.6149805188179016,
-0.08320528268814087,
-1.0278480052947998,
0.7884340882301331,
1.2937120199203491,
0.7776563167572021,
-0.19505588710308075,
-0.5931076407432556,
-0.3377082049846649,
-0.010527269914746284,
-0.23699133098125458,
0.6837595701217651,
-0.7641083598136902,
0.107844777405262,
0.16918660700321198,
-0.05364343896508217,
-0.020060041919350624,
-0.5514832139015198,
0.2877267599105835,
-0.22135142982006073,
-0.1173781305551529,
-0.3844066262245178,
-0.6053282022476196,
-0.12498560547828674,
0.3304606080055237,
-0.46645617485046387,
0.9383665323257446,
-0.051663994789123535,
-0.7760455012321472,
0.502860426902771,
-0.1875922679901123,
-0.42720022797584534,
-0.055541619658470154,
-0.5662186741828918,
-0.02176779881119728,
0.24499966204166412,
-0.11198177188634872,
0.29435649514198303,
-0.31828370690345764,
-0.056166872382164,
-0.25733688473701477,
-0.4343333840370178,
0.360882967710495,
-0.1653771698474884,
0.6130703091621399,
0.09182991087436676,
-0.3455018997192383,
-0.05641688033938408,
-0.43254825472831726,
0.025520170107483864,
-0.4142724275588989,
-0.18129301071166992,
-0.6402376294136047,
0.014297557063400745,
-0.2242830991744995,
0.3892991840839386,
0.43172863125801086,
-0.7594980597496033,
0.08232742547988892,
-0.4339539408683777,
0.3120782673358917,
0.5326047539710999,
-0.21410906314849854,
0.5859363079071045,
-0.4439508616924286,
0.3028579354286194,
-0.29662004113197327,
-0.0504659079015255,
0.18395638465881348,
-0.4584817886352539,
-0.7174288630485535,
-0.07130274921655655,
0.371459037065506,
0.41812342405319214,
-0.3540801405906677,
0.6998197436332703,
-0.5450598001480103,
-0.31259384751319885,
-0.7820960879325867,
0.1429063081741333,
0.4489453434944153,
0.39576244354248047,
0.28364014625549316,
-0.5229758620262146,
-0.4218727648258209,
-1.1317294836044312,
-0.6332626938819885,
-0.09688866883516312,
-0.17194369435310364,
0.1291406899690628,
0.28151342272758484,
-0.2891589105129242,
0.879109263420105,
-0.28246620297431946,
-0.46280637383461,
0.3199806213378906,
0.0072380793280899525,
0.28052130341529846,
0.5222967267036438,
0.7906404137611389,
-0.7762928009033203,
-0.8932233452796936,
0.295380175113678,
-0.7139980792999268,
-0.2774519920349121,
0.08805927634239197,
-0.20762427151203156,
0.12390817701816559,
0.997779369354248,
-0.4397445023059845,
0.34701216220855713,
0.4851706922054291,
-0.5541313886642456,
-0.0010065663373097777,
-0.3121979236602783,
0.16088251769542694,
-0.6430484056472778,
0.30084773898124695,
-0.38864901661872864,
-0.1258164346218109,
-0.754508912563324,
0.13644158840179443,
-0.0013105061370879412,
-0.11918464303016663,
-0.018113214522600174,
0.5390076637268066,
-0.2906094789505005,
-0.2278158813714981,
-0.3915957510471344,
0.020728418603539467,
-0.23129136860370636,
0.5539190769195557,
0.2897808849811554,
0.5920172333717346,
0.8742103576660156,
-0.5164704918861389,
0.1978788524866104,
0.7010577321052551,
-0.004725013393908739,
0.8786142468452454,
-0.5490376949310303,
0.1755572408437729,
-0.1648266464471817,
-0.17789329588413239,
-0.757333517074585,
0.384659081697464,
0.23764605820178986,
-0.7948555946350098,
0.15286749601364136,
0.06283552944660187,
-0.1633426547050476,
-0.16144251823425293,
-0.3717682361602783,
0.4083211123943329,
0.4486749470233917,
-0.28861287236213684,
0.42953237891197205,
0.3719368577003479,
-0.38175323605537415,
-0.7075240015983582,
-0.7949220538139343,
-0.3282456398010254,
-0.0228428915143013,
-0.348347932100296,
0.37383994460105896,
0.24712584912776947,
-0.27791354060173035,
0.5781440734863281,
-0.3114390969276428,
-0.19385698437690735,
-0.08573613315820694,
0.6434414386749268,
-0.18968334794044495,
-0.39310240745544434,
0.14545364677906036,
-0.13056939840316772,
-0.19073380529880524,
0.24936500191688538,
-0.4113820195198059,
0.6682518720626831,
-0.06829194724559784,
-0.4337022602558136,
-0.01183154247701168,
0.6436077952384949,
0.4166661202907562,
-0.15651005506515503,
0.8541034460067749,
0.4713812470436096,
-0.770522952079773,
0.28864815831184387,
-0.46589115262031555,
0.04487244039773941,
-0.4557943046092987,
-0.01568165235221386,
-0.6085626482963562,
-0.8477498888969421,
0.5170556902885437,
0.3468388617038727,
0.11748574674129486,
0.6762444376945496,
0.5087831616401672,
-0.1676197052001953,
0.47861847281455994,
0.8163859844207764,
-0.0035506351850926876,
0.3259512186050415,
0.03429308161139488,
0.19347018003463745,
-0.861021876335144,
-0.33558332920074463,
-0.6879222393035889,
-0.7156535387039185,
-0.5884525775909424,
-0.30645981431007385,
-0.19686268270015717,
0.15124393999576569,
-0.3772934675216675,
0.6862785220146179,
-0.33767086267471313,
0.41532576084136963,
0.5633108019828796,
-0.5388142466545105,
-0.07146304100751877,
0.015291467308998108,
-0.031492654234170914,
-0.22229081392288208,
-0.34082403779029846,
-0.43313491344451904,
0.7854482531547546,
0.14652930200099945,
0.6081650853157043,
0.08841590583324432,
0.7506113052368164,
0.040997765958309174,
0.07886198163032532,
-0.651607871055603,
0.2251196652650833,
-0.6592020392417908,
-0.3529931902885437,
-0.16609857976436615,
-0.3785264492034912,
-0.9201314449310303,
-0.007065352983772755,
-0.29211586713790894,
-0.5306699275970459,
0.46970540285110474,
0.05495236814022064,
-0.2148026078939438,
0.14947263896465302,
-0.3633868992328644,
0.7455945014953613,
-0.2640652358531952,
0.15761680901050568,
-0.02185402624309063,
-0.7814717888832092,
-0.28589752316474915,
-0.11794164776802063,
-0.031136253848671913,
-0.13012927770614624,
-0.18783676624298096,
0.8479050993919373,
-0.5760539770126343,
0.013504995964467525,
-0.09710602462291718,
0.08307620882987976,
0.09880294650793076,
0.1810416430234909,
0.0238620825111866,
-0.23137497901916504,
0.0044654360972344875,
0.24615098536014557,
0.1596018671989441,
-0.2965145707130432,
-0.8002587556838989,
0.8504906892776489,
-0.8819823861122131,
-0.38708269596099854,
-0.39116305112838745,
-0.38269153237342834,
-0.1027841567993164,
0.14190609753131866,
0.4942002296447754,
0.6315391063690186,
-0.1334688812494278,
0.2664017975330353,
0.401441752910614,
0.12616845965385437,
0.4794534146785736,
0.08402347564697266,
0.008637262508273125,
-0.07189365476369858,
0.8052822351455688,
0.049357157200574875,
0.23241664469242096,
0.8878029584884644,
-0.07275869697332382,
-0.3704368770122528,
-0.2672549784183502,
-0.10722604393959045,
0.3431451618671417,
-0.6171029210090637,
-0.30827847123146057,
-0.7810698747634888,
-0.4761205017566681,
-0.3421466052532196,
-0.6607753038406372,
-0.5165280103683472,
-0.45884275436401367,
-0.10488789528608322,
0.19237525761127472,
0.48329979181289673,
0.7337625622749329,
-0.1578909158706665,
0.1437220722436905,
-0.6807308793067932,
0.5292933583259583,
0.5008637309074402,
0.5169712901115417,
-0.08377828449010849,
-0.5227195024490356,
-0.01396359782665968,
0.1685742884874344,
0.07855358719825745,
-0.6012431979179382,
0.26555299758911133,
0.8703615069389343,
0.5486506223678589,
0.763856828212738,
-0.05708783119916916,
0.5884900689125061,
-0.8451097011566162,
0.4357222616672516,
0.06565817445516586,
-1.2425302267074585,
0.08936763554811478,
0.036639027297496796,
0.24235589802265167,
1.0363280773162842,
0.7447007298469543,
-0.9071400761604309,
-0.5573814511299133,
-0.54984050989151,
-0.7411928772926331,
0.4594835937023163,
0.4687716066837311,
0.18450725078582764,
-0.05564204230904579,
0.3779663145542145,
0.4551559090614319,
0.3114272952079773,
-0.6275591254234314,
-0.5350428223609924,
-0.370880126953125,
-0.41457805037498474,
0.015790561214089394,
-0.06725297123193741,
-0.11881870776414871,
-0.07883626967668533,
0.17851167917251587,
-0.028425486758351326,
0.9864287972450256,
0.0752931460738182,
-0.35533252358436584,
-0.06725544482469559,
0.06878605484962463,
0.33987957239151,
0.5012033581733704,
-0.14706416428089142,
0.7502573728561401,
0.04229100048542023,
-0.6534250378608704,
0.3036751449108124,
0.18729059398174286,
0.2675929665565491,
0.05559954419732094,
0.5262441039085388,
0.5929312109947205,
0.12423625588417053,
-0.30493852496147156,
0.6484898924827576,
-0.07471118867397308,
-0.03784211352467537,
-0.1857476681470871,
-0.0989166870713234,
-0.11948736011981964,
0.2047986388206482,
0.5168251395225525,
0.2664860188961029,
-0.00972504261881113,
-0.6204817295074463,
0.5586016774177551,
0.6917173862457275,
-1.0056146383285522,
-0.5000207424163818,
0.5553152561187744,
0.2180626392364502,
-0.765036404132843,
0.4918995499610901,
-0.2735612690448761,
-0.9709067344665527,
0.475837767124176,
0.46578899025917053,
0.8559007048606873,
-0.3915952146053314,
-0.1943683624267578,
0.1570708304643631,
0.42844530940055847,
0.1749739944934845,
0.2177792191505432,
-0.20120660960674286,
-0.8353781700134277,
-0.01873045228421688,
-0.7847751379013062,
-0.13372115790843964,
-0.29720407724380493,
-0.850357174873352,
0.3147188425064087,
-0.4238990247249603,
0.3222576677799225,
-0.04780649393796921,
-0.16047202050685883,
-0.7201648950576782,
0.279261976480484,
0.2956867218017578,
0.6223428845405579,
-0.9117828607559204,
0.6781136393547058,
0.7984579801559448,
0.20947830379009247,
-0.5376420617103577,
0.222618967294693,
-0.1065090149641037,
-0.7766545414924622,
0.39561372995376587,
0.40408849716186523,
-0.0002839979133568704,
-0.15153291821479797,
-0.11454363167285919,
-1.0056185722351074,
0.8630853891372681,
0.37572401762008667,
-0.40005841851234436,
-0.06253747642040253,
0.3796009421348572,
0.7757579684257507,
-0.4873887598514557,
0.15490582585334778,
0.5103025436401367,
0.12821988761425018,
-0.19804887473583221,
-1.0361266136169434,
0.15083681046962738,
-0.44708573818206787,
-0.14961209893226624,
0.7274909615516663,
-0.25024494528770447,
0.9132476449012756,
0.3514636754989624,
-0.5366730690002441,
-0.19268521666526794,
0.6503901481628418,
-0.2545987367630005,
-0.22617177665233612,
0.5271297693252563,
0.5228835940361023,
0.5215736627578735,
-0.2276705652475357,
0.975345253944397,
-0.4018678665161133,
0.2608872652053833,
0.8695839643478394,
-0.16731950640678406,
0.8738277554512024,
0.5532921552658081,
-0.23141632974147797,
0.3044460713863373,
0.2022712230682373,
0.048106446862220764,
0.49492907524108887,
-0.02087920531630516,
0.2709127962589264,
-0.047109153121709824,
0.0586731880903244,
-0.5036324262619019,
0.46954596042633057,
0.28481927514076233,
-0.28045061230659485,
-0.28715282678604126,
-0.061173804104328156,
-0.21906061470508575,
0.2974119782447815,
-0.29927346110343933,
0.7847978472709656,
0.15227140486240387,
-0.4769964814186096,
0.6156986951828003,
-0.22349557280540466,
0.9864513278007507,
-0.7011092901229858,
0.2104114145040512,
-0.004856546875089407,
0.1608545184135437,
-0.1621919423341751,
-0.8767189383506775,
0.9965711832046509,
-0.23202480375766754,
-0.2016323208808899,
-0.3157337009906769,
0.5118266344070435,
-0.6660810708999634,
-0.1074567511677742,
0.4304548501968384,
0.310732901096344,
0.0861135870218277,
-0.17386722564697266,
-0.6538535356521606,
0.0652892217040062,
-0.024599356576800346,
0.10335912555456161,
0.0882595106959343,
0.5110579133033752,
0.05890649929642677,
0.5127138495445251,
0.2959798276424408,
0.3165883421897888,
0.40239059925079346,
-0.4132990539073944,
0.5457437038421631,
-0.6510254144668579,
-0.5606992840766907,
-0.9215905666351318,
-0.04218417406082153,
0.1403050720691681,
-0.559387743473053,
0.5302302241325378,
0.6139810085296631,
0.8963467478752136,
-0.09914441406726837,
0.362491637468338,
-0.3585056662559509,
0.4488692581653595,
-0.46559759974479675,
0.8585432171821594,
-0.3872867226600647,
-0.175826758146286,
-0.2673933207988739,
-1.6584886312484741,
-0.27918994426727295,
0.9088718891143799,
-0.017788218334317207,
-0.32032108306884766,
1.0658025741577148,
0.5536020398139954,
-0.24168501794338226,
0.0754922479391098,
0.18838660418987274,
-0.0293637253344059,
-0.034507326781749725,
0.6360161900520325,
0.9782824516296387,
-0.46219345927238464,
0.46677958965301514,
-0.2706091105937958,
-0.1289195865392685,
0.17944419384002686,
-0.5891162753105164,
-0.7123159766197205,
-1.1393327713012695,
-0.4521324336528778,
0.10268910229206085,
-0.10235558450222015,
1.0920817852020264,
0.2268168181180954,
-1.0038522481918335,
-0.2912363111972809,
-0.17805840075016022,
-0.043061014264822006,
-0.3615666329860687,
-0.17953312397003174,
0.48977771401405334,
-0.09268131107091904,
-0.7049197554588318,
-0.17656126618385315,
0.3832372725009918,
0.033537305891513824,
0.1132965162396431,
0.019473310559988022,
-0.41144269704818726,
0.10577423125505447,
0.1550910621881485,
0.4473201632499695,
-0.6847146153450012,
-0.6809119582176208,
0.06334409862756729,
-0.36502689123153687,
0.17248612642288208,
1.060049295425415,
-0.8111400604248047,
0.19837091863155365,
0.782375693321228,
0.8275210857391357,
0.1174880787730217,
0.04746194928884506,
0.7205392718315125,
-0.9513149857521057,
0.32671573758125305,
0.2551172077655792,
0.29163751006126404,
0.517413854598999,
-0.22697049379348755,
0.38933175802230835,
-0.1747417449951172,
-0.4847838878631592,
-0.7547174096107483,
0.32114920020103455,
-0.8407194018363953,
0.059242215007543564,
1.2094171047210693,
-0.23179389536380768,
-0.005666756071150303,
-0.3310297727584839,
0.02674342505633831,
0.22222308814525604,
-0.01996542513370514,
0.3886373043060303,
0.6589634418487549,
-0.20889946818351746,
0.12706264853477478,
0.05181232839822769,
0.7760345339775085,
0.2060527354478836,
-0.5548201203346252,
0.08768642693758011,
-0.2406085580587387,
0.10074391216039658,
0.5446062088012695,
0.37855106592178345,
0.06861251592636108,
0.012244184501469135,
0.005789693910628557,
0.059998348355293274,
0.0063429479487240314,
-0.28217005729675293,
-0.6190030574798584,
0.12373548001050949,
-0.04606661945581436,
-0.2823936343193054
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.02325v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.02325v1
|
Technical Language Processing for Telecommunications Specifications
| 2024-06-04T13:57:22 | 2024-06-04T13:57:22 |
Felipe A. Rodriguez Y.
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) are continuously being applied in a more diverse
set of contexts. At their current state, however, even state-of-the-art LLMs
such as Generative Pre-Trained Transformer 4 (GTP-4) have challenges when
extracting information from real-world technical documentation without a heavy
preprocessing. One such area with real-world technical documentation is
telecommunications engineering, which could greatly benefit from
domain-specific LLMs. The unique format and overall structure of
telecommunications internal specifications differs greatly from standard
English and thus it is evident that the application of out-of-the-box Natural
Language Processing (NLP) tools is not a viable option. In this article, we
outline the limitations of out-of-the-box NLP tools for processing technical
information generated by telecommunications experts, and expand the concept of
Technical Language Processing (TLP) to the telecommunication domain.
Additionally, we explore the effect of domain-specific LLMs in the work of
Specification Engineers, emphasizing the potential benefits of adopting
domain-specific LLMs to speed up the training of experts in different
telecommunications fields.
|
[
-0.603480339050293,
-0.6972824931144714,
0.3324261009693146,
0.5019956827163696,
-0.22345249354839325,
0.3616662919521332,
-0.2906932532787323,
-0.9919806718826294,
0.19301891326904297,
0.8603405952453613,
-0.41806748509407043,
-0.434036523103714,
-0.38965487480163574,
0.4589953124523163,
-0.3874707818031311,
0.3465738594532013,
-0.22255276143550873,
-0.25075584650039673,
0.2435697615146637,
0.18057437241077423,
-0.582436740398407,
-0.7141923904418945,
-0.6208164095878601,
-0.6240545511245728,
-0.0468626469373703,
0.3767367899417877,
0.4540558457374573,
0.2343069612979889,
0.5453168749809265,
0.33224019408226013,
-0.16219693422317505,
0.032328955829143524,
0.1906215399503708,
0.19595669209957123,
0.12080151587724686,
-0.4734261631965637,
-0.6565847396850586,
0.26185640692710876,
0.6877137422561646,
0.6467255353927612,
-0.09257148206233978,
0.21608954668045044,
-0.002710602944716811,
0.48838886618614197,
0.054214879870414734,
0.2968429923057556,
-0.700871467590332,
0.4204019010066986,
-0.3786323666572571,
-0.9718806743621826,
-0.6319699287414551,
-0.28871220350265503,
0.3056759238243103,
-0.4680030345916748,
0.35298261046409607,
0.07675319910049438,
1.0686637163162231,
0.24863693118095398,
-0.1624477505683899,
-0.2740500271320343,
-0.8670324087142944,
0.6587356328964233,
-0.8131881356239319,
0.6674328446388245,
0.3377010226249695,
0.3710012137889862,
-0.1178637370467186,
-0.7114843726158142,
-0.16917933523654938,
-0.2811199128627777,
-0.053655486553907394,
-0.10303270071744919,
0.07171317934989929,
0.27492478489875793,
0.6086853742599487,
0.23925338685512543,
-0.26680290699005127,
0.44055402278900146,
-0.5937197208404541,
-0.08838996291160583,
0.41032281517982483,
0.028019288554787636,
0.12389814853668213,
-0.05144432187080383,
0.028779057785868645,
0.5558590888977051,
-0.9125953316688538,
-0.16551002860069275,
0.23598557710647583,
0.20472155511379242,
-0.07991306483745575,
0.5911308526992798,
-0.13747449219226837,
0.760001540184021,
0.05658050626516342,
-0.05157685652375221,
0.08934296667575836,
-0.02779790759086609,
-0.5906100869178772,
0.03415899723768234,
0.6013668775558472,
-0.13776765763759613,
0.5267016887664795,
-0.4433833658695221,
-0.29291751980781555,
-0.38044047355651855,
0.33566856384277344,
-0.6045354008674622,
0.08709048479795456,
0.2440609633922577,
-0.31860196590423584,
0.032402291893959045,
-0.1314888298511505,
-0.46944504976272583,
-0.005225194618105888,
-0.5847263336181641,
-0.17791131138801575,
-0.18163715302944183,
-0.3027726113796234,
0.4014361798763275,
-0.11097543686628342,
0.3956460654735565,
0.18108126521110535,
-0.7441856861114502,
0.3209022879600525,
0.6301587224006653,
0.9336340427398682,
0.02739776112139225,
0.14154601097106934,
-0.37331485748291016,
0.15857912600040436,
-0.1498127579689026,
0.752182126045227,
-0.6530906558036804,
-0.5588552951812744,
0.04083660617470741,
-0.06970607489347458,
0.12476208060979843,
-0.7879552245140076,
0.636995255947113,
-1.0098519325256348,
0.11773921549320221,
0.2146080583333969,
-0.42147159576416016,
0.06742645800113678,
-0.13461892306804657,
-0.6593428254127502,
0.8405658602714539,
0.08726845681667328,
-0.4906313419342041,
0.16072209179401398,
-0.6597214341163635,
-0.5736998319625854,
0.44126489758491516,
-0.24123549461364746,
-0.30429479479789734,
0.1446744054555893,
-0.0476025715470314,
0.5061682462692261,
-0.4109697639942169,
0.3455139696598053,
-0.06083252280950546,
-0.28168895840644836,
0.12241411209106445,
0.007051818072795868,
0.7758614420890808,
0.2237839698791504,
-0.3808360993862152,
-0.14069907367229462,
-0.7113476395606995,
0.28475403785705566,
-0.29978618025779724,
-0.3981030583381653,
0.06033192574977875,
0.09517712891101837,
-0.1176106184720993,
0.4945189952850342,
0.15796004235744476,
-0.5908390283584595,
-0.18442374467849731,
-0.6610869765281677,
0.7269744277000427,
0.6053488850593567,
-0.482387900352478,
0.5250140428543091,
-0.08889777213335037,
0.7883220314979553,
-0.11124849319458008,
0.03147799149155617,
0.037278033792972565,
-0.6471375226974487,
-0.8955596685409546,
0.1733250617980957,
0.2847974896430969,
0.43952828645706177,
-1.0030107498168945,
0.40608829259872437,
-0.1527884602546692,
-0.2786150574684143,
-0.41299372911453247,
0.09052358567714691,
0.21312330663204193,
0.4261649549007416,
0.3177652657032013,
-0.2809961438179016,
-0.8734892010688782,
-0.888445258140564,
-0.23203526437282562,
-0.03240319713950157,
-0.2479049265384674,
0.026334304362535477,
-0.0638839527964592,
0.11282999068498611,
1.0900681018829346,
-0.5066393613815308,
-0.6473169326782227,
-0.5840080976486206,
0.09848074615001678,
0.43244725465774536,
0.11573845893144608,
0.44946008920669556,
-0.6836642622947693,
-0.5338985323905945,
0.1014784425497055,
-0.7604670524597168,
-0.4856334924697876,
-0.006499601993709803,
0.45745328068733215,
0.35724976658821106,
0.7677153944969177,
-0.9131498336791992,
0.20314595103263855,
0.42099758982658386,
0.0979558601975441,
0.6024710536003113,
-0.2663130760192871,
-0.1016676127910614,
-0.8186740875244141,
-0.19254685938358307,
0.5832036137580872,
-0.41291293501853943,
-0.7089852094650269,
0.21179915964603424,
-0.0319928340613842,
-0.2896842062473297,
-0.44067835807800293,
0.4878121614456177,
-0.6009737849235535,
-0.3091978132724762,
-0.3297130763530731,
0.10202869772911072,
-0.12613199651241302,
0.16313254833221436,
0.49528247117996216,
0.950676441192627,
0.34523674845695496,
-0.7585354447364807,
0.24970972537994385,
0.19008082151412964,
-0.4121142029762268,
0.27434465289115906,
-0.7772061824798584,
0.27174249291419983,
0.18025606870651245,
0.06885066628456116,
-0.37056875228881836,
0.020710498094558716,
0.101313516497612,
-0.169316366314888,
0.41622215509414673,
-0.16812290251255035,
-0.6874481439590454,
-0.46625301241874695,
-0.022043123841285706,
0.10921976715326309,
0.5135097503662109,
-0.30346694588661194,
0.690629780292511,
0.5278688669204712,
-0.4644472002983093,
-0.4226832091808319,
-0.8603736162185669,
0.5616191625595093,
-0.15218377113342285,
-0.8986207842826843,
0.659951388835907,
-0.02929057739675045,
-0.248927041888237,
-0.350813627243042,
-0.3048444986343384,
-0.4740941822528839,
0.08240100741386414,
0.21440748870372772,
0.07055806368589401,
-0.5555126070976257,
0.1413995772600174,
-0.3030416965484619,
-0.2739085853099823,
0.3332875370979309,
-0.3629681468009949,
0.49645933508872986,
-0.07190294563770294,
-0.0412340983748436,
-0.8418030738830566,
0.3484923839569092,
0.10356784611940384,
-0.10806307941675186,
0.15769121050834656,
0.1667950600385666,
-0.05294046923518181,
-0.6318774819374084,
-0.7406063079833984,
0.10307885706424713,
-0.6548932194709778,
0.30629095435142517,
-0.6986550092697144,
-1.0298460721969604,
0.14956916868686676,
-0.15813200175762177,
0.29941651225090027,
0.3425107002258301,
0.13132227957248688,
-0.15282762050628662,
0.6317576766014099,
1.045107364654541,
-0.0854167714715004,
0.5575735569000244,
-0.007560321595519781,
0.6073915362358093,
-0.5202983617782593,
-0.22502297163009644,
-0.9082202315330505,
-0.07073794305324554,
-0.37507522106170654,
-0.18268224596977234,
0.2679402232170105,
-0.36309555172920227,
0.02149185910820961,
0.6562052369117737,
-0.5084590315818787,
0.5556923747062683,
0.2972954213619232,
-0.023952849209308624,
0.5754191875457764,
0.35677945613861084,
0.1120280846953392,
-0.039856601506471634,
-0.5448361039161682,
-0.8081097602844238,
0.8073434829711914,
0.6200272440910339,
0.6680841445922852,
-0.11595857888460159,
0.38171496987342834,
0.3511337339878082,
0.2578718960285187,
-0.7813855409622192,
0.8714970350265503,
-0.43228593468666077,
-0.25613370537757874,
-0.10511492937803268,
-0.5432726144790649,
-0.6050143837928772,
-0.32896533608436584,
0.3497263491153717,
-0.5421743392944336,
-0.11996426433324814,
-0.00000715758733349503,
-0.23189829289913177,
0.4004932940006256,
-0.7642607092857361,
0.2004324048757553,
-0.012425300665199757,
0.4229869544506073,
-0.27023351192474365,
-0.3458450436592102,
0.23660029470920563,
-0.4629840552806854,
0.21337704360485077,
-0.05575764179229736,
-0.05784161016345024,
0.7311835289001465,
-0.22895938158035278,
0.9086089730262756,
0.01311067957431078,
-0.5610814690589905,
0.2299865037202835,
-0.020082976669073105,
0.15384048223495483,
-0.06899033486843109,
-0.5614529252052307,
0.4422096312046051,
-0.17899732291698456,
-0.048608023673295975,
-0.1484881490468979,
0.5354410409927368,
-0.6709119081497192,
-1.0223129987716675,
-0.09373703598976135,
-0.5581234693527222,
-0.458720326423645,
0.129385843873024,
0.33943814039230347,
0.44498327374458313,
0.09875327348709106,
-0.11440930515527725,
0.6897039413452148,
-0.27026665210723877,
0.6677175164222717,
0.660419225692749,
-0.022351309657096863,
0.13126564025878906,
0.5704907178878784,
0.2852400839328766,
0.29617494344711304,
0.6302706003189087,
-0.3165050148963928,
-0.4018000066280365,
-0.8131417036056519,
-0.09187643975019455,
0.362803190946579,
-0.9630581736564636,
-0.07117679715156555,
-0.6760485172271729,
-0.7373276948928833,
-0.1554902195930481,
-0.17186108231544495,
0.0028976232279092073,
-0.6950633525848389,
-0.5638618469238281,
-0.001368822413496673,
0.00970033835619688,
0.9322029948234558,
0.5950623750686646,
0.4641038477420807,
-0.9190502762794495,
0.41846683621406555,
-0.0012133251875638962,
0.6911799907684326,
-0.40040963888168335,
-0.6872059106826782,
-0.30121910572052,
-0.1271088421344757,
-0.4986289441585541,
-0.3310706615447998,
0.38125908374786377,
0.3676949739456177,
0.46269625425338745,
-0.10812073945999146,
-0.06417141854763031,
0.5222657918930054,
-0.6010029315948486,
0.7236963510513306,
0.1927272081375122,
-0.9946030378341675,
0.37152862548828125,
0.016365131363272667,
0.1840091049671173,
-0.06181589141488075,
0.22372187674045563,
-0.38159698247909546,
-0.6737244725227356,
-0.49716317653656006,
-0.5137264728546143,
0.8426121473312378,
0.07753077149391174,
0.3005751073360443,
0.10560651868581772,
0.5171077251434326,
-0.0032775350846350193,
0.0907430425286293,
-0.6866754293441772,
-0.1166471615433693,
0.072808176279068,
0.15058134496212006,
0.1004151850938797,
-0.24380546808242798,
0.07169154286384583,
0.0062233335338532925,
0.5164421200752258,
0.09029752016067505,
0.3882083594799042,
0.10297397524118423,
-0.1675114780664444,
-0.10002290457487106,
0.5372470617294312,
0.6399312019348145,
0.852715253829956,
-0.24293270707130432,
0.06582774221897125,
0.21038107573986053,
-0.3406163454055786,
0.11387396603822708,
0.05397823080420494,
0.012284258380532265,
0.6370427012443542,
0.2609732151031494,
0.23700834810733795,
0.037668004631996155,
-0.4199889600276947,
0.1218561977148056,
-0.027259834110736847,
-0.30015310645103455,
-0.5712296366691589,
0.0780753642320633,
0.07642754167318344,
0.13248972594738007,
0.4854620397090912,
0.08542812615633011,
-0.1997399628162384,
-0.19414383172988892,
0.26588958501815796,
0.30611833930015564,
-0.22675663232803345,
-0.6205519437789917,
0.7524901032447815,
0.561855673789978,
-0.6541747450828552,
0.24908609688282013,
-0.08194669336080551,
-0.13691502809524536,
0.8403374552726746,
0.5993279218673706,
1.0871684551239014,
-0.18108035624027252,
0.26323509216308594,
-0.045999735593795776,
0.4575134813785553,
-0.05804057791829109,
0.26608407497406006,
0.19809383153915405,
-0.5770612359046936,
-0.9429366588592529,
-0.5734779834747314,
-0.4261035621166229,
0.23079192638397217,
-0.11297830939292908,
0.6089235544204712,
-0.8922423720359802,
-0.4554448425769806,
0.24185505509376526,
-0.2413860261440277,
-0.8207380175590515,
0.18762913346290588,
0.05271134153008461,
1.331013560295105,
-0.2306704819202423,
0.9796545505523682,
0.5549275875091553,
-0.04197397083044052,
-0.7634378671646118,
-0.1191389411687851,
-0.3565926253795624,
-0.7583773732185364,
1.4509388208389282,
0.13124293088912964,
-0.22690217196941376,
0.20524008572101593,
-0.11604272574186325,
-0.5206432938575745,
0.7312324643135071,
0.42420756816864014,
-0.7044796943664551,
-0.5030888915061951,
0.8590385317802429,
0.4565235674381256,
-0.2342654913663864,
0.461841881275177,
0.6867799162864685,
0.31992897391319275,
-0.12426125258207321,
-1.345978856086731,
0.04457445815205574,
-0.10240966826677322,
0.010798574425280094,
0.30895715951919556,
-0.4098115563392639,
0.4083668291568756,
0.13843561708927155,
-0.5156127214431763,
-0.018596913665533066,
0.4600391089916229,
-0.2011856883764267,
-0.019753197208046913,
0.3521078824996948,
0.3103427290916443,
0.31771016120910645,
-0.20991380512714386,
0.795659601688385,
-0.4303882122039795,
0.013530678115785122,
0.8717519640922546,
-0.2595713138580322,
0.607486367225647,
0.35262393951416016,
-0.38783127069473267,
0.39309653639793396,
0.5539029836654663,
0.19466431438922882,
-0.06920965760946274,
0.03212989494204521,
-0.24771925806999207,
-0.11527883261442184,
-0.15101180970668793,
-0.4281911551952362,
0.3081488609313965,
0.5516954660415649,
-0.25091320276260376,
-0.4813409745693207,
-0.3483993411064148,
-0.2679084837436676,
-0.14339590072631836,
-0.280674010515213,
0.46955156326293945,
0.6515872478485107,
-0.45178577303886414,
0.768195390701294,
0.2665325403213501,
0.8282551765441895,
-0.6549463272094727,
0.1476522982120514,
0.027327019721269608,
-0.1735338419675827,
-0.4811047613620758,
-0.9404054880142212,
0.7179250717163086,
0.1271035522222519,
-0.03247838094830513,
-0.7903825044631958,
0.5783949494361877,
0.04437302052974701,
-0.10883288830518723,
0.34310051798820496,
0.37205129861831665,
0.10079337656497955,
-0.1678781807422638,
-0.5079551935195923,
-0.15993216633796692,
-0.13107797503471375,
-0.18725088238716125,
0.21663303673267365,
0.4533757269382477,
0.15091204643249512,
0.9851797819137573,
0.4436939060688019,
0.47000810503959656,
0.13804183900356293,
0.3434288501739502,
0.8545977473258972,
-0.802272617816925,
-0.4279153645038605,
-0.6337406635284424,
0.27512526512145996,
-0.11023718863725662,
-0.21424676477909088,
0.5257018804550171,
0.39578044414520264,
0.7677276730537415,
-0.22115671634674072,
1.0422247648239136,
0.13099347054958344,
0.21718844771385193,
-0.755414605140686,
0.14267627894878387,
-0.2510841488838196,
0.925693929195404,
-0.020185023546218872,
-0.9535975456237793,
-0.40073397755622864,
0.04122615605592728,
-0.4249882698059082,
-0.17975276708602905,
0.8326559066772461,
0.6146977543830872,
-0.11018439382314682,
0.36049044132232666,
0.3290346562862396,
0.12606588006019592,
0.6504372358322144,
0.423135370016098,
0.7973328232765198,
-0.12144044041633606,
0.7366273999214172,
-0.06794732809066772,
0.09064202010631561,
-0.05811712518334389,
-0.9639779329299927,
-0.9577633738517761,
-0.2857329249382019,
-0.2726978659629822,
-0.0734998807311058,
-0.3397839665412903,
0.7408397197723389,
0.6931614875793457,
-0.5922584533691406,
-0.5753419995307922,
-0.09807170927524567,
0.14743605256080627,
0.02860247530043125,
-0.25748109817504883,
-0.006318284664303064,
-0.7821300029754639,
-0.6662173867225647,
0.566026508808136,
0.6608584523200989,
0.021583376452326775,
-0.1220976859331131,
0.15282435715198517,
0.33682429790496826,
-0.14392411708831787,
0.7524237036705017,
0.3540129065513611,
-0.8304739594459534,
-0.2762588560581207,
0.11741849035024643,
-0.007920939475297928,
0.5405219793319702,
1.1254109144210815,
-0.712386965751648,
0.13243740797042847,
0.3181248903274536,
0.5841354727745056,
0.219160795211792,
-0.2714619040489197,
0.8698931932449341,
-0.9902586936950684,
0.18394213914871216,
0.35838982462882996,
0.5305702686309814,
0.2649438977241516,
-0.48354247212409973,
0.5361136794090271,
0.14204789698123932,
-0.5317589044570923,
-0.5512269735336304,
0.49978208541870117,
-0.9190028309822083,
-0.12990283966064453,
1.1728440523147583,
-0.013694711960852146,
0.30657875537872314,
-0.8717166781425476,
-0.13336321711540222,
0.0662178173661232,
-0.222205251455307,
0.6945263743400574,
0.5938163995742798,
0.01884584315121174,
-0.31473830342292786,
-0.9906637668609619,
0.5476224422454834,
0.2294137328863144,
-0.9872285723686218,
-0.022720064967870712,
-0.030049851164221764,
0.4739117920398712,
0.18158549070358276,
0.8235775828361511,
-0.025176525115966797,
-0.02365799993276596,
-0.4930765926837921,
-0.041171032935380936,
-0.21632298827171326,
-0.1755523532629013,
-0.13245680928230286,
0.4159466028213501,
0.22550258040428162,
0.23815812170505524
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.06579v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.06579v2
|
From Redundancy to Relevance: Enhancing Explainability in Multimodal Large Language Models
| 2024-06-04T13:52:54 | 2024-06-13T10:29:45 |
Xiaofeng Zhang, Chen Shen, Xiaosong Yuan, Shaotian Yan, Liang Xie, Wenxiao Wang, Chaochen Gu, Hao Tang, Jieping Ye
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV
|
Recently, multimodal large language models have exploded with an endless
variety, most of the popular Large Vision Language Models (LVLMs) depend on
sequential visual representation, where images are converted into hundreds or
thousands of tokens before being input into the Large Language Model (LLM)
along with language prompts. The black-box design hinders the interpretability
of visual-language models, especially regarding more complex reasoning tasks.
To explore the interaction process between image and text in complex reasoning
tasks, we introduce the information flow method to visualize the interaction
mechanism. By analyzing the dynamic flow of the information flow, we find that
the information flow appears to converge in the shallow layer. Further
investigation revealed a redundancy of the image token in the shallow layer.
Consequently, a truncation strategy was introduced to aggregate image tokens
within these shallow layers. This approach has been validated through
experiments across multiple models, yielding consistent improvements.
|
[
-0.4540981948375702,
-0.9051913022994995,
0.7943114638328552,
0.05003342777490616,
-0.5249530076980591,
-0.06607519090175629,
-0.2554773986339569,
-0.5661919116973877,
-0.022737301886081696,
0.5389887094497681,
-0.45579710602760315,
-0.35012200474739075,
-0.5464184880256653,
-0.1510629504919052,
-0.46462947130203247,
0.700925886631012,
-0.19983837008476257,
-0.3486500382423401,
-0.49447450041770935,
-0.3434186577796936,
-0.6620796322822571,
-0.2618657946586609,
-0.6153039336204529,
-0.3381401300430298,
0.6514726877212524,
0.3117910623550415,
0.95704185962677,
0.7956994771957397,
0.6959114670753479,
0.45814576745033264,
-0.22364281117916107,
0.22305332124233246,
-0.46941885352134705,
0.24796238541603088,
-0.4588169753551483,
-0.4435374140739441,
-0.011184340342879295,
-0.4703499972820282,
0.6993894577026367,
0.8486974239349365,
0.08057950437068939,
-0.06181126460433006,
-0.024142621085047722,
0.47432422637939453,
-0.6904910802841187,
0.2504462003707886,
-0.30581191182136536,
-0.06440295279026031,
-0.1477549821138382,
-0.46057504415512085,
-0.5020932555198669,
0.07002242654561996,
0.3293170928955078,
-0.5151747465133667,
-0.08940068632364273,
-0.12073526531457901,
0.7406244874000549,
0.24670562148094177,
-0.5529321432113647,
-0.12538765370845795,
-0.8876901865005493,
0.8604270815849304,
-0.54981529712677,
0.15595649182796478,
0.035760268568992615,
0.3356325924396515,
0.07650861889123917,
-0.7797358632087708,
-0.8264719247817993,
-0.010009584948420525,
-0.2918681204319,
-0.06269752234220505,
-0.158980593085289,
0.07587704807519913,
0.2490399181842804,
-0.05035562068223953,
-0.3167995810508728,
-0.15508170425891876,
-0.4429062008857727,
0.04036342725157738,
0.41940101981163025,
0.055170245468616486,
0.48948001861572266,
-0.09328682720661163,
-0.4629899859428406,
-0.02839643508195877,
-0.33821797370910645,
0.04364379495382309,
-0.13163216412067413,
0.030090127140283585,
-0.14858604967594147,
0.72043776512146,
0.062284912914037704,
0.9044414758682251,
-0.16683214902877808,
-0.3314119875431061,
0.4162428677082062,
-0.4717272222042084,
-0.20130285620689392,
-0.23011887073516846,
0.5254400372505188,
0.527411162853241,
0.1519717127084732,
0.09502299875020981,
-0.00023393183073494583,
-0.11416637152433395,
0.36965471506118774,
-0.6918524503707886,
0.11067977547645569,
0.36762726306915283,
-0.5971688628196716,
-0.21360865235328674,
-0.06836686283349991,
-0.5981859564781189,
-0.42348238825798035,
-0.37255051732063293,
0.5148547887802124,
-0.44830334186553955,
-0.44454067945480347,
0.11024154722690582,
-0.25180280208587646,
0.08058721572160721,
0.7162876129150391,
-0.5022103786468506,
-0.15490233898162842,
0.39175495505332947,
0.7994397282600403,
-0.20732581615447998,
-0.4828158915042877,
-0.554979681968689,
0.47491729259490967,
-0.1793937385082245,
0.7798864841461182,
-0.8116871118545532,
0.05470338463783264,
-0.013986100442707539,
-0.007474437355995178,
-0.024110710248351097,
-0.33003056049346924,
0.3730558454990387,
-0.47197678685188293,
0.19250783324241638,
-0.09103217720985413,
-0.2697294056415558,
-0.662468671798706,
0.3829747140407562,
-0.6732690334320068,
0.6607630848884583,
-0.1576468050479889,
-0.8030096888542175,
0.15559600293636322,
-0.765946090221405,
-0.4198368489742279,
0.2939514219760895,
-0.1915723979473114,
-0.33323559165000916,
0.1458987146615982,
0.07609357684850693,
0.4863324761390686,
-0.11875133216381073,
0.37065768241882324,
-0.44050464034080505,
-0.5540504455566406,
0.22372694313526154,
-0.48189613223075867,
0.3407517075538635,
0.16932538151741028,
-0.361704558134079,
0.2841007113456726,
-0.7546601295471191,
0.06036188825964928,
0.11270584911108017,
-0.38827845454216003,
-0.5098981261253357,
0.03653856739401817,
0.05031285807490349,
0.282064288854599,
0.06721360981464386,
-0.13650928437709808,
0.015493403188884258,
-0.1368206888437271,
0.707038164138794,
0.5417100787162781,
-0.01931072399020195,
0.46742022037506104,
0.002891537733376026,
0.3557600677013397,
0.470071941614151,
0.13184115290641785,
-0.7249992489814758,
-0.3445320427417755,
-0.880692720413208,
-0.23837287724018097,
0.0294104665517807,
0.4359903335571289,
-1.070666790008545,
-0.10578367859125137,
-0.32930225133895874,
-0.12486579269170761,
-0.36443421244621277,
0.10237113386392593,
0.422041654586792,
0.4458678662776947,
0.28786778450012207,
-0.32120171189308167,
-0.3119758367538452,
-1.1426509618759155,
-0.2202788144350052,
-0.18601281940937042,
0.24530424177646637,
0.28299978375434875,
0.6387828588485718,
-0.47887957096099854,
0.6472496390342712,
-0.30266493558883667,
0.18652953207492828,
-0.3184368312358856,
0.28398677706718445,
0.07729221880435944,
0.5113946795463562,
0.4617825746536255,
-1.0174639225006104,
-0.03776949644088745,
0.2645246088504791,
-0.8052515387535095,
0.2322085052728653,
-0.2773421108722687,
-0.3277120292186737,
0.1918523758649826,
0.5169935822486877,
-0.8597314953804016,
0.7211302518844604,
0.2491479218006134,
-0.4030357599258423,
0.43922463059425354,
-0.27215591073036194,
0.41217944025993347,
-0.7733125686645508,
0.09323383122682571,
0.09054974466562271,
-0.2889665365219116,
-0.8155360817909241,
0.2318052053451538,
0.055424317717552185,
-0.25581297278404236,
-0.5599260926246643,
0.7000712156295776,
-0.5954937934875488,
-0.0037386382464319468,
-0.22038888931274414,
0.4184364378452301,
0.3413739502429962,
0.45730042457580566,
-0.03421191871166229,
0.5056187510490417,
0.5067113041877747,
-0.5504780411720276,
0.46432578563690186,
0.031643327325582504,
-0.37125343084335327,
0.5240406394004822,
-0.6772197484970093,
-0.1533641368150711,
-0.5831648111343384,
-0.044387344270944595,
-1.221645712852478,
-0.3149589002132416,
0.123275987803936,
-0.12281081080436707,
0.2985990345478058,
-0.14293703436851501,
-0.4083321690559387,
-0.346273273229599,
-0.13471129536628723,
0.808789849281311,
0.21639123558998108,
-0.615850567817688,
0.917413055896759,
0.26313135027885437,
-0.13403598964214325,
-0.8674028515815735,
-0.9032353162765503,
0.34546422958374023,
-0.33525705337524414,
-0.9716437458992004,
0.14596527814865112,
-0.08396753668785095,
-0.3938014805316925,
0.09073270112276077,
0.07383555173873901,
-0.2652818560600281,
0.1290026158094406,
0.1829846203327179,
0.2219730019569397,
-0.18924549221992493,
0.6376268267631531,
-0.16620215773582458,
0.1318330466747284,
-0.12249881029129028,
-0.18872834742069244,
0.37588727474212646,
-0.2539829611778259,
-0.48057740926742554,
-0.70002281665802,
0.5907598733901978,
0.9008920192718506,
-0.16922718286514282,
0.992530107498169,
0.5476799607276917,
-0.31463247537612915,
-0.008249972946941853,
-0.5170224905014038,
0.08919971436262131,
-0.4406483769416809,
0.5604735612869263,
-0.5630995631217957,
-0.7238889932632446,
0.4669669568538666,
-0.006691949442028999,
0.10063876211643219,
0.25969088077545166,
0.3617440164089203,
-0.3168835937976837,
0.8650226593017578,
0.696008026599884,
0.5539913773536682,
0.5918595790863037,
-0.08704423904418945,
0.326682448387146,
-0.47070956230163574,
-0.4733380079269409,
-0.13089440762996674,
-0.38241949677467346,
-0.15582111477851868,
-0.6865786910057068,
0.20345085859298706,
0.3718133866786957,
-0.08406094461679459,
-0.08408410102128983,
-0.3352045714855194,
0.6900438666343689,
0.4471046030521393,
0.13918185234069824,
0.37058043479919434,
0.23033760488033295,
-0.16825634241104126,
0.0689777061343193,
-0.6800503730773926,
-0.39678236842155457,
0.3655811548233032,
0.46240007877349854,
1.0200704336166382,
0.20277446508407593,
0.24596470594406128,
0.10803189128637314,
0.09050730615854263,
-0.6597104668617249,
0.5880024433135986,
-0.08290056884288788,
-0.2610633373260498,
-0.2962080240249634,
-0.39130350947380066,
-0.971392035484314,
0.5479036569595337,
-0.37505215406417847,
-0.6142929196357727,
0.2083883285522461,
0.40880686044692993,
-0.05595192313194275,
0.2971005141735077,
-1.1022803783416748,
0.8727367520332336,
-0.25097063183784485,
-0.6830534934997559,
-0.318807452917099,
-0.6106299757957458,
0.4994109272956848,
0.10260508209466934,
0.42506763339042664,
0.3633788228034973,
-0.16226163506507874,
0.49459606409072876,
-0.5836686491966248,
0.906484067440033,
0.01975763961672783,
-0.2344754934310913,
0.24861551821231842,
0.027423644438385963,
0.5372976660728455,
-0.27632075548171997,
0.1374150514602661,
0.03223348408937454,
-0.31680238246917725,
-0.4844750463962555,
-0.8642975091934204,
0.5873059034347534,
-0.41003870964050293,
-0.6847917437553406,
0.0039049023762345314,
-0.7163135409355164,
-0.005063051823526621,
0.2807658910751343,
-0.05005723610520363,
0.6784525513648987,
0.4345373809337616,
0.39131417870521545,
0.536186933517456,
-0.4808427095413208,
0.38083750009536743,
-0.017821140587329865,
-0.13742606341838837,
-0.1575033962726593,
0.7685156464576721,
0.045411400496959686,
0.4412245750427246,
0.419826865196228,
0.03435683622956276,
-0.3616577088832855,
-0.5556521415710449,
-0.20944862067699432,
0.4511886239051819,
-1.1096311807632446,
0.15538717806339264,
-0.7181462049484253,
-0.15842127799987793,
-0.009254030883312225,
-0.14401714503765106,
-0.11727779358625412,
-0.47251051664352417,
-0.27300605177879333,
0.08034040033817291,
0.09118914604187012,
0.6967023611068726,
0.3975967466831207,
0.3459034860134125,
-0.8672816157341003,
0.20018422603607178,
0.2794824540615082,
0.47380244731903076,
0.4196581542491913,
-0.4431881606578827,
-0.3633473217487335,
-0.02596527338027954,
-0.13298076391220093,
-0.706544816493988,
0.03883877024054527,
0.09269160032272339,
0.7015366554260254,
0.4995799958705902,
-0.2533142864704132,
1.0966269969940186,
-0.30998489260673523,
0.6330602765083313,
0.6117672324180603,
-1.0195003747940063,
0.6754521131515503,
-0.16274096071720123,
0.6005336046218872,
0.06233193352818489,
0.060820065438747406,
-0.5253569483757019,
-0.47697725892066956,
-0.46679750084877014,
-1.0345522165298462,
0.453734427690506,
0.32972264289855957,
0.018236476927995682,
0.12332184612751007,
0.428536057472229,
-0.020145365968346596,
0.29631683230400085,
-0.9987579584121704,
-0.09629359841346741,
-0.18851310014724731,
-0.34892722964286804,
0.19354599714279175,
-0.46127524971961975,
-0.24655181169509888,
-0.009624621830880642,
0.2953108549118042,
-0.11388572305440903,
0.13066354393959045,
0.1379879266023636,
-0.38652336597442627,
0.009920233860611916,
0.3728249967098236,
0.8660794496536255,
1.0576980113983154,
0.2166033536195755,
0.5834465026855469,
-0.2101890742778778,
-0.19933409988880157,
-0.01168412808328867,
-0.1992851197719574,
-0.12038877606391907,
0.057868871837854385,
0.9243407845497131,
1.1037709712982178,
0.17120783030986786,
-0.8776254653930664,
0.532016932964325,
-0.13901224732398987,
-0.2618752717971802,
0.022236153483390808,
0.11160266399383545,
0.1192384734749794,
0.6591657996177673,
0.29288339614868164,
0.2639654278755188,
-0.017878802493214607,
-0.755445659160614,
0.0908702164888382,
0.5938360691070557,
-0.3475359082221985,
-0.049487411975860596,
0.5052099823951721,
0.2986947298049927,
-0.11807546019554138,
0.42422208189964294,
0.18764805793762207,
-0.40485936403274536,
0.6317870020866394,
0.32070252299308777,
0.3241935670375824,
0.11653680354356766,
0.25513210892677307,
0.37980613112449646,
0.3878813683986664,
-0.17987172305583954,
0.16372355818748474,
-0.1096220538020134,
-0.49022191762924194,
-0.9191364645957947,
-0.14652034640312195,
-0.0989036038517952,
0.18906815350055695,
-0.3560371994972229,
0.1978500783443451,
-0.1267109215259552,
-0.22718898952007294,
0.23001718521118164,
-0.5460226535797119,
-0.6206398606300354,
0.18046846985816956,
0.184103861451149,
0.722984254360199,
-0.6529947519302368,
0.5088371634483337,
0.843091607093811,
-0.43138444423675537,
-0.5199035406112671,
0.04397476837038994,
-0.19650574028491974,
-0.7491962313652039,
0.9170371890068054,
0.1922893077135086,
-0.19637276232242584,
-0.3876373767852783,
-0.6804232001304626,
-0.774448037147522,
0.906728982925415,
0.4444079101085663,
-0.5796647667884827,
0.05817591771483421,
-0.1327640414237976,
0.5366221070289612,
-0.48365259170532227,
0.2471834421157837,
0.22935320436954498,
0.6984545588493347,
0.5832424759864807,
-0.6709071397781372,
0.1762395054101944,
-0.40875351428985596,
0.2661069333553314,
0.3040376603603363,
-0.4887382984161377,
0.6867921352386475,
-0.7571032047271729,
-0.6016110777854919,
-0.07642477750778198,
0.32482603192329407,
0.12175985425710678,
0.2906751334667206,
0.7059552669525146,
0.4949881434440613,
0.7829008102416992,
-0.08408796787261963,
1.0637850761413574,
0.20003721117973328,
0.3114449977874756,
1.1615893840789795,
0.10067908465862274,
0.7186002731323242,
0.6624544262886047,
0.18357762694358826,
0.5743759870529175,
0.37195268273353577,
0.0020823590457439423,
0.4412408769130707,
0.04265991598367691,
-0.17847664654254913,
-0.4618609547615051,
-0.22873467206954956,
-0.18911334872245789,
0.20196427404880524,
0.3152368664741516,
-0.5801495909690857,
-0.22031815350055695,
0.276446133852005,
-0.23931780457496643,
-0.1322363317012787,
-0.3927079737186432,
0.6165159940719604,
-0.08505287021398544,
-0.6081371307373047,
0.7085697650909424,
-0.2693016827106476,
0.2938174605369568,
-0.26767784357070923,
-0.31420308351516724,
0.06563425064086914,
0.22766438126564026,
-0.2709973454475403,
-1.233676552772522,
0.26679593324661255,
-0.27811700105667114,
-0.327765554189682,
-0.06390698254108429,
0.8285015821456909,
-0.7815318703651428,
-0.4379432797431946,
0.28490573167800903,
0.48445263504981995,
0.22791776061058044,
0.2262168973684311,
-0.6421019434928894,
0.3406814932823181,
0.11766602843999863,
-0.14498890936374664,
-0.03066723234951496,
0.7457746267318726,
-0.23643723130226135,
1.0191468000411987,
0.5148371458053589,
-0.053891003131866455,
-0.010573573410511017,
0.34128913283348083,
0.7591402530670166,
-0.8696489334106445,
-0.3778734803199768,
-0.9940670132637024,
0.9081190228462219,
-0.2971615493297577,
0.055634964257478714,
0.39371493458747864,
0.1261577010154724,
0.5041232109069824,
-0.11020121723413467,
0.7755113244056702,
0.1357148140668869,
0.0863037183880806,
-0.5620694160461426,
0.4056527614593506,
-1.0227035284042358,
0.46990296244621277,
-0.30901768803596497,
-0.7215313911437988,
-0.47882840037345886,
0.5997761487960815,
-0.07749759405851364,
0.01760987564921379,
0.946708619594574,
0.5689824819564819,
-0.20747359097003937,
-0.27659785747528076,
0.39659830927848816,
0.5150488615036011,
0.3270796239376068,
0.5549702644348145,
0.9571665525436401,
-0.17043952643871307,
1.0048192739486694,
-0.018203970044851303,
-0.18804776668548584,
-0.25887101888656616,
-1.0369086265563965,
-0.9273956418037415,
-0.6322093605995178,
-0.4347277283668518,
-0.36978408694267273,
-0.0632762759923935,
0.4120410084724426,
0.8203006982803345,
-0.3303667902946472,
0.006934323813766241,
0.13033846020698547,
0.5201500058174133,
-0.17766991257667542,
-0.23156502842903137,
0.23032386600971222,
-0.20552276074886322,
-0.5710920691490173,
-0.13034065067768097,
0.7360936403274536,
0.2720913589000702,
-0.23201896250247955,
0.011269230395555496,
-0.20957589149475098,
-0.005849906243383884,
0.9037386775016785,
0.060228075832128525,
-0.900009036064148,
-0.31595808267593384,
-0.5579045414924622,
0.06069321185350418,
0.139057457447052,
0.8272562026977539,
-0.518679141998291,
0.7023431062698364,
0.5675143003463745,
0.6884898543357849,
0.4824405312538147,
0.13068516552448273,
0.5545843839645386,
-0.674951434135437,
0.3048938810825348,
-0.1161641851067543,
0.5019323229789734,
0.4420927166938782,
-0.2890753746032715,
0.40308961272239685,
0.21614904701709747,
-0.1669069528579712,
-0.8314063549041748,
0.3518916368484497,
-1.151366949081421,
-0.6402861475944519,
1.0268827676773071,
-0.12532609701156616,
-0.4163011312484741,
-0.2313237190246582,
-0.2719153165817261,
-0.05715077742934227,
-0.24323737621307373,
0.5609050393104553,
0.9712536334991455,
-0.07277138531208038,
-0.8818112015724182,
-0.5309341549873352,
0.01999679207801819,
0.28182828426361084,
-0.9218786954879761,
0.019378842785954475,
0.5447158217430115,
0.08282580226659775,
0.618634045124054,
0.4414046108722687,
-0.1335850954055786,
0.2761106491088867,
-0.19457028806209564,
-0.1009356826543808,
-0.0676233097910881,
-0.34187889099121094,
-0.1475054919719696,
0.379482239484787,
-0.03773895651102066,
-0.13631026446819305
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.06578v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.06578v1
|
SMS Spam Detection and Classification to Combat Abuse in Telephone Networks Using Natural Language Processing
| 2024-06-04T13:44:36 | 2024-06-04T13:44:36 |
Dare Azeez Oyeyemi, Adebola K. Ojo
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
In the modern era, mobile phones have become ubiquitous, and Short Message
Service (SMS) has grown to become a multi-million-dollar service due to the
widespread adoption of mobile devices and the millions of people who use SMS
daily. However, SMS spam has also become a pervasive problem that endangers
users' privacy and security through phishing and fraud. Despite numerous spam
filtering techniques, there is still a need for a more effective solution to
address this problem [1]. This research addresses the pervasive issue of SMS
spam, which poses threats to users' privacy and security. Despite existing spam
filtering techniques, the high false-positive rate persists as a challenge. The
study introduces a novel approach utilizing Natural Language Processing (NLP)
and machine learning models, particularly BERT (Bidirectional Encoder
Representations from Transformers), for SMS spam detection and classification.
Data preprocessing techniques, such as stop word removal and tokenization, are
applied, along with feature extraction using BERT. Machine learning models,
including SVM, Logistic Regression, Naive Bayes, Gradient Boosting, and Random
Forest, are integrated with BERT for differentiating spam from ham messages.
Evaluation results revealed that the Na\"ive Bayes classifier + BERT model
achieves the highest accuracy at 97.31% with the fastest execution time of 0.3
seconds on the test dataset. This approach demonstrates a notable enhancement
in spam detection efficiency and a low false-positive rate. The developed model
presents a valuable solution to combat SMS spam, ensuring faster and more
accurate detection. This model not only safeguards users' privacy but also
assists network providers in effectively identifying and blocking SMS spam
messages.
|
[
-0.3516538441181183,
-1.1273974180221558,
0.004378616344183683,
0.7182603478431702,
-0.28794950246810913,
-0.024217689409852028,
-0.03369397297501564,
-0.7980665564537048,
0.036758530884981155,
0.9570360779762268,
-0.519507110118866,
-0.5272929668426514,
-0.5819610357284546,
0.2844301164150238,
-0.5799364447593689,
1.027236819267273,
0.48978736996650696,
0.123402900993824,
0.02553778514266014,
0.09332038462162018,
-0.4264993965625763,
-0.7286370396614075,
-0.8301517367362976,
-0.2815863788127899,
0.226665660738945,
0.29972732067108154,
0.7216057181358337,
0.3230177164077759,
0.5605789422988892,
0.39531946182250977,
-0.2792540192604065,
0.19558076560497284,
-0.2446630746126175,
0.19097237288951874,
0.07268579304218292,
-0.48604580760002136,
-0.27169710397720337,
-0.1923382729291916,
0.39506784081459045,
0.35363391041755676,
-0.04516945034265518,
-0.10113108158111572,
0.33907461166381836,
0.6916593313217163,
-0.2775362730026245,
-0.2876173257827759,
-0.9330512285232544,
0.06460419297218323,
-0.27338871359825134,
-0.5529871582984924,
-0.5324207544326782,
-0.7905600070953369,
0.44240882992744446,
-0.16395637392997742,
0.32077232003211975,
0.09985405206680298,
0.7308369278907776,
0.02303851582109928,
-0.4807842969894409,
-0.7551432251930237,
-0.714068591594696,
0.8696997761726379,
-0.6398866176605225,
0.23758219182491302,
0.47511905431747437,
0.2739558219909668,
-0.44635632634162903,
-0.3528357148170471,
-0.28173327445983887,
-0.18344949185848236,
0.057924192398786545,
-0.1332051306962967,
-0.2843291461467743,
0.10142667591571808,
0.2421458214521408,
0.277401328086853,
-0.7649268507957458,
0.2975683808326721,
-0.273464173078537,
-0.5899146795272827,
0.5129159092903137,
0.13292501866817474,
0.3418733477592468,
-0.3663444519042969,
-0.7382697463035583,
0.2855708599090576,
-0.4130041003227234,
0.14738517999649048,
0.3780762553215027,
0.3293837904930115,
0.01949012093245983,
0.47823357582092285,
-0.08587158471345901,
0.7043140530586243,
-0.10695413500070572,
-0.11711955070495605,
-0.06966568529605865,
-0.2975553274154663,
-0.45355358719825745,
0.27645108103752136,
0.9397099018096924,
-0.026563387364149094,
0.1952129304409027,
0.036861952394247055,
-0.28577545285224915,
0.16853661835193634,
0.29358938336372375,
-0.9553272128105164,
-0.06178842484951019,
0.1517629474401474,
-0.8502650260925293,
-0.4021591544151306,
-0.05628854036331177,
-0.8958740830421448,
-0.2748017907142639,
-0.08621802181005478,
0.30224281549453735,
-0.48452651500701904,
-0.1458892673254013,
0.321787029504776,
0.030818134546279907,
0.08136510103940964,
0.16353799402713776,
-0.6764683127403259,
0.6333198547363281,
0.6245742440223694,
0.9180589914321899,
-0.15864311158657074,
0.0905870720744133,
-0.4019244909286499,
-0.2734530568122864,
-0.13142052292823792,
0.6984386444091797,
-0.5634102821350098,
-0.5386644005775452,
0.23781850934028625,
-0.08700475096702576,
-0.2197168469429016,
-0.6365312337875366,
0.9693759679794312,
-0.8912079334259033,
0.6581123471260071,
0.1744723916053772,
-0.6336012482643127,
-0.18668000400066376,
0.37088915705680847,
-0.6339924335479736,
1.2240417003631592,
-0.14884540438652039,
-0.6458748579025269,
0.07635324448347092,
-0.8938788771629333,
-0.6625714302062988,
0.19916269183158875,
0.539711058139801,
-0.7306766510009766,
0.06057946756482124,
0.057654667645692825,
0.6027360558509827,
-0.3206692337989807,
0.18822036683559418,
-0.36571985483169556,
-0.37471649050712585,
0.5835917592048645,
-0.5615853071212769,
1.0147784948349,
0.37115707993507385,
-0.3302951753139496,
0.07105263322591782,
-0.7745164632797241,
0.26167523860931396,
-0.08193440735340118,
-0.33815252780914307,
-0.44541430473327637,
-0.13070538640022278,
0.16517937183380127,
0.1996365487575531,
0.1823224276304245,
-0.6215778589248657,
-0.1154383197426796,
-0.7721601128578186,
0.09570375829935074,
0.6670753359794617,
0.17096850275993347,
0.6246973872184753,
-0.2564014196395874,
0.08519801497459412,
0.11335387080907822,
0.29795387387275696,
-0.2106640487909317,
-0.9213398098945618,
-0.5615624785423279,
-0.19126227498054504,
0.48907527327537537,
0.8476161956787109,
-0.6610822677612305,
0.8387484550476074,
-0.28903451561927795,
-0.4059257209300995,
-0.4127345681190491,
0.2812337279319763,
0.3614664077758789,
0.3049756586551666,
0.38276487588882446,
-0.22877132892608643,
-0.6591418385505676,
-0.8329273462295532,
-0.4039369821548462,
-0.07153509557247162,
0.00876266323029995,
-0.010117127560079098,
0.22144615650177002,
-0.5681207776069641,
1.0238655805587769,
-0.3682296872138977,
-0.4726812243461609,
-0.16386020183563232,
0.2644909918308258,
0.28305137157440186,
0.5489909052848816,
0.5814934968948364,
-1.2059547901153564,
-0.5422646403312683,
-0.20860493183135986,
-0.3965541422367096,
-0.2498599886894226,
-0.21331532299518585,
-0.036501504480838776,
0.3087766766548157,
-0.09479837864637375,
-0.4665965735912323,
0.4962864816188812,
0.3186509609222412,
-0.3917568624019623,
0.45604148507118225,
-0.17296163737773895,
0.10876976698637009,
-0.878914475440979,
-0.1616598516702652,
0.26479679346084595,
-0.3656603991985321,
-1.0717023611068726,
-0.6538702249526978,
0.04389571771025658,
-0.14465054869651794,
-0.38772842288017273,
0.30299121141433716,
-0.22572554647922516,
-0.09376721829175949,
-0.6723184585571289,
-0.264362633228302,
-0.2571108937263489,
0.3245672881603241,
0.04196002334356308,
0.6473198533058167,
0.2650272846221924,
-1.040924310684204,
0.2436116486787796,
0.2281305491924286,
-0.1501644104719162,
0.35673633217811584,
-0.6241346001625061,
-0.07043647766113281,
0.20368893444538116,
0.16687090694904327,
-1.08769953250885,
0.13524022698402405,
0.7395521402359009,
-0.7084335088729858,
-0.1557977795600891,
-0.22889328002929688,
-0.6230268478393555,
-0.3523910641670227,
-0.18456503748893738,
-0.1180366575717926,
0.5421738028526306,
-0.712958037853241,
0.4521029591560364,
0.38026162981987,
-0.2912024259567261,
-0.46550121903419495,
-0.4940645098686218,
0.27289536595344543,
-0.08487345278263092,
-0.6266344785690308,
0.4592532813549042,
-0.06630431860685349,
0.10189194977283478,
-0.08908746391534805,
-0.24169044196605682,
-0.5599740147590637,
0.35247161984443665,
0.3335108458995819,
0.4545615017414093,
0.10518668591976166,
0.17857816815376282,
0.09339139610528946,
-0.26662081480026245,
0.31183186173439026,
-0.2760845422744751,
0.715800404548645,
0.05318969115614891,
-0.07359294593334198,
-0.7385775446891785,
0.40684911608695984,
0.4034428894519806,
-0.08827567100524902,
0.8189370632171631,
0.8266716599464417,
-0.546356201171875,
-0.1908971071243286,
-0.5029371380805969,
-0.3648265600204468,
-0.5005924105644226,
0.10581089556217194,
-0.16789279878139496,
-0.7864218950271606,
0.2355094850063324,
-0.08422728627920151,
0.035346876829862595,
0.04330584406852722,
0.34202519059181213,
-0.09997322410345078,
1.112023115158081,
0.82461017370224,
-0.44619038701057434,
0.5544296503067017,
0.009317136369645596,
0.37055662274360657,
-0.291269987821579,
-0.17626091837882996,
-0.750741720199585,
0.0937514677643776,
-0.5692499279975891,
-0.24056127667427063,
0.11842550337314606,
0.0899730771780014,
0.1794874370098114,
0.5445144176483154,
-0.7538449764251709,
0.26321926712989807,
0.3261205554008484,
0.24788449704647064,
0.18891744315624237,
0.24128484725952148,
-0.03168913349509239,
-0.02021089382469654,
-0.6116002202033997,
-0.9111119508743286,
1.073445439338684,
0.627128541469574,
0.5654236078262329,
0.1079016774892807,
0.5633031725883484,
0.6134548187255859,
0.7331795692443848,
-0.5360543727874756,
0.7602412700653076,
0.015550680458545685,
-0.666934609413147,
-0.08136396110057831,
-0.6809117197990417,
-1.1923584938049316,
0.40194302797317505,
-0.40298154950141907,
-0.6502882838249207,
-0.12062374502420425,
0.012534195557236671,
-0.2075483202934265,
0.4266712963581085,
-0.7005111575126648,
0.5656619071960449,
-0.1381579339504242,
-0.15444882214069366,
-0.02772623486816883,
-0.58371901512146,
0.4923784136772156,
-0.06343448162078857,
0.35397371649742126,
-0.022714991122484207,
-0.015753280371427536,
0.8678163886070251,
-0.26620814204216003,
0.9945539832115173,
-0.3353208303451538,
-0.37171489000320435,
0.3939228653907776,
-0.0314301997423172,
0.42145252227783203,
0.15886008739471436,
-0.04079660773277283,
0.27382972836494446,
-0.10802590101957321,
-0.4379202425479889,
-0.22967098653316498,
0.5661882162094116,
-0.38935622572898865,
-0.07700575888156891,
-0.45362454652786255,
-0.17014433443546295,
-0.022525161504745483,
0.3473571538925171,
0.42160558700561523,
0.37543785572052,
-0.13141664862632751,
0.10119317471981049,
1.0505335330963135,
-0.35214242339134216,
0.7235276699066162,
0.415367990732193,
-0.20550745725631714,
-0.32642069458961487,
0.9788440465927124,
-0.18230289220809937,
0.056076936423778534,
0.5520031452178955,
-0.001467490685172379,
-0.7403198480606079,
-0.7653838992118835,
-0.4420459568500519,
-0.08327741175889969,
-0.3660846948623657,
-0.39460787177085876,
-0.8672186732292175,
-0.3392009139060974,
-0.3663639426231384,
0.14572404325008392,
-0.15802858769893646,
-0.09882782399654388,
-0.3759166896343231,
0.48407241702079773,
0.09094186872243881,
0.49042969942092896,
0.2210082858800888,
0.6037464141845703,
-1.3019826412200928,
0.5550422072410583,
0.07177261263132095,
0.435703843832016,
-0.1615227460861206,
-0.4312343895435333,
-0.2464440017938614,
0.22002965211868286,
-0.39806029200553894,
-1.0166223049163818,
0.5653992295265198,
0.09406442195177078,
0.5083218812942505,
0.371328741312027,
0.17638227343559265,
0.5552258491516113,
-0.23552900552749634,
0.6247979402542114,
0.3067038357257843,
-1.044907569885254,
0.5515150427818298,
-0.11438846588134766,
-0.10762523114681244,
0.08722703158855438,
0.30920708179473877,
-0.6023263931274414,
-0.18563897907733917,
-0.7112267017364502,
-0.4395379424095154,
0.47660547494888306,
0.49740341305732727,
0.1022985652089119,
0.08527764678001404,
0.060822565108537674,
0.06419803202152252,
0.28359198570251465,
-0.9072263836860657,
-0.2675783634185791,
0.028246602043509483,
-0.3647829592227936,
0.1535399854183197,
-0.4815537929534912,
0.22975410521030426,
0.042300958186388016,
0.7030391097068787,
0.24652308225631714,
0.5741551518440247,
0.0358903594315052,
-0.3739510774612427,
0.08301013708114624,
0.5698749423027039,
0.649506688117981,
0.1691378653049469,
-0.07774030417203903,
-0.1342310607433319,
0.22739849984645844,
-0.6696096062660217,
0.17211416363716125,
0.19822977483272552,
-0.007318942807614803,
0.5483033657073975,
0.13430941104888916,
0.36467087268829346,
0.4482533931732178,
-0.5191923379898071,
0.6368617415428162,
-0.15271905064582825,
-0.1842244416475296,
-0.45709285140037537,
0.12330387532711029,
-0.2682092785835266,
-0.12995517253875732,
0.7171111702919006,
0.4883713126182556,
0.3332027792930603,
-0.09311047196388245,
0.21388766169548035,
0.5840896964073181,
-0.48659220337867737,
-0.15196281671524048,
0.28160351514816284,
0.4750858545303345,
-0.6152799129486084,
0.23813927173614502,
-0.32087671756744385,
-0.912026584148407,
0.6370123028755188,
0.6923882365226746,
0.7070827484130859,
-0.5498599410057068,
0.20376397669315338,
0.24740338325500488,
0.36581313610076904,
-0.3046664595603943,
0.1658189594745636,
-0.07852723449468613,
-0.8189612030982971,
-0.3326183557510376,
-0.5174508690834045,
-0.3455635905265808,
0.20738919079303741,
-0.6978689432144165,
0.21014398336410522,
-0.48142969608306885,
-0.4044536054134369,
0.2228652983903885,
0.0113365538418293,
-0.5214074850082397,
0.24455460906028748,
0.10228601843118668,
1.0003398656845093,
-0.656330943107605,
0.9866688251495361,
0.5474774241447449,
0.349962055683136,
-0.07567281275987625,
0.0072029330767691135,
-0.09098977595567703,
-0.3696802258491516,
0.8011600375175476,
0.622443437576294,
-0.18081390857696533,
-0.07661750912666321,
-0.4793631136417389,
-0.2516440749168396,
0.42217350006103516,
-0.14821040630340576,
-0.50843745470047,
0.3360305428504944,
0.2859092056751251,
0.5557178258895874,
-0.15063995122909546,
0.12574011087417603,
0.3490511476993561,
0.2850881516933441,
-0.2812459468841553,
-0.879443347454071,
-0.17531535029411316,
-0.26777270436286926,
0.12635894119739532,
0.6851316690444946,
-0.0899318978190422,
0.46431419253349304,
0.290332555770874,
-0.3506162464618683,
0.27869662642478943,
0.5365119576454163,
0.042653996497392654,
0.590823769569397,
0.6062663197517395,
0.3678458034992218,
0.5154068470001221,
-0.2705736756324768,
0.5929029583930969,
-0.06584221124649048,
0.3597356379032135,
0.556121289730072,
-0.2700522840023041,
0.6970841884613037,
0.27449163794517517,
-0.18796932697296143,
0.42544907331466675,
0.6692194938659668,
0.09613225609064102,
0.5202621817588806,
0.20410031080245972,
-0.6850012540817261,
-0.17511917650699615,
0.1553163081407547,
-0.2625691294670105,
0.25168511271476746,
0.6885443329811096,
-0.3175576329231262,
-0.3471871614456177,
0.4494325816631317,
-0.07602295279502869,
0.34522783756256104,
-0.3667718768119812,
0.812631368637085,
-0.13761335611343384,
-0.3690011501312256,
0.6234788298606873,
0.3677985966205597,
1.339040994644165,
-0.5865593552589417,
0.1570674479007721,
0.30407026410102844,
0.41366949677467346,
-0.18222422897815704,
-0.6456407904624939,
0.3761254549026489,
0.2332361489534378,
-0.18967437744140625,
-0.5084895491600037,
1.436149001121521,
-0.3270231783390045,
-0.2022736668586731,
0.21594250202178955,
0.2134658247232437,
0.2617226839065552,
-0.28079769015312195,
-1.1921272277832031,
0.1078009158372879,
0.10882163047790527,
0.0710730105638504,
0.26913103461265564,
0.21431215107440948,
0.28547340631484985,
1.040879487991333,
1.136398196220398,
0.08822150528430939,
0.10259836167097092,
-0.13535694777965546,
0.7025473117828369,
-0.6823046207427979,
-0.85602205991745,
-1.1874877214431763,
0.17285171151161194,
-0.6995500922203064,
-0.12498973309993744,
0.8979161381721497,
0.8597748279571533,
0.5654380321502686,
-0.16370166838169098,
0.6879265904426575,
0.1578264981508255,
0.9713007807731628,
-0.2726212739944458,
0.37713927030563354,
0.059998296201229095,
0.7987856864929199,
-0.12922058999538422,
-0.7879536747932434,
-0.3217584490776062,
0.594063401222229,
-0.4230697751045227,
-0.19531840085983276,
0.22353295981884003,
0.6640229821205139,
0.06482639163732529,
0.6374840140342712,
0.025401417165994644,
-0.32489174604415894,
0.4761485755443573,
0.4423304796218872,
0.9718671441078186,
-0.6977447867393494,
0.8270043134689331,
-0.288160115480423,
-0.2136785238981247,
-0.6308749318122864,
-0.585281252861023,
-1.2724303007125854,
-0.21396075189113617,
-0.09494603425264359,
-0.40238896012306213,
0.029827997088432312,
0.8485766053199768,
0.7044627666473389,
-0.7796919345855713,
-0.23221267759799957,
-0.15457306802272797,
0.4413893520832062,
-0.18829874694347382,
-0.29746946692466736,
-0.03947987034916878,
-0.6070567965507507,
-0.7252596020698547,
0.21410506963729858,
0.3798176348209381,
0.4530581533908844,
0.09793417900800705,
0.10848494619131088,
-0.16242685914039612,
0.06512767821550369,
0.7757427096366882,
0.30370602011680603,
-0.3696380853652954,
0.12749464809894562,
0.1382787674665451,
-0.5150803923606873,
-0.05044041574001312,
0.8014073371887207,
-0.8963706493377686,
0.1034712865948677,
0.23851899802684784,
0.873046875,
0.16309772431850433,
0.0903942883014679,
0.270044207572937,
-0.7944232821464539,
0.12854748964309692,
0.5154784917831421,
0.0016851886175572872,
0.1610220968723297,
-0.561469316482544,
0.1472286731004715,
0.16551710665225983,
-0.41487863659858704,
-1.1288548707962036,
-0.003935593646019697,
-0.8378796577453613,
-0.350864976644516,
0.6974843144416809,
0.06716866791248322,
-0.2783389687538147,
-0.8374632000923157,
-0.6879394054412842,
0.06316710263490677,
-0.5087450742721558,
0.8071687817573547,
0.33538785576820374,
0.06396547704935074,
-0.04037860780954361,
-0.43860748410224915,
0.49645355343818665,
0.5664699673652649,
-1.0359153747558594,
-0.20560818910598755,
0.05075952038168907,
0.4169090986251831,
0.15021738409996033,
0.7018731236457825,
-0.12552474439144135,
0.1972663402557373,
-0.5841569304466248,
-0.15908975899219513,
0.1390610784292221,
-0.07238097488880157,
-0.2912043631076813,
0.42952629923820496,
-0.5337047576904297,
-0.5541506409645081
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.02301v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.02301v1
|
mCoT: Multilingual Instruction Tuning for Reasoning Consistency in Language Models
| 2024-06-04T13:30:45 | 2024-06-04T13:30:45 |
Huiyuan Lai, Malvina Nissim
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) with Chain-of-thought (CoT) have recently
emerged as a powerful technique for eliciting reasoning to improve various
downstream tasks. As most research mainly focuses on English, with few
explorations in a multilingual context, the question of how reliable this
reasoning capability is in different languages is still open. To address it
directly, we study multilingual reasoning consistency across multiple
languages, using popular open-source LLMs. First, we compile the first
large-scale multilingual math reasoning dataset, mCoT-MATH, covering eleven
diverse languages. Then, we introduce multilingual CoT instruction tuning to
boost reasoning capability across languages, thereby improving model
consistency. While existing LLMs show substantial variation across the
languages we consider, and especially low performance for lesser resourced
languages, our 7B parameter model mCoT achieves impressive consistency across
languages, and superior or comparable performance to close- and open-source
models even of much larger sizes.
|
[
-0.3037038743495941,
-0.8877434730529785,
0.7357611060142517,
0.26669400930404663,
-0.18083423376083374,
0.15929797291755676,
-0.6208505034446716,
-0.41541802883148193,
0.07886172831058502,
0.678101658821106,
-0.5133838653564453,
-0.6157447099685669,
-0.6243002414703369,
0.21594269573688507,
0.20399783551692963,
0.8215819597244263,
-0.2924697697162628,
0.3218645453453064,
-0.345920592546463,
-0.4528370499610901,
-0.4946824312210083,
-0.6849108338356018,
-0.698213517665863,
-0.21855393052101135,
0.6289372444152832,
0.5621489882469177,
0.9471893906593323,
0.5962933897972107,
0.6380333304405212,
0.25918400287628174,
0.09687787294387817,
0.8443694114685059,
-0.24531586468219757,
0.163960799574852,
-0.5099462866783142,
-0.45300614833831787,
-0.5422040820121765,
-0.27000850439071655,
0.7607669234275818,
0.6332836151123047,
-0.43974849581718445,
-0.07600469887256622,
-0.2064526230096817,
0.596043050289154,
-0.8039273023605347,
0.1762426644563675,
-0.8302631974220276,
-0.3636323809623718,
-0.10122274607419968,
0.02101554162800312,
-0.8137415647506714,
-0.3872668743133545,
-0.2649199962615967,
-0.5740953087806702,
0.028266752138733864,
0.06503426283597946,
0.590340793132782,
0.11533041298389435,
-0.6903764009475708,
-0.4753367602825165,
-0.4774588942527771,
0.9972832202911377,
-0.5702500939369202,
0.9085195064544678,
0.5596123337745667,
0.3076108396053314,
-0.15873564779758453,
-0.4299249053001404,
-0.4949563443660736,
-0.3937591016292572,
0.044937364757061005,
-0.14548221230506897,
0.2220631241798401,
-0.07241035997867584,
0.2562008500099182,
0.08806248009204865,
-0.4820563495159149,
-0.05726507306098938,
-0.10429628938436508,
-0.3732573688030243,
0.607258677482605,
-0.11777070164680481,
0.17838504910469055,
0.24269618093967438,
-0.2380693256855011,
-0.1504771113395691,
-0.7580897212028503,
-0.17540614306926727,
0.3987226188182831,
0.3289662003517151,
-0.17067183554172516,
0.7646298408508301,
-0.03959960490465164,
0.8346772789955139,
-0.23134976625442505,
-0.38515934348106384,
0.0706678032875061,
-0.22697456181049347,
-0.0463591106235981,
0.18325787782669067,
0.5783266425132751,
0.10188847780227661,
0.5945118069648743,
-0.05950776860117912,
-0.10337881743907928,
0.16409941017627716,
-0.05639141425490379,
-0.4576919972896576,
-0.2566016614437103,
0.04519503563642502,
0.07345321029424667,
0.23808889091014862,
0.09065279364585876,
-0.4319251775741577,
-0.11796461790800095,
-0.5469015836715698,
0.07499802857637405,
-0.42668724060058594,
-0.36590221524238586,
0.37588417530059814,
0.29335540533065796,
0.03818073123693466,
0.31666386127471924,
-0.8964253067970276,
0.04766916483640671,
0.6993067860603333,
0.6017456650733948,
-0.12564310431480408,
-0.6149575114250183,
-0.822519838809967,
0.43409210443496704,
-0.5428094267845154,
0.7840690612792969,
-0.8151569366455078,
-0.08464761823415756,
-0.1565277874469757,
0.19055116176605225,
-0.28677430748939514,
-0.4714936912059784,
0.4810863733291626,
-0.44465336203575134,
0.03957574442028999,
-0.4615362584590912,
-0.5767437815666199,
-0.04900342598557472,
0.687946081161499,
-0.5307055115699768,
1.010943055152893,
-0.20213264226913452,
-0.5354911088943481,
0.13895201683044434,
-0.38789933919906616,
-0.41664257645606995,
-0.34177088737487793,
-0.2341298758983612,
-0.2921234667301178,
0.17391519248485565,
0.5368394255638123,
0.12891952693462372,
-0.3297516405582428,
0.3885214328765869,
-0.5220337510108948,
-0.1532132923603058,
0.22859899699687958,
-0.6964197754859924,
0.8587731719017029,
0.23879796266555786,
-0.16826075315475464,
-0.05032496526837349,
-0.5693022012710571,
0.28239935636520386,
-0.006995577365159988,
-0.0473003089427948,
-0.16307108104228973,
-0.07188982516527176,
-0.34011727571487427,
0.3027521073818207,
0.23856335878372192,
-0.5752267241477966,
0.2966500520706177,
-0.009304272010922432,
0.41082942485809326,
0.7118567228317261,
-0.1305374652147293,
0.10162515938282013,
-0.23243659734725952,
0.5565239787101746,
0.3034074902534485,
0.004685820080339909,
-0.3554176688194275,
-0.5975364446640015,
-0.6226031184196472,
-0.44286274909973145,
0.46737056970596313,
0.506351113319397,
-0.930444598197937,
-0.10606520622968674,
-0.1815311461687088,
-0.2677992880344391,
-0.4890441298484802,
0.28335466980934143,
0.5832390189170837,
0.24554498493671417,
0.30929458141326904,
0.1359199583530426,
-0.3428947329521179,
-0.8417174816131592,
-0.43119776248931885,
-0.023622648790478706,
0.32605817914009094,
0.16244573891162872,
0.38585248589515686,
-0.2833396792411804,
0.45549777150154114,
-0.3826000392436981,
0.19540350139141083,
-0.22209979593753815,
-0.09867024421691895,
0.15391767024993896,
0.5135147571563721,
0.3825344145298004,
-0.5832351446151733,
-0.59247887134552,
0.3475798964500427,
-0.7024420499801636,
0.004578959662467241,
0.11366716027259827,
-0.676522433757782,
0.5187937021255493,
0.551232099533081,
-0.585159182548523,
0.16790638864040375,
0.7899932265281677,
-0.16925722360610962,
0.5970118045806885,
-0.42659664154052734,
0.4118436574935913,
-1.0048046112060547,
-0.36184677481651306,
-0.23388949036598206,
-0.3203381896018982,
-0.18737685680389404,
0.3413536250591278,
0.46761569380760193,
0.014973971992731094,
-0.5914979577064514,
0.8505797386169434,
-0.59474778175354,
0.15063908696174622,
-0.076783686876297,
0.42030206322669983,
0.2060333490371704,
0.37535393238067627,
0.14065074920654297,
0.8423347473144531,
0.666530191898346,
-0.6808122992515564,
0.2663711905479431,
-0.06822129338979721,
-0.1728561520576477,
0.8908315300941467,
-0.46222659945487976,
0.4445980191230774,
-0.00005335029709385708,
0.2064821422100067,
-0.7672287225723267,
-0.3307502269744873,
-0.05452588573098183,
-0.2642563283443451,
0.3060111701488495,
-0.16095498204231262,
-0.8376553654670715,
-0.17358984053134918,
0.019709531217813492,
0.6000447273254395,
0.10829712450504303,
-0.867989718914032,
0.7879244685173035,
0.22545765340328217,
0.11653114855289459,
-0.79350346326828,
-0.6613684296607971,
-0.2688134014606476,
0.13434189558029175,
-0.7228482365608215,
-0.07064273208379745,
-0.274716317653656,
-0.40334123373031616,
-0.16233421862125397,
-0.26130107045173645,
-0.21675647795200348,
-0.21438592672348022,
-0.2684671878814697,
0.2844919264316559,
-0.36382177472114563,
0.5375970602035522,
0.4212694764137268,
-0.028485989198088646,
-0.11844270676374435,
-0.5441938042640686,
0.5068346261978149,
-0.3760763704776764,
-0.8015313744544983,
-0.14232368767261505,
0.3113575279712677,
0.6408268213272095,
-0.4722602367401123,
1.060428500175476,
0.6039820313453674,
-0.2860918343067169,
-0.18997107446193695,
-0.7005869746208191,
0.0022877866867929697,
-0.434896320104599,
0.10215426981449127,
-0.8061932921409607,
-0.8651946187019348,
0.6036629676818848,
-0.1389639526605606,
0.1658278852701187,
0.5108757615089417,
0.6018838286399841,
0.02069530077278614,
1.3604817390441895,
0.5631162524223328,
0.2814766466617584,
0.10371298342943192,
-0.0352645069360733,
0.12162841111421585,
-0.668677568435669,
-0.28103306889533997,
-0.4337923228740692,
-0.16094987094402313,
-0.7120555639266968,
-0.5447133183479309,
0.38894379138946533,
0.38971978425979614,
-0.43750303983688354,
0.08387798070907593,
-0.2585807144641876,
1.120330572128296,
0.5175334811210632,
0.10688690841197968,
0.39786434173583984,
0.016026554629206657,
-0.7004539370536804,
0.12477795034646988,
-0.7989474534988403,
-0.7035550475120544,
1.0657349824905396,
-0.06315014511346817,
0.7770405411720276,
0.4538170099258423,
0.5593695044517517,
0.010481893084943295,
0.28850987553596497,
-0.4513412117958069,
0.41196179389953613,
-0.30823829770088196,
-0.7967498302459717,
-0.12938722968101501,
-0.6570569276809692,
-0.843858003616333,
0.36585307121276855,
0.03972689434885979,
-0.7641593813896179,
-0.1418159157037735,
0.41528549790382385,
0.2274406999349594,
0.5501707792282104,
-0.9378802180290222,
0.954743504524231,
-0.5030823945999146,
-0.5792098641395569,
-0.3141249418258667,
-0.4811021685600281,
0.6396048665046692,
-0.02066127397119999,
0.4434099495410919,
-0.40412673354148865,
-0.022234831005334854,
0.1819467395544052,
-0.5113272666931152,
0.5037006735801697,
0.11654824763536453,
-0.2718382477760315,
0.443471223115921,
0.17893517017364502,
0.6013779640197754,
0.3541969656944275,
-0.20653991401195526,
0.4650064706802368,
0.17846642434597015,
-0.8674907088279724,
-0.7077144384384155,
0.989245593547821,
-0.7721230983734131,
-0.5479599833488464,
-0.24431325495243073,
-0.9493065476417542,
-0.47186678647994995,
0.17737005650997162,
0.10877944529056549,
0.4778186082839966,
0.11402244865894318,
0.16359980404376984,
0.8545475006103516,
-0.11871760338544846,
0.26789987087249756,
0.3725791871547699,
-0.4632013142108917,
-0.6843857765197754,
0.8061882257461548,
0.04810771346092224,
0.6863852739334106,
0.5812894105911255,
0.17131683230400085,
-0.5192705392837524,
0.03717834874987602,
-0.8697939515113831,
0.5035659074783325,
-0.9801760315895081,
-0.2237771898508072,
-0.4401458501815796,
-0.04345197230577469,
-0.3057800531387329,
-0.24022553861141205,
-0.6905674338340759,
-0.5571621656417847,
0.2275685966014862,
0.12534624338150024,
0.3392676115036011,
0.6052650213241577,
0.1716070920228958,
0.13602761924266815,
-0.918075442314148,
0.34846246242523193,
0.1687135100364685,
0.5404797792434692,
-0.01841956190764904,
-0.363587886095047,
-0.36869195103645325,
0.497733473777771,
-0.4489282965660095,
-0.6670438051223755,
-0.020236656069755554,
0.1408475935459137,
0.7741352915763855,
0.21094369888305664,
0.07702545821666718,
0.6646053194999695,
-0.5594605207443237,
0.5903536081314087,
0.24224939942359924,
-1.181822419166565,
0.4646407663822174,
-0.26310744881629944,
0.64723140001297,
0.3479686677455902,
0.38891127705574036,
-0.4482472240924835,
-0.5812131762504578,
-0.6217030882835388,
-0.351872980594635,
0.5242390036582947,
0.021671941503882408,
-0.0010408121161162853,
-0.5042370557785034,
0.19652019441127777,
0.19208508729934692,
0.21502678096294403,
-0.6068959832191467,
-0.06488240510225296,
-0.15037032961845398,
-0.4783129096031189,
-0.2431718111038208,
-0.011135529726743698,
-0.17389774322509766,
-0.3346010744571686,
0.664510190486908,
-0.35214346647262573,
0.03747124224901199,
-0.01055719144642353,
-0.3394564986228943,
-0.10806118696928024,
0.340060830116272,
1.1715506315231323,
1.12490713596344,
0.06969550251960754,
0.5485668778419495,
0.3133533298969269,
-0.5286492705345154,
0.33289721608161926,
-0.1737530529499054,
0.12093164026737213,
-0.014536305330693722,
0.4135313034057617,
0.7403330206871033,
0.3205430507659912,
-0.8759692907333374,
0.0805724635720253,
-0.06441300362348557,
-0.25510427355766296,
-0.08167819678783417,
0.07285965979099274,
0.25709986686706543,
0.23088407516479492,
-0.1883554309606552,
0.13249361515045166,
-0.4758462905883789,
-0.639397919178009,
0.01243699062615633,
0.37116870284080505,
-0.09801216423511505,
-0.1669379025697708,
0.6932900547981262,
-0.10353200882673264,
-0.3599657714366913,
0.8203747272491455,
-0.21365758776664734,
-0.4648028612136841,
0.5709213018417358,
0.6625534892082214,
0.6794131398200989,
-0.21969644725322723,
0.08350656926631927,
0.40533944964408875,
0.6739578247070312,
-0.39346957206726074,
0.5404935479164124,
0.10313516855239868,
-0.8277199268341064,
-0.5930429100990295,
-0.5184161067008972,
-0.8083792924880981,
-0.4132757782936096,
-0.5547752976417542,
0.4251214265823364,
-0.3781490623950958,
-0.0917639210820198,
-0.1851114183664322,
-0.09893818944692612,
-0.6165898442268372,
0.12980087101459503,
0.1275544911623001,
0.8457763195037842,
-0.5814170837402344,
1.2212753295898438,
0.8054447770118713,
-0.20648601651191711,
-0.961017906665802,
-0.24392035603523254,
-0.041927170008420944,
-0.8693267703056335,
0.3315444588661194,
0.15450361371040344,
-0.4990823268890381,
-0.0003412757650949061,
-0.5110032558441162,
-1.0084186792373657,
0.8178688287734985,
1.0395585298538208,
-0.859820544719696,
0.3261222839355469,
0.18942591547966003,
0.37687304615974426,
-0.5729120969772339,
0.3125705122947693,
0.4450250566005707,
0.5154077410697937,
0.3293474018573761,
-1.0302746295928955,
-0.3851518929004669,
0.0009211889700964093,
-0.19003550708293915,
0.6424663066864014,
-0.7653173804283142,
0.8108947277069092,
-0.5398195385932922,
0.26535072922706604,
-0.20345774292945862,
0.5207971930503845,
0.9125375151634216,
0.4901715815067291,
0.27637216448783875,
0.8102227449417114,
1.2174357175827026,
-0.255623459815979,
1.2697837352752686,
-0.494139701128006,
0.24302612245082855,
1.3657541275024414,
-0.3244183361530304,
1.0054856538772583,
0.31862616539001465,
0.005372160114347935,
0.7673813104629517,
0.5520597100257874,
0.40420931577682495,
0.20770128071308136,
-0.09316086024045944,
-0.0867612436413765,
-0.5012461543083191,
-0.016022514551877975,
-0.3457680940628052,
0.3942873477935791,
0.1998341828584671,
-0.2205604463815689,
0.04029844328761101,
0.07475816458463669,
0.1298784464597702,
0.24862053990364075,
-0.551419198513031,
0.40598049759864807,
0.06822072714567184,
-0.8671244382858276,
0.8629696369171143,
-0.00482237758114934,
0.174327090382576,
-0.5822045207023621,
-0.07561737298965454,
-0.29334577918052673,
0.4363986849784851,
0.07362750917673111,
-0.6684014797210693,
0.29630061984062195,
0.033816125243902206,
-0.4435674846172333,
0.01439650822430849,
0.24409154057502747,
-0.8174529671669006,
-0.9652643799781799,
0.13308212161064148,
0.6188820600509644,
0.26865559816360474,
0.09916669875383377,
-0.6620247960090637,
0.36059075593948364,
-0.12124720960855484,
0.0813324972987175,
0.14529569447040558,
0.840802788734436,
-0.3582371473312378,
0.8203617334365845,
0.5942463278770447,
0.0029184073209762573,
0.3735339939594269,
0.43592122197151184,
0.47297513484954834,
-0.595787763595581,
-0.27736741304397583,
-0.9333376288414001,
0.6223485469818115,
-0.04592112824320793,
-0.36630070209503174,
0.8488223552703857,
0.5443839430809021,
1.2858233451843262,
-0.05333174020051956,
0.2966919243335724,
0.37404653429985046,
0.3315451145172119,
-0.853624701499939,
0.28936222195625305,
-0.5482637882232666,
0.400888055562973,
-0.04778332635760307,
-1.1914029121398926,
-0.323007732629776,
0.5790035724639893,
-0.3808612525463104,
0.23022638261318207,
1.1793586015701294,
0.5995969176292419,
-0.3199174106121063,
0.09353162348270416,
0.4749455749988556,
0.02702893130481243,
0.30008524656295776,
0.4474862515926361,
0.6890210509300232,
-0.26789411902427673,
0.4404406249523163,
-0.2707420289516449,
-0.002625485882163048,
0.2170935422182083,
-1.010408878326416,
-1.0427392721176147,
-0.15903927385807037,
-0.41607895493507385,
-0.24318112432956696,
0.05032799392938614,
1.1414239406585693,
0.7493166327476501,
-0.9722400903701782,
-0.46113479137420654,
-0.16716565191745758,
0.6401814818382263,
-0.4617851972579956,
-0.1862253099679947,
0.23192128539085388,
-0.7053397297859192,
-0.7436723113059998,
0.14973904192447662,
0.4256979525089264,
-0.30870920419692993,
-0.15664918720722198,
-0.36783069372177124,
-0.49089205265045166,
0.41473495960235596,
0.649335503578186,
-0.026077840477228165,
-1.0985450744628906,
-0.2854872941970825,
0.20904025435447693,
-0.15391409397125244,
0.04016074165701866,
0.7888941168785095,
-0.2701270878314972,
0.827392578125,
0.15330496430397034,
0.6577183604240417,
0.3539726734161377,
-0.13923484086990356,
0.6118251085281372,
-0.7251284718513489,
0.2426244020462036,
0.02572096325457096,
0.5589672923088074,
0.40210461616516113,
-0.13937993347644806,
0.5893964171409607,
0.23840820789337158,
-0.7315630912780762,
-0.8753012418746948,
0.3543677031993866,
-0.8944174647331238,
-0.24823430180549622,
1.0192152261734009,
-0.29123491048812866,
-0.06843442469835281,
0.16714926064014435,
-0.22742584347724915,
0.09260052442550659,
-0.1116076409816742,
0.5168448090553284,
1.0876847505569458,
-0.1349145621061325,
-0.5536190271377563,
-0.556361734867096,
0.07567337900400162,
0.3317701518535614,
-0.7066456079483032,
0.08085713535547256,
0.34142184257507324,
0.10369299352169037,
0.02994309924542904,
0.3631035387516022,
-0.021906228736042976,
0.4283497631549835,
0.19505272805690765,
-0.03423752263188362,
-0.01293278206139803,
-0.6619551777839661,
0.05758782848715782,
0.05549859628081322,
0.21562083065509796,
0.10391129553318024
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.02267v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.02267v1
|
Prompting Large Language Models with Human Error Markings for Self-Correcting Machine Translation
| 2024-06-04T12:43:47 | 2024-06-04T12:43:47 |
Nathaniel Berger, Stefan Riezler, Miriam Exel, Matthias Huck
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
While large language models (LLMs) pre-trained on massive amounts of unpaired
language data have reached the state-of-the-art in machine translation (MT) of
general domain texts, post-editing (PE) is still required to correct errors and
to enhance term translation quality in specialized domains. In this paper we
present a pilot study of enhancing translation memories (TM) produced by PE
(source segments, machine translations, and reference translations, henceforth
called PE-TM) for the needs of correct and consistent term translation in
technical domains.
We investigate a light-weight two-step scenario where, at inference time, a
human translator marks errors in the first translation step, and in a second
step a few similar examples are extracted from the PE-TM to prompt an LLM. Our
experiment shows that the additional effort of augmenting translations with
human error markings guides the LLM to focus on a correction of the marked
errors, yielding consistent improvements over automatic PE (APE) and MT from
scratch.
|
[
0.024581629782915115,
-0.6047973036766052,
0.7526710033416748,
0.39884015917778015,
-0.18030506372451782,
0.27144715189933777,
-0.3298388719558716,
-0.1735839694738388,
0.1385335624217987,
0.7442508339881897,
-0.5000756978988647,
-0.43658554553985596,
-0.49126705527305603,
0.3491726815700531,
-0.26455190777778625,
0.7520822286605835,
-0.5365569591522217,
0.0472785085439682,
-0.044024623930454254,
-0.1559382677078247,
-0.9082286357879639,
-0.9606990218162537,
-0.7136752605438232,
-0.29341185092926025,
0.5693911910057068,
0.3803139626979828,
0.5566766858100891,
0.6638433337211609,
0.1777309626340866,
0.27866658568382263,
0.1733136773109436,
0.7253915071487427,
-0.06562819331884384,
0.011528736911714077,
-0.39044952392578125,
-0.28551217913627625,
-1.0794800519943237,
-0.06828461587429047,
0.6174446940422058,
0.6714475750923157,
0.26447126269340515,
-0.10811162739992142,
0.2828276753425598,
0.6084819436073303,
-0.33520030975341797,
0.008210058324038982,
-0.42529213428497314,
-0.11160195618867874,
-0.17121388018131256,
-0.4906345009803772,
-0.6079049706459045,
0.018771367147564888,
-0.11854539066553116,
-0.6822428107261658,
0.287945032119751,
0.06885001063346863,
0.9001593589782715,
0.4768325388431549,
-0.20903755724430084,
-0.06969277560710907,
-0.8017396330833435,
0.7531700730323792,
-0.6450169682502747,
0.3337727189064026,
0.4264843463897705,
-0.28268003463745117,
-0.3062409460544586,
-0.47766193747520447,
-0.40198132395744324,
0.05340021103620529,
-0.1226855143904686,
0.02431071363389492,
-0.03075936809182167,
0.09804638475179672,
0.32366707921028137,
-0.12515047192573547,
-0.29147589206695557,
0.2709236741065979,
-0.32118740677833557,
-0.2872684895992279,
0.46812567114830017,
0.12544120848178864,
0.38853344321250916,
0.09279166907072067,
-0.10896793007850647,
-0.13433262705802917,
-1.0966962575912476,
-0.3575098514556885,
0.0777277797460556,
0.15840062499046326,
0.15024462342262268,
0.5614994168281555,
-0.08794235438108444,
0.8958404064178467,
0.31994393467903137,
0.23895184695720673,
0.22028347849845886,
-0.3541416525840759,
-0.17463329434394836,
0.13251198828220367,
0.749046266078949,
0.5944696068763733,
0.46482017636299133,
-0.2831973433494568,
-0.5035731792449951,
-0.1753596067428589,
0.40467777848243713,
-0.5551237463951111,
-0.3988744616508484,
0.019201798364520073,
-0.06839842349290848,
0.015608762390911579,
-0.017409710213541985,
-0.4209650158882141,
-0.3247390687465668,
-0.40953749418258667,
0.8292426466941833,
-0.400465190410614,
-0.004242683760821819,
0.3881543278694153,
0.05341338738799095,
-0.12917593121528625,
0.6218830347061157,
-0.8235030770301819,
-0.13082699477672577,
0.4378761351108551,
0.7951903343200684,
-0.10413885861635208,
-0.5453632473945618,
-0.5661770701408386,
0.4622359871864319,
-0.6582682132720947,
1.0291342735290527,
-0.36012396216392517,
-0.6981971263885498,
-0.13188564777374268,
-0.025794876739382744,
-0.15248678624629974,
-0.6865225434303284,
0.49330759048461914,
-0.5584885478019714,
0.2239677757024765,
-0.3765468895435333,
-0.5239502191543579,
-0.11115111410617828,
0.15535230934619904,
-0.3647797703742981,
1.1311429738998413,
0.2010619193315506,
-0.3331756591796875,
0.3013310432434082,
-0.8301204442977905,
-0.485205739736557,
-0.09886355698108673,
-0.010642594657838345,
-0.3102227747440338,
0.27102696895599365,
0.3519009053707123,
0.43154120445251465,
0.024691332131624222,
0.1286480724811554,
0.10377483814954758,
-0.2089434266090393,
0.3251509964466095,
-0.17767386138439178,
0.30020907521247864,
-0.06789258122444153,
-0.26627638936042786,
0.269381046295166,
-0.5500959753990173,
-0.058488961309194565,
-0.017189905047416687,
-0.44218936562538147,
-0.5016049146652222,
-0.008883780799806118,
-0.41739654541015625,
0.40130892395973206,
0.33640056848526,
-0.37437736988067627,
0.42715659737586975,
-0.1361435204744339,
0.43332627415657043,
0.8978783488273621,
0.09955092519521713,
0.4080211818218231,
-0.25291144847869873,
0.3789476454257965,
0.22087424993515015,
-0.09086007624864578,
-0.5586571097373962,
-0.42395877838134766,
-1.0273241996765137,
0.1552949994802475,
0.5742074251174927,
0.5280238389968872,
-0.8583502769470215,
0.49570566415786743,
-0.33109837770462036,
-0.16407093405723572,
-0.654695987701416,
0.28618088364601135,
0.4366135001182556,
0.7147380709648132,
0.6943283081054688,
-0.22497624158859253,
-0.6233584880828857,
-0.6601499915122986,
-0.43214017152786255,
-0.14479215443134308,
-0.15367043018341064,
0.17142656445503235,
0.13627342879772186,
-0.489033579826355,
0.8058374524116516,
-0.20347261428833008,
-0.3878757059574127,
0.013523831963539124,
0.3984992504119873,
-0.07763590663671494,
0.6587954759597778,
0.24252155423164368,
-0.3394924998283386,
-0.6022431254386902,
0.0062006618827581406,
-0.6330475211143494,
-0.6053918600082397,
-0.4803720712661743,
-0.21296897530555725,
0.40349292755126953,
0.5631304383277893,
-0.5412613153457642,
0.18205444514751434,
0.5015153884887695,
-0.4368128478527069,
0.5756576061248779,
-0.8371120691299438,
0.6991662383079529,
-0.7253672480583191,
-0.01061872486025095,
-0.17065271735191345,
-0.30682268738746643,
-0.7349370718002319,
-0.338286817073822,
0.43720725178718567,
0.23447787761688232,
-0.34337854385375977,
0.6799311637878418,
-0.6130279302597046,
-0.010349458083510399,
-0.5631619095802307,
0.18194299936294556,
0.27532145380973816,
0.22830146551132202,
0.1680588573217392,
1.1554023027420044,
0.15471166372299194,
-0.7035086154937744,
-0.0835985317826271,
0.22255244851112366,
0.04921203851699829,
0.5113013982772827,
-0.555961549282074,
0.5625293850898743,
0.007310184650123119,
-0.041665732860565186,
-0.7806529402732849,
-0.3264141380786896,
0.2677675783634186,
-0.3670399785041809,
0.48510921001434326,
0.1015445813536644,
-0.7655144929885864,
-0.2801051735877991,
0.022389909252524376,
0.3219348192214966,
0.42235758900642395,
-0.5289677977561951,
0.41843685507774353,
0.08679961413145065,
-0.16071632504463196,
-0.24958288669586182,
-0.7749741077423096,
0.51771479845047,
0.11857887357473373,
-0.6502482295036316,
0.37141403555870056,
-0.030603863298892975,
0.02973577380180359,
-0.013067707419395447,
0.004275822080671787,
-0.13352148234844208,
0.20767031610012054,
0.0751836746931076,
0.4512997269630432,
-0.17349281907081604,
0.23882004618644714,
0.17969505488872528,
-0.2837945818901062,
-0.0055192033760249615,
-0.4761125147342682,
0.43697524070739746,
0.20367535948753357,
-0.22848711907863617,
-0.6335446238517761,
0.26068371534347534,
0.4148431718349457,
-0.18641048669815063,
0.5441738963127136,
0.08805794268846512,
-0.44589558243751526,
-0.03603887930512428,
-0.7073506116867065,
-0.243662491440773,
-0.473971962928772,
0.2434074878692627,
-0.5001559853553772,
-0.8234664797782898,
0.17199237644672394,
-0.25774088501930237,
0.00003664525138447061,
0.7444878816604614,
0.22716252505779266,
-0.3732950985431671,
1.0891247987747192,
0.4271019399166107,
0.1399606466293335,
0.3146754205226898,
0.049957968294620514,
0.053995463997125626,
-0.9608819484710693,
0.05035215988755226,
-0.5295275449752808,
-0.3406349718570709,
-0.10884180665016174,
-0.8302103877067566,
0.22427153587341309,
0.2535431683063507,
-0.07231343537569046,
0.42013049125671387,
-0.34459471702575684,
0.5736802220344543,
0.44926023483276367,
0.16525620222091675,
0.46028685569763184,
0.1957559883594513,
-0.23207440972328186,
-0.4353662431240082,
-0.6832717061042786,
-0.7753475308418274,
1.0668083429336548,
0.08365365862846375,
0.5443254113197327,
-0.5310952067375183,
0.6432254910469055,
0.32420071959495544,
0.5575551986694336,
-0.4226871132850647,
0.4116100072860718,
-0.3365813195705414,
-0.4758211672306061,
-0.11349628120660782,
-0.32725656032562256,
-0.7798260450363159,
-0.07718586176633835,
-0.07695019245147705,
-0.421315997838974,
0.10807161778211594,
0.7799763083457947,
-0.4773595333099365,
0.40179187059402466,
-0.6693294048309326,
1.136775016784668,
-0.5468847155570984,
-0.16492310166358948,
-0.4126288890838623,
-0.40759631991386414,
-0.025509092956781387,
-0.4646284580230713,
0.07989152520895004,
0.29598861932754517,
-0.3346779942512512,
0.7562670707702637,
-0.3009074032306671,
0.76982182264328,
-0.2132805585861206,
-0.130685955286026,
0.3027869760990143,
0.26938244700431824,
0.9250344634056091,
-0.69218909740448,
-0.3225463032722473,
0.19550824165344238,
-0.5257827043533325,
-0.3099476099014282,
-0.5101993680000305,
0.39321982860565186,
-0.7925978302955627,
-0.8121573328971863,
-0.2984153628349304,
-0.4760172963142395,
-0.4117754399776459,
0.2521992325782776,
0.18324218690395355,
0.25363078713417053,
0.04318530112504959,
0.07250982522964478,
0.8055393695831299,
-0.38282978534698486,
0.27114152908325195,
0.6213041543960571,
-0.11994806677103043,
-0.33306264877319336,
0.8737120628356934,
0.3069051504135132,
0.4896167516708374,
0.2103138267993927,
0.039807237684726715,
-0.2732565701007843,
-0.7534500360488892,
-0.8478589057922363,
0.5026518106460571,
-0.5513685941696167,
-0.22448718547821045,
-0.8756266236305237,
-0.02411896362900734,
-0.18398429453372955,
-0.3154841363430023,
-0.5329508781433105,
-0.3502485454082489,
-0.46478745341300964,
-0.11164944618940353,
0.2627750039100647,
0.7595824003219604,
-0.07473625987768173,
0.7520878314971924,
-1.2848684787750244,
0.18123242259025574,
0.03289451077580452,
0.18309444189071655,
-0.27089667320251465,
-0.8696339726448059,
-0.5882939100265503,
0.2701139450073242,
-0.36397889256477356,
-0.6842367053031921,
0.39986053109169006,
0.26682859659194946,
0.2459564208984375,
0.017285024747252464,
-0.2354227602481842,
0.9955868124961853,
-0.7906400561332703,
0.8245250582695007,
0.1881738007068634,
-1.1602429151535034,
0.7301130294799805,
-0.3672332763671875,
0.3286101520061493,
0.344094842672348,
0.06337687373161316,
-0.9245575070381165,
-0.4174022078514099,
-0.5412786602973938,
-0.5821169018745422,
0.6920567154884338,
-0.1869683861732483,
0.17789073288440704,
-0.0971929132938385,
0.7729690074920654,
0.049010902643203735,
0.14885644614696503,
-0.44116127490997314,
-0.13384254276752472,
-0.07959485799074173,
-0.12288423627614975,
-0.12409629672765732,
-0.4155537784099579,
0.19612029194831848,
0.1551043540239334,
0.91299968957901,
-0.0443236380815506,
0.1382487714290619,
0.533767819404602,
-0.4262412488460541,
-0.5277172327041626,
0.30340099334716797,
0.791404664516449,
0.8437384963035583,
0.050164561718702316,
0.14849576354026794,
0.41615891456604004,
-0.13109003007411957,
0.3260199725627899,
-0.33120402693748474,
-0.3948651850223541,
0.07282155752182007,
0.09322234243154526,
0.5764281153678894,
0.33654800057411194,
-0.417394757270813,
0.1882861703634262,
0.16836290061473846,
-0.004312488716095686,
0.11663946509361267,
0.09446831792593002,
0.09974782168865204,
0.07025161385536194,
0.38334372639656067,
0.23528683185577393,
-0.1335989534854889,
-0.3074447810649872,
0.17608137428760529,
0.08228836208581924,
-0.25533735752105713,
-0.5669764280319214,
0.7885550856590271,
0.30969589948654175,
-0.5172936320304871,
0.4826684892177582,
-0.292489618062973,
-0.7549737691879272,
0.09586438536643982,
0.49650251865386963,
0.9353727698326111,
-0.6330605149269104,
0.013820896856486797,
0.3856232166290283,
0.4818139970302582,
-0.48586100339889526,
0.158754363656044,
0.2645759582519531,
-0.6077663898468018,
-0.8646662831306458,
-0.36461341381073,
-0.47366783022880554,
-0.14636240899562836,
-0.22811301052570343,
0.3188174366950989,
-0.5305777192115784,
-0.1625547856092453,
-0.41138869524002075,
-0.4168931543827057,
-0.512171745300293,
0.3891243636608124,
0.07413680106401443,
0.7149817943572998,
-0.6241650581359863,
1.2566049098968506,
0.824497640132904,
-0.0704740658402443,
-0.847902774810791,
-0.07724131643772125,
-0.19324053823947906,
-0.6702162623405457,
0.8524799346923828,
-0.003987761214375496,
-0.1715039163827896,
0.1553759127855301,
-0.1425027996301651,
-0.5781688690185547,
0.78700852394104,
0.3758302628993988,
-0.8742612600326538,
-0.01645343191921711,
0.37665054202079773,
0.5689144730567932,
-0.23869459331035614,
-0.320730596780777,
0.5055534243583679,
0.5364413261413574,
-0.23242151737213135,
-0.8685240745544434,
0.1657564640045166,
0.11904585361480713,
-0.08209336549043655,
0.3784518241882324,
-0.4741376042366028,
0.7018156051635742,
-0.1677381992340088,
-0.16548718512058258,
0.03700090944766998,
0.7728562355041504,
0.13021305203437805,
0.04596477001905441,
0.6043419241905212,
0.46120166778564453,
0.736767590045929,
-0.14860405027866364,
0.8650254011154175,
-0.29863181710243225,
0.13598299026489258,
1.3775932788848877,
-0.21343418955802917,
0.7842584848403931,
0.5833759903907776,
-0.06811563670635223,
0.3767009973526001,
0.7600107192993164,
0.01122529711574316,
0.1984792947769165,
-0.1380295306444168,
-0.16918015480041504,
-0.5297405123710632,
0.032614778727293015,
-0.24610407650470734,
0.012332791462540627,
0.4486699402332306,
-0.4400840699672699,
0.0473385825753212,
-0.058566685765981674,
0.21995502710342407,
0.15861131250858307,
-0.3733940124511719,
0.6017130017280579,
0.1683928668498993,
-0.909964382648468,
0.323541522026062,
0.18228551745414734,
0.5326856374740601,
-0.34571442008018494,
-0.08711458742618561,
-0.27637648582458496,
0.2863195240497589,
-0.12254206091165543,
-0.8465633988380432,
0.451642781496048,
0.2771145701408386,
-0.2973193824291229,
-0.7810331583023071,
0.7070271968841553,
-0.5657669901847839,
-0.41625267267227173,
0.39107128977775574,
0.4153282642364502,
0.21925437450408936,
-0.4553908705711365,
-0.49729976058006287,
0.0755547434091568,
-0.003439568681642413,
-0.14342252910137177,
0.15793439745903015,
0.5197919607162476,
-0.07438696920871735,
0.37523525953292847,
0.43568694591522217,
0.2586389183998108,
0.32504430413246155,
0.04402441531419754,
0.4808545708656311,
-0.836209774017334,
-0.3763447403907776,
-0.9238203167915344,
0.7620764970779419,
-0.024731457233428955,
-0.12999491393566132,
0.828005313873291,
0.34423819184303284,
0.9143126010894775,
-0.2592254877090454,
0.7383407950401306,
0.27869489789009094,
0.4326949715614319,
-0.5692978501319885,
0.4322566092014313,
-0.4735944867134094,
0.27231118083000183,
-0.05447590723633766,
-0.8351771831512451,
-0.4862818121910095,
0.4194946885108948,
-0.32212644815444946,
-0.11917656660079956,
0.7142008543014526,
0.8938863277435303,
0.0872054323554039,
-0.3364018499851227,
0.4195096790790558,
0.4121762216091156,
0.2596922218799591,
0.5006516575813293,
0.7313761115074158,
-0.6446079611778259,
0.5422957539558411,
-0.07895774394273758,
-0.11469217389822006,
-0.2635940909385681,
-0.7394798994064331,
-0.7974818348884583,
-0.2927413582801819,
-0.7529484033584595,
-0.5673272013664246,
0.24237297475337982,
1.1792103052139282,
0.41851598024368286,
-0.9219443202018738,
-0.171580508351326,
0.055057816207408905,
-0.03504380211234093,
-0.15662086009979248,
-0.02355201542377472,
0.2970275282859802,
-0.6913028955459595,
-0.7807958126068115,
0.5366507768630981,
0.5420899987220764,
0.36157357692718506,
-0.0729675218462944,
-0.42605331540107727,
-0.03489372879266739,
-0.02118595875799656,
0.5557025671005249,
0.17208516597747803,
-0.6797760128974915,
-0.6605440378189087,
0.136808380484581,
-0.2995118796825409,
0.4166525900363922,
0.9811886548995972,
-0.5300647020339966,
0.6333352327346802,
0.4039531350135803,
0.741782546043396,
0.22453995048999786,
-0.08223799616098404,
0.9541764259338379,
-0.8050905466079712,
-0.11501330882310867,
-0.12109149992465973,
0.5425832867622375,
0.6518931984901428,
-0.44035255908966064,
0.5499951243400574,
0.4790577292442322,
-0.6674314737319946,
-0.5586697459220886,
-0.1627214252948761,
-0.6827472448348999,
-0.08039183914661407,
0.992231547832489,
-0.49105843901634216,
-0.23757897317409515,
0.0016029406106099486,
-0.500921905040741,
0.4115390479564667,
-0.16440659761428833,
0.8882966637611389,
0.9525961875915527,
0.022937996312975883,
-0.05443227291107178,
-0.484033465385437,
0.5162737965583801,
0.5850251317024231,
-0.8745296001434326,
0.18601234257221222,
0.5906932950019836,
0.26635676622390747,
0.11000201106071472,
0.4760138988494873,
-0.13321428000926971,
0.5867847800254822,
-0.27470311522483826,
0.22171476483345032,
-0.10045413672924042,
-0.428691029548645,
-0.46524617075920105,
-0.24828098714351654,
0.36274653673171997,
-0.13947181403636932
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.02266v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.02266v1
|
Enhancing Retrieval-Augmented LMs with a Two-stage Consistency Learning Compressor
| 2024-06-04T12:43:23 | 2024-06-04T12:43:23 |
Chuankai Xu, Dongming Zhao, Bo Wang, Hanwen Xing
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Despite the prevalence of retrieval-augmented language models (RALMs), the
seamless integration of these models with retrieval mechanisms to enhance
performance in document-based tasks remains challenging. While some
post-retrieval processing Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG) methods have
achieved success, most still lack the ability to distinguish pertinent from
extraneous information, leading to potential inconsistencies and reduced
precision in the generated output, which subsequently affects the truthfulness
of the language model's responses. To address these limitations, this work
proposes a novel two-stage consistency learning approach for retrieved
information compression in retrieval-augmented language models to enhance
performance. By incorporating consistency learning, the aim is to generate
summaries that maintain coherence and alignment with the intended semantic
representations of a teacher model while improving faithfulness to the original
retrieved documents. The proposed method is empirically validated across
multiple datasets, demonstrating notable enhancements in precision and
efficiency for question-answering tasks. It outperforms existing baselines and
showcases the synergistic effects of combining contrastive and consistency
learning paradigms within the retrieval-augmented generation framework.
|
[
-0.1932588815689087,
-0.6297926902770996,
0.33132457733154297,
-0.1395280510187149,
-0.12796060740947723,
0.3735010325908661,
-0.25760409235954285,
-0.2714686393737793,
0.18742936849594116,
0.3865160048007965,
-0.24102270603179932,
-0.22253412008285522,
-0.6287945508956909,
0.0752369835972786,
-0.45604580640792847,
0.8214882612228394,
-0.09286978095769882,
-0.01575581170618534,
-0.38310492038726807,
-0.1312294900417328,
-0.7893442511558533,
-0.16751039028167725,
-0.39400714635849,
-0.5430698990821838,
0.2666305601596832,
0.6057325601577759,
0.7056941390037537,
0.622051477432251,
0.34979331493377686,
0.1587645262479782,
0.06433521211147308,
0.8949953317642212,
-0.4411894679069519,
0.664668619632721,
-0.2991279363632202,
-0.29983529448509216,
-0.22103339433670044,
-0.19317081570625305,
0.9325892329216003,
0.5911657810211182,
-0.39884814620018005,
0.1034783273935318,
0.5953408479690552,
0.6320610642433167,
-0.9114245176315308,
0.09688138961791992,
-0.8322499394416809,
-0.21590395271778107,
0.1852763444185257,
-0.25314760208129883,
-0.6165371537208557,
-0.40007466077804565,
-0.28978103399276733,
-0.7805525064468384,
0.215725377202034,
-0.15567155182361603,
1.1679105758666992,
0.23097586631774902,
-0.1562114953994751,
-0.2774425148963928,
-0.5430995225906372,
0.732079267501831,
-0.4569952189922333,
0.7250815033912659,
0.6728668808937073,
0.15501630306243896,
-0.07628753781318665,
-0.8331890106201172,
-0.5750001668930054,
0.13731177151203156,
-0.13687586784362793,
0.237641379237175,
0.28068453073501587,
-0.18762506544589996,
0.02683880552649498,
0.22572684288024902,
-0.5920606851577759,
-0.14582735300064087,
-0.14465679228305817,
-0.21019098162651062,
0.32663944363594055,
-0.10801859200000763,
0.05869752913713455,
-0.09294524788856506,
-0.3854534327983856,
-0.2800082564353943,
-0.5607051849365234,
-0.053484514355659485,
0.22376780211925507,
0.5571315884590149,
0.16488879919052124,
0.6097415685653687,
-0.18131303787231445,
0.6365988850593567,
0.24352231621742249,
-0.3527969717979431,
0.18774805963039398,
-0.36829403042793274,
-0.03467182442545891,
-0.2613614797592163,
0.4280575215816498,
0.1720806062221527,
-0.15378519892692566,
-0.3034398555755615,
-0.4885820746421814,
0.000996136455796659,
0.3304539620876312,
-0.8025317192077637,
-0.20646756887435913,
0.231497123837471,
-0.26326602697372437,
-0.19965356588363647,
0.23896639049053192,
-0.4562782049179077,
-0.17216068506240845,
-0.4783267378807068,
0.881279706954956,
-0.5073468685150146,
-0.28794151544570923,
0.010225699283182621,
0.0633673295378685,
0.041024353355169296,
0.3922979235649109,
-0.8563157916069031,
0.5973296165466309,
0.8913427591323853,
0.8093464970588684,
-0.1451932191848755,
-0.29903629422187805,
-0.9416017532348633,
0.2023775428533554,
-0.5980258584022522,
0.6362013816833496,
-0.4656330943107605,
-0.24266357719898224,
0.148361936211586,
-0.33632999658584595,
-0.038043029606342316,
-0.8737355470657349,
0.5712427496910095,
-0.8282769322395325,
0.32529518008232117,
-0.35410386323928833,
-0.7268810868263245,
-0.023424869403243065,
0.47831183671951294,
-0.4439648389816284,
1.7302486896514893,
0.23473218083381653,
-0.5996215343475342,
0.19700290262699127,
0.017358243465423584,
-0.2585274577140808,
0.051239386200904846,
-0.33978062868118286,
-0.5839058756828308,
0.09394745528697968,
-0.10602791607379913,
0.27937451004981995,
0.01078624464571476,
0.3328731954097748,
0.20255443453788757,
-0.6836207509040833,
-0.06144724041223526,
-0.10433989763259888,
0.3192709982395172,
0.1985424906015396,
0.08779823780059814,
-0.2050873041152954,
-0.7038017511367798,
0.2021765261888504,
-0.03682683780789375,
-0.6548161506652832,
-0.262649267911911,
-0.03558337688446045,
-0.3221617341041565,
0.21288944780826569,
0.538171112537384,
-0.42286407947540283,
0.14743152260780334,
-0.3100430369377136,
-0.3341549336910248,
0.40863847732543945,
0.11431152373552322,
0.45232221484184265,
-0.5845338106155396,
0.2640022337436676,
0.02859601005911827,
-0.0832911878824234,
-0.4704843759536743,
-0.0775575190782547,
-0.7403308749198914,
-0.07134190201759338,
0.40215420722961426,
0.5597580075263977,
-1.0738213062286377,
0.3376120924949646,
-0.43383485078811646,
-0.1727820634841919,
-0.5822983384132385,
0.48667359352111816,
0.701357364654541,
0.9633009433746338,
0.5882883667945862,
-0.4471866190433502,
-0.7315482497215271,
-0.5617257356643677,
-0.375418484210968,
-0.2945161759853363,
0.0218441691249609,
0.20585402846336365,
0.3064941465854645,
0.026794955134391785,
0.8887515664100647,
-0.3646775484085083,
-0.12957414984703064,
-0.03657904639840126,
0.22467681765556335,
0.03850239887833595,
0.6731681823730469,
0.017328204587101936,
-0.9139338135719299,
-0.7004819512367249,
-0.20628206431865692,
-0.6634234189987183,
-0.012217058800160885,
0.09124958515167236,
-0.2201876938343048,
0.33063122630119324,
0.3870674669742584,
-0.2531047463417053,
0.2502303123474121,
0.3773943781852722,
-0.12024789303541183,
0.6556922197341919,
-0.3994733393192291,
0.3455890715122223,
-1.1727205514907837,
0.0700593814253807,
-0.3244834840297699,
-0.4632010757923126,
-0.6622252464294434,
0.12843850255012512,
0.44425103068351746,
0.061027202755212784,
-0.18433628976345062,
0.4401402473449707,
-0.4816804528236389,
-0.19370107352733612,
-0.45525509119033813,
0.3954524099826813,
0.44126439094543457,
0.27302804589271545,
-0.012870612554252148,
0.9967221617698669,
0.27333980798721313,
-0.6110360622406006,
-0.08738020807504654,
0.43791627883911133,
-0.16681449115276337,
0.5410401225090027,
-0.5507040619850159,
0.3153989613056183,
-0.3623048663139343,
0.10955682396888733,
-1.1404122114181519,
-0.34530121088027954,
0.006715533323585987,
-0.5957220196723938,
0.7891969084739685,
-0.1579371839761734,
-0.7222369909286499,
0.15483883023262024,
-0.34811654686927795,
0.18067072331905365,
0.7137538194656372,
-0.5952393412590027,
0.7511288523674011,
0.039278559386730194,
-0.1992112398147583,
-0.9018222093582153,
-0.6211335062980652,
-0.09460693597793579,
0.3242110013961792,
-0.4289652705192566,
0.35636475682258606,
0.00003880578515236266,
-0.12123315036296844,
-0.04448041319847107,
-0.4367971122264862,
-0.1419445276260376,
0.17614531517028809,
-0.06463019549846649,
0.38012880086898804,
0.07692523300647736,
0.3496960401535034,
0.17758594453334808,
0.054615169763565063,
-0.4460383951663971,
-0.29192519187927246,
0.5790099501609802,
0.20195652544498444,
-0.2444208413362503,
-0.29858142137527466,
0.35767173767089844,
0.08410702645778656,
-0.3825545310974121,
0.9987673163414001,
0.5817732810974121,
-0.4545805752277374,
-0.12827423214912415,
-0.6448299884796143,
-0.32859188318252563,
-0.43208077549934387,
0.25035104155540466,
-0.5355289578437805,
-0.777140736579895,
0.4735593795776367,
-0.05601690709590912,
0.2274460792541504,
0.3563983142375946,
0.2283044010400772,
-0.12124183773994446,
0.7274160981178284,
0.45939764380455017,
0.38965174555778503,
0.48924869298934937,
-0.1418289840221405,
-0.09380465000867844,
-0.966909646987915,
-0.5798742771148682,
-0.5682535171508789,
0.14704474806785583,
-0.20435373485088348,
-0.5284839868545532,
0.3664626479148865,
0.7774451375007629,
-0.35159021615982056,
0.0978379026055336,
-0.27881285548210144,
0.4804157614707947,
0.2963518798351288,
0.5103647112846375,
0.4146359860897064,
0.3093060255050659,
-0.2229381501674652,
-0.05742781236767769,
-0.6435852646827698,
-0.5933346748352051,
0.8886805772781372,
0.11561127007007599,
0.43782418966293335,
0.4451708197593689,
0.9516629576683044,
0.30082541704177856,
0.1252010464668274,
-0.41623470187187195,
0.43824678659439087,
-0.24887308478355408,
-0.29196783900260925,
-0.1382765769958496,
-0.4015454947948456,
-0.7812501192092896,
0.4370783567428589,
-0.47926878929138184,
-0.5267791152000427,
0.11221153289079666,
0.19581952691078186,
-0.1172991394996643,
0.10324251651763916,
-0.47091853618621826,
0.4446897804737091,
0.13244110345840454,
-0.8276742696762085,
-0.059858426451683044,
-0.7549505829811096,
0.18388131260871887,
-0.12305737286806107,
0.19236740469932556,
0.10878701508045197,
-0.46005260944366455,
0.4594002366065979,
-0.5107374787330627,
0.4626506268978119,
-0.19834357500076294,
-0.13204722106456757,
0.2619704604148865,
0.3879217207431793,
0.8863793611526489,
-0.15718114376068115,
-0.23515582084655762,
-0.2192579060792923,
-0.10285034775733948,
-0.5752158761024475,
-0.9130483269691467,
0.5241544842720032,
-0.5656377673149109,
-0.41726693511009216,
-0.20501522719860077,
-0.8030436635017395,
-0.4050569236278534,
0.3126889169216156,
-0.07235856354236603,
0.5466019511222839,
0.09520584344863892,
0.13463693857192993,
1.0190017223358154,
0.12535524368286133,
0.15688088536262512,
0.6614564657211304,
-0.37003183364868164,
-0.6094969511032104,
0.9559035301208496,
0.21251429617404938,
0.5586023330688477,
0.5139053463935852,
0.007512274663895369,
-0.5163062810897827,
-0.5985599160194397,
-0.20170839130878448,
0.19176878035068512,
-0.7174747586250305,
-0.3430326581001282,
-0.62205570936203,
-0.08224359154701233,
-0.7104352116584778,
0.20288275182247162,
-0.3250623941421509,
-0.5521259903907776,
-0.3085179030895233,
0.184813991189003,
0.03784343600273132,
0.6855670213699341,
-0.10593711584806442,
-0.05486554652452469,
-0.7757028341293335,
0.47092965245246887,
0.16812381148338318,
0.42188459634780884,
-0.02677709050476551,
-0.9787712097167969,
-0.4673141539096832,
0.11991182714700699,
-0.3575754761695862,
-0.7388395071029663,
0.15547935664653778,
0.5515444874763489,
0.3001481890678406,
0.09532319009304047,
0.07167748361825943,
0.7134139537811279,
-0.5070769190788269,
0.7456938028335571,
0.06465218216180801,
-0.7317032217979431,
0.5999397039413452,
-0.18705718219280243,
0.17517374455928802,
0.7553176283836365,
0.28908073902130127,
-0.3881073594093323,
-0.30125677585601807,
-0.5979396104812622,
-0.8164068460464478,
0.46897658705711365,
0.1577543467283249,
-0.06788866221904755,
-0.13252712786197662,
0.759780764579773,
0.20288975536823273,
0.3330043852329254,
-0.22267915308475494,
-0.33009016513824463,
-0.12258097529411316,
-0.5493216514587402,
0.008495786227285862,
-0.6489689946174622,
-0.08364903926849365,
0.12182791531085968,
0.9727243781089783,
-0.21716700494289398,
-0.19202841818332672,
0.30622243881225586,
-0.26675552129745483,
-0.1275576800107956,
0.3700486719608307,
0.5160261988639832,
0.7358081340789795,
-0.2982214391231537,
0.4470592439174652,
0.19292381405830383,
-0.6438294053077698,
0.2301352471113205,
0.22284141182899475,
-0.5048129558563232,
0.13519679009914398,
0.19306837022304535,
0.46994727849960327,
0.231553852558136,
-0.6687901616096497,
0.48001259565353394,
0.0731617733836174,
-0.10217379033565521,
-0.14042842388153076,
0.09546558558940887,
-0.14248520135879517,
0.2977026700973511,
0.6898971199989319,
0.11732923984527588,
0.05692734941840172,
-0.43987488746643066,
0.4407332241535187,
0.3416019380092621,
-0.09580463916063309,
-0.03504204750061035,
0.6133564114570618,
-0.25342875719070435,
-0.29975974559783936,
0.3996069133281708,
-0.17273150384426117,
-0.40135669708251953,
0.16717585921287537,
0.6004529595375061,
0.5355989933013916,
-0.4163217842578888,
0.17215248942375183,
0.6173587441444397,
-0.028893660753965378,
-0.6973792314529419,
0.6221007108688354,
-0.3635525703430176,
-0.7129091620445251,
-0.37238821387290955,
-0.6143206357955933,
-0.45335859060287476,
-0.3689981698989868,
-1.1220148801803589,
0.18720930814743042,
-0.2639177739620209,
0.09690353274345398,
-0.4709913432598114,
0.3578239679336548,
-0.2783043086528778,
0.3524831533432007,
-0.12268592417240143,
0.8840392231941223,
-0.7934312224388123,
0.883446991443634,
0.5883166193962097,
-0.6131534576416016,
-1.1288797855377197,
0.02323835715651512,
-0.36305123567581177,
-0.5897879004478455,
0.4454372823238373,
-0.0940948948264122,
-0.04960251227021217,
-0.014773688279092312,
-0.23751035332679749,
-0.908012330532074,
1.3848437070846558,
0.4844820201396942,
-0.5834271311759949,
0.024332212284207344,
-0.09820197522640228,
0.45850399136543274,
-0.23592305183410645,
0.3525700271129608,
0.3784744143486023,
0.10822586715221405,
0.33763957023620605,
-0.9288067817687988,
-0.0004320309963077307,
-0.07331623882055283,
0.14904791116714478,
0.2912081182003021,
-0.586286187171936,
0.8100006580352783,
-0.09869953989982605,
-0.424034982919693,
0.3758713901042938,
0.8512423634529114,
0.6254545450210571,
0.3118577301502228,
0.35007748007774353,
0.7555512189865112,
1.1263377666473389,
-0.06958135962486267,
0.994828462600708,
-0.4458100199699402,
0.6267620921134949,
1.6006711721420288,
-0.21347610652446747,
1.2986583709716797,
0.45519185066223145,
-0.11903605610132217,
0.7290600538253784,
0.31506964564323425,
0.2272188663482666,
0.5264050364494324,
-0.32486575841903687,
-0.5556223392486572,
-0.2852514982223511,
-0.5216557383537292,
-0.34431344270706177,
0.09691565483808517,
0.10210106521844864,
-0.3184996247291565,
-0.2624971568584442,
-0.13229896128177643,
0.0024977608118206263,
0.6267127394676208,
-0.3701782822608948,
0.8230109810829163,
-0.20049059391021729,
-0.8411767482757568,
0.840151309967041,
-0.14066331088542938,
0.4623875319957733,
-0.5656561255455017,
-0.4313380718231201,
-0.22640706598758698,
0.09526517242193222,
-0.39752379059791565,
-0.8344048261642456,
0.1995130181312561,
-0.07786023616790771,
-0.4994058907032013,
-0.16554100811481476,
0.9509670734405518,
-1.020141363143921,
-0.24464765191078186,
-0.04076923057436943,
0.48705872893333435,
0.157267227768898,
0.23331734538078308,
-0.5428288578987122,
0.3613705337047577,
-0.2435927838087082,
0.14377738535404205,
0.33187174797058105,
0.24032634496688843,
0.3513878583908081,
0.4364820420742035,
0.36808639764785767,
0.08505362272262573,
-0.03299219161272049,
0.19287540018558502,
0.7576879262924194,
-0.15738436579704285,
-0.32557082176208496,
-0.5459524989128113,
0.5716914534568787,
-0.06963483989238739,
0.2978147864341736,
0.8948833346366882,
1.012404441833496,
0.8559973835945129,
0.289342999458313,
0.6357591152191162,
0.05446891114115715,
1.0488380193710327,
-0.5909921526908875,
0.36555877327919006,
-0.6468576788902283,
0.46451231837272644,
-0.06242256611585617,
-0.7432987093925476,
-0.19862720370292664,
0.39697903394699097,
0.06606971472501755,
0.2333216667175293,
0.5576274394989014,
0.9471603631973267,
-0.008594819344580173,
-0.34192922711372375,
0.46907874941825867,
0.16358768939971924,
0.06660599261522293,
0.36317336559295654,
0.5540660619735718,
-1.0049160718917847,
0.49125972390174866,
-0.18089060485363007,
-0.004990159068256617,
0.013491080142557621,
-0.6064143776893616,
-0.5672464370727539,
-0.6629971861839294,
-0.3062441349029541,
-0.9863184094429016,
0.3856150209903717,
0.9098791480064392,
0.5030131340026855,
-0.7242399454116821,
0.004611107986420393,
-0.14386779069900513,
0.022324111312627792,
-0.14525122940540314,
-0.2191273719072342,
0.4807036817073822,
-0.7201482653617859,
-0.6777048110961914,
0.3661837875843048,
0.1713780164718628,
0.011132638901472092,
-0.1497274786233902,
-0.37018460035324097,
-0.38123348355293274,
0.09301524609327316,
0.4038489758968353,
0.3817123472690582,
-0.6139108538627625,
-0.3550053834915161,
-0.03898680955171585,
-0.21512699127197266,
0.18899042904376984,
0.5300391912460327,
-0.9304078221321106,
0.7279229760169983,
0.4530899226665497,
0.8031289577484131,
0.46833688020706177,
0.4711169898509979,
0.2640571892261505,
-1.1653482913970947,
0.07373515516519547,
0.18396514654159546,
0.22608141601085663,
0.5660558342933655,
-0.24664053320884705,
0.49053630232810974,
0.19121983647346497,
-0.5662072896957397,
-0.9207977056503296,
0.31954291462898254,
-0.7373875379562378,
-0.19901631772518158,
1.0723017454147339,
-0.3499200940132141,
0.12225531786680222,
-0.11969674378633499,
-0.08948443084955215,
0.4661701023578644,
-0.24090054631233215,
0.5834560990333557,
0.4119032025337219,
-0.040685489773750305,
-0.28631410002708435,
-0.3339197635650635,
0.411069393157959,
0.5716211199760437,
-0.4732307493686676,
-0.17868660390377045,
0.5575020909309387,
0.41015636920928955,
0.20172853767871857,
0.5403711795806885,
-0.2191384732723236,
0.415559321641922,
-0.0439312681555748,
-0.004446859005838633,
-0.2834548354148865,
-0.4768625497817993,
-0.4183236360549927,
0.3790925145149231,
0.23351293802261353,
-0.1554528921842575
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.02265v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.02265v2
|
Understanding Retrieval Robustness for Retrieval-Augmented Image Captioning
| 2024-06-04T12:41:54 | 2024-06-06T13:59:03 |
Wenyan Li, Jiaang Li, Rita Ramos, Raphael Tang, Desmond Elliott
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
Recent advances in retrieval-augmented models for image captioning highlight
the benefit of retrieving related captions for efficient, lightweight models
with strong domain-transfer capabilities. While these models demonstrate the
success of retrieval augmentation, retrieval models are still far from perfect
in practice: the retrieved information can sometimes mislead the model,
resulting in incorrect generation and worse performance. In this paper, we
analyze the robustness of a retrieval-augmented captioning model SmallCap. Our
analysis shows that the model is sensitive to tokens that appear in the
majority of the retrieved captions, and the input attribution shows that those
tokens are likely copied into the generated output. Given these findings, we
propose to train the model by sampling retrieved captions from more diverse
sets. This decreases the chance that the model learns to copy majority tokens,
and improves both in-domain and cross-domain performance.
|
[
-0.2090146392583847,
-0.3450496196746826,
0.22436879575252533,
-0.2393646091222763,
-0.6285740733146667,
0.20650428533554077,
0.047252144664525986,
-0.6894159913063049,
0.12617747485637665,
0.3977799713611603,
-0.07636402547359467,
0.0830715075135231,
-0.7769017219543457,
0.30280429124832153,
-0.3674173951148987,
0.8822363018989563,
0.17351965606212616,
0.013940297067165375,
-0.30384257435798645,
-0.5174477100372314,
-0.6866778135299683,
-0.41374000906944275,
-0.55646151304245,
0.14214745163917542,
0.25500917434692383,
0.3869600296020508,
0.8564661145210266,
0.6347434520721436,
0.8583495616912842,
0.1341356635093689,
0.00741113256663084,
0.26192691922187805,
-0.4962896406650543,
-0.04085629805922508,
-0.28164294362068176,
-0.8078595399856567,
0.0433054119348526,
-0.21610844135284424,
0.5739217400550842,
0.6201996803283691,
0.1581946611404419,
0.20607781410217285,
0.02676992304623127,
0.4797161817550659,
-0.8437671065330505,
0.05503138527274132,
-1.2085204124450684,
-0.0690787136554718,
-0.1664767861366272,
-0.07584726810455322,
-0.6845197677612305,
0.06558694690465927,
0.09176792949438095,
-0.6018680930137634,
0.6036999821662903,
0.829432487487793,
0.9749637246131897,
0.1617334932088852,
-0.2742508351802826,
-0.1834704726934433,
-0.33549025654792786,
0.8672191500663757,
-0.36706599593162537,
0.07724417001008987,
0.558839738368988,
0.6140896081924438,
0.3004249334335327,
-0.9364778399467468,
-0.5161896347999573,
-0.22074151039123535,
-0.21759478747844696,
-0.286484956741333,
-0.27600252628326416,
-0.2851872444152832,
0.3030332028865814,
0.6074373126029968,
-0.25403091311454773,
0.012961671687662601,
-0.47711917757987976,
-0.4618152678012848,
0.2999325692653656,
-0.08961670100688934,
0.3989957273006439,
-0.45080235600471497,
-0.657687783241272,
-0.18490184843540192,
-0.960486114025116,
0.06747882813215256,
0.2537487745285034,
0.8684931993484497,
0.006463244091719389,
0.9038631319999695,
0.00006083436528570019,
0.5460778474807739,
0.26206427812576294,
0.1151316687464714,
0.08983197063207626,
-0.5727178454399109,
-0.11479867249727249,
-0.3901771903038025,
0.4650016129016876,
0.3784591555595398,
0.017726143822073936,
-0.37749743461608887,
-0.5480452179908752,
-0.39549383521080017,
0.4962499141693115,
-0.8417019248008728,
-0.4016982614994049,
0.11815442889928818,
-0.709679901599884,
-0.41298437118530273,
0.20698657631874084,
-0.49012061953544617,
-0.22591550648212433,
-0.1749207079410553,
0.7316455841064453,
-0.38699764013290405,
0.2649286687374115,
-0.26422351598739624,
-0.20283089578151703,
-0.029812725260853767,
0.16477638483047485,
-0.9466805458068848,
0.3680943250656128,
0.42742982506752014,
1.0880385637283325,
-0.7957006692886353,
-0.11600375920534134,
-1.1731319427490234,
0.0385199636220932,
-0.11525778472423553,
0.8992370367050171,
-0.4855164885520935,
-0.1976742446422577,
0.1511518955230713,
0.24319173395633698,
-0.11950180679559708,
-0.8550297617912292,
0.2771449685096741,
-1.0692554712295532,
-0.3518097996711731,
-0.5718986988067627,
-0.3500796854496002,
0.23005400598049164,
0.25153282284736633,
-1.2907096147537231,
0.5135572552680969,
0.14337316155433655,
-1.030304193496704,
0.7377257943153381,
-0.3275686800479889,
-0.3803778886795044,
0.08559588342905045,
-0.018381649628281593,
-0.610741376876831,
0.1465761810541153,
0.6072688102722168,
0.22015085816383362,
0.10052457451820374,
-0.3265385031700134,
-0.3670351803302765,
-0.6453866958618164,
0.2745959162712097,
-0.28446266055107117,
0.657526433467865,
0.4701840579509735,
0.10542183369398117,
-0.1944008469581604,
-0.41218167543411255,
-0.2585866451263428,
0.15682077407836914,
-0.16639141738414764,
-0.42929455637931824,
-0.36457952857017517,
0.004441168159246445,
-0.24612106382846832,
0.026192236691713333,
-0.480564683675766,
0.2718852758407593,
-0.0429501011967659,
0.39973369240760803,
0.6737411022186279,
0.40913471579551697,
0.9152014851570129,
-0.6057214140892029,
0.6293045282363892,
0.11440201103687286,
0.17126670479774475,
-0.3164389133453369,
-0.328396201133728,
-0.14857414364814758,
-0.7560776472091675,
0.6677491664886475,
0.257007896900177,
-1.3024709224700928,
-0.13004446029663086,
-0.4316599667072296,
-0.2361069619655609,
-0.4481353461742401,
0.23613418638706207,
0.2312721461057663,
0.5135904550552368,
0.2920322120189667,
-0.6334168314933777,
-0.2642763555049896,
-0.8820671439170837,
-0.44057783484458923,
-0.11182425916194916,
0.16601356863975525,
0.5384719371795654,
0.7587804198265076,
-0.05684761703014374,
0.7260242104530334,
-0.2861173152923584,
-0.22341150045394897,
-0.20739996433258057,
0.07909011840820312,
-0.0003537734446581453,
0.5760558843612671,
0.7791218757629395,
-1.0354772806167603,
-0.5825871229171753,
-0.27705925703048706,
-0.3976458013057709,
0.22522637248039246,
-0.2547278106212616,
-0.31578531861305237,
-0.06896426528692245,
0.29302340745925903,
-0.811485767364502,
0.4817684590816498,
0.08940231800079346,
0.16157527267932892,
0.6770235896110535,
0.09083685278892517,
0.31092968583106995,
-0.7626898288726807,
0.3111201524734497,
-0.3974440097808838,
-0.4395029544830322,
-0.07512374967336655,
0.47380200028419495,
0.06198503449559212,
-0.20246751606464386,
-0.6015387773513794,
0.5115470290184021,
-0.750549852848053,
-0.30915144085884094,
-0.3160722851753235,
0.04877275228500366,
0.19049613177776337,
0.20176789164543152,
-0.17750351130962372,
1.2496867179870605,
0.5127013921737671,
-0.5264711976051331,
0.30438610911369324,
0.4772609770298004,
-0.46137872338294983,
0.6780079007148743,
-0.6446669101715088,
0.2205987572669983,
-0.16643168032169342,
-0.11436688154935837,
-1.1536943912506104,
-0.38263192772865295,
0.08427783101797104,
-0.5271921157836914,
0.7122352123260498,
-0.5535582900047302,
-0.6777287721633911,
-0.30918005108833313,
-0.44807589054107666,
0.7509469985961914,
0.25449338555336,
-0.9737754464149475,
0.5048762559890747,
0.2640818953514099,
-0.2801603674888611,
-0.8029616475105286,
-0.8076764345169067,
-0.035653531551361084,
-0.167848601937294,
-0.37396955490112305,
0.2510624825954437,
-0.027974041178822517,
-0.0630008652806282,
0.02823621779680252,
-0.17468489706516266,
-0.0938350185751915,
-0.0013437861343845725,
0.1089392676949501,
0.4310309588909149,
0.05161922797560692,
0.08136183768510818,
-0.020480912178754807,
0.2938986122608185,
-0.28520041704177856,
-0.10761697590351105,
0.15883496403694153,
-0.13810908794403076,
-0.6693904995918274,
-0.20213057100772858,
0.450027734041214,
0.48698505759239197,
-0.1565382331609726,
0.8393935561180115,
0.31437304615974426,
-0.5033258199691772,
-0.13643479347229004,
-0.2529025673866272,
-0.5417629480361938,
-0.3849063813686371,
0.20120836794376373,
-0.5105360746383667,
-0.7772307991981506,
0.9169155955314636,
0.2798559367656708,
0.0049843802116811275,
0.47845587134361267,
0.19144786894321442,
-0.25767019391059875,
0.8287150859832764,
0.6188120245933533,
-0.05030324310064316,
0.6192622184753418,
-0.254464715719223,
-0.021376056596636772,
-0.7905921339988708,
-0.08643999695777893,
-0.5359175801277161,
-0.23269148170948029,
-0.37562915682792664,
-0.2907579839229584,
0.011944747529923916,
-0.0816211923956871,
-0.09207308292388916,
0.5131903886795044,
-0.4857677221298218,
0.651479959487915,
0.7808624505996704,
0.26576104760169983,
0.37847745418548584,
0.7880327105522156,
-0.1351010650396347,
-0.314548522233963,
-0.7637766003608704,
-0.5050796270370483,
1.177687406539917,
0.0982329472899437,
0.9188451170921326,
0.29602760076522827,
0.33294954895973206,
0.8143148422241211,
0.37311089038848877,
-0.581527829170227,
0.06797793507575989,
-0.17365829646587372,
-0.922235369682312,
-0.05382867902517319,
-0.44528713822364807,
-0.9685560464859009,
0.18682977557182312,
-0.22589129209518433,
-0.7015949487686157,
0.3594677448272705,
0.24305956065654755,
-0.5694775581359863,
0.46652406454086304,
-0.6874347925186157,
0.7602519989013672,
0.03540471941232681,
-0.3563111126422882,
0.2500424087047577,
-0.8275960087776184,
0.2940613627433777,
-0.26194700598716736,
0.15677091479301453,
0.41021236777305603,
-0.08695704489946365,
0.5285311341285706,
-0.4115919768810272,
0.8370477557182312,
-0.11423920840024948,
0.42589041590690613,
0.7201496958732605,
0.3681286573410034,
0.6237901449203491,
-0.010791863314807415,
0.1232786774635315,
-0.17997194826602936,
0.1719028204679489,
-0.7050827741622925,
-0.49796953797340393,
0.40556108951568604,
-0.6435328722000122,
-0.36849069595336914,
-0.3375970721244812,
-0.3855924606323242,
-0.13077862560749054,
0.3674720525741577,
0.5743891596794128,
0.36306431889533997,
0.2979544997215271,
0.42633140087127686,
0.605893611907959,
-0.11350686848163605,
0.34385064244270325,
0.04081003740429878,
-0.06415220350027084,
-0.6470721960067749,
0.8719110488891602,
0.12406543642282486,
0.5947132110595703,
0.34120339155197144,
-0.2287111133337021,
-0.35871776938438416,
-0.7225249409675598,
-0.6390650868415833,
0.2887890338897705,
-1.0165979862213135,
-0.6311860084533691,
-0.2945478558540344,
0.1038602739572525,
-0.2770279049873352,
-0.06908005475997925,
-0.3807816505432129,
-0.4365275204181671,
-0.3964706063270569,
-0.21785803139209747,
0.15860900282859802,
0.41331374645233154,
-0.10320419818162918,
0.4197470247745514,
-0.8399803638458252,
0.4160895347595215,
0.5618945956230164,
0.2670400142669678,
0.10529317706823349,
-1.1399403810501099,
-0.16139568388462067,
-0.03821671009063721,
-0.12242382019758224,
-0.7216788530349731,
0.26339009404182434,
0.3675740957260132,
0.5247288942337036,
0.21504126489162445,
0.2550744116306305,
0.4743451178073883,
-0.3266606330871582,
1.05745267868042,
-0.05237722024321556,
-0.6394267082214355,
0.5170223116874695,
-0.10979390144348145,
0.05743623897433281,
0.9445242881774902,
0.1412559151649475,
0.21338853240013123,
-0.09459373354911804,
-0.5971803069114685,
-0.727023184299469,
0.4970749616622925,
0.20074158906936646,
0.514234185218811,
-0.10931999236345291,
0.6586315035820007,
0.39795395731925964,
0.3389001190662384,
-0.8337562680244446,
0.06839153170585632,
-0.1765865683555603,
-0.033270787447690964,
0.4106304347515106,
-0.2910263240337372,
-0.25077927112579346,
0.014765438623726368,
0.5398659706115723,
-0.4924129843711853,
0.5062233805656433,
0.1114739403128624,
-0.43730470538139343,
-0.21493084728717804,
-0.18354178965091705,
0.3775022625923157,
0.4206065833568573,
-0.3207367956638336,
0.3973293900489807,
0.09311696887016296,
-0.6603680849075317,
-0.16577103734016418,
0.004235736560076475,
-0.33869773149490356,
0.0017875354969874024,
0.490261435508728,
0.6098999977111816,
-0.10347545146942139,
-0.6677950620651245,
1.008148193359375,
-0.11609721928834915,
0.22379331290721893,
0.017163611948490143,
-0.2476152926683426,
-0.5390989780426025,
0.08294796943664551,
0.7308169007301331,
0.7738831043243408,
0.3791697025299072,
-0.6122809648513794,
0.37231379747390747,
0.5649563670158386,
-0.4030361771583557,
-0.1344262808561325,
0.8398342728614807,
-0.17246219515800476,
0.12545862793922424,
0.6916837096214294,
-0.09545768052339554,
-0.4540651738643646,
0.5329701900482178,
0.4979560673236847,
0.4894923269748688,
0.6488587856292725,
-0.11986936628818512,
0.40624555945396423,
0.5289759039878845,
-0.1705915927886963,
0.11002814769744873,
-0.24425050616264343,
-0.5228447318077087,
-0.39690449833869934,
-0.3040063977241516,
-0.43449997901916504,
-0.36322978138923645,
-0.8801204562187195,
-0.1199420765042305,
-0.20707571506500244,
-0.5050494074821472,
-0.33091679215431213,
-0.14533670246601105,
-0.781138002872467,
0.18064568936824799,
-0.09016024321317673,
0.9585374593734741,
-0.9327617883682251,
0.3758619725704193,
0.6160549521446228,
-0.9699535965919495,
-0.8042858242988586,
-0.26679274439811707,
-0.49493828415870667,
-0.9189000725746155,
0.5093269348144531,
0.08905965834856033,
0.13731010258197784,
-0.3348982036113739,
-1.1826711893081665,
-0.7986034154891968,
1.1391534805297852,
0.4609156548976898,
-0.20052140951156616,
0.019324034452438354,
-0.011742298491299152,
0.27116379141807556,
-0.5033698081970215,
-0.07935277372598648,
0.09783277660608292,
-0.09285668283700943,
0.3118067979812622,
-0.7726261019706726,
0.3423278033733368,
-0.14033877849578857,
0.21865399181842804,
-0.5707932114601135,
-0.5423491597175598,
0.7468082308769226,
-0.6040010452270508,
-0.29207611083984375,
0.6404279470443726,
0.7304523587226868,
0.5189844369888306,
0.2915897071361542,
0.5081647634506226,
0.29911404848098755,
0.8221325874328613,
-0.14777429401874542,
1.5477653741836548,
0.08494701981544495,
0.2815820872783661,
1.021644115447998,
0.025988806039094925,
1.1630241870880127,
0.8134547472000122,
-0.07871437817811966,
0.17478756606578827,
0.615287184715271,
-0.2831169366836548,
0.9749802350997925,
-0.10589271038770676,
-0.08341964334249496,
-0.22800274193286896,
-0.13726063072681427,
-0.1623336374759674,
0.08481167256832123,
-0.16179759800434113,
-0.6960936784744263,
0.3525488078594208,
0.2556920349597931,
-0.47013476490974426,
0.013943095691502094,
-0.3700708746910095,
0.5648654699325562,
0.2391076683998108,
-0.6595680117607117,
0.4600095748901367,
-0.3140350580215454,
0.5844911336898804,
-0.00685406569391489,
0.08959738165140152,
-0.30040454864501953,
0.01081299502402544,
-0.16812603175640106,
-0.6648140549659729,
0.3191574513912201,
-0.004203428514301777,
-0.4160260260105133,
0.2282049059867859,
0.9297788739204407,
-0.1602514535188675,
-0.27398014068603516,
-0.339223712682724,
0.47411659359931946,
0.34708118438720703,
-0.27837634086608887,
-0.46007028222084045,
0.18273918330669403,
0.03411181643605232,
0.2457199990749359,
0.3218785524368286,
0.28898733854293823,
-0.06492750346660614,
0.6117321848869324,
0.6742277145385742,
0.1548972725868225,
0.3051793873310089,
0.18007342517375946,
0.6437361240386963,
-0.19414791464805603,
-0.26406624913215637,
-0.5213594436645508,
0.5270624160766602,
-0.21539556980133057,
0.14233849942684174,
0.5946273803710938,
0.5218876600265503,
0.6113787889480591,
-0.5864445567131042,
0.7047356367111206,
0.06970588117837906,
0.41997188329696655,
-0.4190273582935333,
0.8169053196907043,
-0.5769386887550354,
0.40535879135131836,
-0.16660882532596588,
-0.9313892126083374,
-0.4333624839782715,
0.4121745228767395,
-0.03516269102692604,
0.1929156333208084,
0.3346995711326599,
0.7953424453735352,
-0.28917646408081055,
-0.10534993559122086,
0.19183377921581268,
-0.2624012231826782,
0.20419231057167053,
0.21202529966831207,
0.8043985962867737,
-0.8189957141876221,
0.8873510360717773,
-0.21031221747398376,
0.05683149769902229,
-0.262460321187973,
-0.8631083369255066,
-0.7897339463233948,
-0.36887454986572266,
-0.42271050810813904,
-0.3636437654495239,
-0.08657053112983704,
0.6515175700187683,
0.9257809519767761,
-0.9651581645011902,
0.4459691047668457,
0.2253662496805191,
0.044923704117536545,
-0.1878259778022766,
-0.260337233543396,
0.4777499735355377,
-0.3446848690509796,
-0.5765413641929626,
-0.10976031422615051,
-0.18784303963184357,
0.37837666273117065,
0.17744480073451996,
0.13901422917842865,
0.09788171201944351,
0.105648472905159,
0.47708404064178467,
0.5218685269355774,
-0.4898860454559326,
-0.6181802749633789,
0.1849353164434433,
-0.3659391403198242,
0.14431113004684448,
0.49912551045417786,
-0.5690611004829407,
0.7390620708465576,
0.36049506068229675,
0.8962607383728027,
0.5271185636520386,
0.31019163131713867,
0.26527395844459534,
-1.14041268825531,
-0.07167153060436249,
0.10958757996559143,
0.5918363332748413,
0.8300658464431763,
-0.26548126339912415,
0.40838950872421265,
0.5016383528709412,
-0.5083296895027161,
-1.1136823892593384,
-0.04995199292898178,
-1.1309078931808472,
-0.0772242322564125,
1.0261136293411255,
-0.23241733014583588,
-0.24588967859745026,
0.2268468290567398,
-0.3826550841331482,
0.11562129110097885,
-0.32673826813697815,
0.7892961502075195,
0.5722686648368835,
0.20304785668849945,
-0.2802877426147461,
-0.29892897605895996,
0.30211341381073,
0.3161320388317108,
-0.18196842074394226,
-0.18178313970565796,
0.4262535870075226,
0.5261149406433105,
0.3871693015098572,
0.3761740028858185,
-0.3836976885795593,
0.5603532791137695,
0.24917444586753845,
-0.30393123626708984,
-0.18892139196395874,
-0.21866390109062195,
-0.21952690184116364,
0.42684340476989746,
0.594464898109436,
-0.4860607385635376
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.02251v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.02251v1
|
Modeling Emotional Trajectories in Written Stories Utilizing Transformers and Weakly-Supervised Learning
| 2024-06-04T12:17:16 | 2024-06-04T12:17:16 |
Lukas Christ, Shahin Amiriparian, Manuel Milling, Ilhan Aslan, Björn W. Schuller
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Telling stories is an integral part of human communication which can evoke
emotions and influence the affective states of the audience. Automatically
modeling emotional trajectories in stories has thus attracted considerable
scholarly interest. However, as most existing works have been limited to
unsupervised dictionary-based approaches, there is no benchmark for this task.
We address this gap by introducing continuous valence and arousal labels for an
existing dataset of children's stories originally annotated with discrete
emotion categories. We collect additional annotations for this data and map the
categorical labels to the continuous valence and arousal space. For predicting
the thus obtained emotionality signals, we fine-tune a DeBERTa model and
improve upon this baseline via a weakly supervised learning approach. The best
configuration achieves a Concordance Correlation Coefficient (CCC) of $.8221$
for valence and $.7125$ for arousal on the test set, demonstrating the efficacy
of our proposed approach. A detailed analysis shows the extent to which the
results vary depending on factors such as the author, the individual story, or
the section within the story. In addition, we uncover the weaknesses of our
approach by investigating examples that prove to be difficult to predict.
|
[
-0.08210112154483795,
-0.7214991450309753,
0.6434245705604553,
0.30064156651496887,
-0.2557842433452606,
-0.0876094177365303,
-0.14081984758377075,
-0.7803530097007751,
0.3602098524570465,
0.23796863853931427,
-0.8178079724311829,
-0.6869882345199585,
-0.73307204246521,
-0.1491793841123581,
-0.6511983871459961,
1.1667715311050415,
-0.1701163351535797,
-0.6495447754859924,
-0.17646197974681854,
0.10679801553487778,
-0.18665426969528198,
-0.5216220617294312,
-0.11322619020938873,
0.02768375352025032,
0.8151662945747375,
0.5522814989089966,
0.5284342765808105,
0.5183295011520386,
0.4314919412136078,
0.16794176399707794,
-0.35945287346839905,
0.010265309363603592,
-0.6357508301734924,
0.46670347452163696,
0.24203072488307953,
-0.27673405408859253,
-0.13125558197498322,
0.007837691344320774,
0.0385381318628788,
0.6848636269569397,
-0.01797321066260338,
-0.05423955246806145,
0.03274593874812126,
0.7191686630249023,
-0.6262985467910767,
0.22686395049095154,
-0.11373467743396759,
0.4584297835826874,
0.09737256169319153,
0.020378099754452705,
-0.5839525461196899,
-0.5690000653266907,
0.5542132258415222,
-0.31754377484321594,
0.21286064386367798,
-0.14682726562023163,
0.6486099362373352,
0.19561360776424408,
-0.8127246499061584,
-0.624504804611206,
-0.947919487953186,
0.7567538022994995,
-0.26547971367836,
0.02154146134853363,
0.28682202100753784,
-0.13099463284015656,
0.18486738204956055,
-0.6924623847007751,
-0.30468031764030457,
-0.5037647485733032,
-0.36125054955482483,
0.3978751301765442,
-0.43523266911506653,
-0.2762323021888733,
0.2202645242214203,
0.04315474256873131,
-0.6427803039550781,
0.031398266553878784,
-0.3484949767589569,
0.4089055359363556,
0.7903773784637451,
0.6207119822502136,
0.22915250062942505,
-0.28486087918281555,
-0.5963038206100464,
-0.21385562419891357,
-0.1927804797887802,
0.5947449207305908,
0.38394981622695923,
0.165795236825943,
-0.5902819633483887,
0.6972005367279053,
-0.01054438017308712,
0.24209679663181305,
0.376149982213974,
0.1680319905281067,
0.28846773505210876,
0.0909765437245369,
0.3560921847820282,
0.40478384494781494,
0.8548865914344788,
0.5900594592094421,
0.35156843066215515,
-0.3470735251903534,
-0.11327320337295532,
0.6451321840286255,
0.4595833718776703,
-0.7405821681022644,
-0.37136685848236084,
0.23725081980228424,
-0.2039971947669983,
-0.6021100282669067,
-0.18781107664108276,
-1.2660390138626099,
-0.7088208198547363,
-0.3561529517173767,
0.12040793150663376,
-0.5240205526351929,
0.06530194729566574,
-0.047140590846538544,
-0.006273637991398573,
-0.16766025125980377,
0.09748925268650055,
-1.289415717124939,
0.11301032453775406,
0.5583867430686951,
0.8060471415519714,
-0.29545244574546814,
-0.20001958310604095,
-0.2585720121860504,
-0.09621373564004898,
-0.3229200839996338,
0.9093100428581238,
-0.5715919137001038,
-0.40846025943756104,
0.2672816514968872,
0.07942382246255875,
-0.11197783052921295,
0.010410155169665813,
0.8553832173347473,
-0.14735358953475952,
0.00618125731125474,
0.20264704525470734,
-0.4729931950569153,
-0.3083944320678711,
0.2441539764404297,
-0.49257028102874756,
0.9092408418655396,
0.22149758040905,
-0.6995612978935242,
0.18584610521793365,
-0.09859426319599152,
-0.8159005641937256,
-0.534003734588623,
0.4214637577533722,
-0.369515597820282,
0.3761385977268219,
0.5149534940719604,
0.5428182482719421,
0.34132900834083557,
0.3337843418121338,
-0.02049877680838108,
-0.5986281633377075,
0.16181929409503937,
-0.29310092329978943,
0.4759785234928131,
-0.1611214280128479,
-0.5380598902702332,
0.0763511136174202,
-0.8570109009742737,
-0.4455505907535553,
-0.10290844738483429,
0.11533808708190918,
-0.42305707931518555,
0.31043216586112976,
-0.04687878116965294,
0.25826653838157654,
0.2619865834712982,
-0.4165264368057251,
0.29610759019851685,
-0.5672929286956787,
0.04435122385621071,
0.44752779603004456,
0.30128565430641174,
0.4642281234264374,
-0.3039204776287079,
0.55699622631073,
0.438086599111557,
0.45294782519340515,
-0.16308175027370453,
-0.37215617299079895,
-0.8392795920372009,
0.016125062480568886,
-0.3360346555709839,
0.3832944929599762,
-0.4828680157661438,
0.21538563072681427,
-0.11272252351045609,
-1.0668729543685913,
-0.3087358772754669,
-0.10426674783229828,
0.20758894085884094,
0.8733433485031128,
0.5666862726211548,
-0.052081864327192307,
-0.6232855916023254,
-0.6195152401924133,
-0.06591931730508804,
-0.564201295375824,
0.08058029413223267,
0.26944446563720703,
0.2776077687740326,
-0.38728681206703186,
0.7945305109024048,
-0.5846970677375793,
-0.22639235854148865,
-0.16611354053020477,
0.7584937214851379,
0.46393895149230957,
0.4384482800960541,
0.46835416555404663,
-0.7257608771324158,
-0.4727400839328766,
-0.214721217751503,
-0.8689996600151062,
-0.2888528108596802,
-0.17879953980445862,
-0.10456530004739761,
0.25232261419296265,
0.03807530924677849,
-0.6200171709060669,
0.5770207643508911,
0.5362934470176697,
-0.4764883518218994,
0.6765162348747253,
0.02890671417117119,
0.25064873695373535,
-0.615451455116272,
-0.33611100912094116,
0.44069135189056396,
0.10856185853481293,
-0.5523130297660828,
-0.5908216238021851,
-0.003826030995696783,
0.1787205934524536,
-0.7213191986083984,
0.28616175055503845,
-0.2285066395998001,
0.17958499491214752,
0.04170513153076172,
0.4486335217952728,
-0.07855267077684402,
0.8768091797828674,
0.45913881063461304,
0.13361886143684387,
0.47439515590667725,
-0.5234760642051697,
0.38406556844711304,
0.4580002427101135,
0.015179246664047241,
0.6931059956550598,
-0.6105858087539673,
0.18468572199344635,
-0.3701976239681244,
0.1495821326971054,
-0.7923679351806641,
-0.10392676293849945,
0.08725927770137787,
-0.36000046133995056,
0.07531634718179703,
-0.13239897787570953,
-0.4380846619606018,
-0.38982412219047546,
-0.2678394615650177,
-0.10585466772317886,
0.9039576053619385,
-0.7504490613937378,
0.744497537612915,
0.2871282994747162,
-0.18351787328720093,
-0.2541098892688751,
-0.5752503275871277,
-0.08318819105625153,
-0.4822220206260681,
-0.6837667226791382,
0.12243727594614029,
-0.10301433503627777,
-0.17239068448543549,
-0.04364945366978645,
-0.039585843682289124,
-0.08261828869581223,
-0.14324013888835907,
0.7930781841278076,
0.3866961896419525,
-0.13992761075496674,
0.269084632396698,
0.21776831150054932,
-0.21748703718185425,
0.40403619408607483,
0.2588139474391937,
0.0640975758433342,
-0.3445679247379303,
0.17767499387264252,
-0.29483240842819214,
0.21870477497577667,
0.4685298502445221,
0.08302775770425797,
0.8625951409339905,
0.7504128813743591,
-0.3261030912399292,
-0.4354342222213745,
0.08107876032590866,
-0.11799939721822739,
-0.3999205529689789,
0.18623745441436768,
-0.05439186841249466,
-0.6210129261016846,
0.4796874225139618,
-0.05873812362551689,
-0.07329468429088593,
0.5520172715187073,
0.5347604155540466,
-0.5147387385368347,
1.0513041019439697,
0.7336535453796387,
0.06801632791757584,
0.41784772276878357,
-0.17896847426891327,
0.07334780693054199,
-0.645666241645813,
-0.3254845440387726,
-0.35815754532814026,
-0.7222744226455688,
-0.6027588248252869,
0.1753072589635849,
0.4479760527610779,
-0.00024522797320969403,
-0.24802535772323608,
0.5604624152183533,
-0.5845478177070618,
0.5245329737663269,
0.2651219367980957,
0.06937137246131897,
0.4819294810295105,
-0.23892471194267273,
0.11767850071191788,
-0.3784785866737366,
-0.40232014656066895,
-0.6310824751853943,
0.9158377647399902,
0.21576112508773804,
0.9867609739303589,
0.2726394534111023,
0.7112791538238525,
0.28752395510673523,
0.6432347893714905,
-0.7227764129638672,
0.36867624521255493,
-0.3909052908420563,
-0.451487272977829,
-0.11321444809436798,
-0.26091936230659485,
-0.958278477191925,
-0.01360222790390253,
-0.3766239583492279,
-1.5844887495040894,
0.5053439140319824,
-0.053778450936079025,
-0.28854066133499146,
0.02773832343518734,
-0.887457013130188,
0.8074768781661987,
-0.30579307675361633,
-0.5398393273353577,
0.2754826247692108,
-0.9570053815841675,
0.5250753164291382,
-0.1924133598804474,
-0.16793492436408997,
-0.01827806606888771,
0.1891835629940033,
0.7128011584281921,
-0.2568517029285431,
1.1739957332611084,
0.12340794503688812,
-0.05257989838719368,
0.6582101583480835,
0.3423895835876465,
0.750710129737854,
-0.028290074318647385,
-0.09485383331775665,
-0.149865061044693,
0.04272661358118057,
-0.01464717835187912,
-0.5752637386322021,
0.7260158658027649,
-0.7603230476379395,
0.12154793739318848,
-0.5369263887405396,
-0.6133713722229004,
-0.5823315978050232,
-0.2966415286064148,
0.263693630695343,
0.3201361894607544,
-0.13004112243652344,
0.2121335119009018,
0.36022812128067017,
0.04598422348499298,
0.6773843169212341,
0.47833290696144104,
-0.08458040654659271,
-0.06027628108859062,
0.6566448211669922,
-0.16960856318473816,
-0.023922575637698174,
0.23381775617599487,
0.2984718382358551,
-0.4940592646598816,
-0.022689390927553177,
-0.12067263573408127,
0.0791400894522667,
-0.6674579977989197,
0.04759274050593376,
-0.8326274752616882,
-0.05555180460214615,
0.04464476928114891,
-0.6363821625709534,
-0.39126792550086975,
-0.34197619557380676,
-0.8259311318397522,
-0.4718116223812103,
0.4996204674243927,
0.784985363483429,
-0.021458672359585762,
0.4837283790111542,
-0.9924145340919495,
0.31847506761550903,
0.15568001568317413,
0.1299741268157959,
0.13517844676971436,
-0.587949275970459,
-0.4311217665672302,
-0.11940404027700424,
-0.6171968579292297,
-0.9686377048492432,
0.7793137431144714,
0.058441996574401855,
-0.1171460673213005,
0.4149812161922455,
0.5941155552864075,
0.6226734519004822,
-0.2217758446931839,
1.012887954711914,
0.20000243186950684,
-0.9886566996574402,
0.8405232429504395,
-0.4424334466457367,
-0.07196881622076035,
0.5732089877128601,
0.5675913095474243,
-0.5317972898483276,
-0.46615979075431824,
-0.8907689452171326,
-1.1648969650268555,
0.5469232797622681,
0.37850672006607056,
0.3502894937992096,
0.017018144950270653,
0.0782565101981163,
0.25193554162979126,
0.04294499382376671,
-0.69258052110672,
-0.07964975386857986,
-0.04443132132291794,
-0.7388973832130432,
-0.30366379022598267,
-0.24367645382881165,
0.17666903138160706,
-0.2970171868801117,
0.6246085166931152,
0.09322374314069748,
0.04818546399474144,
0.2684786319732666,
-0.2169927954673767,
-0.5038051605224609,
0.023785429075360298,
0.3739161491394043,
0.1758165806531906,
-0.66391921043396,
0.3414747714996338,
-0.0744129940867424,
-0.4492158889770508,
0.30738577246665955,
0.3060697317123413,
-0.01797550544142723,
0.15547682344913483,
0.6645241975784302,
0.9488387107849121,
0.36693453788757324,
-0.7983319759368896,
0.4850858449935913,
-0.09243782609701157,
-0.016323857009410858,
-0.40159136056900024,
0.10129096359014511,
0.13558334112167358,
0.6963903307914734,
0.11739864200353622,
-0.13181214034557343,
-0.00031456307624466717,
-0.48372387886047363,
0.2787987291812897,
-0.4071952700614929,
-1.0636931657791138,
-0.568392276763916,
0.7480896711349487,
0.1288483738899231,
-0.1542600393295288,
0.7270990014076233,
-0.16466699540615082,
-0.4521508812904358,
0.9310766458511353,
0.5501200556755066,
1.0966782569885254,
0.09613851457834244,
0.5019680857658386,
0.4266776442527771,
0.5172761082649231,
0.06403545290231705,
-0.042522139847278595,
0.10523176938295364,
-0.35468789935112,
-0.05774155631661415,
-0.6102333068847656,
-0.8164877891540527,
-0.12593431770801544,
-0.5724798440933228,
0.20163197815418243,
-0.04388691857457161,
-0.06964753568172455,
-0.2544023096561432,
-0.28164857625961304,
-0.5059556365013123,
0.43675801157951355,
0.4893359839916229,
0.31205102801322937,
-1.1391160488128662,
0.1929248869419098,
0.45812830328941345,
-0.5776278972625732,
-0.8221230506896973,
0.015356112271547318,
0.00019218494708184153,
-0.08896605670452118,
0.6698613166809082,
0.3023054003715515,
-0.14020486176013947,
-0.04757281392812729,
-0.509126603603363,
-0.5197835564613342,
0.888950765132904,
-0.07605332136154175,
-0.8108694553375244,
0.053751952946186066,
0.04121195524930954,
1.145238995552063,
-0.4240976572036743,
0.3559904992580414,
0.5397418141365051,
0.31999433040618896,
0.24810896813869476,
-0.12329528480768204,
-0.35120078921318054,
-0.3028867542743683,
-0.2799583971500397,
0.010547538287937641,
-0.5176814198493958,
0.7627428770065308,
-0.3293590545654297,
-0.17305037379264832,
0.06661315262317657,
0.8395802974700928,
0.23048853874206543,
0.7410175800323486,
0.4081695079803467,
0.34887373447418213,
0.5020850896835327,
-0.26737159490585327,
1.1009156703948975,
-0.22943809628486633,
0.6691282391548157,
1.0895885229110718,
-0.2358577847480774,
0.824212372303009,
0.46677395701408386,
-0.0269571952521801,
0.7859213948249817,
0.7724908590316772,
0.014360018074512482,
0.5455226898193359,
0.2894551157951355,
-0.22122055292129517,
-0.07032780349254608,
-0.23924314975738525,
0.09675882756710052,
0.25760990381240845,
0.25673237442970276,
-0.48125913739204407,
0.02201947383582592,
0.14944590628147125,
0.01344379223883152,
-0.04805271700024605,
-0.1708206683397293,
0.6257882118225098,
0.3348900377750397,
-0.5714142918586731,
0.2427658885717392,
-0.4169386625289917,
0.48636963963508606,
-0.37938639521598816,
0.06283045560121536,
-0.45584237575531006,
0.10603217780590057,
-0.11897961050271988,
-0.864047110080719,
0.26696062088012695,
0.6861541867256165,
-0.0745125487446785,
-0.2751537561416626,
0.6092367768287659,
-0.6264363527297974,
-0.6904827356338501,
0.25066396594047546,
0.3838237226009369,
0.1030762568116188,
0.18931692838668823,
-0.15672242641448975,
-0.12177284806966782,
-0.3382733464241028,
-0.7115618586540222,
-0.09315121173858643,
0.7126255035400391,
0.13464206457138062,
0.5334929823875427,
0.38101768493652344,
-0.28664273023605347,
-0.1012931689620018,
0.06856504827737808,
0.6626254320144653,
-0.8563517332077026,
-0.6709732413291931,
-0.787756085395813,
1.0652515888214111,
0.3101700246334076,
-0.543644905090332,
0.4941893517971039,
0.3175615966320038,
0.12098201364278793,
-0.3294527232646942,
0.29733937978744507,
0.14450955390930176,
0.2531661093235016,
-0.4254519045352936,
0.5360131859779358,
-0.5893018841743469,
0.13442382216453552,
-0.6507278084754944,
-0.9911472797393799,
-0.25782081484794617,
0.45726504921913147,
-0.3880959749221802,
-0.09302198141813278,
0.9638147950172424,
0.342366486787796,
0.09990965574979782,
0.3219892680644989,
0.0027737002819776535,
0.33703047037124634,
0.16976191103458405,
1.0191184282302856,
1.2677335739135742,
-0.2916899025440216,
0.38795629143714905,
-0.6168149709701538,
-0.07043828070163727,
-0.29801684617996216,
-0.9794564247131348,
-0.8830270767211914,
-0.5879266262054443,
-0.5378768444061279,
-0.3816494345664978,
0.06808650493621826,
0.43910348415374756,
0.4701482653617859,
-0.43437036871910095,
0.23119224607944489,
-0.07017706334590912,
-0.04266431927680969,
-0.2591531276702881,
-0.24916696548461914,
0.5223820805549622,
-0.11925588548183441,
-0.8334837555885315,
0.2482818216085434,
0.09765271842479706,
0.26336929202079773,
0.028906825929880142,
0.03544878959655762,
0.047612473368644714,
0.24332696199417114,
0.47084859013557434,
0.04325295239686966,
-0.18732850253582,
-0.35556936264038086,
-0.07454139739274979,
-0.37658441066741943,
0.15354140102863312,
0.3630611300468445,
-0.8826186060905457,
0.32984697818756104,
0.1760181039571762,
0.24916435778141022,
1.0405482053756714,
0.21236050128936768,
0.06793081015348434,
-1.013582468032837,
0.09173659235239029,
0.5843691825866699,
0.13772675395011902,
0.17146353423595428,
-0.5782603025436401,
0.7363837361335754,
0.17664124071598053,
-0.4655642807483673,
-0.5272848606109619,
-0.03383718803524971,
-1.5144771337509155,
0.21981212496757507,
1.1301649808883667,
-0.11341739445924759,
-0.41138404607772827,
0.27910304069519043,
-0.2750466763973236,
0.40207040309906006,
-0.4242022633552551,
0.998939037322998,
0.711600661277771,
-0.4808275103569031,
-0.32855507731437683,
-0.29022809863090515,
0.12978312373161316,
0.18943239748477936,
-0.9441877007484436,
0.014229015447199345,
0.6848260760307312,
-0.39096853137016296,
0.13556109368801117,
0.15015068650245667,
0.09887755662202835,
-0.07728628814220428,
0.25703179836273193,
-0.003450114279985428,
0.1150677502155304,
-0.46360835433006287,
-0.1566135287284851,
0.26770448684692383,
-0.6747899055480957,
0.01750246435403824
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.02245v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.02245v1
|
Description Boosting for Zero-Shot Entity and Relation Classification
| 2024-06-04T12:09:44 | 2024-06-04T12:09:44 |
Gabriele Picco, Leopold Fuchs, Marcos Martínez Galindo, Alberto Purpura, Vanessa López, Hoang Thanh Lam
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IR, cs.LG
|
Zero-shot entity and relation classification models leverage available
external information of unseen classes -- e.g., textual descriptions -- to
annotate input text data. Thanks to the minimum data requirement, Zero-Shot
Learning (ZSL) methods have high value in practice, especially in applications
where labeled data is scarce. Even though recent research in ZSL has
demonstrated significant results, our analysis reveals that those methods are
sensitive to provided textual descriptions of entities (or relations). Even a
minor modification of descriptions can lead to a change in the decision
boundary between entity (or relation) classes. In this paper, we formally
define the problem of identifying effective descriptions for zero shot
inference. We propose a strategy for generating variations of an initial
description, a heuristic for ranking them and an ensemble method capable of
boosting the predictions of zero-shot models through description enhancement.
Empirical results on four different entity and relation classification datasets
show that our proposed method outperform existing approaches and achieve new
SOTA results on these datasets under the ZSL settings. The source code of the
proposed solutions and the evaluation framework are open-sourced.
|
[
-0.2835228443145752,
-0.3242752254009247,
0.5735809206962585,
0.14503712952136993,
-0.3233981728553772,
-0.06446729600429535,
-0.19938991963863373,
-0.9715604186058044,
0.3484136760234833,
0.42647913098335266,
-0.575588047504425,
-0.4773017466068268,
-0.23237380385398865,
0.1799233853816986,
-0.3997305631637573,
1.6064622402191162,
-0.043657395988702774,
-0.08237790316343307,
-0.3087412118911743,
0.009444313123822212,
-0.33585140109062195,
-0.20439976453781128,
-0.1551389992237091,
-0.3560314476490021,
0.3860762119293213,
0.3542531430721283,
0.5452892780303955,
0.9248820543289185,
0.3733585774898529,
0.007421893998980522,
-0.2123400717973709,
-0.08152343332767487,
-0.4476739168167114,
0.41360175609588623,
-0.21595783531665802,
-0.6151222586631775,
-0.38043487071990967,
-0.33859768509864807,
0.7489993572235107,
0.6711501479148865,
0.24756474792957306,
0.4575091600418091,
-0.24713170528411865,
0.0026673763059079647,
-1.4224451780319214,
0.3913906514644623,
-0.8334155082702637,
0.23444567620754242,
-0.16677765548229218,
-0.6697492599487305,
-0.5318720936775208,
0.2846300005912781,
0.27914920449256897,
-0.6047454476356506,
0.5226410627365112,
-0.19529153406620026,
1.1860095262527466,
0.04630891606211662,
-0.13559004664421082,
0.037445299327373505,
-1.234237790107727,
0.7983279824256897,
-0.5942903161048889,
0.01858210749924183,
0.21689701080322266,
0.41990676522254944,
0.25853997468948364,
-0.40526247024536133,
-0.39247220754623413,
-0.10558084398508072,
-0.33193501830101013,
0.26504647731781006,
0.09495949000120163,
0.2118046134710312,
0.29948824644088745,
0.7039251923561096,
-0.0948895514011383,
0.18218296766281128,
-0.4185185730457306,
-0.2321864515542984,
0.8666812181472778,
0.36604902148246765,
0.09501861780881882,
-0.09740271419286728,
-0.8162674903869629,
0.09038339555263519,
-0.7238739728927612,
-0.11913632601499557,
0.057144343852996826,
0.6297138333320618,
0.15804749727249146,
0.4690212607383728,
-0.7161657214164734,
0.8602969646453857,
-0.1584189534187317,
-0.014729762449860573,
0.23928400874137878,
-0.427348792552948,
-0.3221164047718048,
0.4983527958393097,
0.5185904502868652,
0.5058630704879761,
-0.10920316725969315,
-0.4550131857395172,
-0.45133092999458313,
0.21300476789474487,
0.08486917614936829,
-1.1436971426010132,
0.02061261422932148,
0.10673847049474716,
-0.21733394265174866,
-0.6514674425125122,
-0.022479215636849403,
-0.9584335684776306,
-0.2531435191631317,
-0.0703534409403801,
0.4832107722759247,
-0.1824742704629898,
-0.2165733277797699,
-0.07387793064117432,
-0.25772640109062195,
0.3283045291900635,
0.20761126279830933,
-0.9039177894592285,
0.09258995950222015,
0.6252883672714233,
0.7890145778656006,
0.2166503369808197,
-0.24391911923885345,
-0.5164139270782471,
0.48588046431541443,
-0.5381096601486206,
0.9119250178337097,
-0.5819036364555359,
-0.12147068232297897,
0.1049673929810524,
-0.3062291145324707,
0.3517582416534424,
-0.06258887052536011,
0.6375171542167664,
-0.37933021783828735,
0.13795621693134308,
0.14941638708114624,
-0.8149688243865967,
0.13493116199970245,
0.12855535745620728,
-0.5447897911071777,
0.7760964035987854,
0.19894802570343018,
-0.8640648126602173,
0.6513046026229858,
-0.548753559589386,
-0.4636452794075012,
0.7235474586486816,
-0.4053318202495575,
-0.5427340865135193,
0.2735442519187927,
0.11801006644964218,
0.576725959777832,
-0.14050236344337463,
-0.35811546444892883,
-0.23479387164115906,
-0.41238293051719666,
0.09983973205089569,
0.1348205953836441,
0.7396093606948853,
0.16893312335014343,
-0.3205556571483612,
0.17247635126113892,
-1.026353120803833,
0.29697179794311523,
0.11411634087562561,
0.14332349598407745,
-0.4992939829826355,
-0.12345250695943832,
-0.18914303183555603,
0.04890839383006096,
0.05693092197179794,
-0.5287249684333801,
0.1754884421825409,
-0.5250978469848633,
0.1828891783952713,
0.29566508531570435,
0.30715280771255493,
0.6353010535240173,
-0.13770678639411926,
0.6550448536872864,
0.016036389395594597,
0.11516951769590378,
-0.955234944820404,
-0.40964943170547485,
-0.5021085143089294,
-0.16721239686012268,
0.5541216135025024,
0.49966421723365784,
-0.9739114046096802,
0.37874412536621094,
-0.40162330865859985,
-0.6132685542106628,
-0.565822422504425,
-0.05496916547417641,
0.597949743270874,
0.8075376152992249,
0.6316487193107605,
-0.20457974076271057,
-0.4730530083179474,
-0.9719964265823364,
-0.16967205703258514,
-0.28810247778892517,
-0.2286272644996643,
0.1316935420036316,
0.29492706060409546,
0.29242458939552307,
0.9770406484603882,
-0.7413139343261719,
-0.5525146126747131,
-0.2688753008842468,
0.20781132578849792,
-0.19155088067054749,
0.11788709461688995,
0.7814593315124512,
-0.6447000503540039,
-0.48073336482048035,
-0.027900731191039085,
-0.660426676273346,
0.10918653756380081,
-0.5474196076393127,
-0.20349903404712677,
0.03742304816842079,
0.006192956119775772,
-0.6377031803131104,
0.7162539958953857,
-0.3068585991859436,
-0.13748188316822052,
0.6260887980461121,
0.04040948674082756,
-0.25823643803596497,
-0.853827178478241,
-0.25219371914863586,
0.2922585904598236,
-0.06905291974544525,
-0.9735998511314392,
0.5692782998085022,
0.12356214225292206,
0.19577448070049286,
-0.49121934175491333,
0.46647682785987854,
-0.653899610042572,
-0.16180279850959778,
-0.10162323713302612,
0.253282368183136,
-0.059356726706027985,
0.3729846179485321,
0.4364628791809082,
0.34361380338668823,
1.0452890396118164,
-0.6467718482017517,
0.2795628607273102,
0.4329693615436554,
-0.27397242188453674,
0.8053497076034546,
-0.2851075530052185,
-0.018044346943497658,
-0.398121178150177,
0.3784039318561554,
-0.6563264727592468,
-0.34119805693626404,
0.10878945142030716,
-0.6664160490036011,
0.43634793162345886,
-0.3160254657268524,
-0.4474269151687622,
-0.2544628083705902,
-0.7030237317085266,
0.06395214051008224,
0.2449905425310135,
-0.402834951877594,
0.3030915856361389,
-0.06049903482198715,
0.36148449778556824,
-0.8794588446617126,
-0.7154269814491272,
0.12513701617717743,
-0.14872924983501434,
-0.22193823754787445,
0.7013857364654541,
0.15286041796207428,
0.040055908262729645,
0.28971585631370544,
-0.21865156292915344,
-0.40479663014411926,
0.22463005781173706,
0.06972862035036087,
0.7623724937438965,
-0.31635355949401855,
0.7210805416107178,
-0.03155267983675003,
-0.01785987801849842,
-0.21851219236850739,
-0.23436160385608673,
0.24727098643779755,
-0.006935349199920893,
0.41596198081970215,
-0.4084843099117279,
0.03606420382857323,
0.025088759139180183,
-0.29918307065963745,
0.8476676940917969,
0.6318306922912598,
-0.44113239645957947,
-0.45861104130744934,
0.03153160586953163,
-0.2641884684562683,
-0.30947890877723694,
0.36496424674987793,
-0.41183310747146606,
-0.5458967089653015,
0.3009394109249115,
0.295000821352005,
0.28445619344711304,
0.6790245175361633,
0.419687956571579,
0.14982695877552032,
0.7510895729064941,
0.7262911796569824,
0.023773498833179474,
0.3901994824409485,
-0.26199209690093994,
0.19117693603038788,
-0.8297631144523621,
-0.09864775091409683,
-0.550929605960846,
-0.23848122358322144,
-0.4921416640281677,
-0.032349374145269394,
0.1083277016878128,
0.45001453161239624,
0.016294104978442192,
0.6774774789810181,
-0.864710807800293,
0.7891571521759033,
0.13085781037807465,
-0.14448824524879456,
0.41656753420829773,
0.12487487494945526,
0.21344687044620514,
0.0093602379783988,
-0.4529836177825928,
-0.42712312936782837,
1.1897335052490234,
0.14774319529533386,
0.5402690172195435,
-0.018599998205900192,
1.0430294275283813,
0.06529136747121811,
0.3861057758331299,
-0.9932310581207275,
0.48629266023635864,
0.1227523684501648,
-0.8826547265052795,
-0.5014153718948364,
-0.7091922163963318,
-0.9050360321998596,
0.08737952262163162,
-0.6421436667442322,
-0.9346684217453003,
0.00017519466928206384,
0.22448639571666718,
-1.003258228302002,
0.11612579226493835,
-0.32763612270355225,
0.4305952787399292,
-0.2776995301246643,
-0.4421067237854004,
0.08811035007238388,
-0.7849624156951904,
0.4002542793750763,
0.16653704643249512,
-0.011002082377672195,
-0.059686917811632156,
-0.2582080364227295,
0.28958845138549805,
-0.2273816615343094,
0.502254843711853,
-0.14449436962604523,
-0.054662611335515976,
0.3493240475654602,
0.031440410763025284,
0.15913842618465424,
0.01613347791135311,
-0.019094102084636688,
-0.12221846729516983,
0.3599318265914917,
-0.4663075804710388,
-0.9373936057090759,
0.48279106616973877,
-0.49194708466529846,
-0.17188328504562378,
-0.01673918589949608,
-0.28493088483810425,
-0.33696305751800537,
0.24150314927101135,
0.5842562317848206,
0.5577904582023621,
-0.044915322214365005,
0.07697570323944092,
0.4716719090938568,
-0.11728554964065552,
0.49054214358329773,
0.5399580001831055,
-0.4025159776210785,
-0.19642186164855957,
0.9719736576080322,
0.36429253220558167,
0.2907011806964874,
0.6367784738540649,
-0.02287343703210354,
-0.1375775784254074,
-0.37379589676856995,
-0.9557983875274658,
-0.05986042320728302,
-0.6117160320281982,
-0.7625821232795715,
-0.408713161945343,
-0.41541144251823425,
-0.40508267283439636,
-0.0014415988698601723,
-0.21481774747371674,
-0.9167614579200745,
-0.26939478516578674,
-0.39042460918426514,
0.3593810796737671,
0.617388129234314,
0.2046111822128296,
0.3353416919708252,
-0.7139754295349121,
0.04432503506541252,
0.06912607699632645,
0.516126811504364,
0.14703573286533356,
-0.13040384650230408,
-0.2736204266548157,
-0.018152160570025444,
-0.36644601821899414,
-1.1967321634292603,
0.23067761957645416,
0.4216974973678589,
0.4842659831047058,
0.5513200163841248,
0.5121882557868958,
0.46142295002937317,
-0.24872896075248718,
0.8111608624458313,
0.32851144671440125,
-0.8193294405937195,
0.9372469782829285,
-0.1326105147600174,
-0.07456289976835251,
0.4313686192035675,
0.39098721742630005,
-0.04866722971200943,
-0.2998676598072052,
-0.924814760684967,
-1.016489863395691,
0.7853904962539673,
0.42954209446907043,
0.4804266393184662,
0.029397504404187202,
0.8248615860939026,
-0.028210913762450218,
0.3279947340488434,
-0.7718660831451416,
-0.44281378388404846,
-0.08522315323352814,
-0.17287234961986542,
0.13345688581466675,
-0.33553048968315125,
-0.018834780901670456,
0.010878952220082283,
0.7169098854064941,
-0.16802021861076355,
0.33465576171875,
0.26516473293304443,
-0.1539313793182373,
-0.39121007919311523,
0.632339596748352,
0.6050554513931274,
0.47792571783065796,
-0.2802616357803345,
0.2972733974456787,
0.16271430253982544,
0.042735982686281204,
-0.022767607122659683,
0.06248929351568222,
-0.700359046459198,
0.347530722618103,
0.6818720698356628,
1.1203138828277588,
0.2591351270675659,
-0.3752638101577759,
0.6681720614433289,
0.25092557072639465,
-0.11341742426156998,
-0.0586470328271389,
0.2484302669763565,
-0.28831762075424194,
-0.132777601480484,
0.38903412222862244,
-0.2010902613401413,
0.4360385537147522,
-0.8779724836349487,
0.17847950756549835,
0.3884381353855133,
-0.6317446827888489,
-0.4193660020828247,
0.4298233687877655,
0.004931751638650894,
-0.36184144020080566,
0.18374419212341309,
-0.4832210838794708,
-0.5189381241798401,
0.5057344436645508,
0.5480571985244751,
0.7193716168403625,
-0.19812694191932678,
0.4558872580528259,
0.4132149815559387,
0.03639952465891838,
-0.007087933365255594,
-0.0958988144993782,
-0.5999707579612732,
-0.7010319828987122,
-0.45487678050994873,
-0.5928789973258972,
-0.35513800382614136,
0.13282763957977295,
-1.0523953437805176,
0.6639893054962158,
-0.5046778917312622,
-0.08254197984933853,
0.712071418762207,
0.022762499749660492,
-0.5051579475402832,
0.03792869672179222,
0.28710874915122986,
0.8124344348907471,
-0.8312784433364868,
0.5986737012863159,
0.7619391679763794,
-1.0120149850845337,
-0.6396295428276062,
0.15689973533153534,
-0.24919641017913818,
-0.44765615463256836,
0.641175389289856,
0.17106136679649353,
-0.006484014913439751,
-0.04797426611185074,
-0.7702212929725647,
-0.44756019115448,
1.0339797735214233,
0.47047603130340576,
-0.3777307868003845,
-0.28196626901626587,
-0.1296503096818924,
0.9218302965164185,
-0.6619173288345337,
0.510272204875946,
0.29422470927238464,
0.13832280039787292,
0.39371609687805176,
-0.7919161319732666,
-0.0725957378745079,
0.015941016376018524,
0.1833067387342453,
0.32308298349380493,
-0.5042093992233276,
0.7773534655570984,
-0.2868461012840271,
-0.5570998191833496,
0.28877776861190796,
0.6412065625190735,
-0.08855246007442474,
0.47217270731925964,
0.3629177212715149,
0.42986735701560974,
0.5404636859893799,
0.10493630170822144,
1.1100735664367676,
-0.20936612784862518,
0.7956602573394775,
1.6344953775405884,
-0.4508345127105713,
1.0151238441467285,
-0.0212392620742321,
-0.055623944848775864,
0.6773027181625366,
0.484211266040802,
-0.3420458436012268,
0.38218382000923157,
0.2008129507303238,
-0.453753799200058,
-0.34649959206581116,
-0.33416032791137695,
-0.30511999130249023,
0.4963786005973816,
0.3237155079841614,
-0.7191413640975952,
-0.6752132773399353,
-0.2980744242668152,
-0.09939020127058029,
-0.02321675233542919,
-0.5821672677993774,
0.8887643218040466,
-0.2686672508716583,
-0.37649399042129517,
0.4544883668422699,
-0.10951004177331924,
0.45941025018692017,
-0.08600762486457825,
-0.14374402165412903,
-0.031153086572885513,
0.06997489929199219,
-0.5948774218559265,
-0.8068341612815857,
0.33977407217025757,
-0.0004255644744262099,
-0.2482777088880539,
-0.1441001296043396,
0.9570345282554626,
-0.5312198400497437,
-0.45367535948753357,
0.3124311864376068,
0.3091666102409363,
0.30300256609916687,
0.07755564153194427,
-0.2608058452606201,
-0.471509724855423,
-0.13058383762836456,
0.2958530783653259,
0.33264538645744324,
0.3889433741569519,
-0.1974005252122879,
0.39109519124031067,
0.20443226397037506,
0.34435153007507324,
0.006904074922204018,
-0.18447889387607574,
0.6455596089363098,
-0.45986294746398926,
-0.5792458057403564,
-0.9250504374504089,
0.3286452293395996,
-0.42586642503738403,
-0.22778475284576416,
0.7200040221214294,
0.5898314714431763,
0.9701259136199951,
-0.030535420402884483,
0.7212271094322205,
0.13759328424930573,
0.6825087666511536,
-0.2627313435077667,
0.42951610684394836,
-0.3270919620990753,
0.26603928208351135,
-0.18337516486644745,
-1.0715768337249756,
-0.42696234583854675,
0.5238150358200073,
-0.02874583564698696,
-0.1637570708990097,
0.3325185179710388,
0.35203781723976135,
0.13677017390727997,
0.1280769556760788,
0.4127034842967987,
0.06293828785419464,
-0.010339215397834778,
0.528724193572998,
0.9815933704376221,
-0.3585064113140106,
0.7140594124794006,
-0.5536011457443237,
-0.3687964975833893,
-0.2450132519006729,
-0.8168814182281494,
-0.7344055771827698,
-0.376097172498703,
-0.7357953190803528,
-0.20323477685451508,
-0.07903265208005905,
0.808245062828064,
0.8559977412223816,
-0.6815441846847534,
0.024757318198680878,
-0.02201981097459793,
0.06935098767280579,
-0.2974269390106201,
-0.31887006759643555,
0.06251198053359985,
-0.742752194404602,
-0.3650597929954529,
0.06408780813217163,
0.5461586117744446,
0.08546911180019379,
-0.421276718378067,
0.11900486052036285,
0.042228974401950836,
0.03136565536260605,
0.6332937479019165,
0.3264652192592621,
-0.5336805582046509,
-0.12235546857118607,
-0.15661801397800446,
0.20017340779304504,
0.07260322570800781,
0.8767228126525879,
-0.8343669772148132,
0.5644494891166687,
0.1876203864812851,
0.4887469410896301,
0.5829229354858398,
-0.15850363671779633,
0.38686123490333557,
-1.158792495727539,
0.02592495270073414,
0.32208406925201416,
0.050103191286325455,
0.396494060754776,
-0.7609622478485107,
0.8507190942764282,
0.0504496768116951,
-0.1690351516008377,
-1.1476744413375854,
0.29681286215782166,
-0.7083075046539307,
-0.21361838281154633,
0.961564838886261,
-0.45717108249664307,
-0.12164489924907684,
0.15822573006153107,
0.19508787989616394,
0.2925545871257782,
-0.2569914758205414,
0.8517712950706482,
0.5763497948646545,
-0.2869359254837036,
-0.19780704379081726,
-0.5716515183448792,
0.6549184918403625,
0.19804203510284424,
-0.7076261043548584,
0.22597023844718933,
0.45167475938796997,
0.07312826067209244,
0.6550604104995728,
0.3672712445259094,
-0.024222014471888542,
0.34290575981140137,
-0.22233179211616516,
0.1315506100654602,
-0.02117418497800827,
-0.30789047479629517,
-0.4957452714443207,
0.09026637673377991,
0.09710527956485748,
-0.3045274019241333
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.02237v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.02237v1
|
Self-Modifying State Modeling for Simultaneous Machine Translation
| 2024-06-04T11:57:58 | 2024-06-04T11:57:58 |
Donglei Yu, Xiaomian Kang, Yuchen Liu, Yu Zhou, Chengqing Zong
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Simultaneous Machine Translation (SiMT) generates target outputs while
receiving stream source inputs and requires a read/write policy to decide
whether to wait for the next source token or generate a new target token, whose
decisions form a \textit{decision path}. Existing SiMT methods, which learn the
policy by exploring various decision paths in training, face inherent
limitations. These methods not only fail to precisely optimize the policy due
to the inability to accurately assess the individual impact of each decision on
SiMT performance, but also cannot sufficiently explore all potential paths
because of their vast number. Besides, building decision paths requires
unidirectional encoders to simulate streaming source inputs, which impairs the
translation quality of SiMT models. To solve these issues, we propose
\textbf{S}elf-\textbf{M}odifying \textbf{S}tate \textbf{M}odeling (SM$^2$), a
novel training paradigm for SiMT task. Without building decision paths, SM$^2$
individually optimizes decisions at each state during training. To precisely
optimize the policy, SM$^2$ introduces Self-Modifying process to independently
assess and adjust decisions at each state. For sufficient exploration, SM$^2$
proposes Prefix Sampling to efficiently traverse all potential states.
Moreover, SM$^2$ ensures compatibility with bidirectional encoders, thus
achieving higher translation quality. Experiments show that SM$^2$ outperforms
strong baselines. Furthermore, SM$^2$ allows offline machine translation models
to acquire SiMT ability with fine-tuning.
|
[
-0.16545122861862183,
-0.5549004077911377,
0.5267032980918884,
0.23954841494560242,
-0.45143309235572815,
0.055438507348299026,
-0.16011372208595276,
0.0003408832708373666,
0.24172721803188324,
0.5644770860671997,
-0.695847749710083,
0.023973437026143074,
-0.6652608513832092,
0.37754884362220764,
-0.056710172444581985,
1.167012333869934,
-0.6407707929611206,
0.2915600538253784,
-0.01670634001493454,
-0.08496458828449249,
-0.4538121223449707,
-0.23057821393013,
-0.5944685935974121,
-0.0621587336063385,
0.14478369057178497,
0.3398688733577728,
0.7402135133743286,
0.8940519094467163,
0.5185055732727051,
0.39939627051353455,
-0.05151361599564552,
0.2654728591442108,
-0.37302157282829285,
0.33478614687919617,
-0.06679456681013107,
-0.5264307260513306,
-0.48906001448631287,
-0.1220175176858902,
1.0990561246871948,
0.2178272157907486,
-0.15097828209400177,
0.0658423900604248,
0.18855591118335724,
0.49886369705200195,
-0.1835084706544876,
0.13249324262142181,
-0.6275964379310608,
0.00013727450277656317,
-0.2386145144701004,
-0.3542001247406006,
-0.24740640819072723,
0.12485750764608383,
-0.3342183232307434,
-0.29013070464134216,
0.2337547391653061,
0.14352154731750488,
0.7815300822257996,
0.7068458199501038,
-0.7013344764709473,
-0.09719415009021759,
-0.8941195011138916,
0.8473559617996216,
-0.6863272786140442,
0.47276926040649414,
0.3556535243988037,
0.2367784082889557,
-0.3644069731235504,
-0.47133970260620117,
-0.28997716307640076,
-0.19663077592849731,
-0.07934977114200592,
0.46128323674201965,
0.0029896998312324286,
0.20673365890979767,
0.3942698538303375,
0.17706188559532166,
-0.390878826379776,
-0.18634754419326782,
-0.5049399733543396,
-0.10131941735744476,
0.6275603771209717,
0.18845604360103607,
0.24740326404571533,
-0.28062647581100464,
-0.8167198300361633,
0.05422809347510338,
-0.6015864014625549,
0.11991110444068909,
0.4300483465194702,
0.18228669464588165,
0.12837260961532593,
0.5302526354789734,
-0.18308253586292267,
0.41414883732795715,
0.13508737087249756,
-0.07217343896627426,
0.18150529265403748,
-0.2059890776872635,
-0.18935343623161316,
0.08040643483400345,
0.9418004155158997,
0.011819787323474884,
-0.26428017020225525,
-0.1558576077222824,
-0.5119746327400208,
-0.22057899832725525,
0.4685995280742645,
-0.8443391919136047,
0.1800578087568283,
0.30222082138061523,
-0.281999796628952,
-0.11927808821201324,
0.039488423615694046,
-0.48758792877197266,
0.0040301363915205,
-0.5108931064605713,
0.6229541301727295,
-0.5765628814697266,
-0.29154929518699646,
0.018875084817409515,
0.20175115764141083,
-0.195024773478508,
0.27407318353652954,
-0.7835476398468018,
0.2844175398349762,
0.36086612939834595,
1.028334140777588,
-0.4118334650993347,
-0.6749221682548523,
-0.4018310606479645,
0.3719235956668854,
-0.3171980381011963,
0.7079240679740906,
-0.21563997864723206,
-0.42416876554489136,
-0.5300425291061401,
-0.055358998477458954,
-0.26398608088493347,
-0.28293362259864807,
0.5056892037391663,
-0.3856973350048065,
-0.4919784367084503,
-0.2604425549507141,
-0.5779740214347839,
-0.1229902058839798,
-0.029072703793644905,
-0.6433600783348083,
1.0451442003250122,
-0.07878580689430237,
-0.7095133662223816,
0.07226389646530151,
-0.9015630483627319,
-0.418306827545166,
-0.2052173763513565,
-0.2299359142780304,
-0.4193113446235657,
0.192207932472229,
0.2085510939359665,
0.3689216077327728,
-0.12406279891729355,
0.5507710576057434,
-0.16937564313411713,
-0.233982652425766,
0.06974311918020248,
-0.6346319913864136,
0.6533705592155457,
0.5159996151924133,
-0.36775219440460205,
0.24803271889686584,
-0.501738965511322,
-0.10426511615514755,
0.09116347879171371,
-0.46881103515625,
-0.16715547442436218,
0.16895973682403564,
-0.231667160987854,
0.4576703906059265,
0.11007211357355118,
-0.7503554224967957,
0.4994063079357147,
-0.20306555926799774,
0.31830573081970215,
0.9379515051841736,
-0.006586517207324505,
0.31007716059684753,
-0.30836808681488037,
0.6221860647201538,
0.3049868643283844,
0.1310456395149231,
-0.29728156328201294,
-0.11684691905975342,
-0.9020911455154419,
-0.34446242451667786,
0.3398354649543762,
0.5725662708282471,
-0.9680484533309937,
-0.014523249119520187,
-0.36005899310112,
-0.33268946409225464,
-0.9674501419067383,
0.1363549679517746,
0.24143190681934357,
0.09552782773971558,
0.666146457195282,
0.023505330085754395,
-0.2867544889450073,
-0.743481457233429,
-0.6371559500694275,
0.06936217844486237,
0.3012334108352661,
0.03659231215715408,
0.48231059312820435,
-0.13284918665885925,
0.8316076993942261,
-0.337150901556015,
-0.48123884201049805,
-0.33072659373283386,
0.43222710490226746,
0.13394570350646973,
0.720008909702301,
0.28748786449432373,
-0.7361401319503784,
-0.6124670505523682,
-0.1518939733505249,
-0.707151472568512,
-0.17254503071308136,
-0.5478532910346985,
-0.13624711334705353,
0.23606571555137634,
0.8013477325439453,
-0.32281413674354553,
0.5181455016136169,
0.6481090784072876,
-0.16963434219360352,
0.4774642288684845,
-0.5272310376167297,
0.379778116941452,
-1.1570738554000854,
-0.39939406514167786,
-0.2847772240638733,
-0.36754468083381653,
-0.55029296875,
0.17346049845218658,
0.2895148992538452,
0.07032697647809982,
-0.5633474588394165,
0.2513326108455658,
-0.8091444969177246,
-0.14748729765415192,
-0.3654756546020508,
-0.3502037525177002,
-0.31864437460899353,
0.6056521534919739,
-0.04848359525203705,
0.9509286880493164,
0.5510905981063843,
-0.42388030886650085,
0.07812941074371338,
0.06858845800161362,
0.06725849956274033,
0.44349992275238037,
-0.5681791305541992,
0.12136941403150558,
-0.26455941796302795,
0.45274096727371216,
-0.7603922486305237,
0.15911762416362762,
0.2513009309768677,
-0.16158199310302734,
0.5735487937927246,
-0.41025984287261963,
-0.6269458532333374,
-0.14503327012062073,
-0.05185707286000252,
0.5310590863227844,
0.448466420173645,
-0.427768349647522,
0.8785890340805054,
0.26242145895957947,
-0.15499134361743927,
-0.2878175377845764,
-0.6216105818748474,
0.00014810977154411376,
0.06591657549142838,
-0.5547760725021362,
0.31833574175834656,
-0.2845720052719116,
0.3250287175178528,
0.06142163649201393,
-0.35435622930526733,
0.03647521138191223,
-0.07768801599740982,
0.37237656116485596,
0.19100911915302277,
-0.13401827216148376,
-0.07260510325431824,
0.6106526851654053,
-0.42523449659347534,
-0.11124712228775024,
-0.3193413019180298,
0.3189711272716522,
-0.300557017326355,
-0.5846049189567566,
-0.5261319279670715,
0.45233801007270813,
0.677487313747406,
-0.4697095453739166,
0.7783318161964417,
0.6488707661628723,
-0.13448135554790497,
-0.1807279884815216,
-0.31123965978622437,
-0.1471673548221588,
-0.5076646208763123,
0.2902870178222656,
-1.0563918352127075,
-0.8336643576622009,
0.23896758258342743,
-0.5095635652542114,
0.19284212589263916,
0.5064706206321716,
0.5806103348731995,
-0.23529110848903656,
1.227676272392273,
0.36318713426589966,
0.318166583776474,
0.3097084164619446,
-0.3466952443122864,
0.173481285572052,
-1.0414831638336182,
0.06072402745485306,
-0.14947085082530975,
-0.2635153830051422,
-0.7102687954902649,
-0.5791985392570496,
0.6331379413604736,
0.1994762271642685,
0.07028576731681824,
0.48997175693511963,
-0.06704460084438324,
0.39775028824806213,
0.5107494592666626,
0.12836232781410217,
0.29051846265792847,
-0.09442103654146194,
-0.6784645915031433,
-0.29416704177856445,
-0.8637313842773438,
-0.3215368986129761,
0.9483178853988647,
0.31408628821372986,
1.0097870826721191,
0.10987653583288193,
1.02864408493042,
0.16538850963115692,
0.19489265978336334,
-0.5088066458702087,
0.5240936875343323,
-0.2960713803768158,
-0.48474374413490295,
-0.3892256021499634,
-0.6702799797058105,
-0.770962655544281,
0.6272429823875427,
-0.14398203790187836,
-0.44073256850242615,
-0.04838895797729492,
0.5223530530929565,
-0.2140364646911621,
0.7849509716033936,
-0.425013929605484,
0.728010356426239,
-0.5106722712516785,
-0.3208785355091095,
-0.17204752564430237,
-0.6401139497756958,
0.21864980459213257,
-0.32721731066703796,
0.15115347504615784,
-0.1416923850774765,
-0.01634305901825428,
0.40468767285346985,
-0.3422563374042511,
0.549306333065033,
-0.0038274619728326797,
0.020891567692160606,
0.19741547107696533,
0.5030794143676758,
0.5583416223526001,
-0.12599912285804749,
-0.10633064806461334,
0.5021082758903503,
0.2553168833255768,
-0.3044663667678833,
-0.5817620158195496,
0.6488547325134277,
-0.724511444568634,
-0.6240867972373962,
-0.7546160221099854,
-0.7755225896835327,
-0.02896782197058201,
0.3446204662322998,
0.29451191425323486,
0.26960811018943787,
-0.08762459456920624,
-0.022038215771317482,
0.23095488548278809,
0.02310112863779068,
0.24933254718780518,
0.7012706995010376,
-0.23484449088573456,
-0.22127225995063782,
1.044793725013733,
0.4230746626853943,
0.5643253326416016,
0.20766760408878326,
0.2489895075559616,
-0.33764368295669556,
-0.34107503294944763,
-0.6677162647247314,
0.36167246103286743,
-0.4154197871685028,
-0.23508229851722717,
-0.7312516570091248,
-0.40707433223724365,
-0.43212518095970154,
0.11200908571481705,
-0.7458829283714294,
-0.22573935985565186,
-0.06563211977481842,
0.18625934422016144,
0.024161700159311295,
0.8232712149620056,
-0.4794533848762512,
0.4577394425868988,
-0.853853702545166,
0.6631600856781006,
0.08037670701742172,
0.49054601788520813,
-0.32958802580833435,
-0.6701846122741699,
-0.22816701233386993,
0.2999444007873535,
-0.2654004395008087,
-1.096969723701477,
0.296736478805542,
-0.004930277820676565,
0.4215773344039917,
0.11836672574281693,
0.12038306891918182,
0.8412186503410339,
-1.0687212944030762,
0.35002413392066956,
-0.008078021928668022,
-0.9903450608253479,
0.6210912466049194,
-0.24593132734298706,
0.2928366959095001,
0.4474569261074066,
0.3372666835784912,
-0.4917362928390503,
-0.480149507522583,
-0.501649022102356,
-0.6778790950775146,
1.2701480388641357,
0.562651515007019,
-0.006228786893188953,
0.20595933496952057,
0.2126869112253189,
0.10544636845588684,
0.09401629865169525,
-0.5551804900169373,
-0.46185311675071716,
-0.24340377748012543,
-0.03942239284515381,
0.03275485336780548,
-0.2946688234806061,
0.23313899338245392,
-0.33198192715644836,
1.1457871198654175,
-0.01638614758849144,
0.29910141229629517,
0.190939798951149,
-0.1294737458229065,
-0.4842539131641388,
0.2693888247013092,
0.29745349287986755,
0.25939440727233887,
-0.25147080421447754,
0.26977062225341797,
0.268016517162323,
-0.3517303764820099,
0.4321855306625366,
0.045167580246925354,
-0.6580618619918823,
0.10339470207691193,
-0.21808774769306183,
1.0986677408218384,
0.27551573514938354,
-0.14301908016204834,
0.3623191714286804,
-0.05613183230161667,
-0.17421424388885498,
-0.09442911297082901,
0.14453786611557007,
-0.1243973970413208,
0.2736137807369232,
-0.0773061066865921,
0.4875635504722595,
0.10754091292619705,
-0.16746142506599426,
0.24725697934627533,
0.14550291001796722,
-0.415840208530426,
-0.2530127465724945,
0.772283673286438,
0.042902685701847076,
-0.3058765232563019,
0.4423757493495941,
-0.3032471537590027,
-0.6104990839958191,
0.309773325920105,
0.9678394198417664,
0.9446950554847717,
-0.7260579466819763,
0.2527450919151306,
0.4531806707382202,
0.5999427437782288,
-0.3993628919124603,
0.23679547011852264,
-0.029424376785755157,
-0.5973423719406128,
-0.21060273051261902,
-0.8206973075866699,
-0.0804973617196083,
-0.09636503458023071,
-0.6543472409248352,
0.4302237629890442,
-0.06473001092672348,
-0.20826935768127441,
-0.2555944323539734,
-0.48197194933891296,
-0.5412776470184326,
0.035751502960920334,
-0.16953016817569733,
0.59980309009552,
-0.9445772767066956,
0.9150856733322144,
0.8891057372093201,
-0.42451438307762146,
-0.7357451319694519,
0.2881584167480469,
0.1752389818429947,
-0.5593514442443848,
0.338374525308609,
-0.04474401846528053,
-0.44517800211906433,
0.41673460602760315,
-0.44755473732948303,
-1.2327169179916382,
0.9891061782836914,
0.614565908908844,
-0.4081384539604187,
0.054764971137046814,
0.24462001025676727,
0.20134149491786957,
-0.01970258168876171,
0.10647585988044739,
0.5236937403678894,
0.3723095953464508,
0.18833929300308228,
-0.7941720485687256,
0.006117126904428005,
-0.04066556319594383,
0.193719282746315,
0.5247536301612854,
-0.883656919002533,
0.8805708289146423,
-0.26195454597473145,
-0.38372179865837097,
0.07460770756006241,
0.7243211269378662,
0.18494759500026703,
-0.1359432488679886,
0.6552338600158691,
0.43336886167526245,
0.14140817523002625,
-0.030558716505765915,
0.9956070780754089,
-0.2809832692146301,
0.6733838319778442,
1.2685530185699463,
-0.018003789708018303,
0.8564484715461731,
0.5874805450439453,
-0.2660519778728485,
0.12381996214389801,
0.3314669728279114,
0.018736418336629868,
0.37836596369743347,
0.022710159420967102,
0.021090995520353317,
-0.45926833152770996,
-0.014371744357049465,
-0.243859201669693,
0.5409664511680603,
0.21454879641532898,
-0.14188408851623535,
-0.39356207847595215,
0.014907862059772015,
0.270591676235199,
-0.15494059026241302,
-0.12977275252342224,
0.5642404556274414,
0.1432344913482666,
-0.8276724815368652,
0.46483951807022095,
0.40178200602531433,
0.3660029172897339,
-0.8455774188041687,
-0.20819921791553497,
-0.1862267553806305,
0.003916253801435232,
-0.0678214356303215,
-0.6787041425704956,
0.25726431608200073,
0.09569863229990005,
0.012128789909183979,
-0.589580237865448,
0.4979214072227478,
-0.8960402607917786,
-0.7307010889053345,
0.2563393712043762,
0.47148486971855164,
0.4740138053894043,
0.08037912845611572,
-0.9529896378517151,
0.02364422380924225,
0.09719482809305191,
-0.34419262409210205,
0.22287216782569885,
0.4583524763584137,
-0.14147356152534485,
0.5641019344329834,
0.7944756746292114,
0.3638997972011566,
0.32258227467536926,
-0.038052987307310104,
0.5317124724388123,
-0.5498879551887512,
-0.878972053527832,
-0.8298320174217224,
0.43510860204696655,
0.328834593296051,
-0.024820946156978607,
0.5201219916343689,
0.46686166524887085,
0.785098671913147,
-0.09907488524913788,
0.6031335592269897,
-0.0609796978533268,
0.29157063364982605,
-0.7344730496406555,
0.708597719669342,
-0.8553639054298401,
0.2333661913871765,
-0.200478196144104,
-0.8700743913650513,
-0.056208882480859756,
0.5058258771896362,
-0.11662469059228897,
0.13020846247673035,
0.9350980520248413,
0.8137176036834717,
-0.42520737648010254,
-0.0327313169836998,
0.5076513290405273,
0.4735543131828308,
0.15867067873477936,
0.2983839511871338,
0.6650677919387817,
-0.4834097623825073,
0.48044610023498535,
-0.2391345202922821,
-0.2168523222208023,
-0.10667099058628082,
-0.7974398732185364,
-0.6067567467689514,
-0.7626537084579468,
-0.11281473189592361,
-0.16246768832206726,
0.1608678698539734,
1.1710954904556274,
0.6595801115036011,
-0.7555586099624634,
-0.36844173073768616,
0.014832514338195324,
-0.11136797815561295,
-0.39835381507873535,
-0.15007871389389038,
0.4554539918899536,
-0.6392478942871094,
-0.6748424768447876,
0.46553096175193787,
0.4588075578212738,
0.33894696831703186,
-0.15601779520511627,
-0.3381955921649933,
-0.36070865392684937,
0.13569194078445435,
0.3289982080459595,
0.040766842663288116,
-0.9025222659111023,
0.10966984927654266,
-0.19205045700073242,
-0.11149226874113083,
0.1606130599975586,
0.8619435429573059,
-0.4584316909313202,
0.8592807054519653,
0.2430538833141327,
0.8409899473190308,
0.712933361530304,
0.11638034135103226,
0.5298291444778442,
-0.5986491441726685,
-0.07455567270517349,
-0.10652021318674088,
0.450034499168396,
0.11547668278217316,
-0.3924156725406647,
0.4798192083835602,
0.2443050891160965,
-0.5155277252197266,
-0.522411048412323,
0.30621859431266785,
-0.7344921827316284,
-0.15778958797454834,
1.233502984046936,
-0.2481035590171814,
-0.1889302283525467,
0.20245200395584106,
-0.5432345867156982,
0.6314319372177124,
-0.41529279947280884,
0.5606563091278076,
0.40910977125167847,
-0.3812420070171356,
0.08640346676111221,
-0.8244064450263977,
0.4729045033454895,
0.6195504069328308,
-0.6897714138031006,
-0.13367268443107605,
0.27776166796684265,
0.34936749935150146,
-0.17497430741786957,
0.7429639101028442,
-0.12014947086572647,
0.00032804461079649627,
-0.14094676077365875,
-0.07132261246442795,
-0.3203347325325012,
-0.6603767275810242,
-0.46855929493904114,
-0.34776246547698975,
-0.1332119107246399,
-0.366933673620224
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.02224v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.02224v2
|
FedMKT: Federated Mutual Knowledge Transfer for Large and Small Language Models
| 2024-06-04T11:36:09 | 2024-06-18T08:17:00 |
Tao Fan, Guoqiang Ma, Yan Kang, Hanlin Gu, Yuanfeng Song, Lixin Fan, Kai Chen, Qiang Yang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Recent research in federated large language models (LLMs) has primarily
focused on enabling clients to fine-tune their locally deployed homogeneous
LLMs collaboratively or on transferring knowledge from server-based LLMs to
small language models (SLMs) at downstream clients. However, a significant gap
remains in the simultaneous mutual enhancement of both the server's LLM and
clients' SLMs. To bridge this gap, we propose FedMKT, a parameter-efficient
federated mutual knowledge transfer framework for large and small language
models. This framework is designed to adaptively transfer knowledge from the
server's LLM to clients' SLMs while concurrently enriching the LLM with
clients' unique domain insights. We facilitate token alignment using minimum
edit distance (MinED) and then selective mutual knowledge transfer between
client-side SLMs and a server-side LLM, aiming to collectively enhance their
performance. Through extensive experiments across three distinct scenarios, we
evaluate the effectiveness of FedMKT using various public LLMs and SLMs on a
range of NLP text generation tasks. Empirical results demonstrate that FedMKT
simultaneously boosts the performance of both LLMs and SLMs.
|
[
-0.37497031688690186,
-0.6092984676361084,
0.5343440771102905,
0.608582079410553,
-0.2515769600868225,
0.18539252877235413,
-0.5075180530548096,
-0.5366342067718506,
0.09443444013595581,
0.47349271178245544,
-0.5879369378089905,
-0.4844112992286682,
-0.36247244477272034,
0.05982323735952377,
-0.2875151038169861,
0.9624688029289246,
0.03415144979953766,
-0.055916693061590195,
-0.6134571433067322,
-0.20835623145103455,
-0.432538241147995,
-0.21594104170799255,
-0.5587866902351379,
-0.5737587213516235,
0.5841623544692993,
0.5548269152641296,
0.6953397393226624,
0.5876344442367554,
0.6197096705436707,
0.27358147501945496,
0.15810446441173553,
0.18388989567756653,
-0.5620913505554199,
0.29732391238212585,
-0.49252113699913025,
-0.4665079712867737,
-0.6472854018211365,
-0.14611604809761047,
0.75944983959198,
0.7061576247215271,
-0.11057766526937485,
0.3557233512401581,
-0.10384050756692886,
0.7340165376663208,
-0.4496616721153259,
0.1442127376794815,
-0.7080993056297302,
0.08589089661836624,
-0.16824528574943542,
0.056458815932273865,
-0.4371907711029053,
-0.3756124675273895,
0.4008270502090454,
-0.6429336071014404,
0.052589431405067444,
0.1459473967552185,
0.4438784420490265,
0.1669376939535141,
-0.2382180392742157,
-0.12622487545013428,
-0.4750399589538574,
0.671962559223175,
-0.5993781089782715,
0.5357535481452942,
0.0699494257569313,
0.3334678113460541,
-0.14899910986423492,
-1.012336015701294,
-0.5581606030464172,
0.011770911514759064,
-0.24531395733356476,
-0.13810665905475616,
-0.11959945410490036,
0.07705626636743546,
0.0524105429649353,
0.19370858371257782,
-0.3331066071987152,
0.2709585726261139,
0.0026775854639708996,
-0.37568801641464233,
0.583912193775177,
0.10882338881492615,
0.23298297822475433,
0.13483044505119324,
-0.5850873589515686,
-0.03365355730056763,
-0.779474675655365,
-0.15412519872188568,
0.24387843906879425,
0.541390597820282,
-0.0901724174618721,
0.46445345878601074,
-0.23346146941184998,
0.7679117321968079,
0.02989804372191429,
-0.33118319511413574,
-0.044380154460668564,
-0.46812358498573303,
-0.29108425974845886,
0.007976623252034187,
0.77846360206604,
0.3882436156272888,
-0.2664613723754883,
-0.31958818435668945,
-0.5216217637062073,
-0.3952226936817169,
-0.05743253231048584,
-0.8241333365440369,
-0.1591452807188034,
-0.1633729338645935,
-0.36423853039741516,
-0.5043818354606628,
-0.12076200544834137,
-0.8222613334655762,
-0.2844197452068329,
-0.3393356502056122,
0.5046294331550598,
-0.1472853124141693,
-0.4655323326587677,
0.058590538799762726,
-0.07925817370414734,
-0.058302026242017746,
0.530981183052063,
-0.9330543279647827,
0.37967365980148315,
1.0511455535888672,
1.1195547580718994,
-0.2708022892475128,
-0.35077786445617676,
-0.7243666052818298,
0.3318216800689697,
-0.03586561232805252,
0.6788545250892639,
-0.36306098103523254,
-0.10461853444576263,
0.21673211455345154,
-0.13406838476657867,
-0.08975095301866531,
-0.19411374628543854,
0.25616541504859924,
-0.691990077495575,
0.2822682559490204,
-0.5166718363761902,
-0.7047238945960999,
0.043355025351047516,
0.16456109285354614,
-0.4431542754173279,
0.969136655330658,
0.19581250846385956,
-1.0547704696655273,
0.33837607502937317,
-0.8473357558250427,
-0.5238003730773926,
0.09073679894208908,
-0.0011396323097869754,
-0.19746436178684235,
0.04700998589396477,
0.21258926391601562,
0.641658365726471,
-0.31045472621917725,
0.17278370261192322,
-0.4657301604747772,
-0.1656234860420227,
0.11034005135297775,
-0.11697583645582199,
0.484292209148407,
0.28607723116874695,
-0.017655588686466217,
0.10745610296726227,
-0.533505380153656,
-0.04821231961250305,
0.06053653359413147,
-0.5580146312713623,
-0.49779263138771057,
-0.2824711799621582,
-0.10232657194137573,
0.2520926296710968,
0.49264079332351685,
-0.4507705569267273,
0.37452128529548645,
-0.5245214700698853,
0.45019397139549255,
0.8961203098297119,
-0.11696168035268784,
0.8912101984024048,
-0.5999852418899536,
0.3964179754257202,
-0.0806925967335701,
-0.03967336192727089,
0.19414818286895752,
-0.2666640877723694,
-0.724402666091919,
-0.31995484232902527,
0.3848598003387451,
0.18222615122795105,
-1.300188660621643,
0.15211603045463562,
-0.6570133566856384,
-0.5445712804794312,
-0.3720249831676483,
0.20845186710357666,
0.1597014218568802,
0.5737343430519104,
0.029242632910609245,
-0.21713612973690033,
-0.4663952887058258,
-0.763359010219574,
-0.3700142800807953,
-0.18179023265838623,
-0.027982749044895172,
0.3285875618457794,
0.19103004038333893,
-0.22919656336307526,
1.1093999147415161,
-0.40826019644737244,
-0.3624535799026489,
-0.17746306955814362,
0.05472538247704506,
0.04611259326338768,
0.3884238302707672,
0.8266887664794922,
-0.4261252284049988,
-0.8084676861763,
0.32111048698425293,
-0.3327406644821167,
-0.4297153353691101,
0.014306382276117802,
-0.3509264886379242,
0.30538928508758545,
0.3555709719657898,
-0.5501737594604492,
-0.3511110544204712,
0.8537822961807251,
-0.420258492231369,
0.7647866606712341,
-0.24994556605815887,
-0.09555366635322571,
-1.1778287887573242,
0.16577374935150146,
-0.4663471281528473,
-0.7592350244522095,
-0.6231942176818848,
0.03354888781905174,
-0.15792438387870789,
0.10277021676301956,
-0.25549185276031494,
0.8622123599052429,
-0.3868475556373596,
-0.43657949566841125,
-0.323199599981308,
0.5791512131690979,
-0.23535698652267456,
0.2988564670085907,
-0.31394949555397034,
0.8864920735359192,
0.4789865016937256,
-0.37310072779655457,
0.6429798007011414,
0.19704832136631012,
-0.08453328162431717,
0.8327506184577942,
-0.19284886121749878,
0.374749094247818,
0.3696436882019043,
0.10666479170322418,
-0.560121476650238,
-0.197838693857193,
0.10935500264167786,
-0.21601296961307526,
0.1474916636943817,
-0.17760425806045532,
-0.7215327620506287,
-0.30379796028137207,
0.05064680427312851,
0.11819815635681152,
0.3092998266220093,
-0.7058467864990234,
0.5950273871421814,
0.3168259561061859,
-0.4348016381263733,
-0.6219366788864136,
-0.7560247778892517,
-0.05975775793194771,
-0.061055321246385574,
-0.9970754981040955,
0.002874709665775299,
-0.03264224901795387,
-0.1293887495994568,
0.13208064436912537,
-0.18040072917938232,
-0.06942816078662872,
0.1513858288526535,
0.21974687278270721,
-0.06813018769025803,
-0.6310682892799377,
0.48665517568588257,
0.268825501203537,
0.03993097320199013,
0.10101860761642456,
-0.7845509052276611,
0.5569350123405457,
-0.3085280656814575,
-0.27547720074653625,
-0.12185085564851761,
0.10558222234249115,
0.5728622078895569,
-0.15884459018707275,
1.0037484169006348,
0.8102267980575562,
-0.039773184806108475,
-0.4974142611026764,
-0.6992260217666626,
-0.2900177836418152,
-0.5124029517173767,
0.10957786440849304,
-0.5514099597930908,
-1.5352327823638916,
0.49995508790016174,
-0.37160348892211914,
0.2856588363647461,
0.31780654191970825,
0.5648494362831116,
0.08412223309278488,
0.5962415337562561,
0.9614152908325195,
-0.29128721356391907,
0.5433387756347656,
0.29622194170951843,
-0.030411267653107643,
-0.47814708948135376,
0.23151865601539612,
-0.37945446372032166,
-0.3658071458339691,
-0.33419257402420044,
-0.5593380928039551,
-0.037424422800540924,
0.03304465487599373,
-0.04691480100154877,
0.09780480712652206,
-0.21718117594718933,
0.5653303265571594,
0.5407044291496277,
-0.001185951055958867,
0.5964291095733643,
0.20346291363239288,
-0.73594069480896,
0.07206141203641891,
-1.0072287321090698,
-0.1969822496175766,
0.9819506406784058,
0.3709103465080261,
0.4622669816017151,
0.23907971382141113,
0.7417830228805542,
0.4505903124809265,
0.6691054701805115,
-0.43956050276756287,
0.6714460849761963,
-0.19247032701969147,
-0.3581373393535614,
-0.2843078374862671,
-0.727009117603302,
-0.3296247720718384,
0.2404351681470871,
-0.35603511333465576,
-0.5327675342559814,
-0.10170811414718628,
0.08729247748851776,
-0.23583118617534637,
0.501888632774353,
-0.642175018787384,
0.6111454963684082,
0.08468931168317795,
-0.46719497442245483,
-0.26326635479927063,
-0.6494106650352478,
0.49793943762779236,
-0.3983703553676605,
0.1498086303472519,
-0.17550058662891388,
-0.07612935453653336,
0.7590984106063843,
-0.49921220541000366,
0.577498197555542,
-0.4071778357028961,
-0.20930112898349762,
0.005260452162474394,
0.28401830792427063,
0.7577323317527771,
0.23583410680294037,
-0.05113958939909935,
0.09244918078184128,
-0.05160483717918396,
-0.242171511054039,
-0.648274302482605,
0.879496157169342,
-0.7189257144927979,
-0.5386731624603271,
-0.0722053274512291,
-0.8751587271690369,
-0.2741139233112335,
0.5917018055915833,
-0.2705759108066559,
0.0013858150923624635,
-0.19056786596775055,
0.2467283308506012,
0.3197198808193207,
-0.08710701018571854,
0.4366458058357239,
0.7503588199615479,
-0.5235248804092407,
-0.6141051650047302,
0.7715750932693481,
-0.1774483323097229,
0.5840862393379211,
0.4670041799545288,
0.17377609014511108,
-0.28590697050094604,
-0.5137178897857666,
-0.225633904337883,
0.42599695920944214,
-0.7976968288421631,
-0.4964021146297455,
-0.7509806156158447,
-0.133804053068161,
-0.2972298860549927,
-0.5065663456916809,
-0.674828052520752,
-0.5090195536613464,
-0.21178394556045532,
-0.11537466198205948,
0.6136925220489502,
0.5134715437889099,
-0.4984697103500366,
0.646854043006897,
-0.9672092795372009,
-0.0985974445939064,
0.4195014536380768,
0.6590008735656738,
-0.0016846198122948408,
-0.20717395842075348,
-0.3883472681045532,
0.1766137331724167,
0.1762566715478897,
-0.42116084694862366,
0.19419138133525848,
0.22774432599544525,
0.32716238498687744,
0.3658563494682312,
0.28271371126174927,
0.6437814831733704,
-0.3656924068927765,
0.6321524977684021,
0.3986847400665283,
-0.9716413617134094,
0.19911810755729675,
-0.44019731879234314,
0.2687387466430664,
0.5528691411018372,
-0.028460510075092316,
-0.834689199924469,
-0.5486674904823303,
-0.46287450194358826,
-0.36837348341941833,
0.9659143686294556,
0.2608344256877899,
-0.14503495395183563,
0.46205759048461914,
0.32041820883750916,
0.30233311653137207,
0.24528495967388153,
-0.6669842600822449,
0.03398618474602699,
0.16495922207832336,
-0.30606043338775635,
0.015555926598608494,
-0.18354856967926025,
-0.3341752886772156,
-0.10192883759737015,
0.7516034841537476,
-0.3785811960697174,
0.47335195541381836,
0.1807970553636551,
-0.3576661944389343,
-0.47265180945396423,
0.17881827056407928,
0.8938117623329163,
0.7132750153541565,
-0.08927077054977417,
0.37568628787994385,
0.2712564766407013,
-0.4547620117664337,
0.03390735387802124,
0.3500031530857086,
-0.12193381786346436,
-0.025706006214022636,
0.22283780574798584,
0.6860636472702026,
0.34920984506607056,
-0.30618539452552795,
0.518447995185852,
-0.32869720458984375,
-0.3270995318889618,
0.19314759969711304,
-0.04151012375950813,
0.3479149639606476,
0.6603490710258484,
0.12904173135757446,
0.15531520545482635,
-0.5242456793785095,
0.029545778408646584,
0.4752354621887207,
0.37963321805000305,
-0.21598969399929047,
-0.4178706109523773,
0.46347132325172424,
0.48851752281188965,
-0.1441548764705658,
0.36202898621559143,
-0.046839043498039246,
-0.5836777687072754,
0.08285487443208694,
0.5927844047546387,
0.7519930005073547,
-0.10036349296569824,
0.28743502497673035,
0.030139755457639694,
0.3204858601093292,
-0.14840152859687805,
-0.004345851019024849,
-0.21157212555408478,
-0.8015910983085632,
-0.5095411539077759,
-0.9270901679992676,
-0.24617445468902588,
-0.16327990591526031,
-0.35621657967567444,
0.1684880405664444,
-0.550071656703949,
-0.06262297183275223,
-0.25171542167663574,
0.42323750257492065,
-0.6081600785255432,
-0.3969346582889557,
-0.06656445562839508,
0.9763689041137695,
-0.8973278403282166,
1.0386700630187988,
0.7245321869850159,
-0.1741308569908142,
-0.8819209933280945,
-0.2095966935157776,
-0.12062670290470123,
-0.8377289175987244,
0.6337594985961914,
-0.22520877420902252,
0.06882242858409882,
0.273635596036911,
-0.4553588926792145,
-0.8331184387207031,
1.4324270486831665,
0.46047312021255493,
-0.5590847730636597,
-0.07610553503036499,
0.6633530855178833,
0.5334760546684265,
-0.5201200842857361,
-0.1562759131193161,
0.4490412473678589,
0.4417688250541687,
0.16409678757190704,
-1.1932246685028076,
0.2838033139705658,
0.3467997908592224,
0.03410179913043976,
0.2335043102502823,
-0.716552197933197,
0.594936192035675,
0.03357546031475067,
-0.2204982191324234,
-0.014231736771762371,
0.9237732887268066,
0.08558296412229538,
0.25416699051856995,
0.6107960939407349,
0.6297826766967773,
0.7673662304878235,
0.014787553809583187,
0.5555253028869629,
-0.24453607201576233,
0.5315130949020386,
1.253304123878479,
-0.2525767385959625,
0.6909766793251038,
0.6154873967170715,
-0.08297080546617508,
0.08690756559371948,
0.19330604374408722,
0.15597940981388092,
0.49506810307502747,
-0.12473136186599731,
-0.3410989046096802,
-0.138234943151474,
-0.011419721879065037,
-0.40999823808670044,
0.32966122031211853,
0.1819869875907898,
-0.3707805573940277,
-0.40280553698539734,
0.17325276136398315,
0.18566583096981049,
-0.14466002583503723,
-0.17248749732971191,
0.9303585886955261,
0.333565890789032,
-0.4104711711406708,
0.24918608367443085,
0.18355460464954376,
0.6267490386962891,
-0.5105344653129578,
0.24516020715236664,
-0.5065851807594299,
0.23656874895095825,
-0.027671504765748978,
-0.6297653913497925,
0.3595269024372101,
-0.014904418960213661,
-0.224898099899292,
-0.5855751633644104,
1.2477467060089111,
-0.7487822771072388,
-0.2223873734474182,
0.1636827290058136,
0.7025670409202576,
-0.1296207159757614,
0.0008820131770335138,
-0.7041690945625305,
-0.026003384962677956,
-0.007628414314240217,
0.04729441925883293,
0.5009689331054688,
0.7287970781326294,
0.4234526753425598,
0.6982236504554749,
0.9137462973594666,
0.3851702809333801,
0.24776537716388702,
-0.07265880703926086,
0.9129270315170288,
-0.2091173678636551,
-0.659382700920105,
-0.6780778765678406,
0.21259760856628418,
-0.16605399549007416,
0.15747803449630737,
0.807173490524292,
0.30330315232276917,
0.8620859384536743,
-0.19097183644771576,
0.5009622573852539,
-0.1511872559785843,
0.47637471556663513,
-0.46711477637290955,
1.3157079219818115,
-0.5058726668357849,
0.25852522253990173,
-0.26738885045051575,
-0.9185254573822021,
-0.2916877567768097,
0.24631717801094055,
-0.27658143639564514,
-0.4032846689224243,
0.5097293257713318,
0.6767935752868652,
-0.15787194669246674,
0.18335308134555817,
0.3735467195510864,
0.33387577533721924,
0.5146381258964539,
0.39537984132766724,
0.6806247234344482,
-0.06524112820625305,
0.4845185875892639,
-0.4299151599407196,
0.050585608929395676,
-0.3994232416152954,
-1.0007352828979492,
-0.9022952914237976,
-0.45206716656684875,
-0.24555407464504242,
0.06126120314002037,
0.1591145247220993,
1.0227121114730835,
0.6425389051437378,
-0.3913700580596924,
-0.13251551985740662,
-0.12191221117973328,
0.3776386082172394,
-0.13880681991577148,
-0.29421061277389526,
0.22628286480903625,
-0.39804673194885254,
-0.39431068301200867,
0.18828965723514557,
0.2818944454193115,
-0.05999407544732094,
-0.2969249188899994,
-0.11635033041238785,
-0.22501987218856812,
-0.15891283750534058,
0.6412469148635864,
0.07351148873567581,
-0.5246550440788269,
-0.5283122658729553,
-0.09271466732025146,
-0.3313238322734833,
-0.16342395544052124,
0.9450240731239319,
-0.5340898036956787,
0.38601720333099365,
0.6207455396652222,
1.0471546649932861,
0.08268606662750244,
-0.18144270777702332,
0.8080945014953613,
-1.3693478107452393,
0.2530144453048706,
0.1878584325313568,
0.11390174925327301,
0.2990501821041107,
-0.24072107672691345,
0.347074031829834,
0.48410218954086304,
-0.7736225724220276,
-0.9241408109664917,
-0.017624858766794205,
-0.8546549081802368,
-0.07467401027679443,
1.1058787107467651,
-0.22597496211528778,
-0.07579243928194046,
0.2531270980834961,
0.11455965787172318,
0.29307395219802856,
-0.45561227202415466,
0.3844967782497406,
0.6571004390716553,
0.2261703461408615,
-0.2878786325454712,
-0.4700225591659546,
0.7692325711250305,
0.28364136815071106,
-0.7638534903526306,
0.24568426609039307,
0.45406296849250793,
0.4408281445503235,
-0.05647642910480499,
0.5879554152488708,
0.17880739271640778,
0.07032105326652527,
-0.0679745301604271,
0.020753614604473114,
-0.2858213186264038,
-0.14930184185504913,
-0.1262350082397461,
0.08337883651256561,
0.06569284200668335,
0.16029056906700134
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.02208v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.02208v1
|
Why Only Text: Empowering Vision-and-Language Navigation with Multi-modal Prompts
| 2024-06-04T11:06:13 | 2024-06-04T11:06:13 |
Haodong Hong, Sen Wang, Zi Huang, Qi Wu, Jiajun Liu
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Current Vision-and-Language Navigation (VLN) tasks mainly employ textual
instructions to guide agents. However, being inherently abstract, the same
textual instruction can be associated with different visual signals, causing
severe ambiguity and limiting the transfer of prior knowledge in the vision
domain from the user to the agent. To fill this gap, we propose
Vision-and-Language Navigation with Multi-modal Prompts (VLN-MP), a novel task
augmenting traditional VLN by integrating both natural language and images in
instructions. VLN-MP not only maintains backward compatibility by effectively
handling text-only prompts but also consistently shows advantages with
different quantities and relevance of visual prompts. Possible forms of visual
prompts include both exact and similar object images, providing adaptability
and versatility in diverse navigation scenarios. To evaluate VLN-MP under a
unified framework, we implement a new benchmark that offers: (1) a
training-free pipeline to transform textual instructions into multi-modal forms
with landmark images; (2) diverse datasets with multi-modal instructions for
different downstream tasks; (3) a novel module designed to process various
image prompts for seamless integration with state-of-the-art VLN models.
Extensive experiments on four VLN benchmarks (R2R, RxR, REVERIE, CVDN) show
that incorporating visual prompts significantly boosts navigation performance.
While maintaining efficiency with text-only prompts, VLN-MP enables agents to
navigate in the pre-explore setting and outperform text-based models, showing
its broader applicability.
|
[
-0.3146470785140991,
-0.5493552088737488,
1.0477265119552612,
0.23820242285728455,
-0.40710335969924927,
-0.17287509143352509,
-0.29278135299682617,
-0.5466640591621399,
0.0032193202059715986,
0.48443278670310974,
-0.7700377106666565,
-0.511042058467865,
-0.37076860666275024,
0.23224598169326782,
0.11447850614786148,
0.7033459544181824,
0.15899942815303802,
0.17623232305049896,
-0.3422744572162628,
-0.16849815845489502,
-0.7785912752151489,
-0.3440546989440918,
-0.40644875168800354,
0.057577040046453476,
0.9608965516090393,
0.30233579874038696,
0.7892137169837952,
0.5806911587715149,
0.4449231028556824,
0.25072577595710754,
0.17626570165157318,
0.5713345408439636,
0.02228856086730957,
0.3085387349128723,
-0.2757296562194824,
-0.33594074845314026,
-0.029229959473013878,
-0.33722084760665894,
0.43393605947494507,
0.31726324558258057,
0.4166782796382904,
-0.2692965865135193,
-0.07007427513599396,
0.5761188268661499,
-0.8885097503662109,
0.5734161734580994,
-0.10158234089612961,
-0.02973984181880951,
-0.044725801795721054,
-0.6138609647750854,
-0.5917101502418518,
-0.08407142013311386,
0.47153440117836,
-0.87322598695755,
-0.3907777965068817,
0.143208846449852,
0.6876104474067688,
0.44667237997055054,
-0.7620947360992432,
-0.2731623947620392,
-0.36222612857818604,
0.8183046579360962,
0.019712507724761963,
0.614625096321106,
0.07913818955421448,
0.5474646687507629,
0.1781539022922516,
-0.5431201457977295,
-0.4092942774295807,
-0.38873934745788574,
-0.18657813966274261,
0.4525388777256012,
-0.07579656690359116,
0.22128894925117493,
0.10253308713436127,
-0.18422599136829376,
-0.6102887988090515,
-0.010341477580368519,
-0.216206893324852,
-0.23068289458751678,
0.12812750041484833,
0.11342056840658188,
0.6475544571876526,
-0.2729000747203827,
-0.9332110285758972,
-0.4132690131664276,
-0.5695789456367493,
0.4740108251571655,
-0.172517329454422,
0.5150399804115295,
-0.23335681855678558,
0.5983195900917053,
-0.1626465767621994,
1.07598078250885,
-0.4222298860549927,
-0.2504658102989197,
0.2630475163459778,
-0.61909019947052,
-0.18093976378440857,
-0.011836576275527477,
0.8123286962509155,
0.7873031497001648,
0.17999248206615448,
-0.0574566088616848,
-0.20396240055561066,
-0.03290366753935814,
0.14776556193828583,
-0.4578167498111725,
-0.06003645062446594,
-0.19522881507873535,
-0.3824782967567444,
-0.004469800274819136,
-0.07874816656112671,
-0.9184214472770691,
-0.7343942523002625,
-0.40548470616340637,
0.5669218301773071,
-0.4528053104877472,
-0.14674362540245056,
0.16932065784931183,
-0.44250917434692383,
0.37798643112182617,
0.9931736588478088,
-0.4786262512207031,
-0.32366105914115906,
0.4612811505794525,
0.7765746116638184,
-0.21306173503398895,
-0.4358787536621094,
-0.6490882635116577,
0.044724225997924805,
-0.06294532865285873,
0.8194023966789246,
-0.8954097032546997,
-0.5100935697555542,
-0.023449605330824852,
0.11921830475330353,
-0.25848188996315,
0.03944030776619911,
0.5404738187789917,
-0.24033847451210022,
0.4662209749221802,
-0.6900721192359924,
0.1959208995103836,
-0.7087815403938293,
0.4234687387943268,
-0.7025794386863708,
0.8626046776771545,
-0.15484461188316345,
-0.3226649761199951,
0.4082241952419281,
-0.5895015001296997,
-0.44824713468551636,
0.21785876154899597,
-0.5280275940895081,
0.19269169867038727,
-0.04841148108243942,
0.5145885944366455,
0.11779589205980301,
-0.5966112613677979,
-0.11132152378559113,
0.2785247564315796,
-0.3557690382003784,
-0.006982308812439442,
-0.8194589018821716,
0.5427495241165161,
-0.0952611118555069,
-0.5964776277542114,
0.21410897374153137,
-0.42764046788215637,
-0.006799841299653053,
-0.13205495476722717,
-0.4365793466567993,
-0.37609216570854187,
-0.05252540111541748,
0.21050238609313965,
0.20121155679225922,
0.49176692962646484,
-0.305801123380661,
0.41030263900756836,
-0.24416111409664154,
-0.18665947020053864,
0.6114394664764404,
-0.09449873119592667,
0.6042202115058899,
-0.34557846188545227,
0.5353569984436035,
0.063046395778656,
0.36413857340812683,
-0.992771327495575,
-1.0432305335998535,
-0.6919105052947998,
-0.5480849742889404,
-0.12044907361268997,
0.8348699808120728,
-1.3174419403076172,
-0.046934377402067184,
-0.3963787853717804,
-0.2999064326286316,
-0.4060513377189636,
-0.24438486993312836,
0.6120796799659729,
0.5933184027671814,
0.5773500204086304,
-0.08651954680681229,
-0.2608596384525299,
-0.6271263957023621,
-0.14635930955410004,
-0.37979695200920105,
0.08962919563055038,
0.6807820200920105,
0.2063818722963333,
-0.30497032403945923,
0.6537050604820251,
-0.09985430538654327,
-0.16132336854934692,
-0.3212875425815582,
0.07635000348091125,
0.0942348837852478,
0.2413545697927475,
0.46530818939208984,
-1.241169810295105,
-0.46541982889175415,
0.40381357073783875,
-0.9608865976333618,
-0.18680286407470703,
-0.6294664740562439,
0.008389873430132866,
0.1394469141960144,
0.30734503269195557,
-0.45287564396858215,
0.531540036201477,
0.3074934482574463,
-0.47993719577789307,
0.46104666590690613,
-0.4201810657978058,
0.7624759078025818,
-0.7578798532485962,
-0.07714373618364334,
0.1814839094877243,
-0.3074619770050049,
-0.4911399483680725,
0.34307992458343506,
0.27612942457199097,
-0.20871129631996155,
-0.5920780301094055,
0.7645875811576843,
-0.5792609453201294,
0.11647473275661469,
-0.1443004012107849,
0.28951317071914673,
0.3181016147136688,
0.6719828844070435,
0.12083212286233902,
0.8107328414916992,
0.9768901467323303,
-0.5722564458847046,
0.5104464888572693,
0.15927006304264069,
0.030698956921696663,
0.8892385959625244,
-0.34249165654182434,
-0.16594870388507843,
-0.5991591215133667,
0.09684551507234573,
-1.1480762958526611,
0.11395974457263947,
0.5392781496047974,
-0.22657813131809235,
0.16442929208278656,
-0.1196971982717514,
-0.2687965929508209,
-0.015198073349893093,
-0.40253517031669617,
0.3811495900154114,
0.4306037724018097,
-0.6850268244743347,
1.163205862045288,
-0.2692762613296509,
-0.11290933191776276,
-0.5840062499046326,
-0.719021201133728,
0.44354313611984253,
0.1637604683637619,
-0.6474978923797607,
0.18351908028125763,
-0.20747633278369904,
0.04502470791339874,
-0.15941423177719116,
-0.035532146692276,
-0.01386172417551279,
-0.2018187940120697,
0.4248278737068176,
0.6014455556869507,
-0.21593621373176575,
0.1464596390724182,
0.0289353895932436,
-0.2943055331707001,
-0.23891621828079224,
-0.43928003311157227,
0.23482519388198853,
-0.22721333801746368,
-0.533931314945221,
-0.6047698855400085,
0.45011478662490845,
0.9301108717918396,
-0.5390918850898743,
0.4433877170085907,
0.49039754271507263,
0.11529786139726639,
0.2254939079284668,
-0.4650205671787262,
-0.11168773472309113,
-0.454062819480896,
0.24689437448978424,
-0.51320880651474,
-0.6317775845527649,
0.027338379994034767,
-0.30716800689697266,
0.20239458978176117,
0.09033545106649399,
0.3792356848716736,
-0.09481325000524521,
0.8757665157318115,
0.6741194128990173,
0.4292446970939636,
0.5598556399345398,
0.17860761284828186,
0.1434141844511032,
-0.5133346915245056,
-0.7863571047782898,
-0.3627006411552429,
-0.2192678153514862,
-0.29610735177993774,
-0.831623911857605,
0.6995688676834106,
-0.15574459731578827,
0.188069149851799,
0.1788507103919983,
-0.589806079864502,
0.5840334892272949,
0.6206756830215454,
0.28999266028404236,
0.39248958230018616,
-0.06480107456445694,
-0.3307926058769226,
-0.2131480574607849,
-0.6418125033378601,
-0.28444674611091614,
0.7837451696395874,
-0.09710428863763809,
0.7111198902130127,
0.08901015669107437,
0.43151724338531494,
0.3237933814525604,
-0.14202554523944855,
-0.9394969940185547,
0.7809925675392151,
0.014050486497581005,
-0.36061912775039673,
-0.14022311568260193,
-0.27581652998924255,
-0.7071179747581482,
0.5888097286224365,
-0.423419326543808,
-0.669415295124054,
0.3410416841506958,
-0.12553532421588898,
-0.3289891183376312,
0.17948557436466217,
-0.7207322120666504,
0.838151216506958,
-0.515559732913971,
-0.319321870803833,
0.04144399240612984,
-0.7842315435409546,
-0.059966154396533966,
0.060473039746284485,
0.2820601463317871,
0.1336398869752884,
-0.5529494285583496,
0.13938897848129272,
-0.11531860381364822,
0.7181779742240906,
-0.18510283529758453,
0.12527044117450714,
0.07950620353221893,
-0.012830806896090508,
0.3935234844684601,
-0.11744813621044159,
0.21949069201946259,
-0.047566287219524384,
-0.24904637038707733,
-0.1215972825884819,
-0.6778863072395325,
0.5292065739631653,
-0.3541278541088104,
-0.4907812476158142,
-0.43035992980003357,
-0.3908977210521698,
0.02308737114071846,
0.3739265203475952,
0.1445039063692093,
0.8398337960243225,
0.12235842645168304,
0.2105950564146042,
0.7217392325401306,
-0.6683895587921143,
0.7438482046127319,
0.505482017993927,
-0.1522563248872757,
-0.24090492725372314,
1.0195749998092651,
-0.2539573609828949,
0.16761517524719238,
0.8714109659194946,
0.2024596482515335,
-0.5823987126350403,
-0.2329464703798294,
-1.0529439449310303,
-0.09539476037025452,
-0.8727133870124817,
-0.04248710721731186,
-0.6605821251869202,
0.16748453676700592,
0.02925884909927845,
-0.5282752513885498,
-0.23748835921287537,
-0.1363030970096588,
-0.15889406204223633,
0.2420373111963272,
0.2473299354314804,
0.4794941842556,
-0.04121057689189911,
0.11155099421739578,
-0.918182373046875,
0.562968373298645,
0.5903511643409729,
-0.14019633829593658,
-0.15341658890247345,
-0.11585897952318192,
0.05463499203324318,
-0.027162082493305206,
0.09411328285932541,
-1.1230863332748413,
-0.08505755662918091,
0.14697091281414032,
0.6224808096885681,
0.17561064660549164,
0.050150372087955475,
0.45606178045272827,
-0.5121418237686157,
1.043383240699768,
0.6001704931259155,
-0.6570455431938171,
0.6424636244773865,
-0.37925663590431213,
0.74104243516922,
0.6132914423942566,
0.29670262336730957,
-0.5849504470825195,
-0.20828737318515778,
0.05629292502999306,
-0.8148012161254883,
0.5733975768089294,
0.03381775692105293,
-0.05757240951061249,
0.15197421610355377,
0.012508802115917206,
-0.022546416148543358,
0.2107638418674469,
-0.8329737782478333,
-0.367779403924942,
-0.3089888095855713,
-0.2011435478925705,
0.1446494311094284,
-0.07954150438308716,
-0.12077947705984116,
-0.02533300220966339,
0.22987425327301025,
-0.3170722723007202,
0.158706933259964,
0.49678778648376465,
-0.36904478073120117,
0.36203789710998535,
0.3438105881214142,
0.5367375016212463,
0.5536800026893616,
0.28573817014694214,
0.14491716027259827,
0.016282349824905396,
-0.3725467026233673,
0.20167846977710724,
0.0610571913421154,
-0.2660292387008667,
0.20175118744373322,
0.28561025857925415,
0.9257670044898987,
0.4030463993549347,
-0.8538591265678406,
0.817269504070282,
-0.24020810425281525,
0.19457784295082092,
0.20017603039741516,
0.05100452899932861,
-0.3333849608898163,
0.4794114828109741,
0.5957571268081665,
0.6246433258056641,
0.22782626748085022,
-0.546951949596405,
0.008683640509843826,
0.2961054742336273,
-0.688843846321106,
-0.09464095532894135,
0.6774938106536865,
0.4723989963531494,
-0.21907271444797516,
0.16512377560138702,
-0.24538792669773102,
-0.4206734895706177,
0.22782889008522034,
0.07427114993333817,
0.7007635235786438,
-0.025591406971216202,
0.43383899331092834,
0.18717165291309357,
0.6095556616783142,
-0.07473651319742203,
0.5027767419815063,
-0.43940240144729614,
-0.19472302496433258,
-0.4708961546421051,
-0.31040337681770325,
-0.530987560749054,
-0.5646954774856567,
-0.47731852531433105,
0.18467263877391815,
-0.371615469455719,
-0.09243360906839371,
-0.3783206343650818,
-0.4809610843658447,
-0.7520098090171814,
0.4188178777694702,
0.3842528164386749,
0.7975091338157654,
-0.49482840299606323,
0.45781123638153076,
1.0630204677581787,
-0.38002830743789673,
-0.4210781455039978,
-0.05456220358610153,
0.3527011275291443,
-0.8852841854095459,
0.4447082281112671,
0.5045386552810669,
-0.47163495421409607,
-0.19357708096504211,
-0.19384250044822693,
-0.41005581617355347,
0.997525691986084,
0.2956242859363556,
-0.5026600360870361,
-0.25907713174819946,
0.07722228020429611,
0.04743274301290512,
-0.13971224427223206,
0.38912105560302734,
0.22277218103408813,
0.8661829829216003,
0.3367576599121094,
-0.9048598408699036,
0.1253824681043625,
-0.3583373725414276,
-0.07638924568891525,
0.145973339676857,
-0.5003721714019775,
0.7483546733856201,
-0.27854758501052856,
-0.3032139539718628,
0.14418265223503113,
0.3968147337436676,
0.23412127792835236,
0.26305508613586426,
0.5393059253692627,
0.20802661776542664,
0.7720462679862976,
-0.42340296506881714,
1.2221375703811646,
-0.22753101587295532,
-0.23040875792503357,
0.8174223303794861,
0.11655814200639725,
0.5478824377059937,
0.6319823861122131,
0.40182065963745117,
0.5046601891517639,
0.2057485282421112,
0.10630213469266891,
0.8092194199562073,
-0.3538074791431427,
-0.5109691023826599,
-0.5121490359306335,
-0.46800917387008667,
-0.515333354473114,
0.49455133080482483,
0.0036747222766280174,
-0.2750914692878723,
-0.430775910615921,
0.40184730291366577,
-0.09648878127336502,
0.05219335854053497,
-0.4363405108451843,
0.647088348865509,
-0.1000807136297226,
-0.5965387225151062,
0.23855628073215485,
-0.13619112968444824,
0.896228015422821,
-0.9262270927429199,
-0.14435173571109772,
0.10049406439065933,
-0.23948626220226288,
-0.009436785243451595,
-0.8309429287910461,
-0.37078359723091125,
-0.05092763528227806,
-0.13442569971084595,
-0.6664944887161255,
0.7022976875305176,
-0.39207586646080017,
-0.3225763440132141,
0.19477450847625732,
0.7497876882553101,
0.04081837087869644,
-0.35883086919784546,
-0.6040195226669312,
0.21500501036643982,
0.25712016224861145,
-0.179010272026062,
0.04158436879515648,
0.6959732174873352,
0.1321304887533188,
0.6767602562904358,
0.5569117069244385,
-0.12211634963750839,
0.1080075353384018,
0.16599372029304504,
0.8988536596298218,
-0.7872161269187927,
-0.6079056262969971,
-0.8168293237686157,
1.0114492177963257,
-0.008811699226498604,
-0.5466156601905823,
0.8931585550308228,
0.5072322487831116,
0.34563490748405457,
-0.10348807275295258,
0.7260697484016418,
0.09409517794847488,
-0.33333349227905273,
-0.7573803663253784,
0.5010761618614197,
-0.9896712303161621,
-0.029972802847623825,
-0.14617633819580078,
-0.7891483902931213,
-0.258254736661911,
0.5205948948860168,
-0.023029344156384468,
-0.12558862566947937,
0.8877288699150085,
0.7816368341445923,
0.07589909434318542,
0.040069207549095154,
0.478866308927536,
-0.4172190725803375,
0.3434391915798187,
0.7750983834266663,
0.8325337171554565,
-0.32903361320495605,
0.7145631313323975,
0.11750779300928116,
-0.44505372643470764,
-0.26067909598350525,
-0.88929283618927,
-0.8979011178016663,
-0.6612797379493713,
-0.2127605527639389,
-0.04311336949467659,
0.20357270538806915,
0.7723909616470337,
0.6900244355201721,
-0.21795471012592316,
0.060057271271944046,
0.13362082839012146,
0.1307658702135086,
-0.15304744243621826,
-0.15246587991714478,
-0.03270021453499794,
-0.3753610849380493,
-0.642022967338562,
0.9780817627906799,
0.933753490447998,
0.22466784715652466,
-0.31857073307037354,
-0.12921366095542908,
0.04281843453645706,
-0.06105870008468628,
0.6286259293556213,
0.24085627496242523,
-0.6973773837089539,
-0.16609694063663483,
0.32246649265289307,
-0.31298530101776123,
0.023071764037013054,
0.7923730611801147,
-0.9752078056335449,
1.0505659580230713,
0.4774298071861267,
0.790625274181366,
0.3075781762599945,
-0.2745427191257477,
0.7314090728759766,
-0.6674206852912903,
0.4522720277309418,
0.1383037120103836,
0.3484409749507904,
0.42590564489364624,
-0.22455048561096191,
0.20616959035396576,
0.20353123545646667,
-0.10577311366796494,
-0.4491679072380066,
0.35940757393836975,
-1.353259801864624,
-0.36785560846328735,
1.1042003631591797,
-0.019385578110814095,
-0.39020615816116333,
-0.13535183668136597,
-0.8228495717048645,
-0.0809229165315628,
-0.5593544840812683,
0.1468573957681656,
0.47069936990737915,
0.06170012801885605,
-0.4426545798778534,
-0.5307157635688782,
0.38585779070854187,
0.36370372772216797,
-0.7622478604316711,
-0.2648182809352875,
0.7906915545463562,
-0.4573728144168854,
0.22561684250831604,
0.595773458480835,
0.08673634380102158,
0.7024374008178711,
-0.004126718267798424,
-0.1495429277420044,
-0.4305313229560852,
-0.9735915660858154,
-0.22894562780857086,
0.24681563675403595,
-0.32735008001327515,
-0.3360217809677124
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.02169v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.02169v2
|
A multilingual dataset for offensive language and hate speech detection for hausa, yoruba and igbo languages
| 2024-06-04T09:58:29 | 2024-06-05T20:07:50 |
Saminu Mohammad Aliyu, Gregory Maksha Wajiga, Muhammad Murtala
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, 14F05, F.2.2; I.2.7
|
The proliferation of online offensive language necessitates the development
of effective detection mechanisms, especially in multilingual contexts. This
study addresses the challenge by developing and introducing novel datasets for
offensive language detection in three major Nigerian languages: Hausa, Yoruba,
and Igbo. We collected data from Twitter and manually annotated it to create
datasets for each of the three languages, using native speakers. We used
pre-trained language models to evaluate their efficacy in detecting offensive
language in our datasets. The best-performing model achieved an accuracy of
90\%. To further support research in offensive language detection, we plan to
make the dataset and our models publicly available.
|
[
-0.4057166576385498,
-0.888225257396698,
-0.18456339836120605,
0.421825647354126,
0.02611089125275612,
0.17781990766525269,
-0.4005866050720215,
-0.8093119263648987,
0.2667681872844696,
0.6544135808944702,
-0.3007935583591461,
-0.443656325340271,
-0.7849023342132568,
0.36300039291381836,
-0.6084092855453491,
0.9903885722160339,
0.12891915440559387,
-0.11712951958179474,
0.7098783850669861,
-0.6634197235107422,
-0.2876637279987335,
-0.4613845944404602,
-0.7338608503341675,
0.14815671741962433,
0.6237450242042542,
0.17333337664604187,
0.6681872606277466,
0.22363236546516418,
0.2532178461551666,
0.33508265018463135,
0.11635366082191467,
0.19861257076263428,
-0.43303442001342773,
0.2688535153865814,
-0.2073821723461151,
-0.23960720002651215,
-0.19045932590961456,
-0.16717180609703064,
0.33482399582862854,
0.04065564274787903,
-0.34480565786361694,
-0.08464858680963516,
-0.32340991497039795,
0.1515151709318161,
-0.7212003469467163,
-0.21990841627120972,
-0.7588678598403931,
-0.07659506052732468,
-0.7801591753959656,
0.2586788535118103,
-0.15186947584152222,
-0.616950273513794,
-0.29272758960723877,
-0.699109673500061,
0.03334006294608116,
-0.2730972468852997,
0.4301903545856476,
-0.19850122928619385,
-0.37622469663619995,
-0.6565036773681641,
-0.3916536569595337,
0.6352611184120178,
-0.8871587514877319,
0.3535434603691101,
0.5983110070228577,
0.48027941584587097,
0.07936946302652359,
-0.20001767575740814,
-0.7419078350067139,
-0.11534640192985535,
-0.09598193317651749,
-0.055210765451192856,
-0.542772114276886,
-0.32289499044418335,
-0.029008887708187103,
0.20442955195903778,
-0.3733377158641815,
0.605013906955719,
-0.3967529833316803,
-0.34260985255241394,
0.7378790378570557,
-0.11875970661640167,
0.43858498334884644,
-0.0988720953464508,
-0.046092890202999115,
0.2815990149974823,
-0.39997467398643494,
-0.5138483047485352,
1.036486268043518,
0.9591342806816101,
-0.26483333110809326,
0.08419854938983917,
-0.28314313292503357,
0.7649621367454529,
-0.5420929789543152,
-0.36236372590065,
0.5495590567588806,
-0.06389573216438293,
0.21731270849704742,
0.05459221825003624,
1.131737232208252,
0.29202884435653687,
0.8275107145309448,
-0.13671913743019104,
-0.26311352849006653,
0.3746756315231323,
0.38357120752334595,
-0.5088469982147217,
-0.01009430456906557,
0.0017825323157012463,
-0.05459624528884888,
-0.6723238825798035,
-0.7195045351982117,
-1.0199847221374512,
-0.8108314275741577,
0.04574451595544815,
0.3193659484386444,
-0.3644068241119385,
-0.6643037796020508,
-0.1910659521818161,
-0.08114037662744522,
-0.26890164613723755,
0.1531016230583191,
-0.8614453673362732,
0.308356374502182,
0.3514304757118225,
0.5609301328659058,
-0.2632555067539215,
-0.3792934715747833,
-0.3552948534488678,
-0.011883036233484745,
-0.20488227903842926,
0.45304638147354126,
-0.5222753882408142,
0.06254152208566666,
0.304049551486969,
-0.1934128701686859,
0.29437845945358276,
-0.7659552097320557,
0.8740079998970032,
-0.6408655047416687,
0.11752483993768692,
0.05987526476383209,
-0.08701414614915848,
-0.19835901260375977,
0.2633097469806671,
-0.6436840295791626,
0.9947395920753479,
0.30013197660446167,
-0.6926026940345764,
0.22984318435192108,
-0.7433502078056335,
-0.8671172857284546,
0.2584943175315857,
-0.1400584578514099,
-0.6203894019126892,
-0.12276136875152588,
0.3371085226535797,
0.3979080319404602,
-0.20827066898345947,
0.3442317843437195,
-0.41849485039711,
-0.12948483228683472,
0.06658586114645004,
-0.3950504958629608,
1.2490218877792358,
0.5695554614067078,
-0.5386875867843628,
-0.04454782232642174,
-0.691936194896698,
-0.39972054958343506,
0.48667341470718384,
-0.3455975651741028,
-0.3961133062839508,
0.05141794681549072,
0.36963164806365967,
0.05667489394545555,
-0.1198151558637619,
-0.8917004466056824,
-0.34627240896224976,
0.018513794988393784,
0.2743186354637146,
0.6498323082923889,
-0.34729427099227905,
-0.26749786734580994,
0.08466068655252457,
0.5428907871246338,
0.24183601140975952,
0.07120615988969803,
0.07531934976577759,
-0.637341320514679,
-0.31073352694511414,
-0.1286269873380661,
-0.14698892831802368,
0.736188530921936,
-0.6849398612976074,
0.02504805661737919,
-0.15198548138141632,
-0.25509053468704224,
-0.5173918604850769,
0.1802975982427597,
0.46460315585136414,
0.5063789486885071,
0.43616458773612976,
0.24360506236553192,
-0.789800226688385,
-0.9714176058769226,
-0.5345572233200073,
-0.2273290753364563,
0.2434670776128769,
0.12972810864448547,
0.421798437833786,
-0.03987222537398338,
0.6251438856124878,
-0.1398029625415802,
-0.4072875380516052,
-0.2467949390411377,
0.3290500044822693,
0.20193640887737274,
0.2332582324743271,
1.027763843536377,
-1.0131925344467163,
-0.8359575271606445,
0.19816122949123383,
-0.7107231616973877,
-0.3338510990142822,
0.5094861388206482,
0.18588782846927643,
0.2720097601413727,
0.28665682673454285,
0.4898923635482788,
0.4275115430355072,
0.6456860899925232,
-0.14282932877540588,
0.46610766649246216,
0.45518723130226135,
0.6068899631500244,
-1.1938221454620361,
-0.28318527340888977,
0.16339841485023499,
-0.41061028838157654,
-1.0664079189300537,
0.11375423520803452,
-0.12783154845237732,
-0.1756017953157425,
-0.5735641717910767,
0.5210521817207336,
-0.07173089683055878,
0.34633341431617737,
-0.18587204813957214,
0.06361617892980576,
-0.3983307480812073,
0.2748858630657196,
0.13079862296581268,
0.727699875831604,
0.2794760465621948,
-0.45210036635398865,
0.6183397173881531,
0.308422327041626,
-0.6510181427001953,
0.801863431930542,
-0.3008979260921478,
-0.08354458212852478,
-0.16092485189437866,
-0.40639418363571167,
-0.7842010259628296,
-0.36871135234832764,
0.5236766338348389,
-0.4824901819229126,
0.15347357094287872,
-0.3072635531425476,
-0.3631223738193512,
-0.5153765678405762,
0.04923783615231514,
0.4154975116252899,
-0.07035234570503235,
-0.6453263163566589,
0.3849796652793884,
0.9266261458396912,
-0.22526101768016815,
-1.0018839836120605,
-0.8653801679611206,
0.28177163004875183,
-0.52773118019104,
-0.39231011271476746,
0.07149334996938705,
0.17158493399620056,
-0.3028872311115265,
-0.34821224212646484,
0.4957219660282135,
-0.37727463245391846,
0.2917238473892212,
-0.03989441692829132,
-0.048954155296087265,
-0.09296824783086777,
-0.09646807610988617,
-0.30418673157691956,
0.6199901700019836,
0.12068615853786469,
0.07654665410518646,
0.47536522150039673,
-0.0076418546959757805,
0.02623269148170948,
-0.2239745855331421,
0.648383617401123,
0.321860671043396,
-0.20724177360534668,
0.7390519976615906,
0.9784064888954163,
-0.6690511107444763,
0.04048597812652588,
-0.5861926078796387,
0.27976107597351074,
-0.4295506775379181,
0.5252503156661987,
-0.2862815260887146,
-0.8804092407226562,
0.5847272276878357,
0.5187507271766663,
0.15726885199546814,
0.026502594351768494,
0.6499207615852356,
0.016981495544314384,
0.573350727558136,
0.3178236484527588,
-0.4517812430858612,
0.5592700839042664,
0.09896260499954224,
0.3368768095970154,
-0.4374224543571472,
0.027501750737428665,
-0.7073126435279846,
-0.1158275380730629,
-0.8378871083259583,
-0.17859819531440735,
0.3389451801776886,
-0.13123950362205505,
-0.1373194456100464,
0.6844837665557861,
-0.20585282146930695,
0.5798029899597168,
0.16760237514972687,
0.11338452994823456,
0.017718078568577766,
0.40168115496635437,
0.08079752326011658,
0.031837694346904755,
-0.3619321286678314,
-0.283248633146286,
1.153182029724121,
0.17227569222450256,
0.4723774194717407,
0.674457311630249,
0.3539525270462036,
0.567182183265686,
0.6201812624931335,
-0.5795095562934875,
0.0054983110167086124,
-0.3552379012107849,
-1.3721559047698975,
-0.3548988401889801,
-0.6312262415885925,
-0.8775776624679565,
0.21429821848869324,
-0.12753728032112122,
-0.8718531131744385,
0.25803276896476746,
0.15364167094230652,
-0.19824406504631042,
0.6734640598297119,
-0.5062525272369385,
0.8412815928459167,
-0.12328748404979706,
-0.45469143986701965,
-0.12957529723644257,
-0.30771404504776,
0.5320603847503662,
-0.26874640583992004,
0.842644214630127,
-0.40286147594451904,
0.08952300995588303,
0.9713208079338074,
-0.15635623037815094,
0.837769091129303,
-0.20577208697795868,
-0.32068920135498047,
0.3250032663345337,
0.011143040843307972,
0.19285760819911957,
-0.29954132437705994,
-0.6206121444702148,
0.4799242317676544,
-0.5430440306663513,
-0.3436894714832306,
0.14650143682956696,
0.5171771049499512,
-0.43502116203308105,
-0.14983855187892914,
-0.23157647252082825,
-0.5866317749023438,
-0.23543566465377808,
0.3946996331214905,
0.2813657224178314,
0.5771505832672119,
-0.5334610939025879,
-0.051478542387485504,
0.36347827315330505,
-0.3166957497596741,
0.3625515401363373,
0.591541051864624,
-0.4488567113876343,
-0.5156608819961548,
0.986676037311554,
0.01403168123215437,
0.14476101100444794,
0.06913688778877258,
0.24644872546195984,
-0.31870320439338684,
-0.6286805868148804,
-0.5405601263046265,
0.054808251559734344,
-0.6543518304824829,
-0.22560860216617584,
-0.7333102226257324,
0.10976745188236237,
-0.6620563268661499,
0.027106257155537605,
-0.15844428539276123,
-0.1752336025238037,
-0.08233625441789627,
0.15846560895442963,
0.5426435470581055,
1.0617135763168335,
-0.45503857731819153,
0.8605484962463379,
-0.43639686703681946,
0.7543428540229797,
0.16030371189117432,
0.4113703966140747,
-0.16906435787677765,
-0.7467023134231567,
-0.33306169509887695,
0.278606116771698,
-0.3029824197292328,
-1.1239440441131592,
0.5308317542076111,
0.28254857659339905,
0.47447213530540466,
0.4369724988937378,
-0.10222170501947403,
0.4106210470199585,
-0.4106881618499756,
0.3038756549358368,
0.20290516316890717,
-0.5152370929718018,
0.7313639521598816,
-0.6923168301582336,
-0.022293301299214363,
0.4107825756072998,
1.056820273399353,
-0.764017641544342,
-0.38772252202033997,
-0.23993448913097382,
-0.33522772789001465,
1.125125765800476,
0.4149065911769867,
0.2795330286026001,
-0.2669084966182709,
-0.19621454179286957,
0.21304446458816528,
0.2632151246070862,
-0.8073430061340332,
-0.46292904019355774,
-0.1519005000591278,
-0.1401521861553192,
-0.11991190165281296,
-0.1364087164402008,
-0.134566992521286,
-0.01829623430967331,
0.690982460975647,
-0.07913167774677277,
0.138518288731575,
-0.5523658990859985,
-0.30809980630874634,
0.006217245478183031,
0.20612387359142303,
0.26019757986068726,
0.6433754563331604,
-0.2404336780309677,
-0.29670485854148865,
-0.04455093666911125,
-0.6443269848823547,
0.12450772523880005,
0.09598317742347717,
-0.23871061205863953,
0.09568066149950027,
0.24775922298431396,
0.9324771761894226,
-0.10033667087554932,
-0.40135496854782104,
0.5408271551132202,
-0.09934292733669281,
0.011140740476548672,
-0.2110150009393692,
-0.16533014178276062,
0.12427160888910294,
-0.18106567859649658,
0.17324191331863403,
0.03147990629076958,
0.28687921166419983,
-0.6130971908569336,
0.13901758193969727,
0.22087159752845764,
-0.21814501285552979,
-0.05769452452659607,
0.48319804668426514,
0.42101404070854187,
-0.4976145625114441,
0.7616217136383057,
-0.16508512198925018,
-1.0123724937438965,
0.5676056146621704,
0.817698061466217,
0.3623100221157074,
-0.6399251818656921,
0.4600103497505188,
0.7073408961296082,
0.4764147698879242,
0.51993727684021,
0.4105125367641449,
-0.005326718557626009,
-1.324167013168335,
0.06252073496580124,
-0.7652689218521118,
-0.11260379105806351,
0.5434257984161377,
-0.819779098033905,
0.2716464400291443,
-0.5469750165939331,
-0.2574940323829651,
0.2933103144168854,
-0.2878604531288147,
-0.44016408920288086,
0.3646787405014038,
0.6210998892784119,
0.5835137963294983,
-1.1193456649780273,
0.6250917911529541,
0.40279102325439453,
-0.11248055845499039,
-0.0749036893248558,
-0.4568668603897095,
0.2847030758857727,
-1.0545237064361572,
0.45374688506126404,
0.2105579376220703,
-0.042232394218444824,
0.004529551137238741,
-0.3600238859653473,
-0.44586876034736633,
0.11932100355625153,
0.32546350359916687,
-0.3503093421459198,
0.39339253306388855,
0.41740185022354126,
0.3505169451236725,
-0.25624480843544006,
0.3027200996875763,
0.9561581015586853,
0.42266297340393066,
-0.30713653564453125,
-0.7451744675636292,
-0.31270429491996765,
-0.2834291458129883,
-0.36159443855285645,
0.5917733311653137,
-0.4842168092727661,
0.7137444615364075,
-0.009287447668612003,
-0.20814411342144012,
-0.27116110920906067,
0.6351186633110046,
0.04884710907936096,
-0.04119807481765747,
0.49598559737205505,
0.759856104850769,
0.6313945055007935,
-0.30166390538215637,
0.7460688352584839,
0.2884298861026764,
-0.14346811175346375,
1.3907687664031982,
-0.03514116629958153,
0.6093712449073792,
-0.040405839681625366,
-0.3904251158237457,
0.32487156987190247,
0.3798917829990387,
0.1721263825893402,
0.2398051917552948,
0.27411529421806335,
-0.4442235231399536,
-0.06808284670114517,
-0.5975522994995117,
-0.25503844022750854,
0.6778917908668518,
0.8755590319633484,
-0.05731065943837166,
-0.39650869369506836,
0.3079383373260498,
0.49303168058395386,
0.3396058678627014,
-0.3878456950187683,
0.4916217625141144,
-0.2978465259075165,
-0.1829354614019394,
0.7275588512420654,
0.08235528320074081,
1.0981190204620361,
-0.682318925857544,
0.19111832976341248,
-0.21746258437633514,
0.04605087265372276,
-0.152720108628273,
-0.8440214395523071,
0.527859091758728,
0.5186263918876648,
0.20965106785297394,
0.035127054899930954,
0.31498274207115173,
-0.4539604187011719,
-0.32685479521751404,
0.5918661952018738,
-0.1209886223077774,
0.2819752097129822,
-0.2257412225008011,
-0.8651348948478699,
0.3388235569000244,
0.057402629405260086,
0.05980757996439934,
0.08986373990774155,
0.21084226667881012,
-0.32889848947525024,
0.49155792593955994,
0.44618120789527893,
0.13153159618377686,
0.5174627304077148,
0.3762519061565399,
0.5655189752578735,
-0.25007638335227966,
-0.4208444356918335,
-0.6059801578521729,
0.10421833395957947,
-0.3273676037788391,
-0.6635194420814514,
0.6574210524559021,
0.5880074501037598,
1.242647409439087,
0.02251092717051506,
0.9695596098899841,
-0.38210615515708923,
0.7645386457443237,
-0.14048554003238678,
0.652521550655365,
-0.608780026435852,
-0.28709760308265686,
-0.34854674339294434,
-0.5265349745750427,
-0.29753726720809937,
0.584240734577179,
-0.15181976556777954,
-0.00932612456381321,
0.3432767391204834,
0.9449558854103088,
-0.2573423981666565,
0.35601383447647095,
0.42814502120018005,
0.3803582191467285,
0.379158616065979,
0.3285602033138275,
0.833183765411377,
-0.8407250046730042,
0.32893913984298706,
-0.6745140552520752,
-0.19512774050235748,
-0.18046191334724426,
-0.9976932406425476,
-0.9414128661155701,
-0.4482297897338867,
-0.32872217893600464,
-0.19556383788585663,
0.15426026284694672,
0.6137217283248901,
0.5576640963554382,
-1.431956171989441,
-0.6594958305358887,
0.34251171350479126,
-0.03964412584900856,
0.10398077964782715,
-0.14937743544578552,
-0.12426041811704636,
-0.024505216628313065,
-0.8438822031021118,
0.7098327875137329,
-0.07257174700498581,
0.04387356713414192,
0.0910119116306305,
-0.030468085780739784,
-0.941661536693573,
-0.16350911557674408,
0.6354514360427856,
0.46041756868362427,
-0.5363778471946716,
0.08678010106086731,
-0.4465843141078949,
-0.08602389693260193,
0.007620292715728283,
0.5468250513076782,
-0.5383185148239136,
0.4257934093475342,
0.3894718885421753,
0.6193476319313049,
0.09909973293542862,
-0.16980746388435364,
0.36797401309013367,
-0.769758403301239,
0.5042484998703003,
0.30713486671447754,
0.3492280840873718,
0.6652098894119263,
-0.36095306277275085,
0.5965760350227356,
0.21994532644748688,
-0.18790626525878906,
-0.8326318860054016,
0.2965458929538727,
-0.35686153173446655,
-0.20847126841545105,
0.7455809712409973,
-0.20824025571346283,
-0.1161261722445488,
-0.4318820834159851,
0.16245032846927643,
0.4519504904747009,
-0.4646085500717163,
0.5379244685173035,
0.6590685844421387,
0.3735921382904053,
0.19984103739261627,
-0.5068175196647644,
0.42097917199134827,
0.18768541514873505,
-0.8607842922210693,
0.19324560463428497,
0.5843272805213928,
0.1014377623796463,
0.33277428150177,
0.5051558613777161,
-0.11977137625217438,
0.28957417607307434,
-0.1490887850522995,
0.06358174979686737,
-0.02774551883339882,
-0.461215078830719,
-0.2801286280155182,
-0.004815797321498394,
-0.5570094585418701,
-0.14843997359275818
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.02166v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.02166v1
|
Whistle: Data-Efficient Multilingual and Crosslingual Speech Recognition via Weakly Phonetic Supervision
| 2024-06-04T09:56:05 | 2024-06-04T09:56:05 |
Saierdaer Yusuyin, Te Ma, Hao Huang, Wenbo Zhao, Zhijian Ou
|
cs.SD
|
cs.SD, cs.CL, eess.AS
|
There exist three approaches for multilingual and crosslingual automatic
speech recognition (MCL-ASR) - supervised pre-training with phonetic or
graphemic transcription, and self-supervised pre-training. We find that
pre-training with phonetic supervision has been underappreciated so far for
MCL-ASR, while conceptually it is more advantageous for information sharing
between different languages. This paper explores the approach of pre-training
with weakly phonetic supervision towards data-efficient MCL-ASR, which is
called Whistle. We relax the requirement of gold-standard human-validated
phonetic transcripts, and obtain International Phonetic Alphabet (IPA) based
transcription by leveraging the LanguageNet grapheme-to-phoneme (G2P) models.
We construct a common experimental setup based on the CommonVoice dataset,
called CV-Lang10, with 10 seen languages and 2 unseen languages. A set of
experiments are conducted on CV-Lang10 to compare, as fair as possible, the
three approaches under the common setup for MCL-ASR. Experiments demonstrate
the advantages of phoneme-based models (Whistle) for MCL-ASR, in terms of
speech recognition for seen languages, crosslingual performance for unseen
languages with different amounts of few-shot data, overcoming catastrophic
forgetting, and training efficiency.It is found that when training data is more
limited, phoneme supervision can achieve better results compared to subword
supervision and self-supervision, thereby providing higher data-efficiency. To
support reproducibility and promote future research along this direction, we
will release the code, models and data for the whole pipeline of Whistle at
https://github.com/thu-spmi/CAT upon publication.
|
[
-0.1378755122423172,
-0.19643951952457428,
-0.08972059190273285,
0.373938649892807,
-0.21464574337005615,
0.03498425707221031,
-0.3349345624446869,
-0.6019971370697021,
0.2794469892978668,
0.5229271650314331,
-0.21327318251132965,
-0.5778074860572815,
-0.5482157468795776,
0.036600954830646515,
-0.3435229957103729,
0.7992072701454163,
0.14847685396671295,
0.39241495728492737,
0.10911465436220169,
-0.02186088263988495,
-0.07171792536973953,
-0.7310702204704285,
-0.7059393525123596,
-0.39834296703338623,
0.6622632741928101,
0.31329146027565,
0.19343918561935425,
0.563929557800293,
0.18947406113147736,
0.17707960307598114,
0.047921694815158844,
-0.045297734439373016,
-0.2624148428440094,
-0.32640567421913147,
0.20015236735343933,
-0.5085406303405762,
-0.4442971348762512,
0.025198159739375114,
0.6736240983009338,
0.7595047354698181,
-0.26444822549819946,
0.4030446410179138,
0.3698864281177521,
0.19764986634254456,
-0.5073569416999817,
0.543938398361206,
-0.9179478287696838,
-0.0929378941655159,
-0.5102410316467285,
-0.17808137834072113,
-0.3763140141963959,
-0.18926961719989777,
0.049595750868320465,
-0.5143356919288635,
0.1792965680360794,
0.0038066848646849394,
0.6700164675712585,
0.13941095769405365,
-0.320602148771286,
-0.5269071459770203,
-0.6180837154388428,
0.8514209985733032,
-0.5969453454017639,
0.8543427586555481,
0.6573755145072937,
0.34735602140426636,
0.1284942477941513,
-0.9010677933692932,
-0.3240879476070404,
-0.1896265745162964,
-0.009537424892187119,
0.49754104018211365,
-0.1498645544052124,
-0.07218258082866669,
0.23616711795330048,
0.11281631886959076,
-0.4349783957004547,
0.23048263788223267,
-0.6110714077949524,
-0.618973433971405,
0.385257363319397,
-0.24665482342243195,
0.33181533217430115,
-0.0329427607357502,
-0.23520734906196594,
-0.06298559159040451,
-0.6944754123687744,
0.44680771231651306,
0.588068425655365,
0.9268872141838074,
-0.41555237770080566,
0.47869306802749634,
-0.12925106287002563,
0.35182297229766846,
-0.08818438649177551,
-0.18497207760810852,
0.38325634598731995,
-0.15037810802459717,
0.024022677913308144,
0.6197625994682312,
0.8476687073707581,
-0.15907689929008484,
0.43794605135917664,
-0.35154181718826294,
-0.026913419365882874,
0.4523186981678009,
-0.12613710761070251,
-0.5882520079612732,
-0.43780621886253357,
0.145035058259964,
-0.37242621183395386,
0.03137647733092308,
-0.23177674412727356,
-0.3992379307746887,
-0.014149840921163559,
-0.571012556552887,
0.36311331391334534,
-0.4698837697505951,
-0.4486147463321686,
0.05225953459739685,
-0.05429740622639656,
0.24299800395965576,
0.2377883344888687,
-0.8837801814079285,
0.5816859006881714,
0.616675853729248,
0.752754807472229,
-0.038122497498989105,
-0.5799263715744019,
-0.9288844466209412,
0.21999825537204742,
-0.2203272581100464,
0.5592477321624756,
-0.3267970681190491,
-0.3688778579235077,
-0.07811490446329117,
-0.08522994071245193,
-0.3426617681980133,
-0.6750290393829346,
0.5476351976394653,
-0.2234182506799698,
0.004453886765986681,
0.05061421915888786,
-0.38894179463386536,
-0.013322037644684315,
-0.13091368973255157,
-0.4726570248603821,
0.7487170696258545,
-0.44425541162490845,
-0.8517550826072693,
0.4849933087825775,
-0.3589286804199219,
-0.607192873954773,
-0.060465242713689804,
-0.16086086630821228,
-0.5098760724067688,
-0.22459383308887482,
0.3718794286251068,
0.35850125551223755,
-0.15536954998970032,
0.17128965258598328,
-0.3285546600818634,
-0.4555469751358032,
0.054976701736450195,
-0.6046239137649536,
1.1674753427505493,
0.23665787279605865,
-0.20855237543582916,
-0.07863996177911758,
-0.8486782908439636,
0.24635109305381775,
-0.25699374079704285,
-0.3869529366493225,
-0.22649437189102173,
-0.3062146008014679,
0.023758668452501297,
0.0808684453368187,
0.1403798907995224,
-0.499756395816803,
-0.04500831291079521,
-0.31010279059410095,
0.24094395339488983,
0.32287731766700745,
-0.24132785201072693,
0.4591352641582489,
-0.19954273104667664,
0.3273210823535919,
0.04575721174478531,
0.26103684306144714,
-0.016921287402510643,
-0.35668379068374634,
-0.6610564589500427,
-0.6400395035743713,
0.8475277423858643,
0.8158205151557922,
-0.7127529382705688,
-0.017245976254343987,
-0.1905604749917984,
-0.4634268879890442,
-0.9219965934753418,
0.2790450155735016,
0.750092625617981,
0.47789642214775085,
0.3442908227443695,
-0.34405502676963806,
-0.6904177665710449,
-0.6120474934577942,
-0.3422611653804779,
-0.3989321291446686,
-0.26322537660598755,
0.31153368949890137,
0.0729854628443718,
-0.1804627627134323,
0.6091336607933044,
0.0248115211725235,
-0.5678226351737976,
-0.26668408513069153,
0.43278399109840393,
0.258332222700119,
0.4695354998111725,
0.3103952407836914,
-0.7392880916595459,
-0.7303723096847534,
0.04733958840370178,
-0.6896029114723206,
-0.3088970482349396,
0.10392997413873672,
0.10577524453401566,
0.17922107875347137,
0.5744078755378723,
-0.38914740085601807,
0.28515633940696716,
0.5428849458694458,
0.3153899013996124,
0.6146466732025146,
-0.06330407410860062,
0.06988710910081863,
-0.7230013608932495,
0.13587577641010284,
-0.16581356525421143,
-0.2795772850513458,
-0.9055019021034241,
-0.3991318345069885,
0.2920660078525543,
-0.3207319676876068,
-0.7326938509941101,
0.38195544481277466,
-0.8270763158798218,
-0.0570480115711689,
0.0006121733458712697,
-0.12190371751785278,
-0.3973485231399536,
0.6830004453659058,
0.5142572522163391,
0.6952571272850037,
1.0453894138336182,
-0.8005667328834534,
0.062238216400146484,
-0.06343621760606766,
-0.12688347697257996,
0.23293271660804749,
-0.5800439715385437,
0.2501205801963806,
0.15131959319114685,
0.03518252074718475,
-0.6144247651100159,
-0.032463204115629196,
0.24324598908424377,
-0.7119762301445007,
0.6246696710586548,
-0.5744408369064331,
-0.4389258027076721,
-0.21341562271118164,
-0.14229026436805725,
0.408854216337204,
0.5845880508422852,
-0.6779500246047974,
0.6083576083183289,
0.7490220069885254,
-0.26044127345085144,
-0.6463154554367065,
-0.8112001419067383,
0.04250367358326912,
-0.4932612180709839,
-0.352559357881546,
-0.011010517366230488,
0.13293954730033875,
-0.09954617917537689,
-0.4124617278575897,
-0.2702852487564087,
-0.25280046463012695,
-0.3775818347930908,
0.28784891963005066,
0.022362107411026955,
-0.11692056059837341,
-0.08733992278575897,
-0.19293300807476044,
-0.24967467784881592,
-0.054893434047698975,
-0.34506797790527344,
0.4701988101005554,
-0.12320204824209213,
-0.240006223320961,
-0.7065373063087463,
0.2555665969848633,
0.31088995933532715,
-0.29838550090789795,
0.15938511490821838,
0.7178021669387817,
-0.27695393562316895,
-0.1569788157939911,
-0.6255574226379395,
-0.09770293533802032,
-0.4429277777671814,
-0.13410313427448273,
-0.7212451696395874,
-0.5729682445526123,
0.7314936518669128,
-0.13714498281478882,
-0.09850504249334335,
-0.009560255333781242,
0.4029921591281891,
-0.049673888832330704,
0.9004424810409546,
0.3359980285167694,
-0.3133624494075775,
0.5279682874679565,
-0.1417292356491089,
-0.06735092401504517,
-0.7995153665542603,
-0.08543100208044052,
-0.548936128616333,
0.3265172839164734,
-0.6119638681411743,
-0.36475953459739685,
0.33275607228279114,
0.14665038883686066,
0.1008262112736702,
0.40384161472320557,
-0.3018571734428406,
0.13289369642734528,
0.9180383086204529,
0.08105432242155075,
0.2886975109577179,
-0.038811709731817245,
-0.28029462695121765,
-0.06613987684249878,
-0.7883664965629578,
-0.5064537525177002,
1.0895506143569946,
0.27717381715774536,
0.9958656430244446,
-0.05783678963780403,
0.9679851531982422,
0.16546516120433807,
-0.0760011300444603,
-0.7674970626831055,
0.3794223964214325,
-0.251974493265152,
-0.41781073808670044,
-0.41455361247062683,
-0.5872325897216797,
-1.0847550630569458,
0.21026836335659027,
0.058468665927648544,
-0.766742467880249,
0.20463183522224426,
0.6004788279533386,
-0.08073138445615768,
0.11424721032381058,
-0.9922606348991394,
0.6401574015617371,
-0.1704116016626358,
-0.13466030359268188,
0.11566219478845596,
-0.8465002775192261,
0.3530975580215454,
-0.19257362186908722,
0.18498274683952332,
0.007236991543322802,
0.31690898537635803,
0.681552529335022,
-0.3174208104610443,
0.9885173439979553,
-0.36428651213645935,
-0.07889533787965775,
0.549536406993866,
-0.24502435326576233,
0.5043625831604004,
-0.03401561453938484,
-0.020904147997498512,
0.5772960186004639,
0.11105792224407196,
-0.24661707878112793,
-0.4518702030181885,
0.3627169132232666,
-0.6655617952346802,
-0.19052095711231232,
-0.33686935901641846,
-0.1435222625732422,
-0.32342737913131714,
0.2659102976322174,
0.4920177161693573,
0.7618765830993652,
-0.00910142995417118,
-0.004067609552294016,
0.5278316140174866,
-0.1286381483078003,
0.2686447501182556,
0.7857359051704407,
-0.30128228664398193,
-0.2598908245563507,
1.2263435125350952,
0.6823873519897461,
0.29551172256469727,
0.3807322680950165,
0.1652296632528305,
-0.5691814422607422,
-0.619349479675293,
-0.30802854895591736,
0.2420251965522766,
-0.4148508906364441,
-0.04061292111873627,
-0.8329073190689087,
-0.21679534018039703,
-0.8307562470436096,
0.24775898456573486,
-0.5667164921760559,
-0.44827818870544434,
-0.23524606227874756,
0.3389125466346741,
0.18298496305942535,
0.14373870193958282,
-0.4985399544239044,
0.3801997900009155,
-0.5631468892097473,
0.6266672015190125,
0.3642469346523285,
0.27432724833488464,
-0.021761348471045494,
-0.5182532668113708,
-0.26343947649002075,
0.24946527183055878,
0.1725863516330719,
-0.4333761930465698,
0.3820136487483978,
0.3719335198402405,
0.5525872111320496,
0.18729974329471588,
0.2714194059371948,
0.9308930039405823,
-0.8316044807434082,
0.3525722026824951,
0.441289484500885,
-1.0416148900985718,
0.5409653186798096,
-0.33648982644081116,
0.33825811743736267,
0.4417595863342285,
0.2826556861400604,
-0.46076011657714844,
-0.7735493183135986,
-0.5421085357666016,
-0.842076301574707,
0.6729085445404053,
0.14420300722122192,
-0.23083314299583435,
0.13080911338329315,
-0.09488987922668457,
0.21709126234054565,
0.17243589460849762,
-0.5241049528121948,
-0.15885967016220093,
-0.4645049273967743,
-0.1736277937889099,
-0.07929274439811707,
0.06437431275844574,
0.01881941221654415,
-0.14831559360027313,
0.7898772954940796,
-0.19838790595531464,
0.29448118805885315,
0.12335539609193802,
-0.41251352429389954,
0.34108346700668335,
0.35404524207115173,
0.21168889105319977,
0.21768051385879517,
-0.19150519371032715,
0.3468051850795746,
0.36455851793289185,
-0.7508717179298401,
-0.006944085005670786,
0.2163284868001938,
0.007175855804234743,
0.07301553338766098,
0.4606643319129944,
0.7689153552055359,
0.2579710781574249,
-0.38378044962882996,
0.3583798408508301,
-0.21117928624153137,
-0.2463020235300064,
-0.5444521903991699,
-0.01940765790641308,
0.10632456094026566,
0.2602301836013794,
0.31247708201408386,
-0.1079544648528099,
0.40833380818367004,
-0.671854555606842,
0.41483038663864136,
0.2830127477645874,
-0.3814631700515747,
-0.4308111071586609,
0.7615128755569458,
0.038706012070178986,
-0.28893059492111206,
0.4995745122432709,
-0.10981963574886322,
-0.47128626704216003,
0.4019834101200104,
0.6064310073852539,
0.49038568139076233,
-0.3710134029388428,
0.1188974529504776,
0.2170129120349884,
0.07917937636375427,
-0.1267973929643631,
0.2784273326396942,
-0.35442036390304565,
-0.6449391841888428,
-0.3550570011138916,
-0.44090819358825684,
-0.6412522792816162,
0.02941611036658287,
-0.9348761439323425,
0.5253722667694092,
-0.2893555462360382,
-0.09533072263002396,
0.16994300484657288,
0.032371409237384796,
-0.6890587210655212,
0.3722056746482849,
0.18998746573925018,
0.683373749256134,
-0.8071514368057251,
1.2607306241989136,
0.28458523750305176,
-0.29982319474220276,
-1.1991873979568481,
-0.0422363318502903,
0.16060669720172882,
-0.9487619400024414,
0.6889758110046387,
0.12237278372049332,
-0.5657104849815369,
0.19111041724681854,
-0.2076055407524109,
-0.6495521664619446,
0.7408401966094971,
0.5642351508140564,
-0.653313934803009,
0.18868984282016754,
0.19908170402050018,
0.45294347405433655,
-0.08622133731842041,
0.10086501389741898,
0.3905731439590454,
0.2539139688014984,
0.2794022858142853,
-1.337907075881958,
-0.44183892011642456,
-0.28419655561447144,
-0.41860759258270264,
0.032450683414936066,
-0.7745782732963562,
0.4920305609703064,
-0.09647717326879501,
-0.41675466299057007,
-0.06666607409715652,
0.6081750988960266,
0.22610679268836975,
0.5612054467201233,
0.5595679879188538,
0.26478174328804016,
0.961144745349884,
-0.014538922347128391,
0.7905266284942627,
-0.0678430125117302,
0.03882557526230812,
1.4092968702316284,
-0.4745047390460968,
0.9866788983345032,
0.4226795732975006,
-0.22078005969524384,
-0.09204784035682678,
0.5180822014808655,
0.16775494813919067,
0.6844438314437866,
0.14861564338207245,
-0.25701653957366943,
-0.022014658898115158,
-0.30124935507774353,
-0.3083038330078125,
0.8068674802780151,
0.1231817975640297,
0.12242865562438965,
0.051981858909130096,
0.09945067018270493,
-0.0726458877325058,
-0.1231260895729065,
-0.5859045386314392,
0.9016812443733215,
0.33908000588417053,
-0.2471703141927719,
0.8048732876777649,
-0.5285115242004395,
0.8023712038993835,
-0.7886260747909546,
0.18801598250865936,
0.06145353615283966,
0.1370750218629837,
-0.22899428009986877,
-0.34654223918914795,
0.30842074751853943,
0.19458840787410736,
-0.10670872032642365,
-0.22065369784832,
0.8411771655082703,
-0.840106189250946,
-0.5536481142044067,
0.5083034038543701,
0.4309205114841461,
0.6597632765769958,
0.04890131950378418,
-0.595485508441925,
0.06920947879552841,
-0.0613582618534565,
0.1365087777376175,
0.31713056564331055,
0.5310063362121582,
0.03664814680814743,
0.6661409139633179,
0.7405670881271362,
0.6240764856338501,
0.40805354714393616,
0.6399545669555664,
0.5150761008262634,
-0.43591219186782837,
-0.8133801221847534,
-0.4914356768131256,
0.3936193585395813,
-0.0018004263984039426,
-0.035197045654058456,
0.8914129734039307,
0.7672185301780701,
0.8541218042373657,
0.01329081505537033,
0.8608053922653198,
0.33288922905921936,
1.0083050727844238,
-0.7983714938163757,
0.6982247829437256,
-0.3892024755477905,
0.12659014761447906,
-0.4734463393688202,
-0.6114221215248108,
-0.5994129180908203,
0.5130067467689514,
-0.2628073990345001,
-0.19078965485095978,
0.3689996600151062,
0.8194647431373596,
-0.4231809675693512,
0.00633526686578989,
0.4066835939884186,
-0.0019115307368338108,
0.14865271747112274,
0.41726112365722656,
0.7115861177444458,
-0.3588756024837494,
0.8364879488945007,
-0.02965058572590351,
-0.07792139053344727,
0.0728779062628746,
-0.5976433157920837,
-0.9272892475128174,
-0.5407407879829407,
-0.377347469329834,
-0.04221200942993164,
0.12109719216823578,
0.7238945960998535,
0.9005283713340759,
-0.8282434344291687,
-0.5841024518013,
0.008141309022903442,
-0.10416025668382645,
-0.3018827736377716,
-0.16515929996967316,
0.5375872850418091,
-0.3935224413871765,
-0.920132040977478,
0.4555991291999817,
0.09259314835071564,
0.26949968934059143,
0.1610240638256073,
-0.1999616175889969,
-0.026923486962914467,
-0.17152175307273865,
0.3757160007953644,
0.6918296217918396,
-0.48693907260894775,
-0.11832544952630997,
-0.21134041249752045,
0.08216577768325806,
0.08546840399503708,
0.7640247344970703,
-0.6426813006401062,
0.4605484902858734,
0.09780754894018173,
0.46030694246292114,
0.9149454236030579,
-0.17835155129432678,
0.6474211812019348,
-0.7573413848876953,
0.37335219979286194,
0.1676148623228073,
0.3591865003108978,
0.3915826082229614,
-0.13235007226467133,
0.542275071144104,
-0.04811063036322594,
-0.4431881904602051,
-1.1240304708480835,
0.24071434140205383,
-1.013012170791626,
0.07194112241268158,
1.1080410480499268,
-0.37063437700271606,
-0.1769476979970932,
-0.3613373041152954,
-0.2721562683582306,
0.6780730485916138,
-0.5041207075119019,
0.5956590175628662,
0.44998055696487427,
-0.2301051914691925,
-0.316379189491272,
-0.4860268235206604,
0.6401816010475159,
0.20950466394424438,
-0.4674101769924164,
0.29805994033813477,
0.0952410027384758,
0.2793639004230499,
0.13596773147583008,
0.9300041794776917,
-0.11072531342506409,
0.20907145738601685,
0.40590086579322815,
0.1482781320810318,
-0.02986215427517891,
-0.5343659520149231,
-0.4326227307319641,
0.05851748213171959,
0.04419216886162758,
-0.5112105011940002
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.02148v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.02148v1
|
Synergetic Event Understanding: A Collaborative Approach to Cross-Document Event Coreference Resolution with Large Language Models
| 2024-06-04T09:35:47 | 2024-06-04T09:35:47 |
Qingkai Min, Qipeng Guo, Xiangkun Hu, Songfang Huang, Zheng Zhang, Yue Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Cross-document event coreference resolution (CDECR) involves clustering event
mentions across multiple documents that refer to the same real-world events.
Existing approaches utilize fine-tuning of small language models (SLMs) like
BERT to address the compatibility among the contexts of event mentions.
However, due to the complexity and diversity of contexts, these models are
prone to learning simple co-occurrences. Recently, large language models (LLMs)
like ChatGPT have demonstrated impressive contextual understanding, yet they
encounter challenges in adapting to specific information extraction (IE) tasks.
In this paper, we propose a collaborative approach for CDECR, leveraging the
capabilities of both a universally capable LLM and a task-specific SLM. The
collaborative strategy begins with the LLM accurately and comprehensively
summarizing events through prompting. Then, the SLM refines its learning of
event representations based on these insights during fine-tuning. Experimental
results demonstrate that our approach surpasses the performance of both the
large and small language models individually, forming a complementary
advantage. Across various datasets, our approach achieves state-of-the-art
performance, underscoring its effectiveness in diverse scenarios.
|
[
-0.5222635865211487,
-0.5623617172241211,
0.5951581597328186,
-0.1957068294286728,
-0.3559107184410095,
0.33512189984321594,
-0.9626935124397278,
-0.6933526992797852,
0.1347508430480957,
0.2528655230998993,
-0.6297528147697449,
-0.6105232238769531,
-0.7487195730209351,
-0.0387394055724144,
-0.23437027633190155,
1.2271523475646973,
-0.1493362933397293,
0.06580507755279541,
-0.3340388238430023,
-0.3030357360839844,
-0.3489045798778534,
-0.7590963840484619,
-0.6503341197967529,
-0.5877208113670349,
0.471322238445282,
0.6675091981887817,
0.46399086713790894,
0.12008801847696304,
0.5936404466629028,
0.22259092330932617,
-0.11311308294534683,
0.33661550283432007,
-0.5223817229270935,
0.11768947541713715,
-0.5238854885101318,
-0.38776111602783203,
-0.294974148273468,
-0.09076254814863205,
0.35946330428123474,
0.8956488370895386,
-0.07233072817325592,
-0.03240559995174408,
0.42381352186203003,
0.1813526153564453,
-0.5578109622001648,
0.19418875873088837,
-0.8319131135940552,
0.011290435679256916,
-0.05203768610954285,
-0.08701243996620178,
-0.5027208924293518,
0.15356621146202087,
0.39585307240486145,
-0.6859520077705383,
0.8339933156967163,
-0.08227451145648956,
0.7140488028526306,
0.007763548754155636,
-0.15344075858592987,
-0.555038332939148,
-0.7755455374717712,
0.9157217144966125,
-0.4021315574645996,
0.3086102604866028,
0.09300114214420319,
0.08629114180803299,
-0.06484690308570862,
-0.8384284973144531,
-0.6570851802825928,
0.11521367728710175,
-0.19110597670078278,
0.1693723052740097,
-0.31725889444351196,
0.07114632427692413,
-0.10636963695287704,
0.31461575627326965,
-0.5628198385238647,
0.3367599844932556,
-0.03505407273769379,
-0.1555452197790146,
0.47403568029403687,
0.3015453815460205,
0.1867276132106781,
-0.027717284858226776,
-0.2777668535709381,
0.06451781094074249,
-0.3417680561542511,
-0.16493453085422516,
-0.2617686688899994,
0.4206630289554596,
-0.2669506072998047,
0.20943976938724518,
0.004852417856454849,
0.30726221203804016,
0.8131245374679565,
-0.03944483771920204,
-0.05224619433283806,
-0.7605270743370056,
-0.12509030103683472,
0.18760865926742554,
0.5685938000679016,
0.3499225676059723,
0.02826310321688652,
-0.6630694270133972,
0.22540685534477234,
-0.09093750268220901,
0.02400091290473938,
-0.5516934990882874,
-0.1993936002254486,
0.24087610840797424,
-0.5410407781600952,
0.07329466193914413,
-0.10704509168863297,
-0.6073485016822815,
-0.43624305725097656,
-0.6501179337501526,
0.18253952264785767,
-0.49528825283050537,
-0.02740168757736683,
-0.15834374725818634,
-0.25908493995666504,
0.18280042707920074,
0.7063368558883667,
-0.7330306768417358,
0.3158315122127533,
0.8951808214187622,
0.7499266266822815,
-0.3727617859840393,
-0.379472941160202,
-0.6854618787765503,
0.29708340764045715,
0.2054777592420578,
0.9096331596374512,
-0.572950541973114,
-0.5191633701324463,
-0.23607192933559418,
-0.1184634268283844,
-0.2474529892206192,
-0.5924934148788452,
0.6853669881820679,
-0.4705803692340851,
0.16791382431983948,
-0.24012568593025208,
-0.7264701724052429,
-0.10694339126348495,
0.43009448051452637,
-0.4763696491718292,
0.6833128333091736,
-0.314982146024704,
-0.7479647994041443,
0.4975084662437439,
-0.30763548612594604,
-0.2961401343345642,
0.2715190649032593,
-0.4346998631954193,
-0.20672790706157684,
0.1250731348991394,
0.4882139563560486,
0.5143907070159912,
-0.2537215054035187,
0.3956790566444397,
-0.13536618649959564,
0.10362274944782257,
-0.11836875975131989,
0.13226483762264252,
0.31818196177482605,
-0.03412218391895294,
-0.14545218646526337,
0.33863696455955505,
-0.7488552927970886,
-0.29597893357276917,
-0.02489413693547249,
-0.03613226115703583,
-0.5661761164665222,
0.02323162369430065,
0.23259858787059784,
0.24781228601932526,
0.5913375020027161,
-0.45152610540390015,
0.08271527290344238,
-0.2380611151456833,
0.0965939536690712,
0.3725455701351166,
0.16379842162132263,
0.7240670323371887,
-0.20053356885910034,
0.3132825195789337,
0.22142566740512848,
0.07750684767961502,
-0.21453259885311127,
-0.2665790617465973,
-0.6673645377159119,
-0.18149331212043762,
-0.037057217210531235,
0.38468968868255615,
-0.6497672200202942,
0.7242162227630615,
-0.22381286323070526,
-0.5994206666946411,
-0.14604850113391876,
0.2571277916431427,
0.307656466960907,
0.43149566650390625,
0.3022162616252899,
-0.5296213030815125,
-0.8818395137786865,
-0.6605855226516724,
-0.2609023451805115,
-0.20408548414707184,
0.12057223916053772,
0.3069636821746826,
0.4192509055137634,
-0.06542668491601944,
1.0815664529800415,
-0.20664221048355103,
-0.5070028305053711,
-0.7127576470375061,
0.642489492893219,
0.2866600751876831,
0.49080702662467957,
0.382046103477478,
-0.8600589036941528,
-0.44008979201316833,
0.2951108515262604,
-0.48487308621406555,
0.028097141534090042,
-0.3181355893611908,
0.07365666329860687,
0.01200260128825903,
0.2263524979352951,
-0.3581210970878601,
0.3352908492088318,
0.6616216897964478,
-0.24932272732257843,
0.5953164100646973,
-0.3000105023384094,
0.057495418936014175,
-1.1790629625320435,
-0.04613345488905907,
-0.06657599657773972,
-0.26529499888420105,
-0.6199389696121216,
0.1331588476896286,
-0.17302267253398895,
-0.013821869157254696,
-0.18230222165584564,
0.41914090514183044,
-0.6304401755332947,
-0.012133193202316761,
-0.4050963819026947,
0.5437201857566833,
-0.0325533002614975,
0.34251296520233154,
0.539107084274292,
0.44332489371299744,
0.35164913535118103,
-0.44741708040237427,
0.32150745391845703,
0.5078372955322266,
-0.20461902022361755,
0.8513035774230957,
-0.34285768866539,
0.23947350680828094,
-0.004540371708571911,
0.5336598753929138,
-0.659039318561554,
-0.05841900408267975,
-0.1109582707285881,
-0.3775949776172638,
0.08354146778583527,
-0.23531757295131683,
-0.585560142993927,
-0.07063990086317062,
0.09952068328857422,
0.34869736433029175,
0.16483761370182037,
-0.901024341583252,
1.0017439126968384,
0.5266253352165222,
-0.3907441794872284,
-0.28358790278434753,
-0.34386175870895386,
0.3383238911628723,
0.02131216786801815,
-0.843237042427063,
0.5747106671333313,
-0.06615117192268372,
-0.30119872093200684,
-0.12305335700511932,
-0.13824546337127686,
-0.2764899432659149,
-0.17328248918056488,
0.39857104420661926,
0.16869096457958221,
-0.0866645947098732,
0.0565652996301651,
-0.20278717577457428,
-0.15646062791347504,
-0.2457324117422104,
-0.26456859707832336,
0.6066901683807373,
-0.14366568624973297,
-0.3082689940929413,
-0.36234161257743835,
0.6643615365028381,
0.24649807810783386,
-0.27258941531181335,
0.8134834170341492,
0.8814873099327087,
-0.4995166063308716,
-0.1714145988225937,
-0.7690359354019165,
-0.27974241971969604,
-0.3614046573638916,
0.18110401928424835,
-0.33474287390708923,
-1.1955925226211548,
0.8118042349815369,
-0.21955879032611847,
0.04304318130016327,
0.2525205910205841,
0.873490035533905,
-0.05576188117265701,
0.6217511892318726,
0.6997918486595154,
-0.19872444868087769,
0.5524621605873108,
0.013812121003866196,
0.15212811529636383,
-0.8654654026031494,
-0.20035181939601898,
-0.6766600012779236,
-0.2318187654018402,
-0.14435607194900513,
-0.6865211129188538,
0.39725780487060547,
0.26172757148742676,
0.30778229236602783,
0.4686826765537262,
-0.1562815010547638,
0.502263069152832,
0.46675190329551697,
0.19367797672748566,
0.5941208004951477,
-0.24309183657169342,
-0.13861647248268127,
-0.170100599527359,
-0.8112735152244568,
-0.35873016715049744,
0.4255407154560089,
-0.0761793702840805,
0.6726222038269043,
-0.18325135111808777,
0.9675079584121704,
0.036122191697359085,
0.05475493520498276,
-0.5433208346366882,
0.457672119140625,
-0.2820718586444855,
-0.4427562654018402,
-0.01917421817779541,
-0.16456080973148346,
-1.0207388401031494,
0.24218927323818207,
-0.16804513335227966,
-1.1681965589523315,
0.5240166187286377,
-0.050350889563560486,
-0.2190207690000534,
0.27753570675849915,
-0.5137237310409546,
0.7671740651130676,
0.10775348544120789,
-0.3383261263370514,
-0.7184416055679321,
-0.6146232485771179,
-0.0007905873935669661,
-0.10424810647964478,
0.4168865978717804,
-0.08288887143135071,
0.0382261648774147,
0.7594026327133179,
-0.1361096203327179,
1.2104436159133911,
0.15314580500125885,
-0.10169446468353271,
0.3918527662754059,
0.1554824858903885,
0.8644335269927979,
-0.006666204892098904,
-0.13909912109375,
0.13988901674747467,
0.0057696993462741375,
-0.22011084854602814,
-0.4727027416229248,
0.8564594388008118,
-0.6173900961875916,
-0.38233187794685364,
-0.06386470049619675,
-0.7611212730407715,
-0.23267972469329834,
-0.01151531096547842,
0.17798952758312225,
0.4606779217720032,
-0.69114089012146,
0.039379749447107315,
0.3143549859523773,
-0.027316376566886902,
0.6252537369728088,
0.7306137084960938,
0.26941898465156555,
-0.3535389006137848,
0.5368531942367554,
-0.07676343619823456,
0.13948532938957214,
0.427741676568985,
-0.11091920733451843,
0.0566188283264637,
-0.6526755094528198,
-0.07331380993127823,
0.12957842648029327,
-0.8977605700492859,
0.04007626324892044,
-0.8716136813163757,
0.04814424738287926,
-0.40033555030822754,
-0.5703331828117371,
-0.3006129562854767,
-0.39854007959365845,
-0.4951944053173065,
-0.06418291479349136,
0.19015277922153473,
0.3997572660446167,
-0.36965447664260864,
0.26128360629081726,
-1.2557826042175293,
0.12839283049106598,
-0.04206579551100731,
-0.03253417834639549,
0.07595788687467575,
-0.4194453954696655,
-0.5126374363899231,
-0.3652242422103882,
-0.31559139490127563,
-0.6292433142662048,
0.3894454538822174,
0.4125434160232544,
0.6418704390525818,
0.2114602029323578,
0.2572647035121918,
0.83860844373703,
-0.3451477885246277,
0.9579063057899475,
0.36523330211639404,
-1.1105419397354126,
0.831277072429657,
-0.22498294711112976,
0.40934842824935913,
0.7615780830383301,
0.2928304970264435,
-0.7363078594207764,
-0.6544203162193298,
-0.9718960523605347,
-0.8419845700263977,
0.7301595211029053,
0.20171648263931274,
-0.30151182413101196,
-0.05272810906171799,
0.1883823424577713,
0.45110979676246643,
-0.09821182489395142,
-0.42151939868927,
0.02138986811041832,
0.41927745938301086,
-0.2643687129020691,
-0.3243247866630554,
0.06589256972074509,
-0.20095600187778473,
-0.05344796180725098,
0.4676695466041565,
-0.29823994636535645,
-0.06513156741857529,
0.43120917677879333,
-0.5523780584335327,
-0.2705513834953308,
0.47449326515197754,
0.2069089561700821,
0.8104400038719177,
-0.035717882215976715,
0.3746497333049774,
0.49480244517326355,
-0.3446927070617676,
-0.27338773012161255,
0.23682044446468353,
0.21599127352237701,
0.11653636395931244,
0.7976289391517639,
0.4335694909095764,
0.5383026599884033,
-0.6696957349777222,
0.39657774567604065,
-0.17606806755065918,
0.03377743437886238,
-0.12521478533744812,
0.040740057826042175,
0.01479551661759615,
0.5134481191635132,
0.4361741840839386,
-0.02914109081029892,
0.060049090534448624,
-0.5621985793113708,
0.5815861821174622,
0.302463561296463,
-0.5236295461654663,
-0.507564902305603,
0.2633906304836273,
0.5186960697174072,
0.07662177085876465,
0.24736152589321136,
-0.06345831602811813,
-0.6833952069282532,
0.7545772790908813,
0.43617191910743713,
0.7810117602348328,
0.0715826079249382,
0.04626660794019699,
0.5395973324775696,
0.14458130300045013,
0.263456791639328,
0.01333145797252655,
-0.43386706709861755,
-1.0562400817871094,
-0.5078883767127991,
-0.409598708152771,
-0.7371559143066406,
-0.19166886806488037,
-0.8788803219795227,
0.04680079594254494,
-0.2457200288772583,
-0.05065423995256424,
0.33289963006973267,
0.24895046651363373,
-0.8470714688301086,
0.11381032317876816,
0.4079890549182892,
0.8778669834136963,
-0.6738169193267822,
0.9541782140731812,
0.7710197567939758,
-0.43853428959846497,
-0.5147219896316528,
0.026473959907889366,
0.09692464023828506,
-0.6146858334541321,
0.6568948030471802,
-0.15448050200939178,
0.2146335393190384,
0.01715715229511261,
-0.2903129756450653,
-0.6140912175178528,
1.0988601446151733,
0.07498744130134583,
-1.1038538217544556,
-0.13992993533611298,
-0.005783417262136936,
0.5733184218406677,
-0.5705124735832214,
0.2721313536167145,
0.6753696799278259,
0.37811562418937683,
0.2526923418045044,
-1.4003994464874268,
0.12493530660867691,
0.26363879442214966,
-0.23559993505477905,
0.21927094459533691,
-0.6005449891090393,
0.3816712498664856,
-0.3853456377983093,
-0.4020824134349823,
0.13849389553070068,
0.7954189777374268,
0.14524580538272858,
0.5786358118057251,
0.5431956052780151,
0.5036385655403137,
0.8957208395004272,
-0.06292109936475754,
0.8693603277206421,
-0.3916776776313782,
0.5955808162689209,
1.6538666486740112,
-0.5447239875793457,
0.6948084831237793,
0.6414330005645752,
0.03858998790383339,
0.3369365930557251,
0.42008090019226074,
0.09365080296993256,
0.4135218560695648,
-0.24485661089420319,
-0.6092292666435242,
-0.6672800779342651,
-0.4317454397678375,
-0.22250674664974213,
0.2881549596786499,
0.5593032240867615,
-0.43251118063926697,
-0.7623899579048157,
0.24407336115837097,
-0.16853857040405273,
0.13532580435276031,
-0.47798338532447815,
1.1903743743896484,
0.2589537501335144,
-0.6150839924812317,
0.043506819754838943,
-0.20366278290748596,
0.5915140509605408,
-0.3752864897251129,
0.1558961272239685,
-0.0026373863220214844,
0.4325278401374817,
-0.10728087276220322,
-0.8488898277282715,
0.5328895449638367,
0.07083069533109665,
-0.518619179725647,
-0.10077788680791855,
0.9329893589019775,
-0.5811462998390198,
-0.2939455509185791,
0.6678904891014099,
0.6205388307571411,
-0.025510817766189575,
0.007671097293496132,
-0.5480161309242249,
0.3029499053955078,
-0.17028096318244934,
0.23816506564617157,
0.4514372944831848,
0.5649073123931885,
0.12359873205423355,
0.3417319059371948,
0.5013373494148254,
0.011806475929915905,
-0.1293228268623352,
0.2542198598384857,
0.8705417513847351,
-0.5519133806228638,
-0.4899318516254425,
-0.6856849193572998,
0.25321537256240845,
-0.16769815981388092,
-0.215040922164917,
0.5163337588310242,
0.5680102705955505,
0.8677242398262024,
0.10067106783390045,
0.8578214645385742,
-0.16141492128372192,
0.4091343879699707,
-0.1971551477909088,
0.27943626046180725,
-0.17300355434417725,
0.04865578934550285,
-0.2427842617034912,
-0.5700423717498779,
-0.3653688132762909,
0.3192245662212372,
-0.4913485050201416,
-0.4199383556842804,
0.6764541268348694,
0.5314541459083557,
-0.10343694686889648,
0.3962714970111847,
0.30977290868759155,
0.19210629165172577,
0.27618181705474854,
0.884525716304779,
0.8558947443962097,
-0.1372031569480896,
0.6686264872550964,
-0.2923915386199951,
-0.3009323477745056,
-0.2017614245414734,
-0.9418277740478516,
-0.9410571455955505,
-0.8567159175872803,
-0.558219313621521,
-0.1675974726676941,
0.3082368075847626,
1.2245512008666992,
0.8980346322059631,
-0.9634847044944763,
-0.029153993353247643,
0.02473146840929985,
0.08383935689926147,
-0.23031343519687653,
-0.18793584406375885,
0.28159359097480774,
-0.5156334042549133,
-0.8454658389091492,
0.4166419208049774,
0.24157574772834778,
-0.29427847266197205,
0.1867348700761795,
0.002956886077299714,
-0.11722134053707123,
-0.18685537576675415,
0.5581315755844116,
0.13480214774608612,
-0.6836967468261719,
-0.455089271068573,
-0.5056471228599548,
-0.1181422770023346,
0.17239004373550415,
1.0940152406692505,
-0.7053082585334778,
0.33539050817489624,
0.4670540690422058,
0.6593197584152222,
0.7106114625930786,
-0.132661372423172,
0.7713178396224976,
-1.0065346956253052,
0.2114255726337433,
0.2567684054374695,
0.5107517838478088,
0.13936690986156464,
-0.5593165159225464,
0.4024318754673004,
0.23593275249004364,
-0.6014237403869629,
-0.37982940673828125,
0.13836121559143066,
-1.4861584901809692,
-0.23587478697299957,
0.9220421314239502,
-0.3208359181880951,
-0.013158434070646763,
-0.28066951036453247,
-0.3384251892566681,
0.30969053506851196,
-0.3732730746269226,
0.6360282301902771,
0.8113535046577454,
-0.2885923981666565,
-0.4906546175479889,
0.23756401240825653,
0.026464680209755898,
0.21879282593727112,
-0.7326582074165344,
0.24471190571784973,
0.45616811513900757,
0.1892431527376175,
0.3910360038280487,
0.392765074968338,
0.12956619262695312,
0.37900441884994507,
-0.10947582125663757,
0.3673027753829956,
0.21018069982528687,
-0.16171498596668243,
-0.25746652483940125,
0.3484974801540375,
-0.07972554862499237,
0.11221852153539658
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.02143v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.02143v1
|
Reinforcement Tuning for Detecting Stances and Debunking Rumors Jointly with Large Language Models
| 2024-06-04T09:31:18 | 2024-06-04T09:31:18 |
Ruichao Yang, Wei Gao, Jing Ma, Hongzhan Lin, Bo Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Learning multi-task models for jointly detecting stance and verifying rumors
poses challenges due to the need for training data of stance at post level and
rumor veracity at claim level, which are difficult to obtain. To address this
issue, we leverage large language models (LLMs) as the foundation annotators
for the joint stance detection (SD) and rumor verification (RV) tasks, dubbed
as JSDRV. We introduce a novel reinforcement tuning framework to enhance the
joint predictive capabilities of LLM-based SD and RV components. Specifically,
we devise a policy for selecting LLM-annotated data at the two levels,
employing a hybrid reward mechanism to choose high-quality labels for effective
LLM fine-tuning on both tasks. Results demonstrate that JSDRV improves the
capabilities of LLMs in the joint tasks, not only outperforming
state-of-the-art methods but also generalizing to non-LLMs accommodated as task
models.
|
[
-0.5307357311248779,
-0.8544681668281555,
0.5627806186676025,
0.2385677844285965,
-0.27720165252685547,
0.24983642995357513,
-0.39230111241340637,
-0.4473761320114136,
0.4002079367637634,
0.741036057472229,
-0.723280668258667,
-0.507090151309967,
-0.8581504821777344,
-0.19955196976661682,
-0.03468818962574005,
1.4641553163528442,
-0.18100814521312714,
-0.005689577199518681,
-0.1882787048816681,
-0.18924231827259064,
-0.4049622714519501,
-0.12734216451644897,
-0.6614990234375,
-0.31873825192451477,
0.6350289583206177,
0.3196091055870056,
0.6888640522956848,
0.6659659743309021,
0.2497216910123825,
0.30861982703208923,
-0.20407144725322723,
0.4651487171649933,
-0.3072534501552582,
0.456409215927124,
-0.31033581495285034,
-0.4463643729686737,
-0.36511871218681335,
-0.004625294823199511,
0.6564368605613708,
0.4004947245121002,
-0.1565624475479126,
0.1830180585384369,
-0.29589053988456726,
0.47207170724868774,
-0.7169752717018127,
0.17771631479263306,
-0.6747373342514038,
-0.2804764211177826,
-0.3251407742500305,
-0.28414928913116455,
-0.39702969789505005,
-0.1771351397037506,
-0.19757111370563507,
-0.5249513387680054,
0.1330237239599228,
0.23449581861495972,
0.9425191283226013,
0.49693089723587036,
-0.5427813529968262,
-0.1033656895160675,
-0.6790467500686646,
0.6652165651321411,
-0.5111760497093201,
0.43584075570106506,
0.2875061333179474,
0.13255268335342407,
-0.4732512831687927,
-0.2261286973953247,
-0.7148082852363586,
-0.5147297382354736,
0.07898508757352829,
0.04677535966038704,
0.06066577509045601,
0.17574700713157654,
0.41142112016677856,
0.20916378498077393,
-0.4401731789112091,
0.4740378260612488,
-0.16348561644554138,
-0.4369891583919525,
0.5873268842697144,
0.0023533145431429148,
0.10076013952493668,
-0.11484910547733307,
-0.5384947061538696,
-0.28388911485671997,
-0.7103589177131653,
0.206367626786232,
0.6301906704902649,
0.37532415986061096,
-0.05301656574010849,
0.5607704520225525,
-0.5778017044067383,
0.6372135281562805,
0.2411908656358719,
-0.5665330290794373,
0.3182017207145691,
-0.2764630913734436,
-0.11062227934598923,
0.2299775630235672,
0.6291919350624084,
0.23588304221630096,
-0.2826055586338043,
-0.31775274872779846,
-0.33484187722206116,
0.4639808237552643,
0.23114235699176788,
-0.4674370288848877,
-0.05656183138489723,
0.12073033303022385,
-0.37736237049102783,
-0.43011805415153503,
0.07300496101379395,
-0.6298269629478455,
-0.7585471272468567,
-0.5404639840126038,
0.46243035793304443,
-0.16151650249958038,
-0.8299093842506409,
0.2498319000005722,
-0.3630483150482178,
-0.03958690166473389,
0.34446343779563904,
-0.7693729400634766,
0.06335240602493286,
0.8522506356239319,
0.37482142448425293,
-0.1644354611635208,
-0.2819906771183014,
-0.9378737807273865,
0.470435231924057,
-0.4489009976387024,
0.9716513752937317,
-0.7218322157859802,
-0.29871267080307007,
-0.028157677501440048,
0.11278653144836426,
0.03907901048660278,
-0.33806538581848145,
0.747157096862793,
-0.5250969529151917,
-0.21732701361179352,
-0.42092302441596985,
-0.4979412257671356,
0.2028726488351822,
0.6190235018730164,
-0.7772023677825928,
1.101070761680603,
-0.048585906624794006,
-0.8464844226837158,
0.7133464813232422,
-0.3760448396205902,
-0.5462064743041992,
-0.07438967376947403,
-0.1884850561618805,
-0.496593713760376,
0.10182067006826401,
0.4483094811439514,
0.5840429663658142,
-0.11412101984024048,
0.21785856783390045,
-0.5189797282218933,
-0.3274444043636322,
0.30852410197257996,
-0.20374101400375366,
0.2797168493270874,
-0.01170254498720169,
-0.21016712486743927,
0.4617901146411896,
-0.6690438985824585,
-0.2554120123386383,
-0.24954789876937866,
-0.4427827298641205,
-0.5968866348266602,
0.04374135285615921,
-0.43937450647354126,
0.27731552720069885,
0.10119830071926117,
-0.7667943835258484,
0.3549214005470276,
-0.28997740149497986,
-0.007979705929756165,
0.7172841429710388,
0.2245481163263321,
0.3068418800830841,
-0.3428090810775757,
0.5830347537994385,
0.24275285005569458,
0.030241040512919426,
-0.01881011761724949,
-0.04908335208892822,
-0.8081508874893188,
-0.3301961123943329,
0.2151249349117279,
0.28186503052711487,
-1.1121196746826172,
0.23246073722839355,
-0.2078014314174652,
-0.40841054916381836,
-0.6097526550292969,
0.08757409453392029,
0.5321202874183655,
0.26834896206855774,
0.35949069261550903,
0.13019798696041107,
-0.6167988777160645,
-0.8760960102081299,
-0.4285910129547119,
-0.2628713846206665,
0.3562597334384918,
0.011945566162467003,
0.355469286441803,
0.16915684938430786,
0.6661792993545532,
-0.23644058406352997,
-0.25723493099212646,
-0.271456241607666,
0.6455866098403931,
0.019398421049118042,
0.34148022532463074,
0.38025182485580444,
-0.9662300944328308,
-0.29834944009780884,
-0.08294086903333664,
-0.30177566409111023,
0.25117331743240356,
-0.17660920321941376,
0.10587617754936218,
0.5179381370544434,
0.8354371786117554,
-0.7402342557907104,
0.1493426263332367,
0.6707163453102112,
-0.43939176201820374,
0.6236192584037781,
-0.12082862854003906,
0.46720078587532043,
-1.0565135478973389,
-0.39564579725265503,
0.4641405940055847,
-0.3843264579772949,
-0.24699324369430542,
-0.15866512060165405,
0.055545222014188766,
0.37547045946121216,
-0.2606503963470459,
0.24994432926177979,
-0.39972710609436035,
-0.05666818842291832,
-0.6324920058250427,
-0.0070212953723967075,
-0.22989487648010254,
0.35819172859191895,
0.19762080907821655,
0.579338014125824,
0.5796883702278137,
-0.7117505073547363,
0.34634122252464294,
-0.0209817998111248,
-0.40457937121391296,
0.73393315076828,
-0.4728058874607086,
-0.16299234330654144,
-0.3492474853992462,
0.7239539623260498,
-1.041007161140442,
-0.21819013357162476,
0.21083219349384308,
-0.4444223940372467,
0.3669506013393402,
-0.574469268321991,
-0.7001841068267822,
-0.49792712926864624,
-0.23154138028621674,
-0.19073224067687988,
0.3193233907222748,
-0.7515161037445068,
0.3990047574043274,
0.6993418335914612,
-0.05064190924167633,
-0.9122223854064941,
-0.40086084604263306,
-0.24077251553535461,
-0.232862189412117,
-0.31614071130752563,
0.5130623579025269,
0.2690200209617615,
-0.19452719390392303,
0.1252269446849823,
-0.5372870564460754,
0.1422947496175766,
-0.04542389139533043,
0.5740968585014343,
0.42127886414527893,
-0.04116659238934517,
0.22733573615550995,
0.36889028549194336,
-0.3152594268321991,
0.19754232466220856,
-0.20760688185691833,
0.20579753816127777,
-0.11198514699935913,
-0.3545004427433014,
-0.058643143624067307,
-0.1536470651626587,
0.6346508264541626,
-0.32269489765167236,
0.8809152245521545,
1.1344903707504272,
-0.05974730849266052,
-0.5631388425827026,
-0.8524592518806458,
-0.2261945903301239,
-0.458132266998291,
0.48215726017951965,
-0.49321603775024414,
-1.2829383611679077,
0.07534323632717133,
-0.49747806787490845,
-0.04625362902879715,
0.2889179587364197,
0.6968845725059509,
0.018834074959158897,
1.2224531173706055,
0.7220310568809509,
-0.24995987117290497,
0.37501493096351624,
0.11922558397054672,
0.018764927983283997,
-0.7010670304298401,
-0.24015241861343384,
-0.6068163514137268,
-0.19008027017116547,
-0.663118839263916,
-0.5859740376472473,
0.45230481028556824,
0.20474225282669067,
-0.01135460939258337,
0.2575870454311371,
-0.3038969039916992,
0.6696649193763733,
0.2900686264038086,
0.022840183228254318,
0.437633216381073,
-0.1750354915857315,
-0.15994784235954285,
-0.09182684123516083,
-0.2866547107696533,
-0.1347416341304779,
0.8346558213233948,
0.4523313045501709,
0.643561601638794,
0.07509540021419525,
0.5627153515815735,
0.220402330160141,
0.14239104092121124,
-0.5468222498893738,
0.6195870041847229,
-0.16005273163318634,
-0.566876232624054,
-0.42462971806526184,
-0.3361240029335022,
-0.5683481097221375,
0.3996904194355011,
-0.6357569694519043,
-0.702563464641571,
-0.11519709974527359,
0.27346521615982056,
-0.1888609677553177,
0.47480231523513794,
-0.17825433611869812,
0.7165069580078125,
0.0814911276102066,
-0.3130626678466797,
-0.9343562126159668,
-0.4861505329608917,
0.63630211353302,
0.3815540373325348,
0.19460417330265045,
-0.47118285298347473,
0.05100338160991669,
0.5598275661468506,
-0.05441805347800255,
0.904510498046875,
-0.48186635971069336,
-0.17137511074543,
-0.013641069643199444,
-0.020460376515984535,
0.9782494306564331,
0.5304670929908752,
-0.09712394326925278,
-0.24082206189632416,
0.060652464628219604,
-0.1381225883960724,
-0.41002580523490906,
0.9135591983795166,
-0.728471577167511,
-0.5383791923522949,
-0.5082411170005798,
-0.7769768238067627,
-0.6276705861091614,
-0.024374334141612053,
-0.03454623743891716,
0.08413347601890564,
-0.17441433668136597,
0.28698912262916565,
0.9786008596420288,
-0.1314171850681305,
0.31762945652008057,
0.8611218333244324,
-0.12573641538619995,
-0.1191026046872139,
1.0802525281906128,
-0.2270682007074356,
0.0328594408929348,
0.42750099301338196,
0.02581794001162052,
-0.4287359118461609,
-0.7266950011253357,
-0.39051657915115356,
0.18702031672000885,
-0.5540029406547546,
-0.22893787920475006,
-0.5312228798866272,
-0.06419055908918381,
-0.30440428853034973,
0.1614375114440918,
-0.7168930172920227,
-0.3545280396938324,
0.27866366505622864,
-0.28286629915237427,
0.5830464363098145,
0.6898608803749084,
-0.07047633081674576,
0.04440619796514511,
-0.6334416270256042,
0.5631075501441956,
0.11895827203989029,
0.5145866870880127,
-0.5000995397567749,
-0.3307023048400879,
-0.32233214378356934,
0.08047161251306534,
-0.023730356246232986,
-0.4485456645488739,
0.1335078328847885,
-0.44470784068107605,
0.6328730583190918,
0.11453861743211746,
0.3067018389701843,
0.6956418752670288,
-0.10354246944189072,
0.5941594839096069,
0.27863121032714844,
-0.79795902967453,
0.5430272817611694,
-0.5826612114906311,
-0.16996245086193085,
0.5410504937171936,
0.49050962924957275,
-0.4502749443054199,
-0.6679306626319885,
-0.5067234039306641,
-0.6982793211936951,
0.7738932371139526,
-0.25158631801605225,
-0.09971194714307785,
-0.012928576208651066,
0.20852090418338776,
0.18056704103946686,
0.37398239970207214,
-0.6538100242614746,
-0.15361091494560242,
0.049459461122751236,
0.02507450245320797,
0.07508660107851028,
-0.22182591259479523,
-0.31041795015335083,
-0.2794179618358612,
0.9294684529304504,
-0.2671563923358917,
-0.12866179645061493,
-0.08740134537220001,
-0.24868246912956238,
-0.4624844491481781,
0.6021706461906433,
0.5171927809715271,
0.5482258796691895,
-0.1065719947218895,
0.038671694695949554,
0.23824594914913177,
-0.06995385140180588,
0.11336934566497803,
0.14518889784812927,
-0.1299278885126114,
-0.05316514894366264,
0.088072270154953,
1.3029247522354126,
0.38081979751586914,
-0.5280792713165283,
0.5691801309585571,
0.013865361921489239,
-0.5499957203865051,
-0.2966349422931671,
0.24912945926189423,
0.15582922101020813,
0.6116829514503479,
-0.023104222491383553,
0.18318355083465576,
-0.16460470855236053,
-0.3063957691192627,
0.0774756595492363,
0.6299383640289307,
-0.36934375762939453,
-0.1691635549068451,
0.5010625123977661,
0.09814221411943436,
0.30654269456863403,
0.22946061193943024,
-0.4195387661457062,
-0.2912701964378357,
0.5095655918121338,
0.571212112903595,
0.3464907109737396,
0.016246045008301735,
0.6660639047622681,
0.32316651940345764,
0.15097153186798096,
-0.5315564274787903,
0.18051311373710632,
0.07318135350942612,
-0.8983388543128967,
-0.8998576998710632,
-0.6998361349105835,
-0.480756938457489,
0.4368557333946228,
-0.7967610955238342,
0.3207520842552185,
-0.42333751916885376,
-0.01879330910742283,
0.16528773307800293,
0.12301888316869736,
-0.362870454788208,
0.0690910741686821,
0.4547623097896576,
0.6747338771820068,
-1.0441944599151611,
1.223594307899475,
0.8885990381240845,
-0.39452582597732544,
-0.9694132208824158,
0.21917937695980072,
0.15706585347652435,
-0.5810054540634155,
0.7295821309089661,
0.05185355246067047,
-0.235530823469162,
-0.13752321898937225,
-0.34109124541282654,
-0.9348822236061096,
1.0384703874588013,
0.3738533854484558,
-0.725834310054779,
0.13628347218036652,
-0.06986114382743835,
0.47898590564727783,
-0.15290483832359314,
-0.032443076372146606,
0.5235900282859802,
0.6739218831062317,
0.2762213349342346,
-1.0903866291046143,
0.1564025580883026,
0.16886059939861298,
-0.005462176166474819,
0.4892047941684723,
-0.808236300945282,
0.7808145880699158,
-0.14232490956783295,
0.18640726804733276,
-0.14070437848567963,
0.9725164175033569,
0.6018564701080322,
0.1398390233516693,
1.0614513158798218,
0.6533988118171692,
0.7862772345542908,
-0.16910892724990845,
0.9687254428863525,
-0.2118397355079651,
0.07430919259786606,
1.0234196186065674,
-0.40382131934165955,
0.7555935978889465,
0.5034254193305969,
0.016409633681178093,
0.7208338379859924,
0.4271363615989685,
-0.19160908460617065,
0.4054117500782013,
0.24945104122161865,
-0.20217519998550415,
-0.6945316195487976,
-0.44881123304367065,
-0.1652822494506836,
0.4342844486236572,
0.6139463186264038,
-0.06744558364152908,
-0.1976836770772934,
0.17742863297462463,
0.16388702392578125,
0.24842001497745514,
-0.6647511124610901,
0.6292844414710999,
-0.2173248529434204,
-1.1381711959838867,
0.19266287982463837,
0.3145560622215271,
0.9180747866630554,
-0.710202693939209,
0.028381070122122765,
0.23644967377185822,
0.4032716155052185,
-0.19458504021167755,
-0.7401936054229736,
0.2665073275566101,
-0.24951308965682983,
-0.32492998242378235,
-0.3692931532859802,
0.9646042585372925,
-0.7387064099311829,
-0.18874922394752502,
0.28034672141075134,
0.3208346664905548,
-0.3338090181350708,
-0.036400433629751205,
-0.6934747099876404,
0.440938264131546,
-0.22041364014148712,
-0.4324384331703186,
0.7315725684165955,
0.36581987142562866,
-0.29093798995018005,
0.4834838807582855,
0.8367119431495667,
0.365459144115448,
-0.2668854892253876,
0.2952163517475128,
1.0364052057266235,
-0.505594789981842,
-0.6590093970298767,
-0.7111991047859192,
0.46730396151542664,
-0.24449492990970612,
-0.17702627182006836,
0.8999423384666443,
0.2264302670955658,
0.8222275376319885,
0.089547298848629,
0.808607280254364,
-0.06530154496431351,
0.9032765626907349,
-0.7891544103622437,
0.4190674424171448,
-0.38006260991096497,
0.2329212874174118,
-0.2451511025428772,
-0.5575673580169678,
-0.01954147033393383,
0.5327886939048767,
-0.36489275097846985,
-0.2180982381105423,
0.6754403710365295,
0.9895070195198059,
0.009260252118110657,
0.1651712954044342,
-0.03476553410291672,
0.3221072852611542,
0.25597500801086426,
0.31346073746681213,
0.7788235545158386,
0.012366019189357758,
0.6977269053459167,
-0.20157723128795624,
0.04856874421238899,
-0.1572614461183548,
-1.0187678337097168,
-1.1945620775222778,
-0.5290199518203735,
-0.6263443827629089,
-0.738660991191864,
0.2747955918312073,
1.016539216041565,
0.8719252347946167,
-0.7103583216667175,
0.07861749827861786,
-0.18702472746372223,
0.1725553274154663,
-0.4306560754776001,
-0.2010062038898468,
0.11621362715959549,
-0.5112027525901794,
-0.5164922475814819,
0.806126594543457,
0.2880931496620178,
-0.17733775079250336,
-0.3599053621292114,
-0.2849726974964142,
-0.14740605652332306,
-0.07714720815420151,
0.2896955907344818,
0.4008849561214447,
-0.7818575501441956,
-0.39517539739608765,
-0.29622742533683777,
-0.11686813086271286,
-0.3621038496494293,
1.0302046537399292,
-0.8758026957511902,
0.09242478758096695,
0.428628534078598,
0.6999417543411255,
0.8376704454421997,
0.04745236411690712,
0.5792549252510071,
-1.201783537864685,
0.44005781412124634,
0.024497488513588905,
0.24740560352802277,
0.14968271553516388,
-0.3571045696735382,
0.1996312290430069,
0.09573761373758316,
-0.3960466980934143,
-0.9887208938598633,
0.3117397427558899,
-1.029496669769287,
-0.5110357403755188,
1.3512696027755737,
0.04329261556267738,
-0.19492791593074799,
-0.14077338576316833,
-0.03462102264165878,
0.3491787612438202,
-0.4572286009788513,
0.711393415927887,
0.7684504985809326,
0.026732757687568665,
-0.25559091567993164,
-0.46271979808807373,
0.9011304974555969,
0.5055829286575317,
-0.632660984992981,
0.2034761607646942,
0.5024042725563049,
0.29679057002067566,
0.07171764224767685,
0.6274190545082092,
0.08250197023153305,
0.3769918382167816,
-0.034614477306604385,
-0.027750881388783455,
-0.5484923124313354,
-0.4622225761413574,
-0.044045258313417435,
0.12957388162612915,
0.1946813464164734,
-0.09984217584133148
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.02135v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.02135v1
|
Robust Interaction-based Relevance Modeling for Online E-Commerce and LLM-based Retrieval
| 2024-06-04T09:24:04 | 2024-06-04T09:24:04 |
Ben Chen, Huangyu Dai, Xiang Ma, Wen Jiang, Wei Ning
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.CL
|
Semantic relevance calculation is crucial for e-commerce search engines, as
it ensures that the items selected closely align with customer intent.
Inadequate attention to this aspect can detrimentally affect user experience
and engagement. Traditional text-matching techniques are prevalent but often
fail to capture the nuances of search intent accurately, so neural networks now
have become a preferred solution to processing such complex text matching.
Existing methods predominantly employ representation-based architectures, which
strike a balance between high traffic capacity and low latency. However, they
exhibit significant shortcomings in generalization and robustness when compared
to interaction-based architectures. In this work, we introduce a robust
interaction-based modeling paradigm to address these shortcomings. It
encompasses 1) a dynamic length representation scheme for expedited inference,
2) a professional terms recognition method to identify subjects and core
attributes from complex sentence structures, and 3) a contrastive adversarial
training protocol to bolster the model's robustness and matching capabilities.
Extensive offline evaluations demonstrate the superior robustness and
effectiveness of our approach, and online A/B testing confirms its ability to
improve relevance in the same exposure position, resulting in more clicks and
conversions. To the best of our knowledge, this method is the first
interaction-based approach for large e-commerce search relevance calculation.
Notably, we have deployed it for the entire search traffic on alibaba.com, the
largest B2B e-commerce platform in the world.
|
[
-0.2790868878364563,
-0.9853051900863647,
0.7144875526428223,
0.1536470204591751,
-0.22747759521007538,
0.03443983569741249,
-0.16710686683654785,
-0.9356697201728821,
0.4089150130748749,
0.13175159692764282,
-0.420789510011673,
-0.2906748950481415,
-0.28057861328125,
-0.13951577246189117,
-0.3499401807785034,
0.5708240270614624,
0.20421545207500458,
-0.24226246774196625,
-0.5217169523239136,
-0.2370922714471817,
-0.000023914288249216042,
-0.7231864929199219,
-0.5878371000289917,
0.07878702133893967,
0.5985510349273682,
-0.2299702763557434,
0.8160130977630615,
0.48048797249794006,
0.7464300990104675,
0.3768974840641022,
-0.3954046070575714,
0.3810459077358246,
-0.5619528889656067,
0.3807307481765747,
-0.13980694115161896,
-0.3235137164592743,
-0.5783387422561646,
-0.1270454376935959,
0.20670422911643982,
0.7779597043991089,
-0.2759341597557068,
0.017600778490304947,
0.10592665523290634,
0.24005286395549774,
-0.6670944094657898,
-0.021123867481946945,
-0.7566995024681091,
-0.09160348027944565,
0.020838357508182526,
-0.30001404881477356,
-0.5080927610397339,
-0.058749664574861526,
0.27950650453567505,
-0.7189883589744568,
-0.13942427933216095,
0.23864132165908813,
1.0170862674713135,
0.09793782234191895,
-0.6365728974342346,
-0.2527937889099121,
-0.6091729998588562,
0.9003685116767883,
-0.7351716160774231,
0.5529726147651672,
0.3257993757724762,
0.2308412343263626,
-0.25394144654273987,
-0.912418007850647,
-0.2470254749059677,
-0.4309569299221039,
-0.22167439758777618,
0.2875731289386749,
-0.06309308111667633,
0.2658572494983673,
0.3323966860771179,
0.3749200403690338,
-0.3413655459880829,
0.08372128754854202,
0.05101846903562546,
-0.03719671070575714,
0.518795371055603,
0.19787836074829102,
0.18494682013988495,
0.13008663058280945,
-0.41085299849510193,
0.0953124389052391,
-0.5690861344337463,
0.3051545321941376,
0.3744218945503235,
0.3452228605747223,
-0.03720661252737045,
0.47950980067253113,
-0.4142955243587494,
0.8505367636680603,
0.2086629718542099,
-0.08411098271608353,
0.0824725329875946,
-0.5579703450202942,
-0.03393331915140152,
-0.3191090226173401,
0.6050770282745361,
0.350343257188797,
-0.2872669994831085,
-0.18592438101768494,
-0.17030693590641022,
-0.20763623714447021,
0.4931722581386566,
-0.6947757601737976,
0.15243591368198395,
0.22053614258766174,
-0.7583702206611633,
-0.24595528841018677,
0.22993586957454681,
-0.8194704651832581,
-0.10934608429670334,
-0.19656497240066528,
0.6918376684188843,
0.059526942670345306,
0.030684126541018486,
-0.004116115625947714,
0.23702247440814972,
0.2612161934375763,
0.34168538451194763,
-0.6708783507347107,
0.2580203413963318,
0.619897723197937,
0.747283935546875,
-0.20669743418693542,
0.14118415117263794,
-0.7110891342163086,
0.10808705538511276,
-0.010570242069661617,
0.42416492104530334,
-0.6220793724060059,
0.008069759234786034,
0.21017953753471375,
-0.253577321767807,
-0.0034370634239166975,
-0.4394613206386566,
0.6248809695243835,
-1.1892642974853516,
-0.07642868161201477,
0.03455225005745888,
-0.6934987306594849,
-0.1848512589931488,
0.5709803104400635,
-0.913040816783905,
0.9796940088272095,
-0.10399311035871506,
-0.6958129405975342,
0.24722644686698914,
-0.5572237372398376,
-0.4708220958709717,
-0.01264217495918274,
-0.039658963680267334,
-0.7306623458862305,
0.05035237595438957,
0.004935522563755512,
0.42116716504096985,
-0.2088245004415512,
0.20128928124904633,
-0.7332869172096252,
-0.574641227722168,
0.31022775173187256,
-0.4746020436286926,
0.4511900842189789,
0.26636457443237305,
-0.2875027358531952,
0.06779526174068451,
-0.7133597135543823,
0.08992300182580948,
0.005440061446279287,
-0.46481946110725403,
-0.27250781655311584,
0.1364394873380661,
0.24094624817371368,
0.3531583845615387,
0.6328878402709961,
-0.36334502696990967,
0.03246859833598137,
-0.4509066939353943,
0.3925469219684601,
0.44954395294189453,
0.033563967794179916,
0.21073901653289795,
-0.3059743046760559,
0.41405153274536133,
-0.0029836606699973345,
0.2220194786787033,
-0.3090580105781555,
-0.5329344868659973,
-0.5824587941169739,
-0.009380979463458061,
0.48562973737716675,
0.5222238898277283,
-0.6612111330032349,
0.6228119730949402,
-0.41174301505088806,
-0.32039761543273926,
-0.23923730850219727,
0.061522990465164185,
0.09036555886268616,
0.3894038498401642,
0.4466264843940735,
-0.4043042063713074,
-0.24200260639190674,
-0.7855803370475769,
-0.38773313164711,
-0.21719993650913239,
-0.16594348847866058,
0.5925266146659851,
0.054445333778858185,
-0.18709412217140198,
0.824835479259491,
-0.3695022165775299,
-0.17686064541339874,
-0.25203630328178406,
-0.016969159245491028,
0.35267144441604614,
0.22484038770198822,
0.3897029459476471,
-1.2782368659973145,
-0.5314857363700867,
0.06670358031988144,
-0.5018709301948547,
0.014021920040249825,
-0.1715826392173767,
-0.17789511382579803,
0.014993652701377869,
0.3723861277103424,
-0.4640207290649414,
0.712114155292511,
0.1695275753736496,
-0.06346582621335983,
0.15367576479911804,
-0.2975861430168152,
0.36719006299972534,
-1.0496563911437988,
0.33005210757255554,
0.22689293324947357,
-0.4653007984161377,
-0.6674833297729492,
0.32428669929504395,
0.08684337884187698,
0.06729267537593842,
-0.6523573994636536,
0.41046226024627686,
-0.23069295287132263,
-0.25503671169281006,
-0.23308835923671722,
0.24750079214572906,
0.37587770819664,
0.4813656806945801,
-0.0004238176916260272,
0.6599858403205872,
0.1531643271446228,
-0.8834991455078125,
0.2765761911869049,
0.2625199258327484,
-0.23559102416038513,
0.5354049205780029,
-0.4675995111465454,
-0.006011940538883209,
0.24715466797351837,
0.01083255372941494,
-0.743442177772522,
-0.19714106619358063,
0.11571642756462097,
-0.3664416968822479,
0.24387305974960327,
-0.16167733073234558,
-0.6875747442245483,
-0.2221696525812149,
-0.4124097228050232,
0.6592941880226135,
0.3213484585285187,
-0.657084584236145,
0.9902809262275696,
0.25275975465774536,
-0.14108119904994965,
-0.41810858249664307,
-0.7245793342590332,
0.1521947830915451,
-0.2724003493785858,
-0.758825421333313,
0.7154715061187744,
-0.2019743174314499,
-0.046312544494867325,
-0.173142209649086,
-0.05241365730762482,
-0.20014630258083344,
0.5086363554000854,
-0.2447035312652588,
0.3280237317085266,
0.015499626286327839,
-0.062074944376945496,
-0.01842910796403885,
0.11380074918270111,
-0.10625433921813965,
0.09913450479507446,
0.39951157569885254,
0.08539310842752457,
-0.7441960573196411,
-0.487101674079895,
0.4484643042087555,
0.47017714381217957,
-0.1478843241930008,
0.8178824782371521,
0.4285113215446472,
-0.5467602014541626,
0.20020990073680878,
-0.5486578345298767,
-0.3289089798927307,
-0.5490202903747559,
0.5075461268424988,
-0.2913821339607239,
-0.8654152750968933,
0.7509828805923462,
-0.16016486287117004,
-0.21460914611816406,
0.14536568522453308,
0.40169596672058105,
-0.011686919257044792,
1.214815616607666,
0.5384684801101685,
0.05666663870215416,
0.4849770963191986,
0.2707103192806244,
0.667876124382019,
-0.9471496343612671,
-0.5447310209274292,
-0.3708338141441345,
-0.365254282951355,
-0.8043551445007324,
-0.08669888973236084,
0.1884981244802475,
0.15669205784797668,
-0.1587594598531723,
0.31797266006469727,
-0.27049559354782104,
0.09805819392204285,
0.5760110020637512,
0.5030395984649658,
0.22897565364837646,
0.1536029577255249,
-0.15866601467132568,
-0.1531064808368683,
-0.5199154019355774,
-0.2630522847175598,
0.924351155757904,
0.2502829134464264,
0.7785392999649048,
0.430418461561203,
0.2640154957771301,
0.27226194739341736,
0.07714641839265823,
-0.9280350804328918,
0.5807249546051025,
0.07629556208848953,
-0.3768143653869629,
0.05471537262201309,
-0.6767110228538513,
-1.0519663095474243,
0.20817658305168152,
-0.2307569831609726,
-0.8658761978149414,
0.10445372760295868,
0.15345384180545807,
-0.397757351398468,
0.30003073811531067,
-0.3563798666000366,
0.6969628930091858,
-0.68623286485672,
-1.1266114711761475,
-0.1540704369544983,
-0.7908920049667358,
-0.14086946845054626,
-0.022341780364513397,
0.13056115806102753,
0.24902646243572235,
-0.32590529322624207,
0.28340405225753784,
-0.2073713093996048,
0.5217587351799011,
0.26430848240852356,
0.047539062798023224,
0.05943286418914795,
0.14341329038143158,
0.6953927874565125,
-0.04521305486559868,
-0.26250404119491577,
-0.09136009216308594,
-0.29798027873039246,
-0.4431569576263428,
-0.676482081413269,
0.7297033667564392,
-0.23104749619960785,
-0.6196267604827881,
-0.37872377038002014,
-0.3209657669067383,
-0.2843422591686249,
0.2940613627433777,
-0.016211755573749542,
0.18433119356632233,
-0.2497694492340088,
0.43561023473739624,
0.6227927803993225,
-0.20603367686271667,
0.5078726410865784,
0.3812183439731598,
-0.20382429659366608,
-0.39717477560043335,
0.7307897806167603,
-0.06508222967386246,
0.2131137102842331,
0.5879083275794983,
-0.09953530877828598,
-0.5487772226333618,
-0.3883114159107208,
-0.19610252976417542,
-0.07572035491466522,
-0.7687781453132629,
-0.278333455324173,
-0.6003149747848511,
-0.18415279686450958,
-0.22262249886989594,
-0.03252190724015236,
-0.057272326201200485,
-0.0895906537771225,
-0.6084368228912354,
0.018118293955922127,
0.17210426926612854,
0.5071216821670532,
0.11834213137626648,
0.036466099321842194,
-0.7346206903457642,
0.1304786503314972,
0.2742828130722046,
0.6482546925544739,
0.18777093291282654,
-0.4634513854980469,
-0.5093201994895935,
0.032615285366773605,
-0.5049344301223755,
-0.6884452104568481,
0.36902084946632385,
0.32548174262046814,
0.7375301718711853,
0.6162499189376831,
0.20011107623577118,
0.5394925475120544,
-0.11955633014440536,
0.8251875638961792,
-0.06910444796085358,
-0.7991938591003418,
0.44056272506713867,
-0.25808247923851013,
-0.11311603337526321,
0.5895722508430481,
0.5562084317207336,
-0.32009023427963257,
-0.044716015458106995,
-0.5494081377983093,
-1.3113230466842651,
0.5847365260124207,
0.4822278618812561,
0.22128409147262573,
-0.004064102657139301,
0.504809558391571,
-0.1941845715045929,
0.4638398587703705,
-0.7476068139076233,
-0.1948942244052887,
0.06137276813387871,
-0.5002089738845825,
0.45638447999954224,
-0.18085800111293793,
0.1823517233133316,
-0.03238546475768089,
0.7315273880958557,
-0.16762351989746094,
0.4057867228984833,
0.1059066653251648,
-0.2317129522562027,
0.28684908151626587,
0.07725438475608826,
0.4202161729335785,
0.6817034482955933,
-0.2098166048526764,
-0.016369055956602097,
0.08439619094133377,
-0.28073713183403015,
0.06430333852767944,
0.349983274936676,
-0.18665224313735962,
-0.31094852089881897,
0.11930130422115326,
0.5647872686386108,
0.33453524112701416,
-0.7902154326438904,
0.7630773186683655,
-0.11005023866891861,
0.30533358454704285,
-0.1879115104675293,
-0.07300150394439697,
0.03469756990671158,
0.1943974494934082,
0.3719289302825928,
-0.010213521309196949,
0.6808707118034363,
-0.4200490713119507,
0.47272929549217224,
0.5520876049995422,
-0.4561246931552887,
-0.12494544684886932,
0.8684656620025635,
0.22469542920589447,
-0.29773589968681335,
0.576093852519989,
-0.1316448450088501,
-0.7118310332298279,
0.7322173118591309,
0.3883949816226959,
0.5414209365844727,
-0.07080667465925217,
-0.21608680486679077,
0.268440306186676,
-0.0390680655837059,
-0.14358903467655182,
0.11697129160165787,
-0.1744697242975235,
-0.43743637204170227,
-0.34248510003089905,
-0.5397528409957886,
-0.6181207299232483,
0.18639680743217468,
-0.8748397827148438,
0.42308059334754944,
-0.15782971680164337,
-0.3603447675704956,
-0.3559221029281616,
0.14214569330215454,
-0.5903362035751343,
0.2029164880514145,
0.05418410524725914,
0.6038384437561035,
-0.4606383144855499,
0.3929705321788788,
0.7573803663253784,
-0.5216510891914368,
-0.45852920413017273,
0.24464312195777893,
-0.21822014451026917,
-0.28675374388694763,
0.16994887590408325,
0.6064615249633789,
-0.08007138222455978,
-0.0950574278831482,
-0.2749282419681549,
-0.825721263885498,
1.28829026222229,
0.29341351985931396,
-0.5513735413551331,
0.297999769449234,
0.1727839857339859,
0.6114660501480103,
-0.4802897870540619,
0.702585756778717,
0.14525607228279114,
0.24676541984081268,
0.11372558772563934,
-0.7134535312652588,
0.04714079573750496,
-0.41241422295570374,
0.18606406450271606,
0.04757064953446388,
-0.8192750215530396,
0.4349503219127655,
0.252727210521698,
-0.08896958082914352,
0.5538946986198425,
0.5904083251953125,
0.2939346432685852,
0.48275700211524963,
0.33313795924186707,
0.699941873550415,
0.6801795363426208,
-0.025845712050795555,
0.8742115497589111,
-0.6082333326339722,
0.591584324836731,
0.9312507510185242,
-0.5699008107185364,
1.1566035747528076,
0.3755589425563812,
-0.14116282761096954,
0.383639395236969,
0.904961884021759,
0.031176786869764328,
0.5312062501907349,
0.06222530081868172,
-0.40138864517211914,
-0.5810920000076294,
-0.2169686108827591,
-0.22842727601528168,
0.05645178630948067,
0.39295241236686707,
-0.45979946851730347,
0.04670495167374611,
-0.19411776959896088,
-0.33713746070861816,
0.19871895015239716,
-0.34370866417884827,
0.809337854385376,
0.0692310780286789,
-0.426239013671875,
0.09648165851831436,
0.003994114696979523,
0.7869588732719421,
-0.4523792862892151,
-0.16425734758377075,
-0.06843256950378418,
0.13011084496974945,
-0.13611619174480438,
-0.5812982320785522,
0.1552925854921341,
-0.38921627402305603,
-0.0800979733467102,
0.039358951151371,
0.972490131855011,
-0.45259037613868713,
-0.3615454137325287,
0.735375702381134,
0.41719943284988403,
-0.12198714911937714,
-0.054970111697912216,
-0.7071056962013245,
0.1086701899766922,
-0.23804637789726257,
-0.4458848834037781,
0.5557249784469604,
0.19717605412006378,
0.1337725669145584,
0.7381119728088379,
0.5919690132141113,
-0.3107263743877411,
0.007294632028788328,
-0.16657890379428864,
0.8706753849983215,
-0.5089005827903748,
-0.6945255398750305,
-0.6165117025375366,
0.5143588781356812,
-0.39117369055747986,
0.1939096450805664,
0.3725581467151642,
0.6901336312294006,
0.7306163311004639,
0.3035615086555481,
0.6177973747253418,
0.13691474497318268,
0.22716309130191803,
-0.4170266091823578,
0.6750554442405701,
-0.9335002899169922,
0.5300286412239075,
0.017534960061311722,
-1.106145977973938,
-0.39023658633232117,
0.6925853490829468,
-0.06459002196788788,
0.5071819424629211,
0.40484338998794556,
0.6536272764205933,
-0.5931456089019775,
-0.1791544258594513,
0.5394989252090454,
0.18802206218242645,
0.26565998792648315,
0.4018505811691284,
0.5340310335159302,
-0.5611841082572937,
0.8041375875473022,
-0.048030007630586624,
-0.1318318396806717,
-0.6745418310165405,
-1.1039503812789917,
-0.6652331352233887,
-0.3491353988647461,
-0.30714067816734314,
-0.43711423873901367,
0.07879097014665604,
1.1359184980392456,
0.7419680953025818,
-0.5599834322929382,
-0.06932797282934189,
0.014570886269211769,
-0.1432981789112091,
-0.23092712461948395,
-0.22293774783611298,
0.3106962740421295,
-0.20081065595149994,
-0.6135322451591492,
0.3524864614009857,
0.41997599601745605,
0.16554869711399078,
-0.16197872161865234,
-0.0606071874499321,
-0.41777077317237854,
0.2941542863845825,
0.6315798759460449,
0.10282358527183533,
-0.720835268497467,
-0.3072923421859741,
0.24829673767089844,
-0.08678857237100601,
0.3093027174472809,
0.479809045791626,
-0.7245481014251709,
0.5215950012207031,
0.506313681602478,
1.149940013885498,
0.5492373704910278,
0.15242400765419006,
0.4228661060333252,
-0.5651190876960754,
-0.035104189068078995,
0.30023783445358276,
0.4292488694190979,
0.44542187452316284,
-0.6271907687187195,
0.36974087357521057,
0.10018585622310638,
-0.6417775750160217,
-0.576056957244873,
0.4812743365764618,
-1.1504260301589966,
-0.01726479083299637,
0.8971609473228455,
-0.5605728626251221,
-0.30115368962287903,
-0.269805908203125,
0.07498437166213989,
0.20840850472450256,
-0.430836021900177,
0.9753210544586182,
0.5797176361083984,
-0.18729013204574585,
-0.16458140313625336,
-0.22197069227695465,
0.009795119054615498,
0.5524983406066895,
-0.7113193869590759,
-0.38081955909729004,
0.22039659321308136,
-0.02743043564260006,
0.18481415510177612,
0.05157924070954323,
0.08944271504878998,
0.29406723380088806,
-0.39191871881484985,
-0.21061694622039795,
0.030730199068784714,
-0.1688399463891983,
-0.27001193165779114,
0.2828269898891449,
0.19439512491226196,
0.09744233638048172
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.02134v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.02134v1
|
The current status of large language models in summarizing radiology report impressions
| 2024-06-04T09:23:30 | 2024-06-04T09:23:30 |
Danqing Hu, Shanyuan Zhang, Qing Liu, Xiaofeng Zhu, Bing Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) like ChatGPT show excellent capabilities in
various natural language processing tasks, especially for text generation. The
effectiveness of LLMs in summarizing radiology report impressions remains
unclear. In this study, we explore the capability of eight LLMs on the
radiology report impression summarization. Three types of radiology reports,
i.e., CT, PET-CT, and Ultrasound reports, are collected from Peking University
Cancer Hospital and Institute. We use the report findings to construct the
zero-shot, one-shot, and three-shot prompts with complete example reports to
generate the impressions. Besides the automatic quantitative evaluation
metrics, we define five human evaluation metrics, i.e., completeness,
correctness, conciseness, verisimilitude, and replaceability, to evaluate the
semantics of the generated impressions. Two thoracic surgeons (ZSY and LB) and
one radiologist (LQ) compare the generated impressions with the reference
impressions and score each impression under the five human evaluation metrics.
Experimental results show that there is a gap between the generated impressions
and reference impressions. Although the LLMs achieve comparable performance in
completeness and correctness, the conciseness and verisimilitude scores are not
very high. Using few-shot prompts can improve the LLMs' performance in
conciseness and verisimilitude, but the clinicians still think the LLMs can not
replace the radiologists in summarizing the radiology impressions.
|
[
-0.3669952154159546,
-0.3169287145137787,
0.98201584815979,
0.317182332277298,
-0.41034382581710815,
0.11132612824440002,
-0.24694721400737762,
-0.6864222288131714,
0.41479381918907166,
0.43842530250549316,
-0.021850604563951492,
-0.50213623046875,
-0.694179117679596,
0.47761908173561096,
-0.07941783219575882,
1.0530691146850586,
0.20023496448993683,
0.37089329957962036,
-0.1112910807132721,
-0.02492869831621647,
-0.48576802015304565,
-0.027391841635107994,
-0.40029674768447876,
-0.438094824552536,
0.5394056439399719,
0.16449898481369019,
0.984990656375885,
0.4257160425186157,
0.7823376655578613,
0.23603467643260956,
-0.15975181758403778,
0.3487241268157959,
-0.2928836941719055,
-0.2550211548805237,
0.06034809350967407,
-0.19091938436031342,
-0.5030865669250488,
-0.16685953736305237,
0.7785460948944092,
0.7892892360687256,
-0.07606435567140579,
-0.11169739812612534,
0.005040479823946953,
0.7275298237800598,
-0.4183143079280853,
0.04014572128653526,
-0.18595321476459503,
0.23178982734680176,
0.12148770689964294,
-0.6793143153190613,
-0.5895715355873108,
-0.49783116579055786,
0.35949018597602844,
-0.348842054605484,
-0.1186557486653328,
-0.10915341973304749,
0.8464974164962769,
-0.28440648317337036,
-0.3657851219177246,
-0.48672640323638916,
-0.7281724214553833,
0.5609583258628845,
-0.941996157169342,
0.03571658208966255,
0.0769151970744133,
0.4410451650619507,
0.027530960738658905,
-0.8041005730628967,
-0.22191528975963593,
-0.4411374032497406,
-0.5638574957847595,
0.43575361371040344,
-0.2876691222190857,
0.26539185643196106,
0.2099127173423767,
0.6276625990867615,
-0.526459276676178,
0.213151216506958,
-0.47033101320266724,
-0.2502860426902771,
0.6379185318946838,
0.5692152380943298,
0.553802490234375,
-0.5757520794868469,
-0.37673625349998474,
-0.11796639859676361,
-0.7269366383552551,
-0.2139972597360611,
-0.10894171893596649,
0.13621753454208374,
-0.23623350262641907,
0.4198470115661621,
-0.42294785380363464,
0.6929118633270264,
-0.07259979099035263,
-0.6786940693855286,
0.34337368607521057,
-0.35665231943130493,
-0.4439028799533844,
-0.026750730350613594,
1.1997759342193604,
0.653975248336792,
0.1436236947774887,
-0.01762262172996998,
-0.16462089121341705,
-0.22675397992134094,
0.15569806098937988,
-0.7918674945831299,
0.17503735423088074,
0.23429986834526062,
-0.6453605890274048,
-0.5788360238075256,
0.1353835016489029,
-0.28492382168769836,
-0.6368569135665894,
-0.12698298692703247,
0.39675572514533997,
-0.6835372447967529,
-0.020248522982001305,
0.3813258707523346,
0.08483856171369553,
0.361167848110199,
0.7657864689826965,
-0.3524375259876251,
0.3273836076259613,
0.5111011266708374,
0.8782592415809631,
0.06470498442649841,
-0.23778559267520905,
-0.32131823897361755,
0.03931383788585663,
-0.3999691903591156,
0.9833164811134338,
-0.20301553606987,
-0.7294889092445374,
0.019573237746953964,
-0.1469958871603012,
-0.04670510068535805,
-0.6189475059509277,
0.23794099688529968,
-0.2631770372390747,
0.5050063133239746,
-0.20662659406661987,
-0.4606042206287384,
-0.22386020421981812,
0.353839635848999,
-0.341376394033432,
0.4153175354003906,
0.09578223526477814,
-0.7314016819000244,
0.29212886095046997,
-0.2932932674884796,
-0.571321964263916,
0.36123913526535034,
-0.4792218506336212,
-0.1894984394311905,
0.15527620911598206,
0.42769813537597656,
0.6551845073699951,
-0.36856481432914734,
0.2027280628681183,
0.3078449070453644,
-0.40192142128944397,
0.4270634651184082,
-0.1718151867389679,
0.5795140862464905,
0.17560088634490967,
0.10720702260732651,
-0.006265475880354643,
-0.29256775975227356,
0.032415881752967834,
0.0021295533515512943,
-0.391131192445755,
0.07501401007175446,
-0.2577016353607178,
-0.1974104642868042,
0.17543573677539825,
0.1020781621336937,
-0.46108654141426086,
0.2403658926486969,
-0.6450382471084595,
0.13459864258766174,
0.3520321547985077,
0.574583113193512,
0.07833831012248993,
-0.7507302165031433,
0.7697194814682007,
-0.16330522298812866,
-0.07722458243370056,
-0.579755961894989,
-0.3610288202762604,
-0.6633069515228271,
-0.4962952733039856,
0.1740274429321289,
0.38494953513145447,
-0.6925527453422546,
-0.10104170441627502,
-0.6783575415611267,
-0.7222065925598145,
-0.37791234254837036,
-0.21910448372364044,
0.772188663482666,
0.4446052312850952,
-0.055885668843984604,
-0.3622661828994751,
-0.4388720393180847,
-1.0652116537094116,
-0.2402157187461853,
-0.21824762225151062,
-0.2523561120033264,
0.44357815384864807,
0.2873961627483368,
0.22365958988666534,
0.5468170642852783,
-0.6126295924186707,
-0.6163749694824219,
-0.48422765731811523,
0.10819631814956665,
0.3952731490135193,
-0.1742493212223053,
0.5507678389549255,
-0.22892096638679504,
-0.6499096751213074,
0.058049723505973816,
-0.7320066690444946,
0.04796672612428665,
-0.14234529435634613,
0.41522514820098877,
0.3550681173801422,
0.2810821831226349,
-0.5034830570220947,
0.13420328497886658,
0.34841546416282654,
-0.003069724887609482,
0.5993168354034424,
-0.4772709608078003,
0.5212945938110352,
-1.0930767059326172,
-0.0895405262708664,
-0.06526049971580505,
-0.49554312229156494,
-0.4306012690067291,
-0.14574842154979706,
-0.2545359432697296,
-0.14976409077644348,
-0.5963125228881836,
0.4744722843170166,
-0.6753984093666077,
-0.19897215068340302,
-0.18307381868362427,
0.4623672664165497,
0.1783885657787323,
0.17665065824985504,
0.13310779631137848,
0.3407764434814453,
0.6212247014045715,
-0.5458171963691711,
0.26565831899642944,
0.22229360044002533,
-0.6145429015159607,
0.4834785461425781,
-0.7196913957595825,
0.2938626706600189,
-0.11821141839027405,
0.5792226791381836,
-1.3096150159835815,
-0.48766466975212097,
-0.0480106845498085,
-0.7039754986763,
0.3688246011734009,
-0.005516852717846632,
-0.5034079551696777,
-0.3524719774723053,
-0.6065138578414917,
-0.019847985357046127,
0.638053834438324,
-0.11899048089981079,
0.517929196357727,
0.21105508506298065,
-0.28838029503822327,
-0.44389641284942627,
-0.8096439838409424,
0.47075918316841125,
-0.055641353130340576,
-0.7652360796928406,
0.23716706037521362,
0.3880918622016907,
-0.22186420857906342,
-0.07953314483165741,
0.28680095076560974,
0.2893351912498474,
-0.40198543667793274,
0.16050182282924652,
0.4610249698162079,
-0.24789050221443176,
0.030809568241238594,
-0.5643832683563232,
-0.04956212267279625,
-0.04538600519299507,
0.3377276360988617,
0.6694803237915039,
-0.33978161215782166,
-0.36520540714263916,
-0.6266766786575317,
0.05469292029738426,
0.6187235713005066,
0.15424352884292603,
0.32853835821151733,
0.3612957298755646,
-0.198497474193573,
0.3163270652294159,
-0.8705751299858093,
-0.17327135801315308,
-0.31410157680511475,
0.5221779346466064,
-0.1568157821893692,
-0.7608113884925842,
0.424888551235199,
0.08183375746011734,
0.21810173988342285,
0.5406060814857483,
0.916448712348938,
-0.33430612087249756,
0.8881180286407471,
0.058525875210762024,
-0.04414766654372215,
-0.026095271110534668,
-0.02398841641843319,
0.06276658922433853,
-0.933268666267395,
-0.15963467955589294,
-0.3260056972503662,
-0.02749202959239483,
-0.7107155919075012,
-0.22927291691303253,
0.7410726547241211,
-0.573652982711792,
0.38224807381629944,
-0.005447708070278168,
-0.5260347723960876,
0.4905443787574768,
-0.006558505352586508,
0.24602177739143372,
0.49238303303718567,
0.0449589267373085,
0.19569741189479828,
-0.09642777591943741,
-0.552953839302063,
-0.5918142199516296,
0.9434362053871155,
0.42893052101135254,
0.7363297343254089,
0.16332274675369263,
0.5837725400924683,
0.19688814878463745,
0.244261234998703,
-1.021089792251587,
0.687208354473114,
-0.4439132511615753,
-0.18317516148090363,
-0.249097540974617,
-0.33022820949554443,
-0.8029730916023254,
0.4370228946208954,
-0.2618056833744049,
-0.6528330445289612,
-0.24807752668857574,
0.10223042219877243,
-0.7198815941810608,
0.0900273472070694,
-0.31270402669906616,
0.18257324397563934,
-0.2401263266801834,
0.013684261590242386,
-0.4791853427886963,
-0.5998319387435913,
0.5487046837806702,
0.08913440257310867,
0.2606015205383301,
-0.07492199540138245,
0.0547323115170002,
0.7847973704338074,
-0.5377992987632751,
0.9056642055511475,
-0.09888911992311478,
-0.05066363885998726,
0.18137627840042114,
0.3601406514644623,
0.4917929172515869,
-0.04358711838722229,
0.18541979789733887,
-0.0346088707447052,
0.031428515911102295,
0.19231708347797394,
-0.5498141646385193,
0.48272839188575745,
-0.7340003252029419,
-0.5215744376182556,
-0.4456556439399719,
-0.576448380947113,
-0.41977599263191223,
0.04732777550816536,
0.5233505964279175,
0.8446952104568481,
-0.4740827977657318,
0.0965626984834671,
0.3486524820327759,
-0.7576099038124084,
0.2372831553220749,
0.6444755792617798,
-0.4880272448062897,
-0.5942357182502747,
0.7769345641136169,
0.13029725849628448,
0.2737632989883423,
0.4418738782405853,
0.5816828608512878,
-0.1144162118434906,
-0.41514793038368225,
-0.22028404474258423,
0.6189084649085999,
-0.7380267977714539,
-0.2172064483165741,
-0.7203629612922668,
-0.5077977776527405,
-0.45953568816185,
-0.34459131956100464,
-0.16254188120365143,
-0.48772555589675903,
0.3151312470436096,
0.1322144865989685,
0.3013805150985718,
0.8663985133171082,
0.11710517853498459,
0.5132864117622375,
-0.7475770115852356,
0.17821277678012848,
0.08114638924598694,
0.09206411242485046,
0.10432307422161102,
-0.8674018383026123,
-0.22325283288955688,
-0.3854734003543854,
-0.35003861784935,
-0.5611570477485657,
0.44117066264152527,
-0.01592617854475975,
0.2693718671798706,
0.5134359002113342,
-0.2814302146434784,
0.516007661819458,
-0.34395793080329895,
0.802230715751648,
0.5727595090866089,
-0.5047168135643005,
0.24765461683273315,
-0.6015729904174805,
0.698191225528717,
0.307626336812973,
0.23376108705997467,
-0.7738915085792542,
-0.6790719628334045,
-0.6549426317214966,
-0.672529935836792,
0.7016289234161377,
0.05306103825569153,
0.21197205781936646,
-0.10152733325958252,
-0.06493262201547623,
-0.10009102523326874,
-0.10050933808088303,
-0.4955606162548065,
-0.005377637222409248,
0.20766595005989075,
0.17235806584358215,
0.08718575537204742,
-0.7239251732826233,
-0.22403877973556519,
0.17550069093704224,
0.6450772881507874,
0.08722266554832458,
0.29493609070777893,
0.29008591175079346,
-0.08204496651887894,
0.06647364795207977,
0.631036102771759,
0.9944895505905151,
1.1020419597625732,
-0.3267306387424469,
0.16573357582092285,
0.3130822479724884,
-0.4981725811958313,
-0.05419401824474335,
-0.5304486155509949,
-0.022063078358769417,
0.34642893075942993,
0.751846969127655,
0.6487549543380737,
0.08435900509357452,
-0.46112823486328125,
0.7633620500564575,
-0.11401605606079102,
-0.2051248848438263,
-0.3860686123371124,
-0.2213304042816162,
0.19865234196186066,
-0.10584746301174164,
0.13646744191646576,
-0.0678456500172615,
0.2964560389518738,
-0.42401188611984253,
-0.001212723320350051,
0.3215060830116272,
-0.5666537880897522,
-0.17999842762947083,
0.20943571627140045,
0.13824142515659332,
0.040597103536129,
0.5305993556976318,
0.0969705730676651,
-0.20634405314922333,
0.4794486463069916,
0.43162471055984497,
0.7814466953277588,
-0.2232426404953003,
0.40161988139152527,
0.6038141846656799,
0.22314606606960297,
-0.06412819772958755,
0.02480901964008808,
0.3941214382648468,
-0.6446613073348999,
-0.7106699347496033,
-0.20279531180858612,
-0.5779913663864136,
0.21595469117164612,
-0.5967283248901367,
0.5614180564880371,
-0.6069904565811157,
-0.20020614564418793,
0.20833532512187958,
-0.2789164185523987,
-0.3997967541217804,
0.37735891342163086,
0.24901671707630157,
0.6123823523521423,
-0.5057323575019836,
0.26447343826293945,
0.6729792356491089,
-0.5382601022720337,
-1.1250320672988892,
-0.23961997032165527,
0.2345040887594223,
-1.2032994031906128,
0.5603727102279663,
0.09008113294839859,
-0.21326248347759247,
-0.5183829069137573,
-0.159544438123703,
-0.4053835868835449,
0.9040893912315369,
0.18850617110729218,
-0.4708106815814972,
-0.19502811133861542,
0.3078470528125763,
0.74375319480896,
-0.4604633152484894,
0.692139208316803,
0.3128877878189087,
0.2737443745136261,
0.28972727060317993,
-1.1457082033157349,
0.2779821455478668,
0.16419965028762817,
-0.02468220144510269,
-0.07656841725111008,
-0.7616185545921326,
0.5721226930618286,
-0.506746232509613,
-0.2912343144416809,
-0.05089441314339638,
0.2832951843738556,
0.41133081912994385,
-0.13562342524528503,
0.37912869453430176,
0.3423917293548584,
0.42175158858299255,
0.09373975545167923,
1.7119290828704834,
-0.26020821928977966,
0.21687644720077515,
1.001526951789856,
-0.15437600016593933,
0.45495688915252686,
0.27957043051719666,
-0.31528231501579285,
0.3736626207828522,
0.3108353018760681,
-0.14547023177146912,
0.30258631706237793,
0.18969100713729858,
-0.1594131588935852,
-0.11456746608018875,
-0.35353410243988037,
-0.4064459502696991,
0.6780208945274353,
0.29101434350013733,
-0.5991074442863464,
-0.5011395812034607,
-0.12120462208986282,
0.45581379532814026,
-0.22964638471603394,
-0.19913019239902496,
1.1718305349349976,
0.40228894352912903,
-0.669731855392456,
0.672020435333252,
0.060350000858306885,
0.40949904918670654,
-0.692314088344574,
-0.002726372331380844,
-0.34014371037483215,
-0.02725161612033844,
-0.6350312829017639,
-0.9207645654678345,
0.23561523854732513,
-0.04843076691031456,
-0.0798342376947403,
-0.08854510635137558,
0.6187490820884705,
0.04678411781787872,
-0.46644127368927,
-0.15249526500701904,
0.28952327370643616,
0.6048147082328796,
0.14075042307376862,
-0.09880917519330978,
-0.04136689007282257,
0.2009761929512024,
-0.3135969340801239,
0.3957499861717224,
0.30850353837013245,
-0.027309082448482513,
0.585838794708252,
0.1665533185005188,
0.6046892404556274,
-0.5426961779594421,
0.4007795751094818,
0.6108021140098572,
-0.41863203048706055,
-0.3840450644493103,
-0.9745593070983887,
0.2059030532836914,
0.11592062562704086,
-0.23120030760765076,
0.54794842004776,
0.6401222944259644,
0.333729088306427,
-0.19747841358184814,
0.8626235127449036,
0.08694037050008774,
0.6742546558380127,
-0.7912790179252625,
0.7379285097122192,
-0.3362171947956085,
0.3791307210922241,
-0.5880268216133118,
-0.7842774987220764,
-0.3972003161907196,
0.292783260345459,
-0.48506852984428406,
0.11103924363851547,
0.8795857429504395,
0.7166261672973633,
0.22241558134555817,
-0.2834184467792511,
0.6564874053001404,
0.42662498354911804,
0.17637339234352112,
0.6656000018119812,
0.9300875067710876,
-0.24617016315460205,
0.6625779867172241,
-0.006361409090459347,
-0.1582111269235611,
-0.3315243721008301,
-0.6892775297164917,
-0.6131331920623779,
-0.2035229206085205,
-0.3844134509563446,
-0.4399949014186859,
-0.16544319689273834,
0.6121055483818054,
0.5303032398223877,
-0.3677363395690918,
-0.29243147373199463,
0.6128203272819519,
-0.34475189447402954,
0.18886223435401917,
-0.28755995631217957,
0.8391193151473999,
-0.20153695344924927,
-0.33051252365112305,
0.10982298105955124,
0.6424950361251831,
0.0012064845068380237,
-0.34431949257850647,
-0.01000007800757885,
0.270583838224411,
0.043838851153850555,
0.632628858089447,
0.06432633846998215,
-0.8846372365951538,
-0.33313119411468506,
0.1524013727903366,
-0.4293982684612274,
0.40408605337142944,
0.7043327689170837,
-0.7710781097412109,
0.6057465672492981,
0.4837459921836853,
0.3542845547199249,
0.4488600194454193,
-0.03020992875099182,
0.5754609704017639,
-0.6647481918334961,
-0.04527564346790314,
0.2061130404472351,
0.5311009883880615,
0.5646906495094299,
-0.3803049921989441,
0.3950115740299225,
-0.10269942879676819,
-0.4233119785785675,
-0.6209718585014343,
0.05291932821273804,
-1.2181791067123413,
-0.12616649270057678,
1.2818775177001953,
-0.09094976633787155,
-0.05346619710326195,
0.23686808347702026,
-0.3445376753807068,
-0.12962420284748077,
-0.28666746616363525,
0.7828863859176636,
0.6564913392066956,
-0.6014642715454102,
-0.3219260275363922,
-0.4527735710144043,
0.3566139042377472,
0.34005284309387207,
-0.8459072709083557,
-0.32224151492118835,
0.5940262079238892,
0.5919156670570374,
0.2506805658340454,
1.208745002746582,
-0.7231242656707764,
0.5024221539497375,
-0.36002209782600403,
0.12102369964122772,
-0.092131607234478,
0.14677485823631287,
-0.20199480652809143,
0.007341369055211544,
0.3357475996017456,
-0.037192218005657196
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.02133v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.02133v1
|
SimulTron: On-Device Simultaneous Speech to Speech Translation
| 2024-06-04T09:21:31 | 2024-06-04T09:21:31 |
Alex Agranovich, Eliya Nachmani, Oleg Rybakov, Yifan Ding, Ye Jia, Nadav Bar, Heiga Zen, Michelle Tadmor Ramanovich
|
eess.AS
|
eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SD
|
Simultaneous speech-to-speech translation (S2ST) holds the promise of
breaking down communication barriers and enabling fluid conversations across
languages. However, achieving accurate, real-time translation through mobile
devices remains a major challenge. We introduce SimulTron, a novel S2ST
architecture designed to tackle this task. SimulTron is a lightweight direct
S2ST model that uses the strengths of the Translatotron framework while
incorporating key modifications for streaming operation, and an adjustable
fixed delay. Our experiments show that SimulTron surpasses Translatotron 2 in
offline evaluations. Furthermore, real-time evaluations reveal that SimulTron
improves upon the performance achieved by Translatotron 1. Additionally,
SimulTron achieves superior BLEU scores and latency compared to previous
real-time S2ST method on the MuST-C dataset. Significantly, we have
successfully deployed SimulTron on a Pixel 7 Pro device, show its potential for
simultaneous S2ST on-device.
|
[
0.09177134186029434,
-0.5772526264190674,
0.3390267789363861,
0.42654329538345337,
-0.7553064823150635,
0.49881869554519653,
-0.17369036376476288,
-0.3150240480899811,
-0.12006568163633347,
0.1676550805568695,
-0.3698035776615143,
0.060160405933856964,
-0.672267735004425,
-0.0969705879688263,
-0.5113186240196228,
0.5678702592849731,
-0.011328151449561119,
0.29178813099861145,
-0.05806239694356918,
-0.1323811411857605,
-0.43841302394866943,
-0.3666609525680542,
-0.5449877381324768,
-0.34798529744148254,
0.19936294853687286,
0.5728467106819153,
1.0929431915283203,
0.8884926438331604,
0.48981499671936035,
0.0993872806429863,
-0.012449943460524082,
-0.10330689698457718,
-0.2823963463306427,
0.2076394259929657,
0.006061353720724583,
-0.3578072190284729,
-0.3305029273033142,
-0.5876356959342957,
0.61524498462677,
0.1796141266822815,
-0.16768504679203033,
0.10669422894716263,
-0.05675806477665901,
0.2953568994998932,
-0.2549704611301422,
-0.27111944556236267,
-0.4602546989917755,
-0.004573567304760218,
-0.3320012092590332,
-0.1450006663799286,
-0.22754108905792236,
-0.4455413222312927,
-0.08970361948013306,
-0.31611692905426025,
0.06220342591404915,
-0.10153157263994217,
0.5327949523925781,
0.9185336232185364,
-0.5974928736686707,
0.05973565950989723,
-1.0278360843658447,
0.5476565957069397,
-0.21152082085609436,
0.8822348713874817,
-0.1679442822933197,
0.658717930316925,
0.2986876964569092,
-1.1784038543701172,
-0.40307000279426575,
-0.2233566790819168,
0.25873374938964844,
0.4087080955505371,
-0.36211562156677246,
-0.26665282249450684,
0.14423640072345734,
0.09452355653047562,
-0.7410624623298645,
-0.08728053420782089,
-0.2691403925418854,
-0.26622146368026733,
0.7106974124908447,
-0.10537432879209518,
0.15480148792266846,
0.0669969990849495,
-0.590592086315155,
0.18930751085281372,
-0.5245026350021362,
-0.05504308268427849,
-0.006399857811629772,
0.18639439344406128,
-0.3886324465274811,
0.5221028923988342,
-0.18349559605121613,
0.3114211857318878,
-0.031017042696475983,
0.12070949375629425,
0.20768152177333832,
-0.5970842838287354,
0.05453072115778923,
0.9428082704544067,
0.7033444046974182,
0.06243860721588135,
-0.130039244890213,
-0.2858898937702179,
-0.05018823966383934,
0.1348714679479599,
0.22755083441734314,
-0.9363653659820557,
0.07236576825380325,
0.506105899810791,
-0.12374551594257355,
-0.23142936825752258,
-0.17055563628673553,
-0.601737380027771,
-0.23803700506687164,
-0.07748541235923767,
0.34150853753089905,
-0.10835252702236176,
-0.35831117630004883,
-0.03022119030356407,
-0.01474788784980774,
0.17533335089683533,
0.5677569508552551,
-0.39016932249069214,
0.6742496490478516,
0.6751195192337036,
1.2757904529571533,
-0.39348745346069336,
-0.14390797913074493,
-0.8842743039131165,
0.2310062050819397,
-0.2447470724582672,
0.7438992261886597,
-0.17218051850795746,
-0.5077604055404663,
-0.2889353930950165,
-0.41218775510787964,
-0.051202498376369476,
-0.3941413462162018,
1.0659574270248413,
-0.09672640264034271,
-0.20931999385356903,
0.10685184597969055,
-0.44613397121429443,
0.28503087162971497,
-0.2715962827205658,
-0.445472776889801,
1.2017571926116943,
-0.2274959534406662,
-0.811163067817688,
-0.14199091494083405,
-0.47335800528526306,
-0.5962743759155273,
0.34975066781044006,
-0.16356152296066284,
-0.31678837537765503,
0.11865741014480591,
-0.06300090253353119,
0.16893994808197021,
-0.6891966462135315,
0.10468082875013351,
-0.02125646360218525,
-0.5724449157714844,
0.2396526038646698,
-0.3177693784236908,
0.7425969243049622,
0.5265734195709229,
-0.538149893283844,
0.10823609679937363,
-0.47953319549560547,
0.03591279312968254,
0.1924210637807846,
-0.04017557203769684,
0.04938821494579315,
0.28032729029655457,
0.3737729489803314,
0.4558391869068146,
0.22285111248493195,
-0.9382794499397278,
-0.06830055266618729,
-0.12599410116672516,
0.6817903518676758,
0.2449769824743271,
-0.28893008828163147,
0.5678644180297852,
-0.27958807349205017,
0.2927054762840271,
-0.10106419771909714,
0.08678726851940155,
0.030655356124043465,
-0.5469835996627808,
-0.45539674162864685,
-0.3975643813610077,
0.49955734610557556,
1.02482271194458,
-0.8821457028388977,
0.14444802701473236,
-0.9486005902290344,
-0.746785044670105,
-0.6946569085121155,
-0.0026432466693222523,
0.2791050970554352,
0.2831171154975891,
0.3175097703933716,
0.01901271753013134,
-0.15598739683628082,
-0.563348650932312,
-0.5547366142272949,
0.095831498503685,
0.10358520597219467,
0.3434865176677704,
-0.05807322636246681,
-0.10902750492095947,
0.8158554434776306,
-0.10583548247814178,
-0.1831875443458557,
-0.5019081234931946,
0.16047470271587372,
-0.12400256842374802,
0.5301211476325989,
0.18711347877979279,
-1.0830875635147095,
-0.41488218307495117,
0.4790579080581665,
-0.5318615436553955,
-0.32162463665008545,
-0.31754833459854126,
0.24324534833431244,
0.11222236603498459,
0.47759267687797546,
-0.6789510250091553,
0.41891375184059143,
0.8112747669219971,
0.15523459017276764,
0.29350602626800537,
-0.13733723759651184,
-0.005373662803322077,
-1.241801381111145,
-0.08300482481718063,
-0.3515709638595581,
-0.6335800886154175,
-0.8801493644714355,
-0.3618497848510742,
0.41278377175331116,
-0.3726637661457062,
-1.0547819137573242,
0.6808907985687256,
0.12913778424263,
-0.48175209760665894,
-0.1520310640335083,
0.3404763638973236,
-0.3700370490550995,
-0.06033841520547867,
0.044478386640548706,
1.044147253036499,
0.4366573989391327,
-0.46865367889404297,
0.654464840888977,
0.3493983745574951,
-0.17614953219890594,
0.4946858584880829,
-0.8839672803878784,
0.1854432374238968,
0.33177444338798523,
0.49693140387535095,
-1.1128000020980835,
-0.30423176288604736,
0.26778173446655273,
-0.6698839664459229,
-0.13972820341587067,
-0.14811769127845764,
-0.5978983044624329,
-0.13460758328437805,
-0.08116880059242249,
0.7824248671531677,
0.4967939257621765,
-0.599288284778595,
0.633314311504364,
0.03742145746946335,
-0.4959835112094879,
-0.04843532294034958,
-0.792141318321228,
0.1421632170677185,
0.0779181718826294,
-0.868462085723877,
0.7388314008712769,
0.0980546623468399,
0.030377380549907684,
-0.05791422724723816,
-0.41561979055404663,
-0.10175905376672745,
-0.19853562116622925,
0.4070297181606293,
0.012399434112012386,
0.10143139958381653,
0.1595851182937622,
0.4526929557323456,
-0.11410877853631973,
-0.33740097284317017,
-0.09214231371879578,
0.5965855121612549,
0.15829165279865265,
-0.2758595049381256,
-0.9096355438232422,
0.33740633726119995,
0.5043941736221313,
-0.2551974356174469,
0.09539438784122467,
0.57781583070755,
-0.24804805219173431,
-0.19960524141788483,
-0.16720202565193176,
-0.0712035745382309,
-0.4373337924480438,
0.18254616856575012,
-0.631565511226654,
-0.7323817610740662,
0.19617657363414764,
-0.5720099210739136,
-0.13456012308597565,
0.05969218537211418,
0.5860887169837952,
-0.1983719766139984,
0.9878168106079102,
-0.02082846499979496,
0.4720641076564789,
0.5776194334030151,
0.13819646835327148,
0.27971723675727844,
-0.6252136826515198,
-0.20503568649291992,
-0.5383883714675903,
-0.19277621805667877,
-0.5528177618980408,
-0.7124732136726379,
0.5446119904518127,
0.08386029303073883,
-0.2703351676464081,
0.5337520241737366,
-0.25525587797164917,
0.004828990902751684,
0.48802557587623596,
0.14572018384933472,
0.3132764995098114,
0.14150911569595337,
0.020989447832107544,
-0.1814124584197998,
-0.9517478942871094,
-0.3565889000892639,
0.629017174243927,
0.3482239842414856,
0.7707548141479492,
0.19904980063438416,
0.5400963425636292,
0.5279747843742371,
0.10965541005134583,
-0.8771696090698242,
0.5843410491943359,
-0.1991509348154068,
-0.5642772912979126,
-0.11513043940067291,
-0.5671442151069641,
-0.5818545818328857,
0.4946542978286743,
0.19403396546840668,
-0.5415100455284119,
-0.2831135094165802,
0.15105849504470825,
-0.3353869318962097,
-0.013600624166429043,
-0.3678891658782959,
0.7380874156951904,
-0.868416965007782,
-0.7307496070861816,
-0.3473905324935913,
-0.8223870396614075,
0.1542312055826187,
-0.1196199581027031,
0.102901890873909,
-0.16635732352733612,
-0.2584364712238312,
0.418680340051651,
-0.2220894694328308,
0.3760727345943451,
-0.003679649904370308,
0.09982363134622574,
0.10118606686592102,
0.3398813009262085,
0.4329811930656433,
0.015419877134263515,
-0.12118707597255707,
0.30685919523239136,
0.179230734705925,
-0.3370700776576996,
-0.5000696182250977,
0.7211751937866211,
-0.6914333701133728,
-0.1782553642988205,
-0.7462761402130127,
-0.5157632827758789,
-0.14562569558620453,
0.041911572217941284,
0.25662121176719666,
0.48768866062164307,
-0.31575119495391846,
0.3450728952884674,
0.2325737029314041,
-0.051518090069293976,
0.562507688999176,
-0.12937892973423004,
-0.32011663913726807,
-0.5236350893974304,
0.946338951587677,
0.2124531865119934,
0.559035062789917,
0.34918829798698425,
0.31003111600875854,
-0.7069013118743896,
-0.10067415982484818,
-1.0188400745391846,
0.2721947133541107,
-0.1932394951581955,
-0.15428413450717926,
-0.6870056986808777,
-0.24332430958747864,
-0.45585402846336365,
-0.1650533676147461,
-0.8056217432022095,
-0.8005318641662598,
-0.1784982532262802,
0.21146894991397858,
0.07688820362091064,
0.319208562374115,
-0.041514698415994644,
0.9346657395362854,
-0.8354128003120422,
0.6106038689613342,
0.31419312953948975,
0.05555795133113861,
-0.5005622506141663,
-0.7896121740341187,
0.053849924355745316,
0.23765116930007935,
-0.39161139726638794,
-0.725749671459198,
0.14270076155662537,
0.15388181805610657,
0.35870346426963806,
0.05900747328996658,
0.13420893251895905,
0.6358088254928589,
-0.5416721105575562,
0.8336362838745117,
0.3041316270828247,
-1.3596330881118774,
0.5030260682106018,
-0.3301386833190918,
0.45523005723953247,
0.2916828691959381,
0.12555159628391266,
-0.7364686727523804,
0.06941772252321243,
-0.5503361821174622,
-0.49106499552726746,
1.0607677698135376,
0.6346153616905212,
0.07977528870105743,
0.628497302532196,
-0.013268104754388332,
-0.23608998954296112,
0.27387964725494385,
-0.23644253611564636,
-0.09908103197813034,
-0.4927242398262024,
-0.4323437809944153,
-0.018756089732050896,
0.03899111971259117,
-0.08395253121852875,
-0.14235122501850128,
0.45646563172340393,
0.19680540263652802,
0.42308309674263,
0.3457009196281433,
-0.3077440857887268,
-0.06907414644956589,
0.24725107848644257,
0.8511603474617004,
0.22088012099266052,
-0.0956631675362587,
0.30368882417678833,
0.3730524182319641,
-0.4029633402824402,
0.26184555888175964,
0.3555753529071808,
-0.20307500660419464,
0.25890520215034485,
0.006262785755097866,
0.8584251403808594,
0.4708639681339264,
-0.6530559062957764,
0.7857971787452698,
-0.06483530253171921,
-0.20812274515628815,
-0.050310127437114716,
-0.29213881492614746,
0.15717466175556183,
0.12527118623256683,
0.2149844616651535,
0.3464292287826538,
-0.05149245634675026,
-0.3669178783893585,
0.4988313317298889,
-0.14154672622680664,
-0.6615288257598877,
-0.2789075970649719,
0.9491444826126099,
0.5467811226844788,
-0.6515211462974548,
0.07934210449457169,
0.09865079075098038,
-0.5076339840888977,
0.3923446238040924,
0.6796283721923828,
0.8625133037567139,
-0.8740724921226501,
0.37072834372520447,
0.05268619582056999,
0.13541114330291748,
-0.30784928798675537,
0.5459758043289185,
-0.28579336404800415,
-0.2612255811691284,
-0.2504097521305084,
-0.5676270723342896,
-0.5333989262580872,
-0.5848208665847778,
-0.3091258704662323,
0.2079683095216751,
-0.27856793999671936,
-0.09132752567529678,
-0.24314211308956146,
-0.3888883888721466,
-0.25257226824760437,
0.24698759615421295,
0.11137183010578156,
0.8915197849273682,
-0.5036157369613647,
1.0848249197006226,
0.5389930605888367,
0.028679873794317245,
-0.6308297514915466,
0.06159120425581932,
0.10611297190189362,
-0.38308680057525635,
0.6538286805152893,
-0.07620132714509964,
-0.6187921762466431,
0.4148198366165161,
-0.15674705803394318,
-0.6076008677482605,
1.1597795486450195,
0.5060480237007141,
-0.8020366430282593,
0.49023401737213135,
0.5937244296073914,
0.36425015330314636,
-0.15647147595882416,
-0.013402015902101994,
0.302473783493042,
0.4158247411251068,
0.47959470748901367,
-1.2074187994003296,
-0.08201125264167786,
0.1924661546945572,
0.10385561734437943,
0.1071176752448082,
-0.8559226989746094,
0.6593737602233887,
-0.07723154872655869,
-0.3473130762577057,
-0.02531846985220909,
0.5358372926712036,
0.046417366713285446,
0.4346106946468353,
0.3036684989929199,
0.32327646017074585,
0.4482269585132599,
-0.20130567252635956,
1.1034150123596191,
-0.09892763942480087,
0.2345854938030243,
1.2659679651260376,
-0.5604009628295898,
1.037853717803955,
0.5101380348205566,
0.14567165076732635,
-0.23501360416412354,
0.3907792270183563,
0.4358084797859192,
0.5534579753875732,
0.006867961958050728,
-0.6071126461029053,
-0.44647806882858276,
-0.6479830145835876,
-0.44291549921035767,
0.5008209347724915,
0.2305801659822464,
0.05342930182814598,
-0.22227735817432404,
0.09319008141756058,
0.04624355956912041,
0.04484891518950462,
-0.3478814661502838,
0.4706076979637146,
0.27816036343574524,
-0.34857019782066345,
0.4983072578907013,
-0.05963612347841263,
0.28996697068214417,
-0.522178053855896,
0.19311775267124176,
-0.24414505064487457,
0.44147059321403503,
-0.1972482055425644,
-0.667409360408783,
0.29041069746017456,
0.1660992056131363,
0.4960220158100128,
-0.39059239625930786,
0.6623856425285339,
-0.39823997020721436,
-0.6230413913726807,
0.4011700749397278,
0.7188958525657654,
0.04934734106063843,
-0.17703598737716675,
-0.7228265404701233,
0.7121422290802002,
-0.08531288057565689,
-0.04528607428073883,
-0.10648766905069351,
0.24047502875328064,
-0.20356594026088715,
0.7055603265762329,
0.5693372488021851,
0.0661749392747879,
0.5764473676681519,
0.08539276570081711,
0.5337380766868591,
-0.43417054414749146,
-0.5031999349594116,
-0.5124517679214478,
0.4375342130661011,
-0.20520083606243134,
-0.19131053984165192,
0.7023094296455383,
0.9762136340141296,
0.7445523738861084,
0.11671675741672516,
0.9811983108520508,
-0.2557068169116974,
0.6180375218391418,
-0.02916635386645794,
0.5086837410926819,
-0.7637848854064941,
-0.12382428348064423,
0.11973108351230621,
-0.9120273590087891,
-0.46650469303131104,
0.36655181646347046,
-0.10899575799703598,
-0.33234280347824097,
0.8451587557792664,
0.8378251791000366,
-0.5174390077590942,
0.29421544075012207,
0.6392842531204224,
0.007179724983870983,
0.32430899143218994,
0.26135849952697754,
0.8843562006950378,
-0.9748498201370239,
1.0129985809326172,
-0.22616364061832428,
-0.12473230808973312,
-0.4949570894241333,
-0.5588403344154358,
-0.3504529893398285,
-0.5363554358482361,
-0.18732203543186188,
-0.16144707798957825,
0.4788818955421448,
1.0506937503814697,
0.641417920589447,
-0.5285853147506714,
-0.5166735053062439,
-0.08099879324436188,
-0.05114976316690445,
-0.42376598715782166,
-0.032655153423547745,
-0.03330335021018982,
0.05059375986456871,
-0.8258746862411499,
0.5979593992233276,
0.42630821466445923,
0.002497947309166193,
0.43904757499694824,
-0.43551963567733765,
-0.030848845839500427,
0.12646019458770752,
0.330566942691803,
0.2016390860080719,
-0.6791109442710876,
-0.3101192116737366,
-0.09529396146535873,
-0.36260342597961426,
0.02010585181415081,
1.042060375213623,
-0.3783802092075348,
0.4332607686519623,
0.7430586218833923,
0.9703738689422607,
0.8846259713172913,
0.3597469925880432,
0.28256794810295105,
-0.5917690992355347,
0.31800878047943115,
0.3603960871696472,
-0.07152528315782547,
0.3106893301010132,
0.010399955324828625,
0.4849587082862854,
0.3476100265979767,
-0.46311819553375244,
-0.8727933764457703,
0.3555946946144104,
-1.659956455230713,
-0.04197920113801956,
1.1927813291549683,
0.1666448712348938,
-0.04854365065693855,
-0.10531040281057358,
-0.6282910108566284,
0.6130858659744263,
-0.5606648921966553,
0.18284019827842712,
0.07288536429405212,
-0.32811030745506287,
-0.5243353247642517,
-0.7841902375221252,
0.40168100595474243,
0.5556320548057556,
-0.7369851469993591,
0.14642320573329926,
0.14719508588314056,
0.11634015291929245,
-0.09565236419439316,
0.5122299790382385,
0.01984795182943344,
0.4941183626651764,
0.23613721132278442,
-0.055417127907276154,
-0.14827005565166473,
-0.3683961033821106,
-0.3147653341293335,
0.15362556278705597,
-0.3657960593700409,
-0.609588623046875
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.02128v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.02128v1
|
Iteration Head: A Mechanistic Study of Chain-of-Thought
| 2024-06-04T09:11:46 | 2024-06-04T09:11:46 |
Vivien Cabannes, Charles Arnal, Wassim Bouaziz, Alice Yang, Francois Charton, Julia Kempe
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Chain-of-Thought (CoT) reasoning is known to improve Large Language Models
both empirically and in terms of theoretical approximation power. However, our
understanding of the inner workings and conditions of apparition of CoT
capabilities remains limited. This paper helps fill this gap by demonstrating
how CoT reasoning emerges in transformers in a controlled and interpretable
setting. In particular, we observe the appearance of a specialized attention
mechanism dedicated to iterative reasoning, which we coined "iteration heads".
We track both the emergence and the precise working of these iteration heads
down to the attention level, and measure the transferability of the CoT skills
to which they give rise between tasks.
|
[
-0.6901119351387024,
-0.7908377051353455,
0.8493666648864746,
0.10777070373296738,
-0.2112894058227539,
0.6591154932975769,
-0.3809114396572113,
-0.335375040769577,
0.11447586864233017,
0.45770469307899475,
-0.7766046524047852,
0.07814209163188934,
-0.6503934860229492,
0.22723878920078278,
-0.7295455932617188,
1.0836505889892578,
-0.25273025035858154,
-0.4714851379394531,
0.010889766737818718,
-0.009555871598422527,
-0.5375356674194336,
-0.4921996593475342,
-0.49622541666030884,
-0.6271856427192688,
0.8165503740310669,
0.46267539262771606,
0.8854328989982605,
0.6311464309692383,
0.6202532052993774,
0.23736871778964996,
0.07580201327800751,
-0.053597018122673035,
-0.608903706073761,
0.17206603288650513,
-0.804112434387207,
-0.6360443234443665,
-0.03176437318325043,
-0.06076538935303688,
0.4906325042247772,
0.6596329212188721,
-0.062274087220430374,
0.1263798028230667,
0.01460618618875742,
0.9017238020896912,
-0.7148162126541138,
-0.13949532806873322,
-0.9087378978729248,
-0.1094585731625557,
-0.05803181603550911,
-0.4369780421257019,
-0.5742000341415405,
-0.019731217995285988,
0.4511604309082031,
-0.17855453491210938,
0.18246302008628845,
0.03920434042811394,
0.4895029366016388,
0.279699444770813,
-0.07160255312919617,
-0.493404746055603,
-1.055269718170166,
0.8232465982437134,
-0.12921041250228882,
0.3959624767303467,
0.09867435693740845,
0.3363476097583771,
-0.11976959556341171,
-0.8908281326293945,
-0.8554260730743408,
-0.14612847566604614,
0.1555681675672531,
0.056425679475069046,
-0.12330996990203857,
0.03007661923766136,
0.1880931407213211,
0.5884132981300354,
-0.1137402132153511,
-0.3160549998283386,
-0.7343716621398926,
0.3919299244880676,
0.39516860246658325,
0.10436396300792694,
0.15864801406860352,
0.24852891266345978,
-0.2856590151786804,
-0.25608229637145996,
-0.337070107460022,
0.03775859251618385,
0.03902817517518997,
0.1138526052236557,
-0.05973009020090103,
0.5731488466262817,
-0.19658368825912476,
0.9054229259490967,
0.4573969841003418,
-0.09293671697378159,
0.03209149092435837,
-0.2149067372083664,
-0.3931841552257538,
0.03806746006011963,
0.37907877564430237,
-0.045982636511325836,
0.6491868495941162,
-0.5374178886413574,
-0.09690125286579132,
0.23440594971179962,
1.1982680559158325,
-0.037728309631347656,
-0.20348164439201355,
0.26060566306114197,
-0.24632856249809265,
-0.4967770576477051,
0.16117022931575775,
-0.4938574731349945,
-0.18356013298034668,
-0.5631777048110962,
0.309463232755661,
-0.47381046414375305,
-0.4624066650867462,
-0.03954218700528145,
-0.1967010200023651,
0.49929237365722656,
0.0332120805978775,
-0.850382924079895,
0.1996600180864334,
0.8491118550300598,
0.8519577383995056,
-0.595754861831665,
-0.5871477127075195,
0.011532533913850784,
0.2637902498245239,
-0.565090537071228,
1.0438693761825562,
-0.8122086524963379,
-0.05979042500257492,
-0.29276037216186523,
0.19210653007030487,
-0.4076697826385498,
-0.45520487427711487,
0.1397605836391449,
-0.5647707581520081,
-0.31823912262916565,
-0.2609761357307434,
-0.1878470778465271,
-0.1896372139453888,
0.20950548350811005,
-0.43035265803337097,
0.713739275932312,
0.4799642264842987,
-0.6750066876411438,
0.17499792575836182,
-0.5594497919082642,
-0.4442718029022217,
-0.10086491703987122,
-0.3889884948730469,
-0.03589707985520363,
0.3784762918949127,
-0.10400357842445374,
0.03065374121069908,
-0.5429921746253967,
0.06882698833942413,
-0.14685876667499542,
-0.3120211660861969,
0.5213163495063782,
-0.15352529287338257,
0.6969039440155029,
0.3727205693721771,
-0.732611894607544,
0.2796823978424072,
-0.5505674481391907,
0.08459208160638809,
-0.06286053359508514,
0.29649630188941956,
-0.046668801456689835,
-0.10354483127593994,
-0.5001529455184937,
0.2841653525829315,
-0.18873919546604156,
-0.06264336407184601,
0.3386106789112091,
-0.23492911458015442,
0.6662617325782776,
0.8553153276443481,
0.318950891494751,
0.6836797595024109,
-0.34220898151397705,
0.6756592988967896,
0.05187569186091423,
0.18853172659873962,
-0.10710763186216354,
-0.4488237798213959,
-0.9920516014099121,
-0.004460561089217663,
0.17651838064193726,
0.17705248296260834,
-0.9079163074493408,
0.21897606551647186,
0.03260092809796333,
-0.5536901354789734,
-0.5561503171920776,
-0.14167991280555725,
0.2688398063182831,
0.3258814811706543,
0.23436713218688965,
-0.4759606420993805,
-0.383137047290802,
-0.8130884170532227,
-0.35037553310394287,
-0.08241236209869385,
-0.11282075196504593,
0.06884074956178665,
0.5081430077552795,
-0.37827539443969727,
0.9454061985015869,
-0.2995024621486664,
-0.053074561059474945,
-0.38592299818992615,
0.41364622116088867,
0.19981776177883148,
0.5433236956596375,
0.2867763638496399,
-0.500551164150238,
-0.11135698109865189,
0.1038454920053482,
-0.8165827989578247,
0.024671847000718117,
-0.5895124673843384,
-0.5959761142730713,
-0.20682822167873383,
0.4772889316082001,
-0.46881020069122314,
0.6326122283935547,
0.2847377359867096,
-0.34997302293777466,
0.8106241822242737,
-0.03333980217576027,
0.09157995879650116,
-0.5667040944099426,
0.09605259448289871,
-0.42666277289390564,
-0.15863944590091705,
-0.4817344546318054,
0.4638640284538269,
-0.10837741941213608,
0.15751199424266815,
-0.1145496591925621,
0.13834288716316223,
-0.6102558374404907,
-0.43764543533325195,
-0.6108424663543701,
0.4593031108379364,
0.008603929542005062,
0.7028796076774597,
-0.06461924314498901,
0.9865211248397827,
0.7094939351081848,
-0.953195333480835,
0.3739575147628784,
0.1672527939081192,
-0.20011742413043976,
0.8457724452018738,
-0.43078428506851196,
0.6772337555885315,
-0.10736744850873947,
-0.028334034606814384,
-0.7463778257369995,
-0.12287168204784393,
0.05790756270289421,
-0.3700734078884125,
0.05425630882382393,
0.38811254501342773,
-0.21782726049423218,
-0.8878606557846069,
-0.245369091629982,
0.5009075403213501,
0.35547661781311035,
-0.4767831861972809,
0.5118380784988403,
0.44511476159095764,
0.06836429983377457,
-0.49968859553337097,
-0.6408075094223022,
-0.06773726642131805,
-0.07815507054328918,
-0.06577128916978836,
0.3162899613380432,
0.13199540972709656,
-0.683249294757843,
-0.055606357753276825,
-0.4530858099460602,
-0.1736302375793457,
-0.22865676879882812,
-0.06227651238441467,
-0.11218933016061783,
-0.02715606987476349,
0.20081137120723724,
0.11565086245536804,
-0.1520686000585556,
0.13881747424602509,
-0.35007554292678833,
0.6710573434829712,
-0.26897379755973816,
-0.20012399554252625,
-0.35590988397598267,
0.1689235270023346,
0.9783098101615906,
-0.25493231415748596,
0.6309497952461243,
0.09598205983638763,
-0.26603466272354126,
-0.26345765590667725,
-0.49182793498039246,
-0.20914195477962494,
-0.4992051422595978,
0.027252554893493652,
-0.7849418520927429,
-0.49404701590538025,
0.5807962417602539,
-0.03837615251541138,
0.006450198125094175,
0.4751743674278259,
0.8543699383735657,
-0.14918109774589539,
0.8063139915466309,
0.6696981191635132,
0.1171233206987381,
0.4045223295688629,
-0.5449424386024475,
0.43361324071884155,
-1.3255618810653687,
-0.20896629989147186,
-0.34638407826423645,
-0.5695534348487854,
-0.4940561354160309,
-0.5818681120872498,
0.2571069002151489,
0.3278779983520508,
-0.2952011227607727,
0.6401580572128296,
-0.9602547883987427,
0.5633187890052795,
0.431132435798645,
0.33331772685050964,
0.36024633049964905,
-0.3980794847011566,
-0.3195507526397705,
0.31105664372444153,
-0.6278276443481445,
-0.45638740062713623,
0.798057496547699,
0.25669917464256287,
0.8425639271736145,
-0.32321155071258545,
0.29797303676605225,
0.38863512873649597,
0.36864742636680603,
-0.8080220818519592,
0.3400879204273224,
0.2509513795375824,
-0.4360947012901306,
-0.1808425486087799,
0.10559364408254623,
-0.9657602310180664,
-0.050440315157175064,
0.2383037805557251,
-1.103555679321289,
0.30254602432250977,
0.10760592669248581,
-0.31288063526153564,
0.3686560392379761,
-0.5428189635276794,
0.6255407929420471,
-0.2528568208217621,
-0.4291597902774811,
-0.6811115145683289,
-0.6068117022514343,
0.29621341824531555,
-0.06705854088068008,
0.07979924976825714,
0.2232978343963623,
0.19138610363006592,
0.7742207646369934,
-0.34888967871665955,
0.3619161546230316,
0.27941587567329407,
-0.3053422272205353,
0.9295530319213867,
0.1618301421403885,
0.4794774055480957,
-0.11838137358427048,
0.171944722533226,
0.12540678679943085,
-0.13415251672267914,
-0.27917033433914185,
-0.718052089214325,
0.735664963722229,
-0.5243409872055054,
-0.8568121790885925,
-0.4351404011249542,
-0.826265275478363,
-0.25292444229125977,
0.21020406484603882,
0.22072243690490723,
0.16887179017066956,
0.39067739248275757,
0.2194449007511139,
0.38098737597465515,
0.09645049273967743,
0.30734166502952576,
-0.009834774769842625,
-0.44621142745018005,
-0.16949209570884705,
0.6141802668571472,
0.1631639301776886,
0.49818602204322815,
0.058602508157491684,
-0.022621093317866325,
-0.017379064112901688,
-0.25220051407814026,
-0.49684545397758484,
0.058945100754499435,
-0.8874120712280273,
-0.14016038179397583,
-0.6867358684539795,
-0.3394150733947754,
0.21290765702724457,
-0.49485093355178833,
-0.5884827971458435,
-0.5418549180030823,
0.11927979439496994,
-0.13648316264152527,
0.4832349121570587,
1.0158251523971558,
0.20291051268577576,
0.38115283846855164,
-0.23882517218589783,
0.4382023215293884,
0.47088396549224854,
0.6290181279182434,
0.499751478433609,
-0.3109864890575409,
-0.32284748554229736,
0.034085776656866074,
-0.7295137047767639,
-0.8003293871879578,
-0.08017531782388687,
-0.22268076241016388,
0.42663636803627014,
0.5877034664154053,
-0.0006670657894574106,
0.9537580609321594,
-0.4403226673603058,
0.6797013878822327,
0.17076921463012695,
-1.0884402990341187,
0.4378594160079956,
-0.12376179546117783,
0.6484485268592834,
0.6624804735183716,
0.24828611314296722,
-0.2956022024154663,
-0.9503480195999146,
-0.9043211936950684,
-0.6812916994094849,
0.5270208716392517,
0.45370766520500183,
-0.05370811000466347,
-0.19163919985294342,
0.6212390065193176,
0.43103915452957153,
0.3445432186126709,
-0.32584232091903687,
-0.10008957237005234,
0.08840696513652802,
-0.0860140472650528,
0.2602040469646454,
0.025523589923977852,
0.07124657183885574,
-0.4993007183074951,
0.3151128590106964,
-0.20624876022338867,
0.7761790752410889,
0.40633562207221985,
-0.30783510208129883,
-0.4364043176174164,
0.014294527471065521,
0.6051785349845886,
1.497156023979187,
0.11488322913646698,
0.49022504687309265,
0.17109331488609314,
-0.439468652009964,
0.10909352451562881,
-0.7604080438613892,
0.035060856491327286,
-0.1212676540017128,
0.3871486783027649,
0.7484501600265503,
0.25498461723327637,
-0.7136111259460449,
0.09660857170820236,
0.10968407988548279,
0.007187218405306339,
-0.41244208812713623,
0.2846539616584778,
-0.13798494637012482,
0.6888468861579895,
0.566487729549408,
0.2963380515575409,
0.20361869037151337,
-0.9212805032730103,
0.5715303421020508,
0.37890732288360596,
-0.5437941551208496,
-0.529627799987793,
0.7150579690933228,
0.04062208533287048,
-0.6255262494087219,
0.46303826570510864,
0.09847132861614227,
-0.708409309387207,
0.663892924785614,
0.4475667178630829,
1.2151103019714355,
-0.1520831435918808,
0.06148219853639603,
0.26044970750808716,
0.46193787455558777,
-0.08583257347345352,
0.2168712168931961,
-0.5143190026283264,
-0.6058915853500366,
-0.40352991223335266,
-0.3643451929092407,
-0.682010293006897,
0.09020897001028061,
-0.8824143409729004,
0.33579379320144653,
-0.5424386858940125,
-0.18655861914157867,
0.15635208785533905,
-0.5284478068351746,
-0.7470094561576843,
0.34102895855903625,
0.15191957354545593,
0.8137010931968689,
-0.19692601263523102,
0.8057777285575867,
0.19635358452796936,
-0.3268224895000458,
-0.4894000291824341,
0.5693331956863403,
-0.5551406741142273,
-1.0541216135025024,
0.3726339340209961,
0.4559348225593567,
-0.5687922835350037,
0.27118605375289917,
-0.48091116547584534,
-0.9439049959182739,
0.9360761046409607,
0.14782220125198364,
-0.7515592575073242,
-0.1516062319278717,
-0.09944122284650803,
0.6005238890647888,
-0.7241474986076355,
0.442867636680603,
1.1354377269744873,
0.3669363856315613,
-0.00726507231593132,
-1.178457260131836,
-0.09419780224561691,
0.10824102908372879,
0.1177438274025917,
0.11017554253339767,
-0.7214308381080627,
0.8802690505981445,
-0.5754170417785645,
-0.2142668068408966,
-0.1051495298743248,
0.5345984101295471,
0.24418103694915771,
0.22019164264202118,
0.5514636635780334,
0.3551875352859497,
0.7063544988632202,
-0.07401143014431,
1.2392418384552002,
-0.49775561690330505,
0.4687138497829437,
0.9560099244117737,
-0.1341019868850708,
0.6426973938941956,
0.8690031170845032,
-0.164286270737648,
1.183517575263977,
0.43360498547554016,
0.25643548369407654,
0.775117814540863,
0.4091792404651642,
0.05611796677112579,
0.0609835684299469,
0.09998099505901337,
-0.03323816508054733,
0.5593957304954529,
0.2195473164319992,
-0.5199095010757446,
0.16791976988315582,
0.38145002722740173,
-0.2807576060295105,
-0.022736823186278343,
-0.6658797860145569,
0.9496177434921265,
0.09560039639472961,
-1.0682318210601807,
1.0034372806549072,
-0.40566349029541016,
0.16331757605075836,
-0.1911001056432724,
-0.08999820053577423,
0.33718907833099365,
0.5206254720687866,
-0.0037513873539865017,
-1.0450806617736816,
0.6773838400840759,
0.09975786507129669,
-0.15615405142307281,
-0.17382366955280304,
0.6589122414588928,
-0.08718247711658478,
-0.27029532194137573,
0.3920170068740845,
0.3532786965370178,
0.18052411079406738,
-0.12889374792575836,
-0.5839387774467468,
0.28574255108833313,
-0.07111970335245132,
-0.5952088832855225,
-0.10576635599136353,
0.5265460014343262,
-0.33145418763160706,
0.8075250387191772,
0.10603008419275284,
-0.13067373633384705,
0.11316433548927307,
0.03182750567793846,
1.081695795059204,
-1.0075745582580566,
-0.5314059853553772,
-0.9919292330741882,
0.4490935206413269,
-0.06163659691810608,
-0.3342546820640564,
0.2378259301185608,
0.13242296874523163,
0.8516954183578491,
-0.24582406878471375,
0.8918631076812744,
-0.3832816481590271,
0.23478059470653534,
-0.33452075719833374,
0.4399494528770447,
-0.23991326987743378,
-0.015789592638611794,
-0.3141278326511383,
-1.0282002687454224,
0.14592096209526062,
0.9847339987754822,
-0.3867988586425781,
-0.0029343136120587587,
1.385806679725647,
0.10774742811918259,
0.03630029782652855,
0.2424028217792511,
0.059774283319711685,
0.3622988760471344,
0.03229697421193123,
0.5724360346794128,
0.6621485352516174,
-0.22407323122024536,
0.15118232369422913,
-0.5471373796463013,
-0.5414849519729614,
0.050029411911964417,
-0.6800230145454407,
-0.8931823968887329,
-0.6610361337661743,
-0.1810745894908905,
-0.4252442419528961,
-0.022583402693271637,
0.8693565130233765,
0.3513016998767853,
-0.9788517355918884,
-0.3218790888786316,
-0.9384457468986511,
0.29749879240989685,
-0.8329572677612305,
-0.2741415500640869,
0.17852863669395447,
-0.6743855476379395,
-0.5951300859451294,
0.11316829174757004,
0.5541394352912903,
-0.5023785829544067,
-0.5630453824996948,
0.17199832201004028,
-0.32195061445236206,
0.3055739402770996,
0.6467607617378235,
0.16164571046829224,
-0.8837254643440247,
-0.5878975987434387,
0.1131526455283165,
0.2817956507205963,
0.22637663781642914,
1.2340998649597168,
-1.0015209913253784,
0.7896260619163513,
0.1897650957107544,
0.5382292866706848,
0.5899014472961426,
-0.02837543934583664,
0.9901826977729797,
-0.5551923513412476,
0.41223669052124023,
0.27106308937072754,
0.15261410176753998,
0.07208044826984406,
-0.3869139552116394,
0.765887975692749,
0.18888366222381592,
-0.5769204497337341,
-1.014765977859497,
0.3537070155143738,
-0.9623464345932007,
-0.12609800696372986,
0.8521290421485901,
0.15479522943496704,
-0.47279590368270874,
-0.14592701196670532,
-0.38578709959983826,
0.5401598215103149,
0.04110916331410408,
1.2877360582351685,
0.8277646899223328,
-0.6820306777954102,
-0.5388814806938171,
-0.343250572681427,
0.4323078393936157,
0.1761874109506607,
-0.5931146740913391,
0.3827270567417145,
-0.42283037304878235,
-0.09898831695318222,
0.6900616884231567,
0.5228370428085327,
-0.09132487326860428,
0.3722120523452759,
0.07811504602432251,
-0.058751750737428665,
0.46526724100112915,
-0.6787410974502563,
0.07590696960687637,
0.015121351927518845,
0.12919600307941437,
-0.13256879150867462
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.02120v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.02120v1
|
Diver: Large Language Model Decoding with Span-Level Mutual Information Verification
| 2024-06-04T09:02:22 | 2024-06-04T09:02:22 |
Jinliang Lu, Chen Wang, Jiajun Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) have shown impressive capabilities in adapting
to various tasks when provided with task-specific instructions. However, LLMs
using standard decoding strategies often struggle with deviations from the
inputs. Intuitively, compliant LLM outputs should reflect the information
present in the input, which can be measured by point-wise mutual information
(PMI) scores. Therefore, we propose Diver, a novel approach that enhances LLM
Decoding through span-level PMI verification. During inference, Diver first
identifies divergence steps that may lead to multiple candidate spans.
Subsequently, it calculates the PMI scores by assessing the log-likelihood
gains of the input if the candidate spans are generated. Finally, the optimal
span is selected based on the PMI re-ranked output distributions. We evaluate
our method across various downstream tasks, and empirical results demonstrate
that Diver significantly outperforms existing decoding methods in both
performance and versatility.
|
[
-0.31298112869262695,
-0.4456631541252136,
0.4334530830383301,
0.5484586358070374,
-0.3042648136615753,
0.17601872980594635,
-0.22234666347503662,
-0.42393067479133606,
0.19096435606479645,
0.14035142958164215,
-0.6328189373016357,
-0.7889647483825684,
-0.8589737415313721,
0.3111456632614136,
-0.25247472524642944,
0.5869771838188171,
0.039176445454359055,
-0.04137232527136803,
0.05138993635773659,
0.1538473516702652,
-0.5166977643966675,
-0.3751392662525177,
-0.726027250289917,
-0.06903384625911713,
0.6450320482254028,
0.26727643609046936,
0.18459640443325043,
0.44954797625541687,
0.4218301475048065,
0.2377070039510727,
-0.255597323179245,
0.46736714243888855,
-0.6478517651557922,
0.05214705690741539,
-0.05002252385020256,
-0.5650079846382141,
-0.4310145676136017,
-0.3242782950401306,
1.0506352186203003,
0.7031583786010742,
0.02626238949596882,
-0.0012364069698378444,
0.0020012843888252974,
0.675209105014801,
-1.0617130994796753,
0.3302469253540039,
-0.5253910422325134,
0.011564857326447964,
-0.2943040132522583,
-0.17218463122844696,
-0.7790713906288147,
-0.2919010519981384,
-0.05703740566968918,
-0.25215405225753784,
-0.2176191210746765,
-0.1744726449251175,
0.8012627959251404,
0.18326276540756226,
-0.7923164963722229,
-0.14241059124469757,
-0.7279684543609619,
0.9142307639122009,
-0.9198083281517029,
0.6550161838531494,
0.4126189053058624,
0.06520789116621017,
0.03214156627655029,
-0.3107542097568512,
-0.4452454745769501,
0.10018090158700943,
-0.012782927602529526,
0.3204035460948944,
-0.25949254631996155,
0.13809511065483093,
0.05440715327858925,
0.5041084885597229,
-0.3766534626483917,
0.23590517044067383,
-0.09630147367715836,
-0.29540491104125977,
0.9342172741889954,
0.30227306485176086,
0.3838980197906494,
-0.02553704008460045,
-0.15715767443180084,
-0.12713320553302765,
-0.938697099685669,
0.20817896723747253,
0.5995943546295166,
0.22393475472927094,
-0.26588261127471924,
0.648157000541687,
-0.5354067087173462,
0.652553379535675,
0.10619240999221802,
-0.16260598599910736,
0.14327776432037354,
-0.5064084529876709,
0.11140450835227966,
0.022133227437734604,
0.6860650181770325,
0.38859766721725464,
0.1344788521528244,
0.07053656131029129,
-0.3712449371814728,
-0.40645796060562134,
-0.2296406626701355,
-0.8645193576812744,
-0.09414573013782501,
0.10907342284917831,
-0.41514164209365845,
-0.03917354345321655,
0.28009724617004395,
-0.4215320348739624,
-0.2512238025665283,
-0.03896557539701462,
0.2853424549102783,
-0.42133575677871704,
-0.662945568561554,
0.6187558770179749,
-0.05366099625825882,
0.4289172887802124,
0.2558225691318512,
-0.9432635307312012,
0.08049748837947845,
0.8627333641052246,
0.935077428817749,
-0.05663887411355972,
-0.41977182030677795,
-0.7614715695381165,
0.20737411081790924,
-0.4187030494213104,
0.4775755703449249,
-0.5627447962760925,
-0.30054134130477905,
0.1611699014902115,
-0.17813707888126373,
-0.35400766134262085,
-0.3259645998477936,
0.46070560812950134,
-0.795249342918396,
0.10015812516212463,
-0.3734579086303711,
-0.8637212514877319,
-0.07267414778470993,
0.2610892653465271,
-0.8152605891227722,
0.6657764315605164,
0.09277865290641785,
-1.2025694847106934,
0.19510626792907715,
-0.5732786655426025,
-0.5883479118347168,
0.03776790201663971,
0.08948937058448792,
-0.31659865379333496,
0.2717418074607849,
0.2581891417503357,
0.51995450258255,
0.021387828513979912,
0.058201730251312256,
-0.31509077548980713,
-0.4146624505519867,
0.08383189141750336,
-0.572492778301239,
0.6609423756599426,
-0.019594600424170494,
0.005930165760219097,
0.05270629748702049,
-0.6520861387252808,
-0.10128539800643921,
0.009252372197806835,
-0.8833429217338562,
-0.4908806383609772,
0.20133447647094727,
-0.3330570459365845,
-0.3034858703613281,
0.36107340455055237,
-0.7211799025535583,
0.18122658133506775,
-0.3251393735408783,
0.45617246627807617,
0.6169646382331848,
0.22955110669136047,
0.32832959294319153,
-0.17490334808826447,
0.3806752562522888,
-0.027489926666021347,
-0.09889348596334457,
-0.171939879655838,
-0.28031134605407715,
-0.6467718482017517,
-0.6685629487037659,
0.4362640380859375,
0.5672877430915833,
-0.5291982889175415,
0.7396502494812012,
-0.45393359661102295,
-0.24765194952487946,
-0.44091731309890747,
0.01830677129328251,
0.2000855952501297,
0.3043745160102844,
0.28583016991615295,
-0.32791203260421753,
-0.7067886590957642,
-0.6153833866119385,
-0.19351433217525482,
-0.4113621413707733,
-0.1587173491716385,
0.3577331304550171,
0.26773545145988464,
-0.438448965549469,
0.9208257794380188,
-0.5508530139923096,
0.045441534370183945,
-0.5420958995819092,
0.17880088090896606,
0.5156165361404419,
0.26928022503852844,
0.13666854798793793,
-0.47664687037467957,
-0.4135754108428955,
-0.11943233758211136,
-0.5092976093292236,
-0.3078308701515198,
-0.22631913423538208,
-0.18353034555912018,
-0.02901604026556015,
0.5034459233283997,
-0.6354342103004456,
0.1536826193332672,
0.7842077612876892,
-0.5283448100090027,
0.7463083863258362,
-0.17381329834461212,
0.2250935435295105,
-0.9806261658668518,
0.11478220671415329,
0.051766589283943176,
-0.4215063452720642,
-0.36634236574172974,
0.12312236428260803,
0.13927298784255981,
0.47583088278770447,
-0.0020243115723133087,
0.34032735228538513,
-0.5567763447761536,
0.013400186784565449,
-0.2259325534105301,
-0.0828884094953537,
0.11373283714056015,
0.04681755602359772,
0.21975943446159363,
0.6077215671539307,
0.5197101831436157,
-0.5399680733680725,
0.40796414017677307,
0.11447041481733322,
-0.5418925881385803,
0.5298429727554321,
-0.7802590131759644,
-0.04885558784008026,
-0.24491959810256958,
0.5325813889503479,
-1.0469233989715576,
-0.2614284157752991,
-0.15082411468029022,
-0.18970687687397003,
0.3600638806819916,
-0.30403631925582886,
-0.47257035970687866,
-0.19007055461406708,
-0.29225802421569824,
0.7539714574813843,
0.32381677627563477,
-0.7120612263679504,
0.670081377029419,
0.2783084511756897,
-0.15915901958942413,
-0.8538091778755188,
-0.5987849831581116,
0.07260517030954361,
-0.11592881381511688,
-0.7473313212394714,
0.28209951519966125,
-0.21764959394931793,
-0.1649753749370575,
-0.1977178156375885,
-0.35751909017562866,
-0.0655120387673378,
0.10153739899396896,
0.2738988697528839,
0.15394853055477142,
-0.393160343170166,
-0.21225416660308838,
0.23510397970676422,
-0.07805133610963821,
0.2523137629032135,
-0.22983086109161377,
0.6819930672645569,
-0.08283377438783646,
-0.589654803276062,
-0.6399294137954712,
0.4418928325176239,
0.6340500712394714,
-0.5512270331382751,
0.6621127724647522,
0.718485414981842,
-0.3307633697986603,
-0.395362913608551,
-0.40047550201416016,
-0.11466983705759048,
-0.46871036291122437,
0.527313232421875,
-0.710996150970459,
-1.0425314903259277,
0.3790966272354126,
-0.3163253664970398,
0.02342631295323372,
0.26243188977241516,
0.41121500730514526,
-0.03142530098557472,
0.8972931504249573,
0.8769916892051697,
-0.4782557189464569,
0.4617201089859009,
-0.35995548963546753,
0.3977600634098053,
-0.7483185529708862,
-0.3900723457336426,
-0.26051202416419983,
-0.2888633608818054,
0.017710546031594276,
-0.3547411561012268,
0.2200770527124405,
0.5477234721183777,
-0.20590560138225555,
0.2713530957698822,
0.0707545205950737,
0.8186236023902893,
0.4770466387271881,
0.18053893744945526,
0.5374744534492493,
-0.2492690235376358,
-0.18188641965389252,
0.08179918676614761,
-0.5054348707199097,
-0.15012270212173462,
0.7383988499641418,
0.6747937798500061,
0.85899817943573,
0.3527798652648926,
0.9431806206703186,
0.43446260690689087,
-0.0408274345099926,
-0.7305117845535278,
0.5219864249229431,
-0.10819821804761887,
-0.18582160770893097,
-0.42736363410949707,
-0.7724896669387817,
-0.7622402310371399,
0.266064316034317,
-0.12956854701042175,
-0.6199350357055664,
0.11690063774585724,
-0.15192659199237823,
-0.2218974530696869,
0.33322957158088684,
-0.5936214923858643,
0.5885147452354431,
0.07497868686914444,
-0.07592526823282242,
-0.40053221583366394,
-0.4712190330028534,
0.5709603428840637,
-0.04462898150086403,
-0.005900292657315731,
-0.15884371101856232,
-0.21975462138652802,
0.4400700628757477,
-0.33939287066459656,
1.04129958152771,
-0.19598913192749023,
-0.5897208452224731,
0.05860770493745804,
0.3598577380180359,
0.5498682856559753,
0.5154216885566711,
-0.23801857233047485,
0.28278788924217224,
-0.11557720601558685,
-0.3600868284702301,
-0.36894306540489197,
0.6965048909187317,
-0.8406998515129089,
-0.4029434323310852,
0.007813332602381706,
-0.6548906564712524,
-0.2047947645187378,
0.29688942432403564,
0.2194441854953766,
0.26333773136138916,
-0.21280843019485474,
-0.008568240329623222,
0.6978340744972229,
-0.20061463117599487,
0.605005145072937,
0.5980342030525208,
0.07056525349617004,
-0.3991306722164154,
0.7027289867401123,
-0.5087944269180298,
0.16430701315402985,
0.9304284453392029,
0.06273479014635086,
-0.47457027435302734,
-0.8249288201332092,
-0.3114042580127716,
0.48725083470344543,
-0.6813366413116455,
-0.33575764298439026,
-0.30783963203430176,
-0.3816871643066406,
-0.05581645295023918,
0.07986914366483688,
-0.5288975834846497,
-0.017507778480648994,
-0.14942166209220886,
-0.08925425261259079,
-0.0034138443879783154,
0.8854151368141174,
-0.2983380854129791,
0.09863308817148209,
-0.9441342949867249,
0.0488513708114624,
0.38373586535453796,
0.4716567397117615,
-0.13985086977481842,
-0.49170029163360596,
-0.2080109417438507,
0.09083382785320282,
0.37166887521743774,
-0.8298389315605164,
0.15212109684944153,
0.2757233679294586,
0.42948225140571594,
0.8099767565727234,
0.10376464575529099,
0.4612164795398712,
-0.6352231502532959,
0.5904919505119324,
0.20252370834350586,
-1.476653814315796,
0.28645288944244385,
-0.2108674794435501,
0.38897648453712463,
0.26440107822418213,
0.47080889344215393,
-0.7079741358757019,
-0.373225599527359,
0.002425271784886718,
-0.7533599138259888,
0.44371914863586426,
-0.17219047248363495,
0.2687394320964813,
-0.03286334499716759,
0.20520256459712982,
-0.04718529433012009,
-0.20186445116996765,
-0.780297577381134,
0.10372120887041092,
0.11106517165899277,
-0.4054544270038605,
0.016806885600090027,
-0.42618635296821594,
0.02925650216639042,
-0.00836421549320221,
0.35952436923980713,
-0.11233147233724594,
0.0783691257238388,
0.1089007556438446,
-0.3393051326274872,
-0.03567386046051979,
0.14361560344696045,
0.46636343002319336,
0.5685805082321167,
-0.1588284820318222,
0.5470389127731323,
0.24743016064167023,
-0.30731892585754395,
0.05798614025115967,
-0.20524141192436218,
0.09907063096761703,
0.2425656020641327,
0.850570023059845,
0.7501665949821472,
-0.003207219997420907,
-0.6261447072029114,
0.9839092493057251,
-0.16516171395778656,
-0.12855757772922516,
0.07026401907205582,
0.017837559804320335,
0.37845346331596375,
0.5159569978713989,
0.3025607466697693,
0.002129301195964217,
-0.07867473363876343,
-0.1280861645936966,
0.18307171761989594,
0.4270947277545929,
-0.048475589603185654,
-0.5370978713035583,
0.3194156885147095,
0.25400739908218384,
0.003977566491812468,
0.7402207255363464,
-0.15928079187870026,
-0.4194406270980835,
0.2634001076221466,
0.5778893232345581,
0.557595431804657,
-0.455780029296875,
0.3171706199645996,
0.5950224995613098,
0.37636521458625793,
-0.21587400138378143,
0.3238082528114319,
-0.1894400715827942,
-0.7377811670303345,
-0.9632154107093811,
-0.5353358387947083,
-0.27066493034362793,
0.04808536916971207,
-0.7127087116241455,
0.21050085127353668,
-0.2771395444869995,
0.07035969942808151,
-0.31927353143692017,
-0.25418412685394287,
-0.4567049741744995,
0.02154822088778019,
0.5492198467254639,
1.212178349494934,
-1.0695892572402954,
0.7571291327476501,
0.1676032394170761,
-0.21906043589115143,
-0.7242743968963623,
0.2644819915294647,
-0.1920800805091858,
-0.8012771606445312,
0.7312985062599182,
0.22413504123687744,
-0.41224080324172974,
0.03138549253344536,
-0.4284239411354065,
-0.9771262407302856,
1.081249475479126,
0.4778914451599121,
-0.7248958945274353,
-0.10087000578641891,
0.22955536842346191,
0.2347300797700882,
-0.403114914894104,
0.37833404541015625,
0.3815757632255554,
0.3461914658546448,
-0.05517406389117241,
-0.7710676193237305,
0.19003921747207642,
-0.21158263087272644,
0.12531429529190063,
0.18032194674015045,
-0.34830495715141296,
0.7608227133750916,
-0.48756712675094604,
-0.49432697892189026,
0.10300720483064651,
0.7530825734138489,
0.2758874297142029,
0.10272891074419022,
0.8060553669929504,
0.5720829367637634,
0.9018070101737976,
0.03703952208161354,
0.9572854042053223,
-0.42494505643844604,
0.3084879517555237,
0.9014567136764526,
-0.23051340878009796,
1.3120479583740234,
0.24092648923397064,
-0.17118456959724426,
0.8028076887130737,
0.6012067794799805,
0.018364885821938515,
0.6210123896598816,
0.4137296676635742,
-0.6206403374671936,
-0.41011399030685425,
0.02057262696325779,
-0.24334777891635895,
0.4563482701778412,
0.2904109060764313,
-0.23291005194187164,
-0.28166717290878296,
-0.19164423644542694,
-0.15774179995059967,
-0.12222541868686676,
-0.23653948307037354,
0.7309665679931641,
-0.08130371570587158,
-0.41996699571609497,
0.7319486141204834,
0.4675866663455963,
0.8968116044998169,
-0.6570883989334106,
0.0743837058544159,
-0.5476085543632507,
0.14831022918224335,
-0.3778060972690582,
-0.6856869459152222,
0.2675749361515045,
-0.006927854847162962,
-0.3921401798725128,
-0.1773305982351303,
0.5222139358520508,
-0.6750820279121399,
-0.10113372653722763,
0.28098636865615845,
0.5777296423912048,
0.04363654553890228,
-0.24393953382968903,
-0.22814634442329407,
0.3906204402446747,
0.02551351487636566,
0.0058086104691028595,
-0.02008756436407566,
0.3679584264755249,
0.25631070137023926,
0.6519675850868225,
0.4762907326221466,
0.208950012922287,
0.2020799070596695,
0.334152489900589,
0.6531866788864136,
-0.5543971657752991,
-0.4338604807853699,
-1.009764313697815,
0.5259109735488892,
-0.06350784003734589,
-0.19118613004684448,
0.7303317785263062,
0.702919065952301,
0.9358157515525818,
-0.23376886546611786,
0.7577670812606812,
0.24870680272579193,
0.1552954912185669,
-0.6012200713157654,
0.6048001646995544,
-0.24276086688041687,
0.4600411653518677,
-0.11120491474866867,
-0.8735709190368652,
-0.45849451422691345,
0.5118680596351624,
-0.3198081851005554,
-0.1519230157136917,
0.6534894704818726,
0.7711606621742249,
-0.24386583268642426,
0.02449512854218483,
0.19572371244430542,
0.03318014740943909,
0.2547622621059418,
1.1122311353683472,
1.2116717100143433,
-0.15642523765563965,
0.5272089838981628,
0.1328791081905365,
-0.25473925471305847,
-0.13459952175617218,
-0.8576204776763916,
-1.0143625736236572,
-0.40086209774017334,
-0.5161455273628235,
-0.3511280417442322,
-0.0733432024717331,
0.46696609258651733,
1.0369056463241577,
-0.6063975691795349,
-0.35501620173454285,
-0.2680763006210327,
0.3068048655986786,
-0.27548593282699585,
-0.19542327523231506,
0.26926523447036743,
-0.2579922378063202,
-0.9418244361877441,
0.8336295485496521,
0.37906888127326965,
-0.042210616171360016,
-0.2726512551307678,
-0.39851757884025574,
-0.09590046107769012,
0.3155004680156708,
0.6301082372665405,
0.13784772157669067,
-0.5561590194702148,
-0.11825474351644516,
-0.11461243033409119,
-0.3538268804550171,
-0.10651503503322601,
0.923996090888977,
-0.34454959630966187,
0.061667002737522125,
0.8302621841430664,
1.0189584493637085,
0.4806377589702606,
-0.0814966931939125,
0.7132315635681152,
-1.0727061033248901,
-0.3495664894580841,
0.045003797858953476,
0.622439980506897,
0.36202776432037354,
-0.1982671469449997,
0.34096530079841614,
0.1686706244945526,
-0.21936877071857452,
-0.7398898005485535,
0.5754796266555786,
-0.9635239839553833,
-0.3406558334827423,
1.2177760601043701,
-0.5831016898155212,
-0.07828175276517868,
0.17568162083625793,
-0.0526462122797966,
0.0629558116197586,
-0.2339152693748474,
0.6663601398468018,
0.6631671190261841,
0.2434300184249878,
-0.38709592819213867,
0.11710746586322784,
0.1466021090745926,
0.3748329281806946,
-0.7425682544708252,
0.144277885556221,
0.48827803134918213,
0.6149020195007324,
-0.02898671291768551,
0.476032555103302,
-0.09816504269838333,
0.049410928040742874,
0.14928923547267914,
-0.07073525339365005,
-0.10630648583173752,
-0.3101685047149658,
-0.4820936918258667,
0.2152274250984192,
0.18983159959316254,
-0.3667127788066864
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.02110v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.02110v1
|
UniOQA: A Unified Framework for Knowledge Graph Question Answering with Large Language Models
| 2024-06-04T08:36:39 | 2024-06-04T08:36:39 |
Zhuoyang Li, Liran Deng, Hui Liu, Qiaoqiao Liu, Junzhao Du
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
OwnThink stands as the most extensive Chinese open-domain knowledge graph
introduced in recent times. Despite prior attempts in question answering over
OwnThink (OQA), existing studies have faced limitations in model representation
capabilities, posing challenges in further enhancing overall accuracy in
question answering. In this paper, we introduce UniOQA, a unified framework
that integrates two complementary parallel workflows. Unlike conventional
approaches, UniOQA harnesses large language models (LLMs) for precise question
answering and incorporates a direct-answer-prediction process as a
cost-effective complement. Initially, to bolster representation capacity, we
fine-tune an LLM to translate questions into the Cypher query language (CQL),
tackling issues associated with restricted semantic understanding and
hallucinations. Subsequently, we introduce the Entity and Relation Replacement
algorithm to ensure the executability of the generated CQL. Concurrently, to
augment overall accuracy in question answering, we further adapt the
Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG) process to the knowledge graph.
Ultimately, we optimize answer accuracy through a dynamic decision algorithm.
Experimental findings illustrate that UniOQA notably advances SpCQL Logical
Accuracy to 21.2% and Execution Accuracy to 54.9%, achieving the new
state-of-the-art results on this benchmark. Through ablation experiments, we
delve into the superior representation capacity of UniOQA and quantify its
performance breakthrough.
|
[
-0.23060931265354156,
-0.708461582660675,
0.6324402689933777,
-0.12513002753257751,
-0.19764326512813568,
0.4995201528072357,
-0.07497241348028183,
-0.30275365710258484,
0.18756020069122314,
0.9028347730636597,
-0.44980958104133606,
-0.3826189339160919,
-0.08379887044429779,
0.06655125319957733,
-0.17942452430725098,
0.55265873670578,
-0.12373872101306915,
0.029757604002952576,
-0.3779996633529663,
-0.3802950382232666,
-0.2848437428474426,
-0.31673717498779297,
-0.45824745297431946,
-0.5221415162086487,
0.5278669595718384,
0.37585189938545227,
0.8595749139785767,
0.647971510887146,
0.12550407648086548,
0.34529879689216614,
-0.04566875100135803,
0.46914780139923096,
-0.3246341943740845,
0.08448988199234009,
-0.30918145179748535,
-0.2990020513534546,
-0.2977410852909088,
-0.4168826639652252,
0.6665433049201965,
1.0344018936157227,
-0.2566990852355957,
0.22497820854187012,
0.17837482690811157,
0.6635968089103699,
-0.4306843876838684,
0.04463367164134979,
-0.782168447971344,
-0.1083260178565979,
-0.14395707845687866,
-0.00573970889672637,
-0.19234836101531982,
-0.06745540350675583,
-0.0880640298128128,
-0.7914808392524719,
-0.20829515159130096,
0.1276322901248932,
0.4647495448589325,
0.45693743228912354,
-0.7427577376365662,
0.2740580439567566,
-0.4870169162750244,
0.39052191376686096,
-0.67861008644104,
0.408537358045578,
-0.14456908404827118,
0.445476233959198,
-0.5415759086608887,
-1.2452731132507324,
-0.6450988054275513,
0.26201707124710083,
0.05315804108977318,
0.24210380017757416,
-0.211856409907341,
0.4302347004413605,
0.14103175699710846,
0.34368035197257996,
-0.6561108827590942,
0.10243508219718933,
-0.5501152873039246,
-0.2520337998867035,
0.5619820952415466,
0.37352558970451355,
0.2098124772310257,
-0.4023120105266571,
-0.51255202293396,
0.1285616010427475,
-0.6635195016860962,
0.309099406003952,
0.0616975836455822,
0.2851113975048065,
0.5803967714309692,
0.6498469710350037,
-0.7685278058052063,
0.8220682740211487,
-0.14889022707939148,
0.32286614179611206,
0.04201171174645424,
0.04525085911154747,
-0.43930599093437195,
-0.1496618539094925,
1.1066559553146362,
0.08965615183115005,
0.22436641156673431,
-0.3487704396247864,
0.15264438092708588,
-0.38007888197898865,
0.2754167318344116,
-0.6140804886817932,
-0.4190056622028351,
0.4648076891899109,
-0.03011520393192768,
-0.08534100651741028,
0.00014049063611309975,
-0.622440755367279,
-0.5001575350761414,
-0.3619467318058014,
0.5014812350273132,
-0.3088250756263733,
-0.19357796013355255,
0.11551119387149811,
0.04311014339327812,
-0.18083588778972626,
0.49608731269836426,
-0.13215932250022888,
0.28615450859069824,
0.5044464468955994,
0.4356198310852051,
-0.31063637137413025,
-0.4927707314491272,
-0.43677347898483276,
0.26321542263031006,
-0.45228680968284607,
0.8273212313652039,
-0.197128564119339,
0.009970723651349545,
-0.23350019752979279,
-0.0375174880027771,
-0.15967661142349243,
-0.4367827773094177,
0.4762113094329834,
-0.9008509516716003,
0.13586191833019257,
-0.33883437514305115,
-0.7068189382553101,
-0.3766920864582062,
0.1590666025876999,
-0.5816513299942017,
1.108656406402588,
0.20927239954471588,
-1.0363006591796875,
-0.17521363496780396,
-0.8106111288070679,
0.006561788264662027,
0.3890816569328308,
-0.14055179059505463,
0.18159134685993195,
-0.12825128436088562,
0.2072555124759674,
0.2899611294269562,
-0.6764688491821289,
0.37017276883125305,
-0.34492698311805725,
-0.5103712677955627,
0.3343029320240021,
-0.36608028411865234,
1.0793246030807495,
0.24658097326755524,
-0.15752410888671875,
0.12831272184848785,
-0.5938611030578613,
0.6485438942909241,
0.16769544780254364,
-0.12539836764335632,
-0.34727704524993896,
-0.2915378212928772,
-0.3796444833278656,
0.17131446301937103,
0.36027148365974426,
-0.8768685460090637,
0.27345672249794006,
-0.4999723732471466,
0.48381179571151733,
0.5859975218772888,
0.018880097195506096,
0.3214418888092041,
-0.09712183475494385,
0.4623742401599884,
-0.08633268624544144,
0.03686380013823509,
0.14029204845428467,
-0.5881643295288086,
-0.45988929271698,
-0.1545945405960083,
0.5042545795440674,
0.5084030032157898,
-1.0575443506240845,
0.1052897647023201,
-0.32055428624153137,
-0.5006821751594543,
-0.7659646272659302,
0.3267904222011566,
0.3454246520996094,
0.7766664624214172,
0.4625106751918793,
-0.11551576852798462,
-0.39796096086502075,
-0.7584750056266785,
-0.40603864192962646,
-0.41150185465812683,
-0.13356955349445343,
0.14169827103614807,
0.3496840298175812,
-0.13304448127746582,
0.9062998294830322,
-0.6026512980461121,
-0.13593794405460358,
-0.20993657410144806,
0.2883729636669159,
0.2682855725288391,
0.0814787819981575,
0.10057402402162552,
-0.8190743327140808,
-0.514417827129364,
-0.06354164332151413,
-0.7287817001342773,
-0.06597555428743362,
0.32500073313713074,
-0.29706987738609314,
0.2545405924320221,
0.41766780614852905,
-0.6875485777854919,
0.5428429245948792,
0.3810253441333771,
-0.30095407366752625,
0.37426021695137024,
-0.23691968619823456,
0.3101192116737366,
-1.0554633140563965,
0.17147749662399292,
-0.7436574697494507,
-0.22713914513587952,
-0.4165847599506378,
0.3479709327220917,
0.19830422103405,
-0.15997253358364105,
-0.4603354036808014,
0.6063674092292786,
-0.3838934600353241,
-0.22123011946678162,
-0.31504949927330017,
0.28941234946250916,
0.3332451581954956,
0.7214094400405884,
-0.09558599442243576,
0.6885997653007507,
0.32682135701179504,
-0.4549047350883484,
0.8395535945892334,
0.30142512917518616,
-0.2759116291999817,
0.22833870351314545,
-0.843166172504425,
0.26214897632598877,
-0.1611703485250473,
0.2766006886959076,
-1.1899152994155884,
-0.18994086980819702,
0.1180809736251831,
-0.5370768308639526,
0.02003210410475731,
-0.20311599969863892,
-0.726412296295166,
-0.8035646677017212,
-0.09527706354856491,
0.3262022137641907,
0.2818957269191742,
-0.7048234939575195,
0.6616679430007935,
0.2953570783138275,
0.07186506688594818,
-0.8940609097480774,
-0.4897267520427704,
-0.08330915868282318,
0.08353184908628464,
-0.8075502514839172,
0.36167261004447937,
-0.3053469955921173,
0.04489763453602791,
0.27627888321876526,
-0.06857169419527054,
-0.313585102558136,
0.1260254979133606,
0.01222032867372036,
0.11571897566318512,
-0.24572613835334778,
0.22011061012744904,
0.12866835296154022,
-0.06771925836801529,
0.08107009530067444,
-0.5661661624908447,
0.4928727149963379,
0.021247217431664467,
-0.25752294063568115,
-0.41811200976371765,
0.3571797013282776,
0.7959861159324646,
-0.541721522808075,
0.5289472341537476,
0.3209695518016815,
-0.3350045084953308,
-0.1790769398212433,
-0.24333198368549347,
0.034581590443849564,
-0.49018070101737976,
0.37444090843200684,
-0.5253235101699829,
-0.8936018943786621,
0.6358943581581116,
-0.06636366993188858,
0.20487776398658752,
0.5024051666259766,
0.40964579582214355,
-0.28973811864852905,
1.0389249324798584,
0.348742812871933,
0.10644128918647766,
-0.1521490514278412,
-0.08190706372261047,
0.06420480459928513,
-1.0387006998062134,
-0.256899356842041,
-0.3793596625328064,
-0.01425801683217287,
-0.5100347399711609,
-0.7341304421424866,
0.5102976560592651,
0.15285523235797882,
-0.7008838653564453,
0.29031434655189514,
-0.538842499256134,
0.38589030504226685,
0.6512883901596069,
-0.059264399111270905,
0.706709086894989,
-0.055265653878450394,
-0.4681624174118042,
-0.010619313456118107,
-0.8021007180213928,
-0.1306028664112091,
1.1569417715072632,
0.03225450962781906,
0.8003917932510376,
0.036964017897844315,
0.5093920230865479,
0.03913631662726402,
0.20623134076595306,
-0.4797247350215912,
0.4392169415950775,
-0.08825511485338211,
-0.757672131061554,
-0.704861044883728,
-0.7431625127792358,
-0.8644968271255493,
0.5292323231697083,
-0.12081931531429291,
-0.966179370880127,
-0.16394060850143433,
0.08008915185928345,
-0.45600375533103943,
0.7830309271812439,
-0.14444084465503693,
1.066351056098938,
-0.3156157433986664,
-0.34170153737068176,
0.05965006723999977,
-0.5369874238967896,
0.33102938532829285,
-0.062176719307899475,
-0.12543293833732605,
-0.05039864405989647,
-0.07336635887622833,
0.7587897777557373,
-0.2988852262496948,
0.4620667099952698,
-0.03948710858821869,
0.008358485996723175,
0.6599462628364563,
0.18273679912090302,
0.4701601266860962,
0.1697005033493042,
-0.20914186537265778,
0.008977114222943783,
0.4030594825744629,
-0.40574827790260315,
-1.0008037090301514,
0.7076772451400757,
-0.7879546284675598,
-0.7093252539634705,
-0.3128345012664795,
-0.7180877327919006,
-0.5564915537834167,
0.42888760566711426,
0.3447318971157074,
0.4859238862991333,
-0.2810421586036682,
0.20224390923976898,
0.6349778771400452,
-0.21426862478256226,
0.04996088892221451,
0.6401687860488892,
-0.4857172966003418,
-0.6048732995986938,
0.5592203140258789,
0.2652212083339691,
0.182782381772995,
0.49052974581718445,
0.21453633904457092,
-0.6981226801872253,
-0.42297300696372986,
-0.850068211555481,
0.34592604637145996,
-0.61097651720047,
-0.4549543857574463,
-1.0395537614822388,
-0.35015127062797546,
-0.7159352898597717,
0.39692121744155884,
-0.6779865622520447,
-0.5254707932472229,
0.14331582188606262,
0.1418534517288208,
0.3055558204650879,
0.6824684739112854,
0.08775236457586288,
0.13219653069972992,
-0.7085115909576416,
0.42720699310302734,
0.5729151368141174,
0.3349190056324005,
-0.15254200994968414,
-0.7144516110420227,
0.019781168550252914,
0.3443910777568817,
-0.25005149841308594,
-1.0164257287979126,
0.07211168110370636,
-0.14310581982135773,
0.5431131720542908,
0.104575976729393,
0.6925811767578125,
0.8261975646018982,
-0.3327508270740509,
0.34695422649383545,
0.016563381999731064,
-0.700485348701477,
0.1726406365633011,
-0.4237790107727051,
0.4459695518016815,
0.7709295749664307,
0.4544219374656677,
-0.7007607817649841,
-0.325458288192749,
-0.7225267887115479,
-0.6732751727104187,
0.49477240443229675,
0.1245218887925148,
-0.13455332815647125,
0.4159706234931946,
0.4965135455131531,
-0.30799776315689087,
0.4324258267879486,
-0.48481181263923645,
-0.41162851452827454,
-0.11761502921581268,
-0.3414415121078491,
0.1238616481423378,
-0.04491841048002243,
-0.07195892184972763,
-0.43809857964515686,
0.5677081942558289,
-0.4555434584617615,
0.4146612286567688,
0.2524617314338684,
0.1555999368429184,
-0.3445582091808319,
0.14860320091247559,
-0.3844354450702667,
0.8105698227882385,
-0.10104865580797195,
-0.04300278052687645,
0.2846483290195465,
0.03075600229203701,
-0.2570938766002655,
0.2776591181755066,
-0.20300927758216858,
-0.22424674034118652,
0.1027693822979927,
0.26063740253448486,
0.022843481972813606,
-0.8159643411636353,
0.5661143064498901,
-0.13964921236038208,
-0.09905532747507095,
-0.3899560570716858,
-0.03133898973464966,
0.33747440576553345,
0.2794896066188812,
0.4017670452594757,
-0.31547388434410095,
0.37321963906288147,
-0.6943302750587463,
0.29476499557495117,
0.36649054288864136,
-0.4954543113708496,
-0.02883295714855194,
0.8139164447784424,
0.03920799493789673,
-0.007638794835656881,
0.76729816198349,
-0.15625102818012238,
-0.830123245716095,
0.5920851230621338,
0.4346754550933838,
0.41433221101760864,
-0.2608470618724823,
0.4936389923095703,
0.38317185640335083,
0.1363736391067505,
0.2603142261505127,
0.4898280203342438,
-0.06466582417488098,
-0.7830590009689331,
-0.46945250034332275,
-0.4793725311756134,
-0.5149912238121033,
0.05572464317083359,
-0.6815322637557983,
-0.01339603029191494,
-0.32621538639068604,
0.38589370250701904,
-0.061484284698963165,
0.3737686574459076,
-0.4742816686630249,
0.36662203073501587,
-0.09807636588811874,
0.8576493263244629,
-0.3566116690635681,
0.9650262594223022,
1.1559988260269165,
-0.27680501341819763,
-1.1888145208358765,
-0.17654068768024445,
-0.05767188221216202,
-0.6166520714759827,
0.2585422694683075,
-0.08691561967134476,
-0.08147380501031876,
0.14107294380664825,
-0.5212301015853882,
-0.9459704160690308,
1.2375956773757935,
0.4817031919956207,
-0.2215510606765747,
-0.010392416268587112,
0.2587132453918457,
0.5741938352584839,
-0.42245519161224365,
0.352485328912735,
0.41561993956565857,
0.27734798192977905,
0.5118418335914612,
-0.830168604850769,
0.14513538777828217,
-0.0926237553358078,
-0.2995556592941284,
0.332762211561203,
-0.776452362537384,
0.8261525630950928,
-0.36234572529792786,
-0.20570461452007294,
0.42662331461906433,
0.9677487015724182,
0.2134854793548584,
0.4021346867084503,
0.5270022749900818,
0.4690571427345276,
1.141163945198059,
0.053678322583436966,
0.6582875847816467,
-0.284709095954895,
0.20801156759262085,
1.346143364906311,
-0.13318319618701935,
0.7683073282241821,
0.12363693863153458,
-0.12980522215366364,
0.5762319564819336,
0.5485660433769226,
0.39286407828330994,
0.13399016857147217,
0.14670531451702118,
-0.04057692363858223,
-0.5775401592254639,
-0.1700020730495453,
-0.21537108719348907,
0.7455451488494873,
0.0495622381567955,
0.0005897870287299156,
-0.22795382142066956,
-0.24372461438179016,
0.10008083283901215,
0.35383862257003784,
-0.2783794105052948,
0.518549919128418,
-0.048104338347911835,
-0.9274943470954895,
0.4549146592617035,
0.06532315909862518,
0.16298602521419525,
-0.4238199293613434,
0.019324464723467827,
-0.31109240651130676,
0.034916914999485016,
-0.03708721697330475,
-0.9855615496635437,
0.15392126142978668,
-0.18386349081993103,
0.12516728043556213,
0.07753423601388931,
0.6498878002166748,
-0.5514355301856995,
-0.38368505239486694,
0.5963215231895447,
0.7813204526901245,
0.1002659723162651,
-0.4545949399471283,
-1.0215328931808472,
-0.4412558674812317,
0.09253035485744476,
-0.10401248931884766,
0.10086556524038315,
0.9392199516296387,
-0.00016981229418888688,
0.806052565574646,
0.4599640369415283,
-0.0498153418302536,
0.07609813660383224,
-0.1607161909341812,
1.026919960975647,
-0.6758283376693726,
-0.49026399850845337,
-0.10054103285074234,
0.4433923363685608,
-0.20112432539463043,
-0.3532727062702179,
0.5246528387069702,
0.4247976243495941,
0.725515604019165,
0.41719603538513184,
0.5382125973701477,
-0.10098319500684738,
0.8477030396461487,
-0.2142685353755951,
0.713446319103241,
-0.9360736012458801,
0.0762367695569992,
-0.35002079606056213,
-0.8343954086303711,
-0.10524950921535492,
0.084283746778965,
-0.0480697900056839,
-0.15278902649879456,
0.7358737587928772,
0.72252357006073,
0.036481138318777084,
0.05843111500144005,
0.6102423667907715,
0.4059831500053406,
-0.007057561073452234,
0.8878873586654663,
0.8796036243438721,
-0.553607165813446,
0.8642032742500305,
-0.4696926176548004,
-0.10289855301380157,
0.3204246461391449,
-0.45510873198509216,
-0.9277380108833313,
-0.6679713726043701,
-0.2471345067024231,
-0.326211154460907,
0.0684448629617691,
0.7653894424438477,
0.32924017310142517,
-0.555086612701416,
-0.12731972336769104,
0.05880673602223396,
0.30400094389915466,
-0.10974621772766113,
-0.19216597080230713,
0.6000525951385498,
-0.187173530459404,
-0.6814457774162292,
0.37803319096565247,
0.19629789888858795,
-0.2826627492904663,
-0.2159484624862671,
-0.029286259785294533,
-0.18276822566986084,
0.10630778968334198,
0.3387972116470337,
0.6079786419868469,
-0.4968317151069641,
-0.16185715794563293,
0.1990174949169159,
-0.0015478659188374877,
0.024797853082418442,
0.8808457255363464,
-0.8378273248672485,
0.6046022176742554,
0.5831469297409058,
0.8547109365463257,
0.3178115785121918,
0.19001100957393646,
0.5697981715202332,
-0.25551819801330566,
-0.1810331642627716,
0.22642874717712402,
0.4134279191493988,
0.32389190793037415,
-0.37209874391555786,
0.5413132905960083,
0.2606483995914459,
-0.527576744556427,
-0.6137571930885315,
0.34615176916122437,
-0.8164923191070557,
-0.5369529724121094,
0.91935133934021,
-0.26843565702438354,
-0.5526428818702698,
-0.49641311168670654,
-0.11248433589935303,
0.4290724992752075,
-0.21352450549602509,
0.4818180501461029,
0.15823644399642944,
-0.3189358115196228,
-0.14756856858730316,
-0.3678492605686188,
0.2820947766304016,
0.4689963459968567,
-0.5729513168334961,
0.26614364981651306,
0.41563311219215393,
0.4091113805770874,
0.09096227586269379,
0.7618573904037476,
-0.2482854276895523,
0.44560927152633667,
-0.34880751371383667,
0.1109391376376152,
-0.3760022819042206,
-0.48579689860343933,
0.028973177075386047,
0.34591346979141235,
0.13433687388896942,
-0.010548065416514874
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.02106v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.02106v1
|
MARS: Benchmarking the Metaphysical Reasoning Abilities of Language Models with a Multi-task Evaluation Dataset
| 2024-06-04T08:35:04 | 2024-06-04T08:35:04 |
Weiqi Wang, Yangqiu Song
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
To enable Large Language Models (LLMs) to function as conscious agents with
generalizable reasoning capabilities, it is crucial that they possess the
reasoning ability to comprehend situational changes (transitions) in
distribution triggered by environmental factors or actions from other agents.
Despite its fundamental significance, this ability remains underexplored due to
the complexity of modeling infinite possible changes in an event and their
associated distributions, coupled with the lack of benchmark data with
situational transitions. Addressing these gaps, we propose a novel formulation
of reasoning with distributional changes as a three-step discriminative
process, termed as MetAphysical ReaSoning. We then introduce the first-ever
benchmark, MARS, comprising three tasks corresponding to each step. These tasks
systematically assess LLMs' capabilities in reasoning the plausibility of (i)
changes in actions, (ii) states caused by changed actions, and (iii)
situational transitions driven by changes in action. Extensive evaluations with
20 (L)LMs of varying sizes and methods indicate that all three tasks in this
process pose significant challenges, even for state-of-the-art LLMs and LMs
after fine-tuning. Further analyses reveal potential causes for the
underperformance of LLMs and demonstrate that pre-training them on large-scale
conceptualization taxonomies can potentially enhance their metaphysical
reasoning capabilities. Our data and models are publicly accessible at
https://github.com/HKUST-KnowComp/MARS.
|
[
-0.4146391451358795,
-0.4617825746536255,
1.0684826374053955,
0.14011913537979126,
0.025236738845705986,
0.0628216341137886,
-0.36418095231056213,
-0.015027055516839027,
-0.3118787705898285,
0.8256174325942993,
-0.8242510557174683,
-0.669387936592102,
-0.6145228743553162,
0.18119099736213684,
-0.2582685649394989,
0.5935843586921692,
-0.04822058230638504,
-0.12988364696502686,
-0.032536279410123825,
-0.14649362862110138,
-0.3342789113521576,
-0.41979166865348816,
-0.3859903812408447,
-0.48959940671920776,
0.361367404460907,
0.23680421710014343,
0.7670894265174866,
0.3313383162021637,
0.7413612604141235,
0.24555793404579163,
-0.05643833801150322,
0.5140107274055481,
-0.24891401827335358,
0.3203490674495697,
-0.5188041925430298,
-0.6566370129585266,
-0.2582338750362396,
0.02583724819123745,
0.9204902052879333,
0.850919246673584,
-0.33646970987319946,
0.27252644300460815,
-0.016243087127804756,
0.7177973985671997,
-1.0579862594604492,
0.05469901114702225,
-1.0008939504623413,
-0.060487814247608185,
0.008744788356125355,
-0.2258477658033371,
-0.6067578196525574,
-0.17794832587242126,
-0.22921398282051086,
-0.6758844256401062,
0.24805523455142975,
-0.13159827888011932,
0.5089346170425415,
0.7019953727722168,
-0.5633740425109863,
-0.20351992547512054,
-0.918959379196167,
0.6160678863525391,
-0.5076363682746887,
0.7682847380638123,
0.386342316865921,
0.29105645418167114,
-0.29270702600479126,
-0.7295517921447754,
-0.6438837051391602,
-0.42730769515037537,
0.1546573042869568,
0.1294996589422226,
0.06963998824357986,
-0.0530889630317688,
0.46006321907043457,
-0.034506432712078094,
-0.2616894543170929,
-0.2926958501338959,
-0.1296246200799942,
0.034537676721811295,
0.42846712470054626,
0.5000834465026855,
0.020799696445465088,
-0.07563243061304092,
-0.19026973843574524,
-0.3790138065814972,
-0.7750705480575562,
-0.09763126075267792,
0.23465165495872498,
0.3680361807346344,
0.05402030795812607,
0.5254433155059814,
-0.19417820870876312,
0.5619045495986938,
-0.30933016538619995,
-0.12409792840480804,
0.31017184257507324,
-0.15352950990200043,
-0.33394354581832886,
-0.35588911175727844,
0.5606561303138733,
0.2621523141860962,
0.025339355692267418,
-0.12784509360790253,
-0.07381130009889603,
0.23820680379867554,
0.3872334957122803,
-0.7993205785751343,
-0.10773797333240509,
0.2425195276737213,
-0.33946630358695984,
0.0737006887793541,
-0.1638525426387787,
-0.4390345811843872,
-0.8656218647956848,
-0.6905714273452759,
0.2539897859096527,
-0.49839577078819275,
-0.4005747139453888,
0.4369756281375885,
-0.016189197078347206,
-0.204554483294487,
0.4832910895347595,
-0.6506451368331909,
0.670982837677002,
0.8234382271766663,
0.5592896342277527,
0.09933427721261978,
-0.46174103021621704,
-0.31847983598709106,
0.1270408183336258,
-0.5060728192329407,
0.8143584132194519,
-0.6892706751823425,
-0.47840824723243713,
-0.2979658842086792,
-0.06822028756141663,
-0.466531902551651,
-0.8459023237228394,
0.8342769145965576,
-0.34875622391700745,
-0.32476261258125305,
-0.5213757753372192,
-0.46483975648880005,
-0.03170650824904442,
0.48465418815612793,
-0.3309082090854645,
1.3199752569198608,
-0.0825309082865715,
-0.5232852697372437,
0.4543381929397583,
-0.758657693862915,
-0.13618142902851105,
-0.12987452745437622,
-0.11890475451946259,
-0.08750148862600327,
0.16885603964328766,
0.14504766464233398,
0.468980073928833,
-0.5768921375274658,
0.3717873692512512,
-0.4815569221973419,
-0.21684013307094574,
0.5032567977905273,
-0.24287475645542145,
0.6088348627090454,
0.2732534110546112,
-0.20690445601940155,
0.009660071693360806,
-0.8313781023025513,
0.20241154730319977,
0.037682630121707916,
0.035852205008268356,
-0.17838403582572937,
0.5374842286109924,
-0.3598809242248535,
0.35460004210472107,
0.012475140392780304,
-0.270841509103775,
0.15865522623062134,
-0.20842047035694122,
0.2962186634540558,
0.6625164151191711,
0.010556591674685478,
0.3886754512786865,
-0.06496508419513702,
0.20012405514717102,
0.007693762890994549,
0.24950332939624786,
-0.058367446064949036,
-0.2396392822265625,
-0.6299644112586975,
-0.35313427448272705,
-0.09529702365398407,
0.6230794787406921,
-0.5260874629020691,
0.15209652483463287,
-0.38973408937454224,
-0.6810947060585022,
-0.22328537702560425,
0.27896273136138916,
0.21181948482990265,
0.12553632259368896,
0.3603675365447998,
0.006759729702025652,
-0.29107922315597534,
-0.8251580595970154,
-0.3445628881454468,
-0.28860196471214294,
0.01308384444564581,
0.414347380399704,
0.8133531808853149,
-0.3286680281162262,
0.966444730758667,
-0.5800995826721191,
0.10332760214805603,
-0.08527317643165588,
0.2484348863363266,
0.2851676344871521,
0.19193747639656067,
0.25735849142074585,
-0.7634138464927673,
0.10557747632265091,
-0.022280726581811905,
-0.7925686836242676,
-0.34255895018577576,
-0.09338013827800751,
-0.3226742446422577,
-0.456319659948349,
0.7105359435081482,
-0.6960544586181641,
0.20678271353244781,
0.3507234454154968,
-0.3510741889476776,
0.5522881746292114,
-0.41296684741973877,
0.19767174124717712,
-1.0003734827041626,
0.031078936532139778,
-0.10387500375509262,
0.10734390467405319,
-0.5150282382965088,
0.2922811806201935,
0.24513384699821472,
-0.12104060500860214,
-0.34287360310554504,
0.8204799294471741,
-0.38443273305892944,
-0.161857470870018,
-0.32270073890686035,
0.31017589569091797,
-0.13075293600559235,
0.25778791308403015,
0.2236880213022232,
0.4962659180164337,
0.5100246667861938,
-0.9812376499176025,
0.2670944929122925,
0.07650168240070343,
-0.3095659017562866,
0.7435526847839355,
-0.2931872308254242,
-0.05738203600049019,
-0.18004129827022552,
0.6349100470542908,
-0.7697630524635315,
-0.015726663172245026,
0.3225384056568146,
-0.269126296043396,
-0.2938114106655121,
-0.05403963103890419,
-0.9715489745140076,
-0.3506394922733307,
0.061969317495822906,
0.25957775115966797,
0.222981795668602,
-0.2903149724006653,
0.8546177744865417,
-0.08832260966300964,
0.0717473030090332,
-0.4918607473373413,
-0.493707537651062,
0.2141900509595871,
-0.26163533329963684,
-0.4753681421279907,
0.2667849361896515,
-0.2835112512111664,
-0.6305872201919556,
-0.0012718461221083999,
-0.19902411103248596,
0.11765272915363312,
0.4057499170303345,
0.4929317235946655,
0.023136502131819725,
-0.029827222228050232,
0.38530784845352173,
0.025223875418305397,
-0.16939213871955872,
0.37432920932769775,
-0.15186889469623566,
0.3434710204601288,
-0.10665562003850937,
-0.6810669898986816,
-0.1603774130344391,
-0.17781686782836914,
0.6314951777458191,
-0.39399033784866333,
0.9617030024528503,
0.45455047488212585,
-0.5984086394309998,
-0.4761756658554077,
-0.5313290357589722,
-0.17684012651443481,
-0.387748658657074,
0.24394486844539642,
-0.7261499166488647,
-0.5050358772277832,
0.7362449765205383,
-0.6028552651405334,
-0.01757780835032463,
0.426365464925766,
0.7210515737533569,
0.23542281985282898,
0.9276149868965149,
0.2198992520570755,
0.5430357456207275,
0.3235189914703369,
-0.2817727327346802,
0.15437963604927063,
-1.124144196510315,
-0.2874267101287842,
-0.4533681571483612,
0.01270784717053175,
-0.4964817464351654,
-0.8823181390762329,
0.39524543285369873,
0.1613800972700119,
-0.5378179550170898,
0.1748322695493698,
-0.21301917731761932,
0.5968209505081177,
0.19132253527641296,
0.1100226417183876,
0.21105358004570007,
-0.3332323729991913,
-0.37621983885765076,
0.150040403008461,
-0.11030514538288116,
-0.8370189070701599,
1.250956416130066,
0.1999574452638626,
0.5979654788970947,
0.26088449358940125,
0.5631952285766602,
0.29030707478523254,
0.6405323147773743,
-0.26911285519599915,
0.8673149943351746,
-0.0019469276303425431,
-0.9439722895622253,
-0.05915108695626259,
-0.4746342897415161,
-0.8030238747596741,
0.7944815158843994,
-0.24266918003559113,
-1.0258580446243286,
0.17584753036499023,
-0.203281432390213,
-0.14171621203422546,
0.30631765723228455,
-0.6096084713935852,
0.7766194343566895,
-0.12728391587734222,
-0.4001537561416626,
-0.44853895902633667,
-0.7208405137062073,
0.30999240279197693,
-0.0719275251030922,
0.42721766233444214,
-0.7009231448173523,
-0.10051122307777405,
0.32217109203338623,
-0.3196585476398468,
0.8069168925285339,
-0.2477531135082245,
-0.2805235683917999,
0.27687621116638184,
0.30253392457962036,
0.4119933843612671,
0.10450088977813721,
-0.33536896109580994,
-0.18094585835933685,
0.09025311470031738,
-0.24015681445598602,
-0.8986066579818726,
0.48882028460502625,
-0.7794702649116516,
-0.4279138147830963,
-0.19993242621421814,
-0.5336359739303589,
-0.6736288070678711,
-0.026827992871403694,
-0.021917743608355522,
0.28959357738494873,
-0.341470867395401,
0.09127114713191986,
0.5532055497169495,
-0.04834136366844177,
0.015522579662501812,
0.9436829090118408,
-0.29868724942207336,
-0.4044005572795868,
0.7916286587715149,
-0.142388716340065,
0.4248920679092407,
0.516259491443634,
0.09985984861850739,
-0.3230222761631012,
-0.39953795075416565,
-0.3246145248413086,
0.2723686099052429,
-1.1252036094665527,
0.10453774780035019,
-0.6943243741989136,
-0.07754812389612198,
-0.08804916590452194,
-0.02436957322061062,
-0.4552505314350128,
-0.12827667593955994,
0.015753213316202164,
-0.021141832694411278,
-0.11549201607704163,
0.7264121174812317,
-0.14506395161151886,
0.27102023363113403,
-0.6961134672164917,
0.4645427465438843,
0.12094907462596893,
0.1467657834291458,
-0.10008788853883743,
-0.40664196014404297,
-0.21401628851890564,
0.1806691288948059,
-0.5274985432624817,
-0.88419508934021,
0.09418327361345291,
-0.014848494902253151,
0.675686776638031,
0.3269921541213989,
-0.01342005468904972,
0.5339891910552979,
-0.6060451865196228,
0.6282883882522583,
-0.13599269092082977,
-1.148820400238037,
0.6338815093040466,
-0.42045655846595764,
0.09503298252820969,
0.5429672598838806,
0.006731805857270956,
-0.4604260325431824,
-0.43794378638267517,
-0.6582095623016357,
-0.5299296379089355,
0.731637716293335,
0.539782702922821,
0.018116740509867668,
-0.1760873794555664,
0.3813810348510742,
0.034988146275281906,
0.2946746349334717,
-0.44719621539115906,
-0.24778619408607483,
0.10692602396011353,
-0.0007571743335574865,
-0.35664984583854675,
0.14528048038482666,
-0.28607648611068726,
-0.20196618139743805,
0.5443041324615479,
-0.20013976097106934,
0.16091176867485046,
0.010892972350120544,
-0.19654333591461182,
0.13355949521064758,
0.5601286888122559,
0.7179474830627441,
0.9522837400436401,
-0.22478872537612915,
0.42025139927864075,
0.4851190745830536,
-0.22954615950584412,
0.37565526366233826,
0.40916013717651367,
0.16093312203884125,
-0.4024380147457123,
0.35590943694114685,
0.7813261151313782,
0.27516189217567444,
-0.8096265196800232,
0.2962682247161865,
-0.04541569575667381,
-0.322410523891449,
-0.11305520683526993,
0.16541017591953278,
0.12777741253376007,
0.4648611545562744,
0.35973700881004333,
0.27685412764549255,
0.2335394024848938,
-0.5183745622634888,
-0.24905987083911896,
0.2781094014644623,
0.0036978900898247957,
-0.27012646198272705,
0.5763245820999146,
0.04654516652226448,
-0.007881274446845055,
0.4353506565093994,
-0.48144322633743286,
-0.4672050178050995,
0.6123824715614319,
0.4587019681930542,
0.757561445236206,
-0.28404322266578674,
0.48117759823799133,
0.3262937068939209,
0.5787608027458191,
-0.3505490720272064,
0.17040131986141205,
-0.3033630847930908,
-1.2379459142684937,
-0.28803393244743347,
-0.523796558380127,
-0.7942532300949097,
0.007259851787239313,
-0.5544387698173523,
0.01116812601685524,
-0.34651893377304077,
-0.3870648145675659,
-0.04179166629910469,
-0.09805234521627426,
-0.764305591583252,
0.5459102392196655,
0.3604317605495453,
0.7157477736473083,
-0.9935168027877808,
0.32346680760383606,
0.8335354328155518,
-0.122948057949543,
-0.5864624977111816,
0.11876112967729568,
0.08748554438352585,
-0.7359901666641235,
0.9641571640968323,
0.11584965884685516,
-0.5130320191383362,
-0.22434557974338531,
-0.3264741003513336,
-0.8053202033042908,
0.9585751891136169,
0.7747347950935364,
-0.26626721024513245,
0.2758410573005676,
0.2399328649044037,
0.7331912517547607,
-0.2622716426849365,
0.4614139795303345,
0.6928615570068359,
0.5794432163238525,
0.10764939337968826,
-0.781129777431488,
0.06347976624965668,
-0.30405393242836,
-0.10531620681285858,
0.4733487367630005,
-0.5039864182472229,
0.6860357522964478,
-0.3117367923259735,
-0.33840128779411316,
-0.0003751549811568111,
0.3405457139015198,
0.6096388101577759,
0.5599659085273743,
0.559637188911438,
0.9051836133003235,
1.0324183702468872,
-0.24574415385723114,
1.1292835474014282,
-0.37175291776657104,
0.3652924597263336,
1.0032117366790771,
-0.8040664196014404,
1.0398032665252686,
0.08857635408639908,
-0.3727618157863617,
0.7568984627723694,
0.6643039584159851,
0.295843243598938,
0.4368341863155365,
0.5267755389213562,
-0.490031361579895,
-0.7796651721000671,
-0.11765680462121964,
-0.3628726303577423,
0.2576885223388672,
0.7360365986824036,
-0.4020029604434967,
-0.21717320382595062,
0.046849023550748825,
-0.14598582684993744,
-0.024535663425922394,
-0.14681947231292725,
0.4975554049015045,
0.014557627961039543,
-0.7597241997718811,
0.48766061663627625,
0.04108523577451706,
-0.04866345599293709,
-0.5854047536849976,
0.06272689253091812,
0.12766075134277344,
0.5673667192459106,
-0.065794438123703,
-0.9087161421775818,
0.08969026803970337,
-0.13441666960716248,
-0.14481684565544128,
-0.35787060856819153,
0.43376487493515015,
0.02463209256529808,
-0.5697669982910156,
0.45568594336509705,
0.7814019322395325,
0.23304212093353271,
-0.33662086725234985,
-0.8272842764854431,
0.2494729608297348,
-0.3640567362308502,
-0.29174360632896423,
0.06326893717050552,
0.7262654304504395,
-0.129624143242836,
1.0061099529266357,
0.6461818218231201,
0.024064235389232635,
-0.058316443115472794,
0.5298655033111572,
0.7896935939788818,
-0.6660151481628418,
-0.32080724835395813,
-0.9979046583175659,
0.3864378035068512,
-0.05727348476648331,
-0.30135753750801086,
0.5232082009315491,
0.5180469155311584,
0.5140504240989685,
0.0971560999751091,
0.6297443509101868,
0.06752985715866089,
0.49318793416023254,
-0.6383488178253174,
0.08870017528533936,
-0.6134498119354248,
0.3470541834831238,
-0.31862685084342957,
-1.1018805503845215,
-0.2483597695827484,
0.46015849709510803,
-0.7433416247367859,
0.2147308737039566,
1.0558916330337524,
0.731514573097229,
-0.12271398305892944,
0.07826127111911774,
0.23057979345321655,
0.09994587302207947,
0.3130241930484772,
0.4039100706577301,
1.179129958152771,
-0.17958173155784607,
0.30215367674827576,
-0.024265578016638756,
0.05120111629366875,
0.002188324462622404,
-0.9218083620071411,
-0.9351662397384644,
-0.7144289016723633,
-0.3657270073890686,
-0.3193736970424652,
0.2213566154241562,
0.865998387336731,
0.765635073184967,
-0.44874683022499084,
-0.1414305418729782,
-0.37020424008369446,
0.03966034948825836,
-0.31190216541290283,
-0.1872662752866745,
0.24302154779434204,
-0.2735407054424286,
-0.4131563901901245,
0.4974853992462158,
0.37991902232170105,
-0.2739335596561432,
-0.07350296527147293,
-0.11029388010501862,
0.14091505110263824,
0.33493345975875854,
0.5818879008293152,
0.06756506115198135,
-1.0542351007461548,
-0.10048262029886246,
-0.17066197097301483,
-0.05067014321684837,
-0.22702965140342712,
0.9036969542503357,
-0.7017961144447327,
0.37507379055023193,
0.18812276422977448,
0.5085328221321106,
0.4970046281814575,
-0.024160653352737427,
0.297129362821579,
-0.5967096090316772,
-0.167234405875206,
0.03646111860871315,
0.4604437053203583,
0.3741467595100403,
0.05388253927230835,
0.7528881430625916,
0.2806001305580139,
-0.6000221967697144,
-0.9361861348152161,
0.3700399696826935,
-0.7369140386581421,
-0.27213409543037415,
1.2524420022964478,
0.020415859296917915,
0.18330715596675873,
0.19297941029071808,
-0.2880145013332367,
0.04038236290216446,
-0.07624936103820801,
0.4750123918056488,
0.9629331231117249,
-0.22238893806934357,
-0.19533230364322662,
-0.6878678202629089,
0.23847126960754395,
0.4223456084728241,
-1.1965731382369995,
0.3650345802307129,
0.46034249663352966,
0.3670651316642761,
0.3069647550582886,
0.615618884563446,
0.18234644830226898,
0.121086984872818,
0.1121593713760376,
-0.018757080659270287,
0.2152003049850464,
-0.3283082842826843,
0.12129568308591843,
0.11304362118244171,
0.09511171281337738,
0.027616925537586212
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.06577v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.06577v1
|
RAG-based Crowdsourcing Task Decomposition via Masked Contrastive Learning with Prompts
| 2024-06-04T08:34:19 | 2024-06-04T08:34:19 |
Jing Yang, Xiao Wang, Yu Zhao, Yuhang Liu, Fei-Yue Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Crowdsourcing is a critical technology in social manufacturing, which
leverages an extensive and boundless reservoir of human resources to handle a
wide array of complex tasks. The successful execution of these complex tasks
relies on task decomposition (TD) and allocation, with the former being a
prerequisite for the latter. Recently, pre-trained language models (PLMs)-based
methods have garnered significant attention. However, they are constrained to
handling straightforward common-sense tasks due to their inherent restrictions
involving limited and difficult-to-update knowledge as well as the presence of
hallucinations. To address these issues, we propose a retrieval-augmented
generation-based crowdsourcing framework that reimagines TD as event detection
from the perspective of natural language understanding. However, the existing
detection methods fail to distinguish differences between event types and
always depend on heuristic rules and external semantic analyzing tools.
Therefore, we present a Prompt-Based Contrastive learning framework for TD
(PBCT), which incorporates a prompt-based trigger detector to overcome
dependence. Additionally, trigger-attentive sentinel and masked contrastive
learning are introduced to provide varying attention to trigger and contextual
features according to different event types. Experiment results demonstrate the
competitiveness of our method in both supervised and zero-shot detection. A
case study on printed circuit board manufacturing is showcased to validate its
adaptability to unknown professional domains.
|
[
-0.3774011433124542,
-0.560950517654419,
0.5841056108474731,
0.0978771448135376,
-0.510596513748169,
0.38564538955688477,
-0.13732565939426422,
-0.27340513467788696,
0.20522339642047882,
0.4686594605445862,
-0.852875292301178,
-0.568591296672821,
-0.4528888761997223,
0.12063467502593994,
-0.01700529456138611,
0.8246564865112305,
0.03628193587064743,
-0.44962701201438904,
-0.14804382622241974,
-0.11320909112691879,
-0.22550204396247864,
-0.5798646807670593,
-0.9793029427528381,
-0.058229848742485046,
0.430027574300766,
0.4266990125179291,
0.12483863532543182,
0.5502753257751465,
0.14724090695381165,
0.36286208033561707,
-0.2763384282588959,
0.5389155745506287,
-0.4969419240951538,
0.24808044731616974,
-0.2944071292877197,
0.04171809181571007,
0.10139597952365875,
0.1723000556230545,
0.23094090819358826,
0.5951705574989319,
-0.13958017528057098,
0.354921817779541,
0.2617458701133728,
0.34637123346328735,
-0.9805591702461243,
0.2879997789859772,
-0.7950817346572876,
-0.11677160859107971,
-0.0846024677157402,
-0.15899887681007385,
-0.46211156249046326,
-0.043825194239616394,
-0.24321742355823517,
-0.7207764983177185,
0.7010196447372437,
-0.0436837300658226,
0.7100774049758911,
0.29952532052993774,
-0.03901977464556694,
-0.34966591000556946,
-0.2162250578403473,
0.7594038844108582,
-0.15799537301063538,
0.1443266123533249,
0.6647503972053528,
0.3001473844051361,
-0.03877083584666252,
-0.7992970943450928,
-0.5150161981582642,
-0.1236521378159523,
-0.13888655602931976,
0.23259885609149933,
-0.051428090780973434,
-0.08841117471456528,
0.13364309072494507,
0.04657161980867386,
-0.44399380683898926,
0.12686632573604584,
-0.3215187191963196,
-0.3233563303947449,
0.3015475273132324,
0.21329203248023987,
0.23666131496429443,
-0.5752018690109253,
-0.41855505108833313,
-0.04516482725739479,
0.06472547352313995,
-0.1653933823108673,
0.1924697458744049,
0.4324248433113098,
-0.22118566930294037,
0.17322492599487305,
-0.3480602204799652,
0.7114032506942749,
0.3160123825073242,
-0.06965404003858566,
0.09619630873203278,
-0.16958612203598022,
-0.2100202441215515,
-0.16877888143062592,
0.563396155834198,
0.15755896270275116,
-0.11061526089906693,
-0.3455573618412018,
-0.23898132145404816,
0.04290646314620972,
0.08991731703281403,
-0.7092064023017883,
-0.25677454471588135,
-0.07119058072566986,
-0.5948155522346497,
-0.3143874704837799,
0.08111415803432465,
-0.5845665335655212,
-0.8562862873077393,
-0.43196219205856323,
0.3679826557636261,
-0.2194995880126953,
-0.3687688112258911,
0.09771133959293365,
-0.18829692900180817,
0.35970911383628845,
0.4623546302318573,
-0.40915703773498535,
-0.016287188977003098,
0.8655263781547546,
0.8762146830558777,
-0.21164041757583618,
0.05545713007450104,
-1.14653480052948,
0.11597206443548203,
-0.07998920232057571,
0.8943740725517273,
-0.4132673442363739,
-0.5880659818649292,
-0.08521364629268646,
0.08656030893325806,
-0.11355996876955032,
-0.9668629169464111,
0.49980083107948303,
-0.5253646969795227,
0.35116592049598694,
-0.40737056732177734,
-0.13082532584667206,
-0.07338321954011917,
0.3409922420978546,
-0.5788919925689697,
0.7349519729614258,
-0.01608821377158165,
-0.7146772146224976,
0.4353528916835785,
-0.5636462569236755,
-0.4597156345844269,
0.30800661444664,
-0.2120787501335144,
-0.5612873435020447,
0.09424025565385818,
0.3136388063430786,
0.6266676187515259,
-0.05090121924877167,
0.48031800985336304,
-0.4307571351528168,
-0.2448275238275528,
0.11206690967082977,
-0.2283816933631897,
1.001758337020874,
0.3643702566623688,
-0.5064072012901306,
0.11712023615837097,
-1.1080583333969116,
-0.41230854392051697,
0.010382355190813541,
0.07415745407342911,
-0.05474894493818283,
-0.11128263175487518,
0.1348087042570114,
0.2839287519454956,
0.055905722081661224,
-0.40553638339042664,
-0.3311252295970917,
-0.07789604365825653,
0.04491369426250458,
0.9006460905075073,
0.3718980848789215,
0.3386264443397522,
-0.31454169750213623,
0.553208589553833,
0.005082889460027218,
-0.023945961147546768,
-0.35663577914237976,
-0.22406640648841858,
-0.6834093332290649,
-0.6048699021339417,
-0.2287270724773407,
0.5260173082351685,
-1.217920184135437,
0.2955135107040405,
0.3944261372089386,
-0.21825243532657623,
-0.31500276923179626,
-0.12786832451820374,
0.3688032925128937,
0.9855836629867554,
0.3542180061340332,
-0.20149897038936615,
-0.7135785818099976,
-0.6444796919822693,
-0.3370741605758667,
-0.1756826490163803,
-0.4159393608570099,
0.10782472789287567,
0.16071537137031555,
-0.035525064915418625,
0.7823122143745422,
-0.5102664232254028,
-0.5304036140441895,
-0.09166669845581055,
0.5984112620353699,
0.06892457604408264,
0.36950770020484924,
0.12742450833320618,
-0.6979608535766602,
-0.249065101146698,
-0.03453028202056885,
-0.49174657464027405,
-0.3743775486946106,
-0.2133777141571045,
0.0013439316535368562,
0.39289045333862305,
0.6207444667816162,
-0.35158804059028625,
0.6274299621582031,
0.10007753223180771,
-0.3283309042453766,
0.6599176526069641,
0.04209255054593086,
0.23213721811771393,
-1.167583703994751,
0.18240100145339966,
0.021224841475486755,
-0.2778945863246918,
-0.37764838337898254,
-0.16737432777881622,
-0.18614228069782257,
-0.5125845074653625,
-0.3769158124923706,
0.6391478180885315,
-0.5719464421272278,
-0.20964264869689941,
-0.5824618935585022,
0.3015817701816559,
0.04569782689213753,
0.5039264559745789,
0.3541015684604645,
0.6057897806167603,
0.3748260736465454,
-0.639141857624054,
0.18933188915252686,
0.1899489313364029,
-0.4558311104774475,
0.7238796949386597,
-0.41344964504241943,
0.30244460701942444,
-0.3210733234882355,
0.07681109011173248,
-0.8676019906997681,
-0.35079458355903625,
0.5315817594528198,
-0.6005949974060059,
-0.007912577129900455,
-0.15997081995010376,
-0.7567716240882874,
-0.0335923433303833,
-0.22576047480106354,
0.17694619297981262,
0.4951719045639038,
-0.7852082848548889,
0.5396673679351807,
0.34194260835647583,
-0.23746873438358307,
-0.3356376886367798,
-0.41091105341911316,
-0.10028757899999619,
-0.13578259944915771,
-0.37504345178604126,
0.2869262397289276,
0.050085388123989105,
-0.5358842015266418,
0.010553127154707909,
-0.33726242184638977,
-0.23967842757701874,
0.1679924577474594,
0.21346566081047058,
0.17689520120620728,
0.04277203977108002,
0.07705967128276825,
-0.229737788438797,
-0.45437222719192505,
0.06224869564175606,
0.011568083427846432,
0.32047340273857117,
0.31480324268341064,
-0.41115429997444153,
-0.5124750733375549,
0.4072208106517792,
0.32516980171203613,
-0.4579087495803833,
0.7251312136650085,
1.0098539590835571,
-0.5518231391906738,
-0.3353407084941864,
-0.9173672795295715,
-0.289389044046402,
-0.5654361844062805,
0.26351842284202576,
-0.08358696848154068,
-0.8318750858306885,
0.7611309289932251,
-0.07594722509384155,
-0.20170815289020538,
0.34662574529647827,
0.5552765130996704,
-0.011313749477267265,
0.5801584124565125,
0.4247548580169678,
0.054336514323949814,
0.5688460469245911,
-0.021399619057774544,
-0.07112450897693634,
-0.3922567069530487,
-0.4568592309951782,
-0.7097070217132568,
-0.08477136492729187,
-0.25991377234458923,
-0.7333563566207886,
0.20143261551856995,
-0.14417259395122528,
-0.23316679894924164,
-0.13643740117549896,
-0.686852216720581,
0.7270037531852722,
0.5738085508346558,
0.42619240283966064,
0.2268955409526825,
-0.05397826060652733,
0.4632623493671417,
0.10804720222949982,
-0.47250795364379883,
-0.30730196833610535,
0.3674758970737457,
-0.24187777936458588,
0.23812498152256012,
-0.39480021595954895,
1.0783209800720215,
0.1858876645565033,
0.3476533889770508,
-0.5926641225814819,
0.6996595859527588,
-0.09680195897817612,
-0.4598834812641144,
-0.22730191051959991,
-0.5036344528198242,
-0.8878737092018127,
0.13308186829090118,
-0.061966706067323685,
-0.6008510589599609,
0.5546733140945435,
-0.11206547170877457,
-0.2982701063156128,
0.5684512853622437,
-0.7488457560539246,
0.8081429600715637,
0.09188783168792725,
-0.41162896156311035,
-0.19469033181667328,
-0.5137212872505188,
0.06261155754327774,
0.13018067181110382,
0.4794037938117981,
-0.25189316272735596,
-0.1581265926361084,
0.8811748623847961,
-0.42090508341789246,
1.0802937746047974,
-0.4515624940395355,
0.23365242779254913,
0.45712822675704956,
0.12497052550315857,
0.6602010726928711,
0.14152850210666656,
-0.32055017352104187,
-0.25601717829704285,
-0.5297764539718628,
-0.5155690908432007,
-0.4423781633377075,
0.41080600023269653,
-0.43866440653800964,
-0.6786254048347473,
-0.1328212320804596,
-0.4631519615650177,
-0.1691567599773407,
-0.10380572080612183,
0.4266767203807831,
0.4413222074508667,
-0.10078095644712448,
0.0486367791891098,
0.5558633208274841,
-0.3387753665447235,
0.6295962929725647,
0.5700257420539856,
0.1781311333179474,
-0.4222697913646698,
0.9927423000335693,
0.017420286312699318,
-0.03475314751267433,
0.3098030090332031,
-0.05861926078796387,
-0.1027740016579628,
-0.46015429496765137,
0.11698582768440247,
0.11721435934305191,
-0.6581874489784241,
-0.31524449586868286,
-0.6362881064414978,
0.21905413269996643,
-0.33359819650650024,
-0.6844452619552612,
-0.04465532302856445,
-0.1070106029510498,
-0.8236747980117798,
-0.2846512198448181,
0.2814323604106903,
0.25662723183631897,
-0.42490625381469727,
-0.0352257564663887,
-0.5590949654579163,
0.7957791090011597,
0.6426805257797241,
0.44170770049095154,
-0.014503370970487595,
-0.44923895597457886,
-0.06533221155405045,
-0.2629251778125763,
-0.22608453035354614,
-0.852590024471283,
0.4605404734611511,
-0.1156635731458664,
0.5776109099388123,
0.21980132162570953,
0.5185949802398682,
0.6905598044395447,
-0.07587733119726181,
0.6078542470932007,
0.20634929835796356,
-1.0370533466339111,
0.5109996795654297,
-0.40082964301109314,
0.31361931562423706,
0.7584297060966492,
0.29558926820755005,
-0.49512913823127747,
-0.38598164916038513,
-0.8197424411773682,
-0.9109836220741272,
1.044668197631836,
-0.01652558520436287,
-0.049989424645900726,
-0.24826498329639435,
0.15728406608104706,
0.3510638177394867,
0.001792036578990519,
-0.5962129235267639,
-0.08200634270906448,
-0.09751679748296738,
-0.011506937444210052,
-0.029903443530201912,
-0.3972335755825043,
0.14927124977111816,
0.013609115965664387,
0.5250511765480042,
0.13418057560920715,
0.00037415928090922534,
0.12420813739299774,
-0.3047204911708832,
0.08545716851949692,
0.15993937849998474,
0.2741348445415497,
0.7623225450515747,
-0.06685657054185867,
0.14045275747776031,
0.10110283643007278,
-0.24215498566627502,
0.023499447852373123,
0.3911201059818268,
0.07523422688245773,
0.20481762290000916,
0.2810678780078888,
0.5612214207649231,
0.22291582822799683,
-0.6312615871429443,
0.25704601407051086,
0.22667354345321655,
-0.22336897253990173,
-0.010256055742502213,
-0.21074023842811584,
-0.09485641121864319,
0.4507049322128296,
0.8221182227134705,
-0.14914387464523315,
0.3685748279094696,
-0.3403974175453186,
0.4680422842502594,
0.23370081186294556,
-0.3140333890914917,
-0.1789308339357376,
0.5606017112731934,
0.37425702810287476,
-0.46148568391799927,
0.39965322613716125,
-0.9638200402259827,
-0.4498704969882965,
0.8803772926330566,
0.2685750424861908,
1.248768925666809,
-0.1267680525779724,
0.6549070477485657,
0.3122907876968384,
0.32098644971847534,
0.21790821850299835,
0.13294506072998047,
-0.43060436844825745,
-0.5230388045310974,
-0.5935471057891846,
-0.38480621576309204,
-0.6029793620109558,
0.32678863406181335,
-0.7304347157478333,
0.2706732153892517,
-0.46461644768714905,
0.11773069202899933,
-0.09447932988405228,
0.07564042508602142,
-0.6532801985740662,
0.03138305991888046,
0.22140681743621826,
0.3228151202201843,
-0.6902529001235962,
0.25828394293785095,
0.6865524649620056,
-0.24766509234905243,
-0.5422170758247375,
0.1988428235054016,
0.12516795098781586,
-0.6215860247612,
0.8709794282913208,
0.43717876076698303,
-0.012067830190062523,
-0.07759076356887817,
-0.5266594290733337,
-0.34084922075271606,
0.8475447297096252,
0.5548067092895508,
-0.07114226371049881,
0.2043512463569641,
-0.1679152548313141,
0.23193778097629547,
0.021328585222363472,
-0.06524037569761276,
0.10616856068372726,
0.3694295585155487,
0.17287996411323547,
-0.7482591271400452,
0.07404771447181702,
-0.06652140617370605,
-0.20575900375843048,
0.10178541392087936,
-0.4272099435329437,
0.6952128410339355,
-0.04530344530940056,
-0.5612083673477173,
-0.1889563947916031,
0.5392337441444397,
0.6699675917625427,
1.0155984163284302,
0.4280839264392853,
0.2336963713169098,
0.750732421875,
0.037973664700984955,
0.6976302266120911,
0.08216054737567902,
0.2606447637081146,
1.096640706062317,
-0.2613304853439331,
0.4496617615222931,
0.29319778084754944,
-0.02428249455988407,
0.5196967720985413,
0.52223140001297,
0.12702049314975739,
0.4699264466762543,
0.15006081759929657,
-0.5102325677871704,
-0.6004258990287781,
-0.40680721402168274,
-0.17738285660743713,
0.2711319029331207,
0.25396493077278137,
-0.14143218100070953,
-0.506060779094696,
0.3142765760421753,
-0.01986575312912464,
0.4285440742969513,
-0.5725037455558777,
0.9978300929069519,
-0.0481894388794899,
-0.37509685754776,
0.5520599484443665,
-0.1280725747346878,
0.7343502044677734,
-0.3715602159500122,
-0.06082627922296524,
-0.31278008222579956,
-0.09623603522777557,
-0.11896330863237381,
-0.473370760679245,
0.4553600251674652,
0.06734433025121689,
-0.25746265053749084,
-0.40434530377388,
1.0736477375030518,
-0.21615782380104065,
-0.24920976161956787,
0.1296515017747879,
0.419120192527771,
-0.1592007577419281,
-0.4891982674598694,
-0.4463261067867279,
0.24044431746006012,
-0.05515063554048538,
-0.20142079889774323,
0.25755518674850464,
0.8609018921852112,
0.09314152598381042,
0.4844675660133362,
0.5469755530357361,
-0.4205344021320343,
-0.2406872659921646,
-0.022591186687350273,
0.8728256821632385,
-0.49967843294143677,
-0.6720550656318665,
-0.6904975771903992,
0.7160050272941589,
-0.3670238256454468,
0.00582599313929677,
0.4746284484863281,
0.5414730906486511,
0.7952081561088562,
-0.18411214649677277,
0.6310057640075684,
0.18921364843845367,
0.632577121257782,
-0.2951500415802002,
0.5557093024253845,
-0.29382723569869995,
0.1697389781475067,
-0.27358224987983704,
-0.49496954679489136,
-0.4074399173259735,
0.41056951880455017,
-0.32620131969451904,
-0.009131080470979214,
0.37280601263046265,
0.7262802720069885,
0.02721520885825157,
-0.1326860636472702,
0.3438757359981537,
-0.05000715330243111,
0.044283751398324966,
0.2668897807598114,
0.7576743364334106,
0.16870534420013428,
0.7833683490753174,
-0.2992362976074219,
-0.4475541114807129,
-0.31034722924232483,
-0.9301770925521851,
-0.8706785440444946,
-0.8861008286476135,
-0.5943918824195862,
-0.09152872115373611,
0.15771962702274323,
0.843437135219574,
0.5973284244537354,
-0.7192947268486023,
-0.06305065751075745,
0.04149476811289787,
0.32809847593307495,
-0.23768043518066406,
-0.31128355860710144,
0.5075534582138062,
-0.7627317309379578,
-0.4388424754142761,
0.3396158218383789,
0.43260645866394043,
-0.23159900307655334,
0.23884764313697815,
0.25261390209198,
-0.0676099956035614,
-0.1409422755241394,
0.7908841967582703,
0.38060593605041504,
-0.4550785422325134,
-0.12990474700927734,
0.05016661807894707,
0.11338222026824951,
-0.2646949589252472,
0.8659346699714661,
-1.2252527475357056,
0.5474040508270264,
0.5413489937782288,
0.8419135808944702,
0.6101240515708923,
-0.04645954817533493,
0.31006404757499695,
-1.0701613426208496,
0.5517042279243469,
0.3875869810581207,
0.13677746057510376,
0.2890395224094391,
-0.3618362843990326,
0.41367748379707336,
0.6066147685050964,
-0.3864426016807556,
-0.8805440664291382,
0.3293479084968567,
-0.9091140627861023,
-0.45980268716812134,
1.1098436117172241,
0.10774311423301697,
-0.13333798944950104,
-0.5387489795684814,
-0.43597570061683655,
0.5644063949584961,
-0.327181339263916,
1.1711944341659546,
0.35038530826568604,
0.1043325737118721,
-0.27958306670188904,
-0.0638960674405098,
0.4985794425010681,
0.15045464038848877,
-0.8026353120803833,
0.2930620312690735,
0.760955810546875,
-0.12961168587207794,
0.17661337554454803,
0.7622742652893066,
-0.028077784925699234,
0.5799944400787354,
-0.11503969877958298,
0.12120358645915985,
-0.5290048122406006,
0.06004461646080017,
-0.20918163657188416,
0.5193920731544495,
-0.2914014756679535,
-0.560936689376831
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.02100v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.02100v1
|
Exploring Mathematical Extrapolation of Large Language Models with Synthetic Data
| 2024-06-04T08:30:37 | 2024-06-04T08:30:37 |
Haolong Li, Yu Ma, Yinqi Zhang, Chen Ye, Jie Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have shown excellent performance in language
understanding, text generation, code synthesis, and many other tasks, while
they still struggle in complex multi-step reasoning problems, such as
mathematical reasoning. In this paper, through a newly proposed arithmetical
puzzle problem, we show that the model can perform well on multi-step reasoning
tasks via fine-tuning on high-quality synthetic data. Experimental results with
the open-llama-3B model on three different test datasets show that not only the
model can reach a zero-shot pass@1 at 0.44 on the in-domain dataset, it also
demonstrates certain generalization capabilities on the out-of-domain datasets.
Specifically, this paper has designed two out-of-domain datasets in the form of
extending the numerical range and the composing components of the arithmetical
puzzle problem separately. The fine-tuned models have shown encouraging
performance on these two far more difficult tasks with the zero-shot pass@1 at
0.33 and 0.35, respectively.
|
[
-0.36920127272605896,
-1.1383568048477173,
0.834712564945221,
0.2910979986190796,
-0.1595953404903412,
0.09151231497526169,
-0.2696513533592224,
-0.5390780568122864,
0.03668830543756485,
0.694305419921875,
-0.48172006011009216,
-0.3362880349159241,
-0.6004101037979126,
0.18455977737903595,
-0.30887606739997864,
0.5836253762245178,
-0.21501092612743378,
0.06711603701114655,
-0.06573261320590973,
-0.060466211289167404,
-0.3149257302284241,
-0.7811408638954163,
-0.47035840153694153,
-0.3322014808654785,
0.14314910769462585,
0.3025578260421753,
0.9603044390678406,
0.7714186906814575,
0.5408992767333984,
0.29347318410873413,
-0.04513215273618698,
0.37484559416770935,
-0.4114344120025635,
-0.059182267636060715,
-0.04805697500705719,
-0.9593982100486755,
-0.45019087195396423,
-0.06304381042718887,
0.6980729103088379,
0.8453623056411743,
-0.12430233508348465,
0.23391608893871307,
-0.4839973449707031,
0.7090827822685242,
-0.17372038960456848,
0.5392956137657166,
-0.7655348181724548,
-0.18993769586086273,
-0.04123830050230026,
-0.040393728762865067,
-0.42289018630981445,
-0.3430839776992798,
-0.24753394722938538,
-0.8956751227378845,
0.12432431429624557,
0.14235681295394897,
0.4052603542804718,
0.19675366580486298,
-0.45601871609687805,
-0.3287554681301117,
-0.6682922840118408,
0.8507230281829834,
-0.9994227290153503,
0.17451569437980652,
0.23329274356365204,
0.3545427620410919,
-0.480089008808136,
-0.3120846152305603,
-0.7520485520362854,
-0.1480018049478531,
0.2106657326221466,
-0.3426681458950043,
-0.2628856897354126,
-0.32982662320137024,
0.5833711624145508,
0.3374015688896179,
-0.42570042610168457,
-0.10249001532793045,
-0.33307039737701416,
0.09620378166437149,
0.8881531357765198,
0.45759689807891846,
0.21447797119617462,
0.09293682128190994,
0.07812058180570602,
-0.1318720430135727,
-1.0969375371932983,
0.0901280865073204,
0.4269082844257355,
0.43390005826950073,
-0.008422363549470901,
0.996821939945221,
-0.3875914216041565,
0.9355045557022095,
-0.18722623586654663,
0.15376730263233185,
0.21226340532302856,
-0.2095044106245041,
-0.07398874312639236,
-0.19204553961753845,
0.42653125524520874,
0.17595461010932922,
0.8056706786155701,
0.31561100482940674,
-0.3167785704135895,
0.24325117468833923,
-0.2742747962474823,
-0.9155867695808411,
-0.4391145706176758,
0.10698612779378891,
0.02365618571639061,
-0.15118490159511566,
-0.2518713176250458,
-0.4191474914550781,
-0.061151858419179916,
-0.8190340399742126,
0.5909163951873779,
-0.45651549100875854,
-0.05819901078939438,
0.5286014676094055,
0.3509334921836853,
-0.1565929651260376,
0.41022706031799316,
-0.8260190486907959,
0.3261050879955292,
0.9331874847412109,
0.9001533389091492,
-0.0041353218257427216,
-0.14696845412254333,
-0.5410800576210022,
0.052275191992521286,
-0.7348695993423462,
0.775777280330658,
-0.8615708351135254,
-0.20724639296531677,
-0.2926486134529114,
-0.22091352939605713,
-0.020161405205726624,
-0.6029444932937622,
0.4834632873535156,
-0.718006432056427,
-0.11960013955831528,
0.0266856849193573,
-0.6357253193855286,
-0.3311634659767151,
0.21742823719978333,
-0.8638105988502502,
0.8948652744293213,
0.1200292780995369,
-0.10776606947183609,
-0.08902039378881454,
-0.6261469721794128,
-0.49736708402633667,
0.00581268360838294,
-0.13468118011951447,
-0.18332479894161224,
0.7557439208030701,
0.5791108012199402,
0.27137142419815063,
-0.5003705620765686,
0.1002008318901062,
-0.4381673336029053,
-0.44402027130126953,
0.3541771471500397,
-0.478155255317688,
0.810001015663147,
0.08539316058158875,
-0.09612897783517838,
-0.2699706554412842,
-1.0433204174041748,
0.4377628266811371,
0.2201479822397232,
-0.3055395185947418,
-0.4633350074291229,
-0.22132952511310577,
-0.48069149255752563,
0.530081033706665,
0.10180709511041641,
-0.48930153250694275,
0.4211898744106293,
-0.6646987795829773,
0.3696884214878082,
0.5940123200416565,
-0.07572788000106812,
0.15410351753234863,
-0.4595438539981842,
0.6419327259063721,
-0.08418330550193787,
-0.17995917797088623,
-0.534345805644989,
-0.7960619330406189,
-0.7897306084632874,
-0.24708004295825958,
0.3723618984222412,
0.45525339245796204,
-0.7824689149856567,
0.24506571888923645,
-0.3757842481136322,
-0.4018985331058502,
-0.4888952970504761,
-0.058018166571855545,
0.2935815453529358,
0.14842890202999115,
0.502405047416687,
0.08720757067203522,
-0.19407868385314941,
-0.642203688621521,
-0.33840376138687134,
0.08704274892807007,
-0.21425026655197144,
0.414323091506958,
0.7342098355293274,
0.13444602489471436,
0.6717022657394409,
-0.8393294215202332,
-0.21021071076393127,
0.036586564034223557,
0.20908339321613312,
0.6345526576042175,
0.38534480333328247,
0.14990048110485077,
-0.5627899169921875,
-0.557684063911438,
0.10687544196844101,
-0.544630229473114,
-0.23252710700035095,
0.017472488805651665,
0.022843383252620697,
0.20796936750411987,
0.37478122115135193,
-0.8715798258781433,
0.2608763873577118,
0.775627076625824,
-0.21877531707286835,
0.5704570412635803,
-0.2834291458129883,
0.06508781015872955,
-1.0005989074707031,
-0.15892118215560913,
0.03482455015182495,
-0.18877841532230377,
-0.7171367406845093,
0.4832737147808075,
0.12348251044750214,
-0.1870547980070114,
-0.43728604912757874,
0.4330141544342041,
-0.42545878887176514,
-0.015021050348877907,
-0.20095711946487427,
-0.10087604820728302,
0.0702153742313385,
0.6395780444145203,
0.11857274174690247,
0.6164359450340271,
0.5871687531471252,
-0.493621826171875,
0.5899224877357483,
0.0851370245218277,
-0.549864649772644,
0.41013360023498535,
-0.8399428725242615,
0.3115447759628296,
0.02671973593533039,
0.40434902906417847,
-0.8196438550949097,
-0.2650517225265503,
-0.1723492443561554,
-0.543786883354187,
0.015729054808616638,
-0.23262238502502441,
-0.744656503200531,
-0.0484049953520298,
-0.2415742576122284,
0.8675976395606995,
0.3127080798149109,
-0.5073250532150269,
0.6372166275978088,
0.3581639528274536,
-0.39666983485221863,
-0.14764341711997986,
-0.5103384852409363,
0.04381800442934036,
-0.12966330349445343,
-0.7972363829612732,
0.22832174599170685,
-0.14574624598026276,
-0.48975712060928345,
-0.24755041301250458,
0.10730036348104477,
-0.02154305763542652,
-0.3027370274066925,
0.01404767669737339,
0.44973206520080566,
-0.3139827847480774,
-0.07932283729314804,
0.10027697682380676,
-0.14260537922382355,
0.39631325006484985,
-0.13507159054279327,
0.6446836590766907,
-0.12723517417907715,
-0.5819365382194519,
-0.11609472334384918,
0.4454618990421295,
0.5312301516532898,
-0.17218482494354248,
0.5053936243057251,
-0.019088422879576683,
-0.6585019826889038,
-0.352206289768219,
-0.33558517694473267,
0.029591841623187065,
-0.5090190768241882,
0.33610856533050537,
-0.8859527111053467,
-0.7823100686073303,
0.5011935234069824,
-0.1362628936767578,
0.008349008858203888,
0.5847455263137817,
0.7780739665031433,
0.24800731241703033,
1.5225309133529663,
0.37549716234207153,
0.23085567355155945,
-0.09732284396886826,
-0.4449763894081116,
0.21617819368839264,
-0.8070542216300964,
-0.17554602026939392,
-0.5047310590744019,
-0.08186159282922745,
-0.5027045011520386,
-0.7980714440345764,
0.5075671672821045,
0.1888955682516098,
-0.22010307013988495,
0.3988412618637085,
-0.10622669011354446,
0.9222651720046997,
0.349543035030365,
0.10610457509756088,
0.6524500846862793,
0.185834601521492,
-0.1467309445142746,
-0.1359994262456894,
-0.4773300588130951,
-0.13325074315071106,
1.1915340423583984,
0.21746644377708435,
0.8108790516853333,
0.39242473244667053,
0.22760100662708282,
-0.016475213691592216,
0.2387903928756714,
-0.6965210437774658,
0.44023171067237854,
-0.2764785885810852,
-0.7780071496963501,
-0.4917660057544708,
-0.7470769882202148,
-0.5703679919242859,
0.4386502802371979,
0.07571772485971451,
-0.47076305747032166,
0.004600530490279198,
0.002566759940236807,
-0.4250774681568146,
0.05092759057879448,
-0.5831657648086548,
0.3117446303367615,
-0.23616231977939606,
-0.13697569072246552,
-0.44118040800094604,
-0.32938504219055176,
0.6179876327514648,
-0.5799612998962402,
0.5875737071037292,
-0.3069114089012146,
0.15510651469230652,
0.42689433693885803,
-0.572829008102417,
0.533944845199585,
0.08616270124912262,
-0.4661906659603119,
0.2996523976325989,
0.58671635389328,
0.9391123056411743,
0.15159660577774048,
-0.277519166469574,
0.32875585556030273,
0.050955310463905334,
-0.44226187467575073,
-0.8762695789337158,
0.7755444645881653,
-0.5082390308380127,
-0.69291752576828,
-0.33955681324005127,
-0.908332347869873,
-0.5599592328071594,
0.07263531535863876,
-0.07703098654747009,
0.6677299737930298,
0.4330276846885681,
0.21138015389442444,
0.5603655576705933,
-0.14236930012702942,
0.2531490921974182,
0.6787398457527161,
-0.3582909107208252,
-0.4020589292049408,
1.0418583154678345,
0.12334070354700089,
0.5219981074333191,
0.4608462154865265,
0.14451992511749268,
-0.49222686886787415,
-0.5669946670532227,
-0.8823058009147644,
0.3090361952781677,
-0.7410888671875,
-0.2779961824417114,
-0.30881625413894653,
-0.19457101821899414,
-0.30160030722618103,
0.05320485681295395,
-0.3581366240978241,
-0.8626804351806641,
-0.2026578038930893,
0.11562589555978775,
0.31563106179237366,
0.8292927742004395,
-0.10643427819013596,
0.0455433689057827,
-0.8001813292503357,
0.4939349293708801,
0.1560152769088745,
0.31966495513916016,
0.07434069365262985,
-0.909730851650238,
-0.33109188079833984,
0.34158357977867126,
-0.10994383692741394,
-0.4837951064109802,
0.6078322529792786,
0.278682142496109,
0.2129559963941574,
-0.014063774608075619,
-0.10062344372272491,
0.8367310166358948,
-0.6639755964279175,
0.514958918094635,
0.11269436031579971,
-1.0647474527359009,
0.09002555906772614,
-0.5039080381393433,
0.3945838510990143,
0.15514302253723145,
0.41118600964546204,
-0.16388645768165588,
-0.08459670096635818,
-0.3064909875392914,
-0.6842058897018433,
0.5972177982330322,
0.4495250880718231,
0.32786479592323303,
0.28164517879486084,
0.4663148522377014,
-0.032373640686273575,
0.09078774601221085,
-0.6012846827507019,
-0.19654569029808044,
0.1742219626903534,
-0.10047619789838791,
-0.18465407192707062,
0.015945062041282654,
-0.009513821452856064,
-0.49313899874687195,
0.6264801621437073,
-0.33599910140037537,
0.09407012909650803,
-0.2900342047214508,
-0.15292441844940186,
-0.37612494826316833,
0.05919194594025612,
0.7757120728492737,
0.8550119400024414,
0.03689655289053917,
0.12804101407527924,
0.32493361830711365,
-0.3960634171962738,
0.2894850969314575,
0.2924594283103943,
0.0644800066947937,
-0.16148091852664948,
0.4157559871673584,
0.5650225877761841,
0.04010437801480293,
-0.6794452667236328,
0.3292921185493469,
0.22746936976909637,
-0.16793176531791687,
-0.1332201212644577,
0.11983965337276459,
0.1427096724510193,
0.26054900884628296,
0.38759827613830566,
-0.10886785387992859,
-0.012805071659386158,
-0.5967589616775513,
0.053946640342473984,
0.4675191342830658,
0.19744834303855896,
-0.5146525502204895,
0.5699695348739624,
-0.06897788494825363,
-0.39663243293762207,
0.5622334480285645,
-0.11425149440765381,
-0.6032732725143433,
0.6992589831352234,
0.9228576421737671,
0.2556174099445343,
-0.07718848437070847,
-0.0003089705132879317,
0.2654341757297516,
0.18440593779087067,
-0.17348302900791168,
0.3997230529785156,
0.12887440621852875,
-0.7057666778564453,
-1.0210427045822144,
-0.7363232374191284,
-0.5194252133369446,
0.23572146892547607,
-0.3912382423877716,
0.3398219048976898,
-0.23767055571079254,
0.1875632405281067,
0.1991410106420517,
0.15918779373168945,
-0.509168267250061,
0.36875879764556885,
0.11812911182641983,
0.7789681553840637,
-0.6215451955795288,
0.776081383228302,
0.466854453086853,
-0.0577264204621315,
-0.9232433438301086,
-0.27879419922828674,
-0.1514936089515686,
-1.0136970281600952,
0.5454191565513611,
0.08942369371652603,
-0.34970948100090027,
0.20236420631408691,
-0.4282865822315216,
-1.244431972503662,
0.6002556681632996,
0.6396807432174683,
-0.7526832222938538,
-0.011589307337999344,
0.7571438550949097,
0.7872152328491211,
-0.4808686673641205,
0.21736949682235718,
0.7598930597305298,
0.31968218088150024,
0.36070185899734497,
-0.8975003361701965,
0.14251580834388733,
-0.3521212041378021,
-0.09738831967115402,
0.34480705857276917,
-0.6073799729347229,
1.2657792568206787,
-0.39799991250038147,
0.14677169919013977,
0.08457665145397186,
0.41298985481262207,
0.6229995489120483,
0.24630790948867798,
0.331346333026886,
0.8730648756027222,
0.36233195662498474,
-0.024196170270442963,
0.9851849675178528,
-0.3539678156375885,
0.39642956852912903,
1.1557774543762207,
-0.4149857759475708,
0.9170147180557251,
0.08188578486442566,
-0.529417872428894,
0.408702552318573,
0.37394675612449646,
0.1000266894698143,
0.1625787615776062,
0.5848032236099243,
-0.36208847165107727,
-0.40424099564552307,
0.08884190022945404,
-0.38381442427635193,
0.3695208430290222,
0.7165144085884094,
-0.12770488858222961,
-0.14783677458763123,
-0.3893755376338959,
0.020132865756750107,
-0.0801524817943573,
-0.3854568600654602,
0.3814612030982971,
0.22586631774902344,
-0.699862003326416,
0.8230594992637634,
0.3153746426105499,
0.28331393003463745,
-0.32592713832855225,
-0.44784805178642273,
-0.20729580521583557,
0.25998184084892273,
-0.08747586607933044,
-0.7967036366462708,
0.2974257171154022,
-0.05087602138519287,
0.1250959038734436,
0.14071115851402283,
0.34016501903533936,
-0.4576584994792938,
-1.0264031887054443,
-0.1449998915195465,
0.5021098852157593,
0.1457693874835968,
-0.5134249925613403,
-0.5383396744728088,
0.14901545643806458,
-0.06650145351886749,
-0.3366105258464813,
0.19659729301929474,
0.7379761338233948,
-0.27046525478363037,
0.7010858654975891,
1.1282364130020142,
0.24193443357944489,
0.30015674233436584,
0.08767930418252945,
0.9664830565452576,
-0.7709677219390869,
-0.5002140402793884,
-1.0898886919021606,
0.09308643639087677,
0.19915856420993805,
-0.3134790062904358,
0.7103328704833984,
0.6592114567756653,
0.8414269685745239,
-0.028116947039961815,
0.5449865460395813,
0.3134605884552002,
0.45480942726135254,
-0.7663288116455078,
0.22437335550785065,
-0.3700553774833679,
0.33105066418647766,
-0.19716954231262207,
-1.0794875621795654,
-0.63094162940979,
0.6146456003189087,
-0.2213975042104721,
0.08817930519580841,
0.6874223947525024,
0.8641926646232605,
-0.10455724596977234,
0.1819457858800888,
0.559726893901825,
0.28452762961387634,
0.4996912479400635,
0.8352417945861816,
0.8352507948875427,
-0.4228586256504059,
0.45755717158317566,
-0.24825571477413177,
-0.22580283880233765,
-0.016333740204572678,
-0.7899217009544373,
-0.8988677859306335,
-0.3945682644844055,
-0.02432182990014553,
-0.2222166806459427,
-0.2655846178531647,
1.0303922891616821,
0.6859891414642334,
-0.9221161007881165,
-0.12025429308414459,
-0.24195979535579681,
-0.12821519374847412,
0.02401283010840416,
-0.2069031000137329,
0.28347593545913696,
-0.010694156400859356,
-0.8933016061782837,
0.5374696850776672,
0.2627461552619934,
0.05764816701412201,
-0.4402942359447479,
0.14510737359523773,
-0.01644963212311268,
0.6641151905059814,
0.7874128222465515,
-0.02512575499713421,
-0.5230996608734131,
-0.047306377440690994,
0.07858645915985107,
0.33668088912963867,
-0.10469193756580353,
1.0712934732437134,
-0.8008174896240234,
0.3616486191749573,
0.35233190655708313,
0.4701704978942871,
0.6126313209533691,
0.2494482398033142,
0.6095280647277832,
-0.5030751824378967,
-0.12488607317209244,
0.13178019225597382,
0.32541999220848083,
0.22523508965969086,
-0.25778692960739136,
0.4549978971481323,
0.14318393170833588,
-0.4484790563583374,
-0.9161654710769653,
0.3252542316913605,
-0.5457039475440979,
-0.2185375988483429,
1.229636311531067,
-0.1649472564458847,
-0.10018265247344971,
-0.04250523820519447,
-0.09980743378400803,
-0.08191541582345963,
-0.31442829966545105,
0.8947344422340393,
0.9763514399528503,
-0.46141836047172546,
0.09736479073762894,
-0.5874335169792175,
0.29227370023727417,
0.4973137378692627,
-0.9952782392501831,
0.25340917706489563,
0.6761602163314819,
0.11703609675168991,
0.19613748788833618,
0.14570623636245728,
-0.21112656593322754,
0.22896413505077362,
-0.03206150606274605,
-0.6243648529052734,
-0.33108025789260864,
-0.5807312726974487,
-0.49527236819267273,
0.14142833650112152,
-0.02751241624355316,
0.2690098285675049
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.02080v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.02080v1
|
LongSSM: On the Length Extension of State-space Models in Language Modelling
| 2024-06-04T08:02:39 | 2024-06-04T08:02:39 |
Shida Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, math.DS
|
In this paper, we investigate the length-extension of state-space models
(SSMs) in language modeling. Length extension involves training models on short
sequences and testing them on longer ones. We show that state-space models
trained with zero hidden states initialization have difficulty doing length
extension. We explain this difficulty by pointing out the length extension is
equivalent to polynomial extrapolation. Based on the theory, we propose a
simple yet effective method - changing the hidden states initialization scheme
- to improve the length extension. Moreover, our method shows that using long
training sequence length is beneficial but not necessary to length extension.
Changing the hidden state initialization enables the efficient training of
long-memory model with a smaller training context length.
|
[
-0.22071173787117004,
-0.5911508798599243,
0.9851827025413513,
-0.1279767006635666,
-0.5270175337791443,
0.26264727115631104,
-0.5274976491928101,
-0.4686758816242218,
0.40272796154022217,
0.4051556885242462,
-0.652106523513794,
-0.19540777802467346,
-0.5326696038246155,
-0.1336095631122589,
-0.4293338358402252,
0.7514615654945374,
-0.2733154296875,
-0.09915635734796524,
-0.14748628437519073,
0.09240453690290451,
-0.030731601640582085,
-0.6959838271141052,
-0.19247198104858398,
-0.08453356474637985,
0.3372274339199066,
0.29055315256118774,
0.8175274729728699,
0.7625671625137329,
0.17303316295146942,
0.27251753211021423,
-0.5150764584541321,
0.19932648539543152,
-0.5372495651245117,
0.11346617341041565,
0.04103599116206169,
-0.7117825150489807,
-0.48540785908699036,
-0.13500288128852844,
0.9144930243492126,
0.9880257844924927,
0.1329929232597351,
0.23465541005134583,
-0.13882139325141907,
0.7217413187026978,
-0.5282881855964661,
0.16427010297775269,
-0.17763108015060425,
-0.0676279366016388,
-0.047236450016498566,
-0.1902783215045929,
-0.3325842022895813,
-0.23187491297721863,
0.15476787090301514,
-0.23118972778320312,
0.2957555949687958,
-0.08043505251407623,
0.9457903504371643,
0.008614076301455498,
-0.5352486371994019,
0.16922937333583832,
-1.427272081375122,
1.0512163639068604,
-0.7794627547264099,
0.48733752965927124,
0.01540057547390461,
0.3368021845817566,
-0.34378403425216675,
-0.2263631373643875,
-0.5932738780975342,
-0.5928165912628174,
0.009470831602811813,
-0.15438240766525269,
-0.06068383902311325,
0.40276405215263367,
0.5699203014373779,
0.24619951844215393,
-0.25119495391845703,
0.15896275639533997,
-1.069846272468567,
0.01874801330268383,
0.6576118469238281,
0.21276557445526123,
0.1868116855621338,
-0.0715487003326416,
-0.5166025757789612,
0.18005670607089996,
-0.9024015069007874,
0.08110429346561432,
0.5361888408660889,
0.40698790550231934,
-0.014760542660951614,
0.6772797107696533,
-0.2478874921798706,
0.6668331027030945,
-0.36650291085243225,
0.03593398258090019,
0.171372652053833,
-0.026628093793988228,
-0.14220982789993286,
-0.12936584651470184,
0.26058313250541687,
-0.0769437626004219,
-0.040654201060533524,
-0.09640461951494217,
-0.13435561954975128,
0.26855263113975525,
0.006030184682458639,
-0.8034230470657349,
0.25688281655311584,
0.14574690163135529,
-0.33279287815093994,
0.14186352491378784,
-0.022157009690999985,
-0.4668113887310028,
0.06530795991420746,
-0.4669756591320038,
0.4527607858181,
-0.7191783785820007,
-0.2851090431213379,
0.41803625226020813,
-0.09467823058366776,
0.18255822360515594,
0.11900998651981354,
-0.6789926886558533,
0.8768275380134583,
0.8759598135948181,
0.7674602270126343,
-0.40401333570480347,
-0.4735800623893738,
-0.19283440709114075,
-0.013392122462391853,
-0.6748209595680237,
0.2908378839492798,
-0.4823669195175171,
-0.5446497201919556,
-0.19032800197601318,
0.1818244755268097,
0.018134845420718193,
0.03096611611545086,
0.2370007485151291,
-0.49927642941474915,
0.36721253395080566,
0.023367414250969887,
-1.0153383016586304,
-0.17884930968284607,
-0.19792668521404266,
-0.5602238178253174,
1.1707195043563843,
0.24179308116436005,
-0.0277533121407032,
0.21232983469963074,
-1.1770564317703247,
-0.42367228865623474,
0.036029212176799774,
0.0435890331864357,
-0.28223979473114014,
0.6026307344436646,
-0.05436016246676445,
0.43647250533103943,
0.10024552047252655,
0.15167376399040222,
-0.30654633045196533,
-0.6913123726844788,
0.22167077660560608,
-0.3429774343967438,
0.4621189832687378,
0.2505587041378021,
-0.0813341960310936,
0.1993536800146103,
-1.0399649143218994,
0.2793630361557007,
0.03345990553498268,
-0.3466424345970154,
-0.5368881225585938,
0.1192551702260971,
-0.3740752041339874,
0.24397945404052734,
0.27469873428344727,
-0.7413021922111511,
0.13006478548049927,
-0.870010256767273,
0.3701319694519043,
0.629277229309082,
-0.1907559484243393,
0.7457089424133301,
0.045321352779865265,
0.803107738494873,
0.058317631483078,
0.1849469095468521,
-0.2879258990287781,
-0.06547918915748596,
-1.0136737823486328,
-0.459554523229599,
0.43228375911712646,
0.1566554754972458,
-0.5948073863983154,
0.4963996708393097,
-0.7191959023475647,
-0.4627459943294525,
-0.3470648229122162,
-0.20946721732616425,
0.319313108921051,
-0.08749822527170181,
0.4413456916809082,
-0.17551568150520325,
-0.6253116130828857,
-0.7811738848686218,
-0.4549134373664856,
-0.10476908832788467,
0.21095459163188934,
-0.04792061820626259,
0.7775031328201294,
-0.06662644445896149,
1.318785548210144,
-0.7129203081130981,
0.48859846591949463,
-0.37806856632232666,
-0.3952445983886719,
0.48056256771087646,
0.35109323263168335,
0.33872663974761963,
-0.291182279586792,
-0.22750324010849,
-0.6076657176017761,
-0.24261720478534698,
0.44976043701171875,
0.06655415892601013,
0.27231189608573914,
0.2829434275627136,
0.37682583928108215,
-1.0172494649887085,
0.7227728962898254,
0.5116548538208008,
-0.44614550471305847,
0.7560097575187683,
-0.4008912444114685,
-0.2020835429430008,
-1.3259212970733643,
-0.2673565447330475,
-0.05342752858996391,
-0.4503706097602844,
-1.0610719919204712,
0.5299440026283264,
0.2924104630947113,
-0.6192988753318787,
-0.7512604594230652,
0.6318676471710205,
-1.0225675106048584,
-0.3638852536678314,
-0.714775800704956,
0.022531673312187195,
-0.0026043180841952562,
0.5591050386428833,
0.04375400394201279,
0.5953903794288635,
0.5110770463943481,
-0.7169076800346375,
0.235869362950325,
-0.1569051742553711,
-0.4954926073551178,
-0.04985682666301727,
-0.28725674748420715,
0.1501283496618271,
-0.31624728441238403,
0.3667002022266388,
-0.7902178168296814,
0.21462289988994598,
-0.07747552543878555,
-0.27873384952545166,
0.506752610206604,
-0.3987131416797638,
-0.5627089142799377,
-0.6949408650398254,
-0.2588721811771393,
0.4453929662704468,
0.72441166639328,
-0.845565915107727,
0.26583990454673767,
-0.026744812726974487,
-0.15991364419460297,
-0.306831955909729,
-0.3644702732563019,
0.0845998078584671,
-0.37593352794647217,
-0.4125800132751465,
0.43239492177963257,
-0.13757097721099854,
0.06686008721590042,
-0.052717678248882294,
-0.10899908095598221,
-0.05793868005275726,
0.2770884037017822,
0.36038297414779663,
0.4007011950016022,
-0.5041840076446533,
0.2522483170032501,
0.4017409682273865,
0.02519148401916027,
0.11058409512042999,
-0.028223995119333267,
0.754821240901947,
-0.4143672585487366,
-0.456734299659729,
-0.3095439672470093,
0.4856796860694885,
0.26361992955207825,
-0.07470903545618057,
0.9163358807563782,
-0.08463776111602783,
-0.6347042918205261,
-0.2621673345565796,
0.019562380388379097,
-0.4090188145637512,
-0.5055395364761353,
0.6881657242774963,
-0.5296663045883179,
-1.2282068729400635,
0.33875757455825806,
-0.4349053204059601,
-0.3720988631248474,
0.4211851954460144,
0.11652952432632446,
0.04384702816605568,
0.990544855594635,
1.180811882019043,
-0.007145213428884745,
0.12702175974845886,
-0.18268194794654846,
0.39433786273002625,
-0.9121437072753906,
0.061549216508865356,
-0.2935332953929901,
-0.18242985010147095,
-0.47388333082199097,
-0.7448127865791321,
-0.1266152709722519,
0.4254702925682068,
-0.08573494851589203,
0.8069155812263489,
-0.11349794268608093,
0.6792293787002563,
-0.05087992176413536,
0.19271951913833618,
-0.14419452846050262,
0.05390021950006485,
-0.002670138608664274,
-0.27752694487571716,
-0.7030244469642639,
-0.165060356259346,
0.7804808616638184,
0.7538350820541382,
0.8510494828224182,
0.30314695835113525,
0.7367128729820251,
-0.15389332175254822,
-0.14782623946666718,
-1.0978692770004272,
0.6845460534095764,
-0.0818127691745758,
-0.46291518211364746,
-0.7453048229217529,
-0.3777216672897339,
-0.9355647563934326,
0.09756088256835938,
0.07180182635784149,
-0.7802828550338745,
0.24391646683216095,
-0.019574085250496864,
-0.552102267742157,
0.3768734931945801,
-0.3106401562690735,
0.04576028138399124,
-0.39704629778862,
0.10744959115982056,
-0.3146272301673889,
-0.30485036969184875,
0.21447281539440155,
-0.04490701109170914,
0.09923076629638672,
-0.29092541337013245,
-0.20272915065288544,
1.0100903511047363,
-0.7245041728019714,
0.8528323173522949,
-0.06696460396051407,
-0.10534585267305374,
0.08005138486623764,
0.08149071782827377,
0.5301529765129089,
-0.24370719492435455,
0.1299595981836319,
0.10952926427125931,
-0.05644179508090019,
-0.5650292634963989,
-0.6227560043334961,
0.7550384402275085,
-0.5807485580444336,
-0.8320322036743164,
-0.4712024927139282,
-0.46916985511779785,
-0.43424472212791443,
0.35081830620765686,
-0.10601957887411118,
0.22141249477863312,
-0.18238037824630737,
0.03756212070584297,
0.5923479199409485,
-0.26952633261680603,
0.559730589389801,
0.9055494666099548,
-0.5067921876907349,
0.019823435693979263,
0.5397345423698425,
0.09361514449119568,
0.4339657425880432,
0.22060921788215637,
0.25994783639907837,
-0.4835241436958313,
-0.3178064227104187,
-0.26058363914489746,
0.24302098155021667,
-0.6444531679153442,
0.0871536135673523,
-0.2874526083469391,
-0.7709226608276367,
-0.4628641903400421,
0.2964971959590912,
-0.6647467017173767,
-1.036665916442871,
-0.4260721504688263,
-0.4769308865070343,
0.6791061758995056,
0.4855659306049347,
-0.04542398825287819,
0.5526869893074036,
-0.776185929775238,
0.08952833712100983,
-0.01438194327056408,
0.6769166588783264,
-0.1331024020910263,
-0.8966206908226013,
-0.470946341753006,
0.04974515363574028,
0.1387004405260086,
-0.9138173460960388,
0.4922974407672882,
0.35230177640914917,
0.39473041892051697,
0.31478285789489746,
-0.22626365721225739,
0.9536817669868469,
-0.875427782535553,
0.9241546988487244,
0.4610494375228882,
-0.9066377878189087,
0.3735625445842743,
-0.15437161922454834,
0.5050919651985168,
0.0219667237251997,
0.5302444100379944,
-0.5660365223884583,
-0.016341939568519592,
-0.5952253937721252,
-0.7501919865608215,
0.43589070439338684,
0.0710676908493042,
0.5662084221839905,
-0.1610870212316513,
0.6166282296180725,
0.20576833188533783,
-0.07266794145107269,
-0.23599833250045776,
-0.5100453495979309,
0.11239524930715561,
0.2352367788553238,
-0.4570070207118988,
-0.7072004079818726,
-0.15943050384521484,
-0.4006342887878418,
0.8316832780838013,
-0.2029263973236084,
0.41756415367126465,
-0.1899561733007431,
-0.290449321269989,
-0.20244759321212769,
0.6892637014389038,
0.8432132601737976,
0.9761818647384644,
-0.031150834634900093,
-0.03411167860031128,
0.4242851436138153,
0.019998425617814064,
0.42919978499412537,
0.11948150396347046,
0.0986228659749031,
0.3314172327518463,
0.043222617357969284,
1.357251524925232,
0.40757063031196594,
-0.17340226471424103,
0.4798220694065094,
0.17603802680969238,
-0.16589030623435974,
-0.4100034236907959,
0.30051136016845703,
0.2530228793621063,
-0.09338443726301193,
0.31271207332611084,
-0.08065690845251083,
-0.033389922231435776,
-0.6396593451499939,
0.08450456708669662,
0.28638502955436707,
-0.5354529023170471,
-0.4747233986854553,
0.306508332490921,
-0.1283256560564041,
-0.4935821294784546,
0.32615235447883606,
0.11521562933921814,
-0.6820212006568909,
0.6292200684547424,
0.8535518050193787,
0.5156751871109009,
-0.3401629626750946,
0.18918639421463013,
0.14354893565177917,
0.21963945031166077,
-0.4011099636554718,
0.6273859143257141,
0.05199974402785301,
-0.5360628366470337,
-0.7521494626998901,
-0.6292657256126404,
-0.16017425060272217,
0.5767985582351685,
-0.9027435779571533,
0.36037859320640564,
-0.5116610527038574,
-0.22471795976161957,
-0.37642768025398254,
0.16938935220241547,
-0.4523477256298065,
0.3396029472351074,
0.25591880083084106,
1.3657681941986084,
-0.6921038031578064,
1.0083729028701782,
0.33533698320388794,
0.3175806999206543,
-0.6553366780281067,
-0.32018300890922546,
-0.2916068434715271,
-0.616816520690918,
0.41186463832855225,
0.21222437918186188,
-0.24740435183048248,
-0.28177252411842346,
-0.6103575825691223,
-1.3124812841415405,
0.8372099995613098,
0.238775372505188,
-0.8788197040557861,
0.00882252398878336,
0.5199904441833496,
0.8968000411987305,
-0.2574714124202728,
-0.11758482456207275,
0.5378329753875732,
-0.0722651332616806,
-0.37344545125961304,
-0.6621304750442505,
0.2922162413597107,
-0.10828246176242828,
0.4728960692882538,
0.6166022419929504,
-0.6526610255241394,
0.7029505372047424,
-0.4520929753780365,
-0.4708212912082672,
0.6712865233421326,
1.1114650964736938,
0.27931690216064453,
-0.18848773837089539,
0.5891594290733337,
0.4216417074203491,
0.524692714214325,
0.2107219696044922,
0.6854121685028076,
-0.47213637828826904,
0.5957407355308533,
1.370577096939087,
-0.5366340279579163,
1.0366425514221191,
0.5744683742523193,
-0.2998051643371582,
0.6832075715065002,
0.5863727927207947,
-0.06206417828798294,
0.2759683430194855,
0.5086138248443604,
-0.23300480842590332,
-0.24032896757125854,
0.5741723775863647,
-0.48389941453933716,
0.3346712589263916,
0.6600671410560608,
-0.4330960810184479,
-0.278343141078949,
0.018872257322072983,
0.19560371339321136,
0.017593208700418472,
-0.3088698387145996,
0.358361154794693,
0.44942745566368103,
-0.5465571284294128,
0.538451611995697,
0.4159269630908966,
0.5030148029327393,
-0.5402804017066956,
0.16463954746723175,
-0.0639299526810646,
0.07129600644111633,
0.02642923966050148,
-0.6486393809318542,
0.12846779823303223,
-0.04638899117708206,
-0.33605116605758667,
-0.03984896466135979,
0.8515720963478088,
-0.5056219100952148,
-0.45861583948135376,
0.3915247917175293,
0.33242154121398926,
0.357521116733551,
0.08024176955223083,
-0.49367862939834595,
-0.4097670912742615,
-0.43536028265953064,
-0.19042322039604187,
0.46221473813056946,
-0.2463293969631195,
-0.36786261200904846,
0.6081845164299011,
0.846842885017395,
0.2535798251628876,
0.3626202940940857,
-0.1016673594713211,
0.7105924487113953,
-0.9081305265426636,
-0.8034412860870361,
-1.0425938367843628,
0.013309596106410027,
-0.051722194999456406,
0.05750313028693199,
0.7862001061439514,
0.8789070844650269,
0.5413093566894531,
-0.33691495656967163,
0.7202854156494141,
0.2300272434949875,
0.850341260433197,
-0.44483646750450134,
0.922062873840332,
-0.4279496371746063,
0.27641594409942627,
0.17277677357196808,
-0.9085865616798401,
0.16183023154735565,
-0.02785063162446022,
-0.41005194187164307,
-0.029781542718410492,
0.7089788913726807,
0.6785317659378052,
-0.1319190412759781,
-0.060784049332141876,
0.5938735008239746,
0.2496083378791809,
0.13365831971168518,
0.5041007399559021,
1.0830912590026855,
-0.3856625258922577,
0.3141805827617645,
-0.37297311425209045,
-0.1537209153175354,
-0.08470094203948975,
-0.8833958506584167,
-0.8686835169792175,
-0.4977703094482422,
-0.11835906654596329,
-0.41085517406463623,
0.30502083897590637,
0.7568762898445129,
0.9467223286628723,
-0.5327537059783936,
-0.26919835805892944,
0.3726916015148163,
-0.16867372393608093,
-0.06281597167253494,
-0.19941741228103638,
0.5257753729820251,
-0.02270279824733734,
-0.550289511680603,
0.9946766495704651,
0.25632089376449585,
0.21665866672992706,
-0.3898216784000397,
-0.24447064101696014,
-0.0958460196852684,
0.46106112003326416,
0.6950967311859131,
0.6510131359100342,
-0.5647737383842468,
-0.34574148058891296,
-0.08324477076530457,
0.030590618029236794,
0.10908794403076172,
0.6237300038337708,
-0.6830463409423828,
0.2579788267612457,
0.2401273101568222,
0.25014686584472656,
0.6855234503746033,
-0.22659583389759064,
0.6768526434898376,
-1.1202130317687988,
0.14213286340236664,
-0.0861440896987915,
0.3726944923400879,
0.16334179043769836,
-0.39482563734054565,
0.0829826071858406,
0.054685838520526886,
-0.09123462438583374,
-0.9174330830574036,
0.5799539685249329,
-0.6448737978935242,
-0.5622227191925049,
1.3102951049804688,
-0.16185709834098816,
-0.6140275001525879,
0.4436165392398834,
0.25287720561027527,
0.35546600818634033,
-0.06323757022619247,
0.6922662258148193,
0.548832893371582,
-0.19922061264514923,
-0.12989003956317902,
-0.12417901307344437,
0.6992030143737793,
0.5779518485069275,
-0.7400532960891724,
-0.19236572086811066,
0.0587766095995903,
0.6666112542152405,
0.30990564823150635,
0.37172484397888184,
-0.213487446308136,
0.3492436408996582,
-0.333288311958313,
-0.2207653522491455,
-0.08628939092159271,
-0.6847545504570007,
-0.8235440850257874,
-0.18183763325214386,
0.054938722401857376,
-0.23283521831035614
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.02079v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.02079v1
|
Assessing the Performance of Chinese Open Source Large Language Models in Information Extraction Tasks
| 2024-06-04T08:00:40 | 2024-06-04T08:00:40 |
Yida Cai, Hao Sun, Hsiu-Yuan Huang, Yunfang Wu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Information Extraction (IE) plays a crucial role in Natural Language
Processing (NLP) by extracting structured information from unstructured text,
thereby facilitating seamless integration with various real-world applications
that rely on structured data. Despite its significance, recent experiments
focusing on English IE tasks have shed light on the challenges faced by Large
Language Models (LLMs) in achieving optimal performance, particularly in
sub-tasks like Named Entity Recognition (NER). In this paper, we delve into a
comprehensive investigation of the performance of mainstream Chinese
open-source LLMs in tackling IE tasks, specifically under zero-shot conditions
where the models are not fine-tuned for specific tasks. Additionally, we
present the outcomes of several few-shot experiments to further gauge the
capability of these models. Moreover, our study includes a comparative analysis
between these open-source LLMs and ChatGPT, a widely recognized language model,
on IE performance. Through meticulous experimentation and analysis, we aim to
provide insights into the strengths, limitations, and potential enhancements of
existing Chinese open-source LLMs in the domain of Information Extraction
within the context of NLP.
|
[
-0.1302589476108551,
-0.8447034955024719,
0.3799407482147217,
0.1840936690568924,
-0.18184293806552887,
-0.2656308114528656,
-0.5733456611633301,
-0.9100032448768616,
-0.2099069505929947,
0.33352360129356384,
-0.15875253081321716,
-0.4945380687713623,
-0.7216097116470337,
0.2477218061685562,
-0.4942687451839447,
0.8235077857971191,
0.005240249913185835,
-0.05659870803356171,
0.2931092083454132,
0.16007234156131744,
-0.42387697100639343,
-0.2659098207950592,
-0.7332847118377686,
-0.31819605827331543,
0.4704650342464447,
0.3466123640537262,
0.45369404554367065,
0.6283152103424072,
0.7633881568908691,
0.17650416493415833,
-0.010381169617176056,
-0.01736411638557911,
-0.5774577856063843,
0.06649906188249588,
-0.2211439311504364,
-0.381593257188797,
-0.3327539265155792,
0.07701359689235687,
0.8457916975021362,
0.38163021206855774,
-0.15418677031993866,
0.2795286476612091,
0.3162984848022461,
0.12505555152893066,
-0.6955647468566895,
0.3792693316936493,
-0.9750979542732239,
0.12097414582967758,
-0.5245494246482849,
-0.2068532556295395,
-0.6303611397743225,
-0.1480463445186615,
0.23507489264011383,
-0.5432230234146118,
0.0061463164165616035,
0.03464730456471443,
1.1559441089630127,
-0.012929846532642841,
-0.10578681528568268,
-0.17372871935367584,
-0.9837729334831238,
0.8637576103210449,
-1.1436952352523804,
0.34029459953308105,
0.030509375035762787,
0.22607825696468353,
-0.26899468898773193,
-0.7637330889701843,
-0.5777333974838257,
-0.24629101157188416,
0.07184740155935287,
0.18242523074150085,
-0.45542392134666443,
0.06834031641483307,
0.42487168312072754,
0.4635300934314728,
-0.5866767764091492,
0.6294302344322205,
-0.35108456015586853,
0.034497130662202835,
0.44241923093795776,
0.018992895260453224,
0.54771488904953,
-0.4360314607620239,
-0.36610138416290283,
0.12438029795885086,
-0.751491367816925,
0.16780580580234528,
0.044619545340538025,
0.5709975361824036,
0.15514323115348816,
0.8945352435112,
-0.2265126258134842,
0.5834740400314331,
-0.28253278136253357,
-0.21284402906894684,
-0.10976654291152954,
-0.14554214477539062,
-0.5302250981330872,
0.023635437712073326,
0.9734816551208496,
0.13249938189983368,
0.395262211561203,
-0.39182913303375244,
-0.46193307638168335,
-0.35137274861335754,
-0.046074915677309036,
-0.9942530989646912,
-0.16914604604244232,
0.23832781612873077,
-0.5497931241989136,
-0.07203607261180878,
0.1807188093662262,
-0.7387451529502869,
-0.34585121273994446,
-0.06274957209825516,
0.4710896611213684,
-0.5531464219093323,
-0.5492957830429077,
0.09048767387866974,
-0.19232483208179474,
0.6205031275749207,
0.5259520411491394,
-0.6797555685043335,
0.07267281413078308,
0.832724392414093,
1.0270439386367798,
-0.5557331442832947,
-0.19298219680786133,
-0.6251672506332397,
0.09698658436536789,
-0.28589385747909546,
0.8095706105232239,
-0.5371569991111755,
-0.09032171964645386,
-0.13309665024280548,
-0.06012871861457825,
-0.33581778407096863,
-0.5916309952735901,
0.6523797512054443,
-0.508395791053772,
0.1130867749452591,
-0.05994473025202751,
-0.6564363837242126,
-0.17095613479614258,
0.44930562376976013,
-0.7852660417556763,
1.002042293548584,
-0.08112803101539612,
-0.8597909212112427,
0.3055245876312256,
-0.8198142051696777,
-0.16817916929721832,
0.4709455370903015,
-0.2924063801765442,
-0.010701515711843967,
0.19038258492946625,
-0.005803471431136131,
0.6154016852378845,
-0.6427929401397705,
0.068332239985466,
-0.2382548451423645,
-0.4328608810901642,
-0.006988850422203541,
-0.5591884851455688,
0.8907617926597595,
0.16744302213191986,
-0.43291082978248596,
-0.014123829081654549,
-0.7863484025001526,
0.11186116188764572,
0.40190690755844116,
-0.42785319685935974,
-0.46282127499580383,
0.15182752907276154,
0.09354586154222488,
0.25949105620384216,
0.25372716784477234,
-0.7835880517959595,
0.3186899721622467,
-0.5552095174789429,
0.4557725787162781,
0.6659409403800964,
-0.08500037342309952,
0.18369531631469727,
0.09400348365306854,
0.4684671461582184,
-0.12349677830934525,
-0.011972474865615368,
-0.24944084882736206,
-0.36984679102897644,
-0.7073280811309814,
-0.29385870695114136,
0.7266131639480591,
0.7287841439247131,
-0.7510389089584351,
0.10116437077522278,
-0.3684103786945343,
-0.6435622572898865,
-0.5265353322029114,
0.13415740430355072,
0.12720541656017303,
0.4480555057525635,
0.09361826628446579,
-0.21630921959877014,
-0.3077072501182556,
-0.8522344827651978,
-0.3054228723049164,
-0.25466465950012207,
-0.3199365437030792,
0.2663635015487671,
0.4708166718482971,
0.066434346139431,
0.9140186905860901,
-0.3568580746650696,
-0.2749826908111572,
-0.4146941900253296,
0.36486122012138367,
0.2902624011039734,
0.16790664196014404,
0.351268470287323,
-0.7251335382461548,
-0.5049898624420166,
0.3559323847293854,
-0.9166680574417114,
-0.20732714235782623,
-0.13755539059638977,
0.10892979055643082,
0.11185742169618607,
0.259032279253006,
-0.818183422088623,
0.4421866834163666,
0.40668874979019165,
0.1411367505788803,
0.7305600643157959,
0.1114380955696106,
-0.023078391328454018,
-0.807425320148468,
0.4021247923374176,
0.22740519046783447,
-0.054483797401189804,
-0.7366014122962952,
0.3602416217327118,
0.2367044985294342,
-0.043963104486465454,
-0.7314624190330505,
0.49398353695869446,
-0.686272144317627,
-0.13321435451507568,
-0.3554409146308899,
0.5384562611579895,
-0.1947370171546936,
0.3714275658130646,
0.165009006857872,
0.7332289814949036,
0.4496479034423828,
-0.6049190163612366,
0.1637692153453827,
-0.13632827997207642,
-0.5608826875686646,
0.3242301940917969,
-0.8357237577438354,
0.16944284737110138,
0.01015391107648611,
-0.3040587604045868,
-0.7963997721672058,
-0.19779588282108307,
0.08453692495822906,
-0.40720996260643005,
0.4475559592247009,
-0.012144546024501324,
-0.689376950263977,
-0.07377361506223679,
-0.2739090621471405,
-0.003036216367036104,
0.34738418459892273,
-0.4042917788028717,
0.40643882751464844,
0.38074997067451477,
-0.23639953136444092,
-0.6376803517341614,
-0.5227413177490234,
0.20454268157482147,
-0.21273717284202576,
-0.6116700172424316,
0.18900378048419952,
0.13253873586654663,
-0.36452198028564453,
0.05795261263847351,
-0.03000672161579132,
-0.1478203982114792,
0.36895596981048584,
0.059844862669706345,
0.3887636661529541,
-0.6010350584983826,
0.0991385206580162,
-0.42327383160591125,
0.08416810631752014,
-0.16007277369499207,
-0.08435186743736267,
0.5265491008758545,
-0.036363352090120316,
-0.45024579763412476,
-0.3572051525115967,
0.13101650774478912,
0.25289279222488403,
-0.5149048566818237,
0.8102797865867615,
0.5369701385498047,
-0.6286795139312744,
-0.29295122623443604,
-0.4298713207244873,
0.053300537168979645,
-0.38034820556640625,
0.5249350666999817,
-0.25851863622665405,
-0.8135805726051331,
0.40778443217277527,
-0.03324965387582779,
0.5039612650871277,
0.696426510810852,
0.319681316614151,
0.1898677945137024,
0.8669090270996094,
0.7685599327087402,
-0.28559455275535583,
0.5396074652671814,
0.003197051351889968,
0.2491433173418045,
-0.8116196990013123,
-0.030691154301166534,
-0.7304680347442627,
-0.01860562339425087,
-0.49296003580093384,
-0.15520121157169342,
0.19124828279018402,
0.3065771460533142,
0.14582106471061707,
0.41837817430496216,
-0.25441643595695496,
0.3428477346897125,
0.4378719627857208,
-0.2895210087299347,
0.47502240538597107,
-0.13931147754192352,
0.18808765709400177,
0.027111897245049477,
-0.6130324602127075,
-0.7154430150985718,
0.8802379965782166,
0.37479281425476074,
0.7013897895812988,
0.0046994430013000965,
0.4503697156906128,
0.022554300725460052,
0.10523722320795059,
-0.8690705895423889,
0.5478807091712952,
-0.3026503920555115,
-0.4129229784011841,
-0.44743698835372925,
-0.4253504276275635,
-1.2053595781326294,
0.3227986693382263,
-0.2091158777475357,
-1.0646096467971802,
-0.12227533757686615,
-0.22688540816307068,
-0.30233606696128845,
0.4838254451751709,
-0.5959466099739075,
0.8088719844818115,
-0.13722461462020874,
-0.2906387746334076,
0.272408127784729,
-0.2661972641944885,
0.5159801840782166,
-0.3086419701576233,
0.07517401874065399,
-0.12573418021202087,
0.05613185465335846,
0.6786546111106873,
0.21163040399551392,
0.4842483699321747,
-0.16442856192588806,
-0.22103537619113922,
0.2496810108423233,
0.12575164437294006,
0.6713343858718872,
-0.3411819338798523,
-0.2843920886516571,
0.651007354259491,
-0.006014561280608177,
-0.17941099405288696,
-0.4694429636001587,
0.6084563136100769,
-0.5086296200752258,
-0.6479945778846741,
-0.28202611207962036,
-0.329071968793869,
0.1011957898736,
0.6520125865936279,
0.2869608998298645,
0.1775585263967514,
-0.31144481897354126,
0.5267930030822754,
0.49030423164367676,
-0.4338459372520447,
0.7671802043914795,
0.7778805494308472,
-0.31626448035240173,
0.13455933332443237,
0.7769255638122559,
0.5480973720550537,
0.30234038829803467,
0.5436410307884216,
-0.008109231479465961,
0.10033833235502243,
-0.8936979174613953,
-0.5219465494155884,
0.036127448081970215,
-0.4497024714946747,
-0.07773271948099136,
-0.7159042358398438,
-0.6872130036354065,
-0.47765812277793884,
0.4630722403526306,
-0.44556909799575806,
-0.41424888372421265,
-0.30253463983535767,
-0.022044535726308823,
-0.2786279618740082,
0.7847257852554321,
0.2525184452533722,
0.1342700719833374,
-0.9761757254600525,
0.19189892709255219,
-0.11263490468263626,
0.24945737421512604,
0.04765833169221878,
-0.4263908863067627,
-0.3221082091331482,
-0.03190530836582184,
-0.2882358133792877,
-0.9039784073829651,
0.47066810727119446,
0.06913893669843674,
0.7236769795417786,
0.49853938817977905,
0.06882881373167038,
0.7214827537536621,
-0.5191027522087097,
1.057363748550415,
-0.18909576535224915,
-0.68782639503479,
0.46110835671424866,
-0.26926425099372864,
0.2495899796485901,
0.24086643755435944,
0.3223753571510315,
-0.4778504967689514,
-0.3903648555278778,
-0.37731561064720154,
-0.8276743292808533,
0.8507931232452393,
0.3695255219936371,
-0.18152949213981628,
0.038962312042713165,
0.28612497448921204,
0.14959968626499176,
0.14624033868312836,
-1.0125733613967896,
-0.01847155950963497,
0.3151053488254547,
0.11155345290899277,
0.04021470621228218,
-0.16670574247837067,
0.38122525811195374,
0.27342331409454346,
0.6971232295036316,
0.07822373509407043,
0.15254823863506317,
0.2278224229812622,
-0.28357091546058655,
-0.14169009029865265,
0.4662466049194336,
0.2860662043094635,
0.4447577893733978,
-0.20207177102565765,
0.018504280596971512,
0.11368978768587112,
-0.3921878933906555,
-0.426970511674881,
0.1794649064540863,
-0.3622998297214508,
0.047752294689416885,
0.5454193949699402,
0.694638729095459,
0.05514508858323097,
-0.732681930065155,
0.5498774647712708,
-0.10458313673734665,
0.14687830209732056,
-0.3712124526500702,
0.28422150015830994,
-0.16975077986717224,
0.27000486850738525,
0.45401784777641296,
-0.3162107765674591,
0.3209843039512634,
-0.4500553011894226,
0.05267668887972832,
0.7281928062438965,
-0.23881588876247406,
-0.40285724401474,
0.4353867173194885,
-0.17453017830848694,
-0.3807213306427002,
0.7696720361709595,
-0.12238145619630814,
-0.2908948063850403,
0.5153974294662476,
0.593519389629364,
0.956886887550354,
-0.23479504883289337,
-0.018859179690480232,
0.3830471932888031,
0.7187856435775757,
-0.2280687540769577,
-0.052542995661497116,
0.018676282837986946,
-0.6978530287742615,
-0.6085829138755798,
-0.5585970282554626,
-0.41889122128486633,
0.5488828420639038,
-0.6246843934059143,
0.5555763840675354,
-0.16830597817897797,
0.06265021115541458,
0.13372112810611725,
0.0472896471619606,
-0.6658663153648376,
0.022192608565092087,
0.283939003944397,
1.1291823387145996,
-0.47666531801223755,
0.9251788854598999,
0.4065437316894531,
-0.45899561047554016,
-0.9881768226623535,
0.0009282346582040191,
-0.0657283291220665,
-0.6294882893562317,
0.6290274262428284,
0.32243213057518005,
0.03802776336669922,
-0.058104172348976135,
-0.5013702511787415,
-0.8661410808563232,
1.1607569456100464,
0.5424766540527344,
-0.6522562503814697,
-0.4132497310638428,
0.2566559314727783,
0.584114670753479,
-0.08859860152006149,
0.6299456357955933,
0.4616953730583191,
0.49023541808128357,
-0.11401599645614624,
-1.2744548320770264,
-0.1179562360048294,
-0.39233940839767456,
-0.2258930206298828,
0.2326963096857071,
-0.619047999382019,
1.140221118927002,
0.141447976231575,
-0.741780161857605,
0.004279459826648235,
0.5380167365074158,
0.036981310695409775,
0.2234652191400528,
0.39892762899398804,
0.35300901532173157,
0.6755703687667847,
0.025438524782657623,
1.00985848903656,
-0.27149540185928345,
0.32278531789779663,
1.071393609046936,
-0.5110629200935364,
1.2883013486862183,
0.25979846715927124,
-0.04061086103320122,
0.27184638381004333,
0.5112913250923157,
-0.16148696839809418,
0.2033790946006775,
-0.07487716525793076,
-0.0027325546834617853,
-0.01123602595180273,
-0.16905878484249115,
-0.18605025112628937,
0.8427696824073792,
0.19537240266799927,
-0.335022896528244,
-0.4547378718852997,
-0.09507855027914047,
0.05698005482554436,
-0.38457396626472473,
-0.3499508798122406,
0.9222237467765808,
0.041868843138217926,
-0.7587016224861145,
0.2586970627307892,
0.271150141954422,
0.7220181226730347,
-0.7185353636741638,
-0.24018855392932892,
0.03960702568292618,
0.0044724722392857075,
-0.2947286367416382,
-0.7431715726852417,
0.15336303412914276,
0.32307833433151245,
0.019836677238345146,
0.06177692860364914,
1.0990461111068726,
-0.20356781780719757,
-0.14539405703544617,
0.4810054898262024,
0.4676084816455841,
0.5132915377616882,
-0.38611847162246704,
-0.5549775958061218,
-0.12194657325744629,
0.022371992468833923,
-0.5562980771064758,
0.5254715085029602,
0.6473162770271301,
0.08571624010801315,
0.4469865560531616,
0.6588086485862732,
0.5430297255516052,
0.14101865887641907,
-0.31651684641838074,
0.6008914709091187,
-0.8650668859481812,
-0.09288566559553146,
-1.2038871049880981,
0.42162036895751953,
-0.13857275247573853,
-0.17244309186935425,
1.0859369039535522,
0.6690956354141235,
0.8807568550109863,
0.1334877610206604,
0.8254507780075073,
-0.10969319194555283,
0.46172064542770386,
-0.5931268930435181,
0.7019725441932678,
-0.5165801644325256,
0.3151393234729767,
-0.41587379574775696,
-1.0700067281723022,
-0.1642431765794754,
0.30823639035224915,
-0.20945394039154053,
-0.28223517537117004,
0.500064492225647,
0.674370288848877,
-0.06903038173913956,
0.22541464865207672,
0.6093316078186035,
0.40571045875549316,
0.5601033568382263,
0.7439365386962891,
0.8377484679222107,
-0.2781761884689331,
0.5563202500343323,
-0.1906212568283081,
-0.1850612759590149,
0.015668364241719246,
-1.115773320198059,
-0.7232020497322083,
-0.3688884377479553,
-0.02050381526350975,
0.11818016320466995,
-0.2567296624183655,
0.7793142199516296,
0.49472203850746155,
-0.7804251909255981,
-0.15243591368198395,
0.06720145046710968,
-0.03724994137883186,
0.08772584795951843,
-0.3168264925479889,
0.34435221552848816,
-0.27095648646354675,
-0.9658607840538025,
0.4450874924659729,
0.5471885204315186,
-0.18220427632331848,
-0.19606955349445343,
0.2721710205078125,
-0.24940533936023712,
0.12753789126873016,
0.6344318389892578,
0.39241570234298706,
-0.7048612833023071,
-0.37366941571235657,
0.1893993467092514,
-0.21938678622245789,
0.17240707576274872,
0.5318235754966736,
-0.4319685697555542,
0.38436055183410645,
0.4722785949707031,
0.7883734107017517,
0.3165387213230133,
-0.060673344880342484,
0.44698789715766907,
-0.5008929371833801,
-0.21328912675380707,
0.1015397235751152,
0.3949625492095947,
0.23151761293411255,
-0.30386799573898315,
0.7387327551841736,
-0.0055663567036390305,
-0.6868259906768799,
-1.101655125617981,
-0.1675337851047516,
-0.8763144016265869,
-0.23145999014377594,
1.3922834396362305,
-0.5724625587463379,
-0.20535486936569214,
0.055111102759838104,
-0.2809154987335205,
0.31731873750686646,
-0.3098556101322174,
0.5643013119697571,
0.9634824395179749,
-0.16689716279506683,
-0.15794821083545685,
-1.004698634147644,
0.06335486471652985,
0.19407902657985687,
-0.8162539601325989,
0.10695444792509079,
0.3507711589336395,
0.2524125277996063,
0.2510475814342499,
0.5381278395652771,
-0.08553331345319748,
0.07148906588554382,
-0.11907356977462769,
0.11733012646436691,
-0.021210329607129097,
-0.25145652890205383,
-0.4005592465400696,
0.5694188475608826,
0.2959415316581726,
-0.053030990064144135
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.02069v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.02069v2
|
PyramidKV: Dynamic KV Cache Compression based on Pyramidal Information Funneling
| 2024-06-04T07:51:30 | 2024-06-16T06:41:08 |
Zefan Cai., Yichi Zhang, Bofei Gao, Yuliang Liu, Tianyu Liu, Keming Lu, Wayne Xiong, Yue Dong, Baobao Chang, Junjie Hu, Wen Xiao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
In this study, we investigate whether attention-based information flow inside
large language models (LLMs) is aggregated through noticeable patterns for long
context processing. Our observations reveal that LLMs aggregate information
through Pyramidal Information Funneling where attention is scattering widely in
lower layers, progressively consolidating within specific contexts, and
ultimately focusin on critical tokens (a.k.a massive activation or attention
sink) in higher layers. Motivated by these insights, we developed PyramidKV, a
novel and effective KV cache compression method. This approach dynamically
adjusts the KV cache size across different layers, allocating more cache in
lower layers and less in higher ones, diverging from traditional methods that
maintain a uniform KV cache size. Our experimental evaluations, utilizing the
LongBench benchmark, show that PyramidKV matches the performance of models with
a full KV cache while retaining only 12% of the KV cache, thus significantly
reducing memory usage. In scenarios emphasizing memory efficiency, where only
0.7% of the KV cache is maintained, PyramidKV surpasses other KV cache
compression techniques achieving up to a 20.5 absolute accuracy improvement on
TREC.
|
[
-0.3280085325241089,
-0.6260254979133606,
0.28753170371055603,
0.648626446723938,
-0.2968974709510803,
0.27151620388031006,
-0.35515445470809937,
-0.3064172565937042,
0.15614110231399536,
0.3107351064682007,
-0.4224199056625366,
-0.5525945425033569,
-0.6690633893013,
-0.25533419847488403,
-0.47135016322135925,
0.6033980250358582,
0.19004863500595093,
0.02828281931579113,
-0.2912704050540924,
0.18072906136512756,
-0.5475950837135315,
-0.1760549396276474,
-0.6320503950119019,
-0.17477668821811676,
0.5375805497169495,
0.3895372748374939,
0.4448107182979584,
0.90401291847229,
0.47005873918533325,
0.2693692147731781,
-0.22147390246391296,
-0.28930214047431946,
-0.6951003074645996,
0.6816086173057556,
0.1346740573644638,
-0.5569241046905518,
-0.4063818156719208,
-0.3968002498149872,
0.9342755079269409,
0.41692283749580383,
-0.4666304290294647,
0.2409055531024933,
0.07979872077703476,
1.053134799003601,
-1.2180407047271729,
0.23228031396865845,
-0.39204147458076477,
0.1318693459033966,
-0.2793916165828705,
-0.34632256627082825,
-0.6836346387863159,
-0.16116049885749817,
0.06416045129299164,
-0.40260300040245056,
-0.021572129800915718,
-0.24329139292240143,
0.33092543482780457,
0.7180585861206055,
-0.35048189759254456,
-0.2365678995847702,
-0.7141484618186951,
0.8371022939682007,
-0.41549888253211975,
0.4663703441619873,
0.2510715126991272,
0.43535587191581726,
-0.18169169127941132,
-1.1410770416259766,
-0.47277143597602844,
0.05853778496384621,
0.2598325312137604,
0.24954797327518463,
-0.2064446061849594,
0.0633779913187027,
0.2984146475791931,
0.3819297254085541,
-0.37163683772087097,
0.003278926480561495,
-0.21349039673805237,
-0.08590690046548843,
0.14268718659877777,
0.2535918951034546,
0.10135605186223984,
-0.21901212632656097,
-0.2852587103843689,
-0.15732955932617188,
-0.8528398275375366,
0.4776819944381714,
0.33970776200294495,
-0.07748592644929886,
-0.08387263119220734,
0.3574841022491455,
-0.6325075626373291,
0.8872132301330566,
0.33354467153549194,
-0.052391309291124344,
-0.014893448911607265,
-0.1929241567850113,
-0.45464256405830383,
0.32239463925361633,
0.47232577204704285,
0.32477840781211853,
0.26876431703567505,
-0.29491162300109863,
-0.05118750035762787,
0.018673943355679512,
0.5854827761650085,
-1.1599024534225464,
-0.4737374186515808,
0.36729374527931213,
-0.59614497423172,
-0.6500394940376282,
-0.026396427303552628,
-0.8995861411094666,
-0.450459361076355,
-0.04624680057168007,
0.06811369210481644,
0.009126395918428898,
-0.20512895286083221,
0.31454944610595703,
-0.0875452384352684,
0.3984096050262451,
0.37406009435653687,
-0.8701849579811096,
0.23534375429153442,
0.7127942442893982,
0.9973828196525574,
-0.31292474269866943,
0.28387904167175293,
-0.8793660998344421,
0.30192625522613525,
-0.14826419949531555,
0.734512984752655,
-0.9312940835952759,
-0.09949000179767609,
0.09665233641862869,
-0.06136637553572655,
0.35861170291900635,
-0.5812773108482361,
0.4461541175842285,
-0.7133899331092834,
-0.2783312201499939,
-0.2777261734008789,
-0.15716241300106049,
-0.08313826471567154,
0.2397262156009674,
-0.7609028220176697,
1.2644585371017456,
0.16588540375232697,
-0.7776654362678528,
0.1905679702758789,
-0.19618989527225494,
-0.37509480118751526,
0.14815767109394073,
-0.1186470165848732,
-0.20821909606456757,
0.11842339485883713,
0.19112853705883026,
0.7962713837623596,
-0.36832207441329956,
0.06884212046861649,
-0.278890997171402,
-0.37252774834632874,
0.13640674948692322,
-0.13204097747802734,
0.3900297284126282,
-0.006716164760291576,
-0.37859660387039185,
0.09580153226852417,
-0.9385156631469727,
0.12416528165340424,
-0.08032463490962982,
-0.8212695717811584,
-0.3829474449157715,
-0.00036348748835735023,
-0.10079663246870041,
0.46359196305274963,
0.0956108495593071,
-0.24828261137008667,
0.7907695174217224,
-0.26105302572250366,
0.40670710802078247,
1.00450599193573,
-0.16254805028438568,
0.7040496468544006,
0.024834003299474716,
0.5621397495269775,
0.1060400903224945,
0.14369168877601624,
-0.24542619287967682,
-0.4865318834781647,
-1.1632049083709717,
-0.30378276109695435,
0.5141106843948364,
0.34043189883232117,
-0.6746294498443604,
0.29886341094970703,
-0.7953760623931885,
-0.3873535096645355,
-0.3797090947628021,
-0.0980263277888298,
0.191355898976326,
0.4907083213329315,
0.08593617379665375,
-0.5765279531478882,
-0.42638278007507324,
-1.042707085609436,
-0.01836356520652771,
-0.006655139848589897,
-0.017857808619737625,
0.4741980731487274,
0.18995727598667145,
0.13954457640647888,
0.6338520646095276,
-0.3577267527580261,
0.07839968800544739,
-0.07054400444030762,
0.3071559965610504,
0.1713460087776184,
0.37284591794013977,
0.3115764856338501,
-0.6751696467399597,
-0.8310592770576477,
-0.07510513067245483,
-0.26557087898254395,
-0.1444469839334488,
-0.08525822311639786,
-0.15327805280685425,
0.04697980731725693,
0.42615434527397156,
-0.8117649555206299,
0.5262628197669983,
0.7371469140052795,
-0.21895240247249603,
0.6735349297523499,
0.0240355022251606,
0.15903708338737488,
-0.9830142855644226,
0.10262396931648254,
-0.28926408290863037,
-0.45442333817481995,
-0.545176088809967,
-0.1105688139796257,
0.3918541967868805,
0.34157031774520874,
-0.4384646713733673,
0.46846702694892883,
-0.6170691251754761,
-0.08417364209890366,
-0.5460700392723083,
-0.04315735772252083,
-0.41123703122138977,
0.7176989316940308,
-0.2935095727443695,
0.7032385468482971,
0.8497703075408936,
-0.9380044341087341,
0.8651469349861145,
-0.19254976511001587,
-0.7204111218452454,
0.43798089027404785,
-0.50214022397995,
0.3750629723072052,
-0.2528555989265442,
0.7324926257133484,
-1.1050012111663818,
-0.2189611792564392,
0.2695988416671753,
-0.490337610244751,
0.49906498193740845,
-0.4560844898223877,
-0.5200495719909668,
-0.1714227795600891,
-0.4549260139465332,
0.7385095953941345,
0.6919503211975098,
-0.49108704924583435,
0.8584581017494202,
0.438321590423584,
-0.18465222418308258,
-1.17073655128479,
-0.7305033206939697,
0.26154541969299316,
-0.12743158638477325,
-0.9585677981376648,
0.5370981097221375,
-0.15013006329536438,
-0.013728374615311623,
-0.0911453440785408,
-0.5013035535812378,
-0.07979726046323776,
-0.16518181562423706,
0.36341819167137146,
-0.16400504112243652,
-0.3656773865222931,
0.2018701732158661,
-0.172980397939682,
-0.10693894326686859,
0.011408503167331219,
-0.7045522332191467,
0.930012047290802,
0.06365080177783966,
0.05906704068183899,
-0.6816748976707458,
0.28408870100975037,
0.7970499396324158,
0.07729639858007431,
0.8953278064727783,
0.6542597413063049,
-0.3016967475414276,
-0.41544488072395325,
-0.7150018811225891,
-0.1559009850025177,
-0.5226918458938599,
0.37874355912208557,
-0.4028061628341675,
-0.8169711232185364,
0.8029295802116394,
-0.30831050872802734,
-0.19292417168617249,
0.13517186045646667,
0.8732039928436279,
0.05921521037817001,
1.0471789836883545,
0.637169599533081,
-0.28782200813293457,
0.6115695238113403,
-0.30104970932006836,
0.17037099599838257,
-0.9981125593185425,
-0.3074735403060913,
-0.5563681721687317,
-0.7856908440589905,
-0.42098769545555115,
-0.7448553442955017,
0.03966629505157471,
0.25621163845062256,
0.0027894210070371628,
-0.03251639008522034,
-0.47339174151420593,
0.6141468286514282,
0.28404873609542847,
-0.06079763174057007,
0.15832017362117767,
-0.03340625390410423,
-0.16196735203266144,
0.12813320755958557,
-0.8307867646217346,
-0.07522136718034744,
0.9950098395347595,
0.1421903818845749,
1.0017368793487549,
0.1856028288602829,
-0.004913619719445705,
0.38782447576522827,
0.25698933005332947,
-1.0056371688842773,
0.5772110819816589,
0.21803011000156403,
-0.18684691190719604,
-0.08795884996652603,
-0.31411507725715637,
-1.0252346992492676,
0.10739332437515259,
0.0642935186624527,
-0.8413397669792175,
0.11139531433582306,
0.2557217478752136,
-0.2821969985961914,
0.2709712088108063,
-0.4357779622077942,
0.4996771812438965,
0.27072983980178833,
-0.5165497064590454,
-0.5278044939041138,
-0.6770086884498596,
0.32908913493156433,
0.07000172883272171,
-0.25809386372566223,
0.23564866185188293,
-0.25955283641815186,
0.6786076426506042,
-0.2097163051366806,
0.7117417454719543,
-0.015122058801352978,
-0.07507450878620148,
0.031075818464159966,
0.1806575059890747,
1.3011375665664673,
0.05627967417240143,
0.1593414843082428,
0.01407028827816248,
-0.5469335913658142,
-0.6016477942466736,
-1.0649163722991943,
0.9678711891174316,
-0.4911070466041565,
-0.5150344967842102,
-0.17613720893859863,
-0.4426136016845703,
-0.008287278935313225,
0.13429875671863556,
0.015043085440993309,
0.34556883573532104,
0.13649848103523254,
0.8086425065994263,
0.879095733165741,
-0.08127845078706741,
0.40335527062416077,
0.5150654315948486,
0.113681860268116,
-0.13546085357666016,
0.5733581185340881,
-0.02307337336242199,
0.24190957844257355,
0.6038244962692261,
0.14583659172058105,
-0.06470120698213577,
-0.7627357244491577,
-0.3258311450481415,
0.13940830528736115,
-0.9734411835670471,
-0.3144517242908478,
-0.9290421605110168,
-0.1954391449689865,
-0.4534452557563782,
-0.09460001438856125,
-0.8626002073287964,
-0.5781278014183044,
0.14449189603328705,
0.18914726376533508,
-0.0728839710354805,
0.6015274524688721,
0.32531487941741943,
0.4793502986431122,
-0.6570683717727661,
0.14315974712371826,
0.31634995341300964,
0.4593884348869324,
0.4880882799625397,
-0.42219609022140503,
-0.4865351915359497,
-0.2562818229198456,
-0.2865584194660187,
-0.668727457523346,
0.25408872961997986,
-0.18883012235164642,
0.3237830102443695,
0.6141201853752136,
0.09820640087127686,
0.8694759011268616,
-0.4714357256889343,
0.8685750365257263,
0.23438407480716705,
-0.7769781947135925,
0.2940561771392822,
-0.31546610593795776,
0.7214847803115845,
0.13188433647155762,
0.15705662965774536,
-0.8940309882164001,
-0.3635375201702118,
-0.3968982398509979,
-1.1369376182556152,
0.6822802424430847,
0.3139744699001312,
0.04687352851033211,
0.22079284489154816,
0.4663625955581665,
-0.11119922250509262,
0.16043460369110107,
-0.7154636383056641,
-0.250413179397583,
0.11031448841094971,
-0.2229018360376358,
0.44650593400001526,
-0.4732707738876343,
0.08451762050390244,
-0.23765259981155396,
0.5561947822570801,
0.08742924779653549,
0.516430675983429,
-0.004444812890142202,
-0.19790306687355042,
-0.1334405392408371,
0.0502508170902729,
0.7305386066436768,
0.6148021221160889,
-0.029652222990989685,
0.32119274139404297,
-0.076348677277565,
-0.8868241906166077,
0.006945191416889429,
-0.4117506146430969,
0.08240870386362076,
-0.3293616771697998,
0.04546787962317467,
0.7130547761917114,
0.18062303960323334,
-0.4620460569858551,
0.5878076553344727,
-0.4581396281719208,
0.0795905813574791,
-0.32176393270492554,
0.23785844445228577,
0.25573158264160156,
0.4482450485229492,
0.39665746688842773,
-0.08386673033237457,
-0.05189081281423569,
-0.09508325904607773,
-0.018066998571157455,
0.4742247462272644,
-0.30994856357574463,
-0.38398921489715576,
0.25576385855674744,
0.4018135964870453,
-0.23155243694782257,
0.8336852788925171,
0.2821635603904724,
-0.34742462635040283,
0.5616172552108765,
0.37553274631500244,
0.8803650140762329,
-0.6212135553359985,
-0.2899305820465088,
0.47974398732185364,
0.22560010850429535,
-0.20973075926303864,
-0.11626481264829636,
-0.7186657190322876,
-0.46201369166374207,
-0.7815263867378235,
-0.6448523998260498,
0.03885290026664734,
0.6179800629615784,
-0.5347883105278015,
0.4691310524940491,
-0.33929771184921265,
-0.015858108177781105,
-0.05265483260154724,
-0.16226495802402496,
-0.582073450088501,
-0.01654001884162426,
0.02261960506439209,
0.9066222906112671,
-0.32331278920173645,
1.0878019332885742,
0.30605143308639526,
0.12339181452989578,
-0.4093042314052582,
0.225763738155365,
-0.11138857156038284,
-0.6826296448707581,
0.8831707835197449,
0.30380672216415405,
-0.3726976215839386,
0.13472144305706024,
-0.6049809455871582,
-1.2550965547561646,
1.1732959747314453,
0.254488080739975,
-0.5019534826278687,
-0.13202229142189026,
0.004944935906678438,
0.22777169942855835,
-0.32359573245048523,
0.1137869581580162,
0.2500903010368347,
0.6058133840560913,
0.37472039461135864,
-0.6945231556892395,
0.09420762211084366,
-0.5058271884918213,
-0.10944576561450958,
0.44985702633857727,
-0.812090277671814,
0.5893697142601013,
0.047734588384628296,
-0.4409022033214569,
0.00015594507567584515,
0.6951521635055542,
-0.15981511771678925,
-0.246048703789711,
0.43286025524139404,
0.6649401783943176,
0.6664779782295227,
0.12390066683292389,
1.16054105758667,
-0.5110459923744202,
0.16720376908779144,
0.8643640279769897,
0.196294903755188,
0.6263420581817627,
0.6282433271408081,
0.06234860047698021,
0.6127171516418457,
0.663004457950592,
0.2506081759929657,
0.8003137707710266,
0.5208262801170349,
-0.4466175436973572,
-0.34693893790245056,
0.07609664648771286,
-0.39022111892700195,
0.41683897376060486,
0.3377760946750641,
-0.3745993375778198,
0.06082148477435112,
-0.2431899905204773,
-0.1306300163269043,
-0.7823408842086792,
-0.33510732650756836,
0.5162343978881836,
-0.051523126661777496,
-0.9756734371185303,
0.7902237176895142,
0.17907138168811798,
0.6607118844985962,
-0.658111572265625,
0.05199459567666054,
-0.004822181072086096,
0.344444215297699,
-0.14418360590934753,
-0.5466201305389404,
-0.078008271753788,
-0.0499899797141552,
-0.5036115646362305,
-0.33073925971984863,
0.8777304291725159,
-0.3325708508491516,
-0.09574784338474274,
0.10491469502449036,
0.018731385469436646,
0.12630580365657806,
-0.15903252363204956,
-0.40683484077453613,
0.1130753681063652,
-0.07625418156385422,
-0.7662240862846375,
0.4951495826244354,
0.27736544609069824,
0.0700167641043663,
1.0088690519332886,
0.6986638307571411,
0.31918245553970337,
0.39085009694099426,
0.0476689450442791,
1.12212336063385,
-0.7002520561218262,
-0.9458974003791809,
-0.8865896463394165,
0.706932008266449,
-0.2610093951225281,
-0.03495541214942932,
0.644108772277832,
0.4708233177661896,
0.7018272280693054,
-0.0138045409694314,
0.7259698510169983,
0.21129390597343445,
-0.23224753141403198,
-0.6437651515007019,
0.6728343963623047,
-0.5017713308334351,
0.1512831747531891,
-0.06720533221960068,
-1.0152310132980347,
-0.22938378155231476,
0.6408970355987549,
0.0362754762172699,
0.059428852051496506,
0.8491328954696655,
0.647869348526001,
-0.3519916236400604,
-0.11320815235376358,
0.16675232350826263,
0.5268535017967224,
0.41702619194984436,
0.684255063533783,
0.8590516448020935,
-0.15104150772094727,
0.6853258013725281,
-0.08449003100395203,
-0.22472113370895386,
-0.3804578185081482,
-1.0722112655639648,
-0.767925500869751,
-0.5878852605819702,
-0.22942091524600983,
-0.5085482001304626,
-0.01890283077955246,
0.4392729103565216,
1.019822597503662,
-0.4082251787185669,
-0.07626711577177048,
-0.261808842420578,
0.05129246041178703,
-0.045421842485666275,
-0.2891148030757904,
0.4209519028663635,
-0.28283682465553284,
-0.760359525680542,
0.20897036790847778,
0.8203109502792358,
-0.1686132401227951,
-0.6066815257072449,
-0.15941308438777924,
0.07268965989351273,
0.12858381867408752,
0.6272698640823364,
-0.0676954984664917,
-0.5787973999977112,
-0.1365916132926941,
0.07261744141578674,
-0.22967903316020966,
0.3968106210231781,
1.3764938116073608,
-1.0613529682159424,
0.6192166209220886,
0.9910217523574829,
0.7413662672042847,
0.881497323513031,
-0.07747015357017517,
0.5875742435455322,
-0.916733980178833,
0.3938641846179962,
0.3441142737865448,
0.08621601015329361,
0.1792200803756714,
-0.4746575653553009,
0.14970515668392181,
0.25085416436195374,
-0.6497910022735596,
-0.8275447487831116,
0.23289074003696442,
-1.2616026401519775,
-0.21378058195114136,
1.4426981210708618,
0.045616500079631805,
-0.5836248397827148,
-0.24667511880397797,
0.1394958198070526,
0.3554627001285553,
-0.6332800984382629,
1.1622145175933838,
1.3298614025115967,
-0.05610352009534836,
-0.2906119227409363,
-0.778849720954895,
0.6752893328666687,
0.3303087055683136,
-0.517917275428772,
0.3010171949863434,
0.28699231147766113,
0.16882465779781342,
0.04314791038632393,
0.654828667640686,
-0.015604428015649319,
0.3701741397380829,
-0.2158128023147583,
-0.006991816218942404,
0.02017129398882389,
-0.5285726189613342,
-0.29112231731414795,
0.32395005226135254,
-0.4658183157444,
-0.006458794232457876
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.02061v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.02061v2
|
Alice in Wonderland: Simple Tasks Showing Complete Reasoning Breakdown in State-Of-the-Art Large Language Models
| 2024-06-04T07:43:33 | 2024-06-05T23:23:54 |
Marianna Nezhurina, Lucia Cipolina-Kun, Mehdi Cherti, Jenia Jitsev
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) are often described as being instances of
foundation models - that is, models that transfer strongly across various tasks
and conditions in few-show or zero-shot manner, while exhibiting scaling laws
that predict function improvement when increasing the pre-training scale. These
claims of excelling in different functions and tasks rely on measurements taken
across various sets of standardized benchmarks showing high scores for such
models. We demonstrate here a dramatic breakdown of function and reasoning
capabilities of state-of-the-art models trained at the largest available scales
which claim strong function, using a simple, short, conventional common sense
problem formulated in concise natural language, easily solvable by humans. The
breakdown is dramatic, as models also express strong overconfidence in their
wrong solutions, while providing often non-sensical "reasoning"-like
explanations akin to confabulations to justify and backup the validity of their
clearly failed responses, making them sound plausible. Various standard
interventions in an attempt to get the right solution, like various type of
enhanced prompting, or urging the models to reconsider the wrong solutions
again by multi step re-evaluation, fail. We take these initial observations to
the scientific and technological community to stimulate urgent re-assessment of
the claimed capabilities of current generation of LLMs, Such re-assessment also
requires common action to create standardized benchmarks that would allow
proper detection of such basic reasoning deficits that obviously manage to
remain undiscovered by current state-of-the-art evaluation procedures and
benchmarks. Code for reproducing experiments in the paper and raw experiments
data can be found at https://github.com/LAION-AI/AIW
|
[
-0.37725791335105896,
-0.8027938604354858,
0.9617672562599182,
-0.018151041120290756,
0.1298297941684723,
-0.09865124523639679,
-0.12196333706378937,
-0.29442474246025085,
-0.0985197052359581,
0.461884468793869,
-0.5762786865234375,
-0.09917383641004562,
-0.6695646643638611,
0.17682452499866486,
-0.7773102521896362,
0.5733818411827087,
-0.12665852904319763,
-0.17786449193954468,
-0.8332521319389343,
-0.15358254313468933,
-0.49211177229881287,
-0.34849557280540466,
-0.5070470571517944,
-0.7324846386909485,
0.19912035763263702,
0.35641130805015564,
0.6369645595550537,
0.4567422866821289,
0.4887205958366394,
0.2572953701019287,
-0.24893155694007874,
0.07397332042455673,
-0.5089308023452759,
0.0013517477782443166,
-0.21726694703102112,
-0.580079197883606,
-0.2494075745344162,
-0.002886720234528184,
0.5609930157661438,
0.9383251070976257,
-0.09403875470161438,
0.04734228923916817,
0.20174217224121094,
0.49376246333122253,
-0.7152430415153503,
0.26267918944358826,
-0.5286794304847717,
-0.15689797699451447,
0.11329801380634308,
0.17419938743114471,
-0.44242697954177856,
0.018082333728671074,
0.042892035096883774,
-0.5047206878662109,
0.011182738468050957,
-0.04629425331950188,
0.7835199236869812,
0.3531869053840637,
-0.6866263747215271,
-0.36223217844963074,
-0.6603204607963562,
1.0545722246170044,
-0.5942890048027039,
0.2476547509431839,
0.2226846069097519,
0.18776465952396393,
-0.1771491914987564,
-0.7351585030555725,
-0.5479380488395691,
-0.6157347559928894,
-0.05849509686231613,
-0.16706430912017822,
-0.5087531208992004,
-0.2376255840063095,
0.5628666877746582,
0.25521939992904663,
-0.35484960675239563,
0.13986511528491974,
-0.19278335571289062,
-0.0500994548201561,
0.6706799864768982,
0.36632663011550903,
0.17919692397117615,
-0.04818274825811386,
0.04549223557114601,
0.2255709022283554,
-0.782804548740387,
0.07518687099218369,
-0.20421543717384338,
0.15683263540267944,
-0.0017766434466466308,
0.5242626667022705,
-0.4156091511249542,
0.5820199847221375,
-0.11125285923480988,
-0.28058546781539917,
-0.05696982890367508,
-0.20537003874778748,
-0.31901639699935913,
-0.23553550243377686,
0.79207444190979,
0.19943052530288696,
0.33304470777511597,
-0.17659485340118408,
-0.4336091876029968,
0.19464290142059326,
0.06971325725317001,
-0.5102437734603882,
-0.11623957008123398,
0.2282276600599289,
-0.23158787190914154,
-0.10716400295495987,
-0.4330289959907532,
-0.2665289342403412,
-0.5986533164978027,
-0.5007631778717041,
0.4879815876483917,
-0.2954238951206207,
-0.4104904234409332,
0.2550913989543915,
0.18198952078819275,
0.12198186665773392,
0.4882417619228363,
-0.7458912134170532,
0.3696122467517853,
0.8262708783149719,
0.8123940229415894,
-0.10643358528614044,
-0.3013237714767456,
-0.43430957198143005,
-0.08559708297252655,
-0.36482957005500793,
0.6764765381813049,
-0.42482301592826843,
-0.4225235879421234,
0.09589904546737671,
0.11175902187824249,
0.03145045414566994,
-0.6990117430686951,
0.7000948786735535,
-0.15947435796260834,
-0.2122124582529068,
-0.48787951469421387,
-0.42630863189697266,
-0.10633794218301773,
0.4991123378276825,
-0.6657705903053284,
0.7104082703590393,
-0.14069722592830658,
-0.7115808725357056,
0.2691669166088104,
-0.7309472560882568,
-0.6503214836120605,
-0.08270315825939178,
-0.17205853760242462,
-0.04247604310512543,
0.2525653839111328,
0.35000792145729065,
0.3639608323574066,
-0.7790766358375549,
0.22186702489852905,
-0.6205713748931885,
-0.5241621136665344,
0.4273410737514496,
-0.5432376265525818,
1.01667320728302,
0.13865962624549866,
-0.36020371317863464,
-0.0005976842949166894,
-0.8728600144386292,
0.017422666773200035,
0.4099613130092621,
-0.10301176458597183,
-0.20127084851264954,
0.002975482027977705,
-0.2310759723186493,
0.09472160786390305,
0.3613038659095764,
-0.31305065751075745,
0.16147835552692413,
-0.18255934119224548,
0.8266974091529846,
0.4684140980243683,
-0.0880773589015007,
0.28282999992370605,
-0.3947800397872925,
0.37121009826660156,
-0.18406535685062408,
0.018497228622436523,
-0.1356959491968155,
-0.3958843946456909,
-0.8128790855407715,
-0.1337769329547882,
0.03844178840517998,
0.45308592915534973,
-0.37639757990837097,
0.17392925918102264,
-0.34613847732543945,
-0.4948597252368927,
-0.5049228072166443,
0.03844720497727394,
0.23777785897254944,
0.7189605832099915,
0.1343134194612503,
-0.0991247147321701,
-0.12735328078269958,
-0.8697541356086731,
-0.3724885582923889,
-0.18622420728206635,
-0.17390276491641998,
0.08349387347698212,
0.7886223793029785,
-0.35251832008361816,
0.8346738219261169,
-0.3314889371395111,
-0.0459742434322834,
-0.3298613131046295,
0.24570834636688232,
0.22713252902030945,
0.37316322326660156,
0.03841700404882431,
-0.5420961380004883,
0.09605798870325089,
-0.12593138217926025,
-1.0646666288375854,
0.02082708664238453,
-0.24699297547340393,
0.06901467591524124,
0.14545945823192596,
0.45310041308403015,
-0.9515764117240906,
0.25058767199516296,
0.05355034023523331,
-0.11031591147184372,
0.9738883972167969,
-0.117538683116436,
0.31002140045166016,
-0.5686936378479004,
0.11730148643255234,
0.11309542506933212,
-0.06406895071268082,
-0.35098332166671753,
0.42079928517341614,
-0.06908996403217316,
-0.07973936945199966,
-0.30433133244514465,
0.4680674076080322,
-0.4961478114128113,
-0.1309918463230133,
-0.21393489837646484,
0.3156943619251251,
0.09981471300125122,
0.20898036658763885,
-0.07896847277879715,
0.46132341027259827,
0.8629595041275024,
-0.3996780514717102,
0.5632405877113342,
0.05265916511416435,
-0.3240754008293152,
0.6428831219673157,
-0.7687711119651794,
0.1856241673231125,
0.06182747334241867,
-0.07265052944421768,
-0.9920642971992493,
-0.4099619388580322,
0.03343085199594498,
-0.3105795979499817,
0.1471739113330841,
-0.04989056661725044,
-0.7989925146102905,
-0.2847716510295868,
0.02217577025294304,
0.11332400143146515,
0.6034973859786987,
-0.49123233556747437,
0.6042083501815796,
0.318578839302063,
0.13181377947330475,
-0.3839583098888397,
-1.055506706237793,
0.16427595913410187,
-0.17543573677539825,
-0.8905105590820312,
-0.17359763383865356,
-0.03269271180033684,
-0.7250838279724121,
0.057676658034324646,
-0.2646356523036957,
-0.15637622773647308,
0.31961676478385925,
0.2354162186384201,
0.012690505012869835,
-0.24959050118923187,
0.1674751192331314,
0.0577557347714901,
0.09252799302339554,
0.5644214749336243,
0.10121443122625351,
0.36017999053001404,
-0.5366591811180115,
-0.6837171316146851,
-0.4542093575000763,
0.340054452419281,
1.0088304281234741,
-0.2715982496738434,
0.7101942896842957,
0.04077830910682678,
-0.6327787637710571,
-0.1738448143005371,
-0.38008415699005127,
-0.16645994782447815,
-0.4142318367958069,
0.3597777783870697,
-0.6504278779029846,
-0.7491347193717957,
0.4114219546318054,
-0.2664605975151062,
0.24697785079479218,
0.4548741281032562,
0.4254462718963623,
-0.20485661923885345,
1.2997877597808838,
0.36115017533302307,
0.2081492841243744,
-0.02232944779098034,
-0.2898387908935547,
0.35690078139305115,
-0.6399989724159241,
-0.11874654144048691,
-0.45317214727401733,
-0.11801610887050629,
-0.20963169634342194,
-0.21941301226615906,
0.043979644775390625,
0.39366212487220764,
-0.4941321313381195,
-0.04900725930929184,
-0.4513545632362366,
0.5422424077987671,
0.41179972887039185,
-0.026030002161860466,
0.5897833108901978,
-0.14934392273426056,
0.053950995206832886,
0.0493784099817276,
-0.6165955662727356,
-0.7151461839675903,
1.1785277128219604,
0.4526771008968353,
0.8772575259208679,
-0.10610578209161758,
0.8451881408691406,
0.31951838731765747,
0.5122167468070984,
-0.946389377117157,
0.7240816950798035,
0.0398993194103241,
-0.5381501913070679,
-0.3070380985736847,
-0.44962313771247864,
-0.7650189399719238,
0.07239393889904022,
-0.12538285553455353,
-0.7271046042442322,
0.02362174540758133,
0.1277271807193756,
-0.31280624866485596,
0.11617857217788696,
-0.734847366809845,
0.9643611311912537,
-0.3242245614528656,
-0.259514719247818,
-0.3529965877532959,
-0.29041776061058044,
0.8628658652305603,
-0.040625013411045074,
0.36221596598625183,
0.03863301873207092,
0.0833301991224289,
0.7081913352012634,
-0.4377017915248871,
0.7277172207832336,
0.06427457183599472,
-0.10677648335695267,
0.32833436131477356,
0.2992192208766937,
0.565004289150238,
0.09111184626817703,
0.093408964574337,
-0.044033899903297424,
0.21157385408878326,
-0.5323280692100525,
-0.7879188656806946,
0.8181542158126831,
-0.7527849078178406,
-0.8411999344825745,
-0.5042368769645691,
-0.5446915030479431,
-0.3523704409599304,
0.18717852234840393,
0.1951281726360321,
0.5474299788475037,
-0.0434790700674057,
0.1440521776676178,
0.6818478107452393,
0.19149743020534515,
0.20826801657676697,
0.4458773136138916,
-0.3610045909881592,
-0.0713522881269455,
0.6308670043945312,
0.15803910791873932,
0.3666224181652069,
-0.13698041439056396,
-0.03345293924212456,
-0.29713132977485657,
-0.7318153977394104,
-0.07442386448383331,
0.40963155031204224,
-1.172404408454895,
0.04571498930454254,
-0.5013691782951355,
-0.15703071653842926,
-0.4609355032444,
-0.24734169244766235,
-0.29575011134147644,
-0.1735278218984604,
-0.3128497302532196,
-0.033883240073919296,
0.00480563472956419,
0.9667653441429138,
0.07569420337677002,
0.149020254611969,
-0.5896028280258179,
0.1957056075334549,
0.4362139403820038,
0.1206216812133789,
0.21187494695186615,
-0.5656735897064209,
-0.2126053124666214,
0.06538913398981094,
-0.37036123871803284,
-0.8357425928115845,
0.07218144834041595,
-0.06043139845132828,
0.586316704750061,
0.3164755403995514,
0.04631597921252251,
0.568469226360321,
-0.22025898098945618,
0.704866886138916,
0.46160945296287537,
-1.078304409980774,
0.5092228055000305,
-0.10829367488622665,
0.514535129070282,
0.35044407844543457,
0.33486077189445496,
-0.46372362971305847,
-0.40951117873191833,
-0.609395444393158,
-0.7243180274963379,
0.47991594672203064,
-0.004972497932612896,
-0.08019451797008514,
-0.14717315137386322,
0.27766361832618713,
-0.05257808789610863,
-0.07904066890478134,
-0.7975957989692688,
-0.05797824263572693,
0.032343316823244095,
0.06584543734788895,
0.0627823993563652,
-0.12723425030708313,
-0.4534446597099304,
-0.2585082948207855,
0.6493166089057922,
-0.13508208096027374,
0.060588084161281586,
0.1700422614812851,
-0.5173617005348206,
-0.129130020737648,
0.3995805084705353,
0.3866646885871887,
1.0546998977661133,
-0.02654206193983555,
0.13555806875228882,
0.162988543510437,
-0.07246457785367966,
0.1852225363254547,
0.1064751148223877,
-0.18171989917755127,
-0.2591022253036499,
0.8245769739151001,
0.7385139465332031,
0.23879756033420563,
-0.914395809173584,
0.3566295802593231,
-0.10221143066883087,
-0.18855862319469452,
-0.4359360933303833,
0.10613729804754257,
0.4219699800014496,
0.3261566162109375,
0.4419112801551819,
0.23393721878528595,
0.15188880264759064,
-0.8648055791854858,
0.43154335021972656,
0.43333539366722107,
-0.2635243535041809,
-0.14138901233673096,
0.5971866846084595,
0.14855799078941345,
-0.4703361988067627,
0.6838265061378479,
-0.48382052779197693,
-0.21585898101329803,
0.5602289438247681,
0.5960838198661804,
0.7573818564414978,
0.2382611781358719,
0.14192329347133636,
0.2622707486152649,
0.6267379522323608,
-0.45837318897247314,
0.14841356873512268,
0.18457847833633423,
-0.6596764326095581,
-0.717204213142395,
-0.5241976380348206,
-0.3105020821094513,
0.4047585427761078,
-0.6848631501197815,
0.1931089460849762,
-0.5981634259223938,
-0.004178676754236221,
-0.19499753415584564,
0.01493367925286293,
-0.6932231187820435,
0.2473762482404709,
0.3265192210674286,
1.0094901323318481,
-0.9818827509880066,
0.6329770088195801,
0.6051351428031921,
-0.5734591484069824,
-0.7027272582054138,
0.3272576630115509,
0.102874755859375,
-0.7139418125152588,
0.7122069597244263,
0.3413219749927521,
-0.05215898156166077,
-0.11767887324094772,
-0.7106013298034668,
-0.8764101266860962,
0.9531299471855164,
0.709044337272644,
-0.8598710894584656,
-0.13898949325084686,
0.1677129566669464,
0.4815206229686737,
-0.4681560695171356,
0.3597719371318817,
1.1015270948410034,
0.463714599609375,
0.16639523208141327,
-1.017059326171875,
0.3951636552810669,
-0.05446598678827286,
-0.3392595946788788,
0.11761535704135895,
-0.4279104769229889,
0.8628389239311218,
-0.342835009098053,
-0.2060079127550125,
0.12227341532707214,
0.5937426090240479,
0.5525106191635132,
0.4331304728984833,
0.6037973165512085,
0.8516659736633301,
0.8254212141036987,
-0.36628052592277527,
1.190778374671936,
0.03734773024916649,
0.3824826180934906,
0.8184479475021362,
-0.2989639341831207,
0.8692924380302429,
0.399033784866333,
-0.29534387588500977,
0.2594412863254547,
0.5346270203590393,
0.12747834622859955,
0.30399248003959656,
0.40830138325691223,
-0.20627440512180328,
-0.6380152702331543,
-0.06406456232070923,
-0.03984546661376953,
0.26938286423683167,
0.3190438747406006,
0.045496806502342224,
-0.2851219177246094,
0.151079460978508,
0.09160973876714706,
0.07294911891222,
-0.5149821639060974,
0.3554963171482086,
0.34245356917381287,
-0.8311432003974915,
1.0081756114959717,
-0.3393661379814148,
0.6003423929214478,
-0.36199653148651123,
-0.030583005398511887,
-0.21919065713882446,
0.15998272597789764,
-0.23019005358219147,
-0.9000545740127563,
0.22529840469360352,
0.0510997548699379,
-0.015446322970092297,
-0.11497597396373749,
0.58261638879776,
-0.16980557143688202,
-0.5812811255455017,
0.4753201901912689,
0.3644668757915497,
0.3574548065662384,
-0.19967298209667206,
-0.8915662169456482,
0.3306996524333954,
-0.051402464509010315,
-0.19504854083061218,
0.2339526265859604,
0.5247505307197571,
-0.04657537117600441,
0.9214275479316711,
0.3193853199481964,
0.07336509972810745,
-0.054737258702516556,
0.06220479682087898,
0.6043107509613037,
-0.6310124397277832,
-0.2322312891483307,
-0.7478334903717041,
0.6853524446487427,
-0.13146555423736572,
-0.27139395475387573,
0.48807787895202637,
0.3122694492340088,
0.6067104935646057,
0.20244204998016357,
0.8895984888076782,
-0.07713908702135086,
0.37840375304222107,
-0.4104622006416321,
0.6702456474304199,
-0.9170055985450745,
0.4726846218109131,
-0.013024757616221905,
-0.6977958679199219,
-0.18124237656593323,
0.3616830110549927,
-0.4770696759223938,
-0.08385517448186874,
0.8665565252304077,
0.5334762930870056,
-0.03914365917444229,
-0.02829919196665287,
0.44959089159965515,
0.4484753906726837,
0.4242829978466034,
0.7764765620231628,
0.961631178855896,
-0.1315983533859253,
0.6692967414855957,
-0.18963681161403656,
-0.4988901615142822,
-0.20260576903820038,
-0.6623845100402832,
-0.8283750414848328,
-0.5441032648086548,
-0.523831844329834,
-0.3463592529296875,
-0.02283533848822117,
0.6432836651802063,
0.37172698974609375,
-0.7215259671211243,
-0.22860252857208252,
-0.21620088815689087,
0.20778720080852509,
-0.2480110079050064,
-0.21004760265350342,
0.16233794391155243,
-0.48447439074516296,
-0.5713331699371338,
0.4333564043045044,
0.2043040692806244,
-0.2840385138988495,
-0.4612218141555786,
-0.11092281341552734,
-0.11595505475997925,
0.15161578357219696,
0.4748806059360504,
0.3189683258533478,
-1.056363821029663,
-0.3616160452365875,
-0.07950247824192047,
-0.09440469741821289,
-0.04053211212158203,
0.6138659715652466,
-0.6991926431655884,
0.22344647347927094,
0.4578740894794464,
0.6982114911079407,
0.3719625174999237,
-0.4339216947555542,
0.5143086910247803,
-0.25181281566619873,
-0.2616626024246216,
0.3934856057167053,
0.7318267226219177,
0.43186354637145996,
-0.1665470451116562,
0.3554469048976898,
0.4007372558116913,
-0.5702318549156189,
-1.3215726613998413,
0.3407655656337738,
-0.736651599407196,
-0.4603673219680786,
0.9163708686828613,
-0.20828714966773987,
-0.37645307183265686,
0.05628920719027519,
0.0010555697372183204,
0.15755310654640198,
-0.22886601090431213,
0.8152315020561218,
1.0595511198043823,
-0.31472134590148926,
-0.32213330268859863,
-0.4800989627838135,
0.2561438977718353,
0.6544755697250366,
-0.6895909905433655,
0.29083237051963806,
0.5428497791290283,
0.3455169200897217,
0.45456433296203613,
0.48365941643714905,
0.02494802698493004,
0.3401241898536682,
0.12622061371803284,
-0.17068159580230713,
-0.03077748790383339,
-0.2772693336009979,
-0.5411813855171204,
0.3111133575439453,
0.3159903883934021,
0.1088029071688652
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.02060v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.02060v1
|
I've got the "Answer"! Interpretation of LLMs Hidden States in Question Answering
| 2024-06-04T07:43:12 | 2024-06-04T07:43:12 |
Valeriya Goloviznina, Evgeny Kotelnikov
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Interpretability and explainability of AI are becoming increasingly important
in light of the rapid development of large language models (LLMs). This paper
investigates the interpretation of LLMs in the context of the knowledge-based
question answering. The main hypothesis of the study is that correct and
incorrect model behavior can be distinguished at the level of hidden states.
The quantized models LLaMA-2-7B-Chat, Mistral-7B, Vicuna-7B and the MuSeRC
question-answering dataset are used to test this hypothesis. The results of the
analysis support the proposed hypothesis. We also identify the layers which
have a negative effect on the model's behavior. As a prospect of practical
application of the hypothesis, we propose to train such "weak" layers
additionally in order to improve the quality of the task solution.
|
[
-0.1334100067615509,
-1.0607666969299316,
1.0490612983703613,
-0.022481804713606834,
-0.2394440770149231,
0.02451830729842186,
0.11437688767910004,
-0.38028484582901,
0.05552905797958374,
0.6842734813690186,
-0.6115736365318298,
-0.33926263451576233,
-0.5417495965957642,
-0.006770424544811249,
-0.64528489112854,
0.8289198279380798,
-0.07008200138807297,
0.142270028591156,
-0.5519382953643799,
0.07097775489091873,
-0.547319233417511,
-0.40187761187553406,
-0.5813285112380981,
-0.3171626627445221,
0.5795510411262512,
0.2582276463508606,
0.7941702008247375,
0.8487703800201416,
0.44619840383529663,
0.313333123922348,
-0.34720340371131897,
-0.2877708077430725,
-0.32437536120414734,
0.15032052993774414,
-0.06763172894716263,
-1.408915638923645,
-0.43841642141342163,
-0.028537428006529808,
0.4858611524105072,
0.626879096031189,
-0.15515032410621643,
0.3312787711620331,
-0.03541656211018562,
0.29184412956237793,
-0.3777605891227722,
0.17184986174106598,
-0.5743991136550903,
-0.15023693442344666,
-0.03514295816421509,
-0.2109132707118988,
-0.21142204105854034,
-0.2273937165737152,
0.10318763554096222,
-0.5658814311027527,
0.23841819167137146,
0.03165099024772644,
0.8036765456199646,
0.5572376251220703,
-0.5768303275108337,
-0.334783136844635,
-0.749970555305481,
0.7539181113243103,
-0.87991863489151,
0.08612967282533646,
0.49699223041534424,
0.5394667387008667,
0.07816638797521591,
-0.506926953792572,
-0.8177244067192078,
-0.17647242546081543,
-0.19517245888710022,
0.23780865967273712,
-0.2886846959590912,
0.053907111287117004,
0.3553520441055298,
0.591074526309967,
-0.4819587171077728,
0.16356685757637024,
-0.3899812400341034,
-0.22320231795310974,
0.42478787899017334,
0.24944739043712616,
0.41260430216789246,
-0.22656334936618805,
-0.4000074863433838,
0.40274038910865784,
-0.6915550231933594,
0.265388548374176,
0.22437168657779694,
0.057343218475580215,
-0.1759490966796875,
0.6823437213897705,
-0.2924663722515106,
0.5616872310638428,
-0.13684172928333282,
-0.10507384687662125,
-0.05574817955493927,
-0.13424165546894073,
-0.3579745590686798,
-0.3125994801521301,
0.30785906314849854,
0.014282746240496635,
0.13673196732997894,
-0.23812900483608246,
-0.255001425743103,
0.05582601949572563,
0.0483807809650898,
-0.5814206004142761,
0.07867829501628876,
0.3716507852077484,
-0.3809584379196167,
-0.4929957389831543,
-0.18484988808631897,
-0.1519552618265152,
-0.5573603510856628,
-0.22696484625339508,
0.6470525860786438,
-0.15963448584079742,
-0.5666386485099792,
0.028169715777039528,
-0.18646560609340668,
0.34755054116249084,
0.4341975748538971,
-0.5640490055084229,
0.4740029275417328,
0.7356482148170471,
0.41053083539009094,
-0.13813744485378265,
-0.1898312270641327,
-0.3340887427330017,
0.17787064611911774,
-0.4490070343017578,
0.8019038438796997,
-0.5725024938583374,
-0.09947259724140167,
-0.19422279298305511,
0.10237319767475128,
-0.18200036883354187,
-0.6540889143943787,
0.4263063073158264,
-0.8257847428321838,
0.2924030125141144,
-0.5510722398757935,
-0.6781517863273621,
-0.4178542196750641,
0.4067114293575287,
-0.6256595253944397,
0.7668708562850952,
-0.03955033794045448,
-0.6462591290473938,
0.0056060138158500195,
-0.6688788533210754,
-0.09031704813241959,
0.11184176802635193,
-0.04717173054814339,
0.1519985944032669,
0.32329967617988586,
0.26890966296195984,
0.3579018712043762,
-0.35587379336357117,
0.12413223087787628,
-0.3040021061897278,
-0.5101609230041504,
0.9902552366256714,
-0.6501339673995972,
0.7272821664810181,
0.21096287667751312,
-0.38826629519462585,
-0.12827067077159882,
-0.6661942005157471,
0.0873909592628479,
0.13910342752933502,
-0.386701375246048,
-0.18934550881385803,
0.18807244300842285,
-0.7000424861907959,
0.24179083108901978,
0.4282139241695404,
-0.5579720139503479,
-0.14065679907798767,
-0.3492828607559204,
0.4313829839229584,
0.8066022992134094,
0.2620621621608734,
0.5013946294784546,
-0.2644239068031311,
0.9233978986740112,
0.33636850118637085,
0.1438271701335907,
0.06611692905426025,
-0.42067620158195496,
-0.9753479361534119,
-0.05839287489652634,
0.1335000842809677,
0.6846793293952942,
-0.8916569352149963,
-0.14520762860774994,
-0.056841734796762466,
-0.2877614200115204,
-0.8868027329444885,
-0.015602459199726582,
0.433655321598053,
0.6242660880088806,
0.18429474532604218,
0.21823574602603912,
-0.1309320032596588,
-1.1045554876327515,
-0.3073407709598541,
-0.26281434297561646,
-0.04154082015156746,
0.3334181606769562,
0.5388882160186768,
-0.035659309476614,
0.6913118362426758,
-0.4868868887424469,
0.24279072880744934,
-0.20220188796520233,
-0.10745082050561905,
0.3873755633831024,
0.17175406217575073,
0.15256360173225403,
-0.8124803304672241,
0.01433075126260519,
-0.2967297434806824,
-0.8921647667884827,
0.0328524224460125,
0.05106104537844658,
-0.12250703573226929,
-0.061456963419914246,
0.48777031898498535,
-0.709418773651123,
0.3993940055370331,
0.3890918493270874,
-0.3370448052883148,
0.3891277015209198,
-0.020364344120025635,
0.03478967025876045,
-0.8906521201133728,
-0.1985369175672531,
-0.14398571848869324,
-0.16574232280254364,
-0.7510858774185181,
0.1741025745868683,
-0.05275148153305054,
-0.171550452709198,
-0.49526911973953247,
0.4948241114616394,
-0.2764371633529663,
-0.24645240604877472,
-0.3413700461387634,
0.3411974310874939,
0.23431777954101562,
0.593498945236206,
-0.1186951994895935,
0.7213116884231567,
0.6546154618263245,
-0.6231572031974792,
0.48649874329566956,
0.11823564022779465,
-0.4352857768535614,
0.3657476007938385,
-0.8648654222488403,
0.24347160756587982,
-0.34272500872612,
-0.015187020413577557,
-1.0514370203018188,
-0.10717450827360153,
0.3116804361343384,
-0.5657716989517212,
-0.05968300998210907,
-0.11282708495855331,
-0.4958961308002472,
-0.296196848154068,
0.015395447611808777,
0.2010551393032074,
0.3434406816959381,
-0.3128204643726349,
0.3419036865234375,
0.30024078488349915,
-0.13332556188106537,
-0.7477414011955261,
-0.8155787587165833,
-0.10173049569129944,
-0.36192962527275085,
-0.41504278779029846,
-0.12958309054374695,
-0.2770080864429474,
-0.5891392827033997,
0.2512037456035614,
-0.28565889596939087,
-0.23923738300800323,
0.6810778975486755,
0.3343885838985443,
0.20448826253414154,
-0.5197691321372986,
0.32494083046913147,
0.1661609411239624,
-0.09062690287828445,
0.4178324043750763,
-0.1043766513466835,
0.40676015615463257,
-0.33872705698013306,
-0.35687804222106934,
-0.5846914649009705,
0.178266242146492,
0.614011287689209,
-0.3069010376930237,
0.833118736743927,
0.21708206832408905,
-0.337759792804718,
-0.07550714164972305,
-0.1550406515598297,
-0.20824505388736725,
-0.47648417949676514,
0.3591519594192505,
-0.5208615660667419,
-0.9359336495399475,
0.7436309456825256,
0.18026384711265564,
-0.2815614938735962,
0.4821006953716278,
0.48137807846069336,
-0.5449622273445129,
1.2978824377059937,
0.4992556869983673,
-0.03558754548430443,
0.077940933406353,
-0.13019408285617828,
0.04431678354740143,
-0.7123931646347046,
-0.333620548248291,
-0.435313880443573,
-0.27475741505622864,
-0.6175995469093323,
-0.24510496854782104,
0.30212724208831787,
0.3386584222316742,
-0.3215574622154236,
-0.05335906147956848,
-0.17179730534553528,
0.5372660756111145,
0.48385700583457947,
0.29442834854125977,
0.2601136863231659,
-0.3303956091403961,
0.085539810359478,
0.22340627014636993,
-0.5479353666305542,
-0.6063129901885986,
0.8297998905181885,
0.6540249586105347,
0.7490939497947693,
0.4053972661495209,
0.44771912693977356,
0.15966254472732544,
0.16705285012722015,
-0.8234661817550659,
0.7336937189102173,
0.2245834618806839,
-0.9498358368873596,
-0.482921838760376,
-0.42820292711257935,
-0.6707938313484192,
0.30487966537475586,
-0.264434814453125,
-0.7127408981323242,
-0.1033220887184143,
0.11589335650205612,
-0.25253522396087646,
0.22348663210868835,
-0.6693940758705139,
0.8077453970909119,
-0.39265936613082886,
0.1583329737186432,
-0.283762127161026,
-0.49964457750320435,
0.49069154262542725,
0.22033920884132385,
0.16498063504695892,
-0.28779131174087524,
-0.13217712938785553,
0.7940747737884521,
-0.21329917013645172,
0.9530087113380432,
-0.40319451689720154,
-0.3703972399234772,
0.47648677229881287,
0.08623988926410675,
0.4106202721595764,
0.057116877287626266,
-0.2391377091407776,
0.024287614971399307,
0.31718042492866516,
-0.538743793964386,
-1.0326427221298218,
0.39998719096183777,
-0.8804108500480652,
-1.058366298675537,
-0.20912057161331177,
-0.7286109328269958,
-0.20103242993354797,
0.13464652001857758,
0.11744103580713272,
0.6072919368743896,
0.233774334192276,
0.03467085584998131,
0.9051831960678101,
-0.38459983468055725,
0.14094220101833344,
0.7291277647018433,
-0.3673449158668518,
0.17450843751430511,
0.9139898419380188,
0.026348063722252846,
0.36697372794151306,
0.6421440839767456,
0.29108279943466187,
-0.27754560112953186,
-0.8409281969070435,
-0.3094249963760376,
0.37439826130867004,
-0.8879971504211426,
0.04552165046334267,
-0.2668871283531189,
-0.3595806360244751,
-0.17031316459178925,
0.4204249978065491,
0.10976254940032959,
-0.5567227602005005,
-0.49625125527381897,
-0.37680909037590027,
0.09183527529239655,
0.8834899663925171,
0.360584020614624,
0.45048925280570984,
-0.5221160054206848,
0.34413397312164307,
0.4927392601966858,
0.12827476859092712,
-0.10859394073486328,
-0.7217095494270325,
-0.32274916768074036,
0.2305644452571869,
0.08236309885978699,
-1.0552514791488647,
-0.031218983232975006,
0.060657333582639694,
0.7893549203872681,
0.40588897466659546,
0.05089770630002022,
0.3227081000804901,
-0.09886559844017029,
0.7327108383178711,
-0.1881197839975357,
-0.936774730682373,
0.6394892930984497,
-0.3150624930858612,
0.2923390567302704,
0.18530863523483276,
0.3258223235607147,
-0.5228080153465271,
-0.8472184538841248,
-0.7377431988716125,
-0.3320906162261963,
0.5179939866065979,
0.027881335467100143,
0.2948245704174042,
0.10295912623405457,
0.6807596683502197,
0.20969772338867188,
0.43968623876571655,
-0.8387477993965149,
-0.3788544237613678,
0.07870921492576599,
-0.09627711772918701,
0.0677332654595375,
-0.5403416156768799,
-0.18511784076690674,
0.11466250568628311,
0.4711948037147522,
-0.0678848922252655,
0.656836748123169,
-0.10785607248544693,
-0.35363253951072693,
-0.15613093972206116,
0.48763129115104675,
0.5780258774757385,
1.0585116147994995,
-0.21837502717971802,
0.49788135290145874,
0.233393594622612,
-0.25351405143737793,
-0.06899241358041763,
-0.18419480323791504,
-0.3375071585178375,
-0.28151190280914307,
0.630448579788208,
0.9503577351570129,
-0.15564288198947906,
-0.4672203063964844,
0.5301735401153564,
-0.03507509455084801,
-0.018779827281832695,
-0.2959873080253601,
0.5288549661636353,
0.1508677452802658,
0.551645040512085,
0.5102543234825134,
0.09486403316259384,
0.09453810006380081,
-0.7241060137748718,
-0.033061109483242035,
0.4334670901298523,
-0.6706040501594543,
-0.5711120367050171,
0.6058376431465149,
0.09393692016601562,
-0.1645060032606125,
0.5186004638671875,
-0.18761691451072693,
-0.7230730056762695,
0.8627842664718628,
0.559760332107544,
0.3798224627971649,
-0.01069067046046257,
0.44601619243621826,
-0.045078009366989136,
0.42064160108566284,
0.4476640224456787,
0.5804688334465027,
-0.02108813263475895,
-0.9264541268348694,
-0.6451475024223328,
-0.4717942476272583,
-0.39757055044174194,
0.40116554498672485,
-1.1147706508636475,
-0.18459588289260864,
-0.20900602638721466,
0.17111918330192566,
0.022459333762526512,
0.030553899705410004,
-0.5148762464523315,
0.5201062560081482,
0.2593551278114319,
0.8330785036087036,
-0.9076724052429199,
0.9228143692016602,
0.5694364905357361,
-0.27808499336242676,
-0.8557413220405579,
0.18268398940563202,
-0.03571873903274536,
-1.3309295177459717,
0.7119002938270569,
-0.16319216787815094,
-0.01572919450700283,
0.12689417600631714,
-0.8949823379516602,
-0.9921883940696716,
1.084108829498291,
0.4733637571334839,
-0.12231997400522232,
-0.029159385710954666,
0.33576780557632446,
0.6911076307296753,
-0.06735090166330338,
0.2475569248199463,
0.631829023361206,
0.2748141288757324,
-0.016099713742733,
-0.5666771531105042,
0.08074947446584702,
-0.24135279655456543,
-0.2187526524066925,
0.025845780968666077,
-0.440497487783432,
0.8859151601791382,
-0.2952321767807007,
-0.4153490662574768,
0.1580001413822174,
0.8521205186843872,
0.09637600183486938,
0.2905648946762085,
0.4888215661048889,
0.33727124333381653,
0.9575127363204956,
-0.0678015798330307,
1.1664693355560303,
-0.05634654313325882,
0.14475102722644806,
0.8030176162719727,
0.15609805285930634,
0.856206476688385,
0.34264901280403137,
-0.18119633197784424,
0.5923125743865967,
0.7051665186882019,
0.15901093184947968,
0.5780794024467468,
0.3248544931411743,
-0.1487606316804886,
-0.2872256338596344,
-0.10074982047080994,
-0.17283068597316742,
0.47328391671180725,
0.42893072962760925,
0.029336195439100266,
-0.07140114158391953,
0.10158555954694748,
0.07977187633514404,
-0.10337772965431213,
-0.5981190204620361,
0.5281848907470703,
0.1746179759502411,
-0.4550167918205261,
0.5054302215576172,
-0.03859098255634308,
0.340709388256073,
-0.24576541781425476,
0.010011009871959686,
-0.38409626483917236,
-0.03844236209988594,
-0.21265602111816406,
-1.0282002687454224,
0.01238975115120411,
0.07943473011255264,
-0.30251213908195496,
-0.038662657141685486,
0.7359475493431091,
-0.365914523601532,
-0.5049555897712708,
0.07153749465942383,
0.9505608677864075,
0.4132652282714844,
-0.19922631978988647,
-0.8233324289321899,
-0.3245125710964203,
-0.059984855353832245,
-0.19797590374946594,
0.11457724124193192,
0.5627056360244751,
-0.12100084125995636,
0.9423938393592834,
0.3091419041156769,
0.05962079018354416,
0.1795962154865265,
-0.11478325724601746,
0.6988843679428101,
-0.6041930317878723,
-0.32621848583221436,
-0.6707746982574463,
0.454144686460495,
0.258930504322052,
-0.15938019752502441,
0.7716278433799744,
0.31204384565353394,
0.4711115062236786,
0.1617548167705536,
0.8807613253593445,
0.10778064280748367,
0.89981609582901,
-0.6795219779014587,
0.748127818107605,
-0.5559184551239014,
0.5839318633079529,
0.002454888541251421,
-0.7504176497459412,
0.1111387088894844,
0.20781292021274567,
-0.6663448810577393,
-0.12276700884103775,
0.7269867658615112,
0.7010502219200134,
0.16428260505199432,
-0.02016964741051197,
0.48189160227775574,
0.5514412522315979,
0.10511289536952972,
0.4590783715248108,
1.5768369436264038,
-0.30323514342308044,
0.6113752126693726,
-0.2611066401004791,
-0.07688572257757187,
-0.022751668468117714,
-0.49035003781318665,
-0.7175121903419495,
-0.605545163154602,
-0.2843848168849945,
-0.36697372794151306,
-0.2170085459947586,
0.0740576907992363,
0.28238654136657715,
-0.7176275253295898,
-0.13379937410354614,
0.1704747974872589,
0.3663865625858307,
-0.2378034144639969,
-0.2150821089744568,
0.425200492143631,
-0.06859562546014786,
-0.5340523719787598,
0.5451655387878418,
0.014813032932579517,
0.12503084540367126,
-0.11952602863311768,
-0.03963795304298401,
0.041157759726047516,
0.15677647292613983,
0.3374185562133789,
0.09733210504055023,
-0.8158616423606873,
-0.5150721669197083,
0.45417097210884094,
-0.16259147226810455,
-0.024139439687132835,
0.5797913670539856,
-0.5543344616889954,
0.19450461864471436,
0.16571751236915588,
0.35431745648384094,
0.5807492136955261,
0.11335375159978867,
0.42265141010284424,
-0.5024195313453674,
-0.029138995334506035,
0.29310342669487,
0.1279638707637787,
0.11716154962778091,
-0.359803169965744,
0.18059971928596497,
0.056457169353961945,
-0.35043299198150635,
-0.849149763584137,
0.41533124446868896,
-0.8873997926712036,
-0.500912606716156,
1.1560916900634766,
-0.25580623745918274,
-0.3421787917613983,
-0.07268846780061722,
0.026456797495484352,
0.3124009668827057,
0.07555687427520752,
0.5563477873802185,
0.6488784551620483,
-0.22139528393745422,
-0.5042762160301208,
-0.9146090745925903,
0.2685576379299164,
0.4284079670906067,
-0.9615821838378906,
-0.18405258655548096,
0.3168068826198578,
0.3715437650680542,
0.05936621502041817,
0.41590946912765503,
0.07365717738866806,
0.2510968744754791,
-0.0953259989619255,
-0.2053498476743698,
-0.09088067710399628,
-0.16911287605762482,
-0.5203717350959778,
0.013041023164987564,
0.4535798132419586,
-0.4187575876712799
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.02050v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.02050v2
|
Analyzing Social Biases in Japanese Large Language Models
| 2024-06-04T07:31:06 | 2024-06-05T07:56:11 |
Hitomi Yanaka, Namgi Han, Ryoma Kumon, Jie Lu, Masashi Takeshita, Ryo Sekizawa, Taisei Kato, Hiromi Arai
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
With the development of Large Language Models (LLMs), social biases in the
LLMs have become a crucial issue. While various benchmarks for social biases
have been provided across languages, the extent to which Japanese LLMs exhibit
social biases has not been fully investigated. In this study, we construct the
Japanese Bias Benchmark dataset for Question Answering (JBBQ) based on the
English bias benchmark BBQ, and analyze social biases in Japanese LLMs. The
results show that while current Japanese LLMs improve their accuracies on JBBQ
by instruction-tuning, their bias scores become larger. In addition, augmenting
their prompts with warning about social biases reduces the effect of biases in
some models.
|
[
-0.5602956414222717,
-1.0686419010162354,
0.7803543210029602,
0.043367691338062286,
-0.14027969539165497,
0.15369397401809692,
-0.3648854196071625,
-0.456901878118515,
0.22339756786823273,
0.7284675240516663,
-0.7668970227241516,
-0.4846779704093933,
-0.7187613844871521,
0.05408948287367821,
0.1703900247812271,
0.85206538438797,
-0.10898516327142715,
0.35922783613204956,
-0.34380924701690674,
-0.2615007162094116,
-0.5466113686561584,
-0.3100397288799286,
-0.789807915687561,
-0.3950960636138916,
0.5078762769699097,
0.37623053789138794,
0.8987480401992798,
0.36543935537338257,
0.30301716923713684,
0.22039835155010223,
-0.2456160932779312,
-0.023961739614605904,
-0.5752451419830322,
0.3283633589744568,
-0.2025749385356903,
-0.990966260433197,
-0.07599351555109024,
-0.13026796281337738,
0.8650339245796204,
1.0207878351211548,
0.3328525125980377,
0.6301021575927734,
-0.08032975345849991,
0.7815317511558533,
-0.6685032844543457,
0.4256584346294403,
-0.5361846089363098,
-0.07875634729862213,
-0.4166528284549713,
-0.08683034777641296,
-0.46126219630241394,
-0.6746207475662231,
-0.07005532085895538,
-0.34103256464004517,
0.16982722282409668,
0.13607366383075714,
0.5977128148078918,
0.14888885617256165,
-0.3169420063495636,
0.05799325555562973,
-0.19897398352622986,
0.7414454817771912,
-0.7762448191642761,
0.2648676037788391,
0.3535277843475342,
0.41414880752563477,
-0.2447027713060379,
0.0016109357820823789,
-0.29088714718818665,
0.04942799732089043,
0.06648604571819305,
0.015209733508527279,
0.38358455896377563,
-0.07483811676502228,
0.6754948496818542,
-0.059583015739917755,
-0.3849426805973053,
0.14022618532180786,
-0.3091541826725006,
-0.023841004818677902,
0.8236132860183716,
0.34371432662010193,
0.4089978039264679,
-0.5599010586738586,
0.12482023984193802,
-0.12243949621915817,
-0.9818148016929626,
0.19285628199577332,
0.5347912907600403,
0.1802012324333191,
-0.02687348611652851,
0.5780825018882751,
-0.37389707565307617,
0.3260955810546875,
-0.06894414871931076,
-0.11687754094600677,
0.14082710444927216,
-0.12522168457508087,
0.07676712423563004,
0.1457805335521698,
0.7577724456787109,
0.8743812441825867,
0.7492622137069702,
-0.014920664951205254,
0.2570861279964447,
-0.03467216715216637,
-0.05959533154964447,
-0.7106752991676331,
0.3241656720638275,
0.11082925647497177,
-0.5551072359085083,
-0.22981557250022888,
-0.1466701179742813,
-0.8590641021728516,
-0.6339995861053467,
0.08186332881450653,
0.14126624166965485,
0.00937720201909542,
-0.29005464911460876,
0.05939590558409691,
-0.47459617257118225,
0.47239768505096436,
0.21676664054393768,
-0.6957787871360779,
0.21967214345932007,
0.6402024626731873,
0.4886525273323059,
0.11341088265180588,
-0.0680910125374794,
-0.22184069454669952,
0.2937474846839905,
-0.5249760150909424,
0.6045626997947693,
-0.855546236038208,
-0.6083624958992004,
0.11047659069299698,
0.33066362142562866,
0.19539056718349457,
-0.4693449139595032,
0.3324079215526581,
-0.5807739496231079,
0.3766404986381531,
-0.9801281690597534,
-0.5475772023200989,
0.03388132154941559,
0.10791642963886261,
-0.3769400417804718,
0.8742945194244385,
-0.025700893253087997,
-0.9043319821357727,
0.30265235900878906,
-0.4098217189311981,
-0.3712176978588104,
0.09952566027641296,
-0.2996346056461334,
-0.3118683099746704,
0.03423473611474037,
0.5801824331283569,
0.6194548010826111,
-0.5111996531486511,
0.47609350085258484,
-0.9367716908454895,
-0.6862133741378784,
0.6019283533096313,
-0.48488444089889526,
1.0565052032470703,
-0.1617991030216217,
-0.38215455412864685,
-0.3705727756023407,
-0.4418189525604248,
-0.01567479968070984,
0.3581869304180145,
-0.11587885767221451,
-0.8122251629829407,
-0.04054442048072815,
-0.43434691429138184,
-0.06699850410223007,
0.33017072081565857,
-0.556666374206543,
0.08221583813428879,
-0.2806970179080963,
0.18811820447444916,
1.053418517112732,
0.28049346804618835,
0.3468780517578125,
-0.347013384103775,
0.7409682869911194,
-0.19552893936634064,
0.19560553133487701,
-0.16225852072238922,
-0.598241925239563,
-0.65743488073349,
0.1939496099948883,
0.14534157514572144,
0.30861493945121765,
-0.762471616268158,
0.1412850022315979,
-0.3063385486602783,
-0.3643574118614197,
-0.7944401502609253,
0.061447203159332275,
0.5432223081588745,
0.2270677536725998,
0.028184592723846436,
-0.12292724847793579,
-0.23398156464099884,
-1.1566424369812012,
-0.6668879389762878,
-0.07385209202766418,
-0.0828261598944664,
0.6041819453239441,
0.17929507791996002,
-0.07011055201292038,
0.5220479965209961,
-0.47464972734451294,
0.3042600750923157,
-0.19697001576423645,
-0.23472854495048523,
0.2730106711387634,
0.02050071582198143,
0.36407923698425293,
-0.45690828561782837,
-0.7450307607650757,
-0.30392569303512573,
-0.5860673785209656,
-0.5889875888824463,
0.17844530940055847,
-0.37179407477378845,
0.011122155003249645,
0.5826412439346313,
-0.5487561225891113,
0.14411413669586182,
0.27565714716911316,
-0.3003224730491638,
0.46770837903022766,
0.44377151131629944,
0.33829471468925476,
-1.2939263582229614,
-0.18626290559768677,
0.4083288908004761,
-0.2636646330356598,
-0.28930985927581787,
0.11181353032588959,
0.16516192257404327,
0.14656659960746765,
-0.23372556269168854,
0.6736178398132324,
-0.5952755212783813,
-0.5436299443244934,
-0.10845853388309479,
0.41760924458503723,
0.24628619849681854,
0.2590770721435547,
-0.03234854340553284,
0.7182364463806152,
0.36534133553504944,
-0.4162504971027374,
0.25815868377685547,
0.06155720353126526,
-0.6029367446899414,
0.46493545174598694,
-0.8084608316421509,
0.17866933345794678,
-0.559733510017395,
0.22911956906318665,
-1.2224364280700684,
-0.32085639238357544,
0.1895729899406433,
-0.5243241786956787,
0.32380884885787964,
-0.3584171235561371,
-0.437287837266922,
-0.5277164578437805,
-0.4819432497024536,
0.034953463822603226,
0.6414963006973267,
-0.32847070693969727,
0.16432514786720276,
0.6343644261360168,
-0.536348283290863,
-0.7377586364746094,
-0.5600005388259888,
-0.5070297718048096,
-0.25407272577285767,
-0.4995257556438446,
-0.01187000423669815,
-0.03623016178607941,
-0.44584956765174866,
-0.015316382050514221,
-0.08561035245656967,
0.20262564718723297,
0.08911699056625366,
0.16876599192619324,
0.5442709922790527,
-0.2455029934644699,
-0.10012687742710114,
0.4685177505016327,
0.2914096713066101,
0.708547830581665,
0.438135027885437,
0.736436128616333,
0.16660673916339874,
-0.25226840376853943,
-0.14499233663082123,
0.06397921591997147,
0.48439377546310425,
0.10027164965867996,
0.7042912840843201,
0.26177623867988586,
-0.11656226217746735,
-0.0275865588337183,
-0.8912317752838135,
-0.21187476813793182,
-0.49816468358039856,
0.6812790036201477,
-0.28229886293411255,
-0.9709146022796631,
0.664168655872345,
0.2047121524810791,
0.031384214758872986,
0.1112370491027832,
0.5443329811096191,
-0.029091574251651764,
1.4851452112197876,
0.045157257467508316,
-0.389249712228775,
0.5322567820549011,
0.2018776386976242,
-0.12333164364099503,
-1.243255853652954,
-0.0014849103754386306,
-0.6791590452194214,
-0.22339561581611633,
-0.9371498823165894,
-0.4246773421764374,
0.4280264377593994,
-0.27914151549339294,
-0.3702051639556885,
-0.20793725550174713,
-0.10778790712356567,
0.9304123520851135,
0.2710930407047272,
0.2550317049026489,
0.034087542444467545,
-0.15659616887569427,
0.025948842987418175,
-0.07478955388069153,
-0.627749502658844,
-0.5377907752990723,
1.3610100746154785,
0.6012135744094849,
0.8041849732398987,
0.03904365375638008,
0.4865959584712982,
0.010696946643292904,
0.5035943984985352,
-0.43883922696113586,
0.6686351299285889,
-0.020914191380143166,
-1.0967684984207153,
-0.38042205572128296,
-0.6277348399162292,
-0.743992269039154,
0.3135237395763397,
-0.09019909799098969,
-0.6998125314712524,
0.007440303917974234,
-0.13247498869895935,
-0.01696454919874668,
-0.0478164441883564,
-0.6822424530982971,
0.6751821637153625,
-0.056735530495643616,
-0.7800207734107971,
-0.12149661034345627,
-0.6111931800842285,
0.5710489153862,
0.16314788162708282,
0.4491744637489319,
-0.44841837882995605,
0.08388591557741165,
0.8490961194038391,
0.01182837039232254,
0.9352904558181763,
-0.5217816233634949,
0.0762522965669632,
0.0347573384642601,
-0.23364517092704773,
0.5300666689872742,
0.46049270033836365,
-0.2844209372997284,
0.012692746706306934,
0.17152200639247894,
-0.6593743562698364,
-0.5324715971946716,
0.7118459343910217,
-0.9982624650001526,
-0.9447685480117798,
-0.19007259607315063,
-0.42434370517730713,
-0.6963978409767151,
0.18579719960689545,
0.07898830622434616,
0.33808356523513794,
-0.11325665563344955,
0.4143871068954468,
0.9485049843788147,
-0.6445611119270325,
0.08329803496599197,
0.8490102291107178,
-0.5253016948699951,
-0.07673755288124084,
0.1681116223335266,
0.3335787057876587,
0.535422682762146,
0.1559142917394638,
0.2964247465133667,
-0.41294434666633606,
-0.17550386488437653,
-0.6680159568786621,
0.5284497141838074,
-0.6879578232765198,
0.0053824069909751415,
-0.4539638161659241,
-0.21305909752845764,
-0.6664775609970093,
-0.116506427526474,
-0.34657368063926697,
-0.07721597701311111,
0.22353452444076538,
-0.12739907205104828,
0.2541823089122772,
0.7276999354362488,
0.5600951910018921,
0.2010480761528015,
-0.520733654499054,
0.4008807837963104,
0.12925800681114197,
0.4410977363586426,
0.09541361778974533,
-0.6582076549530029,
-0.22303229570388794,
0.19484858214855194,
0.01724979281425476,
-1.0475521087646484,
0.10144662857055664,
-0.4121609032154083,
0.6650280952453613,
0.26002225279808044,
0.08746908605098724,
0.6767247915267944,
-0.42804548144340515,
0.7740551829338074,
-0.013583065941929817,
-0.741909921169281,
0.5297012329101562,
-0.5298459529876709,
0.7666797637939453,
0.6658563613891602,
0.8107110857963562,
-0.7554342746734619,
-0.8475962281227112,
-0.617803156375885,
-0.6317078471183777,
0.6986867785453796,
-0.445939838886261,
0.3613615930080414,
-0.32449331879615784,
0.6417610049247742,
0.06884126365184784,
0.2505331039428711,
-0.8855233192443848,
-0.4600081741809845,
0.14987392723560333,
-0.21783582866191864,
-0.1741931140422821,
-0.5080896615982056,
0.23421192169189453,
-0.06413772702217102,
0.7952023148536682,
-0.02126208320260048,
-0.005717022344470024,
-0.08117453008890152,
0.05449914559721947,
-0.4349411129951477,
0.4674419164657593,
-0.22363178431987762,
0.6195349097251892,
-0.18388326466083527,
-0.2602652907371521,
0.35390618443489075,
-0.2598191499710083,
0.09928842633962631,
-0.03402981907129288,
-0.7544800639152527,
-0.004802747163921595,
0.17887532711029053,
0.9740495681762695,
0.20034165680408478,
-0.6309268474578857,
0.5375592708587646,
-0.04790126159787178,
-0.05154348164796829,
-0.323569655418396,
0.3537262976169586,
0.3744966685771942,
0.1654362827539444,
0.15201501548290253,
-0.5790074467658997,
0.14638617634773254,
-0.889236569404602,
-0.36391130089759827,
0.8020264506340027,
-0.24195678532123566,
-0.043859515339136124,
0.5402736663818359,
0.17321038246154785,
-0.035054802894592285,
0.3725492060184479,
0.04863038659095764,
-0.6330312490463257,
0.7041575312614441,
0.6066426634788513,
0.4310888350009918,
-0.333723783493042,
0.259520560503006,
0.5245339274406433,
0.4194182753562927,
0.005086342804133892,
0.2970552444458008,
0.07013718038797379,
-1.0817254781723022,
-0.5899757146835327,
-0.5934630632400513,
-0.6559954285621643,
0.27178463339805603,
-1.0274337530136108,
0.332853227853775,
-0.6362655758857727,
-0.29061099886894226,
0.13059112429618835,
0.2671506702899933,
-0.6331061720848083,
0.1868460774421692,
0.23658324778079987,
0.5098410248756409,
-1.0899747610092163,
0.6631841063499451,
0.8542178869247437,
-0.28503042459487915,
-0.8012571930885315,
0.008125885389745235,
-0.01018569152802229,
-1.1040427684783936,
0.4371536374092102,
0.367851197719574,
0.22260808944702148,
-0.1776181310415268,
-0.6331066489219666,
-0.9194608330726624,
0.8096175193786621,
0.20359183847904205,
-0.670751690864563,
0.06818066537380219,
0.33050739765167236,
0.48498839139938354,
-0.16264592111110687,
0.5790272951126099,
0.6966573596000671,
0.5519495010375977,
-0.34684398770332336,
-0.5308642387390137,
0.1899886280298233,
-0.42090925574302673,
0.2848895192146301,
0.30782485008239746,
-1.1383975744247437,
0.25398075580596924,
0.21271561086177826,
-0.10236319154500961,
-0.4032108187675476,
0.18299363553524017,
0.4650877118110657,
0.30801063776016235,
0.3024548590183258,
0.14813117682933807,
0.6419933438301086,
-0.10243157297372818,
1.122726559638977,
-0.12045778334140778,
-0.1252608746290207,
1.0675146579742432,
-0.7125815153121948,
0.6050698757171631,
0.40106284618377686,
-0.5057293176651001,
0.4492615759372711,
0.5172579288482666,
0.1796756088733673,
0.19634251296520233,
0.23700787127017975,
-0.060705505311489105,
-0.1386372447013855,
-0.14382338523864746,
-0.42484331130981445,
0.14940671622753143,
0.5402341485023499,
-0.4045356810092926,
0.32159027457237244,
-0.12464353442192078,
0.45525407791137695,
0.11729054152965546,
-0.6306285262107849,
0.7931933999061584,
0.04171166941523552,
-1.001065731048584,
0.18910355865955353,
-0.055485133081674576,
0.7408355474472046,
-0.609123945236206,
0.4760759472846985,
-0.490729957818985,
-0.10011789947748184,
0.013400987721979618,
-0.9834127426147461,
0.17520208656787872,
0.09709366410970688,
-0.3951787054538727,
0.027066923677921295,
0.7922963500022888,
-0.26677462458610535,
-0.4334544539451599,
0.3038921356201172,
0.4721146523952484,
0.1473093032836914,
0.15849089622497559,
-0.6493819952011108,
0.25745517015457153,
0.2621303200721741,
-0.47668081521987915,
0.518406331539154,
0.43268710374832153,
-0.03354183956980705,
0.7352377772331238,
0.5884879231452942,
0.2656416594982147,
0.27988192439079285,
0.46629029512405396,
0.6450229287147522,
-0.7761547565460205,
-0.20330585539340973,
-0.8268466591835022,
0.24983666837215424,
-0.47317832708358765,
-0.14231278002262115,
1.1463634967803955,
0.30437055230140686,
0.944024384021759,
0.05781448632478714,
1.1126211881637573,
0.19060273468494415,
0.8770769834518433,
-0.5599296689033508,
0.5524105429649353,
-0.5205462574958801,
0.32336458563804626,
-0.510976254940033,
-1.0573261976242065,
0.13639064133167267,
0.6228991746902466,
-0.8373888731002808,
0.3370037376880646,
0.521882176399231,
0.9271512627601624,
0.28449535369873047,
0.21285521984100342,
0.1979038566350937,
0.40800830721855164,
0.010917553678154945,
0.43183207511901855,
1.0767627954483032,
-0.35734719038009644,
0.08317777514457703,
-0.2966710031032562,
-0.14182226359844208,
-0.11606179177761078,
-0.6145309209823608,
-1.2326793670654297,
0.06423681974411011,
-0.3084888458251953,
-0.37530291080474854,
0.3818042576313019,
0.9338301420211792,
0.2850106358528137,
-0.6777999997138977,
-0.25293293595314026,
0.3012861907482147,
0.28822070360183716,
0.30801069736480713,
-0.36833545565605164,
0.028381455689668655,
-0.36749717593193054,
-0.7778050899505615,
-0.0851975753903389,
0.10918557643890381,
-0.2711105942726135,
-0.4175923764705658,
0.08427305519580841,
0.048282984644174576,
0.3143995404243469,
0.45671138167381287,
-0.11180603504180908,
-0.5260695815086365,
-0.430238276720047,
0.09570632129907608,
-0.05840490013360977,
-0.06942824274301529,
0.2923351526260376,
-0.34815433621406555,
0.32286402583122253,
0.4432680904865265,
0.6603875160217285,
0.5749519467353821,
0.07084964960813522,
0.6858556270599365,
-0.6106001138687134,
-0.0029111099429428577,
-0.06705915927886963,
0.5484722852706909,
0.4958920478820801,
-0.41268953680992126,
0.2448107898235321,
0.02806311845779419,
-0.776757001876831,
-0.6902284026145935,
0.12194094061851501,
-0.5324862599372864,
-0.48648160696029663,
1.4854928255081177,
0.10316502302885056,
-0.5670202374458313,
-0.065883107483387,
-0.2214520424604416,
0.2453477531671524,
-0.31510281562805176,
0.8340058922767639,
1.1742527484893799,
0.366107314825058,
-0.42260897159576416,
-0.6918329000473022,
0.23747588694095612,
0.7024145126342773,
-0.7263600826263428,
0.27474772930145264,
0.7894665598869324,
0.6265353560447693,
-0.09334389120340347,
0.8493933081626892,
-0.39717748761177063,
0.4074719548225403,
-0.20496012270450592,
-0.12488262355327606,
0.2962092161178589,
0.11866208910942078,
-0.10349331051111221,
-0.01350429467856884,
0.3996712267398834,
0.39809706807136536
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.02044v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.02044v1
|
QROA: A Black-Box Query-Response Optimization Attack on LLMs
| 2024-06-04T07:27:36 | 2024-06-04T07:27:36 |
Hussein Jawad, Nicolas J. -B. BRUNEL
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have surged in popularity in recent months, yet
they possess concerning capabilities for generating harmful content when
manipulated. This study introduces the Query-Response Optimization Attack
(QROA), an optimization-based strategy designed to exploit LLMs through a
black-box, query-only interaction. QROA adds an optimized trigger to a
malicious instruction to compel the LLM to generate harmful content. Unlike
previous approaches, QROA does not require access to the model's logit
information or any other internal data and operates solely through the standard
query-response interface of LLMs. Inspired by deep Q-learning and Greedy
coordinate descent, the method iteratively updates tokens to maximize a
designed reward function. We tested our method on various LLMs such as Vicuna,
Falcon, and Mistral, achieving an Attack Success Rate (ASR) over 80\%. We also
tested the model against Llama2-chat, the fine-tuned version of Llama2 designed
to resist Jailbreak attacks, achieving good ASR with a suboptimal initial
trigger seed. This study demonstrates the feasibility of generating jailbreak
attacks against deployed LLMs in the public domain using black-box optimization
methods, enabling more comprehensive safety testing of LLMs.
|
[
-0.14267794787883759,
-1.0680186748504639,
0.531398355960846,
0.2012006789445877,
-0.5640038251876831,
0.38128355145454407,
0.030570799484848976,
-0.46609967947006226,
0.31596407294273376,
0.7405251860618591,
-0.5226088166236877,
-0.4349074959754944,
-0.3810179829597473,
-0.14626747369766235,
-0.5453290939331055,
0.8273758292198181,
0.3655070960521698,
-0.12644828855991364,
-0.015863407403230667,
0.07433066517114639,
-0.6826183795928955,
-0.8026613593101501,
-0.8207984566688538,
0.41824349761009216,
0.4623670279979706,
0.3171013593673706,
0.4819437563419342,
0.31763237714767456,
0.5344271659851074,
0.1970018744468689,
-0.1001381129026413,
0.21327510476112366,
-0.997130811214447,
0.21303535997867584,
0.10668816417455673,
-0.670767068862915,
-0.3954629600048065,
-0.31208139657974243,
0.37029537558555603,
-0.12564800679683685,
-0.3099091351032257,
0.22987209260463715,
-0.27827519178390503,
0.612122654914856,
-0.8913348913192749,
-0.3495122194290161,
-1.1832195520401,
-0.05445823073387146,
-0.15433141589164734,
-0.4453042149543762,
-0.5879828333854675,
-0.463110089302063,
-0.3422817587852478,
-0.36622512340545654,
-0.20560726523399353,
0.47250813245773315,
0.6674549579620361,
0.2594953775405884,
-0.29584699869155884,
-0.2969878315925598,
-0.6663861274719238,
0.7033475637435913,
-0.7142828106880188,
0.20362631976604462,
0.21434733271598816,
0.33100995421409607,
-0.6286342144012451,
-0.4729599952697754,
-0.5661409497261047,
-0.3955235779285431,
0.24473440647125244,
-0.06538603454828262,
-0.6174367070198059,
-0.017904482781887054,
0.11229926347732544,
0.06449323892593384,
-0.5209476351737976,
0.2588209807872772,
-0.6058611869812012,
-0.04469716176390648,
0.5964267253875732,
0.23405469954013824,
0.34857550263404846,
-0.210952490568161,
-0.6513155698776245,
-0.02919740229845047,
-1.076049566268921,
0.07770388573408127,
0.3911738097667694,
0.12933163344860077,
-0.030334848910570145,
0.681165337562561,
0.023787830024957657,
0.6175021529197693,
-0.06271877139806747,
-0.1446361541748047,
-0.24825306236743927,
-0.1983855813741684,
-0.13958153128623962,
0.08662676811218262,
1.0432076454162598,
0.430877149105072,
0.05940898880362511,
-0.30553337931632996,
-0.32684168219566345,
-0.06819980591535568,
0.6450937986373901,
-0.9887461066246033,
0.17773552238941193,
0.4547238051891327,
0.03182404860854149,
-0.7165286540985107,
-0.0209664236754179,
-0.9231851696968079,
-0.36495766043663025,
0.4037306010723114,
0.5464454293251038,
-0.09007778763771057,
-0.02934662066400051,
0.23796333372592926,
0.1683388203382492,
0.35569891333580017,
-0.03556467965245247,
-0.6355000138282776,
0.37879303097724915,
0.7277055382728577,
0.6444961428642273,
-0.09613467752933502,
0.06565392762422562,
-1.1207895278930664,
0.28019070625305176,
-0.46379566192626953,
0.6902031898498535,
-0.49852997064590454,
-0.5472750663757324,
-0.028877196833491325,
-0.10467547923326492,
0.10970178991556168,
-0.5486807227134705,
0.4340727925300598,
-1.2161738872528076,
-0.09997805953025818,
0.07485020160675049,
-0.2821364998817444,
0.0812152773141861,
0.2594129741191864,
-0.5933189392089844,
0.7977378368377686,
-0.014187479391694069,
-0.7496888041496277,
-0.1135973334312439,
-0.5549417734146118,
-0.4304829239845276,
-0.044401053339242935,
0.08100913465023041,
-0.5100892782211304,
0.24932432174682617,
0.06791521608829498,
0.21096140146255493,
-0.39467647671699524,
0.07937350124120712,
-0.41529810428619385,
-0.4710458815097809,
0.5316513180732727,
-0.036930281668901443,
0.5143244862556458,
0.23314931988716125,
-0.44190290570259094,
0.23685526847839355,
-0.6655164957046509,
0.09675224870443344,
0.6642855405807495,
-0.35071244835853577,
-0.47795164585113525,
0.3336566388607025,
-0.30250757932662964,
0.01159665361046791,
0.3156326413154602,
-0.6387905478477478,
0.17925402522087097,
-0.5157434940338135,
0.5508151054382324,
0.6374952793121338,
0.343478262424469,
0.11041311174631119,
0.07983138412237167,
0.8693547248840332,
-0.3174445629119873,
0.4557536840438843,
0.15582287311553955,
-0.23894834518432617,
-0.2615002691745758,
-0.12697885930538177,
0.15134942531585693,
0.6919547915458679,
-0.567088782787323,
0.2639985978603363,
0.12067309767007828,
-0.4159630537033081,
-0.5627180933952332,
0.2519267499446869,
0.5344566702842712,
0.3257383704185486,
0.19232849776744843,
-0.14103436470031738,
-0.38714566826820374,
-0.762888491153717,
-0.22242729365825653,
-0.21766720712184906,
0.09137821197509766,
0.3131709396839142,
0.23767010867595673,
-0.27969568967819214,
0.5830048322677612,
-0.7931864261627197,
-0.17414167523384094,
-0.11308024823665619,
-0.46590617299079895,
-0.017294513061642647,
0.2628612518310547,
0.796741783618927,
-0.5946770310401917,
-0.20097608864307404,
-0.10153185576200485,
-0.5425540208816528,
-0.24876753985881805,
0.0835791826248169,
-0.32749900221824646,
0.06123078614473343,
0.5435316562652588,
-0.5585170984268188,
0.2867039442062378,
0.6188639998435974,
-0.16913463175296783,
0.712336003780365,
0.07869074493646622,
-0.029658513143658638,
-1.0239677429199219,
-0.049429986625909805,
-0.11954684555530548,
-0.08578982204198837,
-0.631240725517273,
0.539995551109314,
0.1440216600894928,
-0.4246523678302765,
-0.6662485003471375,
0.6127240061759949,
-0.13107489049434662,
-0.0562383197247982,
-0.5466836094856262,
0.31776636838912964,
0.03202836215496063,
0.41882333159446716,
-0.35983243584632874,
1.0824531316757202,
0.2708432078361511,
-0.3998461365699768,
0.29401683807373047,
0.11061425507068634,
-0.04811723530292511,
0.22590585052967072,
-0.91275954246521,
0.6501398086547852,
-0.05609539896249771,
-0.05139165744185448,
-1.0204240083694458,
-0.04830671474337578,
0.46681371331214905,
-0.49035847187042236,
0.13253876566886902,
-0.15147905051708221,
-0.38791754841804504,
-0.285117506980896,
-0.7058067917823792,
0.3461507260799408,
0.45116284489631653,
-0.5678833723068237,
0.3431043326854706,
0.4726977050304413,
-0.007948808372020721,
-0.7584694027900696,
-0.3576250374317169,
0.3327360451221466,
-0.4692775011062622,
-0.47856107354164124,
0.07521477341651917,
-0.17591558396816254,
-0.3029650151729584,
-0.261974960565567,
-0.09331230819225311,
0.13057857751846313,
0.49199771881103516,
0.13996464014053345,
0.25980138778686523,
-0.07111885398626328,
-0.2722129821777344,
0.16869311034679413,
0.08359557390213013,
0.38287970423698425,
-0.16195227205753326,
0.8310022354125977,
-0.023522285744547844,
-0.3029908537864685,
-0.5763339996337891,
0.20859381556510925,
0.6040365099906921,
-0.4961794912815094,
0.7249627113342285,
0.1926242858171463,
-0.12973348796367645,
-0.2539753317832947,
-0.5569717288017273,
-0.32615798711776733,
-0.5211046934127808,
0.5578420758247375,
-0.3097929358482361,
-0.9612285494804382,
0.3697932958602905,
-0.04467165842652321,
0.02523428201675415,
0.05257796496152878,
0.410931795835495,
0.033739350736141205,
1.0249189138412476,
0.5386091470718384,
-0.32399997115135193,
0.4890194833278656,
-0.2631717920303345,
0.30080392956733704,
-0.9101712703704834,
-0.3575279712677002,
-0.691797137260437,
-0.054006606340408325,
-0.5095328688621521,
-0.36719462275505066,
0.2813167870044708,
0.28608083724975586,
-0.27290722727775574,
0.4297909438610077,
-0.3425406813621521,
0.47881805896759033,
0.420756071805954,
0.10918457806110382,
0.20111599564552307,
0.11651202291250229,
0.09408946335315704,
0.1443423330783844,
-0.5986841917037964,
-0.48025381565093994,
1.2201099395751953,
0.38825395703315735,
1.0439724922180176,
0.24805906414985657,
0.8439745306968689,
0.3230178952217102,
0.14981725811958313,
-0.7792956829071045,
0.6759858727455139,
0.039391014724969864,
-0.4420070946216583,
-0.1553136110305786,
-0.4322347342967987,
-1.1024787425994873,
0.2556764781475067,
-0.22253896296024323,
-0.8259931206703186,
0.03495798259973526,
-0.016247760504484177,
-0.25896671414375305,
0.39562544226646423,
-0.7476110458374023,
0.7270208597183228,
-0.6286861300468445,
-0.41379737854003906,
-0.3312448561191559,
-0.4656568467617035,
0.5576586723327637,
-0.46041056513786316,
0.3360846936702728,
-0.05790487676858902,
-0.14115101099014282,
0.6008799076080322,
-0.2684671878814697,
0.9079408049583435,
-0.2655984163284302,
-0.16728642582893372,
0.3120810091495514,
0.5419038534164429,
0.8213118314743042,
0.29328131675720215,
0.005053568631410599,
-0.18958713114261627,
0.022350195795297623,
-0.6085193157196045,
-0.7058796882629395,
0.5488020181655884,
-0.7915019392967224,
-0.9590511918067932,
-0.07219518721103668,
-0.21225006878376007,
-0.12460870295763016,
0.13154032826423645,
-0.18574781715869904,
0.20368261635303497,
-0.213009312748909,
0.043343618512153625,
0.4580956995487213,
-0.48282960057258606,
0.14022515714168549,
0.7622325420379639,
-0.3203626275062561,
-0.53627610206604,
0.9694555997848511,
-0.35759255290031433,
0.5029667019844055,
0.31508582830429077,
0.2594907879829407,
-0.2837751805782318,
-1.089132308959961,
-0.46373599767684937,
0.36691009998321533,
-0.3481328785419464,
-0.5389653444290161,
-0.3705902695655823,
-0.1552138477563858,
-0.09930383414030075,
0.07769444584846497,
-0.15169407427310944,
-0.14428000152111053,
-0.18645979464054108,
-0.10638091713190079,
0.34157389402389526,
0.7054946422576904,
0.3804352879524231,
0.5625328421592712,
-0.7199750542640686,
0.3043901026248932,
0.37247994542121887,
0.1491193026304245,
0.10970533639192581,
-0.4207339286804199,
-0.03933937847614288,
-0.08187014609575272,
-0.5015747547149658,
-1.0789885520935059,
0.48584258556365967,
-0.012157951481640339,
0.4139561355113983,
0.4808101952075958,
0.3678400218486786,
0.4227585196495056,
-0.4623607099056244,
0.5468546748161316,
0.12288019061088562,
-0.6618260145187378,
0.7236486077308655,
-0.21068182587623596,
-0.11104749143123627,
0.390087366104126,
0.3115586042404175,
-0.14412634074687958,
-0.6989961862564087,
-0.5348917841911316,
-0.8098225593566895,
0.42729315161705017,
0.028455441817641258,
0.5460599660873413,
-0.21089543402194977,
0.6455825567245483,
-0.23461756110191345,
0.4103372097015381,
-0.7204761505126953,
-0.13589298725128174,
-0.03706856817007065,
0.17745302617549896,
0.22352972626686096,
-0.5635100603103638,
-0.3080929219722748,
0.2047487199306488,
0.5384122729301453,
-0.07073185592889786,
0.08334793895483017,
-0.05649442970752716,
-0.15147913992404938,
-0.24203945696353912,
0.3433859944343567,
0.7231045365333557,
0.4515691101551056,
-0.30423420667648315,
-0.05865196883678436,
0.11331041157245636,
-0.5572733283042908,
0.3148188292980194,
-0.05752395838499069,
-0.27422305941581726,
-0.5198175311088562,
0.025353608652949333,
0.8372461795806885,
0.16875526309013367,
-0.9865096807479858,
0.5416631102561951,
-0.23038794100284576,
0.0196190495043993,
-0.04085497185587883,
0.23768143355846405,
0.05524640902876854,
0.47541436553001404,
0.6406554579734802,
-0.41182735562324524,
0.0234117042273283,
-0.5070213675498962,
0.06583904474973679,
0.8657349348068237,
-0.19577008485794067,
-0.2606315612792969,
0.8706277012825012,
0.07018005102872849,
-0.6084596514701843,
0.391049861907959,
-0.2796076834201813,
-0.6393681168556213,
0.6769933104515076,
0.8977730870246887,
0.7553125023841858,
-0.11451082676649094,
0.1630423665046692,
0.1911848783493042,
0.5442285537719727,
0.3273667097091675,
0.23028649389743805,
0.17867590487003326,
-0.6615924835205078,
-0.4604928493499756,
-0.7428632378578186,
-0.5880436301231384,
0.3159828186035156,
-0.6322425007820129,
0.08295019716024399,
-0.7799620628356934,
-0.2587030231952667,
-0.20038124918937683,
0.12413305044174194,
-0.1606215089559555,
-0.0346619077026844,
-0.12997789680957794,
0.7655574679374695,
-0.4667644500732422,
0.6636219620704651,
0.5650891661643982,
-0.24514469504356384,
-0.6817235946655273,
0.01981068029999733,
-0.15564420819282532,
-1.0982340574264526,
0.5738593339920044,
-0.10988106578588486,
-0.3789691925048828,
0.0019124383106827736,
-0.700318455696106,
-0.7523507475852966,
0.8642230033874512,
0.6068829894065857,
-0.7483835816383362,
0.11181825399398804,
0.11082939058542252,
0.4488801956176758,
-0.21015113592147827,
-0.19718311727046967,
0.591442346572876,
0.2242070734500885,
0.07389283180236816,
-0.4768320620059967,
0.30028292536735535,
-0.07908935099840164,
0.03998718783259392,
0.40148335695266724,
-0.8451066613197327,
0.17491963505744934,
-0.4822820723056793,
-0.09540822356939316,
0.04543904960155487,
0.6203873157501221,
0.6557717323303223,
0.19906394183635712,
0.3625241219997406,
0.47962695360183716,
0.5879319906234741,
0.20574361085891724,
1.2213318347930908,
-0.4534611701965332,
0.035656701773405075,
0.7098609805107117,
-0.37941810488700867,
1.2206891775131226,
0.6509565114974976,
-0.2414911687374115,
0.2400432825088501,
0.5198297500610352,
-0.035012707114219666,
0.5600711107254028,
0.6076106429100037,
-0.3198947012424469,
0.07463199645280838,
0.020873162895441055,
-0.20995986461639404,
0.30063021183013916,
0.30387043952941895,
0.032248251140117645,
0.05519692972302437,
0.08109383285045624,
0.2904297709465027,
0.07247604429721832,
-0.29149559140205383,
0.9446935057640076,
0.17516684532165527,
-0.3673795163631439,
0.9425662755966187,
0.22816821932792664,
0.6386317610740662,
-0.5647280216217041,
0.30412745475769043,
-0.34864288568496704,
-0.15438240766525269,
-0.15608885884284973,
-0.4558219313621521,
0.13425154983997345,
0.14929723739624023,
0.07257916778326035,
0.653666615486145,
0.8066220879554749,
-0.1716357320547104,
-0.2602575421333313,
0.6150026321411133,
0.2654232680797577,
0.07412160187959671,
-0.21816229820251465,
-0.6388756632804871,
0.3673401474952698,
-0.015442567877471447,
-0.2855015695095062,
0.7191716432571411,
0.13585080206394196,
-0.20687206089496613,
0.8108082413673401,
0.8539159893989563,
0.30491748452186584,
0.26655566692352295,
-0.06999281048774719,
1.0979602336883545,
-0.6448732614517212,
-0.36858007311820984,
-0.7799913287162781,
0.04151678830385208,
0.009835352189838886,
0.16422313451766968,
0.5101742148399353,
0.6011114716529846,
0.6616340279579163,
0.09645825624465942,
0.6029123663902283,
0.16991432011127472,
0.23180583119392395,
-0.6657426357269287,
0.6044169068336487,
-0.7131853699684143,
0.646794855594635,
-0.21461348235607147,
-0.8626659512519836,
-0.1374967396259308,
0.19097676873207092,
-0.434894323348999,
-0.10219784826040268,
0.5278351306915283,
1.0950214862823486,
0.16443781554698944,
-0.2613893151283264,
0.29845142364501953,
0.2116442322731018,
0.46050286293029785,
0.5603932738304138,
0.9803295135498047,
-0.3154539167881012,
0.9059702157974243,
-0.1329159438610077,
-0.17107181251049042,
-0.29823431372642517,
-0.7263876795768738,
-1.0056068897247314,
-0.08286234736442566,
-0.03678061440587044,
-0.5200167894363403,
0.5628760457038879,
0.6244524121284485,
0.4976288080215454,
-0.6970673203468323,
-0.31193381547927856,
0.30550864338874817,
0.14919255673885345,
0.14661380648612976,
-0.21490058302879333,
0.39014506340026855,
-0.4481331408023834,
-0.5035727620124817,
0.7630121111869812,
0.2733585238456726,
0.033302128314971924,
-0.2706618010997772,
-0.05624408647418022,
0.0024326692800968885,
0.2308211475610733,
0.658517062664032,
0.4335794448852539,
-0.5873164534568787,
-0.17906637489795685,
0.16346178948879242,
-0.13536280393600464,
0.10652735084295273,
0.6852149963378906,
-0.5424232482910156,
0.267211377620697,
0.21968290209770203,
0.9723029732704163,
0.5997734069824219,
0.3003619909286499,
0.5322197079658508,
-0.6479575634002686,
0.22953881323337555,
0.23713360726833344,
0.06928396224975586,
0.05223749205470085,
-0.5159388184547424,
0.2668757140636444,
-0.08541637659072876,
-0.4824696183204651,
-1.2672010660171509,
0.152609184384346,
-1.0582150220870972,
-0.48392489552497864,
1.1317436695098877,
0.030812647193670273,
-0.6137561798095703,
0.14024680852890015,
-0.4520095884799957,
-0.17003372311592102,
-0.5919196009635925,
1.0459942817687988,
0.1603502333164215,
0.1616399586200714,
-0.1263805329799652,
-0.7582148313522339,
0.4267478585243225,
0.33436331152915955,
-0.9739452004432678,
0.017546512186527252,
0.31151896715164185,
0.42709606885910034,
-0.08161284774541855,
0.4458998441696167,
-0.3773227334022522,
0.4308132529258728,
-0.40686365962028503,
-0.10344133526086807,
-0.22819384932518005,
-0.3326031267642975,
-0.3118354380130768,
0.5217503309249878,
0.46257930994033813,
-0.3511315584182739
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.02030v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.02030v2
|
Multimodal Reasoning with Multimodal Knowledge Graph
| 2024-06-04T07:13:23 | 2024-06-05T03:28:01 |
Junlin Lee, Yequan Wang, Jing Li, Min Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Multimodal reasoning with large language models (LLMs) often suffers from
hallucinations and the presence of deficient or outdated knowledge within LLMs.
Some approaches have sought to mitigate these issues by employing textual
knowledge graphs, but their singular modality of knowledge limits comprehensive
cross-modal understanding. In this paper, we propose the Multimodal Reasoning
with Multimodal Knowledge Graph (MR-MKG) method, which leverages multimodal
knowledge graphs (MMKGs) to learn rich and semantic knowledge across
modalities, significantly enhancing the multimodal reasoning capabilities of
LLMs. In particular, a relation graph attention network is utilized for
encoding MMKGs and a cross-modal alignment module is designed for optimizing
image-text alignment. A MMKG-grounded dataset is constructed to equip LLMs with
initial expertise in multimodal reasoning through pretraining. Remarkably,
MR-MKG achieves superior performance while training on only a small fraction of
parameters, approximately 2.25% of the LLM's parameter size. Experimental
results on multimodal question answering and multimodal analogy reasoning tasks
demonstrate that our MR-MKG method outperforms previous state-of-the-art
models.
|
[
-0.5364711880683899,
-1.0012125968933105,
0.8668938279151917,
-0.11850344389677048,
-0.4280323386192322,
0.02005394548177719,
-0.27142423391342163,
-0.1871037483215332,
0.13842815160751343,
0.30464211106300354,
-0.8262554407119751,
-0.6615622639656067,
-0.5076983571052551,
0.16262389719486237,
0.4970734417438507,
0.4125441908836365,
-0.07774362713098526,
0.25976330041885376,
-0.65586918592453,
-0.209960475564003,
-0.6102039217948914,
-0.1964031606912613,
-0.339169979095459,
-0.46769019961357117,
1.0067262649536133,
0.32307368516921997,
0.722517728805542,
0.4084448516368866,
0.31806236505508423,
0.27624326944351196,
0.311373770236969,
0.9321790933609009,
-0.22050343453884125,
0.1884065568447113,
-0.10784503072500229,
-0.2927250564098358,
-0.4424339830875397,
-0.12005569785833359,
0.3323562443256378,
0.5873250365257263,
0.23519845306873322,
-0.03146732226014137,
-0.2529307007789612,
0.4240633249282837,
-0.5788514614105225,
0.5351281762123108,
-0.46052035689353943,
0.14670246839523315,
0.11641189455986023,
-0.3989273011684418,
-0.7528538107872009,
-0.04365232214331627,
-0.16673536598682404,
-0.8845798969268799,
-0.4411613643169403,
0.28086793422698975,
0.6781954765319824,
0.4022336006164551,
-0.8371174335479736,
0.017677851021289825,
-0.3491339087486267,
0.7924856543540955,
-0.4319869875907898,
0.9947506189346313,
0.6133210062980652,
0.4239627420902252,
-0.002221155446022749,
-0.7594007253646851,
-0.7404699325561523,
-0.3694961667060852,
-0.3024360239505768,
0.20492035150527954,
-0.028806546702980995,
0.09997745603322983,
0.3324190378189087,
-0.12956003844738007,
-0.8247126936912537,
-0.30170169472694397,
0.007916117087006569,
-0.5266438722610474,
0.1660008430480957,
0.12702910602092743,
0.10852662473917007,
-0.6640101671218872,
-0.8042927980422974,
-0.08822377771139145,
-0.41770705580711365,
-0.1175350472331047,
0.08583283424377441,
0.08101963996887207,
0.0693296566605568,
0.6401772499084473,
-0.07520695775747299,
0.8865516781806946,
-0.16558079421520233,
-0.7439098358154297,
0.4019354581832886,
-0.5397617816925049,
-0.17012901604175568,
-0.3181832730770111,
0.7610645294189453,
0.7140957117080688,
0.3072689473628998,
-0.2756664752960205,
0.045604705810546875,
0.02986547164618969,
0.11935609579086304,
-0.49153512716293335,
-0.031162746250629425,
-0.20795656740665436,
-0.643901526927948,
0.0316159762442112,
-0.362440824508667,
-0.6717830896377563,
-0.11708124727010727,
-0.5792077779769897,
0.6908259987831116,
-0.9061831831932068,
-0.2497761845588684,
-0.011623185127973557,
-0.15024018287658691,
-0.1278018057346344,
0.5669098496437073,
-0.5061911344528198,
-0.3965693414211273,
0.13760648667812347,
0.48325979709625244,
0.2825085520744324,
-0.3344765901565552,
-0.2719554305076599,
0.6546248197555542,
-0.009207994677126408,
0.787658154964447,
-0.7437328696250916,
0.010043093003332615,
-0.34994155168533325,
0.10811025649309158,
-0.4480319023132324,
-0.20400860905647278,
0.2961043119430542,
-0.6091154217720032,
0.30767205357551575,
-0.28889867663383484,
-0.34518033266067505,
-0.631806492805481,
0.880236804485321,
-0.42441684007644653,
0.642336905002594,
0.055390384048223495,
-0.7004416584968567,
0.4047046899795532,
-0.37303626537323,
-0.448181688785553,
-0.2449730485677719,
-0.3869737684726715,
-0.15101809799671173,
-0.4168602526187897,
0.6482097506523132,
0.6020005345344543,
-0.2225669026374817,
0.14089621603488922,
-0.6565022468566895,
0.11764686554670334,
0.3275830149650574,
-0.47187328338623047,
0.4277755916118622,
0.37162110209465027,
0.09920093417167664,
0.23522837460041046,
-0.6974939107894897,
0.21468833088874817,
0.08959353715181351,
-0.3352699875831604,
-0.33425572514533997,
-0.21210813522338867,
-0.2968969941139221,
0.45806512236595154,
0.18297024071216583,
-0.1308356523513794,
0.0913524255156517,
0.24601876735687256,
0.4349464774131775,
0.7423214912414551,
-0.03625869005918503,
0.29505065083503723,
-0.3276202976703644,
0.5825754404067993,
0.2961176037788391,
0.23779290914535522,
-0.48202958703041077,
-0.408136785030365,
-0.6417196989059448,
-0.5484040975570679,
0.16269762814044952,
0.37722763419151306,
-1.4198445081710815,
0.1971409171819687,
-0.4174955487251282,
-0.10037972778081894,
-0.11889079213142395,
0.22576284408569336,
0.31458792090415955,
0.6782657504081726,
0.4496152997016907,
-0.11007958650588989,
-0.2999909818172455,
-0.8588376045227051,
0.05296538397669792,
-0.09454163163900375,
0.2601350247859955,
0.8265811204910278,
0.41356444358825684,
-0.6229561567306519,
0.7384345531463623,
-0.5026749968528748,
-0.360100120306015,
-0.2760492265224457,
0.22514835000038147,
-0.34639647603034973,
0.31487613916397095,
0.39725780487060547,
-0.7300002574920654,
-0.0800115242600441,
0.022356990724802017,
-0.9528927206993103,
0.13974353671073914,
-0.2145007997751236,
-0.266674280166626,
0.05253162235021591,
0.5802881717681885,
-0.7881659269332886,
-0.1240338683128357,
0.3627484440803528,
-0.3074989914894104,
0.4775049686431885,
-0.14355576038360596,
0.40057799220085144,
-1.1851459741592407,
-0.20984488725662231,
0.014032200910151005,
-0.4941062331199646,
-0.18480271100997925,
-0.06739145517349243,
0.1003403440117836,
-0.11739493906497955,
-0.1321357786655426,
0.5189303159713745,
-0.5323928594589233,
0.21318544447422028,
0.04800958186388016,
0.38460347056388855,
0.29910746216773987,
0.8503002524375916,
0.009972388856112957,
0.3571023941040039,
0.39496520161628723,
-0.27462610602378845,
0.6727278232574463,
0.18935950100421906,
-0.1200563833117485,
0.5710917711257935,
0.08666963130235672,
0.2372279167175293,
-0.26932013034820557,
0.3000446856021881,
-1.2210229635238647,
-0.24467334151268005,
0.31842803955078125,
-0.5254294276237488,
0.4535213112831116,
-0.2317352443933487,
-0.5915935635566711,
-0.3168526589870453,
-0.040532469749450684,
0.5883733034133911,
0.09286773204803467,
-0.38926056027412415,
1.1987090110778809,
0.03381310775876045,
0.07812992483377457,
-0.7212298512458801,
-0.45871004462242126,
0.015395278111100197,
-0.14875605702400208,
-0.9998065233230591,
-0.07976090908050537,
0.07341191917657852,
-0.014262516051530838,
0.11294253170490265,
-0.06911300867795944,
-0.06350065022706985,
-0.331777423620224,
0.11743972450494766,
0.19109965860843658,
-0.37760114669799805,
0.5597804188728333,
0.10922146588563919,
-0.3251550495624542,
-0.01867593079805374,
-0.24552316963672638,
0.5542449355125427,
0.020340651273727417,
-0.5437520146369934,
-0.17629648745059967,
0.142760768532753,
0.8127073645591736,
-0.3108680546283722,
0.5849546790122986,
1.0156786441802979,
-0.1660129427909851,
0.001886003534309566,
-0.6978262662887573,
-0.397405743598938,
-0.38519227504730225,
0.42503196001052856,
-0.6442861557006836,
-0.8692350387573242,
0.303727388381958,
-0.34828057885169983,
-0.5592921376228333,
-0.014871528372168541,
0.5170477032661438,
-0.13314765691757202,
1.1743147373199463,
0.28288406133651733,
0.2649143636226654,
0.2550634741783142,
-0.13443762063980103,
0.1797252744436264,
-0.7102939486503601,
-0.6970269083976746,
0.11782114207744598,
-0.37147411704063416,
-0.010372554883360863,
-0.8711056709289551,
0.5651497840881348,
0.1376742571592331,
0.019211865961551666,
-0.0009550568065606058,
-0.193538099527359,
0.42933282256126404,
0.42624136805534363,
0.5806026458740234,
0.45946088433265686,
0.0031287362799048424,
-0.6434393525123596,
-0.14312951266765594,
-0.8223047852516174,
-0.2796047627925873,
0.9842436909675598,
0.20071135461330414,
0.9294818639755249,
-0.03217299282550812,
0.16532236337661743,
0.028523577377200127,
0.105697400867939,
-0.7001616358757019,
0.7533881068229675,
0.27027174830436707,
-0.5737040042877197,
-0.2499215453863144,
-0.7305895090103149,
-0.553051233291626,
0.5941870212554932,
-0.3837188184261322,
-0.3310866057872772,
-0.06834554672241211,
0.12887617945671082,
-0.12475551664829254,
0.2571413516998291,
-0.9295584559440613,
1.1283512115478516,
-0.35636651515960693,
-0.2002759426832199,
-0.4690569043159485,
-0.8462153077125549,
0.4917738735675812,
0.2784726917743683,
0.41841062903404236,
-0.18263162672519684,
0.08919844031333923,
0.4301891624927521,
-0.18797653913497925,
0.7371512055397034,
-0.16416527330875397,
0.11551553755998611,
0.21391408145427704,
0.12370403856039047,
0.33827847242355347,
0.10097227990627289,
0.44099006056785583,
-0.05829709395766258,
-0.19730563461780548,
-0.19547580182552338,
-0.933884859085083,
0.579796314239502,
-0.7067176103591919,
-0.457764595746994,
0.009762807749211788,
-1.1811555624008179,
-0.47345057129859924,
0.3052402436733246,
-0.09675665199756622,
0.6435415148735046,
0.2737143933773041,
0.3212723433971405,
0.7081161141395569,
-0.15586872398853302,
0.185777485370636,
0.1193384900689125,
-0.4453454315662384,
-0.8179594278335571,
0.8369608521461487,
0.07700441032648087,
0.4765053689479828,
0.5867410898208618,
0.15862248837947845,
-0.5224394798278809,
-0.1470041573047638,
-0.5363976955413818,
0.43310147523880005,
-1.1030256748199463,
-0.30807510018348694,
-0.9476882815361023,
0.0881705954670906,
-0.4290814995765686,
-0.011051975190639496,
-0.04474625736474991,
-0.46489012241363525,
0.01849883794784546,
-0.03400539606809616,
0.2584853768348694,
0.06165483221411705,
0.025360947474837303,
0.02587476372718811,
-0.702272355556488,
0.6317614912986755,
0.828397810459137,
0.204776793718338,
0.034794051200151443,
-0.2768092453479767,
-0.09215601533651352,
0.0035670066718012094,
-0.3845803141593933,
-0.7661046385765076,
0.003926787059754133,
-0.06679433584213257,
0.5802090764045715,
0.7349681854248047,
-0.13340367376804352,
0.836505651473999,
-0.361484169960022,
0.381882905960083,
0.5389612317085266,
-0.6749419569969177,
0.33011767268180847,
-0.5141807198524475,
0.32188111543655396,
0.2348816990852356,
0.5407554507255554,
-0.3975302278995514,
-0.14369061589241028,
-0.23911826312541962,
-0.4925520122051239,
0.5477970242500305,
0.035984497517347336,
-0.14201222360134125,
0.01446017436683178,
0.13849852979183197,
0.04372873529791832,
0.26918497681617737,
-1.0558373928070068,
-0.21163149178028107,
-0.5061582922935486,
-0.26062828302383423,
0.019367309287190437,
-0.1701042205095291,
-0.3260021209716797,
-0.5096026659011841,
0.3875177502632141,
-0.5123016238212585,
0.3208540081977844,
-0.0023734569549560547,
-0.46049249172210693,
-0.002109820256009698,
0.27177608013153076,
0.8035131692886353,
0.8540951609611511,
-0.07585442811250687,
0.7309596538543701,
0.21173986792564392,
-0.12424644082784653,
0.19734841585159302,
0.05680221691727638,
0.406876802444458,
-0.2368251085281372,
0.5061435699462891,
0.832489013671875,
0.15800313651561737,
-0.7382543683052063,
0.5246790647506714,
-0.027256429195404053,
-0.2669951617717743,
0.06388548761606216,
-0.15959762036800385,
0.4393482804298401,
0.6916595101356506,
0.05250246822834015,
0.0923551395535469,
-0.30133292078971863,
-0.47684842348098755,
0.1569303721189499,
0.6039664149284363,
-0.3296244740486145,
0.013627856969833374,
0.6296323537826538,
-0.07134620100259781,
0.10468423366546631,
0.43531885743141174,
-0.08150932192802429,
-0.40487217903137207,
0.22980864346027374,
0.530809760093689,
0.374820739030838,
-0.02793196216225624,
0.18800322711467743,
0.140086829662323,
0.4912966191768646,
0.34699466824531555,
0.12888383865356445,
-0.4205605089664459,
-0.9519534111022949,
-0.6805035471916199,
-0.33187517523765564,
-0.15469536185264587,
0.11301534622907639,
-0.10467041283845901,
0.10919519513845444,
-0.39787906408309937,
-0.27623844146728516,
-0.044339749962091446,
-0.515251874923706,
-0.410038024187088,
0.3460089862346649,
0.3253200650215149,
0.5473200678825378,
-0.6651716232299805,
0.640895664691925,
0.781217634677887,
-0.6102876663208008,
-0.7795981764793396,
-0.33453699946403503,
-0.13065138459205627,
-1.0497361421585083,
0.9399700164794922,
0.1840580403804779,
-0.3221014440059662,
-0.07001464068889618,
-0.35661017894744873,
-0.5708248615264893,
1.3052834272384644,
0.5279385447502136,
-0.18416891992092133,
-0.09337248653173447,
0.2610345780849457,
0.052429407835006714,
-0.4292483329772949,
0.42827820777893066,
0.05964154750108719,
0.7893341779708862,
0.3322046101093292,
-0.7415284514427185,
0.1160309761762619,
-0.08593770116567612,
-0.12414247542619705,
0.21670599281787872,
-0.6623520851135254,
0.6784244179725647,
-0.19525061547756195,
0.1598288118839264,
-0.5432531833648682,
0.5268880724906921,
0.23474650084972382,
0.38149264454841614,
0.7619030475616455,
1.0077154636383057,
0.5290781855583191,
-0.1883377730846405,
0.7288609743118286,
-0.18170376121997833,
0.17670148611068726,
0.787337601184845,
-0.13809248805046082,
0.24283625185489655,
0.6074855327606201,
0.17178110778331757,
0.6327845454216003,
0.4211099445819855,
0.15676885843276978,
0.47028714418411255,
-0.3442373275756836,
-0.20720870792865753,
-1.0372401475906372,
-0.05036970600485802,
-0.2919514775276184,
0.3664097487926483,
0.12807032465934753,
-0.44058701395988464,
-0.5113776922225952,
0.5102616548538208,
0.03878414258360863,
-0.13348492980003357,
-0.12921245396137238,
0.7323336005210876,
0.11196602135896683,
-0.43099069595336914,
0.568973183631897,
-0.10478881001472473,
0.31168991327285767,
-0.6829131841659546,
-0.11282572895288467,
0.08577082306146622,
0.2049718052148819,
-0.12896829843521118,
-0.6091408729553223,
-0.04492921754717827,
-0.5597679018974304,
-0.3600820004940033,
-0.343748539686203,
0.8682486414909363,
-0.587641179561615,
-0.3380206525325775,
0.40821853280067444,
0.7891618013381958,
-0.1337883025407791,
-0.02384341135621071,
-0.6152039170265198,
-0.14055241644382477,
-0.04086478799581528,
-0.2587805986404419,
0.3585343360900879,
0.7234464287757874,
0.03482493758201599,
0.9722262620925903,
0.6352297067642212,
-0.3153359591960907,
0.13365936279296875,
0.2137690931558609,
1.0352513790130615,
-0.5158931016921997,
-0.3152397871017456,
-0.8328894376754761,
0.4743351638317108,
0.056458909064531326,
-0.012382247485220432,
0.7602933645248413,
0.46131786704063416,
0.7026210427284241,
-0.12491296231746674,
0.5105976462364197,
-0.02396484836935997,
0.2738702595233917,
-0.8136436343193054,
0.5957014560699463,
-0.8122549653053284,
-0.17316600680351257,
-0.279840350151062,
-0.7675161361694336,
-0.32261890172958374,
0.8098623156547546,
-0.42611125111579895,
0.30454421043395996,
1.0756562948226929,
0.8979412317276001,
-0.30204036831855774,
-0.057868361473083496,
0.5658354163169861,
0.08737244457006454,
0.12828056514263153,
0.7379336357116699,
1.0610488653182983,
-0.14001628756523132,
0.7879296541213989,
-0.2606123089790344,
-0.09055183827877045,
-0.09322783350944519,
-0.7772774696350098,
-1.1656608581542969,
-0.5956225395202637,
-0.13197803497314453,
-0.3328847885131836,
-0.11828223615884781,
0.9876601696014404,
0.8384450078010559,
-0.13096019625663757,
0.16453172266483307,
0.44683271646499634,
0.4142448604106903,
-0.16109757125377655,
-0.22974570095539093,
0.213531956076622,
-0.455701619386673,
-0.2762306034564972,
0.4203144907951355,
0.4367559254169464,
-0.10679865628480911,
-0.32888561487197876,
-0.19474676251411438,
-0.5185763835906982,
-0.04204073175787926,
0.8498786687850952,
-0.36062079668045044,
-0.7503948211669922,
-0.4362233281135559,
0.04140222817659378,
-0.04263179004192352,
0.22487211227416992,
0.89057856798172,
-0.7246163487434387,
0.6774036288261414,
0.5017096996307373,
0.44202888011932373,
0.5569955706596375,
0.018368426710367203,
0.21035118401050568,
-0.7378727793693542,
0.3158930540084839,
0.1395835131406784,
0.5740163922309875,
0.18482469022274017,
-0.09549176692962646,
0.13075800240039825,
0.5961657166481018,
-0.4390842318534851,
-0.5778382420539856,
0.4869888722896576,
-1.182039737701416,
-0.5222789645195007,
1.190954327583313,
-0.08363518863916397,
-0.11374763399362564,
-0.0975385382771492,
-0.36829471588134766,
0.3894886076450348,
-0.17466586828231812,
0.5861824154853821,
0.8046967387199402,
-0.3401346206665039,
-0.7826290130615234,
-0.3084515929222107,
0.08150993287563324,
0.354753702878952,
-0.91077721118927,
-0.17523305118083954,
0.9181860685348511,
0.2347283661365509,
0.3478602170944214,
0.44329071044921875,
-0.07847815752029419,
0.2347586452960968,
0.09032158553600311,
0.03386011719703674,
-0.7337340712547302,
-0.5939841270446777,
0.23834091424942017,
0.44910672307014465,
-0.1640680432319641,
-0.05815291777253151
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.02018v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.02018v1
|
Why Would You Suggest That? Human Trust in Language Model Responses
| 2024-06-04T06:57:47 | 2024-06-04T06:57:47 |
Manasi Sharma, Ho Chit Siu, Rohan Paleja, Jaime D. Peña
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC
|
The emergence of Large Language Models (LLMs) has revealed a growing need for
human-AI collaboration, especially in creative decision-making scenarios where
trust and reliance are paramount. Through human studies and model evaluations
on the open-ended News Headline Generation task from the LaMP benchmark, we
analyze how the framing and presence of explanations affect user trust and
model performance. Overall, we provide evidence that adding an explanation in
the model response to justify its reasoning significantly increases
self-reported user trust in the model when the user has the opportunity to
compare various responses. Position and faithfulness of these explanations are
also important factors. However, these gains disappear when users are shown
responses independently, suggesting that humans trust all model responses,
including deceptive ones, equitably when they are shown in isolation. Our
findings urge future research to delve deeper into the nuanced evaluation of
trust in human-machine teaming systems.
|
[
-0.4768950343132019,
-0.48179951310157776,
0.8892375826835632,
0.2268679141998291,
0.10641618818044662,
-0.036371808499097824,
-0.07293739914894104,
-0.9099544286727905,
-0.3613833785057068,
0.3966341018676758,
-0.318562775850296,
-0.11006881296634674,
-0.5282341837882996,
0.28942665457725525,
-0.682564377784729,
0.629500687122345,
0.02614409662783146,
0.14668186008930206,
-0.427919864654541,
0.19186487793922424,
-0.37169593572616577,
-0.4593782424926758,
-0.775671660900116,
-0.6935274004936218,
0.6565045714378357,
0.3124532401561737,
1.096866250038147,
0.6173851490020752,
0.510303795337677,
0.36785635352134705,
0.1373942792415619,
0.08776286989450455,
-0.23083636164665222,
0.09385888278484344,
-0.3157593607902527,
-0.6468801498413086,
-0.5284676551818848,
0.5198744535446167,
0.3436163365840912,
0.585513710975647,
-0.08440662175416946,
0.22583049535751343,
0.17082880437374115,
0.5364398956298828,
-0.30374690890312195,
-0.04425077885389328,
-0.5412390232086182,
-0.18236251175403595,
0.001824721577577293,
-0.1842098981142044,
-0.5683956146240234,
-0.1424340158700943,
0.39936909079551697,
-0.4411252737045288,
0.27495458722114563,
0.5632136464118958,
0.9152039289474487,
0.1273655742406845,
-0.46384626626968384,
-0.11535878479480743,
-0.6878651976585388,
0.5983182787895203,
-0.7232992053031921,
0.10614777356386185,
0.5115768313407898,
0.13921178877353668,
-0.12946438789367676,
-0.4760749042034149,
-0.7318405508995056,
-0.4721447825431824,
-0.2617477774620056,
0.24998846650123596,
-0.16051779687404633,
0.18853014707565308,
0.1550174504518509,
0.26935917139053345,
-0.572185754776001,
0.34847182035446167,
-0.21250788867473602,
-0.27767413854599,
0.7635955214500427,
0.09782373160123825,
0.4174877107143402,
-0.039888642728328705,
-0.6124103665351868,
-0.08882703632116318,
-0.6824734807014465,
0.05799390748143196,
0.4993467926979065,
0.01937001757323742,
-0.17880019545555115,
0.6725056767463684,
-0.01348291989415884,
0.647745668888092,
0.0016524045495316386,
0.11126489192247391,
-0.06914187222719193,
-0.38104358315467834,
-0.27955135703086853,
0.08805195987224579,
0.8749756217002869,
0.734158456325531,
0.5196049809455872,
-0.2948606312274933,
-0.05470969155430794,
0.6221228241920471,
0.4264005422592163,
-0.6776365637779236,
0.061792559921741486,
0.2405175119638443,
-0.670923113822937,
-0.5326501727104187,
0.32084527611732483,
-0.6081192493438721,
-0.5318593978881836,
-0.25465127825737,
0.26773974299430847,
-0.17170597612857819,
-0.47798141837120056,
0.1974724680185318,
-0.23767800629138947,
0.11087208241224289,
0.3847348093986511,
-0.7137250304222107,
0.2935209572315216,
0.6053757667541504,
0.4309655427932739,
-0.3981803059577942,
-0.5503417253494263,
-0.38210222125053406,
0.09823910892009735,
-0.5961140394210815,
0.6200793981552124,
-0.3884599804878235,
-0.4326998293399811,
-0.05649252235889435,
-0.19504651427268982,
0.03818884491920471,
-0.5271312594413757,
0.4668184220790863,
-0.590998649597168,
0.6169440150260925,
-0.4009162485599518,
-0.5738291144371033,
-0.10633763670921326,
0.036310404539108276,
-0.501272439956665,
0.8252948522567749,
-0.08626904338598251,
-0.8901958465576172,
0.45917263627052307,
-0.7697543501853943,
-0.3034866750240326,
0.051197946071624756,
-0.20347358286380768,
-0.17640414834022522,
0.29416412115097046,
0.3082410395145416,
0.38576045632362366,
-0.40439483523368835,
0.3257145881652832,
-0.5572746992111206,
-0.24638906121253967,
0.8893948793411255,
-0.5884293913841248,
0.8370962142944336,
0.3834720849990845,
-0.4393610656261444,
0.17853303253650665,
-0.2951888144016266,
0.0010773425456136465,
0.0396755076944828,
-0.2287774533033371,
-0.28831174969673157,
-0.07835880666971207,
-0.012169459834694862,
0.1739118993282318,
0.21859683096408844,
-0.46494999527931213,
-0.3148270845413208,
-0.3670342266559601,
0.30300968885421753,
0.9738671779632568,
0.015307662077248096,
0.48789283633232117,
-0.6110799908638,
0.6835931539535522,
0.13548971712589264,
-0.019258098676800728,
-0.26210689544677734,
-0.7135133743286133,
-0.4213738441467285,
0.015896830707788467,
0.0796564444899559,
0.1652528941631317,
-0.36395812034606934,
0.131850004196167,
-0.02813812717795372,
-0.09184867888689041,
-0.7032911777496338,
0.19208644330501556,
0.5879185795783997,
0.7384206056594849,
0.017703941091895103,
-0.2772655189037323,
-0.5722808241844177,
-1.213728666305542,
-0.5947752594947815,
-0.3687033951282501,
-0.20053254067897797,
0.39460769295692444,
0.3246546685695648,
-0.04652044549584389,
1.394587516784668,
-0.18208327889442444,
0.06675418466329575,
-0.2739725410938263,
0.29638585448265076,
-0.17689020931720734,
0.19767434895038605,
0.5794131755828857,
-1.0532556772232056,
-0.4007374942302704,
-0.22052989900112152,
-0.9524896740913391,
-0.20157867670059204,
-0.07616686820983887,
-0.054979272186756134,
0.48202821612358093,
0.40688323974609375,
-0.8983250856399536,
0.4023151695728302,
0.7679256200790405,
-0.569128155708313,
0.4912361800670624,
-0.17470121383666992,
0.3214360177516937,
-1.2492724657058716,
0.10646629333496094,
0.06929631531238556,
-0.394149512052536,
-0.33483466506004333,
0.1050984263420105,
-0.22383448481559753,
-0.10720548778772354,
-0.27576944231987,
0.5305848121643066,
-0.6192712783813477,
-0.3988960385322571,
-0.3173160254955292,
0.6868106722831726,
0.11237458139657974,
0.06286432594060898,
-0.12051060050725937,
0.9703776240348816,
0.6695846319198608,
-0.46805983781814575,
0.1648123413324356,
0.25274527072906494,
-0.4416426718235016,
0.43819212913513184,
-0.8720299601554871,
0.13347886502742767,
-0.08906059712171555,
0.215504989027977,
-1.2796663045883179,
-0.39239874482154846,
0.15754809975624084,
-0.9652964472770691,
0.014430155977606773,
0.23826193809509277,
-0.5944573879241943,
-0.48071733117103577,
-0.1198895275592804,
0.011174315586686134,
0.43818312883377075,
-0.5078867077827454,
0.49085062742233276,
0.38856056332588196,
0.16104991734027863,
-0.3590930104255676,
-0.8906325697898865,
0.33266568183898926,
-0.2787936329841614,
-0.811758279800415,
0.3617672324180603,
-0.22877903282642365,
-0.8730202913284302,
0.263747900724411,
-0.23724482953548431,
-0.14731241762638092,
0.4555160403251648,
0.4437269866466522,
0.4494798481464386,
-0.21756546199321747,
0.11344657093286514,
-0.45182350277900696,
-0.22016499936580658,
0.42035460472106934,
0.14269907772541046,
0.239179790019989,
-0.31732410192489624,
-0.31358030438423157,
-0.7218453288078308,
0.2612171471118927,
0.7299103140830994,
-0.2318386435508728,
0.7682285308837891,
0.5592999458312988,
-0.0853433907032013,
-0.06469759345054626,
-0.6384705901145935,
-0.4390332102775574,
-0.5264912843704224,
0.23002445697784424,
-0.13081075251102448,
-1.1061882972717285,
0.2623363733291626,
0.1572110652923584,
-0.16171574592590332,
0.4452967643737793,
0.8008858561515808,
-0.32638785243034363,
1.2232372760772705,
0.5988831520080566,
-0.349972665309906,
0.1295265406370163,
0.3840119242668152,
0.19270600378513336,
-0.5791876316070557,
-0.06182868033647537,
-0.5179398059844971,
-0.26974761486053467,
-0.5272464752197266,
-0.1678704023361206,
0.12239126861095428,
-0.08542031049728394,
0.06643582135438919,
0.09903783351182938,
-0.4732527434825897,
0.4143925607204437,
0.4753897786140442,
0.1225971132516861,
0.544557511806488,
-0.261341392993927,
0.1871672421693802,
0.088657908141613,
-0.4993670582771301,
-0.5733969807624817,
0.9440863728523254,
0.3392316699028015,
0.8545131683349609,
0.042073771357536316,
0.6849043369293213,
0.4516252875328064,
0.40821775794029236,
-0.46753963828086853,
0.5873091816902161,
0.42792561650276184,
-0.9869572520256042,
-0.39577507972717285,
-0.3440178632736206,
-1.0030814409255981,
0.2865602970123291,
-0.06477504968643188,
-0.8884831666946411,
-0.356114000082016,
0.06616155058145523,
-0.49085891246795654,
-0.026548707857728004,
-0.920597493648529,
0.5632051229476929,
-0.25988247990608215,
-0.2257775217294693,
-0.5228233933448792,
-0.6786617636680603,
0.5827447772026062,
0.0968681201338768,
0.35123947262763977,
-0.156235933303833,
-0.11174505203962326,
0.8820600509643555,
-0.22455979883670807,
0.953831672668457,
0.06928043812513351,
-0.1379406899213791,
0.34720489382743835,
0.19939890503883362,
0.22999787330627441,
0.23640118539333344,
-0.12546755373477936,
-0.053020231425762177,
-0.4033289849758148,
-0.12252844870090485,
-0.5722079873085022,
0.6927043199539185,
-0.7612041234970093,
-1.0774222612380981,
-0.36907944083213806,
-0.8413135409355164,
-0.32793375849723816,
0.1228368952870369,
0.14389440417289734,
0.18046405911445618,
-0.06591631472110748,
0.5439576506614685,
0.7153193950653076,
-0.10026560723781586,
0.6088830232620239,
0.4389001727104187,
-0.5357317924499512,
-0.029601003974676132,
0.10194294899702072,
-0.30116552114486694,
0.39750921726226807,
0.11132968217134476,
0.2925978899002075,
-0.10160946846008301,
-0.4232163429260254,
-0.2636049687862396,
0.08280618488788605,
-0.26558560132980347,
-0.030309507623314857,
-0.25465619564056396,
0.03662407025694847,
-0.20704196393489838,
-0.17651629447937012,
-0.3351055979728699,
-0.24766935408115387,
-0.2617557644844055,
-0.37625086307525635,
0.3190585672855377,
0.858989417552948,
0.14689123630523682,
0.2976541817188263,
-0.59758460521698,
0.46004778146743774,
0.31287676095962524,
0.35150453448295593,
0.17912831902503967,
-0.39936476945877075,
-0.28476956486701965,
0.20738989114761353,
-0.2629583477973938,
-0.8694347143173218,
0.13717737793922424,
-0.17292125523090363,
0.8646085262298584,
0.3448246717453003,
0.05939352512359619,
0.40487614274024963,
-0.1982114315032959,
0.7989235520362854,
0.22080013155937195,
-0.95406574010849,
0.3092990815639496,
-0.5807919502258301,
0.12170476466417313,
0.18397337198257446,
0.45812320709228516,
-0.2134174406528473,
-0.47544074058532715,
-0.6489269137382507,
-0.4045293927192688,
0.7780670523643494,
0.33294254541397095,
0.08376207202672958,
0.13134358823299408,
0.28132376074790955,
-0.05316285416483879,
0.15617352724075317,
-0.7813207507133484,
-0.3234255313873291,
0.21697978675365448,
0.16311606764793396,
-0.12522868812084198,
-0.4886370599269867,
-0.42583227157592773,
0.07356279343366623,
0.3100928068161011,
-0.10176830738782883,
0.3481801748275757,
0.39785972237586975,
-0.0394478477537632,
-0.5991990566253662,
0.3049909174442291,
0.6117002964019775,
1.0016037225723267,
0.006336035672575235,
0.14504893124103546,
0.018173890188336372,
0.0816429853439331,
-0.16812266409397125,
-0.08516652882099152,
0.12417303025722504,
-0.1327136605978012,
0.474353164434433,
0.45595481991767883,
0.30365630984306335,
-0.6211053729057312,
0.6122006177902222,
-0.046676646918058395,
-0.29876279830932617,
-0.16178329288959503,
0.08720200508832932,
0.5966529846191406,
0.34378287196159363,
0.4815197288990021,
0.31244832277297974,
-0.06415045261383057,
-0.7656893730163574,
0.37666916847229004,
0.5265558362007141,
-0.1437559276819229,
-0.4020692706108093,
0.9502913951873779,
0.08992336690425873,
-0.38723382353782654,
0.47280120849609375,
0.19044558703899384,
-0.6639032959938049,
0.4864327907562256,
0.5284575819969177,
0.8812311887741089,
-0.15677683055400848,
0.3669320046901703,
-0.02726822718977928,
0.4294480085372925,
-0.18005217611789703,
0.10632100701332092,
0.07996891438961029,
-0.9444920420646667,
-0.37990421056747437,
-0.3145289123058319,
-0.5915943384170532,
-0.097209133207798,
-0.7493996024131775,
-0.12551258504390717,
-0.2769389748573303,
-0.33429139852523804,
-0.03625193610787392,
-0.11771051585674286,
-0.5547195076942444,
0.21233786642551422,
0.3819042444229126,
0.8864758610725403,
-0.7071706056594849,
0.9117273688316345,
0.3418505787849426,
-0.5455894470214844,
-0.8249188661575317,
0.2510620355606079,
0.04382796585559845,
-0.9972641468048096,
0.6980706453323364,
0.20871984958648682,
-0.32938656210899353,
-0.25418949127197266,
-0.6727534532546997,
-0.7386214137077332,
1.1336970329284668,
0.5061407089233398,
-0.31630831956863403,
-0.2496296912431717,
0.027294838801026344,
0.6690242886543274,
-0.6586524844169617,
0.24608305096626282,
0.23660658299922943,
0.5376341342926025,
-0.03344079479575157,
-1.1703128814697266,
0.26143115758895874,
0.027520451694726944,
0.27512824535369873,
-0.2606053650379181,
-0.6781790852546692,
0.9108495712280273,
-0.41454917192459106,
-0.18166327476501465,
0.11650515347719193,
0.6835008263587952,
0.1357000768184662,
0.3161104917526245,
0.45628488063812256,
0.4808901250362396,
0.6561607718467712,
0.17897428572177887,
1.326374888420105,
-0.3504922688007355,
0.17540399730205536,
1.2167032957077026,
-0.3064105808734894,
0.8547613620758057,
0.5196752548217773,
-0.23536017537117004,
0.7198988795280457,
0.5048405528068542,
-0.06355347484350204,
0.26675471663475037,
-0.025886699557304382,
0.1003732904791832,
-0.4488125443458557,
-0.1822618991136551,
-0.42318305373191833,
0.5803290605545044,
0.06576616317033768,
-0.7059184908866882,
-0.2032794952392578,
-0.2212769240140915,
0.15106700360774994,
0.2490358203649521,
-0.05030856654047966,
0.4871446490287781,
0.2989790439605713,
-1.0568464994430542,
0.3761059641838074,
-0.08649888634681702,
0.5315211415290833,
-0.4813304841518402,
0.2776847183704376,
-0.008892538957297802,
0.1930059939622879,
-0.36055421829223633,
-0.8613799810409546,
0.20760445296764374,
-0.13926292955875397,
-0.2794833183288574,
-0.5196381211280823,
0.6877827644348145,
-0.26300427317619324,
-0.06230133771896362,
0.43474411964416504,
0.735342800617218,
-0.12137410044670105,
-0.16088135540485382,
-0.6537541747093201,
0.2190232127904892,
-0.03589596226811409,
-0.5767834782600403,
0.5558313131332397,
0.21546199917793274,
0.07445639371871948,
0.8969626426696777,
0.7315031886100769,
-0.18037326633930206,
-0.17104248702526093,
-0.11902589350938797,
0.6691962480545044,
-0.3283011019229889,
-0.23763848841190338,
-1.1323086023330688,
0.4690203368663788,
-0.23012675344944,
-0.1320430189371109,
1.20896577835083,
0.5395950078964233,
0.6324757933616638,
0.021093621850013733,
0.8696653842926025,
0.10312491655349731,
0.5959181785583496,
-0.32447490096092224,
0.9070723056793213,
-0.4814954698085785,
0.30509626865386963,
-0.339876264333725,
-0.7546833753585815,
-0.0906439796090126,
0.3641921579837799,
-0.22391431033611298,
0.2656526267528534,
0.82985520362854,
0.825013279914856,
0.30977848172187805,
0.21558985114097595,
0.48558899760246277,
0.49746811389923096,
0.2229119837284088,
0.19770614802837372,
0.8836414813995361,
-0.11668702214956284,
0.5889037847518921,
0.011067653074860573,
-0.2962036728858948,
-0.18457892537117004,
-1.0257147550582886,
-1.0207149982452393,
-0.5925371050834656,
-0.23393398523330688,
-0.4220082759857178,
0.01753852888941765,
0.7764276266098022,
0.6411046385765076,
-0.5874274373054504,
-0.5068120956420898,
-0.16545875370502472,
0.1663995385169983,
-0.07422439754009247,
-0.2838388681411743,
0.031477924436330795,
-0.36207515001296997,
-0.6242923736572266,
0.4074144959449768,
0.21529936790466309,
-0.03247319906949997,
-0.5088186264038086,
-0.2640126645565033,
-0.11036370694637299,
0.0972241461277008,
0.41593363881111145,
0.030794860795140266,
-1.1077803373336792,
-0.38900429010391235,
0.1669810563325882,
-0.2110109180212021,
0.009702572599053383,
0.7868925333023071,
-0.9194652438163757,
0.3588455617427826,
0.25891509652137756,
0.5804511308670044,
0.29743093252182007,
0.1750456541776657,
1.101921796798706,
-0.31229692697525024,
-0.07359074801206589,
-0.03652274236083031,
0.38553380966186523,
0.3737378418445587,
-0.46295249462127686,
0.5841442942619324,
0.1698695421218872,
-0.6953811645507812,
-0.9353230595588684,
0.11930259317159653,
-0.9412707686424255,
-0.19626428186893463,
1.1151834726333618,
-0.17366929352283478,
-0.2754823863506317,
-0.025426000356674194,
-0.186339870095253,
0.013471168465912342,
-0.5774972438812256,
0.9726457595825195,
0.9374672770500183,
-0.3149757981300354,
-0.3056294322013855,
-0.531731367111206,
0.511995792388916,
0.3359653651714325,
-0.7257680296897888,
0.2524555027484894,
0.3609794080257416,
0.18820878863334656,
0.15392844378948212,
0.5617470145225525,
0.02189699001610279,
0.3705747127532959,
0.1582527905702591,
-0.2617221772670746,
-0.20875774323940277,
-0.2434156835079193,
0.003746751928701997,
0.20975209772586823,
0.3274988532066345,
-0.1567951887845993
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.02009v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.02009v2
|
Phonetic Enhanced Language Modeling for Text-to-Speech Synthesis
| 2024-06-04T06:43:34 | 2024-06-12T01:33:56 |
Kun Zhou, Shengkui Zhao, Yukun Ma, Chong Zhang, Hao Wang, Dianwen Ng, Chongjia Ni, Nguyen Trung Hieu, Jia Qi Yip, Bin Ma
|
eess.AS
|
eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.SD
|
Recent language model-based text-to-speech (TTS) frameworks demonstrate
scalability and in-context learning capabilities. However, they suffer from
robustness issues due to the accumulation of errors in speech unit predictions
during autoregressive language modeling. In this paper, we propose a phonetic
enhanced language modeling method to improve the performance of TTS models. We
leverage self-supervised representations that are phonetically rich as the
training target for the autoregressive language model. Subsequently, a
non-autoregressive model is employed to predict discrete acoustic codecs that
contain fine-grained acoustic details. The TTS model focuses solely on
linguistic modeling during autoregressive training, thereby reducing the error
propagation that occurs in non-autoregressive training. Both objective and
subjective evaluations validate the effectiveness of our proposed method.
|
[
-0.1795143187046051,
-0.6076759099960327,
0.2110879123210907,
0.2535036504268646,
-0.2540417015552521,
0.2310422658920288,
-0.3712087571620941,
-0.3374718427658081,
0.40834325551986694,
0.4826638996601105,
-0.27510496973991394,
-0.5566089153289795,
-0.4078262746334076,
0.25524142384529114,
-0.3960164785385132,
0.4962886869907379,
0.16719284653663635,
0.12533026933670044,
0.23140589892864227,
0.05939335748553276,
-0.46516740322113037,
-0.8410323858261108,
-0.4878026843070984,
0.05263927951455116,
0.0973455160856247,
0.07381913810968399,
0.5000137686729431,
0.902217447757721,
0.05073707550764084,
0.31825748085975647,
-0.19690150022506714,
0.034324679523706436,
-0.0791921317577362,
0.34816673398017883,
0.1442771553993225,
-0.20051158964633942,
-0.8334033489227295,
-0.14085204899311066,
0.7848436236381531,
0.7222354412078857,
-0.3379518985748291,
-0.11707828938961029,
0.38345542550086975,
0.17811797559261322,
-0.33559292554855347,
0.2863469421863556,
-0.7271985411643982,
0.06807669252157211,
-0.058502692729234695,
-0.3889327347278595,
-0.49231985211372375,
-0.2225703001022339,
0.12540580332279205,
-0.559812068939209,
0.16579082608222961,
-0.24305498600006104,
0.15925414860248566,
0.37252306938171387,
-0.21509374678134918,
-0.1973332315683365,
-0.820117175579071,
0.7931644916534424,
-0.9872584939002991,
1.0268019437789917,
0.40967002511024475,
0.14654631912708282,
-0.2162521779537201,
-0.6544903516769409,
-0.39153921604156494,
-0.41547438502311707,
0.1447925716638565,
0.24501435458660126,
0.12909193336963654,
0.29095253348350525,
-0.08456521481275558,
0.27613765001296997,
-0.5555801391601562,
0.21571403741836548,
-0.06823135912418365,
-0.53964763879776,
0.4857262074947357,
-0.16061973571777344,
0.32725825905799866,
-0.21253104507923126,
-0.2880464792251587,
-0.3010168671607971,
-0.3303776681423187,
-0.09565720707178116,
0.4339807629585266,
0.9993047714233398,
-0.23136600852012634,
0.6044346690177917,
-0.05683577060699463,
0.46368029713630676,
0.3029719591140747,
-0.33345866203308105,
0.33924007415771484,
-0.18335719406604767,
-0.27157244086265564,
0.40636929869651794,
0.7109347581863403,
-0.050069376826286316,
0.06090392917394638,
-0.3228404223918915,
-0.35124069452285767,
-0.05257862061262131,
0.02249896340072155,
-0.7066470384597778,
-0.3520030677318573,
0.14876176416873932,
-0.38102656602859497,
-0.2941542863845825,
-0.3581405580043793,
-0.7607905864715576,
0.20830583572387695,
-0.42820024490356445,
0.3816129267215729,
-0.5939057469367981,
-0.5616752505302429,
-0.10288503766059875,
-0.02444881945848465,
-0.35250145196914673,
0.13973884284496307,
-1.1023207902908325,
0.2835550308227539,
0.24111562967300415,
0.665230929851532,
0.001668273122049868,
-0.3269408047199249,
-0.7023048996925354,
0.4835050106048584,
-0.5896018743515015,
0.6258731484413147,
-0.5666665434837341,
-0.736520528793335,
0.024176180362701416,
-0.17077580094337463,
-0.18918204307556152,
-0.7086939811706543,
0.4218943417072296,
-0.11970970779657364,
0.06565545499324799,
0.10224821418523788,
-0.6891509890556335,
0.1170346811413765,
-0.18499301373958588,
-0.5328201651573181,
1.271756887435913,
0.24120187759399414,
-0.39763355255126953,
0.24042584002017975,
-0.39180099964141846,
-0.6136670112609863,
0.00562804751098156,
-0.0950932428240776,
-0.25485876202583313,
0.17191991209983826,
0.47811219096183777,
0.37692469358444214,
-0.04001486673951149,
0.5362110137939453,
-0.2943115532398224,
-0.12828834354877472,
0.057539984583854675,
-0.663730263710022,
0.5870786905288696,
0.27112165093421936,
-0.42943134903907776,
0.09480100870132446,
-0.9380935430526733,
0.20090195536613464,
-0.1671358346939087,
-0.3581125736236572,
-0.36136674880981445,
-0.4906132221221924,
0.21328386664390564,
0.024260131642222404,
0.30174750089645386,
-0.3147091567516327,
0.10593116283416748,
-0.6343656778335571,
0.30554091930389404,
0.6668953895568848,
-0.0805036723613739,
0.796246349811554,
-0.14795653522014618,
0.5116695761680603,
-0.21768634021282196,
-0.0229195449501276,
-0.22314661741256714,
-0.4366055130958557,
-0.5194501280784607,
-0.6639452576637268,
0.6177318096160889,
0.4565332531929016,
-0.5781823992729187,
0.6841618418693542,
-0.054358337074518204,
-0.30847933888435364,
-0.4184333086013794,
-0.10412147641181946,
0.367927223443985,
0.48822110891342163,
0.5381332635879517,
-0.43205904960632324,
-0.7069311738014221,
-0.432067334651947,
-0.31483155488967896,
-0.680590033531189,
-0.27399742603302,
0.2253568172454834,
-0.07836052775382996,
-0.2981622517108917,
0.8918963074684143,
0.1559838503599167,
-0.5431855916976929,
-0.11242850124835968,
0.33520758152008057,
-0.2866705656051636,
0.6628668308258057,
0.5546912550926208,
-0.16277818381786346,
-0.3242175281047821,
-0.09269440174102783,
-0.5130792856216431,
-0.4076574146747589,
-0.02713608928024769,
0.1783009022474289,
0.46193617582321167,
0.6518230438232422,
-0.3670773506164551,
0.3357013463973999,
0.47131597995758057,
0.007844855077564716,
0.5269615650177002,
-0.3175980746746063,
0.2031707912683487,
-1.0264935493469238,
-0.0729951336979866,
0.09446338564157486,
-0.14557452499866486,
-0.637683093547821,
-0.10187489539384842,
0.030392998829483986,
-0.22793307900428772,
-0.2572501301765442,
0.4796987473964691,
-0.5052859783172607,
-0.42406129837036133,
-0.24241997301578522,
-0.03312021866440773,
0.035140443593263626,
0.3696543574333191,
0.38409489393234253,
0.9199542999267578,
0.7591288685798645,
-0.6015883088111877,
0.113361656665802,
0.09750451892614365,
0.02658252790570259,
0.15356433391571045,
-0.5379145741462708,
0.1222735121846199,
0.15062297880649567,
0.20161865651607513,
-0.908483624458313,
-0.265788197517395,
-0.05712848901748657,
-0.6546605229377747,
0.6810138821601868,
-0.4299823045730591,
-0.6536075472831726,
-0.032997049391269684,
0.05825675651431084,
0.46124544739723206,
0.5498973727226257,
-0.7501358985900879,
0.9066968560218811,
0.5789861679077148,
-0.45021378993988037,
-0.10405515134334564,
-0.7770957350730896,
0.1684023141860962,
-0.33666718006134033,
-0.39482036232948303,
0.5174757838249207,
-0.07650694251060486,
0.10415202379226685,
-0.31791990995407104,
0.07063773274421692,
-0.3465108871459961,
-0.18313321471214294,
-0.13599197566509247,
0.10542020946741104,
-0.2675725221633911,
0.2242196798324585,
0.2927490174770355,
-0.054468706250190735,
0.09256359934806824,
-0.5174833536148071,
0.48564112186431885,
0.1532932072877884,
-0.08138757199048996,
-0.7471413016319275,
0.43011727929115295,
0.652820885181427,
-0.3703902065753937,
0.2299194186925888,
0.4319356083869934,
-0.3610922694206238,
-0.33566299080848694,
-0.5111283659934998,
-0.41042235493659973,
-0.5279569029808044,
0.4795200824737549,
-0.4374910593032837,
-0.513931930065155,
0.5918189287185669,
-0.19987240433692932,
-0.19742843508720398,
0.31499409675598145,
0.39613258838653564,
-0.03437335789203644,
0.9419803023338318,
0.46995383501052856,
-0.14834082126617432,
0.5495281219482422,
-0.16213113069534302,
0.027428606525063515,
-0.746618390083313,
-0.22981983423233032,
-0.3863587975502014,
0.4293854832649231,
-0.6095806956291199,
-0.5701757669448853,
0.36368921399116516,
-0.030884452164173126,
-0.03866427019238472,
0.5523603558540344,
-0.6596483588218689,
-0.11410339921712875,
0.5688387155532837,
-0.10341820120811462,
0.19883812963962555,
0.5158237814903259,
-0.5857822895050049,
-0.22926439344882965,
-0.9100896716117859,
-0.30626434087753296,
1.001954197883606,
0.6322429180145264,
0.8018422722816467,
-0.0064215934835374355,
0.8895219564437866,
0.1316022127866745,
-0.16081808507442474,
-0.6722243428230286,
0.47817718982696533,
-0.28962746262550354,
-0.2839161455631256,
-0.47903740406036377,
-0.5322191119194031,
-0.4925163984298706,
0.011843515560030937,
-0.06964889168739319,
-0.44508129358291626,
0.2808248698711395,
0.25079023838043213,
-0.43322962522506714,
0.29137617349624634,
-0.6154916286468506,
0.4660336673259735,
-0.19211336970329285,
-0.14964984357357025,
-0.11780093610286713,
-0.36442655324935913,
-0.15161065757274628,
-0.12092200666666031,
0.3298660218715668,
0.2642308473587036,
0.23428651690483093,
0.7554261684417725,
-0.5175728797912598,
0.9872834086418152,
-0.24915313720703125,
-0.43713515996932983,
0.3898715376853943,
0.2642301023006439,
0.5695307850837708,
-0.03505396470427513,
-0.23099951446056366,
0.2117728441953659,
-0.16061575710773468,
-0.022409094497561455,
-0.49960970878601074,
0.6744831800460815,
-0.7083606719970703,
-0.3059084713459015,
-0.0821736752986908,
-0.4131251573562622,
-0.4171755015850067,
-0.014860067516565323,
0.34785181283950806,
0.9478127956390381,
-0.12536640465259552,
-0.23471525311470032,
0.48617318272590637,
-0.24840527772903442,
0.572948157787323,
0.4213428199291229,
-0.1658754199743271,
-0.752114474773407,
0.7809016704559326,
0.3260699510574341,
0.33297836780548096,
0.15924181044101715,
0.3298724889755249,
-0.8149028420448303,
-0.8672136664390564,
-0.604880690574646,
0.10750051587820053,
-0.64690762758255,
-0.0610194206237793,
-0.7745578289031982,
-0.28459617495536804,
-1.0457236766815186,
0.1488715559244156,
-0.8089826703071594,
-0.6614333987236023,
-0.6660085320472717,
0.04400401934981346,
0.5067194104194641,
0.6705821752548218,
-0.3637562096118927,
0.3991202116012573,
-0.788994550704956,
0.39672601222991943,
0.3341798782348633,
0.5367790460586548,
0.018223820254206657,
-1.200043797492981,
-0.2913675904273987,
0.11087655276060104,
0.032678183168172836,
-0.7646710872650146,
0.8291184902191162,
0.3334159255027771,
0.4841965138912201,
-0.01597408391535282,
0.15526027977466583,
0.928708016872406,
-0.6697213649749756,
0.6650726199150085,
0.10698890686035156,
-0.9224202036857605,
0.7802739143371582,
-0.5489171743392944,
0.31088167428970337,
0.19822958111763,
-0.12185195088386536,
-0.02298717014491558,
-0.8610034584999084,
-0.5658081769943237,
-0.8899147510528564,
0.21941763162612915,
0.4090237319469452,
0.008444366045296192,
-0.21260422468185425,
0.3676067292690277,
0.07111431658267975,
-0.07716762274503708,
-0.5913785696029663,
-0.25805526971817017,
-0.5657274723052979,
-0.2850155234336853,
0.13982905447483063,
-0.3512553870677948,
0.4683886468410492,
-0.22933755815029144,
1.0318751335144043,
-0.12855112552642822,
0.3129974901676178,
0.331398606300354,
0.10847871005535126,
-0.21746838092803955,
0.25405940413475037,
0.3685065507888794,
0.0689222663640976,
-0.21429714560508728,
-0.12481658160686493,
0.11561355739831924,
-0.4677385687828064,
0.08370409160852432,
0.3795982301235199,
0.08190938830375671,
0.34589213132858276,
0.2384706437587738,
0.6743974089622498,
0.11603444069623947,
-0.31039589643478394,
0.2569606900215149,
-0.07360625267028809,
-0.06089526787400246,
-0.4739818274974823,
-0.16129356622695923,
-0.17600786685943604,
0.20038768649101257,
0.5239311456680298,
0.16394339501857758,
0.38001900911331177,
-0.5124682188034058,
0.413190633058548,
0.3271922171115875,
-0.32109788060188293,
-0.37402886152267456,
0.918998658657074,
0.37928321957588196,
-0.3329739570617676,
0.2620019316673279,
0.0076577248983085155,
-0.43461138010025024,
0.4719700813293457,
0.7140002846717834,
1.018006443977356,
-0.9183622002601624,
-0.07113238424062729,
0.5412976741790771,
0.17568546533584595,
-0.18602557480335236,
0.20255348086357117,
-0.12033364176750183,
-0.30956387519836426,
-0.41296082735061646,
-0.5951265096664429,
-0.3076117932796478,
0.1965056210756302,
-0.5992118120193481,
0.3213891386985779,
-0.3151383697986603,
-0.5001938939094543,
-0.1810094267129898,
-0.4011755585670471,
-0.20833490788936615,
0.7022457122802734,
0.16059885919094086,
0.4532444477081299,
-0.6229637861251831,
1.1880075931549072,
0.3123002052307129,
-0.0800233855843544,
-1.0858538150787354,
0.24918130040168762,
-0.2616507112979889,
-0.5403711199760437,
0.6408935189247131,
-0.06931562721729279,
-0.3575284779071808,
0.16051128506660461,
0.10916534066200256,
-1.0104007720947266,
0.6094955801963806,
0.7280887961387634,
-0.7024052143096924,
-0.12394615262746811,
0.461970716714859,
0.641618549823761,
-0.4840437173843384,
0.2238791286945343,
0.3395306169986725,
0.07553320378065109,
0.11505494266748428,
-1.4809982776641846,
-0.262173593044281,
-0.1281130164861679,
0.20536145567893982,
-0.2365996539592743,
-0.3514105975627899,
0.5775062441825867,
-0.0927017405629158,
-0.35445019602775574,
0.3492763638496399,
0.8387992978096008,
0.24859671294689178,
-0.021554725244641304,
0.49188923835754395,
0.43084749579429626,
0.736667811870575,
0.15633396804332733,
0.7400919198989868,
-0.5344021916389465,
0.15573807060718536,
1.402427315711975,
-0.17774976789951324,
0.9020984768867493,
0.3569808900356293,
-0.1063133254647255,
0.2566192150115967,
0.6006017327308655,
0.20324504375457764,
0.7941511273384094,
-0.08342400938272476,
-0.29109498858451843,
-0.141261026263237,
-0.10606210678815842,
-0.6097754240036011,
0.6119444370269775,
0.34733664989471436,
-0.6045781970024109,
0.06069294363260269,
0.28429850935935974,
-0.521697461605072,
0.2301001101732254,
-0.2632920742034912,
0.9179108738899231,
-0.08599396795034409,
-0.5322773456573486,
0.9567978978157043,
-0.07492286711931229,
0.6521083116531372,
-0.2174876630306244,
-0.0328812338411808,
-0.06401996314525604,
-0.06595662981271744,
0.016471920534968376,
-0.4254525899887085,
0.2838762104511261,
-0.08932420611381531,
-0.160873144865036,
-0.324188768863678,
0.6100719571113586,
-0.8483215570449829,
-0.5933453440666199,
0.597081184387207,
0.3152942657470703,
0.1358002871274948,
-0.038925107568502426,
-0.4315117597579956,
0.12007378041744232,
-0.004213431384414434,
0.1762566864490509,
0.13979455828666687,
0.6329214572906494,
0.1462298184633255,
0.5769131183624268,
0.5833269357681274,
0.1742488592863083,
0.31903719902038574,
0.5380070209503174,
0.649056613445282,
-0.44686731696128845,
-0.9201543927192688,
-0.5606219172477722,
0.2533448338508606,
0.26566100120544434,
0.07257411628961563,
0.6998416185379028,
0.6978902816772461,
0.608999490737915,
-0.10055149346590042,
0.980839192867279,
0.44053417444229126,
0.8362669348716736,
-0.7094601988792419,
0.6797361969947815,
-0.39912375807762146,
0.5309262275695801,
-0.44124719500541687,
-0.8752247095108032,
-0.09864000976085663,
0.6873658299446106,
0.10051457583904266,
0.1962185651063919,
0.3423975110054016,
0.8226022720336914,
-0.005582137499004602,
0.19194771349430084,
0.5447120666503906,
0.3128300607204437,
0.09913551807403564,
-0.062074676156044006,
0.6750243306159973,
-0.5661890506744385,
0.429495245218277,
-0.4167564809322357,
-0.16396041214466095,
-0.10025087743997574,
-0.6275291442871094,
-0.9094732403755188,
-0.6007221341133118,
-0.6142393946647644,
-0.3401245176792145,
0.17381666600704193,
0.9363856911659241,
0.7968366146087646,
-0.713470995426178,
-0.38995781540870667,
-0.3351660966873169,
-0.4088808298110962,
0.048618659377098083,
-0.23782943189144135,
0.3892366588115692,
-0.49086159467697144,
-0.8329204320907593,
0.8684213757514954,
0.13917496800422668,
0.7986599802970886,
-0.20496103167533875,
0.02733132801949978,
0.3615102767944336,
0.1565694808959961,
0.5592420101165771,
0.14179418981075287,
-0.8353232741355896,
-0.04500547796487808,
0.07087204605340958,
0.13078272342681885,
0.23601584136486053,
0.5499062538146973,
-0.9582117795944214,
0.7217913866043091,
0.11841779947280884,
0.3170754015445709,
0.28997084498405457,
-0.24777008593082428,
0.8291018605232239,
-0.8741949796676636,
0.37645095586776733,
0.297865629196167,
0.4132283627986908,
0.6211655735969543,
-0.4731593430042267,
0.0938425362110138,
0.0723581314086914,
-0.3512999713420868,
-0.8418049812316895,
-0.015278425067663193,
-0.8423417210578918,
-0.14569535851478577,
1.213689923286438,
-0.05131040886044502,
-0.072591632604599,
-0.10219155251979828,
-0.03523927554488182,
0.6209131479263306,
-0.7202247977256775,
0.7536466717720032,
0.14615565538406372,
0.1219496876001358,
-0.12772709131240845,
-0.3142684996128082,
0.6167953610420227,
0.5223429203033447,
-0.5034696459770203,
0.3762877285480499,
0.41525542736053467,
0.21778987348079681,
0.03188555687665939,
0.549961507320404,
-0.2577293813228607,
0.19062387943267822,
0.0246510561555624,
0.032430391758680344,
0.09161338955163956,
-0.5383116006851196,
-0.3977394998073578,
0.024872181937098503,
0.11558099091053009,
-0.12739042937755585
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.02004v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.02004v2
|
Efficiently Train ASR Models that Memorize Less and Perform Better with Per-core Clipping
| 2024-06-04T06:34:33 | 2024-06-05T21:44:10 |
Lun Wang, Om Thakkar, Zhong Meng, Nicole Rafidi, Rohit Prabhavalkar, Arun Narayanan
|
cs.CR
|
cs.CR, cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
Gradient clipping plays a vital role in training large-scale automatic speech
recognition (ASR) models. It is typically applied to minibatch gradients to
prevent gradient explosion, and to the individual sample gradients to mitigate
unintended memorization. This work systematically investigates the impact of a
specific granularity of gradient clipping, namely per-core clip-ping (PCC),
across training a wide range of ASR models. We empirically demonstrate that PCC
can effectively mitigate unintended memorization in ASR models. Surprisingly,
we find that PCC positively influences ASR performance metrics, leading to
improved convergence rates and reduced word error rates. To avoid tuning the
additional hyperparameter introduced by PCC, we further propose a novel
variant, adaptive per-core clipping (APCC), for streamlined optimization. Our
findings highlight the multifaceted benefits of PCC as a strategy for robust,
privacy-forward ASR model training.
|
[
-0.35643547773361206,
-0.4216488301753998,
-0.04629633575677872,
0.15036284923553467,
-0.1865328997373581,
0.06657405197620392,
-0.19518879055976868,
-0.1531347632408142,
-0.060467954725027084,
0.3521881699562073,
-0.49119484424591064,
-0.38368692994117737,
-0.26888829469680786,
-0.16997209191322327,
-0.43883076310157776,
0.7888574004173279,
0.3468596339225769,
0.11704651266336441,
-0.036282118409872055,
-0.14067131280899048,
-0.27146637439727783,
-0.9675378203392029,
-0.7210034132003784,
-0.4844650626182556,
0.013478942215442657,
0.41938820481300354,
0.3667128086090088,
1.0499716997146606,
0.5845596790313721,
0.2225254774093628,
-0.5434659719467163,
0.024364566430449486,
-0.378172367811203,
-0.23357965052127838,
0.11831249296665192,
-0.4262847900390625,
-0.6180281043052673,
0.03053213655948639,
0.8749475479125977,
0.5407528877258301,
-0.5733897089958191,
0.1622413843870163,
0.1338099092245102,
0.5567817091941833,
-0.9890504479408264,
-0.0026176529936492443,
-0.907992959022522,
0.2736772894859314,
-0.1878708153963089,
-0.219297394156456,
-0.16304954886436462,
0.10452082753181458,
0.15228921175003052,
-0.264588326215744,
0.5501483082771301,
-0.39777761697769165,
0.6251049041748047,
0.3155519366264343,
0.32081207633018494,
-0.12755875289440155,
-0.7715604305267334,
0.6130226254463196,
-0.47400856018066406,
0.4546894431114197,
0.543222963809967,
0.35285285115242004,
0.25167718529701233,
-0.6324785947799683,
-0.3140186369419098,
-0.13349516689777374,
0.5511903166770935,
0.15116211771965027,
-0.20457066595554352,
0.30499136447906494,
0.4608366787433624,
0.5184343457221985,
-0.028009042143821716,
0.08160951733589172,
-0.32938244938850403,
-0.4275815784931183,
0.3078143894672394,
0.3244207501411438,
0.09890531003475189,
0.0675169825553894,
-0.4759488105773926,
-0.228221133351326,
-0.6589730978012085,
0.6402661204338074,
0.37794414162635803,
0.43632665276527405,
0.15991511940956116,
0.13786284625530243,
0.004762147553265095,
0.40807583928108215,
0.4348229467868805,
-0.1463083177804947,
0.10801566392183304,
-0.27559131383895874,
0.0015927634667605162,
0.27382367849349976,
0.5531550645828247,
0.054262567311525345,
0.183080792427063,
-0.08329310268163681,
-0.15816231071949005,
0.06874456256628036,
0.2101341038942337,
-0.7019999027252197,
-0.634911060333252,
-0.17706957459449768,
-0.48140621185302734,
-0.01557400543242693,
0.2645517885684967,
-0.5544711947441101,
-0.054785892367362976,
-0.3608018159866333,
0.11755546927452087,
-0.3673907518386841,
0.18951454758644104,
0.26427292823791504,
-0.23133155703544617,
0.09262391179800034,
0.3342911899089813,
-0.8571741580963135,
0.8923774361610413,
0.8083475828170776,
1.1358522176742554,
-0.15995606780052185,
-0.5730969905853271,
-0.896573543548584,
0.35068994760513306,
-0.03696895390748978,
0.9058171510696411,
-0.5981730222702026,
-0.9935814142227173,
-0.20776914060115814,
-0.13019879162311554,
-0.2589675784111023,
-0.9598643779754639,
0.6475391983985901,
-0.07297226786613464,
-0.5048988461494446,
-0.6439781188964844,
-0.3383672833442688,
-0.13407963514328003,
-0.008059738203883171,
-0.5161688923835754,
0.721076488494873,
-0.5014308094978333,
-0.7886150479316711,
0.11991178244352341,
-0.41283854842185974,
-0.5409311056137085,
-0.12299063801765442,
-0.2501116096973419,
-0.509903609752655,
0.13373629748821259,
0.4128762185573578,
0.22019338607788086,
-0.12723928689956665,
-0.4470195472240448,
-0.13924138247966766,
-0.44259214401245117,
0.20798441767692566,
-0.286660760641098,
0.7466989159584045,
-0.06321866065263748,
-0.32147523760795593,
0.09564666450023651,
-0.6109206080436707,
0.0655321478843689,
-0.4211295545101166,
-0.6884032487869263,
-0.051969174295663834,
0.1008504256606102,
-0.11646182835102081,
0.12185625731945038,
-0.165993794798851,
-0.563431978225708,
-0.16541266441345215,
-0.017984844744205475,
0.7255591750144958,
0.7319979071617126,
0.1379038393497467,
0.36940252780914307,
-0.6603168249130249,
0.5948849320411682,
-0.08885661512613297,
0.22529540956020355,
-0.1723475158214569,
-0.22992511093616486,
-0.5898823738098145,
-0.8616771697998047,
0.25354743003845215,
0.6323960423469543,
-0.2586805820465088,
0.49826255440711975,
-0.01840871386229992,
-0.47919464111328125,
-0.40389883518218994,
0.05860156565904617,
0.6965200901031494,
0.8323344588279724,
0.49002403020858765,
-0.8071891069412231,
-0.5594437122344971,
-0.5033663511276245,
-0.4854963421821594,
-0.04497499018907547,
-0.3185230791568756,
0.8095209002494812,
0.22743605077266693,
-0.09431316703557968,
0.9424517154693604,
-0.4570949375629425,
-0.662723183631897,
-0.12630216777324677,
0.08250942826271057,
-0.1448344588279724,
0.5765243172645569,
0.24904827773571014,
-0.5006449222564697,
-0.6409270167350769,
-0.25950559973716736,
0.17119677364826202,
-0.09112442284822464,
-0.14276841282844543,
0.06328372657299042,
-0.3678250014781952,
0.6836653351783752,
-0.42143917083740234,
0.5515744090080261,
0.12572449445724487,
0.29208675026893616,
0.8346213698387146,
-0.17874760925769806,
-0.05211126431822777,
-0.2562503516674042,
0.3035626709461212,
-0.08396000415086746,
-0.30577540397644043,
-0.7455377578735352,
-0.31983625888824463,
0.014055940322577953,
-0.2505537271499634,
-0.4551095962524414,
0.06169899180531502,
-0.40587878227233887,
-0.02854090742766857,
-0.18712638318538666,
-0.15871313214302063,
-0.11269378662109375,
0.21263733506202698,
0.1595015674829483,
1.113590955734253,
0.5332330465316772,
-0.8710877299308777,
-0.1418958455324173,
0.6322607398033142,
-0.2050226628780365,
0.26939472556114197,
-0.7686710357666016,
0.45636436343193054,
-0.044671013951301575,
0.5131697058677673,
-0.5064824223518372,
0.17255237698554993,
-0.2345450222492218,
-0.5644515752792358,
0.35939812660217285,
-0.38984158635139465,
-0.3479730486869812,
-0.20352306962013245,
-0.6555996537208557,
0.4493885934352875,
0.6654093265533447,
-0.7515349388122559,
0.5630742311477661,
0.651007890701294,
0.08852127939462662,
-0.5934885740280151,
-0.8995000123977661,
-0.20888154208660126,
-0.2645244598388672,
-0.18448898196220398,
0.3911413848400116,
-0.028142224997282028,
0.14508652687072754,
-0.5003524422645569,
-0.42794445157051086,
-0.27027207612991333,
0.06582751870155334,
0.4553764760494232,
-0.15456202626228333,
-0.08239401131868362,
-0.23250019550323486,
-0.27296751737594604,
-0.10294388979673386,
-0.06638596951961517,
-0.21202361583709717,
0.6900090575218201,
-0.27509355545043945,
-0.311286985874176,
-0.8173717856407166,
0.33471179008483887,
0.4107557237148285,
-0.5038547515869141,
0.4354000985622406,
0.37629932165145874,
-0.19103090465068817,
-0.23297347128391266,
-0.6183628439903259,
-0.26005733013153076,
-0.4967899024486542,
0.37546128034591675,
-0.3464553952217102,
-0.6419264078140259,
0.879741370677948,
-0.04800969734787941,
-0.1925194263458252,
0.07113509625196457,
0.5069659948348999,
-0.12116564810276031,
0.6670138835906982,
0.696578860282898,
-0.38925933837890625,
0.9048817157745361,
-0.30881527066230774,
-0.10558134317398071,
-1.3776626586914062,
-0.07164092361927032,
-0.7035842537879944,
-0.03731878846883774,
-0.11277054250240326,
-0.830078125,
0.5267575979232788,
0.10300517082214355,
-0.3034285306930542,
0.16412578523159027,
-0.5182514786720276,
0.7044009566307068,
0.5230537056922913,
0.25368136167526245,
0.3531120717525482,
0.3065997362136841,
0.004347610753029585,
0.009483475238084793,
-0.8502921462059021,
-0.24396991729736328,
0.9658467173576355,
0.5438829064369202,
0.9071440696716309,
-0.2662973403930664,
0.29573187232017517,
0.08418899029493332,
-0.2748701572418213,
-0.6500634551048279,
0.46668732166290283,
-0.7101492285728455,
-0.5129979252815247,
-0.09661427140235901,
-0.515987753868103,
-0.40840214490890503,
0.20005513727664948,
0.049611110240221024,
-0.7803585529327393,
0.4459700882434845,
0.826036274433136,
-0.695729672908783,
0.5891352295875549,
-0.26666250824928284,
0.3442137539386749,
0.04960049316287041,
0.007688550744205713,
-0.18564021587371826,
-0.7493062615394592,
-0.11338852345943451,
0.293639600276947,
-0.27513280510902405,
-0.10575475543737411,
-0.08059124648571014,
0.7711255550384521,
-0.4656151235103607,
0.6870253682136536,
-0.3026673495769501,
0.6009871363639832,
0.6364495754241943,
0.010750280693173409,
0.40841853618621826,
-0.22307103872299194,
0.0736832544207573,
0.3726379871368408,
-0.131026953458786,
-0.2521378993988037,
-0.18245282769203186,
0.2923597991466522,
-0.7612506747245789,
-0.38855254650115967,
-0.09135023504495621,
-0.4787970781326294,
-0.273453027009964,
-0.21202510595321655,
0.6820927858352661,
0.6050314903259277,
-0.17639228701591492,
0.19611887633800507,
0.8909034729003906,
0.09663543850183487,
0.35020875930786133,
0.40284210443496704,
0.5136121511459351,
-0.47701266407966614,
0.9667547345161438,
0.2581978440284729,
0.46530064940452576,
0.3484312891960144,
0.2725208103656769,
-0.0015290871961042285,
-0.7736460566520691,
-0.06585729122161865,
0.25262513756752014,
-0.6030430793762207,
-0.17529235780239105,
-0.9483718276023865,
-0.34234312176704407,
-0.2952539324760437,
-0.31732913851737976,
-0.7426262497901917,
-0.5175697207450867,
-0.6894899606704712,
0.10315003246068954,
0.10760259628295898,
0.15731431543827057,
-0.280977338552475,
0.7169716358184814,
-0.6463937759399414,
-0.015228865668177605,
0.49379557371139526,
0.26065704226493835,
0.25303709506988525,
-0.7711855173110962,
0.0439317561686039,
-0.16640764474868774,
-0.3324515223503113,
-0.3920966684818268,
0.2684360444545746,
0.8514251708984375,
0.3977644741535187,
0.5819851160049438,
-0.03400598093867302,
1.0365517139434814,
-1.0098856687545776,
0.6738543510437012,
0.25452136993408203,
-1.2454218864440918,
0.2257954627275467,
-0.3979191482067108,
0.6381909847259521,
1.0464223623275757,
0.09760887175798416,
-0.6564680337905884,
0.03804447129368782,
-0.3763938248157501,
-0.8747301697731018,
0.6668446063995361,
-0.10691412538290024,
0.048158444464206696,
0.11929468810558319,
0.3730821907520294,
-0.06784278154373169,
0.34776514768600464,
-0.11746026575565338,
-0.15980061888694763,
-0.41877779364585876,
0.012208772823214531,
0.07134349644184113,
-0.438407301902771,
-0.24623064696788788,
-0.40867775678634644,
0.5810299515724182,
-0.2075498104095459,
0.34892821311950684,
0.405280739068985,
-0.11640109121799469,
-0.09480578452348709,
-0.062040407210588455,
0.6013854742050171,
0.244475319981575,
-0.10832684487104416,
0.10265245288610458,
0.4253321886062622,
-0.8915321230888367,
-0.02766801044344902,
-0.09597078710794449,
-0.11454037576913834,
-0.10721041262149811,
0.24600161612033844,
0.6604533195495605,
0.09976401925086975,
-0.6341697573661804,
0.6788364052772522,
-0.255237877368927,
-0.1166386678814888,
-0.2718667984008789,
0.18499648571014404,
-0.1872667819261551,
0.017853325232863426,
0.2805284559726715,
0.26571688055992126,
0.37511998414993286,
-0.33578991889953613,
0.4057117998600006,
0.5484635233879089,
-0.6174064874649048,
-0.5648144483566284,
0.6089352965354919,
0.2084071785211563,
-0.43367236852645874,
0.7409037947654724,
0.2597928047180176,
-1.065056324005127,
0.6489952206611633,
0.38870543241500854,
0.8371283411979675,
-0.5673723816871643,
-0.15453201532363892,
0.1590351164340973,
0.18966977298259735,
-0.298912912607193,
-0.058456603437662125,
-0.6233024597167969,
-0.378000408411026,
-0.020219767466187477,
-0.21748359501361847,
-0.6315247416496277,
-0.21535401046276093,
-1.0880513191223145,
0.1900160312652588,
-1.0303231477737427,
-0.36240965127944946,
-0.012828611768782139,
-0.17829035222530365,
-0.4668649733066559,
0.02089005894958973,
0.20646552741527557,
1.1326366662979126,
-0.7982286214828491,
0.767528772354126,
0.6647791862487793,
0.05320324748754501,
-0.8535277247428894,
0.23141294717788696,
0.16326060891151428,
-0.5489113926887512,
0.22189004719257355,
0.2123471051454544,
-0.5056298971176147,
-0.21607740223407745,
-0.2181926667690277,
-0.9302688837051392,
0.85772705078125,
0.3036026954650879,
-0.48145419359207153,
-0.0003326181322336197,
-0.09285804629325867,
0.48177486658096313,
-0.39732709527015686,
0.038916684687137604,
0.7992753386497498,
-0.2066219002008438,
0.22602930665016174,
-1.2933745384216309,
-0.3667077124118805,
-0.05044255033135414,
0.17168453335762024,
-0.009131103754043579,
-0.9604112505912781,
1.1033594608306885,
-0.1161121129989624,
-0.3829360604286194,
-0.10952870547771454,
0.3175349235534668,
0.11219273507595062,
0.04313164949417114,
0.608123779296875,
0.3992469906806946,
0.8442853093147278,
0.16134244203567505,
0.9026663303375244,
-0.14164020121097565,
0.3295285999774933,
1.4516665935516357,
-0.10563858598470688,
0.8440701365470886,
0.24916015565395355,
-0.24422670900821686,
0.12626242637634277,
0.24840685725212097,
-0.09156195819377899,
0.7089105248451233,
0.21666085720062256,
-0.32709577679634094,
-0.24637852609157562,
-0.25402918457984924,
-0.2595083713531494,
0.6025473475456238,
0.18455711007118225,
-0.12877200543880463,
0.03832218050956726,
-0.006953704636543989,
0.24169117212295532,
0.11521915346384048,
-0.6779541373252869,
0.8246042132377625,
0.07351382076740265,
-0.1534043401479721,
0.6091331839561462,
-0.31042954325675964,
0.724395215511322,
-0.5589585304260254,
0.28422582149505615,
-0.0516696572303772,
0.47053903341293335,
-0.2868734300136566,
-0.05115259066224098,
0.2766920328140259,
0.06696613878011703,
-0.5678378939628601,
-0.021026315167546272,
0.4735829830169678,
-0.43552324175834656,
-0.22926488518714905,
0.019594397395849228,
-0.05682123824954033,
0.12409855425357819,
-0.22353805601596832,
-0.7577610015869141,
0.18877577781677246,
-0.0017384655075147748,
0.21219947934150696,
0.40098071098327637,
-0.006300113629549742,
0.26234355568885803,
0.7897226214408875,
0.604462742805481,
0.4351317584514618,
0.2239677608013153,
-0.18116453289985657,
1.1772218942642212,
-0.3000698983669281,
-0.9505689740180969,
-0.7516018748283386,
0.2146172672510147,
-0.0314769521355629,
-0.3586843013763428,
0.6800029873847961,
0.5571474432945251,
0.7160109877586365,
0.008488968946039677,
0.49468693137168884,
0.43240663409233093,
0.8560044169425964,
-0.22571122646331787,
0.779738187789917,
-0.016003116965293884,
0.39591363072395325,
-0.3569592237472534,
-0.41053643822669983,
-0.2805273234844208,
0.771427571773529,
-0.2885551154613495,
-0.029456567019224167,
0.5115957856178284,
0.48688772320747375,
-0.07205761969089508,
0.1569812148809433,
0.16773274540901184,
0.03790732100605965,
0.5162025094032288,
0.37818077206611633,
0.6690354943275452,
-0.23122787475585938,
0.6717029809951782,
-0.505048394203186,
-0.3060530424118042,
0.02080991119146347,
-0.6291941404342651,
-1.1336945295333862,
-0.30057311058044434,
-0.4518420100212097,
-0.14456838369369507,
0.14441771805286407,
0.8490060567855835,
1.1337294578552246,
-0.869141161441803,
-0.4648142158985138,
-0.01111762784421444,
-0.2557133734226227,
-0.30605921149253845,
-0.09389779716730118,
0.48443710803985596,
-0.07279586791992188,
-0.34074217081069946,
0.428423136472702,
0.33079448342323303,
0.19401033222675323,
0.2933151125907898,
0.19836437702178955,
-0.03138568997383118,
0.1494579166173935,
0.09081084281206131,
0.7068526744842529,
-0.4779234230518341,
-0.06949391961097717,
-0.28313398361206055,
0.21771825850009918,
0.5266732573509216,
1.4451085329055786,
-0.721972644329071,
0.44549793004989624,
0.08745970577001572,
0.7810149192810059,
0.5197862982749939,
0.5760733485221863,
0.4331032633781433,
-0.8104825019836426,
0.4213448464870453,
0.6816781163215637,
-0.06763245165348053,
0.4179975986480713,
-0.383125364780426,
0.1360168606042862,
0.09539345651865005,
-0.6586262583732605,
-1.037331461906433,
0.1398443579673767,
-0.7584109306335449,
0.004431455861777067,
0.9701501131057739,
-0.464508593082428,
-0.27373141050338745,
-0.11332310736179352,
-0.08313043415546417,
-0.05956868827342987,
-0.6710445880889893,
0.6646360754966736,
0.3577834963798523,
-0.29969409108161926,
-0.06583037227392197,
-0.19531099498271942,
0.849894106388092,
0.5266843438148499,
-0.40956082940101624,
0.4425557553768158,
0.19953300058841705,
0.4175439476966858,
-0.03369482606649399,
0.8125600814819336,
-0.10844386368989944,
0.49129706621170044,
0.10439373552799225,
-0.06715796142816544,
-0.3214607536792755,
-0.5244579911231995,
-0.875289797782898,
0.2500769793987274,
0.03471283242106438,
-0.5439532995223999
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.02002v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.02002v1
|
Position Debiasing Fine-Tuning for Causal Perception in Long-Term Dialogue
| 2024-06-04T06:33:13 | 2024-06-04T06:33:13 |
Shixuan Fan, Wei Wei, Wendi Li, Xian-Ling Mao, Wenfeng Xie, Dangyang Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The core of the dialogue system is to generate relevant, informative, and
human-like responses based on extensive dialogue history. Recently, dialogue
generation domain has seen mainstream adoption of large language models (LLMs),
due to its powerful capability in generating utterances. However, there is a
natural deficiency for such models, that is, inherent position bias, which may
lead them to pay more attention to the nearby utterances instead of causally
relevant ones, resulting in generating irrelevant and generic responses in
long-term dialogue. To alleviate such problem, in this paper, we propose a
novel method, named Causal Perception long-term Dialogue framework (CPD), which
employs perturbation-based causal variable discovery method to extract casually
relevant utterances from the dialogue history and enhances model causal
perception during fine-tuning. Specifically, a local-position awareness method
is proposed in CPD for inter-sentence position correlation elimination, which
helps models extract causally relevant utterances based on perturbations. Then,
a casual-perception fine-tuning strategy is also proposed, to enhance the
capability of discovering the causal invariant factors, by differently
perturbing causally relevant and non-casually relevant ones for response
generation. Experimental results on two datasets prove that our proposed method
can effectively alleviate the position bias for multiple LLMs and achieve
significant progress compared with existing baselines.
|
[
-0.4437430202960968,
-1.0466562509536743,
0.9584186673164368,
0.30540719628334045,
-0.43117204308509827,
-0.2876707911491394,
-0.3125479519367218,
-0.3425105810165405,
0.14659298956394196,
0.6813596487045288,
-0.6240531206130981,
-0.5622584223747253,
-0.5084182620048523,
0.134921133518219,
0.0873195081949234,
0.6935842037200928,
0.26830965280532837,
0.09926240146160126,
-0.08793991804122925,
-0.08617677539587021,
-0.7787773013114929,
-0.47825419902801514,
-0.8483125567436218,
-0.14655163884162903,
0.6599627137184143,
0.3449740707874298,
0.4501151144504547,
0.24642902612686157,
0.2646964192390442,
0.2311018854379654,
-0.2903312146663666,
0.20488134026527405,
-0.6566323041915894,
0.13999435305595398,
-0.5473060607910156,
-0.32661452889442444,
-0.2347758263349533,
-0.31367164850234985,
0.7009440064430237,
0.7633239030838013,
-0.038158971816301346,
-0.08140506595373154,
0.34022730588912964,
0.42202553153038025,
-0.6651036143302917,
0.3442034125328064,
-0.6195698976516724,
-0.08677893877029419,
-0.09880221635103226,
-0.4446440637111664,
-0.47306185960769653,
-0.21143639087677002,
0.24834084510803223,
-0.42096051573753357,
0.28627318143844604,
-0.07383731752634048,
0.5907315015792847,
0.5396421551704407,
-0.6910326480865479,
0.38669154047966003,
-0.8964986801147461,
0.8368416428565979,
-1.0171449184417725,
0.39674729108810425,
0.46618548035621643,
0.07486651837825775,
-0.5779492259025574,
0.05148056522011757,
-0.5388426184654236,
-0.10188090801239014,
-0.22817248106002808,
0.07178804278373718,
0.02689209021627903,
0.3131742477416992,
0.3981245160102844,
-0.09471983462572098,
-0.2299034148454666,
0.339445024728775,
0.13761071860790253,
-0.09307114034891129,
0.4179971516132355,
0.22045911848545074,
-0.10557568073272705,
-0.2559427320957184,
-0.4181338846683502,
0.08962944895029068,
-0.9291436672210693,
0.16965781152248383,
0.23427999019622803,
0.4569496214389801,
-0.061189815402030945,
0.2880856394767761,
-0.5126091837882996,
0.7507914304733276,
0.6434719562530518,
-0.1186804324388504,
-0.06740722805261612,
-0.39016640186309814,
-0.38511383533477783,
0.3416665494441986,
0.6015770435333252,
0.520251452922821,
-0.07816844433546066,
0.059585440903902054,
0.27320975065231323,
-0.02876451425254345,
0.13715149462223053,
-0.6544994115829468,
0.01977161131799221,
-0.05658913776278496,
-0.28141552209854126,
-0.4114122986793518,
-0.1034276932477951,
-0.6333447098731995,
-0.7902932167053223,
-0.6129749417304993,
0.11682529747486115,
-0.1802823394536972,
-0.00022076770255807787,
0.336592435836792,
0.2314075082540512,
0.3153696358203888,
0.4186593294143677,
-0.8762524724006653,
-0.027240000665187836,
0.5310823321342468,
0.3908572196960449,
0.06496557593345642,
-0.04755657911300659,
-0.6995044946670532,
0.5018516778945923,
-0.2895923852920532,
0.7647207975387573,
-0.5181722044944763,
-0.4008604884147644,
-0.07291340082883835,
0.012605586089193821,
0.0944049134850502,
-0.3399448096752167,
0.6534523367881775,
-0.344251424074173,
0.16463786363601685,
-0.29370713233947754,
-0.16718193888664246,
-0.1580321192741394,
0.14469574391841888,
-0.35782721638679504,
0.6020767092704773,
-0.1803666651248932,
-0.8657697439193726,
0.6535722613334656,
-0.1796404868364334,
-0.39045560359954834,
-0.4025185704231262,
-0.41095197200775146,
-0.5203458070755005,
0.17849594354629517,
0.6568009257316589,
0.5135822892189026,
-0.6109297275543213,
0.9871390461921692,
-0.6874913573265076,
-0.2839365303516388,
0.12427139282226562,
-0.7510872483253479,
0.47673308849334717,
-0.09326634556055069,
-0.6553789973258972,
0.13821326196193695,
-0.9086355566978455,
-0.5054218173027039,
-0.2774676978588104,
0.10559773445129395,
-0.6891905665397644,
0.4556777775287628,
-0.6533404588699341,
0.4061393737792969,
0.12978674471378326,
-0.502215564250946,
0.05547298863530159,
-0.6471843123435974,
0.17152701318264008,
0.8581436276435852,
0.6571263670921326,
0.37824711203575134,
0.05363765358924866,
0.11947114020586014,
0.37821394205093384,
0.2672090232372284,
-0.03133292496204376,
-0.12141824513673782,
-0.8390058279037476,
-0.23669056594371796,
-0.2583075165748596,
0.3071797788143158,
-0.46914517879486084,
0.8751075267791748,
-0.10811000317335129,
-0.17976656556129456,
-0.04547709599137306,
0.11232001334428787,
0.4905480742454529,
0.8407728672027588,
0.36196330189704895,
-0.19118444621562958,
-0.32804128527641296,
-1.001983404159546,
-0.3041071891784668,
-0.22941075265407562,
0.0035627991892397404,
0.29047003388404846,
-0.13137049973011017,
-0.27508875727653503,
0.9549261331558228,
-0.8340874910354614,
-0.343501478433609,
0.15285006165504456,
0.25956544280052185,
0.27590176463127136,
0.45957931876182556,
0.35093939304351807,
-0.6411711573600769,
-0.06751534342765808,
-0.3012228310108185,
-0.5630257725715637,
-0.14202144742012024,
-0.33171388506889343,
-0.19372287392616272,
0.24960218369960785,
0.8549838066101074,
-0.3949460983276367,
0.47200921177864075,
0.2516181468963623,
-0.46422407031059265,
0.3240101933479309,
0.01822032779455185,
0.2119823396205902,
-0.9549407958984375,
0.09346114844083786,
0.0941588506102562,
-0.012457660399377346,
-0.27821457386016846,
-0.3717283010482788,
-0.22226886451244354,
0.0038643847219645977,
-0.2242688536643982,
0.4524509608745575,
-0.24314071238040924,
0.30707836151123047,
0.03776150941848755,
0.3384452760219574,
-0.15261700749397278,
0.7562597990036011,
0.10044000297784805,
0.30826336145401,
0.440542608499527,
-0.6650769710540771,
-0.12040881812572479,
0.21500033140182495,
-0.5733178853988647,
0.5937293171882629,
-0.47290927171707153,
-0.0036164182238280773,
-0.2573719024658203,
0.5606549382209778,
-1.2806285619735718,
-0.09614937752485275,
0.23483632504940033,
-0.06364728510379791,
0.32494547963142395,
-0.11123973876237869,
-0.18842190504074097,
-0.11388736963272095,
-0.19554638862609863,
0.5613287091255188,
0.013837493024766445,
-0.5033796429634094,
0.2630959749221802,
0.2125013917684555,
-0.47636839747428894,
-0.6005018949508667,
-0.1670767217874527,
-0.2442660629749298,
-0.5055747032165527,
-0.4142633080482483,
0.16635635495185852,
0.020006386563181877,
-0.20327332615852356,
-0.6500422358512878,
-0.44290420413017273,
0.3727383613586426,
0.13512128591537476,
0.399914413690567,
0.19023892283439636,
0.0878891870379448,
0.15471452474594116,
0.2532067596912384,
-0.3605146110057831,
0.10588957369327545,
-0.215251624584198,
0.4358830451965332,
0.2674090564250946,
-0.3426001965999603,
-0.5247756838798523,
0.07146462798118591,
0.670011043548584,
-0.19643433392047882,
0.4539679288864136,
0.5659295916557312,
-0.04447327181696892,
0.06951852142810822,
-0.8289275169372559,
-0.44465959072113037,
-0.4463307857513428,
0.32625168561935425,
-0.059645138680934906,
-1.0520426034927368,
0.3951950669288635,
-0.2929692566394806,
-0.3642543852329254,
0.2857746183872223,
0.26354169845581055,
0.06318235397338867,
1.311397910118103,
0.52703857421875,
-0.5643289685249329,
0.7532317638397217,
0.1196725144982338,
0.5776854753494263,
-0.849026620388031,
-0.12557153403759003,
-0.6534271836280823,
-0.2444046437740326,
-0.5467753410339355,
-0.39560529589653015,
0.6295485496520996,
0.3857018053531647,
-0.7083001136779785,
0.061746835708618164,
-0.1882963627576828,
0.16449254751205444,
0.41033872961997986,
0.33431217074394226,
0.3394300043582916,
-0.07077983021736145,
-0.3137395977973938,
-0.19777561724185944,
-0.3213813304901123,
-0.17333094775676727,
0.6636963486671448,
0.2680891454219818,
0.7925124168395996,
0.16146577894687653,
0.6409193873405457,
-0.03697001934051514,
-0.24197272956371307,
-0.45457106828689575,
0.5631499886512756,
-0.01968885399401188,
-0.3023650646209717,
-0.566821277141571,
-0.3233093023300171,
-0.7333490252494812,
0.035214949399232864,
-0.2511551082134247,
-1.1897202730178833,
0.6123626828193665,
0.0978255644440651,
-0.5924492478370667,
-0.10555646568536758,
-0.410842627286911,
0.646010160446167,
-0.09128989279270172,
-0.8018182516098022,
-0.6225404143333435,
-0.8932281136512756,
0.2856297791004181,
0.019766991958022118,
0.07414476573467255,
-0.2403251975774765,
0.598494291305542,
0.5196191668510437,
-0.32172104716300964,
1.3603302240371704,
-0.44862037897109985,
-0.626753568649292,
0.05517706647515297,
0.17675557732582092,
0.8020949363708496,
0.5489592552185059,
-0.014777866192162037,
0.11842745542526245,
-0.31665024161338806,
-0.13082319498062134,
-0.6721996665000916,
0.8680565357208252,
-0.6230084896087646,
-1.0041999816894531,
-0.17462557554244995,
-0.2718311548233032,
-0.6466493606567383,
0.2513815760612488,
0.11876185238361359,
0.6400469541549683,
-0.4431218206882477,
0.08898792415857315,
0.6803990602493286,
-0.5604261159896851,
0.3115968108177185,
0.7125644087791443,
-0.08234904706478119,
-0.24058252573013306,
0.4922583997249603,
-0.27922460436820984,
0.2028462141752243,
0.9867295026779175,
0.2840748429298401,
-0.2698380947113037,
-0.4053078591823578,
0.05936388298869133,
0.17285078763961792,
-0.2635610103607178,
-0.345376580953598,
-0.37565848231315613,
0.1851944625377655,
-0.3539029061794281,
-0.3229376971721649,
-0.1747232973575592,
-0.3409976661205292,
-0.216703400015831,
-0.2658301293849945,
0.23788578808307648,
0.22268225252628326,
0.07611119747161865,
0.3317713439464569,
-0.46894359588623047,
0.42252299189567566,
0.4206782281398773,
0.3446160852909088,
-0.17159403860569,
-0.3148557245731354,
-0.1874505579471588,
0.26330918073654175,
-0.4040965735912323,
-0.3377639949321747,
0.45383521914482117,
-0.1942594349384308,
0.3440718352794647,
0.833148717880249,
0.2796179950237274,
1.001079797744751,
-0.3601973354816437,
0.9186136722564697,
0.2765355408191681,
-0.8393265008926392,
0.7130943536758423,
-0.7195520997047424,
0.5160883069038391,
0.5692582726478577,
0.06916476786136627,
-0.2796298563480377,
-0.7460415363311768,
-0.5007079839706421,
-0.9357860088348389,
0.6178218126296997,
-0.2026655077934265,
-0.18502242863178253,
-0.25524139404296875,
0.2836395800113678,
-0.136030912399292,
0.15846523642539978,
-0.28358376026153564,
-0.11876997351646423,
0.22793589532375336,
0.24511264264583588,
-0.6852753758430481,
-0.3496430516242981,
-0.2789529263973236,
-0.38487809896469116,
0.6060134768486023,
-0.20241619646549225,
0.3221829831600189,
0.3857880234718323,
-0.010296893306076527,
-0.28769558668136597,
0.4318729341030121,
0.7380784153938293,
0.5467422604560852,
-0.5423634052276611,
0.027303403243422508,
0.1835787445306778,
-0.018385352566838264,
-0.011529384180903435,
0.06953404098749161,
-0.19759835302829742,
-0.14194771647453308,
0.11624439060688019,
0.8935320377349854,
0.8556548953056335,
-0.2875635027885437,
0.40689149498939514,
0.09978421032428741,
0.3676519989967346,
-0.2671152949333191,
-0.014595302753150463,
-0.22630169987678528,
0.46632447838783264,
0.1679830551147461,
0.2243863344192505,
0.2232913076877594,
-0.4236051142215729,
0.1625739187002182,
0.46479588747024536,
-0.6084888577461243,
-0.21263748407363892,
0.7092081308364868,
0.3362526595592499,
0.22180180251598358,
0.38869383931159973,
0.09316696226596832,
-0.3988116383552551,
0.3945813477039337,
0.6942072510719299,
0.9383062124252319,
-0.28138527274131775,
0.10900723189115524,
0.5963459014892578,
-0.30104318261146545,
-0.027744900435209274,
-0.06402093172073364,
-0.2164355218410492,
-0.8200385570526123,
-0.4270026385784149,
-0.5225318074226379,
-0.09513429552316666,
0.14797593653202057,
-0.7597280740737915,
0.5336334705352783,
-0.3505699634552002,
-0.3343155086040497,
-0.011089245788753033,
0.0711342915892601,
-0.5372852683067322,
0.16308970749378204,
0.19320273399353027,
0.378905713558197,
-0.6077473759651184,
0.8497769832611084,
0.12379387766122818,
-0.160663902759552,
-0.7624189257621765,
0.227304607629776,
0.1884266436100006,
-0.5607028603553772,
0.727206289768219,
-0.12378871440887451,
-0.5552611351013184,
-0.09278156608343124,
-0.5816633105278015,
-0.7903761863708496,
1.0854777097702026,
0.5135647058486938,
-0.9281097054481506,
-0.14301453530788422,
-0.08655783534049988,
0.5074507594108582,
-0.12441950291395187,
0.08160864561796188,
0.6576308608055115,
0.4150582253932953,
-0.2016359269618988,
-0.8897210955619812,
0.22256417572498322,
0.16968297958374023,
0.12219269573688507,
0.445024698972702,
-0.9482749104499817,
0.4351212978363037,
-0.1551918238401413,
-0.0025696088559925556,
0.046837519854307175,
0.39726361632347107,
0.21143470704555511,
0.17113636434078217,
0.4867108464241028,
0.29843130707740784,
0.611405611038208,
0.04277694597840309,
0.7921497225761414,
-0.34906524419784546,
0.3837921619415283,
1.5175124406814575,
-0.4275244176387787,
0.6937703490257263,
0.7111645936965942,
0.10278140008449554,
0.5546474456787109,
0.14690211415290833,
0.248844712972641,
0.902827799320221,
0.12908931076526642,
-0.46462559700012207,
-0.5015238523483276,
-0.08085674047470093,
-0.23529265820980072,
0.5746151804924011,
0.5324886441230774,
-0.4849787652492523,
-0.2266368269920349,
-0.098118357360363,
0.09383785724639893,
0.14893504977226257,
-0.23691831529140472,
0.9469789266586304,
0.1180044412612915,
-0.9444263577461243,
0.7268080711364746,
-0.04998789355158806,
0.5370199084281921,
-0.6436508297920227,
-0.0376749262213707,
-0.2768420875072479,
0.40365174412727356,
0.024816088378429413,
-0.2381981611251831,
0.022460494190454483,
-0.37359970808029175,
-0.32900890707969666,
-0.2046455442905426,
0.6558221578598022,
-0.49126434326171875,
-0.26328885555267334,
0.4398852586746216,
0.19159655272960663,
-0.3464881181716919,
-0.06633252650499344,
-0.1698574274778366,
-0.11265444755554199,
0.2723967134952545,
0.020046604797244072,
0.4331061840057373,
0.4312437176704407,
-0.33955493569374084,
0.41201096773147583,
0.4238627552986145,
-0.12076868116855621,
-0.4453236162662506,
0.3131389915943146,
0.7088319063186646,
-0.8568279147148132,
-0.5343373417854309,
-0.834980309009552,
0.21416473388671875,
-0.0464189276099205,
-0.29621145129203796,
0.704345166683197,
0.2330605685710907,
0.689530611038208,
-0.1239265501499176,
0.5781731605529785,
0.26153799891471863,
0.5154722929000854,
-0.6122193336486816,
0.5957627892494202,
-0.10419707745313644,
0.5208063721656799,
-0.8718636631965637,
-0.8355080485343933,
-0.6066088676452637,
0.6948320269584656,
-0.8996475338935852,
-0.3442416489124298,
0.5766177773475647,
0.9974796175956726,
0.1462308019399643,
-0.012867586687207222,
0.41891393065452576,
0.5980526208877563,
0.4750927686691284,
0.5978042483329773,
0.8157455325126648,
-0.15419109165668488,
0.1324443519115448,
-0.08419770747423172,
-0.06224768981337547,
-0.35965678095817566,
-1.000954508781433,
-0.8112075328826904,
-0.6266489028930664,
-0.27610358595848083,
-0.12240296602249146,
0.11669241636991501,
0.8653886914253235,
0.4232666492462158,
-0.7576163411140442,
-0.04332263767719269,
-0.32861074805259705,
0.24760021269321442,
-0.30798712372779846,
-0.252034455537796,
0.41305211186408997,
-0.5194124579429626,
-0.57500159740448,
0.5359728336334229,
0.4960669279098511,
-0.26400989294052124,
0.008113828487694263,
-0.00587312038987875,
-0.28890329599380493,
0.0722697451710701,
0.8122958540916443,
0.3126338720321655,
-0.6810320019721985,
-0.9151167273521423,
-0.37271952629089355,
0.05002208054065704,
0.013748859986662865,
0.9807145595550537,
-1.0084408521652222,
0.6352571845054626,
0.24649906158447266,
0.10582184046506882,
0.5985594987869263,
0.2788747251033783,
1.0394599437713623,
-0.8500463366508484,
0.47071656584739685,
-0.0015119921881705523,
0.39921772480010986,
0.07838274538516998,
-0.5465680360794067,
0.20060154795646667,
-0.011909316293895245,
-0.5901307463645935,
-0.5058964490890503,
0.40413379669189453,
-1.206154704093933,
-0.14768625795841217,
1.1895482540130615,
-0.014968239702284336,
0.3465935289859772,
-0.20957313477993011,
-0.6164868474006653,
0.4515030086040497,
-0.547664225101471,
1.0190386772155762,
0.4343200623989105,
-0.21497000753879547,
0.23304452002048492,
-0.09390024840831757,
0.6825833320617676,
0.682934582233429,
-0.4751861095428467,
0.33732375502586365,
0.8971302509307861,
0.1971476823091507,
0.18601824343204498,
0.5254523754119873,
-0.15460942685604095,
-0.049878332763910294,
-0.2774624824523926,
-0.34968698024749756,
0.34464699029922485,
-0.46057581901550293,
-0.41074153780937195,
-0.1266029179096222,
0.17827638983726501,
0.030855590477585793
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.01988v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.01988v1
|
Personalized Topic Selection Model for Topic-Grounded Dialogue
| 2024-06-04T06:09:49 | 2024-06-04T06:09:49 |
Shixuan Fan, Wei Wei, Xiaofei Wen, Xianling Mao, Jixiong Chen, Dangyang Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Recently, the topic-grounded dialogue (TGD) system has become increasingly
popular as its powerful capability to actively guide users to accomplish
specific tasks through topic-guided conversations. Most existing works utilize
side information (\eg topics or personas) in isolation to enhance the topic
selection ability. However, due to disregarding the noise within these
auxiliary information sources and their mutual influence, current models tend
to predict user-uninteresting and contextually irrelevant topics. To build
user-engaging and coherent dialogue agent, we propose a \textbf{P}ersonalized
topic s\textbf{E}lection model for \textbf{T}opic-grounded \textbf{D}ialogue,
named \textbf{PETD}, which takes account of the interaction of side information
to selectively aggregate such information for more accurately predicting
subsequent topics. Specifically, we evaluate the correlation between global
topics and personas and selectively incorporate the global topics aligned with
user personas. Furthermore, we propose a contrastive learning based persona
selector to filter out irrelevant personas under the constraint of lacking
pertinent persona annotations. Throughout the selection and generation, diverse
relevant side information is considered. Extensive experiments demonstrate that
our proposed method can generate engaging and diverse responses, outperforming
state-of-the-art baselines across various evaluation metrics.
|
[
-0.8050985336303711,
-0.9493508338928223,
0.7827824354171753,
0.026745500043034554,
-0.5307438969612122,
0.14599384367465973,
-0.23223590850830078,
-0.0322895310819149,
0.6545711755752563,
0.617709755897522,
-0.6183083057403564,
-0.6966127753257751,
-0.27211445569992065,
-0.261118620634079,
0.14081114530563354,
1.0560505390167236,
0.3566047251224518,
-0.013837951235473156,
-0.22062362730503082,
-0.136176198720932,
-0.6419904828071594,
-0.46600863337516785,
-0.687904953956604,
-0.621975839138031,
0.46113768219947815,
0.45274868607521057,
0.4153026342391968,
0.13693898916244507,
0.08293216675519943,
0.22086769342422485,
-0.4451199173927307,
-0.014009813778102398,
-0.5519817471504211,
0.5475771427154541,
-0.6972442865371704,
0.023695699870586395,
-0.41117286682128906,
-0.06538745015859604,
0.27156519889831543,
0.7499773502349854,
-0.13644589483737946,
-0.2494032382965088,
0.0950118899345398,
0.1360316425561905,
-0.4125819206237793,
-0.07294176518917084,
-0.4010429382324219,
0.36008936166763306,
0.1327340006828308,
-0.307325541973114,
-0.43140777945518494,
-0.11344835162162781,
0.5555895566940308,
-0.5902285575866699,
0.13569322228431702,
-0.14480610191822052,
0.752916693687439,
0.10622583329677582,
-0.44771572947502136,
0.02664925344288349,
-0.6388761401176453,
0.7462539672851562,
-0.312634140253067,
0.277040958404541,
0.6280071139335632,
0.29090163111686707,
0.012452722527086735,
-0.577772855758667,
-0.140166237950325,
-0.32750940322875977,
0.01643642969429493,
0.5123610496520996,
0.12103074789047241,
0.23457325994968414,
0.10982299596071243,
0.38400036096572876,
-0.32412558794021606,
0.09674643725156784,
0.1992708444595337,
-0.003216043347492814,
0.33769574761390686,
0.3058770000934601,
0.22964605689048767,
-0.07535405457019806,
-0.16252100467681885,
0.21373958885669708,
-0.3913434147834778,
-0.07492237538099289,
0.31341275572776794,
0.07137298583984375,
-0.07130571454763412,
0.4144956171512604,
-0.4642360508441925,
0.5034403800964355,
0.8226722478866577,
-0.09608237445354462,
0.09543212503194809,
-0.15215368568897247,
-0.09042208641767502,
-0.1819225549697876,
0.5932108163833618,
0.5041598081588745,
-0.1630811095237732,
-0.2727268934249878,
-0.06561601161956787,
-0.1984926015138626,
0.38727056980133057,
-1.005016565322876,
-0.32584866881370544,
0.48744744062423706,
-0.851626455783844,
-0.5110438466072083,
-0.09227337688207626,
-0.9725382328033447,
-0.5169835686683655,
-0.25104856491088867,
0.0990302786231041,
-0.3033587634563446,
-0.3725883364677429,
-0.12817002832889557,
-0.07658347487449646,
-0.023910658434033394,
0.5647911429405212,
-0.8901222348213196,
0.1667783409357071,
0.544522762298584,
0.6717637181282043,
-0.16173386573791504,
-0.13076239824295044,
-0.5139535665512085,
0.05588963255286217,
-0.20164717733860016,
0.8573300242424011,
-1.0376378297805786,
-0.6573784947395325,
-0.09472452849149704,
-0.17298759520053864,
0.18926286697387695,
-0.31111079454421997,
0.6162037253379822,
-0.520699143409729,
0.5943502187728882,
-0.49523836374282837,
-0.3883925676345825,
-0.021109115332365036,
0.3867722749710083,
-0.38801178336143494,
0.6036651134490967,
0.19435159862041473,
-0.9966720342636108,
0.46282854676246643,
-0.5054233074188232,
-0.06719580292701721,
0.13554395735263824,
-0.4734683632850647,
-0.35403889417648315,
0.024541908875107765,
0.27094754576683044,
0.4336746633052826,
-0.5037436485290527,
0.9099060893058777,
-0.5899206399917603,
-0.2846062183380127,
0.12634386122226715,
-0.20844221115112305,
0.35713428258895874,
0.47936928272247314,
-0.15920132398605347,
0.39384573698043823,
-0.47078654170036316,
-0.19411155581474304,
-0.022692272439599037,
-0.232269749045372,
-0.19746142625808716,
0.19220027327537537,
-0.06458158791065216,
0.2748751938343048,
0.1417333334684372,
-0.4615534245967865,
-0.09760504215955734,
-0.2775837779045105,
0.27817440032958984,
0.7928752899169922,
0.517256498336792,
0.3671233057975769,
-0.5994815826416016,
0.4684067964553833,
0.0992404967546463,
-0.23476500809192657,
-0.3987525701522827,
-0.5526658892631531,
-0.7154427170753479,
-0.4390183389186859,
0.24778825044631958,
0.5073615312576294,
-0.6938775181770325,
0.916041374206543,
0.047976069152355194,
-0.4559459388256073,
-0.07133900374174118,
-0.32197174429893494,
0.38848182559013367,
0.8068888783454895,
0.15432056784629822,
-0.3876720070838928,
-0.18163880705833435,
-0.8291789889335632,
-0.09449758380651474,
-0.30108046531677246,
-0.22717589139938354,
0.7817747592926025,
0.04539691284298897,
-0.28098946809768677,
1.1867772340774536,
-0.7544955611228943,
-0.04591700807213783,
-0.3558874726295471,
0.384260356426239,
0.0050267670303583145,
0.47728341817855835,
0.46534863114356995,
-0.8283292055130005,
-0.7496249079704285,
0.04003109782934189,
-0.6818915009498596,
-0.6190181374549866,
-0.23512685298919678,
-0.4762707054615021,
-0.3597186505794525,
0.44643691182136536,
-0.5287736654281616,
0.4758606553077698,
-0.02252008393406868,
-0.5698509216308594,
0.28043419122695923,
0.0013553616590797901,
0.33475261926651,
-1.513846516609192,
0.23629283905029297,
0.16566339135169983,
-0.31349775195121765,
-0.7023647427558899,
-0.2262086272239685,
-0.33343350887298584,
-0.6246725916862488,
-0.25749534368515015,
0.622603714466095,
-0.004319391213357449,
-0.03152201697230339,
-0.42335864901542664,
0.12296459078788757,
-0.06640467792749405,
0.7876466512680054,
0.6307506561279297,
0.5698319673538208,
0.5213670134544373,
-0.5616811513900757,
0.07527323067188263,
0.6487944722175598,
0.11803662776947021,
0.8936338424682617,
-0.6949833035469055,
0.3932025134563446,
-0.13581736385822296,
0.4318692088127136,
-0.8989284634590149,
-0.3249657154083252,
0.5489299893379211,
-0.25777730345726013,
0.2619786858558655,
-0.2797001898288727,
-0.027780471369624138,
0.20134873688220978,
-0.1461687535047531,
0.32336097955703735,
0.3663259446620941,
-0.5531634092330933,
0.7362892031669617,
0.46464747190475464,
-0.5604067444801331,
-0.17951266467571259,
-0.06399878859519958,
0.11183629930019379,
-0.49375227093696594,
-0.6965007781982422,
0.5868496298789978,
-0.4433525502681732,
-0.25390321016311646,
-0.09136361628770828,
-0.02862219139933586,
-0.12669922411441803,
0.09502231329679489,
0.205012246966362,
-0.1590021848678589,
-0.07877478748559952,
0.2875784933567047,
0.25182580947875977,
-0.293093740940094,
-0.23823338747024536,
-0.24311432242393494,
0.7426736950874329,
-0.18703129887580872,
-0.44590070843696594,
-0.47640886902809143,
0.6903671026229858,
0.5157252550125122,
-0.32365182042121887,
0.6393123865127563,
0.5753284096717834,
-0.23616671562194824,
-0.08131571114063263,
-0.5968782305717468,
-0.34615573287010193,
-0.439519464969635,
0.43203604221343994,
-0.5858405232429504,
-0.9186615943908691,
0.7852863669395447,
-0.23809124529361725,
-0.1493220180273056,
0.20732060074806213,
0.5794378519058228,
0.10333314538002014,
0.7984721064567566,
0.44864824414253235,
0.05464671552181244,
0.9476777911186218,
0.08319154381752014,
0.0892396867275238,
-0.8304800987243652,
-0.2803751528263092,
-0.3235664665699005,
-0.12726958096027374,
-0.5259383916854858,
-0.2336706519126892,
0.15505895018577576,
0.011517573148012161,
-0.31727442145347595,
0.011751911602914333,
-0.44161316752433777,
0.3994779884815216,
0.5294772386550903,
0.3807404339313507,
0.013240566477179527,
0.032809704542160034,
-0.2361120730638504,
-0.36454063653945923,
-0.22785110771656036,
-0.5490877032279968,
1.0292319059371948,
0.4544636011123657,
0.711122453212738,
0.10969602316617966,
0.7351282238960266,
0.456332266330719,
0.17999614775180817,
-0.575060248374939,
0.6744474768638611,
0.03629118949174881,
-0.321461945772171,
-0.20184695720672607,
-0.21686038374900818,
-0.5822341442108154,
0.7963096499443054,
-0.11573132872581482,
-1.1410059928894043,
0.34540030360221863,
-0.03923239931464195,
-0.39146187901496887,
0.10963058471679688,
-0.547551155090332,
0.8776387572288513,
-0.041328493505716324,
-0.6141449809074402,
-0.29879727959632874,
-0.5079896450042725,
0.08280527591705322,
-0.25927212834358215,
-0.5280140042304993,
-0.09539441764354706,
0.010725918225944042,
0.4682442247867584,
-0.2841191589832306,
0.8872640132904053,
-0.28454986214637756,
0.05715029686689377,
0.19975905120372772,
0.0010221257107332349,
0.4355044662952423,
0.5492011308670044,
-0.1703597456216812,
-0.06238590553402901,
-0.5995294451713562,
-0.21845075488090515,
-0.5352464318275452,
0.6438083052635193,
-0.6840265989303589,
-1.049981713294983,
-0.3346334397792816,
-0.07810378074645996,
-0.3917999565601349,
0.1578061282634735,
0.34502455592155457,
0.33052754402160645,
-0.6984710097312927,
0.2821090817451477,
0.7731677889823914,
-0.5386666059494019,
0.2190181463956833,
0.735450804233551,
-0.12693019211292267,
-0.7323421835899353,
0.947165846824646,
-0.43873053789138794,
0.3100893497467041,
0.490414559841156,
0.33324331045150757,
-0.12505163252353668,
-0.47377628087997437,
-0.11736254394054413,
0.0010240183910354972,
-0.7523965239524841,
0.1336904764175415,
-1.0264145135879517,
-0.12917087972164154,
-0.15622484683990479,
-0.3535178005695343,
-0.36678051948547363,
-0.15007637441158295,
-0.8169143795967102,
-0.21075651049613953,
-0.20794063806533813,
0.3959345817565918,
0.14709271490573883,
0.3519057035446167,
-0.3340051472187042,
0.579066276550293,
0.4697417616844177,
0.16762302815914154,
-0.32790014147758484,
-0.6795824766159058,
0.12240790575742722,
-0.09813503175973892,
-0.7889581322669983,
-0.978094220161438,
0.5130141377449036,
0.19295161962509155,
0.8224208354949951,
0.771357536315918,
0.3016410768032074,
0.32873520255088806,
-0.2958468496799469,
0.7873890399932861,
0.13298089802265167,
-0.7969067096710205,
0.8954161405563354,
-0.787351667881012,
0.1653261035680771,
0.7070009708404541,
0.09431878477334976,
-0.6698951125144958,
-0.4893268048763275,
-0.7065245509147644,
-0.7148145437240601,
0.9804927110671997,
0.20001813769340515,
0.021140776574611664,
0.01080273650586605,
0.0883375033736229,
0.31023168563842773,
0.5567447543144226,
-0.7123518586158752,
-0.11565326154232025,
-0.46392765641212463,
0.05468115210533142,
0.05148783326148987,
-0.4148232638835907,
-0.10851442068815231,
0.014584118500351906,
0.5595175623893738,
-0.22998078167438507,
0.5320727825164795,
0.20603923499584198,
0.2570309042930603,
-0.1811436265707016,
0.34197938442230225,
0.6213952302932739,
0.5257421731948853,
-0.6435131430625916,
-0.27004602551460266,
-0.15857985615730286,
-0.21216756105422974,
0.037738122045993805,
0.15706408023834229,
-0.14382244646549225,
-0.0006907213828526437,
-0.23318275809288025,
0.9162197709083557,
0.09433393180370331,
-0.4909704327583313,
0.5131127834320068,
-0.19222591817378998,
-0.04314664751291275,
-0.34748029708862305,
-0.018999243155121803,
0.047621950507164,
0.33678552508354187,
0.153910294175148,
0.04161756485700607,
0.13249555230140686,
-0.3808230757713318,
0.22924380004405975,
0.1985720843076706,
-0.4824257791042328,
-0.40145343542099,
0.6157640218734741,
0.8843755722045898,
-0.5525475144386292,
0.45264875888824463,
-0.40076038241386414,
-0.6525272727012634,
0.4332317113876343,
0.42714962363243103,
1.4184348583221436,
-0.251364529132843,
0.5218834280967712,
0.26312875747680664,
-0.14980152249336243,
0.25045767426490784,
0.22827772796154022,
-0.34701183438301086,
-0.7318306565284729,
-0.0641390010714531,
-0.34259042143821716,
-0.6011338233947754,
0.6313940286636353,
-0.5427039861679077,
0.37740039825439453,
-0.572380006313324,
-0.2689351737499237,
-0.22374306619167328,
0.07323841750621796,
-0.2416011542081833,
0.20035293698310852,
0.08303611725568771,
0.49146923422813416,
-0.9643845558166504,
0.5631683468818665,
0.8091590404510498,
-0.3512975871562958,
-0.14872480928897858,
0.6179372668266296,
-0.11498162895441055,
-0.15501654148101807,
0.6156494617462158,
0.05419692024588585,
0.012710374779999256,
-0.15872040390968323,
-0.22215044498443604,
-0.5414355993270874,
1.0138620138168335,
0.42666319012641907,
-0.20641538500785828,
0.23053129017353058,
-0.22725018858909607,
0.639836847782135,
-0.8329367637634277,
0.5926742553710938,
0.03444099426269531,
0.12589295208454132,
0.5091311931610107,
-0.820195198059082,
-0.136749729514122,
-0.4137037992477417,
0.058419518172740936,
0.08428534865379333,
-1.0857739448547363,
0.9232024550437927,
0.13281762599945068,
0.007442972157150507,
0.16903042793273926,
0.6023796796798706,
0.394259512424469,
0.5696942210197449,
0.4070320129394531,
0.4452396035194397,
0.6727923154830933,
0.09492427855730057,
0.6758007407188416,
-0.4536150097846985,
0.27392613887786865,
1.2166420221328735,
-0.48359617590904236,
0.5091175436973572,
0.2845129072666168,
0.22021250426769257,
0.32170939445495605,
1.063657522201538,
0.11876562237739563,
1.0038642883300781,
-0.12262764573097229,
-0.5742239356040955,
-0.6858208179473877,
-0.42544278502464294,
-0.47122442722320557,
0.393633633852005,
0.5449556708335876,
-0.6066625118255615,
-0.18186554312705994,
-0.03154095262289047,
-0.3714043200016022,
0.13542625308036804,
0.03086092695593834,
0.9189879894256592,
0.026179663836956024,
-0.9826814532279968,
0.13777762651443481,
0.23004275560379028,
0.40441492199897766,
-0.39554905891418457,
-0.1497139185667038,
-0.4999713599681854,
-0.08260621130466461,
0.04560113698244095,
-0.5647904872894287,
-0.05070553347468376,
-0.159219428896904,
-0.17702707648277283,
-0.5332152843475342,
1.1537315845489502,
-0.5445556044578552,
0.06268142908811569,
0.08117027580738068,
0.5474537014961243,
0.09484917670488358,
-0.2199988216161728,
-0.6322610378265381,
-0.13599751889705658,
0.3767309784889221,
-0.2890576422214508,
0.41143912076950073,
0.3684700131416321,
-0.05210673436522484,
0.8106728792190552,
0.3127623200416565,
-0.17658527195453644,
-0.7285544872283936,
0.06513134390115738,
1.2116621732711792,
-0.71940016746521,
-1.2773826122283936,
-0.4194352626800537,
0.5667297840118408,
-0.38031598925590515,
-0.4591085910797119,
0.4778899550437927,
0.3827080726623535,
0.4909542500972748,
-0.16297969222068787,
0.8730745315551758,
0.11868798732757568,
0.765383780002594,
-0.4151007831096649,
0.6137725710868835,
-0.3729812502861023,
0.5196925401687622,
-0.4130087196826935,
-1.085320234298706,
0.3757116198539734,
0.7842233777046204,
-0.4061817526817322,
0.39941757917404175,
0.680608868598938,
0.5512727499008179,
-0.2648015320301056,
0.3601851761341095,
0.6330934166908264,
-0.13592855632305145,
0.4904429316520691,
0.5333378911018372,
1.2515230178833008,
0.18506720662117004,
0.1293782889842987,
-0.09993994981050491,
-0.10853692144155502,
-0.6112326383590698,
-0.8155264258384705,
-1.5099387168884277,
-0.616565465927124,
-0.628623902797699,
-0.17774680256843567,
0.01916390284895897,
0.9543834328651428,
0.8445926904678345,
-0.6302475333213806,
0.0753597542643547,
-0.3024348318576813,
0.0694136843085289,
0.39676350355148315,
-0.22901010513305664,
0.09739400446414948,
-0.15187451243400574,
-0.7165541648864746,
0.3916487395763397,
0.3311694860458374,
0.07693330198526382,
-0.19463150203227997,
-0.20639213919639587,
0.09507627785205841,
0.06434313952922821,
0.29235610365867615,
0.2658136785030365,
-0.8016953468322754,
-0.31574419140815735,
-0.25053146481513977,
-0.06929675489664078,
0.16316363215446472,
0.9385320544242859,
-0.7528583407402039,
0.5991347432136536,
0.4270225167274475,
0.5092269778251648,
0.6589151620864868,
0.45188575983047485,
0.864280104637146,
-0.8316644430160522,
0.33551815152168274,
0.530956506729126,
0.19100378453731537,
0.21703651547431946,
-0.48675259947776794,
0.40159302949905396,
0.32678207755088806,
-0.6615332961082458,
-0.676868736743927,
0.5328648686408997,
-0.8633610010147095,
-0.35767146944999695,
1.199623942375183,
-0.36055827140808105,
0.2918005585670471,
-0.4116743803024292,
-0.6288759112358093,
-0.016590077430009842,
-0.8461187481880188,
0.649566650390625,
0.8045489192008972,
-0.23240697383880615,
-0.16407373547554016,
-0.19047501683235168,
0.42149364948272705,
0.5806120038032532,
-0.7818975448608398,
-0.16164815425872803,
0.7130714654922485,
0.12227612733840942,
0.11801832169294357,
0.9178625345230103,
0.36795365810394287,
0.13500680029392242,
0.05867956206202507,
-0.2559855580329895,
0.03786533325910568,
-0.3046175539493561,
-0.2735513746738434,
0.287985235452652,
0.08690143376588821,
-0.16050398349761963
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.01983v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.01983v1
|
RKLD: Reverse KL-Divergence-based Knowledge Distillation for Unlearning Personal Information in Large Language Models
| 2024-06-04T05:51:43 | 2024-06-04T05:51:43 |
Bichen Wang, Yuzhe Zi, Yixin Sun, Yanyan Zhao, Bing Qin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
With the passage of the Right to Be Forgotten (RTBF) regulations and the
scaling up of language model training datasets, research on model unlearning in
large language models (LLMs) has become more crucial. Before the era of LLMs,
machine unlearning research focused mainly on classification tasks in models
with small parameters. In these tasks, the content to be forgotten or retained
is clear and straightforward. However, as parameter sizes have grown and tasks
have become more complex, balancing forget quality and model utility has become
more challenging, especially in scenarios involving personal data instead of
classification results. Existing methods based on gradient ascent and its
variants often struggle with this balance, leading to unintended information
loss or partial forgetting. To address this challenge, we propose RKLD, a novel
\textbf{R}everse \textbf{KL}-Divergence-based Knowledge \textbf{D}istillation
unlearning algorithm for LLMs targeting the unlearning of personal information.
Through RKLD, we achieve significant forget quality and effectively maintain
the model utility in our experiments.
|
[
-0.2526441812515259,
-0.7412211894989014,
0.33923283219337463,
-0.06775995343923569,
-0.36293017864227295,
0.5403996109962463,
-0.1789524108171463,
0.0897970199584961,
-0.07133287936449051,
0.8115456104278564,
-0.7499890923500061,
-0.6256119608879089,
-0.47664156556129456,
-0.3558369576931,
-0.2821677625179291,
1.0759475231170654,
-0.01873316615819931,
-0.05729086697101593,
-0.3766031265258789,
-0.21402645111083984,
-0.44926077127456665,
-0.44702234864234924,
-0.35881757736206055,
-0.8016119003295898,
0.7609536051750183,
0.6145142316818237,
0.1298137754201889,
0.43007656931877136,
0.21271878480911255,
0.1835140436887741,
-0.177913099527359,
0.26619410514831543,
-0.9220724105834961,
0.42723652720451355,
-0.28897738456726074,
-0.4812166392803192,
-0.18792706727981567,
-0.1761971414089203,
0.593076765537262,
0.9419851899147034,
-0.598957359790802,
0.3445150852203369,
0.2727651000022888,
1.3702220916748047,
-0.7539497017860413,
0.1905636489391327,
-0.48863622546195984,
0.245184525847435,
-0.12528647482395172,
-0.24681781232357025,
-0.599967360496521,
-0.33860814571380615,
0.15648378431797028,
-0.33260855078697205,
0.24943210184574127,
0.01555507630109787,
0.5729115605354309,
0.4473349153995514,
-0.31072282791137695,
-0.355876624584198,
-1.0207439661026,
0.8901280760765076,
-0.8179308772087097,
0.7533782720565796,
0.4072991907596588,
0.3360477089881897,
-0.23282696306705475,
-0.8662360906600952,
-0.479508638381958,
0.06013421714305878,
-0.09721189737319946,
0.20100633800029755,
-0.14325687289237976,
-0.07437944412231445,
-0.01758251152932644,
0.24484609067440033,
-0.3973058760166168,
0.3796161115169525,
-0.2996736764907837,
-0.1784159243106842,
0.45969340205192566,
0.2812580466270447,
-0.046429023146629333,
0.3313600718975067,
-0.22289246320724487,
-0.08278188109397888,
-1.026435136795044,
0.024822210893034935,
0.507079005241394,
0.30247044563293457,
0.007392695173621178,
0.5694580078125,
-0.5771713256835938,
0.4440113604068756,
0.19511523842811584,
-0.45772409439086914,
0.3153475224971771,
-0.014342376962304115,
-0.1982303410768509,
0.07164561003446579,
0.5369067788124084,
0.12757663428783417,
0.18138718605041504,
-0.24665583670139313,
-0.16833750903606415,
-0.5965069532394409,
0.05439404770731926,
-0.8021361827850342,
-0.610467791557312,
0.20132394134998322,
-0.5897216200828552,
-0.18621666729450226,
-0.25562626123428345,
-0.7708392143249512,
-0.6739217638969421,
-0.43139171600341797,
0.17992444336414337,
-0.25794675946235657,
-0.6097270250320435,
-0.0023743784986436367,
-0.008221816271543503,
-0.06745036691427231,
0.3029138445854187,
-0.6265637278556824,
-0.1326936036348343,
0.4934569001197815,
0.4774109125137329,
-0.010677359998226166,
-0.42713943123817444,
-0.1744621843099594,
-0.07765001058578491,
-0.11186396330595016,
0.4214806854724884,
-0.2635692059993744,
-0.442859023809433,
-0.0659002736210823,
-0.08842669427394867,
0.06796528398990631,
-0.6495428085327148,
0.5190829038619995,
-0.9625602960586548,
0.398728609085083,
-0.2497217208147049,
-0.8646053075790405,
-0.45296064019203186,
0.13999316096305847,
-0.526537299156189,
0.7838515639305115,
0.005908177699893713,
-0.9489114284515381,
0.47241082787513733,
-0.380990594625473,
-0.2699927091598511,
0.16542214155197144,
-0.03331684321165085,
-1.0168582201004028,
0.07171142846345901,
-0.1430404633283615,
0.6694296598434448,
-0.36962461471557617,
0.4691246747970581,
-0.578722357749939,
-0.13400894403457642,
0.1777637004852295,
-0.7248093485832214,
0.9161611199378967,
0.26260149478912354,
0.045255210250616074,
-0.15691637992858887,
-0.7880347967147827,
-0.019286317750811577,
0.21534845232963562,
-0.850508451461792,
-0.7189908027648926,
0.012546763755381107,
-0.3784298002719879,
0.032804783433675766,
0.26760268211364746,
-0.7122731804847717,
0.17510683834552765,
-0.34455421566963196,
0.24260245263576508,
0.899084746837616,
0.10416217148303986,
0.4558272957801819,
-0.18095719814300537,
0.40547168254852295,
0.36143794655799866,
-0.09129095077514648,
-0.11883401870727539,
-0.2955235540866852,
-0.7572512626647949,
-0.4234863817691803,
0.4147455096244812,
0.4426089823246002,
-0.6048329472541809,
0.452971875667572,
-0.23995749652385712,
-0.5828574895858765,
-0.8267683386802673,
0.4072134494781494,
0.5901674628257751,
0.9048891663551331,
0.17610476911067963,
0.04155895113945007,
-0.548209547996521,
-0.8156768083572388,
-0.3798079788684845,
-0.18000958859920502,
0.10045398771762848,
0.2454349547624588,
0.2445787787437439,
-0.3476825952529907,
1.1771812438964844,
-0.7225621342658997,
-0.48383936285972595,
-0.34254807233810425,
0.22323152422904968,
0.24090199172496796,
0.19229969382286072,
0.06361734867095947,
-0.8476038575172424,
-0.6463755369186401,
0.10521841049194336,
-0.805405855178833,
-0.0698460265994072,
0.11662037670612335,
0.13194933533668518,
0.4796069264411926,
0.43748947978019714,
-0.5007991194725037,
0.37333783507347107,
0.3201412260532379,
-0.2796202003955841,
0.689312756061554,
-0.4727531671524048,
-0.06664334982633591,
-1.0146474838256836,
0.2343149483203888,
-0.4713050127029419,
-0.245731920003891,
-0.7604649662971497,
-0.18959106504917145,
0.2639603912830353,
0.23647700250148773,
-0.4076760709285736,
0.7796948552131653,
-0.3818572163581848,
-0.0029987990856170654,
-0.31702160835266113,
-0.05275435000658035,
-0.027864623814821243,
0.6281423568725586,
-0.20501376688480377,
0.5140252709388733,
0.2769148647785187,
-0.793911337852478,
0.3924705386161804,
0.02648506686091423,
-0.28150051832199097,
0.49337831139564514,
-0.13473881781101227,
0.0940869152545929,
-0.6339144110679626,
0.06472022086381912,
-1.129232406616211,
-0.07318156212568283,
0.08920121937990189,
-0.4026297330856323,
0.4260275363922119,
-0.2764763832092285,
-0.33577316999435425,
-0.44377148151397705,
-0.1233062893152237,
0.39430099725723267,
0.7536665201187134,
-0.8500366806983948,
0.7463701367378235,
0.41108882427215576,
-0.22567608952522278,
-0.9871900677680969,
-0.6139097809791565,
-0.19987431168556213,
-0.58938068151474,
-0.18722151219844818,
-0.00032658109557814896,
-0.24859265983104706,
-0.19154396653175354,
0.20400767028331757,
-0.012276114895939827,
-0.39683976769447327,
0.1653592586517334,
0.09685114771127701,
0.16073687374591827,
0.0674588680267334,
0.2955969572067261,
0.1740422546863556,
-0.13292290270328522,
-0.06415057182312012,
-0.28145095705986023,
0.674282968044281,
0.20862652361392975,
-0.4397672116756439,
-0.46162936091423035,
0.09034689515829086,
0.5359607934951782,
0.10210402309894562,
0.62572181224823,
0.49862051010131836,
-0.14824716746807098,
-0.5574330687522888,
-0.5952353477478027,
-0.22691743075847626,
-0.4743666350841522,
0.5558203458786011,
-0.25515714287757874,
-0.8642749786376953,
0.5882895588874817,
-0.38189926743507385,
0.3698142170906067,
0.16576410830020905,
0.7652748823165894,
-0.45813846588134766,
0.6516919732093811,
0.6997412443161011,
-0.2498154491186142,
0.19054292142391205,
-0.13574126362800598,
0.4175006151199341,
-0.6742366552352905,
-0.343984454870224,
-0.14942161738872528,
-0.3782927393913269,
-0.17970356345176697,
-0.018283596262335777,
0.1944369524717331,
0.4274711310863495,
-0.3178543448448181,
-0.006530090235173702,
-0.1939428150653839,
0.6158968210220337,
0.6636835932731628,
0.05696042254567146,
0.6633872985839844,
0.055023059248924255,
-0.23644089698791504,
-0.03680949658155441,
-0.6515749096870422,
-0.07944442331790924,
1.3548107147216797,
0.3987790048122406,
1.2082252502441406,
0.002801136579364538,
0.9723773002624512,
0.617648184299469,
0.2474343478679657,
-0.5864925980567932,
0.40793484449386597,
-0.3215217590332031,
-0.3293105661869049,
-0.3533727526664734,
-0.5122687220573425,
-0.8684638142585754,
0.19373084604740143,
0.2857053875923157,
-0.4418276846408844,
0.13101492822170258,
0.571125864982605,
-0.31011053919792175,
0.506841778755188,
-0.6880921721458435,
0.5016594529151917,
0.07856427878141403,
-0.02602459490299225,
-0.25781095027923584,
-0.5716565847396851,
0.6048200130462646,
-0.3862846791744232,
0.17023149132728577,
-0.140990749001503,
0.22459520399570465,
0.6685299277305603,
-0.3644815981388092,
1.2308541536331177,
-0.5714921951293945,
-0.3124861717224121,
0.20198723673820496,
0.20779402554035187,
0.7032326459884644,
-0.09293094277381897,
0.3355174660682678,
0.13811729848384857,
-0.2320495992898941,
-0.06807705014944077,
-0.6648994088172913,
0.6782267689704895,
-0.6630570292472839,
-0.36337172985076904,
0.09874078631401062,
-0.5254480242729187,
-0.1399526298046112,
0.3474574685096741,
0.17640940845012665,
0.024949857965111732,
-0.0966925323009491,
0.28672313690185547,
1.0701000690460205,
-0.18649254739284515,
0.4002969264984131,
0.9561519622802734,
-0.3332013785839081,
-0.2783854901790619,
1.178694248199463,
0.17562264204025269,
0.44626080989837646,
0.5106562376022339,
0.38101789355278015,
-0.5176108479499817,
-0.39913299679756165,
-0.36783289909362793,
0.23835864663124084,
-0.9501146674156189,
-0.40082448720932007,
-0.6934497356414795,
-0.3392317295074463,
-0.20733360946178436,
0.07037977874279022,
-0.7744728922843933,
-0.4129970669746399,
-0.4326612949371338,
-0.004477811977267265,
0.44376063346862793,
0.6629068851470947,
-0.07541926950216293,
0.08038988709449768,
-0.4488685131072998,
0.285434365272522,
0.18504248559474945,
0.4604504406452179,
0.2399449497461319,
-0.7952083349227905,
-0.27861881256103516,
0.2132745385169983,
-0.15029756724834442,
-0.21386349201202393,
0.47998157143592834,
0.1768820881843567,
0.6783211827278137,
0.4379000961780548,
0.35871419310569763,
0.5014787316322327,
-0.3165188729763031,
0.2863476872444153,
0.3158414661884308,
-0.40153682231903076,
0.010853739455342293,
0.06143012270331383,
0.2641889750957489,
0.5171639919281006,
0.29247909784317017,
-0.8839302062988281,
-0.2722172439098358,
-0.46420812606811523,
-1.001619815826416,
0.6639871001243591,
-0.3771059811115265,
-0.09983432292938232,
0.45849108695983887,
0.36347368359565735,
0.49783819913864136,
0.3880310654640198,
-0.5759567022323608,
-0.5582985877990723,
0.06282094866037369,
-0.46631956100463867,
0.0515076220035553,
-0.4241443872451782,
0.009314432740211487,
-0.09887531399726868,
0.8624640107154846,
0.11772695183753967,
-0.011581660248339176,
-0.017195381224155426,
-0.1617189645767212,
0.001233476446941495,
0.3318106234073639,
0.3762100040912628,
0.47014474868774414,
-0.13208024203777313,
0.2150781899690628,
0.23742419481277466,
-0.7370152473449707,
0.37973523139953613,
-0.2856682240962982,
-0.5346581339836121,
-0.1941870003938675,
0.141539067029953,
0.6051999926567078,
0.027485402300953865,
-0.7862634658813477,
0.3731246292591095,
0.03778157755732536,
-0.35643792152404785,
-0.43043142557144165,
-0.047729216516017914,
0.40769898891448975,
0.273188054561615,
0.22004948556423187,
-0.08971100300550461,
-0.12473908066749573,
-0.31407713890075684,
0.4199469983577728,
0.2868770956993103,
-0.4238027036190033,
-0.17159418761730194,
0.40147069096565247,
0.0003686777490656823,
-0.268168181180954,
0.8669829964637756,
-0.19211901724338531,
-0.28014278411865234,
0.24225082993507385,
0.3673691749572754,
1.0265477895736694,
-0.3495394289493561,
0.1443435251712799,
0.16100630164146423,
-0.1353965699672699,
-0.14941459894180298,
0.2529253363609314,
0.0276334285736084,
-0.8218519687652588,
-0.315680593252182,
-0.7238820791244507,
-0.061957377940416336,
0.21732202172279358,
-0.5926985740661621,
0.01578165404498577,
-0.43107369542121887,
0.24532975256443024,
-0.24566006660461426,
-0.164941668510437,
-0.6002556681632996,
-0.06731266528367996,
-0.23015396296977997,
0.6809444427490234,
-0.7311141490936279,
1.0781177282333374,
0.16762344539165497,
-0.17655862867832184,
-0.5190707445144653,
-0.0038262351881712675,
0.12800949811935425,
-0.9507949352264404,
1.1386754512786865,
-0.25278687477111816,
-0.19524994492530823,
0.35621559619903564,
-0.18296441435813904,
-0.7332050800323486,
1.3540446758270264,
0.34319937229156494,
-0.7281866073608398,
0.001031296094879508,
0.33178484439849854,
0.257090300321579,
-0.3001610040664673,
-0.18120458722114563,
0.5742447376251221,
0.25443628430366516,
0.2395356446504593,
-0.6298683285713196,
-0.2469145655632019,
0.17454372346401215,
-0.23342788219451904,
0.3320944607257843,
-0.5268616676330566,
0.9227334856987,
-0.33550184965133667,
-0.37340641021728516,
-0.010824237018823624,
0.44331613183021545,
0.24971026182174683,
0.38306453824043274,
0.3995037078857422,
0.8595705032348633,
0.9948086142539978,
0.15027591586112976,
0.5777458548545837,
0.01065108273178339,
0.676893413066864,
1.525681734085083,
-0.3254638612270355,
0.6976292133331299,
0.5524424314498901,
-0.29269298911094666,
0.2650655508041382,
0.32528164982795715,
0.27131861448287964,
0.9757899641990662,
0.1690046340227127,
-0.45977768301963806,
-0.09024755656719208,
0.1001761257648468,
-0.12870508432388306,
0.2516056299209595,
0.17729324102401733,
-0.34879016876220703,
-0.6180511116981506,
0.30377328395843506,
0.14125652611255646,
0.1982278674840927,
-0.1962280124425888,
1.0742437839508057,
-0.05379973724484444,
-0.4652273952960968,
0.6771547794342041,
-0.0250648595392704,
0.5611743927001953,
-0.55641108751297,
-0.1312822848558426,
-0.548419177532196,
0.6969044804573059,
0.014754483476281166,
-0.832527220249176,
0.17367179691791534,
-0.27508407831192017,
-0.5250643491744995,
-0.24918769299983978,
0.8234660625457764,
-0.7383792400360107,
-0.4166252315044403,
0.30562353134155273,
0.5175434947013855,
0.049676887691020966,
0.0856737419962883,
-0.7799930572509766,
-0.18802236020565033,
0.3176423907279968,
-0.35209909081459045,
0.46558865904808044,
0.46489888429641724,
0.07396221905946732,
1.2002638578414917,
0.4834637939929962,
0.07737773656845093,
0.2090880274772644,
0.25807440280914307,
0.9546034336090088,
-0.5639044642448425,
-0.41144299507141113,
-1.0160340070724487,
0.4645477831363678,
0.03419101983308792,
-0.0972665324807167,
0.8590639233589172,
0.6167810559272766,
0.9390629529953003,
-0.17978963255882263,
0.9610685110092163,
0.0566675029695034,
1.193811058998108,
-0.585808277130127,
1.0534480810165405,
-0.464830219745636,
0.34951505064964294,
0.028834940865635872,
-0.5824328660964966,
-0.20573759078979492,
0.08066460490226746,
0.041917700320482254,
0.0027409091126173735,
0.3427194058895111,
0.7542851567268372,
-0.1953926384449005,
-0.23179557919502258,
0.5715377330780029,
0.4549283981323242,
0.5033077001571655,
0.4155671298503876,
0.8362418413162231,
-0.10674577951431274,
0.41374462842941284,
-0.3663243055343628,
-0.07681392878293991,
-0.3181713819503784,
-0.7993939518928528,
-0.8880462646484375,
-0.7150294780731201,
-0.2077312469482422,
-0.2214997559785843,
0.1105148047208786,
0.7595818042755127,
0.4607905447483063,
-0.6733747720718384,
-0.13535627722740173,
-0.31531161069869995,
0.26728615164756775,
-0.09686585515737534,
-0.2210199534893036,
0.41821256279945374,
-0.35612261295318604,
-0.4514019787311554,
0.305366575717926,
0.31137216091156006,
0.1543319821357727,
-0.7026355862617493,
-0.4223126173019409,
-0.19819778203964233,
-0.24582965672016144,
0.4091576039791107,
0.6711675524711609,
-0.7965208292007446,
0.07973304390907288,
-0.37790095806121826,
0.15030892193317413,
-0.1329926699399948,
0.925644040107727,
-0.8380029201507568,
0.566863477230072,
0.4309011399745941,
0.8734927773475647,
0.3713839054107666,
0.06932742893695831,
0.49066346883773804,
-1.123125433921814,
0.09512180089950562,
0.1935071349143982,
0.24474728107452393,
0.24568158388137817,
-0.4632757008075714,
0.2158336639404297,
0.27435532212257385,
-0.652453601360321,
-0.9315198063850403,
0.34331077337265015,
-0.4919995963573456,
-0.6539671421051025,
0.864195704460144,
-0.40643569827079773,
-0.08719323575496674,
-0.4325442910194397,
-0.18361207842826843,
0.12132806330919266,
-0.3675891160964966,
1.0046435594558716,
0.6496568322181702,
-0.025974085554480553,
-0.22068548202514648,
-0.4592297375202179,
0.5946226716041565,
0.2328995019197464,
-0.4192834198474884,
1.0613688230514526,
0.2736135423183441,
0.5490094423294067,
-0.10258154571056366,
0.7321869134902954,
-0.04995991289615631,
-0.04799982160329819,
-0.2691941261291504,
0.1949903815984726,
-0.40645304322242737,
-0.5064587593078613,
-0.28517526388168335,
0.07351554930210114,
0.15648016333580017,
0.03094826638698578
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.01981v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.01981v1
|
Zyda: A 1.3T Dataset for Open Language Modeling
| 2024-06-04T05:47:17 | 2024-06-04T05:47:17 |
Yury Tokpanov, Beren Millidge, Paolo Glorioso, Jonathan Pilault, Adam Ibrahim, James Whittington, Quentin Anthony
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The size of large language models (LLMs) has scaled dramatically in recent
years and their computational and data requirements have surged
correspondingly. State-of-the-art language models, even at relatively smaller
sizes, typically require training on at least a trillion tokens. This rapid
advancement has eclipsed the growth of open-source datasets available for
large-scale LLM pretraining. In this paper, we introduce Zyda (Zyphra Dataset),
a dataset under a permissive license comprising 1.3 trillion tokens, assembled
by integrating several major respected open-source datasets into a single,
high-quality corpus. We apply rigorous filtering and deduplication processes,
both within and across datasets, to maintain and enhance the quality derived
from the original datasets. Our evaluations show that Zyda not only competes
favorably with other open datasets like Dolma, FineWeb, and RefinedWeb, but
also substantially improves the performance of comparable models from the
Pythia suite. Our rigorous data processing methods significantly enhance Zyda's
effectiveness, outperforming even the best of its constituent datasets when
used independently.
|
[
-0.15167641639709473,
-0.42801162600517273,
0.44328317046165466,
0.1337701678276062,
-0.593012809753418,
-0.18209858238697052,
-0.37610629200935364,
-0.2968771755695343,
-0.00321867479942739,
0.5560095310211182,
-0.23539896309375763,
-0.6645797491073608,
-0.3327913284301758,
-0.17635786533355713,
-0.43687182664871216,
0.8815597295761108,
-0.13916528224945068,
0.0913948267698288,
0.11087219417095184,
-0.259782612323761,
-0.07716091722249985,
-0.5177850723266602,
-0.06537123769521713,
-0.09776990115642548,
0.843200147151947,
0.47415316104888916,
0.9694143533706665,
0.966991126537323,
0.35418978333473206,
0.098648801445961,
0.08155780285596848,
0.046712476760149,
-0.5748355984687805,
0.037746623158454895,
-0.21814267337322235,
-0.2603193521499634,
-0.3671073913574219,
0.11849229782819748,
0.9516591429710388,
0.8733046650886536,
-0.38000351190567017,
0.42062878608703613,
-0.2446291744709015,
0.7182222008705139,
-0.8455480933189392,
0.020512308925390244,
-0.605363130569458,
-0.13111461699008942,
-0.6559175252914429,
0.14416569471359253,
-0.010883081704378128,
-0.5941625237464905,
0.05786368250846863,
-0.6296983957290649,
0.055981606245040894,
-0.13534493744373322,
0.5646994709968567,
0.09190220385789871,
-0.09540881961584091,
-0.07502947002649307,
-0.7974767684936523,
0.592911422252655,
-0.762938380241394,
0.5074880123138428,
0.1682121902704239,
0.15607355535030365,
-0.274838924407959,
-0.6577128171920776,
-0.7444802522659302,
-0.08017423748970032,
0.3912428915500641,
-0.330291211605072,
-0.25212299823760986,
0.14262136816978455,
0.15817350149154663,
0.6404209136962891,
-0.6764243245124817,
0.44063594937324524,
-0.5861786007881165,
0.0770583227276802,
0.42605704069137573,
0.044922541826963425,
0.5289917588233948,
0.36450979113578796,
-0.23378635942935944,
-0.16241303086280823,
-1.1361193656921387,
-0.22873328626155853,
0.7157663106918335,
0.8257655501365662,
0.026421453803777695,
0.6165507435798645,
-0.5857365131378174,
0.7341503500938416,
-0.6862912774085999,
0.10352417081594467,
0.35140424966812134,
-0.21905356645584106,
-0.3913564383983612,
0.11704157292842865,
0.8375946283340454,
-0.0011757633183151484,
0.5313454270362854,
-0.24941521883010864,
-0.11981742829084396,
0.036353759467601776,
0.044459715485572815,
-1.028425931930542,
-0.2950724959373474,
0.48539796471595764,
-0.45463287830352783,
-0.11842433363199234,
0.19511790573596954,
-0.7214143872261047,
-0.3096247911453247,
-0.5504242777824402,
0.2268364429473877,
-0.1279486119747162,
-0.6415168642997742,
0.34652265906333923,
0.2009001225233078,
0.005785495508462191,
0.11776763945817947,
-0.9506077170372009,
0.2882007658481598,
0.6952183246612549,
1.078199863433838,
-0.016025258228182793,
-0.3997528851032257,
-0.5963413715362549,
-0.23219533264636993,
-0.8165266513824463,
0.4581409990787506,
-0.35728392004966736,
-0.08994227647781372,
0.12064779549837112,
-0.22132667899131775,
0.0851019024848938,
-0.5945173501968384,
0.3363806903362274,
-0.7916061878204346,
-0.07148779183626175,
-0.1288330852985382,
-0.5604625344276428,
0.09740229696035385,
-0.23069652915000916,
-0.9204123616218567,
0.6331236958503723,
0.5365674495697021,
-0.7169800996780396,
0.48209714889526367,
-0.3202974200248718,
-0.09043575823307037,
0.2784038186073303,
-0.1966954916715622,
-0.14450520277023315,
0.20082631707191467,
0.11994786560535431,
0.10803613811731339,
-0.4596148133277893,
0.19632694125175476,
-0.3807482421398163,
-0.364346981048584,
-0.07002123445272446,
-0.2686959207057953,
0.9027270674705505,
0.4036319851875305,
0.10957284271717072,
0.47044846415519714,
-0.9519425630569458,
0.21164225041866302,
-0.042707882821559906,
-0.36560091376304626,
-0.4079653322696686,
-0.13431012630462646,
0.18484804034233093,
0.46431535482406616,
0.2218666523694992,
-0.9096590280532837,
0.21565043926239014,
-0.48848864436149597,
0.31420040130615234,
0.7354573011398315,
-0.38376349210739136,
0.19754035770893097,
-0.18172359466552734,
0.5569841265678406,
0.16766078770160675,
0.051559362560510635,
0.008732355199754238,
-0.3007395267486572,
-0.3644719421863556,
-0.5496452450752258,
0.4727367162704468,
0.25609543919563293,
-0.5245698690414429,
0.4389083981513977,
-0.5425460338592529,
-0.7365195155143738,
-0.754728376865387,
0.47402799129486084,
0.16753071546554565,
0.1485976129770279,
0.3372974693775177,
-0.14598412811756134,
-0.5926480889320374,
-0.7950480580329895,
0.007676995359361172,
-0.12195300310850143,
-0.2470124512910843,
-0.18359680473804474,
0.23110496997833252,
0.06339710205793381,
1.0735418796539307,
-0.23612219095230103,
-0.2912902235984802,
-0.45786064863204956,
-0.16540120542049408,
0.49604174494743347,
0.4831930696964264,
0.39197808504104614,
-0.40189412236213684,
-0.393609881401062,
0.1593417376279831,
-0.583069920539856,
-0.1630636602640152,
0.16394297778606415,
-0.08122525364160538,
0.17585806548595428,
0.36018332839012146,
-0.7632347941398621,
0.27340540289878845,
0.7410373091697693,
-0.4440159201622009,
0.5976248383522034,
-0.37892723083496094,
-0.2717629075050354,
-0.9195829629898071,
0.3295634686946869,
-0.18344996869564056,
-0.09496906399726868,
-0.6849778294563293,
0.1537550836801529,
0.16637425124645233,
0.011050577275454998,
-0.5530187487602234,
0.7224896550178528,
-0.25752800703048706,
-0.25674229860305786,
-0.284028559923172,
0.14032475650310516,
-0.41164425015449524,
0.24027937650680542,
-0.07800925523042679,
0.9893768429756165,
0.6048312187194824,
-0.48729997873306274,
0.4847353994846344,
0.3632833659648895,
-1.0173109769821167,
-0.09190414845943451,
-0.6052795648574829,
0.1899208128452301,
-0.14156895875930786,
0.09832211583852768,
-0.5986427664756775,
-0.1251591444015503,
0.18845587968826294,
-0.07988298684358597,
-0.13689567148685455,
-0.09965088963508606,
-0.7775294780731201,
-0.14259088039398193,
-0.2964582145214081,
0.3604755401611328,
0.4039241373538971,
-0.8816063404083252,
0.23409193754196167,
0.21484579145908356,
-0.4097815454006195,
-0.7248311638832092,
-0.30999085307121277,
-0.0076996078714728355,
-0.0299492459744215,
-0.248624786734581,
0.20153193175792694,
-0.055477388203144073,
-0.4326426386833191,
-0.019152499735355377,
0.044127218425273895,
0.01976432092487812,
0.10602977126836777,
0.17311100661754608,
0.40371131896972656,
-0.4706769287586212,
0.29913628101348877,
-0.28545480966567993,
0.0018987689400091767,
-0.08642136305570602,
-0.4046144485473633,
0.8105565309524536,
0.18649400770664215,
-0.1872129738330841,
-0.6187480688095093,
0.04918015003204346,
0.7379769682884216,
-0.2771490514278412,
0.9894223809242249,
0.2571506202220917,
-0.39943164587020874,
-0.46287810802459717,
-0.10966257750988007,
0.28749656677246094,
-0.373663991689682,
0.3904310166835785,
-0.26502376794815063,
-0.6441808938980103,
0.3688252568244934,
0.32580870389938354,
0.2677517831325531,
0.290661484003067,
0.5533133149147034,
0.3695131838321686,
0.6902980208396912,
0.47724461555480957,
-0.7231153249740601,
0.6389597654342651,
0.018565945327281952,
0.2739467918872833,
-0.5399174094200134,
-0.006052390206605196,
-0.7171968221664429,
-0.03561362996697426,
-0.494651734828949,
-0.5219855308532715,
-0.18430985510349274,
0.33332452178001404,
-0.408661425113678,
0.11566890776157379,
0.11944104731082916,
0.6070699691772461,
0.6197882294654846,
-0.0450676828622818,
0.47315096855163574,
0.278200626373291,
0.14400134980678558,
0.34374669194221497,
-0.6321750283241272,
-0.780726432800293,
1.5767436027526855,
0.4439614415168762,
0.8223649263381958,
0.2522309720516205,
0.4645228087902069,
0.06048739701509476,
0.44033464789390564,
-0.6286109089851379,
0.3425610363483429,
-0.3605051338672638,
-0.5656677484512329,
-0.5996639728546143,
-0.6331163048744202,
-0.8796218037605286,
0.39966264367103577,
-0.008150052279233932,
-0.6169257164001465,
0.11860403418540955,
-0.06668650358915329,
-0.5268341302871704,
0.6359459757804871,
-0.3306640088558197,
0.7009752988815308,
0.0765751525759697,
-0.43430066108703613,
-0.40676864981651306,
-0.24391260743141174,
0.29953867197036743,
-0.21211308240890503,
0.1353098303079605,
-0.469892680644989,
-0.009784577414393425,
0.7210506200790405,
-0.6374992728233337,
0.4132414758205414,
-0.3234606981277466,
-0.5441851019859314,
0.286322683095932,
-0.052496109157800674,
0.2779529392719269,
-0.10591144859790802,
-0.2442651391029358,
0.2781154215335846,
0.17568917572498322,
-0.46252137422561646,
-0.3981865644454956,
0.7483395338058472,
-0.9346850514411926,
-0.255317360162735,
-0.2450018674135208,
-0.5589720606803894,
-0.3021187484264374,
0.310923308134079,
-0.01099773496389389,
0.6518114805221558,
-0.36122584342956543,
0.2437838315963745,
0.6028270125389099,
-0.3014317750930786,
0.14149703085422516,
0.36025887727737427,
-0.5252753496170044,
-0.3888469636440277,
1.0166997909545898,
0.2901870310306549,
0.21011348068714142,
0.11842750012874603,
0.10884135961532593,
-0.2936326861381531,
-0.9971674680709839,
-0.5724631547927856,
0.2465265542268753,
-0.7318478226661682,
-0.21433359384536743,
-0.5120497345924377,
-0.19207264482975006,
-0.5125851631164551,
0.412527859210968,
-0.31546926498413086,
-0.5599287748336792,
-0.3461509943008423,
-0.2312663197517395,
0.2287372201681137,
0.8397789001464844,
-0.10477247834205627,
0.4243668019771576,
-0.7653393745422363,
0.46975988149642944,
0.2410624474287033,
0.8313848972320557,
0.04897615686058998,
-0.2614474892616272,
-0.31675204634666443,
0.021412398666143417,
0.19086723029613495,
-0.3814127743244171,
0.4560120105743408,
0.1694619059562683,
0.6627829670906067,
0.42379114031791687,
-0.09694547206163406,
0.2989831566810608,
-0.34149909019470215,
0.6071662306785583,
-0.001683385344222188,
-0.7403643131256104,
0.29456135630607605,
-0.5411878228187561,
0.20762574672698975,
0.5721177458763123,
0.42153167724609375,
-0.45379531383514404,
-0.058931879699230194,
-0.3308753967285156,
-0.7601898908615112,
0.8583470582962036,
0.17171689867973328,
0.24368762969970703,
0.05798351392149925,
0.4311273396015167,
0.2709360122680664,
0.17520810663700104,
-0.29647091031074524,
-0.11595532298088074,
-0.13152649998664856,
-0.6370695233345032,
-0.3344323933124542,
-0.23797693848609924,
0.0922919288277626,
-0.15160903334617615,
0.8262874484062195,
-0.0682545006275177,
-0.32011330127716064,
-0.06618353724479675,
-0.35330766439437866,
-0.19943487644195557,
0.21466729044914246,
0.34800833463668823,
1.1025539636611938,
-0.48174333572387695,
-0.028122741729021072,
-0.2969129979610443,
-0.658008873462677,
0.159012570977211,
0.17591939866542816,
0.03558081015944481,
0.029854558408260345,
0.3277173936367035,
0.6645045876502991,
-0.2516058087348938,
-1.0561715364456177,
0.32577207684516907,
0.024819405749440193,
-0.06830952316522598,
0.09126067161560059,
0.09947024285793304,
-0.043367162346839905,
0.09872405230998993,
0.3479178249835968,
-0.5114688873291016,
-0.15385383367538452,
-0.5627259016036987,
0.13343998789787292,
0.08432777225971222,
-0.0818869024515152,
-0.4066982865333557,
0.334407240152359,
-0.05538482964038849,
0.11879025399684906,
0.9882446527481079,
0.24636447429656982,
-0.15036284923553467,
0.468117892742157,
0.27438387274742126,
0.5066426992416382,
-0.33337604999542236,
0.16344518959522247,
0.5795605778694153,
0.2116887867450714,
-0.4442846477031708,
0.6473262906074524,
-0.014137941412627697,
-0.828366756439209,
-0.09067413955926895,
-0.881070077419281,
-0.5118572115898132,
0.487240731716156,
-0.45928382873535156,
0.18027125298976898,
-0.757703423500061,
0.09872616082429886,
-0.13887478411197662,
0.21040895581245422,
-0.633103609085083,
0.20305059850215912,
0.2602370083332062,
1.1826967000961304,
-0.6678481698036194,
1.2111629247665405,
0.18725834786891937,
-0.5035012364387512,
-0.4735255837440491,
-0.19007840752601624,
-0.32606425881385803,
-0.5430095195770264,
0.5945997834205627,
0.13487887382507324,
-0.13298429548740387,
0.17063304781913757,
-0.4315992295742035,
-0.994813859462738,
0.7891045808792114,
0.6425796151161194,
-0.8747803568840027,
-0.13369916379451752,
0.2468157708644867,
0.5251927971839905,
-0.36940017342567444,
-0.18641997873783112,
0.789476215839386,
0.1159796491265297,
-0.20281001925468445,
-0.8549756407737732,
-0.09419453144073486,
-0.1640262007713318,
0.09084150940179825,
0.06633090227842331,
-0.34565234184265137,
1.1152209043502808,
-0.27106064558029175,
-0.3870212733745575,
0.4810907542705536,
0.6977913975715637,
0.38508176803588867,
-0.20654377341270447,
0.40270429849624634,
0.5209436416625977,
0.9193387627601624,
0.1409917026758194,
0.8624389171600342,
-0.3066857159137726,
0.18411849439144135,
1.553857445716858,
-0.49303436279296875,
1.1698592901229858,
0.3487280309200287,
-0.2974541187286377,
0.4920220971107483,
0.5435630679130554,
0.18327677249908447,
0.4626927077770233,
0.5627018213272095,
-0.30789127945899963,
-0.20313487946987152,
-0.036450594663619995,
-0.3495336174964905,
0.35556408762931824,
0.29868608713150024,
-0.33971208333969116,
-0.3442169427871704,
-0.011013756506145,
-0.2297016680240631,
0.054458267986774445,
-0.42770859599113464,
0.4919807016849518,
-0.0979730486869812,
-0.33332550525665283,
0.34058117866516113,
-0.08639401942491531,
0.4844125509262085,
-0.7141794562339783,
0.13433422148227692,
-0.419274240732193,
0.2795172929763794,
-0.1064855232834816,
-0.5573672652244568,
-0.030580658465623856,
0.06742043793201447,
0.021041374653577805,
-0.06158113107085228,
0.34691545367240906,
-0.5567099452018738,
-0.5003683567047119,
0.27439022064208984,
0.5870708227157593,
0.24676275253295898,
-0.25478681921958923,
-0.0818009302020073,
0.2581011950969696,
-0.5023705363273621,
-0.40692731738090515,
0.396832138299942,
0.29746589064598083,
-0.16352874040603638,
0.7199141383171082,
0.851713240146637,
0.603508472442627,
0.1037239134311676,
0.39770522713661194,
1.0308215618133545,
-0.6758944392204285,
-0.5796027779579163,
-0.6351414322853088,
-0.03539421036839485,
0.17605511844158173,
-0.33894774317741394,
0.5967937707901001,
0.6722639799118042,
0.9950069785118103,
0.056593216955661774,
0.9165916442871094,
0.13092009723186493,
0.6603416204452515,
-0.6553670763969421,
0.9256579279899597,
-0.211432084441185,
0.025122394785284996,
0.15643304586410522,
-0.9688210487365723,
-0.3722119629383087,
0.47982773184776306,
-0.08950980752706528,
0.01059611327946186,
0.20623323321342468,
0.7233905792236328,
-0.13832440972328186,
0.1194302961230278,
0.4602717161178589,
0.13914252817630768,
0.4869976043701172,
0.40242302417755127,
0.8569081425666809,
-0.24867703020572662,
0.12033898383378983,
-0.19454960525035858,
-0.1514740139245987,
-0.03937319666147232,
-0.654321551322937,
-0.8170604705810547,
-0.5379436612129211,
-0.08959891647100449,
-0.1059800535440445,
0.02565442956984043,
1.5383275747299194,
0.7205252647399902,
-0.9450135827064514,
-0.4502505362033844,
-0.1307615488767624,
0.01921432837843895,
-0.1363145112991333,
-0.0658370852470398,
0.36449718475341797,
-0.5229119062423706,
-0.6640059351921082,
0.6551886796951294,
-0.057403333485126495,
0.18717749416828156,
-0.6634343266487122,
0.027603937312960625,
-0.1386137306690216,
0.1248730793595314,
0.4632999300956726,
0.3069649636745453,
-0.45064669847488403,
-0.0315171554684639,
-0.5405965447425842,
-0.1687089502811432,
0.1795666217803955,
0.9633855223655701,
-0.8970203995704651,
0.4168824255466461,
0.5408623218536377,
0.4601387679576874,
0.1226719543337822,
-0.1558084785938263,
0.7478609681129456,
-0.3503003418445587,
0.2597492039203644,
0.019045600667595863,
0.3355734944343567,
0.39382559061050415,
-0.026000678539276123,
0.43077701330184937,
-0.11109764128923416,
-0.14771738648414612,
-1.0306870937347412,
-0.11939895153045654,
-0.5615687966346741,
-0.4159907102584839,
1.0361207723617554,
-0.31242501735687256,
-0.20511458814144135,
-0.24154342710971832,
-0.02110177092254162,
0.3664247989654541,
-0.26235342025756836,
0.6892009377479553,
0.7880972623825073,
0.5182161331176758,
0.021607011556625366,
-0.6091117858886719,
0.5697891116142273,
0.0038357458543032408,
-0.8770870566368103,
0.7928296327590942,
0.5539439916610718,
0.5162544250488281,
-0.14077125489711761,
0.759412407875061,
-0.1546986848115921,
0.18391379714012146,
-0.04985189810395241,
0.04660265892744064,
-0.33305856585502625,
-0.7268268465995789,
-0.8380553126335144,
0.3622283339500427,
0.31882333755493164,
-0.20232117176055908
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.01976v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.01976v1
|
Conditional Language Learning with Context
| 2024-06-04T05:22:24 | 2024-06-04T05:22:24 |
Xiao Zhang, Miao Li, Ji Wu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Language models can learn sophisticated language understanding skills from
fitting raw text. They also unselectively learn useless corpus statistics and
biases, especially during finetuning on domain-specific corpora. In this paper,
we propose a simple modification to causal language modeling called conditional
finetuning, which performs language modeling conditioned on a context. We show
that a context can "explain away" certain corpus statistics and make the model
avoid learning them. In this fashion, conditional finetuning achieves selective
learning from a corpus, learning knowledge useful for downstream tasks while
avoiding learning useless corpus statistics like topic biases. This selective
learning effect leads to less forgetting and better stability-plasticity
tradeoff in domain finetuning, potentially benefitting lifelong learning with
language models.
|
[
-0.28568145632743835,
-0.9701873660087585,
0.5652381181716919,
-0.0688851848244667,
-0.1488964557647705,
-0.43985724449157715,
-0.5283544659614563,
-0.27503812313079834,
-0.15383027493953705,
0.6957738399505615,
-0.6767374277114868,
-0.3586706519126892,
-0.5334502458572388,
0.0045389411970973015,
-0.32583075761795044,
1.238147258758545,
0.1259341537952423,
0.2823565602302551,
-0.09891414642333984,
-0.11650961637496948,
-0.7158312201499939,
-0.3203571140766144,
-1.1216312646865845,
-0.34556442499160767,
0.6040465235710144,
0.5227985382080078,
0.531861424446106,
0.30082079768180847,
0.0807562842965126,
0.29952555894851685,
0.27316373586654663,
-0.1739899218082428,
-0.8915044069290161,
0.13454872369766235,
-0.5859266519546509,
-0.7766727805137634,
-0.11432908475399017,
0.09172219783067703,
0.5175095796585083,
1.312912940979004,
0.18214969336986542,
-0.21149858832359314,
0.28235381841659546,
0.7277425527572632,
-0.48745065927505493,
0.3347070813179016,
-0.8974012136459351,
-0.09643618762493134,
-0.010560369119048119,
-0.49614477157592773,
-0.599342942237854,
0.01212373934686184,
0.41081684827804565,
-0.5394097566604614,
0.42723169922828674,
-0.10568647086620331,
0.8502747416496277,
0.5567803382873535,
-0.5337077975273132,
0.006311631761491299,
-0.6525363326072693,
0.8919938802719116,
-0.3008367419242859,
0.582215428352356,
0.8450416326522827,
0.36199507117271423,
-0.016537237912416458,
-0.6472498178482056,
-0.4185634255409241,
-0.23711583018302917,
-0.45294809341430664,
0.1544259637594223,
-0.0027602636255323887,
0.181772843003273,
0.20858831703662872,
0.06522472202777863,
-0.39273327589035034,
0.01239841990172863,
-0.6032615900039673,
-0.3416749835014343,
0.18364770710468292,
-0.05395470932126045,
0.498690128326416,
-0.10245972871780396,
-0.329355388879776,
0.03862304240465164,
-0.8542786836624146,
0.13938148319721222,
0.08422908931970596,
0.5044227838516235,
-0.27934232354164124,
0.30533066391944885,
-0.22133970260620117,
0.748679518699646,
0.23462609946727753,
-0.07984185218811035,
-0.08601130545139313,
-0.07032673060894012,
-0.47599855065345764,
-0.1296909600496292,
0.17330360412597656,
0.06167169660329819,
0.35757511854171753,
-0.5568561553955078,
-0.2546809911727905,
0.16600079834461212,
0.13970288634300232,
-0.6939693689346313,
-0.19751569628715515,
0.23884907364845276,
-0.32313281297683716,
0.12406273186206818,
-0.29303568601608276,
-0.33123472332954407,
0.031154368072748184,
-0.8504573106765747,
0.4400877058506012,
-0.7992293238639832,
0.03479597717523575,
0.06662924587726593,
-0.18068650364875793,
0.030421879142522812,
0.2698681950569153,
-1.005374550819397,
0.5052547454833984,
0.5578300952911377,
0.43034395575523376,
-0.21262188255786896,
-0.46843233704566956,
-0.8977400064468384,
0.10515270382165909,
-0.3075855076313019,
0.6473667621612549,
-0.4455503523349762,
-0.04798314720392227,
-0.03930371254682541,
0.3083413541316986,
-0.08010201901197433,
-0.36068040132522583,
0.30523186922073364,
-0.8219881057739258,
0.20954187214374542,
-0.15859852731227875,
-0.5817975997924805,
-0.435786634683609,
-0.24520540237426758,
-0.6972770094871521,
0.26653650403022766,
0.3112005591392517,
-0.655837893486023,
0.9084054827690125,
-0.01871860958635807,
-0.6399393081665039,
-0.15345612168312073,
-0.13169991970062256,
-0.21418416500091553,
-0.14516668021678925,
-0.27993881702423096,
0.6795989274978638,
-0.005215795710682869,
0.8011045455932617,
-0.463634192943573,
-0.2592548727989197,
0.02975299581885338,
-0.5499012470245361,
0.7599013447761536,
0.4222654402256012,
-0.33328962326049805,
0.15111972391605377,
-0.7073694467544556,
-0.4701274037361145,
-0.2094939649105072,
-0.32166925072669983,
-0.8172467947006226,
0.20207373797893524,
0.03999670594930649,
0.22658860683441162,
-0.08096444606781006,
-0.16304263472557068,
-0.10520803928375244,
-0.5873393416404724,
0.11468829959630966,
0.500649631023407,
0.10480092465877533,
0.9796664118766785,
-0.35751065611839294,
0.23546528816223145,
0.046964097768068314,
-0.24143333733081818,
0.1927720159292221,
-0.2712526023387909,
-0.9069943428039551,
-0.42926549911499023,
0.34601470828056335,
0.6423512697219849,
-0.9977817535400391,
0.00892418622970581,
0.021047871559858322,
0.12758465111255646,
-0.07963293790817261,
0.41037052869796753,
0.6228095293045044,
0.6773551106452942,
0.46282219886779785,
-0.11957398802042007,
-0.8083489537239075,
-0.8301105499267578,
-0.25175002217292786,
0.29171550273895264,
-0.06066446378827095,
0.024820595979690552,
0.3483468294143677,
-0.3059839606285095,
0.9766427874565125,
-0.3234840929508209,
-0.3383995592594147,
-0.42160066962242126,
-0.04970753937959671,
0.06416134536266327,
0.599547266960144,
0.8171238899230957,
-0.9667140245437622,
-0.3634907007217407,
-0.175583153963089,
-0.4404536783695221,
-0.2032310515642166,
-0.46074652671813965,
-0.20320339500904083,
0.38891321420669556,
0.8087016940116882,
-0.3961355686187744,
0.3293343484401703,
0.4711003303527832,
-0.5368965268135071,
0.21595589816570282,
-0.23459866642951965,
-0.08923406898975372,
-0.613173246383667,
0.053438086062669754,
0.0372963473200798,
-0.393366277217865,
-0.7056257128715515,
-0.12851384282112122,
0.09599395096302032,
-0.042972929775714874,
-0.6209315061569214,
1.004293441772461,
-0.379381000995636,
0.20000524818897247,
-0.30577775835990906,
0.0864589661359787,
-0.11412306129932404,
0.6926081776618958,
0.5202720761299133,
0.5162745714187622,
0.6048077344894409,
-1.053051233291626,
-0.5038115382194519,
0.11814235150814056,
-0.27430519461631775,
0.34944814443588257,
-0.34649160504341125,
-0.4494550824165344,
-0.33430811762809753,
0.08574320375919342,
-0.8334166407585144,
-0.22943636775016785,
0.026203354820609093,
-0.3332552909851074,
0.5652304887771606,
-0.31983643770217896,
0.0545654222369194,
0.08594907820224762,
0.043625473976135254,
0.18572036921977997,
0.4155183732509613,
-0.5301305651664734,
0.37272173166275024,
0.5053532123565674,
-0.1631455421447754,
-0.5241352915763855,
-0.7041915059089661,
-0.39251989126205444,
-0.3436381220817566,
-0.28878602385520935,
0.4888724684715271,
-0.21965010464191437,
-0.3763159513473511,
0.03661796823143959,
-0.09858304262161255,
-0.3444080948829651,
0.2928217053413391,
0.19606496393680573,
0.24035409092903137,
-0.08036090433597565,
0.36117810010910034,
0.25678035616874695,
-0.33966952562332153,
-0.15984545648097992,
-0.36852774024009705,
0.4800984859466553,
0.17893414199352264,
0.11905010044574738,
-0.18594667315483093,
0.3219173848628998,
0.2245844602584839,
0.06980385631322861,
0.9172916412353516,
0.551256000995636,
-0.5045703649520874,
-0.4672727584838867,
-0.35840123891830444,
-0.46828776597976685,
-0.47420722246170044,
0.24746592342853546,
-0.6058103442192078,
-1.0554616451263428,
0.40610116720199585,
0.1082192212343216,
-0.09680597484111786,
0.5595995187759399,
0.6159605383872986,
0.11776785552501678,
0.859807014465332,
1.0451228618621826,
-0.01508402545005083,
0.6419752240180969,
-0.12908728420734406,
0.10911838710308075,
-0.242873877286911,
0.09975962340831757,
-0.2414826899766922,
0.17002643644809723,
-0.6128215193748474,
-0.14357605576515198,
-0.09323686361312866,
0.39376339316368103,
-0.45239704847335815,
0.356080025434494,
-0.1098581999540329,
0.5128535032272339,
0.5237568020820618,
0.3045618236064911,
0.1617525964975357,
0.15849778056144714,
-0.3293464779853821,
0.17306333780288696,
-0.7795847654342651,
-0.3862413763999939,
1.007941484451294,
0.06184574216604233,
0.5498524308204651,
0.04255538061261177,
0.6016625165939331,
0.09286459535360336,
0.49484938383102417,
-0.6637520790100098,
0.2230653017759323,
-0.36165571212768555,
-0.7125989198684692,
-0.44056934118270874,
-0.43092459440231323,
-1.0635968446731567,
0.17110493779182434,
-0.30120015144348145,
-0.7256935834884644,
0.3807476758956909,
0.3806898295879364,
-0.5245339274406433,
0.09293094277381897,
-0.9701070785522461,
0.808510422706604,
0.125448077917099,
-0.6033810973167419,
-0.4445740282535553,
-0.5953468084335327,
0.49861598014831543,
-0.260852187871933,
0.4749634265899658,
-0.030745606869459152,
0.19530744850635529,
0.6911295652389526,
-0.31171250343322754,
1.3863760232925415,
-0.1711832731962204,
0.1293598711490631,
0.298542320728302,
0.3605441451072693,
0.19599375128746033,
0.3671332001686096,
-0.11846934258937836,
-0.2219189703464508,
0.2147323340177536,
-0.4957237243652344,
-0.24752755463123322,
0.8549132347106934,
-0.6474277973175049,
-0.6715596914291382,
-0.08056773245334625,
-0.4498046338558197,
-0.3737776279449463,
0.39886486530303955,
0.3297904133796692,
0.3307688236236572,
-0.34667685627937317,
0.013843366876244545,
0.713640570640564,
-0.31104812026023865,
0.3212011158466339,
0.7734788060188293,
0.08711166679859161,
-0.1835760772228241,
0.8312366604804993,
0.022305386140942574,
0.45773348212242126,
0.6398047208786011,
0.2186240255832672,
-0.058579910546541214,
-0.2320064753293991,
-0.04128095135092735,
0.24216659367084503,
-0.9339630007743835,
-0.14785601198673248,
-0.6722370982170105,
-0.06509234011173248,
-0.3722752630710602,
-0.47185641527175903,
-0.0736892819404602,
-0.4868465065956116,
-0.29216405749320984,
-0.22029605507850647,
0.45503348112106323,
0.261820524930954,
-0.34381669759750366,
0.2683563232421875,
-0.4240836203098297,
0.47969403862953186,
0.6026455163955688,
0.43195992708206177,
-0.0094329584389925,
-0.46078014373779297,
-0.14284875988960266,
0.015420329757034779,
-0.06695869565010071,
-0.5820378065109253,
0.5412804484367371,
0.5355682373046875,
0.5982075929641724,
0.6293298006057739,
0.0995398610830307,
0.49701303243637085,
-0.8723406791687012,
0.33267679810523987,
0.17984803020954132,
-0.9705265164375305,
0.4301391541957855,
-0.4810614585876465,
0.3109978139400482,
0.7207487225532532,
0.6909863352775574,
-0.5339673161506653,
-0.4490222930908203,
-0.6412315368652344,
-0.672817587852478,
0.6760649085044861,
-0.03352391719818115,
0.12002859264612198,
-0.3112601339817047,
0.509402334690094,
0.5167973637580872,
-0.14591866731643677,
-0.9306443929672241,
-0.2529454827308655,
-0.10189180076122284,
-0.049324214458465576,
-0.5356515645980835,
-0.2970811724662781,
-0.058193039149045944,
-0.5337434411048889,
0.6294941306114197,
-0.057742614299058914,
0.14748843014240265,
0.11412431299686432,
-0.5681565999984741,
-0.13794443011283875,
0.1760663241147995,
0.6493328213691711,
0.637376606464386,
-0.2695613503456116,
0.25704360008239746,
0.41453075408935547,
-0.17303737998008728,
-0.11298894882202148,
-0.17284494638442993,
-0.3322027921676636,
-0.14215758442878723,
0.4113645553588867,
0.8573535680770874,
0.7365642786026001,
-0.6520527601242065,
0.40228694677352905,
0.06824107468128204,
-0.19687867164611816,
-0.25399670004844666,
0.2548271417617798,
0.09564952552318573,
-0.010785473510622978,
0.1476222723722458,
0.317756712436676,
0.18359921872615814,
-0.6376152038574219,
0.8048236966133118,
0.3041808307170868,
-0.6942009329795837,
-0.32332462072372437,
0.836155891418457,
-0.05635389685630798,
0.07311313599348068,
0.1106332540512085,
-0.25825318694114685,
-0.37727853655815125,
0.5723756551742554,
0.7577019929885864,
0.5119783878326416,
-0.18761835992336273,
0.11572927236557007,
0.45812463760375977,
0.025495201349258423,
-0.07396670430898666,
0.02756211720407009,
-0.16133494675159454,
-0.8581010699272156,
-0.5676117539405823,
-0.7489123344421387,
-0.1550677865743637,
0.0791424959897995,
-0.5073890686035156,
0.5134372115135193,
-0.40617281198501587,
-0.030386250466108322,
0.13036157190799713,
-0.3223962187767029,
-1.0806092023849487,
0.6466695070266724,
0.08389304578304291,
0.6949890851974487,
-1.0088427066802979,
1.2361559867858887,
0.24382424354553223,
-0.6955977082252502,
-0.6671249270439148,
-0.1634310781955719,
-0.02956647239625454,
-0.7074477672576904,
1.1208735704421997,
0.044192176312208176,
-0.15271754562854767,
0.024107638746500015,
-0.5825904607772827,
-0.9088090658187866,
0.5604907274246216,
0.35896363854408264,
-0.39714184403419495,
0.20682752132415771,
-0.23408138751983643,
0.39358752965927124,
-0.308183491230011,
0.13343437016010284,
0.7291450500488281,
0.22552213072776794,
-0.20490451157093048,
-0.5735687017440796,
0.12462903559207916,
0.022589080035686493,
-0.26246464252471924,
-0.017196819186210632,
-0.4059271812438965,
0.8004597425460815,
-0.1815982311964035,
-0.3404634892940521,
-0.11052975803613663,
0.6993400454521179,
-0.09065283834934235,
0.14413152635097504,
0.5382633209228516,
0.11827649921178818,
0.5933910608291626,
0.05932725593447685,
0.991557776927948,
-0.4118692874908447,
0.33810052275657654,
1.011716604232788,
0.06648286432027817,
0.8742755055427551,
0.40967583656311035,
0.15899987518787384,
0.48368024826049805,
0.6606681942939758,
0.5116224884986877,
1.0333728790283203,
-0.009278977289795876,
-0.22973549365997314,
-0.4987920820713043,
0.3439655005931854,
-0.0195978544652462,
0.3394724726676941,
0.5879810452461243,
-0.04853885993361473,
-0.2738683819770813,
0.4896010458469391,
0.31087803840637207,
0.14772742986679077,
-0.36640864610671997,
0.536051869392395,
0.4408226013183594,
-0.9491004943847656,
0.9503815770149231,
-0.08062581717967987,
0.8113177418708801,
-0.592651903629303,
0.019386708736419678,
-0.40839165449142456,
0.3322656750679016,
-0.1941199004650116,
-0.22906561195850372,
0.6812680959701538,
-0.1539323627948761,
-0.5287025570869446,
-0.4180428981781006,
0.6560786962509155,
-0.6870211362838745,
-0.21525709331035614,
0.48696208000183105,
0.36379799246788025,
-0.0767352506518364,
0.24186237156391144,
-0.49975714087486267,
-0.37486109137535095,
0.07997362315654755,
-0.20110276341438293,
0.5714340209960938,
0.4504086375236511,
-0.28195759654045105,
0.8330665826797485,
0.5814090371131897,
0.051022518426179886,
-0.16165342926979065,
0.32211217284202576,
0.6392982602119446,
-0.5897181034088135,
-0.5094102621078491,
-0.7396038770675659,
0.33234506845474243,
0.15007761120796204,
-0.1141766905784607,
0.6304000616073608,
0.3020476698875427,
1.0860826969146729,
-0.4183427691459656,
0.6543992757797241,
0.061833642423152924,
0.5276427268981934,
-0.9216901063919067,
1.0126030445098877,
-0.5373162031173706,
0.30571693181991577,
-0.2268001288175583,
-0.5690767168998718,
-0.5055496096611023,
0.5432314276695251,
-0.7630847692489624,
-0.12465107440948486,
1.0669145584106445,
0.6011610627174377,
-0.34167882800102234,
-0.23390977084636688,
0.6310185790061951,
0.26112550497055054,
-0.10883436352014542,
0.4487038552761078,
0.4152073264122009,
-0.13922999799251556,
0.23976917564868927,
-0.39151084423065186,
-0.4470803141593933,
-0.02746352180838585,
-0.7178709506988525,
-1.1353745460510254,
-0.819433331489563,
-0.2450396716594696,
-0.17992322146892548,
0.14621908962726593,
0.6686384677886963,
0.7962082624435425,
-1.1408004760742188,
-0.1322123259305954,
-0.35317638516426086,
0.39508527517318726,
-0.1742725372314453,
-0.2792622447013855,
0.5007267594337463,
-0.9595120549201965,
-0.6609402894973755,
0.42232006788253784,
0.004242054186761379,
-0.10604333877563477,
0.13444694876670837,
-0.10507317632436752,
-0.12157712131738663,
0.10314957052469254,
0.7380770444869995,
0.5736070871353149,
-0.643013596534729,
-0.46274513006210327,
-0.28837794065475464,
-0.22024476528167725,
-0.0985921174287796,
0.8314828872680664,
-1.0652352571487427,
0.12135873734951019,
0.48996201157569885,
0.552213191986084,
0.5243443846702576,
-0.45708203315734863,
0.7852020263671875,
-0.5307637453079224,
0.7750943899154663,
-0.12396999448537827,
0.6286085844039917,
0.13774803280830383,
-0.4471251964569092,
0.315243124961853,
0.1259235441684723,
-0.36615878343582153,
-0.25268325209617615,
0.2623327374458313,
-0.8335667848587036,
-0.7579349875450134,
1.1675159931182861,
-0.023453202098608017,
-0.23495760560035706,
-0.43055129051208496,
-0.22447986900806427,
0.5803120732307434,
-0.17212393879890442,
0.596240222454071,
0.2946607768535614,
0.12526467442512512,
-0.03547138348221779,
-1.0057997703552246,
1.0621050596237183,
0.7350181937217712,
-0.40593093633651733,
-0.15034647285938263,
0.5248433351516724,
0.8101533651351929,
-0.4262614846229553,
0.6380125284194946,
0.3367566466331482,
0.3615833520889282,
-0.1567092090845108,
-0.10429860651493073,
0.5415378212928772,
-0.4885220527648926,
-0.15230636298656464,
-0.019272711127996445,
0.04617016017436981,
0.2840119004249573
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.06576v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.06576v3
|
OccamLLM: Fast and Exact Language Model Arithmetic in a Single Step
| 2024-06-04T04:17:40 | 2024-06-29T19:13:23 |
Owen Dugan, Donato Manuel Jimenez Beneto, Charlotte Loh, Zhuo Chen, Rumen Dangovski, Marin Soljačić
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Despite significant advancements in text generation and reasoning, Large
Language Models (LLMs) still face challenges in accurately performing complex
arithmetic operations. To achieve accurate calculations, language model systems
often enable LLMs to generate code for arithmetic operations. However, this
approach compromises speed and security and, if finetuning is involved, risks
the language model losing prior capabilities. We propose a framework that
enables exact arithmetic in \textit{a single autoregressive step}, providing
faster, more secure, and more interpretable LLM systems with arithmetic
capabilities. We use the hidden states of an LLM to control a symbolic
architecture which performs arithmetic. Our implementation using Llama 3 8B
Instruct with OccamNet as a symbolic model (OccamLlama) achieves 100\% accuracy
on single arithmetic operations
($+,-,\times,\div,\sin{},\cos{},\log{},\exp{},\sqrt{}$), outperforming GPT 4o
and on par with GPT 4o using a code interpreter. OccamLlama also outperforms
GPT 4o both with and without a code interpreter on mathematical problem solving
benchmarks involving challenging arithmetic, thus enabling small LLMs to match
the arithmetic performance of even much larger models. We will make our code
public shortly.
|
[
0.29561784863471985,
-0.908913791179657,
0.7000556588172913,
0.5031847357749939,
-0.3119531571865082,
0.16329120099544525,
0.10601955652236938,
-0.4149579405784607,
0.044054966419935226,
0.706959068775177,
-0.22003228962421417,
-0.6911039352416992,
-0.617231011390686,
-0.15451519191265106,
-0.49230825901031494,
0.5388213396072388,
-0.16608530282974243,
0.1757640391588211,
0.11613678187131882,
-0.29817041754722595,
-0.01924283802509308,
-0.7571667432785034,
-0.619090735912323,
-0.08682020008563995,
0.20233339071273804,
0.2537648677825928,
0.804397463798523,
0.9089257717132568,
0.6802254915237427,
0.37811338901519775,
0.07548679411411285,
0.2541850209236145,
-0.4910188913345337,
0.10553093254566193,
0.13578301668167114,
-0.6644608378410339,
-0.8681678175926208,
-0.16067224740982056,
0.8611252307891846,
0.6152334213256836,
-0.5331369638442993,
0.2994735836982727,
-0.43094494938850403,
0.7237275242805481,
-0.6303367018699646,
0.5629811882972717,
-0.6493417024612427,
0.015951311215758324,
-0.3044430613517761,
-0.0730833187699318,
-0.40011101961135864,
-0.6810795068740845,
-0.6081441640853882,
-0.6919689178466797,
-0.13090169429779053,
0.20859059691429138,
0.514763355255127,
0.49588173627853394,
-0.5302592515945435,
-0.2857252061367035,
-0.604529082775116,
0.5443044304847717,
-0.7699885964393616,
0.3943907916545868,
0.22146479785442352,
0.3309411108493805,
-0.26620224118232727,
-0.8748877048492432,
-0.549652636051178,
-0.290427565574646,
0.037739869207143784,
-0.20528313517570496,
-0.19327229261398315,
0.10959819704294205,
0.400547593832016,
0.45072290301322937,
-0.5421015620231628,
0.06280234456062317,
-0.18445263803005219,
0.1840764731168747,
0.49256381392478943,
0.5906913876533508,
0.24929046630859375,
0.22188320755958557,
-0.1895459145307541,
0.010986252687871456,
-0.9090554118156433,
-0.10396973043680191,
0.38267871737480164,
0.12297970056533813,
-0.11843506991863251,
0.7897158265113831,
-0.2005942314863205,
0.7210560441017151,
0.0695362389087677,
-0.008831403218209743,
0.0043301060795784,
-0.15234710276126862,
-0.44278571009635925,
0.2560683488845825,
0.779002845287323,
-0.3100608289241791,
0.12345299124717712,
0.20334789156913757,
-0.3863454759120941,
0.4513174295425415,
0.23986707627773285,
-1.162580132484436,
-0.18243560194969177,
0.022917630150914192,
-0.16254960000514984,
-0.387672483921051,
0.14163708686828613,
-0.30640149116516113,
-0.2343679517507553,
-0.310309499502182,
0.4475500285625458,
-0.4562084972858429,
-0.12751272320747375,
0.5606333017349243,
0.31553134322166443,
-0.1840258091688156,
0.5721324682235718,
-0.5911787748336792,
0.7190744280815125,
1.1405682563781738,
0.7752156257629395,
-0.09964994341135025,
-0.1554913967847824,
-0.8406466245651245,
0.039548903703689575,
-0.6763647198677063,
0.1724604219198227,
-0.6348327994346619,
-0.3072250187397003,
-0.029185622930526733,
-0.31589406728744507,
-0.09062961488962173,
-0.250553697347641,
0.31373026967048645,
-0.8877372741699219,
-0.03344573453068733,
0.4180261790752411,
-0.6764609217643738,
-0.1648246794939041,
-0.13728219270706177,
-0.7460902333259583,
0.9266594052314758,
-0.24073074758052826,
-0.40963947772979736,
-0.14711980521678925,
-0.9641297459602356,
-0.4374946057796478,
0.011668093502521515,
-0.16279561817646027,
-0.24651771783828735,
0.40350234508514404,
0.17701442539691925,
0.15239669382572174,
-0.21826313436031342,
0.1333923190832138,
-0.36610203981399536,
-0.4200214147567749,
0.1469266414642334,
-0.7885265946388245,
1.246014952659607,
0.19395793974399567,
-0.5432655215263367,
0.05314868688583374,
-0.9731446504592896,
0.04195127636194229,
0.46680107712745667,
-0.20150123536586761,
-0.3179725110530853,
-0.12273871898651123,
-0.45661380887031555,
-0.0607542023062706,
0.6307510137557983,
-0.5999170541763306,
0.40702348947525024,
-0.5666945576667786,
0.308384507894516,
0.7213325500488281,
-0.09036006778478622,
0.573727011680603,
0.14773838222026825,
0.5170929431915283,
-0.09903471171855927,
0.21911439299583435,
-0.3475874960422516,
-0.6690865755081177,
-0.8917847871780396,
-0.22881513833999634,
0.2532253861427307,
0.5277643799781799,
-0.7103917002677917,
0.4059094786643982,
-0.2549741268157959,
-0.5778264403343201,
-0.5225821733474731,
0.033094994723796844,
0.7517502307891846,
0.36619317531585693,
0.17962832748889923,
-0.23313210904598236,
-0.15497717261314392,
-0.40828508138656616,
-0.19961406290531158,
-0.5717994570732117,
-0.008722364902496338,
-0.2306465059518814,
0.15224403142929077,
0.0851525217294693,
0.5504880547523499,
-0.7873762249946594,
-0.3067750632762909,
0.1498630791902542,
0.244537815451622,
0.41507959365844727,
0.48044127225875854,
0.1372431516647339,
-0.7083589434623718,
-0.2761922776699066,
0.1261785626411438,
-0.7628650665283203,
-0.18766924738883972,
0.19627587497234344,
-0.28418564796447754,
0.6136540770530701,
0.3474203944206238,
-0.7480728626251221,
0.8262205719947815,
0.5777319073677063,
-0.5690810084342957,
0.36653006076812744,
-0.42767515778541565,
0.10674607008695602,
-0.5166134834289551,
-0.04755109176039696,
-0.5031930208206177,
-0.4715842008590698,
-0.7525440454483032,
0.8229879140853882,
0.5304473638534546,
-0.09023258090019226,
-0.5234503746032715,
0.5958748459815979,
-0.5249939560890198,
0.04505687952041626,
-0.1204872876405716,
-0.24095465242862701,
0.08008472621440887,
0.49734532833099365,
0.013314016163349152,
0.5608100891113281,
0.4866866171360016,
-0.5095456838607788,
0.10278450697660446,
-0.017663288861513138,
-0.19233624637126923,
0.41999441385269165,
-0.5795835256576538,
0.2511669993400574,
0.18234749138355255,
0.1847323477268219,
-0.6445308327674866,
0.08966771513223648,
0.23610179126262665,
-0.36019811034202576,
0.36068734526634216,
0.02232852764427662,
-0.6597158908843994,
-0.2193467617034912,
-0.013954535126686096,
0.5812581777572632,
0.5995698571205139,
-0.5755100846290588,
0.9523658752441406,
0.43551862239837646,
-0.12147678434848785,
-0.4069505035877228,
-0.40106797218322754,
0.14839786291122437,
0.26352643966674805,
-0.6480348110198975,
0.01886480301618576,
-0.09560523182153702,
-0.6213908195495605,
-0.11588995903730392,
-0.15597501397132874,
-0.17401301860809326,
0.1219121664762497,
0.4154829680919647,
0.4752187132835388,
-0.4106314182281494,
0.03700580447912216,
-0.012655558064579964,
-0.2065030336380005,
0.1241542249917984,
-0.44543129205703735,
0.6236171722412109,
-0.43568673729896545,
-0.9008950591087341,
-0.3738026022911072,
0.23711766302585602,
0.6528083086013794,
-0.3275392949581146,
0.55820631980896,
0.3477313816547394,
-0.44629669189453125,
-0.11956249177455902,
-0.5749897956848145,
0.011619760654866695,
-0.5210162997245789,
0.22175900638103485,
-0.5960996747016907,
-0.770318329334259,
0.20279623568058014,
0.4756873846054077,
0.528671383857727,
0.4823169410228729,
0.6342036724090576,
0.3102496266365051,
1.2940691709518433,
0.5156846046447754,
0.1690344214439392,
0.2880556881427765,
-0.02508016861975193,
0.18777979910373688,
-0.06886392831802368,
-0.18696466088294983,
-0.6312813758850098,
0.12249837070703506,
-0.2795998156070709,
-0.8298683166503906,
0.3769571781158447,
0.1333777755498886,
-0.5334147214889526,
0.37292274832725525,
-0.3143905699253082,
0.5257489681243896,
0.5851423740386963,
0.13949480652809143,
0.7409805655479431,
0.057322658598423004,
-0.18247772753238678,
0.2397165298461914,
-0.7040231227874756,
-0.44986703991889954,
0.893150269985199,
0.4487035870552063,
1.0924872159957886,
0.3478909432888031,
0.7595007419586182,
0.20048962533473969,
0.4375104010105133,
-0.6354759335517883,
0.772685170173645,
-0.33962124586105347,
-0.43298450112342834,
-0.40110886096954346,
-0.7536547183990479,
-0.6154810190200806,
0.2919096350669861,
0.2821454405784607,
-0.3822192847728729,
0.05159592628479004,
0.2586422860622406,
-0.2894270420074463,
0.47166696190834045,
-0.6554279327392578,
0.5556465983390808,
-0.3019721806049347,
-0.2564878463745117,
-0.34872302412986755,
-0.4834393560886383,
0.5614348649978638,
-0.29930636286735535,
0.16069886088371277,
-0.22216670215129852,
-0.49073559045791626,
0.4185848534107208,
-1.0154799222946167,
0.8684120178222656,
-0.12081872671842575,
-0.41097626090049744,
0.21861256659030914,
0.6590508222579956,
0.8005357980728149,
-0.08294662833213806,
-0.28697770833969116,
0.6825106739997864,
-0.10686959326267242,
-0.48489561676979065,
-0.7186310887336731,
0.7534406781196594,
-0.5125628113746643,
-0.816377580165863,
-0.5137561559677124,
-0.39163824915885925,
-0.0804063007235527,
0.06459566205739975,
-0.31649157404899597,
0.6363681554794312,
-0.14667947590351105,
-0.13071545958518982,
0.5480132102966309,
0.21314337849617004,
0.637968122959137,
1.0198556184768677,
-0.6760752201080322,
-0.34024280309677124,
0.8700095415115356,
-0.02877447009086609,
0.5173173546791077,
0.5962901711463928,
0.11685440689325333,
-0.4558047950267792,
-0.26147934794425964,
-0.8715035915374756,
0.1247049942612648,
-0.6421396732330322,
-0.21580606698989868,
-0.7797628045082092,
-0.246093288064003,
-0.4483497440814972,
0.023269718512892723,
-0.4375808537006378,
-0.9169219732284546,
-0.25726568698883057,
-0.04572158306837082,
0.39377498626708984,
1.007253646850586,
-0.07213465124368668,
0.15183304250240326,
-0.9120673537254333,
0.5645729899406433,
0.4650903046131134,
0.28868773579597473,
0.08616025000810623,
-0.651336669921875,
-0.12772215902805328,
0.07999376207590103,
-0.11264599114656448,
-0.6481375694274902,
0.35168546438217163,
0.270118772983551,
0.13326618075370789,
0.4266953766345978,
0.08414828777313232,
1.032935380935669,
-0.9447016716003418,
0.517159640789032,
0.35223081707954407,
-1.2515203952789307,
0.08156348764896393,
-0.017623858526349068,
0.465823233127594,
0.2805919647216797,
0.17193681001663208,
-0.22508633136749268,
-0.6610894203186035,
-0.6187793612480164,
-0.5362066030502319,
0.7841529846191406,
0.548456072807312,
-0.09589257091283798,
0.13002564013004303,
-0.05721524730324745,
0.03300422802567482,
0.26497170329093933,
-0.42546823620796204,
-0.4229612350463867,
-0.15089663863182068,
-0.22141219675540924,
0.0013866527006030083,
-0.13880106806755066,
-0.1181972473859787,
-0.047357022762298584,
0.6891325116157532,
-0.027275249361991882,
0.2548840343952179,
-0.0948149785399437,
-0.2289293259382248,
-0.27603673934936523,
-0.012982483021914959,
0.6832149028778076,
0.784822404384613,
-0.16289560496807098,
0.38194504380226135,
0.16678670048713684,
-0.7705391049385071,
0.33223956823349,
0.2001790702342987,
-0.15117202699184418,
0.0950641855597496,
0.28259819746017456,
0.731156051158905,
0.2937922775745392,
-0.4532579481601715,
0.4555003046989441,
-0.22623777389526367,
0.10045861452817917,
-0.3821784555912018,
0.2297593355178833,
0.060031816363334656,
0.033643580973148346,
0.45201313495635986,
0.050441332161426544,
0.01206256728619337,
-0.4297805726528168,
0.14678727090358734,
0.23390139639377594,
-0.4416787922382355,
-0.22127336263656616,
0.7613675594329834,
0.10318474471569061,
-0.5689431428909302,
0.29191693663597107,
-0.24634936451911926,
-0.3375171422958374,
0.7794787883758545,
0.6428437232971191,
0.7835819125175476,
-0.4370422959327698,
-0.051738813519477844,
0.07884983718395233,
0.4285523295402527,
-0.05478126183152199,
0.36280229687690735,
0.11358851194381714,
-0.3434893786907196,
-0.4641704559326172,
-1.0590239763259888,
-0.48347610235214233,
-0.5143088698387146,
-0.5285489559173584,
0.15882132947444916,
-0.6168677806854248,
0.2042606920003891,
-0.09753264486789703,
-0.19485628604888916,
-0.6194023489952087,
0.06957465410232544,
0.1817251741886139,
1.1113379001617432,
-0.3188364505767822,
1.0799510478973389,
0.4351305067539215,
-0.10845199227333069,
-0.9500354528427124,
-0.39128178358078003,
0.147929847240448,
-1.284250259399414,
0.674056887626648,
0.08214618265628815,
-0.43392670154571533,
0.18453079462051392,
-0.35820063948631287,
-0.7769693732261658,
0.8192281126976013,
0.4688419699668884,
-0.905147910118103,
-0.045182064175605774,
0.3984178602695465,
0.4470686614513397,
-0.39942023158073425,
0.3773925006389618,
0.558271586894989,
0.4701705276966095,
0.26203015446662903,
-0.9179315567016602,
0.13567835092544556,
-0.21839722990989685,
-0.09070801734924316,
0.5984609127044678,
-0.3548179864883423,
0.88740074634552,
-0.2159702479839325,
-0.38817307353019714,
0.2990567088127136,
0.7384970784187317,
0.2535770833492279,
0.30314838886260986,
0.47409915924072266,
0.7683864831924438,
0.703116238117218,
-0.06830491125583649,
1.1615769863128662,
-0.5565165281295776,
0.1296536773443222,
1.219455599784851,
-0.45464158058166504,
1.0250778198242188,
0.12200308591127396,
-0.3170912563800812,
0.35980352759361267,
0.1289849728345871,
0.6243528723716736,
0.051989808678627014,
0.11179139465093613,
-0.5350672602653503,
-0.4803409278392792,
0.05812996253371239,
-0.3395766317844391,
0.35749611258506775,
0.446662962436676,
-0.12736786901950836,
-0.18007786571979523,
-0.4066236913204193,
0.30838313698768616,
0.012805284932255745,
-0.6656489968299866,
0.6295207738876343,
0.32103076577186584,
-0.41570356488227844,
0.6375887989997864,
0.18332424759864807,
0.31516018509864807,
-0.9197001457214355,
-0.40641582012176514,
-0.283692866563797,
0.23544831573963165,
-0.15344549715518951,
-0.5826805233955383,
0.2625780403614044,
-0.03576980531215668,
0.14944230020046234,
-0.21120518445968628,
0.6242047548294067,
-0.5213157534599304,
-1.1478509902954102,
0.13274089992046356,
0.38776445388793945,
0.1720026731491089,
-0.2501732409000397,
-0.5766131281852722,
0.10056913644075394,
-0.10802888125181198,
-0.09484075009822845,
0.09802214801311493,
0.6384164094924927,
-0.2327566295862198,
0.7269024848937988,
0.881506621837616,
0.22943834960460663,
0.4189414381980896,
0.10182378441095352,
0.7049286365509033,
-0.662568986415863,
-0.6200350522994995,
-1.0265949964523315,
0.2545752227306366,
0.0215823482722044,
-0.09308044612407684,
0.8231284022331238,
0.5193148255348206,
0.43581101298332214,
-0.04409502446651459,
0.15124352276325226,
0.10283097624778748,
0.18276885151863098,
-0.6703888177871704,
0.8962863087654114,
-0.49618449807167053,
0.274549275636673,
0.014603142626583576,
-0.8606625199317932,
-0.525715708732605,
0.21606110036373138,
-0.2023516744375229,
-0.4080570638179779,
0.8277183771133423,
1.1019549369812012,
-0.06828371435403824,
0.15040545165538788,
0.768337070941925,
0.44900447130203247,
0.19983603060245514,
0.4474712610244751,
0.6369595527648926,
-0.36520543694496155,
0.5417945384979248,
-0.26733630895614624,
-0.292363703250885,
-0.2354680746793747,
-0.976283073425293,
-0.7111032009124756,
-0.19220589101314545,
-0.17219674587249756,
-0.2926270663738251,
0.18047431111335754,
0.9066793918609619,
0.4913242757320404,
-0.7687740921974182,
-0.4909912645816803,
-0.20049163699150085,
0.23303233087062836,
-0.030881846323609352,
-0.21387764811515808,
0.39388588070869446,
-0.2864493131637573,
-0.8286365270614624,
0.42192718386650085,
0.7518077492713928,
-0.1428331732749939,
-0.45721110701560974,
-0.2511283755302429,
0.04617232456803322,
0.3855128884315491,
0.6023449897766113,
0.21595455706119537,
-0.7505986094474792,
0.01545324083417654,
-0.1404823362827301,
-0.3678014576435089,
0.09615658223628998,
0.9228066205978394,
-0.5500836372375488,
0.40050625801086426,
0.4153438210487366,
0.5235676765441895,
0.5020759701728821,
0.009796925820410252,
0.5161330103874207,
-0.23802566528320312,
0.13170288503170013,
0.37391069531440735,
0.4657424986362457,
0.029108034446835518,
-0.29447266459465027,
0.6260256767272949,
0.09801668673753738,
-0.4431321620941162,
-0.6857404112815857,
0.21547724306583405,
-0.8193971514701843,
-0.08308465033769608,
1.0148707628250122,
-0.48338782787323,
-0.6275539398193359,
-0.11532503366470337,
-0.1512373983860016,
-0.011989407241344452,
-0.5822615623474121,
0.5086479187011719,
-0.007200686261057854,
0.0708686113357544,
0.20172877609729767,
-0.11714619398117065,
0.1424230933189392,
0.5409374833106995,
-0.7470592260360718,
-0.053974468261003494,
0.6003267765045166,
-0.034285202622413635,
0.27738088369369507,
0.6392139196395874,
-0.33150631189346313,
0.33810725808143616,
0.18791966140270233,
0.3252251148223877,
-0.5247472524642944,
-0.4425341486930847,
-0.4969058930873871,
0.5158289670944214,
0.0736585333943367,
-0.1713419109582901
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.01946v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.01946v2
|
Bileve: Securing Text Provenance in Large Language Models Against Spoofing with Bi-level Signature
| 2024-06-04T03:58:14 | 2024-06-17T15:11:11 |
Tong Zhou, Xuandong Zhao, Xiaolin Xu, Shaolei Ren
|
cs.CR
|
cs.CR, cs.CL
|
Text watermarks for large language models (LLMs) have been commonly used to
identify the origins of machine-generated content, which is promising for
assessing liability when combating deepfake or harmful content. While existing
watermarking techniques typically prioritize robustness against removal
attacks, unfortunately, they are vulnerable to spoofing attacks: malicious
actors can subtly alter the meanings of LLM-generated responses or even forge
harmful content, potentially misattributing blame to the LLM developer. To
overcome this, we introduce a bi-level signature scheme, Bileve, which embeds
fine-grained signature bits for integrity checks (mitigating spoofing attacks)
as well as a coarse-grained signal to trace text sources when the signature is
invalid (enhancing detectability) via a novel rank-based sampling strategy.
Compared to conventional watermark detectors that only output binary results,
Bileve can differentiate 5 scenarios during detection, reliably tracing text
provenance and regulating LLMs. The experiments conducted on OPT-1.3B and
LLaMA-7B demonstrate the effectiveness of Bileve in defeating spoofing attacks
with enhanced detectability.
|
[
-0.007379479240626097,
-0.7990304231643677,
0.2135344296693802,
0.4351803660392761,
-0.34521782398223877,
0.4062754511833191,
0.1562497317790985,
-0.5320665240287781,
0.10659844428300858,
0.8914716839790344,
-0.17845799028873444,
-0.44989442825317383,
-0.9311020970344543,
-0.013109507970511913,
-0.7656306624412537,
1.182835340499878,
0.14102600514888763,
-0.25479957461357117,
-0.3230028450489044,
-0.25242745876312256,
-0.17712904512882233,
-0.49028101563453674,
-0.5656326413154602,
-0.08834315836429596,
0.6012051105499268,
0.10681331157684326,
0.46174994111061096,
0.5367031693458557,
0.4197128117084503,
0.22836150228977203,
-0.3150492310523987,
0.25695285201072693,
-0.7440453767776489,
0.579256534576416,
-0.3760673999786377,
-0.40575313568115234,
-0.4250465929508209,
-0.06673003733158112,
0.8671204447746277,
0.5286083221435547,
0.15524190664291382,
0.10841869562864304,
0.03420513495802879,
0.6071184873580933,
-0.7090444564819336,
0.08893075585365295,
-0.9266809225082397,
-0.40638256072998047,
-0.64823979139328,
-0.2675577998161316,
-0.7165788412094116,
-0.23740415275096893,
-0.24538478255271912,
-0.2383580207824707,
0.2033887803554535,
0.3323439359664917,
1.1542733907699585,
0.246625155210495,
-0.32392287254333496,
-0.14829692244529724,
-0.7323037385940552,
0.7348611354827881,
-0.8684818148612976,
0.18028125166893005,
0.4194239377975464,
0.22718118131160736,
-0.4455031454563141,
-0.4748372435569763,
-0.48503780364990234,
0.061126090586185455,
0.17510473728179932,
0.06175900995731354,
-0.1589771807193756,
-0.2784361243247986,
0.3104097843170166,
0.5520567297935486,
-0.38669896125793457,
0.01948537863790989,
-0.20584207773208618,
-0.6044207215309143,
0.4184674620628357,
-0.14475442469120026,
0.3628738224506378,
0.11717048287391663,
-0.7617082595825195,
-0.17610575258731842,
-1.3576889038085938,
0.08323699235916138,
0.6859539747238159,
0.4247360825538635,
-0.07548979669809341,
0.5082531571388245,
-0.11304426938295364,
0.2887764275074005,
0.22037404775619507,
-0.09507446736097336,
-0.0017774974694475532,
-0.06919638812541962,
-0.21970434486865997,
0.43826746940612793,
0.6281678080558777,
-0.10919854789972305,
-0.027736743912100792,
-0.33080822229385376,
-0.32826679944992065,
-0.17824804782867432,
-0.04431164637207985,
-0.8437312841415405,
-0.1792655736207962,
0.2765029966831207,
-0.28870365023612976,
-0.6381258368492126,
0.1608245074748993,
-0.965142548084259,
-0.9830484986305237,
0.2092548906803131,
0.5863550901412964,
-0.2779006361961365,
-0.40954625606536865,
0.2610562741756439,
-0.0930633619427681,
0.4126187264919281,
0.29638323187828064,
-0.6838365197181702,
0.32197698950767517,
0.7197432518005371,
0.45072469115257263,
-0.07263805717229843,
-0.30921903252601624,
-1.1496044397354126,
0.6789186000823975,
-0.47102296352386475,
1.0696189403533936,
-0.377232164144516,
-0.28486353158950806,
0.10568321496248245,
0.14358283579349518,
0.46287816762924194,
-0.5128839015960693,
0.4643877148628235,
-0.7886559963226318,
-0.04907675459980965,
-0.24802790582180023,
-0.5977105498313904,
0.06331567466259003,
0.5626057982444763,
-1.0558171272277832,
1.3442351818084717,
0.11570333689451218,
-1.0651715993881226,
0.43165475130081177,
0.11922337859869003,
-0.7309074401855469,
0.3322237432003021,
-0.03871199116110802,
-0.653933584690094,
0.015149629674851894,
0.06899970769882202,
0.33449479937553406,
-0.08714893460273743,
-0.10856323689222336,
-0.42517611384391785,
-0.21471314132213593,
0.32420986890792847,
-0.5683262944221497,
1.047813892364502,
-0.24509297311306,
-0.6482744216918945,
0.08433711528778076,
-1.0866594314575195,
-0.29583126306533813,
0.18932850658893585,
-0.6767404079437256,
-0.685221254825592,
0.22491607069969177,
-0.09660612046718597,
-0.11262458562850952,
0.3362106382846832,
-0.5993853211402893,
0.15084494650363922,
-0.48373618721961975,
0.03964383900165558,
0.7671016454696655,
0.19691741466522217,
0.41988715529441833,
-0.31010687351226807,
0.3519517481327057,
0.10389766842126846,
0.05876227840781212,
-0.23281791806221008,
-0.5865187048912048,
-0.6171516180038452,
-0.6098322868347168,
0.3202730417251587,
0.5025853514671326,
-0.6596148014068604,
0.24951428174972534,
-0.5139945149421692,
-0.6931326389312744,
-0.2732517123222351,
0.3647247552871704,
0.38442233204841614,
0.19492846727371216,
0.31541892886161804,
0.05522198975086212,
-0.2087886929512024,
-0.7428651452064514,
-0.5712552666664124,
-0.23636959493160248,
0.1474953442811966,
0.004524308256804943,
0.5202717781066895,
-0.15927927196025848,
0.8198947310447693,
0.07163996249437332,
-0.10209323465824127,
-0.4379796087741852,
0.21011453866958618,
-0.12051821500062943,
0.5332088470458984,
0.6355889439582825,
-0.7039200067520142,
-0.4649457633495331,
-0.0423150435090065,
-0.2280833125114441,
-0.5245015025138855,
-0.184688001871109,
-0.204831063747406,
0.3521023988723755,
0.5695801377296448,
-0.32003113627433777,
0.4762544631958008,
0.8215253353118896,
-0.48853933811187744,
0.7221472263336182,
-0.2977460026741028,
0.15106455981731415,
-0.7948986291885376,
0.11920496076345444,
-0.4024694859981537,
-0.565735399723053,
-0.5731338858604431,
0.215268075466156,
0.3668033182621002,
0.0586959533393383,
-0.2847347557544708,
0.8097411394119263,
-0.5318864583969116,
-0.024077709764242172,
-0.2632603347301483,
-0.08168698847293854,
0.31327566504478455,
0.02409367635846138,
-0.19281424582004547,
0.5481394529342651,
0.5946623086929321,
-0.29802829027175903,
0.1694430708885193,
-0.10125184059143066,
-0.2786683738231659,
0.7705197334289551,
-0.6757345199584961,
0.12989500164985657,
0.0011669157538563013,
0.38931483030319214,
-1.0650153160095215,
0.09126720577478409,
0.35878780484199524,
-0.5861684083938599,
0.7441574931144714,
-0.43497952818870544,
-0.8056866526603699,
0.3720727264881134,
-0.3326917588710785,
0.29516369104385376,
0.139054074883461,
-0.5259038805961609,
0.7855627536773682,
0.2994972765445709,
-0.31729674339294434,
-0.6446064114570618,
-0.7184244990348816,
0.37035128474235535,
-0.15757183730602264,
-0.5224842429161072,
0.17497362196445465,
-0.11261992156505585,
-0.04387925565242767,
-0.32113906741142273,
-0.23912198841571808,
-0.1008826196193695,
0.2855660915374756,
0.37876832485198975,
0.30703428387641907,
0.05208832025527954,
-0.40727168321609497,
0.3667328953742981,
-0.30155837535858154,
0.00004894530866295099,
-0.11061573773622513,
0.4607701301574707,
0.0899793952703476,
-0.3801831007003784,
-0.07821734249591827,
0.6093490123748779,
1.1639326810836792,
-0.5405844449996948,
0.7393996119499207,
0.39963680505752563,
-0.5995277166366577,
-0.48335009813308716,
-0.6334241628646851,
-0.14662331342697144,
-0.43877342343330383,
0.021083276718854904,
-0.16463443636894226,
-0.705078125,
0.6465516686439514,
-0.1557231992483139,
0.20489385724067688,
0.22076953947544098,
0.36783015727996826,
-0.0699915811419487,
0.8920416831970215,
0.37420257925987244,
-0.4633089601993561,
0.29825183749198914,
-0.009385423734784126,
0.38666674494743347,
-0.5057902932167053,
-0.31562790274620056,
-0.8699476718902588,
-0.09018990397453308,
-0.37457728385925293,
-0.4701571464538574,
-0.1975659877061844,
0.23990018665790558,
-0.26513367891311646,
0.30990171432495117,
-0.26262107491493225,
0.40626731514930725,
0.6595948338508606,
-0.014922913163900375,
0.30508559942245483,
0.2718287706375122,
-0.21517354249954224,
0.06149901822209358,
-0.37679997086524963,
-0.5220087766647339,
0.7047615647315979,
0.39305031299591064,
0.8703482151031494,
0.07419972121715546,
0.8513510227203369,
0.43073445558547974,
0.20390652120113373,
-0.3392106294631958,
0.5596652626991272,
0.04816130921244621,
-1.0729444026947021,
-0.16191856563091278,
-0.3338263928890228,
-0.7157622575759888,
-0.09438710659742355,
-0.31526950001716614,
-0.5379352569580078,
0.2214793860912323,
0.05976419150829315,
0.03618667647242546,
0.4905250370502472,
-0.18412770330905914,
0.6595990061759949,
-0.3625844717025757,
-0.7328830361366272,
0.019588859751820564,
-0.6087425947189331,
-0.04745231941342354,
-0.045109886676073074,
0.5405012369155884,
-0.018738048151135445,
0.14184428751468658,
0.5718508958816528,
-0.2948160469532013,
0.9394720792770386,
-0.30769291520118713,
-0.503790557384491,
0.0013025834923610091,
0.6483404636383057,
1.0337454080581665,
0.0835198387503624,
-0.008205435238778591,
0.30350083112716675,
0.22358407080173492,
-0.7802177667617798,
-0.23684196174144745,
0.7249628901481628,
-0.35974109172821045,
-0.45144256949424744,
-0.7198240756988525,
-0.4258069694042206,
-0.17243017256259918,
0.600812554359436,
0.15198972821235657,
0.5256395936012268,
0.21662694215774536,
0.5265018939971924,
0.9350793361663818,
-0.4764866530895233,
0.1460886001586914,
0.6117295026779175,
-0.06928913295269012,
-0.5161424875259399,
1.1046677827835083,
-0.3565404713153839,
0.44895079731941223,
0.6230412125587463,
0.26261842250823975,
-0.0927906334400177,
-0.9330958127975464,
-0.52645343542099,
0.20560108125209808,
-0.6682576537132263,
-0.34068170189857483,
-0.267179399728775,
-0.2051563858985901,
-0.4028371572494507,
-0.20925340056419373,
-0.5885715484619141,
-0.14110174775123596,
0.03520555794239044,
-0.13648919761180878,
0.26568594574928284,
0.3846994638442993,
0.11069507151842117,
-0.024547552689909935,
-0.8275662064552307,
0.1961556226015091,
0.2578602731227875,
0.37366384267807007,
-0.30490320920944214,
-0.6072101593017578,
-0.09517049789428711,
0.1459737867116928,
0.016522416844964027,
-0.9123537540435791,
0.2848382592201233,
0.060575854033231735,
0.6321203112602234,
0.5908787250518799,
0.15018638968467712,
0.4731767773628235,
-0.4664306342601776,
0.9281326532363892,
0.04992092028260231,
-0.9995295405387878,
0.33845341205596924,
-0.45345911383628845,
-0.04058346524834633,
0.5555208325386047,
-0.07006517052650452,
-0.20856884121894836,
-0.9659950733184814,
-0.3648485839366913,
-1.0826610326766968,
0.3838680684566498,
0.2615598738193512,
0.16019810736179352,
0.021536963060498238,
0.24011977016925812,
0.19751283526420593,
0.19102631509304047,
-0.9953896999359131,
-0.3927214741706848,
-0.44618165493011475,
-0.08858662843704224,
0.3819222152233124,
-0.41705429553985596,
-0.15650564432144165,
0.06682577729225159,
0.8456723093986511,
0.10934797674417496,
-0.17537584900856018,
0.18531586229801178,
-0.2557893395423889,
-0.0016533746384084225,
0.2282353937625885,
0.4660947024822235,
0.16945964097976685,
-0.18459081649780273,
0.635830819606781,
-0.15741591155529022,
-0.7254425287246704,
-0.05424381420016289,
0.18312019109725952,
-0.3836795687675476,
-0.07198832184076309,
0.5261669754981995,
0.27254998683929443,
0.42851048707962036,
-0.7191014289855957,
0.6396122574806213,
0.1191970556974411,
-0.009916241280734539,
0.16015644371509552,
-0.18031132221221924,
0.16838504374027252,
0.21762165427207947,
0.4819759130477905,
-0.15000444650650024,
-0.012246744707226753,
-0.4673953652381897,
-0.10781227052211761,
0.28095370531082153,
-0.4219111502170563,
-0.20117424428462982,
0.5125240683555603,
0.06741094589233398,
-0.08953936398029327,
0.1618049591779709,
-0.17435306310653687,
-0.7907291650772095,
0.5815176367759705,
0.7586395740509033,
0.4076991081237793,
-0.3707967698574066,
0.08540942519903183,
0.19262216985225677,
0.6258324980735779,
-0.09820756316184998,
0.10809636116027832,
-0.09477134048938751,
-0.6327924132347107,
-0.029976652935147285,
-0.8114669919013977,
-0.4434981644153595,
0.11282126605510712,
-0.583721935749054,
0.04573681578040123,
-0.463833212852478,
0.33554166555404663,
-0.19256512820720673,
0.01625456102192402,
-0.1921677142381668,
0.14110034704208374,
0.26503482460975647,
0.7610731720924377,
-0.8457701802253723,
0.8128293752670288,
0.7143815755844116,
-0.2505480647087097,
-0.6562955379486084,
-0.14081774652004242,
0.06012997403740883,
-0.5922592282295227,
0.5294621586799622,
0.11487749963998795,
-0.33045828342437744,
0.09851686656475067,
-0.7233657836914062,
-0.7825828194618225,
0.8359003663063049,
0.379497766494751,
-0.3907936215400696,
0.20533514022827148,
0.34143203496932983,
0.2530664801597595,
0.19534778594970703,
-0.3516428470611572,
0.35482996702194214,
0.5145338773727417,
0.09265023469924927,
-0.3598423898220062,
0.3316018581390381,
-0.31867754459381104,
-0.34935346245765686,
0.20880457758903503,
-0.31490159034729004,
0.4504406154155731,
0.26187196373939514,
-0.22284315526485443,
0.21031127870082855,
0.36028897762298584,
0.7760536074638367,
0.39025089144706726,
0.5613070130348206,
0.5403790473937988,
0.6823753714561462,
-0.13516360521316528,
0.8607866764068604,
-0.39063748717308044,
0.29564979672431946,
1.062515377998352,
-0.578002393245697,
0.8667846918106079,
0.6455272436141968,
-0.06903860718011856,
0.6786536574363708,
0.34901344776153564,
-0.16198493540287018,
0.5515609979629517,
0.2229490429162979,
-0.4403984844684601,
-0.3141113817691803,
0.3300052285194397,
-0.17324933409690857,
0.10416760295629501,
0.5586429238319397,
-0.18410618603229523,
-0.1870894432067871,
-0.16351787745952606,
0.2998046576976776,
0.080405093729496,
-0.24636024236679077,
0.5288093090057373,
-0.06935815513134003,
-0.41370058059692383,
0.31461113691329956,
-0.15028275549411774,
0.4666595458984375,
-0.6627846360206604,
0.04204418882727623,
-0.40465018153190613,
0.23145157098770142,
-0.2040172517299652,
-0.5125048756599426,
-0.03164030238986015,
0.028115442022681236,
-0.3599679172039032,
-0.36941447854042053,
0.9755430817604065,
-0.47758379578590393,
-0.42808711528778076,
0.38661202788352966,
0.1312178075313568,
0.14792317152023315,
-0.22876717150211334,
-0.4218890964984894,
0.24733015894889832,
-0.27313733100891113,
-0.23836378753185272,
0.3856301009654999,
0.6151737570762634,
-0.11940079927444458,
0.5894363522529602,
0.7834938764572144,
0.6840366721153259,
0.4155675768852234,
0.22668302059173584,
0.6833891272544861,
-0.2518680989742279,
-0.4173813760280609,
-0.6653615832328796,
0.39423054456710815,
-0.3627716302871704,
0.18932776153087616,
0.9282325506210327,
0.7325830459594727,
0.6146275401115417,
0.13078810274600983,
0.8469718098640442,
0.0644790530204773,
0.5215296745300293,
-0.23610614240169525,
1.1696242094039917,
-0.4628191292285919,
0.6154533624649048,
-0.5752518773078918,
-0.7881408333778381,
-0.5359205007553101,
0.3506612777709961,
-0.20740078389644623,
-0.24507978558540344,
0.6442421674728394,
1.0016010999679565,
-0.06611839681863785,
-0.33036595582962036,
0.31710419058799744,
0.28251829743385315,
0.7927831411361694,
0.21174657344818115,
0.8422296643257141,
-0.4194246530532837,
0.8828041553497314,
-0.14618200063705444,
-0.45751506090164185,
-0.3319200873374939,
-1.2046200037002563,
-0.9326063990592957,
-0.37577497959136963,
-0.3400580883026123,
-0.5861265659332275,
0.003668488236144185,
0.13624757528305054,
0.6364128589630127,
-0.9572586417198181,
0.1387988030910492,
-0.06891708076000214,
0.031766511499881744,
-0.2674473226070404,
-0.2207949161529541,
0.5395281910896301,
-0.06227360665798187,
-0.5375932455062866,
0.2824634909629822,
0.7228657007217407,
0.18794459104537964,
-0.31769484281539917,
0.02658419869840145,
-0.11279301345348358,
0.5364558100700378,
0.35248303413391113,
0.40545380115509033,
-0.5424875020980835,
-0.44251564145088196,
0.08895935863256454,
-0.3268071413040161,
-0.2218071073293686,
0.7302190065383911,
-0.5125535726547241,
0.4734360873699188,
0.7122155427932739,
0.8259699940681458,
0.33493509888648987,
-0.0748099833726883,
0.17931683361530304,
-0.7206322550773621,
0.10554290562868118,
0.17813757061958313,
0.5108404755592346,
0.500511884689331,
-0.23976367712020874,
-0.21800380945205688,
0.4158423840999603,
-0.5083678960800171,
-1.1548246145248413,
0.08196831494569778,
-1.3146384954452515,
-0.28478485345840454,
1.2952669858932495,
-0.46139299869537354,
-0.28756555914878845,
-0.36473581194877625,
-0.328296422958374,
0.14351078867912292,
-0.21721793711185455,
0.9288079738616943,
0.7630357146263123,
0.6767880916595459,
0.06849785149097443,
-0.3342191278934479,
0.3440949320793152,
0.3133569061756134,
-0.8598769307136536,
0.4601692259311676,
0.42099693417549133,
0.5939684510231018,
0.09246844053268433,
0.23651382327079773,
-0.585635781288147,
0.3714289367198944,
0.09070044755935669,
-0.12061914056539536,
-0.11349374800920486,
-0.4839102029800415,
-0.07278432697057724,
0.33824560046195984,
0.11072735488414764,
-0.013902910985052586
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.01943v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.01943v1
|
Enhancing Trust in LLMs: Algorithms for Comparing and Interpreting LLMs
| 2024-06-04T03:54:53 | 2024-06-04T03:54:53 |
Nik Bear Brown
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, 2020: 68T50, 68Q25, I.2.7; F.2.2
|
This paper surveys evaluation techniques to enhance the trustworthiness and
understanding of Large Language Models (LLMs). As reliance on LLMs grows,
ensuring their reliability, fairness, and transparency is crucial. We explore
algorithmic methods and metrics to assess LLM performance, identify weaknesses,
and guide development towards more trustworthy applications. Key evaluation
metrics include Perplexity Measurement, NLP metrics (BLEU, ROUGE, METEOR,
BERTScore, GLEU, Word Error Rate, Character Error Rate), Zero-Shot and Few-Shot
Learning Performance, Transfer Learning Evaluation, Adversarial Testing, and
Fairness and Bias Evaluation. We introduce innovative approaches like LLMMaps
for stratified evaluation, Benchmarking and Leaderboards for competitive
assessment, Stratified Analysis for in-depth understanding, Visualization of
Blooms Taxonomy for cognitive level accuracy distribution, Hallucination Score
for quantifying inaccuracies, Knowledge Stratification Strategy for
hierarchical analysis, and Machine Learning Models for Hierarchy Generation.
Human Evaluation is highlighted for capturing nuances that automated metrics
may miss. These techniques form a framework for evaluating LLMs, aiming to
enhance transparency, guide development, and establish user trust. Future
papers will describe metric visualization and demonstrate each approach on
practical examples.
|
[
-0.12235423177480698,
-0.5793504118919373,
0.7243911623954773,
0.42799317836761475,
-0.00935400277376175,
0.48516690731048584,
-0.2982226014137268,
-0.5074425935745239,
-0.22992035746574402,
0.27118784189224243,
-0.40357303619384766,
-0.7373093962669373,
-0.9489108920097351,
-0.039628420025110245,
-0.393454909324646,
0.7083793878555298,
-0.09202397614717484,
0.39406076073646545,
-0.5515527129173279,
-0.031545769423246384,
-0.30992817878723145,
-0.5719999074935913,
-0.9525186419487,
-0.7102314233779907,
0.1011790856719017,
0.12998536229133606,
0.9066850543022156,
0.6161748766899109,
0.7570924162864685,
0.35749951004981995,
-0.32181262969970703,
0.1292964518070221,
-0.634148120880127,
-0.0037636281922459602,
-0.19895853102207184,
-0.5844730734825134,
-0.6016587615013123,
0.12231519818305969,
0.7179462313652039,
0.7358874678611755,
-0.08693864196538925,
0.48659875988960266,
0.26302939653396606,
0.5520937442779541,
-0.5169312357902527,
0.41891324520111084,
-0.6632691025733948,
0.31896063685417175,
-0.17987269163131714,
-0.4878126382827759,
-0.22302541136741638,
-0.6572521924972534,
0.05961190164089203,
-0.372085303068161,
-0.33601608872413635,
0.19459514319896698,
0.6645966172218323,
0.28032374382019043,
-0.1840156763792038,
-0.6133781671524048,
-0.49649766087532043,
1.0892776250839233,
-0.7995129823684692,
0.5281197428703308,
0.3476089835166931,
0.33263060450553894,
-0.260943740606308,
-0.6540958285331726,
-0.3980988562107086,
-0.6105202436447144,
0.11611206084489822,
0.11085076630115509,
-0.18340705335140228,
0.0023066478315740824,
0.27030619978904724,
0.4626433551311493,
-0.4480275809764862,
0.483963280916214,
0.024310339242219925,
-0.46357542276382446,
0.6698554754257202,
0.2675589323043823,
0.2467324584722519,
-0.1683853566646576,
-0.4147292375564575,
-0.1819310039281845,
-0.6822444796562195,
0.04896470531821251,
0.5945902466773987,
-0.08993704617023468,
-0.07925436645746231,
0.5145861506462097,
-0.013178640976548195,
0.4273235499858856,
-0.1898670792579651,
-0.31630241870880127,
0.3810138404369354,
-0.4750271141529083,
-0.2397405356168747,
-0.32863670587539673,
0.7476353049278259,
0.47247469425201416,
0.44081899523735046,
-0.2882463335990906,
-0.3402886390686035,
0.24371550977230072,
-0.0035171627532690763,
-0.5091509222984314,
0.00895068608224392,
0.25899940729141235,
-0.6470552682876587,
-0.5560449361801147,
-0.01575075089931488,
-0.9031184315681458,
-0.6881157159805298,
-0.36234626173973083,
0.4903835356235504,
-0.28552672266960144,
-0.11990726739168167,
0.047974761575460434,
-0.028388459235429764,
0.42822879552841187,
0.29562339186668396,
-0.6270812749862671,
0.535330593585968,
1.0728797912597656,
0.8098507523536682,
-0.4715970456600189,
-0.46184051036834717,
-0.27023494243621826,
-0.0875823050737381,
-0.38226744532585144,
0.43749091029167175,
-0.5557348728179932,
-0.354743093252182,
0.11830198764801025,
-0.39909255504608154,
0.1509919911623001,
-0.6478168964385986,
0.7333229780197144,
-0.4632568657398224,
0.17668715119361877,
-0.02240833267569542,
-0.7695035934448242,
-0.2149689644575119,
0.5343785285949707,
-0.5030178427696228,
1.043677806854248,
-0.031106634065508842,
-0.7362235188484192,
0.24941480159759521,
-0.9150903820991516,
-0.1484658271074295,
-0.11788717657327652,
-0.24582752585411072,
-0.29232341051101685,
0.1806984394788742,
0.3058200776576996,
0.5565183758735657,
-0.29923439025878906,
0.00671390863135457,
-0.2093387246131897,
-0.48146378993988037,
0.32403451204299927,
-0.5388445258140564,
0.9497660994529724,
0.2525060772895813,
-0.3979873061180115,
0.289436399936676,
-0.4754085838794708,
0.32960566878318787,
0.13516972959041595,
-0.12972840666770935,
-0.13827413320541382,
-0.034956663846969604,
-0.035840634256601334,
-0.16523970663547516,
0.5814135670661926,
-0.21519365906715393,
-0.2071855515241623,
-0.4661020338535309,
0.41710972785949707,
0.9217464923858643,
-0.03476419299840927,
0.2525396943092346,
-0.308784157037735,
0.6222466230392456,
0.008281336165964603,
0.5397414565086365,
0.062167707830667496,
-0.3450672924518585,
-0.8051750063896179,
-0.05690968036651611,
0.5009177923202515,
0.6547313332557678,
-0.6326096057891846,
0.6947516798973083,
-0.5071401596069336,
-0.5757120251655579,
-0.7936986684799194,
0.3882026672363281,
0.5388901829719543,
0.34890079498291016,
0.09285680204629898,
-0.7919254302978516,
-0.36079567670822144,
-0.8904317617416382,
-0.38185107707977295,
-0.3670593202114105,
-0.05790464207530022,
0.31292209029197693,
0.5223962664604187,
-0.32323306798934937,
0.5686275362968445,
-0.22387577593326569,
-0.11841156333684921,
0.04193548113107681,
0.16089943051338196,
-0.040593914687633514,
0.3056418299674988,
0.36367443203926086,
-0.4450652003288269,
-0.2707411050796509,
-0.0029939189553260803,
-0.8282475471496582,
-0.19888144731521606,
0.20199444890022278,
0.12887825071811676,
0.19812634587287903,
0.39796918630599976,
-0.32497790455818176,
0.23096908628940582,
0.828977108001709,
-0.2935720980167389,
0.6643121838569641,
-0.034597527235746384,
0.32910123467445374,
-0.8115940690040588,
-0.04716699570417404,
-0.05584552139043808,
-0.5454050898551941,
-0.26272496581077576,
0.4985162615776062,
-0.2221076339483261,
0.2269309014081955,
-0.4198931157588959,
0.4730997085571289,
-0.45862165093421936,
-0.5961551666259766,
-0.004015588201582432,
0.5654611587524414,
-0.06099661439657211,
0.06259268522262573,
-0.3155263066291809,
0.8218744993209839,
0.6645589470863342,
-0.24056053161621094,
0.49373793601989746,
0.061735063791275024,
-0.6049354672431946,
0.5950599312782288,
-0.5051313638687134,
0.33614814281463623,
0.19634464383125305,
-0.0018374185310676694,
-0.8797692060470581,
0.2715335190296173,
0.11816968768835068,
-0.5944249033927917,
0.18401795625686646,
0.04737160727381706,
-0.8020420074462891,
-0.10054200142621994,
-0.6547080278396606,
0.17369601130485535,
0.5851078033447266,
-0.5393736958503723,
0.40403681993484497,
0.45561033487319946,
-0.09627015143632889,
-0.7969616055488586,
-0.6866077184677124,
0.3138849139213562,
-0.28794464468955994,
-0.5537120699882507,
-0.000795952626504004,
-0.0952155590057373,
-0.6125215291976929,
-0.04866411164402962,
-0.0799475684762001,
-0.01318132784217596,
0.411173552274704,
0.16865365207195282,
0.20157717168331146,
-0.15462306141853333,
-0.16821755468845367,
-0.17377892136573792,
-0.09925199300050735,
0.25948506593704224,
-0.17092594504356384,
0.5080975294113159,
-0.5668610334396362,
-0.5282818078994751,
-0.5940994620323181,
-0.07994583994150162,
0.5183055996894836,
-0.0847848430275917,
0.3904825448989868,
0.8205342888832092,
-0.36875665187835693,
-0.19395284354686737,
-0.6549083590507507,
-0.23391474783420563,
-0.4436259865760803,
0.4448164403438568,
-0.24484139680862427,
-1.0713082551956177,
0.48295658826828003,
-0.39734071493148804,
0.09029629081487656,
0.24652409553527832,
0.8837090730667114,
-0.043369896709918976,
0.8448464274406433,
0.7714441418647766,
-0.3964093327522278,
0.2927413880825043,
-0.02983103320002556,
0.27375099062919617,
-0.6886159777641296,
-0.23015093803405762,
-0.5271094441413879,
-0.14235906302928925,
-0.6797606945037842,
-0.7138220071792603,
0.2169266790151596,
0.16668902337551117,
-0.04616590589284897,
0.005064245779067278,
-0.20118093490600586,
0.6004627346992493,
0.20789507031440735,
-0.28732532262802124,
0.7930017709732056,
0.10081295669078827,
-0.2184423953294754,
-0.28524473309516907,
-0.5201852321624756,
-0.9630297422409058,
1.2348542213439941,
0.9856119751930237,
0.8065447807312012,
0.07634218037128448,
0.6889023184776306,
0.4848313331604004,
0.5571678876876831,
-0.9827589988708496,
0.6022258996963501,
-0.015693005174398422,
-0.2635396718978882,
-0.499198853969574,
-0.6484988331794739,
-0.629322350025177,
0.2766854166984558,
-0.4239509701728821,
-0.8534652590751648,
-0.2851025462150574,
-0.08103926479816437,
-0.07740863412618637,
0.17484883964061737,
-0.739962100982666,
0.5972533822059631,
-0.4213067293167114,
-0.15752525627613068,
-0.3716014325618744,
-0.38844433426856995,
0.5083390474319458,
-0.03769176825881004,
0.20732511579990387,
0.04955058917403221,
-0.2398485392332077,
0.8159618377685547,
0.1338379830121994,
0.5985578298568726,
0.035787664353847504,
-0.1901063770055771,
-0.07711615413427353,
0.28345999121665955,
0.33218809962272644,
-0.0023852218873798847,
-0.3028189241886139,
0.6539203524589539,
0.21973773837089539,
-0.24036788940429688,
-0.9063707590103149,
0.8203708529472351,
-0.8283554315567017,
-0.5089356303215027,
-0.3737548589706421,
-0.5047202110290527,
-0.5806941986083984,
0.011172383092343807,
-0.08054689317941666,
-0.03470687195658684,
-0.42754077911376953,
0.15361514687538147,
0.6778863668441772,
-0.2107573300600052,
0.17531904578208923,
0.2929282486438751,
-0.4256099462509155,
-0.2981182038784027,
0.6725348830223083,
-0.21200744807720184,
0.2654297351837158,
0.29240554571151733,
0.2068466991186142,
-0.48921844363212585,
-0.9250832200050354,
-0.14743459224700928,
0.19970910251140594,
-0.8262994289398193,
-0.1274726390838623,
-0.10508744418621063,
-0.2725214958190918,
-0.39493605494499207,
0.1345290094614029,
-0.37070298194885254,
-0.42878103256225586,
-0.006799909286201,
-0.3353728652000427,
0.14096491038799286,
0.8320515155792236,
0.0016592706087976694,
0.3241664171218872,
-0.42847269773483276,
-0.0010262045543640852,
0.02835250273346901,
0.47047877311706543,
0.23664994537830353,
-0.44958287477493286,
-0.09501805156469345,
-0.20305326581001282,
-0.35357627272605896,
-0.5629146695137024,
0.18731056153774261,
-0.11490876972675323,
0.7804082036018372,
0.3481127917766571,
-0.41119685769081116,
0.7277344465255737,
-0.43315058946609497,
0.9325805902481079,
0.24750150740146637,
-1.3617137670516968,
0.31710878014564514,
-0.04911637678742409,
-0.2143908441066742,
0.6754695773124695,
0.3499578535556793,
-0.4346636235713959,
-0.42868462204933167,
-0.5533650517463684,
-0.6452940106391907,
0.19187095761299133,
0.4015022814273834,
-0.013895195908844471,
0.493330180644989,
0.4674079418182373,
-0.030475560575723648,
0.3068658709526062,
-0.7586411833763123,
-0.3354427218437195,
0.0623466931283474,
-0.3889698088169098,
-0.2777312397956848,
-0.2141430824995041,
-0.46348512172698975,
-0.01473529078066349,
0.43902555108070374,
-0.03146044909954071,
-0.017931951209902763,
0.048114217817783356,
-0.23518982529640198,
0.14869102835655212,
0.437770813703537,
0.49475517868995667,
1.2464783191680908,
-0.15245909988880157,
0.15246137976646423,
0.34554430842399597,
-0.40285414457321167,
-0.058277882635593414,
-0.15698212385177612,
-0.09561269730329514,
-0.18927311897277832,
0.6062842607498169,
0.5505417585372925,
0.02096025086939335,
-0.6059462428092957,
0.6376050114631653,
-0.13048844039440155,
-0.07131664454936981,
-0.29231852293014526,
-0.06217959150671959,
0.16930222511291504,
0.2740522623062134,
0.06930368393659592,
-0.28087466955184937,
0.28199130296707153,
-0.7079121470451355,
0.12185730040073395,
0.6184456944465637,
-0.5153493285179138,
-0.08509709686040878,
0.27858108282089233,
0.13841064274311066,
-0.34459811449050903,
0.2830069363117218,
0.017183149233460426,
-0.4927045404911041,
0.3375447988510132,
0.3418010175228119,
0.7946560382843018,
-0.28572598099708557,
0.20164209604263306,
-0.1605900377035141,
0.7978649139404297,
-0.12832415103912354,
0.2477680742740631,
0.024784240871667862,
-0.7109378576278687,
-0.4024398922920227,
-0.6443754434585571,
-0.871612548828125,
0.13861674070358276,
-0.59333336353302,
0.0002553631493356079,
-0.6498255133628845,
-0.27621281147003174,
-0.23068638145923615,
0.6453455090522766,
-0.6587992310523987,
0.047228917479515076,
0.1733834147453308,
1.0639539957046509,
-0.8191112279891968,
0.5563521385192871,
0.5380500555038452,
-0.17722444236278534,
-0.5665327310562134,
0.07138922810554504,
0.06388821452856064,
-1.043927550315857,
0.5153788924217224,
-0.17934611439704895,
-0.33059144020080566,
-0.2537338137626648,
-0.6353023648262024,
-0.618703305721283,
1.2291244268417358,
0.39326736330986023,
-0.5846766829490662,
0.3358589708805084,
0.15449121594429016,
0.8449364304542542,
-0.5251469612121582,
0.47630447149276733,
0.9104928374290466,
0.6801090240478516,
-0.17638881504535675,
-1.1175588369369507,
0.16831974685192108,
0.10504547506570816,
0.23462030291557312,
-0.3107825815677643,
-0.5539554953575134,
0.43337464332580566,
-0.003582464065402746,
-0.1577148735523224,
0.23931939899921417,
0.6549041271209717,
0.5428415536880493,
0.41433537006378174,
0.5839893221855164,
0.581719696521759,
1.0584189891815186,
0.0020241527818143368,
1.069213628768921,
-0.2107592225074768,
0.4175606071949005,
1.045069694519043,
-0.3624105751514435,
0.9952523112297058,
0.7278334498405457,
-0.2990076541900635,
0.45892831683158875,
0.560393214225769,
-0.08339175581932068,
0.09222811460494995,
0.6510054469108582,
0.05107792466878891,
-0.07828640937805176,
-0.18687166273593903,
-0.2169080227613449,
0.48792046308517456,
0.4004828631877899,
-0.33150461316108704,
-0.18628986179828644,
-0.3504219353199005,
0.2476140707731247,
0.3292354643344879,
-0.40076881647109985,
0.5785779356956482,
0.37431764602661133,
-0.348545640707016,
0.28268641233444214,
0.2051537036895752,
0.856553316116333,
-0.6044594645500183,
0.0580403096973896,
-0.10747157782316208,
0.16362032294273376,
-0.39315855503082275,
-0.9039562344551086,
0.1703532487154007,
0.04229992255568504,
0.113396555185318,
-0.24074338376522064,
0.6579528450965881,
-0.10198754817247391,
-0.4622783362865448,
0.5452837944030762,
0.8251624703407288,
0.3330613970756531,
0.21251286566257477,
-1.087275505065918,
0.4220203459262848,
-0.22467634081840515,
-0.19797590374946594,
0.27998921275138855,
0.2526329457759857,
-0.03660624101758003,
0.9810754656791687,
0.6203457713127136,
0.5954931378364563,
-0.06000770255923271,
0.3919375240802765,
0.5297458171844482,
-0.48208436369895935,
-0.2453005164861679,
-1.003319501876831,
0.04902937263250351,
-0.2143445909023285,
-0.13695287704467773,
1.1198538541793823,
0.47956332564353943,
0.8941592574119568,
0.22531142830848694,
0.6770271062850952,
0.4606528580188751,
0.41119569540023804,
-0.7094573974609375,
0.9025862216949463,
-0.3251875638961792,
0.42904236912727356,
-0.3879109025001526,
-1.0855257511138916,
-0.46152395009994507,
0.6824854612350464,
-0.4293162226676941,
0.12839415669441223,
0.7243055105209351,
0.8389567136764526,
0.20394200086593628,
-0.1313878744840622,
0.5175685882568359,
0.4110639989376068,
0.3810827136039734,
0.5269898772239685,
1.1919621229171753,
-0.4754369854927063,
0.36392420530319214,
-0.010793996974825859,
-0.49382615089416504,
0.042109787464141846,
-1.1199958324432373,
-0.8887154459953308,
-0.3480776846408844,
-0.3430180251598358,
-0.31047743558883667,
0.20291930437088013,
0.6543698310852051,
0.7670849561691284,
-0.7217146158218384,
-0.6735104322433472,
0.34058818221092224,
0.5742427706718445,
-0.21104128658771515,
-0.271003395318985,
0.35175275802612305,
-0.2624385952949524,
-0.7928032279014587,
0.29642748832702637,
0.32996147871017456,
-0.05810656026005745,
-0.8728607892990112,
-0.17268957197666168,
0.3771689832210541,
0.139735609292984,
0.7302461266517639,
-0.0900312140583992,
-0.85819011926651,
-0.2535315155982971,
-0.2283029705286026,
0.016769258305430412,
-0.09319262951612473,
0.697331428527832,
-0.4870409667491913,
0.2659679651260376,
0.49237674474716187,
0.775539755821228,
0.09530407190322876,
0.11504435539245605,
0.537705659866333,
-0.4351446330547333,
-0.1643093079328537,
0.3001779615879059,
0.26880961656570435,
0.5495280027389526,
-0.35265880823135376,
0.6212998628616333,
-0.04294056445360184,
-0.6706360578536987,
-1.0744664669036865,
0.1837528496980667,
-1.0321248769760132,
0.03433294594287872,
1.0773413181304932,
-0.365541934967041,
-0.23453211784362793,
-0.05770466476678848,
0.12761974334716797,
-0.14967624843120575,
-0.16422894597053528,
0.9028158783912659,
0.9949692487716675,
-0.15671437978744507,
-0.06038358062505722,
-0.7279179692268372,
0.6570889949798584,
0.3427473306655884,
-0.98802649974823,
-0.034785594791173935,
0.3245292901992798,
0.4174209535121918,
0.3360615074634552,
0.5073994994163513,
-0.6735583543777466,
-0.06417304277420044,
-0.23949995636940002,
-0.07106224447488785,
-0.04614492505788803,
-0.1510096788406372,
-0.7574761509895325,
0.0826556459069252,
0.4172382950782776,
0.03718331828713417
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.01940v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.01940v1
|
Process-Driven Autoformalization in Lean 4
| 2024-06-04T03:48:08 | 2024-06-04T03:48:08 |
Jianqiao Lu, Zhengying Liu, Yingjia Wan, Yinya Huang, Haiming Wang, Zhicheng Yang, Jing Tang, Zhijiang Guo
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.LO
|
Autoformalization, the conversion of natural language mathematics into formal
languages, offers significant potential for advancing mathematical reasoning.
However, existing efforts are limited to formal languages with substantial
online corpora and struggle to keep pace with rapidly evolving languages like
Lean 4. To bridge this gap, we propose a new benchmark \textbf{Form}alization
for \textbf{L}ean~\textbf{4} (\textbf{\name}) designed to evaluate the
autoformalization capabilities of large language models (LLMs). This benchmark
encompasses a comprehensive assessment of questions, answers, formal
statements, and proofs. Additionally, we introduce a
\textbf{P}rocess-\textbf{S}upervised \textbf{V}erifier (\textbf{PSV}) model
that leverages the precise feedback from Lean 4 compilers to enhance
autoformalization. Our experiments demonstrate that the PSV method improves
autoformalization, enabling higher accuracy using less filtered training data.
Furthermore, when fine-tuned with data containing detailed process information,
PSV can leverage the data more effectively, leading to more significant
improvements in autoformalization for Lean 4. Our dataset and code are
available at \url{https://github.com/rookie-joe/PDA}.
|
[
-0.0017167555633932352,
-0.4951010048389435,
0.6690096855163574,
0.23282870650291443,
-0.09892640262842178,
0.02829085662961006,
-0.26924461126327515,
-0.33697375655174255,
-0.16363675892353058,
0.214647576212883,
-0.6992620825767517,
-0.42562106251716614,
-0.2849247455596924,
0.2709057331085205,
-0.10663828998804092,
0.7895719408988953,
-0.7391587495803833,
0.16873472929000854,
-0.31278011202812195,
0.012072962708771229,
-0.026236290112137794,
-0.49811214208602905,
-0.2804185152053833,
-0.2598564326763153,
0.06621544063091278,
0.15084968507289886,
0.5076360106468201,
0.9466172456741333,
0.5397228598594666,
0.42903321981430054,
0.48622116446495056,
-0.02419385500252247,
-0.38460034132003784,
0.5453639626502991,
0.4034891128540039,
-0.5353783369064331,
-0.6955816149711609,
0.073486328125,
0.756881058216095,
0.595382571220398,
-0.41639000177383423,
0.21713951230049133,
-0.1790609210729599,
0.7130078673362732,
-0.6572942733764648,
0.610668420791626,
-0.5547862648963928,
0.20346064865589142,
-0.3049356937408447,
-0.05162888765335083,
-0.020659539848566055,
-0.612481415271759,
-0.18844932317733765,
-0.6323006749153137,
0.2784639894962311,
-0.13010163605213165,
0.9422869682312012,
0.6594812273979187,
0.022476473823189735,
-0.03105502389371395,
-0.923514187335968,
0.627234160900116,
-0.6565558910369873,
0.707332968711853,
0.2225111424922943,
0.47617658972740173,
0.0619453527033329,
-0.8909060955047607,
-0.375150591135025,
0.12781678140163422,
0.5340741872787476,
0.23215599358081818,
-0.1670057475566864,
0.1049899309873581,
0.4802435040473938,
0.46935227513313293,
-0.4809603691101074,
0.051673926413059235,
-0.5230002403259277,
-0.3284830152988434,
0.7144528031349182,
0.06951911747455597,
0.023262962698936462,
0.2163556069135666,
-0.13129131495952606,
-0.017492985352873802,
-0.6622748970985413,
0.04239954054355621,
0.3988214135169983,
-0.022487744688987732,
0.07186887413263321,
0.5400496125221252,
-0.47420254349708557,
0.725525438785553,
0.24837689101696014,
0.007140903268009424,
0.5125194191932678,
-0.41947969794273376,
-0.6438117623329163,
-0.12020598351955414,
0.7025284767150879,
-0.00533559313043952,
0.08364808559417725,
-0.06400655955076218,
-0.5635846257209778,
0.05885488912463188,
0.1693698763847351,
-1.0011615753173828,
-0.5323007106781006,
0.005368704907596111,
-0.343289852142334,
-0.21929311752319336,
0.01198639441281557,
-0.30937591195106506,
-0.0581916980445385,
-0.7155534625053406,
0.08413968980312347,
-0.3026306927204132,
-0.041516367346048355,
0.005025004968047142,
0.23887519538402557,
0.7122796773910522,
0.5880273580551147,
-0.8591299653053284,
0.35728806257247925,
0.7691638469696045,
0.6764335632324219,
-0.13742613792419434,
-0.045227475464344025,
-0.8289853930473328,
0.045697931200265884,
-0.38567593693733215,
0.8907331228256226,
-0.40153419971466064,
0.1660132110118866,
-0.011335605755448341,
-0.11230605095624924,
0.08656451851129532,
-0.7242069244384766,
0.670466959476471,
-0.35493552684783936,
0.15887776017189026,
-0.26948654651641846,
-0.5225163698196411,
0.041439466178417206,
-0.03651897609233856,
-0.6474115252494812,
1.523028016090393,
-0.02036084607243538,
-0.1385737955570221,
0.6486904621124268,
-0.3434514105319977,
-0.3457982838153839,
0.17225806415081024,
-0.6451005935668945,
-0.7225412726402283,
0.2828569710254669,
0.09842458367347717,
0.5227192640304565,
-0.3697396218776703,
0.38164451718330383,
-0.729666531085968,
-0.10428451746702194,
0.1161932423710823,
-0.35066768527030945,
0.4378613233566284,
0.32676345109939575,
-0.6761667728424072,
0.1984567940235138,
-0.9783772230148315,
0.3351839482784271,
-0.21068207919597626,
-0.2326892465353012,
-0.031710173934698105,
-0.059981394559144974,
-0.3898584544658661,
0.547513484954834,
0.4493958055973053,
-0.36788442730903625,
0.13677892088890076,
-0.3919767439365387,
0.3505568206310272,
0.9021117687225342,
-0.23124687373638153,
0.5118348002433777,
-0.21275626122951508,
0.6427392959594727,
-0.0645504742860794,
0.17057865858078003,
0.036178115755319595,
-0.5347802042961121,
-0.9300110936164856,
-0.49274009466171265,
0.028838522732257843,
0.39058375358581543,
-0.4677577018737793,
0.575803816318512,
0.17428644001483917,
-0.4644412398338318,
-0.41387152671813965,
0.477775901556015,
0.20122338831424713,
0.39326533675193787,
0.24052122235298157,
-0.2840609848499298,
-0.6630464196205139,
-0.9917546510696411,
-0.2023562341928482,
-0.18468952178955078,
-0.35857152938842773,
0.028708552941679955,
0.3343234062194824,
-0.17875611782073975,
0.8789194822311401,
-0.5657975673675537,
-0.20096194744110107,
0.08692541718482971,
0.5083677768707275,
0.23820199072360992,
0.3098909258842468,
0.3149639368057251,
-0.519728422164917,
-0.40121495723724365,
-0.3479064702987671,
-0.7557767033576965,
-0.53078293800354,
-0.01898893155157566,
-0.2515725791454315,
0.45782169699668884,
0.694054901599884,
-0.23566512763500214,
0.4782814383506775,
0.5650867819786072,
-0.09334728866815567,
0.587781548500061,
-0.3187645971775055,
0.05142892897129059,
-0.7663540840148926,
0.10926956683397293,
0.08743097633123398,
-0.22274746000766754,
-0.34389403462409973,
-0.36919188499450684,
0.18994978070259094,
-0.48474064469337463,
-0.2238905429840088,
-0.05482887849211693,
-0.8067986965179443,
-0.47075292468070984,
0.10913629829883575,
-0.14339616894721985,
-0.03880755975842476,
0.37091153860092163,
0.18347296118736267,
0.5932596921920776,
0.679640531539917,
-0.6151264309883118,
0.5344834923744202,
-0.2563817799091339,
-0.16455461084842682,
0.6778146028518677,
-0.8796373009681702,
0.08616979420185089,
-0.19758200645446777,
0.3409744203090668,
-1.035558819770813,
-0.11393594741821289,
0.05999467521905899,
-0.146108940243721,
0.27396875619888306,
-0.018403561785817146,
-0.5793710947036743,
-0.1250753402709961,
-0.24984218180179596,
0.35294631123542786,
0.4186212420463562,
-0.16530199348926544,
0.7284583449363708,
0.4520835876464844,
-0.23738670349121094,
-0.10652467608451843,
-0.576647937297821,
-0.20517173409461975,
0.008672960102558136,
-0.813650369644165,
0.42963239550590515,
-0.5407299399375916,
-0.2284511774778366,
-0.25470268726348877,
-0.4653577506542206,
-0.45788058638572693,
0.00957808643579483,
0.20059408247470856,
0.4568822979927063,
-0.2681941092014313,
0.017006851732730865,
0.009957061149179935,
-0.023131640627980232,
0.29650023579597473,
-0.4379996955394745,
0.25166985392570496,
-0.45020368695259094,
-0.2933216392993927,
-0.6620287299156189,
0.07122179120779037,
0.6439775824546814,
-0.4329099655151367,
0.4412356913089752,
0.4779851734638214,
-0.6815724968910217,
-0.3428056538105011,
-0.5810791850090027,
-0.2308761030435562,
-0.49316176772117615,
0.1041131392121315,
-0.6225975751876831,
-0.5991047620773315,
0.6414871215820312,
-0.24755486845970154,
0.30776578187942505,
0.5537739396095276,
0.7793987989425659,
0.033599499613046646,
1.0987313985824585,
0.41186797618865967,
0.29498639702796936,
0.33459749817848206,
-0.26823097467422485,
0.30747395753860474,
-0.3664923310279846,
-0.40298470854759216,
-0.6862373948097229,
-0.1108081117272377,
-0.45155349373817444,
-0.8350512981414795,
0.2329247146844864,
0.0675928145647049,
-0.22646813094615936,
0.38677525520324707,
-0.3171810507774353,
0.20560429990291595,
-0.09049954265356064,
-0.32068225741386414,
0.35404354333877563,
-0.10193131864070892,
-0.3239992558956146,
-0.45994624495506287,
-0.7517662644386292,
-0.2721981108188629,
0.9016388058662415,
0.6574656367301941,
0.951671302318573,
0.04382265731692314,
0.8787468671798706,
0.09269754588603973,
0.5522042512893677,
-0.7214522361755371,
0.4404173493385315,
0.09866345673799515,
-0.3712809085845947,
-0.2987769842147827,
-0.6475664377212524,
-0.4602227210998535,
-0.019253086298704147,
-0.04400886222720146,
-0.21020455658435822,
0.09890492260456085,
0.23689381778240204,
-0.40069860219955444,
-0.050354406237602234,
-0.5982247591018677,
0.8564708232879639,
-0.648388683795929,
-0.5082213282585144,
0.028335919603705406,
-0.18988384306430817,
0.2192777842283249,
-0.27991825342178345,
0.2424936443567276,
-0.2103223204612732,
-0.27108654379844666,
0.6791781187057495,
-0.8876131176948547,
0.7839800715446472,
-0.08121801912784576,
-0.5364084839820862,
0.08083789050579071,
-0.08543967455625534,
0.5477305054664612,
0.03468814864754677,
-0.1376481056213379,
0.11972028762102127,
-0.3367304503917694,
-0.2724263072013855,
-0.8622866272926331,
0.8886820673942566,
-0.8348214626312256,
-0.04319862276315689,
-0.6588918566703796,
-0.08420223742723465,
-0.2798973321914673,
0.23867227137088776,
0.12524084746837616,
0.4601227939128876,
-0.038864023983478546,
0.09393110871315002,
0.8471764922142029,
0.11566866189241409,
0.3571898937225342,
0.7199140787124634,
0.07079333066940308,
-0.5437122583389282,
0.4817347526550293,
0.17567618191242218,
0.1924767792224884,
0.30246129631996155,
-0.050485994666814804,
-0.6030609607696533,
-0.30516067147254944,
-0.4209926426410675,
0.41523197293281555,
-0.7700406908988953,
-0.35922354459762573,
-0.29848310351371765,
-0.12818825244903564,
-0.6043529510498047,
-0.09315116703510284,
-0.878535270690918,
-0.49074801802635193,
-0.2521628737449646,
-0.008627133443951607,
0.051555875688791275,
0.6995646357536316,
0.019119907170534134,
-0.29092690348625183,
-0.43684130907058716,
0.22655880451202393,
0.3068118691444397,
0.7828147411346436,
-0.5081248879432678,
-0.5710925459861755,
-0.203507661819458,
-0.25984296202659607,
-0.23147885501384735,
-0.7274727821350098,
0.2619890868663788,
0.412747859954834,
0.7864475846290588,
0.5060334205627441,
0.019342171028256416,
0.8352344632148743,
-0.6370165348052979,
0.4008146822452545,
0.2635231614112854,
-1.048421859741211,
0.5724804997444153,
-0.18106995522975922,
0.36526399850845337,
0.737170934677124,
0.5579802989959717,
-0.18808208405971527,
-0.28997111320495605,
-0.647061288356781,
-0.8976649641990662,
0.4330161213874817,
0.26812198758125305,
-0.3879474103450775,
0.2512941360473633,
0.3756949305534363,
0.05374648794531822,
0.38004806637763977,
-0.6029442548751831,
-0.247696653008461,
-0.2810881435871124,
-0.12264721840620041,
0.257289856672287,
0.049818843603134155,
0.045996177941560745,
-0.39392679929733276,
0.7819777131080627,
-0.3010766804218292,
0.400842547416687,
0.2208164781332016,
-0.13370639085769653,
-0.35926923155784607,
-0.06261088699102402,
0.5680886507034302,
0.7825967073440552,
-0.053857527673244476,
-0.007249835412949324,
0.04718230664730072,
-0.26238560676574707,
0.09349898993968964,
0.487343966960907,
-0.15243138372898102,
0.034841954708099365,
0.015356897376477718,
0.8117607235908508,
0.5227658152580261,
-0.4405245780944824,
0.30441901087760925,
-0.2622523009777069,
-0.5170588493347168,
-0.802617073059082,
-0.07244618237018585,
-0.4560454189777374,
0.0710008293390274,
0.4694480895996094,
0.09094303101301193,
0.22333836555480957,
-0.4502719044685364,
0.44813552498817444,
0.20571398735046387,
-0.37237411737442017,
-0.5329582095146179,
0.8637295365333557,
0.4147228002548218,
-0.13211719691753387,
0.41405364871025085,
-0.19051501154899597,
-0.5660765171051025,
0.25784504413604736,
0.3653908967971802,
1.0098882913589478,
-0.32232946157455444,
0.12402479350566864,
0.594444215297699,
0.15126487612724304,
-0.18394321203231812,
0.4928942620754242,
-0.34822607040405273,
-0.4812968373298645,
-0.883703351020813,
-0.7476004362106323,
-0.3358664810657501,
0.30406710505485535,
-0.5432426929473877,
0.5699556469917297,
-0.7456017732620239,
-0.028426170349121094,
-0.06339395046234131,
0.028530091047286987,
-0.8123074769973755,
0.18733187019824982,
0.4151553809642792,
0.6543437838554382,
-0.959316611289978,
0.713533341884613,
0.8443630337715149,
-0.3270455300807953,
-0.9702513217926025,
-0.06295416504144669,
0.1169220432639122,
-0.6120145916938782,
0.8465741276741028,
0.15224994719028473,
-0.291800320148468,
-0.12762674689292908,
-0.3433400094509125,
-1.0215758085250854,
1.104569673538208,
0.48897626996040344,
-0.7838372588157654,
-0.03816501051187515,
0.14515863358974457,
0.45598137378692627,
-0.43282350897789,
0.42266646027565,
0.5581123232841492,
0.43728944659233093,
0.25416138768196106,
-0.95322585105896,
0.05254831165075302,
-0.4321024715900421,
0.01420228835195303,
0.276562362909317,
-0.5319434404373169,
0.6861530542373657,
-0.04210684075951576,
-0.06978114694356918,
-0.17102526128292084,
1.0965685844421387,
0.4985540211200714,
0.13019463419914246,
0.4303402602672577,
0.6984694004058838,
0.9380379915237427,
-0.2167823761701584,
0.6829919219017029,
-0.37524014711380005,
0.29582518339157104,
0.9107503294944763,
-0.6264709830284119,
0.6148532629013062,
0.30235105752944946,
-0.24032647907733917,
0.7358578443527222,
0.5082898736000061,
0.06536182016134262,
0.14783905446529388,
0.5064176321029663,
-0.24401043355464935,
-0.36365482211112976,
0.4428049623966217,
-0.27410587668418884,
0.6710022687911987,
0.19487829506397247,
-0.24314184486865997,
-0.1858719438314438,
-0.35777804255485535,
0.09223608672618866,
0.04247355833649635,
-0.26105228066444397,
0.5310486555099487,
-0.06726086884737015,
-0.9214038252830505,
0.7902669310569763,
0.07994087040424347,
0.447311669588089,
-0.7184045314788818,
-0.13434502482414246,
-0.1516992598772049,
0.32700008153915405,
-0.255074679851532,
-0.39405497908592224,
0.42557433247566223,
0.04682041332125664,
-0.12099345028400421,
-0.8165620565414429,
0.6125696301460266,
-0.5461138486862183,
-0.5218404531478882,
-0.15873384475708008,
0.33676621317863464,
0.2931710183620453,
0.09399565309286118,
-0.9072456359863281,
0.40446937084198,
-0.17369778454303741,
-0.049461670219898224,
0.07971761375665665,
0.7634803056716919,
-0.10500431805849075,
0.582452118396759,
0.6200435757637024,
0.17353206872940063,
0.06658369302749634,
0.3684055507183075,
0.8738089799880981,
-0.4617985486984253,
-0.6973856091499329,
-0.6057504415512085,
0.36228683590888977,
-0.16414406895637512,
-0.3331787586212158,
0.9062106013298035,
1.0552928447723389,
0.7148652076721191,
-0.016456052660942078,
0.7333789467811584,
-0.006464985199272633,
0.21806345880031586,
-0.5818601250648499,
0.5168922543525696,
-0.3213605284690857,
0.34340545535087585,
-0.4575710892677307,
-1.0456691980361938,
-0.2871403098106384,
0.927476704120636,
-0.4379843771457672,
0.17743948101997375,
0.805804967880249,
0.5388078093528748,
-0.07512788474559784,
-0.13697917759418488,
0.233403742313385,
0.1370643675327301,
0.4444042146205902,
0.39541104435920715,
0.4688150882720947,
-0.45921435952186584,
0.7063834071159363,
-0.2497108429670334,
-0.6584396362304688,
-0.03668491914868355,
-1.1979299783706665,
-0.5917549133300781,
-0.7098617553710938,
-0.6816714406013489,
-0.30702799558639526,
-0.1951523870229721,
0.6677919626235962,
0.8494073748588562,
-0.7437834739685059,
-0.48393514752388,
-0.4529990255832672,
-0.418758362531662,
-0.126034215092659,
-0.2595941722393036,
0.010258895345032215,
-0.5559669733047485,
-0.6324576139450073,
0.40365299582481384,
0.5501408576965332,
-0.03147789463400841,
-0.6521201729774475,
-0.22228968143463135,
0.11914816498756409,
-0.05230548977851868,
0.41541698575019836,
0.4325157105922699,
-0.37050774693489075,
0.068045973777771,
0.39769449830055237,
0.11726943403482437,
0.06570253521203995,
1.2216041088104248,
-0.8325129151344299,
0.4709905982017517,
0.5870562195777893,
0.6778393387794495,
0.7699103355407715,
-0.06816156953573227,
1.116389513015747,
-0.5239738821983337,
-0.10671278834342957,
0.46238282322883606,
0.42816275358200073,
0.4262906312942505,
-0.253268301486969,
0.27533403038978577,
0.5537734031677246,
-0.7105231881141663,
-0.6166517734527588,
0.3625621199607849,
-0.6452121734619141,
0.2796440124511719,
1.0259147882461548,
-0.06723187863826752,
-0.3163500130176544,
-0.1690300852060318,
0.21277926862239838,
0.32030680775642395,
-0.5793974995613098,
0.6987575888633728,
0.6783657670021057,
-0.3942754566669464,
-0.121308334171772,
-0.470029354095459,
0.8917315602302551,
0.5117422938346863,
-1.0305598974227905,
0.1513686329126358,
0.8048577904701233,
0.285275399684906,
-0.07060671597719193,
0.8324806094169617,
-0.2857660949230194,
0.4226476550102234,
-0.47378748655319214,
0.1392277479171753,
0.05110881105065346,
-0.25241583585739136,
-0.5101183652877808,
-0.12514032423496246,
0.060303907841444016,
0.15045447647571564
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.01934v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.01934v2
|
Optimal Transport Guided Correlation Assignment for Multimodal Entity Linking
| 2024-06-04T03:35:25 | 2024-06-05T12:13:56 |
Zefeng Zhang, Jiawei Sheng, Chuang Zhang, Yunzhi Liang, Wenyuan Zhang, Siqi Wang, Tingwen Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Multimodal Entity Linking (MEL) aims to link ambiguous mentions in multimodal
contexts to entities in a multimodal knowledge graph. A pivotal challenge is to
fully leverage multi-element correlations between mentions and entities to
bridge modality gap and enable fine-grained semantic matching. Existing methods
attempt several local correlative mechanisms, relying heavily on the
automatically learned attention weights, which may over-concentrate on partial
correlations. To mitigate this issue, we formulate the correlation assignment
problem as an optimal transport (OT) problem, and propose a novel MEL
framework, namely OT-MEL, with OT-guided correlation assignment. Thereby, we
exploit the correlation between multimodal features to enhance multimodal
fusion, and the correlation between mentions and entities to enhance
fine-grained matching. To accelerate model prediction, we further leverage
knowledge distillation to transfer OT assignment knowledge to attention
mechanism. Experimental results show that our model significantly outperforms
previous state-of-the-art baselines and confirm the effectiveness of the
OT-guided correlation assignment.
|
[
-0.5937346816062927,
-0.7766563892364502,
0.7852447628974915,
0.13554488122463226,
-0.370918869972229,
-0.1381962150335312,
-0.026000209152698517,
-0.647006630897522,
0.2709977924823761,
0.2166108638048172,
-0.4380776584148407,
-0.08722854405641556,
-0.49412453174591064,
-0.1180030032992363,
-0.38055220246315,
0.9950659275054932,
-0.06133826822042465,
-0.40311476588249207,
-0.5823303461074829,
-0.21564379334449768,
-0.48379814624786377,
-0.11218759417533875,
-0.795640766620636,
0.010114134289324284,
0.8553048968315125,
0.27809667587280273,
0.6330263614654541,
0.6662117838859558,
1.0240610837936401,
0.2963676154613495,
-0.07552527636289597,
0.44585493206977844,
-0.44439542293548584,
0.06014608219265938,
-0.5936879515647888,
-0.49679461121559143,
-0.6574071049690247,
-0.43767330050468445,
0.41875478625297546,
0.7421813011169434,
-0.17650708556175232,
0.41864895820617676,
-0.15070003271102905,
0.606825053691864,
-0.8919023275375366,
0.05675685033202171,
-0.8887250423431396,
-0.10197178274393082,
-0.5061408281326294,
-0.40906041860580444,
-0.33081310987472534,
-0.21456721425056458,
0.2899855971336365,
-0.9600383639335632,
0.04392910376191139,
0.7607352137565613,
0.7903763651847839,
0.47836002707481384,
-1.131439447402954,
-0.1819244623184204,
-0.7417606115341187,
0.6432811617851257,
0.0482352152466774,
0.1839505434036255,
0.509118378162384,
0.3576464354991913,
0.16120098531246185,
-0.6697733402252197,
-0.3663722276687622,
-0.07097017765045166,
-0.12847977876663208,
0.055165741592645645,
-0.0681661069393158,
0.03285994753241539,
-0.20854799449443817,
0.24738094210624695,
-0.4833427667617798,
-0.23673275113105774,
-0.4495096802711487,
-0.3670269846916199,
0.45155104994773865,
0.35874849557876587,
0.21827276051044464,
0.16721110045909882,
-1.0388360023498535,
0.12129436433315277,
-0.3908342719078064,
-0.2198859304189682,
0.0004525043477769941,
0.09008011966943741,
-0.12089885771274567,
0.7523084878921509,
0.02702385000884533,
0.7069128751754761,
0.33975785970687866,
-0.06941104680299759,
0.2983340620994568,
-0.7099509239196777,
0.05430997163057327,
0.3472733199596405,
0.9171640276908875,
0.7246394753456116,
0.12322743982076645,
-0.3169819116592407,
0.12753035128116608,
0.09846176952123642,
0.31501084566116333,
-0.5790407061576843,
-0.0994178056716919,
-0.17448166012763977,
-0.20244042575359344,
-0.30738893151283264,
-0.3000270128250122,
-0.9727014899253845,
-0.11894115805625916,
-0.21861489117145538,
0.8941933512687683,
-0.502405047416687,
-0.28960341215133667,
0.09594564139842987,
-0.12400087714195251,
-0.2694415748119354,
0.19989903271198273,
-1.2150973081588745,
-0.0161733441054821,
0.19784142076969147,
0.8863787651062012,
-0.13113553822040558,
-0.18809345364570618,
-0.27283862233161926,
0.8877679705619812,
-0.08525434136390686,
0.9485118985176086,
-0.6927931308746338,
-0.19360299408435822,
-0.22232398390769958,
-0.1369151622056961,
-0.41673314571380615,
-0.24120792746543884,
0.5296886563301086,
-0.47356799244880676,
-0.06096820533275604,
-0.15935666859149933,
-0.4128936529159546,
-0.017131207510828972,
0.22637170553207397,
-0.5585926175117493,
0.8117446899414062,
0.17075690627098083,
-0.764336884021759,
0.0894765853881836,
-0.8172587752342224,
-0.735379695892334,
-0.42176878452301025,
0.2302679568529129,
-0.39231517910957336,
-0.0787142887711525,
0.10052209347486496,
0.3585548400878906,
-0.39913782477378845,
0.3727250397205353,
-0.6551950573921204,
0.004753579385578632,
0.08219277858734131,
-0.15722395479679108,
0.5738950967788696,
0.4143739938735962,
-0.012112777680158615,
0.08560284972190857,
-0.9049888253211975,
-0.38574057817459106,
-0.06297735124826431,
-0.18928171694278717,
-0.8564135432243347,
-0.2617688477039337,
-0.1767272800207138,
0.14490705728530884,
0.23912037909030914,
-0.43950575590133667,
0.16046389937400818,
-0.14661917090415955,
0.3948919177055359,
0.8550779223442078,
0.061201054602861404,
1.007334589958191,
-0.18734848499298096,
0.25319746136665344,
0.44890865683555603,
0.3737637400627136,
0.01484209205955267,
-0.4826015532016754,
-0.42081692814826965,
-0.15355682373046875,
0.0863657146692276,
0.21833187341690063,
-0.8099671006202698,
0.08858510106801987,
-0.42998459935188293,
-0.37975263595581055,
-0.6514120101928711,
-0.039761513471603394,
0.1552107185125351,
1.0183542966842651,
0.6056309342384338,
-0.21037429571151733,
-0.2685442268848419,
-0.9977322816848755,
0.2407180219888687,
-0.16263730823993683,
0.2554887533187866,
0.4273586571216583,
0.20229221880435944,
-0.19240443408489227,
0.7753208875656128,
-0.7810518145561218,
-0.8594636917114258,
0.28543657064437866,
0.11553101986646652,
-0.5469376444816589,
0.44710320234298706,
0.8318469524383545,
-0.8531824350357056,
-0.6067156791687012,
0.1385977864265442,
-0.5174725651741028,
0.07429981976747513,
-0.019679030403494835,
-0.8944096565246582,
-0.23072940111160278,
0.6053586006164551,
-0.7133488655090332,
0.001831584027968347,
0.5788321495056152,
-0.4053955674171448,
0.14248602092266083,
-0.22574490308761597,
0.18092341721057892,
-1.4521161317825317,
0.3833106756210327,
-0.052036628127098083,
-0.24382685124874115,
-0.3537789285182953,
-0.1973842829465866,
-0.06236107647418976,
-0.06303942203521729,
-0.3163333237171173,
0.5238803625106812,
-0.438785582780838,
0.16867120563983917,
-0.046853795647621155,
0.6431067585945129,
0.03278770670294762,
0.692343533039093,
-0.22294451296329498,
0.3649764955043793,
0.7104382514953613,
-0.6475852131843567,
0.48012471199035645,
0.48992666602134705,
-0.24089108407497406,
0.9902204275131226,
-0.13258951902389526,
0.07709907740354538,
-0.3921419680118561,
0.1998826265335083,
-1.2286350727081299,
0.05790109559893608,
0.1787601113319397,
-0.17044030129909515,
0.38593125343322754,
-0.03379744663834572,
-0.18436263501644135,
0.045745234936475754,
-0.0954211950302124,
1.0132856369018555,
0.17863531410694122,
-0.35850268602371216,
0.9415556788444519,
0.5079526305198669,
0.08801534026861191,
-0.5974711179733276,
-0.7069361209869385,
-0.2712191939353943,
-0.41162198781967163,
-0.7748391628265381,
0.7816096544265747,
-0.12913024425506592,
0.14129407703876495,
0.5007936358451843,
-0.3135528266429901,
-0.1831357479095459,
0.17298981547355652,
0.25196003913879395,
0.2652236223220825,
-0.3054969310760498,
0.16563723981380463,
0.1410624235868454,
-0.25547751784324646,
0.12200983613729477,
-0.04756052419543266,
0.3176528513431549,
0.13444438576698303,
-0.2924197018146515,
-0.2433537244796753,
0.24965164065361023,
0.9172766208648682,
-0.406372606754303,
0.8614288568496704,
1.353549838066101,
0.09161890298128128,
0.3591199219226837,
-0.4266338348388672,
-0.04283202812075615,
-0.4677700698375702,
0.4636554718017578,
-0.560655951499939,
-0.6986885666847229,
0.4396798014640808,
-0.3303360044956207,
-0.18508793413639069,
0.37461984157562256,
0.08686131983995438,
-0.18333937227725983,
0.814423143863678,
0.705206036567688,
-0.2043176293373108,
0.5658066868782043,
0.03223314508795738,
0.364785373210907,
-1.201475739479065,
-0.5133566856384277,
-0.4031742513179779,
-0.550880491733551,
-0.47562769055366516,
-0.33905476331710815,
0.5252518057823181,
0.07142224162817001,
-0.08694694191217422,
0.4265303313732147,
-0.38751837611198425,
0.05435822159051895,
0.6925190687179565,
0.4371521472930908,
0.3957727253437042,
0.058346763253211975,
-0.4670397639274597,
0.30986735224723816,
-0.8295102119445801,
0.12464555352926254,
1.1333281993865967,
-0.0860472023487091,
0.8347635865211487,
0.40364858508110046,
0.27508974075317383,
0.14920520782470703,
0.14091475307941437,
-0.3421823978424072,
0.6938408017158508,
0.009051144123077393,
-0.8780981302261353,
-0.1809525191783905,
-0.5225599408149719,
-1.0872828960418701,
-0.00793753657490015,
-0.4747609496116638,
-0.6929886341094971,
0.1544221192598343,
0.4680992662906647,
-0.3952923119068146,
0.36856070160865784,
-0.9137557148933411,
0.8951924443244934,
-0.02135622873902321,
-0.636043131351471,
-0.49983784556388855,
-1.1222965717315674,
0.448711633682251,
-0.17089803516864777,
0.269692063331604,
-0.2536567449569702,
-0.04714656621217728,
0.29242178797721863,
-0.02620812878012657,
0.4541562497615814,
0.18728512525558472,
-0.0976426750421524,
0.35248231887817383,
0.0864824652671814,
0.48570752143859863,
-0.20019793510437012,
0.18350985646247864,
-0.14829286932945251,
-0.10215730965137482,
-0.23992624878883362,
-0.6258909702301025,
0.8860905766487122,
-0.6661531925201416,
-0.30239495635032654,
0.07248932123184204,
-0.6760129332542419,
-0.16772118210792542,
0.012518651783466339,
0.12772677838802338,
0.5575499534606934,
0.08073105663061142,
0.17286036908626556,
0.7300240397453308,
-0.02201824076473713,
0.5246656537055969,
0.4247094988822937,
-0.22777773439884186,
-0.3772454559803009,
1.1571452617645264,
-0.28660356998443604,
0.535078763961792,
1.0417472124099731,
-0.022165127098560333,
-0.46395331621170044,
-0.3041563332080841,
-0.4170507788658142,
0.10197839885950089,
-0.6014392375946045,
-0.1506243199110031,
-0.7288186550140381,
-0.05394347384572029,
-0.2250768542289734,
-0.1940896064043045,
-0.5293087363243103,
-0.2669616937637329,
-0.3525516092777252,
0.07068417966365814,
0.3775981664657593,
-0.04733824357390404,
-0.10737484693527222,
0.13147082924842834,
-0.6512763500213623,
0.4451523721218109,
0.5533186197280884,
0.36202165484428406,
0.026841523125767708,
-0.3234626352787018,
-0.37370336055755615,
-0.0542687326669693,
-0.4066983461380005,
-0.648090124130249,
-0.18466292321681976,
0.20424826443195343,
0.5293166637420654,
0.613601565361023,
0.3961971700191498,
1.1455557346343994,
-0.5426870584487915,
0.49986711144447327,
0.366722971200943,
-0.527882993221283,
0.4949531853199005,
-0.23279793560504913,
0.08701279014348984,
0.38989779353141785,
0.47463980317115784,
-0.09306403994560242,
-0.448367178440094,
-0.34845277667045593,
-1.1100773811340332,
0.46716558933258057,
0.505374550819397,
-0.06026652455329895,
-0.13649362325668335,
0.02924865297973156,
-0.1319817304611206,
0.28013312816619873,
-0.6227307319641113,
-0.45419102907180786,
0.25423961877822876,
-0.4591709077358246,
-0.05044107139110565,
-0.23399531841278076,
-0.11537260562181473,
-0.024713553488254547,
0.641497790813446,
0.015561246313154697,
0.5418617725372314,
0.24628694355487823,
-0.40006300806999207,
-0.3073684871196747,
0.07779566943645477,
1.0293381214141846,
0.4855506420135498,
-0.3994518518447876,
0.5363261103630066,
-0.059664901345968246,
-0.41428056359291077,
0.226711243391037,
0.04570425674319267,
0.003899604082107544,
-0.01530766673386097,
-0.03775276243686676,
1.0941078662872314,
0.26173701882362366,
-0.3394649922847748,
0.3342478573322296,
0.30544528365135193,
-0.05517251044511795,
-0.015514915809035301,
0.0645272508263588,
0.16084563732147217,
0.33671480417251587,
0.20532362163066864,
0.7469351291656494,
0.09725586324930191,
-0.43513384461402893,
0.12563756108283997,
0.49401381611824036,
-0.4584544599056244,
-0.35422471165657043,
1.1773788928985596,
0.5652390122413635,
-0.016715150326490402,
0.33020853996276855,
0.04493507742881775,
-0.02094137854874134,
0.36375537514686584,
0.45422250032424927,
0.5898305177688599,
-0.3132331967353821,
0.02375771291553974,
0.4796581268310547,
0.2477305382490158,
0.006269652396440506,
-0.29355764389038086,
-0.13265903294086456,
-0.6601601243019104,
-0.2519190311431885,
-0.36913466453552246,
0.03884304314851761,
-0.250730037689209,
-0.7528288960456848,
0.4489736258983612,
0.019752351567149162,
-0.5332933664321899,
0.1477149873971939,
-0.5073826909065247,
-0.6375772356987,
-0.011314130388200283,
0.18560580909252167,
0.4919123947620392,
-0.7759573459625244,
0.6677134037017822,
0.7690760493278503,
-0.5435936450958252,
-0.5372930765151978,
-0.4025837182998657,
0.058645494282245636,
-0.7530059218406677,
0.3973362147808075,
-0.10886295884847641,
-0.1868855357170105,
0.44910910725593567,
-0.04748471453785896,
-1.2115929126739502,
1.3720064163208008,
0.5256423354148865,
-0.671520471572876,
-0.14988254010677338,
0.017719220370054245,
0.1667514443397522,
-0.2848150134086609,
0.5665152072906494,
-0.11038345098495483,
0.39837902784347534,
0.20617663860321045,
-1.212568998336792,
0.1096053197979927,
0.10045028477907181,
-0.016207851469516754,
0.5103845000267029,
-1.0292730331420898,
0.46383485198020935,
-0.33219999074935913,
-0.09554582089185715,
-0.09375080466270447,
0.4414994418621063,
0.015419243834912777,
0.554155707359314,
0.6575485467910767,
0.7240618467330933,
0.37129002809524536,
0.17331840097904205,
0.7219860553741455,
-0.41516056656837463,
0.4407585561275482,
1.2006226778030396,
-0.27207306027412415,
0.7163339853286743,
0.9506455659866333,
-0.037687402218580246,
0.4800354540348053,
0.4293030798435211,
0.1255418211221695,
1.119537115097046,
-0.14970052242279053,
-0.2532282769680023,
-0.09245648980140686,
-0.33373937010765076,
-0.3544510304927826,
0.12351733446121216,
0.15032236278057098,
-0.5286043882369995,
-0.44897663593292236,
0.3052408993244171,
-0.13281814754009247,
-0.12387017905712128,
-0.4509611427783966,
0.7083687782287598,
0.006642085500061512,
-0.6567030549049377,
0.24686062335968018,
-0.2717974781990051,
0.3967055082321167,
-0.5932919979095459,
0.2889527678489685,
-0.1919446736574173,
0.09776436537504196,
-0.05714940279722214,
-0.6312493681907654,
0.33398228883743286,
-0.5269582867622375,
-0.3376200497150421,
-0.18177548050880432,
0.5213278532028198,
-0.9165127873420715,
-0.20444929599761963,
0.22887925803661346,
-0.04343526437878609,
-0.05246391147375107,
-0.01599164865911007,
-0.4220520257949829,
-0.2217998057603836,
0.03826924040913582,
-0.106960728764534,
0.5867430567741394,
0.7443713545799255,
0.03194383904337883,
1.1005171537399292,
0.6691691875457764,
-0.323231041431427,
0.3036331236362457,
-0.19845762848854065,
0.7686940431594849,
-0.4612864851951599,
-0.3416692018508911,
-0.9368166327476501,
0.7813975811004639,
0.020869480445981026,
-0.19968821108341217,
0.4288368821144104,
0.6713696718215942,
0.6266840100288391,
-0.1885089874267578,
0.451032817363739,
-0.21606789529323578,
-0.03154420480132103,
-0.5526039600372314,
0.19086594879627228,
-0.8523648977279663,
0.17747420072555542,
-0.4034075438976288,
-1.0288695096969604,
0.011246547102928162,
0.5395441055297852,
0.00008379497739952058,
-0.21964074671268463,
1.0675737857818604,
0.8730278611183167,
-0.6348976492881775,
-0.4120480418205261,
0.16114409267902374,
0.08206276595592499,
-0.022888241335749626,
1.0791374444961548,
0.6212449073791504,
-0.49946078658103943,
1.067026138305664,
-0.26956355571746826,
0.18868663907051086,
-0.4681623578071594,
-0.8894107341766357,
-0.954535961151123,
-0.8577330708503723,
-0.7935340404510498,
-0.23856140673160553,
-0.06732580810785294,
0.8033707141876221,
0.800247848033905,
-0.23455889523029327,
0.18759259581565857,
-0.09518126398324966,
0.12191911041736603,
-0.18680737912654877,
-0.1941811889410019,
0.46596136689186096,
-0.19065406918525696,
-0.6094791293144226,
-0.008455062285065651,
0.5869602560997009,
0.29785454273223877,
-0.058990925550460815,
0.21013863384723663,
-0.47610965371131897,
-0.14776752889156342,
0.7742154598236084,
-0.17664046585559845,
-0.5978083610534668,
-0.2616952955722809,
0.0394052118062973,
-0.34154200553894043,
-0.013353579677641392,
0.5524282455444336,
-0.24407096207141876,
0.503838062286377,
0.26156947016716003,
0.6411744356155396,
0.8840524554252625,
0.22240500152111053,
0.5373106598854065,
-0.7164879441261292,
0.38039693236351013,
-0.09743084758520126,
0.27749285101890564,
-0.08921271562576294,
-0.33392736315727234,
0.4551999866962433,
0.34677860140800476,
-0.5731150507926941,
-0.7210021018981934,
0.11492529511451721,
-1.6630778312683105,
-0.06031666696071625,
1.2071104049682617,
-0.028475014492869377,
-0.4319019913673401,
-0.0037034431006759405,
-0.3802099823951721,
0.2262497842311859,
-0.35981234908103943,
1.003310203552246,
0.45806825160980225,
0.03329389914870262,
-0.3318902850151062,
-0.34252476692199707,
0.40335237979888916,
0.48100635409355164,
-0.4835270643234253,
-0.3551867604255676,
0.34773778915405273,
0.3562059998512268,
0.41154706478118896,
0.5712645053863525,
0.12832407653331757,
-0.1385350376367569,
-0.07216903567314148,
-0.06570342183113098,
-0.25529778003692627,
-0.35295289754867554,
0.47962918877601624,
0.33476316928863525,
-0.25936922430992126,
-0.75091952085495
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.01931v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.01931v2
|
Dishonesty in Helpful and Harmless Alignment
| 2024-06-04T03:31:09 | 2024-06-05T07:21:19 |
Youcheng Huang, Jingkun Tang, Duanyu Feng, Zheng Zhang, Wenqiang Lei, Jiancheng Lv, Anthony G. Cohn
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
People tell lies when seeking rewards. Large language models (LLMs) are
aligned to human values with reinforcement learning where they get rewards if
they satisfy human preference. We find that this also induces dishonesty in
helpful and harmless alignment where LLMs tell lies in generating harmless
responses. Using the latest interpreting tools, we detect dishonesty, show how
LLMs can be harmful if their honesty is increased, and analyze such conflicts
at the parameter-level. Given these preliminaries and the hypothesis that
reward-seeking stimulates dishonesty, we theoretically show that the dishonesty
can in-turn decrease the alignment performances and augment reward-seeking
alignment with representation regularization. Extensive results, including
GPT-4 annotated win-rates, perplexities, and cases studies demonstrate that we
can train more honest, helpful, and harmless LLMs. We will make all our codes
and results be open-sourced upon this paper's acceptance.
|
[
0.12099888175725937,
-0.3845728635787964,
0.9032822847366333,
0.018120601773262024,
-0.1909889131784439,
-0.022525861859321594,
-0.1413046419620514,
-0.628143310546875,
-0.044514864683151245,
0.5446980595588684,
-0.6696805357933044,
-0.25682884454727173,
-0.9485760927200317,
0.0352826863527298,
-0.01391019020229578,
1.3160955905914307,
0.02439243346452713,
0.2481088787317276,
-0.24099551141262054,
-0.017039181664586067,
-0.5558484196662903,
-0.5729637742042542,
-0.5947826504707336,
-0.46077853441238403,
1.0121452808380127,
0.5062991976737976,
0.8821251392364502,
0.8069665431976318,
0.5287269353866577,
0.3298225700855255,
0.11543074995279312,
0.006347100716084242,
-0.8127163648605347,
0.4806048572063446,
-0.3853743374347687,
-0.693703830242157,
-0.2171279340982437,
0.5922101140022278,
0.24570100009441376,
0.3599271774291992,
-0.3038289546966553,
0.025027621537446976,
0.09111962467432022,
0.46322953701019287,
-0.789612352848053,
0.3537237048149109,
-0.7934117913246155,
-0.35066547989845276,
-0.3268297016620636,
-0.14056168496608734,
-0.4286021888256073,
-0.7110259532928467,
0.03609485924243927,
-0.6616091728210449,
-0.04124018922448158,
-0.12818513810634613,
1.0240553617477417,
0.6818801164627075,
-0.2525928020477295,
-0.6802043914794922,
-0.6017748713493347,
1.0432854890823364,
-0.5979170799255371,
0.07496824860572815,
0.47179874777793884,
0.3959313631057739,
-0.17529092729091644,
-0.38309094309806824,
-0.4457970857620239,
-0.5513845086097717,
-0.20210471749305725,
0.06783988326787949,
-0.06967338174581528,
0.13350355625152588,
0.19064900279045105,
0.29889991879463196,
-0.46911829710006714,
0.3110242187976837,
-0.005429499316960573,
-0.3647732138633728,
0.8369605541229248,
0.062158457934856415,
0.2909098267555237,
0.03960735723376274,
-0.5049054026603699,
-0.33706149458885193,
-0.8859850168228149,
0.16652260720729828,
0.8334735631942749,
0.29483315348625183,
0.0752904936671257,
0.7178332209587097,
0.13442888855934143,
0.36480051279067993,
-0.03956536576151848,
-0.041199974715709686,
0.01757071726024151,
-0.3492547273635864,
0.15359438955783844,
0.3323803246021271,
0.6556729078292847,
0.46285441517829895,
0.5368409156799316,
-0.2787722647190094,
-0.5460187196731567,
0.6852515339851379,
0.4312416613101959,
-0.5648922324180603,
0.00016585079720243812,
0.1223345547914505,
-0.33958756923675537,
-0.7908257842063904,
0.20686990022659302,
-0.4798884093761444,
-0.7404494881629944,
-0.22653238475322723,
0.34180736541748047,
-0.4843701124191284,
-0.09371019899845123,
0.2303285300731659,
-0.21038705110549927,
0.4457108676433563,
0.2215510457754135,
-0.8285562992095947,
0.3262210190296173,
0.9927049875259399,
0.35701537132263184,
-0.09058237820863724,
-0.4254448413848877,
-1.0059244632720947,
0.17563965916633606,
-0.4372483789920807,
0.5667151212692261,
-0.5244522094726562,
-0.1290397346019745,
0.015418005175888538,
-0.051516491919755936,
0.3242686092853546,
-0.544383704662323,
0.8815352320671082,
-0.42261213064193726,
0.2652677595615387,
-0.563402533531189,
-0.42095646262168884,
0.007098219823092222,
0.23720693588256836,
-0.7170221209526062,
0.6404505372047424,
0.01899769715964794,
-0.6148882508277893,
0.33420130610466003,
-0.419595330953598,
-0.19881398975849152,
0.02089730277657509,
-0.22578902542591095,
-0.4582787752151489,
0.3318830728530884,
0.008533581160008907,
0.393587589263916,
-0.15200093388557434,
0.40241748094558716,
-0.32950785756111145,
-0.6888113021850586,
0.7545563578605652,
-0.5841788649559021,
0.7999471426010132,
0.28681448101997375,
-0.5226349830627441,
0.08225760608911514,
-0.30753156542778015,
-0.3284774720668793,
0.3151891827583313,
-0.24458274245262146,
-0.6339208483695984,
0.13361108303070068,
-0.4077446460723877,
0.4542487859725952,
0.5215897560119629,
-0.6132140159606934,
0.2945980727672577,
-0.500417947769165,
-0.08100153505802155,
1.248831033706665,
-0.166634663939476,
0.3690740466117859,
-0.5853317975997925,
0.5171384215354919,
0.18460401892662048,
0.24589093029499054,
0.21203818917274475,
-0.2786065936088562,
-0.3363381028175354,
-0.10567841678857803,
0.26758337020874023,
0.2628324031829834,
-0.7873544692993164,
0.08223781734704971,
-0.29967260360717773,
-0.2116609364748001,
-0.9217327833175659,
0.007872088812291622,
0.8157867193222046,
0.2818480134010315,
0.24710248410701752,
-0.24036584794521332,
-0.3822159767150879,
-0.9685342907905579,
-0.7462515830993652,
-0.14738686382770538,
-0.07268085330724716,
0.2845460772514343,
0.21412664651870728,
-0.00907082762569189,
0.6502184867858887,
-0.35786929726600647,
-0.35876211524009705,
-0.028086477890610695,
0.14049360156059265,
-0.08868233859539032,
0.3912443518638611,
0.4253920912742615,
-0.8163092136383057,
-0.33032453060150146,
-0.21509979665279388,
-0.5481631755828857,
-0.08113352209329605,
-0.11693482100963593,
0.2273368090391159,
0.36806491017341614,
0.18929283320903778,
-0.5256693363189697,
0.22446851432323456,
0.6258485913276672,
-0.6060085892677307,
0.5994381308555603,
0.12741389870643616,
-0.05688095465302467,
-0.7973088622093201,
-0.02096579782664776,
0.03113524802029133,
-0.28352147340774536,
-0.39631256461143494,
0.05783616378903389,
-0.08077838271856308,
0.3724479079246521,
-0.34292688965797424,
0.4470866918563843,
-0.48886722326278687,
-0.03047581948339939,
-0.19483771920204163,
0.27803799510002136,
-0.1036292165517807,
0.29776349663734436,
-0.027001209557056427,
0.753950297832489,
0.3685632348060608,
-0.4131075441837311,
0.45978114008903503,
0.13314814865589142,
-0.031503088772296906,
0.6077113151550293,
-0.5244295597076416,
0.059473760426044464,
-0.18204127252101898,
0.15102238953113556,
-0.8279549479484558,
-0.347417414188385,
0.39254987239837646,
-0.7302880883216858,
0.395513653755188,
-0.0845670998096466,
-0.37541258335113525,
0.029033010825514793,
-0.6969034075737,
0.19458700716495514,
0.5318878889083862,
-0.5726996660232544,
0.08596861362457275,
0.2605287432670593,
-0.1019778922200203,
-1.1904408931732178,
-0.7047790288925171,
-0.12105508148670197,
-0.2702328562736511,
-0.19622032344341278,
0.35689854621887207,
0.0023633043747395277,
-0.25780200958251953,
0.028296474367380142,
-0.3446376323699951,
0.2906334698200226,
0.25779464840888977,
0.27282679080963135,
0.49410170316696167,
0.03907269984483719,
-0.08517491817474365,
-0.3031688928604126,
-0.3343500792980194,
0.352239191532135,
-0.2508283853530884,
0.3601640462875366,
-0.2792675793170929,
-0.4096453785896301,
-0.32804247736930847,
0.19651280343532562,
0.35914769768714905,
-0.21039316058158875,
0.8566616177558899,
0.49048513174057007,
-0.2258993536233902,
0.08672820776700974,
-0.7018332481384277,
-0.46358296275138855,
-0.5416005849838257,
0.3337221145629883,
-0.16216856241226196,
-0.9368758201599121,
0.2833476662635803,
-0.039542071521282196,
0.10774891823530197,
0.21349123120307922,
0.37537431716918945,
-0.13067525625228882,
1.3740791082382202,
0.6101508736610413,
-0.16088435053825378,
0.19479399919509888,
0.1419842690229416,
0.11175218969583511,
-0.5839458703994751,
-0.36171770095825195,
-0.616110622882843,
-0.27080145478248596,
-0.994054913520813,
-0.0458538755774498,
0.010193648748099804,
-0.048880573362112045,
-0.3309246599674225,
0.10423586517572403,
-0.6579352617263794,
0.635072648525238,
0.40934789180755615,
-0.0011216505663469434,
0.2944464385509491,
-0.34722936153411865,
-0.08787227421998978,
-0.3331141173839569,
-0.27730289101600647,
-0.6228867173194885,
0.9052917957305908,
0.5753347277641296,
0.9915639162063599,
0.3556250035762787,
0.8557001352310181,
-0.10722605139017105,
0.3890402019023895,
-0.904371440410614,
0.39478302001953125,
-0.10120882838964462,
-0.5221639275550842,
-0.33719438314437866,
-0.6197106242179871,
-1.0319809913635254,
-0.1777707040309906,
0.10803002119064331,
-0.8547332882881165,
0.12887591123580933,
0.20932558178901672,
-0.15461912751197815,
0.15444009006023407,
-0.6563253402709961,
0.8226621150970459,
-0.5270872712135315,
-0.4417499303817749,
0.012547830119729042,
-0.8668004274368286,
0.5847716331481934,
0.10176897794008255,
0.055766575038433075,
-0.09201710671186447,
-0.19567309319972992,
0.5350509285926819,
-0.0743236094713211,
0.8991227149963379,
-0.3861236870288849,
-0.3216562271118164,
-0.20108388364315033,
0.43209975957870483,
0.9284601211547852,
-0.0035781548358500004,
-0.15312997996807098,
0.009969339706003666,
-0.07178449630737305,
-0.5600445866584778,
-0.7150892019271851,
0.858251690864563,
-0.7727389335632324,
-0.7387718558311462,
-0.8230664134025574,
-0.7077980637550354,
-0.22397565841674805,
0.21065643429756165,
0.13116395473480225,
-0.1926109492778778,
-0.08456814289093018,
0.07479344308376312,
0.9967181086540222,
-0.28723764419555664,
0.22916027903556824,
0.38688963651657104,
-0.13863229751586914,
0.12751829624176025,
1.181294322013855,
-0.28694602847099304,
0.39160677790641785,
0.09817469865083694,
0.27874377369880676,
-0.4984947144985199,
-0.46093660593032837,
0.025455523282289505,
0.4743478298187256,
-0.4147302508354187,
-0.40317240357398987,
-0.016976645216345787,
-0.04144224897027016,
-0.3634393811225891,
-0.07275307923555374,
-0.5531895160675049,
-0.32746919989585876,
-0.1807389110326767,
-0.2125668227672577,
0.1805446594953537,
1.0599379539489746,
-0.17073547840118408,
0.21737608313560486,
-0.613837718963623,
0.010066818445920944,
0.36027637124061584,
0.4848449230194092,
-0.3640211522579193,
-0.3455464243888855,
-0.08874095231294632,
0.1835363209247589,
-0.48113879561424255,
-0.9755130410194397,
0.25264087319374084,
-0.2873762845993042,
0.6295557022094727,
0.5271153450012207,
0.14118513464927673,
0.2853090167045593,
-0.23985803127288818,
0.905692994594574,
0.2521430552005768,
-0.7983033061027527,
0.2119123637676239,
-0.33362579345703125,
-0.040791697800159454,
0.4829903244972229,
0.6574220657348633,
-0.6747110486030579,
-0.45731648802757263,
-0.7374423146247864,
-0.5546873807907104,
1.0019553899765015,
-0.04012177139520645,
0.18407157063484192,
0.07531607151031494,
0.5557844638824463,
0.243674635887146,
0.23188817501068115,
-1.0617356300354004,
-0.4240586459636688,
-0.27838993072509766,
-0.40099427103996277,
-0.04774198681116104,
-0.49529483914375305,
-0.4417443573474884,
0.15438753366470337,
0.8436191082000732,
-0.09072299301624298,
0.41157013177871704,
-0.10308357328176498,
-0.03043290413916111,
-0.40170764923095703,
0.41632238030433655,
0.7595035433769226,
0.2959422171115875,
-0.10653149336576462,
0.2727157175540924,
-0.08486119657754898,
-0.38034743070602417,
0.3164914548397064,
0.221202552318573,
0.10129627585411072,
-0.25605225563049316,
0.2769702076911926,
0.6553487777709961,
0.29810407757759094,
-0.5187999606132507,
0.9846563339233398,
-0.15267512202262878,
-0.1588355451822281,
-0.23130233585834503,
0.21203671395778656,
0.24112126231193542,
0.09521525353193283,
0.16472040116786957,
-0.13416971266269684,
0.04325440153479576,
-0.6331763863563538,
0.08191613107919693,
0.7919275760650635,
-0.5932526588439941,
-0.31177303194999695,
0.6133564114570618,
-0.1277959644794464,
-0.32438924908638,
0.7000487446784973,
-0.3678862154483795,
-0.6676830649375916,
0.12225723266601562,
0.453978568315506,
0.6569186449050903,
-0.6938439607620239,
0.43361592292785645,
-0.017907898873090744,
0.30879995226860046,
-0.026951877400279045,
0.14851637184619904,
0.11343932151794434,
-0.8174501657485962,
-0.6239259839057922,
-0.39384785294532776,
-0.3639012277126312,
0.3636006712913513,
-0.7258234620094299,
0.17718322575092316,
-0.024269860237836838,
0.20631510019302368,
-0.12976200878620148,
0.13130515813827515,
-0.37264925241470337,
-0.12126342952251434,
0.1525076925754547,
0.5156234502792358,
-0.716732382774353,
0.7656762599945068,
0.5690641403198242,
-0.6209534406661987,
-1.0903462171554565,
0.1509248912334442,
0.1864333599805832,
-0.8859168291091919,
0.549623966217041,
0.1328047662973404,
-0.19134654104709625,
-0.2698165476322174,
-1.0187848806381226,
-0.67243492603302,
1.0631694793701172,
0.7102130055427551,
-0.46658918261528015,
-0.5650401711463928,
0.4232969582080841,
0.42040789127349854,
-0.09419769048690796,
0.15839926898479462,
0.5582979917526245,
0.6146126389503479,
0.06316399574279785,
-0.7741939425468445,
0.42927151918411255,
0.2028835564851761,
0.002433155430480838,
0.1094871237874031,
-0.573260486125946,
0.752561092376709,
-0.18041884899139404,
-0.2303503453731537,
0.07449682056903839,
0.3241996467113495,
0.5715106725692749,
0.26007652282714844,
0.38730716705322266,
0.4079267382621765,
0.7191471457481384,
-0.3033575117588043,
1.1625194549560547,
0.13546285033226013,
0.3116820752620697,
0.9188464283943176,
-0.2898082733154297,
0.2858227789402008,
0.7692733407020569,
0.2166322022676468,
0.5751640796661377,
0.5374208688735962,
0.17187590897083282,
0.717551589012146,
0.40569108724594116,
-0.10954592376947403,
-0.19379903376102448,
-0.19040033221244812,
-0.042765356600284576,
0.4495494067668915,
0.4043932557106018,
-0.26030880212783813,
-0.316120445728302,
-0.18493561446666718,
0.2253139317035675,
0.19966483116149902,
-0.11207994073629379,
0.8184091448783875,
0.23802511394023895,
-0.8968623876571655,
0.483516126871109,
-0.06389141827821732,
0.9182305335998535,
-0.5436200499534607,
-0.28769731521606445,
-0.015822317451238632,
0.1994531750679016,
-0.293084979057312,
-0.8350008130073547,
0.18928366899490356,
-0.17756010591983795,
0.21481390297412872,
-0.30606281757354736,
0.7949181199073792,
-0.37685269117355347,
0.19067923724651337,
0.29234933853149414,
0.3845881223678589,
0.11973925679922104,
-0.11257980018854141,
-0.8218013644218445,
0.019854813814163208,
0.05705050006508827,
-0.28682830929756165,
0.5427044034004211,
0.4759129583835602,
-0.10404834896326065,
0.6063486933708191,
0.7744042277336121,
0.2518138289451599,
-0.15957358479499817,
-0.15474513173103333,
0.8697505593299866,
-0.5598528981208801,
-0.225538432598114,
-0.9178548455238342,
0.5256591439247131,
-0.14147816598415375,
0.007514620199799538,
0.7009908556938171,
0.46226003766059875,
0.9757832884788513,
0.04406890645623207,
0.5524328351020813,
0.34339845180511475,
0.5353713631629944,
-0.46482914686203003,
0.7200438976287842,
-0.4673326313495636,
0.4953562915325165,
-0.25585541129112244,
-0.7433699369430542,
-0.07475820928812027,
0.5774732828140259,
-0.4864378571510315,
0.19085693359375,
0.7048770189285278,
0.7710396647453308,
0.08098702132701874,
-0.005534820258617401,
0.4103828966617584,
0.3326677083969116,
0.33581194281578064,
0.6362854838371277,
1.20521080493927,
-0.14895136654376984,
0.6702867746353149,
-0.2108132243156433,
-0.23291559517383575,
-0.24946802854537964,
-0.9087480902671814,
-0.425340473651886,
-0.5564467310905457,
-0.14210942387580872,
-0.638071596622467,
0.19046907126903534,
0.6990333199501038,
0.23300862312316895,
-0.5966780781745911,
-0.07105428725481033,
-0.20611615478992462,
0.3786507248878479,
-0.34879955649375916,
-0.2980177104473114,
0.05601990222930908,
-0.4400056004524231,
-0.7521959543228149,
0.302330881357193,
-0.09940250962972641,
0.03507471829652786,
-0.4998789429664612,
-0.518571138381958,
-0.05456853285431862,
0.13789594173431396,
0.13615308701992035,
0.25946709513664246,
-0.8188599348068237,
-0.5142400860786438,
0.20488828420639038,
-0.4602750837802887,
-0.02976241335272789,
0.7303548455238342,
-0.623500406742096,
0.19685758650302887,
-0.00411105714738369,
0.6232253313064575,
0.2714082598686218,
0.13369889557361603,
0.7061878442764282,
-1.0085904598236084,
-0.1724129468202591,
0.6232461929321289,
0.1295267641544342,
0.3646877706050873,
-0.8622634410858154,
0.38089925050735474,
-0.052054513245821,
-0.8114818930625916,
-0.9878563284873962,
0.37062475085258484,
-0.733921229839325,
-0.3142842650413513,
1.1963951587677002,
-0.2402217984199524,
-0.28433653712272644,
-0.02563057281076908,
-0.13156351447105408,
0.49115338921546936,
-0.47445422410964966,
1.0189625024795532,
0.8488536477088928,
-0.17684468626976013,
0.10455773025751114,
-0.4110960066318512,
0.9902368187904358,
0.6599626541137695,
-0.7201237082481384,
0.23718470335006714,
0.6577395796775818,
0.44821932911872864,
0.26763036847114563,
0.34681516885757446,
-0.34744274616241455,
0.4873351752758026,
-0.307641863822937,
0.02754034847021103,
-0.20717795193195343,
-0.22788743674755096,
-0.6898974776268005,
-0.28815752267837524,
0.48635050654411316,
-0.21816138923168182
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.01919v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.01919v1
|
OTTAWA: Optimal TransporT Adaptive Word Aligner for Hallucination and Omission Translation Errors Detection
| 2024-06-04T03:00:55 | 2024-06-04T03:00:55 |
Chenyang Huang, Abbas Ghaddar, Ivan Kobyzev, Mehdi Rezagholizadeh, Osmar R. Zaiane, Boxing Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Recently, there has been considerable attention on detecting hallucinations
and omissions in Machine Translation (MT) systems. The two dominant approaches
to tackle this task involve analyzing the MT system's internal states or
relying on the output of external tools, such as sentence similarity or MT
quality estimators. In this work, we introduce OTTAWA, a novel Optimal
Transport (OT)-based word aligner specifically designed to enhance the
detection of hallucinations and omissions in MT systems. Our approach
explicitly models the missing alignments by introducing a "null" vector, for
which we propose a novel one-side constrained OT setting to allow an adaptive
null alignment. Our approach yields competitive results compared to
state-of-the-art methods across 18 language pairs on the HalOmi benchmark. In
addition, it shows promising features, such as the ability to distinguish
between both error types and perform word-level detection without accessing the
MT system's internal states.
|
[
-0.2186966985464096,
-0.4974623918533325,
0.8363916277885437,
0.2932395339012146,
-0.5014627575874329,
-0.1529831439256668,
0.05817963555455208,
-0.22349706292152405,
0.608766496181488,
0.6258552670478821,
-0.5824447274208069,
-0.37133240699768066,
-0.5152844786643982,
0.43750977516174316,
-0.3582246005535126,
0.3084202706813812,
-0.4208570420742035,
-0.22407619655132294,
-0.045360784977674484,
-0.6872014403343201,
-0.9565528631210327,
-0.3197551369667053,
-0.3237079977989197,
0.02005084417760372,
0.3778574466705322,
0.3458612561225891,
0.702979564666748,
0.6788643598556519,
0.6968779563903809,
0.3463329076766968,
0.3032950758934021,
0.4856356680393219,
-0.10325866937637329,
0.16600492596626282,
-0.19780327379703522,
-0.00543759623542428,
-0.4291892945766449,
-0.605350911617279,
0.708119809627533,
0.5912928581237793,
-0.259579062461853,
-0.21188540756702423,
-0.18652161955833435,
0.529962420463562,
-0.7344377636909485,
0.006737474352121353,
-0.7461644411087036,
0.21593067049980164,
-0.20065580308437347,
-0.3625916838645935,
-0.37283411622047424,
-0.6632155776023865,
-0.08229045569896698,
-1.0326945781707764,
-0.3796762228012085,
0.5953396558761597,
0.8051855564117432,
0.8225047588348389,
-0.3084372878074646,
-0.3399869203567505,
-0.4542692005634308,
0.6557725667953491,
-0.5665276646614075,
0.5836251974105835,
0.325779527425766,
0.21139054000377655,
0.026379045099020004,
-0.3145381510257721,
-0.7550540566444397,
0.29735103249549866,
-0.25039368867874146,
0.4681510329246521,
-0.3268577754497528,
0.061188433319330215,
-0.17855148017406464,
0.21460431814193726,
-0.7363399863243103,
0.17586563527584076,
-0.38911423087120056,
-0.5428239703178406,
0.28374093770980835,
0.2807166576385498,
0.48666712641716003,
-0.06889308243989944,
-0.20779410004615784,
-0.048930779099464417,
-0.19583703577518463,
-0.4229139983654022,
0.17515820264816284,
0.3762580156326294,
0.15835416316986084,
0.562754213809967,
0.10516313463449478,
0.5401161313056946,
0.04307480528950691,
0.26770561933517456,
0.6083343029022217,
0.06927323341369629,
-0.33327725529670715,
0.47621071338653564,
1.0308533906936646,
0.3713299334049225,
-0.257914274930954,
-0.4840714633464813,
-0.5626198053359985,
0.20490145683288574,
0.42673182487487793,
-0.4643624424934387,
0.17927730083465576,
0.27593186497688293,
-0.2532711923122406,
-0.10484623908996582,
-0.042067769914865494,
-0.8127613067626953,
-0.33550387620925903,
-0.32824692130088806,
0.9012205600738525,
-0.5956992506980896,
-0.10923535376787186,
0.4246450662612915,
-0.08182220906019211,
0.24366578459739685,
0.055208392441272736,
-0.9795747995376587,
0.28992655873298645,
0.4410436749458313,
1.118179202079773,
-0.6122163534164429,
-0.3323982059955597,
-1.0493303537368774,
-0.1283239722251892,
-0.5773364901542664,
0.9442427754402161,
-0.24756354093551636,
-0.24514690041542053,
0.32180485129356384,
0.13232246041297913,
-0.21214498579502106,
-0.6099866628646851,
1.0576670169830322,
-0.2770567238330841,
0.22136792540550232,
-0.4492809772491455,
-0.2769778072834015,
-0.2805461585521698,
0.18779008090496063,
-0.41455963253974915,
1.0570405721664429,
0.49048906564712524,
-0.4886835217475891,
0.20986498892307281,
-0.777996301651001,
-0.6468356251716614,
0.0909290760755539,
0.26727306842803955,
-0.5412797927856445,
0.37556490302085876,
0.3199111521244049,
-0.05621319264173508,
0.08653580397367477,
0.2720821499824524,
-0.2412097454071045,
-0.5627925395965576,
-0.07531597465276718,
-0.12045899033546448,
0.6259598135948181,
0.1988515406847,
-0.2194928228855133,
0.3808085024356842,
-0.8949222564697266,
-0.05886980891227722,
-0.08769810944795609,
-0.26105210185050964,
-0.5892282724380493,
0.07001104950904846,
0.16046175360679626,
0.0771922618150711,
-0.08467084169387817,
-0.7213541865348816,
0.24524326622486115,
-0.5921381115913391,
0.39617595076560974,
0.930959165096283,
-0.27162715792655945,
0.5293587446212769,
-0.19032150506973267,
0.23033855855464935,
0.13409322500228882,
0.37107744812965393,
0.1653214395046234,
-0.3462664484977722,
-0.9029893279075623,
-0.0748617872595787,
0.1308550387620926,
0.7391835451126099,
-0.9126731753349304,
0.9143782258033752,
-0.42011237144470215,
-0.03124607540667057,
-1.0540878772735596,
-0.08789718151092529,
-0.12218527495861053,
0.6834943890571594,
0.7679998874664307,
-0.37926292419433594,
-0.5571975111961365,
-0.9269785284996033,
-0.2676412761211395,
-0.15857304632663727,
0.20097586512565613,
-0.24611905217170715,
0.4881749451160431,
-0.44153285026550293,
0.7735037803649902,
-0.5366566181182861,
-0.6433701515197754,
0.23662996292114258,
0.05123982951045036,
-0.10906905680894852,
0.4848550260066986,
0.5539578199386597,
-0.5532368421554565,
-0.3961673378944397,
0.22272710502147675,
-1.0080870389938354,
-0.5367108583450317,
-0.24677911400794983,
-0.5181095004081726,
0.14921221137046814,
0.36249542236328125,
-0.4511719048023224,
0.4497953951358795,
0.6133609414100647,
-0.25716081261634827,
0.337137907743454,
-0.48783692717552185,
0.004168888553977013,
-0.9026138782501221,
0.13585874438285828,
-0.5867990255355835,
-0.25906163454055786,
-0.679736316204071,
-0.0714544951915741,
0.25129443407058716,
-0.07231632620096207,
-0.3106958866119385,
0.4835166037082672,
-0.30476832389831543,
0.038257014006376266,
-0.4518614113330841,
0.6456008553504944,
-0.20097841322422028,
0.5975643992424011,
0.16536186635494232,
0.5426902174949646,
0.47285929322242737,
-0.43664804100990295,
-0.05017739534378052,
0.8247202634811401,
-0.20377229154109955,
0.8383857011795044,
-0.24504849314689636,
0.4210470914840698,
-0.2495993971824646,
-0.19440636038780212,
-1.0185065269470215,
-0.021545246243476868,
0.7967171669006348,
-0.20358765125274658,
0.1487252563238144,
0.30948761105537415,
-0.37610551714897156,
-0.30416327714920044,
-0.14948809146881104,
0.4148445725440979,
0.5659114718437195,
-0.6538165807723999,
1.0459303855895996,
0.39339402318000793,
0.1496151089668274,
-0.5347862839698792,
-1.0212842226028442,
0.18723894655704498,
-0.18542605638504028,
-0.4228515028953552,
0.30189982056617737,
-0.297143816947937,
-0.028093118220567703,
0.20901185274124146,
-0.30587923526763916,
-0.10293858498334885,
-0.055840685963630676,
0.28293588757514954,
0.30051296949386597,
-0.3917621076107025,
0.14785555005073547,
0.4287396967411041,
-0.24664315581321716,
0.037881698459386826,
-0.771005392074585,
0.19778494536876678,
0.11259187757968903,
-0.5234461426734924,
-0.6525561809539795,
0.429323673248291,
1.061078667640686,
-0.22818174958229065,
0.8913979530334473,
0.6980718374252319,
-0.5590411424636841,
0.04567674547433853,
-0.6715685129165649,
-0.06470515578985214,
-0.4748820662498474,
0.2675909101963043,
-0.15134325623512268,
-0.4514029026031494,
0.4826641082763672,
0.4252276122570038,
0.09915696084499359,
0.4756050407886505,
0.11252713203430176,
0.3773156404495239,
1.011704921722412,
0.5647988319396973,
-0.2434176206588745,
0.32450494170188904,
0.24135197699069977,
0.621525764465332,
-1.0554630756378174,
-0.02023213729262352,
-0.5260590314865112,
-0.3461512625217438,
-0.415951669216156,
-0.21114219725131989,
0.25848811864852905,
-0.33677637577056885,
-0.2706303894519806,
0.45617595314979553,
-0.8147439360618591,
0.17937655746936798,
0.5185865759849548,
-0.022268813103437424,
0.29749321937561035,
0.00844596792012453,
-0.39229264855384827,
-0.15222659707069397,
-0.6671850085258484,
-0.25595489144325256,
0.7162079215049744,
-0.07469479739665985,
0.2953031063079834,
0.14885272085666656,
0.42994198203086853,
0.26031941175460815,
0.6624084115028381,
-0.7497668862342834,
0.41936078667640686,
-0.11673951894044876,
-0.298157274723053,
-0.13412390649318695,
-0.5250736474990845,
-0.7169684767723083,
0.4730152189731598,
-0.3884846568107605,
-0.7892115116119385,
0.33037352561950684,
0.057528723031282425,
-0.43403175473213196,
0.5970149040222168,
-0.4796457886695862,
0.8483197093009949,
-0.35896286368370056,
-0.28348392248153687,
0.16582849621772766,
-0.5438346266746521,
0.294373482465744,
-0.49288272857666016,
0.36925366520881653,
0.18516644835472107,
-0.02071787416934967,
0.5390074253082275,
-0.3644620180130005,
0.3047814667224884,
-0.1394389420747757,
-0.019817929714918137,
0.057658515870571136,
0.19300392270088196,
0.5970674753189087,
-0.4039577841758728,
-0.105379119515419,
0.09141352772712708,
-0.27983319759368896,
-0.14041545987129211,
-0.540077805519104,
0.6409594416618347,
-0.5526763796806335,
-0.40538284182548523,
-0.4139610528945923,
-0.7781612277030945,
-0.13037742674350739,
0.5460836887359619,
0.342925488948822,
0.2128925919532776,
0.03285623714327812,
-0.06654099375009537,
0.45871663093566895,
-0.446746826171875,
0.3916029632091522,
0.7342537641525269,
-0.4515126347541809,
-0.590071439743042,
1.1267741918563843,
0.09185435622930527,
0.10518883913755417,
0.6901491284370422,
0.41022199392318726,
-0.49568456411361694,
-0.8273463249206543,
-0.4763404428958893,
0.3787313997745514,
-0.7415755391120911,
-0.2276492863893509,
-0.9815361499786377,
-0.1115628182888031,
-0.16825540363788605,
-0.2921859323978424,
-0.4526064395904541,
-0.2946815490722656,
-0.025200925767421722,
-0.07458047568798065,
0.005843084305524826,
0.4948888421058655,
-0.24501945078372955,
0.3946601152420044,
-0.8053909540176392,
0.2194402515888214,
0.2240871638059616,
0.4559553861618042,
-0.24026410281658173,
-0.7582632303237915,
-0.028357528150081635,
-0.1297762095928192,
-0.46428948640823364,
-0.7947465777397156,
0.538439929485321,
-0.1343868225812912,
0.4050087332725525,
0.6205702424049377,
0.31480008363723755,
0.9848386645317078,
-0.482654333114624,
0.5209946632385254,
0.20502641797065735,
-1.2155495882034302,
0.31599390506744385,
-0.1337120532989502,
0.26402729749679565,
0.6079073548316956,
-0.033688340336084366,
-0.7242963910102844,
-0.6710299849510193,
-0.16282406449317932,
-0.787216067314148,
0.7589387893676758,
0.7856045365333557,
-0.1792665421962738,
-0.01939544640481472,
0.2121228128671646,
0.08986692875623703,
0.17068494856357574,
-0.7090203166007996,
-0.17039164900779724,
-0.19667907059192657,
-0.585289716720581,
0.07583820074796677,
0.2661910653114319,
0.17769743502140045,
-0.07694578170776367,
0.914865255355835,
-0.1487528383731842,
0.30378860235214233,
0.4672423303127289,
-0.3473818600177765,
-0.5091063976287842,
0.004397935699671507,
0.9588783383369446,
0.4465102553367615,
-0.4295831024646759,
0.023354224860668182,
0.5093690156936646,
-0.585448682308197,
0.05780063942074776,
-0.007306472864001989,
-0.3797032833099365,
0.40927278995513916,
0.07858789712190628,
0.9067331552505493,
0.09014260768890381,
-0.6441497802734375,
0.403448224067688,
-0.029753966256976128,
-0.3763253688812256,
-0.14609286189079285,
-0.3554087281227112,
-0.19297514855861664,
-0.09952344745397568,
0.25467410683631897,
0.7117674946784973,
-0.05237183719873428,
-0.30533525347709656,
-0.10835496336221695,
0.2819942235946655,
-1.112510323524475,
-0.5012823939323425,
1.1329069137573242,
0.12049905955791473,
-0.7304786443710327,
0.7484049797058105,
-0.3067207634449005,
-0.7565549612045288,
0.11818307638168335,
0.4276117980480194,
1.1725740432739258,
-0.40431854128837585,
-0.1080237552523613,
0.31385311484336853,
0.7251425981521606,
-0.2846817672252655,
0.14619195461273193,
0.3267168700695038,
-0.8740257024765015,
-0.10960554331541061,
-0.42130187153816223,
-0.17278972268104553,
0.21277278661727905,
-0.573762059211731,
0.2953636050224304,
-0.008325678296387196,
-0.05106671527028084,
-0.3272026479244232,
-0.6553128957748413,
-0.5258961319923401,
-0.09187210351228714,
0.15753313899040222,
0.7544494271278381,
-0.8351598381996155,
0.5477970838546753,
0.33199259638786316,
-0.23000432550907135,
-0.3683358132839203,
-0.07107763737440109,
0.17490491271018982,
-0.7234458327293396,
0.029474562034010887,
0.18318307399749756,
-0.21877823770046234,
-0.17162850499153137,
0.02140507847070694,
-0.8003024458885193,
0.8451803922653198,
0.6463481783866882,
-0.6540639400482178,
-0.006754872389137745,
0.22599488496780396,
0.3921518921852112,
-0.25066015124320984,
0.04558626562356949,
0.5083189010620117,
0.8985633850097656,
-0.29241156578063965,
-0.7333910465240479,
0.22764241695404053,
-0.039157260209321976,
-0.28229886293411255,
0.603283166885376,
-0.598967432975769,
0.2959964871406555,
0.23108407855033875,
-0.41061457991600037,
0.24071688950061798,
0.4642360210418701,
-0.23016934096813202,
0.35425662994384766,
0.641990065574646,
0.6045160293579102,
0.8088828325271606,
-0.297504186630249,
0.7501031756401062,
-0.24995076656341553,
0.1793925166130066,
0.950848400592804,
-0.41566967964172363,
0.8363415598869324,
0.7961699366569519,
0.3094804584980011,
0.234352707862854,
0.44541293382644653,
0.20605050027370453,
0.7312832474708557,
0.04038982093334198,
0.1275349259376526,
-0.15149852633476257,
0.07443682104349136,
-0.21869643032550812,
0.21431367099285126,
0.283292293548584,
-0.11844669282436371,
-0.006170313339680433,
0.31397533416748047,
-0.23357881605625153,
0.032489120960235596,
-0.14238421618938446,
0.5649598240852356,
0.011010603047907352,
-1.0014028549194336,
0.520087480545044,
-0.24163563549518585,
0.39826738834381104,
-0.6614537239074707,
0.11449695378541946,
-0.5031142234802246,
0.3238283097743988,
-0.1669187992811203,
-0.4688014090061188,
0.5705752968788147,
-0.39563220739364624,
0.20341894030570984,
-0.2910303473472595,
0.33922314643859863,
-0.5322118997573853,
-0.42772290110588074,
0.4651000499725342,
0.2792758643627167,
0.051313795149326324,
-0.19505199790000916,
-0.39653077721595764,
0.29089978337287903,
-0.08188982307910919,
0.18358461558818817,
0.021789608523249626,
0.5980893969535828,
0.1529058814048767,
0.6096214056015015,
0.35948795080184937,
0.1311478614807129,
0.010377381928265095,
-0.11789260059595108,
0.6347077488899231,
-0.45994892716407776,
-0.5557918548583984,
-0.706599235534668,
0.5265243649482727,
-0.14454686641693115,
-0.5489612817764282,
0.5716008543968201,
0.7150987386703491,
0.386265367269516,
-0.0839410126209259,
0.8023144006729126,
0.1431804746389389,
0.07990525662899017,
-0.5832738876342773,
0.38431259989738464,
-0.8006466031074524,
0.2783503234386444,
-0.31838762760162354,
-1.098787784576416,
-0.5144767165184021,
0.6282105445861816,
-0.1905369907617569,
-0.6314536333084106,
1.3645129203796387,
0.9000651836395264,
-0.41636767983436584,
0.08956066519021988,
0.382623553276062,
0.24714648723602295,
0.17034152150154114,
0.6360222697257996,
0.8052836656570435,
-0.8607428073883057,
0.7813695669174194,
0.13572105765342712,
-0.060099463909864426,
-0.26180508732795715,
-0.6207033395767212,
-0.7568657398223877,
-0.7855944633483887,
-0.5154539346694946,
-0.3197786509990692,
0.22788068652153015,
0.9012752771377563,
0.6252837181091309,
-0.9454911947250366,
0.007628530729562044,
-0.09183312952518463,
0.25636473298072815,
-0.5014138221740723,
-0.1765005737543106,
0.6440552473068237,
-0.3608999252319336,
-0.6684707999229431,
0.4649340808391571,
0.9311270713806152,
-0.07293432950973511,
0.051792409271001816,
-0.1660902500152588,
0.02306090109050274,
0.28666412830352783,
0.4175996780395508,
0.061358075588941574,
-0.7877216339111328,
-0.6727578043937683,
0.31023451685905457,
0.005665736272931099,
0.5115699172019958,
0.7319725751876831,
-0.32267898321151733,
0.8757357001304626,
0.4239767789840698,
0.7616606950759888,
0.11339733749628067,
-0.012686602771282196,
0.5586615800857544,
-0.34035158157348633,
0.16968652606010437,
0.20172107219696045,
0.49313101172447205,
0.3459896445274353,
-0.3479025065898895,
0.4346964657306671,
0.40489649772644043,
-0.6085235476493835,
-0.992458701133728,
-0.2538571059703827,
-1.1202144622802734,
-0.03299207240343094,
0.7222940921783447,
0.288570374250412,
-0.46825411915779114,
-0.3087329864501953,
-0.44913363456726074,
0.1061868816614151,
-0.42640984058380127,
1.083092451095581,
0.7900989055633545,
0.2405233234167099,
0.18476933240890503,
-0.669754147529602,
0.24835146963596344,
0.46332669258117676,
-0.7990754842758179,
-0.09135439991950989,
0.14206483960151672,
-0.047108426690101624,
0.4652605652809143,
0.46930164098739624,
0.11544791609048843,
0.18890966475009918,
-0.10201479494571686,
-0.07814833521842957,
0.06237563118338585,
-0.03085450828075409,
-0.2728748023509979,
0.017610570415854454,
-0.40888845920562744,
-0.6545557975769043
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.01914v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.01914v1
|
HPE-CogVLM: New Head Pose Grounding Task Exploration on Vision Language Model
| 2024-06-04T02:51:26 | 2024-06-04T02:51:26 |
Yu Tian, Tianqi Shao, Tsukasa Demizu, Xuyang Wu, Hsin-Tai Wu
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Head pose estimation (HPE) task requires a sophisticated understanding of 3D
spatial relationships and precise numerical output of yaw, pitch, and roll
Euler angles. Previous HPE studies are mainly based on Non-large language
models (Non-LLMs), which rely on close-up human heads cropped from the full
image as inputs and lack robustness in real-world scenario. In this paper, we
present a novel framework to enhance the HPE prediction task by leveraging the
visual grounding capability of CogVLM. CogVLM is a vision language model (VLM)
with grounding capability of predicting object bounding boxes (BBoxes), which
enables HPE training and prediction using full image information input. To
integrate the HPE task into the VLM, we first cop with the catastrophic
forgetting problem in large language models (LLMs) by investigating the
rehearsal ratio in the data rehearsal method. Then, we propose and validate a
LoRA layer-based model merging method, which keeps the integrity of parameters,
to enhance the HPE performance in the framework. The results show our
HPE-CogVLM achieves a 31.5\% reduction in Mean Absolute Error for HPE
prediction over the current Non-LLM based state-of-the-art in cross-dataset
evaluation. Furthermore, we compare our LoRA layer-based model merging method
with LoRA fine-tuning only and other merging methods in CogVLM. The results
demonstrate our framework outperforms them in all HPE metrics.
|
[
-0.5900049805641174,
-0.6047801375389099,
0.3677227795124054,
-0.04115928336977959,
-0.35434842109680176,
-0.3248702883720398,
0.1845429390668869,
-0.4551966190338135,
0.025533339008688927,
0.6743871569633484,
-0.6265755295753479,
-0.6230397820472717,
-0.5083743333816528,
-0.6242119073867798,
-0.14709416031837463,
0.36603617668151855,
0.22637097537517548,
-0.1498153805732727,
-0.4993099868297577,
-0.1941983997821808,
-0.8401163220405579,
-0.44247114658355713,
-0.51408451795578,
-0.47913235425949097,
0.3217357099056244,
0.2126864641904831,
0.45870649814605713,
0.8030456304550171,
0.6282358169555664,
0.15047039091587067,
-0.13003341853618622,
0.18975040316581726,
-0.6339159607887268,
-0.10603474080562592,
-0.26009953022003174,
-0.14449837803840637,
-0.6051536202430725,
-0.08822637796401978,
0.30074170231819153,
0.6425436735153198,
-0.25177857279777527,
0.2123209536075592,
0.07349281013011932,
0.7685865759849548,
-0.9104682207107544,
0.08938249945640564,
-0.5993998646736145,
0.31152209639549255,
0.006648268550634384,
-0.22337159514427185,
-0.3440523147583008,
0.17289583384990692,
0.26148489117622375,
-0.5394430756568909,
0.03132694959640503,
0.12421005219221115,
0.9075674414634705,
0.5598374009132385,
-0.1002749502658844,
0.44493597745895386,
-0.36051496863365173,
0.9191731214523315,
-0.6764488220214844,
0.7284108996391296,
0.25151148438453674,
0.6695932745933533,
-0.09929810464382172,
-0.20693054795265198,
-0.4059924781322479,
-0.12751592695713043,
0.19281835854053497,
0.24936263263225555,
0.1325763761997223,
0.13357917964458466,
0.47208306193351746,
0.36163631081581116,
-0.5852256417274475,
0.10379425436258316,
-0.043415993452072144,
-0.14823395013809204,
0.49419155716896057,
-0.04398443177342415,
0.36045241355895996,
-0.15094785392284393,
-0.5690279006958008,
-0.2608705759048462,
-0.5420001149177551,
0.2722097933292389,
-0.2857326865196228,
0.13147233426570892,
-0.3107988238334656,
0.4815940260887146,
-0.2994822859764099,
1.0019220113754272,
0.2592258155345917,
-0.4299164414405823,
0.09696002304553986,
0.29119133949279785,
-0.7775406837463379,
-0.33410903811454773,
0.49475568532943726,
0.7399977445602417,
0.13649865984916687,
-0.23106753826141357,
0.04689687117934227,
0.12495747953653336,
0.055046506226062775,
-0.5901089906692505,
0.17850060760974884,
0.2565782070159912,
-0.40335190296173096,
-0.3380146920681,
0.1280185878276825,
-0.7883012890815735,
-0.6699618697166443,
-0.5741605162620544,
0.33408859372138977,
-0.33637896180152893,
-0.05093497037887573,
0.09893302619457245,
-0.03063533641397953,
0.6838774085044861,
0.5680744051933289,
-0.48673275113105774,
0.11157751828432083,
0.44684234261512756,
0.45937976241111755,
-0.4313816428184509,
-0.4903029799461365,
-0.932171106338501,
0.3547617495059967,
-0.20459866523742676,
0.5156163573265076,
-0.010819191113114357,
-0.05291147902607918,
-0.007233701180666685,
0.1400960236787796,
-0.056783899664878845,
-0.6616541147232056,
0.5235140919685364,
-0.5805112719535828,
0.25000545382499695,
-0.3174374997615814,
-0.4125966727733612,
-0.6126248240470886,
0.6060376167297363,
-0.5480017066001892,
0.9579471349716187,
0.09820951521396637,
-0.6915030479431152,
0.3586921691894531,
-0.17455337941646576,
-0.006980138830840588,
0.18602117896080017,
-0.48565489053726196,
-0.7524028420448303,
0.0003648168931249529,
0.5079824328422546,
0.5699871778488159,
-0.44239336252212524,
0.4747264087200165,
-0.3980053663253784,
-0.6422661542892456,
-0.44119077920913696,
-0.06223362311720848,
0.7830573320388794,
-0.16387565433979034,
-0.49475938081741333,
0.15335442125797272,
-0.8421176075935364,
0.28212711215019226,
0.0689982995390892,
0.05243014544248581,
-0.3222513198852539,
-0.001691431156359613,
-0.07238516211509705,
0.4022327959537506,
0.21772246062755585,
-0.1634252369403839,
0.003154522506520152,
-0.35623300075531006,
-0.11566754430532455,
0.2568362057209015,
0.09026631712913513,
0.3002392053604126,
-0.35595816373825073,
0.42969298362731934,
0.05029628798365593,
0.0004771905660163611,
-0.23813945055007935,
-0.4926513135433197,
-0.6441676616668701,
-0.1532483994960785,
-0.13651925325393677,
0.8555676341056824,
-0.5332497358322144,
0.6978397965431213,
-0.1587563306093216,
-0.48427778482437134,
-0.06560415774583817,
-0.10587223619222641,
0.4579249322414398,
0.7494682669639587,
0.5267005562782288,
-0.1278662085533142,
-0.8833097815513611,
-0.7946218252182007,
-0.16716483235359192,
-0.0736432671546936,
-0.1365053802728653,
0.2874127924442291,
0.279812753200531,
-0.2726406157016754,
1.01706063747406,
-0.26613327860832214,
-0.44891780614852905,
0.196150004863739,
-0.05977516248822212,
0.23433268070220947,
0.608293354511261,
0.5228489637374878,
-0.7439679503440857,
-0.45122164487838745,
0.29276344180107117,
-1.204543948173523,
-0.0003885605838149786,
0.17446136474609375,
-0.09039100259542465,
0.024224180728197098,
0.48634544014930725,
-0.38457074761390686,
0.6744892597198486,
0.6917356848716736,
-0.33895033597946167,
0.45185884833335876,
-0.02683481015264988,
0.23762264847755432,
-0.9073452353477478,
0.030177408829331398,
0.12337708473205566,
-0.43311041593551636,
-0.43156325817108154,
0.3784877061843872,
0.07992926985025406,
-0.5171161890029907,
-0.7522860169410706,
0.38734614849090576,
-0.55119788646698,
-0.19728536903858185,
-0.40814003348350525,
0.03325536847114563,
0.06187867373228073,
0.6312436461448669,
0.14307747781276703,
0.5767791867256165,
1.0214474201202393,
-0.6543153524398804,
0.2849423587322235,
0.21749456226825714,
-0.23455549776554108,
0.609644889831543,
-0.5521256327629089,
0.3066351115703583,
-0.22976550459861755,
-0.0702974796295166,
-0.6410970687866211,
-0.3184378147125244,
-0.021632526069879532,
-0.27259117364883423,
0.1523936241865158,
-0.3360233008861542,
0.20964466035366058,
-0.5550686120986938,
-0.25497686862945557,
0.45678985118865967,
0.7844521999359131,
-0.7124479413032532,
0.6449660658836365,
0.532580554485321,
0.09849318116903305,
-0.7301920056343079,
-0.6072009205818176,
0.20537643134593964,
-0.42435315251350403,
-0.9212208390235901,
0.7337614893913269,
-0.040671203285455704,
-0.2234320193529129,
-0.1765369176864624,
-0.03964637219905853,
-0.22703400254249573,
-0.3394171893596649,
0.17246580123901367,
0.36136123538017273,
-0.3093888759613037,
-0.42070022225379944,
-0.2505320608615875,
0.03027189150452614,
-0.0846204087138176,
-0.43394699692726135,
0.49990907311439514,
-0.05663279443979263,
-0.33758607506752014,
-0.5784797072410583,
0.15855930745601654,
0.8695051074028015,
-0.19254599511623383,
0.6446797251701355,
0.4916592836380005,
-0.8661218285560608,
-0.06989884376525879,
-0.7435106039047241,
0.09035345166921616,
-0.42147544026374817,
0.49603837728500366,
-0.18050219118595123,
-0.626634418964386,
0.5660225749015808,
0.15598329901695251,
-0.27465397119522095,
0.2911105453968048,
0.4722532331943512,
-0.21568182110786438,
0.6894950270652771,
0.835992693901062,
-0.1788773089647293,
0.4023350477218628,
-0.42923152446746826,
-0.14901591837406158,
-0.8964889645576477,
-0.27790865302085876,
0.02543630078434944,
-0.09411466121673584,
-0.2577059268951416,
-0.9569187164306641,
0.4705635905265808,
0.29439207911491394,
-0.12833507359027863,
0.22428929805755615,
-0.33521324396133423,
0.5609185099601746,
0.19871442019939423,
0.16689130663871765,
0.017466573044657707,
0.3042284846305847,
0.013190333731472492,
-0.2682070732116699,
-0.4049977958202362,
-0.16303205490112305,
0.5711553692817688,
0.39473792910575867,
0.48554524779319763,
-0.4593030512332916,
0.461099237203598,
0.14230456948280334,
-0.14895398914813995,
-0.830730140209198,
0.7068693041801453,
-0.28428900241851807,
-0.09963833540678024,
-0.5838478803634644,
-0.14136098325252533,
-0.40740981698036194,
0.632120668888092,
-0.21625828742980957,
-0.7014495134353638,
0.31647560000419617,
0.4328905940055847,
-0.27235379815101624,
0.23911865055561066,
-0.22363360226154327,
0.8219927549362183,
-0.11621708422899246,
-0.7441878318786621,
0.04559880867600441,
-0.482260137796402,
0.4074547588825226,
0.20104987919330597,
0.17762349545955658,
-0.11964932829141617,
0.25493913888931274,
0.8585442304611206,
-0.4474114775657654,
0.6658940315246582,
-0.5170192122459412,
-0.4402713477611542,
0.5010549426078796,
-0.2747126817703247,
0.8630915284156799,
-0.09084517508745193,
-0.03195730596780777,
0.377813458442688,
-0.4161604940891266,
-0.3381945788860321,
-0.617996871471405,
0.6497575044631958,
-0.5640287399291992,
-0.4943348467350006,
-0.23897036910057068,
-0.7093654274940491,
-0.5707300305366516,
0.45456865429878235,
0.4404800832271576,
0.28559544682502747,
-0.24297893047332764,
0.3330123722553253,
0.6904527544975281,
-0.30398163199424744,
0.23979003727436066,
0.29222601652145386,
-0.47415846586227417,
-0.6777758598327637,
0.8446754217147827,
0.06835675239562988,
0.05369105190038681,
0.5629648566246033,
0.261705219745636,
-0.07549639791250229,
-0.7128292918205261,
-0.20247675478458405,
0.11094028502702713,
-0.6479080319404602,
-0.14902058243751526,
-0.324677437543869,
-0.360008180141449,
-0.5101578831672668,
-0.32074788212776184,
-0.2761130928993225,
0.08279003202915192,
0.2010202705860138,
0.16340471804141998,
-0.006913401652127504,
0.2019529491662979,
0.2595421373844147,
0.49937498569488525,
-0.47705817222595215,
0.6294607520103455,
0.6284227967262268,
0.2717190980911255,
-0.20745441317558289,
-0.5616910457611084,
-0.2251761108636856,
0.0909099355340004,
-0.2176654189825058,
-0.6465188264846802,
0.5184233784675598,
-0.019964082166552544,
0.47515586018562317,
0.045357637107372284,
-0.22071591019630432,
1.151255488395691,
-0.5197880268096924,
0.5684966444969177,
0.3823540210723877,
-0.7226877808570862,
0.5655945539474487,
-0.748236358165741,
0.2849735915660858,
0.4473875164985657,
-0.22046488523483276,
-0.5479066967964172,
-0.0651380866765976,
-0.42060035467147827,
-0.7030680775642395,
0.5387202501296997,
0.21578097343444824,
-0.510252833366394,
0.4514158368110657,
0.4312964975833893,
-0.12965704500675201,
0.1880914568901062,
-0.7604707479476929,
-0.1444678157567978,
-0.09275390207767487,
-0.055154722183942795,
0.10458777099847794,
-0.21000081300735474,
0.1666596531867981,
-0.4866335690021515,
0.6218167543411255,
-0.2591722011566162,
0.21753112971782684,
0.09502112120389938,
-0.14297541975975037,
-0.44993895292282104,
-0.07044793665409088,
0.3458293080329895,
0.5605400800704956,
-0.4777538478374481,
-0.054666150361299515,
0.42329904437065125,
-0.38173708319664,
-0.03789248317480087,
-0.14971403777599335,
-0.3415578007698059,
-0.17862968146800995,
0.42092299461364746,
1.0979150533676147,
0.06165657192468643,
-0.5612902641296387,
0.6276701092720032,
0.2286418080329895,
-0.22076934576034546,
-0.45889362692832947,
-0.010249864310026169,
-0.030898794531822205,
-0.021440787240862846,
0.18556345999240875,
0.26239636540412903,
0.041665829718112946,
-0.19594506919384003,
0.4565412104129791,
0.5074033737182617,
-0.43917107582092285,
-0.24783137440681458,
0.7080037593841553,
0.08939315378665924,
-0.10685514658689499,
0.2124917358160019,
0.022795770317316055,
-0.33954206109046936,
0.8311470746994019,
0.6234002113342285,
0.9048041701316833,
-0.3469395935535431,
-0.14329230785369873,
0.5160927772521973,
0.19266340136528015,
-0.12945573031902313,
0.42940154671669006,
0.331506609916687,
-0.5841957330703735,
-0.7923558950424194,
-0.5856015086174011,
-0.38691532611846924,
0.6769862174987793,
-0.7632654309272766,
0.8405430316925049,
-0.21324817836284637,
0.19485704600811005,
-0.5103398561477661,
-0.15436460077762604,
-0.761824905872345,
0.8144660592079163,
0.6044356226921082,
0.7176249623298645,
-0.6905326247215271,
0.8756313323974609,
0.8238093852996826,
-0.08129139244556427,
-0.5511472821235657,
0.3608304560184479,
-0.12563762068748474,
-0.9443098902702332,
0.5504541993141174,
0.4830102026462555,
-0.37670189142227173,
0.11424475163221359,
-0.36807897686958313,
-0.9471749663352966,
1.283564567565918,
0.7375996112823486,
-0.7997770309448242,
-0.3477895259857178,
0.1963275671005249,
0.2229800522327423,
-0.4732346832752228,
-0.23407629132270813,
0.3260694444179535,
0.39296969771385193,
0.3690868318080902,
-0.8922191858291626,
-0.19807425141334534,
-0.030891070142388344,
0.1650724709033966,
-0.09759894013404846,
-0.5319558382034302,
0.8032561540603638,
-0.10523568093776703,
0.036151014268398285,
-0.2128821462392807,
0.7781347632408142,
0.49975842237472534,
0.4059034585952759,
0.7236839532852173,
0.8988609910011292,
0.7941433191299438,
0.2693125307559967,
0.849616527557373,
-0.13433808088302612,
0.6527904272079468,
1.1138341426849365,
-0.3896143436431885,
0.8038896322250366,
0.44218721985816956,
-0.05210426449775696,
0.3105941414833069,
0.26619669795036316,
0.15156739950180054,
0.6802140474319458,
-0.11970816552639008,
0.05796058848500252,
-0.3875156044960022,
-0.06202441826462746,
-0.46116921305656433,
0.5859373211860657,
0.05034054443240166,
-0.12812699377536774,
-0.20878058671951294,
0.3604886531829834,
-0.4225890338420868,
0.13620306551456451,
-0.6014138460159302,
0.5677226781845093,
0.0072222016751766205,
-0.6859135627746582,
1.0603642463684082,
-0.25244635343551636,
0.5740857124328613,
-0.30345234274864197,
-0.11312872171401978,
0.04993917793035507,
0.2769783139228821,
-0.10642164200544357,
-0.3075498640537262,
0.43729639053344727,
-0.2154332995414734,
-0.39435258507728577,
0.038195230066776276,
0.9738545417785645,
-0.5656818151473999,
-0.4399607479572296,
0.4499625265598297,
0.4259199798107147,
-0.14705391228199005,
-0.38930580019950867,
-0.5736096501350403,
0.2481396347284317,
-0.07309839874505997,
0.001992573030292988,
0.2931446433067322,
0.24355700612068176,
-0.2768273651599884,
0.4354873597621918,
0.2891743779182434,
-0.025906996801495552,
0.06015331670641899,
0.08937381207942963,
0.5199222564697266,
-0.9552291035652161,
-0.8333380222320557,
-0.7436671257019043,
0.5607221722602844,
-0.10808390378952026,
0.06696546077728271,
0.6408650279045105,
0.4616820514202118,
0.5457293391227722,
-0.43142104148864746,
0.9134019017219543,
-0.0714375302195549,
0.4777982831001282,
-0.773516833782196,
0.6083468198776245,
-0.6167927384376526,
0.0083560049533844,
-0.29126980900764465,
-0.8935562968254089,
-0.3928397595882416,
0.6060658097267151,
-0.24184992909431458,
-0.03894360363483429,
0.7852221131324768,
0.5257036089897156,
-0.19937372207641602,
-0.4789206087589264,
0.9490354657173157,
0.024308957159519196,
0.27832743525505066,
0.7431168556213379,
0.46557819843292236,
-0.8268978595733643,
0.13806064426898956,
-0.44817450642585754,
-0.3197212517261505,
-0.29052719473838806,
-1.2530995607376099,
-1.0211007595062256,
-0.35758131742477417,
-0.5926139950752258,
-0.10007312148809433,
0.08078581094741821,
0.768397331237793,
1.0264753103256226,
-0.8920201659202576,
-0.309306263923645,
-0.40577784180641174,
-0.22168231010437012,
-0.5670104026794434,
-0.16785426437854767,
0.38618263602256775,
-0.020578617230057716,
-0.7125899195671082,
0.6268160939216614,
0.40708959102630615,
0.10969749093055725,
-0.1426040083169937,
-0.18253400921821594,
-0.016663383692502975,
-0.18381492793560028,
0.7906994223594666,
0.31854957342147827,
-0.8910925388336182,
-0.3336490988731384,
-0.019597437232732773,
0.02400279976427555,
0.21625417470932007,
0.5783973932266235,
-1.0142465829849243,
0.326288640499115,
0.4472443461418152,
0.7191967964172363,
0.21392428874969482,
0.17891965806484222,
0.5475288033485413,
-0.7972683310508728,
0.6424274444580078,
0.1262696087360382,
0.5635128617286682,
0.4196872413158417,
-0.4993382692337036,
0.3595028817653656,
0.4166361689567566,
-0.2815437912940979,
-0.7598259449005127,
0.14237937331199646,
-1.2679469585418701,
0.21401266753673553,
0.9543941020965576,
0.019427474588155746,
-0.5376108288764954,
0.1519593447446823,
-0.3833129405975342,
0.32344841957092285,
0.11009103059768677,
0.6414318084716797,
0.5103201270103455,
0.05838286876678467,
-0.4138053059577942,
-0.6033612489700317,
0.35128435492515564,
0.4064900875091553,
-0.9472949504852295,
0.18742311000823975,
0.488701194524765,
0.1301967352628708,
0.22005969285964966,
0.41801923513412476,
-0.02276962623000145,
0.5846165418624878,
-0.3220435082912445,
0.39470919966697693,
-0.316445529460907,
-0.31064948439598083,
-0.19524814188480377,
0.5023376941680908,
-0.09380485862493515,
-0.24869869649410248
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.01895v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.01895v1
|
Explicitly Encoding Structural Symmetry is Key to Length Generalization in Arithmetic Tasks
| 2024-06-04T02:00:07 | 2024-06-04T02:00:07 |
Mahdi Sabbaghi, George Pappas, Hamed Hassani, Surbhi Goel
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, stat.ML
|
Despite the success of Transformers on language understanding, code
generation, and logical reasoning, they still fail to generalize over length on
basic arithmetic tasks such as addition and multiplication. A major reason
behind this failure is the vast difference in structure between numbers and
text; For example, the numbers are typically parsed from right to left, and
there is a correspondence between digits at the same position across different
numbers. In contrast, for text, such symmetries are quite unnatural. In this
work, we propose to encode these semantics explicitly into the model via
modified number formatting and custom positional encodings. Empirically, our
method allows a Transformer trained on numbers with at most 5-digits for
addition and multiplication to generalize up to 50-digit numbers, without using
additional data for longer sequences. We further demonstrate that traditional
absolute positional encodings (APE) fail to generalize to longer sequences,
even when trained with augmented data that captures task symmetries. To
elucidate the importance of explicitly encoding structure, we prove that
explicit incorporation of structure via positional encodings is necessary for
out-of-distribution generalization. Finally, we pinpoint other challenges
inherent to length generalization beyond capturing symmetries, in particular
complexity of the underlying task, and propose changes in the training
distribution to address them.
|
[
-0.11308052390813828,
-0.18724320828914642,
0.5301250219345093,
0.4021703004837036,
-0.42342516779899597,
-0.12883473932743073,
-0.021851150318980217,
-0.34110626578330994,
0.4250003397464752,
0.05569949001073837,
-0.3102588355541229,
-0.35479193925857544,
-0.7537692189216614,
0.4883566200733185,
-0.31156471371650696,
0.9455333352088928,
-0.16408635675907135,
0.18858996033668518,
0.001760022365488112,
-0.3061434030532837,
-0.06963612884283066,
-0.9524057507514954,
-0.11392053216695786,
-0.2659611701965332,
0.3532932996749878,
0.028560064733028412,
1.0624749660491943,
1.1928822994232178,
0.7842491269111633,
0.3463079631328583,
-0.08655184507369995,
0.35581743717193604,
-0.24266467988491058,
-0.2818187177181244,
-0.036000654101371765,
-0.7033959031105042,
-0.7415841817855835,
-0.24676068127155304,
0.9702973365783691,
1.2497649192810059,
-0.1613084375858307,
0.20721393823623657,
-0.14715507626533508,
0.8848941326141357,
-0.458766371011734,
0.4164731800556183,
-0.41029420495033264,
0.21233201026916504,
-0.23858478665351868,
-0.030904682353138924,
-0.491225004196167,
-0.18093109130859375,
-0.30257952213287354,
-0.8226063847541809,
0.31675854325294495,
-0.2780417203903198,
0.8290571570396423,
0.3684864044189453,
-0.43735674023628235,
-0.303606241941452,
-0.7087051272392273,
0.5260365009307861,
-0.6152864098548889,
0.764125406742096,
0.4183032512664795,
0.02381335385143757,
0.0015304484404623508,
-0.42592495679855347,
-0.37997570633888245,
0.13665027916431427,
-0.326564222574234,
0.09040234982967377,
-0.051397889852523804,
0.20839618146419525,
0.6080784797668457,
0.5013160705566406,
-0.4441094696521759,
-0.3162725865840912,
-0.658068835735321,
0.17823123931884766,
0.8020824193954468,
0.3000328242778778,
0.35806965827941895,
-0.2246144711971283,
0.04996742308139801,
-0.49960166215896606,
-0.5772503614425659,
0.16998858749866486,
0.6985056400299072,
-0.05738642439246178,
-0.46437790989875793,
0.8334259986877441,
0.014611827209591866,
0.5965954661369324,
0.37470582127571106,
0.21565373241901398,
0.38909733295440674,
-0.07916445285081863,
-0.39102834463119507,
0.15135227143764496,
0.6848881244659424,
-0.07124586403369904,
0.16410939395427704,
-0.15665511786937714,
-0.10364089906215668,
0.4293096363544464,
0.5102659463882446,
-0.898309051990509,
-0.13272178173065186,
-0.1607913225889206,
-0.33252668380737305,
-0.15561386942863464,
0.44446510076522827,
-0.18236248195171356,
0.039944909512996674,
-0.3317623734474182,
0.29908034205436707,
-0.550404965877533,
0.27019503712654114,
0.5778279304504395,
-0.34505465626716614,
0.21051137149333954,
0.12915679812431335,
-1.559150218963623,
0.3477150499820709,
1.0498086214065552,
0.771503746509552,
0.18657010793685913,
-0.039881106466054916,
-0.21285903453826904,
0.39801326394081116,
-0.8057242035865784,
0.2565554976463318,
-0.7745537161827087,
-0.5279330611228943,
-0.4035657048225403,
0.04120101407170296,
-0.1224270612001419,
-0.2550292909145355,
0.4082377552986145,
-0.472093790769577,
0.19820010662078857,
-0.10713262856006622,
-0.6080643534660339,
0.07530920952558517,
0.018267851322889328,
-0.6921617984771729,
0.5622082948684692,
0.30534788966178894,
-0.6238848567008972,
0.2604312002658844,
-0.6333134174346924,
-0.5885820984840393,
-0.059526167809963226,
-0.5014798045158386,
-0.7244530320167542,
0.7636824250221252,
0.39728549122810364,
0.02214273251593113,
0.05819172412157059,
0.3030020594596863,
-0.4551504850387573,
-0.6587826609611511,
0.19127224385738373,
-0.545950710773468,
0.8330903649330139,
0.01936314068734646,
-0.2689460813999176,
-0.1385226994752884,
-0.7198910713195801,
-0.16275542974472046,
0.06955429911613464,
-0.3130348026752472,
-0.3785111606121063,
0.13909952342510223,
-0.7598370909690857,
-0.07772187143564224,
0.20172357559204102,
-0.6326876282691956,
0.4838828444480896,
-0.8815317749977112,
0.45102524757385254,
0.7527921199798584,
-0.3659210205078125,
0.9932231307029724,
-0.0870494395494461,
0.3463423252105713,
0.01954222470521927,
0.07037524878978729,
-0.39381083846092224,
-0.33300313353538513,
-0.7499914169311523,
-0.20203611254692078,
0.14976291358470917,
0.40493935346603394,
-0.5923588871955872,
0.5610495805740356,
-0.7373517155647278,
-0.2633150815963745,
-0.35757115483283997,
0.007232686039060354,
0.36273834109306335,
0.32629409432411194,
0.386514812707901,
-0.49245989322662354,
-0.5058978796005249,
-0.838310182094574,
-0.3427242040634155,
-0.2261696606874466,
-0.4157046675682068,
-0.06955895572900772,
0.41515934467315674,
-0.13299794495105743,
0.7905192971229553,
-0.7204039096832275,
-0.04086615890264511,
-0.002433259505778551,
0.041140325367450714,
0.6019793748855591,
0.4417059123516083,
0.40052908658981323,
-0.747569739818573,
-0.3700560927391052,
-0.009133705869317055,
-0.9290114641189575,
0.20670749247074127,
-0.15863919258117676,
-0.08581800758838654,
0.13496913015842438,
0.1452462375164032,
-0.8289555311203003,
0.7088510394096375,
0.5327118039131165,
-0.3648563027381897,
0.15134820342063904,
-0.35659265518188477,
-0.10369772464036942,
-1.1386250257492065,
-0.2676646411418915,
-0.007631980814039707,
-0.053573064506053925,
-0.6686683297157288,
-0.015636419877409935,
0.4068496525287628,
-0.56226646900177,
-0.06281661242246628,
0.19521456956863403,
-0.5865345001220703,
-0.21943672001361847,
0.09174814075231552,
-0.6060515642166138,
0.2548738718032837,
0.729592502117157,
0.24011901021003723,
0.5036895275115967,
0.14396703243255615,
-0.3477039039134979,
0.1606355607509613,
0.4144774079322815,
0.08634255826473236,
0.47292962670326233,
-0.8575246334075928,
0.06020556762814522,
-0.3959575891494751,
0.574950098991394,
-0.5953816175460815,
-0.19610071182250977,
0.2979549765586853,
-0.5014816522598267,
0.27604031562805176,
-0.4011150598526001,
-0.3459482789039612,
-0.2850812077522278,
-0.3966407775878906,
0.8572655320167542,
0.7090553045272827,
-0.29605811834335327,
0.5736126899719238,
0.051481157541275024,
0.15514016151428223,
-0.5803313851356506,
-0.6582594513893127,
-0.18984034657478333,
-0.3022811710834503,
-0.9757099747657776,
0.6001313328742981,
0.08907631039619446,
-0.20420366525650024,
-0.17943786084651947,
-0.6153104305267334,
0.02112254500389099,
-0.1021052673459053,
0.28084808588027954,
0.24538612365722656,
-0.3336906433105469,
0.1284734606742859,
0.30843454599380493,
-0.279635488986969,
0.3537728786468506,
-0.34217849373817444,
0.4779113531112671,
-0.17763464152812958,
-0.6856825947761536,
-0.5176925659179688,
0.35528355836868286,
0.38999226689338684,
-0.2280033975839615,
0.68663489818573,
0.4205942451953888,
-0.5600398182868958,
-0.1375330090522766,
-0.051771294325590134,
-0.30791744589805603,
-0.5953691601753235,
0.39968180656433105,
-0.5209166407585144,
-0.6168959736824036,
0.3818929195404053,
0.2172752022743225,
0.054429538547992706,
0.4621160328388214,
0.15521687269210815,
-0.14041517674922943,
1.4439414739608765,
0.7173361778259277,
0.17452339828014374,
0.4699649214744568,
-0.41361087560653687,
0.38392800092697144,
-0.5584378242492676,
-0.33664754033088684,
-0.31122151017189026,
-0.43787845969200134,
-0.4786095917224884,
-0.48590168356895447,
0.39371728897094727,
0.11051421612501144,
-0.42054158449172974,
0.5449701547622681,
-0.5503782033920288,
0.5032922029495239,
0.17639142274856567,
0.15115530788898468,
0.08883650600910187,
0.27746689319610596,
0.19849996268749237,
-0.352223664522171,
-0.4674947261810303,
-0.17615926265716553,
0.9229008555412292,
0.5073584914207458,
0.9760274291038513,
0.1683044731616974,
0.9487343430519104,
0.06756429374217987,
0.16924060881137848,
-0.8636000156402588,
0.24009954929351807,
-0.6366714239120483,
-0.19008931517601013,
-0.5082072615623474,
-0.7188107967376709,
-0.7848559021949768,
0.21175450086593628,
0.2705810070037842,
-0.30968546867370605,
0.7142834067344666,
0.2795952260494232,
-0.09815403074026108,
0.33093270659446716,
-0.7103039622306824,
0.7350162863731384,
-0.1499619036912918,
0.17239326238632202,
-0.03878592699766159,
-0.5937291383743286,
0.07146266847848892,
0.08247246593236923,
0.2534513771533966,
0.07184712588787079,
-0.0639209970831871,
0.6899334788322449,
-0.9258017539978027,
0.9614344239234924,
0.17240889370441437,
-0.35987111926078796,
-0.13371869921684265,
0.22723068296909332,
0.7235528230667114,
0.2735443413257599,
-0.022534549236297607,
0.41568776965141296,
-0.22974279522895813,
-0.6018608808517456,
-0.9252939224243164,
0.22497768700122833,
-1.0403228998184204,
-0.7665258049964905,
-0.3949034512042999,
-0.7332682013511658,
-0.2788098454475403,
-0.04395299404859543,
0.5105137825012207,
0.6592957377433777,
0.1124023050069809,
0.33851128816604614,
0.6611958146095276,
0.28877145051956177,
0.48618805408477783,
-0.005045326426625252,
0.3261612355709076,
-0.6569474339485168,
0.8421277403831482,
0.19008217751979828,
0.26667320728302,
0.7554975748062134,
0.10168973356485367,
-0.43559759855270386,
-0.11407395452260971,
-0.6887785196304321,
0.30163705348968506,
-0.6523085832595825,
-0.052390094846487045,
-0.4623655676841736,
-0.3103025555610657,
-0.4907141923904419,
-0.5052801966667175,
-0.3599143326282501,
-0.8402827382087708,
-0.253773957490921,
-0.22025056183338165,
0.1672062873840332,
0.7326630353927612,
-0.12443054467439651,
0.3199659287929535,
-0.9183365702629089,
0.6555008292198181,
0.2758878171443939,
0.3641003668308258,
-0.16024526953697205,
-0.826045572757721,
-0.3338779807090759,
0.2509036064147949,
-0.28047046065330505,
-0.9211177825927734,
0.32597804069519043,
0.25871530175209045,
0.1926318258047104,
0.465328574180603,
-0.24850216507911682,
0.9933590292930603,
-0.8594158887863159,
0.4056050479412079,
0.420169860124588,
-1.1781747341156006,
0.19513338804244995,
-0.21246884763240814,
0.28540942072868347,
0.12161169946193695,
0.4897090494632721,
-0.6085774302482605,
0.01555373053997755,
-0.6101936101913452,
-0.7587038278579712,
0.8513779044151306,
0.4342706799507141,
0.5163112282752991,
-0.14277146756649017,
0.21469706296920776,
-0.05002589151263237,
-0.002650814363732934,
-0.6343961954116821,
-0.27025067806243896,
-0.7256962060928345,
-0.5222055315971375,
0.10151372849941254,
-0.14238350093364716,
-0.335505872964859,
-0.3630601465702057,
0.2802591919898987,
-0.14593352377414703,
0.40201064944267273,
0.1836095005273819,
-0.27537980675697327,
-0.012520338408648968,
0.3827280104160309,
0.5340962409973145,
0.8733121752738953,
0.05247854068875313,
0.16126781702041626,
0.28883618116378784,
-0.5822324156761169,
0.3384491205215454,
0.1686786264181137,
-0.02977079339325428,
0.1948588490486145,
0.44327694177627563,
0.8994449973106384,
0.21183431148529053,
-0.07691527903079987,
0.388345867395401,
0.2841121554374695,
-0.2888484597206116,
-0.296556681394577,
-0.05266923829913139,
0.03813259303569794,
-0.10075138509273529,
0.3901195526123047,
-0.013970465399324894,
0.1116037592291832,
-0.44454342126846313,
0.10881444066762924,
0.32025596499443054,
-0.5120565891265869,
-0.8134944438934326,
0.5844861268997192,
0.06098281592130661,
-0.45999646186828613,
0.6815897226333618,
-0.07025333493947983,
-0.26994824409484863,
0.887238621711731,
0.7852025032043457,
0.7389534115791321,
-0.29166918992996216,
0.2812456786632538,
0.301298588514328,
0.34567973017692566,
-0.20216695964336395,
0.23716716468334198,
-0.174660325050354,
-0.652031660079956,
-0.401266485452652,
-0.6882592439651489,
-0.1690598875284195,
-0.421469122171402,
-0.7217523455619812,
0.1948719173669815,
-0.6287727355957031,
-0.04209182783961296,
0.029009969905018806,
-0.5055927038192749,
-0.36558666825294495,
0.1718149334192276,
0.3229622542858124,
0.7596972584724426,
-0.8462677597999573,
0.616752564907074,
0.922854483127594,
-0.2842824459075928,
-0.9191411137580872,
-0.41549018025398254,
-0.21898239850997925,
-0.8395665287971497,
0.6035001873970032,
0.30785027146339417,
0.04108535498380661,
-0.23297423124313354,
-0.39027854800224304,
-0.8502208590507507,
1.0219045877456665,
0.7112758755683899,
-0.6163752675056458,
-0.6461883783340454,
0.9235695600509644,
0.6786012649536133,
-0.2627442479133606,
0.06896718591451645,
0.1927519142627716,
0.22793105244636536,
0.10704340785741806,
-0.6425458788871765,
-0.02127845212817192,
-0.43312013149261475,
0.3509288728237152,
0.6838427186012268,
-0.5251541137695312,
0.8855769038200378,
-0.1146630048751831,
-0.21427440643310547,
-0.1537788361310959,
0.7113919854164124,
0.2747500538825989,
0.0030349285807460546,
0.2858567237854004,
0.9175660610198975,
0.3408162593841553,
-0.08991426229476929,
0.9797088503837585,
-0.2332908660173416,
0.28163111209869385,
0.8164564967155457,
0.17222163081169128,
0.37408432364463806,
0.22493582963943481,
-0.3005020022392273,
0.6201164126396179,
0.3909488618373871,
-0.05603141337633133,
0.15062656998634338,
0.09318442642688751,
-0.10207795351743698,
-0.4252316355705261,
0.298272043466568,
-0.60728919506073,
0.265860915184021,
0.5396303534507751,
-0.6383507251739502,
-0.2677854299545288,
-0.3833528757095337,
0.17276757955551147,
0.1907922774553299,
-0.3437860310077667,
0.5923369526863098,
0.46727174520492554,
-0.23038576543331146,
0.609866201877594,
0.19665999710559845,
0.5194453597068787,
-0.829429030418396,
-0.22666335105895996,
-0.3908650875091553,
0.28481319546699524,
-0.29089945554733276,
-0.5888851284980774,
0.5589661002159119,
-0.27478325366973877,
-0.34668344259262085,
-0.39488306641578674,
0.12435046583414078,
-0.3381783664226532,
-0.8760099411010742,
-0.10822179913520813,
-0.1074812114238739,
-0.10437570512294769,
-0.07486086338758469,
-0.4528050422668457,
-0.023663384839892387,
-0.20662140846252441,
-0.030877379700541496,
0.18472586572170258,
0.6877692937850952,
-0.5664492249488831,
0.3404322564601898,
0.8167577981948853,
-0.13122420012950897,
0.1554686725139618,
0.02429681085050106,
0.8544038534164429,
-0.8580681085586548,
-0.8995441198348999,
-1.2953107357025146,
0.37496399879455566,
0.01361839845776558,
-0.2359926700592041,
0.5610270500183105,
0.6319193243980408,
0.9839794635772705,
-0.25555887818336487,
0.19152984023094177,
0.09908828139305115,
-0.4314021170139313,
-0.261543869972229,
0.5076667666435242,
-0.46497809886932373,
0.2022264450788498,
-0.14063766598701477,
-1.16771399974823,
-0.4103320240974426,
0.5827130675315857,
-0.3901292383670807,
-0.1566501259803772,
0.6592913269996643,
0.42854106426239014,
-0.3453001379966736,
0.011306436732411385,
0.29325535893440247,
-0.03881540894508362,
0.3894515037536621,
0.717374324798584,
0.48497870564460754,
-0.6005669236183167,
0.7318177223205566,
-0.3302178680896759,
-0.024703409522771835,
0.0646325945854187,
-0.4692302346229553,
-0.8241288661956787,
-0.4724472761154175,
0.07851053774356842,
-0.018765775486826897,
0.09038003534078598,
0.6391158699989319,
0.7283952832221985,
-0.6211708784103394,
-0.3439706861972809,
-0.23223347961902618,
0.11529163271188736,
-0.07403712719678879,
-0.15501566231250763,
0.5170590281486511,
-0.150976300239563,
-0.7385003566741943,
0.23487520217895508,
0.5627867579460144,
0.40208181738853455,
0.1720626801252365,
-0.16964605450630188,
0.4977256953716278,
0.17088931798934937,
0.5436464548110962,
0.4357362389564514,
-0.4210432171821594,
-0.33417269587516785,
0.2755979597568512,
-0.0827932357788086,
0.3540734052658081,
0.8479477763175964,
-0.4807155728340149,
0.044387925416231155,
0.7138978242874146,
0.6081547141075134,
0.4583680331707001,
0.3471736013889313,
0.8782873153686523,
-0.8030237555503845,
0.29876893758773804,
0.20499160885810852,
0.5242936015129089,
0.242242231965065,
-0.4827509820461273,
0.609825611114502,
0.34454548358917236,
0.0019979195203632116,
-0.7621134519577026,
0.6611656546592712,
-0.7577368021011353,
-0.00845707394182682,
0.7702538967132568,
-0.23610073328018188,
-0.32595351338386536,
0.1593526303768158,
0.16956718266010284,
0.10463500767946243,
-0.24912458658218384,
0.8297111988067627,
0.5047770738601685,
-0.22140681743621826,
0.20264661312103271,
0.3989010155200958,
0.6016989350318909,
0.5120750665664673,
-0.6830114126205444,
-0.041800569742918015,
0.33099833130836487,
0.16748486459255219,
0.4701661467552185,
0.38156595826148987,
-0.4616195559501648,
0.38789093494415283,
0.17365507781505585,
-0.13474337756633759,
-0.17602163553237915,
-0.31411927938461304,
-0.4526757001876831,
0.10043462365865707,
-0.3083146810531616,
-0.05540452152490616
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.01879v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.01879v1
|
Bi-DCSpell: A Bi-directional Detector-Corrector Interactive Framework for Chinese Spelling Check
| 2024-06-04T01:20:14 | 2024-06-04T01:20:14 |
Haiming Wu, Hanqing Zhang, Richeng Xuan, Dawei Song
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Chinese Spelling Check (CSC) aims to detect and correct potentially
misspelled characters in Chinese sentences. Naturally, it involves the
detection and correction subtasks, which interact with each other dynamically.
Such interactions are bi-directional, i.e., the detection result would help
reduce the risk of over-correction and under-correction while the knowledge
learnt from correction would help prevent false detection. Current CSC
approaches are of two types: correction-only or single-directional
detection-to-correction interactive frameworks. Nonetheless, they overlook the
bi-directional interactions between detection and correction. This paper aims
to fill the gap by proposing a Bi-directional Detector-Corrector framework for
CSC (Bi-DCSpell). Notably, Bi-DCSpell contains separate detection and
correction encoders, followed by a novel interactive learning module
facilitating bi-directional feature interactions between detection and
correction to improve each other's representation learning. Extensive
experimental results demonstrate a robust correction performance of Bi-DCSpell
on widely used benchmarking datasets while possessing a satisfactory detection
ability.
|
[
-0.0675751119852066,
-0.47279444336891174,
0.16707222163677216,
0.3016909062862396,
-0.08064709603786469,
0.17262984812259674,
-0.265134334564209,
-0.4553050696849823,
0.1951540857553482,
0.15401265025138855,
-0.7677099108695984,
-0.5446258783340454,
-0.38482266664505005,
0.3219718337059021,
-0.33586424589157104,
0.5336697101593018,
-0.02723904699087143,
0.24412399530410767,
-0.07901658117771149,
-0.14656099677085876,
-0.28957414627075195,
-0.5090113282203674,
-0.9436913132667542,
0.017382420599460602,
0.9110454320907593,
0.5580991506576538,
0.6550610661506653,
0.37247735261917114,
0.15023182332515717,
0.34670040011405945,
-0.3299573063850403,
0.6452666521072388,
-0.30039429664611816,
-0.1393003612756729,
-0.3231005072593689,
-0.6154717206954956,
-0.5647924542427063,
-0.06445284932851791,
0.6702624559402466,
0.8522799611091614,
-0.23350301384925842,
-0.26195091009140015,
0.3653465509414673,
0.8014184832572937,
-0.7148251533508301,
-0.1125040352344513,
-0.403491348028183,
0.10428301244974136,
-0.4046939015388489,
-0.1687728464603424,
-0.43714964389801025,
-0.19643814861774445,
-0.004022521898150444,
-0.5923454165458679,
0.4987533390522003,
0.15812836587429047,
0.7822350859642029,
-0.06535416096448898,
-0.4720519781112671,
-0.4125993549823761,
-0.641431450843811,
0.45196765661239624,
-0.7068305015563965,
0.42773306369781494,
0.5041215419769287,
0.47212719917297363,
-0.19566866755485535,
-0.7417852878570557,
-0.9909051656723022,
0.07148174196481705,
-0.20100617408752441,
0.41294121742248535,
-0.02661026455461979,
0.36645203828811646,
0.2660556733608246,
0.1832980066537857,
-0.6125735640525818,
0.2440738081932068,
-0.1007373258471489,
-0.3179430067539215,
0.5262448787689209,
0.021194132044911385,
0.6599740386009216,
0.15566149353981018,
0.06519431620836258,
-0.05780276656150818,
-0.6854259371757507,
0.25690197944641113,
0.6106869578361511,
0.5153709650039673,
-0.17489439249038696,
0.4567312002182007,
-0.22154778242111206,
0.5490188002586365,
0.6603456139564514,
0.17611992359161377,
0.24502207338809967,
-0.5175084471702576,
-0.11035338044166565,
0.290183961391449,
0.3471643030643463,
0.05610249936580658,
-0.058508384972810745,
-0.02625259757041931,
-0.13426053524017334,
-0.11736474186182022,
0.12286306917667389,
-0.5380008220672607,
-0.5901583433151245,
0.3660573661327362,
-0.4740811884403229,
-0.36267489194869995,
0.3885860741138458,
-0.7343444228172302,
-0.44960081577301025,
-0.435163676738739,
0.3184621334075928,
-0.2739156186580658,
-0.2578648328781128,
0.030895832926034927,
-0.06724811345338821,
0.022094102576375008,
0.3821429908275604,
-0.8582008481025696,
-0.0756508931517601,
0.6206737756729126,
0.7474794387817383,
-0.16518592834472656,
-0.6501421928405762,
-0.8337595462799072,
0.14103886485099792,
-0.2585844099521637,
1.0749704837799072,
-0.28934863209724426,
-0.27370500564575195,
0.3786366283893585,
0.32789286971092224,
-0.10810887068510056,
-0.45499366521835327,
0.3071707785129547,
-0.38597023487091064,
0.31342747807502747,
-0.8173710703849792,
-0.08824498951435089,
-0.36712539196014404,
0.41360408067703247,
-0.7515501976013184,
1.076851487159729,
-0.011277342215180397,
-0.9467601180076599,
0.568178117275238,
-0.2630329728126526,
-0.8209348320960999,
0.3760411739349365,
0.07573529332876205,
-0.6714524030685425,
-0.33501482009887695,
0.20047365128993988,
-0.023024139925837517,
0.2432636320590973,
-0.24644121527671814,
-0.39533066749572754,
-0.8041163086891174,
0.2445875108242035,
-0.3840697407722473,
1.0983327627182007,
-0.23616831004619598,
-0.6010004281997681,
0.23636318743228912,
-0.9537909030914307,
-0.16930216550827026,
-0.14855821430683136,
-0.5709865689277649,
-0.42416462302207947,
0.1674819141626358,
-0.13903596997261047,
0.26584553718566895,
0.2732897698879242,
-0.5894476175308228,
0.08245405554771423,
-0.4378211796283722,
0.05145249515771866,
0.6291297674179077,
-0.3798143267631531,
0.5607937574386597,
-0.0557151734828949,
0.22229140996932983,
0.4041311740875244,
0.2912568151950836,
-0.007402209565043449,
-0.16883616149425507,
-0.9858660101890564,
-0.5441185832023621,
0.3674940764904022,
0.7725653648376465,
-1.0934211015701294,
0.6624323725700378,
0.24050235748291016,
-0.45183229446411133,
-0.36009481549263,
0.12113867700099945,
0.3232036828994751,
0.48934340476989746,
0.518730103969574,
-0.21259884536266327,
-0.47709229588508606,
-0.27310726046562195,
-0.352731853723526,
-0.14183656871318817,
0.004424365237355232,
-0.3050168752670288,
0.11640239506959915,
-0.2466888725757599,
0.5936503410339355,
-0.2777285873889923,
-0.3979378640651703,
-0.38681483268737793,
0.3008950650691986,
-0.006936122663319111,
0.09114513546228409,
0.6472460031509399,
-0.8308523297309875,
-0.7396607995033264,
0.15614371001720428,
-0.4846192002296448,
-0.5061703324317932,
-0.122034952044487,
-0.20605766773223877,
0.5257886648178101,
0.25512975454330444,
-0.2773454487323761,
1.1309146881103516,
0.29201167821884155,
-0.3582461476325989,
1.0313173532485962,
-0.5763431787490845,
0.3662191927433014,
-0.6684398055076599,
0.04202505201101303,
-0.07618889212608337,
0.10551775246858597,
-0.8895535469055176,
-0.11307652294635773,
0.5376718044281006,
0.18513289093971252,
-0.31564468145370483,
0.030128221958875656,
-0.7382742166519165,
0.05061611533164978,
-0.45661231875419617,
0.28678229451179504,
0.09901396185159683,
0.6311950087547302,
0.07973511517047882,
0.48836755752563477,
0.5932565927505493,
-0.7346041202545166,
0.5474042892456055,
0.25557178258895874,
-0.012655958533287048,
1.0333008766174316,
-0.35738563537597656,
-0.004659209866076708,
-0.1780102550983429,
0.2500554621219635,
-1.2848044633865356,
0.17225024104118347,
0.28803399205207825,
-0.4428364932537079,
0.40770381689071655,
-0.12206437438726425,
-0.7602510452270508,
-0.8247682452201843,
-0.5312796831130981,
0.352194219827652,
-0.10561604797840118,
-1.2473276853561401,
0.48881492018699646,
-0.00811026431620121,
0.0973651334643364,
-0.69022136926651,
-0.9017149209976196,
-0.11808738857507706,
0.38309547305107117,
-0.5360531806945801,
0.3050976097583771,
-0.1335058957338333,
0.24048343300819397,
-0.07189945131540298,
0.01680639199912548,
-0.14475946128368378,
-0.2659679353237152,
0.2204751819372177,
0.6292831897735596,
0.10491746664047241,
-0.14615586400032043,
0.4262850284576416,
-0.013863563537597656,
-0.22322691977024078,
0.005471356678754091,
0.21155992150306702,
0.34701231122016907,
-0.7821527123451233,
-0.4984472692012787,
0.2112174928188324,
0.4994947612285614,
-0.45689857006073,
0.6488528847694397,
0.5665732622146606,
-0.5276705026626587,
-0.5002255439758301,
-0.3918818235397339,
-0.08697345107793808,
-0.5691753625869751,
0.3811717927455902,
-0.1023898646235466,
-0.4981146454811096,
0.38707658648490906,
-0.046773165464401245,
0.049363501369953156,
-0.038988903164863586,
0.5398462414741516,
-0.1703007072210312,
1.2875245809555054,
0.5050464272499084,
0.16770274937152863,
0.33313629031181335,
0.05157852545380592,
0.8015019297599792,
-0.6708577871322632,
-0.4999653697013855,
-0.5020934343338013,
-0.48480162024497986,
-0.29687461256980896,
-0.31486862897872925,
0.20053452253341675,
0.18266785144805908,
-0.22276641428470612,
0.7251007556915283,
-0.7209227681159973,
0.07745548337697983,
0.6864984035491943,
0.25615984201431274,
0.1805848777294159,
0.07309878617525101,
-0.7735801339149475,
-0.16210639476776123,
-0.44559842348098755,
0.044178083539009094,
0.4189753830432892,
-0.11176986992359161,
0.4657205641269684,
0.10095161199569702,
0.23104096949100494,
0.0025614553596824408,
-0.1173427477478981,
-0.6276833415031433,
0.6858500838279724,
-0.3804537057876587,
-0.3591710329055786,
-0.18079450726509094,
-0.08752495795488358,
-0.5975536108016968,
0.28839990496635437,
-0.5607545971870422,
-0.3872418999671936,
0.6798136234283447,
0.37220844626426697,
-0.30774983763694763,
0.7446349859237671,
-0.4983585774898529,
0.7282930612564087,
-0.6100957989692688,
-0.5835803151130676,
-0.3312169313430786,
-0.6336224675178528,
0.0658208504319191,
0.18314838409423828,
0.020747454836964607,
0.2849142253398895,
0.4158037006855011,
0.09382548928260803,
-0.8126795887947083,
0.8673032522201538,
-0.19586753845214844,
0.0023217597045004368,
0.349447637796402,
0.2329045534133911,
0.5480116605758667,
-0.3159264028072357,
-0.22981035709381104,
0.3575412929058075,
0.2506847083568573,
-0.1777721792459488,
-0.43120747804641724,
0.5173755288124084,
-0.45755165815353394,
-0.15298759937286377,
-0.7855902314186096,
-0.4568544924259186,
0.09140680730342865,
0.334197074174881,
0.2873819172382355,
0.47186294198036194,
-0.0980151817202568,
-0.36421260237693787,
0.35350558161735535,
-0.5018854737281799,
0.3901990056037903,
0.9613611102104187,
-0.13741078972816467,
-0.36163437366485596,
0.8642004132270813,
0.32462140917778015,
-0.05533960461616516,
0.6346247792243958,
0.01867927424609661,
-0.21110163629055023,
-0.5188524723052979,
-0.30802246928215027,
0.4106137156486511,
-0.5447627305984497,
-0.0023356364108622074,
-0.35919779539108276,
-0.4915373623371124,
-0.6598962545394897,
-0.38260704278945923,
-0.13999584317207336,
0.027897080406546593,
-0.3315126299858093,
-0.029873402789235115,
0.1345120072364807,
0.4196515679359436,
-0.6601402759552002,
0.132776141166687,
-0.47795215249061584,
0.4166897237300873,
0.48330986499786377,
0.3008453845977783,
0.08038832247257233,
-0.39453402161598206,
-0.37691858410835266,
0.3357672095298767,
-0.3488938808441162,
-0.6679319143295288,
0.4019019603729248,
-0.07492619007825851,
0.4944112002849579,
0.5972795486450195,
0.01797976903617382,
1.035819411277771,
-0.5099672675132751,
0.7875338196754456,
0.3382231295108795,
-0.8662770986557007,
0.43761423230171204,
0.1453334391117096,
0.218909353017807,
0.5377970337867737,
0.10549246519804001,
-1.0277432203292847,
-0.19592376053333282,
-0.029343917965888977,
-0.5921735167503357,
0.9874781370162964,
-0.010302825830876827,
-0.5331774353981018,
-0.11037987470626831,
0.2915481626987457,
-0.01612563617527485,
0.11404133588075638,
-0.228542760014534,
-0.3110795021057129,
-0.31844887137413025,
-0.3655247390270233,
0.40178972482681274,
-0.503627359867096,
0.2516676187515259,
-0.41691482067108154,
0.8682518601417542,
0.003776747500523925,
0.09389985352754593,
0.2716526389122009,
-0.16497988998889923,
-0.28022611141204834,
-0.0056511713191866875,
0.42808136343955994,
0.3530106544494629,
-0.01573878340423107,
0.17239926755428314,
0.3489820957183838,
-0.7716040015220642,
-0.4163464307785034,
0.26224249601364136,
-0.37728995084762573,
0.008728012442588806,
0.3389432430267334,
0.5009332299232483,
0.18704119324684143,
-0.4426550269126892,
0.7804682850837708,
0.03372396528720856,
-0.3241215944290161,
-0.3416789770126343,
-0.40908387303352356,
-0.0006871873047202826,
0.0916743054986,
0.2092590183019638,
0.23136171698570251,
0.23948201537132263,
-0.3987668454647064,
0.09404648095369339,
0.4552016258239746,
-0.5312337279319763,
-0.5539774894714355,
0.6284604072570801,
0.3193955719470978,
-0.3365609347820282,
0.7153268456459045,
-0.47333115339279175,
-1.0966099500656128,
0.6465283036231995,
0.4272668659687042,
0.8100255727767944,
-0.5234325528144836,
0.2837575078010559,
0.6371875405311584,
0.3043420612812042,
-0.09568403661251068,
0.2531552314758301,
-0.1341298669576645,
-0.7394787669181824,
-0.06412113457918167,
-0.1697998344898224,
-0.5442479252815247,
-0.3732665777206421,
-0.5013033151626587,
0.8992979526519775,
-0.5386968851089478,
0.3233902156352997,
-0.18327249586582184,
0.06257946789264679,
-0.48905855417251587,
0.08159160614013672,
0.49927443265914917,
0.7609438896179199,
-0.44835343956947327,
1.036819577217102,
0.7029280066490173,
-0.39153042435646057,
-0.9425949454307556,
0.04230411350727081,
0.5669047236442566,
-0.6530976295471191,
0.5979085564613342,
0.4205862283706665,
-0.47319164872169495,
-0.3804377615451813,
-0.4109784662723541,
-0.272956907749176,
1.309575080871582,
-0.10491762310266495,
-0.9152910113334656,
0.03141235187649727,
0.4104940891265869,
0.681082546710968,
0.05739086866378784,
0.4364416301250458,
0.5387328267097473,
0.5853723287582397,
0.39062103629112244,
-0.8278666734695435,
-0.14207398891448975,
-0.14118613302707672,
0.011088576167821884,
-0.059524279087781906,
-0.7418325543403625,
0.7904543876647949,
-0.22649118304252625,
-0.5032327771186829,
0.21424195170402527,
0.663327693939209,
0.29208478331565857,
0.6434512734413147,
0.6903319358825684,
0.547374427318573,
0.8486676216125488,
-0.01362999901175499,
0.33821484446525574,
-0.1799515187740326,
0.16996324062347412,
0.9842837452888489,
-0.7934668064117432,
0.796655535697937,
0.2294691801071167,
-0.27982643246650696,
0.9369498491287231,
0.558159351348877,
-0.011014772579073906,
0.55013108253479,
0.08468011021614075,
-0.4522343873977661,
-0.2794543206691742,
0.2666100859642029,
0.055110178887844086,
0.30680006742477417,
0.32070958614349365,
0.2631431818008423,
-0.2015882134437561,
0.057074494659900665,
-0.12007265537977219,
0.46851903200149536,
-0.38769012689590454,
0.41977211833000183,
-0.20865708589553833,
-0.5521975755691528,
0.10564359277486801,
0.12202370166778564,
1.0457887649536133,
-0.6275430917739868,
-0.3069517910480499,
-0.36292192339897156,
0.4995519816875458,
-0.5502057671546936,
-0.8579509854316711,
0.28218740224838257,
-0.28881874680519104,
-0.14546866714954376,
0.2507210969924927,
1.0204681158065796,
-1.1185941696166992,
-0.506648063659668,
0.6688609719276428,
-0.22008958458900452,
-0.13566730916500092,
-0.14845502376556396,
-0.7994926571846008,
0.036717940121889114,
-0.04960403963923454,
0.3611472249031067,
0.047470804303884506,
0.6684678792953491,
0.052948761731386185,
0.42264610528945923,
0.7794191241264343,
0.27847549319267273,
0.16475731134414673,
0.3847586214542389,
0.5715457797050476,
-0.3616172671318054,
-0.6242662668228149,
-0.5290372967720032,
0.5132772326469421,
-0.28503692150115967,
0.029589902609586716,
0.809161901473999,
0.5033592581748962,
0.7772419452667236,
-0.0455920547246933,
0.7785377502441406,
-0.10891342163085938,
0.8911870718002319,
-0.026452405378222466,
0.9348798394203186,
-0.539972186088562,
0.1627327799797058,
-0.17061294615268707,
-0.6753515005111694,
-0.6737636923789978,
0.5210952162742615,
-0.2565203011035919,
-0.15362320840358734,
0.9778239727020264,
1.3512638807296753,
-0.03764702379703522,
0.18550287187099457,
0.3866623640060425,
0.20507514476776123,
0.13796056807041168,
0.5983768105506897,
0.5258835554122925,
-0.5790537595748901,
0.709968090057373,
-0.7074406743049622,
-0.46267300844192505,
-0.407577246427536,
-0.6475226879119873,
-1.3055155277252197,
-0.6288204789161682,
-0.4624682068824768,
-0.4299249053001404,
0.175176739692688,
0.7305762767791748,
0.40940213203430176,
-1.1648865938186646,
-0.06739155203104019,
-0.03282605856657028,
0.24388262629508972,
-0.9791314601898193,
-0.206393763422966,
0.5634754300117493,
-0.11236679553985596,
-0.9154908657073975,
0.2909785509109497,
0.6803375482559204,
-0.15011146664619446,
-0.11604072898626328,
-0.03480911627411842,
-0.5644011497497559,
0.007555825170129538,
0.7724201083183289,
0.5863915085792542,
-0.39418864250183105,
-0.5945327281951904,
0.05937108397483826,
-0.29722681641578674,
-0.13296326994895935,
0.8114392757415771,
-0.49377959966659546,
0.8618589043617249,
0.7763216495513916,
0.466085821390152,
0.1723749041557312,
-0.18696272373199463,
0.26546505093574524,
-0.6757976412773132,
0.26104065775871277,
-0.3163698613643646,
0.39901965856552124,
0.45118266344070435,
-0.707903265953064,
0.15935693681240082,
0.590718686580658,
-0.6430874466896057,
-0.5578373074531555,
-0.0409395731985569,
-1.3112051486968994,
-0.1882493495941162,
1.0731281042099,
-0.030811244621872902,
-0.3441055715084076,
-0.4286593198776245,
-0.6326541304588318,
0.6810255646705627,
0.0664391964673996,
0.6779924035072327,
0.513134241104126,
0.2398049384355545,
-0.046867311000823975,
0.11793361604213715,
0.33332863450050354,
0.32024407386779785,
-0.4414670467376709,
0.23626399040222168,
0.4155629575252533,
0.4565054178237915,
-0.04292979836463928,
0.310201495885849,
-0.2401745766401291,
0.636610746383667,
-0.03844190016388893,
0.636364221572876,
-0.17846232652664185,
-0.23765414953231812,
-0.22893400490283966,
-0.24547554552555084,
-0.2064245194196701,
-0.44487929344177246
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.01876v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.01876v1
|
GRAM: Generative Retrieval Augmented Matching of Data Schemas in the Context of Data Security
| 2024-06-04T01:08:00 | 2024-06-04T01:08:00 |
Xuanqing Liu, Luyang Kong, Runhui Wang, Patrick Song, Austin Nevins, Henrik Johnson, Nimish Amlathe, Davor Golac
|
cs.DB
|
cs.DB, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.IR, cs.LG
|
Schema matching constitutes a pivotal phase in the data ingestion process for
contemporary database systems. Its objective is to discern pairwise
similarities between two sets of attributes, each associated with a distinct
data table. This challenge emerges at the initial stages of data analytics,
such as when incorporating a third-party table into existing databases to
inform business insights. Given its significance in the realm of database
systems, schema matching has been under investigation since the 2000s. This
study revisits this foundational problem within the context of large language
models. Adhering to increasingly stringent data security policies, our focus
lies on the zero-shot and few-shot scenarios: the model should analyze only a
minimal amount of customer data to execute the matching task, contrasting with
the conventional approach of scrutinizing the entire data table. We emphasize
that the zero-shot or few-shot assumption is imperative to safeguard the
identity and privacy of customer data, even at the potential cost of accuracy.
The capability to accurately match attributes under such stringent requirements
distinguishes our work from previous literature in this domain.
|
[
-0.11425401270389557,
-0.8964727520942688,
0.6929864883422852,
-0.2358085662126541,
-0.0008984934538602829,
0.10724765807390213,
0.21872685849666595,
-0.6440311670303345,
0.02301686815917492,
0.769852340221405,
-0.2689310312271118,
-0.7330760955810547,
-0.31577613949775696,
0.06016216799616814,
-0.7232859134674072,
0.9506394267082214,
0.19468490779399872,
-0.14482876658439636,
-0.32551878690719604,
-0.07552339136600494,
-0.30568596720695496,
-0.8256387710571289,
-0.16396161913871765,
-0.005893695633858442,
0.380928635597229,
0.49997326731681824,
0.7923263907432556,
0.8712860941886902,
0.794276773929596,
0.1385575830936432,
-0.09700598567724228,
-0.08907371759414673,
-0.6096432209014893,
0.4182027280330658,
-0.1622328758239746,
-0.4799550175666809,
-0.38274848461151123,
-0.07897431403398514,
0.3769863545894623,
0.7232985496520996,
-0.2798103094100952,
0.2842763662338257,
-0.05336694046854973,
0.6098862290382385,
-0.9651966094970703,
0.07328411191701889,
-1.0618067979812622,
0.15718141198158264,
-0.6648537516593933,
-0.1748991757631302,
-0.5432053804397583,
-0.22012245655059814,
-0.18449163436889648,
-0.5424378514289856,
0.5812709331512451,
0.22340689599514008,
1.0790690183639526,
-0.1843835860490799,
-0.395296573638916,
-0.21884645521640778,
-0.7073132395744324,
0.16445210576057434,
-0.3307291269302368,
0.22566482424736023,
0.5556079745292664,
0.3884339928627014,
-0.1813705712556839,
-0.5074771642684937,
-0.874131441116333,
-0.03538225591182709,
-0.3849790692329407,
-0.10942617803812027,
-0.3782060742378235,
0.14486348628997803,
0.5994142293930054,
0.6464104652404785,
-0.7404469847679138,
0.1674858182668686,
-0.4505644738674164,
-0.20217958092689514,
0.48876234889030457,
0.45044592022895813,
0.23283985257148743,
-0.1848878413438797,
-0.3158065378665924,
-0.05547887086868286,
-0.8545160293579102,
-0.4038698971271515,
0.6028042435646057,
0.7283910512924194,
0.00493371207267046,
0.8325419425964355,
-0.5839210152626038,
1.011613130569458,
-0.1182132288813591,
-0.055764339864254,
0.06567203253507614,
-0.5429766178131104,
-0.3659241795539856,
0.14596214890480042,
0.5644676089286804,
0.44677209854125977,
0.21046698093414307,
-0.28890931606292725,
0.0672953873872757,
0.5335932970046997,
0.1851039081811905,
-0.537371039390564,
-0.10531584918498993,
0.023622645065188408,
-0.3104912042617798,
-0.4766283929347992,
0.2806786000728607,
-0.9647484421730042,
-0.6044106483459473,
-0.17693528532981873,
0.44831451773643494,
-0.1576092690229416,
-0.024289969354867935,
0.01498579140752554,
0.04544219747185707,
0.8410468697547913,
-0.1356194019317627,
-1.1547688245773315,
0.4121733605861664,
1.297762155532837,
0.8993096947669983,
-0.03907168656587601,
0.07292285561561584,
-0.5192402005195618,
0.5052014589309692,
-0.6107216477394104,
0.6672594547271729,
-0.8775036334991455,
-0.6623101234436035,
0.15673097968101501,
-0.07344160228967667,
-0.007116576191037893,
-0.3811168372631073,
0.5197275280952454,
-0.7970075607299805,
-0.06081559136509895,
-0.40798619389533997,
-0.7524853348731995,
0.1844482719898224,
0.22847670316696167,
-0.3188747763633728,
0.8530751466751099,
0.41883566975593567,
-0.5852421522140503,
0.775745153427124,
-0.2833350598812103,
-0.5217381715774536,
0.46827569603919983,
-0.3667762875556946,
-0.4347634017467499,
0.14151646196842194,
-0.08441198617219925,
0.3723708391189575,
-0.24106594920158386,
-0.5563106536865234,
-0.7479118704795837,
-0.38266295194625854,
-0.041453007608652115,
-0.006057094782590866,
0.5876038670539856,
0.3679138720035553,
0.22025428712368011,
-0.2633100152015686,
-0.8421714305877686,
0.11771415174007416,
0.25989845395088196,
0.17690765857696533,
-0.4300931394100189,
-0.28534582257270813,
-0.18026994168758392,
0.0987076610326767,
0.16222840547561646,
-0.6982243061065674,
0.4105656147003174,
-0.29655399918556213,
0.25656554102897644,
0.5590079426765442,
0.07850288599729538,
0.6954866051673889,
-0.006483200937509537,
0.6430358290672302,
-0.12474855035543442,
0.377552330493927,
-0.27934950590133667,
-0.19819527864456177,
-0.4474642872810364,
-0.3669379651546478,
0.3648982346057892,
0.7235894203186035,
-0.4704216420650482,
0.16781476140022278,
-0.3837948143482208,
-0.6195608377456665,
-0.7034195065498352,
0.17047995328903198,
0.354993999004364,
0.4929402768611908,
0.2313593626022339,
-0.35331565141677856,
-0.3786424398422241,
-0.9463571310043335,
-0.11063798516988754,
-0.12460557371377945,
-0.22695372998714447,
0.7095493078231812,
0.21979562938213348,
0.08100354671478271,
0.9109744429588318,
-1.0695369243621826,
-0.8101032972335815,
-0.07009325921535492,
-0.0692504420876503,
0.26054322719573975,
0.27501747012138367,
0.7866764664649963,
-0.4599190056324005,
-0.8231708407402039,
0.30727389454841614,
-0.9722843766212463,
-0.1166987344622612,
0.2518349885940552,
-0.32486072182655334,
0.1663404256105423,
0.6168895959854126,
-0.5935238003730774,
0.564268946647644,
0.43359774351119995,
-0.46499353647232056,
0.15338221192359924,
-0.11295607686042786,
0.22059084475040436,
-0.972137987613678,
0.020930122584104538,
-0.3058130741119385,
-0.21646571159362793,
-0.8649794459342957,
0.5468562841415405,
0.2903875410556793,
-0.6125213503837585,
-0.3595946729183197,
0.21052686870098114,
-0.521441638469696,
-0.450310617685318,
-0.13618749380111694,
0.14714057743549347,
0.14986902475357056,
0.00890570692718029,
-0.3434085249900818,
1.0270103216171265,
0.985113263130188,
-0.5577432513237,
0.27881157398223877,
0.4479260742664337,
-0.3432551920413971,
1.3288869857788086,
-0.4866671562194824,
0.438618004322052,
-0.14201171696186066,
0.01583242230117321,
-0.6923807859420776,
-0.47324928641319275,
0.3962489664554596,
-0.3929111957550049,
0.3221498727798462,
-0.5346266627311707,
-0.7778562307357788,
-0.21999116241931915,
-0.130751833319664,
0.3020091950893402,
0.36642369627952576,
-0.35715219378471375,
0.7689176201820374,
0.3522135317325592,
-0.0539855882525444,
-0.47509074211120605,
-0.5414266586303711,
0.40100985765457153,
-0.2664607763290405,
-0.5483225584030151,
0.387751966714859,
0.31786686182022095,
-0.2032034546136856,
0.04409507289528847,
-0.10368970036506653,
-0.07938721030950546,
0.19887912273406982,
0.30299028754234314,
0.488961398601532,
-0.03732176870107651,
-0.16646139323711395,
-0.3874378502368927,
-0.24184678494930267,
-0.30381274223327637,
0.01059980969876051,
0.5586271286010742,
0.1505676656961441,
-0.5516413450241089,
-0.34761926531791687,
0.6745867133140564,
0.4101954996585846,
-0.23411479592323303,
0.9376968741416931,
0.19433081150054932,
-0.24386641383171082,
0.09414052218198776,
-0.5136229991912842,
-0.02244538441300392,
-0.4902229607105255,
0.08639837801456451,
-0.7364894151687622,
-0.40297096967697144,
0.6615533828735352,
0.7162386178970337,
-0.3022642731666565,
0.2108578383922577,
0.15972769260406494,
-0.22428783774375916,
0.8369138836860657,
0.6473625302314758,
-0.23189327120780945,
0.38627105951309204,
0.1564057320356369,
0.5529876351356506,
-0.6834402680397034,
-0.32000353932380676,
-0.7438256144523621,
0.08808006346225739,
-0.7521463632583618,
-0.08670371770858765,
0.23362909257411957,
0.02969128079712391,
0.02595311403274536,
0.6427098512649536,
-0.4232204556465149,
0.7723318934440613,
0.3872688412666321,
0.03695284575223923,
0.3569657802581787,
-0.005296510644257069,
0.09685764461755753,
0.22245895862579346,
-0.3248923718929291,
-0.23714406788349152,
1.1024916172027588,
-0.09348011016845703,
0.892156183719635,
0.34890323877334595,
0.6897333860397339,
0.3752591013908386,
-0.031207937747240067,
-0.6658004522323608,
0.7941548824310303,
-0.12913186848163605,
-0.7189338207244873,
-0.018668724223971367,
-0.4008108079433441,
-1.121569037437439,
0.29276740550994873,
-0.3219446837902069,
-0.7166118621826172,
0.3373095989227295,
0.07545620203018188,
-0.3063788414001465,
0.05474717915058136,
-0.7594357132911682,
0.7277061939239502,
0.07167649269104004,
-0.4233503043651581,
0.04098055511713028,
-0.6716095209121704,
0.3406835198402405,
-0.01761036366224289,
-0.03454073518514633,
-0.15110547840595245,
0.23738016188144684,
0.33780568838119507,
-0.4478749632835388,
0.32696816325187683,
-0.11412917822599411,
-0.13060112297534943,
0.037949103862047195,
0.38469555974006653,
0.5654755234718323,
-0.2853482961654663,
-0.03007669746875763,
0.2790697515010834,
0.33706650137901306,
-0.6127307415008545,
-0.650882363319397,
0.6824865937232971,
-0.08657027781009674,
-0.6473557949066162,
-0.7612733244895935,
-0.2433575540781021,
-0.15314489603042603,
0.2071770429611206,
0.17648626863956451,
-0.0718231275677681,
-0.08668860793113708,
0.2763746380805969,
0.6432162523269653,
0.20797990262508392,
0.16123850643634796,
0.828342616558075,
-0.15936338901519775,
-0.01553172618150711,
0.6187458038330078,
0.13495786488056183,
0.4285113513469696,
0.16274937987327576,
-0.28679776191711426,
-0.12568072974681854,
-0.40984606742858887,
-0.2458459436893463,
0.17203189432621002,
-0.8019675016403198,
-0.6493757963180542,
-0.5889596343040466,
-0.16071321070194244,
-0.4172860383987427,
-0.07701855897903442,
0.07429350167512894,
0.01859571970999241,
-0.4471997618675232,
-0.3766813278198242,
0.5586694478988647,
0.4664457440376282,
0.01846196874976158,
0.3160755932331085,
-0.697914183139801,
0.4282967448234558,
0.19853399693965912,
0.5936999917030334,
-0.2037286013364792,
-0.4280082583427429,
-0.038235124200582504,
-0.28178709745407104,
-0.03264077752828598,
-1.1082122325897217,
-0.052415668964385986,
0.3265424370765686,
0.4171176850795746,
0.5228842496871948,
-0.09372497349977493,
0.8232060074806213,
-0.5957863330841064,
0.8254422545433044,
-0.19694773852825165,
-0.9042449593544006,
0.509615957736969,
-0.201158344745636,
-0.35940927267074585,
0.8584353923797607,
0.21567048132419586,
-0.7328398823738098,
-0.006306347902864218,
-0.5533783435821533,
-1.0676814317703247,
0.5646160244941711,
0.2591276168823242,
0.45583802461624146,
-0.19685088098049164,
0.4081566035747528,
-0.024038072675466537,
0.07519061118364334,
-0.39419233798980713,
-0.2538863718509674,
0.35207119584083557,
-0.13499076664447784,
0.230617955327034,
-0.3778011202812195,
-0.2010626643896103,
0.18806833028793335,
0.42938417196273804,
-0.02704578824341297,
0.27775663137435913,
-0.2780502140522003,
-0.12343303859233856,
0.15305468440055847,
0.2733108401298523,
0.2395520955324173,
0.4449041485786438,
-0.15326663851737976,
-0.08081521093845367,
0.05903349071741104,
-0.36031991243362427,
0.04593681916594505,
0.13583332300186157,
-0.5154736042022705,
0.0671461895108223,
0.12294168025255203,
0.63653564453125,
0.04080948233604431,
-0.3427220582962036,
0.7592332363128662,
0.2616334557533264,
-0.06495845317840576,
-0.13644276559352875,
0.10959824919700623,
-0.42377525568008423,
0.0009311610483564436,
0.47333788871765137,
-0.397220253944397,
0.2723890542984009,
-0.7854564785957336,
0.34983280301094055,
0.8228679895401001,
-0.24967357516288757,
-0.12851862609386444,
0.4962309002876282,
-0.18720819056034088,
-0.35171377658843994,
0.6155678629875183,
-0.39427533745765686,
-0.3181648254394531,
0.26526737213134766,
0.4340638220310211,
0.6961212158203125,
-0.21323052048683167,
0.15024255216121674,
0.1070355474948883,
0.13086242973804474,
-0.019535692408680916,
0.3288766145706177,
-0.08332548290491104,
-0.5605008006095886,
0.082369863986969,
-0.5846758484840393,
-0.2972263991832733,
-0.08098982274532318,
-0.9677655100822449,
0.4656991958618164,
-0.3109910786151886,
-0.06582871079444885,
0.05983695015311241,
-0.2800063192844391,
-0.7961668372154236,
-0.13562674820423126,
0.11153919994831085,
0.7766175866127014,
-1.1912490129470825,
0.4489438533782959,
-0.06486799567937851,
-0.8300154209136963,
-0.5335516929626465,
-0.051476456224918365,
-0.04711812362074852,
-0.9977552890777588,
0.41512569785118103,
-0.25078484416007996,
0.10676127672195435,
-0.15087872743606567,
-0.37109631299972534,
-0.8925524950027466,
0.9566925168037415,
0.2848159968852997,
-0.4683160185813904,
-0.09621395170688629,
0.4231875240802765,
0.6022443771362305,
-0.14822667837142944,
-0.18191149830818176,
1.0390146970748901,
0.18599089980125427,
0.09748072922229767,
-0.7276241183280945,
-0.0024373740889132023,
0.16041477024555206,
0.016650119796395302,
0.35652071237564087,
-0.30670011043548584,
0.746788740158081,
-0.057447146624326706,
-0.6082910895347595,
0.1580117642879486,
0.6437202095985413,
0.05027129128575325,
0.4189046621322632,
0.2593900263309479,
0.7787621021270752,
0.7123717665672302,
-0.22118543088436127,
1.1876214742660522,
-0.38687601685523987,
0.4603409767150879,
1.209814190864563,
-0.9469684362411499,
0.9581925868988037,
0.3872566223144531,
-0.4922485053539276,
0.2317322939634323,
0.4464638829231262,
-0.38627639412879944,
0.5695295929908752,
0.011261995881795883,
-0.29913797974586487,
0.0025754375383257866,
-0.27724769711494446,
-0.5040540099143982,
0.6888160109519958,
0.30301156640052795,
-0.39588478207588196,
-0.247026264667511,
-0.1580417901277542,
-0.045350082218647,
0.16528694331645966,
-0.20347249507904053,
1.2278794050216675,
-0.25242677330970764,
-0.10899066925048828,
0.17919926345348358,
-0.1153048723936081,
0.23609276115894318,
-0.6226481199264526,
0.1097521111369133,
-0.48104730248451233,
-0.14243711531162262,
-0.3554127514362335,
-0.8852084875106812,
0.265907883644104,
0.13407137989997864,
0.026268381625413895,
0.10843705385923386,
0.4112705588340759,
-0.29064545035362244,
-0.46698257327079773,
0.18598346412181854,
0.04784366860985756,
-0.011517385020852089,
-0.15110962092876434,
-0.40009549260139465,
0.06037412956357002,
-0.45714402198791504,
0.21243993937969208,
0.4496444761753082,
0.3699217140674591,
0.06771963834762573,
0.3382239043712616,
0.7920265793800354,
0.1825416535139084,
0.0031332660000771284,
0.12592364847660065,
0.6702305674552917,
-0.5104519724845886,
-0.6393483877182007,
-1.0330512523651123,
0.025174876675009727,
-0.3679429292678833,
0.06939419358968735,
0.8910570740699768,
0.8729621767997742,
0.7146629691123962,
0.027881717309355736,
0.6790810227394104,
-0.05262927711009979,
0.45563772320747375,
-0.5573293566703796,
0.5030928254127502,
-0.25909489393234253,
0.21777984499931335,
-0.4474530518054962,
-1.088568091392517,
-0.3807083070278168,
0.41034364700317383,
-0.10420320183038712,
-0.13999782502651215,
0.40814393758773804,
1.3062982559204102,
-0.2049219310283661,
-0.23305635154247284,
0.5404358506202698,
0.03695784881711006,
0.303070604801178,
0.27188730239868164,
0.39105865359306335,
-0.6105066537857056,
0.6764330267906189,
0.06940511614084244,
-0.040924299508333206,
-0.4848269820213318,
-0.8517922163009644,
-0.38713204860687256,
-0.4434213936328888,
-0.19588880240917206,
-0.5885764956474304,
0.1705847829580307,
0.6057552099227905,
0.49083587527275085,
-0.818812370300293,
0.21631214022636414,
0.05620645731687546,
-0.062296781688928604,
-0.24659325182437897,
-0.24704530835151672,
0.32233402132987976,
-0.11557280272245407,
-0.48555269837379456,
0.20464758574962616,
0.5727334022521973,
0.348108172416687,
-0.1240912526845932,
0.43344801664352417,
-0.05919516459107399,
0.27160775661468506,
0.5902913808822632,
0.49980995059013367,
-0.5397882461547852,
-0.43730998039245605,
0.11425106227397919,
-0.3601270914077759,
0.04574490711092949,
0.7898921966552734,
-0.47069379687309265,
0.45697373151779175,
0.5904558897018433,
0.741615891456604,
0.614119291305542,
0.16429506242275238,
0.23004402220249176,
-0.916800856590271,
0.06938522309064865,
0.03786623850464821,
0.3409343957901001,
0.5044301748275757,
-0.707592248916626,
0.6739194393157959,
0.016344845294952393,
-0.3364527225494385,
-1.1458280086517334,
0.6357852220535278,
-1.039977788925171,
-0.013707350008189678,
1.1072216033935547,
0.003500937484204769,
-0.015820806846022606,
-0.15195995569229126,
-0.01139384787529707,
-0.03984196484088898,
-0.05206723511219025,
0.8106067776679993,
0.8480749130249023,
0.13832400739192963,
-0.012388278730213642,
-0.26709818840026855,
0.5252730250358582,
0.17059318721294403,
-0.7434759140014648,
0.3735671043395996,
0.4666219651699066,
0.12002779543399811,
0.07686328887939453,
0.461180716753006,
-0.1666276901960373,
0.062164537608623505,
0.14284555613994598,
-0.2210024893283844,
0.058479491621255875,
-0.23924793303012848,
-0.3436358869075775,
0.25989899039268494,
-0.0739116296172142,
-0.500887393951416
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.01873v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.01873v2
|
CR-UTP: Certified Robustness against Universal Text Perturbations on Large Language Models
| 2024-06-04T01:02:22 | 2024-06-05T15:53:01 |
Qian Lou, Xin Liang, Jiaqi Xue, Yancheng Zhang, Rui Xie, Mengxin Zheng
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CR, cs.LG
|
It is imperative to ensure the stability of every prediction made by a
language model; that is, a language's prediction should remain consistent
despite minor input variations, like word substitutions. In this paper, we
investigate the problem of certifying a language model's robustness against
Universal Text Perturbations (UTPs), which have been widely used in universal
adversarial attacks and backdoor attacks. Existing certified robustness based
on random smoothing has shown considerable promise in certifying the
input-specific text perturbations (ISTPs), operating under the assumption that
any random alteration of a sample's clean or adversarial words would negate the
impact of sample-wise perturbations. However, with UTPs, masking only the
adversarial words can eliminate the attack. A naive method is to simply
increase the masking ratio and the likelihood of masking attack tokens, but it
leads to a significant reduction in both certified accuracy and the certified
radius due to input corruption by extensive masking. To solve this challenge,
we introduce a novel approach, the superior prompt search method, designed to
identify a superior prompt that maintains higher certified accuracy under
extensive masking. Additionally, we theoretically motivate why ensembles are a
particularly suitable choice as base prompts for random smoothing. The method
is denoted by superior prompt ensembling technique. We also empirically confirm
this technique, obtaining state-of-the-art results in multiple settings. These
methodologies, for the first time, enable high certified accuracy against both
UTPs and ISTPs. The source code of CR-UTP is available at \url
{https://github.com/UCFML-Research/CR-UTP}.
|
[
-0.3200535774230957,
-0.9437131285667419,
0.385550320148468,
0.22473078966140747,
-0.15217915177345276,
0.1743600070476532,
-0.4561043083667755,
-0.2510678768157959,
-0.357950896024704,
0.5000483989715576,
-0.3492945730686188,
-0.7203474640846252,
-0.7470611929893494,
0.16857346892356873,
-0.3912840485572815,
0.5543189644813538,
0.237582266330719,
0.11966100335121155,
-0.10121826082468033,
-0.05674058571457863,
-0.7409351468086243,
-0.8444778919219971,
-0.7258008122444153,
-0.28495797514915466,
0.20363295078277588,
0.31365516781806946,
0.8109191656112671,
0.49231791496276855,
0.4436304271221161,
0.34208446741104126,
-0.3214431703090668,
0.1492110788822174,
-0.16000966727733612,
0.66839998960495,
-0.04842573404312134,
-0.3724229335784912,
-0.08496234565973282,
-0.13722127676010132,
0.651803731918335,
0.2654995024204254,
-0.07271077483892441,
-0.05071645975112915,
0.5798220634460449,
0.4902176260948181,
-0.9288630485534668,
-0.27379506826400757,
-0.9259355068206787,
0.07734151184558868,
-0.4940616190433502,
-0.4408382475376129,
-0.7607670426368713,
0.04677659645676613,
-0.32006317377090454,
-0.2901354432106018,
0.12905210256576538,
-0.17013663053512573,
0.8269203305244446,
0.3427850902080536,
-0.22113987803459167,
0.05211237072944641,
-0.8044516444206238,
0.6824662089347839,
-0.6151372194290161,
0.6457914710044861,
0.3027457594871521,
0.3039815127849579,
-0.6361387372016907,
-0.6321419477462769,
-0.4749639332294464,
-0.3696040213108063,
0.1808769702911377,
0.07233402878046036,
-0.30911985039711,
0.3067018687725067,
0.330459326505661,
0.0241493321955204,
-0.7623403072357178,
0.3321249485015869,
0.41555705666542053,
-0.6983707547187805,
0.24600832164287567,
0.16728229820728302,
0.5467823147773743,
0.09185546636581421,
-0.5461781024932861,
-0.3612208068370819,
-0.7459179759025574,
0.5499969720840454,
0.43248674273490906,
0.3197954297065735,
-0.009149385616183281,
0.5639658570289612,
-0.3898519277572632,
0.5754251480102539,
-0.0672580748796463,
-0.06312540918588638,
-0.29961058497428894,
-0.2792360782623291,
-0.2602691352367401,
-0.268750935792923,
0.8133309483528137,
0.19135059416294098,
0.2776589095592499,
-0.09219063818454742,
-0.21747194230556488,
0.4378107786178589,
0.03784907981753349,
-0.6139465570449829,
-0.15267956256866455,
0.29317477345466614,
-0.0789647251367569,
-0.36604437232017517,
0.006571612320840359,
-0.9152497053146362,
-0.5436550974845886,
-0.01275393646210432,
0.15526540577411652,
-0.3019343614578247,
0.219845712184906,
0.03493240475654602,
0.08478552103042603,
-0.04540484771132469,
0.22288505733013153,
-0.8385206460952759,
0.14698871970176697,
0.5561605095863342,
0.45676472783088684,
-0.11258883029222488,
-0.292630672454834,
-0.778476893901825,
-0.16703085601329803,
-0.24968703091144562,
0.9941099286079407,
-0.9352269172668457,
-0.49237850308418274,
0.3316200077533722,
-0.3687460422515869,
-0.10545015335083008,
-0.215515598654747,
1.1253900527954102,
-0.7346369624137878,
0.11719387024641037,
-0.18338459730148315,
-0.19809459149837494,
0.09066025167703629,
0.6004619598388672,
-0.25258952379226685,
1.116457223892212,
-0.06844253838062286,
-0.7918699383735657,
0.3453482985496521,
-0.2999131679534912,
-0.156429722905159,
-0.05354919284582138,
-0.27239716053009033,
-0.24781100451946259,
-0.05304117500782013,
0.7068144083023071,
0.23065438866615295,
-0.18411819636821747,
0.15449924767017365,
-0.4597072899341583,
-0.23083649575710297,
0.618975818157196,
-0.8405424356460571,
0.8444383144378662,
0.19245782494544983,
-0.18654225766658783,
0.28122803568840027,
-0.7761080265045166,
0.28446272015571594,
0.03408069536089897,
-0.31612029671669006,
-0.32795631885528564,
-0.2072594314813614,
0.09549769014120102,
0.0963262990117073,
0.1747245192527771,
-0.5022961497306824,
0.29457905888557434,
-0.2530789077281952,
0.26689162850379944,
0.9042560458183289,
0.09219204634428024,
0.3852725327014923,
-0.08500847965478897,
0.5534240007400513,
-0.17511381208896637,
0.4105207920074463,
-0.3891211748123169,
-0.7092489004135132,
-0.3834562599658966,
-0.332087904214859,
0.6995069980621338,
0.8380950093269348,
-0.474900484085083,
0.5842834115028381,
0.10509605705738068,
-0.35477468371391296,
-0.036564283072948456,
-0.024036884307861328,
0.5029302835464478,
0.6514550447463989,
0.473799467086792,
-0.25370901823043823,
-0.5523052215576172,
-0.5910316109657288,
-0.5863316059112549,
-0.16497203707695007,
-0.31535831093788147,
-0.15807557106018066,
0.03484562784433365,
-0.484613299369812,
0.744714081287384,
-0.21043238043785095,
-0.399920791387558,
-0.11957398056983948,
0.048882998526096344,
-0.11039454489946365,
0.7200509309768677,
0.3528367578983307,
-0.5871602296829224,
-0.33760762214660645,
-0.318279892206192,
-0.3884989619255066,
-0.2803906202316284,
-0.3100566565990448,
-0.127268984913826,
0.38177934288978577,
0.25581568479537964,
-0.43220293521881104,
0.6118075847625732,
0.64037024974823,
-0.549128532409668,
0.536808431148529,
-0.35375991463661194,
0.4361010789871216,
-0.6760913729667664,
-0.03433367237448692,
0.20333349704742432,
-0.21045531332492828,
-0.6780550479888916,
0.6017231345176697,
0.07665618509054184,
-0.004208344966173172,
-0.1873420923948288,
0.3420581817626953,
-0.1287590116262436,
0.2688046097755432,
-0.091666579246521,
0.05178632214665413,
-0.16930648684501648,
0.45106592774391174,
-0.18186217546463013,
0.5800299644470215,
0.5955876708030701,
-0.6784701347351074,
0.06114867702126503,
0.4077824354171753,
0.13411401212215424,
0.6254163384437561,
-0.4806981086730957,
0.4100196361541748,
0.24901950359344482,
0.32776936888694763,
-1.1974098682403564,
-0.12078722566366196,
0.15724967420101166,
-0.9810331463813782,
0.567816436290741,
-0.32031044363975525,
-0.5401567816734314,
-0.24628841876983643,
-0.31993088126182556,
0.2223973125219345,
0.6035595536231995,
-0.6430906653404236,
0.5173159837722778,
0.2873779535293579,
-0.03387000411748886,
-0.9817882180213928,
-0.570155680179596,
0.37606075406074524,
-0.007408104836940765,
-0.734000563621521,
0.08407844603061676,
-0.23368823528289795,
-0.10670473426580429,
-0.5752745866775513,
-0.26501378417015076,
-0.14437785744667053,
0.4209756851196289,
0.23649360239505768,
0.43217524886131287,
0.07268887013196945,
-0.4349667727947235,
0.09987616539001465,
-0.46670570969581604,
-0.08125443756580353,
-0.28175368905067444,
0.8265699744224548,
-0.03857516497373581,
-0.47231870889663696,
-0.6899172067642212,
0.2542010545730591,
0.5016939043998718,
-0.17415350675582886,
0.2567640542984009,
0.6250840425491333,
-0.5141449570655823,
-0.15406487882137299,
-0.7123461961746216,
-0.2190789431333542,
-0.5327932834625244,
0.10820180177688599,
-0.45573660731315613,
-0.8452155590057373,
0.8725281357765198,
0.18459588289260864,
0.21250292658805847,
0.5070467591285706,
0.3537147045135498,
0.023578034713864326,
1.393366813659668,
0.46233341097831726,
-0.07506943494081497,
0.38918840885162354,
0.12922313809394836,
-0.24202005565166473,
-0.7690730690956116,
-0.36581408977508545,
-1.2973151206970215,
-0.04824020341038704,
-0.4853537082672119,
-0.03482168912887573,
0.32675644755363464,
0.1939159631729126,
-0.349258154630661,
0.3069669008255005,
-0.8078679442405701,
0.3675079643726349,
0.6547438502311707,
-0.01651538722217083,
0.5373619794845581,
0.16924715042114258,
-0.5573112368583679,
-0.33500921726226807,
-0.455243855714798,
-0.6551347374916077,
1.0593656301498413,
0.3184047341346741,
0.7405702471733093,
-0.13023677468299866,
0.49412158131599426,
0.5237252712249756,
-0.0011755259474739432,
-0.23776109516620636,
0.7195814847946167,
0.011769738979637623,
-0.2938534617424011,
-0.3693753778934479,
-0.34276026487350464,
-1.0207260847091675,
0.22793647646903992,
-0.6074850559234619,
-1.1285117864608765,
0.1370759755373001,
0.2947983741760254,
-0.29907312989234924,
0.4098764657974243,
-0.24101504683494568,
0.5882630944252014,
0.1453481912612915,
-0.11983808875083923,
0.040811460465192795,
-0.628752589225769,
0.2197793871164322,
0.1311328113079071,
0.18208542466163635,
0.24049827456474304,
-0.03631215915083885,
0.5304016470909119,
-0.19084854423999786,
0.5869145393371582,
-0.08831258863210678,
-0.1322360783815384,
0.19285136461257935,
0.4592132866382599,
0.7889857292175293,
0.2974558174610138,
0.12373081594705582,
0.4047778844833374,
-0.016468927264213562,
-0.3170303702354431,
-0.49544376134872437,
0.7501847147941589,
-0.5734100937843323,
-0.6113041043281555,
-0.4505372643470764,
-0.2656692862510681,
-0.4588185250759125,
0.2140277475118637,
0.6888740658760071,
0.7204652428627014,
-0.14686857163906097,
0.17910216748714447,
0.8139457702636719,
-0.15825346112251282,
0.6083113551139832,
0.36083564162254333,
-0.04915943369269371,
-0.6012890338897705,
0.5464679002761841,
-0.12130317836999893,
0.13018177449703217,
0.5596494078636169,
0.2795407474040985,
-0.4273551404476166,
-0.9407358169555664,
-0.6298747658729553,
-0.298825740814209,
-0.6703871488571167,
-0.39741963148117065,
-0.6912405490875244,
-0.06117621064186096,
-0.6922703385353088,
-0.3311655521392822,
-0.27703139185905457,
-0.4246949851512909,
-0.15487033128738403,
0.20131343603134155,
-0.11264865100383759,
0.4269309341907501,
-0.14135704934597015,
0.15075726807117462,
-0.9906682372093201,
0.2832393944263458,
0.3288503587245941,
0.24311858415603638,
-0.3194364309310913,
-0.8967442512512207,
0.2566337287425995,
0.12864257395267487,
-0.47604864835739136,
-0.9394259452819824,
0.2465466558933258,
-0.021066688001155853,
0.5964445471763611,
0.47099223732948303,
0.47035717964172363,
0.5325831770896912,
-0.23183028399944305,
1.0708345174789429,
0.13072943687438965,
-1.0778645277023315,
0.45136088132858276,
-0.4256802797317505,
0.35517650842666626,
0.7453848719596863,
-0.17546091973781586,
-0.643194854259491,
-0.9211015701293945,
-0.8278763890266418,
-0.7676864266395569,
0.280749648809433,
0.31509748101234436,
0.07065564393997192,
0.1696087270975113,
0.1849847435951233,
-0.10520026087760925,
-0.005761549808084965,
-0.4963335692882538,
-0.38426509499549866,
-0.0696701630949974,
0.024038976058363914,
0.21732957661151886,
-0.4602796137332916,
-0.07470209151506424,
0.18955929577350616,
0.7890585660934448,
-0.017107712104916573,
0.207659050822258,
0.40130001306533813,
-0.06644657254219055,
-0.17418378591537476,
0.7021738290786743,
0.7059348821640015,
0.2485409677028656,
0.023946771398186684,
0.27898064255714417,
0.18685224652290344,
-0.7998925447463989,
0.04008980095386505,
0.12309323996305466,
-0.426116019487381,
-0.057740531861782074,
0.3014433681964874,
0.06223408877849579,
0.13268733024597168,
-0.5835299491882324,
0.5219931602478027,
-0.278119832277298,
0.12459684908390045,
-0.21868672966957092,
0.07522715628147125,
-0.5155773162841797,
0.13632509112358093,
0.5430654883384705,
0.5848722457885742,
0.14826031029224396,
-0.19946224987506866,
0.31079578399658203,
0.716182291507721,
-0.5773184299468994,
-0.2890496850013733,
0.8505756855010986,
0.09215517342090607,
-0.4292312562465668,
0.5619023442268372,
0.047490622848272324,
-0.740033745765686,
0.4660799205303192,
0.592588484287262,
1.0243995189666748,
-0.543977677822113,
0.05663837492465973,
0.3793965280056,
0.6597301363945007,
-0.24307239055633545,
0.1521751582622528,
0.008346577174961567,
-0.6507185697555542,
-0.2982005476951599,
-0.3223586678504944,
-0.5598530173301697,
0.16862669587135315,
-0.5970768332481384,
0.166802778840065,
-0.6384531855583191,
-0.22808146476745605,
-0.39406129717826843,
-0.11567450314760208,
-0.5481551289558411,
0.2953788936138153,
0.26136672496795654,
1.0199012756347656,
-0.7288686037063599,
0.6929203271865845,
0.6101030111312866,
-0.1778317242860794,
-0.7456925511360168,
0.038749273866415024,
0.0681004673242569,
-0.7765820622444153,
0.22133567929267883,
0.11899543553590775,
-0.012879570946097374,
-0.17085613310337067,
-0.7964585423469543,
-0.6024788022041321,
0.5894941687583923,
0.49226075410842896,
-0.44122105836868286,
0.037206728011369705,
0.20728737115859985,
0.34928250312805176,
-0.007610286120325327,
0.38264238834381104,
0.45353683829307556,
0.6114959120750427,
0.135250985622406,
-0.8660874962806702,
0.30766868591308594,
-0.025407029315829277,
-0.07675733417272568,
0.02888687327504158,
-0.2796134650707245,
0.47450217604637146,
-0.17878349125385284,
-0.49382907152175903,
0.49005740880966187,
0.7355602979660034,
0.43824464082717896,
0.442232608795166,
0.500178873538971,
0.6490406394004822,
0.8017624616622925,
-0.3663387894630432,
0.8400223851203918,
-0.28640854358673096,
0.25536075234413147,
1.01949942111969,
-0.11137586086988449,
0.7201824188232422,
0.22566750645637512,
-0.1981215924024582,
0.4123844802379608,
0.561402440071106,
0.06757581233978271,
0.23551279306411743,
0.07053438574075699,
-0.14276239275932312,
-0.5931543111801147,
-0.046346601098775864,
-0.5537326335906982,
0.3062923550605774,
0.21219798922538757,
-0.030975989997386932,
-0.2040107101202011,
-0.013370259664952755,
0.06957826018333435,
0.5098972320556641,
-0.16078710556030273,
0.5123847126960754,
-0.13243119418621063,
-0.6784220337867737,
0.6407604813575745,
0.018156511709094048,
0.8663114309310913,
-0.8275987505912781,
0.03542444109916687,
-0.06471778452396393,
0.14858661592006683,
-0.21926984190940857,
-0.6798068284988403,
-0.12620040774345398,
-0.044261083006858826,
0.21989105641841888,
-0.0930449366569519,
0.8040810823440552,
-0.19525429606437683,
-0.11259515583515167,
0.06503660976886749,
0.11466986685991287,
-0.28611117601394653,
-0.22222919762134552,
-0.5734965801239014,
0.1731652021408081,
0.07189323753118515,
-0.39513546228408813,
0.520551323890686,
0.1080833375453949,
0.11447490751743317,
0.767406702041626,
0.9156426191329956,
0.07819493114948273,
-0.08309973776340485,
0.005780598148703575,
0.7224666476249695,
-0.3827763795852661,
-0.6461575627326965,
-0.9468840956687927,
0.6458280682563782,
-0.033161044120788574,
-0.5152437686920166,
0.8617090582847595,
0.3471936881542206,
0.7176264524459839,
0.19642411172389984,
0.6557382345199585,
0.2931843400001526,
0.12361568212509155,
-0.6500921845436096,
0.49110186100006104,
-0.10319159179925919,
0.4697680175304413,
-0.4973478615283966,
-0.9257556200027466,
-0.7324575185775757,
0.27003392577171326,
0.19414907693862915,
-0.10409169644117355,
0.716718316078186,
0.794562041759491,
0.27120983600616455,
0.13591770827770233,
0.6654189229011536,
0.1271163821220398,
0.4222913682460785,
0.34517884254455566,
0.8199692964553833,
-0.3055471181869507,
0.6832771301269531,
-0.14904573559761047,
-0.4226834774017334,
-0.06756097823381424,
-0.9248405694961548,
-0.9622281193733215,
-0.6494682431221008,
-0.3396322429180145,
-0.8265371322631836,
0.0834043100476265,
0.913716733455658,
0.39261335134506226,
-0.8982828259468079,
0.2776176929473877,
-0.10081340372562408,
0.2090522050857544,
-0.36680999398231506,
-0.1866418719291687,
0.33382952213287354,
-0.5168329477310181,
-0.5432966351509094,
0.5842724442481995,
0.2276437133550644,
0.18431776762008667,
-0.2537432909011841,
0.23530574142932892,
0.2377208024263382,
0.35389381647109985,
0.14471933245658875,
0.624548614025116,
-0.5510067939758301,
-0.35235539078712463,
0.03427961841225624,
-0.2091735452413559,
0.08175159245729446,
0.952761173248291,
-0.7166167497634888,
0.44556546211242676,
0.5303340554237366,
0.7005777955055237,
-0.14063476026058197,
-0.02961941994726658,
0.5099074840545654,
-0.7394934892654419,
0.07220885902643204,
0.23275388777256012,
0.5990647077560425,
0.2804996967315674,
-0.6239874958992004,
0.29204320907592773,
0.31560078263282776,
-0.8043185472488403,
-1.0364741086959839,
0.4215068221092224,
-1.179957389831543,
-0.007175742648541927,
1.248814582824707,
-0.14572389423847198,
-0.006275361869484186,
-0.3045274317264557,
-0.30220186710357666,
0.1759522557258606,
-0.7997649312019348,
0.7910933494567871,
0.4242335259914398,
0.25466588139533997,
0.22704988718032837,
-0.1315791755914688,
0.43050068616867065,
0.43188709020614624,
-0.5106010437011719,
0.1820162981748581,
0.42127054929733276,
0.07713813334703445,
0.31906658411026,
0.4175976514816284,
-0.3027391731739044,
0.23447945713996887,
-0.05722613260149956,
-0.10106834024190903,
-0.2679145336151123,
-0.4061070382595062,
-0.5420590043067932,
0.5542804002761841,
0.12726733088493347,
-0.18151405453681946
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.01866v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.01866v2
|
#EpiTwitter: Public Health Messaging During the COVID-19 Pandemic
| 2024-06-04T00:37:29 | 2024-06-10T20:33:51 |
Ashwin Rao, Nazanin Sabri, Siyi Guo, Louiqa Raschid, Kristina Lerman
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.SI
|
Effective communication during health crises is critical, with social media
serving as a key platform for public health experts (PHEs) to engage with the
public. However, it also amplifies pseudo-experts promoting contrarian views.
Despite its importance, the role of emotional and moral language in PHEs'
communication during COVID-19 remains under explored. This study examines how
PHEs and pseudo-experts communicated on Twitter during the pandemic, focusing
on emotional and moral language and their engagement with political elites.
Analyzing tweets from 489 PHEs and 356 pseudo-experts from January 2020 to
January 2021, alongside public responses, we identified key priorities and
differences in messaging strategy. PHEs prioritize masking, healthcare,
education, and vaccines, using positive emotional language like optimism. In
contrast, pseudo-experts discuss therapeutics and lockdowns more frequently,
employing negative emotions like pessimism and disgust. Negative emotional and
moral language tends to drive engagement, but positive language from PHEs
fosters positivity in public responses. PHEs exhibit liberal partisanship,
expressing more positivity towards liberals and negativity towards conservative
elites, while pseudo-experts show conservative partisanship. These findings
shed light on the polarization of COVID-19 discourse and underscore the
importance of strategic use of emotional and moral language by experts to
mitigate polarization and enhance public trust.
|
[
-0.37889254093170166,
-0.6499865055084229,
0.6333671808242798,
0.24546003341674805,
-0.4494853615760803,
0.2803710997104645,
-0.37583857774734497,
-0.30410078167915344,
0.6639319658279419,
0.1253911405801773,
-0.1931990534067154,
-0.3496242165565491,
-0.7389650940895081,
-0.03083639219403267,
-0.18539756536483765,
1.1256574392318726,
0.26026955246925354,
-0.1073044016957283,
0.3646162450313568,
0.057690974324941635,
0.11024141311645508,
-0.6676486134529114,
-0.7940114736557007,
-0.2498544305562973,
0.7718965411186218,
0.6596617102622986,
0.8328800797462463,
0.09150174260139465,
0.4431307315826416,
0.20408913493156433,
-0.06602269411087036,
-0.15812136232852936,
-1.1112762689590454,
-0.07759137451648712,
-0.6000447273254395,
-0.24773427844047546,
-0.4482661783695221,
0.2013549506664276,
-0.11665097624063492,
-0.08940606564283371,
-0.32817214727401733,
0.4788612723350525,
-0.11002598702907562,
0.46475815773010254,
-0.5575241446495056,
0.11492841690778732,
-0.5027779936790466,
-0.02024002932012081,
-0.3296462893486023,
-0.4912126958370209,
-0.17145128548145294,
-0.31094443798065186,
0.4649965763092041,
-0.645908772945404,
-0.3563266098499298,
-0.354318767786026,
0.9192227721214294,
-0.019587060436606407,
-0.49590641260147095,
-0.1346278339624405,
-0.630227267742157,
0.6748203635215759,
-0.53522789478302,
0.06867033988237381,
0.6243512630462646,
0.05611034482717514,
-0.08447131514549255,
-0.38518980145454407,
-0.3731482923030853,
0.39206138253211975,
0.1435440331697464,
0.20737703144550323,
-0.6281818151473999,
0.05219566822052002,
-0.3349786400794983,
-0.06483627110719681,
-0.12041164189577103,
-0.12958022952079773,
-0.3430025577545166,
0.020234595984220505,
0.9107428789138794,
-0.02138344943523407,
0.3939775824546814,
-0.2749011218547821,
-0.14645640552043915,
0.05190238356590271,
-0.1971047818660736,
0.29972267150878906,
-0.132532000541687,
0.044059451669454575,
-0.6472090482711792,
0.19947810471057892,
0.41652294993400574,
0.021042587235569954,
0.596392810344696,
-0.07999160885810852,
-0.15167021751403809,
-0.3021583557128906,
-0.3195609450340271,
0.23969712853431702,
0.7693671584129333,
0.8501338362693787,
0.4253575801849365,
0.10854632407426834,
0.03599316626787186,
-0.2132226526737213,
0.44136321544647217,
-0.7141975164413452,
-0.6201637387275696,
0.2672392725944519,
-0.5590678453445435,
-0.18824589252471924,
0.17177128791809082,
-1.154122233390808,
-0.8376758098602295,
0.17563176155090332,
0.04595349356532097,
-0.1492854803800583,
-0.4583575129508972,
0.09145278483629227,
-0.25297945737838745,
0.044720109552145004,
0.32281145453453064,
-0.5949811339378357,
0.15577153861522675,
0.7177799344062805,
0.5294710993766785,
0.5496833324432373,
0.4687850773334503,
-0.5793485045433044,
0.21024273335933685,
-0.7674156427383423,
0.4673624634742737,
-0.7186188697814941,
-0.27324044704437256,
0.006597672123461962,
-0.2804986536502838,
-0.20151928067207336,
-0.14521102607250214,
0.6451042890548706,
-0.010834667831659317,
0.14577257633209229,
-0.8952687382698059,
-0.060916509479284286,
-0.1351224184036255,
-0.08451994508504868,
0.07331521809101105,
0.48571616411209106,
-0.08888617157936096,
-1.009002923965454,
0.14025908708572388,
-0.4616585075855255,
-0.32529670000076294,
0.22072815895080566,
-0.5244928598403931,
-0.5429857969284058,
0.2741461396217346,
0.41062819957733154,
0.7391836047172546,
-0.48978444933891296,
0.1103542372584343,
-0.43046706914901733,
-0.31663575768470764,
-0.0014665110502392054,
0.0869961604475975,
0.5223197937011719,
0.08298180997371674,
-0.7545108795166016,
0.04490309953689575,
-0.02899312973022461,
-0.2282337099313736,
0.12101663649082184,
0.16331006586551666,
-0.5374050736427307,
0.17835497856140137,
0.133870467543602,
0.36303144693374634,
-0.05570158362388611,
-0.4586242139339447,
-0.14345502853393555,
-0.457828551530838,
0.6915836334228516,
0.5773196220397949,
0.5693660974502563,
0.3630541265010834,
-0.469062864780426,
0.40138500928878784,
-0.023637276142835617,
0.45916828513145447,
0.31975090503692627,
-0.8347329497337341,
-0.3703426718711853,
-0.2897057831287384,
-0.962608814239502,
0.8576682209968567,
-0.3698759078979492,
0.3782426118850708,
-0.1144862174987793,
-0.7820554971694946,
-0.5093561410903931,
-0.25189298391342163,
0.34046223759651184,
0.480183482170105,
0.49785634875297546,
0.3517928421497345,
-0.4481024742126465,
-0.9131317138671875,
-0.4363057613372803,
-0.6534271240234375,
0.5957701206207275,
0.2971610724925995,
0.07583508640527725,
-0.05333809554576874,
0.4748836159706116,
-0.19274815917015076,
0.10710863023996353,
-0.4048362672328949,
0.5974935293197632,
-0.2157350480556488,
-0.06363996863365173,
0.8485954999923706,
-0.7048715949058533,
-0.6575533747673035,
0.12593431770801544,
-0.410961389541626,
-0.16572177410125732,
-0.166487917304039,
0.09385281056165695,
-0.3448740243911743,
0.14367321133613586,
0.04516956955194473,
0.4914271831512451,
0.6206797361373901,
-0.3082922697067261,
0.20024558901786804,
0.03608042374253273,
0.5968098640441895,
-1.2007408142089844,
-0.24952010810375214,
0.4188803434371948,
-0.1481436938047409,
-1.070488691329956,
-0.3473771810531616,
-0.35014989972114563,
-0.1327192485332489,
-0.5941005349159241,
0.14161503314971924,
-0.16709786653518677,
0.534865140914917,
-0.1761530190706253,
-0.2547522783279419,
-0.082644984126091,
-0.4298766553401947,
0.01260055135935545,
0.6784165501594543,
0.7561209797859192,
-0.17224572598934174,
0.4192468523979187,
0.21849681437015533,
0.16570188105106354,
0.8718402981758118,
-0.6680170297622681,
0.28469860553741455,
-0.2613115608692169,
0.3800550699234009,
-0.5707699060440063,
-0.2719309628009796,
0.7241536378860474,
-0.27493032813072205,
-0.23570142686367035,
0.19398076832294464,
-0.17378073930740356,
-0.6656023859977722,
-0.3674115240573883,
-0.040084440261125565,
0.42838332056999207,
0.16855476796627045,
0.28960177302360535,
0.8578053712844849,
-0.20245838165283203,
-0.37728431820869446,
-1.0400665998458862,
0.5213189721107483,
-0.486960768699646,
-0.7996187806129456,
0.18613754212856293,
0.3512803018093109,
-0.6922979354858398,
-0.1755562275648117,
-0.06930751353502274,
-0.3195861577987671,
0.12932589650154114,
0.05214257910847664,
-0.31414586305618286,
-0.26064905524253845,
0.23308353126049042,
0.17998437583446503,
0.1858743131160736,
0.19454652070999146,
0.14365564286708832,
0.42690014839172363,
-0.7164151668548584,
-0.007930601015686989,
-1.0451692342758179,
0.6049879789352417,
0.5228524208068848,
-0.0956973284482956,
1.088144302368164,
0.5850366950035095,
-0.3382434546947479,
0.4215010404586792,
-0.6080155372619629,
-0.4952791631221771,
-0.35859447717666626,
0.16184145212173462,
0.2410712093114853,
-0.51286780834198,
0.3509882688522339,
0.1406463086605072,
-0.27660202980041504,
0.258205384016037,
0.5805349946022034,
-0.23329006135463715,
0.4520798623561859,
0.4995494484901428,
-0.15082620084285736,
0.1963997632265091,
-0.1898421049118042,
0.7208867073059082,
-0.11019694060087204,
-0.33829358220100403,
-0.4066268801689148,
0.006086236331611872,
-0.49940600991249084,
-0.4033201336860657,
0.44447967410087585,
-0.04121197760105133,
-0.14894002676010132,
0.4190603494644165,
-0.7953498363494873,
-0.1560133844614029,
-0.039925627410411835,
0.2964414358139038,
-0.36954790353775024,
-0.15663909912109375,
0.23610429465770721,
-0.19702653586864471,
-0.6607475280761719,
-0.5440847277641296,
0.2479693740606308,
0.5355443954467773,
0.631610631942749,
-0.12145767360925674,
0.9574885964393616,
0.2608643174171448,
-0.08640552312135696,
-0.3243084251880646,
0.5867186188697815,
-0.13953880965709686,
-0.2108418345451355,
-0.08040648698806763,
-0.02149076573550701,
-0.758256733417511,
-0.11848841607570648,
-0.42396485805511475,
-0.6878684163093567,
0.8867552280426025,
-0.0213469248265028,
-0.7284632325172424,
0.36844688653945923,
-0.563269853591919,
0.5057269930839539,
-0.07254693657159805,
-0.033488884568214417,
-0.6772298216819763,
-0.7895766496658325,
-0.1579187661409378,
-0.03957008570432663,
0.4199788272380829,
-0.34573638439178467,
-0.2381926327943802,
0.7967647314071655,
-0.5055562257766724,
0.8980303406715393,
0.18130753934383392,
0.13096483051776886,
0.3131718635559082,
-0.4763971269130707,
0.38963186740875244,
0.4112306535243988,
-0.19865775108337402,
0.049666255712509155,
0.11779794096946716,
-0.719303548336029,
0.20617304742336273,
0.5583182573318481,
-1.222487449645996,
-0.7916533350944519,
-0.5116786360740662,
-0.08713000267744064,
0.22134464979171753,
-0.08925435692071915,
0.4328470230102539,
0.4750730097293854,
-0.2805141508579254,
0.057387907058000565,
0.6329391002655029,
-0.41423895955085754,
0.37879854440689087,
0.13278643786907196,
0.2557452321052551,
-0.5669261813163757,
0.6917757391929626,
0.1736850142478943,
0.05835401639342308,
0.3625577986240387,
0.8279030919075012,
0.2576290965080261,
-0.04016697406768799,
0.10931959748268127,
0.4133065342903137,
-0.397474467754364,
-0.04081031307578087,
-0.8633584380149841,
-0.20740941166877747,
-0.6643381118774414,
-0.7990296483039856,
-0.49367696046829224,
0.24443845450878143,
-0.5134252309799194,
-0.18269455432891846,
0.7129793763160706,
1.0546613931655884,
-0.4220064878463745,
0.20076429843902588,
-0.7942204475402832,
0.06210149824619293,
0.2426527887582779,
-0.23012705147266388,
-0.17543546855449677,
0.11617909371852875,
-0.2171732634305954,
0.14384379982948303,
0.005737421568483114,
-1.3937773704528809,
0.18043853342533112,
0.2222142070531845,
0.5257558226585388,
0.7784225940704346,
0.5339144468307495,
0.5609936714172363,
-0.03564188629388809,
0.8946377635002136,
0.31599655747413635,
-0.9371902942657471,
0.4954735338687897,
-0.7116389870643616,
0.1761554628610611,
0.6177192330360413,
0.499844491481781,
-0.8924482464790344,
-0.8424654006958008,
-0.546329140663147,
-0.6887661218643188,
0.34298044443130493,
0.1798436939716339,
0.187729611992836,
-0.5762231349945068,
-0.15730902552604675,
-0.005023219157010317,
0.2952505052089691,
-0.1482480764389038,
-0.5621979236602783,
-0.5840897560119629,
0.1549074798822403,
0.21195809543132782,
-0.47236111760139465,
-0.5936720967292786,
-0.2794955372810364,
0.1661742478609085,
0.4818228483200073,
0.34653452038764954,
0.4323490858078003,
0.43904754519462585,
-0.48851972818374634,
0.6463434100151062,
0.8124170303344727,
0.9156720638275146,
-0.14140768349170685,
0.393600195646286,
-0.3468916714191437,
-0.6290139555931091,
0.007081120274960995,
-0.004614687990397215,
0.18128027021884918,
-0.07814256101846695,
0.33923038840293884,
0.7467533349990845,
0.08008722215890884,
-0.03577776625752449,
0.724457859992981,
0.19093774259090424,
0.12782691419124603,
-0.0843568667769432,
-0.47044938802719116,
0.32352158427238464,
0.10140138864517212,
0.7907014489173889,
0.3399394452571869,
-0.09655240178108215,
-0.7718145251274109,
0.44531872868537903,
0.2094169408082962,
-0.41489824652671814,
-0.8974164724349976,
0.5953364968299866,
0.5915638208389282,
-0.13137900829315186,
0.3338279128074646,
-0.013894977979362011,
-0.7762331962585449,
0.4124299883842468,
0.09420418739318848,
0.7772696614265442,
-0.627357006072998,
0.8743443489074707,
0.07721695303916931,
0.5455938577651978,
0.11321936547756195,
0.5154458284378052,
0.4096023142337799,
-0.34239959716796875,
-0.3557354509830475,
0.053447458893060684,
0.04736120626330376,
0.19139276444911957,
-0.6751936078071594,
0.23133011162281036,
-0.6847588419914246,
-0.7225117683410645,
-0.06464838236570358,
-0.06814414262771606,
-0.5913529396057129,
0.2964476943016052,
0.37682977318763733,
0.7542248368263245,
-1.2485575675964355,
0.41098645329475403,
0.9238107204437256,
-0.4141010642051697,
-1.017212152481079,
0.6086949110031128,
0.19103796780109406,
-0.5338804721832275,
0.2773033678531647,
0.06181762367486954,
-0.21647921204566956,
-0.24759140610694885,
-0.553796112537384,
-0.4927480220794678,
0.6195517778396606,
0.32930493354797363,
-0.2951890826225281,
0.2678452134132385,
0.23736776411533356,
0.8943430185317993,
-0.4833661913871765,
0.34912487864494324,
0.028104031458497047,
0.6771482825279236,
-0.21022473275661469,
-1.1918517351150513,
0.09062279015779495,
-0.2447909712791443,
-0.3256518542766571,
-0.024819687008857727,
-1.0362731218338013,
0.5282833576202393,
-0.15538479387760162,
-0.2788304388523102,
-0.5152921080589294,
0.662941575050354,
-0.25639164447784424,
0.8184515237808228,
0.2778994143009186,
0.2902851104736328,
0.8925079107284546,
0.1023550033569336,
1.0647811889648438,
-0.36631613969802856,
-0.04644922539591789,
0.5028093457221985,
0.08876591175794601,
0.732322633266449,
0.4041392207145691,
0.23391935229301453,
0.5096375942230225,
0.5073413252830505,
0.4174777567386627,
0.6020185351371765,
-0.07639677822589874,
-0.19430877268314362,
-0.473818302154541,
-0.5448172688484192,
-0.6550400853157043,
0.1832297444343567,
0.4804207980632782,
-0.2806089520454407,
-0.28130629658699036,
0.4017791450023651,
0.4293292760848999,
0.40083321928977966,
-0.48115095496177673,
0.5097147822380066,
0.3023781478404999,
-0.1615147739648819,
0.4356715679168701,
-0.10876841098070145,
0.3869008719921112,
-0.00890333577990532,
0.34152257442474365,
0.22522473335266113,
-0.1178869754076004,
-0.3639192581176758,
-0.9633062481880188,
0.6306543350219727,
-0.29912516474723816,
0.01763339899480343,
-0.35084083676338196,
0.6339834928512573,
-0.45144400000572205,
-0.29015713930130005,
0.6301602721214294,
0.4430052936077118,
0.12127798050642014,
-0.1526067554950714,
-1.0815821886062622,
0.2182796746492386,
-0.23666556179523468,
-0.1100490391254425,
0.015361015684902668,
0.26461610198020935,
-0.15038147568702698,
0.5456159114837646,
0.1433141529560089,
0.4142813980579376,
0.09886812418699265,
0.044424012303352356,
0.8141615986824036,
-0.10239626467227936,
-0.5748454928398132,
-0.7228745222091675,
0.26485225558280945,
-0.3004053235054016,
-0.23499290645122528,
0.8305360674858093,
0.24978357553482056,
0.2607373595237732,
0.0733189582824707,
0.7438560724258423,
0.011993355117738247,
0.28129643201828003,
0.31467220187187195,
0.9569697976112366,
-0.3202142119407654,
-0.2806928753852844,
-0.2034386843442917,
-0.20959270000457764,
0.22887001931667328,
0.40513524413108826,
-0.9548376202583313,
-0.23965425789356232,
0.6191893219947815,
0.32353752851486206,
0.2628554105758667,
0.07144657522439957,
0.06807553023099899,
0.4868299961090088,
0.48055556416511536,
0.2859383523464203,
0.5110445618629456,
0.08966711163520813,
0.43590298295021057,
-0.471025675535202,
-0.3947429656982422,
-0.3860062062740326,
-0.6779441237449646,
-1.1656105518341064,
-0.7336219549179077,
-0.46696406602859497,
-0.4377906620502472,
0.6778128743171692,
1.2970982789993286,
0.48679956793785095,
-0.7150036096572876,
0.04458795487880707,
0.06506817042827606,
-0.14355452358722687,
-0.25163933634757996,
-0.23111140727996826,
0.353641152381897,
0.34658706188201904,
-0.28105679154396057,
0.13819941878318787,
0.8570153713226318,
-0.34937942028045654,
-0.08767803013324738,
0.3374094069004059,
-0.4483078718185425,
0.708899974822998,
0.45005252957344055,
0.3633290231227875,
-0.6712883710861206,
-0.2263628989458084,
0.177995964884758,
-0.6591646075248718,
0.0291491337120533,
0.7036334276199341,
-0.1677490919828415,
0.2918729782104492,
0.9031935930252075,
0.3225826025009155,
-0.2465522140264511,
0.2969664931297302,
0.8514947891235352,
-0.007903692312538624,
0.04132462665438652,
0.6114048957824707,
0.009467175230383873,
0.6539281606674194,
-0.805333137512207,
-0.03357996791601181,
0.2974167764186859,
-0.4322546124458313,
-0.5127654671669006,
0.060344770550727844,
-0.741865873336792,
-0.08741675317287445,
1.1663024425506592,
-0.017787085846066475,
-0.2138408124446869,
-0.6377561688423157,
-0.12774202227592468,
0.2678922414779663,
-1.0357178449630737,
0.7773359417915344,
0.7201148271560669,
0.06847739964723587,
-0.448950856924057,
-0.28409793972969055,
0.5736005306243896,
0.39014095067977905,
-0.6288980841636658,
-0.3430250585079193,
-0.3235653042793274,
-0.025547580793499947,
-0.07873328030109406,
0.9830877184867859,
0.19207683205604553,
0.39597663283348083,
-0.37888461351394653,
-0.24891096353530884,
0.23545412719249725,
-0.10244692862033844,
0.21650546789169312,
0.02437272109091282,
-0.4776136875152588,
0.08398377895355225
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.01863v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.01863v1
|
Towards Effective Time-Aware Language Representation: Exploring Enhanced Temporal Understanding in Language Models
| 2024-06-04T00:30:37 | 2024-06-04T00:30:37 |
Jiexin Wang, Adam Jatowt, Yi Cai
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In the evolving field of Natural Language Processing, understanding the
temporal context of text is increasingly crucial. This study investigates
methods to incorporate temporal information during pre-training, aiming to
achieve effective time-aware language representation for improved performance
on time-related tasks. In contrast to common pre-trained models like BERT,
which rely on synchronic document collections such as BookCorpus and Wikipedia,
our research introduces BiTimeBERT 2.0, a novel language model pre-trained on a
temporal news article collection. BiTimeBERT 2.0 utilizes this temporal news
collection, focusing on three innovative pre-training objectives: Time-Aware
Masked Language Modeling (TAMLM), Document Dating (DD), and Time-Sensitive
Entity Replacement (TSER). Each objective targets a unique aspect of temporal
information. TAMLM is designed to enhance the understanding of temporal
contexts and relations, DD integrates document timestamps as chronological
markers, and TSER focuses on the temporal dynamics of "Person" entities,
recognizing their inherent temporal significance. The experimental results
consistently demonstrate that BiTimeBERT 2.0 outperforms models like BERT and
other existing pre-trained models, achieving substantial gains across a variety
of downstream NLP tasks and applications where time plays a pivotal role.
|
[
-0.20236700773239136,
-0.7449628710746765,
0.5298910737037659,
0.5244684219360352,
-0.42626893520355225,
0.2821352481842041,
-0.16409394145011902,
-0.7589125633239746,
0.061141930520534515,
0.23658710718154907,
-0.5440126657485962,
-0.1502053439617157,
-0.4978310465812683,
-0.19541743397712708,
-0.4685617983341217,
0.8116537928581238,
-0.21226617693901062,
0.1260482370853424,
0.1889691948890686,
-0.16350099444389343,
-0.15418334305286407,
-0.7213155031204224,
-0.5603846907615662,
-0.7335365414619446,
0.32647112011909485,
-0.18035542964935303,
0.6795904040336609,
0.6351528167724609,
-0.03314272686839104,
0.16972891986370087,
0.008510023355484009,
-0.20737199485301971,
-0.23210977017879486,
-0.08196990936994553,
-0.2190859466791153,
-0.32957571744918823,
-0.3747578263282776,
0.43107402324676514,
0.664055347442627,
0.8603910207748413,
-0.09656744450330734,
0.18719731271266937,
0.016163088381290436,
0.3552333414554596,
-0.6038979291915894,
0.19234322011470795,
-0.5079224109649658,
0.3924795389175415,
-0.45200371742248535,
-0.48735755681991577,
-0.3570961058139801,
-0.21841861307621002,
0.3020237684249878,
-0.6409610509872437,
0.3733157217502594,
0.01912282034754753,
1.0155963897705078,
0.16781994700431824,
-0.4689362645149231,
-0.02806713618338108,
-1.0691741704940796,
0.7534784078598022,
-0.4693003296852112,
0.8729803562164307,
0.5815971493721008,
0.37530407309532166,
0.3138788044452667,
-0.8472737669944763,
-0.6679659485816956,
0.012141036801040173,
-0.16060234606266022,
-0.025496497750282288,
-0.07498655468225479,
-0.1915724277496338,
0.20770196616649628,
0.23457872867584229,
-0.6380856037139893,
0.10303491353988647,
0.04501434415578842,
-0.3201994299888611,
0.10681760311126709,
0.009466995485126972,
-0.10551876574754715,
-0.0009877034462988377,
-0.3463784158229828,
0.05921432003378868,
-0.42068371176719666,
0.024360060691833496,
0.33032628893852234,
-0.18837544322013855,
-0.07042241096496582,
0.30654680728912354,
-0.01466909609735012,
0.6648799180984497,
-0.07515942305326462,
0.2891341745853424,
0.18515253067016602,
-0.4235721826553345,
-0.1685078889131546,
0.20394542813301086,
0.5210376381874084,
0.10644405335187912,
0.31143268942832947,
-0.37950843572616577,
-0.2534816265106201,
0.025173116475343704,
0.060189180076122284,
-1.0186030864715576,
-0.17210620641708374,
0.31020912528038025,
-0.44685906171798706,
-0.3884696066379547,
-0.16120491921901703,
-0.2951294779777527,
-0.11146490275859833,
-0.46945616602897644,
0.5354650616645813,
-0.4757448434829712,
-0.26424142718315125,
0.11874134838581085,
-0.06572641432285309,
0.20033690333366394,
0.4566528797149658,
-0.7807786464691162,
0.08394508063793182,
0.6219242215156555,
0.7057240605354309,
0.32394662499427795,
-0.2866731286048889,
-0.6401228904724121,
0.41607972979545593,
-0.5817219614982605,
0.47106313705444336,
-0.539714515209198,
-0.23929375410079956,
0.020883886143565178,
-0.03146757930517197,
0.07525700330734253,
-0.15657024085521698,
0.1247507855296135,
-1.0323286056518555,
0.6570870876312256,
0.26907339692115784,
-0.37442439794540405,
0.028938867151737213,
0.11583040654659271,
-0.677833080291748,
1.0360459089279175,
0.35620468854904175,
-0.833609402179718,
0.3810686469078064,
-0.6072226762771606,
-0.44336774945259094,
0.03330623358488083,
0.033549241721630096,
-0.3774348497390747,
-0.009969813749194145,
0.3572099804878235,
0.46091482043266296,
0.11810562759637833,
0.38104236125946045,
0.06885095685720444,
-0.34394440054893494,
0.4447828233242035,
-0.4070476293563843,
0.9734946489334106,
0.2819851040840149,
-0.3760112524032593,
-0.1829655021429062,
-0.5147634744644165,
-0.08904127031564713,
0.29107147455215454,
-0.2454429566860199,
-0.482228547334671,
0.06234610825777054,
0.3206515312194824,
0.28225526213645935,
0.6120650172233582,
-0.5590075254440308,
-0.0002915930235758424,
-0.33651697635650635,
0.5142602920532227,
0.6676273941993713,
0.06476974487304688,
0.5184136033058167,
-0.2287539839744568,
0.07746457308530807,
0.07488412410020828,
0.315350204706192,
-0.436471164226532,
0.162173330783844,
-0.8241151571273804,
0.1290285736322403,
0.5877826809883118,
0.5571054220199585,
-0.8688462376594543,
0.36990588903427124,
-0.46209320425987244,
-0.2907055914402008,
-0.5774223208427429,
0.13697591423988342,
0.2915845513343811,
0.24675941467285156,
0.2755483388900757,
-0.27121540904045105,
-0.7852166891098022,
-0.4438476264476776,
-0.0722382590174675,
-0.3846120238304138,
-0.04396155849099159,
0.13851477205753326,
0.3736533224582672,
-0.39340752363204956,
0.965143620967865,
-0.2878941297531128,
0.01801198720932007,
-0.23736420273780823,
0.6731367111206055,
-0.05961627885699272,
0.42451781034469604,
0.6910064816474915,
-0.8063869476318359,
-0.14647427201271057,
-0.205414816737175,
-0.537108302116394,
-0.15585957467556,
-0.2748679220676422,
0.08190614730119705,
0.4596998393535614,
0.6206061840057373,
-0.13839414715766907,
0.3572942614555359,
0.6739462614059448,
-0.4994717240333557,
0.5114787220954895,
-0.22981229424476624,
0.23047798871994019,
-1.0160417556762695,
0.05698079988360405,
-0.336501806974411,
-0.7344228625297546,
-0.8040671348571777,
-0.3326064348220825,
0.20540398359298706,
-0.35910385847091675,
-0.5537649393081665,
0.8266193270683289,
-0.45541098713874817,
0.05822736397385597,
-0.2713924050331116,
0.161535382270813,
0.13549740612506866,
0.36702388525009155,
0.31650957465171814,
0.8065647482872009,
0.13372161984443665,
-0.602704644203186,
-0.15798984467983246,
-0.13948731124401093,
-0.4141945242881775,
0.2281009405851364,
-0.7810617685317993,
0.3677636384963989,
-0.335483193397522,
0.05316012352705002,
-0.4889627993106842,
0.06764087080955505,
0.1435168832540512,
-0.6245343685150146,
0.776893675327301,
-0.24178822338581085,
-0.7569363713264465,
-0.050162289291620255,
-0.3549712598323822,
0.4511888921260834,
0.29377588629722595,
-0.4870678782463074,
0.6176729798316956,
0.3317186236381531,
-0.09402145445346832,
-0.4320020079612732,
-0.6992926597595215,
-0.011228497140109539,
0.08011253923177719,
-0.3939777612686157,
0.678978681564331,
0.044613853096961975,
-0.35319003462791443,
0.17929707467556,
-0.2248634397983551,
-0.18460744619369507,
0.3158198893070221,
0.03847538307309151,
0.3607347309589386,
-0.10467962175607681,
0.3503924608230591,
-0.22195316851139069,
-0.35415470600128174,
-0.06436602771282196,
-0.52315354347229,
0.9823625683784485,
-0.019219307228922844,
-0.0538710318505764,
-0.34945064783096313,
0.35141488909721375,
0.20243698358535767,
-0.5367575883865356,
1.0308510065078735,
1.0755894184112549,
-0.5407236218452454,
0.0289152842015028,
-0.7028424143791199,
-0.228703111410141,
-0.38239413499832153,
0.1779201179742813,
0.010072216391563416,
-1.158656120300293,
0.24471302330493927,
0.19762201607227325,
0.2088628113269806,
0.40184205770492554,
0.2903165817260742,
-0.5698680877685547,
0.6433723568916321,
0.7621858716011047,
-0.1568693220615387,
1.2703311443328857,
-0.35785457491874695,
0.003093728329986334,
-0.8147397041320801,
-0.21953165531158447,
-0.4361235797405243,
-0.03869621828198433,
-0.4168706238269806,
-0.6733661890029907,
0.017999162897467613,
0.37370336055755615,
-0.3578697741031647,
0.4960295855998993,
0.035293061286211014,
0.1977984458208084,
0.383970707654953,
0.06247042492032051,
0.17852066457271576,
0.011157047934830189,
0.10235182195901871,
-0.19191564619541168,
-0.4507042169570923,
-0.6099936366081238,
0.7785434722900391,
0.389085590839386,
0.5640976428985596,
0.023583129048347473,
0.4657706022262573,
0.5113454461097717,
-0.01299235038459301,
-0.4441097676753998,
0.3883269727230072,
-0.08015983551740646,
-0.872374415397644,
-0.20740260183811188,
-0.5128170251846313,
-0.9970299005508423,
-0.028713591396808624,
-0.2658413350582123,
-0.9523837566375732,
-0.027422834187746048,
0.1366610825061798,
-0.24419453740119934,
0.19355382025241852,
-0.5526636242866516,
0.8241462707519531,
-0.40503641963005066,
-0.5261259078979492,
-0.5216877460479736,
-0.7853947877883911,
-0.2570260763168335,
-0.13020339608192444,
0.1461217701435089,
-0.23790769279003143,
-0.16922879219055176,
1.0625097751617432,
-0.15147510170936584,
0.7163528800010681,
-0.16465337574481964,
0.31080392003059387,
0.2767874598503113,
0.4434811472892761,
0.5015279054641724,
0.1126847043633461,
0.020951785147190094,
0.5002004504203796,
0.08406432718038559,
-0.4814029932022095,
-0.5966983437538147,
0.4132058322429657,
-0.8106656670570374,
-0.461008757352829,
-0.626789391040802,
-0.46731457114219666,
-0.0921051874756813,
0.17726413905620575,
0.08571343868970871,
0.7865922451019287,
-0.2160351425409317,
0.05702298879623413,
0.7499747276306152,
-0.07587629556655884,
0.8063571453094482,
0.9321072697639465,
-0.3983196020126343,
-0.1554722636938095,
0.4929203689098358,
0.10166776925325394,
0.09098868817090988,
0.9742537140846252,
0.055937133729457855,
-0.4511631429195404,
-0.3979366421699524,
-0.1786617487668991,
0.3485781252384186,
-0.5121424198150635,
0.21837462484836578,
-1.0457199811935425,
-0.48103195428848267,
-0.5263854265213013,
-0.1108778864145279,
-0.3969659209251404,
-0.7726140022277832,
-0.4158537983894348,
0.1000288724899292,
0.22637797892093658,
0.4088711142539978,
-0.03478239104151726,
0.645706295967102,
-0.856682300567627,
0.10536891967058182,
0.39418843388557434,
0.42165231704711914,
-0.2551390826702118,
-0.5377832651138306,
-0.4276420772075653,
-0.23883382976055145,
-0.06358461827039719,
-0.8210245370864868,
0.05732385814189911,
0.09663037955760956,
0.6266855001449585,
0.3013012409210205,
-0.2607766389846802,
0.47571367025375366,
-0.5230146646499634,
0.8300302028656006,
-0.1093658059835434,
-1.1102548837661743,
0.851710319519043,
-0.2774523198604584,
0.4294854998588562,
0.3376569151878357,
0.32194364070892334,
-0.7796279788017273,
-0.08440838009119034,
-0.6910382509231567,
-0.6954386234283447,
0.7768428325653076,
0.6389095783233643,
0.029300082474946976,
0.20518596470355988,
0.09468197822570801,
0.05359242111444473,
0.44570475816726685,
-0.8070487976074219,
-0.1651400327682495,
-0.3616866171360016,
-0.012409134767949581,
-0.3601604402065277,
-0.601615309715271,
0.28770366311073303,
0.1502966731786728,
0.7333352565765381,
0.28285300731658936,
0.6203296184539795,
0.08943479508161545,
-0.5345906615257263,
0.05786782130599022,
0.5671578645706177,
0.4596714675426483,
0.7201818227767944,
-0.46451613306999207,
0.44380250573158264,
0.09488053619861603,
-0.4965982437133789,
-0.016512108966708183,
0.6734702587127686,
-0.07254228740930557,
0.40315520763397217,
0.7616561055183411,
0.6675208210945129,
0.16398385167121887,
-0.35742661356925964,
0.4183002710342407,
-0.12556792795658112,
0.4341984987258911,
-0.33976566791534424,
-0.18512029945850372,
-0.03798836097121239,
0.33206433057785034,
0.3649919927120209,
-0.14117704331874847,
-0.15229283273220062,
-0.5659656524658203,
0.07256659120321274,
0.06647676974534988,
-0.5399567484855652,
-0.504788875579834,
0.7756276726722717,
0.10417807847261429,
-0.3331815302371979,
0.4934924840927124,
-0.44904494285583496,
-0.749182403087616,
0.09887946397066116,
0.5381109714508057,
0.7640089392662048,
-0.49216583371162415,
0.23394283652305603,
0.22094422578811646,
0.40943828225135803,
0.08438626676797867,
0.3382132053375244,
-0.49060478806495667,
-0.631251871585846,
-0.40072450041770935,
-0.6326383352279663,
0.0033380729146301746,
0.06624051928520203,
-0.2481951266527176,
0.07231954485177994,
-0.49664413928985596,
-0.42325690388679504,
-0.12962226569652557,
0.29495856165885925,
-0.9106004238128662,
0.017103878781199455,
0.01043920312076807,
0.8742328882217407,
-0.7994655966758728,
0.8683322072029114,
0.6564962863922119,
-0.2139553427696228,
-0.4905301332473755,
0.1488354504108429,
-0.05219972878694534,
-0.7086478471755981,
0.6599943041801453,
0.13521945476531982,
-0.13339291512966156,
0.07120447605848312,
-0.28328052163124084,
-0.368351548910141,
1.0547292232513428,
0.24814826250076294,
-0.660905659198761,
-0.14293046295642853,
0.0024684437084943056,
0.5467938780784607,
-0.20094627141952515,
0.12911385297775269,
0.4162125885486603,
0.027843216434121132,
-0.16987858712673187,
-0.8385563492774963,
-0.3107356131076813,
-0.2653864920139313,
0.3127731382846832,
0.6473352313041687,
-0.353281170129776,
0.7324689626693726,
-0.09084673225879669,
-0.4672352075576782,
-0.2257169634103775,
0.7757417559623718,
0.013644776307046413,
0.6302199363708496,
0.5292678475379944,
0.3930661082267761,
0.6732195019721985,
-0.23741084337234497,
0.9744586944580078,
-0.3632136583328247,
0.2342110425233841,
1.4498205184936523,
0.01133558340370655,
0.5585235953330994,
0.5155881643295288,
-0.12720610201358795,
0.3906482756137848,
0.5916226506233215,
0.34785306453704834,
0.6840465068817139,
-0.33347994089126587,
-0.4152699112892151,
-0.404504656791687,
-0.6253342628479004,
-0.4479047656059265,
0.2082306146621704,
0.2769176959991455,
-0.4240128993988037,
-0.2347504049539566,
0.03407355025410652,
0.31907105445861816,
-0.09302383661270142,
-0.2455161064863205,
0.6023074984550476,
0.014957252889871597,
-0.22429552674293518,
0.014419020153582096,
0.031682420521974564,
0.2717320919036865,
-0.6856979727745056,
0.008452150039374828,
-0.11018106341362,
0.14648832380771637,
0.1892387717962265,
-0.8922474384307861,
0.19753330945968628,
0.11190707981586456,
-0.15185903012752533,
-0.513573408126831,
0.7188007235527039,
-0.5875836610794067,
-0.43458059430122375,
0.24620391428470612,
0.5183108448982239,
0.037195172160863876,
-0.12026804685592651,
-0.460417777299881,
0.14734938740730286,
-0.2319522351026535,
-0.15841390192508698,
-0.12310077995061874,
0.6242777705192566,
-0.05152967944741249,
0.4525270462036133,
0.28299447894096375,
0.15503756701946259,
-0.11579085141420364,
0.321376770734787,
0.6147687435150146,
-0.5900740623474121,
-0.6012240648269653,
-0.8803039789199829,
0.33074888586997986,
-0.08722884953022003,
0.00012843582953792065,
0.5475668907165527,
0.6932973265647888,
0.9254079461097717,
0.13823029398918152,
0.46684423089027405,
-0.12992164492607117,
0.5320485234260559,
-0.7324031591415405,
0.7992607355117798,
-0.441902756690979,
0.30284202098846436,
0.030887402594089508,
-0.889346718788147,
-0.02934219315648079,
0.5154963135719299,
-0.3445976972579956,
0.14785756170749664,
0.6904259920120239,
0.5326111912727356,
0.08240211009979248,
-0.019495517015457153,
0.08278633654117584,
0.03484439477324486,
0.4184974133968353,
0.625862181186676,
0.98610919713974,
-0.4266875386238098,
0.5936681032180786,
-0.5690104961395264,
-0.02265109121799469,
-0.2661880552768707,
-0.9738320112228394,
-1.2233285903930664,
-0.9786845445632935,
-0.30937108397483826,
-0.3416213393211365,
0.3881702423095703,
1.2477023601531982,
0.7896101474761963,
-0.6081488728523254,
0.05646495893597603,
0.3391875922679901,
-0.1606471687555313,
-0.05651845410466194,
-0.16012246906757355,
0.3808027505874634,
-0.19246061146259308,
-0.5355027318000793,
0.20617134869098663,
0.294816792011261,
0.506905198097229,
-0.17620180547237396,
0.0393693707883358,
-0.173629030585289,
-0.22005033493041992,
0.6859726309776306,
0.014689347706735134,
-0.3011188507080078,
-0.35500141978263855,
0.0832555890083313,
-0.2969023585319519,
-0.004806799348443747,
1.2039337158203125,
-0.8908872604370117,
0.8051157593727112,
0.4381314516067505,
0.43537551164627075,
0.9729298949241638,
-0.20362573862075806,
0.4561261534690857,
-0.9866011738777161,
0.505297839641571,
0.4168982207775116,
0.3807402551174164,
0.5019586086273193,
-0.22463271021842957,
0.6580424308776855,
0.28609994053840637,
-0.2563585937023163,
-0.44540935754776,
0.20238901674747467,
-0.8020138144493103,
-0.36902379989624023,
0.8312298059463501,
-0.028235506266355515,
-0.058372098952531815,
-0.34561389684677124,
0.02910766750574112,
0.8517336249351501,
-0.3207220435142517,
0.8156231641769409,
0.79356449842453,
0.13495223224163055,
-0.25642505288124084,
-0.7561101913452148,
0.24232463538646698,
0.13087092339992523,
-0.6439913511276245,
-0.02529585361480713,
0.23297244310379028,
0.14087292551994324,
0.21703822910785675,
0.7581910490989685,
-0.32567155361175537,
0.27255210280418396,
-0.12443440407514572,
-0.15691769123077393,
-0.449958860874176,
-0.5144302248954773,
-0.22117607295513153,
-0.24870379269123077,
-0.00013855111319571733,
-0.20808741450309753
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.01860v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.01860v1
|
Eliciting the Priors of Large Language Models using Iterated In-Context Learning
| 2024-06-04T00:09:43 | 2024-06-04T00:09:43 |
Jian-Qiao Zhu, Thomas L. Griffiths
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
As Large Language Models (LLMs) are increasingly deployed in real-world
settings, understanding the knowledge they implicitly use when making decisions
is critical. One way to capture this knowledge is in the form of Bayesian prior
distributions. We develop a prompt-based workflow for eliciting prior
distributions from LLMs. Our approach is based on iterated learning, a Markov
chain Monte Carlo method in which successive inferences are chained in a way
that supports sampling from the prior distribution. We validated our method in
settings where iterated learning has previously been used to estimate the
priors of human participants -- causal learning, proportion estimation, and
predicting everyday quantities. We found that priors elicited from GPT-4
qualitatively align with human priors in these settings. We then used the same
method to elicit priors from GPT-4 for a variety of speculative events, such as
the timing of the development of superhuman AI.
|
[
-0.04571865499019623,
-0.7140029668807983,
1.0620439052581787,
-0.10368981957435608,
-0.2537199854850769,
-0.10184556990861893,
-0.29731518030166626,
0.07271973043680191,
-0.2096954882144928,
0.5275824666023254,
-0.49028754234313965,
-0.5182713866233826,
-0.31782227754592896,
-0.03506685420870781,
-0.24291838705539703,
0.7859275937080383,
0.006122589111328125,
-0.12278597801923752,
0.07678639888763428,
0.3881361186504364,
-0.3736366331577301,
-0.5182655453681946,
-0.6580249667167664,
-0.4651816785335541,
0.6352190971374512,
0.3625423312187195,
0.39729732275009155,
0.338875412940979,
0.18082821369171143,
0.23791591823101044,
0.1678965985774994,
-0.17386578023433685,
-0.27646028995513916,
0.23270417749881744,
-0.507217526435852,
-0.44452083110809326,
-0.04333312436938286,
0.04136894643306732,
0.942069947719574,
0.9301502108573914,
-0.5329979658126831,
0.07425988465547562,
-0.1004297286272049,
0.4354083836078644,
-0.8688429594039917,
0.21929386258125305,
-0.7419775724411011,
0.17126213014125824,
-0.27329155802726746,
-0.36025935411453247,
-0.644843339920044,
-0.2179616093635559,
0.2582767605781555,
-0.5023548603057861,
0.027646856382489204,
-0.016810882836580276,
0.3505099415779114,
0.024985725060105324,
-0.36490219831466675,
-0.13331246376037598,
-0.7138431668281555,
0.5847343802452087,
-0.8775140643119812,
0.26373153924942017,
0.6105763912200928,
0.5563918352127075,
-0.2960459887981415,
-0.9339490532875061,
-0.7147983312606812,
-0.4979442059993744,
0.23751620948314667,
0.2074759304523468,
0.127559632062912,
-0.0920005515217781,
0.49253860116004944,
0.14009146392345428,
-0.6499698162078857,
0.3098551630973816,
-0.4332897365093231,
0.16457846760749817,
0.41640785336494446,
0.10907179117202759,
-0.02313792146742344,
0.13151264190673828,
-0.30499327182769775,
-0.24994726479053497,
-1.114548683166504,
-0.15119247138500214,
0.19194836914539337,
0.3025849163532257,
-0.018533486872911453,
0.4824664890766144,
-0.29670029878616333,
0.9531702995300293,
0.04069878160953522,
-0.21410886943340302,
0.24524682760238647,
-0.11690039932727814,
-0.24987521767616272,
-0.08488716930150986,
0.9057923555374146,
0.0007729605422355235,
0.47334346175193787,
0.0022848076187074184,
-0.1509011834859848,
-0.23281461000442505,
0.216033473610878,
-0.7144314646720886,
-0.3280681371688843,
0.03570102900266647,
-0.13807198405265808,
0.09592582285404205,
0.07316514849662781,
-0.6201934814453125,
-0.3800427317619324,
-0.21573491394519806,
0.4284573197364807,
-0.18763135373592377,
-0.3934248387813568,
-0.08660535514354706,
-0.2173166126012802,
0.08960078656673431,
0.1991555094718933,
-1.0059386491775513,
0.115615613758564,
0.41268017888069153,
0.6531295776367188,
0.047753892838954926,
-0.33770567178726196,
-0.6128859519958496,
0.5312079191207886,
-0.649684488773346,
0.8686463832855225,
-0.7155307531356812,
-0.31563514471054077,
0.18779417872428894,
-0.24099595844745636,
-0.24591164290905,
-0.5453541278839111,
0.3856741786003113,
-0.617728590965271,
0.17830704152584076,
-0.16144390404224396,
-0.7695084810256958,
-0.13207688927650452,
0.1860383301973343,
-0.38851577043533325,
0.6689920425415039,
0.07393205165863037,
-0.8451585173606873,
0.4689185321331024,
-0.33396846055984497,
-0.4089064598083496,
0.14246010780334473,
-0.31733986735343933,
-0.14546112716197968,
0.26437684893608093,
0.43474337458610535,
0.9672060608863831,
-0.30581235885620117,
0.4244822859764099,
-0.4253230690956116,
-0.12835267186164856,
0.13113471865653992,
-0.5172215104103088,
0.6903689503669739,
0.34329187870025635,
-0.17537881433963776,
0.060337889939546585,
-0.43240052461624146,
-0.2314525544643402,
0.1433681845664978,
0.008543509989976883,
-0.213653564453125,
0.22006146609783173,
-0.5598322153091431,
0.4591865837574005,
-0.02238261140882969,
-0.07415718585252762,
0.5322906970977783,
-0.3242996335029602,
0.4345392882823944,
0.7853513956069946,
0.49400898814201355,
0.8168103098869324,
-0.2892395555973053,
0.44708776473999023,
0.09324687719345093,
-0.06677334010601044,
-0.46255362033843994,
-0.46107226610183716,
-0.11187496036291122,
-0.33700525760650635,
-0.04316285252571106,
0.4166118800640106,
-0.8601813912391663,
0.3460954427719116,
-0.12932296097278595,
-0.42708462476730347,
0.16086173057556152,
0.0077848490327596664,
-0.00284362118691206,
0.6695681214332581,
0.09633135795593262,
0.04753471165895462,
-0.16108664870262146,
-0.5535467863082886,
-0.01318581122905016,
-0.4430268108844757,
-0.33649754524230957,
0.08605615794658661,
0.6125921010971069,
-0.32036250829696655,
0.879170298576355,
-0.46868619322776794,
0.10825352370738983,
-0.2361414134502411,
0.2740263044834137,
0.3970188498497009,
0.4345744550228119,
0.26632869243621826,
-0.5341999530792236,
-0.3114650547504425,
-0.058320652693510056,
-0.5969515442848206,
-0.07780306786298752,
-0.18193435668945312,
-0.18456482887268066,
-0.00639682449400425,
0.5108216404914856,
-0.4903142750263214,
0.1442611813545227,
0.3567081093788147,
-0.058298345655202866,
0.47809723019599915,
-0.3282334506511688,
0.11549018323421478,
-1.2672934532165527,
0.07424905151128769,
0.03899183124303818,
-0.12971630692481995,
-0.4544107913970947,
-0.04974951595067978,
0.18621891736984253,
0.06602176278829575,
-0.21810612082481384,
0.767527163028717,
-0.47078508138656616,
-0.3268246650695801,
0.00928491074591875,
0.28426504135131836,
-0.4387538731098175,
0.3330831527709961,
0.569257378578186,
0.5792236328125,
0.6647695899009705,
-0.7867113351821899,
0.07646453380584717,
-0.014121441170573235,
-0.5712873339653015,
0.5997220873832703,
-0.4118671715259552,
0.03136806935071945,
-0.19741706550121307,
0.5175573229789734,
-1.002038836479187,
-0.4052376449108124,
0.35796719789505005,
-0.30077505111694336,
0.2818065285682678,
-0.26442402601242065,
-0.8389475345611572,
-0.36124172806739807,
0.0698479413986206,
0.1588360071182251,
0.5051063895225525,
-0.5730135440826416,
0.3930119574069977,
0.36937645077705383,
-0.3794653117656708,
-0.46908828616142273,
-0.3498675525188446,
-0.06147079914808273,
-0.3171822726726532,
-0.2451935112476349,
0.13000793755054474,
-0.21111741662025452,
-0.4463713765144348,
-0.2644788324832916,
0.026419363915920258,
-0.2696722745895386,
0.19197165966033936,
0.051577143371105194,
0.06989748775959015,
-0.021345391869544983,
0.14422418177127838,
0.28172731399536133,
-0.14147858321666718,
0.08901721984148026,
-0.6974855065345764,
0.40256646275520325,
0.32331377267837524,
-0.5030450224876404,
-0.3228815793991089,
0.33525845408439636,
0.2913346290588379,
-0.01751098409295082,
0.5308070182800293,
0.44437143206596375,
-0.5855644941329956,
-0.2957933843135834,
-0.4282767176628113,
-0.4185856878757477,
-0.397068053483963,
0.04018528759479523,
-0.37478455901145935,
-0.8637060523033142,
0.5246459245681763,
-0.30093488097190857,
0.23393061757087708,
0.3446539342403412,
0.9717504978179932,
-0.1436963528394699,
1.0957812070846558,
0.5856578350067139,
-0.27191802859306335,
0.880516767501831,
-0.23669490218162537,
0.07080391049385071,
-0.5162683129310608,
0.0601075105369091,
-0.3159334659576416,
0.1834234595298767,
-0.22600647807121277,
-0.5055870413780212,
0.40221989154815674,
0.2138187438249588,
-0.5212590098381042,
-0.004577465821057558,
0.19203542172908783,
0.47519415616989136,
0.598585844039917,
0.035887300968170166,
0.23497483134269714,
-0.0423392727971077,
-0.5304996371269226,
0.26094427704811096,
-0.5885196924209595,
-0.513090193271637,
0.8955538868904114,
0.1233852431178093,
0.7900869846343994,
0.05687979981303215,
0.7482743859291077,
0.0367637500166893,
0.7042573094367981,
-0.40287983417510986,
0.20382320880889893,
0.5265937447547913,
-0.5422856211662292,
-0.05864311382174492,
-0.5168886184692383,
-0.9022783041000366,
0.2131461203098297,
0.033982053399086,
-1.2406710386276245,
0.022859729826450348,
0.2218673676252365,
-0.5005832314491272,
0.06629449129104614,
-0.5602447390556335,
0.964231550693512,
0.10573691874742508,
-0.2557477355003357,
-0.3519741892814636,
-0.8421362638473511,
0.46647909283638,
-0.1117185428738594,
0.29981672763824463,
-0.004568831995129585,
0.015112991444766521,
0.41406872868537903,
-0.36793452501296997,
0.956619381904602,
-0.1748218536376953,
-0.4262031614780426,
0.33608660101890564,
0.07888095825910568,
0.7030258774757385,
0.3458225131034851,
-0.17341811954975128,
-0.16141381859779358,
-0.17060306668281555,
-0.22547967731952667,
-0.6287434697151184,
0.5515393018722534,
-0.535654604434967,
-0.47324231266975403,
-0.3724266588687897,
-0.5321191549301147,
-0.394938588142395,
-0.026132676750421524,
0.4953082799911499,
0.4209563434123993,
-0.008712212555110455,
-0.11816814541816711,
0.48048821091651917,
-0.022405371069908142,
0.6297432780265808,
0.6449053287506104,
-0.15963466465473175,
-0.331354558467865,
0.5793914198875427,
0.10666847229003906,
0.44736167788505554,
0.6627547144889832,
0.3839161694049835,
-0.4248424470424652,
-0.4817228615283966,
-0.5157427191734314,
0.2555854618549347,
-0.7433857321739197,
-0.054002679884433746,
-0.589958667755127,
0.1530722677707672,
-0.4178180396556854,
-0.3150619864463806,
-0.09400685876607895,
0.001996251055970788,
-0.20887048542499542,
-0.2824766933917999,
0.23806342482566833,
0.8669599890708923,
-0.2271173596382141,
0.5114105939865112,
-0.7938252091407776,
0.035210248082876205,
0.22001604735851288,
-0.01438659057021141,
-0.028626656159758568,
-0.7983384132385254,
-0.13028673827648163,
-0.00208408385515213,
-0.11987783014774323,
-1.1934313774108887,
0.6112061142921448,
0.10026263445615768,
0.8416064977645874,
0.58321213722229,
0.02502833493053913,
0.6091995239257812,
-0.8918400406837463,
0.8749753832817078,
-0.05928662046790123,
-0.684843897819519,
0.5596412420272827,
-0.6112892627716064,
0.2968084216117859,
0.4166681170463562,
0.7087641358375549,
-0.44071269035339355,
-0.48048049211502075,
-0.6912548542022705,
-0.793688952922821,
0.3131992220878601,
-0.07704983651638031,
0.05448133870959282,
-0.49678146839141846,
0.36197665333747864,
0.20291289687156677,
0.4364871382713318,
-0.5543873906135559,
-0.05847426876425743,
0.2526884078979492,
-0.3090173304080963,
-0.4249422550201416,
-0.0712653398513794,
0.15632283687591553,
-0.265159547328949,
0.4276388883590698,
-0.3549738824367523,
0.23549804091453552,
-0.019260495901107788,
-0.4479655623435974,
0.08868394047021866,
0.10040229558944702,
0.48743656277656555,
1.2251896858215332,
-0.13520433008670807,
0.2271619439125061,
0.11888496577739716,
-0.0946328416466713,
0.013644282706081867,
0.14787791669368744,
0.006053691264241934,
-0.2356334924697876,
0.2541621923446655,
0.5565029978752136,
0.4070426821708679,
-0.803921639919281,
0.500167191028595,
-0.04341380298137665,
0.008581053465604782,
-0.44620513916015625,
-0.1323450803756714,
0.1507905125617981,
0.5539155006408691,
0.5663440823554993,
-0.35733145475387573,
0.2531847059726715,
-0.6086222529411316,
0.4159030616283417,
0.2312132567167282,
-0.13366355001926422,
-0.31892654299736023,
0.360212117433548,
-0.30620962381362915,
0.0059637390077114105,
0.5623579025268555,
-0.2950367033481598,
-0.4568755030632019,
0.3194245398044586,
0.8244978785514832,
0.738027036190033,
-0.28631341457366943,
0.31970927119255066,
0.6663119792938232,
0.10177769511938095,
-0.6191487312316895,
0.18156416714191437,
-0.5812434554100037,
-0.6646678447723389,
-0.7539094090461731,
-0.41160762310028076,
-0.6538172960281372,
-0.0947493240237236,
-0.45757171511650085,
-0.07371000200510025,
-0.3417775630950928,
0.0774257481098175,
-0.3014766573905945,
-0.14631997048854828,
-0.6862804293632507,
-0.011518837884068489,
0.2841447591781616,
0.7591163516044617,
-1.1250568628311157,
0.9208196997642517,
0.4746910035610199,
-0.5751562714576721,
-0.8749693632125854,
0.3413946330547333,
-0.061014898121356964,
-0.5210599303245544,
0.6535271406173706,
0.10366111248731613,
0.33682796359062195,
0.4031849801540375,
-0.5748234987258911,
-0.8754622340202332,
0.9806285500526428,
0.496599406003952,
-0.6822280883789062,
0.14123818278312683,
-0.46246811747550964,
0.33285439014434814,
-0.2787759304046631,
0.5989837050437927,
0.5173149704933167,
0.26657500863075256,
0.18425360321998596,
-0.7149035930633545,
-0.05435540899634361,
-0.17052985727787018,
-0.04207506403326988,
0.11206580698490143,
0.016401860862970352,
0.8552184700965881,
-0.526740550994873,
-0.25219205021858215,
0.024503175169229507,
0.8052429556846619,
0.7125465273857117,
-0.005240150727331638,
0.4431050419807434,
0.3655243515968323,
1.2075440883636475,
0.2582021653652191,
1.280306339263916,
-0.12702013552188873,
0.21708030998706818,
1.2070847749710083,
-0.4183312654495239,
1.240797519683838,
0.3770838677883148,
-0.13830465078353882,
0.6890197396278381,
1.035215973854065,
0.45781391859054565,
0.6974197030067444,
0.27853822708129883,
-0.4761659801006317,
-0.2647304832935333,
0.296150803565979,
-0.31168273091316223,
-0.08952291309833527,
0.6674360036849976,
-0.2995713949203491,
-0.4412909746170044,
0.1311616152524948,
-0.04838239774107933,
-0.18009011447429657,
-0.311390221118927,
0.9291988611221313,
0.2422383725643158,
-0.8874536752700806,
0.3295903503894806,
-0.3460580110549927,
0.3832336962223053,
-0.5884618163108826,
-0.13484086096286774,
-0.1949329674243927,
0.1952727884054184,
0.33308151364326477,
-0.9030030369758606,
-0.08151189237833023,
0.027754714712500572,
-0.10538242012262344,
-0.20246267318725586,
0.405632883310318,
-0.6385127305984497,
-0.334314227104187,
0.01916065625846386,
0.653735339641571,
0.30503228306770325,
-0.3283807039260864,
-0.418571799993515,
-0.2316761612892151,
-0.5293369889259338,
-0.46218401193618774,
0.34358757734298706,
0.5747738480567932,
-0.39502280950546265,
0.683635950088501,
0.5106028914451599,
-0.05006691813468933,
0.12308003008365631,
0.3301965892314911,
0.6270502209663391,
-0.5094341039657593,
-0.6074376106262207,
-1.1089656352996826,
0.5374797582626343,
-0.016356520354747772,
-0.1849949210882187,
0.6652042269706726,
0.062306713312864304,
0.780511736869812,
-0.05752965807914734,
0.7719758152961731,
0.19756798446178436,
0.3187562823295593,
-0.6184208393096924,
0.39316526055336,
-0.2768079340457916,
0.15203487873077393,
-0.3591378927230835,
-0.8675354719161987,
-0.2693849802017212,
1.0173749923706055,
-0.46901068091392517,
0.12489897012710571,
0.7526549100875854,
0.597793698310852,
0.1624983549118042,
-0.12277045845985413,
0.3206527829170227,
0.06293702870607376,
0.39660629630088806,
0.6378365755081177,
1.0717391967773438,
0.06746138632297516,
-0.0824039950966835,
-0.1572122722864151,
-0.330417662858963,
-0.11854862421751022,
-1.2662768363952637,
-0.8668005466461182,
-0.8466150760650635,
-0.11314550787210464,
0.006787885911762714,
0.15471725165843964,
1.2452806234359741,
0.6301644444465637,
-0.563786506652832,
-0.18007589876651764,
-0.2551546096801758,
0.23255163431167603,
-0.3240968883037567,
-0.14737984538078308,
0.19437406957149506,
-0.5902518630027771,
-0.7068678140640259,
0.4788156747817993,
0.19435633718967438,
-0.10956672579050064,
-0.23971454799175262,
0.09781970828771591,
-0.17783457040786743,
-0.1857508420944214,
0.7362743020057678,
0.2858494222164154,
-0.5412886142730713,
-0.23302215337753296,
-0.2440119832754135,
-0.12093154340982437,
-0.2344372719526291,
0.9469277858734131,
-1.061672568321228,
0.33891475200653076,
0.752752423286438,
0.6275234222412109,
0.5226209759712219,
-0.20739878714084625,
1.0863174200057983,
-0.8607251644134521,
0.1979181170463562,
0.2270267903804779,
0.6587403416633606,
0.198801189661026,
-0.09440214931964874,
0.5127591490745544,
0.16109785437583923,
-0.5919743180274963,
-0.7085978984832764,
0.19190292060375214,
-0.7646427154541016,
-0.2785186469554901,
1.302512526512146,
-0.30053040385246277,
-0.10930687189102173,
-0.09003697335720062,
-0.0811455249786377,
0.08446229249238968,
-0.3456691801548004,
0.41706934571266174,
0.4152657985687256,
0.24642474949359894,
-0.34670111536979675,
-0.9534052014350891,
0.382941871881485,
-0.034663837403059006,
-0.9327530264854431,
0.14656300842761993,
0.6287027597427368,
0.29181429743766785,
-0.1530693918466568,
0.9298211932182312,
0.15446719527244568,
0.20398154854774475,
-0.10737567394971848,
-0.13250090181827545,
0.45290350914001465,
-0.5084306597709656,
-0.26081082224845886,
0.08222747594118118,
0.07140902429819107,
0.17057135701179504
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.01855v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.01855v1
|
TruthEval: A Dataset to Evaluate LLM Truthfulness and Reliability
| 2024-06-04T00:01:35 | 2024-06-04T00:01:35 |
Aisha Khatun, Daniel G. Brown
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large Language Model (LLM) evaluation is currently one of the most important
areas of research, with existing benchmarks proving to be insufficient and not
completely representative of LLMs' various capabilities. We present a curated
collection of challenging statements on sensitive topics for LLM benchmarking
called TruthEval. These statements were curated by hand and contain known truth
values. The categories were chosen to distinguish LLMs' abilities from their
stochastic nature. We perform some initial analyses using this dataset and find
several instances of LLMs failing in simple tasks showing their inability to
understand simple questions.
|
[
0.029219595715403557,
-0.8149611949920654,
0.7183957695960999,
0.1587531417608261,
0.05526294931769371,
0.3028719127178192,
-0.3339815139770508,
-0.20257596671581268,
-0.39584288001060486,
0.5054008364677429,
-0.7317085862159729,
-0.5970243811607361,
-0.7614596486091614,
0.10488332062959671,
-0.4023112654685974,
1.0728180408477783,
-0.06054149195551872,
0.06861184537410736,
-0.44357889890670776,
-0.47823628783226013,
-0.5163463950157166,
-0.49363189935684204,
-0.30067184567451477,
-0.3113364279270172,
0.21391059458255768,
0.5299820899963379,
0.5855351090431213,
0.554227352142334,
1.0482665300369263,
0.2629958689212799,
-0.11953047662973404,
-0.12094620615243912,
-0.7939572334289551,
0.27121177315711975,
-0.4004623591899872,
-0.6551998853683472,
-0.25085413455963135,
0.18246808648109436,
0.7375141382217407,
0.9566125869750977,
-0.3903029263019562,
0.5753002762794495,
-0.018054066225886345,
0.7325730323791504,
-0.5961317420005798,
0.045345038175582886,
-0.7297288775444031,
0.04874392971396446,
-0.2565360367298126,
0.14903998374938965,
-0.30769339203834534,
-0.8777862787246704,
0.08843731880187988,
-0.07336977124214172,
0.24728523194789886,
0.08407338708639145,
0.5334755182266235,
0.4635804295539856,
-0.4156041443347931,
-0.4872531592845917,
-0.7234299182891846,
1.1609638929367065,
-0.580990195274353,
0.36614400148391724,
0.28050342202186584,
0.677122175693512,
-0.07720104604959488,
-0.7229238152503967,
-0.4498855769634247,
-0.5863617658615112,
0.26522791385650635,
0.034236062318086624,
-0.060414087027311325,
-0.22519969940185547,
0.3298315107822418,
0.6099933981895447,
-0.5417878031730652,
0.13900144398212433,
-0.3350793123245239,
-0.12995731830596924,
0.5757508277893066,
0.5445642471313477,
-0.13003146648406982,
-0.11272641271352768,
-0.45211419463157654,
-0.032428182661533356,
-0.7811406254768372,
-0.17354507744312286,
0.33069750666618347,
0.051599614322185516,
-0.05286870151758194,
0.7331871390342712,
-0.09198952466249466,
0.6333603262901306,
-0.27120441198349,
-0.5561882257461548,
0.30338555574417114,
-0.4138534367084503,
-0.08254726231098175,
-0.15171372890472412,
0.4913654327392578,
0.4363502562046051,
0.08046156167984009,
-0.013738305307924747,
-0.319827139377594,
-0.08866813033819199,
0.22320762276649475,
-0.7134051322937012,
0.04822976142168045,
0.38262739777565,
-0.6311691403388977,
-0.3996582627296448,
-0.1862848699092865,
-0.5088216066360474,
-0.6276415586471558,
-0.09774523973464966,
0.2255970984697342,
-0.3418267071247101,
-0.24846281111240387,
-0.032762426882982254,
0.10636808723211288,
0.053025178611278534,
0.17570839822292328,
-0.42832162976264954,
0.2566269338130951,
0.7480705976486206,
0.6260538697242737,
-0.48622363805770874,
-0.226704940199852,
-0.41062232851982117,
-0.22837130725383759,
-0.3687167167663574,
0.6247684359550476,
-0.6051485538482666,
-0.49475041031837463,
0.10671589523553848,
0.09443139284849167,
0.014638494700193405,
-0.8029305934906006,
1.0083997249603271,
-0.46328598260879517,
-0.07009706646203995,
-0.4944573938846588,
-0.786424458026886,
-0.005646968726068735,
0.4708119332790375,
-0.7103955149650574,
0.9212389588356018,
0.20969372987747192,
-0.762855589389801,
0.2957930564880371,
-0.5373983979225159,
-0.17016486823558807,
0.18155121803283691,
-0.25472038984298706,
-0.290962278842926,
0.22049331665039062,
-0.3473384976387024,
0.28876957297325134,
-0.5005663633346558,
0.512989342212677,
-0.3794514536857605,
-0.2003757506608963,
0.6029363870620728,
-0.7788535356521606,
0.5806565284729004,
0.30964359641075134,
-0.14706793427467346,
-0.08874659985303879,
-0.9950850605964661,
0.033320631831884384,
0.16610264778137207,
-0.5869457125663757,
-0.02888534776866436,
0.260380357503891,
0.01080165896564722,
0.16462942957878113,
0.5636481642723083,
-0.5137879848480225,
0.1277572363615036,
-0.15626640617847443,
0.17874616384506226,
0.891177773475647,
0.03937830775976181,
-0.16665543615818024,
-0.5551822185516357,
0.49259281158447266,
-0.08848264068365097,
0.18765132129192352,
0.23027119040489197,
-0.14845646917819977,
-0.8181660175323486,
0.07095194607973099,
0.20393583178520203,
0.5344229936599731,
-0.6075330972671509,
0.29106444120407104,
-0.4298020303249359,
-0.6125785708427429,
-0.6830673813819885,
0.49684464931488037,
0.527859628200531,
0.8192499279975891,
0.2729828953742981,
0.061372920870780945,
-0.233086958527565,
-1.3601744174957275,
-0.23687127232551575,
-0.3477898836135864,
-0.054610442370176315,
0.4021672010421753,
0.6468602418899536,
-0.2017182856798172,
0.627906858921051,
-0.4525785744190216,
-0.08988430351018906,
-0.3053896725177765,
0.29076072573661804,
0.3731403350830078,
0.16809312999248505,
0.19128625094890594,
-0.5713050961494446,
-0.07141111046075821,
-0.45347630977630615,
-0.9388105869293213,
-0.22167816758155823,
0.24521088600158691,
0.22344593703746796,
0.07229692488908768,
0.3218730688095093,
-0.17691922187805176,
0.18021124601364136,
0.6555931568145752,
-0.17876194417476654,
0.6734097003936768,
-0.08607246726751328,
0.06376329809427261,
-0.7892958521842957,
0.06839311867952347,
-0.13889458775520325,
-0.054410919547080994,
-0.364348441362381,
0.08928120881319046,
0.039326105266809464,
0.15054777264595032,
-0.6191485524177551,
0.41831281781196594,
-0.2528831660747528,
-0.17629964649677277,
-0.2955138385295868,
0.21018174290657043,
-0.1443241685628891,
0.09254185855388641,
-0.023843159899115562,
0.8006452322006226,
0.3558684289455414,
-0.3921408951282501,
0.8505565524101257,
0.3246855139732361,
-0.6045729517936707,
0.9029410481452942,
-0.6873696446418762,
0.29190969467163086,
-0.007255766075104475,
-0.23682236671447754,
-0.9439651966094971,
-0.13512322306632996,
-0.2736330032348633,
-0.053293377161026,
0.15883798897266388,
-0.04161599278450012,
-0.4972047507762909,
-0.39563247561454773,
-0.25570496916770935,
0.3766927421092987,
0.32056093215942383,
-0.5198816061019897,
0.08930553495883942,
0.3457167148590088,
-0.13065697252750397,
-0.6287302374839783,
-0.7299644351005554,
0.1920890361070633,
-0.11787966638803482,
-0.5345889329910278,
-0.1664590984582901,
-0.47695663571357727,
-0.7666386961936951,
-0.024016795679926872,
-0.15132249891757965,
0.025327635928988457,
0.2711046636104584,
0.4513413906097412,
0.32822540402412415,
-0.32449957728385925,
0.4581798315048218,
-0.5104996562004089,
0.09562502801418304,
0.22815395891666412,
0.1637706160545349,
0.2948698401451111,
-0.6536343693733215,
-0.71926349401474,
-0.03426321595907211,
0.15138259530067444,
0.3601536750793457,
0.20384225249290466,
0.7537432909011841,
0.23097212612628937,
-0.21705849468708038,
-0.20817402005195618,
-0.8356561064720154,
0.06101646274328232,
-0.48343196511268616,
0.4038673937320709,
-0.3295908272266388,
-1.0636664628982544,
0.3100570738315582,
-0.09402717649936676,
0.11119402199983597,
0.47654667496681213,
0.7257202863693237,
-0.06660644710063934,
0.5948877930641174,
0.482039213180542,
-0.19449838995933533,
-0.19739504158496857,
-0.002680673496797681,
-0.12518063187599182,
-0.6033684015274048,
-0.2548300623893738,
-0.5442476272583008,
-0.21704132854938507,
-0.6945463418960571,
-0.4380567669868469,
0.3313271701335907,
-0.18428629636764526,
-0.1376047134399414,
-0.1148371696472168,
-0.4291262626647949,
0.4423448145389557,
0.30039915442466736,
0.048396721482276917,
0.5855509638786316,
-0.3089275062084198,
-0.08619476109743118,
-0.24178512394428253,
-0.38668641448020935,
-0.9621189832687378,
1.332709550857544,
0.5159329771995544,
1.0609055757522583,
0.3044961392879486,
0.20840230584144592,
0.44682273268699646,
0.6153334379196167,
-0.7981606125831604,
0.6231265664100647,
-0.02816047891974449,
-0.8703259229660034,
-0.29082342982292175,
-0.5054823756217957,
-0.7683907151222229,
-0.15170231461524963,
-0.14975057542324066,
-0.5548397898674011,
-0.1121482104063034,
-0.24385780096054077,
-0.2750205397605896,
0.25020137429237366,
-0.33863314986228943,
0.6170232892036438,
-0.48102909326553345,
-0.3990538418292999,
-0.16184169054031372,
-0.6525006890296936,
0.6474335193634033,
-0.36494123935699463,
0.19276706874370575,
-0.31527212262153625,
-0.14743801951408386,
0.9957745671272278,
-0.31681209802627563,
0.6158564686775208,
0.026556996628642082,
-0.04443613812327385,
0.16928769648075104,
0.14330735802650452,
0.4103940427303314,
0.011115423403680325,
-0.529809832572937,
0.07496614754199982,
0.04473195597529411,
-0.34945905208587646,
-0.39868125319480896,
0.8716104030609131,
-0.7605070471763611,
-0.7152350544929504,
-0.4985774755477905,
-0.5001459717750549,
-0.6332747936248779,
0.02854778803884983,
0.06994348764419556,
0.32899415493011475,
-0.5779743790626526,
0.42403268814086914,
0.8470500111579895,
-0.2166840136051178,
0.37496012449264526,
0.7620773911476135,
-0.17485614120960236,
-0.15930679440498352,
0.6909191012382507,
0.246769517660141,
0.3141325116157532,
0.09352418035268784,
0.09667735546827316,
-0.43215036392211914,
-0.9784175157546997,
-0.08463726937770844,
0.05709066987037659,
-0.9865649342536926,
-0.13865724205970764,
-0.34078750014305115,
-0.41444921493530273,
-0.03426341339945793,
0.11376190185546875,
-0.4533410668373108,
-0.4259045124053955,
-0.027446340769529343,
-0.47390639781951904,
0.25356248021125793,
1.0287941694259644,
0.10526915639638901,
0.11483276635408401,
-0.7270318865776062,
0.4358120858669281,
0.661267101764679,
0.3963952958583832,
-0.3820458948612213,
-0.6292298436164856,
-0.03973833844065666,
-0.14177389442920685,
-0.2859387993812561,
-0.6430680751800537,
0.07988741993904114,
0.23318859934806824,
0.7742797136306763,
0.5102509260177612,
0.18417681753635406,
0.34168741106987,
-0.30095958709716797,
0.8000970482826233,
0.06459222733974457,
-0.7509695291519165,
0.793282687664032,
-0.167273610830307,
0.1076013520359993,
1.0181819200515747,
0.4664696455001831,
-0.38279569149017334,
-0.2895351052284241,
-0.670538067817688,
-0.5514918565750122,
0.4228889048099518,
0.1443215161561966,
0.03144245967268944,
-0.024137789383530617,
0.3535503149032593,
0.35545289516448975,
0.5495061278343201,
-0.5489215850830078,
-0.29395925998687744,
0.0006503092008642852,
-0.32446858286857605,
-0.08158908784389496,
-0.6144384741783142,
-0.5053344368934631,
-0.006934150122106075,
0.33739909529685974,
-0.1063128262758255,
-0.044326066970825195,
-0.034288518130779266,
-0.30044206976890564,
-0.0946335420012474,
0.48601993918418884,
0.46818187832832336,
1.159536600112915,
-0.46223175525665283,
0.3557669520378113,
0.48878178000450134,
-0.5084541440010071,
0.27955731749534607,
-0.025838734582066536,
0.09809950739145279,
-0.24989387392997742,
0.6637415885925293,
0.6120952367782593,
0.04318689927458763,
-0.9465931057929993,
0.7717396020889282,
-0.14324752986431122,
-0.1517236977815628,
-0.44282424449920654,
0.09272749722003937,
0.12237829715013504,
0.1325729936361313,
0.5122609734535217,
-0.14944878220558167,
0.07068850100040436,
-0.7655727863311768,
0.23761361837387085,
0.38628628849983215,
-0.56939297914505,
-0.14964814484119415,
0.5123640894889832,
0.06443309783935547,
-0.18829134106636047,
0.7982234954833984,
-0.08172651380300522,
-0.4795857071876526,
0.46745243668556213,
0.3187621235847473,
0.677415132522583,
-0.2696199417114258,
0.10482002794742584,
0.0749339908361435,
0.545871376991272,
-0.048962466418743134,
0.39407777786254883,
0.25839173793792725,
-0.70839524269104,
-0.3757348656654358,
-0.7672770619392395,
-0.813744843006134,
0.40915900468826294,
-0.5857539176940918,
-0.03498457744717598,
-0.6522796750068665,
-0.1334879994392395,
-0.24041946232318878,
0.21979856491088867,
-0.6970763802528381,
0.447017639875412,
-0.10346441715955734,
1.117876648902893,
-0.8621104955673218,
0.6588292717933655,
0.3289332687854767,
-0.2303948998451233,
-0.6239392161369324,
-0.089784175157547,
0.1853267252445221,
-1.1799036264419556,
0.9047949910163879,
-0.18938195705413818,
0.018588222563266754,
-0.5513292551040649,
-0.7746151685714722,
-0.553057849407196,
1.127051591873169,
0.45874765515327454,
-0.6358818411827087,
0.29021334648132324,
0.45761945843696594,
0.5668039321899414,
-0.31307438015937805,
0.3852246105670929,
0.7627479434013367,
0.6954078078269958,
0.3008875846862793,
-0.9249200820922852,
0.2309190183877945,
-0.14684487879276276,
-0.10458947718143463,
-0.3167072534561157,
-0.9659143686294556,
0.7158615589141846,
-0.17002099752426147,
-0.06217803433537483,
0.030086694285273552,
0.5051812529563904,
0.4569510221481323,
0.3515603542327881,
0.44084805250167847,
0.5531350374221802,
1.0848467350006104,
-0.2279025912284851,
1.0053653717041016,
-0.17885848879814148,
0.29692456126213074,
1.2396421432495117,
-0.5118612051010132,
0.8536412119865417,
0.3034728765487671,
-0.3763936161994934,
0.21796704828739166,
0.48111844062805176,
-0.2623521387577057,
0.3859163820743561,
0.42824605107307434,
-0.3429030776023865,
-0.4330357611179352,
-0.3930530548095703,
-0.37008601427078247,
0.3514571487903595,
0.3832341134548187,
-0.18962746858596802,
-0.21940813958644867,
0.00725304801017046,
-0.15000437200069427,
0.10995036363601685,
-0.25632503628730774,
0.6226416230201721,
0.19491060078144073,
-0.35637643933296204,
0.5515069961547852,
-0.1469179093837738,
0.43409204483032227,
-0.4551725685596466,
-0.060361988842487335,
-0.2859487235546112,
0.059504952281713486,
-0.21285828948020935,
-1.1641038656234741,
0.30045679211616516,
0.017628366127610207,
-0.1024276539683342,
-0.08975107222795486,
0.8842771649360657,
-0.07410664111375809,
-0.7499892711639404,
0.14049912989139557,
0.7307453751564026,
0.3363385796546936,
0.18163476884365082,
-0.6570497155189514,
0.29281824827194214,
-0.1546926647424698,
-0.451871782541275,
0.11793896555900574,
0.34786707162857056,
0.12269145995378494,
1.1823123693466187,
0.3974381983280182,
0.30567944049835205,
-0.08797672390937805,
0.135609969496727,
0.7010552287101746,
-0.8437591791152954,
0.13037128746509552,
-0.8459153771400452,
0.25627967715263367,
-0.2004980891942978,
-0.26739487051963806,
0.9245633482933044,
0.662087082862854,
0.38583600521087646,
0.2160949409008026,
1.0018682479858398,
0.29925206303596497,
0.8507943749427795,
-0.571983277797699,
0.6191812753677368,
-0.33170562982559204,
0.6382970809936523,
0.059860046952962875,
-0.7750430703163147,
0.005384907592087984,
0.41961613297462463,
-0.4586608409881592,
0.11532001197338104,
0.7977020144462585,
0.6941481232643127,
0.13958190381526947,
0.15808966755867004,
0.5193262100219727,
0.5278105139732361,
0.139687642455101,
0.7435756325721741,
1.3541899919509888,
-0.1245713159441948,
0.6445088386535645,
-0.04769947752356529,
-0.1400197595357895,
-0.3214731514453888,
-1.0425572395324707,
-0.9771150946617126,
-0.4305118918418884,
-0.45057445764541626,
-0.48730361461639404,
0.23948867619037628,
0.7621850371360779,
0.5183970332145691,
-0.8781219124794006,
-0.12254254519939423,
0.14556708931922913,
0.47218286991119385,
0.17555297911167145,
-0.20156407356262207,
0.43619105219841003,
-0.22967155277729034,
-0.48298126459121704,
0.6406934261322021,
0.2317628264427185,
-0.06782115250825882,
-0.5116852521896362,
0.08167365193367004,
0.16304002702236176,
0.11714980006217957,
0.3058280348777771,
0.03066365234553814,
-0.3963624835014343,
-0.515860915184021,
-0.08210334926843643,
-0.3237442374229431,
0.1152225211262703,
0.5322138667106628,
-0.47421401739120483,
0.2559918165206909,
0.3375084698200226,
0.5879503488540649,
0.43049922585487366,
0.04750123992562294,
0.20343680679798126,
-0.7018553018569946,
-0.25829216837882996,
0.42392560839653015,
0.38791248202323914,
0.510097086429596,
-0.07091303169727325,
0.6833937764167786,
0.31717798113822937,
-0.741374135017395,
-0.8362961411476135,
0.2553505599498749,
-1.0013223886489868,
-0.20867371559143066,
1.266632080078125,
-0.21060220897197723,
-0.28096097707748413,
-0.4452425539493561,
0.032725926488637924,
-0.1594788283109665,
-0.0954802855849266,
0.7374143004417419,
1.1151918172836304,
-0.1065506711602211,
-0.19930309057235718,
-0.8666781783103943,
0.38296762108802795,
0.262744665145874,
-0.7469356656074524,
0.17350509762763977,
0.5727917551994324,
0.6147018074989319,
0.2099587321281433,
0.49314528703689575,
-0.1356915980577469,
-0.018380040302872658,
-0.025422584265470505,
-0.23447604477405548,
0.017409279942512512,
0.005627953447401524,
-0.3984875977039337,
0.5694705247879028,
0.6640792489051819,
0.09337550401687622
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.01835v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.01835v1
|
An Open Multilingual System for Scoring Readability of Wikipedia
| 2024-06-03T23:07:18 | 2024-06-03T23:07:18 |
Mykola Trokhymovych, Indira Sen, Martin Gerlach
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
With over 60M articles, Wikipedia has become the largest platform for open
and freely accessible knowledge. While it has more than 15B monthly visits, its
content is believed to be inaccessible to many readers due to the lack of
readability of its text. However, previous investigations of the readability of
Wikipedia have been restricted to English only, and there are currently no
systems supporting the automatic readability assessment of the 300+ languages
in Wikipedia. To bridge this gap, we develop a multilingual model to score the
readability of Wikipedia articles. To train and evaluate this model, we create
a novel multilingual dataset spanning 14 languages, by matching articles from
Wikipedia to simplified Wikipedia and online children encyclopedias. We show
that our model performs well in a zero-shot scenario, yielding a ranking
accuracy of more than 80% across 14 languages and improving upon previous
benchmarks. These results demonstrate the applicability of the model at scale
for languages in which there is no ground-truth data available for model
fine-tuning. Furthermore, we provide the first overview on the state of
readability in Wikipedia beyond English.
|
[
-0.44447872042655945,
-0.46792519092559814,
0.3402768075466156,
0.2129136025905609,
-0.3386784493923187,
-0.06056249514222145,
-0.6060288548469543,
-0.9418769478797913,
0.30201685428619385,
-0.029759537428617477,
-0.44415825605392456,
-0.5417633056640625,
-0.4365389943122864,
0.3808099329471588,
-0.32735341787338257,
1.0028101205825806,
-0.27826157212257385,
-0.0487012043595314,
-0.16307123005390167,
-0.39368730783462524,
-0.07268542796373367,
-0.08606777340173721,
-0.29281312227249146,
-0.2309771180152893,
0.8990259170532227,
0.7589250802993774,
0.5862501859664917,
0.6930107474327087,
0.39794906973838806,
0.17135678231716156,
-0.04960715025663376,
0.30334651470184326,
-0.6686238646507263,
-0.09101828932762146,
-0.4303077161312103,
-0.1887924075126648,
-0.2800876498222351,
-0.027006160467863083,
0.6956271529197693,
0.6948010921478271,
-0.018665950745344162,
0.23079048097133636,
-0.007445821072906256,
0.3123106062412262,
-0.5240825414657593,
0.2531651556491852,
-0.37551626563072205,
0.014942139387130737,
-0.2779093384742737,
0.20640411972999573,
-0.5579944849014282,
-0.26062560081481934,
0.029420090839266777,
-0.8456180095672607,
0.16356147825717926,
-0.111541248857975,
0.7202908992767334,
-0.1832883059978485,
-0.49806028604507446,
-0.26540160179138184,
-0.5027391910552979,
0.648746132850647,
-0.554790198802948,
0.8909039497375488,
0.24905693531036377,
0.15936526656150818,
0.328887939453125,
-0.14832645654678345,
-0.9807358980178833,
-0.5181249976158142,
0.06287286430597305,
-0.09570637345314026,
0.029747692868113518,
-0.5554243326187134,
-0.013293374329805374,
0.2013315111398697,
-0.7674979567527771,
0.2231539934873581,
-0.40785762667655945,
0.055339694023132324,
0.44724172353744507,
-0.08261315524578094,
0.6323226690292358,
-0.312004029750824,
-0.32224568724632263,
0.04416871815919876,
-0.45068615674972534,
-0.010249866172671318,
0.5820496678352356,
0.44546300172805786,
-0.18118146061897278,
0.8561338782310486,
-0.361682653427124,
0.7180113196372986,
-0.21587221324443817,
-0.18727998435497284,
0.251179575920105,
-0.10630817711353302,
0.19788174331188202,
-0.013441394083201885,
0.7414657473564148,
0.614234983921051,
0.5165195465087891,
-0.507095217704773,
0.10822024941444397,
-0.2138650119304657,
0.35986530780792236,
-0.6283710598945618,
-0.28847020864486694,
0.06804955750703812,
-0.3037601411342621,
-0.2891850471496582,
0.11358573287725449,
-0.7508569955825806,
-0.5357658267021179,
-0.023300776258111,
0.45644864439964294,
-0.6236900091171265,
-0.5161030292510986,
-0.02920294739305973,
0.029438277706503868,
-0.00858747772872448,
0.40156736969947815,
-0.9474342465400696,
-0.00023045961279422045,
0.44746410846710205,
1.0314120054244995,
-0.34606555104255676,
-0.8896756172180176,
-0.03242732584476471,
0.3373059332370758,
-0.48300009965896606,
0.8761188983917236,
-0.2625446021556854,
0.03743768110871315,
-0.23321905732154846,
0.059730786830186844,
-0.26351216435432434,
-0.07423903793096542,
0.5047298073768616,
-0.6834192276000977,
-0.08171270042657852,
0.020706355571746826,
-0.5849263668060303,
-0.3442966639995575,
0.5614866614341736,
-0.993399441242218,
0.6061923503875732,
0.05152634531259537,
-0.901687741279602,
0.570382297039032,
-0.5973016619682312,
-0.42897137999534607,
-0.11963053792715073,
0.3163275122642517,
0.027278471738100052,
0.008464382030069828,
0.2276836335659027,
0.096515953540802,
0.02714146301150322,
0.04198070988059044,
-0.48322513699531555,
-0.3037663996219635,
-0.055116135627031326,
-0.6264600157737732,
0.7715620994567871,
0.12110935896635056,
-0.2558501958847046,
-0.09225860238075256,
-0.8876550793647766,
0.2786372900009155,
-0.19950512051582336,
-0.6986480355262756,
-0.35806435346603394,
0.026325706392526627,
0.44068995118141174,
0.41594991087913513,
0.47003716230392456,
-0.8270963430404663,
0.11597438156604767,
-0.5393233299255371,
0.10754536837339401,
0.43823695182800293,
-0.30931541323661804,
0.34687045216560364,
-0.0646204873919487,
0.2717428207397461,
0.044497642666101456,
0.21244852244853973,
-0.2535106837749481,
-0.5142863392829895,
-0.9283159375190735,
-0.22532260417938232,
0.47117799520492554,
0.821439802646637,
-0.6360777616500854,
0.28894492983818054,
-0.45972222089767456,
-0.9103781580924988,
-0.6031739115715027,
0.29358041286468506,
0.37043890357017517,
0.5511243939399719,
0.3997153043746948,
-0.08347565680742264,
-0.03424970805644989,
-0.6499110460281372,
-0.2701944410800934,
-0.27447614073753357,
0.06970812380313873,
0.38311031460762024,
0.6568496227264404,
-0.13265414535999298,
0.34947800636291504,
-0.3308027386665344,
0.009500416927039623,
-0.11567296087741852,
-0.12582941353321075,
0.46744441986083984,
0.3316892087459564,
0.20313780009746552,
-0.7702964544296265,
-0.7899193167686462,
0.5358338952064514,
-1.126760482788086,
0.21413420140743256,
0.3576894700527191,
-0.1717853546142578,
0.05601659044623375,
0.29406848549842834,
-0.5855913162231445,
0.12622320652008057,
0.5191271901130676,
-0.41192033886909485,
0.3431699872016907,
-0.529579758644104,
0.38048622012138367,
-0.9737738966941833,
0.3238082826137543,
-0.04510737955570221,
-0.22747652232646942,
-0.5217982530593872,
0.6187352538108826,
0.48567697405815125,
-0.43386828899383545,
-0.5879589319229126,
0.688384473323822,
-0.27086764574050903,
0.32192376255989075,
-0.002120045945048332,
0.11261707544326782,
0.13492147624492645,
0.19515125453472137,
-0.04797922819852829,
0.5324344038963318,
0.28923219442367554,
-0.6012451648712158,
0.6547586917877197,
0.2320251762866974,
-0.6669772863388062,
0.8648062348365784,
-0.6328216791152954,
-0.1364108771085739,
-0.34397774934768677,
-0.034975774586200714,
-0.8042396306991577,
-0.3535609245300293,
0.1769924759864807,
-0.40184611082077026,
0.45158591866493225,
0.25101420283317566,
-0.3706682026386261,
-0.1352251172065735,
-0.11861682683229446,
0.25852349400520325,
-0.3248027265071869,
-0.6831529140472412,
0.2749714255332947,
0.4267432987689972,
-0.3378596305847168,
-0.8580451011657715,
-0.282329797744751,
0.15611611306667328,
0.08026018738746643,
-0.8151211142539978,
0.1906297653913498,
-0.3794041574001312,
-0.07832176238298416,
0.20990817248821259,
0.05607286095619202,
-0.4116035997867584,
0.00844505149871111,
-0.05044591799378395,
0.06663299351930618,
-0.18026615679264069,
0.30794647336006165,
-0.24539436399936676,
-0.18064142763614655,
-0.41617920994758606,
-0.2189413160085678,
0.33832046389579773,
-0.11102155596017838,
-0.2879081964492798,
-0.16119109094142914,
0.6807330846786499,
0.7495407462120056,
-0.4117432236671448,
1.1407333612442017,
0.5498002767562866,
-0.5836617350578308,
-0.16408006846904755,
-0.21018661558628082,
0.4869670569896698,
-0.3325243592262268,
0.48698416352272034,
-0.5941337943077087,
-0.5528372526168823,
0.5003220438957214,
0.3190388083457947,
0.23587660491466522,
0.8735374808311462,
0.5802247524261475,
-0.22939208149909973,
0.8616943955421448,
0.8729512095451355,
-0.20537501573562622,
0.13436400890350342,
0.0016896965680643916,
0.2900444567203522,
-0.1714746057987213,
-0.500966489315033,
-0.6947963833808899,
-0.2703513503074646,
-0.5390065908432007,
-0.30184561014175415,
0.39396432042121887,
0.4401059150695801,
-0.11890684068202972,
0.4181055724620819,
-0.19464264810085297,
0.8324027061462402,
0.5554990768432617,
0.24161936342716217,
0.7516448497772217,
-0.13087549805641174,
-0.6282052993774414,
-0.15709751844406128,
-0.6481528878211975,
-0.38721635937690735,
1.033146619796753,
0.08489201217889786,
0.5702504515647888,
0.5634006261825562,
0.4930317997932434,
0.2628295123577118,
0.4908052682876587,
-0.6532807350158691,
0.04852878674864769,
-0.2980434000492096,
-1.0519176721572876,
-0.692385733127594,
-0.5147191286087036,
-0.6642962098121643,
0.18253068625926971,
-0.21335874497890472,
-0.5999562740325928,
0.05397830158472061,
-0.25404414534568787,
0.003446275368332863,
0.4077548384666443,
-0.8091908693313599,
1.0874840021133423,
-0.09552407264709473,
-0.058780502527952194,
-0.24930214881896973,
-0.48001042008399963,
0.38774916529655457,
-0.4747017025947571,
0.6172028183937073,
-0.1384558230638504,
-0.035318467766046524,
0.4801377058029175,
-0.11694946885108948,
0.53037029504776,
0.09576327353715897,
-0.25424444675445557,
-0.21896155178546906,
-0.10693853348493576,
0.0839279443025589,
0.3244257867336273,
-0.4291406571865082,
0.44610974192619324,
0.12007736414670944,
-0.41119855642318726,
-0.37788301706314087,
1.0506335496902466,
-1.0102144479751587,
-0.06640643626451492,
-0.3138931095600128,
-0.5172342658042908,
-0.2671085000038147,
0.7065837383270264,
0.42310830950737,
0.18439170718193054,
-0.569062352180481,
-0.04515373706817627,
0.6499109864234924,
-0.4084193706512451,
0.28506338596343994,
1.032619833946228,
-0.18486735224723816,
-0.44933995604515076,
1.1892157793045044,
0.3740166127681732,
-0.13883532583713531,
0.43697288632392883,
-0.10237390547990799,
-0.4539873003959656,
-0.214965358376503,
-0.9865032434463501,
0.34772831201553345,
-0.7408863306045532,
0.16223004460334778,
-0.5089929103851318,
-0.09170767664909363,
-0.28141582012176514,
0.09066706150770187,
-0.16274063289165497,
-0.43849998712539673,
-0.32845789194107056,
-0.29159584641456604,
0.034521378576755524,
0.9922845959663391,
-0.3514973819255829,
-0.028365300968289375,
-0.6807805895805359,
0.594762921333313,
0.22563336789608002,
1.0506430864334106,
-0.053196728229522705,
-0.4506675601005554,
-0.5276926755905151,
-0.19066743552684784,
-0.11296388506889343,
-1.0941262245178223,
0.10107198357582092,
0.4012714922428131,
0.6249086856842041,
0.39897486567497253,
0.01177504938095808,
0.40741127729415894,
-1.141420602798462,
0.4315590560436249,
0.32256898283958435,
-0.9152602553367615,
0.38420143723487854,
-0.3225628137588501,
0.17645728588104248,
0.683517336845398,
0.7864587903022766,
-0.8010911345481873,
-0.30112263560295105,
-0.27716749906539917,
-0.6437351703643799,
0.587934136390686,
-0.26399579644203186,
0.46860671043395996,
-0.1169392317533493,
0.22290796041488647,
0.4473194181919098,
0.06877569109201431,
-0.7952762246131897,
-0.1438547968864441,
-0.293678879737854,
-0.3250180780887604,
-0.6550979018211365,
-0.23667259514331818,
0.2297869175672531,
-0.3196937143802643,
0.8581361174583435,
-0.07080753147602081,
-0.08786288648843765,
-0.23671092092990875,
-0.4385160803794861,
-0.4008794128894806,
0.25704890489578247,
0.38800305128097534,
1.0082919597625732,
-0.09462455660104752,
-0.03061506152153015,
0.049636248499155045,
-0.5724310874938965,
0.26485320925712585,
0.3958801031112671,
-0.5777345895767212,
0.2308391034603119,
0.4244789183139801,
0.5670005679130554,
0.43107056617736816,
-0.7308924198150635,
0.4847387373447418,
-0.026575874537229538,
0.11245250701904297,
-0.20479334890842438,
-0.02749692276120186,
0.3022162914276123,
0.43399518728256226,
0.24623481929302216,
-0.15008145570755005,
-0.06424359977245331,
-0.31887713074684143,
0.3157343864440918,
0.17224085330963135,
-0.5763779282569885,
-0.130644291639328,
0.7511147260665894,
0.20224273204803467,
-0.17066256701946259,
0.6814491748809814,
-0.14742404222488403,
-0.22638024389743805,
0.33783093094825745,
0.2866078019142151,
0.18042966723442078,
-0.38375040888786316,
0.6074464917182922,
0.5113515257835388,
0.8136922717094421,
0.053356073796749115,
0.40326324105262756,
0.10107322782278061,
-0.8241646885871887,
-0.41103455424308777,
-0.8452907800674438,
-0.6143277883529663,
-0.08135776966810226,
-0.550458550453186,
0.3243764638900757,
0.02784905396401882,
0.02979923039674759,
0.34863635897636414,
0.327347993850708,
-0.6245140433311462,
0.4603797197341919,
0.0777871236205101,
1.3227746486663818,
-0.8904730081558228,
0.7284590601921082,
0.5556681752204895,
-0.5465645790100098,
-0.48066890239715576,
-0.11040762811899185,
-0.42562136054039,
-0.44933396577835083,
0.15750207006931305,
0.31275174021720886,
0.2121724784374237,
0.15851223468780518,
-0.13804851472377777,
-0.8009640574455261,
0.8099765181541443,
0.6558092832565308,
-0.3425162136554718,
-0.2876584529876709,
0.08409567177295685,
0.46898558735847473,
0.010653339326381683,
0.23777656257152557,
0.17253167927265167,
0.6691387891769409,
-0.4090135991573334,
-1.1571184396743774,
-0.5160010457038879,
-0.4482206404209137,
-0.5252114534378052,
0.1823793649673462,
-0.6351461410522461,
0.9076570272445679,
-0.30795061588287354,
0.08687767386436462,
0.04098296910524368,
0.6186022758483887,
-0.06272578239440918,
0.43087396025657654,
0.510431170463562,
0.8473101854324341,
1.0406272411346436,
0.11379379034042358,
1.0341600179672241,
-0.4176301062107086,
0.6000240445137024,
0.8338211178779602,
-0.19488589465618134,
1.1637767553329468,
0.22013996541500092,
-0.123201884329319,
0.608597993850708,
0.5146476626396179,
0.03320058435201645,
0.5832138061523438,
0.026305852457880974,
-0.44012171030044556,
-0.26857230067253113,
-0.22473636269569397,
-0.23346439003944397,
0.6479951739311218,
0.10936150699853897,
-0.47307145595550537,
-0.5259655117988586,
0.2546032965183258,
0.05026426538825035,
0.024202656000852585,
-0.4633573293685913,
0.5272567868232727,
-0.11306993663311005,
-0.46097704768180847,
0.34816238284111023,
0.41223078966140747,
0.43477723002433777,
-0.44077008962631226,
0.09936077892780304,
-0.163644939661026,
0.17536437511444092,
-0.15248404443264008,
-0.8688532710075378,
0.22897131741046906,
0.5403916239738464,
-0.8496440649032593,
0.11350398510694504,
0.5073596239089966,
-0.49000629782676697,
-0.9528650045394897,
0.4517267942428589,
0.9120701551437378,
0.38023021817207336,
0.01949336752295494,
-0.34626513719558716,
-0.2435074746608734,
-0.1814303994178772,
-0.32322874665260315,
0.184840127825737,
0.5904678702354431,
0.01229106169193983,
0.6001916527748108,
0.6030691266059875,
0.17069073021411896,
0.19126996397972107,
0.03585715591907501,
0.6080493330955505,
-0.5158838033676147,
-0.6380215883255005,
-0.6935031414031982,
0.37852048873901367,
-0.025689346715807915,
-0.6627731919288635,
0.8099919557571411,
0.59521484375,
0.940824568271637,
0.07189596444368362,
0.84059077501297,
-0.06671631336212158,
0.702048122882843,
-0.09389897435903549,
1.2633836269378662,
-0.8032598495483398,
-0.3205642104148865,
-0.3289627730846405,
-0.9376205205917358,
-0.35900557041168213,
0.5174838900566101,
-0.08452125638723373,
-0.08003252744674683,
0.45417484641075134,
0.35243529081344604,
-0.31643086671829224,
0.09505308419466019,
0.464713990688324,
0.17005734145641327,
-0.055174726992845535,
0.6396772265434265,
0.5424072742462158,
-0.14697831869125366,
0.7587603330612183,
-0.32155099511146545,
-0.4178910553455353,
0.0375853106379509,
-0.8331313133239746,
-0.773494303226471,
-0.4112015664577484,
0.1065056324005127,
-0.27100273966789246,
0.13411381840705872,
0.3581552505493164,
0.47146180272102356,
-1.02122962474823,
-0.09006921201944351,
0.4378165006637573,
0.21480579674243927,
-0.20549625158309937,
-0.17767518758773804,
0.26002463698387146,
-0.1286017745733261,
-0.8413999080657959,
0.5230645537376404,
0.2309889942407608,
-0.41474831104278564,
-0.43295782804489136,
-0.1538228690624237,
-0.35382798314094543,
0.0016887398669496179,
0.41056758165359497,
0.232384592294693,
-0.32192474603652954,
-0.2917177677154541,
0.2695245146751404,
-0.3200642466545105,
-0.16732366383075714,
0.3324895203113556,
-0.3905535638332367,
0.8524431586265564,
0.4116051495075226,
0.4985991418361664,
0.41551119089126587,
-0.3051066994667053,
0.329835444688797,
-0.5027973651885986,
-0.12849369645118713,
0.020101342350244522,
0.30130457878112793,
0.37095481157302856,
-0.33422356843948364,
0.42262977361679077,
0.11132356524467468,
-0.3320831060409546,
-0.4806528389453888,
0.03923051431775093,
-0.5546531081199646,
-0.22960995137691498,
0.6241711378097534,
-0.572715699672699,
-0.08097486197948456,
-0.2574949860572815,
0.15377074480056763,
0.554508626461029,
-0.03981451690196991,
0.8943243026733398,
1.1966062784194946,
0.25147420167922974,
-0.33641931414604187,
-0.6582427620887756,
-0.04508259892463684,
-0.20608219504356384,
-0.7562068104743958,
-0.241348534822464,
0.6248342394828796,
0.5732340812683105,
0.31208404898643494,
0.5012309551239014,
0.1354130506515503,
0.4737837314605713,
0.056543730199337006,
-0.008390629664063454,
-0.06730205565690994,
-0.8084054589271545,
-0.3442496657371521,
0.5462214350700378,
0.010826420970261097,
0.15810014307498932
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.01806v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.01806v1
|
Contextualized Sequence Likelihood: Enhanced Confidence Scores for Natural Language Generation
| 2024-06-03T21:55:07 | 2024-06-03T21:55:07 |
Zhen Lin, Shubhendu Trivedi, Jimeng Sun
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The advent of large language models (LLMs) has dramatically advanced the
state-of-the-art in numerous natural language generation tasks. For LLMs to be
applied reliably, it is essential to have an accurate measure of their
confidence. Currently, the most commonly used confidence score function is the
likelihood of the generated sequence, which, however, conflates semantic and
syntactic components. For instance, in question-answering (QA) tasks, an
awkward phrasing of the correct answer might result in a lower probability
prediction. Additionally, different tokens should be weighted differently
depending on the context. In this work, we propose enhancing the predicted
sequence probability by assigning different weights to various tokens using
attention values elicited from the base LLM. By employing a validation set, we
can identify the relevant attention heads, thereby significantly improving the
reliability of the vanilla sequence probability confidence measure. We refer to
this new score as the Contextualized Sequence Likelihood (CSL). CSL is easy to
implement, fast to compute, and offers considerable potential for further
improvement with task-specific prompts. Across several QA datasets and a
diverse array of LLMs, CSL has demonstrated significantly higher reliability
than state-of-the-art baselines in predicting generation quality, as measured
by the AUROC or AUARC.
|
[
-0.3718775510787964,
-0.8292269706726074,
0.5631376504898071,
0.470795214176178,
-0.28049328923225403,
-0.09590445458889008,
-0.4079139530658722,
-0.261430948972702,
0.06898517161607742,
0.3543032705783844,
-0.4405422508716583,
-0.6128313541412354,
-0.4538540840148926,
0.3119086027145386,
-0.3068564534187317,
0.9592405557632446,
0.41139572858810425,
-0.12652741372585297,
-0.46515771746635437,
0.11086838692426682,
-0.6610202789306641,
-0.5124930739402771,
-0.6157686710357666,
-0.010237482376396656,
0.5816237926483154,
0.2972455620765686,
0.5597691535949707,
0.41669946908950806,
0.4398055970668793,
0.22152741253376007,
-0.06916309893131256,
0.2664763331413269,
-0.3702135682106018,
0.4549967050552368,
-0.08047965168952942,
-0.22580789029598236,
-0.5452449321746826,
-0.2738778591156006,
0.7055865526199341,
0.9661547541618347,
0.006518973037600517,
0.25847646594047546,
0.47156211733818054,
0.5743187665939331,
-0.608156681060791,
0.02067023329436779,
-0.8007411360740662,
-0.0025315259117633104,
-0.02944774739444256,
-0.6975953578948975,
-0.6673409938812256,
-0.4688684046268463,
0.19802270829677582,
-0.46267417073249817,
0.2401346117258072,
-0.005392097402364016,
0.4821895360946655,
0.3103003203868866,
-0.3805687129497528,
0.004759620409458876,
-0.47297680377960205,
0.9195274710655212,
-0.7659273743629456,
0.1345997154712677,
0.08474769443273544,
0.17369109392166138,
-0.3670347034931183,
-0.7358725666999817,
-0.3343568444252014,
-0.2186642289161682,
0.06435296684503555,
0.03266509622335434,
0.19623030722141266,
-0.08026225864887238,
0.32100608944892883,
0.4258838891983032,
-0.5756652355194092,
-0.3119441568851471,
-0.02302004024386406,
-0.2840552031993866,
0.6455979943275452,
0.11044441163539886,
0.09020164608955383,
-0.20685720443725586,
-0.2676331102848053,
-0.15981650352478027,
-0.681298553943634,
0.2042611539363861,
0.2866622507572174,
0.5978801846504211,
0.080543652176857,
0.5324073433876038,
-0.4349469840526581,
0.8189182877540588,
0.5193151831626892,
-0.1732761710882187,
0.38027116656303406,
-0.3230735957622528,
-0.33647286891937256,
0.23582270741462708,
0.6097469329833984,
0.3415946662425995,
0.35670438408851624,
0.0049889422953128815,
0.07030658423900604,
-0.19534994661808014,
0.3771064877510071,
-0.6316264271736145,
0.04635181650519371,
0.43402403593063354,
-0.11573588848114014,
-0.416130930185318,
0.34430256485939026,
-0.5411558747291565,
-0.22349749505519867,
-0.2305375188589096,
0.025789208710193634,
-0.4010375440120697,
0.1734430342912674,
-0.18169334530830383,
0.06902442872524261,
0.26776647567749023,
0.2592398226261139,
-0.7088262438774109,
0.0066574071533977985,
0.544295072555542,
0.5444280505180359,
-0.4186064898967743,
0.01046622171998024,
-0.9667922854423523,
0.10167824476957321,
-0.4082081615924835,
0.5727066397666931,
-0.38142192363739014,
-0.29293859004974365,
0.13127577304840088,
-0.06754163652658463,
0.1570090651512146,
-0.31366389989852905,
0.5888948440551758,
-0.5544204711914062,
0.37678617238998413,
-0.186870276927948,
-0.6119869947433472,
0.0915355235338211,
0.41595029830932617,
-0.4821041524410248,
1.2239835262298584,
0.13862857222557068,
-0.7971295118331909,
0.487020879983902,
-0.21881356835365295,
-0.8202016949653625,
0.2522795796394348,
-0.15138539671897888,
-0.29287925362586975,
0.2501416802406311,
0.28142574429512024,
0.6781639456748962,
-0.26883962750434875,
0.6677301526069641,
-0.3020716607570648,
-0.14190229773521423,
0.5371379852294922,
-0.595416784286499,
0.4352265000343323,
0.20468994975090027,
-0.38815054297447205,
0.14618022739887238,
-0.82264643907547,
0.5113088488578796,
-0.29408127069473267,
-0.6707369089126587,
-0.08202020823955536,
-0.11761502176523209,
0.13304740190505981,
0.35952526330947876,
0.23092201352119446,
-0.36400142312049866,
-0.31731659173965454,
-0.7341576814651489,
0.003316758433356881,
0.5546043515205383,
0.4213475286960602,
0.3752220571041107,
-0.20633165538311005,
0.4670957922935486,
-0.1355731189250946,
-0.11128253489732742,
-0.311614453792572,
-0.7449856400489807,
-0.6068614721298218,
-0.031087679788470268,
0.32797473669052124,
0.528511643409729,
-0.46642011404037476,
0.8730788230895996,
-0.3466310501098633,
-0.334160715341568,
-0.2219342738389969,
0.15118266642093658,
0.3901163339614868,
0.7543438673019409,
0.3727206885814667,
-0.5176903605461121,
-0.6211074590682983,
-0.6504632234573364,
-0.3693721294403076,
0.009123497642576694,
-0.29995056986808777,
0.3112470507621765,
-0.09457871317863464,
0.21371270716190338,
1.236996054649353,
-0.5030308365821838,
-0.06553224474191666,
-0.4391644597053528,
0.13555943965911865,
0.24594004452228546,
0.5173949003219604,
0.19208523631095886,
-0.7133564949035645,
-0.53171306848526,
-0.22242498397827148,
-0.5839593410491943,
-0.19896703958511353,
-0.19759683310985565,
-0.12994398176670074,
0.19970665872097015,
0.45114296674728394,
-0.5000550150871277,
0.3632083535194397,
0.47608107328414917,
-0.33152639865875244,
0.4658624231815338,
-0.059170763939619064,
0.2950921952724457,
-1.2615578174591064,
0.3295561969280243,
0.11099479347467422,
-0.33498725295066833,
-0.6493485569953918,
0.010534655302762985,
-0.03918450325727463,
0.03616727516055107,
-0.5940626859664917,
0.4226955473423004,
-0.23207034170627594,
-0.16764381527900696,
-0.15591035783290863,
0.12787750363349915,
0.04551606997847557,
0.40874990820884705,
0.11775415390729904,
0.5737789869308472,
0.35315653681755066,
-0.6971036791801453,
0.17610742151737213,
0.06362801790237427,
-0.3044992983341217,
0.5809659361839294,
-0.6481411457061768,
0.13138779997825623,
-0.03057926706969738,
0.24226732552051544,
-0.9992933869361877,
-0.4771617650985718,
-0.048331547528505325,
-0.6623880863189697,
0.39567163586616516,
0.3549976944923401,
-0.37801221013069153,
-0.0730728879570961,
-0.14578425884246826,
0.3773709237575531,
0.4492669403553009,
-0.3229405879974365,
0.40237313508987427,
0.204107403755188,
-0.3514975607395172,
-0.7342552542686462,
-0.760143518447876,
0.18567822873592377,
-0.24691078066825867,
-0.6545753479003906,
0.50379478931427,
-0.26508620381355286,
-0.1497446894645691,
-0.1663631945848465,
0.10682518780231476,
0.14926837384700775,
0.24925096333026886,
0.2054063230752945,
0.06706966459751129,
-0.29666104912757874,
0.30190765857696533,
0.11669516563415527,
-0.0967436209321022,
0.04188455268740654,
-0.3837726414203644,
0.41860339045524597,
0.016161225736141205,
-0.14919134974479675,
-0.1735890507698059,
0.37565210461616516,
0.35899120569229126,
-0.1280665397644043,
0.5529822707176208,
0.5010389089584351,
-0.48141875863075256,
-0.2579546868801117,
-0.511012613773346,
-0.29557865858078003,
-0.40279683470726013,
0.33611223101615906,
-0.08825775980949402,
-0.9974814653396606,
0.1800009161233902,
0.09176964312791824,
0.03600911423563957,
0.35477352142333984,
0.6179906725883484,
0.05526832118630409,
0.9978951215744019,
0.4479684829711914,
-0.011537584476172924,
0.1809403896331787,
0.301620751619339,
0.23538322746753693,
-0.6841408014297485,
-0.012475048191845417,
-0.2009662240743637,
-0.06612972170114517,
-0.48498812317848206,
-0.5309232473373413,
0.426806777715683,
0.06919155269861221,
-0.09258263558149338,
0.11034662276506424,
-0.4236831068992615,
0.2814647853374481,
0.6262558698654175,
-0.08319756388664246,
0.2545192539691925,
0.22063276171684265,
-0.23815779387950897,
0.06013631075620651,
-0.6304728388786316,
-0.6821619868278503,
1.2590036392211914,
0.19873633980751038,
0.20849207043647766,
-0.0007722867885604501,
0.6470354199409485,
0.4057007431983948,
0.4452841877937317,
-0.4964691996574402,
0.5803555250167847,
0.022553101181983948,
-0.5706144571304321,
-0.49466177821159363,
-0.32742398977279663,
-0.7480951547622681,
-0.01485788356512785,
-0.3265862762928009,
-0.7451467514038086,
-0.1486668586730957,
0.43883633613586426,
-0.7837320566177368,
-0.28361713886260986,
-0.2845108211040497,
0.8768392205238342,
-0.08072103559970856,
-0.659170925617218,
0.008431976661086082,
-0.7637737989425659,
0.468187153339386,
-0.18226730823516846,
0.05354331433773041,
-0.15068863332271576,
0.1595575511455536,
0.43316778540611267,
-0.3999635875225067,
0.8447233438491821,
-0.019288770854473114,
-0.1983805149793625,
0.6014622449874878,
-0.17379535734653473,
0.5485619902610779,
0.29660671949386597,
-0.1975955218076706,
-0.1907842755317688,
-0.3402484953403473,
-0.18100039660930634,
-0.4314720332622528,
0.9040266275405884,
-0.20860718190670013,
-0.5271444320678711,
-0.35429778695106506,
-0.6298019289970398,
-0.5889919996261597,
0.007514057215303183,
0.4744473695755005,
0.4880552887916565,
-0.2914583384990692,
0.32727155089378357,
0.6147471070289612,
-0.44220295548439026,
0.35089972615242004,
-0.008265790529549122,
0.25982245802879333,
-0.5158218741416931,
0.5822415351867676,
-0.19780559837818146,
0.3825816512107849,
0.5169768929481506,
0.1599186807870865,
-0.3413657546043396,
-0.3082534372806549,
-0.23360727727413177,
-0.31867995858192444,
-0.7535397410392761,
-0.4058436453342438,
-0.5607064962387085,
-0.21865203976631165,
-0.6403700113296509,
-0.27537116408348083,
-0.06395676732063293,
-0.4604954123497009,
-0.3845426142215729,
-0.2786402702331543,
0.16529841721057892,
0.24059303104877472,
0.16502541303634644,
0.15478353202342987,
-0.6600008606910706,
0.11734988540410995,
0.362287700176239,
0.10657578706741333,
-0.09972403943538666,
-0.5678064823150635,
-0.14554950594902039,
-0.11785422265529633,
-0.32257595658302307,
-0.9261190295219421,
0.6307680606842041,
0.29991161823272705,
0.42331621050834656,
0.30227482318878174,
0.11283542960882187,
0.5315415263175964,
-0.5537701845169067,
0.9154753088951111,
0.220639169216156,
-0.8103559613227844,
0.6749657392501831,
-0.24404531717300415,
0.5379687547683716,
0.5614277124404907,
0.05895264446735382,
-0.36309316754341125,
-0.7453501224517822,
-0.6490782499313354,
-1.0355949401855469,
0.32042089104652405,
0.17834629118442535,
0.18382425606250763,
-0.49850955605506897,
0.39719897508621216,
0.03719023987650871,
0.30553919076919556,
-0.6212034821510315,
-0.2433554232120514,
-0.09326189011335373,
-0.6923509836196899,
-0.2596849799156189,
-0.30082690715789795,
0.10788562893867493,
-0.04309295117855072,
0.8177616000175476,
-0.455549955368042,
0.020049797371029854,
0.4181784391403198,
-0.19061218202114105,
-0.23040330410003662,
0.47309356927871704,
0.6081053614616394,
0.5784375667572021,
-0.25831446051597595,
0.14416974782943726,
0.3415397107601166,
-0.30655795335769653,
0.06633290648460388,
0.03596704080700874,
-0.3109373450279236,
0.05401492491364479,
0.36460527777671814,
0.6224820017814636,
0.4760710895061493,
-0.8432220220565796,
0.5239330530166626,
0.12779559195041656,
-0.04498802497982979,
-0.4700179994106293,
0.053116071969270706,
0.08917228132486343,
0.035450831055641174,
0.5799539685249329,
0.04135952889919281,
0.2608232796192169,
-0.34958717226982117,
0.5353115797042847,
0.37592771649360657,
-0.5636634826660156,
-0.0633402168750763,
0.544677197933197,
0.3604220747947693,
-0.0820828452706337,
0.24727460741996765,
-0.3685733377933502,
-0.21461668610572815,
0.6576845645904541,
0.4870215654373169,
1.0128724575042725,
-0.2894013226032257,
0.09260884672403336,
0.7860351800918579,
0.18160748481750488,
0.023009056225419044,
0.21545401215553284,
-0.057597801089286804,
-0.6772607564926147,
-0.6178848147392273,
-0.8640432357788086,
-0.16058601438999176,
0.11326511949300766,
-0.6191447973251343,
0.09099837392568588,
-0.36527469754219055,
-0.465191513299942,
-0.31130251288414,
-0.12037559598684311,
-0.676129162311554,
0.5665162205696106,
0.42985019087791443,
0.788923442363739,
-0.712889552116394,
0.7422814965248108,
0.5841125249862671,
-0.07948815077543259,
-0.7863242030143738,
0.16429291665554047,
-0.133806511759758,
-0.31611791253089905,
0.6875369548797607,
0.46133291721343994,
0.051326438784599304,
0.1925257444381714,
-0.28237655758857727,
-1.0719956159591675,
1.2143700122833252,
0.21096032857894897,
-0.6600287556648254,
0.12032148241996765,
0.28735578060150146,
0.4640478789806366,
-0.7686138153076172,
0.10712476819753647,
0.5623469352722168,
0.3512928783893585,
0.06916241347789764,
-0.6517983675003052,
0.3648383319377899,
-0.10056295990943909,
0.19081519544124603,
-0.1150217205286026,
-0.035372212529182434,
0.5028262138366699,
-0.4955151081085205,
-0.3453136086463928,
0.23253364861011505,
1.0056535005569458,
0.6400783061981201,
0.2687443196773529,
0.5607714056968689,
0.33406177163124084,
0.8545287251472473,
-0.10815007239580154,
1.1088733673095703,
-0.6070961952209473,
0.02815815433859825,
1.3256312608718872,
-0.29963573813438416,
0.9861544370651245,
0.678299069404602,
0.05406428128480911,
0.5289227962493896,
0.5327664613723755,
0.1676672399044037,
0.45207324624061584,
0.34721997380256653,
-0.2699115574359894,
-0.4871536195278168,
-0.17359325289726257,
-0.1434183120727539,
0.1853690892457962,
0.28013792634010315,
-0.6950536370277405,
0.14545463025569916,
-0.17472374439239502,
-0.34095415472984314,
0.3150789439678192,
-0.28660014271736145,
0.7114508152008057,
0.12229976803064346,
-1.115524411201477,
0.35888075828552246,
0.024830101057887077,
0.5678495764732361,
-0.4748128652572632,
0.020125698298215866,
-0.1339091658592224,
0.05106452852487564,
-0.14090977609157562,
-0.7968655824661255,
0.139137402176857,
0.1673695594072342,
-0.236480712890625,
-0.10801688581705093,
0.7319518327713013,
-0.5815058946609497,
-0.6160407066345215,
-0.04759184643626213,
0.4274388551712036,
-0.09163103997707367,
-0.19239282608032227,
-0.4133799076080322,
-0.1626129001379013,
-0.09602601826190948,
-0.4645964205265045,
0.21853093802928925,
0.3013419806957245,
-0.05106997862458229,
0.49151840806007385,
0.816796600818634,
-0.017408952116966248,
0.13959364593029022,
0.19191332161426544,
0.4599238336086273,
-0.6394686698913574,
-0.5697092413902283,
-0.6498692035675049,
0.7877694368362427,
-0.3760963976383209,
-0.5730984210968018,
0.7451253533363342,
0.4434102773666382,
0.5102248191833496,
-0.21131391823291779,
0.8622543215751648,
-0.02968897856771946,
0.5295570492744446,
-0.5411641597747803,
0.3949151635169983,
-0.33688831329345703,
0.25565046072006226,
-0.3144707679748535,
-1.0325392484664917,
-0.5599125027656555,
0.4776417911052704,
-0.15379562973976135,
0.07108709961175919,
0.7933156490325928,
0.6852487325668335,
0.3176942765712738,
-0.24726784229278564,
0.3883429169654846,
-0.11026250571012497,
0.10016775131225586,
0.7744647860527039,
0.5827566981315613,
-0.3365039527416229,
0.5264552235603333,
-0.24670444428920746,
-0.08335777372121811,
-0.24195806682109833,
-1.2255072593688965,
-0.8039987683296204,
-0.3763035833835602,
-0.5889919996261597,
-0.39060497283935547,
0.04789314046502113,
0.999792218208313,
0.6224753856658936,
-0.969024121761322,
-0.003854484995827079,
-0.3432251214981079,
-0.11749095469713211,
-0.42311063408851624,
-0.29995930194854736,
0.27888813614845276,
-0.7106428742408752,
-0.6366903185844421,
0.5129479169845581,
0.4055631756782532,
-0.07969925552606583,
-0.2261423021554947,
-0.21705441176891327,
-0.0808367133140564,
0.2477167695760727,
0.6939277052879333,
0.2589248716831207,
-0.8721557259559631,
-0.5199841260910034,
0.06276364624500275,
-0.3553730249404907,
-0.04245375096797943,
0.6004489660263062,
-0.9562954902648926,
0.2138095647096634,
0.5658462047576904,
0.6786543726921082,
-0.0026071839965879917,
0.2686622142791748,
1.0750789642333984,
-1.3243203163146973,
-0.14932510256767273,
0.2873650789260864,
0.44808703660964966,
0.7968334555625916,
-0.4926489293575287,
0.40112361311912537,
0.056037504225969315,
-0.32529282569885254,
-0.6442163586616516,
0.2043658345937729,
-1.0877470970153809,
-0.049688637256622314,
1.2761704921722412,
-0.15030285716056824,
-0.1887809783220291,
0.012984855100512505,
-0.057881951332092285,
0.3318556845188141,
-0.33763977885246277,
0.6706625819206238,
0.4873793125152588,
0.208585724234581,
0.01980941742658615,
-0.3715604841709137,
0.8058091402053833,
0.6411004662513733,
-0.9100169539451599,
0.032294370234012604,
0.5257655382156372,
0.25235578417778015,
0.29265180230140686,
0.379611998796463,
-0.09546197950839996,
0.4765343964099884,
-0.404988169670105,
0.14839884638786316,
0.19273686408996582,
-0.22354736924171448,
-0.3520628809928894,
0.5808857679367065,
0.1712876260280609,
0.0343443937599659
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.01789v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.01789v1
|
AI-based Classification of Customer Support Tickets: State of the Art and Implementation with AutoML
| 2024-06-03T21:13:02 | 2024-06-03T21:13:02 |
Mario Truss, Stephan Boehm
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.HC, I.2; I.2.7; K.6
|
Automation of support ticket classification is crucial to improve customer
support performance and shortening resolution time for customer inquiries. This
research aims to test the applicability of automated machine learning (AutoML)
as a technology to train a machine learning model (ML model) that can classify
support tickets. The model evaluation conducted in this research shows that
AutoML can be used to train ML models with good classification performance.
Moreover, this paper fills a research gap by providing new insights into
developing AI solutions without a dedicated professional by utilizing AutoML,
which makes this technology more accessible for companies without specialized
AI departments and staff.
|
[
-0.39776337146759033,
-0.29303258657455444,
0.10863972455263138,
0.14529584348201752,
0.0543239526450634,
-0.012074381113052368,
0.2698585093021393,
-0.6591676473617554,
-0.3284749388694763,
0.30722376704216003,
-0.747062087059021,
-0.11527474224567413,
-0.3226233720779419,
0.2201971560716629,
-0.747770369052887,
0.908019483089447,
-0.29390817880630493,
0.48762571811676025,
-0.6053927540779114,
-0.20876218378543854,
-0.3716770112514496,
-0.9083722829818726,
-0.8203852772712708,
-0.24319438636302948,
0.33257484436035156,
0.30269762873649597,
0.3207390606403351,
0.39686793088912964,
0.7792226076126099,
0.4422876238822937,
0.3987763822078705,
0.20379844307899475,
0.29116424918174744,
0.20628994703292847,
0.12130168825387955,
-0.7527068257331848,
-0.46348804235458374,
0.39387047290802,
0.33802899718284607,
0.40092331171035767,
-0.5802525877952576,
0.3510127365589142,
0.12850914895534515,
0.377399742603302,
-0.42067134380340576,
0.42122745513916016,
-0.6237033009529114,
0.37320059537887573,
0.25533047318458557,
-0.16280414164066315,
-0.5237887501716614,
-0.2508676052093506,
0.1336652636528015,
-0.6827900409698486,
0.20473699271678925,
0.35602208971977234,
1.0378549098968506,
0.8130109310150146,
-0.02742825821042061,
-0.5425782799720764,
-0.828337550163269,
0.6468208432197571,
-0.507794976234436,
0.1409277468919754,
0.11434019356966019,
1.0850099325180054,
0.03870370239019394,
-0.4762008786201477,
-0.6740862727165222,
-0.13376466929912567,
-0.22276854515075684,
0.05373133718967438,
0.06332143396139145,
-0.039680059999227524,
0.23367945849895477,
0.2177639901638031,
-0.8251310586929321,
0.3498961329460144,
-0.20293307304382324,
-0.15875090658664703,
0.774482786655426,
0.6467354893684387,
0.24177119135856628,
0.17436327040195465,
-0.4305521845817566,
0.01452962588518858,
-0.0796506479382515,
0.03224648907780647,
-0.16345252096652985,
0.09587784111499786,
0.07683008164167404,
0.11644524335861206,
-0.15013745427131653,
0.94828861951828,
0.09328076988458633,
-0.08039501309394836,
0.1945265680551529,
0.11690737307071686,
-0.7866373658180237,
0.08081526309251785,
0.6141759157180786,
0.12546968460083008,
0.38427820801734924,
-0.13872618973255157,
-0.4034201204776764,
0.008222607895731926,
0.32053470611572266,
-0.5501809120178223,
-0.12059679627418518,
-0.0351715050637722,
-0.6645904779434204,
-0.3442135751247406,
0.2075081616640091,
-0.5146740674972534,
-0.6233338117599487,
-0.7954202890396118,
0.28356170654296875,
-0.044235989451408386,
-0.4703710675239563,
-0.38609275221824646,
0.023132825270295143,
0.5653630495071411,
0.7394142150878906,
-0.5525959730148315,
0.19812379777431488,
0.7274087071418762,
0.6108107566833496,
-0.31809547543525696,
-0.36178699135780334,
-0.19332122802734375,
-0.015469660982489586,
-0.4011099636554718,
1.044965147972107,
-0.28070011734962463,
-0.23700080811977386,
0.029100919142365456,
0.16648003458976746,
-0.4580676555633545,
-0.8970938324928284,
0.20771892368793488,
-0.6693158745765686,
0.3468252122402191,
0.46827518939971924,
-0.7726484537124634,
-0.33367905020713806,
0.42509686946868896,
-0.510613739490509,
0.6291640996932983,
0.4531097114086151,
-0.15683861076831818,
0.8242892026901245,
-0.7982931733131409,
-0.23512202501296997,
0.3616497218608856,
-0.18838649988174438,
-0.7830958366394043,
-0.12519009411334991,
-0.12948748469352722,
0.4700252413749695,
0.05391540750861168,
0.07083763927221298,
-0.42753711342811584,
-0.3502545654773712,
0.11524595320224762,
-0.2804516553878784,
0.6637834906578064,
0.6532144546508789,
-0.6100673079490662,
0.07734590023756027,
-0.8376073837280273,
-0.16085965931415558,
0.11200042814016342,
-0.48426780104637146,
-0.08636106550693512,
-0.10743675380945206,
0.30781906843185425,
0.24839133024215698,
0.020709866657853127,
-0.324443519115448,
0.27474135160446167,
-0.3903060257434845,
-0.08255667239427567,
0.6520731449127197,
-0.2502930462360382,
0.5823685526847839,
-0.20643746852874756,
0.5822033882141113,
0.2278781682252884,
0.7146931886672974,
0.05734293535351753,
-0.6949576735496521,
-0.967504620552063,
0.1053905263543129,
0.3124774098396301,
0.8027805089950562,
-0.4725804030895233,
0.3724488615989685,
0.22162966430187225,
-0.5123478174209595,
-0.7480983734130859,
0.13255082070827484,
-0.006154760252684355,
0.725824773311615,
0.3499191403388977,
-0.12666644155979156,
-0.7648040652275085,
-0.8853359222412109,
0.05730205029249191,
-0.5175926089286804,
0.1784624308347702,
0.5104064345359802,
0.050415895879268646,
-0.47939229011535645,
1.0581119060516357,
-0.3576873540878296,
-0.7059529423713684,
-0.1669796258211136,
0.16523724794387817,
0.11691859364509583,
0.528948962688446,
0.67597496509552,
-1.0540542602539062,
-0.8111629486083984,
0.032854847609996796,
-0.9837520122528076,
0.03363709896802902,
0.008713185787200928,
0.1785925328731537,
1.202496886253357,
0.2764616310596466,
-0.24563635885715485,
1.074691891670227,
0.22920727729797363,
-0.5854253172874451,
0.13553838431835175,
-0.33675140142440796,
0.34597983956336975,
-0.6858286261558533,
0.14490611851215363,
-0.09641646593809128,
-0.28479450941085815,
-0.7135594487190247,
-0.5152742862701416,
0.1587812751531601,
-0.41411882638931274,
-0.14467701315879822,
0.24445044994354248,
-0.2190314531326294,
-0.24692952632904053,
-0.9082635045051575,
-0.5434127449989319,
-0.1864439845085144,
0.31657081842422485,
0.20762744545936584,
0.6057577729225159,
0.5726585388183594,
-0.9146468639373779,
0.6951995491981506,
0.19098497927188873,
-0.21855376660823822,
0.6733033657073975,
-0.18608617782592773,
-0.14097756147384644,
-0.1831187754869461,
0.13266386091709137,
-1.0624152421951294,
-0.2372705191373825,
0.547198474407196,
-0.5324093699455261,
0.4412165880203247,
-0.15027692914009094,
-0.40107277035713196,
-0.572037935256958,
0.6709721088409424,
-0.10928734391927719,
0.779329776763916,
-0.39316487312316895,
0.7732588052749634,
0.5636151432991028,
0.12123434990644455,
-0.3234972357749939,
-0.47570136189460754,
0.08311765640974045,
-0.28543686866760254,
-0.3412562310695648,
0.043181583285331726,
0.04136811941862106,
-0.2971874177455902,
0.0251487884670496,
0.14312998950481415,
-0.43099096417427063,
0.4933610260486603,
0.5486828088760376,
0.007109099067747593,
-0.10894934087991714,
0.42648226022720337,
-0.43287232518196106,
-0.4583723545074463,
0.07987765222787857,
-0.36380645632743835,
0.34172701835632324,
-0.09026078134775162,
-0.28276926279067993,
-0.8513435125350952,
0.3922910690307617,
0.7648690938949585,
0.08360885828733444,
0.7759560346603394,
0.5793924927711487,
-0.429638534784317,
-0.4433097839355469,
-0.6162245869636536,
-0.24707339704036713,
-0.4921974539756775,
0.05227448418736458,
-0.21091915667057037,
-0.26585811376571655,
0.2926816940307617,
0.10696475207805634,
0.017085000872612,
0.4975433945655823,
0.4832193851470947,
-0.3385215699672699,
1.1691442728042603,
0.7691922783851624,
-0.459303617477417,
0.3658028841018677,
-0.14221139252185822,
-0.03344599902629852,
0.042169682681560516,
-0.5095048546791077,
-0.811424732208252,
-0.11694671213626862,
-0.16827356815338135,
0.052662067115306854,
0.3430185317993164,
-0.2189994901418686,
-0.16555899381637573,
0.34090104699134827,
-0.6871482729911804,
-0.012934776023030281,
0.48254314064979553,
-0.10888257622718811,
0.17093928158283234,
-0.021341634914278984,
0.15593503415584564,
0.35258495807647705,
-0.6524221301078796,
-0.35654085874557495,
0.6786428093910217,
0.49721652269363403,
0.699091911315918,
-0.30473265051841736,
0.28806790709495544,
0.6394299268722534,
0.7261611819267273,
-0.46142399311065674,
0.38713717460632324,
0.09296638518571854,
-0.7301323413848877,
-0.3715384304523468,
-0.2763823866844177,
-0.7006696462631226,
-0.35950496792793274,
-0.1195513978600502,
-0.10814978182315826,
0.21330459415912628,
0.37969255447387695,
-0.3740313947200775,
0.18888480961322784,
-0.9248752593994141,
0.830278217792511,
-0.4304502606391907,
0.4183734953403473,
-0.13358929753303528,
-0.3895450830459595,
-0.1662130504846573,
-0.22531935572624207,
0.12667378783226013,
0.11355079710483551,
-0.09979002177715302,
0.9190158843994141,
-0.6925225257873535,
0.6334015727043152,
-0.721013605594635,
-0.04573514685034752,
0.37873104214668274,
-0.2772258520126343,
0.36847203969955444,
-0.21276932954788208,
-0.13134139776229858,
0.02873830311000347,
-0.24675096571445465,
-0.21363481879234314,
-1.0647194385528564,
0.3956502676010132,
-0.8146588206291199,
-0.570712685585022,
-0.32712072134017944,
-0.2710326015949249,
-0.30240097641944885,
-0.10349840670824051,
-0.10957731306552887,
0.1080145314335823,
0.5613476634025574,
-0.2512604296207428,
0.4210680425167084,
-0.09563804417848587,
0.892555832862854,
0.8137149214744568,
-0.3039867877960205,
-0.248799130320549,
0.6954565644264221,
0.4753091037273407,
-0.300428569316864,
0.15596865117549896,
-0.023786325007677078,
-0.39117416739463806,
-0.7570763826370239,
-0.8901730179786682,
-0.08011572062969208,
-0.664745032787323,
-0.32449135184288025,
-0.7351021766662598,
-0.3236142694950104,
-0.7005825042724609,
0.25110360980033875,
-0.1344456970691681,
-0.368691623210907,
-0.36064866185188293,
-0.038101788610219955,
0.4217718541622162,
0.982325553894043,
0.1376885324716568,
0.21438702940940857,
-0.6908584237098694,
-0.27071624994277954,
0.3074030876159668,
0.6145759224891663,
0.10694368183612823,
-0.36552315950393677,
-0.7032652497291565,
-0.6105361580848694,
-0.24069896340370178,
-0.8009825944900513,
0.32301416993141174,
0.20985014736652374,
1.0481233596801758,
0.596619188785553,
0.18870003521442413,
0.6901074647903442,
-0.4467482566833496,
0.6560782790184021,
0.007105896715074778,
-0.7205609679222107,
0.696506679058075,
-0.01465687807649374,
-0.27599745988845825,
0.4679039418697357,
0.7376717329025269,
-0.3423751890659332,
-0.17833523452281952,
-0.5316751599311829,
-0.471379816532135,
0.9245169162750244,
-0.18620772659778595,
-0.1969565749168396,
0.5277119874954224,
0.5548524260520935,
0.06749914586544037,
0.29053404927253723,
-0.468328595161438,
-0.32954245805740356,
-0.20829610526561737,
-0.48679184913635254,
-0.1885310709476471,
0.1478821486234665,
0.39957699179649353,
-0.4121629595756531,
0.5872277617454529,
-0.1765299141407013,
0.5072556138038635,
0.3187934458255768,
0.01759900338947773,
-0.36075520515441895,
-0.27665284276008606,
0.6084946393966675,
0.6212742328643799,
-0.006884652655571699,
-0.31230732798576355,
0.37070977687835693,
-0.24264948070049286,
0.14212225377559662,
0.166046604514122,
0.012346754781901836,
0.17833475768566132,
-0.013886561617255211,
0.46097245812416077,
-0.3768497109413147,
-0.4599403738975525,
0.505488932132721,
-0.23299004137516022,
-0.3626389801502228,
-0.9040228724479675,
0.47555169463157654,
-0.4078744053840637,
0.17148685455322266,
0.6571593284606934,
0.14713698625564575,
0.40864843130111694,
-0.33147773146629333,
0.6412946581840515,
0.46652740240097046,
-0.8032392263412476,
0.20520612597465515,
0.4922582805156708,
0.24077081680297852,
-0.836764395236969,
0.5760352611541748,
-0.14425033330917358,
-0.7170596718788147,
0.8288918137550354,
0.19714027643203735,
0.8541516661643982,
-0.6086543202400208,
-0.10502415150403976,
0.1430264115333557,
-0.04250049591064453,
0.3452848196029663,
0.1451348215341568,
-0.058576975017786026,
-0.4136861264705658,
-0.18793049454689026,
-0.5884965658187866,
-0.5232329368591309,
0.02053471840918064,
-0.5226975083351135,
0.414050430059433,
-0.47776469588279724,
-0.04193898290395737,
-0.215685173869133,
0.04898957163095474,
-0.4356326460838318,
0.5831528306007385,
0.46691641211509705,
1.234571933746338,
-0.6353896856307983,
0.8796858191490173,
0.9620012044906616,
-0.3396841287612915,
-0.9893238544464111,
-0.2083463817834854,
-0.022580387070775032,
-0.6011713743209839,
1.1633565425872803,
0.3112439215183258,
0.3962783217430115,
0.00467263488098979,
-0.4365367591381073,
-0.469776451587677,
1.090200662612915,
-0.5062373876571655,
-0.47026926279067993,
-0.11803333461284637,
0.46484267711639404,
0.5536565184593201,
-0.7869253754615784,
0.5432202219963074,
0.269404798746109,
0.4245270788669586,
-0.09555234760046005,
-1.0288792848587036,
-0.21911807358264923,
-0.34837013483047485,
-0.2041359841823578,
-0.008312756195664406,
-0.5602691769599915,
0.7308343648910522,
0.4711989164352417,
-0.14008136093616486,
-0.10449035465717316,
0.5866347551345825,
-0.14362306892871857,
0.9128806591033936,
0.9745010733604431,
0.6625828146934509,
0.7702864408493042,
-0.09530957788228989,
0.8419428467750549,
-0.2995613217353821,
0.3909261226654053,
0.4595198333263397,
-0.3466161787509918,
0.48785269260406494,
0.2350139170885086,
-0.10046952217817307,
0.7258262634277344,
0.7837483882904053,
-0.45131006836891174,
0.41871190071105957,
0.41152626276016235,
-0.11443702131509781,
-0.48047325015068054,
0.1453109234571457,
-0.288915753364563,
0.5270639657974243,
0.31204795837402344,
-0.4425089359283447,
-0.13920068740844727,
0.5371792912483215,
-0.3955789804458618,
-0.22977690398693085,
-0.7250060439109802,
1.293898344039917,
-0.020918169990181923,
-0.8420130610466003,
0.45006847381591797,
-0.2348860651254654,
0.5128734111785889,
-0.17546485364437103,
-0.15464867651462555,
-0.15183812379837036,
0.7126767039299011,
-0.3508051931858063,
-0.33305829763412476,
0.7269802093505859,
0.21621175110340118,
-0.27910763025283813,
-0.20565690100193024,
0.9496222138404846,
0.0782395601272583,
-0.3726145029067993,
0.3212846517562866,
0.23571257293224335,
0.17358872294425964,
0.0166385006159544,
-1.0981545448303223,
-0.44863763451576233,
-0.2525831162929535,
-0.07474863529205322,
0.33887457847595215,
0.35656607151031494,
-0.05549793690443039,
0.959555983543396,
0.42090627551078796,
-0.16450084745883942,
0.04317707195878029,
-0.0394887775182724,
0.7720112204551697,
-0.6203187704086304,
-0.6252262592315674,
-0.8952193260192871,
0.7042763829231262,
-0.3159838318824768,
-0.07039791345596313,
0.7985631227493286,
0.5573632121086121,
0.5739185810089111,
-0.1847681701183319,
0.9015615582466125,
0.2568311095237732,
1.0010820627212524,
-0.22919288277626038,
1.0954314470291138,
-0.7084067463874817,
0.15877309441566467,
-0.06441193073987961,
-0.2408023327589035,
-0.5009440183639526,
0.5867034196853638,
-0.2543494999408722,
-0.06209510937333107,
0.35101786255836487,
0.6272361278533936,
0.24343733489513397,
0.29149922728538513,
0.28864187002182007,
-0.17115125060081482,
0.38956624269485474,
0.484160840511322,
1.2578214406967163,
-0.5421410202980042,
0.8771802186965942,
-0.19819855690002441,
-0.40914666652679443,
-0.7014111876487732,
-0.3821541666984558,
-0.9171136021614075,
-0.5813572406768799,
-0.49236810207366943,
-0.542490541934967,
-0.009117874316871166,
0.8570602536201477,
1.0984784364700317,
-1.1311986446380615,
-0.2928367257118225,
-0.3098543584346771,
0.16366271674633026,
-0.18031583726406097,
-0.2631593644618988,
0.14776943624019623,
-1.009514570236206,
-0.7163205146789551,
0.030605897307395935,
0.10939902812242508,
0.41965609788894653,
-0.4339624345302582,
-0.2904667854309082,
0.2934863567352295,
-0.2426399141550064,
0.20187143981456757,
0.09797447919845581,
-0.23602497577667236,
0.16566526889801025,
0.2781841456890106,
-0.16041791439056396,
0.05475737154483795,
0.7607135772705078,
-0.9467211961746216,
-0.09844829142093658,
0.46818217635154724,
0.9617296457290649,
0.007380309514701366,
0.05115431919693947,
0.7027305364608765,
-0.29759740829467773,
-0.054041117429733276,
0.2526029646396637,
0.39514511823654175,
-0.09475666284561157,
-0.6300332546234131,
0.5844168663024902,
0.5863666534423828,
-0.8972258567810059,
-0.8037344813346863,
0.1087508425116539,
-0.7392070293426514,
-0.443454384803772,
0.9804468750953674,
-0.33808988332748413,
-0.3942059278488159,
-0.8297980427742004,
-0.1253698617219925,
0.29240483045578003,
-0.035231661051511765,
0.8741466999053955,
0.3505692183971405,
-0.5432669520378113,
-0.5029321908950806,
-0.19127462804317474,
1.0072686672210693,
0.14568419754505157,
-1.0758578777313232,
-0.39303985238075256,
0.16491760313510895,
0.059811193495988846,
0.432446151971817,
0.31390678882598877,
0.05663037672638893,
0.33848482370376587,
-0.30791017413139343,
-0.06017554551362991,
-0.3007352352142334,
-0.5497602224349976,
-0.5359333753585815,
0.4862222969532013,
0.05778743699193001,
-0.4284425377845764
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.