id
stringlengths 33
33
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
33
| title
stringlengths 13
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 6
16.6k
| category_primary
stringclasses 60
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
132
| abstract
stringlengths 123
1.99k
| embeddings
listlengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.04625v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.04625v2
|
Key-Element-Informed sLLM Tuning for Document Summarization
| 2024-06-07T04:19:01 | 2024-06-26T02:22:11 |
Sangwon Ryu, Heejin Do, Yunsu Kim, Gary Geunbae Lee, Jungseul Ok
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Remarkable advances in large language models (LLMs) have enabled high-quality
text summarization. However, this capability is currently accessible only
through LLMs of substantial size or proprietary LLMs with usage fees. In
response, smaller-scale LLMs (sLLMs) of easy accessibility and low costs have
been extensively studied, yet they often suffer from missing key information
and entities, i.e., low relevance, in particular, when input documents are
long. We hence propose a key-element-informed instruction tuning for
summarization, so-called KEITSum, which identifies key elements in documents
and instructs sLLM to generate summaries capturing these key elements.
Experimental results on dialogue and news datasets demonstrate that sLLM with
KEITSum indeed provides high-quality summarization with higher relevance and
less hallucinations, competitive to proprietary LLM.
|
[
-0.20634479820728302,
-0.3313820958137512,
0.8865763545036316,
-0.08826436847448349,
-0.5893490314483643,
0.22579848766326904,
-0.2961950898170471,
-0.3183821737766266,
0.36355945467948914,
0.6504102945327759,
-0.6425561904907227,
-0.8814047574996948,
-0.6102770566940308,
0.0028960343915969133,
-0.16797186434268951,
1.2495129108428955,
0.2688557207584381,
0.053725190460681915,
-0.3769941031932831,
-0.2670247256755829,
-0.36415016651153564,
-0.13590916991233826,
-0.5114136934280396,
-0.44269001483917236,
0.6848254799842834,
0.5990967750549316,
0.7844361662864685,
0.686903178691864,
0.6413139700889587,
0.21220465004444122,
-0.3526627719402313,
0.34044137597084045,
-0.5684319138526917,
0.23412176966667175,
-0.08642725646495819,
-0.8884981870651245,
-0.7838573455810547,
-0.13814124464988708,
0.7686027884483337,
0.7767038941383362,
0.3781002461910248,
0.14567632973194122,
0.10684163123369217,
0.8759213089942932,
-0.6647792458534241,
0.17029033601284027,
-0.6771164536476135,
0.04201822355389595,
-0.06846199184656143,
-0.2542697787284851,
-0.4847577214241028,
-0.43512386083602905,
0.031201213598251343,
-0.6176849007606506,
0.30276134610176086,
0.17751094698905945,
0.7038655877113342,
0.47914135456085205,
-0.3580627739429474,
-0.42841678857803345,
-0.41724511981010437,
0.611607015132904,
-1.101696252822876,
0.26040589809417725,
0.46938201785087585,
0.006234442815184593,
-0.05966014042496681,
-0.5951210260391235,
0.0104637760668993,
0.016749508678913116,
-0.3731711804866791,
0.18161550164222717,
0.3466006815433502,
0.3899913430213928,
0.3078896999359131,
0.251554936170578,
-0.5455568432807922,
0.3895120620727539,
-0.31403082609176636,
-0.24284802377223969,
0.6069663166999817,
0.5277682542800903,
-0.10298947244882584,
-0.039137862622737885,
0.16067859530448914,
0.12282639741897583,
-0.7942842841148376,
-0.3462667167186737,
0.16180498898029327,
0.3023269474506378,
-0.2420967072248459,
0.4870847165584564,
-0.2548205554485321,
0.583950400352478,
0.0031524088699370623,
-0.5813019871711731,
0.05004376173019409,
-0.3527644872665405,
-0.16434697806835175,
0.4789043962955475,
0.4413413405418396,
0.5518474578857422,
-0.030128128826618195,
-0.26780903339385986,
-0.2563295364379883,
-0.19864703714847565,
0.14656080305576324,
-1.0340020656585693,
-0.1052774116396904,
0.0746379867196083,
-0.5614070296287537,
-0.403825968503952,
0.006148224696516991,
-0.7260724902153015,
-0.48347243666648865,
-0.26495322585105896,
0.40310198068618774,
-0.23867270350456238,
0.034550368785858154,
-0.23002828657627106,
-0.2922695279121399,
0.2025333046913147,
0.5330848693847656,
-0.8057368397712708,
0.18683238327503204,
0.7636405229568481,
1.0819261074066162,
-0.31463220715522766,
-0.23012197017669678,
-0.7453984022140503,
0.23406243324279785,
-0.5662450790405273,
0.7765018343925476,
-0.5364750027656555,
-0.7071237564086914,
-0.16262012720108032,
-0.15862342715263367,
0.22212807834148407,
-0.41786059737205505,
0.31572291254997253,
-0.5647798180580139,
0.10447145998477936,
-0.44036635756492615,
-0.7248608469963074,
-0.05342938378453255,
-0.0427858829498291,
-0.5702124238014221,
0.9247217178344727,
0.19794121384620667,
-0.7146697044372559,
0.3073456287384033,
-0.6287288665771484,
-0.904384970664978,
0.06058524176478386,
-0.22562314569950104,
-0.6001067161560059,
0.5595024824142456,
0.23982249200344086,
0.530816376209259,
-0.1940414011478424,
0.07443299144506454,
-0.18879584968090057,
-0.6214315295219421,
0.15436148643493652,
-0.279937207698822,
0.22440525889396667,
0.26560142636299133,
-0.13964511454105377,
0.08693673461675644,
-0.7951191663742065,
-0.1578395813703537,
-0.04779248684644699,
-0.23458267748355865,
-0.5958894491195679,
-0.11774910986423492,
-0.3058122992515564,
-0.08097540587186813,
0.4013919532299042,
-0.1179775521159172,
0.038348402827978134,
-0.6245095133781433,
0.3389386832714081,
0.7608095407485962,
0.2808194160461426,
0.6866253018379211,
-0.5733996033668518,
0.5217396020889282,
0.001828931039199233,
-0.2100851833820343,
-0.6574819087982178,
-0.18715238571166992,
-0.9500234723091125,
-0.2519214153289795,
0.4093373715877533,
0.08757112175226212,
-0.5541790127754211,
0.46527189016342163,
-0.43918856978416443,
-0.45803195238113403,
-0.7025704979896545,
0.04604153707623482,
0.31424155831336975,
0.4218734800815582,
0.046735018491744995,
-0.061404403299093246,
-0.3171570301055908,
-0.8275219202041626,
-0.12679342925548553,
0.02906273864209652,
0.05828263610601425,
0.29484671354293823,
0.5079038143157959,
0.10408476740121841,
1.0289573669433594,
-0.8496233224868774,
-0.38944077491760254,
-0.4228612780570984,
0.4864256680011749,
0.1878753900527954,
0.08769837766885757,
0.2866254448890686,
-0.6480379700660706,
-0.49866411089897156,
-0.13658472895622253,
-0.4924411475658417,
-0.4460410177707672,
-0.33782631158828735,
0.015746096149086952,
0.1962796002626419,
0.7621356844902039,
-0.46761950850486755,
0.3281756341457367,
0.12268602102994919,
-0.09501632302999496,
0.31238415837287903,
-0.5148003101348877,
-0.006724943406879902,
-1.385640025138855,
0.13429005444049835,
-0.26522430777549744,
-0.5619715452194214,
-0.41730087995529175,
0.08395826816558838,
0.412177711725235,
-0.41005653142929077,
-0.35399994254112244,
0.395433634519577,
-0.7098174095153809,
-0.5205727815628052,
-0.626365602016449,
0.4882611036300659,
0.20133502781391144,
0.6364611387252808,
-0.05880270153284073,
1.0431424379348755,
0.037916556000709534,
-0.7141846418380737,
-0.2215886414051056,
-0.009053275920450687,
-0.27186518907546997,
0.5410633087158203,
-0.5926381349563599,
0.10157673805952072,
-0.5150471925735474,
0.17046336829662323,
-0.7595845460891724,
-0.3221797049045563,
-0.20937477052211761,
-0.22904351353645325,
0.5648031234741211,
-0.008632981218397617,
-0.3985072076320648,
0.29957225918769836,
-0.670078456401825,
0.062318235635757446,
0.497443825006485,
-0.3050262928009033,
0.745092511177063,
0.32411664724349976,
-0.5472886562347412,
-0.22391654551029205,
-0.500245213508606,
0.011268223635852337,
-0.16394855082035065,
-0.26052865386009216,
0.4789758026599884,
-0.1364469677209854,
-0.12273968756198883,
0.17102959752082825,
-0.39611390233039856,
0.25542452931404114,
0.46794357895851135,
0.31122732162475586,
0.2871924638748169,
-0.35791653394699097,
0.3090604245662689,
0.5274030566215515,
-0.3996184468269348,
-0.13966301083564758,
0.015814928337931633,
0.3219169080257416,
0.12001698464155197,
-0.28659239411354065,
-0.1810121387243271,
0.49136099219322205,
0.9267002940177917,
-0.23642422258853912,
0.400130957365036,
0.5109484195709229,
-0.23777395486831665,
-0.21621784567832947,
-0.44449448585510254,
-0.3205507695674896,
-0.4218734800815582,
0.6370769143104553,
-0.06805048882961273,
-1.0711755752563477,
0.42042291164398193,
-0.32958295941352844,
0.337765634059906,
0.5942825078964233,
0.518476665019989,
-0.299868643283844,
1.0700536966323853,
0.5935797095298767,
-0.6200002431869507,
0.3857189416885376,
-0.1248885989189148,
0.029976455494761467,
-0.9770745635032654,
0.07616996020078659,
-0.7100527286529541,
-0.6421619653701782,
-0.394801527261734,
-0.19064593315124512,
0.9276242256164551,
-0.0598931685090065,
0.12211664021015167,
-0.023747483268380165,
-0.23367127776145935,
0.8705752491950989,
0.44662201404571533,
-0.08993818610906601,
0.6298109292984009,
-0.42247381806373596,
-0.07776438444852829,
-0.1085742935538292,
-0.6784677505493164,
-0.30326101183891296,
1.0064730644226074,
0.2733592987060547,
1.1138134002685547,
0.021206479519605637,
0.8819662928581238,
0.5262219309806824,
0.08646814525127411,
-0.8532916903495789,
0.608600378036499,
-0.17896710336208344,
-0.18315698206424713,
-0.3185087740421295,
-0.3149939775466919,
-0.8041841983795166,
0.33000195026397705,
-0.12758594751358032,
-0.5450955033302307,
-0.10241562128067017,
-0.10220348834991455,
-0.5645822882652283,
-0.20220403373241425,
-0.4899323582649231,
0.3731704652309418,
-0.188251793384552,
0.08464130759239197,
-0.455228716135025,
-0.707261860370636,
0.3552340865135193,
-0.1772327870130539,
0.2478756606578827,
-0.39264345169067383,
-0.3329760730266571,
0.691782534122467,
-0.6273778080940247,
0.9301379323005676,
0.14130845665931702,
-0.12040466070175171,
-0.32161229848861694,
-0.16410791873931885,
0.8102824091911316,
0.23178201913833618,
0.09869062155485153,
-0.1774766445159912,
-0.25794631242752075,
-0.037384454160928726,
-0.8211460709571838,
0.9580044746398926,
-0.7692645788192749,
-0.6357883810997009,
-0.41571444272994995,
-0.731221616268158,
-0.18656720221042633,
0.31397950649261475,
0.5542781949043274,
0.5022159814834595,
0.0662795901298523,
0.42428165674209595,
1.1262646913528442,
0.1403224617242813,
0.5645508766174316,
0.8553732633590698,
-0.1874866783618927,
-0.4717619717121124,
1.0038280487060547,
0.34478259086608887,
0.25138044357299805,
0.5064494013786316,
0.13071787357330322,
-0.07809709757566452,
-0.6693527698516846,
-0.3269002437591553,
0.3568170666694641,
-0.7568291425704956,
-0.5050534009933472,
-0.5662007927894592,
-0.3697430193424225,
-0.45235109329223633,
-0.5309768319129944,
-0.2607189118862152,
-0.5257729291915894,
-0.6542174220085144,
-0.10848779231309891,
0.30788716673851013,
0.5130370259284973,
0.34627604484558105,
0.44821441173553467,
-1.001083493232727,
0.4704747200012207,
0.08099203556776047,
0.30942726135253906,
-0.1252395063638687,
-0.5536177158355713,
-0.6889410614967346,
-0.1416579782962799,
-0.15965873003005981,
-0.9420435428619385,
0.11512727290391922,
0.4182913303375244,
0.5329611301422119,
0.4700867533683777,
0.38468506932258606,
0.5160241723060608,
-0.2117564082145691,
0.8798277378082275,
-0.1434854120016098,
-0.8365069031715393,
0.7245966196060181,
-0.15377959609031677,
0.8322510719299316,
0.7411006689071655,
0.18854308128356934,
-0.5428266525268555,
-0.9287278652191162,
-0.43748265504837036,
-0.7942222952842712,
0.9460159540176392,
0.09042949229478836,
-0.061771176755428314,
0.31057673692703247,
0.3350974917411804,
0.14149266481399536,
0.2775934934616089,
-0.3207392692565918,
-0.18496784567832947,
0.09460102766752243,
-0.4932909905910492,
-0.14451773464679718,
-0.4348371922969818,
0.08309314399957657,
0.0706789568066597,
1.0836875438690186,
-0.3275199830532074,
-0.008789136074483395,
0.11186062544584274,
-0.6484947204589844,
-0.03866741061210632,
0.35648661851882935,
1.0240737199783325,
0.6451106667518616,
-0.1592031717300415,
0.1363610327243805,
0.4303254783153534,
-0.5437732338905334,
0.0640929713845253,
-0.16925516724586487,
-0.577664315700531,
0.45128220319747925,
0.5180075764656067,
1.0198829174041748,
0.7510691285133362,
-0.5981791019439697,
0.3617452085018158,
-0.08325174450874329,
-0.24467957019805908,
-0.09719624370336533,
0.3955754339694977,
0.14227557182312012,
0.2159385234117508,
0.2827172577381134,
-0.2883147597312927,
0.14610250294208527,
-0.2880094349384308,
-0.20606018602848053,
0.3149701952934265,
-0.12309107929468155,
-0.21012848615646362,
0.549391508102417,
0.2912493944168091,
-0.3447982370853424,
0.4478927254676819,
-0.07007796317338943,
-0.2900804579257965,
0.47864729166030884,
0.3981034755706787,
1.0146821737289429,
0.02684687077999115,
0.20097145438194275,
0.006299286615103483,
0.5419343709945679,
0.07052783668041229,
0.06419065594673157,
-0.25213947892189026,
-0.4260910451412201,
-0.31493663787841797,
-0.46867072582244873,
-0.6848883032798767,
0.2566467523574829,
-0.7921792268753052,
0.3432987332344055,
-0.3519406020641327,
-0.08189977705478668,
0.034671470522880554,
0.21203812956809998,
-0.26904726028442383,
-0.010003468953073025,
-0.13281933963298798,
0.9079533219337463,
-0.7228199243545532,
0.7030678987503052,
0.3792778253555298,
-0.15375663340091705,
-0.33406388759613037,
0.17169272899627686,
0.04978492856025696,
-0.6081004738807678,
0.1372625082731247,
0.04653225839138031,
-0.12436316907405853,
0.1713530272245407,
-0.13880108296871185,
-0.8577620387077332,
1.4108059406280518,
0.4126010537147522,
-0.6165292859077454,
-0.4597271978855133,
0.17978312075138092,
0.2952231466770172,
-0.2616325318813324,
0.09495557099580765,
0.7393803000450134,
0.44525983929634094,
0.05693967267870903,
-0.5554344058036804,
-0.20507575571537018,
-0.11963432282209396,
0.37924909591674805,
0.6003451347351074,
-0.8177737593650818,
0.35113614797592163,
-0.20796841382980347,
-0.11489947140216827,
-0.16167986392974854,
0.8487042784690857,
-0.08903085440397263,
0.4622056484222412,
0.24436143040657043,
0.521395742893219,
0.8960026502609253,
0.04983397573232651,
0.5898816585540771,
-0.5454462170600891,
0.11322468519210815,
1.5853372812271118,
-0.41437867283821106,
0.5912806391716003,
0.24507611989974976,
0.03521279618144035,
0.15109995007514954,
0.46913260221481323,
0.13618029654026031,
0.7118345499038696,
-0.20357920229434967,
-0.2522072494029999,
-0.071688711643219,
-0.0014421603409573436,
-0.4660315215587616,
0.41304394602775574,
0.5541512370109558,
-0.6247662305831909,
-0.49130621552467346,
0.07315272837877274,
0.2014794796705246,
-0.07277009636163712,
-0.5497056841850281,
1.3763339519500732,
0.2458488494157791,
-0.6852124929428101,
0.07482979446649551,
0.2914417088031769,
0.48115938901901245,
-0.8204935193061829,
0.14739954471588135,
-0.5246922969818115,
-0.14540526270866394,
-0.1085539236664772,
-0.48212745785713196,
0.3164753317832947,
0.0860261470079422,
-0.36729806661605835,
-0.05660613253712654,
1.1382440328598022,
-0.5172495245933533,
-0.5008534789085388,
-0.19136174023151398,
0.24196270108222961,
0.06505806744098663,
0.12158317863941193,
-0.12061584740877151,
0.1704980581998825,
-0.1790672242641449,
-0.22068803012371063,
0.7150214314460754,
0.37441587448120117,
0.03088252991437912,
0.3768939971923828,
0.46393072605133057,
0.20813077688217163,
-0.29693907499313354,
0.12323904782533646,
0.8414471745491028,
-0.5765013098716736,
-0.7861656546592712,
-0.8902434706687927,
0.2958318591117859,
-0.261387437582016,
-0.23881691694259644,
0.6259779930114746,
0.7665007710456848,
0.58351731300354,
0.08874727785587311,
0.8209266066551208,
0.5662899017333984,
0.5079463720321655,
-0.90207839012146,
1.00675368309021,
-0.4726933538913727,
0.2889609932899475,
-0.21068598330020905,
-0.8911885023117065,
-0.11034111678600311,
0.48082610964775085,
-0.054916445165872574,
-0.16103814542293549,
0.6913542747497559,
0.9578850269317627,
0.1252177357673645,
0.20307967066764832,
0.5671877861022949,
0.1931203007698059,
0.1640484780073166,
0.3174225389957428,
0.3614634573459625,
-0.08874166756868362,
0.31403011083602905,
-0.09614754468202591,
-0.026177342981100082,
-0.6547651290893555,
-1.00536048412323,
-0.8987687230110168,
-0.6212879419326782,
-0.33728042244911194,
0.0718078538775444,
0.06602518260478973,
0.9993519186973572,
0.4984164535999298,
-0.504088819026947,
0.012139989994466305,
0.1934189796447754,
0.4571591019630432,
-0.05612558126449585,
-0.21325218677520752,
0.33324673771858215,
-0.7122097611427307,
-0.5835920572280884,
0.36229217052459717,
0.7316762804985046,
0.03196336701512337,
-0.329029381275177,
-0.2540186643600464,
0.28804925084114075,
0.2533625364303589,
0.5492458343505859,
-0.1918012946844101,
-0.5709267854690552,
-0.2591181695461273,
-0.07816795259714127,
-0.22744224965572357,
0.10812404006719589,
1.0317671298980713,
-0.4206264913082123,
0.26310041546821594,
0.508152425289154,
0.8025039434432983,
0.6549654603004456,
-0.18977119028568268,
0.4236152768135071,
-1.0052753686904907,
-0.07112807035446167,
0.26925143599510193,
0.3429262936115265,
-0.018426256254315376,
-0.6420997977256775,
0.3157072067260742,
-0.0023423274978995323,
-0.4600394368171692,
-0.6975332498550415,
-0.02444056048989296,
-0.7638424038887024,
-0.2817453145980835,
0.9279077649116516,
-0.13297022879123688,
-0.2852548360824585,
0.07023594528436661,
-0.4008907973766327,
0.19495780766010284,
-0.41058745980262756,
0.7773444056510925,
0.7955747246742249,
0.10995054990053177,
-0.3800264298915863,
-0.041900634765625,
0.48987895250320435,
0.35839805006980896,
-1.0484795570373535,
0.09571409970521927,
0.5609320402145386,
0.09657826274633408,
0.003968089818954468,
0.8231127858161926,
0.07297108322381973,
0.5477950572967529,
-0.20594251155853271,
-0.37999677658081055,
-0.34516042470932007,
-0.48594316840171814,
-0.3940871059894562,
0.20720258355140686,
0.3672388792037964,
-0.07159116119146347
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.04615v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.04615v1
|
What do MLLMs hear? Examining reasoning with text and sound components in Multimodal Large Language Models
| 2024-06-07T03:55:00 | 2024-06-07T03:55:00 |
Enis Berk Çoban, Michael I. Mandel, Johanna Devaney
|
eess.AS
|
eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.SD
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated remarkable reasoning
capabilities, notably in connecting ideas and adhering to logical rules to
solve problems. These models have evolved to accommodate various data
modalities, including sound and images, known as multimodal LLMs (MLLMs), which
are capable of describing images or sound recordings. Previous work has
demonstrated that when the LLM component in MLLMs is frozen, the audio or
visual encoder serves to caption the sound or image input facilitating
text-based reasoning with the LLM component. We are interested in using the
LLM's reasoning capabilities in order to facilitate classification. In this
paper, we demonstrate through a captioning/classification experiment that an
audio MLLM cannot fully leverage its LLM's text-based reasoning when generating
audio captions. We also consider how this may be due to MLLMs separately
representing auditory and textual information such that it severs the reasoning
pathway from the LLM to the audio encoder.
|
[
-0.5680114030838013,
-0.6438295245170593,
0.9245436191558838,
-0.015983982011675835,
-0.30016592144966125,
0.05476297810673714,
-0.2938512861728668,
-0.6189205646514893,
-0.14454017579555511,
0.699811577796936,
-0.7222641706466675,
-0.40502724051475525,
-0.4853861927986145,
0.299650102853775,
-0.5652723908424377,
0.970287024974823,
0.18428921699523926,
0.2798927128314972,
-0.5146397948265076,
-0.10063426941633224,
-0.6027015447616577,
-0.7301204204559326,
-0.6100746393203735,
-0.28742313385009766,
0.7361783385276794,
0.24525140225887299,
0.6636913418769836,
0.34957727789878845,
0.40722209215164185,
0.36349108815193176,
-0.19600416719913483,
0.31103938817977905,
-0.008863555267453194,
0.4029983580112457,
0.1254182606935501,
-0.6683454513549805,
-0.059925708919763565,
0.12351010739803314,
0.5343934297561646,
0.5605483651161194,
0.10327450186014175,
0.15228740870952606,
-0.1746353656053543,
0.30263158679008484,
-0.44166111946105957,
0.2793029844760895,
-0.7080400586128235,
0.33476555347442627,
0.0013818100560456514,
-0.5716326832771301,
-0.7531312108039856,
0.07493199408054352,
0.21881601214408875,
-0.474837988615036,
0.0023307520896196365,
0.3769164979457855,
0.6993644833564758,
0.43401721119880676,
-0.4442656934261322,
-0.5307629704475403,
-0.896809995174408,
0.9067560434341431,
-0.7368088364601135,
0.6370965242385864,
0.6054019927978516,
0.33200904726982117,
0.07601606845855713,
-0.5345261096954346,
-0.8433226943016052,
-0.35775092244148254,
-0.1808752715587616,
-0.007689436431974173,
-0.18274065852165222,
-0.020122596994042397,
0.5038714408874512,
0.16140532493591309,
-0.5072675943374634,
0.11357707530260086,
-0.3859189748764038,
-0.35542988777160645,
0.5423852801322937,
0.06696785241365433,
0.3590306341648102,
-0.18720024824142456,
-0.4651027321815491,
-0.06999874114990234,
-0.43189844489097595,
-0.0429263561964035,
0.18980443477630615,
0.23386551439762115,
-0.14949214458465576,
0.8288965821266174,
0.3908367455005646,
0.6349883079528809,
-0.21313782036304474,
-0.5922073125839233,
0.4226699471473694,
-0.1515204906463623,
-0.4904141128063202,
0.3620438575744629,
0.7939339280128479,
0.4180910587310791,
0.1646883636713028,
-0.11386308073997498,
-0.5478383898735046,
0.0390799380838871,
-0.07192021608352661,
-0.40908682346343994,
0.01427688542753458,
0.4448237419128418,
-0.5942221879959106,
-0.07529740035533905,
-0.20923063158988953,
-0.5855364203453064,
-0.5625467896461487,
-0.6608681678771973,
0.7244793772697449,
-0.2721724510192871,
-0.21904726326465607,
0.1705843061208725,
-0.4390222728252411,
0.23440077900886536,
0.4721783995628357,
-0.9362756609916687,
0.033196769654750824,
0.4120265245437622,
0.6158731579780579,
-0.17595764994621277,
-0.14400404691696167,
-0.6894845962524414,
0.11970968544483185,
-0.23439009487628937,
0.8863852024078369,
-0.5234531760215759,
-0.39138394594192505,
0.007932287640869617,
0.075888991355896,
-0.26793456077575684,
-0.6281003355979919,
0.6383762359619141,
-0.5435773134231567,
0.3018166422843933,
-0.1842518448829651,
-0.4930422306060791,
-0.20231808722019196,
0.17194059491157532,
-0.7286611795425415,
0.5457474589347839,
-0.4623737335205078,
-0.8403148055076599,
0.6170979142189026,
-0.5891546607017517,
-0.36892253160476685,
-0.0966554656624794,
-0.545637845993042,
-0.3538239598274231,
0.022320182994008064,
0.30889666080474854,
0.4781648814678192,
-0.17227420210838318,
0.1259063482284546,
-0.380840003490448,
-0.4312630593776703,
1.0004096031188965,
-0.9589692950248718,
0.5849353671073914,
0.39733412861824036,
-0.25590258836746216,
0.3263130784034729,
-0.49030759930610657,
-0.2529613673686981,
0.2941707968711853,
-0.6335282921791077,
-0.2246883511543274,
0.19028496742248535,
0.1899174451828003,
0.06711414456367493,
-0.1015825867652893,
-0.5974388122558594,
0.04846475273370743,
-0.05407283827662468,
0.546981692314148,
0.6055108308792114,
-0.26358747482299805,
0.3250536620616913,
-0.4457769989967346,
0.17202802002429962,
0.08601544052362442,
0.06723787635564804,
-0.531689465045929,
-0.5122199654579163,
-0.9101706147193909,
-0.4297998547554016,
0.22517144680023193,
0.44332534074783325,
-0.7966853976249695,
-0.03910726681351662,
0.030208570882678032,
-0.1270076185464859,
-0.6910169720649719,
0.07852055877447128,
-0.026922106742858887,
0.15227536857128143,
0.3722521662712097,
0.24593102931976318,
-0.6100324988365173,
-0.9447190761566162,
-0.001265502069145441,
-0.1824527382850647,
-0.19606763124465942,
0.42459994554519653,
0.3734759986400604,
-0.21605819463729858,
0.7285661101341248,
-0.21447135508060455,
-0.30708998441696167,
-0.1509375423192978,
0.11870413273572922,
0.2881442606449127,
0.31806954741477966,
0.43439528346061707,
-1.0448414087295532,
0.11721641570329666,
0.025142699480056763,
-0.9526510834693909,
0.009645183570683002,
-0.3720725178718567,
0.2682037949562073,
0.2337285280227661,
0.7995531558990479,
-1.1047812700271606,
0.3666955828666687,
0.5519434213638306,
-0.39125174283981323,
0.8257652521133423,
-0.17823386192321777,
0.12744326889514923,
-0.4479012191295624,
-0.2882841229438782,
-0.3545977473258972,
-0.18719623982906342,
-0.4636208713054657,
-0.26150670647621155,
-0.28270846605300903,
-0.14017051458358765,
-0.3510640561580658,
0.3570089340209961,
-0.6277208924293518,
-0.45022323727607727,
-0.4248105585575104,
0.28579503297805786,
0.14061401784420013,
0.35747262835502625,
0.13500860333442688,
0.6299633979797363,
0.7027897238731384,
-0.5655900835990906,
0.5976008176803589,
0.09936603158712387,
-0.4787594974040985,
0.46046844124794006,
-0.43920448422431946,
0.1460496187210083,
-0.30544430017471313,
0.2390742152929306,
-0.9492722153663635,
-0.23510003089904785,
0.09496510028839111,
-0.4620922803878784,
0.34360286593437195,
-0.0019460197072476149,
-0.82429438829422,
-0.2427162379026413,
0.02246929332613945,
0.47626182436943054,
0.4042907655239105,
-0.7389482855796814,
0.8224682807922363,
0.4901525378227234,
-0.17445731163024902,
-0.22745071351528168,
-0.9512777924537659,
0.09840686619281769,
-0.4387664794921875,
-0.3363162577152252,
-0.2540038824081421,
-0.343542218208313,
-0.6783568263053894,
0.08846770972013474,
-0.10131029784679413,
-0.06999994069337845,
-0.03659633919596672,
0.49793922901153564,
0.3798551857471466,
-0.4328059256076813,
0.5757901072502136,
0.04904913902282715,
0.06286898255348206,
0.3872595727443695,
-0.05636772885918617,
0.34106531739234924,
-0.15792782604694366,
-0.8606904149055481,
-0.39860987663269043,
0.37791934609413147,
1.1287912130355835,
-0.29754671454429626,
0.5418215394020081,
0.7425912618637085,
-0.1815883219242096,
-0.20816326141357422,
-0.6619113683700562,
-0.2734547555446625,
-0.4395218789577484,
0.2564210295677185,
-0.3907986283302307,
-0.9774744510650635,
0.26097768545150757,
0.07282408326864243,
0.13570575416088104,
0.22695417702198029,
0.6664171814918518,
-0.5605115294456482,
1.2012516260147095,
0.018216002732515335,
0.19072379171848297,
0.09964422136545181,
-0.02226041443645954,
-0.10114017874002457,
-0.7181389927864075,
-0.5295349955558777,
-0.5698999762535095,
-0.18924452364444733,
-0.20837004482746124,
-0.62323397397995,
0.24305206537246704,
0.040876809507608414,
-0.20457139611244202,
-0.10490147769451141,
-0.3065394163131714,
0.4923872649669647,
0.5703709721565247,
0.07626298815011978,
0.4029386639595032,
0.1306651383638382,
-0.30597880482673645,
-0.11251894384622574,
-0.5768211483955383,
-0.5443221926689148,
0.7618651986122131,
0.6368662118911743,
0.7666804194450378,
0.14771050214767456,
0.2921147048473358,
0.396488219499588,
0.20054392516613007,
-1.0106287002563477,
0.5341036915779114,
-0.10745933651924133,
-0.6428229808807373,
-0.44662320613861084,
-0.21439096331596375,
-0.9720686078071594,
0.7069143056869507,
-0.6001890301704407,
-0.5877674221992493,
0.1480649709701538,
-0.13287042081356049,
-0.022471779957413673,
0.43817538022994995,
-0.4424246549606323,
0.6202096343040466,
-0.504762589931488,
0.0863669291138649,
-0.11975624412298203,
-0.27927643060684204,
0.34745094180107117,
-0.13025733828544617,
0.8364028334617615,
-0.18306325376033783,
0.23301948606967926,
0.8088546991348267,
-0.0597103126347065,
0.8219469785690308,
-0.041527751833200455,
-0.3864442706108093,
0.43253710865974426,
0.12151072174310684,
0.04740820452570915,
-0.04492610692977905,
0.11344552040100098,
0.05785622075200081,
-0.11145882308483124,
-0.0770355686545372,
-0.739739179611206,
0.41063201427459717,
-0.621196985244751,
-0.744775652885437,
-0.22243037819862366,
-0.912943959236145,
-0.3535105884075165,
0.051997873932123184,
0.10736455023288727,
0.5187702178955078,
0.3705616295337677,
0.5170517563819885,
0.7046265006065369,
-0.44008925557136536,
0.577921450138092,
0.5418432354927063,
-0.8018388152122498,
-0.2361646443605423,
0.8299272060394287,
-0.13257284462451935,
0.3118619918823242,
0.350591778755188,
0.2380528748035431,
-0.5230470299720764,
-0.6038891673088074,
-0.5006047487258911,
0.15922196209430695,
-1.0431498289108276,
0.10300444811582565,
-0.4677428901195526,
-0.2702608108520508,
-0.033780328929424286,
0.2368750423192978,
0.014888696372509003,
-0.05687431991100311,
-0.41691967844963074,
-0.3392831087112427,
0.07882668823003769,
0.6742138862609863,
-0.051877886056900024,
-0.1663590669631958,
-1.0742502212524414,
0.35126742720603943,
0.7025216817855835,
-0.09990076720714569,
0.051817428320646286,
-0.5685062408447266,
-0.14308302104473114,
0.011852944269776344,
0.0571303591132164,
-0.9508533477783203,
0.24380597472190857,
-0.03546833619475365,
0.8818715810775757,
0.42572927474975586,
0.04569657891988754,
0.3984737694263458,
-0.6266586780548096,
0.7208148241043091,
0.2941521108150482,
-0.9127784371376038,
0.45097893476486206,
-0.22978778183460236,
0.4240097999572754,
0.024659350514411926,
0.1372380554676056,
-0.2411259561777115,
-0.7411472201347351,
-0.09580238908529282,
-0.5239279866218567,
0.3252381682395935,
0.27524423599243164,
0.17413736879825592,
0.01095512043684721,
-0.16930164396762848,
0.2629057765007019,
0.28682464361190796,
-0.8603627681732178,
-0.15428289771080017,
-0.14129428565502167,
0.009423120878636837,
-0.0909062996506691,
-0.26064062118530273,
-0.3533773124217987,
-0.2650396525859833,
0.2040424644947052,
-0.12003647536039352,
0.3683973252773285,
0.4092666208744049,
-0.17370669543743134,
0.04992114007472992,
0.5758012533187866,
0.9266412258148193,
0.2828148305416107,
-0.0699457973241806,
0.6964917778968811,
0.23834916949272156,
-0.1899854838848114,
0.09150276333093643,
-0.1681177020072937,
0.01607583835721016,
0.3417021632194519,
0.9321717023849487,
1.385784387588501,
0.3550216257572174,
-1.092040777206421,
0.45832476019859314,
-0.13109014928340912,
-0.5649022459983826,
-0.3501843214035034,
-0.04670325294137001,
0.402483731508255,
0.6147650480270386,
0.5219559669494629,
0.22307784855365753,
0.10983217507600784,
-0.628014087677002,
0.20036298036575317,
0.3911327123641968,
-0.44602537155151367,
-0.02865615300834179,
0.6667888760566711,
-0.11641900986433029,
-0.15412834286689758,
0.6300071477890015,
0.21556946635246277,
-0.44653064012527466,
0.5539219379425049,
0.4871370792388916,
0.6131702661514282,
0.15068118274211884,
0.07313975691795349,
-0.08543585985898972,
0.4085931181907654,
0.23957151174545288,
0.10103306919336319,
-0.19881713390350342,
-0.9554868340492249,
-0.6888539791107178,
-0.7635068297386169,
-0.41402995586395264,
0.27345010638237,
-0.6889552474021912,
-0.04954315349459648,
-0.2952621877193451,
-0.31274139881134033,
0.16468286514282227,
-0.8031149506568909,
-0.6384299993515015,
0.255836546421051,
0.70321124792099,
0.7171135544776917,
-0.7217971086502075,
0.5733928084373474,
0.5454598069190979,
-0.28558728098869324,
-0.7567225098609924,
-0.04805396497249603,
0.058686938136816025,
-0.6589797735214233,
1.214272141456604,
0.29254430532455444,
-0.16828352212905884,
-0.48483434319496155,
-0.8351966142654419,
-0.5512244701385498,
0.835618793964386,
0.5113270282745361,
-0.8586487174034119,
0.29765090346336365,
0.20453901588916779,
0.4449101984500885,
-0.481131911277771,
0.218934565782547,
0.33420100808143616,
0.7799037098884583,
0.28610602021217346,
-1.3141604661941528,
-0.14332935214042664,
0.02115471661090851,
-0.5173014402389526,
-0.3026975095272064,
-0.21051010489463806,
1.0315780639648438,
-0.542681872844696,
-0.2726983428001404,
-0.17424681782722473,
0.4864581525325775,
0.5515156984329224,
0.5607393980026245,
0.8568912744522095,
0.3729627728462219,
0.8568143248558044,
-0.21119114756584167,
1.0852628946304321,
0.28822746872901917,
0.28536373376846313,
1.1600667238235474,
-0.35662156343460083,
1.048279881477356,
0.629303514957428,
-0.2237015813589096,
0.4677487313747406,
0.537620484828949,
-0.24001988768577576,
0.4593896269798279,
0.37159040570259094,
-0.5055482983589172,
-0.6418588757514954,
-0.2669324278831482,
-0.24550515413284302,
0.6677584052085876,
0.3058926463127136,
-0.4459620714187622,
0.15105213224887848,
0.6382490396499634,
-0.2805277705192566,
-0.16941861808300018,
-0.4538680613040924,
0.8767468929290771,
0.39320772886276245,
-0.21479471027851105,
0.455844908952713,
-0.4086357355117798,
0.6362292766571045,
-0.2708408832550049,
-0.16219066083431244,
0.29718607664108276,
-0.029638366773724556,
-0.2601310908794403,
-1.021102786064148,
0.2472885251045227,
-0.10766568034887314,
-0.432260125875473,
-0.07830849289894104,
0.6266083121299744,
-0.6244028806686401,
-0.36802446842193604,
0.5886058807373047,
0.4766324758529663,
0.5248165130615234,
0.021543800830841064,
-0.513778805732727,
0.6306278705596924,
-0.10934631526470184,
-0.18458126485347748,
0.33322781324386597,
0.5784562826156616,
0.172671839594841,
0.9161630272865295,
0.9203528165817261,
0.05810452625155449,
0.1396402269601822,
0.5332204103469849,
0.7297170758247375,
-0.5382153987884521,
-0.1701970249414444,
-0.942595899105072,
0.3767102062702179,
0.11349823325872421,
0.12176702916622162,
0.6613163352012634,
0.5783412456512451,
0.6421761512756348,
-0.42062753438949585,
0.7713314294815063,
0.4536280333995819,
0.26657313108444214,
-1.0304408073425293,
0.6908954381942749,
-0.7074500322341919,
0.3595879077911377,
-0.11333529651165009,
-0.7099666595458984,
-0.3058931231498718,
0.544902503490448,
-0.07695751637220383,
-0.1978670209646225,
0.9274830222129822,
0.4264710545539856,
0.19325415790081024,
0.3617558777332306,
0.768671989440918,
0.44108715653419495,
0.1962546557188034,
0.2543037235736847,
1.2980855703353882,
0.02289164997637272,
0.7638387084007263,
0.2023766189813614,
0.2786758840084076,
0.2000151127576828,
-0.6006569266319275,
-1.1244553327560425,
-0.5666415691375732,
-0.23737232387065887,
-0.23323577642440796,
-0.19791170954704285,
0.6943721771240234,
0.7122038006782532,
-0.9004478454589844,
-0.1758316457271576,
0.3178584575653076,
0.2161593735218048,
0.06960676610469818,
-0.32708364725112915,
0.2670818269252777,
-0.1934218555688858,
-0.7092373967170715,
0.7778699398040771,
0.35120758414268494,
0.23004654049873352,
-0.47562119364738464,
-0.22475621104240417,
0.0680273175239563,
0.0704868957400322,
0.8199695348739624,
0.002115953015163541,
-1.1907520294189453,
-0.4144996702671051,
-0.12309141457080841,
-0.07992520183324814,
-0.07069113105535507,
0.7050618529319763,
-0.647619366645813,
0.4419648349285126,
0.3673528730869293,
0.6022149920463562,
0.5841780304908752,
-0.4353552460670471,
0.3931855261325836,
-0.4525930881500244,
0.1682523787021637,
0.23929408192634583,
0.7199304103851318,
0.33504170179367065,
0.06701100617647171,
0.06313227862119675,
0.2924002707004547,
-0.5707644820213318,
-0.9678568840026855,
0.07223498821258545,
-1.192306637763977,
-0.6430866122245789,
1.3733710050582886,
-0.05460737273097038,
-0.11002679169178009,
-0.4500238299369812,
-0.7140412926673889,
0.015907688066363335,
-0.3155123293399811,
0.21776269376277924,
0.8483095169067383,
-0.1476835012435913,
-0.7592541575431824,
-0.8650880455970764,
0.28505340218544006,
0.17003826797008514,
-0.6849858164787292,
-0.035467326641082764,
0.5030481219291687,
0.18665969371795654,
0.5333913564682007,
0.49192726612091064,
-0.09285885840654373,
0.21422627568244934,
0.2830275595188141,
-0.06313824653625488,
-0.10244975984096527,
-0.31356361508369446,
-0.12875798344612122,
0.45035848021507263,
0.0838419646024704,
-0.3279576897621155
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.04614v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.04614v1
|
LawGPT: A Chinese Legal Knowledge-Enhanced Large Language Model
| 2024-06-07T03:52:56 | 2024-06-07T03:52:56 |
Zhi Zhou, Jiang-Xin Shi, Peng-Xiao Song, Xiao-Wen Yang, Yi-Xuan Jin, Lan-Zhe Guo, Yu-Feng Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large language models (LLMs), including both proprietary and open-source
models, have showcased remarkable capabilities in addressing a wide range of
downstream tasks. Nonetheless, when it comes to practical Chinese legal tasks,
these models fail to meet the actual requirements. Proprietary models do not
ensure data privacy for sensitive legal cases, while open-source models
demonstrate unsatisfactory performance due to their lack of legal knowledge. To
address this problem, we introduce LawGPT, the first open-source model
specifically designed for Chinese legal applications. LawGPT comprises two key
components: legal-oriented pre-training and legal supervised fine-tuning.
Specifically, we employ large-scale Chinese legal documents for legal-oriented
pre-training to incorporate legal domain knowledge. To further improve the
model's performance on downstream legal tasks, we create a knowledge-driven
instruction dataset for legal supervised fine-tuning. Our experimental results
demonstrate that LawGPT outperforms the open-source LLaMA 7B model. Our code
and resources are publicly available at https://github.com/pengxiao-song/LaWGPT
and have received 5.7K stars on GitHub.
|
[
0.07962766289710999,
-0.5470964908599854,
0.4925159215927124,
0.1689009964466095,
-0.5969860553741455,
-0.5560291409492493,
-0.5061558485031128,
-0.32044917345046997,
-0.3203750252723694,
0.8285083770751953,
-0.19593580067157745,
-0.6496062874794006,
-0.5664704442024231,
-0.5425816774368286,
-0.4177702069282532,
1.307103157043457,
0.08765412867069244,
0.3903389275074005,
0.38612258434295654,
-0.08111265301704407,
-0.31573328375816345,
-0.38804158568382263,
-0.7446754574775696,
-0.3519631624221802,
0.4501977264881134,
-0.025395041331648827,
0.6998338103294373,
0.8642038106918335,
0.6249808073043823,
0.07738634198904037,
-0.07754979282617569,
-0.292923241853714,
-0.5320411920547485,
-0.43199336528778076,
-0.30642393231391907,
-0.37197163701057434,
-0.6994128823280334,
-0.0772242322564125,
0.30066385865211487,
0.18757401406764984,
-0.5313771367073059,
0.14163489639759064,
-0.07568719238042831,
0.5635833740234375,
-0.4799852669239044,
0.46931323409080505,
-0.7420644760131836,
0.07386866211891174,
-0.35244056582450867,
0.024993648752570152,
-0.23357585072517395,
-0.33962324261665344,
-0.005143181420862675,
-0.7116149067878723,
0.18300679326057434,
-0.07652636617422104,
0.7709224820137024,
0.48948919773101807,
-0.3844764232635498,
-0.27064642310142517,
-0.5325543880462646,
0.34592071175575256,
-1.1395741701126099,
0.4007842540740967,
0.20874594151973724,
0.46434473991394043,
-0.19190442562103271,
-0.974064826965332,
-0.5053570866584778,
-0.7086458206176758,
0.11134864389896393,
0.1322382688522339,
0.13919180631637573,
0.3081548810005188,
0.3217855989933014,
0.3103056252002716,
-0.8002015948295593,
0.2934954762458801,
-0.36475640535354614,
-0.15988443791866302,
0.5386863946914673,
-0.0016103697707876563,
0.5652972459793091,
0.12752200663089752,
-0.356568843126297,
0.23446974158287048,
-1.088824987411499,
0.14412572979927063,
0.32004013657569885,
0.5262419581413269,
-0.08161522448062897,
0.6681618094444275,
-0.1606782227754593,
0.6466904282569885,
-0.11538798362016678,
-0.06394251435995102,
-0.09521687030792236,
-0.051868125796318054,
-0.465456485748291,
0.3198601305484772,
0.9092071652412415,
-0.009850593283772469,
0.2757866382598877,
0.024370308965444565,
-0.4439438283443451,
-0.5864745378494263,
-0.008065687492489815,
-0.9035009741783142,
-0.40595293045043945,
0.1110561192035675,
-0.44901472330093384,
-0.17735172808170319,
0.3064638078212738,
-0.288396418094635,
-0.804806113243103,
-0.4944406747817993,
0.37618058919906616,
-0.39997008442878723,
-0.308524489402771,
0.34329330921173096,
0.1515950858592987,
0.4868564307689667,
0.38275599479675293,
-0.8366943001747131,
-0.03368692472577095,
1.017938494682312,
0.5791521668434143,
0.14991424977779388,
-0.18860846757888794,
-0.7430447340011597,
0.3744391202926636,
-0.198679581284523,
0.30512309074401855,
-0.4634891152381897,
0.1279044896364212,
0.029767844825983047,
-0.012997515499591827,
0.18402636051177979,
-0.5305617451667786,
0.7293202877044678,
-0.7454822659492493,
-0.2589384913444519,
-0.22579555213451385,
-0.448813259601593,
-0.21205276250839233,
0.22482624650001526,
-0.7371078729629517,
0.49844473600387573,
0.04687536135315895,
-0.8482280969619751,
0.7180275917053223,
-0.8921589851379395,
-0.4967136085033417,
0.4555594027042389,
-0.31638145446777344,
-0.46560582518577576,
-0.30799248814582825,
0.28520235419273376,
0.45674851536750793,
-0.3878934979438782,
0.7566573619842529,
-0.1911957859992981,
-0.4738924205303192,
-0.36137863993644714,
-0.19182641804218292,
1.2671679258346558,
0.44824957847595215,
-0.39822113513946533,
0.2661280035972595,
-0.5859211087226868,
-0.3178853392601013,
0.38440901041030884,
-0.6749778389930725,
-0.3300694525241852,
-0.09937413036823273,
-0.17274439334869385,
0.1764092594385147,
0.5766523480415344,
-0.5405420660972595,
0.2573576271533966,
-0.27414771914482117,
0.6698997020721436,
0.8362610936164856,
-0.3135155737400055,
0.14761610329151154,
-0.16247473657131195,
0.4366150200366974,
-0.008639965206384659,
0.22822345793247223,
0.013114565052092075,
-0.3879624307155609,
-0.5568415522575378,
-0.048846568912267685,
0.5030235648155212,
0.7387617826461792,
-0.4345376491546631,
0.1942884773015976,
-0.5754625201225281,
-0.5618501901626587,
-0.4477183222770691,
0.3892894685268402,
0.17518001794815063,
0.05388962849974632,
0.19451725482940674,
-0.026890259236097336,
-0.30954447388648987,
-0.7402839064598083,
-0.551419198513031,
-0.280071496963501,
-0.11024569720029831,
0.26161327958106995,
0.41313448548316956,
-0.05472633242607117,
0.6078439354896545,
-0.2666293680667877,
-0.5047056674957275,
-0.4306761920452118,
0.026619242504239082,
0.40628746151924133,
0.3494255244731903,
0.4568112790584564,
-0.737223744392395,
-0.48506268858909607,
0.6116365194320679,
-0.6741704344749451,
-0.20657838881015778,
-0.05130453035235405,
0.09280310571193695,
-0.20358693599700928,
0.48924902081489563,
-0.697817325592041,
0.2744675576686859,
0.29833415150642395,
-0.285908043384552,
0.6676369309425354,
-0.32544374465942383,
-0.058877673000097275,
-0.8870065808296204,
0.04975861310958862,
-0.07050580531358719,
-0.17240206897258759,
-0.4878422021865845,
0.42005789279937744,
0.2347640097141266,
-0.2964474558830261,
-0.7848693132400513,
0.3734574615955353,
-0.33791789412498474,
-0.11436236649751663,
-0.33899712562561035,
0.10017931461334229,
-0.3868521749973297,
0.43128111958503723,
0.068548783659935,
0.9336424469947815,
0.5388268828392029,
-0.5213056206703186,
0.5940807461738586,
0.08514688163995743,
-0.5147849917411804,
0.23700477182865143,
-0.6015971302986145,
0.04595266655087471,
-0.004908842034637928,
-0.05526791512966156,
-0.19801869988441467,
-0.3830839693546295,
0.3012940287590027,
0.010673895478248596,
0.15951856970787048,
-0.5668060183525085,
-0.6806460618972778,
-0.2184041291475296,
0.07052192836999893,
0.19884055852890015,
0.5568976402282715,
-0.5659162402153015,
0.5047556161880493,
0.3430732786655426,
-0.193978950381279,
-0.7269461154937744,
-0.6427696347236633,
-0.016399137675762177,
-0.20833756029605865,
-0.6154646873474121,
-0.07596100121736526,
0.2527279555797577,
-0.13447333872318268,
0.11388135701417923,
0.03194044157862663,
-0.3739528954029083,
-0.11489749699831009,
0.1040346771478653,
-0.08937467634677887,
-0.4717029631137848,
0.20957279205322266,
0.007565384265035391,
0.20328372716903687,
0.20417024195194244,
-0.6305183172225952,
0.44966447353363037,
0.016386643052101135,
-0.6550379991531372,
-0.20997188985347748,
-0.24070386588573456,
0.2995453178882599,
-0.578484833240509,
0.43752211332321167,
0.6022627353668213,
-0.26599210500717163,
-0.4516936242580414,
-0.4411107897758484,
0.2466820627450943,
-0.4812392592430115,
0.47127535939216614,
-0.4108496904373169,
-1.0830326080322266,
0.327075332403183,
-0.007684436626732349,
0.39264997839927673,
0.24761101603507996,
0.6036868095397949,
0.4087912440299988,
0.4344204366207123,
0.7156904935836792,
-0.40810054540634155,
0.6792826652526855,
0.2358924299478531,
0.49499809741973877,
-0.26310160756111145,
0.06063540652394295,
-0.31579506397247314,
0.2569672465324402,
-0.5285471081733704,
-0.28857865929603577,
0.3209286630153656,
-0.01774502918124199,
-0.7310341000556946,
0.6091642379760742,
-0.23836754262447357,
0.6273072361946106,
0.7696626782417297,
0.3888675570487976,
0.44616854190826416,
-0.1301078349351883,
0.07863340526819229,
0.2891959846019745,
-0.7474714517593384,
-0.38308772444725037,
1.1321083307266235,
0.4171435236930847,
0.9953062534332275,
0.039892762899398804,
0.5733428001403809,
0.22236402332782745,
0.22684377431869507,
-0.718349814414978,
0.6077014207839966,
-0.5677279829978943,
-0.5711978077888489,
-0.6066293120384216,
-0.5190327763557434,
-0.7562426328659058,
0.06785415858030319,
0.15529030561447144,
-0.37311017513275146,
-0.40731489658355713,
0.048380378633737564,
-0.5031121969223022,
0.6104373335838318,
-0.37124064564704895,
0.9580426216125488,
-0.42909201979637146,
-0.5457613468170166,
-0.10333696752786636,
-0.4653972387313843,
0.7328208684921265,
-0.3806641101837158,
0.13882626593112946,
-0.09921015799045563,
0.3468850553035736,
0.6802165508270264,
-0.7421525120735168,
0.7806017994880676,
-0.4417128562927246,
-0.4434431195259094,
0.5158247947692871,
0.08497561514377594,
0.8335558176040649,
-0.042465273290872574,
0.04534810781478882,
0.024482300505042076,
-0.014674721285700798,
-0.22567853331565857,
-0.5424020290374756,
0.566754162311554,
-0.4715679883956909,
-0.9335124492645264,
-0.03667538985610008,
-0.745585024356842,
0.2586231231689453,
0.5890337824821472,
-0.006868727970868349,
-0.07667525857686996,
-0.023243654519319534,
0.09653469920158386,
0.6298314929008484,
-0.5758728981018066,
0.08087989687919617,
0.7341968417167664,
-0.25642654299736023,
-0.026324626058340073,
0.9173547029495239,
0.15823255479335785,
-0.04182460531592369,
0.30451369285583496,
0.47072479128837585,
-0.19061215221881866,
-0.8221591711044312,
-0.3754761517047882,
0.1767445057630539,
-0.8512831926345825,
0.08610596507787704,
-0.3552830219268799,
-0.5162084102630615,
-0.6149998307228088,
0.22833144664764404,
-0.347819983959198,
-0.09851062297821045,
0.03585900738835335,
-0.11281124502420425,
0.2486976832151413,
0.8997541069984436,
-0.025761285796761513,
0.29596176743507385,
-0.8673970103263855,
0.29590708017349243,
0.40110257267951965,
0.6526293158531189,
-0.3024848401546478,
-0.7790551781654358,
-0.2666425108909607,
0.0019886381924152374,
-0.10948924720287323,
-0.4414964020252228,
0.2883093059062958,
-0.1132141724228859,
0.5892897248268127,
0.6050443649291992,
0.04478555545210838,
0.5450018048286438,
-0.6149173378944397,
0.7412784099578857,
-0.07134398818016052,
-0.8408364057540894,
0.6614564061164856,
-0.7768966555595398,
-0.038998886942863464,
0.27790209650993347,
-0.012647585943341255,
-0.20870988070964813,
-0.29639479517936707,
-0.18029791116714478,
-0.5777462124824524,
0.7084996104240417,
0.08751444518566132,
0.18878449499607086,
0.5156996846199036,
0.5455146431922913,
0.21574611961841583,
0.09282337129116058,
-1.2473769187927246,
0.2895921766757965,
-0.21161425113677979,
-0.19032005965709686,
0.1216166689991951,
-0.008649052120745182,
0.037828776985406876,
-0.2447461485862732,
0.764772891998291,
0.06558073312044144,
-0.07683669030666351,
-0.11272506415843964,
-0.14049582183361053,
0.08376514166593552,
0.398528128862381,
0.6164470314979553,
0.5785838961601257,
-0.11800239980220795,
-0.07617634534835815,
0.11193573474884033,
-0.7008273005485535,
0.08363191038370132,
0.22894524037837982,
-0.4078078269958496,
-0.2931382358074188,
0.21938484907150269,
0.8648860454559326,
-0.2086624950170517,
-0.7836108207702637,
0.8466174006462097,
0.20156608521938324,
-0.32601383328437805,
-0.48988285660743713,
0.29370182752609253,
0.08916052430868149,
0.41865015029907227,
0.04424617439508438,
-0.48446935415267944,
0.19759881496429443,
-0.2767200767993927,
0.29375484585762024,
0.36756932735443115,
-0.524425208568573,
0.012833165004849434,
1.1329509019851685,
-0.003672989085316658,
0.03178361430764198,
0.4091494381427765,
-0.046537723392248154,
-0.3916063904762268,
0.567753255367279,
0.36253678798675537,
0.6986293196678162,
-0.030927082523703575,
0.011820982210338116,
0.32070478796958923,
0.6119527220726013,
-0.4633010923862457,
0.16793882846832275,
0.05895133689045906,
-0.45723864436149597,
-0.5485419631004333,
-0.4588052034378052,
-0.300502747297287,
0.5663488507270813,
-0.2794526517391205,
0.5426518321037292,
-0.6512498259544373,
0.1698639988899231,
-0.497587651014328,
-0.14863567054271698,
-0.5077695846557617,
0.15118427574634552,
0.02125236950814724,
1.118513822555542,
-0.5342674255371094,
1.2954357862472534,
0.6128442883491516,
-0.6589145064353943,
-1.1280384063720703,
0.09815135598182678,
-0.3301437795162201,
-0.9097989201545715,
0.879827618598938,
0.026356518268585205,
0.127423495054245,
0.017874622717499733,
-0.818210780620575,
-0.35708361864089966,
1.2551939487457275,
0.7983106374740601,
-0.9244881868362427,
-0.06414833664894104,
0.718135416507721,
0.48795124888420105,
-0.01657179743051529,
-0.11881159991025925,
0.5835761427879333,
0.5502986311912537,
-0.06975498795509338,
-1.0417526960372925,
0.17351235449314117,
-0.0384262353181839,
-0.2664264738559723,
0.08232831954956055,
-0.694172739982605,
1.0217808485031128,
-0.31439441442489624,
-0.17371980845928192,
-0.15122929215431213,
0.5087370276451111,
0.2909839451313019,
0.20786350965499878,
0.37769776582717896,
0.7254753112792969,
0.6820153594017029,
-0.05409548059105873,
0.9522340297698975,
-0.5308319330215454,
0.284566193819046,
1.203065037727356,
-0.4216150641441345,
0.5395239591598511,
0.18833640217781067,
-0.03581876680254936,
-0.002519123489037156,
0.47335392236709595,
-0.2801720201969147,
0.38297268748283386,
0.49803563952445984,
-0.2971658408641815,
-0.34557852149009705,
-0.08386301249265671,
-0.2530995309352875,
0.23905599117279053,
0.006362412124872208,
-0.47964999079704285,
-0.27758553624153137,
-0.22610297799110413,
-0.03109361045062542,
-0.05945570394396782,
-0.5924074649810791,
0.7811239957809448,
0.16527272760868073,
-0.42267265915870667,
0.2563236951828003,
0.16043509542942047,
0.48143550753593445,
-0.6589856147766113,
-0.16059300303459167,
-0.3123905658721924,
0.09570563584566116,
-0.1761760413646698,
-0.9396550059318542,
-0.10218311101198196,
0.16954582929611206,
0.33095717430114746,
0.11577600240707397,
0.7916742563247681,
-0.48623383045196533,
-0.18870840966701508,
0.386213481426239,
0.2633983790874481,
0.33464136719703674,
-0.4194052815437317,
-0.6281144618988037,
-0.23695655167102814,
-0.05289163440465927,
-0.3133644163608551,
0.32222768664360046,
0.864613950252533,
-0.3300320506095886,
0.802155077457428,
0.6537676453590393,
0.40062615275382996,
0.3862793743610382,
0.27298790216445923,
0.9207125902175903,
-0.6591203212738037,
-0.5049512386322021,
-0.8628829121589661,
0.37272489070892334,
0.19397732615470886,
-0.012300877831876278,
0.3315023183822632,
0.6093893647193909,
1.0102035999298096,
-0.260871946811676,
1.2237401008605957,
-0.11371535807847977,
0.19726251065731049,
-0.8248999714851379,
1.065636157989502,
-0.4330955445766449,
0.4140922725200653,
-0.005687464959919453,
-0.8034100532531738,
-0.3545631766319275,
0.3244502544403076,
-0.4714811444282532,
-0.001432966673746705,
0.22788108885288239,
0.9042842388153076,
-0.4664628803730011,
-0.13081568479537964,
0.6371145844459534,
0.10053858906030655,
0.5168938040733337,
0.8875575661659241,
0.6872875690460205,
-0.33759063482284546,
0.9141457676887512,
-0.15636445581912994,
-0.04721008613705635,
0.0010834319982677698,
-0.8661674857139587,
-1.0884195566177368,
-0.11821359395980835,
0.11451134085655212,
0.006895743310451508,
0.25839728116989136,
0.9314085841178894,
0.5865633487701416,
-0.9110780954360962,
-0.1593984216451645,
-0.44262072443962097,
-0.26916253566741943,
0.025694038718938828,
-0.1898966133594513,
0.39006784558296204,
-0.439418226480484,
-0.4850560426712036,
0.3254163861274719,
0.04598031938076019,
0.13025274872779846,
-0.037194542586803436,
-0.31947728991508484,
0.1645800918340683,
-0.11708302795886993,
0.4113143980503082,
0.17328548431396484,
-0.7094984650611877,
-0.05910087749361992,
-0.3120160400867462,
-0.23954887688159943,
0.0840127170085907,
1.1709752082824707,
-0.044577375054359436,
0.16420716047286987,
0.44234511256217957,
0.8525968194007874,
0.35491034388542175,
0.099490687251091,
0.6780896186828613,
-0.3577299118041992,
0.2657891511917114,
0.03575776517391205,
0.5772688388824463,
-0.008930794894695282,
-0.5529752969741821,
0.7002977728843689,
0.042428333312273026,
-0.6160997748374939,
-0.4450393617153168,
0.18146562576293945,
-0.8839539289474487,
-0.36251357197761536,
1.1557196378707886,
-0.6324813365936279,
-0.08816301822662354,
-0.02415217086672783,
-0.44416847825050354,
0.5246847867965698,
-0.4336433708667755,
0.6441805958747864,
0.6844764351844788,
0.3078838586807251,
-0.4070243537425995,
-1.0602796077728271,
0.42110273241996765,
0.13991783559322357,
-0.7389587759971619,
0.4832944869995117,
0.3800168037414551,
0.48917993903160095,
-0.41224902868270874,
0.6806493997573853,
-0.33338409662246704,
0.3588971495628357,
-0.03360756114125252,
0.2868710458278656,
-0.5283170938491821,
-0.0948963388800621,
-0.2866477072238922,
0.23730866611003876,
0.4046013653278351,
0.1970430314540863
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.04604v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.04604v1
|
Learning Task Decomposition to Assist Humans in Competitive Programming
| 2024-06-07T03:27:51 | 2024-06-07T03:27:51 |
Jiaxin Wen, Ruiqi Zhong, Pei Ke, Zhihong Shao, Hongning Wang, Minlie Huang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.PL
|
When using language models (LMs) to solve complex problems, humans might
struggle to understand the LM-generated solutions and repair the flawed ones.
To assist humans in repairing them, we propose to automatically decompose
complex solutions into multiple simpler pieces that correspond to specific
subtasks. We introduce a novel objective for learning task decomposition,
termed assistive value (AssistV), which measures the feasibility and speed for
humans to repair the decomposed solution. We collect a dataset of human repair
experiences on different decomposed solutions. Utilizing the collected data as
in-context examples, we then learn to critique, refine, and rank decomposed
solutions to improve AssistV. We validate our method under competitive
programming problems: under 177 hours of human study, our method enables
non-experts to solve 33.3\% more problems, speeds them up by 3.3x, and empowers
them to match unassisted experts.
|
[
-0.08483557403087616,
-0.49013999104499817,
0.3871621787548065,
0.17282801866531372,
0.15362514555454254,
0.3960559368133545,
-0.3223957419395447,
-0.5211315751075745,
0.16104522347450256,
0.3945888876914978,
-0.7674993872642517,
-0.1986323446035385,
-0.42399856448173523,
0.11520322412252426,
0.09939634799957275,
0.9063514471054077,
0.04080798476934433,
-0.07399864494800568,
-0.7013350129127502,
-0.10404501110315323,
-0.6246325373649597,
-0.27858445048332214,
-0.9707129597663879,
-0.2663574814796448,
0.2585172653198242,
1.0215827226638794,
0.34545373916625977,
0.7168019413948059,
0.6230567693710327,
0.4717365503311157,
0.1030956283211708,
0.21292395889759064,
-0.6703547239303589,
0.3871428072452545,
-0.04829975590109825,
-0.660871684551239,
-0.5020273923873901,
0.09779223054647446,
0.05740997567772865,
1.0479813814163208,
-0.32219818234443665,
0.4246865212917328,
0.23355433344841003,
0.9198569059371948,
-0.4733158349990845,
0.6286457180976868,
-0.429267019033432,
-0.17824554443359375,
0.10774335265159607,
-0.11936631798744202,
-0.19560354948043823,
-0.1768493950366974,
-0.07706959545612335,
-0.8738448619842529,
0.49460047483444214,
-0.01874275878071785,
0.3526383936405182,
0.8798221349716187,
0.023605143651366234,
-0.015145859681069851,
-0.5299968123435974,
0.9721547961235046,
-0.30292150378227234,
0.1322653591632843,
0.4993215799331665,
0.24462319910526276,
-0.3828928470611572,
-0.2132328450679779,
-0.22500507533550262,
-0.17902173101902008,
0.18251487612724304,
0.145785853266716,
0.04642152413725853,
0.14033274352550507,
0.2249932587146759,
0.13760361075401306,
-0.4752790927886963,
-0.0104635925963521,
-0.5665635466575623,
-0.17599080502986908,
0.9313745498657227,
0.38716375827789307,
0.6319330930709839,
-0.06532750278711319,
-0.18193037807941437,
0.007727599702775478,
-0.2548011839389801,
0.447008341550827,
0.20302516222000122,
0.2235233038663864,
0.2874089479446411,
0.2856529951095581,
-0.35742878913879395,
0.7623599171638489,
-0.052080847322940826,
-0.579818606376648,
0.37182852625846863,
-0.19253060221672058,
-0.34272411465644836,
-0.04731824994087219,
0.15945641696453094,
0.3976799547672272,
0.0073302933014929295,
-0.6375975608825684,
-0.3457755744457245,
-0.0019617853686213493,
0.5139464735984802,
-0.16083742678165436,
-0.5787237882614136,
0.20636612176895142,
-0.6377691030502319,
-0.14505967497825623,
-0.25081783533096313,
-0.18180076777935028,
-0.5732400417327881,
-0.46338602900505066,
0.4132446050643921,
-0.22245928645133972,
-0.39742252230644226,
0.16025686264038086,
-0.22921791672706604,
-0.011811251752078533,
0.5085362792015076,
-0.6720743179321289,
0.3942936956882477,
0.7342015504837036,
0.5431436896324158,
-0.18111440539360046,
-0.291000634431839,
-0.8696220517158508,
-0.17678755521774292,
-0.18183983862400055,
0.945817768573761,
-0.5075279474258423,
-0.4978652596473694,
-0.4789431691169739,
0.031105155125260353,
-0.03613211214542389,
-0.9487380385398865,
0.5766808986663818,
-0.25144246220588684,
-0.10923758894205093,
-0.5032723546028137,
-0.43646910786628723,
-0.08322764188051224,
0.3426129221916199,
-0.7466725707054138,
1.148328423500061,
0.37103790044784546,
-0.5635019540786743,
0.38770410418510437,
-0.9433070421218872,
-0.3259642720222473,
0.3037520945072174,
0.08858378231525421,
-0.5276551246643066,
0.18585684895515442,
-0.06289362162351608,
0.4855053722858429,
-0.26582953333854675,
-0.1227620542049408,
-0.29608362913131714,
-0.27838605642318726,
-0.08130689710378647,
0.22942638397216797,
0.8346210718154907,
0.002976276446133852,
-0.3288886845111847,
0.2834240198135376,
-0.785473644733429,
-0.017280371859669685,
0.15636469423770905,
-0.582461416721344,
-0.5150600671768188,
0.3454672396183014,
-0.06600427627563477,
0.26534366607666016,
0.26037466526031494,
-0.7374324202537537,
0.20037789642810822,
-0.4937155246734619,
0.0025783295277506113,
0.9424704909324646,
-0.027490202337503433,
0.47187674045562744,
-0.4376947283744812,
0.8521106243133545,
-0.2995745539665222,
0.023896487429738045,
0.08628355711698532,
-0.368390828371048,
-0.9322396516799927,
-0.26802054047584534,
0.10357055068016052,
0.6383599042892456,
-0.8273593187332153,
0.12897199392318726,
0.02601097896695137,
-0.3243773579597473,
-0.8149518966674805,
0.3970792889595032,
0.6880304217338562,
0.7900067567825317,
0.574596107006073,
-0.17835687100887299,
-0.7772713303565979,
-0.9078296422958374,
-0.1856662631034851,
-0.11862073093652725,
-0.36624354124069214,
0.2688479721546173,
0.3942246735095978,
-0.004051778465509415,
0.7278284430503845,
-0.6449546813964844,
-0.6509599685668945,
-0.3644227981567383,
0.25273600220680237,
-0.11590522527694702,
0.4279260039329529,
0.23416027426719666,
-0.7181292176246643,
-0.5180355906486511,
-0.15787340700626373,
-0.5290454626083374,
-0.16578350961208344,
-0.06507081538438797,
0.19373027980327606,
0.3436647653579712,
0.6190797090530396,
0.08335037529468536,
0.16864468157291412,
0.3865179717540741,
-0.4083331823348999,
0.46799662709236145,
-0.639491081237793,
0.26580575108528137,
-0.9198412895202637,
0.2663324475288391,
0.13017593324184418,
-0.4257536232471466,
-0.37125086784362793,
-0.004253016784787178,
-0.18365418910980225,
-0.16607432067394257,
-0.11961372941732407,
0.1260850876569748,
-0.7836495041847229,
-0.09925351291894913,
-0.39552566409111023,
0.17078550159931183,
-0.45559248328208923,
0.4860330820083618,
0.11600016802549362,
0.49293234944343567,
0.34691351652145386,
-0.3209332227706909,
0.5372505187988281,
0.0014993620570749044,
-0.38460004329681396,
0.5307479500770569,
-0.8381778001785278,
0.13420447707176208,
-0.3656913936138153,
-0.08080212026834488,
-1.2202951908111572,
-0.35842666029930115,
0.0356721431016922,
-0.4859444200992584,
0.07952902466058731,
-0.11671890318393707,
-0.29151785373687744,
-0.16158843040466309,
-0.2838411331176758,
0.4078933000564575,
0.5413858294487,
-0.20293927192687988,
0.27019941806793213,
0.8139714002609253,
-0.2413971871137619,
-0.6793710589408875,
-0.27696317434310913,
-0.19251321256160736,
0.051654841750860214,
-0.5817975997924805,
0.42637860774993896,
-0.3626951575279236,
-0.3347742557525635,
0.2677219808101654,
-0.31236571073532104,
-0.2329995185136795,
0.6379168033599854,
0.5445343852043152,
0.17067229747772217,
0.3157460689544678,
0.0790010318160057,
-0.22363121807575226,
-0.6062496900558472,
0.0999545231461525,
0.07920721173286438,
0.018068276345729828,
0.048202212899923325,
-0.4000578820705414,
-0.19434460997581482,
0.6062663793563843,
0.4595324397087097,
-0.42081135511398315,
0.5398185849189758,
0.40374648571014404,
-0.4391483962535858,
-0.44117242097854614,
-0.5206959247589111,
0.12326925247907639,
-0.4305539131164551,
0.6074886322021484,
-0.3220340311527252,
-0.6561528444290161,
0.4771854281425476,
0.010459402576088905,
0.13536208868026733,
0.15423963963985443,
0.45003822445869446,
-0.11599579453468323,
1.2352607250213623,
1.1330177783966064,
-0.1487383395433426,
0.3481243848800659,
-0.34859082102775574,
0.019372418522834778,
-0.5948543548583984,
-0.7749516367912292,
-0.6222224831581116,
-0.5692658424377441,
0.017113296315073967,
-0.5484875440597534,
0.5100131034851074,
0.09733763337135315,
0.06830815970897675,
0.3021604120731354,
-0.8818394541740417,
0.8500990867614746,
0.6892543435096741,
0.4887217581272125,
0.07216580212116241,
-0.3344453275203705,
0.14232543110847473,
0.049536410719156265,
-0.7591285705566406,
-0.07501186430454254,
0.8529993295669556,
0.23343132436275482,
0.49878183007240295,
-0.04063441604375839,
1.0165618658065796,
0.34653863310813904,
0.44046515226364136,
-1.0954927206039429,
0.5200424790382385,
-0.005536678247153759,
-0.2423374503850937,
-0.4761285185813904,
-0.3763495087623596,
-0.9580733180046082,
-0.28431907296180725,
-0.17415179312229156,
-0.6723423600196838,
-0.0517825186252594,
0.42520785331726074,
-0.5195204019546509,
0.00874971505254507,
-0.8146799802780151,
1.0906174182891846,
-0.11163625121116638,
-0.28954124450683594,
-0.43359556794166565,
-0.6576810479164124,
0.08656162023544312,
0.25298944115638733,
0.4507294297218323,
-0.12149830162525177,
-0.13749200105667114,
1.0966564416885376,
-0.5074004530906677,
0.9000261425971985,
-0.5135393738746643,
0.04923529177904129,
0.021771175786852837,
0.22299514710903168,
0.26524314284324646,
-0.10047247260808945,
-0.08512358367443085,
-0.46712973713874817,
-0.13472650945186615,
-0.7005916833877563,
-0.5640918016433716,
0.6580547094345093,
-0.626185417175293,
-0.6182271838188171,
-0.26469510793685913,
-0.6870392560958862,
-0.26062119007110596,
0.09286290407180786,
-0.17495520412921906,
0.2975476086139679,
-0.04697246849536896,
0.15220849215984344,
0.7216930985450745,
0.16726893186569214,
0.6879311800003052,
0.5037533044815063,
0.5347805023193359,
-0.12145382165908813,
0.9456479549407959,
0.02468080446124077,
-0.06220577657222748,
0.39194267988204956,
-0.07707671821117401,
-0.13579051196575165,
-0.8353216648101807,
-0.009358035400509834,
-0.10589626431465149,
-0.6964442729949951,
-0.3763323426246643,
-0.310683012008667,
0.4069334864616394,
-0.016422783955931664,
-0.39174139499664307,
-0.42127305269241333,
-0.2599750757217407,
-0.1604904681444168,
-0.05532138794660568,
0.024476684629917145,
0.7765704393386841,
-0.2396262139081955,
-0.47250765562057495,
-1.0631145238876343,
0.43092602491378784,
0.5056305527687073,
0.522601842880249,
-0.06367482244968414,
-0.06886018067598343,
-0.5922132730484009,
0.05861432105302811,
0.02143719792366028,
-0.8421758413314819,
0.3784431517124176,
0.1271311640739441,
1.104292869567871,
-0.11990047246217728,
0.31551679968833923,
0.7203823328018188,
-0.31357499957084656,
0.8656960129737854,
0.1168833076953888,
-1.065595030784607,
0.5696216225624084,
-0.12645603716373444,
0.23273460566997528,
0.6534508466720581,
0.5450567603111267,
-0.5825190544128418,
-0.2171853482723236,
-0.49078139662742615,
-0.9848201274871826,
0.9961490631103516,
-0.011290266178548336,
-0.42750847339630127,
-0.039174698293209076,
0.436470627784729,
0.09926966577768326,
-0.22980037331581116,
-0.44307518005371094,
-0.3623334467411041,
0.03284424543380737,
-0.279132604598999,
-0.31837955117225647,
-0.20188023149967194,
-0.14562076330184937,
-0.31711044907569885,
0.634716808795929,
-0.24178917706012726,
0.2881200313568115,
0.2324625551700592,
-0.4631860554218292,
-0.21870696544647217,
0.12443523854017258,
0.6260716915130615,
0.7496947050094604,
-0.09049803763628006,
-0.03198361024260521,
0.14035917818546295,
-0.08401916921138763,
0.1762460470199585,
0.028454827144742012,
0.4885130226612091,
-0.4968428909778595,
0.49651646614074707,
0.33731159567832947,
0.20463798940181732,
-1.0329532623291016,
0.4466331899166107,
-0.09551604092121124,
-0.3019667863845825,
-0.17979773879051208,
0.30669647455215454,
0.21665962040424347,
0.39607253670692444,
0.6274425387382507,
0.4568023383617401,
0.3193510174751282,
-0.5547333359718323,
0.2472713589668274,
0.4190084636211395,
-0.24880537390708923,
-0.49051961302757263,
0.7259638905525208,
0.5691063404083252,
-0.7456241250038147,
0.43626463413238525,
-0.5071302056312561,
-0.684174120426178,
0.8499965667724609,
0.3339554965496063,
0.9199943542480469,
-0.30126717686653137,
0.3518935739994049,
0.26922106742858887,
0.03577740862965584,
-0.27086594700813293,
0.41498667001724243,
-0.40940240025520325,
-0.5219082236289978,
-0.6645391583442688,
-0.44866856932640076,
-0.34305158257484436,
-0.10033507645130157,
-0.685565173625946,
-0.16718119382858276,
-0.0627317875623703,
0.32207760214805603,
0.045310214161872864,
0.15127819776535034,
-0.7261254787445068,
0.2344130426645279,
0.03213803470134735,
0.5953168272972107,
-1.0303337574005127,
0.6837972402572632,
1.2636102437973022,
-0.6229910254478455,
-0.9903055429458618,
-0.06842785328626633,
-0.011918105185031891,
-0.5831513404846191,
1.1445987224578857,
0.02973041497170925,
-0.25489887595176697,
-0.08958470076322556,
-0.4504440724849701,
-0.538327157497406,
0.9342921376228333,
0.5400828123092651,
-0.12722353637218475,
-0.2788788676261902,
-0.0689995065331459,
0.5195280313491821,
-0.16224391758441925,
0.2275160700082779,
0.4730921685695648,
0.29217374324798584,
-0.30736806988716125,
-1.4491713047027588,
0.0884096622467041,
-0.518187940120697,
-0.12272590398788452,
0.2911362946033478,
-0.5214319229125977,
0.5878507494926453,
-0.4056367874145508,
-0.06684964895248413,
-0.22067612409591675,
0.23254036903381348,
-0.20710988342761993,
0.2381727248430252,
0.7746931314468384,
0.41620391607284546,
0.7942935228347778,
0.09788553416728973,
0.7742108702659607,
-0.2361888438463211,
0.5395722985267639,
0.8740390539169312,
0.2863337993621826,
0.834664523601532,
0.45225295424461365,
-0.16129668056964874,
0.5250080227851868,
0.593779981136322,
0.42202597856521606,
0.5297980904579163,
0.24307100474834442,
-0.27830180525779724,
-0.8693628907203674,
0.053788527846336365,
0.012236585840582848,
0.740842878818512,
0.19546182453632355,
-0.07625839859247208,
-0.4113773703575134,
0.3165428340435028,
-0.17662543058395386,
0.356133371591568,
-0.4545946419239044,
1.023404836654663,
-0.28487929701805115,
-0.9749972224235535,
0.8373317718505859,
0.022399209439754486,
0.42158910632133484,
-0.33795446157455444,
-0.2996773421764374,
-0.08417453616857529,
0.495417982339859,
-0.5257012248039246,
-0.6302929520606995,
0.5412828922271729,
-0.27140024304389954,
-0.4933820366859436,
-0.47550490498542786,
0.6808905601501465,
-0.4616456627845764,
-0.2757909893989563,
0.1869603991508484,
0.35227805376052856,
-0.045307740569114685,
-0.17802050709724426,
-0.8121463060379028,
-0.0060247634537518024,
0.1970110982656479,
-0.06495650857686996,
0.3760722577571869,
0.02989991195499897,
0.10271385312080383,
1.0107430219650269,
0.29626724123954773,
-0.244304358959198,
-0.2496584951877594,
-0.4455867111682892,
0.9000592231750488,
-0.45078006386756897,
-0.33643704652786255,
-0.59962397813797,
1.0608086585998535,
-0.23709410429000854,
-0.0416933111846447,
0.7968014478683472,
0.6140859723091125,
0.9825738668441772,
-0.2730947434902191,
0.8986353278160095,
-0.03211243078112602,
0.640179455280304,
-0.24950969219207764,
0.4625547528266907,
-0.743790864944458,
0.337552547454834,
-0.39656078815460205,
-0.5220075845718384,
-0.526462972164154,
0.720230758190155,
-0.24405288696289062,
-0.23681989312171936,
0.5403195023536682,
0.6324406862258911,
0.00237843906506896,
-0.5129848718643188,
0.2798329293727875,
-0.3259406089782715,
0.2310560792684555,
0.8615709543228149,
0.3634115159511566,
-0.015245934017002583,
0.7485105395317078,
-0.4934524893760681,
-0.7416199445724487,
-0.34573376178741455,
-0.7703249454498291,
-0.8488776683807373,
-0.7937825322151184,
-0.6197556853294373,
-0.1964728683233261,
0.11432156711816788,
1.3033666610717773,
0.7513546943664551,
-0.7072186470031738,
-0.2714451253414154,
-0.16612643003463745,
0.2169232815504074,
-0.6761200428009033,
-0.21454675495624542,
0.4272741973400116,
-0.7543041706085205,
-0.7881091833114624,
0.6986407041549683,
0.19868212938308716,
-0.5416390895843506,
-0.10537245124578476,
-0.11316882818937302,
0.07573205977678299,
-0.2666836678981781,
0.574019193649292,
0.5152396559715271,
-0.36398181319236755,
-0.5325745940208435,
0.3246881663799286,
0.2844020426273346,
0.04101581126451492,
1.1235461235046387,
-0.9161373972892761,
0.8674939274787903,
0.8096869587898254,
0.9581530094146729,
0.21369783580303192,
0.13400273025035858,
0.5963645577430725,
-0.984184205532074,
0.020901573821902275,
0.3141304850578308,
0.4604737162590027,
0.09895990788936615,
-0.4263036549091339,
0.34698566794395447,
0.36605387926101685,
-0.8127915263175964,
-0.8623761534690857,
0.18916338682174683,
-1.0054075717926025,
-0.4640326201915741,
0.9857998490333557,
-0.3834318518638611,
-0.313016414642334,
-0.5644546747207642,
-0.42203161120414734,
0.30192679166793823,
-0.30333566665649414,
1.0745099782943726,
0.2533618211746216,
-0.6339825987815857,
-0.18734435737133026,
-0.10842543840408325,
0.9218528866767883,
0.4468892812728882,
-0.9482375979423523,
0.08857527375221252,
0.6304190754890442,
0.6524576544761658,
0.2146168202161789,
0.9048847556114197,
0.23955106735229492,
0.6246557235717773,
0.11376343667507172,
0.25411656498908997,
-0.6305756568908691,
-0.20907919108867645,
-0.17783033847808838,
0.5391703248023987,
0.3246479332447052,
-0.5367834568023682
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.04595v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.04595v1
|
Pitch-Aware RNN-T for Mandarin Chinese Mispronunciation Detection and Diagnosis
| 2024-06-07T02:59:58 | 2024-06-07T02:59:58 |
Xintong Wang, Mingqian Shi, Ye Wang
|
cs.SD
|
cs.SD, cs.CL, eess.AS
|
Mispronunciation Detection and Diagnosis (MDD) systems, leveraging Automatic
Speech Recognition (ASR), face two main challenges in Mandarin Chinese: 1) The
two-stage models create an information gap between the phoneme or tone
classification stage and the MDD stage. 2) The scarcity of Mandarin MDD
datasets limits model training. In this paper, we introduce a stateless RNN-T
model for Mandarin MDD, utilizing HuBERT features with pitch embedding through
a Pitch Fusion Block. Our model, trained solely on native speaker data, shows a
3% improvement in Phone Error Rate and a 7% increase in False Acceptance Rate
over the state-of-the-art baseline in non-native scenarios
|
[
-0.1212848424911499,
-0.34642869234085083,
0.06889408081769943,
0.6687495708465576,
-0.36488741636276245,
0.025526046752929688,
0.028113873675465584,
-0.30834096670150757,
0.24134787917137146,
0.33978450298309326,
-0.2828056216239929,
-0.6008070707321167,
-0.15046387910842896,
0.11381746083498001,
-0.36223894357681274,
0.5964369177818298,
0.18462690711021423,
0.35881543159484863,
0.3173302710056305,
-0.07740586996078491,
-0.3356265127658844,
-0.22682419419288635,
-1.1348110437393188,
-0.3702152669429779,
0.18525269627571106,
0.6955009698867798,
0.5367062091827393,
0.7198912501335144,
0.37320080399513245,
0.09250707924365997,
-0.13462114334106445,
-0.08452478796243668,
-0.012452658265829086,
0.06458467245101929,
0.2926977872848511,
-0.1683933436870575,
-0.6419128179550171,
-0.09699051827192307,
0.5467185378074646,
0.5437439680099487,
-0.40837764739990234,
-0.2381836622953415,
-0.10304304212331772,
0.5229806303977966,
-0.21107029914855957,
-0.08875495940446854,
-0.4942632019519806,
0.43481746315956116,
-0.21316154301166534,
-0.2662827670574188,
-0.12322390079498291,
-0.3880375027656555,
0.2609117031097412,
-0.6255252361297607,
0.5861052870750427,
-0.06959307938814163,
0.6780410408973694,
0.25885844230651855,
-0.28375548124313354,
0.022427277639508247,
-0.7726497054100037,
0.34352654218673706,
-0.7879506945610046,
0.3921322524547577,
0.4050205945968628,
0.3943040668964386,
-0.11845073848962784,
-0.1871699094772339,
-0.585339367389679,
-0.4804227352142334,
0.20194217562675476,
0.17010818421840668,
0.14291614294052124,
0.5497785210609436,
0.3583585321903229,
0.617883026599884,
-0.8235757946968079,
0.3436294198036194,
-0.46067339181900024,
-0.42440491914749146,
0.540382981300354,
-0.05570578947663307,
0.4590131938457489,
-0.5956308245658875,
-0.4289778769016266,
0.2414029985666275,
-0.6284918189048767,
0.007321509998291731,
0.1262819468975067,
0.6364567279815674,
-0.34673815965652466,
0.5096246600151062,
-0.14031089842319489,
0.7734377980232239,
0.14735320210456848,
-0.41687464714050293,
0.330406129360199,
-0.12914295494556427,
-0.33104875683784485,
0.5367791652679443,
0.743233323097229,
-0.006705774925649166,
0.3565371036529541,
0.10279527306556702,
-0.6057855486869812,
-0.03157859295606613,
-0.11728295683860779,
-0.40973201394081116,
-0.5488482713699341,
0.5222234129905701,
-0.40906429290771484,
-0.3414689898490906,
0.01805036887526512,
-0.12074720859527588,
-0.6593608856201172,
-0.09704212844371796,
0.6099308729171753,
-0.5350183844566345,
-0.9113482236862183,
0.003311091335490346,
-0.40321001410484314,
0.16170579195022583,
0.06059429049491882,
-0.7016850113868713,
0.10012532770633698,
0.4565187394618988,
1.1267454624176025,
-0.14427363872528076,
-0.08043446391820908,
-0.4190555214881897,
-0.18550273776054382,
-0.6623430848121643,
0.5752606987953186,
-0.05128210783004761,
-0.6242342591285706,
-0.16287408769130707,
-0.3083314001560211,
-0.4227352440357208,
-1.0616170167922974,
0.4215752184391022,
0.10730347037315369,
-0.11446500569581985,
-0.033336229622364044,
-0.3148978650569916,
-0.09133703261613846,
0.2932538092136383,
-0.7213512659072876,
1.2124323844909668,
0.45777106285095215,
-0.6617356538772583,
0.4735056161880493,
-0.7697204351425171,
-0.8592286705970764,
-0.003419932909309864,
-0.11715571582317352,
-0.5346711277961731,
0.00794900581240654,
0.21181753277778625,
0.498309850692749,
-0.13900387287139893,
0.533690333366394,
-0.057251594960689545,
-0.3438405394554138,
-0.028891650959849358,
-0.480328768491745,
0.8525033593177795,
0.1864752620458603,
-0.4189125895500183,
0.18524986505508423,
-1.0413970947265625,
-0.13342423737049103,
0.000014880299204378389,
-0.47049471735954285,
-0.12356942892074585,
-0.34159764647483826,
0.2707298994064331,
0.4626651108264923,
0.04018496721982956,
-0.5719618797302246,
-0.07296853512525558,
-0.44896602630615234,
0.18079620599746704,
0.3497094213962555,
0.17186351120471954,
0.1626177579164505,
-0.6769573092460632,
0.5239489674568176,
0.5750871896743774,
0.12779156863689423,
-0.21491986513137817,
-0.7225093841552734,
-0.919518232345581,
-0.29459330439567566,
0.20990172028541565,
0.9131882786750793,
-0.8392968773841858,
0.3804496228694916,
0.021999044343829155,
-0.3115943670272827,
-0.8735092282295227,
-0.08648798614740372,
0.4879955053329468,
0.7442044019699097,
0.5464919805526733,
-0.15382562577724457,
-0.7124060988426208,
-0.7814146280288696,
-0.29509228467941284,
-0.13459232449531555,
-0.2589956521987915,
0.24830861389636993,
-0.06672581285238266,
0.24534064531326294,
0.6073243618011475,
0.1259438842535019,
-0.6905015707015991,
-0.5128234624862671,
-0.06072404980659485,
0.27957794070243835,
0.7185668349266052,
0.11565738916397095,
-0.9159526228904724,
-0.5478976368904114,
0.298904687166214,
-0.6083080768585205,
-0.1916893869638443,
-0.24748055636882782,
0.6244139671325684,
0.4484209418296814,
0.47747907042503357,
-0.4251227378845215,
0.588586151599884,
0.392305850982666,
-0.2978842854499817,
0.6061058640480042,
-0.40357881784439087,
0.1504591405391693,
-1.2457400560379028,
0.14198477566242218,
0.2846708297729492,
-0.23471733927726746,
-1.1570323705673218,
-0.4602551758289337,
0.33064231276512146,
-0.22378486394882202,
-0.38744086027145386,
0.27861809730529785,
-0.5041514039039612,
-0.3213755488395691,
-0.20692701637744904,
0.30836737155914307,
-0.12166905403137207,
0.054362352937459946,
0.2747919261455536,
0.5241992473602295,
0.5587911605834961,
-1.0284032821655273,
0.35099005699157715,
0.02552471123635769,
-0.3005380630493164,
0.5107848048210144,
-0.7514578700065613,
-0.2583112120628357,
0.26501041650772095,
0.1186620369553566,
-0.8758866190910339,
-0.17408926784992218,
0.2984239161014557,
-0.798985481262207,
0.4771794378757477,
-0.3141537010669708,
-0.22615429759025574,
-0.6711998581886292,
0.029167603701353073,
0.39246436953544617,
0.3279856741428375,
-0.6466666460037231,
0.46179333329200745,
0.07538260519504547,
0.14320842921733856,
-0.5952386260032654,
-0.6785537004470825,
-0.01150281261652708,
-0.15950743854045868,
-0.7169018387794495,
0.4228056073188782,
0.29574188590049744,
-0.04601007327437401,
-0.29791274666786194,
-0.4080955982208252,
-0.41436004638671875,
0.1349056512117386,
0.13545390963554382,
0.1447797417640686,
-0.5810533761978149,
0.1489793062210083,
-0.1012980043888092,
-0.36991414427757263,
-0.29122602939605713,
-0.5077410936355591,
0.5167002081871033,
0.4687763452529907,
-0.31641656160354614,
-0.8849430084228516,
0.14308203756809235,
0.6902669072151184,
-0.37555554509162903,
0.4061949849128723,
0.7827509045600891,
-0.7296509146690369,
-0.38850003480911255,
-0.5000132918357849,
-0.14416855573654175,
-0.44917866587638855,
0.2798387110233307,
-0.37613528966903687,
-0.5963651537895203,
0.5559058785438538,
0.3668535053730011,
-0.2029796987771988,
0.2529847323894501,
0.10273808985948563,
-0.03659479320049286,
0.7313329577445984,
0.41152483224868774,
-0.3100053071975708,
0.30045437812805176,
-0.1631021350622177,
0.3104921579360962,
-0.9947150945663452,
-0.3938303291797638,
-0.38579311966896057,
-0.03796624392271042,
-0.44037503004074097,
-0.7152034640312195,
0.47176793217658997,
0.15430612862110138,
-0.4204727113246918,
0.2102188766002655,
-0.40423932671546936,
0.24791677296161652,
0.5340380668640137,
0.186298206448555,
0.2885395884513855,
-0.3357097804546356,
-0.20139524340629578,
-0.1211913600564003,
-0.7847804427146912,
0.16263233125209808,
0.9098244905471802,
0.23128345608711243,
0.4662347137928009,
-0.08607814460992813,
0.6368094682693481,
0.18728114664554596,
-0.08878980576992035,
-0.9914137721061707,
0.22755064070224762,
-0.2964339852333069,
-0.6090441942214966,
-0.3733893036842346,
-0.5595009922981262,
-0.4087343215942383,
0.34383559226989746,
-0.21815641224384308,
-0.4667944610118866,
0.10612780600786209,
0.3915557265281677,
-0.6646356582641602,
0.5967639088630676,
-0.35078781843185425,
0.7951251864433289,
-0.172333762049675,
0.48143404722213745,
-0.04217712581157684,
-0.4165046811103821,
0.6358689069747925,
0.057069215923547745,
-0.058430880308151245,
-0.3209734857082367,
0.25973859429359436,
0.6817565560340881,
-0.35134801268577576,
0.44681963324546814,
-0.7401974201202393,
-0.12774251401424408,
0.16570498049259186,
0.19507953524589539,
0.3577701151371002,
-0.008215310052037239,
-0.10094065964221954,
0.04551016166806221,
-0.4425504207611084,
-0.16567398607730865,
-0.4362083375453949,
0.507935643196106,
-0.2722628116607666,
-0.5449808835983276,
-0.3980819284915924,
-0.41089606285095215,
-0.19219979643821716,
0.08867575973272324,
0.4015521705150604,
0.5689378380775452,
-0.19877974689006805,
-0.04606538265943527,
0.8466038703918457,
-0.45463961362838745,
0.47887977957725525,
0.4788956940174103,
-0.32426902651786804,
-0.28877297043800354,
1.0618722438812256,
0.30586665868759155,
0.5376564264297485,
0.30790770053863525,
0.35377874970436096,
-0.17162150144577026,
-0.6178300380706787,
-0.4446118175983429,
0.12349075824022293,
-0.2353266328573227,
-0.23053988814353943,
-0.7283072471618652,
-0.7416273355484009,
-0.5061364769935608,
-0.0018017523689195514,
-0.6012200117111206,
-0.5598427653312683,
-0.4159090518951416,
-0.22757001221179962,
0.5284514427185059,
0.6949588060379028,
-0.5077885985374451,
0.2929438054561615,
-0.5875770449638367,
0.9431120157241821,
-0.12983864545822144,
0.3380810618400574,
0.20505766570568085,
-0.8201497793197632,
-0.18734747171401978,
0.12129487097263336,
0.08222679048776627,
-0.5024378895759583,
0.5503469109535217,
0.5207895040512085,
0.2206900268793106,
0.9484635591506958,
0.2660949230194092,
0.7372045516967773,
-0.23393528163433075,
0.8227734565734863,
0.22712016105651855,
-1.0298055410385132,
0.7568045854568481,
-0.5241454243659973,
0.27412667870521545,
0.05757680907845497,
0.2682477831840515,
-1.1206276416778564,
-0.27427682280540466,
-0.36407530307769775,
-0.631947934627533,
0.895190417766571,
-0.0680130273103714,
-0.38247910141944885,
0.12221618741750717,
0.13808900117874146,
-0.1965852677822113,
-0.15198351442813873,
-0.4400576055049896,
-0.49295806884765625,
-0.22153380513191223,
-0.15787775814533234,
-0.1397913247346878,
-0.06642110645771027,
0.2880796194076538,
-0.5849074125289917,
0.5473620891571045,
0.10729740560054779,
0.20800603926181793,
0.48924520611763,
-0.08473776280879974,
-0.03984883055090904,
-0.062391139566898346,
0.7170942425727844,
0.27883344888687134,
-0.26475661993026733,
-0.16125370562076569,
0.17523600161075592,
-0.6261699795722961,
0.15356352925300598,
0.04396561160683632,
-0.21600475907325745,
0.3213820159435272,
0.14644671976566315,
0.7235840559005737,
0.37508678436279297,
-0.2340763807296753,
0.7010672092437744,
0.16168667376041412,
-0.26544636487960815,
-0.45307835936546326,
0.03990941494703293,
0.22830720245838165,
-0.007682999595999718,
0.49545609951019287,
0.3033696413040161,
0.029630351811647415,
-0.006016870960593224,
0.4825834333896637,
0.20618018507957458,
-0.7656246423721313,
-0.23923653364181519,
0.559047281742096,
0.16336484253406525,
-0.5533373355865479,
0.7474580407142639,
-0.1959732323884964,
-0.9085354804992676,
0.9012552499771118,
0.9303980469703674,
0.8551120758056641,
-0.8929848074913025,
0.4647550582885742,
0.47398945689201355,
0.45597371459007263,
-0.3280033469200134,
0.6313629150390625,
0.07758913189172745,
-0.9189105033874512,
-0.005054734647274017,
-0.31537091732025146,
-0.24037520587444305,
0.36246785521507263,
-0.9031911492347717,
0.40996649861335754,
-0.8657363653182983,
0.028490588068962097,
-0.27553218603134155,
-0.17723076045513153,
-0.22045157849788666,
0.5384109616279602,
0.13068731129169464,
1.0281949043273926,
-0.6001048684120178,
0.9442456364631653,
0.16996222734451294,
-0.22652709484100342,
-1.0196512937545776,
0.1282949149608612,
0.21613715589046478,
-0.7674494385719299,
0.21258921921253204,
0.43534156680107117,
0.09437548369169235,
0.11223515123128891,
-0.08055445551872253,
-0.7241473197937012,
1.0037122964859009,
0.19546663761138916,
-0.31474569439888,
0.27214881777763367,
0.20742665231227875,
0.34105750918388367,
-0.3737412989139557,
-0.023751746863126755,
0.845899760723114,
0.4780368506908417,
0.08402494341135025,
-1.431913137435913,
-0.1327723115682602,
-0.08958658576011658,
0.013968182727694511,
0.17666926980018616,
-0.4284433126449585,
1.0518757104873657,
-0.49923864006996155,
-0.5047674775123596,
-0.06075218319892883,
0.4925134479999542,
0.2330486923456192,
0.5191593766212463,
0.4390529990196228,
0.5894688963890076,
1.029968500137329,
-0.20138461887836456,
0.6828035116195679,
-0.3144027888774872,
-0.019150221720337868,
0.8877964615821838,
-0.05024510622024536,
0.9704330563545227,
0.036858610808849335,
-0.013441585004329681,
0.015726706013083458,
0.8631443977355957,
0.1064382791519165,
0.15915554761886597,
0.3835602402687073,
-0.5645784735679626,
-0.20378965139389038,
-0.15145637094974518,
-0.5806671380996704,
0.6120909452438354,
0.6443406343460083,
-0.16437579691410065,
-0.00323873502202332,
0.17696841061115265,
-0.1372511088848114,
-0.050878312438726425,
-0.5052355527877808,
0.628882110118866,
0.3225097954273224,
-0.21223591268062592,
0.869648277759552,
0.00873285997658968,
1.0812783241271973,
-0.37405574321746826,
-0.055919814854860306,
-0.5071178674697876,
0.08810438215732574,
-0.5156965851783752,
-0.3610098958015442,
0.19881069660186768,
-0.013324285857379436,
-0.31365126371383667,
0.21933625638484955,
0.4932180941104889,
-0.7370017170906067,
-0.323755145072937,
0.4202266037464142,
0.3821359872817993,
0.1591660976409912,
-0.3100596070289612,
-0.5662925839424133,
-0.38050442934036255,
-0.012663866393268108,
0.310499906539917,
0.027810899540781975,
0.3689044415950775,
0.13393466174602509,
1.0178550481796265,
0.5815709829330444,
0.3780111074447632,
0.21723024547100067,
0.3460841178894043,
0.4488060474395752,
-0.9156082272529602,
-0.6072795391082764,
-0.5116785168647766,
0.367302805185318,
0.04881628230214119,
-0.45794937014579773,
0.5216079354286194,
0.5898194313049316,
0.8343788385391235,
0.038521382957696915,
0.9679796099662781,
0.079962819814682,
0.8181313872337341,
-0.46279793977737427,
1.3527480363845825,
-0.4062824845314026,
0.09649809449911118,
-0.17794646322727203,
-0.7258680462837219,
-0.6329410672187805,
0.7305932641029358,
0.2446417212486267,
0.1337963193655014,
0.5981249809265137,
0.944534957408905,
-0.04252789169549942,
0.17791742086410522,
0.5890055298805237,
0.12499935179948807,
0.1900232583284378,
0.42898765206336975,
0.5981221199035645,
-0.5146564245223999,
0.3037165701389313,
-0.43636465072631836,
-0.052085574716329575,
-0.44847214221954346,
-0.3829042315483093,
-0.8152645230293274,
-0.5961160063743591,
-0.22366106510162354,
-0.5793222188949585,
-0.006246272940188646,
1.2337077856063843,
0.6004069447517395,
-1.1216745376586914,
-0.3395790457725525,
0.014958973042666912,
0.34366336464881897,
-0.4058857560157776,
-0.24581363797187805,
0.46658965945243835,
-0.17042648792266846,
-0.33716797828674316,
0.9005240201950073,
0.3361160159111023,
0.3789129853248596,
-0.09667924791574478,
-0.1080862507224083,
-0.0401206836104393,
-0.1439291387796402,
0.19774484634399414,
0.6559035181999207,
-0.6876383423805237,
-0.11403092741966248,
-0.034413956105709076,
-0.09855452179908752,
0.35936424136161804,
0.9430155158042908,
-0.5136452913284302,
0.5669929385185242,
0.14985990524291992,
0.451212078332901,
0.0016548436833545566,
0.10303259640932083,
0.7356282472610474,
-0.654252827167511,
0.23321449756622314,
0.39639630913734436,
0.22111600637435913,
0.74033123254776,
-0.4122864603996277,
0.09164736419916153,
0.49828410148620605,
-0.05845078453421593,
-0.8371343016624451,
0.012197053991258144,
-0.8817880153656006,
0.2076869010925293,
1.1009150743484497,
-0.20177879929542542,
-0.04537491127848625,
-0.7121179103851318,
-0.029737677425146103,
0.4078126847743988,
-0.41097292304039,
0.6226720213890076,
0.15016262233257294,
-0.07822507619857788,
-0.0786018893122673,
-0.3713683485984802,
0.9390131235122681,
0.17116525769233704,
-0.24832658469676971,
0.058155227452516556,
0.21736708283424377,
0.38235387206077576,
-0.09905700385570526,
0.8610635995864868,
0.028259754180908203,
0.6716746687889099,
0.32974985241889954,
0.18363946676254272,
-0.36033445596694946,
-0.7332512736320496,
-0.8096190690994263,
-0.21669870615005493,
0.024735838174819946,
-0.46657174825668335
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.04583v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.04583v1
|
Extroversion or Introversion? Controlling The Personality of Your Large Language Models
| 2024-06-07T02:11:49 | 2024-06-07T02:11:49 |
Yanquan Chen, Zhen Wu, Junjie Guo, Shujian Huang, Xinyu Dai
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) exhibit robust capabilities in text generation
and comprehension, mimicking human behavior and exhibiting synthetic
personalities. However, some LLMs have displayed offensive personality,
propagating toxic discourse. Existing literature neglects the origin and
evolution of LLM personalities, as well as the effective personality control.
To fill these gaps, our study embarked on a comprehensive investigation into
LLM personality control. We investigated several typical methods to influence
LLMs, including three training methods: Continual Pre-training, Supervised
Fine-Tuning (SFT), and Reinforcement Learning from Human Feedback (RLHF), along
with inference phase considerations (prompts). Our investigation revealed a
hierarchy of effectiveness in control: Prompt > SFT > RLHF > Continual
Pre-train. Notably, SFT exhibits a higher control success rate compared to
prompt induction. While prompts prove highly effective, we found that
prompt-induced personalities are less robust than those trained, making them
more prone to showing conflicting personalities under reverse personality
prompt induction. Besides, harnessing the strengths of both SFT and prompt, we
proposed $\underline{\text{P}}$rompt $\underline{\text{I}}$nduction post
$\underline{\text{S}}$upervised $\underline{\text{F}}$ine-tuning (PISF), which
emerges as the most effective and robust strategy for controlling LLMs'
personality, displaying high efficacy, high success rates, and high robustness.
Even under reverse personality prompt induction, LLMs controlled by PISF still
exhibit stable and robust personalities.
|
[
-0.4954448342323303,
-0.8505443334579468,
0.6291068196296692,
0.40792325139045715,
-0.031143978238105774,
0.09354431927204132,
-0.5810328125953674,
-0.10448005795478821,
0.07895959913730621,
0.4070916771888733,
-0.6255800127983093,
-0.17037715017795563,
-0.6119542121887207,
0.20946191251277924,
0.07717693597078323,
1.0632890462875366,
0.05646153911948204,
0.13378241658210754,
0.20785470306873322,
-0.08004564791917801,
-0.40085744857788086,
-0.815848708152771,
-0.8149863481521606,
-0.7336554527282715,
1.043871521949768,
0.37961167097091675,
0.6581857800483704,
0.4586610198020935,
0.26594775915145874,
0.2951757609844208,
-0.3488905727863312,
-0.06713370978832245,
-0.5826892256736755,
0.3203575313091278,
-0.5465280413627625,
-0.556557297706604,
-0.2747955024242401,
0.11268222332000732,
0.6074443459510803,
0.44168633222579956,
-0.26018017530441284,
-0.13350829482078552,
0.11546207219362259,
0.7729204893112183,
-0.5689668655395508,
0.024408146739006042,
-0.5708760619163513,
-0.014069522731006145,
-0.12881968915462494,
-0.30834871530532837,
-0.5874539613723755,
-0.4368171691894531,
-0.11433148384094238,
-0.08930106461048126,
-0.2619609236717224,
0.009984374046325684,
0.5454587340354919,
0.2886096239089966,
-0.5762328505516052,
-0.42465734481811523,
-0.99122554063797,
0.5529402494430542,
-0.651995837688446,
0.2418481707572937,
0.3747555911540985,
0.12458363175392151,
-0.2555810511112213,
-0.19645102322101593,
-0.49808967113494873,
-0.45334550738334656,
-0.0987795740365982,
0.09403673559427261,
0.08007516711950302,
0.03309527039527893,
0.27739807963371277,
0.08714190125465393,
-0.36513593792915344,
0.696372389793396,
0.03292163461446762,
-0.06137226149439812,
0.4072231352329254,
0.22524656355381012,
0.05848369374871254,
0.09247162193059921,
-0.04121159389615059,
-0.23458273708820343,
-1.077365756034851,
0.2298155277967453,
0.5057296752929688,
0.16001662611961365,
-0.009948848746716976,
0.7084842920303345,
-0.149338960647583,
0.2553503215312958,
0.6241536140441895,
-0.27371060848236084,
-0.11345627158880234,
-0.1548871099948883,
-0.01567733846604824,
-0.15540598332881927,
0.7617926597595215,
0.09816370159387589,
0.6056428551673889,
-0.06985247135162354,
-0.37703001499176025,
-0.028319500386714935,
0.2914445400238037,
-0.6445844769477844,
-0.18510174751281738,
0.27383866906166077,
-0.36954551935195923,
-0.3524676561355591,
-0.03614984452724457,
-0.5987093448638916,
-0.5262234807014465,
-0.4316236972808838,
0.3048810660839081,
-0.5622914433479309,
-0.29459547996520996,
-0.2845948040485382,
0.10950387269258499,
0.6241388916969299,
0.25219640135765076,
-1.3087656497955322,
0.17490456998348236,
0.6147400140762329,
0.7469791769981384,
-0.3485673666000366,
-0.3321252167224884,
-0.6210822463035583,
-0.015965906903147697,
-0.34031859040260315,
0.5162808895111084,
-0.5058027505874634,
-0.3802753686904907,
0.04165571182966232,
0.0019312200602144003,
-0.03349165618419647,
-0.5803902745246887,
0.24979768693447113,
-0.5996919870376587,
0.213787242770195,
-0.2899389863014221,
-0.39580070972442627,
0.12439465522766113,
0.09559901803731918,
-0.25660431385040283,
0.6577133536338806,
0.12358178943395615,
-0.5771400332450867,
0.3190339505672455,
-0.31706947088241577,
-0.38534125685691833,
-0.17400650680065155,
-0.2744850218296051,
-0.35210201144218445,
0.12219152599573135,
0.03263655677437782,
0.6471339464187622,
0.2571863532066345,
0.11131349205970764,
-0.44031766057014465,
-0.19574864208698273,
0.6695407032966614,
-0.0517837256193161,
0.6597484350204468,
0.007074898574501276,
-0.4280025064945221,
0.5188528895378113,
-0.41843634843826294,
-0.01875319704413414,
0.10125192254781723,
-0.37250909209251404,
-0.2175433486700058,
0.07239244878292084,
-0.32605186104774475,
0.37105393409729004,
0.0936785340309143,
-0.47935396432876587,
0.17588897049427032,
-0.40049979090690613,
0.40189534425735474,
1.0449888706207275,
0.2578059732913971,
0.5640315413475037,
-0.6134909391403198,
0.539484441280365,
-0.12194688618183136,
0.02504928968846798,
-0.19451764225959778,
-0.2025381624698639,
-0.527878999710083,
-0.15337494015693665,
-0.41763216257095337,
0.5921611785888672,
-0.5082667469978333,
0.767922580242157,
0.07330147922039032,
-0.7059067487716675,
-0.054546743631362915,
0.29633817076683044,
0.5504236221313477,
0.3301559090614319,
0.28588512539863586,
-0.23832742869853973,
-0.1045575886964798,
-0.7721620202064514,
-0.35918623208999634,
-0.28831061720848083,
-0.17982861399650574,
0.3224850296974182,
0.49018383026123047,
-0.06878745555877686,
0.5955221056938171,
-0.22195182740688324,
0.015716752037405968,
-0.5105199813842773,
0.08557403832674026,
0.25793007016181946,
0.5760972499847412,
0.41342034935951233,
-0.6781550049781799,
-0.7634894847869873,
-0.03158016875386238,
-0.35906144976615906,
-0.3127173185348511,
-0.24382129311561584,
-0.001867057872004807,
0.39011871814727783,
0.6808445453643799,
-0.5566783547401428,
0.15089203417301178,
0.28869932889938354,
-0.3535216450691223,
0.9620490074157715,
-0.11076461523771286,
-0.2276415377855301,
-0.5324633121490479,
0.047712959349155426,
-0.0976538136601448,
-0.3220911920070648,
-0.5606992244720459,
0.2326337993144989,
0.19653375446796417,
0.33270615339279175,
-0.38027843832969666,
0.32169851660728455,
-0.3924383819103241,
0.28779712319374084,
-0.26719900965690613,
-0.04375888779759407,
-0.27868059277534485,
0.9216658473014832,
0.08769246935844421,
0.5420153737068176,
0.4427677094936371,
-0.8291448950767517,
0.48937368392944336,
0.2429376095533371,
-0.1689579039812088,
0.8414388298988342,
-0.7193983197212219,
0.43128257989883423,
-0.49593260884284973,
0.397257924079895,
-0.8891028761863708,
-0.30008092522621155,
0.37577229738235474,
-0.2241056263446808,
0.7174869775772095,
0.23127390444278717,
-0.46245551109313965,
-0.04595598205924034,
-0.2722163200378418,
-0.3988351821899414,
0.5867143869400024,
-0.4849288761615753,
0.5908173322677612,
-0.09690570831298828,
-0.5933080315589905,
-0.21864309906959534,
-0.7329679131507874,
-0.20415668189525604,
-0.42578327655792236,
-0.06820577383041382,
0.15442955493927002,
-0.5148043036460876,
-0.541100263595581,
-0.42251312732696533,
-0.020851310342550278,
0.20318840444087982,
0.11091198772192001,
0.23751525580883026,
0.1407000869512558,
0.09280893951654434,
0.178170308470726,
0.24490411579608917,
-0.04569866508245468,
0.21048599481582642,
-0.03686181828379631,
0.7288984060287476,
-0.02841506153345108,
-0.2332465648651123,
-0.6070621609687805,
0.3016999065876007,
0.6807411909103394,
-0.1783222258090973,
0.9535555243492126,
0.32232654094696045,
0.25628411769866943,
-0.25237879157066345,
-0.5097506046295166,
-0.48364323377609253,
-0.46047720313072205,
0.3311346173286438,
-0.36524125933647156,
-1.0690211057662964,
0.5263952016830444,
-0.01747100241482258,
0.1442304402589798,
0.054637547582387924,
1.0623226165771484,
-0.24244704842567444,
1.0689029693603516,
0.6148935556411743,
0.038310084491968155,
0.7315565347671509,
0.22650866210460663,
0.010035744868218899,
-0.9514720439910889,
-0.22278307378292084,
-0.4521566331386566,
-0.49082911014556885,
-0.6882910132408142,
0.016012806445360184,
0.293078750371933,
-0.09746767580509186,
-0.778298020362854,
0.05372967943549156,
-0.28091490268707275,
0.47277387976646423,
0.21377573907375336,
0.3142414093017578,
0.2829209864139557,
-0.5224305987358093,
0.015620270743966103,
-0.14694327116012573,
-0.45493748784065247,
-0.37697073817253113,
1.115310549736023,
0.6358118057250977,
1.0585638284683228,
0.4729602336883545,
0.3850529193878174,
-0.0969068706035614,
0.5744985342025757,
-0.6935973167419434,
0.4154595136642456,
0.08992020785808563,
-0.645373523235321,
-0.3270694613456726,
-0.31877419352531433,
-0.49144577980041504,
0.23072493076324463,
-0.01093246042728424,
-1.0704498291015625,
0.270029753446579,
0.404891699552536,
-0.5303940176963806,
0.12468951940536499,
-0.7638002038002014,
0.5225656628608704,
-0.3981756865978241,
-0.6389811635017395,
-0.08133088797330856,
-0.9739099740982056,
0.4186455011367798,
-0.37761762738227844,
-0.1903543621301651,
0.08010123670101166,
-0.174354687333107,
0.28675970435142517,
-0.07317952066659927,
1.0274335145950317,
-0.10879972577095032,
-0.33991560339927673,
-0.1435176432132721,
0.2834587097167969,
1.0733933448791504,
0.24640455842018127,
-0.048590920865535736,
-0.28968551754951477,
-0.025184405967593193,
-0.29855042695999146,
-0.7328320145606995,
0.6453754305839539,
-0.9765734076499939,
-0.6516690850257874,
-0.2477009892463684,
-0.2848939597606659,
-0.48238468170166016,
0.16593661904335022,
0.5961127877235413,
0.2152012586593628,
-0.2612454891204834,
0.36251142621040344,
1.060051679611206,
-0.37104007601737976,
0.3791675865650177,
0.8504907488822937,
-0.559508740901947,
-0.12852664291858673,
0.5712336301803589,
-0.041672855615615845,
0.748500406742096,
0.510063886642456,
0.4313890337944031,
-0.2806588113307953,
-0.35211077332496643,
0.03293398395180702,
0.4565543532371521,
-0.586992084980011,
0.0720173716545105,
-0.6317101120948792,
-0.1306619495153427,
-0.5216729044914246,
-0.17775940895080566,
-0.39296525716781616,
0.02429543063044548,
-0.3934982120990753,
0.06824827194213867,
0.11081576347351074,
0.9043439626693726,
0.12781673669815063,
0.7812140583992004,
-0.2214299440383911,
-0.02970094233751297,
0.33434122800827026,
0.35806313157081604,
-0.015205474570393562,
-0.6656261682510376,
-0.09540633112192154,
-0.1968757063150406,
-0.4373815357685089,
-1.1245808601379395,
0.37810707092285156,
0.188581183552742,
0.34775978326797485,
0.7403644323348999,
-0.18540756404399872,
-0.011524318717420101,
-0.31507453322410583,
0.5912477374076843,
-0.04352199658751488,
-0.7578675746917725,
0.41164782643318176,
-0.4380204677581787,
0.5462669730186462,
0.5007784366607666,
0.5592942833900452,
-0.6139171123504639,
-0.7272050976753235,
-0.39144158363342285,
-0.504632294178009,
0.6268177032470703,
-0.13701587915420532,
0.2401229590177536,
0.06354890018701553,
0.48018932342529297,
0.2254621684551239,
0.2782094180583954,
-0.8491204977035522,
-0.230845645070076,
-0.13914987444877625,
0.14376384019851685,
-0.13126814365386963,
-0.2666168510913849,
-0.23449470102787018,
-0.305862158536911,
0.722335934638977,
-0.2913983166217804,
0.09062007814645767,
0.20643362402915955,
0.07098415493965149,
-0.18215647339820862,
0.4067689776420593,
0.5731282234191895,
0.6149144172668457,
-0.23969215154647827,
0.29765447974205017,
0.04999862611293793,
-0.22959767282009125,
0.29384663701057434,
-0.4123634994029999,
-0.10823744535446167,
-0.3843490481376648,
0.22220785915851593,
0.9119856953620911,
0.12971389293670654,
-0.40780922770500183,
0.34675517678260803,
0.048519283533096313,
-0.03284567594528198,
-0.42534902691841125,
0.42751985788345337,
0.1624608039855957,
0.2557290196418762,
-0.11640258878469467,
-0.026193678379058838,
-0.5519680976867676,
-0.5985890626907349,
-0.09484141319990158,
0.5018903017044067,
-0.3458932042121887,
-0.4915386438369751,
0.5257710814476013,
0.004099707584828138,
-0.3519101142883301,
0.6296132206916809,
-0.31159383058547974,
-0.452676922082901,
0.30460092425346375,
0.7685011029243469,
0.8441547155380249,
-0.39585819840431213,
0.18347297608852386,
0.20782864093780518,
0.3436063230037689,
0.14686790108680725,
0.15051496028900146,
-0.07423065602779388,
-1.001022458076477,
-0.6199823617935181,
-0.43100646138191223,
-0.5257176756858826,
0.43916815519332886,
-0.6204714775085449,
0.14046287536621094,
-0.9029319286346436,
0.05595171079039574,
-0.2074621021747589,
-0.13745050132274628,
-0.46917182207107544,
-0.15244121849536896,
0.18387910723686218,
1.0924603939056396,
-0.7635238170623779,
0.9546570777893066,
0.7774577140808105,
-0.2465793639421463,
-0.8335761427879333,
0.11011265218257904,
0.3844871520996094,
-0.6746700406074524,
0.7018277645111084,
0.030262654647231102,
0.01403761561959982,
0.2834060490131378,
-0.8153194189071655,
-0.7674726247787476,
0.7232604026794434,
0.06063959002494812,
-0.6084699630737305,
-0.025987787172198296,
-0.33813005685806274,
0.5125913619995117,
-0.3304192125797272,
0.2516865134239197,
0.8637442588806152,
0.617389440536499,
0.08261162787675858,
-0.7772912979125977,
-0.010898622684180737,
-0.129073828458786,
-0.0008690148824825883,
0.19458523392677307,
-0.8869948983192444,
0.7504317760467529,
-0.3764963448047638,
-0.13480864465236664,
0.0980958566069603,
0.6488468647003174,
0.2015971690416336,
-0.21529287099838257,
0.448740154504776,
0.2956356704235077,
0.6296949982643127,
0.05435171350836754,
0.8985714912414551,
-0.2450956255197525,
-0.02816593088209629,
1.3704860210418701,
-0.4856027066707611,
0.6761066317558289,
0.6037601828575134,
-0.12736482918262482,
0.700433611869812,
0.4560371935367584,
0.0856395810842514,
0.37814274430274963,
0.2164086550474167,
-0.2564285397529602,
-0.0005499880062416196,
-0.05952346697449684,
-0.010984187014400959,
0.452037513256073,
0.39828526973724365,
-0.41442373394966125,
0.12057312577962875,
0.2147006392478943,
0.5801970362663269,
0.14298680424690247,
-0.2165442258119583,
0.9543824195861816,
-0.000005619962394121103,
-0.9825025796890259,
0.3272302448749542,
-0.09057057648897171,
0.7676218152046204,
-1.0296080112457275,
0.462473601102829,
-0.41365039348602295,
0.3096604645252228,
-0.05944792553782463,
-0.7859761118888855,
0.2903982102870941,
-0.12617217004299164,
-0.04524363577365875,
-0.7154544591903687,
0.45073381066322327,
-0.4663275182247162,
0.13433890044689178,
0.11730854958295822,
0.42714834213256836,
-0.06668752431869507,
-0.3774263560771942,
-0.37007850408554077,
-0.07184511423110962,
-0.1658000946044922,
-0.7051149010658264,
0.603935718536377,
0.30158698558807373,
-0.011861669830977917,
0.7381026148796082,
0.5729143619537354,
0.49908629059791565,
-0.1165478453040123,
-0.1403486728668213,
0.9294065833091736,
-0.6380085945129395,
-0.542776346206665,
-1.0431830883026123,
0.3127340078353882,
0.17921249568462372,
-0.5079312920570374,
0.8009498119354248,
0.05090104788541794,
0.7372574806213379,
-0.10755313187837601,
0.6562841534614563,
-0.21147219836711884,
0.48312637209892273,
-0.4666478633880615,
0.6732423305511475,
-0.18061551451683044,
0.013885370455682278,
-0.07378571480512619,
-0.9264959692955017,
-0.12235219031572342,
0.30196037888526917,
-0.3886997699737549,
0.18843069672584534,
0.8209605813026428,
0.9746468663215637,
0.45073628425598145,
-0.08157428354024887,
0.24575665593147278,
0.6509917378425598,
0.5486729741096497,
0.5501503348350525,
0.9751899838447571,
0.5729332566261292,
0.037738703191280365,
-0.40473589301109314,
-0.6581882238388062,
-0.1236148253083229,
-0.8038172721862793,
-0.8296951651573181,
-0.3691290616989136,
-0.10100068897008896,
-0.4424755275249481,
-0.17614366114139557,
1.150740623474121,
0.4106477200984955,
-0.7715567350387573,
-0.17618143558502197,
-0.290204256772995,
0.14033332467079163,
-0.34375637769699097,
-0.22359460592269897,
-0.029938040301203728,
-0.5138559937477112,
-0.6676402688026428,
0.357822060585022,
0.46545150876045227,
0.09051868319511414,
-0.8458783030509949,
-0.14288508892059326,
-0.2153196930885315,
0.07752730697393417,
0.6569094657897949,
0.5209914445877075,
-0.5718061327934265,
-0.29485517740249634,
0.21886850893497467,
-0.28194165229797363,
-0.014930710196495056,
1.0946619510650635,
-0.5430483818054199,
0.40544500946998596,
0.5106831789016724,
0.17406511306762695,
0.049446579068899155,
0.06592047959566116,
0.6561846733093262,
-0.634522020816803,
0.025815891101956367,
0.377582311630249,
0.1243874654173851,
0.25593268871307373,
-0.5517768263816833,
0.13338804244995117,
0.1855665147304535,
-0.9487171173095703,
-0.4337087571620941,
0.5038002729415894,
-0.7247501611709595,
-0.23419106006622314,
1.4248543977737427,
-0.10188441723585129,
-0.2001161128282547,
-0.07922050356864929,
-0.4208435118198395,
0.16393759846687317,
-0.3921486735343933,
0.7556313276290894,
0.7665607929229736,
-0.6786498427391052,
-0.27876216173171997,
-0.3971153199672699,
0.6184579133987427,
0.6444748044013977,
-0.7013808488845825,
0.27189040184020996,
0.3253181278705597,
0.20182818174362183,
0.07424235343933105,
0.6313454508781433,
-0.08681544661521912,
-0.12866027653217316,
-0.5019816160202026,
-0.06651293486356735,
0.08063895255327225,
-0.4034340977668762,
-0.7241169810295105,
0.03535888344049454,
0.32341498136520386,
0.3914233148097992
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.04578v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.04578v1
|
SC2: Towards Enhancing Content Preservation and Style Consistency in Long Text Style Transfer
| 2024-06-07T01:43:07 | 2024-06-07T01:43:07 |
Jie Zhao, Ziyu Guan, Cai Xu, Wei Zhao, Yue Jiang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Text style transfer (TST) aims to vary the style polarity of text while
preserving the semantic content. Although recent advancements have demonstrated
remarkable progress in short TST, it remains a relatively straightforward task
with limited practical applications. The more comprehensive long TST task
presents two challenges: (1) existing methods encounter difficulties in
accurately evaluating content attributes in multiple words, leading to content
degradation; (2) the conventional vanilla style classifier loss encounters
obstacles in maintaining consistent style across multiple generated sentences.
In this paper, we propose a novel method SC2, where a multilayer Joint
Style-Content Weighed (JSCW) module and a Style Consistency loss are designed
to address the two issues. The JSCW simultaneously assesses the amounts of
style and content attributes within a token, aiming to acquire a lossless
content representation and thereby enhancing content preservation. The multiple
JSCW layers further progressively refine content representations. We design a
style consistency loss to ensure the generated multiple sentences consistently
reflect the target style polarity. Moreover, we incorporate a denoising
non-autoregressive decoder to accelerate the training. We conduct plentiful
experiments and the results show significant improvements of SC2 over
competitive baselines. Our code: https://github.com/jiezhao6/SC2.
|
[
0.21083740890026093,
-0.6189032793045044,
0.32184064388275146,
0.4982428252696991,
-0.501884400844574,
0.37511101365089417,
-0.6019648909568787,
-0.37142759561538696,
0.3773430585861206,
0.5337094068527222,
-0.5234503149986267,
-0.2657098174095154,
-0.634629487991333,
0.0257123876363039,
-0.3433535099029541,
0.9862725138664246,
-0.32912492752075195,
-0.18763619661331177,
-0.3647139072418213,
-0.22872215509414673,
-0.6373665928840637,
-0.2545154094696045,
-0.898415207862854,
-0.180515319108963,
0.21772269904613495,
0.5442728400230408,
0.38880953192710876,
0.44842642545700073,
0.5649222731590271,
0.22104428708553314,
-0.06991764903068542,
0.3132125437259674,
-0.5763923525810242,
0.5188964605331421,
-0.4320765733718872,
-0.29322004318237305,
-0.3284628093242645,
-0.14518356323242188,
0.6706932187080383,
-0.010915480554103851,
-0.10012113302946091,
0.14836397767066956,
0.4131731688976288,
1.0997143983840942,
-0.52689528465271,
0.38137659430503845,
-0.42320629954338074,
-0.1465902328491211,
-0.4229995012283325,
-0.19874946773052216,
-0.6622287631034851,
-0.04725378006696701,
0.044951118528842926,
-0.47722557187080383,
0.02326657995581627,
0.042006704956293106,
0.6802670359611511,
-0.06380677968263626,
-0.7006224989891052,
-0.21491625905036926,
-0.7128605246543884,
0.9199886918067932,
-0.48466652631759644,
0.4573459327220917,
0.2551765739917755,
0.11134810745716095,
0.1004514992237091,
-0.7815381288528442,
-0.7142900824546814,
0.03770736977458,
-0.014930006116628647,
0.6140167117118835,
-0.14480312168598175,
-0.302852988243103,
-0.09764259308576584,
0.005504324566572905,
-0.5878776907920837,
-0.07396845519542694,
-0.30447646975517273,
-0.4069702923297882,
0.6370044350624084,
-0.054383017122745514,
0.11741317808628082,
-0.3512732982635498,
-0.7125274538993835,
-0.17059504985809326,
-0.3906785249710083,
0.07861736416816711,
0.42508846521377563,
0.23105297982692719,
-0.23238562047481537,
0.472790390253067,
-0.12936390936374664,
-0.01517089456319809,
-0.025633549317717552,
-0.4695139527320862,
0.26322585344314575,
-0.5677969455718994,
0.3775128722190857,
0.05788096785545349,
0.6126570105552673,
0.7204684615135193,
-0.04630891606211662,
-0.10823532938957214,
-0.12489577382802963,
0.0438375398516655,
0.3015992343425751,
-0.7674329280853271,
-0.20835980772972107,
0.007911235094070435,
-0.604620099067688,
-0.4545007348060608,
0.3592621982097626,
-0.6897494196891785,
-0.40118956565856934,
-0.5964894890785217,
0.3976040482521057,
-0.4879612326622009,
-0.6251488327980042,
0.1371186226606369,
-0.48152822256088257,
0.2735086679458618,
0.47650146484375,
-0.8851451873779297,
0.33100369572639465,
0.6199271082878113,
0.9910652041435242,
-0.6371574997901917,
0.05417105555534363,
-0.1619395911693573,
0.6236264705657959,
-0.34265822172164917,
0.8188494443893433,
-0.03821517899632454,
-0.17717142403125763,
-0.10133164376020432,
0.05448916181921959,
0.2230147272348404,
-0.11164148151874542,
0.40410342812538147,
-0.25090980529785156,
0.16803330183029175,
-0.49131327867507935,
-0.2961775064468384,
0.2523263990879059,
0.2250562310218811,
-0.4860685169696808,
1.222051739692688,
0.44951432943344116,
-1.0023163557052612,
0.08152108639478683,
-0.4814412593841553,
-0.8878141641616821,
0.015179488807916641,
0.23341180384159088,
-0.8172010183334351,
0.1328691989183426,
-0.26530832052230835,
0.13563379645347595,
-0.09920569509267807,
-0.25779852271080017,
-0.3365989625453949,
-0.5814543962478638,
0.05313087999820709,
-0.24280548095703125,
0.32327231764793396,
0.09823194146156311,
-0.26681289076805115,
-0.0552142933011055,
-0.6025327444076538,
0.12325876206159592,
0.43788349628448486,
-0.12549209594726562,
-0.5110675096511841,
0.12982159852981567,
0.4284585118293762,
0.24792197346687317,
0.3788236975669861,
-0.6728019714355469,
0.2975887358188629,
0.09113352745771408,
0.7643331289291382,
0.9149667024612427,
-0.1422603726387024,
0.5410175919532776,
-0.310500830411911,
0.1274273693561554,
0.006356697995215654,
0.07335256040096283,
0.039663415402173996,
-0.19801512360572815,
-0.7960458993911743,
-0.10249802470207214,
0.01070190966129303,
0.6508786678314209,
-0.993614912033081,
0.3075571060180664,
-0.2588409185409546,
-0.49493834376335144,
-0.14409512281417847,
0.029390444979071617,
0.25675836205482483,
0.3033415377140045,
0.6344643831253052,
-0.6184829473495483,
-0.5675969123840332,
-0.9300685524940491,
-0.26480862498283386,
-0.15645316243171692,
0.08380003273487091,
0.18108689785003662,
0.1736087054014206,
-0.08903663605451584,
0.9199526906013489,
-0.5265195369720459,
-0.3885110318660736,
-0.49342912435531616,
0.4562586545944214,
-0.46855244040489197,
0.8178598284721375,
0.40816786885261536,
-0.4338078498840332,
-0.504245400428772,
-0.047527387738227844,
-0.45527851581573486,
-0.1538497358560562,
-0.46895572543144226,
-0.3170506954193115,
0.4957776367664337,
0.4158225357532501,
-0.42048272490501404,
0.4572456181049347,
0.5388574004173279,
-0.12587031722068787,
0.692642331123352,
-0.08595851808786392,
0.15850111842155457,
-1.3577754497528076,
0.007621024735271931,
0.10318920016288757,
-0.23416168987751007,
-0.5233083963394165,
-0.16124658286571503,
0.472647488117218,
-0.05164983123540878,
-0.36550551652908325,
0.5581965446472168,
-0.4876750707626343,
-0.0025079576298594475,
-0.35258814692497253,
0.12030022591352463,
0.6348878145217896,
0.4339210093021393,
0.07928775250911713,
0.8601173162460327,
0.3294254541397095,
-0.08233397454023361,
0.29157957434654236,
0.14386677742004395,
-0.008495485410094261,
1.1676106452941895,
-0.6049281358718872,
0.6435477137565613,
-0.3508031666278839,
0.6888735294342041,
-1.152356743812561,
0.15870679914951324,
0.24143701791763306,
-0.07190991193056107,
0.6405187249183655,
-0.3378465473651886,
-0.8156588673591614,
-0.4165588617324829,
-0.7625647783279419,
0.1963813155889511,
0.4955156147480011,
-0.23438815772533417,
0.4992467761039734,
-0.11669925600290298,
-0.39942988753318787,
-0.33085760474205017,
-0.9382679462432861,
0.2931271195411682,
-0.108047716319561,
-0.6429291367530823,
0.5069225430488586,
-0.13433580100536346,
0.1273597627878189,
-0.13201171159744263,
-0.5879637002944946,
0.0746951773762703,
-0.05104651302099228,
0.12482097744941711,
0.34773018956184387,
-0.227470263838768,
0.10847169905900955,
0.6107473373413086,
-0.1441362053155899,
-0.03680584579706192,
-0.6192934513092041,
0.6428526043891907,
-0.11904536187648773,
-0.3306128680706024,
-1.0187193155288696,
0.47741714119911194,
0.4834127426147461,
-0.39163798093795776,
0.5979799628257751,
0.9923290014266968,
0.09112393856048584,
-0.286396324634552,
-0.6473519802093506,
-0.030734332278370857,
-0.5041558146476746,
0.4474000930786133,
-0.3252282738685608,
-0.751661479473114,
0.3817257881164551,
-0.05156603083014488,
-0.09448461979627609,
0.6116231083869934,
0.06279046088457108,
-0.3877921998500824,
0.8638909459114075,
0.6144742369651794,
0.24331843852996826,
0.7001897692680359,
-0.2744433879852295,
0.16242346167564392,
-0.8456259965896606,
-0.40850263833999634,
-0.3927117884159088,
-0.37367767095565796,
-0.636043906211853,
-0.3285680115222931,
0.24161572754383087,
0.2063399702310562,
-0.1919240951538086,
0.6378604769706726,
-0.49177882075309753,
0.5517799854278564,
0.42047038674354553,
0.5271410346031189,
0.12023333460092545,
0.24006305634975433,
0.3113047480583191,
-0.18448200821876526,
-0.2768832743167877,
-0.25061503052711487,
0.7932834625244141,
0.45560359954833984,
0.8171296119689941,
0.3988596796989441,
0.7529069185256958,
0.4471154808998108,
-0.10553950071334839,
-0.8904514908790588,
0.41735324263572693,
-0.6229901313781738,
-0.15453161299228668,
-0.19715945422649384,
-0.36922401189804077,
-0.4546140730381012,
-0.13451719284057617,
-0.3057345449924469,
-0.39982113242149353,
-0.10028568655252457,
0.08153487741947174,
0.1348535120487213,
0.28417378664016724,
-0.5194389224052429,
0.5783931612968445,
-0.08067034184932709,
-0.8204210996627808,
-0.32615312933921814,
-0.9624962210655212,
0.013794656842947006,
0.09976696968078613,
-0.14750388264656067,
0.08340108394622803,
-0.0946546271443367,
0.8975130915641785,
-0.24410437047481537,
0.6040351390838623,
0.018663516268134117,
-0.14188317954540253,
0.44187629222869873,
0.29604512453079224,
0.7766764163970947,
0.0651312991976738,
-0.0756220817565918,
0.1684478223323822,
0.17536136507987976,
-0.6186889410018921,
-0.7820942997932434,
0.5727850794792175,
-0.6905417442321777,
-0.17220662534236908,
-0.44512009620666504,
-0.467777281999588,
-0.12075192481279373,
0.47856491804122925,
0.05935122072696686,
0.6602218151092529,
0.09982016682624817,
0.3267524242401123,
0.5956612229347229,
0.04211193695664406,
0.5002243518829346,
0.19819995760917664,
0.25995004177093506,
-0.5641440153121948,
1.0964744091033936,
0.06470143049955368,
0.6320769190788269,
0.14397278428077698,
0.43730872869491577,
-0.4574735462665558,
-0.7079246640205383,
-0.6905601620674133,
0.06887666881084442,
-0.6424596905708313,
-0.3542307913303375,
-0.3698715269565582,
-0.28511378169059753,
-0.7383282780647278,
-0.2939406633377075,
-0.5277453064918518,
-0.6253316402435303,
-0.2523531913757324,
0.30242183804512024,
0.29345953464508057,
0.9576927423477173,
0.18390624225139618,
0.3999265134334564,
-0.5054014921188354,
0.18364840745925903,
0.12254513800144196,
0.6405495405197144,
-0.16923856735229492,
-0.5694875717163086,
-0.11178356409072876,
-0.025351671501994133,
-0.27026963233947754,
-0.7088686227798462,
-0.05650688335299492,
-0.027858221903443336,
0.2185475081205368,
0.4026419222354889,
0.12238271534442902,
0.712630033493042,
-0.2195950299501419,
0.8494148254394531,
0.5002760291099548,
-1.0419527292251587,
0.42475590109825134,
-0.29000917077064514,
0.40503400564193726,
0.8760498762130737,
-0.14687411487102509,
-0.976279079914093,
-0.3022010922431946,
-0.475062757730484,
-0.9776586890220642,
0.7722602486610413,
0.2803403437137604,
0.22909212112426758,
-0.04325864464044571,
0.40426042675971985,
0.29093465209007263,
0.08168823271989822,
-0.40407395362854004,
-0.016871551051735878,
-0.8604517579078674,
-0.2778031527996063,
0.4372996687889099,
-0.5166397094726562,
0.1122032105922699,
0.08986315876245499,
0.6894497275352478,
-0.2924954891204834,
0.2773456275463104,
0.10720779746770859,
-0.22146917879581451,
-0.006742078810930252,
0.4720112085342407,
0.678415060043335,
0.23250582814216614,
-0.0003330932231619954,
0.32573023438453674,
0.1653250902891159,
-0.635375440120697,
-0.04727825149893761,
-0.22138570249080658,
-0.38132280111312866,
-0.17687715590000153,
0.35706743597984314,
0.6434698104858398,
-0.029520191252231598,
-0.09655003994703293,
0.7627097964286804,
0.031471963971853256,
-0.1466268002986908,
-0.3457232415676117,
-0.2668251395225525,
-0.1822369247674942,
-0.038095440715551376,
0.21305927634239197,
0.46808961033821106,
0.06574445217847824,
-0.7640991806983948,
0.319627583026886,
0.40372589230537415,
-0.3950418531894684,
-0.12683649361133575,
0.4185014069080353,
0.26097390055656433,
-0.07783883064985275,
0.5508021116256714,
-0.3665691316127777,
-0.5529183149337769,
0.43230119347572327,
0.9272106885910034,
0.6659529805183411,
0.07101752609014511,
0.29767340421676636,
0.3844689130783081,
0.048655763268470764,
-0.533038318157196,
0.26499417424201965,
-0.18107497692108154,
-0.2836032807826996,
-0.2115083485841751,
-0.582760214805603,
-0.31172916293144226,
-0.2106913924217224,
-0.8222365975379944,
0.584492027759552,
-0.5751993656158447,
0.054408613592386246,
-0.37292230129241943,
0.13579724729061127,
-0.28610581159591675,
-0.10490044206380844,
0.2992325723171234,
0.7749873399734497,
-0.92706298828125,
0.7239609956741333,
0.4039638638496399,
-0.3043806552886963,
-0.6541033387184143,
0.16865533590316772,
0.3054906129837036,
-0.538198709487915,
0.2653330862522125,
0.3864608407020569,
-0.44110116362571716,
-0.05941672995686531,
-0.521378219127655,
-1.079755425453186,
1.3249168395996094,
0.0017518280074000359,
-0.5362488031387329,
0.1389094740152359,
0.24188928306102753,
0.5358542799949646,
-0.01100847963243723,
0.17107151448726654,
0.3659781217575073,
0.5932295918464661,
0.3959176242351532,
-0.7763256430625916,
0.23538170754909515,
-0.17683236300945282,
0.29456987977027893,
0.18742521107196808,
-0.9803888201713562,
0.4837339222431183,
-0.13082663714885712,
-0.3578345477581024,
0.5972582697868347,
0.9298113584518433,
0.06527851521968842,
0.461787611246109,
0.561471164226532,
0.3906101882457733,
0.3853186368942261,
-0.23620186746120453,
0.6272484064102173,
-0.22077935934066772,
0.5297996401786804,
1.036984920501709,
-0.4472889304161072,
0.8024863004684448,
0.41621536016464233,
-0.02105235680937767,
0.791434109210968,
0.18333089351654053,
-0.11857530474662781,
0.6057806015014648,
0.2974027395248413,
-0.07776837050914764,
-0.06186670809984207,
-0.34546294808387756,
-0.43275243043899536,
0.732030987739563,
-0.0867822989821434,
0.04375796392560005,
0.08234786987304688,
-0.04977653920650482,
0.4684407114982605,
0.18456222116947174,
0.022750701755285263,
0.7752276062965393,
-0.19658884406089783,
-0.4245584011077881,
-0.003701618406921625,
0.1770620495080948,
0.7990977168083191,
-0.7909130454063416,
-0.03250579163432121,
-0.26342910528182983,
0.17205826938152313,
-0.23876817524433136,
-1.0719696283340454,
0.3178142011165619,
-0.5179666876792908,
-0.11254072189331055,
-0.6544035077095032,
1.0160908699035645,
-0.7314104437828064,
-0.4885083734989166,
0.16887065768241882,
0.1331338882446289,
-0.154533252120018,
0.011059414595365524,
-0.5202562808990479,
0.351223886013031,
-0.38945820927619934,
-0.22895100712776184,
0.3728576898574829,
0.44083645939826965,
-0.2980956435203552,
0.29778704047203064,
0.6301047801971436,
-0.01201292872428894,
-0.4544983506202698,
0.32780420780181885,
0.7144106030464172,
-0.41444072127342224,
-0.609300971031189,
-0.6395290493965149,
0.409156858921051,
-0.4353996217250824,
-0.24342288076877594,
0.7144525647163391,
0.7566069960594177,
0.5885478854179382,
0.08834070712327957,
0.735016942024231,
-0.28434357047080994,
0.21387046575546265,
-0.49891242384910583,
0.9266695380210876,
-0.5360089540481567,
-0.004272679798305035,
-0.4760432243347168,
-0.7637893557548523,
-0.27260833978652954,
0.35923078656196594,
0.2818787097930908,
-0.0653734803199768,
0.9225994348526001,
0.6250810623168945,
-0.04385485500097275,
0.11670079082250595,
-0.18426558375358582,
0.06425858289003372,
0.3237590789794922,
0.3320256769657135,
0.48991212248802185,
-0.46535080671310425,
0.5275693535804749,
-0.6427162289619446,
-0.20420385897159576,
-0.06330788880586624,
-0.9334120154380798,
-0.6617867350578308,
-0.6527877449989319,
-0.34054073691368103,
-0.8092172741889954,
0.26594844460487366,
0.8938615918159485,
0.7816905975341797,
-0.6869130730628967,
-0.0604468397796154,
0.15375636518001556,
-0.2069464772939682,
-0.5994769930839539,
-0.22735409438610077,
0.5703535079956055,
-0.0459916777908802,
-0.2596057951450348,
0.24451838433742523,
0.5884957909584045,
0.13324831426143646,
-0.2052115499973297,
0.00843927450478077,
0.2307896614074707,
0.06333480030298233,
1.0849504470825195,
-0.02016109973192215,
-0.5175579786300659,
-0.7694156765937805,
0.024243224412202835,
-0.22444412112236023,
0.014941202476620674,
0.9774227738380432,
-0.42777934670448303,
0.2513826787471771,
0.6781105399131775,
0.39823246002197266,
0.5094719529151917,
0.22845010459423065,
-0.01130090095102787,
-0.8960770964622498,
-0.0008090026094578207,
-0.025472767651081085,
0.16882304847240448,
0.46971583366394043,
-0.40529873967170715,
0.4038445055484772,
0.6888107657432556,
-0.1886243373155594,
-0.5068828463554382,
0.3984583616256714,
-1.859283447265625,
-0.24478234350681305,
1.4666603803634644,
0.012119763530790806,
-0.010793084278702736,
0.004292851779609919,
-0.42554420232772827,
0.4659537971019745,
-0.570959210395813,
0.6768164038658142,
0.49614742398262024,
-0.0035522643011063337,
-0.20833824574947357,
-0.3220037817955017,
0.25644612312316895,
0.4133117198944092,
-0.6733585596084595,
0.3635367453098297,
0.27718695998191833,
0.4864973723888397,
0.04842057451605797,
0.38889646530151367,
-0.3319827616214752,
0.2302509993314743,
-0.11289991438388824,
-0.014058069325983524,
-0.37838107347488403,
-0.5443441867828369,
-0.017839904874563217,
0.09992898255586624,
-0.26638802886009216,
0.10077416151762009
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.04566v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.04566v1
|
SpaRC and SpaRP: Spatial Reasoning Characterization and Path Generation for Understanding Spatial Reasoning Capability of Large Language Models
| 2024-06-07T01:06:34 | 2024-06-07T01:06:34 |
Md Imbesat Hassan Rizvi, Xiaodan Zhu, Iryna Gurevych
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Spatial reasoning is a crucial component of both biological and artificial
intelligence. In this work, we present a comprehensive study of the capability
of current state-of-the-art large language models (LLMs) on spatial reasoning.
To support our study, we created and contribute a novel Spatial Reasoning
Characterization (SpaRC) framework and Spatial Reasoning Paths (SpaRP)
datasets, to enable an in-depth understanding of the spatial relations and
compositions as well as the usefulness of spatial reasoning chains. We found
that all the state-of-the-art LLMs do not perform well on the datasets -- their
performances are consistently low across different setups. The spatial
reasoning capability improves substantially as model sizes scale up. Finetuning
both large language models (e.g., Llama-2-70B) and smaller ones (e.g.,
Llama-2-13B) can significantly improve their F1-scores by 7--32 absolute
points. We also found that the top proprietary LLMs still significantly
outperform their open-source counterparts in topological spatial understanding
and reasoning.
|
[
-0.5851179957389832,
-0.9827367067337036,
0.9178628921508789,
0.21530456840991974,
0.14847251772880554,
-0.22865931689739227,
-0.49632295966148376,
-0.615229606628418,
-0.09521520882844925,
0.5968989133834839,
-0.2988241910934448,
-0.6526114344596863,
-0.5887613296508789,
0.30735892057418823,
-0.2898412346839905,
0.6800409555435181,
0.02625455893576145,
0.07954466342926025,
-0.26062139868736267,
-0.30447909235954285,
-0.4482155442237854,
-0.29198938608169556,
-0.11344180256128311,
-0.3550960123538971,
0.6162600517272949,
0.4385564625263214,
1.000606656074524,
0.6314089894294739,
0.6804884076118469,
0.40271899104118347,
-0.39291152358055115,
0.43770676851272583,
-0.38978901505470276,
0.29941481351852417,
-0.5313276052474976,
0.15988759696483612,
-0.3840293884277344,
-0.4047738015651703,
0.9366852641105652,
1.0462960004806519,
-0.011142623610794544,
-0.07438315451145172,
-0.22261576354503632,
0.5994694232940674,
-0.3131349980831146,
0.10981141775846481,
-0.642036497592926,
0.033936187624931335,
-0.23221606016159058,
-0.1255679875612259,
-0.37481653690338135,
-0.03763039782643318,
0.19266848266124725,
-0.8196958303451538,
0.09068851917982101,
0.3405115306377411,
0.5363510847091675,
0.32040470838546753,
-0.39950883388519287,
-0.24942360818386078,
-0.9585375189781189,
0.5498775243759155,
-0.489253968000412,
0.39144566655158997,
0.30981558561325073,
0.665840744972229,
-0.4903559982776642,
-0.44959279894828796,
-0.3481369614601135,
-0.5528231263160706,
-0.1459624171257019,
-0.3013729453086853,
-0.27794983983039856,
-0.025656791403889656,
0.4456237554550171,
0.09846148639917374,
-0.8618825674057007,
0.03368457779288292,
-0.5226096510887146,
-0.0944553017616272,
0.5963028073310852,
0.2724485695362091,
0.10881029069423676,
-0.04050373658537865,
-0.31787142157554626,
-0.07396678626537323,
-0.8817099928855896,
-0.2860303819179535,
-0.048195336014032364,
0.41574811935424805,
0.24481044709682465,
0.7733851671218872,
-0.04404941573739052,
0.784619927406311,
-0.30017685890197754,
0.0037088904064148664,
-0.09171972423791885,
-0.2936520576477051,
-0.02684534341096878,
-0.34584420919418335,
0.7125027179718018,
-0.0013714780798181891,
0.30417633056640625,
-0.28458842635154724,
-0.15285935997962952,
-0.3541760742664337,
0.05928298085927963,
-0.31033045053482056,
-0.2037806659936905,
0.11496413499116898,
-0.2633517384529114,
0.2092125564813614,
0.011601820588111877,
-0.820447564125061,
-0.7070830464363098,
-0.308170884847641,
0.1507629007101059,
-0.6085540652275085,
-0.441803902387619,
0.5216424465179443,
-0.15856356918811798,
0.38111355900764465,
0.5186644196510315,
-0.6089352369308472,
0.5062128305435181,
0.9207773208618164,
0.8909403085708618,
-0.10821497440338135,
-0.7313287854194641,
-0.06663685292005539,
0.3754904270172119,
-0.3388421833515167,
1.2492613792419434,
-0.7018378376960754,
-0.4640292227268219,
-0.42070701718330383,
-0.18018785119056702,
-0.12817271053791046,
-0.6411861181259155,
0.39847108721733093,
-0.27815428376197815,
-0.2489781528711319,
-0.47956061363220215,
-0.2673550844192505,
-0.2053828239440918,
0.33046504855155945,
-0.7457951903343201,
1.1969234943389893,
0.27789926528930664,
-0.7098210453987122,
0.1938934624195099,
-0.7868384718894958,
-0.59173184633255,
0.3096458613872528,
-0.1432049572467804,
-0.11832572519779205,
-0.0742986798286438,
0.2100803405046463,
0.28974291682243347,
-0.2575259506702423,
0.4937277138233185,
-0.5579180121421814,
-0.44123920798301697,
0.37816116213798523,
-0.13299791514873505,
0.5993481278419495,
0.31768545508384705,
-0.3744765520095825,
0.13147833943367004,
-0.5161158442497253,
-0.16882085800170898,
0.19299890100955963,
-0.08653299510478973,
-0.12061119824647903,
0.22949844598770142,
-0.1333388090133667,
0.1368691772222519,
0.12952806055545807,
-0.33707964420318604,
0.28783541917800903,
-0.2529054582118988,
0.5262430906295776,
0.7561349868774414,
-0.13276946544647217,
0.7199445366859436,
-0.14878703653812408,
0.5003626346588135,
-0.2655690312385559,
0.0031963891815394163,
0.05270930752158165,
-0.5551456809043884,
-0.413542240858078,
-0.4072975218296051,
-0.043677765876054764,
0.5527251958847046,
-0.3817101716995239,
0.6630990505218506,
-0.4800425171852112,
-0.8187205791473389,
0.18198300898075104,
-0.14304879307746887,
0.14471043646335602,
0.414391428232193,
0.3327254056930542,
0.10534889250993729,
-0.5034987330436707,
-0.4228600561618805,
-0.0607704296708107,
-0.15674661099910736,
0.24678535759449005,
0.7331676483154297,
0.8707184791564941,
-0.3660033345222473,
0.8261419534683228,
-0.43084871768951416,
0.1444694697856903,
-0.5684535503387451,
-0.299736350774765,
0.21324853599071503,
0.26099300384521484,
0.6863196492195129,
-0.3946719467639923,
-0.00942833349108696,
0.36839547753334045,
-0.498119592666626,
-0.27879729866981506,
0.12285605072975159,
-0.5644932985305786,
0.0023830083664506674,
0.3106325566768646,
-0.8993464708328247,
0.38490650057792664,
0.31873199343681335,
-0.9072955846786499,
0.7720212340354919,
-0.3925098478794098,
0.07502271234989166,
-0.36500295996665955,
0.18788953125476837,
0.2586798369884491,
0.004816772416234016,
-0.4948327839374542,
0.150787353515625,
-0.48632073402404785,
-0.27743032574653625,
-0.14007490873336792,
0.9442785978317261,
-0.3054167926311493,
-0.683801531791687,
-0.0894416868686676,
0.02332759089767933,
0.12527266144752502,
0.32105422019958496,
0.3913208842277527,
0.5776686072349548,
0.5028783082962036,
-0.5238667130470276,
0.4114891290664673,
0.3080975115299225,
-0.3272934556007385,
0.025921234861016273,
-0.7516775727272034,
-0.039603762328624725,
-0.04357869178056717,
0.5032628178596497,
-1.2463642358779907,
-0.20252446830272675,
0.2978261411190033,
-0.4190632998943329,
0.07088828831911087,
-0.026454173028469086,
-0.790648877620697,
-0.3186275362968445,
0.11599771678447723,
0.4511513113975525,
0.13761653006076813,
-0.47008904814720154,
0.621283769607544,
0.4619239270687103,
-0.11546620726585388,
-0.15747371315956116,
-0.664002001285553,
-0.08474469929933548,
-0.3611936569213867,
-0.7902418375015259,
-0.15975531935691833,
0.06715922802686691,
-0.4024483859539032,
-0.11560143530368805,
0.04397008568048477,
-0.11882835626602173,
0.11266268044710159,
0.192946195602417,
0.22068580985069275,
-0.3280661702156067,
-0.02272639609873295,
-0.08075635135173798,
-0.16705498099327087,
0.20732882618904114,
-0.28329864144325256,
0.45478731393814087,
-0.27553731203079224,
-0.6086719632148743,
0.036221109330654144,
0.39938637614250183,
0.7534731030464172,
-0.288158655166626,
0.8055877089500427,
0.40452611446380615,
-0.4517207145690918,
-0.2034478634595871,
-0.27072322368621826,
-0.05274052917957306,
-0.4220718443393707,
0.473837286233902,
-0.3452884554862976,
-1.1434762477874756,
0.4228566288948059,
-0.3645787835121155,
-0.0697995126247406,
0.3349638283252716,
0.47928526997566223,
-0.16524027287960052,
0.8415824770927429,
0.31009629368782043,
0.061615586280822754,
0.14247991144657135,
-0.26313531398773193,
0.4361923038959503,
-0.5726641416549683,
-0.614001452922821,
-0.8332521319389343,
-0.20051555335521698,
-0.4768383800983429,
-0.8791113495826721,
0.4833327829837799,
-0.03193320333957672,
-0.791935384273529,
0.12187366932630539,
-0.5858153700828552,
0.5119932889938354,
0.3379114270210266,
0.030355827882885933,
-0.00825079157948494,
0.34699496626853943,
-0.2131413370370865,
0.04667946696281433,
-0.7582522034645081,
-0.7161597013473511,
0.6413576006889343,
0.47947680950164795,
0.6734476685523987,
0.10167728364467621,
0.1388406604528427,
0.33043578267097473,
-0.05137902498245239,
-0.5427536368370056,
0.912061333656311,
-0.22960053384304047,
-0.484988272190094,
-0.5233899354934692,
-0.6010263562202454,
-0.835942804813385,
0.4979546070098877,
-0.16801099479198456,
-0.705470085144043,
0.06412389874458313,
0.11785738170146942,
-0.23305636644363403,
0.545871376991272,
-0.48876482248306274,
0.858864426612854,
-0.7010505199432373,
-0.36318427324295044,
-0.04955541342496872,
-0.539588212966919,
0.23059198260307312,
0.2663612365722656,
0.2586577534675598,
-0.25612616539001465,
0.06935805827379227,
0.330544650554657,
-0.24392960965633392,
0.6696716547012329,
-0.3580199182033539,
-0.09892471134662628,
0.24896259605884552,
0.4204781651496887,
0.20021821558475494,
-0.08969701081514359,
-0.33493489027023315,
0.5163148045539856,
-0.04489589482545853,
-0.2534918189048767,
-0.5773928165435791,
0.6005524396896362,
-0.7779006361961365,
-0.42086175084114075,
-0.4336525797843933,
-0.732455849647522,
-0.3314661681652069,
0.061093155294656754,
0.05087660998106003,
0.2154085487127304,
-0.23422792553901672,
-0.12919867038726807,
0.7492544054985046,
-0.5240915417671204,
-0.17114707827568054,
0.24827831983566284,
-0.3397483825683594,
-0.41715067625045776,
0.6777548789978027,
-0.09616599231958389,
-0.114397794008255,
0.28725942969322205,
0.3141643702983856,
-0.6118930578231812,
-0.6413432955741882,
-0.18284688889980316,
0.5364397168159485,
-0.5895608067512512,
-0.1959080994129181,
-0.2991390526294708,
-0.3102162480354309,
-0.41513824462890625,
-0.36913278698921204,
-0.0653696283698082,
-0.5578563809394836,
-0.07406057417392731,
-0.21200163662433624,
0.5714790225028992,
1.3279014825820923,
-0.23582322895526886,
0.05419885739684105,
-0.706400990486145,
0.18549707531929016,
-0.21058514714241028,
0.22001799941062927,
0.07454117387533188,
-0.5146090984344482,
-0.1702146679162979,
0.12177208811044693,
-0.13392919301986694,
-0.9410472512245178,
0.4009683430194855,
-0.036116551607847214,
0.7473552227020264,
0.3468964099884033,
-0.3685815632343292,
0.8110492825508118,
-0.6306483149528503,
0.6704106330871582,
-0.22871141135692596,
-0.7620407342910767,
0.7776053547859192,
-0.6010931134223938,
0.2026413530111313,
0.060950782150030136,
0.09656625986099243,
-0.29643598198890686,
-0.3128097355365753,
-0.2892727553844452,
-0.8470195531845093,
0.47616031765937805,
0.0871804729104042,
-0.37942689657211304,
-0.029776085168123245,
0.46236252784729004,
0.16978874802589417,
-0.26661568880081177,
-0.6342170834541321,
0.13417817652225494,
-0.08837039023637772,
0.04992176964879036,
-0.1508408486843109,
-0.21419720351696014,
-0.14178621768951416,
-0.6156256794929504,
0.41746532917022705,
0.10389962792396545,
0.4245489537715912,
0.07986921072006226,
0.025137968361377716,
-0.04136037454009056,
0.26995885372161865,
0.6563277244567871,
0.8195657730102539,
0.11413811147212982,
0.20409023761749268,
0.2871396839618683,
-0.24391914904117584,
0.11156798154115677,
0.1584632694721222,
-0.002367646200582385,
-0.15797166526317596,
0.6396920680999756,
0.6965619921684265,
0.17376039922237396,
-0.8605376482009888,
0.25144726037979126,
0.0980805829167366,
-0.2957840859889984,
-0.12279726564884186,
0.053689632564783096,
-0.09513945877552032,
0.5444356203079224,
0.04429338127374649,
0.2006717324256897,
0.22672145068645477,
-0.018108095973730087,
-0.0033414545468986034,
0.4541652500629425,
0.20648464560508728,
-0.2921220362186432,
0.3512534201145172,
-0.017615342512726784,
0.18190087378025055,
0.8174212574958801,
-0.2563911974430084,
-0.614258348941803,
0.659214973449707,
0.5969816446304321,
0.4321327209472656,
0.04120452702045441,
0.277698814868927,
0.6538671851158142,
0.44284507632255554,
-0.04985343664884567,
0.09374068677425385,
-0.3719595968723297,
-0.8692541122436523,
-0.4556967616081238,
-0.6296917200088501,
-0.39985132217407227,
-0.0780182033777237,
-0.3974060118198395,
-0.14125992357730865,
-0.44336196780204773,
-0.09381221234798431,
-0.47057193517684937,
0.19213855266571045,
-0.3742063343524933,
-0.16670659184455872,
0.3050144612789154,
1.3055667877197266,
-0.9689607620239258,
0.5236903429031372,
1.1195756196975708,
0.01447652094066143,
-0.7690793871879578,
-0.3378121554851532,
-0.12181783467531204,
-0.5643609762191772,
0.6628458499908447,
0.06780730187892914,
-0.5242262482643127,
-0.4408932626247406,
-0.6449300050735474,
-0.9410480260848999,
1.1184324026107788,
0.5726487636566162,
-0.4753831624984741,
-0.08604405075311661,
0.594750165939331,
0.8118154406547546,
-0.21824267506599426,
0.20169328153133392,
0.6178691387176514,
0.7610750794410706,
0.35883691906929016,
-0.7708783745765686,
0.004413419868797064,
-0.18340590596199036,
0.1694682091474533,
0.1588549166917801,
-0.35792577266693115,
0.49540767073631287,
-0.513927698135376,
-0.19262322783470154,
0.42340603470802307,
0.5678533911705017,
0.9740081429481506,
0.27568066120147705,
0.43979161977767944,
0.800994336605072,
0.7363465428352356,
-0.39147189259529114,
0.8779332041740417,
-0.09431412070989609,
0.17538513243198395,
0.8592620491981506,
-0.6751967072486877,
0.9691474437713623,
0.29138654470443726,
-0.09320811182260513,
0.5214139819145203,
0.6215015053749084,
0.013391128741204739,
0.44507262110710144,
0.4584520161151886,
-0.10257876664400101,
-0.5334736108779907,
0.19699710607528687,
-0.29598698019981384,
0.5649378895759583,
0.732387900352478,
0.009316411800682545,
-0.33864346146583557,
-0.13500654697418213,
-0.10862290859222412,
0.223906010389328,
-0.4260176718235016,
0.49922600388526917,
-0.15986663103103638,
-0.6684209108352661,
0.2178199589252472,
-0.24927954375743866,
0.19262966513633728,
-0.5563853979110718,
-0.36196479201316833,
-0.2748664319515228,
0.2405720055103302,
-0.2609301209449768,
-1.2350819110870361,
0.3795925974845886,
0.17684480547904968,
-0.013354507274925709,
-0.28284332156181335,
0.8538386821746826,
-0.2006952166557312,
-0.3512437045574188,
0.4883202016353607,
0.5870903134346008,
0.339227557182312,
0.17230087518692017,
-0.756338894367218,
0.2934139668941498,
-0.25408339500427246,
-0.15291601419448853,
0.12966468930244446,
0.968695878982544,
-0.05455121397972107,
0.9484578371047974,
0.6190987825393677,
0.42860472202301025,
0.23532943427562714,
-0.06472180038690567,
0.9304229617118835,
-0.8859484791755676,
-0.1256871372461319,
-0.6762434244155884,
0.3185402750968933,
0.10880570858716965,
-0.12234143912792206,
0.5591709017753601,
0.5224508047103882,
0.6385228633880615,
0.07306019961833954,
0.4677566885948181,
-0.09021400660276413,
0.5580406785011292,
-0.46630731225013733,
0.571690559387207,
-0.2699236273765564,
0.5612614750862122,
-0.18239833414554596,
-0.7609752416610718,
-0.49776995182037354,
1.1480072736740112,
-0.5968105792999268,
0.29390811920166016,
0.6605937480926514,
0.9774295091629028,
-0.028597868978977203,
-0.1907801777124405,
0.318580687046051,
0.26003190875053406,
0.23826661705970764,
0.8118919134140015,
1.345132827758789,
0.07468044757843018,
0.5145429968833923,
-0.06216227635741234,
-0.15318581461906433,
0.13795170187950134,
-0.7598689794540405,
-0.726546049118042,
-0.5674102902412415,
-0.04771600291132927,
-0.2536177337169647,
0.0971209853887558,
0.2892313301563263,
0.7654396891593933,
-0.4815071225166321,
-0.3984830975532532,
-0.26141926646232605,
0.1594080924987793,
-0.08700854331254959,
-0.2592792212963104,
0.12613947689533234,
-0.06442655622959137,
-0.13593485951423645,
0.5192543268203735,
0.5978449583053589,
-0.13542205095291138,
-0.3976769745349884,
-0.43501824140548706,
-0.0969795435667038,
-0.07088296860456467,
0.6662262678146362,
0.45593175292015076,
-0.8576421141624451,
-0.19853608310222626,
0.14273902773857117,
-0.16931095719337463,
-0.011284122243523598,
0.9481741786003113,
-0.5501561164855957,
-0.03507160767912865,
0.5441048741340637,
0.410552978515625,
0.13081537187099457,
-0.11372952908277512,
0.4795967638492584,
-0.4083031415939331,
0.05825424566864967,
0.3543766736984253,
0.8665067553520203,
0.4008236229419708,
-0.32618996500968933,
0.568315863609314,
0.021839840337634087,
-1.0019384622573853,
-0.6087208390235901,
0.31381478905677795,
-1.143438458442688,
-0.3576664626598358,
1.582053303718567,
-0.13927814364433289,
-0.3386639356613159,
-0.026741061359643936,
-0.4007617235183716,
-0.05369490012526512,
-0.20649361610412598,
0.40244555473327637,
0.5483746528625488,
-0.47005870938301086,
-0.198927104473114,
-0.1420423686504364,
0.07412669062614441,
0.0867578536272049,
-1.0259255170822144,
0.23489728569984436,
1.0336567163467407,
0.291534960269928,
0.13349643349647522,
0.6115263104438782,
-0.21700897812843323,
0.4323290288448334,
-0.12429993599653244,
-0.1961950659751892,
-0.18675753474235535,
-0.7211982607841492,
-0.37369492650032043,
0.035134561359882355,
0.312982976436615,
0.2977239191532135
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.06613v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.06613v1
|
GameBench: Evaluating Strategic Reasoning Abilities of LLM Agents
| 2024-06-07T00:28:43 | 2024-06-07T00:28:43 |
Anthony Costarelli, Mat Allen, Roman Hauksson, Grace Sodunke, Suhas Hariharan, Carlson Cheng, Wenjie Li, Arjun Yadav
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large language models have demonstrated remarkable few-shot performance on
many natural language understanding tasks. Despite several demonstrations of
using large language models in complex, strategic scenarios, there lacks a
comprehensive framework for evaluating agents' performance across various types
of reasoning found in games. To address this gap, we introduce GameBench, a
cross-domain benchmark for evaluating strategic reasoning abilities of LLM
agents. We focus on 9 different game environments, where each covers at least
one axis of key reasoning skill identified in strategy games, and select games
for which strategy explanations are unlikely to form a significant portion of
models' pretraining corpuses. Our evaluations use GPT-3 and GPT-4 in their base
form along with two scaffolding frameworks designed to enhance strategic
reasoning ability: Chain-of-Thought (CoT) prompting and Reasoning Via Planning
(RAP). Our results show that none of the tested models match human performance,
and at worse GPT-4 performs worse than random action. CoT and RAP both improve
scores but not comparable to human levels.
|
[
-0.42338287830352783,
-0.7487313151359558,
0.8897685408592224,
0.16375577449798584,
-0.024654271081089973,
0.4678374230861664,
-0.1964898705482483,
-0.22399353981018066,
-0.18065398931503296,
0.27343079447746277,
-0.7167962789535522,
-0.6749241948127747,
-0.40474289655685425,
-0.08114376664161682,
0.04730254411697388,
0.7889904379844666,
-0.2429257482290268,
0.24755573272705078,
-0.27004218101501465,
-0.041490718722343445,
-0.49853113293647766,
-0.4592021703720093,
-0.9273272752761841,
-0.68950355052948,
0.17836721241474152,
0.38732823729515076,
0.7258854508399963,
0.33611345291137695,
0.6199658513069153,
0.3325866162776947,
0.10814014822244644,
0.0966210812330246,
-0.8021337985992432,
0.3584541082382202,
-0.876181423664093,
-0.4939208924770355,
-0.5734937191009521,
0.15204480290412903,
0.42637670040130615,
0.30352529883384705,
-0.1731196939945221,
0.1588478833436966,
-0.3334072530269623,
0.39391252398490906,
-0.6021032929420471,
0.2635030746459961,
-0.6676690578460693,
0.15659500658512115,
0.031054459512233734,
-0.25474831461906433,
-0.3678257167339325,
-0.10624657571315765,
0.19299176335334778,
-0.8153122663497925,
0.16389164328575134,
0.15322452783584595,
0.8100863695144653,
0.2482653707265854,
-0.2432888001203537,
-0.21753978729248047,
-0.6807054281234741,
0.5856070518493652,
-0.5223748683929443,
0.11457730084657669,
0.3207716643810272,
0.6580801010131836,
-0.3893633186817169,
-0.5819686651229858,
-0.3055803179740906,
-0.3170260787010193,
0.2633545696735382,
0.5818566083908081,
-0.4173325002193451,
0.23388522863388062,
0.5761347413063049,
-0.12367112189531326,
-0.6941090226173401,
-0.02735120989382267,
-0.21211719512939453,
-0.12443777918815613,
0.7911372184753418,
0.2283254712820053,
0.030045026913285255,
0.23200270533561707,
-0.6655904054641724,
-0.2599562704563141,
-0.5525707006454468,
0.1554429531097412,
0.3110441267490387,
-0.054773617535829544,
0.1793454885482788,
0.4599033296108246,
-0.11099068075418472,
0.47031068801879883,
0.20992441475391388,
-0.046555254608392715,
-0.1108585074543953,
-0.47539040446281433,
-0.04946870729327202,
0.06446924060583115,
0.5354102253913879,
0.5947148203849792,
0.21609574556350708,
-0.3706094026565552,
-0.19612860679626465,
0.352230966091156,
0.3102158308029175,
-0.5502333641052246,
-0.300125390291214,
0.1408536434173584,
-0.31625357270240784,
-0.026295725256204605,
-0.05323493480682373,
-0.6644325256347656,
-0.5427618622779846,
0.0006849381024949253,
0.3225918114185333,
-0.5851635932922363,
-0.07054238766431808,
0.10542987287044525,
-0.6030551791191101,
0.659562885761261,
0.08163512498140335,
-0.6277855038642883,
0.4992249608039856,
0.7777299284934998,
0.5908243656158447,
-0.5306859016418457,
-0.5591144561767578,
-0.4982854425907135,
0.1637631505727768,
-0.5184032917022705,
1.1976455450057983,
-0.4478283226490021,
-0.48302537202835083,
-0.26950785517692566,
-0.2848844528198242,
-0.10012642294168472,
-0.6410021185874939,
0.7840325236320496,
-0.4668208360671997,
-0.21449442207813263,
-0.611210823059082,
-0.5765761733055115,
-0.13027018308639526,
0.5979214906692505,
-0.5857179164886475,
0.8222522735595703,
0.1223239004611969,
-0.4024397134780884,
0.6317277550697327,
-0.7554858326911926,
-0.4560035765171051,
0.21999584138393402,
-0.29019883275032043,
-0.0022685439325869083,
-0.16650241613388062,
0.2843329906463623,
0.16983181238174438,
-0.539821982383728,
0.17914612591266632,
-0.4017259180545807,
-0.6281252503395081,
0.32062315940856934,
-0.29214444756507874,
0.3810703754425049,
0.07318658381700516,
-0.5938963294029236,
0.38461679220199585,
-0.40135565400123596,
0.5821362733840942,
0.2489653080701828,
-0.20224040746688843,
0.09608238190412521,
0.19277021288871765,
-0.490281879901886,
0.4803015887737274,
0.02552558109164238,
-0.0997338742017746,
0.1665956974029541,
-0.19617532193660736,
0.22275468707084656,
0.6646460890769958,
0.21950146555900574,
0.4881514608860016,
-0.4183734655380249,
0.8535817861557007,
-0.14496512711048126,
0.028722042217850685,
0.47501450777053833,
-0.5841959714889526,
-0.5103910565376282,
-0.1484338641166687,
0.124998539686203,
0.6845349073410034,
-0.9890928268432617,
-0.014974775724112988,
-0.3263563811779022,
-0.5928106307983398,
-0.22554253041744232,
0.10811498016119003,
0.4885629117488861,
0.11165257543325424,
0.28186556696891785,
-0.32332995533943176,
-0.440956175327301,
-0.7999243140220642,
-0.6228591799736023,
-0.2750992774963379,
0.11971628665924072,
0.4160468280315399,
0.6826350092887878,
-0.017253272235393524,
0.8425195217132568,
-0.1099727675318718,
0.08938769996166229,
-0.7919079065322876,
0.2314644157886505,
-0.06485084444284439,
0.05986462160944939,
0.3894462287425995,
-0.23073561489582062,
-0.12455862015485764,
-0.24268895387649536,
-0.6673194169998169,
-0.1667879819869995,
-0.1953331083059311,
-0.5163720846176147,
-0.117350272834301,
0.5251807570457458,
-0.8686526417732239,
0.512055516242981,
0.34146547317504883,
-0.5193524360656738,
0.7006187438964844,
-0.09037011861801147,
0.2038421779870987,
-0.3980289399623871,
0.02732028067111969,
-0.18389052152633667,
-0.04005658999085426,
-0.563683807849884,
0.22606398165225983,
-0.35565537214279175,
-0.1084938645362854,
-0.29244133830070496,
0.5971691012382507,
-0.439532607793808,
-0.5273019671440125,
-0.09073048830032349,
0.732273280620575,
0.15138575434684753,
0.43183204531669617,
0.16399803757667542,
0.9495695233345032,
0.2378809154033661,
-0.35101017355918884,
0.5555877685546875,
0.10525611788034439,
-0.36386510729789734,
0.7113866209983826,
-0.6276646852493286,
0.22027185559272766,
0.2271360456943512,
0.5746593475341797,
-0.7464032769203186,
0.08303245902061462,
0.23819592595100403,
-0.22016164660453796,
-0.10398242622613907,
-0.20374059677124023,
-0.34557652473449707,
-0.41671523451805115,
-0.257609099149704,
0.18921980261802673,
0.2397034913301468,
-0.21758122742176056,
0.7205326557159424,
0.15342570841312408,
0.08165177702903748,
-0.4555720388889313,
-0.5603367686271667,
-0.018669001758098602,
-0.23405735194683075,
-0.5728883743286133,
0.411577045917511,
0.021860506385564804,
-0.4933971166610718,
-0.01760317198932171,
-0.374517023563385,
-0.10798244923353195,
-0.008880238980054855,
0.1340070366859436,
0.05462617054581642,
-0.4267265200614929,
0.0411248616874218,
-0.3282018005847931,
-0.2331669181585312,
0.4901861846446991,
-0.168614462018013,
0.3646944463253021,
-0.45737552642822266,
-0.5251820683479309,
0.27577120065689087,
0.1991695761680603,
0.31351548433303833,
-0.3275700509548187,
0.46602576971054077,
0.46773475408554077,
-0.04634945094585419,
-0.5257502794265747,
-0.4819561243057251,
-0.1625896543264389,
-0.4138599634170532,
0.3970799446105957,
-0.688491940498352,
-0.4849235415458679,
0.6400318741798401,
-0.48036763072013855,
-0.21456122398376465,
0.37300047278404236,
0.5096491575241089,
0.015835922211408615,
1.0052130222320557,
0.09845505654811859,
0.1514953225851059,
0.04172619804739952,
-0.41260677576065063,
0.21984261274337769,
-0.5341153740882874,
-0.10577933490276337,
-0.11425671726465225,
-0.4812490940093994,
-0.3714289963245392,
-0.7578499913215637,
0.12073907256126404,
0.07118920981884003,
-0.5065473914146423,
0.10323647409677505,
-0.1904214769601822,
0.9134166836738586,
0.5926783680915833,
0.05491204559803009,
0.18515561521053314,
-0.24404661357402802,
-0.48574113845825195,
0.1921890825033188,
-0.9774168729782104,
-0.5552282929420471,
0.9158549308776855,
0.19247806072235107,
0.5834686160087585,
0.23039545118808746,
0.6063864231109619,
0.1055508404970169,
0.11335086077451706,
-0.676300585269928,
0.8997482061386108,
0.19625797867774963,
-0.9489636421203613,
-0.3706001043319702,
-0.46263137459754944,
-0.8523998260498047,
0.3962447941303253,
-0.18808281421661377,
-0.7547551393508911,
-0.11209864169359207,
-0.25239622592926025,
-0.6566673517227173,
0.3777933418750763,
-0.7560111284255981,
1.1091313362121582,
-0.6572697162628174,
-0.5939105153083801,
-0.3558062016963959,
-0.38244789838790894,
0.3996691405773163,
0.31267353892326355,
-0.0365447923541069,
-0.2099732607603073,
-0.1736258566379547,
0.5518049597740173,
-0.1312645524740219,
0.3626742959022522,
-0.15767455101013184,
0.1347741335630417,
0.5097840428352356,
0.436436265707016,
0.4573826491832733,
-0.12101329863071442,
-0.1316874474287033,
-0.005584904924035072,
0.18461617827415466,
-0.4105207026004791,
-0.8329688310623169,
0.5507392287254333,
-0.7394481301307678,
-0.7738609910011292,
-0.6023369431495667,
-0.5949141979217529,
-0.6605981588363647,
0.05856309086084366,
0.29621681571006775,
0.005833634175360203,
-0.6600777506828308,
-0.029104245826601982,
0.374747097492218,
-0.11173789203166962,
0.06728135049343109,
0.5311800837516785,
-0.026411443948745728,
-0.13910715281963348,
0.7305335998535156,
-0.037954624742269516,
0.394931435585022,
0.009626279585063457,
0.08399837464094162,
-0.4272707998752594,
-0.6319352388381958,
-0.22103272378444672,
-0.039788007736206055,
-1.1032203435897827,
-0.06465239822864532,
-0.02031657099723816,
-0.26179108023643494,
0.1698824018239975,
-0.2768263518810272,
-0.19716812670230865,
-0.3002127707004547,
0.3217394948005676,
-0.2764448821544647,
0.09151237457990646,
0.904668390750885,
-0.12974753975868225,
0.2324981838464737,
-0.29660436511039734,
0.24274055659770966,
0.17218370735645294,
0.3862179219722748,
-0.09350847452878952,
-0.16875088214874268,
0.05171608924865723,
-0.03875640779733658,
-0.39882728457450867,
-0.8935293555259705,
-0.05368741229176521,
-0.1024768278002739,
0.8882682919502258,
0.2731105387210846,
-0.1779422163963318,
0.7298510670661926,
-0.32874277234077454,
0.7877465486526489,
-0.11462730914354324,
-0.9075079560279846,
0.5530600547790527,
-0.3952241837978363,
0.43414366245269775,
0.6638540625572205,
0.26146426796913147,
-0.06616733223199844,
-0.18538706004619598,
-0.8376764059066772,
-0.5759848952293396,
0.7393677234649658,
0.1922551840543747,
-0.6202410459518433,
-0.03188600763678551,
0.10002287477254868,
-0.24311886727809906,
-0.07339353114366531,
-0.4449464678764343,
0.027075380086898804,
0.0043937149457633495,
0.05859117582440376,
-0.2589337229728699,
0.011663051322102547,
-0.3204892873764038,
-0.21907389163970947,
0.6332955956459045,
-0.1043175607919693,
0.27793222665786743,
0.11771153658628464,
-0.1820702850818634,
-0.12701240181922913,
0.27433010935783386,
0.5085982084274292,
0.8670885562896729,
-0.07229622453451157,
0.05546967312693596,
0.6485246419906616,
-0.24810291826725006,
0.34747254848480225,
0.13345183432102203,
0.1470414102077484,
-0.3259108364582062,
0.6715243458747864,
0.5116463899612427,
0.5699865818023682,
-0.823743999004364,
0.48388877511024475,
-0.1560163050889969,
-0.38721880316734314,
0.027280762791633606,
0.26611295342445374,
0.15695057809352875,
0.6006121635437012,
-0.08446211367845535,
-0.02366810478270054,
0.1687510758638382,
-0.7026764750480652,
0.16329419612884521,
0.474884033203125,
-0.1925998032093048,
0.03260895609855652,
0.37715011835098267,
0.16020381450653076,
-0.15081773698329926,
0.4272643029689789,
-0.6652514338493347,
-0.7198693752288818,
0.6580725908279419,
0.4439716637134552,
0.6897563338279724,
0.04525480419397354,
0.42041605710983276,
0.13462893664836884,
0.4147217869758606,
0.008952099829912186,
0.48586562275886536,
-0.010420042090117931,
-0.7130194902420044,
-0.4450947344303131,
-0.01486462727189064,
-0.707054078578949,
0.0587863028049469,
-0.21106591820716858,
-0.1084405928850174,
-0.6842800378799438,
-0.4950488209724426,
-0.05523717403411865,
0.41228029131889343,
-0.9503551721572876,
-0.13968683779239655,
0.18095333874225616,
1.012528419494629,
-0.4173952341079712,
0.36549198627471924,
0.7137004137039185,
-0.5998038649559021,
-0.9463475942611694,
0.0030668259132653475,
0.195813849568367,
-0.7141490578651428,
0.7314800024032593,
-0.16884809732437134,
-0.6137841939926147,
-0.11250964552164078,
-0.42693161964416504,
-0.7322655916213989,
1.230835199356079,
0.2648795247077942,
-0.35043787956237793,
0.012251180596649647,
0.23047983646392822,
0.6188222765922546,
-0.45484861731529236,
0.63234543800354,
0.9775360226631165,
0.6028460264205933,
0.30992814898490906,
-0.6529725193977356,
0.12113939225673676,
-0.05594224855303764,
-0.18262852728366852,
-0.24344176054000854,
-0.6056525111198425,
0.571100115776062,
-0.37880831956863403,
-0.30550456047058105,
0.030552655458450317,
0.3117642104625702,
0.6108681559562683,
0.28830140829086304,
0.3456879258155823,
0.6019153594970703,
0.8408505320549011,
-0.4245709180831909,
1.0157792568206787,
-0.3091726005077362,
-0.010893750004470348,
1.1820467710494995,
-0.7916297912597656,
0.8613921999931335,
0.044256459921598434,
-0.1397780179977417,
0.6819316148757935,
0.5227072834968567,
0.03147783875465393,
0.3905974328517914,
0.5601771473884583,
-0.05069863423705101,
-0.5672256946563721,
0.03638928756117821,
-0.23155291378498077,
0.708596408367157,
0.4357842803001404,
-0.02437605708837509,
-0.45843207836151123,
-0.5008839964866638,
-0.09074673056602478,
-0.0012213545851409435,
-0.2549745738506317,
0.6865240335464478,
0.06930731981992722,
-0.960006833076477,
0.41949909925460815,
-0.05090644210577011,
0.1931159347295761,
-0.605739414691925,
-0.018181754276156425,
-0.16422925889492035,
0.5842209458351135,
0.17249345779418945,
-1.0389147996902466,
-0.05478200316429138,
0.08473164588212967,
0.12674644589424133,
-0.07798879593610764,
0.8382138609886169,
-0.09246839582920074,
-0.17080987989902496,
0.5911151766777039,
0.9440687894821167,
0.13665996491909027,
-0.030593199655413628,
-1.2301503419876099,
0.17992953956127167,
-0.42424532771110535,
-0.2305547595024109,
0.17175599932670593,
0.7523958086967468,
-0.12463035434484482,
0.8060287237167358,
0.5932069420814514,
0.12160947918891907,
-0.21317030489444733,
0.2824931740760803,
0.7080641388893127,
-0.6779730916023254,
-0.3557698726654053,
-0.8293266892433167,
0.0419587641954422,
-0.46204620599746704,
-0.4773542284965515,
0.6525591611862183,
0.5292357802391052,
0.5808667540550232,
0.07293854653835297,
0.7104533314704895,
0.2638029158115387,
0.11724110692739487,
-0.4093632102012634,
0.6284353733062744,
-0.0054419017396867275,
0.15730638802051544,
-0.18615174293518066,
-0.871673047542572,
0.02575523965060711,
0.7188752293586731,
-0.8284950256347656,
0.24385859072208405,
0.9582234621047974,
0.6810773015022278,
-0.09766841679811478,
0.14088913798332214,
0.33060717582702637,
0.17538626492023468,
0.30471479892730713,
1.051957368850708,
1.2746647596359253,
-0.04457605257630348,
0.6541274785995483,
0.048226434737443924,
-0.32024627923965454,
-0.02944326214492321,
-0.962096631526947,
-1.2699183225631714,
-0.15814441442489624,
-0.019850322976708412,
-0.3016188144683838,
0.49032559990882874,
0.7957704067230225,
0.6451165080070496,
-0.6006604433059692,
-0.2768094837665558,
-0.02365247718989849,
0.2750418782234192,
-0.4910258948802948,
-0.1821136772632599,
0.08022696524858475,
-0.18972966074943542,
0.07532376050949097,
0.6529419422149658,
0.22884425520896912,
-0.13485819101333618,
-0.3224014639854431,
-0.27729499340057373,
-0.37337547540664673,
0.4847809374332428,
0.5186727046966553,
0.3090527653694153,
-0.9023685455322266,
-0.19306917488574982,
0.14711284637451172,
-0.056337129324674606,
-0.1789269745349884,
0.7864710688591003,
-0.7835870981216431,
0.27211833000183105,
0.3861030340194702,
0.5182597041130066,
0.5166583061218262,
0.18620142340660095,
0.7186012268066406,
-0.33664804697036743,
-0.024943819269537926,
0.42884764075279236,
0.35014933347702026,
0.0973152369260788,
-0.03341124951839447,
0.836937665939331,
0.1082388237118721,
-0.5474227070808411,
-0.3106650412082672,
0.1759309619665146,
-0.6727846264839172,
-0.2930740714073181,
1.1788179874420166,
-0.22959068417549133,
-0.18196715414524078,
0.013853147625923157,
-0.36178046464920044,
-0.00311066722497344,
-0.2806639075279236,
0.37891632318496704,
1.1902121305465698,
-0.3251799941062927,
0.02048579417169094,
-0.7132851481437683,
0.6062639951705933,
0.3099870979785919,
-0.8501002788543701,
0.06277703493833542,
0.46589136123657227,
0.10548225790262222,
0.031947359442710876,
0.7005203366279602,
0.1979208141565323,
0.6217315196990967,
0.5539031624794006,
-0.15177667140960693,
0.0728447362780571,
-0.305886834859848,
0.055068496614694595,
-0.06295130401849747,
0.0876515731215477,
0.14572471380233765
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.04555v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.04555v1
|
Creating an AI Observer: Generative Semantic Workspaces
| 2024-06-07T00:09:13 | 2024-06-07T00:09:13 |
Pavan Holur, Shreyas Rajesh, David Chong, Vwani Roychowdhury
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
An experienced human Observer reading a document -- such as a crime report --
creates a succinct plot-like $\textit{``Working Memory''}$ comprising different
actors, their prototypical roles and states at any point, their evolution over
time based on their interactions, and even a map of missing Semantic parts
anticipating them in the future. $\textit{An equivalent AI Observer currently
does not exist}$. We introduce the $\textbf{[G]}$enerative
$\textbf{[S]}$emantic $\textbf{[W]}$orkspace (GSW) -- comprising an
$\textit{``Operator''}$ and a $\textit{``Reconciler''}$ -- that leverages
advancements in LLMs to create a generative-style Semantic framework, as
opposed to a traditionally predefined set of lexicon labels. Given a text
segment $C_n$ that describes an ongoing situation, the $\textit{Operator}$
instantiates actor-centric Semantic maps (termed ``Workspace instance''
$\mathcal{W}_n$). The $\textit{Reconciler}$ resolves differences between
$\mathcal{W}_n$ and a ``Working memory'' $\mathcal{M}_n^*$ to generate the
updated $\mathcal{M}_{n+1}^*$. GSW outperforms well-known baselines on several
tasks ($\sim 94\%$ vs. FST, GLEN, BertSRL - multi-sentence Semantics
extraction, $\sim 15\%$ vs. NLI-BERT, $\sim 35\%$ vs. QA). By mirroring the
real Observer, GSW provides the first step towards Spatial Computing assistants
capable of understanding individual intentions and predicting future behavior.
|
[
-0.4103025496006012,
-0.6183562278747559,
0.967269241809845,
-0.09364362806081772,
-0.0371839739382267,
-0.24430252611637115,
-0.002380355726927519,
-0.5057446360588074,
0.3911319375038147,
0.2980922758579254,
-0.8722248077392578,
-0.5196230411529541,
-0.6689345836639404,
0.20912019908428192,
-0.41403383016586304,
0.9622049331665039,
-0.12297505885362625,
-0.28048762679100037,
-0.32676053047180176,
-0.1303575485944748,
-0.5305739641189575,
-0.19656281173229218,
-0.5260405540466309,
-0.37702131271362305,
0.4820532202720642,
0.12316472828388214,
0.9759018421173096,
0.7303945422172546,
0.33005490899086,
0.4773975908756256,
0.07439158856868744,
0.1598183661699295,
-0.3772026002407074,
0.059418074786663055,
-0.046017784625291824,
-0.5636504888534546,
-0.41626933217048645,
0.28720536828041077,
0.522805392742157,
0.7765801548957825,
-0.23559406399726868,
-0.19740164279937744,
-0.056020453572273254,
0.47820788621902466,
-0.8380444049835205,
0.41923993825912476,
-0.21973057091236115,
0.5487515330314636,
-0.1877746880054474,
-0.14594849944114685,
-0.34676751494407654,
0.0650390163064003,
0.04010358452796936,
-1.1656465530395508,
0.10379310697317123,
0.06672500818967819,
0.7693476676940918,
0.6566618084907532,
-0.34226399660110474,
-0.12861642241477966,
-0.8166536688804626,
0.5291502475738525,
-0.621466338634491,
0.42825260758399963,
0.19096776843070984,
0.37127241492271423,
-0.5160062909126282,
-0.900367021560669,
-1.0525848865509033,
-0.12049662321805954,
-0.0682775154709816,
0.7074317932128906,
-0.29007938504219055,
0.11017659306526184,
0.21723739802837372,
0.05763677507638931,
-0.34241583943367004,
-0.04466269910335541,
-0.11581801623106003,
-0.09050275385379791,
0.49754995107650757,
0.5747443437576294,
0.25175103545188904,
-0.14742614328861237,
-0.42259281873703003,
-0.12578751146793365,
-0.5792987942695618,
-0.42561280727386475,
0.1858752816915512,
-0.21134813129901886,
-0.11366599053144455,
0.6048967838287354,
-0.10183826833963394,
0.8467336297035217,
0.02533392794430256,
-0.051024165004491806,
0.14291387796401978,
-0.22416482865810394,
-0.2821379005908966,
-0.2666570544242859,
0.7341867685317993,
0.37636950612068176,
0.05224166437983513,
-0.29179465770721436,
-0.24013720452785492,
0.5479047894477844,
0.8441086411476135,
-0.49743595719337463,
-0.4787040054798126,
-0.08980946987867355,
-0.48463156819343567,
-0.2718087434768677,
0.09278053790330887,
-0.5390769839286804,
-0.514216423034668,
-0.6647874712944031,
0.468899667263031,
-0.5058941841125488,
-0.04297806695103645,
-0.29672771692276,
-0.19362376630306244,
0.3611764907836914,
0.7788043022155762,
-0.6065074801445007,
0.02890733815729618,
0.8192669153213501,
0.5492565631866455,
-0.19753704965114594,
-0.8143406510353088,
-0.6314592957496643,
0.26366233825683594,
-0.620667576789856,
0.8028457164764404,
-0.4944714605808258,
-0.5119324326515198,
0.06219303607940674,
-0.18463963270187378,
-0.08447763323783875,
-0.4978126585483551,
0.3119516372680664,
-0.56955486536026,
0.3333692252635956,
0.04092634096741676,
-0.7113773822784424,
0.08751816302537918,
0.31660133600234985,
-0.48098990321159363,
1.028530478477478,
0.16778114438056946,
-0.4101867973804474,
0.718216598033905,
-0.838161051273346,
-0.2886149287223816,
0.18633215129375458,
-0.5827001929283142,
-0.2465369701385498,
0.24194307625293732,
0.04256778582930565,
0.2513529360294342,
0.16524705290794373,
0.154989093542099,
-0.08902830630540848,
-0.34653523564338684,
0.2964349687099457,
-0.19968336820602417,
0.6089431643486023,
0.2845698297023773,
-0.2305813729763031,
0.3165073096752167,
-0.6428552269935608,
-0.29316121339797974,
-0.031849779188632965,
-0.41535624861717224,
-0.262040913105011,
0.5661059617996216,
-0.12223442643880844,
-0.08440133184194565,
0.21523383259773254,
-0.8184781074523926,
-0.012382317334413528,
-0.2721973657608032,
0.30473563075065613,
1.0156893730163574,
-0.10183922946453094,
0.463217169046402,
-0.3455749452114105,
0.4685005843639374,
0.13337399065494537,
0.3183377981185913,
-0.22108429670333862,
-0.5789270997047424,
-0.9348224401473999,
-0.36200040578842163,
-0.35961106419563293,
0.4584941864013672,
-1.0445293188095093,
0.6725046634674072,
-0.30909135937690735,
-0.31717854738235474,
-0.5297535061836243,
0.06151112541556358,
0.4731118083000183,
0.5581675171852112,
0.23985213041305542,
-0.19149340689182281,
-0.405032217502594,
-0.8060805797576904,
-0.2986553907394409,
-0.41183778643608093,
-0.1514335721731186,
0.2119322270154953,
0.40366142988204956,
-0.4883744418621063,
1.127992868423462,
-0.8902975916862488,
-0.49129578471183777,
-0.1431293487548828,
0.20754604041576385,
0.17678888142108917,
0.4399254024028778,
0.5113439559936523,
-0.7817469239234924,
-0.47496843338012695,
-0.2907162308692932,
-1.0545785427093506,
-0.10641833394765854,
-0.19539226591587067,
-0.4433552920818329,
0.42195069789886475,
1.058968424797058,
-0.665516197681427,
0.9470707774162292,
0.5775488018989563,
-0.7330077886581421,
0.3678315281867981,
-0.24989168345928192,
-0.18222223222255707,
-1.3483872413635254,
-0.08231528848409653,
-0.14166668057441711,
-0.2348490208387375,
-0.6974770426750183,
0.3083905875682831,
-0.13409043848514557,
-0.14169734716415405,
-0.23627477884292603,
0.4171367585659027,
-0.5688819885253906,
-0.24614070355892181,
-0.45592883229255676,
0.46951013803482056,
-0.11363914608955383,
0.7691450119018555,
0.13171054422855377,
0.6656131744384766,
0.24795082211494446,
-0.4064794182777405,
0.13804852962493896,
0.49842381477355957,
-0.45784521102905273,
0.7563971281051636,
-0.38751307129859924,
0.20768387615680695,
-0.3062722086906433,
0.16087773442268372,
-0.8514769077301025,
-0.02506965398788452,
0.30190354585647583,
-0.520592212677002,
0.2030820995569229,
-0.04457706958055496,
-0.6260026693344116,
-0.20282010734081268,
0.0005996511899866164,
0.21901991963386536,
0.5067888498306274,
-0.7296938896179199,
1.1935272216796875,
0.3284876048564911,
-0.037988100200891495,
-0.22476617991924286,
-0.6720695495605469,
0.3728090524673462,
0.18281115591526031,
-0.44298237562179565,
0.2557961344718933,
0.05716685578227043,
-0.4406171441078186,
0.4293748438358307,
0.09804017096757889,
0.30985912680625916,
0.22226916253566742,
0.44056379795074463,
0.7682657837867737,
0.000911413342691958,
-0.20665903389453888,
-0.12313725054264069,
-0.5486651659011841,
0.25552138686180115,
-0.18071585893630981,
0.14335186779499054,
-0.08968749642372131,
-0.8178352117538452,
-0.34275636076927185,
0.4020064175128937,
0.5865324139595032,
-0.11254848539829254,
0.5704574584960938,
0.4547198414802551,
-0.48532044887542725,
-0.10732503235340118,
-0.38753122091293335,
0.07719146460294724,
-0.51584792137146,
0.47122856974601746,
-0.32035696506500244,
-0.8024733066558838,
0.49494609236717224,
0.09930445998907089,
0.1572103500366211,
0.48517459630966187,
0.6114612817764282,
-0.326437383890152,
0.9652596116065979,
0.7771469950675964,
-0.2479308843612671,
0.8706662058830261,
-0.06751299649477005,
0.39667752385139465,
-1.0956999063491821,
-0.28435733914375305,
-0.34191495180130005,
-0.333768755197525,
-0.6035758852958679,
-0.5825375318527222,
0.9341241717338562,
-0.12927162647247314,
-0.23735159635543823,
0.3559933006763458,
-0.40920600295066833,
0.4148798882961273,
0.747456967830658,
0.038021963089704514,
0.14771318435668945,
-0.41228315234184265,
-0.07111981511116028,
-0.21243929862976074,
-0.6310283541679382,
-0.39018189907073975,
0.8085731863975525,
-0.036404628306627274,
0.83673095703125,
0.37996065616607666,
0.7401574850082397,
0.4223971366882324,
0.689833402633667,
-0.6858277320861816,
0.7484745979309082,
-0.029597628861665726,
-0.2583315968513489,
-0.4176293611526489,
-0.14500878751277924,
-1.008543610572815,
0.6087106466293335,
-0.4140882194042206,
-0.9133861660957336,
0.33708950877189636,
0.15783235430717468,
-0.1306740939617157,
0.17315788567066193,
-0.6077626943588257,
0.8922869563102722,
0.09954846650362015,
-0.3327760398387909,
-0.44053804874420166,
-0.7131251692771912,
0.011586055159568787,
0.14904145896434784,
-0.04148830845952034,
-0.11060941964387894,
-0.0482686385512352,
0.49797990918159485,
-0.7825494408607483,
1.1321088075637817,
-0.4316207468509674,
0.10427350550889969,
0.31642553210258484,
0.1922081559896469,
0.614467203617096,
-0.0523383803665638,
0.22217589616775513,
-0.15466448664665222,
-0.12612658739089966,
-0.25300467014312744,
-0.732314944267273,
0.3967619240283966,
-0.9343125820159912,
-0.6027740836143494,
-0.6258289217948914,
-0.6052394509315491,
-0.1845516413450241,
0.26952964067459106,
0.05716527998447418,
0.4017980694770813,
-0.5103989243507385,
-0.2313338965177536,
0.2962131202220917,
-0.1718290150165558,
0.39774152636528015,
0.867154598236084,
-0.24498870968818665,
-0.18062350153923035,
0.7318586111068726,
-0.32738521695137024,
0.019919205456972122,
0.5184366703033447,
0.06830672174692154,
0.0409366600215435,
-0.29056569933891296,
-0.47032755613327026,
-0.11129029840230942,
-0.6534616947174072,
-0.2957635819911957,
-0.5440255403518677,
-0.2538806200027466,
-0.09811728447675705,
-0.5272795557975769,
-0.21934929490089417,
-0.009610334411263466,
-0.3669154942035675,
-0.12108585983514786,
0.21039822697639465,
0.8265292048454285,
-0.19903184473514557,
0.1444527804851532,
-0.6131028532981873,
0.41896411776542664,
0.3636622428894043,
0.07225369662046432,
0.10236319154500961,
-0.25389498472213745,
-0.33228862285614014,
-0.1446235477924347,
-0.2835257649421692,
-0.7202122807502747,
0.48574572801589966,
0.08749392628669739,
0.7146333456039429,
0.6513314247131348,
-0.08659227937459946,
0.7844417095184326,
-0.701784074306488,
0.9350787997245789,
0.12950752675533295,
-0.9351795315742493,
0.5813308954238892,
-0.2636912763118744,
0.43454909324645996,
0.5845422148704529,
-0.19748231768608093,
-0.7052426338195801,
-0.9435158371925354,
-0.509505569934845,
-0.677847146987915,
0.8031893372535706,
0.27393436431884766,
0.1124151200056076,
-0.3090079426765442,
0.4836190640926361,
-0.09794260561466217,
0.15828149020671844,
-0.3713276982307434,
-0.10319525003433228,
-0.35210585594177246,
-0.17460961639881134,
-0.3644150197505951,
-0.06642159074544907,
-0.3013249337673187,
-0.21283337473869324,
0.41134944558143616,
-0.39766761660575867,
0.7614067792892456,
0.36355334520339966,
-0.06817416101694107,
-0.01636628434062004,
0.11573515087366104,
0.4964466094970703,
0.5774959921836853,
-0.003149336436763406,
0.11062982678413391,
0.10765182971954346,
-0.4944297969341278,
-0.20479638874530792,
0.17994454503059387,
-0.39391833543777466,
-0.18503648042678833,
0.8699021935462952,
0.9595401883125305,
0.18796369433403015,
-0.6801843643188477,
0.6996230483055115,
0.04249776899814606,
-0.22363853454589844,
-0.8236801624298096,
0.27979302406311035,
-0.05680592730641365,
0.5513407588005066,
0.31347137689590454,
0.28752052783966064,
0.16372208297252655,
-0.8762031197547913,
0.02566780522465706,
0.30109116435050964,
-0.45383334159851074,
-0.4135119915008545,
1.0648163557052612,
0.030992310494184494,
-0.39375627040863037,
1.066610336303711,
-0.29361313581466675,
-0.6759443879127502,
0.7064507603645325,
0.4791421890258789,
1.1516544818878174,
0.3133009672164917,
0.007821453735232353,
0.008526750840246677,
0.2063952088356018,
0.28658172488212585,
0.41841286420822144,
-0.3076290190219879,
-1.2235890626907349,
-0.33709466457366943,
-0.5803987979888916,
-0.6100656986236572,
-0.4295109808444977,
-0.8769002556800842,
-0.2772921025753021,
-0.2939528822898865,
-0.08326775580644608,
0.007894940674304962,
-0.20345398783683777,
-0.6849014759063721,
0.030529940500855446,
0.1358068883419037,
1.06757390499115,
-0.8583822250366211,
0.7671778798103333,
1.0353201627731323,
-0.24746036529541016,
-0.562720775604248,
0.2899443209171295,
0.26304197311401367,
-1.0263996124267578,
0.32279446721076965,
-0.14252977073192596,
-0.13666488230228424,
-0.29708096385002136,
-0.5291938185691833,
-0.6821873784065247,
1.3196629285812378,
0.07158540189266205,
-0.4624856114387512,
0.10286947339773178,
-0.21639196574687958,
0.9973689317703247,
-0.4374665915966034,
-0.11105509847402573,
0.4263342022895813,
0.5010660290718079,
-0.06938540190458298,
-0.44865456223487854,
0.09812793880701065,
-0.5061460137367249,
0.16078519821166992,
0.4757799506187439,
-0.7226990461349487,
0.6871750950813293,
-0.33201852440834045,
-0.18108190596103668,
0.4090734124183655,
0.9736295342445374,
0.12167157977819443,
0.38531386852264404,
0.6406533122062683,
0.8476657271385193,
0.5384260416030884,
-0.20736443996429443,
1.2061078548431396,
-0.4536113440990448,
-0.11396357417106628,
1.3899013996124268,
-0.4420715570449829,
0.9085104465484619,
0.7419366240501404,
-0.24703900516033173,
0.7639054656028748,
0.16299910843372345,
-0.16934114694595337,
0.7491382956504822,
-0.0945931002497673,
-0.30484262108802795,
-0.2775280475616455,
0.03598589450120926,
0.21461252868175507,
0.5128551721572876,
0.30228301882743835,
-0.12335707247257233,
-0.08469618856906891,
0.09226326644420624,
-0.004420456942170858,
0.3779144585132599,
-0.04401496797800064,
1.3055636882781982,
-0.012163727544248104,
-0.9745394587516785,
-0.21079176664352417,
0.040163688361644745,
0.36320731043815613,
-0.6295472383499146,
-0.09943967312574387,
-0.3326922655105591,
0.4653435945510864,
-0.018833329901099205,
-0.9715593457221985,
0.4435988664627075,
-0.0742814764380455,
-0.10860856622457504,
-0.26111266016960144,
0.4777472913265228,
-0.2663291096687317,
-0.28807592391967773,
0.4254220426082611,
0.40122345089912415,
0.05910410359501839,
0.2257516086101532,
-0.31088578701019287,
0.1632099747657776,
-0.27643436193466187,
-0.1671707034111023,
0.29009124636650085,
0.5537567138671875,
-0.030692070722579956,
0.5531606674194336,
0.4162118136882782,
-0.00973030086606741,
0.061468254774808884,
0.07386336475610733,
1.147103190422058,
-0.5958414077758789,
-0.6616005897521973,
-0.5726760625839233,
0.3349935710430145,
-0.0017215496627613902,
-0.5941861271858215,
0.6397184729576111,
0.5991947650909424,
0.9159682989120483,
-0.029104696586728096,
0.7578102946281433,
-0.3379078507423401,
0.2905855178833008,
-0.5943900942802429,
0.5541934370994568,
-0.7571170926094055,
-0.06129549443721771,
-0.3049388825893402,
-0.7593401074409485,
-0.028687098994851112,
0.7427076697349548,
-0.12404102087020874,
-0.17931869626045227,
0.6083061695098877,
0.8887766599655151,
0.14750416576862335,
-0.006354185752570629,
0.3076603412628174,
0.29805925488471985,
0.36105260252952576,
0.6001962423324585,
1.0530081987380981,
-0.19337263703346252,
0.32574012875556946,
-0.05230994150042534,
-0.28127601742744446,
-0.018520306795835495,
-0.8228989839553833,
-0.8296807408332825,
-0.7447006702423096,
-0.18409202992916107,
-0.2865698039531708,
0.1012534499168396,
0.6530764102935791,
0.6214535236358643,
-0.5965166687965393,
0.06909284740686417,
-0.3326568007469177,
-0.07878787070512772,
-0.3420754373073578,
-0.30480870604515076,
0.3082740604877472,
-0.3229127526283264,
-0.8575529456138611,
0.5222061276435852,
0.48222723603248596,
0.00021510157966986299,
-0.3707347810268402,
-0.3155970275402069,
0.03882301226258278,
0.0677412748336792,
0.7186479568481445,
0.30305442214012146,
-0.6621478199958801,
-0.5815979838371277,
-0.302715927362442,
-0.3089601397514343,
-0.023591332137584686,
0.6294488310813904,
-0.7598258256912231,
0.7060154676437378,
0.32015863060951233,
0.5993019938468933,
0.8462255597114563,
-0.18304696679115295,
0.8302034735679626,
-0.505711555480957,
0.20367181301116943,
0.10813167691230774,
0.5099168419837952,
0.07959432899951935,
-0.38121986389160156,
0.8149657845497131,
0.31085899472236633,
-0.4875587522983551,
-0.4284140467643738,
0.29110145568847656,
-0.9160939455032349,
-0.26239949464797974,
0.6499373912811279,
-0.12029504776000977,
-0.17278140783309937,
0.1594706028699875,
-0.12667277455329895,
0.17844800651073456,
-0.24354824423789978,
0.9754820466041565,
0.4199386239051819,
-0.5046318173408508,
0.0945080816745758,
-0.3894813358783722,
0.4423612356185913,
0.38964444398880005,
-0.9613795876502991,
-0.21140888333320618,
0.8969072103500366,
0.072556272149086,
0.3407891094684601,
0.9379702806472778,
-0.1544184386730194,
0.3969077169895172,
0.36675071716308594,
0.15017853677272797,
-0.12887336313724518,
-0.47617945075035095,
-0.06739276647567749,
-0.21812109649181366,
-0.02560214139521122,
-0.5056043863296509
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.04541v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.04541v1
|
Label-Synchronous Neural Transducer for E2E Simultaneous Speech Translation
| 2024-06-06T22:39:43 | 2024-06-06T22:39:43 |
Keqi Deng, Philip C. Woodland
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, eess.AS
|
While the neural transducer is popular for online speech recognition,
simultaneous speech translation (SST) requires both streaming and re-ordering
capabilities. This paper presents the LS-Transducer-SST, a label-synchronous
neural transducer for SST, which naturally possesses these two properties. The
LS-Transducer-SST dynamically decides when to emit translation tokens based on
an Auto-regressive Integrate-and-Fire (AIF) mechanism. A latency-controllable
AIF is also proposed, which can control the quality-latency trade-off either
only during decoding, or it can be used in both decoding and training. The
LS-Transducer-SST can naturally utilise monolingual text-only data via its
prediction network which helps alleviate the key issue of data sparsity for E2E
SST. During decoding, a chunk-based incremental joint decoding technique is
designed to refine and expand the search space. Experiments on the
Fisher-CallHome Spanish (Es-En) and MuST-C En-De data show that the
LS-Transducer-SST gives a better quality-latency trade-off than existing
popular methods. For example, the LS-Transducer-SST gives a 3.1/2.9 point BLEU
increase (Es-En/En-De) relative to CAAT at a similar latency and a 1.4 s
reduction in average lagging latency with similar BLEU scores relative to
Wait-k.
|
[
-0.07675390690565109,
-0.45147705078125,
0.08721072971820831,
0.4421566426753998,
-0.6170161962509155,
0.4124435782432556,
-0.1878497451543808,
-0.6945561766624451,
0.5484130382537842,
-0.05556619167327881,
-0.30864113569259644,
-0.028399119153618813,
-0.5859805941581726,
0.09630291163921356,
-0.5322726964950562,
0.5469538569450378,
-0.09778998792171478,
0.23231899738311768,
0.2047409862279892,
-0.0031214216724038124,
-0.5149475932121277,
-0.3740347921848297,
-0.9266125559806824,
-0.30183809995651245,
0.6557807326316833,
-0.15795853734016418,
0.7974573373794556,
0.8351361155509949,
0.2027571201324463,
0.24310986697673798,
-0.2973560094833374,
-0.0772276446223259,
-0.0901276096701622,
0.685031533241272,
-0.014388315379619598,
-0.27845728397369385,
-0.5208386778831482,
-0.31278765201568604,
0.7585657835006714,
0.46942898631095886,
-0.2455892711877823,
0.09068998694419861,
0.03147602453827858,
0.2182510644197464,
-0.2593107521533966,
0.2039860486984253,
-0.4138166904449463,
0.3443131446838379,
-0.28459087014198303,
-0.3387889564037323,
-0.4040412902832031,
-0.1505008041858673,
0.30519264936447144,
-0.4269134998321533,
-0.15306004881858826,
-0.0115694934502244,
0.5144584774971008,
0.6953785419464111,
-0.34549203515052795,
-0.14149484038352966,
-0.9400460124015808,
0.48937180638313293,
-0.6094297766685486,
0.9567517638206482,
0.2830786108970642,
0.13862302899360657,
0.17346929013729095,
-0.8705494403839111,
-0.1683053821325302,
-0.3190242648124695,
-0.10813340544700623,
0.6548854112625122,
0.23431488871574402,
-0.1189114972949028,
-0.05607427656650543,
0.2351466417312622,
-0.7731022238731384,
0.2596496641635895,
-0.216953843832016,
-0.5396900773048401,
0.6467691659927368,
-0.09297048300504684,
0.1478697955608368,
0.2734376788139343,
-0.4239334762096405,
0.09029458463191986,
-0.36483874917030334,
0.08703144639730453,
0.18648262321949005,
0.33530184626579285,
-0.1719229370355606,
0.22955210506916046,
0.29866281151771545,
0.7365926504135132,
-0.026348412036895752,
0.026783525943756104,
0.3873752951622009,
-0.3921399712562561,
0.2108006477355957,
0.5261525511741638,
0.7479673624038696,
0.07021787762641907,
-0.23794487118721008,
-0.3301849663257599,
-0.49137362837791443,
-0.03891075402498245,
0.02677336148917675,
-0.47500747442245483,
0.25316035747528076,
0.34063494205474854,
-0.21499308943748474,
0.12090761214494705,
-0.19835010170936584,
-0.480333536863327,
0.15714497864246368,
-0.3529060482978821,
0.42478740215301514,
-0.06019000709056854,
-0.3934614062309265,
-0.04187385365366936,
-0.0019176603527739644,
-0.04695788770914078,
0.21167628467082977,
-0.6906384229660034,
0.2929072678089142,
0.1977735459804535,
1.1337718963623047,
-0.40883487462997437,
-0.34429317712783813,
-0.880290687084198,
0.21906843781471252,
-0.13566379249095917,
0.5578778982162476,
-0.06103011593222618,
-0.3929899036884308,
-0.10623275488615036,
-0.2387252151966095,
-0.24871878325939178,
-0.3141140043735504,
0.487390398979187,
-0.6130152940750122,
-0.002306312322616577,
-0.004620396066457033,
-0.48932650685310364,
0.23564346134662628,
-0.10183755308389664,
-0.7033938765525818,
1.1407792568206787,
0.004098501522094011,
-0.470990389585495,
-0.05786614120006561,
-0.30073103308677673,
-0.6848610639572144,
0.27211445569992065,
-0.11995045840740204,
-0.35812145471572876,
-0.10496845841407776,
-0.167108952999115,
0.2107154130935669,
-0.13474516570568085,
0.33165591955184937,
0.052986543625593185,
-0.4401291608810425,
0.5265438556671143,
-0.6047173142433167,
0.5736686587333679,
0.3393881022930145,
-0.5087335109710693,
-0.20180505514144897,
-0.5844547152519226,
0.22926704585552216,
0.04311661422252655,
-0.6839946508407593,
-0.08686000853776932,
0.216804638504982,
0.22881875932216644,
0.3194206655025482,
0.2602059543132782,
-0.7063531875610352,
-0.21186526119709015,
-0.3022302985191345,
0.6385098099708557,
0.38462966680526733,
-0.19511142373085022,
0.28457024693489075,
-0.20773766934871674,
0.27136266231536865,
-0.21175704896450043,
0.09167715907096863,
-0.023585794493556023,
-0.47349920868873596,
-0.7256582379341125,
-0.2606181800365448,
0.42703020572662354,
0.9378098845481873,
-0.5926499962806702,
0.475511759519577,
-0.24665385484695435,
-0.4055982530117035,
-0.7610563039779663,
-0.21118398010730743,
0.49699175357818604,
0.35582318902015686,
0.6057539582252502,
-0.3492876887321472,
-0.36937764286994934,
-0.5509288311004639,
-0.5715916752815247,
0.01939542032778263,
0.08379927277565002,
0.027357064187526703,
-0.07999113947153091,
0.17996405065059662,
0.3749731481075287,
0.06308849155902863,
-0.17860040068626404,
-0.02221687138080597,
0.1623651683330536,
0.15038354694843292,
0.47759661078453064,
-0.04732654243707657,
-0.7778298854827881,
-0.6590048670768738,
0.13161857426166534,
-0.593281090259552,
-0.28396016359329224,
-0.41433194279670715,
0.2396404892206192,
0.26885899901390076,
0.5194972157478333,
-0.2793467044830322,
0.4305410087108612,
0.5551610589027405,
-0.16520170867443085,
0.14738377928733826,
-0.2958212196826935,
-0.06461238116025925,
-0.9761792421340942,
-0.18523162603378296,
-0.17586910724639893,
-0.5857205390930176,
-0.6928532719612122,
-0.08112224191427231,
0.32589203119277954,
0.1307956576347351,
-0.6645522713661194,
0.3377853035926819,
-0.5262439846992493,
-0.4926563501358032,
-0.07224083691835403,
0.3252876400947571,
-0.2342587262392044,
0.22336266934871674,
0.32422155141830444,
0.9473766088485718,
0.2205577939748764,
-0.5162355303764343,
0.6066142320632935,
0.23440386354923248,
-0.12117201089859009,
0.43213191628456116,
-0.7053815126419067,
0.4271719455718994,
0.03188713267445564,
0.37323325872421265,
-0.7972532510757446,
0.11402659118175507,
0.06803309917449951,
-0.6026285290718079,
0.6193053126335144,
-0.06320620328187943,
-0.31599855422973633,
-0.4260654151439667,
0.12647534906864166,
0.4877847135066986,
0.35481977462768555,
-0.508736252784729,
0.2816159427165985,
0.22613029181957245,
-0.4135098457336426,
-0.4098273515701294,
-1.170487403869629,
0.0530649796128273,
0.1857621669769287,
-0.5401470065116882,
0.7089461088180542,
-0.12072863429784775,
0.27237144112586975,
-0.019560087472200394,
-0.3374802768230438,
0.05607060715556145,
-0.12372352927923203,
0.1757369339466095,
0.20952238142490387,
-0.13165226578712463,
0.128899484872818,
0.23364105820655823,
-0.5190794467926025,
-0.18380410969257355,
-0.7615770697593689,
0.6236170530319214,
-0.09091069549322128,
-0.41585925221443176,
-0.6960346698760986,
0.524074912071228,
0.42472782731056213,
-0.3518233895301819,
0.49513766169548035,
0.6228718757629395,
-0.25060081481933594,
-0.12883661687374115,
-0.3674962818622589,
-0.12747310101985931,
-0.44045066833496094,
0.42965805530548096,
-0.45091837644577026,
-0.8501392602920532,
0.5156213641166687,
0.025567807257175446,
0.012461675330996513,
0.2786056101322174,
0.7130928039550781,
-0.2591448426246643,
0.681492269039154,
-0.2720014452934265,
0.1370074450969696,
0.574837327003479,
-0.20756053924560547,
0.20117990672588348,
-0.8672977089881897,
-0.44856923818588257,
-0.4086003303527832,
-0.48427334427833557,
-0.5503673553466797,
-0.34873029589653015,
0.4318317174911499,
0.03303674980998039,
-0.10930053144693375,
0.5514861941337585,
-0.6262398362159729,
0.3093060851097107,
0.575656533241272,
0.2718394100666046,
0.14545758068561554,
0.09020104259252548,
-0.08824902772903442,
-0.3251931071281433,
-0.6684418320655823,
0.00872456282377243,
0.6598498225212097,
0.2768755555152893,
0.4676482677459717,
0.07244560122489929,
0.7390897274017334,
0.42754417657852173,
-0.11277519911527634,
-0.753393828868866,
0.2774016559123993,
-0.23287244141101837,
-0.5483498573303223,
-0.413860559463501,
-0.2848849296569824,
-0.745779275894165,
0.42248061299324036,
0.12239502370357513,
-0.6085814237594604,
0.1838066428899765,
0.3432873487472534,
-0.39293983578681946,
0.18573682010173798,
-0.5906610488891602,
0.38261863589286804,
-0.7541665434837341,
-0.7047948837280273,
-0.031351786106824875,
-0.8955049514770508,
-0.1927555799484253,
-0.284625768661499,
0.12887538969516754,
-0.048485349863767624,
-0.18991807103157043,
0.48781266808509827,
-0.3167307376861572,
0.5421438813209534,
-0.2683030664920807,
-0.08301518112421036,
0.19610469043254852,
0.21005108952522278,
0.8605117797851562,
-0.08901547640562057,
-0.32438719272613525,
0.27205243706703186,
0.23575912415981293,
-0.1250065267086029,
-0.3747286796569824,
0.5610913038253784,
-0.7663678526878357,
-0.12920744717121124,
-0.5270324945449829,
-0.4439818561077118,
-0.08347386121749878,
0.1321813017129898,
0.46556371450424194,
0.37471112608909607,
0.09749455004930496,
-0.0014357137260958552,
0.4577714502811432,
0.013989577069878578,
0.5665402412414551,
0.4922531247138977,
-0.08623410016298294,
-0.6055232882499695,
1.2122117280960083,
0.5685137510299683,
0.637466311454773,
0.44762179255485535,
0.1368805468082428,
-0.5949903726577759,
-0.4250563979148865,
-0.5138795971870422,
0.13659453392028809,
-0.43417036533355713,
-0.38462740182876587,
-0.5719109177589417,
-0.6720860004425049,
-0.14121629297733307,
-0.16504085063934326,
-0.7786049246788025,
-0.4791105091571808,
-0.20731039345264435,
0.11276398599147797,
0.2165379524230957,
0.5426941514015198,
-0.3590430021286011,
0.40944531559944153,
-0.8748264312744141,
0.40866053104400635,
0.25761324167251587,
0.34792444109916687,
-0.26087072491645813,
-0.8276856541633606,
-0.28748294711112976,
0.23660007119178772,
0.12532475590705872,
-1.0574126243591309,
0.692188560962677,
0.21113762259483337,
0.3449600040912628,
-0.029958263039588928,
-0.04998369887471199,
0.5686407089233398,
-0.31598538160324097,
0.5865119099617004,
0.21559950709342957,
-1.024702548980713,
0.3456800580024719,
-0.30149686336517334,
0.2984761893749237,
0.24936535954475403,
0.04036619886755943,
-0.9299495220184326,
-0.2907101511955261,
-0.10754318535327911,
-1.0553168058395386,
1.043873906135559,
0.453290730714798,
-0.13537397980690002,
0.23973137140274048,
0.3292182981967926,
0.11451023072004318,
0.20747452974319458,
-0.6003484129905701,
-0.4654273986816406,
-0.39110106229782104,
-0.10651346296072006,
0.1486431062221527,
-0.09020310640335083,
0.22257523238658905,
-0.40633803606033325,
0.7493683099746704,
0.09598769247531891,
0.6347212791442871,
0.3582397401332855,
-0.17950677871704102,
-0.21610571444034576,
0.3220464587211609,
0.5727328062057495,
0.03244752064347267,
-0.2752474546432495,
0.24567893147468567,
0.19037604331970215,
-0.5625318288803101,
0.38229575753211975,
0.5360829830169678,
-0.49153321981430054,
0.26158860325813293,
0.06304549425840378,
1.0316458940505981,
0.2807355523109436,
-0.13609538972377777,
0.3693573772907257,
0.07456578314304352,
-0.16841189563274384,
-0.48477232456207275,
-0.38357165455818176,
0.3046964108943939,
0.3648855686187744,
0.33698639273643494,
0.06568591296672821,
-0.08832801133394241,
-0.030378589406609535,
0.05305429548025131,
0.02872408553957939,
-0.09776187688112259,
-0.40620312094688416,
0.9301086664199829,
0.4209999144077301,
-0.7536465525627136,
0.5427529215812683,
-0.1481168121099472,
-0.46629372239112854,
0.543493390083313,
0.9288297295570374,
0.9288605451583862,
-0.9044283032417297,
0.22053785622119904,
0.34306028485298157,
0.39839261770248413,
-0.1351446807384491,
0.54249507188797,
-0.31525856256484985,
-0.5055599212646484,
-0.45304936170578003,
-0.6893073916435242,
-0.3434451222419739,
0.017422370612621307,
-0.8260220289230347,
0.03248750418424606,
-0.1598881334066391,
-0.20824241638183594,
-0.13062484562397003,
-0.4238213002681732,
-0.6975178718566895,
0.23268850147724152,
0.28405022621154785,
0.5356014370918274,
-0.4352729022502899,
0.9571453928947449,
0.3806450664997101,
-0.14333614706993103,
-0.716929018497467,
-0.10640079528093338,
-0.0036774647887796164,
-0.8323073983192444,
0.6098933219909668,
-0.059307221323251724,
-0.2555168569087982,
0.34305697679519653,
-0.051391955465078354,
-1.369463324546814,
1.2327179908752441,
0.5189758539199829,
-1.0979242324829102,
0.0248101856559515,
0.45489007234573364,
0.5175194144248962,
0.006966319400817156,
0.274028480052948,
0.4858619272708893,
0.5124216079711914,
0.08926666527986526,
-1.228865146636963,
-0.19692687690258026,
-0.19421182572841644,
0.07658851146697998,
0.22468362748622894,
-0.8004078269004822,
0.6031017899513245,
0.08317171782255173,
-0.26795074343681335,
-0.07946302741765976,
0.49474766850471497,
-0.10339639335870743,
0.22615687549114227,
0.47757431864738464,
0.34093645215034485,
0.6863934397697449,
-0.24601958692073822,
0.6065787672996521,
-0.3528396487236023,
0.2973190248012543,
1.411138653755188,
-0.34186482429504395,
1.0586508512496948,
0.6139576435089111,
-0.3287115693092346,
-0.021665507927536964,
0.6743650436401367,
0.2750195264816284,
0.633238673210144,
0.11020888388156891,
-0.5298953056335449,
-0.26435279846191406,
-0.26496919989585876,
-0.7618787884712219,
0.4221458435058594,
0.5981547832489014,
-0.3745746910572052,
-0.07880029082298279,
-0.0278374794870615,
-0.22459760308265686,
-0.2168348729610443,
0.0461440272629261,
0.5772861242294312,
0.24235054850578308,
-0.5477083921432495,
0.5988446474075317,
-0.22560229897499084,
0.4938465356826782,
-0.750804603099823,
0.23668651282787323,
-0.36262401938438416,
0.09751030057668686,
-0.23369140923023224,
-0.5856552720069885,
0.4495925307273865,
-0.2242840826511383,
0.10598807781934738,
-0.6867709755897522,
0.5603272914886475,
-0.8367239236831665,
-0.08640500158071518,
0.6418780088424683,
0.6082639098167419,
0.22881031036376953,
0.13411109149456024,
-0.6315500140190125,
0.4422535300254822,
0.030747169628739357,
-0.48008447885513306,
0.15911558270454407,
-0.05406101793050766,
0.20161689817905426,
0.36720311641693115,
0.5156359076499939,
0.4736080467700958,
0.6691854000091553,
0.1109631210565567,
0.4928887188434601,
-0.4614308178424835,
-0.7019883394241333,
-0.3577563166618347,
0.6128525137901306,
-0.045941513031721115,
0.011714677326381207,
0.43589916825294495,
0.5280448198318481,
0.9331470727920532,
0.12434632331132889,
0.852907657623291,
0.004918564576655626,
0.6798956990242004,
-0.4608957767486572,
0.6415046453475952,
-0.5603334903717041,
0.1320129781961441,
0.2176092267036438,
-0.8652658462524414,
-0.32824277877807617,
0.6847941875457764,
0.17128340899944305,
-0.06683092564344406,
0.8472259044647217,
0.7224029302597046,
0.1419709473848343,
0.2816312611103058,
0.5290878415107727,
0.2825124263763428,
0.11850070208311081,
0.46875301003456116,
0.7581813931465149,
-0.6772577166557312,
0.5479777455329895,
-0.16920089721679688,
0.11454034596681595,
-0.09263933449983597,
-0.5032812356948853,
-0.34080588817596436,
-0.7530328631401062,
-0.4905184805393219,
-0.43431293964385986,
0.33731675148010254,
0.8998275399208069,
0.6818227767944336,
-0.8149308562278748,
-0.28260576725006104,
-0.19902263581752777,
-0.20111580193042755,
-0.34078747034072876,
-0.10772600769996643,
0.17986541986465454,
-0.2416945993900299,
-0.7573692798614502,
0.9438101649284363,
0.4126347601413727,
0.30794209241867065,
-0.2471078783273697,
-0.43742865324020386,
-0.20727844536304474,
-0.1120067685842514,
0.3279839754104614,
0.5608405470848083,
-0.7916262149810791,
-0.2591169476509094,
0.02092537097632885,
-0.11626317352056503,
-0.0005650765378959477,
0.7424346208572388,
-0.5880006551742554,
0.9191729426383972,
0.5174444317817688,
0.8749414682388306,
0.9013327956199646,
-0.5665640234947205,
0.4314440190792084,
-0.8753865957260132,
0.3675806522369385,
0.3730161786079407,
0.29469195008277893,
0.16017235815525055,
-0.4263782799243927,
0.3399379849433899,
0.48647966980934143,
-0.566443920135498,
-0.5839697122573853,
0.2020004540681839,
-1.0659793615341187,
0.10912013798952103,
1.0713465213775635,
-0.1859138309955597,
0.02587389573454857,
-0.22407248616218567,
-0.0481344535946846,
0.7909793257713318,
-0.6035374402999878,
0.2514322102069855,
0.42812731862068176,
-0.07098966091871262,
-0.11345196515321732,
-0.5737850069999695,
0.1842917650938034,
0.760879397392273,
-0.6397312879562378,
-0.25220978260040283,
0.4030812382698059,
0.024184657260775566,
0.034121911972761154,
0.5879506468772888,
0.06027114763855934,
0.3547748327255249,
0.1537197083234787,
0.023375041782855988,
-0.3345390558242798,
-0.3039974272251129,
-0.3800537586212158,
-0.014214026741683483,
-0.10699187964200974,
-0.5564136505126953
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.04528v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.04528v1
|
llmNER: (Zero|Few)-Shot Named Entity Recognition, Exploiting the Power of Large Language Models
| 2024-06-06T22:01:59 | 2024-06-06T22:01:59 |
Fabián Villena, Luis Miranda, Claudio Aracena
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) allow us to generate high-quality human-like
text. One interesting task in natural language processing (NLP) is named entity
recognition (NER), which seeks to detect mentions of relevant information in
documents. This paper presents llmNER, a Python library for implementing
zero-shot and few-shot NER with LLMs; by providing an easy-to-use interface,
llmNER can compose prompts, query the model, and parse the completion returned
by the LLM. Also, the library enables the user to perform prompt engineering
efficiently by providing a simple interface to test multiple variables. We
validated our software on two NER tasks to show the library's flexibility.
llmNER aims to push the boundaries of in-context learning research by removing
the barrier of the prompting and parsing steps.
|
[
-0.3604341447353363,
-0.7470572590827942,
0.679537296295166,
0.061626363545656204,
-0.12283485382795334,
-0.21939300000667572,
-0.22500118613243103,
-0.3235807716846466,
0.17329712212085724,
0.2960548996925354,
-0.42158928513526917,
-0.43906500935554504,
-0.493767648935318,
0.6060306429862976,
-0.5215518474578857,
0.9088801741600037,
-0.08175601810216904,
-0.04510951414704323,
-0.05588237941265106,
0.20665037631988525,
-0.22172124683856964,
-0.40410956740379333,
-0.8664608597755432,
-0.6637782454490662,
0.9386065602302551,
0.45075181126594543,
0.09943593293428421,
0.4462457597255707,
0.5357862710952759,
0.26662003993988037,
-0.14528469741344452,
-0.24051108956336975,
-0.37920960783958435,
0.433513879776001,
-0.1840992420911789,
-0.5219977498054504,
-0.2110379934310913,
-0.2983437478542328,
0.6796559691429138,
0.31494414806365967,
0.11468103528022766,
0.16489101946353912,
-0.0011344695230945945,
0.15261103212833405,
-0.6351494193077087,
-0.03145911544561386,
-0.7672103643417358,
-0.030406000092625618,
-0.39201995730400085,
-0.19693544507026672,
-0.3667708933353424,
0.057323746383190155,
-0.020282074809074402,
-0.374421089887619,
0.27126479148864746,
0.11057209968566895,
0.8902081251144409,
0.41869449615478516,
-0.27896666526794434,
-0.3375564217567444,
-0.5088022351264954,
0.8004305958747864,
-0.6922821998596191,
0.3583153486251831,
0.08190996199846268,
0.39741626381874084,
-0.4261685311794281,
-0.7309821844100952,
-0.8423369526863098,
-0.14832374453544617,
-0.07607293128967285,
-0.340118944644928,
-0.33152854442596436,
0.09736201912164688,
0.4578661620616913,
0.11676487326622009,
-0.5485251545906067,
0.1998434215784073,
-0.10571711510419846,
-0.12458977848291397,
0.3235321044921875,
0.23072199523448944,
0.3060776889324188,
-0.46173325181007385,
-0.17466731369495392,
0.2716429829597473,
-0.6447497606277466,
-0.026531409472227097,
0.14915992319583893,
0.3474114239215851,
0.04386857897043228,
0.9116165637969971,
-0.4505770206451416,
0.8576322793960571,
-0.021103911101818085,
-0.31647318601608276,
0.061926670372486115,
0.2048557698726654,
-0.2642955183982849,
0.4311710298061371,
0.8410330414772034,
0.18801087141036987,
-0.004278938751667738,
-0.23407675325870514,
-0.4247836768627167,
-0.07519698888063431,
-0.17500446736812592,
-1.1753219366073608,
-0.2441701889038086,
0.2954208254814148,
-0.1513156145811081,
-0.2233717143535614,
-0.16012455523014069,
-0.5596174597740173,
-0.42733025550842285,
-0.35612040758132935,
0.3157520592212677,
-0.39356666803359985,
0.0010255837114527822,
0.01021636463701725,
-0.2196637988090515,
0.5004571676254272,
0.41667771339416504,
-0.6575913429260254,
0.3057461977005005,
0.7955357432365417,
0.9254624247550964,
-0.10427380353212357,
-0.37030914425849915,
-0.8868024945259094,
0.08120012283325195,
-0.08554762601852417,
1.036253571510315,
-0.43131887912750244,
-0.1938730627298355,
-0.21264390647411346,
-0.017092060297727585,
0.1630813479423523,
-0.34589684009552,
0.35313883423805237,
-0.5791043639183044,
-0.019294241443276405,
0.02742851711809635,
-0.8155045509338379,
-0.16024644672870636,
0.6876898407936096,
-0.5092077851295471,
0.9280379414558411,
0.09406836330890656,
-0.9008293747901917,
0.3739173114299774,
-0.6465993523597717,
-0.23255281150341034,
0.5376611948013306,
-0.36366894841194153,
-0.25900521874427795,
0.1253095120191574,
0.15399067103862762,
0.6354812979698181,
-0.17507675290107727,
0.23078769445419312,
-0.1624504029750824,
-0.5464840531349182,
0.326763391494751,
-0.36936721205711365,
0.5573657155036926,
0.03895717114210129,
-0.10613162815570831,
0.12873606383800507,
-0.9302692413330078,
-0.111643485724926,
0.25124454498291016,
-0.5729467272758484,
-0.4098558723926544,
-0.20833183825016022,
0.3080054223537445,
0.09197255969047546,
0.2516690492630005,
-0.6396067142486572,
0.48114240169525146,
-0.5081034302711487,
0.5070255398750305,
0.2609967291355133,
0.21830104291439056,
0.7323843240737915,
-0.0048638517037034035,
0.43541857600212097,
-0.26083943247795105,
-0.3429182767868042,
-0.47725334763526917,
-0.30542799830436707,
-0.9699572920799255,
-0.4243333339691162,
0.5101168751716614,
0.7582896947860718,
-0.9102330803871155,
0.28213441371917725,
-0.2541975677013397,
-0.2958092987537384,
-0.41499316692352295,
0.4030490219593048,
0.1122535690665245,
0.6457912921905518,
0.20171476900577545,
0.17553235590457916,
-0.7330156564712524,
-0.6624963283538818,
-0.08051178604364395,
-0.09324473142623901,
-0.4541962146759033,
0.38499903678894043,
0.7864134907722473,
-0.39368072152137756,
1.1590228080749512,
-0.4442848861217499,
-0.3944745361804962,
-0.5401389598846436,
0.2016846090555191,
0.5770166516304016,
0.29998013377189636,
0.23757559061050415,
-0.577879011631012,
-0.489162415266037,
-0.16512344777584076,
-0.7857343554496765,
-0.15607011318206787,
0.004108598921447992,
0.05013515427708626,
0.12843334674835205,
0.4775097966194153,
-0.6818205118179321,
0.20943483710289001,
0.21286071836948395,
0.04177654907107353,
0.3008420467376709,
0.049596596509218216,
-0.1694367229938507,
-1.0872342586517334,
0.010288689285516739,
0.11847089976072311,
-0.36651790142059326,
-0.7879461646080017,
0.08366629481315613,
0.1410093456506729,
-0.1469905823469162,
-0.7630569934844971,
0.9933438897132874,
-0.4680047631263733,
0.09747661650180817,
-0.45892030000686646,
0.23840129375457764,
-0.12465512007474899,
0.09745115041732788,
0.2538343369960785,
0.6173467040061951,
0.6889590620994568,
-0.6916680335998535,
0.4979204833507538,
0.21028785407543182,
-0.22499071061611176,
0.7646113038063049,
-0.734468400478363,
0.2978481650352478,
-0.3334483802318573,
0.08566579967737198,
-0.5912279486656189,
-0.5883589386940002,
0.46299320459365845,
-0.5069350600242615,
0.39076748490333557,
-0.5042901039123535,
-0.47577139735221863,
-0.2201952040195465,
-0.27193236351013184,
0.1768953949213028,
0.10629746317863464,
-0.6457488536834717,
0.8158212900161743,
0.18184885382652283,
-0.1947154402732849,
-0.5478909015655518,
-0.651368260383606,
0.43648257851600647,
-0.22099483013153076,
-0.29236483573913574,
0.2562146782875061,
0.028692418709397316,
-0.25253674387931824,
0.06695444881916046,
0.00013535685138776898,
-0.21286876499652863,
0.0016203606501221657,
0.39338570833206177,
0.36557403206825256,
-0.2892778813838959,
0.1587751805782318,
-0.26604780554771423,
-0.432636022567749,
-0.25494280457496643,
-0.09090124070644379,
0.5929824709892273,
-0.19589082896709442,
-0.14090369641780853,
-0.46962788701057434,
0.029268331825733185,
-0.00584908714517951,
-0.14298789203166962,
0.5659655332565308,
0.39910081028938293,
-0.576425313949585,
-0.3494406044483185,
-0.48651745915412903,
-0.0881650373339653,
-0.4719916582107544,
0.2248699963092804,
-0.6300856471061707,
-1.0791559219360352,
0.08456660062074661,
-0.09178820252418518,
-0.04328661039471626,
0.24300771951675415,
0.3999105393886566,
-0.08545833826065063,
0.5228379964828491,
0.7215259075164795,
-0.2486943006515503,
0.456206351518631,
-0.23423536121845245,
0.29953619837760925,
-0.9332094788551331,
-0.12031456083059311,
-0.6248504519462585,
-0.3466756343841553,
-0.2283429205417633,
-0.2300126701593399,
0.03663421794772148,
0.34983184933662415,
-0.23017765581607819,
0.6652208566665649,
-0.5978758335113525,
0.9120076894760132,
0.5904170870780945,
-0.2550007104873657,
0.21885107457637787,
-0.17060236632823944,
0.04693317040801048,
-0.017612075433135033,
-0.3608500361442566,
-0.6776187419891357,
0.7352168560028076,
0.2409237027168274,
0.9514065384864807,
-0.04502561688423157,
1.3510425090789795,
-0.02605651132762432,
0.32680705189704895,
-1.4301042556762695,
0.6673649549484253,
0.23051239550113678,
-0.5659999847412109,
-0.3525703549385071,
-0.35758522152900696,
-0.8459627628326416,
0.1954500526189804,
-0.223255455493927,
-1.0023167133331299,
0.04544709995388985,
-0.017316436395049095,
-0.3883432149887085,
0.26682496070861816,
-0.23959201574325562,
0.7538414597511292,
-0.23398970067501068,
-0.06187073886394501,
0.42789503931999207,
-0.396707147359848,
0.30661407113075256,
0.007357919588685036,
-0.10099459439516068,
-0.2146340012550354,
-0.2513100504875183,
0.47743239998817444,
0.14404751360416412,
0.6629241704940796,
-0.10801710933446884,
0.01577548310160637,
0.2610175311565399,
0.42494624853134155,
0.5294091701507568,
0.2464066445827484,
-0.22497645020484924,
0.29888713359832764,
-0.09562467783689499,
0.052023909986019135,
-0.5487439036369324,
0.8875170946121216,
-0.3733218014240265,
-0.40097859501838684,
-0.6544521450996399,
-0.5590583086013794,
0.42627960443496704,
0.5625470876693726,
0.23307877779006958,
0.25612902641296387,
-0.3166937828063965,
0.10933270305395126,
0.5578988790512085,
-0.149163156747818,
0.6551574468612671,
0.7137895226478577,
-0.5185611248016357,
-0.5046562552452087,
0.8979012370109558,
0.03687561675906181,
-0.34249821305274963,
0.7773506045341492,
-0.07978717237710953,
-0.1649341732263565,
-0.4552346169948578,
-0.5194075107574463,
0.29238682985305786,
-0.6999925374984741,
-0.4786073565483093,
-0.7808486223220825,
-0.4225881099700928,
-0.26323777437210083,
-0.31428614258766174,
-0.10012754797935486,
-0.3766633868217468,
-0.5931451916694641,
-0.0165439173579216,
0.30443093180656433,
0.7168642282485962,
0.16187721490859985,
0.5772666931152344,
-0.6964929103851318,
0.4900079369544983,
0.2013426423072815,
0.15551920235157013,
-0.2713923752307892,
-0.368962824344635,
0.13387592136859894,
-0.4264317750930786,
-0.14668959379196167,
-0.8347271680831909,
0.41013771295547485,
0.3899625539779663,
0.49997004866600037,
0.5651392936706543,
0.14551839232444763,
0.38679760694503784,
-0.8070715069770813,
0.6253366470336914,
0.17527425289154053,
-0.8975592851638794,
0.6963896155357361,
-0.010611328296363354,
0.21280595660209656,
0.4960661232471466,
0.4508246183395386,
-0.6721857190132141,
-0.15244589745998383,
-0.3102218806743622,
-0.8111964464187622,
0.7260244488716125,
0.04435807839035988,
0.15653261542320251,
-0.23457981646060944,
0.46527716517448425,
-0.13913926482200623,
0.012324942275881767,
-0.9020586609840393,
-0.2474241405725479,
0.04579174146056175,
-0.31062817573547363,
-0.1656823754310608,
-0.33112141489982605,
0.14180438220500946,
-0.05937592685222626,
0.7625144124031067,
-0.3170734643936157,
0.018747135996818542,
0.23299932479858398,
-0.5120546817779541,
0.12123866379261017,
0.7879842519760132,
0.29791030287742615,
0.08369109779596329,
-0.33176201581954956,
0.4330722689628601,
0.4319102466106415,
-0.05804523453116417,
0.3170963227748871,
0.1570555716753006,
-0.5953662395477295,
0.18202298879623413,
0.3215959668159485,
0.6335323452949524,
0.3904137909412384,
-0.5096606016159058,
0.5268748998641968,
-0.18941852450370789,
-0.0191788487136364,
-0.39728111028671265,
0.24895864725112915,
0.202381893992424,
0.47280192375183105,
0.23787575960159302,
-0.19315670430660248,
0.3207271993160248,
-0.10571800917387009,
0.2661445140838623,
0.4398554265499115,
-0.5245842933654785,
-0.09443365037441254,
0.5917490124702454,
-0.008642025291919708,
-0.7426449656486511,
0.7262502312660217,
-0.5682785511016846,
-0.4141238331794739,
0.3118852376937866,
0.7924243211746216,
0.8710209131240845,
0.06835123896598816,
0.06670664995908737,
0.5344457626342773,
0.1242332011461258,
-0.07557138800621033,
0.16298966109752655,
-0.2052987664937973,
-0.7865188717842102,
-0.31784823536872864,
-0.9476569294929504,
-0.515434980392456,
0.21976421773433685,
-0.27563467621803284,
0.6120980978012085,
-0.45604565739631653,
-0.328669011592865,
0.31663885712623596,
-0.055288247764110565,
-0.5808411240577698,
-0.2388947606086731,
0.44301867485046387,
0.9201193451881409,
-0.4504621922969818,
0.9828569889068604,
0.8326451182365417,
-0.6344438195228577,
-0.5724359154701233,
-0.09100222587585449,
0.3056364953517914,
-0.43360164761543274,
1.07156240940094,
0.5131378769874573,
-0.10880333930253983,
0.3298180103302002,
-0.6521977186203003,
-0.7182014584541321,
1.038043737411499,
0.33839330077171326,
-0.7754297852516174,
-0.21895785629749298,
0.06618276238441467,
0.20945589244365692,
-0.3125956654548645,
0.43103018403053284,
0.5075580477714539,
0.38337215781211853,
0.2407858520746231,
-0.6678506731987,
-0.1056695356965065,
0.0034028857480734587,
0.16646775603294373,
0.28006502985954285,
-0.06592343747615814,
0.940108060836792,
-0.33108988404273987,
-0.250537633895874,
0.13833901286125183,
0.7298145890235901,
0.43534186482429504,
0.4165860712528229,
0.2830135226249695,
0.5308427214622498,
0.6762027740478516,
0.04934234544634819,
0.883514940738678,
-0.21792928874492645,
0.45022284984588623,
1.3269965648651123,
-0.5390031337738037,
1.0922504663467407,
0.6226177215576172,
-0.18061617016792297,
0.34915152192115784,
0.3523215353488922,
-0.3157045841217041,
0.41960835456848145,
0.3977833688259125,
-0.5917225480079651,
-0.18534408509731293,
-0.2551232576370239,
0.08107652515172958,
0.2583564817905426,
0.25221556425094604,
-0.08279486000537872,
-0.5030785799026489,
-0.020465372130274773,
0.05165352299809456,
-0.3004416823387146,
-0.3502407968044281,
0.8140081763267517,
0.41688308119773865,
-0.05685779079794884,
0.37986889481544495,
0.18457753956317902,
1.1754965782165527,
-0.43311038613319397,
-0.32452449202537537,
0.03875047340989113,
0.29450052976608276,
-0.37170830368995667,
-0.7829363942146301,
0.06436190754175186,
0.2919921576976776,
-0.23211409151554108,
0.03563661500811577,
1.1795434951782227,
-0.3311144709587097,
-0.6075004935264587,
0.39844200015068054,
0.4038156569004059,
0.5949245691299438,
-0.24326485395431519,
-0.4959027171134949,
-0.059854526072740555,
-0.3097902238368988,
-0.34783732891082764,
0.21912233531475067,
0.4610482156276703,
0.23275619745254517,
0.7021995782852173,
0.6187071800231934,
0.13877995312213898,
0.07582368701696396,
0.1572086364030838,
0.6418991684913635,
-0.8127673864364624,
-0.005546821281313896,
-1.107081413269043,
0.33348655700683594,
0.03545384109020233,
-0.02694118581712246,
0.709296464920044,
0.7119274139404297,
0.9117252826690674,
-0.04900528863072395,
0.6657806634902954,
-0.2838841378688812,
0.44210556149482727,
-0.31751787662506104,
0.8401510119438171,
-0.3624476492404938,
0.17052847146987915,
-0.09949667751789093,
-0.9773439168930054,
-0.744426429271698,
0.7620568871498108,
-0.2710477113723755,
-0.38461482524871826,
0.37280747294425964,
0.9807219505310059,
-0.15953947603702545,
-0.4196225702762604,
0.5096796154975891,
0.04239119216799736,
0.40504997968673706,
0.5076384544372559,
1.0033111572265625,
-0.4710195064544678,
0.463530570268631,
-0.3571334481239319,
0.01692446880042553,
-0.22960634529590607,
-1.1090401411056519,
-1.0650274753570557,
-0.1489904820919037,
-0.23234215378761292,
-0.03804261237382889,
-0.12863807380199432,
1.264158010482788,
0.4106348156929016,
-0.9287580847740173,
-0.07258396595716476,
-0.041008830070495605,
0.326481431722641,
0.24002166092395782,
-0.23842796683311462,
0.048490457236766815,
-0.5241029262542725,
-0.9032183885574341,
0.6161664724349976,
0.3320109248161316,
0.04151611402630806,
-0.008584905415773392,
-0.2564711272716522,
-0.18290090560913086,
-0.14325623214244843,
0.48494234681129456,
0.40893250703811646,
-0.8247224688529968,
-0.07243905961513519,
0.0306891817599535,
-0.1999209225177765,
0.07396513223648071,
0.6210423111915588,
-0.8635551929473877,
0.11562177538871765,
0.6160606741905212,
0.7561400532722473,
0.4091770648956299,
-0.27693891525268555,
0.121211938560009,
-0.7251358032226562,
0.10413341224193573,
0.18594224750995636,
0.6343724131584167,
0.4614308178424835,
-0.4129983186721802,
0.4234175980091095,
0.03408225253224373,
-0.6344069838523865,
-0.8333421349525452,
0.03751988708972931,
-0.8954862952232361,
-0.13242463767528534,
1.180300235748291,
-0.0701557993888855,
-0.4181365668773651,
-0.047002363950014114,
-0.4017808139324188,
0.27065935730934143,
-0.6045167446136475,
0.2856767773628235,
0.48529624938964844,
-0.3322363793849945,
-0.5194805264472961,
-0.6622642278671265,
0.11014823615550995,
-0.30503398180007935,
-0.6483638882637024,
-0.28894245624542236,
0.4484878480434418,
0.7513396739959717,
0.21406958997249603,
0.7612094879150391,
0.21664239466190338,
-0.07483819127082825,
-0.024778248742222786,
0.4291882812976837,
-0.27392518520355225,
-0.4609034061431885,
-0.6998339891433716,
0.07603219151496887,
0.20653048157691956,
0.0394684299826622
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.04523v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.04523v1
|
Proofread: Fixes All Errors with One Tap
| 2024-06-06T21:38:08 | 2024-06-06T21:38:08 |
Renjie Liu, Yanxiang Zhang, Yun Zhu, Haicheng Sun, Yuanbo Zhang, Michael Xuelin Huang, Shanqing Cai, Lei Meng, Shumin Zhai
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
The impressive capabilities in Large Language Models (LLMs) provide a
powerful approach to reimagine users' typing experience. This paper
demonstrates Proofread, a novel Gboard feature powered by a server-side LLM in
Gboard, enabling seamless sentence-level and paragraph-level corrections with a
single tap. We describe the complete system in this paper, from data
generation, metrics design to model tuning and deployment. To obtain models
with sufficient quality, we implement a careful data synthetic pipeline
tailored to online use cases, design multifaceted metrics, employ a two-stage
tuning approach to acquire the dedicated LLM for the feature: the Supervised
Fine Tuning (SFT) for foundational quality, followed by the Reinforcement
Learning (RL) tuning approach for targeted refinement. Specifically, we find
sequential tuning on Rewrite and proofread tasks yields the best quality in SFT
stage, and propose global and direct rewards in the RL tuning stage to seek
further improvement. Extensive experiments on a human-labeled golden set showed
our tuned PaLM2-XS model achieved 85.56\% good ratio. We launched the feature
to Pixel 8 devices by serving the model on TPU v5 in Google Cloud, with
thousands of daily active users. Serving latency was significantly reduced by
quantization, bucket inference, text segmentation, and speculative decoding.
Our demo could be seen in \href{https://youtu.be/4ZdcuiwFU7I}{Youtube}.
|
[
-0.017206840217113495,
-0.7655088305473328,
0.5382228493690491,
0.1544117033481598,
-0.35843074321746826,
0.27959421277046204,
-0.06878641992807388,
-0.5233335494995117,
0.24874520301818848,
0.8110047578811646,
-0.5573334097862244,
-0.6362373232841492,
-0.3699275553226471,
0.029856732115149498,
-0.37727952003479004,
1.1422852277755737,
-0.1811620593070984,
-0.12206844240427017,
-0.058191876858472824,
-0.08907026797533035,
-0.41188734769821167,
-0.31691455841064453,
-0.6390431523323059,
0.007447446696460247,
0.3064574599266052,
0.781261146068573,
0.8161225318908691,
0.8190053105354309,
0.3793606460094452,
0.22050777077674866,
-0.2852433919906616,
0.43311741948127747,
-0.6820313930511475,
0.305154412984848,
-0.08793353289365768,
-0.7131258845329285,
-0.6063280701637268,
-0.1338859349489212,
0.3167332112789154,
0.2032461166381836,
-0.27504873275756836,
-0.012256055139005184,
0.1521521508693695,
0.5821736454963684,
-0.25562039017677307,
-0.10199537873268127,
-0.7041134238243103,
-0.19552114605903625,
-0.11122696101665497,
-0.05815187469124794,
-0.41629472374916077,
-0.5828459858894348,
-0.296367347240448,
-0.8111621737480164,
0.7704866528511047,
0.25391578674316406,
0.8742343783378601,
0.0951567068696022,
-0.10791240632534027,
-0.14412590861320496,
-0.2748945355415344,
0.3198452591896057,
-0.793467104434967,
0.44378820061683655,
0.570754885673523,
0.22699804604053497,
-0.3005065619945526,
-0.6615080237388611,
-0.724338710308075,
-0.1831999570131302,
0.2602649927139282,
-0.03654530271887779,
0.1636422723531723,
0.3128804564476013,
0.2756267786026001,
0.6403452754020691,
-0.4184017777442932,
0.23981274664402008,
-0.14701290428638458,
-0.32671359181404114,
0.5677186846733093,
-0.04818763583898544,
0.3868025243282318,
0.10890118777751923,
0.12105903029441833,
-0.09605716913938522,
-0.9344030022621155,
0.20684070885181427,
0.42581021785736084,
0.13078616559505463,
0.008647940121591091,
0.5986512303352356,
-0.19601967930793762,
0.7810053825378418,
0.323829710483551,
-0.5345331430435181,
0.03793901950120926,
-0.20885244011878967,
-0.2872931659221649,
-0.02855396643280983,
0.6296988725662231,
0.5004299283027649,
0.1364542692899704,
-0.25447332859039307,
-0.4629839062690735,
0.0095569659024477,
0.2435462772846222,
-0.7187516093254089,
-0.2447548657655716,
0.4463668167591095,
-0.20425482094287872,
-0.5701061487197876,
-0.23220834136009216,
-0.5270800590515137,
-0.7906916737556458,
-0.11163166910409927,
0.3520742356777191,
-0.512849748134613,
0.11696268618106842,
0.3518012464046478,
-0.14495949447155,
-0.3727254271507263,
0.5915610194206238,
-1.2992777824401855,
0.0868721455335617,
0.9476073980331421,
0.8729540109634399,
0.3459245264530182,
-0.3962908983230591,
-0.5498649477958679,
-0.0781150534749031,
-0.4029368460178375,
0.9143319129943848,
-0.1622021645307541,
-0.3714146018028259,
0.017369786277413368,
-0.18949618935585022,
0.14314760267734528,
-0.5544739961624146,
0.781419038772583,
-0.84858238697052,
-0.01561431959271431,
-0.22601281106472015,
-0.7157962322235107,
0.016159994527697563,
0.23338305950164795,
-0.5599050521850586,
0.7029685974121094,
0.0954272598028183,
-0.748683750629425,
0.6937950849533081,
-0.46893540024757385,
-0.7133110761642456,
0.01587802544236183,
0.3655073344707489,
-0.5649287700653076,
0.21176184713840485,
0.4875992238521576,
0.3472288250923157,
-0.14720919728279114,
0.20489725470542908,
-0.36950230598449707,
-0.06052374094724655,
0.06968595832586288,
-0.11571768671274185,
0.38282933831214905,
0.058540232479572296,
-0.2752450406551361,
0.47049030661582947,
-1.0876957178115845,
0.27244696021080017,
-0.16724634170532227,
-0.3737611770629883,
0.3311775028705597,
-0.005040545016527176,
0.3180886507034302,
0.20268483459949493,
0.21968767046928406,
-0.7335708141326904,
0.4359017610549927,
-0.22101399302482605,
1.0772833824157715,
0.5577684044837952,
-0.20660440623760223,
0.2045542597770691,
-0.4747702181339264,
0.7913336157798767,
-0.22645652294158936,
0.20977629721164703,
-0.5239091515541077,
-0.3333861529827118,
-0.7088746428489685,
-0.4945465326309204,
0.4917261302471161,
0.7733352184295654,
-0.6638970971107483,
0.505439281463623,
-0.3637779951095581,
-0.5430465340614319,
-1.255623698234558,
0.6514687538146973,
0.6420705914497375,
0.5542541742324829,
0.41397449374198914,
-0.06412102282047272,
-0.2608009874820709,
-0.6268323659896851,
-0.25693416595458984,
-0.0891713947057724,
-0.2676967978477478,
0.1745251715183258,
-0.04637109115719795,
-0.2772384583950043,
0.870444118976593,
-0.21382293105125427,
-0.47561490535736084,
-0.47168734669685364,
0.08864195644855499,
0.14134395122528076,
0.26661017537117004,
0.07069598883390427,
-0.4050880968570709,
-0.33677271008491516,
0.1375962197780609,
-0.46647191047668457,
-0.5245556235313416,
-0.08976255357265472,
0.1370837241411209,
0.38549983501434326,
0.6286726593971252,
-0.44335466623306274,
0.15674979984760284,
0.7550703287124634,
-0.5602216124534607,
0.5742455124855042,
-0.5594373345375061,
0.23522107303142548,
-1.0398056507110596,
-0.028615444898605347,
-0.062091510742902756,
-0.6061972379684448,
-0.18824513256549835,
0.45276322960853577,
0.522428572177887,
-0.13711227476596832,
-0.12446320056915283,
0.15559135377407074,
-0.41065195202827454,
0.0028354779351502657,
-0.49084240198135376,
0.37715476751327515,
0.26476454734802246,
0.05878998711705208,
-0.2954188287258148,
1.0028547048568726,
0.3163740932941437,
-0.30109333992004395,
0.3551996350288391,
0.34517955780029297,
-0.5703657865524292,
0.521041750907898,
-0.8959735035896301,
0.24071630835533142,
-0.07435138523578644,
0.19689302146434784,
-1.1858464479446411,
-0.21502946317195892,
-0.22747059166431427,
-0.3025955855846405,
0.15704134106636047,
-0.2157645970582962,
-0.7257305979728699,
-0.3645734488964081,
-0.26869529485702515,
-0.14159418642520905,
0.34727397561073303,
-0.8301098346710205,
0.5645809173583984,
0.3794305920600891,
-0.3299001455307007,
-0.17376528680324554,
-0.570014238357544,
0.21691866219043732,
0.19137753546237946,
-1.146588921546936,
0.42021411657333374,
0.1523098349571228,
0.07910382747650146,
-0.295289546251297,
-0.12758265435695648,
0.08885067701339722,
0.13481414318084717,
0.21782658994197845,
0.2971741557121277,
-0.07295384258031845,
-0.07654057443141937,
0.21339985728263855,
-0.1287202388048172,
-0.2860298156738281,
-0.38887035846710205,
0.3469983637332916,
0.012043574824929237,
-0.08503121137619019,
-0.5470404028892517,
-0.027124399319291115,
0.8048503398895264,
-0.24223782122135162,
0.3338770866394043,
0.31430360674858093,
0.007904024794697762,
-0.3098219037055969,
-0.8234599232673645,
-0.050534240901470184,
-0.4867558479309082,
0.207560196518898,
-0.5871888995170593,
-1.2512820959091187,
0.5969493985176086,
0.3267853856086731,
0.302433043718338,
0.11421028524637222,
0.12909772992134094,
-0.2677622437477112,
0.9199752807617188,
0.9003896117210388,
-0.4393557906150818,
0.38576558232307434,
0.016120823100209236,
0.35283321142196655,
-0.8034009337425232,
0.056424085050821304,
-0.5413938164710999,
-0.3467538356781006,
-0.5978674292564392,
-0.0737481340765953,
0.2803781032562256,
0.6832648515701294,
0.08611653745174408,
0.31302186846733093,
-0.23016828298568726,
0.6711810231208801,
0.7822816371917725,
0.41297268867492676,
0.4539607763290405,
-0.14715325832366943,
-0.41079702973365784,
-0.2682773768901825,
-0.6290946006774902,
-0.5745811462402344,
1.1805838346481323,
0.3108491897583008,
0.8386448621749878,
0.1520608514547348,
0.4960325360298157,
0.22212228178977966,
0.38340798020362854,
-0.680711030960083,
0.45721369981765747,
-0.13774903118610382,
-0.2780718207359314,
-0.31549742817878723,
-0.20557312667369843,
-0.6500281095504761,
0.23233433067798615,
-0.33378249406814575,
-0.6197641491889954,
-0.1694723218679428,
0.7050060033798218,
-0.4467301070690155,
0.29734811186790466,
-0.7274921536445618,
1.030525803565979,
-0.27223116159439087,
-0.6139910221099854,
-0.46742963790893555,
-0.5389403104782104,
0.343416303396225,
0.029679913073778152,
0.18471549451351166,
0.1143231987953186,
0.15498264133930206,
0.3585401475429535,
-0.7857969999313354,
0.7041777968406677,
-0.1295880675315857,
-0.4038175046443939,
0.02212057262659073,
0.3999052345752716,
0.751565158367157,
0.19181101024150848,
0.1543899029493332,
-0.2090442031621933,
-0.1174788549542427,
-0.19585908949375153,
-0.5670942664146423,
0.608745813369751,
-0.6713812351226807,
-0.662483274936676,
-0.07291842997074127,
-0.34029483795166016,
-0.4481758773326874,
0.35910290479660034,
0.3415776193141937,
0.38940027356147766,
-0.04766865074634552,
0.016340984031558037,
0.8987347483634949,
0.03576517105102539,
0.32192572951316833,
0.5895760655403137,
-0.7351270914077759,
-0.7269887924194336,
0.6996541023254395,
-0.14261342585086823,
0.4289654493331909,
0.5856110453605652,
-0.06218155473470688,
-0.4832128584384918,
-0.8380757570266724,
-0.8353387117385864,
0.1529182344675064,
-0.5965067148208618,
-0.06581725925207138,
-0.6305307745933533,
0.11465287208557129,
-0.6280214786529541,
-0.4383781850337982,
-0.16403953731060028,
-0.375093549489975,
-0.3398406505584717,
-0.41109204292297363,
0.49791043996810913,
0.566137433052063,
-0.024156812578439713,
0.5963959097862244,
-0.8063182830810547,
0.7020037770271301,
0.2136853188276291,
0.4853041172027588,
-0.3734510838985443,
-0.9300686717033386,
-0.04687773063778877,
-0.05208764970302582,
-0.4254904091358185,
-0.4165019094944,
0.5695829391479492,
0.30274420976638794,
0.12466157972812653,
0.4542750120162964,
-0.4298781752586365,
0.7353510856628418,
-0.5644237995147705,
0.6806289553642273,
-0.02710295468568802,
-1.081607460975647,
0.6007426977157593,
-0.4669262170791626,
0.32705894112586975,
0.8631762862205505,
0.0307310838252306,
-0.9707067608833313,
-0.3662284314632416,
-0.5324549674987793,
-0.8399792313575745,
0.3279229998588562,
-0.4795561134815216,
-0.3236316740512848,
0.2316575050354004,
0.38491666316986084,
0.21451765298843384,
0.2835054397583008,
-0.3214041292667389,
0.11719237267971039,
-0.21251046657562256,
-0.2911478877067566,
-0.5025397539138794,
-0.5125301480293274,
0.13718725740909576,
-0.04240020737051964,
0.8480727672576904,
-0.20328421890735626,
-0.24721358716487885,
0.3364567160606384,
-0.5074152946472168,
-0.09279856830835342,
0.41036614775657654,
0.9160634875297546,
0.6797095537185669,
-0.16593235731124878,
-0.20393730700016022,
-0.30161601305007935,
-0.6942034363746643,
0.20909452438354492,
0.19155088067054749,
-0.5910158157348633,
-0.018804030492901802,
0.15019869804382324,
0.9593135118484497,
0.40580788254737854,
-0.719176709651947,
0.32191184163093567,
-0.03518623858690262,
-0.24505376815795898,
0.24944867193698883,
0.12441720068454742,
0.07474806159734726,
0.1256360560655594,
0.1465306580066681,
0.11163938790559769,
0.009223325178027153,
-0.4008665084838867,
0.16616986691951752,
0.2530049681663513,
-0.015237927436828613,
-0.1816449910402298,
1.0061091184616089,
0.44928887486457825,
-0.32751932740211487,
0.6616016626358032,
-0.24316611886024475,
-0.5563645958900452,
0.26971495151519775,
0.6924984455108643,
0.895630419254303,
0.11374931782484055,
0.302982896566391,
0.009934657253324986,
0.4303690493106842,
-0.3534088730812073,
0.48695486783981323,
-0.01571795903146267,
-0.9557653069496155,
-0.5110703110694885,
-0.5240527391433716,
-0.657972514629364,
0.14532966911792755,
-0.5597711205482483,
0.13733036816120148,
-0.8784032464027405,
-0.008706621825695038,
0.07135230302810669,
-0.09968345612287521,
-0.4610702097415924,
0.16824747622013092,
-0.14544326066970825,
1.0729100704193115,
-0.651129961013794,
0.7517240047454834,
0.5533640384674072,
-0.242767333984375,
-0.6742063164710999,
-0.15631677210330963,
-0.01744115725159645,
-0.8200604319572449,
0.14917892217636108,
0.11577676236629486,
0.04084976762533188,
0.2859000265598297,
-0.2202143520116806,
-0.690337598323822,
0.898795485496521,
0.3947882354259491,
-1.2456899881362915,
0.3498631417751312,
0.02442353405058384,
0.5996144413948059,
0.08496924489736557,
0.3428824245929718,
0.6455879807472229,
0.3090088665485382,
-0.259641170501709,
-1.3117622137069702,
-0.15233959257602692,
-0.11506690084934235,
0.1743965893983841,
0.26852619647979736,
-0.6840465664863586,
0.3827109634876251,
-0.563112735748291,
0.02821115031838417,
0.09394741803407669,
0.6626424789428711,
0.3296673893928528,
-0.14784404635429382,
0.17704327404499054,
1.1046087741851807,
1.1282705068588257,
-0.08067652583122253,
1.0174915790557861,
-0.489795982837677,
0.08039387315511703,
1.0744479894638062,
-0.429830938577652,
0.9851141571998596,
0.3538149297237396,
-0.2022213190793991,
0.207294762134552,
0.44401806592941284,
0.16416074335575104,
0.6996309161186218,
0.2919337749481201,
-0.32593896985054016,
-0.16219280660152435,
0.15171407163143158,
-0.15416841208934784,
-0.03258293867111206,
0.1598699986934662,
-0.3013152480125427,
-0.06845767796039581,
0.20209629833698273,
-0.010385265573859215,
0.2909999489784241,
-0.6058232188224792,
0.7290031313896179,
-0.17745232582092285,
-0.6870625019073486,
0.4705671966075897,
0.42743194103240967,
1.026158094406128,
-0.49338603019714355,
0.26539531350135803,
-0.5810220241546631,
0.39570698142051697,
-0.257209837436676,
-0.8565744757652283,
-0.25509873032569885,
0.0652930736541748,
-0.5280966758728027,
-0.5337587594985962,
0.7053699493408203,
-0.45436251163482666,
-0.49623316526412964,
-0.08697906136512756,
0.01231667585670948,
-0.15842734277248383,
-0.2591198682785034,
-0.4102684259414673,
0.25339964032173157,
0.13788513839244843,
-0.06655478477478027,
0.2807713449001312,
0.534714937210083,
0.07549335807561874,
1.0294238328933716,
0.7384956479072571,
0.3590273857116699,
0.22746729850769043,
0.2597696781158447,
0.5250668525695801,
-0.8014282584190369,
-0.8909042477607727,
-0.6742931008338928,
0.3981553316116333,
0.061819881200790405,
-0.6768825650215149,
0.6525532007217407,
0.6234323382377625,
1.004331350326538,
-0.1443384438753128,
1.0916434526443481,
0.14043809473514557,
0.681290864944458,
-0.7465780377388,
0.5729823708534241,
-0.01072815340012312,
-0.015156276524066925,
0.05829335004091263,
-0.5426656603813171,
-0.35887911915779114,
0.5082743763923645,
-0.1355251520872116,
-0.2618138790130615,
0.7119122743606567,
0.9676176905632019,
0.08581606298685074,
0.3142096698284149,
0.2752799093723297,
0.19468238949775696,
0.43588900566101074,
0.34974437952041626,
0.33499062061309814,
-0.6667335629463196,
0.26166701316833496,
-0.21076256036758423,
-0.3000113070011139,
-0.5408615469932556,
-0.8895847797393799,
-0.6836414337158203,
-0.19785305857658386,
-0.2291780561208725,
-0.580579936504364,
0.42537835240364075,
0.808849573135376,
0.486594021320343,
-0.8452603816986084,
0.024194469675421715,
-0.39176759123802185,
0.06979800760746002,
-0.28496596217155457,
-0.2216986119747162,
0.08876310288906097,
-0.5177987217903137,
-0.3533889055252075,
0.6122007966041565,
0.2862066924571991,
-0.016359243541955948,
-0.044059477746486664,
0.2490873485803604,
0.3939255177974701,
-0.3801230490207672,
0.6142983436584473,
0.4472096264362335,
-0.5308250188827515,
-0.166012704372406,
-0.14382897317409515,
-0.37546753883361816,
0.1225423812866211,
0.7833481431007385,
-0.6274810433387756,
0.5329569578170776,
0.5060248970985413,
0.9475663900375366,
0.4490066170692444,
0.04789276793599129,
0.5532180070877075,
-0.30874747037887573,
-0.02782362885773182,
0.09662072360515594,
0.47259390354156494,
0.4089360535144806,
-0.43777376413345337,
0.22765173017978668,
0.16353078186511993,
-0.7808548808097839,
-0.562961757183075,
0.024434059858322144,
-0.9258854985237122,
0.18193404376506805,
1.0140174627304077,
-0.22500549256801605,
-0.23358018696308136,
-0.06362178921699524,
-0.5822710990905762,
-0.20433518290519714,
-0.424250990152359,
1.1932793855667114,
0.9227507710456848,
0.229442298412323,
-0.33855679631233215,
-0.42113927006721497,
0.5427014827728271,
0.435568630695343,
-0.7941229343414307,
0.23446519672870636,
0.8520680665969849,
0.6570473909378052,
-0.28572535514831543,
0.6873967051506042,
-0.01089648436754942,
0.5740423798561096,
-0.1534021496772766,
0.3889000713825226,
-0.3345595598220825,
-0.37852632999420166,
-0.45363959670066833,
0.15655727684497833,
0.478996217250824,
-0.053114164620637894
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.04520v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.04520v1
|
NATURAL PLAN: Benchmarking LLMs on Natural Language Planning
| 2024-06-06T21:27:35 | 2024-06-06T21:27:35 |
Huaixiu Steven Zheng, Swaroop Mishra, Hugh Zhang, Xinyun Chen, Minmin Chen, Azade Nova, Le Hou, Heng-Tze Cheng, Quoc V. Le, Ed H. Chi, Denny Zhou
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
We introduce NATURAL PLAN, a realistic planning benchmark in natural language
containing 3 key tasks: Trip Planning, Meeting Planning, and Calendar
Scheduling. We focus our evaluation on the planning capabilities of LLMs with
full information on the task, by providing outputs from tools such as Google
Flights, Google Maps, and Google Calendar as contexts to the models. This
eliminates the need for a tool-use environment for evaluating LLMs on Planning.
We observe that NATURAL PLAN is a challenging benchmark for state of the art
models. For example, in Trip Planning, GPT-4 and Gemini 1.5 Pro could only
achieve 31.1% and 34.8% solve rate respectively. We find that model performance
drops drastically as the complexity of the problem increases: all models
perform below 5% when there are 10 cities, highlighting a significant gap in
planning in natural language for SoTA LLMs. We also conduct extensive ablation
studies on NATURAL PLAN to further shed light on the (in)effectiveness of
approaches such as self-correction, few-shot generalization, and in-context
planning with long-contexts on improving LLM planning.
|
[
-0.5018386244773865,
-0.6593376398086548,
0.5394047498703003,
0.36946389079093933,
-0.1244136244058609,
-0.07103372365236282,
-0.2678629457950592,
-0.7437930703163147,
0.23356090486049652,
0.6411232352256775,
-0.9406249523162842,
-0.4510461688041687,
-0.10829096287488937,
0.1666557937860489,
-0.18521477282047272,
0.5488249063491821,
-0.35603955388069153,
0.1956143081188202,
-0.234513059258461,
-0.1209912970662117,
-0.5089970827102661,
-0.43631285429000854,
-0.7818978428840637,
-0.43157100677490234,
0.1687493920326233,
0.45362362265586853,
0.41356587409973145,
0.5464083552360535,
0.6665605902671814,
0.19745898246765137,
-0.28964272141456604,
0.22572341561317444,
-0.5596215724945068,
-0.013660520315170288,
-0.021693456918001175,
-0.12401382625102997,
-0.44996318221092224,
0.04203145205974579,
0.6567376255989075,
0.864518940448761,
-0.25706467032432556,
0.3120364844799042,
-0.2160448133945465,
0.850192666053772,
-0.4699847400188446,
0.19880855083465576,
-0.7953943014144897,
0.21934989094734192,
-0.007683156058192253,
-0.010967781767249107,
0.22749833762645721,
-0.6028319001197815,
0.3665265142917633,
-0.4883051812648773,
0.22093552350997925,
0.18238873779773712,
0.5445720553398132,
0.43372997641563416,
-0.24623480439186096,
-0.3653498888015747,
-1.0409538745880127,
0.6710207462310791,
-0.5861006379127502,
0.09966114163398743,
0.34715569019317627,
0.665002167224884,
-0.4773936867713928,
-0.667724609375,
-0.4771767854690552,
-0.3542455732822418,
0.19897176325321198,
0.11424235999584198,
-0.06919413059949875,
0.09912075847387314,
0.4868590235710144,
0.5359438061714172,
-0.6925175786018372,
0.03793533146381378,
-0.26295000314712524,
-0.05421033501625061,
0.7935953140258789,
0.4321146607398987,
0.0926203653216362,
-0.0003914858971256763,
-0.4724613130092621,
0.17361775040626526,
-0.9857842922210693,
-0.0320187509059906,
0.27408772706985474,
0.27352720499038696,
-0.21522463858127594,
0.6021608114242554,
-0.5804986357688904,
0.7259449362754822,
-0.5601694583892822,
0.19470180571079254,
-0.23267625272274017,
-0.8733229041099548,
-0.5016276240348816,
-0.06287167221307755,
0.44794145226478577,
0.756270170211792,
0.44455721974372864,
-0.34162867069244385,
-0.21501214802265167,
0.09806102514266968,
0.23420831561088562,
-0.9120687246322632,
-0.26136088371276855,
-0.01571735553443432,
-0.04240862652659416,
0.07827437669038773,
-0.45880642533302307,
-0.7090309262275696,
-0.22611771523952484,
-0.48188114166259766,
0.18014347553253174,
-0.3110466003417969,
0.03458748012781143,
0.22651028633117676,
0.050855573266744614,
0.3490879237651825,
0.29957857728004456,
-0.9758830666542053,
0.9149801135063171,
0.743598997592926,
0.7283039093017578,
0.013488830998539925,
-0.2845403552055359,
-0.4676072895526886,
-0.07982516288757324,
-0.48616406321525574,
1.1375021934509277,
-0.15152043104171753,
-0.6812511086463928,
0.0868779644370079,
-0.4840729832649231,
0.05999136343598366,
-0.7818036079406738,
0.8096766471862793,
-0.028926603496074677,
0.11302939802408218,
-0.6564618349075317,
-0.5415310859680176,
-0.25873032212257385,
0.7301024794578552,
-0.7572731971740723,
1.215886116027832,
-0.023946590721607208,
-0.23475150763988495,
0.5559564828872681,
-0.9700710773468018,
-0.43131324648857117,
-0.029992710798978806,
-0.13016943633556366,
-0.11260543018579483,
0.04131626710295677,
0.12498203665018082,
0.168490931391716,
-0.4961142838001251,
0.41223713755607605,
-0.010902275331318378,
-0.34516027569770813,
-0.02664327062666416,
-0.039680954068899155,
0.3782333731651306,
0.1809263378381729,
-0.2605094015598297,
0.4632170796394348,
-0.7930802702903748,
0.17579030990600586,
0.13859562575817108,
-0.6032174825668335,
0.08240920305252075,
0.196867436170578,
0.23487962782382965,
0.2055555135011673,
0.29918572306632996,
-0.45558997988700867,
0.6303312182426453,
-0.6119064092636108,
0.34448006749153137,
0.5214425325393677,
-0.01667993888258934,
0.5898286700248718,
-0.48288196325302124,
0.37756720185279846,
-0.4835999608039856,
0.23491662740707397,
0.11756502836942673,
-0.59233558177948,
-0.6058653593063354,
0.08913791179656982,
0.10784416645765305,
0.4042665958404541,
-0.4433455467224121,
0.15403681993484497,
-0.5002999305725098,
-0.7912001609802246,
-0.022530702874064445,
0.0001823959464672953,
0.39909783005714417,
0.6088286638259888,
0.4185410141944885,
-0.36170318722724915,
-0.6681492328643799,
-0.8166860938072205,
-0.6079065799713135,
0.0038000966887921095,
-0.056944798678159714,
0.06878912448883057,
0.5077246427536011,
-0.016200629994273186,
1.0513499975204468,
-0.43180572986602783,
-0.37799155712127686,
-0.5318219065666199,
0.23543614149093628,
0.3157426118850708,
0.10733672231435776,
0.5952931642532349,
-0.70235276222229,
-0.5166985988616943,
-0.4046980142593384,
-0.33227789402008057,
-0.140539288520813,
-0.014394314028322697,
-0.14249983429908752,
0.2755090594291687,
0.12529820203781128,
-0.46507322788238525,
0.5299878120422363,
0.5127602219581604,
-0.4016452431678772,
0.6297497749328613,
-0.2865453362464905,
-0.2846604287624359,
-0.7711732983589172,
0.18113090097904205,
0.08219535648822784,
-0.19852401316165924,
-0.9067676663398743,
0.0660267248749733,
0.01848018728196621,
-0.09374391287565231,
-0.5253110527992249,
0.8324340581893921,
-0.3438182473182678,
-0.38837388157844543,
-0.3078899681568146,
-0.10558370500802994,
-0.2359539121389389,
0.5042985677719116,
0.26571622490882874,
0.790982723236084,
0.24845291674137115,
-0.7652580738067627,
0.14588716626167297,
0.3323533833026886,
-0.34206220507621765,
0.3248232305049896,
-0.3745081126689911,
0.11098308116197586,
0.17226609587669373,
0.47113025188446045,
-0.5306760668754578,
-0.09133093059062958,
0.05792679265141487,
-0.05145714432001114,
-0.0536186620593071,
-0.19560560584068298,
-0.6620835661888123,
-0.3913577198982239,
-0.47054940462112427,
-0.09900572150945663,
0.2486686408519745,
-0.4619869291782379,
0.6816188097000122,
0.2935340404510498,
-0.006967973429709673,
-0.029565952718257904,
-0.5667811036109924,
0.37173524498939514,
-0.21630160510540009,
-0.5397603511810303,
0.787300705909729,
-0.3200533390045166,
-0.37186694145202637,
0.1579611450433731,
-0.601085901260376,
-0.16615116596221924,
0.08567134290933609,
0.2819795608520508,
0.18382127583026886,
0.028791572898626328,
-0.22856900095939636,
-0.7036594152450562,
-0.3217878043651581,
0.22862501442432404,
-0.11701128631830215,
0.78802889585495,
-0.26703450083732605,
-0.11971749365329742,
-0.20197546482086182,
0.25940749049186707,
0.3113114833831787,
-0.26867806911468506,
0.3169087767601013,
0.20035672187805176,
-0.856336236000061,
0.17415101826190948,
-0.5439412593841553,
0.12978743016719818,
-0.4028564691543579,
-0.00871325097978115,
-0.4687153697013855,
-0.43005284667015076,
0.5578057169914246,
-0.21073834598064423,
0.4898780286312103,
0.36524030566215515,
0.44475170969963074,
0.1532490849494934,
0.6659121513366699,
0.7327070832252502,
-0.13146314024925232,
0.26933759450912476,
-0.6057261228561401,
0.10727640986442566,
-0.7593200206756592,
-0.25581610202789307,
-0.5502508878707886,
-0.6796500086784363,
-0.6008791327476501,
-0.40996724367141724,
0.07374488562345505,
0.06923782825469971,
-0.16344140470027924,
0.5761957764625549,
-0.23926164209842682,
0.5839007496833801,
0.8589955568313599,
-0.41551947593688965,
0.4278179109096527,
-0.2247425615787506,
-0.280173659324646,
-0.08650944381952286,
-0.5916979908943176,
-0.8224793076515198,
1.1844927072525024,
-0.030376330018043518,
0.4254944622516632,
-0.036564651876688004,
0.9056837558746338,
-0.2803462743759155,
0.4415943920612335,
-0.6419289112091064,
0.8583770990371704,
0.15100783109664917,
-0.845791220664978,
-0.3471354842185974,
-0.4675135612487793,
-0.6629594564437866,
0.06157254800200462,
-0.3435939848423004,
-0.8673965334892273,
-0.15049856901168823,
-0.058694951236248016,
-0.4762139618396759,
0.4653133749961853,
-0.7193620204925537,
0.9374005198478699,
-0.520509660243988,
-0.3467690944671631,
-0.22464153170585632,
-0.37622395157814026,
0.13002672791481018,
-0.053156059235334396,
0.11890793591737747,
-0.5839607119560242,
0.10184377431869507,
0.7125580906867981,
-0.15921275317668915,
0.4399598240852356,
-0.21852822601795197,
0.36573708057403564,
0.1347106248140335,
0.15708117187023163,
0.5711240172386169,
-0.07957548648118973,
-0.3332965075969696,
0.21313345432281494,
-0.06998522579669952,
-0.2464422881603241,
-0.3046756684780121,
0.6697919368743896,
-0.49604490399360657,
-0.17363063991069794,
-0.44424042105674744,
-0.5915311574935913,
-0.3459036350250244,
0.33275216817855835,
0.22825901210308075,
0.519879162311554,
-0.7129864692687988,
-0.31493958830833435,
0.08067868649959564,
-0.0726919025182724,
0.7774128317832947,
0.5846524834632874,
-0.4966393709182739,
-0.39039066433906555,
0.5804561972618103,
0.4522665739059448,
0.3256931006908417,
0.40343591570854187,
0.24762144684791565,
-0.5843102931976318,
-1.0816282033920288,
-0.06708917766809464,
0.043701522052288055,
-0.5189753770828247,
-0.02337435632944107,
-0.39755478501319885,
-0.1829245686531067,
-0.28162679076194763,
-0.23232106864452362,
-0.6041253805160522,
-0.4534744918346405,
0.18368658423423767,
-0.049210481345653534,
-0.004477669019252062,
0.9738849997520447,
-0.05516986548900604,
0.15841221809387207,
-0.46999698877334595,
0.5416401624679565,
0.11524337530136108,
0.5694032907485962,
-0.5584957003593445,
0.18505744636058807,
-0.1251191645860672,
-0.01553941797465086,
-0.6337339878082275,
-0.5336068272590637,
0.6265870928764343,
0.08385151624679565,
0.7509766221046448,
0.3703858554363251,
0.24759675562381744,
1.0744376182556152,
-0.6114755272865295,
0.6591722369194031,
0.004861696157604456,
-0.4696881175041199,
0.7224283218383789,
-0.23558025062084198,
0.5509454011917114,
0.939701497554779,
0.3490908145904541,
-0.5711541175842285,
-0.20449458062648773,
-0.8444392085075378,
-0.8530703186988831,
0.5036028027534485,
0.42323294281959534,
-0.16773086786270142,
0.1432783007621765,
0.05470297113060951,
-0.1345347762107849,
0.23753105103969574,
-0.7888695001602173,
-0.09371078014373779,
0.16403481364250183,
0.28102707862854004,
-0.3024795651435852,
-0.4133457541465759,
-0.33702564239501953,
-0.23326115310192108,
0.2977229356765747,
-0.018346847966313362,
0.2760904133319855,
0.2820484936237335,
0.11739218235015869,
-0.2857567071914673,
0.222473606467247,
1.0559301376342773,
0.9401832818984985,
-0.7177317142486572,
0.21458999812602997,
0.6355863213539124,
-0.3831290304660797,
-0.3703728914260864,
0.29583150148391724,
-0.08230384439229965,
-0.06001345068216324,
0.32766464352607727,
0.43387117981910706,
0.6430537104606628,
-0.6563481092453003,
-0.06512311846017838,
-0.37090811133384705,
-0.42506393790245056,
-0.45447489619255066,
0.00744364270940423,
0.2781253159046173,
0.10832682996988297,
0.3507412075996399,
0.10277622938156128,
0.1693122684955597,
-0.6888503432273865,
-0.19579888880252838,
0.38108065724372864,
-0.45320290327072144,
-0.24558047950267792,
0.5572604537010193,
0.3886520564556122,
-0.6997303366661072,
0.4577755630016327,
-0.606502890586853,
-0.6348316669464111,
0.5561421513557434,
0.4905129075050354,
0.9672961235046387,
0.0977105051279068,
-0.29456475377082825,
0.5428740978240967,
0.554417073726654,
0.01152767613530159,
0.6306009292602539,
0.07686687260866165,
-0.48950421810150146,
-0.472466379404068,
-0.6016231179237366,
-0.7902962565422058,
0.26167115569114685,
-0.2274864912033081,
0.3487185835838318,
-0.5056034326553345,
-0.01877286285161972,
-0.33874791860580444,
0.8237329125404358,
-0.9451326727867126,
0.022289568558335304,
0.1878286451101303,
1.466633915901184,
-0.5978049039840698,
0.4712253212928772,
0.9714683294296265,
0.009242145344614983,
-0.7047481536865234,
0.11663546413183212,
0.3102210760116577,
-0.6588083505630493,
0.408734530210495,
0.6107138395309448,
-0.09801872074604034,
0.03201204165816307,
-0.08600837737321854,
-0.7773474454879761,
1.0962860584259033,
0.16163726150989532,
-0.5706867575645447,
-0.15438005328178406,
0.2413211464881897,
0.39192208647727966,
-0.31505000591278076,
0.11227671056985855,
0.7653583884239197,
0.6352866291999817,
0.28746509552001953,
-1.216796636581421,
-0.12871718406677246,
-0.016484929248690605,
-0.09836150705814362,
0.25873786211013794,
-0.08133621513843536,
0.3124593198299408,
-0.2102481871843338,
-0.5068422555923462,
0.08447559922933578,
0.30119648575782776,
0.25229838490486145,
0.6335687041282654,
0.4520522952079773,
0.8476783037185669,
0.7232549786567688,
-0.2432778924703598,
1.1626330614089966,
-0.32270631194114685,
0.058017563074827194,
1.2361235618591309,
-0.6216385364532471,
1.0271457433700562,
0.5335201621055603,
-0.37771672010421753,
-0.09829234331846237,
0.7773051857948303,
0.19492806494235992,
0.7877199649810791,
0.46301013231277466,
-0.3150463402271271,
-0.1405249536037445,
-0.13726940751075745,
-0.23716334998607635,
0.5082451105117798,
0.09828005731105804,
0.6204246282577515,
-0.7652355432510376,
-0.2996858060359955,
-0.04263700172305107,
0.19424544274806976,
-0.2892276644706726,
0.7225098013877869,
0.07994171231985092,
-0.8114373683929443,
0.3168717324733734,
-0.035695880651474,
0.4846431612968445,
-0.5169685482978821,
0.18173269927501678,
-0.2601495385169983,
0.023117274045944214,
-0.03636297211050987,
-0.7335898280143738,
0.7957472205162048,
0.06969702243804932,
0.14029142260551453,
-0.5447995066642761,
0.6260911226272583,
-0.024207832291722298,
-0.4692639112472534,
0.15171591937541962,
0.3219282925128937,
0.05039799585938454,
-0.4587841331958771,
-0.49354851245880127,
-0.10455148667097092,
-0.2844846546649933,
-0.2435971200466156,
0.13160154223442078,
0.19500166177749634,
-0.0032964134588837624,
0.8589050769805908,
0.9133793115615845,
0.30368098616600037,
0.17381002008914948,
-0.08762151002883911,
0.764485239982605,
-0.9681377410888672,
-0.5405209064483643,
-0.9761845469474792,
0.3228423297405243,
-0.38100361824035645,
-0.5287253856658936,
0.5513502955436707,
1.0323553085327148,
0.8044934272766113,
0.1812170296907425,
0.27235960960388184,
0.10590801388025284,
0.46330976486206055,
-0.711227536201477,
0.33725306391716003,
-0.18506285548210144,
0.4595545530319214,
0.13829836249351501,
-1.2431100606918335,
-0.4702035188674927,
0.47648826241493225,
-0.7837749123573303,
-0.324219673871994,
0.6672562956809998,
0.5787767171859741,
0.1725512593984604,
0.1733369380235672,
0.25543808937072754,
-0.4210662245750427,
0.61065274477005,
0.7312094569206238,
1.0570558309555054,
-0.0543370246887207,
0.5283158421516418,
-0.5091889500617981,
-0.1437128484249115,
-0.4067531228065491,
-1.148016095161438,
-0.7519431710243225,
-0.3739030957221985,
-0.2859560251235962,
0.3696407675743103,
0.04610557109117508,
1.006060004234314,
0.821876049041748,
-0.3780581057071686,
-0.46056830883026123,
-0.6147955656051636,
0.10277188569307327,
-0.13996484875679016,
-0.15794670581817627,
-0.05365876108407974,
-0.3717074692249298,
-0.49584731459617615,
0.6281847357749939,
0.49431315064430237,
0.16189301013946533,
-0.19538451731204987,
-0.14799728989601135,
-0.18956510722637177,
-0.13399823009967804,
0.39718884229660034,
0.4511640965938568,
-0.5905745029449463,
-0.05371805280447006,
0.1506386697292328,
-0.19217485189437866,
0.05552149936556816,
0.7652788758277893,
-0.7365087866783142,
0.3637515902519226,
0.29407167434692383,
0.43457236886024475,
0.9444445967674255,
-0.22756071388721466,
0.6500744223594666,
-0.6448331475257874,
-0.0334160141646862,
0.3877861499786377,
0.3600565195083618,
0.2035677582025528,
0.1646791696548462,
1.0919336080551147,
-0.1436697244644165,
-0.7319270968437195,
-0.688275933265686,
0.36777812242507935,
-1.1268259286880493,
0.10708792507648468,
1.0287665128707886,
0.24798278510570526,
-0.058376118540763855,
-0.06087039038538933,
-0.25986605882644653,
0.15781232714653015,
0.031618278473615646,
0.8564345836639404,
0.5860781073570251,
-0.5355636477470398,
0.25572535395622253,
-1.1680262088775635,
0.6965241432189941,
0.01891394704580307,
-0.9156730771064758,
0.1171298548579216,
0.45290422439575195,
0.1215207576751709,
0.1597045212984085,
1.1252564191818237,
0.21424521505832672,
0.08890768140554428,
-0.1805981993675232,
0.24036046862602234,
-0.005502490792423487,
-0.329282283782959,
-0.10763184726238251,
-0.18146276473999023,
0.3226662278175354,
-0.2424212098121643
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.04512v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.04512v1
|
To Distill or Not to Distill? On the Robustness of Robust Knowledge Distillation
| 2024-06-06T21:11:53 | 2024-06-06T21:11:53 |
Abdul Waheed, Karima Kadaoui, Muhammad Abdul-Mageed
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
Arabic is known to present unique challenges for Automatic Speech Recognition
(ASR). On one hand, its rich linguistic diversity and wide range of dialects
complicate the development of robust, inclusive models. On the other, current
multilingual ASR models are compute-intensive and lack proper comprehensive
evaluations. In light of these challenges, we distill knowledge from large
teacher models into smaller student variants that are more efficient. We also
introduce a novel human-annotated dataset covering five under-represented
Arabic dialects for evaluation. We further evaluate both our models and
existing SoTA multilingual models on both standard available benchmarks and our
new dialectal data. Our best-distilled model's overall performance ($45.0$\%
WER) surpasses that of a SoTA model twice its size (SeamlessM4T-large-v2,
WER=$47.0$\%) and its teacher model (Whisper-large-v2, WER=$55.1$\%), and its
average performance on our new dialectal data ($56.9$\% WER) outperforms all
other models. To gain more insight into the poor performance of these models on
dialectal data, we conduct an error analysis and report the main types of
errors the different models tend to make. The GitHub repository for the project
is available at \url{https://github.com/UBC-NLP/distill-whisper-ar}.
|
[
-0.3055465519428253,
-0.39824220538139343,
0.3411845564842224,
-0.13393104076385498,
-0.3059123158454895,
0.2674124836921692,
-0.3075034022331238,
-0.36601722240448,
-0.4077424705028534,
0.22468602657318115,
-0.04222676903009415,
-0.3032646179199219,
-1.0870001316070557,
0.13264517486095428,
-0.7344085574150085,
1.216231346130371,
0.28022313117980957,
0.2919445335865021,
0.10984746366739273,
-0.4567069113254547,
-0.27990958094596863,
-0.6928485631942749,
-0.5523253083229065,
-0.5376875996589661,
0.11909082531929016,
0.45803627371788025,
0.8005387187004089,
0.5506322383880615,
0.15733309090137482,
0.4478818476200104,
-0.40576687455177307,
0.00711063900962472,
-0.3014111816883087,
0.20159053802490234,
-0.015163232572376728,
-0.13936227560043335,
-0.19482043385505676,
-0.19346992671489716,
0.4181947410106659,
0.9123660326004028,
-0.4763510525226593,
0.1741073727607727,
0.3770177662372589,
0.9351462125778198,
-0.586786150932312,
0.15424279868602753,
-0.7667283415794373,
-0.41042378544807434,
-0.28085288405418396,
0.6348190903663635,
-0.08240003138780594,
-0.41083791851997375,
0.6041954755783081,
-0.1766575574874878,
0.25022822618484497,
-0.23545444011688232,
0.7624456286430359,
0.47901636362075806,
-0.6125513315200806,
-0.484282910823822,
-1.002912998199463,
0.6949049234390259,
-0.7574509978294373,
0.4217154383659363,
0.6058420538902283,
0.8194189667701721,
0.12480204552412033,
-0.9198146462440491,
-0.6133913993835449,
-0.16109412908554077,
0.1420220285654068,
-0.19382405281066895,
-0.5636243224143982,
-0.16031533479690552,
0.2164919674396515,
0.44118285179138184,
-0.269592821598053,
-0.13682518899440765,
-0.6290985345840454,
-0.19816599786281586,
0.5792894959449768,
-0.09836741536855698,
0.09865504503250122,
0.1092846691608429,
-0.20463037490844727,
-0.1722702831029892,
-0.4353451728820801,
0.09610316902399063,
0.37824171781539917,
0.4976222515106201,
-0.000584460562095046,
0.3333059251308441,
-0.1473497897386551,
0.6863752603530884,
0.16859588027000427,
-0.37663882970809937,
0.11169148981571198,
-0.27482685446739197,
-0.018070349469780922,
0.3537985682487488,
0.8401249647140503,
-0.07062022387981415,
0.4793999195098877,
0.08737565577030182,
-0.40575650334358215,
0.0213351771235466,
0.06422077119350433,
-0.9027627110481262,
-0.8497833013534546,
0.0577450729906559,
-0.2525829076766968,
-0.06322243809700012,
-0.05131395533680916,
-0.5786339044570923,
-0.4679255783557892,
-0.28265562653541565,
0.5047305822372437,
-0.6087061762809753,
-0.35462963581085205,
0.06845137476921082,
-0.27044835686683655,
-0.3278596103191376,
0.22084078192710876,
-0.8956279158592224,
0.4512235224246979,
0.34929579496383667,
0.7581542730331421,
0.10143166780471802,
-0.30789029598236084,
-0.24722187221050262,
-0.08050040155649185,
-0.14248524606227875,
0.5618299841880798,
-0.33042964339256287,
-0.524482786655426,
-0.107200488448143,
-0.493863970041275,
0.023655468598008156,
-1.060470700263977,
0.6185598373413086,
-0.39067256450653076,
-0.10065937042236328,
-0.5078780055046082,
-0.3630933463573456,
-0.3496881425380707,
-0.12899558246135712,
-0.8026490211486816,
0.9103823304176331,
0.09804187715053558,
-0.7157987952232361,
0.5409727692604065,
-0.39655518531799316,
-0.4482521116733551,
-0.23879845440387726,
-0.09036523103713989,
-0.5627656579017639,
0.0534600168466568,
0.3616390824317932,
0.1773296594619751,
-0.4251614809036255,
0.6434529423713684,
-0.005385101307183504,
-0.23972167074680328,
0.4825895428657532,
-0.8061147332191467,
1.076167345046997,
0.5772355198860168,
-0.4061049818992615,
-0.14005735516548157,
-0.9421507120132446,
-0.1662648767232895,
-0.14152966439723969,
-0.3809435963630676,
-0.4354481101036072,
0.12611347436904907,
0.24919858574867249,
-0.07818599790334702,
0.15228883922100067,
-0.26495665311813354,
-0.05139961466193199,
-0.2621743679046631,
0.6445930600166321,
0.6137552261352539,
-0.3898923099040985,
0.284387469291687,
-0.4820834994316101,
0.330507755279541,
0.31020495295524597,
-0.03666399046778679,
0.06508918851613998,
-0.3690709173679352,
-0.8416256308555603,
-0.7719503045082092,
0.5634461045265198,
0.31214767694473267,
-0.7320774793624878,
0.25123298168182373,
-0.2446102648973465,
-0.7405086159706116,
-0.6094380617141724,
0.2754199504852295,
0.5501571297645569,
0.6846844553947449,
0.5411734580993652,
-0.23696796596050262,
-0.5820939540863037,
-0.6445329785346985,
-0.29134032130241394,
-0.4368641674518585,
0.009702899493277073,
-0.05116401985287666,
0.5811015963554382,
-0.21753720939159393,
1.1168129444122314,
-0.2530269920825958,
-0.30818843841552734,
-0.5153312087059021,
0.2717452049255371,
0.14625392854213715,
0.3352154493331909,
0.7326822876930237,
-0.8804271221160889,
-0.861979603767395,
-0.03184070065617561,
-0.46490737795829773,
-0.24766074120998383,
0.24983833730220795,
0.33749106526374817,
0.24788863956928253,
0.09915994107723236,
-0.3824376165866852,
0.5262359976768494,
0.4345814883708954,
-0.22250646352767944,
0.47989028692245483,
-0.05778633430600166,
0.07815288007259369,
-1.1648930311203003,
0.14160645008087158,
-0.1086316779255867,
-0.2924439311027527,
-0.8553429245948792,
-0.19804450869560242,
-0.09071916341781616,
-0.08899318426847458,
-0.209675595164299,
0.23106566071510315,
-0.48290276527404785,
0.24936631321907043,
-0.28843212127685547,
-0.18944238126277924,
0.13239577412605286,
0.11080186069011688,
-0.023888321593403816,
0.8412119746208191,
0.5797781348228455,
-0.6040962934494019,
0.4407564699649811,
0.19512410461902618,
-0.6191235184669495,
0.36665740609169006,
-0.9495686888694763,
0.15952394902706146,
-0.029632696881890297,
0.05648418888449669,
-1.0419256687164307,
-0.24707485735416412,
-0.06716408580541611,
-0.4427688717842102,
0.5342986583709717,
-0.3525799810886383,
-0.19925540685653687,
-0.0769604817032814,
-0.02714824676513672,
0.4674677848815918,
0.6112579703330994,
-0.6416248679161072,
0.6674391627311707,
0.5495420694351196,
-0.3482421338558197,
-0.7678351402282715,
-0.6914926171302795,
0.013874736614525318,
-0.5703669786453247,
-0.45060425996780396,
-0.04121851921081543,
0.24736668169498444,
-0.6515961289405823,
-0.02089957892894745,
-0.3433486819267273,
-0.6141981482505798,
0.23692722618579865,
0.282996267080307,
0.26119449734687805,
-0.10421698540449142,
-0.06066951900720596,
0.007482203189283609,
-0.13008807599544525,
-0.06628891080617905,
-0.36592933535575867,
0.3951357305049896,
-0.21399973332881927,
-0.5652868151664734,
-0.6124219298362732,
0.4233282208442688,
0.6733230352401733,
-0.16765354573726654,
0.7195623517036438,
0.44924718141555786,
-0.3049623668193817,
-0.04885207116603851,
-0.654173731803894,
-0.18993327021598816,
-0.4995492100715637,
0.45503371953964233,
-0.39062997698783875,
-0.6680023074150085,
0.6681153774261475,
-0.04137970507144928,
-0.007207217160612345,
0.4128414988517761,
0.4222240447998047,
-0.007259894162416458,
0.8180918097496033,
0.5946331024169922,
-0.6690256595611572,
0.22958427667617798,
-0.22332897782325745,
0.2504003345966339,
-0.18499308824539185,
-0.25276878476142883,
-0.984965980052948,
-0.2067277580499649,
-0.44462424516677856,
-0.09285835176706314,
0.6789817810058594,
0.1047789454460144,
-0.2569831311702728,
0.10870146751403809,
-0.35880401730537415,
0.2967633306980133,
0.7611091732978821,
-0.26003149151802063,
0.5119708776473999,
0.14174535870552063,
-0.02047429420053959,
-0.12267143279314041,
-0.7339003086090088,
-0.6955886483192444,
1.2677308320999146,
0.29573172330856323,
0.9483696818351746,
0.4852338433265686,
0.7468345165252686,
0.3109167814254761,
-0.051898226141929626,
-0.7082081437110901,
0.14844562113285065,
-0.22363705933094025,
-0.7198822498321533,
-0.36540910601615906,
-0.4725251793861389,
-0.8787984848022461,
0.17726477980613708,
0.06002065911889076,
-0.5175530314445496,
0.24838711321353912,
0.3295370936393738,
-0.5420643091201782,
0.20753775537014008,
-0.9476195573806763,
0.6954091191291809,
-0.0624803826212883,
-0.00021094274416100234,
0.04445626586675644,
-0.7468487024307251,
0.15093974769115448,
-0.32351934909820557,
0.3501889109611511,
-0.014665703289210796,
0.4324006140232086,
0.6293879151344299,
-0.8679012656211853,
0.7347793579101562,
-0.4180624783039093,
0.00005419261287897825,
0.610018789768219,
-0.008416798897087574,
0.2533685564994812,
-0.16251611709594727,
-0.24214941263198853,
0.4323604106903076,
0.40494146943092346,
-0.2834489345550537,
-0.5342274904251099,
0.31222671270370483,
-1.1332818269729614,
-0.5774631500244141,
-0.7439661622047424,
-0.342208594083786,
-0.121921107172966,
-0.0025077019818127155,
0.43654394149780273,
0.6689873933792114,
-0.08876997977495193,
0.11945033818483353,
0.475640207529068,
0.11876530200242996,
0.3895798921585083,
0.4782979190349579,
-0.18194130063056946,
-0.39701491594314575,
0.9370779991149902,
0.5608890652656555,
0.28930190205574036,
-0.09234106540679932,
0.3223898708820343,
-0.6748649477958679,
-0.8369176983833313,
-0.75331050157547,
-0.19854013621807098,
-0.6511038541793823,
-0.1921761929988861,
-0.4650435745716095,
-0.4127994477748871,
-0.5187930464744568,
0.2829572856426239,
-0.6086792945861816,
-0.604951024055481,
-0.39734527468681335,
-0.031144896522164345,
0.5657169818878174,
0.825771152973175,
-0.208062082529068,
0.26288458704948425,
-0.8671138286590576,
0.2322806715965271,
0.5411092042922974,
-0.25056710839271545,
0.029302438721060753,
-0.9903689622879028,
-0.3359765112400055,
0.3646739721298218,
-0.4244518578052521,
-0.8890537619590759,
0.5351885557174683,
0.8138654828071594,
0.48612937331199646,
0.6254450678825378,
0.5572556853294373,
0.9319542646408081,
-0.5026202201843262,
0.7345398664474487,
0.019215483218431473,
-1.0965087413787842,
0.4312020242214203,
-0.14290881156921387,
0.268412321805954,
0.9870783686637878,
0.5447209477424622,
-0.23234713077545166,
-0.3484841287136078,
-0.2916144132614136,
-1.0343432426452637,
0.497963547706604,
0.11397939175367355,
0.0968920886516571,
0.26146939396858215,
0.21126967668533325,
0.3884175419807434,
0.30886346101760864,
-0.5252199172973633,
-0.4542061984539032,
-0.5263047218322754,
-0.4292217195034027,
-0.220057874917984,
-0.528897225856781,
-0.21164612472057343,
-0.4133731424808502,
0.6034862399101257,
0.045325614511966705,
-0.25595027208328247,
0.07183661311864853,
-0.17331266403198242,
0.2388393133878708,
0.42934152483940125,
0.1875876784324646,
0.619621753692627,
-0.07337036728858948,
0.5505048036575317,
0.25985223054885864,
-0.827300488948822,
0.393312007188797,
0.47608712315559387,
-0.16021481156349182,
0.13910044729709625,
0.37348926067352295,
0.6203661561012268,
-0.1526585966348648,
-0.6989443302154541,
0.3989858031272888,
-0.10654810070991516,
-0.06174900382757187,
-0.4609183669090271,
0.047227974981069565,
-0.009593469090759754,
0.4515382945537567,
0.629970133304596,
0.2917167842388153,
0.5462126731872559,
-0.6277980208396912,
0.09004273265600204,
0.249598890542984,
-0.3834614157676697,
-0.42089608311653137,
0.6022751927375793,
0.11994604766368866,
-0.019252052530646324,
0.7667754888534546,
-0.15758492052555084,
-0.6970909237861633,
0.27567240595817566,
0.32020434737205505,
0.6768996119499207,
-0.4830535054206848,
0.0770278126001358,
0.24289092421531677,
-0.0248193871229887,
-0.21138618886470795,
0.1837104707956314,
-0.29509469866752625,
-0.7136952877044678,
-0.0853612944483757,
-0.7066490650177002,
-0.3253628611564636,
-0.09249484539031982,
-0.948749303817749,
0.01927194558084011,
-0.24917593598365784,
-0.4093236029148102,
0.1500358134508133,
0.006641070358455181,
-0.369399756193161,
0.1400180459022522,
-0.16075684130191803,
0.5393328070640564,
-1.0025137662887573,
1.1366164684295654,
0.74907386302948,
-0.18502478301525116,
-0.9852715730667114,
0.04507356882095337,
0.3083690404891968,
-0.5533207654953003,
0.702718198299408,
-0.12368495017290115,
-0.4333382248878479,
-0.11078415811061859,
-0.2039928436279297,
-0.6814630627632141,
0.8940597772598267,
0.705739438533783,
-0.7291398644447327,
0.25654828548431396,
0.2574213743209839,
0.5310476422309875,
0.04447799548506737,
0.21115215122699738,
0.7576922178268433,
0.17798812687397003,
0.4577026665210724,
-1.3298999071121216,
-0.2501588463783264,
-0.22814461588859558,
0.06088166683912277,
-0.09252608567476273,
-0.5031988024711609,
0.9625153541564941,
-0.3303437829017639,
-0.3134743869304657,
0.11407116800546646,
0.5792347192764282,
0.1541311889886856,
0.6249738931655884,
0.4845014214515686,
0.5645046234130859,
0.8981494307518005,
-0.14992783963680267,
0.6398385763168335,
-0.128458634018898,
0.116857148706913,
1.3321189880371094,
-0.37696149945259094,
0.9312585592269897,
0.5595909357070923,
-0.48955488204956055,
0.4047439992427826,
0.418359637260437,
0.3003665506839752,
0.7594748735427856,
0.06229213625192642,
-0.5634793043136597,
-0.1431354582309723,
-0.19536970555782318,
-0.5603840947151184,
0.9172464609146118,
0.05763038247823715,
-0.12772759795188904,
-0.2173498570919037,
-0.11208587884902954,
0.1484895646572113,
0.4030294120311737,
-0.04144301638007164,
0.983491837978363,
0.13261854648590088,
-0.4642803370952606,
0.8738661408424377,
-0.11449170112609863,
0.5377420783042908,
-0.5296294689178467,
0.14456014335155487,
-0.16741883754730225,
0.3429814875125885,
-0.13898801803588867,
-0.2207915484905243,
0.6172533631324768,
0.36317604780197144,
-0.1941109299659729,
-0.03542331978678703,
0.6090903282165527,
-0.47171902656555176,
-0.6009302139282227,
0.07327477633953094,
0.6579689383506775,
0.2893417775630951,
-0.213282510638237,
-0.33399835228919983,
0.25322186946868896,
0.1582237035036087,
0.11482367664575577,
0.3644300699234009,
0.6832095384597778,
0.06539725512266159,
0.7469950318336487,
0.46389415860176086,
0.16941551864147186,
0.06593085080385208,
0.1275366246700287,
1.1161367893218994,
-0.2782116234302521,
-0.239763081073761,
-1.250935673713684,
0.6547785997390747,
0.08352836221456528,
-0.15105220675468445,
0.8722005486488342,
0.5854498147964478,
0.7567424178123474,
0.15389297902584076,
0.9504903554916382,
0.04509655758738518,
0.649452269077301,
-0.3354242742061615,
1.2144083976745605,
-0.47777605056762695,
0.46963590383529663,
-0.30827832221984863,
-0.7342996001243591,
0.1301337033510208,
0.882575273513794,
-0.11546102166175842,
0.2557934522628784,
0.2730119824409485,
0.5985954999923706,
-0.036894895136356354,
0.20545987784862518,
0.3188669681549072,
0.2819782495498657,
0.21423104405403137,
0.3112294375896454,
1.104370355606079,
-0.4017558693885803,
0.5584736466407776,
-0.28872838616371155,
-0.12047872692346573,
-0.049055468291044235,
-0.6617375016212463,
-0.9008823037147522,
-0.8750686645507812,
-0.417758584022522,
-0.2766512632369995,
0.12097955495119095,
0.9748213291168213,
0.8527370095252991,
-1.1211909055709839,
-0.423944890499115,
0.07637553662061691,
0.03708407282829285,
-0.26256152987480164,
-0.08124201744794846,
0.3300780653953552,
-0.05447417125105858,
-0.8174607753753662,
0.26264461874961853,
-0.2118266522884369,
0.2873041331768036,
-0.12873579561710358,
-0.09088507294654846,
0.08062861859798431,
-0.15586848556995392,
0.30251336097717285,
0.20408430695533752,
-0.6406067609786987,
-0.16776207089424133,
-0.27441757917404175,
0.06225177273154259,
-0.13396607339382172,
0.4510413408279419,
-0.6850918531417847,
0.6374044418334961,
0.04571414738893509,
0.5851631164550781,
0.5106899738311768,
0.011946585960686207,
0.5380547642707825,
-0.637805163860321,
0.28024497628211975,
0.3225449323654175,
0.40533003211021423,
0.5119510889053345,
0.10349676012992859,
0.21933971345424652,
0.11046385765075684,
-0.6130866408348083,
-0.9875400066375732,
0.218109592795372,
-0.678311824798584,
-0.1476162225008011,
0.985327422618866,
-0.5804831981658936,
0.12900260090827942,
-0.6280724406242371,
-0.3743014335632324,
0.3453323245048523,
-0.6060891151428223,
1.128404974937439,
0.8229418396949768,
0.02448355033993721,
-0.03141313046216965,
-0.46513882279396057,
0.6689764261245728,
0.2726157605648041,
-0.19459329545497894,
0.01882755011320114,
0.6903179287910461,
0.5005525350570679,
0.037062980234622955,
0.5042591691017151,
0.06840972602367401,
0.10126511752605438,
0.2817923426628113,
-0.1627194583415985,
-0.25585344433784485,
-0.4911857545375824,
-0.46074292063713074,
0.16900621354579926,
0.7444862127304077,
-0.2340453565120697
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.04501v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.04501v1
|
FLUID-LLM: Learning Computational Fluid Dynamics with Spatiotemporal-aware Large Language Models
| 2024-06-06T20:55:40 | 2024-06-06T20:55:40 |
Max Zhu, Adrián Bazaga, Pietro Liò
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, stat.ML
|
Learning computational fluid dynamics (CFD) traditionally relies on
computationally intensive simulations of the Navier-Stokes equations. Recently,
large language models (LLMs) have shown remarkable pattern recognition and
reasoning abilities in natural language processing (NLP) and computer vision
(CV). However, these models struggle with the complex geometries inherent in
fluid dynamics. We introduce FLUID-LLM, a novel framework combining pre-trained
LLMs with spatiotemporal-aware encoding to predict unsteady fluid dynamics. Our
approach leverages the temporal autoregressive abilities of LLMs alongside
spatial-aware layers, bridging the gap between previous CFD prediction methods.
Evaluations on standard benchmarks reveal significant performance improvements
across various fluid datasets. Our results demonstrate that FLUID-LLM
effectively integrates spatiotemporal information into pre-trained LLMs,
enhancing CFD task performance.
|
[
-0.2857903242111206,
-0.6961325407028198,
0.6258952617645264,
0.47667309641838074,
-0.45294395089149475,
0.4642254114151001,
-0.2674753963947296,
-0.5142184495925903,
0.3250075876712799,
0.643806517124176,
-0.508979082107544,
-0.39077192544937134,
-0.5702866911888123,
-0.41647204756736755,
-0.4790821969509125,
0.5646677017211914,
-0.6270581483840942,
0.07010139524936676,
-0.4086465835571289,
0.2786816656589508,
0.028598228469491005,
-0.6358169913291931,
-0.5450769066810608,
-0.47981593012809753,
0.42086097598075867,
-0.03903781622648239,
0.6130723357200623,
0.7657526731491089,
0.4036664068698883,
0.34347033500671387,
0.12451788038015366,
0.25249454379081726,
-0.37601345777511597,
0.19016747176647186,
0.1563037782907486,
0.021022837609052658,
0.15537236630916595,
-0.3164054751396179,
0.8061454892158508,
0.945622980594635,
-0.5203161835670471,
-0.21328969299793243,
0.05812222138047218,
0.8608943819999695,
-0.7589961290359497,
0.7049694061279297,
-0.31156766414642334,
0.43656453490257263,
-0.10424979776144028,
-0.4785921275615692,
-0.00460317637771368,
0.3010638952255249,
0.19624218344688416,
-0.8657712936401367,
0.10181575268507004,
-0.026073871180415154,
0.3759290874004364,
0.6461571455001831,
-0.39098870754241943,
0.14045432209968567,
-1.14231538772583,
0.43542107939720154,
-0.2708854377269745,
0.790964663028717,
0.015166796743869781,
0.5022690296173096,
-0.33567652106285095,
-0.8969907760620117,
-0.3989507257938385,
0.36094701290130615,
0.18469765782356262,
0.33397236466407776,
-0.00570976035669446,
0.14825168251991272,
-0.02586224675178528,
-0.0891198217868805,
-0.8081409335136414,
0.16806496679782867,
-0.29692384600639343,
-0.09696498513221741,
0.7716622352600098,
0.19276700913906097,
-0.03914852440357208,
0.4723258316516876,
-0.7605266571044922,
0.017264919355511665,
-0.35543856024742126,
0.23320941627025604,
0.026407010853290558,
0.2957373261451721,
-0.5682356357574463,
0.1603502482175827,
-0.20541150867938995,
0.3555956184864044,
-0.038304831832647324,
-0.014689823612570763,
0.19942505657672882,
0.5039891600608826,
-0.44671738147735596,
0.06323739141225815,
0.768780529499054,
-0.23812396824359894,
0.19242189824581146,
-0.32372522354125977,
-0.28976789116859436,
-0.44347456097602844,
0.013565592467784882,
-0.6597517728805542,
-0.2408645749092102,
0.1718536764383316,
-0.1441168189048767,
-0.23727892339229584,
-0.008697133511304855,
-0.7560074925422668,
-0.6893818974494934,
-0.7458748817443848,
0.23238910734653473,
-0.08827419579029083,
-0.41492462158203125,
0.5171501636505127,
-0.009206992574036121,
0.279707133769989,
0.5690200328826904,
-0.6317145228385925,
0.11496474593877792,
0.7248445153236389,
0.7605761289596558,
-0.3858744204044342,
-0.6844292283058167,
-0.7570779919624329,
0.5840721130371094,
-0.3764569163322449,
1.1008260250091553,
-0.6043739914894104,
-0.3510150909423828,
0.2259979397058487,
-0.22284333407878876,
-0.02187858335673809,
-0.45700597763061523,
0.24500936269760132,
-0.6484106779098511,
-0.15217085182666779,
-0.1707289069890976,
-0.588180422782898,
-0.3012513518333435,
-0.1099347397685051,
-0.5864080786705017,
0.9358240365982056,
-0.09965821355581284,
-0.6975428462028503,
0.2632964551448822,
-0.4165797233581543,
-0.4614211618900299,
0.1552056223154068,
-0.3200451731681824,
-0.34959983825683594,
0.12541928887367249,
0.07460913062095642,
0.694793164730072,
-0.29527395963668823,
0.6220983266830444,
-0.6774082779884338,
-0.126705601811409,
0.13439445197582245,
-0.5428370237350464,
0.3375215530395508,
0.3024721145629883,
-0.05359024181962013,
0.2225484848022461,
-0.5168628692626953,
0.002802293049171567,
-0.06753906607627869,
-0.312387079000473,
0.20942510664463043,
-0.06962917000055313,
0.31321805715560913,
0.16344477236270905,
0.11591358482837677,
-0.15457601845264435,
-0.05539191886782646,
-0.31534233689308167,
0.29147663712501526,
0.6615270376205444,
0.04766117036342621,
0.6809784770011902,
-0.23793302476406097,
0.671468198299408,
0.19565579295158386,
-0.002290300792083144,
0.16634218394756317,
-0.2194344401359558,
-0.47738492488861084,
-0.39074981212615967,
-0.11135950684547424,
0.4879506528377533,
-1.0678967237472534,
0.0934615209698677,
-0.16453132033348083,
-0.7244970798492432,
0.23389701545238495,
0.48637789487838745,
0.02813517116010189,
0.29543739557266235,
0.4272817373275757,
0.14099058508872986,
-0.6493515372276306,
-0.33793169260025024,
-0.15338869392871857,
-0.3545144200325012,
0.1224203035235405,
0.23925694823265076,
0.2548134922981262,
-0.3405700922012329,
0.5899782180786133,
-0.5045234560966492,
-0.07805847376585007,
-0.18169356882572174,
0.36098092794418335,
-0.1583007574081421,
0.3698374032974243,
0.6162852644920349,
-0.5576990842819214,
-0.4853001832962036,
0.02211107686161995,
-0.6205320954322815,
-0.2647574543952942,
-0.06596360355615616,
-0.5189729928970337,
0.28551533818244934,
1.014325737953186,
-0.5971745252609253,
0.44203394651412964,
0.7254607081413269,
-0.4624166190624237,
0.4324950575828552,
-0.3623548150062561,
-0.3158905506134033,
-0.684412956237793,
-0.02900654822587967,
-0.15772026777267456,
-0.219853937625885,
-0.43309882283210754,
-0.12401612848043442,
-0.10065639764070511,
-0.3069666624069214,
-0.7537686228752136,
0.9782474040985107,
-0.733212411403656,
-0.29570361971855164,
-0.5035201907157898,
-0.11749467253684998,
-0.03256482630968094,
0.42396819591522217,
0.7508370876312256,
0.31713587045669556,
0.9878225326538086,
-0.5611308217048645,
0.4896262586116791,
-0.37894967198371887,
-0.31957879662513733,
-0.10714323073625565,
-0.48478949069976807,
0.08897694200277328,
-0.3019384741783142,
0.28567400574684143,
-0.7864062190055847,
-0.30932527780532837,
-0.23182155191898346,
0.04852607101202011,
0.652484118938446,
-0.017746582627296448,
-0.3360784351825714,
-0.25860700011253357,
-0.024015968665480614,
0.5811063647270203,
0.2503181993961334,
-0.9163837432861328,
1.195605993270874,
0.662324845790863,
-0.013652462512254715,
-0.6976866722106934,
-0.5222221612930298,
-0.37332484126091003,
-0.1185288354754448,
-0.3060357868671417,
0.3635190427303314,
-0.15080158412456512,
-0.07865428179502487,
-0.17094779014587402,
-0.16474410891532898,
-0.5676954984664917,
0.20234522223472595,
0.48745355010032654,
0.11622808873653412,
-0.10226694494485855,
0.091983363032341,
-0.07627511024475098,
-0.12298361212015152,
0.2397485375404358,
-0.4331551790237427,
0.6322139501571655,
-0.1498677134513855,
-0.37175506353378296,
-0.286559522151947,
0.20033489167690277,
0.7513505220413208,
-0.04460188373923302,
0.5533992648124695,
1.06895112991333,
-0.6842510104179382,
-0.4001407325267792,
-0.5190806984901428,
-0.1158856451511383,
-0.5258969664573669,
0.37731555104255676,
0.017929838970303535,
-0.9309285283088684,
0.6405149698257446,
-0.2146393358707428,
-0.14220590889453888,
0.2108442485332489,
0.5847172737121582,
-0.4279802739620209,
0.5473694801330566,
0.7097233533859253,
-0.4156472086906433,
0.49209168553352356,
-0.3342861533164978,
-0.05523240193724632,
-0.3792385160923004,
-0.4281189441680908,
-0.384048730134964,
-0.47645896673202515,
-0.20638690888881683,
-0.9051457643508911,
0.3218042254447937,
0.229040265083313,
-0.5208781957626343,
-0.3697971701622009,
-0.01977415196597576,
0.7082874178886414,
-0.035191860049963,
-0.13019952178001404,
0.015209328383207321,
0.11609797924757004,
-0.35358813405036926,
0.08919882029294968,
-0.8203213214874268,
-0.14092238247394562,
0.812161386013031,
0.31340572237968445,
0.8264256119728088,
-0.023200472816824913,
0.47733816504478455,
0.15861362218856812,
0.2486496865749359,
-0.559377908706665,
0.3408695459365845,
-0.023396911099553108,
-0.3997109532356262,
-0.2764638364315033,
-0.32815074920654297,
-1.0297383069992065,
-0.06280303746461868,
-0.49709081649780273,
-0.31611916422843933,
0.03754497691988945,
0.08605381846427917,
-0.5054215788841248,
0.6796965599060059,
-0.5685590505599976,
0.5706090331077576,
-0.6276023387908936,
-0.524681806564331,
-0.12357193976640701,
-0.40615177154541016,
0.16496792435646057,
-0.15090395510196686,
0.36644306778907776,
-0.18600043654441833,
-0.4905787706375122,
0.43055519461631775,
-0.5199686884880066,
0.95225989818573,
-0.40124741196632385,
-0.11717531830072403,
0.36189004778862,
0.10292660444974899,
0.19443927705287933,
0.4172244966030121,
0.21950359642505646,
0.5191311240196228,
-0.07717478275299072,
-0.4011438488960266,
-0.7295826077461243,
0.8121147751808167,
-1.098012924194336,
-0.24592910706996918,
-0.5225250720977783,
-0.6229086518287659,
-0.3162343204021454,
0.08750055730342865,
0.08335566520690918,
0.4195093810558319,
-0.18130140006542206,
-0.06316492706537247,
0.5689959526062012,
-0.24662552773952484,
0.7750842571258545,
0.8247226476669312,
-0.6682224869728088,
-0.2682516574859619,
0.6336979269981384,
0.04367749020457268,
-0.12314135581254959,
0.8056384325027466,
0.14511261880397797,
-0.5072611570358276,
-0.5783584713935852,
-0.285833477973938,
0.2914375364780426,
-0.5530460476875305,
-0.42338359355926514,
-0.6382386088371277,
-0.6475597023963928,
-0.05367130786180496,
-0.5019233822822571,
-0.5423291325569153,
-0.3283694386482239,
-0.5069315433502197,
-0.0512072890996933,
0.5209788680076599,
0.9100589752197266,
-0.26892849802970886,
0.07846125215291977,
-0.7296537756919861,
0.17062832415103912,
0.3676897883415222,
0.6192001700401306,
-0.06289006769657135,
-0.5622405409812927,
-0.23359721899032593,
-0.1546354740858078,
-0.24705864489078522,
-0.27208179235458374,
0.6300591826438904,
0.39376771450042725,
0.5898662209510803,
0.612952470779419,
-0.019675329327583313,
0.7693501114845276,
-0.6226159334182739,
0.5937818884849548,
0.2237590253353119,
-0.8564246892929077,
0.27348875999450684,
-0.3347257971763611,
0.4032513499259949,
-0.06248501315712929,
0.6356639266014099,
-0.20313356816768646,
-0.1804569661617279,
-0.47025153040885925,
-0.628836452960968,
0.20129387080669403,
-0.24236039817333221,
-0.07929647713899612,
0.10338648408651352,
0.6653119325637817,
0.20362171530723572,
0.15620937943458557,
-0.23206119239330292,
-0.06704817712306976,
-0.04988827928900719,
-0.0065575107000768185,
-0.2734827995300293,
-0.12640182673931122,
0.37649136781692505,
-0.4576813578605652,
0.47968411445617676,
-0.31071051955223083,
0.4576965868473053,
0.2728492021560669,
0.10620816797018051,
-0.35865694284439087,
-0.3053860068321228,
0.7186728715896606,
0.34634366631507874,
-0.0006672253366559744,
0.17665569484233856,
0.13114051520824432,
-0.5827600955963135,
-0.173173725605011,
0.2388121783733368,
0.21277906000614166,
-0.022473786026239395,
0.5166252255439758,
0.8419046401977539,
0.45483776926994324,
-0.8740781545639038,
0.37617915868759155,
-0.18826861679553986,
-0.3459480404853821,
-0.5583873391151428,
0.009522541426122189,
0.281941294670105,
0.6588029265403748,
0.3248103857040405,
0.19269707798957825,
0.054134875535964966,
-0.1937524378299713,
0.014126766473054886,
0.4856564700603485,
-0.37644824385643005,
-0.31023404002189636,
0.7939085364341736,
0.18633168935775757,
0.05501268804073334,
0.2230047732591629,
-0.008887818083167076,
-0.6227912306785583,
0.6504870653152466,
0.18882609903812408,
1.0042635202407837,
-0.22565799951553345,
-0.051951248198747635,
0.29272010922431946,
-0.01649244874715805,
-0.1927483230829239,
0.8084884285926819,
-0.06970933824777603,
-1.0006405115127563,
-0.7265095114707947,
-0.7315102815628052,
-0.48040539026260376,
0.35693031549453735,
-0.3674718737602234,
0.3891899883747101,
-0.941045343875885,
-0.13490118086338043,
-0.13152152299880981,
0.028719795867800713,
-0.9366032481193542,
-0.09151948243379593,
0.58778977394104,
0.8200652599334717,
-0.7165402173995972,
0.7140695452690125,
0.8921896815299988,
0.12285535037517548,
-0.8695092797279358,
-0.10950140655040741,
0.10760712623596191,
-0.6765523552894592,
0.7017427682876587,
-0.12438174337148666,
-0.40586259961128235,
-0.06625856459140778,
-0.5245446562767029,
-1.105280876159668,
1.071722149848938,
0.7892031669616699,
-0.6284947991371155,
0.021016579121351242,
0.3562147617340088,
0.6688789129257202,
-0.5123281478881836,
0.06812659651041031,
0.13327905535697937,
0.17000192403793335,
0.14091534912586212,
-0.9933353066444397,
-0.44603806734085083,
-0.26086944341659546,
0.033745791763067245,
0.15920540690422058,
-0.7447659969329834,
0.5981448292732239,
-0.5418376326560974,
-0.14273673295974731,
-0.25365185737609863,
0.9466527104377747,
0.2917827367782593,
0.369925320148468,
0.3963688910007477,
0.4253605604171753,
0.9412721395492554,
-0.1374971866607666,
1.0083554983139038,
-0.6202178001403809,
0.2003956288099289,
0.9378662109375,
-0.5240252017974854,
0.9918018579483032,
0.4071114957332611,
0.025617403909564018,
0.4735386073589325,
0.5012494921684265,
0.5049251914024353,
0.5739123821258545,
0.2725479304790497,
-0.38150182366371155,
-0.4771081805229187,
-0.007887111976742744,
-0.32492172718048096,
0.7127982378005981,
0.449491024017334,
0.07009558379650116,
-0.13308420777320862,
0.02339564822614193,
-0.2948998212814331,
0.26737308502197266,
-0.4752098023891449,
0.6907299160957336,
0.21050815284252167,
-0.11813918501138687,
0.6181135177612305,
-0.23497746884822845,
0.6335363984107971,
-0.4466409385204315,
0.07293669134378433,
-0.032853834331035614,
0.10144837200641632,
-0.022055519744753838,
-0.8661437630653381,
0.4325543940067291,
-0.15990686416625977,
-0.29599729180336,
-0.3845473527908325,
0.7970873117446899,
-0.7084731459617615,
-0.5393452048301697,
0.5155556201934814,
0.7387689352035522,
0.11852233111858368,
-0.06584303826093674,
-0.6160006523132324,
0.16398228704929352,
-0.32727330923080444,
0.022583486512303352,
0.3969521224498749,
0.8685511946678162,
0.2315329760313034,
1.0841261148452759,
0.6338961720466614,
0.20491823554039001,
-0.02671121433377266,
0.21650782227516174,
0.8211965560913086,
-0.47279587388038635,
-0.5499780178070068,
-0.5012503266334534,
0.12738098204135895,
0.34670770168304443,
0.06664804369211197,
0.11835070699453354,
0.6681024432182312,
0.8778371214866638,
-0.1411939263343811,
0.6960959434509277,
0.6849738955497742,
0.5414249300956726,
-0.8527427315711975,
0.879039466381073,
-0.4397451877593994,
0.3564817011356354,
-0.05046514794230461,
-0.6828235387802124,
-0.389249324798584,
0.5949811935424805,
-0.2540123164653778,
0.25260382890701294,
0.6435433626174927,
0.42984944581985474,
-0.0915229544043541,
0.21197782456874847,
0.3720043897628784,
0.28529420495033264,
0.21843935549259186,
0.6838237643241882,
0.9542436003684998,
-0.11959901452064514,
0.1394331455230713,
-0.6215449571609497,
0.0390021912753582,
-0.056288156658411026,
-1.2618730068206787,
-0.9635230302810669,
-0.6028130054473877,
-0.5353021025657654,
0.027462994679808617,
-0.20572835206985474,
1.160398006439209,
0.7360602617263794,
-0.6228873133659363,
-0.4144912660121918,
-0.015346301719546318,
-0.23706583678722382,
0.0459485724568367,
-0.2117224633693695,
0.2053668200969696,
-0.21165157854557037,
-0.4335857629776001,
0.43786245584487915,
0.5473847985267639,
0.36308199167251587,
-0.4752771258354187,
-0.3343522548675537,
0.11177525669336319,
-0.09513334929943085,
0.6387647390365601,
0.4220742881298065,
-0.3516715168952942,
0.02526874653995037,
0.01848992332816124,
0.055584054440259933,
-0.22733008861541748,
0.8876519203186035,
-0.8730790615081787,
0.30769219994544983,
0.5647861957550049,
0.953986406326294,
0.7499164938926697,
-0.3048137426376343,
0.5428367853164673,
-0.7220741510391235,
0.4672626256942749,
0.20071479678153992,
0.7463898062705994,
0.26686015725135803,
-0.4268832802772522,
0.35887157917022705,
0.4003142714500427,
-0.5240952372550964,
-0.6636396050453186,
-0.1250416338443756,
-1.0440679788589478,
-0.3656643033027649,
1.207226037979126,
0.007182963192462921,
-0.15648126602172852,
-0.26603105664253235,
0.049187272787094116,
0.18561773002147675,
-0.35467618703842163,
0.7408882975578308,
0.5449895858764648,
-0.15246528387069702,
-0.15605950355529785,
-0.5875212550163269,
0.5860387682914734,
0.02713232859969139,
-0.8237485885620117,
0.32425934076309204,
0.3830406069755554,
0.26226484775543213,
-0.1954023391008377,
0.42891833186149597,
0.07874438911676407,
0.27063101530075073,
-0.27181679010391235,
0.11679069697856903,
-0.20431458950042725,
-0.690976083278656,
-0.33252447843551636,
-0.04638561233878136,
-0.06550237536430359,
0.4973846971988678
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.04496v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.04496v1
|
Time Sensitive Knowledge Editing through Efficient Finetuning
| 2024-06-06T20:41:36 | 2024-06-06T20:41:36 |
Xiou Ge, Ali Mousavi, Edouard Grave, Armand Joulin, Kun Qian, Benjamin Han, Mostafa Arefiyan, Yunyao Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated impressive capability in
different tasks and are bringing transformative changes to many domains.
However, keeping the knowledge in LLMs up-to-date remains a challenge once
pretraining is complete. It is thus essential to design effective methods to
both update obsolete knowledge and induce new knowledge into LLMs. Existing
locate-and-edit knowledge editing (KE) method suffers from two limitations.
First, the post-edit LLMs by such methods generally have poor capability in
answering complex queries that require multi-hop reasoning. Second, the long
run-time of such locate-and-edit methods to perform knowledge edits make it
infeasible for large scale KE in practice. In this paper, we explore
Parameter-Efficient Fine-Tuning (PEFT) techniques as an alternative for KE. We
curate a more comprehensive temporal KE dataset with both knowledge update and
knowledge injection examples for KE performance benchmarking. We further probe
the effect of fine-tuning on a range of layers in an LLM for the multi-hop QA
task. We find that PEFT performs better than locate-and-edit techniques for
time-sensitive knowledge edits.
|
[
-0.20992039144039154,
-1.172653079032898,
0.748200535774231,
0.07364125549793243,
-0.1561775952577591,
0.15862834453582764,
-0.4122534990310669,
-0.5389977097511292,
-0.2901029884815216,
0.2656654715538025,
-0.3718512952327728,
-0.431797057390213,
-0.44881483912467957,
-0.060346569865942,
-0.05371065437793732,
0.6017293930053711,
-0.1740090698003769,
-0.22850191593170166,
0.23440510034561157,
-0.3073277175426483,
-0.3834484815597534,
-0.48880112171173096,
-0.960745096206665,
-0.11508423835039139,
0.5049974918365479,
0.42788854241371155,
0.6667541861534119,
0.6903285980224609,
0.35257574915885925,
0.28341102600097656,
-0.6944007277488708,
0.6418992280960083,
-0.32602450251579285,
0.07613661140203476,
-0.480406254529953,
-0.4772937297821045,
-0.631023108959198,
-0.22394247353076935,
0.7583879232406616,
0.8606148362159729,
0.06730398535728455,
0.1571231335401535,
0.11504828184843063,
0.6659474968910217,
-0.8939418196678162,
-0.021665558218955994,
-0.8626406788825989,
-0.05027511715888977,
-0.3043820261955261,
-0.2737608850002289,
-0.16125209629535675,
-0.44111162424087524,
0.16715534031391144,
-0.7467552423477173,
0.037049297243356705,
-0.07913491129875183,
0.7424123287200928,
0.5089864730834961,
-0.3080498278141022,
0.1221717894077301,
-0.7588316202163696,
0.7072199583053589,
-0.8280855417251587,
0.9072017073631287,
0.15427105128765106,
0.208394855260849,
-0.3022204637527466,
-0.5367008447647095,
-0.5066264271736145,
-0.010765177197754383,
0.057044606655836105,
-0.32043978571891785,
0.16251015663146973,
0.10961809009313583,
0.4934327304363251,
0.17457500100135803,
-0.06683260947465897,
0.3173328936100006,
0.07757782191038132,
-0.2896769642829895,
0.24475054442882538,
0.06074869632720947,
-0.006875956896692514,
-0.02087375335395336,
-0.06682989001274109,
0.1604936271905899,
-0.7586667537689209,
0.12845544517040253,
0.3400186002254486,
0.20883511006832123,
0.36843612790107727,
0.615371584892273,
-0.5434468984603882,
0.9022496938705444,
0.3824656009674072,
-0.3509950339794159,
0.03518277779221535,
-0.47874754667282104,
-0.2744889259338379,
-0.18202033638954163,
0.5452449917793274,
0.32462310791015625,
0.192155659198761,
-0.15938441455364227,
-0.15288394689559937,
-0.4064246714115143,
-0.05708150193095207,
-0.6990392208099365,
-0.16803905367851257,
0.12583652138710022,
-0.2136228233575821,
-0.14613887667655945,
-0.42562946677207947,
-0.5132120847702026,
-0.35990503430366516,
-0.4605773985385895,
0.5369203090667725,
-0.6621770262718201,
0.17916537821292877,
0.2797623872756958,
-0.0195776354521513,
0.16137976944446564,
0.6041121482849121,
-0.6347940564155579,
-0.07160954177379608,
0.5509618520736694,
0.647200345993042,
0.14324623346328735,
-0.3740704357624054,
-0.787991464138031,
0.4828038215637207,
-0.29513004422187805,
0.6810117363929749,
-0.6217935681343079,
-0.05934114754199982,
-0.29075929522514343,
0.0750625878572464,
-0.03262990713119507,
-0.5337917804718018,
0.3103170394897461,
-0.9859470725059509,
-0.020672205835580826,
-0.33991268277168274,
-0.5748483538627625,
0.011432374827563763,
0.28095269203186035,
-0.39022913575172424,
0.967423677444458,
0.1769089251756668,
-0.48517104983329773,
0.499769002199173,
-0.683235228061676,
-0.5774868130683899,
-0.2945743501186371,
0.307617723941803,
-0.4120146930217743,
-0.12876400351524353,
0.6060594320297241,
0.6162923574447632,
0.2161082923412323,
0.20297956466674805,
-0.2874639928340912,
-0.3918319046497345,
0.07863640785217285,
-0.20162440836429596,
0.5404684543609619,
0.3204376995563507,
-0.32309404015541077,
-0.09136253595352173,
-0.8220025897026062,
0.14157786965370178,
-0.10324862599372864,
-0.6803320050239563,
-0.5122970342636108,
0.09094896912574768,
-0.3922847509384155,
0.06402016431093216,
0.43623819947242737,
-0.4696853458881378,
0.4648224711418152,
-0.48582324385643005,
0.47919565439224243,
0.8186131119728088,
0.2766883373260498,
0.5238048434257507,
-0.24667608737945557,
0.34318703413009644,
0.02650490403175354,
0.49699780344963074,
0.05726232752203941,
-0.0002724634250625968,
-0.6572878360748291,
0.031976036727428436,
0.5222042798995972,
0.6163191795349121,
-0.7264465689659119,
0.34450775384902954,
-0.07331735640764236,
-0.6235097050666809,
-0.4933716058731079,
0.4843046963214874,
0.25379157066345215,
0.5466378331184387,
0.5402299761772156,
0.22681684792041779,
-0.2206716686487198,
-0.7327269911766052,
-0.6680458188056946,
0.12358732521533966,
-0.07530099898576736,
0.38184088468551636,
-0.008703461848199368,
-0.10943818837404251,
0.5735017657279968,
-0.6060405373573303,
-0.29010117053985596,
0.16160233318805695,
-0.10627786070108414,
-0.0038028638809919357,
0.4343441426753998,
0.47094079852104187,
-0.37044933438301086,
-0.49942833185195923,
0.029812142252922058,
-0.3771383762359619,
-0.3360692858695984,
-0.27188190817832947,
-0.3280644714832306,
0.17034828662872314,
0.8197041153907776,
-0.5022053122520447,
-0.019562194123864174,
0.3207642436027527,
-0.47717997431755066,
0.5113453269004822,
-0.17469020187854767,
0.5400492548942566,
-0.8612514138221741,
0.04217611253261566,
-0.2851264774799347,
-0.3910564184188843,
-0.40490880608558655,
0.15207961201667786,
0.37177324295043945,
0.03177087754011154,
-0.6754801869392395,
0.6261114478111267,
-0.5046573877334595,
0.4081465005874634,
0.09977440536022186,
0.12994049489498138,
0.008461583405733109,
0.5208593010902405,
-0.22185905277729034,
0.7246837019920349,
0.30344200134277344,
-0.820501983165741,
0.04413258656859398,
0.22926606237888336,
-0.439507395029068,
0.5206003189086914,
-0.45697611570358276,
0.4103981852531433,
0.002802464412525296,
-0.1236930713057518,
-0.5320835113525391,
0.0761091560125351,
0.124000184237957,
0.019178003072738647,
0.39126378297805786,
-0.3599276542663574,
-0.6530418992042542,
0.049779750406742096,
-0.34663084149360657,
0.4541837275028229,
0.19704556465148926,
-0.6253760457038879,
0.5500203371047974,
0.1642308235168457,
-0.21280743181705475,
-0.568111002445221,
-0.31493204832077026,
-0.14494729042053223,
-0.25041037797927856,
-0.5589357614517212,
0.5238893032073975,
-0.07790286093950272,
-0.20027311146259308,
-0.17179523408412933,
-0.2582043409347534,
-0.07527036964893341,
0.20236565172672272,
-0.18329478800296783,
-0.06975457072257996,
0.04197157919406891,
0.2939625382423401,
0.5573634505271912,
0.005878516938537359,
-0.3554927706718445,
-0.15055979788303375,
0.3059324622154236,
0.13456866145133972,
-0.31505581736564636,
-0.5822212100028992,
0.1551087200641632,
0.763296365737915,
-0.4664681851863861,
0.6849236488342285,
0.5819709897041321,
-0.3171214163303375,
-0.16798344254493713,
-1.025148630142212,
-0.090920090675354,
-0.49931079149246216,
0.4027988612651825,
-0.47462722659111023,
-1.0790109634399414,
0.4486481845378876,
-0.5458711385726929,
0.24658560752868652,
0.39552828669548035,
0.17651869356632233,
-0.1920126974582672,
0.853367805480957,
0.5679170489311218,
0.0961657389998436,
0.8135684728622437,
0.000060285034123808146,
0.15999892354011536,
-0.9881051182746887,
-0.10944515466690063,
-0.5591102242469788,
-0.546443521976471,
-0.263984352350235,
-0.3714660406112671,
0.44634300470352173,
0.6067090034484863,
-0.2996855080127716,
0.2181033343076706,
-0.28468018770217896,
0.7157191038131714,
0.4854544401168823,
0.3409291207790375,
0.5058212876319885,
-0.28504711389541626,
-0.11666594445705414,
-0.0339830219745636,
-0.7874926328659058,
-0.3147099018096924,
1.1378746032714844,
0.2262232005596161,
0.7079196572303772,
0.027648216113448143,
0.3344951570034027,
-0.00048705804510973394,
-0.3225260078907013,
-0.5318652987480164,
0.47649869322776794,
-0.38028764724731445,
-0.35194048285484314,
-0.6791588664054871,
-0.34493592381477356,
-0.5516718029975891,
-0.29675859212875366,
-0.26215437054634094,
-0.5522372722625732,
0.28332456946372986,
0.4472399055957794,
-0.7911544442176819,
0.7292430400848389,
-1.0664259195327759,
0.764350950717926,
-0.0802057683467865,
-0.3903282582759857,
-0.28706830739974976,
-0.5283200144767761,
-0.10069327801465988,
-0.3854707181453705,
0.1038164421916008,
-0.20866261422634125,
-0.023219604045152664,
0.6594711542129517,
-0.5309814214706421,
0.5809791684150696,
-0.4904526174068451,
-0.10367451608181,
0.08328801393508911,
0.3305526375770569,
0.9025706648826599,
0.14361076056957245,
-0.2156960368156433,
0.023692162707448006,
0.2696445882320404,
-0.3986680805683136,
-0.7335232496261597,
0.7339580059051514,
-0.6196256279945374,
-0.5222289562225342,
0.17972508072853088,
-0.6265947818756104,
-0.6666771173477173,
0.20342005789279938,
0.00103572232183069,
0.4534539580345154,
0.14014612138271332,
0.22447416186332703,
0.8234573006629944,
-0.44072800874710083,
0.45586463809013367,
0.5941504240036011,
0.048921797424554825,
-0.020633364096283913,
0.48675262928009033,
0.45933905243873596,
0.3649991750717163,
0.7640196681022644,
0.2620494067668915,
-0.3135754466056824,
-0.7951970100402832,
-0.20120681822299957,
0.1935376077890396,
-0.43823105096817017,
-0.21840208768844604,
-0.810761570930481,
-0.06423518806695938,
-0.33720144629478455,
-0.38737890124320984,
-0.5366201400756836,
-0.6142452359199524,
-0.15253695845603943,
0.20465388894081116,
0.6302337050437927,
0.25159287452697754,
-0.12363145500421524,
0.4673570394515991,
-0.8314707279205322,
0.4791099727153778,
0.6894752979278564,
0.8743284344673157,
-0.12804852426052094,
-0.5300789475440979,
-0.3410376310348511,
-0.14916762709617615,
-0.16293230652809143,
-0.6823239326477051,
-0.2712758779525757,
0.3478460907936096,
0.3953649699687958,
0.1695401817560196,
0.04089817777276039,
0.9720150232315063,
-0.43303990364074707,
0.7118993401527405,
-0.43649694323539734,
-1.1047258377075195,
0.8412435054779053,
-0.3813352882862091,
0.7269029021263123,
0.5909180641174316,
0.14798274636268616,
-0.46195703744888306,
-0.4872744381427765,
-0.3557576835155487,
-0.7255407571792603,
0.49532365798950195,
-0.13687798380851746,
-0.07260822504758835,
0.2139413058757782,
0.8227298259735107,
0.19526439905166626,
0.08260221779346466,
-0.19576948881149292,
-0.07789506763219833,
0.263603538274765,
0.1198325902223587,
0.08696967363357544,
-0.6315577626228333,
0.19288668036460876,
-0.5479407906532288,
0.8762633204460144,
-0.08491634577512741,
0.007187789771705866,
0.26758813858032227,
-0.20744504034519196,
-0.228515163064003,
0.6600263118743896,
0.41459643840789795,
1.0294767618179321,
-0.2145192176103592,
0.04341178759932518,
0.7432779669761658,
-0.23689016699790955,
0.08110311627388,
0.17779405415058136,
-0.22764769196510315,
-0.1451570987701416,
0.27642086148262024,
0.47784802317619324,
0.29988256096839905,
-0.5126797556877136,
0.18924200534820557,
0.18106287717819214,
-0.1591983139514923,
0.11378540098667145,
0.3645961284637451,
0.014050261117517948,
0.6463421583175659,
-0.03818226233124733,
0.14305461943149567,
-0.10697028785943985,
-0.20772862434387207,
0.027064360678195953,
0.1924794316291809,
-0.012407357804477215,
-0.03970824182033539,
0.8612025380134583,
-0.00043721325346268713,
-0.24728260934352875,
0.6871536374092102,
-0.13839228451251984,
-0.31922900676727295,
0.07236166298389435,
0.10783584415912628,
0.5563296675682068,
-0.43218928575515747,
-0.11464383453130722,
0.32592087984085083,
0.22928151488304138,
0.14075973629951477,
0.3912811875343323,
0.06527888029813766,
-0.6680994033813477,
-0.8752492070198059,
-0.5279335379600525,
-0.177761048078537,
0.42711231112480164,
-0.3240894377231598,
0.3865419030189514,
-0.6038703322410583,
-0.20158135890960693,
0.09329161792993546,
0.01988760381937027,
-0.8738409280776978,
0.06527376174926758,
-0.31385311484336853,
0.9738261103630066,
-0.4583093225955963,
0.7162534594535828,
0.7622541189193726,
0.2001705765724182,
-0.9483339190483093,
-0.14550615847110748,
-0.1553911566734314,
-0.537043035030365,
0.28380995988845825,
-0.42178109288215637,
0.02564036287367344,
0.1294490098953247,
-0.4672483503818512,
-0.6652581691741943,
1.019600749015808,
0.6159189343452454,
-1.0546536445617676,
-0.2600785791873932,
-0.05482163652777672,
0.38227617740631104,
0.46404731273651123,
-0.15300080180168152,
0.8025482296943665,
0.5386414527893066,
-0.22326979041099548,
-1.173776626586914,
-0.011823941022157669,
0.02349969558417797,
-0.22620396316051483,
0.5582903027534485,
-0.8263902068138123,
0.5867483615875244,
-0.2639564871788025,
0.13755735754966736,
-0.1984756737947464,
0.2385398894548416,
0.111698679625988,
-0.023021528497338295,
0.7889958620071411,
0.7095942497253418,
0.784798800945282,
-0.12067638337612152,
0.6928872466087341,
-0.3356757164001465,
0.1401032954454422,
1.3692331314086914,
0.09357047826051712,
0.7080568075180054,
0.5587714314460754,
-0.18815471231937408,
0.1347571313381195,
0.5604937076568604,
0.11564789712429047,
0.5168952345848083,
-0.05773765966296196,
-0.237588569521904,
-0.5352535247802734,
-0.022538214921951294,
-0.4213135838508606,
0.4925501346588135,
0.06373241543769836,
-0.2307378649711609,
-0.18400993943214417,
-0.06408156454563141,
0.2805466949939728,
-0.04924086108803749,
-0.41939496994018555,
0.844425618648529,
-0.076210618019104,
-0.46373897790908813,
0.3142274022102356,
0.14280672371387482,
0.45632046461105347,
-0.5473346710205078,
-0.06769286096096039,
-0.198022723197937,
0.19706317782402039,
-0.08314726501703262,
-0.7513580322265625,
0.37833264470100403,
0.008271425031125546,
-0.2134215533733368,
-0.2826579213142395,
0.6879215240478516,
-0.41834452748298645,
-0.2934418022632599,
0.17509180307388306,
0.6539506316184998,
-0.23531565070152283,
-0.4748951196670532,
-0.57370924949646,
-0.047864895313978195,
-0.02346448227763176,
-0.3610411584377289,
0.17693385481834412,
0.7683897614479065,
-0.017167825251817703,
0.6321463584899902,
0.6841786503791809,
0.3413882255554199,
0.12372925877571106,
0.15393409132957458,
0.7149140238761902,
-0.6770588755607605,
-0.5259450078010559,
-0.87140953540802,
0.4427086114883423,
0.18162934482097626,
-0.27222940325737,
0.41506528854370117,
0.467134028673172,
0.9441841840744019,
-0.026714369654655457,
0.6019484400749207,
0.016341354697942734,
0.7037557363510132,
-0.8905346393585205,
0.869678258895874,
-0.5986400246620178,
0.3443901836872101,
-0.45166879892349243,
-1.0114506483078003,
-0.40149956941604614,
0.16531361639499664,
-0.38795480132102966,
-0.14818018674850464,
0.6075387001037598,
0.8160688877105713,
-0.08597881346940994,
-0.23778003454208374,
0.23073749244213104,
0.41749364137649536,
0.3801400065422058,
0.6758198142051697,
0.7669717073440552,
-0.31733736395835876,
0.5684371590614319,
-0.7245110869407654,
-0.0834910124540329,
0.014997178688645363,
-0.9984574913978577,
-0.8793016076087952,
-0.41948142647743225,
-0.5228872299194336,
0.03831924498081207,
0.28173840045928955,
0.8436592817306519,
0.7570561766624451,
-0.7676050662994385,
0.3456006944179535,
0.22295218706130981,
0.25537267327308655,
-0.4442601501941681,
-0.1998969167470932,
0.7257918119430542,
-0.3585147559642792,
-0.7113597989082336,
0.5607235431671143,
0.14218810200691223,
0.131513774394989,
0.24446652829647064,
0.21744173765182495,
-0.348018616437912,
-0.20039401948451996,
0.8873618841171265,
0.09919782727956772,
-0.4603942930698395,
-0.7702650427818298,
0.08577224612236023,
0.2981065511703491,
-0.08545277267694473,
0.5399085879325867,
-0.7849553823471069,
0.7019174098968506,
0.4474233388900757,
0.7765860557556152,
0.26132258772850037,
0.01470700278878212,
0.477731853723526,
-0.8498653173446655,
-0.16505685448646545,
0.0018049593782052398,
0.28172436356544495,
0.16071557998657227,
-0.6353769898414612,
0.4475504457950592,
0.15005695819854736,
-0.7449862360954285,
-0.6236247420310974,
-0.10614010691642761,
-0.9555509090423584,
-0.26595282554626465,
1.1149457693099976,
0.07512771338224411,
0.10182064771652222,
-0.19617323577404022,
-0.3820519745349884,
0.5267755389213562,
-0.20033997297286987,
0.9177606105804443,
0.6542739272117615,
-0.21034245193004608,
-0.12911219894886017,
-0.4721987843513489,
0.6110939979553223,
0.47910523414611816,
-0.8101718425750732,
0.1016165167093277,
0.45013856887817383,
0.566398024559021,
-0.25084570050239563,
0.4932888448238373,
-0.19853772222995758,
0.24283264577388763,
-0.45262137055397034,
-0.241303488612175,
-0.45146793127059937,
-0.45813700556755066,
-0.12911249697208405,
0.2419414073228836,
0.3663429617881775,
-0.1609002649784088
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.06610v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.06610v1
|
Reinterpreting 'the Company a Word Keeps': Towards Explainable and Ontologically Grounded Language Models
| 2024-06-06T20:38:35 | 2024-06-06T20:38:35 |
Walid S. Saba
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
We argue that the relative success of large language models (LLMs) is not a
reflection on the symbolic vs. subsymbolic debate but a reflection on employing
a successful bottom-up strategy of a reverse engineering of language at scale.
However, and due to their subsymbolic nature whatever knowledge these systems
acquire about language will always be buried in millions of weights none of
which is meaningful on its own, rendering such systems utterly unexplainable.
Furthermore, and due to their stochastic nature, LLMs will often fail in making
the correct inferences in various linguistic contexts that require reasoning in
intensional, temporal, or modal contexts. To remedy these shortcomings we
suggest employing the same successful bottom-up strategy employed in LLMs but
in a symbolic setting, resulting in explainable, language-agnostic, and
ontologically grounded language models.
|
[
0.026949303224682808,
-0.7148845791816711,
0.7497032284736633,
0.06482195854187012,
-0.31997978687286377,
0.34881091117858887,
-0.1916247010231018,
-0.15901730954647064,
0.45240873098373413,
0.5690920352935791,
-0.6890392303466797,
-0.11847905814647675,
-0.6882140040397644,
-0.06630002707242966,
-0.588783323764801,
0.966028094291687,
0.05252714082598686,
-0.017368581146001816,
-0.08134400099515915,
-0.38583651185035706,
-0.2247438281774521,
-0.6888848543167114,
-0.7986547946929932,
-0.7497684359550476,
0.34966200590133667,
0.33752724528312683,
1.3214302062988281,
0.8073837161064148,
0.03775820881128311,
0.22545859217643738,
-0.3960314691066742,
-0.35739386081695557,
-0.8554244041442871,
0.19339069724082947,
-0.34817275404930115,
-0.760400652885437,
0.20303966104984283,
0.1901783049106598,
0.6035498976707458,
1.1260628700256348,
-0.6776311993598938,
0.09834811091423035,
-0.175369530916214,
0.44907936453819275,
-0.380100280046463,
0.0505596324801445,
-0.8361970782279968,
-0.10962500423192978,
0.16109231114387512,
-0.2239355444908142,
-0.32906225323677063,
-0.30707186460494995,
0.010028151795268059,
-0.35772302746772766,
-0.07441432029008865,
0.38431140780448914,
1.1320865154266357,
-0.025029120966792107,
0.04213027283549309,
-0.38171812891960144,
-0.6715188026428223,
1.1550445556640625,
-0.6969565153121948,
0.5574793219566345,
0.47082623839378357,
0.14414082467556,
-0.24863305687904358,
-0.4367150366306305,
-0.6218419075012207,
-0.5335795283317566,
0.036693818867206573,
0.11723789572715759,
-0.3007676899433136,
-0.24150361120700836,
0.09321849793195724,
0.3116569221019745,
-0.1936749964952469,
0.3171825408935547,
-0.23162676393985748,
0.06648280471563339,
0.4631602168083191,
0.09217928349971771,
0.5234832763671875,
0.2170853465795517,
-0.5013665556907654,
0.10272406786680222,
-1.0077682733535767,
-0.021647963672876358,
0.09963565319776535,
0.11097963154315948,
0.1318153291940689,
0.5698726177215576,
0.04820922762155533,
-0.024502428248524666,
0.047106508165597916,
-0.20820558071136475,
-0.2235071361064911,
0.02773318439722061,
-0.38110220432281494,
0.46045079827308655,
0.46324628591537476,
0.10354210436344147,
0.5542899370193481,
-0.6940082907676697,
-0.2855016887187958,
0.44911879301071167,
0.49425041675567627,
-0.3428920805454254,
-0.2245233654975891,
0.32075485587120056,
-0.5310823917388916,
-0.32923340797424316,
-0.2178003489971161,
-0.20888815820217133,
-0.47642821073532104,
-0.37061652541160583,
0.23797394335269928,
-0.35267671942710876,
-0.4910687208175659,
0.11769764870405197,
-0.24962055683135986,
0.29052579402923584,
0.2526082396507263,
-0.9279322028160095,
0.2897535562515259,
0.93183833360672,
0.7953881621360779,
0.10570573061704636,
-0.33415162563323975,
-0.21325388550758362,
0.4227682054042816,
-0.9741734862327576,
0.4410252571105957,
-0.6300956010818481,
-0.6508339047431946,
0.09606800228357315,
0.19920675456523895,
0.17052683234214783,
-0.5039744973182678,
0.23866352438926697,
-0.4811455011367798,
0.32759854197502136,
-0.5808703303337097,
-0.48274898529052734,
-0.21113644540309906,
0.5551196932792664,
-0.20986641943454742,
0.6810356974601746,
-0.16156451404094696,
-0.6260187029838562,
0.4721114933490753,
-0.2973945140838623,
-0.13189968466758728,
0.11738305538892746,
-0.5210137367248535,
-0.11501190811395645,
0.6945844292640686,
-0.38075482845306396,
0.3009288012981415,
-0.5747706294059753,
0.4487961530685425,
-0.7302716374397278,
-0.29613810777664185,
0.4175482392311096,
-0.2592126131057739,
0.9972774982452393,
0.12856006622314453,
-0.24305638670921326,
-0.15045413374900818,
-0.6896672248840332,
-0.050841134041547775,
0.5433149337768555,
-0.21015684306621552,
-0.8372448682785034,
0.24382950365543365,
-0.29185378551483154,
0.38951921463012695,
0.2596982717514038,
-0.7219260931015015,
0.2619822919368744,
-0.6055086255073547,
0.5829777121543884,
0.9266146421432495,
-0.2411070317029953,
0.40398135781288147,
-0.25838378071784973,
0.7243669033050537,
-0.07425271719694138,
-0.06954611092805862,
-0.22525696456432343,
-0.27431389689445496,
-0.8248018026351929,
-0.29115960001945496,
-0.08560515940189362,
0.3312913179397583,
-0.4885033667087555,
0.09248718619346619,
-0.6583064794540405,
-0.46334099769592285,
-0.510718822479248,
0.008715799078345299,
0.46296969056129456,
0.24433930218219757,
0.0670214518904686,
-0.5898263454437256,
-0.3275914788246155,
-1.2119314670562744,
-0.46768155694007874,
-0.5602278709411621,
-0.03143148496747017,
0.044048331677913666,
0.4576749801635742,
-0.2942812442779541,
1.165484070777893,
-0.21518981456756592,
0.1931244432926178,
-0.45844587683677673,
0.11970981955528259,
0.35739022493362427,
0.23090043663978577,
0.39904600381851196,
-0.5642515420913696,
0.1699809432029724,
0.005166621413081884,
-1.0763955116271973,
-0.19177035987377167,
-0.07938702404499054,
-0.014859238639473915,
0.1772381067276001,
0.5453485250473022,
-0.8986528515815735,
0.26212838292121887,
0.531048059463501,
-0.5385428667068481,
0.5500767827033997,
-0.301523357629776,
-0.22841542959213257,
-1.122227430343628,
-0.031019367277622223,
-0.2950388491153717,
-0.10156326740980148,
-0.6721858382225037,
0.2406885176897049,
-0.1580657809972763,
-0.05172111093997955,
-0.2694210410118103,
0.6448211669921875,
-0.48200932145118713,
-0.22381819784641266,
-0.5354616641998291,
0.19769927859306335,
0.1441035270690918,
0.12634652853012085,
-0.052757252007722855,
0.5651698708534241,
0.5447854995727539,
-0.8210535645484924,
0.23931273818016052,
0.21591337025165558,
-0.2769746780395508,
0.6949726939201355,
-0.8087907433509827,
-0.2640306353569031,
-0.36096349358558655,
0.08514606207609177,
-1.24610435962677,
0.19128556549549103,
0.08190040290355682,
-0.15878818929195404,
0.4345279932022095,
-0.026889028027653694,
-0.5634692311286926,
-0.1717485934495926,
-0.07236698269844055,
-0.05748501047492027,
0.6956223845481873,
-0.6704130172729492,
0.4225625991821289,
0.5524179339408875,
-0.3404224216938019,
-0.34388935565948486,
-1.2722238302230835,
0.49318546056747437,
-0.4044747054576874,
-0.5684780478477478,
0.05541345104575157,
0.24949650466442108,
-0.7990244626998901,
0.1757250875234604,
-0.5637533068656921,
0.0003177644102834165,
0.37527230381965637,
0.19913847744464874,
-0.08932202309370041,
-0.19472278654575348,
0.44411084055900574,
-0.16722068190574646,
-0.2172779142856598,
0.39404046535491943,
-0.4768405258655548,
0.28931400179862976,
-0.22085578739643097,
-0.29456576704978943,
-0.2643086910247803,
0.14309045672416687,
0.7595969438552856,
0.18820732831954956,
1.2394380569458008,
-0.05633481964468956,
-0.44623345136642456,
-0.2101728916168213,
-0.48615047335624695,
-0.14326943457126617,
-0.4401508867740631,
0.21599875390529633,
-0.4673006534576416,
-0.7541463375091553,
0.5843673348426819,
-0.27888092398643494,
0.08271663635969162,
0.5584337711334229,
0.56093430519104,
-0.18568822741508484,
0.8363085389137268,
0.9369284510612488,
-0.28211039304733276,
0.034414708614349365,
-0.13847193121910095,
0.7997205853462219,
-0.29230812191963196,
-0.15590763092041016,
-0.4562671482563019,
-0.04467285796999931,
-0.533696174621582,
0.1920633763074875,
-0.03338328376412392,
0.34258002042770386,
-0.2323949635028839,
0.39731884002685547,
-0.12707845866680145,
0.35987043380737305,
0.3036464750766754,
-0.4573829472064972,
0.3828291893005371,
0.04895046353340149,
-0.4059693515300751,
-0.01584947295486927,
-0.8859943747520447,
-1.0765528678894043,
0.41772952675819397,
0.6544767022132874,
1.1480777263641357,
0.2992641031742096,
0.518130362033844,
0.08847425132989883,
0.5730425715446472,
-0.667938232421875,
0.5771787166595459,
-0.06007303670048714,
-0.6612564325332642,
-0.33785033226013184,
-0.23352207243442535,
-0.9515653252601624,
0.4861030876636505,
0.004754964727908373,
-1.0198198556900024,
0.0873454213142395,
0.2461172342300415,
0.07935009151697159,
0.3434544503688812,
-0.5752010345458984,
0.7799235582351685,
-0.3135320246219635,
-0.45362839102745056,
-0.37334105372428894,
-0.37664595246315,
0.47477638721466064,
-0.23576702177524567,
0.6515671014785767,
-0.16076500713825226,
-0.1709606796503067,
0.7939811944961548,
-0.654094398021698,
1.003361701965332,
0.14316745102405548,
-0.6763858199119568,
0.15784572064876556,
0.4083858132362366,
0.5721392035484314,
-0.10795675218105316,
-0.0804973691701889,
0.39044076204299927,
0.2853850722312927,
-0.4341762661933899,
-0.6698629260063171,
0.759917676448822,
-0.39881259202957153,
-0.8097721934318542,
-0.42164716124534607,
-0.3324854373931885,
-0.2206450253725052,
0.0987689197063446,
0.06496946513652802,
0.35780447721481323,
-0.19245825707912445,
0.49844247102737427,
0.5360478162765503,
-0.35672762989997864,
0.35295969247817993,
0.5843822360038757,
-0.34010112285614014,
-0.18423669040203094,
0.6229971051216125,
0.3808784782886505,
0.30001965165138245,
0.20284859836101532,
0.6557735800743103,
-0.47144463658332825,
-0.057604506611824036,
-0.27182671427726746,
0.3070082366466522,
-0.8588107228279114,
0.3303605616092682,
-0.6115447282791138,
0.07014808058738708,
-0.17618732154369354,
-0.36598777770996094,
-0.6895720362663269,
-0.47687065601348877,
-0.04192105308175087,
-0.09825166314840317,
0.21778680384159088,
0.784483790397644,
0.2878623902797699,
0.4053853154182434,
-0.7218524217605591,
0.18792133033275604,
0.0265663992613554,
0.33788836002349854,
-0.04096290469169617,
-0.9289692044258118,
-0.3081568777561188,
0.180190309882164,
-0.04746388643980026,
-0.8251519203186035,
0.34428322315216064,
-0.08463185280561447,
0.746330738067627,
0.4880889356136322,
-0.13429665565490723,
0.6465042233467102,
-0.5263760685920715,
0.9420053958892822,
0.421207457780838,
-1.0584079027175903,
0.3141346275806427,
-0.22207355499267578,
0.4839702546596527,
0.381710410118103,
0.6518283486366272,
-0.7031731009483337,
-0.6843900680541992,
-1.056588053703308,
-0.9947870373725891,
0.7026445865631104,
0.14413300156593323,
0.42585283517837524,
-0.17993955314159393,
0.39620035886764526,
0.05750904232263565,
0.6799255013465881,
-0.6550526022911072,
-0.06956284493207932,
0.039959896355867386,
-0.2057296335697174,
-0.2850039005279541,
-0.6274510025978088,
-0.08375299721956253,
0.2044999748468399,
0.9072133898735046,
0.2343997061252594,
-0.04532237723469734,
-0.07802474498748779,
-0.08948447555303574,
-0.1988736093044281,
0.4372963607311249,
0.4297885000705719,
1.0765857696533203,
0.10871502012014389,
0.5856346487998962,
0.09970083087682724,
-0.2697443962097168,
0.18046049773693085,
-0.42684733867645264,
-0.29052263498306274,
-0.014695086516439915,
0.46203961968421936,
0.6599940657615662,
0.5247225761413574,
-0.7857317924499512,
0.17475245893001556,
0.3566068708896637,
-0.2520478665828705,
-0.4613051414489746,
-0.24646009504795074,
0.33068448305130005,
0.2570308744907379,
0.3010355234146118,
-0.45899590849876404,
-0.3188653290271759,
-1.1563682556152344,
0.1757531762123108,
0.5448682308197021,
-0.41596925258636475,
-0.4298483431339264,
0.6967476010322571,
-0.3653317987918854,
-0.24966920912265778,
0.4679296314716339,
-0.10540800541639328,
-0.7368654608726501,
0.4405287802219391,
0.6462305188179016,
1.1386351585388184,
-0.20551997423171997,
-0.009588629938662052,
-0.08940857648849487,
0.7622606158256531,
-0.5569421052932739,
0.19979889690876007,
0.2996388375759125,
-0.9081938862800598,
-0.32889774441719055,
-0.6822372078895569,
-0.6799247860908508,
0.26005128026008606,
-0.3095264434814453,
0.013813682831823826,
-0.6370001435279846,
-0.08379500359296799,
-0.16443763673305511,
-0.31984075903892517,
-0.19445879757404327,
0.4657469093799591,
-0.007091553416103125,
0.7792972326278687,
-0.8899255990982056,
0.6488242149353027,
0.6654236912727356,
-0.5735098123550415,
-0.5592455267906189,
0.161203071475029,
-0.12743587791919708,
-1.0444326400756836,
0.9274678230285645,
0.2015172690153122,
-0.3839266896247864,
-0.12699894607067108,
-0.6186535954475403,
-1.1678425073623657,
0.8130014538764954,
0.48023197054862976,
-0.45362842082977295,
0.1400388926267624,
-0.0818932056427002,
0.7749801278114319,
-0.3731555938720703,
-0.11002696305513382,
0.4915753901004791,
0.2823317050933838,
0.1339585930109024,
-0.7525407075881958,
0.18248027563095093,
-0.0015324450796470046,
0.3048095405101776,
0.0752149298787117,
-0.6063498258590698,
0.5636640787124634,
-0.2041916698217392,
-0.5799585580825806,
-0.07476039975881577,
0.4370528757572174,
0.35713985562324524,
0.2703703045845032,
0.4811975359916687,
0.7605905532836914,
0.5636078119277954,
-0.062340956181287766,
1.3536746501922607,
-0.4916697144508362,
0.38630571961402893,
0.9678653478622437,
-0.3724815249443054,
0.7841601967811584,
0.7512294054031372,
-0.17750641703605652,
0.44708770513534546,
0.3574914038181305,
-0.0072684334591031075,
0.43250954151153564,
0.6223277449607849,
0.14771300554275513,
-0.44597169756889343,
-0.2499045580625534,
-0.08775650709867477,
0.6318922638893127,
0.32612091302871704,
-0.5157288312911987,
-0.20544472336769104,
-0.3195927143096924,
0.09884898364543915,
0.16282379627227783,
-0.23007315397262573,
0.4434617757797241,
0.4889273941516876,
-0.5684395432472229,
0.7546515464782715,
0.26219549775123596,
0.29897379875183105,
-0.6247350573539734,
0.24619288742542267,
-0.15610477328300476,
0.23018129169940948,
0.06958572566509247,
-0.511361837387085,
0.6921324133872986,
-0.11496539413928986,
-0.009456789121031761,
-0.6429831981658936,
0.704707682132721,
-0.6276304721832275,
-0.3991389274597168,
0.2877512276172638,
0.5494359135627747,
0.30534517765045166,
0.1419144570827484,
-0.6165046095848083,
0.12294210493564606,
-0.36833393573760986,
-0.6506428718566895,
0.1485883742570877,
0.6329480409622192,
-0.10958661884069443,
1.0701175928115845,
0.5070385932922363,
0.032065123319625854,
-0.18327786028385162,
-0.010031322948634624,
0.54957515001297,
-0.9429107308387756,
-0.7712109088897705,
-1.0329056978225708,
0.1964847445487976,
0.0724010244011879,
-0.09763767570257187,
1.020642638206482,
0.34328562021255493,
0.6784722805023193,
-0.1222042366862297,
0.8144334554672241,
0.18935883045196533,
0.32237187027931213,
-0.561646580696106,
0.7740902304649353,
-0.7731666564941406,
0.47176292538642883,
-0.18900351226329803,
-0.957261323928833,
-0.07630003243684769,
0.8364368081092834,
-0.43153831362724304,
0.18232768774032593,
0.6576255559921265,
0.511816143989563,
-0.0899159163236618,
0.19401226937770844,
0.6965911388397217,
0.8073328137397766,
0.11859200149774551,
-0.03293386474251747,
1.1157406568527222,
-0.1354273110628128,
0.2696360647678375,
0.212288498878479,
-0.18603917956352234,
-0.16630487143993378,
-1.0587475299835205,
-0.5682398080825806,
-0.09099210798740387,
-0.6399123668670654,
-0.5541345477104187,
0.16004027426242828,
0.7278099060058594,
0.348470002412796,
-0.6599182486534119,
-0.349957138299942,
-0.38593050837516785,
0.009803990833461285,
-0.1254197508096695,
-0.14352959394454956,
-0.031989920884370804,
-0.42931583523750305,
-0.3738958537578583,
0.41840896010398865,
0.7295621633529663,
-0.10187797993421555,
-0.6258967518806458,
-0.13408783078193665,
-0.20881623029708862,
0.5442357659339905,
0.7976369857788086,
0.42438027262687683,
-1.0991624593734741,
-0.3278859257698059,
-0.2057601660490036,
-0.10215609520673752,
-0.3161148726940155,
0.5515121817588806,
-0.4732878506183624,
0.4051133990287781,
0.36971813440322876,
0.8911955952644348,
0.021271483972668648,
-0.05786224454641342,
0.6856657862663269,
-0.49437415599823,
-0.059774503111839294,
-0.11670096963644028,
0.6267955899238586,
0.4515622854232788,
-0.07903861254453659,
0.6642331480979919,
0.5918741226196289,
-0.24148163199424744,
-0.9009362459182739,
0.4108855426311493,
-0.6234539747238159,
-0.5065600872039795,
1.3347586393356323,
-0.17648309469223022,
-0.28927186131477356,
-0.08266468346118927,
0.14122313261032104,
0.15508702397346497,
0.045373037457466125,
0.9848431944847107,
0.9520689249038696,
0.28136003017425537,
-0.0557468943297863,
-0.45872142910957336,
0.08384391665458679,
0.6576544046401978,
-0.36342567205429077,
0.30326440930366516,
0.3121068775653839,
0.4831749200820923,
0.41511839628219604,
0.7653141617774963,
-0.12584173679351807,
-0.2619163691997528,
0.19004876911640167,
0.11075643450021744,
0.2114214450120926,
-0.3173477351665497,
-0.5282844305038452,
0.2417089343070984,
0.325790137052536,
-0.04274386167526245
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.04493v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.04493v1
|
CORU: Comprehensive Post-OCR Parsing and Receipt Understanding Dataset
| 2024-06-06T20:38:15 | 2024-06-06T20:38:15 |
Abdelrahman Abdallah, Mahmoud Abdalla, Mahmoud SalahEldin Kasem, Mohamed Mahmoud, Ibrahim Abdelhalim, Mohamed Elkasaby, Yasser ElBendary, Adam Jatowt
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
In the fields of Optical Character Recognition (OCR) and Natural Language
Processing (NLP), integrating multilingual capabilities remains a critical
challenge, especially when considering languages with complex scripts such as
Arabic. This paper introduces the Comprehensive Post-OCR Parsing and Receipt
Understanding Dataset (CORU), a novel dataset specifically designed to enhance
OCR and information extraction from receipts in multilingual contexts involving
Arabic and English. CORU consists of over 20,000 annotated receipts from
diverse retail settings, including supermarkets and clothing stores, alongside
30,000 annotated images for OCR that were utilized to recognize each detected
line, and 10,000 items annotated for detailed information extraction. These
annotations capture essential details such as merchant names, item
descriptions, total prices, receipt numbers, and dates. They are structured to
support three primary computational tasks: object detection, OCR, and
information extraction. We establish the baseline performance for a range of
models on CORU to evaluate the effectiveness of traditional methods, like
Tesseract OCR, and more advanced neural network-based approaches. These
baselines are crucial for processing the complex and noisy document layouts
typical of real-world receipts and for advancing the state of automated
multilingual document processing. Our datasets are publicly accessible
(https://github.com/Update-For-Integrated-Business-AI/CORU).
|
[
-0.3155903220176697,
-0.5312095284461975,
0.16341961920261383,
0.023764222860336304,
-0.34233739972114563,
0.18591374158859253,
-0.04034338891506195,
-1.0220812559127808,
-0.1475023329257965,
0.4709983170032501,
-0.3708314299583435,
-0.5180411338806152,
-0.5657787919044495,
0.4550813138484955,
-0.2210952788591385,
1.0060293674468994,
-0.1436125934123993,
0.2864527106285095,
-0.10867378860712051,
-0.485765278339386,
-0.4081104099750519,
-0.774170994758606,
-0.5671980381011963,
-0.11293353140354156,
0.43310099840164185,
0.5793060064315796,
0.3083072602748871,
0.3737497329711914,
0.46085062623023987,
0.20350885391235352,
0.21091018617153168,
0.4905454218387604,
-0.11165620386600494,
-0.08435816317796707,
-0.18470802903175354,
-0.14439578354358673,
-0.6058505177497864,
-0.29227888584136963,
0.527925968170166,
0.5884873867034912,
-0.12422500550746918,
0.25684309005737305,
0.21559175848960876,
0.571030855178833,
-0.7734022736549377,
0.24239476025104523,
-0.16182532906532288,
-0.011720310896635056,
-0.31849879026412964,
-0.1456485539674759,
-0.5429354906082153,
-0.41470861434936523,
-0.00498422933742404,
-0.6804627180099487,
0.09630412608385086,
0.053768232464790344,
1.0727002620697021,
-0.04764030501246452,
-0.3216066062450409,
-0.9240919351577759,
-0.5376586318016052,
0.7173333168029785,
-0.2205929160118103,
0.8267078995704651,
0.724857747554779,
0.2952181100845337,
-0.055991753935813904,
-0.7616806030273438,
-0.3944500982761383,
0.2192060500383377,
-0.3631212115287781,
0.19966137409210205,
-0.212672159075737,
-0.2943117022514343,
0.055816564708948135,
0.5520326495170593,
-0.5374987125396729,
-0.09601497650146484,
-0.1864759773015976,
-0.3264588713645935,
0.3249114453792572,
-0.04386758804321289,
0.48248156905174255,
-0.04970201104879379,
-0.4849752187728882,
-0.18097303807735443,
-0.4416489005088806,
0.3735843002796173,
0.3794708251953125,
0.2038302719593048,
-0.4081890285015106,
0.4115481376647949,
-0.08728408068418503,
1.0818331241607666,
-0.3263101875782013,
-0.23529189825057983,
0.21304376423358917,
-0.7772026658058167,
-0.2873561382293701,
0.43536362051963806,
0.6634585857391357,
-0.12762434780597687,
0.036562297493219376,
-0.12527398765087128,
-0.083580881357193,
-0.19600217044353485,
-0.19144393503665924,
-0.6499297618865967,
-0.05202006176114082,
0.15198229253292084,
-0.5159927010536194,
0.01712246797978878,
0.25752589106559753,
-0.8622184991836548,
-0.421217143535614,
-0.5171439051628113,
-0.12571574747562408,
-0.434378057718277,
-0.15059006214141846,
0.4264812767505646,
-0.1798517405986786,
0.20242834091186523,
0.7156564593315125,
-0.6840751767158508,
0.45019403100013733,
0.45732080936431885,
0.8993363380432129,
0.2663082778453827,
-0.12046921998262405,
-0.9006657600402832,
0.25585272908210754,
-0.17839427292346954,
1.0109869241714478,
-0.42614299058914185,
-0.04083112254738808,
-0.1127275824546814,
-0.1652803272008896,
-0.21541082859039307,
-0.5445713400840759,
0.8562389612197876,
-0.6653800010681152,
0.10215005278587341,
-0.38603782653808594,
-0.08346255123615265,
-0.3751765787601471,
0.6267939805984497,
-1.2041417360305786,
0.7787373661994934,
0.26069799065589905,
-0.7697891592979431,
0.3710910975933075,
-0.7389424443244934,
-0.6901815533638,
0.410169780254364,
-0.29307377338409424,
-0.30940014123916626,
-0.05127008259296417,
0.3673050105571747,
0.3080442249774933,
-0.3082975447177887,
0.30964383482933044,
0.062375787645578384,
-0.32882145047187805,
0.0528210885822773,
-0.4377756416797638,
0.960511326789856,
0.5921252369880676,
-0.04260848090052605,
0.042872387915849686,
-1.0134130716323853,
-0.31036967039108276,
-0.10548987239599228,
-0.5143141150474548,
-0.43566933274269104,
-0.20423877239227295,
0.5803971886634827,
0.03602328151464462,
0.7855902314186096,
-0.6163253784179688,
0.11612329632043839,
0.01032951194792986,
0.5069929361343384,
0.27854472398757935,
-0.3474684953689575,
0.3536373972892761,
-0.010552913881838322,
0.39959394931793213,
-0.04527926817536354,
0.11297141760587692,
-0.3603877127170563,
-0.30166319012641907,
-0.40515679121017456,
-0.6019061207771301,
0.27940475940704346,
0.7116667628288269,
-0.6902241110801697,
0.3781740665435791,
-0.3199782073497772,
-0.20764324069023132,
-0.26281386613845825,
0.031034093350172043,
0.33952099084854126,
0.5772281885147095,
0.3508421778678894,
-0.15901508927345276,
-0.8331693410873413,
-0.5835937857627869,
-0.21539415419101715,
-0.1623253971338272,
0.14570143818855286,
0.43297678232192993,
0.35301825404167175,
-0.2136375606060028,
0.6734486818313599,
-0.24337296187877655,
-0.7794873714447021,
-0.4389278292655945,
0.294902503490448,
0.4858493506908417,
0.4157540202140808,
0.26557549834251404,
-0.899859607219696,
-0.32218173146247864,
0.6396351456642151,
-0.831713080406189,
0.23374366760253906,
-0.17090749740600586,
-0.23068159818649292,
0.6084194183349609,
0.524075448513031,
-0.09321960061788559,
0.7033684253692627,
0.4463629722595215,
-0.6646566390991211,
0.5252060890197754,
-0.37013375759124756,
0.2069672793149948,
-1.0865166187286377,
0.33274969458580017,
-0.08449297398328781,
-0.4354812204837799,
-0.3967231810092926,
0.14129042625427246,
0.34998029470443726,
-0.013804956339299679,
-0.29060661792755127,
0.31826841831207275,
-0.6641333103179932,
-0.2870081067085266,
0.21779687702655792,
-0.3631756007671356,
0.6079806089401245,
0.2865377962589264,
0.5054321885108948,
0.9654368162155151,
-0.04908699169754982,
-0.5295469760894775,
0.10642284899950027,
0.4457741975784302,
-0.9244120121002197,
0.6326633095741272,
-0.40762123465538025,
0.21516002714633942,
-0.11482058465480804,
0.012816913425922394,
-1.0591952800750732,
-0.17554670572280884,
0.48577582836151123,
-0.28087374567985535,
0.14694556593894958,
-0.12184851616621017,
-0.6228212714195251,
0.053911928087472916,
0.02640634775161743,
0.663402795791626,
-0.1398356556892395,
-0.5631880760192871,
0.9177585244178772,
0.16911709308624268,
-0.335911363363266,
-0.6201342940330505,
-0.6857104301452637,
0.344116747379303,
0.15763233602046967,
-0.5672498345375061,
0.13929034769535065,
0.19828490912914276,
-0.1502559930086136,
-0.04447084665298462,
0.19882038235664368,
-0.3578220009803772,
0.19295763969421387,
-0.2627294063568115,
0.11864882707595825,
-0.3065541684627533,
-0.2518155574798584,
0.1589706689119339,
-0.02889513224363327,
-0.28806552290916443,
-0.18150542676448822,
1.0240864753723145,
-0.27464520931243896,
-0.0951906368136406,
-0.5970965027809143,
0.5650275945663452,
0.4184670150279999,
-0.628365159034729,
0.5776998400688171,
0.9001914262771606,
-0.5444122552871704,
0.5969948172569275,
-0.41314497590065,
0.5038554072380066,
-0.3722177743911743,
0.47741827368736267,
-0.8251470327377319,
-0.5148192048072815,
0.6963320970535278,
0.2703075110912323,
-0.11283911764621735,
0.4082464277744293,
0.38264620304107666,
0.0415666326880455,
0.6099879145622253,
0.3857361972332001,
-0.10297273099422455,
0.5260874032974243,
-0.3164789378643036,
0.30104172229766846,
-0.8157287240028381,
-0.8167976140975952,
-0.8849126696586609,
0.030652767047286034,
0.06994716823101044,
-0.16842034459114075,
0.1208922266960144,
0.24427959322929382,
0.05750826373696327,
0.359022319316864,
-0.211796373128891,
0.41372743248939514,
0.5690422654151917,
0.23594141006469727,
0.5605278611183167,
0.4412844777107239,
0.16871240735054016,
0.2892371714115143,
-0.46582552790641785,
-0.5517421960830688,
0.691845178604126,
0.20963096618652344,
0.5263404250144958,
0.28618037700653076,
0.6024224758148193,
0.45051178336143494,
-0.016546614468097687,
-0.9473373889923096,
0.09763599932193756,
-0.285858154296875,
-0.14101651310920715,
-0.23681749403476715,
-0.21899640560150146,
-1.0224484205245972,
0.041174501180648804,
0.13694654405117035,
-0.6676152348518372,
0.8312533497810364,
-0.11442672461271286,
-0.46325361728668213,
0.19911015033721924,
-0.6833347082138062,
0.9426497220993042,
-0.28599822521209717,
-0.47487547993659973,
-0.027547748759388924,
-0.3886391818523407,
-0.10186029970645905,
0.06874649226665497,
0.5783033967018127,
0.06794984638690948,
-0.21335464715957642,
0.8805988430976868,
-0.5099480748176575,
0.49192938208580017,
-0.10375296324491501,
-0.31478050351142883,
0.23296214640140533,
0.048510100692510605,
0.36525198817253113,
-0.011090854182839394,
-0.4639420807361603,
0.6884476542472839,
0.40481990575790405,
-0.486485093832016,
-0.3512033522129059,
0.15307986736297607,
-0.7248057723045349,
0.09130575507879257,
-0.6241925954818726,
-0.6799117922782898,
0.25931861996650696,
0.5847512483596802,
0.4126131534576416,
0.8212500810623169,
-0.38692426681518555,
0.01611325889825821,
0.2766161561012268,
-0.2122351974248886,
0.4105951189994812,
0.21681061387062073,
0.008055849932134151,
-0.7032333016395569,
0.9085473418235779,
0.22908233106136322,
-0.22681273519992828,
0.6076027154922485,
0.1621571183204651,
-0.6723856925964355,
-0.5934998989105225,
-1.1630244255065918,
-0.17762137949466705,
-0.658149778842926,
-0.34478989243507385,
-0.6164589524269104,
0.2570904791355133,
-0.5624902844429016,
0.0584733709692955,
0.09061329066753387,
-0.002205326920375228,
-0.5087396502494812,
0.14215178787708282,
0.2704572379589081,
1.1299643516540527,
0.0661030262708664,
0.16218158602714539,
-1.115840196609497,
0.3543379008769989,
-0.22638876736164093,
0.41999930143356323,
0.3156510293483734,
-0.279581755399704,
-0.7101606726646423,
0.07663049548864365,
0.1976204663515091,
-0.727231502532959,
0.44491949677467346,
0.28139835596084595,
0.25582948327064514,
0.6906028985977173,
0.021879520267248154,
1.0321531295776367,
-0.2665138840675354,
0.5278292894363403,
0.20471800863742828,
-1.0075985193252563,
0.22989557683467865,
-0.44197988510131836,
0.25328102707862854,
0.7369483113288879,
0.45041927695274353,
-0.548681378364563,
0.0983380600810051,
-0.0846339762210846,
-0.772369921207428,
1.0614567995071411,
0.05184909701347351,
-0.2416531890630722,
0.112937793135643,
0.1807563602924347,
0.5833879113197327,
0.19250845909118652,
-0.3266812264919281,
-0.005048131104558706,
-0.14377066493034363,
-0.6564220190048218,
-0.10919740051031113,
-0.6288198828697205,
0.1419650912284851,
-0.40025246143341064,
0.1992613971233368,
0.13088245689868927,
0.18836744129657745,
0.4259841740131378,
-0.5798662900924683,
0.3472260534763336,
0.2172892838716507,
0.6731232404708862,
0.6954856514930725,
-0.3994143009185791,
0.0468265637755394,
-0.19948072731494904,
-1.080603837966919,
0.13186095654964447,
0.20861034095287323,
0.052031129598617554,
-0.11632677167654037,
0.6838999390602112,
0.5368291139602661,
-0.09713612496852875,
-0.7518059611320496,
0.33555445075035095,
-0.5242496728897095,
-0.08815199881792068,
-0.7561702132225037,
-0.45697861909866333,
-0.4690239727497101,
0.02875077910721302,
0.4733731150627136,
0.42488574981689453,
0.6311847567558289,
-0.6867237687110901,
0.19114603102207184,
0.01731269061565399,
-0.19743016362190247,
-0.27461013197898865,
0.11285560578107834,
-0.025586295872926712,
-0.458970844745636,
0.7527796030044556,
-0.3983222246170044,
-0.46500328183174133,
0.5852775573730469,
0.5835004448890686,
0.4595479965209961,
-0.0816115215420723,
0.17963099479675293,
0.45202696323394775,
0.1428539752960205,
-0.04121434688568115,
0.6658629775047302,
-0.6837605237960815,
-0.7872250080108643,
-0.3289911448955536,
-0.6471771597862244,
-0.3804587423801422,
0.03210688382387161,
-1.154975175857544,
0.2906758785247803,
-0.5301603078842163,
0.3120713531970978,
-0.3056582808494568,
0.06233079731464386,
-0.8776638507843018,
0.23510976135730743,
-0.04448183625936508,
0.700132429599762,
-0.7379765510559082,
0.8596641421318054,
0.7380446791648865,
-0.44369274377822876,
-0.6777294278144836,
-0.29602935910224915,
-0.4480912387371063,
-0.8850655555725098,
0.691735029220581,
0.3653092384338379,
-0.3048185110092163,
-0.14058905839920044,
0.044346097856760025,
-0.8147013783454895,
0.707849383354187,
0.45769885182380676,
-0.8589306473731995,
0.02463820017874241,
0.404617577791214,
0.36594536900520325,
-0.188141331076622,
0.4426986277103424,
0.7449114918708801,
0.5394224524497986,
0.14527474343776703,
-0.5802263021469116,
-0.006266564596444368,
-0.6169472932815552,
-0.47045207023620605,
0.0718667060136795,
-0.2989955246448517,
0.9346319437026978,
0.03464103862643242,
-0.20335668325424194,
0.5182923078536987,
0.3414839804172516,
0.18466298282146454,
0.6618009209632874,
0.41147539019584656,
0.695176362991333,
1.2260524034500122,
-0.0069575123488903046,
1.093475341796875,
-0.0959262102842331,
-0.17992046475410461,
1.232407808303833,
-0.26483649015426636,
1.0192134380340576,
0.39823293685913086,
-0.06618311256170273,
0.9537819027900696,
0.7134459018707275,
0.20627935230731964,
0.3805886507034302,
-0.23701320588588715,
-0.28390657901763916,
-0.16583387553691864,
-0.5078002214431763,
-0.4133809208869934,
0.6504324674606323,
0.5177457928657532,
-0.24898578226566315,
-0.3184796869754791,
0.17101189494132996,
-0.0748944953083992,
-0.03607778996229172,
-0.43834802508354187,
1.0666128396987915,
-0.15100878477096558,
-0.3355885446071625,
0.4735983610153198,
-0.11491267383098602,
0.3741692900657654,
-0.3958863914012909,
-0.31619375944137573,
-0.10131248086690903,
0.4020989239215851,
-0.5063415765762329,
-0.5763051509857178,
0.47736644744873047,
0.13744863867759705,
-0.2860468327999115,
-0.08590417355298996,
0.6837551593780518,
-0.3553130030632019,
-0.7772176265716553,
0.3640178143978119,
0.26147451996803284,
0.379430890083313,
-0.1356787532567978,
-0.41939297318458557,
0.4020862281322479,
-0.08969808369874954,
0.11391458660364151,
0.18566741049289703,
0.4236544072628021,
-0.14423444867134094,
-0.019691113382577896,
0.6598617434501648,
-0.031132595613598824,
-0.1753925085067749,
0.39755573868751526,
0.47558027505874634,
-0.5914002656936646,
-0.8019282221794128,
-1.0130587816238403,
0.3224124014377594,
-0.08132113516330719,
-0.11992433667182922,
0.6774182915687561,
1.0719691514968872,
1.040607213973999,
0.0016365533228963614,
0.8092194199562073,
0.10720837861299515,
0.1737600862979889,
-0.639529824256897,
0.8131940960884094,
-0.737179160118103,
-0.048619113862514496,
-0.3815460205078125,
-0.5800061821937561,
-0.4514060616493225,
0.7917233109474182,
-0.3977597653865814,
-0.3163091838359833,
0.49918755888938904,
0.41187870502471924,
-0.1200636550784111,
0.2355298399925232,
0.09559787064790726,
-0.17392569780349731,
0.21328173577785492,
0.6648948788642883,
0.8239960074424744,
-0.7700871825218201,
0.6384778618812561,
-0.014583054929971695,
-0.08225088566541672,
-0.20894132554531097,
-0.7031029462814331,
-0.8239655494689941,
-0.6528668999671936,
-0.043771933764219284,
-0.40126919746398926,
-0.17288334667682648,
0.7458274364471436,
0.5938857197761536,
-0.9827800393104553,
-0.6264324188232422,
-0.22727467119693756,
0.28410661220550537,
-0.17928412556648254,
-0.1523682028055191,
0.6304799318313599,
-0.23027724027633667,
-0.820383608341217,
0.15941299498081207,
0.3187685012817383,
0.04053739830851555,
0.181031733751297,
-0.18882204592227936,
-0.36375775933265686,
-0.4003373086452484,
0.7947372198104858,
0.1764497458934784,
-0.2735484540462494,
0.20567923784255981,
0.03363056480884552,
0.08610817044973373,
0.36633360385894775,
0.7646755576133728,
-0.5531514883041382,
0.4390729069709778,
0.6709991693496704,
0.644382655620575,
0.3327862620353699,
-0.09024067223072052,
0.5347431898117065,
-0.35803502798080444,
0.5324304699897766,
0.08672372251749039,
0.6032035946846008,
0.3975045382976532,
-0.7299522757530212,
0.3557925522327423,
0.1672678291797638,
0.027511535212397575,
-0.899919867515564,
0.40671995282173157,
-0.9646310210227966,
-0.2827261686325073,
0.6924771070480347,
-0.45690828561782837,
-0.49642035365104675,
-0.869304358959198,
-0.43783459067344666,
0.43168342113494873,
-0.6066388487815857,
0.37231531739234924,
0.5894571542739868,
0.05724719166755676,
-0.30227863788604736,
0.1844337284564972,
0.15688163042068481,
0.2211645394563675,
-0.7527480721473694,
-0.007418307941406965,
0.4463689923286438,
0.025339119136333466,
0.2463437020778656,
0.7692002654075623,
-0.3727319538593292,
0.48810043931007385,
0.00012261670781299472,
0.160004660487175,
-0.5192685127258301,
-0.6085419654846191,
-0.5720548629760742,
0.389263778924942,
0.10866434872150421,
-0.25055500864982605
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.04482v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.04482v1
|
Automatic Bug Detection in LLM-Powered Text-Based Games Using LLMs
| 2024-06-06T20:11:08 | 2024-06-06T20:11:08 |
Claire Jin, Sudha Rao, Xiangyu Peng, Portia Botchway, Jessica Quaye, Chris Brockett, Bill Dolan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC, cs.SE
|
Advancements in large language models (LLMs) are revolutionizing interactive
game design, enabling dynamic plotlines and interactions between players and
non-player characters (NPCs). However, LLMs may exhibit flaws such as
hallucinations, forgetfulness, or misinterpretations of prompts, causing
logical inconsistencies and unexpected deviations from intended designs.
Automated techniques for detecting such game bugs are still lacking. To address
this, we propose a systematic LLM-based method for automatically identifying
such bugs from player game logs, eliminating the need for collecting additional
data such as post-play surveys. Applied to a text-based game DejaBoom!, our
approach effectively identifies bugs inherent in LLM-powered interactive games,
surpassing unstructured LLM-powered bug-catching methods and filling the gap in
automated detection of logical and design flaws.
|
[
-0.23361800611019135,
-0.9970555305480957,
1.0578854084014893,
0.36940374970436096,
-0.262113481760025,
0.21772946417331696,
0.045214083045721054,
-0.5958201885223389,
0.5204981565475464,
0.8105107545852661,
-0.9906894564628601,
-0.7691089510917664,
-0.5001157522201538,
0.2648956775665283,
-0.2741265296936035,
0.8316075205802917,
-0.1915876269340515,
-0.47044864296913147,
-0.5440632104873657,
0.26398786902427673,
-0.7995882034301758,
-0.5317302942276001,
-0.6158877015113831,
-0.20886598527431488,
0.33191412687301636,
0.6010702848434448,
0.6280076503753662,
0.441294401884079,
0.670073926448822,
0.348482608795166,
-0.11619134992361069,
0.7793686985969543,
-0.40521660447120667,
0.5566982626914978,
0.2569832503795624,
-0.7079886198043823,
-0.47343355417251587,
-0.34163355827331543,
0.15581433475017548,
0.04458615556359291,
0.11338996887207031,
-0.005509707611054182,
0.12559418380260468,
0.3021836280822754,
-0.40965935587882996,
0.38994958996772766,
-0.3871729075908661,
0.3928944766521454,
-0.3076060116291046,
-0.4376063346862793,
-0.3581182062625885,
-0.36941489577293396,
-0.7285943031311035,
-0.6094556450843811,
0.027417145669460297,
-0.23084919154644012,
0.7484499216079712,
0.7617013454437256,
-0.12556828558444977,
-0.6312909722328186,
-0.551594078540802,
0.5816748738288879,
-1.0115153789520264,
0.15957561135292053,
0.39777863025665283,
0.2291199266910553,
-0.6846239566802979,
-0.08471329510211945,
-0.6127848029136658,
-0.5147769451141357,
-0.08252885937690735,
0.01597641222178936,
-0.03698905557394028,
-0.008983110077679157,
0.5075643658638,
0.021719899028539658,
-0.6598811149597168,
0.41811394691467285,
0.2982794940471649,
-0.11527645587921143,
0.8684784173965454,
0.5353226065635681,
0.4757460653781891,
-0.2335519939661026,
-0.13754673302173615,
0.20763254165649414,
-0.7403369545936584,
-0.03464550897479057,
0.36738625168800354,
-0.2282543033361435,
0.10536365956068039,
0.44805341958999634,
0.07168909162282944,
0.6906164884567261,
0.10680444538593292,
-0.3790440261363983,
-0.024843787774443626,
-0.12555792927742004,
0.19281625747680664,
0.2214266061782837,
0.587297260761261,
0.4771823585033417,
0.2804606854915619,
-0.26381194591522217,
-0.5970084071159363,
0.09042871743440628,
-0.07085514813661575,
-0.3957536816596985,
-0.67167729139328,
0.24992239475250244,
-0.40384700894355774,
-0.5684624314308167,
-0.0036512832157313824,
-0.8183268308639526,
-1.0953220129013062,
0.0002642352192196995,
0.358178049325943,
-0.19717277586460114,
-0.16904208064079285,
-0.11197881400585175,
-0.26020383834838867,
0.04784388467669487,
0.27356860041618347,
-0.8800914287567139,
-0.0007777103455737233,
0.6266801357269287,
0.7967416048049927,
-0.24582695960998535,
-0.1135733425617218,
-0.6490369439125061,
0.22665493190288544,
-0.3921806216239929,
1.239647388458252,
-0.40003126859664917,
-0.7016958594322205,
-0.3638845980167389,
-0.0632886216044426,
0.27852335572242737,
-0.811444103717804,
0.35618075728416443,
-0.256696879863739,
0.13053415715694427,
-0.21610412001609802,
-0.600918173789978,
0.20370188355445862,
0.5818725824356079,
-0.6165485382080078,
0.9229381680488586,
-0.0186938289552927,
-0.5043473839759827,
0.21207912266254425,
-0.4568921625614166,
-0.25792837142944336,
0.26724734902381897,
-0.2224000096321106,
-0.5302720069885254,
0.36129698157310486,
0.33073925971984863,
0.17587226629257202,
-0.05886247009038925,
0.17189472913742065,
-0.28614333271980286,
-0.7249029278755188,
0.5632984638214111,
-0.3905351758003235,
0.698738157749176,
-0.044149525463581085,
-0.4418625235557556,
0.18847428262233734,
-0.6479178071022034,
0.05234379693865776,
0.10816789418458939,
-0.2072104811668396,
-0.3488752543926239,
0.6163597702980042,
-0.32276415824890137,
0.17760060727596283,
0.33355045318603516,
-0.42513254284858704,
0.5678811073303223,
-0.30375829339027405,
-0.14501959085464478,
0.8133519887924194,
0.12006712704896927,
-0.019240600988268852,
-0.3550606071949005,
0.5896729230880737,
-0.029092764481902122,
0.24678531289100647,
-0.45140790939331055,
-0.6136507391929626,
-0.6410617828369141,
-0.5581232309341431,
0.13941067457199097,
0.9401535987854004,
-0.7643917798995972,
1.0191839933395386,
0.0847989022731781,
-0.38954371213912964,
-0.05466469004750252,
0.06229475513100624,
0.20329508185386658,
0.35241273045539856,
0.09277765452861786,
-0.0555785708129406,
-0.5724648237228394,
-0.36011654138565063,
-0.3955426514148712,
-0.5110118985176086,
-0.42580312490463257,
0.414313405752182,
0.36883947253227234,
-0.7075896263122559,
1.0171313285827637,
-0.6299968361854553,
-0.43251344561576843,
-0.14168484508991241,
0.10251101106405258,
0.031789325177669525,
0.30789801478385925,
0.5006101727485657,
-0.3141650855541229,
-0.20028038322925568,
-0.28715384006500244,
-1.0184316635131836,
-1.011062741279602,
-0.21530063450336456,
0.3740944266319275,
0.4270726144313812,
0.6616538166999817,
-0.4808949828147888,
0.5252735018730164,
0.627122163772583,
-0.7104706764221191,
0.44145673513412476,
-0.22843040525913239,
0.49823886156082153,
-0.5732227563858032,
-0.18707282841205597,
-0.3732723891735077,
-0.25908106565475464,
-0.14938518404960632,
0.041067227721214294,
-0.10188590735197067,
0.16201737523078918,
0.07333987206220627,
0.5566188097000122,
-0.614701509475708,
-0.01865088939666748,
-0.43801161646842957,
0.3483491837978363,
0.13607122004032135,
0.09425503760576248,
-0.13647028803825378,
0.4312736690044403,
0.19976195693016052,
-0.6111171245574951,
0.8030806183815002,
0.06492520868778229,
-0.20611204206943512,
0.6159012913703918,
-0.4712814688682556,
0.25638750195503235,
-0.12084095925092697,
0.21467013657093048,
-1.2209233045578003,
-0.14711064100265503,
0.6572085618972778,
-0.5232913494110107,
0.2003905177116394,
-0.0733545571565628,
-0.8706990480422974,
-0.3723544180393219,
-0.34061169624328613,
-0.0037478404119610786,
0.5653384327888489,
-0.6729664206504822,
0.3561205267906189,
0.5108926892280579,
-0.07992413640022278,
-0.15675854682922363,
-0.7264602780342102,
0.293974369764328,
-0.3376767635345459,
-0.6816743016242981,
0.29175183176994324,
-0.23982256650924683,
-0.3822312355041504,
-0.10770124942064285,
-0.2639594078063965,
-0.19502054154872894,
0.47522836923599243,
0.3146137297153473,
0.18221426010131836,
-0.0507982037961483,
0.23979923129081726,
-0.1759829968214035,
-0.20576414465904236,
0.2785745859146118,
-0.0642341896891594,
0.28293606638908386,
0.12032283842563629,
-0.6347122192382812,
-0.12163996696472168,
0.2549957036972046,
0.5399975180625916,
-0.04109920561313629,
0.1327103227376938,
0.08706806600093842,
-0.3531816899776459,
-0.265997976064682,
-0.6398218870162964,
-0.3273836374282837,
-0.48044848442077637,
0.3589470386505127,
-0.13408911228179932,
-0.6784582138061523,
0.8937129974365234,
-0.25238117575645447,
-0.06803721934556961,
0.13130290806293488,
0.0024515949189662933,
-0.2957475781440735,
1.2556096315383911,
0.7201917767524719,
0.05977793410420418,
0.17926080524921417,
0.20675818622112274,
0.07250557094812393,
-0.45815587043762207,
-0.4402320384979248,
-0.5196655988693237,
-0.5360183119773865,
-0.4791945219039917,
-0.43260902166366577,
0.24861504137516022,
0.36289069056510925,
0.15357089042663574,
0.15271325409412384,
-0.48565053939819336,
0.893304705619812,
0.015684783458709717,
0.050341926515102386,
0.5676908493041992,
-0.24912120401859283,
-0.08366800099611282,
-0.35543641448020935,
-0.3885808289051056,
-0.44987738132476807,
0.593687117099762,
0.3043573796749115,
0.9116367697715759,
0.29938024282455444,
1.145727276802063,
0.4410320222377777,
0.16142064332962036,
-0.9096407294273376,
0.5859754085540771,
0.27498021721839905,
-0.384333074092865,
-0.35740193724632263,
-0.5258442759513855,
-0.8806202411651611,
-0.1753116101026535,
-0.13332337141036987,
-0.8046340942382812,
-0.018902581185102463,
0.28136008977890015,
-0.5290946364402771,
0.44179168343544006,
-0.2758532166481018,
0.9306113123893738,
-0.583507239818573,
-0.05570050701498985,
-0.10939327627420425,
-0.04981008917093277,
0.48804938793182373,
-0.29683756828308105,
0.37053775787353516,
-0.08032375574111938,
-0.1904778778553009,
0.5968549847602844,
-0.3182813823223114,
0.6651083827018738,
-0.3669686019420624,
-0.4998196065425873,
0.23294346034526825,
0.5731186866760254,
0.7225568294525146,
0.3233569264411926,
0.35997307300567627,
0.23997657001018524,
0.021185902878642082,
-0.08650322258472443,
-0.6392905116081238,
0.765788197517395,
-0.30945613980293274,
-0.6063101291656494,
-0.855532169342041,
-0.5152086615562439,
-0.19101834297180176,
-0.012117408215999603,
0.12504403293132782,
0.016123728826642036,
-0.385407030582428,
-0.22438892722129822,
1.0048346519470215,
-0.5603368878364563,
0.6282314658164978,
1.0432960987091064,
-0.547990620136261,
0.006153739523142576,
0.8855229020118713,
0.09209239482879639,
-0.303669273853302,
0.19690562784671783,
-0.03168356046080589,
-0.06616756319999695,
-0.6283562779426575,
-0.37611016631126404,
-0.018691187724471092,
-0.43291449546813965,
-0.3527086079120636,
-0.42185643315315247,
-0.11994380503892899,
0.17689350247383118,
-0.05435013025999069,
-0.05836410075426102,
-0.1631728559732437,
-0.5346407294273376,
0.048048894852399826,
0.6399529576301575,
0.9495485424995422,
-0.20117919147014618,
0.39707422256469727,
-1.1672784090042114,
0.4943453073501587,
0.15993984043598175,
0.4319053590297699,
-0.39733147621154785,
-0.48767349123954773,
0.048773400485515594,
0.017922306433320045,
-0.2514318525791168,
-1.3189104795455933,
0.511998176574707,
-0.19312304258346558,
0.5504111051559448,
0.26068270206451416,
-0.18894188106060028,
0.6096770167350769,
-0.6051632761955261,
0.8166974186897278,
0.07757654786109924,
-0.8888776898384094,
0.5990002751350403,
-0.3193351626396179,
0.4511618912220001,
0.33030012249946594,
-0.009266494773328304,
-0.9547537565231323,
-0.5029430389404297,
-0.53993159532547,
-0.6773644089698792,
0.7411083579063416,
-0.08865491300821304,
-0.10591359436511993,
-0.38724851608276367,
0.31539225578308105,
-0.026950865983963013,
0.10408743470907211,
-0.5831862092018127,
-0.17127197980880737,
0.1657005250453949,
-0.3169897496700287,
0.031727384775877,
-0.34812816977500916,
0.27285683155059814,
0.11029207706451416,
0.526667058467865,
0.009003235027194023,
0.1921360343694687,
0.23148863017559052,
-0.4700296223163605,
-0.45661482214927673,
-0.02831193059682846,
0.682183563709259,
0.6067835092544556,
-0.2592243552207947,
0.10306660830974579,
0.2516748011112213,
-0.31173938512802124,
0.22237999737262726,
0.06134456396102905,
-0.3852766752243042,
0.4216407239437103,
0.3294118642807007,
0.3280322849750519,
0.2895326614379883,
-1.0226572751998901,
0.3720913529396057,
-0.10240864753723145,
0.12526002526283264,
-0.48831018805503845,
0.24943886697292328,
-0.028750572353601456,
0.44615674018859863,
0.3486645221710205,
0.025639472529292107,
0.12573696672916412,
-0.33360427618026733,
0.44519859552383423,
0.628520667552948,
-0.6256535053253174,
-0.1616223305463791,
0.4330439567565918,
0.2701495587825775,
-0.6996155381202698,
0.509083092212677,
-0.2994627356529236,
-0.45889919996261597,
0.9852263331413269,
0.4040403962135315,
0.9193435311317444,
-0.37440741062164307,
0.28549206256866455,
-0.08892181515693665,
0.6556756496429443,
0.04648062214255333,
0.2807449698448181,
0.23302482068538666,
-0.38159680366516113,
-0.46991166472435,
-0.3090609610080719,
-0.4462231397628784,
0.19620876014232635,
-0.005279787816107273,
0.45155835151672363,
-0.4336928129196167,
-0.08386397361755371,
-0.3466109037399292,
-0.019626908004283905,
-0.11580725759267807,
-0.25464263558387756,
0.741875946521759,
0.7001681923866272,
-0.7715720534324646,
0.45984917879104614,
0.3524092137813568,
-0.2883775532245636,
-0.19529816508293152,
0.1291673332452774,
0.28926119208335876,
-0.3992782533168793,
0.5170271396636963,
0.14231206476688385,
0.06266681104898453,
0.10006009787321091,
-0.5231968760490417,
-0.7306410670280457,
0.9302806854248047,
0.324043869972229,
-0.8685804009437561,
0.030092298984527588,
0.10211075097322464,
0.4020317792892456,
-0.07550287991762161,
0.5416012406349182,
0.4303586483001709,
0.7160088419914246,
-0.2143832892179489,
-0.822003960609436,
-0.11302139610052109,
0.1585060954093933,
-0.2710493505001068,
0.5575830340385437,
-0.4433649480342865,
0.466022253036499,
-0.16356943547725677,
-0.11074542999267578,
-0.06828854978084564,
0.54839688539505,
0.5657860040664673,
0.45694905519485474,
0.5819803476333618,
0.7358853220939636,
1.132048487663269,
-0.3491148054599762,
0.6600707769393921,
-0.15898749232292175,
0.13004612922668457,
0.8205773234367371,
-0.345618337392807,
0.2105066329240799,
0.2537662982940674,
0.09589105099439621,
0.6922693252563477,
0.7506544589996338,
-0.33097633719444275,
0.5336119532585144,
0.5834395289421082,
-0.2161777764558792,
-0.23619668185710907,
0.24884161353111267,
-0.34568655490875244,
0.26979660987854004,
0.4619472026824951,
-0.1362660527229309,
-0.3487611711025238,
0.03089810349047184,
0.20515218377113342,
0.09838197380304337,
-0.43718618154525757,
0.8493220806121826,
0.03720426931977272,
-0.7198498845100403,
0.596919059753418,
0.05721944943070412,
1.0128554105758667,
-0.7067892551422119,
-0.32627367973327637,
-0.4934959411621094,
0.4229508936405182,
-0.3457283079624176,
-0.7121508121490479,
0.43254855275154114,
0.25943228602409363,
-0.1731099635362625,
-0.025708982720971107,
0.7924903631210327,
-0.4004659354686737,
-0.390800803899765,
0.40234389901161194,
0.42379218339920044,
0.3582943379878998,
-0.34112921357154846,
-0.49251559376716614,
0.5488812327384949,
-0.012080173008143902,
-0.06512882560491562,
0.1300450712442398,
0.682098388671875,
-0.2027110457420349,
0.46491116285324097,
0.3512595295906067,
-0.12588083744049072,
-0.11430906504392624,
-0.24376893043518066,
0.6542494297027588,
-0.7437011003494263,
-0.23097781836986542,
-1.245932698249817,
0.400736927986145,
-0.22439154982566833,
-0.07349427789449692,
0.9284889101982117,
0.4460359215736389,
0.506561815738678,
-0.1425810605287552,
0.7685365080833435,
0.04265601933002472,
0.18413574993610382,
-0.43507811427116394,
0.6454162001609802,
-0.24768535792827606,
0.6636298894882202,
-0.3228111267089844,
-0.9125490188598633,
-0.3898289203643799,
0.6528713703155518,
-0.012663890607655048,
-0.14627699553966522,
0.6196057200431824,
0.9049121737480164,
0.06035669520497322,
-0.20296433568000793,
0.17369966208934784,
0.2101757824420929,
0.3838593661785126,
0.7883704304695129,
1.128951072692871,
-0.2823996841907501,
0.4876478910446167,
0.1945149004459381,
-0.5730522274971008,
-0.4123198091983795,
-1.0258464813232422,
-1.0666911602020264,
-0.028178682550787926,
-0.538618266582489,
-0.4105879068374634,
0.36267930269241333,
0.7360482215881348,
0.10418950021266937,
-0.9629231691360474,
-0.20659925043582916,
-0.15169624984264374,
0.5644681453704834,
-0.4116327464580536,
-0.24364380538463593,
-0.13796348869800568,
-0.29068225622177124,
-0.4862557351589203,
0.6652531027793884,
0.38498711585998535,
0.04688461497426033,
-0.42369788885116577,
-0.1168668195605278,
0.1252477616071701,
0.3101235628128052,
0.40918201208114624,
0.4159470796585083,
-0.7667916417121887,
-0.42853111028671265,
0.371959924697876,
-0.13970012962818146,
-0.10675349831581116,
0.7028860449790955,
-0.9945476055145264,
0.3591043949127197,
0.6609401106834412,
0.3387739360332489,
0.15267838537693024,
-0.22599761188030243,
0.4221746325492859,
-0.7488552927970886,
0.1744784116744995,
0.49147430062294006,
0.06620125472545624,
0.2708083987236023,
-0.5896556973457336,
0.2878674566745758,
0.38822320103645325,
-0.6248450875282288,
-0.9949514865875244,
0.358593225479126,
-0.4945397973060608,
-0.44329026341438293,
1.0727297067642212,
-0.06169911101460457,
-0.12511026859283447,
-0.2332710325717926,
-0.49123841524124146,
0.027906173840165138,
0.03821030259132385,
1.0736117362976074,
0.8168430924415588,
-0.20348495244979858,
-0.17227782309055328,
-0.332407683134079,
0.8519428968429565,
0.058662593364715576,
-0.9094980955123901,
0.12612596154212952,
0.9128588438034058,
-0.06644800305366516,
0.1671902984380722,
0.4946187734603882,
-0.1444971114397049,
0.21222613751888275,
-0.04198755696415901,
0.24769555032253265,
-0.24799542129039764,
-0.36837729811668396,
-0.4290347099304199,
-0.23641972243785858,
-0.07097841054201126,
0.0736861601471901
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.04478v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.04478v1
|
PromptFix: Few-shot Backdoor Removal via Adversarial Prompt Tuning
| 2024-06-06T20:06:42 | 2024-06-06T20:06:42 |
Tianrong Zhang, Zhaohan Xi, Ting Wang, Prasenjit Mitra, Jinghui Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Pre-trained language models (PLMs) have attracted enormous attention over the
past few years with their unparalleled performances. Meanwhile, the soaring
cost to train PLMs as well as their amazing generalizability have jointly
contributed to few-shot fine-tuning and prompting as the most popular training
paradigms for natural language processing (NLP) models. Nevertheless, existing
studies have shown that these NLP models can be backdoored such that model
behavior is manipulated when trigger tokens are presented. In this paper, we
propose PromptFix, a novel backdoor mitigation strategy for NLP models via
adversarial prompt-tuning in few-shot settings. Unlike existing NLP backdoor
removal methods, which rely on accurate trigger inversion and subsequent model
fine-tuning, PromptFix keeps the model parameters intact and only utilizes two
extra sets of soft tokens which approximate the trigger and counteract it
respectively. The use of soft tokens and adversarial optimization eliminates
the need to enumerate possible backdoor configurations and enables an adaptive
balance between trigger finding and preservation of performance. Experiments
with various backdoor attacks validate the effectiveness of the proposed method
and the performances when domain shift is present further shows PromptFix's
applicability to models pretrained on unknown data source which is the common
case in prompt tuning scenarios.
|
[
-0.3970332443714142,
-1.0116138458251953,
0.3228347897529602,
0.08316153287887573,
-0.1938449740409851,
-0.05603823810815811,
-0.2447708398103714,
0.14165252447128296,
-0.3422379195690155,
0.6000869274139404,
-1.1347124576568604,
-0.5710152387619019,
-0.5484338402748108,
0.252895325422287,
-0.23684558272361755,
1.1016653776168823,
0.5047798156738281,
0.036770179867744446,
0.26429876685142517,
-0.13628333806991577,
-0.7781590223312378,
-0.40423569083213806,
-0.9637551307678223,
-0.2774166762828827,
0.5961431860923767,
0.14413456618785858,
1.1145280599594116,
0.3189448416233063,
0.2842572331428528,
0.18192139267921448,
-0.27655547857284546,
0.061794739216566086,
-0.6076943278312683,
-0.04381445422768593,
-0.1906661093235016,
-0.7068646550178528,
-0.1709056794643402,
0.18647263944149017,
0.5725124478340149,
0.3430595397949219,
-0.062283169478178024,
0.019984912127256393,
0.08768914639949799,
0.4558248221874237,
-0.8010449409484863,
-0.43737953901290894,
-1.0041711330413818,
0.09323254972696304,
-0.2713131606578827,
-0.411886602640152,
-0.5249308943748474,
-0.37404701113700867,
-0.29708585143089294,
-0.6054818630218506,
0.37718889117240906,
0.2334226667881012,
0.6216379404067993,
0.5652368068695068,
-0.05611119791865349,
-0.04743243381381035,
-0.2740882635116577,
0.5310346484184265,
-0.9283013939857483,
0.13985814154148102,
0.3172530233860016,
0.1565774530172348,
-0.7219525575637817,
-0.5269702076911926,
-0.7011069059371948,
-0.0496089830994606,
-0.2747199535369873,
-0.13205234706401825,
-0.4098472595214844,
0.096809983253479,
0.567130446434021,
0.0610382966697216,
-0.9315099716186523,
0.46135953068733215,
0.19213524460792542,
-0.40774255990982056,
0.21874666213989258,
0.3491848409175873,
0.36724352836608887,
-0.0016909090336412191,
-0.5504963397979736,
0.012192396447062492,
-1.133935809135437,
0.28023749589920044,
0.5728403925895691,
0.777343213558197,
-0.006149320863187313,
0.2587527632713318,
0.04966301470994949,
0.7599571943283081,
0.15374517440795898,
0.03833916783332825,
-0.08928106725215912,
-0.24095027148723602,
-0.19634704291820526,
-0.053957272320985794,
0.6862208247184753,
0.07602083683013916,
0.1863187700510025,
-0.15823428332805634,
-0.47283050417900085,
0.026430340483784676,
0.30661576986312866,
-0.7848606705665588,
-0.0780818909406662,
0.1414354294538498,
-0.4316960871219635,
-0.49533796310424805,
-0.272296279668808,
-0.766204297542572,
-0.6396186351776123,
0.06090671196579933,
0.7280786037445068,
-0.4807077646255493,
-0.007367416750639677,
-0.12792998552322388,
-0.2241365611553192,
0.3880451023578644,
0.1924147754907608,
-0.7264223694801331,
0.19170032441616058,
1.0926110744476318,
0.9461736083030701,
-0.08327007293701172,
-0.41240236163139343,
-1.2832810878753662,
-0.18866142630577087,
-0.40516307950019836,
0.49198922514915466,
-0.657443642616272,
-0.5190995335578918,
0.14088286459445953,
0.10304904729127884,
-0.163962721824646,
-0.3454040586948395,
0.45623743534088135,
-0.8726675510406494,
0.4203638732433319,
-0.0033452592324465513,
-0.3828027546405792,
0.009588918648660183,
0.38285666704177856,
-0.5996291041374207,
0.7037766575813293,
-0.14690567553043365,
-0.6340048909187317,
0.13153934478759766,
-0.47901642322540283,
-0.5675253868103027,
0.12187054008245468,
0.23392866551876068,
-0.5896210670471191,
0.1347714066505432,
0.5862419605255127,
0.25080248713493347,
-0.1090553030371666,
0.030610237270593643,
-0.3530711829662323,
-0.5559514164924622,
0.0807759016752243,
-0.6056138277053833,
1.062028169631958,
0.18551425635814667,
-0.30557748675346375,
0.17641140520572662,
-0.8616805672645569,
-0.1638617366552353,
0.07341580837965012,
0.005353264044970274,
-0.52443927526474,
-0.4998072683811188,
-0.37482306361198425,
0.32941287755966187,
0.04305505380034447,
-0.3973691165447235,
0.28450924158096313,
-1.2557131052017212,
0.027378197759389877,
0.8642317652702332,
0.1868072897195816,
0.7015137076377869,
-0.24448981881141663,
0.8321752548217773,
-0.1270160675048828,
0.4086438715457916,
-0.6309483647346497,
-0.6661628484725952,
-0.46677839756011963,
-0.4093542993068695,
0.15846198797225952,
0.7008132338523865,
-0.8594768643379211,
0.3554733097553253,
0.30315089225769043,
-0.24600321054458618,
-0.601538896560669,
0.2668519616127014,
0.45883896946907043,
0.7274414300918579,
0.3450249135494232,
0.1850171834230423,
-0.10468641668558121,
-0.5474757552146912,
-0.8040618896484375,
0.03840641677379608,
-0.14711490273475647,
0.16406208276748657,
0.31810706853866577,
-0.04150636866688728,
1.0117568969726562,
-0.43842676281929016,
-0.3663260340690613,
-0.10435062646865845,
0.3433319628238678,
0.46655362844467163,
0.5843397974967957,
0.7395384907722473,
-0.717427134513855,
-0.1953398436307907,
-0.5577455163002014,
-0.24213942885398865,
-0.33173084259033203,
-0.378983736038208,
-0.06128469482064247,
0.12010347098112106,
0.33235639333724976,
-0.6907187104225159,
0.6089168190956116,
0.419405460357666,
-0.4139947295188904,
0.392610102891922,
-0.008162880316376686,
0.0013371807290241122,
-0.7851001024246216,
0.17675155401229858,
-0.3103533089160919,
-0.343717098236084,
-0.5905440449714661,
0.3394070863723755,
0.11535758525133133,
-0.6430759429931641,
-0.7063381671905518,
0.9556102752685547,
-0.12441941350698471,
0.2824440598487854,
-0.5192766785621643,
-0.027518650516867638,
-0.015457848086953163,
0.7053693532943726,
-0.2311871498823166,
1.065297245979309,
0.5306330919265747,
-0.5506454110145569,
0.3462601602077484,
0.561906099319458,
0.24521991610527039,
0.4615691602230072,
-0.6044630408287048,
0.4333678185939789,
0.036176953464746475,
0.21149331331253052,
-1.0877889394760132,
0.3888167142868042,
0.6019794940948486,
-0.6515541672706604,
0.41042187809944153,
-0.40006598830223083,
-0.4056735634803772,
-0.16733868420124054,
-0.5528305768966675,
-0.0027510207146406174,
0.5172070264816284,
-0.8608394265174866,
0.5421539545059204,
-0.24652047455310822,
-0.25441211462020874,
-0.5154529809951782,
-0.2837871015071869,
0.25476688146591187,
-0.22716623544692993,
-0.5297094583511353,
0.20906180143356323,
-0.2320680022239685,
0.0982164815068245,
-0.3291420042514801,
0.04995907098054886,
0.06179378926753998,
0.510736346244812,
0.28672266006469727,
0.21480974555015564,
-0.3643874526023865,
0.27937886118888855,
-0.018822701647877693,
-0.4102366268634796,
0.02524099312722683,
-0.31008338928222656,
0.48245400190353394,
0.05878407135605812,
-0.12153559178113937,
-0.36335301399230957,
0.5515929460525513,
0.27837684750556946,
-0.2542975842952728,
0.9714698791503906,
0.7702010273933411,
-0.4470878541469574,
-0.4347420930862427,
-0.3836105763912201,
-0.6953084468841553,
-0.5187243819236755,
-0.08481790870428085,
-0.43993282318115234,
-0.7417835593223572,
0.48617109656333923,
-0.2425900250673294,
0.08747509866952896,
0.291484534740448,
0.45497700572013855,
0.21726740896701813,
1.1835250854492188,
0.7048418521881104,
-0.1591109037399292,
0.363389253616333,
0.06819472461938858,
0.14580678939819336,
-0.4544930160045624,
0.19622279703617096,
-0.8238282799720764,
-0.1936255246400833,
-0.3722951114177704,
0.18378029763698578,
0.4245143532752991,
0.03857045620679855,
-0.19855809211730957,
0.23130296170711517,
-0.16016939282417297,
0.5706905722618103,
0.7961247563362122,
0.23613224923610687,
0.08692381531000137,
-0.1941605657339096,
-0.20267707109451294,
0.010807652026414871,
-0.8849771022796631,
-0.39072856307029724,
0.964353621006012,
0.2598016560077667,
0.8455551862716675,
-0.08175583183765411,
0.467905193567276,
0.29948166012763977,
0.022357197478413582,
-0.48138850927352905,
0.4767121970653534,
-0.32699254155158997,
-0.6877776980400085,
-0.32133376598358154,
-0.29326966404914856,
-0.7937792539596558,
-0.010892718099057674,
-0.4044409394264221,
-0.45796364545822144,
0.07039309293031693,
0.30985504388809204,
-1.0050386190414429,
0.3199024498462677,
-0.6887620687484741,
0.9877415299415588,
-0.05947589501738548,
-0.38192346692085266,
-0.14480137825012207,
-0.9074185490608215,
0.3474770486354828,
-0.15014779567718506,
0.019399315118789673,
0.0012475935509428382,
0.010751843452453613,
0.6119494438171387,
-0.6176783442497253,
1.054998517036438,
-0.4500882923603058,
-0.12223225086927414,
-0.06585508584976196,
0.282153844833374,
1.084702968597412,
0.4175564646720886,
-0.025075212121009827,
0.25164660811424255,
-0.20250453054904938,
-0.3402003049850464,
-0.7704364061355591,
0.7420186996459961,
-0.5395930409431458,
-0.9869157075881958,
-0.3048313856124878,
-0.1703128069639206,
-0.3335971236228943,
0.16750821471214294,
0.5477956533432007,
0.42450693249702454,
-0.08649682998657227,
0.02427152544260025,
0.5836264491081238,
-0.5973340272903442,
0.7002573013305664,
0.8185336589813232,
0.17814886569976807,
-0.364655464887619,
0.628086268901825,
-0.39479395747184753,
0.06071162968873978,
0.32203546166419983,
0.5060533285140991,
-0.2485583871603012,
-0.5333985686302185,
-0.2845722436904907,
-0.017001207917928696,
-0.45754194259643555,
-0.6495323181152344,
-0.56929612159729,
-0.11822649091482162,
-0.6799234747886658,
-0.2516673505306244,
-0.29316720366477966,
-0.3060145378112793,
-0.7449443340301514,
0.2015867829322815,
0.4113214612007141,
0.07333115488290787,
-0.0538090318441391,
0.9450916647911072,
-0.8768965601921082,
0.6113661527633667,
0.4664113223552704,
0.33976781368255615,
-0.34317299723625183,
-0.7980653643608093,
0.007145422510802746,
-0.03956981748342514,
-0.16227807104587555,
-0.8476352095603943,
0.629113495349884,
0.36621594429016113,
0.47466281056404114,
0.3717021644115448,
0.4025004208087921,
0.4231034219264984,
-0.638453483581543,
0.9118703007698059,
0.1027659997344017,
-0.9421831369400024,
0.8377792239189148,
-0.1767951250076294,
0.4296771287918091,
0.5554918050765991,
0.24202586710453033,
-0.36043304204940796,
-0.3933876156806946,
-0.5050608515739441,
-0.6013036966323853,
0.8100106716156006,
0.17947900295257568,
0.19748643040657043,
0.18776245415210724,
0.43807485699653625,
0.4623858332633972,
0.39381831884384155,
-0.33739519119262695,
-0.2770800292491913,
-0.2964611053466797,
-0.08961933106184006,
-0.13937973976135254,
-0.3127526044845581,
-0.2835022807121277,
0.17549964785575867,
0.8285799026489258,
-0.24092751741409302,
-0.1821112036705017,
-0.17494326829910278,
-0.20814701914787292,
-0.1952735036611557,
0.4926135540008545,
0.6840255260467529,
0.19507788121700287,
-0.03333118185400963,
0.016899388283491135,
0.19168448448181152,
-0.3955751955509186,
0.1093001663684845,
0.25660979747772217,
-0.45828577876091003,
0.00660731690004468,
0.388540118932724,
0.8018897175788879,
0.19297952950000763,
-0.25809887051582336,
0.8811519145965576,
-0.22138547897338867,
0.3065263330936432,
-0.046817585825920105,
0.3437412977218628,
-0.5593920946121216,
0.28041574358940125,
0.4545551836490631,
0.4450015723705292,
0.0686032697558403,
-0.17776572704315186,
0.34788647294044495,
0.6429426670074463,
-0.3410925269126892,
-0.41810745000839233,
0.7455167174339294,
0.49043920636177063,
-0.6728411316871643,
0.6015383005142212,
-0.15378065407276154,
-0.7330710291862488,
0.4038504362106323,
0.6769253611564636,
1.2070972919464111,
-0.31453701853752136,
0.10817595571279526,
0.17147274315357208,
0.6612619757652283,
0.13603436946868896,
-0.08792892843484879,
0.008382015861570835,
-0.7877078056335449,
-0.13801755011081696,
-0.5088189840316772,
-0.17177507281303406,
0.3463513255119324,
-0.3072028160095215,
0.48503801226615906,
-0.7634922862052917,
-0.12837281823158264,
-0.19784753024578094,
-0.018075505271553993,
-0.6465877294540405,
0.1254182904958725,
0.17840097844600677,
1.0747205018997192,
-0.972935676574707,
0.6826943755149841,
0.39433127641677856,
-0.14865495264530182,
-0.6113952398300171,
0.20181973278522491,
0.2913486063480377,
-0.9374436140060425,
0.49552658200263977,
0.11452153325080872,
-0.22405098378658295,
0.3699343800544739,
-0.9059149026870728,
-0.35447046160697937,
0.38067111372947693,
0.5223179459571838,
-0.6285839676856995,
-0.07365377992391586,
-0.23883773386478424,
0.2403731495141983,
-0.10884296149015427,
0.09845837205648422,
0.6231203675270081,
0.47375959157943726,
-0.01496810931712389,
-0.535405158996582,
0.24934247136116028,
-0.15682072937488556,
-0.12015452980995178,
-0.0030825550202280283,
-0.4938047230243683,
0.758439838886261,
-0.11128520965576172,
-0.44664520025253296,
0.2709803581237793,
0.3972584307193756,
0.22603465616703033,
0.4182054400444031,
0.6688195466995239,
0.3854650855064392,
0.5102971196174622,
-0.07319717109203339,
0.8148138523101807,
-0.32827290892601013,
0.04226120933890343,
1.2031638622283936,
-0.4254623055458069,
0.44960424304008484,
0.5108824968338013,
0.04745384305715561,
0.07743579894304276,
0.42923006415367126,
-0.0905124694108963,
0.7178178429603577,
-0.08575311303138733,
-0.11165516823530197,
-0.4513339698314667,
-0.017886847257614136,
-0.4590398371219635,
0.49352920055389404,
0.30393514037132263,
-0.20900596678256989,
-0.3485220968723297,
0.4921164810657501,
0.023487867787480354,
0.3236841857433319,
-0.41391903162002563,
0.9681159853935242,
0.05551537871360779,
-0.6232073903083801,
0.6625117063522339,
0.06519456952810287,
0.8318368196487427,
-0.8618796467781067,
-0.016877876594662666,
-0.4620000720024109,
0.04738427326083183,
0.016169272363185883,
-0.3802361488342285,
0.1571703404188156,
0.05559151992201805,
-0.05020624026656151,
-0.32956504821777344,
0.939241349697113,
-0.22653082013130188,
-0.1553972214460373,
0.09841817617416382,
0.14886701107025146,
-0.35327666997909546,
-0.5399468541145325,
-0.8098382353782654,
-0.1095375344157219,
-0.23936472833156586,
-0.408266544342041,
0.12705174088478088,
0.3779996335506439,
0.250027060508728,
0.558851420879364,
0.9678714275360107,
0.3353692889213562,
0.061350494623184204,
0.18454423546791077,
1.0591790676116943,
-0.7884430885314941,
-0.9613063931465149,
-0.9571555852890015,
0.2676902711391449,
0.1044650450348854,
-0.5393298864364624,
0.7900441288948059,
0.4077007472515106,
0.3702080249786377,
-0.09954259544610977,
0.5668036937713623,
0.5346481204032898,
0.609097421169281,
-0.8941916227340698,
0.8179996609687805,
-0.3546562194824219,
0.4448227286338806,
-0.25741633772850037,
-0.5421807169914246,
-0.5076847076416016,
0.0757484957575798,
-0.1707417070865631,
-0.18088875710964203,
0.46246224641799927,
1.2031248807907104,
0.2316170185804367,
0.17385993897914886,
0.5657134056091309,
0.28142595291137695,
0.33261048793792725,
0.47038522362709045,
0.951124906539917,
-0.3881756365299225,
0.6983927488327026,
-0.03421417996287346,
-0.26625218987464905,
-0.2729684114456177,
-0.8963014483451843,
-1.1972835063934326,
-0.07311657816171646,
-0.2534967064857483,
-0.253152996301651,
0.49605661630630493,
0.8672332763671875,
0.5720237493515015,
-1.122519850730896,
0.6651030778884888,
0.003576456569135189,
0.5077807903289795,
-0.27032527327537537,
-0.20255255699157715,
0.21206066012382507,
-0.6796030402183533,
-0.4371291995048523,
0.7770330309867859,
0.3729388415813446,
0.03925612196326256,
-0.20606647431850433,
0.05515407770872116,
-0.1996726542711258,
0.09246417880058289,
0.26014551520347595,
0.4243554472923279,
-0.7116937041282654,
-0.2965588867664337,
0.05753011628985405,
-0.23754042387008667,
-0.13304218649864197,
1.0584162473678589,
-1.1903151273727417,
0.28793424367904663,
0.5680453181266785,
0.7155069708824158,
-0.06071681156754494,
0.11000598967075348,
0.8593223690986633,
-1.390013337135315,
0.6076074838638306,
0.3415026366710663,
0.06379923969507217,
0.24544799327850342,
-0.7242907285690308,
0.09570642560720444,
0.3767648935317993,
-0.22026824951171875,
-0.8553078174591064,
0.23459787666797638,
-0.4621993899345398,
-0.634569525718689,
1.0381028652191162,
-0.12888193130493164,
-0.2305811494588852,
-0.05373339354991913,
-0.28409436345100403,
0.14374394714832306,
-0.44946858286857605,
0.7322866320610046,
0.4948435127735138,
0.4419829845428467,
-0.27554720640182495,
-0.05772802233695984,
0.8459566235542297,
0.48168087005615234,
-0.48710307478904724,
-0.043599933385849,
0.31649795174598694,
0.04186638072133064,
-0.10298310965299606,
0.23856230080127716,
0.10451492667198181,
0.4458663761615753,
-0.05454593524336815,
-0.3525388538837433,
-0.3273780941963196,
-0.4369547665119171,
-1.0806163549423218,
0.5195702314376831,
-0.31228676438331604,
-0.360750675201416
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.04467v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.04467v2
|
Small-E: Small Language Model with Linear Attention for Efficient Speech Synthesis
| 2024-06-06T19:48:17 | 2024-06-11T12:36:36 |
Théodor Lemerle, Nicolas Obin, Axel Roebel
|
eess.AS
|
eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.SD
|
Recent advancements in text-to-speech (TTS) powered by language models have
showcased remarkable capabilities in achieving naturalness and zero-shot voice
cloning. Notably, the decoder-only transformer is the prominent architecture in
this domain. However, transformers face challenges stemming from their
quadratic complexity in sequence length, impeding training on lengthy sequences
and resource-constrained hardware. Moreover they lack specific inductive bias
with regards to the monotonic nature of TTS alignments. In response, we propose
to replace transformers with emerging recurrent architectures and introduce
specialized cross-attention mechanisms for reducing repeating and skipping
issues. Consequently our architecture can be efficiently trained on long
samples and achieve state-of-the-art zero-shot voice cloning against baselines
of comparable size. Our implementation and demos are available at
https://github.com/theodorblackbird/lina-speech.
|
[
-0.4789264500141144,
-0.6766749024391174,
0.4335368573665619,
0.0039381468668580055,
-0.06575420498847961,
-0.006729600951075554,
-0.22187228500843048,
-0.41487494111061096,
0.41629892587661743,
0.25023752450942993,
-0.7896719574928284,
-0.0821378231048584,
-0.30106398463249207,
0.13903389871120453,
-0.7099677920341492,
0.9846264123916626,
0.3985293507575989,
-0.1981516182422638,
0.21339130401611328,
-0.12197820097208023,
-0.2819735109806061,
-0.2448708713054657,
-0.9091907739639282,
-0.16496235132217407,
0.6181010007858276,
0.6030691266059875,
0.45516437292099,
0.6870657801628113,
0.007987565360963345,
0.18219229578971863,
-0.2061968445777893,
-0.060911644250154495,
-0.6411707401275635,
0.04229500889778137,
-0.1678670197725296,
-0.2974458336830139,
-0.7169793844223022,
-0.395070880651474,
0.773913562297821,
0.7009426355361938,
0.1397085338830948,
0.4482673406600952,
0.22640788555145264,
0.5424022674560547,
-0.36306488513946533,
-0.25799235701560974,
-0.8342199921607971,
0.2112416923046112,
-0.010717958211898804,
0.03190061077475548,
-0.8122035264968872,
-0.12868033349514008,
0.34245747327804565,
-0.3958014249801636,
0.5359861850738525,
0.08148730546236038,
0.4906269907951355,
0.5840641856193542,
-0.041437648236751556,
-0.1005321815609932,
-1.2232484817504883,
0.9622868895530701,
-0.528261125087738,
0.621546745300293,
-0.25693756341934204,
0.23504702746868134,
0.13484340906143188,
-1.1913193464279175,
-0.485282301902771,
-0.08158163726329803,
0.009445376694202423,
-0.06336751580238342,
-0.6555954813957214,
0.06948890537023544,
0.3700803816318512,
0.22903867065906525,
-0.5628035664558411,
0.0040779137052595615,
-0.5386982560157776,
-0.10852310806512833,
0.15898779034614563,
0.16347520053386688,
0.29557865858078003,
-0.0024142058100551367,
-0.18342217803001404,
0.13756662607192993,
-0.8603229522705078,
-0.13829462230205536,
0.1754167228937149,
0.5447043776512146,
-0.12303707003593445,
0.538407564163208,
0.05539305880665779,
0.7812735438346863,
0.6111871600151062,
0.04187644273042679,
0.1652105152606964,
-0.47138169407844543,
-0.4316662847995758,
0.23808516561985016,
0.7104788422584534,
-0.16485315561294556,
0.05969269573688507,
-0.11987125128507614,
-0.05923651531338692,
-0.043826863169670105,
0.4135225713253021,
-0.78101646900177,
-0.024512488394975662,
0.2616237699985504,
-0.4611530303955078,
-0.2162925899028778,
-0.34059882164001465,
-1.1703414916992188,
0.1772298812866211,
-0.416006863117218,
0.45385631918907166,
-0.18552163243293762,
0.11032873392105103,
0.04889685660600662,
0.13721558451652527,
0.12035899609327316,
0.05900568887591362,
-1.031008243560791,
0.3613809645175934,
0.44370919466018677,
0.7630801200866699,
-0.05124456435441971,
-0.17464816570281982,
-0.8451053500175476,
0.17513516545295715,
-0.173475980758667,
0.554607093334198,
-0.20929621160030365,
-0.31371766328811646,
-0.21343694627285004,
-0.06440260261297226,
-0.051070306450128555,
-0.3321506381034851,
0.6361001133918762,
-0.03878459334373474,
0.38261881470680237,
0.3180304765701294,
-0.3585062623023987,
0.23662069439888,
-0.19318056106567383,
-0.6115270853042603,
1.0694808959960938,
0.014668806456029415,
-0.5776800513267517,
-0.08897105604410172,
-0.539750337600708,
-0.5108624696731567,
-0.2621694505214691,
-0.12574242055416107,
-0.5942193269729614,
0.39435911178588867,
0.33568307757377625,
0.13870678842067719,
-0.5234729647636414,
-0.23966364562511444,
-0.1388235092163086,
-0.3761903643608093,
-0.05655273050069809,
-0.46394988894462585,
0.4870559275150299,
0.3752988278865814,
-0.5491561889648438,
0.33453455567359924,
-0.9383272528648376,
0.19772380590438843,
0.21166546642780304,
0.09778772294521332,
-0.18039904534816742,
-0.17224599421024323,
0.323129802942276,
0.25906801223754883,
0.0770927295088768,
-0.5355252027511597,
0.1269763559103012,
-0.9212477803230286,
0.7921398878097534,
0.4464229643344879,
0.006251159124076366,
0.8611322045326233,
-0.39466220140457153,
0.618291437625885,
-0.3138640224933624,
0.3152308464050293,
-0.2861820459365845,
-0.49268049001693726,
-0.9658311605453491,
-0.5637637376785278,
0.4076380431652069,
0.3502751588821411,
-0.6606847047805786,
0.24574847519397736,
-0.550064742565155,
-0.5649616718292236,
-0.9734890460968018,
-0.050380852073431015,
0.3972055912017822,
0.3697545528411865,
0.3470550775527954,
-0.10373735427856445,
-0.9347742199897766,
-1.111033320426941,
-0.12324649840593338,
0.13096089661121368,
-0.3753257095813751,
0.31893762946128845,
0.3098081946372986,
-0.18783262372016907,
1.2291399240493774,
-0.16245315968990326,
-0.5303565263748169,
-0.4875623285770416,
-0.1161692887544632,
0.12569838762283325,
0.28737491369247437,
0.6661133170127869,
-0.4062698781490326,
-0.7362214922904968,
0.13720381259918213,
-0.19169358909130096,
-0.22784315049648285,
-0.2794112265110016,
0.28775110840797424,
0.2400026023387909,
0.5469313859939575,
-0.7573174834251404,
0.3641264736652374,
0.43829259276390076,
0.1473122537136078,
-0.05623685568571091,
0.043193768709897995,
-0.2597227990627289,
-0.9452953934669495,
0.3283917009830475,
-0.20544865727424622,
-0.48914825916290283,
-1.0220041275024414,
-0.2108091115951538,
-0.22785653173923492,
-0.5479949116706848,
-0.9344318509101868,
0.6469926834106445,
-0.42461851239204407,
-0.47281086444854736,
-0.30336737632751465,
0.306961327791214,
-0.14298027753829956,
0.6199837327003479,
-0.12150488048791885,
0.890097975730896,
0.2950269877910614,
-0.3101050853729248,
0.09172786772251129,
0.23548589646816254,
-0.06502430140972137,
0.48861443996429443,
-1.0177698135375977,
0.5326169729232788,
-0.13235874474048615,
0.0867723897099495,
-0.8137428760528564,
-0.005137740168720484,
0.27306339144706726,
-0.5877953767776489,
0.48400476574897766,
-0.1848486363887787,
-0.4085088074207306,
-0.3602144718170166,
-0.3146216571331024,
0.6401028037071228,
0.7873391509056091,
-0.622450590133667,
0.8078420162200928,
0.38302183151245117,
-0.4486362338066101,
-0.2861559987068176,
-0.6889864206314087,
0.019225727766752243,
-0.1699349582195282,
-0.46524176001548767,
0.2713538110256195,
0.003245664993301034,
0.1191972941160202,
0.08167450875043869,
0.03126748278737068,
0.10473621636629105,
-0.33395373821258545,
-0.07961884140968323,
-0.05608478561043739,
-0.2793854773044586,
-0.05792221054434776,
0.03773767501115799,
-0.26784053444862366,
-0.3196636140346527,
-0.6134303212165833,
0.4378480613231659,
-0.058435071259737015,
-0.14018943905830383,
-0.7260422706604004,
0.5639772415161133,
1.0169705152511597,
-0.06724309176206589,
0.13987261056900024,
0.3149878978729248,
-0.441639244556427,
-0.512362003326416,
-0.16868527233600616,
-0.3909051716327667,
-0.44594964385032654,
0.4512176215648651,
-0.3590048551559448,
-0.9574422240257263,
0.16514483094215393,
0.1425468921661377,
0.058669909834861755,
0.3174242079257965,
0.843769907951355,
0.043045636266469955,
0.9908113479614258,
0.6279641389846802,
-0.23149991035461426,
0.6790552139282227,
-0.039031777530908585,
0.3404374122619629,
-0.6964997053146362,
0.281411737203598,
-0.4894501268863678,
-0.392194539308548,
-0.5228964686393738,
-0.4360464811325073,
0.313249409198761,
-0.6259126663208008,
-0.24484434723854065,
0.4794631600379944,
-0.8962773084640503,
0.40786367654800415,
0.5416387319564819,
-0.20107662677764893,
0.13660022616386414,
0.15627340972423553,
0.11162906140089035,
-0.3783106505870819,
-0.9583228826522827,
-0.35345473885536194,
1.0887322425842285,
0.5552641749382019,
0.9686523675918579,
-0.1247028112411499,
0.7984644174575806,
0.2284330129623413,
0.1108311340212822,
-0.9628629088401794,
0.4984075725078583,
-0.2714097499847412,
-0.5552671551704407,
-0.35803890228271484,
-0.19371816515922546,
-0.8944249749183655,
0.11432630568742752,
0.0007982776151038706,
-0.7767921090126038,
0.18036283552646637,
0.19474224746227264,
-0.6638258695602417,
0.17890667915344238,
-0.7869768142700195,
0.7899516820907593,
0.048720505088567734,
-0.4242601990699768,
-0.08592819422483444,
-0.680878221988678,
0.13409557938575745,
-0.18075500428676605,
0.1847645342350006,
0.41067078709602356,
0.06292258948087692,
0.4606547951698303,
-0.27348941564559937,
1.1105297803878784,
0.08712826669216156,
-0.030510926619172096,
0.39911097288131714,
-0.13118022680282593,
0.5375052094459534,
-0.25950556993484497,
0.30929040908813477,
-0.0466136708855629,
-0.12898851931095123,
-0.251872181892395,
-0.4203701913356781,
0.7302249073982239,
-0.5312188267707825,
-0.54033362865448,
-0.2620273530483246,
-0.4233357310295105,
-0.14131057262420654,
0.3306054174900055,
0.40221500396728516,
0.26079949736595154,
-0.3532728850841522,
0.4487088620662689,
0.7516194581985474,
-0.12821854650974274,
0.4449973404407501,
0.05586414784193039,
-0.34376341104507446,
-0.5728757381439209,
0.8510617017745972,
-0.008401681669056416,
0.5430929064750671,
0.4492584466934204,
-0.05711321532726288,
-0.11087586730718613,
-0.2990701496601105,
-0.538828432559967,
0.3284236490726471,
-0.39688247442245483,
-0.05687280371785164,
-0.6735751628875732,
-0.3274056017398834,
-0.19345079362392426,
-0.1156563088297844,
-1.093337893486023,
-0.6637014746665955,
-0.417086124420166,
0.04584398493170738,
-0.003996452782303095,
0.6978588700294495,
0.06656502187252045,
0.16013701260089874,
-0.8409931063652039,
0.5953337550163269,
0.5580185055732727,
0.03561589866876602,
0.221530020236969,
-0.8261669278144836,
-0.4044756293296814,
0.04196937009692192,
-0.31056928634643555,
-0.6662904620170593,
0.5038259029388428,
0.2988399565219879,
0.3064556121826172,
-0.06171266362071037,
-0.1296975016593933,
0.45463308691978455,
-1.0008494853973389,
0.688771665096283,
0.26167556643486023,
-1.2654132843017578,
0.6412855982780457,
-0.26133447885513306,
0.4777074456214905,
0.210399329662323,
-0.148687943816185,
-0.35010194778442383,
-0.5853003859519958,
-0.6287062764167786,
-0.8506802916526794,
0.8334757685661316,
0.551015317440033,
0.06294462829828262,
0.1558336317539215,
0.18499262630939484,
-0.015868933871388435,
0.02677503228187561,
-0.6997990608215332,
-0.4552086293697357,
-0.16828005015850067,
-0.5993302464485168,
0.0917707309126854,
-0.280388206243515,
-0.07998650521039963,
-0.14937320351600647,
0.6849709749221802,
-0.13596630096435547,
0.6188675761222839,
0.24366483092308044,
-0.027442140504717827,
-0.3109619617462158,
0.6003482341766357,
1.046661138534546,
0.2892100512981415,
-0.10776162892580032,
0.017273643985390663,
0.2364024668931961,
-0.2775839567184448,
0.2738092839717865,
0.023689938709139824,
-0.5522735118865967,
0.395722359418869,
-0.03029128722846508,
0.8653653860092163,
0.6084343194961548,
-0.377284973859787,
0.3804308772087097,
-0.15961423516273499,
-0.06733912229537964,
-0.4122644066810608,
-0.2831462323665619,
0.1689513921737671,
0.130720853805542,
0.35705167055130005,
0.14999447762966156,
0.16334651410579681,
-0.4283317029476166,
0.37931519746780396,
0.16747084259986877,
-0.4737270176410675,
-0.4632966220378876,
0.9417409300804138,
0.43063557147979736,
-0.6405282020568848,
0.1727655678987503,
0.11570340394973755,
-0.14730313420295715,
0.4139727056026459,
0.46782201528549194,
1.1253790855407715,
-0.22491610050201416,
-0.18094795942306519,
0.3520263135433197,
0.5526774525642395,
0.010045468807220459,
0.20810604095458984,
0.08031199127435684,
-0.21865589916706085,
-0.38741010427474976,
-0.36494019627571106,
-0.4292726516723633,
0.1289280503988266,
-0.6672691106796265,
0.5781105160713196,
-0.5524812936782837,
-0.19855009019374847,
0.1502925306558609,
-0.5904226303100586,
-0.6542426943778992,
0.13071158528327942,
0.29477575421333313,
0.6033450365066528,
-0.5328543782234192,
1.2759195566177368,
0.3652283251285553,
-0.2834700345993042,
-0.4995414912700653,
-0.14917466044425964,
-0.028621068224310875,
-0.36752891540527344,
0.620231568813324,
0.03949780762195587,
-0.36635759472846985,
0.39737650752067566,
-0.19305939972400665,
-0.8659557700157166,
0.9261118769645691,
0.4502744972705841,
-1.033104419708252,
-0.30886849761009216,
0.1948624551296234,
0.7791040539741516,
-0.5808666944503784,
-0.04432977735996246,
0.6035804748535156,
0.030239494517445564,
-0.0630902424454689,
-1.199623942375183,
-0.2501150369644165,
0.076092429459095,
0.2289092093706131,
0.18248538672924042,
-0.5824933648109436,
0.6837047934532166,
-0.1935412883758545,
-0.352408766746521,
0.5246978402137756,
0.6309616565704346,
-0.01734016463160515,
0.21424417197704315,
0.44685378670692444,
0.6410835981369019,
0.34236225485801697,
-0.010970973409712315,
0.796595573425293,
-0.3409498333930969,
0.6566939949989319,
1.391441822052002,
-0.2684946656227112,
0.8801886439323425,
0.7774287462234497,
-0.11621590703725815,
0.1484227031469345,
0.15844060480594635,
0.06655281037092209,
0.8129845857620239,
-0.056813500821590424,
-0.15513335168361664,
-0.012464804574847221,
-0.05038344860076904,
-0.38764140009880066,
0.40170180797576904,
0.3791316747665405,
-0.5429757237434387,
-0.07091338187456131,
0.2450031042098999,
-0.40667515993118286,
0.05008343607187271,
-0.3182075321674347,
0.8062683343887329,
0.23199476301670074,
-0.36750322580337524,
0.502348780632019,
-0.2135280817747116,
0.5948520302772522,
-0.5267707705497742,
-0.042279284447431564,
-0.07986103743314743,
0.2475845217704773,
-0.03186403959989548,
-0.4229448735713959,
0.5148105621337891,
0.07822081446647644,
-0.590179979801178,
-0.4102889597415924,
0.6382772922515869,
-0.46390005946159363,
-0.26921162009239197,
0.25820475816726685,
0.4405941069126129,
-0.26245030760765076,
0.2631833851337433,
-0.47813886404037476,
0.17496179044246674,
0.391560822725296,
-0.1884489506483078,
0.23455041646957397,
0.2836020290851593,
0.2401251196861267,
0.5772188901901245,
0.5568997859954834,
0.048707254230976105,
0.22449520230293274,
0.1144382506608963,
0.6065742373466492,
-0.6596074104309082,
-0.615405797958374,
-0.760498046875,
0.5823842287063599,
0.13942213356494904,
-0.016892846673727036,
0.4962356388568878,
0.5566407442092896,
0.8342562913894653,
-0.5546693801879883,
0.9082419276237488,
0.014530688524246216,
0.874605119228363,
-0.3356398344039917,
0.5354156494140625,
-0.4915325343608856,
0.3153132200241089,
-0.2465948760509491,
-1.0660942792892456,
-0.19986329972743988,
0.616979718208313,
-0.004324716050177813,
-0.13106808066368103,
0.7623165249824524,
0.7966349124908447,
-0.16980154812335968,
-0.09388518333435059,
0.6181662678718567,
0.29157349467277527,
0.24066807329654694,
0.9606137275695801,
0.7268421649932861,
-0.7219605445861816,
0.9489049911499023,
-0.062139689922332764,
-0.020443638786673546,
-0.2807207703590393,
-0.6129778623580933,
-0.7288392186164856,
-0.37163639068603516,
-0.26855093240737915,
-0.10269290208816528,
-0.07026463747024536,
1.0618318319320679,
0.7653896808624268,
-0.8921361565589905,
-0.049189258366823196,
-0.10800129175186157,
0.10531525313854218,
-0.04304022341966629,
-0.24607039988040924,
0.2457924485206604,
-0.23443540930747986,
-1.2803105115890503,
0.47195035219192505,
0.6855345964431763,
0.22733327746391296,
-0.2534920573234558,
0.1330171674489975,
0.030976552516222,
0.20689716935157776,
0.6704521179199219,
0.7567098140716553,
-1.001345157623291,
-0.49403053522109985,
0.1552795171737671,
-0.29733848571777344,
0.11231523007154465,
0.883074164390564,
-0.7297746539115906,
0.5397400259971619,
0.388801246881485,
0.892783522605896,
0.6524604558944702,
-0.3986144959926605,
0.576841413974762,
-0.9898391366004944,
0.4833510220050812,
0.4092411696910858,
0.4191215932369232,
0.35381537675857544,
-0.1314934492111206,
0.340466171503067,
0.21920379996299744,
-0.5583659410476685,
-0.9311015605926514,
0.4014577567577362,
-1.1195242404937744,
0.09748532623052597,
1.1402119398117065,
0.07099328935146332,
-0.27906811237335205,
-0.011941567994654179,
-0.5253294110298157,
0.17199312150478363,
-0.36174866557121277,
0.6038680672645569,
0.3726939558982849,
-0.03261319547891617,
-0.5330858826637268,
-0.4919891059398651,
0.39889079332351685,
0.5509762167930603,
-0.5469209551811218,
0.14617890119552612,
0.411977618932724,
0.3572489023208618,
0.33941301703453064,
0.5412397384643555,
-0.009200897067785263,
0.5027845501899719,
0.10420961678028107,
0.07477057725191116,
0.1552993357181549,
-0.4455723464488983,
-0.5071091651916504,
0.24260537326335907,
0.013117942959070206,
-0.33314579725265503
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.04461v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.04461v1
|
Multi-Label Classification for Implicit Discourse Relation Recognition
| 2024-06-06T19:37:25 | 2024-06-06T19:37:25 |
Wanqiu Long, N. Siddharth, Bonnie Webber
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Discourse relations play a pivotal role in establishing coherence within
textual content, uniting sentences and clauses into a cohesive narrative. The
Penn Discourse Treebank (PDTB) stands as one of the most extensively utilized
datasets in this domain. In PDTB-3, the annotators can assign multiple labels
to an example, when they believe that multiple relations are present. Prior
research in discourse relation recognition has treated these instances as
separate examples during training, and only one example needs to have its label
predicted correctly for the instance to be judged as correct. However, this
approach is inadequate, as it fails to account for the interdependence of
labels in real-world contexts and to distinguish between cases where only one
sense relation holds and cases where multiple relations hold simultaneously. In
our work, we address this challenge by exploring various multi-label
classification frameworks to handle implicit discourse relation recognition. We
show that multi-label classification methods don't depress performance for
single-label prediction. Additionally, we give comprehensive analysis of
results and data. Our work contributes to advancing the understanding and
application of discourse relations and provide a foundation for the future
study
|
[
-0.4719284176826477,
-0.6237509250640869,
0.6674891114234924,
0.5731668472290039,
-0.16166678071022034,
0.16777129471302032,
0.20615924894809723,
-0.6933574676513672,
-0.2551591694355011,
0.22307783365249634,
-0.36809033155441284,
-0.45346763730049133,
-0.6704190373420715,
0.13214027881622314,
-0.08508796989917755,
1.1180860996246338,
-0.064190573990345,
0.19262295961380005,
-0.25520384311676025,
-0.5939897894859314,
-0.20508797466754913,
-0.7192051410675049,
-0.6117262244224548,
-0.36921459436416626,
0.5794369578361511,
0.13074006140232086,
0.29441866278648376,
0.39017486572265625,
0.014214955270290375,
0.28542375564575195,
-0.3079836666584015,
0.06703248620033264,
-0.2817381024360657,
0.36716288328170776,
0.15793760120868683,
-0.110694020986557,
-0.4264823794364929,
0.1722317785024643,
0.7260668873786926,
0.7611140608787537,
0.2966597080230713,
0.02558760903775692,
0.20001405477523804,
0.0496806800365448,
-0.7044103741645813,
0.5602597594261169,
-0.3589121401309967,
0.03301260247826576,
-0.2786543667316437,
-0.00648365868255496,
-0.7319052815437317,
-0.6854320764541626,
0.5057646036148071,
-0.5976687669754028,
0.13320164382457733,
0.17777019739151,
0.8801428079605103,
0.020017297938466072,
-1.1381207704544067,
-0.25328248739242554,
-0.6462072134017944,
0.3970390260219574,
-0.29974040389060974,
0.3245963156223297,
0.19794082641601562,
0.11535736918449402,
-0.06384263187646866,
-0.6144186854362488,
-0.4667998254299164,
0.07901576161384583,
-0.5621611475944519,
0.406833291053772,
0.05793500319123268,
0.3483182191848755,
0.39643919467926025,
0.1569097340106964,
-0.4427482485771179,
0.00492507079616189,
-0.28856492042541504,
-0.36537691950798035,
0.11147557199001312,
-0.0867033451795578,
0.07866230607032776,
-0.3168858587741852,
-0.8248034119606018,
0.16216115653514862,
-0.5462449193000793,
0.0982188805937767,
0.16883370280265808,
0.1273738294839859,
0.12428751587867737,
0.17435188591480255,
0.24877169728279114,
0.5410791039466858,
-0.06210073456168175,
-0.4431314468383789,
0.07993684709072113,
-0.2549036741256714,
-0.015179414302110672,
0.48923999071121216,
0.8975435495376587,
-0.031232547014951706,
0.14653372764587402,
0.19403555989265442,
0.37556615471839905,
0.12049030512571335,
0.04837920144200325,
-0.737127423286438,
-0.11845797300338745,
0.03665577247738838,
-0.3677753806114197,
0.16312523186206818,
0.038453251123428345,
-0.6951302886009216,
-0.41092848777770996,
-0.3436078429222107,
-0.11992661654949188,
-0.44602856040000916,
-0.4929460287094116,
-0.34576907753944397,
-0.1765987128019333,
0.30998966097831726,
0.44031280279159546,
-0.5671428442001343,
0.8057351112365723,
0.7076740264892578,
0.7512056827545166,
-0.018284302204847336,
-0.49503764510154724,
-0.2733592689037323,
0.5848547220230103,
-0.13787841796875,
0.9408167004585266,
-0.48585426807403564,
-0.19392821192741394,
0.10605098307132721,
-0.08468367904424667,
-0.1927156299352646,
-0.07151304930448532,
0.80806964635849,
-0.3334018886089325,
0.3442688584327698,
-0.26927924156188965,
-0.6208109855651855,
-0.41947683691978455,
0.27030089497566223,
-0.7425704002380371,
0.8072265386581421,
-0.10785476118326187,
-1.0121588706970215,
0.4841875731945038,
-0.3362260162830353,
-0.5612661838531494,
0.05195015296339989,
-0.19755521416664124,
-0.7232345938682556,
0.05232401564717293,
0.09994195401668549,
0.6018795967102051,
-0.21445299685001373,
0.4818921983242035,
-0.6057723164558411,
-0.24575820565223694,
0.2199040949344635,
-0.5003708004951477,
0.9744055867195129,
-0.22486960887908936,
0.05759860947728157,
0.08057606965303421,
-0.8560115694999695,
-0.13799980282783508,
-0.3388040065765381,
-0.15945537388324738,
-0.9126121997833252,
-0.23832349479198456,
0.0365215539932251,
0.3552691638469696,
-0.1351187378168106,
-0.6170336604118347,
0.2473694086074829,
-0.23244458436965942,
0.021149106323719025,
0.7888140082359314,
0.07520515471696854,
0.3889612555503845,
0.12350494414567947,
0.3719509541988373,
0.2674591839313507,
-0.19168974459171295,
-0.3101995885372162,
-0.5869359970092773,
-0.834422767162323,
-0.4802369475364685,
0.7025867700576782,
0.459388792514801,
-0.4905068576335907,
0.12388774007558823,
-0.2686631977558136,
-0.367778480052948,
-0.39907240867614746,
-0.4114568829536438,
0.699051022529602,
0.6327503323554993,
0.5221351981163025,
-0.017325688153505325,
-0.5969089269638062,
-0.9916613101959229,
-0.08106998354196548,
-0.33347249031066895,
0.31547003984451294,
0.3322499692440033,
0.560372531414032,
0.3231995105743408,
1.0051636695861816,
-0.7244154810905457,
-0.5701516270637512,
0.23974435031414032,
0.8560745716094971,
-0.26807940006256104,
0.398522287607193,
0.5767138004302979,
-0.7670386433601379,
-0.6601474285125732,
-0.013269373215734959,
-0.738495409488678,
-0.05278713256120682,
-0.09706594049930573,
-0.08954818546772003,
0.30900150537490845,
0.32566386461257935,
-0.3740053176879883,
0.4785501956939697,
0.37683022022247314,
-0.3540205955505371,
0.5024391412734985,
-0.12370225787162781,
-0.05377883091568947,
-0.9300869107246399,
-0.19283021986484528,
0.1784646213054657,
-0.26240628957748413,
-0.6633100509643555,
-0.582172155380249,
0.20755799114704132,
0.1427874118089676,
-0.49030938744544983,
0.5188270211219788,
-0.6314162611961365,
-0.17269761860370636,
0.017215995118021965,
-0.20163382589817047,
0.14614258706569672,
0.8183504343032837,
0.31124329566955566,
0.4819857180118561,
0.480448454618454,
-0.6877669095993042,
0.15547293424606323,
0.33042943477630615,
-0.060192424803972244,
1.073807716369629,
-0.40344852209091187,
0.2424558401107788,
-0.2374080866575241,
0.6505616307258606,
-1.3249999284744263,
-0.01916908472776413,
0.6586191058158875,
-0.16453978419303894,
0.43887341022491455,
-0.4123637080192566,
-0.5092850923538208,
-0.1655794233083725,
-0.25156116485595703,
0.47842153906822205,
-0.14801940321922302,
-0.628892719745636,
0.8283243775367737,
0.5227820873260498,
-0.36476337909698486,
-0.6999995112419128,
-0.44852906465530396,
-0.3099867105484009,
-0.31479576230049133,
-0.18317364156246185,
0.4924784004688263,
0.1954043060541153,
0.17776857316493988,
0.12910324335098267,
-0.38149333000183105,
-0.676214337348938,
-0.005738353356719017,
0.5723795294761658,
0.24256330728530884,
0.03674475476145744,
0.41402125358581543,
0.642127513885498,
-0.30141228437423706,
0.20237310230731964,
0.01316482201218605,
0.07633397728204727,
-0.28634196519851685,
-0.16292154788970947,
-0.37455278635025024,
0.5051374435424805,
0.48937997221946716,
-0.06454356014728546,
0.8076871633529663,
0.6520224213600159,
-0.534027636051178,
0.2048150599002838,
-0.5149129629135132,
0.21891067922115326,
-0.31729623675346375,
0.1308712363243103,
-0.8058650493621826,
-0.8068329691886902,
0.3630424439907074,
-0.5655126571655273,
-0.07960890978574753,
0.3310520648956299,
-0.02500552497804165,
-0.14912894368171692,
0.852033793926239,
0.4910922348499298,
0.04377042502164841,
-0.02700302004814148,
0.15066447854042053,
-0.011014538817107677,
-1.1185673475265503,
-0.31818389892578125,
-0.7219400405883789,
-0.10409092158079147,
-0.6235061287879944,
0.13495399057865143,
0.40559569001197815,
0.025336340069770813,
-0.16477590799331665,
0.35785195231437683,
-0.5204491019248962,
0.4658429026603699,
0.3390534520149231,
-0.11933275312185287,
0.5446745157241821,
-0.21443504095077515,
-0.35567641258239746,
-0.3980166018009186,
-0.5736698508262634,
-0.5347280502319336,
0.732903242111206,
0.3192477524280548,
0.239584282040596,
0.19510307908058167,
0.620562732219696,
-0.18297891318798065,
0.8510252237319946,
-0.6630082726478577,
0.5761982798576355,
-0.0767660140991211,
-0.5471553802490234,
0.00204547680914402,
-0.4199902415275574,
-1.2131664752960205,
0.7443637847900391,
-0.08154869079589844,
-0.8371569514274597,
0.36037296056747437,
0.06756877154111862,
-0.2513718903064728,
-0.13383932411670685,
-0.8037818074226379,
1.0138098001480103,
-0.34177353978157043,
-0.40661725401878357,
0.22317443788051605,
-0.7180794477462769,
0.7013888955116272,
0.02930549532175064,
0.2615193724632263,
-0.2948657274246216,
0.03727081045508385,
0.8433637619018555,
0.016817882657051086,
0.9673200249671936,
-0.18981464207172394,
-0.1785450428724289,
0.14071181416511536,
-0.10509449243545532,
-0.1032806783914566,
0.23622474074363708,
0.16356278955936432,
0.1436527520418167,
0.2105398029088974,
-0.04972139000892639,
-0.3288818597793579,
0.671047568321228,
-0.7019398808479309,
-0.31593725085258484,
-1.0649564266204834,
-0.3842184543609619,
-0.35840505361557007,
0.32485491037368774,
0.05692427232861519,
0.3733031749725342,
-0.60499507188797,
-0.02021298184990883,
0.6444826126098633,
-0.030498439446091652,
0.3674025535583496,
0.45640087127685547,
-0.3075430691242218,
-0.5551796555519104,
0.7918822765350342,
0.4183020293712616,
-0.16994702816009521,
0.2938493490219116,
0.09151292592287064,
-0.660551130771637,
-0.16027165949344635,
-0.15587832033634186,
0.2092284858226776,
-0.744272768497467,
-0.4110212028026581,
-0.7853579521179199,
-0.132764533162117,
-0.461259663105011,
0.2725684344768524,
-0.1319124847650528,
-0.39967668056488037,
-0.39942219853401184,
-0.044819530099630356,
0.19648706912994385,
0.6956526041030884,
0.18132168054580688,
0.35770031809806824,
-0.6062914133071899,
0.6124790906906128,
0.5058215856552124,
0.4497620165348053,
-0.15524457395076752,
-0.0970655009150505,
0.25828903913497925,
-0.3477061092853546,
-0.6017051339149475,
-1.4240949153900146,
0.1923220306634903,
0.33356592059135437,
0.47619444131851196,
0.3470318019390106,
0.18580007553100586,
0.766843855381012,
-0.6510493159294128,
0.24452736973762512,
0.27638721466064453,
-1.1368467807769775,
0.5392106175422668,
-0.12070664018392563,
0.40758731961250305,
0.44468069076538086,
0.8706051111221313,
-0.28293225169181824,
-0.3548027575016022,
-0.6461645364761353,
-0.9676321744918823,
0.9635604619979858,
0.1922537237405777,
-0.2181670367717743,
0.21154654026031494,
0.09668605774641037,
0.3413492739200592,
0.38067367672920227,
-1.0738346576690674,
-0.4888048470020294,
-0.12545794248580933,
-0.16988308727741241,
0.2556943893432617,
-0.40587344765663147,
-0.24921993911266327,
-0.3961066007614136,
0.7130529284477234,
-0.29126954078674316,
0.2715778052806854,
-0.09847205132246017,
-0.18678419291973114,
0.18727564811706543,
0.6461852788925171,
0.522442638874054,
0.6080448627471924,
-0.20739668607711792,
0.46418970823287964,
0.11502864211797714,
-0.2255481630563736,
0.557429850101471,
0.7051509618759155,
-0.16568244993686676,
0.19516338407993317,
0.11468368768692017,
0.8114216923713684,
0.4078531265258789,
0.04204511642456055,
0.4461449384689331,
-0.36612188816070557,
-0.1842261403799057,
-0.28126659989356995,
-0.46168187260627747,
0.20252275466918945,
-0.015174681320786476,
0.21420766413211823,
0.31937375664711,
0.36554956436157227,
-0.5443181395530701,
0.11967749148607254,
0.2770187556743622,
-0.3850732147693634,
-0.18586236238479614,
0.29687756299972534,
0.18412575125694275,
0.033120546489953995,
0.49467793107032776,
-0.4423183798789978,
-0.8555506467819214,
0.4154600203037262,
0.46556222438812256,
0.6939588189125061,
-0.4550868272781372,
0.3928873836994171,
0.46009355783462524,
0.07960662990808487,
-0.0734155923128128,
-0.1442650854587555,
-0.0723399892449379,
-0.7498360276222229,
-0.46090787649154663,
-0.34549587965011597,
-0.6640588641166687,
0.2337677925825119,
-0.8226991891860962,
0.15223149955272675,
-0.39815130829811096,
-0.233188197016716,
0.29228246212005615,
-0.29214954376220703,
-0.4985046982765198,
-0.029832951724529266,
0.27942582964897156,
0.21535278856754303,
-0.9315508008003235,
0.9842935800552368,
0.6598479747772217,
-0.2721215784549713,
-0.47045236825942993,
0.02620766870677471,
0.21037723124027252,
0.04836639389395714,
0.7448458075523376,
0.6445937156677246,
-0.25643348693847656,
-0.12357690185308456,
-0.24049724638462067,
-0.6436274647712708,
0.7263635993003845,
0.5692617893218994,
-0.3377312421798706,
0.11879384517669678,
0.021214548498392105,
0.6207286715507507,
-0.2678277790546417,
0.41240739822387695,
0.5540276169776917,
0.602149248123169,
0.1163455992937088,
-0.8771377205848694,
0.1458617001771927,
0.061409369111061096,
0.05358659476041794,
0.2807468771934509,
-0.49235063791275024,
0.7576479315757751,
0.2377808392047882,
-0.40651342272758484,
-0.20136184990406036,
0.8462575674057007,
0.5665298700332642,
0.5354260206222534,
0.5057493448257446,
0.38889721035957336,
0.9024332165718079,
-0.682456910610199,
0.7140047550201416,
0.06164797395467758,
0.2836381494998932,
1.7018587589263916,
-0.5274152159690857,
0.5934687852859497,
0.30803370475769043,
-0.1635211706161499,
0.603029727935791,
0.6334697008132935,
0.06336188316345215,
0.3305669128894806,
0.12035159766674042,
-0.3355942666530609,
0.01302864495664835,
-0.40677955746650696,
-0.488485187292099,
0.4481354057788849,
0.7021530270576477,
-0.11294626444578171,
-0.14376771450042725,
0.15047375857830048,
0.197423055768013,
-0.09331841766834259,
-0.22715869545936584,
1.0056663751602173,
0.12244994938373566,
-0.8341142535209656,
0.3881985545158386,
-0.3263486921787262,
0.39935705065727234,
-0.40717026591300964,
-0.2478913962841034,
0.2875120937824249,
0.2771456241607666,
-0.1721738576889038,
-0.907853364944458,
0.21881817281246185,
-0.44982805848121643,
0.030592914670705795,
-0.5747051239013672,
1.0111638307571411,
-0.6610711812973022,
-0.3688543438911438,
0.5093016028404236,
0.5772998929023743,
-0.08522013574838638,
0.08351701498031616,
-0.6316695809364319,
0.1421227902173996,
-0.41865992546081543,
-0.1636330932378769,
0.22616270184516907,
0.701124370098114,
0.09129463136196136,
0.35910892486572266,
0.24764838814735413,
-0.19075606763362885,
0.03499729558825493,
-0.02213858999311924,
0.746509313583374,
-0.46405985951423645,
-0.4240739345550537,
-0.691900908946991,
0.4457094669342041,
-0.4065970480442047,
-0.3948085606098175,
0.7851528525352478,
0.5875745415687561,
0.6740872859954834,
0.00908441562205553,
0.8149479031562805,
0.19413217902183533,
0.5432145595550537,
-0.34385818243026733,
0.2200494408607483,
-0.0727948471903801,
0.09784761071205139,
-0.6035371422767639,
-0.913600504398346,
-0.5046064257621765,
0.7995687127113342,
-0.27440860867500305,
-0.057996299117803574,
1.0518146753311157,
0.08626072853803635,
-0.03908391669392586,
0.3044707477092743,
-0.10457129776477814,
0.30977341532707214,
0.15324494242668152,
0.5228884816169739,
0.9886256456375122,
-0.4179278314113617,
0.8537303805351257,
-0.2064516842365265,
-0.07253730297088623,
0.25598326325416565,
-0.9577571153640747,
-0.8113200068473816,
-0.7427290081977844,
-0.6168529391288757,
-0.3072741627693176,
0.02381681650876999,
0.5346396565437317,
0.7536132335662842,
-0.6949865221977234,
-0.28728562593460083,
-0.1883087009191513,
0.4457511603832245,
-0.3969494700431824,
-0.2740432024002075,
0.3733616769313812,
-0.051043860614299774,
-0.785124659538269,
-0.004123269114643335,
0.44518381357192993,
0.296796590089798,
-0.15499615669250488,
0.14182765781879425,
-0.7057703137397766,
-0.27386823296546936,
0.8770959377288818,
0.2099972665309906,
-0.7620434165000916,
-0.21681907773017883,
-0.556365430355072,
-0.03444505110383034,
0.3112335801124573,
0.9570078253746033,
-0.9190482497215271,
0.3822488784790039,
0.32362619042396545,
0.4248005151748657,
0.7435504794120789,
-0.044908758252859116,
0.4446657598018646,
-1.1846866607666016,
0.037582796066999435,
0.35352572798728943,
0.4080750048160553,
0.22059504687786102,
-0.09955301880836487,
0.47268086671829224,
0.08399274945259094,
-0.45609113574028015,
-0.7299144268035889,
0.41983941197395325,
-1.1332755088806152,
-0.3827463686466217,
1.0209760665893555,
-0.5489547252655029,
-0.008175518363714218,
-0.8368068933486938,
-0.6254796385765076,
0.49971187114715576,
-0.6627497673034668,
0.42603304982185364,
0.8725606203079224,
-0.41864871978759766,
-0.5559107065200806,
-0.21159237623214722,
0.5121219754219055,
0.155968576669693,
-1.038082242012024,
0.0992334708571434,
0.6656721830368042,
-0.07265246659517288,
0.581620454788208,
0.8665409088134766,
0.21262779831886292,
0.03714941814541817,
-0.21872560679912567,
-0.35370442271232605,
0.22966209053993225,
-0.6129782795906067,
-0.13116449117660522,
0.8347456455230713,
-0.17195962369441986,
-0.060019463300704956
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.04460v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.04460v1
|
Evaluating the Smooth Control of Attribute Intensity in Text Generation with LLMs
| 2024-06-06T19:35:51 | 2024-06-06T19:35:51 |
Shang Zhou, Feng Yao, Chengyu Dong, Zihan Wang, Jingbo Shang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Controlling the attribute intensity of text generation is crucial across
scenarios (e.g., writing conciseness, chatting emotion, and explanation
clarity). The remarkable capabilities of large language models (LLMs) have
revolutionized text generation, prompting us to explore such \emph{smooth
control} of LLM generation. Specifically, we propose metrics to assess the
range, calibration, and consistency of the generated text's attribute intensity
in response to varying control values, as well as its relevance to the intended
context. To quantify the attribute intensity and context relevance, we propose
an effective evaluation framework leveraging the Elo rating system and GPT4,
both renowned for their robust alignment with human judgment. We look into two
viable training-free methods for achieving smooth control of LLMs: (1)
Prompting with semantic shifters, and (2) Modifying internal model
representations. The evaluations of these two methods are conducted on $5$
different attributes with various models. Our code and dataset can be obtained
from \url{https://github.com/ShangDataLab/Smooth-Control}.
|
[
-0.12204264104366302,
-0.8581997752189636,
0.607936441898346,
0.36732199788093567,
-0.20539630949497223,
-0.24438802897930145,
-0.40079087018966675,
-0.40619924664497375,
-0.2446051985025406,
0.4428357779979706,
-0.556946873664856,
-0.5200770497322083,
-0.6260519027709961,
0.16559070348739624,
-0.5388633012771606,
1.3490344285964966,
-0.39318522810935974,
-0.23942042887210846,
-0.15114450454711914,
0.10731231421232224,
-0.4608755111694336,
-0.31300508975982666,
-0.778268039226532,
-0.5182438492774963,
0.7955467700958252,
0.1615799367427826,
0.6334577798843384,
0.4960269033908844,
0.5488269329071045,
0.30100566148757935,
-0.08979178965091705,
0.20562028884887695,
-0.8483303189277649,
0.4655492603778839,
0.132104754447937,
-0.20422357320785522,
-0.6437789797782898,
0.03061208687722683,
0.8166494369506836,
0.43096184730529785,
-0.07459075003862381,
-0.052509892731904984,
0.4827241599559784,
0.4052841067314148,
-0.5477957129478455,
-0.13471642136573792,
-0.9522584080696106,
0.02371114492416382,
0.008708134293556213,
-0.5349957346916199,
-0.4146827757358551,
-0.30725303292274475,
0.047740425914525986,
-0.5411033034324646,
0.16215544939041138,
0.00045874013449065387,
0.9270506501197815,
0.19182975590229034,
-0.6251111626625061,
-0.29612430930137634,
-0.9799809455871582,
0.8798938393592834,
-0.5224761962890625,
0.38656750321388245,
0.45552510023117065,
-0.03009503334760666,
-0.19196030497550964,
-0.7369828820228577,
-0.42322131991386414,
-0.5017308592796326,
0.18272559344768524,
0.30095192790031433,
0.1313663125038147,
0.16575250029563904,
0.23011761903762817,
0.4815940260887146,
-0.3828442096710205,
0.49155834317207336,
-0.08258715271949768,
-0.23078835010528564,
0.7127963304519653,
0.4401450455188751,
0.08931152522563934,
-0.012501982972025871,
-0.35341838002204895,
-0.008786280639469624,
-0.7477268576622009,
0.037797264754772186,
0.6465533971786499,
-0.03694777935743332,
-0.006328413262963295,
0.698384702205658,
-0.2860366702079773,
0.483386367559433,
0.3182239234447479,
-0.27416330575942993,
0.0910455733537674,
-0.4912876784801483,
-0.18400493264198303,
-0.306344598531723,
0.8458831906318665,
0.6361117362976074,
0.15033811330795288,
-0.3916773796081543,
-0.5770029425621033,
0.0472826324403286,
0.4747164249420166,
-0.859372615814209,
0.1692531704902649,
0.26997503638267517,
-0.35583633184432983,
-0.446662962436676,
-0.259985089302063,
-0.5181923508644104,
-0.40506985783576965,
-0.35827112197875977,
0.3257039785385132,
-0.42529523372650146,
-0.06661144644021988,
-0.06571031361818314,
0.0782688707113266,
0.5437670946121216,
0.38902461528778076,
-1.0535285472869873,
0.1250656545162201,
0.6318479776382446,
0.8592914342880249,
-0.4055621325969696,
-0.1959882378578186,
-0.3276599049568176,
0.1880175620317459,
-0.4351993203163147,
0.5598458647727966,
-0.5264389514923096,
-0.5144103169441223,
0.23945143818855286,
-0.3686639070510864,
0.11483579128980637,
-0.17801497876644135,
0.7034379243850708,
-0.4582490921020508,
0.21815833449363708,
0.19753499329090118,
-0.7584618330001831,
0.1963953971862793,
0.29326656460762024,
-0.48480120301246643,
1.260748267173767,
0.17075423896312714,
-0.49275097250938416,
0.7113315463066101,
-0.30210423469543457,
-0.3824177384376526,
0.1427065134048462,
0.006235935725271702,
-0.6018956899642944,
0.30469420552253723,
0.024912353605031967,
0.6199036240577698,
-0.1729878932237625,
0.35597503185272217,
-0.1658463478088379,
-0.2723548412322998,
0.45832905173301697,
-0.5361146926879883,
0.002799455774948001,
0.09159237146377563,
-0.370059609413147,
0.3947499096393585,
-0.7978528738021851,
0.23387491703033447,
-0.1435488909482956,
-0.34934160113334656,
-0.18713876605033875,
0.20204313099384308,
0.2285390943288803,
0.10643114894628525,
0.3009151816368103,
-0.27614647150039673,
-0.00021501527226064354,
-0.33049139380455017,
0.278712660074234,
0.9161934852600098,
0.2467932105064392,
0.5684237480163574,
-0.24756944179534912,
0.4710889756679535,
-0.1865541785955429,
0.07287997752428055,
0.016773775219917297,
-0.36159688234329224,
-0.8004026412963867,
-0.15216365456581116,
0.06597847491502762,
0.34181469678878784,
-0.6387876868247986,
0.5499353408813477,
-0.05316205695271492,
-0.466022253036499,
-0.5022839903831482,
0.3568781018257141,
0.43837183713912964,
0.5867294669151306,
0.2264166623353958,
-0.3712459206581116,
0.03848477080464363,
-0.6650526523590088,
-0.4025597870349884,
0.15167273581027985,
-0.48664045333862305,
0.3140711784362793,
0.4406406879425049,
-0.07808935642242432,
0.8107113838195801,
-0.27876603603363037,
-0.08168051391839981,
-0.417694091796875,
0.4060462415218353,
-0.1975858211517334,
0.5889206528663635,
0.3847784698009491,
-0.6487400531768799,
-0.5043818950653076,
0.0004691203066613525,
-0.45172879099845886,
-0.4788561463356018,
-0.39901870489120483,
-0.42960792779922485,
0.20025156438350677,
0.3485051691532135,
-0.42737147212028503,
0.5021947026252747,
0.4349575340747833,
-0.3198058009147644,
0.551065981388092,
-0.21464812755584717,
0.3126624524593353,
-0.8493376970291138,
0.2003336399793625,
0.2371252328157425,
-0.2736411988735199,
-0.8946340680122375,
-0.025905128568410873,
0.12421980500221252,
0.20388978719711304,
-0.3998945355415344,
0.48662254214286804,
-0.3453606069087982,
0.07864399254322052,
-0.4138910174369812,
0.27207285165786743,
0.16750310361385345,
0.6272798180580139,
-0.043714236468076706,
0.6915640830993652,
0.3366406559944153,
-0.7256296277046204,
0.22571513056755066,
0.07802017778158188,
-0.4602425694465637,
0.8677361011505127,
-0.8427658081054688,
0.41695451736450195,
-0.11238287389278412,
0.09144899994134903,
-0.7404296398162842,
-0.3475359082221985,
0.01463310606777668,
-0.19361352920532227,
0.2572464942932129,
0.17438893020153046,
-0.4378056228160858,
-0.09086870402097702,
-0.4920101761817932,
0.0853542611002922,
0.607959508895874,
-0.14351987838745117,
0.4196392297744751,
0.08808312565088272,
-0.11576922982931137,
-0.3091263175010681,
-0.5144690871238708,
0.04734722524881363,
-0.448872834444046,
-0.37652796506881714,
0.5541653037071228,
-0.24553726613521576,
-0.2362516224384308,
-0.32012200355529785,
0.00962213147431612,
-0.08986006677150726,
0.24958080053329468,
0.21200047433376312,
0.1740969866514206,
0.12225771695375443,
0.0718558058142662,
0.4460600018501282,
-0.09053035825490952,
0.10594408959150314,
-0.10357896983623505,
0.4488959014415741,
0.10082890093326569,
-0.16866174340248108,
-0.6195892691612244,
0.2911319434642792,
0.12488994747400284,
-0.1596960723400116,
0.5151740908622742,
0.5705867409706116,
-0.21401934325695038,
-0.2851809859275818,
-0.33741965889930725,
-0.18369373679161072,
-0.5100094676017761,
0.6088318824768066,
-0.32143402099609375,
-0.8978095650672913,
0.6326307058334351,
0.14225485920906067,
0.16246473789215088,
0.5121484398841858,
0.9607144594192505,
0.1166800931096077,
1.4131808280944824,
0.8847828507423401,
0.11110454052686691,
0.6736080646514893,
0.042523715645074844,
0.07233325392007828,
-0.8497890830039978,
-0.27073606848716736,
-0.5133165121078491,
-0.4479049742221832,
-0.6618371605873108,
-0.17835815250873566,
0.40234822034835815,
0.1371319741010666,
-0.27978190779685974,
-0.08623377978801727,
-0.42134788632392883,
0.4007663130760193,
0.36055171489715576,
0.23620131611824036,
0.3528311550617218,
-0.14129287004470825,
0.1404411494731903,
-0.11822115629911423,
-0.4732322096824646,
-0.6954239010810852,
0.9934453964233398,
0.5306098461151123,
1.089896559715271,
-0.14563946425914764,
0.42185989022254944,
0.15828077495098114,
0.4654383361339569,
-0.8865007162094116,
0.42471233010292053,
0.0573735274374485,
-0.2583623230457306,
-0.29826733469963074,
-0.6122646927833557,
-0.8233657479286194,
0.007546063046902418,
-0.37614762783050537,
-0.7937386631965637,
-0.041491780430078506,
0.3055576682090759,
-0.29709792137145996,
0.04502411186695099,
-0.5963101983070374,
0.7123596668243408,
-0.3056486248970032,
-0.6479977965354919,
-0.1132180318236351,
-0.5158133506774902,
0.2797945439815521,
-0.1608954519033432,
-0.32716119289398193,
-0.2988588809967041,
-0.2949583828449249,
0.5599559545516968,
-0.22194963693618774,
0.731606125831604,
0.06018771603703499,
-0.3976533114910126,
0.2405679076910019,
0.1718146651983261,
0.5147203207015991,
0.09411858767271042,
-0.1505945324897766,
0.05972158908843994,
-0.4550028145313263,
-0.18017667531967163,
-0.6417434811592102,
0.7979428172111511,
-0.6986342668533325,
-0.18046967685222626,
-0.05197490006685257,
-0.8600205183029175,
-0.3592812716960907,
0.16924113035202026,
0.4860669672489166,
0.4917552173137665,
-0.30664730072021484,
0.17412322759628296,
0.6050835251808167,
-0.18468046188354492,
0.32602596282958984,
0.2227897346019745,
-0.19213391840457916,
-0.26971444487571716,
0.8534955382347107,
-0.015241657383739948,
0.5855257511138916,
0.3103371858596802,
0.15258561074733734,
-0.3590224087238312,
-0.6452596187591553,
-0.42829981446266174,
-0.11861146986484528,
-0.47479352355003357,
-0.39902999997138977,
-0.386444091796875,
-0.22554850578308105,
-0.2817230522632599,
-0.42003390192985535,
-0.04323432222008705,
-0.3258878290653229,
-0.4963293969631195,
-0.11047402024269104,
0.4901283085346222,
0.9987615346908569,
0.3379288911819458,
0.7694472670555115,
-0.41878247261047363,
0.07148334383964539,
0.042727142572402954,
0.5784356594085693,
-0.13359370827674866,
-0.6081540584564209,
-0.3362416923046112,
-0.044784825295209885,
-0.6073252558708191,
-0.9048090577125549,
0.6474950909614563,
0.4760171175003052,
0.2100057750940323,
0.3978237807750702,
-0.23067906498908997,
0.41792386770248413,
-0.6258453130722046,
0.9226663112640381,
0.13495898246765137,
-1.0552022457122803,
0.5414581298828125,
-0.3329348862171173,
0.3762645125389099,
0.5127243399620056,
0.3390919268131256,
-0.49689891934394836,
-1.056176781654358,
-0.3446485996246338,
-1.0541948080062866,
0.45938366651535034,
0.3189253509044647,
0.38170936703681946,
0.2669251561164856,
0.6907932758331299,
0.1856725960969925,
0.2613953649997711,
-0.8748133182525635,
0.015172101557254791,
-0.3091246783733368,
-0.5699180960655212,
0.08030737191438675,
-0.33090940117836,
-0.07960493862628937,
0.1318930685520172,
0.4968324601650238,
-0.21863675117492676,
0.20293042063713074,
0.139038547873497,
-0.07027897983789444,
-0.18148203194141388,
0.32135167717933655,
0.5961465835571289,
0.49537184834480286,
-0.03324376046657562,
0.08548443019390106,
0.18225456774234772,
-0.5863977670669556,
-0.10652108490467072,
-0.08231163024902344,
-0.4856732487678528,
-0.24019545316696167,
0.22094526886940002,
1.0990591049194336,
0.22342459857463837,
-0.316010981798172,
0.32676962018013,
0.041877634823322296,
-0.2668819725513458,
0.20535974204540253,
0.27715590596199036,
-0.4208551347255707,
-0.09916341304779053,
0.2123347669839859,
-0.3937261402606964,
0.1707339733839035,
-0.07381554692983627,
0.018034230917692184,
0.5101323127746582,
-0.46577972173690796,
-0.3827818036079407,
0.8489953875541687,
0.37879183888435364,
-0.05437011644244194,
0.5662807822227478,
-0.13429206609725952,
-0.42452892661094666,
0.4431799352169037,
0.6814454197883606,
1.1558160781860352,
-0.13451917469501495,
0.07064973562955856,
0.20422929525375366,
0.4002969264984131,
0.21118415892124176,
0.1866159737110138,
0.021300289779901505,
-0.7435912489891052,
-0.673051118850708,
-0.6405656337738037,
-0.4956398606300354,
0.15710821747779846,
-0.443485289812088,
0.2444322109222412,
-0.40670081973075867,
-0.2610155940055847,
-0.24275819957256317,
0.054790809750556946,
-0.6543712615966797,
0.15706932544708252,
0.11691129952669144,
0.807181715965271,
-0.7456454038619995,
0.6713391542434692,
0.2617214620113373,
-0.3336796462535858,
-0.7844085097312927,
0.08131445199251175,
-0.1499835103750229,
-0.667368471622467,
0.4461381137371063,
0.235931396484375,
-0.30282145738601685,
0.08239521086215973,
-0.784795880317688,
-0.4578514099121094,
1.1106709241867065,
0.10926183313131332,
-0.4442038834095001,
0.02152058854699135,
0.13476350903511047,
0.7020221948623657,
-0.3725805878639221,
0.4593607485294342,
0.6711753010749817,
0.44845056533813477,
-0.07555931061506271,
-0.9241575598716736,
-0.1673690229654312,
-0.08707144111394882,
0.36942583322525024,
0.24598310887813568,
-0.405832439661026,
0.5189359188079834,
0.06571755558252335,
-0.22359314560890198,
0.2794700562953949,
1.074013590812683,
0.048510774970054626,
0.2190999835729599,
0.41813692450523376,
0.38111090660095215,
0.6992061734199524,
-0.23288501799106598,
1.1906083822250366,
-0.5425254106521606,
0.3231790363788605,
0.787638783454895,
-0.5435848236083984,
0.7343041300773621,
0.4291970729827881,
0.11277735233306885,
0.4320017695426941,
0.5132582187652588,
0.23439034819602966,
0.37989139556884766,
0.18895183503627777,
-0.4918603003025055,
-0.005209679715335369,
-0.2606496810913086,
-0.14232392609119415,
0.3351258337497711,
0.307560533285141,
-0.2110164761543274,
0.07520709931850433,
-0.015634601935744286,
0.1367364227771759,
0.04531444236636162,
-0.5481622815132141,
0.8805514574050903,
-0.04432074353098869,
-0.6892011165618896,
0.39598172903060913,
0.07957467436790466,
0.7400714755058289,
-0.947927713394165,
0.13470010459423065,
-0.3656690716743469,
0.11118166893720627,
-0.15917882323265076,
-1.0602495670318604,
0.1279176026582718,
0.3789604902267456,
0.0029481910169124603,
-0.7281391024589539,
0.8689188361167908,
-0.8140270709991455,
-0.36137625575065613,
-0.022073950618505478,
0.2385653853416443,
-0.0020611551590263844,
0.10084426403045654,
-0.5614011883735657,
0.12147165834903717,
-0.20420363545417786,
-0.6148173213005066,
0.2995714247226715,
0.5885226130485535,
-0.055607665330171585,
0.46660134196281433,
0.5159991383552551,
0.21152785420417786,
0.09378759562969208,
0.15336541831493378,
0.7562721967697144,
-0.4837839603424072,
-0.26529020071029663,
-0.7064843773841858,
0.5083809494972229,
-0.07605801522731781,
-0.7447071671485901,
0.8643636107444763,
0.3759772479534149,
0.7076459527015686,
0.1662275791168213,
0.5987316966056824,
-0.1175510436296463,
0.2605799734592438,
-0.6912623047828674,
0.744224488735199,
-0.5156288743019104,
-0.05486687645316124,
-0.3343718945980072,
-1.0205165147781372,
-0.45028403401374817,
0.5094556212425232,
-0.2990351617336273,
0.2828729450702667,
0.5373698472976685,
0.8788154125213623,
0.154961496591568,
-0.2820715308189392,
0.3289918005466461,
0.25556209683418274,
0.36618772149086,
0.4699828624725342,
0.9379166960716248,
-0.07207845151424408,
0.3698514699935913,
-0.10644658654928207,
-0.44834351539611816,
0.024431070312857628,
-1.2769323587417603,
-0.5290190577507019,
-0.36634087562561035,
-0.1691812425851822,
-0.44224563241004944,
-0.06100350618362427,
0.79814213514328,
0.4529152810573578,
-0.5360802412033081,
-0.3092551529407501,
-0.157912477850914,
0.14231759309768677,
-0.1788882315158844,
-0.22187207639217377,
0.17646844685077667,
-0.6927773952484131,
-1.0119469165802002,
0.2299022227525711,
0.3470955193042755,
0.14282117784023285,
-0.5539414882659912,
-0.31133848428726196,
0.16002580523490906,
0.2212892323732376,
0.7205410003662109,
0.014891357161104679,
-0.5343201160430908,
-0.2831808030605316,
0.013167614117264748,
-0.5555238127708435,
-0.042348701506853104,
1.0477116107940674,
-0.5141980648040771,
0.3738040030002594,
0.5356484651565552,
0.4119007885456085,
0.2855983078479767,
0.01233094185590744,
0.7435349225997925,
-0.9567711353302002,
0.08083416521549225,
0.2617329955101013,
0.08256495743989944,
0.4014153778553009,
-0.40850985050201416,
0.27920785546302795,
-0.02410617284476757,
-1.029901385307312,
-0.7387019991874695,
0.25625282526016235,
-1.0072628259658813,
0.16435076296329498,
1.2430866956710815,
-0.006115213502198458,
-0.08588576316833496,
0.19040359556674957,
-0.3519236743450165,
0.17227409780025482,
-0.4517459571361542,
0.679936945438385,
0.5220013856887817,
-0.3337692320346832,
-0.010169186629354954,
-0.6660811305046082,
0.7756195664405823,
0.4427625238895416,
-0.9380338788032532,
0.008120783604681492,
0.7681592702865601,
-0.09132611751556396,
-0.28557541966438293,
0.6748219728469849,
-0.005371027626097202,
-0.04319306090474129,
-0.35780876874923706,
0.29208293557167053,
0.3426688313484192,
-0.3437805771827698,
-0.4863033890724182,
-0.03828192502260208,
0.11728901416063309,
0.3457396328449249
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.04449v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.04449v1
|
MAIRA-2: Grounded Radiology Report Generation
| 2024-06-06T19:12:41 | 2024-06-06T19:12:41 |
Shruthi Bannur, Kenza Bouzid, Daniel C. Castro, Anton Schwaighofer, Sam Bond-Taylor, Maximilian Ilse, Fernando Pérez-García, Valentina Salvatelli, Harshita Sharma, Felix Meissen, Mercy Ranjit, Shaury Srivastav, Julia Gong, Fabian Falck, Ozan Oktay, Anja Thieme, Matthew P. Lungren, Maria Teodora Wetscherek, Javier Alvarez-Valle, Stephanie L. Hyland
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CV
|
Radiology reporting is a complex task that requires detailed image
understanding, integration of multiple inputs, including comparison with prior
imaging, and precise language generation. This makes it ideal for the
development and use of generative multimodal models. Here, we extend report
generation to include the localisation of individual findings on the image - a
task we call grounded report generation. Prior work indicates that grounding is
important for clarifying image understanding and interpreting AI-generated
text. Therefore, grounded reporting stands to improve the utility and
transparency of automated report drafting. To enable evaluation of grounded
reporting, we propose a novel evaluation framework - RadFact - leveraging the
reasoning capabilities of large language models (LLMs). RadFact assesses the
factuality of individual generated sentences, as well as correctness of
generated spatial localisations when present. We introduce MAIRA-2, a large
multimodal model combining a radiology-specific image encoder with a LLM, and
trained for the new task of grounded report generation on chest X-rays. MAIRA-2
uses more comprehensive inputs than explored previously: the current frontal
image, the current lateral image, the prior frontal image and prior report, as
well as the Indication, Technique and Comparison sections of the current
report. We demonstrate that these additions significantly improve report
quality and reduce hallucinations, establishing a new state of the art on
findings generation (without grounding) on MIMIC-CXR while demonstrating the
feasibility of grounded reporting as a novel and richer task.
|
[
-0.2828216552734375,
-0.49891331791877747,
0.7636097073554993,
0.13398520648479462,
-0.35246211290359497,
-0.19582243263721466,
0.05010626092553139,
-0.5080944299697876,
0.17384175956249237,
0.6186768412590027,
-0.28320038318634033,
-0.5930232405662537,
-0.83739173412323,
0.032471913844347,
-0.2598855495452881,
0.625542163848877,
0.05445951968431473,
0.12153974920511246,
-0.2553017735481262,
-0.4384324550628662,
-1.1238212585449219,
-0.36564815044403076,
-0.4327853322029114,
-0.4730660915374756,
0.3765065670013428,
0.6869266033172607,
0.9428783655166626,
0.38976189494132996,
0.7087148427963257,
0.19115538895130157,
0.18829572200775146,
0.484205961227417,
-0.3296360373497009,
0.19573023915290833,
0.06854743510484695,
-0.3874164819717407,
-0.5778985619544983,
-0.10541289299726486,
0.48981431126594543,
0.4511464238166809,
-0.08031783252954483,
0.010011544451117516,
-0.33868691325187683,
0.851772129535675,
-0.682796835899353,
0.1756409853696823,
-0.100542351603508,
0.08142293244600296,
0.059606440365314484,
-0.514022707939148,
-0.6611500978469849,
-0.27540579438209534,
-0.28962600231170654,
-0.46429023146629333,
0.051717609167099,
-0.0804673507809639,
0.9919766783714294,
0.17626038193702698,
-0.5732606649398804,
-0.3083857297897339,
-0.672311544418335,
0.31456682085990906,
-0.5354948043823242,
0.2716142535209656,
0.5413148403167725,
0.6622847318649292,
0.19519942998886108,
-0.9025880694389343,
-0.10370997339487076,
-0.1667381227016449,
-0.3404231369495392,
0.44015321135520935,
-0.40013575553894043,
-0.02503719925880432,
0.1569908708333969,
0.3703250288963318,
-0.4165845513343811,
-0.010591086931526661,
-0.419447660446167,
-0.0629848912358284,
0.5737441778182983,
0.11808507889509201,
0.40779975056648254,
-0.27117908000946045,
-0.0788479596376419,
-0.062391944229602814,
-0.7646566033363342,
-0.4247913956642151,
-0.20588645339012146,
-0.002410308690741658,
-0.2873384356498718,
0.7363252639770508,
-0.45697441697120667,
0.33138805627822876,
0.238974466919899,
-0.5094991326332092,
0.41208091378211975,
0.09875745326280594,
-0.07325883954763412,
0.3166033625602722,
0.3987060487270355,
0.8073030114173889,
-0.24579723179340363,
-0.06116524338722229,
-0.194753497838974,
0.4642469882965088,
0.1443641483783722,
-0.8859806656837463,
-0.1864852011203766,
0.24382872879505157,
-0.7823140025138855,
-0.7347446084022522,
0.07563482224941254,
-0.4053207337856293,
-0.42894890904426575,
-0.3914110064506531,
0.3749212324619293,
-0.36270496249198914,
-0.6896329522132874,
0.26512637734413147,
0.02940373122692108,
0.1132182776927948,
0.4005802273750305,
-0.37379780411720276,
0.2867674231529236,
0.29437652230262756,
0.6292524933815002,
0.44715777039527893,
-0.0069042993709445,
-0.9817951917648315,
0.3167942762374878,
-0.4408077001571655,
1.1163418292999268,
-0.35327228903770447,
-0.47293415665626526,
-0.1555144190788269,
-0.025516055524349213,
0.19822105765342712,
-0.547207772731781,
0.5713856220245361,
-0.4059372544288635,
0.34547755122184753,
-0.5396307706832886,
0.15618355572223663,
-0.5331247448921204,
0.3197903037071228,
-0.4959688186645508,
1.0395658016204834,
0.48964038491249084,
-0.886518120765686,
0.5150483250617981,
-0.5409382581710815,
-0.622443437576294,
-0.1343517005443573,
-0.583717405796051,
-0.31778761744499207,
0.3033507466316223,
0.4758273661136627,
0.4709753096103668,
-0.6696876287460327,
0.46923014521598816,
0.3848574161529541,
-0.17845067381858826,
0.2719903886318207,
-0.2620883584022522,
0.3950602114200592,
0.27614524960517883,
-0.5701770186424255,
0.2168719470500946,
-0.6971164345741272,
0.06940431892871857,
0.2787317633628845,
-0.06461445987224579,
0.010584529489278793,
0.032934870570898056,
-0.0192004032433033,
0.37946808338165283,
-0.31877952814102173,
-0.4973311126232147,
-0.2767714858055115,
-0.38399040699005127,
0.09416494518518448,
0.2066410332918167,
0.24648375809192657,
0.13215959072113037,
-0.8026957511901855,
0.5635147094726562,
0.3007764518260956,
0.022906990721821785,
-0.6356694102287292,
-0.5483342409133911,
-0.7493683695793152,
-0.6218114495277405,
0.04601317271590233,
0.3935241103172302,
-0.36164411902427673,
-0.03247097134590149,
-0.43100661039352417,
-0.5279174447059631,
-0.46445438265800476,
-0.27638697624206543,
0.4891929030418396,
0.6558306813240051,
0.24029885232448578,
-0.34413206577301025,
-0.576471209526062,
-0.972774863243103,
0.2308019995689392,
-0.01996774598956108,
0.12984810769557953,
0.28476592898368835,
-0.007316795643419027,
-0.5164588093757629,
0.8853843808174133,
-0.6399572491645813,
-0.5729765892028809,
-0.34096530079841614,
0.4533349275588989,
0.005789178889244795,
0.3785824179649353,
0.8195335865020752,
-0.6676496267318726,
-0.265249639749527,
0.26639801263809204,
-1.3561680316925049,
-0.09706389904022217,
-0.2333548367023468,
-0.10713078826665878,
0.09767717868089676,
0.4113991856575012,
-0.6759262681007385,
0.4448651969432831,
0.388653427362442,
-0.30923306941986084,
0.1136661022901535,
-0.4081959128379822,
0.5315686464309692,
-1.0249725580215454,
0.10177689045667648,
-0.2999765872955322,
-0.5986834168434143,
-0.14948853850364685,
0.25784456729888916,
0.12440265715122223,
-0.5333424210548401,
-0.19645963609218597,
0.14526470005512238,
-0.9507203102111816,
-0.11589882522821426,
-0.2779410481452942,
-0.08496125042438507,
0.32801878452301025,
-0.08089406043291092,
0.05022589489817619,
0.4719291925430298,
0.6609764695167542,
-0.3919197618961334,
-0.07237133383750916,
0.42934998869895935,
-0.030064374208450317,
0.38172367215156555,
-0.4886453449726105,
0.3848415017127991,
-0.526337742805481,
0.18202726542949677,
-1.1276804208755493,
-0.5466009378433228,
0.0722261592745781,
-0.5204702019691467,
0.6708038449287415,
-0.08359329402446747,
-0.5776457190513611,
-0.19283638894557953,
-0.24390475451946259,
0.3527929484844208,
0.8090221285820007,
-0.37911081314086914,
0.7198216915130615,
0.38928183913230896,
-0.11253773421049118,
-0.11599163711071014,
-0.8549033403396606,
0.3566873073577881,
-0.13760915398597717,
-0.7451835870742798,
-0.03564334660768509,
0.23383955657482147,
-0.4971647262573242,
-0.09185555577278137,
0.08586715161800385,
-0.05849601328372955,
0.18754786252975464,
0.6829650402069092,
-0.05879269912838936,
-0.6456527709960938,
-0.30457866191864014,
0.4767497777938843,
-0.5213243961334229,
0.4005490839481354,
0.14383423328399658,
0.34504860639572144,
0.004027822520583868,
-0.591244637966156,
-0.5075228810310364,
0.5290616750717163,
0.8340106010437012,
-0.3712598383426666,
0.4199252128601074,
0.3968642055988312,
-0.5453023314476013,
0.1991274654865265,
-0.7870079874992371,
-0.10059899836778641,
-0.3941340446472168,
0.07544627785682678,
-0.40226420760154724,
-0.487479567527771,
0.20873047411441803,
-0.3276533782482147,
0.014392918907105923,
0.7359222769737244,
0.766596794128418,
0.05277018994092941,
1.211440920829773,
0.5071801543235779,
0.28770801424980164,
-0.303939551115036,
-0.20279757678508759,
0.18327510356903076,
-0.49022242426872253,
-0.4861786365509033,
-0.3976518213748932,
0.14698517322540283,
-0.06643684953451157,
-0.5013533234596252,
0.6156929731369019,
-0.09139557927846909,
0.2537839412689209,
-0.3617286682128906,
-0.7262300848960876,
0.5467914938926697,
-0.032028019428253174,
0.33274415135383606,
0.4037024974822998,
0.34967491030693054,
0.015460441820323467,
-0.38402730226516724,
-0.7303651571273804,
-0.5200492143630981,
1.161128044128418,
0.36338797211647034,
0.46206343173980713,
0.2011440545320511,
0.5561413168907166,
0.49366506934165955,
0.7978283762931824,
-0.686863362789154,
0.1886468082666397,
0.024743931367993355,
-0.34985944628715515,
0.3100265562534332,
0.1568729132413864,
-0.5813462734222412,
0.43049654364585876,
-0.25197547674179077,
-0.15015624463558197,
-0.11785800009965897,
-0.22330692410469055,
-0.46043696999549866,
-0.05681685358285904,
-0.469621866941452,
0.2876444160938263,
-0.1516532152891159,
-0.2908374071121216,
-0.3865610957145691,
-0.7688315510749817,
0.6505756974220276,
-0.09052538126707077,
0.4539622366428375,
-0.15876129269599915,
0.4069315195083618,
0.6390626430511475,
-0.3400302529335022,
0.8318226933479309,
-0.302674800157547,
-0.18911953270435333,
0.4352182149887085,
0.33397385478019714,
0.1294003129005432,
0.462560772895813,
-0.016386421397328377,
0.12423154711723328,
-0.0019068971741944551,
0.014980582520365715,
-0.4171861410140991,
0.6674064993858337,
-0.763942539691925,
-0.3974806070327759,
-0.6308252215385437,
-0.6993976831436157,
-0.07281704992055893,
0.27742868661880493,
0.5275945663452148,
0.8694033026695251,
-0.2838995158672333,
0.06869228929281235,
0.4974081218242645,
-0.291756272315979,
-0.1938566416501999,
0.5141866207122803,
-0.44666144251823425,
-0.646864652633667,
0.7482323050498962,
0.24132905900478363,
-0.11450042575597763,
0.3970591723918915,
0.17560110986232758,
-0.11087533831596375,
-0.48647913336753845,
-0.43003037571907043,
0.4888257682323456,
-0.9870997667312622,
-0.5709928870201111,
-0.930214524269104,
-0.21111010015010834,
-0.31147637963294983,
-0.49330058693885803,
-0.35908710956573486,
-0.42908230423927307,
-0.19216737151145935,
-0.23064807057380676,
0.3389052748680115,
0.8659138679504395,
-0.334943562746048,
0.27736520767211914,
-0.811053454875946,
0.646783709526062,
-0.054814957082271576,
-0.30325815081596375,
-0.15278157591819763,
-0.35841771960258484,
-0.12540720403194427,
0.09934808313846588,
-0.31994208693504333,
-0.8540692329406738,
0.450417160987854,
-0.14263916015625,
0.3047991991043091,
0.5330405831336975,
0.14225947856903076,
0.7397881150245667,
-0.3630848228931427,
0.4700634181499481,
0.5168246626853943,
-0.6187841296195984,
0.8731942772865295,
-0.6394857168197632,
0.16586773097515106,
0.4713957607746124,
-0.16560541093349457,
-0.058120615780353546,
-0.4897763133049011,
-0.7046490907669067,
-0.7097445130348206,
0.5231775641441345,
0.3686788082122803,
0.09437575191259384,
-0.34857121109962463,
0.41265183687210083,
0.1711161732673645,
-0.10565073043107986,
-0.3123227655887604,
-0.008401156403124332,
-0.15773747861385345,
-0.030939962714910507,
-0.019300471991300583,
-0.9133020639419556,
-0.693760097026825,
-0.36746490001678467,
0.31657126545906067,
-0.24797751009464264,
0.5616997480392456,
0.3784038722515106,
-0.33908340334892273,
-0.39571115374565125,
0.10517511516809464,
0.5839501023292542,
1.0036967992782593,
-0.20806899666786194,
0.25837618112564087,
0.08466591686010361,
-0.14792174100875854,
0.2297559380531311,
-0.1457500457763672,
-0.14589379727840424,
0.441353976726532,
0.4362163543701172,
0.5198922753334045,
0.38343796133995056,
-0.5229190587997437,
0.669590175151825,
-0.1505795270204544,
-0.5935508012771606,
-0.5090237259864807,
-0.046778250485658646,
0.026230746880173683,
0.14175784587860107,
0.20273128151893616,
0.3056641221046448,
0.25160983204841614,
-0.298165500164032,
0.37164977192878723,
0.0085300849750638,
-0.24498729407787323,
-0.3408934772014618,
0.8959723711013794,
0.07620082050561905,
0.3302065134048462,
0.7787537574768066,
0.07138025015592575,
-0.1614793986082077,
0.7613831758499146,
0.9219907522201538,
0.81866055727005,
0.0055932230316102505,
0.41741010546684265,
0.6370636224746704,
0.44154229760169983,
-0.17917321622371674,
0.5287454724311829,
0.05142924189567566,
-0.47819840908050537,
-0.2773185074329376,
-0.0841694101691246,
-0.1871277093887329,
-0.14086054265499115,
-1.254769206047058,
0.4024326801300049,
-0.7021802067756653,
-0.09543025493621826,
-0.2200249433517456,
-0.30597159266471863,
-0.3025466501712799,
0.5754684209823608,
0.2573865056037903,
0.7211698293685913,
-0.8805915117263794,
0.6008102893829346,
0.6914786696434021,
-0.4709435701370239,
-0.8993784785270691,
-0.08495581895112991,
0.11490267515182495,
-0.6466094255447388,
0.7602791786193848,
0.7003194093704224,
-0.3543407618999481,
-0.08694769442081451,
-0.1979878693819046,
-0.7734149694442749,
1.4209096431732178,
0.496191143989563,
-0.17974284291267395,
0.221576988697052,
-0.030918734148144722,
0.3157733678817749,
-0.4813278317451477,
0.4039634168148041,
0.32890555262565613,
0.4202690124511719,
0.1347474306821823,
-0.5945853590965271,
0.43809178471565247,
-0.19572007656097412,
-0.1697862595319748,
0.0010553378378972411,
-0.6476936936378479,
0.6309821009635925,
-0.4957653284072876,
-0.33062443137168884,
0.09256619960069656,
0.7784463763237,
0.35751795768737793,
0.46229687333106995,
0.30680182576179504,
0.6365694403648376,
0.7630366683006287,
-0.04865897446870804,
1.2923632860183716,
-0.19843897223472595,
0.11040342599153519,
0.8562557101249695,
-0.5425392389297485,
0.5427730083465576,
0.21202412247657776,
0.34052160382270813,
0.41211768984794617,
0.3046347498893738,
0.1104053258895874,
0.5341272354125977,
-0.3003040552139282,
-0.1589660942554474,
-0.2866588830947876,
-0.2754303514957428,
-0.8259380459785461,
0.6242256760597229,
0.2948422431945801,
-0.34810665249824524,
-0.510563850402832,
0.24220885336399078,
0.2715975046157837,
0.08536618202924728,
-0.0035715154372155666,
0.7398037910461426,
0.04463532939553261,
-0.43501725792884827,
0.8344660401344299,
0.470733642578125,
0.051109787076711655,
-0.625630795955658,
-0.2677617073059082,
-0.41162970662117004,
0.2532636523246765,
-0.5424803495407104,
-0.37481626868247986,
0.7133539319038391,
0.13168683648109436,
-0.3087994158267975,
-0.2903079688549042,
0.8183460831642151,
0.11353588849306107,
-0.6154018044471741,
0.2622705399990082,
0.5031942129135132,
0.014569371938705444,
-0.15230123698711395,
-0.2729165256023407,
0.1923796385526657,
-0.04886062070727348,
-0.07575105875730515,
0.42647606134414673,
0.46055617928504944,
-0.30641788244247437,
0.39737215638160706,
0.622611403465271,
-0.23825955390930176,
-0.33445361256599426,
0.25330227613449097,
1.321121335029602,
-0.3665134906768799,
-0.6651168465614319,
-0.3381631672382355,
0.7182595133781433,
0.192464679479599,
-0.23471999168395996,
0.638377845287323,
0.870765209197998,
0.1261579394340515,
0.038416698575019836,
0.8177646398544312,
-0.10346919298171997,
0.4002397656440735,
-0.8894667625427246,
0.9470322132110596,
-0.6049724221229553,
0.10453803837299347,
-0.17107121646404266,
-0.5283907651901245,
-0.6070955395698547,
0.6807443499565125,
-0.02015358954668045,
-0.29290971159935,
1.0033100843429565,
0.9058409333229065,
-0.30286845564842224,
-0.16913805902004242,
0.38390877842903137,
0.3384796977043152,
0.2334071844816208,
0.13183638453483582,
0.9628968238830566,
-0.627522349357605,
0.14989696443080902,
-0.2864903509616852,
-0.37508702278137207,
-0.05031723901629448,
-0.5297337174415588,
-0.8483543395996094,
-0.26922285556793213,
-0.6204227209091187,
-0.7112379670143127,
-0.0015328924637287855,
0.40936747193336487,
0.716099739074707,
-0.5355711579322815,
0.009292255155742168,
0.029424430802464485,
-0.38747650384902954,
-0.10953900963068008,
-0.20754340291023254,
0.40868666768074036,
-0.08401380479335785,
-0.067623570561409,
0.5936025977134705,
0.5272495150566101,
-0.24785803258419037,
-0.10661819577217102,
-0.22163836658000946,
0.044110942631959915,
-0.24195095896720886,
0.7884326577186584,
0.0541301965713501,
-0.6712251901626587,
-0.07954251021146774,
-0.1661730259656906,
-0.15422789752483368,
0.4529851973056793,
0.8864009380340576,
-0.889849066734314,
0.48267683386802673,
0.17775140702724457,
0.49306222796440125,
0.6709061861038208,
-0.010790644213557243,
0.46237480640411377,
-0.43191227316856384,
0.6761049628257751,
0.1655760258436203,
0.2734117805957794,
0.42541512846946716,
-0.7672814726829529,
0.5365214943885803,
0.06841341406106949,
-0.16991469264030457,
-0.9139419794082642,
0.030324170365929604,
-1.148901343345642,
-0.16835007071495056,
1.2141215801239014,
-0.03823089227080345,
0.13671274483203888,
0.00898811873048544,
-0.6690205335617065,
0.11839216947555542,
-0.04463880509138107,
0.4430428147315979,
0.21967464685440063,
0.08269443362951279,
-0.4125424921512604,
-0.5596145391464233,
0.08160359412431717,
0.5226135849952698,
-0.7609294652938843,
-0.3889726400375366,
0.9598503708839417,
0.4408262372016907,
-0.047032274305820465,
1.0695303678512573,
-0.5054335594177246,
0.687329113483429,
0.23555633425712585,
-0.1598859429359436,
-0.47024551033973694,
-0.4717673659324646,
-0.3100048303604126,
0.5036300420761108,
0.5153399109840393,
-0.17739072442054749
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.04438v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.04438v1
|
TexIm FAST: Text-to-Image Representation for Semantic Similarity Evaluation using Transformers
| 2024-06-06T18:28:50 | 2024-06-06T18:28:50 |
Wazib Ansar, Saptarsi Goswami, Amlan Chakrabarti
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
One of the principal objectives of Natural Language Processing (NLP) is to
generate meaningful representations from text. Improving the informativeness of
the representations has led to a tremendous rise in the dimensionality and the
memory footprint. It leads to a cascading effect amplifying the complexity of
the downstream model by increasing its parameters. The available techniques
cannot be applied to cross-modal applications such as text-to-image. To
ameliorate these issues, a novel Text-to-Image methodology for generating
fixed-length representations through a self-supervised Variational Auto-Encoder
(VAE) for semantic evaluation applying transformers (TexIm FAST) has been
proposed in this paper. The pictorial representations allow oblivious inference
while retaining the linguistic intricacies, and are potent in cross-modal
applications. TexIm FAST deals with variable-length sequences and generates
fixed-length representations with over 75% reduced memory footprint. It
enhances the efficiency of the models for downstream tasks by reducing its
parameters. The efficacy of TexIm FAST has been extensively analyzed for the
task of Semantic Textual Similarity (STS) upon the MSRPC, CNN/ Daily Mail, and
XSum data-sets. The results demonstrate 6% improvement in accuracy compared to
the baseline and showcase its exceptional ability to compare disparate length
sequences such as a text with its summary.
|
[
-0.559581458568573,
-0.5428209900856018,
0.5061665773391724,
0.35513022541999817,
-0.5731269121170044,
0.07056344300508499,
-0.3955739736557007,
-0.38038507103919983,
0.09774559736251831,
0.414721816778183,
-0.45790985226631165,
-0.5642792582511902,
-0.7921138405799866,
0.4407700300216675,
-0.7682598233222961,
0.6251720190048218,
-0.1297030746936798,
-0.342174232006073,
-0.39514967799186707,
-0.2951662540435791,
-0.4403339624404907,
-0.12276393920183182,
-0.3644644618034363,
0.05082119256258011,
0.3694861829280853,
0.09387586265802383,
0.8063669800758362,
1.0333318710327148,
0.5845496654510498,
0.34218963980674744,
0.26303666830062866,
0.1177603006362915,
-0.3371952772140503,
0.17202536761760712,
-0.23798997700214386,
-0.4511176645755768,
0.06915440410375595,
-0.21020099520683289,
1.0035227537155151,
0.30113694071769714,
0.18287678062915802,
0.00915288645774126,
-0.005818272475153208,
0.7030556201934814,
-0.7321193814277649,
0.15907849371433258,
-0.5574400424957275,
0.17756222188472748,
-0.18139547109603882,
-0.47650453448295593,
-0.3797840476036072,
-0.1265791952610016,
0.022428832948207855,
-0.3607729375362396,
0.4028382897377014,
0.016739841550588608,
1.0218284130096436,
0.4540494978427887,
-0.6050264835357666,
-0.23247036337852478,
-0.892778754234314,
0.7444899082183838,
-0.576442539691925,
0.6515980362892151,
0.019405387341976166,
0.36875060200691223,
0.028750697150826454,
-0.7652888894081116,
-0.6619409918785095,
-0.24082334339618683,
-0.30585387349128723,
0.36641591787338257,
-0.24012649059295654,
-0.2395581752061844,
0.19042201340198517,
0.4398309886455536,
-0.6284373998641968,
0.02897423319518566,
0.010723208077251911,
-0.23990248143672943,
0.46238407492637634,
0.33439576625823975,
0.31407463550567627,
-0.3378138244152069,
-0.7183631658554077,
-0.48491260409355164,
-0.2466004639863968,
-0.2797453999519348,
0.18842919170856476,
0.05432915687561035,
-0.18263578414916992,
0.5840256214141846,
-0.1979416310787201,
0.5186270475387573,
-0.029420478269457817,
0.09300552308559418,
0.3207249939441681,
-0.2875118851661682,
-0.25002825260162354,
-0.18047669529914856,
0.9423083662986755,
0.52638840675354,
-0.07887208461761475,
-0.24046708643436432,
-0.297938734292984,
0.3036288917064667,
0.14794036746025085,
-0.9845593571662903,
0.350077360868454,
-0.21418596804141998,
-0.6720591187477112,
0.0719577893614769,
0.20496651530265808,
-0.9929728507995605,
0.06590940058231354,
-0.3787055015563965,
0.499119371175766,
-0.7853582501411438,
0.030375100672245026,
0.1614072173833847,
-0.17695121467113495,
0.4609113037586212,
0.1888161450624466,
-0.6419566869735718,
0.49933263659477234,
0.5250484943389893,
0.8266533613204956,
-0.3255135715007782,
-0.19457682967185974,
-0.4308473765850067,
0.19701337814331055,
-0.17740990221500397,
0.9334839582443237,
-0.5741006135940552,
-0.616904616355896,
-0.26005321741104126,
-0.12481055408716202,
-0.16068901121616364,
-0.4559085965156555,
0.5414819121360779,
-0.3816050887107849,
0.24273480474948883,
0.2956756353378296,
-0.6873891353607178,
-0.0489937998354435,
0.11596109718084335,
-0.6175642609596252,
1.1396461725234985,
0.14637194573879242,
-0.869823694229126,
0.21617965400218964,
-0.5747124552726746,
-0.3249277174472809,
0.03522207587957382,
-0.414600670337677,
-0.47427675127983093,
0.2189609706401825,
0.40761831402778625,
0.42592379450798035,
-0.5475776195526123,
-0.02344934083521366,
0.15884704887866974,
-0.4066216051578522,
0.08386755734682083,
-0.7991714477539062,
0.12055078893899918,
0.13916368782520294,
-0.5276952981948853,
0.10014156997203827,
-0.7072623372077942,
0.04255298525094986,
0.3033658266067505,
0.033260032534599304,
-0.7497667670249939,
-0.21915188431739807,
0.18069468438625336,
0.2707914113998413,
0.1811804473400116,
-0.4954884648323059,
-0.02470121905207634,
-0.562776505947113,
-0.07308349758386612,
0.5297691822052002,
-0.1393737941980362,
0.5048812627792358,
-0.06995928287506104,
0.4265006482601166,
0.09747517853975296,
0.23571494221687317,
-0.5466943979263306,
-0.27201151847839355,
-0.7486648559570312,
-0.35408318042755127,
0.5800487399101257,
0.421845406293869,
-0.8943966031074524,
0.38622066378593445,
-0.7256026864051819,
-0.5162277817726135,
-0.34658515453338623,
-0.1340532898902893,
0.29355838894844055,
0.47871050238609314,
0.5320436954498291,
-0.83917635679245,
-0.1460215151309967,
-1.2167471647262573,
-0.35217076539993286,
0.3605925142765045,
-0.45140236616134644,
0.2724913954734802,
0.437129408121109,
-0.6699008345603943,
1.0872254371643066,
-0.47573328018188477,
-0.3110858201980591,
0.08273055404424667,
0.5825697183609009,
-0.13793867826461792,
0.3614082336425781,
0.8713666200637817,
-0.7086119651794434,
-0.5899202823638916,
-0.2477569580078125,
-0.2799132168292999,
-0.02457015961408615,
-0.22520390152931213,
-0.16649143397808075,
0.3631775975227356,
0.27243801951408386,
-0.5636057257652283,
0.7187668085098267,
0.3453786075115204,
-0.537459671497345,
0.29013514518737793,
-0.3508068025112152,
0.3946802318096161,
-1.0293220281600952,
-0.0007844475912861526,
0.26166602969169617,
-0.5393348932266235,
-0.15110093355178833,
-0.14868351817131042,
0.3101541996002197,
-0.13463133573532104,
-0.2751666009426117,
0.5012256503105164,
-0.4066006541252136,
0.01994454860687256,
-0.3876214921474457,
0.13786448538303375,
0.028559528291225433,
0.2935798168182373,
0.18247456848621368,
0.7729635238647461,
0.5633661150932312,
-0.3907906711101532,
0.1050712913274765,
0.1482851505279541,
-0.06565655022859573,
0.6686076521873474,
-0.3929182291030884,
0.1091235801577568,
-0.31388241052627563,
0.22027285397052765,
-0.5657534599304199,
0.14160604774951935,
0.08323148638010025,
-0.2624286711215973,
0.5585165023803711,
0.3144758343696594,
-0.5582830905914307,
-0.28351399302482605,
-0.45202070474624634,
0.5374492406845093,
0.4794166684150696,
-0.3878651261329651,
0.87176513671875,
0.055082932114601135,
0.20574700832366943,
-0.598674476146698,
-0.6477041244506836,
0.3250028192996979,
-0.005164595786482096,
-0.5183923840522766,
0.7651692628860474,
0.14000248908996582,
0.2012891322374344,
0.3452330231666565,
-0.26993027329444885,
0.02230842225253582,
-0.3915945589542389,
0.18710854649543762,
0.21052777767181396,
-0.34560427069664,
0.21871544420719147,
0.13163922727108002,
-0.5095338225364685,
-0.031897686421871185,
-0.10633861273527145,
0.46273377537727356,
-0.3362375795841217,
-0.2088479995727539,
-0.4248390197753906,
0.7767007946968079,
0.39007100462913513,
-0.31913045048713684,
0.508289635181427,
0.8506801128387451,
-0.31462928652763367,
-0.2550424337387085,
-0.42158612608909607,
-0.2519543468952179,
-0.43064334988594055,
0.3655315935611725,
-0.2973100543022156,
-0.8592398166656494,
0.2161858081817627,
-0.3435266315937042,
-0.3680693209171295,
0.9433330297470093,
0.5007115006446838,
0.08240778744220734,
0.7972607016563416,
0.8991870880126953,
0.005778102669864893,
0.3214944005012512,
-0.30291110277175903,
0.13724711537361145,
-0.3599512279033661,
-0.18262071907520294,
-0.5413923263549805,
-0.18619172275066376,
-0.6827802658081055,
-0.9458707571029663,
0.04214507341384888,
-0.5124216675758362,
0.011715276166796684,
0.5510743260383606,
-0.5243173837661743,
0.38298431038856506,
0.4673018753528595,
-0.07175882160663605,
0.20963966846466064,
0.08413384854793549,
-0.179355651140213,
-0.2603333294391632,
-0.4356295168399811,
-0.4834730625152588,
0.7844569087028503,
0.27185824513435364,
0.9101220965385437,
-0.31429219245910645,
0.5395650267601013,
0.5355268716812134,
0.2640698254108429,
-0.8808761239051819,
0.6711216568946838,
-0.4144207835197449,
0.05322600528597832,
-0.062247004359960556,
-0.5835519433021545,
-0.9586427211761475,
-0.03410787135362625,
-0.45995625853538513,
-0.4333510100841522,
0.15839050710201263,
-0.17782051861286163,
0.09671380370855331,
0.30019617080688477,
-0.5686702132225037,
0.6888278126716614,
-0.26631319522857666,
-0.26440519094467163,
-0.3774888813495636,
-0.8754678964614868,
-0.09653592854738235,
-0.06389695405960083,
-0.07444804906845093,
-0.22337013483047485,
-0.2656736373901367,
0.6314575672149658,
-0.48523062467575073,
0.5091684460639954,
0.09885498881340027,
0.041014790534973145,
0.18294434249401093,
0.04203752428293228,
0.12873467803001404,
-0.08022619783878326,
0.05928828567266464,
0.4600719213485718,
-0.01127445325255394,
-0.2434556484222412,
-0.9680327773094177,
0.7229962944984436,
-0.5797135829925537,
-0.49394491314888,
-0.41402095556259155,
-0.588445246219635,
-0.08177697658538818,
0.21826867759227753,
0.22083836793899536,
0.5453371405601501,
-0.1832718849182129,
0.2372237592935562,
0.3796897232532501,
-0.2956877648830414,
0.6682848334312439,
0.2834712266921997,
-0.00680325785651803,
-0.2552800476551056,
0.6233452558517456,
-0.08948680758476257,
0.061317138373851776,
0.7899409532546997,
0.14918658137321472,
-0.5876149535179138,
-0.09990843385457993,
-0.3973004221916199,
0.28911638259887695,
-0.678102970123291,
-0.4246653914451599,
-0.5609902143478394,
-0.2430340200662613,
-0.13700951635837555,
-0.08503807336091995,
-0.807226300239563,
-0.4566253423690796,
-0.11142881959676743,
0.3819807767868042,
0.378274142742157,
0.4807942509651184,
0.13575905561447144,
0.20292633771896362,
-0.8881186842918396,
0.4222058057785034,
0.23255488276481628,
0.635402262210846,
-0.14964385330677032,
-0.30142468214035034,
-0.21197155117988586,
-0.19302743673324585,
-0.34669458866119385,
-0.815034806728363,
0.4809798002243042,
0.2952660620212555,
0.37151074409484863,
0.32305267453193665,
0.1119227260351181,
0.5893387794494629,
-0.5804229974746704,
0.4840248227119446,
0.25254523754119873,
-1.1164686679840088,
0.6200991868972778,
-0.030141621828079224,
0.4488794505596161,
0.31412026286125183,
0.4312782287597656,
-0.4321432113647461,
-0.4291200637817383,
-0.5307841897010803,
-1.0109758377075195,
0.30529075860977173,
0.6684017181396484,
0.41911259293556213,
-0.08784127235412598,
0.3206222355365753,
0.3716958463191986,
-0.11773232370615005,
-0.47461041808128357,
-0.5183818340301514,
-0.4516139030456543,
-0.49865221977233887,
0.03909318894147873,
-0.29178160429000854,
0.15892329812049866,
-0.18330033123493195,
0.3882216811180115,
-0.2926797866821289,
0.8948758244514465,
0.4078224301338196,
-0.033730488270521164,
0.1973935067653656,
0.4879118502140045,
0.38940075039863586,
0.30722516775131226,
0.0008491819025948644,
0.39755603671073914,
0.2791593670845032,
-0.5658246874809265,
0.011032557114958763,
0.3079301416873932,
-0.02490461803972721,
0.31958121061325073,
0.17160016298294067,
0.7782432436943054,
0.057487864047288895,
-0.649648904800415,
0.7105977535247803,
-0.4639168679714203,
0.05695014446973801,
-0.03977388143539429,
-0.07581669092178345,
-0.14178648591041565,
0.0624794103205204,
0.3967883586883545,
0.32462912797927856,
0.31746765971183777,
-0.31701764464378357,
0.44845107197761536,
0.29700928926467896,
-0.5261033773422241,
-0.09390076249837875,
0.6250628232955933,
0.09597291052341461,
-0.32025012373924255,
0.5517562031745911,
0.0468878448009491,
-0.3155819773674011,
0.6351446509361267,
0.6807918548583984,
0.9510284662246704,
-0.23596300184726715,
0.22919516265392303,
0.28903695940971375,
0.20961974561214447,
0.035129234194755554,
-0.08158241957426071,
-0.21909008920192719,
-0.49044477939605713,
-0.40480005741119385,
-0.5455248951911926,
-0.3075665831565857,
-0.19310890138149261,
-0.5637651681900024,
0.3730410933494568,
-0.031290002167224884,
-0.14432208240032196,
-0.2373121678829193,
-0.36347851157188416,
-0.8648188710212708,
0.47405412793159485,
0.2598375678062439,
0.9154319167137146,
-0.611344575881958,
0.7747378349304199,
0.3350512385368347,
-0.18599861860275269,
-0.6863341927528381,
0.33084040880203247,
-0.3926694989204407,
-0.39867210388183594,
0.4766378700733185,
0.649321973323822,
-0.3590504825115204,
-0.058926332741975784,
-0.23592083156108856,
-0.553244948387146,
1.0169546604156494,
0.5065093040466309,
-0.651717483997345,
0.266728937625885,
0.6786537766456604,
0.6257119178771973,
-0.5039740204811096,
0.5456481575965881,
0.3546755909919739,
0.36748117208480835,
0.031220315024256706,
-0.748403787612915,
0.35106998682022095,
-0.3061913847923279,
0.47476524114608765,
0.3426133096218109,
-0.4063846170902252,
0.4001777470111847,
0.0779699832201004,
-0.4486614167690277,
-0.06620041280984879,
0.7775217890739441,
-0.30189526081085205,
0.3419434130191803,
0.661568284034729,
0.5920571088790894,
0.23959340155124664,
-0.11677747964859009,
1.1066914796829224,
-0.2958678603172302,
0.5176098942756653,
1.0192344188690186,
-0.023841021582484245,
0.761588990688324,
0.5224968791007996,
0.13598565757274628,
0.7157729268074036,
0.4016568958759308,
-0.21935544908046722,
0.5070654153823853,
-0.0399775467813015,
-0.15971533954143524,
-0.12352054566144943,
-0.047185689210891724,
-0.33143994212150574,
0.6276718974113464,
0.27169811725616455,
-0.6405443549156189,
-0.7041838765144348,
0.1519515961408615,
-0.2157364934682846,
0.4279322326183319,
-0.2121860533952713,
0.454596608877182,
0.09647373110055923,
-0.30481499433517456,
0.3983686566352844,
0.30016055703163147,
0.891282856464386,
-0.5999888181686401,
-0.07561880350112915,
0.028456125408411026,
0.037909213453531265,
0.059283964335918427,
-0.7768540382385254,
0.797539472579956,
-0.04073344171047211,
-0.11782287806272507,
-0.3357146978378296,
1.0423250198364258,
-0.23584990203380585,
-0.43154647946357727,
0.4765024483203888,
0.4370432198047638,
-0.20472238957881927,
-0.13609229028224945,
-0.7495397925376892,
-0.18640470504760742,
-0.37767940759658813,
-0.32804757356643677,
0.013914900831878185,
0.4360524117946625,
-0.18699418008327484,
0.5725157260894775,
0.17373456060886383,
-0.3914974629878998,
0.021644582971930504,
0.09390148520469666,
0.856574535369873,
-0.8803450465202332,
-0.42512017488479614,
-0.9881329536437988,
0.355528324842453,
-0.1607387512922287,
-0.09127947688102722,
0.6614240407943726,
0.8696807026863098,
0.7005943655967712,
-0.4344353973865509,
0.4075796902179718,
-0.06289223581552505,
0.09141245484352112,
-0.3385179042816162,
0.6514366865158081,
-0.5832675695419312,
-0.09002026170492172,
-0.17880399525165558,
-0.912564218044281,
-0.5380894541740417,
0.3517647683620453,
-0.27514493465423584,
-0.01747553050518036,
0.9834539294242859,
0.7816165685653687,
-0.266132652759552,
-0.03698235750198364,
0.3369700610637665,
0.05901739001274109,
0.04351544380187988,
0.4535309374332428,
0.7364403009414673,
-0.6295414566993713,
0.6421247124671936,
-0.3593255281448364,
-0.1119355857372284,
0.046767812222242355,
-1.0727226734161377,
-0.7475054860115051,
-0.7592778205871582,
-0.515172004699707,
-0.04612882807850838,
-0.16456077992916107,
0.7642607092857361,
0.5101331472396851,
-0.38604190945625305,
0.048777297139167786,
-0.13097277283668518,
-0.04481542482972145,
-0.22218608856201172,
-0.2724960744380951,
0.638197660446167,
-0.14496639370918274,
-0.8170760869979858,
0.10481135547161102,
0.809080183506012,
0.123897485435009,
-0.06008196994662285,
0.1474614143371582,
-0.0034660943783819675,
0.4116418957710266,
0.6895052790641785,
0.037930697202682495,
-0.5342549681663513,
-0.4174114465713501,
0.021722765639424324,
-0.3148948848247528,
0.49591419100761414,
0.8287971019744873,
-0.9893050193786621,
0.44797590374946594,
0.608124852180481,
0.690085232257843,
0.7253615260124207,
-0.12587206065654755,
0.4724648594856262,
-0.673725962638855,
0.2409074604511261,
0.3032919466495514,
0.318739652633667,
0.40615227818489075,
-0.2981640696525574,
0.4053593575954437,
0.25766637921333313,
-0.33000317215919495,
-0.23731082677841187,
0.15860584378242493,
-1.3244013786315918,
-0.15990976989269257,
0.9093665480613708,
-0.04537021368741989,
-0.521039605140686,
0.2419634312391281,
-0.3744884133338928,
0.5080673098564148,
-0.2588411271572113,
0.8842369318008423,
0.11716010421514511,
0.1245032548904419,
-0.254412978887558,
-0.21040673553943634,
0.17816492915153503,
0.4267636835575104,
-0.9016491174697876,
-0.349595844745636,
0.2586434483528137,
0.3130572438240051,
0.15348345041275024,
0.3460855185985565,
-0.29511138796806335,
-0.02130190096795559,
-0.002424560720100999,
0.13463638722896576,
0.10887100547552109,
-0.007062407676130533,
-0.0077141388319432735,
0.22315752506256104,
-0.4316594898700714,
-0.2825629711151123
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.04432v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.04432v1
|
LipGER: Visually-Conditioned Generative Error Correction for Robust Automatic Speech Recognition
| 2024-06-06T18:17:59 | 2024-06-06T18:17:59 |
Sreyan Ghosh, Sonal Kumar, Ashish Seth, Purva Chiniya, Utkarsh Tyagi, Ramani Duraiswami, Dinesh Manocha
|
eess.AS
|
eess.AS, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Visual cues, like lip motion, have been shown to improve the performance of
Automatic Speech Recognition (ASR) systems in noisy environments. We propose
LipGER (Lip Motion aided Generative Error Correction), a novel framework for
leveraging visual cues for noise-robust ASR. Instead of learning the
cross-modal correlation between the audio and visual modalities, we make an LLM
learn the task of visually-conditioned (generative) ASR error correction.
Specifically, we instruct an LLM to predict the transcription from the N-best
hypotheses generated using ASR beam-search. This is further conditioned on lip
motions. This approach addresses key challenges in traditional AVSR learning,
such as the lack of large-scale paired datasets and difficulties in adapting to
new domains. We experiment on 4 datasets in various settings and show that
LipGER improves the Word Error Rate in the range of 1.1%-49.2%. We also release
LipHyp, a large-scale dataset with hypothesis-transcription pairs that is
additionally equipped with lip motion cues to promote further research in this
space
|
[
-0.09310083091259003,
-0.5598607063293457,
-0.03287983685731888,
0.01815730519592762,
-0.16295938193798065,
-0.046446219086647034,
-0.08399757742881775,
-0.1841435432434082,
-0.08213300257921219,
0.41976407170295715,
-0.5165615081787109,
-0.5938562750816345,
-0.5951678156852722,
-0.016712069511413574,
-0.6176470518112183,
0.6797667145729065,
0.27125564217567444,
0.565518856048584,
-0.13408243656158447,
-0.2157951444387436,
-0.48166054487228394,
-0.11167819797992706,
-0.7255130410194397,
-0.08647312968969345,
0.2809687554836273,
0.40696024894714355,
0.5376456379890442,
0.8441372513771057,
0.7867276668548584,
0.28760063648223877,
-0.033157046884298325,
-0.03342994675040245,
-0.2741711735725403,
0.13512708246707916,
0.2108365148305893,
-0.2878679931163788,
-0.3774232864379883,
-0.5798843502998352,
0.6775290369987488,
0.44708749651908875,
-0.6002795696258545,
0.05884809419512749,
0.14057216048240662,
0.8921213746070862,
-0.4855194389820099,
0.2665364444255829,
-0.7167233824729919,
0.18738776445388794,
-0.27352866530418396,
-0.11447188258171082,
-0.015779556706547737,
-0.11167079955339432,
0.2913091778755188,
-0.6099948287010193,
0.541601300239563,
0.2845938205718994,
0.6814990043640137,
1.0011924505233765,
0.08324882388114929,
-0.18885384500026703,
-0.8324834704399109,
0.6360141634941101,
-0.4924742877483368,
0.8465225100517273,
0.44406044483184814,
0.4605899453163147,
-0.16209056973457336,
-0.5431743860244751,
-0.3879243731498718,
-0.0008024845155887306,
0.2401963174343109,
0.2757319211959839,
-0.42617267370224,
0.24093450605869293,
0.46269094944000244,
0.2003384828567505,
-0.5451946258544922,
0.09557771682739258,
-0.29344990849494934,
-0.6762161254882812,
0.18800987303256989,
-0.15844348073005676,
0.5339502096176147,
-0.10882946848869324,
-0.15812066197395325,
-0.5933120250701904,
-0.4258314371109009,
0.2585235834121704,
0.05685935541987419,
0.39672279357910156,
-0.3540298044681549,
0.49750906229019165,
0.11928541958332062,
0.8621231317520142,
-0.01908160001039505,
-0.38265329599380493,
0.23940999805927277,
-0.01731782965362072,
-0.32433614134788513,
0.4586532711982727,
0.6822595000267029,
0.46710827946662903,
0.14539900422096252,
0.089226633310318,
-0.4544816315174103,
0.2822670042514801,
0.08622705191373825,
-0.636499285697937,
-0.5513066649436951,
-0.14770029485225677,
-0.10423660278320312,
0.09823165088891983,
0.16214783489704132,
-1.1333807706832886,
-0.3722008466720581,
-0.33727577328681946,
0.5189275145530701,
-0.5035833120346069,
0.1569424271583557,
0.08399812132120132,
-0.3034750819206238,
0.24933642148971558,
0.5310766696929932,
-0.6690111756324768,
0.35985562205314636,
0.2219751924276352,
0.7665306329727173,
0.04182250425219536,
-0.03606009483337402,
-1.08296537399292,
0.4515697658061981,
-0.278613418340683,
0.863030731678009,
-0.36834749579429626,
-0.5136411786079407,
0.11949563771486282,
-0.34104472398757935,
0.05785171315073967,
-0.8634511232376099,
0.649652361869812,
-0.19053736329078674,
-0.05213720351457596,
-0.37465712428092957,
-0.3054487109184265,
-0.007167189382016659,
-0.248807892203331,
-0.6869118213653564,
0.7407691478729248,
-0.23779277503490448,
-0.5894345045089722,
0.7433247566223145,
-0.44698798656463623,
-0.4399476647377014,
-0.037341829389333725,
-0.26046881079673767,
-0.7477126121520996,
0.014042827300727367,
0.6348958015441895,
0.13299083709716797,
-0.10506508499383926,
-0.15271568298339844,
-0.1860877275466919,
-0.22462357580661774,
0.31070131063461304,
-0.20384977757930756,
0.3626306354999542,
0.028582701459527016,
-0.5024542808532715,
0.2812897861003876,
-1.0539753437042236,
-0.1000879630446434,
-0.21732133626937866,
-0.36249348521232605,
-0.041398972272872925,
0.00231072586029768,
-0.16371044516563416,
-0.34150129556655884,
-0.25946152210235596,
-0.48051717877388,
-0.14873488247394562,
-0.2603137195110321,
0.39790788292884827,
0.5000476241111755,
-0.10985881090164185,
0.4399319589138031,
-0.3795849680900574,
0.580634355545044,
-0.09758247435092926,
0.01912328414618969,
-0.012103292159736156,
-0.2503969073295593,
-1.1481447219848633,
-0.6164677143096924,
0.2939933240413666,
0.8036273717880249,
-0.8919340372085571,
0.289226770401001,
-0.15821346640586853,
-0.030436424538493156,
-0.7085670232772827,
0.39528733491897583,
0.7167777419090271,
0.7297155261039734,
0.5333406329154968,
-0.30671995878219604,
-0.8452458381652832,
-0.4771829843521118,
-0.21147319674491882,
-0.19852350652217865,
-0.28946229815483093,
0.4070751965045929,
0.12095972150564194,
-0.45129212737083435,
0.6152621507644653,
-0.1652216911315918,
-0.9216313362121582,
-0.0068794796243309975,
0.28374144434928894,
-0.1045086532831192,
0.4902571439743042,
0.31718680262565613,
-0.6194725036621094,
-0.27868345379829407,
-0.30408865213394165,
-0.25289154052734375,
-0.3527664542198181,
0.10843570530414581,
0.050739835947752,
0.2195170372724533,
0.753115177154541,
-0.4082672595977783,
0.5393097400665283,
0.6189786791801453,
0.1598934680223465,
0.306615948677063,
-0.024728525429964066,
0.10779540240764618,
-0.37083524465560913,
-0.30500084161758423,
0.20017476379871368,
-0.15084308385849,
-0.5116486549377441,
-0.5696720480918884,
-0.15330494940280914,
-0.296244353055954,
-0.27068036794662476,
0.3135155737400055,
-0.4255429804325104,
-0.2954268753528595,
-0.16316650807857513,
-0.06309927999973297,
-0.2640452980995178,
0.3645176291465759,
-0.1491144746541977,
0.9171611666679382,
1.095164179801941,
-0.78780597448349,
0.4303792715072632,
0.38587233424186707,
-0.29534026980400085,
0.5832351446151733,
-0.7890397310256958,
0.11174006760120392,
-0.34717559814453125,
0.04822753369808197,
-1.133468747138977,
-0.6503068804740906,
0.29084068536758423,
-0.72309809923172,
0.6526193022727966,
-0.21033579111099243,
-0.27636823058128357,
-0.2501220703125,
-0.010757919400930405,
0.22034986317157745,
0.7895992398262024,
-0.6543379426002502,
0.7635571956634521,
0.48833584785461426,
-0.09759116917848587,
-0.5930317044258118,
-0.8433197140693665,
-0.06882161647081375,
-0.22963601350784302,
-0.3384680151939392,
0.18188916146755219,
0.17861512303352356,
-0.2719023823738098,
-0.06356420367956161,
-0.535464882850647,
0.04324407875537872,
-0.3548877537250519,
0.4118482768535614,
0.14562280476093292,
-0.009836639277637005,
0.06497792899608612,
-0.4857900142669678,
-0.15719887614250183,
-0.06644471734762192,
-0.2801287770271301,
0.06951341778039932,
-0.3466387987136841,
-0.47752851247787476,
-0.7284408807754517,
-0.19253163039684296,
0.5589017271995544,
-0.06954007595777512,
0.07825881242752075,
0.9900853037834167,
-0.44852954149246216,
-0.3337398171424866,
-0.5525034666061401,
-0.2012510448694229,
-0.5104874968528748,
0.312621146440506,
-0.09203936159610748,
-0.6903582215309143,
0.41104656457901,
0.2358296811580658,
-0.3308398127555847,
0.12392132729291916,
0.2052905112504959,
-0.552379846572876,
0.9204913377761841,
0.6074540019035339,
-0.08156187832355499,
0.7075843214988708,
-0.2827427387237549,
0.06373607367277145,
-0.8475172519683838,
-0.36394253373146057,
-0.5163378715515137,
-0.24371151626110077,
-0.22653266787528992,
-0.5679805278778076,
0.8281475901603699,
0.12762194871902466,
-0.29448679089546204,
0.05865304544568062,
-0.4671339690685272,
0.030752388760447502,
0.9788252115249634,
0.30625972151756287,
-0.013360923156142235,
0.32171809673309326,
-0.21331346035003662,
-0.3412282168865204,
-0.9086062908172607,
-0.03590475395321846,
0.6189711689949036,
0.1374310553073883,
1.3619673252105713,
0.20317940413951874,
0.32385721802711487,
0.2307385504245758,
0.05601468309760094,
-0.9025126099586487,
0.5555866956710815,
-0.39320632815361023,
-0.19552908837795258,
-0.5679416060447693,
-0.42151278257369995,
-0.6739173531532288,
-0.20369800925254822,
-0.38926249742507935,
-0.6149347424507141,
0.07415486872196198,
1.0617339611053467,
-0.342180073261261,
0.1606961190700531,
-0.3837924897670746,
0.6245064735412598,
-0.5497491359710693,
-0.29533514380455017,
0.022143345326185226,
-0.8188493847846985,
0.08027172833681107,
0.1717919558286667,
0.3180224597454071,
-0.045995645225048065,
-0.054861217737197876,
0.5698778629302979,
-0.3278268575668335,
1.0442665815353394,
-0.4869973659515381,
0.10734748095273972,
0.3625999093055725,
0.06579753011465073,
0.483662486076355,
-0.19894547760486603,
0.11228690296411514,
-0.07450225949287415,
-0.3068787157535553,
0.02649937942624092,
-0.6971432566642761,
0.23759542405605316,
-0.7424617409706116,
-0.5060803294181824,
-0.41740211844444275,
-0.34321102499961853,
-0.2586667537689209,
-0.0665142610669136,
0.44972336292266846,
0.7518083453178406,
-0.17721955478191376,
0.4961602985858917,
0.8692810535430908,
-0.28172776103019714,
0.14151868224143982,
0.3680512309074402,
-0.16501758992671967,
-0.9276523590087891,
0.8120447993278503,
-0.1470889449119568,
0.08651147037744522,
0.6299706697463989,
0.3307199776172638,
-0.49146217107772827,
-0.7239347100257874,
-0.5228651165962219,
-0.025905931368470192,
-0.7070350646972656,
-0.35868921875953674,
-0.5179893374443054,
-0.07500070333480835,
-0.33823487162590027,
-0.08504950255155563,
-0.30013811588287354,
-0.12109328806400299,
-0.5992324352264404,
0.0893845483660698,
0.6945765018463135,
0.14567458629608154,
-0.4332065284252167,
0.5493842959403992,
-0.8391750454902649,
0.557125985622406,
0.45458877086639404,
0.2935597896575928,
-0.3649889826774597,
-0.7998856902122498,
0.10281164944171906,
0.09254522621631622,
0.06629512459039688,
-0.5422545671463013,
0.5452916622161865,
0.9560901522636414,
0.6564744710922241,
0.2985791563987732,
-0.06983327865600586,
1.110015630722046,
-0.6030667424201965,
0.49469393491744995,
0.5451458096504211,
-1.107811689376831,
0.9788941740989685,
-0.2821982502937317,
0.4182330071926117,
0.3783203661441803,
0.1330462247133255,
-0.43700292706489563,
-0.25307247042655945,
-0.3365265130996704,
-0.7774519920349121,
0.32788437604904175,
-0.04596390947699547,
-0.2352360635995865,
0.4053753912448883,
0.3546794056892395,
-0.1905229687690735,
0.24198272824287415,
-0.5718943476676941,
-0.055620431900024414,
-0.7164608240127563,
-0.33293262124061584,
-0.08923031389713287,
-0.1134505644440651,
-0.2653445899486542,
-0.4542158544063568,
0.6653120517730713,
-0.332628071308136,
0.2277245968580246,
0.4172942340373993,
-0.21033255755901337,
-0.5219523906707764,
0.10697831213474274,
0.43370330333709717,
0.19395969808101654,
-0.1602955013513565,
0.2189493328332901,
0.3496817648410797,
-0.43062326312065125,
0.08893143385648727,
0.039645303040742874,
-0.24018248915672302,
-0.029914380982518196,
0.447871595621109,
1.1251007318496704,
0.3652587831020355,
-0.9741925597190857,
0.5533194541931152,
-0.03674967586994171,
-0.21110236644744873,
-0.5452281832695007,
0.3721572160720825,
-0.2747889459133148,
0.252082884311676,
0.3093060553073883,
0.37785616517066956,
0.26413312554359436,
-0.39702343940734863,
0.5761044025421143,
0.4757596254348755,
-0.8011531233787537,
-0.27172738313674927,
1.0576943159103394,
0.16554602980613708,
-0.3964872360229492,
0.3740204870700836,
-0.10561700165271759,
-0.6529346108436584,
0.39552223682403564,
0.3216003179550171,
0.9005808234214783,
-0.375667005777359,
-0.05275599658489227,
0.5025037527084351,
0.17704017460346222,
-0.16022470593452454,
0.23523324728012085,
-0.07157053053379059,
-0.8889923095703125,
-0.3227944076061249,
-0.673789381980896,
-0.5676245093345642,
0.1336905062198639,
-0.7472292184829712,
0.45654040575027466,
-0.6195977330207825,
-0.2835259735584259,
-0.0762362852692604,
-0.5761753916740417,
-0.5710103511810303,
0.26228803396224976,
0.13369326293468475,
0.4474131762981415,
-0.6483672857284546,
0.6402308940887451,
0.7536624073982239,
-0.19678889214992523,
-0.5743142366409302,
0.15172889828681946,
0.5824527144432068,
-0.9583726525306702,
0.7639370560646057,
-0.015101423487067223,
-0.7513455152511597,
0.03041924349963665,
-0.5880401730537415,
-1.0936403274536133,
0.9135081768035889,
0.3273574709892273,
-0.8859039545059204,
0.33628612756729126,
0.0016211112961173058,
0.5631267428398132,
-0.08273055404424667,
-0.4337769150733948,
0.38948506116867065,
0.2696467638015747,
0.7473222017288208,
-0.8443915843963623,
-0.3414440453052521,
-0.06596148759126663,
0.2164640724658966,
0.07054229825735092,
-0.4085747003555298,
0.28704187273979187,
-0.5458179116249084,
-0.24387215077877045,
0.17561829090118408,
0.8249866962432861,
0.17319855093955994,
0.1475464552640915,
0.7059759497642517,
0.7343335151672363,
0.7106150984764099,
-0.15030857920646667,
0.6607912182807922,
-0.17620760202407837,
-0.18824085593223572,
1.1269477605819702,
-0.20556345582008362,
0.6765341758728027,
0.4064041078090668,
-0.0030026156455278397,
0.25561466813087463,
0.29246655106544495,
-0.2861652672290802,
0.8274888396263123,
0.27536240220069885,
-0.21453401446342468,
-0.06305011361837387,
-0.09348887950181961,
0.033715732395648956,
0.7002977132797241,
0.7145439386367798,
-0.05621138587594032,
0.013410474173724651,
0.3744041621685028,
-0.31082573533058167,
0.22589094936847687,
-0.5263823866844177,
0.8774207234382629,
0.10929442942142487,
-0.36134955286979675,
0.5388442277908325,
-0.4415821135044098,
0.7232906222343445,
-0.4074414372444153,
-0.15725202858448029,
0.140204057097435,
0.48432275652885437,
-0.12637881934642792,
-0.3304119408130646,
0.2652130424976349,
0.03980838879942894,
-0.09504803270101547,
-0.15649154782295227,
1.0318338871002197,
-0.5896098017692566,
-0.5756723284721375,
0.12991027534008026,
0.3476148247718811,
-0.006718246731907129,
0.3043234050273895,
-0.7250181436538696,
0.43784621357917786,
0.11402096599340439,
0.24956604838371277,
-0.13465328514575958,
0.44834327697753906,
0.342762291431427,
1.0297389030456543,
0.5898774266242981,
0.18261216580867767,
0.21942485868930817,
0.34514501690864563,
0.5693537592887878,
-0.5349974036216736,
-0.18807892501354218,
-0.5412558317184448,
0.5305100679397583,
0.16598379611968994,
-0.09116297215223312,
0.704507052898407,
0.30258166790008545,
0.7865058183670044,
-0.091923289000988,
0.7809616327285767,
0.1139364242553711,
0.785861611366272,
-0.8973905444145203,
0.24714548885822296,
-0.46325504779815674,
0.4484518766403198,
-0.3769836127758026,
-0.6064478158950806,
-0.6898208260536194,
0.9445174336433411,
0.04127670079469681,
0.02615891769528389,
0.34334346652030945,
1.0414795875549316,
0.015150755643844604,
-0.2510921061038971,
0.24656954407691956,
0.1939065009355545,
0.1863160878419876,
0.16359670460224152,
0.7801129817962646,
-0.35722002387046814,
0.8025414943695068,
-0.27151063084602356,
-0.2652578055858612,
-0.3480338156223297,
-0.7965047359466553,
-0.7946649193763733,
-0.49390506744384766,
-0.7287433743476868,
-0.38414573669433594,
0.3456679582595825,
0.8013005256652832,
0.7647235989570618,
-0.8757967352867126,
-0.17730244994163513,
-0.3223567605018616,
-0.13277865946292877,
-0.3792184889316559,
-0.1734628528356552,
0.13049085438251495,
-0.31777074933052063,
-0.5277701020240784,
0.3995554447174072,
0.2790737450122833,
0.6166739463806152,
0.16910861432552338,
-0.19133694469928741,
0.44260373711586,
-0.38336634635925293,
0.2575121521949768,
0.47396591305732727,
-0.8101327419281006,
-0.4011687636375427,
0.0037716685328632593,
0.05941732972860336,
0.3645302653312683,
0.7455247044563293,
-0.5129373073577881,
0.6223554015159607,
0.3331679105758667,
0.5603262782096863,
0.6950547099113464,
0.04838194698095322,
0.6789975762367249,
-0.7703074812889099,
0.2026640623807907,
0.39217036962509155,
0.49978551268577576,
0.8034400939941406,
-0.12312009930610657,
0.41843655705451965,
0.313797265291214,
-0.5680743455886841,
-0.7470839023590088,
0.22628013789653778,
-1.187941551208496,
0.15563349425792694,
1.1821187734603882,
0.22619463503360748,
-0.2877171039581299,
-0.03806459531188011,
-0.27153846621513367,
0.39547470211982727,
-0.5795239210128784,
0.7728107571601868,
0.28514036536216736,
-0.2791968584060669,
-0.758471667766571,
-0.4856143295764923,
1.0566647052764893,
0.29876211285591125,
-0.4478486478328705,
-0.06123843789100647,
0.8573299646377563,
0.1933085322380066,
0.08742906153202057,
0.32527148723602295,
-0.025626670569181442,
0.4932378828525543,
0.1115824282169342,
0.3560939431190491,
0.10991202294826508,
-0.4818955063819885,
-0.39376866817474365,
-0.27639657258987427,
0.14593861997127533,
-0.46476706862449646
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.04428v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.04428v1
|
MoralBench: Moral Evaluation of LLMs
| 2024-06-06T18:15:01 | 2024-06-06T18:15:01 |
Jianchao Ji, Yutong Chen, Mingyu Jin, Wujiang Xu, Wenyue Hua, Yongfeng Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
In the rapidly evolving field of artificial intelligence, large language
models (LLMs) have emerged as powerful tools for a myriad of applications, from
natural language processing to decision-making support systems. However, as
these models become increasingly integrated into societal frameworks, the
imperative to ensure they operate within ethical and moral boundaries has never
been more critical. This paper introduces a novel benchmark designed to measure
and compare the moral reasoning capabilities of LLMs. We present the first
comprehensive dataset specifically curated to probe the moral dimensions of LLM
outputs, addressing a wide range of ethical dilemmas and scenarios reflective
of real-world complexities.
The main contribution of this work lies in the development of benchmark
datasets and metrics for assessing the moral identity of LLMs, which accounts
for nuance, contextual sensitivity, and alignment with human ethical standards.
Our methodology involves a multi-faceted approach, combining quantitative
analysis with qualitative insights from ethics scholars to ensure a thorough
evaluation of model performance. By applying our benchmark across several
leading LLMs, we uncover significant variations in moral reasoning capabilities
of different models. These findings highlight the importance of considering
moral reasoning in the development and evaluation of LLMs, as well as the need
for ongoing research to address the biases and limitations uncovered in our
study. We publicly release the benchmark at
https://drive.google.com/drive/u/0/folders/1k93YZJserYc2CkqP8d4B3M3sgd3kA8W7
and also open-source the code of the project at
https://github.com/agiresearch/MoralBench.
|
[
-0.33986517786979675,
-0.41763484477996826,
0.8238758444786072,
0.053921591490507126,
-0.3124905824661255,
0.16716180741786957,
-0.0927908718585968,
-0.39034053683280945,
-0.6294045448303223,
0.5541157722473145,
-0.5589534044265747,
-0.6545620560646057,
-0.5771932601928711,
0.11426390707492828,
-0.2607167065143585,
0.731168270111084,
0.25876057147979736,
0.49788305163383484,
-0.730648934841156,
-0.6266109347343445,
-0.20931120216846466,
-0.5567188262939453,
-0.6059359312057495,
-0.44830772280693054,
0.31448984146118164,
0.051038239151239395,
0.46805933117866516,
0.6811161041259766,
0.7752065658569336,
0.3460123538970947,
-0.2048809975385666,
-0.0323159284889698,
-0.7427857518196106,
-0.02519063651561737,
-0.6230932474136353,
-0.36408019065856934,
-0.5073146224021912,
0.5343837738037109,
0.43607279658317566,
0.43703538179397583,
-0.16383136808872223,
0.8345558643341064,
-0.1573176383972168,
0.6595312356948853,
-0.6604477167129517,
-0.06624837219715118,
-0.6234107613563538,
0.1099504753947258,
-0.10731121897697449,
-0.04122292995452881,
-0.29396140575408936,
-0.964821457862854,
-0.10012267529964447,
-0.25650501251220703,
-0.2651077210903168,
0.13416226208209991,
0.46033984422683716,
0.4116758704185486,
-0.5060617923736572,
-0.21965809166431427,
-0.34830838441848755,
1.2870885133743286,
-0.7091639041900635,
0.41449862718582153,
0.2540268003940582,
0.19528628885746002,
0.06261797249317169,
-0.6844285130500793,
-0.4325377941131592,
-0.29571768641471863,
0.2074502408504486,
0.11711543053388596,
-0.058174166828393936,
-0.21511566638946533,
0.36640048027038574,
0.3615105450153351,
-0.250530481338501,
0.14029818773269653,
-0.155166357755661,
-0.02976308763027191,
0.8395283818244934,
0.47804054617881775,
-0.06776701658964157,
-0.26552924513816833,
-0.3726528584957123,
-0.17417031526565552,
-0.599927544593811,
0.39050087332725525,
0.7477583289146423,
-0.0781402662396431,
-0.2259313464164734,
0.5842642784118652,
0.14895100891590118,
0.30003809928894043,
-0.11236443370580673,
0.09098696708679199,
0.20470209419727325,
-0.3994940519332886,
-0.08360899984836578,
-0.03738168254494667,
0.944252610206604,
0.8550669550895691,
0.7580257058143616,
0.4095214605331421,
-0.1416744440793991,
0.17730091512203217,
0.49947023391723633,
-0.9060633778572083,
0.19184646010398865,
0.20500896871089935,
-0.7211903929710388,
-0.6201098561286926,
0.002067611552774906,
-0.5363083481788635,
-0.7787753939628601,
-0.3396441638469696,
-0.3105373680591583,
-0.314252108335495,
-0.03723127767443657,
0.24236543476581573,
0.10235143452882767,
0.49843722581863403,
0.20397259294986725,
-0.22019727528095245,
0.13122372329235077,
0.9707953929901123,
0.6447710394859314,
-0.1714208722114563,
-0.01915823295712471,
-0.8225417137145996,
0.00649411091580987,
-0.49820318818092346,
0.5511815547943115,
-0.7000668048858643,
-0.43045514822006226,
-0.08726170659065247,
-0.04665781930088997,
0.3900463581085205,
-0.45788347721099854,
1.1991900205612183,
-0.25415682792663574,
-0.2654653489589691,
-0.47216394543647766,
-0.6544094085693359,
-0.29823756217956543,
0.3694226145744324,
-0.49527260661125183,
0.762267529964447,
-0.11489242315292358,
-0.4975064694881439,
0.3202557861804962,
-0.3832709491252899,
-0.1816135197877884,
0.15923531353473663,
-0.3780117332935333,
-0.37622275948524475,
0.22234134376049042,
-0.026607783511281013,
0.5366238355636597,
-0.8618301153182983,
0.748979389667511,
-0.7461200952529907,
-0.44023972749710083,
0.5288199186325073,
-0.4981935918331146,
1.051639199256897,
-0.0889846533536911,
-0.07974753528833389,
0.05487428233027458,
-0.7339965105056763,
0.32178935408592224,
0.38892191648483276,
-0.19038549065589905,
-0.25313490629196167,
0.2987745404243469,
-0.11344148963689804,
0.17167559266090393,
0.4363255798816681,
-0.5644828081130981,
-0.2447361946105957,
-0.09911599010229111,
0.521862268447876,
1.1429033279418945,
-0.3197760283946991,
0.06644096970558167,
-0.4527966380119324,
0.27159422636032104,
-0.39292702078819275,
0.4268198311328888,
0.37465494871139526,
-0.10008012503385544,
-0.5520069003105164,
-0.12545835971832275,
-0.04686673358082771,
0.5936819314956665,
0.000030715815228177235,
0.553225040435791,
-0.1333569586277008,
-0.5491124987602234,
-0.48461025953292847,
0.1524953693151474,
0.6116621494293213,
0.2134271115064621,
0.24811680614948273,
-0.3073575794696808,
-0.14893153309822083,
-1.0624662637710571,
-0.8065504431724548,
-0.49910059571266174,
-0.14122150838375092,
0.7774457335472107,
0.6057415008544922,
-0.06490037590265274,
0.6359974145889282,
-0.02430528961122036,
-0.023661533370614052,
0.0718773901462555,
-0.060850840061903,
0.3607524037361145,
0.3878868520259857,
0.5257104635238647,
-0.6862848401069641,
0.0005225760396569967,
0.04135553911328316,
-1.0890543460845947,
-0.19429397583007812,
0.12864229083061218,
-0.17940717935562134,
-0.21630056202411652,
0.5335369110107422,
-0.3358697295188904,
0.25879085063934326,
0.42869144678115845,
-0.5458681583404541,
0.7693449854850769,
0.09522881358861923,
0.27679404616355896,
-0.5950744152069092,
0.29688480496406555,
-0.1376057118177414,
-0.2830173373222351,
-0.08461180329322815,
-0.0959622785449028,
0.13981851935386658,
0.22445116937160492,
-0.5881645083427429,
0.6453443765640259,
-0.09034829586744308,
-0.41850024461746216,
0.23465919494628906,
0.32980620861053467,
-0.0061036269180476665,
0.15902455151081085,
-0.5007064342498779,
0.8364860415458679,
0.30496472120285034,
-0.30466753244400024,
0.6950764060020447,
0.462319016456604,
-0.3819968104362488,
1.0892666578292847,
-0.9286085963249207,
0.13893204927444458,
0.11292543262243271,
0.15408861637115479,
-0.2977086901664734,
0.09475915133953094,
0.08180568367242813,
-0.29771602153778076,
-0.32536783814430237,
-0.18396516144275665,
-0.6074273586273193,
-0.33722224831581116,
-0.5908046364784241,
0.5021358728408813,
0.4247511923313141,
-0.3491043150424957,
0.6878124475479126,
0.36850661039352417,
-0.3347826898097992,
-0.5536487698554993,
-0.5230159759521484,
0.08202354609966278,
-0.3908223807811737,
-0.5766687989234924,
0.16659703850746155,
-0.26524317264556885,
-0.7115187644958496,
-0.052495524287223816,
-0.19390340149402618,
0.36192819476127625,
0.16342134773731232,
0.29308566451072693,
0.22356995940208435,
-0.18080182373523712,
0.19162927567958832,
0.01828509196639061,
-0.3004755973815918,
0.6088622808456421,
0.07258465886116028,
0.4125673472881317,
-1.121788740158081,
-0.5870248079299927,
-0.25780853629112244,
0.14471235871315002,
0.6862235069274902,
-0.6569953560829163,
0.48897895216941833,
0.34143975377082825,
-0.08087983727455139,
-0.10203003883361816,
-0.7282042503356934,
0.0924764946103096,
-0.5072287917137146,
0.17873626947402954,
0.010175835341215134,
-0.7967388033866882,
0.5195019841194153,
-0.3544099032878876,
0.20545998215675354,
0.33390289545059204,
0.43859246373176575,
-0.1708865910768509,
0.8790222406387329,
0.43536174297332764,
0.1608097404241562,
0.18916380405426025,
-0.1269959658384323,
0.16945762932300568,
-0.956692636013031,
-0.1884247362613678,
-0.30525916814804077,
-0.13223545253276825,
-0.8024048805236816,
-0.5906349420547485,
0.20016488432884216,
0.1699303388595581,
-0.8557968735694885,
-0.15452627837657928,
-0.42567551136016846,
0.7950777411460876,
0.32692065834999084,
-0.17134146392345428,
0.5537397265434265,
-0.2535775899887085,
-0.35767024755477905,
0.11040946841239929,
-0.20125746726989746,
-1.2421362400054932,
1.1600666046142578,
0.21679967641830444,
0.5141460299491882,
0.16726908087730408,
0.4347250759601593,
0.5768617987632751,
0.31076744198799133,
-0.6445841193199158,
1.0402958393096924,
-0.5379877686500549,
-0.3709962069988251,
-0.10085738450288773,
-0.4857513904571533,
-0.6039448380470276,
0.2915206551551819,
-0.18718241155147552,
-0.7763493657112122,
0.13768069446086884,
-0.39159655570983887,
-0.23206651210784912,
0.3438940942287445,
-0.28100866079330444,
0.750277042388916,
-0.771247923374176,
-0.845344603061676,
-0.5811243653297424,
-0.6257097125053406,
0.21090203523635864,
-0.10585398226976395,
0.07055993378162384,
-0.7695009708404541,
-0.2267790585756302,
0.6479912996292114,
-0.13751615583896637,
0.6052377223968506,
0.06026729196310043,
-0.22596265375614166,
0.2121487706899643,
0.13758745789527893,
0.4541052579879761,
0.4319866895675659,
-0.6405486464500427,
0.5689714550971985,
0.25797271728515625,
-0.23909048736095428,
-0.09978584945201874,
0.7049559950828552,
-0.561166524887085,
-0.5813992023468018,
-0.46073853969573975,
-0.5738331079483032,
-0.48765698075294495,
0.30187276005744934,
-0.24449914693832397,
0.2668462097644806,
-0.6298531293869019,
0.6234853863716125,
0.4729570150375366,
-0.6755019426345825,
0.28211966156959534,
0.5920945405960083,
-0.14332418143749237,
-0.33159440755844116,
0.5336832404136658,
-0.35888203978538513,
0.20562857389450073,
-0.24482828378677368,
0.3572603464126587,
-0.40956419706344604,
-0.516221821308136,
-0.38623034954071045,
0.4049464464187622,
-0.9652852416038513,
-0.2147444784641266,
-0.41148847341537476,
-0.22831274569034576,
0.2485152930021286,
-0.4310230612754822,
-0.5471276640892029,
0.03741442412137985,
-0.15591420233249664,
-0.13759763538837433,
0.47042375802993774,
0.7507421374320984,
0.1718742996454239,
-0.1223784014582634,
-0.8078763484954834,
0.27125126123428345,
0.1701659858226776,
0.7343040108680725,
-0.1704554557800293,
-0.15068784356117249,
0.3577975034713745,
0.037427984178066254,
-0.22453218698501587,
-0.37228092551231384,
-0.07085350155830383,
-0.07166790962219238,
0.7196661233901978,
0.3401435911655426,
0.16917330026626587,
0.4050385653972626,
-0.40613290667533875,
0.5018790364265442,
0.12578225135803223,
-1.048073172569275,
0.4059828817844391,
-0.6127448081970215,
0.08331281691789627,
0.8485457301139832,
0.20002639293670654,
-0.2653518319129944,
-0.3447752892971039,
-0.5192729234695435,
-0.6438303589820862,
0.5883839726448059,
0.48097941279411316,
0.12438958138227463,
0.15349633991718292,
0.3232995271682739,
0.15749670565128326,
0.35237041115760803,
-0.5886592864990234,
-0.01591969095170498,
0.10048271715641022,
-0.32235148549079895,
-0.07949423789978027,
-0.15585745871067047,
-0.3092849850654602,
-0.23768019676208496,
0.47140246629714966,
-0.1755492240190506,
-0.13591225445270538,
-0.11134837567806244,
-0.020651426166296005,
-0.022945765405893326,
0.2515987753868103,
0.17084214091300964,
0.907026469707489,
-0.23956087231636047,
-0.1773785799741745,
0.31911391019821167,
-0.3971250653266907,
0.29209643602371216,
0.18251027166843414,
0.0655231848359108,
-0.5721540451049805,
0.4680420160293579,
0.3064274191856384,
-0.006256268359720707,
-1.0678530931472778,
0.6331307291984558,
-0.3382616639137268,
-0.03428081423044205,
-0.44406136870384216,
0.11366739869117737,
0.2144860029220581,
0.7615266442298889,
0.07226341962814331,
-0.12513168156147003,
0.04795311763882637,
-0.45335593819618225,
0.10087281465530396,
0.5370393395423889,
-0.17794454097747803,
0.08191628754138947,
0.44400089979171753,
0.35329169034957886,
-0.3353388011455536,
0.7076228857040405,
-0.11663196980953217,
-0.30430668592453003,
0.8588914275169373,
-0.008250964805483818,
0.8985523581504822,
-0.05985381454229355,
0.24930711090564728,
0.33684638142585754,
0.4265344738960266,
0.08215295523405075,
0.35217341780662537,
-0.01582654006779194,
-0.7384886741638184,
-0.2954273819923401,
-0.8411355018615723,
-0.5002793073654175,
-0.038339000195264816,
-0.8285154700279236,
0.060618288815021515,
-0.7103844285011292,
-0.3884342908859253,
-0.2699238657951355,
0.13737811148166656,
-0.576971173286438,
-0.03128083050251007,
0.10526936501264572,
0.5701460242271423,
-0.33021631836891174,
0.28874659538269043,
0.5657976865768433,
-0.06398381292819977,
-0.2628440856933594,
-0.14397171139717102,
0.1858098804950714,
-0.9794647693634033,
0.3876388967037201,
0.41664817929267883,
-0.7022861242294312,
-0.17111089825630188,
-0.708284854888916,
-0.5637496709823608,
1.0625396966934204,
0.5720753073692322,
-0.7555147409439087,
0.4492289423942566,
0.359364777803421,
0.5650293827056885,
-0.4378109574317932,
0.1385091096162796,
0.8196696639060974,
0.7760909795761108,
-0.16105735301971436,
-0.6093544363975525,
0.23030245304107666,
-0.4572826027870178,
-0.09486691653728485,
0.06486179679632187,
-0.8087784647941589,
0.690493643283844,
-0.3394155502319336,
-0.10546628385782242,
0.2212911695241928,
0.16914285719394684,
0.7724320292472839,
0.37984105944633484,
0.5547139048576355,
0.34145477414131165,
0.8919625282287598,
-0.15423142910003662,
0.9934757351875305,
-0.31725212931632996,
0.39099639654159546,
1.1040376424789429,
-0.6234691739082336,
0.5960726737976074,
0.3684154152870178,
-0.19704969227313995,
0.4062636196613312,
0.41292017698287964,
-0.49655285477638245,
0.10831478238105774,
0.4703393876552582,
-0.01861826702952385,
-0.6451058387756348,
-0.6304863691329956,
-0.28275904059410095,
0.4975944757461548,
0.4222458004951477,
-0.4246874153614044,
0.013709012418985367,
-0.4385833740234375,
-0.19761212170124054,
0.2160080522298813,
-0.33707964420318604,
0.6649425625801086,
0.3664364814758301,
-0.30763331055641174,
0.39718911051750183,
-0.09395498782396317,
0.38658180832862854,
-0.47133970260620117,
-0.021403281018137932,
-0.21007177233695984,
0.46184825897216797,
-0.060063693672418594,
-1.1921085119247437,
0.12420304119586945,
0.5378623604774475,
0.16744424402713776,
-0.4441463053226471,
0.5571475028991699,
0.24491676688194275,
-0.760753870010376,
0.8230553269386292,
0.6617845892906189,
-0.01722741685807705,
0.24955397844314575,
-0.9551352858543396,
0.13044869899749756,
-0.254317045211792,
-0.3323093354701996,
0.002453490626066923,
0.5137806534767151,
-0.19290441274642944,
1.0497543811798096,
0.8738097548484802,
-0.1632968783378601,
-0.2568759620189667,
0.3347639739513397,
0.7542732954025269,
-0.9282789826393127,
-0.2733224630355835,
-1.0212724208831787,
0.35135188698768616,
-0.3530906140804291,
-0.5038131475448608,
0.608090877532959,
0.5406618714332581,
0.8575005531311035,
0.34518009424209595,
0.6078156232833862,
0.08011749386787415,
0.1918843686580658,
-0.4677751958370209,
0.787661075592041,
-0.6352863311767578,
0.4358302652835846,
-0.18043796718120575,
-0.8405920267105103,
0.061719078570604324,
0.6989943981170654,
-0.5281939506530762,
0.3486150801181793,
0.5469878315925598,
0.5057054162025452,
-0.015506401658058167,
0.24692970514297485,
0.20844846963882446,
0.2735978364944458,
0.2891968786716461,
0.47736015915870667,
1.3287863731384277,
-0.0474766381084919,
0.46144407987594604,
0.005992364138364792,
0.07414817065000534,
-0.01196141354739666,
-1.1922470331192017,
-1.0365808010101318,
-0.05016295239329338,
0.006020353175699711,
0.03417493402957916,
0.19932977855205536,
0.6737436652183533,
0.4392693340778351,
-0.6497698426246643,
-0.4509172737598419,
-0.06383898854255676,
0.1958094835281372,
-0.1459389328956604,
-0.1616995930671692,
0.1551177054643631,
0.16698960959911346,
-0.3851351737976074,
0.2462434470653534,
0.38632145524024963,
-0.24516911804676056,
-0.33233869075775146,
-0.19475030899047852,
-0.18318738043308258,
0.4574258029460907,
0.6787077188491821,
-0.36268696188926697,
-0.9009778499603271,
-0.3398902714252472,
-0.2467757910490036,
-0.09964177757501602,
0.007043300196528435,
0.7516651153564453,
-0.46640151739120483,
0.12176331877708435,
0.27990391850471497,
0.6088921427726746,
0.16383104026317596,
0.08686705678701401,
0.5967594981193542,
-0.15791402757167816,
-0.18303856253623962,
0.6402089595794678,
0.45908352732658386,
0.39051494002342224,
-0.2390165477991104,
0.9238758683204651,
-0.12095209211111069,
-0.5525150299072266,
-0.8337801694869995,
0.26162880659103394,
-0.954617977142334,
-0.20825546979904175,
1.0882335901260376,
-0.1773495227098465,
-0.01882806234061718,
-0.0498620830476284,
-0.00007335087866522372,
0.027043674141168594,
-0.4193635582923889,
0.44838929176330566,
0.655855655670166,
0.12232103198766708,
0.019318455830216408,
-0.7555553317070007,
0.10328406095504761,
0.47116124629974365,
-0.9595096111297607,
0.48225703835487366,
0.7048240303993225,
0.2536478042602539,
-0.1480318307876587,
0.22197949886322021,
-0.36209526658058167,
0.2820260226726532,
-0.25693076848983765,
0.01136696245521307,
-0.11915583163499832,
-0.014870199374854565,
-0.23468217253684998,
0.00021455528622027487,
-0.3233625292778015,
0.36827191710472107
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.06608v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.06608v2
|
The Prompt Report: A Systematic Survey of Prompting Techniques
| 2024-06-06T18:10:11 | 2024-06-17T01:28:09 |
Sander Schulhoff, Michael Ilie, Nishant Balepur, Konstantine Kahadze, Amanda Liu, Chenglei Si, Yinheng Li, Aayush Gupta, HyoJung Han, Sevien Schulhoff, Pranav Sandeep Dulepet, Saurav Vidyadhara, Dayeon Ki, Sweta Agrawal, Chau Pham, Gerson Kroiz, Feileen Li, Hudson Tao, Ashay Srivastava, Hevander Da Costa, Saloni Gupta, Megan L. Rogers, Inna Goncearenco, Giuseppe Sarli, Igor Galynker, Denis Peskoff, Marine Carpuat, Jules White, Shyamal Anadkat, Alexander Hoyle, Philip Resnik
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Generative Artificial Intelligence (GenAI) systems are being increasingly
deployed across all parts of industry and research settings. Developers and end
users interact with these systems through the use of prompting or prompt
engineering. While prompting is a widespread and highly researched concept,
there exists conflicting terminology and a poor ontological understanding of
what constitutes a prompt due to the area's nascency. This paper establishes a
structured understanding of prompts, by assembling a taxonomy of prompting
techniques and analyzing their use. We present a comprehensive vocabulary of 33
vocabulary terms, a taxonomy of 58 text-only prompting techniques, and 40
techniques for other modalities. We further present a meta-analysis of the
entire literature on natural language prefix-prompting.
|
[
-0.7325888872146606,
-1.0949465036392212,
0.5961009860038757,
0.638948380947113,
-0.015507298521697521,
0.13885922729969025,
0.03542386367917061,
-0.0412743017077446,
0.23462101817131042,
0.0847420021891594,
-1.1737315654754639,
-0.31285110116004944,
-0.09885360300540924,
0.7735113501548767,
-0.3056803047657013,
0.7365151047706604,
0.040065616369247437,
0.05123006924986839,
-0.28463396430015564,
0.09215997159481049,
-1.1245838403701782,
-0.15869106352329254,
-0.6369471549987793,
-0.1223311573266983,
0.8615917563438416,
0.6564037203788757,
0.41210323572158813,
0.18455903232097626,
0.24939189851284027,
0.2919962406158447,
-0.1944282203912735,
-0.07252179086208344,
0.09131505340337753,
0.39576271176338196,
0.1143990159034729,
-0.4525884687900543,
-0.06850641220808029,
0.15765097737312317,
0.3751402795314789,
0.8322662115097046,
-0.0713866725564003,
0.42466142773628235,
0.14143922924995422,
0.5007684826850891,
-0.6521257162094116,
-0.08670006692409515,
-0.054033953696489334,
0.2463274896144867,
-0.42673763632774353,
-0.42472177743911743,
-0.5664564371109009,
-0.4049952030181885,
0.27952784299850464,
-0.9332300424575806,
0.41123127937316895,
0.0812034010887146,
0.45120278000831604,
0.37850117683410645,
-0.0492418110370636,
-0.5213181376457214,
-0.47503605484962463,
0.5091946721076965,
-0.0837259516119957,
-0.0447537861764431,
0.4257320463657379,
0.3104625940322876,
0.02095312625169754,
-0.6786342859268188,
-0.5375487804412842,
-0.2878207266330719,
-0.12273049354553223,
0.1625840663909912,
-0.2986982464790344,
0.41590431332588196,
0.5277684330940247,
0.1943734735250473,
-0.790319561958313,
0.20275065302848816,
-0.2925296425819397,
-0.14201229810714722,
0.3563694953918457,
0.3243545889854431,
0.8332840204238892,
-0.32633572816848755,
-0.31536975502967834,
-0.05816871300339699,
-0.5967276096343994,
0.13445702195167542,
0.2572091519832611,
0.22311587631702423,
-0.06092631071805954,
0.36640021204948425,
-0.3236995041370392,
1.0170674324035645,
-0.005269300192594528,
0.10456843674182892,
-0.08951492607593536,
-0.5924558043479919,
-0.27826279401779175,
-0.06313852965831757,
0.8756486773490906,
0.3014447093009949,
0.18937687575817108,
-0.1286647468805313,
-0.10612747073173523,
-0.028309468179941177,
0.3032713532447815,
-0.22171179950237274,
-0.1831091046333313,
0.14937493205070496,
-0.3678426444530487,
-0.23664452135562897,
0.0596156045794487,
-1.0060316324234009,
-0.48242148756980896,
-0.2926112711429596,
0.18621695041656494,
-0.33892735838890076,
-0.05715017765760422,
-0.3912389278411865,
-0.6462856531143188,
0.5403698086738586,
0.1915140151977539,
-1.007822871208191,
-0.062464531511068344,
0.6266926527023315,
0.8907617330551147,
0.1478293240070343,
-0.4197464883327484,
-0.2881690263748169,
-0.22441349923610687,
-0.4483361542224884,
1.1274998188018799,
-0.6521368622779846,
-1.0736122131347656,
0.2120669186115265,
-0.2363956719636917,
-0.09630456566810608,
-0.369901567697525,
0.6052497625350952,
-0.5404420495033264,
0.4135740399360657,
-0.6158419251441956,
-0.35694146156311035,
-0.35401400923728943,
0.21007922291755676,
-0.5923782587051392,
0.8484604358673096,
0.06663332879543304,
-0.3540083169937134,
0.5272569060325623,
-0.9171011447906494,
-0.22606852650642395,
0.5770423412322998,
-0.2613341510295868,
0.4795967638492584,
0.02842755801975727,
0.3230796158313751,
0.14723417162895203,
-0.26754891872406006,
0.48622772097587585,
0.49253955483436584,
-0.09433386474847794,
0.2746852934360504,
-0.39067015051841736,
0.8447379469871521,
0.4463421404361725,
-0.03989626467227936,
0.5014375448226929,
-0.4118339419364929,
-0.08439946174621582,
-0.2940618693828583,
0.09215003997087479,
-0.3049861490726471,
-0.32846808433532715,
-0.17720846831798553,
-0.1850493997335434,
-0.024814017117023468,
-0.2910591661930084,
0.4715193212032318,
-0.1617654412984848,
0.4682007431983948,
0.6527398228645325,
0.17301158607006073,
0.5536219477653503,
-0.40202781558036804,
1.0352109670639038,
-0.49002692103385925,
0.37339863181114197,
-0.8019652962684631,
-0.8860928416252136,
-0.4459921419620514,
-0.1809932142496109,
0.37756583094596863,
0.6580361723899841,
-1.0847587585449219,
0.2836402356624603,
-0.039638541638851166,
-0.35428178310394287,
-0.44232645630836487,
-0.061867401003837585,
0.24142707884311676,
0.6405013799667358,
0.2021203488111496,
0.13236568868160248,
-0.39722439646720886,
-0.6463385820388794,
-0.06266823410987854,
-0.26793739199638367,
-0.1690136194229126,
0.02975369058549404,
0.23640866577625275,
-0.1123817041516304,
1.354509949684143,
-0.25584062933921814,
-0.06663048267364502,
-0.11276694387197495,
0.8790153861045837,
0.08513467758893967,
0.16715574264526367,
0.47598937153816223,
-0.6851837038993835,
-0.3391318917274475,
-0.47272244095802307,
-0.9135346412658691,
-0.49954715371131897,
-0.37736448645591736,
0.09399660676717758,
-0.12379416078329086,
0.8837102651596069,
-0.5113595128059387,
0.2989722192287445,
0.22237570583820343,
-0.4325255751609802,
0.7010470032691956,
0.013554682955145836,
0.18088962137699127,
-0.7202785015106201,
0.2825149893760681,
-0.07397641986608505,
0.4974558353424072,
-0.8962017297744751,
0.25719010829925537,
-0.12749768793582916,
-0.28606143593788147,
-0.36235272884368896,
0.6997110843658447,
-0.6199414134025574,
0.3903016149997711,
-0.2633202373981476,
0.03396821767091751,
0.05864662304520607,
-0.03033410757780075,
-0.24372892081737518,
1.2645412683486938,
0.7132043838500977,
-1.0679216384887695,
0.7200689911842346,
0.7856367826461792,
0.046616118401288986,
0.6677811145782471,
-0.8431537747383118,
0.09483704715967178,
-0.3419427275657654,
0.21094368398189545,
-1.1065542697906494,
-0.40510475635528564,
0.6598853468894958,
-0.6378815770149231,
0.038217030465602875,
0.05743223428726196,
-0.38899651169776917,
-0.5046100616455078,
-0.28442367911338806,
0.5627735257148743,
0.6565110683441162,
-0.3965144455432892,
0.46514230966567993,
-0.10893931239843369,
-0.5544200539588928,
-0.397096186876297,
-0.5069447159767151,
0.505704939365387,
-0.12592755258083344,
-0.5791045427322388,
0.14706584811210632,
-0.2858350872993469,
-0.4527587890625,
-0.13482441008090973,
0.3727806806564331,
-0.030028654262423515,
0.18463481962680817,
0.24221673607826233,
0.5081492066383362,
-0.09565556794404984,
0.24451743066310883,
-0.14785434305667877,
-0.2986283600330353,
0.4129091203212738,
0.09621913731098175,
0.49444010853767395,
0.4136766493320465,
-0.28988057374954224,
-0.6906509399414062,
0.46163299679756165,
0.13631543517112732,
0.0053342352621257305,
0.3414776921272278,
0.31056860089302063,
0.014543261379003525,
0.02032441273331642,
-0.3433418869972229,
-0.4255629777908325,
-0.5318343043327332,
-0.4017205238342285,
-0.39470285177230835,
-0.5691057443618774,
0.5444885492324829,
-0.11651407182216644,
0.1301983892917633,
0.47578656673431396,
0.20256303250789642,
-0.05964914709329605,
0.8508126735687256,
0.6100918650627136,
-0.05859139561653137,
0.468925803899765,
-0.12614746391773224,
0.16277368366718292,
-0.593998908996582,
-0.4929386079311371,
-0.9639829993247986,
-0.22444802522659302,
-0.4317013621330261,
-0.11549735069274902,
0.35372674465179443,
-0.057554442435503006,
0.1081906110048294,
-0.07663226872682571,
-0.7898381948471069,
0.4290781617164612,
0.7361490726470947,
-0.34051716327667236,
0.08020369708538055,
-0.037188977003097534,
-0.017041891813278198,
0.20059266686439514,
-0.7656331062316895,
-0.4907391667366028,
0.4995524287223816,
0.02163747139275074,
0.7000010013580322,
-0.040076058357954025,
0.5165206789970398,
0.5701549649238586,
0.2512742280960083,
-1.2489738464355469,
0.758292019367218,
0.4509327709674835,
-0.4895494282245636,
-0.4758276045322418,
-0.21331067383289337,
-1.3565080165863037,
-0.26267343759536743,
0.08436413109302521,
-0.4915488660335541,
0.31535255908966064,
-0.12974418699741364,
-0.9664502739906311,
-0.13012704253196716,
-0.6128467917442322,
0.5624117255210876,
-0.07436762005090714,
0.4289420545101166,
0.10200991481542587,
-0.7248198390007019,
0.26600319147109985,
0.18041357398033142,
0.2682981789112091,
-0.033158767968416214,
-0.31859350204467773,
0.7996085286140442,
-0.18149657547473907,
0.9111675024032593,
-0.14390064775943756,
-0.27423572540283203,
0.6040483713150024,
0.03002716228365898,
0.0463201180100441,
-0.1300542801618576,
0.041918110102415085,
-0.13464272022247314,
-0.13350564241409302,
-0.1355719417333603,
-0.6634512543678284,
0.25731828808784485,
-0.34176984429359436,
-0.5743703246116638,
-0.6336266398429871,
-0.31773263216018677,
-0.2661972641944885,
0.185885488986969,
0.8702076077461243,
0.6421530246734619,
-0.4627052843570709,
-0.42894065380096436,
0.8703544735908508,
-0.44712457060813904,
0.7029075622558594,
0.14353346824645996,
-0.1340080201625824,
-0.1653861701488495,
0.7979788780212402,
0.0677681565284729,
-0.026130490005016327,
0.09583045542240143,
0.15726163983345032,
-0.357631117105484,
-0.30330559611320496,
-0.8404418230056763,
-0.030191071331501007,
-0.5437926650047302,
-0.247624933719635,
-0.4763706922531128,
-0.13792537152767181,
-0.6283370852470398,
-0.37239810824394226,
0.5370769500732422,
-0.03733436390757561,
-0.6267144680023193,
-0.16144084930419922,
0.6192848086357117,
1.0999772548675537,
0.059161227196455,
0.40815281867980957,
-1.0416440963745117,
0.31681638956069946,
0.631818950176239,
0.14187495410442352,
0.11976288259029388,
-0.2916998267173767,
0.37895190715789795,
-0.11897024512290955,
-0.04052503779530525,
-1.074151873588562,
0.08184771984815598,
0.13693149387836456,
0.7064427137374878,
0.5739878416061401,
0.2819986045360565,
0.3375933766365051,
-0.37430617213249207,
1.3698309659957886,
0.4190875291824341,
-0.8374276757240295,
1.0596591234207153,
-0.4519413411617279,
0.4383450746536255,
0.6969437599182129,
0.6351502537727356,
-1.0007339715957642,
-0.03163144737482071,
-0.5545360445976257,
-0.8565918207168579,
0.523845911026001,
-0.25911834836006165,
0.5136125683784485,
-0.22115372121334076,
0.3169316351413727,
0.2856680750846863,
0.13191667199134827,
0.06065560504794121,
-0.38441377878189087,
-0.053525157272815704,
-0.1644279807806015,
0.32139015197753906,
-0.29672107100486755,
-0.37075644731521606,
-0.012314078398048878,
0.25159752368927,
-0.2507445812225342,
0.34070295095443726,
0.3367308974266052,
-0.08541499823331833,
-0.05039417743682861,
0.46581703424453735,
0.7030545473098755,
0.8401383757591248,
0.41022205352783203,
-0.10730227828025818,
0.0639357715845108,
-0.44804614782333374,
0.26787179708480835,
-0.021106058731675148,
-0.7179993391036987,
0.3161097764968872,
0.2522185444831848,
0.6443924903869629,
-0.05309676006436348,
-0.513620913028717,
0.16181637346744537,
-0.1821916550397873,
-0.30787572264671326,
-0.05398834869265556,
0.039711304008960724,
-0.4731586277484894,
-0.4074922502040863,
0.7006781697273254,
-0.13459648191928864,
0.5633795261383057,
-0.6660761833190918,
-0.059696391224861145,
0.2984340786933899,
-0.6039885878562927,
-0.3187546133995056,
0.32824012637138367,
0.666901707649231,
-0.4955945909023285,
0.79881751537323,
-0.4777497351169586,
-0.2922346293926239,
0.5700016021728516,
0.05061269551515579,
1.055057406425476,
-0.2790610194206238,
0.8554199934005737,
0.38926517963409424,
0.19171714782714844,
-0.006814048159867525,
0.4637071192264557,
-0.21110616624355316,
-0.4178219437599182,
-0.4270312190055847,
-0.32206374406814575,
-0.5763322114944458,
-0.12344909459352493,
-0.5743420124053955,
-0.03033372201025486,
-0.491437703371048,
-0.430175244808197,
0.140335351228714,
-0.5079669952392578,
-0.42634934186935425,
-0.14388731122016907,
0.1971118450164795,
1.4256538152694702,
-0.7885498404502869,
-0.07667341828346252,
1.0695024728775024,
-0.5909636616706848,
-1.140943169593811,
0.10962916165590286,
0.3116057813167572,
-0.6237345933914185,
0.5704902410507202,
0.16797088086605072,
0.11793788522481918,
0.12206695973873138,
-0.869942307472229,
-0.30999407172203064,
0.6641384363174438,
-0.27855005860328674,
-0.03152771294116974,
-0.11929833143949509,
-0.0462854839861393,
0.35800328850746155,
-0.011107109487056732,
0.4978284239768982,
0.5929769277572632,
0.9395736455917358,
0.03683612495660782,
-0.8497763276100159,
0.12238913029432297,
-0.42452964186668396,
0.17446549236774445,
0.11240725219249725,
-0.4300951361656189,
0.4261856973171234,
-0.0873400866985321,
-0.6261695623397827,
0.5701475143432617,
0.5377680659294128,
0.26286977529525757,
0.7388225793838501,
0.30977317690849304,
0.04371317848563194,
0.8300215601921082,
-0.3400641083717346,
0.914461076259613,
-0.21173129975795746,
-0.22967252135276794,
0.2882711589336395,
-0.09316049516201019,
0.19387036561965942,
0.4696715176105499,
-0.13104015588760376,
0.6800040006637573,
1.0089246034622192,
-0.08780277520418167,
0.21165475249290466,
0.13759452104568481,
-0.5137119293212891,
0.13493521511554718,
-0.7716308236122131,
-0.5644903779029846,
0.21257774531841278,
0.4817844331264496,
0.054201241582632065,
-0.19261179864406586,
0.49248069524765015,
-0.17721308767795563,
-0.17696550488471985,
-0.4388939142227173,
1.210883378982544,
0.14008207619190216,
-1.1811856031417847,
0.3557746708393097,
-0.43384087085723877,
0.7271325588226318,
-0.6133949160575867,
-0.07390756905078888,
-0.29127806425094604,
-0.8911566138267517,
-0.1704673320055008,
-0.9900864958763123,
0.10165970027446747,
0.08088750392198563,
-0.1555180847644806,
-0.6008644700050354,
0.540973961353302,
0.0805416852235794,
-0.08776462823152542,
-0.17214460670948029,
0.7878548502922058,
-0.04061003401875496,
0.09975241124629974,
-0.6944344639778137,
-0.2122766077518463,
-0.3048420250415802,
0.07043487578630447,
-0.12049403041601181,
0.7210882306098938,
0.005881486926227808,
0.6793853640556335,
0.6255543828010559,
-0.15433219075202942,
0.037919655442237854,
0.4787551164627075,
0.6016603112220764,
-0.788415789604187,
-0.58487468957901,
-0.8539785742759705,
0.47198066115379333,
0.05422027036547661,
-0.6974496841430664,
0.8479357361793518,
-0.0524945929646492,
0.2630622088909149,
-0.07095102965831757,
0.9376987218856812,
-0.3872013986110687,
0.10798043757677078,
-0.6183496713638306,
0.29712727665901184,
-0.046284276992082596,
-0.018325388431549072,
-0.13720162212848663,
-0.7437834143638611,
-0.23264223337173462,
0.03478694334626198,
-0.13383157551288605,
0.15573443472385406,
0.5288394689559937,
0.7289379239082336,
0.4465351402759552,
0.43419918417930603,
0.0776219442486763,
-0.29770588874816895,
-0.06445464491844177,
-0.2144332379102707,
1.4373341798782349,
0.1853911429643631,
0.30774402618408203,
0.1892414391040802,
-0.4778955578804016,
-0.3828287124633789,
-0.5432938933372498,
-0.5577700138092041,
-0.5485419034957886,
-0.21028561890125275,
-0.11130350083112717,
0.03002404049038887,
0.664020299911499,
0.46685510873794556,
-0.7289025783538818,
-0.03853202983736992,
-0.30705490708351135,
0.14186982810497284,
-0.21827062964439392,
-0.2843875288963318,
-0.1207544356584549,
-0.8252254724502563,
-0.418233186006546,
0.5195106863975525,
0.0886726826429367,
0.15712442994117737,
-0.5044163465499878,
0.17335189878940582,
-0.03551706299185753,
-0.018165433779358864,
0.3437962234020233,
0.6694056987762451,
-0.7280609011650085,
0.040014948695898056,
0.5892040729522705,
-0.02778475172817707,
-0.1646542251110077,
1.3038480281829834,
-0.80597984790802,
0.5553570985794067,
1.112303614616394,
0.49063700437545776,
-0.5944981575012207,
0.259711891412735,
0.753517210483551,
-0.8694208860397339,
-0.17238083481788635,
0.35864347219467163,
0.009328779764473438,
0.37057602405548096,
-0.5360981225967407,
0.5008381605148315,
0.2542348802089691,
-0.5440442562103271,
-0.5127289295196533,
0.4552956223487854,
-0.6360301971435547,
-0.40830057859420776,
0.9869319796562195,
0.3575626313686371,
-0.08950074017047882,
-0.501608669757843,
-0.5497674942016602,
0.09094008058309555,
-0.6236864328384399,
0.5645976662635803,
0.7367693781852722,
-0.31405162811279297,
-0.40549618005752563,
-0.6441709995269775,
0.736784815788269,
0.42160922288894653,
-0.726367712020874,
-0.14055828750133514,
0.5162436366081238,
-0.16704653203487396,
0.6066244840621948,
0.7758617401123047,
0.33649274706840515,
0.5258632898330688,
-0.10576756298542023,
0.08444026857614517,
0.1853267401456833,
-0.4121435284614563,
-0.7427003383636475,
0.051214948296546936,
0.14157497882843018,
-0.14423824846744537
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.04412v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.04412v1
|
Aligning Large Language Models with Self-generated Preference Data
| 2024-06-06T18:01:02 | 2024-06-06T18:01:02 |
Dongyoung Kim, Kimin Lee, Jinwoo Shin, Jaehyung Kim
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Aligning large language models (LLMs) with human preferences becomes a key
component to obtaining state-of-the-art performance, but it yields a huge cost
to construct a large human-annotated preference dataset. To tackle this
problem, we propose a new framework that boosts the alignment of LLMs through
Self-generated Preference data (Selfie) using only a very small amount of
human-annotated preference data. Our key idea is leveraging the human prior
knowledge within the small (seed) data and progressively improving the
alignment of LLM, by iteratively generating the responses and learning from
them with the self-annotated preference data. To be specific, we propose to
derive the preference label from the logits of LLM to explicitly extract the
model's inherent preference. Compared to the previous approaches using external
reward models or implicit in-context learning, we observe that the proposed
approach is significantly more effective. In addition, we introduce a
noise-aware preference learning algorithm to mitigate the risk of low quality
within generated preference data. Our experimental results demonstrate that the
proposed framework significantly boosts the alignment of LLMs. For example, we
achieve superior alignment performance on AlpacaEval 2.0 with only 3.3\% of the
ground-truth preference labels in the Ultrafeedback data compared to the cases
using the entire data or state-of-the-art baselines.
|
[
-0.3085517883300781,
-0.1262396275997162,
0.4249219596385956,
-0.05611101910471916,
-0.19738328456878662,
-0.2519886791706085,
-0.43099597096443176,
-0.45566439628601074,
0.49017268419265747,
0.6340012550354004,
-0.4623921811580658,
-0.4398418068885803,
-0.3043295741081238,
-0.07664542645215988,
0.054730791598558426,
0.9478347897529602,
0.19670157134532928,
-0.13251854479312897,
-0.2973369061946869,
-0.22438877820968628,
-0.34602707624435425,
-0.615767240524292,
-0.3933162987232208,
-0.36504945158958435,
0.5971072912216187,
0.6374351382255554,
0.6358419060707092,
1.0108166933059692,
0.35588860511779785,
0.1717739999294281,
0.15113775432109833,
0.23873229324817657,
-0.44629642367362976,
0.15108728408813477,
-0.049365825951099396,
-0.12189500033855438,
-0.4426465928554535,
-0.08482862263917923,
0.5931440591812134,
0.42645707726478577,
-0.03190997987985611,
0.3474045693874359,
0.20226432383060455,
0.8482296466827393,
-0.5767855644226074,
0.10005626082420349,
-0.6308993101119995,
-0.009234501048922539,
-0.3444817066192627,
-0.2523621916770935,
-0.28665298223495483,
-0.22722862660884857,
0.09039032459259033,
-0.5828836560249329,
-0.010967581532895565,
0.12370871752500534,
0.7165058851242065,
0.3920831084251404,
-0.2960420548915863,
-0.11194057017564774,
-0.5042206645011902,
0.6856562495231628,
-0.744604229927063,
0.3824771046638489,
0.3007037341594696,
0.15261037647724152,
-0.2620265781879425,
-0.09986530244350433,
-0.5384669303894043,
0.07932226359844208,
-0.1540081650018692,
-0.04225384071469307,
-0.0025471036788076162,
-0.23539575934410095,
-0.05816997215151787,
0.2545044720172882,
-0.6298934817314148,
0.5390315055847168,
-0.06296621263027191,
-0.2953369915485382,
0.7667952179908752,
0.016271857544779778,
0.038468532264232635,
-0.23644296824932098,
-0.4305732548236847,
-0.24977897107601166,
-0.9288319945335388,
0.1962641030550003,
0.513698399066925,
0.7270187139511108,
-0.049021873623132706,
0.5197170972824097,
-0.37819617986679077,
0.7143747210502625,
0.454877644777298,
-0.4710206389427185,
0.5221781730651855,
-0.1680242419242859,
-0.10617905110120773,
0.4243546724319458,
1.0359554290771484,
0.5300171375274658,
0.13772563636302948,
-0.029019542038440704,
-0.16271932423114777,
-0.016475673764944077,
-0.01914706453680992,
-0.7335765957832336,
-0.191927969455719,
0.16728612780570984,
-0.34149637818336487,
-0.4578869640827179,
-0.183418869972229,
-0.6621242761611938,
-0.4744141399860382,
-0.41235846281051636,
0.36469390988349915,
-0.06381761282682419,
-0.4091123044490814,
0.12379908561706543,
0.5017496943473816,
0.27068498730659485,
0.2411293238401413,
-1.420305609703064,
-0.07375539839267731,
0.6640619039535522,
0.6890003681182861,
-0.41917434334754944,
-0.12480815500020981,
-0.4378482699394226,
0.32814091444015503,
-0.4380373954772949,
0.8799294233322144,
-0.3765407204627991,
-0.2507445812225342,
-0.16850243508815765,
-0.04343497380614281,
0.29824918508529663,
-0.5318228006362915,
0.4848007261753082,
-0.42585477232933044,
0.20672859251499176,
-0.40695083141326904,
-0.7010678052902222,
0.26944997906684875,
0.08631631731987,
-0.5101545453071594,
1.1908308267593384,
-0.03248545899987221,
-0.7040577530860901,
0.5312273502349854,
-0.5460809469223022,
-0.3437137007713318,
0.03948448598384857,
-0.4624381363391876,
-0.4942437708377838,
-0.022655412554740906,
0.43636006116867065,
0.6517989039421082,
-0.12460590153932571,
0.4152970016002655,
-0.45273250341415405,
-0.10374525189399719,
0.2364468276500702,
-0.2026347815990448,
0.6036823391914368,
0.3178689181804657,
-0.3438115119934082,
0.10867442935705185,
-0.607916533946991,
-0.07801491767168045,
0.12146591395139694,
-0.2667650878429413,
-0.3705981373786926,
-0.1288527250289917,
-0.3033420443534851,
0.33624279499053955,
0.516822338104248,
-0.5584938526153564,
0.4771985411643982,
-0.41083985567092896,
0.15019676089286804,
1.1861294507980347,
-0.36468854546546936,
0.734923779964447,
-0.16446378827095032,
0.23198546469211578,
-0.05506302788853645,
0.08054430037736893,
-0.14309395849704742,
-0.10083483904600143,
-0.6393859386444092,
-0.43180903792381287,
0.4533548951148987,
0.03414011001586914,
-0.0395234115421772,
0.7707539200782776,
-0.6471822261810303,
-0.25297829508781433,
-0.779478907585144,
0.5353014469146729,
0.27876707911491394,
0.8996792435646057,
0.35765594244003296,
-0.2859620451927185,
-0.5618807077407837,
-1.120079517364502,
0.1467726230621338,
-0.23223760724067688,
0.095328189432621,
0.5307031273841858,
-0.033683549612760544,
-0.22104498744010925,
1.1610417366027832,
-0.5773372054100037,
-0.4752040207386017,
0.0722331777215004,
-0.029895033687353134,
0.16005335748195648,
0.7302715182304382,
0.5469957590103149,
-0.5148618221282959,
-0.43367674946784973,
0.032108187675476074,
-0.5848041772842407,
-0.24015556275844574,
0.13328993320465088,
-0.3450181782245636,
0.3966076076030731,
0.3068269193172455,
-0.4165375530719757,
-0.08847013115882874,
0.7606056928634644,
-0.11324206739664078,
0.3261023163795471,
0.01791505143046379,
-0.05510509014129639,
-1.2162988185882568,
0.0273163802921772,
0.032472848892211914,
-0.3463362753391266,
-0.3207937180995941,
-0.3441004157066345,
0.20966403186321259,
0.1481265127658844,
-0.42693859338760376,
0.8695916533470154,
-0.4346221685409546,
-0.23059840500354767,
-0.4210628271102905,
-0.0769883543252945,
0.03587789461016655,
0.5152472257614136,
0.389728844165802,
0.8554010391235352,
0.45071813464164734,
-0.47618693113327026,
0.1721148043870926,
0.2973506450653076,
-0.30068153142929077,
0.4499862790107727,
-0.20285341143608093,
0.3201911151409149,
-0.17793628573417664,
0.2681979238986969,
-0.9787128567695618,
-0.3646184504032135,
0.137621209025383,
-0.36711055040359497,
0.4139055907726288,
-0.3979962468147278,
-0.3029557168483734,
-0.19985100626945496,
-0.25130799412727356,
0.39614468812942505,
0.4650290608406067,
-1.0869513750076294,
0.471904993057251,
0.6061704754829407,
-0.20339564979076385,
-0.8074795007705688,
-0.42185384035110474,
-0.05789334326982498,
-0.4251587688922882,
-0.3416174352169037,
0.298130601644516,
-0.11804522573947906,
0.022363407537341118,
-0.0520838238298893,
-0.16287386417388916,
0.35606831312179565,
-0.0669565498828888,
0.3747425973415375,
0.4512128233909607,
-0.2621927857398987,
0.43609368801116943,
-0.1461462676525116,
-0.3585481345653534,
-0.21213246881961823,
-0.6559930443763733,
0.534170925617218,
-0.193121075630188,
-0.21624566614627838,
-0.35273486375808716,
0.1601167619228363,
0.29611584544181824,
-0.2010931819677353,
0.4254651963710785,
0.3742661774158478,
-0.1339636892080307,
0.0747952088713646,
-0.8159253001213074,
-0.1437169760465622,
-0.49067533016204834,
0.026008011773228645,
-0.3823097050189972,
-1.0481268167495728,
0.14633889496326447,
0.015588061884045601,
0.054015375673770905,
0.510891854763031,
0.6652963161468506,
-0.4258262813091278,
1.0596674680709839,
0.6777068376541138,
-0.6532636880874634,
0.5053090453147888,
0.07374603301286697,
0.09755217283964157,
-0.8090298175811768,
-0.0779799148440361,
-0.41068732738494873,
-0.30081766843795776,
-0.6062212586402893,
-0.2719584107398987,
0.2132529765367508,
-0.08445346355438232,
-0.3314446806907654,
0.3006545603275299,
-0.5718349814414978,
0.528577446937561,
0.4942994713783264,
0.01830006204545498,
0.3013870120048523,
0.19128495454788208,
-0.04500625655055046,
-0.13160833716392517,
-0.5922144055366516,
-0.6615042686462402,
1.317618727684021,
0.26530921459198,
0.9623368978500366,
0.17861294746398926,
0.9542646408081055,
0.14817513525485992,
0.41271111369132996,
-0.6602974534034729,
0.3346128463745117,
-0.05534244328737259,
-0.5423845648765564,
-0.4499270021915436,
-0.4314084053039551,
-0.8678684830665588,
0.19876353442668915,
-0.3841108977794647,
-0.7617226839065552,
0.23482297360897064,
0.5719073414802551,
-0.6094544529914856,
0.09524748474359512,
-0.560045599937439,
0.8337081670761108,
-0.683476448059082,
-0.5850836634635925,
0.05098673328757286,
-0.6456049680709839,
0.28912296891212463,
-0.19447025656700134,
0.22494280338287354,
-0.4690339267253876,
0.08939016610383987,
0.8577190041542053,
-0.13739843666553497,
0.9521713852882385,
-0.0512138195335865,
-0.33076342940330505,
0.04481525346636772,
-0.03165408596396446,
0.5083474516868591,
-0.039010368287563324,
-0.15989045798778534,
0.16734004020690918,
-0.1581086963415146,
-0.3529967963695526,
-0.5186533331871033,
1.027571201324463,
-0.8202857375144958,
-0.6328346729278564,
-0.37943923473358154,
-0.49420860409736633,
-0.38169941306114197,
0.2763094902038574,
0.08064618706703186,
0.22334913909435272,
-0.1211237758398056,
0.06495535373687744,
0.6015114188194275,
0.10938679426908493,
0.3197115659713745,
0.6408241391181946,
-0.4148317575454712,
-0.4718930721282959,
1.0800453424453735,
0.04662923514842987,
0.15078553557395935,
0.294574111700058,
0.4897829592227936,
-0.7162054181098938,
-0.2923247218132019,
-0.5583829283714294,
0.2969840466976166,
-0.6026496291160583,
-0.44401395320892334,
-0.6810716390609741,
0.1479186713695526,
-0.6343168020248413,
-0.2557659447193146,
-0.6584262847900391,
-0.4588885009288788,
-0.28897982835769653,
-0.20345909893512726,
0.38426434993743896,
0.48108816146850586,
-0.27493348717689514,
0.33092954754829407,
-0.5189465880393982,
0.09751345962285995,
0.4934760332107544,
0.388288289308548,
-0.1773933619260788,
-0.5861992835998535,
-0.18251493573188782,
0.0748157948255539,
-0.20584948360919952,
-0.4967498183250427,
0.36494964361190796,
0.00449834018945694,
0.43909770250320435,
0.6719611883163452,
0.03263268247246742,
0.8309814929962158,
-0.3323672115802765,
0.5282360315322876,
0.3552244305610657,
-0.7803407907485962,
0.49694541096687317,
-0.35416972637176514,
0.09205903857946396,
0.8244712352752686,
0.34251725673675537,
-0.3589940369129181,
0.07455536723136902,
-0.7052321434020996,
-0.6823617815971375,
0.5590808391571045,
-0.1525256186723709,
0.19358748197555542,
0.10352151840925217,
0.4871569275856018,
0.23257869482040405,
0.1894991099834442,
-0.9022166728973389,
-0.16940169036388397,
-0.10771410912275314,
-0.5516781210899353,
-0.3384028375148773,
-0.2492365837097168,
-0.20864203572273254,
-0.32083165645599365,
0.8120682835578918,
-0.603607177734375,
-0.007720029912889004,
0.0008520686533302069,
-0.06411007046699524,
-0.31942835450172424,
0.1877891570329666,
0.35761919617652893,
0.3211946189403534,
-0.2798168957233429,
0.31131893396377563,
-0.005291035398840904,
0.07905258983373642,
0.38150754570961,
-0.07501766830682755,
-0.28432461619377136,
-0.4816187620162964,
0.002356954151764512,
0.7560850977897644,
0.16020649671554565,
-0.5254835486412048,
0.6200414299964905,
0.049390967935323715,
0.013775576837360859,
-0.0941661074757576,
0.02610446698963642,
0.29785966873168945,
0.1397351175546646,
0.17429429292678833,
-0.16367225348949432,
-0.008824225515127182,
-0.3726045787334442,
0.18587903678417206,
0.8073920607566833,
-0.3172910213470459,
-0.21456584334373474,
0.4167599380016327,
0.22219601273536682,
0.008629342541098595,
0.24229516088962555,
-0.01502864621579647,
-0.29386579990386963,
0.24612975120544434,
0.8353468775749207,
0.5893539786338806,
-0.2703889012336731,
0.1473325788974762,
0.4330136775970459,
0.023776045069098473,
-0.20683203637599945,
-0.05371491611003876,
-0.29155218601226807,
-1.0269508361816406,
-0.3239636719226837,
-0.7721605896949768,
-0.3561817407608032,
0.2700405418872833,
-0.5000724196434021,
0.29704323410987854,
-0.2320546805858612,
-0.12086492776870728,
0.010694688186049461,
-0.03228412941098213,
-0.5833061933517456,
0.25100359320640564,
0.31923744082450867,
0.4479624330997467,
-0.9317197799682617,
0.9925475716590881,
0.4572920501232147,
-0.1904599964618683,
-0.9792497754096985,
-0.07208038866519928,
0.09679240733385086,
-1.00283682346344,
0.6335069537162781,
0.2881958782672882,
-0.32182368636131287,
0.11152353137731552,
-0.5501234531402588,
-1.1832507848739624,
0.9562798142433167,
0.5990064144134521,
-0.7627542614936829,
0.23500323295593262,
0.0680447369813919,
0.411791056394577,
-0.7648127675056458,
0.06796542555093765,
0.46030110120773315,
0.35069310665130615,
0.19537116587162018,
-0.7133469581604004,
0.016566909849643707,
-0.09608916938304901,
-0.1350882202386856,
0.31008821725845337,
-0.8342881202697754,
0.3721649944782257,
-0.20756131410598755,
-0.12344665080308914,
-0.22664394974708557,
0.8708866834640503,
0.18418093025684357,
-0.0946676954627037,
0.6249892711639404,
0.6444652080535889,
0.8331153988838196,
0.1434268355369568,
0.7231181263923645,
-0.37935537099838257,
0.33258330821990967,
1.3857996463775635,
-0.47803741693496704,
0.9036174416542053,
0.6069863438606262,
0.025635724887251854,
0.2518813908100128,
0.7276017069816589,
0.12377064675092697,
0.4536847770214081,
-0.0841873437166214,
-0.04430226981639862,
-0.5229910016059875,
-0.3172619044780731,
-0.37410005927085876,
0.5895313620567322,
0.03157271817326546,
-0.3266827464103699,
0.027724280953407288,
-0.27986910939216614,
0.02417120523750782,
-0.0370742492377758,
-0.08492817729711533,
1.0027670860290527,
-0.13999012112617493,
-0.768538773059845,
0.5930158495903015,
-0.2776426076889038,
0.8012925386428833,
-0.49278345704078674,
0.19063463807106018,
-0.22197061777114868,
0.0035231781657785177,
-0.3203887939453125,
-0.8366049528121948,
-0.04791790992021561,
-0.08518749475479126,
-0.23039625585079193,
-0.24269519746303558,
0.6835708022117615,
-0.6569216251373291,
-0.4258560240268707,
0.20224334299564362,
0.3071286678314209,
-0.019913874566555023,
0.1809762567281723,
-0.5332314372062683,
0.03774416446685791,
0.0369267612695694,
-0.11076566576957703,
0.6734614372253418,
-0.05381695553660393,
-0.051198720932006836,
0.5549797415733337,
0.8220712542533875,
0.15127348899841309,
-0.14324942231178284,
-0.05091933533549309,
0.8402867913246155,
-0.5633445978164673,
-0.6000382304191589,
-0.9361035227775574,
0.19421735405921936,
-0.12490350008010864,
-0.20584723353385925,
0.6379194855690002,
0.7294751405715942,
0.8191742300987244,
0.1643274575471878,
0.8137237429618835,
0.26353031396865845,
0.5274802446365356,
-0.583282470703125,
0.4832535684108734,
-0.613802969455719,
0.23363789916038513,
-0.29435020685195923,
-0.8669273257255554,
-0.1851935088634491,
0.6853042244911194,
-0.3888448476791382,
-0.19566203653812408,
0.21094144880771637,
1.1145788431167603,
-0.17297972738742828,
-0.18141907453536987,
0.2457461953163147,
-0.07497236877679825,
0.18397288024425507,
0.4709455072879791,
0.6651632785797119,
-0.11074639111757278,
0.24318541586399078,
-0.43536728620529175,
-0.3098220229148865,
-0.24054484069347382,
-1.1856180429458618,
-0.5832158923149109,
-0.6280012130737305,
-0.30002161860466003,
-0.2793978154659271,
-0.04049484804272652,
1.4783713817596436,
0.8800941109657288,
-0.7649111747741699,
-0.2961577773094177,
0.2518550753593445,
-0.07629593461751938,
-0.02814529277384281,
-0.1526375263929367,
0.5130424499511719,
-0.28520846366882324,
-0.6014190912246704,
0.43914079666137695,
0.4119413197040558,
0.3320329487323761,
-0.2127247452735901,
-0.3806781768798828,
0.023873673751950264,
-0.07855020463466644,
0.38287895917892456,
0.5212832093238831,
-0.7359881401062012,
-0.4359060227870941,
-0.11632099747657776,
-0.27485930919647217,
0.562869131565094,
0.7295159101486206,
-0.7291345596313477,
0.48571500182151794,
0.17999354004859924,
0.7375394105911255,
0.4753103256225586,
0.24293407797813416,
0.5441867113113403,
-0.6995699405670166,
0.07258916646242142,
-0.011179576627910137,
0.46029844880104065,
0.6585016250610352,
-0.640760064125061,
0.38131919503211975,
-0.11134659498929977,
-0.5944808125495911,
-0.6975830793380737,
0.24435560405254364,
-0.9236701726913452,
-0.008971501141786575,
1.2503669261932373,
0.07943975180387497,
-0.21936272084712982,
0.1793452352285385,
-0.24971814453601837,
0.09238224476575851,
-0.5969974994659424,
0.8712234497070312,
0.4028171896934509,
-0.284962922334671,
-0.020960984751582146,
-0.07036314904689789,
0.6560263633728027,
0.6583186984062195,
-0.6941342949867249,
0.3631459176540375,
0.6099007725715637,
0.4688570499420166,
0.2098080813884735,
0.9062609672546387,
-0.20003724098205566,
-0.020843541249632835,
-0.6388067007064819,
0.4295189082622528,
-0.026856327429413795,
-0.2824456989765167,
-0.5739551782608032,
0.04983868449926376,
0.301149845123291,
-0.08003433793783188
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.04344v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.04344v1
|
Verbalized Machine Learning: Revisiting Machine Learning with Language Models
| 2024-06-06T17:59:56 | 2024-06-06T17:59:56 |
Tim Z. Xiao, Robert Bamler, Bernhard Schölkopf, Weiyang Liu
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CV
|
Motivated by the large progress made by large language models (LLMs), we
introduce the framework of verbalized machine learning (VML). In contrast to
conventional machine learning models that are typically optimized over a
continuous parameter space, VML constrains the parameter space to be
human-interpretable natural language. Such a constraint leads to a new
perspective of function approximation, where an LLM with a text prompt can be
viewed as a function parameterized by the text prompt. Guided by this
perspective, we revisit classical machine learning problems, such as regression
and classification, and find that these problems can be solved by an
LLM-parameterized learner and optimizer. The major advantages of VML include
(1) easy encoding of inductive bias: prior knowledge about the problem and
hypothesis class can be encoded in natural language and fed into the
LLM-parameterized learner; (2) automatic model class selection: the optimizer
can automatically select a concrete model class based on data and verbalized
prior knowledge, and it can update the model class during training; and (3)
interpretable learner updates: the LLM-parameterized optimizer can provide
explanations for why each learner update is performed. We conduct several
studies to empirically evaluate the effectiveness of VML, and hope that VML can
serve as a stepping stone to stronger interpretability and trustworthiness in
ML.
|
[
-0.048583097755908966,
-0.8495187163352966,
0.7843140363693237,
-0.012828894890844822,
-0.07294929027557373,
0.006518951151520014,
-0.44559717178344727,
-0.29514023661613464,
-0.3395509421825409,
0.5918588638305664,
-0.428515762090683,
-0.4670643210411072,
-0.74964839220047,
0.10872480273246765,
-0.4869210720062256,
0.8341374397277832,
0.03916080668568611,
0.4818885624408722,
-0.5988552570343018,
0.0664520338177681,
-0.21021804213523865,
-0.8510847091674805,
-0.8314727544784546,
-0.7747517824172974,
0.48076340556144714,
0.1957630217075348,
0.7785297632217407,
0.6983444690704346,
0.320238322019577,
0.35033097863197327,
0.08018171042203903,
0.15798206627368927,
-0.4282251000404358,
0.4215666353702545,
0.3145047426223755,
-0.6315850615501404,
-0.22553928196430206,
0.06795721501111984,
0.796768307685852,
1.1242939233779907,
-0.09668853133916855,
0.018568307161331177,
0.10749935358762741,
0.6231764554977417,
-0.4611823856830597,
0.7230793833732605,
-0.546051561832428,
0.1685376763343811,
0.41140347719192505,
-0.13750967383384705,
-0.7340807914733887,
-0.325023889541626,
0.07760614156723022,
-0.7367163896560669,
0.07165475934743881,
-0.1738540083169937,
0.8323253393173218,
0.6710138916969299,
-0.2648889124393463,
-0.38274016976356506,
-0.8721385598182678,
1.0910052061080933,
-0.5218976140022278,
0.5932980179786682,
0.5275976061820984,
0.575927197933197,
-0.2348269373178482,
-1.086138367652893,
-0.2687585949897766,
-0.8386050462722778,
-0.11058763414621353,
-0.02520020864903927,
-0.15460337698459625,
0.0969773456454277,
0.38923245668411255,
0.05479788780212402,
-0.2964754104614258,
0.26561909914016724,
-0.4587278366088867,
-0.01282566599547863,
0.6717455983161926,
0.18346571922302246,
0.1528242975473404,
0.1831119805574417,
-0.24293912947177887,
-0.038414593786001205,
-0.5441192388534546,
0.020909862592816353,
-0.014798627234995365,
0.3834379017353058,
0.29912564158439636,
0.4435531795024872,
-0.08312296122312546,
0.879716694355011,
-0.22453978657722473,
-0.09093444049358368,
0.27981773018836975,
0.046935271471738815,
-0.3806248605251312,
0.027629295364022255,
0.7024226188659668,
0.038509320467710495,
0.6796920299530029,
-0.07090991735458374,
-0.20401237905025482,
-0.225912407040596,
0.4763215184211731,
-0.7981070876121521,
0.10147091001272202,
0.13666406273841858,
-0.5488814115524292,
-0.4647781550884247,
0.09140238165855408,
-0.25028491020202637,
-0.40353137254714966,
-0.9137957692146301,
0.16771948337554932,
-0.43172571063041687,
0.13323277235031128,
0.10924472659826279,
-0.01839323900640011,
0.43717777729034424,
0.6448504328727722,
-0.7927876114845276,
0.5191159844398499,
1.0017333030700684,
0.6343300342559814,
0.037686627358198166,
-0.3578181564807892,
-0.6532655358314514,
-0.01186873484402895,
-0.3235304355621338,
0.46252161264419556,
-0.7118594646453857,
-0.5908837914466858,
0.08674672245979309,
-0.09323900938034058,
-0.11858414113521576,
-0.682618260383606,
0.2938745617866516,
-0.2483726143836975,
0.538707971572876,
-0.06064340099692345,
-0.7956495881080627,
-0.125506192445755,
0.2031511664390564,
-0.5427885055541992,
1.17947256565094,
0.16950829327106476,
-0.5266651511192322,
0.3520222008228302,
-0.671143114566803,
-0.2048339992761612,
0.0058015985414385796,
-0.14387403428554535,
-0.5010578036308289,
0.22435952723026276,
0.071049265563488,
0.6200116872787476,
-0.3317128121852875,
0.2611103355884552,
-0.3526180684566498,
-0.3015519082546234,
0.4159279465675354,
-0.5693865418434143,
0.6086541414260864,
0.47654134035110474,
-0.037501297891139984,
0.3356432318687439,
-0.787049412727356,
0.19466158747673035,
0.23272252082824707,
-0.5286094546318054,
-0.2695740759372711,
0.19198355078697205,
0.05835931375622749,
-0.10423976927995682,
0.2621701955795288,
-0.17570234835147858,
0.08491162955760956,
-0.4684789478778839,
0.5887102484703064,
0.7141494154930115,
-0.39972493052482605,
0.5146492123603821,
-0.16224025189876556,
0.538352370262146,
-0.2637823522090912,
0.30850642919540405,
-0.17469671368598938,
-0.394549697637558,
-0.706775426864624,
-0.47766613960266113,
0.4860066771507263,
0.5709843635559082,
-0.49888715147972107,
0.15858612954616547,
-0.06618854403495789,
-0.3055369257926941,
-0.8343918919563293,
0.1376871019601822,
0.25476908683776855,
0.6193079948425293,
0.31697097420692444,
0.08825992792844772,
-0.4697812497615814,
-0.7824335098266602,
-0.17152492702007294,
-0.4306942820549011,
-0.2826581299304962,
0.4207444489002228,
0.28713497519493103,
-0.3191390633583069,
0.8755731582641602,
-0.44669198989868164,
0.04985816776752472,
-0.37981659173965454,
0.011469833552837372,
0.021428383886814117,
0.1412036269903183,
0.2625509798526764,
-0.7381162643432617,
-0.49385780096054077,
0.12065433710813522,
-0.9959703683853149,
-0.2570435702800751,
-0.02922443300485611,
0.2002883404493332,
0.19412824511528015,
0.9028557538986206,
-0.34384188055992126,
0.217129185795784,
0.09757156670093536,
-0.04268086329102516,
0.519025981426239,
-0.4453418552875519,
-0.3447415232658386,
-0.9598027467727661,
-0.0722702294588089,
0.019460121169686317,
-0.5489039421081543,
-0.8099049925804138,
0.08795993775129318,
-0.08939028531312943,
-0.15050284564495087,
-0.38601765036582947,
0.6691591143608093,
-0.38974878191947937,
-0.06957533955574036,
-0.5942469239234924,
0.1032596305012703,
-0.3226630985736847,
0.0738481879234314,
0.1879817247390747,
0.5715472102165222,
0.6139343976974487,
-0.47235098481178284,
0.32637104392051697,
-0.006826794706285,
0.23844154179096222,
0.5401360392570496,
-0.7926180958747864,
0.12860430777072906,
-0.5977661609649658,
0.2154015153646469,
-0.674633264541626,
-0.07108419388532639,
0.27046117186546326,
-0.6400599479675293,
0.36936771869659424,
-0.02949291653931141,
-0.16531789302825928,
-0.1316768229007721,
-0.24365293979644775,
-0.07329419255256653,
0.7127473950386047,
-0.5049033761024475,
0.5918133854866028,
0.1987907588481903,
0.18937835097312927,
-0.6320880055427551,
-0.425935298204422,
0.11266874521970749,
-0.1393548548221588,
-0.3183267116546631,
0.01618167944252491,
0.042316701263189316,
-0.5765241384506226,
0.005384833551943302,
0.2193649858236313,
-0.2192586213350296,
0.4449194371700287,
0.3397720456123352,
0.2610161304473877,
-0.3382178246974945,
0.340741902589798,
-0.16234461963176727,
-0.40291109681129456,
0.27101215720176697,
-0.4738393723964691,
0.4215622842311859,
-0.46831923723220825,
-0.16199488937854767,
-0.36074379086494446,
0.1563812792301178,
0.2968120574951172,
-0.078087717294693,
0.9363104104995728,
0.773474395275116,
-0.43338558077812195,
-0.37537065148353577,
-0.10224324464797974,
-0.2943122684955597,
-0.42284125089645386,
0.4572642743587494,
-0.38692542910575867,
-0.9802528023719788,
-0.10324594378471375,
-0.16165103018283844,
-0.013123281300067902,
0.2491999864578247,
0.6799800992012024,
-0.23886743187904358,
1.035556435585022,
0.8151705265045166,
-0.22507160902023315,
0.46055206656455994,
-0.11404459923505783,
-0.01680212840437889,
-0.48766598105430603,
-0.1832001954317093,
-0.5904685854911804,
-0.0542716346681118,
-0.6084288954734802,
-0.3496907949447632,
0.09927874803543091,
0.013727123849093914,
-0.2566145062446594,
0.015060418285429478,
-0.2528621256351471,
0.4223247468471527,
0.7312936186790466,
-0.024521220475435257,
0.17437101900577545,
-0.05375394970178604,
-0.010745573788881302,
0.0034986278042197227,
-0.5165256261825562,
-0.8122024536132812,
1.1780006885528564,
0.5760878920555115,
0.6277244091033936,
-0.29498255252838135,
0.7582142353057861,
0.1937400996685028,
0.5189470052719116,
-1.0865976810455322,
0.5158758163452148,
-0.0805378183722496,
-0.26975247263908386,
-0.30750441551208496,
-0.47980523109436035,
-1.140143871307373,
0.47977423667907715,
-0.27620020508766174,
-0.5872536301612854,
-0.390790730714798,
0.20659911632537842,
0.10120540112257004,
0.08144357800483704,
-0.8111854195594788,
0.776721179485321,
-0.2358960211277008,
-0.06951019912958145,
-0.09628424793481827,
-0.7932151556015015,
0.10394864529371262,
-0.13115574419498444,
0.30964478850364685,
0.12497317045927048,
-0.28055110573768616,
0.46259185671806335,
-0.7928855419158936,
0.9728113412857056,
-0.31533676385879517,
0.11681986600160599,
-0.1074269562959671,
-0.352162629365921,
0.30488085746765137,
-0.11691201478242874,
-0.1617942452430725,
-0.03642050921916962,
0.07377595454454422,
-0.48946937918663025,
-0.9683986902236938,
0.43070483207702637,
-0.7245270013809204,
-0.7753390073776245,
-0.4579080045223236,
-0.3835976719856262,
-0.29120123386383057,
0.11913979053497314,
-0.030524713918566704,
0.1521713137626648,
-0.39718103408813477,
0.17081569135189056,
0.7204324007034302,
-0.2881178557872772,
0.2975527048110962,
0.392029345035553,
-0.47060978412628174,
-0.19304709136486053,
0.8160723447799683,
-0.1579514741897583,
0.3648717999458313,
0.5123579502105713,
0.47492295503616333,
-0.2824496030807495,
-0.5064589977264404,
-0.2138517051935196,
0.42778411507606506,
-0.8187609314918518,
0.3213570713996887,
-0.4766733646392822,
-0.5927845239639282,
-0.1307975798845291,
-0.14250701665878296,
-0.2096308171749115,
-0.3684632480144501,
-0.6623104810714722,
-0.17778804898262024,
0.17177827656269073,
0.8866640329360962,
0.10886993259191513,
0.3022090494632721,
-0.33913740515708923,
0.06362923979759216,
0.20203925669193268,
-0.05781326815485954,
-0.1919076144695282,
-0.4808788001537323,
-0.14892712235450745,
-0.1251349300146103,
-0.06882546842098236,
-0.6842196583747864,
0.3653136193752289,
0.3137536942958832,
0.6301496624946594,
0.26634451746940613,
-0.2895236313343048,
0.24883079528808594,
-0.732185423374176,
0.5698274970054626,
0.09214041382074356,
-0.7457759380340576,
0.5490550398826599,
-0.0029368821997195482,
0.23735411465168,
0.3453170359134674,
0.6616249680519104,
-0.6615484356880188,
-0.42979785799980164,
-0.4693237841129303,
-0.6187248826026917,
0.4093189239501953,
0.06540842354297638,
0.302431583404541,
0.11046034097671509,
0.5078606009483337,
0.2303745150566101,
0.3514467477798462,
-0.6272372603416443,
-0.42792442440986633,
-0.1762995421886444,
-0.5673975944519043,
-0.36428385972976685,
-0.31942224502563477,
0.09189271181821823,
-0.29917842149734497,
0.563565194606781,
-0.31939786672592163,
0.27391543984413147,
0.08376220613718033,
-0.26401907205581665,
0.1307152807712555,
0.25805917382240295,
0.5420810580253601,
0.8456414937973022,
-0.0709049254655838,
0.14586271345615387,
0.1908176690340042,
-0.41040560603141785,
0.10407967120409012,
0.20277619361877441,
-0.34816670417785645,
0.1081056296825409,
0.5868889689445496,
0.9765455722808838,
0.12074583768844604,
-0.6974170207977295,
0.37526243925094604,
-0.23283751308918,
-0.42331641912460327,
-0.4766070246696472,
0.15425844490528107,
0.022653896361589432,
0.2879604995250702,
0.18299812078475952,
-0.0959421768784523,
0.11787957698106766,
-0.40521153807640076,
0.1812366396188736,
0.6106588244438171,
-0.778922438621521,
-0.17248210310935974,
0.913062334060669,
-0.11549726128578186,
-0.5657610297203064,
0.42197495698928833,
0.027442848309874535,
-0.5417688488960266,
0.42681294679641724,
0.5336392521858215,
0.8873591423034668,
-0.33804401755332947,
0.4028896689414978,
0.12486843764781952,
0.3783934414386749,
-0.095099076628685,
0.21136464178562164,
-0.009368699043989182,
-0.6088646054267883,
-0.44518792629241943,
-0.6851190328598022,
-0.643157958984375,
0.14507688581943512,
-0.6325759887695312,
0.2718363404273987,
-0.6979628205299377,
-0.087459035217762,
0.18907330930233002,
-0.03861325606703758,
-0.4520430266857147,
0.264661580324173,
0.3666589558124542,
0.7257326245307922,
-0.6091868877410889,
1.0843307971954346,
0.8057132959365845,
-0.36199289560317993,
-0.7061213254928589,
-0.18180784583091736,
0.05276509374380112,
-1.080112338066101,
0.856941819190979,
0.13247187435626984,
-0.08040770888328552,
-0.04234479367733002,
-0.5906393527984619,
-0.6137285232543945,
0.8616045117378235,
0.5608409643173218,
-0.4297125041484833,
0.12290803343057632,
0.3101015090942383,
0.7724482417106628,
-0.45572859048843384,
0.27177467942237854,
0.5475907325744629,
0.44579586386680603,
0.0889369398355484,
-0.9332822561264038,
-0.016698243096470833,
-0.13301844894886017,
0.2354639321565628,
0.1675466150045395,
-0.19559186697006226,
0.6015893220901489,
-0.20105139911174774,
0.17790162563323975,
-0.05337600037455559,
0.802341639995575,
0.12818102538585663,
0.47632330656051636,
0.4038647711277008,
0.3070419132709503,
1.178073763847351,
-0.11104962974786758,
1.2210447788238525,
0.06511043012142181,
0.286615788936615,
1.0829461812973022,
-0.2651330530643463,
0.9447069764137268,
0.5146267414093018,
-0.3759039342403412,
0.2661757469177246,
0.670129656791687,
0.022630808874964714,
0.267775297164917,
0.5006133913993835,
-0.3531944751739502,
-0.20944830775260925,
-0.03043375536799431,
-0.3250247538089752,
0.3680278956890106,
0.23516617715358734,
-0.7385154366493225,
-0.14756254851818085,
0.3522894084453583,
0.34197646379470825,
0.28352057933807373,
-0.31284627318382263,
0.8373609781265259,
0.3456493318080902,
-0.34024667739868164,
0.674778401851654,
0.10336572676897049,
0.343420147895813,
-0.561953604221344,
0.032107386738061905,
0.027474407106637955,
0.3426932990550995,
-0.04821282625198364,
-0.3861579895019531,
0.28658968210220337,
-0.024447942152619362,
-0.17796650528907776,
-0.45354118943214417,
0.8987423777580261,
-0.4818682074546814,
-0.7761410474777222,
0.17732873558998108,
0.5011629462242126,
0.3200170695781708,
-0.015134617686271667,
-0.969372034072876,
-0.04213177040219307,
-0.12962360680103302,
-0.23369933664798737,
0.28522393107414246,
0.30851367115974426,
-0.0340486541390419,
0.9878919124603271,
0.5139293074607849,
0.09453874826431274,
0.024228980764746666,
0.22381331026554108,
0.7597336173057556,
-0.6915047764778137,
-0.22174182534217834,
-0.9617191553115845,
0.192541241645813,
-0.029792791232466698,
0.038634683936834335,
0.7027004957199097,
0.3928641080856323,
0.8707064986228943,
-0.04490095376968384,
0.9285409450531006,
0.33463358879089355,
0.4053210914134979,
-0.7760492563247681,
0.5411021113395691,
-0.5650802850723267,
0.38018566370010376,
0.056751590222120285,
-0.7081677317619324,
-0.5679630637168884,
0.608679473400116,
-0.5631410479545593,
0.1850971281528473,
0.741387665271759,
0.5849893689155579,
0.10783922672271729,
0.05781371891498566,
0.46301838755607605,
0.12675414979457855,
0.3094020187854767,
0.30375877022743225,
1.108843445777893,
-0.1819385588169098,
0.17735065519809723,
-0.05702793598175049,
-0.20003321766853333,
-0.21099665760993958,
-0.7515361309051514,
-0.9914662837982178,
-0.618748128414154,
-0.40095874667167664,
-0.2501348853111267,
0.2110326588153839,
1.2003837823867798,
0.7299917936325073,
-0.6966721415519714,
-0.5151453018188477,
0.014650396071374416,
0.27698802947998047,
-0.1338685303926468,
-0.20487751066684723,
0.13882258534431458,
-0.8635172843933105,
-0.7948805689811707,
0.437623530626297,
0.1483723670244217,
-0.03147978335618973,
-0.38245993852615356,
-0.3689613342285156,
0.17787908017635345,
0.15634393692016602,
0.8240759968757629,
0.2669517695903778,
-0.7778487205505371,
-0.13678717613220215,
-0.02592773362994194,
-0.09159728139638901,
0.06285867840051651,
0.8209868669509888,
-0.8939708471298218,
0.3729270100593567,
0.08036968111991882,
0.8500121831893921,
0.6277333498001099,
-0.08565302193164825,
0.803260087966919,
-0.5922108888626099,
0.13095125555992126,
0.15601025521755219,
0.33335059881210327,
0.37028345465660095,
-0.25209566950798035,
0.49477314949035645,
0.15351277589797974,
-0.48752710223197937,
-0.9453789591789246,
0.1806841790676117,
-0.7261087894439697,
-0.652529776096344,
1.1888083219528198,
0.01789783500134945,
-0.5485475063323975,
-0.07413028925657272,
-0.3352324068546295,
0.0675695389509201,
-0.1635640412569046,
0.5477594137191772,
0.6588572859764099,
-0.10627701878547668,
-0.18594549596309662,
-0.8235628008842468,
0.6739194989204407,
0.3205464780330658,
-0.9092538356781006,
0.007557745557278395,
0.4908127188682556,
0.21157482266426086,
-0.297883003950119,
0.49039050936698914,
0.06047561392188072,
0.10792781412601471,
-0.24050113558769226,
-0.19751186668872833,
-0.37114498019218445,
-0.25861096382141113,
-0.5721890926361084,
0.18848490715026855,
0.5277094841003418,
-0.18077246844768524
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.04331v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.04331v1
|
PaCE: Parsimonious Concept Engineering for Large Language Models
| 2024-06-06T17:59:10 | 2024-06-06T17:59:10 |
Jinqi Luo, Tianjiao Ding, Kwan Ho Ryan Chan, Darshan Thaker, Aditya Chattopadhyay, Chris Callison-Burch, René Vidal
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR, cs.LG
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) are being used for a wide variety of tasks.
While they are capable of generating human-like responses, they can also
produce undesirable output including potentially harmful information, racist or
sexist language, and hallucinations. Alignment methods are designed to reduce
such undesirable output, via techniques such as fine-tuning, prompt
engineering, and representation engineering. However, existing methods face
several challenges: some require costly fine-tuning for every alignment task;
some do not adequately remove undesirable concepts, failing alignment; some
remove benign concepts, lowering the linguistic capabilities of LLMs. To
address these issues, we propose Parsimonious Concept Engineering (PaCE), a
novel activation engineering framework for alignment. First, to sufficiently
model the concepts, we construct a large-scale concept dictionary in the
activation space, in which each atom corresponds to a semantic concept. Then,
given any alignment task, we instruct a concept partitioner to efficiently
annotate the concepts as benign or undesirable. Finally, at inference time, we
decompose the LLM activations along the concept dictionary via sparse coding,
to accurately represent the activation as a linear combination of the benign
and undesirable components. By removing the latter ones from the activation, we
reorient the behavior of LLMs towards alignment goals. We conduct experiments
on tasks such as response detoxification, faithfulness enhancement, and
sentiment revising, and show that PaCE achieves state-of-the-art alignment
performance while maintaining linguistic capabilities.
|
[
-0.1575300097465515,
-0.9510520100593567,
0.5501340627670288,
0.4168117940425873,
-0.19804568588733673,
0.29190269112586975,
-0.31046736240386963,
-0.16787013411521912,
0.37077316641807556,
0.21538777649402618,
-0.4928027093410492,
-0.44140809774398804,
-0.4288758933544159,
-0.13047859072685242,
-0.41219595074653625,
0.6461417078971863,
-0.14459381997585297,
-0.15738098323345184,
-0.17583094537258148,
-0.0729515478014946,
-0.6069381833076477,
-0.0909515768289566,
-0.5758278369903564,
-0.18982000648975372,
0.2696637213230133,
0.23564231395721436,
0.8065712451934814,
1.0609714984893799,
0.5464474558830261,
0.328581839799881,
-0.390426367521286,
0.1350998729467392,
-0.6555843949317932,
0.17604106664657593,
-0.3552146255970001,
-0.19179607927799225,
-0.6764491200447083,
0.008994869887828827,
0.5988807082176208,
0.9571781158447266,
-0.10480799525976181,
0.19586776196956635,
0.21524572372436523,
0.5692052245140076,
-0.6856604218482971,
-0.05552796274423599,
-0.775822639465332,
-0.28521108627319336,
-0.2171134501695633,
-0.22377142310142517,
-0.3580004572868347,
-0.1435934603214264,
-0.29871270060539246,
-0.7705830931663513,
-0.05963212996721268,
0.1395011693239212,
0.8934208750724792,
0.6542129516601562,
0.003597470698878169,
-0.21053682267665863,
-0.6963539719581604,
0.925917387008667,
-0.607666015625,
0.40247270464897156,
0.1969350278377533,
-0.24497349560260773,
-0.38778236508369446,
-0.12434641271829605,
-0.643368661403656,
-0.18472027778625488,
0.06484236568212509,
-0.022094450891017914,
0.15580540895462036,
0.24760465323925018,
0.46544867753982544,
0.3261890709400177,
-0.6112493276596069,
0.4566788375377655,
0.03215566650032997,
-0.2539205551147461,
0.6826320886611938,
0.2492639720439911,
0.5307442545890808,
-0.0644054263830185,
-0.585431694984436,
0.1315433382987976,
-0.6329993009567261,
0.0340462252497673,
0.35840851068496704,
0.30447110533714294,
0.10617908835411072,
0.9875003695487976,
-0.3879115581512451,
0.6510613560676575,
0.3006107807159424,
-0.07502695173025131,
0.2847030460834503,
-0.29685407876968384,
-0.20781861245632172,
0.40157997608184814,
0.7322573065757751,
0.2796710431575775,
-0.09590091556310654,
-0.32727137207984924,
-0.33081820607185364,
0.5940405130386353,
0.5265737175941467,
-0.811935305595398,
0.09341591596603394,
0.6278037428855896,
-0.21232230961322784,
-0.3978281617164612,
-0.27521276473999023,
-0.7359328866004944,
-0.44314509630203247,
-0.5614151358604431,
0.39704886078834534,
-0.7391259074211121,
-0.23965026438236237,
0.3538970351219177,
0.054598964750766754,
0.4100460708141327,
0.14925184845924377,
-0.8908025622367859,
-0.14037984609603882,
1.1030497550964355,
0.7550031542778015,
-0.24034428596496582,
-0.2953152358531952,
-0.5141168236732483,
0.3507727086544037,
-0.49421605467796326,
0.5901055335998535,
-0.7697786688804626,
-0.40316757559776306,
-0.2678239345550537,
-0.1802232414484024,
-0.056070007383823395,
-0.3470560312271118,
0.6956536173820496,
-0.6447057723999023,
-0.37421151995658875,
-0.20244188606739044,
-0.9222274422645569,
0.18216435611248016,
0.20815926790237427,
-0.5854436159133911,
0.9431803822517395,
-0.19635407626628876,
-0.7136039733886719,
0.023082122206687927,
-0.743725061416626,
-0.3591731786727905,
0.02404310554265976,
0.034789491444826126,
-0.2589263319969177,
0.4372652471065521,
-0.04752275347709656,
0.34569063782691956,
-0.13642685115337372,
0.4993726909160614,
-0.3209945857524872,
-0.41135865449905396,
0.18361857533454895,
-0.04003964364528656,
0.7044438123703003,
0.3355574309825897,
-0.24734170734882355,
0.3733448386192322,
-1.029139518737793,
-0.19434216618537903,
0.12056471407413483,
-0.09304258227348328,
-0.682482898235321,
0.16247789561748505,
-0.3665176331996918,
0.101031593978405,
0.4572114050388336,
-0.7368724346160889,
0.08010523021221161,
-0.6196312308311462,
0.3531159460544586,
0.8457269072532654,
-0.06057099252939224,
0.7588037252426147,
-0.4124341309070587,
0.5000814199447632,
-0.14532984793186188,
-0.035793401300907135,
-0.08932016789913177,
-0.34505343437194824,
-0.6439415812492371,
-0.5561986565589905,
0.09386302530765533,
0.556106686592102,
-0.6926112174987793,
0.8216330409049988,
-0.6319619417190552,
-0.4415680170059204,
-0.6165209412574768,
0.36002346873283386,
0.26192864775657654,
0.6863502860069275,
0.29831916093826294,
-0.1544138491153717,
-0.31701743602752686,
-0.7562103271484375,
-0.33679184317588806,
-0.21655170619487762,
0.09923379868268967,
-0.2960986793041229,
0.09295112639665604,
-0.19492730498313904,
1.0138765573501587,
-0.39567267894744873,
-0.01828589476644993,
-0.0021186363883316517,
0.18593072891235352,
0.03720346465706825,
0.7383689284324646,
0.10068538039922714,
-0.6783303618431091,
-0.10258229821920395,
-0.010756212286651134,
-0.5409303903579712,
-0.4041159749031067,
-0.3909892737865448,
-0.36927494406700134,
-0.21867935359477997,
0.6808508634567261,
-0.8217530846595764,
0.14495079219341278,
0.3041994571685791,
-0.17793704569339752,
0.35550162196159363,
0.1676168441772461,
-0.05814891308546066,
-1.2083781957626343,
0.27465444803237915,
0.19381701946258545,
-0.10642943531274796,
-0.7841305732727051,
0.31855446100234985,
0.23302271962165833,
-0.2570347785949707,
-0.476276159286499,
0.6146608591079712,
-0.30686646699905396,
0.31514453887939453,
-0.25061705708503723,
0.021990103647112846,
0.005208044312894344,
0.37321633100509644,
-0.006548308301717043,
0.8457220792770386,
0.3303910791873932,
-0.5783683657646179,
0.1590140014886856,
0.5943477749824524,
-0.26945555210113525,
0.6437974572181702,
-0.5172057747840881,
0.04151594638824463,
-0.34165623784065247,
-0.24978941679000854,
-1.0420339107513428,
-0.21573850512504578,
0.23529350757598877,
-0.27887967228889465,
0.4945983290672302,
0.1656431257724762,
-0.28077390789985657,
0.014669191092252731,
-0.39051133394241333,
0.46918344497680664,
0.5291349291801453,
-0.42673617601394653,
0.661576509475708,
0.43445199728012085,
-0.29463350772857666,
-0.43937861919403076,
-0.2631049156188965,
-0.04164294898509979,
-0.5786775350570679,
-0.5344351530075073,
0.582729697227478,
0.027685346081852913,
-0.29173794388771057,
-0.07037123292684555,
-0.34237879514694214,
0.18857057392597198,
0.36743393540382385,
0.21387743949890137,
0.38332048058509827,
-0.028842339292168617,
0.14152869582176208,
0.15204578638076782,
-0.21292394399642944,
0.1912013739347458,
-0.07939258217811584,
0.687252938747406,
0.27085378766059875,
-0.40892305970191956,
-0.6392472982406616,
0.2660985589027405,
0.5677368640899658,
-0.5946527719497681,
0.5330920815467834,
0.5465347766876221,
-0.3560047149658203,
-0.15954472124576569,
-0.46501362323760986,
0.007193625904619694,
-0.508161723613739,
0.6153004765510559,
-0.48832201957702637,
-1.002794861793518,
0.38625165820121765,
-0.5413517951965332,
0.2904740273952484,
0.3756277859210968,
0.6600520610809326,
-0.12357243150472641,
1.017245888710022,
0.6066412329673767,
0.02294919081032276,
0.6045851111412048,
0.005194876343011856,
0.48193374276161194,
-1.139404296875,
-0.046583130955696106,
-0.5653033256530762,
-0.5301637053489685,
-0.34551969170570374,
-0.5476913452148438,
0.1382901966571808,
0.3634180724620819,
-0.3294982612133026,
0.3594253361225128,
-0.4262186586856842,
0.3497145473957062,
0.16968774795532227,
0.008036231622099876,
0.18079057335853577,
-0.055735811591148376,
0.016180256381630898,
-0.09976020455360413,
-0.37414705753326416,
-0.6766218543052673,
0.9124111533164978,
0.3988506495952606,
1.035550594329834,
0.040214866399765015,
0.9557820558547974,
-0.06808746606111526,
0.31577757000923157,
-1.027840256690979,
0.6285476088523865,
-0.1108987107872963,
-0.3589164614677429,
-0.44191622734069824,
-0.3432846963405609,
-0.5685363411903381,
-0.05286167934536934,
-0.17479486763477325,
-0.8193027377128601,
0.22662091255187988,
0.21055173873901367,
-0.5775659680366516,
0.21069423854351044,
-0.4931429326534271,
0.8619883060455322,
-0.24896766245365143,
-0.5421069860458374,
-0.3368869423866272,
-0.6263253688812256,
0.5668087005615234,
-0.500694990158081,
0.23510776460170746,
-0.3747190535068512,
-0.21361689269542694,
0.5237761735916138,
-0.24833279848098755,
0.9889605641365051,
-0.06178837642073631,
-0.49716269969940186,
-0.0171305350959301,
0.3334696292877197,
0.7327088713645935,
-0.19005480408668518,
-0.11964508146047592,
-0.07457158714532852,
-0.26025286316871643,
-0.37707266211509705,
-0.6453420519828796,
0.7429580688476562,
-0.5145632028579712,
-0.8748281002044678,
-0.02814675308763981,
-0.8378520011901855,
-0.5332129001617432,
0.16801585257053375,
-0.125328928232193,
0.07991071045398712,
-0.4532693922519684,
-0.10421325266361237,
0.904656171798706,
-0.31249675154685974,
0.32816094160079956,
0.17751455307006836,
-0.09294424951076508,
-0.27720215916633606,
1.3275508880615234,
-0.38177138566970825,
0.5839306712150574,
0.5755971670150757,
-0.0144130177795887,
-0.3070760667324066,
-0.6391187310218811,
-0.25184890627861023,
0.18253007531166077,
-0.37957313656806946,
-0.1257365196943283,
-0.7758059501647949,
-0.1080235168337822,
-0.359721839427948,
-0.21273252367973328,
-0.5609883069992065,
-0.5234712362289429,
-0.31748875975608826,
-0.028593312948942184,
-0.02510976791381836,
0.2700507938861847,
0.03359376639127731,
0.48321041464805603,
-0.7225240468978882,
0.504518449306488,
0.14009514451026917,
0.2582140862941742,
-0.2728215754032135,
-0.4792061746120453,
-0.09438164532184601,
0.13566698133945465,
-0.4149805009365082,
-0.6349679231643677,
0.1813645213842392,
0.14783933758735657,
0.42502498626708984,
0.5749309659004211,
0.021745163947343826,
0.9829822182655334,
-0.7322414517402649,
0.6889867186546326,
0.22633540630340576,
-1.2255432605743408,
0.5500021576881409,
-0.051597435027360916,
-0.1101117879152298,
0.5031007528305054,
0.46064987778663635,
-0.5477232933044434,
-0.4922965168952942,
-0.3805237412452698,
-0.8339653611183167,
0.43730103969573975,
0.06645776331424713,
0.2328197956085205,
-0.2231283038854599,
0.5520661473274231,
-0.04068125784397125,
0.1639348864555359,
-0.15264704823493958,
0.051382847130298615,
-0.16156771779060364,
-0.5799845457077026,
-0.07774299383163452,
-0.3682398498058319,
-0.16127000749111176,
-0.04281323030591011,
0.9672224521636963,
-0.22583292424678802,
-0.03142582252621651,
0.0620693638920784,
-0.23299679160118103,
-0.17183823883533478,
0.34066247940063477,
0.5287907719612122,
0.4523683190345764,
-0.06277025490999222,
-0.007182932924479246,
-0.1608220785856247,
-0.28432145714759827,
0.4653927981853485,
0.17879030108451843,
-0.2884141504764557,
-0.30639395117759705,
0.23037104308605194,
0.6976552605628967,
0.14235776662826538,
-0.7102323174476624,
0.38082143664360046,
0.225518599152565,
0.19360190629959106,
0.23525843024253845,
0.18275026977062225,
0.24914367496967316,
0.1364545375108719,
-0.19800348579883575,
0.006934947334229946,
0.0061778295785188675,
-0.3269439935684204,
0.04780139774084091,
0.8412840366363525,
-0.3329088091850281,
-0.4348748028278351,
0.9966050386428833,
0.3085050880908966,
-0.27675795555114746,
0.4622524082660675,
-0.3482836186885834,
-0.36635446548461914,
0.42007243633270264,
0.52811199426651,
1.039022445678711,
-0.4427087604999542,
0.2393977791070938,
0.2988711893558502,
0.35584941506385803,
-0.1294480413198471,
0.3225799798965454,
0.10198192298412323,
-1.1305330991744995,
-0.8966593742370605,
-1.1208490133285522,
-0.06329052895307541,
0.05083224177360535,
-0.6258459687232971,
0.18243764340877533,
-0.4458083510398865,
-0.17992649972438812,
0.24037772417068481,
-0.30129191279411316,
-0.33335521817207336,
-0.06747770309448242,
0.22592942416667938,
0.9461456537246704,
-1.0416406393051147,
0.7487508058547974,
0.9390295743942261,
-0.21450364589691162,
-0.7243350148200989,
0.06305089592933655,
0.18449652194976807,
-0.9880691766738892,
0.5635468363761902,
0.16547834873199463,
0.09509933739900589,
0.30420371890068054,
-0.48318320512771606,
-0.8319800496101379,
0.9292448163032532,
0.4746076166629791,
-0.8880249261856079,
-0.14804154634475708,
0.30817461013793945,
0.33293575048446655,
-0.22420747578144073,
-0.3236367106437683,
0.7907220125198364,
0.41126108169555664,
0.1744670271873474,
-0.7107803821563721,
0.28576818108558655,
-0.17246870696544647,
0.43329325318336487,
0.4165422022342682,
-0.5990862846374512,
0.4781157672405243,
-0.11580011993646622,
-0.41199368238449097,
0.43879038095474243,
0.6560498476028442,
0.3533053696155548,
-0.1477094441652298,
0.5803120732307434,
1.141029953956604,
0.7756935954093933,
-0.032520025968551636,
0.7530902028083801,
-0.6867123246192932,
0.19833627343177795,
1.0815651416778564,
-0.7454037070274353,
0.5833691358566284,
0.8683251738548279,
0.00363898859359324,
-0.05938658490777016,
0.44500401616096497,
0.3023007810115814,
0.4600561261177063,
0.28029337525367737,
-0.3600386679172516,
-0.5975165963172913,
-0.43645283579826355,
0.0493154339492321,
0.46511611342430115,
0.564740002155304,
-0.1207544356584549,
-0.21299374103546143,
-0.14480769634246826,
-0.23267042636871338,
0.11376737058162689,
-0.22233864665031433,
0.8972108364105225,
-0.01735498011112213,
-0.37855708599090576,
0.4088725447654724,
0.06597565859556198,
0.46132513880729675,
-0.44894012808799744,
-0.006204627919942141,
-0.14084015786647797,
-0.0015372885391116142,
-0.1280389130115509,
-0.5565224289894104,
0.43992936611175537,
-0.13941945135593414,
-0.0853809267282486,
-0.26078587770462036,
0.5688204765319824,
-0.4290745258331299,
-0.401212215423584,
0.049072057008743286,
0.4803507328033447,
-0.22809608280658722,
-0.005369163583964109,
-0.6265671253204346,
0.41234275698661804,
0.023650966584682465,
-0.1329086273908615,
0.28051573038101196,
0.6249166131019592,
-0.1881885826587677,
0.5084574818611145,
0.8316839933395386,
0.389443963766098,
0.012245462276041508,
-0.045591022819280624,
1.0099388360977173,
-0.718004047870636,
-0.5119948983192444,
-0.9354393482208252,
0.5655059218406677,
-0.05025249347090721,
-0.10166165977716446,
0.5213674306869507,
0.6302370429039001,
0.6612359881401062,
0.2623843848705292,
0.5019128918647766,
-0.10863016545772552,
0.32563865184783936,
-0.6501163840293884,
0.45710134506225586,
-0.46741220355033875,
0.49921914935112,
-0.27794086933135986,
-1.1697852611541748,
-0.255318820476532,
0.40146398544311523,
-0.1301177442073822,
-0.4582284092903137,
0.5750294923782349,
1.0504692792892456,
-0.03935826197266579,
0.14693138003349304,
0.26432210206985474,
0.4205072820186615,
0.5397791266441345,
0.43883058428764343,
1.0648199319839478,
0.0020992644131183624,
0.017711203545331955,
-0.31227317452430725,
-0.45334964990615845,
0.20875266194343567,
-0.869581937789917,
-0.7681438326835632,
-0.40681973099708557,
-0.6003409028053284,
-0.26730990409851074,
-0.07267381995916367,
1.1398993730545044,
0.28941309452056885,
-0.7649105191230774,
-0.016564825549721718,
-0.06628777831792831,
-0.012530416250228882,
-0.23851297795772552,
-0.22362205386161804,
0.41609182953834534,
-0.8346337676048279,
-0.8738731741905212,
0.5011195540428162,
0.5636852979660034,
-0.03606453910470009,
-0.18715353310108185,
0.08105204999446869,
-0.08117842674255371,
-0.04024337977170944,
0.4211673140525818,
0.19027023017406464,
-0.7234739661216736,
-0.29411593079566956,
-0.07380157709121704,
-0.10379055887460709,
0.05482666194438934,
0.7724239826202393,
-0.4825601577758789,
0.4155624508857727,
0.381621390581131,
1.2532554864883423,
-0.2685311436653137,
0.41816914081573486,
0.43936681747436523,
-0.7113758325576782,
0.24582473933696747,
0.3018886148929596,
0.40526828169822693,
0.25826454162597656,
-0.42462828755378723,
0.30756765604019165,
0.20332938432693481,
-0.39342212677001953,
-0.8735317587852478,
0.30586478114128113,
-1.0079492330551147,
-0.0855700895190239,
1.164505124092102,
0.057966139167547226,
-0.5628737807273865,
0.10621795803308487,
-0.11302203685045242,
0.29276689887046814,
-0.24060817062854767,
0.8734320402145386,
0.6805106401443481,
-0.08723466098308563,
0.2668183147907257,
-0.3473125994205475,
0.5697761178016663,
0.680511474609375,
-0.6753019690513611,
0.31624260544776917,
0.5937878489494324,
0.2860507369041443,
0.44151630997657776,
0.29387688636779785,
-0.2140955924987793,
-0.057666365057229996,
-0.38139885663986206,
0.25853151082992554,
0.09123393148183823,
-0.06921698153018951,
-0.5496945381164551,
0.08093675225973129,
0.08212143182754517,
-0.22519028186798096
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.04313v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.04313v2
|
Improving Alignment and Robustness with Circuit Breakers
| 2024-06-06T17:57:04 | 2024-06-10T17:40:19 |
Andy Zou, Long Phan, Justin Wang, Derek Duenas, Maxwell Lin, Maksym Andriushchenko, Rowan Wang, Zico Kolter, Matt Fredrikson, Dan Hendrycks
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.CY
|
AI systems can take harmful actions and are highly vulnerable to adversarial
attacks. We present an approach, inspired by recent advances in representation
engineering, that interrupts the models as they respond with harmful outputs
with "circuit breakers." Existing techniques aimed at improving alignment, such
as refusal training, are often bypassed. Techniques such as adversarial
training try to plug these holes by countering specific attacks. As an
alternative to refusal training and adversarial training, circuit-breaking
directly controls the representations that are responsible for harmful outputs
in the first place. Our technique can be applied to both text-only and
multimodal language models to prevent the generation of harmful outputs without
sacrificing utility -- even in the presence of powerful unseen attacks.
Notably, while adversarial robustness in standalone image recognition remains
an open challenge, circuit breakers allow the larger multimodal system to
reliably withstand image "hijacks" that aim to produce harmful content.
Finally, we extend our approach to AI agents, demonstrating considerable
reductions in the rate of harmful actions when they are under attack. Our
approach represents a significant step forward in the development of reliable
safeguards to harmful behavior and adversarial attacks.
|
[
-0.28151416778564453,
-0.7437304258346558,
0.5811296701431274,
-0.22600451111793518,
0.0801486149430275,
0.3450540602207184,
-0.07708515971899033,
-0.25083237886428833,
0.14524327218532562,
0.6067439317703247,
-0.3341062068939209,
-0.07228507101535797,
-0.7254707217216492,
-0.22254231572151184,
-0.4736826717853546,
0.9128816723823547,
-0.0689966082572937,
0.03610390052199364,
-0.17274072766304016,
-0.18800412118434906,
-0.8357215523719788,
-0.4102513790130615,
-0.4190334975719452,
-0.3195470869541168,
0.648478627204895,
0.15112189948558807,
1.1646314859390259,
0.5686102509498596,
0.7608212232589722,
0.4124718904495239,
0.21216505765914917,
0.2324797362089157,
-0.22951994836330414,
0.37635722756385803,
-0.42137452960014343,
-0.31828275322914124,
-0.3113071918487549,
0.021966638043522835,
0.39795419573783875,
0.4627319872379303,
0.15372446179389954,
-0.3447262942790985,
0.09825006127357483,
0.7132763266563416,
-0.8766205906867981,
0.056557901203632355,
-0.8590850830078125,
-0.150112584233284,
-0.20812536776065826,
-0.20844240486621857,
-1.041220784187317,
-0.008655303157866001,
-0.6332383751869202,
-0.3262079060077667,
-0.19413776695728302,
0.17486050724983215,
1.2393380403518677,
0.4373289942741394,
-0.4485275447368622,
0.07453763484954834,
-1.0000754594802856,
0.5498524308204651,
-0.12223252654075623,
0.46729329228401184,
0.1827745884656906,
0.24322152137756348,
-0.28393155336380005,
-0.527874767780304,
-0.43737366795539856,
-0.16528694331645966,
-0.2101438045501709,
0.06790181994438171,
-0.6434052586555481,
0.4087902009487152,
0.49427664279937744,
-0.09759082645177841,
-0.5605990290641785,
0.08975861221551895,
-0.3647521436214447,
-0.39866170287132263,
0.6189554929733276,
0.15513992309570312,
0.8285441398620605,
-0.024072442203760147,
-0.47632884979248047,
-0.3195602297782898,
-0.8759953379631042,
-0.04037809371948242,
0.6708167791366577,
0.15816177427768707,
0.36765310168266296,
0.5642723441123962,
0.34847015142440796,
0.4762975871562958,
0.2562089264392853,
0.3528081178665161,
-0.02061338536441326,
-0.19088076055049896,
-0.17699658870697021,
0.05088525265455246,
1.028403639793396,
0.27192357182502747,
0.20265640318393707,
-0.2930772304534912,
-0.19122056663036346,
0.48568764328956604,
0.9026995301246643,
-0.4668503403663635,
-0.7331900000572205,
0.10587330162525177,
-0.2877516448497772,
-0.6340682506561279,
0.34795331954956055,
-0.7991786003112793,
-0.6565720438957214,
-0.22421440482139587,
0.3857361972332001,
-0.6388919949531555,
-0.06044306233525276,
-0.28120890259742737,
-0.17926600575447083,
0.18680934607982635,
0.12328461557626724,
-0.875893771648407,
0.4377942681312561,
0.23357924818992615,
0.7233380079269409,
0.08686745166778564,
-0.24194484949111938,
-0.820587694644928,
0.09844973683357239,
-0.45593854784965515,
0.8047125339508057,
-0.3168540596961975,
-0.2504977285861969,
-0.32086262106895447,
0.05566583573818207,
-0.19872653484344482,
-0.5397242307662964,
0.34041470289230347,
-0.8764536380767822,
-0.27002108097076416,
-0.09208858758211136,
-0.043579619377851486,
-0.027585582807660103,
0.4571966528892517,
-0.9469581842422485,
0.46942830085754395,
-0.15179443359375,
-0.9483068585395813,
-0.05087324231863022,
-0.5147992968559265,
-0.7039499878883362,
-0.5001931190490723,
-0.37256157398223877,
-0.8362460732460022,
0.08753082901239395,
0.530219316482544,
0.070054791867733,
0.3284015357494354,
0.013802031055092812,
-0.4601821303367615,
-0.25250256061553955,
0.347199410200119,
-0.792453408241272,
1.0091594457626343,
0.10140804201364517,
-0.24255777895450592,
0.6628409624099731,
-0.5982769131660461,
0.016507912427186966,
0.30986717343330383,
0.24639306962490082,
-0.3902629315853119,
0.21558015048503876,
-0.045594826340675354,
0.43504598736763,
-0.09520766884088516,
-0.5055102705955505,
0.23276527225971222,
-0.509977400302887,
0.3894824981689453,
1.2284601926803589,
-0.03848297894001007,
0.4531003534793854,
-0.4363568425178528,
0.6877990961074829,
-0.013745266012847424,
0.2362527847290039,
-0.2467377483844757,
-0.18419989943504333,
-0.7575982213020325,
-0.22421865165233612,
0.19888365268707275,
0.6752825379371643,
-1.319629430770874,
0.46697044372558594,
-0.2531058192253113,
-0.48929107189178467,
-0.31216394901275635,
0.22353453934192657,
0.46888846158981323,
0.30958378314971924,
0.5005288124084473,
-0.5428907871246338,
-0.530849814414978,
-0.784232497215271,
-0.3215920627117157,
-0.4296416640281677,
0.13081663846969604,
-0.1554626077413559,
0.3794042468070984,
-0.044662296772003174,
0.501469075679779,
-0.5058914422988892,
-0.03453992307186127,
-0.27352088689804077,
-0.05312131345272064,
-0.19343076646327972,
0.6324037909507751,
0.44087204337120056,
-0.8884074687957764,
-0.34002241492271423,
-0.0042253825813531876,
-0.828587532043457,
0.33583909273147583,
-0.5873466730117798,
-0.3130577802658081,
-0.13432776927947998,
0.6587160229682922,
-0.6553524136543274,
0.7220338582992554,
0.2932446599006653,
-0.21076741814613342,
0.4608277976512909,
-0.03403517231345177,
0.2085471898317337,
-0.8089516758918762,
0.0036830389872193336,
-0.22801780700683594,
-0.4475841522216797,
-0.7079950571060181,
0.31941860914230347,
0.17245101928710938,
-0.4644449055194855,
-0.6381180882453918,
0.24534231424331665,
-0.41584840416908264,
0.2398047298192978,
-0.32251888513565063,
-0.01740647479891777,
0.2912880480289459,
0.49713584780693054,
-0.35124170780181885,
0.8086554408073425,
0.5829363465309143,
-0.3735984265804291,
0.42859700322151184,
0.45276063680648804,
0.04502975195646286,
0.6780650019645691,
-0.5643834471702576,
0.25268125534057617,
-0.18599431216716766,
0.05293061584234238,
-0.7942611575126648,
-0.3147408366203308,
0.4686572253704071,
-0.40817442536354065,
0.9023122787475586,
0.1721823513507843,
-0.3817141354084015,
-0.31510642170906067,
-0.5538787841796875,
0.5086312890052795,
0.3981916010379791,
-0.8380867838859558,
0.8234416246414185,
0.22962459921836853,
0.09657445549964905,
-0.54304438829422,
-0.6468526124954224,
0.3353855609893799,
-0.23593886196613312,
-0.6779802441596985,
0.253587931394577,
0.00812387466430664,
-0.276254802942276,
-0.25075775384902954,
-0.1560225486755371,
-0.06290951371192932,
0.32957059144973755,
0.41007959842681885,
0.6423570513725281,
0.2011457085609436,
0.057841718196868896,
-0.09574403613805771,
-0.36442118883132935,
0.25587886571884155,
-0.23171545565128326,
0.5613793730735779,
-0.1257597804069519,
-0.7986599206924438,
-0.7517500519752502,
0.42046812176704407,
0.8692527413368225,
-0.5837443470954895,
0.5894198417663574,
0.3001370131969452,
-0.4418528974056244,
0.16862167418003082,
-0.14057841897010803,
-0.07855571061372757,
-0.5708128809928894,
0.4243753254413605,
-0.056434497237205505,
-0.36622217297554016,
0.20872899889945984,
0.01358169224113226,
-0.1730804741382599,
0.2981797158718109,
0.3584854006767273,
-0.08494280278682709,
1.4965823888778687,
0.6529803276062012,
-0.4297560751438141,
0.7354140281677246,
-0.08275038748979568,
0.7460935115814209,
-0.7462695240974426,
-0.13954125344753265,
-0.4748649597167969,
-0.38522985577583313,
-0.46803992986679077,
-0.08149644732475281,
0.32007336616516113,
0.05784669890999794,
-0.49504855275154114,
0.5954181551933289,
-0.7273561358451843,
0.5779925584793091,
0.2969190776348114,
0.40028324723243713,
0.1017170250415802,
0.15277719497680664,
0.08729151636362076,
-0.10525254905223846,
-0.602865993976593,
-0.6482054591178894,
0.8358317017555237,
0.4148600697517395,
1.316753625869751,
0.1434638649225235,
0.6677339673042297,
0.2093820571899414,
0.3904813230037689,
-0.743023157119751,
0.40757617354393005,
-0.022983020171523094,
-0.5241398215293884,
0.08168461918830872,
-0.31170758605003357,
-0.869448184967041,
0.12054417282342911,
-0.05164960026741028,
-1.1073070764541626,
0.23157544434070587,
0.5049067139625549,
-0.2885650098323822,
0.8175884485244751,
-0.6196607947349548,
0.8699524402618408,
-0.5921903252601624,
-0.4519639015197754,
0.02799821086227894,
-0.6428724527359009,
0.550606906414032,
0.2439964860677719,
0.2753808796405792,
0.3640426695346832,
0.3828664720058441,
0.2593865692615509,
-0.5260522365570068,
0.8440183401107788,
0.020323803648352623,
0.16326314210891724,
0.38130462169647217,
0.324145644903183,
0.6934354901313782,
-0.16467110812664032,
0.18210068345069885,
-0.10128873586654663,
-0.3733976483345032,
-0.5604255199432373,
-0.7376388311386108,
0.5801262855529785,
-0.6328856945037842,
-0.5869647264480591,
-0.6104981303215027,
-0.6780110597610474,
-0.1227305606007576,
0.38099974393844604,
0.4809391498565674,
0.2752027213573456,
-0.17936328053474426,
-0.1905456930398941,
0.7960503697395325,
-0.10852830111980438,
0.4948928952217102,
-0.25728997588157654,
-0.0663042813539505,
-0.543077290058136,
1.2790260314941406,
-0.12399979680776596,
0.6882467865943909,
0.2212742418050766,
-0.2366965115070343,
0.001707598683424294,
-0.3632563650608063,
-0.3823116719722748,
-0.174944669008255,
-0.7832717299461365,
-0.5113950371742249,
-0.5598729848861694,
-0.4350912868976593,
-0.4283250868320465,
-0.3764275908470154,
-0.4478903114795685,
-0.38546252250671387,
-0.2339297980070114,
-0.13108056783676147,
-0.0693805143237114,
0.5195479393005371,
0.11965866386890411,
0.271573543548584,
-0.7783787250518799,
0.3239823281764984,
0.30353763699531555,
0.10229221731424332,
-0.13713714480400085,
-0.17612633109092712,
-0.07366594672203064,
-0.21965733170509338,
-1.1191282272338867,
-1.0229647159576416,
0.22797609865665436,
0.07583808153867722,
0.3266511559486389,
0.5895186066627502,
0.2649496793746948,
0.6119924187660217,
-0.6438099145889282,
0.6291372776031494,
0.7062903046607971,
-1.0658411979675293,
0.852340042591095,
-0.12599162757396698,
0.016414886340498924,
0.5506248474121094,
0.08627260476350784,
-0.2846522927284241,
-0.7720648050308228,
-0.8847306370735168,
-0.8461415767669678,
0.3049429953098297,
0.5259472727775574,
0.2682345509529114,
-0.11396469175815582,
-0.0489639937877655,
-0.3990541994571686,
0.1051245927810669,
-0.8649698495864868,
-0.17204371094703674,
-0.5186217427253723,
-0.36940813064575195,
0.37224990129470825,
0.2621840834617615,
-0.37256863713264465,
0.007470152340829372,
0.8708447813987732,
-0.11537868529558182,
0.18853221833705902,
0.06896183639764786,
-0.293189138174057,
-0.09444064646959305,
0.4449250102043152,
0.3672455847263336,
0.27308809757232666,
0.24258561432361603,
0.5327767133712769,
-0.10175712406635284,
-0.45638737082481384,
0.5216510891914368,
0.11367659270763397,
-0.4037112593650818,
-0.2245195358991623,
0.645977795124054,
0.5085106492042542,
-0.21487455070018768,
-0.6700524687767029,
0.6157395243644714,
-0.19056977331638336,
0.23434925079345703,
0.01123679056763649,
0.33565452694892883,
-0.3885595500469208,
0.09845840185880661,
-0.3795974552631378,
0.8467701077461243,
0.04217296838760376,
-0.6215232610702515,
0.5082046389579773,
0.6595263481140137,
-0.8713074922561646,
-0.23832407593727112,
0.9373064637184143,
0.05280238017439842,
-0.41943031549453735,
0.8118640780448914,
-0.1805879771709442,
-0.7088923454284668,
0.757770836353302,
0.4997848868370056,
0.8123843669891357,
-0.3389469087123871,
0.031621143221855164,
0.19551266729831696,
0.7919803857803345,
0.048271309584379196,
-0.0011657406575977802,
0.2298719882965088,
-0.8003262877464294,
-0.023544741794466972,
-0.019943980500102043,
-0.19266271591186523,
-0.09433034807443619,
-0.9239403605461121,
0.33349376916885376,
-1.0274920463562012,
-0.17874591052532196,
0.01712450198829174,
-0.5355303883552551,
-0.556779682636261,
0.09817678481340408,
0.02918178215622902,
0.6125475168228149,
-0.9869880676269531,
0.7303566336631775,
0.7314876914024353,
-0.7923017144203186,
-0.7471024990081787,
0.15720030665397644,
0.3096016049385071,
-0.5329691767692566,
0.2569078207015991,
0.39844921231269836,
-0.08795271813869476,
-0.2973079979419708,
-0.6725804209709167,
-0.6009405851364136,
0.8671674132347107,
0.5975654125213623,
-0.5059204697608948,
-0.0022132727317512035,
-0.40733659267425537,
0.24295198917388916,
0.01968102902173996,
0.09613007307052612,
0.6073222160339355,
0.40468630194664,
-0.12640437483787537,
-0.5354220271110535,
0.24621349573135376,
-0.4740588366985321,
-0.10218339413404465,
0.6647123694419861,
-0.5863832831382751,
0.5470329523086548,
-0.3065580129623413,
-0.3611833453178406,
0.3273777365684509,
0.5638987421989441,
0.071532242000103,
0.19786299765110016,
0.5836694240570068,
0.5286468863487244,
0.7926396727561951,
-0.33189406991004944,
1.0162591934204102,
-0.13398973643779755,
0.284530371427536,
1.2677414417266846,
-0.30191364884376526,
0.5402065515518188,
0.6347535252571106,
-0.04052845761179924,
0.5140150189399719,
0.19935770332813263,
-0.3090116083621979,
0.5353513956069946,
0.043853338807821274,
-0.2162020355463028,
-0.4727398455142975,
-0.11609917134046555,
-0.003563620848581195,
0.4832427501678467,
0.1964639574289322,
-0.412092387676239,
-0.16879481077194214,
0.4272773861885071,
0.0184182059019804,
0.5745769739151001,
-0.224807009100914,
0.5373032689094543,
-0.03512744605541229,
-0.3955172300338745,
0.27277064323425293,
-0.1981356292963028,
0.19863423705101013,
-0.30576851963996887,
-0.13254636526107788,
0.30566489696502686,
0.18789689242839813,
-0.3313157260417938,
-0.4959178864955902,
0.5845972895622253,
-0.05750478804111481,
-0.26213738322257996,
-0.23745456337928772,
1.0153151750564575,
-0.08017124980688095,
-0.7255375385284424,
0.4132080376148224,
-0.08831878006458282,
-0.296955943107605,
0.03699060156941414,
-0.4577546715736389,
0.21034185588359833,
-0.08554393798112869,
0.12566454708576202,
0.2627982795238495,
-0.056614089757204056,
-0.17501865327358246,
0.5445080399513245,
0.39852243661880493,
0.09257584810256958,
-0.0964963361620903,
-0.014249269850552082,
1.3023735284805298,
-0.5493738055229187,
-0.26626116037368774,
-1.0077757835388184,
0.7861002683639526,
-0.28437429666519165,
0.14626261591911316,
0.5085104703903198,
0.2666082978248596,
0.9889938235282898,
0.40810200572013855,
0.8601097464561462,
-0.11227505654096603,
-0.3512643277645111,
-0.6602987051010132,
0.769865095615387,
-0.3225119411945343,
0.503804624080658,
-0.5034143328666687,
-0.5611520409584045,
-0.5432276725769043,
0.5593287348747253,
-0.28759944438934326,
-0.017165031284093857,
0.7747045159339905,
0.7830018401145935,
-0.17740054428577423,
-0.14752766489982605,
0.34986862540245056,
0.20117470622062683,
0.9014265537261963,
0.5986878871917725,
0.9591285586357117,
-0.7591502666473389,
0.7096834182739258,
-0.2657085359096527,
-0.2565230131149292,
0.2686884105205536,
-0.6268528699874878,
-0.9743760824203491,
-0.09674588590860367,
-0.4356314539909363,
-0.8017987012863159,
0.10946077108383179,
0.7041136026382446,
0.5957088470458984,
-0.8222114443778992,
0.3520511984825134,
-0.13140270113945007,
0.5446809530258179,
-0.3610304892063141,
-0.1958867311477661,
0.36673077940940857,
-0.445467084646225,
-0.3294183313846588,
0.46995019912719727,
0.6298444867134094,
-0.04525289684534073,
-0.2442474365234375,
-0.015184329822659492,
-0.04925117641687393,
0.10639828443527222,
0.38461190462112427,
0.42689016461372375,
-0.669241189956665,
-0.647056519985199,
-0.13586533069610596,
-0.10618303716182709,
0.344908744096756,
0.8112115859985352,
-0.5470778346061707,
0.7231445908546448,
0.26504191756248474,
0.7722470164299011,
-0.26152166724205017,
0.06489057838916779,
0.6185739040374756,
-0.731886088848114,
0.18203042447566986,
0.3641985058784485,
0.5210719704627991,
0.446708619594574,
-0.6602332592010498,
0.06842496246099472,
0.1742364913225174,
-0.5304012298583984,
-0.738806426525116,
0.7131530046463013,
-0.7203897833824158,
-0.3727568984031677,
0.47725164890289307,
-0.25253111124038696,
-0.3217727839946747,
-0.08996163308620453,
-0.2951183617115021,
0.2797737121582031,
-0.17516091465950012,
0.902685284614563,
0.6254221796989441,
-0.3080848157405853,
-0.018171465024352074,
-0.26702427864074707,
0.0867529809474945,
0.398947149515152,
-0.9664880037307739,
0.08679485321044922,
0.42269888520240784,
0.023825082927942276,
0.6336749196052551,
0.24603165686130524,
-0.38939955830574036,
0.4956938624382019,
0.003449130104854703,
0.07951568812131882,
-0.15249748528003693,
-0.9118516445159912,
-0.591284990310669,
0.25821349024772644,
0.27739912271499634,
-0.3815978765487671
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.04391v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.04391v1
|
Why Has Predicting Downstream Capabilities of Frontier AI Models with Scale Remained Elusive?
| 2024-06-06T17:46:56 | 2024-06-06T17:46:56 |
Rylan Schaeffer, Hailey Schoelkopf, Brando Miranda, Gabriel Mukobi, Varun Madan, Adam Ibrahim, Herbie Bradley, Stella Biderman, Sanmi Koyejo
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Predictable behavior from scaling advanced AI systems is an extremely
desirable property. Although a well-established literature exists on how
pretraining performance scales, the literature on how particular downstream
capabilities scale is significantly muddier. In this work, we take a step back
and ask: why has predicting specific downstream capabilities with scale
remained elusive? While many factors are certainly responsible, we identify a
new factor that makes modeling scaling behavior on widely used multiple-choice
question-answering benchmarks challenging. Using five model families and twelve
well-established multiple-choice benchmarks, we show that downstream
performance is computed from negative log likelihoods via a sequence of
transformations that progressively degrade the statistical relationship between
performance and scale. We then reveal the mechanism causing this degradation:
downstream metrics require comparing the correct choice against a small number
of specific incorrect choices, meaning accurately predicting downstream
capabilities requires predicting not just how probability mass concentrates on
the correct choice with scale, but also how probability mass fluctuates on
specific incorrect choices with scale. We empirically study how probability
mass on the correct choice co-varies with probability mass on incorrect choices
with increasing compute, suggesting that scaling laws for incorrect choices
might be achievable. Our work also explains why pretraining scaling laws are
commonly regarded as more predictable than downstream capabilities and
contributes towards establishing scaling-predictable evaluations of frontier AI
models.
|
[
-0.6398566365242004,
-0.5606848001480103,
0.9410452246665955,
-0.11601105332374573,
0.13636605441570282,
0.06300606578588486,
-0.009925453923642635,
-0.5112472772598267,
-0.04683735594153404,
0.3795602023601532,
-0.9710118770599365,
0.5357226729393005,
-1.10744047164917,
-0.20391236245632172,
-0.253231942653656,
1.120965838432312,
0.0348934531211853,
0.06511034071445465,
-0.07481613755226135,
-0.4078506827354431,
-0.46019062399864197,
-0.49408233165740967,
-0.7902088761329651,
-0.36127692461013794,
0.7894533276557922,
0.30244559049606323,
0.8573358058929443,
0.9543934464454651,
0.7680193185806274,
0.22208808362483978,
0.011056418530642986,
-0.31498733162879944,
-0.48860201239585876,
-0.14168059825897217,
0.10358387231826782,
-0.8164381384849548,
-0.5073002576828003,
0.2525465190410614,
0.7982662916183472,
0.7973455190658569,
0.10396997630596161,
0.5762035846710205,
0.11162928491830826,
0.7267346382141113,
-0.6136135458946228,
0.030198661610484123,
-0.7124459147453308,
-0.3201313614845276,
-0.25051960349082947,
0.08107369393110275,
-0.3992195427417755,
-0.06531330198049545,
0.2087467759847641,
-0.65078204870224,
0.19337426126003265,
0.08844204992055893,
0.8938597440719604,
0.6495040655136108,
-0.5140742063522339,
-0.22063113749027252,
-1.1570258140563965,
0.8462514281272888,
-0.36947038769721985,
0.1026189923286438,
0.4539119005203247,
0.6620224118232727,
0.2584918141365051,
-0.9094472527503967,
-0.22466561198234558,
-0.2125294953584671,
0.06841066479682922,
-0.22989369928836823,
-0.17238911986351013,
0.07795794308185577,
0.3396438956260681,
0.15059062838554382,
-0.33905673027038574,
0.4215477406978607,
-0.4541699290275574,
-0.3509574234485626,
0.7597823739051819,
0.34842440485954285,
-0.03269653767347336,
0.28260621428489685,
-0.15833505988121033,
-0.19962197542190552,
-0.7088539600372314,
0.5558477640151978,
0.3206080496311188,
0.652827799320221,
0.16828563809394836,
0.3914794325828552,
-0.08425619453191757,
0.510969340801239,
0.13207563757896423,
-0.07883521169424057,
0.1452869474887848,
-0.11758850514888763,
0.010569613426923752,
-0.2718089818954468,
0.39575058221817017,
0.06763819605112076,
0.09311001002788544,
0.05606633424758911,
-0.18405908346176147,
-0.33811771869659424,
0.6038700342178345,
-0.7190144062042236,
-0.01754891127347946,
0.3269524872303009,
-0.5255563855171204,
0.023157885298132896,
-0.12798242270946503,
-0.6173852682113647,
-0.41958630084991455,
-0.22150400280952454,
0.8113090991973877,
-0.11206050962209702,
-0.3739687502384186,
-0.4234750270843506,
-0.3248240649700165,
0.23113223910331726,
0.4362996220588684,
-0.929935872554779,
0.07018506526947021,
0.7166805267333984,
0.819087028503418,
0.10198351740837097,
-0.5788785219192505,
-0.8420997858047485,
-0.25584226846694946,
-0.5072011351585388,
0.4605633020401001,
-0.657565176486969,
-0.13471880555152893,
-0.32508084177970886,
-0.09377595037221909,
-0.24874307215213776,
-0.4652811288833618,
0.3191499412059784,
-0.672917366027832,
-0.4031710624694824,
-0.6037856936454773,
-0.47113290429115295,
-0.19167661666870117,
0.16800953447818756,
-0.7925360202789307,
0.3509570062160492,
0.17006084322929382,
-0.6967846155166626,
0.9987065196037292,
-0.6259794235229492,
-0.09933146834373474,
0.1871929168701172,
0.04885546863079071,
-0.5663127899169922,
0.13786962628364563,
-0.023467447608709335,
0.28567495942115784,
-0.2347315549850464,
0.10742072016000748,
-0.7957578897476196,
-0.40716588497161865,
0.10308954119682312,
-0.5727574825286865,
0.5406172871589661,
0.2814653813838959,
-0.16837409138679504,
0.23040319979190826,
-0.6277413964271545,
0.110779769718647,
-0.1763981729745865,
-0.14410093426704407,
-0.04068049415946007,
0.26274916529655457,
-0.45898178219795227,
0.16942144930362701,
0.3882681727409363,
-0.5109243392944336,
-0.1577061414718628,
0.40326520800590515,
0.5505595207214355,
0.9782185554504395,
-0.13327527046203613,
0.7449139952659607,
-0.5199629068374634,
0.7683223485946655,
-0.29243016242980957,
0.38988566398620605,
0.19789475202560425,
-0.539547324180603,
-0.4807765781879425,
-0.3962233066558838,
0.18986833095550537,
0.3647415339946747,
-0.30930107831954956,
0.03791837394237518,
-0.5454422831535339,
-0.9530652165412903,
-0.3561244010925293,
-0.008432531729340553,
-0.040455807000398636,
0.5817273855209351,
0.5837055444717407,
-0.025714894756674767,
-0.14681114256381989,
-1.0113030672073364,
-0.6633055806159973,
-0.5630388855934143,
-0.3469015955924988,
0.3079749047756195,
0.29549697041511536,
-0.1800708919763565,
0.8867265582084656,
-0.5881578326225281,
-0.2908448576927185,
-0.4270799160003662,
0.523463785648346,
0.173488050699234,
0.5132101774215698,
0.39992421865463257,
-0.9478000402450562,
-0.16735556721687317,
-0.2856462895870209,
-0.23495617508888245,
0.25563445687294006,
-0.29441455006599426,
0.11722826212644577,
-0.3899507522583008,
0.5725724101066589,
-0.4354780614376068,
0.26198267936706543,
0.3995857238769531,
-0.18913547694683075,
0.8492801189422607,
-0.39974695444107056,
-0.016299886628985405,
-0.4562932252883911,
-0.0311752837151289,
0.05302109196782112,
0.3046584725379944,
-0.7631749510765076,
0.26878297328948975,
0.3131239712238312,
0.18746188282966614,
-0.09474680572748184,
0.2541132867336273,
-0.09959743916988373,
-0.28128230571746826,
-0.01916428841650486,
-0.4798554480075836,
-0.3129698932170868,
0.3158659040927887,
-0.07275822013616562,
0.8996561169624329,
0.561165988445282,
-0.8789817094802856,
-0.20870360732078552,
-0.07744886726140976,
0.11047185957431793,
0.31698501110076904,
-0.547461986541748,
-0.3873421847820282,
-0.1549154371023178,
0.29207083582878113,
-1.0435618162155151,
-0.24019396305084229,
-0.5139281749725342,
-0.6154196262359619,
0.4546797573566437,
-0.3385542631149292,
-0.017573554068803787,
-0.5865563154220581,
-0.010670797899365425,
0.40049847960472107,
0.6734338402748108,
-0.3089829981327057,
0.817940890789032,
0.188101664185524,
-0.11113523691892624,
-0.6157367825508118,
-0.946274995803833,
-0.2787722945213318,
-0.6026782393455505,
-0.5689220428466797,
-0.1416020691394806,
-0.13229595124721527,
-0.1427335888147354,
-0.41227445006370544,
-0.3306537866592407,
-0.2589004933834076,
0.3744810223579407,
0.30391913652420044,
0.2752750813961029,
-0.3774110674858093,
0.331536203622818,
0.025357553735375404,
-0.07494855672121048,
0.5653471350669861,
-0.16998161375522614,
0.2578850984573364,
-0.33233198523521423,
-0.3023549020290375,
-0.06588655710220337,
-0.05775652825832367,
1.0137274265289307,
-0.37215983867645264,
0.7885645031929016,
0.8104134798049927,
-0.06627022475004196,
-0.020164988934993744,
-0.4043678045272827,
-0.23984335362911224,
-0.4405926764011383,
0.48966965079307556,
-0.3807082772254944,
-0.7152388691902161,
0.8732593655586243,
-0.22808513045310974,
0.0917920470237732,
0.9465348124504089,
0.10956159234046936,
-0.062257133424282074,
1.040746808052063,
0.7304985523223877,
0.31000760197639465,
0.3626624047756195,
-0.382639616727829,
0.4029257893562317,
-0.8910102248191833,
0.1130998358130455,
-0.5969966650009155,
-0.5142093300819397,
-1.2612582445144653,
-0.07246533036231995,
0.6051771640777588,
0.034975066781044006,
-0.7913106679916382,
0.14353422820568085,
-0.09683792293071747,
0.12901844084262848,
0.6831648945808411,
0.037715304642915726,
0.14044322073459625,
-0.17438997328281403,
0.1259755641222,
-0.0038504665717482567,
-0.6757251620292664,
-0.41006380319595337,
1.5242191553115845,
0.5152707099914551,
0.5510632991790771,
-0.1145789623260498,
0.739742636680603,
0.1867227405309677,
0.673166036605835,
-0.6862493753433228,
0.2408321052789688,
-0.22888457775115967,
-1.0057357549667358,
-0.937248706817627,
-0.6163658499717712,
-0.8176255226135254,
0.14240168035030365,
-0.16656430065631866,
-0.8425050973892212,
0.13696686923503876,
0.100127674639225,
-0.8809585571289062,
0.6000237464904785,
-0.8431285619735718,
0.8255897164344788,
0.04623580724000931,
-0.3480561673641205,
-0.22797013819217682,
-0.9157145619392395,
0.1980888694524765,
-0.45615726709365845,
0.508390486240387,
-0.08732269704341888,
-0.12118477374315262,
0.6391286253929138,
-0.6584634780883789,
0.4726017713546753,
-0.2373664826154709,
0.18874792754650116,
0.3460336923599243,
0.16103629767894745,
0.23532596230506897,
0.23484809696674347,
-0.14296308159828186,
0.14173051714897156,
-0.06413019448518753,
-0.6471421122550964,
-0.5080198049545288,
0.425106018781662,
-1.132633090019226,
-0.6457526683807373,
-0.18212443590164185,
-0.3499109447002411,
-0.5088343024253845,
0.22114187479019165,
0.6463804841041565,
0.42356109619140625,
0.1561412215232849,
0.03992456942796707,
0.48538270592689514,
0.1904178261756897,
0.7734458446502686,
0.19787143170833588,
0.04504196345806122,
-0.08170255273580551,
1.0642837285995483,
0.7651192545890808,
0.6188809275627136,
0.33783847093582153,
0.1954277902841568,
-0.32710471749305725,
-0.6062254309654236,
-0.6090245842933655,
-0.02825981192290783,
-0.42009782791137695,
-0.04574725404381752,
-0.5652802586555481,
-0.443716824054718,
-0.012289069592952728,
-0.3633952736854553,
-0.512631356716156,
-0.41308465600013733,
-0.3050495982170105,
-0.2294187992811203,
0.038521163165569305,
0.9067809581756592,
-0.42751944065093994,
0.31084951758384705,
-0.7342424988746643,
0.07215186953544617,
0.6763770580291748,
0.4228380620479584,
0.3689533770084381,
-0.7534250020980835,
-0.12989577651023865,
0.2531329095363617,
-0.36072057485580444,
-0.4811209738254547,
0.11716943979263306,
0.02977801114320755,
0.4395830035209656,
0.4448437988758087,
0.16286902129650116,
0.6407253742218018,
-0.3239208161830902,
0.846600353717804,
0.06953754276037216,
-0.6450644731521606,
0.3794507682323456,
-0.33714768290519714,
0.4092099368572235,
0.5725342631340027,
0.6643345952033997,
-0.020288167521357536,
-0.45478034019470215,
-0.787371039390564,
-0.6906898617744446,
0.6698226928710938,
-0.042501918971538544,
0.24780994653701782,
0.4020039439201355,
0.25140947103500366,
0.5144098401069641,
0.13355037569999695,
-0.5639535188674927,
-0.09660949558019638,
-0.024350428953766823,
0.5239464640617371,
-0.685081958770752,
-0.03949849680066109,
0.22401051223278046,
-0.2962130606174469,
0.46115240454673767,
-0.1371791958808899,
0.1747547835111618,
0.03326979652047157,
0.3433874547481537,
-0.24564968049526215,
0.10824224352836609,
0.4035993218421936,
0.9241021275520325,
-0.47129157185554504,
-0.30426037311553955,
0.03856554627418518,
-0.7171308994293213,
0.2888193428516388,
0.33314085006713867,
-0.1925082951784134,
-0.4024686813354492,
0.6009199619293213,
0.765563428401947,
-0.43247535824775696,
-0.4176029860973358,
0.2896680533885956,
-0.15893502533435822,
-0.35310491919517517,
-0.6010966300964355,
0.15312673151493073,
-0.12851664423942566,
0.22049959003925323,
1.040507197380066,
0.6079214811325073,
0.17986997961997986,
-0.3718447685241699,
0.09401434659957886,
0.2751918137073517,
-0.7022404670715332,
-0.12316350638866425,
0.8547827005386353,
0.06037293002009392,
-0.18411654233932495,
1.029266357421875,
-0.2847321033477783,
-0.2937425971031189,
1.004173755645752,
-0.22266900539398193,
0.8180510401725769,
-0.08247615396976471,
0.41223424673080444,
0.6555547714233398,
0.5250514149665833,
-0.13198280334472656,
-0.14332740008831024,
0.1338384449481964,
-0.6061298847198486,
-0.4531186521053314,
-0.5483993887901306,
-0.2744719684123993,
0.3580077290534973,
-0.8646296858787537,
0.141353040933609,
-0.6219207644462585,
-0.7456738352775574,
-0.04059656336903572,
0.009582231752574444,
-0.7787703275680542,
0.45495858788490295,
0.16597490012645721,
0.7230328917503357,
-0.9512833952903748,
0.24045942723751068,
0.4274546802043915,
-0.4895654618740082,
-1.1424401998519897,
0.32460322976112366,
-0.048339661210775375,
-0.6094081997871399,
0.4584922790527344,
0.37710535526275635,
0.16868820786476135,
-0.01222530659288168,
-0.4032282829284668,
-1.2988752126693726,
1.0872963666915894,
0.1835603415966034,
-0.20961977541446686,
-0.21319741010665894,
0.05392523109912872,
0.6053880453109741,
-0.4283028542995453,
0.6029070019721985,
0.6493129730224609,
0.44160446524620056,
0.2637849450111389,
-1.1138312816619873,
0.0782957375049591,
0.26128673553466797,
-0.1306876838207245,
0.3743518590927124,
-0.856761634349823,
1.2284204959869385,
-0.8906999826431274,
0.08654874563217163,
-0.09817302972078323,
0.4667240083217621,
0.09327927976846695,
0.38777485489845276,
0.5278775095939636,
0.5379409790039062,
0.7663987874984741,
-0.10964138805866241,
1.0926933288574219,
0.041160255670547485,
0.20758940279483795,
1.0087168216705322,
-0.03751144930720329,
1.1718404293060303,
0.4214046001434326,
-0.4531412720680237,
0.6623408198356628,
1.055996298789978,
0.10108309239149094,
0.4751988649368286,
0.21600671112537384,
0.05887985974550247,
-0.5401222109794617,
0.2718242108821869,
-0.29436013102531433,
0.6246162056922913,
0.3427268862724304,
-0.23348407447338104,
-0.15272104740142822,
-0.23502887785434723,
-0.34346550703048706,
-0.25793007016181946,
-0.7042996883392334,
0.6459410786628723,
-0.30975738167762756,
-0.9353554248809814,
0.6319873929023743,
-0.42259833216667175,
0.44412505626678467,
-0.7632874846458435,
0.2732517123222351,
-0.267812579870224,
0.10190687328577042,
-0.0006318191299214959,
-0.6355801224708557,
0.2480987161397934,
-0.45353803038597107,
-0.1924314796924591,
-0.22881676256656647,
0.2847382128238678,
0.10898660123348236,
-0.3808373510837555,
0.29883119463920593,
0.7833585739135742,
-0.10693583637475967,
-0.21303138136863708,
-0.3643261790275574,
-0.1888485699892044,
-0.013661414384841919,
-0.37108364701271057,
0.651887059211731,
0.4922049343585968,
0.008145302534103394,
1.0908114910125732,
0.4319823384284973,
0.044317957013845444,
0.21814857423305511,
-0.3612527847290039,
0.5933178067207336,
-0.16709889471530914,
-0.6064818501472473,
-0.5745173692703247,
0.5381025671958923,
0.04275314137339592,
-0.44742730259895325,
0.27630549669265747,
0.2643091678619385,
0.7463006973266602,
-0.03128702938556671,
0.841693639755249,
-0.04976554214954376,
0.250708669424057,
-0.0881635993719101,
0.8591654300689697,
-0.7063600420951843,
0.08710233122110367,
0.13371865451335907,
-0.7935857772827148,
0.14197196066379547,
-0.21060438454151154,
-0.6189188957214355,
0.3840053379535675,
0.6448666453361511,
0.47061505913734436,
0.024656187742948532,
0.11207572370767593,
0.3806823492050171,
0.18910199403762817,
0.28858551383018494,
0.3894208073616028,
0.47003036737442017,
-0.20345669984817505,
0.8289299011230469,
-0.09862920641899109,
-0.6012424230575562,
-0.22946228086948395,
-0.6473121643066406,
-0.3909526467323303,
-0.7731814980506897,
-0.22673910856246948,
-0.1688818633556366,
-0.3246611952781677,
0.2570233643054962,
1.0243396759033203,
-0.6110748648643494,
-0.19790631532669067,
-0.3952619731426239,
0.045898959040641785,
-0.5058331489562988,
-0.2176945060491562,
0.01968402788043022,
-0.7439862489700317,
-0.27765336632728577,
-0.2082834541797638,
-0.05117872357368469,
0.0877833217382431,
-0.1915874183177948,
-0.06044131889939308,
-0.08689481765031815,
0.29624128341674805,
0.23200532793998718,
0.5076993703842163,
-0.6124241352081299,
-0.20762494206428528,
-0.12944349646568298,
-0.028043031692504883,
-0.11260145157575607,
0.727162778377533,
-0.58029705286026,
0.2671811878681183,
0.3290223777294159,
0.8096403479576111,
0.5142170190811157,
-0.06201602891087532,
0.7388373017311096,
-0.2150270938873291,
-0.3509640395641327,
0.2696523666381836,
0.17031367123126984,
0.1106468141078949,
-0.4599887728691101,
0.4949345588684082,
0.02825874276459217,
-0.8046995997428894,
-0.5590603947639465,
0.3246264159679413,
-0.14164382219314575,
-0.42929911613464355,
0.9172869920730591,
-0.27830901741981506,
-0.09632522612810135,
0.1919195055961609,
0.19605398178100586,
-0.07621296495199203,
-0.17872925102710724,
0.48321712017059326,
1.0458242893218994,
-0.5857059359550476,
0.05593102052807808,
-0.6231305003166199,
0.600533127784729,
0.5105185508728027,
-0.29016217589378357,
0.35062018036842346,
0.4102657735347748,
0.2408575564622879,
0.49393773078918457,
0.3461063802242279,
0.20519520342350006,
0.3141481876373291,
0.48630478978157043,
-0.5735624432563782,
0.30129942297935486,
-0.3968251347541809,
-0.39617985486984253,
0.4212151765823364,
0.44881996512413025,
-0.10311981290578842
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.04298v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.04298v1
|
Measuring and Addressing Indexical Bias in Information Retrieval
| 2024-06-06T17:42:37 | 2024-06-06T17:42:37 |
Caleb Ziems, William Held, Jane Dwivedi-Yu, Diyi Yang
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.CL
|
Information Retrieval (IR) systems are designed to deliver relevant content,
but traditional systems may not optimize rankings for fairness, neutrality, or
the balance of ideas. Consequently, IR can often introduce indexical biases, or
biases in the positional order of documents. Although indexical bias can
demonstrably affect people's opinion, voting patterns, and other behaviors,
these issues remain understudied as the field lacks reliable metrics and
procedures for automatically measuring indexical bias. Towards this end, we
introduce the PAIR framework, which supports automatic bias audits for ranked
documents or entire IR systems. After introducing DUO, the first
general-purpose automatic bias metric, we run an extensive evaluation of 8 IR
systems on a new corpus of 32k synthetic and 4.7k natural documents, with 4k
queries spanning 1.4k controversial issue topics. A human behavioral study
validates our approach, showing that our bias metric can help predict when and
how indexical bias will shift a reader's opinion.
|
[
-0.6523698568344116,
-0.26105886697769165,
0.38134557008743286,
0.3296896517276764,
0.07482690364122391,
0.10511710494756699,
0.10491276532411575,
-0.4109824001789093,
0.5953324437141418,
0.3127128779888153,
-0.0949556976556778,
-0.11318378150463104,
-0.4444752633571625,
0.04539065062999725,
-0.5635262727737427,
1.223979115486145,
0.08658977597951889,
0.42577239871025085,
-0.17172770202159882,
-0.48004409670829773,
-0.28872886300086975,
-0.425120085477829,
-0.18690109252929688,
-0.36145374178886414,
0.486391544342041,
0.650425910949707,
0.7031940221786499,
0.25171196460723877,
0.9929883480072021,
0.1467222422361374,
0.2544364631175995,
-0.04578324407339096,
-0.646475076675415,
0.18433710932731628,
-0.272323340177536,
-0.5152764320373535,
-0.2933878004550934,
0.4874522387981415,
0.696305513381958,
0.6629083752632141,
-0.06840529292821884,
0.30006325244903564,
-0.1661394089460373,
1.2469408512115479,
-0.722874641418457,
-0.2053810954093933,
-0.5736613869667053,
-0.000012438231351552531,
-0.49375197291374207,
-0.4306957423686981,
-0.31628891825675964,
-0.37015682458877563,
0.36383894085884094,
-0.3944351375102997,
0.46677157282829285,
0.6227388978004456,
0.7595580220222473,
0.3219519555568695,
-0.550537645816803,
-0.09167276322841644,
-0.5570040345191956,
0.5889559388160706,
-0.19884738326072693,
0.4787873327732086,
0.489503413438797,
0.04488931968808174,
0.028848519548773766,
-0.17210498452186584,
-0.36723968386650085,
0.004617740400135517,
-0.2335425764322281,
0.2819548547267914,
0.11456825584173203,
0.07304637879133224,
0.3157958686351776,
0.33481693267822266,
-0.6490169763565063,
-0.15657076239585876,
-0.28159576654434204,
0.11765862256288528,
0.7631202340126038,
0.02532185986638069,
0.3901994824409485,
-0.37629958987236023,
-0.4558877646923065,
-0.2689957618713379,
-0.535910427570343,
-0.061073705554008484,
0.9653350114822388,
-0.2150638848543167,
0.20209135115146637,
0.4928554594516754,
-0.11474454402923584,
0.3294517695903778,
0.52607262134552,
0.6575796008110046,
0.1494464874267578,
-0.5045756697654724,
0.14592914283275604,
0.1910170465707779,
0.8008697032928467,
0.8539388179779053,
-0.16786663234233856,
-0.4077760577201843,
-0.27969539165496826,
0.18757304549217224,
0.47266584634780884,
-0.6274157762527466,
-0.034562572836875916,
0.2333088517189026,
-0.45800942182540894,
-0.28634804487228394,
0.5749701261520386,
-0.9421740174293518,
-0.6801232695579529,
-0.207106813788414,
0.5436558723449707,
-0.09285783022642136,
-0.3983204662799835,
-0.06856241822242737,
-0.44625696539878845,
0.13276593387126923,
-0.13844114542007446,
-0.9043310284614563,
0.48304426670074463,
0.8635510206222534,
0.6361598968505859,
-0.42334362864494324,
-0.09227576106786728,
-0.6497204899787903,
0.020439522340893745,
-0.38006699085235596,
0.9953445196151733,
-0.46488744020462036,
-0.31694334745407104,
-0.15099960565567017,
-0.3088151514530182,
0.01376148872077465,
-0.6356270909309387,
0.5730429887771606,
-0.6953688859939575,
0.39385145902633667,
-0.4933904707431793,
-0.36654236912727356,
0.2410012185573578,
0.19574686884880066,
-0.5074087977409363,
1.2901064157485962,
-0.13330750167369843,
-1.2686958312988281,
0.6740594506263733,
-0.7248592972755432,
-0.2984769344329834,
-0.2664649188518524,
-0.1817922294139862,
-0.18741244077682495,
0.00256822956725955,
0.019829774275422096,
-0.0845751091837883,
-0.5057265758514404,
0.4483806788921356,
-0.3274598717689514,
-0.6232331991195679,
0.03569667786359787,
-0.007604420650750399,
0.6610455513000488,
-0.06903737783432007,
-0.5332176685333252,
0.005586294922977686,
-0.49386852979660034,
0.006408673711121082,
-0.25504305958747864,
0.00513793108984828,
-0.9479888081550598,
0.1255582720041275,
0.16703639924526215,
-0.1397206336259842,
0.21958114206790924,
-0.5435153841972351,
0.17557300627231598,
-0.38972246646881104,
0.39207935333251953,
0.9092531204223633,
-0.0727839469909668,
0.737838864326477,
-0.4236443340778351,
0.19881942868232727,
0.11687076836824417,
0.134553924202919,
0.23425811529159546,
-0.2751429080963135,
-0.9301071763038635,
0.3555983901023865,
0.3432590365409851,
0.5083828568458557,
-0.2682899832725525,
0.28470417857170105,
-0.2941925823688507,
-0.20632776618003845,
-0.7811239361763,
0.1283375471830368,
0.48972323536872864,
0.36575230956077576,
0.15266960859298706,
-0.7370028495788574,
-0.4613017737865448,
-1.2152518033981323,
-0.7486476302146912,
-0.6010698676109314,
0.04039844870567322,
0.533560574054718,
0.43933722376823425,
-0.15799038112163544,
0.9355133771896362,
-0.152236208319664,
-0.3788781762123108,
0.5731713771820068,
0.719236433506012,
0.04117320850491524,
0.46060478687286377,
0.26482802629470825,
-1.0035368204116821,
-0.36162322759628296,
-0.37077122926712036,
-0.7106122970581055,
-0.43380269408226013,
0.25489333271980286,
-0.651288628578186,
0.13813406229019165,
0.23463979363441467,
0.060902778059244156,
0.31015539169311523,
0.09040454775094986,
-0.6454793214797974,
0.2899370491504669,
-0.034660983830690384,
0.39670538902282715,
-0.6761292219161987,
0.2929397523403168,
0.38045626878738403,
-0.0431520901620388,
-0.25106295943260193,
0.025835314765572548,
0.14510875940322876,
0.3916894495487213,
0.15788060426712036,
0.5160835981369019,
-0.5303663015365601,
-0.6359742283821106,
0.12627413868904114,
0.11260142177343369,
0.20168712735176086,
-0.028944119811058044,
-0.17718416452407837,
1.0557622909545898,
-0.13598854839801788,
-0.281931608915329,
0.10964597761631012,
0.2408754527568817,
-0.35841697454452515,
1.404553771018982,
-0.43512630462646484,
0.5427495241165161,
-0.20478245615959167,
0.2508726418018341,
-0.8830069899559021,
-0.17243817448616028,
-0.038256339728832245,
-0.5936597585678101,
0.2740970551967621,
-0.18568408489227295,
-0.5066375136375427,
-0.3799828588962555,
-0.8156131505966187,
0.4045656621456146,
0.07019862532615662,
-0.5289620161056519,
0.13525773584842682,
0.715076744556427,
0.11023282259702682,
-0.8835188746452332,
-0.3107086718082428,
0.35492879152297974,
-0.26031991839408875,
-0.8572325110435486,
0.5281268358230591,
-0.35524433851242065,
-0.9378764033317566,
0.1417161375284195,
-0.3056758642196655,
-0.2872846722602844,
-0.004738728981465101,
0.3359690308570862,
0.3112848401069641,
-0.1528625190258026,
0.16117654740810394,
-0.2437218874692917,
-0.3658091723918915,
0.1650751829147339,
-0.10463497042655945,
0.22049447894096375,
-0.24832946062088013,
-0.3005121946334839,
-0.28922638297080994,
0.4114495813846588,
0.6572832465171814,
-0.16029763221740723,
0.36727190017700195,
0.45460155606269836,
-0.13647332787513733,
0.2936628460884094,
-1.2980360984802246,
-0.4054332375526428,
-0.3802012801170349,
0.0005294379661791027,
-0.05506165698170662,
-0.43279868364334106,
0.578484296798706,
0.47252586483955383,
-0.01449066586792469,
0.33961179852485657,
0.20817245543003082,
-0.3492584228515625,
1.5705478191375732,
0.5544984936714172,
-0.5330294370651245,
0.6712299585342407,
-0.19282986223697662,
0.2288385033607483,
-1.1652915477752686,
-0.007764250971376896,
-0.7235708832740784,
-0.7715059518814087,
-0.6649494171142578,
-0.09806890040636063,
0.7336373329162598,
-0.05218314379453659,
-0.24376215040683746,
-0.2568110227584839,
-0.7862308621406555,
0.4212284982204437,
1.0932950973510742,
0.19094397127628326,
0.34029215574264526,
0.03004470095038414,
-0.044232193380594254,
-0.25186887383461,
-0.22987544536590576,
-0.38872674107551575,
1.2374160289764404,
-0.18861123919487,
0.6860882043838501,
0.019192831590771675,
0.7430213689804077,
0.7314150333404541,
0.1761561632156372,
-0.5306861400604248,
0.24056370556354523,
0.10222050547599792,
-0.9914156198501587,
-0.11762499809265137,
-0.20068266987800598,
-0.5672187805175781,
0.2086891382932663,
0.03367133438587189,
-0.557266354560852,
0.4372236132621765,
0.05794178694486618,
-0.15038466453552246,
0.10904527455568314,
-0.8768717646598816,
0.4485766887664795,
-0.410176545381546,
-1.000404715538025,
-0.46443992853164673,
-0.8965855240821838,
0.16725598275661469,
0.2467702329158783,
0.1704060286283493,
0.04313323646783829,
-0.027472203597426414,
1.2976456880569458,
-0.29014354944229126,
0.32458657026290894,
-0.2527158558368683,
0.4391371011734009,
-0.08432779461145401,
0.2787579298019409,
0.33483564853668213,
0.18189027905464172,
-0.48331356048583984,
0.2189330905675888,
0.2927247881889343,
-0.197060227394104,
-0.4643823504447937,
0.8755856156349182,
-0.9288017749786377,
-0.6449167728424072,
-0.7795509099960327,
-0.32201147079467773,
-0.1469407081604004,
0.2809213399887085,
0.15432260930538177,
0.24927639961242676,
-0.23693184554576874,
0.1151781976222992,
0.7001404166221619,
0.25768470764160156,
0.12678052484989166,
0.8617332577705383,
0.2051108479499817,
-0.13445857167243958,
0.8322120904922485,
0.34957197308540344,
-0.15121984481811523,
0.3420575261116028,
0.2961396872997284,
-0.14924441277980804,
-0.4056130647659302,
-0.38818472623825073,
0.1852973997592926,
-0.3684522211551666,
-0.07392681390047073,
-0.7418131828308105,
0.15511161088943481,
-0.43214473128318787,
-0.06557521224021912,
-0.14307372272014618,
-0.39295080304145813,
-0.08386100828647614,
-0.0985960140824318,
0.15931399166584015,
0.9039326906204224,
-0.2856285274028778,
-0.0167285967618227,
-0.37184038758277893,
0.3805027902126312,
0.2536449730396271,
0.7104055285453796,
-0.34809064865112305,
-0.30678918957710266,
0.011210371740162373,
-0.21584638953208923,
-0.2660750448703766,
-0.8465315699577332,
0.24659723043441772,
-0.1703532487154007,
0.2949034571647644,
0.5247082114219666,
0.3266533315181732,
0.6826674342155457,
-0.22680915892124176,
0.5435774922370911,
-0.10352469235658646,
-0.7656367421150208,
0.6661658883094788,
-0.4985814094543457,
-0.21594038605690002,
0.8890259265899658,
0.1778998076915741,
-0.7054683566093445,
-0.10363389551639557,
-0.6547009348869324,
-0.7730407118797302,
0.9906526207923889,
-0.0430142916738987,
-0.28414589166641235,
-0.03876737877726555,
0.41269344091415405,
0.11993572115898132,
0.394591361284256,
-0.4232601523399353,
-0.3594294488430023,
0.06539078801870346,
-0.2407124787569046,
0.10914532095193863,
-0.5937150716781616,
-0.37900787591934204,
-0.16238516569137573,
0.7398141026496887,
-0.1607014685869217,
0.26022350788116455,
0.3707164525985718,
-0.32495906949043274,
-0.5557187795639038,
0.1027178168296814,
0.27832433581352234,
0.7156558036804199,
-0.6321294903755188,
0.2236618846654892,
-0.411434531211853,
-0.4262010157108307,
0.15644752979278564,
0.10624960064888,
-0.5402899980545044,
-0.14576731622219086,
-0.11266674101352692,
0.41993075609207153,
0.36010074615478516,
-0.3985731601715088,
0.6849437355995178,
-0.16469013690948486,
0.1864415556192398,
-0.33755430579185486,
-0.03257625177502632,
-0.24926476180553436,
0.04417084902524948,
0.4725797176361084,
0.022225525230169296,
0.6037003397941589,
-0.5122859477996826,
0.16274189949035645,
0.8183376789093018,
-0.7080198526382446,
-0.49302810430526733,
0.6932861804962158,
0.6217578053474426,
-0.4366035461425781,
0.5527921319007874,
-0.056440483778715134,
-0.6303880214691162,
0.6728765964508057,
0.13105261325836182,
0.7326267957687378,
0.021651171147823334,
0.049125898629426956,
0.4030337631702423,
0.4267486035823822,
-0.26576897501945496,
0.015566890127956867,
-0.20285286009311676,
-0.6972218155860901,
0.585959792137146,
-0.3011710047721863,
-0.5843083262443542,
-0.2103271633386612,
-1.032377004623413,
0.20244398713111877,
-0.39060109853744507,
-0.3339467942714691,
0.06736510992050171,
0.3603140711784363,
-0.7333165407180786,
-0.20476412773132324,
-0.23209120333194733,
0.70435631275177,
-0.6805996894836426,
0.29899194836616516,
0.9537272453308105,
-0.6892299652099609,
-0.054231975227594376,
-0.04766852408647537,
0.29180780053138733,
-1.1473281383514404,
0.8212565183639526,
0.2925947606563568,
-0.14649845659732819,
-0.022637467831373215,
-0.4524909555912018,
-0.7018789649009705,
0.8512574434280396,
0.023055456578731537,
-0.39159461855888367,
-0.29742899537086487,
-0.11672060936689377,
0.34138190746307373,
-0.013458918780088425,
0.9106113314628601,
0.685411274433136,
0.6878488659858704,
-0.5197027921676636,
-1.1594083309173584,
-0.3751545548439026,
-0.461060106754303,
-0.1666584312915802,
0.5424759387969971,
-1.0271905660629272,
0.3994128406047821,
-0.052686743438243866,
-0.12881983816623688,
-0.27211061120033264,
0.094712994992733,
-0.4035852551460266,
0.7322263121604919,
0.6483863592147827,
0.7221734523773193,
0.9537397623062134,
-0.0784754604101181,
0.8429363369941711,
-0.5090052485466003,
0.03198132663965225,
0.9602508544921875,
-0.7505351305007935,
0.7033979892730713,
0.9399675130844116,
-0.18833227455615997,
0.353466272354126,
0.512578010559082,
0.284890353679657,
0.3730388879776001,
0.025474246591329575,
-0.23759771883487701,
-0.22072601318359375,
-0.37356138229370117,
-0.40824025869369507,
0.17392376065254211,
0.43385520577430725,
-0.32853734493255615,
0.17137369513511658,
-0.3270249664783478,
-0.07207384705543518,
0.175931915640831,
-0.029948443174362183,
0.9240204095840454,
-0.14675773680210114,
-1.1846287250518799,
-0.07148009538650513,
-0.09751730412244797,
1.0003491640090942,
-0.17690986394882202,
0.014834873378276825,
-0.566084086894989,
0.1919180005788803,
-0.34528979659080505,
-0.7391356229782104,
-0.05508285388350487,
-0.04791553318500519,
-0.6028732061386108,
-0.38565728068351746,
0.6314982175827026,
-0.04252385348081589,
-0.24700172245502472,
0.41939860582351685,
0.46455609798431396,
-0.061496712267398834,
-0.034699298441410065,
-0.6475417613983154,
0.026455329731106758,
-0.13491728901863098,
-0.2691197693347931,
0.4756670594215393,
0.0717272162437439,
-0.14648710191249847,
0.47611814737319946,
0.5334200263023376,
0.054959241300821304,
0.10782435536384583,
0.01872285082936287,
0.518904983997345,
-0.680267870426178,
-0.5581287145614624,
-0.4989023506641388,
0.0034313935320824385,
-0.35261350870132446,
-0.08966643363237381,
0.6433913707733154,
0.5714117288589478,
0.7396516799926758,
0.7690715789794922,
0.7838611602783203,
-0.03139762580394745,
0.6276430487632751,
-0.1122925877571106,
0.7590040564537048,
-0.5176259875297546,
0.2736903429031372,
-0.1099606603384018,
-0.9431271553039551,
-0.052898723632097244,
0.8090606331825256,
-0.3945320248603821,
-0.032576125115156174,
0.6431748867034912,
0.8153464794158936,
-0.04813440144062042,
0.1037486344575882,
-0.33257079124450684,
0.3701190650463104,
0.2870803773403168,
0.23516061902046204,
0.6304596662521362,
-0.5728549957275391,
0.2783091366291046,
-0.2257668673992157,
-0.39982789754867554,
-0.6730717420578003,
-0.6878283023834229,
-0.6774657964706421,
-0.4728109836578369,
-0.31019070744514465,
-0.4510287642478943,
0.5944911241531372,
0.8524082899093628,
0.7646368145942688,
-0.6030040383338928,
-0.48430395126342773,
-0.02066180668771267,
0.4361122250556946,
0.1106274276971817,
-0.3124610185623169,
0.24989891052246094,
-0.203731968998909,
-0.5964137315750122,
0.12021984159946442,
0.38409602642059326,
-0.47925466299057007,
-0.5469936728477478,
0.037681274116039276,
-0.40874746441841125,
-0.1618863046169281,
0.08106841146945953,
0.3939917981624603,
-0.5216647982597351,
-0.5565094947814941,
0.08677338063716888,
-0.350250780582428,
0.34816300868988037,
0.9230455756187439,
-0.903932511806488,
1.0821787118911743,
0.7723966836929321,
0.2359640896320343,
0.33100447058677673,
0.15835987031459808,
0.7340829968452454,
-0.4691300094127655,
-0.08444370329380035,
0.2806355953216553,
0.23246048390865326,
0.37558513879776,
-0.30043426156044006,
0.8074174523353577,
0.3800291121006012,
-0.8281764984130859,
-1.205273151397705,
-0.23391975462436676,
-0.7067496180534363,
0.39893341064453125,
0.9544166326522827,
0.49924907088279724,
-0.037199582904577255,
-0.014145857654511929,
-0.14359121024608612,
0.04199894517660141,
-0.6199454665184021,
1.1384881734848022,
0.8459299802780151,
-0.21446147561073303,
0.38627803325653076,
-0.5541372299194336,
0.11366496235132217,
0.8047777414321899,
-0.4207620918750763,
-0.2506806552410126,
0.5073335766792297,
0.255230188369751,
0.17891313135623932,
0.7423389554023743,
-0.04925286024808884,
0.27595818042755127,
-0.3328748941421509,
0.07225091010332108,
0.26173391938209534,
-0.1663401573896408,
-0.17773428559303284,
-0.15220187604427338,
0.036193035542964935,
0.044287122786045074
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.04292v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.04292v1
|
VISTA: Visualized Text Embedding For Universal Multi-Modal Retrieval
| 2024-06-06T17:37:47 | 2024-06-06T17:37:47 |
Junjie Zhou, Zheng Liu, Shitao Xiao, Bo Zhao, Yongping Xiong
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.CL, cs.CV
|
Multi-modal retrieval becomes increasingly popular in practice. However, the
existing retrievers are mostly text-oriented, which lack the capability to
process visual information. Despite the presence of vision-language models like
CLIP, the current methods are severely limited in representing the text-only
and image-only data. In this work, we present a new embedding model VISTA for
universal multi-modal retrieval. Our work brings forth threefold technical
contributions. Firstly, we introduce a flexible architecture which extends a
powerful text encoder with the image understanding capability by introducing
visual token embeddings. Secondly, we develop two data generation strategies,
which bring high-quality composed image-text to facilitate the training of the
embedding model. Thirdly, we introduce a multi-stage training algorithm, which
first aligns the visual token embedding with the text encoder using massive
weakly labeled data, and then develops multi-modal representation capability
using the generated composed image-text data. In our experiments, VISTA
achieves superior performances across a variety of multi-modal retrieval tasks
in both zero-shot and supervised settings. Our model, data, and source code are
available at https://github.com/FlagOpen/FlagEmbedding.
|
[
-0.07777504622936249,
-0.7326030135154724,
0.6541460752487183,
0.15135902166366577,
-0.4669182300567627,
-0.2177862972021103,
0.12171543389558792,
-0.44575706124305725,
0.33039435744285583,
0.3953723609447479,
-0.17064738273620605,
-0.6975194215774536,
-0.46425530314445496,
-0.09077046066522598,
-0.24998463690280914,
0.814291775226593,
0.133443683385849,
0.3725253641605377,
-0.2706977128982544,
-0.22324863076210022,
-0.6119171977043152,
-0.3961482644081116,
-0.02330184541642666,
0.04532739892601967,
0.3381843864917755,
0.2501174211502075,
0.6299411058425903,
0.7839774489402771,
0.31562069058418274,
0.23964884877204895,
-0.00014497405209112912,
0.01181843876838684,
-0.48150280117988586,
0.2530878186225891,
0.04848171025514603,
-0.46842944622039795,
-0.1715894192457199,
-0.18610411882400513,
0.7728051543235779,
0.2371046096086502,
0.18289625644683838,
-0.15847545862197876,
-0.023611463606357574,
0.3180517554283142,
-0.8236141204833984,
0.6735363006591797,
-0.8673194050788879,
0.24278245866298676,
-0.07937847822904587,
-0.22276955842971802,
-0.41858527064323425,
-0.23026151955127716,
0.12132518738508224,
-0.7169598340988159,
0.09229879081249237,
0.10154791921377182,
0.6121094226837158,
-0.01948555000126362,
-0.9452956914901733,
-0.154770627617836,
-0.39133915305137634,
0.7596744298934937,
-0.03604833781719208,
0.5492497682571411,
0.078702911734581,
0.3125191032886505,
0.3146401047706604,
-0.5012692809104919,
-0.5171836614608765,
-0.14044682681560516,
0.3504633903503418,
0.1555749624967575,
0.1620626598596573,
-0.05410503223538399,
-0.13201913237571716,
0.46214818954467773,
-0.31322765350341797,
-0.2820756435394287,
-0.4043905735015869,
-0.3500458896160126,
-0.08329672366380692,
0.18613150715827942,
0.2283523678779602,
-0.4779495596885681,
-1.0540369749069214,
-0.24423770606517792,
-0.5600141286849976,
0.14333224296569824,
-0.076381616294384,
0.35445791482925415,
0.03595515340566635,
0.6599910855293274,
0.09562413394451141,
0.5356494784355164,
-0.2835020422935486,
-0.09639287739992142,
0.5105780363082886,
-0.5391326546669006,
-0.16778525710105896,
-0.31904175877571106,
0.6677908301353455,
0.36939066648483276,
-0.1674189418554306,
-0.036548491567373276,
-0.34910300374031067,
0.06509089469909668,
0.22255448997020721,
-0.7875011563301086,
0.10500852018594742,
-0.19388172030448914,
-0.533578634262085,
-0.41203776001930237,
0.38109588623046875,
-0.8106715679168701,
-0.4367193281650543,
-0.2695852518081665,
0.8101658225059509,
-0.58705073595047,
-0.22293376922607422,
0.2338670939207077,
-0.3518624007701874,
0.3279607594013214,
0.4628092646598816,
-0.5022068023681641,
-0.13252374529838562,
0.5514222383499146,
0.8851078152656555,
-0.09696201980113983,
-0.1669880747795105,
-0.8418480753898621,
0.3144347667694092,
-0.15119047462940216,
0.6811984777450562,
-1.0018583536148071,
-0.4070129990577698,
0.4173796772956848,
0.02018273063004017,
-0.21196503937244415,
-0.09498744457960129,
0.47852689027786255,
-0.64975506067276,
0.05858875438570976,
-0.443356454372406,
-0.4346752166748047,
-0.3826984763145447,
0.4684382379055023,
-0.9166248440742493,
0.7689873576164246,
-0.3507046103477478,
-0.7863684296607971,
0.2100738286972046,
-0.5241067409515381,
-0.0911455750465393,
-0.10930567979812622,
-0.6159206032752991,
-0.3419519066810608,
0.10048218816518784,
0.3900150954723358,
0.44609901309013367,
-0.35875821113586426,
-0.020075809210538864,
-0.2351142168045044,
-0.44267213344573975,
0.05811552330851555,
-0.6234066486358643,
0.3212852478027344,
0.15361171960830688,
-0.0867251306772232,
0.0779142752289772,
-0.519397497177124,
-0.1065458357334137,
-0.052469998598098755,
-0.4214572012424469,
-0.39930495619773865,
-0.01916954107582569,
0.6775288581848145,
0.26351138949394226,
0.5177961587905884,
-0.7839910984039307,
0.30008113384246826,
-0.15263338387012482,
0.030487334355711937,
0.5525345206260681,
0.01794312708079815,
0.49304452538490295,
-0.08311749994754791,
0.5404412150382996,
0.37145617604255676,
0.3595393896102905,
-1.0024124383926392,
-0.5546483993530273,
-0.5099767446517944,
-0.48957836627960205,
0.200883150100708,
0.6521196961402893,
-1.0784735679626465,
0.1528581976890564,
-0.31824952363967896,
-0.1584031581878662,
-0.3716390132904053,
0.08522637188434601,
0.6246359348297119,
0.4732799828052521,
0.4671422839164734,
-0.4035892188549042,
-0.08550918102264404,
-0.8267385363578796,
0.11705615371465683,
0.10579721629619598,
-0.06951475143432617,
0.3731853663921356,
0.597329318523407,
-0.3106327950954437,
0.8483895659446716,
-0.6783462166786194,
-0.5922992825508118,
-0.08208972960710526,
0.265533447265625,
-0.12169365584850311,
0.4476640224456787,
0.5043078660964966,
-1.044425129890442,
-0.26572540402412415,
-0.017591984942555428,
-0.7579643130302429,
0.3825197219848633,
-0.08350472152233124,
-0.10412571579217911,
-0.10724581032991409,
0.44907835125923157,
-0.2527184784412384,
0.5752862095832825,
0.42240390181541443,
-0.44600188732147217,
0.25740107893943787,
-0.38779276609420776,
0.4279472231864929,
-1.1862775087356567,
0.043881095945835114,
0.07067819684743881,
-0.43500378727912903,
-0.23681148886680603,
0.0972462147474289,
0.4305465817451477,
-0.4288918077945709,
-0.6283904314041138,
0.21486559510231018,
-0.6499379277229309,
0.055707916617393494,
-0.3057083785533905,
0.1273534893989563,
0.32278069853782654,
0.37437888979911804,
-0.018869096413254738,
0.6499793529510498,
0.8784692287445068,
-0.4897702634334564,
0.23344449698925018,
0.28970420360565186,
-0.2259872853755951,
0.7421546578407288,
-0.6946703791618347,
-0.05440441146492958,
-0.658684492111206,
0.33228009939193726,
-1.039670705795288,
0.003564603626728058,
0.15573614835739136,
-0.07803040742874146,
0.2212316393852234,
-0.3645690083503723,
-0.4878365397453308,
-0.05007059499621391,
-0.7943739295005798,
0.6084827184677124,
0.08180404454469681,
-0.6715995669364929,
0.6439733505249023,
0.5376253128051758,
0.1611374318599701,
-0.5923102498054504,
-0.629630446434021,
0.05077165737748146,
0.23076064884662628,
-0.4958438575267792,
0.5200652480125427,
-0.15435299277305603,
0.4421274960041046,
-0.0482436865568161,
-0.15701733529567719,
-0.2746370732784271,
-0.3759194016456604,
0.2575136721134186,
0.3630998432636261,
-0.24041195213794708,
0.3985646665096283,
0.22390802204608917,
-0.21536263823509216,
-0.37441644072532654,
-0.30994904041290283,
0.29938575625419617,
-0.408934086561203,
-0.677801787853241,
-0.3728402256965637,
0.6375742554664612,
0.748389720916748,
-0.6744251847267151,
0.6838790774345398,
0.6817124485969543,
-0.2868399918079376,
0.09558658301830292,
-0.48864829540252686,
0.11451888084411621,
-0.4201948046684265,
0.37092000246047974,
-0.5078189373016357,
-0.806827187538147,
0.38849619030952454,
-0.18183521926403046,
0.05473098158836365,
0.27741214632987976,
0.4184652268886566,
0.12065921723842621,
1.0500328540802002,
0.9699902534484863,
0.08198901265859604,
0.6392781138420105,
-0.3080434203147888,
-0.24714992940425873,
-0.8258134722709656,
-0.8247231245040894,
-0.375593900680542,
-0.12215887755155563,
-0.3203485608100891,
-1.1302558183670044,
0.7834808826446533,
0.045271921902894974,
-0.026924503967165947,
0.10334540158510208,
-0.5342975854873657,
0.6347534656524658,
0.2888234853744507,
0.37039458751678467,
0.5527660250663757,
0.09443039447069168,
-0.34319204092025757,
-0.15341807901859283,
-0.39156657457351685,
-0.34426528215408325,
1.1084871292114258,
0.2841000556945801,
1.0940529108047485,
0.06111277639865875,
0.4451015591621399,
0.20899465680122375,
0.005331618245691061,
-0.8210193514823914,
0.3001226484775543,
-0.11487460136413574,
-0.4649825692176819,
0.08156874775886536,
-0.18760240077972412,
-1.0020389556884766,
0.8518403768539429,
-0.5437460541725159,
-0.49003010988235474,
0.38092830777168274,
-0.08705669641494751,
0.002919751452282071,
0.2722817659378052,
-0.5210947394371033,
0.8704679012298584,
-0.1615842878818512,
-0.13728246092796326,
-0.1635357290506363,
-0.6550856828689575,
0.21040312945842743,
0.09984583407640457,
0.13009513914585114,
-0.058487389236688614,
-0.5482912063598633,
0.39480504393577576,
-0.004249459598213434,
0.7695345878601074,
-0.11870135366916656,
0.0028477641753852367,
0.21729063987731934,
0.009084897115826607,
0.215988889336586,
0.27438029646873474,
-0.1475716382265091,
0.04212360084056854,
0.13725616037845612,
-0.3775728940963745,
-0.39484208822250366,
0.8466134071350098,
-0.42063042521476746,
-0.1472521722316742,
-0.4536921977996826,
-0.3734479248523712,
0.06475794315338135,
0.3126377463340759,
0.17571057379245758,
0.8156217336654663,
-0.47967004776000977,
0.6883640289306641,
0.880305290222168,
-0.2623368203639984,
0.5162081718444824,
0.3661547601222992,
-0.49833667278289795,
-0.5568592548370361,
1.0436826944351196,
-0.11020584404468536,
-0.11504048854112625,
0.7075060606002808,
0.01952739991247654,
-0.46319064497947693,
-0.04439428821206093,
-0.5856767296791077,
0.15048380196094513,
-0.7443589568138123,
-0.3649067282676697,
-0.6194120049476624,
0.22049780189990997,
-0.22749440371990204,
-0.10952112078666687,
-0.6460646390914917,
-0.26066604256629944,
-0.47444242238998413,
0.1590247005224228,
0.20931324362754822,
0.8586612343788147,
0.2041138857603073,
0.07711594551801682,
-0.9220020174980164,
0.5331935882568359,
0.22965069115161896,
0.4174351692199707,
-0.05134040489792824,
-0.10101915895938873,
-0.3402310907840729,
-0.09059005230665207,
-0.44120916724205017,
-1.0907262563705444,
0.1628289371728897,
0.23407338559627533,
0.4436994791030884,
0.6147927045822144,
-0.125910222530365,
0.4635985493659973,
-0.597865641117096,
0.7955673933029175,
0.5514394640922546,
-0.9033682346343994,
0.6712066531181335,
-0.38479477167129517,
0.43775230646133423,
0.5475321412086487,
0.3694078326225281,
-0.28241416811943054,
-0.07356023043394089,
-0.05837295949459076,
-0.8875877261161804,
0.4363657832145691,
-0.01067016925662756,
0.4271649122238159,
-0.12478665262460709,
0.16365118324756622,
0.3542238771915436,
0.338505357503891,
-0.8002413511276245,
-0.061929743736982346,
-0.4523475170135498,
-0.21867798268795013,
0.30029964447021484,
-0.19501207768917084,
-0.07626041769981384,
-0.26763349771499634,
0.017705509439110756,
-0.4544382095336914,
0.48015522956848145,
0.16248279809951782,
-0.3431175649166107,
0.33151495456695557,
0.315523624420166,
0.0926380604505539,
0.5145406723022461,
0.06161210685968399,
0.13117781281471252,
-0.2303503304719925,
-0.3560655415058136,
-0.027488090097904205,
0.17467431724071503,
-0.2744368016719818,
0.1174999326467514,
-0.15114031732082367,
0.7256268262863159,
0.5623593926429749,
-0.6335923075675964,
1.1818565130233765,
-0.16031646728515625,
0.1445493847131729,
-0.22883693873882294,
-0.1039801612496376,
-0.18976792693138123,
0.3927443027496338,
0.5247003436088562,
0.18768079578876495,
0.3930957019329071,
-0.5528311133384705,
0.27290597558021545,
0.6842620968818665,
-0.4375256299972534,
-0.38558444380760193,
0.9927960634231567,
0.369159996509552,
0.06915675103664398,
0.31207773089408875,
0.04536066949367523,
-0.4101012647151947,
0.23121342062950134,
0.5160230994224548,
0.7194347381591797,
0.07737070322036743,
0.5173325538635254,
0.10202706605195999,
0.21227651834487915,
0.00409786868840456,
0.5041065812110901,
-0.28750017285346985,
-0.3293014466762543,
-0.2103320062160492,
-0.6032800078392029,
-0.27362462878227234,
-0.22789612412452698,
-0.6283955574035645,
0.23844298720359802,
-0.23332858085632324,
-0.269233375787735,
-0.40949878096580505,
-0.372611403465271,
-1.029252529144287,
0.016331639140844345,
0.25638827681541443,
0.741717517375946,
-0.7911908626556396,
0.717706561088562,
0.7468799352645874,
-0.7883715629577637,
-0.16958944499492645,
0.1628367006778717,
0.12445428967475891,
-0.5852267742156982,
0.37430521845817566,
0.5242899656295776,
-0.3661373257637024,
-0.24613183736801147,
-0.4829889237880707,
-0.8891865015029907,
1.3162039518356323,
0.36201348900794983,
-0.18498024344444275,
-0.01259446982294321,
-0.06263483315706253,
0.3689468204975128,
-0.5924341082572937,
0.3820883631706238,
-0.0830366462469101,
0.27645114064216614,
0.3392544388771057,
-0.7541975378990173,
0.00778961880132556,
-0.25779157876968384,
0.5314602255821228,
-0.1619112491607666,
-0.5959179401397705,
0.9062137603759766,
-0.08724166452884674,
-0.13680581748485565,
0.08949257433414459,
0.8412249088287354,
-0.030412277206778526,
0.24152766168117523,
0.4927736222743988,
0.3889692425727844,
0.6987079381942749,
0.058102868497371674,
1.090712070465088,
-0.29178449511528015,
0.34948205947875977,
0.5854759216308594,
0.02291274070739746,
1.0471447706222534,
0.4235624670982361,
0.41299229860305786,
0.4686049222946167,
0.05130034312605858,
0.0682901069521904,
0.5904712677001953,
-0.29288890957832336,
-0.498970091342926,
-0.34572646021842957,
-0.29961803555488586,
-0.5273737907409668,
0.7204384207725525,
0.21904446184635162,
-0.5291569828987122,
-0.3464545011520386,
0.4805588126182556,
-0.059412404894828796,
0.006761319935321808,
-0.2821164131164551,
0.4935670793056488,
-0.27455583214759827,
-0.24945494532585144,
0.37399163842201233,
0.18734967708587646,
1.0113900899887085,
-0.5336518287658691,
-0.19772061705589294,
0.09725339710712433,
0.03329562395811081,
0.06639516353607178,
-0.7563960552215576,
-0.06004578247666359,
-0.11184027791023254,
-0.30544719099998474,
-0.3672519028186798,
0.6533612012863159,
-0.6980974078178406,
-0.5336096286773682,
0.1524982750415802,
0.662484884262085,
0.051121342927217484,
-0.16562698781490326,
-0.6227193474769592,
0.3798756003379822,
-0.08149608969688416,
-0.2899855375289917,
0.3976217210292816,
0.5062259435653687,
0.10980213433504105,
0.4930761456489563,
0.5157977938652039,
-0.3056974411010742,
0.21752847731113434,
0.18997713923454285,
1.1061513423919678,
-0.7494933605194092,
-0.6548259854316711,
-0.45231175422668457,
0.5880863070487976,
0.0657029002904892,
-0.18176278471946716,
0.5579026937484741,
0.8224095702171326,
0.35632094740867615,
-0.3165866732597351,
0.5639676451683044,
0.07630061358213425,
0.012452335096895695,
-0.5276188850402832,
0.5359347462654114,
-0.8953142762184143,
0.17940056324005127,
-0.26147499680519104,
-0.8900706171989441,
-0.29306042194366455,
0.5376595258712769,
0.1965940296649933,
-0.09969530999660492,
0.6436475515365601,
0.8483337759971619,
-0.3180682957172394,
-0.010634238831698895,
0.289454847574234,
-0.04395843297243118,
0.4981442391872406,
0.6058493256568909,
0.401227742433548,
-0.6049513816833496,
0.9747365117073059,
0.20941583812236786,
-0.3842014670372009,
-0.2349267452955246,
-0.8337970972061157,
-0.7153972387313843,
-0.860256016254425,
-0.045987315475940704,
-0.05919104069471359,
-0.200773686170578,
0.6542272567749023,
0.5878837704658508,
-0.35099175572395325,
0.06832271814346313,
0.28498923778533936,
0.11260336637496948,
0.08364793658256531,
-0.20860843360424042,
0.2703653872013092,
-0.3749840259552002,
-0.9865447282791138,
0.6573785543441772,
0.5386654138565063,
-0.12552271783351898,
-0.4348098635673523,
0.12835007905960083,
-0.23421569168567657,
0.021803580224514008,
0.9325703978538513,
0.15174506604671478,
-0.5073395371437073,
-0.3843086361885071,
0.06443124264478683,
-0.2188621461391449,
0.27477824687957764,
0.8698390126228333,
-1.0571866035461426,
0.9290423393249512,
0.6987415552139282,
0.7287151217460632,
0.6694499254226685,
-0.04094766825437546,
0.3842982351779938,
-0.8147977590560913,
0.19352784752845764,
0.1032901257276535,
0.35299360752105713,
0.3255293369293213,
-0.13205131888389587,
0.0029069988522678614,
0.31795376539230347,
-0.289974182844162,
-0.3563884496688843,
0.22207511961460114,
-1.175287127494812,
-0.21376074850559235,
0.9763669967651367,
0.02139888145029545,
-0.24169921875,
-0.08450476825237274,
-0.4327792823314667,
0.18807916343212128,
-0.592166543006897,
0.5636905431747437,
0.22138293087482452,
-0.04554668068885803,
-0.13497589528560638,
-0.5295943021774292,
0.00861369539052248,
0.141699880361557,
-0.49001356959342957,
-0.35247379541397095,
0.9483163952827454,
0.2853756844997406,
0.19004075229167938,
0.7329186797142029,
-0.4955483675003052,
0.22263893485069275,
0.13929973542690277,
-0.0718594491481781,
-0.3141154944896698,
-0.580876886844635,
-0.3588780164718628,
0.6727513074874878,
-0.3679806888103485,
-0.6695119738578796
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.04289v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.04289v3
|
What Languages are Easy to Language-Model? A Perspective from Learning Probabilistic Regular Languages
| 2024-06-06T17:34:24 | 2024-06-10T21:53:32 |
Nadav Borenstein, Anej Svete, Robin Chan, Josef Valvoda, Franz Nowak, Isabelle Augenstein, Eleanor Chodroff, Ryan Cotterell
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
What can large language models learn? By definition, language models (LM) are
distributions over strings. Therefore, an intuitive way of addressing the above
question is to formalize it as a matter of learnability of classes of
distributions over strings. While prior work in this direction focused on
assessing the theoretical limits, in contrast, we seek to understand the
empirical learnability. Unlike prior empirical work, we evaluate neural LMs on
their home turf-learning probabilistic languages-rather than as classifiers of
formal languages. In particular, we investigate the learnability of regular LMs
(RLMs) by RNN and Transformer LMs. We empirically test the learnability of RLMs
as a function of various complexity parameters of the RLM and the hidden state
size of the neural LM. We find that the RLM rank, which corresponds to the size
of linear space spanned by the logits of its conditional distributions, and the
expected length of sampled strings are strong and significant predictors of
learnability for both RNNs and Transformers. Several other predictors also
reach significance, but with differing patterns between RNNs and Transformers.
|
[
-0.07012543827295303,
-0.6652023196220398,
0.598659336566925,
0.20761749148368835,
-0.04479338228702545,
0.050924427807331085,
-0.7908419370651245,
-0.4725417196750641,
0.035615574568510056,
0.36030659079551697,
-0.13372719287872314,
-0.23202523589134216,
-0.5846280455589294,
0.12542104721069336,
-0.6249854564666748,
1.009895920753479,
0.0548417903482914,
-0.06901048123836517,
0.07404084503650665,
0.0477263480424881,
0.007398152258247137,
-0.34715375304222107,
-0.7624350786209106,
-0.31292444467544556,
0.8920981884002686,
0.07356061041355133,
0.8577688932418823,
0.9221393465995789,
0.44016358256340027,
0.3316582143306732,
-0.03857215493917465,
-0.35632431507110596,
-0.41512420773506165,
0.21948614716529846,
0.007061931304633617,
-0.9990480542182922,
-0.14383116364479065,
-0.04556039720773697,
0.6752569675445557,
0.9413824081420898,
-0.3804416060447693,
0.12346712499856949,
0.07202243059873581,
0.7505987286567688,
-0.17593474686145782,
0.5365390777587891,
-0.6868817806243896,
0.18136058747768402,
-0.2931484878063202,
0.192323237657547,
-0.6794265508651733,
-0.5055556297302246,
0.14732317626476288,
-0.6168108582496643,
0.3058364987373352,
0.1654854714870453,
0.7290303111076355,
-0.10182108730077744,
-0.2826441526412964,
-0.26152631640434265,
-1.0609557628631592,
0.9372914433479309,
-0.4897683262825012,
0.7778963446617126,
0.4975475072860718,
0.7567387819290161,
-0.04473870247602463,
-0.7832573652267456,
-0.3394712209701538,
-0.640055239200592,
-0.16642598807811737,
-0.14303526282310486,
-0.09175029397010803,
0.0037273007910698652,
0.2876057028770447,
0.5471929311752319,
-0.6114109754562378,
0.15897350013256073,
-0.18032750487327576,
-0.06856942921876907,
0.5691782236099243,
-0.11680259555578232,
0.4173358082771301,
0.05919666960835457,
-0.06787319481372833,
0.04681028798222542,
-0.5620368123054504,
0.09397581964731216,
0.46934741735458374,
0.47625675797462463,
-0.11715363711118698,
0.31623902916908264,
0.19248567521572113,
0.7576452493667603,
-0.326177179813385,
-0.24894627928733826,
-0.2043650597333908,
0.006754327565431595,
-0.07975496351718903,
-0.45621445775032043,
0.6285626292228699,
-0.3825038969516754,
0.7639798521995544,
-0.3905878961086273,
-0.4824901819229126,
-0.38111257553100586,
0.17751362919807434,
-0.4530177712440491,
-0.5955846309661865,
-0.07660281658172607,
-0.7416926622390747,
0.036470916122198105,
-0.04082699865102768,
-0.41673314571380615,
-0.2745206654071808,
-0.20371094346046448,
0.4937760829925537,
-0.5384922027587891,
-0.49881505966186523,
0.03829554468393326,
0.15902727842330933,
0.20745514333248138,
0.33918797969818115,
-0.8996450901031494,
0.5417996644973755,
0.7416719794273376,
0.5557115077972412,
-0.09685876965522766,
-0.3141920566558838,
-0.09971411526203156,
-0.3501691520214081,
-0.4820384085178375,
0.3924887180328369,
-0.297075480222702,
-0.05423742160201073,
0.10288959741592407,
0.14050374925136566,
-0.40987148880958557,
-0.532879650592804,
0.41702988743782043,
-0.8493739366531372,
-0.03213968873023987,
0.06642046570777893,
-0.579200267791748,
-0.3761204183101654,
-0.15401515364646912,
-0.7713025808334351,
0.3801444470882416,
0.21159031987190247,
-0.6694174408912659,
0.2783471643924713,
-0.010659188032150269,
-0.6073864698410034,
0.20450221002101898,
-0.09336400032043457,
-0.41986867785453796,
0.2888014018535614,
-0.6324660181999207,
0.493290513753891,
-0.16860707104206085,
0.2700824737548828,
-0.2340923547744751,
-0.41245442628860474,
0.5582029819488525,
-0.9417465329170227,
0.6697884798049927,
0.4108481705188751,
-0.21089895069599152,
0.004864291287958622,
-1.037577509880066,
0.013851082883775234,
0.23822017014026642,
-0.6288840770721436,
-0.34243151545524597,
0.33220306038856506,
0.11912169307470322,
0.16253185272216797,
-0.047815944999456406,
-0.43853506445884705,
0.18580719828605652,
-0.5063327550888062,
0.44352877140045166,
0.7140951752662659,
-0.44632548093795776,
0.5845359563827515,
0.005914623849093914,
0.4096686542034149,
-0.11568433046340942,
0.08362741023302078,
0.06449716538190842,
-0.5796201825141907,
-0.9518505930900574,
-0.6342183947563171,
0.7441772818565369,
0.4358765184879303,
-0.541991651058197,
0.28471922874450684,
-0.0278485044836998,
-0.5141608119010925,
-0.40120232105255127,
0.34413209557533264,
0.46302881836891174,
0.07350987195968628,
0.07683844864368439,
-0.18152138590812683,
-0.47734007239341736,
-1.1122604608535767,
-0.5666177868843079,
-0.07589587569236755,
-0.12885740399360657,
0.32218635082244873,
0.37304335832595825,
0.03699794411659241,
0.7367876768112183,
-0.3022189140319824,
0.09372557699680328,
-0.592989981174469,
-0.05492522940039635,
0.473652184009552,
0.3503677248954773,
0.3757014274597168,
-0.7025361061096191,
-0.6745756268501282,
0.014825055375695229,
-0.6309951543807983,
0.43168118596076965,
-0.009676516987383366,
0.3988663852214813,
0.15717734396457672,
0.282108873128891,
-0.5915213227272034,
0.43238741159439087,
0.2950194478034973,
-0.10680951923131943,
0.32514315843582153,
-0.5711007714271545,
-0.5711470246315002,
-0.5665258169174194,
-0.21321003139019012,
0.07341975718736649,
-0.3442756235599518,
-0.9373830556869507,
0.07522715628147125,
0.16248120367527008,
-0.07412206381559372,
-0.41737282276153564,
0.47962307929992676,
-0.3905191123485565,
-0.31331807374954224,
-0.123484306037426,
-0.20256386697292328,
-0.5550785660743713,
0.47011521458625793,
0.2640191912651062,
0.3108748197555542,
0.738450288772583,
-0.8055758476257324,
0.00015853987133596092,
-0.32044410705566406,
-0.8036020994186401,
0.002649583388119936,
-0.7338274717330933,
-0.12077957391738892,
-0.3196437656879425,
0.28825950622558594,
-0.8552260398864746,
-0.3119947910308838,
-0.08910399675369263,
-0.2350756824016571,
0.4790720045566559,
-0.0369548536837101,
-0.3677358627319336,
0.0029782061465084553,
0.3018971085548401,
0.20580808818340302,
0.665895938873291,
-0.42657536268234253,
0.45321035385131836,
0.13468238711357117,
-0.0642474815249443,
-0.4783722460269928,
-0.47415661811828613,
-0.15101845562458038,
-0.05440704524517059,
-0.32675597071647644,
-0.2972339391708374,
0.05657978355884552,
-0.5258094072341919,
-0.08287889510393143,
0.13729187846183777,
-0.17023411393165588,
0.5607231855392456,
0.394875168800354,
0.07920879870653152,
-0.3947049379348755,
0.10258796066045761,
-0.5544186234474182,
-0.3151937425136566,
-0.1260332614183426,
-0.28193727135658264,
0.5639290809631348,
-0.39072656631469727,
-0.27877557277679443,
-0.1965959072113037,
0.055769920349121094,
0.4595654010772705,
-0.23584584891796112,
0.9459527730941772,
0.49285954236984253,
-0.39871054887771606,
-0.46550866961479187,
-0.17846181988716125,
-0.2668324112892151,
-0.39608484506607056,
0.3938279151916504,
-0.541591227054596,
-0.6833916902542114,
0.5635440349578857,
0.35842791199684143,
0.19922597706317902,
0.5036113858222961,
0.47736114263534546,
-0.11271596699953079,
1.2058912515640259,
0.7624497413635254,
0.19437582790851593,
0.4199313819408417,
-0.20954753458499908,
0.4485931098461151,
-0.2316056340932846,
-0.1487012803554535,
-0.5659210681915283,
-0.31367114186286926,
-0.9353506565093994,
-0.3415016233921051,
-0.04094935953617096,
0.23996351659297943,
-0.3224000036716461,
0.4222021698951721,
0.08536070585250854,
0.47555187344551086,
0.6785328388214111,
-0.11379627138376236,
0.22951069474220276,
0.0022671117912977934,
-0.05965711921453476,
-0.011065282858908176,
-0.7991601824760437,
-0.3803653419017792,
0.8598960041999817,
0.8266961574554443,
0.9443012475967407,
0.07473217695951462,
0.6030492782592773,
-0.24354523420333862,
0.4206398129463196,
-0.8850125670433044,
0.4917348027229309,
-0.3490215539932251,
-0.6699365973472595,
-0.3536803424358368,
-0.4598188102245331,
-1.0406180620193481,
0.1816038191318512,
-0.2854466736316681,
-0.6298484206199646,
0.33700597286224365,
-0.053857024759054184,
-0.30799078941345215,
0.5511517524719238,
-0.689549446105957,
0.5666967034339905,
-0.27884700894355774,
-0.007662934251129627,
0.013853035867214203,
-0.7786253690719604,
0.47921234369277954,
-0.19345824420452118,
0.5775002837181091,
-0.010263039730489254,
-0.008318912237882614,
0.6949623823165894,
-0.06935153901576996,
0.8590465784072876,
-0.01699778065085411,
-0.15135981142520905,
0.08407411724328995,
0.45145782828330994,
0.37626373767852783,
0.08468523621559143,
-0.07051960378885269,
0.3404672145843506,
-0.2000652402639389,
-0.2831541895866394,
-0.7322911024093628,
0.5802678465843201,
-0.7778497338294983,
-0.34244588017463684,
-0.25810128450393677,
-0.5861860513687134,
-0.07888989895582199,
0.1340419352054596,
0.19413268566131592,
0.46959877014160156,
-0.05428550764918327,
0.4446919560432434,
0.8690652251243591,
-0.4777698516845703,
0.49783751368522644,
0.7103074193000793,
-0.5277390480041504,
-0.07696685940027237,
1.4088971614837646,
0.4943406283855438,
0.28071922063827515,
0.3626711070537567,
0.3260214626789093,
-0.1997213363647461,
-0.5952085256576538,
-0.23356413841247559,
0.20463532209396362,
-0.5110472440719604,
0.35503071546554565,
-0.4232846796512604,
-0.5688566565513611,
0.007493108976632357,
0.018471961840987206,
-0.4205755591392517,
-0.7105594873428345,
-0.1590670794248581,
-0.3330954313278198,
0.1562645584344864,
0.9148204326629639,
-0.10062506049871445,
0.2048296183347702,
-0.636451005935669,
0.1563982516527176,
0.604292631149292,
0.5557135343551636,
0.07074619829654694,
-0.7170993685722351,
-0.22879235446453094,
-0.1451849490404129,
0.30988967418670654,
-0.6393382549285889,
0.36006659269332886,
0.40732210874557495,
0.695570707321167,
0.5291944742202759,
-0.3033978044986725,
0.012886553071439266,
-0.7206665873527527,
0.6383318305015564,
0.1034417599439621,
-0.5168218612670898,
0.03571029379963875,
-0.3736443519592285,
-0.2962566614151001,
0.24156951904296875,
0.6602847576141357,
-0.379133015871048,
-0.632108747959137,
-0.9189397692680359,
-0.7154026031494141,
0.48332831263542175,
0.13433903455734253,
0.2805422842502594,
-0.07272884994745255,
0.4725932776927948,
0.42727118730545044,
0.10876312851905823,
-0.8738389611244202,
-0.5997451543807983,
-0.14627039432525635,
-0.30366402864456177,
-0.6203994154930115,
-0.28661659359931946,
0.16580215096473694,
-0.11486218869686127,
0.2299645096063614,
0.12814712524414062,
0.2330661565065384,
-0.32302936911582947,
-0.3368460237979889,
-0.04091097041964531,
0.4523152709007263,
0.6893438696861267,
0.7487430572509766,
-0.39142167568206787,
0.6155016422271729,
-0.08695505559444427,
-0.45153284072875977,
0.23046353459358215,
-0.1471482366323471,
-0.36306625604629517,
0.08251607418060303,
0.6154153347015381,
1.0046526193618774,
0.41698309779167175,
-0.46769583225250244,
0.3271332383155823,
-0.2390640527009964,
-0.18352311849594116,
-0.3437601625919342,
0.11811117082834244,
0.21528077125549316,
-0.012666700407862663,
0.28979992866516113,
0.046214509755373,
-0.12393365055322647,
-0.7830488681793213,
0.27042341232299805,
0.19161787629127502,
-0.7379129528999329,
-0.7160698771476746,
0.47921520471572876,
0.07959505170583725,
-0.7665520906448364,
0.598520815372467,
-0.19217026233673096,
-0.5449526309967041,
0.6925737857818604,
0.8628488183021545,
0.7639563083648682,
-0.31373322010040283,
0.20483697950839996,
0.31433889269828796,
0.42031392455101013,
-0.3313676416873932,
0.21739031374454498,
0.1572057157754898,
-0.767608642578125,
-0.2745102643966675,
-0.7692662477493286,
-0.1943216472864151,
0.18589796125888824,
-0.7580292820930481,
-0.09877065569162369,
-0.5265960693359375,
0.06575300544500351,
-0.03019542805850506,
-0.22403112053871155,
-0.6637414693832397,
0.3943080008029938,
-0.010454199276864529,
1.0891269445419312,
-1.02919602394104,
0.8702611327171326,
0.4521768391132355,
-0.3382326066493988,
-1.0336401462554932,
-0.329269677400589,
-0.3444357216358185,
-0.9030795693397522,
1.0574257373809814,
-0.02907424233853817,
0.24729834496974945,
0.06052844226360321,
-0.3082682490348816,
-0.6676652431488037,
0.5470541715621948,
0.3492501676082611,
-0.811278760433197,
-0.036019597202539444,
0.054480861872434616,
0.7045446038246155,
-0.19641797244548798,
0.5281521081924438,
0.659824550151825,
0.36967673897743225,
-0.3978031575679779,
-0.8622732162475586,
-0.3092502951622009,
0.14850033819675446,
0.09354653209447861,
0.3775949776172638,
-0.5211911797523499,
1.114540934562683,
-0.228817880153656,
-0.19937096536159515,
-0.07508862763643265,
0.8628736138343811,
-0.009011099115014076,
0.09449733793735504,
0.7305936813354492,
0.3703683614730835,
0.6071219444274902,
-0.18125474452972412,
1.3448479175567627,
-0.46759626269340515,
0.45185744762420654,
0.9001060724258423,
-0.017867356538772583,
1.3150405883789062,
0.263971209526062,
-0.396256685256958,
0.6430503726005554,
0.5078001022338867,
0.3038983643054962,
0.4745293855667114,
0.6750537157058716,
-0.09680546075105667,
-0.5923305153846741,
0.41710326075553894,
-0.151114821434021,
0.4371662735939026,
0.29576534032821655,
-0.4252403676509857,
-0.23746195435523987,
0.060494184494018555,
-0.17909982800483704,
0.1661367565393448,
-0.317588746547699,
0.5969480276107788,
0.5647785663604736,
-0.36913639307022095,
0.46124517917633057,
0.0324459932744503,
0.5140286684036255,
-0.71695876121521,
0.11107662320137024,
-0.22636346518993378,
0.2762661576271057,
-0.1421898901462555,
-0.7078878283500671,
0.2248654067516327,
-0.018694473430514336,
-0.2758171558380127,
-0.08895545452833176,
0.7722877860069275,
-0.48840343952178955,
-0.4944695830345154,
0.13498292863368988,
0.5876609086990356,
0.37041428685188293,
0.28800368309020996,
-0.5548772215843201,
-0.23751915991306305,
-0.1732102781534195,
-0.4486556947231293,
0.7320350408554077,
0.05331313610076904,
-0.0830511748790741,
1.0590534210205078,
0.4035241901874542,
0.42235228419303894,
0.26012280583381653,
0.08294442296028137,
0.2128766030073166,
-0.5554024577140808,
-0.11824145168066025,
-0.6734930872917175,
0.17476828396320343,
0.40994560718536377,
-0.07479950785636902,
1.022042155265808,
0.43006864190101624,
0.680680513381958,
-0.39928120374679565,
0.5963190197944641,
0.15428376197814941,
0.7161542773246765,
-0.3933963477611542,
1.0000718832015991,
-0.4150741696357727,
0.19679412245750427,
0.22560426592826843,
-0.9368689656257629,
-0.33496445417404175,
0.9816401600837708,
-0.30213651061058044,
0.0901307687163353,
0.533950686454773,
0.6199612617492676,
-0.13512830436229706,
0.024238284677267075,
0.559657096862793,
0.2761284112930298,
0.028393929824233055,
0.5772665739059448,
1.1128484010696411,
-0.21114687621593475,
0.3473958671092987,
-0.3080008327960968,
-0.17907288670539856,
-0.15377171337604523,
-0.7508364319801331,
-0.6660940647125244,
-0.47739699482917786,
-0.17749451100826263,
-0.33359086513519287,
0.08100719004869461,
0.8821847438812256,
0.5861812233924866,
-0.9689401984214783,
-0.4534125328063965,
-0.2211911380290985,
0.4646257162094116,
-0.38544967770576477,
-0.22809290885925293,
0.4294564425945282,
-0.31889230012893677,
-0.7146254777908325,
0.49567845463752747,
0.09790430217981339,
0.06876494735479355,
-0.3753911256790161,
-0.08086328208446503,
0.14567264914512634,
0.2183542549610138,
0.5639437437057495,
0.7098562121391296,
-0.6702286005020142,
-0.39621642231941223,
0.08296124637126923,
-0.23891475796699524,
-0.31105372309684753,
0.7778469324111938,
-0.47567376494407654,
0.22762754559516907,
0.6713473796844482,
0.4936540722846985,
0.07996921986341476,
-0.38655757904052734,
0.6798879504203796,
-0.6915416717529297,
0.1719832420349121,
0.07310057431459427,
0.3848896026611328,
0.04733295366168022,
0.10581908375024796,
0.23394954204559326,
0.1198093369603157,
-0.543312132358551,
-1.0276939868927002,
0.50883948802948,
-0.7014526724815369,
-0.23260684311389923,
1.3638826608657837,
-0.4704761505126953,
-0.33743178844451904,
-0.4760147035121918,
0.14626768231391907,
0.08280110359191895,
0.12108784168958664,
0.39194539189338684,
0.4464832544326782,
0.21357658505439758,
-0.15682469308376312,
-0.9936882853507996,
0.7643880248069763,
0.4227235019207001,
-0.30935394763946533,
0.0021761558018624783,
-0.03444366902112961,
0.672561764717102,
0.17501641809940338,
0.4275389313697815,
0.09861904382705688,
0.19394341111183167,
-0.08397910743951797,
-0.011079220101237297,
0.028424818068742752,
-0.7340009808540344,
-0.7213271856307983,
0.186053067445755,
0.4426940977573395,
0.12652945518493652
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.04286v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.04286v1
|
ABEX: Data Augmentation for Low-Resource NLU via Expanding Abstract Descriptions
| 2024-06-06T17:29:57 | 2024-06-06T17:29:57 |
Sreyan Ghosh, Utkarsh Tyagi, Sonal Kumar, C. K. Evuru, S Ramaneswaran, S Sakshi, Dinesh Manocha
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
We present ABEX, a novel and effective generative data augmentation
methodology for low-resource Natural Language Understanding (NLU) tasks. ABEX
is based on ABstract-and-EXpand, a novel paradigm for generating diverse forms
of an input document -- we first convert a document into its concise, abstract
description and then generate new documents based on expanding the resultant
abstraction. To learn the task of expanding abstract descriptions, we first
train BART on a large-scale synthetic dataset with abstract-document pairs.
Next, to generate abstract descriptions for a document, we propose a simple,
controllable, and training-free method based on editing AMR graphs. ABEX brings
the best of both worlds: by expanding from abstract representations, it
preserves the original semantic properties of the documents, like style and
meaning, thereby maintaining alignment with the original label and data
distribution. At the same time, the fundamental process of elaborating on
abstract descriptions facilitates diverse generations. We demonstrate the
effectiveness of ABEX on 4 NLU tasks spanning 12 datasets and 4 low-resource
settings. ABEX outperforms all our baselines qualitatively with improvements of
0.04% - 38.8%. Qualitatively, ABEX outperforms all prior methods from
literature in terms of context and length diversity.
|
[
-0.5961906909942627,
-0.886898398399353,
0.658957302570343,
0.1399582177400589,
-0.2578562796115875,
0.4404316246509552,
-0.5441606044769287,
-0.9663684964179993,
0.2217980921268463,
0.23122480511665344,
-0.6174858808517456,
-0.6719862222671509,
-0.5803424119949341,
0.4869963526725769,
-0.44588345289230347,
1.0226250886917114,
0.044398173689842224,
-0.3827717900276184,
-0.4576585590839386,
-0.31072545051574707,
-0.31200212240219116,
-0.0919097438454628,
-0.8660714030265808,
-0.2931496500968933,
0.38525718450546265,
0.4724001884460449,
1.0264897346496582,
0.9122066497802734,
0.17288926243782043,
0.33921200037002563,
-0.08227647095918655,
0.3011097013950348,
-0.4413059651851654,
0.1393955945968628,
-0.08277039229869843,
-0.48042160272598267,
-0.6133952140808105,
-0.28335264325141907,
0.7208433747291565,
1.1769070625305176,
-0.14175467193126678,
-0.10129161179065704,
-0.01219106838107109,
0.6339481472969055,
-0.747809648513794,
0.2168113887310028,
-0.4475243389606476,
0.10144983977079391,
-0.0329589881002903,
0.12738168239593506,
-0.2603592574596405,
-0.37435182929039,
0.2016841322183609,
-1.1390235424041748,
0.309549480676651,
0.1778113842010498,
0.5912673473358154,
0.18669186532497406,
-0.4743952751159668,
-0.2546660006046295,
-0.8908484578132629,
1.0040817260742188,
-0.7434239387512207,
0.2871226668357849,
0.3839401304721832,
0.2624424993991852,
0.28911423683166504,
-0.7166950702667236,
-0.7163322567939758,
-0.024082882329821587,
-0.39312976598739624,
0.1689056009054184,
-0.49412426352500916,
0.33153197169303894,
0.3077179193496704,
0.9538553357124329,
-0.5785928964614868,
0.17025956511497498,
-0.47661006450653076,
-0.2304677963256836,
0.8456975221633911,
0.23857972025871277,
0.3970540463924408,
-0.0988636314868927,
-0.22240732610225677,
-0.19840362668037415,
-0.24694330990314484,
-0.338366836309433,
0.29336702823638916,
0.15885865688323975,
-0.3035455048084259,
0.5626920461654663,
-0.5356160998344421,
0.6775185465812683,
-0.15355195105075836,
0.24373650550842285,
0.5163169503211975,
-0.6241121888160706,
-0.1270778328180313,
0.34024739265441895,
0.6487799286842346,
0.09319192171096802,
-0.3129897117614746,
-0.4544517695903778,
-0.24838541448116302,
0.14804017543792725,
0.3317672312259674,
-0.6716115474700928,
-0.06590969115495682,
-0.03415601700544357,
-0.5497161746025085,
-0.33961495757102966,
-0.15949466824531555,
-0.9810723662376404,
-0.2876775860786438,
-0.5497950315475464,
0.18142591416835785,
-0.5477815270423889,
-0.18871405720710754,
0.012848309241235256,
-0.014599881134927273,
0.12363581359386444,
0.5186254382133484,
-0.8727482557296753,
0.6338186860084534,
0.6655498743057251,
0.7629052996635437,
-0.21466536819934845,
0.04381375014781952,
-0.44365450739860535,
0.007870162837207317,
-0.3105587661266327,
0.5958918333053589,
-0.8542385101318359,
-0.5948339700698853,
-0.15759055316448212,
-0.09364194422960281,
0.4781486690044403,
-0.39957761764526367,
0.5732449889183044,
-0.4040282070636749,
0.23068659007549286,
0.1262938231229782,
-0.37782230973243713,
-0.2673555016517639,
0.14232927560806274,
-0.895332932472229,
1.0667535066604614,
0.4565756022930145,
-0.43026766180992126,
0.16605348885059357,
-0.9330760836601257,
-0.6291875839233398,
0.13489536941051483,
-0.24806015193462372,
-0.17015385627746582,
0.30308637022972107,
0.3642391264438629,
-0.16683118045330048,
-0.1925814300775528,
-0.27018818259239197,
-0.07132842391729355,
-0.03901533782482147,
0.14861994981765747,
-0.5664402842521667,
0.47872281074523926,
0.227821484208107,
-0.13553786277770996,
0.1366710066795349,
-1.136707067489624,
0.060745708644390106,
-0.023102587088942528,
-0.5276641249656677,
-0.6893437504768372,
-0.3144850432872772,
0.10292825102806091,
-0.0030333606991916895,
0.26810121536254883,
-0.7921404242515564,
0.2590305805206299,
-0.8122596740722656,
0.21837787330150604,
0.7330840229988098,
-0.09382817149162292,
0.9974496960639954,
-0.22222130000591278,
0.856482982635498,
-0.4021231234073639,
0.09386560320854187,
-0.5460397005081177,
-0.5500404834747314,
-0.7450466156005859,
0.06956155598163605,
0.4238668382167816,
0.2891210615634918,
-0.8029704689979553,
0.4303446114063263,
-0.4548055827617645,
-0.2828659117221832,
-0.8373726606369019,
0.2499469369649887,
0.30860796570777893,
0.6383614540100098,
0.696343719959259,
-0.4158433675765991,
-0.6273223161697388,
-0.9243553876876831,
0.31410112977027893,
0.047069188207387924,
-0.12200883030891418,
0.41706550121307373,
0.18037088215351105,
-0.5972830057144165,
1.0024842023849487,
-0.6063929200172424,
-0.03005344606935978,
-0.27101951837539673,
0.6080108284950256,
0.04660504683852196,
0.37158873677253723,
0.23197826743125916,
-0.575854480266571,
-0.37585458159446716,
0.3736533522605896,
-0.8054966330528259,
-0.0892706885933876,
-0.39124420285224915,
-0.14965549111366272,
0.18012525141239166,
0.34568992257118225,
-0.4075605869293213,
0.4412562847137451,
0.45426851511001587,
-0.255838006734848,
0.5674614906311035,
-0.3376266658306122,
-0.17165973782539368,
-1.1677820682525635,
-0.1253518909215927,
-0.3164920210838318,
-0.27044233679771423,
-0.36136963963508606,
0.05923597887158394,
-0.11536609381437302,
-0.3248242735862732,
-0.12293758243322372,
0.7707506418228149,
-0.631901204586029,
-0.07420113682746887,
-0.6369166374206543,
0.20559698343276978,
0.15971159934997559,
0.314113974571228,
0.02455633133649826,
0.5543858408927917,
0.6892393231391907,
-0.4182453751564026,
0.30227428674697876,
0.6226796507835388,
-0.09378188103437424,
0.3820456564426422,
-0.42351266741752625,
0.34199246764183044,
-0.36838680505752563,
0.281961590051651,
-0.6282939314842224,
-0.03264492377638817,
0.048097483813762665,
-0.33452439308166504,
0.16986577212810516,
0.0034241164103150368,
-0.3440631628036499,
-0.25394299626350403,
-0.24272337555885315,
0.6273949146270752,
0.5422058701515198,
-0.5325837135314941,
1.0198521614074707,
-0.008738665841519833,
-0.49810659885406494,
-0.7273409366607666,
-0.6052456498146057,
0.3210056722164154,
0.09515466541051865,
-0.5851413011550903,
0.7108049988746643,
0.003404039889574051,
-0.472392201423645,
0.5869818329811096,
-0.31243836879730225,
-0.02387261763215065,
-0.1103057861328125,
0.15803349018096924,
0.3543459177017212,
-0.3367651402950287,
0.24890334904193878,
0.5592967867851257,
-0.1759205013513565,
-0.02488824725151062,
-0.3117256462574005,
0.4551382064819336,
-0.14676351845264435,
0.016813796013593674,
-0.1968555450439453,
0.7521531581878662,
0.18017692863941193,
-0.16598908603191376,
0.5284419059753418,
0.640091598033905,
-0.3206251263618469,
-0.41351842880249023,
-0.14056451618671417,
-0.4226168692111969,
-0.4719151556491852,
0.3503788411617279,
-0.054084617644548416,
-0.8170642256736755,
0.31644269824028015,
-0.06781993806362152,
0.3314690589904785,
0.40650883316993713,
-0.012306676246225834,
-0.06946420669555664,
0.9592445492744446,
0.8854618072509766,
0.059235695749521255,
0.2740683853626251,
-0.5144290328025818,
0.037038903683423996,
-1.0596301555633545,
-0.00508539006114006,
-0.11949619650840759,
-0.7233708500862122,
-0.38466015458106995,
-0.543555736541748,
0.08615683764219284,
0.03225500136613846,
0.3048701882362366,
0.21592707931995392,
-0.5034258961677551,
0.44276726245880127,
0.3963566720485687,
-0.017862483859062195,
0.6425876617431641,
-0.037673503160476685,
0.13008616864681244,
0.044191762804985046,
-0.5401279926300049,
-0.3407406806945801,
1.61601722240448,
0.1572687029838562,
0.8197957873344421,
0.0784246101975441,
0.8191022276878357,
0.5788902640342712,
0.4882206916809082,
-0.9543216228485107,
0.5176689624786377,
-0.25019386410713196,
-0.37158969044685364,
-0.33799320459365845,
-0.5071679353713989,
-1.224503755569458,
0.11653342097997665,
-0.6705126166343689,
-0.33305343985557556,
0.4659311771392822,
0.22624433040618896,
-0.402643084526062,
0.12962962687015533,
-0.5341947078704834,
0.42389553785324097,
-0.38133588433265686,
-0.22245843708515167,
-0.5105791091918945,
-0.5306159853935242,
0.29165804386138916,
-0.207161083817482,
0.47604459524154663,
0.1161574274301529,
-0.2859862446784973,
0.6913180947303772,
-0.6856328845024109,
0.624271810054779,
0.12467891722917557,
-0.12033821642398834,
0.10741501301527023,
-0.21735361218452454,
0.5734105706214905,
0.34332358837127686,
-0.049289241433143616,
0.1762610226869583,
-0.5123468637466431,
-0.3696710467338562,
-0.9315348267555237,
0.6712782382965088,
-0.640591561794281,
-0.3331965208053589,
-0.30977359414100647,
-0.8533977270126343,
-0.164158433675766,
0.2598503828048706,
0.07262949645519257,
0.5861610770225525,
-0.2667808532714844,
0.2453966736793518,
0.5303767323493958,
-0.43159690499305725,
0.3993779420852661,
0.40740641951560974,
-0.15641064941883087,
-0.5621690154075623,
0.7797726988792419,
-0.3945566713809967,
0.40832164883613586,
0.43851736187934875,
0.12269188463687897,
-0.3695877194404602,
-0.5958104729652405,
-0.381786972284317,
0.14851656556129456,
-0.6758378148078918,
-0.18363387882709503,
-0.7821417450904846,
0.02815529704093933,
-0.30426183342933655,
-0.4000585973262787,
-0.22931000590324402,
-0.8885414600372314,
-0.06172696128487587,
-0.42216745018959045,
0.45949262380599976,
0.5801402926445007,
-0.3827526867389679,
0.6922230124473572,
-0.7022362351417542,
0.4195418655872345,
0.41103824973106384,
0.15005473792552948,
-0.045257121324539185,
-0.15678204596042633,
-0.37770700454711914,
0.038047805428504944,
-0.37648484110832214,
-0.7495196461677551,
0.4505913555622101,
0.3389778137207031,
0.4184950888156891,
0.6044114828109741,
0.1478876769542694,
0.5131837725639343,
-0.4942539930343628,
0.4166646897792816,
0.3471440374851227,
-0.7472199201583862,
0.6518974900245667,
-0.084953673183918,
0.3370540738105774,
0.6518477201461792,
0.023450206965208054,
-0.4196045994758606,
-0.5383801460266113,
-0.7773662209510803,
-1.397617220878601,
0.8677945733070374,
0.5379716157913208,
0.4882202744483948,
0.028487689793109894,
0.3671513795852661,
0.43946534395217896,
0.07488584518432617,
-0.5979712605476379,
-0.5484746694564819,
-0.2822844684123993,
-0.41330695152282715,
-0.011549565009772778,
0.06134957820177078,
-0.21756382286548615,
-0.16092853248119354,
0.5574955344200134,
-0.18421629071235657,
0.30546700954437256,
0.09903158247470856,
-0.1763640195131302,
-0.03964301943778992,
0.699580729007721,
0.15366674959659576,
0.5329180359840393,
-0.13244523108005524,
0.36184045672416687,
0.26656728982925415,
-0.5591289401054382,
-0.04294995963573456,
0.6497128009796143,
-0.28861692547798157,
0.3171157240867615,
0.34560033679008484,
1.031944751739502,
0.2738841772079468,
-0.7565015554428101,
0.025275349617004395,
-0.1908482313156128,
-0.1933116614818573,
-0.09864548593759537,
0.08883555233478546,
-0.12135589122772217,
-0.17928224802017212,
0.4192286431789398,
0.28365764021873474,
0.4690108895301819,
-0.6789606213569641,
0.19731943309307098,
0.3775343596935272,
-0.22592617571353912,
-0.26799720525741577,
0.7887732982635498,
0.4143744111061096,
-0.20764385163784027,
0.6489312052726746,
-0.4410087466239929,
0.014888448640704155,
0.547451376914978,
0.7044807076454163,
0.8035765290260315,
0.055743154138326645,
0.32356682419776917,
0.4636327624320984,
0.3594190180301666,
0.27644896507263184,
0.06810831278562546,
-0.5601286292076111,
-0.7527376413345337,
-0.6098477840423584,
-0.7820311188697815,
-0.3642956614494324,
0.19974185526371002,
-0.7827678918838501,
0.07782431691884995,
-0.4120553433895111,
-0.11911178380250931,
0.09368869662284851,
-0.21024920046329498,
-0.5371891260147095,
0.26429837942123413,
0.3815297484397888,
0.9294894933700562,
-0.7790307998657227,
0.6061936020851135,
0.7935518622398376,
-0.39206430315971375,
-0.49970173835754395,
0.034199751913547516,
-0.057009752839803696,
-0.6617907881736755,
0.32013553380966187,
0.08310568332672119,
0.06295853853225708,
0.14873602986335754,
-0.17102599143981934,
-0.8319882750511169,
1.1461069583892822,
0.2628818452358246,
-0.6294548511505127,
-0.2479950338602066,
0.1435701847076416,
0.39714494347572327,
-0.2888750433921814,
0.06963062286376953,
0.4173613488674164,
0.5784377455711365,
-0.044666826725006104,
-0.5421828627586365,
0.14523588120937347,
-0.49362680315971375,
0.021073395386338234,
0.2998849153518677,
0.1290048062801361,
0.4818333685398102,
-0.3426649570465088,
-0.4020586609840393,
0.08233541995286942,
0.8487908840179443,
0.10682999342679977,
0.3789863884449005,
0.7163506746292114,
0.7628887891769409,
0.9691501259803772,
-0.13576073944568634,
1.3327603340148926,
-0.08549162745475769,
0.07460429519414902,
1.3328325748443604,
0.13313542306423187,
0.45834246277809143,
0.21459342539310455,
-0.09358755499124527,
0.8372832536697388,
0.3543921113014221,
0.08616934716701508,
0.3789609372615814,
-0.13234302401542664,
-0.6655477285385132,
-0.13507120311260223,
-0.03917350992560387,
-0.3572249114513397,
0.184424489736557,
0.5311406850814819,
-0.41457730531692505,
-0.4498666822910309,
0.3428581655025482,
0.030918356031179428,
0.29181623458862305,
-0.43505096435546875,
0.9972507953643799,
0.06619042903184891,
-0.35478389263153076,
0.4422094225883484,
0.08663701266050339,
0.7941573262214661,
-0.6728181838989258,
-0.18929842114448547,
-0.2749491035938263,
-0.042665790766477585,
-0.313070148229599,
-0.776577353477478,
0.5946522355079651,
-0.08231120556592941,
-0.29748132824897766,
-0.23869788646697998,
0.6065597534179688,
-0.47500863671302795,
-0.6396893262863159,
0.24625533819198608,
0.21585054695606232,
-0.08021140098571777,
0.23557883501052856,
-0.5577026605606079,
-0.12381648272275925,
-0.008966541849076748,
0.268049031496048,
0.09086930006742477,
0.39535561203956604,
-0.2134614884853363,
0.3586713671684265,
0.7195500731468201,
0.2266046553850174,
0.1263868659734726,
0.0037009394727647305,
0.8167502284049988,
-0.2926754951477051,
-0.5164823532104492,
-0.598353922367096,
0.4972493648529053,
-0.515856146812439,
-0.07323702424764633,
0.6427509784698486,
0.8813427686691284,
0.856663703918457,
-0.0011720178881660104,
1.3146977424621582,
-0.2297510802745819,
0.1484358310699463,
-0.529082715511322,
0.5248788595199585,
-0.4514240026473999,
0.2147257924079895,
-0.026618003845214844,
-1.0683393478393555,
-0.11831365525722504,
0.48441681265830994,
-0.40142834186553955,
-0.22860461473464966,
0.7302208542823792,
0.4967646598815918,
-0.2824658155441284,
0.1333218216896057,
-0.019741984084248543,
0.28096112608909607,
0.15431766211986542,
0.39203086495399475,
0.7594621777534485,
-0.2139018177986145,
0.8210705518722534,
-0.5334871411323547,
-0.5497092008590698,
0.1279476135969162,
-0.5083979368209839,
-0.3661139905452728,
-0.27431294322013855,
-0.6034391522407532,
-0.13825668394565582,
-0.10923714935779572,
0.6547738909721375,
0.7366649508476257,
-0.7583785653114319,
0.13935448229312897,
-0.4381132423877716,
0.22447703778743744,
-0.41449135541915894,
-0.31425610184669495,
0.29136013984680176,
-0.6453508138656616,
-0.9942781329154968,
0.7207356095314026,
0.3589804172515869,
-0.04026515781879425,
-0.009564057923853397,
-0.3694911301136017,
0.041637349873781204,
0.16891953349113464,
0.7554147839546204,
0.5124742388725281,
-0.4880484640598297,
0.08785371482372284,
-0.007207942195236683,
0.32077834010124207,
0.20141153037548065,
0.6729027032852173,
-0.9664710164070129,
0.8516152501106262,
0.23995937407016754,
0.8750072717666626,
0.4436725676059723,
0.2572041451931,
0.8319408297538757,
-1.1202136278152466,
0.06829217821359634,
0.33404868841171265,
0.3051527440547943,
0.41010573506355286,
-0.46612748503685,
0.5637524127960205,
0.07691220939159393,
-0.19535483419895172,
-0.6740565299987793,
0.3300212025642395,
-1.3043919801712036,
-0.3044617474079132,
1.0198599100112915,
0.24737094342708588,
0.0693645104765892,
-0.22293628752231598,
-0.37144356966018677,
0.09779268503189087,
-0.6436756253242493,
0.9107165336608887,
0.24781402945518494,
-0.3390447795391083,
-0.16334056854248047,
-0.4954310357570648,
0.46805980801582336,
0.23725230991840363,
-1.1430280208587646,
0.17270445823669434,
0.7040567398071289,
-0.1089545488357544,
0.47878727316856384,
0.6513519287109375,
-0.22702454030513763,
0.32143455743789673,
-0.20115713775157928,
0.12545478343963623,
-0.16643564403057098,
0.10621680319309235,
-0.40429776906967163,
-0.012990053743124008,
-0.09716593474149704,
-0.24524804949760437
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.04278v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.04278v1
|
Characterizing Similarities and Divergences in Conversational Tones in Humans and LLMs by Sampling with People
| 2024-06-06T17:26:00 | 2024-06-06T17:26:00 |
Dun-Ming Huang, Pol Van Rijn, Ilia Sucholutsky, Raja Marjieh, Nori Jacoby
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.HC
|
Conversational tones -- the manners and attitudes in which speakers
communicate -- are essential to effective communication. Amidst the increasing
popularization of Large Language Models (LLMs) over recent years, it becomes
necessary to characterize the divergences in their conversational tones
relative to humans. However, existing investigations of conversational
modalities rely on pre-existing taxonomies or text corpora, which suffer from
experimenter bias and may not be representative of real-world distributions for
the studies' psycholinguistic domains. Inspired by methods from cognitive
science, we propose an iterative method for simultaneously eliciting
conversational tones and sentences, where participants alternate between two
tasks: (1) one participant identifies the tone of a given sentence and (2) a
different participant generates a sentence based on that tone. We run 100
iterations of this process with human participants and GPT-4, then obtain a
dataset of sentences and frequent conversational tones. In an additional
experiment, humans and GPT-4 annotated all sentences with all tones. With data
from 1,339 human participants, 33,370 human judgments, and 29,900 GPT-4
queries, we show how our approach can be used to create an interpretable
geometric representation of relations between conversational tones in humans
and GPT-4. This work demonstrates how combining ideas from machine learning and
cognitive science can address challenges in human-computer interactions.
|
[
-0.4377906620502472,
-0.7167949676513672,
0.693097710609436,
0.34562918543815613,
-0.24948671460151672,
0.20935258269309998,
-0.46331220865249634,
-0.5371997356414795,
0.16801010072231293,
0.3714933693408966,
-0.7290369868278503,
-0.5965946912765503,
-0.12927213311195374,
0.21665172278881073,
-0.24713709950447083,
0.7386439442634583,
0.42340287566185,
0.2899097204208374,
-0.10145322978496552,
-0.011509228497743607,
-0.5018009543418884,
-0.5988748669624329,
-0.5032119154930115,
-0.39421769976615906,
0.3516381084918976,
0.32958924770355225,
0.4060533046722412,
0.12318983674049377,
0.39523038268089294,
0.29533347487449646,
-0.09540519118309021,
-0.04968143254518509,
-0.41902652382850647,
0.09615267068147659,
0.1469416320323944,
-0.5716918110847473,
0.05095285549759865,
0.16192582249641418,
0.35381338000297546,
1.01350736618042,
-0.33336251974105835,
-0.23862366378307343,
0.15561963617801666,
0.5660286545753479,
-0.10587096214294434,
0.3519555926322937,
-0.6762861609458923,
0.11584756523370743,
-0.23828795552253723,
-0.5272526144981384,
-0.3240501582622528,
-0.4083592891693115,
0.3157269358634949,
-0.4588721990585327,
0.560072124004364,
0.08755256980657578,
0.6658790111541748,
-0.010254819877445698,
-0.3905290961265564,
-0.6483428478240967,
-0.7271555662155151,
0.8248966932296753,
-0.6085199117660522,
0.4034304916858673,
0.32473623752593994,
0.16321782767772675,
-0.13519695401191711,
-0.3969244360923767,
-0.5949092507362366,
-0.6259572505950928,
-0.12935519218444824,
0.28575149178504944,
-0.04185523837804794,
0.06948168575763702,
0.1736982762813568,
0.45622915029525757,
-0.3336681127548218,
-0.14770178496837616,
-0.6545221209526062,
-0.08034620434045792,
0.550581693649292,
0.3483428359031677,
0.3403239846229553,
-0.2778080999851227,
-0.16475175321102142,
-0.30604082345962524,
-0.5916196703910828,
0.019931092858314514,
0.6210810542106628,
0.5477796196937561,
-0.23737561702728271,
0.3792887032032013,
-0.12586461007595062,
0.5812552571296692,
-0.004279727581888437,
-0.1292887181043625,
0.492773175239563,
-0.4767894744873047,
0.06778404116630554,
-0.06194340065121651,
0.9409587979316711,
0.47671326994895935,
0.4811057150363922,
-0.15032003819942474,
0.04075394198298454,
0.17164388298988342,
0.31281983852386475,
-0.5893369317054749,
-0.3980601131916046,
0.028881385922431946,
-0.41885659098625183,
-0.3012131154537201,
0.030291803181171417,
-0.9362696409225464,
-0.41258522868156433,
-0.44112497568130493,
-0.11498431116342545,
-0.48890700936317444,
-0.3546823263168335,
-0.011482092551887035,
-0.1827506721019745,
0.26299360394477844,
0.08263424783945084,
-0.9633244872093201,
0.46151432394981384,
0.51738041639328,
0.7450219988822937,
-0.17095522582530975,
-0.15131936967372894,
-0.030362512916326523,
-0.2128313034772873,
-0.44097188115119934,
0.6884022355079651,
-0.6277012825012207,
-0.879913330078125,
-0.0722617581486702,
-0.2290216088294983,
0.04030760005116463,
-0.6777904033660889,
0.6003186702728271,
-0.36527854204177856,
0.4363614022731781,
-0.4651409685611725,
-0.3928627669811249,
0.015635376796126366,
0.10740211606025696,
-0.5690244436264038,
0.8252071142196655,
0.19015413522720337,
-0.8448135256767273,
0.2905794680118561,
-0.6930949091911316,
-0.44121479988098145,
0.16930218040943146,
-0.6331863403320312,
-0.44196459650993347,
0.26521170139312744,
0.04334162920713425,
0.2177462875843048,
-0.2841101586818695,
0.06311890482902527,
-0.29130393266677856,
-0.4556233882904053,
0.4573811888694763,
-0.2396114468574524,
0.8962044715881348,
0.36071380972862244,
-0.2233070582151413,
-0.027628980576992035,
-0.5568333864212036,
0.06166728585958481,
0.17748470604419708,
-0.3658492863178253,
-0.08377533406019211,
0.08913733065128326,
0.1625720113515854,
-0.029321901500225067,
-0.051793307065963745,
-0.4278755486011505,
0.004287756513804197,
-0.4037000834941864,
0.6500048041343689,
0.6490921974182129,
0.26953989267349243,
0.3052210807800293,
-0.5067538619041443,
0.3109511137008667,
0.1686771810054779,
-0.13040927052497864,
-0.4448755979537964,
-0.5720371603965759,
-0.5856978297233582,
-0.3307744860649109,
-0.13682925701141357,
0.441250741481781,
-0.19890566170215607,
0.3954879343509674,
-0.28546589612960815,
-0.22328871488571167,
-0.5643520951271057,
0.006019141525030136,
0.274350643157959,
0.4447106420993805,
0.2878046929836273,
-0.48412251472473145,
-0.4752276837825775,
-0.9213282465934753,
-0.39544418454170227,
-0.41833505034446716,
-0.506587028503418,
0.6759667992591858,
0.032875414937734604,
-0.09630889445543289,
1.1528804302215576,
-0.37460243701934814,
0.0771889016032219,
-0.06830573827028275,
0.5237410664558411,
0.07166407257318497,
0.25148722529411316,
0.3684246242046356,
-0.7977328300476074,
-0.2549724578857422,
0.0018502500606700778,
-0.48590224981307983,
-0.2574327886104584,
-0.11527549475431442,
-0.0003363019786775112,
0.08575857430696487,
0.6078866124153137,
-0.312020480632782,
0.16508671641349792,
0.26264071464538574,
-0.19965727627277374,
0.48649120330810547,
0.008251860737800598,
0.325538694858551,
-1.0956292152404785,
-0.0457400307059288,
0.2729758620262146,
0.017961379140615463,
-0.6179623603820801,
-0.32358798384666443,
-0.26569682359695435,
-0.013143563643097878,
-0.07197488844394684,
0.3370289206504822,
-0.5897681713104248,
-0.41284286975860596,
0.08687760680913925,
0.2462947964668274,
-0.14236322045326233,
0.6045958995819092,
0.07098634541034698,
0.6705777049064636,
0.33830347657203674,
-0.48242801427841187,
0.3608185946941376,
0.3847835063934326,
-0.5170069932937622,
1.0294820070266724,
-0.6360700130462646,
0.3688177168369293,
-0.17229069769382477,
0.31823286414146423,
-1.2045848369598389,
-0.30575743317604065,
0.23925581574440002,
-0.3599627912044525,
-0.016159387305378914,
-0.22482207417488098,
-0.36995330452919006,
-0.38677603006362915,
-0.1670730710029602,
0.5055361390113831,
0.7300009727478027,
-0.2879459857940674,
0.496939480304718,
0.3870684504508972,
-0.5081508755683899,
-0.0973338708281517,
-0.6599056720733643,
0.32377171516418457,
-0.575151264667511,
-0.7122833132743835,
0.2506504952907562,
-0.3193429112434387,
-0.654765248298645,
-0.39061611890792847,
0.07394322752952576,
-0.082279734313488,
-0.04293890297412872,
0.30539149045944214,
0.29525816440582275,
0.0011396599002182484,
0.04967636987566948,
-0.43062570691108704,
0.21501493453979492,
0.2601616084575653,
-0.30897194147109985,
0.721971333026886,
-0.17512141168117523,
-0.6156205534934998,
-0.7095085382461548,
0.35055339336395264,
0.3340179920196533,
0.03881528228521347,
0.0781157985329628,
0.41146528720855713,
-0.0003440661821514368,
0.12236834317445755,
-0.6080549359321594,
-0.4283295273780823,
-0.45748427510261536,
0.37507501244544983,
-0.5410966873168945,
-0.7467762231826782,
0.5723444819450378,
-0.06581713259220123,
0.031603727489709854,
-0.12277878820896149,
0.7700373530387878,
-0.2821165919303894,
0.886751115322113,
0.49509379267692566,
-0.13793854415416718,
0.8745055794715881,
0.1070915088057518,
0.3647972345352173,
-0.6791753768920898,
-0.26515865325927734,
-0.5358440279960632,
-0.1991071105003357,
-0.7488455176353455,
-0.41308608651161194,
0.33547890186309814,
-0.11180364340543747,
-0.10288672149181366,
-0.023583896458148956,
-0.39961397647857666,
0.49376267194747925,
0.5667141079902649,
0.27549219131469727,
0.2912481725215912,
0.26075872778892517,
-0.11763498932123184,
-0.14854560792446136,
-0.1700914353132248,
-0.46656179428100586,
0.893487811088562,
0.16184820234775543,
0.6316676139831543,
0.08087625354528427,
0.8375532627105713,
0.16223590075969696,
0.34644606709480286,
-0.8082525730133057,
0.5553945302963257,
0.1727072149515152,
-0.40717417001724243,
-0.13543632626533508,
-0.7530224919319153,
-1.1360056400299072,
0.22650088369846344,
0.027839547023177147,
-1.146275520324707,
-0.010208976455032825,
0.049975160509347916,
-0.229600727558136,
-0.1650361865758896,
-0.6273995637893677,
0.6751748919487,
-0.12135380506515503,
-0.0037911843974143267,
-0.21237079799175262,
-0.7765434384346008,
0.3595464825630188,
0.018476618453860283,
0.335114061832428,
-0.18840238451957703,
0.27933308482170105,
0.6750815510749817,
-0.08877930790185928,
0.9890503287315369,
0.020028335973620415,
-0.3235507309436798,
0.5618483424186707,
0.04844772070646286,
0.2912023365497589,
-0.13971686363220215,
-0.01868491992354393,
0.13934379816055298,
-0.07413174211978912,
-0.41160765290260315,
-0.493100106716156,
0.512373685836792,
-0.7262824177742004,
-0.36825087666511536,
-0.08610739558935165,
-0.6953588128089905,
-0.4439125955104828,
-0.014399167150259018,
0.2670649588108063,
0.4080520570278168,
-0.5849736332893372,
-0.2476794719696045,
0.30487364530563354,
-0.12286464869976044,
0.3740525543689728,
0.36608198285102844,
-0.08134641498327255,
-0.2750549614429474,
0.8356881737709045,
-0.2557563781738281,
0.4155615568161011,
0.1757473200559616,
0.2984018623828888,
-0.37976521253585815,
-0.36221715807914734,
-0.1427413821220398,
0.2592281401157379,
-0.6243776679039001,
0.293334424495697,
-0.5756314396858215,
0.08119021356105804,
-0.28856223821640015,
-0.11677635461091995,
0.021386919543147087,
-0.19395068287849426,
-0.17122040688991547,
-0.0015385843580588698,
0.3202473819255829,
0.9378663897514343,
0.05794702470302582,
0.34956327080726624,
-0.5921983122825623,
0.20653925836086273,
0.3034246563911438,
0.05465089902281761,
-0.12276311218738556,
-0.46723875403404236,
0.27372246980667114,
0.2867678701877594,
-0.20924031734466553,
-1.0880577564239502,
0.45483526587486267,
0.10841070115566254,
0.4509723484516144,
0.4460257291793823,
-0.21882449090480804,
0.671697735786438,
-0.3640464246273041,
0.8347787857055664,
0.4845416843891144,
-0.8845952153205872,
0.3768678605556488,
-0.5854127407073975,
0.11720641702413559,
0.6306541562080383,
0.12439287453889847,
-0.8995153903961182,
-0.44555187225341797,
-0.5813648104667664,
-0.7752809524536133,
0.5934845805168152,
0.28702104091644287,
0.2941516637802124,
-0.19459529221057892,
0.16243183612823486,
-0.1866982877254486,
0.13380926847457886,
-0.49582934379577637,
0.0007994441548362374,
-0.1815226674079895,
-0.5682098865509033,
-0.04620426520705223,
-0.05575425550341606,
-0.6004080772399902,
0.06549497693777084,
0.03058197721838951,
-0.38546472787857056,
0.34935808181762695,
-0.005670145153999329,
-0.08694345504045486,
0.03604598715901375,
0.3814632296562195,
0.5321771502494812,
0.4642532467842102,
-0.198807030916214,
0.24924112856388092,
0.2401275634765625,
-0.4278112053871155,
0.02677939645946026,
-0.027076011523604393,
0.1715822070837021,
-0.14270827174186707,
0.30344438552856445,
0.5692843198776245,
0.25039947032928467,
-0.5983086824417114,
0.49498769640922546,
-0.22665902972221375,
-0.08429364114999771,
-0.22008974850177765,
-0.12644727528095245,
0.46199777722358704,
0.2595175802707672,
0.3165079355239868,
0.08646589517593384,
0.251717746257782,
-0.8190128207206726,
0.22071266174316406,
0.5310399532318115,
-0.3339426815509796,
-0.40745747089385986,
0.21383176743984222,
0.48000088334083557,
-0.482784241437912,
0.8000112175941467,
-0.3310159742832184,
-0.400703489780426,
0.6328837871551514,
0.4214059114456177,
0.8869486451148987,
0.01740560121834278,
0.07867559045553207,
0.26743996143341064,
-0.07356803119182587,
-0.18437424302101135,
0.326315313577652,
-0.3546602427959442,
-0.8326826691627502,
-0.20687387883663177,
-0.57168048620224,
-0.530910313129425,
-0.09325443208217621,
-0.7475093603134155,
0.21534797549247742,
-0.28103283047676086,
-0.1445998102426529,
0.13740850985050201,
-0.022880438715219498,
-0.6417394280433655,
-0.115903839468956,
0.4222630560398102,
0.4108239412307739,
-0.8303229212760925,
0.4156661927700043,
0.45241665840148926,
-0.43111124634742737,
-0.6765410900115967,
0.36078596115112305,
0.33590200543403625,
-0.850167453289032,
0.6518127918243408,
0.2410377711057663,
-0.31615951657295227,
-0.01668948493897915,
-0.5794013142585754,
-0.436341792345047,
1.0148959159851074,
0.24933594465255737,
-0.794965922832489,
0.027501100674271584,
0.3067767918109894,
0.5619499087333679,
-0.34154248237609863,
0.4393419325351715,
0.9002360105514526,
0.41852137446403503,
0.29676148295402527,
-0.9220485687255859,
-0.044017329812049866,
-0.24416758120059967,
0.14022356271743774,
0.008152376860380173,
-0.539080023765564,
0.8372631072998047,
-0.2609182298183441,
-0.6571521759033203,
0.16230234503746033,
0.5699720978736877,
0.4775543808937073,
0.2285921424627304,
0.7230868339538574,
0.39149025082588196,
1.0620230436325073,
-0.17598788440227509,
0.8077173829078674,
-0.505323052406311,
0.3383829891681671,
0.976911187171936,
-0.35222190618515015,
0.5428667664527893,
0.4159209430217743,
-0.5061004757881165,
0.48867174983024597,
0.6621878147125244,
-0.000828151882160455,
0.2682947814464569,
0.6837447285652161,
-0.6169695854187012,
0.005397439934313297,
0.04173912853002548,
-0.10360430181026459,
0.45379331707954407,
0.3680877387523651,
-0.1363644152879715,
-0.09366713464260101,
-0.19643422961235046,
0.061562247574329376,
-0.05197246000170708,
0.01325057353824377,
0.8809848427772522,
0.15061062574386597,
-0.7139779329299927,
0.4527714252471924,
-0.36681389808654785,
0.83758944272995,
-0.2855960726737976,
-0.04532497748732567,
-0.38319164514541626,
0.004474116023629904,
-0.2121119350194931,
-0.7548527121543884,
0.14354325830936432,
-0.03817066550254822,
-0.08915704488754272,
-0.11665280908346176,
0.2950589656829834,
-0.6054664254188538,
-0.44527170062065125,
0.15947268903255463,
0.41279011964797974,
0.5114866495132446,
-0.06500202417373657,
-0.5092557072639465,
0.17533603310585022,
0.13177627325057983,
-0.11865770816802979,
0.043569739907979965,
0.481044203042984,
-0.12521962821483612,
0.5782855153083801,
0.625359296798706,
-0.016965709626674652,
0.20647399127483368,
0.5831037759780884,
0.8853661417961121,
-0.9064479470252991,
-0.5777289867401123,
-0.8580283522605896,
0.20063136518001556,
-0.23275242745876312,
-0.26445919275283813,
0.4404469430446625,
0.4107547104358673,
0.6362699866294861,
0.24752768874168396,
0.9921125173568726,
0.01671156845986843,
0.4032416343688965,
-0.5207887887954712,
0.20661941170692444,
-0.1351364254951477,
0.3916913568973541,
-0.33478084206581116,
-0.9020001888275146,
-0.09070856869220734,
0.8018230199813843,
-0.26783987879753113,
0.3740712106227875,
0.6586998105049133,
1.0021791458129883,
-0.03147848695516586,
0.40350377559661865,
0.15339988470077515,
0.07408881932497025,
0.5347344279289246,
0.47363173961639404,
1.1076523065567017,
0.2165743112564087,
0.7005463242530823,
0.012759149074554443,
-0.25778627395629883,
-0.39220020174980164,
-0.6908190250396729,
-0.810799777507782,
-0.6676390171051025,
-0.15269102156162262,
-0.2981978952884674,
-0.0041005732491612434,
0.96259605884552,
0.784942626953125,
-0.5203989744186401,
-0.45818737149238586,
-0.2911399006843567,
-0.31418463587760925,
-0.20148076117038727,
-0.26576903462409973,
-0.012298236601054668,
-0.4947512149810791,
-0.9277224540710449,
0.49448561668395996,
0.14275382459163666,
0.16354414820671082,
-0.35898762941360474,
-0.058459553867578506,
0.27281925082206726,
0.31130141019821167,
0.3452352285385132,
0.27789175510406494,
-0.7556557059288025,
-0.13002972304821014,
-0.14959698915481567,
-0.3082793056964874,
0.3879312574863434,
1.2653580904006958,
-0.6180925965309143,
0.3863302767276764,
0.44657278060913086,
0.35153740644454956,
0.6251717805862427,
0.2023114114999771,
0.6156061291694641,
-1.0310204029083252,
0.1075805202126503,
0.4075453579425812,
0.22648130357265472,
0.8325881958007812,
-0.10755552351474762,
0.44428715109825134,
0.2443738728761673,
-0.44062960147857666,
-0.6864172220230103,
0.5114686489105225,
-1.244794249534607,
-0.18887008726596832,
1.1359496116638184,
-0.03646911680698395,
-0.047781992703676224,
-0.20231959223747253,
-0.42044106125831604,
0.11604999750852585,
-0.5411688089370728,
1.0086445808410645,
0.723063051700592,
-0.4783439636230469,
-0.20523624122142792,
-0.5043366551399231,
0.527250349521637,
0.4100087285041809,
-1.053635597229004,
0.223087877035141,
0.6204332113265991,
0.38720250129699707,
0.4955638349056244,
0.9402970671653748,
-0.09285105019807816,
-0.15328693389892578,
0.1292973756790161,
0.16861632466316223,
0.33260777592658997,
-0.004584616981446743,
-0.24920670688152313,
0.06831332296133041,
-0.12522372603416443,
-0.08717130869626999
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.04274v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.04274v1
|
Self-Play with Adversarial Critic: Provable and Scalable Offline Alignment for Language Models
| 2024-06-06T17:23:49 | 2024-06-06T17:23:49 |
Xiang Ji, Sanjeev Kulkarni, Mengdi Wang, Tengyang Xie
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
This work studies the challenge of aligning large language models (LLMs) with
offline preference data. We focus on alignment by Reinforcement Learning from
Human Feedback (RLHF) in particular. While popular preference optimization
methods exhibit good empirical performance in practice, they are not
theoretically guaranteed to converge to the optimal policy and can provably
fail when the data coverage is sparse by classical offline reinforcement
learning (RL) results. On the other hand, a recent line of work has focused on
theoretically motivated preference optimization methods with provable
guarantees, but these are not computationally efficient for large-scale
applications like LLM alignment. To bridge this gap, we propose SPAC, a new
offline preference optimization method with self-play, inspired by the
on-average pessimism technique from the offline RL literature, to be the first
provable and scalable approach to LLM alignment. We both provide theoretical
analysis for its convergence under single-policy concentrability for the
general function approximation setting and demonstrate its competitive
empirical performance for LLM alignment on a 7B Mistral model with Open LLM
Leaderboard evaluations.
|
[
-0.492304265499115,
-0.7845221161842346,
0.3743895888328552,
0.0179000124335289,
0.19310075044631958,
0.04130108654499054,
-0.5804190039634705,
0.09109760820865631,
0.37688806653022766,
0.5893348455429077,
-0.8126166462898254,
-0.11587227135896683,
-0.29314321279525757,
-0.1321214884519577,
-0.1956917643547058,
1.1716116666793823,
0.026841018348932266,
-0.0372994989156723,
-0.2075509876012802,
-0.36228469014167786,
-0.2030188888311386,
-0.46299874782562256,
-0.6308153867721558,
-0.31203150749206543,
0.35904809832572937,
0.47893404960632324,
1.0032861232757568,
0.7752138376235962,
0.32516440749168396,
0.43611493706703186,
0.12525628507137299,
0.3911953568458557,
-0.7582794427871704,
0.14842571318149567,
-0.194385826587677,
-0.2994968593120575,
-0.5234531760215759,
-0.012972118332982063,
0.7466894388198853,
0.23179292678833008,
-0.5976775288581848,
-0.24070844054222107,
0.10238812118768692,
0.7835449576377869,
-0.4429638385772705,
-0.1751263588666916,
-0.542243242263794,
0.00008459917444270104,
-0.10472377389669418,
-0.2044263780117035,
-0.473338782787323,
-0.648468017578125,
0.35609737038612366,
-0.7361379265785217,
-0.0680493637919426,
0.127137690782547,
0.7884157299995422,
0.49345070123672485,
-0.1007625013589859,
-0.3144524097442627,
-0.6833510994911194,
0.7529324889183044,
-0.757510781288147,
0.09273462742567062,
0.3186306953430176,
0.4561521112918854,
-0.42860597372055054,
-0.1844692975282669,
-0.5058121085166931,
-0.34154027700424194,
0.19322893023490906,
0.049816351383924484,
-0.18908190727233887,
0.08049742877483368,
-0.0580214187502861,
0.26099666953086853,
-0.701930582523346,
0.18965503573417664,
0.17417864501476288,
0.045733556151390076,
0.6529285907745361,
0.07652690261602402,
0.1524752676486969,
0.3984420895576477,
-0.37904655933380127,
-0.02208402194082737,
-0.7800151705741882,
0.2105017751455307,
0.7564980387687683,
0.3460136950016022,
0.05288534238934517,
0.41460981965065,
0.10804653912782669,
0.937353253364563,
0.5461843013763428,
-0.08689474314451218,
-0.052851103246212006,
-0.10892660915851593,
0.27759334444999695,
0.2753325402736664,
0.9036134481430054,
0.3981598913669586,
0.19294771552085876,
-0.279340922832489,
-0.1689048409461975,
-0.09028562903404236,
0.6030656695365906,
-0.22415603697299957,
-0.2267344743013382,
0.1256161779165268,
-0.12856721878051758,
-0.40841737389564514,
-0.04019339755177498,
-0.873234748840332,
-0.5989851355552673,
-0.30585840344429016,
0.5652892589569092,
0.023352354764938354,
-0.2670283615589142,
-0.07685817033052444,
0.49729740619659424,
-0.08539503812789917,
0.1676901876926422,
-1.0783772468566895,
0.45666468143463135,
0.5659558773040771,
0.8146282434463501,
-0.3841249346733093,
-0.49501731991767883,
-0.5535839200019836,
-0.1010759100317955,
-0.5709031224250793,
0.7473312020301819,
-0.15407951176166534,
-0.24813665449619293,
0.07250463217496872,
0.031085336580872536,
-0.019675105810165405,
-0.42389771342277527,
0.3833932876586914,
-0.5578935742378235,
0.2684282064437866,
-0.10448665916919708,
-0.6111127138137817,
0.10774872452020645,
0.38503095507621765,
-0.6847192049026489,
1.1300679445266724,
0.22552870213985443,
-0.7641570568084717,
0.09984660148620605,
-0.49346160888671875,
-0.2820512056350708,
-0.322338730096817,
-0.14149890840053558,
-0.785186231136322,
-0.09758040308952332,
-0.03849104419350624,
0.16067583858966827,
-0.13611657917499542,
0.4064009189605713,
-0.8067959547042847,
-0.5306124687194824,
0.5431019067764282,
-0.20642797648906708,
0.2940509617328644,
0.15502439439296722,
-0.7597201466560364,
0.43193820118904114,
-0.44433677196502686,
0.16505010426044464,
0.09909386187791824,
-0.23016218841075897,
0.010658657178282738,
0.37587282061576843,
-0.1912367343902588,
0.40652209520339966,
0.21420298516750336,
-0.4039723873138428,
0.5265926122665405,
-0.6454768180847168,
0.518790602684021,
0.9316344857215881,
-0.43186846375465393,
0.707431435585022,
-0.22087465226650238,
0.5514499545097351,
-0.5878552198410034,
0.21750694513320923,
0.2941863238811493,
-0.06819046288728714,
-0.6228052973747253,
-0.27817878127098083,
0.4061020314693451,
0.2912374436855316,
-0.5366766452789307,
0.6887643337249756,
-0.19381065666675568,
-0.4427635669708252,
-0.6743282675743103,
0.09240416437387466,
0.6958191394805908,
0.36646220088005066,
0.3832770586013794,
-0.047288794070482254,
-0.7410072684288025,
-0.7990232110023499,
-0.23781488835811615,
-0.2068217247724533,
0.5675621628761292,
0.5940170288085938,
-0.14429731667041779,
-0.11662109196186066,
1.2331112623214722,
-0.6334640979766846,
-0.4624793529510498,
-0.46260932087898254,
0.07149115204811096,
0.12199003249406815,
0.2694805860519409,
0.43006476759910583,
-0.4521285593509674,
-0.6915884017944336,
0.03213711827993393,
-0.31749093532562256,
-0.22147375345230103,
0.004989756271243095,
-0.11185545474290848,
0.597154438495636,
0.2846231460571289,
-0.2046942263841629,
0.19387325644493103,
1.011968731880188,
-0.2908409535884857,
0.34116581082344055,
-0.670779824256897,
0.2818909287452698,
-0.8321520090103149,
-0.005790411960333586,
0.027590451762080193,
-0.5840218663215637,
-0.6756169199943542,
-0.22410064935684204,
-0.1336987465620041,
0.12393047660589218,
-0.41133418679237366,
0.5556237101554871,
-0.32668864727020264,
-0.19529809057712555,
-0.6899501085281372,
0.3771965503692627,
-0.26727575063705444,
0.5128693580627441,
0.27511096000671387,
0.789009690284729,
0.4059259295463562,
-0.5312755107879639,
0.34209370613098145,
0.07069938629865646,
-0.1534205973148346,
0.24248702824115753,
-0.4145934283733368,
0.016136398538947105,
0.10654670745134354,
0.4322001338005066,
-0.9551223516464233,
0.004770358558744192,
0.21719709038734436,
-0.3337220251560211,
0.49436071515083313,
-0.1212775781750679,
-0.041222576051950455,
-0.03257419541478157,
-0.19006502628326416,
0.29311099648475647,
0.4104999601840973,
-0.809517502784729,
0.4306960701942444,
0.7948178052902222,
0.031221188604831696,
-0.81857830286026,
-0.4047432541847229,
-0.18158605694770813,
-0.32150349020957947,
-0.34770676493644714,
0.3567504584789276,
-0.08737249672412872,
-0.0723249688744545,
-0.11244578659534454,
0.09416510164737701,
0.19333258271217346,
0.10759822279214859,
0.23901447653770447,
0.4477086067199707,
-0.0625130757689476,
-0.32255956530570984,
-0.38135799765586853,
-0.2418186217546463,
-0.25749891996383667,
-0.2899439334869385,
0.4988873600959778,
-0.39221587777137756,
-0.25008976459503174,
-0.10100273042917252,
0.1749468743801117,
0.2462097853422165,
0.11374776810407639,
0.5371410846710205,
0.1937331259250641,
-0.1694747358560562,
-0.3074263632297516,
-0.5927173495292664,
0.04193062707781792,
-0.43925637006759644,
0.39552339911460876,
-0.14691796898841858,
-1.0208293199539185,
0.33502835035324097,
0.08772075921297073,
-0.04324400797486305,
0.3533213138580322,
0.8155753016471863,
-0.1629960983991623,
1.3405365943908691,
0.44764816761016846,
-0.21763856709003448,
0.4026348888874054,
-0.18416285514831543,
0.161183163523674,
-0.5200271606445312,
-0.038385841995477676,
-0.41827619075775146,
-0.33971837162971497,
-0.7640124559402466,
-0.19489307701587677,
0.25046759843826294,
0.17953434586524963,
-0.3631553053855896,
0.6544369459152222,
-0.4915093183517456,
0.5860649347305298,
0.34335795044898987,
0.015200406312942505,
-0.021409478038549423,
-0.3260587453842163,
-0.19837485253810883,
-0.21216952800750732,
-0.7454166412353516,
-0.28986456990242004,
0.9951949715614319,
0.3234129846096039,
0.9756240844726562,
0.43734896183013916,
0.6667826175689697,
0.3603956401348114,
0.39824923872947693,
-0.5326122641563416,
0.3432154357433319,
-0.20997828245162964,
-0.701554536819458,
-0.6594650745391846,
-0.5023887157440186,
-0.7294506430625916,
0.21995246410369873,
-0.32830488681793213,
-0.8200609087944031,
-0.06007346510887146,
0.6436619758605957,
-0.5850120782852173,
0.3763352334499359,
-0.4546744227409363,
1.0557289123535156,
-0.598795473575592,
-0.5970467329025269,
-0.08571016043424606,
-0.6436179280281067,
0.3270200788974762,
-0.05624670907855034,
0.3428861200809479,
0.05650307238101959,
0.00028414090047590435,
0.5658906698226929,
-0.391562283039093,
0.5804712772369385,
-0.1862049698829651,
-0.08934102207422256,
0.28937116265296936,
0.25400859117507935,
0.7006098628044128,
-0.09003721177577972,
0.18805783987045288,
-0.11347967386245728,
0.14419682323932648,
-0.1985238790512085,
-0.8364772200584412,
1.132472038269043,
-1.056304931640625,
-0.6360312700271606,
-0.7164021134376526,
-0.27306032180786133,
-0.42117172479629517,
0.009575633332133293,
0.2114216834306717,
0.23203708231449127,
-0.4570664167404175,
0.09378339350223541,
0.6706422567367554,
0.09822352230548859,
0.46025246381759644,
0.5619452595710754,
-0.3664722144603729,
-0.7324138283729553,
1.2361259460449219,
0.18603213131427765,
0.16072630882263184,
0.2646007835865021,
0.3626689314842224,
-0.8330262303352356,
-0.21999746561050415,
-0.7264125943183899,
0.031442899256944656,
-0.44536200165748596,
0.01489314716309309,
-0.4676756262779236,
0.009337879717350006,
-0.27720192074775696,
-0.3508509695529938,
-0.8097447752952576,
-0.4196628928184509,
-0.2768750488758087,
0.25286054611206055,
-0.0755041241645813,
0.7899807095527649,
-0.2085091769695282,
0.24431483447551727,
-0.4925619959831238,
-0.14527711272239685,
0.06970085203647614,
0.4251098930835724,
-0.09558581560850143,
-0.6680803894996643,
-0.38992950320243835,
-0.1941017210483551,
-0.4074908494949341,
-0.8110606074333191,
0.3843410015106201,
0.14655405282974243,
0.5702981948852539,
0.7678478360176086,
0.11816062033176422,
0.6258612871170044,
-0.5595315098762512,
0.5517803430557251,
0.30617594718933105,
-0.8143479824066162,
0.17888592183589935,
-0.2473618984222412,
-0.07347916066646576,
0.7079976797103882,
0.35481926798820496,
-0.4787168800830841,
0.04155388101935387,
-0.6227837800979614,
-0.6146884560585022,
0.9482400417327881,
-0.13066509366035461,
-0.2728028893470764,
0.0914062038064003,
0.28221285343170166,
0.11588986217975616,
0.06075112521648407,
-0.5520983934402466,
-0.3240530490875244,
-0.37092745304107666,
-0.21372827887535095,
-0.51814204454422,
-0.04399346560239792,
-0.1969459354877472,
0.18397502601146698,
1.0563685894012451,
-0.5001237988471985,
0.031365055590867996,
-0.05300906300544739,
0.05219443887472153,
-0.17786677181720734,
0.3064155578613281,
0.8406853079795837,
0.4399939477443695,
-0.15514330565929413,
0.22560518980026245,
0.201492577791214,
0.13486936688423157,
0.5098009705543518,
-0.09680414944887161,
-0.2251611053943634,
-0.42582687735557556,
-0.032947272062301636,
0.7320724725723267,
0.517511248588562,
-0.6070907711982727,
0.7565637230873108,
-0.1201314926147461,
-0.2230217158794403,
-0.35730427503585815,
0.0405379943549633,
0.060872938483953476,
0.199587881565094,
-0.22714835405349731,
-0.0020997815299779177,
-0.006294001825153828,
-0.41980332136154175,
0.31335023045539856,
0.6582713723182678,
-0.8389429450035095,
-0.2853839099407196,
0.5927443504333496,
0.02707543969154358,
-0.29924264550209045,
0.2535659074783325,
-0.2208191603422165,
-0.7886805534362793,
0.3021954596042633,
0.6386587023735046,
0.7978963255882263,
-0.1382392793893814,
0.30587244033813477,
0.2943440079689026,
-0.06997284293174744,
-0.62691330909729,
-0.007931315340101719,
-0.03739410638809204,
-0.7233248353004456,
-0.346524178981781,
-0.2817341983318329,
-0.5572764277458191,
-0.18194887042045593,
-0.5102542638778687,
0.25252848863601685,
-0.48038846254348755,
-0.4278668165206909,
-0.3971741199493408,
0.17946875095367432,
-0.120228610932827,
0.09100142121315002,
0.02793852984905243,
0.4203833043575287,
-0.7155877947807312,
0.9223225116729736,
0.437247633934021,
-0.2576361894607544,
-0.835699737071991,
-0.07482462376356125,
0.3080047369003296,
-0.6959197521209717,
0.3825943171977997,
-0.14912821352481842,
-0.3236891031265259,
0.1791563630104065,
-0.2769411504268646,
-1.0155001878738403,
0.7998533844947815,
0.40627768635749817,
-0.5671492218971252,
-0.09590715169906616,
-0.011354958638548851,
0.530846118927002,
-0.5073325634002686,
0.6491628289222717,
0.5520903468132019,
0.45234596729278564,
0.12024141848087311,
-0.6728109121322632,
-0.09353060275316238,
0.06854777783155441,
-0.05669470503926277,
0.3701167702674866,
-1.0442140102386475,
0.4124477505683899,
-0.22342509031295776,
0.020952574908733368,
0.08000998944044113,
0.6963486075401306,
0.23826611042022705,
-0.0671335831284523,
0.6880264282226562,
0.8834447264671326,
0.33704474568367004,
-0.22377891838550568,
0.7816121578216553,
-0.40603166818618774,
0.6589165925979614,
1.2818299531936646,
-0.4143865406513214,
0.8654037117958069,
0.4168079197406769,
-0.31716638803482056,
0.2838597595691681,
0.8717670440673828,
0.039614222943782806,
0.771892249584198,
0.4679873585700989,
-0.042514998465776443,
-0.4485603868961334,
-0.08971324563026428,
-0.2714425027370453,
0.20010176301002502,
-0.18810923397541046,
0.010763796977698803,
-0.15454848110675812,
-0.4295993745326996,
0.009444407187402248,
0.3343507945537567,
-0.25729435682296753,
0.9438361525535583,
-0.2250392735004425,
-1.2919636964797974,
0.43068912625312805,
0.11094579100608826,
0.7077639698982239,
-0.6399239897727966,
0.07187636196613312,
-0.1953575760126114,
0.6220300197601318,
-0.3228672444820404,
-0.7171703577041626,
0.17170403897762299,
-0.20511813461780548,
-0.09174773097038269,
-0.06932754069566727,
0.44928914308547974,
-0.6827478408813477,
0.006737506482750177,
0.3806714117527008,
0.12144453823566437,
0.030066801235079765,
0.1673930436372757,
-0.8843583464622498,
-0.04597415775060654,
0.0006489547085948288,
-0.43434080481529236,
0.7985531687736511,
0.03482638671994209,
-0.06506041437387466,
0.7857981324195862,
0.5333806872367859,
0.25297796726226807,
0.08872302621603012,
-0.12550215423107147,
0.7080681920051575,
-0.27891311049461365,
-0.7407094240188599,
-0.8356876969337463,
0.2320384979248047,
0.11768258363008499,
-0.3769421875476837,
0.6180291175842285,
0.5616496801376343,
0.8741346597671509,
0.1193588450551033,
0.6752147674560547,
0.07821834087371826,
0.5139718055725098,
-0.43343815207481384,
0.7124267816543579,
-0.5985900163650513,
0.050258882343769073,
-0.11145615577697754,
-0.8337625861167908,
-0.0365048386156559,
0.5690209269523621,
-0.230210542678833,
0.012495859526097775,
0.6426555514335632,
0.9870991706848145,
0.15939268469810486,
-0.02613888494670391,
0.502254068851471,
-0.17158113420009613,
0.1057746559381485,
0.49741071462631226,
0.8370855450630188,
-0.10015201568603516,
0.6041325330734253,
-0.1533447802066803,
-0.46458813548088074,
-0.1923573762178421,
-0.963046133518219,
-0.8009442687034607,
-0.5625516176223755,
-0.2414359748363495,
-0.9241651892662048,
0.1869419515132904,
1.3631948232650757,
0.653479814529419,
-0.9358165860176086,
-0.3537890911102295,
-0.05501255765557289,
-0.06304465979337692,
-0.34386369585990906,
-0.1869034320116043,
0.507247269153595,
-0.32379961013793945,
-0.5616325736045837,
0.5953767895698547,
0.2987876534461975,
-0.202845498919487,
-0.777942955493927,
-0.7877660989761353,
-0.39067399501800537,
0.2347843050956726,
-0.10187695920467377,
0.7517990469932556,
-0.8342092037200928,
-0.11153899878263474,
0.0570499561727047,
-0.33398669958114624,
0.1843980997800827,
1.023256778717041,
-0.38908588886260986,
0.6341252326965332,
0.45046842098236084,
0.9734667539596558,
0.3466513454914093,
0.2714161276817322,
0.6274418234825134,
-0.4207552373409271,
-0.2880712151527405,
-0.019061267375946045,
0.33989912271499634,
0.19330425560474396,
-0.2745676338672638,
0.3315400779247284,
0.13204564154148102,
-0.9956492185592651,
-0.6726314425468445,
0.13505208492279053,
-0.650620698928833,
-0.0225830078125,
1.1983153820037842,
-0.5137059092521667,
-0.28551825881004333,
0.07302869111299515,
-0.21410243213176727,
0.26407358050346375,
-0.47713565826416016,
0.8747377395629883,
0.8021702766418457,
-0.25796324014663696,
-0.03572985157370567,
-0.10212712734937668,
0.8685498237609863,
0.6181210279464722,
-0.6075917482376099,
0.2114180028438568,
0.3112567961215973,
0.16434945166110992,
-0.05012739822268486,
0.7953241467475891,
-0.06019950658082962,
0.14418397843837738,
-0.3198700249195099,
0.17330850660800934,
-0.06513533741235733,
-0.45275503396987915,
-0.6130533218383789,
0.059296321123838425,
0.2882375717163086,
0.09058085083961487
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.04271v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.04271v1
|
Buffer of Thoughts: Thought-Augmented Reasoning with Large Language Models
| 2024-06-06T17:22:08 | 2024-06-06T17:22:08 |
Ling Yang, Zhaochen Yu, Tianjun Zhang, Shiyi Cao, Minkai Xu, Wentao Zhang, Joseph E. Gonzalez, Bin Cui
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We introduce Buffer of Thoughts (BoT), a novel and versatile
thought-augmented reasoning approach for enhancing accuracy, efficiency and
robustness of large language models (LLMs). Specifically, we propose
meta-buffer to store a series of informative high-level thoughts, namely
thought-template, distilled from the problem-solving processes across various
tasks. Then for each problem, we retrieve a relevant thought-template and
adaptively instantiate it with specific reasoning structures to conduct
efficient reasoning. To guarantee the scalability and stability, we further
propose buffer-manager to dynamically update the meta-buffer, thus enhancing
the capacity of meta-buffer as more tasks are solved. We conduct extensive
experiments on 10 challenging reasoning-intensive tasks, and achieve
significant performance improvements over previous SOTA methods: 11% on Game of
24, 20% on Geometric Shapes and 51% on Checkmate-in-One. Further analysis
demonstrate the superior generalization ability and model robustness of our
BoT, while requiring only 12% of the cost of multi-query prompting methods
(e.g., tree/graph of thoughts) on average. Notably, we find that our
Llama3-8B+BoT has the potential to surpass Llama3-70B model. Our project is
available at: https://github.com/YangLing0818/buffer-of-thought-llm
|
[
-0.6337893009185791,
-1.237202763557434,
0.884219229221344,
0.16113926470279694,
-0.0027884712908416986,
0.2624778747558594,
-0.2523074448108673,
-0.4039228558540344,
0.5208804607391357,
0.7602880001068115,
-0.3879362940788269,
-0.13109929859638214,
-0.34120506048202515,
-0.06011160463094711,
-0.29532644152641296,
0.6827654838562012,
0.11546527594327927,
-0.02295195870101452,
-0.01918424852192402,
-0.10289172828197479,
-0.5901513695716858,
-0.5075655579566956,
-0.5227048397064209,
-0.1871422976255417,
0.48661550879478455,
0.3984762132167816,
0.48988664150238037,
0.36445003747940063,
0.5325966477394104,
0.34542790055274963,
-0.1056525707244873,
0.4406146705150604,
-0.520254909992218,
0.39801260828971863,
-0.5717954039573669,
-0.5842838287353516,
-1.0516242980957031,
-0.30241551995277405,
0.6443487405776978,
0.4897633492946625,
-0.2460440844297409,
0.347145140171051,
-0.06872262805700302,
0.87222820520401,
-0.9209537506103516,
0.135740727186203,
-0.8702847361564636,
-0.025155961513519287,
-0.26831531524658203,
-0.12343516200780869,
-0.5746010541915894,
-0.06816757470369339,
0.1323060244321823,
-0.5790760517120361,
-0.28304731845855713,
0.24277760088443756,
0.3993120789527893,
0.5898789763450623,
0.007632611785084009,
-0.000225095049245283,
-0.7612898945808411,
0.6047609448432922,
-0.6135618686676025,
0.4423459470272064,
0.008296851068735123,
0.3810175657272339,
-0.40821927785873413,
-0.5657534003257751,
-0.903900146484375,
0.17794673144817352,
0.33376604318618774,
0.3233610987663269,
-0.23306559026241302,
0.21805298328399658,
0.6749883890151978,
0.2316756695508957,
-0.3623221814632416,
-0.31491589546203613,
0.08699890226125717,
0.011998251080513,
0.6072092056274414,
0.2556252181529999,
0.17117956280708313,
0.04283267259597778,
-0.2914239168167114,
0.02706727385520935,
-0.7140353918075562,
0.02178458869457245,
0.2626267075538635,
0.03263403847813606,
0.31293123960494995,
0.5180068612098694,
-0.283197283744812,
0.7412754893302917,
0.1291757971048355,
0.017825117334723473,
0.06550364941358566,
-0.187891885638237,
-0.2929757833480835,
-0.19042477011680603,
0.9006834626197815,
0.24666666984558105,
0.2222868651151657,
0.15823397040367126,
-0.24176914989948273,
0.07735666632652283,
0.37434807419776917,
-0.6809112429618835,
-0.4287301003932953,
0.33126795291900635,
-0.1592479795217514,
-0.14093585312366486,
-0.3014889657497406,
-0.988240659236908,
-0.505801260471344,
0.06692780554294586,
0.39927104115486145,
-0.38059237599372864,
-0.426361620426178,
0.6672995090484619,
-0.041771311312913895,
-0.11327984929084778,
0.5510576367378235,
-0.8893157839775085,
0.33149558305740356,
0.5394026637077332,
0.445913702249527,
-0.10300013422966003,
-0.09674143046140671,
-0.5160791277885437,
0.3683462142944336,
-0.42495089769363403,
1.0283492803573608,
-0.7026928663253784,
-0.12376479059457779,
-0.2739253640174866,
-0.3144361674785614,
0.1482686698436737,
-0.5615336894989014,
0.4305008053779602,
-0.564568817615509,
0.10085741430521011,
-0.4435107409954071,
-0.6227322816848755,
-0.2770293056964874,
0.5908308625221252,
-0.8750335574150085,
1.1838929653167725,
-0.13333477079868317,
-0.8721140623092651,
0.09193684905767441,
-0.9583953022956848,
-0.19087933003902435,
0.22390002012252808,
-0.002688231412321329,
-0.03084377944469452,
0.01449561771005392,
0.28206750750541687,
0.3398292660713196,
-0.3911937475204468,
0.3911561667919159,
-0.49564117193222046,
-0.3459795117378235,
0.3810965120792389,
-0.19970428943634033,
0.5842847228050232,
0.18919438123703003,
-0.30792996287345886,
0.28688308596611023,
-0.4842586815357208,
0.21799933910369873,
0.24681468307971954,
-0.31421706080436707,
-0.018515581265091896,
0.2269085943698883,
-0.32014214992523193,
0.12823790311813354,
0.17828743159770966,
-0.61515212059021,
0.42014217376708984,
-0.4155196249485016,
0.7583715915679932,
0.7377959489822388,
-0.1498878002166748,
0.30660751461982727,
-0.22706308960914612,
0.4591797888278961,
-0.047133833169937134,
0.08428843319416046,
-0.3648630380630493,
-0.3638308346271515,
-1.1593537330627441,
-0.375884085893631,
0.27548855543136597,
0.761050820350647,
-0.7547047138214111,
0.33092355728149414,
-0.2723897099494934,
-0.45066961646080017,
-0.5612128376960754,
0.029788386076688766,
0.30776968598365784,
0.6023457050323486,
0.4365721046924591,
-0.21804852783679962,
-0.7102790474891663,
-0.7559098601341248,
-0.29462510347366333,
-0.31843823194503784,
0.36363279819488525,
0.3865717053413391,
0.6105453372001648,
-0.33958888053894043,
1.0754138231277466,
-0.681751012802124,
0.20316430926322937,
-0.5656996965408325,
-0.1694888025522232,
0.350497841835022,
0.34038060903549194,
0.3554553985595703,
-0.38685446977615356,
-0.35664066672325134,
-0.32391414046287537,
-0.5513160228729248,
-0.12077013403177261,
-0.07991809397935867,
-0.581322968006134,
0.15871737897396088,
0.40247872471809387,
-1.0197936296463013,
0.20526640117168427,
0.2629010081291199,
-0.1287918984889984,
0.7020677924156189,
0.06513749063014984,
-0.01948549784719944,
-1.0599138736724854,
0.13929219543933868,
-0.2784295678138733,
-0.49501562118530273,
-0.4866578280925751,
0.12266053259372711,
0.0625201091170311,
-0.012225870974361897,
-0.32199516892433167,
0.6828536987304688,
-0.17208585143089294,
0.08540113270282745,
-0.39011693000793457,
0.2150876671075821,
0.16377606987953186,
0.6683852076530457,
0.16540583968162537,
0.7811455130577087,
0.4913569688796997,
-0.41823437809944153,
0.6365559101104736,
0.1686399281024933,
-0.4877908229827881,
0.3312675356864929,
-0.6669020056724548,
0.5208156108856201,
-0.041774675250053406,
0.6942047476768494,
-0.8684887886047363,
-0.011086249724030495,
0.313874214887619,
-0.2929404079914093,
0.15551510453224182,
0.09498875588178635,
-0.7242887616157532,
-0.43972474336624146,
-0.2695436477661133,
0.47373586893081665,
0.28453001379966736,
-0.32263174653053284,
0.6311695575714111,
0.786754846572876,
-0.23627695441246033,
-0.8233510255813599,
-0.4766789674758911,
0.18179045617580414,
-0.15575693547725677,
-0.5083383917808533,
0.20073261857032776,
-0.1636330783367157,
-0.353794127702713,
0.10459311306476593,
-0.08650482445955276,
0.06473951786756516,
0.17289073765277863,
-0.011048386804759502,
0.4299270510673523,
-0.11331482976675034,
0.3472299873828888,
-0.07098277658224106,
-0.10246551781892776,
0.2489902228116989,
-0.613527238368988,
0.771452009677887,
-0.48676690459251404,
-0.43589264154434204,
0.028566967695951462,
0.33284491300582886,
0.5009697675704956,
-0.46434012055397034,
0.4966430068016052,
0.3901756703853607,
-0.5290059447288513,
-0.3813527822494507,
-0.9342796802520752,
-0.22897231578826904,
-0.452327162027359,
0.5198022723197937,
-0.5398611426353455,
-1.0324269533157349,
0.5658697485923767,
-0.18236508965492249,
0.15839563310146332,
0.3328043222427368,
0.7609376907348633,
-0.5908997058868408,
1.0572443008422852,
0.564498782157898,
-0.21537597477436066,
0.47761234641075134,
-0.3598526418209076,
0.37954428791999817,
-1.0349457263946533,
-0.011854312382638454,
0.05016139894723892,
-0.4888156056404114,
-0.2314884513616562,
-0.7335114479064941,
0.31826531887054443,
0.07607505470514297,
-0.41513580083847046,
0.15364643931388855,
-0.4331378638744354,
0.6273269653320312,
0.48784664273262024,
0.09593582153320312,
0.22935611009597778,
-0.48362961411476135,
-0.17337985336780548,
0.19797837734222412,
-0.8454578518867493,
-0.6467165350914001,
1.1196296215057373,
0.21916641294956207,
0.7202386260032654,
0.08343135565519333,
0.4011833071708679,
0.28446707129478455,
0.222926527261734,
-0.694929301738739,
0.9199496507644653,
0.37986260652542114,
-0.9618905782699585,
-0.40315622091293335,
-0.25639981031417847,
-0.7614161968231201,
0.3580937385559082,
-0.4082786440849304,
-0.961963415145874,
-0.3410492241382599,
0.39841029047966003,
-0.6505088210105896,
0.7742394804954529,
-0.49664565920829773,
0.797904372215271,
-0.27333250641822815,
-0.6408190727233887,
-0.6169489026069641,
-0.6269820928573608,
0.4673236012458801,
0.012980394065380096,
-0.07654290646314621,
-0.04495967552065849,
0.03546791523694992,
0.6292003393173218,
-0.3064490258693695,
0.6759065985679626,
0.0471094511449337,
-0.07424937188625336,
0.7288825511932373,
0.14740556478500366,
0.6115221977233887,
0.02747420035302639,
0.1292717307806015,
-0.05352722853422165,
-0.06966874748468399,
-0.2800538241863251,
-0.8470198512077332,
0.3263075649738312,
-0.44195637106895447,
-1.143682599067688,
-0.3805474042892456,
-0.9392989873886108,
-0.3771037757396698,
0.3436460494995117,
-0.19197311997413635,
0.2764926552772522,
-0.10425185412168503,
0.10398990660905838,
1.0225605964660645,
-0.32023385167121887,
0.32186436653137207,
0.3547156751155853,
-0.5062952637672424,
-0.44657450914382935,
0.66254061460495,
0.036083102226257324,
0.23725232481956482,
0.6302791237831116,
0.14576536417007446,
-0.3178836405277252,
-0.45523306727409363,
-0.6606940031051636,
0.21083107590675354,
-0.656567394733429,
-0.1919870525598526,
-0.869986355304718,
-0.1848161369562149,
-0.1985376626253128,
0.20256637036800385,
-0.5134410858154297,
-0.5708193182945251,
0.18168041110038757,
-0.1774895042181015,
0.4173152446746826,
0.5209693312644958,
0.24129921197891235,
0.1224840059876442,
-0.7597787976264954,
0.2104269117116928,
0.29994478821754456,
0.3265834450721741,
0.11275351047515869,
-0.28782039880752563,
-0.2098824828863144,
0.08998439460992813,
-0.5603742003440857,
-1.0875705480575562,
0.22383956611156464,
-0.12887349724769592,
0.5649530291557312,
0.39215099811553955,
-0.0385168083012104,
0.8538103103637695,
-0.6678498387336731,
0.48226380348205566,
0.0749162957072258,
-1.0646015405654907,
0.6889091730117798,
-0.6026894450187683,
0.2728608250617981,
0.4008016586303711,
-0.09307387471199036,
-0.5280398726463318,
-0.40243667364120483,
-0.6968353390693665,
-0.5984815359115601,
0.4214572608470917,
-0.13794325292110443,
-0.06950968503952026,
-0.11361507326364517,
0.2997872233390808,
-0.02047649957239628,
0.27208396792411804,
-0.6463690400123596,
-0.008381921797990799,
-0.08183560520410538,
-0.14606724679470062,
0.18886272609233856,
-0.4426955580711365,
-0.08272570371627808,
-0.36784371733665466,
0.5941559076309204,
-0.3032039999961853,
0.3608802556991577,
0.03401845693588257,
-0.24517707526683807,
0.00264188926666975,
0.37291762232780457,
0.47920501232147217,
0.6238823533058167,
-0.15490534901618958,
0.401157021522522,
0.7384935617446899,
-0.4132564067840576,
0.0034473768901079893,
-0.2855605185031891,
-0.047324568033218384,
-0.3608904480934143,
0.14186471700668335,
0.6596124172210693,
0.14406445622444153,
-1.0960899591445923,
0.2688015103340149,
0.13715995848178864,
0.02064608968794346,
-0.16941705346107483,
0.27296173572540283,
0.4493252635002136,
0.5549024343490601,
-0.07990900427103043,
0.22847244143486023,
0.23392878472805023,
-0.6574087738990784,
-0.14386165142059326,
0.5531848073005676,
-0.25661370158195496,
-0.30332785844802856,
0.552247941493988,
0.4109308421611786,
-0.06951300799846649,
0.5960937142372131,
-0.3111545443534851,
-0.8428847789764404,
0.21051298081874847,
0.718238890171051,
0.9068105220794678,
0.0909503772854805,
-0.08483223617076874,
0.4142892360687256,
0.22502624988555908,
-0.17638301849365234,
0.7156690955162048,
-0.23126588761806488,
-1.0708895921707153,
-0.8100255727767944,
-0.372397243976593,
-0.5961347818374634,
0.18487313389778137,
-0.28311634063720703,
0.08717214316129684,
-0.6696598529815674,
-0.5928599238395691,
-0.33992958068847656,
0.08445410430431366,
-0.4161115288734436,
-0.1344812959432602,
0.34807154536247253,
1.1281921863555908,
-0.5136117935180664,
0.8609206080436707,
0.7568149566650391,
-0.11286231875419617,
-0.6878097057342529,
-0.26647770404815674,
-0.12370482087135315,
-0.615458607673645,
0.4914261996746063,
0.15116001665592194,
-0.5510891079902649,
-0.005917794071137905,
-0.4548611342906952,
-1.0627708435058594,
0.8940008282661438,
0.5781120657920837,
-0.7409329414367676,
0.15003351867198944,
-0.01689346507191658,
0.42276981472969055,
-0.27999672293663025,
0.37687361240386963,
0.5671885013580322,
0.4862152636051178,
-0.11750026792287827,
-0.8540579080581665,
-0.03575534746050835,
-0.5934860110282898,
-0.34058403968811035,
0.4671679735183716,
-0.9165894389152527,
0.7181490063667297,
-0.46268418431282043,
-0.19298547506332397,
-0.16577835381031036,
0.6341504454612732,
0.5391439199447632,
-0.07684371620416641,
0.5973595976829529,
1.0593230724334717,
1.0451626777648926,
-0.08999566733837128,
0.8360028862953186,
-0.36626356840133667,
0.023562295362353325,
1.1492289304733276,
-0.48458871245384216,
1.0417258739471436,
0.38492247462272644,
-0.16142763197422028,
0.6817945241928101,
0.455897718667984,
0.2249043583869934,
0.24604937434196472,
0.23493900895118713,
-0.15180501341819763,
-0.5654675960540771,
-0.07219688594341278,
-0.1963997334241867,
0.3609122335910797,
0.6236833930015564,
0.06663546711206436,
0.2696075439453125,
-0.301940381526947,
-0.007434507831931114,
-0.016151150688529015,
-0.2448958307504654,
0.6569562554359436,
-0.03989972919225693,
-0.8610081076622009,
0.3198692798614502,
-0.30957093834877014,
0.4954586923122406,
-0.27452194690704346,
-0.0477326475083828,
0.0842697024345398,
0.4260062277317047,
-0.08841928094625473,
-1.060149908065796,
0.18068790435791016,
0.3012244701385498,
-0.28308236598968506,
-0.4890493154525757,
0.8574365377426147,
-0.29178839921951294,
-0.45138370990753174,
0.07884106040000916,
0.8543881177902222,
0.12125419825315475,
-0.1660435050725937,
-0.7056017518043518,
0.06696005165576935,
-0.2063627541065216,
-0.2877417206764221,
0.07369796186685562,
0.5660319924354553,
-0.21554529666900635,
1.1157649755477905,
0.623749315738678,
0.2015845626592636,
-0.09474177658557892,
0.0314338356256485,
0.9972276091575623,
-0.7247631549835205,
-0.405495285987854,
-1.2323204278945923,
0.3717501163482666,
-0.19466572999954224,
-0.09045875817537308,
0.5692819952964783,
0.7088338136672974,
0.8320558667182922,
0.07570718228816986,
0.7643529772758484,
0.095094233751297,
0.534928023815155,
-0.4109295606613159,
0.7315297722816467,
-0.31286829710006714,
0.1487419456243515,
-0.45063725113868713,
-1.0995646715164185,
-0.08980701118707657,
0.7202792763710022,
-0.45824894309043884,
-0.20644265413284302,
0.7224926948547363,
0.6670703887939453,
0.10373692959547043,
0.1881881207227707,
-0.011188365519046783,
0.15344220399856567,
0.33147385716438293,
0.9964982867240906,
1.3010998964309692,
-0.03907172381877899,
0.42602118849754333,
0.14477971196174622,
-0.205631822347641,
-0.16446445882320404,
-0.8428367376327515,
-0.9933077096939087,
-0.413950651884079,
-0.10533078014850616,
-0.13166598975658417,
-0.0319586917757988,
0.9942936301231384,
0.7498348951339722,
-0.6775538325309753,
-0.278533011674881,
-0.14355649054050446,
0.2085740715265274,
-0.1411672830581665,
-0.15472689270973206,
0.14441214501857758,
-0.3194546103477478,
-0.6534296274185181,
0.2834545969963074,
0.6417432427406311,
-0.23611989617347717,
-0.4323078393936157,
0.12049009650945663,
-0.29256129264831543,
0.3352736532688141,
0.6187169551849365,
0.12350344657897949,
-0.8657873272895813,
-0.35743552446365356,
0.33425745368003845,
-0.12382102757692337,
0.0859377384185791,
0.6237961053848267,
-0.9654501080513,
0.7400564551353455,
0.7459558844566345,
0.7852136492729187,
0.6192217469215393,
-0.09382376074790955,
0.6377074122428894,
-0.22889167070388794,
0.1496657431125641,
0.5209845900535583,
0.7424023747444153,
0.1493113785982132,
0.009513061493635178,
0.5755431056022644,
0.09335969388484955,
-0.41092827916145325,
-0.925479531288147,
0.5655677914619446,
-0.9727948904037476,
-0.14628146588802338,
0.9780084490776062,
-0.08455751091241837,
-0.27104872465133667,
0.11860399693250656,
-0.37881705164909363,
0.18327420949935913,
-0.35923898220062256,
0.896085798740387,
0.896878182888031,
-0.33803656697273254,
-0.2379988133907318,
-0.6227750778198242,
0.4209333062171936,
0.6372490525245667,
-0.996518075466156,
0.2716132402420044,
0.4224708676338196,
0.01644001342356205,
0.2383590191602707,
0.7744936347007751,
0.003808360081166029,
0.28441694378852844,
-0.0030473372898995876,
0.2008863389492035,
-0.017779573798179626,
-0.49989375472068787,
0.28424134850502014,
-0.010829255916178226,
-0.16223402321338654,
-0.12916535139083862
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.04267v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.04267v1
|
Transformers need glasses! Information over-squashing in language tasks
| 2024-06-06T17:14:44 | 2024-06-06T17:14:44 |
Federico Barbero, Andrea Banino, Steven Kapturowski, Dharshan Kumaran, João G. M. Araújo, Alex Vitvitskyi, Razvan Pascanu, Petar Veličković
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
We study how information propagates in decoder-only Transformers, which are
the architectural backbone of most existing frontier large language models
(LLMs). We rely on a theoretical signal propagation analysis -- specifically,
we analyse the representations of the last token in the final layer of the
Transformer, as this is the representation used for next-token prediction. Our
analysis reveals a representational collapse phenomenon: we prove that certain
distinct sequences of inputs to the Transformer can yield arbitrarily close
representations in the final token. This effect is exacerbated by the
low-precision floating-point formats frequently used in modern LLMs. As a
result, the model is provably unable to respond to these sequences in different
ways -- leading to errors in, e.g., tasks involving counting or copying.
Further, we show that decoder-only Transformer language models can lose
sensitivity to specific tokens in the input, which relates to the well-known
phenomenon of over-squashing in graph neural networks. We provide empirical
evidence supporting our claims on contemporary LLMs. Our theory also points to
simple solutions towards ameliorating these issues.
|
[
-0.31645289063453674,
-0.7618488669395447,
0.5091308951377869,
0.12906262278556824,
-0.06619378924369812,
0.08712495118379593,
-0.11720025539398193,
-0.4141688048839569,
0.25143176317214966,
0.5137068033218384,
-0.48840785026550293,
-0.010778569616377354,
-1.0921920537948608,
-0.0929192304611206,
-0.9055800437927246,
0.7024862170219421,
0.1032722219824791,
0.05027106776833534,
-0.1702663004398346,
0.14435414969921112,
-0.5307272672653198,
-0.3524484932422638,
-0.7466663718223572,
-0.5177674293518066,
0.25231894850730896,
0.3004986345767975,
1.118874430656433,
0.48127248883247375,
0.44289371371269226,
0.3659462630748749,
-0.34362342953681946,
-0.12571404874324799,
-0.6458210349082947,
0.08992649614810944,
0.11408020555973053,
-1.0583933591842651,
-0.24318519234657288,
-0.1448957473039627,
0.7743594646453857,
0.9915853142738342,
-0.07163596898317337,
-0.011190361343324184,
0.16940295696258545,
0.7004868388175964,
-0.3634316027164459,
0.4892948269844055,
-0.6371869444847107,
0.40075013041496277,
-0.333506315946579,
-0.17176423966884613,
-0.7380289435386658,
0.08838816732168198,
-0.1832170933485031,
-0.5259990096092224,
0.31532061100006104,
0.17482484877109528,
0.8757022619247437,
0.2657787501811981,
-0.42264705896377563,
-0.027385784313082695,
-1.0606729984283447,
0.5552117824554443,
-0.3968970775604248,
0.7009372711181641,
0.1971442848443985,
0.3081916570663452,
-0.43884652853012085,
-0.7693918347358704,
-0.5727699995040894,
-0.13207301497459412,
-0.25797009468078613,
0.24425947666168213,
-0.6713655591011047,
0.157716765999794,
0.3998608887195587,
0.24473363161087036,
-0.3365893065929413,
-0.05400810390710831,
-0.8690717220306396,
-0.11939172446727753,
0.09329333901405334,
0.24292010068893433,
0.20775644481182098,
-0.13902390003204346,
-0.3954988718032837,
-0.16926181316375732,
-0.7886566519737244,
-0.2556373178958893,
0.2259647250175476,
0.0996072068810463,
-0.02521468512713909,
0.7198613286018372,
0.13637091219425201,
0.7031882405281067,
0.29315611720085144,
0.2470014989376068,
0.30568403005599976,
0.08886010199785233,
-0.277284175157547,
-0.04921577125787735,
0.8086608052253723,
0.3271542191505432,
0.3834250569343567,
-0.5581128597259521,
-0.23186874389648438,
0.15764939785003662,
0.3720112144947052,
-0.45006948709487915,
-0.09604650735855103,
0.1518283486366272,
-0.5494949817657471,
-0.28496894240379333,
-0.08990690857172012,
-0.6482701301574707,
-0.4348212778568268,
-0.17074134945869446,
0.3783841133117676,
-0.3046673834323883,
-0.38009750843048096,
0.22649160027503967,
-0.4397663474082947,
0.1580335944890976,
-0.11817687004804611,
-1.1330580711364746,
0.5686014294624329,
0.653422474861145,
0.8653324842453003,
-0.16760753095149994,
-0.3203273415565491,
-0.35568928718566895,
0.18101383745670319,
-0.3866191804409027,
0.6650395393371582,
-0.6666029095649719,
-0.6024147868156433,
0.055135149508714676,
0.11952576041221619,
-0.24231384694576263,
-0.610140860080719,
0.6557497978210449,
-0.6745148301124573,
0.13319894671440125,
-0.19988380372524261,
-0.4375910758972168,
0.012492645531892776,
0.08183163404464722,
-0.9675378203392029,
0.8605446219444275,
0.23239579796791077,
-0.7435431480407715,
0.3006104528903961,
-0.5842722058296204,
-0.5664690732955933,
-0.05892685428261757,
-0.2632555663585663,
-0.26259154081344604,
0.5743699073791504,
0.05144667252898216,
0.47010210156440735,
-0.1960429549217224,
0.22613905370235443,
-0.030981428921222687,
-0.4966520071029663,
0.29983338713645935,
-0.8071504235267639,
0.5780438184738159,
0.15144819021224976,
-0.24815158545970917,
0.18721763789653778,
-0.6476848125457764,
-0.346954345703125,
0.359714150428772,
-0.1186535581946373,
-0.07066705822944641,
0.25116294622421265,
0.022165462374687195,
0.2454371154308319,
0.006812969222664833,
-0.7125911116600037,
0.10186221450567245,
-0.4455571174621582,
0.8926656246185303,
0.7094965577125549,
-0.4242539703845978,
0.7007923722267151,
-0.320881724357605,
0.6068903207778931,
0.2412099838256836,
0.26341113448143005,
-0.3883175551891327,
-0.7280369997024536,
-0.9291710257530212,
0.30449971556663513,
-0.07077448070049286,
0.655580461025238,
-0.7627997398376465,
0.05521729961037636,
-0.6903653740882874,
-0.40272441506385803,
-0.27592208981513977,
-0.17295020818710327,
0.09187320619821548,
0.5243859887123108,
0.3774251639842987,
-0.4364811182022095,
-0.47105085849761963,
-0.8218497633934021,
-0.19715161621570587,
-0.10001784563064575,
-0.1316739171743393,
-0.1266252100467682,
0.3271212577819824,
-0.08842043578624725,
1.078183889389038,
-0.6587464213371277,
-0.5371490716934204,
-0.32903236150741577,
-0.05075935646891594,
0.3228946328163147,
0.3236616849899292,
0.3451806306838989,
-0.9471446871757507,
0.15731385350227356,
-0.24786479771137238,
-0.7191944122314453,
0.38770756125450134,
-0.048419054597616196,
0.19557827711105347,
0.19184191524982452,
0.8168064951896667,
-1.1850568056106567,
0.5098930597305298,
0.7028331756591797,
-0.25062039494514465,
0.3887936472892761,
-0.15911465883255005,
-0.17476722598075867,
-1.0199286937713623,
-0.22362177073955536,
0.07226099073886871,
-0.2833358347415924,
-0.6058110594749451,
-0.07262274622917175,
-0.022121209651231766,
-0.3197941780090332,
-0.18156678974628448,
0.3997339904308319,
-0.4834522008895874,
-0.044983331114053726,
-0.3175596296787262,
0.3210974931716919,
0.055030547082424164,
0.40973377227783203,
-0.009455163963139057,
0.6018708348274231,
0.5252141356468201,
-0.2773703932762146,
0.3950671851634979,
0.16307422518730164,
-0.19745267927646637,
0.3463984727859497,
-0.7928371429443359,
-0.10991910099983215,
-0.5310242176055908,
0.3431217074394226,
-1.30657160282135,
-0.12285935133695602,
0.4598374366760254,
-0.5733360052108765,
0.6555855870246887,
-0.16247321665287018,
-0.398607075214386,
-0.5276883244514465,
-0.07460237294435501,
0.4848971664905548,
0.7122815847396851,
-0.406488299369812,
0.8546669483184814,
0.4516037106513977,
0.07992562651634216,
-0.5166310667991638,
-1.2092829942703247,
0.2291892170906067,
-0.11730717867612839,
-0.9398268461227417,
0.33778277039527893,
0.2258690595626831,
-0.17464043200016022,
0.24086011946201324,
-0.08697543293237686,
0.04082254320383072,
-0.05583057180047035,
0.46897611021995544,
0.08998823910951614,
-0.4155648350715637,
0.08057599514722824,
-0.09288407117128372,
-0.441123902797699,
0.3063219487667084,
-0.34326183795928955,
0.671450674533844,
-0.16021984815597534,
-0.6058114171028137,
-0.19386331737041473,
0.3372161388397217,
0.7784326672554016,
-0.1651945561170578,
0.8723432421684265,
0.4586314857006073,
-0.4498644173145294,
0.025988047942519188,
-0.485542893409729,
-0.37071236968040466,
-0.536818265914917,
0.5669167637825012,
-0.3739915192127228,
-0.878391444683075,
0.7058961987495422,
-0.011074007488787174,
-0.20506931841373444,
0.5828144550323486,
0.4046274721622467,
0.07758890092372894,
0.9306262135505676,
0.8363384008407593,
-0.2344227284193039,
0.4364168345928192,
-0.3125598728656769,
0.504973828792572,
-0.6578511595726013,
-0.3094014525413513,
-0.311643123626709,
-0.3087286055088043,
-0.39465099573135376,
-0.5374964475631714,
0.2879302203655243,
0.047047972679138184,
-0.07476016879081726,
0.3675977885723114,
-0.43254005908966064,
0.5862624645233154,
0.454436331987381,
0.024998558685183525,
0.26056069135665894,
0.20508767664432526,
0.09975462406873703,
0.07567165791988373,
-0.9009411334991455,
-0.2089117467403412,
0.7371891140937805,
0.6244288682937622,
0.9060863852500916,
-0.11915718764066696,
0.3449011445045471,
0.15345200896263123,
0.134809672832489,
-0.8337564468383789,
0.3886477053165436,
-0.27210599184036255,
-0.6242867112159729,
-0.39113640785217285,
-0.36217251420021057,
-1.0046032667160034,
0.1482037901878357,
-0.0692950114607811,
-0.9102823138237,
0.16941919922828674,
0.26783251762390137,
-0.08875305950641632,
0.5628322958946228,
-0.7712315320968628,
0.8075185418128967,
0.10702982544898987,
-0.10454504936933517,
-0.2387661188840866,
-0.6099200248718262,
0.4159620404243469,
0.1694726049900055,
0.46635702252388,
0.10899893939495087,
0.191822350025177,
0.6452823877334595,
-0.24927204847335815,
1.1164683103561401,
-0.11267811805009842,
-0.1670716255903244,
0.19045542180538177,
0.3443388342857361,
0.7105640769004822,
-0.3488573431968689,
0.09444843232631683,
0.32954272627830505,
-0.18144936859607697,
-0.38188686966896057,
-0.7195409536361694,
0.3614926040172577,
-0.5195583701133728,
-0.8171845078468323,
-0.4222683012485504,
-0.429806113243103,
-0.153516948223114,
0.11731550842523575,
0.7165773510932922,
0.6404249668121338,
0.1495259702205658,
-0.017366349697113037,
0.4962863028049469,
0.18205247819423676,
0.4858555793762207,
0.08736910670995712,
-0.35673820972442627,
-0.002058684593066573,
0.8680503368377686,
0.4134175479412079,
0.47988027334213257,
0.1661200374364853,
-0.03978140652179718,
-0.03576439246535301,
-0.697924792766571,
-0.6364966630935669,
0.1759956181049347,
-0.9523959755897522,
-0.07289136201143265,
-0.23975634574890137,
-0.4104452133178711,
-0.21251200139522552,
0.05637504905462265,
-0.45560118556022644,
-0.467542439699173,
-0.25038856267929077,
-0.39034393429756165,
0.25782114267349243,
1.148131012916565,
0.014467531815171242,
0.6791363954544067,
-1.0279948711395264,
0.24001261591911316,
-0.05751114338636398,
0.548092782497406,
0.2605854570865631,
-0.6900705099105835,
-0.25686919689178467,
0.021981805562973022,
-0.27903130650520325,
-0.9049042463302612,
0.17108365893363953,
0.0075231739319860935,
0.47633618116378784,
0.44069069623947144,
-0.11306527256965637,
0.5101155638694763,
-0.9272556900978088,
0.8564023971557617,
0.440055787563324,
-0.9975980520248413,
-0.09903813153505325,
-0.23291276395320892,
0.2091481238603592,
0.039308514446020126,
0.28689175844192505,
-0.902091920375824,
-0.6104540824890137,
-0.5024845004081726,
-1.0393688678741455,
0.6772395372390747,
0.24835935235023499,
0.7155484557151794,
-0.2925512492656708,
0.18987251818180084,
-0.18816828727722168,
-0.05767089128494263,
-0.5689617991447449,
-0.4551648199558258,
-0.1244313046336174,
-0.06470904499292374,
-0.05872059240937233,
-0.701808512210846,
-0.05353105440735817,
0.08045247197151184,
0.38531070947647095,
0.017359938472509384,
0.5176626443862915,
0.1871059238910675,
0.04509052634239197,
-0.38564708828926086,
0.11094412207603455,
0.5651640892028809,
0.7169839143753052,
0.12852022051811218,
0.0886145830154419,
0.196647047996521,
-0.545256495475769,
-0.0863654688000679,
-0.11617201566696167,
-0.13836735486984253,
0.13660676777362823,
0.36625906825065613,
1.0212745666503906,
0.2950146496295929,
-0.3664020895957947,
0.7437720894813538,
-0.17434024810791016,
0.09498833119869232,
-0.5790538191795349,
-0.16120260953903198,
0.14132891595363617,
0.22331590950489044,
0.7831906080245972,
0.5597198605537415,
0.033942461013793945,
-0.40966659784317017,
0.30914124846458435,
0.44209620356559753,
-0.7707871198654175,
-0.49532443284988403,
0.9392445087432861,
0.08685556799173355,
-0.545123815536499,
0.7312793135643005,
-0.06745082139968872,
-0.6598947048187256,
0.5264492630958557,
0.7823832631111145,
0.7364132404327393,
-0.1940748691558838,
0.17848561704158783,
0.010584534145891666,
0.5818193554878235,
-0.24768537282943726,
0.016642572358250618,
0.13364093005657196,
-0.8624609112739563,
-0.8741794228553772,
-0.4428195059299469,
-0.17104801535606384,
-0.17139539122581482,
-0.5029194951057434,
0.24103139340877533,
-0.2020431011915207,
-0.3381495177745819,
-0.17171505093574524,
-0.867557168006897,
-0.5193489193916321,
0.14499858021736145,
0.28001582622528076,
1.0394537448883057,
-1.013352870941162,
0.5968543291091919,
0.1384749412536621,
-0.3336871266365051,
-0.7345205545425415,
0.04870249703526497,
-0.13683775067329407,
-0.9896893501281738,
0.805872917175293,
0.16526035964488983,
-0.2550814151763916,
-0.05726945027709007,
-0.40499141812324524,
-1.1156572103500366,
0.6994165778160095,
0.7622095346450806,
-0.6605729460716248,
-0.4712415635585785,
0.49649471044540405,
0.3422098159790039,
0.08209259063005447,
0.3621605634689331,
0.6942877173423767,
0.40308451652526855,
0.31320920586586,
-1.1433587074279785,
0.16507486999034882,
-0.14842230081558228,
-0.21765033900737762,
0.5641719698905945,
-0.7499890327453613,
0.8250871300697327,
-0.1178785040974617,
-0.28717857599258423,
-0.059521470218896866,
0.6837196946144104,
-0.25556227564811707,
0.05034297704696655,
0.4447759687900543,
0.49722081422805786,
0.5327633619308472,
-0.3131093680858612,
1.2291512489318848,
-0.473833292722702,
0.28039783239364624,
0.7896051406860352,
0.13294491171836853,
0.8657621145248413,
0.6732674837112427,
-0.35547566413879395,
0.19363732635974884,
0.24867179989814758,
-0.017285780981183052,
0.16694384813308716,
0.4358442425727844,
0.12519541382789612,
-0.1327098309993744,
-0.0006316924118436873,
-0.3760603070259094,
0.40515753626823425,
0.5943060517311096,
-0.3751678764820099,
-0.21909917891025543,
0.25230371952056885,
0.14421916007995605,
-0.053444746881723404,
-0.2781027853488922,
0.2994078993797302,
0.39501282572746277,
-0.39970171451568604,
0.5972599983215332,
0.01747138611972332,
0.6066992282867432,
-0.5095074772834778,
0.08074259757995605,
-0.12786540389060974,
0.11958468705415726,
-0.448698490858078,
-0.8579819202423096,
0.7414551973342896,
-0.4662589728832245,
-0.24480320513248444,
-0.21346116065979004,
0.7041692733764648,
-0.19418121874332428,
-0.5844647884368896,
0.5358608961105347,
0.14938104152679443,
0.21525169909000397,
-0.12855879962444305,
-0.19302663207054138,
0.3264634907245636,
-0.15445609390735626,
-0.49920639395713806,
0.0968843623995781,
0.2937200665473938,
-0.0307751651853323,
0.8506302237510681,
0.3473173677921295,
0.13628973066806793,
0.596473753452301,
0.011106527410447598,
0.9479742050170898,
-0.5628674626350403,
-0.12439130246639252,
-1.0238838195800781,
0.5202195048332214,
0.09577096253633499,
-0.11179148405790329,
0.7556395530700684,
0.6972793936729431,
0.8622552752494812,
-0.11818510293960571,
0.6879268884658813,
0.08539508283138275,
0.007210708223283291,
-0.6620321869850159,
0.6853542327880859,
-0.4131604731082916,
0.21270355582237244,
-0.21061953902244568,
-1.0739279985427856,
-0.5046250820159912,
0.3529943525791168,
-0.4302249848842621,
-0.1279541552066803,
0.5986414551734924,
0.6474661231040955,
-0.17084066569805145,
0.20617011189460754,
0.4321044087409973,
0.3884105086326599,
0.29784753918647766,
0.6418323516845703,
0.9148890972137451,
-0.5861626267433167,
0.9165990352630615,
0.030619623139500618,
0.03895969316363335,
-0.046715252101421356,
-0.6360561847686768,
-0.6555498242378235,
-0.867544949054718,
-0.15231449902057648,
-0.5887030363082886,
0.022953664883971214,
0.4784744679927826,
0.7517573833465576,
-0.5918970108032227,
-0.1406782567501068,
-0.3517567217350006,
0.1012989953160286,
0.10435933619737625,
-0.18023356795310974,
0.36670053005218506,
-0.5162808895111084,
-0.7200698256492615,
0.37707018852233887,
0.2348482310771942,
0.11489447206258774,
-0.38948601484298706,
0.21733641624450684,
0.49435898661613464,
0.04381916671991348,
0.6924579739570618,
0.2032988965511322,
-0.565200686454773,
-0.4588162899017334,
0.1702684611082077,
0.08247136324644089,
0.3608046770095825,
0.8239903450012207,
-1.0256060361862183,
0.3359607756137848,
0.47663044929504395,
0.4623987078666687,
0.5586294531822205,
-0.2464619129896164,
0.7397245168685913,
-0.704821765422821,
0.40479663014411926,
0.14092865586280823,
0.6322218775749207,
0.23932209610939026,
-0.30857643485069275,
0.17521092295646667,
0.36818501353263855,
-0.34103575348854065,
-0.7869293689727783,
0.5288984179496765,
-0.7269747853279114,
-0.2553764581680298,
1.0639911890029907,
0.07578016072511673,
-0.5493871569633484,
0.03327474370598793,
-0.22308865189552307,
0.18318068981170654,
-0.3090835511684418,
0.676286518573761,
0.885765552520752,
0.00011912142508663237,
-0.1697651892900467,
-0.481828898191452,
0.36726686358451843,
0.35534602403640747,
-0.12573188543319702,
0.2566394805908203,
0.22165895998477936,
0.20951956510543823,
0.5497788786888123,
0.40276992321014404,
-0.11880392581224442,
0.03569027781486511,
0.2627476155757904,
-0.2811262011528015,
-0.108894944190979,
-0.3298332691192627,
-0.3978218734264374,
0.44753947854042053,
0.2329329252243042,
-0.21419069170951843
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.04264v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.04264v2
|
MLVU: A Comprehensive Benchmark for Multi-Task Long Video Understanding
| 2024-06-06T17:09:32 | 2024-06-19T09:04:38 |
Junjie Zhou, Yan Shu, Bo Zhao, Boya Wu, Shitao Xiao, Xi Yang, Yongping Xiong, Bo Zhang, Tiejun Huang, Zheng Liu
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
The evaluation of Long Video Understanding (LVU) performance poses an
important but challenging research problem. Despite previous efforts, the
existing video understanding benchmarks are severely constrained by several
issues, especially the insufficient lengths of videos, a lack of diversity in
video types and evaluation tasks, and the inappropriateness for evaluating LVU
performances. To address the above problems, we propose a new benchmark, called
MLVU (Multi-task Long Video Understanding Benchmark), for the comprehensive and
in-depth evaluation of LVU. MLVU presents the following critical values: 1) The
substantial and flexible extension of video lengths, which enables the
benchmark to evaluate LVU performance across a wide range of durations. 2) The
inclusion of various video genres, e.g., movies, surveillance footage,
egocentric videos, cartoons, game videos, etc., which reflects the models' LVU
performances in different scenarios. 3) The development of diversified
evaluation tasks, which enables a comprehensive examination of MLLMs' key
abilities in long-video understanding. The empirical study with 20 latest MLLMs
reveals significant room for improvement in today's technique, as all existing
methods struggle with most of the evaluation tasks and exhibit severe
performance degradation when handling longer videos. Additionally, it suggests
that factors such as context length, image-understanding quality, and the
choice of LLM backbone can play critical roles in future advancements. We
anticipate that MLVU will advance the research of long video understanding by
providing a comprehensive and in-depth analysis of MLLMs.
|
[
-0.5334300994873047,
-0.8354305028915405,
0.4037363827228546,
0.41492247581481934,
-0.5618391036987305,
-0.04572007805109024,
-0.2644385099411011,
-0.405142217874527,
-0.21220476925373077,
0.32424136996269226,
-0.7932184338569641,
-0.30668044090270996,
-0.8240616917610168,
0.020339064300060272,
-0.4947448670864105,
0.6799998879432678,
-0.14869065582752228,
0.11847753822803497,
-0.5892322659492493,
-0.6262699365615845,
-0.7748592495918274,
-0.332457035779953,
-0.2580256164073944,
-0.22859729826450348,
0.48983538150787354,
0.14159348607063293,
0.31082484126091003,
0.5905803442001343,
0.6575363874435425,
0.309905081987381,
-0.13726438581943512,
0.5532087683677673,
-0.9142924547195435,
0.06723394989967346,
0.1308533400297165,
0.007483122870326042,
-0.39673134684562683,
-0.39152437448501587,
1.1881358623504639,
0.4908653795719147,
0.35920488834381104,
0.7420690655708313,
0.3577630817890167,
1.1276967525482178,
-1.199401617050171,
-0.04045721888542175,
-0.22779841721057892,
0.43271708488464355,
-0.13914112746715546,
-0.12918183207511902,
-0.27634963393211365,
0.11356545984745026,
0.005108197219669819,
-0.6170247197151184,
0.3360835611820221,
-0.29806584119796753,
0.5407631397247314,
0.39034485816955566,
-0.689189076423645,
0.451761394739151,
-0.8694314360618591,
0.6588956713676453,
0.02430354245007038,
0.8068590760231018,
0.06547147780656815,
0.6725260019302368,
-0.12875574827194214,
-0.5880341529846191,
-0.3933650553226471,
-0.17653489112854004,
0.4709504246711731,
0.31754568219184875,
-0.08077148348093033,
0.17447210848331451,
0.3430812656879425,
0.36619123816490173,
-0.606097400188446,
0.21554799377918243,
-0.47166985273361206,
-0.012396241538226604,
0.5732002258300781,
0.5207642912864685,
-0.33338961005210876,
-0.07536222785711288,
-0.5767992734909058,
0.11426813155412674,
-0.3650902807712555,
0.6342326998710632,
0.2385540008544922,
-0.23968194425106049,
-0.15751738846302032,
0.5383475422859192,
-0.4481971859931946,
0.9353954792022705,
-0.3070400059223175,
-0.379530131816864,
0.37594664096832275,
-0.3335071802139282,
-0.8821637630462646,
-0.35083842277526855,
0.5289340019226074,
0.8335944414138794,
0.08646434545516968,
-0.012110933661460876,
0.10270165652036667,
0.053807325661182404,
0.27256712317466736,
-1.1174023151397705,
0.17425304651260376,
0.21771453320980072,
-0.9384257197380066,
0.11909522861242294,
-0.0526900440454483,
-0.7762868404388428,
-0.7412694692611694,
-0.5203359127044678,
0.5427622199058533,
-0.3383355140686035,
-0.32805266976356506,
0.10927906632423401,
-0.35408368706703186,
0.39549607038497925,
0.6267319321632385,
-0.495561420917511,
0.3629177510738373,
1.002253532409668,
0.7672353982925415,
-0.6758734583854675,
-0.5698180198669434,
-0.7829912900924683,
0.04815742373466492,
-0.13945366442203522,
0.4666109085083008,
-0.2600674331188202,
-0.49612194299697876,
0.21197931468486786,
0.05787558853626251,
0.27120494842529297,
-0.4207727015018463,
0.5301603078842163,
-0.2235197126865387,
-0.30091193318367004,
-0.31218838691711426,
-0.7406747937202454,
-0.22461067140102386,
0.5302768349647522,
-0.7423658967018127,
0.914293110370636,
-0.17656941711902618,
-0.49202433228492737,
0.701339840888977,
-0.5471983551979065,
-0.2145063877105713,
-0.1648567169904709,
-0.2594098746776581,
-0.3300570249557495,
0.16754686832427979,
0.1046641394495964,
0.5733813047409058,
-0.3185563087463379,
0.33176442980766296,
-0.5385350584983826,
-0.6362189650535583,
0.3669573664665222,
-1.019874930381775,
0.3140801787376404,
0.1546449065208435,
0.014232276007533073,
0.24880030751228333,
-0.8340357542037964,
-0.13971196115016937,
-0.29597294330596924,
0.18884119391441345,
0.08011448383331299,
-0.1297522485256195,
-0.06238656863570213,
-0.10636020451784134,
0.19839265942573547,
-0.4034058451652527,
-0.053823959082365036,
0.32273435592651367,
0.09949018061161041,
0.8623304963111877,
-0.1551647186279297,
0.2228069305419922,
0.09194262325763702,
0.5181687474250793,
-0.1013447493314743,
0.8526601791381836,
-0.1216634064912796,
-0.4265083968639374,
-0.6114237904548645,
-0.298525869846344,
-0.19766907393932343,
0.18763703107833862,
-0.316989004611969,
-0.053191181272268295,
-0.3410472273826599,
-0.4918796420097351,
-0.5440914034843445,
0.3636654019355774,
0.41874146461486816,
0.5472058057785034,
0.5998167395591736,
-0.39906325936317444,
-0.4891892969608307,
-0.9179529547691345,
-0.198518306016922,
0.0987340584397316,
-0.06691902875900269,
0.39319857954978943,
0.4471771717071533,
-0.09421709924936295,
0.8159639835357666,
-0.4344789981842041,
-0.2713935077190399,
0.09947402030229568,
0.04457993060350418,
0.4659857153892517,
-0.017992714419960976,
0.28199130296707153,
-0.8738623261451721,
-0.24096350371837616,
0.0003348338941577822,
-0.9380071759223938,
0.622938334941864,
0.012196975760161877,
0.017789524048566818,
-0.22534987330436707,
0.35782837867736816,
-0.5467194318771362,
0.6242893934249878,
0.4973156452178955,
-0.2881926894187927,
0.9871838092803955,
-0.3981401026248932,
0.5678726434707642,
-0.4618459641933441,
-0.05466495826840401,
-0.07735870033502579,
-0.23548363149166107,
-0.5176263451576233,
0.095125213265419,
0.2167726457118988,
-0.030454901978373528,
-0.750896692276001,
0.2588413655757904,
-0.4077509343624115,
-0.37175169587135315,
-0.24433228373527527,
0.1644134223461151,
0.08886276930570602,
0.28858205676078796,
-0.17176535725593567,
0.6668624877929688,
0.6382032036781311,
-0.789911150932312,
0.8177697062492371,
-0.199133962392807,
-0.627114474773407,
0.7733145952224731,
-0.5037499666213989,
-0.1725754290819168,
-0.382564902305603,
0.2141011655330658,
-0.7273496389389038,
0.15926003456115723,
-0.23512917757034302,
-0.5374816060066223,
0.1973785161972046,
-0.4184492826461792,
-0.06767876446247101,
-0.3363727629184723,
-0.362623929977417,
0.6700384020805359,
0.4165104925632477,
-0.32550105452537537,
0.674906313419342,
0.054647475481033325,
0.4671366512775421,
-1.2769405841827393,
-0.235927551984787,
0.08349363505840302,
-0.6208695769309998,
-0.789760410785675,
0.3444400429725647,
-0.2956778109073639,
-0.1564100682735443,
-0.15370473265647888,
-0.3175428807735443,
-0.15885551273822784,
-0.12172151356935501,
0.46849074959754944,
0.10671605169773102,
-0.26723402738571167,
0.22727707028388977,
-0.3433014452457428,
0.06309528648853302,
0.14975880086421967,
0.0883384495973587,
0.08824345469474792,
-0.06632694602012634,
-0.28764188289642334,
-0.2521984577178955,
0.5086394548416138,
0.600558876991272,
-0.2981545925140381,
0.2864273488521576,
1.3257101774215698,
-0.21956618130207062,
-0.07027508318424225,
-0.8632297515869141,
0.15779966115951538,
-0.42244115471839905,
0.8582196831703186,
-0.6150261163711548,
-0.8807560205459595,
0.38406288623809814,
-0.012747112661600113,
-0.02199305221438408,
0.3718194365501404,
0.5454673767089844,
-0.3351021409034729,
0.41476476192474365,
0.8550957441329956,
-0.14479388296604156,
0.40967831015586853,
-0.39365875720977783,
-0.4183860123157501,
-0.776629626750946,
-0.41119787096977234,
-0.09615204483270645,
-0.24647043645381927,
-0.45950326323509216,
-0.8118491768836975,
0.46083658933639526,
0.009686721488833427,
-0.34785333275794983,
0.014032267965376377,
-0.2744238078594208,
0.4684184789657593,
-0.023720266297459602,
0.29636403918266296,
0.19383341073989868,
-0.15493661165237427,
0.4001501798629761,
-0.034217458218336105,
-0.20320136845111847,
-0.07487969845533371,
1.1774314641952515,
0.6602463126182556,
0.6539142727851868,
0.3905683159828186,
0.5225962996482849,
0.6520087718963623,
-0.0248569268733263,
-0.7339347004890442,
0.5301060080528259,
-0.3149508535861969,
-0.3859260678291321,
-0.5573803186416626,
-0.21618907153606415,
-1.0848335027694702,
0.3802882730960846,
-0.22889059782028198,
-0.7758482694625854,
-0.046450454741716385,
0.08533813059329987,
-0.33797454833984375,
0.13541169464588165,
-0.48127079010009766,
1.137090802192688,
-0.28243473172187805,
-0.9104554653167725,
-0.6183373332023621,
-0.5764063596725464,
0.5651810169219971,
0.21032744646072388,
0.3678644895553589,
-0.29620710015296936,
-0.13079358637332916,
0.7491472959518433,
-0.2178240865468979,
0.4636451303958893,
-0.24630719423294067,
0.14635449647903442,
0.3789913058280945,
-0.17348062992095947,
0.17498457431793213,
0.37250611186027527,
0.18594931066036224,
-0.004987895023077726,
0.023227674886584282,
-0.4299306273460388,
-0.7284866571426392,
0.5375215411186218,
-0.8047021627426147,
-0.6049363613128662,
-0.17483408749103546,
-0.3980904519557953,
-0.1594177931547165,
0.007525190245360136,
0.12315041571855545,
0.423611581325531,
-0.5366237163543701,
0.5152783393859863,
0.8308940529823303,
0.07497300207614899,
0.4920547604560852,
0.20723462104797363,
-0.24505369365215302,
-0.4583505690097809,
0.8319882750511169,
-0.1892300397157669,
0.17737378180027008,
0.5681517124176025,
-0.024177677929401398,
-0.3006119728088379,
-0.6598145961761475,
-0.5409374237060547,
-0.23945997655391693,
-0.8671491146087646,
-0.1877940148115158,
-0.3773132562637329,
-0.020385636016726494,
-0.17191720008850098,
0.2757934331893921,
-0.5822635293006897,
0.10029621422290802,
-0.34480810165405273,
-0.19964314997196198,
0.40175363421440125,
0.5308672785758972,
0.135855570435524,
-0.016173575073480606,
-0.9448884129524231,
0.8542155027389526,
0.6196535229682922,
0.4835498332977295,
-0.005544903222471476,
-0.6592663526535034,
-0.4919629395008087,
-0.24894988536834717,
-0.5210773348808289,
-0.7629660964012146,
-0.163906067609787,
0.225457102060318,
0.7100507020950317,
0.6076854467391968,
-0.32574236392974854,
1.4552183151245117,
-0.5207614302635193,
0.8216720819473267,
0.45628392696380615,
-0.7841121554374695,
0.2892265021800995,
-0.05840620398521423,
0.19964519143104553,
0.6143107414245605,
0.208729550242424,
-0.3666013479232788,
0.24542006850242615,
-0.21105776727199554,
-0.646433413028717,
-0.046033043414354324,
0.47875094413757324,
0.06615859270095825,
0.5201228857040405,
0.054599303752183914,
0.4462169110774994,
0.03852963447570801,
-0.5481261610984802,
-0.4377319812774658,
-0.3208502531051636,
0.4151513874530792,
-0.38720181584358215,
-0.3032723665237427,
-0.16747714579105377,
-0.4635332524776459,
0.14918279647827148,
-0.05947245657444,
0.3175017535686493,
0.3156399130821228,
-0.36936816573143005,
0.13731633126735687,
0.2530878782272339,
0.6291788816452026,
1.0457652807235718,
-0.5577274560928345,
-0.17553502321243286,
0.5824529528617859,
-0.6013982892036438,
0.19360288977622986,
0.05538298189640045,
0.35837045311927795,
0.06442011147737503,
0.5508987903594971,
0.9442929029464722,
-0.11706400662660599,
-0.6038212776184082,
0.6889307498931885,
-0.09505575895309448,
-0.11568747460842133,
-0.580421507358551,
-0.021647699177265167,
-0.25261566042900085,
0.3810374140739441,
0.4417233467102051,
-0.12087470293045044,
0.5230266451835632,
-0.545469343662262,
0.22276081144809723,
0.42295247316360474,
-0.3804061710834503,
0.07521694153547287,
0.2807171642780304,
0.30402880907058716,
-0.17282941937446594,
0.5712987780570984,
-0.06839572638273239,
-0.07957063615322113,
0.821765124797821,
0.04920116066932678,
0.8339386582374573,
0.07376088947057724,
0.013134640641510487,
0.4408271908760071,
0.22972340881824493,
-0.046306733042001724,
0.22852766513824463,
-0.6042549014091492,
-0.4147275388240814,
-0.7828790545463562,
-0.4714367985725403,
-0.4249156713485718,
0.29932156205177307,
-0.913485050201416,
0.5367388725280762,
-0.05276898667216301,
-0.3465678095817566,
-0.0883098840713501,
-0.06190146505832672,
-1.1606487035751343,
0.48541808128356934,
0.4218085706233978,
1.0915056467056274,
-0.5742934942245483,
0.8428379893302917,
0.08539324253797531,
-0.004004410468041897,
-0.1727243959903717,
-0.5327736735343933,
-0.07267122715711594,
-0.6170796751976013,
0.6168451309204102,
0.5935032963752747,
-0.2699120044708252,
-0.6759526133537292,
-0.0602206215262413,
-0.4986753463745117,
1.2861428260803223,
0.19741922616958618,
-0.7796832919120789,
0.05241468921303749,
0.25202280282974243,
0.37156879901885986,
-0.29747655987739563,
0.569159746170044,
0.6568984985351562,
0.40991443395614624,
-0.13123303651809692,
-0.934370219707489,
-0.38570263981819153,
-0.1768408715724945,
-0.15904901921749115,
0.18926075100898743,
-0.6812016367912292,
0.5521849393844604,
-0.33710840344429016,
0.24960419535636902,
0.1265164017677307,
1.0745116472244263,
0.1409706175327301,
0.807538628578186,
0.5745402574539185,
0.35010942816734314,
0.46023592352867126,
0.192391037940979,
0.6244773268699646,
0.17659932374954224,
0.4128555357456207,
1.2462184429168701,
0.10149946063756943,
0.8263190984725952,
0.6953688859939575,
-0.49873217940330505,
0.15099285542964935,
0.5930240154266357,
-0.28156378865242004,
0.3175179958343506,
0.3444380760192871,
-0.30262964963912964,
-0.5208406448364258,
0.018705017864704132,
-0.7278118133544922,
0.7356148362159729,
0.4101332426071167,
-0.32102036476135254,
0.16328145563602448,
0.20443308353424072,
-0.42581677436828613,
-0.05284760892391205,
-0.6470286250114441,
0.584729015827179,
0.06153382733464241,
-0.6191990375518799,
0.6601285338401794,
-0.3841986060142517,
0.6095132827758789,
-0.7249612808227539,
-0.09377127885818481,
-0.015523732639849186,
0.1961742490530014,
-0.2352244108915329,
-0.9966212511062622,
-0.03910551592707634,
0.2618904709815979,
-0.12943656742572784,
0.04533086344599724,
0.49232739210128784,
-0.08858329057693481,
-0.4007937014102936,
0.5552771687507629,
0.2840939164161682,
0.31820863485336304,
-0.19361013174057007,
-0.49389714002609253,
0.45444461703300476,
-0.2122807800769806,
-0.05345650762319565,
0.48313018679618835,
0.38698461651802063,
0.11800826340913773,
0.7060105800628662,
0.36539873480796814,
-0.3025318384170532,
-0.06169549375772476,
0.3115279972553253,
0.6864193677902222,
-0.7073003649711609,
-0.250993013381958,
-1.1278698444366455,
0.7823408246040344,
-0.3288232386112213,
-0.44235095381736755,
0.6560510993003845,
0.769044816493988,
0.7705150842666626,
-0.24134793877601624,
0.5175002217292786,
0.2925373315811157,
-0.19420428574085236,
-0.5965079665184021,
0.30406615138053894,
-0.7556949853897095,
-0.19604334235191345,
-0.46511581540107727,
-0.9397085905075073,
-0.02048814855515957,
0.01714557223021984,
0.15568099915981293,
-0.11626088619232178,
0.6255242824554443,
0.2727223336696625,
-0.19255642592906952,
-0.069073885679245,
0.6910080313682556,
0.04792235419154167,
0.3045463562011719,
0.73324054479599,
0.880276083946228,
-0.41676855087280273,
0.9521899819374084,
-0.48322969675064087,
-0.3255470395088196,
-0.28493621945381165,
-1.1501611471176147,
-0.9256141185760498,
-0.48312729597091675,
-0.26294901967048645,
-0.1494886577129364,
0.3667623996734619,
0.5733909606933594,
0.7163059711456299,
-0.2910754680633545,
-0.5707423686981201,
0.3949598968029022,
0.12414413690567017,
-0.5935031175613403,
-0.1645362824201584,
0.43178895115852356,
0.15439993143081665,
-0.4337364137172699,
0.49751999974250793,
0.46406978368759155,
-0.36871573328971863,
-0.4826546013355255,
-0.3498535752296448,
0.25022104382514954,
-0.37825238704681396,
1.190097689628601,
0.3120179772377014,
-0.8661063313484192,
-0.2470550537109375,
0.03824882581830025,
0.40868598222732544,
0.09857291728258133,
1.036467432975769,
-0.7536195516586304,
0.8974310755729675,
0.5520117878913879,
0.5852085947990417,
1.0341386795043945,
-0.17787566781044006,
0.33267518877983093,
-0.5129826664924622,
0.23640571534633636,
0.017251037061214447,
0.5418516397476196,
0.18127982318401337,
-0.27307814359664917,
0.36422380805015564,
0.024086114019155502,
-0.5861470699310303,
-0.914097011089325,
0.31572794914245605,
-1.3939114809036255,
-0.1375301629304886,
1.0147149562835693,
-0.28901445865631104,
-0.1536703109741211,
0.0015641215723007917,
-0.10778003931045532,
0.4977327883243561,
-0.2892955243587494,
0.5360596776008606,
0.5516429543495178,
-0.362710565328598,
-0.4288046360015869,
-0.8161597847938538,
0.2682540714740753,
0.33564454317092896,
-0.5099442005157471,
0.24978716671466827,
0.38745900988578796,
0.24868495762348175,
-0.28505972027778625,
0.43567660450935364,
0.08204612880945206,
0.7548962831497192,
-0.14506135880947113,
-0.27521654963493347,
-0.40257832407951355,
-0.5220276713371277,
-0.32984521985054016,
0.37153974175453186,
-0.07706530392169952,
-0.6242105960845947
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.04244v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.04244v1
|
Benchmark Data Contamination of Large Language Models: A Survey
| 2024-06-06T16:41:39 | 2024-06-06T16:41:39 |
Cheng Xu, Shuhao Guan, Derek Greene, M-Tahar Kechadi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The rapid development of Large Language Models (LLMs) like GPT-4, Claude-3,
and Gemini has transformed the field of natural language processing. However,
it has also resulted in a significant issue known as Benchmark Data
Contamination (BDC). This occurs when language models inadvertently incorporate
evaluation benchmark information from their training data, leading to
inaccurate or unreliable performance during the evaluation phase of the
process. This paper reviews the complex challenge of BDC in LLM evaluation and
explores alternative assessment methods to mitigate the risks associated with
traditional benchmarks. The paper also examines challenges and future
directions in mitigating BDC risks, highlighting the complexity of the issue
and the need for innovative solutions to ensure the reliability of LLM
evaluation in real-world applications.
|
[
-0.4876956045627594,
-0.8158985376358032,
0.6838988065719604,
0.06795183569192886,
-0.07631760835647583,
0.22026427090168,
-0.2940114438533783,
-0.8533911108970642,
-0.608798086643219,
0.823440670967102,
-0.43607720732688904,
-0.35609206557273865,
-0.899028480052948,
-0.1712561845779419,
-0.5649021863937378,
0.8877452611923218,
-0.3486317992210388,
-0.06229110062122345,
-0.3929814398288727,
-0.205781027674675,
-0.5337094664573669,
-0.7944614887237549,
-0.6244081258773804,
-0.383646696805954,
0.2124452292919159,
0.34949201345443726,
0.5714686512947083,
0.669347882270813,
0.7565409541130066,
0.30312904715538025,
-0.2698805630207062,
-0.012771067209541798,
-0.5938138961791992,
0.2924465835094452,
-0.26981282234191895,
-0.47042855620384216,
-0.30160412192344666,
0.13794566690921783,
0.6990265846252441,
1.0388106107711792,
-0.29670456051826477,
0.21698172390460968,
0.028675220906734467,
0.8297259211540222,
-0.8581135272979736,
0.16566026210784912,
-0.6756335496902466,
-0.2745742201805115,
-0.44227635860443115,
0.04104115441441536,
-0.2963067293167114,
-0.6299272775650024,
-0.014288533478975296,
-0.056563422083854675,
0.16490647196769714,
-0.1316329687833786,
0.7575384974479675,
0.3234403729438782,
-0.3658526837825775,
-0.14448900520801544,
-0.9796017408370972,
0.9062495231628418,
-0.6568514704704285,
0.2421838492155075,
0.4075931906700134,
0.6910549998283386,
-0.2679467499256134,
-0.6991541385650635,
-0.5684466361999512,
-0.018335068598389626,
0.3286864161491394,
-0.16575051844120026,
-0.3033515512943268,
-0.22179019451141357,
0.4711410403251648,
0.22239235043525696,
-0.36037150025367737,
0.45765528082847595,
-0.3719392418861389,
-0.2750469744205475,
0.6460766792297363,
0.49061664938926697,
0.32714977860450745,
-0.24422284960746765,
-0.41601312160491943,
-0.19469299912452698,
-1.3882097005844116,
-0.10712283104658127,
0.5694394707679749,
0.17762741446495056,
0.1411580592393875,
0.452835351228714,
-0.15277062356472015,
0.7300933599472046,
-0.3423059284687042,
0.10655531287193298,
0.25878411531448364,
-0.5166570544242859,
-0.3219970166683197,
0.04452585056424141,
0.662776529788971,
0.38804376125335693,
0.3777346909046173,
-0.2414953112602234,
-0.15846659243106842,
0.17853619158267975,
0.17398644983768463,
-0.7377238273620605,
0.07595265656709671,
0.43699219822883606,
-0.04787672683596611,
-0.27486127614974976,
-0.01716461032629013,
-0.9035677909851074,
-0.5340735912322998,
-0.297403484582901,
0.32481256127357483,
-0.09991715103387833,
-0.26575323939323425,
-0.020798733457922935,
0.08620085567235947,
-0.009460612200200558,
0.3073139786720276,
-0.9528607130050659,
0.5440502762794495,
0.8016802668571472,
0.42796775698661804,
-0.22906725108623505,
-0.19748413562774658,
-0.48463407158851624,
0.3955863416194916,
-0.3537559509277344,
0.6753478050231934,
-0.44093602895736694,
-0.7751801013946533,
0.06414967775344849,
-0.12070168554782867,
0.2634650468826294,
-1.0576159954071045,
0.5711356997489929,
-0.31448063254356384,
-0.11452195793390274,
-0.3034452497959137,
-0.5290237665176392,
-0.02260435000061989,
0.2948683798313141,
-0.6536038517951965,
1.1340402364730835,
0.13268330693244934,
-0.8953559398651123,
0.42628246545791626,
-0.03544696047902107,
-0.37933051586151123,
0.12858541309833527,
-0.14780911803245544,
-0.45013728737831116,
-0.08652149140834808,
0.16091521084308624,
0.3772624135017395,
-0.5695298314094543,
0.3214811682701111,
-0.40230458974838257,
-0.5273642539978027,
0.2867143154144287,
-0.6300086379051208,
0.6019285917282104,
0.13311351835727692,
-0.4213469922542572,
-0.0028135008178651333,
-0.9405561089515686,
0.22246038913726807,
-0.16366663575172424,
-0.13747496902942657,
-0.2625739574432373,
-0.03579104691743851,
0.16027610003948212,
0.34946727752685547,
0.08347557485103607,
-0.44215789437294006,
-0.09447771310806274,
0.003437172854319215,
0.3367307186126709,
0.9567019939422607,
0.33933088183403015,
0.0917636901140213,
-0.565096378326416,
0.5454785227775574,
0.20144227147102356,
0.2640515863895416,
-0.0023102646227926016,
-0.4185309112071991,
-0.6826453804969788,
-0.08186835050582886,
0.33371293544769287,
0.3821004331111908,
-0.6394184231758118,
0.36169251799583435,
-0.3558497130870819,
-0.9472033977508545,
-0.6072350740432739,
0.31049320101737976,
0.41893285512924194,
0.5159845352172852,
0.412675142288208,
-0.34410297870635986,
-0.4148883819580078,
-0.8294705748558044,
-0.4516277313232422,
0.01788206957280636,
-0.0400393083691597,
0.2318335473537445,
0.43286728858947754,
-0.5197895765304565,
0.8141124248504639,
-0.34633538126945496,
-0.16114266216754913,
-0.28007739782333374,
0.23399318754673004,
0.1852082908153534,
0.690384566783905,
0.28237462043762207,
-0.4396825134754181,
-0.41567856073379517,
-0.2294287383556366,
-0.5417270064353943,
-0.3267398178577423,
-0.033914633095264435,
0.18178695440292358,
0.0725768432021141,
0.7815300226211548,
-0.5891550779342651,
0.31195664405822754,
0.6741471290588379,
0.2343030869960785,
0.9426649808883667,
-0.13504809141159058,
0.01340764481574297,
-0.5389043092727661,
0.23557758331298828,
0.16168424487113953,
-0.21926987171173096,
-0.5965067148208618,
0.09370721876621246,
0.21019206941127777,
0.06417185068130493,
-0.5688535571098328,
0.5623379945755005,
-0.3266879618167877,
-0.16776616871356964,
-0.07642275094985962,
0.38139253854751587,
-0.030847299844026566,
-0.11665423959493637,
-0.26958540081977844,
0.6986182332038879,
0.5803505778312683,
-0.44784295558929443,
0.4089326858520508,
0.2603209614753723,
-0.8961026072502136,
0.4976104199886322,
-0.6078926920890808,
0.1844051480293274,
0.07477981597185135,
0.26863893866539,
-0.8807551860809326,
0.20163337886333466,
0.053634122014045715,
-0.15307851135730743,
0.5285370349884033,
-0.12097352743148804,
-0.8664337992668152,
-0.14341695606708527,
-0.2153053730726242,
0.34406712651252747,
0.4220442473888397,
-0.7177892923355103,
-0.14791443943977356,
0.24343594908714294,
-0.2952568531036377,
-0.5864089131355286,
-0.820455014705658,
0.2562645971775055,
-0.29162365198135376,
-0.5530688166618347,
0.19959072768688202,
-0.11126969754695892,
-0.43950343132019043,
-0.02281293086707592,
-0.3044252395629883,
0.07254403829574585,
0.3181624114513397,
0.3734428882598877,
0.240408256649971,
0.0638352707028389,
-0.08689087629318237,
-0.24402223527431488,
-0.10834914445877075,
0.29580190777778625,
0.44439882040023804,
0.5511761903762817,
0.20407608151435852,
-0.4553050994873047,
-0.3564496636390686,
0.08948300033807755,
0.5481621623039246,
-0.2281527817249298,
0.6007335186004639,
0.2856217622756958,
-0.4662030041217804,
-0.28269997239112854,
-0.6991881132125854,
0.06665541976690292,
-0.533820390701294,
0.3901642858982086,
-0.18571624159812927,
-0.5201468467712402,
0.3392406702041626,
-0.2675676643848419,
-0.38539719581604004,
0.22493766248226166,
0.5760105848312378,
-0.02478335052728653,
0.7883541584014893,
0.5636855363845825,
-0.2002788931131363,
0.3222072422504425,
-0.2762599289417267,
0.17732825875282288,
-1.0888162851333618,
-0.19501812756061554,
-0.7493026256561279,
-0.0846950113773346,
-0.7133787870407104,
-0.5688325762748718,
0.14764003455638885,
-0.08689206093549728,
-0.31328871846199036,
0.2165617048740387,
-0.02137114480137825,
0.4587411880493164,
0.24483737349510193,
-0.06102309748530388,
0.48318567872047424,
-0.36325934529304504,
-0.33086010813713074,
-0.13252989947795868,
-0.36149391531944275,
-0.6065081357955933,
1.261029601097107,
0.39773064851760864,
0.8588402271270752,
0.07826374471187592,
0.7169603705406189,
0.06331775337457657,
0.5292682647705078,
-0.2808583080768585,
0.4638150632381439,
0.011725892312824726,
-0.8747544884681702,
-0.3008752763271332,
-0.7791697382926941,
-0.7663466930389404,
0.1876370757818222,
0.007275341544300318,
-1.1378124952316284,
0.2301633059978485,
-0.42212748527526855,
0.1073806881904602,
0.22503618896007538,
-0.5948117971420288,
0.8974349498748779,
-0.31803616881370544,
-0.6467809081077576,
-0.12094341218471527,
-0.5003368258476257,
0.6426011919975281,
-0.5096626281738281,
0.4240044951438904,
-0.1868506222963333,
0.193038672208786,
0.5912097692489624,
-0.49818021059036255,
0.6327241063117981,
-0.09147495031356812,
-0.09606046974658966,
0.05415591597557068,
0.1737031191587448,
0.6654760837554932,
-0.05069081485271454,
-0.21801219880580902,
0.15738289058208466,
-0.04170213267207146,
-0.43358129262924194,
-0.35969147086143494,
0.8281248211860657,
-0.7801418304443359,
-0.663654625415802,
-0.5366129875183105,
-0.47016414999961853,
-0.7665571570396423,
0.1115233525633812,
0.18534120917320251,
0.26345181465148926,
-0.22318799793720245,
0.17512233555316925,
0.281338095664978,
-0.38456830382347107,
0.6248188018798828,
0.5579178333282471,
-0.040389709174633026,
-0.24234922230243683,
0.8662919402122498,
0.17822977900505066,
0.6794438362121582,
-0.059340089559555054,
-0.08155380189418793,
-0.2859291732311249,
-1.0305557250976562,
-0.1263348013162613,
0.2340162843465805,
-0.8392994403839111,
-0.1599036455154419,
-0.37863507866859436,
-0.23500578105449677,
-0.19948984682559967,
0.16676096618175507,
-0.4838108718395233,
-0.1579296886920929,
-0.15863828361034393,
-0.3589770495891571,
0.029242444783449173,
0.8444898724555969,
0.02516898885369301,
0.46284937858581543,
-0.767655611038208,
0.1909695416688919,
0.20422068238258362,
0.6412127614021301,
0.11730623245239258,
-0.20789340138435364,
-0.17802658677101135,
-0.009617296978831291,
-0.36622413992881775,
-0.5179165005683899,
0.27975785732269287,
-0.1660565584897995,
0.9592292308807373,
0.46583056449890137,
-0.12372873723506927,
0.6080048084259033,
-0.48281121253967285,
0.6451350450515747,
0.2792811989784241,
-1.0339746475219727,
0.25232037901878357,
-0.3959766626358032,
0.35397133231163025,
0.6757079362869263,
0.4563963711261749,
-0.8700608015060425,
-0.650269627571106,
-0.60360187292099,
-1.0171250104904175,
0.5229039192199707,
0.1570800542831421,
-0.13736078143119812,
0.009867754764854908,
0.15027716755867004,
0.09848401695489883,
0.2568358778953552,
-0.42306968569755554,
-0.07125672698020935,
0.1242252066731453,
0.07995933294296265,
-0.541950523853302,
-0.38688451051712036,
-0.12054244428873062,
-0.02138206921517849,
0.5220317244529724,
0.21660740673542023,
-0.332792192697525,
-0.19942833483219147,
-0.4032841622829437,
-0.34986305236816406,
0.26999011635780334,
0.33176401257514954,
0.8996068239212036,
-0.25896987318992615,
0.08667776733636856,
0.11091642081737518,
-0.4438859820365906,
0.21700289845466614,
0.048192404210567474,
0.04904790222644806,
-0.3718396723270416,
0.4022359848022461,
0.3362864851951599,
0.34989097714424133,
-0.8031274676322937,
0.4098506569862366,
-0.05783404782414436,
0.09665534645318985,
-0.12687626481056213,
0.06675834953784943,
0.30830541253089905,
-0.12685367465019226,
0.4068581163883209,
0.028669167309999466,
-0.08674363791942596,
-0.9174900054931641,
0.42206281423568726,
0.2756221294403076,
-0.5059359669685364,
0.022206733003258705,
0.5862143635749817,
0.03936098888516426,
0.1477188915014267,
0.6313063502311707,
0.1870555877685547,
-0.5557768940925598,
0.8821170330047607,
0.40189117193222046,
0.5993875861167908,
-0.3715653121471405,
-0.011548297479748726,
0.01273519080132246,
0.6325316429138184,
-0.20177008211612701,
0.19006916880607605,
0.38849925994873047,
-0.7623154520988464,
-0.42529723048210144,
-0.4729152023792267,
-0.8451142311096191,
0.32384946942329407,
-0.6666368842124939,
0.3647385239601135,
-0.6774263978004456,
-0.07081086188554764,
0.09476419538259506,
0.22425834834575653,
-0.730614423751831,
0.24833931028842926,
0.2826448082923889,
0.9020392298698425,
-0.8363505601882935,
0.9625557661056519,
0.13249355554580688,
-0.41913700103759766,
-0.49280011653900146,
-0.0067418827675282955,
0.07894359529018402,
-0.557564914226532,
0.7691428661346436,
0.23379464447498322,
0.17895403504371643,
-0.22614578902721405,
-0.22914505004882812,
-0.6904850006103516,
0.7969882488250732,
0.34072020649909973,
-0.5825978517532349,
0.4041890501976013,
0.4245105981826782,
0.6382285952568054,
0.029103068634867668,
0.20351369678974152,
1.0965126752853394,
0.7924028038978577,
-0.16287581622600555,
-0.9059993028640747,
0.31868502497673035,
-0.04174727573990822,
-0.007571698632091284,
0.29165419936180115,
-0.6029379367828369,
0.6963481903076172,
-0.06279857456684113,
-0.1909182369709015,
0.22397731244564056,
0.03499070927500725,
0.3048059940338135,
0.09083554893732071,
0.2478773295879364,
0.6926056146621704,
0.7705488801002502,
-0.2942731976509094,
1.0735164880752563,
0.04685463383793831,
0.3328709900379181,
1.3000823259353638,
-0.783440351486206,
0.9689379334449768,
0.4751588702201843,
-0.506104588508606,
0.15855085849761963,
0.6099507808685303,
-0.41630929708480835,
0.3694179654121399,
0.7124088406562805,
-0.3155994713306427,
0.1261914074420929,
0.005413616541773081,
-0.37435442209243774,
0.5826475024223328,
0.5369744896888733,
-0.03232944384217262,
-0.40068867802619934,
-0.18172571063041687,
0.03080156072974205,
0.21211151778697968,
-0.1581377238035202,
0.5323452949523926,
-0.008454008027911186,
-0.49988219141960144,
0.578973114490509,
0.02064918912947178,
0.425896555185318,
-0.3507445454597473,
0.05708489567041397,
-0.3656017482280731,
0.2645947337150574,
-0.30372488498687744,
-0.567018985748291,
0.3292584717273712,
-0.03658531233668327,
0.11279138177633286,
-0.30774152278900146,
0.36477887630462646,
-0.34986791014671326,
-0.38073065876960754,
0.6606667041778564,
0.6171927452087402,
0.11227785795927048,
-0.12088697403669357,
-0.44197410345077515,
0.3978572189807892,
-0.37184906005859375,
-0.09405539184808731,
0.6390232443809509,
0.2694562077522278,
0.006970916409045458,
1.012173056602478,
0.7525011897087097,
0.49810633063316345,
0.1666579693555832,
0.18778541684150696,
0.8901190757751465,
-0.6907641887664795,
-0.12027723342180252,
-0.8403237462043762,
0.12370441854000092,
0.06089404225349426,
-0.04969973862171173,
0.6748594641685486,
0.6249843835830688,
0.6342592239379883,
0.20792075991630554,
0.9101730585098267,
0.30077630281448364,
0.6026236414909363,
-0.40856310725212097,
0.9977872967720032,
-0.14765623211860657,
0.6464720964431763,
-0.6385727524757385,
-1.046356201171875,
-0.3384605050086975,
-0.09838129580020905,
-0.44236546754837036,
0.27690717577934265,
1.0182538032531738,
0.5537714958190918,
0.09496121108531952,
-0.005844435654580593,
0.5366781949996948,
0.4091187119483948,
0.6438438892364502,
0.5870097279548645,
0.9480097889900208,
-0.23932620882987976,
0.7840986847877502,
-0.4276401400566101,
-0.1349221020936966,
-0.2830732762813568,
-0.9932152628898621,
-0.7165520787239075,
-0.3237954080104828,
-0.4081059992313385,
-0.22558173537254333,
0.18787194788455963,
0.23150356113910675,
0.41870465874671936,
-0.8897223472595215,
-0.3354693353176117,
-0.08509644120931625,
0.3703896701335907,
-0.30511948466300964,
-0.18587911128997803,
0.3900853991508484,
-0.3586764633655548,
-0.8098481297492981,
0.38942545652389526,
0.05970823019742966,
0.12026363611221313,
-0.3543509840965271,
0.31842032074928284,
-0.0797143429517746,
-0.24500583112239838,
0.24366705119609833,
0.17332051694393158,
-0.3780228793621063,
-0.4933110177516937,
-0.5510340929031372,
-0.2588386535644531,
-0.05109294131398201,
0.6363422274589539,
-0.7588382959365845,
0.47670668363571167,
0.1991693377494812,
0.7714611291885376,
0.671075701713562,
0.0181549284607172,
0.8460950255393982,
-0.7499500513076782,
0.16242296993732452,
0.12044014036655426,
0.4420475363731384,
0.6794052124023438,
-0.3544035255908966,
0.5851786732673645,
0.19316881895065308,
-0.4408380389213562,
-1.0709800720214844,
0.16732296347618103,
-0.9469980597496033,
-0.245216965675354,
1.2620618343353271,
-0.2602369487285614,
-0.10757036507129669,
-0.30211368203163147,
0.15647390484809875,
0.09070567041635513,
0.03552084043622017,
0.9075644612312317,
1.1531867980957031,
0.10128645598888397,
-0.172324538230896,
-1.1199039220809937,
0.43950286507606506,
0.23511531949043274,
-1.0452914237976074,
0.45732247829437256,
0.2685811221599579,
0.57087242603302,
-0.17584827542304993,
0.16117791831493378,
-0.5795000791549683,
0.2921428382396698,
0.007252224255353212,
0.09488067030906677,
0.023766813799738884,
-0.12238837778568268,
-0.47525420784950256,
0.022963089868426323,
0.23085945844650269,
-0.006686042528599501
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.04240v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.04240v4
|
Hypernetworks for Personalizing ASR to Atypical Speech
| 2024-06-06T16:39:00 | 2024-07-02T19:51:54 |
Max Müller-Eberstein, Dianna Yee, Karren Yang, Gautam Varma Mantena, Colin Lea
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Parameter-efficient fine-tuning (PEFT) for personalizing automatic speech
recognition (ASR) has recently shown promise for adapting general population
models to atypical speech. However, these approaches assume a priori knowledge
of the atypical speech disorder being adapted for -- the diagnosis of which
requires expert knowledge that is not always available. Even given this
knowledge, data scarcity and high inter/intra-speaker variability further limit
the effectiveness of traditional fine-tuning. To circumvent these challenges,
we first identify the minimal set of model parameters required for ASR
adaptation. Our analysis of each individual parameter's effect on adaptation
performance allows us to reduce Word Error Rate (WER) by half while adapting
0.03% of all weights. Alleviating the need for cohort-specific models, we next
propose the novel use of a meta-learned hypernetwork to generate highly
individualized, utterance-level adaptations on-the-fly for a diverse set of
atypical speech characteristics. Evaluating adaptation at the global, cohort
and individual-level, we show that hypernetworks generalize better to
out-of-distribution speakers, while maintaining an overall relative WER
reduction of 75.2% using 0.1% of the full parameter budget.
|
[
-0.45976462960243225,
-0.4205559194087982,
0.1860053837299347,
0.12807081639766693,
-0.22278618812561035,
0.02920534275472164,
-0.3590751588344574,
-0.347532719373703,
0.45261168479919434,
0.5132643580436707,
-0.39416298270225525,
-0.3422475755214691,
-0.47204479575157166,
0.024408452212810516,
-0.42393139004707336,
0.8250296115875244,
0.296277791261673,
-0.1497838944196701,
0.1536228358745575,
-0.10874176025390625,
-0.2011297345161438,
-0.4756845235824585,
-0.9276580810546875,
-0.45233282446861267,
0.4278567433357239,
0.8106678128242493,
0.672781229019165,
0.9670115113258362,
0.432635635137558,
0.3193996846675873,
-0.20775218307971954,
-0.04553060606122017,
-0.432367205619812,
-0.04237072542309761,
-0.41126739978790283,
-0.1357513666152954,
-0.6866432428359985,
-0.21052151918411255,
0.7791503667831421,
0.8763473033905029,
-0.4277587831020355,
0.3439795970916748,
0.19327424466609955,
0.5870595574378967,
-0.7738003134727478,
-0.138522669672966,
-0.9070367217063904,
0.009800595231354237,
-0.41359031200408936,
-0.42601874470710754,
-0.005578466225415468,
-0.028477918356657028,
0.2700887620449066,
-0.857011616230011,
0.4723338186740875,
0.13015834987163544,
0.4460847079753876,
0.471550315618515,
-0.0797254666686058,
-0.08629962056875229,
-0.9585620164871216,
0.5310289263725281,
-0.5711747407913208,
0.5826092958450317,
0.8311265707015991,
0.3555546700954437,
-0.10376273840665817,
-0.8149646520614624,
-0.2929280400276184,
-0.1933068335056305,
0.2398383617401123,
0.02132788859307766,
-0.4362379312515259,
0.30370286107063293,
0.16687177121639252,
0.1935015469789505,
-0.7398334741592407,
0.2405659556388855,
-0.5445900559425354,
-0.40767809748649597,
0.49724215269088745,
0.184188112616539,
-0.07743411511182785,
0.12504006922245026,
-0.12987862527370453,
-0.005654945038259029,
-0.5092171430587769,
0.02218097448348999,
0.4925732910633087,
0.620252788066864,
0.11353331804275513,
0.1746256798505783,
-0.44611555337905884,
0.7344106435775757,
0.42863062024116516,
-0.005143459420651197,
0.33789846301078796,
-0.027394210919737816,
-0.07370100170373917,
0.37776559591293335,
0.6186025142669678,
0.08425618708133698,
0.47298353910446167,
-0.1481451690196991,
-0.18072769045829773,
-0.4070861041545868,
0.2734244465827942,
-0.5617321133613586,
-0.4582366943359375,
-0.0003314884379506111,
-0.3980983793735504,
-0.09765253216028214,
-0.2782328724861145,
-0.4067617654800415,
-0.5144941210746765,
-0.5121803879737854,
0.5424266457557678,
-0.22621898353099823,
-0.01127778273075819,
0.18581806123256683,
-0.3085024654865265,
-0.3020631968975067,
0.24693337082862854,
-0.9398455619812012,
0.7397977709770203,
0.2811303734779358,
0.6867877840995789,
-0.15983892977237701,
-0.40215158462524414,
-0.8009302616119385,
0.44439026713371277,
-0.029559100046753883,
0.8604408502578735,
-0.49290066957473755,
-0.31273379921913147,
-0.38114994764328003,
-0.09975951910018921,
-0.33653196692466736,
-0.85112065076828,
0.6214600205421448,
-0.23375268280506134,
-0.06410786509513855,
-0.28760990500450134,
-0.3356252610683441,
0.07788459956645966,
-0.07772182673215866,
-0.3710296154022217,
0.2960955500602722,
-0.09520844370126724,
-0.6181541085243225,
0.2310582399368286,
-0.7856685519218445,
-0.4117567539215088,
0.1597755402326584,
-0.08638688921928406,
-0.3473219871520996,
0.3597559332847595,
0.12735871970653534,
0.28337714076042175,
-0.32515454292297363,
0.175733283162117,
-0.28536874055862427,
-0.6150626540184021,
0.12047754973173141,
-0.48775121569633484,
0.4208986461162567,
0.26891493797302246,
-0.11749999970197678,
0.1930699348449707,
-1.114661693572998,
0.13914278149604797,
-0.21174651384353638,
-0.613827109336853,
-0.30047541856765747,
0.2947711646556854,
0.2877035439014435,
-0.03803220018744469,
0.04625428095459938,
-0.4724348187446594,
-0.3857387602329254,
-0.7030779123306274,
0.44215404987335205,
0.6333541870117188,
-0.018494348973035812,
0.16514380276203156,
-0.4079221785068512,
0.28207242488861084,
-0.07112167030572891,
0.10829194635152817,
0.16291293501853943,
-0.36361178755760193,
-0.67093825340271,
-0.42313313484191895,
0.32445767521858215,
0.5171833634376526,
-0.5042539238929749,
0.5588886737823486,
-0.12113010138273239,
-0.28383317589759827,
-0.4381371736526489,
0.155984029173851,
0.5876144766807556,
0.7366108298301697,
0.5553597807884216,
-0.5344113707542419,
-0.6574596166610718,
-1.0040276050567627,
-0.4928009510040283,
-0.18731200695037842,
-0.28879451751708984,
0.17492564022541046,
0.12530012428760529,
-0.18665367364883423,
0.9105156660079956,
-0.3786614239215851,
-0.3247261643409729,
-0.00578285800293088,
0.10489599406719208,
0.24764962494373322,
0.5453819036483765,
0.23154917359352112,
-0.6610187292098999,
-0.4151242971420288,
0.00920043420046568,
-0.08136474341154099,
-0.18735148012638092,
0.15955474972724915,
0.27194055914878845,
-0.20627760887145996,
0.5725449323654175,
-0.12039162218570709,
0.4318045973777771,
0.46141064167022705,
-0.5243119597434998,
0.42775461077690125,
-0.5953705906867981,
-0.03334252908825874,
-0.9124740362167358,
0.27276885509490967,
0.097002774477005,
-0.32528048753738403,
-0.9158573150634766,
-0.2122635543346405,
-0.18999852240085602,
-0.3937024772167206,
-0.3779677152633667,
0.40440836548805237,
-0.2035909742116928,
-0.050569988787174225,
-0.5407832264900208,
-0.21765482425689697,
-0.30196520686149597,
0.4281056225299835,
-0.03822185471653938,
0.629067063331604,
0.5579502582550049,
-0.7663753628730774,
0.33797311782836914,
0.29954496026039124,
0.01719064638018608,
0.48306694626808167,
-0.7849463224411011,
0.35323095321655273,
0.024082070216536522,
0.10083065927028656,
-0.7397305965423584,
-0.3882298767566681,
0.31380167603492737,
-0.41877540946006775,
0.37237364053726196,
-0.17877866327762604,
-0.13528122007846832,
-0.2621186375617981,
-0.09023478627204895,
0.23905165493488312,
0.3636808395385742,
-0.41565409302711487,
0.5507757067680359,
0.2799223065376282,
-0.3316393792629242,
-0.29044586420059204,
-0.5831401944160461,
0.2161298394203186,
-0.2777164578437805,
-0.3923456072807312,
0.6319253444671631,
-0.16478386521339417,
-0.07362627983093262,
-0.09567109495401382,
-0.1827830672264099,
-0.36825037002563477,
0.04438793659210205,
0.045752450823783875,
-0.4161672592163086,
-0.3545859158039093,
0.10743365436792374,
0.1048276275396347,
-0.4417363405227661,
-0.17575249075889587,
-0.3972533643245697,
0.36115431785583496,
-0.13884510099887848,
-0.40478241443634033,
-0.7184939384460449,
0.374961256980896,
0.6195424795150757,
-0.20776836574077606,
0.3409666121006012,
0.8386503458023071,
-0.5755001306533813,
-0.01212348323315382,
-0.5163379907608032,
-0.11534728109836578,
-0.5335102081298828,
0.6237424612045288,
-0.44488948583602905,
-0.7132812738418579,
0.5735782384872437,
0.047483135014772415,
-0.3267556428909302,
0.20330607891082764,
0.6427531242370605,
-0.15398655831813812,
0.8466408252716064,
0.6627969741821289,
-0.24023815989494324,
0.5731214284896851,
0.17335709929466248,
-0.14835995435714722,
-0.8457689881324768,
0.09383305162191391,
-0.7145950794219971,
-0.3943619430065155,
-0.508322536945343,
-0.13028958439826965,
0.559401273727417,
-0.23727184534072876,
-0.48509421944618225,
0.18819881975650787,
-0.48609790205955505,
0.5921989679336548,
0.7258129119873047,
0.4141450524330139,
0.2970450818538666,
0.25352683663368225,
0.24438700079917908,
0.03699891269207001,
-0.7450794577598572,
-0.18739943206310272,
1.139533281326294,
0.28042417764663696,
0.6597115397453308,
0.09140226244926453,
0.5407907962799072,
0.45626991987228394,
-0.1675717681646347,
-0.624028742313385,
0.23197627067565918,
-0.6822505593299866,
-0.6360023021697998,
-0.5647073984146118,
-0.47039154171943665,
-1.0203173160552979,
0.06136370450258255,
-0.1979304403066635,
-1.11046302318573,
0.5875954627990723,
0.7644175291061401,
-0.9386127591133118,
-0.0250087883323431,
-0.6567057371139526,
0.5605968236923218,
0.032036926597356796,
-0.1141747385263443,
-0.5076488256454468,
-0.8678218126296997,
-0.02554142475128174,
-0.5300862789154053,
0.10174503922462463,
-0.19403426349163055,
-0.1366311013698578,
0.9826269745826721,
-0.29359087347984314,
0.8274058699607849,
-0.48145586252212524,
0.4493505358695984,
0.0503673180937767,
-0.22455507516860962,
0.4357411861419678,
-0.15615032613277435,
-0.3627939224243164,
-0.09702830016613007,
0.00437255809083581,
-0.2050502449274063,
-0.5459332466125488,
0.596954882144928,
-0.9753456711769104,
-0.6325713992118835,
0.006174521986395121,
-0.6388269066810608,
-0.7068419456481934,
-0.02848811447620392,
0.4581272304058075,
0.7768511176109314,
-0.20240579545497894,
0.45837074518203735,
0.8377342820167542,
-0.22446535527706146,
0.2557200491428375,
0.6468017101287842,
0.22987467050552368,
-0.49159952998161316,
1.2436927556991577,
0.3954996168613434,
0.13140998780727386,
0.27374958992004395,
0.755317211151123,
-0.16360428929328918,
-0.9705264568328857,
-0.31037241220474243,
-0.008705510757863522,
-0.5809234380722046,
-0.024441387504339218,
-0.5134495496749878,
-0.10848046839237213,
-0.43576401472091675,
-0.17683382332324982,
-0.5020895600318909,
-0.465663343667984,
-0.6349387168884277,
0.33213770389556885,
0.33489400148391724,
0.2761681377887726,
-0.23117537796497345,
0.6808065176010132,
-0.641218364238739,
0.644722580909729,
0.3214339315891266,
0.4425303637981415,
-0.25402289628982544,
-1.16080904006958,
-0.3796903192996979,
-0.10020218789577484,
-0.2530733346939087,
-0.703546941280365,
0.3521929681301117,
0.9705187082290649,
0.5735225677490234,
0.4057961702346802,
0.12837131321430206,
0.8982987403869629,
-0.5149361491203308,
0.2741125524044037,
0.29073384404182434,
-0.9284000396728516,
0.4765664339065552,
-0.36450308561325073,
0.4501667022705078,
0.7835506796836853,
0.38723239302635193,
-0.5295048356056213,
-0.2387203574180603,
-0.6548708081245422,
-0.9120007753372192,
0.7872995734214783,
0.19978633522987366,
0.04785483703017235,
0.4848676025867462,
0.4467419683933258,
-0.11540983617305756,
0.11485994607210159,
-0.05776839330792427,
-0.12185321003198624,
-0.1650402843952179,
-0.4057072401046753,
-0.4921090602874756,
-0.002534847240895033,
-0.3863912522792816,
-0.831965982913971,
0.6135740876197815,
-0.4068348705768585,
0.23173707723617554,
0.15806902945041656,
0.04045712947845459,
-0.39220672845840454,
0.14339862763881683,
0.6423776745796204,
0.7421842217445374,
-0.3174521327018738,
0.16773055493831635,
0.5948805809020996,
-0.7266107201576233,
0.19775082170963287,
0.5288151502609253,
0.21552890539169312,
-0.07177800685167313,
0.27699023485183716,
0.9221002459526062,
0.11978097259998322,
-0.5286809206008911,
0.5109536647796631,
-0.07147914916276932,
-0.22178268432617188,
-0.2873506546020508,
0.3173646926879883,
0.13921423256397247,
0.39386847615242004,
0.4233691096305847,
0.4463561773300171,
0.4582241475582123,
-0.4327966570854187,
0.3566168248653412,
0.07395510375499725,
-0.5044969916343689,
-0.4721234142780304,
0.6220731139183044,
0.3315589129924774,
-0.77361661195755,
0.3931140601634979,
-0.04982440546154976,
-0.25227975845336914,
0.46354591846466064,
0.7297733426094055,
0.9654079675674438,
-0.48487207293510437,
-0.19748526811599731,
-0.02513408288359642,
0.1437498927116394,
0.028185103088617325,
0.16328132152557373,
-0.13924890756607056,
-0.7655216455459595,
-0.19257359206676483,
-0.5928110480308533,
-0.44162654876708984,
0.24339285492897034,
-0.7324203252792358,
0.3403068482875824,
-0.7412066459655762,
-0.2913495898246765,
0.13653618097305298,
-0.14381150901317596,
-0.5365446209907532,
0.49685153365135193,
0.3145298957824707,
0.747940182685852,
-0.7656821012496948,
0.8738535046577454,
0.9109913110733032,
0.08603758364915848,
-0.7316768765449524,
0.24087916314601898,
0.17263951897621155,
-0.8023918867111206,
0.13865743577480316,
-0.3369365334510803,
-0.2590395510196686,
0.41896820068359375,
-0.35085374116897583,
-1.1794553995132446,
0.8461495637893677,
0.7119631767272949,
-0.7242771983146667,
0.0785980150103569,
0.10765594244003296,
0.578231930732727,
-0.23996615409851074,
-0.00031477041193284094,
0.7147026658058167,
0.4013063907623291,
0.24041317403316498,
-1.4160292148590088,
-0.11560140550136566,
-0.146170511841774,
0.023830855265259743,
-0.04440813884139061,
-0.36474132537841797,
0.6082512140274048,
-0.1362895965576172,
0.0834987536072731,
-0.20932874083518982,
0.4968622624874115,
0.24337787926197052,
0.4751795828342438,
0.6586004495620728,
0.27475705742836,
0.9657415747642517,
0.25908181071281433,
0.6642657518386841,
-0.4129808247089386,
0.07483714818954468,
1.2437092065811157,
0.03140488266944885,
0.7664971351623535,
0.4141054153442383,
0.04442283511161804,
-0.02586725912988186,
0.5086454749107361,
0.22769778966903687,
0.5857043266296387,
0.3381544053554535,
-0.11981600522994995,
-0.371154248714447,
-0.1305023431777954,
-0.3511800765991211,
0.7289924621582031,
0.36637604236602783,
-0.37812554836273193,
-0.06496374309062958,
0.040876857936382294,
-0.16103452444076538,
-0.010432232171297073,
-0.5199859142303467,
0.7382504343986511,
0.09052851796150208,
-0.1717180609703064,
0.8371667265892029,
0.08257396519184113,
0.5648617744445801,
-0.6442978978157043,
0.3951730728149414,
0.07552904635667801,
0.3996994197368622,
-0.40956637263298035,
-0.3390263020992279,
0.6023688912391663,
0.1333012580871582,
-0.4010445177555084,
-0.13542824983596802,
0.9507625699043274,
-0.2968849837779999,
-0.41487354040145874,
0.05931906774640083,
0.5924190282821655,
0.25024086236953735,
-0.4530472457408905,
-0.8208737969398499,
-0.00692967651411891,
-0.08592809736728668,
-0.4067677855491638,
0.2858962118625641,
0.21184587478637695,
-0.03375820443034172,
0.6445667147636414,
0.6220778822898865,
0.2786283493041992,
-0.08409170806407928,
0.25064027309417725,
0.9044789671897888,
-0.49900397658348083,
-0.6082103848457336,
-0.6293957829475403,
0.34750500321388245,
0.14167346060276031,
-0.7043300271034241,
0.4145183563232422,
0.34339699149131775,
0.6434364914894104,
0.022683437913656235,
0.6988781690597534,
0.1763008087873459,
0.664250910282135,
-0.22882157564163208,
0.9191485643386841,
-0.7068434357643127,
-0.07478562742471695,
-0.40515536069869995,
-0.7074026465415955,
-0.4354541003704071,
0.4560016691684723,
-0.2905574440956116,
-0.09715445339679718,
0.47234046459198,
0.8341162204742432,
-0.22956562042236328,
0.03622879460453987,
0.6225374937057495,
0.07810288667678833,
0.13028870522975922,
0.41870322823524475,
0.7217345833778381,
-0.1818191260099411,
0.531027615070343,
-0.019904913380742073,
-0.4228798747062683,
-0.2895120084285736,
-0.6203691959381104,
-0.5225487351417542,
-0.5989094376564026,
-0.5241230130195618,
0.055815648287534714,
0.6084273457527161,
1.4168367385864258,
0.9970784783363342,
-0.8431556224822998,
-0.4556642472743988,
0.026390286162495613,
-0.25056177377700806,
-0.23724611103534698,
-0.035840947180986404,
0.2391236126422882,
-0.13433921337127686,
-0.3831946849822998,
0.7835628390312195,
0.09437965601682663,
0.017438217997550964,
0.14114691317081451,
-0.19087672233581543,
0.16517242789268494,
0.18858829140663147,
0.2625028192996979,
0.4956732988357544,
-0.30699431896209717,
-0.32313236594200134,
-0.29495498538017273,
0.26102349162101746,
0.13370484113693237,
0.801726222038269,
-0.6214699149131775,
0.4725896716117859,
0.3650017976760864,
0.5214803218841553,
0.45619019865989685,
0.1024467796087265,
0.6969420909881592,
-0.6763264536857605,
0.0733845978975296,
0.47100403904914856,
0.23975753784179688,
0.24549442529678345,
-0.3372876048088074,
0.037173107266426086,
0.5115159749984741,
-0.5093058347702026,
-0.7752246856689453,
0.12442784756422043,
-0.7226589322090149,
-0.08170729130506516,
1.0624706745147705,
-0.027702607214450836,
-0.01775810308754444,
-0.6068494915962219,
-0.06051037833094597,
0.2994702160358429,
-0.41623368859291077,
0.667966365814209,
0.3126428723335266,
-0.4431949555873871,
0.1919606477022171,
-0.24834829568862915,
0.5184287428855896,
0.32977837324142456,
-0.4574328660964966,
0.03770864009857178,
0.2543800175189972,
0.5463547110557556,
0.057593636214733124,
0.7330837249755859,
0.34077057242393494,
0.3578993082046509,
-0.03849603235721588,
0.17184343934059143,
-0.3413836359977722,
-0.5860587954521179,
-0.6394310593605042,
0.33398836851119995,
0.33923596143722534,
-0.25691840052604675
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.04233v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.04233v2
|
FairytaleQA Translated: Enabling Educational Question and Answer Generation in Less-Resourced Languages
| 2024-06-06T16:31:47 | 2024-06-24T15:39:17 |
Bernardo Leite, Tomás Freitas Osório, Henrique Lopes Cardoso
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Question Answering (QA) datasets are crucial in assessing reading
comprehension skills for both machines and humans. While numerous datasets have
been developed in English for this purpose, a noticeable void exists in
less-resourced languages. To alleviate this gap, our paper introduces
machine-translated versions of FairytaleQA, a renowned QA dataset designed to
assess and enhance narrative comprehension skills in young children. By
employing fine-tuned, modest-scale models, we establish benchmarks for both
Question Generation (QG) and QA tasks within the translated datasets. In
addition, we present a case study proposing a model for generating
question-answer pairs, with an evaluation incorporating quality metrics such as
question well-formedness, answerability, relevance, and children suitability.
Our evaluation prioritizes quantifying and describing error cases, along with
providing directions for future work. This paper contributes to the advancement
of QA and QG research in less-resourced languages, promoting accessibility and
inclusivity in the development of these models for reading comprehension. The
code and data is publicly available at
github.com/bernardoleite/fairytaleqa-translated.
|
[
-0.2614251375198364,
-0.690196692943573,
0.2542576193809509,
0.23486125469207764,
-0.22928322851657867,
0.1471063792705536,
0.26165956258773804,
-0.4171576499938965,
-0.18188969790935516,
0.5034298896789551,
-0.8491408824920654,
-0.11769028007984161,
-0.20889094471931458,
0.3612159788608551,
-0.46177512407302856,
0.8206918835639954,
-0.25076448917388916,
0.1488633155822754,
-0.6823631525039673,
0.005174973513931036,
-0.5139340758323669,
-0.1807420402765274,
-0.6562415361404419,
-0.15628843009471893,
0.38321542739868164,
0.7513957023620605,
0.6883571743965149,
0.6100524067878723,
0.12778928875923157,
0.1460532397031784,
0.05874129384756088,
0.3769563138484955,
-0.38813701272010803,
0.19014360010623932,
-0.05976606905460358,
-0.6401723027229309,
-0.24960274994373322,
-0.12403398752212524,
0.486249715089798,
0.7495285272598267,
0.007257274817675352,
0.6054533123970032,
0.38926932215690613,
0.6755726337432861,
-0.41932162642478943,
0.13800480961799622,
-0.4663046598434448,
0.17255239188671112,
0.10821325331926346,
-0.15742015838623047,
-0.1529839187860489,
-0.6317536234855652,
0.01858559250831604,
-0.7282471060752869,
0.32724258303642273,
0.009230664931237698,
0.6972114443778992,
0.24886897206306458,
-0.5845842361450195,
-0.4814412593841553,
-0.38051894307136536,
0.9594370126724243,
-0.5187649726867676,
0.3089155852794647,
0.7205161452293396,
0.1851038932800293,
0.17648781836032867,
-0.7858040928840637,
-0.6159310936927795,
0.14951089024543762,
-0.17121346294879913,
0.17981822788715363,
-0.31914612650871277,
-0.4430292248725891,
0.07082150131464005,
0.15215516090393066,
-0.8016347289085388,
-0.12218954414129257,
-0.4448440670967102,
0.03293473646044731,
0.641670823097229,
0.4041769504547119,
0.49029427766799927,
-0.5722425580024719,
0.04658987745642662,
-0.2217433601617813,
-0.6991173028945923,
0.38666263222694397,
0.3618317246437073,
0.35501885414123535,
-0.10766413807868958,
0.5194722414016724,
-0.3280424475669861,
0.5644662976264954,
0.0789923444390297,
-0.205717533826828,
0.07288726419210434,
-0.6468431949615479,
0.05164065212011337,
-0.014125359244644642,
0.5477204918861389,
0.29602164030075073,
0.27533280849456787,
-0.04823710769414902,
-0.25101399421691895,
-0.1677619367837906,
0.06640012562274933,
-1.0486048460006714,
-0.10589773952960968,
0.31105419993400574,
-0.38730719685554504,
-0.35721495747566223,
-0.37624937295913696,
-0.9086388945579529,
-0.20791944861412048,
-0.0500301867723465,
0.4162142276763916,
-0.4476238191127777,
-0.0866798385977745,
0.22448433935642242,
0.11993677914142609,
0.37545421719551086,
0.17219828069210052,
-1.0107266902923584,
0.09780702739953995,
0.41306474804878235,
0.32126399874687195,
0.02862965315580368,
-0.21581940352916718,
-0.46383148431777954,
-0.26235800981521606,
-0.8013205528259277,
0.643734872341156,
-0.35820600390434265,
-0.319626122713089,
0.09204135090112686,
-0.025797436013817787,
-0.16537171602249146,
-0.4766099452972412,
0.7890210747718811,
-0.7302924394607544,
0.7038083672523499,
-0.2654194235801697,
-0.26459842920303345,
-0.26431331038475037,
0.21976162493228912,
-0.5628986954689026,
0.8684165477752686,
0.31449347734451294,
-0.834625780582428,
0.24524545669555664,
-0.3012526035308838,
-0.40641289949417114,
0.25307077169418335,
0.11347305774688721,
-0.18908794224262238,
0.07992745190858841,
0.7226513624191284,
0.20309264957904816,
-0.396186888217926,
0.09838026016950607,
0.2595883011817932,
-0.06776858121156693,
0.26344266533851624,
-0.9153870344161987,
0.7956817150115967,
0.31081056594848633,
0.05308952555060387,
-0.23728768527507782,
-0.5341265201568604,
0.6293809413909912,
0.3271912634372711,
-0.21612074971199036,
-0.14568108320236206,
-0.03910592198371887,
0.2841433584690094,
0.3614722490310669,
0.5542144179344177,
-0.33581557869911194,
-0.12169291824102402,
-0.4770291745662689,
0.45931923389434814,
-0.06384652853012085,
0.2153104692697525,
0.23251058161258698,
-0.43355101346969604,
1.114713430404663,
-0.1751967817544937,
0.25517311692237854,
-0.346131294965744,
-0.5863029360771179,
-0.6484708189964294,
0.21099089086055756,
0.6323011517524719,
0.7201668620109558,
-1.4759063720703125,
0.1115826815366745,
-0.04926005378365517,
-0.5655544996261597,
-1.0664541721343994,
0.2662394940853119,
0.6219651699066162,
0.5704632997512817,
0.4052245318889618,
-0.01811249926686287,
-0.27365702390670776,
-0.7278977036476135,
-0.04375173896551132,
-0.5361691117286682,
-0.33677950501441956,
0.500593364238739,
0.34616991877555847,
0.14131343364715576,
0.7048075199127197,
-0.26472949981689453,
0.24579839408397675,
-0.21594084799289703,
-0.06125007942318916,
0.22115284204483032,
0.48933249711990356,
0.4806795120239258,
-0.9650862216949463,
-0.554940938949585,
-0.09220936894416809,
-0.8209632039070129,
-0.21122802793979645,
-0.06097516417503357,
-0.1947944015264511,
-0.02513311430811882,
0.08078096807003021,
-0.5736278295516968,
-0.02075337991118431,
0.7424153685569763,
-0.5968443155288696,
0.6495145559310913,
0.028806937858462334,
0.6343058347702026,
-1.1954691410064697,
0.06960254907608032,
-0.3248085081577301,
-0.3184986710548401,
-0.6291319131851196,
0.39530089497566223,
0.22052395343780518,
-0.22901281714439392,
-0.7530906796455383,
0.6196766495704651,
-0.08499347418546677,
0.06120186299085617,
0.06287220120429993,
0.40454405546188354,
0.36956918239593506,
0.11230403184890747,
-0.05226776376366615,
1.1865414381027222,
0.3774595260620117,
-0.3361934423446655,
0.3216964900493622,
0.7127188444137573,
-0.18854151666164398,
0.8723250031471252,
-0.7902453541755676,
0.17660823464393616,
0.08434540778398514,
-0.20426853001117706,
-0.7246991991996765,
-0.34491437673568726,
0.289245069026947,
-0.7022093534469604,
0.05595044419169426,
-0.31218597292900085,
-0.7220965027809143,
-0.47145557403564453,
-0.07799378037452698,
0.4786677658557892,
0.7154505252838135,
-0.735567033290863,
0.06587632745504379,
0.14669480919837952,
-0.6802364587783813,
-0.4306519329547882,
-0.6304963827133179,
0.06598688662052155,
-0.2689257562160492,
-0.7458352446556091,
-0.034848086535930634,
-0.2153370976448059,
-0.11608815938234329,
0.13772298395633698,
-0.16781705617904663,
-0.5453628897666931,
0.09630101919174194,
-0.3276504576206207,
0.28803104162216187,
-0.6607798337936401,
0.33752986788749695,
0.626957893371582,
-0.0387028343975544,
0.14431390166282654,
-0.30530354380607605,
0.3297409415245056,
-0.11174584180116653,
-0.16676495969295502,
-0.10410505533218384,
0.5307958126068115,
0.33642709255218506,
-0.45386388897895813,
0.5889454483985901,
0.24236808717250824,
-0.42612817883491516,
-0.3447940945625305,
0.06560569256544113,
-0.1893567591905594,
-0.44405803084373474,
0.26318472623825073,
-0.45074155926704407,
-0.8034838438034058,
0.3370662033557892,
0.32754191756248474,
0.0815311074256897,
0.47819840908050537,
0.29011306166648865,
-0.3566153943538666,
1.1585301160812378,
0.38994577527046204,
0.3000693917274475,
-0.08871608972549438,
0.004641614854335785,
-0.07391326129436493,
-0.5140994787216187,
-0.15657629072666168,
-0.6739402413368225,
-0.09451855719089508,
-0.6819594502449036,
-0.46207624673843384,
0.37674662470817566,
0.6486489176750183,
0.13159078359603882,
0.20640596747398376,
-0.4790487587451935,
0.674996554851532,
0.49304792284965515,
-0.22021111845970154,
0.666160523891449,
-0.07691818475723267,
0.13557660579681396,
-0.24870027601718903,
-1.0501060485839844,
-1.0776945352554321,
1.0575401782989502,
0.12068622559309006,
0.42132318019866943,
-0.020798861980438232,
0.6892699599266052,
0.16238175332546234,
-0.10320104658603668,
-0.673762321472168,
0.33880728483200073,
-0.08881351351737976,
-0.6816039681434631,
-0.6043211221694946,
-0.5105509161949158,
-1.2967315912246704,
0.4067659378051758,
-0.3562321364879608,
-0.4467330574989319,
0.23728923499584198,
0.014483600854873657,
-0.39136773347854614,
-0.02721327543258667,
-0.7399855852127075,
1.0358362197875977,
-0.2820897102355957,
-0.31240659952163696,
-0.20148831605911255,
-0.30776989459991455,
0.3983030617237091,
-0.5634947419166565,
-0.051445938646793365,
0.10775420814752579,
-0.1350468248128891,
0.789770245552063,
-0.06559710949659348,
0.4949284493923187,
-0.031321194022893906,
-0.21743519604206085,
0.6657081246376038,
0.250769704580307,
0.21809890866279602,
0.33834221959114075,
-0.12358223646879196,
-0.20356377959251404,
0.8846943974494934,
-0.7781171202659607,
-0.404439240694046,
0.5217878222465515,
-0.7283014059066772,
-0.3647237718105316,
-0.19205810129642487,
-0.7297718524932861,
-0.4986322224140167,
0.14665289223194122,
0.04241650551557541,
0.19644176959991455,
-0.19565854966640472,
0.14473646879196167,
0.8232741951942444,
-0.5725708603858948,
0.32089126110076904,
0.8231388926506042,
-0.3469216823577881,
-0.14850109815597534,
0.9041547179222107,
0.1812397539615631,
0.09416438639163971,
0.13827303051948547,
-0.0379369892179966,
-0.4195995628833771,
-0.5143442153930664,
-0.8991769552230835,
0.08738156408071518,
-0.4772109389305115,
-0.27684780955314636,
-0.4269329607486725,
-0.35632309317588806,
-0.18434952199459076,
-0.12274854630231857,
-0.17848193645477295,
-0.6107484102249146,
-0.40390557050704956,
-0.2044660449028015,
0.3234708905220032,
0.6027488112449646,
0.05549311265349388,
0.16418400406837463,
-0.9316627383232117,
0.4956926703453064,
0.5937687754631042,
0.0038940319791436195,
-0.0015735559863969684,
-0.45924121141433716,
-0.32620540261268616,
0.1505005806684494,
-0.43659117817878723,
-0.8577563166618347,
0.5202966928482056,
0.08733201026916504,
0.19324436783790588,
0.02606976591050625,
0.32905814051628113,
0.34839117527008057,
-0.5501449108123779,
0.8295860886573792,
0.06108624488115311,
-0.8482347130775452,
0.4534328877925873,
-0.3329125940799713,
0.24575434625148773,
0.562099277973175,
0.34230470657348633,
-0.8701412081718445,
-0.17832031846046448,
-0.6945896148681641,
-0.6892464756965637,
0.6848354935646057,
0.35317787528038025,
0.480318158864975,
0.14845401048660278,
0.10169949382543564,
0.5223942995071411,
0.3505777418613434,
-0.19231966137886047,
-0.05739600956439972,
-0.38087984919548035,
-0.36433276534080505,
-0.08250308036804199,
-0.08476874232292175,
0.1292632520198822,
-0.11144835501909256,
0.650346040725708,
-0.2576923370361328,
-0.07109442353248596,
-0.04140907898545265,
-0.12804153561592102,
-0.3257943391799927,
0.4245305359363556,
-0.06868796795606613,
0.7370520234107971,
0.2591777741909027,
-0.19469979405403137,
0.19702398777008057,
-0.41113123297691345,
0.2340332269668579,
0.39308804273605347,
-0.6743106842041016,
-0.1631709337234497,
0.5863730311393738,
0.49560481309890747,
-0.19954000413417816,
-0.8680911064147949,
0.3402528166770935,
-0.2985461950302124,
-0.10630300641059875,
0.02264399453997612,
0.2264283001422882,
0.30685263872146606,
0.3906998336315155,
0.5046781301498413,
-0.4486163854598999,
0.07626761496067047,
-0.22646911442279816,
0.3968549072742462,
0.04547327384352684,
-0.3227418065071106,
-0.29442599415779114,
0.6526778340339661,
0.41532135009765625,
-0.3321393132209778,
0.7227184772491455,
-0.3458932340145111,
-0.1492989957332611,
0.7155940532684326,
0.4721474349498749,
0.8136635422706604,
-0.10459911823272705,
0.930560290813446,
0.39223775267601013,
0.6212639808654785,
0.327953577041626,
0.698552131652832,
-0.1197681725025177,
-0.6873427629470825,
-0.37967854738235474,
-0.6000353693962097,
-0.4904751479625702,
0.20106780529022217,
-0.7113670706748962,
-0.21159158647060394,
0.08268691599369049,
0.1544540971517563,
-0.34912458062171936,
0.37212711572647095,
-0.8611108660697937,
0.40682655572891235,
-0.06317462772130966,
0.7665683627128601,
-1.006072998046875,
0.622509777545929,
0.6763175129890442,
-0.6248761415481567,
-0.8373640775680542,
0.2349696159362793,
-0.6683765053749084,
-0.582813024520874,
0.20935212075710297,
-0.22912447154521942,
0.23742851614952087,
0.42282339930534363,
-0.6077390909194946,
-0.7105945348739624,
0.9661822319030762,
0.36733242869377136,
-0.346993625164032,
-0.01399835292249918,
0.4560334086418152,
0.8168148398399353,
-0.21595458686351776,
0.12482258677482605,
0.6566053032875061,
0.47472116351127625,
-0.014456050470471382,
-0.7186792492866516,
-0.26872339844703674,
-0.34429532289505005,
-0.23942303657531738,
-0.17730224132537842,
-0.4033885598182678,
0.5609904527664185,
-0.17002210021018982,
-0.3518964350223541,
0.42044752836227417,
0.7362983226776123,
0.39840856194496155,
0.5056482553482056,
0.09975360333919525,
0.2381124049425125,
0.93636155128479,
-0.17109991610050201,
0.9861709475517273,
-0.40858694911003113,
0.10717862099409103,
0.8646417856216431,
0.10454671829938889,
0.8444861769676208,
0.5654215216636658,
-0.33567801117897034,
0.1491604894399643,
1.0234959125518799,
0.21636100113391876,
0.4710518419742584,
0.05552767217159271,
-0.1893385499715805,
-0.39672648906707764,
-0.42883485555648804,
-0.30287131667137146,
0.17948634922504425,
0.11136796325445175,
-0.11507377028465271,
-0.23809191584587097,
-0.009730404242873192,
-0.007569341454654932,
0.4155994653701782,
-0.34512412548065186,
0.49593469500541687,
0.23847703635692596,
-0.6588214635848999,
0.8283605575561523,
0.04787057265639305,
0.35444512963294983,
-0.4973246157169342,
0.03133000433444977,
-0.7145465016365051,
-0.41951602697372437,
-0.14721806347370148,
-1.0815290212631226,
0.055596835911273956,
0.5351370573043823,
-0.2844325006008148,
-0.1861981451511383,
0.4567691385746002,
-0.6757097244262695,
-0.7760381698608398,
-0.10474807769060135,
1.2069569826126099,
0.14286378026008606,
0.32023534178733826,
-0.9045631289482117,
-0.40533125400543213,
0.023971116170287132,
-0.2300412356853485,
0.12802667915821075,
0.753731369972229,
-0.14481563866138458,
0.7290775775909424,
0.4480174481868744,
-0.0022812953684479,
0.21316218376159668,
-0.2617122530937195,
0.5110604166984558,
-0.26891669631004333,
-0.5634771585464478,
-0.14879103004932404,
0.6222843527793884,
0.31838953495025635,
-0.5166103839874268,
0.7560795545578003,
0.4510580897331238,
0.6664119362831116,
-0.2274685502052307,
0.7992920279502869,
-0.015052810311317444,
0.5264130234718323,
-0.4681262969970703,
0.9487099051475525,
-0.6207104921340942,
-0.13876032829284668,
-0.07853098213672638,
-0.9181959629058838,
0.09637532383203506,
0.2526528537273407,
-0.22495660185813904,
-0.04556694254279137,
0.7046277523040771,
0.6903538703918457,
0.0008961384301073849,
-0.004599119536578655,
0.5458821654319763,
-0.047865740954875946,
-0.0233678687363863,
0.8632412552833557,
1.1230437755584717,
-0.80763179063797,
0.7011338472366333,
-0.058245301246643066,
0.03428655490279198,
0.2392059564590454,
-0.5037007331848145,
-0.772044837474823,
-0.6535577774047852,
-0.3428005874156952,
-0.269167959690094,
0.1887936145067215,
0.6152681112289429,
0.42592912912368774,
-0.8973488211631775,
-0.04601423442363739,
0.11456544697284698,
0.29549703001976013,
-0.20328301191329956,
-0.1831258088350296,
0.5099328756332397,
-0.2504769265651703,
-1.07059907913208,
0.48851650953292847,
-0.3293258249759674,
0.034702323377132416,
-0.3995943069458008,
-0.24764923751354218,
0.257724404335022,
0.5834671854972839,
0.44105684757232666,
0.35365030169487,
-0.31613436341285706,
-0.06357693672180176,
0.14215153455734253,
-0.22320036590099335,
-0.1490488499403,
0.15803313255310059,
-0.8652326464653015,
0.423331081867218,
0.618556022644043,
0.8142073750495911,
0.3502469062805176,
0.11371961236000061,
0.33792394399642944,
-0.6457211375236511,
-0.1695382297039032,
0.5212751030921936,
-0.06405980885028839,
0.48945772647857666,
-0.12918604910373688,
0.42110633850097656,
0.02686294913291931,
-0.22441641986370087,
-0.7762213945388794,
0.21941760182380676,
-0.27782922983169556,
-0.11294062435626984,
0.8792162537574768,
-0.09238428622484207,
-0.21368791162967682,
-0.09027943015098572,
-0.209658682346344,
0.10897137969732285,
-0.2582862973213196,
0.7632525563240051,
0.6930626034736633,
0.2315545529127121,
-0.38433703780174255,
-0.6195929050445557,
0.44577082991600037,
0.40938273072242737,
-1.0385633707046509,
0.07871599495410919,
0.5144357085227966,
0.010530045256018639,
-0.10351208597421646,
0.30896249413490295,
-0.10929855704307556,
0.5264359712600708,
0.17670783400535583,
0.0911736786365509,
0.07961050420999527,
-0.1707301139831543,
-0.28687068819999695,
0.32091599702835083,
0.11228986829519272,
-0.18827062845230103
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.04229v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.04229v1
|
The CLRS-Text Algorithmic Reasoning Language Benchmark
| 2024-06-06T16:29:25 | 2024-06-06T16:29:25 |
Larisa Markeeva, Sean McLeish, Borja Ibarz, Wilfried Bounsi, Olga Kozlova, Alex Vitvitskyi, Charles Blundell, Tom Goldstein, Avi Schwarzschild, Petar Veličković
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.DS, stat.ML
|
Eliciting reasoning capabilities from language models (LMs) is a critical
direction on the path towards building intelligent systems. Most recent studies
dedicated to reasoning focus on out-of-distribution performance on
procedurally-generated synthetic benchmarks, bespoke-built to evaluate specific
skills only. This trend makes results hard to transfer across publications,
slowing down progress. Three years ago, a similar issue was identified and
rectified in the field of neural algorithmic reasoning, with the advent of the
CLRS benchmark. CLRS is a dataset generator comprising graph execution traces
of classical algorithms from the Introduction to Algorithms textbook. Inspired
by this, we propose CLRS-Text -- a textual version of these algorithmic traces.
Out of the box, CLRS-Text is capable of procedurally generating trace data for
thirty diverse, challenging algorithmic tasks across any desirable input
distribution, while offering a standard pipeline in which any additional
algorithmic tasks may be created in the benchmark. We fine-tune and evaluate
various LMs as generalist executors on this benchmark, validating prior work
and revealing a novel, interesting challenge for the LM reasoning community.
Our code is available at
https://github.com/google-deepmind/clrs/tree/master/clrs/_src/clrs_text.
|
[
-0.3094855844974518,
-0.6671348214149475,
0.7296283841133118,
-0.404074102640152,
-0.3303813338279724,
-0.11819073557853699,
-0.5162379741668701,
-0.4173917770385742,
-0.2267284393310547,
0.831490159034729,
-0.649631142616272,
-0.43520864844322205,
-0.46637922525405884,
0.12830780446529388,
-0.7802971005439758,
1.1555815935134888,
-0.1046082153916359,
-0.16978411376476288,
-0.2002410888671875,
-0.26124629378318787,
-0.3333192467689514,
-0.5897715091705322,
-0.5351086854934692,
-0.35873061418533325,
0.5121407508850098,
0.06110253930091858,
0.6526285409927368,
0.8895478248596191,
0.44413381814956665,
0.2885042130947113,
-0.07895106077194214,
0.3915591239929199,
-0.3665609061717987,
0.3159383237361908,
-0.32609662413597107,
-0.3210088908672333,
-0.07887423783540726,
-0.36288923025131226,
0.5317947268486023,
0.4818039834499359,
-0.10805293172597885,
0.2534726560115814,
0.07564539462327957,
0.8279543519020081,
-0.5533822774887085,
0.17533639073371887,
-0.7538642287254333,
-0.13915954530239105,
-0.31598833203315735,
-0.2699374258518219,
-0.6048603057861328,
-0.5160000920295715,
0.18936458230018616,
-0.5130258798599243,
0.3630680441856384,
-0.06593524664640427,
0.509260356426239,
0.5428721904754639,
-0.12833352386951447,
-0.9379767775535583,
-0.7376558780670166,
0.6559600234031677,
-0.5482762455940247,
0.17110389471054077,
-0.04774168133735657,
0.6471856236457825,
-0.02916668727993965,
-1.1072965860366821,
-0.5022391080856323,
-0.10116297006607056,
-0.2115958333015442,
-0.2841614782810211,
-0.01449313573539257,
-0.20206117630004883,
0.38345304131507874,
0.3561151623725891,
-0.635803759098053,
-0.22270075976848602,
-0.3626940846443176,
-0.012565226294100285,
0.623802661895752,
0.3349071741104126,
-0.013522454537451267,
0.23924176394939423,
-0.10661856085062027,
-0.25308912992477417,
-0.7536223530769348,
0.022297462448477745,
0.32329097390174866,
0.358717143535614,
-0.04697245731949806,
0.48115086555480957,
-0.23090732097625732,
0.9604483842849731,
-0.30976876616477966,
0.1443779170513153,
0.1974579095840454,
-0.3880518078804016,
-0.002177146030589938,
0.07549421489238739,
0.8077758550643921,
0.15658344328403473,
0.5566318035125732,
-0.026776980608701706,
-0.3402581512928009,
0.21341842412948608,
-0.0009101080358959734,
-0.848060131072998,
-0.4928383529186249,
0.09494730085134506,
-0.30854901671409607,
-0.01649663783609867,
-0.182249516248703,
-0.7113030552864075,
-0.6842544674873352,
-0.462959885597229,
0.021287433803081512,
-0.39540576934814453,
0.050025079399347305,
0.21976038813591003,
-0.14959098398685455,
0.014495492912828922,
0.14894449710845947,
-0.5554850697517395,
0.5499767065048218,
0.8662483096122742,
0.5588859915733337,
-0.11323821544647217,
-0.0016980251530185342,
-0.510898232460022,
0.08220663666725159,
-0.15471869707107544,
0.8931325078010559,
-0.6667075157165527,
-0.148622527718544,
0.1282677948474884,
-0.25897762179374695,
0.01592821627855301,
-0.6092451810836792,
0.7821654081344604,
-0.42925772070884705,
0.17739775776863098,
-0.3867158591747284,
-0.7510865926742554,
-0.07665549963712692,
0.1448814570903778,
-0.602321982383728,
1.0761853456497192,
-0.15642842650413513,
-0.5202233195304871,
0.171298548579216,
-0.6554220914840698,
-0.42557594180107117,
0.29301273822784424,
-0.5818418860435486,
-0.21363911032676697,
-0.2098611444234848,
0.1844947636127472,
0.280787855386734,
-0.5625203847885132,
0.35852673649787903,
-0.2311488687992096,
-0.4056966304779053,
0.5788583159446716,
-0.4458225965499878,
0.5745479464530945,
0.3811528980731964,
-0.46351924538612366,
0.09078336507081985,
-0.7682874202728271,
0.4811525046825409,
-0.05844884365797043,
-0.07969799637794495,
-0.098451629281044,
0.4939687252044678,
-0.21134191751480103,
0.24152395129203796,
0.3168281316757202,
-0.27099907398223877,
-0.22276894748210907,
-0.3174975514411926,
0.798723578453064,
0.7063630819320679,
-0.21138916909694672,
0.297489732503891,
-0.5099886655807495,
0.17580817639827728,
-0.3625681400299072,
-0.16096873581409454,
-0.49057573080062866,
-0.39579907059669495,
-0.7363042831420898,
-0.39257359504699707,
0.07406309992074966,
0.4773710072040558,
-0.661370575428009,
0.32214051485061646,
-0.3229624032974243,
-0.5330410003662109,
-0.4415097236633301,
0.3126969337463379,
0.6418630480766296,
0.4743330776691437,
0.45238038897514343,
-0.012353260070085526,
-0.459328830242157,
-0.7782137393951416,
-0.6815063953399658,
0.023888003081083298,
0.06409163773059845,
0.4464537799358368,
0.5557848811149597,
0.11008736491203308,
0.9024470448493958,
-0.42657220363616943,
-0.20747855305671692,
-0.2541389763355255,
0.10366065055131912,
0.3408854901790619,
0.42901238799095154,
0.15652024745941162,
-0.5992199778556824,
-0.42916396260261536,
0.11202922463417053,
-0.8051379919052124,
-0.17437483370304108,
-0.06751690804958344,
0.044708266854286194,
0.2025822401046753,
0.6772897839546204,
-0.6272121071815491,
0.3087591230869293,
0.39432844519615173,
-0.26649773120880127,
0.5726451277732849,
-0.3647828698158264,
-0.13826701045036316,
-0.6027427315711975,
0.3956424593925476,
-0.16781102120876312,
-0.13222013413906097,
-0.3469160497188568,
0.2800416648387909,
-0.11818569898605347,
-0.06781117618083954,
-0.20761002600193024,
0.7465661764144897,
-0.4741457402706146,
-0.14574889838695526,
-0.18102335929870605,
0.4123747646808624,
-0.1561957150697708,
0.33808663487434387,
0.04812612384557724,
0.698455274105072,
0.2908761203289032,
-0.6988906264305115,
0.3570620119571686,
0.04270882159471512,
-0.592967689037323,
0.5584344267845154,
-0.8299807906150818,
0.4099520146846771,
-0.10008179396390915,
0.26738160848617554,
-0.775468647480011,
0.01837066188454628,
0.23833009600639343,
-0.3243980407714844,
-0.028259165585041046,
0.11806780844926834,
-0.7141433358192444,
-0.35466107726097107,
0.07027997821569443,
0.4213285744190216,
0.7283678650856018,
-0.356632262468338,
0.5444632768630981,
0.207244411110878,
-0.04575873166322708,
-0.4193399250507355,
-0.6700295209884644,
0.034044742584228516,
-0.03140265867114067,
-0.43678396940231323,
0.18264487385749817,
-0.3013013005256653,
-0.383802205324173,
0.27610358595848083,
0.18707941472530365,
-0.18818408250808716,
-0.11779534071683884,
-0.005614735186100006,
-0.14243659377098083,
-0.3038756549358368,
0.08175402879714966,
0.042240992188453674,
-0.2558553218841553,
0.23926691710948944,
-0.23951208591461182,
0.4377637207508087,
-0.24750357866287231,
-0.5385511517524719,
-0.3579969108104706,
0.15834097564220428,
0.4201442301273346,
-0.33314353227615356,
0.3468925952911377,
0.10860950499773026,
-0.21259519457817078,
-0.6703913807868958,
-0.5418877601623535,
-0.12461499124765396,
-0.4854927062988281,
0.2531321048736572,
-0.392378032207489,
-0.9229377508163452,
0.4311828315258026,
-0.0402592308819294,
0.1659228652715683,
0.36413195729255676,
0.62174391746521,
0.013048408553004265,
0.973572313785553,
0.11442650109529495,
0.15011543035507202,
0.09250221401453018,
-0.06439211964607239,
0.07284621149301529,
-0.528312087059021,
-0.2307559698820114,
-0.7479047775268555,
-0.3377854824066162,
-0.43677231669425964,
-0.5461728572845459,
0.20774509012699127,
-0.09495405852794647,
-0.5013347268104553,
0.287763774394989,
-0.9521674513816833,
0.6258652806282043,
0.49959853291511536,
0.10038728266954422,
0.36776790022850037,
-0.1676749736070633,
-0.18002761900424957,
0.0181888435035944,
-0.47470125555992126,
-0.697677731513977,
0.815089762210846,
0.14426203072071075,
0.442535936832428,
-0.14318028092384338,
0.47327926754951477,
0.45056357979774475,
0.40102311968803406,
-0.24917103350162506,
0.8135115504264832,
-0.32902124524116516,
-0.693766713142395,
-0.1242663636803627,
-0.4619137942790985,
-0.784197211265564,
0.16487601399421692,
0.14008891582489014,
-0.7107193470001221,
-0.17148011922836304,
0.21630582213401794,
-0.16510803997516632,
0.37035515904426575,
-0.37302711606025696,
0.9375027418136597,
-0.27956846356391907,
-0.21791969239711761,
-0.2905643582344055,
-0.7189728021621704,
0.2617715299129486,
0.07558544725179672,
0.5148110389709473,
-0.11702600121498108,
-0.0418962761759758,
0.5134478211402893,
-0.6899460554122925,
0.7437570691108704,
-0.180055171251297,
0.013631625100970268,
0.6682676076889038,
0.2147030532360077,
0.7380850911140442,
-0.2884206473827362,
-0.31873634457588196,
-0.2108164280653,
0.07209938019514084,
-0.1804850846529007,
-0.6319300532341003,
0.6121693849563599,
-0.45059794187545776,
-0.24558217823505402,
-0.3360002636909485,
-0.6657435297966003,
0.08875741809606552,
0.3221401572227478,
0.07426659762859344,
0.6836138963699341,
-0.09121885150671005,
0.24583613872528076,
0.7480055093765259,
-0.12090785801410675,
0.46802666783332825,
0.4164886772632599,
-0.1380273848772049,
-0.5302270650863647,
0.9316317439079285,
-0.015631964430212975,
0.10776115953922272,
0.5350134968757629,
0.11282485723495483,
-0.5039478540420532,
-0.6628361940383911,
-0.6784025430679321,
0.004717133939266205,
-0.9795145988464355,
-0.036134861409664154,
-0.42538556456565857,
-0.30684584379196167,
0.10473081469535828,
-0.37412646412849426,
-0.26895710825920105,
-0.18664531409740448,
-0.2407517284154892,
0.1618615984916687,
0.3141516149044037,
0.8553811311721802,
0.09633464366197586,
-0.0128575274720788,
-0.6624820828437805,
0.23169797658920288,
0.06959747523069382,
0.2877010703086853,
-0.03273976221680641,
-0.4220831096172333,
-0.06205835938453674,
0.19285161793231964,
-0.08951764553785324,
-0.5319066643714905,
0.25318804383277893,
0.0171293243765831,
0.6312506794929504,
0.16943639516830444,
0.181847482919693,
0.6100119352340698,
-0.5046981573104858,
0.6178596019744873,
0.1045123040676117,
-0.8878640532493591,
0.31304478645324707,
-0.4266100525856018,
0.19485700130462646,
0.7073594331741333,
-0.08573004603385925,
-0.3974572420120239,
-0.4157167971134186,
-0.38715091347694397,
-0.6176162362098694,
0.37937790155410767,
0.2315482646226883,
0.014435766264796257,
-0.29095426201820374,
0.36102330684661865,
0.26947563886642456,
0.25938689708709717,
-0.6246602535247803,
-0.2987823188304901,
-0.00019051005074288696,
-0.5919002294540405,
-0.11185534298419952,
-0.12460481375455856,
-0.030636560171842575,
-0.05553875118494034,
0.43585890531539917,
-0.23635230958461761,
-0.029722286388278008,
0.2759769558906555,
-0.3055400550365448,
0.19867029786109924,
0.3246399462223053,
0.7345236539840698,
0.7778611183166504,
0.01179532427340746,
0.3933882713317871,
0.09924536943435669,
-0.14523904025554657,
-0.03488028049468994,
0.3328000605106354,
-0.4859865605831146,
0.07538469135761261,
0.1176777184009552,
0.6557821035385132,
0.27893415093421936,
-1.0782885551452637,
0.31485116481781006,
0.04091355577111244,
-0.21224236488342285,
-0.5431053042411804,
0.06303813308477402,
0.15937289595603943,
0.21764537692070007,
0.4949832856655121,
0.09369942545890808,
0.1247396394610405,
-0.27988871932029724,
0.3553200960159302,
0.3819047212600708,
-0.6933790445327759,
-0.21067208051681519,
0.7330837845802307,
0.2639705240726471,
-0.45522379875183105,
0.36649271845817566,
-0.49439510703086853,
-0.46867313981056213,
0.5686078667640686,
0.34068456292152405,
0.7478570342063904,
0.2853417992591858,
0.04049528017640114,
0.4158138036727905,
0.38153862953186035,
-0.31105029582977295,
0.29817894101142883,
-0.11307689547538757,
-0.4839792847633362,
-0.53829425573349,
-0.36957642436027527,
-0.3629322052001953,
-0.07688004523515701,
-0.41701939702033997,
0.27375999093055725,
-0.5315574407577515,
0.11210399866104126,
-0.0778714269399643,
-0.11975937336683273,
-0.6061332821846008,
0.19688580930233002,
0.21078276634216309,
0.9685273170471191,
-0.37926432490348816,
0.621025025844574,
0.42838719487190247,
-0.10010982304811478,
-0.4524820148944855,
-0.4962277412414551,
-0.08704785257577896,
-0.7301771640777588,
0.5898913741111755,
0.2652616798877716,
-0.13180813193321228,
-0.0353524275124073,
-0.5324582457542419,
-0.7135409712791443,
0.9888834953308105,
0.4138214886188507,
-0.5708996653556824,
0.031932439655065536,
0.4502907693386078,
0.6940337419509888,
-0.5159103870391846,
0.40572044253349304,
0.518154501914978,
0.4286932051181793,
-0.10731242597103119,
-0.7033702731132507,
0.4100398123264313,
-0.35437583923339844,
-0.1507009118795395,
0.3906843066215515,
-0.3642190098762512,
1.0530561208724976,
-0.1232978031039238,
-0.32759520411491394,
0.5524778366088867,
0.5565413236618042,
0.5285982489585876,
0.4832611083984375,
0.31877774000167847,
0.8325937986373901,
0.9568458199501038,
-0.13449497520923615,
1.285674810409546,
-0.5144060254096985,
0.1711106151342392,
1.4634616374969482,
-0.46507343649864197,
0.8020955920219421,
0.28413066267967224,
-0.06639000028371811,
0.9976847767829895,
0.12586542963981628,
0.040649112313985825,
0.5444808602333069,
0.6230251789093018,
-0.2932910919189453,
-0.21557974815368652,
-0.15169532597064972,
-0.5012520551681519,
0.0425717756152153,
0.3786793649196625,
-0.554143488407135,
-0.3229398727416992,
-0.5237849950790405,
-0.040558937937021255,
0.5268833637237549,
-0.26246821880340576,
0.5772550702095032,
0.08351930230855942,
-0.8772881627082825,
0.3778262138366699,
-0.17528490722179413,
0.42249006032943726,
-0.5722832083702087,
-0.20146086812019348,
0.11695875972509384,
0.6949241757392883,
0.06801531463861465,
-0.9570895433425903,
0.3450535833835602,
-0.015447014011442661,
-0.18420830368995667,
-0.32107996940612793,
0.7604962587356567,
-0.34721314907073975,
-0.43374454975128174,
0.2617481052875519,
0.5702977180480957,
0.31728842854499817,
-0.019109973683953285,
-0.859259307384491,
0.20761090517044067,
-0.13279370963573456,
-0.025305764749646187,
0.23246966302394867,
0.762600839138031,
-0.002438429743051529,
0.8580077290534973,
0.8033298254013062,
-0.08429508656263351,
0.13112877309322357,
-0.026024917140603065,
0.8746830224990845,
-0.7071796655654907,
-0.4963051974773407,
-0.9986231327056885,
0.4723820686340332,
-0.24469131231307983,
-0.5753223299980164,
0.5355194807052612,
0.706654965877533,
0.8026739358901978,
0.15573501586914062,
0.9376441240310669,
-0.15495377779006958,
0.8534312844276428,
-0.4843918979167938,
0.6731606721878052,
-0.2006806880235672,
0.30719131231307983,
-0.04742831364274025,
-0.5688307881355286,
-0.09786153584718704,
0.3471328318119049,
-0.33941391110420227,
0.097569540143013,
0.902857780456543,
0.7608500719070435,
0.24145293235778809,
0.14141304790973663,
-0.002650157082825899,
0.00784387905150652,
0.18481659889221191,
0.8854932188987732,
0.9529260396957397,
-0.4571402370929718,
0.9036739468574524,
-0.2327161282300949,
0.12602141499519348,
0.05333840474486351,
-1.052379846572876,
-1.0756827592849731,
-0.47550642490386963,
-0.2629428803920746,
-0.39027950167655945,
0.31287235021591187,
0.6344558000564575,
0.39545938372612,
-0.861720860004425,
-0.380454421043396,
-0.6186653971672058,
0.22010357677936554,
-0.28475040197372437,
-0.20000790059566498,
0.3255102038383484,
-0.3616713285446167,
-0.4212200939655304,
0.29840707778930664,
0.019566381350159645,
-0.29769670963287354,
-0.18849407136440277,
-0.4030659794807434,
0.08488423377275467,
-0.058765511959791183,
0.3242303133010864,
0.43881791830062866,
-0.679669976234436,
-0.22611171007156372,
0.09940721094608307,
-0.2652418613433838,
-0.21140187978744507,
1.0974845886230469,
-0.9113451838493347,
0.32473132014274597,
0.48308485746383667,
0.8308372497558594,
0.497732937335968,
-0.16547858715057373,
0.5232325792312622,
-0.5345698595046997,
-0.029376231133937836,
0.3968238830566406,
0.36458054184913635,
0.37266042828559875,
0.014243592508137226,
0.5700870752334595,
0.23729237914085388,
-0.5823273062705994,
-1.0397242307662964,
0.17101705074310303,
-0.7691195011138916,
-0.3418032228946686,
1.1097804307937622,
-0.1127304658293724,
-0.14491219818592072,
-0.19363032281398773,
-0.07329704612493515,
0.02395773120224476,
-0.3449719250202179,
0.5070169568061829,
0.528644323348999,
0.06927955895662308,
-0.2841269075870514,
-0.5748159289360046,
0.5632675290107727,
0.44909852743148804,
-0.8319195508956909,
0.30105629563331604,
0.5624650716781616,
0.15498508512973785,
0.12147127091884613,
0.8210814595222473,
-0.14178584516048431,
0.2755841314792633,
0.04285380616784096,
0.01760607212781906,
-0.18734830617904663,
-0.1750563085079193,
-0.007465646136552095,
0.32190993428230286,
-0.12207990884780884,
0.15885819494724274
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.04220v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.04220v2
|
BEADs: Bias Evaluation Across Domains
| 2024-06-06T16:18:30 | 2024-06-07T12:29:48 |
Shaina Raza, Mizanur Rahman, Michael R. Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Recent improvements in large language models (LLMs) have significantly
enhanced natural language processing (NLP) applications. However, these models
can also inherit and perpetuate biases from their training data. Addressing
this issue is crucial, yet many existing datasets do not offer evaluation
across diverse NLP tasks. To tackle this, we introduce the Bias Evaluations
Across Domains (BEADs) dataset, designed to support a wide range of NLP tasks,
including text classification, bias entity recognition, bias quantification,
and benign language generation. BEADs uses AI-driven annotation combined with
experts' verification to provide reliable labels. This method overcomes the
limitations of existing datasets that typically depend on crowd-sourcing,
expert-only annotations with limited bias evaluations, or unverified AI
labeling. Our empirical analysis shows that BEADs is effective in detecting and
reducing biases across different language models, with smaller models
fine-tuned on BEADs often outperforming LLMs in bias classification tasks.
However, these models may still exhibit biases towards certain demographics.
Fine-tuning LLMs with our benign language data also reduces biases while
preserving the models' knowledge. Our findings highlight the importance of
comprehensive bias evaluation and the potential of targeted fine-tuning for
reducing the bias of LLMs. We are making BEADs publicly available at
https://huggingface.co/datasets/shainar/BEAD
Warning: This paper contains examples that may be considered offensive.
|
[
-0.43956905603408813,
-0.8344531059265137,
0.272844523191452,
0.5626124143600464,
-0.06567858904600143,
0.2964838147163391,
-0.5122947692871094,
-0.4235486686229706,
0.1301708221435547,
0.46683481335639954,
-0.45699700713157654,
-0.5450790524482727,
-0.7604444622993469,
0.02960822358727455,
-0.35464516282081604,
1.4775798320770264,
0.0663236677646637,
0.25322937965393066,
-0.4025052785873413,
-0.12709195911884308,
-0.5620471835136414,
-0.23701313138008118,
-0.6746553182601929,
-0.3633190095424652,
0.12804029881954193,
-0.03785110265016556,
0.3289085328578949,
0.20258164405822754,
0.4133206605911255,
0.11303731799125671,
-0.2824143171310425,
0.5022894144058228,
-0.6023042798042297,
0.18386191129684448,
-0.6247397065162659,
-0.14919513463974,
-0.5415872931480408,
0.20016351342201233,
0.4067068099975586,
0.968153178691864,
0.08244910091161728,
0.33713820576667786,
0.28068605065345764,
0.6262974739074707,
-0.8086787462234497,
0.011555730365216732,
-0.8889888525009155,
0.13973690569400787,
-0.7249197363853455,
-0.16647936403751373,
-0.406619668006897,
-0.4448510706424713,
0.3060981035232544,
-0.28332972526550293,
0.27427470684051514,
0.20262299478054047,
0.5676019191741943,
0.19405867159366608,
-0.5373234748840332,
-0.42686498165130615,
-0.4651224911212921,
1.1266998052597046,
-0.4544847905635834,
0.3074710965156555,
0.5908600687980652,
-0.0602140836417675,
-0.2703504264354706,
-0.3115621507167816,
-0.29767823219299316,
0.2026243805885315,
0.07438614219427109,
-0.2074127495288849,
-0.07463932782411575,
-0.17571213841438293,
0.1920095682144165,
0.40513142943382263,
-0.47743475437164307,
-0.12450095266103745,
-0.35134023427963257,
-0.31439298391342163,
0.6564218997955322,
0.025573236867785454,
0.41590380668640137,
0.1427215188741684,
-0.3547222912311554,
0.22300377488136292,
-0.7042043805122375,
-0.22103461623191833,
0.19933322072029114,
0.3847033679485321,
-0.15147115290164948,
0.4449586570262909,
-0.14485394954681396,
0.48775890469551086,
0.4181393086910248,
-0.14582641422748566,
0.2258114516735077,
-0.08929800242185593,
-0.14131687581539154,
-0.02397702820599079,
0.5606058835983276,
0.5182746052742004,
0.41367337107658386,
-0.3271867334842682,
-0.10163918882608414,
0.07630875706672668,
0.27272218465805054,
-0.6647310256958008,
-0.24159392714500427,
0.03118239901959896,
-0.5381709933280945,
-0.291808545589447,
-0.4199047088623047,
-1.0523217916488647,
-0.811173677444458,
-0.2568920850753784,
0.1155589297413826,
-0.04682145640254021,
-0.11926474422216415,
0.23723798990249634,
0.06708650290966034,
-0.1955360323190689,
0.18372531235218048,
-1.0283794403076172,
0.6201742887496948,
0.7593138217926025,
0.8191810250282288,
-0.5527568459510803,
0.02330942265689373,
-0.544775128364563,
0.0063070207834243774,
-0.2801610827445984,
0.8605430126190186,
-0.8723626136779785,
-0.5247907638549805,
0.01645820215344429,
-0.04393050819635391,
-0.025154978036880493,
-0.7794762849807739,
0.9057249426841736,
-0.5347467660903931,
0.14458920061588287,
-0.39623627066612244,
-0.5345980525016785,
-0.00895878579467535,
0.02404525876045227,
-0.4468328356742859,
0.8719480633735657,
-0.03908608853816986,
-0.9246543645858765,
0.6631074547767639,
-0.3569508194923401,
-0.5481746196746826,
-0.25794845819473267,
-0.08318935334682465,
-0.5875892043113708,
0.24302464723587036,
0.5999622344970703,
0.32777056097984314,
-0.46492868661880493,
0.35280847549438477,
-0.6060769557952881,
-0.1692897230386734,
0.08591274917125702,
-0.5418381094932556,
0.9630948305130005,
0.05321956053376198,
-0.39578181505203247,
-0.03601458668708801,
-0.7766834497451782,
-0.23147225379943848,
-0.26501116156578064,
-0.1772594451904297,
-0.7081595063209534,
0.055003635585308075,
0.32421183586120605,
0.07851127535104752,
0.0034614061005413532,
-0.5401742458343506,
0.31189948320388794,
-0.309497594833374,
0.19366493821144104,
1.0936133861541748,
0.06414929032325745,
0.7409695386886597,
-0.14978289604187012,
0.5198708176612854,
-0.1831967681646347,
0.08532969653606415,
0.17290250957012177,
-0.7920212149620056,
-0.6397111415863037,
-0.3622561991214752,
0.5024608969688416,
0.19868305325508118,
-0.5131468176841736,
0.29957669973373413,
-0.05165997892618179,
-0.03345060348510742,
-0.5590927004814148,
0.22336623072624207,
0.565323531627655,
0.43677887320518494,
0.42133912444114685,
-0.7901180386543274,
-0.5739606618881226,
-0.8862771987915039,
-0.47331950068473816,
0.1034446507692337,
-0.056487154215574265,
0.356560081243515,
0.445868581533432,
-0.33312955498695374,
1.045525312423706,
-0.21619673073291779,
-0.5181318521499634,
0.1999986171722412,
0.25666525959968567,
0.06982869654893875,
0.5557984709739685,
0.4646191895008087,
-0.494848370552063,
-0.4605993628501892,
-0.021327193826436996,
-0.5143187642097473,
-0.5977637767791748,
-0.20731385052204132,
-0.5467678904533386,
0.07780608534812927,
0.01676778681576252,
-0.6003609299659729,
0.49982380867004395,
0.6349361538887024,
-0.33222898840904236,
0.5593116283416748,
0.46176207065582275,
-0.008344647474586964,
-0.5076644420623779,
-0.058059606701135635,
0.1852133721113205,
-0.29641348123550415,
-0.4926638603210449,
-0.12349934130907059,
-0.04920515418052673,
0.2669096291065216,
-0.09597305953502655,
0.9561251401901245,
-0.4437521696090698,
-0.13032269477844238,
-0.35372641682624817,
0.11400613933801651,
0.24654464423656464,
0.1738264262676239,
0.22269535064697266,
0.8681575655937195,
0.6054457426071167,
-0.6177098155021667,
0.062097400426864624,
0.4692637026309967,
-0.4441835880279541,
0.6721777319908142,
-0.3577120900154114,
0.2763121724128723,
0.19462081789970398,
0.47852247953414917,
-0.2737163007259369,
-0.06155172362923622,
0.37232255935668945,
-0.16351988911628723,
0.34571292996406555,
-0.18208909034729004,
0.019468093290925026,
-0.23966065049171448,
-0.5439575910568237,
0.6280125975608826,
0.20862530171871185,
-0.7980928421020508,
0.3379766345024109,
0.7632685899734497,
-0.20213215053081512,
-0.8978966474533081,
-0.644206702709198,
0.0193838682025671,
-0.29038500785827637,
-0.34173813462257385,
0.3142988085746765,
-0.15998834371566772,
-0.408314049243927,
-0.18022090196609497,
-0.3618467152118683,
-0.239630326628685,
-0.10533126443624496,
0.17184686660766602,
-0.013350213877856731,
0.005311134736984968,
0.2714286744594574,
0.3901819884777069,
0.03805384039878845,
0.15096116065979004,
-0.4568336606025696,
0.5305907130241394,
0.16238267719745636,
-0.4289465844631195,
-0.15763027966022491,
-0.004653127398341894,
0.019198788329958916,
-0.10515929013490677,
0.5531387329101562,
0.6309755444526672,
-0.4378822147846222,
-0.6746799945831299,
-0.64915531873703,
-0.1716727912425995,
-0.3953682482242584,
0.15985047817230225,
-0.3348609209060669,
-0.8658936023712158,
0.30603262782096863,
-0.03899645432829857,
0.03900906816124916,
0.16986708343029022,
0.7444556951522827,
0.2073744237422943,
0.887444794178009,
0.6154918670654297,
-0.41358157992362976,
0.05406152084469795,
0.11323040723800659,
0.48264071345329285,
-1.1256983280181885,
-0.016518086194992065,
-0.3497934639453888,
-0.1945519596338272,
-0.5036894679069519,
-0.7198185920715332,
-0.0067864214070141315,
0.20359589159488678,
0.02919098362326622,
-0.1533716470003128,
-0.5203533172607422,
0.6716067790985107,
0.44489413499832153,
0.14427317678928375,
0.2758212089538574,
0.19513893127441406,
0.04750889539718628,
-0.20282040536403656,
-0.3477623760700226,
-0.7227980494499207,
1.5620633363723755,
0.4110651910305023,
0.8791161179542542,
-0.2197732776403427,
0.391786128282547,
0.4782792329788208,
0.32637321949005127,
-0.5313574075698853,
0.2853599488735199,
-0.18479527533054352,
-0.9074915051460266,
0.06795759499073029,
-0.32994890213012695,
-0.6592749357223511,
0.1827816367149353,
-0.20231893658638,
-0.7090112566947937,
0.4511984586715698,
-0.08174911141395569,
-0.35801005363464355,
0.44271108508110046,
-0.43387749791145325,
0.4054378569126129,
-0.029399346560239792,
-0.7307764291763306,
-0.09024553000926971,
-0.1684875637292862,
0.6566511392593384,
-0.40550699830055237,
0.31825968623161316,
-0.25199609994888306,
0.2699178159236908,
0.7104883790016174,
-0.12143247574567795,
0.8616620302200317,
-0.02778198942542076,
-0.29311031103134155,
0.23170748353004456,
0.18003426492214203,
0.0984293594956398,
0.4847857654094696,
-0.22811733186244965,
0.3950434625148773,
-0.3617025315761566,
-0.42567771673202515,
-0.27150338888168335,
0.8685954213142395,
-0.47374197840690613,
-0.4962086081504822,
-0.4139612317085266,
-0.5849363207817078,
-0.4325716197490692,
-0.0041735246777534485,
-0.14670731127262115,
0.3311424255371094,
-0.1229243278503418,
-0.03878261148929596,
0.8606986403465271,
-0.49000054597854614,
0.09195960313081741,
0.2140241414308548,
-0.4237416684627533,
0.04836640506982803,
0.8489610552787781,
-0.289056658744812,
-0.033544957637786865,
-0.020425748080015182,
-0.0018096246058121324,
-0.06826495379209518,
-0.6151881217956543,
-0.5323411822319031,
0.04286813735961914,
-0.489656537771225,
-0.36728397011756897,
-0.627278745174408,
0.06054732948541641,
-0.536824107170105,
-0.18765881657600403,
-0.334306538105011,
-0.4838253855705261,
-0.0913843959569931,
-0.14812330901622772,
0.22031262516975403,
0.9265276193618774,
-0.24348032474517822,
0.08305549621582031,
-0.45350250601768494,
0.36426427960395813,
0.47421759366989136,
0.609706699848175,
0.021416421979665756,
-0.5166492462158203,
-0.20743203163146973,
0.15045703947544098,
-0.42379412055015564,
-0.5463334321975708,
0.4414405822753906,
0.39521491527557373,
0.4102800488471985,
0.46027421951293945,
-0.11345786601305008,
0.6873782277107239,
-0.785822331905365,
0.8039204478263855,
-0.1813783496618271,
-1.174440860748291,
0.5008431673049927,
-0.29508176445961,
-0.056711699813604355,
0.5128833651542664,
0.4664148688316345,
-0.34251952171325684,
-0.30027633905410767,
-0.2603066563606262,
-0.7977921962738037,
0.7648912072181702,
0.3003019094467163,
0.12655574083328247,
-0.307493656873703,
0.326621413230896,
0.460841566324234,
0.3723764717578888,
-0.7879757285118103,
-0.353564977645874,
0.26292121410369873,
-0.1180228590965271,
0.28402939438819885,
-0.3022530972957611,
-0.23727387189865112,
-0.027307843789458275,
0.9883976578712463,
0.016677098348736763,
0.09080219268798828,
-0.0809365063905716,
-0.3260652720928192,
-0.2394106388092041,
0.05524774640798569,
0.2922118008136749,
0.7852090001106262,
-0.23941883444786072,
0.015268813818693161,
0.3754526972770691,
-0.6709768772125244,
-0.20098596811294556,
-0.20700354874134064,
-0.4493238031864166,
0.0652255117893219,
0.26627177000045776,
0.5922854542732239,
-0.04786797612905502,
-0.7291520833969116,
0.5046625733375549,
-0.1030738577246666,
0.21499621868133545,
0.11931470036506653,
-0.25323012471199036,
-0.24951224029064178,
0.3416357636451721,
0.1605062186717987,
0.3742636442184448,
0.5338994264602661,
-0.4405362010002136,
0.22100462019443512,
0.6324060559272766,
-0.457032710313797,
-0.4955889880657196,
0.6830552220344543,
0.39197680354118347,
0.0017964410362765193,
0.2410186529159546,
-0.42587265372276306,
-0.5066283941268921,
0.3940404951572418,
0.37523654103279114,
0.8454731106758118,
-0.2211778163909912,
0.22612279653549194,
0.26863205432891846,
0.24806790053844452,
-0.0026008200366050005,
-0.16530825197696686,
-0.10347576439380646,
-0.7960537672042847,
-0.4843367338180542,
-0.9327331781387329,
-0.38828426599502563,
0.016524946317076683,
-0.6355910897254944,
0.29666775465011597,
-0.49955636262893677,
-0.2812404930591583,
-0.19390437006950378,
0.006321732886135578,
-0.5595701336860657,
0.32171693444252014,
0.4199793338775635,
0.5625560879707336,
-0.8982651829719543,
0.7647050619125366,
0.48331424593925476,
-0.2785648703575134,
-0.035557471215724945,
0.15607118606567383,
0.3211482763290405,
-0.7133185863494873,
0.9491139650344849,
0.19682396948337555,
-0.072608582675457,
-0.5419981479644775,
-0.4119792580604553,
-0.7623752355575562,
0.5468571186065674,
0.0655558705329895,
-0.5731096863746643,
0.11251524090766907,
0.0998191386461258,
0.5102918148040771,
-0.42431285977363586,
0.6137789487838745,
0.7705242037773132,
0.2251075655221939,
-0.6073417067527771,
-1.1073851585388184,
-0.08455482125282288,
-0.17702849209308624,
0.13630354404449463,
-0.06526301056146622,
-0.5537249445915222,
0.8228055834770203,
0.2183411717414856,
-0.16719114780426025,
-0.07039918005466461,
0.45715755224227905,
0.4928702116012573,
0.5550407767295837,
0.30003321170806885,
0.4899330139160156,
0.9412171840667725,
-0.130637064576149,
0.8368659615516663,
-0.2472779005765915,
0.3311801552772522,
1.2351040840148926,
-0.5829975605010986,
0.49812963604927063,
0.4738674759864807,
-0.3871631920337677,
0.4753376245498657,
0.5283018350601196,
0.2614647448062897,
0.5203658938407898,
0.4456002712249756,
-0.3842456340789795,
-0.07503516227006912,
-0.43011730909347534,
-0.3318061828613281,
0.3180702030658722,
0.5725598335266113,
-0.12195498496294022,
-0.09867914021015167,
0.289955198764801,
0.09530264139175415,
0.2801761329174042,
-0.3444257080554962,
0.4141789674758911,
0.10988324880599976,
-0.18416355550289154,
0.2411348819732666,
-0.06217952072620392,
1.1390262842178345,
-0.21195487678050995,
0.0037847869098186493,
-0.4151565730571747,
0.1618606150150299,
-0.3726196885108948,
-0.5063226222991943,
0.304895281791687,
0.3316784203052521,
-0.37611308693885803,
-0.43308764696121216,
0.9287786483764648,
-0.3838167190551758,
-0.45140472054481506,
0.40206730365753174,
0.3713817894458771,
0.12810422480106354,
0.03741873800754547,
-0.808029294013977,
0.3096347451210022,
0.13029524683952332,
-0.403716117143631,
0.4008040428161621,
0.44463062286376953,
-0.38143616914749146,
0.7064608335494995,
0.4913693070411682,
0.4678310751914978,
0.32695654034614563,
0.36038938164711,
0.8647950887680054,
-0.2627926766872406,
0.2063831239938736,
-0.6754769086837769,
0.2772260904312134,
-0.3113746643066406,
-0.42819082736968994,
0.9169409871101379,
0.6197000741958618,
1.0795648097991943,
-0.07195139676332474,
0.8449499011039734,
0.1327115297317505,
0.9411031603813171,
-0.5104378461837769,
0.6596636772155762,
-0.25095775723457336,
0.5698354244232178,
-0.3385932445526123,
-1.1489113569259644,
-0.35585978627204895,
1.04413640499115,
-0.46051374077796936,
0.17585349082946777,
0.5892473459243774,
0.685053288936615,
-0.13567447662353516,
0.2212623953819275,
-0.05376384034752846,
0.2408694475889206,
0.34071457386016846,
0.37725841999053955,
0.6932324767112732,
-0.5648500323295593,
0.0846327617764473,
-0.5257452130317688,
-0.2639721930027008,
0.037000421434640884,
-0.7639757990837097,
-1.2115771770477295,
-0.3097369372844696,
-0.4640014171600342,
-0.2496441900730133,
0.4770682454109192,
0.9844562411308289,
0.776724636554718,
-1.267767310142517,
-0.2525614798069,
0.04583131894469261,
0.19710035622119904,
0.1205880269408226,
-0.2388824075460434,
0.3494204580783844,
-0.6549708247184753,
-1.2079968452453613,
0.3898349702358246,
0.3668517470359802,
-0.530941903591156,
-0.3171258270740509,
0.19715450704097748,
-0.2801155149936676,
0.11258377134799957,
0.7542968988418579,
0.037642110139131546,
-0.6055555939674377,
-0.1642899066209793,
-0.33055582642555237,
0.09088267385959625,
-0.20262542366981506,
0.6703726649284363,
-0.8970821499824524,
0.5819447040557861,
0.2552851736545563,
0.9050279259681702,
0.4018029570579529,
-0.06471850723028183,
0.6514571905136108,
-0.8946095705032349,
0.15944401919841766,
0.26956504583358765,
0.2606620788574219,
0.4066922068595886,
-0.2082981914281845,
0.7110244631767273,
0.022736405953764915,
-0.8118990659713745,
-0.9299401044845581,
0.00007811965042492375,
-0.7805283665657043,
-0.3252315819263458,
1.2374341487884521,
-0.09370545297861099,
-0.11825086921453476,
-0.4016377329826355,
-0.2875747084617615,
-0.016939673572778702,
-0.4159039556980133,
1.1971675157546997,
0.8337045907974243,
0.04593844711780548,
0.20891942083835602,
-0.7035987377166748,
0.7909501791000366,
0.7301976084709167,
-0.6163825392723083,
0.20419512689113617,
0.48136043548583984,
0.0827895998954773,
0.14430595934391022,
0.6588982343673706,
-0.11789733171463013,
-0.08379210531711578,
-0.2830964922904968,
0.21757332980632782,
0.5537685751914978,
-0.1800801008939743,
-0.43663614988327026,
-0.14374662935733795,
-0.07163936644792557,
0.20747902989387512
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.04218v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.04218v2
|
Linguistic Steganalysis via LLMs: Two Modes for Efficient Detection of Strongly Concealed Stego
| 2024-06-06T16:18:02 | 2024-06-21T05:17:53 |
Yifan Tang, Yihao Wang, Ru Zhang, Jianyi Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
To detect stego (steganographic text) in complex scenarios, linguistic
steganalysis (LS) with various motivations has been proposed and achieved
excellent performance. However, with the development of generative
steganography, some stegos have strong concealment, especially after the
emergence of LLMs-based steganography, the existing LS has low detection or
cannot detect them. We designed a novel LS with two modes called LSGC. In the
generation mode, we created an LS-task "description" and used the generation
ability of LLM to explain whether texts to be detected are stegos. On this
basis, we rethought the principle of LS and LLMs, and proposed the
classification mode. In this mode, LSGC deleted the LS-task "description" and
used the "causalLM" LLMs to extract steganographic features. The LS features
can be extracted by only one pass of the model, and a linear layer with
initialization weights is added to obtain the classification probability.
Experiments on strongly concealed stegos show that LSGC significantly improves
detection and reaches SOTA performance. Additionally, LSGC in classification
mode greatly reduces training time while maintaining high performance.
|
[
-0.29652267694473267,
-0.9915255904197693,
0.4600594937801361,
0.1861574798822403,
-0.605243444442749,
0.18531514704227448,
-0.5244696140289307,
-0.43987250328063965,
0.40797293186187744,
0.5590390563011169,
-0.2778273820877075,
-0.8077380061149597,
-0.7192395925521851,
0.311049222946167,
-0.6213187575340271,
1.0672481060028076,
-0.2001112997531891,
0.16075140237808228,
0.17055721580982208,
0.13213816285133362,
-0.09675551950931549,
-0.6087867021560669,
-0.8134204745292664,
0.0922430008649826,
0.621080756187439,
-0.19168253242969513,
0.48042285442352295,
0.7250359058380127,
0.3455469608306885,
0.2672182619571686,
-0.34121307730674744,
0.4550004303455353,
-0.60539710521698,
0.663687527179718,
0.20841149985790253,
-0.5526995062828064,
-0.21376322209835052,
-0.25309816002845764,
0.8644883036613464,
0.2657243609428406,
-0.14078933000564575,
-0.37595871090888977,
0.2222965806722641,
0.44355544447898865,
-0.533417284488678,
0.22451771795749664,
-0.6543659567832947,
0.15701600909233093,
-0.6843061447143555,
-0.27709653973579407,
-0.2836965024471283,
-0.195756733417511,
-0.22597792744636536,
-0.48610398173332214,
0.4130088984966278,
0.20789708197116852,
0.7788411974906921,
-0.04143717139959335,
-0.1405562311410904,
-0.27756038308143616,
-0.6897961497306824,
0.5638697743415833,
-0.6296194195747375,
0.43459317088127136,
0.42030543088912964,
0.3401118516921997,
-0.15978018939495087,
-0.6791453957557678,
-0.5479246377944946,
-0.3523363769054413,
-0.007770435884594917,
-0.02177734486758709,
-0.151450976729393,
0.39026302099227905,
0.24682411551475525,
0.3547370731830597,
-0.48500752449035645,
0.3006192445755005,
-0.24375396966934204,
-0.3962300717830658,
0.5111077427864075,
0.007924537174403667,
0.33235102891921997,
-0.30165764689445496,
-0.6733149290084839,
0.31246015429496765,
-0.8719692230224609,
-0.10448075085878372,
0.4428828954696655,
0.3487767279148102,
0.1640729159116745,
0.24856622517108917,
-0.19329191744327545,
0.21672941744327545,
-0.41379600763320923,
-0.27633756399154663,
-0.06552081555128098,
-0.4227677881717682,
-0.13456991314888,
0.05030890181660652,
0.963542640209198,
-0.24892480671405792,
-0.022840674966573715,
-0.30468088388442993,
-0.7096402049064636,
0.23302818834781647,
0.2398044764995575,
-0.6823110580444336,
0.11997072398662567,
-0.3358391225337982,
-0.571576714515686,
-0.7144200205802917,
-0.10477983206510544,
-0.6467670798301697,
-0.4928625524044037,
0.014493816532194614,
0.4365738332271576,
0.009336716495454311,
-0.09170198440551758,
0.04116680473089218,
-0.06226387247443199,
0.03364633396267891,
0.23181703686714172,
-1.11394202709198,
0.5169868469238281,
0.8112820386886597,
0.9359362721443176,
-0.4127439260482788,
0.146505668759346,
-0.21604935824871063,
0.11023823171854019,
-0.3735441267490387,
0.6049817800521851,
-0.44573649764060974,
-0.24732553958892822,
0.14770622551441193,
0.18529701232910156,
0.20275507867336273,
-0.408465713262558,
0.6476664543151855,
-0.7349191308021545,
0.10654851794242859,
-0.2939685583114624,
-0.4948368966579437,
-0.2504556477069855,
-0.007429325021803379,
-0.7745081782341003,
1.116201400756836,
-0.24002578854560852,
-0.620520830154419,
0.3955562114715576,
-0.13247983157634735,
-0.5756132006645203,
0.44744494557380676,
-0.37870875000953674,
-0.6960528492927551,
-0.1134180948138237,
-0.23186089098453522,
0.7089393734931946,
-0.29572534561157227,
0.6500582695007324,
-0.37825608253479004,
-0.5563886165618896,
0.14089076220989227,
-0.8522441387176514,
0.6174231767654419,
0.24751147627830505,
-0.6833686828613281,
0.2820778489112854,
-0.322400838136673,
-0.2278224378824234,
0.26037585735321045,
-0.5354592204093933,
-0.3116426467895508,
0.13719160854816437,
-0.036521732807159424,
-0.23530924320220947,
0.1903824806213379,
-0.28126654028892517,
0.13666512072086334,
-0.23691606521606445,
0.47623515129089355,
0.8902438879013062,
-0.13922129571437836,
0.4892784059047699,
0.034630581736564636,
0.41605374217033386,
-0.3666149377822876,
0.19063498079776764,
0.2532953917980194,
-0.672610878944397,
-0.712207555770874,
-0.5594990849494934,
0.1450279802083969,
0.4020308256149292,
-0.8263685703277588,
0.4693900942802429,
0.09424718469381332,
-0.2014777958393097,
-0.17167334258556366,
0.6201915144920349,
0.6631972193717957,
0.226627379655838,
0.1385907083749771,
-0.3251080811023712,
-0.5254466533660889,
-1.0013614892959595,
-0.4158318042755127,
-0.026645805686712265,
0.18578964471817017,
0.1768866926431656,
0.5878491401672363,
-0.03370148688554764,
0.17810606956481934,
-0.312949538230896,
-0.3497218191623688,
-0.4729403257369995,
-0.13183264434337616,
-0.03761279210448265,
0.1022314503788948,
0.4596380889415741,
-0.6756920218467712,
-0.2639007270336151,
-0.12346219271421432,
-1.0011177062988281,
-0.2511294186115265,
0.047197725623846054,
-0.19749952852725983,
0.32562318444252014,
0.7761803865432739,
-0.39913204312324524,
0.5693243741989136,
0.2903342843055725,
-0.15532228350639343,
0.4274126887321472,
-0.11156901717185974,
0.05435808375477791,
-0.6961547136306763,
-0.19374528527259827,
-0.04965803027153015,
-0.4281322658061981,
-0.8511770963668823,
0.08154284954071045,
0.030054496601223946,
-0.005920868832617998,
-0.2513444423675537,
0.28522253036499023,
-0.604546070098877,
0.033329129219055176,
-0.26437488198280334,
0.14572302997112274,
-0.029517974704504013,
0.6058682799339294,
0.04928535968065262,
0.6550095677375793,
0.8313944339752197,
-0.45005035400390625,
0.35327544808387756,
-0.028162989765405655,
-0.3793949782848358,
-0.029272615909576416,
-0.4264281094074249,
0.13939696550369263,
-0.20564284920692444,
0.38749268651008606,
-1.110527515411377,
-0.13260291516780853,
0.5776987075805664,
0.02595910243690014,
0.576518177986145,
-0.29247722029685974,
-0.6609331965446472,
-0.04330235347151756,
-0.5203402042388916,
0.28232595324516296,
0.5337209105491638,
-0.5420764684677124,
0.2517937123775482,
0.36976730823516846,
-0.0452875979244709,
-0.35578128695487976,
-0.605198323726654,
0.32481467723846436,
-0.39330193400382996,
-0.48160314559936523,
0.2875021994113922,
0.3175077736377716,
-0.07960573583841324,
-0.2524939477443695,
-0.23543702065944672,
0.11813517659902573,
0.383114218711853,
0.19014835357666016,
0.27352628111839294,
-0.164953351020813,
0.2583995759487152,
0.4733278453350067,
0.028470894321799278,
0.09515976905822754,
-0.18697623908519745,
0.646737813949585,
-0.14527800679206848,
-0.14670854806900024,
-0.4962303042411804,
0.5032978653907776,
0.3785317540168762,
-0.05987571179866791,
0.9109650254249573,
0.6831821799278259,
-0.43539875745773315,
-0.3932970464229584,
-0.32116347551345825,
-0.20882436633110046,
-0.4991971254348755,
0.3204280734062195,
-0.09922286868095398,
-0.8467004895210266,
0.4415501356124878,
0.056944340467453,
-0.0857192799448967,
0.27388158440589905,
0.4543881416320801,
-0.19018419086933136,
1.006571888923645,
0.14311987161636353,
-0.014826115220785141,
0.6891529560089111,
-0.2626722753047943,
0.2189061939716339,
-0.70332270860672,
-0.46450817584991455,
-0.4173460304737091,
-0.395903617143631,
-0.459995836019516,
-0.3257833421230316,
0.5773184299468994,
0.5294604301452637,
-0.021141275763511658,
0.1942475438117981,
-0.6177532076835632,
0.4105819761753082,
0.47487321496009827,
0.4964860677719116,
0.18742682039737701,
0.29350048303604126,
-0.04460109770298004,
-0.014777700416743755,
-0.6405050158500671,
-0.708426833152771,
1.0271426439285278,
0.49934661388397217,
0.8633266687393188,
0.20756308734416962,
0.9740447998046875,
0.29916051030158997,
0.2362932413816452,
-0.7404162287712097,
0.875297486782074,
-0.4484335482120514,
-0.6465070843696594,
-0.28074365854263306,
-0.2593032419681549,
-0.8000856637954712,
0.35029128193855286,
-0.4901251792907715,
-0.3476301431655884,
-0.2342417687177658,
-0.007548080757260323,
-0.017289556562900543,
0.5205036401748657,
-0.5910865664482117,
0.6451109051704407,
-0.5016464591026306,
-0.57044517993927,
-0.0407327376306057,
-0.6491266489028931,
0.30973494052886963,
0.07371985167264938,
0.23585477471351624,
-0.033138472586870193,
-0.18277889490127563,
1.2632420063018799,
-0.19330237805843353,
1.1232017278671265,
-0.3236238956451416,
-0.3698071539402008,
0.17370212078094482,
0.2625041902065277,
0.8073359131813049,
0.2369474470615387,
0.40432941913604736,
0.23135238885879517,
-0.5117743015289307,
-0.09546728432178497,
-0.620842456817627,
0.7489016652107239,
-0.24312633275985718,
-1.0282658338546753,
-0.22826972603797913,
-0.15556669235229492,
0.06211273744702339,
0.35594096779823303,
0.28683194518089294,
0.37668928503990173,
-0.01061476394534111,
0.2613443434238434,
1.0464097261428833,
0.09561803191900253,
0.4778017997741699,
-0.06191673502326012,
-0.20303773880004883,
-0.22518563270568848,
0.8434979319572449,
-0.0929076299071312,
0.3984755277633667,
0.2511029839515686,
0.40389683842658997,
-0.3850899040699005,
-0.9971468448638916,
-0.3018423616886139,
0.29044002294540405,
-0.7716242671012878,
-0.17201633751392365,
-0.4784906208515167,
-0.1759180724620819,
-0.27929505705833435,
-0.11781500279903412,
-0.053047485649585724,
-0.15410839021205902,
-0.7878854870796204,
0.016735006123781204,
0.3744109869003296,
0.5897126793861389,
0.28577810525894165,
0.21376028656959534,
-0.32416895031929016,
0.7257686257362366,
0.34538325667381287,
0.23745352029800415,
-0.3005516827106476,
-0.6389631628990173,
0.04458529129624367,
-0.09588898718357086,
-0.05912449583411217,
-1.0103013515472412,
0.4079877436161041,
0.2514321506023407,
0.5806415677070618,
0.6759155988693237,
-0.26283425092697144,
0.37110158801078796,
-0.33556312322616577,
0.6788676977157593,
0.13511669635772705,
-0.8690682053565979,
0.5235909819602966,
-0.3778628408908844,
-0.37582188844680786,
0.24024826288223267,
0.2759994566440582,
-0.33280661702156067,
-0.6705049276351929,
-0.2027834802865982,
-0.7725126147270203,
0.47152063250541687,
0.3776436746120453,
0.1539546549320221,
0.053951263427734375,
0.4049344062805176,
0.3033638894557953,
0.2569526433944702,
-0.8319944143295288,
-0.23757246136665344,
-0.1785324066877365,
-0.21888422966003418,
0.02283511310815811,
-0.5156855583190918,
-0.559602677822113,
-0.08738385140895844,
0.48113930225372314,
0.12080293893814087,
0.36316144466400146,
0.14568673074245453,
-0.1323089897632599,
0.2854083776473999,
0.3546243906021118,
0.7593575119972229,
-0.1571952849626541,
0.14458855986595154,
0.7060559391975403,
0.053016360849142075,
-0.555116593837738,
0.08982862532138824,
-0.2604258954524994,
-0.42172399163246155,
0.02232484705746174,
0.6109641194343567,
1.0660748481750488,
0.3959047794342041,
-0.38330724835395813,
0.6238546371459961,
0.12155047059059143,
-0.28666436672210693,
-0.007549591362476349,
0.27946797013282776,
0.08341585844755173,
0.4022911787033081,
0.3205983638763428,
0.18339233100414276,
0.22820548713207245,
-0.5074100494384766,
-0.006049962714314461,
0.8326314687728882,
-0.19608451426029205,
-0.3862358331680298,
0.7725772261619568,
0.27817243337631226,
-0.2500699758529663,
-0.13842666149139404,
-0.3530953824520111,
-1.0098021030426025,
0.42487528920173645,
0.7146199941635132,
1.0038212537765503,
-0.11897525936365128,
0.13959616422653198,
-0.14524807035923004,
0.29860758781433105,
-0.3604374825954437,
0.29939502477645874,
-0.4225759208202362,
-0.658457338809967,
0.2379778027534485,
-0.6135821342468262,
0.29607445001602173,
0.06782913953065872,
-0.44685789942741394,
0.17931164801120758,
-0.7111560106277466,
0.013801809400320053,
-0.09090365469455719,
-0.12899239361286163,
-0.22257313132286072,
-0.11230215430259705,
0.4018005132675171,
0.41051939129829407,
-0.9274501800537109,
0.7228787541389465,
0.09435387700796127,
-0.0128606166690588,
-0.5803113579750061,
-0.18118040263652802,
0.07855526357889175,
-1.0774478912353516,
0.7251573204994202,
0.027323145419359207,
-0.4485069811344147,
-0.1837962418794632,
-0.6699875593185425,
-0.49543696641921997,
1.1320635080337524,
0.27689287066459656,
-0.6317854523658752,
-0.14226125180721283,
-0.1901768445968628,
0.6397820711135864,
-0.21064136922359467,
-0.26080745458602905,
0.26891180872917175,
0.4335431158542633,
-0.1951933205127716,
-0.819460928440094,
0.45764246582984924,
-0.016126222908496857,
0.1630866825580597,
0.28067073225975037,
-0.49385321140289307,
0.697034478187561,
0.10008734464645386,
-0.83012855052948,
0.05029955878853798,
0.5188553333282471,
0.2746250629425049,
0.22992965579032898,
0.4852224290370941,
0.2627752423286438,
0.6884229183197021,
-0.22724713385105133,
0.8514697551727295,
0.22908839583396912,
0.5012493133544922,
0.3225528597831726,
-0.07989253103733063,
0.635841429233551,
0.5271830558776855,
-0.16640928387641907,
0.409671425819397,
0.43774959444999695,
0.027406496927142143,
0.6876727342605591,
0.4037880301475525,
-0.7429323792457581,
-0.3997690677642822,
-0.04072067141532898,
-0.3896227777004242,
0.34259307384490967,
0.34449687600135803,
-0.5561655759811401,
-0.06898309290409088,
0.2229490876197815,
0.2689071297645569,
0.03067656047642231,
-0.46199196577072144,
0.6289970874786377,
0.06449566781520844,
-0.35158902406692505,
1.034414529800415,
-0.02026294358074665,
1.030863642692566,
-0.7372968196868896,
0.06039759889245033,
-0.21367652714252472,
-0.11397439986467361,
-0.33159977197647095,
-0.7724886536598206,
0.03351324796676636,
0.07125955075025558,
0.06799821555614471,
-0.5247970223426819,
1.1532998085021973,
-0.7215234041213989,
-0.17582063376903534,
0.37841930985450745,
0.07344881445169449,
0.21003952622413635,
-0.011668501421809196,
-0.36445826292037964,
0.22464513778686523,
-0.05797383189201355,
-0.2927968502044678,
0.24077622592449188,
0.2322205901145935,
-0.406406432390213,
0.6876736879348755,
0.777511477470398,
0.3296073377132416,
0.2416485697031021,
0.2606184482574463,
0.9140053987503052,
-0.5183219909667969,
-0.5603727102279663,
-0.8837904334068298,
-0.25611943006515503,
0.043040163815021515,
-0.025336595252156258,
0.8570653796195984,
0.41966891288757324,
0.47478216886520386,
-0.15136203169822693,
0.6700686812400818,
0.17009328305721283,
0.018091564998030663,
-0.9701669216156006,
0.8886694312095642,
-0.6301833391189575,
0.5948963761329651,
-0.20663100481033325,
-0.6128705739974976,
-0.4367363452911377,
0.36115342378616333,
0.037196289747953415,
0.01222547609359026,
0.8244342803955078,
0.941182017326355,
0.04450327530503273,
0.1283418983221054,
0.33430880308151245,
0.08448252081871033,
0.365298867225647,
0.41524696350097656,
0.9117082953453064,
-0.3895276188850403,
0.5188459157943726,
-0.12506647408008575,
-0.30812305212020874,
-0.22421620786190033,
-0.4494609832763672,
-1.1706632375717163,
-0.6184338927268982,
-0.11189247667789459,
-0.39726370573043823,
0.15458321571350098,
0.264070063829422,
0.43816280364990234,
-0.6635493636131287,
-0.09855320304632187,
-0.31999024748802185,
0.29052942991256714,
-0.07150609791278839,
-0.23371750116348267,
0.32598355412483215,
-0.13850286602973938,
-0.5362899899482727,
0.6745854616165161,
0.48088163137435913,
0.1587652862071991,
-0.5680698156356812,
0.006111902184784412,
-0.11436934024095535,
-0.27755096554756165,
0.5113962292671204,
0.14371225237846375,
-1.106550931930542,
-0.4049597978591919,
0.10326778143644333,
-0.3629809319972992,
-0.19136101007461548,
1.1150310039520264,
-0.5013651251792908,
0.4155065417289734,
0.7173441052436829,
0.4180971682071686,
0.6193192601203918,
-0.37141111493110657,
0.1947355568408966,
-0.8572627902030945,
0.17637141048908234,
0.28986459970474243,
0.4094458818435669,
-0.07472967356443405,
-0.61558997631073,
0.13481871783733368,
0.7202057242393494,
-0.26012474298477173,
-1.1210805177688599,
0.2909662127494812,
-1.2284902334213257,
-0.40540561079978943,
1.5386766195297241,
-0.1352146565914154,
-0.38053420186042786,
-0.3368469476699829,
-0.24777714908123016,
0.4093715250492096,
-0.31548815965652466,
0.6201526522636414,
0.42324313521385193,
0.12429603189229965,
0.13869744539260864,
-0.489433228969574,
0.8275926113128662,
0.45473718643188477,
-0.6876547336578369,
0.14977985620498657,
0.11710439622402191,
0.44340312480926514,
0.03137248009443283,
0.4728044867515564,
-0.14747226238250732,
0.02262284979224205,
0.026466943323612213,
-0.22030162811279297,
-0.23349200189113617,
-0.49194759130477905,
-0.45300164818763733,
0.2737286388874054,
-0.25786757469177246,
-0.3170948922634125
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.04216v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.04216v2
|
What Do Language Models Learn in Context? The Structured Task Hypothesis
| 2024-06-06T16:15:34 | 2024-06-08T11:59:08 |
Jiaoda Li, Yifan Hou, Mrinmaya Sachan, Ryan Cotterell
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Large language models (LLMs) exhibit an intriguing ability to learn a novel
task from in-context examples presented in a demonstration, termed in-context
learning (ICL). Understandably, a swath of research has been dedicated to
uncovering the theories underpinning ICL. One popular hypothesis explains ICL
by task selection. LLMs identify the task based on the demonstration and
generalize it to the prompt. Another popular hypothesis is that ICL is a form
of meta-learning, i.e., the models learn a learning algorithm at pre-training
time and apply it to the demonstration. Finally, a third hypothesis argues that
LLMs use the demonstration to select a composition of tasks learned during
pre-training to perform ICL. In this paper, we empirically explore these three
hypotheses that explain LLMs' ability to learn in context with a suite of
experiments derived from common text classification tasks. We invalidate the
first two hypotheses with counterexamples and provide evidence in support of
the last hypothesis. Our results suggest an LLM could learn a novel task in
context via composing tasks learned during pre-training.
|
[
-0.227091446518898,
-0.949327290058136,
0.8739910125732422,
0.046013470739126205,
-0.12374670058488846,
-0.031239794567227364,
-0.2555018365383148,
-0.42048564553260803,
-0.32782644033432007,
0.29998597502708435,
-0.5210332870483398,
-0.5519345998764038,
-0.39644041657447815,
0.2881588339805603,
-0.5691441893577576,
1.003946304321289,
-0.13218694925308228,
-0.005957238841801882,
-0.3331656754016876,
0.14793512225151062,
-0.5567173957824707,
-0.6204221844673157,
-0.4561259150505066,
-0.47234511375427246,
0.5264890789985657,
0.5655118227005005,
0.1956455558538437,
0.5373567342758179,
0.06010366976261139,
0.28077569603919983,
0.21509426832199097,
-0.10004282742738724,
-0.3411259949207306,
0.16544358432292938,
-0.18025551736354828,
-0.7830491662025452,
-0.013930467888712883,
0.28633856773376465,
0.7557712197303772,
0.8973161578178406,
0.051583364605903625,
0.10262028872966766,
0.42272666096687317,
0.319160133600235,
-0.7350121736526489,
0.154728502035141,
-0.8265431523323059,
0.0062883635982871056,
-0.10562853515148163,
-0.18050338327884674,
-0.7763363122940063,
0.196336567401886,
0.26571810245513916,
-0.5014558434486389,
0.07865525037050247,
0.11379769444465637,
0.6153257489204407,
0.10456883907318115,
-0.8071841597557068,
-0.5841076374053955,
-0.7687123417854309,
0.7577276229858398,
-0.539073646068573,
0.3045506179332733,
0.43553563952445984,
0.20908091962337494,
0.03929680958390236,
-0.9735960364341736,
-0.49650126695632935,
-0.48803946375846863,
-0.38678011298179626,
-0.19892409443855286,
0.19415056705474854,
-0.09830289334058762,
0.6309000253677368,
0.24253912270069122,
-0.3080344796180725,
0.23241682350635529,
-0.06218807399272919,
0.1026388481259346,
0.25114232301712036,
0.07616633176803589,
0.5173681378364563,
-0.036767810583114624,
-0.4175132215023041,
0.03361498937010765,
-1.002591848373413,
0.2258693277835846,
-0.09977076947689056,
0.26783037185668945,
-0.30843567848205566,
0.38162702322006226,
-0.10584518313407898,
0.7493775486946106,
0.0256701298058033,
-0.42058801651000977,
0.22327354550361633,
-0.057762641459703445,
-0.34183359146118164,
0.050783585757017136,
0.6143419146537781,
-0.25591138005256653,
0.2486094981431961,
-0.19396597146987915,
-0.4534105062484741,
-0.11480648815631866,
0.17978636920452118,
-0.5645487904548645,
0.03565826639533043,
-0.03523710370063782,
-0.5786007642745972,
-0.002972096437588334,
0.0235623549669981,
-0.1486334353685379,
0.05866149067878723,
-0.4667964279651642,
0.7675034403800964,
-0.34250596165657043,
-0.12414675205945969,
-0.07866477966308594,
-0.0682000145316124,
0.2424090951681137,
0.21744532883167267,
-1.0241615772247314,
0.5110699534416199,
0.7900571227073669,
0.6615746021270752,
-0.4749508798122406,
-0.5980619788169861,
-0.44902849197387695,
0.19178418815135956,
-0.313848078250885,
0.782568633556366,
-0.6035091876983643,
-0.3059519827365875,
0.08925922214984894,
0.1751856654882431,
-0.5299404859542847,
-0.4681427478790283,
0.20776085555553436,
-0.41820859909057617,
0.3520214557647705,
-0.38747283816337585,
-0.6198822855949402,
-0.17739634215831757,
0.20359846949577332,
-0.5126675367355347,
0.913196325302124,
-0.05450267717242241,
-0.900084912776947,
0.7067945599555969,
-0.578691303730011,
-0.6898301839828491,
0.04469531401991844,
-0.4595522880554199,
-0.1350889950990677,
0.3113917410373688,
-0.1796681135892868,
0.7918927669525146,
-0.11677417904138565,
0.24032633006572723,
-0.22313833236694336,
-0.6389982104301453,
0.62687087059021,
-0.27201971411705017,
0.6399750113487244,
0.17897601425647736,
-0.6977492570877075,
0.09836503118276596,
-0.5156222581863403,
-0.2128123939037323,
0.09865957498550415,
-0.5452752113342285,
-0.5736774802207947,
0.4405398666858673,
-0.2590145766735077,
0.33043229579925537,
-0.11927961558103561,
-0.4891761839389801,
0.12610778212547302,
-0.43243011832237244,
0.47008001804351807,
0.5011495351791382,
-0.17653118073940277,
0.5227707028388977,
-0.4121330976486206,
0.3782944679260254,
-0.12576575577259064,
-0.3780147135257721,
-0.38259729743003845,
-0.033906836062669754,
-0.6159644722938538,
-0.3161705732345581,
0.021364063024520874,
0.3793623149394989,
-0.6810235977172852,
-0.10836824029684067,
-0.13540109992027283,
-0.19270524382591248,
-0.01775861158967018,
0.19374039769172668,
0.5430914759635925,
0.6948596835136414,
0.10685785114765167,
0.11466722935438156,
-0.39146801829338074,
-0.8624131679534912,
-0.3390725255012512,
0.009238033555448055,
-0.01640407182276249,
0.33156582713127136,
0.7995054125785828,
-0.11214062571525574,
0.8472880721092224,
-0.3424186110496521,
0.08397737145423889,
-0.5195607542991638,
0.1355137974023819,
0.15664248168468475,
0.4217015504837036,
0.6372629404067993,
-0.930992841720581,
-0.6964895129203796,
-0.17037895321846008,
-0.724776029586792,
-0.03913799673318863,
0.05175778269767761,
0.29369834065437317,
0.3088831901550293,
1.0343801975250244,
-0.5119220614433289,
0.3492133617401123,
0.3907344937324524,
-0.1512337625026703,
0.5834488868713379,
-0.24489720165729523,
-0.0550069585442543,
-1.0819646120071411,
-0.03095511719584465,
-0.24066177010536194,
-0.22716134786605835,
-0.7006229162216187,
0.016473472118377686,
0.20401453971862793,
0.15339921414852142,
-0.558636486530304,
0.7192366123199463,
-0.5869253873825073,
-0.2777072787284851,
-0.5569184422492981,
-0.08768512308597565,
-0.31189632415771484,
0.5192710161209106,
0.48886632919311523,
0.561327338218689,
0.6578571796417236,
-0.8316121101379395,
-0.33446764945983887,
-0.02619512379169464,
-0.635779619216919,
0.0294547900557518,
-0.5749462842941284,
0.0843430683016777,
-0.2005116045475006,
0.3210771083831787,
-1.1482913494110107,
-0.360847145318985,
0.004271560814231634,
-0.05542705953121185,
0.26398909091949463,
0.07170484215021133,
-0.43702128529548645,
0.07045093178749084,
0.25555282831192017,
0.4351429343223572,
0.4621868133544922,
-0.47039327025413513,
0.43417665362358093,
0.30515748262405396,
0.06414618343114853,
-0.6111918091773987,
-0.7193467020988464,
-0.24765561521053314,
-0.46222513914108276,
0.0869348868727684,
0.4509430527687073,
-0.16078032553195953,
-0.5737151503562927,
-0.18456575274467468,
0.01385305356234312,
-0.10473326593637466,
0.6577651500701904,
0.5344321727752686,
0.0012391015188768506,
-0.22977730631828308,
0.26427289843559265,
-0.23764638602733612,
0.016901014372706413,
0.2015630155801773,
-0.22980867326259613,
0.5322024822235107,
-0.04890218377113342,
-0.5852043032646179,
-0.14075423777103424,
0.20726220309734344,
0.604962170124054,
-0.03963644430041313,
0.7084295749664307,
0.28914234042167664,
-0.4509236812591553,
-0.6070422530174255,
-0.3121289908885956,
-0.20565250515937805,
-0.4257846474647522,
0.40358713269233704,
-0.5292189717292786,
-0.9465664625167847,
0.2646619379520416,
-0.23231621086597443,
0.13532862067222595,
0.2786679267883301,
0.5275683403015137,
-0.24782012403011322,
0.9714019894599915,
0.8111523389816284,
0.2667924165725708,
0.6462501287460327,
-0.22987045347690582,
0.05489258095622063,
-0.8384674191474915,
-0.2875434458255768,
-0.5717380046844482,
-0.29017844796180725,
-0.49661585688591003,
-0.07320446521043777,
0.3695061206817627,
0.10548466444015503,
-0.2703293263912201,
0.20008105039596558,
0.08947192877531052,
0.6068552732467651,
0.5964167714118958,
0.18737953901290894,
0.15875248610973358,
-0.11092948913574219,
-0.38304558396339417,
0.23212496936321259,
-0.6481645703315735,
-0.6064927577972412,
1.0083906650543213,
0.11938582360744476,
0.5061032772064209,
-0.11322452127933502,
0.6119430661201477,
0.13175417482852936,
0.5436117053031921,
-0.6474219560623169,
0.583442747592926,
-0.019192682579159737,
-0.610255241394043,
-0.2250710129737854,
0.052632369101047516,
-0.8526944518089294,
0.3141292333602905,
-0.26338034868240356,
-0.7614752650260925,
-0.12290019541978836,
0.2518247663974762,
-0.019661732017993927,
0.11711519211530685,
-0.47313714027404785,
0.9114922881126404,
-0.27510708570480347,
-0.35877037048339844,
-0.2627808451652527,
-0.6868305802345276,
0.43142786622047424,
-0.20261073112487793,
0.3808309733867645,
0.17405255138874054,
0.0009115891298279166,
0.6062771081924438,
0.002929941052570939,
1.107757329940796,
-0.09837933629751205,
-0.23676396906375885,
0.2353702336549759,
0.27352285385131836,
0.3197748064994812,
0.04379519820213318,
-0.052500151097774506,
-0.26267388463020325,
-0.08783181011676788,
-0.2631058990955353,
-0.5741354823112488,
0.39032673835754395,
-0.5691202878952026,
-0.7654733061790466,
-0.27763068675994873,
-0.5039945840835571,
-0.20121686160564423,
0.10353674739599228,
0.4481813311576843,
0.7381519675254822,
-0.2546761631965637,
0.5544761419296265,
0.633927047252655,
-0.1597074568271637,
0.7609875202178955,
0.7685188055038452,
-0.10583286732435226,
0.2107696831226349,
0.3963130712509155,
-0.009725390002131462,
0.5601310133934021,
0.7320369482040405,
0.24078187346458435,
-0.08074463903903961,
-0.7942543029785156,
0.1357225775718689,
0.0035565532743930817,
-0.9696179628372192,
0.2413627803325653,
-0.6612849831581116,
-0.16629236936569214,
-0.2151462882757187,
-0.31357541680336,
0.08892463892698288,
-0.033320050686597824,
-0.2993362545967102,
-0.3392445147037506,
-0.37251386046409607,
0.9721533060073853,
0.2167934626340866,
0.40589287877082825,
-0.4757222831249237,
0.11310425400733948,
0.48828601837158203,
-0.2033505141735077,
0.09282322973012924,
-0.5053627490997314,
-0.3016662299633026,
0.13138143718242645,
-0.2063804566860199,
-0.6901857852935791,
0.30237868428230286,
0.3399227261543274,
0.8642438054084778,
0.46720194816589355,
-0.17623770236968994,
0.412661612033844,
-0.760158896446228,
0.7596034407615662,
-0.2722187936306,
-0.9915995597839355,
0.4115612804889679,
-0.36143678426742554,
0.3441954255104065,
0.36039215326309204,
0.7522796988487244,
-0.4428246319293976,
-0.27970701456069946,
-0.48950842022895813,
-0.34961065649986267,
0.6083751320838928,
-0.2475566565990448,
0.16480033099651337,
-0.2675867974758148,
0.5215387940406799,
0.5183526873588562,
0.33433154225349426,
-1.2591643333435059,
-0.011348934844136238,
0.09735686331987381,
-0.18365797400474548,
-0.3960917294025421,
-0.4168075919151306,
0.06473308801651001,
-0.20988018810749054,
0.2600351572036743,
-0.42618444561958313,
0.0960337445139885,
0.18648754060268402,
-0.6544245481491089,
0.1674376130104065,
0.2843082547187805,
0.8193987607955933,
1.0134505033493042,
0.06279396265745163,
0.5329908728599548,
0.32574203610420227,
-0.11570798605680466,
0.12212328612804413,
-0.4560548663139343,
-0.24390800297260284,
-0.24830275774002075,
1.1226147413253784,
1.0701733827590942,
0.7131919860839844,
-0.7635576128959656,
0.6125322580337524,
0.06309264898300171,
-0.29487550258636475,
-0.3229901194572449,
0.24743886291980743,
0.12360861152410507,
0.12918873131275177,
0.49858689308166504,
-0.10932821035385132,
0.04716523364186287,
-1.0776888132095337,
0.2989676296710968,
0.6005316376686096,
-0.4153144359588623,
-0.6242989301681519,
0.4901711344718933,
-0.13109883666038513,
-0.4329550564289093,
0.32504674792289734,
-0.03762638196349144,
-0.6924977898597717,
0.5425854325294495,
0.9954491257667542,
0.8553066253662109,
-0.16844509541988373,
0.134443461894989,
0.20186002552509308,
0.07855385541915894,
-0.15482033789157867,
0.05546218156814575,
-0.5096119046211243,
-0.8138123154640198,
-0.532637357711792,
-0.6524421572685242,
-0.2582985460758209,
0.2395256757736206,
-0.429916650056839,
0.3116295635700226,
-0.2624775171279907,
0.30271416902542114,
-0.22406014800071716,
-0.19835953414440155,
-0.6882186532020569,
0.23321768641471863,
0.2797272801399231,
0.8544199466705322,
-1.1485728025436401,
1.0143241882324219,
0.6254625916481018,
0.00139914033934474,
-0.840259850025177,
0.276579350233078,
-0.12935824692249298,
-0.80555659532547,
1.3448516130447388,
0.40202537178993225,
-0.02008175663650036,
-0.01602994091808796,
-0.7474574446678162,
-0.9914124608039856,
0.9719812870025635,
0.296317994594574,
-0.2860376834869385,
-0.26874682307243347,
0.007296326104551554,
0.3680471181869507,
-1.0529491901397705,
0.3445736765861511,
0.262557715177536,
0.11301160603761673,
0.017733672633767128,
-0.9316006898880005,
0.14890222251415253,
0.011894880793988705,
-0.22287185490131378,
-0.1493038386106491,
-0.38478177785873413,
1.2518398761749268,
-0.3452646732330322,
-0.3433552384376526,
-0.1048428937792778,
0.5061819553375244,
0.2593998908996582,
0.40842899680137634,
0.7449065446853638,
0.13552117347717285,
0.4509665071964264,
0.03316958248615265,
1.1445035934448242,
-0.24654880166053772,
0.03185344487428665,
1.13813054561615,
-0.48492273688316345,
0.9446579217910767,
0.3429476022720337,
0.22645436227321625,
1.0371555089950562,
0.7857577204704285,
0.3861963450908661,
0.7474654912948608,
0.060315005481243134,
-0.08878371119499207,
-0.33660727739334106,
0.12670458853244781,
0.08540182560682297,
0.7175742983818054,
0.47598111629486084,
-0.3417621850967407,
-0.11317171156406403,
0.505516767501831,
0.043113239109516144,
0.03464488312602043,
-0.25630664825439453,
0.9686905145645142,
0.24543240666389465,
-1.0717886686325073,
0.4075804352760315,
-0.2402443289756775,
0.42921537160873413,
-0.6834332346916199,
-0.15825802087783813,
0.18402701616287231,
0.2174156904220581,
-0.028933748602867126,
-0.39857593178749084,
0.23002417385578156,
-0.37306341528892517,
-0.19938687980175018,
-0.4711652994155884,
0.7092634439468384,
-0.4708132743835449,
-0.1019316092133522,
0.19295845925807953,
0.4707629680633545,
0.04693154618144035,
-0.06437021493911743,
-0.4156133532524109,
-0.07294490188360214,
-0.15352767705917358,
-0.3145827054977417,
0.5452980995178223,
0.4648413360118866,
-0.18514420092105865,
0.8044189214706421,
0.39759668707847595,
0.0462435744702816,
-0.10595706105232239,
-0.3485795259475708,
0.616304337978363,
-0.5068597197532654,
-0.5315895676612854,
-1.160003900527954,
0.44374242424964905,
0.19381651282310486,
-0.15528106689453125,
0.996020495891571,
0.445165753364563,
1.036848783493042,
-0.27616068720817566,
0.805648684501648,
0.017728552222251892,
0.5755485892295837,
-0.9412050843238831,
0.3087191581726074,
-0.5582401156425476,
0.10145190358161926,
-0.29831162095069885,
-0.7000832557678223,
0.013786987401545048,
0.4416730999946594,
-0.4618425965309143,
0.08364568650722504,
1.2153757810592651,
0.34094005823135376,
-0.16347990930080414,
-0.015471421182155609,
0.30362892150878906,
0.19971001148223877,
0.23481760919094086,
0.4852564036846161,
0.9465531706809998,
0.010118845850229263,
0.007774094585329294,
-0.008728262037038803,
-0.1348971128463745,
-0.19402022659778595,
-0.9977872371673584,
-1.2496217489242554,
-0.9343221783638,
-0.10111601650714874,
-0.10023272037506104,
-0.1852273941040039,
1.003443717956543,
0.8188114762306213,
-0.614105224609375,
-0.5643792748451233,
-0.08302317559719086,
0.2486419677734375,
-0.1872180849313736,
-0.18061912059783936,
0.3741583824157715,
-0.612307608127594,
-0.7678249478340149,
0.650312066078186,
0.15926380455493927,
0.1009741872549057,
0.08685492724180222,
0.028880732133984566,
-0.32280856370925903,
-0.22656415402889252,
0.6301030516624451,
0.3240149915218353,
-0.7901735305786133,
-0.43091970682144165,
0.006997645366936922,
-0.18420784175395966,
-0.15116141736507416,
1.2022403478622437,
-0.935056209564209,
-0.0994005873799324,
0.5094507932662964,
0.5825722813606262,
0.4697284400463104,
-0.17816096544265747,
0.6817899942398071,
-0.751135528087616,
0.31813639402389526,
-0.001796258962713182,
0.542643129825592,
0.16076090931892395,
-0.06927872449159622,
0.23496703803539276,
0.30473771691322327,
-0.5246998071670532,
-0.9379419088363647,
0.42380112409591675,
-0.42613276839256287,
-0.7534738183021545,
1.2311851978302002,
-0.16190023720264435,
-0.4439021646976471,
-0.08456115424633026,
-0.045410070568323135,
0.06204192712903023,
0.2803002595901489,
0.5883411169052124,
0.7650322914123535,
-0.1200353130698204,
-0.010143142193555832,
-0.7493993639945984,
0.8416445255279541,
0.3044421374797821,
-0.6898351311683655,
-0.03540264815092087,
0.17037136852741241,
0.6694482564926147,
-0.05449814349412918,
0.6803106665611267,
0.3338521122932434,
0.130433589220047,
-0.40349122881889343,
-0.23261897265911102,
0.04043992981314659,
-0.6243407726287842,
-0.2062043845653534,
0.3465708792209625,
0.036314599215984344,
-0.01770598255097866
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.04215v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.04215v1
|
mCSQA: Multilingual Commonsense Reasoning Dataset with Unified Creation Strategy by Language Models and Humans
| 2024-06-06T16:14:54 | 2024-06-06T16:14:54 |
Yusuke Sakai, Hidetaka Kamigaito, Taro Watanabe
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
It is very challenging to curate a dataset for language-specific knowledge
and common sense in order to evaluate natural language understanding
capabilities of language models. Due to the limitation in the availability of
annotators, most current multilingual datasets are created through translation,
which cannot evaluate such language-specific aspects. Therefore, we propose
Multilingual CommonsenseQA (mCSQA) based on the construction process of CSQA
but leveraging language models for a more efficient construction, e.g., by
asking LM to generate questions/answers, refine answers and verify QAs followed
by reduced human efforts for verification. Constructed dataset is a benchmark
for cross-lingual language-transfer capabilities of multilingual LMs, and
experimental results showed high language-transfer capabilities for questions
that LMs could easily solve, but lower transfer capabilities for questions
requiring deep knowledge or commonsense. This highlights the necessity of
language-specific datasets for evaluation and training. Finally, our method
demonstrated that multilingual LMs could create QA including language-specific
knowledge, significantly reducing the dataset creation cost compared to manual
creation. The datasets are available at
https://huggingface.co/datasets/yusuke1997/mCSQA.
|
[
-0.544047474861145,
-0.48838600516319275,
0.36924949288368225,
-0.013765610754489899,
-0.03583435341715813,
-0.04104369878768921,
-0.14272572100162506,
-0.14156129956245422,
-0.060336098074913025,
0.6650736927986145,
-0.46353986859321594,
-0.44225606322288513,
-0.15588386356830597,
0.2707822322845459,
0.04078027978539467,
0.7976670861244202,
-0.009563261643052101,
0.18334907293319702,
-0.5917180776596069,
-0.3793395757675171,
-0.2741429805755615,
-0.6489432454109192,
-0.45610520243644714,
-0.11849004775285721,
0.45540881156921387,
0.7111093997955322,
0.7055519819259644,
0.40093129873275757,
0.1702318638563156,
0.29777947068214417,
-0.01602618396282196,
0.5444815158843994,
-0.11711061745882034,
-0.16796419024467468,
-0.48422086238861084,
-0.25149640440940857,
-0.19079291820526123,
-0.3466041684150696,
0.6538339257240295,
0.7776451110839844,
-0.20761491358280182,
0.4405285120010376,
-0.08392128348350525,
0.5399302244186401,
-0.6575586199760437,
-0.20076677203178406,
-0.7496311664581299,
-0.04231657087802887,
-0.1513698399066925,
0.0741734653711319,
-0.14899992942810059,
-0.2855061888694763,
-0.121975377202034,
-0.6680567860603333,
0.15473394095897675,
-0.032090138643980026,
0.7350797653198242,
0.0013519541826099157,
-0.7958093285560608,
-0.2639008164405823,
-0.17077916860580444,
0.9783006906509399,
-0.7397172451019287,
0.6914756298065186,
0.15383145213127136,
0.520561933517456,
-0.14198657870292664,
-0.647777259349823,
-0.8762649893760681,
-0.2501511573791504,
0.02612902782857418,
-0.04163201525807381,
0.10125807672739029,
-0.4064381420612335,
0.20531433820724487,
0.06322510540485382,
-0.7695643305778503,
0.004856324754655361,
-0.5702804923057556,
-0.40845930576324463,
0.742361307144165,
0.1627206951379776,
0.4644797444343567,
-0.4645155370235443,
-0.3992170989513397,
0.11665912717580795,
-0.7717328071594238,
0.06594519317150116,
0.3666919767856598,
0.6217136383056641,
0.0006780590629205108,
0.5398545861244202,
-0.7101992964744568,
0.5779896974563599,
-0.3171035051345825,
-0.3390336036682129,
0.41670554876327515,
-0.39366254210472107,
0.0000669595247018151,
-0.11461754888296127,
0.760977029800415,
0.14920678734779358,
0.49702218174934387,
-0.13673162460327148,
-0.1355924755334854,
0.09835636615753174,
0.038820140063762665,
-0.45848992466926575,
-0.10841724276542664,
0.3160397708415985,
-0.09098374098539352,
-0.2480255514383316,
-0.20559494197368622,
-0.5055410861968994,
-0.20868948101997375,
-0.6071553230285645,
0.09562293440103531,
-0.05705486238002777,
-0.5883243083953857,
0.2990292012691498,
0.1756056696176529,
0.043665871024131775,
0.1396513432264328,
-0.502379298210144,
0.23164059221744537,
0.31317979097366333,
0.4201282858848572,
-0.2426348179578781,
-0.5209344625473022,
-0.5584795475006104,
0.20856907963752747,
-0.1870540827512741,
0.8685137033462524,
-0.19892556965351105,
-0.16391751170158386,
-0.019663730636239052,
0.026108667254447937,
-0.044914159923791885,
-0.4954380989074707,
0.6014773845672607,
-0.5118620991706848,
0.3180274963378906,
-0.6187381148338318,
-0.35078057646751404,
-0.06903823465108871,
0.6196930408477783,
-0.6627316474914551,
1.1306082010269165,
-0.09463248401880264,
-0.6633752584457397,
0.20557621121406555,
-0.7635353803634644,
-0.3936864733695984,
0.2530641555786133,
-0.24176086485385895,
-0.03172009810805321,
-0.375351220369339,
0.6998725533485413,
0.6228495240211487,
-0.31000208854675293,
0.6689602732658386,
-0.2660689651966095,
-0.03207044675946236,
0.539553165435791,
-0.49177610874176025,
0.9546032547950745,
0.545222282409668,
-0.0841258093714714,
-0.22197361290454865,
-0.7042648196220398,
0.20681311190128326,
0.13170161843299866,
-0.31699833273887634,
-0.10385177284479141,
-0.2709932327270508,
0.14021050930023193,
0.5647361874580383,
0.19771327078342438,
-0.5047380328178406,
-0.06792642921209335,
-0.06452114135026932,
0.1945565938949585,
0.4697081744670868,
0.05829412862658501,
0.30611053109169006,
-0.28081315755844116,
0.5402829647064209,
0.22075685858726501,
0.14310941100120544,
0.10305479913949966,
-0.4361608326435089,
-0.5721433162689209,
-0.10290811955928802,
0.27434659004211426,
0.7357137203216553,
-1.0951076745986938,
0.03726208209991455,
-0.37834373116493225,
-0.4127497971057892,
-0.33192962408065796,
0.44491246342658997,
0.6592673063278198,
0.6063162684440613,
0.35383760929107666,
-0.10309020429849625,
-0.3610219359397888,
-0.9775857925415039,
-0.25800660252571106,
0.06881609559059143,
0.05630875006318092,
0.22256317734718323,
0.5319715738296509,
-0.0590452142059803,
0.7701774835586548,
-0.42065683007240295,
0.1085568219423294,
-0.37480297684669495,
-0.0350806750357151,
0.057408761233091354,
0.5492676496505737,
0.3110112249851227,
-1.074203610420227,
-0.22117722034454346,
0.02075367234647274,
-0.8527455925941467,
-0.21960262954235077,
-0.004675489850342274,
-0.24251876771450043,
0.18122009932994843,
0.49699100852012634,
-0.3496536612510681,
0.07916144281625748,
0.5301783680915833,
-0.16345572471618652,
0.8965299725532532,
0.18574164807796478,
0.329588919878006,
-1.4501609802246094,
0.2764912545681,
-0.08832439035177231,
-0.1730465441942215,
-0.6257599592208862,
0.2461720108985901,
0.10422352701425552,
-0.2960571348667145,
-0.9004470109939575,
0.851646900177002,
-0.4912247955799103,
-0.08180564641952515,
0.21058626472949982,
0.5355927348136902,
0.17339208722114563,
0.8088595271110535,
0.16980642080307007,
0.5721037983894348,
0.4011044502258301,
-0.8141474723815918,
0.39693695306777954,
0.3063298761844635,
-0.44906383752822876,
0.9534209370613098,
-0.6108067631721497,
0.06934622675180435,
0.03592712804675102,
0.014677776023745537,
-0.7900140285491943,
-0.1842680722475052,
0.1852116584777832,
-0.47786223888397217,
-0.1471763253211975,
-0.10221459716558456,
-0.6010239124298096,
-0.41793715953826904,
0.18890297412872314,
0.5965093970298767,
-0.07112191617488861,
-0.6574916839599609,
0.3301859498023987,
0.39331236481666565,
-0.4091559946537018,
-0.8559601306915283,
-0.9080919027328491,
0.13256818056106567,
-0.10809896141290665,
-0.6873631477355957,
-0.0510474294424057,
-0.20080219209194183,
-0.204213485121727,
-0.040167517960071564,
0.08008547872304916,
-0.3037249445915222,
0.052117567509412766,
-0.1613846868276596,
0.16404499113559723,
-0.19863136112689972,
0.4817192852497101,
0.4287582039833069,
-0.011258753947913647,
-0.0004710697685368359,
-0.025464188307523727,
0.16002072393894196,
-0.26205530762672424,
-0.6076460480690002,
-0.3039657175540924,
0.4967710077762604,
0.5052574276924133,
-0.5232097506523132,
0.47703811526298523,
0.5563924908638,
-0.3615189790725708,
-0.15077193081378937,
-0.6882626414299011,
-0.0033952349331229925,
-0.4194204807281494,
0.40044063329696655,
-0.8022798299789429,
-0.9240866899490356,
0.5865844488143921,
-0.1110341027379036,
0.09600900858640671,
0.5405433177947998,
0.5143454670906067,
0.2152479887008667,
0.9994692802429199,
-0.10918320715427399,
0.17019304633140564,
-0.16616353392601013,
-0.016271617263555527,
-0.1982763111591339,
-0.7227529883384705,
-0.3405447006225586,
-0.5825793147087097,
0.024477388709783554,
-0.48195260763168335,
-0.4728238880634308,
0.13442257046699524,
0.07743252068758011,
-0.4883330464363098,
0.15060101449489594,
-0.4193546175956726,
0.5481619834899902,
0.5098033547401428,
0.0565989650785923,
0.5111499428749084,
-0.05068798363208771,
-0.5821765065193176,
0.0925101712346077,
-0.9007334113121033,
-0.7286511063575745,
1.190219521522522,
0.1252949982881546,
0.14444606006145477,
0.44748204946517944,
0.6090317964553833,
0.16894128918647766,
0.30545857548713684,
-0.43454307317733765,
0.5607402920722961,
0.03744249790906906,
-0.7045244574546814,
-0.324846476316452,
-0.7908413410186768,
-0.7377630472183228,
0.3084251284599304,
-0.29182717204093933,
-0.5908586978912354,
0.09652085602283478,
-0.0360209159553051,
-0.051277756690979004,
0.3070548176765442,
-0.7144244313240051,
1.0318511724472046,
-0.33685243129730225,
-0.3258931040763855,
0.0977642834186554,
-0.5540710091590881,
0.5836489200592041,
-0.04613421484827995,
0.5388569235801697,
-0.1619715392589569,
0.012575129047036171,
0.7433932423591614,
-0.45226868987083435,
0.6429299116134644,
-0.26184919476509094,
-0.25486040115356445,
0.47459203004837036,
-0.015712805092334747,
0.29900509119033813,
0.4176122546195984,
-0.11414165049791336,
0.11781948059797287,
0.30731409788131714,
-0.7004534602165222,
-0.6443638205528259,
0.6832978129386902,
-0.6061939001083374,
-0.289989709854126,
-0.20488305389881134,
-0.6332635879516602,
-0.510418713092804,
0.16794075071811676,
0.05960406735539436,
0.6077540516853333,
-0.3254161477088928,
-0.08860298991203308,
0.6113356947898865,
-0.22513602674007416,
0.1872883141040802,
0.5881077647209167,
-0.2964519262313843,
-0.562431275844574,
0.855791449546814,
0.03356228768825531,
0.3695327341556549,
0.300485759973526,
0.04212726652622223,
-0.56627357006073,
-0.3465366065502167,
-0.8272541761398315,
0.17745673656463623,
-0.7847805023193359,
-0.30012592673301697,
-0.4222013056278229,
-0.048187918961048126,
-0.5806669592857361,
-0.04726537689566612,
-0.41003063321113586,
-0.5222709774971008,
0.06014664098620415,
0.0964045524597168,
0.16082943975925446,
0.42650747299194336,
-0.1620180308818817,
0.03136952221393585,
-0.9980387091636658,
0.5490236878395081,
0.6221417188644409,
0.23865120112895966,
0.005014628637582064,
-0.3585611581802368,
-0.33583343029022217,
0.47223979234695435,
-0.2029513567686081,
-0.7608340382575989,
0.18226748704910278,
-0.06459285318851471,
0.8407167196273804,
0.2612358629703522,
0.09334354102611542,
0.5013825297355652,
-0.18574626743793488,
0.8313825130462646,
0.23810134828090668,
-0.9946216940879822,
0.3283277153968811,
-0.3574604094028473,
0.6435913443565369,
0.6622317433357239,
0.4117904603481293,
-0.7368172407150269,
-0.15333159267902374,
-0.602104663848877,
-0.46670979261398315,
0.356035053730011,
0.14712786674499512,
0.04815119877457619,
-0.10739243030548096,
0.21858803927898407,
0.06307514756917953,
0.18783602118492126,
-0.7092482447624207,
-0.05427301302552223,
-0.13110114634037018,
-0.16018182039260864,
0.055005915462970734,
-0.030321504920721054,
-0.09198660403490067,
-0.20633690059185028,
0.7281412482261658,
-0.4481513202190399,
-0.12395959347486496,
0.10919326543807983,
-0.29305499792099,
0.23698900640010834,
0.6771711707115173,
0.49353843927383423,
0.71058189868927,
0.15254941582679749,
0.10012450069189072,
0.5161046981811523,
-0.18394845724105835,
0.08132918924093246,
0.0369340255856514,
0.02827831730246544,
-0.17028780281543732,
0.03565280884504318,
0.474152147769928,
0.19373665750026703,
-0.9382538199424744,
0.439047634601593,
-0.07921852916479111,
-0.4969317615032196,
-0.08872263133525848,
-0.173519566655159,
0.3034197688102722,
0.2526811361312866,
0.2389974743127823,
-0.09737475961446762,
0.09967493265867233,
-0.2530190050601959,
0.3371545970439911,
0.22945135831832886,
-0.09476236999034882,
-0.08357750624418259,
0.31350433826446533,
0.17574132978916168,
0.1392941027879715,
0.7279059290885925,
-0.4306023418903351,
-0.5987619757652283,
0.4788378179073334,
0.39796772599220276,
0.3755750060081482,
-0.43463727831840515,
0.5654032826423645,
0.5323123931884766,
0.2340112328529358,
-0.07991335541009903,
0.6647358536720276,
-0.24600757658481598,
-1.0469257831573486,
-0.5181588530540466,
-0.4917225241661072,
-0.46212038397789,
0.06918207556009293,
-0.758846640586853,
0.14840185642242432,
0.023143555968999863,
0.17753565311431885,
-0.21663743257522583,
0.2269178032875061,
-0.8483629822731018,
0.6314042210578918,
0.004155459348112345,
0.9134593605995178,
-0.9927375912666321,
0.6717746257781982,
0.7404646277427673,
-0.45863181352615356,
-0.890758216381073,
-0.5199854969978333,
-0.02133585698902607,
-0.6714197397232056,
0.4486011862754822,
-0.0018914106767624617,
-0.02815609984099865,
-0.17040668427944183,
-0.5354703068733215,
-0.7679927349090576,
1.003832221031189,
0.46447572112083435,
-0.44110655784606934,
0.21692317724227905,
0.5532487630844116,
0.2949039340019226,
-0.37834346294403076,
-0.016672657802700996,
0.3409818410873413,
0.5650344491004944,
0.36651158332824707,
-0.8919219970703125,
0.19239337742328644,
-0.46936705708503723,
-0.14692625403404236,
0.17630580067634583,
-0.32530057430267334,
0.6455312967300415,
-0.33737441897392273,
-0.17386694252490997,
0.1378588080406189,
0.6538360118865967,
0.6641260981559753,
0.48018550872802734,
0.4315889775753021,
0.8108015060424805,
1.011264681816101,
0.1814902424812317,
0.6170921325683594,
0.061447545886039734,
0.07280275970697403,
1.3054972887039185,
-0.2682894170284271,
0.99315345287323,
0.4915117621421814,
-0.10978306829929352,
0.47292187809944153,
0.49545955657958984,
0.13762880861759186,
0.17654350399971008,
0.45932862162590027,
-0.22667169570922852,
-0.4303252100944519,
-0.3281088173389435,
-0.400170236825943,
0.6003381609916687,
0.2933289706707001,
-0.0617101825773716,
-0.17604728043079376,
0.07351234555244446,
0.1251906007528305,
0.283952534198761,
-0.35703542828559875,
0.6336477398872375,
-0.07072941213846207,
-0.5999549031257629,
0.5672553181648254,
-0.07840056717395782,
0.46044662594795227,
-0.4292239248752594,
0.18552911281585693,
-0.3288629651069641,
-0.18622435629367828,
-0.17373664677143097,
-0.7763424515724182,
0.24963749945163727,
0.10931097716093063,
-0.046582162380218506,
-0.019565198570489883,
0.5404865741729736,
-0.7077805399894714,
-0.6591665148735046,
-0.22554735839366913,
1.0389102697372437,
0.37857764959335327,
-0.2036845088005066,
-0.8305255770683289,
-0.31292274594306946,
0.016349850222468376,
-0.08818931132555008,
0.22257941961288452,
0.6944844722747803,
-0.2541634142398834,
0.6090635061264038,
0.8979029059410095,
0.09421572834253311,
-0.08162780851125717,
0.35508933663368225,
0.7755091786384583,
-0.4822445809841156,
-0.49610042572021484,
-0.26735225319862366,
0.7636750936508179,
-0.17869675159454346,
-0.5005923509597778,
0.6600322127342224,
0.5991933941841125,
0.9411031007766724,
0.0036231849808245897,
0.9516721963882446,
0.1663372814655304,
0.6443696022033691,
-0.6447190642356873,
0.8006796836853027,
-0.7198852300643921,
0.14395412802696228,
-0.35131219029426575,
-0.7374980449676514,
-0.42785751819610596,
0.12708070874214172,
-0.2093125730752945,
0.11715788394212723,
0.6272086501121521,
1.0760294198989868,
-0.193070188164711,
0.002431422472000122,
0.3841376304626465,
-0.23546433448791504,
0.06667779386043549,
0.780519962310791,
0.7303368449211121,
-0.5079911351203918,
0.7101535797119141,
-0.20216156542301178,
-0.029585808515548706,
0.27472755312919617,
-1.0074071884155273,
-0.884305477142334,
-0.857406735420227,
-0.34028878808021545,
-0.09872027486562729,
-0.056112248450517654,
0.7210339307785034,
0.4950028955936432,
-0.9283300042152405,
-0.2756320834159851,
-0.07778678834438324,
0.21434321999549866,
-0.27342137694358826,
-0.2746823728084564,
0.4604727625846863,
-0.3016144037246704,
-0.5962497591972351,
0.27378249168395996,
-0.2498951554298401,
-0.16904820501804352,
-0.3411237299442291,
-0.4356730282306671,
-0.5281960368156433,
0.07832885533571243,
0.5036281943321228,
0.4629625082015991,
-0.6419988870620728,
-0.05472433194518089,
0.06773245334625244,
-0.04686534032225609,
-0.2715250551700592,
0.553446352481842,
-0.7772241234779358,
0.576591432094574,
0.34321361780166626,
0.7254914045333862,
0.24632397294044495,
-0.25454476475715637,
0.5009683966636658,
-0.8348603844642639,
-0.03159145265817642,
0.014144000597298145,
0.37201258540153503,
0.6361642479896545,
-0.1901923567056656,
0.4272901117801666,
0.19436776638031006,
-0.4289671778678894,
-0.7541899681091309,
0.3333471715450287,
-0.8770716786384583,
-0.3365470767021179,
1.2089991569519043,
-0.051466770470142365,
-0.08938835561275482,
-0.382602721452713,
-0.24717092514038086,
0.3943975865840912,
-0.26752549409866333,
0.6297518014907837,
0.4202985167503357,
0.14790980517864227,
-0.29139164090156555,
-0.30443722009658813,
0.3449977934360504,
0.34643256664276123,
-1.0824174880981445,
0.01705804094672203,
0.5484506487846375,
0.29471197724342346,
0.2601686716079712,
0.4545504152774811,
-0.1264381855726242,
0.5188296437263489,
-0.027594199404120445,
0.2426924705505371,
-0.37998539209365845,
-0.2539391815662384,
0.03656115010380745,
0.3352930247783661,
-0.16852331161499023,
-0.17160704731941223
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.04214v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.04214v1
|
ValueBench: Towards Comprehensively Evaluating Value Orientations and Understanding of Large Language Models
| 2024-06-06T16:14:16 | 2024-06-06T16:14:16 |
Yuanyi Ren, Haoran Ye, Hanjun Fang, Xin Zhang, Guojie Song
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) are transforming diverse fields and gaining
increasing influence as human proxies. This development underscores the urgent
need for evaluating value orientations and understanding of LLMs to ensure
their responsible integration into public-facing applications. This work
introduces ValueBench, the first comprehensive psychometric benchmark for
evaluating value orientations and value understanding in LLMs. ValueBench
collects data from 44 established psychometric inventories, encompassing 453
multifaceted value dimensions. We propose an evaluation pipeline grounded in
realistic human-AI interactions to probe value orientations, along with novel
tasks for evaluating value understanding in an open-ended value space. With
extensive experiments conducted on six representative LLMs, we unveil their
shared and distinctive value orientations and exhibit their ability to
approximate expert conclusions in value-related extraction and generation
tasks. ValueBench is openly accessible at
https://github.com/Value4AI/ValueBench.
|
[
-0.4360988736152649,
-0.47830715775489807,
0.6507999897003174,
0.2271641194820404,
-0.12777435779571533,
0.17555870115756989,
-0.3883758783340454,
-0.4744407832622528,
0.2680233120918274,
0.35067394375801086,
-0.5568587183952332,
-0.5017334818840027,
-0.6323833465576172,
-0.2760634422302246,
-0.30016425251960754,
0.7247251272201538,
0.17870841920375824,
0.21966002881526947,
-0.18698954582214355,
-0.3866272568702698,
-0.16675402224063873,
-0.7027561664581299,
-0.460309237241745,
-0.4978120028972626,
0.5903432965278625,
0.20320436358451843,
0.5763505101203918,
0.39802584052085876,
0.36449506878852844,
0.24691207706928253,
-0.18982218205928802,
-0.3794651925563812,
-0.7224307656288147,
-0.008850790560245514,
-0.332993745803833,
-0.3602898418903351,
-0.8073863387107849,
0.26550325751304626,
0.5041942000389099,
0.953617513179779,
-0.23668399453163147,
0.5407467484474182,
-0.20327948033809662,
0.7051252722740173,
-0.8517597317695618,
0.42378005385398865,
-0.3868844211101532,
-0.03336679935455322,
-0.3478628695011139,
0.1370079070329666,
-0.3347349762916565,
-0.4824907183647156,
0.010853234678506851,
-0.09096221625804901,
-0.33680960536003113,
-0.18591248989105225,
0.7745031118392944,
0.08357628434896469,
-0.5028605461120605,
0.07095640897750854,
-0.30561554431915283,
0.9134842157363892,
-0.5951775908470154,
0.6532244086265564,
0.26536718010902405,
0.5829628109931946,
-0.2214839607477188,
-0.6297548413276672,
-0.6250279545783997,
0.03959225118160248,
0.2857191562652588,
0.014753676950931549,
-0.0821436420083046,
0.08221807330846786,
0.05634094402194023,
0.38905227184295654,
-0.31587475538253784,
0.2765330970287323,
-0.21042431890964508,
0.041567202657461166,
0.7981377840042114,
0.355122834444046,
0.16095881164073944,
-0.1142917275428772,
-0.11279457807540894,
-0.47228366136550903,
-0.57883620262146,
0.4838465452194214,
0.4606243371963501,
0.3137374520301819,
-0.15140755474567413,
0.589907169342041,
-0.02482515014708042,
0.6456846594810486,
-0.10466437041759491,
-0.30653053522109985,
0.5924519300460815,
-0.42432501912117004,
-0.1961759477853775,
0.008521157316863537,
0.5999956130981445,
0.5677638053894043,
0.4273618459701538,
-0.26345017552375793,
-0.07190108299255371,
-0.2746133506298065,
0.3598644733428955,
-0.9552293419837952,
0.008403303101658821,
0.2893226146697998,
-0.5248477458953857,
-0.4795413613319397,
-0.005739163141697645,
-0.9030609130859375,
-0.6712215542793274,
-0.4815494418144226,
-0.10105428844690323,
-0.1704825460910797,
-0.49449291825294495,
0.008603793568909168,
-0.22602032124996185,
0.6653562188148499,
0.36390870809555054,
-1.048786997795105,
0.2217692881822586,
0.9116928577423096,
0.691321849822998,
-0.3792639672756195,
-0.35225710272789,
-0.52540123462677,
-0.1327083557844162,
-0.32604026794433594,
0.7388055324554443,
-0.4603540003299713,
-0.35540473461151123,
-0.30467525124549866,
-0.17007257044315338,
0.438836932182312,
-0.5241647362709045,
0.45213782787323,
-0.646770179271698,
0.05736320838332176,
-0.31508204340934753,
-0.2194911390542984,
-0.1402938961982727,
0.595780074596405,
-0.7491968870162964,
1.0990698337554932,
0.5815417766571045,
-0.5892466902732849,
0.7165902256965637,
-0.7265650629997253,
-0.08549481630325317,
0.13321280479431152,
-0.38367798924446106,
-0.0070508127100765705,
0.21366144716739655,
-0.1464005410671234,
0.2339099943637848,
-0.7032998204231262,
0.4597751498222351,
-0.6246200203895569,
-0.07494788616895676,
0.5281882882118225,
-0.5742268562316895,
0.8412166833877563,
-0.05976157635450363,
-0.20540767908096313,
0.525783360004425,
-0.971519947052002,
0.45371392369270325,
0.04140432924032211,
-0.33189505338668823,
-0.2845718562602997,
0.0005130390636622906,
0.35246866941452026,
0.39312297105789185,
0.3530424237251282,
-0.5408972501754761,
0.0825226902961731,
-0.45102599263191223,
0.2400413155555725,
0.9951273202896118,
-0.5217005014419556,
0.1607998013496399,
0.2041298747062683,
0.5481350421905518,
-0.18940706551074982,
-0.12035948038101196,
0.11614812165498734,
-0.04461817815899849,
-0.4052112102508545,
-0.6323453187942505,
-0.010687600821256638,
0.18977420032024384,
0.051321521401405334,
0.6991477012634277,
-0.5186977386474609,
-0.5830596685409546,
-0.7205800414085388,
0.19270192086696625,
0.09981919825077057,
0.4142538607120514,
0.3587600290775299,
-0.37197524309158325,
-0.24309711158275604,
-1.0344985723495483,
-0.5069670677185059,
-0.21400311589241028,
-0.4215255677700043,
0.2538815438747406,
0.30168431997299194,
-0.26857927441596985,
1.246884822845459,
-0.29194504022598267,
0.06735096126794815,
-0.35689637064933777,
0.393332302570343,
0.34461331367492676,
-0.005251792259514332,
0.5441558957099915,
-0.644970178604126,
-0.23105071485042572,
-0.20210297405719757,
-0.5003750920295715,
-0.29299595952033997,
0.3271504342556,
-0.08864492923021317,
0.19071905314922333,
0.2819761633872986,
-0.262470006942749,
0.3570553660392761,
0.7318578958511353,
-0.6050477623939514,
0.4517880380153656,
0.07026201486587524,
0.10625309497117996,
-0.9350389838218689,
0.5229613780975342,
-0.1356419324874878,
-0.328993558883667,
-0.37993261218070984,
0.07024085521697998,
0.03565629571676254,
0.06779734790325165,
-0.4340682029724121,
0.7612400054931641,
-0.18226397037506104,
-0.5677534341812134,
-0.21152092516422272,
0.30663254857063293,
0.05865752324461937,
0.22032544016838074,
-0.05393381416797638,
0.7510780096054077,
0.11781275272369385,
-0.03690594434738159,
0.7475931644439697,
0.05458230897784233,
-0.5123721361160278,
0.9256443977355957,
-0.5476177334785461,
0.21970134973526,
-0.19563812017440796,
0.1964569240808487,
-0.8689423203468323,
-0.10153676569461823,
0.0663146823644638,
-0.14225347340106964,
-0.0003374060906935483,
-0.12878017127513885,
-0.4616250693798065,
-0.07655328512191772,
-0.4285028576850891,
0.4437386691570282,
0.26071617007255554,
-0.4762837588787079,
0.6113162636756897,
0.7436388731002808,
-0.35008272528648376,
-0.6101549863815308,
-0.6063227653503418,
0.3776979446411133,
-0.22954481840133667,
-0.5183089375495911,
0.11990201473236084,
-0.0012575016589835286,
-0.6349284052848816,
-0.1213800311088562,
-0.07221292704343796,
-0.21186865866184235,
0.27079418301582336,
0.25476759672164917,
0.10648361593484879,
-0.16896602511405945,
0.04494943097233772,
-0.17155934870243073,
-0.38124439120292664,
0.3778636157512665,
-0.017200369387865067,
0.6865532398223877,
-0.6886980533599854,
-0.5432842969894409,
-0.06212359666824341,
0.020700659602880478,
0.9759394526481628,
-0.5120949745178223,
0.9090396165847778,
0.5359940528869629,
-0.14163389801979065,
0.10798836499452591,
-0.5567046999931335,
-0.017376357689499855,
-0.4439961910247803,
0.5832340121269226,
-0.5073784589767456,
-0.7267440557479858,
0.44398632645606995,
-0.2085675448179245,
-0.07081063091754913,
0.2658214569091797,
0.6732809543609619,
0.03715529665350914,
0.8298277258872986,
0.8076423406600952,
-0.27905964851379395,
0.31184324622154236,
0.008423243649303913,
0.48272505402565,
-0.7538241147994995,
-0.35902589559555054,
-0.3891446590423584,
-0.47358351945877075,
-0.3936934769153595,
-0.49048054218292236,
0.5571038126945496,
0.07024398446083069,
-0.31556254625320435,
-0.12104545533657074,
-0.08796483278274536,
0.37709665298461914,
0.22588114440441132,
-0.24214519560337067,
0.2216004878282547,
-0.23938877880573273,
0.10549312084913254,
-0.13793353736400604,
-0.0983988419175148,
-0.7548708319664001,
1.18438720703125,
0.6067606806755066,
0.6420937180519104,
0.1743379682302475,
0.39947304129600525,
-0.1122647076845169,
0.6743927597999573,
-1.1716679334640503,
0.5023136138916016,
0.20258139073848724,
-0.5909501314163208,
-0.6413282752037048,
-0.22540073096752167,
-0.7436705827713013,
0.4563136398792267,
0.13003267347812653,
-1.1121267080307007,
0.017035169526934624,
-0.15146800875663757,
-0.22789441049098969,
0.23839570581912994,
-0.3426392078399658,
1.307816743850708,
-0.7689343690872192,
-0.5349640250205994,
-0.6914527416229248,
-0.6130375862121582,
0.2977496087551117,
-0.19988228380680084,
0.412128210067749,
-0.43363189697265625,
-0.08438844233751297,
0.572645902633667,
-0.03255508467555046,
0.5159892439842224,
-0.21948717534542084,
-0.3635191321372986,
-0.025878801941871643,
0.15025803446769714,
-0.07085351645946503,
-0.16054345667362213,
-0.6047680974006653,
0.3308672308921814,
0.3951859176158905,
-0.40298008918762207,
-0.5858485102653503,
0.5563206076622009,
-0.7492557764053345,
-0.37706154584884644,
-0.45782771706581116,
-0.5889516472816467,
-0.2962057888507843,
0.40693575143814087,
-0.38047683238983154,
0.040987830609083176,
-0.8839176893234253,
0.4168579876422882,
0.2210988998413086,
-0.2857799828052521,
0.2032260149717331,
0.504837155342102,
-0.383708655834198,
-0.1948622763156891,
0.6458407640457153,
-0.21394366025924683,
0.25289568305015564,
0.12991675734519958,
0.3176600933074951,
-0.42100363969802856,
-0.26277172565460205,
-0.46607130765914917,
0.04293660447001457,
-0.8448120951652527,
0.14242659509181976,
-0.3623431921005249,
0.010737954638898373,
-0.27443382143974304,
-0.24956361949443817,
-0.7091102004051208,
-0.17055737972259521,
0.17439810931682587,
-0.3107033371925354,
0.33119404315948486,
0.5586186051368713,
0.11107885837554932,
0.014945990405976772,
-0.808682382106781,
0.2884836494922638,
0.2026107907295227,
0.795624852180481,
-0.025319475680589676,
-0.2465503066778183,
-0.23162302374839783,
0.1222286969423294,
-0.07832446694374084,
-0.8077608942985535,
0.6217020153999329,
-0.23039115965366364,
0.6285710334777832,
0.6535338759422302,
-0.12677012383937836,
0.563024640083313,
-0.20886261761188507,
0.8046669960021973,
-0.029172364622354507,
-1.1969982385635376,
0.30322378873825073,
-0.13722994923591614,
0.132565438747406,
1.018120527267456,
0.3330835998058319,
-0.747565746307373,
0.1337861865758896,
-0.46765393018722534,
-1.0321749448776245,
0.8537668585777283,
-0.24759820103645325,
0.08753158897161484,
0.3378082513809204,
0.13078239560127258,
0.0970945954322815,
0.5838693380355835,
-0.6916067004203796,
0.10707836598157883,
-0.30493077635765076,
-0.490820050239563,
-0.2884717583656311,
-0.23797737061977386,
-0.3900936245918274,
-0.264397531747818,
0.12432052195072174,
-0.33720269799232483,
-0.090865857899189,
-0.3645801842212677,
-0.19142934679985046,
-0.1594891995191574,
0.6697399020195007,
0.24523144960403442,
1.1196564435958862,
-0.5094324350357056,
0.3375180661678314,
0.23568695783615112,
-0.1489180326461792,
0.21989206969738007,
-0.0564182884991169,
0.448650062084198,
-0.5284556150436401,
0.16351355612277985,
0.6391382813453674,
0.1592133641242981,
-1.083275556564331,
0.7074254155158997,
0.0005591685185208917,
0.2987431287765503,
-0.46103280782699585,
-0.03918393701314926,
0.3059791028499603,
0.1891738772392273,
-0.007607409730553627,
-0.4784334897994995,
0.06312448531389236,
-0.8702407479286194,
-0.033562153577804565,
0.48935216665267944,
-0.41221919655799866,
-0.444254070520401,
0.27720358967781067,
0.2323499619960785,
-0.2368248850107193,
0.844476044178009,
-0.05621139705181122,
-0.4428824782371521,
0.5325325131416321,
0.21945476531982422,
1.0245832204818726,
-0.10824881494045258,
-0.05160508304834366,
0.049086879938840866,
0.15984883904457092,
0.1816040724515915,
0.38571637868881226,
-0.03213120624423027,
-0.8792508244514465,
-0.2585628628730774,
-0.68522709608078,
-0.713826596736908,
0.20724155008792877,
-0.761317253112793,
0.39157259464263916,
-0.39482933282852173,
-0.03787573426961899,
0.008581545203924179,
-0.1051151379942894,
-0.7392960786819458,
-0.04696500301361084,
0.29959985613822937,
0.829843282699585,
-0.7422452569007874,
0.8437711000442505,
0.6938782930374146,
-0.3884350061416626,
-0.5565279126167297,
0.055272992700338364,
0.2908761203289032,
-0.9531418681144714,
1.1399145126342773,
0.29471081495285034,
-0.5437756180763245,
-0.13820934295654297,
-0.3577975630760193,
-0.7532196044921875,
1.1271910667419434,
0.4063902795314789,
-0.1939435750246048,
0.004645832814276218,
0.46162402629852295,
0.6823270320892334,
-0.31221359968185425,
0.8095403909683228,
1.062434434890747,
0.910321056842804,
-0.04169265925884247,
-0.9754749536514282,
-0.026039542630314827,
-0.3048202097415924,
-0.14041344821453094,
0.12487068772315979,
-0.713874876499176,
0.6291548013687134,
0.04655713215470314,
0.071270652115345,
-0.38993337750434875,
0.3457830846309662,
0.3441016674041748,
0.15567809343338013,
0.5765305161476135,
0.5719908475875854,
0.644163966178894,
0.10983045399188995,
0.833451509475708,
-0.6284748315811157,
0.05023783817887306,
0.9749849438667297,
-0.5260886549949646,
0.9566097259521484,
0.6309449672698975,
-0.37130609154701233,
0.5017756223678589,
0.3877762258052826,
0.10405487567186356,
0.20043431222438812,
0.48305416107177734,
-0.08272738754749298,
-0.14049814641475677,
-0.1590326726436615,
-0.09090697765350342,
0.8303717970848083,
0.5578761100769043,
-0.09027288854122162,
-0.25736838579177856,
-0.3085262179374695,
0.19256311655044556,
0.020125048235058784,
-0.04324643313884735,
0.6791843175888062,
0.06954993307590485,
-0.6304778456687927,
0.5126610398292542,
0.2743808329105377,
0.39216867089271545,
-0.6809471845626831,
0.17443758249282837,
-0.08027830719947815,
0.49322354793548584,
-0.047680992633104324,
-1.1343300342559814,
0.3463018834590912,
0.17509105801582336,
-0.021002326160669327,
-0.6465595364570618,
0.29341456294059753,
-0.24301603436470032,
-0.2458687573671341,
0.6759946346282959,
0.5678437352180481,
0.20543760061264038,
-0.2266090363264084,
-0.47962436079978943,
0.13843530416488647,
-0.3462470471858978,
-0.5272374749183655,
0.5381184816360474,
0.50441974401474,
-0.010132895782589912,
0.692148745059967,
0.4068014919757843,
0.10392230749130249,
-0.27147307991981506,
0.19108326733112335,
0.8886007070541382,
-0.8606435656547546,
-0.44551271200180054,
-0.9118970036506653,
0.5147261023521423,
-0.061594873666763306,
-0.48662620782852173,
0.5944284200668335,
0.571471095085144,
0.8230423331260681,
0.15491530299186707,
0.7150037288665771,
-0.008466517552733421,
0.3352523446083069,
-0.18709397315979004,
0.7910093665122986,
-0.49125126004219055,
0.023655684664845467,
-0.343442440032959,
-0.8192063570022583,
-0.05105815827846527,
0.7076530456542969,
-0.5556454062461853,
-0.06346578150987625,
0.4475778043270111,
0.6036643385887146,
-0.16048645973205566,
-0.05636243149638176,
0.23042893409729004,
0.07022365927696228,
0.7215955853462219,
0.34646835923194885,
0.7904241681098938,
0.10495849698781967,
0.16180533170700073,
-0.11998071521520615,
-0.5288684368133545,
-0.34033098816871643,
-1.1637675762176514,
-0.8800438046455383,
-0.24949301779270172,
0.10260218381881714,
-0.14636783301830292,
-0.22260476648807526,
1.3166078329086304,
0.7070906758308411,
-0.7341731786727905,
-0.8396285772323608,
0.10565696656703949,
0.04269230365753174,
-0.08975932747125626,
-0.2581441104412079,
0.16098573803901672,
-0.10119029879570007,
-0.6631391644477844,
0.5001837015151978,
0.43218860030174255,
-0.1571570634841919,
-0.7300777435302734,
-0.04677743837237358,
0.14206694066524506,
0.08595316112041473,
0.7323960661888123,
0.23523779213428497,
-0.6521520018577576,
-0.23814646899700165,
-0.07212191820144653,
-0.14525403082370758,
0.2113674432039261,
0.8243457078933716,
-0.7361792325973511,
0.5522016286849976,
0.6515859365463257,
0.8111051321029663,
0.5678518414497375,
-0.11482234299182892,
0.7617238163948059,
-0.28063085675239563,
0.38093459606170654,
0.3101239800453186,
0.17577773332595825,
0.18281371891498566,
-0.11398454755544662,
0.45542478561401367,
-0.006150495260953903,
-0.26812058687210083,
-0.9110538959503174,
0.2910924255847931,
-0.9219743013381958,
-0.11792244762182236,
0.8273063898086548,
-0.2246922105550766,
-0.09186771512031555,
0.15842759609222412,
-0.07089001685380936,
0.10908138006925583,
-0.3847214877605438,
0.7838808298110962,
0.8725150227546692,
-0.21385549008846283,
-0.34143590927124023,
-0.5160238742828369,
0.1687416136264801,
0.44915059208869934,
-1.0861494541168213,
0.373136043548584,
0.5840469598770142,
0.2310023456811905,
0.05074545741081238,
0.511104166507721,
-0.3157024085521698,
-0.14567013084888458,
-0.3358171284198761,
0.6064609885215759,
-0.03589016571640968,
-0.16721773147583008,
-0.5281845331192017,
0.24163761734962463,
0.5310034155845642,
0.18917648494243622
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.04202v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.04202v1
|
Legal Documents Drafting with Fine-Tuned Pre-Trained Large Language Model
| 2024-06-06T16:00:20 | 2024-06-06T16:00:20 |
Chun-Hsien Lin, Pu-Jen Cheng
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
With the development of large-scale Language Models (LLM), fine-tuning
pre-trained LLM has become a mainstream paradigm for solving downstream tasks
of natural language processing. However, training a language model in the legal
field requires a large number of legal documents so that the language model can
learn legal terminology and the particularity of the format of legal documents.
The typical NLP approaches usually rely on many manually annotated data sets
for training. However, in the legal field application, it is difficult to
obtain a large number of manually annotated data sets, which restricts the
typical method applied to the task of drafting legal documents. The
experimental results of this paper show that not only can we leverage a large
number of annotation-free legal documents without Chinese word segmentation to
fine-tune a large-scale language model, but more importantly, it can fine-tune
a pre-trained LLM on the local computer to achieve the generating legal
document drafts task, and at the same time achieve the protection of
information privacy and to improve information security issues.
|
[
-0.5755425691604614,
-0.7077799439430237,
0.36423107981681824,
-0.062535859644413,
-0.7265564203262329,
-0.28247106075286865,
-0.3268422782421112,
-0.7000216841697693,
0.15479569137096405,
0.9839014410972595,
-0.4088895618915558,
-0.6224949955940247,
-0.6321762800216675,
0.18725813925266266,
-0.3919592797756195,
1.1098713874816895,
0.14346569776535034,
0.04664769023656845,
0.14860029518604279,
-0.10873804986476898,
-0.19535477459430695,
-0.5257102251052856,
-0.7802157402038574,
-0.283123254776001,
0.2523733973503113,
0.1453389674425125,
0.570735514163971,
0.8259227275848389,
0.5451276898384094,
0.3306584060192108,
-0.1254529356956482,
0.16573934257030487,
-0.31509897112846375,
0.02337772212922573,
0.027077116072177887,
-0.6611639857292175,
-0.5227251052856445,
0.2085070163011551,
0.6518377661705017,
0.37017640471458435,
0.1351926475763321,
0.20314106345176697,
-0.18978293240070343,
0.7998605370521545,
-0.41487833857536316,
0.1518324762582779,
-0.9376144409179688,
0.10042546689510345,
-0.43117228150367737,
-0.4179730713367462,
-0.3025263547897339,
-0.3029368817806244,
-0.06350941956043243,
-0.8368356227874756,
0.36455580592155457,
0.14896118640899658,
0.990277111530304,
0.2029665857553482,
-0.16638171672821045,
-0.2292659729719162,
-0.6593058109283447,
0.21043141186237335,
-0.9403242468833923,
0.3164060413837433,
0.6373523473739624,
0.17819693684577942,
-0.14648042619228363,
-0.6115556955337524,
-0.648213803768158,
-0.4224948585033417,
0.12940558791160583,
-0.05599375441670418,
0.25104355812072754,
0.40836748480796814,
0.746054470539093,
0.07531532645225525,
-0.45820990204811096,
0.551763653755188,
-0.4636206328868866,
-0.16148854792118073,
0.9503869414329529,
0.06203775852918625,
0.2402724176645279,
0.0889071673154831,
0.08916664868593216,
-0.10886479169130325,
-0.7913283705711365,
0.08665147423744202,
0.574654757976532,
0.4151466190814972,
-0.052374038845300674,
0.6141795516014099,
-0.33783185482025146,
0.6642138361930847,
0.04699081555008888,
-0.22348153591156006,
0.2797941565513611,
-0.20076508820056915,
-0.6394973993301392,
0.06627938896417618,
0.9539281129837036,
0.12066438794136047,
0.5069628357887268,
0.02348758466541767,
-0.3477879464626312,
-0.4752857983112335,
0.18554839491844177,
-0.8328329920768738,
0.07315459102392197,
0.36442509293556213,
-0.4406951367855072,
-0.2542817294597626,
0.05496113374829292,
-0.4810601472854614,
-0.5133455395698547,
-0.7284323573112488,
0.037514861673116684,
-0.4414407014846802,
0.004570005461573601,
0.13523510098457336,
-0.05664091557264328,
0.353561133146286,
0.42850974202156067,
-1.083723783493042,
-0.09367776662111282,
0.727624237537384,
0.5558308959007263,
0.33797603845596313,
-0.2222655713558197,
-0.7496400475502014,
0.19492825865745544,
-0.47499170899391174,
0.7368557453155518,
-0.40663594007492065,
-0.3446130156517029,
0.313824862241745,
0.026962047442793846,
0.12296120822429657,
-0.48358285427093506,
0.5376068353652954,
-0.6311238408088684,
-0.1656012088060379,
-0.13656508922576904,
-0.5112398266792297,
0.08541081845760345,
0.4320720136165619,
-0.7012366652488708,
0.5956681966781616,
-0.08896683156490326,
-0.8211692571640015,
0.8620062470436096,
-0.7103973627090454,
-0.5751272439956665,
0.3086501359939575,
-0.30191099643707275,
-0.5884615778923035,
0.09847839921712875,
0.3377121090888977,
0.6465633511543274,
-0.2185932695865631,
0.366984099149704,
-0.27999547123908997,
-0.3375326097011566,
-0.0004841479822061956,
-0.07816001772880554,
0.9016227722167969,
0.35934826731681824,
-0.17046354711055756,
0.15550298988819122,
-0.7401506304740906,
-0.12685780227184296,
0.01727898046374321,
-0.6638361811637878,
-0.350705087184906,
-0.1648833304643631,
0.03849269449710846,
0.28131651878356934,
0.20662511885166168,
-0.5406307578086853,
0.2708326280117035,
-0.547394335269928,
0.24921990931034088,
0.40762385725975037,
-0.09102568030357361,
0.46848633885383606,
-0.28987228870391846,
0.46275827288627625,
-0.09553111344575882,
0.14236901700496674,
-0.08956018090248108,
-0.2153870165348053,
-0.6560693383216858,
-0.2706468105316162,
0.42287877202033997,
0.4174024760723114,
-0.42406165599823,
0.6897946000099182,
-0.2969496548175812,
-0.5027600526809692,
-0.5240715146064758,
0.387616366147995,
0.18324105441570282,
0.16350068151950836,
0.11940748244524002,
-0.06157941371202469,
-0.5647140741348267,
-0.8162506818771362,
-0.25509947538375854,
0.017515381798148155,
0.02382817678153515,
0.16206127405166626,
0.5370092988014221,
-0.09472490102052689,
0.583832859992981,
-0.15381257236003876,
-0.6956026554107666,
-0.3904183506965637,
0.5213421583175659,
-0.015772167593240738,
0.44706764817237854,
0.34580668807029724,
-0.8244773745536804,
-0.41965121030807495,
0.12605606019496918,
-0.6231783628463745,
-0.20316480100154877,
-0.49552205204963684,
0.026173565536737442,
0.21157769858837128,
0.9589085578918457,
-0.5805453658103943,
0.36066076159477234,
0.00003366480450495146,
-0.32179421186447144,
0.46551626920700073,
-0.749312698841095,
-0.11604693531990051,
-1.0438964366912842,
0.11474928259849548,
-0.035245247185230255,
-0.2605624496936798,
-0.5481660962104797,
0.3712897002696991,
0.22542217373847961,
-0.30111464858055115,
-0.5126460790634155,
0.49005234241485596,
-0.8197091817855835,
-0.03471294790506363,
-0.48837387561798096,
0.22354035079479218,
-0.21912403404712677,
0.22492599487304688,
0.2860088050365448,
0.5540988445281982,
0.3963474929332733,
-0.5789271593093872,
0.13593173027038574,
0.26374679803848267,
-0.27433860301971436,
0.42516568303108215,
-0.31156161427497864,
0.06119581684470177,
-0.4561847746372223,
0.1340218484401703,
-0.32645392417907715,
-0.2583846151828766,
-0.08668483048677444,
0.06996827572584152,
0.6660581231117249,
-0.07115130126476288,
-0.7407242059707642,
-0.3325827121734619,
-0.38176336884498596,
-0.11533938348293304,
0.29283154010772705,
-0.09139145165681839,
0.5036092400550842,
0.561617910861969,
-0.10840106755495071,
-0.41777047514915466,
-0.7103448510169983,
0.09029624611139297,
-0.2009257972240448,
-0.5240958333015442,
0.07691104710102081,
0.1398395150899887,
-0.16980119049549103,
-0.2282716929912567,
0.24573971331119537,
-0.3064837157726288,
0.1919163018465042,
0.5769540667533875,
0.08923204243183136,
-0.1977725476026535,
0.12458303570747375,
0.12269272655248642,
-0.1633649468421936,
0.0783533900976181,
-0.15346777439117432,
0.4306488335132599,
0.17947418987751007,
-0.3867383301258087,
-0.35620930790901184,
0.3995887041091919,
0.5401365756988525,
-0.629814088344574,
0.5334808826446533,
0.30262669920921326,
-0.32561200857162476,
-0.4156683683395386,
-0.6752539277076721,
0.18368542194366455,
-0.4231066107749939,
0.3896072506904602,
-0.29976215958595276,
-1.099469780921936,
0.3851028084754944,
-0.18963168561458588,
0.5160039663314819,
0.4893975853919983,
0.502102792263031,
0.10246570408344269,
0.4571438431739807,
0.8082887530326843,
-0.28801438212394714,
0.6774870157241821,
-0.05110660195350647,
0.14352725446224213,
-0.5055403709411621,
-0.03662087023258209,
-0.8270925283432007,
-0.1704024374485016,
-0.4499381482601166,
-0.11803101003170013,
0.13440582156181335,
0.07113441079854965,
-0.10353948920965195,
0.3663199841976166,
-0.37299802899360657,
0.6597037315368652,
0.8018190860748291,
0.012379545718431473,
0.3331088423728943,
0.021371446549892426,
-0.27226343750953674,
0.19138473272323608,
-0.2582987844944,
-0.6339183449745178,
1.1658730506896973,
0.22065651416778564,
0.515317976474762,
-0.529954195022583,
0.9193134903907776,
-0.12526987493038177,
0.15146617591381073,
-0.642242431640625,
0.6580480933189392,
-0.4203389585018158,
-0.6758233904838562,
-0.7203195691108704,
-0.1252811849117279,
-0.9949135780334473,
0.07832898944616318,
-0.66489177942276,
-0.6679770350456238,
-0.09209997951984406,
0.06589291244745255,
-0.49425145983695984,
0.24236677587032318,
-0.47456246614456177,
0.6728280782699585,
-0.24887779355049133,
-0.11595240235328674,
-0.16657638549804688,
-0.4889284670352936,
0.234259232878685,
-0.6375216245651245,
0.23623718321323395,
-0.27834072709083557,
0.3287898004055023,
0.790664792060852,
-0.6521459817886353,
0.6912183165550232,
-0.20137068629264832,
-0.1050356924533844,
0.34988266229629517,
-0.01761389523744583,
0.63722825050354,
0.039130352437496185,
-0.19811777770519257,
-0.06179841235280037,
0.04553449898958206,
0.10995647311210632,
-0.40824392437934875,
0.31991931796073914,
-0.6123300194740295,
-0.71755450963974,
-0.16200567781925201,
-0.7849256992340088,
-0.17583921551704407,
0.6316184401512146,
0.5453299283981323,
0.14777179062366486,
-0.11926546692848206,
0.22948817908763885,
0.5015546083450317,
-0.19550366699695587,
0.5155426859855652,
0.6286951899528503,
0.0020190642680972815,
-0.034955982118844986,
0.41387036442756653,
0.524896502494812,
-0.20089127123355865,
0.3837483525276184,
0.08449071645736694,
-0.3254293203353882,
-1.107810616493225,
-0.11152905970811844,
0.2427719086408615,
-0.5904070138931274,
-0.03674563765525818,
-0.5016288161277771,
-0.4228086769580841,
-0.37609273195266724,
-0.2081098109483719,
-0.15613588690757751,
-0.13661758601665497,
-0.3018482029438019,
-0.10502614080905914,
0.25897902250289917,
0.6095900535583496,
0.14326809346675873,
0.24750648438930511,
-0.9396231174468994,
0.5999147295951843,
0.08631334453821182,
0.4282115697860718,
-0.2654721736907959,
-0.5150051116943359,
-0.23614151775836945,
-0.028271576389670372,
-0.08354847878217697,
-0.4267714023590088,
0.31520840525627136,
0.09990152716636658,
0.49916884303092957,
0.5692012906074524,
0.0962112620472908,
0.6502521634101868,
-0.6520929932594299,
0.47880107164382935,
-0.00882320199161768,
-0.6677370667457581,
0.6200207471847534,
-0.6243023872375488,
0.26146426796913147,
0.8828176259994507,
0.2498844414949417,
-0.15466517210006714,
-0.7165641784667969,
-0.47436976432800293,
-0.8079176545143127,
0.6885737776756287,
-0.04360441863536835,
0.2350303828716278,
0.18362219631671906,
0.4735647737979889,
0.06665641069412231,
0.10942487418651581,
-0.7206884622573853,
0.33543822169303894,
0.10511530935764313,
-0.05773886293172836,
-0.0081539461389184,
-0.2025482952594757,
-0.18687337636947632,
-0.20898355543613434,
0.6155653595924377,
0.00454236613586545,
-0.20364294946193695,
0.14338301122188568,
-0.02845202386379242,
-0.036097873002290726,
0.34666675329208374,
0.6219610571861267,
0.4401854872703552,
-0.17486296594142914,
0.02979811280965805,
0.14859381318092346,
-0.7240696549415588,
0.15320050716400146,
0.2685201168060303,
-0.5659962892532349,
-0.01472990307956934,
0.38835278153419495,
0.8010060787200928,
-0.20784087479114532,
-0.6370610594749451,
0.44299575686454773,
0.03445980325341225,
-0.8734756112098694,
-0.3574017584323883,
0.2369445264339447,
0.24779000878334045,
0.2182016670703888,
0.1774880290031433,
-0.24955350160598755,
-0.16191036999225616,
-0.23237790167331696,
0.11217767000198364,
0.6501004695892334,
-0.05914345011115074,
0.08665318787097931,
0.7221546173095703,
0.17410871386528015,
-0.2850000858306885,
0.5361799001693726,
-0.14509734511375427,
-0.02006874606013298,
0.5378237962722778,
0.4955730438232422,
0.8338839411735535,
0.16498036682605743,
-0.004871922545135021,
0.3159518837928772,
0.505000114440918,
-0.557529866695404,
0.24926231801509857,
-0.055716563016176224,
-0.5067846775054932,
-0.37867364287376404,
-0.6378703117370605,
-0.12613750994205475,
0.7007662653923035,
-0.3043495714664459,
0.3526996672153473,
-0.9016050100326538,
-0.1494172215461731,
0.03147516027092934,
0.14802056550979614,
-0.7632268667221069,
0.41189926862716675,
0.20951518416404724,
1.0551939010620117,
-0.7343207001686096,
1.0803829431533813,
0.4964216351509094,
-0.4898984134197235,
-1.0437302589416504,
-0.05667402967810631,
-0.28036758303642273,
-0.5594820380210876,
0.8041685819625854,
0.24267320334911346,
0.14208708703517914,
-0.2004927396774292,
-0.5580297708511353,
-0.5505408048629761,
0.8971475958824158,
0.5925043821334839,
-0.9501913785934448,
-0.21859456598758698,
0.5259200930595398,
0.6266943216323853,
-0.22383123636245728,
-0.14730283617973328,
0.44760334491729736,
0.4158068895339966,
-0.06716932356357574,
-0.8984211683273315,
0.19790183007717133,
-0.3043022155761719,
-0.015359306707978249,
0.15464892983436584,
-0.34770485758781433,
0.6859277486801147,
-0.041515007615089417,
-0.16113613545894623,
-0.2700187861919403,
0.45636773109436035,
0.15208660066127777,
0.12557776272296906,
0.4239068627357483,
0.5754991769790649,
0.973788857460022,
0.08502192050218582,
0.9438547492027283,
-0.4146609902381897,
-0.10611475259065628,
1.1650604009628296,
-0.5131958723068237,
0.880825400352478,
0.34832513332366943,
0.0717969760298729,
-0.16543971002101898,
0.42681199312210083,
-0.3033806383609772,
0.12385977804660797,
0.4081053137779236,
-0.11156978458166122,
-0.3792455494403839,
0.047593120485544205,
-0.17741523683071136,
0.4801327884197235,
0.13506238162517548,
-0.5644395351409912,
-0.34808677434921265,
-0.11311531066894531,
-0.03470071032643318,
0.15630701184272766,
-0.4917922914028168,
0.9527141451835632,
0.19037196040153503,
-0.578367292881012,
0.36648693680763245,
0.22501149773597717,
0.6207754015922546,
-0.715233325958252,
0.13827332854270935,
-0.07430608570575714,
-0.17570623755455017,
-0.2713269293308258,
-0.5869700312614441,
0.2727815806865692,
0.2533729076385498,
0.12961378693580627,
-0.247923344373703,
0.8248119354248047,
-0.2009211927652359,
-0.5388557314872742,
0.17466163635253906,
0.2836204171180725,
0.2806309461593628,
-0.2630738317966461,
-0.5302610397338867,
-0.24315182864665985,
-0.18630316853523254,
-0.47493845224380493,
0.4958171546459198,
0.8172881007194519,
-0.2828664183616638,
0.4707295298576355,
0.9500318765640259,
0.6357007026672363,
0.14029034972190857,
0.21501411497592926,
0.8326677083969116,
-0.6423742175102234,
-0.7895811200141907,
-0.9132646322250366,
0.3808712065219879,
-0.13294057548046112,
-0.43643876910209656,
0.3982313275337219,
0.6160522103309631,
0.8429741263389587,
-0.16452334821224213,
1.0235811471939087,
0.20144928991794586,
0.3458828628063202,
-0.8043457269668579,
1.0480170249938965,
-0.24204669892787933,
-0.08509004861116409,
-0.1682656854391098,
-0.8462451696395874,
-0.664912760257721,
0.557489812374115,
-0.32070013880729675,
-0.1594228595495224,
0.5014893412590027,
0.7276502847671509,
-0.0572541169822216,
-0.1466541588306427,
0.49446573853492737,
-0.07771626114845276,
0.25042209029197693,
0.36498454213142395,
0.35298797488212585,
-0.06023557484149933,
0.5489882230758667,
-0.0792669728398323,
0.09987176954746246,
-0.20077386498451233,
-1.0185902118682861,
-1.3242377042770386,
-0.466625452041626,
-0.03483095392584801,
0.005020034499466419,
-0.1876080334186554,
0.9907786250114441,
0.6889470815658569,
-0.6437090635299683,
-0.10899236053228378,
-0.2264907956123352,
-0.2929707467556,
0.1981026530265808,
-0.059770114719867706,
0.37343528866767883,
-0.5261338949203491,
-0.5921066403388977,
0.21518391370773315,
0.2342432737350464,
0.40974587202072144,
0.044215910136699677,
0.046922601759433746,
-0.21929165720939636,
-0.033528223633766174,
0.33366769552230835,
0.47636690735816956,
-0.47112372517585754,
0.004034976940602064,
-0.4340672791004181,
-0.3244320750236511,
0.11989367753267288,
0.9364863038063049,
-0.2880007028579712,
0.45919787883758545,
0.5715495944023132,
0.8336596488952637,
0.5999966263771057,
0.07956238090991974,
0.638084352016449,
-0.6426122784614563,
0.5837527513504028,
-0.012687645852565765,
0.5440002083778381,
0.07037808746099472,
-0.48139286041259766,
0.29980558156967163,
-0.17668819427490234,
-0.3497355878353119,
-0.5400846004486084,
0.06402900815010071,
-0.8518815636634827,
-0.33722826838493347,
1.0519697666168213,
-0.13805215060710907,
-0.20663830637931824,
-0.3335742950439453,
-0.4321843385696411,
0.5291677713394165,
-0.24681895971298218,
0.7292896509170532,
0.7175740599632263,
0.2319411188364029,
-0.0739334374666214,
-0.780951738357544,
0.7762696743011475,
0.06124483421444893,
-1.0630611181259155,
0.35261255502700806,
0.413815438747406,
0.14729569852352142,
0.1208018958568573,
1.1204724311828613,
-0.17166081070899963,
0.1776229590177536,
0.08820395916700363,
0.05300552770495415,
-0.7111600041389465,
-0.1977687031030655,
-0.350758820772171,
0.3553619682788849,
0.42711758613586426,
0.06274023652076721
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.04197v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.04197v1
|
DICE: Detecting In-distribution Contamination in LLM's Fine-tuning Phase for Math Reasoning
| 2024-06-06T15:55:53 | 2024-06-06T15:55:53 |
Shangqing Tu, Kejian Zhu, Yushi Bai, Zijun Yao, Lei Hou, Juanzi Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The advancement of large language models (LLMs) relies on evaluation using
public benchmarks, but data contamination can lead to overestimated
performance. Previous researches focus on detecting contamination by
determining whether the model has seen the exact same data during training. In
this work, we argue that even training on data similar to benchmark data
inflates performance on in-distribution tasks without improving overall
capacity, which we called In-distribution contamination. To effectively detect
in-distribution contamination, we propose DICE, a novel method that leverages
the internal states of LLMs to locate-then-detect the contamination. DICE first
identifies the most sensitive layer to contamination, then trains a classifier
based on the internal states of that layer. Experiments reveal DICE's high
accuracy in detecting in-distribution contamination across various LLMs and
math reasoning datasets. We also show the generalization capability of the
trained DICE detector, which is able to detect contamination across multiple
benchmarks with similar distributions. Additionally, we find that the DICE
detection scores are positively correlated with the performance of ten LLMs
fine-tuned by either us or other organizations on four math reasoning datasets
(with $R^2$ values between 0.6 and 0.75). This indicates that the
in-distribution contamination problem potentially lead to an overestimation of
the true capabilities of many existing models. The code and data are available
at https://github.com/THU-KEG/DICE.
|
[
-0.5468488335609436,
-0.5364324450492859,
0.7782403826713562,
-0.16405154764652252,
-0.3682388961315155,
-0.024035338312387466,
0.08392135798931122,
-0.3094274401664734,
-0.34664446115493774,
0.9725340604782104,
-0.518203616142273,
-0.5691503286361694,
-0.7251952886581421,
-0.14533723890781403,
-0.5576522946357727,
0.9202048182487488,
0.05899893864989281,
0.05354227125644684,
-0.6288113594055176,
-0.1631285697221756,
-0.10514120012521744,
-0.4500857889652252,
-0.3890233635902405,
-0.5804930329322815,
-0.018265383318066597,
0.5783861875534058,
0.7837503552436829,
0.7242937684059143,
0.7903351783752441,
0.31993693113327026,
-0.3103669583797455,
0.5509350895881653,
-0.5892783403396606,
-0.16225400567054749,
-0.26057732105255127,
-0.7208257913589478,
0.005400440655648708,
-0.2607898414134979,
0.7014840841293335,
0.32750657200813293,
-0.17502133548259735,
0.04430514946579933,
0.009950620122253895,
0.6129838228225708,
-0.9492464065551758,
-0.10452496260404587,
-0.9313643574714661,
-0.00558647932484746,
-0.4703286290168762,
-0.20169782638549805,
-0.4786622226238251,
-0.4360337257385254,
-0.35809090733528137,
-0.4693238437175751,
0.24155770242214203,
-0.23730887472629547,
0.7321838736534119,
0.6430220603942871,
-0.34874609112739563,
-0.282648503780365,
-0.7247974276542664,
0.8576556444168091,
-0.6171488761901855,
0.2681072950363159,
0.6124293804168701,
0.41703030467033386,
-0.43267813324928284,
-0.21693634986877441,
-0.6120795011520386,
0.024991940706968307,
0.36759239435195923,
0.031053239479660988,
0.009782140143215656,
-0.12274134159088135,
0.38027501106262207,
0.11987625807523727,
-0.15315788984298706,
0.21566513180732727,
-0.15751203894615173,
-0.21464835107326508,
0.6411129832267761,
0.3251808285713196,
0.44738897681236267,
-0.013764907605946064,
-0.4818006753921509,
-0.18843327462673187,
-0.8593860268592834,
0.015619956888258457,
0.5726602673530579,
-0.1642674058675766,
-0.15748199820518494,
0.7326251864433289,
0.07952260226011276,
0.4840468168258667,
-0.24664993584156036,
-0.1372247338294983,
0.22200168669223785,
-0.3930899500846863,
-0.3395994305610657,
-0.032595790922641754,
0.5666055083274841,
0.16337676346302032,
0.6518915891647339,
0.10869099199771881,
-0.47530099749565125,
0.2038860321044922,
0.18958836793899536,
-0.7713779807090759,
-0.38137975335121155,
0.025000866502523422,
-0.10176244378089905,
-0.5081750750541687,
0.030115101486444473,
-0.47675973176956177,
-0.8375388383865356,
-0.18968309462070465,
0.5277830958366394,
-0.45556679368019104,
-0.2253367304801941,
0.37378087639808655,
-0.23177234828472137,
-0.33730027079582214,
0.25465768575668335,
-0.7644811868667603,
0.2206428200006485,
1.1824909448623657,
0.6287846565246582,
-0.1296520233154297,
-0.08904046565294266,
-0.916842520236969,
0.08719447255134583,
-0.47335386276245117,
1.1261175870895386,
-0.5704250335693359,
-0.3043319880962372,
0.16299940645694733,
-0.6131622791290283,
0.24346567690372467,
-1.3410108089447021,
0.6849325895309448,
-0.23754511773586273,
-0.4495883882045746,
-0.09882321208715439,
-0.9884731769561768,
0.27766409516334534,
0.28092309832572937,
-0.5831220746040344,
1.0836290121078491,
0.1841023713350296,
-0.6553390622138977,
0.7817040681838989,
-0.30481013655662537,
-0.2149559110403061,
0.17919792234897614,
-0.4180217385292053,
-0.7083086371421814,
0.22446821630001068,
0.2726224958896637,
0.356823205947876,
-0.18492957949638367,
0.11131029576063156,
-0.8953385949134827,
-0.7185072898864746,
0.5850884318351746,
-0.5355085134506226,
0.9080814123153687,
0.24349944293498993,
-0.025712408125400543,
-0.07132560759782791,
-0.9039821028709412,
0.16222704946994781,
-0.28257742524147034,
-0.10355450958013535,
-0.38529688119888306,
0.05016757547855377,
-0.35518792271614075,
0.14787408709526062,
-0.09210702776908875,
-0.4786154627799988,
-0.005353130865842104,
-0.16001605987548828,
0.2660023868083954,
0.8835678100585938,
0.1399541199207306,
0.6567517518997192,
-0.5438323616981506,
0.16891781985759735,
0.6950855851173401,
0.3881475031375885,
-0.023318683728575706,
-0.4927905201911926,
-0.6125383973121643,
-0.5933408141136169,
0.07018885016441345,
0.47552841901779175,
-0.7617284059524536,
0.5846272110939026,
-0.1745874136686325,
-0.5252547264099121,
-0.4497281312942505,
0.34909722208976746,
0.16003893315792084,
0.41410595178604126,
0.30453309416770935,
0.006808532867580652,
0.00884143728762865,
-0.7921715974807739,
-0.41750186681747437,
0.15682253241539001,
-0.21656033396720886,
0.2672528624534607,
0.6095179319381714,
-0.5120145082473755,
1.0271594524383545,
-0.6841117739677429,
-0.518172025680542,
0.15935435891151428,
0.05064375326037407,
0.2698187530040741,
0.3419220447540283,
0.28618699312210083,
-0.63013756275177,
-0.32221171259880066,
-0.14062799513339996,
-0.7158374786376953,
-0.2880157232284546,
-0.01767875626683235,
-0.25548315048217773,
-0.1662929505109787,
0.6255246996879578,
-0.3099029064178467,
0.35295405983924866,
0.3905995786190033,
-0.32893961668014526,
0.34525808691978455,
-0.4265834093093872,
-0.14958898723125458,
-0.7555118203163147,
-0.5136359930038452,
0.34181374311447144,
-0.08540499955415726,
-0.38329315185546875,
-0.028263181447982788,
0.467248797416687,
0.21001102030277252,
-0.4088585376739502,
0.3804358243942261,
0.01615925319492817,
-0.042873818427324295,
-0.09355659782886505,
0.18230898678302765,
0.08954118192195892,
-0.025024140253663063,
-0.35147154331207275,
0.938208281993866,
0.24810151755809784,
-0.6230639219284058,
0.10799403488636017,
0.07907284796237946,
-0.8990417718887329,
0.7709996700286865,
-0.2777051627635956,
-0.09739375114440918,
-0.04593773931264877,
0.24503470957279205,
-0.9962081909179688,
0.06397325545549393,
0.1958269476890564,
-0.1573799103498459,
-0.08092688024044037,
-0.4239393174648285,
-0.9709393978118896,
0.11095693707466125,
-0.08961404860019684,
0.37976527214050293,
0.467195987701416,
-0.8273711204528809,
0.4055311381816864,
0.4518129825592041,
0.5984616279602051,
-0.3462967276573181,
-0.7782781720161438,
-0.46213865280151367,
-0.42024925351142883,
-0.7878562211990356,
0.05230728164315224,
-0.3738061189651489,
-0.5731163620948792,
0.007475689519196749,
-0.3548964858055115,
-0.5153927206993103,
0.335263192653656,
0.2148071676492691,
0.006294987164437771,
0.09550383687019348,
0.3787189722061157,
0.23492588102817535,
-0.21157513558864594,
0.3602103292942047,
-0.010803112760186195,
0.43660643696784973,
0.42368176579475403,
-0.7421577572822571,
-0.2163311243057251,
-0.16561053693294525,
0.5299864411354065,
-0.17401137948036194,
0.4134821891784668,
0.42129334807395935,
-0.5609472990036011,
-0.6825639009475708,
-0.6774102449417114,
-0.07957632839679718,
-0.6037670969963074,
0.2278643250465393,
-0.48260608315467834,
-0.1899726837873459,
0.573867678642273,
-0.21706685423851013,
-0.10825156420469284,
0.3347184956073761,
0.19814229011535645,
-0.2337629348039627,
0.9909292459487915,
0.4357525110244751,
-0.009551048278808594,
0.5238393545150757,
-0.4361115097999573,
0.021384425461292267,
-0.6969462633132935,
-0.06585843116044998,
-0.5082222819328308,
-0.07802769541740417,
-0.2880313992500305,
-0.7620915174484253,
0.47509294748306274,
0.14859755337238312,
-0.44121092557907104,
-0.11554466187953949,
-0.3754834234714508,
0.9241662621498108,
0.2878803610801697,
0.2891293466091156,
0.4193752110004425,
0.015218215063214302,
-0.35579437017440796,
-0.09621070325374603,
-0.2899751663208008,
-0.2296702265739441,
1.0572165250778198,
0.3125457167625427,
0.812209963798523,
-0.09253054857254028,
1.1975058317184448,
0.22215798497200012,
0.2839788496494293,
-0.2820376455783844,
0.380543977022171,
-0.543136477470398,
-0.4260213375091553,
-0.24201057851314545,
-0.8358184695243835,
-0.5596516728401184,
0.1302899420261383,
-0.20291943848133087,
-0.48513755202293396,
0.14043335616588593,
-0.17270083725452423,
-0.17135389149188995,
0.5899724960327148,
-0.7133418917655945,
0.5098852515220642,
-0.28243452310562134,
-0.19916702806949615,
-0.2917916178703308,
0.01863235980272293,
0.4468042552471161,
-0.2315046638250351,
0.5296144485473633,
-0.38825833797454834,
0.04576587304472923,
0.24500219523906708,
-0.5070986151695251,
0.5989856719970703,
-0.014619979076087475,
-0.4407772719860077,
0.22353971004486084,
0.26561591029167175,
0.7067357897758484,
0.40498432517051697,
-0.10369202494621277,
0.22937346994876862,
-0.13044314086437225,
-0.3130383789539337,
-0.738368809223175,
0.643814206123352,
-0.8672338128089905,
-0.0936417281627655,
-0.39105018973350525,
-0.7041777968406677,
-0.2861051559448242,
0.155971959233284,
0.633442223072052,
0.4288901388645172,
0.34307020902633667,
0.13861216604709625,
1.2593376636505127,
-0.0042208838276565075,
0.13145557045936584,
0.3574758470058441,
-0.0554061122238636,
-0.3665759563446045,
1.063093900680542,
0.2403116673231125,
0.5429427027702332,
0.3866514265537262,
0.34824177622795105,
-0.285935640335083,
-0.6774277687072754,
-0.45967909693717957,
0.20199960470199585,
-0.7731350064277649,
-0.4755922257900238,
-0.36528125405311584,
-0.3148050606250763,
0.06573590636253357,
-0.16704128682613373,
-0.4160168468952179,
0.139155313372612,
-0.4486702084541321,
0.05919769033789635,
0.36260488629341125,
0.9194101095199585,
-0.0039626904763281345,
0.22481563687324524,
-0.800918698310852,
0.30679115653038025,
0.056611236184835434,
0.763778030872345,
-0.3894321024417877,
-0.5232008099555969,
-0.18982473015785217,
0.429827481508255,
-0.22460485994815826,
-0.625308632850647,
0.10356155782938004,
-0.11399411410093307,
0.4543338119983673,
0.8814803957939148,
0.05326908454298973,
0.8048889636993408,
-0.2207617312669754,
0.35712191462516785,
0.16232623159885406,
-1.1335746049880981,
0.1352972835302353,
-0.3256162703037262,
0.31055116653442383,
0.45437565445899963,
0.11258856952190399,
-0.29773446917533875,
-0.7532300353050232,
-0.6419121026992798,
-0.5080344080924988,
0.47478002309799194,
0.031758442521095276,
0.022351987659931183,
-0.04618704319000244,
0.33913663029670715,
-0.056357160210609436,
0.012631410732865334,
-0.25376614928245544,
-0.05895710363984108,
0.2924394905567169,
-0.36485299468040466,
-0.20049509406089783,
-0.4721032381057739,
-0.25059229135513306,
-0.10693656653165817,
0.34578821063041687,
0.06887204200029373,
-0.03474438562989235,
-0.204927459359169,
-0.20446573197841644,
-0.2963424623012543,
-0.08983784914016724,
0.6029139757156372,
0.785685122013092,
-0.11760953813791275,
0.21527482569217682,
0.3288567066192627,
-0.643771231174469,
0.11097244173288345,
-0.1754060834646225,
-0.31865790486335754,
-0.19590029120445251,
0.2974790632724762,
0.18079981207847595,
0.6779781579971313,
-0.8123109936714172,
0.5498560667037964,
-0.012704949826002121,
-0.1715741753578186,
-0.6212737560272217,
0.4443083703517914,
0.038777612149715424,
0.371081680059433,
0.3372045159339905,
0.2764204740524292,
0.28637373447418213,
-0.5237034559249878,
0.5991966724395752,
0.4972233772277832,
-0.28091591596603394,
0.23114152252674103,
0.31285998225212097,
-0.032764192670583725,
-0.16162917017936707,
0.9330532550811768,
-0.34979841113090515,
-0.5061540603637695,
0.9483303427696228,
0.5286596417427063,
0.511877179145813,
0.11101116240024567,
0.2224312424659729,
0.018770238384604454,
0.2709296941757202,
-0.17529945075511932,
0.2859589755535126,
0.17495080828666687,
-1.1404058933258057,
-0.33931490778923035,
-0.27075284719467163,
-0.417203813791275,
0.16994711756706238,
-0.6286720633506775,
0.5143566727638245,
-0.42155352234840393,
0.04595828056335449,
0.009955832734704018,
0.08934398740530014,
-0.7014739513397217,
0.1985069066286087,
0.24347126483917236,
0.9227598905563354,
-1.0171318054199219,
0.8191660642623901,
0.26287132501602173,
-0.19338393211364746,
-0.4893684685230255,
0.009363756515085697,
-0.04087948799133301,
-0.7759844064712524,
0.5535542368888855,
0.09179741144180298,
-0.09918130934238434,
-0.19518886506557465,
-0.39530327916145325,
-0.8959983587265015,
0.8139399290084839,
0.5287868976593018,
-0.4396468698978424,
0.47164294123649597,
0.3975411653518677,
0.38503298163414,
-0.04606469348073006,
0.6418295502662659,
0.65610671043396,
0.40811076760292053,
-0.043854523450136185,
-0.5314735770225525,
-0.2548519968986511,
-0.08466927707195282,
-0.20601646602153778,
0.8292493224143982,
-0.420132040977478,
0.827129065990448,
-0.19007785618305206,
-0.16126587986946106,
-0.13320404291152954,
0.35133618116378784,
0.5664563179016113,
0.5986446142196655,
0.7492610216140747,
1.0132180452346802,
0.9500112533569336,
-0.2701990604400635,
0.7696595788002014,
0.04548252746462822,
0.3964078426361084,
0.8722524642944336,
-0.4370929002761841,
0.8530756235122681,
0.2649451792240143,
-0.19268138706684113,
0.25192713737487793,
0.33124783635139465,
-0.2067466825246811,
0.5655971765518188,
0.6223984360694885,
-0.3850563168525696,
-0.41864079236984253,
0.03504643961787224,
-0.1564474105834961,
0.3316647410392761,
0.5653530359268188,
0.0015959902666509151,
-0.49968546628952026,
0.13032960891723633,
-0.046631231904029846,
0.2565669119358063,
-0.2823590040206909,
0.7263859510421753,
-0.08154555410146713,
-0.4490166902542114,
0.41329964995384216,
-0.40957319736480713,
0.6596948504447937,
-0.3993209898471832,
-0.25043341517448425,
-0.38144055008888245,
0.7815324068069458,
-0.2759866714477539,
-1.1639881134033203,
0.24670901894569397,
-0.28967443108558655,
0.01723848655819893,
-0.12425920367240906,
0.591769278049469,
-0.3391743004322052,
-0.43791407346725464,
0.43109020590782166,
0.25419649481773376,
0.22914358973503113,
-0.2346545308828354,
-0.41165289282798767,
0.36582186818122864,
-0.11966970562934875,
0.2938796281814575,
0.6007856130599976,
0.9329031705856323,
-0.10710178315639496,
1.034100890159607,
0.8367857336997986,
0.07575784623622894,
0.2663942277431488,
0.18403612077236176,
0.7439661622047424,
-0.27384790778160095,
-0.41615989804267883,
-0.8825079202651978,
0.4397304356098175,
-0.2411055564880371,
-0.6120252013206482,
0.5432345271110535,
0.7102910876274109,
1.092248797416687,
0.09453745931386948,
0.6123756170272827,
0.6681941151618958,
0.303204745054245,
-0.4681893587112427,
0.5499274134635925,
-0.38433295488357544,
0.46016016602516174,
-0.1072702705860138,
-0.7454557418823242,
-0.18322154879570007,
0.5326793789863586,
-0.294412761926651,
-0.14302504062652588,
0.590329110622406,
0.6556679010391235,
-0.37312814593315125,
0.00889307539910078,
0.4643886089324951,
0.09324375540018082,
0.6350577473640442,
0.4309542179107666,
0.8009791970252991,
-0.1291484236717224,
0.7738679647445679,
-0.7192257046699524,
-0.282930850982666,
-0.33988553285598755,
-0.8048768639564514,
-0.8985068202018738,
-0.45206916332244873,
-0.25607913732528687,
-0.4265204071998596,
-0.062113016843795776,
0.49183401465415955,
0.40807050466537476,
-0.6180161833763123,
-0.22450456023216248,
-0.3689429759979248,
0.3615966737270355,
-0.4027772843837738,
-0.22844764590263367,
0.07948331534862518,
-0.5439746975898743,
-0.6516081094741821,
0.24243402481079102,
0.15105482935905457,
-0.08616088330745697,
-0.2440982162952423,
0.23905330896377563,
0.1967972368001938,
0.13249652087688446,
0.386576771736145,
-0.27972421050071716,
-0.3514831066131592,
-0.310514360666275,
-0.1999306082725525,
-0.294780969619751,
-0.0909319818019867,
0.7662937045097351,
-0.4744695723056793,
0.5098667144775391,
0.5709676146507263,
0.5985433459281921,
0.5074476003646851,
-0.09933572262525558,
0.3394339978694916,
-0.5436768531799316,
-0.022634441033005714,
0.3233049809932709,
0.41339316964149475,
0.08960641175508499,
-0.7441295981407166,
0.6048270463943481,
-0.00013061624485999346,
-0.7392787933349609,
-1.119614601135254,
0.36104699969291687,
-0.5713197588920593,
-0.190443754196167,
1.2902644872665405,
0.05948276445269585,
-0.05518925189971924,
-0.19392667710781097,
0.09470532834529877,
0.15769276022911072,
-0.34780406951904297,
0.9530460238456726,
0.8471418023109436,
0.16451618075370789,
0.04883556440472603,
-0.6986486911773682,
0.4823964834213257,
0.35185807943344116,
-0.9744127988815308,
-0.04326153174042702,
0.24842862784862518,
0.6187026500701904,
0.10502026975154877,
0.39924168586730957,
-0.08350218832492828,
0.27855533361434937,
-0.032054368406534195,
-0.2676437795162201,
-0.10373547673225403,
-0.3649718165397644,
-0.31791698932647705,
-0.04360945522785187,
-0.1512632966041565,
-0.21862058341503143
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.04175v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.04175v2
|
Confabulation: The Surprising Value of Large Language Model Hallucinations
| 2024-06-06T15:32:29 | 2024-06-25T18:37:19 |
Peiqi Sui, Eamon Duede, Sophie Wu, Richard Jean So
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
This paper presents a systematic defense of large language model (LLM)
hallucinations or 'confabulations' as a potential resource instead of a
categorically negative pitfall. The standard view is that confabulations are
inherently problematic and AI research should eliminate this flaw. In this
paper, we argue and empirically demonstrate that measurable semantic
characteristics of LLM confabulations mirror a human propensity to utilize
increased narrativity as a cognitive resource for sense-making and
communication. In other words, it has potential value. Specifically, we analyze
popular hallucination benchmarks and reveal that hallucinated outputs display
increased levels of narrativity and semantic coherence relative to veridical
outputs. This finding reveals a tension in our usually dismissive
understandings of confabulation. It suggests, counter-intuitively, that the
tendency for LLMs to confabulate may be intimately associated with a positive
capacity for coherent narrative-text generation.
|
[
-0.5484874844551086,
-0.6848626732826233,
0.9679282307624817,
0.24976539611816406,
-0.266602098941803,
0.008348113857209682,
-0.06551948189735413,
-0.947796642780304,
0.4104422926902771,
0.48055920004844666,
-0.5620569586753845,
0.004299025051295757,
-0.7739685773849487,
0.2748282253742218,
-0.8389565348625183,
0.7914872765541077,
0.27936941385269165,
-0.04833435267210007,
-0.2424772083759308,
-0.14425548911094666,
-0.8242915272712708,
-0.9685248732566833,
-0.6618266105651855,
-0.7790112495422363,
0.4737796187400818,
0.11064411699771881,
1.1573580503463745,
0.10871519893407822,
0.5987187027931213,
0.3339180052280426,
0.1560499221086502,
0.08021087944507599,
-0.5887378454208374,
0.48394903540611267,
-0.05268560349941254,
-0.4051837623119354,
-0.008358148857951164,
0.13688266277313232,
0.42942214012145996,
1.069257378578186,
-0.3155951201915741,
-0.254952996969223,
0.1182151809334755,
0.8087610006332397,
-0.2836975157260895,
-0.10491291433572769,
-0.5654340982437134,
0.11417088657617569,
-0.2741200625896454,
-0.30296239256858826,
-0.5451850295066833,
-0.4671249985694885,
0.25228390097618103,
-0.5229349136352539,
0.2639792263507843,
0.31882357597351074,
0.8593041300773621,
0.6187211275100708,
-0.22657519578933716,
-1.054060697555542,
-0.9070886969566345,
0.698377788066864,
-0.39151039719581604,
0.37680622935295105,
0.3168446719646454,
0.23339632153511047,
-0.3011212646961212,
-0.531130313873291,
-1.0431196689605713,
-0.642652153968811,
-0.2554302215576172,
-0.08910158276557922,
-0.1110377088189125,
0.03266433626413345,
0.38838303089141846,
0.5334489941596985,
-0.48501843214035034,
0.09324458986520767,
-0.10948418825864792,
-0.24075506627559662,
0.46446093916893005,
0.4687434136867523,
0.3800199031829834,
-0.13504400849342346,
-0.23201066255569458,
0.0225048940628767,
-0.5611011385917664,
-0.1507730334997177,
0.3863115608692169,
0.05090109631419182,
-0.028545117005705833,
0.5154930949211121,
0.015833780169487,
0.40815505385398865,
0.03967835754156113,
-0.145578995347023,
0.38424012064933777,
-0.3172067701816559,
-0.09082186967134476,
0.3659338653087616,
0.6011021733283997,
0.24258093535900116,
0.5638838410377502,
-0.4860600233078003,
-0.032018061727285385,
0.5195299386978149,
0.5206047892570496,
-0.7595638632774353,
-0.025628458708524704,
0.36226359009742737,
-0.5150054693222046,
-0.087627112865448,
0.09074492007493973,
-0.5029123425483704,
-0.80332350730896,
-0.2501952052116394,
0.39108696579933167,
-0.5406495928764343,
-0.2707287669181824,
0.5300878286361694,
-0.17641609907150269,
0.0168137326836586,
0.5185844898223877,
-0.8308727145195007,
0.13625991344451904,
0.7474780082702637,
0.907277524471283,
-0.3014272153377533,
-0.4700077772140503,
-0.535126268863678,
-0.2128787338733673,
-0.5074957609176636,
0.7658555507659912,
-0.48781201243400574,
-0.5232899188995361,
0.11837870627641678,
-0.07346788048744202,
0.13158085942268372,
-0.8247026205062866,
0.3710767328739166,
-0.17010731995105743,
-0.059830453246831894,
-0.24637457728385925,
-0.37434327602386475,
-0.11091970652341843,
0.05793364718556404,
-0.7290311455726624,
0.6490030288696289,
0.0009583272621966898,
-0.42536675930023193,
0.3480662405490875,
-0.20116211473941803,
-0.49012869596481323,
0.10471699386835098,
-0.4390144944190979,
-0.2621399760246277,
0.3638647496700287,
-0.6010158658027649,
0.2533842921257019,
-0.49390819668769836,
0.7448350191116333,
-0.1057964488863945,
-0.4435371160507202,
0.6754705309867859,
-0.5538305044174194,
0.35932034254074097,
0.22899727523326874,
-0.5000014305114746,
-0.2004137486219406,
-0.8477597236633301,
-0.4986594021320343,
-0.06783564388751984,
-0.2709558308124542,
-0.4690231382846832,
0.10597345978021622,
-0.2570668160915375,
0.2024996429681778,
0.130898579955101,
-0.20733268558979034,
-0.07637832313776016,
-0.3435786962509155,
-0.15403228998184204,
0.5172731280326843,
0.18081894516944885,
0.27066928148269653,
-0.603073239326477,
0.27608051896095276,
0.10765859484672546,
0.07961089164018631,
-0.0933627337217331,
-0.4751538038253784,
-0.9327942132949829,
0.12753227353096008,
-0.2761988043785095,
0.20947538316249847,
-0.778351366519928,
-0.008554685860872269,
-0.057287562638521194,
-0.37887871265411377,
-0.4369972348213196,
-0.12764526903629303,
0.3746785521507263,
0.5084241628646851,
0.2778777480125427,
-0.35840654373168945,
-0.7594243288040161,
-0.8317714333534241,
-0.046254295855760574,
-0.17231327295303345,
0.06558024883270264,
0.05053889378905296,
0.31960809230804443,
-0.31522348523139954,
0.47191473841667175,
-0.028599342331290245,
-0.22733162343502045,
-0.13992847502231598,
0.37837299704551697,
0.38727378845214844,
0.36527058482170105,
0.3897892236709595,
-0.8959681987762451,
-0.019432520493865013,
-0.19301152229309082,
-1.1441411972045898,
-0.09933650493621826,
-0.7693234086036682,
0.01794695295393467,
0.4130178689956665,
0.6084040999412537,
-0.7740808129310608,
0.3036941587924957,
0.6645050048828125,
-0.6116576194763184,
0.872596025466919,
-0.07016313821077347,
0.29037922620773315,
-0.7569776773452759,
-0.09235665947198868,
-0.3411310613155365,
0.037937235087156296,
-0.4783063232898712,
-0.15796048939228058,
-0.5361350774765015,
0.3691723942756653,
-0.2219039797782898,
0.40254124999046326,
-0.2970799505710602,
-0.10979612171649933,
-0.36611106991767883,
0.6087362766265869,
-0.25486326217651367,
-0.09242025762796402,
-0.006309508811682463,
0.6269587874412537,
0.14156831800937653,
-0.6351979374885559,
0.46722525358200073,
0.43005162477493286,
-0.381944864988327,
0.43435779213905334,
-0.24377113580703735,
0.00661180354654789,
-0.09025520086288452,
0.08663751929998398,
-0.7445246577262878,
-0.3619649410247803,
0.09807337075471878,
-0.4534219801425934,
-0.02247684635221958,
0.45441094040870667,
-0.49883314967155457,
-0.12354528903961182,
-0.2412184476852417,
0.34006640315055847,
0.3921871483325958,
-0.5423896908760071,
0.4154667556285858,
0.25198838114738464,
-0.04668574780225754,
-0.3625134825706482,
-0.9202325344085693,
0.44402509927749634,
-0.10875087976455688,
-0.552028238773346,
0.19784027338027954,
-0.41083085536956787,
-0.7526705861091614,
-0.1509382575750351,
0.038006074726581573,
0.47170814871788025,
0.262522429227829,
0.7074999213218689,
0.2250414788722992,
-0.06218592822551727,
0.27873846888542175,
-0.32171541452407837,
-0.34800419211387634,
0.2391240894794464,
0.10998646914958954,
1.005171537399292,
0.0020109708420932293,
-0.4296337068080902,
-0.3832581341266632,
0.40818122029304504,
0.45991215109825134,
0.35878217220306396,
0.9620673656463623,
0.25892704725265503,
-0.535315752029419,
-0.01789628341794014,
-0.6455219388008118,
-0.27597537636756897,
-0.4557279348373413,
0.29041987657546997,
-0.3268005847930908,
-0.8490887880325317,
0.612709105014801,
0.021825702860951424,
-0.2863408625125885,
0.2492210865020752,
0.6563286781311035,
0.020698320120573044,
0.6208038926124573,
0.44249600172042847,
0.18625536561012268,
0.3413989543914795,
-0.13193562626838684,
0.3861023783683777,
-0.5798186659812927,
-0.4421789348125458,
-0.5057854652404785,
-0.1887993961572647,
-0.8716879487037659,
-0.12912672758102417,
0.14121748507022858,
-0.04209722951054573,
-0.3433191478252411,
-0.1596948504447937,
-0.4258340895175934,
0.15673911571502686,
0.39985018968582153,
-0.10712593793869019,
0.6061142683029175,
-0.2941494584083557,
0.25855571031570435,
-0.3429567217826843,
-0.34719204902648926,
-0.7399891018867493,
0.6512015461921692,
0.09885130077600479,
0.7036417722702026,
0.23873348534107208,
0.7597633600234985,
0.39993366599082947,
0.3327907919883728,
-0.7256521582603455,
0.5570102334022522,
-0.05008377879858017,
-0.3681788146495819,
-0.25194698572158813,
-0.19725202023983002,
-1.0668418407440186,
0.11958571523427963,
-0.5180770754814148,
-0.946033775806427,
0.4562298059463501,
-0.0030423705466091633,
-0.4694646894931793,
0.05169946327805519,
-0.4666760563850403,
0.5999326109886169,
-0.11188708990812302,
-0.2135084718465805,
-0.4038247764110565,
-0.4117383360862732,
0.5303919911384583,
-0.26350411772727966,
0.4229026436805725,
0.02806149609386921,
0.12564034759998322,
0.38558605313301086,
-0.3238983750343323,
0.8488816022872925,
0.1727912276983261,
-0.17519821226596832,
0.30479535460472107,
0.5082874298095703,
0.5167340040206909,
0.10837632417678833,
-0.1869683563709259,
0.08536326140165329,
-0.32412949204444885,
-0.1636793613433838,
-0.4962960183620453,
0.6394385695457458,
-0.691537082195282,
-0.9602656960487366,
-0.7143093943595886,
-0.801842987537384,
0.011176838539540768,
0.015599220059812069,
0.22585806250572205,
0.40585920214653015,
-0.22638997435569763,
0.26592549681663513,
0.5889058113098145,
-0.23877789080142975,
0.6189036965370178,
0.23608945310115814,
-0.5553956031799316,
-0.20801624655723572,
0.8426065444946289,
0.17683014273643494,
0.6741196513175964,
-0.043972309678792953,
-0.14885909855365753,
0.077144555747509,
-0.8606989979743958,
0.04048127308487892,
0.259010374546051,
-0.6782476305961609,
-0.07660800218582153,
-0.6360160708427429,
-0.3350659906864166,
0.08710546791553497,
-0.3820417821407318,
-0.2667657732963562,
-0.24091248214244843,
-0.2383866012096405,
-0.14447712898254395,
0.13416241109371185,
0.7811089754104614,
-0.10251080989837646,
0.14288555085659027,
-0.628097414970398,
0.3558014929294586,
0.0005652254330925643,
-0.018981829285621643,
0.16399066150188446,
-0.4747573733329773,
-0.4166443645954132,
-0.05963984504342079,
-0.36874523758888245,
-0.665675163269043,
0.31821826100349426,
-0.12527452409267426,
0.3816291093826294,
0.48803144693374634,
0.1962144672870636,
0.6728838086128235,
-0.37734362483024597,
0.9510638117790222,
0.3491802215576172,
-0.8304473161697388,
0.11610984802246094,
-0.05905911326408386,
0.13980154693126678,
0.3587981164455414,
0.3887821137905121,
-0.898459792137146,
-0.8880923986434937,
-0.6598977446556091,
-0.7482587695121765,
0.2696482241153717,
0.19474171102046967,
0.399842232465744,
-0.3388381898403168,
0.4213832914829254,
0.4898017644882202,
0.31479984521865845,
-0.8168821930885315,
-0.18717904388904572,
-0.004523871000856161,
0.03154032304883003,
-0.1333310455083847,
-0.46841922402381897,
0.015738649293780327,
0.056807033717632294,
0.40259501338005066,
-0.04208691045641899,
0.09844747185707092,
0.4099056124687195,
-0.1177910566329956,
-0.26303601264953613,
0.011117881163954735,
0.5686960816383362,
0.7602113485336304,
-0.07546289265155792,
0.41178470849990845,
0.14868952333927155,
-0.5947778820991516,
0.11732520908117294,
-0.04834064468741417,
-0.11303476989269257,
0.14224621653556824,
0.7311351895332336,
0.681913435459137,
0.34672486782073975,
-0.7572234272956848,
0.2977712154388428,
0.017212964594364166,
-0.08142195641994476,
-0.6451377868652344,
0.28170251846313477,
0.19034770131111145,
0.6963646411895752,
0.7292833924293518,
0.20115473866462708,
0.23290278017520905,
-1.1128568649291992,
0.2372334897518158,
0.4164431691169739,
-0.025545058771967888,
-0.2042972594499588,
0.5568023324012756,
-0.015723710879683495,
-0.6955515742301941,
0.672655463218689,
-0.45015764236450195,
-0.4750497341156006,
0.4224596321582794,
0.6212539076805115,
0.7974264025688171,
-0.09630777686834335,
0.2676052451133728,
0.2941947281360626,
0.3617151379585266,
-0.124980129301548,
0.20980189740657806,
0.3004671335220337,
-1.0017889738082886,
-0.22982658445835114,
-0.7931207418441772,
-0.5701996088027954,
0.15146270394325256,
-0.49569573998451233,
0.2683197259902954,
-0.2832431197166443,
-0.04971145838499069,
-0.01347395684570074,
-0.15510264039039612,
-0.42898139357566833,
0.13844746351242065,
0.37395820021629333,
0.6633170247077942,
-0.4739162027835846,
0.6757588982582092,
0.034555334597826004,
-0.6797237992286682,
-0.48487192392349243,
0.4019080698490143,
-0.13881812989711761,
-0.4710116684436798,
0.4897683560848236,
0.36626365780830383,
-0.26501262187957764,
-0.15865084528923035,
-0.4053596258163452,
-0.6169366240501404,
1.0329604148864746,
0.45251375436782837,
-0.7703028321266174,
-0.15215294063091278,
0.41419199109077454,
0.7595457434654236,
-0.689516544342041,
-0.11156748235225677,
0.6373340487480164,
0.5446270704269409,
0.03849928081035614,
-0.8532676100730896,
0.5020255446434021,
0.14418205618858337,
-0.09244485944509506,
0.19182749092578888,
-0.7361318469047546,
0.7103551030158997,
-0.5050907731056213,
-0.44050008058547974,
0.2591240704059601,
0.5737878084182739,
0.33168134093284607,
0.5959929823875427,
0.34036633372306824,
0.3883321285247803,
0.7768757939338684,
-0.06514085829257965,
1.2565475702285767,
-0.09489720314741135,
0.17150098085403442,
1.0792949199676514,
-0.14866137504577637,
0.7032408714294434,
0.9027509093284607,
-0.0617796927690506,
0.6953832507133484,
0.5524617433547974,
0.18646888434886932,
0.4363629221916199,
0.07622082531452179,
-0.266818642616272,
-0.45675840973854065,
-0.13331104815006256,
-0.37590935826301575,
0.2121202051639557,
0.3957049548625946,
-0.23244024813175201,
-0.06928148120641708,
0.22470316290855408,
0.1329900175333023,
0.3587161600589752,
0.06866984069347382,
0.5753622055053711,
0.5266652703285217,
-0.6631854772567749,
0.7096829414367676,
-0.704093873500824,
0.5340647101402283,
-0.3606853485107422,
-0.1967618763446808,
-0.20607174932956696,
0.09107503294944763,
-0.24037137627601624,
-0.7606005072593689,
0.7164739370346069,
-0.29142647981643677,
-0.3535532057285309,
-0.08991562575101852,
0.3440554440021515,
-0.23370963335037231,
-0.13216125965118408,
0.7400712966918945,
0.5730950236320496,
0.275181382894516,
-0.12287500500679016,
-0.2705424129962921,
0.547538697719574,
-0.12724265456199646,
-0.20051604509353638,
0.3094140887260437,
0.7934817671775818,
0.09031475335359573,
0.73360276222229,
0.6443617343902588,
0.08192963898181915,
-0.15991993248462677,
0.20792889595031738,
0.7629603147506714,
-0.8886433839797974,
-0.15407557785511017,
-1.109171748161316,
0.4538464844226837,
0.06315436959266663,
-0.3296006917953491,
0.48154914379119873,
0.47802668809890747,
0.8264359831809998,
0.1601569801568985,
0.7234868407249451,
-0.018726348876953125,
0.19588662683963776,
-0.6902007460594177,
0.7231026291847229,
-0.39166173338890076,
0.4361514747142792,
-0.24551139771938324,
-0.6822450160980225,
-0.2909106910228729,
0.5706201791763306,
-0.3451082408428192,
-0.09120770543813705,
1.0615596771240234,
0.6793392300605774,
0.41935786604881287,
0.20038200914859772,
0.7999321818351746,
0.6280437707901001,
0.1846476048231125,
0.5459427833557129,
1.165928602218628,
-0.17755457758903503,
0.4978216290473938,
-0.009148881770670414,
-0.1167149692773819,
-0.39939945936203003,
-0.7179187536239624,
-0.8606218099594116,
-1.000306248664856,
-0.07322463393211365,
-0.7813572883605957,
0.20279929041862488,
0.8667905926704407,
0.0913541242480278,
-0.6411104202270508,
-0.29040953516960144,
-0.14900758862495422,
0.22864963114261627,
0.051561590284109116,
-0.25997090339660645,
0.03268977999687195,
-0.6461062431335449,
-0.6684314608573914,
0.06980564445257187,
0.3553708493709564,
0.27386072278022766,
-0.47716382145881653,
-0.43168386816978455,
-0.10479609668254852,
0.3454674780368805,
0.6524617075920105,
-0.053419772535562515,
-0.7765498757362366,
-0.6094902157783508,
-0.18228626251220703,
-0.2104780673980713,
0.06692349165678024,
0.6951400637626648,
-0.8113556504249573,
0.3712296187877655,
-0.042261186987161636,
0.4715639352798462,
0.2921852171421051,
-0.2804792821407318,
0.5753839015960693,
-0.18241684138774872,
0.3860795795917511,
0.08986180275678635,
0.4653923809528351,
0.4793812930583954,
-0.5390322208404541,
0.5795713663101196,
0.3957039713859558,
-0.6043429374694824,
-1.073264479637146,
0.37630483508110046,
-0.7603603601455688,
-0.1959943026304245,
0.9566807150840759,
0.14541055262088776,
-0.09661257266998291,
-0.17169739305973053,
-0.30977851152420044,
0.2468683123588562,
-0.2581740617752075,
1.412654161453247,
1.1357078552246094,
-0.495328813791275,
-0.052351485937833786,
-0.836143434047699,
0.6892313361167908,
0.3355281352996826,
-0.8106783628463745,
0.10254419595003128,
0.7156913876533508,
-0.28981608152389526,
0.7071498036384583,
0.47468671202659607,
0.07749070972204208,
0.37375062704086304,
0.3560377359390259,
-0.0137191666290164,
0.21601834893226624,
-0.23890016973018646,
-0.09566674381494522,
0.07605559378862381,
0.19099491834640503,
0.040770381689071655
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.06606v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.06606v1
|
Prototypical Reward Network for Data-Efficient RLHF
| 2024-06-06T15:23:30 | 2024-06-06T15:23:30 |
Jinghan Zhang, Xiting Wang, Yiqiao Jin, Changyu Chen, Xinhao Zhang, Kunpeng Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The reward model for Reinforcement Learning from Human Feedback (RLHF) has
proven effective in fine-tuning Large Language Models (LLMs). Notably,
collecting human feedback for RLHF can be resource-intensive and lead to
scalability issues for LLMs and complex tasks. Our proposed framework Proto-RM
leverages prototypical networks to enhance reward models under limited human
feedback. By enabling stable and reliable structural learning from fewer
samples, Proto-RM significantly enhances LLMs' adaptability and accuracy in
interpreting human preferences. Extensive experiments on various datasets
demonstrate that Proto-RM significantly improves the performance of reward
models and LLMs in human feedback tasks, achieving comparable and usually
better results than traditional methods, while requiring significantly less
data. in data-limited scenarios. This research offers a promising direction for
enhancing the efficiency of reward models and optimizing the fine-tuning of
language models under restricted feedback conditions.
|
[
-0.13942061364650726,
-0.5844805240631104,
0.1470465064048767,
0.35812854766845703,
-0.13192018866539001,
0.06689811497926712,
-0.5123276710510254,
-0.19766740500926971,
0.4931338131427765,
0.4436642527580261,
-0.7342690825462341,
-0.315030962228775,
-0.3931499719619751,
0.006617539096623659,
-0.07195822894573212,
0.9347983002662659,
0.12973849475383759,
-0.1721722036600113,
-0.020240554586052895,
-0.0777997151017189,
-0.11027839779853821,
-0.5718681812286377,
-0.8956155180931091,
-0.627548336982727,
0.9841941595077515,
0.9615296125411987,
0.5698880553245544,
0.8781648874282837,
0.3460533618927002,
0.2610519230365753,
0.06245681643486023,
0.4372629225254059,
-0.8806658983230591,
0.1946599781513214,
-0.3181855082511902,
-0.4419480264186859,
-0.5643253326416016,
-0.1862228810787201,
0.6677976846694946,
0.8510295152664185,
-0.4583267569541931,
0.22678352892398834,
0.3173578977584839,
1.0009351968765259,
-0.7477439045906067,
0.5907959342002869,
-0.37343883514404297,
0.05914020165801048,
-0.17760810256004333,
-0.3702278435230255,
-0.5082345604896545,
-0.3785156309604645,
0.011865382082760334,
-0.74696946144104,
0.1714513599872589,
0.08409281820058823,
0.8462543487548828,
-0.0006958776502870023,
0.10854621976613998,
-0.034171074628829956,
-0.8769055008888245,
0.5300087928771973,
-0.41060444712638855,
0.36988869309425354,
0.5219292640686035,
0.39848315715789795,
-0.3082379400730133,
-0.8941482305526733,
-0.2865496873855591,
-0.39760032296180725,
-0.09445029497146606,
0.08468051999807358,
-0.03738035261631012,
0.3292939066886902,
-0.05094204843044281,
0.22410140931606293,
-0.5244814157485962,
0.42383086681365967,
-0.2011391967535019,
-0.14900384843349457,
0.5212607383728027,
0.49667108058929443,
0.0016150212613865733,
-0.16702598333358765,
-0.15275447070598602,
-0.5227962732315063,
-0.9830629825592041,
0.37178581953048706,
0.43458840250968933,
0.8041747212409973,
-0.17615555226802826,
0.542439341545105,
-0.4939974844455719,
0.8955786824226379,
-0.10698741674423218,
-0.13916811347007751,
0.07983170449733734,
-0.3564670979976654,
-0.09702413529157639,
-0.2939929962158203,
0.7039442658424377,
0.24417875707149506,
0.2721661329269409,
-0.43525683879852295,
-0.4751867353916168,
-0.004610817413777113,
0.21927419304847717,
-0.8362179398536682,
-0.47865259647369385,
-0.01364091970026493,
-0.6524785757064819,
-0.43999701738357544,
0.10328667610883713,
-0.5565463304519653,
-0.32912278175354004,
-0.1281970739364624,
0.3232420086860657,
-0.08760128915309906,
-0.5092059969902039,
0.3725399672985077,
-0.14108704030513763,
-0.15896987915039062,
0.10926971584558487,
-1.214332938194275,
0.48091235756874084,
0.6195811033248901,
0.8048107028007507,
-0.013674941845238209,
-0.328008234500885,
-0.7338689565658569,
0.06611693650484085,
-0.18134979903697968,
0.7063336968421936,
-0.46674615144729614,
-0.37383776903152466,
-0.08484068512916565,
0.10546903312206268,
-0.04599218815565109,
-1.020506739616394,
0.36583366990089417,
-0.5835396647453308,
-0.22114509344100952,
-0.22917896509170532,
-0.40432578325271606,
-0.04225599393248558,
0.41683104634284973,
-0.9235168695449829,
0.6161897778511047,
0.3755314350128174,
-0.522591769695282,
0.3326228857040405,
-0.6492109894752502,
-0.43050915002822876,
0.1615094244480133,
-0.06072200462222099,
-0.44849082827568054,
-0.03855084627866745,
-0.018318578600883484,
0.5791015625,
-0.15953390300273895,
0.3276670575141907,
-0.5689125657081604,
-0.4306795001029968,
0.1742694079875946,
-0.1510435789823532,
0.07233241945505142,
0.12202222645282745,
-0.292888343334198,
0.5817568898200989,
-0.7908393144607544,
-0.14392313361167908,
0.17387251555919647,
-0.7779560685157776,
-0.17795883119106293,
0.1666937619447708,
0.3479118347167969,
0.05416979640722275,
-0.03727591037750244,
-0.49446287751197815,
0.34345462918281555,
-0.5023353695869446,
0.5785828828811646,
0.8875922560691833,
-0.10581759363412857,
0.47885075211524963,
-0.6306160092353821,
0.8036935925483704,
-0.25423741340637207,
0.018262289464473724,
0.10090889781713486,
0.03701140731573105,
-0.6054823398590088,
-0.28139621019363403,
0.5915210843086243,
0.41859450936317444,
-0.7746551632881165,
0.322721391916275,
-0.3179459273815155,
-0.20199517905712128,
-0.42305251955986023,
0.21788179874420166,
0.5477979779243469,
0.4471895694732666,
0.28724366426467896,
-0.3118165135383606,
-0.7478735446929932,
-1.0953997373580933,
-0.046362582594156265,
-0.44069793820381165,
-0.14439205825328827,
0.6525225043296814,
0.20600078999996185,
0.011894652619957924,
0.8478439450263977,
-0.17524971067905426,
-0.2995428740978241,
-0.8009286522865295,
0.17983050644397736,
0.34097820520401,
0.40756911039352417,
0.10915857553482056,
-0.6693745255470276,
-0.22239667177200317,
-0.15502287447452545,
-0.38062018156051636,
0.07567432522773743,
-0.1797308772802353,
0.18206672370433807,
-0.17130452394485474,
0.3158174157142639,
-0.291399747133255,
0.03258923441171646,
0.6310328245162964,
-0.4060291349887848,
0.6707002520561218,
-0.2530667781829834,
-0.24261708557605743,
-0.6879072785377502,
0.1959840953350067,
-0.07427044212818146,
-0.5023553371429443,
-0.37732020020484924,
-0.0909205749630928,
0.04780266806483269,
0.07286501675844193,
-0.30842605233192444,
0.651211142539978,
-0.1055099293589592,
-0.1128334030508995,
-0.30003365874290466,
-0.06913184374570847,
-0.2572689354419708,
0.8083943724632263,
0.4301966428756714,
0.6439691185951233,
0.1690978854894638,
-0.9073911905288696,
0.3066168427467346,
0.03656579554080963,
-0.3405606746673584,
0.24323883652687073,
-0.9566777944564819,
-0.14285635948181152,
-0.09817710518836975,
0.3456266522407532,
-0.7204806804656982,
-0.3975751996040344,
0.34890323877334595,
-0.41341519355773926,
0.16588951647281647,
0.020525576546788216,
-0.515116810798645,
-0.12822017073631287,
-0.28688597679138184,
0.2693993151187897,
0.2645748257637024,
-0.6075000166893005,
0.3958640396595001,
0.2995583713054657,
-0.1475892961025238,
-0.5901695489883423,
-0.2312794178724289,
-0.07972164452075958,
-0.016831720247864723,
-0.36470091342926025,
0.46707913279533386,
0.2095772624015808,
0.09276708960533142,
0.1414250135421753,
0.042489659041166306,
0.29347631335258484,
0.3010016679763794,
0.35374748706817627,
0.03228454664349556,
0.09575632959604263,
0.3064820468425751,
-0.2789783477783203,
-0.19830696284770966,
-0.0554625503718853,
-0.3292030394077301,
0.6948711276054382,
-0.25623899698257446,
-0.03521136939525604,
-0.2649746239185333,
-0.04809703305363655,
0.386368989944458,
-0.023989949375391006,
0.6869542598724365,
0.4390285015106201,
-0.1096176728606224,
-0.44600868225097656,
-0.09276971966028214,
-0.7149500846862793,
-0.4256194233894348,
0.7871384620666504,
-0.37473586201667786,
-1.2634246349334717,
0.40886950492858887,
-0.25417304039001465,
0.14997559785842896,
0.0491817444562912,
0.6012997031211853,
-0.1184098944067955,
0.8901239633560181,
0.6114029884338379,
-0.11440259963274002,
0.5624800324440002,
-0.39450255036354065,
-0.31402328610420227,
-0.7980621457099915,
-0.47443944215774536,
-0.3739648461341858,
-0.711030125617981,
-0.44391363859176636,
-0.2237243801355362,
0.3289412260055542,
0.20760217308998108,
-0.35833629965782166,
0.29607638716697693,
-0.04951795935630798,
0.2627151608467102,
0.5086035132408142,
0.5410308837890625,
0.18584954738616943,
-0.20113012194633484,
-0.3212602138519287,
0.16151463985443115,
-1.2259719371795654,
-0.3367644250392914,
1.1692875623703003,
0.5996413230895996,
0.9398877024650574,
0.14963747560977936,
0.5333936214447021,
0.35321399569511414,
0.42514750361442566,
-0.7629072070121765,
0.3740544617176056,
-0.15375453233718872,
-0.46065035462379456,
-0.604632556438446,
-0.7289742827415466,
-1.1247167587280273,
0.1304987668991089,
-0.4766632318496704,
-0.5520955920219421,
0.29335835576057434,
0.5510321259498596,
-0.547873854637146,
0.3854929804801941,
-0.3269515931606293,
0.8408936262130737,
-0.0047985888086259365,
-0.5414840579032898,
-0.33373478055000305,
-0.6516399383544922,
0.37700095772743225,
0.2572188675403595,
0.2118537575006485,
0.05858081951737404,
0.11451798677444458,
0.8656357526779175,
-0.39428073167800903,
1.0362273454666138,
-0.2765500843524933,
0.26224052906036377,
-0.09789232909679413,
0.3254185616970062,
0.8165160417556763,
0.35825780034065247,
-0.03267163038253784,
-0.42161238193511963,
-0.37581634521484375,
-0.4530220329761505,
-0.7574517726898193,
0.29441824555397034,
-0.8876622915267944,
-0.2366705685853958,
0.12119520455598831,
-0.5502159595489502,
-0.44767871499061584,
-0.03470607101917267,
0.20299510657787323,
0.5289415121078491,
-0.268116295337677,
0.4647948145866394,
0.7298324704170227,
-0.21906989812850952,
0.28886982798576355,
0.5118467211723328,
-0.3297898769378662,
-0.4097742736339569,
1.0088618993759155,
-0.3139045834541321,
0.28303802013397217,
0.6172958016395569,
0.2121850550174713,
-0.45224472880363464,
-0.5238191485404968,
-0.5024793148040771,
0.2398480772972107,
-0.363010972738266,
-0.16540300846099854,
-0.5137205719947815,
-0.03709343448281288,
-0.031970180571079254,
0.1591469794511795,
-0.7550473809242249,
-0.5332516431808472,
-0.13927702605724335,
-0.26955437660217285,
0.10904442518949509,
0.734233558177948,
-0.3091050982475281,
0.4694734215736389,
-0.7873556613922119,
0.2666909694671631,
0.5116797089576721,
0.6985805630683899,
0.21819961071014404,
-0.42654457688331604,
-0.5025414824485779,
-0.06368682533502579,
0.16364580392837524,
-0.5558972358703613,
0.2789485454559326,
0.17079764604568481,
0.5577353239059448,
0.4114835858345032,
0.05636828765273094,
0.35301345586776733,
-0.20845754444599152,
0.36662542819976807,
0.23300810158252716,
-0.5470266938209534,
0.26481524109840393,
-0.33057278394699097,
0.21572469174861908,
0.6300475597381592,
0.2467673271894455,
-0.5615695714950562,
-0.09078551083803177,
-0.5506420135498047,
-0.887213945388794,
0.7933363318443298,
-0.0935397818684578,
-0.08294901251792908,
-0.022205907851457596,
0.6016343832015991,
0.017838390544056892,
0.1461736410856247,
-0.7751889824867249,
-0.1791079193353653,
-0.141778826713562,
-0.01712663471698761,
-0.21082726120948792,
-0.18647658824920654,
-0.20767982304096222,
-0.21010296046733856,
0.6320236325263977,
-0.2971070110797882,
0.17070026695728302,
0.06927859038114548,
-0.13273558020591736,
-0.2814016044139862,
0.34989020228385925,
0.6346046924591064,
0.5294950008392334,
-0.5589607357978821,
0.22394995391368866,
-0.09721828252077103,
-0.2720593512058258,
0.42886969447135925,
-0.31193438172340393,
-0.07245828956365585,
-0.27848607301712036,
0.4335613548755646,
1.1587018966674805,
0.3391079306602478,
-0.7425557971000671,
0.27714303135871887,
-0.2261308878660202,
-0.42644619941711426,
-0.06903481483459473,
0.26844504475593567,
0.35404857993125916,
0.3029119670391083,
0.07588543742895126,
-0.03236638382077217,
-0.07322783768177032,
-0.5535095930099487,
0.4753780663013458,
0.31805020570755005,
-0.6230911612510681,
-0.4301029145717621,
0.4234156012535095,
0.2565191388130188,
-0.480983167886734,
0.8559180498123169,
-0.25660422444343567,
-0.36558979749679565,
0.5456765294075012,
0.651928722858429,
0.727268397808075,
0.06266884505748749,
0.6092846393585205,
0.4168446362018585,
0.09109524637460709,
-0.3889130651950836,
0.19223174452781677,
-0.32462069392204285,
-0.9405937790870667,
-0.4438723623752594,
-0.7170769572257996,
-0.5097739100456238,
0.27385619282722473,
-0.7419570684432983,
0.016312003135681152,
-0.7300112843513489,
-0.2740866541862488,
-0.30585354566574097,
-0.19718638062477112,
-0.5584951043128967,
0.08696185052394867,
-0.059621792286634445,
0.9165940880775452,
-0.869382381439209,
1.0263786315917969,
0.8106054663658142,
-0.2929113209247589,
-1.2619320154190063,
-0.36227643489837646,
-0.18893909454345703,
-0.8126813769340515,
1.1336290836334229,
-0.18284139037132263,
-0.31309881806373596,
0.0871594026684761,
-0.22125957906246185,
-0.5944800972938538,
1.1071029901504517,
0.20194020867347717,
-0.7894684672355652,
-0.13993245363235474,
0.03917485103011131,
0.48078808188438416,
-0.5646036267280579,
0.2780487537384033,
0.5452402830123901,
0.44892334938049316,
0.18443024158477783,
-0.9312846660614014,
0.052588511258363724,
-0.24157795310020447,
0.16783098876476288,
0.13899780809879303,
-0.5882738828659058,
0.7735975384712219,
-0.20120689272880554,
-0.24180451035499573,
-0.10145541280508041,
0.6481770277023315,
0.7142916321754456,
-0.1710239201784134,
0.8247416019439697,
0.5920356512069702,
0.5314021110534668,
0.08367102593183517,
1.0216612815856934,
-0.11420132964849472,
0.3381447196006775,
1.050247073173523,
-0.07162370532751083,
0.8476278185844421,
0.39123600721359253,
-0.24504943192005157,
0.7134672403335571,
0.8741304874420166,
0.33557018637657166,
0.7270070910453796,
0.7444935441017151,
-0.00715186120942235,
-0.5461804270744324,
-0.2253284454345703,
-0.15839722752571106,
0.37320101261138916,
0.30084121227264404,
-0.2347804605960846,
-0.35700371861457825,
-0.09420424699783325,
-0.2211262285709381,
0.1433950960636139,
-0.34203779697418213,
0.7725635766983032,
-0.023148946464061737,
-0.4918612539768219,
0.5496492385864258,
0.30252689123153687,
0.7403564453125,
-0.6685202121734619,
-0.17642073333263397,
-0.46434786915779114,
0.2837466299533844,
-0.21554690599441528,
-0.4434604346752167,
0.21608957648277283,
-0.2850703001022339,
-0.3684662878513336,
-0.18368318676948547,
0.5459373593330383,
-0.3331187963485718,
-0.09751821309328079,
0.4485014081001282,
0.5470109581947327,
-0.2024659365415573,
0.062462612986564636,
-0.6414207220077515,
-0.12660406529903412,
-0.24010223150253296,
-0.47262096405029297,
0.6286852359771729,
0.013241102918982506,
0.006949644070118666,
0.8601757287979126,
0.7244241833686829,
0.6150802969932556,
-0.3446904420852661,
0.2093912661075592,
0.8325784206390381,
-0.6909015774726868,
-0.8252019286155701,
-0.8545775413513184,
0.277862548828125,
0.12015846371650696,
-0.16166621446609497,
0.3336069881916046,
0.43453580141067505,
0.9510552883148193,
-0.056246280670166016,
0.6251822710037231,
0.10664785653352737,
0.6338388323783875,
-0.5621591210365295,
0.533892035484314,
-0.48234882950782776,
0.4291727542877197,
-0.021265849471092224,
-0.7964119911193848,
-0.2799912691116333,
0.5132393836975098,
0.09175869822502136,
-0.000037022382457507774,
0.369469553232193,
1.0081332921981812,
-0.0855741947889328,
-0.10541393607854843,
0.22134363651275635,
-0.07739496231079102,
0.17816610634326935,
0.8502475023269653,
0.873262882232666,
0.10818841308355331,
0.39335113763809204,
-0.2682487964630127,
-0.37682709097862244,
-0.3691099286079407,
-0.7009071111679077,
-0.7379071712493896,
-0.43820637464523315,
-0.01271006092429161,
-0.45534977316856384,
0.339756578207016,
1.2493870258331299,
1.105430006980896,
-0.8408957719802856,
-0.7355766296386719,
-0.30682918429374695,
0.31548890471458435,
-0.568800151348114,
-0.24620062112808228,
0.40894362330436707,
-0.45463070273399353,
-0.2861008942127228,
0.5381205081939697,
0.4533534348011017,
-0.21966561675071716,
-0.43286842107772827,
-0.6496278643608093,
0.00716694351285696,
-0.1255301833152771,
0.4580309987068176,
0.615567684173584,
-0.42388230562210083,
-0.3022603988647461,
0.20860889554023743,
-0.032554712146520615,
-0.15099871158599854,
1.1573004722595215,
-0.9070446491241455,
0.2981533110141754,
0.5160883069038391,
0.8138037919998169,
0.5887259840965271,
0.07906542718410492,
0.7903080582618713,
-0.9347277879714966,
0.1479288637638092,
0.2788647413253784,
0.20082321763038635,
0.14806200563907623,
-0.21278467774391174,
0.4226909875869751,
0.35624241828918457,
-0.42936939001083374,
-0.7700968384742737,
0.4705878496170044,
-0.8001623749732971,
-0.35660210251808167,
1.1643255949020386,
-0.3090183734893799,
-0.18559855222702026,
-0.14266934990882874,
0.28930798172950745,
0.20154699683189392,
-0.3682669401168823,
0.8782814145088196,
0.47469577193260193,
-0.3322523236274719,
-0.44924625754356384,
-0.22148990631103516,
0.8188880085945129,
0.6173662543296814,
-0.7785089015960693,
0.299347847700119,
0.14086183905601501,
0.22947007417678833,
-0.2784397304058075,
0.860811173915863,
-0.051839347928762436,
0.4235609769821167,
-0.21997274458408356,
0.0638432651758194,
-0.64287930727005,
-0.7042391896247864,
-0.387417197227478,
0.4400879144668579,
0.5451568365097046,
-0.15328450500965118
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.04156v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.04156v1
|
Pointer-Guided Pre-Training: Infusing Large Language Models with Paragraph-Level Contextual Awareness
| 2024-06-06T15:17:51 | 2024-06-06T15:17:51 |
Lars Hillebrand, Prabhupad Pradhan, Christian Bauckhage, Rafet Sifa
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
We introduce "pointer-guided segment ordering" (SO), a novel pre-training
technique aimed at enhancing the contextual understanding of paragraph-level
text representations in large language models. Our methodology leverages a
self-attention-driven pointer network to restore the original sequence of
shuffled text segments, addressing the challenge of capturing the structural
coherence and contextual dependencies within documents. This pre-training
approach is complemented by a fine-tuning methodology that incorporates dynamic
sampling, augmenting the diversity of training instances and improving sample
efficiency for various downstream applications. We evaluate our method on a
diverse set of datasets, demonstrating its efficacy in tasks requiring
sequential text classification across scientific literature and financial
reporting domains. Our experiments show that pointer-guided pre-training
significantly enhances the model's ability to understand complex document
structures, leading to state-of-the-art performance in downstream
classification tasks.
|
[
-0.07667078077793121,
-0.6145133972167969,
0.5361226797103882,
0.3764871656894684,
-0.47355085611343384,
-0.14530381560325623,
0.09047307074069977,
-0.3854614496231079,
0.060727182775735855,
0.4204777181148529,
-0.4221978783607483,
-0.4757974445819855,
-0.6392773985862732,
0.02986178547143936,
-0.6642866730690002,
1.0248405933380127,
0.24425332248210907,
0.28385668992996216,
-0.08363529294729233,
0.13465280830860138,
-0.14709436893463135,
-0.696543276309967,
-0.5681896209716797,
-0.06566007435321808,
0.6306335926055908,
0.34143394231796265,
0.23751163482666016,
1.024135708808899,
0.5502755641937256,
0.34081241488456726,
0.06150197610259056,
-0.1524248868227005,
-0.6682170629501343,
-0.02122298628091812,
-0.26135072112083435,
-0.2828212380409241,
-0.4910260736942291,
0.20976413786411285,
0.7693497538566589,
0.950788676738739,
0.046728141605854034,
0.06853096932172775,
0.2519470453262329,
0.5707714557647705,
-0.76731938123703,
0.1009056568145752,
-0.4030068516731262,
0.09880095720291138,
-0.27056223154067993,
-0.4585305154323578,
-0.6765666007995605,
-0.3457454442977905,
0.8548591136932373,
-0.8286802172660828,
0.1567835509777069,
0.35495054721832275,
0.6957445740699768,
0.41229182481765747,
-0.45826050639152527,
-0.18028146028518677,
-0.37441444396972656,
0.662926197052002,
-0.2708606421947479,
0.5232012271881104,
0.31108683347702026,
-0.0409667044878006,
-0.07466772198677063,
-1.1493291854858398,
-0.34605222940444946,
0.16671505570411682,
0.02685825154185295,
0.10824974626302719,
0.11147042363882065,
0.15935270488262177,
0.19072198867797852,
0.12879429757595062,
-0.5105801820755005,
0.1726675033569336,
-0.23237761855125427,
0.08867044001817703,
0.2331240028142929,
-0.21130917966365814,
0.1540922075510025,
0.003550425171852112,
-0.45771709084510803,
-0.2812193036079407,
-0.9043779969215393,
-0.005827674176543951,
0.12095408886671066,
0.05219166353344917,
0.24742180109024048,
0.1880686730146408,
-0.2517643868923187,
0.8803779482841492,
0.5552814602851868,
-0.10469996929168701,
0.16808553040027618,
-0.37846073508262634,
-0.5429487824440002,
0.6772790551185608,
0.6039795279502869,
0.02249973639845848,
0.07359634339809418,
0.15216097235679626,
0.13571381568908691,
-0.3784610629081726,
0.32623547315597534,
-1.037190318107605,
-0.42552199959754944,
-0.15429797768592834,
-0.44984492659568787,
-0.14172165095806122,
0.027204586192965508,
-0.3768197000026703,
-0.29088571667671204,
-0.520714282989502,
0.30192136764526367,
-0.615644097328186,
0.102210134267807,
0.46950140595436096,
-0.08084215223789215,
0.2399299442768097,
0.5874444246292114,
-1.1201541423797607,
-0.22817674279212952,
0.8466964960098267,
0.45000073313713074,
0.09213313460350037,
-0.6431968212127686,
-0.7003148794174194,
0.6315197348594666,
-0.2640325129032135,
1.1225862503051758,
-0.6799305081367493,
-0.3972923457622528,
-0.04521875083446503,
-0.3415631949901581,
-0.22338177263736725,
-0.3959004878997803,
0.5590630769729614,
-0.5834640860557556,
0.41537636518478394,
-0.3642187714576721,
-0.43678462505340576,
-0.014223533682525158,
0.46183133125305176,
-0.19425465166568756,
1.101786494255066,
-0.08207609504461288,
-1.1616021394729614,
0.6275998950004578,
-0.2703849971294403,
-0.3848537504673004,
-0.10533163696527481,
-0.35628488659858704,
-0.25496140122413635,
0.09354067593812943,
0.21650618314743042,
0.7501549124717712,
-0.05749144032597542,
0.21503455936908722,
-0.3548525273799896,
-0.26499807834625244,
0.05122736468911171,
-0.05096816271543503,
0.4159187078475952,
-0.08333408087491989,
-0.13736091554164886,
0.6112138032913208,
-0.9179933667182922,
-0.21969448029994965,
-0.23334981501102448,
-0.3631380498409271,
-0.8143136501312256,
0.13237260282039642,
-0.24441027641296387,
0.1596599668264389,
0.3544965088367462,
-0.23632273077964783,
0.18345065414905548,
-0.623730480670929,
0.45606306195259094,
0.7716689705848694,
0.0693233385682106,
0.8106788396835327,
0.1316116750240326,
0.1541295051574707,
0.05441370606422424,
0.3089374899864197,
-0.4694478213787079,
-0.07303746044635773,
-0.9723535776138306,
-0.323541522026062,
0.1430242657661438,
0.4346355199813843,
-0.5277543067932129,
0.7328000664710999,
-0.4477701783180237,
-0.3892022371292114,
0.09331539273262024,
-0.24532747268676758,
0.4190177321434021,
1.0729516744613647,
0.3268917500972748,
-0.2752801775932312,
-0.3589264154434204,
-0.7605530023574829,
-0.13978974521160126,
-0.25462451577186584,
-0.08523225784301758,
-0.064076267182827,
0.26551878452301025,
-0.1892530620098114,
0.8758900165557861,
-0.8156726956367493,
-0.264125257730484,
-0.20117098093032837,
0.5321878790855408,
0.12242822349071503,
0.6452615857124329,
0.22418898344039917,
-0.8383985757827759,
-0.7640018463134766,
-0.022290179505944252,
-0.43082430958747864,
0.056170348078012466,
-0.10659849643707275,
-0.31239384412765503,
-0.34289121627807617,
0.9939213395118713,
-0.21978828310966492,
0.25996455550193787,
0.05645114555954933,
-0.4300033450126648,
0.6058230400085449,
-0.4904656708240509,
-0.10568749159574509,
-1.0985674858093262,
0.18490861356258392,
-0.06124558672308922,
-0.1214645728468895,
-0.7979762554168701,
-0.4005158841609955,
0.36408528685569763,
-0.13634541630744934,
-0.25478821992874146,
0.4490470290184021,
-0.5548476576805115,
-0.1078534945845604,
-0.2058703601360321,
-0.03115200810134411,
0.2325146198272705,
0.3435271978378296,
0.33786943554878235,
0.6788904070854187,
0.5685940980911255,
-0.6338205933570862,
-0.3820205628871918,
0.5907917618751526,
-0.6567375659942627,
0.7713630199432373,
-0.5137882232666016,
0.05324675887823105,
-0.28699740767478943,
0.265858918428421,
-0.7214040160179138,
-0.12152533233165741,
0.16186995804309845,
-0.1740952581167221,
0.555129885673523,
-0.03344161435961723,
-0.2587737739086151,
-0.04643932357430458,
-0.17928941547870636,
0.5241124033927917,
0.02735123597085476,
-0.4635726511478424,
0.5362653732299805,
0.2983253300189972,
-0.5205427408218384,
-0.8446416258811951,
-0.26261675357818604,
-0.2219262272119522,
-0.20167633891105652,
-0.42760464549064636,
0.5237287878990173,
-0.02160697616636753,
0.18266072869300842,
-0.33683162927627563,
-0.3745644688606262,
-0.310173362493515,
0.20151205360889435,
0.23106887936592102,
0.07410048693418503,
-0.05157404765486717,
0.1574523150920868,
0.1941266655921936,
-0.22819675505161285,
0.038473330438137054,
-0.7712192535400391,
0.5492488145828247,
0.10735616832971573,
-0.2862355709075928,
-0.4225812554359436,
0.25964924693107605,
0.3142315149307251,
-0.6719115972518921,
0.4042540490627289,
0.4933045506477356,
0.00856386311352253,
-0.2894417643547058,
-0.4530438780784607,
-0.17773854732513428,
-0.5492885112762451,
0.5120580196380615,
-0.42482292652130127,
-1.1476014852523804,
0.17820464074611664,
-0.22053185105323792,
-0.19989314675331116,
0.202182337641716,
0.26064518094062805,
-0.40366074442863464,
0.8916455507278442,
1.0369584560394287,
-0.1427120864391327,
1.1577931642532349,
-0.19861970841884613,
0.5208859443664551,
-0.5525433421134949,
-0.39420971274375916,
-0.6949434876441956,
-0.07134075462818146,
-0.05272712558507919,
-0.5733696818351746,
0.5390318632125854,
0.4591880142688751,
-0.40978163480758667,
0.016596276313066483,
-0.4469352960586548,
0.632042407989502,
0.6220071315765381,
-0.09626597166061401,
0.18526719510555267,
0.008375642821192741,
-0.22335918247699738,
0.07851093262434006,
-0.6576297879219055,
-0.36571773886680603,
0.804337203502655,
0.38024142384529114,
0.6882724761962891,
-0.4966762661933899,
0.7104276418685913,
-0.08199453353881836,
0.3350479006767273,
-0.7710553407669067,
0.5286332368850708,
-0.15827417373657227,
-0.26832115650177,
-0.5368354916572571,
-0.16672350466251373,
-0.8647344708442688,
0.30494117736816406,
-0.08837953209877014,
-0.71262127161026,
0.5415182113647461,
0.3530174493789673,
-0.7117602825164795,
-0.29111817479133606,
-0.7961994409561157,
1.2226029634475708,
-0.22092781960964203,
-0.26469942927360535,
-0.36521586775779724,
-0.6958029270172119,
0.041461799293756485,
-0.10566151887178421,
-0.320963591337204,
-0.060435742139816284,
0.11112400889396667,
0.8115078806877136,
-0.3538501560688019,
0.8115723133087158,
-0.17860983312129974,
-0.05866016447544098,
0.08368921279907227,
-0.16339051723480225,
0.485591322183609,
0.0509304516017437,
0.03824273496866226,
-0.054752983152866364,
0.007548329420387745,
-0.38477104902267456,
-0.5544705390930176,
0.40110844373703003,
-0.6848254203796387,
-0.6987903714179993,
-0.566206157207489,
-0.42261382937431335,
-0.2203226238489151,
0.7081272602081299,
0.2670420706272125,
0.627539336681366,
-0.3704344928264618,
0.27256181836128235,
1.0703016519546509,
-0.05063470080494881,
0.42168036103248596,
0.6254891753196716,
0.08501297235488892,
-0.3523351848125458,
0.7269278764724731,
-0.03961557149887085,
-0.20510119199752808,
0.9379770159721375,
0.10919007658958435,
-0.5349270701408386,
-1.0301437377929688,
-0.1366986185312271,
0.23967382311820984,
-0.671849250793457,
0.07777243107557297,
-0.8949871063232422,
0.021969130262732506,
-0.5765002369880676,
-0.31691527366638184,
-0.20803368091583252,
-0.16066764295101166,
-0.7130740284919739,
-0.14500924944877625,
-0.25755345821380615,
0.7432960867881775,
0.2982296347618103,
0.7654810547828674,
-0.9170774221420288,
-0.03826572746038437,
0.4717743396759033,
0.20108136534690857,
-0.10339505970478058,
-0.42154064774513245,
-0.573022723197937,
-0.5503218173980713,
-0.21001499891281128,
-0.7338818907737732,
0.4938744008541107,
0.24707993865013123,
0.5050197839736938,
0.9628114104270935,
0.03381730988621712,
0.8612966537475586,
-0.9611465334892273,
0.3228338956832886,
0.43548959493637085,
-1.0750367641448975,
0.7327728867530823,
-0.6040575504302979,
0.4570649266242981,
0.8395428657531738,
0.7508763670921326,
-0.4440835416316986,
-0.09247603267431259,
-0.1813800036907196,
-0.7835505604743958,
0.8613064885139465,
-0.36796969175338745,
-0.22586727142333984,
-0.03847818449139595,
0.4785853922367096,
0.04830422252416611,
0.39149209856987,
-0.5595636963844299,
0.15269896388053894,
-0.41895049810409546,
-0.32814082503318787,
-0.24806010723114014,
-0.5926634669303894,
0.002270121593028307,
-0.2684333920478821,
0.4519816040992737,
-0.45389556884765625,
0.04991132766008377,
0.5180895924568176,
-0.44371792674064636,
0.35722580552101135,
0.1506061851978302,
0.5566644668579102,
1.0270507335662842,
-0.28890299797058105,
0.2980644702911377,
-0.29871565103530884,
-0.6594863533973694,
0.05488685891032219,
0.4368772804737091,
-0.1808573305606842,
-0.4172627925872803,
0.2354588508605957,
0.8236059546470642,
0.5624191164970398,
-0.42535755038261414,
0.48301413655281067,
-0.17177022993564606,
-0.03887391462922096,
-0.1689775437116623,
-0.0066528827883303165,
-0.11021162569522858,
0.23624487221240997,
0.5260641574859619,
-0.1827755868434906,
0.34630581736564636,
-0.3710516095161438,
0.20594173669815063,
0.18778221309185028,
-0.43692031502723694,
-0.5000415444374084,
0.3389497697353363,
0.3534327745437622,
0.0793469101190567,
0.5794503688812256,
0.06371574103832245,
-0.5898038744926453,
0.21345385909080505,
0.5713281631469727,
0.8134190440177917,
-0.38099732995033264,
0.1957143396139145,
0.2647417485713959,
0.017657792195677757,
-0.2711389362812042,
0.23088839650154114,
-0.4170626997947693,
-0.6481696367263794,
-0.4950677752494812,
-0.7913347482681274,
-0.3055516183376312,
-0.21882681548595428,
-0.5496372580528259,
0.115576833486557,
-0.6540929079055786,
-0.09657059609889984,
0.12694449722766876,
-0.14592194557189941,
-0.2340332269668579,
0.30822277069091797,
0.0041336663998663425,
1.136322021484375,
-0.611884355545044,
1.3495291471481323,
0.7104058265686035,
-0.07223563641309738,
-0.6486196517944336,
0.30225300788879395,
-0.3580525815486908,
-0.5840153694152832,
1.1065045595169067,
0.47981759905815125,
-0.17112520337104797,
0.43195539712905884,
-0.27386876940727234,
-1.1147427558898926,
0.966688334941864,
0.26568159461021423,
-0.39896494150161743,
-0.34114477038383484,
0.02191418968141079,
0.5246365070343018,
-0.35724344849586487,
0.16418223083019257,
0.3322640657424927,
0.262397825717926,
0.11137278378009796,
-0.7517775893211365,
-0.3170134425163269,
-0.13482943177223206,
0.047186534851789474,
0.24753674864768982,
-0.5401350855827332,
0.7377029657363892,
0.15261346101760864,
-0.2531253397464752,
-0.21746689081192017,
1.0169330835342407,
0.15744851529598236,
0.24311445653438568,
0.6799424886703491,
0.6551671624183655,
0.9106404185295105,
0.007769595831632614,
0.8279922008514404,
-0.44214871525764465,
-0.07293491810560226,
1.3794605731964111,
-0.44646942615509033,
1.027854561805725,
0.5303688645362854,
0.23161572217941284,
0.5682340860366821,
0.8166092038154602,
0.2441300004720688,
0.7558606266975403,
-0.01534061785787344,
-0.13793785870075226,
-0.28107696771621704,
-0.31889423727989197,
-0.40525195002555847,
0.3968898355960846,
0.34259751439094543,
-0.3662312626838684,
-0.09498659521341324,
-0.023169225081801414,
-0.15471036732196808,
-0.12252885848283768,
-0.5120896697044373,
0.7656100988388062,
0.1839917004108429,
-0.7867301106452942,
0.33138614892959595,
-0.12937068939208984,
0.4827175736427307,
-0.8610295653343201,
0.2803039848804474,
-0.1735353022813797,
0.36675816774368286,
0.11226347833871841,
-0.40725722908973694,
0.17657387256622314,
-0.1734200268983841,
-0.5460742115974426,
-0.9234784245491028,
0.7407640218734741,
-0.4078080654144287,
-0.23688852787017822,
0.15679840743541718,
0.32454439997673035,
-0.1824476271867752,
-0.40673309564590454,
-0.5642467737197876,
-0.14282351732254028,
-0.006719503551721573,
-0.2821890413761139,
0.6307998299598694,
0.5904019474983215,
-0.049043506383895874,
0.5572015047073364,
0.535395085811615,
-0.3347929120063782,
0.13807791471481323,
0.09296990931034088,
0.9453287720680237,
-0.6346927285194397,
-1.1735509634017944,
-0.7046409845352173,
0.31731295585632324,
-0.2655476927757263,
-0.1735115349292755,
0.8388654589653015,
0.6783448457717896,
1.045941948890686,
-0.16650594770908356,
0.3913991153240204,
0.3195157051086426,
0.41127273440361023,
-0.4576864242553711,
0.7956001162528992,
-0.3166930377483368,
-0.08778185397386551,
-0.10005813091993332,
-0.8509513139724731,
-0.38620322942733765,
0.6759862303733826,
-0.9268367290496826,
-0.29971179366111755,
0.9323036074638367,
0.5112696290016174,
-0.2451373040676117,
-0.0017029617447406054,
0.2061954289674759,
0.34185990691185,
0.15761184692382812,
0.23531319200992584,
1.0044567584991455,
0.04504399001598358,
0.5421012043952942,
-0.0819743350148201,
-0.28408676385879517,
-0.20528028905391693,
-0.9200183153152466,
-1.054113745689392,
-0.5424169898033142,
-0.30526095628738403,
0.04527382180094719,
-0.07084189355373383,
0.7026610374450684,
1.007858395576477,
-0.6389709711074829,
-0.28327473998069763,
-0.12561197578907013,
-0.0568704828619957,
0.19292712211608887,
-0.08218686282634735,
0.6470995545387268,
-0.5083256363868713,
-0.8203331828117371,
0.6754949688911438,
0.8563277721405029,
0.21288369596004486,
-0.10106392204761505,
0.1917090266942978,
-0.4007555842399597,
-0.20008574426174164,
0.7380305528640747,
0.24560990929603577,
-0.2757059335708618,
-0.13115845620632172,
0.13590691983699799,
-0.20075346529483795,
0.17835234105587006,
1.164937973022461,
-0.6205964684486389,
0.31408360600471497,
0.8776324987411499,
0.714616596698761,
0.4883958697319031,
0.11737228184938431,
0.6160585880279541,
-0.8056333065032959,
0.40605100989341736,
0.17574799060821533,
0.35630035400390625,
0.07574865967035294,
-0.40812617540359497,
0.17584747076034546,
0.07275755703449249,
-0.5308853983879089,
-0.6169432401657104,
0.24856576323509216,
-1.0497362613677979,
-0.3739652931690216,
0.6550306081771851,
-0.5866717100143433,
-0.37347567081451416,
-0.20543812215328217,
-0.2440202534198761,
0.21602383255958557,
-0.3170194923877716,
0.7920864820480347,
0.4142889678478241,
-0.17291252315044403,
-0.07730084657669067,
0.05805196985602379,
0.7884820103645325,
0.7409266233444214,
-1.0078197717666626,
-0.014193604700267315,
0.6994540095329285,
0.017856616526842117,
0.2488669604063034,
0.946530818939209,
0.15914276242256165,
-0.03771336376667023,
-0.35317400097846985,
-0.21159310638904572,
0.06983266025781631,
-0.7499003410339355,
-0.4262217879295349,
0.47599080204963684,
0.12300856411457062,
-0.052526019513607025
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.04151v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.04151v1
|
AgentGym: Evolving Large Language Model-based Agents across Diverse Environments
| 2024-06-06T15:15:41 | 2024-06-06T15:15:41 |
Zhiheng Xi, Yiwen Ding, Wenxiang Chen, Boyang Hong, Honglin Guo, Junzhe Wang, Dingwen Yang, Chenyang Liao, Xin Guo, Wei He, Songyang Gao, Lu Chen, Rui Zheng, Yicheng Zou, Tao Gui, Qi Zhang, Xipeng Qiu, Xuanjing Huang, Zuxuan Wu, Yu-Gang Jiang
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Building generalist agents that can handle diverse tasks and evolve
themselves across different environments is a long-term goal in the AI
community. Large language models (LLMs) are considered a promising foundation
to build such agents due to their generalized capabilities. Current approaches
either have LLM-based agents imitate expert-provided trajectories step-by-step,
requiring human supervision, which is hard to scale and limits environmental
exploration; or they let agents explore and learn in isolated environments,
resulting in specialist agents with limited generalization. In this paper, we
take the first step towards building generally-capable LLM-based agents with
self-evolution ability. We identify a trinity of ingredients: 1) diverse
environments for agent exploration and learning, 2) a trajectory set to equip
agents with basic capabilities and prior knowledge, and 3) an effective and
scalable evolution method. We propose AgentGym, a new framework featuring a
variety of environments and tasks for broad, real-time, uni-format, and
concurrent agent exploration. AgentGym also includes a database with expanded
instructions, a benchmark suite, and high-quality trajectories across
environments. Next, we propose a novel method, AgentEvol, to investigate the
potential of agent self-evolution beyond previously seen data across tasks and
environments. Experimental results show that the evolved agents can achieve
results comparable to SOTA models. We release the AgentGym suite, including the
platform, dataset, benchmark, checkpoints, and algorithm implementations. The
AgentGym suite is available on https://github.com/WooooDyy/AgentGym.
|
[
-0.32355624437332153,
-0.7870869636535645,
0.6770907044410706,
-0.025343671441078186,
0.18101057410240173,
0.5240240097045898,
-0.46015021204948425,
-0.4413560926914215,
0.21889232099056244,
0.6912455558776855,
-0.7413870692253113,
-0.523489236831665,
-0.4038693308830261,
-0.11212053894996643,
-0.08817876875400543,
0.996199905872345,
0.025211773812770844,
-0.31646814942359924,
-0.19966603815555573,
-0.2185407429933548,
-0.3357642590999603,
0.004757853224873543,
-0.45820435881614685,
-0.3742545247077942,
0.34205755591392517,
0.44371041655540466,
0.7396740913391113,
0.9372685551643372,
-0.012230691500008106,
0.36368897557258606,
0.03622026741504669,
0.4043816328048706,
-0.43610113859176636,
0.6184890866279602,
-0.42320430278778076,
-0.10900229215621948,
-0.453959584236145,
-0.217076376080513,
0.6160407662391663,
0.17950180172920227,
-0.25495415925979614,
0.1675005555152893,
-0.11622143536806107,
0.11576812714338303,
-0.45114514231681824,
0.2664262652397156,
-0.6217670440673828,
0.018910260871052742,
0.1958281397819519,
0.050061266869306564,
-0.029177548363804817,
0.1570730209350586,
0.20914822816848755,
-0.623770534992218,
-0.0012024786556139588,
-0.04133918881416321,
0.35129037499427795,
0.1854921281337738,
-0.3879343569278717,
-0.44830286502838135,
-0.9221420884132385,
0.5611645579338074,
-0.4366700351238251,
0.23206281661987305,
-0.25560957193374634,
0.6317875981330872,
-0.48154476284980774,
-0.8503527641296387,
-0.402455598115921,
-0.5786214470863342,
0.3623794615268707,
0.1665126383304596,
-0.06585439294576645,
0.005997038446366787,
-0.009927453473210335,
-0.021597685292363167,
-0.5599914193153381,
0.4003077745437622,
0.0034018331207334995,
0.13542790710926056,
0.6576486825942993,
0.23570360243320465,
0.5669221878051758,
0.14109082520008087,
-0.3710733950138092,
-0.21274499595165253,
-0.5069198608398438,
-0.12313961982727051,
0.44896265864372253,
0.43990546464920044,
-0.03416482359170914,
0.14451609551906586,
-0.28508809208869934,
0.35844048857688904,
-0.09664419293403625,
0.020127760246396065,
0.10410938411951065,
-0.24527589976787567,
0.040020715445280075,
-0.12391579151153564,
0.5901976823806763,
-0.24251945316791534,
-0.05594579502940178,
-0.314656138420105,
-0.2275683432817459,
-0.10241057723760605,
0.4079379439353943,
-0.6194683313369751,
-0.20382243394851685,
0.31305167078971863,
-0.12696020305156708,
-0.209801584482193,
-0.23445327579975128,
-1.024366021156311,
-0.5453799962997437,
-0.20421752333641052,
0.42209410667419434,
-0.20459263026714325,
-0.5405410528182983,
0.1969074308872223,
0.012737157754600048,
0.4153830111026764,
0.316344290971756,
-0.7996546030044556,
0.40443941950798035,
0.7662996649742126,
0.7066758275032043,
-0.2382684051990509,
-0.6509827375411987,
-0.4352453649044037,
0.10680430382490158,
-0.2793406844139099,
0.8135942220687866,
-0.5545973777770996,
-0.3580651879310608,
-0.009951336309313774,
0.0025312539655715227,
0.11099842935800552,
-0.38823407888412476,
0.08889365941286087,
-0.39712125062942505,
0.05482960492372513,
0.10797081887722015,
-0.3233218193054199,
-0.11159565299749374,
0.3683106601238251,
-0.4208378791809082,
0.9691685438156128,
0.3676629960536957,
-0.03162016719579697,
0.25045740604400635,
-1.0676829814910889,
-0.23081421852111816,
0.5338374376296997,
-0.3250866234302521,
-0.3161564767360687,
0.0013955027097836137,
0.15751737356185913,
0.42226168513298035,
-0.14920161664485931,
0.19736313819885254,
-0.43352463841438293,
-0.04688577726483345,
-0.1024172455072403,
-0.06504502892494202,
0.4594612717628479,
0.38607800006866455,
-0.5040271878242493,
0.1780036985874176,
-0.5078339576721191,
0.15514159202575684,
0.2893911600112915,
-0.16016875207424164,
-0.1349569410085678,
0.30691972374916077,
-0.046966031193733215,
0.342926949262619,
0.4391666054725647,
-0.18423642218112946,
0.664089560508728,
-0.17172373831272125,
0.5086042881011963,
0.77546226978302,
0.036096107214689255,
0.5051711797714233,
-0.4177389144897461,
0.8344907164573669,
-0.3299451470375061,
0.17598894238471985,
-0.21581268310546875,
-0.28627488017082214,
-0.5403441786766052,
-0.37400341033935547,
-0.23381060361862183,
0.3680548667907715,
-0.6049590110778809,
0.4572087824344635,
-0.4765178859233856,
-0.7470157146453857,
-0.24213725328445435,
0.4424843192100525,
0.05969264730811119,
-0.18983657658100128,
0.3825712203979492,
0.04461125284433365,
-0.28663232922554016,
-0.5685295462608337,
-0.30460259318351746,
-0.15128356218338013,
0.17497017979621887,
0.465037077665329,
0.5299667119979858,
-0.9726062417030334,
0.8882319927215576,
-0.3296493589878082,
0.2043851763010025,
-0.5580987930297852,
0.04987948760390282,
-0.019927147775888443,
0.42876213788986206,
0.6227836012840271,
-0.42894446849823,
-0.26698067784309387,
0.28044575452804565,
-0.692573070526123,
-0.19291552901268005,
-0.24427182972431183,
-0.236466646194458,
-0.23564782738685608,
0.4006040394306183,
-0.971531331539154,
-0.12922745943069458,
0.4771086871623993,
-0.45952603220939636,
0.4665251672267914,
-0.31884416937828064,
-0.15814627707004547,
-1.212446689605713,
-0.0793783962726593,
-0.10276290029287338,
-0.4879615902900696,
-0.7952327132225037,
0.5603510141372681,
-0.2505549490451813,
-0.1354406625032425,
-0.25559788942337036,
0.9403303265571594,
-0.8167231678962708,
-0.26712456345558167,
-0.5457371473312378,
0.13624297082424164,
-0.3250482976436615,
0.3549668490886688,
-0.13910415768623352,
0.4173157811164856,
0.8201250433921814,
-0.6075006723403931,
0.6192123293876648,
0.020807484164834023,
0.0874214842915535,
0.10813512653112411,
-0.2388664335012436,
0.4268042743206024,
-0.2354489117860794,
0.1221402958035469,
-0.6758739948272705,
-0.06789939850568771,
0.35169675946235657,
-0.14127476513385773,
0.4285176694393158,
-0.053174395114183426,
-0.3145580291748047,
-0.36861148476600647,
-0.1336640864610672,
0.2804773151874542,
0.5813755393028259,
-0.707621693611145,
1.0283660888671875,
0.0992351621389389,
-0.2693745195865631,
-0.3977494239807129,
-0.174857035279274,
0.4089104235172272,
-0.4435703754425049,
-0.5819075107574463,
0.0066591789945960045,
-0.3494082987308502,
-0.43450143933296204,
0.023026488721370697,
-0.20776858925819397,
0.3431350290775299,
0.367167592048645,
0.04269363731145859,
-0.024036524817347527,
-0.25990667939186096,
0.2218523621559143,
-0.011582795530557632,
0.19988353550434113,
0.20555327832698822,
-0.8546464443206787,
0.593865692615509,
-0.23502102494239807,
-0.11590102314949036,
0.35092294216156006,
0.176655575633049,
0.6191215515136719,
-0.2515493631362915,
0.2888944745063782,
0.6200870275497437,
-0.21624022722244263,
-1.0685160160064697,
-0.3824296295642853,
-0.027109863236546516,
-0.5190086364746094,
0.8342652916908264,
-0.3879736661911011,
-0.9131221771240234,
0.6711574196815491,
-0.49459049105644226,
0.1608383059501648,
0.49655255675315857,
0.6935616731643677,
0.24980267882347107,
0.7363141179084778,
0.582787811756134,
0.01637898199260235,
0.6346727013587952,
-0.3862279951572418,
-0.0861891359090805,
-0.5522764325141907,
-0.10145348310470581,
-0.3091577887535095,
-0.25803613662719727,
-0.8584275841712952,
-0.5900828838348389,
0.13658259809017181,
-0.3155096471309662,
-0.30154189467430115,
0.3264123201370239,
-0.4605814516544342,
0.6137170195579529,
0.19670118391513824,
-0.00023714429698884487,
0.028941746801137924,
-0.07903449237346649,
0.15395855903625488,
0.5255192518234253,
-0.7099978923797607,
-0.48314690589904785,
1.184643030166626,
0.4475374221801758,
0.9385837912559509,
0.19258850812911987,
0.8524507880210876,
0.7072668671607971,
0.34777113795280457,
-0.6084322333335876,
0.5587618947029114,
0.19854125380516052,
-0.474810391664505,
-0.5842266082763672,
-0.3624117970466614,
-1.1271008253097534,
0.40017756819725037,
-0.15916050970554352,
-0.8467954397201538,
-0.0565955713391304,
-0.09990081191062927,
-0.13550406694412231,
0.17912137508392334,
-0.37517648935317993,
0.9419195055961609,
-0.660615861415863,
-0.34602323174476624,
-0.2661035358905792,
-0.6332933902740479,
0.22114154696464539,
-0.14577673375606537,
0.08932564407587051,
-0.14000041782855988,
-0.3632090389728546,
0.3621046543121338,
-0.24592623114585876,
0.46877142786979675,
-0.2544727921485901,
-0.15072761476039886,
0.5481503009796143,
0.2175562083721161,
0.7333630323410034,
0.19421420991420746,
0.23006397485733032,
0.058989010751247406,
-0.25565943121910095,
-0.5384290814399719,
-0.737746000289917,
0.7438220381736755,
-1.030961036682129,
-0.7736586928367615,
-0.36669522523880005,
-0.504693865776062,
-0.2166772335767746,
0.22706452012062073,
-0.12861979007720947,
0.26934897899627686,
-0.20002515614032745,
-0.02966892160475254,
0.5711655020713806,
-0.0862245038151741,
0.4455412030220032,
0.6349874138832092,
-0.29382798075675964,
-0.08514274656772614,
0.8137286901473999,
0.02767893299460411,
0.26526743173599243,
0.07670961320400238,
0.39049696922302246,
-0.2590722441673279,
-0.7981122136116028,
-0.3777010142803192,
-0.006889802403748035,
-0.7367851734161377,
-0.010703762993216515,
-0.7306803464889526,
-0.18591195344924927,
-0.3493778109550476,
-0.13980993628501892,
-0.3531746566295624,
0.08058202266693115,
-0.18891139328479767,
-0.10629172623157501,
0.2713707685470581,
0.9740736484527588,
-0.09614226222038269,
0.2670699954032898,
-0.3966912031173706,
0.12257830798625946,
0.5637321472167969,
0.0829290971159935,
-0.11032982915639877,
-0.3000832498073578,
-0.3991822302341461,
0.06569406390190125,
-0.27625593543052673,
-0.8763703107833862,
0.41422852873802185,
0.3245728313922882,
0.969399631023407,
0.29749321937561035,
-0.18367548286914825,
0.27235305309295654,
-0.2884644567966461,
0.7665077447891235,
-0.18186737596988678,
-0.6816366314888,
0.4926995635032654,
-0.6997739672660828,
0.3364396393299103,
0.3166070282459259,
0.04786820709705353,
-0.4172110855579376,
-0.4892173111438751,
-0.5319705605506897,
-0.6624732613563538,
0.4795619547367096,
-0.03658457100391388,
0.2634364664554596,
0.1302744299173355,
0.5668296217918396,
0.38989827036857605,
0.08151599764823914,
-0.8059341907501221,
-0.017253663390874863,
-0.43941956758499146,
-0.19583599269390106,
-0.4255167543888092,
0.16784308850765228,
-0.07854679226875305,
-0.08579431474208832,
0.4828629791736603,
-0.5982439517974854,
0.25828608870506287,
0.02332574874162674,
-0.25492584705352783,
0.07343019545078278,
0.49790158867836,
0.4896160364151001,
0.6755054593086243,
0.016774972900748253,
0.15761423110961914,
0.34968847036361694,
-0.445322722196579,
0.5697775483131409,
0.21352262794971466,
0.06944483518600464,
-0.3430619239807129,
0.26227274537086487,
0.6423926949501038,
-0.09465377777814865,
-0.8023224472999573,
0.2620123326778412,
-0.002139289863407612,
-0.11380123347043991,
-0.33090218901634216,
0.5900314450263977,
0.09661280363798141,
0.7810474038124084,
0.413483202457428,
-0.2410208284854889,
0.12235966324806213,
-0.7823425531387329,
0.12247415632009506,
0.4087055027484894,
-0.21319735050201416,
-0.4083530306816101,
0.4918837249279022,
0.1371556967496872,
-0.5259850025177002,
0.3567219376564026,
-0.7206498980522156,
-0.40617382526397705,
0.9060822129249573,
0.7005485892295837,
1.3898835182189941,
-0.2033354490995407,
0.3069861829280853,
-0.15266108512878418,
0.4198463261127472,
-0.2814024090766907,
0.15466299653053284,
-0.09956218302249908,
-0.7524834871292114,
-0.15805768966674805,
-0.5136960744857788,
-0.47752922773361206,
0.1929539144039154,
-0.010255875997245312,
0.20281265676021576,
-0.4955865442752838,
0.10964358597993851,
-0.355871319770813,
0.08023808896541595,
-0.8226564526557922,
0.048782527446746826,
0.2875286042690277,
0.6626462340354919,
-0.6082530617713928,
0.638095498085022,
1.150382399559021,
0.026305215433239937,
-0.46129894256591797,
0.1780935674905777,
-0.14026977121829987,
-0.9204645752906799,
0.27020272612571716,
0.10482745617628098,
-0.22436538338661194,
0.14710494875907898,
-0.7890515327453613,
-1.0167806148529053,
1.4026234149932861,
0.28154075145721436,
-0.44686776399612427,
-0.12288691103458405,
-0.044787824153900146,
0.7150315642356873,
-0.7710920572280884,
0.3286442458629608,
0.4200271964073181,
0.3918735682964325,
-0.12696729600429535,
-0.26344725489616394,
0.17785510420799255,
-0.2219884693622589,
0.031062867492437363,
0.1777486354112625,
-0.8972738981246948,
0.8690058588981628,
-0.2395458221435547,
-0.1538538932800293,
0.06785710901021957,
0.5912205576896667,
0.09515124559402466,
0.1860325187444687,
0.4998760223388672,
0.4239569902420044,
0.5215207934379578,
0.17966888844966888,
0.6438416838645935,
-0.4919334352016449,
0.41731250286102295,
0.9098752737045288,
-0.35015958547592163,
0.29103004932403564,
-0.041032616049051285,
0.090266652405262,
0.8048413991928101,
0.5792371034622192,
-0.1731441617012024,
0.3400605320930481,
0.44627636671066284,
-0.2814810276031494,
-0.45812568068504333,
0.0887708067893982,
-0.14275416731834412,
0.7983690500259399,
0.3271976709365845,
-0.07311912626028061,
-0.3514549732208252,
-0.06210901588201523,
-0.008787103928625584,
-0.036521825939416885,
-0.45731276273727417,
0.7768236398696899,
-0.08271589875221252,
-0.7091413140296936,
0.06352061778306961,
-0.07456973195075989,
0.5105178356170654,
-0.7545052766799927,
-0.055592652410268784,
-0.32366979122161865,
-0.013258518651127815,
0.028293414041399956,
-0.4513162076473236,
-0.2059832364320755,
-0.2006005197763443,
0.20445120334625244,
-0.25973036885261536,
0.9328387379646301,
-0.44391751289367676,
-0.1756368726491928,
0.5307220816612244,
0.8758887648582458,
-0.04799814149737358,
0.2377815842628479,
-0.6635158061981201,
-0.26789039373397827,
-0.3950560986995697,
-0.46324601769447327,
0.4238679111003876,
0.4559133052825928,
0.09141557663679123,
0.9524341225624084,
0.3201732933521271,
0.14038044214248657,
-0.019540267065167427,
-0.31120261549949646,
0.7345563769340515,
-0.7400178909301758,
-0.7298474311828613,
-0.9322881698608398,
0.2583842873573303,
-0.01816437765955925,
-0.42382270097732544,
0.6301100850105286,
0.3427550494670868,
0.5056318640708923,
0.053936202079057693,
0.9505171179771423,
0.07837613672018051,
-0.0941770076751709,
-0.45063528418540955,
0.5809701085090637,
-0.5667716264724731,
0.0799245685338974,
-0.109001025557518,
-1.1486998796463013,
0.20022688806056976,
0.33868879079818726,
-0.05100813880562782,
0.4484903812408447,
0.46510496735572815,
0.6653281450271606,
-0.048142556101083755,
-0.23010827600955963,
0.30569988489151,
0.3131377696990967,
0.5335596203804016,
0.5293647050857544,
1.1589385271072388,
0.08810964971780777,
0.39803969860076904,
0.4617130756378174,
-0.15165090560913086,
-0.1511569768190384,
-0.650068998336792,
-0.9171245098114014,
-0.1895906776189804,
-0.48226016759872437,
-0.23779748380184174,
0.2833254635334015,
1.2988674640655518,
0.7688915133476257,
-0.3228103816509247,
-0.32518112659454346,
-0.2794191539287567,
0.10510405898094177,
-0.372053325176239,
-0.1722842901945114,
-0.11568277329206467,
-0.378705769777298,
-0.561415433883667,
0.7018235921859741,
0.41536766290664673,
0.04105399549007416,
-0.8237162828445435,
-0.5325106382369995,
0.027927273884415627,
0.23840463161468506,
0.30953097343444824,
0.6192123293876648,
-0.5129082798957825,
-0.5720170736312866,
0.020433524623513222,
-0.07593069970607758,
0.07782454043626785,
0.47729143500328064,
-0.5738580822944641,
0.7051204442977905,
0.2362789809703827,
0.8341920971870422,
0.6247888207435608,
-0.24334849417209625,
0.4926164746284485,
-0.5555908679962158,
-0.2255389243364334,
0.3481132686138153,
0.27631333470344543,
0.14243414998054504,
-0.3314160406589508,
0.4784802794456482,
0.2324036806821823,
-0.7674488425254822,
-0.6331839561462402,
0.34613853693008423,
-0.8862380385398865,
-0.4046880900859833,
1.354775071144104,
0.05623350664973259,
-0.3113822042942047,
-0.030836526304483414,
-0.01480346079915762,
0.10233761370182037,
-0.5154759883880615,
0.8342209458351135,
0.6155061721801758,
-0.21865232288837433,
-0.2781558632850647,
-0.4781981110572815,
0.40687692165374756,
-0.0063476888462901115,
-1.3046879768371582,
0.12687699496746063,
0.35752275586128235,
0.4652133584022522,
0.13406765460968018,
0.44687125086784363,
0.48194071650505066,
0.22767852246761322,
0.1998363882303238,
0.22059395909309387,
-0.19253835082054138,
-0.5124764442443848,
-0.47390612959861755,
0.00474866759032011,
0.29600656032562256,
0.01805051788687706
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.04146v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.04146v1
|
Towards Understanding Task-agnostic Debiasing Through the Lenses of Intrinsic Bias and Forgetfulness
| 2024-06-06T15:11:11 | 2024-06-06T15:11:11 |
Guangliang Liu, Milad Afshari, Xitong Zhang, Zhiyu Xue, Avrajit Ghosh, Bidhan Bashyal, Rongrong Wang, Kristen Johnson
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
While task-agnostic debiasing provides notable generalizability and reduced
reliance on downstream data, its impact on language modeling ability and the
risk of relearning social biases from downstream task-specific data remain as
the two most significant challenges when debiasing Pretrained Language Models
(PLMs). The impact on language modeling ability can be alleviated given a
high-quality and long-contextualized debiasing corpus, but there remains a
deficiency in understanding the specifics of relearning biases. We empirically
ascertain that the effectiveness of task-agnostic debiasing hinges on the
quantitative bias level of both the task-specific data used for downstream
applications and the debiased model. We empirically show that the lower bound
of the bias level of the downstream fine-tuned model can be approximated by the
bias level of the debiased model, in most practical cases. To gain more
in-depth understanding about how the parameters of PLMs change during
fine-tuning due to the forgetting issue of PLMs, we propose a novel framework
which can Propagate Socially-fair Debiasing to Downstream Fine-tuning,
ProSocialTuning. Our proposed framework can push the fine-tuned model to
approach the bias lower bound during downstream fine-tuning, indicating that
the ineffectiveness of debiasing can be alleviated by overcoming the forgetting
issue through regularizing successfully debiased attention heads based on the
PLMs' bias levels from stages of pretraining and debiasing.
|
[
-0.32817476987838745,
-0.8204126954078674,
0.597628116607666,
-0.0651443749666214,
-0.1338687688112259,
-0.09377352148294449,
-0.2524580955505371,
-0.09448190033435822,
-0.08423744887113571,
0.4464009702205658,
-0.6962791681289673,
-0.30817747116088867,
-0.8794237375259399,
-0.18242402374744415,
-0.19736212491989136,
1.0150736570358276,
-0.013701074756681919,
0.029373440891504288,
-0.12441197782754898,
-0.16698874533176422,
-0.5248521566390991,
-0.5797292590141296,
-0.5616235136985779,
-0.37230440974235535,
0.3835243880748749,
0.3943219482898712,
0.6261814832687378,
0.4360286593437195,
0.21396730840206146,
0.21753360331058502,
-0.12538112699985504,
-0.1623048633337021,
-0.732016921043396,
0.06407518684864044,
-0.423660546541214,
-0.5767031311988831,
-0.3884446322917938,
0.3815423250198364,
0.47894570231437683,
1.021345853805542,
-0.14555346965789795,
0.5698793530464172,
0.6019873023033142,
0.7599449753761292,
-1.0047705173492432,
0.1894053816795349,
-0.9605036377906799,
-0.1346060335636139,
-0.07181738317012787,
0.0661253109574318,
-0.17958521842956543,
-0.17248161137104034,
0.15504705905914307,
-0.5054111480712891,
0.46525293588638306,
-0.23795916140079498,
0.7646605968475342,
0.8108002543449402,
-0.11450035125017166,
-0.06591582298278809,
-0.8793867230415344,
1.0396778583526611,
-0.46508705615997314,
0.30050504207611084,
0.8269590735435486,
0.13173168897628784,
0.1907104104757309,
-0.15932151675224304,
-0.4634634852409363,
-0.022125421091914177,
0.12515296041965485,
0.060181424021720886,
-0.0907973125576973,
0.21619632840156555,
0.2535949945449829,
0.4525752663612366,
-0.12326391041278839,
-0.13172593712806702,
-0.2261280119419098,
0.023273397237062454,
0.2490748018026352,
-0.031145965680480003,
0.010566258803009987,
0.049816280603408813,
-0.2202458679676056,
0.31126609444618225,
-0.7268626093864441,
0.045278601348400116,
0.44822371006011963,
0.21255287528038025,
-0.08708447217941284,
0.1148778647184372,
-0.37076762318611145,
0.4766661822795868,
0.45296305418014526,
0.1552516371011734,
0.2676764726638794,
-0.1598086953163147,
-0.2530616223812103,
-0.10728897899389267,
0.2967775762081146,
0.2575555443763733,
0.5810731053352356,
-0.35056349635124207,
-0.03426984325051308,
0.5259321331977844,
0.4488268196582794,
-0.4600200951099396,
-0.0008422965765930712,
0.39229512214660645,
-0.3868240416049957,
-0.10605582594871521,
-0.29388314485549927,
-0.30673906207084656,
-0.26654356718063354,
-0.7949044704437256,
0.3368529677391052,
-0.31315678358078003,
-0.28385066986083984,
0.17215347290039062,
0.07155191153287888,
-0.062361594289541245,
0.18375341594219208,
-0.9396470189094543,
0.27104753255844116,
0.730864405632019,
0.8150263428688049,
0.007500805892050266,
-0.37572968006134033,
-0.6190750002861023,
0.3565342128276825,
-0.11887490004301071,
0.4058047831058502,
-0.617931067943573,
-0.22779011726379395,
-0.2981341481208801,
-0.06572962552309036,
-0.18720842897891998,
-0.6141065955162048,
0.4556800425052643,
-0.44359099864959717,
-0.3920036852359772,
-0.6052950024604797,
-0.26825129985809326,
-0.22519001364707947,
0.3840419352054596,
-0.3824187219142914,
0.7007861733436584,
0.14979062974452972,
-0.7288080453872681,
0.7107067108154297,
-0.10670076310634613,
-0.14440317451953888,
-0.22730524837970734,
-0.07270292937755585,
-0.1770787239074707,
0.36618784070014954,
0.06306619942188263,
0.5277255177497864,
-0.3302166163921356,
0.8376349210739136,
-0.7410631775856018,
-0.4818476736545563,
-0.18522536754608154,
-0.4689085781574249,
0.8973842263221741,
0.09318744391202927,
-0.5332750082015991,
-0.047969769686460495,
-0.6064547300338745,
-0.26802435517311096,
-0.257455050945282,
0.004585586953908205,
-0.7806633710861206,
0.1838129758834839,
-0.34324055910110474,
0.3117503821849823,
0.17806191742420197,
-0.6401616930961609,
-0.22719888389110565,
-0.4177555441856384,
0.5451208353042603,
1.063988208770752,
-0.1765269786119461,
0.595487117767334,
-0.3431931436061859,
0.3663640320301056,
0.18989427387714386,
0.35222500562667847,
-0.0038160139229148626,
0.006903355475515127,
-0.8021939396858215,
-0.27004024386405945,
0.1645413190126419,
0.6707127690315247,
-0.4263959527015686,
0.27863809466362,
-0.08814527839422226,
-0.3914715647697449,
-0.6649088263511658,
0.36229750514030457,
0.661357581615448,
0.6835111379623413,
0.3603266775608063,
-0.34758418798446655,
-0.4908866584300995,
-1.00417160987854,
-0.4981444180011749,
0.0034700240939855576,
0.05588018149137497,
0.11695900559425354,
0.5899839997291565,
-0.38360610604286194,
0.8536159992218018,
-0.29553860425949097,
-0.5025565028190613,
-0.12178529798984528,
0.1508253961801529,
0.11267887055873871,
0.6698578000068665,
0.5141115188598633,
-0.5595230460166931,
-0.4175034761428833,
-0.3695472478866577,
-0.6591899394989014,
-0.23202566802501678,
-0.009371448308229446,
-0.12964501976966858,
0.267074316740036,
0.30701181292533875,
-0.5329303741455078,
0.4853818416595459,
0.3093279004096985,
-0.3735201954841614,
0.6275508403778076,
-0.17375987768173218,
-0.06149241700768471,
-0.5444239974021912,
0.20981021225452423,
0.0360783189535141,
-0.06197291985154152,
-0.5485154986381531,
-0.07703269273042679,
-0.15885233879089355,
0.2279181331396103,
-0.10354942828416824,
0.4623784124851227,
-0.4792436361312866,
0.1101122796535492,
-0.29885661602020264,
0.03248349949717522,
-0.07001107931137085,
0.5666500329971313,
-0.02005128376185894,
0.5263487696647644,
0.7703966498374939,
-0.7723461985588074,
-0.2057209461927414,
0.17501606047153473,
-0.22101421654224396,
0.49104899168014526,
-0.7867034077644348,
0.02936476096510887,
-0.5657825469970703,
0.029435887932777405,
-0.8243203163146973,
0.19968421757221222,
0.20905598998069763,
-0.3516197204589844,
0.2598939538002014,
-0.3011426031589508,
-0.16462919116020203,
-0.10399889200925827,
-0.29630938172340393,
0.43828117847442627,
0.4722191095352173,
-0.19811296463012695,
0.3714124262332916,
0.6181128621101379,
-0.38957852125167847,
-0.8500985503196716,
-0.5059817433357239,
-0.2338087558746338,
-0.25726667046546936,
-0.20130160450935364,
0.557547926902771,
0.10682637244462967,
-0.44458842277526855,
-0.17743657529354095,
-0.4873320758342743,
0.06368943303823471,
0.2844531536102295,
0.3741523325443268,
0.108565554022789,
0.3298947513103485,
-0.11013762652873993,
0.19520322978496552,
-0.4439687728881836,
0.2926517426967621,
-0.3771388828754425,
0.4144607484340668,
-0.05088525637984276,
-0.47085827589035034,
-0.18868491053581238,
0.29133495688438416,
0.4936046004295349,
-0.15655535459518433,
0.647009015083313,
0.4736121892929077,
-0.4894982874393463,
-0.19836698472499847,
-0.8453728556632996,
-0.30945277214050293,
-0.43807223439216614,
0.2644880712032318,
-0.2291879951953888,
-0.9576869010925293,
0.7608205676078796,
0.24413491785526276,
0.04334070533514023,
0.17586016654968262,
0.5483582615852356,
0.09582560509443283,
0.9036592841148376,
0.7606824636459351,
-0.2307741940021515,
0.41100504994392395,
-0.23814190924167633,
0.05078563839197159,
-0.8787304759025574,
0.020733261480927467,
-0.44156384468078613,
-0.424631804227829,
-0.1753794401884079,
-0.3689717948436737,
0.12908042967319489,
0.25106513500213623,
-0.6445518732070923,
-0.11827126145362854,
-0.38950079679489136,
0.3311684727668762,
0.7526037096977234,
0.3091047704219818,
0.22689040005207062,
-0.10389173030853271,
0.00008916210208553821,
-0.1882658749818802,
-0.5638216733932495,
-0.6521694660186768,
1.086243748664856,
0.33956608176231384,
0.6661545038223267,
-0.2866579294204712,
0.5154264569282532,
0.3238469958305359,
0.31688255071640015,
-0.4569352865219116,
0.3602990508079529,
-0.2576853036880493,
-0.862902045249939,
-0.15621121227741241,
-0.2774823307991028,
-0.5344813466072083,
0.2718658149242401,
0.13758178055286407,
-0.7797466516494751,
0.5801186561584473,
0.7319291234016418,
-0.6230158805847168,
0.1762247234582901,
-0.8076199293136597,
0.9914326071739197,
0.0364333838224411,
-0.7469629049301147,
-0.5611565113067627,
-0.6027055382728577,
0.29268592596054077,
-0.042288895696401596,
0.2996048033237457,
-0.37788859009742737,
0.08883237093687057,
0.6735796928405762,
-0.2372485101222992,
1.3072152137756348,
-0.779910683631897,
-0.12374743074178696,
0.3943948745727539,
0.13175085186958313,
0.34973713755607605,
0.24621059000492096,
-0.18449808657169342,
0.25271493196487427,
-0.06525599211454391,
-0.4918992221355438,
-0.3375404477119446,
0.7404524087905884,
-0.7090200781822205,
-0.8953814506530762,
-0.24520301818847656,
-0.5125958919525146,
-0.550165593624115,
0.15698127448558807,
0.03585969656705856,
0.2597217857837677,
-0.12670227885246277,
-0.0335436649620533,
0.8509715795516968,
-0.18488135933876038,
0.179360494017601,
0.569193959236145,
0.36691781878471375,
-0.09172281622886658,
0.8725963234901428,
0.3128948211669922,
0.33324190974235535,
0.14727969467639923,
-0.02475373074412346,
-0.1176360547542572,
-0.5588490962982178,
-0.1840263158082962,
0.1021684855222702,
-0.6100248694419861,
0.001637049252167344,
-0.7193906903266907,
0.2630290687084198,
-0.3663516938686371,
-0.166965514421463,
-0.4355204701423645,
-0.21131819486618042,
-0.301931232213974,
-0.1654455065727234,
0.1226767897605896,
0.3977024257183075,
-0.1117844432592392,
0.3037664294242859,
-0.705769419670105,
0.5148777961730957,
0.23861706256866455,
0.5484031438827515,
0.2956855595111847,
-0.6091097593307495,
-0.291365385055542,
0.44801244139671326,
-0.42288827896118164,
-0.7497231960296631,
0.26660919189453125,
0.23200933635234833,
0.8080796003341675,
0.45248863101005554,
0.1882692575454712,
0.7697352766990662,
-0.5339698195457458,
0.553723931312561,
-0.0325264073908329,
-1.2660338878631592,
0.5340129137039185,
-0.5200510621070862,
0.251796692609787,
0.9954590201377869,
0.3730201721191406,
-0.281307578086853,
-0.43964749574661255,
-0.4935590624809265,
-0.9939061999320984,
0.8467546701431274,
0.016335880383849144,
0.13580593466758728,
-0.14544521272182465,
0.5830971002578735,
0.3416060209274292,
0.5180222988128662,
-0.6749444603919983,
-0.29494184255599976,
-0.3435012698173523,
-0.1637141853570938,
-0.3202979862689972,
-0.5058184266090393,
0.09595438838005066,
-0.5812137126922607,
0.7397280931472778,
-0.02689344435930252,
0.0617784820497036,
0.20836327970027924,
-0.40530455112457275,
-0.06881353259086609,
0.25629815459251404,
0.23955096304416656,
0.647439181804657,
-0.25852447748184204,
0.12119107693433762,
0.2613213062286377,
-0.6283297538757324,
0.26483774185180664,
0.04041017219424248,
-0.42212969064712524,
-0.2532527446746826,
-0.01595897413790226,
0.8216228485107422,
0.2674654722213745,
-0.6312114000320435,
0.3339318633079529,
0.4593070447444916,
-0.11212451756000519,
-0.26810893416404724,
0.03225567191839218,
-0.0019435059512034059,
0.13320523500442505,
0.37413516640663147,
0.21949060261249542,
0.24817022681236267,
-0.5140189528465271,
0.15749751031398773,
0.7579520344734192,
-0.6912333369255066,
-0.616639256477356,
0.9512193202972412,
0.19852161407470703,
0.30251094698905945,
0.18153606355190277,
-0.2667263150215149,
-0.4523833990097046,
0.5774444937705994,
0.35101303458213806,
1.0757668018341064,
-0.4197132885456085,
0.12485332041978836,
0.3015327751636505,
0.3944470286369324,
-0.19777469336986542,
0.21763457357883453,
-0.23492000997066498,
-0.7576014995574951,
-0.7855338454246521,
-0.7516553997993469,
-0.15113145112991333,
0.0982719287276268,
-0.8228027820587158,
0.025372041389346123,
-0.39182353019714355,
-0.4113610088825226,
-0.21088267862796783,
-0.18484625220298767,
-0.6651084423065186,
0.3650406301021576,
0.13519351184368134,
0.5697211027145386,
-0.6963405609130859,
0.7056406140327454,
0.7394707202911377,
-0.17458762228488922,
-0.43842220306396484,
0.08164369314908981,
-0.03778286278247833,
-0.9276601672172546,
0.8743663430213928,
0.21088507771492004,
-0.4089117646217346,
0.0331839956343174,
-0.23230691254138947,
-0.8122483491897583,
0.8386597037315369,
0.6627629995346069,
-0.5590283274650574,
-0.2557034194469452,
0.09603263437747955,
0.3577396869659424,
-0.2222849279642105,
0.1255226880311966,
0.7325289845466614,
0.38775497674942017,
-0.3295202851295471,
-0.9475795030593872,
0.19558417797088623,
-0.19879136979579926,
0.009909936226904392,
0.08085505664348602,
-0.712533175945282,
0.9144628047943115,
-0.22445522248744965,
-0.14619538187980652,
-0.48805102705955505,
0.23959317803382874,
-0.028272012248635292,
0.3099253475666046,
0.6162027716636658,
0.6305727958679199,
0.38117536902427673,
-0.03689360246062279,
0.6104781627655029,
-0.4225756525993347,
0.3265307545661926,
1.1255792379379272,
-0.41294077038764954,
0.42400264739990234,
0.5768106579780579,
-0.11861379444599152,
0.17865979671478271,
0.2716140151023865,
0.46033987402915955,
0.6124472618103027,
0.2481277585029602,
-0.06664416939020157,
-0.41535231471061707,
-0.0051246145740151405,
-0.2679811716079712,
0.3331317901611328,
0.4914630055427551,
-0.3115171492099762,
-0.2876330316066742,
0.23489925265312195,
-0.020741786807775497,
0.1515912264585495,
-0.6717764139175415,
0.6807135343551636,
0.20730279386043549,
-0.7909942865371704,
0.8872320652008057,
-0.1653512865304947,
0.870244026184082,
-0.5012410283088684,
0.32728585600852966,
-0.016950177028775215,
0.558563768863678,
-0.0019210967002436519,
-0.436828076839447,
0.8452821373939514,
0.00830199383199215,
-0.5882793664932251,
-0.599852442741394,
0.8391744494438171,
-0.2491001933813095,
-0.16355577111244202,
0.38890397548675537,
0.6511453986167908,
-0.35885927081108093,
-0.5306881666183472,
-0.6442474126815796,
0.01767980493605137,
0.16540509462356567,
-0.3888968229293823,
0.43422931432724,
0.27020561695098877,
0.03791527450084686,
0.8518951535224915,
0.22684252262115479,
0.08050583302974701,
-0.26388972997665405,
0.014018029905855656,
0.7564628720283508,
-0.5947409868240356,
-0.6657275557518005,
-1.1454635858535767,
0.4141044318675995,
0.19109702110290527,
-0.2739942669868469,
0.7859705090522766,
0.179291769862175,
0.9891720414161682,
-0.22499488294124603,
1.0267471075057983,
0.03659556433558464,
0.7210940718650818,
-0.23754571378231049,
0.8134134411811829,
-0.47385677695274353,
0.2186797559261322,
-0.5542843341827393,
-0.6098809838294983,
-0.06177486479282379,
0.6690443754196167,
-0.8235333561897278,
0.1263318508863449,
0.3058428168296814,
0.518537163734436,
-0.05224659666419029,
-0.058817796409130096,
0.10457859933376312,
0.17674589157104492,
-0.07901065796613693,
0.6403924822807312,
0.49867570400238037,
-0.08705363422632217,
0.35948988795280457,
-0.3437093496322632,
-0.3785940110683441,
-0.0041034892201423645,
-0.6837388277053833,
-1.0363922119140625,
-0.6067088842391968,
-0.3846536874771118,
-0.0914006307721138,
0.378464013338089,
0.6514914631843567,
0.647016167640686,
-0.830746054649353,
-0.036728110164403915,
-0.4749714732170105,
0.12377439439296722,
-0.38237032294273376,
-0.21615207195281982,
0.10306354612112045,
-0.624148964881897,
-0.6992462277412415,
-0.262728214263916,
0.15728549659252167,
-0.065782830119133,
-0.3268224895000458,
-0.008348646573722363,
-0.09124085307121277,
0.007972221821546555,
0.6469525098800659,
0.0891314446926117,
-0.666718602180481,
-0.2107311338186264,
-0.024459339678287506,
0.19984333217144012,
-0.18330663442611694,
0.7794228196144104,
-1.0955408811569214,
0.14246425032615662,
0.16160553693771362,
0.4074317216873169,
0.16864000260829926,
0.08950919657945633,
0.7231881618499756,
-0.701539933681488,
0.37183859944343567,
0.19835913181304932,
0.2269565314054489,
0.1714361608028412,
-0.30332982540130615,
0.2470960170030594,
0.33336445689201355,
-0.5179080367088318,
-0.8995905518531799,
0.5926036238670349,
-0.6465273499488831,
-0.27725499868392944,
1.0756219625473022,
-0.2774218022823334,
-0.0884990245103836,
-0.4872104823589325,
-0.26960986852645874,
0.47991943359375,
-0.3187566101551056,
1.037296175956726,
0.7161624431610107,
0.2666664719581604,
0.004835408180952072,
-0.6153134703636169,
0.7038164138793945,
0.7949066758155823,
-0.29834264516830444,
0.6281055808067322,
0.5868162512779236,
0.4015096127986908,
0.011912173591554165,
0.7748501300811768,
0.03175139054656029,
0.06671687960624695,
-0.09334667772054672,
-0.11263331025838852,
-0.20255471765995026,
-0.19228273630142212,
-0.11111072450876236,
0.09144237637519836,
0.06172547861933708,
-0.10646295547485352
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.04145v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.04145v1
|
Every Answer Matters: Evaluating Commonsense with Probabilistic Measures
| 2024-06-06T15:10:27 | 2024-06-06T15:10:27 |
Qi Cheng, Michael Boratko, Pranay Kumar Yelugam, Tim O'Gorman, Nalini Singh, Andrew McCallum, Xiang Lorraine Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large language models have demonstrated impressive performance on commonsense
tasks; however, these tasks are often posed as multiple-choice questions,
allowing models to exploit systematic biases. Commonsense is also inherently
probabilistic with multiple correct answers. The purpose of "boiling water"
could be making tea and cooking, but it also could be killing germs. Existing
tasks do not capture the probabilistic nature of common sense. To this end, we
present commonsense frame completion (CFC), a new generative task that
evaluates common sense via multiple open-ended generations. We also propose a
method of probabilistic evaluation that strongly correlates with human
judgments. Humans drastically outperform strong language model baselines on our
dataset, indicating this approach is both a challenging and useful evaluation
of machine common sense.
|
[
-0.5409255623817444,
-0.682548463344574,
0.8016952872276306,
-0.012711972929537296,
-0.14428558945655823,
-0.47817981243133545,
-0.20697705447673798,
-0.11002842336893082,
-0.1322648972272873,
0.3993679881095886,
-0.2346518188714981,
-0.28813979029655457,
-0.7921119928359985,
0.1730274260044098,
-0.18092484772205353,
0.8458548784255981,
0.139321967959404,
-0.11103527247905731,
-0.4563169777393341,
-0.23400551080703735,
-0.15821237862110138,
-0.25473731756210327,
-0.5106393694877625,
-0.4152885377407074,
0.4846327006816864,
0.5208737254142761,
0.970791220664978,
0.254081666469574,
0.3016175925731659,
0.3569408357143402,
-0.18759536743164062,
0.3173384666442871,
-0.5004487633705139,
-0.2507193982601166,
-0.4389447867870331,
-0.2923952043056488,
-0.21358154714107513,
0.34471866488456726,
0.2654251158237457,
0.9845598340034485,
-0.11061851680278778,
0.16692593693733215,
0.16021350026130676,
0.5753886103630066,
-0.8730019927024841,
0.20514699816703796,
-0.5647907853126526,
-0.01508869044482708,
0.12716728448867798,
-0.008783054538071156,
-0.2993568480014801,
-0.3572135269641876,
-0.0026218793354928493,
-0.8757139444351196,
0.4480854570865631,
0.12069821357727051,
0.5802832245826721,
0.12859244644641876,
-0.6738957762718201,
-0.12083382159471512,
-0.2693076431751251,
1.1131914854049683,
-0.49849820137023926,
0.289975643157959,
0.473259299993515,
0.12343136966228485,
-0.3244931101799011,
-0.6762953400611877,
-1.0063042640686035,
-0.39074084162712097,
-0.21752887964248657,
0.36944645643234253,
-0.3587610721588135,
0.22455526888370514,
-0.011304842308163643,
0.13248224556446075,
-0.5438512563705444,
-0.3795316517353058,
-0.47090956568717957,
-0.03158636391162872,
0.7465658783912659,
0.13055655360221863,
0.29755643010139465,
-0.2715677320957184,
-0.49819016456604004,
-0.05498654022812843,
-0.14705967903137207,
-0.10978613048791885,
0.337406188249588,
0.14195416867733002,
-0.0005090048653073609,
0.3989720046520233,
-0.4147782027721405,
1.226509690284729,
-0.1740598827600479,
0.2568991482257843,
0.0037008291110396385,
-0.15792407095432281,
-0.12426766008138657,
-0.2698984742164612,
0.614626407623291,
0.6838010549545288,
0.479572594165802,
-0.021944567561149597,
-0.007903066463768482,
0.09999661892652512,
0.26803433895111084,
-0.3856874108314514,
-0.4066992700099945,
0.4399210512638092,
-0.40895015001296997,
-0.38434430956840515,
0.333585262298584,
-0.5110000967979431,
-0.2999890446662903,
-0.5160484910011292,
0.23412656784057617,
-0.1957886666059494,
-0.6126253604888916,
0.3939921259880066,
-0.6195389032363892,
0.18787622451782227,
0.41635066270828247,
-0.7596380710601807,
0.3731837868690491,
1.1645708084106445,
0.6464476585388184,
-0.15733765065670013,
-0.519792377948761,
-0.5576391220092773,
-0.10188250243663788,
-0.44214776158332825,
1.0322797298431396,
-0.7840918898582458,
-0.3360404074192047,
-0.3664417564868927,
-0.22194957733154297,
-0.30575570464134216,
-0.7571415901184082,
0.6160531044006348,
-0.43659666180610657,
0.08589817583560944,
-0.3347926437854767,
-0.6560785174369812,
-0.24539877474308014,
0.2409747987985611,
-0.7811126112937927,
0.6105059385299683,
0.056551478803157806,
-0.9370586276054382,
0.6418418288230896,
-0.8479952812194824,
-0.4491342604160309,
0.24361884593963623,
0.05730007588863373,
-0.08716244250535965,
0.3226051330566406,
0.02254735864698887,
0.7246354818344116,
-0.09934746474027634,
0.6738922595977783,
-0.5775872468948364,
-0.2683045268058777,
0.6938455700874329,
-0.9502724409103394,
0.8323810696601868,
0.4802228808403015,
0.19103464484214783,
-0.0709909126162529,
-0.5044770836830139,
0.03737537935376167,
-0.1667848378419876,
-0.3408544063568115,
-0.32623764872550964,
-0.0182128194719553,
0.2898239195346832,
-0.030500290915369987,
0.16554322838783264,
-0.5191150307655334,
-0.1030624657869339,
-0.2012995183467865,
0.3764975965023041,
0.7235187888145447,
0.17107751965522766,
0.41953667998313904,
-0.7493618130683899,
0.2805550694465637,
0.00786077044904232,
0.24256695806980133,
0.15241020917892456,
-0.9518423676490784,
-0.4447001516819,
-0.34202852845191956,
-0.10595005750656128,
0.635435938835144,
-0.4498579204082489,
0.4987868070602417,
-0.20654556155204773,
-0.5987359285354614,
-0.18735270202159882,
0.2117459625005722,
0.48012199997901917,
0.48901230096817017,
0.32639867067337036,
-0.43443459272384644,
-0.04848642274737358,
-0.7631547451019287,
-0.5623480081558228,
-0.14703743159770966,
-0.3172132968902588,
0.33113089203834534,
0.48616451025009155,
0.29302647709846497,
1.1533490419387817,
-0.8833467960357666,
-0.026670336723327637,
-0.35191020369529724,
0.4898764193058014,
0.3593369424343109,
0.46844005584716797,
0.22072091698646545,
-1.107284426689148,
-0.023625751957297325,
-0.06938517093658447,
-0.7121549844741821,
-0.029377233237028122,
-0.09746818244457245,
0.01715417206287384,
-0.07588446885347366,
0.32013678550720215,
-0.6574642062187195,
0.23964336514472961,
0.5387539267539978,
-0.5666483044624329,
0.5050358772277832,
-0.41584134101867676,
0.4141974151134491,
-0.957730233669281,
0.2260330468416214,
0.04750926047563553,
0.054838839918375015,
-0.7466227412223816,
0.2148953378200531,
-0.1043340414762497,
-0.29494720697402954,
-0.8311737179756165,
0.9258933663368225,
-0.13451696932315826,
-0.0390343964099884,
-0.0051496452651917934,
0.3032058775424957,
0.14774376153945923,
0.3048950433731079,
0.25567978620529175,
0.49233508110046387,
0.2900256812572479,
-0.6210041046142578,
0.49397772550582886,
0.0067843166179955006,
-0.490540087223053,
0.8251878619194031,
-0.570631742477417,
0.037275515496730804,
-0.45508429408073425,
0.1337457299232483,
-1.1881252527236938,
-0.5536724328994751,
0.11593253910541534,
-0.7375622391700745,
-0.10332722216844559,
0.1570368856191635,
-0.3869155943393707,
-0.3285571038722992,
0.22701595723628998,
0.19573046267032623,
0.009084991179406643,
-0.5428019762039185,
0.4961700141429901,
0.24674591422080994,
0.04215284436941147,
-0.573432445526123,
-0.6665021777153015,
-0.05886894837021828,
-0.16696511209011078,
-0.6388136744499207,
-0.18804092705249786,
0.0012187567772343755,
-0.6514536142349243,
0.1261223405599594,
-0.2381003051996231,
-0.4011230170726776,
0.5049267411231995,
0.05128132179379463,
0.06949175894260406,
0.011810852214694023,
0.16656339168548584,
-0.052471667528152466,
-0.35161498188972473,
-0.023375770077109337,
-0.05437171831727028,
0.34107092022895813,
-0.34395793080329895,
-0.6034241318702698,
-0.330972820520401,
0.5909566283226013,
0.4770956039428711,
-0.12696821987628937,
0.29760921001434326,
0.3606283664703369,
-0.37987253069877625,
-0.22985221445560455,
-0.5368671417236328,
-0.15105964243412018,
-0.4404597580432892,
0.5278989672660828,
-0.3484193980693817,
-1.006527304649353,
0.34282946586608887,
0.09740440547466278,
0.12545274198055267,
0.3831561207771301,
0.14929082989692688,
-0.3190837502479553,
0.6140414476394653,
0.013558691367506981,
0.20937077701091766,
-0.06444395333528519,
-0.01636490784585476,
0.42199769616127014,
-0.48605677485466003,
0.009373627603054047,
-0.4580190181732178,
-0.2952521741390228,
-0.4236066937446594,
-0.6504305005073547,
0.36505192518234253,
0.2569083869457245,
-0.27689415216445923,
0.3818020224571228,
-0.6585946083068848,
0.849320113658905,
0.7193995118141174,
0.2609511613845825,
0.48972025513648987,
-0.4322989881038666,
0.1497800499200821,
0.32312247157096863,
-0.6502231359481812,
-0.7418156266212463,
1.0947370529174805,
-0.03095015324652195,
0.28770798444747925,
0.18684501945972443,
0.942594587802887,
0.34670498967170715,
0.7475634217262268,
-0.7158105969429016,
0.6779677271842957,
-0.46300604939460754,
-0.9341095089912415,
-0.5425950884819031,
-0.48043015599250793,
-1.0955463647842407,
0.38276389241218567,
-0.2378603219985962,
-0.5377122759819031,
0.053661663085222244,
0.2711402177810669,
-0.5965742468833923,
0.3707009255886078,
-0.9047752618789673,
1.0344164371490479,
-0.16104941070079803,
-0.4110378921031952,
-0.4792363941669464,
-0.3467888832092285,
0.6911041140556335,
0.0801842138171196,
0.3899543881416321,
-0.3391985297203064,
-0.026697935536503792,
0.7383708357810974,
-0.13184872269630432,
0.8162988424301147,
-0.2849779725074768,
0.19324621558189392,
0.4795251190662384,
-0.031685587018728256,
-0.0697544738650322,
0.33932191133499146,
-0.1360558569431305,
0.21227693557739258,
0.02634667046368122,
-0.6161113977432251,
-0.9033525586128235,
0.565375804901123,
-0.6077589988708496,
-0.7250909209251404,
-0.5519958734512329,
-0.29989179968833923,
-0.09131939709186554,
-0.0042097666300833225,
0.20840227603912354,
0.23867224156856537,
-0.5420536994934082,
0.052212949842214584,
0.6932448744773865,
-0.30885154008865356,
0.4994494915008545,
0.3017553985118866,
0.2297227829694748,
-0.4111900329589844,
0.7509673833847046,
0.00658088643103838,
0.3524026870727539,
0.5284825563430786,
0.4724443256855011,
-0.24195025861263275,
-0.2120412141084671,
-0.4389796555042267,
-0.16086052358150482,
-0.8114884495735168,
-0.2820681035518646,
-0.5996096730232239,
0.0695561096072197,
-0.3278122842311859,
-0.7295169234275818,
-0.11424003541469574,
-0.27964842319488525,
-0.3972650170326233,
-0.2399187982082367,
0.3746222257614136,
0.5253700017929077,
-0.380010724067688,
0.18293511867523193,
-0.8939787149429321,
0.6114140152931213,
1.0884673595428467,
0.28591784834861755,
0.03919630125164986,
-0.13104777038097382,
0.3445781171321869,
-0.16544286906719208,
-0.31037452816963196,
-0.8841419219970703,
0.21168296039104462,
0.17613013088703156,
0.7427009344100952,
0.7020519375801086,
0.41942405700683594,
0.44706496596336365,
-0.04343579337000847,
0.9326788783073425,
0.612357497215271,
-0.9399624466896057,
0.42449620366096497,
-0.37388524413108826,
0.34229546785354614,
0.682590126991272,
0.32707127928733826,
-0.5991941690444946,
-0.2732335925102234,
-0.9202783703804016,
-0.7133969068527222,
0.19686035811901093,
-0.06088250130414963,
0.4205804765224457,
-0.6494715809822083,
-0.24472670257091522,
-0.06356720626354218,
-0.005376863293349743,
-0.29447415471076965,
0.16496486961841583,
-0.21412913501262665,
0.005262832157313824,
-0.007927597500383854,
-0.05901244282722473,
-0.24941226840019226,
-0.13208816945552826,
0.3519769012928009,
-0.13912537693977356,
0.08944457769393921,
0.20681041479110718,
0.061791662126779556,
0.260096937417984,
0.7702032327651978,
0.6428918838500977,
0.6637051701545715,
-0.09488577395677567,
0.19604672491550446,
0.42174410820007324,
-0.22950075566768646,
-0.0585162490606308,
-0.0032521409448236227,
-0.0224680844694376,
-0.0015988743398338556,
0.5929555892944336,
0.6053306460380554,
0.5666223168373108,
-0.7242961525917053,
0.771181583404541,
0.0546501986682415,
-0.37260425090789795,
-0.33924511075019836,
0.3554985523223877,
0.27515918016433716,
-0.041989024728536606,
0.4817422926425934,
0.48930856585502625,
0.24965810775756836,
-0.6292697787284851,
0.6777368187904358,
0.23229870200157166,
-0.08961980044841766,
0.006317204795777798,
0.5125961899757385,
0.2932394742965698,
-0.1704365611076355,
0.7297608852386475,
-0.37641003727912903,
-0.516070544719696,
0.7307397723197937,
0.20832513272762299,
0.7286502718925476,
-0.21191240847110748,
0.42301806807518005,
0.6288247108459473,
-0.009324103593826294,
-0.29746073484420776,
0.349950909614563,
-0.4839235246181488,
-1.1581252813339233,
-0.4671132564544678,
-0.8240780830383301,
-0.46582838892936707,
-0.2115243673324585,
-0.6478386521339417,
0.10464837402105331,
-0.4822738766670227,
-0.14510515332221985,
-0.13170573115348816,
-0.043847598135471344,
-0.7457200884819031,
0.4738120138645172,
0.09201871603727341,
0.9733787775039673,
-1.3717424869537354,
0.5672932267189026,
0.3711985647678375,
-0.33991190791130066,
-0.719556450843811,
-0.11190633475780487,
0.021552948281168938,
-0.7182048559188843,
0.722592830657959,
0.11309678852558136,
-0.04614667221903801,
-0.23423321545124054,
-0.7590990662574768,
-0.698665201663971,
0.6802016496658325,
0.01699104905128479,
-0.468390554189682,
0.23313479125499725,
-0.01670430600643158,
0.23254172503948212,
-0.042392145842313766,
0.2995679974555969,
0.8347344398498535,
0.9398351907730103,
0.25924181938171387,
-0.9566977024078369,
-0.19315983355045319,
-0.22588062286376953,
-0.011417153291404247,
0.0076483371667563915,
-0.49996641278266907,
0.5047536492347717,
-0.6708609461784363,
-0.303961843252182,
-0.1555442363023758,
0.8170821070671082,
0.7598328590393066,
0.7564781904220581,
0.6862300038337708,
0.9661852121353149,
0.8981180787086487,
-0.14857301115989685,
0.8611746430397034,
-0.12534932792186737,
0.2775108814239502,
1.3131238222122192,
-0.20378869771957397,
1.0883322954177856,
0.4882790148258209,
-0.374500036239624,
-0.14691627025604248,
0.4365967810153961,
0.1110696792602539,
0.41325703263282776,
0.7217805981636047,
-0.6132932901382446,
-0.639710009098053,
-0.0252523273229599,
0.03353762999176979,
0.7318019866943359,
0.40972527861595154,
-0.03899708762764931,
-0.3749975264072418,
-0.04087063670158386,
0.23724761605262756,
0.5197240114212036,
-0.26993775367736816,
0.7861105799674988,
0.2169870138168335,
-1.059975504875183,
0.3840062916278839,
-0.15625618398189545,
0.7792354226112366,
-0.3502247929573059,
-0.02092091180384159,
-0.3267701268196106,
-0.03739148750901222,
-0.2383892685174942,
-1.2535922527313232,
0.6967284083366394,
-0.009475811384618282,
-0.0369228832423687,
-0.2937372326850891,
0.4254624843597412,
-0.2298271358013153,
-0.5609334707260132,
0.06384508311748505,
0.37328872084617615,
0.3537862300872803,
-0.1858900934457779,
-0.43393653631210327,
-0.21038204431533813,
-0.11561200022697449,
-0.2808259427547455,
0.07010488212108612,
0.45448461174964905,
0.09502234309911728,
0.5249239206314087,
0.8360298871994019,
0.09019912779331207,
-0.008399355225265026,
-0.03412394970655441,
0.4686516523361206,
-0.3769552707672119,
-0.1348751038312912,
-0.4802282452583313,
0.5902762413024902,
-0.23601870238780975,
-0.6368976831436157,
0.35554662346839905,
0.5245181918144226,
1.273439884185791,
-0.15726949274539948,
0.9798282384872437,
-0.12283588200807571,
0.2245810478925705,
-0.35022449493408203,
0.8513779640197754,
-0.4262256324291229,
-0.19815538823604584,
-0.2182229459285736,
-0.6767473816871643,
-0.4650058448314667,
0.7630452513694763,
-0.4998539686203003,
-0.09864897280931473,
0.5982778668403625,
0.8822798728942871,
-0.13592901825904846,
0.3940469026565552,
0.7763243913650513,
-0.33690565824508667,
-0.0629412904381752,
0.7675355672836304,
0.6961491703987122,
-0.10313975065946579,
0.3444478213787079,
0.08514456450939178,
-0.5014963746070862,
0.16035139560699463,
-0.8993434906005859,
-0.451895147562027,
-0.838555634021759,
-0.3414253294467926,
-0.0712219849228859,
0.038371141999959946,
0.8494415283203125,
0.6345469355583191,
-0.9398803114891052,
-0.042016442865133286,
-0.10677976161241531,
0.10717201977968216,
-0.5540067553520203,
-0.30886754393577576,
0.34086260199546814,
-0.5497581958770752,
-0.6683796644210815,
0.24665896594524384,
0.11182976514101028,
-0.3812732398509979,
0.06619246304035187,
-0.07349187135696411,
-0.03641732037067413,
0.12165923416614532,
0.5366004705429077,
0.18959377706050873,
-0.8270005583763123,
-0.36803489923477173,
-0.19458675384521484,
0.14984340965747833,
-0.23472827672958374,
0.8434634804725647,
-0.6185666918754578,
0.5114454627037048,
0.8133184313774109,
0.4719334840774536,
0.07227877527475357,
0.1228630468249321,
0.5104516744613647,
-0.43967604637145996,
-0.06107885763049126,
0.29034045338630676,
0.4026152491569519,
0.3927815854549408,
-0.26043349504470825,
0.38824379444122314,
0.2693691551685333,
-0.4929739534854889,
-0.332121342420578,
0.3868711590766907,
-1.0481914281845093,
-0.6375008821487427,
1.1614323854446411,
-0.3250211179256439,
-0.21148040890693665,
-0.43058499693870544,
0.11037007719278336,
0.2787151038646698,
-0.46703487634658813,
0.7964469790458679,
0.769776463508606,
-0.09385760128498077,
-0.24863557517528534,
-0.5478464365005493,
0.2544756829738617,
0.2915942370891571,
-0.5702599883079529,
0.3781052827835083,
0.6695256233215332,
0.4486614763736725,
0.1857200264930725,
0.8639295101165771,
0.1445521116256714,
0.3956843316555023,
0.09342315047979355,
-0.1292199343442917,
0.006923533044755459,
-0.20321141183376312,
-0.19868415594100952,
0.552436351776123,
-0.09061594307422638,
-0.16603820025920868
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.04143v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.04143v1
|
Do Language Models Understand Morality? Towards a Robust Detection of Moral Content
| 2024-06-06T15:08:16 | 2024-06-06T15:08:16 |
Luana Bulla, Aldo Gangemi, Misael Mongiovì
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
The task of detecting moral values in text has significant implications in
various fields, including natural language processing, social sciences, and
ethical decision-making. Previously proposed supervised models often suffer
from overfitting, leading to hyper-specialized moral classifiers that struggle
to perform well on data from different domains. To address this issue, we
introduce novel systems that leverage abstract concepts and common-sense
knowledge acquired from Large Language Models and Natural Language Inference
models during previous stages of training on multiple data sources. By doing
so, we aim to develop versatile and robust methods for detecting moral values
in real-world scenarios. Our approach uses the GPT 3.5 model as a zero-shot
ready-made unsupervised multi-label classifier for moral values detection,
eliminating the need for explicit training on labeled data. We compare it with
a smaller NLI-based zero-shot model. The results show that the NLI approach
achieves competitive results compared to the Davinci model. Furthermore, we
conduct an in-depth investigation of the performance of supervised systems in
the context of cross-domain multi-label moral value detection. This involves
training supervised models on different domains to explore their effectiveness
in handling data from different sources and comparing their performance with
the unsupervised methods. Our contributions encompass a thorough analysis of
both supervised and unsupervised methodologies for cross-domain value
detection. We introduce the Davinci model as a state-of-the-art zero-shot
unsupervised moral values classifier, pushing the boundaries of moral value
detection without the need for explicit training on labeled data. Additionally,
we perform a comparative evaluation of our approach with the supervised models,
shedding light on their respective strengths and weaknesses.
|
[
-0.3239944279193878,
-0.6360735297203064,
0.8697758316993713,
-0.3672355115413666,
-0.4750445783138275,
-0.16744720935821533,
0.09491746127605438,
-0.5105735659599304,
-0.4514797031879425,
0.5069448351860046,
-0.33200350403785706,
-0.5057581067085266,
-0.8233152627944946,
-0.20632749795913696,
-0.07330299913883209,
1.2399119138717651,
0.4167097210884094,
0.08335574716329575,
-0.13112077116966248,
-0.5208173394203186,
0.03317243233323097,
-0.8703891038894653,
-0.5790188908576965,
-0.32704252004623413,
0.34509479999542236,
0.04427216202020645,
0.731637179851532,
0.6404976844787598,
0.21704520285129547,
0.243378683924675,
-0.27594032883644104,
-0.006032243836671114,
-0.5040740370750427,
-0.13672764599323273,
-0.4073900282382965,
-0.2428344190120697,
-0.4544855058193207,
0.5512396097183228,
0.2328922301530838,
0.33898869156837463,
0.09573909640312195,
0.2022465020418167,
-0.14715561270713806,
0.49030444025993347,
-0.88112872838974,
0.3219779133796692,
-0.5419528484344482,
0.09324264526367188,
0.003988903481513262,
-0.26752570271492004,
-0.6208425760269165,
-0.5975212454795837,
0.024113649502396584,
-0.483733206987381,
0.1267194300889969,
-0.28299036622047424,
0.9167850613594055,
0.09326103329658508,
-0.6674442887306213,
-0.5139912962913513,
-0.4667738080024719,
1.688266634941101,
-0.5969805717468262,
0.38044390082359314,
0.5368660688400269,
-0.05369163677096367,
0.19971831142902374,
-0.3447696566581726,
-0.6733896136283875,
-0.044658638536930084,
-0.031116001307964325,
0.22194592654705048,
-0.25308099389076233,
-0.19481252133846283,
0.08434043079614639,
0.3634626865386963,
-0.20467832684516907,
0.015085474587976933,
-0.049129653722047806,
0.04599238559603691,
0.648013710975647,
-0.021283959969878197,
0.20031365752220154,
-0.3996153175830841,
-0.24022744596004486,
-0.33898845314979553,
-0.4138588607311249,
0.5568129420280457,
0.6003654599189758,
0.16670556366443634,
0.04807019606232643,
0.3295472264289856,
0.35815760493278503,
0.6800631284713745,
0.06719227135181427,
-0.19094085693359375,
0.05731145292520523,
-0.5437518358230591,
-0.28445082902908325,
-0.023780610412359238,
0.7621474862098694,
0.4637930393218994,
1.0525740385055542,
0.2996906638145447,
-0.15384113788604736,
0.35647469758987427,
0.3468153476715088,
-0.8844771981239319,
-0.12134803086519241,
0.019543813541531563,
-0.6282844543457031,
-0.8692120909690857,
-0.184068962931633,
-0.3425022065639496,
-0.35316139459609985,
-0.32355180382728577,
-0.011219250038266182,
-0.5098897814750671,
-0.21433798968791962,
0.678621768951416,
-0.05818154662847519,
0.44377732276916504,
0.3897223174571991,
-0.8958278894424438,
-0.04764155298471451,
0.7178921699523926,
0.7408416867256165,
0.046769898384809494,
0.14670643210411072,
-0.8625975847244263,
0.32296228408813477,
-0.1719464659690857,
0.6476671099662781,
-0.8533145189285278,
-0.28475648164749146,
-0.14612312614917755,
0.12554655969142914,
0.2828516364097595,
-0.005011991132050753,
0.9820840358734131,
-0.562290608882904,
0.08297549933195114,
-0.1347421109676361,
-0.752226710319519,
-0.33701449632644653,
0.3386572003364563,
-0.6392357349395752,
0.5312822461128235,
-0.1594001054763794,
-0.8575617671012878,
0.6147570013999939,
-0.5739212036132812,
-0.20205029845237732,
0.03124782256782055,
-0.030222201719880104,
-0.6477871537208557,
0.1455857902765274,
0.299267053604126,
0.867504894733429,
-0.22369730472564697,
0.7258381843566895,
-0.6304444074630737,
-0.4490034282207489,
0.3137555420398712,
-0.9367703199386597,
1.1702771186828613,
0.05552822723984718,
-0.011901606805622578,
-0.23762179911136627,
-0.626882016658783,
0.2344905436038971,
0.293413370847702,
-0.10280194133520126,
-0.7742485404014587,
0.07947789132595062,
0.16504622995853424,
0.15048335492610931,
-0.019621914252638817,
-0.8360552787780762,
0.06623546034097672,
-0.11358790099620819,
0.34137067198753357,
0.8233959078788757,
-0.1814463585615158,
0.31527647376060486,
-0.20894038677215576,
0.23650550842285156,
0.010355303063988686,
0.41118887066841125,
0.020914455875754356,
-0.6159842610359192,
-0.4950576722621918,
-0.3650049865245819,
-0.155020073056221,
0.6540451049804688,
-0.480930358171463,
0.4744970202445984,
0.107281394302845,
-0.17935827374458313,
-0.38914042711257935,
-0.22318151593208313,
0.4527754485607147,
0.39097458124160767,
0.6005879640579224,
-0.07466013729572296,
0.03761761263012886,
-0.7530816793441772,
-0.5938042998313904,
-0.4129783809185028,
-0.19647954404354095,
0.3303245007991791,
0.7261443734169006,
-0.03133302181959152,
0.8236826062202454,
-0.514478325843811,
-0.09757176786661148,
0.028448661789298058,
0.4329383671283722,
0.3378487527370453,
0.3512582778930664,
0.6632385849952698,
-1.1978332996368408,
-0.19058819115161896,
0.20251914858818054,
-0.982976496219635,
-0.033540841192007065,
0.1112239882349968,
0.2072199136018753,
-0.06584461778402328,
0.07699809223413467,
0.00569146079942584,
0.7383465766906738,
0.3677443265914917,
-0.4908328950405121,
0.39057135581970215,
0.015096687711775303,
0.40905922651290894,
-0.7915080785751343,
-0.15399287641048431,
0.23553553223609924,
-0.44098374247550964,
-0.6535849571228027,
-0.28693705797195435,
0.1996457427740097,
0.3221556842327118,
-0.732637882232666,
0.4501313865184784,
-0.03998132050037384,
0.08469471335411072,
-0.19457675516605377,
-0.01152006071060896,
0.42884162068367004,
0.42561596632003784,
0.39017176628112793,
0.7126705050468445,
0.3723551630973816,
-0.5066310167312622,
0.5040889978408813,
0.38101980090141296,
-0.0946885496377945,
1.1654599905014038,
-0.697141706943512,
-0.009096088819205761,
-0.30476418137550354,
0.10898198187351227,
-0.42019835114479065,
0.1374359428882599,
0.26648885011672974,
-0.5160356760025024,
-0.1435374766588211,
-0.8687407374382019,
-0.28947511315345764,
0.019701899960637093,
-0.3943547010421753,
0.6454254388809204,
0.31463122367858887,
-0.5908051133155823,
0.44243326783180237,
0.6079759001731873,
-0.1331331580877304,
-0.8056013584136963,
-0.7037389278411865,
-0.08265524357557297,
-0.2593386173248291,
-0.4546410143375397,
-0.003488545771688223,
0.05803654342889786,
-0.28843727707862854,
0.1362394392490387,
0.06164006143808365,
-0.5466696619987488,
-0.019478121772408485,
0.16011449694633484,
0.3642752170562744,
-0.1041482537984848,
0.3387998938560486,
0.15911690890789032,
-0.35206687450408936,
0.04219672083854675,
-0.5915951132774353,
0.03844045102596283,
-0.9403364658355713,
-0.4927085340023041,
-0.37784484028816223,
0.46924424171447754,
0.6323219537734985,
-0.5854612588882446,
0.7477198243141174,
0.609623372554779,
-0.23829501867294312,
-0.013301048427820206,
-0.4549763798713684,
0.09517590701580048,
-0.45659977197647095,
-0.11280316859483719,
-0.05034761503338814,
-0.9873780012130737,
0.274893194437027,
0.14102821052074432,
-0.06078117713332176,
0.2515046000480652,
0.35334789752960205,
-0.06683479249477386,
1.0231794118881226,
0.7182410955429077,
0.35373276472091675,
0.36626094579696655,
-0.31329864263534546,
0.4615227282047272,
-0.504714846611023,
0.02474687434732914,
-0.3587168753147125,
0.2192196249961853,
-0.7734119296073914,
-0.43694859743118286,
0.17153680324554443,
0.209463432431221,
-0.4591978192329407,
0.14345121383666992,
-0.7242312431335449,
0.8444610238075256,
0.44437241554260254,
-0.12143898010253906,
0.7387795448303223,
-0.11536331474781036,
0.03379037231206894,
0.02705654874444008,
-0.28454992175102234,
-1.0824329853057861,
0.9993835091590881,
0.20809049904346466,
0.6931995153427124,
0.0035520202945917845,
0.4568362832069397,
0.5068643093109131,
0.34589600563049316,
-1.0630992650985718,
0.23512019217014313,
-0.6040522456169128,
-0.5373647809028625,
-0.2596047520637512,
-0.41461363434791565,
-0.7614303827285767,
0.2966654896736145,
-0.013721001334488392,
-0.6296172738075256,
0.5892688632011414,
-0.15174278616905212,
-0.3772788345813751,
0.8164103031158447,
-0.5142079591751099,
0.8122097253799438,
-0.41729167103767395,
-0.6226163506507874,
-0.13678142428398132,
-0.48480963706970215,
0.2339836210012436,
-0.2255527675151825,
0.14903321862220764,
-0.3237805664539337,
0.2470538467168808,
0.45633912086486816,
0.006638008635491133,
0.74214768409729,
-0.05757332965731621,
-0.38116422295570374,
0.3409562408924103,
-0.04540768265724182,
0.2939300835132599,
0.46659567952156067,
-0.41689440608024597,
0.43350037932395935,
0.3968815505504608,
-0.6046907901763916,
-0.4217369258403778,
0.637076199054718,
-0.4310758411884308,
-0.18978865444660187,
-0.7485371232032776,
-0.6049023270606995,
-0.14206811785697937,
0.17669418454170227,
0.027307452633976936,
0.4689723253250122,
-0.33340340852737427,
0.2806306481361389,
0.8243298530578613,
-0.7188969254493713,
0.48201462626457214,
0.5727218389511108,
0.1913416087627411,
-0.2361675202846527,
0.8017472624778748,
-0.2471059262752533,
0.35062065720558167,
0.09911879152059555,
0.2758790850639343,
-0.4300759434700012,
-0.1713000237941742,
-0.6224513649940491,
0.19981352984905243,
-0.816769003868103,
-0.10446948558092117,
-0.6805880665779114,
-0.09920687973499298,
-0.04170490801334381,
-0.5760408639907837,
-0.5382929444313049,
-0.11629269272089005,
-0.251941442489624,
-0.16734986007213593,
0.648505687713623,
0.910108208656311,
-0.055076714605093,
0.16112160682678223,
-1.0619285106658936,
0.4634188413619995,
0.38705188035964966,
0.7007458806037903,
-0.27088695764541626,
-0.22020070254802704,
0.1278645396232605,
0.4644260108470917,
-0.18402789533138275,
-0.6419302821159363,
0.512568473815918,
-0.11194716393947601,
0.23147226870059967,
0.4521636962890625,
0.24891869723796844,
0.31595736742019653,
-0.2286476045846939,
0.46632659435272217,
0.06036978214979172,
-1.218866229057312,
0.5858170986175537,
-0.4442698061466217,
-0.07607924193143845,
0.573581874370575,
0.6146359443664551,
-0.42233791947364807,
-0.3331648111343384,
-0.5130844116210938,
-0.3401150405406952,
0.7078197598457336,
0.4560754597187042,
0.1809571236371994,
-0.07642389088869095,
0.3812491297721863,
0.12139583379030228,
0.1798512041568756,
-1.031062364578247,
0.030476870015263557,
-0.5014415383338928,
-0.22185881435871124,
0.0893656462430954,
-0.038729362189769745,
-0.004338013008236885,
-0.24296970665454865,
0.4819801151752472,
-0.3764335513114929,
0.030910298228263855,
0.13935686647891998,
-0.04255629703402519,
0.08805105090141296,
0.5201067924499512,
0.10454662889242172,
0.5117636322975159,
-0.46467217803001404,
-0.114956796169281,
-0.06987838447093964,
-0.43705570697784424,
0.5140404105186462,
-0.048670146614313126,
-0.1966864913702011,
-0.24542120099067688,
0.3153528869152069,
0.7188447117805481,
-0.2464345395565033,
-0.33008450269699097,
1.0180978775024414,
-0.38561758399009705,
0.007105651311576366,
-0.18175865709781647,
-0.12379056215286255,
-0.16555069386959076,
0.2518671452999115,
0.019756069406867027,
0.02990572899580002,
0.22201457619667053,
-0.6582508087158203,
0.5061428546905518,
0.5183277726173401,
-0.6747957468032837,
-0.2113782912492752,
0.4746198356151581,
0.0481213741004467,
0.01393108256161213,
0.46183374524116516,
-0.3936125636100769,
-0.5009403824806213,
0.7007558941841125,
0.2770005762577057,
0.7052313685417175,
-0.13918733596801758,
0.6606109738349915,
0.07077319920063019,
0.11907065659761429,
-0.10201571136713028,
0.21480247378349304,
-0.1487455815076828,
-1.0746047496795654,
-0.790657639503479,
-0.7833908796310425,
-0.4326810836791992,
0.0637819841504097,
-1.01649010181427,
0.10485871881246567,
-0.2679712176322937,
-0.12572702765464783,
0.0775088295340538,
-0.1870926171541214,
-0.5111182928085327,
0.37244942784309387,
0.11165391653776169,
0.1301470249891281,
-0.933006763458252,
0.9583725929260254,
0.32758641242980957,
-0.363726407289505,
-0.4439902901649475,
-0.028029145672917366,
0.02285655215382576,
-0.7162342071533203,
0.6254076957702637,
0.33034688234329224,
-0.8013239502906799,
-0.01665128581225872,
-0.7125232815742493,
-0.33120375871658325,
0.6181482076644897,
0.27490338683128357,
-0.27811115980148315,
0.24300454556941986,
0.11724146455526352,
0.5945308804512024,
-0.2984602451324463,
0.2206220179796219,
0.5495524406433105,
0.6102729439735413,
0.06709077954292297,
-0.45077332854270935,
-0.20497602224349976,
-0.2668028771877289,
-0.3643651306629181,
0.302766352891922,
-0.27601900696754456,
0.8165943026542664,
-0.14306625723838806,
-0.17301549017429352,
-0.2308008372783661,
0.15320397913455963,
0.3122778832912445,
0.5788914561271667,
0.5913801193237305,
0.41050606966018677,
0.7026091814041138,
-0.0493483804166317,
1.216805100440979,
-0.08016642928123474,
0.7388365268707275,
0.7527866363525391,
-0.30636146664619446,
0.44124752283096313,
0.22467045485973358,
0.08269543945789337,
0.3469947278499603,
0.2635635435581207,
-0.3438948690891266,
0.3708025813102722,
-0.019394829869270325,
-0.27721527218818665,
-0.6933788061141968,
-0.6008695363998413,
-0.066584512591362,
0.6361442804336548,
0.43270617723464966,
-0.21134637296199799,
-0.14031316339969635,
0.09510190784931183,
-0.075444296002388,
0.17270061373710632,
-0.22719085216522217,
0.613827645778656,
0.24676910042762756,
-0.3360414206981659,
0.6728600859642029,
-0.0704999640583992,
0.6756544709205627,
-0.4190104603767395,
-0.2091073840856552,
0.10789342224597931,
0.34418830275535583,
0.03995949402451515,
-1.3360471725463867,
0.4584255516529083,
0.4000423550605774,
-0.10488168150186539,
-0.7027793526649475,
0.7432543039321899,
-0.2082652598619461,
-0.695068895816803,
0.7145854234695435,
0.5039456486701965,
-0.08914896845817566,
-0.190978541970253,
-0.6366138458251953,
-0.2951709032058716,
-0.09679876267910004,
-0.11824960261583328,
-0.04600664973258972,
0.7101339101791382,
-0.27652508020401,
0.7362588047981262,
0.9315165877342224,
-0.2504311203956604,
-0.33850932121276855,
0.21677257120609283,
0.6547608375549316,
-0.8192939162254333,
-0.41266536712646484,
-0.9678016901016235,
0.3520820140838623,
-0.1612369865179062,
-0.24780888855457306,
0.5091137886047363,
0.18908138573169708,
1.0136981010437012,
0.06801468133926392,
0.7115153670310974,
0.26887035369873047,
0.1916579306125641,
-0.4835660755634308,
0.7844235897064209,
-0.6682495474815369,
0.05432058498263359,
-0.47101256251335144,
-0.5011056065559387,
-0.5714568495750427,
0.9156572222709656,
-0.4575751721858978,
0.09704374521970749,
0.404933363199234,
0.42110392451286316,
-0.3736719787120819,
0.34528639912605286,
0.4818563461303711,
-0.025919362902641296,
0.5148144364356995,
0.6400842070579529,
1.1513984203338623,
-0.32760390639305115,
0.51804518699646,
-0.02789289504289627,
-0.23449833691120148,
0.23581922054290771,
-1.1093758344650269,
-0.958884596824646,
-0.310046523809433,
-0.06726885586977005,
-0.011541482992470264,
0.10386260598897934,
0.3316039741039276,
0.7545169591903687,
-1.027877926826477,
0.03748302534222603,
-0.17732784152030945,
0.21204936504364014,
-0.07061080634593964,
-0.22022025287151337,
0.3223726451396942,
0.09645258635282516,
-0.7900055646896362,
0.336912602186203,
0.6255417466163635,
0.10565916448831558,
0.09936083108186722,
0.056726597249507904,
-0.4941251277923584,
0.4603874385356903,
0.786063015460968,
-0.19901345670223236,
-0.680819571018219,
-0.4574970602989197,
-0.11610465496778488,
-0.04328189045190811,
0.1097155213356018,
0.7561764717102051,
-0.6312868595123291,
0.3044455647468567,
0.34001868963241577,
0.5058426856994629,
0.343529611825943,
0.1779167503118515,
0.5279969573020935,
-0.42334067821502686,
0.05515332892537117,
0.49026158452033997,
0.35644418001174927,
0.40402838587760925,
-0.5503993034362793,
0.5255529880523682,
0.22076690196990967,
-0.6334377527236938,
-0.5555010437965393,
0.7150672674179077,
-0.8535301089286804,
-0.48875758051872253,
0.8568021655082703,
-0.39471307396888733,
-0.04378683492541313,
-0.6107373237609863,
-0.06462276726961136,
0.3174252510070801,
-0.3827412724494934,
0.4945763647556305,
0.6655825972557068,
0.12492572516202927,
0.025465695187449455,
-0.8331836462020874,
0.3191298842430115,
0.40255045890808105,
-0.6524194478988647,
0.30600428581237793,
0.5931911468505859,
0.15004146099090576,
0.08239530771970749,
0.2785148620605469,
-0.3304756283760071,
0.22061099112033844,
-0.42612922191619873,
0.023372510448098183,
-0.1234884038567543,
-0.18825066089630127,
-0.4255949854850769,
0.21925930678844452,
-0.524777889251709,
-0.0012668980052694678
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.04136v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.04136v1
|
Legal Judgment Reimagined: PredEx and the Rise of Intelligent AI Interpretation in Indian Courts
| 2024-06-06T14:57:48 | 2024-06-06T14:57:48 |
Shubham Kumar Nigam, Anurag Sharma, Danush Khanna, Noel Shallum, Kripabandhu Ghosh, Arnab Bhattacharya
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
In the era of Large Language Models (LLMs), predicting judicial outcomes
poses significant challenges due to the complexity of legal proceedings and the
scarcity of expert-annotated datasets. Addressing this, we introduce
\textbf{Pred}iction with \textbf{Ex}planation (\texttt{PredEx}), the largest
expert-annotated dataset for legal judgment prediction and explanation in the
Indian context, featuring over 15,000 annotations. This groundbreaking corpus
significantly enhances the training and evaluation of AI models in legal
analysis, with innovations including the application of instruction tuning to
LLMs. This method has markedly improved the predictive accuracy and explanatory
depth of these models for legal judgments. We employed various
transformer-based models, tailored for both general and Indian legal contexts.
Through rigorous lexical, semantic, and expert assessments, our models
effectively leverage \texttt{PredEx} to provide precise predictions and
meaningful explanations, establishing it as a valuable benchmark for both the
legal profession and the NLP community.
|
[
-0.30027908086776733,
-0.48123252391815186,
0.7343965768814087,
0.005516244098544121,
-0.7829807996749878,
-0.009847413748502731,
-0.1496935784816742,
-0.35515666007995605,
0.4807775318622589,
0.750007688999176,
-0.3526003360748291,
-0.5003116726875305,
-0.8053726553916931,
-0.12449489533901215,
-0.7841678261756897,
1.0576918125152588,
0.09724154323339462,
0.2796027362346649,
-0.2868148386478424,
-0.05255837365984917,
-0.6234570145606995,
-0.4387784004211426,
-0.24509119987487793,
-0.24854078888893127,
0.1299239546060562,
0.10139641910791397,
0.8365373611450195,
0.4981619119644165,
0.6822856664657593,
0.42727360129356384,
0.2387397587299347,
-0.24135589599609375,
-0.16304415464401245,
-0.09273195266723633,
-0.19862070679664612,
-0.8717208504676819,
-0.6976728439331055,
0.11955332010984421,
0.31921881437301636,
0.5820755362510681,
-0.602994441986084,
-0.05692582577466965,
-0.3847692906856537,
0.4762508273124695,
-0.8735074400901794,
0.1427488625049591,
-0.49558335542678833,
0.3135624825954437,
-0.2352013885974884,
-0.21173682808876038,
-0.49914854764938354,
-0.6000758409500122,
0.04834732040762901,
-0.7196442484855652,
-0.0038684182800352573,
0.1731160581111908,
0.8002249598503113,
0.8617046475410461,
-0.41786882281303406,
0.08591459691524506,
-0.9579700231552124,
0.4690367877483368,
-0.732162594795227,
0.30817005038261414,
0.22027763724327087,
0.8190680742263794,
-0.03896785527467728,
-1.2887145280838013,
-0.7124377489089966,
-0.09470716118812561,
-0.01158300880342722,
0.37338459491729736,
-0.0919337198138237,
0.15368127822875977,
0.30036741495132446,
0.23916232585906982,
-0.34544867277145386,
0.17389948666095734,
-0.2600586712360382,
0.006261156871914864,
0.8416610360145569,
0.07156600058078766,
0.31744787096977234,
-0.08204417675733566,
-0.11839865893125534,
-0.0582209974527359,
-0.6281164884567261,
-0.12166796624660492,
0.31264829635620117,
0.11453600227832794,
0.06572337448596954,
0.5022704005241394,
-0.13547371327877045,
0.7611182332038879,
0.1913338154554367,
0.09354949742555618,
0.1920570433139801,
-0.28134775161743164,
-0.5176882147789001,
0.3204125463962555,
0.856763482093811,
0.4225916266441345,
0.5337548851966858,
0.18423473834991455,
-0.4360499978065491,
-0.10145707428455353,
0.5695446133613586,
-0.5809892416000366,
0.00012285768752917647,
0.09017805755138397,
-0.7724428772926331,
-0.23178328573703766,
0.23220084607601166,
-0.8730302453041077,
-0.7903539538383484,
-0.8535994291305542,
0.07637015730142593,
-0.23787261545658112,
-0.2869982421398163,
0.27823933959007263,
0.03379818797111511,
0.5899888277053833,
0.5707640647888184,
-0.6327831149101257,
0.18030861020088196,
0.754292905330658,
0.1394023448228836,
0.285537987947464,
0.08243587613105774,
-0.40243712067604065,
-0.1753135621547699,
-0.5748149752616882,
1.0577964782714844,
-0.9538925886154175,
-0.3290516436100006,
0.09253213554620743,
-0.21815957129001617,
0.19659018516540527,
-0.43626242876052856,
0.8964719176292419,
-0.6805759072303772,
-0.008880176581442356,
0.12690024077892303,
-0.4903883934020996,
-0.3626038730144501,
0.10769011080265045,
-0.5505577325820923,
0.21960686147212982,
-0.07349769026041031,
-0.44804301857948303,
1.2456133365631104,
-0.7999848127365112,
-0.6087601184844971,
0.5462621450424194,
-0.4270453453063965,
-0.2960154712200165,
0.48660963773727417,
0.26335301995277405,
0.3014145493507385,
-0.5735979080200195,
0.6875138282775879,
-0.30371564626693726,
-0.30662837624549866,
-0.31128305196762085,
-0.11348748207092285,
0.7489290237426758,
0.5106469392776489,
-0.24748650193214417,
0.5510539412498474,
-0.7725763320922852,
0.15223315358161926,
0.05940456688404083,
0.06560321152210236,
-0.3213719427585602,
0.2920292019844055,
-0.08955620974302292,
0.30431580543518066,
0.00442886957898736,
-0.43845969438552856,
-0.1258658915758133,
-0.5457510352134705,
0.48089998960494995,
0.839643657207489,
-0.20877785980701447,
0.43548333644866943,
-0.017563849687576294,
0.8803994655609131,
-0.23710983991622925,
0.5031026005744934,
-0.22969838976860046,
-0.2966918349266052,
-0.43198147416114807,
-0.1461048722267151,
0.6043243408203125,
0.5960885286331177,
-0.328490674495697,
0.2862868905067444,
-0.7772523760795593,
-0.5402683615684509,
-0.791017472743988,
-0.22658079862594604,
0.07034007459878922,
0.21093620359897614,
0.3559158444404602,
-0.18061646819114685,
-0.7806950211524963,
-1.0228321552276611,
-0.7409244775772095,
-0.0742167979478836,
0.2509169280529022,
0.21097077429294586,
0.45692721009254456,
-0.42820680141448975,
1.2038190364837646,
-0.011974787339568138,
-0.12972310185432434,
-0.2987898588180542,
0.1439782977104187,
0.4681365489959717,
0.2068357616662979,
0.31067341566085815,
-1.252845048904419,
-0.4376586675643921,
-0.06517735123634338,
-0.7844357490539551,
-0.21935151517391205,
-0.3692859709262848,
0.015240092761814594,
-0.03506257385015488,
0.7341342568397522,
-0.4682307243347168,
0.9077538251876831,
-0.27420109510421753,
-0.5825102925300598,
0.6945854425430298,
-0.2730310261249542,
0.32909518480300903,
-1.0025135278701782,
-0.2051723599433899,
-0.29063549637794495,
-0.39288410544395447,
-0.3548401892185211,
0.2115745097398758,
0.18293318152427673,
0.023599594831466675,
-0.5891891121864319,
0.4974326193332672,
-0.2635095417499542,
-0.2666107714176178,
-0.3841106593608856,
0.1517266482114792,
-0.34653645753860474,
0.1796354055404663,
-0.043367981910705566,
0.6898826360702515,
0.20023436844348907,
-0.34223446249961853,
0.5261849761009216,
0.26885390281677246,
-0.41303208470344543,
0.7573488354682922,
-0.6821609139442444,
-0.14690688252449036,
-0.18330378830432892,
0.2749316990375519,
-0.5641279816627502,
-0.251831978559494,
0.02445920556783676,
-0.300207257270813,
0.4797956943511963,
-0.129017636179924,
-0.5099000930786133,
-0.46783939003944397,
-0.0980643704533577,
0.43555644154548645,
0.418205589056015,
-0.44991958141326904,
1.3807393312454224,
0.6052016615867615,
-0.1303105354309082,
-0.8645687699317932,
-0.6807706356048584,
0.5262404680252075,
-0.2849401831626892,
-0.4098137617111206,
0.2721109092235565,
0.26166337728500366,
-0.7616085410118103,
0.12378891557455063,
0.22590264678001404,
0.10978692024946213,
0.07442577183246613,
0.7252349257469177,
0.28094208240509033,
-0.12120506167411804,
0.1519865244626999,
0.23719677329063416,
-0.3070544898509979,
0.46018412709236145,
-0.17608517408370972,
0.44041958451271057,
-0.05386057123541832,
-0.7540450692176819,
-0.4519531726837158,
0.13587117195129395,
0.5712277293205261,
-0.5604619979858398,
0.3092976212501526,
0.11215168982744217,
-0.47385427355766296,
0.039467889815568924,
-0.7092392444610596,
0.12385497242212296,
-0.3782241642475128,
0.41237422823905945,
-0.532802164554596,
-0.4708397686481476,
0.2795593738555908,
-0.2819209694862366,
0.14344297349452972,
0.827360987663269,
0.5050182342529297,
0.24879665672779083,
0.9305415749549866,
0.7191318273544312,
0.018345307558774948,
0.39575880765914917,
0.09259326010942459,
0.6716465950012207,
-0.3771677315235138,
-0.35943374037742615,
-0.33038267493247986,
-0.0658286064863205,
-0.725204348564148,
-0.09372236579656601,
0.07850901037454605,
-0.04326460510492325,
-0.33774447441101074,
0.07881273329257965,
-0.36269405484199524,
0.6737118363380432,
0.8117303252220154,
-0.10755224525928497,
0.2684253454208374,
-0.19610632956027985,
-0.18688039481639862,
0.04836677387356758,
-0.3259173333644867,
-0.6877884864807129,
1.5236117839813232,
0.008636219426989555,
0.6057993173599243,
-0.12367383390665054,
0.7460824251174927,
0.6195909976959229,
0.33066797256469727,
-0.5748844146728516,
0.7017669677734375,
-0.2915331721305847,
-0.5149317383766174,
0.028582492843270302,
0.03794833645224571,
-0.7333352565765381,
0.03430693596601486,
-0.7055982351303101,
-0.12026389688253403,
0.16230981051921844,
-0.28776681423187256,
-1.0080642700195312,
0.1511879712343216,
-0.7485914826393127,
0.7327603697776794,
-0.36233240365982056,
-0.4089982807636261,
-0.6735503673553467,
-0.700388491153717,
0.4472528398036957,
-0.51673823595047,
0.32219353318214417,
0.1300661265850067,
0.05847451090812683,
0.7197997570037842,
-0.902481734752655,
0.42429864406585693,
-0.33117547631263733,
0.2040247768163681,
0.318452924489975,
-0.10369031876325607,
0.3483736515045166,
0.08762300759553909,
-0.03881044313311577,
-0.046578846871852875,
0.12969206273555756,
-0.20762552320957184,
-0.6431943774223328,
0.46904146671295166,
-0.6047855615615845,
-0.7980871796607971,
-0.5053628087043762,
-0.3873206377029419,
0.034917235374450684,
0.2935664653778076,
-0.018649207428097725,
0.20179326832294464,
-0.12185804545879364,
-0.04599335789680481,
0.17526228725910187,
-0.39728257060050964,
0.4720536470413208,
0.5636025667190552,
-0.34487876296043396,
-0.34813448786735535,
0.5497789978981018,
-0.08227536827325821,
-0.43745049834251404,
0.2177387923002243,
-0.07715979963541031,
-0.7343003153800964,
-0.6849493384361267,
-0.2744855284690857,
0.10061397403478622,
-0.9728162884712219,
-0.1648942083120346,
-0.5192925930023193,
-0.14517559111118317,
-0.4929782748222351,
-0.06943022459745407,
-0.2720484137535095,
-0.40346094965934753,
0.19342041015625,
-0.38194456696510315,
0.08675340563058853,
0.9422476291656494,
-0.05446397513151169,
0.17220495641231537,
-0.5214586853981018,
0.2747066617012024,
0.3286871016025543,
0.5543580055236816,
-0.5594752430915833,
-0.6833772659301758,
0.15013399720191956,
-0.07170986384153366,
0.19614975154399872,
-0.3792562782764435,
0.48436811566352844,
-0.00907839834690094,
0.5677618384361267,
0.7044211626052856,
-0.012545514851808548,
0.7111813426017761,
-0.8564760684967041,
0.5405152440071106,
0.0978049710392952,
-0.6740834712982178,
0.8788914680480957,
0.006188622675836086,
-0.05062299966812134,
0.5612476468086243,
0.09909289330244064,
-0.14116814732551575,
-0.04460355266928673,
-0.5396666526794434,
-0.9919983148574829,
0.6810646057128906,
-0.38171201944351196,
0.3372379243373871,
0.01902809925377369,
0.7131671905517578,
0.3875540792942047,
0.04547661542892456,
-0.4451030194759369,
0.16821220517158508,
-0.26669076085090637,
-0.2586800158023834,
-0.11130189150571823,
-0.41230326890945435,
0.07624933123588562,
-0.3477621376514435,
0.47494029998779297,
0.20455412566661835,
0.13196566700935364,
-0.02410086616873741,
-0.4167723059654236,
0.14236076176166534,
0.26982635259628296,
0.7865172624588013,
0.9162737131118774,
-0.07526145130395889,
-0.012581232003867626,
0.0731278657913208,
-0.3968154489994049,
0.0842287540435791,
0.39510679244995117,
0.026388397440314293,
-0.16924479603767395,
0.5958429574966431,
0.8710101246833801,
-0.10152576863765717,
-0.8829804062843323,
0.4853711426258087,
-0.3977644145488739,
-0.11066640913486481,
-1.0115997791290283,
0.014686260372400284,
-0.30425384640693665,
0.44451621174812317,
0.400368332862854,
0.34085899591445923,
0.2190319448709488,
-0.35780805349349976,
0.3705367147922516,
0.2439975142478943,
-0.3357568681240082,
-0.02349146641790867,
1.1471818685531616,
0.21671205759048462,
-0.42518743872642517,
0.6103966236114502,
-0.0417264886200428,
-0.28511908650398254,
0.4827980101108551,
-0.057486068457365036,
0.8730764985084534,
-0.10030116885900497,
-0.23489020764827728,
0.3055007755756378,
0.14060941338539124,
-0.23146969079971313,
0.05098980665206909,
-0.0851111114025116,
-0.4393599033355713,
-0.7268431186676025,
-0.8380357623100281,
-0.036482103168964386,
-0.24729497730731964,
-0.49745386838912964,
0.46975505352020264,
-0.6698340177536011,
-0.20814582705497742,
-0.10870996862649918,
-0.12286326289176941,
-0.6885311007499695,
0.34794238209724426,
0.19620466232299805,
0.9639528393745422,
-0.7649962306022644,
0.7658746242523193,
0.6059655547142029,
-0.6234962344169617,
-0.5811750292778015,
-0.2069065421819687,
0.005979389883577824,
-0.8631730079650879,
1.0001628398895264,
0.032825957983732224,
-0.13748100399971008,
-0.09952337294816971,
-0.5148390531539917,
-0.450801283121109,
0.8383780121803284,
0.37862151861190796,
-0.9336021542549133,
0.12514619529247284,
0.4543445408344269,
0.7246869802474976,
-0.4084279239177704,
0.7721244096755981,
0.8268505334854126,
0.6314319968223572,
-0.11603114008903503,
-0.8490554690361023,
0.03937378153204918,
-0.5504840612411499,
-0.17142538726329803,
0.23133346438407898,
0.08849676698446274,
0.601431131362915,
-0.3739908039569855,
-0.15798191726207733,
-0.22991591691970825,
0.6490247249603271,
-0.09253361076116562,
0.19577763974666595,
0.6110844612121582,
0.9942727088928223,
0.6733717322349548,
-0.4625612795352936,
1.637250304222107,
-0.5126206278800964,
-0.18091166019439697,
1.2792689800262451,
-0.32912102341651917,
0.7300263047218323,
0.37084054946899414,
-0.3090941309928894,
0.5785968899726868,
0.8688529133796692,
-0.04749263823032379,
0.3334707021713257,
0.1956888735294342,
0.14489564299583435,
-0.6441791653633118,
-0.2240508496761322,
-0.2820262908935547,
0.7408474087715149,
0.09857994318008423,
-0.34064698219299316,
-0.0979640856385231,
0.0751127377152443,
-0.2556200325489044,
0.5596747398376465,
-0.57130366563797,
0.8483883142471313,
-0.07698843628168106,
-0.7144773006439209,
0.2376331388950348,
0.012533344328403473,
0.552295446395874,
-0.3751784563064575,
-0.22092539072036743,
-0.3085725009441376,
0.3740758001804352,
-0.21322745084762573,
-0.94145667552948,
0.3678519129753113,
-0.12433360517024994,
-0.1338990032672882,
-0.36651498079299927,
0.6343299150466919,
-0.028937216848134995,
-0.49086782336235046,
0.4555738866329193,
0.4017159342765808,
0.23536153137683868,
-0.32213908433914185,
-0.7693135738372803,
-0.20963118970394135,
-0.3559224605560303,
-0.05845697596669197,
0.16379261016845703,
0.5454726219177246,
-0.4560122489929199,
0.6498822569847107,
0.4174816906452179,
0.1133875772356987,
0.23342262208461761,
0.39956313371658325,
0.7334078550338745,
-0.7715996503829956,
-0.43488726019859314,
-0.9026926755905151,
0.47701722383499146,
-0.26731595396995544,
-0.011713194660842419,
0.33335956931114197,
0.5494875907897949,
0.8122395277023315,
-0.010204057209193707,
0.6022919416427612,
-0.06750160455703735,
0.5626785159111023,
-0.48128795623779297,
0.8899838924407959,
-0.5495762825012207,
0.28392335772514343,
-0.10968727618455887,
-0.8694584369659424,
-0.3631078004837036,
0.406330943107605,
-0.6817191243171692,
0.39490848779678345,
0.4316030740737915,
0.4417599141597748,
-0.055137261748313904,
0.19707323610782623,
0.25851938128471375,
0.19139839708805084,
0.2791807949542999,
0.3519684076309204,
0.9153335690498352,
-0.34311237931251526,
0.5450422763824463,
0.0627446249127388,
-0.12349601835012436,
-0.2998296916484833,
-0.714878499507904,
-0.5741326808929443,
-0.33815139532089233,
-0.00269756349734962,
-0.0009664458921179175,
-0.04986432194709778,
1.0057618618011475,
0.7135223150253296,
-0.9845161437988281,
-0.05395649001002312,
-0.33934852480888367,
-0.07366754114627838,
0.16487586498260498,
-0.1810108870267868,
0.4646376073360443,
-0.503091037273407,
-0.7742561101913452,
0.23791785538196564,
0.3615991473197937,
-0.3021053969860077,
0.16095253825187683,
-0.1421581655740738,
-0.38557812571525574,
0.10319484025239944,
0.6435171961784363,
0.04689856618642807,
-0.8713425397872925,
-0.0717659592628479,
-0.5725120902061462,
0.12231297045946121,
-0.017669757828116417,
0.8674106001853943,
-0.8563485145568848,
0.7836644649505615,
0.319164901971817,
0.7961990833282471,
0.2931782901287079,
0.1506621092557907,
0.8532708287239075,
-0.09448323398828506,
0.34755194187164307,
0.39076128602027893,
0.680432915687561,
-0.013238171115517616,
0.03596842288970947,
0.772399365901947,
0.12732191383838654,
-0.27514225244522095,
-0.6847866773605347,
-0.04141298308968544,
-0.5372169017791748,
-0.562343955039978,
0.6882653832435608,
-0.11127327382564545,
-0.25651320815086365,
-0.1932729333639145,
-0.14252860844135284,
0.2927124500274658,
-0.13032178580760956,
0.8503698110580444,
0.6015254855155945,
0.11473693698644638,
-0.19427981972694397,
-0.7017033100128174,
0.6466664671897888,
0.6881711483001709,
-0.9124581217765808,
-0.20110255479812622,
0.6438721418380737,
-0.01655648462474346,
0.23379307985305786,
0.4148448705673218,
-0.3688857853412628,
0.4533027112483978,
-0.06298602372407913,
0.364574670791626,
-0.33267873525619507,
-0.21312454342842102,
-0.5132433772087097,
0.11336687207221985,
-0.07621825486421585,
-0.01433724444359541
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.04127v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.04127v2
|
Are We Done with MMLU?
| 2024-06-06T14:49:06 | 2024-06-07T15:19:06 |
Aryo Pradipta Gema, Joshua Ong Jun Leang, Giwon Hong, Alessio Devoto, Alberto Carlo Maria Mancino, Rohit Saxena, Xuanli He, Yu Zhao, Xiaotang Du, Mohammad Reza Ghasemi Madani, Claire Barale, Robert McHardy, Joshua Harris, Jean Kaddour, Emile van Krieken, Pasquale Minervini
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Maybe not. We identify and analyse errors in the popular Massive Multitask
Language Understanding (MMLU) benchmark. Even though MMLU is widely adopted,
our analysis demonstrates numerous ground truth errors that obscure the true
capabilities of LLMs. For example, we find that 57% of the analysed questions
in the Virology subset contain errors. To address this issue, we introduce a
comprehensive framework for identifying dataset errors using a novel error
taxonomy. Then, we create MMLU-Redux, which is a subset of 3,000 manually
re-annotated questions across 30 MMLU subjects. Using MMLU-Redux, we
demonstrate significant discrepancies with the model performance metrics that
were originally reported. Our results strongly advocate for revising MMLU's
error-ridden questions to enhance its future utility and reliability as a
benchmark. Therefore, we open up MMLU-Redux for additional annotation
https://huggingface.co/datasets/edinburgh-dawg/mmlu-redux.
|
[
-0.10547692328691483,
-0.8260905146598816,
0.4731582701206207,
0.056231748312711716,
0.005273784045130014,
0.2185371071100235,
-0.0699492022395134,
-0.37412524223327637,
0.044516537338495255,
0.3153800368309021,
-1.043470859527588,
-0.35248175263404846,
-0.5533677935600281,
0.41808444261550903,
-0.35809457302093506,
0.8366208076477051,
-0.18219420313835144,
0.036198023706674576,
-0.6315885186195374,
-0.6720013618469238,
-0.4556976854801178,
-0.5988777875900269,
-0.36740607023239136,
-0.3845368027687073,
0.7505883574485779,
0.6030653715133667,
0.38409242033958435,
0.2803153693675995,
0.6222827434539795,
0.2276265174150467,
0.07434668391942978,
0.6380869746208191,
-0.7420163750648499,
-0.2115146666765213,
0.2090691328048706,
-0.6071776747703552,
-0.6726891994476318,
0.22240379452705383,
0.5790440440177917,
0.9005534052848816,
-0.25306662917137146,
0.41368088126182556,
0.04908879101276398,
0.8315618634223938,
-0.7243685722351074,
0.18517254292964935,
-0.5148404836654663,
0.14902421832084656,
-0.4025498926639557,
-0.2045203149318695,
-0.45712557435035706,
-0.03212182968854904,
-0.11473825573921204,
-0.6945821046829224,
0.22526895999908447,
-0.19019129872322083,
0.6940319538116455,
0.7368457317352295,
-0.33774533867836,
0.035822559148073196,
-0.6030510067939758,
1.0353279113769531,
-0.6947341561317444,
0.4038620889186859,
0.4751420319080353,
0.5516369938850403,
-0.24512551724910736,
-0.5028027892112732,
-0.5388575792312622,
-0.08456389605998993,
-0.2864416837692261,
0.2656065821647644,
-0.2399163693189621,
-0.19094163179397583,
0.41766440868377686,
0.18731415271759033,
-0.5703025460243225,
0.003209162037819624,
-0.5673795342445374,
-0.2227528691291809,
0.6659924387931824,
0.477830171585083,
0.12586838006973267,
-0.03826334699988365,
-0.14501313865184784,
0.10972416400909424,
-0.7086905837059021,
0.09976626932621002,
0.2990422248840332,
-0.017818517982959747,
-0.15252597630023956,
0.5765898823738098,
-0.23105116188526154,
0.816068172454834,
-0.3635269105434418,
-0.22812797129154205,
0.5920227766036987,
-0.6410440802574158,
-0.5765328407287598,
-0.31708860397338867,
0.6170376539230347,
0.5141929984092712,
0.24725696444511414,
0.06586092710494995,
-0.07668470591306686,
0.030386846512556076,
0.5907262563705444,
-0.4981210231781006,
-0.14061330258846283,
0.6825482249259949,
-0.11528429388999939,
-0.2938753366470337,
-0.0722280740737915,
-0.6363511085510254,
-0.4997767210006714,
-0.3123050332069397,
0.15193898975849152,
-0.06632491946220398,
-0.4385949373245239,
0.10815715044736862,
0.0328182727098465,
0.29197263717651367,
0.6323031783103943,
-0.6306731104850769,
0.03424922376871109,
0.8315852284431458,
0.6554849147796631,
-0.10195355117321014,
-0.6212973594665527,
-0.5248202085494995,
-0.22938674688339233,
-0.352182537317276,
0.7015003561973572,
-0.2375945746898651,
-0.20697270333766937,
-0.14941640198230743,
0.23853150010108948,
-0.40771713852882385,
-0.614044725894928,
0.4414476156234741,
-0.2175324559211731,
-0.061863526701927185,
-0.6880980134010315,
-0.48807409405708313,
-0.2773021459579468,
0.5125499367713928,
-0.7669886350631714,
0.9307429194450378,
0.0641448050737381,
-0.8161380290985107,
0.40379440784454346,
-0.6764353513717651,
-0.014675191603600979,
-0.11654214560985565,
-0.24991409480571747,
-0.41378775238990784,
0.15469135344028473,
0.13425134122371674,
0.5172337293624878,
-0.2230689823627472,
0.44695067405700684,
-0.36663392186164856,
-0.4595482349395752,
0.5769988298416138,
-0.49315083026885986,
0.7177507281303406,
0.04316464811563492,
-0.17276707291603088,
0.23131971061229706,
-0.9970030188560486,
-0.22596026957035065,
-0.0015023171436041594,
-0.34651216864585876,
-0.07449095696210861,
0.05693018436431885,
-0.038435354828834534,
0.0013927854597568512,
0.26471632719039917,
-0.6280214190483093,
0.21357163786888123,
0.17690962553024292,
0.35358482599258423,
0.6687467694282532,
-0.47462913393974304,
-0.014094867743551731,
-0.3834975063800812,
0.5012748837471008,
0.10155808925628662,
0.268151193857193,
-0.0907568410038948,
-0.7038848996162415,
-0.7588806748390198,
-0.1361318826675415,
0.0916212648153305,
0.5222447514533997,
-0.5570621490478516,
0.12723341584205627,
-0.2624720633029938,
-0.6034875512123108,
-0.8086404204368591,
0.2930465638637543,
0.37104153633117676,
0.6675719618797302,
0.35790398716926575,
0.02076515182852745,
-0.5862115025520325,
-0.9152540564537048,
-0.16258077323436737,
-0.3254777789115906,
0.29516831040382385,
0.38940930366516113,
0.6767228245735168,
-0.6420934200286865,
0.7989341616630554,
-0.43672457337379456,
-0.14131422340869904,
-0.10573940724134445,
0.2649446129798889,
0.17137795686721802,
0.20215484499931335,
0.25139516592025757,
-0.8516197800636292,
-0.06537516415119171,
0.07909836620092392,
-1.1269760131835938,
-0.16053776443004608,
-0.13201645016670227,
0.16316340863704681,
0.026290645822882652,
0.5056989192962646,
-0.4638775587081909,
0.2604433298110962,
0.7677028179168701,
-0.22445321083068848,
1.1192102432250977,
-0.25633445382118225,
0.3084705173969269,
-0.6840313673019409,
0.33917707204818726,
-0.13600994646549225,
-0.15350402891635895,
-0.779075026512146,
0.1439446359872818,
0.3724219799041748,
0.1308291256427765,
-0.5368351340293884,
0.3408691883087158,
-0.18089810013771057,
-0.26474758982658386,
-0.18932239711284637,
0.07129236310720444,
0.10614123195409775,
0.4713886082172394,
-0.4783647656440735,
0.8798962235450745,
0.3939530551433563,
-0.47175133228302,
0.5411369204521179,
0.10042385011911392,
-0.2193346619606018,
0.6843779683113098,
-0.4841347932815552,
0.01105131022632122,
-0.2636664807796478,
0.03508792817592621,
-1.240769863128662,
-0.4912611246109009,
0.16639570891857147,
-0.5959664583206177,
0.14087165892124176,
-0.24277634918689728,
-0.389118492603302,
-0.40527892112731934,
-0.3903813362121582,
0.3420640826225281,
0.05651231110095978,
-0.5518589019775391,
0.5669747591018677,
0.3815375566482544,
0.22576561570167542,
-1.2345755100250244,
-0.6970627307891846,
-0.042554084211587906,
-0.26285281777381897,
-0.6695252060890198,
-0.2110559642314911,
-0.25178325176239014,
-0.4920753538608551,
-0.04535948485136032,
-0.08338561654090881,
-0.1762106865644455,
0.5133165717124939,
0.4178594946861267,
0.16425471007823944,
-0.2372155785560608,
0.15714377164840698,
-0.3307019770145416,
-0.16953594982624054,
0.07305514812469482,
0.21642889082431793,
0.21019740402698517,
-0.22197331488132477,
-0.5900244116783142,
-0.3404335677623749,
0.038817692548036575,
1.0331209897994995,
-0.1173814982175827,
0.43417632579803467,
0.7459061145782471,
-0.4368618130683899,
0.24449576437473297,
-0.6797101497650146,
0.0974460244178772,
-0.41195276379585266,
0.4017704725265503,
-0.4523358941078186,
-0.7822294235229492,
0.66983562707901,
0.2445155829191208,
0.6228362321853638,
0.49446630477905273,
0.45193952322006226,
-0.46548786759376526,
0.5416951775550842,
0.6278937458992004,
-0.07011517137289047,
-0.08082526922225952,
-0.2996472418308258,
-0.12485110014677048,
-0.9009398221969604,
-0.17921575903892517,
-0.26192551851272583,
-0.43531307578086853,
-0.38772937655448914,
-0.6360568404197693,
0.1396048367023468,
0.0936003178358078,
0.24037864804267883,
0.33401069045066833,
-0.0707426369190216,
0.17176151275634766,
0.3158772885799408,
-0.186447873711586,
0.3686622083187103,
-0.16437916457653046,
-0.10618911683559418,
-0.13009540736675262,
-0.49356839060783386,
-0.34179162979125977,
1.2528976202011108,
0.32795798778533936,
0.7984896302223206,
0.3185522258281708,
0.50071120262146,
0.18335802853107452,
0.5600026845932007,
-0.7209169268608093,
0.40353265404701233,
-0.14095932245254517,
-0.5704836845397949,
-0.3008548319339752,
-0.5452879667282104,
-1.0506584644317627,
0.5203937292098999,
-0.004178783856332302,
-0.6876972913742065,
0.02467752806842327,
0.258250892162323,
-0.5532280206680298,
0.3363577127456665,
-0.8024991154670715,
1.1506365537643433,
-0.08154218643903732,
-0.23951134085655212,
-0.15923210978507996,
-0.28635963797569275,
0.7230464816093445,
-0.4652775526046753,
0.4093371629714966,
-0.49734219908714294,
0.049519795924425125,
0.8947689533233643,
-0.2578485906124115,
0.9718306064605713,
-0.11428354680538177,
-0.16910859942436218,
0.14872072637081146,
-0.2466525286436081,
0.2667008638381958,
-0.007264634594321251,
0.04280305653810501,
0.209825798869133,
0.07453770935535431,
-0.3708798289299011,
-0.578935980796814,
0.647559404373169,
-0.6684659719467163,
-0.49767884612083435,
-0.3503469228744507,
-0.5267977714538574,
-0.14657150208950043,
-0.10020622611045837,
-0.06999528408050537,
0.5973816514015198,
-0.09343075752258301,
0.0933196097612381,
0.3097313642501831,
-0.14258672297000885,
0.34392523765563965,
0.7426722645759583,
-0.19484132528305054,
-0.23492982983589172,
0.9390624761581421,
0.23333996534347534,
0.06849571317434311,
0.19106049835681915,
0.2511392831802368,
-0.30883967876434326,
-0.5104285478591919,
-0.6978645324707031,
0.34864115715026855,
-0.8054456114768982,
0.009143039584159851,
-0.7922263145446777,
-0.004024947062134743,
-0.1569686383008957,
0.15554986894130707,
-0.5494535565376282,
-0.031969062983989716,
-0.48003190755844116,
-0.30750206112861633,
0.3669687509536743,
0.7978333830833435,
0.04790220409631729,
0.17002785205841064,
-0.9594914317131042,
0.2922861874103546,
0.24207916855812073,
0.13572953641414642,
-0.1424102485179901,
-0.49070268869400024,
-0.34913429617881775,
0.011079821735620499,
-0.16508185863494873,
-0.736603856086731,
0.22782406210899353,
0.18805795907974243,
0.6769005656242371,
0.186517134308815,
-0.1679055392742157,
1.0076168775558472,
-0.47899243235588074,
0.8625787496566772,
0.0874781608581543,
-0.516213595867157,
0.33559975028038025,
-0.13530385494232178,
0.41203784942626953,
0.6380729079246521,
0.35732895135879517,
-0.7819650769233704,
-0.5076109766960144,
-0.7414991855621338,
-0.5934122800827026,
0.3647345304489136,
0.14585116505622864,
-0.1477205604314804,
0.19669128954410553,
0.28005942702293396,
0.3277924656867981,
0.2054114043712616,
-0.48878014087677,
-0.6503560543060303,
0.11814942210912704,
-0.03133628889918327,
-0.38908249139785767,
-0.4454602599143982,
-0.23704366385936737,
-0.2424684464931488,
0.39085426926612854,
-0.47456294298171997,
0.05659433454275131,
0.13993333280086517,
-0.47178274393081665,
-0.22358694672584534,
0.2516394257545471,
1.0447543859481812,
1.3696250915527344,
-0.4403574764728546,
0.09273478388786316,
0.1707225739955902,
-0.6954105496406555,
0.12346813827753067,
0.1405767947435379,
0.10250326991081238,
0.12390036880970001,
0.5907250046730042,
0.4768408238887787,
0.3184688091278076,
-0.9615755677223206,
0.366108775138855,
-0.2292366772890091,
-0.2938840687274933,
-0.4410475790500641,
-0.1860429346561432,
0.2895832359790802,
0.07140100747346878,
0.5572333931922913,
0.053128741681575775,
0.008130345493555069,
-0.30009403824806213,
0.4706335663795471,
0.31417763233184814,
-0.4313966631889343,
-0.3792317509651184,
0.526305079460144,
0.3287898004055023,
0.15600964426994324,
0.42253702878952026,
-0.1521199494600296,
-0.35791271924972534,
0.620261549949646,
-0.0983782634139061,
0.609836757183075,
0.06249856576323509,
0.1416521668434143,
0.4261969327926636,
0.4314141869544983,
-0.0240891482681036,
0.45846572518348694,
0.21028368175029755,
-0.925936222076416,
-1.0003677606582642,
-0.5156142115592957,
-0.6010486483573914,
0.39229801297187805,
-0.7080313563346863,
0.09272810071706772,
-0.24434725940227509,
-0.1364629566669464,
0.26811960339546204,
0.032664403319358826,
-0.5675083994865417,
0.255048006772995,
0.015647010877728462,
0.7621615529060364,
-1.0069185495376587,
0.888910710811615,
0.7321721315383911,
-0.11811360716819763,
-0.5178245902061462,
-0.36463624238967896,
0.48258355259895325,
-0.8629691004753113,
0.7543572783470154,
0.49127739667892456,
-0.005999457091093063,
-0.349056601524353,
-0.23923952877521515,
-0.5924224853515625,
1.1638511419296265,
0.18049703538417816,
-0.8084702491760254,
0.24975207448005676,
0.06198608875274658,
0.2860662043094635,
-0.1824186146259308,
0.33420154452323914,
0.9597806930541992,
0.456233412027359,
-0.19015352427959442,
-1.1189312934875488,
-0.11155259609222412,
-0.14336644113063812,
-0.6265081167221069,
0.1662028729915619,
-0.4516959488391876,
0.8951967358589172,
-0.5537018775939941,
-0.10576630383729935,
-0.09150197356939316,
0.39849406480789185,
0.25934821367263794,
0.6150034666061401,
0.44646814465522766,
0.8106571435928345,
1.182163953781128,
-0.24353542923927307,
0.9649920463562012,
0.19119924306869507,
0.6381310820579529,
1.2230478525161743,
-0.2057047337293625,
0.8535009026527405,
0.49634402990341187,
-0.483579158782959,
-0.010010634548962116,
0.7505097389221191,
-0.13214318454265594,
0.11746653914451599,
0.24297140538692474,
-0.09180368483066559,
-0.14535728096961975,
0.1204291358590126,
-0.2408927083015442,
0.43457701802253723,
0.5126732587814331,
-0.007974273525178432,
-0.30866938829421997,
-0.010529723018407822,
-0.09475872665643692,
-0.21872760355472565,
-0.10999424755573273,
0.5577812790870667,
0.02897278219461441,
-0.4507967233657837,
0.8952938318252563,
-0.2410813719034195,
0.8604966402053833,
-0.4146900773048401,
-0.10489103198051453,
-0.5789165496826172,
0.08570367842912674,
-0.37006574869155884,
-0.7477771639823914,
0.45218387246131897,
-0.061243485659360886,
-0.025570005178451538,
0.009134793654084206,
0.6068426370620728,
-0.3401916027069092,
-0.4736401438713074,
0.3004407286643982,
0.7584500908851624,
0.5279087424278259,
-0.09538378566503525,
-0.8660086393356323,
0.2698187828063965,
0.1914057582616806,
0.12588684260845184,
0.03738486394286156,
0.09650760143995285,
0.25846201181411743,
1.0489230155944824,
0.6272658705711365,
-0.11294671148061752,
0.169437438249588,
0.15287594497203827,
0.5605155229568481,
-0.6630728244781494,
-0.0677989050745964,
-1.0920259952545166,
0.793627142906189,
-0.07674283534288406,
-0.3625308573246002,
0.8330701589584351,
0.3974142372608185,
0.8947930932044983,
-0.129582017660141,
0.6770903468132019,
0.21412783861160278,
0.36976346373558044,
-0.4112689793109894,
0.689567506313324,
-0.9943580031394958,
0.29888981580734253,
-0.06931113451719284,
-0.6614518761634827,
-0.1458536684513092,
0.27041926980018616,
-0.1794309765100479,
-0.3711431622505188,
0.7926239967346191,
0.8691566586494446,
-0.0318133644759655,
0.08270179480314255,
0.8513623476028442,
0.24500487744808197,
0.41912156343460083,
0.4697982370853424,
0.9438846111297607,
-0.5474405288696289,
0.5019649267196655,
-0.2850516438484192,
-0.19002854824066162,
-0.5035455226898193,
-0.703201174736023,
-0.6966273784637451,
-0.5050586462020874,
-0.6722622513771057,
-0.29565346240997314,
0.04357902705669403,
0.5741901397705078,
0.5708293318748474,
-0.82281094789505,
-0.27756187319755554,
0.14805881679058075,
0.23741643130779266,
-0.40116235613822937,
-0.18268612027168274,
0.2869747281074524,
-0.37910550832748413,
-0.5840011835098267,
0.5769556760787964,
0.25875359773635864,
-0.06126973405480385,
-0.40018320083618164,
0.029455646872520447,
-0.3167618215084076,
-0.36902934312820435,
0.5076197385787964,
0.39616289734840393,
-0.9357462525367737,
-0.22051358222961426,
0.05151666700839996,
-0.09190407395362854,
0.17294658720493317,
0.9905723929405212,
-0.3837289810180664,
0.48266831040382385,
0.20448948442935944,
0.9602435827255249,
0.16667315363883972,
-0.20173510909080505,
0.5720270872116089,
-0.8882982134819031,
-0.1450105905532837,
-0.17107129096984863,
0.706808865070343,
0.5582481622695923,
-0.3699725270271301,
0.7613760232925415,
0.5801029205322266,
-0.41117262840270996,
-0.8293765783309937,
0.07621967047452927,
-1.033143401145935,
-0.14400890469551086,
1.143268346786499,
-0.36259108781814575,
-0.3728337287902832,
-0.40192359685897827,
0.01233004778623581,
-0.1468583643436432,
-0.019085410982370377,
0.3982027471065521,
0.9718807935714722,
-0.14577285945415497,
-0.2843228876590729,
-1.1795765161514282,
0.5694973468780518,
0.48401665687561035,
-0.8044794201850891,
0.5745334625244141,
0.4358287453651428,
0.4755087196826935,
0.4101925790309906,
0.8103818893432617,
-0.046407874673604965,
0.5694299936294556,
-0.07718883454799652,
-0.15846441686153412,
-0.12370867282152176,
-0.3455401360988617,
-0.27046072483062744,
-0.02388201840221882,
0.046259112656116486,
-0.3438415229320526
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.04116v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.04116v1
|
Promoting Fairness and Diversity in Speech Datasets for Mental Health and Neurological Disorders Research
| 2024-06-06T14:36:07 | 2024-06-06T14:36:07 |
Eleonora Mancini, Ana Tanevska, Andrea Galassi, Alessio Galatolo, Federico Ruggeri, Paolo Torroni
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Current research in machine learning and artificial intelligence is largely
centered on modeling and performance evaluation, less so on data collection.
However, recent research demonstrated that limitations and biases in data may
negatively impact trustworthiness and reliability. These aspects are
particularly impactful on sensitive domains such as mental health and
neurological disorders, where speech data are used to develop AI applications
aimed at improving the health of patients and supporting healthcare providers.
In this paper, we chart the landscape of available speech datasets for this
domain, to highlight possible pitfalls and opportunities for improvement and
promote fairness and diversity. We present a comprehensive list of desiderata
for building speech datasets for mental health and neurological disorders and
distill it into a checklist focused on ethical concerns to foster more
responsible research.
|
[
-0.25457659363746643,
-0.4374145567417145,
0.3089383840560913,
0.08453040570020676,
0.2909884750843048,
0.15540850162506104,
-0.022912070155143738,
-0.7103057503700256,
0.2102365642786026,
0.4733850657939911,
-0.4748441278934479,
-0.3350115120410919,
-0.9349411129951477,
-0.2073032110929489,
-0.367649644613266,
1.1700804233551025,
0.4575508236885071,
0.4568631052970886,
-0.3021737039089203,
-0.3967171013355255,
-0.46627646684646606,
-0.8366336226463318,
-0.7606400847434998,
-0.30642199516296387,
0.6301112174987793,
0.3056870996952057,
1.0075949430465698,
0.3954390287399292,
0.630992591381073,
0.1738043576478958,
-0.07361435890197754,
0.07062439620494843,
-0.5005313754081726,
0.3540599048137665,
-0.5136733055114746,
-0.394596129655838,
-0.5728603005409241,
0.21876902878284454,
0.3260848820209503,
0.9801317453384399,
-0.3038608431816101,
0.3613530993461609,
-0.1676931381225586,
0.5858559012413025,
-0.4639846086502075,
0.026686860248446465,
-0.2965258061885834,
0.3905441462993622,
-0.6730504035949707,
0.07741644978523254,
0.05145924538373947,
-0.6804556250572205,
0.15693402290344238,
-0.43381303548812866,
0.11062987893819809,
-0.08591631799936295,
0.4745360314846039,
0.5580480694770813,
-0.4173550307750702,
-0.17561304569244385,
-0.7194492220878601,
0.9139319062232971,
-0.6963619589805603,
0.3632891774177551,
0.7457364797592163,
0.4361056983470917,
-0.05537234619259834,
-0.7809996604919434,
-0.43741610646247864,
0.1002049371600151,
0.19397591054439545,
-0.15865717828273773,
-0.6863411664962769,
0.0027170865796506405,
0.5933099985122681,
0.27247142791748047,
-0.5228033661842346,
0.4144373834133148,
-0.5446609854698181,
-0.31996384263038635,
0.7813752293586731,
0.38939356803894043,
0.5773703455924988,
0.029630277305841446,
0.5115217566490173,
0.027261169627308846,
-0.41260072588920593,
0.234071746468544,
0.6008222103118896,
0.3997289836406708,
-0.13421499729156494,
0.5284414291381836,
-0.029873579740524292,
0.5616108179092407,
-0.06983859091997147,
0.06495124101638794,
0.584345817565918,
-0.10133571922779083,
0.022546863183379173,
0.07708939909934998,
0.18404947221279144,
0.5020616054534912,
0.21154065430164337,
-0.36760184168815613,
-0.0325060673058033,
0.4925614595413208,
0.5209085941314697,
-0.574840784072876,
-0.18228241801261902,
0.461556613445282,
-0.6604161262512207,
-0.10829830169677734,
-0.1764587163925171,
-0.928214430809021,
-0.7201555967330933,
-0.6668075919151306,
-0.09379103779792786,
-0.4109025299549103,
-0.3746526539325714,
-0.011101874522864819,
-0.4136737883090973,
-0.07050121575593948,
-0.00444961991161108,
-0.8201254606246948,
0.49173659086227417,
0.7388385534286499,
0.5266991257667542,
-0.1853657364845276,
-0.013814249075949192,
-0.5709753632545471,
0.07645604014396667,
-0.15228092670440674,
0.36346694827079773,
-0.8459232449531555,
-0.22278237342834473,
-0.19081661105155945,
-0.10341392457485199,
0.08192621171474457,
-0.6784272193908691,
0.6790377497673035,
-0.024631092324852943,
0.25930172204971313,
-0.6194971203804016,
-0.35997337102890015,
-0.28441673517227173,
-0.20443056523799896,
-0.5753626823425293,
0.4717181921005249,
0.3576469123363495,
-1.1312532424926758,
0.4754347503185272,
-0.9071251153945923,
-0.7078542113304138,
-0.10465066134929657,
-0.696815550327301,
-0.3566063940525055,
0.16287720203399658,
0.05794868245720863,
0.06275399774312973,
-0.26867398619651794,
0.5590777397155762,
-0.6039857864379883,
-0.2909543514251709,
0.24819828569889069,
-0.43698081374168396,
1.2561980485916138,
0.4234714210033417,
-0.5620325207710266,
-0.03231024369597435,
-0.7677286863327026,
0.1379326730966568,
-0.17220135033130646,
0.32584652304649353,
-0.31071358919143677,
0.40386441349983215,
0.33157527446746826,
0.17206156253814697,
-0.23265410959720612,
-0.44165217876434326,
-0.3135441839694977,
-0.47145330905914307,
0.6760558485984802,
0.8296722769737244,
-0.1779216229915619,
0.16276276111602783,
-0.8616769909858704,
0.667172908782959,
0.3632516860961914,
0.4481898844242096,
0.5243968367576599,
-0.7084193825721741,
-0.18929049372673035,
-0.38468310236930847,
0.4403301179409027,
0.7089632153511047,
-0.3920564651489258,
0.3912063539028168,
-0.15766435861587524,
-0.3042770326137543,
-1.0299571752548218,
-0.4851876199245453,
-0.019539279863238335,
0.7260743379592896,
0.3133939504623413,
-0.3087264895439148,
-0.6043364405632019,
-1.1672451496124268,
-0.24153010547161102,
0.1719619184732437,
-0.040832869708538055,
0.4630299210548401,
0.399088591337204,
-0.24439182877540588,
1.1459920406341553,
-0.049919478595256805,
-0.1988086849451065,
0.18961766362190247,
-0.11582174897193909,
-0.08459626883268356,
0.7680560350418091,
0.7027720808982849,
-0.8803520798683167,
-0.03737621754407883,
-0.38667038083076477,
-0.9647630453109741,
-0.008596718311309814,
0.5397412776947021,
0.08899467438459396,
-0.2101249247789383,
-0.11908252537250519,
-0.23901459574699402,
0.47343742847442627,
0.6203052401542664,
-0.29722458124160767,
-0.045344386249780655,
0.25968560576438904,
0.41646653413772583,
-0.8273067474365234,
0.26558688282966614,
-0.15644881129264832,
-0.16224339604377747,
-0.6651393175125122,
-0.40061506628990173,
-0.5977392792701721,
-0.16568347811698914,
-0.3049853444099426,
0.2318558692932129,
0.2130247801542282,
-0.09574101120233536,
-0.056805066764354706,
-0.0019647444132715464,
-0.19909775257110596,
-0.14062505960464478,
-0.5077194571495056,
0.48242253065109253,
0.977318525314331,
-0.4376119077205658,
0.16650676727294922,
0.22806380689144135,
-0.24219930171966553,
1.0031064748764038,
-0.6360667943954468,
0.1693572700023651,
-0.42767995595932007,
0.055422116070985794,
-0.2358502745628357,
-0.21638308465480804,
0.3769584000110626,
-0.7077611088752747,
0.08617749810218811,
0.3059055209159851,
-0.2596617639064789,
-0.2577701210975647,
-0.10708434134721756,
0.7040167450904846,
0.49751052260398865,
-0.12818118929862976,
0.08345380425453186,
1.5092345476150513,
-0.18175245821475983,
-0.9134829044342041,
-1.0792508125305176,
0.165500208735466,
-0.557584822177887,
-0.5718330144882202,
0.466501384973526,
0.010926415212452412,
-0.7093062996864319,
0.05810180678963661,
0.20228710770606995,
-0.3076058626174927,
0.2965758442878723,
0.3280818462371826,
-0.33935078978538513,
0.12412036210298538,
0.19469261169433594,
0.1924990713596344,
-0.06440067291259766,
0.11716519296169281,
-0.27577710151672363,
0.28762519359588623,
0.036654870957136154,
-0.3710614740848541,
-0.40703320503234863,
0.905606746673584,
0.2632213234901428,
-0.12191371619701385,
0.30140334367752075,
0.6132329702377319,
-0.8921151161193848,
-0.07510636001825333,
-0.2780161201953888,
-0.34405770897865295,
-0.36219051480293274,
0.23938797414302826,
0.08077412843704224,
-1.0237499475479126,
0.5404258966445923,
0.23630769550800323,
0.14647655189037323,
0.30200597643852234,
0.3723284900188446,
-0.22488068044185638,
1.2339084148406982,
0.6190412640571594,
-0.23190423846244812,
0.11032900214195251,
0.2155405879020691,
0.345488041639328,
-0.4160210192203522,
-0.0662088617682457,
-0.8190038204193115,
-0.5197932720184326,
-1.0651147365570068,
-0.13765907287597656,
0.10362707078456879,
-0.4810706377029419,
-0.3383600115776062,
-0.3122998774051666,
-0.9550405144691467,
0.11012002825737,
0.5714223384857178,
0.1750667542219162,
0.2754301428794861,
-0.0518282875418663,
0.09713400900363922,
-0.6586626172065735,
-0.6918039917945862,
-0.6021493673324585,
0.9864421486854553,
0.44965288043022156,
0.7234469056129456,
-0.09908416122198105,
0.4820336401462555,
0.8192951679229736,
0.12460622936487198,
-0.505859911441803,
0.07390720397233963,
-0.44228696823120117,
-0.8993784785270691,
-0.2992928922176361,
-0.6922149062156677,
-1.1572314500808716,
-0.18331657350063324,
0.17441879212856293,
-0.8507407307624817,
0.7665096521377563,
0.1540616750717163,
-0.2516304552555084,
0.2980390191078186,
-0.30031970143318176,
0.5216944813728333,
-0.16528263688087463,
0.11028587073087692,
-0.3327006697654724,
-0.6934858560562134,
0.2909628450870514,
-0.06975168734788895,
0.27153128385543823,
-0.5594720244407654,
0.19556361436843872,
1.0230218172073364,
0.021019358187913895,
0.7355687618255615,
-0.35059815645217896,
0.023966073989868164,
0.14877812564373016,
-0.340046226978302,
-0.19910839200019836,
0.19402843713760376,
-0.3797587752342224,
0.6712745428085327,
0.14180736243724823,
-0.3483760952949524,
-0.33896538615226746,
0.6657450199127197,
-0.8468607664108276,
-0.5025081634521484,
-0.5804611444473267,
-0.6812330484390259,
-0.6881475448608398,
0.14989088475704193,
0.15280213952064514,
0.24283233284950256,
-0.08129207789897919,
0.10797867923974991,
0.700081467628479,
-0.3193220794200897,
0.03660682588815689,
0.11722594499588013,
-0.018827926367521286,
-0.4659386873245239,
0.8465665578842163,
0.5690348744392395,
-0.3014138340950012,
-0.24081480503082275,
-0.17508549988269806,
-0.14121557772159576,
-0.5913314819335938,
-0.03643079102039337,
-0.10637147724628448,
-0.5602224469184875,
-0.14770406484603882,
-0.44267821311950684,
-0.334378719329834,
-0.6731732487678528,
0.10374335944652557,
-0.23646453022956848,
-0.8215590119361877,
-0.2622404992580414,
-0.1854630559682846,
0.43863150477409363,
0.5906524062156677,
-0.4143604040145874,
-0.03528105467557907,
-0.30783361196517944,
0.45658090710639954,
0.15007849037647247,
0.5695176720619202,
0.054987430572509766,
-0.33168095350265503,
0.04672074690461159,
0.457933634519577,
-0.35134199261665344,
-0.5501056909561157,
0.2813282907009125,
0.020038388669490814,
0.8482978343963623,
0.14743538200855255,
0.17457228899002075,
0.5790295004844666,
-0.45696642994880676,
0.7044057846069336,
0.09272612631320953,
-0.8824924826622009,
0.8303667306900024,
-0.17535896599292755,
-0.2205040603876114,
0.800469696521759,
0.6763910055160522,
-0.7062051892280579,
-0.5317702293395996,
-0.933631956577301,
-0.6681339144706726,
0.6641640663146973,
0.5276843905448914,
-0.0026191198267042637,
0.06670534610748291,
0.16161805391311646,
0.31807494163513184,
0.33881744742393494,
-0.22656132280826569,
-0.5464749336242676,
-0.45731762051582336,
-0.22098727524280548,
-0.06651365011930466,
0.24443230032920837,
-0.8211997151374817,
-0.42618414759635925,
0.37620750069618225,
-0.0153023237362504,
0.24919839203357697,
0.17989838123321533,
0.2467731535434723,
-0.035578370094299316,
0.15642598271369934,
0.3571939468383789,
0.8121399879455566,
0.015308263711631298,
0.05336365848779678,
-0.11417865008115768,
-0.5433459281921387,
0.17623820900917053,
0.337866872549057,
-0.23481829464435577,
0.06897252053022385,
-0.09766024351119995,
0.5608689785003662,
-0.35334575176239014,
-0.7530366778373718,
0.27095067501068115,
-0.17155390977859497,
-0.08991522341966629,
-0.0926700010895729,
0.1426788717508316,
0.015236182138323784,
0.31791678071022034,
-0.04170217365026474,
0.2569267749786377,
0.5907793045043945,
-0.37639090418815613,
0.47766366600990295,
0.34343940019607544,
-0.4401145279407501,
-0.16643252968788147,
0.6564263701438904,
0.14728079736232758,
-0.4760320782661438,
1.091827630996704,
0.3319430649280548,
0.17655321955680847,
0.6712921857833862,
0.2622445523738861,
0.6449522376060486,
-0.2060200423002243,
0.15012921392917633,
-0.1251341700553894,
0.31790608167648315,
0.17942950129508972,
0.5516639947891235,
0.3579592704772949,
-0.5837236046791077,
-0.023789165541529655,
-0.210225448012352,
-0.5628042817115784,
0.21426056325435638,
-0.803986668586731,
0.022509567439556122,
-0.3810057044029236,
-1.0683791637420654,
0.28074198961257935,
-0.048683930188417435,
-0.6475028395652771,
0.3008846342563629,
0.3250037431716919,
0.6079902052879333,
-0.6030430197715759,
0.7079713940620422,
0.40901297330856323,
-0.3950958549976349,
-0.09978635609149933,
-0.12603922188282013,
0.11976130306720734,
-0.6712314486503601,
0.2838424742221832,
-0.023748021572828293,
0.05615294724702835,
-0.2661854028701782,
-0.6051235198974609,
-0.8236678838729858,
0.7182496786117554,
0.8379321098327637,
-0.5140907168388367,
-0.0007433069404214621,
0.4158833920955658,
0.49705225229263306,
-0.30687934160232544,
0.10637915879487991,
0.4860689043998718,
0.7394989728927612,
-0.2963356077671051,
-1.0187216997146606,
-0.06306463479995728,
-0.26317334175109863,
0.15740714967250824,
-0.3268243968486786,
-0.45855826139450073,
0.803200900554657,
-0.24172522127628326,
-0.18978257477283478,
-0.46147313714027405,
0.43023449182510376,
0.3241133987903595,
0.558853268623352,
0.3716276288032532,
0.7195296287536621,
1.4805364608764648,
-0.1697644144296646,
0.7943388819694519,
0.003173128003254533,
-0.009944213554263115,
1.0963979959487915,
-0.437582790851593,
0.14644235372543335,
0.19524532556533813,
-0.23926787078380585,
0.15216577053070068,
0.7736347913742065,
-0.24029341340065002,
0.39771783351898193,
0.6140283346176147,
-0.17330048978328705,
0.06262002885341644,
-0.6521142721176147,
-0.7454921007156372,
0.6574560403823853,
0.6748623847961426,
-0.4519432783126831,
-0.10633239895105362,
0.28880107402801514,
0.07130606472492218,
0.06757213920354843,
-0.034980349242687225,
0.36378318071365356,
0.28446999192237854,
-0.1096915751695633,
0.06557171046733856,
-0.08511892706155777,
0.5936475396156311,
-0.24256840348243713,
-0.09998240321874619,
-0.06433876603841782,
-0.1496133655309677,
-0.39969712495803833,
-0.7130135893821716,
0.7312412261962891,
0.027236640453338623,
-0.5864167213439941,
-0.09376584738492966,
0.7071554660797119,
0.011520728468894958,
-0.34989944100379944,
0.23700331151485443,
0.5755688548088074,
0.23358623683452606,
0.05929343029856682,
-0.9307267665863037,
0.051266878843307495,
-0.07626212388277054,
0.1494140923023224,
0.38621824979782104,
0.3232089579105377,
-0.15708500146865845,
0.8664100170135498,
0.5073305368423462,
0.35281902551651,
-0.16762810945510864,
0.3035223186016083,
0.585417628288269,
-0.6656402349472046,
-0.37406960129737854,
-0.6458213925361633,
0.35942700505256653,
-0.31752970814704895,
-0.47189077734947205,
0.6082974076271057,
0.3502521216869354,
0.5055825710296631,
0.3300718665122986,
1.0285699367523193,
-0.10461445152759552,
0.6968140602111816,
0.028583088889718056,
1.153416395187378,
-0.3250526189804077,
-0.14199498295783997,
-0.07033628970384598,
-0.38761287927627563,
-0.4211800992488861,
0.7063697576522827,
-0.10124032199382782,
0.4505622982978821,
0.2766198515892029,
0.6406667232513428,
0.19223082065582275,
0.4471130669116974,
0.19324436783790588,
0.20607860386371613,
0.45674386620521545,
0.5323006510734558,
0.8366587162017822,
-0.2766337990760803,
-0.07830087840557098,
-0.33962172269821167,
-0.2942534387111664,
0.3855621814727783,
-0.7936909794807434,
-0.42175328731536865,
-0.5641127228736877,
-0.5047289729118347,
-0.34785374999046326,
0.46995142102241516,
0.5885023474693298,
0.9672055244445801,
-0.9303380846977234,
-0.12891845405101776,
0.19919465482234955,
0.4166233539581299,
-0.46393588185310364,
-0.2898878753185272,
0.0569356270134449,
-0.09661386162042618,
-0.703906774520874,
0.22846925258636475,
0.07430976629257202,
-0.12315993756055832,
-0.17172309756278992,
0.1612563282251358,
0.17789973318576813,
0.09448211640119553,
0.3220721185207367,
0.38114723563194275,
-0.4044209122657776,
-0.193411186337471,
-0.33064061403274536,
-0.159759521484375,
0.11736676841974258,
0.6606719493865967,
-0.7818469405174255,
0.18719208240509033,
0.24540942907333374,
0.7433732151985168,
-0.2330569177865982,
-0.3651127517223358,
0.6566126346588135,
-0.18456332385540009,
-0.10645710676908493,
1.078385829925537,
0.23213456571102142,
0.33356258273124695,
-0.5326398015022278,
0.536950409412384,
0.1859247237443924,
-0.7567224502563477,
-0.9999693036079407,
0.0360054112970829,
-1.06621253490448,
-0.047431595623493195,
0.6812002062797546,
0.15479923784732819,
0.1893964558839798,
-0.4893738329410553,
0.057199876755476,
0.27889305353164673,
-0.46324437856674194,
1.1017614603042603,
0.5732792615890503,
-0.515445351600647,
0.24956953525543213,
-0.8160971999168396,
0.9158092141151428,
0.41029292345046997,
-0.9260579347610474,
0.2577248513698578,
0.575346827507019,
0.18375873565673828,
-0.18359850347042084,
0.6715697646141052,
-0.47753041982650757,
0.3363967537879944,
0.04704729840159416,
-0.2599259912967682,
0.19482651352882385,
-0.15347756445407867,
-0.3889068067073822,
0.13407769799232483,
-0.2674809694290161,
-0.027190033346414566
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.04113v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.04113v1
|
Uncovering Limitations of Large Language Models in Information Seeking from Tables
| 2024-06-06T14:30:59 | 2024-06-06T14:30:59 |
Chaoxu Pang, Yixuan Cao, Chunhao Yang, Ping Luo
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Tables are recognized for their high information density and widespread
usage, serving as essential sources of information. Seeking information from
tables (TIS) is a crucial capability for Large Language Models (LLMs), serving
as the foundation of knowledge-based Q&A systems. However, this field presently
suffers from an absence of thorough and reliable evaluation. This paper
introduces a more reliable benchmark for Table Information Seeking (TabIS). To
avoid the unreliable evaluation caused by text similarity-based metrics, TabIS
adopts a single-choice question format (with two options per question) instead
of a text generation format. We establish an effective pipeline for generating
options, ensuring their difficulty and quality. Experiments conducted on 12
LLMs reveal that while the performance of GPT-4-turbo is marginally
satisfactory, both other proprietary and open-source models perform
inadequately. Further analysis shows that LLMs exhibit a poor understanding of
table structures, and struggle to balance between TIS performance and
robustness against pseudo-relevant tables (common in retrieval-augmented
systems). These findings uncover the limitations and potential challenges of
LLMs in seeking information from tables. We release our data and code to
facilitate further research in this field.
|
[
-0.21390114724636078,
-0.7372794151306152,
0.92820143699646,
-0.007119025569409132,
-0.28534284234046936,
-0.020286493003368378,
-0.23190660774707794,
-0.35487475991249084,
-0.12262580543756485,
0.4005792438983917,
-0.4666838049888611,
-0.5680270195007324,
-0.3646928369998932,
0.07080096006393433,
-0.4768114387989044,
0.9167208671569824,
-0.11426644772291183,
-0.00504043186083436,
-0.2029542773962021,
-0.11706464737653732,
-0.5009761452674866,
-0.43262913823127747,
-0.4846772253513336,
0.02503732219338417,
0.758560299873352,
0.6174452900886536,
0.705842912197113,
0.510793924331665,
0.6917789578437805,
0.1597106158733368,
0.007152814418077469,
0.13676872849464417,
-0.5440505743026733,
0.25428470969200134,
0.002881145104765892,
-0.6237073540687561,
-0.21972472965717316,
-0.023937005549669266,
0.97173672914505,
0.4018923342227936,
-0.2651291787624359,
0.5049344301223755,
0.03632519394159317,
0.7497801184654236,
-0.5990957617759705,
0.33965250849723816,
-1.0256868600845337,
0.114726722240448,
-0.7549586892127991,
-0.24782702326774597,
-0.5185513496398926,
-0.6323035955429077,
0.16092966496944427,
-0.38226523995399475,
0.09506934881210327,
0.18203793466091156,
1.0144675970077515,
-0.021775254979729652,
-0.5259554386138916,
-0.36640578508377075,
-0.8497072458267212,
0.45544588565826416,
-0.7405158281326294,
0.9289055466651917,
0.3832017481327057,
0.45069244503974915,
-0.3899872899055481,
-0.8392500877380371,
-0.7048487663269043,
-0.5541625022888184,
-0.05711023136973381,
-0.284125953912735,
-0.1395319253206253,
-0.20219893753528595,
0.5237977504730225,
0.2437867820262909,
-0.8858674168586731,
-0.07101723551750183,
-0.2735550105571747,
-0.04733309894800186,
0.1715240627527237,
0.18094652891159058,
0.203569695353508,
-0.186412051320076,
-0.2474983036518097,
-0.27917414903640747,
-0.9272505044937134,
0.2275668978691101,
0.3878612518310547,
0.43429073691368103,
0.08482152223587036,
0.744636058807373,
-0.03229823708534241,
0.7587066292762756,
-0.4223577380180359,
0.07584306597709656,
0.1423139125108719,
-0.22992029786109924,
0.08008157461881638,
-0.5206181406974792,
0.6047101616859436,
0.06462999433279037,
0.1439943164587021,
-0.4302537143230438,
-0.2390202432870865,
-0.34865790605545044,
0.24672673642635345,
-0.5087985992431641,
0.0021732496097683907,
0.11640647053718567,
-0.10071778297424316,
0.2774820923805237,
0.10900688916444778,
-0.9238880276679993,
-0.3952757716178894,
-0.025040460750460625,
0.3764190971851349,
-0.31563088297843933,
-0.13133899867534637,
-0.396846204996109,
-0.1901455521583557,
0.4871014654636383,
0.09621218591928482,
-0.6465336084365845,
0.2817642390727997,
0.4408723711967468,
0.8265845775604248,
-0.5013348460197449,
-0.18433041870594025,
-0.6508322358131409,
0.2449750155210495,
-0.437582790851593,
0.9318409562110901,
-0.6372642517089844,
-0.3469904959201813,
-0.051002103835344315,
-0.20638570189476013,
-0.002289446070790291,
-0.7117688655853271,
0.6594761610031128,
-0.774390697479248,
-0.15423309803009033,
-0.7672237753868103,
-0.37206777930259705,
0.12035974115133286,
0.41019630432128906,
-0.9765582084655762,
1.1540074348449707,
0.09343618154525757,
-0.7255104780197144,
0.7776475548744202,
-0.5450757145881653,
-0.16545335948467255,
0.09770907461643219,
-0.4819960594177246,
-0.5005455613136292,
0.13762648403644562,
0.024271074682474136,
0.21544606983661652,
-0.5706643462181091,
0.44415047764778137,
-0.48845797777175903,
-0.37704649567604065,
0.4061402976512909,
-0.4638802409172058,
0.11382218450307846,
0.1942291557788849,
-0.2296193242073059,
0.08447002619504929,
-0.6510946750640869,
0.22534601390361786,
0.34537503123283386,
-0.5721736550331116,
-0.22048954665660858,
0.41614556312561035,
-0.11713739484548569,
0.23579265177249908,
0.23313473165035248,
-0.5465102791786194,
-0.019378822296857834,
-0.0641007274389267,
0.3596974313259125,
0.5772291421890259,
-0.17742320895195007,
0.0873677134513855,
-0.23874236643314362,
0.41634830832481384,
0.004685054067522287,
-0.0653473511338234,
0.31904491782188416,
-0.17137669026851654,
-0.594297468662262,
0.21967220306396484,
0.3241054117679596,
0.3901691734790802,
-0.8100858926773071,
-0.007437144406139851,
-0.3499205708503723,
-0.5744764804840088,
-0.29483675956726074,
0.04129251837730408,
0.3419199585914612,
0.43485602736473083,
0.3883410692214966,
-0.03448231518268585,
-0.5304242372512817,
-1.047713041305542,
-0.4703250229358673,
-0.20082585513591766,
-0.10142109543085098,
0.5006609559059143,
0.39311715960502625,
0.19719278812408447,
0.8750712871551514,
-0.3016332983970642,
-0.0926288366317749,
-0.6109766364097595,
-0.00887137372046709,
0.27211275696754456,
0.16715441644191742,
0.2790551781654358,
-0.8210105299949646,
-0.5302609205245972,
-0.022726306691765785,
-0.5588043928146362,
0.17822889983654022,
0.3647485673427582,
0.05956540256738663,
0.18892720341682434,
0.3551437258720398,
-0.5799853205680847,
0.4728822410106659,
0.25083160400390625,
-0.007502211257815361,
0.40786120295524597,
-0.06004057079553604,
0.16471140086650848,
-0.6695680618286133,
0.5832548141479492,
0.19659841060638428,
-0.02167193777859211,
-0.5710164308547974,
0.12353499978780746,
0.3072132170200348,
-0.18580059707164764,
-0.29830628633499146,
0.6661375164985657,
-0.6372998952865601,
-0.3459053933620453,
0.11151913553476334,
0.45523276925086975,
-0.1116713434457779,
0.3916058838367462,
-0.1448449194431305,
1.1460533142089844,
0.11845246702432632,
-0.6588257551193237,
0.07622195780277252,
0.17516900599002838,
-0.4981628656387329,
0.3457801342010498,
-0.46922075748443604,
0.2741800546646118,
-0.21552222967147827,
0.19300124049186707,
-1.090952754020691,
-0.24919186532497406,
0.04096297547221184,
-0.1627860963344574,
0.44931551814079285,
0.08660605549812317,
-0.5402563810348511,
-0.783997654914856,
-0.3360418975353241,
0.398333340883255,
0.19347907602787018,
-0.5697878003120422,
0.36611175537109375,
0.7207421064376831,
-0.2921687960624695,
-0.9299447536468506,
-0.3038311302661896,
0.14867083728313446,
-0.23234501481056213,
-0.3831180930137634,
0.06904853880405426,
0.03845538571476936,
-0.07918525487184525,
-0.10119321942329407,
-0.6429598331451416,
-0.1299765259027481,
-0.10682404041290283,
-0.2060563862323761,
0.10635517537593842,
-0.245356485247612,
0.33104634284973145,
-0.24429477751255035,
0.2265440821647644,
0.021330196410417557,
-0.08533329516649246,
0.7453839182853699,
-0.3285796344280243,
-0.2643868327140808,
-0.25150343775749207,
0.21339046955108643,
0.4109255373477936,
-0.39922964572906494,
0.6084893345832825,
0.2547954320907593,
-0.34659120440483093,
-0.26299726963043213,
-1.0136792659759521,
-0.17921806871891022,
-0.45722293853759766,
0.654032826423645,
-0.4639247953891754,
-0.8342623710632324,
0.7651588320732117,
0.24095472693443298,
0.002834852784872055,
0.5771791338920593,
0.16125217080116272,
-0.04365400969982147,
0.8780459761619568,
0.5241008400917053,
0.05194832757115364,
0.33772018551826477,
-0.044600412249565125,
0.12264149636030197,
-0.6372478604316711,
-0.42859476804733276,
-1.101099967956543,
-0.20381209254264832,
-0.5645461082458496,
-0.08327911049127579,
0.6162417531013489,
-0.19991253316402435,
-0.08130624145269394,
0.3387332558631897,
-0.27910056710243225,
0.523634672164917,
0.5775888562202454,
0.24026066064834595,
0.4933169484138489,
0.04951977729797363,
-0.2721083462238312,
-0.11581091582775116,
-0.7259766459465027,
-0.5786912441253662,
1.0576062202453613,
0.3368876576423645,
0.730657696723938,
0.07311555743217468,
0.30898529291152954,
0.12535753846168518,
0.3295372724533081,
-0.4250089228153229,
0.6510937809944153,
-0.1823432594537735,
-0.9325075745582581,
-0.6980528235435486,
-0.909049391746521,
-0.9097504615783691,
0.13252700865268707,
-0.001961724366992712,
-0.9252207279205322,
-0.06761489808559418,
0.12884654104709625,
-0.14054623246192932,
0.5175958275794983,
-0.5871473550796509,
1.0371211767196655,
-0.25362628698349,
-0.49774742126464844,
0.10417989641427994,
-0.5932018160820007,
0.28073328733444214,
-0.11497008055448532,
0.21598930656909943,
-0.22250406444072723,
0.09842658787965775,
0.70143723487854,
-0.08693544566631317,
0.3050493597984314,
-0.1407778561115265,
-0.07863923907279968,
0.44959020614624023,
0.18908832967281342,
0.5734473466873169,
-0.018193049356341362,
-0.2689202129840851,
-0.10085904598236084,
0.13231204450130463,
-0.22767823934555054,
-0.5500218272209167,
0.711885392665863,
-0.35969212651252747,
-0.7076146602630615,
-0.35545188188552856,
-0.5276235342025757,
-0.5661939382553101,
0.2889132797718048,
0.24960699677467346,
0.5067023038864136,
-0.2808193564414978,
0.266217440366745,
0.5019823312759399,
-0.2510543465614319,
0.41093942523002625,
0.5830729603767395,
-0.1409195065498352,
0.028637021780014038,
0.8573154807090759,
0.35681235790252686,
-0.04133495315909386,
0.4904749095439911,
0.027736756950616837,
-0.7189595103263855,
-0.7370649576187134,
-0.5964543223381042,
0.1778448075056076,
-0.42333370447158813,
-0.3349369168281555,
-0.5054855346679688,
-0.24368473887443542,
-0.10228356719017029,
0.5953920483589172,
-0.2656858563423157,
-0.1316271722316742,
-0.13026243448257446,
-0.15822385251522064,
0.10451924800872803,
0.8612646460533142,
0.3133811950683594,
0.13997100293636322,
-0.8097729086875916,
0.18273349106311798,
0.28241273760795593,
1.0051336288452148,
0.11127310246229172,
-0.43564632534980774,
-0.14902560412883759,
-0.034514714032411575,
-0.2797677516937256,
-1.2186094522476196,
0.11652297526597977,
0.042339056730270386,
0.7772705554962158,
-0.0089881531894207,
0.04274250566959381,
0.5157216787338257,
-0.42730626463890076,
0.5447037220001221,
-0.2952485680580139,
-0.7329021096229553,
0.3884538412094116,
-0.34806713461875916,
0.23891395330429077,
0.8662112355232239,
0.47859588265419006,
-0.3284089267253876,
-0.36734768748283386,
-0.23439380526542664,
-0.8920676708221436,
0.8738535046577454,
0.18142981827259064,
-0.11964928358793259,
-0.22275792062282562,
0.5434723496437073,
0.1441803127527237,
0.34833231568336487,
-1.243257999420166,
0.0005792016163468361,
0.41232094168663025,
0.09538521617650986,
0.09915021806955338,
-0.33979523181915283,
0.2738443911075592,
-0.012901200912892818,
0.7482514381408691,
0.13815489411354065,
0.12097160518169403,
0.09549284726381302,
-0.021266886964440346,
-0.3875996768474579,
0.66520756483078,
0.374717652797699,
0.7437164783477783,
-0.37067145109176636,
0.15540800988674164,
0.34841811656951904,
-0.38437628746032715,
-0.12359021604061127,
0.1778346449136734,
-0.07600206136703491,
0.08021436631679535,
-0.23146089911460876,
0.7979480028152466,
-0.05579322203993797,
-0.820564866065979,
0.4044438600540161,
-0.15375575423240662,
0.19998300075531006,
-0.2615545392036438,
-0.05286859720945358,
0.013476554304361343,
0.03364952653646469,
0.46959829330444336,
-0.5617031455039978,
0.24162796139717102,
-0.7983413934707642,
0.3221728205680847,
0.8332091569900513,
-0.5345826148986816,
-0.09266266971826553,
0.5716113448143005,
-0.08834435790777206,
-0.30787593126296997,
0.6901751756668091,
-0.18314921855926514,
-0.18678633868694305,
0.4287729263305664,
0.4385668635368347,
0.5559824705123901,
-0.20369893312454224,
0.334829181432724,
0.33805590867996216,
0.4320705831050873,
-0.24135997891426086,
0.5324214100837708,
0.08141225576400757,
-0.3579980432987213,
-0.33169686794281006,
-0.5847595930099487,
-0.5763254165649414,
0.559726893901825,
-0.4398426413536072,
0.2517338991165161,
-0.17709524929523468,
-0.45727938413619995,
-0.1880437582731247,
-0.07873585820198059,
-0.7973495125770569,
-0.07218507677316666,
-0.13018105924129486,
0.993862509727478,
-0.4470071494579315,
0.6451135277748108,
0.5224384069442749,
-0.46770983934402466,
-1.1041710376739502,
-0.06647427380084991,
-0.28407955169677734,
-0.5973308086395264,
0.19539940357208252,
0.11708018183708191,
0.13058677315711975,
-0.1189759224653244,
-0.5789015293121338,
-1.0132826566696167,
0.8544136881828308,
0.4578940272331238,
-0.6284534335136414,
-0.5130866765975952,
0.5657844543457031,
0.6402421593666077,
0.0676819458603859,
0.4503357410430908,
0.9337834715843201,
0.6378235816955566,
0.0192140843719244,
-1.1046867370605469,
0.03137639909982681,
-0.2658193111419678,
-0.22823412716388702,
0.5722132921218872,
-0.5051140785217285,
0.6951966881752014,
-0.13408571481704712,
-0.45211178064346313,
0.05368305370211601,
0.41504141688346863,
0.23316514492034912,
0.4907546937465668,
0.40460383892059326,
0.4306764304637909,
0.5864193439483643,
-0.30590584874153137,
0.900816023349762,
-0.076329305768013,
0.2577502429485321,
1.1446253061294556,
-0.49594229459762573,
1.0498665571212769,
0.43994346261024475,
-0.30954691767692566,
0.2758384048938751,
0.44140681624412537,
-0.13465642929077148,
0.18657231330871582,
0.5196610689163208,
0.029045576229691505,
-0.08095613121986389,
0.03350451588630676,
-0.4351067841053009,
0.432524174451828,
0.4206768572330475,
-0.13236087560653687,
-0.4798612594604492,
-0.3915783762931824,
-0.20993953943252563,
0.09232695400714874,
-0.08017118275165558,
0.794376790523529,
-0.06717761605978012,
-0.735273003578186,
0.2930086553096771,
-0.14982828497886658,
0.13931213319301605,
-0.6909016966819763,
-0.041667208075523376,
-0.25657084584236145,
-0.26019805669784546,
0.06857910007238388,
-0.7761581540107727,
0.06561051309108734,
0.143833190202713,
0.14861810207366943,
0.29941460490226746,
0.5139992237091064,
-0.34130439162254333,
-0.23741957545280457,
0.08853374421596527,
0.9748528599739075,
0.2182968705892563,
-0.12114203721284866,
-0.3768612742424011,
0.08227308839559555,
-0.050037868320941925,
-0.33012935519218445,
0.24125368893146515,
0.5596700310707092,
-0.04874424636363983,
0.7364698648452759,
0.30614012479782104,
0.021920744329690933,
0.08181330561637878,
-0.16187350451946259,
0.8023591637611389,
-0.7333769798278809,
-0.32529065012931824,
-0.8125779628753662,
0.17357607185840607,
-0.008628412149846554,
-0.3339555859565735,
0.5879391431808472,
0.9670543670654297,
0.763555645942688,
-0.09034842997789383,
0.5864334106445312,
0.03784780576825142,
0.815298855304718,
-0.5234578847885132,
0.7113062739372253,
-0.6593462824821472,
0.5150719285011292,
-0.41083991527557373,
-1.3247677087783813,
-0.2572338581085205,
0.22017833590507507,
-0.3895280361175537,
0.2724590003490448,
0.7928211688995361,
0.6675911545753479,
-0.05412043258547783,
0.0531235933303833,
0.3017226457595825,
0.2337123304605484,
0.29851484298706055,
0.46086204051971436,
1.0069193840026855,
-0.1002742201089859,
1.0109660625457764,
0.09245316684246063,
0.03156855329871178,
0.03558797016739845,
-0.6737203598022461,
-0.7057859301567078,
-0.7497690916061401,
0.20026181638240814,
-0.19298644363880157,
0.2401771992444992,
0.8113183975219727,
0.39713403582572937,
-0.6917732954025269,
-0.3948994576931,
-0.08579474687576294,
0.21589288115501404,
0.2986234128475189,
-0.16897185146808624,
0.4253230690956116,
-0.35646942257881165,
-0.4070969820022583,
0.29328522086143494,
0.21905888617038727,
0.03805840015411377,
-0.07297682017087936,
0.40923795104026794,
-0.23005132377147675,
0.023927675560116768,
0.20290081202983856,
0.5733619928359985,
-0.5998440384864807,
-0.39154231548309326,
0.18214696645736694,
-0.25394630432128906,
0.27775639295578003,
0.8800287842750549,
-0.5284736752510071,
0.1222814992070198,
0.3176717460155487,
0.5877410769462585,
0.7841445207595825,
-0.07445820420980453,
0.4366961419582367,
-0.6539164781570435,
-0.3112429976463318,
0.3996753990650177,
0.2948133051395416,
0.2739156484603882,
-0.12627890706062317,
0.48611173033714294,
-0.2371922880411148,
-0.5509806275367737,
-0.9533025622367859,
0.16276125609874725,
-0.8997470736503601,
-0.02064364403486252,
1.0580135583877563,
0.06427620351314545,
-0.12351174652576447,
-0.10919640213251114,
-0.189442977309227,
0.2925516366958618,
-0.5300822257995605,
1.0097415447235107,
0.69675612449646,
-0.018012244254350662,
-0.09198404103517532,
-0.7583501935005188,
0.6611936688423157,
0.3395429849624634,
-0.894601583480835,
0.29126229882240295,
0.5086298584938049,
0.2134213000535965,
0.05383370816707611,
0.5679935216903687,
-0.2919028103351593,
0.16634225845336914,
-0.18361051380634308,
-0.01093745231628418,
0.17862555384635925,
-0.5999993085861206,
0.01371026411652565,
0.5269940495491028,
0.35958442091941833,
0.30819767713546753
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.04109v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.04109v1
|
Intention and Face in Dialog
| 2024-06-06T14:26:35 | 2024-06-06T14:26:35 |
Adil Soubki, Owen Rambow
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The notion of face described by Brown and Levinson (1987) has been studied in
great detail, but a critical aspect of the framework, that which focuses on how
intentions mediate the planning of turns which impose upon face, has received
far less attention. We present an analysis of three computational systems
trained for classifying both intention and politeness, focusing on how the
former influences the latter. In politeness theory, agents attend to the desire
to have their wants appreciated (positive face), and a complementary desire to
act unimpeded and maintain freedom (negative face). Similar to speech acts,
utterances can perform so-called face acts which can either raise or threaten
the positive or negative face of the speaker or hearer. We begin by using an
existing corpus to train a model which classifies face acts, achieving a new
SoTA in the process. We then observe that every face act has an underlying
intention that motivates it and perform additional experiments integrating
dialog act annotations to provide these intentions by proxy. Our analysis finds
that dialog acts improve performance on face act detection for minority classes
and points to a close relationship between aspects of face and intent.
|
[
-0.5479694604873657,
-0.7678848505020142,
0.6887792944908142,
0.332675963640213,
0.17636781930923462,
-0.39917629957199097,
-0.028956817463040352,
-0.673857569694519,
0.28768035769462585,
0.5163326859474182,
-0.8283641338348389,
-0.19087769091129303,
-0.43646013736724854,
0.17587162554264069,
-0.0858059749007225,
1.131600260734558,
0.4755755066871643,
0.529169499874115,
-0.028456222265958786,
-0.3328804671764374,
-0.47624722123146057,
-0.5962561368942261,
-0.892011821269989,
-0.6158879399299622,
0.49168360233306885,
0.3094175457954407,
0.9201315641403198,
0.05121709406375885,
0.31115326285362244,
0.38372334837913513,
0.041835177689790726,
-0.3222859799861908,
-0.5886775255203247,
0.06938577443361282,
-0.27222034335136414,
-0.433500736951828,
-0.22244635224342346,
0.5085489153862,
0.4188985526561737,
0.83491450548172,
0.0921502485871315,
-0.04853694513440132,
-0.006440260447561741,
0.6039605736732483,
-0.3150060474872589,
0.2915807366371155,
-0.28102365136146545,
0.1606302708387375,
-0.017604012042284012,
-0.22305229306221008,
-0.29242655634880066,
-0.4219210743904114,
0.2749679386615753,
-0.4016631543636322,
-0.04172448441386223,
-0.05430702120065689,
0.543425977230072,
-0.03957687318325043,
-0.29500851035118103,
-0.37874990701675415,
-0.317196786403656,
0.8291133046150208,
-0.42529767751693726,
0.4357468783855438,
0.2821003496646881,
0.3925035893917084,
-0.3042600452899933,
-0.3941909074783325,
-0.769373893737793,
-0.05328091233968735,
-0.20530931651592255,
-0.06320833414793015,
-0.30981573462486267,
0.5242676138877869,
0.5274836421012878,
0.3627479374408722,
-0.421785831451416,
-0.21586988866329193,
-0.4187842905521393,
-0.32523250579833984,
0.49109843373298645,
0.17405088245868683,
0.5035644173622131,
-0.11471759527921677,
-0.15368352830410004,
0.06340577453374863,
-0.5293651223182678,
0.4613579213619232,
0.33646687865257263,
0.6050893068313599,
-0.25035786628723145,
0.3310306966304779,
-0.5629770755767822,
0.5874467492103577,
0.09556867182254791,
-0.03942453861236572,
0.13685601949691772,
-0.0596998929977417,
-0.25779205560684204,
0.004075396340340376,
0.5929785370826721,
0.44008779525756836,
0.8048893213272095,
0.18096968531608582,
-0.13201771676540375,
0.17456243932247162,
0.27875804901123047,
-1.132401943206787,
-0.022252382710576057,
0.11382719874382019,
-0.6278973817825317,
-0.6427382230758667,
0.07708370685577393,
-0.36500993371009827,
-0.511718213558197,
-0.8284122347831726,
0.42607516050338745,
-0.29934415221214294,
-0.3065084218978882,
-0.1114112138748169,
-0.010508706793189049,
0.39781785011291504,
0.730326235294342,
-0.8125318288803101,
0.6151700615882874,
0.7934149503707886,
0.36842218041419983,
0.37989795207977295,
-0.3501427471637726,
-0.8066087365150452,
-0.31486985087394714,
-0.2564350366592407,
0.6437219381332397,
-0.8249642848968506,
-0.27110418677330017,
0.23441435396671295,
-0.0010362688917666674,
-0.06121698021888733,
-0.5412508845329285,
0.2704816162586212,
-0.42759543657302856,
0.3495887815952301,
-0.5772255659103394,
-0.11867891252040863,
-0.4614912271499634,
0.41712677478790283,
-0.387846976518631,
0.735892653465271,
0.31846877932548523,
-0.41456761956214905,
0.27077236771583557,
-0.8690148591995239,
-0.6265892386436462,
0.12789443135261536,
-0.7220352292060852,
0.0666378065943718,
0.38923272490501404,
-0.1893756240606308,
0.6210526823997498,
0.078419029712677,
0.1058754101395607,
-0.21106110513210297,
-0.45098137855529785,
0.7585397362709045,
0.11317361891269684,
1.0658597946166992,
0.17705735564231873,
-0.4884266257286072,
0.23462213575839996,
-0.1746627390384674,
0.014005200006067753,
-0.13896411657333374,
-0.01585192233324051,
-0.16036340594291687,
0.01627650111913681,
-0.059839699417352676,
0.5288531184196472,
0.1229206994175911,
-0.47745609283447266,
-0.04426495358347893,
-0.3253280222415924,
0.46300646662712097,
0.9115018844604492,
-0.12311632186174393,
0.4401046931743622,
-0.3510890603065491,
0.4169824719429016,
-0.01698371209204197,
0.6165100336074829,
-0.1057901605963707,
-0.6830592751502991,
-0.7317325472831726,
-0.02072949707508087,
-0.14078086614608765,
0.38066449761390686,
-0.7387868762016296,
-0.056475043296813965,
-0.0915880873799324,
0.01863398216664791,
-0.248529314994812,
-0.26710423827171326,
0.6150006055831909,
0.21895676851272583,
-0.04585769400000572,
-0.6059961318969727,
-0.33493101596832275,
-1.0144178867340088,
-0.319688081741333,
-0.6117603182792664,
0.277161568403244,
0.6933938264846802,
0.028372587636113167,
-0.0957215204834938,
1.0093506574630737,
-0.31458279490470886,
-0.21901045739650726,
-0.285118967294693,
0.0269774217158556,
0.12667745351791382,
0.31886202096939087,
0.8880096077919006,
-1.1036732196807861,
-0.5250129103660583,
0.021420400589704514,
-0.7237588167190552,
-0.3385085463523865,
0.0638854131102562,
-0.26696160435676575,
-0.05785473436117172,
0.6010434627532959,
-0.5452424883842468,
0.6693422794342041,
0.316281795501709,
-0.2896900773048401,
0.5501739382743835,
0.5548555850982666,
0.5534358024597168,
-0.4730829894542694,
-0.12568140029907227,
-0.07898242026567459,
-0.35827645659446716,
-1.2572498321533203,
-0.06365616619586945,
-0.2527279257774353,
-0.5482354760169983,
-0.8419449925422668,
0.8039244413375854,
-0.11325187236070633,
-0.2316344976425171,
-0.297588050365448,
-0.06418711692094803,
-0.09063073247671127,
0.7882437109947205,
0.22493717074394226,
0.8206968307495117,
0.4871774911880493,
-0.9399935007095337,
-0.15899533033370972,
0.33322760462760925,
-0.038030900061130524,
1.1976202726364136,
-0.3163895905017853,
0.24005556106567383,
-0.32604870200157166,
0.0034763256553560495,
-0.9349614381790161,
-0.4712774455547333,
0.5382599830627441,
-0.7949073314666748,
0.11762649565935135,
-0.2031956911087036,
0.08039211481809616,
-0.10771239548921585,
-0.4003211557865143,
0.37183964252471924,
0.5087820887565613,
-0.4608285427093506,
0.9620121121406555,
0.3258386254310608,
-0.3616608679294586,
-0.32740092277526855,
-0.7422470450401306,
-0.052633415907621384,
-0.10277342051267624,
-0.6396842002868652,
0.03856344893574715,
-0.14567933976650238,
-0.6683349013328552,
-0.5487855672836304,
0.1739930957555771,
-0.10856853425502777,
0.00998931284993887,
0.5599192976951599,
-0.024575186893343925,
0.21787966787815094,
-0.26094985008239746,
-0.1970495730638504,
0.09692788124084473,
0.3147364556789398,
0.14464372396469116,
0.5613841414451599,
-0.12070710211992264,
-0.049924787133932114,
-1.0885484218597412,
0.5521278977394104,
0.7248364090919495,
0.14042600989341736,
0.6483502984046936,
0.1668367087841034,
-0.4116993546485901,
0.19818086922168732,
-0.630257248878479,
-0.39278361201286316,
-0.5134074091911316,
-0.07296694070100784,
-0.6162716746330261,
-0.8043683767318726,
0.6079747080802917,
0.02569115348160267,
0.08370887488126755,
0.04158153757452965,
0.2211114466190338,
-0.24136407673358917,
0.9908496141433716,
0.7187191247940063,
0.03661425784230232,
1.005123257637024,
0.1075623631477356,
0.27955007553100586,
-0.8569661974906921,
-0.13321876525878906,
-0.5254250764846802,
-0.378849595785141,
-0.5942580103874207,
-0.13285920023918152,
0.14568966627120972,
-0.2417987883090973,
-0.13644511997699738,
0.28043338656425476,
-0.4836353659629822,
0.23419734835624695,
0.23622030019760132,
0.013804005458950996,
0.061980996280908585,
0.03902043029665947,
0.3657616674900055,
-0.18755243718624115,
-0.15333324670791626,
-0.6282464265823364,
0.6013797521591187,
0.4812304377555847,
0.373035192489624,
0.3531864881515503,
0.7315596342086792,
0.335468590259552,
0.8038800358772278,
-0.9032807946205139,
1.014336109161377,
0.05987700819969177,
-0.8145036101341248,
-0.2369018942117691,
-0.46342933177948,
-0.8373613953590393,
0.2831445336341858,
-0.04551681503653526,
-1.0313043594360352,
0.4394073188304901,
0.282517671585083,
-0.3522249460220337,
-0.23017695546150208,
-0.7595195174217224,
0.8433598279953003,
0.03146778419613838,
-0.17527984082698822,
-0.2536943554878235,
-0.6098256707191467,
0.315151184797287,
0.3695952594280243,
0.25191953778266907,
-0.34775325655937195,
0.40190133452415466,
0.8328962326049805,
-0.20790274441242218,
0.9907063841819763,
-0.7359814643859863,
0.13244417309761047,
0.5303516387939453,
0.2330065816640854,
0.414884090423584,
-0.1818525791168213,
-0.07206645607948303,
0.5244176387786865,
-0.10102716088294983,
-0.24953621625900269,
-0.6863576769828796,
0.3369253873825073,
-0.48972466588020325,
-0.47634807229042053,
-0.3166634142398834,
-0.2014671415090561,
-0.19348925352096558,
0.2854987382888794,
0.016723819077014923,
0.4906134605407715,
-0.8085496425628662,
-0.21805483102798462,
0.7511480450630188,
-0.020556865260004997,
0.14103300869464874,
0.6388756632804871,
-0.670402467250824,
-0.13604742288589478,
0.7263478636741638,
-0.1042027398943901,
0.5573590397834778,
0.10315810889005661,
0.1697438806295395,
-0.04117756709456444,
-0.3967709243297577,
-0.21653330326080322,
0.20184876024723053,
-0.6488320827484131,
-0.008451852947473526,
-0.7668940424919128,
-0.24591179192066193,
-0.6348586082458496,
-0.25859662890434265,
-0.09752807021141052,
-0.414108008146286,
-0.20610114932060242,
0.29482024908065796,
0.22295597195625305,
0.8214747905731201,
0.034701868891716,
0.6471268534660339,
-0.1811375617980957,
0.08677893877029419,
0.6080971360206604,
0.22539721429347992,
-0.13094264268875122,
-0.3416022062301636,
0.12394537776708603,
0.1907942146062851,
-0.3831985592842102,
-0.789572536945343,
-0.03201735019683838,
0.009964082390069962,
0.31489506363868713,
0.8503886461257935,
-0.06341864913702011,
0.4083116352558136,
-0.6147098541259766,
0.5258563756942749,
0.3515668511390686,
-0.8181958794593811,
0.5654756426811218,
-0.5382736921310425,
0.132018581032753,
0.9370526075363159,
0.2582941949367523,
-0.9291169047355652,
-0.3195897936820984,
-0.7649243474006653,
0.05799417197704315,
0.9844118356704712,
0.5135189294815063,
0.43931496143341064,
-0.06975970417261124,
0.3398420214653015,
0.1310465931892395,
0.3900233507156372,
-0.7169568538665771,
-0.20785246789455414,
-0.20724938809871674,
-0.1966499239206314,
0.19929665327072144,
-0.19524289667606354,
-0.3242102265357971,
-0.08580953627824783,
0.4388684332370758,
-0.317050039768219,
0.5545458793640137,
0.13042321801185608,
-0.02042885683476925,
-0.03128679096698761,
0.4235197901725769,
0.6155112385749817,
0.4661570191383362,
-0.0663173496723175,
-0.04097111523151398,
-0.06419897824525833,
-0.648337185382843,
-0.009616944938898087,
-0.1032792255282402,
-0.18418832123279572,
-0.18141037225723267,
-0.05703960359096527,
0.6621890068054199,
0.14582541584968567,
-0.5728650689125061,
0.8304314613342285,
-0.3075164556503296,
-0.08206995576620102,
-0.2708587944507599,
0.294673353433609,
-0.3354324996471405,
0.2917689383029938,
0.0994417816400528,
0.12467938661575317,
0.683404803276062,
-1.1905553340911865,
-0.18180197477340698,
0.6065671443939209,
-0.6378177404403687,
-0.5601925849914551,
0.06891058385372162,
0.5591312050819397,
-0.8063887357711792,
0.5951457023620605,
-0.5392093062400818,
-1.0191041231155396,
0.4320531189441681,
0.02966208942234516,
1.003137469291687,
-0.49712151288986206,
0.2845897376537323,
0.11017975211143494,
0.16207633912563324,
0.3076193928718567,
0.5912647247314453,
-0.4439939558506012,
-0.9943095445632935,
-0.06154906004667282,
-0.4478745758533478,
-0.5070096254348755,
0.12306199222803116,
-0.5792321562767029,
0.17072762548923492,
-0.5610399842262268,
-0.3723805546760559,
0.3404887616634369,
-0.15806734561920166,
-0.9298679828643799,
0.328288197517395,
0.1576242297887802,
0.5777372717857361,
-1.0104966163635254,
0.13178285956382751,
0.8269903659820557,
-0.09510568529367447,
-0.6202066540718079,
0.05938437953591347,
0.35238778591156006,
-0.8004903197288513,
0.6428713798522949,
0.7713703513145447,
-0.2749817669391632,
-0.18996284902095795,
-0.6656559705734253,
-0.5344763994216919,
0.41456079483032227,
0.071949802339077,
-0.2913118004798889,
0.1262558251619339,
0.1422387808561325,
0.3027300536632538,
-0.48896703124046326,
0.35470354557037354,
0.7651519775390625,
0.5460729598999023,
0.11183284223079681,
-1.1252409219741821,
-0.05493643879890442,
-0.37746232748031616,
0.020225247368216515,
0.24710582196712494,
-0.7289319634437561,
0.70115727186203,
-0.08853533118963242,
-0.5770737528800964,
0.024321584030985832,
0.5274154543876648,
0.1311412900686264,
0.6018559336662292,
0.5818169713020325,
0.1760125607252121,
0.425332635641098,
-0.36267492175102234,
0.9579464197158813,
0.19728264212608337,
-0.20950303971767426,
0.7076670527458191,
-0.5904306173324585,
0.3749183118343353,
0.583194375038147,
-0.32800260186195374,
0.6553006172180176,
0.6310863494873047,
0.6483787894248962,
0.5421201586723328,
0.08163774758577347,
-0.43540123105049133,
-0.019017327576875687,
-0.5007172226905823,
-0.11404181271791458,
0.740709125995636,
0.550162672996521,
-0.16918586194515228,
0.07519914209842682,
0.25946736335754395,
0.15064553916454315,
-0.06002771481871605,
-0.5343853831291199,
0.923048734664917,
-0.01554156094789505,
-0.8304703235626221,
-0.0038850598502904177,
-0.23839884996414185,
0.3683016002178192,
-0.24401262402534485,
-0.07404790073633194,
0.02086099050939083,
-0.03540169447660446,
-0.39431044459342957,
-0.6522197723388672,
0.12230988591909409,
-0.22413647174835205,
-0.27568355202674866,
-0.2807512581348419,
0.7262531518936157,
0.01967334933578968,
-0.012668738141655922,
0.07556785643100739,
0.18744316697120667,
0.7595653533935547,
-0.17178691923618317,
-0.6740285158157349,
0.3266063332557678,
0.0767800509929657,
-0.34622660279273987,
0.3246126174926758,
0.5271997451782227,
-0.14869171380996704,
0.23302140831947327,
0.5690224766731262,
-0.15508416295051575,
-0.23333537578582764,
0.42255541682243347,
0.9083414077758789,
-0.6848590970039368,
-0.673620879650116,
-0.4850562512874603,
0.5209996700286865,
-0.29968345165252686,
-0.22715458273887634,
0.16904716193675995,
0.24913492798805237,
0.7028466463088989,
0.2796921730041504,
0.6241120100021362,
-0.2716798782348633,
0.41420093178749084,
-0.5139257907867432,
0.3039575219154358,
-0.12090358883142471,
-0.1252109706401825,
-0.32711824774742126,
-1.11817467212677,
0.0599195621907711,
0.9762399792671204,
-0.7285425662994385,
0.6597897410392761,
0.5394671559333801,
0.842697024345398,
0.2003186047077179,
0.5685468316078186,
0.4070737063884735,
-0.06458957493305206,
0.20999543368816376,
0.5004072189331055,
1.0189584493637085,
-0.1525680422782898,
-0.00894120056182146,
-0.24449792504310608,
-0.664239227771759,
-0.36825478076934814,
-0.44094088673591614,
-1.1988661289215088,
-0.5263581275939941,
-0.28853198885917664,
-0.1965194046497345,
0.018465964123606682,
0.7984511852264404,
1.0175061225891113,
-0.5002309083938599,
-0.346486896276474,
-0.0458391010761261,
-0.2247040718793869,
0.010510130785405636,
-0.3435734510421753,
-0.1437998116016388,
-0.4558946490287781,
-0.6495970487594604,
0.1769379824399948,
0.430892676115036,
0.2931255102157593,
-0.4216097891330719,
-0.27402058243751526,
-0.007624966558068991,
0.5017033219337463,
0.7879232168197632,
0.5871196389198303,
-0.617085337638855,
-0.4404085576534271,
-0.08963441103696823,
-0.14188741147518158,
0.0961720421910286,
1.1092506647109985,
-0.7871392965316772,
0.3258848786354065,
0.15938319265842438,
0.18382447957992554,
0.22193467617034912,
0.09901364147663116,
0.3848196864128113,
-0.6171075105667114,
0.2776922881603241,
0.46967005729675293,
0.16009442508220673,
0.43889912962913513,
-0.6376584768295288,
0.4848953187465668,
-0.012810145504772663,
-0.5192683339118958,
-0.7187663912773132,
0.6289499402046204,
-0.8671913743019104,
-0.2717130184173584,
0.8797590732574463,
0.2837449610233307,
-0.32127323746681213,
-0.07525824755430222,
-0.5107398629188538,
-0.1315193474292755,
-0.6780428290367126,
0.6698893308639526,
0.8499907851219177,
-0.8144658207893372,
-0.035252828150987625,
-0.7401646375656128,
0.8232381343841553,
0.4253007173538208,
-0.8594984412193298,
0.16805356740951538,
0.6614275574684143,
-0.02254301682114601,
0.49107813835144043,
1.2109519243240356,
-0.14552561938762665,
0.7672812342643738,
-0.42523103952407837,
0.20079150795936584,
0.2935042381286621,
-0.5528296828269958,
-0.350100576877594,
0.0409182570874691,
0.02641879767179489,
0.011503752321004868
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.04106v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.04106v1
|
Explainability and Hate Speech: Structured Explanations Make Social Media Moderators Faster
| 2024-06-06T14:23:10 | 2024-06-06T14:23:10 |
Agostina Calabrese, Leonardo Neves, Neil Shah, Maarten W. Bos, Björn Ross, Mirella Lapata, Francesco Barbieri
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Content moderators play a key role in keeping the conversation on social
media healthy. While the high volume of content they need to judge represents a
bottleneck to the moderation pipeline, no studies have explored how models
could support them to make faster decisions. There is, by now, a vast body of
research into detecting hate speech, sometimes explicitly motivated by a desire
to help improve content moderation, but published research using real content
moderators is scarce. In this work we investigate the effect of explanations on
the speed of real-world moderators. Our experiments show that while generic
explanations do not affect their speed and are often ignored, structured
explanations lower moderators' decision making time by 7.4%.
|
[
-0.571620762348175,
-1.1576757431030273,
0.7752066254615784,
0.33847710490226746,
-0.459900826215744,
-0.006136125884950161,
-0.2801204025745392,
-0.5278982520103455,
0.11548231542110443,
0.1750411093235016,
-0.6269176602363586,
0.04530319571495056,
-0.7818215489387512,
0.06851618736982346,
-0.6585021018981934,
1.0412499904632568,
0.33366361260414124,
-0.05716182664036751,
0.02844567596912384,
0.026727180927991867,
-0.33673858642578125,
-0.08886992931365967,
-1.048519253730774,
-0.1072283536195755,
1.066365361213684,
0.2834436297416687,
1.258424997329712,
1.0999298095703125,
0.18916797637939453,
0.3739539384841919,
-0.5721012949943542,
-0.2064431607723236,
-0.9870049357414246,
0.4234827756881714,
-0.45201560854911804,
-0.4521491229534149,
-0.1972474753856659,
0.008546318858861923,
0.3173762559890747,
0.5228944420814514,
0.1720409393310547,
-0.031430359929800034,
-0.01278348546475172,
0.504300057888031,
-0.4017757773399353,
-0.28586071729660034,
-0.5596210360527039,
0.017000660300254822,
-0.10686090588569641,
-0.48903656005859375,
-0.2548820972442627,
-0.49080291390419006,
0.15531110763549805,
-0.8221063017845154,
0.5210216641426086,
0.19227908551692963,
0.5750195384025574,
0.1917116791009903,
-0.5777509808540344,
-0.4032970070838928,
-1.0919811725616455,
0.6084784269332886,
-0.6277338266372681,
0.31789112091064453,
0.24745707213878632,
0.1782761812210083,
-0.2614925801753998,
-0.5741881132125854,
-0.8567900657653809,
0.15018416941165924,
-0.16449221968650818,
-0.12603330612182617,
-0.20192790031433105,
0.22030219435691833,
0.6204347610473633,
0.39937877655029297,
-0.4702332317829132,
0.32171785831451416,
-0.6539046764373779,
-0.26896539330482483,
0.7273042798042297,
0.33806338906288147,
0.22854411602020264,
-0.40375372767448425,
-0.02514161728322506,
0.47576746344566345,
-0.3900212049484253,
0.12557978928089142,
0.6474815011024475,
-0.025957901030778885,
-0.14146362245082855,
0.3182516396045685,
-0.03003094717860222,
0.7588348388671875,
0.21839526295661926,
-0.3148772716522217,
-0.24335947632789612,
-0.40246614813804626,
-0.03200644627213478,
0.022743312641978264,
0.5713235139846802,
0.7859899997711182,
0.32807889580726624,
-0.0008990553324110806,
0.2727195620536804,
0.2841819226741791,
0.41404032707214355,
-1.1722959280014038,
-0.06888975948095322,
0.3279898166656494,
-0.83714359998703,
-0.41917216777801514,
0.03865514695644379,
-0.7638809084892273,
-0.6882911920547485,
-0.12720677256584167,
0.17388401925563812,
-0.14130306243896484,
-0.21779458224773407,
-0.18036095798015594,
-0.5737439393997192,
0.09491029381752014,
0.508177638053894,
-0.5396019220352173,
0.28380677103996277,
0.7304765582084656,
0.9622723460197449,
-0.37953418493270874,
0.26089268922805786,
-0.8335885405540466,
-0.1491566151380539,
-0.4130886495113373,
0.9387173056602478,
-0.4921395480632782,
-0.1253613531589508,
-0.10497468709945679,
0.09317126125097275,
0.23491793870925903,
-0.39626044034957886,
0.8101154565811157,
-0.5925622582435608,
0.3603217303752899,
-0.4543967843055725,
-0.503370463848114,
-0.33024826645851135,
-0.16696622967720032,
-0.40664243698120117,
0.39092063903808594,
0.041363008320331573,
-0.7323602437973022,
0.6272438764572144,
-0.5466327667236328,
-0.6064444184303284,
0.38890060782432556,
0.08805571496486664,
-0.18959727883338928,
0.1532890349626541,
-0.015674060210585594,
0.45475971698760986,
-0.03694325312972069,
0.24767759442329407,
-0.5790571570396423,
-0.7606465220451355,
0.3394116163253784,
-0.3518029451370239,
0.7820749878883362,
0.47452640533447266,
-0.5471401214599609,
0.26348307728767395,
-0.4557334780693054,
-0.33394283056259155,
-0.022326873615384102,
-0.35770145058631897,
-0.3467453122138977,
0.44024091958999634,
-0.05346238985657692,
0.3618280291557312,
-0.4811301827430725,
-0.6034676432609558,
-0.3937602937221527,
-0.34995022416114807,
0.619280993938446,
1.0266757011413574,
0.12093158066272736,
0.2889678180217743,
-0.5173709988594055,
0.782835066318512,
-0.07755828648805618,
0.3896883726119995,
-0.03364573419094086,
-0.6296581029891968,
-0.3997572362422943,
-0.2887362837791443,
0.07163110375404358,
0.13858965039253235,
-0.5518863201141357,
-0.1694716066122055,
0.00006921080057509243,
-0.4729968309402466,
-0.4437737762928009,
0.10945948213338852,
0.502005398273468,
0.43173569440841675,
0.03571182116866112,
-0.1800374835729599,
-0.5516078472137451,
-0.8003529906272888,
-0.7664869427680969,
-0.09890126436948776,
-0.22215776145458221,
0.2739861011505127,
0.23713049292564392,
0.18405453860759735,
0.6916579008102417,
-0.35352012515068054,
0.2702515125274658,
-0.2915146052837372,
0.16457226872444153,
0.04891263321042061,
0.11250676959753036,
0.5086966156959534,
-1.283575177192688,
-0.5327470302581787,
-0.7029846906661987,
-0.15638810396194458,
-0.3592278063297272,
-0.09119946509599686,
-0.15651476383209229,
-0.14963214099407196,
0.6801496148109436,
-0.34558308124542236,
0.7002600431442261,
0.3752235472202301,
-0.6789829134941101,
0.6763815879821777,
0.22546826303005219,
0.32306206226348877,
-0.6257897615432739,
-0.5105317831039429,
-0.057733748108148575,
-0.43930014967918396,
-0.7883163690567017,
-0.14811553061008453,
-0.3483427166938782,
-0.005652841180562973,
-0.7706140875816345,
0.3433944582939148,
-0.13800197839736938,
0.013812028802931309,
-0.288826584815979,
0.5614210367202759,
-0.016890497878193855,
0.3329126536846161,
-0.41389262676239014,
0.4268176257610321,
0.39022132754325867,
-1.115744948387146,
0.25539126992225647,
0.1442149132490158,
-0.5099523067474365,
0.7383352518081665,
-0.8502975702285767,
-0.21546059846878052,
-0.38786935806274414,
0.5380350351333618,
-1.1416109800338745,
-0.35797613859176636,
0.33103859424591064,
-0.5092350244522095,
-0.34918782114982605,
-0.48185279965400696,
-0.3254379332065582,
-0.4717106819152832,
-0.5185166597366333,
0.3145786225795746,
0.3558070659637451,
-0.29749158024787903,
0.5044282674789429,
0.3289016783237457,
-0.12352398782968521,
-0.2610796093940735,
-0.4676593244075775,
-0.20048895478248596,
-0.37627801299095154,
-0.5778125524520874,
0.734248161315918,
-0.6223590970039368,
-0.8288893699645996,
0.2219916731119156,
-0.34988531470298767,
-0.2533292770385742,
0.44209906458854675,
0.6480180025100708,
-0.4175935983657837,
-0.09729111194610596,
0.21155676245689392,
0.051024630665779114,
0.1174522265791893,
0.2293107509613037,
0.3356113135814667,
0.43324577808380127,
0.2955552041530609,
0.16389411687850952,
-0.7796913981437683,
0.2997490167617798,
0.6224363446235657,
0.2535627782344818,
1.1113122701644897,
0.605411171913147,
0.018481653183698654,
-0.28696152567863464,
-0.41896623373031616,
-0.18793955445289612,
-0.4992404282093048,
-0.062134478241205215,
-0.08745713531970978,
-1.150801181793213,
0.5656360983848572,
0.43060052394866943,
0.19801005721092224,
0.5545341372489929,
0.5602237582206726,
0.013027735985815525,
1.441142201423645,
0.4139222204685211,
0.5356065630912781,
0.7654359340667725,
0.32759249210357666,
0.4002115726470947,
-0.34049615263938904,
-0.1550751030445099,
-0.7037227749824524,
-0.4209112823009491,
-0.7982269525527954,
-0.259346067905426,
0.07308297604322433,
-0.160958394408226,
0.007908709347248077,
0.045467909425497055,
-0.44839560985565186,
0.6217367649078369,
0.12882842123508453,
-0.04668194055557251,
0.19867749512195587,
-0.17377839982509613,
0.33212172985076904,
0.014805288054049015,
-0.8303175568580627,
-0.15407772362232208,
0.5175188779830933,
0.3975219130516052,
0.6424567103385925,
0.06765539944171906,
0.0005188493523746729,
0.6652488112449646,
0.35194653272628784,
-0.7901114225387573,
0.4868822693824768,
-0.05305558070540428,
-0.9516745209693909,
-0.12071369588375092,
-0.5343896150588989,
-0.6384734511375427,
0.3489934206008911,
-0.378266841173172,
-0.0781431496143341,
0.022860689088702202,
0.4276141822338104,
-0.7004808783531189,
0.2717294692993164,
-0.47283002734184265,
0.6340925693511963,
0.02311287447810173,
-0.2859462797641754,
-0.6081218719482422,
-0.5856385231018066,
0.3869430422782898,
0.0878993347287178,
0.7855648398399353,
-0.3017871081829071,
0.1884501427412033,
1.172356367111206,
-0.5338201522827148,
0.5901699066162109,
-0.3494415879249573,
0.011485731229186058,
0.26216238737106323,
0.22547858953475952,
0.009281701408326626,
-0.05880904570221901,
-0.1619701385498047,
-0.003395371837541461,
-0.13622473180294037,
-0.3458729386329651,
-0.7992491722106934,
0.6247456073760986,
-0.15874986350536346,
-0.6666790246963501,
0.1480846107006073,
-0.40243402123451233,
0.2528197765350342,
-0.2328556329011917,
0.3258223235607147,
0.46283581852912903,
-0.09636896848678589,
0.564346194267273,
0.853622317314148,
-0.30083316564559937,
0.2783052325248718,
0.6711737513542175,
-0.12645424902439117,
0.06678140163421631,
0.6737788319587708,
0.3754025101661682,
0.27772384881973267,
-0.03153889253735542,
0.5043354034423828,
0.02484084852039814,
-0.652206301689148,
-0.34132394194602966,
0.040430501103401184,
-0.37964004278182983,
0.061946988105773926,
-0.8718085885047913,
0.22973114252090454,
-0.44095003604888916,
-0.5916723012924194,
-0.021706711500883102,
-0.8528652787208557,
-0.04111708328127861,
-0.2661668360233307,
0.38626402616500854,
0.944686770439148,
-0.16917245090007782,
0.8083639740943909,
-0.07442258298397064,
0.7412832975387573,
0.5696635246276855,
0.48926591873168945,
0.17577458918094635,
-1.0285698175430298,
-0.2040099799633026,
0.010040992870926857,
-0.23272369801998138,
-1.1661102771759033,
0.023354193195700645,
0.06564369052648544,
0.28972211480140686,
0.98508220911026,
0.05626481771469116,
0.9757053852081299,
-0.2816195785999298,
0.8861449956893921,
-0.30807921290397644,
-0.7965362668037415,
0.6310227513313293,
-0.3260505199432373,
-0.03495120629668236,
0.21466173231601715,
0.7301658987998962,
-0.7618961334228516,
-0.7616064548492432,
-0.5116021633148193,
-0.6373763084411621,
0.6775794625282288,
0.20906125009059906,
0.22116132080554962,
-0.1970910131931305,
0.5603216886520386,
0.27212321758270264,
0.039369694888591766,
-0.7300515174865723,
-0.608193576335907,
-0.16966654360294342,
0.19624526798725128,
0.15609808266162872,
-0.9193831086158752,
-0.1768665611743927,
-0.3582887053489685,
0.7061545252799988,
0.23230047523975372,
0.10498522222042084,
0.24426615238189697,
-0.12890136241912842,
-0.4942903220653534,
0.31652167439460754,
0.8415868282318115,
0.948631763458252,
-0.041977543383836746,
0.3119954466819763,
-0.2595067024230957,
-0.1304538995027542,
-0.18816649913787842,
-0.0839090421795845,
-0.2799355685710907,
0.3519246280193329,
0.4608694016933441,
0.8143329620361328,
0.3422238230705261,
-0.546184778213501,
0.6088933944702148,
-0.4503253102302551,
-0.39399829506874084,
-0.07090765982866287,
0.3462456464767456,
-0.0021046807523816824,
0.11005150526762009,
0.25861024856567383,
-0.1740652471780777,
0.048024505376815796,
-0.6465355157852173,
0.13758806884288788,
0.37338608503341675,
-0.49178484082221985,
-0.4851546585559845,
0.9550899267196655,
0.2211669683456421,
-0.6880549192428589,
0.3054375648498535,
-0.05075344070792198,
-0.7336980700492859,
0.5479533672332764,
0.4093700349330902,
0.47720038890838623,
-0.38529151678085327,
0.5461078882217407,
0.23568978905677795,
0.13116654753684998,
0.32992789149284363,
0.012987487018108368,
-0.22460700571537018,
-0.5651236772537231,
-0.45129379630088806,
-0.7637268304824829,
-0.2888709008693695,
0.21349462866783142,
-0.4323635697364807,
-0.05785917863249779,
-0.7224112153053284,
-0.02765442058444023,
0.6604242920875549,
-0.1246345043182373,
-0.4706916809082031,
0.1745731383562088,
-0.04411366581916809,
0.9462283849716187,
-0.9159150123596191,
-0.11026452481746674,
0.051644664257764816,
-0.1294194906949997,
-0.6634909510612488,
-0.006237493362277746,
0.21952416002750397,
-0.5474036335945129,
0.4923071563243866,
0.2611508071422577,
-0.18656736612319946,
-0.2613444924354553,
-1.0327184200286865,
-0.2807612419128418,
0.47715604305267334,
0.20533736050128937,
-0.31722912192344666,
-0.12577441334724426,
-0.32378315925598145,
0.905460000038147,
-0.33526116609573364,
0.15120935440063477,
0.26890572905540466,
0.5825988054275513,
-0.03671281412243843,
-0.6077996492385864,
0.22698694467544556,
-0.0435367226600647,
-0.05859917774796486,
0.039902351796627045,
-0.3980727195739746,
0.7216588258743286,
-0.15078039467334747,
-0.2692278027534485,
-0.3654351234436035,
0.6307315826416016,
-0.2555071711540222,
0.400539368391037,
0.9448883533477783,
0.2289476990699768,
0.38042157888412476,
0.06726883351802826,
1.0682953596115112,
-0.20807160437107086,
-0.10529004782438278,
0.9280148148536682,
0.2562386393547058,
0.23669196665287018,
0.3954000771045685,
0.20249632000923157,
1.1870453357696533,
0.6340939402580261,
0.10776723921298981,
0.15620526671409607,
0.33201879262924194,
-0.40805912017822266,
-0.336324542760849,
-0.5938215255737305,
-0.13957764208316803,
0.29203763604164124,
0.38949039578437805,
-0.6207700967788696,
-0.0349903479218483,
0.2348441332578659,
0.5452615022659302,
0.31089556217193604,
-0.6403987407684326,
0.5264959931373596,
-0.10213185846805573,
-0.8327727317810059,
0.23698826134204865,
0.20400062203407288,
0.6432827711105347,
-0.4942350387573242,
0.1467261165380478,
-0.15376971662044525,
-0.1929558515548706,
-0.3896823823451996,
-0.7569750547409058,
0.6476023197174072,
0.043713442981243134,
-0.3535001277923584,
-0.6733900308609009,
0.7496426701545715,
-0.25134411454200745,
0.22149544954299927,
0.3742123246192932,
0.3536604046821594,
0.3114849030971527,
-0.3541313409805298,
-0.6763573288917542,
0.21247364580631256,
-0.17490345239639282,
-0.4535748064517975,
-0.05088082328438759,
0.2708268463611603,
-0.25577396154403687,
0.7659837007522583,
0.8148718476295471,
-0.034042004495859146,
0.12388964742422104,
-0.13194850087165833,
0.8306801915168762,
-0.5502943396568298,
-0.3763023018836975,
-1.1468069553375244,
0.21257299184799194,
-0.03913196548819542,
-0.1388172209262848,
0.9280382990837097,
0.444225937128067,
0.9541739821434021,
0.15479566156864166,
0.4627392888069153,
-0.4990063011646271,
0.8057767152786255,
-0.18754635751247406,
0.8028322458267212,
-0.5816874504089355,
-0.17090828716754913,
-0.1613902598619461,
-0.571094810962677,
-0.20255236327648163,
0.3182853162288666,
-0.21146759390830994,
-0.16237400472164154,
0.6718409657478333,
0.9433661103248596,
0.10782375931739807,
-0.025671077892184258,
0.29990217089653015,
0.9677708148956299,
0.4972752332687378,
-0.07504725456237793,
0.6508445143699646,
0.04034433886408806,
0.8855065703392029,
-0.4322478473186493,
-0.02428516000509262,
-0.33817246556282043,
-0.7634904384613037,
-0.9014526605606079,
-0.4563041031360626,
-0.34666907787323,
-0.6341831088066101,
0.13581635057926178,
0.36016520857810974,
0.89517742395401,
-0.44804415106773376,
0.21028682589530945,
0.2027483880519867,
0.9153606295585632,
-0.2828521728515625,
-0.3886273205280304,
-0.13433264195919037,
0.21188564598560333,
-0.5052552223205566,
0.415284663438797,
0.3020447790622711,
-0.3565312922000885,
0.020281121134757996,
-0.0075992075726389885,
-0.15081526339054108,
0.5455216765403748,
0.7529431581497192,
0.325371116399765,
-0.7934049963951111,
-0.4235011339187622,
-0.3157348036766052,
0.14038808643817902,
0.09725762158632278,
1.1701983213424683,
-0.7560027241706848,
0.4223909080028534,
0.7519621253013611,
0.04867074638605118,
0.32189878821372986,
0.2873149514198303,
0.5155925750732422,
-0.24073196947574615,
0.03856182098388672,
-0.031050464138388634,
-0.04292624071240425,
0.22939513623714447,
-0.39672765135765076,
0.20336350798606873,
0.6047824621200562,
-0.6158227920532227,
-0.9000132083892822,
0.459118127822876,
-0.8929895162582397,
-0.3693370223045349,
0.9843365550041199,
0.04285401478409767,
-0.2633384168148041,
-0.5799357891082764,
-0.22322896122932434,
0.38312286138534546,
-0.3539182245731354,
0.7503349781036377,
0.7071649432182312,
-0.21686919033527374,
-0.06741838157176971,
-0.6779364347457886,
0.9379624128341675,
0.3467135727405548,
-0.4604518711566925,
0.2113608419895172,
0.8013736605644226,
0.5223418474197388,
-0.08543198555707932,
0.9011940360069275,
0.07263509184122086,
0.46253782510757446,
-0.2260119765996933,
-0.6020625829696655,
-0.03268638625741005,
-0.3526189923286438,
-0.394209086894989,
0.4070759415626526,
-0.2911039888858795,
0.4095841348171234
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.06601v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.06601v1
|
A Human-in-the-Loop Approach to Improving Cross-Text Prosody Transfer
| 2024-06-06T14:01:53 | 2024-06-06T14:01:53 |
Himanshu Maurya, Atli Sigurgeirsson
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
Text-To-Speech (TTS) prosody transfer models can generate varied prosodic
renditions, for the same text, by conditioning on a reference utterance. These
models are trained with a reference that is identical to the target utterance.
But when the reference utterance differs from the target text, as in cross-text
prosody transfer, these models struggle to separate prosody from text,
resulting in reduced perceived naturalness. To address this, we propose a
Human-in-the-Loop (HitL) approach. HitL users adjust salient correlates of
prosody to make the prosody more appropriate for the target text, while
maintaining the overall reference prosodic effect. Human adjusted renditions
maintain the reference prosody while being rated as more appropriate for the
target text $57.8\%$ of the time. Our analysis suggests that limited user
effort suffices for these improvements, and that closeness in the latent
reference space is not a reliable prosodic similarity metric for the cross-text
condition.
|
[
-0.2756662666797638,
-0.332131028175354,
0.4878223240375519,
0.16570380330085754,
-0.8053720593452454,
0.3909725546836853,
-0.38568997383117676,
-0.6866170167922974,
0.1249244436621666,
0.46344301104545593,
-0.4001474678516388,
-0.3209640681743622,
-0.21293576061725616,
0.6040359735488892,
-0.14018620550632477,
1.1796519756317139,
0.08353520184755325,
0.007310737855732441,
0.05006894841790199,
-0.22547531127929688,
-0.4184212386608124,
-0.48941570520401,
-0.43648087978363037,
-0.4865521192550659,
0.508635401725769,
0.4105459153652191,
0.9808229207992554,
0.09449252486228943,
0.754389762878418,
0.13882450759410858,
-0.17042948305606842,
0.08549053966999054,
-0.15729235112667084,
0.14986175298690796,
-0.7135122418403625,
-0.392098069190979,
-0.5646657347679138,
0.07277380675077438,
0.7596008777618408,
0.6605721712112427,
0.09972795099020004,
-0.10794734209775925,
0.17400579154491425,
0.5502625703811646,
-0.4430854320526123,
-0.39031046628952026,
-0.2752406597137451,
-0.10713618248701096,
-0.3137255012989044,
-0.3914327323436737,
-0.3902490437030792,
-0.37170249223709106,
0.6452433466911316,
-0.5948562026023865,
0.49004220962524414,
0.1491396427154541,
0.43570053577423096,
0.22676962614059448,
-0.19988323748111725,
-0.17186538875102997,
-0.9085413217544556,
0.6447333097457886,
-0.6956688165664673,
0.7557753324508667,
0.4945937991142273,
0.16693168878555298,
-0.0005471805925481021,
-0.43024855852127075,
-0.6622503995895386,
-0.5247204303741455,
-0.030858619138598442,
0.08791954815387726,
-0.10418122261762619,
0.10047980397939682,
0.020762138068675995,
0.0980733186006546,
-0.548309326171875,
-0.29436197876930237,
-0.4117370545864105,
-0.15035593509674072,
0.7649975419044495,
-0.04861631989479065,
0.4260232150554657,
-0.13183972239494324,
-0.30280613899230957,
-0.143964484333992,
-0.47272056341171265,
-0.009285958483815193,
0.23879384994506836,
0.5982481241226196,
-0.2619246542453766,
0.34056997299194336,
0.01916857436299324,
0.7078525424003601,
0.4907485842704773,
-0.44963711500167847,
0.3869646191596985,
-0.8568122982978821,
-0.010745900683104992,
0.20486155152320862,
0.846102774143219,
0.35624805092811584,
0.6460949182510376,
-0.7015382647514343,
-0.10490745306015015,
-0.197472482919693,
0.5948871374130249,
-0.42657724022865295,
-0.14694736897945404,
-0.1802222728729248,
-0.20546920597553253,
-0.033584754914045334,
0.23047100007534027,
-0.5751110315322876,
-0.3539295196533203,
-0.579954206943512,
0.5013744235038757,
-0.6832574605941772,
-0.07018239796161652,
-0.16208778321743011,
-0.22963716089725494,
-0.25956645607948303,
0.14040647447109222,
-0.7471249103546143,
0.3369492292404175,
0.10099134594202042,
1.0996583700180054,
-0.30961212515830994,
-0.4474899172782898,
-0.5479017496109009,
0.48798495531082153,
-0.18022197484970093,
0.7598979473114014,
-0.7077888250350952,
-0.6855709552764893,
-0.29923015832901,
-0.20504388213157654,
-0.22581349313259125,
-0.8079822063446045,
0.4677749574184418,
-0.287602961063385,
0.047570060938596725,
-0.24640780687332153,
-0.3175036609172821,
0.2988344132900238,
-0.24255289137363434,
-0.7634066939353943,
0.9140962362289429,
0.2981427013874054,
-0.8872731924057007,
0.039178669452667236,
-0.717816174030304,
-0.5902621150016785,
-0.34007832407951355,
0.3722163140773773,
-0.28715166449546814,
0.3212944567203522,
0.30606576800346375,
0.032658204436302185,
-0.2809399664402008,
0.14294710755348206,
-0.22779689729213715,
-0.7281874418258667,
0.6112192273139954,
-0.24320191144943237,
0.4856794774532318,
0.2835850417613983,
-0.22574888169765472,
0.1486453115940094,
-0.7048205137252808,
-0.2068098932504654,
-0.44377774000167847,
-0.1945129781961441,
-0.5941539406776428,
-0.28745540976524353,
0.2287747859954834,
0.06022999435663223,
-0.2994668781757355,
-0.6030359864234924,
0.17321611940860748,
-0.5347129702568054,
0.47453296184539795,
0.448576420545578,
0.2102995663881302,
0.6353009939193726,
-0.4760836064815521,
0.6413332223892212,
-0.1467716246843338,
-0.023522719740867615,
0.1438610851764679,
-0.3353295922279358,
-0.4041467010974884,
-0.18616724014282227,
0.3588506877422333,
0.4824075698852539,
-0.7711681127548218,
0.22372035682201385,
-0.2669648826122284,
-0.413785845041275,
-0.9639676213264465,
-0.16523157060146332,
0.621724545955658,
0.5462389588356018,
0.5992754697799683,
-0.4518025517463684,
-0.5860464572906494,
-0.6076641082763672,
-0.7264339923858643,
-0.38871973752975464,
-0.2957971692085266,
-0.00002505689553800039,
0.21186284720897675,
0.02512780949473381,
1.280659556388855,
-0.051712263375520706,
-0.2514331042766571,
0.02649003267288208,
0.4032135307788849,
-0.1288670152425766,
0.37245213985443115,
0.41594061255455017,
-0.5404691696166992,
-0.48628297448158264,
0.03439679741859436,
-0.2691514492034912,
-0.4998338520526886,
-0.16483592987060547,
-0.14638130366802216,
0.12842141091823578,
0.5153772234916687,
-0.4319611191749573,
0.45137616991996765,
0.3958323299884796,
-0.6430277228355408,
0.8560715913772583,
-0.40638303756713867,
0.29210761189460754,
-1.1013740301132202,
0.2562125325202942,
-0.02171282097697258,
-0.5085309743881226,
-0.4353916347026825,
-0.23043997585773468,
-0.06526879966259003,
-0.2885301411151886,
-0.4985913634300232,
0.5017986297607422,
-0.36107414960861206,
-0.3603387475013733,
-0.3557906448841095,
0.2747855484485626,
0.029251689091324806,
0.2355397492647171,
-0.015737248584628105,
1.3633408546447754,
0.18456318974494934,
-0.6538201570510864,
0.438129186630249,
0.23412275314331055,
0.025870518758893013,
1.2316429615020752,
-0.8724176287651062,
0.5230114459991455,
-0.026929743587970734,
0.5767590999603271,
-0.887243926525116,
-0.061468083411455154,
0.2529422342777252,
-0.5566955804824829,
0.3120960295200348,
0.0248127281665802,
-0.2614918053150177,
-0.09094864875078201,
-0.17598725855350494,
0.6090210676193237,
0.5402156710624695,
-0.3823795020580292,
0.2191341519355774,
0.04590141400694847,
-0.2805004119873047,
-0.03075519949197769,
-0.5186312198638916,
0.2783592939376831,
-0.1825445145368576,
-0.43877050280570984,
0.935272753238678,
-0.14862796664237976,
-0.2863990366458893,
-0.03796931728720665,
-0.000898198108188808,
-0.03022521175444126,
-0.43172550201416016,
-0.028658663854002953,
0.009162076748907566,
0.14831678569316864,
0.44689804315567017,
-0.1359763890504837,
-0.23105861246585846,
-0.0932721346616745,
-0.4468800127506256,
0.11657055467367172,
0.08000697940587997,
-0.2608996629714966,
-1.1092768907546997,
0.4390708804130554,
0.6627873778343201,
-0.016809044405817986,
0.38704416155815125,
0.706333339214325,
-0.0988282635807991,
0.12885111570358276,
-0.13122554123401642,
-0.2908738851547241,
-0.38523831963539124,
0.27311471104621887,
-0.5752348303794861,
-0.45171624422073364,
0.299370139837265,
0.02030607871711254,
-0.18156270682811737,
0.0851043313741684,
0.3635241389274597,
-0.6384523510932922,
0.7298387885093689,
0.6240389347076416,
-0.10143474489450455,
0.7066239714622498,
-0.04130144789814949,
0.07033585011959076,
-1.0137447118759155,
-0.1269128918647766,
-0.8275513052940369,
-0.3760332465171814,
-0.40942418575286865,
-0.5745090246200562,
0.32960498332977295,
0.21927663683891296,
-0.31800514459609985,
0.5746852159500122,
-0.30308008193969727,
0.18626335263252258,
0.6835668087005615,
0.47494298219680786,
0.3812411427497864,
0.11546195298433304,
-0.2084778994321823,
-0.48665857315063477,
-0.49641674757003784,
-0.4419873058795929,
0.7507925033569336,
0.1666674017906189,
0.7667936682701111,
0.07761459797620773,
0.7076311707496643,
0.5321816205978394,
0.39329609274864197,
-0.4006887674331665,
0.3211173713207245,
-0.322574645280838,
-0.2157594859600067,
-0.3382311761379242,
-0.3535366356372833,
-0.8851664662361145,
-0.13318437337875366,
-0.06353649497032166,
-0.8147501349449158,
0.07031011581420898,
0.5215575695037842,
-0.41020095348358154,
0.20162321627140045,
-0.6831864714622498,
0.4406600892543793,
0.07536868751049042,
-0.5094439387321472,
-0.1408281773328781,
-0.7318080067634583,
-0.16137798130512238,
-0.07508330047130585,
0.27002668380737305,
0.11475814878940582,
0.10370983928442001,
0.8086830973625183,
-0.6470003128051758,
0.9904318451881409,
-0.042173873633146286,
-0.24963167309761047,
0.4544699490070343,
0.12455736845731735,
0.8055292367935181,
-0.307861328125,
-0.09703195840120316,
0.03374786674976349,
-0.2597605288028717,
-0.22825613617897034,
-0.7857301831245422,
0.2850286364555359,
-0.8384451866149902,
-0.22887828946113586,
-0.07717018574476242,
-0.6618079543113708,
-0.4095447361469269,
-0.31837165355682373,
0.576266884803772,
0.4663659930229187,
-0.1839524358510971,
-0.06096716225147247,
0.4697816073894501,
0.11704312264919281,
0.5110657811164856,
0.24699784815311432,
0.07153374701738358,
-0.699577808380127,
0.8972322344779968,
0.04134155437350273,
0.6363572478294373,
0.3550451099872589,
0.3396773040294647,
-0.7425461411476135,
-0.3313538432121277,
-0.49687594175338745,
0.41411998867988586,
-0.3192249834537506,
-0.004230603110045195,
-0.3376480042934418,
0.1292455643415451,
-0.6132990717887878,
-0.44690701365470886,
-0.3988676369190216,
-0.20994307100772858,
-0.6219857335090637,
0.24042360484600067,
0.6580196619033813,
0.41978123784065247,
-0.1111077070236206,
0.6066989302635193,
-1.1325982809066772,
0.6578568816184998,
0.3412174582481384,
0.5368481278419495,
-0.34070006012916565,
-1.4490914344787598,
-0.15156184136867523,
0.0740930438041687,
-0.05052753910422325,
-1.2618805170059204,
0.42631179094314575,
0.4225597381591797,
0.17349857091903687,
0.04166032746434212,
0.4561229348182678,
0.9159018397331238,
-0.4339296519756317,
0.6551669836044312,
0.506931722164154,
-1.3692113161087036,
0.7659083008766174,
-0.13894185423851013,
0.609548032283783,
0.615109384059906,
0.17348863184452057,
-0.743415355682373,
-0.6926403641700745,
-0.5717374682426453,
-0.5519260168075562,
0.6415852308273315,
0.5367403030395508,
-0.07737104594707489,
0.295458048582077,
0.38848206400871277,
0.10897047817707062,
-0.24109861254692078,
-0.38346949219703674,
0.051252592355012894,
-0.05821201577782631,
-0.37371477484703064,
-0.16328425705432892,
0.03674039617180824,
0.11554086208343506,
-0.2898395359516144,
0.5468283891677856,
-0.2348073422908783,
0.30066320300102234,
0.7039951682090759,
-0.3943755030632019,
-0.4066302478313446,
0.3193228840827942,
0.5417048931121826,
0.843909740447998,
-0.31321796774864197,
0.3965340256690979,
0.23957961797714233,
-0.8635057806968689,
0.4165526330471039,
-0.09240396320819855,
-0.4384210407733917,
0.42886877059936523,
0.6502845883369446,
1.0668997764587402,
0.4882209897041321,
-0.5251815915107727,
0.151636004447937,
0.22050699591636658,
-0.022843049839138985,
0.18668127059936523,
0.11315722018480301,
0.049670036882162094,
0.3803245425224304,
0.2595180571079254,
0.08664537221193314,
-0.10149261355400085,
-0.5304256081581116,
0.3566962480545044,
-0.009125597774982452,
-0.6023741364479065,
-0.7337446212768555,
0.7667103409767151,
0.6476137042045593,
-1.216477394104004,
0.3813188374042511,
0.09094269573688507,
-0.43028727173805237,
0.2995629608631134,
0.95383620262146,
1.1082706451416016,
-0.42510536313056946,
0.20440995693206787,
0.38640326261520386,
0.13978712260723114,
0.1878441721200943,
0.3748813569545746,
-0.2012089639902115,
-0.4593662917613983,
-0.43894222378730774,
-0.4849000871181488,
-0.6852478981018066,
-0.2848778963088989,
-0.6673991084098816,
0.27633631229400635,
0.025812998414039612,
-0.5718345046043396,
0.21667467057704926,
-0.12776994705200195,
-0.5978764295578003,
0.34257927536964417,
-0.02624364010989666,
0.5995662212371826,
-0.8457835912704468,
1.0483589172363281,
0.9777670502662659,
-0.3876822590827942,
-0.461993545293808,
0.47524091601371765,
-0.31965625286102295,
-0.19657206535339355,
0.546398401260376,
-0.2079145461320877,
-0.3215257525444031,
0.13356317579746246,
-0.33290156722068787,
-0.7106391191482544,
0.7358608841896057,
0.4637105464935303,
-1.0517430305480957,
0.251312255859375,
0.3091614246368408,
0.7393897771835327,
-0.28535139560699463,
0.3100706934928894,
0.8698645830154419,
0.4146350920200348,
0.02892577275633812,
-1.5987026691436768,
-0.02143382467329502,
0.09075280278921127,
0.12304998934268951,
0.021991664543747902,
-0.46663570404052734,
0.5014814138412476,
-0.6906023025512695,
-0.10491592437028885,
-0.1924862414598465,
0.7757260799407959,
0.4234277606010437,
0.4651598334312439,
0.6545520424842834,
0.2982805371284485,
0.8389121890068054,
0.36859068274497986,
1.0361260175704956,
0.03263481333851814,
0.25659117102622986,
1.1868314743041992,
-0.29885247349739075,
0.8372147083282471,
0.8424250483512878,
-0.722204864025116,
0.2604432702064514,
0.46630859375,
0.6194072961807251,
0.7101755142211914,
0.11867287009954453,
-0.5093802213668823,
-0.11613734811544418,
-0.24066703021526337,
-0.2811330258846283,
0.44976502656936646,
-0.0867922455072403,
-0.37725830078125,
-0.12716972827911377,
0.32569631934165955,
-0.14015555381774902,
0.3140639364719391,
-0.04445010423660278,
0.7131200432777405,
-0.0336514450609684,
-0.7627494931221008,
0.9133374691009521,
-0.15801197290420532,
0.528157114982605,
-0.21855580806732178,
0.0348602831363678,
-0.40311411023139954,
0.10358390212059021,
0.06722266227006912,
-0.6583053469657898,
0.5734439492225647,
0.3436756730079651,
-0.5198339819908142,
-0.23592603206634521,
0.6286666393280029,
-0.6564887762069702,
-0.28886669874191284,
0.24395613372325897,
0.17325624823570251,
0.4387529194355011,
-0.21783235669136047,
-0.41753968596458435,
-0.0736018642783165,
0.12836715579032898,
0.012250293046236038,
0.1405196189880371,
0.32394909858703613,
-0.3428862392902374,
0.46684280037879944,
0.6036385893821716,
0.22751280665397644,
-0.11824958026409149,
0.5614451766014099,
0.6521326303482056,
-1.0403590202331543,
-0.5974245071411133,
-0.7555657029151917,
0.2460906058549881,
0.04023104906082153,
-0.733544111251831,
0.40617579221725464,
0.0965193584561348,
0.7377550005912781,
-0.051652293652296066,
0.7532715201377869,
0.1530425250530243,
0.8244115710258484,
-0.4030539095401764,
0.4377675950527191,
-0.302578330039978,
0.07079659402370453,
-0.578853964805603,
-1.0299208164215088,
-0.14468887448310852,
0.685362696647644,
0.052919164299964905,
-0.0863020271062851,
0.708710789680481,
0.6707606911659241,
0.05760248750448227,
0.01716102845966816,
0.2826730012893677,
-0.16906379163265228,
0.09109711647033691,
0.5656909346580505,
0.8394397497177124,
-0.47771283984184265,
0.6537364721298218,
-0.26577988266944885,
-0.13336889445781708,
-0.4477001130580902,
-0.7460293173789978,
-0.5439048409461975,
-0.44224995374679565,
-0.527469277381897,
-0.37376707792282104,
0.5211115479469299,
0.9374139308929443,
0.828106164932251,
-0.7056543827056885,
-0.257775217294693,
-0.15808366239070892,
-0.06856822222471237,
-0.39881306886672974,
-0.16496430337429047,
0.4407263696193695,
-0.33684298396110535,
-0.9838924407958984,
0.42958393692970276,
0.24731537699699402,
0.22914451360702515,
-0.06072300300002098,
-0.35530227422714233,
-0.15232309699058533,
0.08215872198343277,
0.5369763374328613,
0.24621081352233887,
-0.5903947949409485,
-0.5594888925552368,
-0.010774592868983746,
-0.28344789147377014,
0.03506060317158699,
1.1336451768875122,
-1.0148346424102783,
0.6115376353263855,
0.585717499256134,
0.41139355301856995,
0.3935585916042328,
0.20466837286949158,
0.6676991581916809,
-1.2155145406723022,
0.22730274498462677,
0.332641065120697,
-0.1375277191400528,
0.3516838252544403,
-0.2237909436225891,
0.3840215504169464,
0.7198390960693359,
-0.3482987880706787,
-0.6351290941238403,
-0.04721803963184357,
-1.0302962064743042,
-0.21327024698257446,
1.1588644981384277,
-0.098235584795475,
-0.04558215290307999,
-0.47712382674217224,
-0.5407968163490295,
0.7419325709342957,
-0.39678311347961426,
0.7536178827285767,
0.5685397386550903,
-0.302360862493515,
-0.12854595482349396,
-0.2687041759490967,
0.34001466631889343,
0.5491755604743958,
-0.7153638005256653,
0.20139387249946594,
0.3339970111846924,
0.2031799554824829,
0.016370126977562904,
0.7378841638565063,
0.1905192732810974,
0.2724607586860657,
-0.0569460466504097,
0.2571817636489868,
0.07367444038391113,
-0.39316773414611816,
-0.1752626597881317,
-0.04605093598365784,
-0.17650353908538818,
-0.4949611723423004
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.06600v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.06600v1
|
HORAE: A Domain-Agnostic Modeling Language for Automating Multimodal Service Regulation
| 2024-06-06T13:44:57 | 2024-06-06T13:44:57 |
Yutao Sun, Mingshuai Chen, Kangjia Zhao, He Li, Jintao Chen, Linyu Yang, Zhongyi Wang, Tiancheng Zhao, Jianwei Yin
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Artificial intelligence is rapidly encroaching on the field of service
regulation. This work presents the design principles behind HORAE, a unified
specification language to model multimodal regulation rules across a diverse
set of domains. We show how HORAE facilitates an intelligent service regulation
pipeline by further exploiting a fine-tuned large language model named HORAE
that automates the HORAE modeling process, thereby yielding an end-to-end
framework for fully automated intelligent service regulation.
|
[
-0.6075926423072815,
-0.7582804560661316,
0.38902395963668823,
0.23696205019950867,
0.08238139003515244,
0.13509629666805267,
0.43551066517829895,
-0.8048722147941589,
-0.020402435213327408,
0.9715090394020081,
-0.34487250447273254,
-0.17864185571670532,
-0.2535339593887329,
-0.05721597000956535,
-0.39988192915916443,
0.8009384870529175,
-0.13355329632759094,
-0.30522242188453674,
-0.1497506946325302,
-0.07741303741931915,
-0.06169044226408005,
-0.6963561177253723,
-0.3224794566631317,
-0.34133148193359375,
0.4798884391784668,
0.24133650958538055,
0.7557175159454346,
0.7227030992507935,
0.6897798776626587,
0.4024617373943329,
0.2940462827682495,
0.2287522554397583,
0.027556277811527252,
0.12756867706775665,
-0.21527187526226044,
0.08657427132129669,
-0.73685222864151,
-0.07164972275495529,
0.28621044754981995,
0.4880315661430359,
-0.3200514018535614,
0.5186350345611572,
-0.16373677551746368,
0.4840829074382782,
-0.9034489393234253,
0.3968755006790161,
-0.3842759132385254,
-0.14313216507434845,
-0.14167845249176025,
-0.40201303362846375,
-0.4946241080760956,
-0.3232349753379822,
0.041363343596458435,
-0.7968626618385315,
-0.3300878703594208,
0.4745995104312897,
0.9794290065765381,
0.6339656710624695,
-0.882620096206665,
-0.5446688532829285,
-1.2199053764343262,
0.4576544165611267,
-0.3743959069252014,
0.2635243833065033,
0.4324650764465332,
0.5356244444847107,
0.1710842400789261,
-1.1287904977798462,
-0.57148677110672,
-0.19674333930015564,
-0.20748646557331085,
-0.13779646158218384,
-0.643588125705719,
0.2771381735801697,
0.13353781402111053,
0.3667810261249542,
-0.07812944799661636,
-0.27335232496261597,
-0.3441201150417328,
-0.2344082146883011,
0.5749500393867493,
0.33185574412345886,
0.3588431775569916,
0.09046120196580887,
-0.25438833236694336,
0.3216244578361511,
-0.19527287781238556,
0.3493221700191498,
0.32604727149009705,
-0.04001030698418617,
-0.18167279660701752,
0.5822060108184814,
-0.5989484190940857,
0.585326075553894,
0.160237655043602,
0.13772837817668915,
-0.10239816457033157,
-0.03269922360777855,
-0.6679233312606812,
0.14012157917022705,
0.713417112827301,
0.12663911283016205,
0.16921858489513397,
-0.1765754073858261,
-0.3272983133792877,
0.7373064160346985,
0.6303835511207581,
-0.5756411552429199,
-0.2998236417770386,
0.10730684548616409,
-0.229519322514534,
-0.1341370791196823,
0.038854848593473434,
-0.5416178107261658,
0.018003590404987335,
-0.618167519569397,
0.470583438873291,
-0.09976673871278763,
0.09990200400352478,
0.36013224720954895,
0.14049145579338074,
0.11703664064407349,
0.11873538792133331,
-0.9145598411560059,
0.48811304569244385,
0.46379467844963074,
0.5119621157646179,
0.3438465893268585,
-0.3291839361190796,
-0.6160798668861389,
0.5477598309516907,
-0.3740292489528656,
0.758979320526123,
-0.6052924394607544,
-0.3212624490261078,
-0.04653044417500496,
0.26060521602630615,
0.31277576088905334,
0.04903421923518181,
0.15445388853549957,
-1.1957714557647705,
0.02778702601790428,
0.2251623570919037,
-0.4266040325164795,
-0.4605310261249542,
0.012010449543595314,
-0.6326791644096375,
0.608001172542572,
0.12983784079551697,
-0.33936449885368347,
0.3308892250061035,
-0.9582847356796265,
-0.7281910181045532,
0.3230486810207367,
0.11697331070899963,
-0.30580607056617737,
0.034875016659498215,
-0.19627077877521515,
0.2870713472366333,
-0.3675922751426697,
0.3289068937301636,
-0.36891603469848633,
0.13184024393558502,
-0.05713345482945442,
-0.397511750459671,
1.0057904720306396,
0.40753069519996643,
-0.7206884622573853,
0.5880632400512695,
-0.809873640537262,
0.2970407009124756,
-0.28200602531433105,
-0.2898300588130951,
-0.3228451907634735,
-0.09116988629102707,
0.49429625272750854,
0.419254332780838,
0.1092841848731041,
-0.5666216015815735,
0.01753891631960869,
-0.10093007236719131,
0.7955198884010315,
0.5834025740623474,
0.07118591666221619,
0.7111731767654419,
-0.6758990287780762,
0.4952946901321411,
-0.40689271688461304,
0.8068044781684875,
-0.10378966480493546,
-0.5181698203086853,
-0.5225442051887512,
-0.6055094003677368,
-0.02685220167040825,
0.4561380445957184,
-0.542763888835907,
0.5302717089653015,
0.048690129071474075,
-0.8310020565986633,
-0.7521651387214661,
-0.015350230038166046,
0.3254740536212921,
0.04893029108643532,
0.32554492354393005,
-0.2900385558605194,
-0.6967299580574036,
-1.1438862085342407,
0.2254542112350464,
0.014426571317017078,
0.5539557933807373,
0.2320229858160019,
0.4990525543689728,
-1.0332791805267334,
1.136005163192749,
-0.1011926680803299,
-0.3545934855937958,
0.02071521431207657,
0.12866495549678802,
-0.13370783627033234,
0.4486447870731354,
0.6427871584892273,
-0.8757452964782715,
-0.7674155831336975,
0.4248407781124115,
-0.8720932006835938,
0.01513060461729765,
-0.18035799264907837,
-0.5381322503089905,
0.05602215975522995,
0.37418171763420105,
-0.9267932772636414,
0.7365997433662415,
0.655889630317688,
-0.47238919138908386,
0.7236939668655396,
-0.5074949264526367,
0.30368664860725403,
-0.8048563599586487,
0.3839242160320282,
-0.28932297229766846,
-0.322388619184494,
-0.8559576272964478,
0.3979986906051636,
0.20450104773044586,
-0.11599821597337723,
-0.48779556155204773,
0.7336218357086182,
-0.2953643798828125,
-0.22332006692886353,
-0.16519273817539215,
-0.3654123842716217,
0.38249439001083374,
0.5821184515953064,
-0.3017410337924957,
0.683039128780365,
0.839455246925354,
-1.3019345998764038,
0.7655000686645508,
0.5994202494621277,
-0.4006185233592987,
0.4884945750236511,
-0.9609423279762268,
-0.24803762137889862,
-0.012812994420528412,
0.24636270105838776,
-0.7244833707809448,
-0.6912795901298523,
0.044746216386556625,
0.09002181887626648,
-0.12472361326217651,
-0.0419362410902977,
-0.3487634062767029,
-0.24547512829303741,
0.4066978693008423,
0.3524414598941803,
0.4485040009021759,
-0.5356167554855347,
1.330377459526062,
0.7964746356010437,
0.023955779150128365,
-0.1925683468580246,
-0.5560850501060486,
0.13161271810531616,
0.07402942329645157,
-0.2504340410232544,
0.6455509066581726,
-0.5018889307975769,
-0.71868896484375,
-0.06581637263298035,
0.30177974700927734,
-0.23994527757167816,
0.40876805782318115,
0.7330248355865479,
0.4076058864593506,
-0.012078735046088696,
-0.37469521164894104,
0.1195371076464653,
-0.03650620952248573,
0.12551362812519073,
-0.41749244928359985,
0.5809600353240967,
-0.397332102060318,
-0.6950529217720032,
-1.0835155248641968,
0.34196245670318604,
1.7082643508911133,
-0.4370850622653961,
0.18128716945648193,
0.3275602161884308,
-0.09207487851381302,
0.09219737350940704,
-0.43397417664527893,
0.32433754205703735,
-0.5347314476966858,
0.03185894340276718,
-0.47070083022117615,
-0.7097221612930298,
0.4705006182193756,
0.07276535779237747,
0.6757422685623169,
0.2507355511188507,
0.8058489561080933,
-0.18278972804546356,
1.3418322801589966,
0.864018976688385,
0.10019329190254211,
0.33750203251838684,
0.18248523771762848,
0.2255660891532898,
-0.597134530544281,
-0.31802091002464294,
-0.5262182354927063,
-0.09470066428184509,
-0.5440092086791992,
0.026810510084033012,
0.26242896914482117,
-0.24066588282585144,
-0.479009747505188,
0.1402609497308731,
-0.34523826837539673,
0.23078644275665283,
0.6367492079734802,
-0.1965448409318924,
0.14919237792491913,
0.06620857864618301,
-0.397500604391098,
0.47749069333076477,
-0.5083962678909302,
-0.6644031405448914,
0.4112681746482849,
0.44575023651123047,
1.0263330936431885,
0.5162596702575684,
0.20596618950366974,
0.8568773865699768,
0.4238029420375824,
-0.7068093419075012,
0.30717143416404724,
0.0055696675553917885,
-0.8985508680343628,
-0.3733251690864563,
-0.1965261846780777,
-0.6472413539886475,
-0.18620991706848145,
-0.023466989398002625,
-0.13324646651744843,
0.26864972710609436,
0.5006833672523499,
-0.7159762382507324,
0.3428151607513428,
-0.5733885765075684,
0.33726420998573303,
-0.5624854564666748,
-0.29285928606987,
-0.34321150183677673,
-0.42027658224105835,
0.13609716296195984,
0.019730083644390106,
0.6209695935249329,
-0.2860921323299408,
0.14020344614982605,
0.27878665924072266,
-0.09706957638263702,
0.8289090394973755,
-0.0024477499537169933,
-0.3087959587574005,
0.24335026741027832,
0.47451627254486084,
0.3414508104324341,
0.11880612373352051,
0.2089618444442749,
-0.02643628790974617,
0.3398486077785492,
-0.5038939118385315,
-0.37174367904663086,
0.3633144199848175,
-0.901508629322052,
-0.16830873489379883,
-0.13718852400779724,
-0.5882546901702881,
-0.28536367416381836,
0.36365363001823425,
0.23045241832733154,
0.8484960198402405,
-0.2792298495769501,
0.1289786845445633,
0.5117429494857788,
0.09025679528713226,
0.6334563493728638,
0.5951109528541565,
-0.6300805807113647,
-0.3610170781612396,
0.6165971159934998,
-0.44666576385498047,
0.2702183127403259,
0.36115118861198425,
-0.15944543480873108,
-0.45628926157951355,
0.2031066119670868,
-0.842761218547821,
-0.02701464481651783,
-0.8650640249252319,
-0.07187621295452118,
-0.7928539514541626,
-0.26984119415283203,
-0.6467670798301697,
-0.3436984121799469,
-0.3627201020717621,
-0.29583001136779785,
-0.13733342289924622,
0.2985127866268158,
0.11608543246984482,
1.440938115119934,
0.10742612183094025,
0.20052878558635712,
-0.8640273213386536,
0.465515673160553,
0.807753324508667,
0.7302936315536499,
-0.08849161118268967,
-0.33227816224098206,
-0.30493319034576416,
-0.05266758054494858,
0.012323369272053242,
-0.48796385526657104,
0.29285728931427,
0.4272332191467285,
0.9019954800605774,
0.3980775475502014,
0.13922397792339325,
0.5586581826210022,
-0.8354844450950623,
0.577977180480957,
0.3740636706352234,
-1.3516236543655396,
0.2095731645822525,
-0.11229582130908966,
0.3860807716846466,
0.2271810919046402,
0.3720379173755646,
-0.7101640701293945,
-0.27047085762023926,
-0.5351439118385315,
-0.6138211488723755,
0.1718980371952057,
-0.1295473873615265,
0.5692789554595947,
-0.08721235394477844,
0.20391309261322021,
0.12004278600215912,
0.3819660544395447,
-0.6496216058731079,
-0.21261602640151978,
-0.3484675884246826,
-0.3092207610607147,
0.12000510096549988,
-0.26153242588043213,
-0.3306748569011688,
-0.11283085495233536,
1.0429433584213257,
-0.16932879388332367,
0.39810070395469666,
0.159788578748703,
-0.18752321600914001,
-0.3770618140697479,
0.41325533390045166,
0.8101431727409363,
0.7619805335998535,
0.35345974564552307,
0.3322623074054718,
-0.2351970076560974,
-0.39074695110321045,
0.325655072927475,
-0.426948606967926,
-0.43844568729400635,
-0.07182193547487259,
0.2559148073196411,
0.8857424259185791,
0.422180712223053,
-0.6614514589309692,
-0.09942371398210526,
-0.356638640165329,
-0.6223661303520203,
-0.30628517270088196,
0.23264113068580627,
-0.3826625943183899,
0.4068688154220581,
0.28078365325927734,
0.5937674045562744,
0.04177764058113098,
-0.5269694328308105,
0.5034489631652832,
0.5121579170227051,
-0.7772368788719177,
-0.4525895118713379,
0.9384374618530273,
0.07840415835380554,
-0.33042165637016296,
0.07039950042963028,
-0.0674392580986023,
-0.3660156726837158,
0.3282022774219513,
0.2970949709415436,
0.5534836649894714,
-0.3492780029773712,
0.3966282606124878,
0.020512567833065987,
0.2554647624492645,
0.03857022151350975,
0.30533069372177124,
-0.07411251217126846,
-0.49342527985572815,
-0.32976800203323364,
-0.8350688815116882,
-0.17020364105701447,
-0.31027349829673767,
-0.8835169672966003,
0.01069705281406641,
-0.9279568791389465,
-0.4953608512878418,
0.2024809867143631,
-0.5347900986671448,
-0.5507171154022217,
0.24724869430065155,
0.1770477294921875,
0.9124984741210938,
-0.4071405827999115,
0.8860952258110046,
0.973794162273407,
-0.16779614984989166,
-0.5380326509475708,
-0.280892550945282,
-0.21431764960289001,
-0.6729996800422668,
0.8406425714492798,
-0.20986023545265198,
-0.5486379265785217,
0.6562528610229492,
-0.3893379867076874,
-0.8736376762390137,
0.9698792695999146,
0.05373162776231766,
-0.6227942705154419,
-0.3189936876296997,
0.018377091735601425,
0.39001989364624023,
-0.6639488935470581,
0.0069861337542533875,
0.4533408582210541,
0.4709835350513458,
-0.006161743309348822,
-1.1153854131698608,
-0.35137709975242615,
-0.3818591237068176,
-0.029839161783456802,
0.16254466772079468,
-0.5169233083724976,
0.8711516261100769,
-0.14339697360992432,
-0.2753586769104004,
0.021387269720435143,
0.47523078322410583,
-0.47334057092666626,
0.19604992866516113,
0.49787333607673645,
0.38525429368019104,
0.6519364714622498,
0.4579603374004364,
1.0427443981170654,
-0.7768006920814514,
0.40910017490386963,
0.9530078768730164,
-0.6295701861381531,
0.6800392866134644,
0.3382025957107544,
0.11459734290838242,
0.6635022759437561,
0.3143598437309265,
0.010078497231006622,
0.7095258831977844,
-0.4626021087169647,
-0.17632780969142914,
-0.26768895983695984,
-0.686484694480896,
0.05838720127940178,
0.8651328086853027,
0.08502604812383652,
-0.0015413997462019324,
-0.17131444811820984,
0.24341946840286255,
-0.1963443160057068,
-0.0032809076365083456,
-0.5768663287162781,
0.9203600287437439,
-0.28901588916778564,
-0.6445371508598328,
0.44359713792800903,
0.18770861625671387,
0.23725537955760956,
-0.5123378038406372,
0.20607899129390717,
0.20916859805583954,
0.1293412297964096,
-0.007742688991129398,
-0.5509178042411804,
0.604045569896698,
-0.08068540692329407,
-0.3686681091785431,
-0.46895647048950195,
0.37308269739151,
-0.167101189494133,
-0.21490921080112457,
0.4674765467643738,
0.4272235631942749,
-0.533061683177948,
0.2336759716272354,
-0.8160253167152405,
-0.0853482261300087,
-0.06997055560350418,
0.017070012167096138,
0.0790371522307396,
0.5310181379318237,
-0.0625353679060936,
0.9480618834495544,
0.7998664379119873,
-0.08548902720212936,
0.09735672920942307,
-0.002500465838238597,
0.6889565587043762,
-0.19489668309688568,
-1.0760202407836914,
-0.8223105669021606,
0.6912080645561218,
0.13924892246723175,
-0.28221872448921204,
0.5156005024909973,
0.2610364556312561,
0.49727052450180054,
-0.10363277047872543,
1.2348401546478271,
-0.33143091201782227,
0.3090108335018158,
-0.4234103858470917,
0.84991854429245,
-0.7088187336921692,
0.0464312918484211,
0.16392919421195984,
-0.5487735271453857,
-0.2009768933057785,
0.44640469551086426,
-0.07283923774957657,
-0.27656030654907227,
0.3314383327960968,
0.7121891379356384,
-0.3828580379486084,
0.0015111711109057069,
0.7769733667373657,
0.19065098464488983,
0.42143240571022034,
0.06570353358983994,
0.789047122001648,
-0.12928958237171173,
0.4087238013744354,
-0.4066677987575531,
-0.1961788833141327,
-0.5464702248573303,
-0.46789485216140747,
-0.8770344853401184,
-0.9477502703666687,
-0.134914368391037,
-0.2432687133550644,
-0.3550548851490021,
1.088733196258545,
1.1041545867919922,
-0.9467719197273254,
-0.33509451150894165,
0.04484530910849571,
-0.39380568265914917,
-0.28745293617248535,
-0.1692589670419693,
-0.27548372745513916,
-0.42508119344711304,
-0.32342448830604553,
0.16694174706935883,
0.8925351500511169,
0.22591820359230042,
-0.6056542992591858,
-0.48630407452583313,
-0.1293381005525589,
0.5222664475440979,
0.7330488562583923,
0.2860163748264313,
-1.0459343194961548,
-0.12845951318740845,
0.1580825299024582,
-0.74949049949646,
-0.2423177808523178,
1.0851283073425293,
-0.3474629819393158,
0.2561565637588501,
0.017468588426709175,
0.6861211657524109,
-0.1447659432888031,
-0.110991470515728,
0.5022169947624207,
-0.47821667790412903,
0.12378675490617752,
0.1113218441605568,
0.45915213227272034,
0.04184475541114807,
-0.55897456407547,
0.19907091557979584,
0.12732231616973877,
-0.7488396167755127,
-0.44235721230506897,
0.7125711441040039,
-0.708716094493866,
-0.3153420686721802,
0.7650465965270996,
-0.1525084674358368,
-0.41072985529899597,
-0.8402581810951233,
-0.22716525197029114,
0.2181025594472885,
-0.08219601958990097,
0.996005117893219,
0.5068901181221008,
-0.17433130741119385,
-0.15245996415615082,
-0.6880804300308228,
0.620314359664917,
0.017842721194028854,
-1.027195930480957,
0.3091822564601898,
0.6054916977882385,
-0.06205806881189346,
0.40275779366493225,
0.5616454482078552,
0.2530304491519928,
0.6289772987365723,
-0.2968498170375824,
0.20573017001152039,
-0.17667867243289948,
-0.6603972315788269,
0.1207677349448204,
0.2995147705078125,
-0.08458510041236877,
0.28689342737197876
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.04064v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.04064v1
|
Ask LLMs Directly, "What shapes your bias?": Measuring Social Bias in Large Language Models
| 2024-06-06T13:32:09 | 2024-06-06T13:32:09 |
Jisu Shin, Hoyun Song, Huije Lee, Soyeong Jeong, Jong C. Park
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY
|
Social bias is shaped by the accumulation of social perceptions towards
targets across various demographic identities. To fully understand such social
bias in large language models (LLMs), it is essential to consider the composite
of social perceptions from diverse perspectives among identities. Previous
studies have either evaluated biases in LLMs by indirectly assessing the
presence of sentiments towards demographic identities in the generated text or
measuring the degree of alignment with given stereotypes. These methods have
limitations in directly quantifying social biases at the level of distinct
perspectives among identities. In this paper, we aim to investigate how social
perceptions from various viewpoints contribute to the development of social
bias in LLMs. To this end, we propose a novel strategy to intuitively quantify
these social perceptions and suggest metrics that can evaluate the social
biases within LLMs by aggregating diverse social perceptions. The experimental
results show the quantitative demonstration of the social attitude in LLMs by
examining social perception. The analysis we conducted shows that our proposed
metrics capture the multi-dimensional aspects of social bias, enabling a
fine-grained and comprehensive investigation of bias in LLMs.
|
[
-0.5773518085479736,
-0.5969162583351135,
0.7255704998970032,
0.32071006298065186,
-0.1878432184457779,
0.4592868685722351,
-0.2979256510734558,
-0.19401681423187256,
0.6168513298034668,
0.2190522849559784,
-0.5964118838310242,
-0.4628932774066925,
-0.8341104388237,
0.059593576937913895,
-0.07647775113582611,
1.0670735836029053,
0.22536501288414001,
0.6034128665924072,
-0.21309617161750793,
-0.29928120970726013,
-0.16134321689605713,
-0.6114383339881897,
-0.40445414185523987,
-0.5291854739189148,
0.7241016030311584,
0.24218419194221497,
0.6188651323318481,
0.36046332120895386,
0.11492028087377548,
0.21732006967067719,
-0.5340515971183777,
0.09616684913635254,
-0.6893929243087769,
-0.005497975740581751,
-0.2500915825366974,
-0.6692873239517212,
-0.24981439113616943,
0.19624200463294983,
0.7868944406509399,
1.01352858543396,
0.21777193248271942,
0.86029452085495,
0.3275853395462036,
0.6968613862991333,
-0.7117086052894592,
-0.01509348675608635,
-0.8272121548652649,
0.0025106999091804028,
-0.5428078174591064,
-0.15416443347930908,
-0.2321871519088745,
-0.3882889747619629,
0.002380887744948268,
0.06437341868877411,
0.2734068036079407,
-0.07313044369220734,
0.3933914601802826,
-0.18158449232578278,
-0.9088684916496277,
-0.0461052842438221,
-0.6264046430587769,
0.7916156053543091,
-0.43947434425354004,
0.3885832130908966,
0.007873876951634884,
0.35838836431503296,
0.06644322723150253,
0.011290834285318851,
-0.47702765464782715,
0.19085608422756195,
0.008097889833152294,
-0.010848529636859894,
0.35629600286483765,
-0.39687642455101013,
0.2398473173379898,
0.16104334592819214,
-0.3282474875450134,
-0.05114306882023811,
-0.29134899377822876,
-0.07651412487030029,
0.7668672800064087,
0.18198329210281372,
0.3364115357398987,
-0.3378337621688843,
-0.32575103640556335,
0.18480059504508972,
-0.8830663561820984,
0.07376449555158615,
0.9939286112785339,
0.18109260499477386,
-0.4238688349723816,
0.652532696723938,
-0.06616286933422089,
0.34865862131118774,
0.284680038690567,
-0.00865695346146822,
0.3425889313220978,
-0.21047468483448029,
0.07965851575136185,
0.20789340138435364,
0.6541067957878113,
0.5642915964126587,
0.5695991516113281,
0.18399111926555634,
-0.04178541898727417,
0.31613218784332275,
0.08455559611320496,
-0.4668084383010864,
0.3821829557418823,
-0.05477742850780487,
-0.6957452893257141,
-0.6267743706703186,
-0.12508507072925568,
-0.9526974558830261,
-0.970943033695221,
-0.21582449972629547,
-0.09354007989168167,
0.09693845361471176,
-0.3930813670158386,
-0.0665464699268341,
-0.24163901805877686,
0.43848755955696106,
0.4237106442451477,
-0.9527142643928528,
0.0999712198972702,
0.8094240427017212,
0.6922878623008728,
-0.3709297776222229,
-0.09563998132944107,
-0.22558560967445374,
0.26984715461730957,
-0.182567298412323,
0.8400744199752808,
-0.7089352011680603,
-0.32037782669067383,
0.11788231134414673,
-0.30322596430778503,
0.147037535905838,
-0.3986724019050598,
0.18520179390907288,
-0.3147888779640198,
0.012639136053621769,
-0.6150566339492798,
-0.33490705490112305,
0.21784208714962006,
0.377297580242157,
-0.4144139289855957,
0.9256302714347839,
-0.04795520380139351,
-1.094131350517273,
0.7291749119758606,
-0.1870281994342804,
-0.10838843137025833,
0.03662220016121864,
-0.7999936938285828,
-0.1068134754896164,
0.3856615424156189,
0.35526207089424133,
0.4372810125350952,
-0.35840651392936707,
0.35123878717422485,
-0.8275453448295593,
-0.015119199641048908,
0.7072429656982422,
-0.459713876247406,
1.0095254182815552,
0.01848902925848961,
-0.3410138189792633,
0.060534484684467316,
-0.636849045753479,
-0.40014469623565674,
0.2037874162197113,
-0.32495471835136414,
-0.8188013434410095,
0.062486760318279266,
-0.18456828594207764,
0.1302417665719986,
0.33431145548820496,
-0.48421981930732727,
0.08619678020477295,
-0.3812382221221924,
0.34943678975105286,
1.2019635438919067,
0.13207602500915527,
0.7787466049194336,
-0.23592674732208252,
0.3781546354293823,
0.01855335384607315,
0.33707094192504883,
0.38945600390434265,
-0.3064272403717041,
-0.7031214237213135,
0.009479699656367302,
-0.09614711254835129,
0.02777588739991188,
-0.44379913806915283,
0.19660848379135132,
-0.4226994514465332,
-0.5353859663009644,
-0.5158817172050476,
0.3425038754940033,
0.2703394889831543,
-0.014265910722315311,
-0.12535269558429718,
-0.2479054033756256,
-0.4160587191581726,
-1.1937246322631836,
-0.7988613247871399,
-0.2953603267669678,
-0.12543818354606628,
0.4001293480396271,
0.5483823418617249,
-0.17405660450458527,
0.6943079233169556,
-0.5378484129905701,
-0.027131859213113785,
-0.2715132534503937,
-0.10865136981010437,
-0.07945112138986588,
0.002075165044516325,
0.6338310241699219,
-0.6406744122505188,
-0.4414476752281189,
-0.06995970755815506,
-0.38549569249153137,
-0.36858469247817993,
0.11274462193250656,
-0.29722803831100464,
-0.12820391356945038,
0.2540244162082672,
-0.5150967240333557,
0.11898396909236908,
0.7665491700172424,
-0.5602269172668457,
0.625893771648407,
0.4366494417190552,
-0.042495835572481155,
-1.0132614374160767,
-0.46128618717193604,
0.4469086229801178,
0.12833864986896515,
-0.36415785551071167,
0.043476004153490067,
-0.1542767733335495,
0.374002605676651,
-0.5043073892593384,
0.6747671961784363,
-0.6666327118873596,
-0.332266628742218,
0.31921371817588806,
0.32691216468811035,
0.06924524158239365,
0.24906465411186218,
-0.20144017040729523,
0.43492382764816284,
0.3775283098220825,
-0.4323911666870117,
0.17948980629444122,
0.04575371369719505,
-0.597123920917511,
0.9214308857917786,
-0.5238975286483765,
0.28609052300453186,
-0.67198646068573,
0.38718894124031067,
-1.2789380550384521,
-0.11233220994472504,
0.04843387380242348,
-0.5931448936462402,
-0.03831368684768677,
-0.2478070855140686,
-0.17581690847873688,
-0.21928051114082336,
-0.5065063238143921,
0.7190022468566895,
0.2520963251590729,
-0.3315446674823761,
0.6853888630867004,
0.7438708543777466,
-0.28849291801452637,
-0.4687226712703705,
-0.6803174614906311,
-0.12402983009815216,
-0.6612893342971802,
-0.6761141419410706,
0.09062906354665756,
-0.0016816837014630437,
-0.8465245962142944,
-0.4147961437702179,
-0.06936736404895782,
0.16807463765144348,
-0.26180943846702576,
0.25122684240341187,
0.21730218827724457,
-0.11013256758451462,
-0.17501239478588104,
0.21791695058345795,
0.27540794014930725,
0.3957937955856323,
-0.07911916822195053,
0.8607340455055237,
0.16249056160449982,
-0.5036965608596802,
0.10947570204734802,
0.14305941760540009,
0.9312372803688049,
-0.19695621728897095,
0.6580504775047302,
0.22471195459365845,
-0.13196828961372375,
-0.33128416538238525,
-0.9512807130813599,
0.013144322670996189,
-0.45204851031303406,
0.2874563932418823,
-0.08478818833827972,
-0.830163836479187,
0.8650534152984619,
0.016650155186653137,
-0.10673778504133224,
0.17980630695819855,
0.9741725921630859,
0.15566696226596832,
1.2268567085266113,
0.25757065415382385,
-0.16231952607631683,
0.40514177083969116,
-0.005113564897328615,
0.1280660778284073,
-1.0688754320144653,
-0.4815625250339508,
-0.6780204176902771,
-0.4365565776824951,
-0.4754081666469574,
-0.5440660119056702,
0.6064287424087524,
-0.4190773665904999,
-0.42281532287597656,
-0.36780133843421936,
-0.26809194684028625,
0.3504435122013092,
0.12464874982833862,
0.17493963241577148,
0.1841413676738739,
0.133904829621315,
-0.1920449286699295,
-0.1492883414030075,
-0.38019469380378723,
-0.8131170272827148,
1.078268051147461,
0.6870710849761963,
0.8104748725891113,
0.20877784490585327,
0.7165693640708923,
0.29027849435806274,
0.4060763716697693,
-0.5999231338500977,
0.6240001320838928,
0.07413966953754425,
-0.7397785186767578,
-0.3419807553291321,
-0.34360697865486145,
-0.7088150382041931,
0.502606987953186,
-0.35917913913726807,
-0.833018958568573,
0.3289307653903961,
0.02493342198431492,
-0.23979055881500244,
0.19719474017620087,
-0.5370727777481079,
0.5756999850273132,
-0.3474380671977997,
-0.30909258127212524,
-0.1364821046590805,
-0.39390677213668823,
0.47931692004203796,
-0.07031983882188797,
0.6069497466087341,
-0.3866029381752014,
-0.017172755673527718,
0.7450745701789856,
-0.1813388168811798,
1.1363321542739868,
-0.25898224115371704,
-0.3930768668651581,
0.11221704632043839,
-0.021260380744934082,
0.37448009848594666,
0.12683968245983124,
-0.23763853311538696,
0.3067522943019867,
-0.14110077917575836,
-0.32671499252319336,
-0.6263924241065979,
0.7418490052223206,
-1.0899975299835205,
-0.4171542823314667,
-0.2275591790676117,
-0.4337528944015503,
-0.3165215253829956,
-0.00030410801991820335,
-0.0048520443961024284,
0.21645213663578033,
-0.5833832621574402,
-0.0358453169465065,
0.535285472869873,
-0.5101805925369263,
-0.08444193750619888,
0.42526760697364807,
-0.41591450572013855,
-0.06082039698958397,
0.41858339309692383,
0.35418668389320374,
0.5752987861633301,
0.19489936530590057,
0.3551699221134186,
-0.2624852657318115,
-0.26356759667396545,
-0.356369286775589,
0.34164124727249146,
-0.7369105815887451,
0.08592112362384796,
-0.5460241436958313,
0.008029326796531677,
-0.669845461845398,
-0.20549757778644562,
-0.19185127317905426,
-0.03595346212387085,
0.14440812170505524,
-0.2390553206205368,
0.15195171535015106,
0.8439339995384216,
0.2562745213508606,
0.43097200989723206,
-0.2798902094364166,
0.29146140813827515,
0.358083575963974,
0.2464519590139389,
0.26860642433166504,
-0.37367865443229675,
0.06860698014497757,
0.23589801788330078,
0.015634318813681602,
-1.0376737117767334,
0.26776495575904846,
-0.22908788919448853,
0.563094973564148,
0.567577064037323,
-0.20213674008846283,
0.3554227650165558,
-0.49226921796798706,
0.8900593519210815,
0.20911645889282227,
-0.8481128811836243,
0.3536875247955322,
-0.46834662556648254,
0.22917822003364563,
0.4656684994697571,
0.3123571276664734,
-0.467492938041687,
-0.7671351432800293,
-0.4534108638763428,
-0.7900758981704712,
0.37576746940612793,
-0.0007169704185798764,
0.39920687675476074,
-0.2533656358718872,
0.31388622522354126,
0.04243240877985954,
0.1352045238018036,
-0.8789216876029968,
-0.566666305065155,
0.19621486961841583,
-0.06320090591907501,
-0.15711280703544617,
-0.6175777912139893,
-0.16325710713863373,
-0.2305569350719452,
0.30969861149787903,
-0.010750572197139263,
-0.06515023857355118,
-0.21060970425605774,
-0.0596831813454628,
-0.13678401708602905,
0.42270269989967346,
0.2929771840572357,
0.7476977705955505,
-0.04512685164809227,
0.451408714056015,
0.34161537885665894,
-0.51179039478302,
0.17450051009655,
-0.4279240071773529,
-0.4709358513355255,
0.10443517565727234,
0.15116356313228607,
0.7097181081771851,
0.017864476889371872,
-0.2100796103477478,
0.5918841361999512,
-0.04406958818435669,
-0.10036751627922058,
-0.35540229082107544,
-0.19292297959327698,
0.38653022050857544,
0.23923400044441223,
0.4421657621860504,
-0.28091874718666077,
-0.04940212890505791,
-0.8995499014854431,
-0.2816523611545563,
0.6973772048950195,
-0.457512229681015,
-0.24574528634548187,
0.47376760840415955,
0.28683894872665405,
-0.12295131385326385,
0.04357045888900757,
0.021349327638745308,
-0.5595493316650391,
0.6295264959335327,
0.4173772931098938,
0.8279488682746887,
-0.2862434685230255,
0.43533605337142944,
0.12303975224494934,
0.4496730864048004,
0.14276374876499176,
-0.06073157116770744,
0.12652303278446198,
-1.1613352298736572,
-0.34624141454696655,
-0.8846892714500427,
0.004166539292782545,
-0.07177934795618057,
-0.749255895614624,
0.38311251997947693,
-0.28692594170570374,
-0.3197095990180969,
0.3772276043891907,
-0.2875806391239166,
-0.7420583963394165,
0.08538917452096939,
0.4863821268081665,
0.719462513923645,
-1.2218159437179565,
0.3654421865940094,
0.8934932947158813,
-0.1600693166255951,
-0.6755315065383911,
0.08330782502889633,
0.44642359018325806,
-1.3663363456726074,
0.7957004308700562,
0.02530333213508129,
-0.13952456414699554,
-0.34327590465545654,
-0.5624355673789978,
-0.8177061676979065,
0.6190146803855896,
0.31615105271339417,
-0.42263421416282654,
-0.2302800416946411,
0.5978618264198303,
0.37419408559799194,
-0.5588090419769287,
0.2716728448867798,
0.7348242998123169,
0.5586485862731934,
-0.13228824734687805,
-0.6830452680587769,
0.12344659864902496,
-0.18578757345676422,
0.26748204231262207,
0.20837049186229706,
-0.8472684621810913,
0.7779396176338196,
-0.01252997387200594,
-0.03869252651929855,
-0.5118982195854187,
0.41801393032073975,
0.268807053565979,
0.41852521896362305,
0.6093697547912598,
0.1184806227684021,
0.5830894708633423,
0.10337743908166885,
0.7950620651245117,
-0.29714730381965637,
0.24348954856395721,
0.8100744485855103,
-0.4511038661003113,
0.25032728910446167,
0.7307291626930237,
-0.3192750811576843,
0.5285018086433411,
0.4148259460926056,
0.2345426231622696,
0.25290852785110474,
0.7199351787567139,
-0.4350701570510864,
-0.15162186324596405,
-0.3621270954608917,
-0.2267502397298813,
0.4522698223590851,
0.47113582491874695,
-0.4432229697704315,
-0.22742322087287903,
-0.11346446722745895,
0.0789293572306633,
0.29415345191955566,
-0.6537173986434937,
0.776748776435852,
0.2602427303791046,
-0.5123765468597412,
0.0022841813042759895,
-0.09681356698274612,
0.9194712042808533,
-0.5299054980278015,
0.2282899171113968,
-0.32167401909828186,
0.06105468049645424,
-0.4338057339191437,
-0.896943211555481,
0.10171382129192352,
0.040507424622774124,
-0.3136384189128876,
-0.2595188319683075,
0.6350328326225281,
-0.36644744873046875,
-0.6850813031196594,
0.24619460105895996,
0.7029645442962646,
0.26080968976020813,
-0.14281108975410461,
-0.42141610383987427,
0.5557833909988403,
0.17504273355007172,
-0.19083574414253235,
0.644105851650238,
0.8016743659973145,
-0.16364417970180511,
0.5607051849365234,
0.3573972284793854,
0.34063971042633057,
0.2043887823820114,
0.4083579480648041,
0.6371370553970337,
-0.38352859020233154,
-0.25509920716285706,
-1.2097909450531006,
0.354187935590744,
-0.22147829830646515,
-0.3389703333377838,
1.0006695985794067,
0.5446056723594666,
0.9505553245544434,
0.12466385960578918,
1.0420167446136475,
0.22017577290534973,
0.4371784031391144,
-0.24019992351531982,
0.8235881328582764,
-0.48431268334388733,
0.22741152346134186,
-0.7327423691749573,
-1.1004853248596191,
0.124723881483078,
0.6460033059120178,
-0.6719156503677368,
0.14389657974243164,
0.2758580446243286,
0.752598226070404,
0.2537013292312622,
-0.15710464119911194,
-0.04141239449381828,
0.2931329011917114,
0.16846418380737305,
0.36771661043167114,
1.0960010290145874,
0.15848253667354584,
0.3130389451980591,
0.14722371101379395,
-0.30866312980651855,
0.04441284015774727,
-0.7665231227874756,
-1.088897943496704,
-0.30478808283805847,
-0.24855218827724457,
-0.5437805652618408,
-0.1381402462720871,
1.01085364818573,
0.4119470417499542,
-0.44006046652793884,
-0.459429532289505,
0.4205397963523865,
0.3528123199939728,
0.27429816126823425,
-0.32265764474868774,
0.06719734519720078,
-0.09692537784576416,
-0.7340530753135681,
-0.3656582534313202,
0.22495615482330322,
-0.08556734770536423,
-0.9351958632469177,
0.006798658519983292,
-0.007046024315059185,
0.28232190012931824,
0.8380184173583984,
-0.24027301371097565,
-0.568070650100708,
-0.40988534688949585,
-0.0003396832325961441,
-0.2374466359615326,
-0.14824216067790985,
0.791204035282135,
-0.2614552080631256,
0.1790480613708496,
0.4345109462738037,
0.30018821358680725,
0.38152560591697693,
-0.030534224584698677,
0.661942183971405,
-0.6106505990028381,
0.11173804104328156,
0.026056155562400818,
0.3223170042037964,
0.43655315041542053,
-0.431462824344635,
0.2230152040719986,
0.13161413371562958,
-0.36110690236091614,
-0.8481819033622742,
0.5039130449295044,
-0.9285635352134705,
-0.11353340744972229,
1.6452089548110962,
0.4466996192932129,
-0.15437161922454834,
-0.01981344446539879,
-0.2987787425518036,
0.08942655473947525,
-0.4328983724117279,
0.9544675946235657,
0.6868089437484741,
0.0869269147515297,
0.018100246787071228,
-0.49860966205596924,
0.31412070989608765,
0.2887536883354187,
-0.4439707100391388,
0.10929198563098907,
0.6766627430915833,
0.40580418705940247,
0.22867517173290253,
0.7365691065788269,
-0.3560895621776581,
-0.40152251720428467,
-0.19767656922340393,
-0.12878310680389404,
0.5711212754249573,
0.08355632424354553,
-0.07294432818889618,
0.18157929182052612,
0.1558784693479538,
0.24786433577537537
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.04025v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.04025v1
|
The syntax-semantics interface in a child's path: A study of 3- to 11-year-olds' elicited production of Mandarin recursive relative clauses
| 2024-06-06T12:51:14 | 2024-06-06T12:51:14 |
Caimei Yang, Qihang Yang, Xingzhi Su, Chenxi Fu, Xiaoyi Wang, Ying Yan, Zaijiang Man
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
There have been apparently conflicting claims over the syntax-semantics
relationship in child acquisition. However, few of them have assessed the
child's path toward the acquisition of recursive relative clauses (RRCs). The
authors of the current paper did experiments to investigate 3- to 11-year-olds'
most-structured elicited production of eight Mandarin RRCs in a 4 (syntactic
types)*2 (semantic conditions) design. The four syntactic types were RRCs with
a subject-gapped RC embedded in an object-gapped RC (SORRCs), RRCs with an
object-gapped RC embedded in another object-gapped RC (OORRCs), RRCs with an
object-gapped RC embedded in a subject-gapped RC (OSRRCs), and RRCs with a
subject-gapped RC embedded in another subject-gapped RC (SSRRCs). Each
syntactic type was put in two conditions differing in internal semantics:
irreversible internal semantics (IIS) and reversible internal semantics (RIS).
For example, "the balloon that [the girl that _ eats the banana] holds _" is
SORRCs in the IIS condition; "the monkey that [the dog that _ bites the pig]
hits_" is SORRCs in the RIS condition. For each target, the participants were
provided with a speech-visual stimulus constructing a condition of irreversible
external semantics (IES). The results showed that SSRRCs, OSRRCs and SORRCs in
the IIS-IES condition were produced two years earlier than their counterparts
in the RIS-IES condition. Thus, a 2-stage development path is proposed: the
language acquisition device starts with the interface between (irreversible)
syntax and IIS, and ends with the interface between syntax and IES, both
abiding by the syntax-semantic interface principle.
|
[
-0.23420505225658417,
-0.7192890048027039,
0.39526283740997314,
0.25989773869514465,
-0.1277012676000595,
0.04969935864210129,
-0.062347933650016785,
-0.6529280543327332,
-0.18676520884037018,
0.329902708530426,
-0.6393265724182129,
-0.10996882617473602,
-0.38148969411849976,
0.13778086006641388,
-0.34138092398643494,
1.0627646446228027,
-0.1608995944261551,
-0.3473092019557953,
-0.028335046023130417,
-0.04215008020401001,
-0.3182481825351715,
-0.48847225308418274,
-0.668735921382904,
-0.17183725535869598,
0.5404490232467651,
0.7342413067817688,
0.5693775415420532,
0.6228066682815552,
0.40400394797325134,
0.3208746314048767,
-0.2891113758087158,
-0.11958473175764084,
-0.030177097767591476,
0.3859321177005768,
-0.3109217882156372,
-0.2539024353027344,
0.041963718831539154,
0.14875903725624084,
0.6401203274726868,
0.7960329055786133,
-0.29076796770095825,
-0.1656448394060135,
0.15972359478473663,
1.1015503406524658,
-0.4360053241252899,
0.3625442087650299,
-0.4984593689441681,
0.2621060311794281,
-0.20878267288208008,
-0.22380875051021576,
-0.4183084964752197,
-0.35126787424087524,
0.29070189595222473,
-0.45767125487327576,
-0.11099105328321457,
-0.04661864414811134,
1.0254037380218506,
-0.14660325646400452,
-0.3200629949569702,
-0.3338190019130707,
-0.5591750741004944,
0.5598563551902771,
-0.4365578591823578,
0.451014906167984,
0.29451143741607666,
0.18356125056743622,
-0.550751268863678,
-0.9517999887466431,
-0.6734569668769836,
-0.6809951663017273,
-0.4843475818634033,
0.07567868381738663,
-0.07575356215238571,
-0.019528163596987724,
0.5373702645301819,
0.12624213099479675,
-0.7019157409667969,
-0.26912984251976013,
-0.49807193875312805,
0.13223274052143097,
0.16947327554225922,
0.2056679129600525,
0.45419842004776,
-0.37467578053474426,
-0.49119067192077637,
0.24490834772586823,
-1.1492799520492554,
0.21754813194274902,
0.2699297368526459,
0.6589959859848022,
-0.1577601134777069,
0.7332404255867004,
-0.4232671558856964,
0.7744998335838318,
0.08688170462846756,
-0.10484004020690918,
0.19686606526374817,
-0.7906537055969238,
0.12116310000419617,
0.044688351452350616,
0.5544500946998596,
0.04240240901708603,
0.7760158777236938,
-0.03982715681195259,
-0.25988999009132385,
0.3096622824668884,
0.22870180010795593,
-0.458621084690094,
-0.06809837371110916,
-0.09534543007612228,
-0.5148778557777405,
-0.1871211975812912,
-0.0246345903724432,
-0.27949023246765137,
0.0159083791077137,
-0.23434506356716156,
0.09237214177846909,
-0.5261654853820801,
-0.18524028360843658,
-0.14044100046157837,
-0.10323832929134369,
0.5234057307243347,
-0.10735739767551422,
-0.9279693961143494,
0.4439135789871216,
0.5030404925346375,
0.6984699368476868,
0.030183764174580574,
-0.5128130912780762,
-0.3248654305934906,
0.2004421204328537,
-0.42813771963119507,
0.9729702472686768,
-0.724315881729126,
-0.18813124299049377,
0.1985647976398468,
0.08159759640693665,
-0.1702214926481247,
-0.7207570672035217,
0.2415941059589386,
-0.40122872591018677,
0.47031471133232117,
0.21692009270191193,
-0.0550423264503479,
-0.203691303730011,
-0.04385221749544144,
-0.128625750541687,
0.9367592930793762,
0.4230387210845947,
-0.7509689927101135,
0.5464348196983337,
-0.25170984864234924,
-0.9003023505210876,
-0.23204918205738068,
-0.546665608882904,
-0.08035025000572205,
-0.21469877660274506,
-0.2378443479537964,
0.16753792762756348,
-0.19773045182228088,
0.24387547373771667,
-0.021317316219210625,
-0.2573537826538086,
0.23363763093948364,
-0.30041342973709106,
0.8213911652565002,
0.22464722394943237,
-0.6162380576133728,
-0.1372939944267273,
-0.5426592826843262,
-0.09816545248031616,
0.3150971531867981,
-0.33850300312042236,
-0.1638190597295761,
0.20364880561828613,
-0.39526715874671936,
0.5484715700149536,
0.15126746892929077,
-0.5032166242599487,
0.24813514947891235,
-0.49658969044685364,
0.741519570350647,
0.35913896560668945,
0.27827346324920654,
0.3750659227371216,
-0.3185780644416809,
0.4160110056400299,
0.04982060566544533,
0.23779937624931335,
-0.4093427360057831,
-0.7043544054031372,
-0.9873284101486206,
0.5114953517913818,
-0.1261271834373474,
0.4150342643260956,
-0.751179575920105,
0.2843094766139984,
0.0460369735956192,
-0.14579050242900848,
0.07045769691467285,
-0.18590199947357178,
0.7185739278793335,
0.44963642954826355,
0.09626978635787964,
-0.3328650891780853,
-0.3502730429172516,
-1.0355451107025146,
-0.168390691280365,
-0.798508882522583,
0.26040422916412354,
0.16687053442001343,
0.2525177299976349,
0.23216915130615234,
0.5875548124313354,
-0.39837267994880676,
-0.3030316233634949,
-0.4063971936702728,
0.17107170820236206,
0.31855151057243347,
0.7424635887145996,
0.5238856077194214,
-0.6105955839157104,
-0.44785207509994507,
0.17054273188114166,
-0.3282961845397949,
-0.15988561511039734,
-0.16785770654678345,
-0.16762465238571167,
0.45122256875038147,
0.7136643528938293,
-0.7446844577789307,
0.5991590023040771,
0.17755647003650665,
-0.4983167052268982,
0.5511882305145264,
-0.012299496680498123,
0.020714208483695984,
-0.418348491191864,
-0.15660862624645233,
-0.02185884304344654,
-0.19716881215572357,
-0.6275257468223572,
0.28006747364997864,
-0.16453585028648376,
0.19288142025470734,
-0.6169782280921936,
0.16228312253952026,
-0.4523942172527313,
-0.22637760639190674,
-0.0011810320429503918,
0.5342954993247986,
0.0002884402056224644,
0.5988934636116028,
0.3968633711338043,
0.8366448283195496,
0.19533085823059082,
-0.6982924938201904,
0.03722259774804115,
-0.2151670902967453,
-0.13027533888816833,
0.4763809144496918,
-0.6056838035583496,
0.08903265744447708,
0.026670796796679497,
0.21420066058635712,
-1.08307945728302,
0.12429700791835785,
0.7635767459869385,
-0.8439279794692993,
0.4900522828102112,
0.08270799368619919,
-0.37950482964515686,
-0.19819185137748718,
-0.24054622650146484,
0.4044826924800873,
0.4993836283683777,
-0.3618147671222687,
0.4461393654346466,
0.1687941551208496,
-0.34042248129844666,
-0.4751148819923401,
-0.9194891452789307,
0.04762804135680199,
-0.14673271775245667,
-0.6767269372940063,
0.4060107469558716,
0.12177975475788116,
-0.33392155170440674,
0.3619896173477173,
-0.156831294298172,
-0.13474221527576447,
-0.24250853061676025,
0.032822709530591965,
0.2544448673725128,
-0.5822343230247498,
-0.0328911729156971,
0.1224212795495987,
-0.1917499303817749,
0.08882741630077362,
0.08348913490772247,
0.28565552830696106,
-0.07518090307712555,
-0.13158759474754333,
-0.22411379218101501,
0.14834660291671753,
0.2863415479660034,
0.09418869763612747,
0.5883929133415222,
-0.0087754400447011,
-0.5213890075683594,
-0.14521251618862152,
-0.19472737610340118,
0.04716411605477333,
-0.4962890148162842,
0.15987418591976166,
-0.5327041745185852,
-0.5264970660209656,
0.24974940717220306,
0.07467290014028549,
0.03624018654227257,
0.5956725478172302,
0.17925067245960236,
-0.015886466950178146,
0.7480760812759399,
0.21701709926128387,
0.2917051315307617,
0.5687897801399231,
-0.2551906108856201,
-0.031277649104595184,
-1.2303094863891602,
-0.460299015045166,
-0.7568408250808716,
0.19754931330680847,
-0.6126459836959839,
-0.39298710227012634,
-0.1217665821313858,
0.15051423013210297,
-0.7684757709503174,
0.6346884965896606,
-0.4263831377029419,
0.30390486121177673,
0.4874957501888275,
-0.1979767084121704,
0.26051685214042664,
-0.24822787940502167,
-0.27484801411628723,
-0.09454174339771271,
-0.746829628944397,
-0.5001323223114014,
0.5679583549499512,
0.34589478373527527,
0.5194525718688965,
0.43239626288414,
0.40797144174575806,
0.03129488602280617,
0.3622880280017853,
-0.6783035397529602,
0.672418475151062,
-0.3215235471725464,
-0.5954532027244568,
-0.09598469734191895,
-0.21741339564323425,
-0.9938154816627502,
0.39524176716804504,
-0.001004231977276504,
-1.0630875825881958,
0.3500927686691284,
-0.04747214540839195,
-0.1629614531993866,
-0.17168360948562622,
-0.8370877504348755,
0.8241064548492432,
-0.3038717806339264,
-0.6254754066467285,
-0.13853120803833008,
-1.0592790842056274,
0.4496334493160248,
0.18420419096946716,
0.05265771225094795,
0.08412452787160873,
-0.07245293259620667,
0.6889147162437439,
-0.322898268699646,
0.6978538036346436,
-0.2710866332054138,
0.09511424601078033,
0.8066202402114868,
0.3985570967197418,
0.5216721892356873,
-0.195375457406044,
0.35793164372444153,
-0.18424612283706665,
-0.24266545474529266,
-0.0027398436795920134,
-0.793099582195282,
0.730379045009613,
-0.4329305589199066,
-0.722474992275238,
-0.9096652269363403,
-0.01233668439090252,
-0.3572236895561218,
0.31376567482948303,
-0.13991080224514008,
0.6045535206794739,
0.1414473056793213,
0.10614639520645142,
0.22734571993350983,
-0.4664347171783447,
0.34575191140174866,
0.8459427952766418,
-0.45651376247406006,
-0.1256711781024933,
0.7731672525405884,
0.04589478299021721,
0.7846989631652832,
0.3544905483722687,
0.2947019934654236,
-0.40358683466911316,
-0.41868388652801514,
-0.30190613865852356,
0.5103623867034912,
-0.6996870636940002,
-0.1549476683139801,
-0.22294387221336365,
-0.6407780647277832,
-0.12843666970729828,
-0.1895727813243866,
-0.10459281504154205,
-0.5706470012664795,
-0.24869778752326965,
-0.1686471700668335,
0.19593678414821625,
1.1008479595184326,
-0.1886741667985916,
0.03659801557660103,
-0.6793015599250793,
0.4818614423274994,
0.13309769332408905,
0.2536880671977997,
0.2576799988746643,
-0.7889795303344727,
-0.03105374053120613,
-0.1551755666732788,
-0.3844379782676697,
-0.7493528127670288,
0.05504602566361427,
0.2581993043422699,
0.4560088813304901,
0.5003504753112793,
-0.1309482604265213,
0.7430017590522766,
-0.5854620337486267,
0.9880915880203247,
0.22337529063224792,
-0.7694233655929565,
0.6575762629508972,
-0.42233678698539734,
0.0825844407081604,
0.30370473861694336,
0.11795006692409515,
-0.84824138879776,
-0.699519693851471,
-0.6742651462554932,
-0.8374975323677063,
0.991937518119812,
0.3545158803462982,
0.04993942379951477,
-0.41176676750183105,
0.26634055376052856,
-0.019345078617334366,
0.04089612141251564,
-0.8653967380523682,
-0.38743728399276733,
-0.015846312046051025,
0.06719628721475601,
0.2725647985935211,
-0.15265020728111267,
0.10554295778274536,
-0.2577727138996124,
0.42681583762168884,
0.20401814579963684,
0.21758145093917847,
0.38291680812835693,
0.22471970319747925,
-0.18358471989631653,
0.14871440827846527,
0.6500298976898193,
0.6173204779624939,
-0.2042330503463745,
0.31857380270957947,
-0.390545517206192,
-0.3088300824165344,
0.15210263431072235,
-0.07545852661132812,
-0.09014763683080673,
-0.2265588492155075,
0.643633246421814,
0.551960825920105,
0.12012042850255966,
-0.5446839928627014,
0.45165327191352844,
0.0656794086098671,
0.06218695268034935,
-0.508891761302948,
0.17351152002811432,
0.07072308659553528,
0.1610749512910843,
0.14990440011024475,
-0.02700725570321083,
0.07125253975391388,
-0.8914842009544373,
0.3816744089126587,
0.15608978271484375,
-0.42409783601760864,
-0.33624356985092163,
0.46073117852211,
0.05467978119850159,
-0.2828918397426605,
0.8241439461708069,
-0.16646073758602142,
-0.5591445565223694,
0.6501653790473938,
0.7671859860420227,
1.022987961769104,
-0.11106766760349274,
0.3525647222995758,
0.4990362524986267,
0.7227858901023865,
0.31403547525405884,
0.2372976392507553,
-0.10758501291275024,
-0.7916317582130432,
-0.20651274919509888,
-0.17218410968780518,
0.05851925536990166,
-0.12241905927658081,
-0.5782983303070068,
0.1358450949192047,
-0.2852618992328644,
-0.027047375217080116,
-0.04779127612709999,
-0.3736143708229065,
-0.5273881554603577,
0.27309104800224304,
-0.029255511239171028,
0.84916752576828,
-0.6410015225410461,
0.6735919117927551,
0.5194081664085388,
-0.8511768579483032,
-0.8855499029159546,
0.23343916237354279,
-0.22021062672138214,
-0.9322652816772461,
1.0975791215896606,
0.003895275294780731,
-0.47535601258277893,
-0.3124353587627411,
-0.2074800431728363,
-0.9337523579597473,
0.6262184381484985,
-0.2081151008605957,
-0.4408169090747833,
0.001696786843240261,
0.17724348604679108,
0.5786584615707397,
-0.4746222496032715,
0.27478596568107605,
0.879833459854126,
0.49667277932167053,
0.054108407348394394,
-0.7013779878616333,
0.1927611082792282,
-0.08449488878250122,
0.08448771387338638,
0.2846052944660187,
-0.6871337890625,
0.7806870341300964,
-0.478108286857605,
-0.5895867943763733,
0.22259584069252014,
0.6615967154502869,
0.30201131105422974,
0.17193658649921417,
0.49938860535621643,
0.3978377878665924,
-0.08966004103422165,
-0.09158384054899216,
1.0595375299453735,
-0.401842325925827,
0.09251905232667923,
1.142180323600769,
-0.01949126645922661,
1.0665136575698853,
0.6162886619567871,
-0.6192876100540161,
0.7928071618080139,
0.7930999994277954,
0.7522151470184326,
0.7362650632858276,
0.4786680042743683,
0.031003111973404884,
0.2217871993780136,
-0.32776764035224915,
-0.43806931376457214,
0.2915017306804657,
0.7522727847099304,
-0.4209939241409302,
0.05994091555476189,
-0.37870320677757263,
0.21125173568725586,
0.11762480437755585,
-0.1014023944735527,
0.7611672282218933,
0.2833020091056824,
-0.8948267698287964,
0.5073687434196472,
-0.08334501832723618,
0.3365505635738373,
-0.742047131061554,
-0.4501335322856903,
-0.4694899916648865,
-0.2123286873102188,
-0.33529356122016907,
-1.2760210037231445,
0.3394029438495636,
-0.0530124269425869,
0.16000281274318695,
0.11963607370853424,
0.7015603184700012,
-0.4695056974887848,
-0.21271604299545288,
0.3089826703071594,
0.340104341506958,
0.20692315697669983,
0.4811405539512634,
-0.6059533357620239,
0.010946329683065414,
0.03902023658156395,
-0.48918700218200684,
0.2088976800441742,
0.6378089189529419,
0.030457548797130585,
0.6720867156982422,
0.3802284896373749,
0.4598369598388672,
0.07844492793083191,
0.20382161438465118,
0.98153156042099,
-0.8891580700874329,
-0.16015556454658508,
-0.519183337688446,
0.45485037565231323,
0.4493565857410431,
-0.4277420938014984,
0.48494550585746765,
0.3159828186035156,
0.8666657209396362,
0.2940734326839447,
0.6164466738700867,
-0.2515009045600891,
0.5286736488342285,
-0.5655719637870789,
0.07041237503290176,
-0.6389875411987305,
0.06063840538263321,
-0.45586317777633667,
-1.0787734985351562,
-0.21831831336021423,
0.9063135981559753,
-0.21235254406929016,
0.3443193733692169,
1.3127285242080688,
0.5314609408378601,
0.1961204558610916,
-0.1973494291305542,
-0.039751749485731125,
0.14485424757003784,
0.2020236849784851,
0.5311065912246704,
1.357406735420227,
-0.10243915766477585,
0.3864169418811798,
-0.532527506351471,
-0.3616127073764801,
0.14122223854064941,
-0.5332598090171814,
-0.3457186222076416,
-0.6012983918190002,
-0.2730700373649597,
-0.38624948263168335,
0.3355037569999695,
0.6965947151184082,
0.18139681220054626,
-0.556797444820404,
-0.43193942308425903,
-0.37717095017433167,
0.2583467662334442,
-0.1746872365474701,
-0.3402133584022522,
0.29200270771980286,
-0.36818501353263855,
-0.5645129084587097,
0.2248661369085312,
0.4371759593486786,
0.06138516589999199,
-0.5225358009338379,
0.04511973634362221,
-0.32824617624282837,
0.04070454463362694,
0.6647019386291504,
0.5369442701339722,
-0.8704209923744202,
-0.6934953331947327,
-0.21600939333438873,
-0.21355625987052917,
0.12746372818946838,
0.8813608884811401,
-0.8697571158409119,
0.42009237408638,
0.38150402903556824,
0.09830674529075623,
0.13917085528373718,
0.12185248732566833,
0.449646532535553,
-0.5540889501571655,
0.34468039870262146,
0.13732053339481354,
0.32392945885658264,
0.16215559840202332,
-0.15624693036079407,
0.6720343828201294,
0.29336127638816833,
-0.4771924912929535,
-0.5721825957298279,
0.4442703425884247,
-0.6562167406082153,
-0.3274857699871063,
1.3141480684280396,
-0.07795760780572891,
-0.18408450484275818,
-0.22752125561237335,
-0.26207035779953003,
0.15845194458961487,
-0.477092444896698,
0.3815094828605652,
0.40351447463035583,
-0.5286774039268494,
0.2433064877986908,
-0.4912914037704468,
0.29450297355651855,
0.23598268628120422,
-0.49857911467552185,
0.13463044166564941,
0.5541490912437439,
0.013552069664001465,
0.15452386438846588,
0.7637665271759033,
-0.2879755198955536,
0.282826691865921,
0.4733426570892334,
-0.03494046628475189,
0.42742475867271423,
-0.6299777626991272,
-0.062074992805719376,
-0.18294982612133026,
0.576556384563446,
-0.49330049753189087
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.04024v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.04024v2
|
American Sign Language Handshapes Reflect Pressures for Communicative Efficiency
| 2024-06-06T12:46:21 | 2024-06-10T13:45:36 |
Kayo Yin, Terry Regier, Dan Klein
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Communicative efficiency is a key topic in linguistics and cognitive
psychology, with many studies demonstrating how the pressure to communicate
with minimal effort guides the form of natural language. However, this
phenomenon is rarely explored in signed languages. This paper shows how
handshapes in American Sign Language (ASL) reflect these efficiency pressures
and provides new evidence of communicative efficiency in the visual-gestural
modality.
We focus on hand configurations in native ASL signs and signs borrowed from
English to compare efficiency pressures from both ASL and English usage. First,
we develop new methodologies to quantify the articulatory effort needed to
produce handshapes and the perceptual effort required to recognize them. Then,
we analyze correlations between communicative effort and usage statistics in
ASL or English. Our findings reveal that frequent ASL handshapes are easier to
produce and that pressures for communicative efficiency mostly come from ASL
usage, rather than from English lexical borrowing.
|
[
0.13248606026172638,
-0.3821242153644562,
0.3849189281463623,
0.1398961991071701,
-0.5800660252571106,
-0.015980985015630722,
-0.18547305464744568,
-0.7461262345314026,
0.3908124268054962,
0.19961194694042206,
-0.15051433444023132,
-0.4588320255279541,
-0.8437147736549377,
0.32175973057746887,
-0.052149467170238495,
0.36634036898612976,
-0.24170909821987152,
-0.05255447328090668,
-0.07826050370931625,
-0.4298645555973053,
-0.09216533601284027,
-0.5633746385574341,
-0.6689671874046326,
-0.5453099608421326,
-0.02593594789505005,
0.4210321009159088,
1.1251016855239868,
0.6769688725471497,
0.7627681493759155,
0.34680789709091187,
0.18294888734817505,
-0.09956666827201843,
-0.07351011037826538,
0.08395475894212723,
0.4138120114803314,
-0.0001823195634642616,
-0.2244633585214615,
0.2462102323770523,
0.4420618414878845,
0.9482700824737549,
-0.1935572773218155,
0.00852749403566122,
0.36089634895324707,
0.6632928252220154,
-0.5650776624679565,
0.36049121618270874,
-0.27048447728157043,
-0.0819615051150322,
-0.39507240056991577,
-0.4165213406085968,
-0.18534737825393677,
-0.41758784651756287,
-0.00823100283741951,
-0.6496193408966064,
-0.2245461642742157,
-0.16570433974266052,
0.7804169058799744,
0.4285627603530884,
-0.8192688226699829,
-0.7619785666465759,
-0.43611449003219604,
0.5477267503738403,
-0.5968006253242493,
0.8578078150749207,
0.20995880663394928,
0.08085034787654877,
0.12121313810348511,
-0.38725554943084717,
-0.40768373012542725,
-0.36031094193458557,
-0.1674467772245407,
-0.027971364557743073,
-0.39654064178466797,
0.20693789422512054,
0.5516947507858276,
0.35425493121147156,
-0.5103397965431213,
0.23962843418121338,
-0.5212365388870239,
-0.24072515964508057,
0.7537292242050171,
-0.08200769126415253,
0.6083442568778992,
-0.25424179434776306,
-0.3328491449356079,
-0.44355353713035583,
-0.6347303986549377,
0.4292907118797302,
0.22070248425006866,
0.3090023398399353,
-0.3859114348888397,
0.4537925124168396,
-0.22100114822387695,
0.9950208067893982,
-0.3181420862674713,
-0.17486515641212463,
0.1767345666885376,
-0.40648671984672546,
-0.1560458391904831,
-0.473118394613266,
0.7268087863922119,
0.4264911413192749,
0.5590953230857849,
0.27668020129203796,
-0.08601167798042297,
0.19391146302223206,
-0.061675313860177994,
-0.5312392115592957,
-0.25171032547950745,
-0.4446895718574524,
-0.7150447368621826,
0.11613740026950836,
0.31765487790107727,
0.010233936831355095,
-0.4744751453399658,
-0.30251240730285645,
0.4712783098220825,
-0.6534422636032104,
-0.10959237813949585,
0.3167189359664917,
-0.4430486261844635,
0.394840806722641,
0.5011067986488342,
-0.7007554173469543,
0.4846900999546051,
0.5035882592201233,
0.7511956691741943,
-0.16092726588249207,
-0.16505029797554016,
-0.4096185266971588,
-0.2964576184749603,
-0.0499739833176136,
0.5710347294807434,
-0.39855170249938965,
-0.49304935336112976,
-0.05486898869276047,
-0.3488054871559143,
-0.0858793705701828,
-0.3479596972465515,
0.41928619146347046,
-0.14502838253974915,
-0.2602032423019409,
-0.43012070655822754,
-0.32745498418807983,
-0.20416535437107086,
-0.3259205222129822,
-0.5732648968696594,
0.5762386918067932,
-0.289878785610199,
0.0955045148730278,
0.6910468339920044,
-0.43763595819473267,
-1.1774320602416992,
0.3152889013290405,
-0.46296003460884094,
0.046610455960035324,
0.5379455089569092,
-0.32082420587539673,
0.5965739488601685,
-0.12659065425395966,
-0.5580248832702637,
0.28432697057724,
-0.35680535435676575,
0.3244132995605469,
-0.2625708281993866,
1.242383360862732,
0.2600390315055847,
-0.6453858017921448,
-0.4240551292896271,
-0.5688167214393616,
0.016762005165219307,
-0.23429368436336517,
-0.4760991632938385,
-0.863645613193512,
-0.008544180542230606,
-0.36216047406196594,
0.18389596045017242,
0.3062887191772461,
-0.41590917110443115,
-0.0198283102363348,
0.07131943106651306,
-0.040463853627443314,
0.2616311013698578,
0.1056634858250618,
0.28671661019325256,
0.19243872165679932,
0.41831669211387634,
-0.5510727167129517,
0.4374668598175049,
0.08508814126253128,
-0.558556318283081,
-0.7749524712562561,
-0.0662383884191513,
-0.3918669521808624,
0.32333043217658997,
-0.6587961912155151,
0.3437345623970032,
0.016765078529715538,
-0.4725373685359955,
-0.18324071168899536,
0.11057845503091812,
0.7365033626556396,
0.21480728685855865,
0.0413864329457283,
-0.7672215700149536,
0.09931307286024094,
-0.9022099375724792,
-0.3817116320133209,
-0.165270134806633,
0.1674165576696396,
0.28207504749298096,
0.14605765044689178,
0.7478497624397278,
0.03322120010852814,
-0.40723252296447754,
-0.2924015522003174,
0.11787034571170807,
0.44820672273635864,
0.2664816677570343,
0.28398048877716064,
0.3983592689037323,
-0.714144229888916,
-1.0104206800460815,
0.022236119955778122,
-0.6600921750068665,
-0.4242245852947235,
-0.13287782669067383,
0.13768962025642395,
0.4263783097267151,
0.703946590423584,
-0.4259776771068573,
0.5080738067626953,
0.6421276926994324,
-1.1405049562454224,
0.4811509847640991,
-0.3345654308795929,
0.5992134809494019,
-0.1494179517030716,
0.0399329848587513,
-0.24183742702007294,
-0.10137429088354111,
-0.7368794679641724,
0.2110227793455124,
0.2865341603755951,
-0.3403221368789673,
-0.287627249956131,
0.2470632642507553,
-1.4545326232910156,
-0.11745290458202362,
-0.3394750952720642,
0.09436511993408203,
-0.10137971490621567,
0.24137276411056519,
0.2531106173992157,
0.5444639921188354,
0.6213338375091553,
-0.6527320146560669,
0.3072092831134796,
0.0999574214220047,
-0.3515762984752655,
0.7429190874099731,
-0.5879630446434021,
0.13905096054077148,
0.23074401915073395,
-0.04408416524529457,
-0.9679144620895386,
0.04454365372657776,
0.07201256603002548,
-0.2223757654428482,
0.3611980676651001,
0.26674768328666687,
-0.17965012788772583,
-0.45748209953308105,
-0.44055044651031494,
0.17624229192733765,
0.743049681186676,
-0.5033336281776428,
0.3522869646549225,
0.43591561913490295,
0.049875207245349884,
-0.4441717267036438,
-0.6272169947624207,
0.14369086921215057,
0.019527332857251167,
-0.556093692779541,
-0.18812306225299835,
0.1382027417421341,
-0.4848615229129791,
-0.24574647843837738,
-0.18162962794303894,
-0.01979587785899639,
0.4215478301048279,
0.3250686824321747,
0.25512510538101196,
0.17011001706123352,
0.1510441154241562,
-0.22441871464252472,
-0.011761383153498173,
0.13198311626911163,
0.007334502879530191,
0.31295883655548096,
0.09685663133859634,
-0.6703066229820251,
-0.8219282627105713,
0.42954736948013306,
0.4910977780818939,
0.10909214615821838,
0.31691041588783264,
-0.13625796139240265,
-0.11872401833534241,
0.19267158210277557,
-0.4782329797744751,
-0.38146039843559265,
-0.4529247283935547,
0.08803439140319824,
-0.6233441829681396,
-0.5095030665397644,
0.17128658294677734,
0.21102258563041687,
0.2562846541404724,
0.07290098071098328,
0.13330605626106262,
-0.021275321021676064,
0.640495240688324,
0.279572069644928,
0.45214158296585083,
0.7005721926689148,
-0.12586425244808197,
-0.07499680668115616,
-0.24027463793754578,
0.10491886734962463,
-0.5164254307746887,
-0.7505341172218323,
-0.20545311272144318,
-0.8600223660469055,
0.5470513105392456,
-0.11574478447437286,
0.29597973823547363,
0.754057765007019,
-0.5896481275558472,
0.397775262594223,
0.6582581996917725,
-0.18549834191799164,
0.8117004036903381,
-0.2043197751045227,
0.324491947889328,
-0.09665124863386154,
-0.4124665856361389,
-0.5785669088363647,
0.835896909236908,
0.1473097801208496,
0.566730260848999,
0.4141252636909485,
0.7545112371444702,
-0.08580321818590164,
0.17470738291740417,
-0.9079620838165283,
0.7286276817321777,
-0.43829938769340515,
-0.4000176191329956,
-0.4684915840625763,
-0.22540070116519928,
-1.165300726890564,
0.043064143508672714,
-0.4896046817302704,
-0.6710301041603088,
0.34540170431137085,
0.58332359790802,
-0.28125181794166565,
-0.244894340634346,
-0.9302192330360413,
0.6475473046302795,
-0.24810437858104706,
-0.0012199846096336842,
-0.6123058795928955,
-0.5625225901603699,
0.07710059732198715,
0.37881946563720703,
0.14085136353969574,
-0.03733265772461891,
-0.2535621225833893,
0.8272793292999268,
-0.6132782101631165,
0.8369667530059814,
-0.43166041374206543,
-0.17729341983795166,
0.2920628786087036,
-0.038233332335948944,
0.8798076510429382,
-0.44058871269226074,
-0.01421996857970953,
0.1683601588010788,
-0.16922052204608917,
-0.3757093846797943,
-0.653266966342926,
0.43833690881729126,
-0.3904942274093628,
-0.4565654397010803,
-0.3485614061355591,
-0.1751091331243515,
0.03162107989192009,
0.013668865896761417,
0.5665589570999146,
0.7243080735206604,
-0.42992693185806274,
0.0003878308634739369,
0.04181875288486481,
0.15903352200984955,
0.5236654281616211,
0.6261856555938721,
0.18441326916217804,
0.05525336042046547,
0.6042409539222717,
0.7121516466140747,
0.5165766477584839,
0.09569844603538513,
-0.019142914563417435,
-0.3921838104724884,
-0.4950111210346222,
-0.3128613233566284,
0.365215539932251,
-0.6169434785842896,
-0.20498807728290558,
-0.14178183674812317,
0.11174879968166351,
-0.4720747470855713,
-0.500094473361969,
-0.1427440047264099,
-0.8831616640090942,
0.2595857083797455,
0.005429539829492569,
0.4289310872554779,
0.8104808330535889,
-0.32415154576301575,
0.16787311434745789,
-0.5339469909667969,
0.2719915807247162,
0.6800774931907654,
0.2627359628677368,
0.023848483338952065,
-0.2605536878108978,
-0.21496371924877167,
-0.2310464084148407,
-0.2260565608739853,
-1.0122900009155273,
-0.10118339955806732,
0.3568366765975952,
0.2791600525379181,
0.5692063570022583,
0.2791140377521515,
0.39960286021232605,
-0.2093534618616104,
0.6530212163925171,
0.6166354417800903,
-1.0419509410858154,
0.0147794708609581,
-0.2488732635974884,
0.46772390604019165,
0.48908424377441406,
0.32920747995376587,
-0.7451316118240356,
-0.5373437404632568,
-0.9357736110687256,
-0.8606143593788147,
0.35138630867004395,
0.23020388185977936,
0.1893744170665741,
0.07722491770982742,
0.053232334554195404,
0.3334857225418091,
0.19091488420963287,
-0.6149410009384155,
-0.5549216270446777,
0.09375286102294922,
-0.12380288541316986,
-0.1555386632680893,
0.05953255668282509,
-0.1167633906006813,
-0.3010613024234772,
0.19913052022457123,
-0.00253350380808115,
0.10250943899154663,
0.06343279778957367,
-0.5078896284103394,
-0.12405932694673538,
0.27330440282821655,
0.4752247631549835,
0.3974144160747528,
0.3685099184513092,
0.6625133156776428,
0.24427534639835358,
-0.7164273858070374,
0.0947231873869896,
0.12015528976917267,
-0.14947301149368286,
0.021213583648204803,
0.619611382484436,
1.2501709461212158,
0.3616979122161865,
-0.3944879472255707,
0.4031183123588562,
0.21517831087112427,
-0.14913617074489594,
-0.28377383947372437,
0.2869315445423126,
-0.1158599779009819,
0.1692829430103302,
0.510586678981781,
-0.08025020360946655,
0.38672563433647156,
-0.8077601194381714,
-0.012028145603835583,
0.7917382121086121,
-0.11877322942018509,
-0.4194902181625366,
0.35659530758857727,
0.8151699304580688,
-0.5574327111244202,
0.24135258793830872,
-0.15811654925346375,
-0.4600817859172821,
0.2465246468782425,
0.30062299966812134,
0.591964602470398,
-0.1421699821949005,
0.22941014170646667,
0.1924433708190918,
0.013622617349028587,
0.0997215285897255,
0.6163905262947083,
-0.7387213706970215,
-0.648029625415802,
-0.3144984543323517,
-0.15667295455932617,
-0.6264175772666931,
-0.3522544205188751,
-0.5268241167068481,
0.4381183087825775,
-0.3995378017425537,
-0.17383220791816711,
0.14613564312458038,
0.15982522070407867,
-0.6766812801361084,
0.2631872892379761,
0.5422009825706482,
0.9223599433898926,
-1.244949460029602,
0.258405864238739,
0.9510401487350464,
-0.03173638507723808,
-1.266771674156189,
0.0036327133420854807,
0.34482577443122864,
-0.971848726272583,
0.6660699248313904,
0.06794902682304382,
-0.5563727021217346,
0.3113499879837036,
-0.21196214854717255,
-0.9072814583778381,
0.8788621425628662,
0.2449731081724167,
-0.12154439091682434,
0.30476704239845276,
-0.11534448713064194,
0.5689937472343445,
-0.12646830081939697,
0.05735833942890167,
0.5856589078903198,
0.6354733109474182,
-0.07744403183460236,
-1.0966626405715942,
0.5875426530838013,
-0.3030475676059723,
-0.25766822695732117,
0.6227375864982605,
-0.7232397794723511,
0.36727067828178406,
-0.30198824405670166,
-0.8109225034713745,
-0.31427961587905884,
0.6504161357879639,
0.01770941913127899,
0.24694836139678955,
0.899032711982727,
0.1999710202217102,
0.8660523891448975,
-0.16750897467136383,
1.0642608404159546,
-0.11517266184091568,
-0.14270609617233276,
0.3785698711872101,
0.1392863243818283,
0.8423820734024048,
0.7571596503257751,
-0.35138142108917236,
0.47869640588760376,
-0.06944388896226883,
0.42098522186279297,
-0.07083012163639069,
0.2687881886959076,
-0.058688193559646606,
-0.21495388448238373,
-0.04992055147886276,
0.04703284054994583,
0.9540933966636658,
-0.008919407613575459,
-0.1250174343585968,
-0.0358443520963192,
0.16102971136569977,
0.23135605454444885,
0.36139482259750366,
0.023703360930085182,
0.6040634512901306,
0.312023788690567,
-0.7296185493469238,
0.9269461035728455,
-0.7837353348731995,
0.7274098992347717,
-0.44740816950798035,
0.12542486190795898,
0.05515964701771736,
-0.4339223802089691,
-0.05632839724421501,
-0.8766570687294006,
0.49781039357185364,
-0.07408410310745239,
0.1532154232263565,
-0.749347984790802,
0.7603092789649963,
-0.3249153196811676,
0.07383543998003006,
0.2472473382949829,
0.4650940001010895,
0.8697700500488281,
0.15574203431606293,
-0.38901591300964355,
0.18749484419822693,
0.06883881241083145,
-0.4980645477771759,
-0.0886465385556221,
0.25007492303848267,
-0.10934089124202728,
0.248285174369812,
0.44497817754745483,
0.4441123604774475,
-0.004884880967438221,
0.08367235213518143,
0.21257080137729645,
-0.7103450298309326,
-0.5433131456375122,
-0.5645738244056702,
0.678945004940033,
-0.6380833983421326,
-0.6048809885978699,
0.6477298140525818,
0.25254514813423157,
0.26327258348464966,
-0.1596415787935257,
0.457205206155777,
-0.5286745429039001,
0.2332400679588318,
-0.6907897591590881,
0.8339651823043823,
-0.5470302104949951,
-0.183669775724411,
-0.34180065989494324,
-0.636192798614502,
-0.3287799060344696,
0.780820369720459,
-0.31758415699005127,
-0.10892823338508606,
0.8100218176841736,
0.3164372146129608,
0.06259416788816452,
-0.03836880251765251,
0.5054118633270264,
0.09022322297096252,
-0.2588024139404297,
0.7269371151924133,
0.6108813285827637,
-0.3443586826324463,
0.5270626544952393,
-0.36429694294929504,
-0.6764851212501526,
-0.35709941387176514,
-0.6634052991867065,
-0.47476279735565186,
-0.9890102744102478,
-0.6766273975372314,
0.000007854016075725667,
-0.17049400508403778,
0.8959225416183472,
0.6902443766593933,
-0.4433906078338623,
-0.7150294184684753,
-0.05676242709159851,
-0.14287951588630676,
-0.5640174150466919,
-0.18331819772720337,
0.5367894768714905,
-0.06838533282279968,
-1.0003101825714111,
0.4558230936527252,
0.3403186500072479,
0.5175774097442627,
0.2748089134693146,
-0.13833658397197723,
0.05601036921143532,
0.0054092383943498135,
0.5104064345359802,
0.7876685857772827,
-0.3480517864227295,
-0.603108823299408,
0.038070935755968094,
-0.5169309973716736,
-0.28334635496139526,
0.9034683704376221,
-0.532634973526001,
0.24987250566482544,
0.7790213823318481,
-0.16951529681682587,
0.13770635426044464,
0.1802259087562561,
0.9865180253982544,
-0.9884410500526428,
0.29619300365448,
-0.040012139827013016,
0.3218761682510376,
0.5231111645698547,
-0.3313635289669037,
0.526847779750824,
0.266541451215744,
-0.31217315793037415,
-0.4877074658870697,
0.4609406888484955,
-1.0613069534301758,
-0.11479809880256653,
1.2760400772094727,
0.10093766450881958,
0.04319632798433304,
-0.4157003164291382,
-0.32997119426727295,
0.2990564703941345,
-0.5051255822181702,
0.6029539704322815,
0.6729368567466736,
-0.8701039552688599,
-0.07955142855644226,
-0.1777566522359848,
0.9558044672012329,
0.7333716154098511,
-0.46712401509284973,
0.472940593957901,
0.7713689208030701,
-0.14655576646327972,
0.5092023015022278,
1.0177805423736572,
0.2746526300907135,
0.5450001955032349,
0.14033278822898865,
0.1531335860490799,
-0.08685522526502609,
0.0571620911359787,
-0.4320991337299347,
0.09414525330066681,
0.5703732967376709,
-0.26930153369903564
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.03993v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.03993v1
|
Assessing LLMs for Zero-shot Abstractive Summarization Through the Lens of Relevance Paraphrasing
| 2024-06-06T12:08:43 | 2024-06-06T12:08:43 |
Hadi Askari, Anshuman Chhabra, Muhao Chen, Prasant Mohapatra
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have achieved state-of-the-art performance at
zero-shot generation of abstractive summaries for given articles. However,
little is known about the robustness of such a process of zero-shot
summarization. To bridge this gap, we propose relevance paraphrasing, a simple
strategy that can be used to measure the robustness of LLMs as summarizers. The
relevance paraphrasing approach identifies the most relevant sentences that
contribute to generating an ideal summary, and then paraphrases these inputs to
obtain a minimally perturbed dataset. Then, by evaluating model performance for
summarization on both the original and perturbed datasets, we can assess the
LLM's one aspect of robustness. We conduct extensive experiments with relevance
paraphrasing on 4 diverse datasets, as well as 4 LLMs of different sizes
(GPT-3.5-Turbo, Llama-2-13B, Mistral-7B, and Dolly-v2-7B). Our results indicate
that LLMs are not consistent summarizers for the minimally perturbed articles,
necessitating further improvements.
|
[
-0.006829279009252787,
-0.8480020761489868,
0.8649035096168518,
-0.00956298690289259,
-0.585320770740509,
-0.08630776405334473,
-0.038308002054691315,
-0.01608593575656414,
0.26972419023513794,
0.45645374059677124,
-0.1769275963306427,
-0.7457963228225708,
-0.6068162322044373,
0.3773306608200073,
-0.800168514251709,
1.261130690574646,
0.1352558135986328,
-0.4246256351470947,
-0.4353809356689453,
-0.40447860956192017,
-0.25590330362319946,
-0.4685197174549103,
-0.058718953281641006,
-0.08745506405830383,
0.7791444659233093,
0.3808319866657257,
0.6420300006866455,
0.6525373458862305,
0.5596746802330017,
0.17473725974559784,
-0.5398809909820557,
-0.22572147846221924,
-0.713577389717102,
0.4543287456035614,
-0.14933009445667267,
-0.5227987766265869,
-0.5945833921432495,
-0.2634868323802948,
0.7302329540252686,
0.7577068209648132,
0.0013949121348559856,
0.4555067718029022,
0.3168507218360901,
0.24428023397922516,
-0.8399738669395447,
-0.1747012585401535,
-0.9338554739952087,
-0.1310448944568634,
-0.07269164174795151,
-0.5354930758476257,
-0.20518043637275696,
-0.44090476632118225,
0.14471857249736786,
-0.2103622555732727,
0.1375049352645874,
-0.14176905155181885,
0.7687480449676514,
0.176581010222435,
-0.2451048493385315,
-0.1305202692747116,
-0.5694985389709473,
0.9793345928192139,
-1.171111822128296,
-0.26661619544029236,
0.21263854205608368,
0.13263368606567383,
0.14136981964111328,
-0.7469850182533264,
-0.30975234508514404,
-0.34730082750320435,
0.14842616021633148,
0.13445986807346344,
-0.1003292053937912,
-0.15763115882873535,
0.23445004224777222,
0.5127949714660645,
-0.5038226842880249,
-0.18175184726715088,
-0.20461174845695496,
-0.15477414429187775,
0.298110693693161,
0.39546269178390503,
0.09807876497507095,
-0.11554692685604095,
-0.21132691204547882,
0.22905556857585907,
-0.8160049915313721,
-0.21847985684871674,
0.19705207645893097,
0.43478089570999146,
-0.02827605791389942,
0.7523141503334045,
-0.3241508901119232,
0.7111749053001404,
-0.054427921772003174,
-0.4932215213775635,
-0.01851663738489151,
-0.6635650992393494,
-0.0586809366941452,
0.008849681355059147,
0.6675222516059875,
0.637132465839386,
-0.02279116027057171,
-0.4369771182537079,
-0.21640220284461975,
-0.3762836456298828,
0.2829165756702423,
-0.8271922469139099,
0.22821922600269318,
0.2915196120738983,
-0.3488474190235138,
-0.5040131211280823,
0.009274767711758614,
-0.8161399364471436,
-0.08456318080425262,
0.039898574352264404,
0.6531137824058533,
-0.2515605092048645,
0.10105416178703308,
-0.16106215119361877,
-0.1263483613729477,
0.33059245347976685,
0.23038983345031738,
-0.8691619038581848,
-0.05089534819126129,
0.729856014251709,
1.3198117017745972,
-0.2616240978240967,
-0.30617278814315796,
-0.4387582540512085,
0.33106204867362976,
-0.3593532145023346,
0.9804108142852783,
-0.3613835573196411,
-0.36952224373817444,
-0.01853950135409832,
-0.3390295207500458,
0.011566626839339733,
-0.44092586636543274,
0.7355336546897888,
-0.4033654034137726,
-0.02006569504737854,
-0.26404324173927307,
-0.6928278207778931,
-0.09656453877687454,
0.5875595808029175,
-0.4240940809249878,
0.6287600994110107,
0.003977308515459299,
-0.8923479914665222,
0.25787419080734253,
-0.21163640916347504,
-0.5210493803024292,
-0.10736650973558426,
-0.2442883998155594,
-0.4683786630630493,
0.4859094023704529,
0.18833425641059875,
0.6032359004020691,
-0.10748527199029922,
0.2146134227514267,
-0.5266625285148621,
-0.5203342437744141,
0.20940783619880676,
-0.5653221011161804,
0.2988276779651642,
0.07606994360685349,
-0.05819764733314514,
0.0041546570137143135,
-0.7840914130210876,
-0.12214814871549606,
-0.020104942843317986,
-0.2839551568031311,
-0.3364996612071991,
-0.10522224009037018,
-0.20533868670463562,
0.07544006407260895,
0.34494882822036743,
-0.14803504943847656,
-0.1913900077342987,
-0.579156219959259,
0.3156702518463135,
0.4419483244419098,
0.4753957688808441,
0.35545891523361206,
-0.7473987936973572,
0.6828722953796387,
-0.22969673573970795,
-0.14577355980873108,
-0.7442008256912231,
-0.314736008644104,
-0.45650771260261536,
-0.10340320318937302,
0.361074835062027,
0.4534852206707001,
-0.5965117812156677,
0.3833877742290497,
-0.47203075885772705,
-0.492992639541626,
-0.16260318458080292,
0.12069426476955414,
0.3155052661895752,
0.8865824341773987,
0.4493114650249481,
-0.12482314556837082,
-0.20077663660049438,
-0.7480592727661133,
-0.5020137429237366,
-0.0030358924996107817,
-0.2747546434402466,
-0.05843213200569153,
0.5103886723518372,
0.19707036018371582,
0.8001610636711121,
-0.26904088258743286,
0.02391817234456539,
-0.5231009125709534,
0.24773778021335602,
0.457480788230896,
-0.014826513826847076,
0.7190157175064087,
-0.47645458579063416,
-0.49219679832458496,
-0.2231113612651825,
-1.1082895994186401,
-0.29329046607017517,
-0.17177940905094147,
0.2287399172782898,
-0.15320253372192383,
0.4498736560344696,
-0.5551811456680298,
0.4388006627559662,
0.1937638521194458,
-0.06543812900781631,
0.5380622744560242,
-0.12573359906673431,
0.10448814183473587,
-1.1190704107284546,
0.4293581545352936,
-0.19501522183418274,
-0.2752147614955902,
-0.5925089120864868,
0.1997896134853363,
-0.2730433940887451,
-0.060422688722610474,
-0.5619696974754333,
0.3760237395763397,
-0.4115399420261383,
-0.11282870173454285,
-0.6379963159561157,
0.4186081290245056,
-0.09527016431093216,
0.03157427906990051,
-0.30560922622680664,
0.7730115056037903,
0.603161633014679,
-0.8520880341529846,
0.07733657956123352,
0.09686611592769623,
-0.38692447543144226,
0.5219383835792542,
-0.8127760291099548,
-0.07916584610939026,
-0.2670803964138031,
-0.034094974398612976,
-1.0468251705169678,
-0.30850785970687866,
-0.08543261140584946,
-0.39272212982177734,
0.14093250036239624,
0.05791106075048447,
-0.3112737834453583,
0.13206854462623596,
-0.77190762758255,
0.4185064435005188,
0.48746630549430847,
-0.09725215286016464,
0.46220794320106506,
0.16385121643543243,
-0.6310846209526062,
-0.6014968156814575,
-0.560154914855957,
0.4787745177745819,
-0.6315433979034424,
-0.24329712986946106,
0.16428717970848083,
0.0007507192203775048,
-0.30470550060272217,
-0.19347819685935974,
-0.47779256105422974,
0.13407085835933685,
0.26618799567222595,
0.04624896124005318,
0.08751143515110016,
-0.29988157749176025,
-0.21315109729766846,
0.13967490196228027,
-0.05130169540643692,
-0.007134018000215292,
0.11070302128791809,
0.2724415957927704,
0.11398591846227646,
-0.27875956892967224,
-0.28123995661735535,
0.19792023301124573,
0.7197573781013489,
0.13882654905319214,
0.5408696532249451,
0.3145820200443268,
-0.09896694868803024,
0.1966506540775299,
-0.43867427110671997,
-0.1167702004313469,
-0.3538724482059479,
0.35663020610809326,
-0.15653298795223236,
-0.8100544214248657,
0.6962454319000244,
0.06341909617185593,
0.25911495089530945,
0.5382118225097656,
0.6039226651191711,
-0.09872522205114365,
0.6050472855567932,
0.58489590883255,
-0.1013156846165657,
0.3474923074245453,
0.011052820831537247,
0.01344374194741249,
-0.7328571677207947,
0.11834891885519028,
-0.4792701005935669,
-0.2053486704826355,
-0.1919114589691162,
-0.25779613852500916,
0.48236602544784546,
0.19986705482006073,
0.13341698050498962,
0.36821505427360535,
-0.04242704063653946,
0.6390212178230286,
0.3746013641357422,
-0.094258613884449,
0.5717803239822388,
0.2973434031009674,
-0.12405487149953842,
0.009632652625441551,
-0.6539499759674072,
-0.9769202470779419,
1.4119104146957397,
0.11366892606019974,
0.7749617695808411,
0.22269852459430695,
0.6154292821884155,
0.15958042442798615,
0.3357551395893097,
-0.6052331328392029,
0.6726813316345215,
0.007105542812496424,
-0.3289635479450226,
-0.29185765981674194,
-0.474323570728302,
-0.8810682892799377,
0.3294558823108673,
-0.10790702700614929,
-0.8114936351776123,
-0.08737922459840775,
0.10151183605194092,
-0.7855638861656189,
0.21889807283878326,
-0.007554787676781416,
0.583478569984436,
-0.055881284177303314,
-0.3342728912830353,
-0.039828650653362274,
-0.8402187824249268,
0.4035772383213043,
-0.20369881391525269,
0.09034554660320282,
-0.1958913654088974,
-0.36180809140205383,
0.5969298481941223,
-0.2991693317890167,
0.6778711676597595,
0.27908796072006226,
-0.11797832697629929,
0.25196996331214905,
0.07280757278203964,
0.1130155473947525,
0.15203708410263062,
-0.35751447081565857,
0.13694342970848083,
0.005946596153080463,
-0.5769601464271545,
-0.5643189549446106,
0.7761823534965515,
-0.20669937133789062,
-0.645053505897522,
-0.4102902412414551,
-0.5638520121574402,
-0.2535259425640106,
0.2982453405857086,
0.5037820935249329,
0.3528774678707123,
-0.28987064957618713,
0.5666558742523193,
0.5119010806083679,
-0.03993338719010353,
0.6430099606513977,
0.43069329857826233,
-0.14344774186611176,
-0.4661044180393219,
0.8095636963844299,
0.3045729696750641,
0.38577038049697876,
0.6128572225570679,
0.17035941779613495,
-0.18016846477985382,
-0.8790643215179443,
-0.3297226130962372,
0.23373101651668549,
-0.6518478393554688,
-0.34115010499954224,
-0.5834598541259766,
-0.11176738888025284,
-0.416935533285141,
-0.21364948153495789,
-0.00349121424369514,
-0.4755081832408905,
-0.3995906114578247,
-0.19485604763031006,
0.039545007050037384,
0.5468696355819702,
0.23301108181476593,
0.2450622171163559,
-0.8203529119491577,
0.3411495089530945,
0.20909155905246735,
-0.02162718027830124,
0.025762366130948067,
-1.1480578184127808,
-0.19729289412498474,
-0.08895032852888107,
-0.5667704343795776,
-0.9266136884689331,
0.3746427595615387,
0.4562408924102783,
0.6377424597740173,
0.5103455781936646,
0.22037304937839508,
0.5728796720504761,
-0.37091776728630066,
1.0450457334518433,
-0.0464886836707592,
-0.8588460683822632,
0.7469322085380554,
-0.5695788264274597,
0.5818827748298645,
0.772237241268158,
0.41723617911338806,
0.012680107727646828,
-0.8927239179611206,
-0.5522912740707397,
-1.1710331439971924,
0.2559899091720581,
0.3137565553188324,
0.5223593711853027,
-0.13834647834300995,
0.9088867902755737,
0.008125276304781437,
0.532490611076355,
-0.7803760766983032,
-0.23481544852256775,
0.034389033913612366,
-0.18958497047424316,
-0.019033798947930336,
-0.6150805354118347,
-0.10272587090730667,
0.06854312121868134,
0.49178776144981384,
-0.18446427583694458,
0.03191918879747391,
0.1759391725063324,
-0.23030053079128265,
0.018104512244462967,
0.3720880448818207,
0.9515804052352905,
1.1369118690490723,
-0.4466959238052368,
0.24440865218639374,
0.4051627814769745,
-0.3710867166519165,
0.09818032383918762,
-0.20021849870681763,
-0.5864527225494385,
0.3950667381286621,
0.8163942694664001,
0.5819878578186035,
0.532906174659729,
-0.8433732390403748,
0.6129633188247681,
0.048252250999212265,
-0.10400055348873138,
0.08057691901922226,
0.06300683319568634,
-0.14489731192588806,
0.030849773436784744,
0.4425514340400696,
-0.23690690100193024,
0.30736246705055237,
-0.670224130153656,
0.2590453624725342,
0.2906722128391266,
-0.2914981245994568,
-0.4672079086303711,
0.8130645751953125,
-0.10944682359695435,
0.009725828655064106,
0.16431373357772827,
-0.025372039526700974,
-0.11252165585756302,
0.4975629448890686,
0.5993095636367798,
0.9387271404266357,
-0.17112138867378235,
-0.07431092858314514,
0.4590729773044586,
0.3044258654117584,
-0.177558034658432,
0.04670710861682892,
-0.1039176881313324,
-0.2909074127674103,
-0.5682897567749023,
-0.6208308339118958,
-0.6180046200752258,
0.2569204866886139,
-0.8845987915992737,
0.26941969990730286,
-0.3136363923549652,
-0.273827463388443,
-0.12184242159128189,
-0.5057528018951416,
0.07272990792989731,
-0.0026897790376096964,
-0.20690171420574188,
0.7658271789550781,
-0.7777246832847595,
0.4807342290878296,
0.7438894510269165,
-0.5322085022926331,
-0.2566993236541748,
0.5210171937942505,
-0.09825145453214645,
-0.5805169343948364,
0.15145769715309143,
0.15670330822467804,
-0.02898133173584938,
-0.22675324976444244,
-0.4115118682384491,
-0.8036373853683472,
1.4916458129882812,
0.7243903875350952,
-0.3759613037109375,
-0.10869377851486206,
-0.0349494032561779,
0.6700177192687988,
-0.20353995263576508,
0.3170698583126068,
0.42557504773139954,
0.0839475765824318,
0.3817744255065918,
-0.8555585145950317,
-0.06440454721450806,
0.04494619742035866,
0.15026459097862244,
-0.08972412347793579,
-0.5159814357757568,
0.7865008115768433,
-0.34994885325431824,
-0.12244317680597305,
0.4245893955230713,
0.7522159218788147,
0.24425028264522552,
0.44194015860557556,
0.04429371654987335,
0.5970901250839233,
0.4582900106906891,
0.15121054649353027,
1.0493749380111694,
-0.4694211184978485,
0.5977168679237366,
1.3521246910095215,
-0.2917732894420624,
1.0726020336151123,
0.5349883437156677,
-0.1333383470773697,
0.11124112457036972,
0.26163795590400696,
0.13198135793209076,
0.6523481011390686,
0.0865473747253418,
-0.4010096788406372,
-0.21617145836353302,
-0.013816598802804947,
-0.37299296259880066,
0.2919379770755768,
0.2935653030872345,
-0.5890952348709106,
-0.7773314714431763,
-0.13158729672431946,
0.15844877064228058,
0.11269057542085648,
-0.39393696188926697,
0.9944377541542053,
0.3188219368457794,
-0.5170410871505737,
0.6233277320861816,
-0.06340321898460388,
0.5754890441894531,
-0.5009482502937317,
0.02487783320248127,
-0.5266668796539307,
-0.02155909314751625,
-0.1128784716129303,
-0.7019843459129333,
0.684294581413269,
0.3063742220401764,
-0.10776561498641968,
0.053102076053619385,
0.5908244252204895,
-0.3610607385635376,
-0.5090777277946472,
0.08468697965145111,
0.5606465935707092,
0.33062535524368286,
-0.14955534040927887,
-0.4599992036819458,
-0.05101215839385986,
-0.10003978759050369,
-0.2728655934333801,
0.7123239040374756,
0.4109853506088257,
0.2035655528306961,
0.6633530855178833,
0.32752111554145813,
0.2764522135257721,
-0.1390088051557541,
-0.04109222814440727,
0.6166518330574036,
-0.7331894636154175,
-0.2957095503807068,
-1.3354629278182983,
0.3602927625179291,
-0.07857982069253922,
-0.37232327461242676,
1.2154909372329712,
0.6020686626434326,
0.31580519676208496,
0.10441074520349503,
0.6406599283218384,
0.09012898057699203,
0.5657374262809753,
-0.447457879781723,
0.6507066488265991,
-0.5360707640647888,
0.5858679413795471,
-0.37104564905166626,
-1.1494731903076172,
-0.6631622314453125,
0.6566376090049744,
-0.3188462555408478,
0.05048545077443123,
0.4752342700958252,
0.7884551286697388,
-0.11515632271766663,
-0.26520806550979614,
0.7718304395675659,
0.36607304215431213,
-0.009409510530531406,
0.24537669122219086,
0.7241401076316833,
-0.5208799839019775,
0.8679124116897583,
-0.05127342790365219,
-0.1666802167892456,
-0.34027260541915894,
-1.268874168395996,
-0.9378487467765808,
-0.25757279992103577,
-0.45024582743644714,
-0.2854476273059845,
0.1970054656267166,
0.534797728061676,
0.3467330038547516,
-0.7897636294364929,
-0.14649635553359985,
-0.0003047868376597762,
0.2502821981906891,
-0.11781923472881317,
-0.20432905852794647,
0.2607559263706207,
-0.4682912230491638,
-0.504150927066803,
0.3977019786834717,
0.6975890398025513,
0.02071792632341385,
-0.17436730861663818,
0.32473742961883545,
-0.043323103338479996,
0.26589542627334595,
0.71993488073349,
0.2875978946685791,
-0.7927944660186768,
-0.24144920706748962,
-0.18871596455574036,
-0.05281951650977135,
0.0008201816817745566,
0.5776861906051636,
-0.443766713142395,
0.23304198682308197,
0.3874514698982239,
0.6921159625053406,
0.19621542096138,
0.28595906496047974,
0.4689064919948578,
-0.9047547578811646,
-0.2022787183523178,
0.3562665283679962,
0.3190467059612274,
0.2380293756723404,
0.012545555830001831,
0.3691847324371338,
0.09179558604955673,
-0.7864504456520081,
-1.0246115922927856,
-0.05466601625084877,
-0.9002089500427246,
-0.09245438873767853,
1.2136322259902954,
-0.4760603606700897,
-0.14805994927883148,
-0.19685587286949158,
0.004687189124524593,
-0.018772529438138008,
-0.14814865589141846,
0.9375647306442261,
0.7590872645378113,
-0.1270536184310913,
-0.14328394830226898,
-0.6438645124435425,
0.1023893803358078,
0.4493773579597473,
-0.6767519116401672,
0.01666756346821785,
0.2742260694503784,
0.5516427755355835,
0.27321258187294006,
0.6049513816833496,
-0.22413893043994904,
0.2778443396091461,
-0.09229659289121628,
-0.4205589294433594,
0.09098559617996216,
-0.14385832846164703,
-0.6574535965919495,
0.5409140586853027,
0.33741074800491333,
0.08598314225673676
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.03986v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.03986v1
|
On The Persona-based Summarization of Domain-Specific Documents
| 2024-06-06T12:00:41 | 2024-06-06T12:00:41 |
Ankan Mullick, Sombit Bose, Rounak Saha, Ayan Kumar Bhowmick, Pawan Goyal, Niloy Ganguly, Prasenjit Dey, Ravi Kokku
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IR
|
In an ever-expanding world of domain-specific knowledge, the increasing
complexity of consuming, and storing information necessitates the generation of
summaries from large information repositories. However, every persona of a
domain has different requirements of information and hence their summarization.
For example, in the healthcare domain, a persona-based (such as Doctor, Nurse,
Patient etc.) approach is imperative to deliver targeted medical information
efficiently. Persona-based summarization of domain-specific information by
humans is a high cognitive load task and is generally not preferred. The
summaries generated by two different humans have high variability and do not
scale in cost and subject matter expertise as domains and personas grow.
Further, AI-generated summaries using generic Large Language Models (LLMs) may
not necessarily offer satisfactory accuracy for different domains unless they
have been specifically trained on domain-specific data and can also be very
expensive to use in day-to-day operations. Our contribution in this paper is
two-fold: 1) We present an approach to efficiently fine-tune a domain-specific
small foundation LLM using a healthcare corpus and also show that we can
effectively evaluate the summarization quality using AI-based critiquing. 2) We
further show that AI-based critiquing has good concordance with Human-based
critiquing of the summaries. Hence, such AI-based pipelines to generate
domain-specific persona-based summaries can be easily scaled to other domains
such as legal, enterprise documents, education etc. in a very efficient and
cost-effective manner.
|
[
-0.14639803767204285,
-0.5918869972229004,
0.41602131724357605,
0.2562510669231415,
-0.08951299637556076,
-0.0576641783118248,
-0.18525423109531403,
-0.4744425117969513,
0.32904887199401855,
0.7820912003517151,
-0.38787761330604553,
-0.5930374264717102,
-0.5329465270042419,
0.09499908238649368,
-0.14748652279376984,
1.1812268495559692,
0.20838028192520142,
-0.030738985165953636,
-0.5225389003753662,
-0.2973795235157013,
-0.3922345042228699,
-0.737736701965332,
-0.6891623139381409,
-0.5595687627792358,
0.551470160484314,
0.43827947974205017,
0.5316881537437439,
0.6039574146270752,
0.7357984185218811,
0.24126102030277252,
0.13693398237228394,
0.3030289113521576,
-0.44371917843818665,
0.2322249710559845,
-0.3962906002998352,
-0.5158771872520447,
-0.9121173024177551,
-0.14044010639190674,
0.4986785352230072,
0.8691909909248352,
0.04469360411167145,
0.09922477602958679,
0.09589261561632156,
0.8071812987327576,
-0.39024609327316284,
0.19124652445316315,
-0.37853682041168213,
0.00915453489869833,
-0.12209232151508331,
-0.4462282061576843,
-0.33940234780311584,
-0.16051657497882843,
0.3790425658226013,
-0.5572971105575562,
0.37791791558265686,
0.0507441945374012,
0.7285079956054688,
0.4154677093029022,
-0.41408950090408325,
-0.18081799149513245,
-0.5437475442886353,
0.7326537370681763,
-0.7132089138031006,
-0.01118949893862009,
0.4661200940608978,
0.3053627908229828,
0.19128745794296265,
-0.8802323341369629,
-0.3313085436820984,
0.06918957829475403,
-0.452136367559433,
0.14259561896324158,
0.13367541134357452,
0.11199600249528885,
0.13928531110286713,
0.3802987337112427,
-0.6206664443016052,
0.025645101442933083,
-0.018132461234927177,
-0.2304224818944931,
0.8663827776908875,
0.4912879765033722,
0.3044266402721405,
-0.2743511199951172,
-0.09920693188905716,
0.07687872648239136,
-0.6527339220046997,
0.0019156477646902204,
0.04739653691649437,
0.23932793736457825,
-0.2241164594888687,
0.6390676498413086,
-0.45905113220214844,
0.4150606691837311,
0.44770681858062744,
-0.6731675267219543,
0.22828270494937897,
-0.3534366190433502,
-0.25150778889656067,
-0.26884281635284424,
0.6304804086685181,
0.629583477973938,
0.38016828894615173,
-0.1364620178937912,
-0.05381685495376587,
0.055838823318481445,
0.4025717079639435,
-0.7655256986618042,
-0.34429553151130676,
0.5598198175430298,
-0.558385968208313,
-0.18819846212863922,
-0.31248122453689575,
-0.8663777112960815,
-0.4302135705947876,
-0.5094946026802063,
0.024828702211380005,
-0.5018690228462219,
0.22343780100345612,
-0.054446566849946976,
0.10350500047206879,
0.13372103869915009,
0.6531943678855896,
-0.9837179183959961,
0.19899556040763855,
0.6519719362258911,
0.6847473382949829,
-0.37440574169158936,
-0.34836170077323914,
-0.46233856678009033,
0.4153180420398712,
0.11767350137233734,
1.047283411026001,
-0.3023534417152405,
-0.5480163097381592,
-0.0024781199172139168,
-0.32004329562187195,
-0.37877535820007324,
-0.7015833258628845,
0.3735191822052002,
-0.3030562996864319,
0.203877791762352,
-0.25625038146972656,
-0.6335547566413879,
0.17197313904762268,
0.3905019462108612,
-0.2946568429470062,
0.5423772931098938,
0.5499022006988525,
-0.8756040930747986,
0.35206446051597595,
-0.5425837635993958,
-0.8557075262069702,
0.34286901354789734,
-0.43840762972831726,
-0.4916892945766449,
-0.14790892601013184,
0.4763256907463074,
0.578498363494873,
-0.3607274293899536,
0.23823033273220062,
0.29336366057395935,
-0.16748785972595215,
0.07661187648773193,
0.1876530945301056,
0.6757930517196655,
0.10781168192625046,
-0.31310591101646423,
0.12711061537265778,
-0.514578640460968,
-0.017481070011854172,
-0.03604731336236,
-0.4089276194572449,
-0.249534472823143,
-0.05924639850854874,
0.06776317954063416,
0.11275527626276016,
0.45676562190055847,
-0.0012399364495649934,
0.18958714604377747,
-0.5126746296882629,
0.22739700973033905,
0.44547632336616516,
0.5245318412780762,
0.5125916600227356,
-0.8853349685668945,
0.7174465656280518,
0.1261797696352005,
0.008057364262640476,
-0.5337979793548584,
-0.5499038100242615,
-0.46272239089012146,
-0.7698972821235657,
0.49756309390068054,
0.7526665925979614,
-0.5708417892456055,
0.5030086040496826,
-0.47986656427383423,
-0.37131819128990173,
-0.5036755204200745,
-0.004129473119974136,
0.5463886857032776,
0.9228760600090027,
0.34345704317092896,
-0.5017831921577454,
-0.35930079221725464,
-1.0497610569000244,
-0.44273319840431213,
-0.2925913333892822,
-0.2834865152835846,
0.5792195796966553,
0.46681854128837585,
-0.39303332567214966,
0.9272159934043884,
-0.665298342704773,
-0.5188271403312683,
-0.5129548907279968,
0.1518748700618744,
-0.18123680353164673,
0.3597075641155243,
0.7552038431167603,
-0.8874044418334961,
-0.6673542857170105,
-0.0896744504570961,
-0.9375848770141602,
-0.2526252865791321,
-0.4592576324939728,
-0.06349636614322662,
0.15185926854610443,
0.09096039831638336,
-0.7793813943862915,
0.48896798491477966,
-0.10038992017507553,
-0.25633949041366577,
0.5871996283531189,
-0.386368066072464,
0.45161381363868713,
-1.052760124206543,
0.3746492266654968,
0.08463076502084732,
-0.47566911578178406,
-0.5485098361968994,
0.40874582529067993,
0.0003057380672544241,
-0.012953580357134342,
-0.15547144412994385,
0.5993354320526123,
-0.2822417914867401,
0.04997237026691437,
-0.20179890096187592,
0.38694173097610474,
0.24935540556907654,
0.7814903259277344,
0.03251490741968155,
0.5739807486534119,
0.37120321393013,
-0.7398681044578552,
0.13840699195861816,
0.6675232648849487,
-0.008827166631817818,
1.2516734600067139,
-0.6569143533706665,
-0.17400120198726654,
-0.11423611640930176,
0.3470905125141144,
-0.5687194466590881,
-0.5377311706542969,
0.22759296000003815,
-0.5148314833641052,
0.2852358818054199,
0.0190732441842556,
-0.48396384716033936,
0.00012853379303123802,
-0.36041468381881714,
0.19232362508773804,
0.4917925298213959,
-0.3113759160041809,
0.8201344013214111,
0.7624816298484802,
-0.5414926409721375,
-0.36464178562164307,
-0.728668749332428,
0.30689167976379395,
-0.24843822419643402,
-0.7658930420875549,
0.6000655293464661,
-0.24431757628917694,
-0.568464457988739,
-0.13562871515750885,
0.11648579686880112,
-0.07194799929857254,
-0.05075681209564209,
0.40077537298202515,
0.06463024020195007,
-0.12065301835536957,
-0.16318866610527039,
0.28371182084083557,
-0.16839198768138885,
-0.052967097610235214,
-0.16245432198047638,
0.2490607053041458,
0.049057625234127045,
-0.32157474756240845,
-0.5877652764320374,
0.8354811668395996,
0.6844741106033325,
-0.3305535316467285,
0.5197557210922241,
0.14476044476032257,
-0.4665305018424988,
-0.20770584046840668,
-0.48049837350845337,
-0.027889113873243332,
-0.3996383249759674,
0.26081985235214233,
-0.36162060499191284,
-0.7137342691421509,
0.7127777934074402,
-0.2674551010131836,
0.26065194606781006,
0.764170229434967,
0.9408105611801147,
-0.1820409595966339,
0.7315366268157959,
0.6159979104995728,
-0.3589341342449188,
0.03316726163029671,
-0.25925037264823914,
0.08910593390464783,
-0.7707556486129761,
-0.3333817720413208,
-0.62123042345047,
-0.28137123584747314,
-0.19638948142528534,
-0.20555561780929565,
0.5120420455932617,
-0.428557425737381,
0.02137593738734722,
0.3157879114151001,
-0.49991375207901,
0.21731150150299072,
0.5177689790725708,
0.08448752015829086,
0.5698425769805908,
-0.036788709461688995,
-0.07165956497192383,
-0.16845959424972534,
-0.555618405342102,
-0.5364260077476501,
1.0542535781860352,
0.07845418900251389,
0.4948415160179138,
0.12584459781646729,
0.5392094254493713,
0.7331932783126831,
0.32009151577949524,
-0.6627259850502014,
0.5827508568763733,
-0.1571032702922821,
-0.30173459649086,
-0.15854832530021667,
-0.39423462748527527,
-0.8992334008216858,
0.1963101476430893,
-0.1357141137123108,
-0.6312713027000427,
0.19334697723388672,
0.30608388781547546,
-0.4837430417537689,
0.030993670225143433,
-0.5150009989738464,
0.7312046885490417,
0.00017392153677064925,
-0.10628081858158112,
-0.4159644544124603,
-0.981444776058197,
0.17373773455619812,
-0.22284018993377686,
0.06315238028764725,
0.06947208940982819,
-0.20676042139530182,
0.48919153213500977,
-0.6124124526977539,
0.7257075905799866,
-0.0334460586309433,
-0.038959767669439316,
0.2374425083398819,
-0.06312568485736847,
0.2899683117866516,
0.2300090491771698,
-0.1075289398431778,
0.06266451627016068,
-0.082618847489357,
-0.4771984815597534,
-0.6304947733879089,
0.7132440209388733,
-0.7215548753738403,
-0.5652702450752258,
-0.3394929766654968,
-0.6455489993095398,
-0.5983721613883972,
0.06968577951192856,
0.48897784948349,
0.4955536127090454,
-0.26515740156173706,
-0.2428768128156662,
0.7471922039985657,
-0.2141917645931244,
-0.032043881714344025,
0.6059240698814392,
0.12670382857322693,
-0.41464346647262573,
0.8091294169425964,
0.08937018364667892,
-0.14692994952201843,
0.7801434397697449,
-0.04996729642152786,
-0.01455947570502758,
-0.5836681127548218,
-0.5509792566299438,
0.5329334735870361,
-0.5634505748748779,
-0.2894970178604126,
-0.9339207410812378,
-0.23350167274475098,
-0.6358816623687744,
-0.5365767478942871,
0.14799273014068604,
-0.589705228805542,
-0.41097450256347656,
0.2006966769695282,
0.08852025121450424,
0.4453887939453125,
0.3579160273075104,
0.4253757894039154,
-0.7711144685745239,
0.6676427721977234,
0.29182106256484985,
0.10251626372337341,
-0.009616882540285587,
-0.7240669131278992,
-0.43442294001579285,
-0.09316124767065048,
-0.2932034432888031,
-0.6818913817405701,
0.49259546399116516,
0.36741408705711365,
0.5649913549423218,
0.45198825001716614,
0.10835310071706772,
0.538814127445221,
-0.4730719327926636,
1.0113691091537476,
-0.05775123089551926,
-0.7278048396110535,
0.6701745986938477,
-0.630532443523407,
0.35576024651527405,
0.8065659999847412,
0.2506413757801056,
-0.5459070205688477,
-0.47629860043525696,
-0.783411979675293,
-1.07278573513031,
0.5136324763298035,
0.07292208075523376,
-0.06348909437656403,
0.0688420832157135,
0.7982896566390991,
0.17612747848033905,
0.33021849393844604,
-0.013651459477841854,
-0.39492642879486084,
-0.04444074258208275,
-0.49544063210487366,
-0.008615347556769848,
-0.13673387467861176,
-0.176685631275177,
-0.021174442023038864,
0.7968354821205139,
-0.21656152606010437,
0.23709379136562347,
0.34425318241119385,
-0.34044861793518066,
0.005057197064161301,
0.12883210182189941,
0.702954888343811,
0.7672023177146912,
-0.05057099089026451,
-0.12669658660888672,
-0.041273560374975204,
-0.5642246603965759,
-0.10130369663238525,
-0.10922276228666306,
-0.37612244486808777,
0.05164868384599686,
0.46385273337364197,
0.38359713554382324,
0.19601993262767792,
-1.05088210105896,
0.6656229496002197,
-0.1291389912366867,
-0.2984817922115326,
-0.2810814082622528,
0.2330191284418106,
0.055129051208496094,
0.1892426609992981,
0.3139553964138031,
0.20630495250225067,
0.1723034530878067,
-0.3881347179412842,
0.3446536958217621,
0.1528957486152649,
0.14075574278831482,
-0.2951093018054962,
0.8700647950172424,
0.359098345041275,
-0.3841967284679413,
0.4936807453632355,
0.15296459197998047,
-0.14732031524181366,
0.547553539276123,
0.26503902673721313,
0.7285373210906982,
-0.1364802122116089,
0.0714665874838829,
0.17550493776798248,
-0.10024339705705643,
-0.05112475901842117,
0.040240079164505005,
-0.07780580222606659,
-0.3931009769439697,
-0.43526366353034973,
-0.3121468126773834,
-0.8195730447769165,
-0.044864486902952194,
-0.6334851980209351,
0.01805437169969082,
-0.614173948764801,
-0.254000186920166,
0.17491286993026733,
0.18637391924858093,
-0.5400947332382202,
0.5134216547012329,
-0.33612915873527527,
0.8535803556442261,
-0.4081816077232361,
0.565390944480896,
0.7167443037033081,
-0.47699031233787537,
-0.5360348224639893,
0.2410023808479309,
0.021142061799764633,
-0.6468239426612854,
0.27068912982940674,
-0.277351438999176,
-0.010189150460064411,
-0.24371543526649475,
-0.19201771914958954,
-0.43290233612060547,
1.1669255495071411,
0.3663211166858673,
-0.4466334581375122,
-0.4160395860671997,
0.20439350605010986,
0.8978794813156128,
-0.6240113377571106,
-0.09663451462984085,
0.4727647006511688,
0.3616318106651306,
-0.13075779378414154,
-0.8190000057220459,
-0.07467207312583923,
-0.44684892892837524,
-0.2198188155889511,
-0.048972222954034805,
-0.8483986258506775,
0.6884862184524536,
-0.2542392611503601,
0.09016057848930359,
0.14691027998924255,
0.6799731254577637,
0.02204996347427368,
0.5123012065887451,
0.19520990550518036,
0.4650581181049347,
0.9300171136856079,
0.23344525694847107,
1.294572114944458,
-0.6696012020111084,
0.07123268395662308,
1.3532650470733643,
-0.5240238904953003,
0.5831587910652161,
0.17067597806453705,
-0.12458430975675583,
0.35043323040008545,
0.47253015637397766,
0.03880435228347778,
0.35410141944885254,
-0.12130418419837952,
-0.34322917461395264,
-0.13710999488830566,
-0.10606437176465988,
-0.25432735681533813,
0.326970636844635,
0.43580886721611023,
-0.535761296749115,
-0.05065491423010826,
-0.12677216529846191,
-0.00019530754070729017,
0.3901596963405609,
-0.36034607887268066,
0.9435227513313293,
0.21150082349777222,
-1.0199034214019775,
0.24753029644489288,
0.42662644386291504,
0.5315889120101929,
-0.6517108082771301,
0.2676093876361847,
-0.39166975021362305,
0.1298668384552002,
-0.33147042989730835,
-0.36351820826530457,
0.48599758744239807,
0.27761605381965637,
-0.43049097061157227,
-0.3081958293914795,
0.7878542542457581,
-0.2659277021884918,
-0.23174773156642914,
-0.07440508157014847,
0.8140479922294617,
0.23437242209911346,
-0.13372187316417694,
-0.6282121539115906,
-0.5385890007019043,
-0.014797376468777657,
-0.25370877981185913,
0.7352579236030579,
0.397905558347702,
-0.20265229046344757,
0.7084183692932129,
0.3320997953414917,
0.2817036211490631,
-0.5551736354827881,
0.21878036856651306,
0.7764197587966919,
-0.5208731889724731,
-0.7998154759407043,
-0.6746582388877869,
0.493423730134964,
-0.05998039245605469,
-0.3095724880695343,
0.6292827129364014,
0.7202649712562561,
0.45596975088119507,
-0.10016268491744995,
1.047592043876648,
0.045109909027814865,
0.819421648979187,
-0.17309756577014923,
0.9631070494651794,
-0.4600767493247986,
0.29775428771972656,
-0.2641596794128418,
-0.47513240575790405,
-0.4510554075241089,
0.6051331162452698,
-0.14852231740951538,
0.10133178532123566,
0.6258386373519897,
0.5321424603462219,
0.23960371315479279,
-0.026327844709157944,
0.3050282597541809,
0.03968828171491623,
0.13642893731594086,
0.4843643307685852,
0.07907262444496155,
-0.1720222532749176,
0.2167835384607315,
-0.05635068565607071,
-0.25839874148368835,
-0.4896910488605499,
-0.6163285374641418,
-0.9975907206535339,
-0.6780165433883667,
-0.6760943531990051,
-0.22358646988868713,
0.0726039782166481,
0.7985950112342834,
0.727355420589447,
-0.7698312997817993,
0.0682506114244461,
0.4267773926258087,
0.07996797561645508,
-0.39171087741851807,
-0.24951720237731934,
0.5934808850288391,
-0.05004964768886566,
-0.6220654845237732,
0.1468234658241272,
0.5365949273109436,
-0.07226480543613434,
-0.24255207180976868,
0.06885441392660141,
0.03435151278972626,
0.4445844888687134,
0.617777943611145,
0.32108616828918457,
-0.4267089366912842,
-0.18244242668151855,
-0.11018458753824234,
-0.45996037125587463,
0.3698437213897705,
1.1264541149139404,
-0.9001562595367432,
-0.07168759405612946,
0.2925046682357788,
0.7052246928215027,
0.36958709359169006,
0.3310226798057556,
0.5510127544403076,
-0.8221217393875122,
-0.20989520847797394,
0.39298173785209656,
0.46088850498199463,
0.49354615807533264,
-0.8856437802314758,
0.49309733510017395,
0.2589576542377472,
-0.6647807359695435,
-0.4688161015510559,
0.2722110152244568,
-1.3033727407455444,
-0.12714815139770508,
0.8598964214324951,
-0.41125744581222534,
-0.07698608934879303,
-0.3394240438938141,
-0.36030760407447815,
0.15808144211769104,
-0.38117119669914246,
0.9036990404129028,
0.2158827781677246,
-0.4985353350639343,
0.11358663439750671,
-0.10742069780826569,
0.49335452914237976,
0.2848275601863861,
-1.1613214015960693,
0.18790271878242493,
0.5340125560760498,
0.42437756061553955,
0.06772089004516602,
1.1178381443023682,
-0.15871037542819977,
0.3528972864151001,
-0.103592649102211,
-0.18320883810520172,
0.03159673884510994,
-0.3240026533603668,
-0.12163896858692169,
0.6335945725440979,
-0.12287147343158722,
0.31407999992370605
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.03963v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.03963v1
|
A + B: A General Generator-Reader Framework for Optimizing LLMs to Unleash Synergy Potential
| 2024-06-06T11:14:27 | 2024-06-06T11:14:27 |
Wei Tang, Yixin Cao, Jiahao Ying, Bo Wang, Yuyue Zhao, Yong Liao, Pengyuan Zhou
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG) is an effective solution to supplement
necessary knowledge to large language models (LLMs). Targeting its bottleneck
of retriever performance, "generate-then-read" pipeline is proposed to replace
the retrieval stage with generation from the LLM itself. Although promising,
this research direction is underexplored and still cannot work in the scenario
when source knowledge is given. In this paper, we formalize a general "A + B"
framework with varying combinations of foundation models and types for
systematic investigation. We explore the efficacy of the base and chat versions
of LLMs and found their different functionalities suitable for generator A and
reader B, respectively. Their combinations consistently outperform single
models, especially in complex scenarios. Furthermore, we extend the application
of the "A + B" framework to scenarios involving source documents through
continuous learning, enabling the direct integration of external knowledge into
LLMs. This approach not only facilitates effective acquisition of new knowledge
but also addresses the challenges of safety and helpfulness post-adaptation.
The paper underscores the versatility of the "A + B" framework, demonstrating
its potential to enhance the practical application of LLMs across various
domains.
|
[
-0.3137155771255493,
-0.6621318459510803,
0.38773179054260254,
0.12083204090595245,
-0.3665023744106293,
0.49343711137771606,
-0.2529260516166687,
-0.7224941253662109,
0.19702838361263275,
0.4873442053794861,
-0.5181475877761841,
-0.17962956428527832,
-0.514313817024231,
-0.01775950938463211,
-0.7542911171913147,
0.7017216682434082,
0.049890078604221344,
0.06294577568769455,
-0.07020238786935806,
-0.04856424406170845,
-0.5400431156158447,
-0.5096818804740906,
-0.7611657381057739,
-0.5285066366195679,
0.6501462459564209,
0.251354455947876,
0.7442213892936707,
0.5648568868637085,
0.6016826033592224,
0.23940883576869965,
-0.15845683217048645,
0.40888768434524536,
-0.471451997756958,
0.6390634179115295,
-0.43525785207748413,
-0.5320667624473572,
-0.38060036301612854,
-0.2716534733772278,
0.8726934790611267,
0.5533356070518494,
-0.12068404257297516,
0.2569257616996765,
0.04069293662905693,
0.5895211696624756,
-0.8196258544921875,
-0.18648512661457062,
-0.778121829032898,
-0.30598950386047363,
-0.10151075571775436,
-0.3029547929763794,
-0.6549506783485413,
-0.31647637486457825,
0.10564091056585312,
-0.395323783159256,
0.2400413304567337,
0.3673192858695984,
0.8395243883132935,
0.023781588301062584,
-0.5392935872077942,
-0.6604791879653931,
-0.7955327033996582,
0.7458018064498901,
-0.3616043031215668,
0.5912739634513855,
-0.16124211251735687,
0.4574728310108185,
-0.25874063372612,
-0.8000490665435791,
-0.774200975894928,
-0.07488697022199631,
-0.30955004692077637,
0.17219161987304688,
-0.09279780089855194,
0.05175343155860901,
0.051719482988119125,
0.5220374464988708,
-0.38581448793411255,
0.06995714455842972,
-0.22270449995994568,
-0.08370114862918854,
0.5201172828674316,
0.09353029727935791,
0.23128536343574524,
-0.2803278863430023,
-0.3623351752758026,
-0.03856832534074783,
-0.9879027605056763,
-0.13543015718460083,
0.33858633041381836,
0.1747824251651764,
0.040928468108177185,
0.6587624549865723,
0.20642268657684326,
0.8694908022880554,
0.0723019391298294,
-0.0013949970016255975,
0.1360059678554535,
-0.4484795331954956,
-0.04028670862317085,
-0.3518575131893158,
0.37299519777297974,
0.09693370759487152,
0.1313544660806656,
-0.4631914794445038,
-0.12639392912387848,
-0.0476032979786396,
0.290530264377594,
-0.8039669990539551,
0.04496731609106064,
0.2034868448972702,
-0.4899459481239319,
-0.2816151976585388,
-0.13092462718486786,
-0.6830720901489258,
-0.5020033121109009,
-0.5851737856864929,
0.38515976071357727,
-0.33674657344818115,
-0.7387338876724243,
0.004027060233056545,
-0.42409300804138184,
0.6018251180648804,
0.3160731792449951,
-0.7513795495033264,
0.20930089056491852,
0.6619388461112976,
0.747700572013855,
-0.31332916021347046,
-0.07011714577674866,
-0.6375770568847656,
0.3729926645755768,
-0.19625166058540344,
0.9298649430274963,
-0.30405423045158386,
-0.7213153839111328,
0.20487281680107117,
-0.2846817076206207,
-0.10891325026750565,
-0.3395223021507263,
0.2722961902618408,
-0.6681716442108154,
0.3373093008995056,
-0.22495897114276886,
-0.5482277274131775,
-0.26458004117012024,
0.3133520483970642,
-0.5383020639419556,
0.7840361595153809,
0.2825060784816742,
-0.6983982920646667,
0.3096793591976166,
-0.3405432403087616,
-0.3877623379230499,
0.13075973093509674,
-0.24606472253799438,
-0.1620171070098877,
0.25021496415138245,
-0.17602041363716125,
0.14995282888412476,
-0.540654718875885,
0.28931665420532227,
-0.22289089858531952,
-0.2844505310058594,
0.262820839881897,
-0.3427814543247223,
0.8553462028503418,
0.16984668374061584,
-0.07247550785541534,
0.08118098229169846,
-0.8689059615135193,
0.07736308127641678,
-0.07166927307844162,
-0.5915507674217224,
-0.19354690611362457,
0.21531197428703308,
0.014963041059672832,
0.14887714385986328,
0.2662944793701172,
-0.5326661467552185,
0.3232349455356598,
-0.459951251745224,
-0.13176491856575012,
0.5107222199440002,
0.2394353747367859,
0.7583457231521606,
-0.5171747207641602,
0.6444851756095886,
-0.14874394237995148,
-0.2571471035480499,
-0.3824681043624878,
-0.07807289063930511,
-1.0188993215560913,
-0.34413307905197144,
0.47300687432289124,
0.7129165530204773,
-0.8806335926055908,
0.3053203821182251,
-0.08750533312559128,
-0.34307798743247986,
-0.7394188046455383,
0.400231271982193,
0.6525838375091553,
0.512067437171936,
0.347540020942688,
-0.3063494563102722,
-0.8111169338226318,
-0.5282466411590576,
-0.2652060091495514,
-0.3660164773464203,
-0.013742123730480671,
0.32961615920066833,
0.048337336629629135,
-0.32136285305023193,
0.9435402750968933,
-0.2748805284500122,
-0.1427498459815979,
-0.7620168328285217,
-0.1137002557516098,
0.3596530258655548,
0.33816730976104736,
0.4944097101688385,
-0.8883426785469055,
-0.3676294982433319,
0.04636086896061897,
-0.8613175749778748,
-0.16399887204170227,
-0.03717489540576935,
-0.5386428236961365,
0.2551712989807129,
0.4798693060874939,
-0.6107146143913269,
0.11398518830537796,
0.7386037707328796,
-0.3533473312854767,
0.7424057126045227,
-0.1272483915090561,
-0.20530962944030762,
-1.365628719329834,
0.2743455469608307,
-0.1766682267189026,
-0.1067575067281723,
-0.6769707798957825,
0.4960141181945801,
0.23593609035015106,
-0.07270500063896179,
-0.456218957901001,
1.0227428674697876,
-0.7461509108543396,
-0.16211654245853424,
-0.39048847556114197,
0.08879503607749939,
0.1575775146484375,
0.19745029509067535,
0.07361974567174911,
0.7276948690414429,
0.4673387408256531,
-0.6256720423698425,
0.3076140880584717,
0.356801301240921,
-0.11933577060699463,
0.4877016544342041,
-0.3604781925678253,
0.12157832831144333,
-0.30771470069885254,
0.3835483491420746,
-0.7342696189880371,
-0.2474721223115921,
0.021061521023511887,
-0.5120298862457275,
0.8462302088737488,
0.024954577907919884,
-0.6371380686759949,
-0.21653105318546295,
-0.11321743577718735,
0.12466294318437576,
0.5766211748123169,
-0.7514759302139282,
1.0400644540786743,
0.29144543409347534,
-0.1777677834033966,
-0.635964035987854,
-0.5600714087486267,
-0.026112226769328117,
-0.08301910012960434,
-0.836026132106781,
0.2779427468776703,
-0.04424455761909485,
-0.3820571005344391,
0.23577122390270233,
-0.14515072107315063,
0.1643396019935608,
0.01829182542860508,
0.012637774460017681,
0.20752575993537903,
-0.21545761823654175,
0.07185500115156174,
0.021772263571619987,
-0.1292712390422821,
-0.1812308132648468,
-0.20796909928321838,
0.45191940665245056,
0.19581598043441772,
-0.21778824925422668,
0.09798017144203186,
0.5896629095077515,
0.1602068394422531,
-0.31037792563438416,
0.8250111937522888,
0.41149577498435974,
-0.11570193618535995,
-0.43853330612182617,
-0.7773450016975403,
0.05459119379520416,
-0.524625837802887,
0.1819993555545807,
-0.4061892330646515,
-0.921388566493988,
0.6126394867897034,
-0.27898213267326355,
0.32914039492607117,
0.272531121969223,
0.7250084280967712,
-0.21424931287765503,
0.7305833101272583,
0.8031721711158752,
-0.07121213525533676,
0.742148220539093,
-0.4200962483882904,
0.19617655873298645,
-0.9649792313575745,
-0.24800574779510498,
-0.5609368085861206,
-0.19918590784072876,
-0.5280804634094238,
-0.3320637047290802,
0.2170880287885666,
0.48058199882507324,
-0.022583508864045143,
0.32110700011253357,
-0.16843004524707794,
0.3786405622959137,
0.4147990643978119,
-0.023933976888656616,
0.5843005776405334,
-0.1545882374048233,
-0.2715912163257599,
0.23617888987064362,
-0.6411092877388,
-0.2944898009300232,
1.175835132598877,
0.20880405604839325,
0.6073041558265686,
0.4058948755264282,
0.9408114552497864,
0.04035263508558273,
0.7017362713813782,
-0.8930366039276123,
0.5489857196807861,
-0.2415808141231537,
-0.969081461429596,
-0.06823091953992844,
-0.3908504545688629,
-1.0746780633926392,
0.664236843585968,
-0.1974438726902008,
-0.5944613218307495,
0.4138248562812805,
0.34094247221946716,
0.1315213143825531,
0.1200074851512909,
-0.9598323106765747,
0.5280280709266663,
-0.22018548846244812,
-0.35720962285995483,
-0.35968467593193054,
-0.4642735421657562,
0.5661745667457581,
-0.18736521899700165,
0.4347846210002899,
0.23533198237419128,
-0.07583317160606384,
-0.08184009045362473,
-0.08897218853235245,
0.3294728100299835,
-0.15996421873569489,
-0.062410879880189896,
0.5945163369178772,
0.21009431779384613,
0.584097683429718,
-0.05779995024204254,
-0.4846683442592621,
-0.2863472104072571,
-0.4239315390586853,
-0.2888452708721161,
-0.6994056701660156,
0.4326549768447876,
-0.5242138504981995,
-0.7548288106918335,
-0.3165105879306793,
-0.7372853755950928,
-0.3320491909980774,
0.3036450147628784,
0.18374750018119812,
0.4955082833766937,
-0.11932610720396042,
0.48010215163230896,
0.4820958077907562,
-0.128972128033638,
0.3953843116760254,
0.8515000343322754,
-0.3913307785987854,
-0.275786817073822,
0.9294885396957397,
-0.12141832709312439,
0.4812219440937042,
0.4517055153846741,
-0.09754019975662231,
-0.5075045824050903,
-0.7374269366264343,
-0.5043408274650574,
0.2874816656112671,
-0.6426292657852173,
-0.4107275605201721,
-0.5174717903137207,
-0.542521059513092,
-0.10245262086391449,
-0.2702406346797943,
0.0710575059056282,
-0.31422606110572815,
-0.24911785125732422,
-0.10489784926176071,
0.20030063390731812,
0.429813414812088,
-0.12210220843553543,
0.41533011198043823,
-0.7804282307624817,
0.48481589555740356,
0.15735125541687012,
0.2708207666873932,
0.0891559049487114,
-0.384203165769577,
-0.26357096433639526,
-0.11195782572031021,
-0.6267672181129456,
-0.9663692712783813,
0.4144507348537445,
0.26465970277786255,
0.7472127079963684,
-0.0324648879468441,
-0.22167643904685974,
0.45389077067375183,
-0.4679873585700989,
0.4507867097854614,
0.21458527445793152,
-0.7557904720306396,
0.2998944818973541,
-0.5578840374946594,
0.20645320415496826,
0.5743445754051208,
0.18882565200328827,
-0.25759825110435486,
-0.6935052275657654,
-0.5796025991439819,
-0.9995039105415344,
0.372699111700058,
0.17029744386672974,
0.12767358124256134,
0.07394817471504211,
0.34866079688072205,
-0.045678939670324326,
0.3220232129096985,
-0.6279628276824951,
-0.12334812432527542,
0.15704740583896637,
-0.17914246022701263,
-0.14262355864048004,
-0.2454005926847458,
0.22448290884494781,
0.06600882112979889,
0.6752286553382874,
0.06519909203052521,
0.04621734097599983,
-0.020407654345035553,
-0.5517355799674988,
-0.30745846033096313,
0.29523521661758423,
-0.11654791235923767,
0.7738742232322693,
-0.36985570192337036,
-0.03840180113911629,
-0.019235411658883095,
-0.38061100244522095,
0.2527739405632019,
0.16243696212768555,
-0.42356353998184204,
0.1498177945613861,
0.355183869600296,
0.6096172332763672,
0.34069862961769104,
-0.5329667329788208,
0.1310829371213913,
0.05251697078347206,
-0.12256724387407303,
-0.058370187878608704,
0.4238130748271942,
0.2213471531867981,
0.49702247977256775,
0.6461741924285889,
-0.13913944363594055,
0.20897062122821808,
-0.7058344483375549,
0.34426289796829224,
0.4597746729850769,
0.31096625328063965,
-0.11318345367908478,
0.27909255027770996,
0.5275565981864929,
-0.3879965841770172,
0.2154977172613144,
-0.5684078335762024,
-0.3564188480377197,
0.4126044809818268,
0.7078771591186523,
0.7885392308235168,
-0.19134850800037384,
0.014901859685778618,
0.29671525955200195,
0.0770912915468216,
-0.15633109211921692,
0.387009859085083,
-0.0403033010661602,
-0.8806502223014832,
-0.6954388618469238,
-0.9974654316902161,
-0.7251701354980469,
-0.004389233887195587,
-0.7157161831855774,
0.36784443259239197,
-0.23379726707935333,
-0.005422309041023254,
-0.06065068766474724,
0.3753247559070587,
-0.7334011793136597,
0.1002478078007698,
-0.2004586011171341,
0.9577166438102722,
-0.4712647795677185,
0.7668154835700989,
0.6684535145759583,
-0.4900226593017578,
-0.7994109392166138,
0.1393289417028427,
-0.02199304662644863,
-0.7786756753921509,
0.4120737910270691,
-0.10527510941028595,
-0.01515157986432314,
0.4202658534049988,
-0.11537200212478638,
-1.0078682899475098,
1.1810365915298462,
0.41345998644828796,
-0.6708104014396667,
-0.3375392258167267,
-0.44842201471328735,
0.7147772312164307,
-0.3385639488697052,
0.06056535243988037,
0.5901986956596375,
0.29631829261779785,
0.5033474564552307,
-0.7273125052452087,
-0.00616299407556653,
-0.16546933352947235,
-0.0047322968021035194,
0.4353609085083008,
-0.5750630497932434,
0.4873180389404297,
-0.10588634014129639,
-0.34328538179397583,
0.2674907445907593,
0.667572021484375,
0.6967968940734863,
0.13521632552146912,
0.3724333345890045,
0.447761595249176,
0.46955689787864685,
0.11475270986557007,
1.2049306631088257,
-0.3319685459136963,
0.09422146528959274,
1.1431034803390503,
-0.1038634404540062,
0.9628051519393921,
0.4300406575202942,
-0.03878767415881157,
0.6731160283088684,
0.22372619807720184,
0.07595783472061157,
0.4697093069553375,
0.3049365282058716,
-0.5004388093948364,
-0.11208918690681458,
-0.2013888657093048,
-0.5320668816566467,
0.20655371248722076,
0.6910462379455566,
-0.2504296898841858,
-0.428866446018219,
-0.3179241120815277,
-0.12241565436124802,
0.051785796880722046,
-0.37837934494018555,
0.8511761426925659,
0.3989790380001068,
-0.8845442533493042,
0.40253499150276184,
0.033868905156850815,
0.6105639338493347,
-0.5863491892814636,
0.11478238552808762,
-0.31918594241142273,
0.3570094108581543,
-0.15912050008773804,
-0.7516078948974609,
0.5041082501411438,
0.31847262382507324,
-0.30966320633888245,
-0.3930668234825134,
1.0540481805801392,
-0.5003839731216431,
-0.6131452918052673,
0.5402409434318542,
0.7884462475776672,
-0.0963381677865982,
0.36732107400894165,
-0.4428516626358032,
0.1428622007369995,
-0.13642528653144836,
-0.32060694694519043,
0.5423792600631714,
0.5087595582008362,
0.13968394696712494,
0.6137928366661072,
0.8243327140808105,
0.46701619029045105,
0.0733928233385086,
0.16784997284412384,
0.9622046947479248,
-0.48935332894325256,
-0.3693736791610718,
-0.5396436452865601,
0.8347975611686707,
0.052468251436948776,
-0.034322310239076614,
0.7620202302932739,
0.4595670700073242,
0.6560386419296265,
0.27563709020614624,
0.9329975843429565,
-0.0698537826538086,
0.7816519737243652,
-0.5230515599250793,
0.5437737703323364,
-0.5427665710449219,
0.2426590621471405,
-0.15596362948417664,
-1.1911425590515137,
-0.227500319480896,
0.4415607452392578,
-0.0012831087224185467,
-0.11318693310022354,
0.6859819293022156,
0.5750287771224976,
0.01687018945813179,
-0.26421502232551575,
0.12310726195573807,
0.07868893444538116,
0.43359068036079407,
0.4700787365436554,
0.7553093433380127,
-0.2553180456161499,
0.7299178242683411,
0.2470506876707077,
-0.20625248551368713,
-0.12596122920513153,
-0.9931145906448364,
-0.8762311935424805,
-0.2641969323158264,
0.0713382363319397,
-0.6128981113433838,
0.33935776352882385,
0.4980827271938324,
0.40689724683761597,
-0.5676013827323914,
-0.38483116030693054,
-0.3485974371433258,
0.27919474244117737,
0.25684285163879395,
-0.1691148728132248,
0.1516132950782776,
-0.7180455923080444,
-0.5139412879943848,
0.4145457148551941,
0.09334592521190643,
0.036031998693943024,
-0.4549846947193146,
-0.21814747154712677,
-0.18485459685325623,
0.06635937094688416,
0.5342571139335632,
0.41981011629104614,
-0.38932982087135315,
-0.08378350734710693,
0.12556715309619904,
0.03768271580338478,
-0.38533928990364075,
0.8582167625427246,
-0.7294517159461975,
0.6705880165100098,
0.6488795876502991,
0.8887054920196533,
0.7684066891670227,
0.1845332384109497,
0.9480417966842651,
-0.933277428150177,
0.3920971155166626,
0.32519835233688354,
0.31802502274513245,
0.27907314896583557,
-0.24476496875286102,
0.44784700870513916,
0.11512083560228348,
-0.39288589358329773,
-1.0205237865447998,
0.5929042100906372,
-0.7992668151855469,
-0.1571199595928192,
1.4589651823043823,
-0.1428251713514328,
0.119904525578022,
-0.06601032614707947,
-0.22556030750274658,
0.42595094442367554,
-0.29568520188331604,
0.6037675738334656,
0.8022440075874329,
0.07072397321462631,
-0.16633076965808868,
-0.4109628200531006,
0.3915638029575348,
0.29880255460739136,
-0.7954830527305603,
-0.17945732176303864,
0.6463114619255066,
0.14975543320178986,
0.1333608627319336,
0.7329316735267639,
0.05058591440320015,
0.33519816398620605,
-0.09226629883050919,
-0.11198949813842773,
-0.09459291398525238,
-0.47414740920066833,
-0.2846468985080719,
0.10860433429479599,
0.26034969091415405,
0.045889340341091156
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.03953v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.03953v1
|
Tox-BART: Leveraging Toxicity Attributes for Explanation Generation of Implicit Hate Speech
| 2024-06-06T10:54:44 | 2024-06-06T10:54:44 |
Neemesh Yadav, Sarah Masud, Vikram Goyal, Vikram Goyal, Md Shad Akhtar, Tanmoy Chakraborty
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Employing language models to generate explanations for an incoming implicit
hate post is an active area of research. The explanation is intended to make
explicit the underlying stereotype and aid content moderators. The training
often combines top-k relevant knowledge graph (KG) tuples to provide world
knowledge and improve performance on standard metrics. Interestingly, our study
presents conflicting evidence for the role of the quality of KG tuples in
generating implicit explanations. Consequently, simpler models incorporating
external toxicity signals outperform KG-infused models. Compared to the
KG-based setup, we observe a comparable performance for SBIC (LatentHatred)
datasets with a performance variation of +0.44 (+0.49), +1.83 (-1.56), and
-4.59 (+0.77) in BLEU, ROUGE-L, and BERTScore. Further human evaluation and
error analysis reveal that our proposed setup produces more precise
explanations than zero-shot GPT-3.5, highlighting the intricate nature of the
task.
|
[
-0.34929773211479187,
-0.7908657789230347,
0.77801913022995,
0.2681925296783447,
-0.04834076017141342,
-0.0813865140080452,
-0.08900507539510727,
-0.46036574244499207,
-0.38528716564178467,
0.3416185677051544,
-0.5308451056480408,
-0.6050487756729126,
-0.8733645081520081,
0.07155562192201614,
-0.25890296697616577,
1.4838422536849976,
0.22229446470737457,
0.0929412841796875,
-0.059644665569067,
-0.15130729973316193,
-0.4737253487110138,
-0.38016027212142944,
-0.9288309216499329,
-0.2687274217605591,
1.1310962438583374,
0.4623294472694397,
0.8021976351737976,
0.40446898341178894,
-0.04690777137875557,
0.23811787366867065,
-0.18535536527633667,
-0.10708903521299362,
-0.9508688449859619,
0.3284744620323181,
-0.38645175099372864,
-0.3038758635520935,
-0.47988805174827576,
0.0628720298409462,
0.30688807368278503,
0.6744281053543091,
0.23341350257396698,
-0.0001666240132180974,
-0.13510189950466156,
0.5092806816101074,
-0.6607017517089844,
-0.005615169648081064,
-0.5001487135887146,
0.043078359216451645,
-0.03600894659757614,
-0.06288697570562363,
-0.678677499294281,
-0.5788530111312866,
0.11069408804178238,
-0.8691585063934326,
0.10686592757701874,
0.1509799063205719,
0.7059114575386047,
0.4151831269264221,
-0.6376983523368835,
-0.4527880549430847,
-0.8990553617477417,
0.6667641401290894,
-0.6717934608459473,
0.32578620314598083,
0.344102680683136,
0.2988665997982025,
0.014135234989225864,
-0.48350828886032104,
-0.42967116832733154,
-0.26854702830314636,
-0.40528708696365356,
0.2868572175502777,
-0.3896304965019226,
0.2554107904434204,
0.5218707919120789,
0.18130362033843994,
-0.49229660630226135,
0.24983419477939606,
-0.3383035361766815,
-0.28404852747917175,
0.7656849026679993,
0.19001366198062897,
0.12111441791057587,
-0.10765904933214188,
-0.24098360538482666,
0.007296884432435036,
-0.6673495769500732,
0.08149069547653198,
0.4983845353126526,
0.37554430961608887,
-0.2209138423204422,
0.5797523856163025,
-0.14160412549972534,
0.3290783166885376,
0.09128972887992859,
-0.02909839153289795,
0.04926646873354912,
-0.10635478049516678,
-0.00802203081548214,
0.2111663818359375,
0.8555573225021362,
0.35959532856941223,
0.4107751250267029,
-0.36697691679000854,
0.09861783683300018,
0.3040751814842224,
0.497505247592926,
-1.085351586341858,
-0.3344363868236542,
0.15372270345687866,
-0.287837415933609,
-0.7364700436592102,
-0.5050306916236877,
-0.8953715562820435,
-0.4861779510974884,
-0.08557863533496857,
0.6137385964393616,
-0.38102030754089355,
-0.4436432123184204,
-0.39024022221565247,
-0.5164056420326233,
-0.23207615315914154,
0.19105586409568787,
-0.5894165635108948,
0.3513592481613159,
0.27655676007270813,
0.6522164940834045,
-0.117575503885746,
0.20179669559001923,
-0.455872118473053,
0.3737417757511139,
-0.48413729667663574,
0.8421018123626709,
-0.6455235481262207,
-0.4471571147441864,
-0.26503679156303406,
-0.2210138738155365,
0.26256778836250305,
-0.30528128147125244,
0.5590032339096069,
-0.437835693359375,
0.6394307613372803,
-0.6479206681251526,
-0.35888156294822693,
-0.47824931144714355,
0.12064576148986816,
-0.35450461506843567,
1.2745174169540405,
0.23667219281196594,
-0.8125672936439514,
0.49340584874153137,
-0.9107683897018433,
-0.32450875639915466,
-0.10061214119195938,
0.082902692258358,
-0.6087543964385986,
0.15502382814884186,
0.21355044841766357,
0.3318149745464325,
-0.22325019538402557,
0.20222295820713043,
-0.6778116822242737,
-0.2859315872192383,
0.08576871454715729,
-0.38108929991722107,
0.9039918780326843,
0.29242098331451416,
-0.43312039971351624,
0.23972685635089874,
-0.7180272340774536,
-0.21063929796218872,
0.2677122950553894,
-0.05890519171953201,
-0.7093239426612854,
0.04111902788281441,
-0.22568316757678986,
0.32310402393341064,
-0.30021893978118896,
-0.552167534828186,
-0.3659783601760864,
-0.1874900907278061,
0.12693235278129578,
1.0121771097183228,
0.09070974588394165,
0.28802552819252014,
-0.34967806935310364,
0.5216707587242126,
0.00800414476543665,
0.23807211220264435,
0.289503812789917,
-0.4837034344673157,
-0.3197743594646454,
-0.3262583911418915,
-0.01389412023127079,
0.17389632761478424,
-0.5073695778846741,
-0.26430433988571167,
-0.315944105386734,
-0.5305062532424927,
-0.1270695924758911,
-0.28572171926498413,
0.749946653842926,
1.0927770137786865,
0.4135797619819641,
-0.19854386150836945,
-0.355845183134079,
-0.9385091662406921,
-0.05134829133749008,
-0.3705672323703766,
0.10168793052434921,
0.7850026488304138,
0.4568489193916321,
0.11546751856803894,
0.995841383934021,
-0.3936086595058441,
0.1463886797428131,
-0.047996506094932556,
0.3632449805736542,
-0.14160802960395813,
0.09753213077783585,
0.9087555408477783,
-0.4865064322948456,
-0.6809166669845581,
-0.1300131231546402,
-0.6534184217453003,
-0.6725919246673584,
0.2952200770378113,
-0.4444636106491089,
0.14345009624958038,
0.4004533886909485,
0.059451259672641754,
0.24499228596687317,
0.5981630086898804,
-0.4991735517978668,
0.9375723600387573,
0.24180486798286438,
0.26245006918907166,
-0.8199859857559204,
0.2651660144329071,
0.05491003021597862,
-0.18806418776512146,
-0.8923876285552979,
-0.24397525191307068,
-0.3659473955631256,
-0.04753785580396652,
-0.5215677618980408,
0.6087485551834106,
-0.07980877161026001,
-0.04405425861477852,
-0.11454616487026215,
0.20605255663394928,
-0.07161171734333038,
0.6803249716758728,
0.08990440517663956,
0.6620391607284546,
0.33559495210647583,
-0.8241893649101257,
0.25223806500434875,
0.23969191312789917,
0.11629974097013474,
0.7052222490310669,
-0.6224601864814758,
0.026447635143995285,
-0.24125660955905914,
0.3104550242424011,
-1.3531972169876099,
-0.23817019164562225,
0.5838271379470825,
-0.5279853940010071,
0.17813216149806976,
-0.6589924097061157,
-0.29674434661865234,
-0.30260011553764343,
-0.19577571749687195,
0.7526468634605408,
0.6671947836875916,
-0.47939547896385193,
0.4788089990615845,
0.26413798332214355,
-0.41702085733413696,
-0.8156399130821228,
-0.47146326303482056,
-0.2636769115924835,
-0.5223886370658875,
-0.5599427223205566,
0.1251620650291443,
-0.1490899920463562,
-0.3907311260700226,
0.054048601537942886,
-0.1521276831626892,
-0.0021532634273171425,
0.11282052844762802,
0.47812777757644653,
0.057715047150850296,
-0.25360405445098877,
0.2662283778190613,
0.3630484342575073,
-0.13886235654354095,
0.5429015755653381,
0.15458518266677856,
0.2970448434352875,
0.19641146063804626,
0.04585101827979088,
-0.1903904378414154,
0.36740240454673767,
0.5277553200721741,
0.24809974431991577,
0.8174801468849182,
0.45644015073776245,
0.022315436974167824,
-0.2843157649040222,
-0.3083485960960388,
-0.21778762340545654,
-0.45571422576904297,
0.33086711168289185,
-0.21693257987499237,
-0.7864338159561157,
0.6463412046432495,
-0.12669268250465393,
0.025447849184274673,
0.466827392578125,
0.6531218886375427,
-0.20597565174102783,
1.3877055644989014,
0.4032454788684845,
0.1555352360010147,
0.5181708335876465,
0.08474710583686829,
0.07055313885211945,
-0.5800049304962158,
-0.282230943441391,
-0.6371287107467651,
-0.10013528168201447,
-0.539853036403656,
-0.12708057463169098,
0.6566389203071594,
-0.2574770450592041,
-0.7900879979133606,
-0.22588936984539032,
-0.5333268642425537,
0.34830722212791443,
0.3114469647407532,
0.035347167402505875,
0.24805055558681488,
0.2722975015640259,
-0.199140265583992,
-0.08925825357437134,
-0.9101542830467224,
-0.13858795166015625,
1.2609299421310425,
0.4912932217121124,
0.573591947555542,
0.11143405735492706,
0.15034151077270508,
0.3805328607559204,
0.7680632472038269,
-0.5845204591751099,
0.4764816462993622,
-0.201125830411911,
-1.017027735710144,
-0.2347719371318817,
-0.618462085723877,
-0.7028038501739502,
0.2345932126045227,
-0.25727060437202454,
-0.5951505899429321,
-0.18670889735221863,
0.41934895515441895,
-0.2647971212863922,
0.15877482295036316,
-0.7862805724143982,
0.8698056936264038,
-0.2906869053840637,
-0.4940054416656494,
-0.33809545636177063,
-0.6441758275032043,
0.6146948337554932,
0.09332429617643356,
0.6031671762466431,
-0.19506008923053741,
0.23858067393302917,
0.7826984524726868,
-0.5100677609443665,
0.8230795860290527,
-0.4931749105453491,
-0.4160730838775635,
0.05869545787572861,
0.12135729193687439,
0.3340968191623688,
-0.12851686775684357,
-0.30421677231788635,
0.3437296748161316,
-0.4073791801929474,
-0.33519551157951355,
-0.5911102294921875,
0.3967381715774536,
-0.874070405960083,
-0.4881246089935303,
-0.14997892081737518,
-0.7093620896339417,
-0.3138805329799652,
0.012671668082475662,
0.37064820528030396,
0.3890282213687897,
-0.11340299248695374,
-0.18841610848903656,
0.7789679765701294,
-0.6707249283790588,
-0.0778350979089737,
0.5493493676185608,
-0.3263934850692749,
-0.3069838583469391,
1.0111445188522339,
-0.11415711790323257,
0.6011005640029907,
0.060375310480594635,
0.51235431432724,
-0.3862001597881317,
-0.5985335111618042,
-0.4797753393650055,
0.4485268294811249,
-0.610662579536438,
-0.06650176644325256,
-0.6060363054275513,
-0.18019501864910126,
-0.45000746846199036,
-0.16410648822784424,
-0.4219900965690613,
-0.4287049174308777,
0.23146767914295197,
-0.16006003320217133,
0.6162908673286438,
1.0039904117584229,
-0.41232818365097046,
0.576429545879364,
-0.24742230772972107,
0.3378179371356964,
0.32950559258461,
0.5618612766265869,
0.13673195242881775,
-0.7683731317520142,
-0.1972324699163437,
0.2666267156600952,
-0.20953911542892456,
-1.34110689163208,
0.15074659883975983,
-0.06929173320531845,
0.4666576385498047,
0.4682689905166626,
0.1796356439590454,
0.7432264685630798,
-0.19299161434173584,
0.7402786612510681,
0.013285679742693901,
-0.7617967128753662,
0.7951691746711731,
-0.611376941204071,
-0.26741018891334534,
0.2035192996263504,
0.8113957643508911,
-0.6839333772659302,
-0.9431054592132568,
-0.5629394054412842,
-0.7803128361701965,
1.1868958473205566,
0.4046253263950348,
-0.1324676126241684,
0.004777830559760332,
0.3474804759025574,
0.4012869596481323,
0.025993164628744125,
-1.127703070640564,
-0.6224673986434937,
-0.31173667311668396,
-0.10834795236587524,
0.12426614761352539,
-0.6297855973243713,
-0.46463266015052795,
-0.18696588277816772,
1.081190586090088,
0.13910260796546936,
0.3935772180557251,
-0.1234818622469902,
-0.13466687500476837,
-0.3300713300704956,
0.1698497235774994,
0.6036527752876282,
0.38514336943626404,
-0.19608861207962036,
0.13099877536296844,
0.2569442391395569,
-0.30003827810287476,
-0.009077814407646656,
0.032718904316425323,
-0.05921490117907524,
-0.07117808610200882,
0.30031800270080566,
0.9075035452842712,
0.02281051129102707,
-0.4615955352783203,
0.47335338592529297,
-0.1462624967098236,
-0.3901630938053131,
-0.12925831973552704,
0.1178649440407753,
-0.18483349680900574,
0.1401873081922531,
0.019196802750229836,
-0.22420759499073029,
0.09016566723585129,
-0.44013094902038574,
-0.11741600930690765,
0.496917724609375,
-0.3755778968334198,
-0.28878524899482727,
0.7953644394874573,
0.23142200708389282,
0.19478839635849,
0.6866817474365234,
-0.21700894832611084,
-0.5877388715744019,
0.29194214940071106,
0.4465166926383972,
0.34644272923469543,
-0.23316127061843872,
0.4703306257724762,
0.63292396068573,
0.05204218998551369,
0.5150290727615356,
-0.06828414648771286,
-0.20921629667282104,
-0.7157378792762756,
-0.4933408796787262,
-0.5417351722717285,
-0.2703600525856018,
0.3596646189689636,
-0.4779391586780548,
0.025686733424663544,
-0.29321858286857605,
0.07994449883699417,
0.1494084745645523,
-0.2904329299926758,
-0.3217325806617737,
0.2738495469093323,
0.35448071360588074,
0.47341519594192505,
-1.3953462839126587,
0.2734205424785614,
0.5024402737617493,
-0.7064136266708374,
-0.9493308067321777,
-0.23082855343818665,
0.006958737503737211,
-0.9784596562385559,
0.8947383761405945,
-0.18086935579776764,
-0.15079757571220398,
-0.1058388501405716,
-0.6861088275909424,
-0.7557180523872375,
0.7687450051307678,
0.40199312567710876,
-0.17923977971076965,
-0.22726508975028992,
0.4030457139015198,
0.7342134118080139,
-0.006821084767580032,
0.7155643701553345,
0.39703014492988586,
0.6080340147018433,
0.2796888053417206,
-0.788754940032959,
0.31813913583755493,
-0.1081712394952774,
0.0021567107178270817,
-0.02264496311545372,
-0.40447548031806946,
0.5021684765815735,
-0.22369466722011566,
-0.23912537097930908,
-0.34788933396339417,
0.3458895981311798,
0.24809007346630096,
0.45832765102386475,
0.6428731083869934,
0.6922248601913452,
0.5576871633529663,
-0.03874174878001213,
1.1180381774902344,
0.01310479361563921,
0.07053322345018387,
1.0606029033660889,
0.20369550585746765,
0.20974025130271912,
0.07318767160177231,
-0.14009617269039154,
0.8932068347930908,
0.6320544481277466,
0.16127698123455048,
0.5947734117507935,
0.037612468004226685,
-0.240146204829216,
-0.23566438257694244,
-0.27794817090034485,
-0.45098263025283813,
0.21280959248542786,
0.6307544708251953,
-0.5103554725646973,
-0.45264044404029846,
0.08114921301603317,
0.3741820156574249,
-0.13869640231132507,
-0.4693622291088104,
0.9618468284606934,
-0.14245392382144928,
-0.711926281452179,
0.5414789915084839,
-0.248689666390419,
0.4339841604232788,
-0.5734632015228271,
0.11928408592939377,
-0.23661433160305023,
-0.052169546484947205,
-0.308545857667923,
-0.849204421043396,
0.4694383144378662,
0.310667484998703,
-0.18619133532047272,
-0.4048299789428711,
0.6340331435203552,
-0.35086962580680847,
-0.1449059247970581,
0.4013051986694336,
0.3372768759727478,
0.4380442500114441,
-0.15348462760448456,
-0.7929538488388062,
0.03683481365442276,
-0.04355235770344734,
-0.18677206337451935,
0.1829034686088562,
0.7304742336273193,
-0.2450193464756012,
0.5456221103668213,
0.5465664863586426,
0.08133012056350708,
0.12381726503372192,
0.23024839162826538,
0.8699752688407898,
-0.2765328884124756,
-0.3979748785495758,
-0.7746627926826477,
0.7336249351501465,
-0.0844670906662941,
-0.15475787222385406,
0.5461411476135254,
0.5233942270278931,
0.7469673752784729,
0.11770457029342651,
0.9386311173439026,
-0.18786536157131195,
0.6911851167678833,
-0.24737553298473358,
0.8947626352310181,
-0.7036165595054626,
0.06123477593064308,
-0.5000479221343994,
-0.7490603923797607,
-0.004076438024640083,
0.4945913255214691,
-0.526365339756012,
0.2655465602874756,
0.7806892991065979,
0.9768156409263611,
0.015929142013192177,
-0.06245669350028038,
0.29305699467658997,
0.9611963629722595,
0.4957295358181,
0.4622049629688263,
0.86873859167099,
-0.1703321486711502,
0.9463265538215637,
-0.3322787582874298,
-0.22142384946346283,
-0.12084390968084335,
-0.888709545135498,
-0.9165380597114563,
-0.5851025581359863,
-0.3738355040550232,
-0.6453366875648499,
0.34306150674819946,
0.3424094021320343,
0.7295213341712952,
-0.6221622228622437,
0.06125371530652046,
-0.13333772122859955,
0.378722220659256,
-0.0698457881808281,
-0.26250800490379333,
0.0763527899980545,
-0.39628541469573975,
-0.5705854296684265,
0.08055359870195389,
-0.014725751243531704,
-0.18780408799648285,
0.1810893714427948,
-0.2552497088909149,
0.22257694602012634,
0.13853569328784943,
0.8920361995697021,
0.2118207961320877,
-0.6804293394088745,
-0.582832932472229,
-0.38016757369041443,
0.0007792150136083364,
0.001664498238824308,
0.6924397945404053,
-0.8509067296981812,
0.37145525217056274,
0.24852050840854645,
0.18394045531749725,
0.5879391431808472,
0.06323873996734619,
0.7406296730041504,
-0.929207444190979,
-0.09652558714151382,
0.20451082289218903,
-0.026932524517178535,
0.17810410261154175,
-0.33852672576904297,
0.5284544825553894,
0.3570571541786194,
-0.5584355592727661,
-0.9434653520584106,
0.3591998517513275,
-1.1573691368103027,
-0.3667050302028656,
1.504334568977356,
-0.002767023630440235,
-0.026883643120527267,
-0.3812788128852844,
-0.27500519156455994,
0.6255800724029541,
-0.7066067457199097,
1.0025818347930908,
0.7059372663497925,
-0.3587811291217804,
-0.12112630158662796,
-0.39787405729293823,
0.826323926448822,
0.37039947509765625,
-0.8427836894989014,
0.24763809144496918,
0.8460362553596497,
0.6518731713294983,
-0.054994672536849976,
0.6072839498519897,
-0.2579600214958191,
0.4577433466911316,
0.1493578553199768,
0.00866598542779684,
-0.28598180413246155,
-0.23203504085540771,
0.01764347031712532,
0.22764454782009125,
-0.04558304697275162,
0.2312709242105484
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.03949v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.03949v1
|
UltraMedical: Building Specialized Generalists in Biomedicine
| 2024-06-06T10:50:26 | 2024-06-06T10:50:26 |
Kaiyan Zhang, Sihang Zeng, Ermo Hua, Ning Ding, Zhang-Ren Chen, Zhiyuan Ma, Haoxin Li, Ganqu Cui, Biqing Qi, Xuekai Zhu, Xingtai Lv, Hu Jinfang, Zhiyuan Liu, Bowen Zhou
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated remarkable capabilities across
various domains and are moving towards more specialized areas. Recent advanced
proprietary models such as GPT-4 and Gemini have achieved significant
advancements in biomedicine, which have also raised privacy and security
challenges. The construction of specialized generalists hinges largely on
high-quality datasets, enhanced by techniques like supervised fine-tuning and
reinforcement learning from human or AI feedback, and direct preference
optimization. However, these leading technologies (e.g., preference learning)
are still significantly limited in the open source community due to the
scarcity of specialized data. In this paper, we present the UltraMedical
collections, which consist of high-quality manual and synthetic datasets in the
biomedicine domain, featuring preference annotations across multiple advanced
LLMs. By utilizing these datasets, we fine-tune a suite of specialized medical
models based on Llama-3 series, demonstrating breathtaking capabilities across
various medical benchmarks. Moreover, we develop powerful reward models skilled
in biomedical and general reward benchmark, enhancing further online preference
learning within the biomedical LLM community.
|
[
-0.025223251432180405,
-0.37896043062210083,
0.75937420129776,
-0.48053857684135437,
-0.1298755556344986,
0.36139822006225586,
-0.14998890459537506,
-0.5310918092727661,
0.49662458896636963,
0.7360193729400635,
-0.27608588337898254,
-0.6659712195396423,
-0.5832458734512329,
0.10627046972513199,
0.11323725432157516,
1.3429226875305176,
-0.10263635218143463,
0.21208536624908447,
0.06621869653463364,
-0.30977246165275574,
0.1555539071559906,
-0.8565249443054199,
-0.19401147961616516,
-0.48949313163757324,
0.6236692070960999,
0.22501380741596222,
0.8665062785148621,
0.9068089127540588,
0.44400328397750854,
0.19801874458789825,
0.0423416905105114,
0.41945701837539673,
-0.3990969955921173,
-0.008527636528015137,
-0.27174171805381775,
-0.5067540407180786,
-0.5784057378768921,
0.06606614589691162,
0.21323196589946747,
0.709875226020813,
-0.3478444218635559,
0.10697168111801147,
-0.2541671693325043,
0.7159537672996521,
-0.29975420236587524,
0.005964457988739014,
-0.539627194404602,
0.23733410239219666,
-0.1188838854432106,
-0.30343401432037354,
-0.009290402755141258,
-0.5563672184944153,
0.14590910077095032,
-0.7734386324882507,
0.26301246881484985,
-0.20562075078487396,
0.7537067532539368,
0.35472896695137024,
-0.22118204832077026,
-0.038656238466501236,
-0.5972344875335693,
0.5952017307281494,
-0.5586178302764893,
0.25466635823249817,
0.5084676146507263,
0.16488909721374512,
0.06550529599189758,
-0.8259623646736145,
0.21435029804706573,
-0.43290454149246216,
0.20039509236812592,
0.10045991092920303,
-0.11899903416633606,
0.30324071645736694,
-0.14160990715026855,
0.45097029209136963,
-0.40187036991119385,
0.5650118589401245,
-0.3861083984375,
-0.013868995010852814,
0.5107996463775635,
0.3779798448085785,
0.16552215814590454,
-0.03899000212550163,
-0.04286723956465721,
0.11955755949020386,
-0.9641447067260742,
-0.08767478913068771,
0.26922550797462463,
0.03034185990691185,
-0.18962760269641876,
0.6009805798530579,
-0.3153947591781616,
0.5993430018424988,
0.012416054494678974,
-0.14425517618656158,
0.38128983974456787,
-0.21260657906532288,
-0.29988351464271545,
-0.16326871514320374,
0.6859464049339294,
0.3145509958267212,
0.2953478693962097,
-0.2110527604818344,
-0.07839716225862503,
0.04360700771212578,
0.31411483883857727,
-0.5325047969818115,
-0.5168974995613098,
0.4773804843425751,
-0.8065835237503052,
-0.581413745880127,
-0.31831231713294983,
-0.3429582715034485,
-0.5958845019340515,
-0.48906391859054565,
0.023292388767004013,
-0.24538053572177887,
0.025322744622826576,
0.43993043899536133,
0.2194882482290268,
-0.3095434010028839,
0.2152319699525833,
-1.264944314956665,
0.07563527673482895,
0.4774392545223236,
0.6768653392791748,
-0.13293451070785522,
0.07048530876636505,
-0.02080332674086094,
0.4969708323478699,
-0.18751272559165955,
0.9615421295166016,
-0.762451708316803,
-0.6289101839065552,
0.0133988531306386,
-0.09503986686468124,
0.2688431739807129,
-0.817081093788147,
0.49254587292671204,
-0.30167219042778015,
-0.23799574375152588,
-0.07290211319923401,
-0.4796184003353119,
-0.08794519305229187,
0.1451641470193863,
-0.46342289447784424,
0.44784173369407654,
0.28066590428352356,
-0.3985249996185303,
0.3338790833950043,
-0.8203710913658142,
-0.2257567197084427,
0.49461743235588074,
-0.5916863679885864,
-0.21537744998931885,
0.4299399256706238,
0.33225885033607483,
0.6923887729644775,
-0.37702879309654236,
0.5601635575294495,
-0.3890894651412964,
-0.22558115422725677,
0.282991498708725,
-0.12593422830104828,
0.42662057280540466,
0.2221784144639969,
-0.21794694662094116,
0.32535219192504883,
-0.7778502106666565,
-0.15286380052566528,
0.0922083631157875,
-0.4992716312408447,
-0.35010722279548645,
0.13620807230472565,
-0.018641097471117973,
-0.04428737983107567,
0.3027017116546631,
-0.5649554133415222,
0.5807498097419739,
-0.5519009828567505,
0.6637783646583557,
1.0563958883285522,
0.01952662318944931,
0.07535377889871597,
-0.24336041510105133,
0.48286163806915283,
-0.1390674114227295,
0.5585764050483704,
0.3528911769390106,
-0.5282676219940186,
-0.4295193552970886,
-0.6005773544311523,
0.3401382565498352,
0.5280656218528748,
-0.48348304629325867,
0.2680419087409973,
-0.2304190695285797,
-0.4058665931224823,
-0.8830339908599854,
0.17131049931049347,
0.237528458237648,
0.3433893024921417,
0.5783679485321045,
-0.058995917439460754,
-0.4522000849246979,
-1.2269927263259888,
0.026890810579061508,
-0.10819697380065918,
-0.37547802925109863,
0.7639095783233643,
0.2927230894565582,
-0.8136082291603088,
0.6204578280448914,
-0.6372037529945374,
-0.33023059368133545,
-0.20268578827381134,
-0.06630349159240723,
0.5117443799972534,
0.23594729602336884,
0.369587779045105,
-0.5803313851356506,
-0.151480570435524,
0.2884537875652313,
-0.8503158092498779,
-0.044673141092061996,
0.2643561065196991,
0.16554272174835205,
0.017818911001086235,
0.11845729500055313,
-0.317884624004364,
0.016360945999622345,
0.5488585233688354,
-0.022774677723646164,
0.43362855911254883,
-0.446775883436203,
0.09885897487401962,
-1.1204922199249268,
0.2331446409225464,
0.04747244715690613,
-0.18192924559116364,
-0.517170250415802,
0.16566681861877441,
-0.09360361844301224,
0.1981792449951172,
-0.4991992115974426,
0.5786235332489014,
-0.13749870657920837,
0.16181421279907227,
-0.16979698836803436,
-0.625986635684967,
-0.41037437319755554,
0.25188204646110535,
0.30178970098495483,
0.45888009667396545,
0.5532548427581787,
-0.5056628584861755,
0.49365514516830444,
0.39993277192115784,
-0.03903140872716904,
0.3101921081542969,
-0.8370122313499451,
0.10646209865808487,
0.19920431077480316,
0.2738827168941498,
-0.2638871669769287,
-0.7897273898124695,
0.07628854364156723,
-0.3703936040401459,
0.16731788218021393,
-0.14350558817386627,
-0.6067070960998535,
-0.4547135829925537,
-0.3992910087108612,
0.3252857029438019,
0.643561065196991,
-0.4330451190471649,
0.21087998151779175,
0.6572843790054321,
-0.299724280834198,
-0.6033115983009338,
-0.5293565988540649,
0.005051870364695787,
0.01779094710946083,
0.0130426324903965,
0.18870368599891663,
-0.08004245907068253,
-0.1379772126674652,
-0.07111242413520813,
0.1127854511141777,
0.11594157665967941,
0.04275423288345337,
0.35199597477912903,
0.5292354822158813,
0.06124718859791756,
0.05982329696416855,
0.26027166843414307,
-0.27122941613197327,
-0.10711643844842911,
-0.5110346078872681,
0.29687076807022095,
-0.009640959091484547,
-0.36947524547576904,
-0.11211011558771133,
0.42144522070884705,
0.3363151252269745,
-0.13112743198871613,
0.35802823305130005,
0.22598175704479218,
-0.325994610786438,
0.10025688260793686,
-0.692335844039917,
-0.27891895174980164,
-0.4215248227119446,
0.392106831073761,
-0.11632583290338516,
-1.4912189245224,
0.29955217242240906,
-0.11715719103813171,
0.16702160239219666,
0.4585413336753845,
0.9620110988616943,
-0.037971604615449905,
1.2287286520004272,
0.501821756362915,
-0.16731871664524078,
-0.01968255452811718,
-0.1992679387331009,
-0.262556254863739,
-0.7471424341201782,
-0.4689473509788513,
-0.39175543189048767,
-0.1462540477514267,
-0.6857424378395081,
-0.29889053106307983,
0.8575406670570374,
-0.4185689687728882,
-0.2640672028064728,
-0.01810299977660179,
-0.8795118927955627,
0.4845300316810608,
0.4815311133861542,
0.402696818113327,
0.276698499917984,
0.257294625043869,
-0.4943075478076935,
0.21650822460651398,
-0.4653147757053375,
-0.6318146586418152,
1.705868124961853,
0.4773869514465332,
0.9221298098564148,
-0.02836274914443493,
0.8220754265785217,
0.17749135196208954,
0.46319127082824707,
-0.6181883811950684,
0.3471953272819519,
-0.5099967122077942,
-0.6964261531829834,
0.057061001658439636,
-0.4651893675327301,
-1.122496485710144,
-0.23508785665035248,
-0.2933194637298584,
-0.6229429841041565,
0.27750957012176514,
0.20854918658733368,
-0.8432511687278748,
0.5526576638221741,
-0.04707523062825203,
0.2897845208644867,
-0.15269438922405243,
-0.4957882761955261,
-0.28555867075920105,
-0.9352556467056274,
0.3352735638618469,
-0.19734793901443481,
-0.0083036869764328,
-0.2240390181541443,
-0.1890634447336197,
0.5968215465545654,
-0.13184517621994019,
0.8591650128364563,
0.05708007141947746,
-0.01324003841727972,
-0.3854299485683441,
0.03305670991539955,
0.11732195317745209,
0.46742990612983704,
-0.028070751577615738,
0.44351688027381897,
-0.13168910145759583,
-0.42863190174102783,
0.045754361897706985,
0.8775846362113953,
-1.1087526082992554,
-0.46926406025886536,
-0.2861007750034332,
-0.5809777975082397,
-0.5512089729309082,
-0.017726192250847816,
0.47874313592910767,
0.456510454416275,
-0.21311068534851074,
0.10716346651315689,
1.015456199645996,
-0.45602867007255554,
-0.01598690077662468,
0.6333204507827759,
0.1899232268333435,
-0.7040018439292908,
0.8301375508308411,
0.009137891232967377,
-0.06561892479658127,
0.49138543009757996,
0.14947161078453064,
-0.45371580123901367,
-0.8352837562561035,
-0.6085034012794495,
0.27057644724845886,
-0.48614418506622314,
-0.2681921422481537,
-0.8460111618041992,
-0.11382914334535599,
-0.287497878074646,
-0.45876020193099976,
-0.20292344689369202,
-0.234407439827919,
-0.4690195620059967,
-0.32047489285469055,
0.4507533311843872,
1.053000569343567,
-0.2656821608543396,
-0.024259109050035477,
-1.1618247032165527,
0.5995607376098633,
0.3952539265155792,
0.5498051047325134,
-0.3847927749156952,
-0.2025897055864334,
-0.344661682844162,
-0.20083504915237427,
-0.27931562066078186,
-0.6692655086517334,
0.3589452803134918,
-0.017632070928812027,
0.8068996071815491,
0.5741079449653625,
-0.44388577342033386,
0.15759004652500153,
-0.609484851360321,
0.704070508480072,
0.274431049823761,
-0.4264681935310364,
0.6408173441886902,
-0.7067081928253174,
-0.08663924038410187,
0.795799970626831,
0.5773615837097168,
-0.19108706712722778,
-0.09174645692110062,
-0.7184287309646606,
-0.8717169165611267,
0.28632599115371704,
-0.21740524470806122,
0.173589825630188,
-0.12154993414878845,
0.7422382831573486,
0.4776391088962555,
0.3303072154521942,
-0.5649586915969849,
-0.21614909172058105,
-0.11221098154783249,
-0.4048958420753479,
-0.3125949203968048,
-0.1693035364151001,
-0.6078952550888062,
-0.3062181770801544,
0.5288811922073364,
-0.4301270544528961,
0.14387238025665283,
0.10239226371049881,
0.087592713534832,
0.0039430661126971245,
0.4571096897125244,
0.47864648699760437,
0.5403178930282593,
-0.3212752640247345,
-0.05508251488208771,
-0.09415071457624435,
-0.4474456310272217,
0.5355896949768066,
0.37507811188697815,
-0.008675009943544865,
-0.3007448613643646,
0.15895166993141174,
0.7001615762710571,
0.08703242987394333,
-0.8339611291885376,
0.16547934710979462,
0.2247566282749176,
-0.33535462617874146,
0.17600667476654053,
0.1524077206850052,
0.08872321248054504,
0.044544048607349396,
0.20903675258159637,
0.034721020609140396,
0.5331546664237976,
-0.3783145248889923,
0.09081705659627914,
0.3337199091911316,
-0.46335163712501526,
-0.3886456787586212,
0.8877947926521301,
0.3166865408420563,
0.12368234246969223,
0.37738025188446045,
0.21788467466831207,
-0.0026556479278951883,
0.3290150463581085,
0.337966650724411,
0.7606767416000366,
-0.34802842140197754,
0.40698498487472534,
0.06072773039340973,
0.04877800494432449,
-0.3117465078830719,
0.22533385455608368,
-0.0011387331178411841,
-0.474282830953598,
-0.3052244782447815,
-0.7425493001937866,
-0.7475554943084717,
0.18861357867717743,
-0.5520483255386353,
-0.007690286263823509,
-0.585067629814148,
-0.264011025428772,
-0.00549316918477416,
-0.08521498739719391,
-0.4544808566570282,
0.27566584944725037,
0.05249909311532974,
0.6201478838920593,
-0.6771885752677917,
0.8404393196105957,
1.0312985181808472,
-0.4476890563964844,
-0.5730461478233337,
-0.2456549108028412,
-0.03017031028866768,
-1.0778316259384155,
0.4782889187335968,
-0.07739187777042389,
0.16086359322071075,
-0.025210440158843994,
-0.6723837852478027,
-0.47115856409072876,
0.8339205980300903,
0.5311070680618286,
-0.6055963635444641,
-0.32651469111442566,
0.28402963280677795,
0.7563161849975586,
-0.25035560131073,
0.208437979221344,
0.5659850239753723,
0.30252379179000854,
-0.26910656690597534,
-0.8634552955627441,
-0.046588264405727386,
-0.22911250591278076,
-0.0988742858171463,
0.12266462296247482,
-0.6716428995132446,
0.7400400042533875,
-0.33947300910949707,
0.3594808578491211,
0.09864722937345505,
0.11694856733083725,
0.6744707226753235,
-0.045733217149972916,
0.015923209488391876,
0.7003011703491211,
0.5922089219093323,
-0.03213438764214516,
1.2013323307037354,
-0.39076361060142517,
0.11967775970697403,
0.5791523456573486,
-0.40994933247566223,
0.5253673195838928,
0.30401378870010376,
-0.29999619722366333,
0.4062426686286926,
0.9705916047096252,
-0.15080440044403076,
0.49306637048721313,
0.2661093771457672,
-0.34267547726631165,
-0.5301656126976013,
-0.4280165433883667,
-0.6542621850967407,
0.13085632026195526,
0.4722374975681305,
-0.6091820597648621,
0.22181782126426697,
-0.005926523357629776,
-0.04306346923112869,
-0.10888245701789856,
-0.47587868571281433,
0.9075924754142761,
0.10114474594593048,
-0.24443671107292175,
0.5254701972007751,
-0.005916881375014782,
0.7162689566612244,
-0.7496302127838135,
0.08500540256500244,
-0.23716115951538086,
0.09589837491512299,
-0.34140685200691223,
-0.6668781042098999,
-0.17432358860969543,
-0.10181812942028046,
-0.17217253148555756,
0.07044278830289841,
0.5394229292869568,
-0.10521676391363144,
-0.5071181058883667,
0.2721312642097473,
0.47191596031188965,
0.07742183655500412,
0.2246643751859665,
-0.738326907157898,
-0.22044388949871063,
-0.043680984526872635,
-0.2761135697364807,
0.5167357325553894,
-0.06897708773612976,
-0.09413312375545502,
0.5501652359962463,
0.9094894528388977,
0.5385433435440063,
-0.4697357714176178,
0.2593516707420349,
0.9970594644546509,
-0.5559907555580139,
-0.4278465211391449,
-0.8057949542999268,
0.11459500342607498,
0.04698134586215019,
-0.41337668895721436,
0.3242848515510559,
0.6358988881111145,
0.5156940817832947,
-0.22401262819766998,
1.0398399829864502,
0.5630861520767212,
0.5915069580078125,
-0.5305185317993164,
0.7223311066627502,
-0.6963599324226379,
0.0994611456990242,
-0.05369935557246208,
-0.5621938705444336,
-0.619842529296875,
0.2768513262271881,
0.05988569185137749,
0.017891790717840195,
0.4016384482383728,
0.5505936741828918,
-0.14891698956489563,
-0.1611858606338501,
0.4734092354774475,
0.21462248265743256,
0.22382134199142456,
0.8729246258735657,
0.6066160202026367,
0.17353875935077667,
0.007972031831741333,
0.09831012040376663,
-0.5883269906044006,
-0.39089301228523254,
-0.5139363408088684,
-0.8295182585716248,
-0.161241352558136,
-0.0550009123980999,
-0.15414460003376007,
0.3458464741706848,
1.4041943550109863,
0.8858749866485596,
-0.8307843804359436,
-0.05531197786331177,
0.04628501459956169,
-0.2843835651874542,
0.0187583826482296,
-0.036498744040727615,
0.509642481803894,
0.05807578191161156,
-0.46552371978759766,
0.763373613357544,
0.6244369149208069,
0.1503010094165802,
-0.2657027244567871,
0.003983314614742994,
0.07755716145038605,
0.3093535900115967,
0.42908257246017456,
0.4111054241657257,
-0.8313719630241394,
-0.06625095754861832,
0.08566159754991531,
-0.15856106579303741,
0.20990312099456787,
0.8330545425415039,
-0.8871943354606628,
0.25747203826904297,
0.134999617934227,
0.6549206376075745,
0.17066003382205963,
-0.18461821973323822,
0.48338595032691956,
-0.23819500207901,
-0.12281627207994461,
0.4212145209312439,
0.47122615575790405,
0.28491729497909546,
-0.49559473991394043,
0.7302510142326355,
0.34874576330184937,
-0.7516520023345947,
-0.7923464179039001,
0.22822730243206024,
-0.7659134268760681,
-0.3421545922756195,
1.273010015487671,
-0.003790833055973053,
0.14344827830791473,
-0.38035228848457336,
-0.20544876158237457,
0.14912822842597961,
-0.41857293248176575,
0.8299545645713806,
0.17679663002490997,
-0.5384361743927002,
0.3660494387149811,
-0.6638580560684204,
0.6688640713691711,
0.4636523425579071,
-1.1258853673934937,
-0.13368375599384308,
0.5569539666175842,
0.4750710129737854,
-0.18794412910938263,
0.8020375370979309,
-0.4019629955291748,
0.2164595127105713,
-0.5880963206291199,
0.30283740162849426,
-0.31486445665359497,
-0.3748230040073395,
-0.5110592246055603,
0.35035911202430725,
0.020417870953679085,
0.20217683911323547
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.06599v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.06599v1
|
Anna Karenina Strikes Again: Pre-Trained LLM Embeddings May Favor High-Performing Learners
| 2024-06-06T10:36:48 | 2024-06-06T10:36:48 |
Abigail Gurin Schleifer, Beata Beigman Klebanov, Moriah Ariely, Giora Alexandron
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY, cs.HC, cs.IR, cs.LG
|
Unsupervised clustering of student responses to open-ended questions into
behavioral and cognitive profiles using pre-trained LLM embeddings is an
emerging technique, but little is known about how well this captures
pedagogically meaningful information. We investigate this in the context of
student responses to open-ended questions in biology, which were previously
analyzed and clustered by experts into theory-driven Knowledge Profiles (KPs).
Comparing these KPs to ones discovered by purely data-driven clustering
techniques, we report poor discoverability of most KPs, except for the ones
including the correct answers. We trace this "discoverability bias" to the
representations of KPs in the pre-trained LLM embeddings space.
|
[
-0.5242152810096741,
-0.7809244990348816,
0.9374409914016724,
-0.3927922248840332,
-0.10022954642772675,
0.28483155369758606,
-0.17895253002643585,
-0.14389118552207947,
0.6305558681488037,
0.18290334939956665,
-0.25438225269317627,
-0.615184485912323,
-0.6521394848823547,
-0.14091379940509796,
-0.5088624954223633,
0.8713860511779785,
0.13106849789619446,
0.25468704104423523,
-1.0571167469024658,
-0.16019433736801147,
-0.0582975409924984,
-0.6270537972450256,
-0.09021075814962387,
-0.34571412205696106,
0.7254250049591064,
0.4153286814689636,
0.21807992458343506,
0.5227653384208679,
0.22094744443893433,
0.15278524160385132,
-0.3012656271457672,
-0.13980406522750854,
-0.5220283269882202,
-0.07231687009334564,
-0.05653298646211624,
-0.9140862822532654,
-0.2732674479484558,
0.4731287360191345,
0.7111339569091797,
1.1760776042938232,
-0.1619507074356079,
0.23100261390209198,
0.3693118393421173,
0.7419439554214478,
-0.595214307308197,
0.0555710643529892,
-0.42424920201301575,
0.3391112685203552,
-0.16423195600509644,
-0.07507449388504028,
-0.4879778325557709,
-0.4680132269859314,
0.3038220703601837,
-0.83786940574646,
0.211434468626976,
-0.3868917226791382,
0.35540536046028137,
0.31712964177131653,
-0.49215811491012573,
-0.25606346130371094,
-0.600085437297821,
0.6329004764556885,
-0.38090917468070984,
0.14574554562568665,
0.3103879690170288,
0.4538755416870117,
-0.017463644966483116,
-0.459309458732605,
-0.3133697211742401,
0.16605421900749207,
-0.19511865079402924,
0.13244640827178955,
0.028303779661655426,
0.08324135094881058,
0.25039055943489075,
0.315537691116333,
-0.19755791127681732,
0.3628873825073242,
-0.42096421122550964,
-0.1837652176618576,
0.35262438654899597,
-0.09947535395622253,
-0.15606318414211273,
0.1956864893436432,
0.011022159829735756,
-0.17380812764167786,
-0.7030701637268066,
0.45837104320526123,
0.6420232653617859,
0.1528274118900299,
0.12740589678287506,
0.768444299697876,
-0.03526882082223892,
0.5965927839279175,
0.11070118099451065,
0.024332983419299126,
0.23566189408302307,
-0.057940177619457245,
0.11711385846138,
0.044891588389873505,
0.3034623861312866,
0.1160900816321373,
0.42200034856796265,
-0.028017472475767136,
0.08574657887220383,
0.08422454446554184,
0.42232421040534973,
-0.522571325302124,
-0.21186453104019165,
0.1426531970500946,
-0.5367453098297119,
-0.42020925879478455,
0.46787887811660767,
-0.9479559659957886,
-0.194742351770401,
-0.1167655736207962,
0.3421885073184967,
0.08106441795825958,
-0.22981926798820496,
-0.17035558819770813,
0.03631952404975891,
0.03339559584856033,
0.28836995363235474,
-0.5874297022819519,
0.047867707908153534,
0.47782570123672485,
0.514083743095398,
-0.34644564986228943,
-0.20926867425441742,
-0.14077499508857727,
0.1592402458190918,
-0.41497889161109924,
0.8200497627258301,
-0.8453827500343323,
-0.46435850858688354,
0.21455802023410797,
0.12711040675640106,
-0.1520705223083496,
-0.735497236251831,
0.06479658931493759,
-0.46625787019729614,
0.009892047382891178,
-0.7635671496391296,
-0.7058067321777344,
-0.318052738904953,
0.10760356485843658,
-0.30351874232292175,
0.740490198135376,
0.12115176022052765,
-0.6743380427360535,
0.7096471786499023,
-0.4917021095752716,
-0.2002146691083908,
-0.09989138692617416,
-0.5429542064666748,
-0.3087894320487976,
0.12325161695480347,
0.06180207058787346,
0.6727357506752014,
0.20909754931926727,
0.5195978283882141,
-0.4700500965118408,
-0.4135099947452545,
0.356537789106369,
0.10956426709890366,
0.42957252264022827,
-0.0687897652387619,
-0.14811624586582184,
-0.05435549467802048,
-0.8356794118881226,
0.025051413103938103,
0.025737065821886063,
-0.7362054586410522,
-0.4391077756881714,
0.05428854003548622,
-0.6700308322906494,
0.06763257831335068,
0.19286249577999115,
-0.7563344836235046,
0.2144937664270401,
0.042260248214006424,
0.4377364218235016,
0.9921457767486572,
-0.25150159001350403,
0.5401824712753296,
-0.3363613188266754,
0.4891769289970398,
0.46882712841033936,
-0.012344497255980968,
-0.16150961816310883,
-0.5236005783081055,
-0.6267128586769104,
0.05172869190573692,
-0.12616904079914093,
0.16874416172504425,
-0.40127071738243103,
0.3936903476715088,
0.14858461916446686,
-0.8160408139228821,
-0.5973931550979614,
0.24272900819778442,
0.46759551763534546,
0.6758407950401306,
0.4824787974357605,
-0.33482685685157776,
-0.26884591579437256,
-0.956322431564331,
-0.511835515499115,
-0.0011441083624958992,
0.055783770978450775,
0.6045002341270447,
0.6208455562591553,
-0.2217726707458496,
0.8493748903274536,
-0.8692952394485474,
-0.03086385503411293,
0.043324392288923264,
0.02650206722319126,
0.19970372319221497,
0.5405049920082092,
0.52897047996521,
-0.3568961024284363,
-0.3437647521495819,
-0.31126514077186584,
-0.829154908657074,
0.17364558577537537,
0.28282788395881653,
-0.1257493942975998,
-0.07820803672075272,
0.5497741103172302,
-0.6719783544540405,
0.5237070918083191,
0.17448391020298004,
-0.1824578195810318,
0.44584959745407104,
0.00030599653837271035,
-0.047574732452631,
-0.8633773922920227,
0.15708164870738983,
-0.20654483139514923,
0.020831387490034103,
-0.5399462580680847,
-0.0964728370308876,
-0.1933458298444748,
0.08614238351583481,
-0.2735343873500824,
0.10426737368106842,
-0.36052441596984863,
-0.5973960757255554,
-0.053120195865631104,
-0.20508895814418793,
-0.26152580976486206,
0.5166015625,
-0.07203451544046402,
0.64522385597229,
0.7576881647109985,
-0.7619704604148865,
-0.10184811800718307,
0.46985551714897156,
-0.45681148767471313,
0.5308166742324829,
-0.5637524724006653,
0.2928710877895355,
-0.4241204559803009,
0.2359892576932907,
-0.9543626308441162,
-0.34494155645370483,
-0.17573148012161255,
-0.4591045677661896,
0.20659971237182617,
-0.11748327314853668,
-0.1624305546283722,
-0.570019543170929,
-0.350633829832077,
0.73203045129776,
0.6205256581306458,
-0.7820767164230347,
0.42932936549186707,
0.543069064617157,
0.0598008818924427,
-0.5464387536048889,
-0.5215966701507568,
-0.7911006212234497,
-0.12641887366771698,
-0.24337169528007507,
0.008265323005616665,
-0.11631812155246735,
-0.08734231442213058,
-0.0915333479642868,
-0.31408193707466125,
-0.06493775546550751,
0.25162816047668457,
0.3234441578388214,
-0.10873452574014664,
-0.203480526804924,
0.2818835377693176,
0.007656009867787361,
0.07746664434671402,
0.25614503026008606,
-0.37304678559303284,
0.5732837915420532,
0.1710009127855301,
-0.5083804130554199,
-0.049017369747161865,
0.37978240847587585,
0.49118682742118835,
-0.018444543704390526,
0.6469836235046387,
0.39008423686027527,
-0.2663380801677704,
-0.09576910734176636,
-0.3664778769016266,
-0.4665868878364563,
-0.4050682783126831,
0.23032133281230927,
0.10980303585529327,
-1.3373205661773682,
0.6295642256736755,
-0.12412679940462112,
-0.08232889324426651,
0.4158071279525757,
0.15656113624572754,
-0.553984522819519,
1.137850284576416,
0.8674820065498352,
0.2350500226020813,
0.22783443331718445,
-0.32461419701576233,
0.14918996393680573,
-0.6656914949417114,
-0.7202361822128296,
-0.47590699791908264,
-0.49478045105934143,
-0.5873652100563049,
-0.22981438040733337,
0.5521072149276733,
0.09098029881715775,
-0.28941959142684937,
-0.25695136189460754,
-0.5652166604995728,
0.46409738063812256,
0.8309073448181152,
0.3121521472930908,
0.03687245026230812,
-0.00018079305300489068,
-0.3520115911960602,
0.08700013905763626,
-0.7176967859268188,
-0.41856059432029724,
1.4647955894470215,
0.20606639981269836,
0.6871681213378906,
-0.17266446352005005,
0.621812641620636,
-0.0804474726319313,
0.24627141654491425,
-0.6197958588600159,
0.5918906331062317,
0.11061905324459076,
-0.5106905102729797,
-0.2132769376039505,
-0.2682531774044037,
-0.9997296333312988,
-0.03622909635305405,
-0.3403106927871704,
-0.6834667921066284,
0.26034340262413025,
0.27895352244377136,
-0.5540527105331421,
0.5524656176567078,
-0.3558458685874939,
0.5996649861335754,
0.037133052945137024,
-0.04091621935367584,
-0.12742596864700317,
-0.6286158561706543,
0.2927137017250061,
-0.43392136693000793,
0.20805670320987701,
0.15045632421970367,
0.13503497838974,
1.3580331802368164,
-0.48305565118789673,
0.8493181467056274,
-0.5534146428108215,
0.06101829558610916,
0.435433566570282,
-0.10071074962615967,
0.10102704912424088,
0.157706618309021,
0.39505013823509216,
0.0025039075408130884,
0.21625104546546936,
-0.7717240452766418,
-0.6011999845504761,
0.6499947905540466,
-0.8627968430519104,
-0.8859135508537292,
-0.3633100390434265,
-0.2947535812854767,
-0.38143113255500793,
-0.026555083692073822,
0.33960065245628357,
-0.005145984701812267,
-0.04267135635018349,
0.3314334452152252,
0.8131970167160034,
-0.3433886468410492,
0.22455228865146637,
0.6224427223205566,
-0.2806379497051239,
-0.101153165102005,
0.6585373878479004,
0.43016359210014343,
0.1943126618862152,
0.1456436812877655,
0.05925198644399643,
0.02754603885114193,
-0.4771488606929779,
0.06459318101406097,
0.31768834590911865,
-0.7618678212165833,
-0.05862921103835106,
-0.7776150107383728,
-0.07483406364917755,
-0.33894261717796326,
-0.4746343791484833,
-0.31676486134529114,
-0.19073638319969177,
-0.6212769746780396,
-0.6804901361465454,
0.03058309108018875,
1.203018307685852,
-0.12530569732189178,
0.5375056862831116,
-0.5648919343948364,
-0.09387653321027756,
0.6546659469604492,
0.3273276388645172,
0.18773917853832245,
-0.2091444581747055,
-0.5327432155609131,
0.1486491560935974,
-0.4059217572212219,
-0.9269248843193054,
-0.06981230527162552,
0.17444105446338654,
0.7346357703208923,
0.7544091939926147,
-0.38559800386428833,
0.22615255415439606,
-0.07514898478984833,
0.7624565958976746,
-0.028348572552204132,
-0.3712186813354492,
0.8409269452095032,
-0.2600116729736328,
0.2273373156785965,
0.6783273816108704,
0.8776706457138062,
0.09354285895824432,
-0.10598212480545044,
-0.6028846502304077,
-0.5392013788223267,
0.5465690493583679,
-0.43387094140052795,
0.11543300002813339,
-0.17587579786777496,
0.6855011582374573,
0.4991675317287445,
0.5635945200920105,
-0.5271896719932556,
-0.3122612535953522,
-0.14461085200309753,
0.013058355078101158,
-0.46373915672302246,
-0.518361508846283,
-0.2687017023563385,
-0.7275935411453247,
0.41942065954208374,
-0.46431198716163635,
0.3641376197338104,
0.26308494806289673,
0.006145097780972719,
-0.3197079002857208,
0.10685946047306061,
0.18151319026947021,
0.7123547792434692,
-0.3187282979488373,
0.2549651265144348,
-0.15457212924957275,
-0.7737035751342773,
0.2754722535610199,
-0.09047380089759827,
-0.336366206407547,
-0.3279401361942291,
0.4917529821395874,
0.34138914942741394,
0.16105559468269348,
-0.6352880597114563,
0.6585883498191833,
0.19502118229866028,
-0.30076006054878235,
-0.3093421459197998,
0.155130535364151,
-0.0663936659693718,
0.2975589632987976,
0.49951329827308655,
0.17006932199001312,
-0.11594465374946594,
-0.7677440643310547,
0.147080197930336,
0.4940457344055176,
-0.4778176248073578,
-0.6563966870307922,
0.5612297654151917,
-0.029839973896741867,
0.13748669624328613,
0.4993875324726105,
0.270412415266037,
-0.5707838535308838,
0.6499515175819397,
0.29994335770606995,
0.47459864616394043,
-0.46782904863357544,
0.5096550583839417,
0.485877126455307,
-0.024972444400191307,
0.10279092192649841,
0.5929224491119385,
-0.24926231801509857,
-0.7172656655311584,
-0.09238650649785995,
-0.7184409499168396,
-0.15895044803619385,
-0.04429251700639725,
-1.0378881692886353,
-0.08090205490589142,
-0.48824337124824524,
-0.13827180862426758,
-0.10160999000072479,
-0.32404041290283203,
-0.8271384239196777,
0.24039003252983093,
-0.3889375925064087,
0.783460795879364,
-1.1832950115203857,
0.5672668218612671,
1.0423942804336548,
-0.3539113402366638,
-0.7439703345298767,
-0.1106165423989296,
-0.22765041887760162,
-0.8738900423049927,
0.552028477191925,
0.4033638834953308,
0.4534280300140381,
0.2044224739074707,
-0.8411763310432434,
-1.0895092487335205,
1.4087728261947632,
0.2321634441614151,
-0.3187510073184967,
-0.2178078591823578,
0.3138677179813385,
0.47653377056121826,
-0.42045897245407104,
0.2593158781528473,
0.5779460668563843,
0.3390199840068817,
-0.035013992339372635,
-0.49511903524398804,
-0.16632655262947083,
-0.09368102997541428,
-0.5979142189025879,
-0.03523058816790581,
-0.49941736459732056,
1.0488389730453491,
-0.4875054955482483,
-0.006343447137624025,
-0.23144035041332245,
0.4916714131832123,
0.01268122810870409,
0.6143893599510193,
0.2972431480884552,
1.010000467300415,
0.985792338848114,
-0.1360190063714981,
0.8932428359985352,
0.0037631576415151358,
0.10816911607980728,
0.6078174710273743,
0.112076036632061,
0.6619213223457336,
0.6814383864402771,
-0.3683341145515442,
0.545773983001709,
1.0392143726348877,
0.014011522755026817,
0.7816147804260254,
0.4333144426345825,
0.006231463979929686,
-0.43972450494766235,
-0.18133090436458588,
-0.4805116355419159,
0.4599614143371582,
0.25050169229507446,
-0.44776198267936707,
0.007424659561365843,
0.09981795400381088,
-0.16160286962985992,
0.23845961689949036,
-0.49763843417167664,
0.7867180705070496,
0.20806875824928284,
-0.6748545169830322,
0.3252907991409302,
-0.5686646103858948,
0.7070598602294922,
-0.20564085245132446,
-0.0715535506606102,
-0.3236697316169739,
-0.13598722219467163,
-0.3879832923412323,
-0.8403435349464417,
-0.028865298256278038,
-0.3022383451461792,
-0.2791288495063782,
0.04727067053318024,
0.5678759217262268,
-0.3966096341609955,
-0.24367281794548035,
0.4707108736038208,
0.9901811480522156,
0.32175418734550476,
0.040269069373607635,
-0.030711807310581207,
-0.4363064467906952,
-0.08994866162538528,
-0.34549644589424133,
0.6584303379058838,
-0.07607380300760269,
0.18953648209571838,
0.7255284190177917,
0.7186061143875122,
-0.07569300383329391,
0.09353451430797577,
-0.27040234208106995,
1.1517338752746582,
-0.4401491582393646,
-0.3594789206981659,
-0.6774204969406128,
0.3149791359901428,
0.19755934178829193,
-0.27098727226257324,
0.6545618772506714,
0.60014808177948,
1.2397335767745972,
-0.10842067003250122,
0.7592757940292358,
0.5903040766716003,
0.7794064283370972,
-0.5719338059425354,
0.6437234878540039,
-0.5564357042312622,
0.27846473455429077,
-0.32294538617134094,
-0.9917150735855103,
0.0665719136595726,
0.4365383982658386,
-0.4247031509876251,
0.3529437184333801,
0.6351297497749329,
0.33371615409851074,
0.008302987553179264,
-0.002301775850355625,
0.3702585995197296,
0.4278354048728943,
0.09274733811616898,
0.5399755239486694,
0.8527305126190186,
0.27663275599479675,
0.08795090019702911,
-0.25392282009124756,
-0.2815604507923126,
-0.16987353563308716,
-0.4610694944858551,
-1.3014568090438843,
-0.748460590839386,
-0.04903331398963928,
-0.09041211754083633,
-0.029228543862700462,
0.5147743821144104,
0.5109058022499084,
-0.7027155756950378,
0.10784216225147247,
-0.109382763504982,
0.060153473168611526,
0.196681410074234,
-0.16200394928455353,
0.4137723743915558,
0.012844284065067768,
-0.19676566123962402,
0.4503161609172821,
-0.04877181351184845,
0.5012190937995911,
-0.4393438994884491,
-0.004341318737715483,
-0.1858055293560028,
0.02743665687739849,
0.2930522859096527,
0.20442558825016022,
-0.5369212627410889,
-0.29559236764907837,
0.10206909477710724,
0.2885693609714508,
0.04635179415345192,
0.8396978974342346,
-0.8867297172546387,
0.20021241903305054,
0.16828787326812744,
0.7389634847640991,
0.286075621843338,
0.053801488131284714,
0.5578969120979309,
-0.7319728136062622,
-0.15530388057231903,
0.3127032220363617,
0.4188925325870514,
0.20800547301769257,
-0.557604193687439,
0.412944495677948,
0.4886474907398224,
-0.49669119715690613,
-0.8498514294624329,
0.13244140148162842,
-0.6477486491203308,
-0.4351147711277008,
0.704322338104248,
-0.3973916471004486,
-0.24940617382526398,
0.18335402011871338,
0.03613097593188286,
0.15803419053554535,
-0.09481758624315262,
0.7144192457199097,
0.7324373722076416,
-0.19136781990528107,
0.11832553148269653,
-0.49681028723716736,
0.6577516794204712,
0.6536672115325928,
-0.8418352007865906,
-0.34549346566200256,
0.2521616518497467,
0.12743018567562103,
0.26412442326545715,
0.5000339150428772,
-0.023855185136198997,
0.22938723862171173,
-0.21633277833461761,
-0.1830580234527588,
-0.2607930302619934,
-0.6238041520118713,
-0.21743445098400116,
0.19257928431034088,
0.1646794229745865,
0.038252364844083786
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.03930v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.03930v1
|
Culturally Aware and Adapted NLP: A Taxonomy and a Survey of the State of the Art
| 2024-06-06T10:16:43 | 2024-06-06T10:16:43 |
Chen Cecilia Liu, Iryna Gurevych, Anna Korhonen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The surge of interest in culturally aware and adapted Natural Language
Processing (NLP) has inspired much recent research. However, the lack of common
understanding of the concept of "culture" has made it difficult to evaluate
progress in this emerging area. Drawing on prior research in NLP and related
fields, we propose an extensive taxonomy of elements of culture that can
provide a systematic framework for analyzing and understanding research
progress. Using the taxonomy, we survey existing resources and models for
culturally aware and adapted NLP, providing an overview of the state of the art
and the research gaps that still need to be filled.
|
[
-0.46898308396339417,
-0.5085155367851257,
0.0667494460940361,
0.32186228036880493,
0.030745383352041245,
0.39323922991752625,
-0.42335501313209534,
-0.8901879787445068,
0.5825347900390625,
0.3488261103630066,
-0.4543437957763672,
-0.28577113151550293,
-0.6117393374443054,
0.38621169328689575,
-0.4118536412715912,
0.8854214549064636,
0.16032183170318604,
-0.09130392223596573,
-0.19660677015781403,
-0.6120280027389526,
-0.7572636604309082,
-0.45937827229499817,
-0.5217267274856567,
-0.22359487414360046,
0.15492293238639832,
0.20219357311725616,
0.6909648180007935,
0.40214186906814575,
0.7039040923118591,
0.16306523978710175,
-0.6824889779090881,
0.07914161682128906,
-0.24029596149921417,
0.2655079662799835,
-0.5439908504486084,
-0.2885393798351288,
-0.674049973487854,
-0.09344322979450226,
0.5645445585250854,
0.8705723285675049,
-0.1257944405078888,
0.537341296672821,
-0.13378342986106873,
0.6734821796417236,
-0.640943706035614,
-0.03467337042093277,
-0.5972205996513367,
0.3993782699108124,
-0.17780573666095734,
-0.3822104036808014,
-0.2858319878578186,
-0.2965444326400757,
0.49911510944366455,
-0.6870496869087219,
-0.027403630316257477,
-0.19816362857818604,
0.02618984505534172,
0.0662185549736023,
-0.3704698383808136,
-0.6423624157905579,
-0.9655994772911072,
0.7207702398300171,
-0.46574172377586365,
0.30679476261138916,
0.36053696274757385,
0.12339133024215698,
-0.0848260447382927,
-1.0235704183578491,
-0.4229183495044708,
0.16804151237010956,
0.08295901119709015,
0.2521566152572632,
-0.48333489894866943,
-0.32082274556159973,
0.2892206609249115,
0.5125880837440491,
-0.49944573640823364,
0.1918972283601761,
-0.3400381803512573,
-0.14989131689071655,
0.5336475968360901,
0.19947847723960876,
0.7274127006530762,
-0.2288588434457779,
-0.3044063448905945,
0.3730006217956543,
-0.3735412061214447,
0.12211577594280243,
-0.3571724593639374,
0.11280496418476105,
0.0783744528889656,
0.18119752407073975,
-0.4857540726661682,
0.8635307550430298,
-0.4589247703552246,
-0.2394258975982666,
0.2470046728849411,
-0.5043009519577026,
-0.04940067604184151,
-0.006489024963229895,
0.38614600896835327,
0.484948068857193,
0.04709194600582123,
-0.1593727320432663,
-0.010694756172597408,
0.21127274632453918,
0.24225954711437225,
-0.40409010648727417,
-0.011314484290778637,
0.1634577512741089,
-0.5907225608825684,
0.04500168561935425,
-0.12136023491621017,
-0.7533503174781799,
-0.43549734354019165,
-0.23051245510578156,
-0.05800444632768631,
-0.40309834480285645,
-0.7716422080993652,
0.017543215304613113,
-0.44773197174072266,
0.3210688829421997,
0.22705601155757904,
-1.0455790758132935,
0.18475888669490814,
0.8951349258422852,
1.118025779724121,
-0.23936979472637177,
-0.05547531321644783,
0.3511238098144531,
-0.07253905385732651,
-0.3465763330459595,
0.8129699230194092,
-0.7236437201499939,
-0.5138686299324036,
0.3631213307380676,
-0.07526922225952148,
0.09757068753242493,
-0.4400715231895447,
1.0396568775177002,
-0.6478055119514465,
0.3012228012084961,
-0.5423012971878052,
-0.4282265603542328,
-0.5681138038635254,
0.4515608847141266,
-0.6236380934715271,
0.9192653298377991,
0.26388564705848694,
-0.9412025213241577,
0.5927821397781372,
-0.8867495059967041,
-0.32796016335487366,
0.4514105021953583,
0.2581821382045746,
0.2508508265018463,
0.19042038917541504,
0.1985171139240265,
0.14558814465999603,
-0.06630586832761765,
0.03704546391963959,
-0.11821687966585159,
-0.33056655526161194,
0.20763349533081055,
0.09404957294464111,
1.0451692342758179,
0.6198428273200989,
0.13484729826450348,
0.1644783467054367,
-0.8342704772949219,
-0.11978083848953247,
-0.07062451541423798,
-0.3741571009159088,
-0.6472705006599426,
0.27800193428993225,
0.10779575258493423,
0.27290454506874084,
0.29554420709609985,
-0.2187580168247223,
0.31253206729888916,
-0.2476201206445694,
0.7990261912345886,
0.35830798745155334,
-0.3091179132461548,
0.9545465707778931,
-0.32762348651885986,
0.7545047998428345,
-0.30857163667678833,
0.07888132333755493,
-0.2558687627315521,
-0.443735271692276,
-0.6479787826538086,
-0.07069094479084015,
0.22018666565418243,
0.7079969048500061,
-0.9541192054748535,
0.34602221846580505,
-0.31247711181640625,
-0.6420383453369141,
-0.5080112218856812,
-0.09378835558891296,
-0.21493425965309143,
0.5221384167671204,
0.45921337604522705,
-0.8632394075393677,
-0.7057508826255798,
-0.4736422896385193,
-0.3500521779060364,
-0.32830819487571716,
-0.11547680199146271,
0.05956792086362839,
0.43839970231056213,
-0.21417748928070068,
0.9848111867904663,
-0.362892210483551,
-0.43373557925224304,
-0.20110639929771423,
0.32680726051330566,
0.2764313817024231,
0.37999778985977173,
0.67775958776474,
-0.675439178943634,
-0.32484859228134155,
0.07414945960044861,
-0.7591409087181091,
-0.1077146977186203,
0.2253970354795456,
-0.07899988442659378,
0.1808592826128006,
0.46026262640953064,
-0.16188332438468933,
0.16752181947231293,
0.5392962694168091,
-0.36937612295150757,
0.2528340220451355,
0.07965146750211716,
0.050816264003515244,
-1.1111234426498413,
0.08280666172504425,
-0.05693221092224121,
0.013733319006860256,
-1.0203932523727417,
0.21208208799362183,
-0.12816111743450165,
-0.04294731095433235,
-0.20535750687122345,
0.4660249948501587,
-0.5283232927322388,
-0.10595099627971649,
-0.5455648303031921,
0.04934932291507721,
-0.14034080505371094,
-0.14497102797031403,
0.7577492594718933,
0.4015411138534546,
0.7490360736846924,
-0.6488226652145386,
0.3596529960632324,
0.3328424394130707,
-0.6254653334617615,
0.7900785803794861,
-0.19411389529705048,
0.09936285763978958,
-0.20184984803199768,
0.4237450063228607,
-0.3713398873806,
-0.25427281856536865,
0.2365598976612091,
-0.4173704981803894,
0.07197434455156326,
-0.2708500325679779,
-0.18586444854736328,
-0.4285655915737152,
-0.032172348350286484,
0.4652637541294098,
0.5303296446800232,
-0.17015862464904785,
0.6403384208679199,
0.5528634786605835,
-0.5272220969200134,
-0.7683826684951782,
-0.6673187017440796,
0.25762924551963806,
-0.3833313286304474,
-0.5564045906066895,
0.3287408947944641,
0.09908715635538101,
-0.4242260158061981,
-0.17406976222991943,
-0.08607510477304459,
-0.34850531816482544,
0.4631117284297943,
-0.35261034965515137,
-0.21649189293384552,
-0.4132702946662903,
0.25432291626930237,
-0.47639229893684387,
0.17904117703437805,
0.1426885575056076,
-0.1602393537759781,
0.6231930255889893,
-0.28602638840675354,
0.12280301004648209,
-0.08649228513240814,
0.5483126044273376,
0.3445492386817932,
-0.45654410123825073,
0.5811805129051208,
0.9297640919685364,
-0.4620516002178192,
-0.2097332775592804,
-0.14332515001296997,
-0.04772116243839264,
-0.3525523543357849,
0.4209304451942444,
0.06594826281070709,
-0.9638858437538147,
0.6146703362464905,
-0.17022013664245605,
0.18644611537456512,
0.4105253517627716,
0.3953729569911957,
-0.2733824551105499,
0.5613575577735901,
1.1323611736297607,
0.16499628126621246,
0.5802904963493347,
0.12121792882680893,
0.31773439049720764,
-0.8521146178245544,
-0.009455968625843525,
-0.7460574507713318,
-0.31266865134239197,
-0.9197052121162415,
-0.47910869121551514,
0.20256255567073822,
-0.13868726789951324,
0.14052920043468475,
0.24338310956954956,
-0.6925195455551147,
0.1620347499847412,
0.6855626702308655,
-0.2632533013820648,
0.6115672588348389,
-0.2429068386554718,
0.3689694404602051,
-0.07471727579832077,
-0.8820773363113403,
-0.5561960935592651,
0.7641895413398743,
0.3889559507369995,
0.48886457085609436,
0.47869208455085754,
0.15878547728061676,
0.5587916970252991,
0.3467341959476471,
-0.9428747892379761,
0.3927637040615082,
-0.07793912291526794,
-0.7924599051475525,
-0.11323055624961853,
-0.11858576536178589,
-0.9001461863517761,
0.1624496728181839,
-0.4446486532688141,
-0.7314712405204773,
0.25340092182159424,
0.14461028575897217,
-0.13668188452720642,
0.20593321323394775,
-0.40143677592277527,
0.5761116147041321,
0.015084628947079182,
0.20888382196426392,
-0.18029659986495972,
-0.7517395615577698,
0.5170447826385498,
-0.19252806901931763,
0.5157729983329773,
-0.5107129812240601,
0.08879252523183823,
1.084665298461914,
0.1806952804327011,
0.5173965692520142,
0.09044485539197922,
-0.06886082142591476,
0.29779931902885437,
0.2033504992723465,
-0.19251060485839844,
-0.08890233933925629,
-0.16128861904144287,
0.15848715603351593,
0.4401282072067261,
-0.34837326407432556,
-0.3989017605781555,
0.3912968337535858,
-0.27049630880355835,
-0.4130617380142212,
-0.8453328013420105,
-0.669267475605011,
-0.36750516295433044,
0.12238802015781403,
-0.02932017855346203,
0.06005023047327995,
-0.4669514298439026,
0.21410299837589264,
0.49714556336402893,
-0.44838953018188477,
0.6872307658195496,
0.5596354603767395,
-0.3785303831100464,
-0.07892163097858429,
0.6473884582519531,
0.27906233072280884,
0.06696299463510513,
0.3262118399143219,
0.09690948575735092,
-0.19174709916114807,
-0.7176645994186401,
-0.10700181126594543,
-0.2671307325363159,
-1.0114612579345703,
-0.019402524456381798,
-0.516655683517456,
-0.1369844675064087,
-0.5170488953590393,
-0.39801228046417236,
-0.04224945977330208,
-0.5198168158531189,
-0.2726700007915497,
0.01942518912255764,
0.5342522263526917,
0.7978793382644653,
-0.23839089274406433,
0.3129921555519104,
-0.7098862528800964,
0.10806136578321457,
0.3077560365200043,
0.6156905293464661,
0.1208193227648735,
-0.6263201832771301,
-0.29036960005760193,
-0.0852554440498352,
-0.1236056312918663,
-0.7181035280227661,
0.4072084128856659,
0.5061267018318176,
0.5302106738090515,
0.3529707193374634,
0.16859976947307587,
0.4808260202407837,
-0.3317687511444092,
1.1692509651184082,
0.20454716682434082,
-0.896747350692749,
0.7589545249938965,
-0.23744560778141022,
0.5837012529373169,
0.5086604952812195,
0.6956681609153748,
-1.2208480834960938,
-0.1360848844051361,
-0.5437938570976257,
-1.0737959146499634,
0.5206639170646667,
-0.23601749539375305,
0.4227239191532135,
-0.09709243476390839,
-0.2575529217720032,
0.15896110236644745,
-0.038507141172885895,
-0.7770642638206482,
0.0865747481584549,
-0.38863420486450195,
0.1423768550157547,
0.2126471996307373,
-0.3656328320503235,
-0.3220856785774231,
-0.3208804428577423,
0.47747933864593506,
-0.27021095156669617,
0.27439263463020325,
0.20498745143413544,
-0.5400245189666748,
0.18589191138744354,
0.5923287272453308,
0.4547167718410492,
1.2241616249084473,
-0.3938852548599243,
0.2066069394350052,
0.13631241023540497,
-0.741488516330719,
-0.0825851708650589,
-0.08213037252426147,
-0.3587315082550049,
-0.05753912404179573,
0.5892736911773682,
0.4140024483203888,
-0.04270283505320549,
-0.5716077089309692,
0.24577048420906067,
-0.2584228515625,
0.010295910760760307,
-0.5279871225357056,
-0.06436152011156082,
0.06614401936531067,
0.02979172021150589,
0.5859525203704834,
0.13700120151042938,
0.28334712982177734,
-1.0234838724136353,
0.10274476557970047,
0.276233047246933,
-0.6923473477363586,
-0.23036643862724304,
0.34051981568336487,
0.5188146829605103,
-0.23413453996181488,
0.5749325156211853,
-0.00901273638010025,
-0.3036838471889496,
0.3581595718860626,
0.6202897429466248,
0.6278873085975647,
-0.08883769810199738,
0.24444127082824707,
0.3522394299507141,
0.4554251432418823,
-0.0036481209099292755,
0.5166178345680237,
0.1610666662454605,
-1.1621984243392944,
-0.6423082947731018,
-0.8998726606369019,
-0.2881357967853546,
-0.1832837462425232,
-0.8892415761947632,
0.08798685669898987,
-0.4354718327522278,
-0.4282197058200836,
0.007855868898332119,
-0.2893039286136627,
-0.7016401290893555,
0.20437191426753998,
0.3096078932285309,
1.481196403503418,
-1.0129528045654297,
0.5380644798278809,
1.002229928970337,
-0.19508779048919678,
-0.20199258625507355,
-0.03472262620925903,
0.02886071801185608,
-0.6881736516952515,
0.3711909055709839,
-0.1712515503168106,
-0.04247960075736046,
-0.10244620591402054,
-0.24454958736896515,
-1.0546441078186035,
1.0036907196044922,
-0.2220935970544815,
0.1172659620642662,
0.389218807220459,
-0.2580254077911377,
0.8321877121925354,
-0.39261481165885925,
0.3333456814289093,
0.8679468631744385,
0.3561287820339203,
-0.16615962982177734,
-0.9220044016838074,
-0.16930077970027924,
-0.21337956190109253,
0.21432243287563324,
0.0029282185714691877,
-0.41704294085502625,
0.2805223762989044,
0.09743424504995346,
-0.30304384231567383,
-0.08263059705495834,
1.0551960468292236,
-0.08391452580690384,
0.45493799448013306,
0.4193401038646698,
0.43081173300743103,
0.8238496780395508,
-0.4357617497444153,
0.6717090010643005,
-0.23358391225337982,
0.11075077205896378,
0.8239920735359192,
-0.20130227506160736,
0.8815531134605408,
0.19964319467544556,
-0.18759986758232117,
0.6039517521858215,
0.8301964998245239,
0.07549989223480225,
0.27166369557380676,
0.1378396898508072,
-0.49863511323928833,
0.04002055153250694,
-0.8756295442581177,
-0.51967453956604,
1.1666722297668457,
0.74232017993927,
-0.5392268300056458,
-0.05424133688211441,
-0.16377735137939453,
0.1517413705587387,
0.25965285301208496,
-0.757276713848114,
0.9470037221908569,
-0.0310214851051569,
-0.8738852143287659,
0.46108540892601013,
-0.02500937320291996,
1.0720068216323853,
-0.6521671414375305,
0.010705040767788887,
-0.1678578108549118,
-0.5788211226463318,
-0.3891332447528839,
-1.0968599319458008,
0.6226256489753723,
0.007571825757622719,
-0.21907225251197815,
-0.5749273300170898,
0.976605236530304,
-0.2534259259700775,
-0.3164725601673126,
0.19450394809246063,
0.7021430730819702,
0.04388231039047241,
0.40112102031707764,
-0.2807662785053253,
-0.01092387456446886,
-0.08969436585903168,
0.10031067579984665,
0.16338686645030975,
0.21564950048923492,
-0.07514289766550064,
0.7278709411621094,
0.48097550868988037,
0.1698346883058548,
0.059986550360918045,
0.1562952846288681,
0.3989289402961731,
-0.8760385513305664,
-0.3043423593044281,
-0.6230337023735046,
0.33618947863578796,
-0.15840549767017365,
-0.6003700494766235,
0.6115413904190063,
0.08390606194734573,
0.9617459177970886,
-0.09996134042739868,
0.9672606587409973,
-0.5561483502388,
0.5000492334365845,
-0.4759877324104309,
0.7793129682540894,
-0.3172120749950409,
-0.06365080177783966,
-0.43654873967170715,
-0.7467114329338074,
-0.4359297454357147,
0.5593361854553223,
-0.038187045603990555,
-0.08673058450222015,
0.6010309457778931,
0.2734208106994629,
0.11208736151456833,
0.5764690637588501,
-0.08764785528182983,
0.1363409161567688,
-0.08324021100997925,
0.11533482372760773,
0.9762536287307739,
0.28423628211021423,
0.04775657132267952,
-0.35969626903533936,
-0.3778047561645508,
-0.16941264271736145,
-1.3686561584472656,
-0.13010986149311066,
-0.7833127975463867,
-0.3161472976207733,
-0.058199916034936905,
-0.3540641963481903,
0.8845314979553223,
0.6857373118400574,
-0.6449957489967346,
0.00808682944625616,
0.3639160990715027,
0.2284243106842041,
-0.6486130356788635,
-0.24051165580749512,
0.07794198393821716,
-0.25479406118392944,
-0.634699821472168,
0.32703113555908203,
0.37652963399887085,
-0.19700630009174347,
-0.17209801077842712,
0.2673669755458832,
-0.3763710558414459,
-0.0843496099114418,
1.1329727172851562,
0.6522583961486816,
-0.6812548041343689,
-0.28536349534988403,
-0.05099084973335266,
0.29746055603027344,
0.009812998585402966,
0.880591630935669,
-0.4094654619693756,
0.7834861278533936,
0.7303985357284546,
0.6825827360153198,
-0.032491832971572876,
-0.14307692646980286,
0.8379083275794983,
-0.7519914507865906,
-0.03133493661880493,
0.717365026473999,
0.4859597384929657,
0.5050265789031982,
-0.06801275163888931,
0.796174168586731,
0.2567759156227112,
-0.5475916266441345,
-0.6745576858520508,
0.6201488375663757,
-1.1906437873840332,
-0.46046316623687744,
0.8998040556907654,
-0.0178291667252779,
0.02340981923043728,
-0.3891753554344177,
0.17085321247577667,
0.19138358533382416,
-0.079794742166996,
0.8679943680763245,
0.9899406433105469,
-0.22372040152549744,
-0.2766316831111908,
-0.7442758679389954,
0.7479074597358704,
0.2943703830242157,
-0.6608473658561707,
-0.11044342815876007,
0.26620814204216003,
0.19229722023010254,
0.41902080178260803,
0.7154552936553955,
-0.13225314021110535,
0.32583847641944885,
-0.3589410185813904,
0.23258653283119202,
0.614026665687561,
-0.01306907832622528,
-0.2928342819213867,
0.2005457729101181,
0.55166095495224,
0.3932949900627136
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.03916v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.03916v1
|
ArMeme: Propagandistic Content in Arabic Memes
| 2024-06-06T09:56:49 | 2024-06-06T09:56:49 |
Firoj Alam, Abul Hasnat, Fatema Ahmed, Md Arid Hasan, Maram Hasanain
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV, 68T50, I.2.7
|
With the rise of digital communication, memes have become a significant
medium for cultural and political expression that is often used to mislead
audiences. Identification of such misleading and persuasive multimodal content
has become more important among various stakeholders, including social media
platforms, policymakers, and the broader society as they often cause harm to
individuals, organizations, and/or society. While there has been effort to
develop AI-based automatic systems for resource-rich languages (e.g., English),
it is relatively little to none for medium to low resource languages. In this
study, we focused on developing an Arabic memes dataset with manual annotations
of propagandistic content. We annotated ~6K Arabic memes collected from various
social media platforms, which is a first resource for Arabic multimodal
research. We provide a comprehensive analysis aiming to develop computational
tools for their detection. We will make them publicly available for the
community.
|
[
-0.5863109230995178,
-1.1160048246383667,
0.22423148155212402,
0.3483130931854248,
-0.49461182951927185,
0.23764728009700775,
-0.1459062248468399,
-0.24562887847423553,
0.41931620240211487,
0.4135722219944,
-0.515134334564209,
-0.5964450836181641,
-1.1629250049591064,
0.3418788015842438,
-0.5412639379501343,
0.860930323600769,
-0.17548635601997375,
-0.2039089947938919,
0.24297918379306793,
-0.4808756411075592,
-0.13762199878692627,
-0.37119850516319275,
-0.6703505516052246,
0.31367170810699463,
0.7808828353881836,
0.7127763032913208,
0.9353437423706055,
0.43358030915260315,
0.19978830218315125,
0.34095343947410583,
0.3109578788280487,
0.4966523051261902,
-0.08359810709953308,
0.004788311198353767,
-0.4231477379798889,
0.06878939270973206,
-0.017771054059267044,
0.13823944330215454,
0.5769688487052917,
0.14716869592666626,
-0.01765851117670536,
0.5936349034309387,
-0.2017841339111328,
0.3652728796005249,
-0.8333813548088074,
-0.015739550814032555,
-0.5339668393135071,
-0.11779064685106277,
-0.6559630036354065,
-0.3063792884349823,
-0.2256508469581604,
-0.3966054320335388,
-0.36973100900650024,
-0.23638926446437836,
-0.2572396993637085,
0.06856401264667511,
0.4863778352737427,
0.23816439509391785,
-0.6279221177101135,
-0.8491329550743103,
-0.6574255228042603,
1.0282591581344604,
-0.5905234813690186,
0.23089687526226044,
0.2497597634792328,
0.2958347499370575,
-0.3305806517601013,
-0.41781991720199585,
-1.0724939107894897,
-0.12687115371227264,
-0.17806699872016907,
-0.3332153558731079,
-0.463506817817688,
-0.34387850761413574,
-0.12731808423995972,
-0.08755502849817276,
-0.6612192988395691,
-0.10205613821744919,
-0.32200542092323303,
-0.6650382876396179,
0.5985929369926453,
-0.2738630473613739,
0.7052555084228516,
-0.5101413130760193,
-0.2216794490814209,
-0.44413208961486816,
-0.6385636329650879,
-0.4179284870624542,
0.6392059922218323,
-0.25767385959625244,
-0.22935892641544342,
0.6969112753868103,
0.038308702409267426,
0.555816113948822,
-0.20940092206001282,
-0.5273301005363464,
0.27004727721214294,
-0.3508119583129883,
0.046030376106500626,
0.22015756368637085,
1.0424935817718506,
0.17260262370109558,
0.525023877620697,
0.36115917563438416,
0.020389189943671227,
0.17876344919204712,
0.0743211880326271,
-0.7299284338951111,
-0.07981399446725845,
0.08691233396530151,
-0.5965932607650757,
-0.20641636848449707,
0.023796172812581062,
-0.6501474380493164,
-0.5379324555397034,
-0.022166436538100243,
0.3033713102340698,
-0.5598695874214172,
-0.539824366569519,
-0.1731259673833847,
-0.17796729505062103,
-0.18842756748199463,
0.3296099603176117,
-0.5466054677963257,
-0.21725603938102722,
0.41788312792778015,
0.7513854503631592,
0.5049204230308533,
-0.04699879512190819,
-0.1064261943101883,
0.20711252093315125,
-0.6378753781318665,
0.8156492114067078,
-0.8721569180488586,
-0.20782919228076935,
0.17855000495910645,
0.1855049729347229,
0.19974765181541443,
-0.4085084795951843,
0.9869657754898071,
-0.5955719351768494,
-0.07190524786710739,
-0.18031316995620728,
-0.2822878360748291,
-0.45658746361732483,
0.002709280699491501,
-0.9348220825195312,
0.37508392333984375,
0.16524189710617065,
-0.7324710488319397,
0.3469870686531067,
-0.7874303460121155,
-0.4268505871295929,
-0.17061246931552887,
-0.4722974896430969,
-0.5504579544067383,
-0.030633987858891487,
0.2300725281238556,
0.7229797840118408,
-0.16436302661895752,
0.046635668724775314,
0.13364236056804657,
-0.1920567899942398,
0.512787938117981,
-0.8837416768074036,
0.47420769929885864,
0.7932921648025513,
-0.2910144031047821,
-0.027095777913928032,
-0.5412729978561401,
-0.27032074332237244,
0.07923188805580139,
0.1468779742717743,
-0.47308382391929626,
-0.09729724377393723,
0.13994218409061432,
0.2267380654811859,
0.3435109853744507,
-0.5624504685401917,
0.022872883826494217,
0.12718170881271362,
0.19450752437114716,
0.6870693564414978,
0.39778199791908264,
0.36370962858200073,
-0.4416483938694,
0.45872581005096436,
0.47959616780281067,
0.28959351778030396,
-0.1938888430595398,
-0.510019063949585,
-0.18123877048492432,
-0.46551698446273804,
-0.06169601529836655,
0.44605308771133423,
-1.177625298500061,
-0.0067155491560697556,
0.020006222650408745,
-0.7706879377365112,
-0.7445980906486511,
0.3490391969680786,
0.25463631749153137,
0.10839330404996872,
0.411152184009552,
0.23339121043682098,
-0.5470447540283203,
-1.3653935194015503,
-0.37303364276885986,
0.01960538700222969,
0.11128456145524979,
0.09621356427669525,
0.3963279128074646,
-0.34155842661857605,
0.45796340703964233,
-0.03881198167800903,
-0.27728790044784546,
-0.15562878549098969,
0.8308081030845642,
0.2129139006137848,
0.40449169278144836,
0.8804692625999451,
-0.8797318339347839,
-0.5848214030265808,
-0.11132386326789856,
-0.6244158744812012,
-0.2219637781381607,
-0.37998613715171814,
0.10070809721946716,
0.12489553540945053,
0.2562471628189087,
-0.37535345554351807,
0.4112176299095154,
0.8379679322242737,
-0.48263609409332275,
0.5458442568778992,
-0.001353595987893641,
0.7940922379493713,
-1.126469373703003,
-0.19006246328353882,
0.26567554473876953,
-0.12843602895736694,
-0.34975701570510864,
-0.577303946018219,
-0.031439777463674545,
0.29037347435951233,
-0.4058001935482025,
0.660759687423706,
-0.513369083404541,
0.29503852128982544,
-0.388079434633255,
-0.22763249278068542,
-0.19915597140789032,
-0.009450715966522694,
-0.23918762803077698,
1.213079810142517,
0.1156538724899292,
-0.4241786003112793,
0.3002989590167999,
0.10558127611875534,
-0.3861837387084961,
0.5372744798660278,
-0.29433566331863403,
0.04903285577893257,
-0.43664687871932983,
0.15929105877876282,
-0.8252496123313904,
-0.39654096961021423,
1.0247008800506592,
-0.5046840906143188,
0.12842917442321777,
0.07458071410655975,
-0.8104903697967529,
-0.129099503159523,
-0.28334614634513855,
0.6282882690429688,
0.2124575525522232,
-0.2553301751613617,
0.3762366771697998,
0.49969741702079773,
-0.144068643450737,
-1.0277310609817505,
-0.21222282946109772,
0.23219561576843262,
-0.3698846697807312,
-0.4829580783843994,
0.029581453651189804,
0.2181728333234787,
-0.5531041622161865,
0.05694138631224632,
0.14906954765319824,
-0.11924715340137482,
0.06082881614565849,
0.3229869306087494,
-0.20440830290317535,
-0.14420686662197113,
0.32864031195640564,
0.3678605258464813,
-0.005386092700064182,
-0.023203235119581223,
0.02600044384598732,
0.5840981602668762,
-0.14296703040599823,
-0.6480700969696045,
-0.7729710936546326,
0.6596546173095703,
0.5748400092124939,
-0.2553301751613617,
1.1084219217300415,
0.994158923625946,
-0.3392280340194702,
-0.2232765555381775,
-0.7678053975105286,
-0.2783903479576111,
-0.4768993556499481,
0.41412127017974854,
-0.19970396161079407,
-0.5578544735908508,
0.20227430760860443,
-0.2919021546840668,
-0.027749842032790184,
0.6925490498542786,
0.4910796880722046,
-0.08887457102537155,
0.9989527463912964,
0.3726097345352173,
-0.3327273726463318,
0.39343690872192383,
-0.08778220415115356,
0.22347788512706757,
-0.21939769387245178,
-0.031090935692191124,
-0.5714766383171082,
-0.5862082242965698,
-0.827494204044342,
-0.6738898158073425,
0.4671836495399475,
-0.16738644242286682,
-0.2246701717376709,
0.14065015316009521,
-0.5724264979362488,
0.25850990414619446,
0.51772540807724,
-0.10389687865972519,
0.15324516594409943,
0.20842276513576508,
0.1493031233549118,
-0.09917151927947998,
-0.5371605157852173,
-1.1318271160125732,
1.0396277904510498,
0.37847790122032166,
0.7446455359458923,
0.3921017646789551,
0.35870638489723206,
1.0818196535110474,
0.7270851731300354,
-0.31510764360427856,
0.31090062856674194,
-0.25683534145355225,
-0.530251145362854,
-0.1723558008670807,
-0.09141536802053452,
-0.8617218136787415,
-0.3792714774608612,
-0.3021445572376251,
-0.37915730476379395,
0.10069829225540161,
0.13309629261493683,
-0.06326434016227722,
0.3019903004169464,
-0.49698567390441895,
0.7699882388114929,
-0.21273888647556305,
-0.24872766435146332,
-0.7464353442192078,
-0.48826223611831665,
0.016512572765350342,
-0.00921737402677536,
0.5784692764282227,
-0.4618677794933319,
-0.3244308531284332,
0.812202513217926,
-0.07874657213687897,
0.8263817429542542,
-0.19681908190250397,
0.053096916526556015,
0.761694073677063,
0.022816985845565796,
0.3315313458442688,
0.051460620015859604,
0.06859706342220306,
0.4854201674461365,
-0.11275115609169006,
-0.6986809372901917,
-0.24777187407016754,
0.6158748865127563,
-0.9547311663627625,
-0.3453866243362427,
-0.3267042338848114,
-0.34975090622901917,
0.25081488490104675,
-0.026508472859859467,
-0.019438382238149643,
0.41125398874282837,
-0.009980796836316586,
0.20020385086536407,
0.48894357681274414,
-0.21948932111263275,
0.5030343532562256,
0.29437577724456787,
0.12016505002975464,
-0.3663187325000763,
1.1569315195083618,
0.3537035882472992,
-0.31167566776275635,
0.11039566993713379,
-0.01024584285914898,
-0.2913721203804016,
-0.5033001899719238,
-0.7605347633361816,
0.31727901101112366,
-0.785490870475769,
-0.13028846681118011,
-0.3023357689380646,
-0.21632102131843567,
-0.08944622427225113,
-0.1849258989095688,
-0.3283514976501465,
-0.2273019552230835,
-0.33475160598754883,
0.06163544952869415,
0.5023732781410217,
0.9907650947570801,
-0.05684401094913483,
0.8113577961921692,
-0.8228827118873596,
0.038732971996068954,
-0.06721986830234528,
-0.12467385083436966,
-0.29391899704933167,
-0.35408684611320496,
-0.21389223635196686,
0.3705022633075714,
-0.33763521909713745,
-1.3080134391784668,
0.2900238633155823,
0.17064432799816132,
0.6207159161567688,
1.0810068845748901,
0.15069827437400818,
0.33873268961906433,
-0.32992812991142273,
0.6218101382255554,
-0.03257285803556442,
-0.6334655284881592,
0.32756704092025757,
-0.34016501903533936,
0.054608799517154694,
0.29606756567955017,
0.9051128029823303,
-0.6157132387161255,
-0.44744744896888733,
-0.8491642475128174,
-0.4026520550251007,
0.11488138884305954,
0.12701429426670074,
0.5350013971328735,
-0.5018570423126221,
0.3966403305530548,
0.3293364346027374,
0.558709979057312,
-0.5258072018623352,
-0.47237539291381836,
-0.4645030200481415,
-0.5805582404136658,
-0.08067367970943451,
-0.7340168356895447,
-0.07972966879606247,
0.076078861951828,
0.822943389415741,
-0.0358659029006958,
0.06904690712690353,
0.295472651720047,
-0.32288360595703125,
-0.11022666096687317,
0.2578544020652771,
0.9152759313583374,
0.8536753058433533,
0.08167056739330292,
0.5443397164344788,
-0.29444605112075806,
-0.564604640007019,
0.31522420048713684,
-0.16708199679851532,
-0.004271616693586111,
0.32029539346694946,
0.38693729043006897,
0.40578046441078186,
-0.09934486448764801,
-0.8303042650222778,
0.5021155476570129,
0.40043163299560547,
0.1487569957971573,
-0.7834153175354004,
-0.2943105101585388,
-0.003568641608580947,
0.39467400312423706,
0.7505879998207092,
0.1950312703847885,
0.18449732661247253,
-0.5748092532157898,
0.5252739787101746,
0.6067041158676147,
-0.1719208061695099,
-0.5429233908653259,
0.47511494159698486,
0.04120185598731041,
-0.14098145067691803,
0.1033325344324112,
-0.42683255672454834,
-0.46737128496170044,
0.5699073076248169,
0.2252742201089859,
0.3834226727485657,
-0.6531745791435242,
0.5931039452552795,
0.46528127789497375,
0.6798765659332275,
0.31775903701782227,
0.3163851499557495,
0.19448216259479523,
-0.8725907802581787,
-0.3567832112312317,
-0.5026745200157166,
-0.07171421498060226,
0.4036960005760193,
0.2674501836299896,
0.22461816668510437,
-0.583475649356842,
-0.19078783690929413,
0.32109248638153076,
-0.07399773597717285,
-0.4083552360534668,
0.2954707443714142,
0.46098196506500244,
0.756617546081543,
-1.135562539100647,
0.582782506942749,
0.8912513256072998,
-0.5740923285484314,
-0.5686596632003784,
0.03341950848698616,
0.2955917418003082,
-0.8612310290336609,
0.3614523708820343,
0.18926595151424408,
-0.3119391202926636,
0.01946479082107544,
-0.751133143901825,
-0.6581466794013977,
0.8359729051589966,
0.22934381663799286,
-0.15561774373054504,
0.5345553159713745,
0.32868391275405884,
0.26594358682632446,
-0.6102969646453857,
0.5096222758293152,
0.12271595746278763,
0.7757160663604736,
0.11369344592094421,
-0.7050067186355591,
0.10726866871118546,
-0.0517628937959671,
-0.3564987778663635,
0.16782154142856598,
-0.6325797438621521,
1.104986310005188,
0.18266092240810394,
-0.14212778210639954,
-0.20220035314559937,
0.6871597766876221,
-0.25248363614082336,
0.49688708782196045,
0.5693445801734924,
0.013130435720086098,
0.4341469407081604,
0.23604866862297058,
0.6261895895004272,
-0.3326471149921417,
-0.11787949502468109,
0.6928417682647705,
0.2860177755355835,
0.7508728504180908,
0.6545608639717102,
0.0925641655921936,
0.6840488910675049,
0.6187465786933899,
0.007571817375719547,
0.35503101348876953,
0.07224676012992859,
-0.6583138108253479,
-0.00004746920967590995,
-0.6168131232261658,
-0.15594425797462463,
0.6451671719551086,
0.8501366972923279,
-0.6186476945877075,
-0.38479363918304443,
0.1645548939704895,
0.7340622544288635,
0.42246463894844055,
-0.34304744005203247,
0.661464273929596,
-0.17865751683712006,
-0.37240996956825256,
0.5392057299613953,
0.3680872619152069,
0.5269081592559814,
-0.4968701899051666,
-0.34384283423423767,
0.182218998670578,
0.08892063796520233,
-0.30044448375701904,
-0.6256192326545715,
0.726050615310669,
-0.2247668355703354,
0.0586579404771328,
-0.05019861087203026,
0.9646575450897217,
-0.3450709283351898,
-0.57696533203125,
0.08623234927654266,
0.9352509379386902,
0.2816256284713745,
-0.374183714389801,
-0.6646732687950134,
0.1416279524564743,
0.10716018825769424,
-0.12212804704904556,
-0.08779606223106384,
0.3945385813713074,
-0.5602110624313354,
0.6483879685401917,
0.6398351788520813,
-0.060874875634908676,
0.07813350111246109,
-0.14658638834953308,
0.7403519153594971,
-0.3550160229206085,
0.021023036912083626,
-1.1288526058197021,
0.3324190676212311,
-0.4301117956638336,
0.02313016727566719,
0.9627573490142822,
0.3511851727962494,
0.5053960680961609,
-0.13071149587631226,
0.8493720889091492,
-0.17340072989463806,
0.6427897214889526,
-0.24611683189868927,
1.1379555463790894,
-0.532623827457428,
0.09989701211452484,
-0.06980638206005096,
-0.5185127854347229,
0.1998826116323471,
0.5804248452186584,
-0.2690444886684418,
-0.14059141278266907,
0.27756649255752563,
0.8371657133102417,
-0.030605420470237732,
-0.006885833572596312,
0.1525762528181076,
0.40629562735557556,
0.04130071774125099,
0.09219369292259216,
0.9874122738838196,
-0.0901593267917633,
0.47630369663238525,
-0.5288735628128052,
-0.3112970292568207,
-0.5012794733047485,
-0.8510622382164001,
-0.8869689106941223,
-0.8663408756256104,
-0.21310795843601227,
-0.16064226627349854,
0.15953361988067627,
1.153968095779419,
0.5452752113342285,
-0.9554276466369629,
-0.10615721344947815,
0.23855580389499664,
0.5165928602218628,
-0.03724982962012291,
-0.16101138293743134,
0.425051748752594,
0.04503583163022995,
-0.7645266056060791,
0.11040188372135162,
0.05328900367021561,
0.03646935150027275,
-0.5045282244682312,
0.10530965030193329,
-0.6236276626586914,
0.4220331609249115,
0.3656240701675415,
0.171163409948349,
-0.6062842011451721,
-0.4848478138446808,
-0.25823286175727844,
-0.00700301444157958,
-0.05920417606830597,
0.4334584176540375,
-0.5504779815673828,
0.19548733532428741,
0.04859472066164017,
0.36617517471313477,
-0.26639339327812195,
0.21411040425300598,
0.245112806558609,
-0.9526357650756836,
0.7113839387893677,
0.3313930928707123,
0.22685538232326508,
0.4056198000907898,
-0.42685142159461975,
0.2034865766763687,
0.2210453897714615,
-0.3334428668022156,
-0.3602120578289032,
0.16375577449798584,
-0.5297733545303345,
-0.30299338698387146,
1.0420526266098022,
0.052582331001758575,
-0.35487833619117737,
-0.30630582571029663,
-0.48354682326316833,
0.40029263496398926,
-0.7259081602096558,
0.8777238130569458,
0.8652227520942688,
0.18368121981620789,
-0.330500066280365,
-0.7813203930854797,
0.8067986369132996,
0.2656864821910858,
-0.6708092093467712,
-0.5897660255432129,
0.6150992512702942,
0.2481757402420044,
0.533778965473175,
0.425459623336792,
0.19255363941192627,
0.39520028233528137,
0.036805812269449234,
-0.006818818394094706,
-0.0019466883968561888,
-0.37918269634246826,
0.329965740442276,
0.3604747951030731,
0.11291364580392838,
-0.41461116075515747
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.03897v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.03897v2
|
HeSum: a Novel Dataset for Abstractive Text Summarization in Hebrew
| 2024-06-06T09:36:14 | 2024-06-10T05:45:25 |
Tzuf Paz-Argaman, Itai Mondshine, Asaf Achi Mordechai, Reut Tsarfaty
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
While large language models (LLMs) excel in various natural language tasks in
English, their performance in lower-resourced languages like Hebrew, especially
for generative tasks such as abstractive summarization, remains unclear. The
high morphological richness in Hebrew adds further challenges due to the
ambiguity in sentence comprehension and the complexities in meaning
construction. In this paper, we address this resource and evaluation gap by
introducing HeSum, a novel benchmark specifically designed for abstractive text
summarization in Modern Hebrew. HeSum consists of 10,000 article-summary pairs
sourced from Hebrew news websites written by professionals. Linguistic analysis
confirms HeSum's high abstractness and unique morphological challenges. We show
that HeSum presents distinct difficulties for contemporary state-of-the-art
LLMs, establishing it as a valuable testbed for generative language technology
in Hebrew, and MRLs generative challenges in general.
|
[
-0.23223350942134857,
-0.44917649030685425,
0.13344569504261017,
0.3927612006664276,
-0.40827760100364685,
0.15535810589790344,
-0.29238834977149963,
-0.3979080617427826,
0.18559470772743225,
0.1276257187128067,
-0.1972876787185669,
-0.6840588450431824,
-0.8389350771903992,
0.32287731766700745,
-0.6158766150474548,
0.9733493328094482,
-0.15360333025455475,
-0.15718726813793182,
-0.3825244605541229,
-0.440268874168396,
-0.3489140272140503,
-0.1270798295736313,
-0.41452598571777344,
-0.3494926691055298,
0.37806347012519836,
0.37029004096984863,
0.7103028893470764,
0.48378264904022217,
0.7178674936294556,
0.34002935886383057,
-0.28331202268600464,
0.270085871219635,
-0.33942708373069763,
0.23034866154193878,
-0.1902136206626892,
-0.2208453118801117,
-0.5709678530693054,
-0.36329928040504456,
0.844899594783783,
1.0990126132965088,
-0.18224510550498962,
0.35858410596847534,
-0.2994280159473419,
0.8921163082122803,
-1.0987340211868286,
0.17671364545822144,
-0.6262192726135254,
0.15067848563194275,
-0.4483763873577118,
-0.11587544530630112,
-0.42440247535705566,
-0.3072732090950012,
0.06404000520706177,
-0.42342182993888855,
0.2994057536125183,
0.04980284348130226,
0.8713833093643188,
0.3700864315032959,
-0.36432498693466187,
-0.17925941944122314,
-0.37344348430633545,
0.6376333832740784,
-0.8956416845321655,
0.2530515491962433,
0.3242160677909851,
0.2105938196182251,
-0.020375872030854225,
-0.6701618432998657,
-0.3367994427680969,
-0.1939162313938141,
-0.11094895005226135,
0.2919537425041199,
-0.29405131936073303,
-0.45678210258483887,
-0.20261532068252563,
0.7010397911071777,
-0.30127087235450745,
0.1522088646888733,
-0.5702118277549744,
-0.18964317440986633,
0.38573867082595825,
0.4945410490036011,
0.3221454322338104,
-0.3170500099658966,
-0.10771157592535019,
0.07953446358442307,
-0.8456486463546753,
-0.17058826982975006,
0.15709362924098969,
0.1902243047952652,
-0.3784339129924774,
0.8702147603034973,
-0.2781209647655487,
0.6378820538520813,
-0.4942941665649414,
-0.10687007009983063,
0.4737722873687744,
-0.3557543456554413,
-0.03662785142660141,
0.3447428047657013,
0.8729627132415771,
0.3965761959552765,
0.33421647548675537,
-0.036958131939172745,
-0.12404250353574753,
0.061751626431941986,
0.2628551423549652,
-1.1040409803390503,
-0.021068187430500984,
0.07755586504936218,
-0.5190929770469666,
-0.1454392671585083,
0.10819727182388306,
-0.3682965934276581,
-0.30425772070884705,
0.18196597695350647,
-0.013008326292037964,
-0.6176682114601135,
-0.19179874658584595,
0.3469468951225281,
-0.2646388113498688,
-0.038192857056856155,
0.45577746629714966,
-1.0392067432403564,
0.669887363910675,
0.7925258874893188,
1.013860821723938,
-0.3580140769481659,
-0.28329333662986755,
-0.3611764907836914,
0.20024342834949493,
-0.6853643655776978,
0.7434209585189819,
-0.36534783244132996,
-0.2913413345813751,
-0.08980821818113327,
-0.3724454939365387,
0.06545419245958328,
-0.7382714152336121,
0.503684401512146,
-0.5951557159423828,
-0.07550054043531418,
0.05726198852062225,
-0.664394736289978,
0.009886080399155617,
0.266134113073349,
-0.7027428150177002,
0.8930713534355164,
0.16320902109146118,
-1.0337616205215454,
0.17189082503318787,
-0.4023342430591583,
-0.7976672649383545,
0.4048452079296112,
-0.37601086497306824,
-0.4215563237667084,
0.4530898332595825,
-0.01697809062898159,
0.4151614010334015,
-0.40733298659324646,
0.2513454556465149,
0.43002232909202576,
-0.35393595695495605,
0.20327329635620117,
-0.3474169075489044,
0.3917793035507202,
0.25378426909446716,
-0.20082001388072968,
0.2675773501396179,
-0.7671018242835999,
-0.1263270378112793,
0.206848606467247,
-0.4161372482776642,
-0.5344488620758057,
0.1684107929468155,
-0.03910191357135773,
-0.28120461106300354,
0.43097472190856934,
-0.29388412833213806,
-0.22893144190311432,
-0.3844166100025177,
0.06918933987617493,
0.6279109716415405,
-0.2204819917678833,
0.155451700091362,
-0.20366328954696655,
0.3381984233856201,
-0.27087661623954773,
-0.6317386031150818,
-0.8069742321968079,
-0.6100908517837524,
-0.5094020962715149,
-0.5268738865852356,
0.4228212237358093,
0.4234364330768585,
-0.179499551653862,
0.6395596861839294,
-0.422744482755661,
-0.5468428730964661,
-0.4578087329864502,
-0.013809902593493462,
0.518225371837616,
0.580642580986023,
0.28324416279792786,
-0.30993983149528503,
-0.4046425223350525,
-1.089543104171753,
-0.053774576634168625,
0.011364159174263477,
-0.18829412758350372,
-0.09467970579862595,
0.7442888021469116,
0.10938744246959686,
0.7404298186302185,
-0.554053783416748,
-0.3110247254371643,
-0.4616037607192993,
0.364501953125,
0.13490399718284607,
0.31147482991218567,
0.20916293561458588,
-0.6097866296768188,
-0.48829934000968933,
0.020023321732878685,
-1.019648790359497,
-0.12043780088424683,
0.16478225588798523,
0.335290789604187,
0.07408285140991211,
0.6749356985092163,
-0.42002052068710327,
0.2905406653881073,
0.5799195766448975,
-0.4932749271392822,
0.4787249267101288,
-0.589266836643219,
0.27162277698516846,
-1.0559883117675781,
0.15529510378837585,
0.11105664074420929,
-0.25629448890686035,
-0.2752533257007599,
0.42013490200042725,
0.23181717097759247,
0.16230127215385437,
-0.4279061257839203,
0.4180951714515686,
-0.48714205622673035,
-0.4224059283733368,
-0.40988293290138245,
0.24384523928165436,
-0.1415180265903473,
0.0579310767352581,
-0.1849919557571411,
1.1346583366394043,
0.2088537961244583,
-0.5698971152305603,
0.22187688946723938,
0.6878116726875305,
-0.705395519733429,
0.4446010887622833,
-0.9132473468780518,
-0.4836769104003906,
-0.42670565843582153,
0.2614039480686188,
-0.8967329263687134,
-0.37202906608581543,
-0.23327629268169403,
-0.4570525288581848,
0.23594732582569122,
0.34753158688545227,
-0.5889672636985779,
0.12358403950929642,
-0.42285510897636414,
0.9017344117164612,
0.7637436389923096,
-0.03133559599518776,
0.44412556290626526,
0.31284916400909424,
-0.5817176699638367,
-0.4131659269332886,
-0.4144504964351654,
0.6291239261627197,
0.11181637644767761,
-0.6835481524467468,
0.8258984088897705,
0.09312142431735992,
-0.6424055695533752,
0.4075513780117035,
-0.15371236205101013,
0.27345597743988037,
0.11561219394207001,
0.05831770971417427,
0.16625048220157623,
-0.27201518416404724,
-0.038610056042671204,
0.03301538527011871,
-0.514944314956665,
-0.083623506128788,
0.1474934071302414,
0.7684963941574097,
-0.22027157247066498,
-0.39479100704193115,
-0.44962257146835327,
0.3555425703525543,
0.4316869378089905,
-0.3302440345287323,
0.599479615688324,
0.4541878402233124,
-0.5692945122718811,
0.11956185102462769,
-0.3950541317462921,
0.18322555720806122,
-0.3817940056324005,
0.802463710308075,
-0.4204937815666199,
-0.6441138386726379,
0.562936544418335,
-0.04720280319452286,
0.46604350209236145,
0.8686866760253906,
0.8413170576095581,
0.10370638966560364,
0.7954280972480774,
0.37773123383522034,
-0.09932436048984528,
-0.0015623149229213595,
-0.07966174930334091,
-0.16121433675289154,
-0.789524257183075,
-0.35494011640548706,
-0.7051907181739807,
-0.2733769416809082,
-0.5655927062034607,
-0.19956444203853607,
0.4660285711288452,
-0.3102421164512634,
-0.07235338538885117,
0.20727497339248657,
0.02448919601738453,
0.5094285011291504,
0.5541313290596008,
-0.2658136785030365,
0.6588121056556702,
-0.005494177807122469,
0.09470884501934052,
-0.33146530389785767,
-0.5029687881469727,
-0.49366623163223267,
0.6575473546981812,
0.22863911092281342,
0.6696102619171143,
0.31904810667037964,
0.5237024426460266,
0.5685824751853943,
0.12997663021087646,
-0.677506685256958,
0.5973142385482788,
-0.5942014455795288,
-0.4349892735481262,
-0.16996760666370392,
-0.5328853726387024,
-1.0345786809921265,
0.5636810064315796,
-0.26049473881721497,
-0.5398305654525757,
-0.4687700569629669,
-0.0507696308195591,
-0.25032272934913635,
0.2893458604812622,
-0.3003156781196594,
0.6379827260971069,
0.08909454941749573,
-0.32889324426651,
-0.5866588354110718,
-0.5857049822807312,
0.24362041056156158,
0.17155009508132935,
0.47752949595451355,
-0.4333438575267792,
-0.33625853061676025,
0.9904679656028748,
-0.5363501310348511,
0.7061779499053955,
0.3476623594760895,
-0.22634132206439972,
-0.016476117074489594,
0.16156595945358276,
0.35558581352233887,
-0.06463449448347092,
-0.055197328329086304,
0.009317722171545029,
-0.37699493765830994,
-0.7723572254180908,
-0.08571382611989975,
0.7110194563865662,
-0.5633110404014587,
-0.27393555641174316,
-0.6437045931816101,
-0.8460522294044495,
-0.13059745728969574,
0.3531892001628876,
0.30733031034469604,
0.5967432260513306,
-0.32457640767097473,
0.21691790223121643,
0.783785343170166,
-0.3519110381603241,
0.44520145654678345,
0.29698020219802856,
-0.03694356605410576,
-0.5847817063331604,
0.9060202240943909,
-0.2140665203332901,
0.2921399772167206,
0.3713783323764801,
0.2847999036312103,
0.0429825484752655,
-0.9521309733390808,
-0.7513654828071594,
0.06225292384624481,
-0.835471510887146,
-0.04305560514330864,
-0.6342697143554688,
-0.19857589900493622,
-0.18726219236850739,
-0.3403851389884949,
-0.5206442475318909,
-0.5322104096412659,
0.08691716194152832,
-0.2298659086227417,
0.07765825092792511,
0.8709142804145813,
0.3387267291545868,
0.21198688447475433,
-1.0128215551376343,
0.7066617608070374,
-0.19371095299720764,
0.36963555216789246,
-0.029132861644029617,
-0.5582869052886963,
-0.2695358097553253,
-0.4703702926635742,
0.10196094214916229,
-0.6434516906738281,
0.29904404282569885,
0.2703382670879364,
0.40746819972991943,
0.2677629888057709,
-0.05432068929076195,
0.4319923520088196,
-0.9374326467514038,
0.715068519115448,
0.4014260172843933,
-0.6988278031349182,
-0.07329750806093216,
-0.345613569021225,
0.8345421552658081,
0.8415964245796204,
0.3138680160045624,
-0.6937857270240784,
-0.47671830654144287,
-0.3832898437976837,
-1.2790708541870117,
0.3546198606491089,
0.4707343578338623,
0.5414938926696777,
-0.12032876908779144,
0.19116365909576416,
0.49757489562034607,
0.46396028995513916,
-0.3763043284416199,
-0.49529439210891724,
0.14751486480236053,
-0.5185896158218384,
0.042419031262397766,
-0.5829041004180908,
0.06374892592430115,
-0.19357885420322418,
0.6603372097015381,
0.14952930808067322,
-0.17605356872081757,
-0.13250145316123962,
-0.3388701379299164,
-0.008133363910019398,
0.3540453314781189,
0.8343105316162109,
0.8407069444656372,
-0.1988440454006195,
0.5364134907722473,
0.24358178675174713,
-0.4462820887565613,
-0.03119390457868576,
-0.018506750464439392,
-0.4197567403316498,
0.20273557305335999,
0.9900062680244446,
0.5702114701271057,
0.4680994153022766,
-0.8880955576896667,
0.40023350715637207,
-0.0038252912927418947,
-0.4042450189590454,
-0.4519357979297638,
-0.2192755937576294,
0.3561191260814667,
-0.1819595843553543,
0.6299536824226379,
0.06549536436796188,
0.1491343379020691,
-0.5118657350540161,
0.11216208338737488,
0.24050812423229218,
-0.18766506016254425,
-0.3344355821609497,
0.5405553579330444,
0.23350608348846436,
-0.24284210801124573,
0.4820530414581299,
-0.49959322810173035,
-0.438029021024704,
0.4299355447292328,
0.7821769714355469,
0.6555019617080688,
0.016123689711093903,
-0.013363499194383621,
0.5199269652366638,
0.20818504691123962,
-0.01707647740840912,
0.25124242901802063,
0.05867123603820801,
-0.6731929183006287,
-0.6083871722221375,
-0.4813774526119232,
-0.4595004916191101,
-0.25603482127189636,
-0.4438980519771576,
0.06711747497320175,
-0.2900846004486084,
0.2588556110858917,
0.27687394618988037,
-0.5315954685211182,
-0.10464885830879211,
-0.03946315124630928,
-0.09838546067476273,
0.985140860080719,
-0.6727699041366577,
0.0452994629740715,
0.5291264057159424,
-0.3636358678340912,
0.13234005868434906,
-0.1621038019657135,
-0.11862209439277649,
-0.802360475063324,
0.5715690851211548,
0.14950114488601685,
-0.335664302110672,
-0.0907786563038826,
-0.08191975951194763,
-0.5585898756980896,
0.8251974582672119,
0.13325689733028412,
-0.36373046040534973,
-0.10432656109333038,
-0.015988361090421677,
0.3219313323497772,
-0.13465209305286407,
0.12442214787006378,
0.45786452293395996,
0.42864441871643066,
0.32431843876838684,
-0.7358831167221069,
0.16353757679462433,
-0.6366564035415649,
-0.06829845160245895,
0.5751346349716187,
-0.43571749329566956,
0.8568708896636963,
-0.4373520314693451,
-0.20926333963871002,
0.12966538965702057,
0.9707050323486328,
0.16724781692028046,
0.3327673077583313,
0.3788291811943054,
0.6693083047866821,
0.558458149433136,
-0.046263184398412704,
1.0670353174209595,
-0.3226388096809387,
-0.026942573487758636,
1.2112222909927368,
-0.28282320499420166,
0.8602867126464844,
0.26451048254966736,
-0.2687149941921234,
0.5564161539077759,
0.3515857458114624,
0.09493792802095413,
0.45424187183380127,
0.5025577545166016,
-0.7065825462341309,
-0.17606577277183533,
-0.16861630976200104,
-0.3874952793121338,
0.3717898428440094,
0.4358791410923004,
0.009199999272823334,
-0.7141830921173096,
-0.2247750461101532,
0.24007102847099304,
0.5715318918228149,
-0.3609894812107086,
0.8962931632995605,
0.10920745879411697,
-0.6230760216712952,
0.3950783610343933,
0.536624014377594,
0.7604368329048157,
-0.6530708074569702,
-0.1034645140171051,
-0.09517251700162888,
0.14902152121067047,
-0.35562583804130554,
-0.39244040846824646,
0.5162143707275391,
0.22611004114151,
0.05705398693680763,
0.06995751708745956,
0.5028426647186279,
-0.08921385556459427,
-0.6451064944267273,
-0.10419909656047821,
0.6185092329978943,
0.1422305703163147,
0.1815132200717926,
-0.12022608518600464,
0.040341876447200775,
-0.33817723393440247,
-0.12777920067310333,
0.3372316062450409,
0.26800987124443054,
-0.38118019700050354,
0.5721539855003357,
0.3513813316822052,
0.16813640296459198,
-0.0782402977347374,
0.3515072166919708,
0.5216050148010254,
-0.9797760844230652,
-0.5715352296829224,
-1.1738040447235107,
0.4956880807876587,
-0.15770767629146576,
-0.37303856015205383,
0.7631824612617493,
0.8541318774223328,
0.5491202473640442,
0.18382267653942108,
0.8557971715927124,
-0.1652887761592865,
0.12146186083555222,
-0.43790990114212036,
0.5566415190696716,
-0.42443469166755676,
0.13384661078453064,
-0.10889720916748047,
-0.6394107341766357,
-0.5242050290107727,
0.528102695941925,
0.012399116531014442,
0.011820289306342602,
0.9325653910636902,
0.22192803025245667,
-0.10652372986078262,
-0.053941596299409866,
0.29743215441703796,
0.012527269311249256,
0.19278445839881897,
0.11126739531755447,
0.7108731269836426,
-0.3398605287075043,
0.38194215297698975,
0.026101408526301384,
-0.3104854226112366,
-0.1920737773180008,
-1.0102351903915405,
-0.858256459236145,
-0.6271554827690125,
-0.30615538358688354,
-0.21402154862880707,
0.13392317295074463,
1.1901475191116333,
0.32663485407829285,
-0.8775386214256287,
-0.4195685088634491,
-0.22109279036521912,
-0.04547727480530739,
-0.11242477595806122,
-0.08893615007400513,
0.48901981115341187,
-0.5392529368400574,
-0.7548201680183411,
0.4949052035808563,
0.3917244076728821,
0.00877190101891756,
-0.2572699785232544,
-0.02655581757426262,
-0.013131621293723583,
-0.12288513034582138,
0.6782447099685669,
-0.0737362876534462,
-0.4530160427093506,
0.04696604236960411,
0.031107228249311447,
-0.194227397441864,
0.10526344180107117,
0.9524874091148376,
-0.4668167233467102,
0.17002443969249725,
0.6673935651779175,
0.9150073528289795,
0.6826744675636292,
-0.0420357808470726,
0.5867514610290527,
-0.8454009890556335,
0.12481176108121872,
0.07548116892576218,
0.6599006056785583,
0.4993631839752197,
0.2401328831911087,
0.4921656548976898,
0.003807230619713664,
0.04238968342542648,
-0.5861970782279968,
0.4374973177909851,
-0.7653225660324097,
-0.32690101861953735,
0.9119033813476562,
-0.12387145310640335,
-0.1388929933309555,
-0.1056377962231636,
-0.15542817115783691,
-0.019569270312786102,
-0.3499472141265869,
0.9530816078186035,
0.5790606141090393,
0.21115835011005402,
0.02272486686706543,
-0.627252459526062,
0.11592092365026474,
0.5768859386444092,
-0.9149712324142456,
0.11503413319587708,
0.6844027638435364,
0.09197293221950531,
0.3535543382167816,
0.8675738573074341,
-0.26042312383651733,
0.43255606293678284,
0.1586647927761078,
0.13243332505226135,
-0.41239941120147705,
-0.1657325029373169,
-0.09244107455015182,
0.5134290456771851,
0.3967714011669159,
-0.03764701634645462
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.03893v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.03893v1
|
How Good is Zero-Shot MT Evaluation for Low Resource Indian Languages?
| 2024-06-06T09:28:08 | 2024-06-06T09:28:08 |
Anushka Singh, Ananya B. Sai, Raj Dabre, Ratish Puduppully, Anoop Kunchukuttan, Mitesh M Khapra
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
While machine translation evaluation has been studied primarily for
high-resource languages, there has been a recent interest in evaluation for
low-resource languages due to the increasing availability of data and models.
In this paper, we focus on a zero-shot evaluation setting focusing on
low-resource Indian languages, namely Assamese, Kannada, Maithili, and Punjabi.
We collect sufficient Multi-Dimensional Quality Metrics (MQM) and Direct
Assessment (DA) annotations to create test sets and meta-evaluate a plethora of
automatic evaluation metrics. We observe that even for learned metrics, which
are known to exhibit zero-shot performance, the Kendall Tau and Pearson
correlations with human annotations are only as high as 0.32 and 0.45.
Synthetic data approaches show mixed results and overall do not help close the
gap by much for these languages. This indicates that there is still a long way
to go for low-resource evaluation.
|
[
-0.08838210999965668,
-0.5773695111274719,
0.4420323669910431,
0.24380260705947876,
-0.5847147107124329,
0.3627395033836365,
-0.328738272190094,
-0.2942934036254883,
0.2427739053964615,
0.0788322165608406,
-0.357545405626297,
-0.24135425686836243,
-0.78581303358078,
0.4987824559211731,
-0.2545678913593292,
0.920827329158783,
-0.1279834508895874,
-0.11291756480932236,
0.059325505048036575,
-0.575697660446167,
-0.7845788598060608,
-0.4644823372364044,
-0.4062771797180176,
-0.22336545586585999,
0.5793961882591248,
0.5207816362380981,
0.8228607773780823,
0.7504512071609497,
0.6998078227043152,
0.22098834812641144,
0.1685977727174759,
0.061940744519233704,
-0.37293967604637146,
0.10004366934299469,
0.14460034668445587,
-0.3967607915401459,
-0.2242857813835144,
0.20374025404453278,
0.7449705004692078,
0.6904104351997375,
0.13477471470832825,
0.5819892287254333,
-0.03488873690366745,
0.7109052538871765,
-1.0503435134887695,
0.0739135667681694,
-0.5351312756538391,
0.3401622474193573,
-0.4800563156604767,
-0.34814879298210144,
-0.506920337677002,
-0.3098685145378113,
-0.17701931297779083,
-0.39304280281066895,
-0.22615647315979004,
-0.01912384293973446,
0.8300275802612305,
0.3876694440841675,
-0.45365142822265625,
0.07234357297420502,
-0.9570379257202148,
1.4040850400924683,
-0.47758373618125916,
0.07830684632062912,
0.6813517212867737,
0.7006083726882935,
0.22126194834709167,
0.06534210592508316,
-0.4750666916370392,
-0.2467351108789444,
0.03404933959245682,
0.2765474319458008,
-0.3287513256072998,
-0.3052516281604767,
0.1114983856678009,
0.6910824179649353,
-0.4933496415615082,
0.2693656086921692,
-0.4186075031757355,
-0.2095230221748352,
0.6120617985725403,
0.46119385957717896,
0.3580460548400879,
-0.5962629914283752,
-0.12320826947689056,
-0.1348564177751541,
-0.4029960632324219,
-0.04106680676341057,
0.20673911273479462,
0.5396617650985718,
-0.38061341643333435,
0.9698572158813477,
-0.47411131858825684,
1.0068297386169434,
-0.14655596017837524,
-0.25065144896507263,
0.42362433671951294,
-0.5750255584716797,
-0.4125683605670929,
-0.1333349347114563,
1.2047237157821655,
0.33369937539100647,
0.2501809597015381,
-0.2769508957862854,
-0.2506043314933777,
0.2310696244239807,
0.002664611442014575,
-0.7235764265060425,
0.2121761441230774,
-0.007111713290214539,
-0.5357427597045898,
-0.28639236092567444,
-0.5471170544624329,
-0.7536216974258423,
-0.30090034008026123,
-0.18977543711662292,
0.64560866355896,
-0.5659762620925903,
-0.4227547347545624,
-0.16347278654575348,
-0.040322452783584595,
0.5754028558731079,
0.16778874397277832,
-0.7579801082611084,
-0.08910614252090454,
0.39787358045578003,
1.1012611389160156,
-0.11694411188364029,
-0.3019755482673645,
-0.6648791432380676,
-0.20275191962718964,
-0.6146087646484375,
0.7742742896080017,
-0.6745657920837402,
-0.5861433744430542,
-0.13940629363059998,
-0.3274252414703369,
-0.3553191125392914,
-0.4010264575481415,
0.8530638217926025,
-0.25519347190856934,
0.08986937999725342,
-0.32474514842033386,
-0.03564024716615677,
-0.0963306799530983,
0.47032487392425537,
-0.31597664952278137,
0.937750518321991,
0.4619992673397064,
-0.5967869162559509,
0.5736691355705261,
-0.7870323061943054,
-0.6573692560195923,
0.21400462090969086,
-0.12389816343784332,
-0.14890892803668976,
0.4000228941440582,
0.19826368987560272,
0.13604934513568878,
-0.4100956618785858,
-0.32475799322128296,
-0.24264346063137054,
-0.730360746383667,
0.3070298731327057,
-0.824755072593689,
0.8193356394767761,
0.5951971411705017,
-0.24642308056354523,
-0.10884767025709152,
-0.8009070754051208,
0.36608177423477173,
0.14143136143684387,
-0.26920387148857117,
-0.3774789571762085,
-0.4960002303123474,
-0.17899154126644135,
0.4193364679813385,
-0.15281064808368683,
-0.7737957239151001,
0.0426822267472744,
-0.4785662293434143,
0.26355820894241333,
0.3748137354850769,
0.10853610932826996,
0.5402458906173706,
-0.17632657289505005,
0.7790733575820923,
0.06638606637716293,
0.32801133394241333,
-0.11005854606628418,
-0.47378677129745483,
-0.8891519904136658,
-0.3974316120147705,
0.659041702747345,
0.6197009086608887,
-0.9635846018791199,
0.14210814237594604,
-0.41560250520706177,
-0.6729271411895752,
-1.2053508758544922,
0.2089696079492569,
0.7241137623786926,
0.37660688161849976,
0.22118757665157318,
-0.39350226521492004,
-0.15633442997932434,
-1.0209015607833862,
-0.23868396878242493,
-0.015720294788479805,
-0.12735635042190552,
0.08952555060386658,
0.28133413195610046,
-0.12336122989654541,
0.6641232371330261,
-0.3354495167732239,
-0.2787294387817383,
-0.1301758587360382,
0.37372952699661255,
0.28251227736473083,
0.23302873969078064,
0.6207287311553955,
-0.3364625871181488,
-0.8427770733833313,
0.0030596654396504164,
-0.8543503284454346,
-0.08646579086780548,
-0.014921360649168491,
-0.2948282063007355,
0.4350583851337433,
-0.20041389763355255,
-0.6426997780799866,
0.3756033182144165,
0.7480039596557617,
-0.06400658935308456,
0.5105153322219849,
-0.22174614667892456,
0.646098256111145,
-0.8445910215377808,
0.1872912049293518,
-0.06664782017469406,
-0.12675347924232483,
-0.39616698026657104,
-0.03685376048088074,
-0.06475553661584854,
-0.47651591897010803,
-0.7313109636306763,
0.6062137484550476,
-0.44285520911216736,
-0.20338110625743866,
-0.3114849030971527,
0.25297296047210693,
-0.24760186672210693,
0.5384608507156372,
-0.10394638031721115,
0.957708477973938,
0.3593365252017975,
-0.4355238080024719,
-0.10686077177524567,
0.14352546632289886,
-0.3217340409755707,
0.8795629739761353,
-0.45019567012786865,
0.07474807649850845,
0.11334950476884842,
-0.29562732577323914,
-0.6652148365974426,
-0.04219576343894005,
0.4068111479282379,
-0.7028871774673462,
0.3073444664478302,
-0.23631469905376434,
-0.7528489828109741,
-0.12871316075325012,
-0.4355004131793976,
0.534428596496582,
0.6596582531929016,
-0.07401691377162933,
0.11621525138616562,
0.28504833579063416,
0.12293853610754013,
-0.5931949019432068,
-0.9819875359535217,
0.2956755459308624,
-0.035133544355630875,
-0.2668391466140747,
-0.3141751289367676,
-0.03514329344034195,
-0.2452690601348877,
0.028799287974834442,
0.0005429794546216726,
-0.24830752611160278,
0.022407975047826767,
0.3517565131187439,
0.21670381724834442,
-0.20966248214244843,
-0.11001243442296982,
-0.15168851613998413,
-0.47546523809432983,
-0.4385665953159332,
0.09490667283535004,
0.4014137387275696,
-0.22952884435653687,
-0.46501579880714417,
-0.46784013509750366,
0.10642266273498535,
0.6652970314025879,
-0.39743858575820923,
0.7170178890228271,
0.8813911080360413,
-0.28839072585105896,
0.3591906726360321,
-0.38053098320961,
0.24034366011619568,
-0.333488404750824,
0.04827781766653061,
-0.5308094024658203,
-0.5687428712844849,
0.2614513635635376,
0.1839718222618103,
-0.13987517356872559,
0.9711310863494873,
0.7143006324768066,
-0.11567118763923645,
0.9441781640052795,
0.6870037317276001,
-0.09411105513572693,
0.1273968666791916,
-0.3636696934700012,
0.45606333017349243,
-0.8895578980445862,
0.13410022854804993,
-0.5455935597419739,
-0.3487400710582733,
-0.8503039479255676,
-0.3590661287307739,
0.3319959044456482,
0.2227550894021988,
0.1724848747253418,
0.47281479835510254,
-0.5308972597122192,
0.561794638633728,
0.48293617367744446,
-0.23093608021736145,
0.3755985200405121,
0.07625745236873627,
-0.12704983353614807,
-0.38260865211486816,
-0.6772171854972839,
-0.6219239234924316,
1.1536486148834229,
0.15232069790363312,
0.31435710191726685,
0.03624565154314041,
0.6056670546531677,
0.5145031809806824,
0.3865799307823181,
-1.1254026889801025,
0.2883250415325165,
-0.22972863912582397,
-0.6628281474113464,
-0.4083251357078552,
-0.6373460292816162,
-0.8369157314300537,
0.42716118693351746,
-0.4275114834308624,
-0.15764474868774414,
-0.021345779299736023,
-0.13066039979457855,
-0.6788450479507446,
0.25562629103660583,
-0.9991317987442017,
0.822035014629364,
-0.37494194507598877,
-0.18687154352664948,
-0.3031526207923889,
-0.4147737920284271,
0.5667561888694763,
-0.42218512296676636,
0.34396517276763916,
-0.41987526416778564,
0.04594694823026657,
0.49722105264663696,
-0.2963152825832367,
0.483277827501297,
-0.21414418518543243,
0.2885507345199585,
0.5293444991111755,
0.45884302258491516,
-0.2908566892147064,
-0.2550191283226013,
-0.4509314000606537,
0.4600350260734558,
0.37009498476982117,
-0.8326177597045898,
-0.48730215430259705,
0.5419797897338867,
-0.7215746641159058,
-0.138488307595253,
-0.7102372050285339,
-0.5093730092048645,
-0.123332679271698,
0.36761048436164856,
0.21861496567726135,
0.2858121991157532,
0.08161325752735138,
0.1984655112028122,
-0.027236929163336754,
-0.42547062039375305,
0.6235228180885315,
0.6731149554252625,
0.04852863401174545,
-0.5018578767776489,
1.052838683128357,
0.35683155059814453,
0.2645130455493927,
0.2239740639925003,
0.2700260579586029,
-0.2011372298002243,
-0.472139835357666,
-1.1202009916305542,
0.13561993837356567,
-0.327508807182312,
-0.4430830478668213,
-0.3300655782222748,
-0.16076071560382843,
-0.15130767226219177,
-0.0121482964605093,
-0.5016103386878967,
-0.7288505434989929,
0.3555540442466736,
0.21265806257724762,
0.17184922099113464,
0.46026256680488586,
-0.15182873606681824,
0.36131852865219116,
-1.1338051557540894,
0.14453604817390442,
0.02106155827641487,
0.47035130858421326,
-0.030965037643909454,
-0.7185314297676086,
-0.6191763281822205,
0.2340400367975235,
-0.512420117855072,
-0.41755211353302,
0.2918279469013214,
0.22237509489059448,
0.42656806111335754,
0.1823512315750122,
0.21116502583026886,
0.8518267869949341,
-0.5480436086654663,
0.9882417321205139,
0.28887292742729187,
-0.7595852017402649,
0.4980277419090271,
-0.1561879813671112,
0.6149381399154663,
0.87203049659729,
0.3239519000053406,
-0.5422921180725098,
-0.36931663751602173,
-0.26021599769592285,
-0.41882219910621643,
0.5226384997367859,
0.5243397951126099,
0.3010752201080322,
-0.11144965142011642,
0.3183957636356354,
0.10925457626581192,
0.13846299052238464,
-0.48432832956314087,
-0.17828169465065002,
-0.032800719141960144,
-0.06911363452672958,
-0.18376542627811432,
-0.34372779726982117,
0.06974959373474121,
-0.2175782173871994,
0.3466607630252838,
0.1454744189977646,
0.13525721430778503,
0.012649314478039742,
-0.3583146333694458,
-0.48028019070625305,
0.5281291604042053,
0.6078883409500122,
0.625056266784668,
-0.5112626552581787,
-0.04984855279326439,
0.3038727641105652,
-0.3762069344520569,
0.3194841742515564,
-0.2068551629781723,
-0.3215959966182709,
0.20421254634857178,
0.4900997281074524,
0.5729466676712036,
0.17671263217926025,
-0.48443469405174255,
0.5966441035270691,
-0.08050403743982315,
0.07296372950077057,
-0.07836470752954483,
-0.24756820499897003,
-0.44050732254981995,
-0.12658344209194183,
0.13647931814193726,
0.20151828229427338,
0.05819835513830185,
-0.6495742797851562,
-0.09407723695039749,
0.3246949315071106,
-0.5203256011009216,
-0.5538693070411682,
0.5361313819885254,
0.3700278401374817,
-0.3155159652233124,
0.751613438129425,
-0.5667312145233154,
-0.23993699252605438,
0.03671028092503548,
0.211990624666214,
0.9968159198760986,
-0.2505103051662445,
0.21900364756584167,
0.5474976897239685,
0.6063206791877747,
0.36185136437416077,
0.1535986363887787,
-0.24734042584896088,
-0.22316907346248627,
-1.0108282566070557,
-1.1015698909759521,
-0.5272030234336853,
-0.023948926478624344,
-0.3234299123287201,
0.4804289638996124,
-0.193827286362648,
-0.4108242988586426,
-0.06771554052829742,
0.2949219346046448,
-0.7379945516586304,
0.16678744554519653,
0.022450951859354973,
0.7127702832221985,
-1.0039159059524536,
0.8495767712593079,
0.3359834849834442,
-1.027657389640808,
-0.31434378027915955,
-0.1576433628797531,
0.011805178597569466,
-0.8600762486457825,
0.8207978010177612,
0.019512619823217392,
-0.2587302029132843,
-0.3418777585029602,
0.1744527369737625,
-0.5967053174972534,
0.7596375942230225,
0.5356501340866089,
-0.3401710093021393,
0.3611704111099243,
0.565767765045166,
0.8816525936126709,
0.00792876910418272,
0.4731346368789673,
0.4356273412704468,
0.5388867855072021,
-0.0315445214509964,
-1.1457324028015137,
-0.30820780992507935,
-0.1273946762084961,
-0.01919131726026535,
0.3871791660785675,
-0.6703799366950989,
0.5688695311546326,
-0.08016420900821686,
-0.46768486499786377,
0.021503789350390434,
0.2315407693386078,
-0.0477021224796772,
0.4065234363079071,
0.3706454932689667,
0.717718780040741,
0.10775324702262878,
-0.031750667840242386,
1.4301507472991943,
-0.4814240634441376,
0.2036689817905426,
0.9304518699645996,
-0.3029378652572632,
1.2554658651351929,
0.4547419250011444,
-0.3107911944389343,
0.12986652553081512,
0.7193630933761597,
-0.010829411447048187,
0.4316633939743042,
0.09064988791942596,
-0.09785742312669754,
-0.20050963759422302,
-0.5237760543823242,
-0.12657050788402557,
0.7543544173240662,
-0.07355117052793503,
-0.08213828504085541,
-0.37237435579299927,
-0.08167203515768051,
-0.04353896528482437,
0.14601264894008636,
-0.1335866004228592,
0.5897247195243835,
0.18739716708660126,
-0.4341811537742615,
0.9887840151786804,
0.13068553805351257,
0.683646559715271,
-0.39929115772247314,
-0.05504647269845009,
-0.43278640508651733,
-0.0625428855419159,
-0.28678226470947266,
-0.8754609823226929,
0.9159747958183289,
0.4409022033214569,
-0.23474478721618652,
-0.23721154034137726,
0.5665660500526428,
-0.22776472568511963,
-0.6173888444900513,
0.2233113944530487,
0.7559993863105774,
0.5200240612030029,
-0.11751267313957214,
-0.5372271537780762,
0.07190340757369995,
-0.3545306622982025,
0.2872583270072937,
0.42958566546440125,
0.4490503966808319,
-0.0322234220802784,
0.41877633333206177,
0.6671196818351746,
0.25243034958839417,
-0.006648703943938017,
-0.0026340882759541273,
0.16353780031204224,
-0.6146708130836487,
0.03790383040904999,
-1.0487467050552368,
0.4028867185115814,
0.04620363563299179,
-0.3403652310371399,
1.0432592630386353,
0.827438473701477,
0.725233256816864,
-0.09998884052038193,
0.58323073387146,
0.07788567990064621,
0.5628736019134521,
-0.24646613001823425,
0.893778920173645,
-0.5291642546653748,
-0.14271289110183716,
-0.0674411803483963,
-1.2190604209899902,
-0.42841073870658875,
0.3095991909503937,
-0.4033203125,
-0.18374162912368774,
0.5405181050300598,
0.30235767364501953,
-0.18210498988628387,
-0.5082133412361145,
0.8412960171699524,
-0.08990815281867981,
0.15041299164295197,
0.4679238796234131,
0.746354341506958,
-0.8105132579803467,
0.9132038950920105,
-0.446120023727417,
-0.3776996433734894,
-0.07525084912776947,
-0.8322424292564392,
-0.5528775453567505,
-0.29360607266426086,
-0.2697640657424927,
-0.16930340230464935,
-0.3295660614967346,
0.7648074626922607,
0.6623633503913879,
-0.6963614821434021,
-0.3786027431488037,
0.6638562679290771,
-0.020912857726216316,
-0.079195536673069,
-0.229175865650177,
0.3887750804424286,
-0.49833500385284424,
-0.8350614905357361,
0.3360595405101776,
0.8392019867897034,
-0.09588108956813812,
-0.33479687571525574,
-0.08657792210578918,
-0.2261006236076355,
0.07453025132417679,
1.0447975397109985,
0.3621925115585327,
-0.6023237109184265,
-0.23541855812072754,
0.10824170708656311,
-0.221567764878273,
0.1209678128361702,
0.4923369586467743,
-0.6245325803756714,
0.7750718593597412,
0.3937334716320038,
0.9388092756271362,
0.3869815170764923,
-0.17229510843753815,
0.41835570335388184,
-0.7095810770988464,
0.335452139377594,
0.10431128740310669,
0.12771621346473694,
0.6581571102142334,
-0.02571019157767296,
0.8228042721748352,
0.24296219646930695,
-0.43394067883491516,
-1.024194359779358,
-0.04120202362537384,
-0.789812445640564,
0.2592596411705017,
0.9734854102134705,
0.04137316346168518,
-0.49119266867637634,
0.24929919838905334,
-0.07104675471782684,
0.3474218547344208,
-0.13905452191829681,
0.9446297883987427,
0.7882235050201416,
-0.19102022051811218,
0.013037147931754589,
-1.0241514444351196,
0.2352980673313141,
0.602125883102417,
-0.5687357783317566,
-0.11119075864553452,
0.3171280026435852,
0.19702628254890442,
0.471696138381958,
0.8252685070037842,
-0.4416661560535431,
0.17781849205493927,
0.07394451647996902,
-0.11358073353767395,
0.009172962978482246,
0.1079244315624237,
-0.6534018516540527,
-0.28740692138671875,
0.407147079706192,
-0.7470261454582214
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.06598v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.06598v1
|
Qabas: An Open-Source Arabic Lexicographic Database
| 2024-06-06T09:25:36 | 2024-06-06T09:25:36 |
Mustafa Jarrar, Tymaa Hammouda
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
We present Qabas, a novel open-source Arabic lexicon designed for NLP
applications. The novelty of Qabas lies in its synthesis of 110 lexicons.
Specifically, Qabas lexical entries (lemmas) are assembled by linking lemmas
from 110 lexicons. Furthermore, Qabas lemmas are also linked to 12
morphologically annotated corpora (about 2M tokens), making it the first Arabic
lexicon to be linked to lexicons and corpora. Qabas was developed
semi-automatically, utilizing a mapping framework and a web-based tool.
Compared with other lexicons, Qabas stands as the most extensive Arabic
lexicon, encompassing about 58K lemmas (45K nominal lemmas, 12.5K verbal
lemmas, and 473 functional-word lemmas). Qabas is open-source and accessible
online at https://sina.birzeit.edu/qabas.
|
[
-0.4802480638027191,
-0.05399705842137337,
0.373186856508255,
0.18674933910369873,
-0.42372867465019226,
0.27227506041526794,
0.046384476125240326,
-0.49065718054771423,
0.3908529579639435,
0.3485543429851532,
-0.248052716255188,
-1.1181271076202393,
-0.5203229188919067,
0.14399726688861847,
-0.7686532139778137,
1.0504177808761597,
0.13408342003822327,
-0.15804056823253632,
0.35566818714141846,
-0.6397271156311035,
0.18543441593647003,
-0.4216933250427246,
-0.35603320598602295,
0.5464272499084473,
0.6086856126785278,
0.3572310209274292,
1.7060621976852417,
0.6912998557090759,
0.4275653660297394,
0.35203132033348083,
-0.06085534766316414,
0.36415573954582214,
-0.14114275574684143,
0.2048782855272293,
-0.26725614070892334,
-0.38066989183425903,
-0.5001837611198425,
-0.6622387170791626,
0.6766815781593323,
0.5438289642333984,
-0.3108229339122772,
0.3286036550998688,
-0.20402081310749054,
1.0004538297653198,
-0.9500970840454102,
-0.1949189454317093,
-0.49401065707206726,
-0.17573665082454681,
-0.6358559131622314,
-0.1417541205883026,
0.0464041605591774,
-0.8940918445587158,
-0.03585265949368477,
-0.6816005706787109,
0.06328102946281433,
-0.03726963698863983,
0.585826575756073,
0.17634853720664978,
-0.07480110973119736,
-1.139456868171692,
-0.4959975481033325,
0.5681813359260559,
-0.5540252327919006,
0.3246947228908539,
0.4756729304790497,
0.6098101735115051,
-0.005267815198749304,
-1.0631179809570312,
-0.4348379969596863,
-0.0856444388628006,
0.012199565768241882,
-0.38753625750541687,
-0.16992390155792236,
-0.01500222459435463,
-0.010412720032036304,
0.4288301169872284,
-0.6453378200531006,
-0.27561694383621216,
-0.19722062349319458,
-0.26670002937316895,
0.44627633690834045,
0.17422348260879517,
0.7042548060417175,
0.06659260392189026,
-0.15797847509384155,
0.020961172878742218,
-1.18318510055542,
-0.2610757052898407,
0.17806516587734222,
0.19934311509132385,
-0.08293412625789642,
0.6572487354278564,
-0.05518645793199539,
0.4673929810523987,
-0.4889603853225708,
-0.4872671961784363,
0.27924391627311707,
-0.646754264831543,
-0.08250352740287781,
0.289987713098526,
0.8568569421768188,
0.043615587055683136,
0.1614508479833603,
0.060653917491436005,
-0.3698752522468567,
0.12085387855768204,
0.03998831287026405,
-0.9025508761405945,
-0.24848733842372894,
0.4510018229484558,
-0.380842387676239,
-0.08056243509054184,
-0.29773828387260437,
-0.5128263831138611,
-0.3320053517818451,
0.2877901494503021,
0.21944236755371094,
-0.7093112468719482,
0.008822483941912651,
-0.12985597550868988,
0.2050517350435257,
-0.12095391750335693,
0.36708828806877136,
-0.7112241983413696,
0.39517635107040405,
0.3838385045528412,
1.1978912353515625,
0.34543487429618835,
0.06864462792873383,
-0.1822701245546341,
0.13118432462215424,
-0.664979100227356,
0.7048222422599792,
-0.5652589201927185,
-0.6481009125709534,
0.3675951361656189,
-0.24140381813049316,
0.5383225083351135,
-0.820706844329834,
0.734771192073822,
-0.6572678089141846,
-0.034865185618400574,
-0.36824703216552734,
-0.5665535926818848,
-0.03442244976758957,
-0.10977956652641296,
-0.7841760516166687,
0.9738929867744446,
0.46918752789497375,
-0.6852953433990479,
0.001715433201752603,
-0.6003433465957642,
-0.09351249039173126,
0.608540415763855,
-0.6284701228141785,
-0.1900230199098587,
-0.05341002345085144,
0.23920221626758575,
-0.16667044162750244,
-0.36743637919425964,
0.34792372584342957,
0.195571631193161,
-0.3317427933216095,
0.27496010065078735,
0.19492657482624054,
1.1047847270965576,
0.5357747673988342,
-0.21316535770893097,
0.08218514174222946,
-0.7310131788253784,
0.1391657143831253,
-0.06920618563890457,
-0.18834850192070007,
-0.4097049832344055,
0.17909350991249084,
0.10554768890142441,
0.11749635636806488,
0.5248859524726868,
-0.6074939966201782,
0.34234315156936646,
-0.49432653188705444,
0.14838220179080963,
0.2679273188114166,
-0.27447509765625,
0.08769266307353973,
-0.4111826419830322,
0.545311689376831,
0.019132722169160843,
-0.1659543514251709,
-0.29760757088661194,
-0.6766617894172668,
-0.4207998216152191,
-0.553612470626831,
0.5667149424552917,
0.3003266453742981,
-0.7488057017326355,
0.31023088097572327,
-0.18032120168209076,
-0.7783615589141846,
-0.8084396719932556,
0.2489214688539505,
0.405186265707016,
-0.13168255984783173,
0.36449506878852844,
-0.46013137698173523,
-0.5282644033432007,
-0.9809257388114929,
-0.1287437081336975,
-0.20716549456119537,
-0.15387225151062012,
-0.12224938720464706,
0.5828313231468201,
-0.09959782660007477,
0.7802292108535767,
-0.40937498211860657,
-0.6436461806297302,
-0.08312434703111649,
-0.09967293590307236,
0.1358029991388321,
0.17815127968788147,
1.313478946685791,
-0.48236483335494995,
-0.6747311353683472,
-0.023716740310192108,
-0.5057229995727539,
-0.14370061457157135,
0.027368158102035522,
-0.27153322100639343,
0.06443122029304504,
0.31733742356300354,
-0.7550959587097168,
0.5187710523605347,
0.5012876391410828,
-0.3002490699291229,
0.5769135355949402,
0.14467187225818634,
-0.22837437689304352,
-1.2728993892669678,
0.053987860679626465,
-0.4371655583381653,
-0.04759480059146881,
-0.27638086676597595,
0.28842973709106445,
0.21840842068195343,
-0.016644246876239777,
-0.5184264779090881,
0.6540043950080872,
-0.48568907380104065,
-0.30378368496894836,
-0.20405037701129913,
0.35653406381607056,
-0.2370467633008957,
0.30175817012786865,
-0.09096935391426086,
1.2070873975753784,
0.6802882552146912,
-0.5594813823699951,
0.45886245369911194,
0.640038788318634,
-0.8094427585601807,
0.36508071422576904,
-0.5456598997116089,
-0.043091803789138794,
-0.11685372143983841,
0.07925906032323837,
-0.9121595621109009,
-0.054934948682785034,
0.36445939540863037,
-0.565519392490387,
-0.05470120534300804,
0.16125400364398956,
-0.4280698597431183,
0.16033098101615906,
-0.3675159513950348,
0.5930635929107666,
0.4601958394050598,
-0.5743640065193176,
0.3561074435710907,
0.557422399520874,
-0.5914346575737,
-0.8098493814468384,
-0.3246811330318451,
0.35680773854255676,
0.37521663308143616,
-0.3461233973503113,
0.6441488862037659,
0.017917530611157417,
-0.4707591235637665,
0.5234642624855042,
0.09873205423355103,
-0.037453971803188324,
-0.04898563772439957,
0.5906822681427002,
0.03133115917444229,
-0.35379737615585327,
0.4288395643234253,
0.10860665887594223,
0.2542968690395355,
-0.03305939957499504,
-0.1802784651517868,
0.46447333693504333,
-0.46692508459091187,
-0.4502544701099396,
-0.46774137020111084,
0.45338737964630127,
0.5189284086227417,
-0.3120153546333313,
1.0523320436477661,
0.3220020532608032,
-0.5355238914489746,
-0.20762673020362854,
0.011728488840162754,
0.49327361583709717,
-0.5055315494537354,
0.47938284277915955,
-0.3619886636734009,
-0.7054528594017029,
0.35910743474960327,
-0.0020731447730213404,
0.5067129731178284,
0.5660195350646973,
0.8612661361694336,
-0.058869369328022,
0.6897672414779663,
0.23230543732643127,
-0.3048228919506073,
0.13466013967990875,
-0.07075724750757217,
0.1792871505022049,
-0.43582481145858765,
-0.24564407765865326,
-0.8688516020774841,
-0.3752424716949463,
-0.85028076171875,
-0.5292932987213135,
0.45918700098991394,
-0.0064467210322618484,
-0.270731121301651,
0.23892033100128174,
-0.18943512439727783,
0.27275291085243225,
0.5567435026168823,
-0.21476410329341888,
0.2978680729866028,
0.286706805229187,
-0.29365038871765137,
0.013665092177689075,
-0.50300133228302,
-0.8659161329269409,
1.2510566711425781,
0.3198210597038269,
0.4451649785041809,
0.8769306540489197,
0.9311863780021667,
0.5616666078567505,
0.641875684261322,
-0.835578203201294,
0.7325121164321899,
0.10733216255903244,
-0.763142466545105,
-0.22026978433132172,
-0.13844187557697296,
-1.0981519222259521,
0.14365343749523163,
-0.11540509760379791,
-0.5062796473503113,
0.19616259634494781,
0.006831307429820299,
-0.595289945602417,
0.35844871401786804,
-0.18886670470237732,
0.4511067867279053,
-0.39403507113456726,
-0.41243240237236023,
-0.3565045893192291,
-0.5846482515335083,
0.1301262229681015,
-0.014238218776881695,
0.5000209808349609,
-0.15111379325389862,
-0.4551190435886383,
0.8137367367744446,
-0.844846785068512,
0.5187727212905884,
-0.21200798451900482,
-0.1643713265657425,
0.8634186387062073,
0.49542349576950073,
-0.09571101516485214,
-0.12433384358882904,
-0.07937969267368317,
0.21239271759986877,
0.5987207293510437,
-0.7303289771080017,
-0.3578609824180603,
0.6699583530426025,
-0.9939070343971252,
-0.12456512451171875,
-0.7778273224830627,
-0.5233620405197144,
-0.20314380526542664,
0.24571651220321655,
-0.14116398990154266,
0.6755428314208984,
-0.5832277536392212,
0.3595067858695984,
0.06153625249862671,
-0.48566892743110657,
0.33892664313316345,
0.37395450472831726,
-0.6290512681007385,
-0.6716180443763733,
0.9488365650177002,
0.09381697326898575,
-0.027518924325704575,
0.3908386826515198,
-0.07369302213191986,
-0.31238314509391785,
-0.8630555868148804,
-0.6789090037345886,
0.36768263578414917,
-0.5992785096168518,
-0.2608042061328888,
-0.21411697566509247,
-0.3433557450771332,
-0.19804854691028595,
0.12110123038291931,
-0.3947645127773285,
-0.5694459676742554,
0.027923395857214928,
0.042695824056863785,
0.2767656147480011,
1.053208351135254,
-0.06748000532388687,
0.5586519837379456,
-1.2800371646881104,
0.36249828338623047,
0.18892881274223328,
0.24193890392780304,
-0.15269342064857483,
-0.2799273431301117,
-0.42911460995674133,
0.1265830397605896,
-0.44340890645980835,
-1.443582534790039,
0.8621466159820557,
0.5926215052604675,
0.1639639437198639,
0.8376711010932922,
-0.0526050440967083,
0.26818951964378357,
-0.29047903418540955,
0.8090566992759705,
0.1591528058052063,
-0.8371061086654663,
0.20374877750873566,
-0.4460946321487427,
0.39938610792160034,
0.6285181045532227,
0.9050147533416748,
-0.4416719079017639,
-0.15431824326515198,
-0.49115291237831116,
-0.6627450585365295,
0.34338822960853577,
0.6066676378250122,
-0.05220117047429085,
-0.34659677743911743,
0.28429487347602844,
0.18857423961162567,
0.6648188829421997,
-0.10573684424161911,
-0.38764074444770813,
-0.11604835093021393,
-0.6059377193450928,
0.09372086822986603,
-0.6186199188232422,
-0.07680488377809525,
-0.12419544905424118,
0.7419424653053284,
-0.024967757984995842,
0.0657949224114418,
0.10191074758768082,
-0.3000045418739319,
-0.04436288774013519,
0.38001206517219543,
0.6330406069755554,
0.9187713265419006,
-0.4514114558696747,
0.3275097608566284,
-0.23782780766487122,
-0.7919961214065552,
0.044980283826589584,
-0.3379743993282318,
-0.46835723519325256,
0.6475479602813721,
0.17784683406352997,
0.43445441126823425,
-0.06803081929683685,
-1.1080689430236816,
0.20171111822128296,
0.016329098492860794,
-0.09964679926633835,
-0.5593250393867493,
-0.3251863420009613,
0.6370226740837097,
0.10351673513650894,
0.5377967953681946,
-0.014151905663311481,
0.08495307713747025,
-0.8200830817222595,
0.1296289563179016,
0.419929176568985,
0.043409500271081924,
-0.32703620195388794,
0.3014974892139435,
0.15032438933849335,
-0.42938432097435,
0.4147360622882843,
-0.4964241683483124,
-0.45878803730010986,
0.47824329137802124,
0.3471589684486389,
0.5048081874847412,
-0.5752689242362976,
0.36175239086151123,
0.7404398322105408,
0.2671777009963989,
0.1317732036113739,
0.6940664052963257,
-0.20506519079208374,
-0.7546476125717163,
0.0068221199326217175,
-0.8812825679779053,
-0.8436251878738403,
-0.11313597112894058,
-0.48530733585357666,
0.04275248199701309,
-0.673085629940033,
-0.2195025086402893,
-0.028581907972693443,
-0.190755233168602,
-0.5823139548301697,
0.31321394443511963,
0.31972241401672363,
0.9559057950973511,
-0.3994019627571106,
1.0048577785491943,
0.7369782328605652,
-0.29748794436454773,
-0.4102749526500702,
-0.34712719917297363,
-0.056090548634529114,
-1.1795161962509155,
0.676278293132782,
-0.13908393681049347,
-0.4420449137687683,
-0.0176492128521204,
-0.5469475388526917,
-1.0824198722839355,
0.7747572660446167,
0.3797689974308014,
-1.0005892515182495,
-0.2246670126914978,
0.5045758485794067,
0.6760888695716858,
-0.28748801350593567,
0.38420894742012024,
0.46438634395599365,
0.17646090686321259,
-0.09389767050743103,
-0.7733246088027954,
0.09387392550706863,
-0.3525391221046448,
-0.16401700675487518,
0.4899632930755615,
-0.25822120904922485,
0.761143684387207,
-0.3717677593231201,
-0.6447919607162476,
0.6832713484764099,
0.8722115159034729,
0.12231285870075226,
0.18506623804569244,
0.147305428981781,
0.758456289768219,
0.7736549973487854,
0.044145382940769196,
0.9334139823913574,
-0.9040494561195374,
0.021474838256835938,
1.217315912246704,
-0.10008329898118973,
1.0107008218765259,
0.41392093896865845,
-0.5927115678787231,
0.896081268787384,
0.5282378792762756,
0.4908287823200226,
0.4582814574241638,
0.15074175596237183,
-0.6128681898117065,
0.13676664233207703,
-0.5010004043579102,
-0.7684491872787476,
0.2824506163597107,
1.0359382629394531,
-0.47402387857437134,
-0.4056045711040497,
-0.7966046929359436,
-0.0716712698340416,
0.04707865044474602,
-0.2944643795490265,
0.3976369798183441,
0.19502384960651398,
-0.482059508562088,
0.8553413152694702,
0.2031046450138092,
0.162502259016037,
-0.8080958724021912,
-0.08070535957813263,
-0.2497340887784958,
-0.031053680926561356,
-0.6558513045310974,
-0.828923225402832,
0.40283581614494324,
-0.16213177144527435,
0.6249844431877136,
0.19011932611465454,
0.5250260829925537,
-0.5043409466743469,
-0.3205644488334656,
0.06865168362855911,
0.9272851943969727,
0.33889883756637573,
-0.13386808335781097,
-0.3553098142147064,
-0.05272376164793968,
-0.1910277009010315,
-0.04402245581150055,
0.5500134825706482,
0.41615721583366394,
-0.12594808638095856,
0.5279365181922913,
0.5501983761787415,
0.26433539390563965,
0.014860699884593487,
-0.10613216459751129,
0.909342348575592,
-0.9293585419654846,
-0.535881519317627,
-0.7297472357749939,
0.006774023175239563,
0.28516891598701477,
-0.387329638004303,
0.585466206073761,
0.4782406985759735,
0.8173012733459473,
-0.04804321750998497,
0.9374772310256958,
-0.16576801240444183,
0.5160602331161499,
-0.2573019564151764,
0.5933274626731873,
-0.6238301396369934,
0.16392236948013306,
0.0725473165512085,
-1.005519151687622,
-0.15502381324768066,
0.6596816182136536,
-0.019019240513443947,
-0.2159326821565628,
0.7072223424911499,
0.9758239984512329,
0.36231812834739685,
0.10657516866922379,
0.24322812259197235,
0.1440243422985077,
-0.13922956585884094,
0.5833418369293213,
0.8903065919876099,
-0.31284841895103455,
0.5075740814208984,
-0.21315601468086243,
-0.06446368247270584,
-0.2870056927204132,
-0.5825419425964355,
-0.6085523366928101,
-0.7356491088867188,
-0.174902081489563,
-0.42821204662323,
0.3239894509315491,
1.3367815017700195,
0.05671284720301628,
-1.1676568984985352,
-0.5081322193145752,
0.10548297315835953,
0.004744398407638073,
0.03551897034049034,
-0.0891285315155983,
0.5758118629455566,
0.07317495346069336,
-0.445425808429718,
0.36099115014076233,
0.36322468519210815,
-0.16310282051563263,
-0.23877696692943573,
-0.16347414255142212,
-0.30931881070137024,
-0.028777534142136574,
0.434167742729187,
0.49750301241874695,
-0.44453948736190796,
0.02173595502972603,
-0.22074264287948608,
-0.5400848984718323,
0.254282146692276,
0.5993420481681824,
-0.7727572917938232,
0.3380865156650543,
0.48813489079475403,
0.6906490325927734,
0.1617904156446457,
-0.1109631359577179,
0.16397087275981903,
-0.5001227855682373,
0.33386072516441345,
0.4874795377254486,
0.5073298811912537,
0.3165399134159088,
0.16416329145431519,
0.45717185735702515,
0.08314249664545059,
-0.22972841560840607,
-0.6101190447807312,
0.4708195626735687,
-0.8173983097076416,
-0.2605387568473816,
0.7189251780509949,
-0.1126396581530571,
-0.2561095356941223,
-0.12581904232501984,
-0.581128716468811,
0.18126437067985535,
-0.5182604193687439,
0.751063346862793,
0.35976773500442505,
0.229622021317482,
0.057016681879758835,
-0.42146962881088257,
0.772627055644989,
0.6709113717079163,
-0.6646022796630859,
-0.6633018255233765,
0.6730321049690247,
0.27734869718551636,
0.4949783682823181,
0.850844144821167,
-0.3653140366077423,
0.48013976216316223,
0.10264397412538528,
0.505490779876709,
-0.043853629380464554,
-0.36373287439346313,
0.14646509289741516,
0.5702427625656128,
0.6191479563713074,
-0.34338364005088806
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.03882v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.03882v1
|
Spontaneous Speech-Based Suicide Risk Detection Using Whisper and Large Language Models
| 2024-06-06T09:21:13 | 2024-06-06T09:21:13 |
Ziyun Cui, Chang Lei, Wen Wu, Yinan Duan, Diyang Qu, Ji Wu, Runsen Chen, Chao Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
The early detection of suicide risk is important since it enables the
intervention to prevent potential suicide attempts. This paper studies the
automatic detection of suicide risk based on spontaneous speech from
adolescents, and collects a Mandarin dataset with 15 hours of suicide speech
from more than a thousand adolescents aged from ten to eighteen for our
experiments. To leverage the diverse acoustic and linguistic features embedded
in spontaneous speech, both the Whisper speech model and textual large language
models (LLMs) are used for suicide risk detection. Both all-parameter
finetuning and parameter-efficient finetuning approaches are used to adapt the
pre-trained models for suicide risk detection, and multiple audio-text fusion
approaches are evaluated to combine the representations of Whisper and the LLM.
The proposed system achieves a detection accuracy of 0.807 and an F1-score of
0.846 on the test set with 119 subjects, indicating promising potential for
real suicide risk detection applications.
|
[
0.13399097323417664,
-0.8626083731651306,
0.780116081237793,
0.5786364078521729,
-0.026839209720492363,
-0.16928623616695404,
-0.3071558475494385,
-0.25569602847099304,
-0.10936716198921204,
-0.024208975955843925,
-0.7299527525901794,
-0.5064647197723389,
-0.23951493203639984,
0.029455335810780525,
-0.530375599861145,
0.41253501176834106,
0.3194849491119385,
0.17247045040130615,
0.5573113560676575,
0.30528905987739563,
-0.42733633518218994,
-0.13182984292507172,
-1.1618698835372925,
0.24951736629009247,
0.6870430707931519,
0.32973146438598633,
0.506279468536377,
0.08019404113292694,
-0.08081188052892685,
0.2979171872138977,
-0.2102416753768921,
-0.17404994368553162,
-0.3164041340351105,
0.11351589113473892,
0.2398451566696167,
-0.47469425201416016,
-0.2807801067829132,
0.131867453455925,
0.7766920328140259,
0.13426019251346588,
-0.3373945951461792,
0.011856148019433022,
0.046948377043008804,
0.34743306040763855,
-0.5195695757865906,
-0.12370225787162781,
-0.6124384999275208,
0.34606072306632996,
-0.29209545254707336,
0.1849171668291092,
-0.4887197017669678,
-0.545570969581604,
0.054274436086416245,
-0.27189120650291443,
-0.13965152204036713,
-0.25662508606910706,
0.20101113617420197,
0.19894619286060333,
-0.3360699713230133,
-0.3230815529823303,
-0.8629193305969238,
0.7861745953559875,
-0.8877385854721069,
0.4805581867694855,
0.27338263392448425,
0.2895528972148895,
-0.14871016144752502,
-0.3523431420326233,
-0.7355724573135376,
-0.5051526427268982,
0.04835237190127373,
0.18535684049129486,
-0.17232681810855865,
0.47000589966773987,
-0.04915181174874306,
0.437023401260376,
-0.9112367033958435,
0.5376420617103577,
-0.06223388388752937,
-0.6328570246696472,
0.8477932810783386,
0.2335139513015747,
0.6873459219932556,
-0.5865839719772339,
-0.2871207594871521,
0.046619366854429245,
-0.3512258529663086,
0.03981846198439598,
0.6685277223587036,
0.518210768699646,
-0.1901029497385025,
0.4194830656051636,
-0.1614956557750702,
0.7847248315811157,
-0.2659013271331787,
-0.7898567318916321,
0.2677834630012512,
-0.07566099613904953,
-0.10356983542442322,
0.5195088386535645,
1.13005530834198,
0.17023253440856934,
0.28452086448669434,
0.25739869475364685,
-0.21406598389148712,
-0.061562925577163696,
-0.1316048502922058,
-0.4068555533885956,
-0.08622335642576218,
0.27408015727996826,
-0.6714004874229431,
-0.3979989290237427,
-0.4634900987148285,
-0.3496992588043213,
-0.42665043473243713,
-0.2416837364435196,
0.7227248549461365,
-0.7034913897514343,
-0.42596670985221863,
0.11792155355215073,
-0.07009797543287277,
0.0317358672618866,
0.27870699763298035,
-0.31229618191719055,
-0.03989892452955246,
0.37636637687683105,
1.1910336017608643,
-0.31510448455810547,
-0.07680216431617737,
-0.5184332728385925,
-0.0961015447974205,
-0.172233447432518,
0.8078592419624329,
-0.042240507900714874,
-0.3339478075504303,
0.06340320408344269,
0.03729678690433502,
-0.11713622510433197,
-0.38088327646255493,
1.1754155158996582,
0.1324733942747116,
0.03424941375851631,
0.22671054303646088,
-0.5464990139007568,
-0.07864255458116531,
-0.11160540580749512,
-0.5042340755462646,
0.8397607803344727,
-0.3162933886051178,
-0.45437541604042053,
0.3995489478111267,
-0.3032447397708893,
-0.5212281942367554,
0.3754063844680786,
-0.07148806750774384,
-0.5253234505653381,
-0.19470641016960144,
0.10713691264390945,
1.0475739240646362,
0.08430785685777664,
0.580531120300293,
-0.1700749546289444,
-0.23391039669513702,
0.4383334815502167,
-1.0653259754180908,
0.8096680641174316,
0.275437593460083,
-0.0024824319407343864,
0.09431902319192886,
-0.4537947177886963,
0.22467586398124695,
-0.023455528542399406,
-0.18616995215415955,
-0.2873488962650299,
0.15506897866725922,
0.43465182185173035,
0.30112677812576294,
0.30292725563049316,
-0.5710554718971252,
-0.13036170601844788,
-0.4929400384426117,
0.30189022421836853,
0.5213322639465332,
0.3582661747932434,
0.03710757568478584,
-0.40151718258857727,
0.409510999917984,
0.12634703516960144,
0.5035053491592407,
-0.2202824503183365,
-0.6319891214370728,
-0.14137543737888336,
-0.7950741648674011,
-0.24454723298549652,
1.0872225761413574,
-0.2850837707519531,
0.7167971730232239,
0.3621285557746887,
-0.7493342161178589,
-0.18160808086395264,
-0.10469373315572739,
0.23025132715702057,
0.42403048276901245,
0.3489120304584503,
0.37225237488746643,
-0.8527246117591858,
-0.8461673259735107,
-0.5998054146766663,
-0.4510360062122345,
-0.17830869555473328,
0.061840321868658066,
-0.052641451358795166,
0.14176449179649353,
0.7775653600692749,
-0.9329851269721985,
-0.8545545935630798,
-0.5941706895828247,
0.1290016919374466,
0.46880975365638733,
0.388553649187088,
0.2806279957294464,
-1.00867760181427,
-0.5631988048553467,
-0.39583003520965576,
-0.8630499243736267,
0.03483325242996216,
-0.4026513397693634,
0.44934728741645813,
-0.29994234442710876,
0.4678792357444763,
-0.4211343824863434,
0.6548552513122559,
0.24783743917942047,
0.23755009472370148,
0.6862637400627136,
-0.024516478180885315,
-0.030969934538006783,
-0.9756473302841187,
-0.35605087876319885,
0.2094009816646576,
-0.19697685539722443,
-1.062686562538147,
-0.4602237641811371,
-0.12985444068908691,
-0.4260282516479492,
-0.8532716631889343,
0.4678003787994385,
-0.4567511975765228,
0.44335296750068665,
-0.3242526352405548,
0.20838767290115356,
-0.6574912667274475,
-0.005878634750843048,
0.1796458214521408,
0.7392940521240234,
0.566582441329956,
-0.6578313708305359,
0.12236397713422775,
0.2793194651603699,
-0.4381968080997467,
0.487703800201416,
-0.5643879771232605,
-0.1937987208366394,
-0.09731650352478027,
0.4153502583503723,
-1.0030972957611084,
-0.5709734559059143,
0.1326889544725418,
-0.5124158263206482,
-0.08423380553722382,
-0.12848103046417236,
-0.3791457712650299,
-0.4177894592285156,
-0.3010329604148865,
0.18296997249126434,
0.47287797927856445,
0.0942218154668808,
0.4681074023246765,
0.5543758273124695,
-0.6493218541145325,
-0.22096402943134308,
-0.47944948077201843,
0.13542082905769348,
-0.34065160155296326,
-0.5554381012916565,
0.1708175539970398,
-0.016978487372398376,
0.022610096260905266,
-0.25514042377471924,
0.2502230405807495,
-0.2348490059375763,
0.0958641991019249,
0.7361917495727539,
0.3111117482185364,
-0.2741190493106842,
0.40692055225372314,
0.5160250663757324,
-0.15323156118392944,
-0.2441762089729309,
-0.22177724540233612,
0.5639044046401978,
-0.0075651612132787704,
-0.18946509063243866,
-0.89878910779953,
0.3756747245788574,
0.39282673597335815,
0.2789337933063507,
0.9943177103996277,
0.5139473080635071,
-0.7524350881576538,
-0.3531351685523987,
-0.6332936882972717,
-0.03760094568133354,
-0.4805122911930084,
0.03380342945456505,
0.2217208594083786,
-0.8133602142333984,
0.509068489074707,
-0.06157011166214943,
-0.43803128600120544,
0.15650391578674316,
0.6404925584793091,
-0.09361983835697174,
0.9379278421401978,
0.5029842853546143,
-0.4100120961666107,
0.4271007478237152,
0.0850948691368103,
0.3680950999259949,
-0.43791621923446655,
0.016912251710891724,
-0.3179846704006195,
0.007474089972674847,
-0.2033219337463379,
-0.0909561887383461,
0.9731589555740356,
0.1231749951839447,
-0.20196500420570374,
0.2399132251739502,
-0.5551117062568665,
0.5487384796142578,
0.11612594127655029,
0.15941134095191956,
0.4070175588130951,
-0.29675281047821045,
-0.08874371647834778,
-0.28087326884269714,
-0.3744519352912903,
-0.45391225814819336,
0.7137466073036194,
0.11584381759166718,
0.6542210578918457,
0.03544166684150696,
0.7529081702232361,
0.5628923773765564,
0.3791334331035614,
-0.8469780683517456,
0.5746567249298096,
-0.25846362113952637,
-0.6844484806060791,
-0.7910716533660889,
-0.2986898124217987,
-0.48134279251098633,
-0.05177668482065201,
-0.20252510905265808,
-0.9866873025894165,
0.18820388615131378,
0.007889830507338047,
-0.8524145483970642,
0.03688632696866989,
-0.6082305312156677,
0.5740820169448853,
-0.2163107991218567,
0.17402012646198273,
-0.02251562289893627,
-0.4409376084804535,
0.8895322680473328,
-0.32478684186935425,
0.30549556016921997,
-0.5739275217056274,
0.26194682717323303,
0.7941557168960571,
-0.46000897884368896,
0.9834414124488831,
-0.2983519732952118,
-0.1981886625289917,
0.5324109792709351,
0.0016572941094636917,
0.4555374085903168,
0.27511125802993774,
-0.3313027620315552,
-0.13959194719791412,
-0.23147794604301453,
0.18608269095420837,
-0.18457530438899994,
0.8655804991722107,
-0.5431984066963196,
-0.24876613914966583,
-0.38731124997138977,
-0.2849139869213104,
-0.12945199012756348,
0.4126143455505371,
0.5451015830039978,
0.4141320586204529,
-0.5075749158859253,
-0.1306644231081009,
0.5138380527496338,
-0.5227205753326416,
0.6919728517532349,
0.6261582374572754,
-0.4256795048713684,
-0.6671854257583618,
1.0240858793258667,
0.3834957480430603,
0.17991268634796143,
0.10993633419275284,
0.4775533676147461,
-0.47498151659965515,
-0.36377617716789246,
-0.16796661913394928,
0.37011289596557617,
-0.576645016670227,
-0.30733850598335266,
-1.0278946161270142,
-0.6427216529846191,
-0.5117089152336121,
-0.242869034409523,
-0.13568636775016785,
-0.07874385267496109,
-0.4862922728061676,
-0.23161961138248444,
0.49302664399147034,
0.4532744586467743,
-0.5761900544166565,
0.39248642325401306,
-1.0842921733856201,
0.632142186164856,
0.4539662301540375,
-0.1549018770456314,
0.26851382851600647,
-0.39082232117652893,
0.10148398578166962,
0.057155415415763855,
-0.11731655150651932,
-1.1493316888809204,
0.5141533613204956,
0.6359878182411194,
0.41651424765586853,
0.6421083211898804,
0.5039342641830444,
0.42895835638046265,
-0.5043247938156128,
0.8403105735778809,
0.2537652850151062,
-0.989078938961029,
0.7576321363449097,
-0.7216139435768127,
0.16699762642383575,
0.6903175711631775,
0.7899749875068665,
-1.1219629049301147,
-0.5195532441139221,
-0.4788459241390228,
-0.6493374109268188,
0.6145418286323547,
0.403283029794693,
-0.09115570038557053,
0.1337457299232483,
0.02117803506553173,
-0.02389315329492092,
0.06196507066488266,
-0.6802645325660706,
-0.35205864906311035,
0.15362873673439026,
-0.5864713191986084,
-0.02568674087524414,
-0.06264709681272507,
0.06533262133598328,
-0.3800981342792511,
0.4736507833003998,
-0.040994077920913696,
0.3497059941291809,
0.2546265721321106,
-0.06995924562215805,
-0.11989317089319229,
0.1432364135980606,
0.5604748725891113,
-0.07000971585512161,
-0.07600149512290955,
-0.18795304000377655,
0.35923871397972107,
-0.7582163214683533,
0.873269259929657,
-0.004161597229540348,
-0.24375919997692108,
0.07644851505756378,
0.5473394393920898,
0.6422964930534363,
0.34910276532173157,
-0.9638211131095886,
0.9386240243911743,
-0.1666102260351181,
0.013710501603782177,
-1.0095906257629395,
0.3049015998840332,
0.1731606274843216,
-0.13312478363513947,
0.7316122651100159,
-0.12318306416273117,
0.40104013681411743,
-0.29709890484809875,
0.43761712312698364,
0.26400575041770935,
-0.43142515420913696,
-0.34481382369995117,
0.48911890387535095,
-0.08388389647006989,
-0.4596933424472809,
0.3040318191051483,
-0.29751667380332947,
-0.8525260090827942,
0.38054972887039185,
0.374793142080307,
1.1677979230880737,
-0.7506586909294128,
0.7831248044967651,
0.2770515978336334,
0.3106113374233246,
-0.18645258247852325,
0.40195420384407043,
0.05349857360124588,
-0.7434033751487732,
-0.5022500157356262,
-0.76645427942276,
-0.2390040159225464,
0.40491533279418945,
-0.6665087342262268,
0.4417223334312439,
-0.6379634141921997,
0.18895934522151947,
0.09347189217805862,
-0.38878291845321655,
-0.1954418569803238,
0.4050891101360321,
0.5803265571594238,
0.7993372678756714,
-1.2488973140716553,
0.3316573202610016,
0.1778818964958191,
-0.1562495231628418,
-1.1471209526062012,
0.40965718030929565,
0.46479880809783936,
-0.48490557074546814,
0.6154534816741943,
0.5242099761962891,
-0.07437584549188614,
0.03685569018125534,
-0.5782392024993896,
-0.8317498564720154,
0.6029388308525085,
0.2834465205669403,
-0.6569699645042419,
-0.05905846506357193,
0.31237146258354187,
0.5398095846176147,
0.04546158015727997,
0.2469378113746643,
0.3883019983768463,
0.5222018957138062,
0.03706069663167,
-0.988440990447998,
-0.19776198267936707,
0.35472846031188965,
-0.24949096143245697,
0.4045267105102539,
-0.6324745416641235,
0.8051630258560181,
0.04083908349275589,
-0.605511486530304,
0.14384524524211884,
0.9507907032966614,
0.28502601385116577,
0.5036213397979736,
0.7499257326126099,
0.37830814719200134,
0.8488179445266724,
0.2561866044998169,
0.478838711977005,
0.1525937169790268,
0.12993784248828888,
0.7458385825157166,
-0.5155938267707825,
1.0012314319610596,
-0.3855220377445221,
-0.13259701430797577,
0.16401070356369019,
0.42566755414009094,
0.5512056946754456,
0.434524267911911,
0.06925742328166962,
-0.9295516610145569,
-0.5069695115089417,
-0.04829997196793556,
-0.05907222628593445,
0.3762595057487488,
0.8181660175323486,
-0.22107285261154175,
-0.299140065908432,
0.912969172000885,
0.10721330344676971,
-0.15345485508441925,
-0.24355167150497437,
0.7963087558746338,
0.4775632321834564,
-0.28614330291748047,
0.5714099407196045,
-0.21729038655757904,
0.7095246315002441,
-0.49739035964012146,
0.0966886356472969,
0.11489708721637726,
0.19477146863937378,
-0.15872375667095184,
-0.7936382293701172,
0.2561957538127899,
0.20408914983272552,
0.03405958041548729,
-0.1088276356458664,
1.151971697807312,
-0.45323705673217773,
-0.70196533203125,
0.15203747153282166,
0.26695120334625244,
0.16078849136829376,
-0.479036420583725,
-0.8127949237823486,
0.08594097197055817,
-0.12131167203187943,
-0.044879935681819916,
0.20084591209888458,
0.3024125099182129,
0.10399547219276428,
0.7755966782569885,
0.8782685995101929,
0.38855603337287903,
0.19675663113594055,
-0.27191323041915894,
0.6844724416732788,
-0.5741316080093384,
-0.7371301054954529,
-0.777484655380249,
0.34069299697875977,
0.013809697702527046,
-0.62613445520401,
0.8267152309417725,
0.4303276836872101,
0.19095554947853088,
-0.1753867268562317,
0.8328998684883118,
0.04037529230117798,
0.943663477897644,
-0.7648926377296448,
1.2300220727920532,
-0.31896278262138367,
-0.3030182421207428,
-0.47647276520729065,
-0.8353279232978821,
-0.39534491300582886,
0.5310197472572327,
-0.36455249786376953,
-0.2765403687953949,
0.4791959524154663,
0.808502197265625,
0.24802081286907196,
0.10297740995883942,
0.4429171681404114,
0.42035800218582153,
0.369690477848053,
0.32625359296798706,
1.040978193283081,
-0.37186846137046814,
0.0016800271114334464,
-0.0337454155087471,
-0.32041558623313904,
-0.2761728763580322,
-0.8380124568939209,
-0.674559473991394,
-0.8422961831092834,
-0.2768324911594391,
0.15821127593517303,
-0.13909050822257996,
0.8032965064048767,
0.5318372845649719,
-0.5025776028633118,
-0.026769278571009636,
0.052386678755283356,
-0.07135938107967377,
-0.21213552355766296,
-0.27406832575798035,
0.204506054520607,
0.2043953537940979,
-0.22114267945289612,
1.137756109237671,
0.3572365641593933,
0.3763231635093689,
-0.41722768545150757,
0.18875829875469208,
-0.29474735260009766,
0.23427130281925201,
0.40026187896728516,
0.4299444854259491,
-0.6502629518508911,
-0.25556278228759766,
-0.2428794652223587,
-0.09066372364759445,
-0.39988717436790466,
0.6632006764411926,
-0.7675140500068665,
-0.27442753314971924,
0.5004730820655823,
0.05746854469180107,
-0.08083891868591309,
-0.21597029268741608,
0.2748219072818756,
-0.6675248742103577,
0.5446545481681824,
0.5738894939422607,
-0.034680478274822235,
0.32623744010925293,
-0.9173912405967712,
-0.1159418374300003,
0.19408336281776428,
-0.5434474349021912,
-1.2241355180740356,
0.17503872513771057,
-0.7911667227745056,
-0.021552961319684982,
0.809339702129364,
-0.05971412733197212,
-0.29389524459838867,
-0.3580511212348938,
-0.4957631230354309,
0.3117295801639557,
-0.4471646547317505,
0.16268469393253326,
0.342751681804657,
0.02536766603589058,
0.05602381378412247,
-0.2944331169128418,
0.8226075768470764,
0.06770138442516327,
-0.6175915002822876,
0.086238794028759,
0.22083230316638947,
0.02439621090888977,
0.1892601102590561,
0.5489996671676636,
0.3532848656177521,
0.3485093414783478,
-0.2905864417552948,
-0.1424214392900467,
0.2121807336807251,
-0.5740389823913574,
-0.5291514992713928,
0.21898721158504486,
-0.21375004947185516,
0.12699857354164124
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.03881v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.03881v1
|
Evaluating the IWSLT2023 Speech Translation Tasks: Human Annotations, Automatic Metrics, and Segmentation
| 2024-06-06T09:18:42 | 2024-06-06T09:18:42 |
Matthias Sperber, Ondřej Bojar, Barry Haddow, Dávid Javorský, Xutai Ma, Matteo Negri, Jan Niehues, Peter Polák, Elizabeth Salesky, Katsuhito Sudoh, Marco Turchi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Human evaluation is a critical component in machine translation system
development and has received much attention in text translation research.
However, little prior work exists on the topic of human evaluation for speech
translation, which adds additional challenges such as noisy data and
segmentation mismatches. We take first steps to fill this gap by conducting a
comprehensive human evaluation of the results of several shared tasks from the
last International Workshop on Spoken Language Translation (IWSLT 2023). We
propose an effective evaluation strategy based on automatic resegmentation and
direct assessment with segment context. Our analysis revealed that: 1) the
proposed evaluation strategy is robust and scores well-correlated with other
types of human judgements; 2) automatic metrics are usually, but not always,
well-correlated with direct assessment scores; and 3) COMET as a slightly
stronger automatic metric than chrF, despite the segmentation noise introduced
by the resegmentation step systems. We release the collected human-annotated
data in order to encourage further investigation.
|
[
-0.38380327820777893,
-0.2096756398677826,
0.3811504542827606,
0.5908550024032593,
-0.44572821259498596,
0.3655567169189453,
-0.4257824122905731,
-0.5644640922546387,
-0.29454901814460754,
0.30722782015800476,
-0.6831430196762085,
-0.3556974530220032,
-0.6670625805854797,
0.3931083083152771,
-0.7494715452194214,
0.680343747138977,
-0.08000434935092926,
0.28722164034843445,
-0.2530549466609955,
-0.1413000375032425,
-0.6161491870880127,
-0.33997946977615356,
-0.4282938838005066,
-0.4325103461742401,
0.37707197666168213,
0.35124388337135315,
0.31311964988708496,
0.6392953395843506,
0.8604885339736938,
0.3230656087398529,
0.02920590713620186,
0.08806563913822174,
-0.1166338175535202,
0.028140608221292496,
-0.2905047535896301,
0.04027846083045006,
-0.3012489974498749,
0.06676305085420609,
0.8905039429664612,
0.9692283272743225,
0.1414317488670349,
0.3613855540752411,
0.1572125256061554,
0.5135940909385681,
-0.29926416277885437,
0.019360270351171494,
-0.45112237334251404,
0.23649020493030548,
-0.44409817457199097,
-0.18817195296287537,
-0.4077583849430084,
-0.10109502077102661,
0.4209643602371216,
-0.22293712198734283,
-0.09150160104036331,
0.1889546513557434,
0.6332570910453796,
0.5315066576004028,
-0.4850139021873474,
-0.0022990235593169928,
-0.6527950763702393,
1.0264910459518433,
-0.47139689326286316,
0.6411835551261902,
0.345478355884552,
0.22700569033622742,
-0.2166767418384552,
-0.6283115148544312,
-0.1518755555152893,
-0.24242350459098816,
0.01095966063439846,
0.10457822680473328,
-0.520189642906189,
-0.0869777724146843,
-0.045956939458847046,
0.22692963480949402,
-0.4967779517173767,
0.17161671817302704,
-0.4921593964099884,
-0.5870060920715332,
1.011098861694336,
0.23802949488162994,
0.31202876567840576,
-0.22791557013988495,
-0.49459269642829895,
-0.20468491315841675,
-0.028576934710144997,
-0.1980714201927185,
0.41448351740837097,
0.4165283143520355,
-0.11474324762821198,
0.36131733655929565,
-0.46453577280044556,
0.7204688787460327,
-0.07347016036510468,
0.05731261894106865,
0.5729252099990845,
-0.8040356636047363,
0.07998006045818329,
0.12944717705249786,
1.1753957271575928,
0.4467870891094208,
0.1362161636352539,
-0.48555296659469604,
-0.33119308948516846,
-0.3175676465034485,
0.47634267807006836,
-0.4868796169757843,
0.09029053896665573,
0.06362012028694153,
-0.4419851005077362,
-0.39588430523872375,
0.062169481068849564,
-0.5345051884651184,
-0.15525919198989868,
-0.45101067423820496,
0.4511893689632416,
-0.27878421545028687,
-0.08067286759614944,
-0.2277267873287201,
-0.01870877854526043,
0.10997062921524048,
0.4133022725582123,
-0.6208352446556091,
0.5853445529937744,
0.7035325169563293,
0.6185538172721863,
-0.6737476587295532,
-0.48326900601387024,
-0.7116755843162537,
-0.30064547061920166,
-0.24664460122585297,
0.7296894192695618,
-0.11458808183670044,
-0.33086758852005005,
-0.3774595558643341,
0.02852255292236805,
-0.23719553649425507,
-0.5632020235061646,
1.067962408065796,
-0.23393189907073975,
0.2722061276435852,
-0.22210197150707245,
-0.5111918449401855,
-0.0883597806096077,
0.15193171799182892,
-0.28025761246681213,
0.9018816947937012,
0.27173012495040894,
-0.6786298751831055,
0.36305925250053406,
-0.8698147535324097,
-0.5852584838867188,
0.27485930919647217,
0.06853967159986496,
-0.2839944362640381,
0.011789817363023758,
0.21008364856243134,
0.25551697611808777,
-0.3356536030769348,
0.18516460061073303,
0.2956736087799072,
-0.4987225830554962,
0.42214512825012207,
-0.48279333114624023,
0.7147417664527893,
0.33246874809265137,
-0.5049189925193787,
0.5244657397270203,
-0.49481287598609924,
0.08841780573129654,
-0.024912966415286064,
-0.4863322079181671,
0.03354521468281746,
-0.13046586513519287,
0.3293043375015259,
-0.08759316056966782,
0.23876740038394928,
-0.6553687453269958,
-0.06849398463964462,
-0.2989291548728943,
0.3852309584617615,
0.4606911540031433,
0.1545448899269104,
0.5282569527626038,
-0.0032542243134230375,
0.419010728597641,
-0.07897088676691055,
0.24980366230010986,
0.13496606051921844,
-0.6619970202445984,
-0.511193037033081,
0.11385379731655121,
0.6450388431549072,
0.6448489427566528,
-0.310005247592926,
0.8330121040344238,
-0.3392101228237152,
-0.5717000961303711,
-0.7045510411262512,
-0.103469118475914,
0.5764107704162598,
0.6702907085418701,
0.5231239795684814,
-0.6540814638137817,
-0.5645655989646912,
-0.9615100622177124,
-0.3552599251270294,
-0.1474057137966156,
-0.16486352682113647,
-0.2022833228111267,
0.38258808851242065,
-0.45080986618995667,
0.8289632201194763,
-0.09246648848056793,
-0.39846205711364746,
-0.06542090326547623,
0.3601243793964386,
-0.13466717302799225,
0.7774305939674377,
0.12800709903240204,
-0.669307291507721,
-0.2724813222885132,
0.09439405798912048,
-0.23325607180595398,
-0.2772563397884369,
-0.10645348578691483,
-0.09689069539308548,
-0.15784715116024017,
0.3848385810852051,
-0.14887703955173492,
0.5056850910186768,
0.47465208172798157,
-0.20898787677288055,
0.5597928762435913,
-0.09269367903470993,
0.6113936901092529,
-0.49328041076660156,
0.15132910013198853,
-0.13787147402763367,
-0.6515077948570251,
-0.48696187138557434,
-0.03094942681491375,
0.09875942766666412,
-0.07451114058494568,
-0.3460238575935364,
0.5220719575881958,
-0.21027766168117523,
-0.526116132736206,
-0.09195036441087723,
0.4683210551738739,
-0.12571310997009277,
0.15467630326747894,
-0.23629361391067505,
0.8637002110481262,
-0.04921324551105499,
-0.3826674222946167,
0.2906312346458435,
0.40094664692878723,
-0.6379728317260742,
0.5575510263442993,
-0.3854489028453827,
0.427981436252594,
0.2090999335050583,
0.1650623381137848,
-1.139080286026001,
-0.37734776735305786,
0.4606762230396271,
-0.6917117834091187,
0.23518595099449158,
0.18488860130310059,
-0.3098948895931244,
-0.3248494565486908,
0.0030539704021066427,
0.3053862154483795,
0.40991488099098206,
-0.1350516378879547,
0.1672133505344391,
0.3610379695892334,
-0.15342406928539276,
-0.21768802404403687,
-0.7238748669624329,
0.6188221573829651,
-0.2818727195262909,
-0.6468074917793274,
0.4632854461669922,
-0.08061634749174118,
-0.526830792427063,
0.018261954188346863,
-0.19168907403945923,
0.00040640876977704465,
0.34385451674461365,
-0.014727810397744179,
-0.08134029805660248,
0.07608404755592346,
-0.1506883203983307,
0.017695939168334007,
-0.33154821395874023,
-0.06992921978235245,
-0.13399282097816467,
0.525751531124115,
-0.31338217854499817,
-0.5140025615692139,
-0.8942429423332214,
0.23539605736732483,
0.44435009360313416,
-0.35733845829963684,
0.030986977741122246,
1.1639723777770996,
-0.4173099100589752,
0.4756110608577728,
-0.654201090335846,
-0.06573043018579483,
-0.32183417677879333,
0.6629947423934937,
-0.31366488337516785,
-0.5872100591659546,
0.26475775241851807,
-0.10628602653741837,
0.1379011571407318,
0.6944460272789001,
0.5564061999320984,
-0.34358832240104675,
1.106844425201416,
0.2250157743692398,
-0.0025291796773672104,
0.4447658658027649,
0.07359261065721512,
0.011596723459661007,
-1.1795612573623657,
-0.26601943373680115,
-0.6705403923988342,
-0.40382105112075806,
-0.21309404075145721,
-0.5565614700317383,
0.32814592123031616,
-0.04101664200425148,
0.11683153361082077,
0.6231393218040466,
-0.7053720951080322,
0.06416735053062439,
0.4281649887561798,
-0.13627265393733978,
0.26594069600105286,
-0.036297086626291275,
0.04096180200576782,
-0.3085630536079407,
-0.2818881869316101,
-0.5790743231773376,
0.7584303021430969,
0.4986637830734253,
0.09530968219041824,
-0.1921624094247818,
0.9205763339996338,
0.6884340047836304,
0.3024233877658844,
-0.9297630190849304,
0.5561020374298096,
-0.269441694021225,
-0.4204133152961731,
-0.6189306378364563,
-0.5133986473083496,
-1.1014835834503174,
0.532433807849884,
-0.15789756178855896,
-0.8450303077697754,
-0.08371784538030624,
-0.2490333914756775,
-0.18521319329738617,
-0.2648840546607971,
-0.7534392476081848,
0.9877362251281738,
-0.5349990725517273,
0.01004739385098219,
-0.39600053429603577,
-0.9027760624885559,
0.03731478005647659,
-0.17357008159160614,
0.4918140172958374,
-0.2937849164009094,
-0.05212482064962387,
1.2602286338806152,
-0.23767125606536865,
0.45325717329978943,
-0.29310667514801025,
0.07708202302455902,
0.19105976819992065,
-0.07397812604904175,
0.21722929179668427,
-0.48405343294143677,
-0.25589075684547424,
0.1659972071647644,
0.176815465092659,
-0.2126334309577942,
-0.3045753538608551,
0.26796814799308777,
-0.6707774996757507,
-0.37472814321517944,
-0.26954978704452515,
-0.601043164730072,
-0.43673455715179443,
0.3235833942890167,
0.24309971928596497,
0.328456312417984,
-0.46096527576446533,
0.18707606196403503,
0.05813458189368248,
0.033696647733449936,
0.3454422950744629,
0.29584798216819763,
-0.15267087519168854,
-0.7464604377746582,
0.9015296101570129,
0.002091749804094434,
0.20498433709144592,
0.10671902447938919,
0.5186958312988281,
-0.31800368428230286,
-0.8663349747657776,
-0.815001904964447,
0.04905959963798523,
-0.7046224474906921,
-0.058551378548145294,
-0.4819513261318207,
0.038704611361026764,
-0.3639427721500397,
0.12359828501939774,
-0.4488872289657593,
-0.36749276518821716,
-0.2753349840641022,
0.1485210508108139,
-0.07659702748060226,
0.7367478609085083,
-0.05262506380677223,
0.3277614712715149,
-1.0294945240020752,
0.06216981261968613,
0.011455917730927467,
-0.14999407529830933,
-0.1654835045337677,
-0.6953664422035217,
-0.3691504895687103,
0.06348904222249985,
-0.158209890127182,
-0.602379560470581,
0.09288977086544037,
0.08172202855348587,
0.5861528515815735,
-0.07243337482213974,
-0.017702456563711166,
1.037353277206421,
-0.5431775450706482,
0.8197441697120667,
0.4071767330169678,
-1.163985252380371,
0.31701451539993286,
-0.26666951179504395,
0.567150890827179,
0.9615336060523987,
-0.01476852223277092,
-0.6955559253692627,
-0.3332750201225281,
-0.47458532452583313,
-0.7961440682411194,
0.6970326900482178,
0.3806075155735016,
0.046751972287893295,
0.09624350816011429,
0.19370870292186737,
-0.06319627165794373,
0.08985986560583115,
-0.24505290389060974,
0.10573334246873856,
0.16272491216659546,
-0.213502436876297,
0.040931425988674164,
0.12015718966722488,
-0.1399763524532318,
-0.38370561599731445,
0.566922664642334,
0.018346745520830154,
0.07976752519607544,
0.418862521648407,
-0.17751549184322357,
-0.34368109703063965,
0.4156602919101715,
0.6295483112335205,
0.635135293006897,
-0.18560904264450073,
-0.14139777421951294,
0.39694270491600037,
-0.5374712347984314,
0.1451006531715393,
0.11224345862865448,
-0.1369786262512207,
-0.03845527768135071,
0.7767517566680908,
0.8116534948348999,
0.49811097979545593,
-0.5902055501937866,
0.6849649548530579,
-0.2818154990673065,
-0.22013022005558014,
-0.14196546375751495,
-0.18395859003067017,
0.05983982980251312,
0.26733773946762085,
0.46046143770217896,
0.4199085831642151,
0.3914588689804077,
-0.430400013923645,
0.3461804986000061,
0.01826779544353485,
-0.9813750982284546,
-0.3698716163635254,
0.536445140838623,
0.5215519666671753,
-0.5595796704292297,
0.5781311392784119,
-0.380878210067749,
-0.7013678550720215,
0.27827581763267517,
0.21879521012306213,
1.1606260538101196,
-0.38841456174850464,
-0.12818995118141174,
0.411624014377594,
0.5014250874519348,
0.07213462889194489,
0.07924165576696396,
-0.3208140730857849,
-0.32165005803108215,
-0.6680929660797119,
-0.8219360113143921,
-0.5502282381057739,
-0.3962472677230835,
-0.8031603693962097,
0.2847578227519989,
0.16298514604568481,
-0.4460097849369049,
-0.23591981828212738,
0.048706796020269394,
-0.6676827669143677,
0.3928828239440918,
0.23037199676036835,
0.8447343707084656,
-0.634357213973999,
0.7427887320518494,
0.707396388053894,
-0.23215875029563904,
-0.522281289100647,
0.2187059074640274,
-0.015057394281029701,
-0.6086589097976685,
0.7553629279136658,
0.003110466990619898,
-0.25032514333724976,
0.05069912597537041,
-0.042636435478925705,
-0.8797741532325745,
0.949468195438385,
0.21569697558879852,
-0.7267867922782898,
0.10721669346094131,
0.1625635176897049,
0.475620299577713,
-0.2691081464290619,
0.027105310931801796,
0.9455276131629944,
0.8941490650177002,
-0.01236471813172102,
-1.5076478719711304,
-0.053866613656282425,
0.05630510300397873,
-0.12712395191192627,
-0.009349314495921135,
-0.4063405394554138,
0.34442847967147827,
-0.020073842257261276,
-0.3094010651111603,
0.3111525774002075,
0.6307910680770874,
-0.20383410155773163,
0.2119310051202774,
1.0444260835647583,
0.22814495861530304,
0.7992075681686401,
-0.24923089146614075,
0.908847451210022,
-0.002177133457735181,
0.31554001569747925,
1.079836368560791,
-0.13538309931755066,
0.9500365257263184,
0.6603213548660278,
-0.5910362005233765,
0.11436720937490463,
0.6579351425170898,
0.05263349786400795,
0.5093436241149902,
0.41352781653404236,
-0.10470756888389587,
-0.32259973883628845,
-0.3738435208797455,
-0.13855652511119843,
0.8827008605003357,
0.22622552514076233,
-0.06501583009958267,
-0.15615226328372955,
0.1641518771648407,
-0.06592289358377457,
0.08645655959844589,
0.0632672905921936,
0.9725773334503174,
0.03136186674237251,
-0.8086997866630554,
0.40407371520996094,
0.185609370470047,
0.44990357756614685,
-0.48274555802345276,
0.1721176952123642,
0.16325907409191132,
-0.0392698310315609,
-0.4409387707710266,
-0.8298117518424988,
0.668368935585022,
0.18030300736427307,
0.28540390729904175,
-0.4761788547039032,
0.5518271923065186,
-0.42038458585739136,
-0.248845636844635,
0.3504633903503418,
0.22560973465442657,
0.5313417911529541,
-0.22627326846122742,
-0.6814361810684204,
0.6066691875457764,
0.3177994191646576,
-0.19389113783836365,
0.2670007050037384,
-0.00010932903387583792,
-0.20692501962184906,
0.35378003120422363,
0.5255009531974792,
-0.1261281818151474,
0.012280935421586037,
0.313368558883667,
0.5352375507354736,
-0.6241884827613831,
-0.2443113923072815,
-0.7891781330108643,
0.7540030479431152,
-0.1488618403673172,
-0.28047361969947815,
0.835192859172821,
0.578095555305481,
0.656386137008667,
0.10851958394050598,
0.792082667350769,
-0.051138993352651596,
0.5534838438034058,
-0.12934671342372894,
0.6799197196960449,
-0.4190444350242615,
-0.07819315791130066,
-0.4404706656932831,
-1.0366179943084717,
-0.32242876291275024,
0.5179013609886169,
-0.45709091424942017,
-0.40373536944389343,
0.6025769710540771,
0.06383538991212845,
0.09951142221689224,
0.0021101543679833412,
0.3770970106124878,
-0.1301405429840088,
0.3885413408279419,
0.06365376710891724,
1.000447392463684,
-0.7981665134429932,
0.5919609665870667,
-0.4417644739151001,
-0.3206025958061218,
-0.2849327623844147,
-0.8745620250701904,
-0.3452713191509247,
-0.8260101675987244,
-0.6314542293548584,
-0.06962162256240845,
-0.13367104530334473,
0.9909066557884216,
0.8366248607635498,
-0.7481620907783508,
-0.5818454027175903,
0.19771358370780945,
-0.13972556591033936,
-0.21438270807266235,
-0.1897960901260376,
0.26070818305015564,
-0.41218656301498413,
-0.8832436800003052,
0.9181421995162964,
0.46433505415916443,
-0.13446778059005737,
-0.32395029067993164,
-0.1642053872346878,
-0.15293148159980774,
-0.22245191037654877,
0.5433454513549805,
-0.13710710406303406,
-0.9191516637802124,
-0.5598031878471375,
-0.14750924706459045,
0.030830001458525658,
0.051365889608860016,
0.4998163878917694,
-0.49893561005592346,
0.679563045501709,
0.4669135510921478,
0.7286043763160706,
0.6118471026420593,
0.23493535816669464,
0.6373212933540344,
-0.6809827089309692,
0.10064654797315598,
0.4256528913974762,
0.371859073638916,
0.7217751145362854,
-0.04762249067425728,
0.7591353058815002,
0.14912842214107513,
-0.6932168006896973,
-1.0091835260391235,
-0.0642724335193634,
-1.0267510414123535,
0.22531403601169586,
0.780952513217926,
-0.2287418246269226,
-0.219002828001976,
-0.13232865929603577,
-0.32281163334846497,
0.365921288728714,
-0.20823687314987183,
0.26261624693870544,
0.8158693909645081,
-0.38405635952949524,
0.18691648542881012,
-0.45963722467422485,
0.18699689209461212,
0.39597955346107483,
-0.7739778757095337,
-0.0213788989931345,
0.21387594938278198,
0.22638511657714844,
0.42405107617378235,
0.5979448556900024,
-0.3522438704967499,
0.254563570022583,
-0.11534472554922104,
0.0866687148809433,
0.20794154703617096,
0.015550920739769936,
-0.4234500229358673,
-0.24767020344734192,
0.32978323101997375,
-0.4335368275642395
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.03878v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.03878v1
|
Decoder-only Streaming Transformer for Simultaneous Translation
| 2024-06-06T09:13:13 | 2024-06-06T09:13:13 |
Shoutao Guo, Shaolei Zhang, Yang Feng
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Simultaneous Machine Translation (SiMT) generates translation while reading
source tokens, essentially producing the target prefix based on the source
prefix. To achieve good performance, it leverages the relationship between
source and target prefixes to exact a policy to guide the generation of
translations. Although existing SiMT methods primarily focus on the
Encoder-Decoder architecture, we explore the potential of Decoder-only
architecture, owing to its superior performance in various tasks and its
inherent compatibility with SiMT. However, directly applying the Decoder-only
architecture to SiMT poses challenges in terms of training and inference. To
alleviate the above problems, we propose the first Decoder-only SiMT model,
named Decoder-only Streaming Transformer (DST). Specifically, DST separately
encodes the positions of the source and target prefixes, ensuring that the
position of the target prefix remains unaffected by the expansion of the source
prefix. Furthermore, we propose a Streaming Self-Attention (SSA) mechanism
tailored for the Decoder-only architecture. It is capable of obtaining
translation policy by assessing the sufficiency of input source information and
integrating with the soft-attention mechanism to generate translations.
Experiments demonstrate that our approach achieves state-of-the-art performance
on three translation tasks.
|
[
-0.33307281136512756,
-0.32990553975105286,
0.5102496147155762,
0.4419790208339691,
-0.8117964863777161,
-0.07521207630634308,
-0.07656070590019226,
0.032430876046419144,
0.43858572840690613,
0.5414525866508484,
-0.8102145791053772,
-0.055900778621435165,
-0.859306275844574,
0.39669618010520935,
-0.44047775864601135,
1.0191597938537598,
-0.3068041205406189,
0.037889979779720306,
-0.03241598978638649,
-0.0893363505601883,
-0.5401896238327026,
-0.3610747158527374,
-0.609904944896698,
-0.006828167475759983,
0.39424169063568115,
0.15608324110507965,
0.780806839466095,
1.028053641319275,
0.6722143292427063,
0.28749221563339233,
0.16087454557418823,
0.16238394379615784,
-0.36405494809150696,
0.2975802421569824,
0.002764482283964753,
-0.30168622732162476,
-0.3507623076438904,
-0.5360738635063171,
0.7438696622848511,
0.09409765899181366,
0.16779480874538422,
0.265926718711853,
0.06062499061226845,
0.4943400025367737,
-0.40979501605033875,
0.28011348843574524,
-0.4024449288845062,
0.01302428636699915,
-0.37229248881340027,
-0.43065690994262695,
-0.4530266523361206,
-0.04728946462273598,
-0.34797781705856323,
-0.2506319582462311,
0.24990923702716827,
-0.2371586263179779,
0.7405792474746704,
1.0464143753051758,
-0.6408677697181702,
0.11715936660766602,
-1.0074406862258911,
0.540048360824585,
-0.4150712192058563,
0.6228522658348083,
-0.08060834556818008,
0.4388795495033264,
0.19563737511634827,
-0.6893284320831299,
-0.2910554111003876,
0.007269618567079306,
-0.159210205078125,
0.7115310430526733,
-0.10991843789815903,
-0.03144240379333496,
0.16606669127941132,
0.2653749883174896,
-0.6651008129119873,
-0.42730194330215454,
-0.4504079222679138,
0.12346164882183075,
0.5829034447669983,
-0.012201606296002865,
0.33525559306144714,
-0.19017699360847473,
-0.977762758731842,
-0.07909998297691345,
-0.357636034488678,
-0.20020879805088043,
0.10889523476362228,
0.13388603925704956,
-0.015696130692958832,
0.507581353187561,
0.03158223256468773,
-0.03650686517357826,
0.008277633227407932,
0.16819337010383606,
0.3176085650920868,
-0.3790137469768524,
-0.17373673617839813,
0.3268747925758362,
0.9868112206459045,
-0.19333916902542114,
-0.06146891415119171,
-0.448166161775589,
-0.4391869604587555,
0.2412772923707962,
0.7191922664642334,
-0.6894500851631165,
0.30940166115760803,
0.28436964750289917,
-0.28321608901023865,
-0.09616164118051529,
0.14193400740623474,
-0.5810397267341614,
0.1561778485774994,
-0.11419292539358139,
0.488640159368515,
-0.3905590772628784,
-0.6003564596176147,
0.08092253655195236,
0.0075697158463299274,
0.18686756491661072,
-0.05813562870025635,
-0.7549498081207275,
0.5643001794815063,
0.5638462901115417,
1.0086638927459717,
-0.5998551845550537,
-0.4366491436958313,
-0.5655854344367981,
0.4215790033340454,
-0.12977340817451477,
0.919015109539032,
-0.0448690727353096,
-0.22317034006118774,
-0.15733012557029724,
-0.1513534039258957,
-0.33809491991996765,
-0.12896153330802917,
0.9244852662086487,
-0.5841701030731201,
-0.5825876593589783,
-0.07411027699708939,
-0.6133449673652649,
-0.07202096283435822,
-0.24254339933395386,
-0.8717464804649353,
0.8330461382865906,
-0.018931249156594276,
-0.7152946591377258,
-0.05453389883041382,
-0.9440637826919556,
-0.5796802639961243,
0.238857239484787,
-0.2863718867301941,
-0.3041091561317444,
0.30766311287879944,
0.25480127334594727,
0.16431137919425964,
-0.20534949004650116,
0.5215393900871277,
-0.07336143404245377,
-0.41111838817596436,
0.024141322821378708,
-1.011123538017273,
0.497443825006485,
0.45449382066726685,
-0.36379802227020264,
0.13477937877178192,
-0.281096488237381,
-0.1732577681541443,
0.40003278851509094,
-0.15859362483024597,
0.04626782611012459,
0.18596583604812622,
0.20247003436088562,
0.4725009500980377,
0.07930421829223633,
-0.6589563488960266,
0.2916872203350067,
-0.05291452631354332,
0.24189475178718567,
0.5922062397003174,
-0.1648927927017212,
0.4306638836860657,
-0.07944396138191223,
0.7125844955444336,
0.0982586145401001,
0.11536804586648941,
-0.4612385034561157,
-0.21208292245864868,
-0.7663845419883728,
-0.535559892654419,
0.34070220589637756,
0.5709871053695679,
-0.8792474865913391,
0.10497061163187027,
-0.8745214939117432,
-0.17078019678592682,
-0.9661411046981812,
0.27717864513397217,
0.17131491005420685,
-0.0053313979879021645,
0.6151937246322632,
-0.10244923084974289,
-0.3472960889339447,
-0.8586798310279846,
-0.3900962769985199,
0.41353240609169006,
0.16098271310329437,
-0.12461324781179428,
0.20699083805084229,
0.00936173927038908,
0.8475120663642883,
-0.42620009183883667,
-0.41916486620903015,
-0.6029223203659058,
0.08674032241106033,
0.04088127985596657,
0.37692582607269287,
0.3713206946849823,
-0.9357048869132996,
-0.6298035383224487,
0.02949436381459236,
-0.7613182067871094,
-0.25338006019592285,
-0.42233794927597046,
-0.13420861959457397,
0.06120513752102852,
0.5179359912872314,
-0.6483218669891357,
0.5626933574676514,
0.7536110281944275,
0.025587989017367363,
-0.02672865241765976,
-0.24409128725528717,
-0.0392189584672451,
-1.1256465911865234,
-0.1266651600599289,
-0.25541990995407104,
-0.42993953824043274,
-0.6720839738845825,
-0.019976556301116943,
0.3879992961883545,
-0.11010795086622238,
-0.6564957499504089,
0.4673357605934143,
-0.3542187511920929,
-0.17374162375926971,
-0.484144926071167,
-0.13056866824626923,
-0.13163195550441742,
0.7125053405761719,
0.37890416383743286,
0.8389511704444885,
0.31847164034843445,
-0.3582184314727783,
0.0647566169500351,
0.27104708552360535,
0.0614909827709198,
0.11968595534563065,
-0.5007025599479675,
0.28587159514427185,
-0.18415449559688568,
0.4889439344406128,
-0.8538326025009155,
-0.026291145011782646,
0.3185092508792877,
-0.3183344900608063,
0.4318626821041107,
-0.2470199018716812,
-0.36191263794898987,
-0.3756672441959381,
0.04735391214489937,
0.500650942325592,
0.514775276184082,
-0.42700546979904175,
0.6952016949653625,
-0.05319095402956009,
-0.20663467049598694,
-0.3212038278579712,
-0.8241523504257202,
0.051015570759773254,
0.15734192728996277,
-0.7509303092956543,
0.3409136235713959,
-0.02005542814731598,
0.4362141788005829,
0.08802510052919388,
-0.7441509366035461,
-0.24697276949882507,
-0.12965478003025055,
0.3398935794830322,
0.19016030430793762,
-0.43227896094322205,
-0.15703697502613068,
0.4488374888896942,
-0.6240174174308777,
-0.11931157857179642,
-0.4212486445903778,
0.349494606256485,
0.0017280376050621271,
-0.6311686635017395,
-0.6421856880187988,
0.7668778300285339,
0.7524775266647339,
-0.60799640417099,
0.6485421061515808,
0.6775193214416504,
0.22399434447288513,
-0.27616041898727417,
-0.40878599882125854,
-0.18581783771514893,
-0.4736253619194031,
0.20272201299667358,
-0.8377993106842041,
-0.48753464221954346,
0.16269491612911224,
-0.2384120523929596,
0.05049541965126991,
0.3640219271183014,
0.43897566199302673,
0.010022956877946854,
1.102815866470337,
0.41401129961013794,
0.3852536678314209,
0.4256208539009094,
-0.20425927639007568,
0.4577224552631378,
-0.7922986149787903,
0.08892130106687546,
-0.24789945781230927,
-0.2753349840641022,
-0.4674273133277893,
-0.36114251613616943,
0.3227410316467285,
-0.08640915900468826,
0.11645936220884323,
0.5576992630958557,
-0.28119125962257385,
0.44435301423072815,
0.548664927482605,
-0.04080234095454216,
0.3904048204421997,
-0.02799322083592415,
0.024893948808312416,
0.07362060993909836,
-0.8165320158004761,
-0.5234248638153076,
0.787810742855072,
0.22317315638065338,
0.5556113719940186,
0.06245740130543709,
1.0122778415679932,
0.24114510416984558,
0.08277367055416107,
-0.7054791450500488,
0.440551221370697,
-0.3076203465461731,
-0.487202912569046,
-0.11052700877189636,
-0.4783920347690582,
-0.6821765899658203,
0.6902587413787842,
0.28198543190956116,
-0.07366105169057846,
-0.07983841001987457,
-0.0217494647949934,
-0.021344760432839394,
0.4366861879825592,
-0.6043368577957153,
0.9342414736747742,
-0.5461563467979431,
-0.1834057718515396,
0.13045981526374817,
-0.6284927725791931,
0.2854660451412201,
-0.35746294260025024,
0.1060967966914177,
-0.03176987171173096,
-0.20286697149276733,
0.0668085440993309,
-0.19779057800769806,
0.4281463921070099,
0.011202927678823471,
0.081656314432621,
0.19055406749248505,
0.2742205858230591,
0.4808063507080078,
-0.03028661571443081,
0.15045620501041412,
0.562551736831665,
0.1030711978673935,
-0.5549724698066711,
-0.655034065246582,
0.37092238664627075,
-0.8233318328857422,
-0.7144509553909302,
-0.6412011981010437,
-0.624559760093689,
0.07174387574195862,
0.4806216061115265,
0.18929468095302582,
0.13588276505470276,
-0.08587157726287842,
0.1823882907629013,
0.3910966217517853,
0.24888503551483154,
0.44600218534469604,
0.4207848310470581,
-0.024399783462285995,
-0.2758975028991699,
0.9510030150413513,
-0.005385399796068668,
0.5263981223106384,
0.4719505310058594,
0.1273908168077469,
-0.4413854777812958,
-0.48035821318626404,
-0.8019043803215027,
0.2872259020805359,
-0.5147209763526917,
-0.3675517737865448,
-0.9225720763206482,
-0.5167332291603088,
-0.5090599060058594,
0.008610919117927551,
-0.8155059218406677,
-0.10164439678192139,
0.0419604629278183,
0.06463257968425751,
-0.04177427664399147,
0.7105040550231934,
-0.020738352090120316,
0.3603214919567108,
-1.064365267753601,
0.8408404588699341,
0.26880624890327454,
0.2703900933265686,
-0.3632810711860657,
-0.4071090519428253,
-0.08178392052650452,
0.1813325583934784,
-0.3474734127521515,
-0.9428848028182983,
0.4651966392993927,
-0.09218285977840424,
0.4020404517650604,
0.26884615421295166,
0.20442084968090057,
0.4907769560813904,
-0.818610429763794,
0.5259339809417725,
-0.03699040785431862,
-1.0050203800201416,
0.272538959980011,
-0.19956262409687042,
0.5982831716537476,
0.34434521198272705,
0.14833714067935944,
-0.4634915888309479,
-0.4042351245880127,
-0.3217155635356903,
-0.6770645976066589,
1.3356943130493164,
0.7468280792236328,
0.33410605788230896,
-0.13093861937522888,
0.12730678915977478,
0.19586369395256042,
-0.0663398802280426,
-0.528991162776947,
-0.3470095098018646,
-0.6121456027030945,
-0.29976338148117065,
0.08041790127754211,
-0.09650929272174835,
0.244486466050148,
0.03622784465551376,
0.7421765327453613,
-0.22438891232013702,
0.30448222160339355,
0.23645687103271484,
-0.2991545498371124,
-0.2776322662830353,
0.3227071166038513,
0.384539395570755,
0.1829993575811386,
-0.15946634113788605,
0.17537206411361694,
0.015087533742189407,
-0.4756440222263336,
0.2626204192638397,
-0.057104382663965225,
-0.6144943237304688,
0.27472078800201416,
-0.06812991201877594,
1.0783026218414307,
0.4087560474872589,
-0.18944013118743896,
0.7242920398712158,
-0.22743886709213257,
-0.18834088742733002,
-0.06523168087005615,
-0.09900505095720291,
0.32204127311706543,
0.1798243671655655,
0.21848994493484497,
0.45914405584335327,
-0.018966645002365112,
0.11239642649888992,
0.27133098244667053,
0.09052303433418274,
-0.23133283853530884,
-0.30102649331092834,
0.75540691614151,
0.24250969290733337,
-0.34433579444885254,
0.4420361816883087,
-0.04770521819591522,
-0.4948769509792328,
0.4274320900440216,
0.9082199335098267,
1.354207158088684,
-0.5689748525619507,
0.3010798394680023,
0.13281989097595215,
0.33297669887542725,
-0.21293894946575165,
0.11896388977766037,
-0.44291406869888306,
-0.48050644993782043,
-0.5216922163963318,
-0.8472219109535217,
-0.07529667764902115,
-0.2505834400653839,
-0.875914454460144,
0.512492299079895,
0.34305429458618164,
0.05714373663067818,
-0.1575240045785904,
-0.45026695728302,
-0.7031064033508301,
-0.07273969054222107,
0.4144724905490875,
0.834387481212616,
-0.8917718529701233,
1.251758337020874,
0.716589093208313,
-0.5832622051239014,
-0.5807283520698547,
0.08162210881710052,
-0.1275595873594284,
-0.6124825477600098,
0.48461416363716125,
0.07404953986406326,
-0.493728905916214,
0.3542093336582184,
-0.10682398080825806,
-1.1261297464370728,
1.0914405584335327,
0.6009171605110168,
-0.4111587107181549,
-0.17096047103405,
0.5249730944633484,
0.1730225384235382,
-0.06961090117692947,
0.20959138870239258,
0.4770037531852722,
0.47278183698654175,
0.451071172952652,
-0.6461507678031921,
-0.06514036655426025,
-0.13762643933296204,
0.2357918918132782,
0.36069732904434204,
-0.8587092757225037,
0.5128232836723328,
0.19253456592559814,
-0.673911988735199,
-0.1730542927980423,
0.8487203121185303,
-0.23865079879760742,
-0.023740407079458237,
0.3794531226158142,
0.23042051494121552,
-0.014059407636523247,
-0.03168117254972458,
1.3093281984329224,
-0.28939923644065857,
0.5157512426376343,
1.2505580186843872,
-0.13795727491378784,
0.6811983585357666,
0.6888929009437561,
-0.0017855820478871465,
-0.13714490830898285,
0.2405996322631836,
0.016801442950963974,
0.8268522024154663,
-0.2937197685241699,
-0.1603488028049469,
-0.4670271575450897,
-0.1610420048236847,
-0.2877955436706543,
0.46607938408851624,
0.09682497382164001,
-0.2591497004032135,
-0.5240302085876465,
0.08279046416282654,
0.026308929547667503,
-0.1374686360359192,
-0.05094750598073006,
0.8779255151748657,
0.2192283421754837,
-0.7898390889167786,
0.5014005899429321,
-0.015686020255088806,
0.45113977789878845,
-1.0153788328170776,
0.12541231513023376,
-0.45531073212623596,
0.15896499156951904,
-0.04273674637079239,
-0.5252049565315247,
0.6497105956077576,
0.04184852913022041,
0.0019796353299170732,
-0.646001935005188,
0.42884331941604614,
-0.5349656343460083,
-0.5300482511520386,
0.32011523842811584,
0.6157445311546326,
0.3153792917728424,
-0.2461099475622177,
-0.5677042603492737,
0.41891247034072876,
0.08680621534585953,
-0.37472158670425415,
0.202535480260849,
0.4259359538555145,
0.10506460070610046,
0.4210908114910126,
0.5100089907646179,
0.09738554060459137,
0.583715558052063,
-0.028683951124548912,
0.6208041310310364,
-0.5013060569763184,
-0.5253247022628784,
-0.7324581742286682,
0.3914162218570709,
0.2863636016845703,
0.08015744388103485,
0.5376103520393372,
0.40272966027259827,
0.7242200374603271,
-0.20763003826141357,
0.8500902056694031,
0.04077444598078728,
-0.18461455404758453,
-0.23423124849796295,
0.513045608997345,
-0.6578989624977112,
-0.08053278177976608,
0.006933268625289202,
-1.184704303741455,
-0.24522948265075684,
0.22431811690330505,
-0.03275107964873314,
-0.25613734126091003,
1.1019705533981323,
0.5615541934967041,
-0.5027575492858887,
0.3859359323978424,
0.6300598978996277,
0.11622323840856552,
0.2591192424297333,
0.4483885169029236,
0.45726150274276733,
-0.5969645977020264,
0.946353018283844,
-0.21328319609165192,
-0.018874885514378548,
-0.04136054962873459,
-0.6596617698669434,
-0.603175163269043,
-0.4534955620765686,
-0.18863898515701294,
0.03373796492815018,
0.031232845038175583,
0.898754894733429,
0.5072131156921387,
-0.6828134655952454,
-0.0805208683013916,
-0.16440001130104065,
-0.15546129643917084,
-0.6385853886604309,
-0.1347542405128479,
0.39005374908447266,
-0.7236170172691345,
-0.9463684558868408,
0.5450560450553894,
0.6493394374847412,
-0.045971862971782684,
-0.22067540884017944,
-0.053947340697050095,
-0.1391664296388626,
0.3507046401500702,
0.3183950185775757,
0.02119189128279686,
-0.7934926748275757,
0.0642404779791832,
-0.03470481559634209,
-0.24191507697105408,
0.44911879301071167,
0.911544680595398,
-0.43481317162513733,
0.5469104051589966,
0.45970582962036133,
1.0656108856201172,
0.951316773891449,
0.14650803804397583,
0.5212727785110474,
-0.5892563462257385,
0.014639437198638916,
0.1929425597190857,
0.18102137744426727,
0.055074967443943024,
-0.34945935010910034,
0.4498250484466553,
0.06608383357524872,
-0.2716755270957947,
-0.4835669696331024,
0.2586572468280792,
-1.0909067392349243,
-0.11342708766460419,
1.1111018657684326,
-0.22031629085540771,
-0.44268500804901123,
0.022604387253522873,
-0.25579288601875305,
0.7010983228683472,
-0.4591814875602722,
0.35105788707733154,
0.41257548332214355,
0.07248752564191818,
-0.1977754831314087,
-0.9235736131668091,
0.20081152021884918,
0.5630902051925659,
-0.6030352711677551,
0.06542059034109116,
-0.05360196530818939,
0.221207395195961,
0.012119239196181297,
0.5281084179878235,
-0.2077828198671341,
0.1732054352760315,
0.1843973696231842,
0.04705049842596054,
-0.4120900332927704,
-0.4687475264072418,
-0.4367998540401459,
0.15842558443546295,
-0.5042716264724731,
-0.4814978837966919
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.03872v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.03872v1
|
BLSP-Emo: Towards Empathetic Large Speech-Language Models
| 2024-06-06T09:02:31 | 2024-06-06T09:02:31 |
Chen Wang, Minpeng Liao, Zhongqiang Huang, Junhong Wu, Chengqing Zong, Jiajun Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
The recent release of GPT-4o showcased the potential of end-to-end multimodal
models, not just in terms of low latency but also in their ability to
understand and generate expressive speech with rich emotions. While the details
are unknown to the open research community, it likely involves significant
amounts of curated data and compute, neither of which is readily accessible. In
this paper, we present BLSP-Emo (Bootstrapped Language-Speech Pretraining with
Emotion support), a novel approach to developing an end-to-end speech-language
model capable of understanding both semantics and emotions in speech and
generate empathetic responses. BLSP-Emo utilizes existing speech recognition
(ASR) and speech emotion recognition (SER) datasets through a two-stage
process. The first stage focuses on semantic alignment, following recent work
on pretraining speech-language models using ASR data. The second stage performs
emotion alignment with the pretrained speech-language model on an emotion-aware
continuation task constructed from SER data. Our experiments demonstrate that
the BLSP-Emo model excels in comprehending speech and delivering empathetic
responses, both in instruction-following tasks and conversations.
|
[
-0.2786823809146881,
-0.566402018070221,
0.49261748790740967,
0.25199130177497864,
-0.01575285755097866,
-0.009602156467735767,
-0.46873146295547485,
-0.5020071864128113,
0.29952895641326904,
0.09047426283359528,
-0.736583948135376,
-0.25030964612960815,
-0.5134151577949524,
0.19475536048412323,
-0.31233102083206177,
0.8784554600715637,
0.028175029903650284,
0.13220268487930298,
0.09139356762170792,
0.07972638309001923,
0.17629732191562653,
-0.5509786605834961,
-0.6105901598930359,
-0.4331881105899811,
0.6188530921936035,
0.28020066022872925,
0.40416035056114197,
0.33743739128112793,
0.08286513388156891,
0.2255772203207016,
-0.16717049479484558,
-0.312423974275589,
-0.25582465529441833,
0.48783260583877563,
0.07776906341314316,
-0.17372830212116241,
-0.5740697383880615,
0.06659691780805588,
0.4839721918106079,
0.43019983172416687,
-0.4602665603160858,
0.10240188986063004,
-0.06348595023155212,
0.49858230352401733,
-0.6958879828453064,
-0.03207870572805405,
-0.40163692831993103,
0.30324944853782654,
0.0816291868686676,
-0.06554757058620453,
-0.5672231912612915,
-0.02198822610080242,
0.25503063201904297,
-0.4381541609764099,
-0.24147306382656097,
0.08668316900730133,
0.4532122313976288,
0.34233570098876953,
-0.29491713643074036,
-0.5515798330307007,
-0.5999518632888794,
0.8057538866996765,
-0.7057021260261536,
0.8965307474136353,
0.3381357192993164,
0.21794700622558594,
0.4891093373298645,
-0.47880223393440247,
-0.6176256537437439,
-0.19204269349575043,
0.32682979106903076,
0.3717344105243683,
-0.25362876057624817,
0.2688734829425812,
0.24673493206501007,
0.03394103795289993,
-0.7811995148658752,
0.2988564670085907,
0.009718803688883781,
-0.022443240508437157,
0.45378729701042175,
-0.034000106155872345,
0.19264376163482666,
0.047485027462244034,
-0.3102244734764099,
0.08426976948976517,
-0.5068321824073792,
-0.034807439893484116,
0.23912794888019562,
0.3908909559249878,
-0.5079736709594727,
0.6624670624732971,
-0.14057563245296478,
0.8084356784820557,
0.019836345687508583,
0.006363719701766968,
0.39748892188072205,
0.12673014402389526,
-0.4384750723838806,
0.37375113368034363,
0.5869277119636536,
0.22540225088596344,
0.37055495381355286,
-0.3650285005569458,
-0.2936514616012573,
0.28000640869140625,
0.05657267943024635,
-0.9849177002906799,
0.2283974289894104,
0.7793983817100525,
-0.40165191888809204,
-0.19701051712036133,
-0.6529947519302368,
-0.9090442657470703,
-0.16558904945850372,
-0.5915229320526123,
0.28608280420303345,
-0.4299643933773041,
-0.23135539889335632,
-0.13078933954238892,
0.006399532780051231,
0.31227219104766846,
0.3273039758205414,
-0.977733314037323,
0.27984365820884705,
0.6060873866081238,
1.052794337272644,
0.20089855790138245,
-0.37400737404823303,
-0.6066369414329529,
0.381491482257843,
-0.012604238465428352,
0.39540019631385803,
-1.116154670715332,
-0.024479705840349197,
0.07461904734373093,
-0.14330193400382996,
0.07545333355665207,
0.021836649626493454,
0.4890862703323364,
-0.21169833838939667,
0.24857065081596375,
-0.01374198030680418,
-0.5782669186592102,
-0.015865514054894447,
0.49142417311668396,
-0.2150173932313919,
0.4066352844238281,
-0.08837751299142838,
-0.6206310987472534,
0.050866398960351944,
-0.6658186316490173,
-0.31191396713256836,
-0.2826034724712372,
-0.013793112710118294,
-0.10792570561170578,
0.43913957476615906,
-0.09900959581136703,
0.6654133796691895,
-0.6690730452537537,
0.14661620557308197,
-0.5247092843055725,
0.05795123800635338,
0.21719202399253845,
-0.039016176015138626,
0.3371643126010895,
0.4815807640552521,
-0.14026416838169098,
0.007636147551238537,
-0.9876206517219543,
-0.022493362426757812,
-0.03354756906628609,
0.05518050864338875,
-0.3747003972530365,
-0.06528504937887192,
0.3718271851539612,
0.8950161933898926,
0.34121328592300415,
-1.0699292421340942,
-0.32574376463890076,
-0.3339923322200775,
0.47563275694847107,
0.711272120475769,
-0.5954827070236206,
0.3792775571346283,
-0.1420300453901291,
0.6234331130981445,
0.007949983701109886,
0.24871523678302765,
-0.5890170335769653,
-0.317213237285614,
-0.43184226751327515,
-0.3216049075126648,
-0.10244835913181305,
0.49803394079208374,
-0.38218626379966736,
0.38675400614738464,
0.040080491453409195,
-0.6841501593589783,
-0.8641429543495178,
-0.3546031415462494,
0.7266528606414795,
0.5992860794067383,
0.37744447588920593,
-0.3007403016090393,
-0.5225439667701721,
-0.6865763664245605,
-0.1221453994512558,
0.15363121032714844,
-0.0717761218547821,
0.37814897298812866,
0.060586679726839066,
-0.4493257999420166,
0.6814998388290405,
-0.30718639492988586,
-0.07902578264474869,
0.08020956069231033,
0.06285465508699417,
-0.23206529021263123,
0.45409369468688965,
0.2066776007413864,
-0.6118373870849609,
-0.42770835757255554,
0.2713635265827179,
-0.6089195609092712,
-0.30201104283332825,
0.10808257013559341,
0.17622536420822144,
0.312101811170578,
0.13735437393188477,
-0.5413105487823486,
-0.09171561151742935,
1.0732359886169434,
-0.3854551315307617,
0.07625515013933182,
0.017919689416885376,
0.23363974690437317,
-1.1889598369598389,
0.19823026657104492,
0.06425341218709946,
-0.10849638283252716,
-0.9363980889320374,
-0.28304600715637207,
-0.11729945242404938,
-0.6773867011070251,
-0.3628860414028168,
0.5333309769630432,
-0.35291028022766113,
-0.4161604642868042,
-0.16973647475242615,
0.286050021648407,
-0.20287935435771942,
0.5020429491996765,
0.3649958670139313,
0.10504446178674698,
0.9080334901809692,
-0.2888369858264923,
0.41738542914390564,
0.49339231848716736,
0.5162338614463806,
0.6848882436752319,
-0.6966130137443542,
0.3664947748184204,
-0.11541078239679337,
0.049148619174957275,
-0.9174325466156006,
-0.16137759387493134,
-0.10555938631296158,
-0.6187115907669067,
0.47993600368499756,
-0.32932692766189575,
-0.2769061028957367,
-0.06585465371608734,
-0.2154877632856369,
0.307456910610199,
0.6536045074462891,
-0.43727999925613403,
0.9306340217590332,
0.4548274576663971,
-0.5827135443687439,
-0.3669579327106476,
-0.7843502163887024,
-0.10520815849304199,
-0.0690910667181015,
-0.6997274160385132,
0.14693213999271393,
-0.02616923674941063,
-0.0643208846449852,
-0.3208789825439453,
0.3148832321166992,
-0.09809782356023788,
-0.20974187552928925,
0.45068445801734924,
-0.27997931838035583,
-0.015786023810505867,
0.28357619047164917,
0.31728795170783997,
-0.18752412497997284,
0.007448721211403608,
0.01600436307489872,
0.8435977697372437,
-0.14700210094451904,
-0.29302215576171875,
-0.6346203088760376,
0.40811076760292053,
0.6717433333396912,
-0.4202883541584015,
0.46888384222984314,
0.46684256196022034,
-0.42741072177886963,
-0.11624036729335785,
-0.4359740614891052,
-0.20641767978668213,
-0.38715794682502747,
0.25730007886886597,
-0.3654513955116272,
-0.9188296794891357,
0.5249097347259521,
-0.24443329870700836,
0.02297777496278286,
-0.12273798137903214,
0.8805747032165527,
0.023097092285752296,
1.1446713209152222,
0.4884799122810364,
0.1097761020064354,
0.6786656379699707,
0.3678860068321228,
0.10880781710147858,
-0.9451377391815186,
-0.3645190894603729,
-0.5190995335578918,
-0.2925289273262024,
-0.5892899632453918,
-0.1316126137971878,
-0.022355681285262108,
-0.5192921161651611,
-0.5236713290214539,
-0.03850538656115532,
-0.2837035357952118,
-0.03050016611814499,
0.12102632224559784,
0.04755755886435509,
0.0337536595761776,
-0.09249487519264221,
0.2556488513946533,
-0.07211700081825256,
-0.4790409207344055,
-0.3722136914730072,
1.0411744117736816,
0.5479435920715332,
0.8780648112297058,
0.08282813429832458,
0.8410535454750061,
-0.06670113652944565,
0.3096858561038971,
-0.7893513441085815,
0.22139564156532288,
-0.09296136349439621,
-0.3763149082660675,
-0.3068753182888031,
-0.3140600323677063,
-0.7783591151237488,
0.20878681540489197,
-0.181025892496109,
-0.8878883719444275,
0.1405329704284668,
0.451234370470047,
-0.21769537031650543,
-0.07494723796844482,
-0.8842126131057739,
0.8199685215950012,
-0.353296160697937,
-0.4474458694458008,
-0.23069001734256744,
-0.9860489368438721,
0.23055391013622284,
-0.27503129839897156,
0.38947784900665283,
-0.1640401929616928,
-0.19648127257823944,
0.6314027905464172,
-0.2551087439060211,
0.769174337387085,
-0.3088724613189697,
-0.17963986098766327,
-0.06518471986055374,
0.15941323339939117,
0.45650336146354675,
-0.40503206849098206,
-0.3862612843513489,
-0.07238888740539551,
-0.09002265334129333,
-0.29136258363723755,
-0.6531243920326233,
0.722456157207489,
-0.6575446724891663,
0.00905267521739006,
-0.377693235874176,
-0.628758430480957,
-0.4438430666923523,
-0.08596786856651306,
-0.02757990173995495,
0.47221091389656067,
-0.1796421855688095,
0.006766424514353275,
0.36664333939552307,
-0.37848538160324097,
0.4025121331214905,
0.7567709684371948,
-0.3038944602012634,
-0.36515355110168457,
0.8569351434707642,
-0.04534047096967697,
0.5630789399147034,
0.3303125202655792,
0.293391615152359,
-0.3737814724445343,
-0.017293978482484818,
-0.4253350794315338,
0.3961992859840393,
-0.3839804232120514,
-0.005685074254870415,
-0.706561267375946,
0.15795177221298218,
-0.5648524165153503,
-0.4312295913696289,
-0.7555937170982361,
-0.4458329379558563,
0.008660171180963516,
-0.02700706012547016,
0.41132646799087524,
0.6826308369636536,
-0.32588109374046326,
0.33465173840522766,
-0.9454023838043213,
0.1287507563829422,
0.12390299141407013,
0.3799551725387573,
0.13664063811302185,
-0.7378628849983215,
-0.1656929850578308,
0.09789387881755829,
-0.2308855652809143,
-1.1320565938949585,
0.8513185977935791,
0.38060280680656433,
0.021906452253460884,
0.5101926326751709,
-0.2157411426305771,
0.5230205059051514,
-0.757977306842804,
0.592654824256897,
0.5931258797645569,
-1.3933147192001343,
0.8601120114326477,
-0.3256189525127411,
-0.0745483934879303,
0.18021826446056366,
0.6746895909309387,
-0.7508035898208618,
-0.2764285206794739,
-0.7287428975105286,
-0.7724769711494446,
0.8176479339599609,
0.14131991565227509,
0.07164587080478668,
0.12460142374038696,
0.12156733870506287,
0.0007276374963112175,
0.43055737018585205,
-0.6426677703857422,
0.06212569773197174,
-0.23115777969360352,
-0.5981830358505249,
-0.2724897265434265,
-0.2311992198228836,
-0.2869766652584076,
0.15466395020484924,
0.5279005765914917,
-0.023491358384490013,
0.422107994556427,
0.10499453544616699,
-0.10732603818178177,
-0.3863197863101959,
0.39668864011764526,
0.4595975875854492,
0.15539585053920746,
-0.2358999103307724,
0.13958114385604858,
-0.018272170796990395,
-0.1722368746995926,
0.3110657334327698,
0.37291163206100464,
0.18657058477401733,
-0.30733612179756165,
0.22771912813186646,
0.8459567427635193,
0.3141721189022064,
-0.9808865189552307,
0.717176616191864,
0.12363433837890625,
0.334349125623703,
-0.2030566781759262,
-0.4834651052951813,
0.025325560942292213,
0.5598973631858826,
0.012299752794206142,
-0.31548500061035156,
0.3414103090763092,
-0.6855369210243225,
0.3661056458950043,
0.20716853439807892,
-0.5959809422492981,
-0.7507480978965759,
0.5228899717330933,
0.4102340340614319,
-0.4756682217121124,
0.3724322021007538,
-0.1588035523891449,
-0.515900194644928,
0.4308546781539917,
0.9211942553520203,
0.8729420304298401,
-0.8487222790718079,
0.17024244368076324,
0.17982564866542816,
0.03325815126299858,
-0.002785432618111372,
0.7061712741851807,
-0.20162077248096466,
-0.79463130235672,
-0.4073721170425415,
-0.6721489429473877,
-0.713449239730835,
-0.383752703666687,
-0.9298833012580872,
0.16720150411128998,
-0.4440706670284271,
0.09447408467531204,
-0.10846589505672455,
-0.40235215425491333,
-0.5258616209030151,
0.597209095954895,
0.5991645455360413,
0.553314208984375,
-1.3071826696395874,
0.7052743434906006,
0.6853246688842773,
-0.4485922157764435,
-0.7492793798446655,
-0.17282143235206604,
0.05575740709900856,
-0.8875710964202881,
0.6992749571800232,
0.3231915831565857,
-0.06943207234144211,
0.384429931640625,
-0.4161783456802368,
-0.7713678479194641,
1.165037751197815,
0.362883985042572,
-0.8394939303398132,
0.003340416820719838,
-0.17643171548843384,
0.7578045725822449,
-0.49317580461502075,
0.4455266296863556,
0.4272862672805786,
0.272176057100296,
0.20224817097187042,
-0.9620465040206909,
0.13821929693222046,
-0.15099167823791504,
-0.17886261641979218,
0.2394990175962448,
-0.8830174207687378,
0.85430908203125,
-0.2230815589427948,
0.11196587234735489,
-0.20278333127498627,
0.4517183005809784,
0.511535108089447,
0.6385538578033447,
0.379317969083786,
0.8802402019500732,
0.6425909996032715,
-0.004430747590959072,
1.103905439376831,
-0.6697530746459961,
0.38092830777168274,
0.9482857584953308,
-0.7155689597129822,
1.1470019817352295,
0.5721442699432373,
-0.06438732892274857,
0.11988100409507751,
0.6454666256904602,
0.22611205279827118,
0.513530969619751,
0.12108702957630157,
-0.2873289883136749,
-0.16620071232318878,
-0.38675713539123535,
-0.27244988083839417,
0.6438918113708496,
0.34806790947914124,
-0.44587892293930054,
-0.02629455178976059,
0.21931950747966766,
-0.023430636152625084,
-0.20931005477905273,
-0.35773587226867676,
0.6075288653373718,
0.3186863362789154,
-0.269621342420578,
0.2888268232345581,
-0.3104528486728668,
0.6393582820892334,
-0.6776123642921448,
0.1598758101463318,
0.12098337709903717,
-0.11932597309350967,
-0.29356494545936584,
-0.6716678738594055,
0.3784627914428711,
0.39454060792922974,
0.037798378616571426,
-0.3813762962818146,
0.45929768681526184,
-0.8656365275382996,
-0.20085832476615906,
0.8166463971138,
0.5711938142776489,
0.342871755361557,
-0.09855004400014877,
-0.675809383392334,
0.28968772292137146,
-0.26748141646385193,
-0.5266704559326172,
0.39835673570632935,
0.6713600158691406,
0.5475813746452332,
0.7160857915878296,
0.5630481243133545,
0.06461232155561447,
0.0732075646519661,
0.39215004444122314,
0.8987441658973694,
-0.6641255617141724,
-0.5776445269584656,
-0.8144304752349854,
0.4950715899467468,
0.18369905650615692,
-0.3016684651374817,
0.3254975974559784,
0.5310946106910706,
0.5611481666564941,
0.027671195566654205,
0.7649148106575012,
-0.174993097782135,
0.5822559595108032,
-0.5900070667266846,
0.45368504524230957,
-0.812272846698761,
-0.34355252981185913,
-0.6655198335647583,
-0.6081618070602417,
-0.26413431763648987,
0.6385301351547241,
-0.2912026643753052,
0.1753019243478775,
0.44498637318611145,
0.7360713481903076,
0.10586678981781006,
0.20364928245544434,
0.6865111589431763,
0.4352177083492279,
0.13582627475261688,
0.79359370470047,
0.8963310122489929,
-0.12427052110433578,
0.09851785749197006,
-0.1824130117893219,
-0.3806103765964508,
-0.006234333850443363,
-0.7784804105758667,
-0.6240495443344116,
-0.6621583104133606,
-0.016471540555357933,
-0.2899128496646881,
0.09045025706291199,
1.3300474882125854,
0.522316575050354,
-0.6038733124732971,
-0.25202447175979614,
-0.003881619079038501,
-0.2960188686847687,
0.19377098977565765,
-0.07863427698612213,
0.14330993592739105,
-0.49457255005836487,
-0.8038391470909119,
0.24837496876716614,
0.5217021703720093,
0.1969679892063141,
0.041781947016716,
-0.41751760244369507,
-0.027531122788786888,
0.035827554762363434,
0.8838538527488708,
0.28412511944770813,
-0.6234135627746582,
-0.12466602772474289,
-0.019746258854866028,
0.19631746411323547,
-0.12097425758838654,
0.7467755079269409,
-0.375480979681015,
0.5909889340400696,
0.23384885489940643,
0.8261429071426392,
0.515165388584137,
-0.059512075036764145,
0.8078787922859192,
-0.5985476970672607,
0.328972190618515,
0.39882373809814453,
0.4843606650829315,
0.46785297989845276,
-0.2681933641433716,
0.4266012907028198,
0.03323383256793022,
-0.6192127466201782,
-0.94781893491745,
0.5105058550834656,
-1.3050252199172974,
0.09639866650104523,
1.2741912603378296,
-0.325762540102005,
-0.05858512967824936,
0.24861891567707062,
-0.10340076684951782,
0.6082366108894348,
-0.565804123878479,
0.6822942495346069,
0.5160655975341797,
-0.46375682950019836,
-0.5175326466560364,
-0.25282973051071167,
0.4059562385082245,
0.49109387397766113,
-1.0352237224578857,
0.27323177456855774,
0.50541752576828,
0.0789903849363327,
0.15858663618564606,
0.5073885321617126,
0.006201700307428837,
0.06508556008338928,
0.04812155291438103,
0.5263996720314026,
0.07112351059913635,
-0.38862115144729614,
-0.7070333361625671,
0.053475379943847656,
-0.006800509989261627,
-0.08198919147253036
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.03869v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.03869v1
|
Recovering document annotations for sentence-level bitext
| 2024-06-06T08:58:14 | 2024-06-06T08:58:14 |
Rachel Wicks, Matt Post, Philipp Koehn
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Data availability limits the scope of any given task. In machine translation,
historical models were incapable of handling longer contexts, so the lack of
document-level datasets was less noticeable. Now, despite the emergence of
long-sequence methods, we remain within a sentence-level paradigm and without
data to adequately approach context-aware machine translation. Most large-scale
datasets have been processed through a pipeline that discards document-level
metadata. In this work, we reconstruct document-level information for three
(ParaCrawl, News Commentary, and Europarl) large datasets in German, French,
Spanish, Italian, Polish, and Portuguese (paired with English). We then
introduce a document-level filtering technique as an alternative to traditional
bitext filtering. We present this filtering with analysis to show that this
method prefers context-consistent translations rather than those that may have
been sentence-level machine translated. Last we train models on these longer
contexts and demonstrate improvement in document-level translation without
degradation of sentence-level translation. We release our dataset, ParaDocs,
and resulting models as a resource to the community.
|
[
-0.35457295179367065,
-0.4498423635959625,
0.6733680367469788,
0.021552203223109245,
-0.42486289143562317,
0.006552737206220627,
-0.4060077667236328,
-0.5845856666564941,
0.22533254325389862,
0.8832690119743347,
-0.450708270072937,
-0.7666803598403931,
-0.6535556316375732,
0.3580261468887329,
-0.8027418851852417,
1.3672890663146973,
-0.27691513299942017,
-0.1495899111032486,
-0.24428561329841614,
-0.24313828349113464,
-0.13266488909721375,
-0.29611876606941223,
-0.6167467832565308,
-0.21184171736240387,
0.5524181723594666,
0.21525774896144867,
0.6256712079048157,
0.7242979407310486,
0.38968849182128906,
0.1451503336429596,
-0.21283237636089325,
0.16252288222312927,
-0.284043550491333,
0.04632377624511719,
-0.16877175867557526,
-0.43242138624191284,
-0.2884175181388855,
-0.06752987951040268,
0.7611208558082581,
0.8569177389144897,
0.09769368916749954,
-0.31527477502822876,
0.027911322191357613,
0.5314177870750427,
-0.5138535499572754,
0.24636971950531006,
-0.4862172603607178,
0.11229201406240463,
-0.2956887185573578,
-0.14857591688632965,
-0.6650925874710083,
-0.22607433795928955,
0.10911022126674652,
-0.5733829736709595,
0.3061239421367645,
-0.0026361756026744843,
0.8343332409858704,
0.14148910343647003,
-0.5585296750068665,
-0.2983710467815399,
-0.7771785855293274,
0.5649635791778564,
-0.7687851190567017,
0.2984388768672943,
0.6278337836265564,
-0.016818681731820107,
-0.21955148875713348,
-0.781335175037384,
-0.28901147842407227,
-0.04832901433110237,
-0.23886965215206146,
0.17642726004123688,
-0.22973084449768066,
-0.011752494610846043,
0.26178058981895447,
0.2993711829185486,
-0.46382635831832886,
0.2127307802438736,
-0.3325560688972473,
-0.3539716899394989,
0.36451998353004456,
0.05672095715999603,
0.25211185216903687,
-0.46958640217781067,
-0.5322874784469604,
-0.10827595740556717,
-0.7478455901145935,
-0.00310432817786932,
0.08759806305170059,
0.3428618311882019,
0.151942178606987,
0.3127690553665161,
-0.1656733900308609,
0.7589951753616333,
-0.36106109619140625,
-0.1284589171409607,
0.372925341129303,
-0.31902971863746643,
-0.05240532383322716,
-0.11633729189634323,
0.7223727107048035,
0.31715327501296997,
0.0745394378900528,
-0.418072909116745,
-0.3455175757408142,
-0.2978242337703705,
0.2642197012901306,
-0.6213726997375488,
0.09622523933649063,
0.33948373794555664,
-0.17605921626091003,
0.01047932542860508,
0.09270335733890533,
-0.7739810347557068,
-0.5112215280532837,
-0.18860872089862823,
0.16045963764190674,
-0.5393403768539429,
-0.06669112294912338,
0.18243129551410675,
-0.3990864157676697,
0.1577696055173874,
0.3307534456253052,
-0.5452096462249756,
0.23734167218208313,
0.6778045296669006,
0.7995939254760742,
-0.1890995353460312,
-0.42146673798561096,
-0.5506770014762878,
0.15605460107326508,
-0.6047362089157104,
0.5750167369842529,
-0.6417704224586487,
-0.36968547105789185,
0.3054299056529999,
0.3350013494491577,
0.019046274945139885,
-0.6407365798950195,
0.9144684076309204,
-0.513630747795105,
0.200142964720726,
-0.2730334997177124,
-0.6168188452720642,
-0.01121988333761692,
0.09192783385515213,
-0.5968232750892639,
0.8922615647315979,
0.2669449746608734,
-0.8410119414329529,
0.5146338939666748,
-0.40323013067245483,
-0.7819226384162903,
0.13679103553295135,
-0.04424918070435524,
-0.17127682268619537,
0.09014740586280823,
0.5758191347122192,
0.5978392362594604,
-0.18887360394001007,
0.3089512288570404,
-0.23254433274269104,
-0.29153162240982056,
-0.1731007695198059,
-0.15185047686100006,
0.6474155187606812,
0.1670883595943451,
-0.20648293197155,
0.0915195420384407,
-0.8502746224403381,
-0.5322179198265076,
-0.12610913813114166,
-0.37611860036849976,
-0.7154838442802429,
0.20438095927238464,
0.2270292341709137,
0.4423519968986511,
0.14501887559890747,
-0.9066610336303711,
0.24392831325531006,
-0.3801564574241638,
1.0505515336990356,
0.4286120533943176,
0.18332462012767792,
0.4306427240371704,
-0.004856156650930643,
0.5821435451507568,
0.3110406994819641,
-0.09989967942237854,
-0.43356984853744507,
-0.2508084774017334,
-0.7074235677719116,
-0.1957038789987564,
0.3320940136909485,
0.40482574701309204,
-1.165207862854004,
0.21500472724437714,
-0.8197730779647827,
-0.3368491232395172,
-0.5551725029945374,
-0.06488349288702011,
0.23372071981430054,
0.6568707823753357,
0.48184734582901,
-0.19530926644802094,
-0.38897794485092163,
-1.0468531847000122,
-0.13564430177211761,
0.1385612189769745,
-0.20724213123321533,
0.18710735440254211,
0.5955666303634644,
-0.11560406535863876,
1.047334909439087,
-0.32988759875297546,
-0.341403603553772,
-0.2818533182144165,
0.27233216166496277,
0.1567484736442566,
0.4453873634338379,
0.3968079686164856,
-0.8965011239051819,
-0.0033424128778278828,
0.07270081341266632,
-0.6495911478996277,
0.0690985843539238,
-0.3764030337333679,
-0.028893345966935158,
0.3210214078426361,
0.7357800602912903,
-0.4551943838596344,
0.4323795437812805,
0.36602577567100525,
-0.19248780608177185,
0.0017399678472429514,
-0.3119773268699646,
0.11132128536701202,
-1.3586454391479492,
0.12724927067756653,
0.1201934814453125,
-0.7251838445663452,
-0.4399256110191345,
0.0390794463455677,
0.45613086223602295,
-0.28835293650627136,
-0.37926405668258667,
0.6857630014419556,
-0.4090811610221863,
-0.10465603321790695,
-0.37629368901252747,
0.565723180770874,
0.16366195678710938,
0.2943671941757202,
0.3755320608615875,
0.6609776020050049,
0.3459111452102661,
-0.41303008794784546,
0.040849074721336365,
0.4815830588340759,
-0.3559027910232544,
0.5940127372741699,
-0.31144899129867554,
0.017810944467782974,
-0.28913575410842896,
0.6521438360214233,
-0.8175375461578369,
-0.43440553545951843,
0.19395260512828827,
-0.3332013785839081,
0.29195138812065125,
-0.30596959590911865,
-0.6092091202735901,
-0.5366203784942627,
-0.24692116677761078,
-0.13137415051460266,
0.2749667167663574,
-0.4593394100666046,
0.4128199815750122,
0.3824785053730011,
-0.2204972803592682,
-0.4284854233264923,
-0.843064546585083,
0.573036253452301,
-0.2348950207233429,
-0.46121010184288025,
0.4351970851421356,
0.25292688608169556,
0.1908329874277115,
-0.12529249489307404,
-0.2930874526500702,
-0.2599206566810608,
-0.019216349348425865,
0.18221941590309143,
0.10091476887464523,
0.08066975325345993,
0.2732025980949402,
0.29013898968696594,
0.05362216755747795,
0.11157560348510742,
-0.5837203860282898,
0.42646491527557373,
0.15025244653224945,
0.1496865302324295,
-0.023369112983345985,
0.5244207382202148,
0.6108272075653076,
-0.4917602241039276,
0.7661579251289368,
0.8288500308990479,
-0.6454235911369324,
-0.10912679880857468,
-0.449717253446579,
0.011420153081417084,
-0.3555246591567993,
0.2604311406612396,
-0.4544945955276489,
-1.032248616218567,
0.5685347318649292,
0.16446875035762787,
0.13303184509277344,
0.5859286189079285,
0.14007796347141266,
-0.03012675978243351,
0.6198710799217224,
0.5135581493377686,
-0.3164798617362976,
0.5822654366493225,
-0.13757063448429108,
-0.018533730879426003,
-1.0128569602966309,
-0.03604181110858917,
-0.4785463213920593,
-0.07910949736833572,
-0.4917418956756592,
-0.037193216383457184,
0.4488965570926666,
-0.02456529252231121,
0.2318485677242279,
0.9283975958824158,
-0.21169471740722656,
0.23160786926746368,
0.6409063339233398,
0.3674703538417816,
0.18749946355819702,
-0.0700482577085495,
0.08433853089809418,
0.09275245666503906,
-0.5899145007133484,
-0.5449340343475342,
0.9379276633262634,
0.19986143708229065,
0.3569246828556061,
-0.2624264657497406,
0.9879910945892334,
0.16575683653354645,
-0.16145820915699005,
-0.594192385673523,
0.5012938976287842,
-0.2479827105998993,
-0.5670653581619263,
-0.2368200123310089,
-0.5377112627029419,
-1.1998412609100342,
0.02676044963300228,
-0.01922876015305519,
-0.8821588754653931,
0.3626059293746948,
-0.2583136260509491,
-0.2909509539604187,
0.18577703833580017,
-0.6079898476600647,
1.0390958786010742,
0.35237330198287964,
-0.39716482162475586,
-0.07319452613592148,
-0.9714884161949158,
-0.10646418482065201,
-0.37541601061820984,
0.39085516333580017,
-0.00831711944192648,
-0.21004259586334229,
0.7956347465515137,
-0.5171354413032532,
0.7818408012390137,
-0.1691521555185318,
-0.3714897930622101,
0.24841883778572083,
0.06605523824691772,
0.6642798781394958,
0.02019832655787468,
-0.07312905788421631,
-0.07903295010328293,
0.24005812406539917,
-0.542929470539093,
-0.40625661611557007,
0.6505569219589233,
-0.5101706981658936,
-0.5509634613990784,
-0.16543395817279816,
-0.6306397914886475,
-0.2929358184337616,
0.5214428901672363,
0.27732396125793457,
0.6016549468040466,
0.09970299154520035,
0.4423723518848419,
0.4620416462421417,
-0.038911767303943634,
0.7921242117881775,
0.43093329668045044,
-0.0022167079150676727,
-0.2764163017272949,
0.7729271054267883,
0.2008313238620758,
0.09560442715883255,
0.6077451109886169,
-0.06724625080823898,
-0.08515851944684982,
-0.7066332101821899,
-0.3921182453632355,
-0.040878381580114365,
-0.6793362498283386,
-0.10941366106271744,
-0.8359525799751282,
-0.032462503761053085,
-0.5018696188926697,
-0.13434122502803802,
-0.17726516723632812,
-0.4381997883319855,
-0.2055799961090088,
-0.17859265208244324,
0.14992399513721466,
0.520393967628479,
0.0461755245923996,
0.20407810807228088,
-0.9496023058891296,
0.24224421381950378,
-0.38548544049263,
0.07244542986154556,
-0.31207647919654846,
-0.46193572878837585,
-0.39058127999305725,
-0.07050324976444244,
0.11821578443050385,
-0.8517608046531677,
0.3599056005477905,
0.11942148208618164,
0.11698687076568604,
0.05777355656027794,
0.29440003633499146,
0.47981035709381104,
-0.6786193251609802,
0.8225515484809875,
-0.2905574142932892,
-0.9548099637031555,
0.8297641277313232,
-0.6411744952201843,
0.42986127734184265,
0.5152948498725891,
0.5539530515670776,
-0.755660891532898,
-0.5528503060340881,
-0.4881487488746643,
-1.340531587600708,
0.8070934414863586,
0.17350983619689941,
0.24067039787769318,
-0.3425777852535248,
0.6737405061721802,
0.21039153635501862,
0.27478843927383423,
-0.74252849817276,
0.23594620823860168,
-0.04923750460147858,
-0.1842968612909317,
-0.3186091482639313,
-0.05227096751332283,
-0.02390630915760994,
-0.028683701530098915,
0.6339623332023621,
-0.015505260787904263,
-0.07012596726417542,
0.517918050289154,
-0.416720986366272,
0.16530269384384155,
0.3900008797645569,
0.309948205947876,
0.6446586847305298,
-0.2663917541503906,
0.14633506536483765,
-0.038936253637075424,
-0.4709986448287964,
-0.038285501301288605,
0.33043232560157776,
-0.40227851271629333,
0.05947888642549515,
0.5874685049057007,
0.8434900045394897,
0.40441152453422546,
-0.6104827523231506,
0.5656141042709351,
0.34865307807922363,
0.09934581816196442,
-0.2924312949180603,
-0.15202775597572327,
0.07024172693490982,
0.20337937772274017,
0.24835748970508575,
-0.03686334565281868,
0.34786415100097656,
-0.4439893960952759,
0.451183944940567,
0.009748335927724838,
-0.5155882239341736,
-0.09376195073127747,
0.620174765586853,
0.18992604315280914,
0.002253631129860878,
0.5692132711410522,
-0.015351686626672745,
-0.24531027674674988,
0.43612948060035706,
0.5213662981987,
0.7104315757751465,
0.19022460281848907,
0.3070407211780548,
0.37548354268074036,
0.3872820734977722,
-0.20519809424877167,
-0.16382399201393127,
-0.1801186352968216,
-0.35727715492248535,
-0.3674892485141754,
-0.5941835641860962,
-0.15885433554649353,
-0.0030664606019854546,
-0.9340835809707642,
0.1918911337852478,
-0.1280364990234375,
-0.15707899630069733,
0.12419487535953522,
-0.06421910971403122,
-0.5042764544487,
0.29917627573013306,
0.18741677701473236,
1.2099515199661255,
-0.7775341868400574,
1.0104975700378418,
0.5558156371116638,
-0.648661732673645,
-0.4348733127117157,
0.10869984328746796,
-0.2764284610748291,
-0.6798705458641052,
0.22336524724960327,
0.19787077605724335,
0.10594393312931061,
0.19546762108802795,
-0.4217076301574707,
-0.7480021715164185,
0.9572668075561523,
0.3396610915660858,
-0.5591362714767456,
-0.3991016447544098,
0.2212628871202469,
0.6990699172019958,
-0.27899378538131714,
-0.04906894266605377,
0.6264729499816895,
0.46960175037384033,
-0.006793839856982231,
-0.723321795463562,
0.06127181649208069,
-0.14342433214187622,
0.25866594910621643,
0.39297059178352356,
-0.3307294547557831,
0.5024697184562683,
0.3292667269706726,
-0.14513155817985535,
0.018228156492114067,
0.5856908559799194,
-0.4825296103954315,
0.09150334447622299,
0.34069180488586426,
0.47942087054252625,
0.5656955242156982,
-0.2134835124015808,
1.2707891464233398,
-0.2735476493835449,
0.3971898555755615,
1.3143590688705444,
-0.2604437470436096,
1.1399341821670532,
0.5432009696960449,
0.05333835631608963,
0.33575552701950073,
0.8699980974197388,
-0.0573551207780838,
0.37521398067474365,
0.023075345903635025,
-0.09956109523773193,
-0.31227540969848633,
-0.20332682132720947,
-0.08524157106876373,
0.3899534344673157,
0.22493433952331543,
-0.48295778036117554,
-0.3608144521713257,
0.4256835877895355,
0.4449689984321594,
-0.03132866695523262,
-0.36029180884361267,
0.7827869057655334,
0.031086474657058716,
-0.8634474277496338,
0.5339251756668091,
0.04918559640645981,
0.38725546002388,
-0.41948965191841125,
0.29909762740135193,
-0.4941560924053192,
0.10588569939136505,
-0.222069650888443,
-0.8234843015670776,
0.37286806106567383,
0.07141418009996414,
-0.19982415437698364,
-0.2863484025001526,
0.542049765586853,
-0.5461810827255249,
-0.3540264368057251,
0.35277068614959717,
0.41647404432296753,
0.2859742343425751,
-0.2393055409193039,
-0.3057941794395447,
-0.03777115046977997,
-0.04860779270529747,
-0.3095549941062927,
0.26496633887290955,
0.4404744505882263,
-0.2161456048488617,
0.45662301778793335,
0.24048268795013428,
-0.045930806547403336,
0.05438648536801338,
-0.017881736159324646,
0.7802850604057312,
-0.7118302583694458,
-0.3176921010017395,
-0.750904381275177,
0.4391942620277405,
-0.13210368156433105,
-0.36681482195854187,
0.5941919088363647,
0.7139542102813721,
1.0858614444732666,
0.009336900897324085,
0.8531129956245422,
-0.10742466151714325,
0.50345778465271,
-0.5925126671791077,
0.6506476402282715,
-0.6056400537490845,
0.0708533301949501,
-0.3586256504058838,
-0.89017254114151,
-0.35543209314346313,
0.18988139927387238,
-0.44054675102233887,
-0.18778777122497559,
0.7741439938545227,
0.43029165267944336,
-0.20848187804222107,
0.011250793933868408,
0.22274045646190643,
0.3166106343269348,
0.31105974316596985,
0.7168697714805603,
0.4084608852863312,
-0.529269278049469,
0.6881728768348694,
-0.17891621589660645,
-0.15392324328422546,
-0.021912040188908577,
-0.9257083535194397,
-0.7860461473464966,
-0.8622556924819946,
-0.35342922806739807,
-0.4333372712135315,
0.07889598608016968,
0.7293322086334229,
0.5457161664962769,
-0.6544643044471741,
0.06974080950021744,
-0.2643420696258545,
-0.11305547505617142,
0.029678748920559883,
-0.17825917899608612,
0.4228351414203644,
-0.5300726890563965,
-0.8776017427444458,
0.5590802431106567,
0.34318527579307556,
-0.1552860289812088,
0.04314006492495537,
0.30008769035339355,
-0.17270365357398987,
-0.05767403542995453,
0.5339467525482178,
0.25656166672706604,
-0.7500010132789612,
-0.5024574995040894,
-0.13723605871200562,
-0.2161874920129776,
0.4241294264793396,
0.6577361822128296,
-0.8274968862533569,
0.5006434917449951,
0.300770103931427,
0.72064608335495,
0.6566870808601379,
-0.3019784092903137,
0.5745682716369629,
-0.8497617244720459,
0.2640020251274109,
0.2109251469373703,
0.6676745414733887,
0.3744625449180603,
-0.0905119776725769,
0.7501975893974304,
0.15414750576019287,
-0.25056540966033936,
-0.7188497185707092,
0.231276273727417,
-0.9573071002960205,
-0.39415666460990906,
1.2875831127166748,
-0.6975563168525696,
-0.31436610221862793,
0.14299176633358002,
-0.29138511419296265,
0.46712952852249146,
-0.32772693037986755,
0.4675663411617279,
1.0701768398284912,
0.2649584412574768,
-0.1568991243839264,
-0.6879630088806152,
0.4194200932979584,
0.1287730187177658,
-0.8745325207710266,
0.20251072943210602,
0.6228458881378174,
0.22031083703041077,
0.244048073887825,
0.4874962866306305,
-0.23286600410938263,
-0.05300460755825043,
-0.11064469069242477,
-0.051531851291656494,
0.03424122929573059,
-0.4209814965724945,
-0.3856898844242096,
0.247041255235672,
-0.11104445904493332,
-0.03795093670487404
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.03857v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.03857v1
|
MuJo: Multimodal Joint Feature Space Learning for Human Activity Recognition
| 2024-06-06T08:42:36 | 2024-06-06T08:42:36 |
Stefan Gerd Fritsch, Cennet Oguz, Vitor Fortes Rey, Lala Ray, Maximilian Kiefer-Emmanouilidis, Paul Lukowicz
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CV
|
Human Activity Recognition is a longstanding problem in AI with applications
in a broad range of areas: from healthcare, sports and fitness, security, and
human computer interaction to robotics. The performance of HAR in real-world
settings is strongly dependent on the type and quality of the input signal that
can be acquired. Given an unobstructed, high-quality camera view of a scene,
computer vision systems, in particular in conjunction with foundational models
(e.g., CLIP), can today fairly reliably distinguish complex activities. On the
other hand, recognition using modalities such as wearable sensors (which are
often more broadly available, e.g, in mobile phones and smartwatches) is a more
difficult problem, as the signals often contain less information and labeled
training data is more difficult to acquire. In this work, we show how we can
improve HAR performance across different modalities using multimodal
contrastive pretraining. Our approach MuJo (Multimodal Joint Feature Space
Learning), learns a multimodal joint feature space with video, language, pose,
and IMU sensor data. The proposed approach combines contrastive and multitask
learning methods and analyzes different multitasking strategies for learning a
compact shared representation. A large dataset with parallel video, language,
pose, and sensor data points is also introduced to support the research, along
with an analysis of the robustness of the multimodal joint space for
modal-incomplete and low-resource data. On the MM-Fit dataset, our model
achieves an impressive Macro F1-Score of up to 0.992 with only 2% of the train
data and 0.999 when using all available training data for classification tasks.
Moreover, in the scenario where the MM-Fit dataset is unseen, we demonstrate a
generalization performance of up to 0.638.
|
[
-0.2003924697637558,
-0.44973182678222656,
0.3793972134590149,
-0.1310075968503952,
-0.33004873991012573,
0.05666935071349144,
-0.07156569510698318,
-0.5423698425292969,
0.5025034546852112,
0.17991019785404205,
-0.493651807308197,
-0.3872099816799164,
-0.7350662350654602,
-0.2623518407344818,
0.19365110993385315,
0.687110424041748,
-0.22580230236053467,
0.046864017844200134,
-0.20577354729175568,
-0.8495940566062927,
-0.5571267604827881,
-0.5852810740470886,
-0.31611835956573486,
-0.3531550467014313,
0.5657673478126526,
0.32640624046325684,
0.43619194626808167,
0.3383864462375641,
0.4655762016773224,
0.42628341913223267,
0.20196688175201416,
0.5161852240562439,
-0.33482375741004944,
0.1403234452009201,
0.3840673863887787,
-0.2921265661716461,
-0.32276415824890137,
0.041327591985464096,
0.44342276453971863,
0.7109536528587341,
0.12076251953840256,
0.10388433188199997,
0.2017800658941269,
0.6417520642280579,
-0.9653935432434082,
0.4923801124095917,
-0.10388826578855515,
0.1296013444662094,
-0.35418450832366943,
-0.1133311465382576,
0.1693287491798401,
0.24317017197608948,
-0.04608430340886116,
-0.8090766668319702,
0.21234451234340668,
0.1537037044763565,
0.6101619601249695,
0.40599334239959717,
-0.47561562061309814,
-0.21230696141719818,
-0.6388570666313171,
0.891636073589325,
-0.03514112904667854,
0.805368959903717,
0.5769520401954651,
0.3369748294353485,
0.059551797807216644,
-0.3582380414009094,
-0.5423417687416077,
-0.20231078565120697,
-0.30433380603790283,
0.36493489146232605,
0.26511797308921814,
-0.056277018040418625,
0.27061718702316284,
0.33299750089645386,
-0.6242461800575256,
-0.2737458348274231,
-0.4711942970752716,
-0.2375110387802124,
0.4885447025299072,
0.2342560887336731,
-0.026722770184278488,
-0.26119810342788696,
-0.6307387948036194,
-0.5741373896598816,
-0.3124985992908478,
0.5904178023338318,
0.018966952338814735,
0.10718022286891937,
-0.5028209686279297,
0.27377545833587646,
-0.18722742795944214,
0.49984779953956604,
-0.19022858142852783,
-0.5195375680923462,
0.7263809442520142,
-0.5195255279541016,
-0.22357158362865448,
-0.5118609070777893,
0.6049911975860596,
0.06245756149291992,
-0.42892250418663025,
-0.007364100776612759,
-0.3043762445449829,
0.1474778801202774,
0.17941516637802124,
-0.3822290003299713,
-0.4164923131465912,
-0.1215805783867836,
-0.5665855407714844,
0.1704835742712021,
0.2706397771835327,
-0.6509135365486145,
-0.5389211773872375,
-0.5581235289573669,
0.6881959438323975,
-0.35374000668525696,
-0.309386670589447,
0.002085442654788494,
0.06184353679418564,
-0.116933673620224,
0.6025177836418152,
-0.6044129133224487,
0.09940814971923828,
0.10314836353063583,
0.6937636733055115,
-0.2233603447675705,
-0.37037041783332825,
-0.6117739081382751,
0.14220720529556274,
-0.005405368749052286,
0.4100114703178406,
-0.3383972942829132,
-0.3723258674144745,
-0.32109352946281433,
0.14731568098068237,
-0.39880919456481934,
-0.5725395679473877,
0.3135773539543152,
-0.4170772135257721,
0.13266031444072723,
0.045985277742147446,
-0.018793048337101936,
-0.22898034751415253,
0.5225251913070679,
-0.9685341715812683,
0.8728587627410889,
0.22586753964424133,
-0.46442070603370667,
0.5804426074028015,
-1.0248138904571533,
-0.6350553035736084,
-0.25243079662323,
-0.40404126048088074,
-0.8539825677871704,
-0.0501556396484375,
0.2572728395462036,
0.6567971706390381,
0.0904938131570816,
-0.20647595822811127,
-0.4704901874065399,
-0.2002854198217392,
0.465198814868927,
-0.36374619603157043,
0.3785530924797058,
0.4937822222709656,
-0.13394321501255035,
0.36393511295318604,
-0.8244502544403076,
-0.1895257979631424,
0.0003186464309692383,
-0.6948143839836121,
-0.29366087913513184,
-0.07279253751039505,
0.1401771605014801,
0.4110673666000366,
0.02649848163127899,
-0.5843934416770935,
-0.23041637241840363,
0.11761968582868576,
0.17340362071990967,
0.35569092631340027,
-0.38940104842185974,
0.31770220398902893,
-0.36006537079811096,
0.5002942681312561,
0.34579139947891235,
0.18082085251808167,
-0.47082141041755676,
-0.33776694536209106,
-0.5875603556632996,
-0.6783267259597778,
0.11822372674942017,
0.357694536447525,
-0.7753074765205383,
0.5228860378265381,
-0.2865830659866333,
-0.22781434655189514,
-0.4289417266845703,
0.4633779525756836,
0.5256931185722351,
0.4050460755825043,
0.5211102366447449,
-0.39075228571891785,
-0.4683791399002075,
-0.42217788100242615,
0.12106429785490036,
0.17124830186367035,
-0.09227733314037323,
0.6708076596260071,
0.3967877924442291,
-0.3771571218967438,
0.45124343037605286,
-0.5166473984718323,
-0.5998040437698364,
-0.27708274126052856,
0.3596956133842468,
0.24510174989700317,
0.620314359664917,
0.3608856201171875,
-1.2078170776367188,
-0.20527157187461853,
0.0678180381655693,
-0.705535888671875,
0.5677213668823242,
0.013244381174445152,
0.05604938417673111,
-0.0963430404663086,
0.6195043325424194,
-0.42130187153816223,
0.5635590553283691,
0.6912524700164795,
-0.20985595881938934,
0.04071998596191406,
-0.36530807614326477,
0.44068801403045654,
-1.135420560836792,
0.4125307500362396,
0.01529415138065815,
-0.40389078855514526,
-0.4705396294593811,
-0.0889805257320404,
0.06307390332221985,
-0.5818942785263062,
-0.5919784307479858,
0.48021507263183594,
-0.5957417488098145,
-0.05657412111759186,
-0.2532198429107666,
-0.39670252799987793,
0.019386814907193184,
0.8215734958648682,
-0.025259383022785187,
0.5202295780181885,
0.408203125,
-0.9618486762046814,
0.2691262364387512,
0.18681281805038452,
-0.5857549905776978,
0.27664420008659363,
-0.09368131309747696,
0.10117548704147339,
-0.13163793087005615,
0.2740142047405243,
-1.3280346393585205,
-0.9005529880523682,
0.18980973958969116,
-0.412913054227829,
0.5665016174316406,
-0.008687152527272701,
-0.2878805994987488,
-0.2631281614303589,
-0.3324321508407593,
0.8390811681747437,
0.2720910310745239,
-0.6027200818061829,
0.9369657635688782,
0.6670016646385193,
0.2743473947048187,
-0.8034858107566833,
-0.5644202828407288,
-0.6053803563117981,
-0.30340853333473206,
-0.3771713674068451,
0.2915976047515869,
0.004794523119926453,
0.39933502674102783,
-0.19463220238685608,
-0.2404577136039734,
-0.4483548104763031,
0.23198044300079346,
0.608609139919281,
0.41632217168807983,
0.104399673640728,
0.20821453630924225,
-0.2734036147594452,
-0.17680644989013672,
-0.24264027178287506,
0.4184172451496124,
0.5365855097770691,
0.08568859100341797,
-0.5503050684928894,
-0.44960007071495056,
0.38832762837409973,
0.7929468750953674,
-0.17149986326694489,
0.42832887172698975,
1.03582763671875,
-0.4215953052043915,
0.46630939841270447,
-0.41371023654937744,
0.017790615558624268,
-0.44291797280311584,
0.4713478982448578,
-0.36626899242401123,
-0.9121063351631165,
0.24800638854503632,
-0.23551087081432343,
-0.06244439259171486,
0.029250655323266983,
0.37521231174468994,
-0.5909143090248108,
0.9734249711036682,
0.7167719006538391,
-0.03911841660737991,
0.8166288137435913,
-0.36580634117126465,
0.09619604051113129,
-0.9060690402984619,
-0.38888779282569885,
-0.093044213950634,
-0.7899353504180908,
-0.4442114233970642,
-0.6003575921058655,
0.8734130859375,
0.0029332840349525213,
0.07634282857179642,
0.1966041773557663,
-0.05770498886704445,
0.40917208790779114,
0.4411928057670593,
0.7041352987289429,
-0.062425628304481506,
0.028069209307432175,
0.00925122294574976,
-0.11972904205322266,
-0.651465892791748,
0.017772383987903595,
0.9554955959320068,
0.23315615952014923,
1.0369045734405518,
0.18833598494529724,
0.6130419373512268,
0.26677200198173523,
0.23248447477817535,
-0.6290869116783142,
0.3217912018299103,
-0.30857303738594055,
-0.5799956917762756,
-0.20758001506328583,
-0.31245410442352295,
-1.2756367921829224,
0.3816528618335724,
-0.6470596790313721,
-0.31093040108680725,
0.29718104004859924,
0.5910031795501709,
-0.6098788976669312,
0.2629466652870178,
-0.8655760288238525,
1.0529268980026245,
-0.43885159492492676,
-0.475810170173645,
-0.4438420832157135,
-0.9390763640403748,
0.34102004766464233,
0.11434546113014221,
0.46561428904533386,
-0.18411709368228912,
0.06361545622348785,
0.7277366518974304,
0.09734437614679337,
1.050095796585083,
-0.37840232253074646,
0.49293869733810425,
0.03265661746263504,
-0.21097078919410706,
0.2586216628551483,
-0.008140559308230877,
0.33110901713371277,
0.11000664532184601,
-0.16206589341163635,
-0.47191786766052246,
-0.3880372643470764,
0.49336734414100647,
-0.8895331621170044,
-0.18974658846855164,
-0.3105689287185669,
-0.6137194633483887,
-0.32551291584968567,
0.09140021353960037,
0.10163156688213348,
0.4400600790977478,
-0.19032344222068787,
0.5320342779159546,
0.5877326726913452,
-0.012256443500518799,
0.3708248436450958,
0.1287463754415512,
-0.012494144029915333,
-0.4456251561641693,
1.2171456813812256,
-0.0996541902422905,
-0.16514314711093903,
0.6425720453262329,
0.11692357808351517,
-0.44310295581817627,
-0.3151875436306,
-0.18209423124790192,
0.0907459706068039,
-0.6139804720878601,
-0.291396826505661,
-0.6450851559638977,
-0.019237089902162552,
-0.22647053003311157,
-0.15823328495025635,
-0.29420268535614014,
-0.12906624376773834,
-0.29736024141311646,
0.29669469594955444,
-0.19280582666397095,
0.3399980664253235,
-0.11214663833379745,
0.33427128195762634,
-0.9033180475234985,
0.593212902545929,
0.6061573028564453,
0.2591397166252136,
-0.32169973850250244,
-0.23572085797786713,
-0.577492892742157,
-0.17230768501758575,
-0.5724430680274963,
-0.2981138527393341,
0.16674189269542694,
0.25116321444511414,
0.6310120224952698,
0.4672424793243408,
-0.06875927001237869,
0.7153187394142151,
-0.005354125518351793,
0.44496214389801025,
0.9019513726234436,
-0.5370712876319885,
0.5358776450157166,
0.029421014711260796,
0.4370812475681305,
0.605705201625824,
0.6936076879501343,
-0.180193230509758,
0.3096217215061188,
-0.5567318201065063,
-0.6770482659339905,
0.7466051578521729,
-0.04794221371412277,
-0.04711203649640083,
0.3760472238063812,
-0.019396817311644554,
0.3698645532131195,
0.20074914395809174,
-0.9615947008132935,
-0.041876327246427536,
-0.4554981291294098,
-0.282309889793396,
-0.22818176448345184,
0.14418341219425201,
-0.3323553800582886,
-0.27960464358329773,
0.12317537516355515,
-0.32783713936805725,
0.37108519673347473,
0.015027008019387722,
-0.37535208463668823,
-0.022118639200925827,
0.2357322722673416,
0.5806841850280762,
0.5666723251342773,
-0.11598485708236694,
0.23745720088481903,
0.18587447702884674,
-0.5136383771896362,
0.2818545401096344,
0.12178058922290802,
0.4182202219963074,
-0.1118629053235054,
0.3196025490760803,
0.8768517374992371,
0.40249305963516235,
-0.6723160743713379,
0.7723066210746765,
-0.007887640967965126,
-0.21401409804821014,
-0.32824385166168213,
0.48548468947410583,
-0.26391851902008057,
0.40437981486320496,
0.08582115173339844,
0.6222909688949585,
0.13468320667743683,
-0.6681641936302185,
-0.017826899886131287,
0.4139898717403412,
-0.32963478565216064,
-0.607320249080658,
0.5819262862205505,
0.3734566569328308,
0.02167067490518093,
0.3386342525482178,
-0.14166465401649475,
-0.2336917519569397,
0.3723192512989044,
0.10904537886381149,
0.5154708027839661,
-0.4802604913711548,
-0.17258518934249878,
0.6225346326828003,
-0.1898937076330185,
0.19795739650726318,
0.526454746723175,
-0.5812793970108032,
-0.8661292791366577,
-0.30816149711608887,
-0.4308013916015625,
-0.3613089621067047,
0.4834223985671997,
-0.4477487802505493,
0.22667686641216278,
-0.46046340465545654,
-0.128738135099411,
0.011871498078107834,
-0.15011709928512573,
-1.1033855676651,
0.4362936019897461,
0.30182263255119324,
0.16598498821258545,
-0.7851700782775879,
1.06300687789917,
1.1010454893112183,
-0.2696263790130615,
-0.3723302483558655,
-0.028404127806425095,
-0.008748706430196762,
-0.7928723692893982,
0.7251755595207214,
0.5717792510986328,
-0.30878353118896484,
-0.5011588335037231,
-0.2410919964313507,
-0.8296858072280884,
1.3514419794082642,
0.18877097964286804,
-0.361480712890625,
0.15407614409923553,
-0.05410301685333252,
0.17604827880859375,
-0.43205398321151733,
-0.0909598171710968,
0.05012993887066841,
0.33221298456192017,
0.02999640628695488,
-0.757966935634613,
-0.28526267409324646,
-0.23345543444156647,
-0.13997004926204681,
0.29563722014427185,
-0.6823983788490295,
0.7861392498016357,
-0.27958688139915466,
-0.3096145689487457,
-0.15385989844799042,
0.6532282829284668,
0.437000036239624,
0.6954779028892517,
1.0406864881515503,
0.4874120354652405,
0.6863086819648743,
-0.030049333348870277,
0.869062066078186,
-0.01450458075851202,
0.10965678840875626,
0.8183405995368958,
-0.28070467710494995,
0.7125430107116699,
0.3316836953163147,
-0.2103101760149002,
0.311720073223114,
0.29874446988105774,
0.34205079078674316,
0.8136045932769775,
-0.16782574355602264,
-0.4567667245864868,
-0.4098849594593048,
0.13672533631324768,
-0.14344632625579834,
0.8244314789772034,
0.6378104090690613,
-0.10243554413318634,
-0.09879974275827408,
0.5051220059394836,
-0.28906771540641785,
-0.13448719680309296,
-0.21112209558486938,
0.6475549340248108,
-0.27526551485061646,
-0.6367208361625671,
0.37106332182884216,
-0.24441978335380554,
0.9362637996673584,
-0.8834260702133179,
-0.15570741891860962,
0.02358817495405674,
0.3068199157714844,
-0.26977217197418213,
-0.5582612752914429,
0.39619895815849304,
-0.35657909512519836,
-0.35843437910079956,
-0.18354444205760956,
0.7881495952606201,
-0.340615838766098,
-0.13584356009960175,
0.21729902923107147,
0.5576555728912354,
0.1950293481349945,
0.12793035805225372,
-0.7357122302055359,
0.018232837319374084,
-0.12663871049880981,
-0.0738971009850502,
0.7276398539543152,
0.15473012626171112,
0.031416889280080795,
0.40267330408096313,
0.7684209942817688,
-0.4115273356437683,
-0.04986608028411865,
-0.29779404401779175,
1.034926176071167,
-0.6305469274520874,
-0.7488847970962524,
-0.2732182741165161,
0.5723865032196045,
-0.024091968312859535,
-0.5151067972183228,
0.20911310613155365,
0.5411049127578735,
0.9812269806861877,
-0.13812768459320068,
0.5302621126174927,
-0.3050236701965332,
0.754534900188446,
-0.7272459268569946,
0.48773324489593506,
-0.8274077773094177,
0.027459008619189262,
0.11278585344552994,
-0.507796585559845,
-0.3562450110912323,
0.7735806107521057,
0.016519173979759216,
0.12245559692382812,
0.7255361080169678,
0.6493650078773499,
-0.7515779733657837,
-0.3086504340171814,
0.6495465040206909,
-0.224324569106102,
0.1641009896993637,
0.5174918174743652,
0.8652818202972412,
-0.42380988597869873,
0.7188515663146973,
-0.3680981397628784,
-0.380237340927124,
-0.4321608245372772,
-0.5554705262184143,
-0.7355711460113525,
-0.8516819477081299,
-0.24799872934818268,
-0.06920071691274643,
-0.23635023832321167,
0.9236466884613037,
1.264430046081543,
-0.7584260702133179,
-0.2971576750278473,
0.29406508803367615,
-0.13708047568798065,
-0.40862929821014404,
-0.13972719013690948,
0.3702734410762787,
-0.3114810585975647,
-0.514910101890564,
0.6627984642982483,
0.17759981751441956,
-0.031083500012755394,
-0.10760199278593063,
-0.496959924697876,
-0.3915548026561737,
-0.6603434085845947,
0.690601110458374,
0.5608509182929993,
-0.5082623362541199,
-0.08468910306692123,
-0.20468397438526154,
-0.031122013926506042,
0.4709545373916626,
1.169031023979187,
-0.7451202273368835,
0.5975905060768127,
0.5193738341331482,
0.8183809518814087,
0.6833164095878601,
-0.1533346027135849,
-0.07209029048681259,
-1.1672831773757935,
0.43495237827301025,
0.21996675431728363,
0.7300594449043274,
0.2905312478542328,
-0.20482341945171356,
0.5656948685646057,
0.44230300188064575,
-0.5322765111923218,
-0.31641560792922974,
0.1659746915102005,
-1.3080155849456787,
-0.24931497871875763,
0.6841657161712646,
-0.47197407484054565,
-0.31313708424568176,
-0.5201277136802673,
-0.2755664885044098,
0.194147527217865,
-0.28261029720306396,
0.8910130262374878,
0.48173317313194275,
-0.6331560611724854,
-0.36864182353019714,
-0.3986436426639557,
0.30366602540016174,
0.4775497317314148,
-0.8337716460227966,
-0.13748162984848022,
0.5692226886749268,
0.1654060035943985,
0.5684198141098022,
0.7141239047050476,
-0.09386315941810608,
0.6620205640792847,
-0.21566776931285858,
0.0217057466506958,
-0.286467045545578,
-0.4826790690422058,
-0.18061183393001556,
0.4389726221561432,
-0.22024166584014893,
-0.7427598834037781
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.03855v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.03855v2
|
Performance of large language models in numerical vs. semantic medical knowledge: Benchmarking on evidence-based Q&As
| 2024-06-06T08:41:46 | 2024-07-01T11:36:02 |
Eden Avnat, Michal Levy, Daniel Herstain, Elia Yanko, Daniel Ben Joya, Michal Tzuchman Katz, Dafna Eshel, Sahar Laros, Yael Dagan, Shahar Barami, Joseph Mermelstein, Shahar Ovadia, Noam Shomron, Varda Shalev, Raja-Elie E. Abdulnour
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Clinical problem-solving requires processing of semantic medical knowledge
such as illness scripts and numerical medical knowledge of diagnostic tests for
evidence-based decision-making. As large language models (LLMs) show promising
results in many aspects of language-based clinical practice, their ability to
generate non-language evidence-based answers to clinical questions is
inherently limited by tokenization. Therefore, we evaluated LLMs' performance
on two question types: numeric (correlating findings) and semantic
(differentiating entities) while examining differences within and between LLMs
in medical aspects and comparing their performance to humans. To generate
straightforward multi-choice questions and answers (QAs) based on
evidence-based medicine (EBM), we used a comprehensive medical knowledge graph
(encompassed data from more than 50,00 peer-reviewed articles) and created the
"EBMQA". EBMQA contains 105,000 QAs labeled with medical and non-medical topics
and classified into numerical or semantic questions. We benchmarked this
dataset using more than 24,500 QAs on two state-of-the-art LLMs: Chat-GPT4 and
Claude3-Opus. We evaluated the LLMs accuracy on semantic and numerical question
types and according to sub-labeled topics. For validation, six medical experts
were tested on 100 numerical EBMQA questions. We found that both LLMs excelled
more in semantic than numerical QAs, with Claude3 surpassing GPT4 in numerical
QAs. However, both LLMs showed inter and intra gaps in different medical
aspects and remained inferior to humans. Thus, their medical advice should be
addressed carefully.
|
[
-0.22509075701236725,
-0.9581385850906372,
1.0386440753936768,
0.21847355365753174,
-0.12693537771701813,
-0.03905567526817322,
-0.2406962811946869,
-0.5652188062667847,
0.26212865114212036,
0.5590877532958984,
-0.1939302682876587,
-0.7189633846282959,
-0.7998842000961304,
0.34724360704421997,
-0.09451639652252197,
0.7882532477378845,
-0.06446171551942825,
0.7449173927307129,
-0.6329491138458252,
-0.3127360939979553,
-0.3897795081138611,
-0.6393001079559326,
-0.6847826838493347,
-0.2934379577636719,
0.6123180389404297,
0.16513539850711823,
0.7270062565803528,
0.41265299916267395,
0.7621201276779175,
0.28091955184936523,
-0.1610805243253708,
0.18359221518039703,
-0.342629075050354,
0.10936689376831055,
-0.2537892460823059,
-0.5459960699081421,
-0.4506600499153137,
-0.30355340242385864,
0.40748924016952515,
0.959274172782898,
-0.17675161361694336,
0.06688448786735535,
-0.4159555733203888,
0.5520785450935364,
-0.35206615924835205,
0.25998035073280334,
-0.5977916121482849,
-0.05657286196947098,
0.0009957305155694485,
-0.22884449362754822,
-0.37039676308631897,
-0.5866993069648743,
0.2516156733036041,
-0.725696325302124,
-0.031166983768343925,
0.12199745327234268,
0.8021897077560425,
0.28695937991142273,
-0.6296595335006714,
-0.513606607913971,
-0.3844469487667084,
0.661980926990509,
-0.9427971839904785,
0.35396820306777954,
0.41080689430236816,
0.06954705715179443,
-0.36728987097740173,
-0.6604459881782532,
-0.3791562616825104,
-0.3148067891597748,
0.022196264937520027,
0.07342575490474701,
-0.13844405114650726,
0.20570914447307587,
0.5605931878089905,
0.04445706680417061,
-0.7532239556312561,
0.3250128924846649,
-0.40211349725723267,
-0.41362932324409485,
0.5795043110847473,
0.31667640805244446,
0.3980858027935028,
-0.028143782168626785,
-0.09708277136087418,
-0.16044393181800842,
-0.8882908225059509,
-0.10052748769521713,
-0.31411534547805786,
-0.11079217493534088,
0.13282062113285065,
0.6738957166671753,
-0.36933082342147827,
0.6950823068618774,
-0.17305591702461243,
-0.5144182443618774,
0.37357738614082336,
-0.21266193687915802,
-0.037236254662275314,
0.040861960500478745,
0.898350715637207,
0.6232122778892517,
0.2918644845485687,
-0.1424541175365448,
0.0149457436054945,
0.21814686059951782,
0.07459112256765366,
-0.9782834053039551,
-0.0649074837565422,
0.34110474586486816,
-0.4673376679420471,
0.07608041912317276,
-0.3000694811344147,
-0.5384815335273743,
-0.35276687145233154,
-0.3227093815803528,
0.414329469203949,
-0.4685860872268677,
-0.2661745250225067,
0.3733803629875183,
-0.028943713754415512,
0.15427270531654358,
0.50194251537323,
-0.5504642128944397,
0.5125912427902222,
0.6946104168891907,
0.48022058606147766,
-0.0962570458650589,
0.011265154927968979,
-0.3555077910423279,
-0.07624472677707672,
-0.5104606747627258,
1.0214486122131348,
-0.49612531065940857,
-0.2952345311641693,
0.014168455265462399,
0.011340681463479996,
-0.21321918070316315,
-0.8770378232002258,
0.5438167452812195,
-0.6376705169677734,
0.1796279400587082,
-0.5639795660972595,
-0.8495045304298401,
-0.1780620962381363,
0.3337571322917938,
-0.48787999153137207,
0.6537023782730103,
-0.18842993676662445,
-0.6103229522705078,
0.6642692685127258,
-0.5097339153289795,
-0.2805010676383972,
0.031251389533281326,
-0.5678004026412964,
-0.27683618664741516,
0.055501360446214676,
0.2250734567642212,
0.3812028467655182,
-0.7446514964103699,
0.5732253193855286,
-0.4308602213859558,
-0.13556736707687378,
0.46084749698638916,
-0.24997399747371674,
0.29528412222862244,
0.1480761021375656,
-0.19325409829616547,
0.031697582453489304,
-0.8405641317367554,
0.26263031363487244,
0.14454923570156097,
-0.20788516104221344,
-0.4710302948951721,
0.08273084461688995,
-0.2893705368041992,
0.5792519450187683,
0.09105203300714493,
-0.666644811630249,
-0.04947783425450325,
-0.4475630223751068,
0.3272677958011627,
0.16734760999679565,
0.22140619158744812,
-0.2193635255098343,
-0.6179916858673096,
0.42043954133987427,
0.11008831858634949,
0.052996352314949036,
0.07511286437511444,
-0.8353059887886047,
-0.509091317653656,
-0.15595762431621552,
0.335686594247818,
0.4299642741680145,
-0.8805879354476929,
0.023757329210639,
-0.41330936551094055,
-0.3890172839164734,
-0.5559133291244507,
-0.17549742758274078,
0.5511432886123657,
0.7381218075752258,
0.4370017647743225,
-0.4574037194252014,
-0.08008334040641785,
-0.994053065776825,
-0.14912348985671997,
-0.3634200990200043,
-0.0023798977490514517,
0.5362768769264221,
0.6561898589134216,
-0.04674133285880089,
0.6018762588500977,
-0.5165694952011108,
0.004929781425744295,
0.10106121003627777,
0.14233694970607758,
0.13920025527477264,
0.09929661452770233,
0.3154001533985138,
-0.695907473564148,
-0.344952255487442,
-0.03362371027469635,
-0.8934634923934937,
-0.2912388741970062,
0.14734520018100739,
0.01904071308672428,
0.20203696191310883,
0.39663371443748474,
-0.6921055912971497,
0.31839367747306824,
0.349844753742218,
-0.5417922139167786,
0.44302332401275635,
-0.4094686210155487,
0.31257492303848267,
-0.8938685655593872,
0.15015874803066254,
-0.03918932378292084,
-0.08787784725427628,
-0.594698965549469,
-0.23941148817539215,
0.06667344272136688,
0.0902647078037262,
-0.41005685925483704,
0.4746275842189789,
-0.20473328232765198,
-0.15994411706924438,
-0.020786842331290245,
0.2187526971101761,
0.059179678559303284,
0.29287654161453247,
0.22402340173721313,
0.5287487506866455,
0.43098798394203186,
-0.49689361453056335,
0.2138327956199646,
0.31851524114608765,
-0.47461050748825073,
0.4689251482486725,
-0.9570726752281189,
0.0778392031788826,
-0.10173682868480682,
0.15429028868675232,
-0.935380220413208,
-0.17008797824382782,
-0.10951513797044754,
-0.43765461444854736,
0.14746727049350739,
-0.0435321219265461,
-0.7046731114387512,
-0.24968768656253815,
0.02480883151292801,
0.6204125881195068,
0.4804377257823944,
0.013931356370449066,
0.2563819885253906,
0.4118858873844147,
-0.583469569683075,
-0.37790635228157043,
-0.40355274081230164,
0.0866769403219223,
-0.09419596195220947,
-0.8476188778877258,
0.27761057019233704,
0.0842544212937355,
-0.5078591704368591,
0.12076923996210098,
0.02865554392337799,
-0.21863877773284912,
-0.054716408252716064,
-0.023105140775442123,
0.3132993280887604,
-0.38430076837539673,
0.48104456067085266,
0.07769612222909927,
-0.09216319769620895,
0.44049859046936035,
0.05315951257944107,
0.525499701499939,
-0.10207834839820862,
-0.7520341873168945,
-0.2918742597103119,
0.3967786431312561,
0.814765214920044,
-0.24959713220596313,
0.8670920729637146,
0.22398370504379272,
-0.3944861590862274,
0.24665603041648865,
-0.897730827331543,
-0.2729930579662323,
-0.27899864315986633,
0.5841709971427917,
-0.22258764505386353,
-1.0534576177597046,
0.6626631021499634,
-0.07280994206666946,
0.10612346976995468,
0.6883610486984253,
0.9398360848426819,
0.07770657539367676,
1.2224682569503784,
-0.16391249001026154,
0.2770754396915436,
-0.16780909895896912,
-0.04545224830508232,
-0.0244520902633667,
-0.5662330985069275,
-0.42064884305000305,
-0.5238025784492493,
0.09338743984699249,
-0.5895446538925171,
-0.6179255843162537,
0.7660474181175232,
-0.22289367020130157,
-0.2644522786140442,
-0.18425221741199493,
-0.3640992045402527,
0.10530219972133636,
0.1863885521888733,
0.21795931458473206,
0.5152387619018555,
-0.18500681221485138,
-0.3543499708175659,
-0.0994589701294899,
-0.9281563758850098,
-0.4610356092453003,
1.401820182800293,
0.48629528284072876,
0.6356203556060791,
0.15261177718639374,
0.43853577971458435,
-0.05283239483833313,
0.31598976254463196,
-0.7317129969596863,
0.5517047643661499,
-0.0038265411276370287,
-0.6234146952629089,
-0.2979183793067932,
-0.7139986157417297,
-0.970471978187561,
0.5907756090164185,
-0.36649951338768005,
-0.2572002112865448,
-0.018872452899813652,
-0.15269656479358673,
-0.44681516289711,
0.12977272272109985,
-0.6322364807128906,
0.7239135503768921,
-0.4056883752346039,
-0.30874794721603394,
-0.2693123519420624,
-0.6565680503845215,
0.2330717295408249,
-0.17224518954753876,
0.3550727665424347,
-0.212901309132576,
-0.2869347333908081,
0.8504163026809692,
-0.49126115441322327,
0.6016998887062073,
-0.18239594995975494,
-0.13182716071605682,
0.08838816732168198,
-0.14532211422920227,
0.2498628944158554,
0.21666188538074493,
0.020726798102259636,
0.25189468264579773,
0.5842234492301941,
-0.41961362957954407,
-0.6368504166603088,
0.5335115194320679,
-0.7997370958328247,
-0.6691626906394958,
-0.5895740985870361,
-0.39115941524505615,
-0.596987783908844,
0.13171546161174774,
0.13062937557697296,
0.892643928527832,
-0.19463008642196655,
0.20274776220321655,
0.8570606112480164,
-0.634833037853241,
-0.0967191606760025,
0.8986522555351257,
-0.2821522057056427,
-0.4809451997280121,
0.5386577844619751,
0.15092484652996063,
0.5381495952606201,
0.43194571137428284,
0.24953709542751312,
-0.5618270635604858,
-0.876582145690918,
-0.4387422204017639,
0.5305152535438538,
-0.6588391661643982,
-0.08981165289878845,
-0.8124874830245972,
-0.19025938212871552,
-0.31806498765945435,
0.2535480260848999,
-0.1470247507095337,
-0.32716935873031616,
0.06639760732650757,
0.1698482781648636,
0.4800626039505005,
0.709628164768219,
0.2566060721874237,
-0.4419172704219818,
-0.880858838558197,
0.3613259196281433,
0.19305212795734406,
0.301945298910141,
-0.06365777552127838,
-0.39078086614608765,
-0.07015049457550049,
0.13241271674633026,
-0.059834402054548264,
-0.6548903584480286,
0.26264920830726624,
0.08261054009199142,
0.5245400071144104,
0.4035414159297943,
0.07090512663125992,
0.7102186679840088,
-0.5333513617515564,
0.6225401163101196,
0.24357134103775024,
-0.40853527188301086,
0.22522813081741333,
-0.3409406244754791,
0.2127375453710556,
0.6152041554450989,
0.532171905040741,
-0.6045958399772644,
-0.3824070692062378,
-0.48050782084465027,
-0.6948169469833374,
0.4417010545730591,
0.11973655968904495,
-0.22964149713516235,
-0.3318539261817932,
0.36637839674949646,
0.019217990338802338,
0.23194776475429535,
-0.3295617997646332,
-0.01435763482004404,
0.2768551707267761,
-0.14559215307235718,
-0.003872060915455222,
-0.19013382494449615,
-0.4212702810764313,
-0.3391403257846832,
0.37680867314338684,
-0.17056746780872345,
0.37930795550346375,
0.5451539754867554,
-0.04568760097026825,
0.048312362283468246,
0.4587433338165283,
0.7661560773849487,
0.9544343948364258,
-0.0710102841258049,
-0.015096036717295647,
0.42851296067237854,
-0.42905527353286743,
0.061793066561222076,
0.00040888178045861423,
0.05395734682679176,
-0.10710465908050537,
0.6799507141113281,
0.6896621584892273,
0.3789600133895874,
-1.125243902206421,
0.5891132950782776,
-0.26124149560928345,
-0.5290274024009705,
-0.27658212184906006,
-0.09877367317676544,
0.17697857320308685,
-0.03763214126229286,
-0.0811861902475357,
-0.11294037103652954,
0.11557760089635849,
-0.5772513151168823,
0.17562489211559296,
0.36309802532196045,
-0.20249497890472412,
-0.12596161663532257,
0.5424520373344421,
-0.0007006534724496305,
0.03962286561727524,
0.533875048160553,
0.056418877094984055,
-0.32037854194641113,
0.7153615355491638,
0.5412324666976929,
0.23139700293540955,
0.16553613543510437,
0.16358299553394318,
0.30090418457984924,
-0.0881335586309433,
-0.21576569974422455,
0.5220375061035156,
0.33693021535873413,
-0.7578034400939941,
-0.7658461332321167,
-0.38136836886405945,
-0.6069269180297852,
0.10639040172100067,
-0.7507724761962891,
0.06795122474431992,
-0.36162588000297546,
-0.290239155292511,
0.1502709835767746,
0.021395651623606682,
-0.649566113948822,
0.2790132761001587,
-0.06697636842727661,
0.9847995042800903,
-0.5670294761657715,
0.570988655090332,
0.9613736271858215,
-0.3494257926940918,
-0.8543869853019714,
-0.28681036829948425,
-0.12475801259279251,
-0.904118001461029,
0.5797255039215088,
-0.09724622964859009,
0.09382374584674835,
-0.3379116654396057,
-0.2657352387905121,
-0.948334276676178,
1.0857003927230835,
0.2352101057767868,
-0.405722051858902,
-0.11656899005174637,
0.34005188941955566,
0.9209776520729065,
-0.3300945460796356,
0.6171221137046814,
0.4208594858646393,
0.35805007815361023,
0.4649691581726074,
-1.292493224143982,
0.02991591952741146,
-0.2731999158859253,
-0.16660000383853912,
0.2674122452735901,
-0.673953652381897,
0.6828425526618958,
-0.23127608001232147,
0.011505813337862492,
0.027743715792894363,
0.16778185963630676,
0.5316123962402344,
0.6111355423927307,
0.342906653881073,
0.724145233631134,
0.8267098665237427,
-0.23573368787765503,
1.102683663368225,
-0.5891181230545044,
0.17551541328430176,
0.6125355362892151,
-0.637630820274353,
0.842108428478241,
0.3354761600494385,
-0.33913514018058777,
0.48822733759880066,
0.685573399066925,
0.19227755069732666,
0.36728960275650024,
0.3403891324996948,
-0.24187597632408142,
-0.4591973125934601,
-0.253217488527298,
-0.6005330085754395,
0.257648766040802,
0.5733978152275085,
-0.3327159881591797,
-0.041706983000040054,
-0.12850089371204376,
0.3037068843841553,
-0.04603544622659683,
-0.2664387822151184,
1.0928233861923218,
0.2373470962047577,
-0.864453911781311,
0.7469271421432495,
0.05041392147541046,
0.2318064272403717,
-0.767157256603241,
-0.08881545066833496,
0.045064374804496765,
-0.06967455893754959,
-0.19777223467826843,
-0.7459388375282288,
0.1461586058139801,
0.09820009768009186,
-0.051060523837804794,
0.09215988963842392,
0.6281699538230896,
-0.3202841281890869,
-0.5253840684890747,
0.16993434727191925,
0.724291980266571,
0.33145201206207275,
0.08107974380254745,
-0.5591146349906921,
-0.10403294116258621,
-0.31335774064064026,
-0.04993245378136635,
0.5520234704017639,
0.6169435977935791,
-0.23838958144187927,
0.8668426275253296,
0.714310884475708,
0.4746621549129486,
-0.047193512320518494,
0.282770574092865,
1.0350676774978638,
-0.6305603384971619,
-0.17383277416229248,
-0.7447236776351929,
0.14345060288906097,
-0.13302186131477356,
-0.3298754096031189,
0.5030843615531921,
0.49388188123703003,
0.5770313143730164,
0.11354541778564453,
0.5453446507453918,
0.07419735938310623,
0.6551423072814941,
-0.8153354525566101,
0.5548886060714722,
-0.5768466591835022,
0.2220485359430313,
-0.2732035517692566,
-0.5331122875213623,
-0.4229849576950073,
0.41310304403305054,
-0.671613335609436,
0.2207721769809723,
0.938531219959259,
0.6870846152305603,
0.3482542335987091,
0.1442108005285263,
0.4973198473453522,
0.4100612699985504,
0.385801762342453,
0.8661159873008728,
0.8468342423439026,
-0.17556317150592804,
0.16351664066314697,
0.09276292473077774,
-0.3163762390613556,
-0.09253905713558197,
-0.5742062330245972,
-0.9035019278526306,
-0.28539910912513733,
-0.21835197508335114,
-0.3172832429409027,
0.02343129739165306,
1.2646589279174805,
0.5274820923805237,
-0.7932711839675903,
0.00031585447140969336,
0.23055139183998108,
-0.04795428365468979,
-0.07909391820430756,
-0.15520553290843964,
0.6085342168807983,
-0.22178751230239868,
-0.23710814118385315,
0.2333860993385315,
0.35472968220710754,
-0.24270585179328918,
-0.14222155511379242,
0.04073342680931091,
0.04500523954629898,
0.030323298647999763,
0.7465770244598389,
0.11414927989244461,
-0.792117178440094,
-0.07635904103517532,
0.2301294207572937,
-0.17802150547504425,
0.08632700145244598,
0.7694038152694702,
-0.6721932888031006,
0.4272238314151764,
0.44191572070121765,
0.7972227334976196,
0.25595253705978394,
-0.03851427510380745,
0.49336445331573486,
0.00009281439270125702,
-0.19864676892757416,
0.5353493094444275,
0.4336322247982025,
0.13766856491565704,
-0.020789505913853645,
0.25873303413391113,
0.309658408164978,
-0.8299846053123474,
-0.5479957461357117,
0.041591059416532516,
-0.8280022144317627,
-0.1462792307138443,
1.3676555156707764,
-0.1884465217590332,
-0.0243097934871912,
-0.4848683774471283,
-0.280133992433548,
-0.10542500764131546,
-0.4258265495300293,
0.821431040763855,
0.827906608581543,
-0.4360041916370392,
0.16628365218639374,
-0.8100998997688293,
0.5084671378135681,
0.5484789609909058,
-0.9599659442901611,
-0.23061193525791168,
0.5657386779785156,
0.4593173861503601,
-0.04129905253648758,
0.8309698104858398,
-0.6055564284324646,
0.48481762409210205,
-0.18800517916679382,
-0.09347832202911377,
0.0035621735733002424,
-0.07325796782970428,
-0.19118081033229828,
0.23083171248435974,
0.35247641801834106,
0.1988999992609024
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.03853v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.03853v1
|
Speculative Decoding via Early-exiting for Faster LLM Inference with Thompson Sampling Control Mechanism
| 2024-06-06T08:40:28 | 2024-06-06T08:40:28 |
Jiahao Liu, Qifan Wang, Jingang Wang, Xunliang Cai
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The recent advancements in large language models (LLMs) have been
extraordinary, yet the escalating inference costs associated with them present
challenges in real-world applications. To address these challenges, we propose
a novel approach called Early-exiting Speculative Decoding (EESD) with lossless
acceleration. Specifically, EESD utilizes a segment of the LLM to generate
draft tokens, incorporating Early-exiting structures after the first N layers.
To enhance the quality of draft tokens, a self-distillation method is
integrated. This early-exiting design not only reduces deployment and training
costs but also significantly accelerates the token generation speed. Moreover,
we introduce a novel sampling mechanism that leverages Thompson Sampling to
regulate the generation processes, automatically determining the quantity of
draft tokens in each round. The original LLM is then employed to validate these
draft tokens through a single forward pass, and thus guarantees that the final
output text maintains a distribution consistent with vanilla auto-regressive
decoding. The experimental results on both 13B and 70B models demonstrate that
our approach decodes tokens at a markedly accelerated rate compared to prior
methods, showing the effectiveness of our approach.
|
[
-0.1198253333568573,
-0.7569224834442139,
0.49847573041915894,
0.29740458726882935,
-0.6273748278617859,
0.344870388507843,
-0.09493906050920486,
-0.4126775860786438,
0.22301410138607025,
0.3776854872703552,
-0.7152255773544312,
-0.5571714639663696,
-0.6640070080757141,
0.2338898479938507,
-0.6037760376930237,
0.6151453256607056,
-0.05865565314888954,
-0.29477956891059875,
0.1983184814453125,
0.4278348684310913,
0.01336225587874651,
-0.4905218780040741,
-0.8908573985099792,
-0.07391458004713058,
0.3538455069065094,
0.266694039106369,
0.2552928924560547,
1.0759896039962769,
0.1698421835899353,
0.2687600255012512,
-0.34249716997146606,
0.17289964854717255,
-0.7233133912086487,
0.10736194998025894,
0.3194246292114258,
-0.5278419852256775,
-0.39567455649375916,
-0.08329504728317261,
0.5054762363433838,
0.5298994183540344,
-0.5248632431030273,
0.0026962626725435257,
0.09559499472379684,
0.4342971444129944,
-0.8073410987854004,
0.1056855171918869,
-0.6758968234062195,
0.055459000170230865,
-0.5234121084213257,
-0.48274269700050354,
-0.9740553498268127,
-0.24207456409931183,
-0.12505453824996948,
-0.6095601320266724,
0.19430457055568695,
0.11011546850204468,
0.46037450432777405,
0.12028932571411133,
-0.26532313227653503,
-0.1874677985906601,
-0.6968922019004822,
0.6853812336921692,
-0.7724791765213013,
0.4277540445327759,
0.1644853949546814,
0.06534571200609207,
-0.31586048007011414,
-0.9295123219490051,
-0.7380009889602661,
-0.137945294380188,
0.10116104781627655,
0.15625733137130737,
-0.4321647882461548,
0.1776098608970642,
-0.0016409341478720307,
0.3201720714569092,
-0.38405516743659973,
0.6103479862213135,
-0.3623712360858917,
-0.5319328308105469,
0.3741741180419922,
0.30449730157852173,
-0.1380397081375122,
-0.37585997581481934,
-0.5631698966026306,
-0.21101436018943787,
-0.7601410150527954,
0.012422111816704273,
0.5866754055023193,
0.2648871839046478,
-0.19234855473041534,
0.5109302997589111,
-0.4276912212371826,
0.46494704484939575,
0.28277575969696045,
-0.0050983671098947525,
0.14989995956420898,
-0.19536009430885315,
-0.32897233963012695,
0.18284089863300323,
0.5850229263305664,
0.2827587425708771,
-0.1825593113899231,
-0.23434950411319733,
-0.31803807616233826,
0.03881964832544327,
-0.09645960479974747,
-0.8432267308235168,
-0.2167695164680481,
0.5155072808265686,
-0.7746813893318176,
-0.3132341802120209,
-0.06189979612827301,
-0.6631513237953186,
-0.07593195885419846,
-0.06744930148124695,
0.06463772803544998,
-0.454658567905426,
-0.27908405661582947,
0.33397766947746277,
-0.0912286713719368,
0.2276592254638672,
0.20550139248371124,
-1.007249116897583,
0.25990426540374756,
0.46614405512809753,
0.726060152053833,
-0.42750585079193115,
-0.16846328973770142,
-0.908988893032074,
0.18289020657539368,
-0.418213814496994,
0.8687498569488525,
-0.47489094734191895,
-0.5577764511108398,
-0.07626111060380936,
-0.1602843999862671,
0.4353027045726776,
-0.4100046455860138,
0.7649142742156982,
-0.8469088673591614,
0.051202043890953064,
0.1400216519832611,
-0.5216901302337646,
0.2036803811788559,
0.055742185562849045,
-0.5646278262138367,
1.0701961517333984,
-0.17527441680431366,
-0.6192848086357117,
0.5648202300071716,
-0.4668026566505432,
-0.3290645480155945,
0.16063377261161804,
-0.07098504155874252,
0.03516611084342003,
0.4223906695842743,
0.4314151406288147,
0.6596869230270386,
-0.284862220287323,
0.10082424432039261,
-0.46805036067962646,
-0.6352629065513611,
-0.11165457963943481,
-0.7529538869857788,
0.6571809649467468,
0.6192703247070312,
-0.1855555921792984,
-0.15531234443187714,
-0.9553301334381104,
0.16150768101215363,
0.10693875700235367,
-0.46316367387771606,
-0.371405690908432,
-0.08235178887844086,
-0.14217770099639893,
-0.07019807398319244,
0.11293753981590271,
-0.6826091408729553,
0.26504895091056824,
-0.438585489988327,
0.250914603471756,
0.9776922464370728,
0.015945717692375183,
0.4741958677768707,
0.026450637727975845,
0.5934120416641235,
0.32810890674591064,
0.030579326674342155,
-0.6606087684631348,
-0.27200520038604736,
-0.5677971839904785,
-0.5071612000465393,
0.29825520515441895,
0.20279522240161896,
-0.8452733159065247,
0.715684711933136,
-0.22409223020076752,
-0.47427546977996826,
-0.6033854484558105,
-0.2436906099319458,
0.1553693264722824,
0.40903666615486145,
0.33594632148742676,
-0.08184494078159332,
-0.4788568913936615,
-0.7095843553543091,
-0.29398441314697266,
-0.40803423523902893,
-0.12103822082281113,
-0.12524054944515228,
0.07769042253494263,
-0.06792690604925156,
0.7085096836090088,
-0.4790835678577423,
0.06578178703784943,
-0.3323008418083191,
0.4490688145160675,
0.48366737365722656,
0.541779100894928,
0.14441166818141937,
-0.25522807240486145,
-0.15253464877605438,
-0.2490392029285431,
-0.3935104310512543,
-0.4018944501876831,
-0.41282182931900024,
-0.35554027557373047,
0.3248162865638733,
0.8364290595054626,
-0.6457797288894653,
0.4441792070865631,
0.4851585328578949,
-0.4363965690135956,
0.40781137347221375,
-0.28556209802627563,
0.07602225244045258,
-0.9654330611228943,
0.028735637664794922,
-0.121048204600811,
-0.06823069602251053,
-0.4215056598186493,
0.13180619478225708,
0.22195567190647125,
0.27958011627197266,
-0.6704534292221069,
0.520304799079895,
-0.6497578620910645,
0.30395013093948364,
-0.3658677637577057,
-0.03386395052075386,
0.13314810395240784,
0.2399098426103592,
0.08157295733690262,
0.7244442105293274,
0.3775215744972229,
-0.6450127959251404,
0.11978399008512497,
-0.02909454144537449,
-0.17761282622814178,
-0.12657694518566132,
-0.5461100339889526,
0.13395042717456818,
-0.5265858769416809,
0.5682028532028198,
-0.911095380783081,
0.07585390657186508,
0.25954756140708923,
-0.26083412766456604,
0.37856918573379517,
-0.18746216595172882,
-0.49689802527427673,
-0.5673782229423523,
-0.3630949556827545,
0.22527708113193512,
0.650576114654541,
-0.5882030725479126,
0.7004928588867188,
0.07660551369190216,
0.050824493169784546,
-0.652144193649292,
-1.0810407400131226,
0.04157770052552223,
-0.23899772763252258,
-0.26156648993492126,
0.5200888514518738,
-0.0017844499088823795,
0.047109898179769516,
0.11024568229913712,
-0.051473941653966904,
0.12630803883075714,
0.026981422677636147,
-0.12775231897830963,
0.35733699798583984,
-0.19405479729175568,
-0.08158501982688904,
0.6068253517150879,
-0.3990538418292999,
0.15072055160999298,
-0.8422300815582275,
0.6701191663742065,
0.3000405728816986,
-0.3348821699619293,
-0.6864261627197266,
0.4840887784957886,
0.5040068030357361,
0.0805937722325325,
0.828080952167511,
0.5573159456253052,
-0.3079579770565033,
-0.4112679660320282,
-0.617145299911499,
-0.35367393493652344,
-0.5063163638114929,
0.3651338219642639,
-0.6455409526824951,
-0.7425001859664917,
0.6782377362251282,
-0.15618537366390228,
0.036525506526231766,
0.6206039786338806,
0.7591633200645447,
-0.0514722540974617,
0.5538235902786255,
0.7094806432723999,
0.08361716568470001,
0.2998126447200775,
-0.3118722438812256,
0.17901594936847687,
-0.5900524854660034,
-0.4047006666660309,
-0.4385946989059448,
-0.27274617552757263,
-0.36007729172706604,
-0.43022024631500244,
0.08085675537586212,
0.2683770954608917,
0.16529470682144165,
0.05278012529015541,
-0.292344331741333,
0.8701784610748291,
0.5515918135643005,
-0.06711673736572266,
0.5660710334777832,
0.20789362490177155,
-0.5381814241409302,
-0.02136733941733837,
-0.8192558884620667,
-0.46360689401626587,
1.2985196113586426,
0.4176758825778961,
1.1366064548492432,
0.05383963882923126,
1.137603759765625,
0.48736488819122314,
0.3870179355144501,
-0.560684323310852,
0.5288618803024292,
-0.12402746826410294,
-0.4518415331840515,
-0.23315027356147766,
-0.5377424359321594,
-0.7195795178413391,
0.11052902042865753,
0.015984604135155678,
-0.7447041869163513,
0.37946274876594543,
0.328694224357605,
-0.6367471814155579,
0.3648982644081116,
-0.8657196164131165,
0.49495354294776917,
0.1239001452922821,
-0.41555243730545044,
-0.1817130148410797,
-0.4557986557483673,
0.6824249029159546,
-0.2162061631679535,
-0.09607391804456711,
-0.08978868275880814,
-0.10794532299041748,
0.6260887384414673,
-0.37758296728134155,
0.7501001954078674,
-0.39622095227241516,
-0.3374922573566437,
0.4967077672481537,
0.290496826171875,
0.8494420647621155,
0.15402527153491974,
-0.27566635608673096,
0.11413101851940155,
-0.009580603800714016,
-0.3892657160758972,
-0.4033968150615692,
0.5126936435699463,
-0.6114034056663513,
-0.4258713126182556,
-0.30909019708633423,
-0.1737101674079895,
-0.04810284450650215,
0.2682816684246063,
0.5572172999382019,
0.4354720413684845,
0.06381523609161377,
-0.03874121606349945,
0.31914985179901123,
-0.13444359600543976,
0.7643073201179504,
0.45945167541503906,
-0.31334421038627625,
-0.16085651516914368,
0.5846112966537476,
-0.1015574038028717,
0.39544200897216797,
0.3993847072124481,
0.1101735457777977,
-0.8774515986442566,
-1.0760737657546997,
-0.5240825414657593,
-0.009964583441615105,
-0.7348759174346924,
-0.2680402994155884,
-0.7914773225784302,
0.015666380524635315,
-0.4215112626552582,
0.057843200862407684,
-0.45435211062431335,
-0.38161951303482056,
-0.3091200590133667,
-0.21971359848976135,
0.22526848316192627,
0.5401918888092041,
-0.33445242047309875,
0.40247228741645813,
-1.0857921838760376,
0.2560272216796875,
-0.09419064223766327,
0.3939341902732849,
0.41864025592803955,
-0.8325459361076355,
-0.24239186942577362,
-0.2696242928504944,
-0.16017939150333405,
-0.7051512002944946,
0.36941611766815186,
0.04523620754480362,
0.5758471488952637,
0.7745710015296936,
0.440100759267807,
0.8353745937347412,
-0.4666476249694824,
0.704526424407959,
0.2251451313495636,
-0.9757291078567505,
0.2877036929130554,
-0.2191004455089569,
0.2725703716278076,
0.5037481784820557,
0.2707696855068207,
-0.482975035905838,
-0.4549538195133209,
-0.2912267744541168,
-0.961395800113678,
0.7814102172851562,
0.16152632236480713,
0.20365652441978455,
-0.4176400899887085,
0.48474523425102234,
0.4060172438621521,
0.00641848286613822,
-0.5017072558403015,
-0.3304174840450287,
0.013154885731637478,
-0.20173805952072144,
0.19069761037826538,
-0.4670465588569641,
0.12869703769683838,
0.03910275548696518,
0.4542357325553894,
-0.19054864346981049,
0.3753335475921631,
0.2175261378288269,
0.06516948342323303,
-0.13673824071884155,
0.19072890281677246,
0.29584425687789917,
0.14274315536022186,
-0.14394493401050568,
0.20533597469329834,
0.11808991432189941,
-0.4732387661933899,
0.43921536207199097,
0.1655660718679428,
-0.19924227893352509,
-0.17614318430423737,
0.27732351422309875,
0.5815865993499756,
0.041998039931058884,
-0.624808669090271,
0.248131662607193,
-0.3684123158454895,
-0.1973162442445755,
-0.010957002639770508,
-0.17098550498485565,
-0.1479450762271881,
0.21699365973472595,
0.9665153622627258,
-0.16236612200737,
0.27452751994132996,
-0.3501392900943756,
0.3191823363304138,
0.23437996208667755,
0.33075010776519775,
-0.260732501745224,
0.9001734256744385,
0.371647447347641,
0.19529126584529877,
0.6277570724487305,
-0.5099710822105408,
-0.025129660964012146,
0.3416617810726166,
0.7622769474983215,
1.1588166952133179,
0.07331609725952148,
0.05196860432624817,
0.140848770737648,
0.42445725202560425,
0.015276646241545677,
0.42482319474220276,
-0.18273551762104034,
-0.6975646615028381,
-0.9633276462554932,
-0.9415975213050842,
-0.2412680685520172,
0.07924351096153259,
-0.7113271355628967,
0.1700202226638794,
-0.3175868093967438,
-0.10018964856863022,
-0.4963954985141754,
-0.26358747482299805,
-0.5693261623382568,
0.1619650274515152,
0.5232917666435242,
1.2554901838302612,
-0.5788264870643616,
0.7922252416610718,
0.11645356565713882,
0.2194991409778595,
-0.8179205656051636,
0.3415466845035553,
0.05127321556210518,
-0.7961426973342896,
0.7645408511161804,
0.1098133996129036,
-0.31649893522262573,
0.36535847187042236,
-0.30626603960990906,
-0.9206876754760742,
1.0175890922546387,
0.44709107279777527,
-0.7794990539550781,
-0.27033400535583496,
-0.10064318776130676,
0.24205343425273895,
-0.2355547547340393,
0.41975972056388855,
0.7569342851638794,
0.3489067554473877,
0.30420729517936707,
-0.42016056180000305,
0.06354114413261414,
-0.2670113444328308,
-0.0003718118241522461,
0.1367458999156952,
-0.5070202946662903,
0.74006587266922,
-0.32171982526779175,
-0.6339352130889893,
0.2580949366092682,
1.080276608467102,
0.39871737360954285,
0.09383492171764374,
0.5238867402076721,
0.5898452401161194,
0.8796197175979614,
-0.028601333498954773,
0.9947575926780701,
-0.6946882605552673,
0.1981452852487564,
0.9178051352500916,
-0.2887219190597534,
0.8881881237030029,
0.7124462723731995,
-0.17744244635105133,
0.36374616622924805,
0.8143350481987,
0.33059653639793396,
0.7023422122001648,
0.2773759663105011,
-0.3377600610256195,
-0.2209562063217163,
0.0038417752366513014,
-0.4964729845523834,
0.6191330552101135,
0.19402234256267548,
-0.2721470594406128,
-0.29826852679252625,
-0.12456244975328445,
-0.07309509068727493,
-0.1742173433303833,
-0.18966582417488098,
0.4775799810886383,
-0.05887340381741524,
-0.5018661618232727,
0.6080109477043152,
0.3870196044445038,
0.8214181661605835,
-0.7182297110557556,
0.30338674783706665,
-0.474671334028244,
0.00030224904185160995,
0.09858199208974838,
-0.4385853409767151,
0.37199196219444275,
0.10508741438388824,
0.07835382968187332,
-0.4082706570625305,
0.49349290132522583,
-0.3529999852180481,
-0.5714828372001648,
0.3173941969871521,
0.761859118938446,
0.19763682782649994,
0.19792643189430237,
-0.16661685705184937,
0.4881289005279541,
-0.21689431369304657,
-0.5558754801750183,
-0.019078070297837257,
0.7939611077308655,
0.33793675899505615,
0.49536195397377014,
1.060806155204773,
0.34227120876312256,
0.4670121967792511,
0.0131083894520998,
1.072568416595459,
-0.7597838640213013,
-0.8537515997886658,
-1.1846824884414673,
0.5003201961517334,
0.10726573318243027,
-0.3395996689796448,
0.6411705017089844,
0.43170052766799927,
0.6913273930549622,
-0.03176552429795265,
0.6442911624908447,
0.11128119379281998,
0.2605292797088623,
-1.0668030977249146,
0.6673386096954346,
-0.32202595472335815,
0.4426184296607971,
-0.07617402821779251,
-0.8539935350418091,
-0.2202606499195099,
0.15249909460544586,
0.1389314979314804,
0.033371757715940475,
0.7432271242141724,
0.5778965950012207,
0.034004345536231995,
0.022857025265693665,
0.2611789405345917,
0.37545740604400635,
0.4898921847343445,
0.5164863467216492,
0.8435022830963135,
-0.20742906630039215,
0.5798710584640503,
-0.19556961953639984,
-0.28545138239860535,
-0.08862433582544327,
-1.1734246015548706,
-0.6503240466117859,
-0.16851747035980225,
-0.007054747082293034,
-0.36510998010635376,
-0.20577307045459747,
1.031740665435791,
0.7766183614730835,
-0.5408722758293152,
0.036839284002780914,
-0.3409259021282196,
-0.3178175985813141,
-0.03149932622909546,
-0.2245664894580841,
0.3316097557544708,
-0.37415069341659546,
-0.9491128921508789,
0.583625316619873,
0.4281242787837982,
0.3203653395175934,
-0.5630672574043274,
-0.11617251485586166,
0.24853752553462982,
0.17787504196166992,
0.529609739780426,
0.11471781879663467,
-0.8219100832939148,
0.15710748732089996,
0.10922306030988693,
0.03450993448495865,
-0.1251482367515564,
1.0289864540100098,
-1.1916536092758179,
0.32757318019866943,
0.3572610318660736,
0.9265678524971008,
0.5959823727607727,
-0.04271668195724487,
0.5574299097061157,
-0.6029348969459534,
0.4558025896549225,
0.27514705061912537,
0.27033090591430664,
-0.0869024246931076,
-0.49151846766471863,
0.09741499274969101,
0.40094810724258423,
-0.05710768699645996,
-1.036453127861023,
0.0007668230100534856,
-0.7760788202285767,
0.011223793029785156,
0.7572008371353149,
-0.11138299107551575,
-0.41191866993904114,
-0.019990164786577225,
-0.01683412306010723,
0.1263643503189087,
-0.7115554809570312,
0.9031051993370056,
0.7009080052375793,
-0.04334692656993866,
-0.2514374852180481,
0.02443605475127697,
0.36218520998954773,
0.39369910955429077,
-0.7082950472831726,
0.477841854095459,
0.2945219576358795,
-0.3190677762031555,
-0.16690774261951447,
0.9286022782325745,
-0.1180962547659874,
0.13285008072853088,
0.22962546348571777,
0.011204659938812256,
-0.24002553522586823,
-0.4516369104385376,
-0.44041988253593445,
0.30782613158226013,
-0.06101182475686073,
-0.20775561034679413
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.03847v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.03847v2
|
Lean Workbook: A large-scale Lean problem set formalized from natural language math problems
| 2024-06-06T08:25:43 | 2024-06-07T16:12:21 |
Huaiyuan Ying, Zijian Wu, Yihan Geng, Jiayu Wang, Dahua Lin, Kai Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models have demonstrated impressive capabilities across
various natural language processing tasks, especially in solving mathematical
problems. However, large language models are not good at math theorem proving
using formal languages like Lean. A significant challenge in this area is the
scarcity of training data available in these formal languages. To address this
issue, we propose a novel pipeline that iteratively generates and filters
synthetic data to translate natural language mathematical problems into Lean 4
statements, and vice versa. Our results indicate that the synthetic data
pipeline can provide useful training data and improve the performance of LLMs
in translating and understanding complex mathematical problems and proofs. Our
final dataset contains about 57K formal-informal question pairs along with
searched proof from the math contest forum and 21 new IMO questions. We
open-source our code at https://github.com/InternLM/InternLM-Math and our data
at https://huggingface.co/datasets/InternLM/Lean-Workbook.
|
[
-0.10089379549026489,
-0.5150526762008667,
0.36885693669319153,
0.16351458430290222,
-0.0386040024459362,
0.17508292198181152,
-0.3126297891139984,
-0.430756539106369,
0.07752078771591187,
0.4713050127029419,
-0.8690019249916077,
-0.6140143871307373,
-0.4013842046260834,
0.33206722140312195,
-0.5314609408378601,
1.0323970317840576,
-0.41632089018821716,
0.501384437084198,
-0.3181600868701935,
-0.0249575637280941,
-0.08438976854085922,
-0.11781948059797287,
-0.3735332489013672,
-0.33542004227638245,
0.04457763582468033,
0.651724636554718,
0.670514702796936,
0.6116700172424316,
0.5940855145454407,
0.4240044355392456,
0.27376025915145874,
-0.018462806940078735,
-0.6362800598144531,
0.2812906801700592,
0.06256021559238434,
-0.7208063006401062,
-0.13103453814983368,
-0.14273010194301605,
0.6600154638290405,
0.8128007054328918,
-0.14193779230117798,
0.25243183970451355,
-0.23082754015922546,
0.7266440987586975,
-0.302481085062027,
0.5208348035812378,
-0.823138952255249,
0.2661984860897064,
-0.26526668667793274,
0.2712087035179138,
-0.02658762037754059,
-0.5041347742080688,
-0.04067102074623108,
-0.7628484964370728,
0.2836831510066986,
-0.04376428574323654,
0.9561362862586975,
0.4762459993362427,
-0.12745490670204163,
-0.5564022660255432,
-0.5513895750045776,
0.8274936079978943,
-1.1136343479156494,
0.264243483543396,
0.4278205335140228,
0.4192996025085449,
-0.19620946049690247,
-0.8190908432006836,
-0.6725462079048157,
-0.0429379940032959,
0.18800745904445648,
0.03111417032778263,
0.20711611211299896,
-0.2095411866903305,
0.43275102972984314,
0.5967816710472107,
-0.5851073861122131,
0.13934895396232605,
-0.6765499711036682,
-0.2800273895263672,
0.6456997990608215,
0.40768715739250183,
0.31855645775794983,
0.01113957166671753,
0.04975096136331558,
-0.04025417938828468,
-0.4985186457633972,
-0.14967679977416992,
0.26694557070732117,
0.190370574593544,
-0.22669275104999542,
0.8951948881149292,
-0.3006836771965027,
0.7406973242759705,
-0.45388883352279663,
-0.5576397180557251,
0.26216596364974976,
-0.5842102766036987,
-0.22709029912948608,
-0.04539455100893974,
0.6247643232345581,
-0.13137072324752808,
0.5158370137214661,
0.06981680542230606,
-0.3452965319156647,
0.13520759344100952,
0.01639525219798088,
-0.9760615825653076,
-0.21527579426765442,
0.11154153198003769,
0.022021949291229248,
-0.38217878341674805,
-0.06847219914197922,
-0.5824236869812012,
-0.13949082791805267,
-0.9472211599349976,
0.12648464739322662,
-0.5026455521583557,
0.14346882700920105,
0.1296287328004837,
-0.1250172108411789,
0.31285932660102844,
0.3284515142440796,
-0.7210075855255127,
0.3533116579055786,
0.6909468770027161,
0.7523629069328308,
0.21549662947654724,
-0.05250990763306618,
-0.8053781390190125,
0.005794113036245108,
-0.5326147079467773,
0.5275219678878784,
-0.5069255828857422,
-0.014208370819687843,
0.3810432255268097,
-0.22950154542922974,
0.08103638887405396,
-0.9098759293556213,
0.879120409488678,
-0.15757915377616882,
0.27915751934051514,
-0.08694218844175339,
-0.5599266290664673,
0.2584923207759857,
0.4021347463130951,
-0.6811435222625732,
1.198058009147644,
0.23062707483768463,
-0.42625388503074646,
0.22015170753002167,
-0.568360447883606,
-0.6369211673736572,
0.15026094019412994,
-0.19242143630981445,
-0.4075371325016022,
0.047598160803318024,
0.1795312911272049,
0.30741116404533386,
-0.777055025100708,
0.18907420337200165,
-0.41402891278266907,
-0.2562400996685028,
0.20919117331504822,
0.09125880151987076,
0.7131865620613098,
0.34293895959854126,
-0.2610960006713867,
-0.06935068964958191,
-1.1024892330169678,
0.3800523281097412,
0.05055477097630501,
-0.40207961201667786,
-0.27116239070892334,
-0.17298623919487,
-0.14702919125556946,
0.23957768082618713,
0.19329003989696503,
-0.6142171621322632,
0.1508183479309082,
-0.5035611391067505,
0.49218103289604187,
0.6652874946594238,
-0.2690940797328949,
0.3388857841491699,
-0.15793250501155853,
0.41072505712509155,
0.0800582766532898,
-0.13517774641513824,
-0.13459524512290955,
-0.5507307648658752,
-0.8908770680427551,
-0.5694686770439148,
0.2077554166316986,
0.4455822706222534,
-0.7393572330474854,
0.09328413009643555,
-0.23584401607513428,
-0.3404000401496887,
-0.5555403828620911,
0.7002372145652771,
0.22620843350887299,
0.7530317902565002,
0.3310893476009369,
0.22998042404651642,
-0.7028458714485168,
-1.008264422416687,
-0.3797416388988495,
0.16671302914619446,
-0.41616085171699524,
0.03509145975112915,
0.6170040965080261,
-0.44617414474487305,
0.9054045081138611,
-0.800955057144165,
-0.5613001585006714,
-0.019820427522063255,
0.2758307158946991,
0.5701093077659607,
0.3767971396446228,
0.1693403422832489,
-0.48763567209243774,
-0.6972394585609436,
-0.022654106840491295,
-0.838688313961029,
-0.18105050921440125,
0.022942572832107544,
-0.2621852159500122,
0.12295480072498322,
0.5382615923881531,
-0.6130525469779968,
0.3293454051017761,
0.3667566776275635,
-0.14471177756786346,
0.5988047122955322,
0.0708109587430954,
-0.3056676983833313,
-1.1932169198989868,
-0.03424137085676193,
0.18945647776126862,
-0.1860121190547943,
-0.4486219882965088,
-0.1840215027332306,
-0.10355989634990692,
-0.6279349327087402,
-0.07549441605806351,
0.5117363333702087,
-0.32473278045654297,
-0.03491071239113808,
0.23500505089759827,
-0.02280290797352791,
0.07873297482728958,
0.4634949266910553,
-0.26677656173706055,
0.42292946577072144,
0.5524349808692932,
-0.6766961812973022,
0.49900156259536743,
0.34585389494895935,
-0.35462042689323425,
0.6937282681465149,
-0.570940375328064,
0.08973131328821182,
-0.0749397948384285,
0.1616685390472412,
-0.9142941236495972,
-0.5596912503242493,
0.14839114248752594,
-0.3091791868209839,
0.4340578615665436,
-0.3043411672115326,
-0.5919966101646423,
-0.3489077091217041,
-0.28971683979034424,
0.24326717853546143,
0.5278220176696777,
-0.5310059785842896,
0.49642413854599,
0.3259084224700928,
-0.2057468295097351,
-0.49685966968536377,
-0.6331284642219543,
0.12046684324741364,
0.10782605409622192,
-0.945431649684906,
0.21762822568416595,
-0.18215005099773407,
-0.5626569986343384,
0.15601696074008942,
-0.39520853757858276,
-0.668770968914032,
-0.2760331630706787,
-0.0811028778553009,
0.3841460347175598,
-0.11012208461761475,
0.053456518799066544,
-0.19507423043251038,
-0.09539227187633514,
0.3260572850704193,
-0.6357757449150085,
0.07526150345802307,
-0.22050102055072784,
-0.1803215742111206,
-0.14979755878448486,
0.35216596722602844,
0.7602001428604126,
-0.09480935335159302,
0.6306079030036926,
0.713422417640686,
-0.8202909827232361,
-0.7844790816307068,
-0.20252209901809692,
-0.18141597509384155,
-0.5038820505142212,
0.31608980894088745,
-0.26982179284095764,
-0.6547569632530212,
0.3814292252063751,
-0.05477646738290787,
0.5897647738456726,
0.3766242563724518,
0.8372636437416077,
-0.3081900477409363,
0.724111020565033,
0.18728463351726532,
0.17741067707538605,
0.19226665794849396,
-0.5226472616195679,
0.4337533414363861,
-0.26162993907928467,
-0.41083481907844543,
-0.8433728218078613,
-0.3588273823261261,
-0.30287519097328186,
-0.6561884880065918,
0.5071011185646057,
-0.23973684012889862,
-0.13848347961902618,
0.2727172076702118,
-0.17153653502464294,
0.42088407278060913,
0.2919929027557373,
-0.15001915395259857,
0.4188278615474701,
0.13727472722530365,
-0.42943069338798523,
-0.6514491438865662,
-0.5941259860992432,
-0.23463666439056396,
1.0060757398605347,
0.12548597157001495,
1.017348051071167,
-0.012753240764141083,
0.6272833347320557,
0.0715768113732338,
0.5361484289169312,
-1.1446245908737183,
0.5316727757453918,
-0.04772951081395149,
-0.7533954381942749,
-0.4086540937423706,
-0.80498868227005,
-0.5815670490264893,
-0.031295083463191986,
-0.13476809859275818,
-0.1861645132303238,
-0.2230268120765686,
0.02732572704553604,
0.3142842650413513,
0.1845930814743042,
-0.7493792176246643,
0.6980045437812805,
-0.29048484563827515,
-0.6128918528556824,
-0.1555403769016266,
-0.279031366109848,
0.6610769629478455,
-0.3354807496070862,
0.5834968686103821,
-0.24986155331134796,
0.06752769649028778,
0.7627933621406555,
-1.25883150100708,
0.8656459450721741,
0.0786576047539711,
-0.45115143060684204,
0.5378034710884094,
0.15904486179351807,
0.6169244647026062,
0.23371700942516327,
-0.202069491147995,
0.023179372772574425,
-0.03929905965924263,
-0.5105092525482178,
-0.7121812105178833,
0.7683585286140442,
-0.5159986615180969,
-0.19478221237659454,
-0.5440186262130737,
-0.6394519805908203,
-0.4700859785079956,
0.3714772164821625,
0.10021623969078064,
0.6978217959403992,
0.08992096036672592,
0.22969891130924225,
0.4520464837551117,
0.1233457624912262,
0.37973880767822266,
0.37467142939567566,
0.16061699390411377,
-0.5712541341781616,
1.0143905878067017,
0.2155217081308365,
0.1435200721025467,
0.3283032774925232,
0.2825087010860443,
-0.4467315375804901,
-0.39161890745162964,
-0.39290618896484375,
0.3380689024925232,
-0.9997855424880981,
-0.5029035806655884,
-0.02858232706785202,
-0.16892214119434357,
-0.25494444370269775,
-0.1878357082605362,
-0.7081571817398071,
-0.6352300047874451,
-0.04321172460913658,
0.09975161403417587,
0.28924623131752014,
0.6888288855552673,
0.007937297224998474,
-0.3808201253414154,
-0.8066239953041077,
0.5776127576828003,
0.291640967130661,
0.6218347549438477,
-0.4511038064956665,
-0.5135321021080017,
-0.6652361750602722,
0.15496446192264557,
-0.15673455595970154,
-0.5111098289489746,
0.5444661378860474,
0.38209083676338196,
0.3071242868900299,
0.32970014214515686,
0.245869442820549,
0.8120319247245789,
-0.5435946583747864,
0.2252783328294754,
0.3346311151981354,
-1.033408522605896,
0.23067189753055573,
-0.2804730236530304,
0.3078137934207916,
0.7158059477806091,
0.6316670775413513,
-0.29508334398269653,
-0.06793065369129181,
-0.33317384123802185,
-0.739446759223938,
0.5694695115089417,
0.5055447220802307,
0.021707110106945038,
0.3599797189235687,
0.45840826630592346,
-0.015719017013907433,
0.2748560905456543,
-0.6563775539398193,
-0.032828763127326965,
-0.25076180696487427,
-0.6926888227462769,
0.2601355016231537,
0.09708011150360107,
-0.4560593366622925,
-0.47545763850212097,
0.6480823755264282,
-0.5021786689758301,
0.1987585574388504,
0.12706716358661652,
-0.03147877752780914,
-0.33833035826683044,
0.1016363874077797,
0.20212574303150177,
0.8134890198707581,
-0.045970283448696136,
0.025329526513814926,
0.10255251079797745,
-0.6423687934875488,
0.09188777208328247,
0.1813734918832779,
-0.18314504623413086,
0.1718982458114624,
0.508255124092102,
0.44456392526626587,
0.6147993803024292,
-1.127638578414917,
0.07242409884929657,
-0.012928764335811138,
-0.6058027744293213,
-0.6483334898948669,
-0.0028032674454152584,
0.1481904536485672,
-0.15237395465373993,
0.36997297406196594,
0.04087289795279503,
0.07723115384578705,
-0.7969275712966919,
0.25645729899406433,
0.4119240641593933,
-0.21473237872123718,
-0.34490063786506653,
0.532380998134613,
0.06462074816226959,
-0.3812914192676544,
0.9332514405250549,
0.0343913808465004,
-0.6654858589172363,
0.5517188906669617,
0.7349328994750977,
0.6076272130012512,
0.1178700402379036,
0.2418641895055771,
0.7977978587150574,
0.20255914330482483,
0.11185348033905029,
0.31325799226760864,
0.0009985187789425254,
-0.5564009547233582,
-0.668255090713501,
-0.6851125359535217,
-0.7079331278800964,
0.2564275860786438,
-0.4078458547592163,
0.7072683572769165,
-0.6798403859138489,
0.3385288417339325,
-0.04561412334442139,
0.11460360139608383,
-0.8543333411216736,
0.2543288469314575,
0.14465901255607605,
0.7325908541679382,
-0.5880997776985168,
0.5214859247207642,
0.7337648272514343,
-0.04324425384402275,
-0.8670777082443237,
-0.15415869653224945,
0.04350019618868828,
-0.879772424697876,
0.7666721343994141,
0.10846656560897827,
0.07933124154806137,
-0.04804376885294914,
-0.8658016324043274,
-0.8858235478401184,
0.8415147662162781,
0.6199265718460083,
-0.6127941608428955,
-0.02907225675880909,
0.507500410079956,
0.5150451064109802,
-0.3326018452644348,
0.027761006727814674,
0.37824079394340515,
0.5670086741447449,
0.7442543506622314,
-0.6786278486251831,
0.009803385473787785,
-0.48720014095306396,
-0.37900447845458984,
0.17658379673957825,
-0.371273934841156,
0.7407106161117554,
-0.49714988470077515,
0.05275880917906761,
-0.3095462918281555,
0.47578221559524536,
0.3734065294265747,
0.539707362651825,
0.2542852461338043,
0.9413304328918457,
0.9438289999961853,
-0.1423501819372177,
0.9257878661155701,
-0.01907556690275669,
0.16103383898735046,
0.9548186659812927,
-0.43961286544799805,
0.5564663410186768,
0.3133332133293152,
-0.2780001163482666,
0.5716054439544678,
0.4504536986351013,
-0.0027215632144361734,
0.09100528061389923,
0.7201886773109436,
-0.23997531831264496,
-0.27050238847732544,
0.03870972990989685,
-0.24714770913124084,
0.3798452317714691,
0.40195831656455994,
0.1208057627081871,
-0.3259695768356323,
-0.45702171325683594,
0.30481889843940735,
0.0003606668906286359,
-0.05115162208676338,
0.41050446033477783,
0.4077756702899933,
-0.7732534408569336,
0.9193680882453918,
0.1019873321056366,
0.1464579701423645,
-0.8413780927658081,
-0.2493077516555786,
-0.3811641335487366,
0.44872617721557617,
-0.3360540270805359,
-0.4718886911869049,
0.34817084670066833,
0.15486808121204376,
0.09842651337385178,
-0.16247659921646118,
0.43143829703330994,
-0.46411022543907166,
-0.8751546740531921,
-0.23823876678943634,
0.43865612149238586,
-0.006309607997536659,
0.15930910408496857,
-0.7043794393539429,
0.07381045818328857,
-0.06887705624103546,
-0.07095704972743988,
0.2850041389465332,
0.7265092134475708,
0.003176885424181819,
0.9026326537132263,
1.0555680990219116,
-0.27359357476234436,
0.21114203333854675,
0.04346681758761406,
1.1153398752212524,
-0.5534586906433105,
-0.47589659690856934,
-0.669502317905426,
0.578338623046875,
-0.14196275174617767,
-0.2851864993572235,
0.8032335638999939,
0.6947310566902161,
0.5644170641899109,
-0.1620485484600067,
0.7566846013069153,
-0.059261664748191833,
0.30052852630615234,
-0.6253348588943481,
0.1783319115638733,
-0.4934885799884796,
0.3664413094520569,
-0.30597737431526184,
-0.9753731489181519,
-0.30450376868247986,
0.7200630307197571,
0.007278179284185171,
-0.16291265189647675,
0.8939610123634338,
0.48532235622406006,
-0.038128532469272614,
0.09569325298070908,
0.07558620721101761,
0.5059749484062195,
0.5015571117401123,
0.5106338262557983,
0.5134945511817932,
-0.5492755770683289,
0.8804503679275513,
-0.2150854468345642,
-0.020477429032325745,
-0.06148425489664078,
-0.8832236528396606,
-1.0331777334213257,
-0.582893431186676,
-0.42164167761802673,
-0.6734225749969482,
-0.5717463493347168,
0.8462704420089722,
0.7385298609733582,
-0.8371654748916626,
-0.395464688539505,
-0.34317269921302795,
0.29461950063705444,
0.09139324724674225,
-0.2480304092168808,
-0.0020149846095591784,
-0.7203793525695801,
-0.9107939600944519,
0.5326194167137146,
0.1609194129705429,
-0.07843632996082306,
-0.436176061630249,
-0.4135375916957855,
-0.06905954331159592,
0.11087574064731598,
0.4121263325214386,
0.44964486360549927,
-0.04529056325554848,
0.3017288148403168,
0.3378170132637024,
0.12287270277738571,
0.040633659809827805,
1.1640986204147339,
-0.6383883357048035,
0.5133475661277771,
0.4865962862968445,
0.7934227585792542,
0.9174829125404358,
-0.3340928852558136,
0.8345531821250916,
-0.5748745799064636,
0.2075553834438324,
0.5874063372612,
0.5127939581871033,
0.3923501968383789,
-0.160658597946167,
0.744655966758728,
0.6379930973052979,
-0.1954686939716339,
-0.9861010313034058,
0.21304790675640106,
-0.6306604743003845,
0.04068797454237938,
0.947269082069397,
0.04276696965098381,
-0.2530113160610199,
-0.3161284029483795,
0.029924027621746063,
0.015390398912131786,
-0.22118690609931946,
0.644809365272522,
0.8228270411491394,
-0.018077822402119637,
0.24753865599632263,
-0.820238471031189,
0.5647547245025635,
0.4793351888656616,
-1.0557276010513306,
-0.1782263219356537,
0.577523410320282,
0.3443351089954376,
0.0033029154874384403,
0.4547290503978729,
-0.23928432166576385,
-0.08783777058124542,
-0.03338737040758133,
-0.2345547080039978,
-0.10542777925729752,
-0.23735350370407104,
0.10934626311063766,
0.0819273293018341,
-0.14769628643989563,
0.1601904034614563
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.06596v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.06596v1
|
Are Large Language Models the New Interface for Data Pipelines?
| 2024-06-06T08:10:32 | 2024-06-06T08:10:32 |
Sylvio Barbon Junior, Paolo Ceravolo, Sven Groppe, Mustafa Jarrar, Samira Maghool, Florence Sèdes, Soror Sahri, Maurice Van Keulen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.DB
|
A Language Model is a term that encompasses various types of models designed
to understand and generate human communication. Large Language Models (LLMs)
have gained significant attention due to their ability to process text with
human-like fluency and coherence, making them valuable for a wide range of
data-related tasks fashioned as pipelines. The capabilities of LLMs in natural
language understanding and generation, combined with their scalability,
versatility, and state-of-the-art performance, enable innovative applications
across various AI-related fields, including eXplainable Artificial Intelligence
(XAI), Automated Machine Learning (AutoML), and Knowledge Graphs (KG).
Furthermore, we believe these models can extract valuable insights and make
data-driven decisions at scale, a practice commonly referred to as Big Data
Analytics (BDA). In this position paper, we provide some discussions in the
direction of unlocking synergies among these technologies, which can lead to
more powerful and intelligent AI solutions, driving improvements in data
pipelines across a wide range of applications and domains integrating humans,
computers, and knowledge.
|
[
-0.3978410065174103,
-0.8284314870834351,
0.66835618019104,
-0.09487827122211456,
-0.075831338763237,
0.34637412428855896,
-0.28816288709640503,
-0.6882449388504028,
0.1643049269914627,
0.5927868485450745,
-0.43584033846855164,
-0.2956690490245819,
-0.7253747582435608,
-0.03363783285021782,
-0.9114699959754944,
0.7083863019943237,
0.019867507740855217,
0.05717872455716133,
-0.5160267949104309,
-0.029928168281912804,
-0.5023510456085205,
-0.8172658085823059,
-0.7195057272911072,
-0.5622219443321228,
0.5928184986114502,
0.20533260703086853,
0.8768960237503052,
0.9845449924468994,
0.5148196220397949,
0.40192341804504395,
0.08398624509572983,
-0.0705074742436409,
-0.35798588395118713,
0.28707730770111084,
-0.2665867805480957,
-0.6507675051689148,
-0.4966470003128052,
0.03770965337753296,
0.8905590772628784,
1.2107534408569336,
-0.11267753690481186,
0.19530576467514038,
-0.050902508199214935,
0.6670428514480591,
-0.37853753566741943,
0.42055776715278625,
-0.6074747443199158,
-0.0990082249045372,
-0.36061757802963257,
0.10964785516262054,
-0.25811463594436646,
0.05376274511218071,
0.24270908534526825,
-0.20491598546504974,
-0.25796958804130554,
0.20054657757282257,
0.6912505626678467,
0.3275681436061859,
-0.42934203147888184,
-0.34005147218704224,
-0.9715414047241211,
0.8309080600738525,
-0.7540302872657776,
0.7423861026763916,
-0.010725472122430801,
0.5860980749130249,
-0.23712918162345886,
-0.9021155834197998,
-0.8970988988876343,
0.039005130529403687,
-0.02677208185195923,
-0.10912693291902542,
-0.4096342623233795,
-0.03329095244407654,
0.2960401475429535,
0.4042988121509552,
-0.4267825484275818,
0.8468449115753174,
-0.2569642663002014,
-0.12219953536987305,
0.9322381615638733,
0.64676433801651,
0.30284249782562256,
0.0029713609255850315,
-0.029568485915660858,
0.19979584217071533,
-0.8302829265594482,
-0.1957034170627594,
0.31822794675827026,
0.4322647452354431,
-0.3347243666648865,
0.5114612579345703,
-0.322812557220459,
0.9717863202095032,
-0.3589048683643341,
-0.028139548376202583,
0.145724356174469,
-0.4835561513900757,
-0.3646376132965088,
-0.17129731178283691,
0.8778077363967896,
-0.05521806329488754,
0.3379080593585968,
-0.45044466853141785,
-0.10262344777584076,
0.1864892691373825,
-0.009094217792153358,
-0.7470064759254456,
-0.16832537949085236,
0.37540632486343384,
-0.6747483015060425,
-0.19047124683856964,
-0.167202427983284,
-0.9459772706031799,
-0.6016473174095154,
-0.696280837059021,
0.02751154452562332,
0.02572314441204071,
-0.4691900908946991,
0.10748370736837387,
0.12927530705928802,
0.40591537952423096,
0.2323569506406784,
-0.9974743723869324,
0.3488568067550659,
0.9810299873352051,
0.8381529450416565,
-0.21176384389400482,
-0.3304007351398468,
-0.5253802537918091,
0.11643006652593613,
-0.3588390350341797,
0.5108522176742554,
-0.7550291419029236,
-0.2895764708518982,
0.047443196177482605,
-0.17979879677295685,
0.04007896035909653,
-0.5256455540657043,
0.3426094651222229,
-0.3999078571796417,
0.23279136419296265,
-0.1361202448606491,
-0.7097205519676208,
-0.0842350423336029,
-0.029919762164354324,
-0.7731783986091614,
0.45215514302253723,
-0.09201523661613464,
-0.5931698679924011,
0.44140881299972534,
-0.7760435342788696,
-0.3600456714630127,
0.27018386125564575,
-0.12640155851840973,
-0.25330817699432373,
-0.0672723725438118,
-0.0027161305770277977,
0.5851820707321167,
-0.8694725036621094,
0.5766105055809021,
-0.4403022229671478,
-0.03310023248195648,
0.4720269441604614,
-0.4085288941860199,
0.6859616637229919,
0.5436678528785706,
-0.13637743890285492,
0.026794344186782837,
-0.7107353210449219,
0.03109639883041382,
-0.10173165798187256,
-0.316502183675766,
-0.1911463886499405,
0.2910582423210144,
0.13235735893249512,
0.413117378950119,
0.3661980628967285,
-0.5222983360290527,
0.22273358702659607,
-0.3150659501552582,
0.6876177787780762,
0.6418607234954834,
-0.4322775900363922,
0.5136694312095642,
-0.09398403018712997,
0.5221441984176636,
0.11237403750419617,
-0.09867698699235916,
-0.28094178438186646,
-0.45034292340278625,
-0.7467653155326843,
-0.28351083397865295,
0.49317145347595215,
0.4285590350627899,
-0.696988582611084,
0.463890016078949,
-0.38856807351112366,
-0.5768033862113953,
-0.6482099294662476,
0.30833712220191956,
0.09463666379451752,
0.4619441628456116,
-0.08546676486730576,
-0.31987324357032776,
-0.789475679397583,
-0.8923529386520386,
-0.21691270172595978,
-0.17625226080417633,
0.030075693503022194,
0.22247380018234253,
0.3243292272090912,
-0.43446895480155945,
1.1862026453018188,
-0.267732173204422,
-0.009224365465342999,
-0.6309688091278076,
-0.010680118575692177,
0.42375341057777405,
0.15467488765716553,
0.2855580151081085,
-0.9402292966842651,
-0.2819647490978241,
0.16196510195732117,
-1.0310931205749512,
-0.2819978892803192,
0.030198831111192703,
0.09103426337242126,
0.29596829414367676,
0.6012548804283142,
-0.8384929299354553,
0.044942472130060196,
0.7649556398391724,
-0.2619284689426422,
0.3448661267757416,
-0.10068301856517792,
-0.24254150688648224,
-1.1658921241760254,
0.32996711134910583,
0.05956098437309265,
-0.060812585055828094,
-0.9697543382644653,
0.047463685274124146,
-0.2448338270187378,
-0.36372536420822144,
-0.22803008556365967,
0.8835189938545227,
-0.43852731585502625,
-0.4183768332004547,
-0.37411320209503174,
0.02209877222776413,
-0.15313751995563507,
0.012759442441165447,
0.17057670652866364,
0.6708531975746155,
1.0119677782058716,
-0.4895227551460266,
0.7430152297019958,
0.2006949782371521,
-0.3568984568119049,
0.4275662302970886,
-0.562297523021698,
0.12876686453819275,
-0.20360931754112244,
0.38382062315940857,
-0.7691612243652344,
-0.29781708121299744,
-0.04774580895900726,
-0.3447842001914978,
0.07169757783412933,
0.014973939396440983,
-0.7810075879096985,
-0.5379729866981506,
0.07076086848974228,
0.1750665307044983,
0.46141865849494934,
-0.495038241147995,
0.5876157879829407,
0.7991718649864197,
-0.2978227734565735,
-0.3964516222476959,
-0.7396038174629211,
0.48033398389816284,
-0.2796217203140259,
-0.7450159788131714,
-0.15297546982765198,
-0.008922421373426914,
-0.4816151261329651,
-0.13674022257328033,
0.2929348647594452,
-0.44604218006134033,
0.1722075641155243,
0.2592643201351166,
0.4550575017929077,
-0.29775354266166687,
0.22628644108772278,
-0.21799857914447784,
-0.2152455747127533,
0.2604362964630127,
-0.579279363155365,
0.6926811337471008,
0.07833307236433029,
-0.1990739107131958,
-0.5517714619636536,
0.43078532814979553,
0.9263679385185242,
-0.3773612082004547,
0.921247661113739,
0.48645439743995667,
-0.3744886815547943,
-0.02419256418943405,
-0.3796369433403015,
-0.07321569323539734,
-0.4490533173084259,
0.3277645707130432,
-0.25429168343544006,
-1.114354133605957,
0.7035080194473267,
-0.1907690465450287,
-0.008774840272963047,
0.2464040219783783,
0.872869074344635,
-0.0771026760339737,
1.2226612567901611,
0.7572286128997803,
-0.5936107039451599,
0.3704022169113159,
-0.25535261631011963,
0.8243895173072815,
-0.5435770750045776,
-0.09678653627634048,
-0.5958094596862793,
-0.34381935000419617,
-0.6694638133049011,
-0.07031439989805222,
0.22104215621948242,
-0.2803020179271698,
-0.09720530360937119,
0.012358097359538078,
-0.039702922105789185,
0.23484371602535248,
0.4142509400844574,
-0.4658410847187042,
0.3266744911670685,
-0.20520322024822235,
0.47106271982192993,
0.06918824464082718,
-0.8435710072517395,
-0.48285481333732605,
1.261983036994934,
0.6277185082435608,
0.842448890209198,
-0.0928841307759285,
0.48651793599128723,
0.2242335081100464,
0.11315436661243439,
-0.8369441032409668,
0.5408416390419006,
-0.21372149884700775,
-0.501227855682373,
-0.34916555881500244,
-0.565677285194397,
-1.1071699857711792,
0.019168609753251076,
-0.31538310647010803,
-0.757258415222168,
0.0788232609629631,
0.12765273451805115,
-0.03784851357340813,
0.512737512588501,
-0.9290478229522705,
0.8412992358207703,
-0.32219526171684265,
-0.3807508945465088,
-0.25590163469314575,
-0.4285801947116852,
0.4337729513645172,
-0.2759193480014801,
0.4582608938217163,
0.13565221428871155,
0.03703104332089424,
0.6935736536979675,
-0.36024805903434753,
0.6525958180427551,
-0.11785536259412766,
-0.3619043231010437,
0.29255160689353943,
-0.08252564817667007,
0.5527464747428894,
-0.21673280000686646,
-0.18588939309120178,
0.4074515700340271,
-0.23782911896705627,
-0.24954235553741455,
-0.6150386929512024,
0.7254579663276672,
-0.5284537076950073,
-0.5112509727478027,
-0.1819390058517456,
-0.9058447480201721,
-0.1302795112133026,
0.17683632671833038,
-0.2143985629081726,
0.5684049725532532,
0.017246514558792114,
0.13613872230052948,
0.5075052380561829,
-0.16543909907341003,
0.45702555775642395,
0.42798465490341187,
-0.25202128291130066,
0.23856937885284424,
1.1082714796066284,
0.220278799533844,
0.23457174003124237,
0.32560059428215027,
0.0581781268119812,
-0.3838050961494446,
-0.8989505767822266,
-0.25010058283805847,
0.3297707140445709,
-0.46042224764823914,
-0.1246042400598526,
-0.7226861119270325,
-0.3215617537498474,
-0.312605082988739,
0.04090007767081261,
-0.2170845866203308,
-0.261539489030838,
-0.022201647982001305,
0.0405249260365963,
0.23311832547187805,
0.8462406992912292,
0.06252635270357132,
0.2322375625371933,
-0.7578017115592957,
0.15919864177703857,
0.31016674637794495,
0.5471401810646057,
0.15312734246253967,
-0.06645888090133667,
-0.5321699976921082,
0.14655233919620514,
0.0734805017709732,
-0.3660479187965393,
0.5522117018699646,
-0.04619760811328888,
0.47713813185691833,
0.16229575872421265,
-0.42479193210601807,
0.3625628352165222,
-0.33962583541870117,
0.6785587668418884,
0.17934538424015045,
-0.9639770984649658,
0.1880134642124176,
-0.4432598948478699,
0.36794257164001465,
0.0663025975227356,
0.3759101927280426,
-0.8865557312965393,
-0.3486015796661377,
-0.4032583236694336,
-0.7578110694885254,
0.5961970090866089,
-0.07164223492145538,
0.28402629494667053,
0.16009970009326935,
0.13084007799625397,
0.22606216371059418,
0.5426762104034424,
-0.5310808420181274,
-0.19190771877765656,
0.2638518214225769,
-0.24323083460330963,
0.03834979608654976,
0.007458703126758337,
0.07679561525583267,
-0.1977815479040146,
0.27126210927963257,
-0.1937074363231659,
0.12675419449806213,
-0.40312179923057556,
-0.03277895599603653,
-0.11199675500392914,
0.3591828942298889,
-0.02603258192539215,
0.9629849791526794,
0.164972722530365,
-0.09491176158189774,
-0.05501271411776543,
-0.3222179412841797,
-0.05655314773321152,
0.040021490305662155,
-0.03927523270249367,
-0.2451789528131485,
0.3820500671863556,
0.9378809928894043,
-0.2559092044830322,
-0.8931184411048889,
0.2576240301132202,
0.0029885212425142527,
-0.10497722774744034,
-0.2724224328994751,
0.19560444355010986,
0.20578885078430176,
0.4135657846927643,
0.31335771083831787,
-0.27180734276771545,
0.06456782668828964,
-0.9593520164489746,
0.08941099792718887,
0.6958350539207458,
-0.11520987749099731,
-0.2326638102531433,
0.6937037110328674,
0.4345858693122864,
-0.3605434000492096,
0.6742611527442932,
0.057114873081445694,
-0.3642978370189667,
0.5376284718513489,
0.3493092656135559,
0.6694552302360535,
-0.1229391023516655,
0.04023579880595207,
-0.02963029220700264,
0.07500063627958298,
0.1780519038438797,
0.1068059578537941,
0.21168555319309235,
-0.8587951064109802,
-0.7770242691040039,
-0.6612401008605957,
-0.5474820137023926,
0.28293994069099426,
-0.26526811718940735,
0.3483450412750244,
-0.3190779685974121,
0.25082090497016907,
0.380303293466568,
0.031443700194358826,
-0.7839394807815552,
0.2080773413181305,
0.5213928818702698,
0.9653739333152771,
-0.959958553314209,
1.0695773363113403,
0.5247204899787903,
-0.16392675042152405,
-0.6331740617752075,
-0.24865128099918365,
-0.040748849511146545,
-0.5961191654205322,
0.8243878483772278,
-0.08842823654413223,
0.07141467928886414,
0.005374472122639418,
-0.6095535159111023,
-0.948678731918335,
1.035918951034546,
0.47737592458724976,
-0.7856847047805786,
-0.11792348325252533,
0.36358460783958435,
0.7679402232170105,
-0.7001731991767883,
0.2993270456790924,
0.9822277426719666,
0.5769568085670471,
-0.12647345662117004,
-1.1058293581008911,
-0.09791922569274902,
-0.16986550390720367,
0.0480961911380291,
0.5049551129341125,
-0.5699935555458069,
0.8948045372962952,
-0.039298754185438156,
-0.22084079682826996,
0.041903987526893616,
0.6922519207000732,
-0.1848980188369751,
0.2831302583217621,
0.37252330780029297,
0.5679178237915039,
0.7350674271583557,
-0.09690019488334656,
1.3467655181884766,
-0.2662171423435211,
0.1951913833618164,
0.798062264919281,
-0.6707144379615784,
0.7261158227920532,
0.3946024477481842,
-0.3269391655921936,
0.5504065752029419,
0.4095074534416199,
0.037261806428432465,
0.1087280809879303,
0.3175586462020874,
-0.17336112260818481,
-0.16612207889556885,
-0.298880934715271,
-0.07072196900844574,
0.7167378067970276,
0.7197973728179932,
-0.2669849097728729,
-0.2148536890745163,
-0.02487466111779213,
0.06909597665071487,
0.08431674540042877,
-0.37657594680786133,
0.7456480264663696,
0.032318297773599625,
-0.5850234031677246,
0.47951528429985046,
-0.11319684237241745,
0.6055645942687988,
-0.6018158793449402,
-0.062333956360816956,
-0.1097765788435936,
-0.047644518315792084,
-0.2698808014392853,
-1.0060290098190308,
0.40931856632232666,
0.11937839537858963,
-0.2995661199092865,
-0.1731119453907013,
0.5373966693878174,
-0.539147675037384,
-0.34930840134620667,
0.34910160303115845,
0.7381728887557983,
0.09268982708454132,
0.1944475769996643,
-0.6872044205665588,
0.3417481780052185,
-0.30899691581726074,
0.06554491072893143,
0.4298219084739685,
0.40111929178237915,
-0.06724037230014801,
1.16937255859375,
0.7812628149986267,
0.33129367232322693,
0.08138209581375122,
0.17169632017612457,
0.9618130326271057,
-0.5858917236328125,
-0.4814358651638031,
-0.7983387112617493,
0.3712553381919861,
-0.17485204339027405,
0.09999620914459229,
0.5803146958351135,
0.5456560254096985,
0.6619685292243958,
0.2933647036552429,
1.171924352645874,
-0.24002721905708313,
0.6610918641090393,
-0.6014737486839294,
0.6962379813194275,
-0.26324373483657837,
0.30618342757225037,
-0.16465029120445251,
-1.0242712497711182,
-0.19497855007648468,
0.07042283564805984,
-0.47429612278938293,
0.05417280271649361,
0.5842233896255493,
0.692619800567627,
-0.2277706116437912,
-0.0031613309402018785,
0.2976027727127075,
0.5490752458572388,
0.4464198052883148,
0.593316912651062,
0.6416008472442627,
-0.08900297433137894,
0.33932021260261536,
0.23897357285022736,
-0.10371343046426773,
-0.03100576251745224,
-0.6430917382240295,
-0.7346757054328918,
-0.7722441554069519,
-0.14148978888988495,
-0.0001715426769806072,
0.02600143477320671,
0.6697646379470825,
0.6685630083084106,
-0.6910017728805542,
-0.7095800638198853,
-0.1650073230266571,
0.26080623269081116,
0.14310748875141144,
-0.21028125286102295,
0.07488521933555603,
-0.31235361099243164,
-0.9938055872917175,
0.22436681389808655,
0.45405277609825134,
-0.13226287066936493,
-0.8066655397415161,
-0.1399650275707245,
-0.19895227253437042,
0.033397357910871506,
0.6360337138175964,
0.41100624203681946,
-0.482205331325531,
-0.1898033320903778,
-0.21773266792297363,
0.06421242654323578,
-0.09423176944255829,
0.9644825458526611,
-1.0663179159164429,
0.5145912170410156,
0.4876844882965088,
0.9862470626831055,
0.3110243082046509,
-0.2872629165649414,
0.9506010413169861,
-0.3994615972042084,
0.3431549072265625,
-0.03393871337175369,
0.4537956118583679,
0.6051092743873596,
-0.24678681790828705,
0.4094918370246887,
-0.062046557664871216,
-0.6127253770828247,
-0.9850196242332458,
0.5162888765335083,
-0.5957111120223999,
-0.12302296608686447,
0.9027788043022156,
0.03923914581537247,
-0.2614721953868866,
-0.2817893922328949,
-0.04203243926167488,
0.1680530309677124,
-0.23179782927036285,
0.7597373127937317,
0.8654609322547913,
-0.10203379392623901,
-0.39144375920295715,
-0.7459656000137329,
0.36414051055908203,
0.29755765199661255,
-1.1826010942459106,
0.5171342492103577,
0.42118868231773376,
-0.1203886866569519,
0.02121332474052906,
0.3543066680431366,
-0.01909959502518177,
0.020314611494541168,
-0.32541438937187195,
-0.176321342587471,
0.1959642916917801,
-0.3888225257396698,
-0.42859557271003723,
-0.14316250383853912,
0.23692384362220764,
0.07665424793958664
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.03827v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.03827v1
|
Chaos with Keywords: Exposing Large Language Models Sycophancy to Misleading Keywords and Evaluating Defense Strategies
| 2024-06-06T08:03:05 | 2024-06-06T08:03:05 |
Aswin RRV, Nemika Tyagi, Md Nayem Uddin, Neeraj Varshney, Chitta Baral
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This study explores the sycophantic tendencies of Large Language Models
(LLMs), where these models tend to provide answers that match what users want
to hear, even if they are not entirely correct. The motivation behind this
exploration stems from the common behavior observed in individuals searching
the internet for facts with partial or misleading knowledge. Similar to using
web search engines, users may recall fragments of misleading keywords and
submit them to an LLM, hoping for a comprehensive response. Our empirical
analysis of several LLMs shows the potential danger of these models amplifying
misinformation when presented with misleading keywords. Additionally, we
thoroughly assess four existing hallucination mitigation strategies to reduce
LLMs sycophantic behavior. Our experiments demonstrate the effectiveness of
these strategies for generating factually correct statements. Furthermore, our
analyses delve into knowledge-probing experiments on factual keywords and
different categories of sycophancy mitigation.
|
[
-0.24603122472763062,
-0.9096737504005432,
0.592610776424408,
0.013971680775284767,
-0.2675391435623169,
0.19630151987075806,
-0.0966821238398552,
-0.2899443805217743,
0.19210168719291687,
0.8393455147743225,
-0.6850283145904541,
-0.3498449921607971,
-0.6557589173316956,
0.13897404074668884,
-0.6743112802505493,
1.0758293867111206,
0.3227273225784302,
-0.02192060835659504,
-0.22123193740844727,
0.24685652554035187,
-0.41513821482658386,
-0.8269307017326355,
-0.6933292746543884,
-0.24750055372714996,
0.5300523042678833,
0.1626308262348175,
0.8962752223014832,
0.3930356800556183,
0.5416149497032166,
0.3066101670265198,
-0.1881992667913437,
0.1527448445558548,
-0.8696692585945129,
0.5970170497894287,
-0.29005497694015503,
-0.7997663021087646,
-0.22542297840118408,
-0.16848672926425934,
0.429800808429718,
0.54471355676651,
-0.4101620018482208,
-0.05865229293704033,
0.09294261783361435,
0.5369588136672974,
-0.8214595913887024,
0.06509604305028915,
-1.0495797395706177,
0.023430110886693,
-0.2942667603492737,
-0.4238416254520416,
-0.5838609933853149,
-0.1805897057056427,
0.21479225158691406,
-0.45688632130622864,
0.1703583151102066,
0.3530738949775696,
0.731785237789154,
0.37191566824913025,
-0.2668924033641815,
-0.7271438241004944,
-0.7531502842903137,
0.5737436413764954,
-0.6683041453361511,
0.23205555975437164,
0.4919571578502655,
-0.061551835387945175,
-0.33865153789520264,
-0.6074138879776001,
-0.6683962345123291,
-0.18826068937778473,
0.12367671728134155,
0.2691476047039032,
-0.5453081727027893,
0.481586217880249,
0.3244202435016632,
0.16635696589946747,
-0.5858582258224487,
0.12351227551698685,
-0.3886180818080902,
-0.5380886197090149,
0.6496769785881042,
0.412749320268631,
0.3468930125236511,
-0.23005667328834534,
-0.016077348962426186,
-0.2265779674053192,
-0.6696850657463074,
-0.32573646306991577,
0.5908229351043701,
0.39783427119255066,
0.08715002238750458,
0.7678313255310059,
0.038738857954740524,
0.625802755355835,
0.13149449229240417,
-0.3648473918437958,
-0.16386458277702332,
-0.26281315088272095,
-0.42457273602485657,
0.4335259199142456,
0.5874577760696411,
0.4244493842124939,
0.0814019963145256,
-0.5082123875617981,
-0.4128667116165161,
0.09345069527626038,
0.6442874073982239,
-0.7299623489379883,
-0.10955692082643509,
0.26850250363349915,
-0.34832507371902466,
-0.5035793781280518,
-0.11365476250648499,
-1.1092065572738647,
-0.826002836227417,
0.00942916888743639,
0.7575404047966003,
-0.31729450821876526,
-0.02558075822889805,
0.22498036921024323,
-0.2270951122045517,
-0.02820393815636635,
0.3013533353805542,
-0.58586186170578,
0.5741342306137085,
0.6564642786979675,
0.788798987865448,
-0.32484620809555054,
0.030430316925048828,
-0.16412238776683807,
0.16755084693431854,
-0.6264764666557312,
0.7267001271247864,
-0.4410635232925415,
-0.7445614337921143,
0.23070283234119415,
-0.03762158378958702,
-0.15877284109592438,
-0.7481827735900879,
0.6554718017578125,
-0.6905497908592224,
0.3024557828903198,
-0.38277122378349304,
-0.4902507960796356,
-0.5861935615539551,
0.23222017288208008,
-0.6348111033439636,
0.5815377831459045,
-0.44152355194091797,
-0.8663460612297058,
-0.038916703313589096,
-0.33320799469947815,
-0.3759075999259949,
0.055681709200143814,
-0.20738664269447327,
-0.33683693408966064,
0.37612229585647583,
-0.19393347203731537,
0.2687402665615082,
-0.3569173812866211,
0.17782273888587952,
-0.26648855209350586,
-0.25104808807373047,
0.3865824043750763,
-0.4640744924545288,
0.661148726940155,
0.4189494550228119,
-0.4451702833175659,
-0.010098575614392757,
-0.3950338661670685,
-0.21740153431892395,
0.2467418909072876,
-0.10067848116159439,
-0.6062495708465576,
0.3150191307067871,
-0.3767564594745636,
0.22789311408996582,
0.09923503547906876,
-0.05191035941243172,
0.13095936179161072,
-0.5926738977432251,
0.16610610485076904,
0.6953718066215515,
0.12041414529085159,
0.07660003006458282,
-0.6846596002578735,
0.6369422078132629,
0.38992294669151306,
-0.08515238016843796,
-0.1307826042175293,
-0.4005562663078308,
-0.9031778573989868,
0.030987031757831573,
-0.11661512404680252,
0.4920816719532013,
-0.6882884502410889,
0.20705875754356384,
-0.261593759059906,
-0.34535810351371765,
-0.3607679307460785,
-0.04348016157746315,
0.22321216762065887,
0.2716226875782013,
0.1025368943810463,
-0.15112662315368652,
-0.6204349994659424,
-0.8450304269790649,
-0.3900238573551178,
-0.301094651222229,
0.4158683717250824,
0.10025537759065628,
0.5417025089263916,
-0.2457703799009323,
0.5902734994888306,
-0.48016655445098877,
-0.19999049603939056,
-0.23135501146316528,
0.40062257647514343,
-0.08664066344499588,
-0.061694636940956116,
0.28156551718711853,
-0.8013782501220703,
0.13912735879421234,
-0.21239282190799713,
-0.4508269429206848,
-0.0644281879067421,
-0.20380093157291412,
0.26695168018341064,
0.4778911769390106,
0.5726954936981201,
-0.757547914981842,
0.21020691096782684,
0.6123038530349731,
-0.0649951696395874,
0.605524480342865,
-0.01859465427696705,
0.005192159675061703,
-1.2713894844055176,
0.006006590090692043,
-0.044662848114967346,
0.010128027759492397,
-0.6757731437683105,
0.3198166489601135,
-0.40064355731010437,
-0.006400240585207939,
-0.1925385445356369,
0.1850123256444931,
-0.4550900459289551,
0.058139216154813766,
-0.4178617596626282,
0.4342995285987854,
-0.36919519305229187,
0.1582982987165451,
-0.20604242384433746,
0.858012318611145,
0.529127299785614,
-0.7315017580986023,
0.4527437388896942,
-0.27074676752090454,
-0.2659297585487366,
0.107111357152462,
-0.40796154737472534,
0.04895040765404701,
-0.42898377776145935,
0.10460691899061203,
-1.2831991910934448,
-0.29625749588012695,
0.3335949778556824,
-0.24716857075691223,
0.1953524649143219,
0.2575519382953644,
-0.7799011468887329,
-0.5201473236083984,
-0.24676893651485443,
0.1455930769443512,
0.3525455892086029,
-0.0796734094619751,
0.5203458070755005,
0.5562392473220825,
-0.2783057689666748,
-0.5982258319854736,
-0.5923212170600891,
0.32128164172172546,
-0.47919031977653503,
-0.288584440946579,
0.261741578578949,
-0.08231557905673981,
-0.593722939491272,
-0.20147240161895752,
-0.34518226981163025,
0.06470154225826263,
0.30262768268585205,
0.40241843461990356,
0.195066437125206,
-0.052941497415304184,
0.3742285966873169,
-0.1821192502975464,
0.37949493527412415,
0.46531999111175537,
-0.2489394098520279,
1.0134363174438477,
0.09303555637598038,
-0.2801080048084259,
-0.28177410364151,
0.07667577266693115,
0.743874192237854,
0.0855940580368042,
0.6604680418968201,
0.13018611073493958,
-0.49492180347442627,
-0.3403989374637604,
-0.6854561567306519,
-0.5068567395210266,
-0.4611174464225769,
0.5552532076835632,
-0.051113311201334,
-0.9626113772392273,
0.49036166071891785,
-0.2575790286064148,
-0.18515241146087646,
0.4515606462955475,
0.7892174124717712,
-0.04532445967197418,
1.2346584796905518,
0.6310773491859436,
-0.1991497129201889,
-0.010485125705599785,
-0.10376330465078354,
0.57380211353302,
-0.2934885025024414,
-0.405222624540329,
-0.6755726337432861,
-0.20207369327545166,
-0.8487687110900879,
-0.3816872835159302,
0.3633019030094147,
0.03844664618372917,
0.0038313826080411673,
0.02469804883003235,
-0.3432115316390991,
0.242287740111351,
0.1608428657054901,
0.06544961780309677,
0.31400495767593384,
0.09365731477737427,
-0.3881620168685913,
-0.0978112444281578,
-0.7290710210800171,
-0.4820554852485657,
1.015326976776123,
0.3002960979938507,
1.1302790641784668,
0.27290666103363037,
0.49374350905418396,
0.22996346652507782,
-0.037873703986406326,
-1.01852548122406,
0.6555087566375732,
0.10408346354961395,
-0.8830373883247375,
-0.15474212169647217,
-0.3781907558441162,
-0.940529465675354,
0.20326553285121918,
-0.30802804231643677,
-0.9405841827392578,
0.020874716341495514,
0.1133672446012497,
-0.5533169507980347,
0.3046458661556244,
-0.31270885467529297,
0.465946763753891,
-0.23353248834609985,
-0.18296222388744354,
-0.5513864159584045,
-0.49756181240081787,
0.7510011196136475,
-0.4640807807445526,
0.2895655632019043,
0.24158158898353577,
-0.1585671454668045,
0.7849552035331726,
-0.06081939488649368,
1.04726243019104,
0.38372349739074707,
-0.47955453395843506,
0.13200260698795319,
0.3395340144634247,
0.5531256198883057,
-0.26189950108528137,
0.09926154464483261,
-0.09867056459188461,
-0.07027565687894821,
0.050016216933727264,
-0.45766374468803406,
0.6813128590583801,
-0.7370477318763733,
-1.190781593322754,
-0.6251195073127747,
-0.7729707360267639,
-0.22616054117679596,
0.20441392064094543,
0.5277124047279358,
0.1831471025943756,
-0.10233138501644135,
0.24121636152267456,
1.107810378074646,
-0.32989823818206787,
0.45609262585639954,
0.42219972610473633,
-0.4246075451374054,
-0.11994710564613342,
0.783436119556427,
0.27808627486228943,
0.3704839050769806,
0.2964862883090973,
0.15840987861156464,
-0.24382737278938293,
-0.5860605835914612,
0.15465328097343445,
0.4193413257598877,
-0.49110251665115356,
-0.24969176948070526,
-0.7978555560112,
-0.40366196632385254,
-0.6680577993392944,
0.29515373706817627,
-0.14215676486492157,
-0.24617570638656616,
-0.1982877254486084,
0.006206977646797895,
0.10242576152086258,
0.6620126962661743,
0.09350994974374771,
0.495484322309494,
-0.43553730845451355,
0.1486579030752182,
0.26430660486221313,
-0.1842252016067505,
0.09169632196426392,
-0.580070972442627,
-0.14756976068019867,
0.21698500216007233,
-0.8992920517921448,
-1.3072221279144287,
0.4765429198741913,
-0.15790705382823944,
0.6351020336151123,
0.8006543517112732,
0.20549556612968445,
0.7406104803085327,
-0.26836955547332764,
0.918843686580658,
0.13267502188682556,
-0.8863874673843384,
0.5353309512138367,
-0.27091023325920105,
0.10804563015699387,
0.163864403963089,
0.8092021346092224,
-0.619311511516571,
-0.7501019835472107,
-0.6607639789581299,
-0.7061851620674133,
0.5598270893096924,
0.09039489924907684,
0.28449296951293945,
-0.021390903741121292,
0.289753794670105,
-0.2928870618343353,
0.518792450428009,
-0.7204225063323975,
-0.39422595500946045,
0.0625382736325264,
-0.0152250025421381,
-0.001919090747833252,
-0.45705801248550415,
-0.5391175746917725,
0.06143743917346001,
0.8335030674934387,
0.0001892386208055541,
0.22321274876594543,
0.18233025074005127,
-0.12809668481349945,
-0.3844708502292633,
0.18142400681972504,
1.0503106117248535,
0.5273867845535278,
0.023636769503355026,
0.3719651401042938,
0.23465561866760254,
-0.652820348739624,
0.11081665009260178,
-0.17980703711509705,
-0.23279690742492676,
0.057239849120378494,
0.34889206290245056,
0.7113189697265625,
0.22303636372089386,
-0.8101254105567932,
0.4571734368801117,
0.161056250333786,
-0.14366228878498077,
-0.19547735154628754,
0.23414018750190735,
0.15388725697994232,
0.17538675665855408,
0.37858617305755615,
0.08240001648664474,
0.2544417083263397,
-0.8351665735244751,
0.12492210417985916,
0.7106127738952637,
-0.2762953042984009,
-0.3247779905796051,
0.47779786586761475,
-0.19154338538646698,
-0.2727015018463135,
0.4971277117729187,
0.03958709165453911,
-0.8082450032234192,
0.43002045154571533,
0.848006546497345,
0.8760623931884766,
-0.5479524731636047,
0.24721835553646088,
0.19961102306842804,
0.7356947660446167,
-0.23847876489162445,
0.13984337449073792,
0.22537289559841156,
-0.9046604037284851,
-0.19588737189769745,
-0.4273555874824524,
-0.1724151372909546,
0.6193331480026245,
-0.5684878826141357,
0.34939926862716675,
-0.5266516208648682,
-0.47192540764808655,
-0.1311780959367752,
0.061186566948890686,
-0.19337406754493713,
0.12114523351192474,
0.34587690234184265,
0.9264688491821289,
-0.6278610825538635,
0.6534948348999023,
0.6049139499664307,
-0.33947840332984924,
-0.682019829750061,
0.5196742415428162,
0.521474301815033,
-0.8745875358581543,
0.760134756565094,
-0.09661398082971573,
-0.372334748506546,
-0.03661613166332245,
-0.8172073364257812,
-0.8198557496070862,
0.9180409908294678,
0.3187706470489502,
-0.6559594869613647,
-0.32865485548973083,
0.3104524612426758,
0.4143231213092804,
-0.2340635359287262,
-0.06981222331523895,
0.41060546040534973,
0.560539960861206,
0.2709997892379761,
-0.7933445572853088,
0.04242792725563049,
0.14479948580265045,
0.08675108104944229,
0.07108502835035324,
-0.574388861656189,
0.7186183929443359,
-0.31139424443244934,
-0.5413535237312317,
0.071316197514534,
0.47288578748703003,
0.3023586869239807,
0.15303821861743927,
0.40883833169937134,
0.7952048182487488,
0.7416751980781555,
-0.12428312748670578,
0.8630412220954895,
-0.40812522172927856,
0.32085877656936646,
0.8775951862335205,
-0.23287031054496765,
0.7153441309928894,
0.5590897798538208,
0.19711486995220184,
0.3053136467933655,
0.6225101351737976,
-0.036679282784461975,
0.6115279197692871,
0.522300660610199,
-0.2963279187679291,
-0.27410775423049927,
-0.054766833782196045,
-0.20516885817050934,
0.5507177710533142,
0.6933294534683228,
-0.3051694929599762,
-0.3340691924095154,
-0.01400466077029705,
0.4544489085674286,
0.013978730887174606,
-0.32974347472190857,
0.8477742671966553,
0.11965339630842209,
-0.763108491897583,
0.5020920038223267,
0.07583575695753098,
0.60248202085495,
-0.527016818523407,
0.250108927488327,
-0.2672901451587677,
0.050911396741867065,
-0.12231635302305222,
-0.4365951418876648,
0.3396989703178406,
-0.2091434746980667,
-0.010795662179589272,
0.15452322363853455,
0.6853198409080505,
-0.4309926927089691,
-0.36042076349258423,
0.18763239681720734,
0.42528799176216125,
0.10536185652017593,
-0.017223410308361053,
-0.6985812783241272,
0.24953944981098175,
-0.09752210229635239,
0.0844363123178482,
0.18810983002185822,
0.592182993888855,
0.0322578102350235,
1.0696345567703247,
0.42389386892318726,
0.47136467695236206,
0.18432089686393738,
-0.2060978263616562,
0.8677681088447571,
-0.6054863333702087,
-0.3510150611400604,
-1.0222376585006714,
0.049211226403713226,
-0.025338804349303246,
-0.09871945530176163,
0.9987630844116211,
0.6409094929695129,
0.791655421257019,
-0.012397532351315022,
0.8009812831878662,
0.3495768904685974,
0.2416934072971344,
-0.5355392694473267,
0.9031226634979248,
-0.6433194875717163,
0.306517630815506,
-0.4194297790527344,
-0.9015921950340271,
-0.2789096534252167,
0.5987574458122253,
-0.1711941510438919,
0.0320250503718853,
0.8379183411598206,
1.1008416414260864,
0.24972522258758545,
0.28728288412094116,
0.6185009479522705,
0.8740678429603577,
0.02105507254600525,
0.3070049583911896,
1.0377979278564453,
-0.368977427482605,
0.354707807302475,
-0.026563622057437897,
0.03174927830696106,
-0.4742249846458435,
-0.726842999458313,
-0.8167434334754944,
-0.7023998498916626,
-0.32585811614990234,
-0.4926243722438812,
0.40327930450439453,
0.7512138485908508,
0.4349023401737213,
-0.7137935757637024,
-0.5947058796882629,
0.01740097627043724,
0.365472674369812,
-0.04368656501173973,
-0.24241556227207184,
-0.08306362479925156,
-0.5980470776557922,
-0.519577145576477,
0.019532499834895134,
0.3370472490787506,
0.22566697001457214,
-0.49416619539260864,
0.06250425428152084,
-0.01590961404144764,
0.535983681678772,
0.5294878482818604,
-0.028491144999861717,
-1.1196953058242798,
-0.20310243964195251,
0.05046215280890465,
-0.3545779585838318,
-0.3513173758983612,
0.8633691668510437,
-0.49837765097618103,
0.3640035390853882,
0.3719649910926819,
0.621574878692627,
-0.08328446000814438,
-0.10601557791233063,
0.497585266828537,
-0.2788614332675934,
-0.03597613051533699,
0.3096112012863159,
0.16445764899253845,
0.030608676373958588,
-0.4323098659515381,
0.08132129162549973,
0.4856179356575012,
-0.4328199326992035,
-0.9631234407424927,
0.11134357750415802,
-0.8856838345527649,
-0.6163235902786255,
1.2557904720306396,
0.29940611124038696,
-0.23466674983501434,
0.008381678722798824,
-0.18693609535694122,
0.2436167448759079,
-0.1758439540863037,
1.3746474981307983,
1.2327628135681152,
0.11284195631742477,
-0.1314878612756729,
-0.6429161429405212,
0.7087082266807556,
0.2942659854888916,
-0.7619029879570007,
0.1641198992729187,
0.4904741644859314,
0.10996834933757782,
0.5104872584342957,
0.15262086689472198,
-0.14523999392986298,
0.15348610281944275,
-0.12603159248828888,
-0.124554343521595,
0.37935951352119446,
-0.39972683787345886,
-0.3173758387565613,
0.23928962647914886,
-0.068907231092453,
0.09713137149810791
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.03816v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.03816v1
|
ReST-MCTS*: LLM Self-Training via Process Reward Guided Tree Search
| 2024-06-06T07:40:00 | 2024-06-06T07:40:00 |
Dan Zhang, Sining Zhoubian, Yisong Yue, Yuxiao Dong, Jie Tang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Recent methodologies in LLM self-training mostly rely on LLM generating
responses and filtering those with correct output answers as training data.
This approach often yields a low-quality fine-tuning training set (e.g.,
incorrect plans or intermediate reasoning). In this paper, we develop a
reinforced self-training approach, called ReST-MCTS*, based on integrating
process reward guidance with tree search MCTS* for collecting higher-quality
reasoning traces as well as per-step value to train policy and reward models.
ReST-MCTS* circumvents the per-step manual annotation typically used to train
process rewards by tree-search-based reinforcement learning: Given oracle final
correct answers, ReST-MCTS* is able to infer the correct process rewards by
estimating the probability this step can help lead to the correct answer. These
inferred rewards serve dual purposes: they act as value targets for further
refining the process reward model and also facilitate the selection of
high-quality traces for policy model self-training. We first show that the
tree-search policy in ReST-MCTS* achieves higher accuracy compared with prior
LLM reasoning baselines such as Best-of-N and Tree-of-Thought, within the same
search budget. We then show that by using traces searched by this tree-search
policy as training data, we can continuously enhance the three language models
for multiple iterations, and outperform other self-training algorithms such as
ReST$^\text{EM}$ and Self-Rewarding LM.
|
[
-0.3223188817501068,
-0.48402729630470276,
0.6858583688735962,
-0.05657588317990303,
-0.26493754982948303,
0.21052438020706177,
-0.015431832522153854,
-0.2214800864458084,
0.33968427777290344,
0.6465047001838684,
-1.0906034708023071,
-0.24602273106575012,
-0.5375950336456299,
0.22288420796394348,
0.14197218418121338,
0.9744627475738525,
-0.3394295871257782,
0.07354309409856796,
0.08997515588998795,
0.08793316036462784,
-0.3756687343120575,
-0.6644788980484009,
-0.8115790486335754,
-0.33310073614120483,
0.8461325168609619,
0.484466016292572,
0.1367492377758026,
0.7334750294685364,
0.39146170020103455,
0.19342510402202606,
0.08716778457164764,
0.25371497869491577,
-0.5637428164482117,
0.2980152666568756,
-0.35790061950683594,
-0.19985462725162506,
-0.26207077503204346,
0.2599620819091797,
0.34057357907295227,
-0.04697670415043831,
-0.25894179940223694,
0.20698145031929016,
0.1309179663658142,
0.6301120519638062,
-0.71677565574646,
0.1739448755979538,
-0.597281813621521,
0.10672665387392044,
0.038821373134851456,
-0.7892821431159973,
-0.4775010943412781,
-0.3491727411746979,
-0.23588842153549194,
-0.323525071144104,
0.0025945696979761124,
-0.11874369531869888,
0.7347012758255005,
0.5121464729309082,
-0.3696518540382385,
-0.31861087679862976,
-0.4305000603199005,
0.6934870481491089,
-0.586146354675293,
0.3615989089012146,
0.5377486348152161,
0.5138096809387207,
-0.24181097745895386,
-0.49424925446510315,
-0.16153287887573242,
-0.3525129556655884,
-0.17205452919006348,
0.3181684613227844,
0.34771373867988586,
0.3495500385761261,
0.22466321289539337,
0.2001751959323883,
-0.2689303159713745,
0.06715618818998337,
0.028472598642110825,
-0.17285454273223877,
0.5359445810317993,
0.12193949520587921,
-0.09056244045495987,
-0.15223129093647003,
-0.48850634694099426,
-0.453777551651001,
-0.8110288977622986,
0.3597298562526703,
0.13204805552959442,
0.4706098139286041,
0.4517260193824768,
0.5465809106826782,
-0.576094925403595,
0.44255101680755615,
-0.1110587939620018,
-0.428195059299469,
-0.05557384714484215,
-0.31082436442375183,
-0.20301313698291779,
0.1123124286532402,
0.605559229850769,
-0.23346000909805298,
0.22951701283454895,
-0.19670136272907257,
-0.5612872838973999,
-0.2059226781129837,
0.17643463611602783,
-0.8235028386116028,
-0.1317783147096634,
-0.08300995826721191,
-0.27470821142196655,
-0.30204060673713684,
-0.16568131744861603,
-0.06515257060527802,
0.068468376994133,
-0.4514005184173584,
0.3883751332759857,
-0.4208683669567108,
-0.28032931685447693,
0.01795755885541439,
-0.08428977429866791,
0.15279728174209595,
0.43021664023399353,
-1.1031112670898438,
0.3302179276943207,
0.6796626448631287,
0.6052194833755493,
-0.13175207376480103,
-0.4097977578639984,
-0.8442951440811157,
0.22745680809020996,
-0.161342591047287,
0.8782774806022644,
-0.6198205351829529,
-0.1539585441350937,
-0.16310428082942963,
0.11192750930786133,
-0.07947525382041931,
-0.36633989214897156,
0.6226256489753723,
-0.43837878108024597,
0.03169114515185356,
-0.602187991142273,
-0.40788477659225464,
-0.251981258392334,
0.772922158241272,
-0.336240291595459,
1.2814258337020874,
0.22389887273311615,
-0.5212000608444214,
0.4905799925327301,
-0.569555401802063,
-0.3017618656158447,
-0.10570424795150757,
-0.2855522036552429,
-0.3309527039527893,
-0.017293939366936684,
0.4639010429382324,
0.5596128106117249,
0.01594238169491291,
0.16434863209724426,
-0.4679146409034729,
-0.2701692283153534,
0.06282398104667664,
-0.482494056224823,
0.5420054793357849,
0.1834835261106491,
-0.49847087264060974,
0.19147424399852753,
-0.5438438057899475,
0.24446675181388855,
0.09294687956571579,
-0.5809369087219238,
-0.2723454236984253,
-0.01251771580427885,
-0.5703098773956299,
0.4574548900127411,
0.09014410525560379,
-0.5966238975524902,
0.409149169921875,
-0.12069371342658997,
0.4089773893356323,
0.951819896697998,
0.20070214569568634,
-0.04878336563706398,
-0.3335757851600647,
0.5273671746253967,
-0.0023039395455271006,
0.2142554074525833,
-0.40739983320236206,
-0.05738462135195732,
-0.5567840933799744,
-0.3038375675678253,
0.1776929497718811,
0.4258551001548767,
-0.5518208146095276,
0.25837528705596924,
-0.08431300520896912,
-0.29192104935646057,
-0.5204614996910095,
-0.07535349577665329,
0.48934584856033325,
0.565096378326416,
0.5978677272796631,
-0.35617852210998535,
-0.6554316282272339,
-0.6206046342849731,
-0.20182658731937408,
-0.11926675587892532,
0.1884450763463974,
0.21016350388526917,
0.5227958559989929,
-0.030489226803183556,
0.8275822997093201,
-0.023310892283916473,
-0.11231617629528046,
0.064891517162323,
0.14537277817726135,
-0.03081616759300232,
0.6359491944313049,
-0.0681067630648613,
-0.21678301692008972,
-0.245804101228714,
-0.25569650530815125,
-0.47294020652770996,
0.038063958287239075,
-0.12126731872558594,
-0.03700718656182289,
0.15800417959690094,
0.3250848650932312,
-0.23328909277915955,
0.23672427237033844,
0.37129905819892883,
-0.22792744636535645,
0.4768873453140259,
-0.18475328385829926,
0.26436883211135864,
-0.8393660187721252,
-0.17636437714099884,
-0.2918236553668976,
-0.5471363067626953,
-0.022003743797540665,
-0.0374576561152935,
0.04223334416747093,
0.277818888425827,
-0.2417655736207962,
0.4106302261352539,
-0.5964735150337219,
-0.34086528420448303,
-0.40067195892333984,
-0.07006688416004181,
-0.1861487329006195,
0.9673274755477905,
0.29657095670700073,
0.8326072096824646,
0.29274407029151917,
-0.6656893491744995,
0.16323362290859222,
0.0015352307818830013,
0.10424453765153885,
0.7132009267807007,
-0.20142698287963867,
0.12684109807014465,
0.043529853224754333,
0.4114176630973816,
-0.9543180465698242,
0.1154511570930481,
0.2594964802265167,
-0.2810616195201874,
0.2603515684604645,
-0.44217419624328613,
-0.4254174828529358,
-0.325681209564209,
-0.27239367365837097,
0.1547003984451294,
0.40622204542160034,
-0.9410303831100464,
0.33954092860221863,
0.1555294543504715,
0.20076555013656616,
-0.8040800094604492,
-0.6483510732650757,
-0.18239320814609528,
-0.128851056098938,
-0.2905087172985077,
0.08060386776924133,
0.06073186546564102,
0.4324135482311249,
0.12501560151576996,
-0.5302534103393555,
0.15012004971504211,
0.3014281690120697,
0.25660240650177,
-0.15141089260578156,
-0.17635121941566467,
0.12436044216156006,
-0.006409235764294863,
-0.37850821018218994,
0.10629405826330185,
-0.4721137583255768,
0.4012228548526764,
-0.2144024670124054,
-0.7157818675041199,
-0.45755910873413086,
-0.09519625455141068,
0.023443009704351425,
-0.3307397663593292,
0.3792757987976074,
0.4180105924606323,
-0.10335737466812134,
-0.06730713695287704,
-0.7396507859230042,
-0.5595412850379944,
-0.4376274347305298,
0.044357653707265854,
-0.770168125629425,
-1.1899616718292236,
0.06789214164018631,
-0.4081326127052307,
0.16395041346549988,
0.49432870745658875,
0.4396626353263855,
-0.3808882534503937,
1.242507815361023,
0.2711004614830017,
0.0721612200140953,
0.6103643178939819,
-0.41093218326568604,
-0.19274787604808807,
-1.0456403493881226,
-0.3669380247592926,
-0.42693760991096497,
-0.30812814831733704,
-0.580268919467926,
-0.18815775215625763,
0.1140388622879982,
0.20193850994110107,
-0.5150318741798401,
0.33930930495262146,
-0.7534163594245911,
0.5582469701766968,
0.8530552387237549,
0.19141888618469238,
0.4510209560394287,
0.019386453554034233,
-0.29795733094215393,
0.11019628494977951,
-0.9035947918891907,
-0.48569557070732117,
0.8964692950248718,
0.41112151741981506,
0.9498662948608398,
-0.2689085900783539,
1.2048767805099487,
0.0873638391494751,
0.4456608295440674,
-0.4775598347187042,
0.4130563735961914,
0.22670632600784302,
-0.32322701811790466,
-0.45077943801879883,
-0.5343675017356873,
-0.9807627201080322,
0.24598509073257446,
0.08607993274927139,
-0.55364590883255,
-0.04971453920006752,
0.36537542939186096,
-0.26926419138908386,
0.4899227023124695,
-0.5617111921310425,
0.8934929370880127,
-0.6558415293693542,
-0.3234616219997406,
-0.4224988520145416,
-0.4897819757461548,
0.5119094252586365,
0.43798238039016724,
-0.0921049639582634,
-0.42179247736930847,
-0.026701126247644424,
0.5974304676055908,
-0.48329469561576843,
0.8486915230751038,
-0.3755675256252289,
0.1784873753786087,
0.39756277203559875,
0.3568321466445923,
0.9386205673217773,
0.12348104268312454,
0.24223902821540833,
-0.24662387371063232,
0.3563286066055298,
-0.5240343809127808,
-0.5873364806175232,
0.5601530075073242,
-0.5997324585914612,
-0.5480307936668396,
-0.7187912464141846,
-0.28953227400779724,
-0.2759768068790436,
0.07343002408742905,
-0.15709158778190613,
0.19949200749397278,
-0.10480378568172455,
-0.09803424030542374,
0.6818920969963074,
0.23381568491458893,
0.47783803939819336,
0.49840113520622253,
-0.034846287220716476,
-0.5690687894821167,
0.6629133820533752,
-0.025252019986510277,
0.20768049359321594,
0.4887296259403229,
0.3082427978515625,
-0.6114823222160339,
-0.49989205598831177,
-0.3795727491378784,
0.20842532813549042,
-0.6321020126342773,
-0.5236509442329407,
-0.49795296788215637,
-0.29190462827682495,
-0.2121109664440155,
-0.014563317410647869,
-0.4350755214691162,
-0.4622558355331421,
0.03883608430624008,
-0.24450965225696564,
0.5013672113418579,
0.6856461763381958,
-0.3316006064414978,
0.4056016504764557,
-0.5916972160339355,
0.012318183667957783,
0.5417615175247192,
0.6653098464012146,
-0.13051190972328186,
-0.46790754795074463,
-0.33338662981987,
0.244408518075943,
-0.3941284716129303,
-0.8060508370399475,
0.17034904658794403,
-0.30577418208122253,
0.5805922150611877,
0.10250143706798553,
-0.11734749376773834,
0.8255802392959595,
-0.231655552983284,
0.4207506775856018,
0.16386570036411285,
-0.5441145896911621,
0.6669566631317139,
-0.07630495727062225,
0.1333009898662567,
0.8125512599945068,
0.23771536350250244,
-0.5731532573699951,
-0.26019513607025146,
-0.913709819316864,
-0.4006333649158478,
1.01111900806427,
0.07383812218904495,
-0.2511521279811859,
-0.1160481721162796,
0.5080379247665405,
-0.09146570414304733,
-0.01612885482609272,
-0.8342674970626831,
0.2999894618988037,
-0.3749787211418152,
-0.1486244648694992,
0.13209235668182373,
-0.4520576596260071,
-0.2696116864681244,
-0.10006508231163025,
1.1197091341018677,
-0.4082779288291931,
0.09807934612035751,
0.4809756875038147,
-0.07455451041460037,
-0.22549684345722198,
0.2456696629524231,
0.43784061074256897,
0.17152716219425201,
-0.3426854908466339,
0.5239590406417847,
0.2706034481525421,
-0.017595892772078514,
0.4486205279827118,
-0.14395171403884888,
-0.06269646435976028,
-0.27986806631088257,
0.04213930293917656,
0.9112157225608826,
0.23314595222473145,
-0.5705466270446777,
0.22299794852733612,
-0.004331470932811499,
-0.19066403806209564,
-0.23330675065517426,
0.25093385577201843,
0.08992981910705566,
0.40570980310440063,
0.03792864456772804,
-0.17333175241947174,
0.03337666019797325,
-0.5151339769363403,
0.35042282938957214,
0.6919453740119934,
-0.5113343000411987,
-0.1172499805688858,
0.31365740299224854,
0.0007995268097147346,
-0.33326345682144165,
0.5376040935516357,
-0.32299163937568665,
-0.5653396844863892,
0.3258856236934662,
0.574990451335907,
0.9690543413162231,
-0.31972065567970276,
0.18955235183238983,
0.6450105905532837,
0.4560633897781372,
-0.45951518416404724,
0.38645899295806885,
-0.47491851449012756,
-0.3822220265865326,
-0.7328591346740723,
-0.42361798882484436,
-0.5323129892349243,
0.0756710022687912,
-0.25666582584381104,
0.20874671638011932,
-0.4819006323814392,
0.10655283182859421,
-0.631148636341095,
0.10509313642978668,
-0.4828627407550812,
0.3897446095943451,
-0.08353227376937866,
0.9132988452911377,
-0.5171306133270264,
0.9671276807785034,
0.32910436391830444,
-0.7265284657478333,
-1.1145902872085571,
-0.26363563537597656,
-0.3355215787887573,
-1.1183061599731445,
0.6500686407089233,
0.11452289670705795,
-0.25336918234825134,
0.20621833205223083,
-0.45039403438568115,
-1.2133244276046753,
1.205675721168518,
0.33654794096946716,
-0.5017456412315369,
-0.1323675513267517,
0.008986616507172585,
0.31067007780075073,
-0.4289300739765167,
0.6795385479927063,
0.6791200637817383,
0.3879905045032501,
0.5313548445701599,
-0.6913031339645386,
0.18850669264793396,
0.18119776248931885,
-0.10817989706993103,
0.3290348947048187,
-0.6180275678634644,
0.48535478115081787,
-0.017256222665309906,
-0.1771758496761322,
-0.2581396698951721,
0.4403543472290039,
0.7676427960395813,
0.19245927035808563,
0.48548179864883423,
0.745935320854187,
0.6524471044540405,
-0.23265883326530457,
0.9706682562828064,
-0.16635529696941376,
0.3532187044620514,
1.393950343132019,
0.17951735854148865,
0.7721614241600037,
0.5365398526191711,
-0.03396586328744888,
0.5798770189285278,
1.2263994216918945,
0.14431071281433105,
0.5989202857017517,
0.3154783546924591,
0.051456473767757416,
-0.40695086121559143,
0.0049501508474349976,
-0.158750981092453,
-0.04373631626367569,
0.11925318092107773,
-0.2025551199913025,
-0.4127834737300873,
-0.1635669618844986,
-0.0804934948682785,
-0.08942613750696182,
-0.22973789274692535,
0.8941627740859985,
0.06210285797715187,
-1.0126031637191772,
0.7581762075424194,
-0.10838969051837921,
0.5318670272827148,
-0.7251019477844238,
-0.10016775131225586,
-0.3441865146160126,
-0.026875676587224007,
-0.18863056600093842,
-0.7650299072265625,
0.2607075572013855,
-0.05652650073170662,
0.2402142584323883,
-0.7086134552955627,
0.5999729037284851,
-0.36310407519340515,
-0.08139652758836746,
0.17349186539649963,
0.39841023087501526,
0.32773950695991516,
-0.2483464926481247,
-0.9037854671478271,
-0.3177075684070587,
-0.11872986704111099,
-0.5326420068740845,
0.31148022413253784,
0.6497595906257629,
-0.02346969209611416,
0.6931616067886353,
0.6366089582443237,
-0.0006959791062399745,
0.13800273835659027,
-0.02282601222395897,
0.6772953867912292,
-0.8856892585754395,
-0.6485012173652649,
-0.8852035403251648,
0.41115033626556396,
0.016808398067951202,
-0.12540647387504578,
0.4372636675834656,
0.7132107615470886,
1.0686662197113037,
0.2324553281068802,
0.6844800114631653,
0.11254053562879562,
0.6908355951309204,
-0.7785863280296326,
-0.03526635840535164,
-0.48773467540740967,
0.2740653455257416,
0.08831674605607986,
-0.7279660105705261,
0.12180180847644806,
0.663682758808136,
-0.3023679554462433,
0.24602562189102173,
0.7410746216773987,
0.6759932637214661,
-0.24972279369831085,
-0.09619174152612686,
0.18398717045783997,
-0.1430220901966095,
0.38503608107566833,
0.7323476672172546,
1.0493996143341064,
-0.18687224388122559,
0.6268653869628906,
-0.4023440182209015,
-0.058552201837301254,
-0.29395925998687744,
-0.8268207907676697,
-0.7451590299606323,
-0.48958900570869446,
-0.13587477803230286,
-0.39896103739738464,
0.2228015661239624,
1.0286356210708618,
0.90849369764328,
-0.7719019651412964,
-0.3437538743019104,
-0.4664817154407501,
0.2709032893180847,
-0.5434024333953857,
-0.08954890072345734,
0.29369285702705383,
-0.9443404674530029,
-0.31347227096557617,
0.6046644449234009,
0.3621522784233093,
0.2646431028842926,
-0.49366140365600586,
-0.5202620625495911,
-0.30704355239868164,
-0.07318773120641708,
0.3626846671104431,
0.4895094335079193,
-0.8246263265609741,
-0.4056691825389862,
0.08300688862800598,
-0.25132620334625244,
0.4118451774120331,
1.092369556427002,
-1.095587968826294,
0.32687345147132874,
0.3824315369129181,
0.8594688177108765,
1.0982939004898071,
-0.03670801967382431,
0.2848799228668213,
-0.7371280789375305,
-0.14846162497997284,
0.3768291473388672,
0.3947967290878296,
0.25971242785453796,
-0.289537638425827,
1.0594598054885864,
0.2731046676635742,
-0.5810368061065674,
-0.748388946056366,
0.4549899995326996,
-0.8269754648208618,
-0.27705061435699463,
0.9372429251670837,
-0.04497259855270386,
-0.29976287484169006,
0.2018449753522873,
-0.40783101320266724,
0.43145421147346497,
-0.43920615315437317,
0.9514272809028625,
0.5200278162956238,
-0.37611231207847595,
-0.4581000804901123,
-0.2867528796195984,
0.8303441405296326,
0.5894489288330078,
-0.8890284299850464,
0.11298157274723053,
0.26602914929389954,
0.31804734468460083,
-0.200353741645813,
0.9231668710708618,
0.05275275930762291,
0.13870370388031006,
-0.3103931248188019,
0.22758997976779938,
-0.3265087306499481,
-0.36808186769485474,
-0.29742395877838135,
0.05553097650408745,
0.44091856479644775,
-0.3525177538394928
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.03814v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.03814v2
|
Improving Zero-Shot Chinese-English Code-Switching ASR with kNN-CTC and Gated Monolingual Datastores
| 2024-06-06T07:39:17 | 2024-06-14T02:36:39 |
Jiaming Zhou, Shiwan Zhao, Hui Wang, Tian-Hao Zhang, Haoqin Sun, Xuechen Wang, Yong Qin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
The kNN-CTC model has proven to be effective for monolingual automatic speech
recognition (ASR). However, its direct application to multilingual scenarios
like code-switching, presents challenges. Although there is potential for
performance improvement, a kNN-CTC model utilizing a single bilingual datastore
can inadvertently introduce undesirable noise from the alternative language. To
address this, we propose a novel kNN-CTC-based code-switching ASR (CS-ASR)
framework that employs dual monolingual datastores and a gated datastore
selection mechanism to reduce noise interference. Our method selects the
appropriate datastore for decoding each frame, ensuring the injection of
language-specific information into the ASR process. We apply this framework to
cutting-edge CTC-based models, developing an advanced CS-ASR system. Extensive
experiments demonstrate the remarkable effectiveness of our gated datastore
mechanism in enhancing the performance of zero-shot Chinese-English CS-ASR.
|
[
-0.10260512679815292,
-0.3874764144420624,
-0.0695100799202919,
0.24110546708106995,
-0.4222084879875183,
0.24475398659706116,
-0.29797133803367615,
-0.4999404847621918,
-0.01740739867091179,
0.2946089506149292,
-0.31671613454818726,
-0.6576933264732361,
-0.38041171431541443,
0.2129867672920227,
-0.5455653667449951,
0.7679851055145264,
-0.1731376200914383,
0.3296191692352295,
0.2816292643547058,
-0.1457819789648056,
-0.4066048562526703,
-0.5811300873756409,
-1.1053366661071777,
-0.25980570912361145,
0.3120419383049011,
0.23406711220741272,
0.7342930436134338,
0.8255835771560669,
0.12166526168584824,
0.12860283255577087,
-0.11645127832889557,
-0.19091898202896118,
-0.042570702731609344,
-0.17791320383548737,
0.15860995650291443,
-0.3355468809604645,
-0.33788245916366577,
-0.5830965042114258,
0.553249716758728,
0.5012468695640564,
-0.16352301836013794,
-0.28622516989707947,
-0.03056528978049755,
0.42592376470565796,
-0.7085574269294739,
0.36312997341156006,
-0.6269350647926331,
0.386178195476532,
-0.38771310448646545,
-0.1161346435546875,
-0.5007545351982117,
0.03956030309200287,
0.03054785542190075,
-0.4695693850517273,
0.2362576723098755,
-0.7869191765785217,
0.7664245963096619,
-0.039580147713422775,
-0.56085604429245,
-0.26813599467277527,
-0.8966798782348633,
0.6669965386390686,
-0.6992138028144836,
1.020445466041565,
0.2857620418071747,
0.25732406973838806,
0.45464569330215454,
-0.23433427512645721,
-0.4754357933998108,
-0.1186419203877449,
0.20677880942821503,
0.3259439468383789,
0.01966942846775055,
-0.16411231458187103,
0.128286212682724,
0.04554416239261627,
-0.6427549719810486,
0.06345388293266296,
-0.4424059987068176,
-0.5494269728660583,
0.5255110263824463,
-0.08003319054841995,
0.20633576810359955,
-0.13310977816581726,
-0.23393553495407104,
-0.0990968570113182,
-0.6362598538398743,
0.23926307260990143,
0.22674551606178284,
0.8884217739105225,
-0.13412880897521973,
-0.05335790291428566,
-0.2691876292228699,
0.5635847449302673,
-0.02588096261024475,
0.06471207737922668,
0.4014650583267212,
-0.47917357087135315,
0.01982431858778,
0.6468079686164856,
0.6643451452255249,
0.08864110708236694,
0.05133017897605896,
-0.48403385281562805,
-0.14331600069999695,
0.6331837773323059,
0.10929124057292938,
-0.660465657711029,
-0.35327407717704773,
0.195415198802948,
-0.375384122133255,
-0.3915792405605316,
0.09521038830280304,
-0.5959333181381226,
0.06559869647026062,
-0.16922463476657867,
0.3198687434196472,
-0.2840491533279419,
-0.6059072613716125,
0.22184155881404877,
0.16240067780017853,
0.3181375563144684,
0.044101908802986145,
-0.6040244102478027,
0.47416672110557556,
0.3008618950843811,
1.0389224290847778,
-0.5034142136573792,
-0.38076531887054443,
-0.597488284111023,
0.27287158370018005,
-0.3499711751937866,
0.5943238139152527,
-0.4596351683139801,
-0.7105231285095215,
0.34357693791389465,
0.085228331387043,
-0.04175104573369026,
-0.46639761328697205,
0.5424540638923645,
-0.6562307476997375,
-0.21147501468658447,
-0.264301598072052,
0.02494663931429386,
-0.015037329867482185,
0.184382364153862,
-0.8118944764137268,
0.726041853427887,
-0.3005390465259552,
-0.45697638392448425,
0.4172411262989044,
-0.8601723909378052,
-1.0063793659210205,
-0.04007365182042122,
-0.20580632984638214,
-0.3930251896381378,
-0.35058894753456116,
0.423409640789032,
-0.08956881612539291,
-0.021010398864746094,
0.03598389774560928,
0.09141210466623306,
-0.44749459624290466,
0.1950850933790207,
-0.7926856875419617,
1.0218900442123413,
0.4169774055480957,
-0.2522118389606476,
-0.1425512135028839,
-0.7992773652076721,
0.20248199999332428,
-0.03509886935353279,
-0.48287248611450195,
-0.36038365960121155,
-0.017257176339626312,
0.3247245252132416,
0.48878079652786255,
0.22749045491218567,
-0.642817497253418,
-0.0025451492983847857,
-0.25408515334129333,
0.3573037385940552,
0.4143727123737335,
-0.2764236629009247,
0.5518757700920105,
-0.18481624126434326,
0.5416988134384155,
0.613627016544342,
0.11759772896766663,
-0.07656723260879517,
-0.24233478307724,
-0.6118065118789673,
-0.06492536514997482,
0.4498986005783081,
0.7794655561447144,
-1.154359221458435,
0.1092657744884491,
-0.16741664707660675,
-0.07296285778284073,
-0.7626668810844421,
-0.020631734281778336,
0.5859720706939697,
0.41295698285102844,
0.3282904624938965,
-0.5160800814628601,
-0.6024264693260193,
-0.48861321806907654,
-0.27669814229011536,
-0.1428554207086563,
0.039641913026571274,
0.3722134232521057,
0.07884100824594498,
-0.154015451669693,
0.7965856194496155,
-0.14285120368003845,
-0.21074403822422028,
-0.19453993439674377,
0.0023885115515440702,
0.386371910572052,
0.4064653217792511,
0.126409649848938,
-0.9957072734832764,
-0.8802089691162109,
0.37107279896736145,
-0.4730658233165741,
-0.30128633975982666,
-0.31297338008880615,
-0.16102267801761627,
0.6556540131568909,
0.45112043619155884,
-0.41108277440071106,
0.6579724550247192,
0.32220467925071716,
-0.1468583345413208,
0.734663724899292,
-0.0433705635368824,
0.471478670835495,
-0.9063677787780762,
0.12087094038724899,
-0.308401882648468,
-0.1814335286617279,
-1.0134220123291016,
-0.06217968463897705,
0.43100813031196594,
-0.12963683903217316,
-0.5684964060783386,
0.30231791734695435,
-0.4116877317428589,
-0.02458980120718479,
-0.2974853813648224,
0.02111954055726528,
-0.19751615822315216,
0.4529699981212616,
0.413459450006485,
0.7454524040222168,
0.7354204654693604,
-0.9732301235198975,
0.06504185497760773,
0.39585697650909424,
0.035141848027706146,
0.42154642939567566,
-0.30734968185424805,
0.20246362686157227,
0.06550808250904083,
0.06683551520109177,
-0.6216593384742737,
0.33886799216270447,
0.10595150291919708,
-0.6003010272979736,
0.4600401520729065,
-0.4232223331928253,
-0.4050762355327606,
-0.4202613830566406,
-0.19876886904239655,
0.5920915007591248,
0.18710488080978394,
-0.8150073289871216,
0.4198817014694214,
0.3012293577194214,
-0.08392590284347534,
-0.5732394456863403,
-1.034691572189331,
0.29789894819259644,
0.21311922371387482,
-0.4153105914592743,
0.25499624013900757,
-0.19633892178535461,
0.31422343850135803,
-0.10001546889543533,
-0.523207426071167,
-0.5000715851783752,
-0.3935439884662628,
0.041665054857730865,
0.5784821510314941,
-0.38957399129867554,
-0.05302320048213005,
0.20501293241977692,
-0.4254043996334076,
-0.13253605365753174,
-0.5846810936927795,
0.5686752200126648,
0.003015697468072176,
-0.2725153863430023,
-0.38965171575546265,
0.3979101777076721,
0.41892385482788086,
-0.30578669905662537,
0.2790747880935669,
0.3452553451061249,
-0.2558847665786743,
-0.2070307582616806,
-0.244284987449646,
-0.14383362233638763,
-0.4618350863456726,
0.5544816851615906,
-0.5178800821304321,
-0.8116728067398071,
0.784559965133667,
0.154091015458107,
0.02092733047902584,
0.03967246785759926,
0.554126501083374,
0.31697529554367065,
0.8512421250343323,
0.2574091851711273,
-0.4736509919166565,
0.5199901461601257,
-0.19665466248989105,
0.3877337574958801,
-0.540638267993927,
0.2047685831785202,
-0.5041020512580872,
-0.21150492131710052,
-0.5574789643287659,
-0.5195029377937317,
0.43275731801986694,
-0.13149487972259521,
-0.2754017412662506,
0.6563997864723206,
-0.6114647388458252,
0.6802577376365662,
0.23139749467372894,
-0.014812826178967953,
0.7122122049331665,
0.10623083263635635,
-0.26326772570610046,
-0.09501786530017853,
-0.9130536317825317,
0.028931597247719765,
0.9505966305732727,
0.026281658560037613,
0.7797285914421082,
0.09823067486286163,
0.4006440341472626,
0.1262536495923996,
-0.21249344944953918,
-0.5339947938919067,
0.5611330270767212,
-0.6925305128097534,
-0.7150302529335022,
-0.20547659695148468,
-0.6941770315170288,
-0.7817883491516113,
0.27483201026916504,
0.17356553673744202,
-0.6541773676872253,
0.306747168302536,
0.19636563956737518,
-0.30088919401168823,
0.5884851217269897,
-0.5248289704322815,
0.7235634326934814,
-0.17534400522708893,
-0.24567089974880219,
-0.09686611592769623,
-0.6670700311660767,
0.06690075993537903,
-0.05433039739727974,
0.026675967499613762,
0.40422844886779785,
0.1530838906764984,
0.44694602489471436,
-0.29037946462631226,
0.6025772094726562,
-0.4044955372810364,
-0.07072826474905014,
0.3155651390552521,
0.37011322379112244,
0.4763142168521881,
-0.008319785818457603,
-0.27297720313072205,
0.7726118564605713,
0.17603282630443573,
-0.11472215503454208,
-0.4701148271560669,
0.6802254915237427,
-0.7696073651313782,
0.038380272686481476,
-0.30984100699424744,
-0.6114392876625061,
-0.14948999881744385,
0.2159164845943451,
0.3913886249065399,
0.4622805416584015,
-0.221791610121727,
0.12291791290044785,
0.5297252535820007,
-0.16440387070178986,
0.4829445481300354,
1.2011266946792603,
-0.20160475373268127,
-0.43676283955574036,
1.0317904949188232,
0.40991857647895813,
0.3391645550727844,
0.5184565782546997,
0.0424155592918396,
-0.31154340505599976,
-0.3119000494480133,
-0.6415964961051941,
-0.17506346106529236,
-0.35408151149749756,
-0.35223376750946045,
-0.7229681611061096,
-0.7618463635444641,
-0.5763119459152222,
-0.393860787153244,
-0.7104782462120056,
-0.25678157806396484,
-0.0799567699432373,
0.008577707223594189,
0.3814069330692291,
0.12412143498659134,
-0.2613093852996826,
0.2224501669406891,
-0.7555993795394897,
0.4656420648097992,
0.11440262943506241,
0.6916984915733337,
0.12307979166507721,
-0.649540364742279,
-0.37686726450920105,
0.28081071376800537,
0.046528421342372894,
-0.7785956263542175,
0.2943103015422821,
0.15652193129062653,
0.17861562967300415,
0.4948800206184387,
0.3444141447544098,
0.7376932501792908,
-0.53514164686203,
0.5568857192993164,
0.19880381226539612,
-1.1292967796325684,
0.38801324367523193,
-0.3581247329711914,
0.8089296817779541,
0.6266197562217712,
0.029998168349266052,
-1.024130940437317,
-0.34919610619544983,
-0.10408137738704681,
-0.8831154108047485,
1.1323224306106567,
0.3112327754497528,
-0.1040281131863594,
0.08871807903051376,
0.0394999124109745,
0.06048119068145752,
0.16808302700519562,
-0.8742168545722961,
-0.13552971184253693,
-0.5110840797424316,
-0.04618903249502182,
0.3440592288970947,
0.26697471737861633,
0.2481352835893631,
-0.32248353958129883,
0.8242805600166321,
-0.13811032474040985,
0.26187217235565186,
0.22075243294239044,
-0.1954353302717209,
-0.2110414355993271,
0.3754272758960724,
0.2360447496175766,
0.0009538185549899936,
0.008954362943768501,
-0.061531346291303635,
0.3771010935306549,
-0.6868880391120911,
0.015363713726401329,
0.26317840814590454,
-0.6758576035499573,
0.3180800974369049,
-0.157371386885643,
0.8280960321426392,
0.4089462161064148,
-0.4839664101600647,
0.4473038911819458,
0.04346882179379463,
-0.12250999361276627,
-0.30684906244277954,
-0.035284578800201416,
-0.09330146759748459,
-0.012556811794638634,
0.2703453302383423,
0.12783798575401306,
0.18009410798549652,
-0.3222334384918213,
0.4251505136489868,
0.306368887424469,
-0.44575390219688416,
-0.2692543864250183,
0.5708370208740234,
0.2944329082965851,
-0.46485865116119385,
0.7102695107460022,
-0.2551729083061218,
-0.6009182929992676,
0.748049795627594,
0.8145524263381958,
1.0106786489486694,
-0.5400260090827942,
0.2504827380180359,
0.5792480707168579,
0.35295069217681885,
0.02187380939722061,
0.375747412443161,
-0.48762035369873047,
-1.0061193704605103,
-0.21448096632957458,
-0.30560949444770813,
-0.3514831066131592,
-0.14801250398159027,
-0.8950669765472412,
0.5888673067092896,
-0.21534572541713715,
0.08671539276838303,
-0.28609979152679443,
-0.10510072857141495,
-0.5198714733123779,
0.035124871879816055,
0.20706115663051605,
0.8355188965797424,
-0.5554630756378174,
1.2277965545654297,
0.38141947984695435,
-0.24045094847679138,
-0.7673726081848145,
-0.03749362379312515,
0.20698605477809906,
-0.580489993095398,
0.3052539527416229,
-0.05519740656018257,
-0.19415049254894257,
-0.16547365486621857,
-0.3156174421310425,
-0.6152613162994385,
1.0203601121902466,
0.12657439708709717,
-0.5987228155136108,
0.18953876197338104,
0.540749728679657,
0.44252899289131165,
-0.27539366483688354,
0.07172587513923645,
0.6402509212493896,
0.2535361349582672,
0.39014875888824463,
-1.1172611713409424,
-0.3203672766685486,
-0.47995802760124207,
0.04900628328323364,
0.3875139355659485,
-0.6885572075843811,
0.6629742980003357,
-0.08302716165781021,
-0.4839441776275635,
-0.042782582342624664,
0.3387607932090759,
0.2753465175628662,
0.3872385323047638,
0.6775557994842529,
0.28714072704315186,
0.35356223583221436,
0.13712485134601593,
0.5691187381744385,
-0.49060046672821045,
0.2307807207107544,
1.400093913078308,
-0.6363996863365173,
1.059821367263794,
0.19790583848953247,
-0.269649475812912,
0.18399620056152344,
-0.03286006301641464,
-0.16374149918556213,
0.6395511627197266,
-0.09124167263507843,
-0.5224636197090149,
-0.09673504531383514,
-0.10829410701990128,
-0.42552897334098816,
0.6093348860740662,
0.0989721342921257,
0.0294854287058115,
-0.3796612620353699,
0.06401553750038147,
0.1206866130232811,
-0.19919882714748383,
-0.2544359564781189,
0.8132928609848022,
-0.10524289309978485,
-0.14408688247203827,
0.5561777353286743,
-0.04055606946349144,
1.0784568786621094,
-1.0876283645629883,
0.030206551775336266,
-0.14546746015548706,
0.10930895060300827,
-0.19979479908943176,
-0.4294109046459198,
0.42523738741874695,
0.36200207471847534,
-0.404621422290802,
-0.28588366508483887,
0.8249903917312622,
-0.9435699582099915,
-0.548575222492218,
0.5934072732925415,
0.10871302336454391,
0.17197145521640778,
0.0010394181590527296,
-0.5815748572349548,
0.32964709401130676,
0.14049626886844635,
0.39862868189811707,
0.3860751688480377,
0.3336122930049896,
0.009265418164432049,
0.34476301074028015,
0.933659017086029,
0.27153241634368896,
0.09995931386947632,
0.4323859214782715,
0.659528911113739,
-0.6468096971511841,
-1.0080839395523071,
-0.45605021715164185,
0.44725677371025085,
-0.04908493906259537,
-0.1655542105436325,
0.630924642086029,
0.8873552083969116,
1.0264936685562134,
-0.15333192050457,
0.8273313641548157,
-0.009346944279968739,
0.445665568113327,
-0.23762068152427673,
1.2557700872421265,
-0.27797913551330566,
0.21070356667041779,
-0.4860343337059021,
-0.3891312777996063,
-0.4774160385131836,
0.7193384766578674,
0.04212528467178345,
0.004099362529814243,
0.49728676676750183,
1.2542024850845337,
-0.12337037920951843,
0.34210482239723206,
0.6384017467498779,
0.5741830468177795,
0.35599419474601746,
0.8071744441986084,
0.42066067457199097,
-0.9316156506538391,
1.0400115251541138,
-0.2255413979291916,
-0.015579435974359512,
0.067289337515831,
-0.6388395428657532,
-0.48247748613357544,
-0.6245863437652588,
-0.7331347465515137,
-0.4153088629245758,
0.33785879611968994,
0.697127640247345,
0.6897296905517578,
-1.2344269752502441,
-0.6229915618896484,
-0.06732507795095444,
0.006286634132266045,
-0.4256473779678345,
-0.2732784152030945,
0.21131041646003723,
-0.145594984292984,
-0.5355475544929504,
0.4740154445171356,
0.5648556351661682,
-0.15787744522094727,
0.12188361585140228,
-0.43216779828071594,
-0.23327261209487915,
0.03608763590455055,
0.5867680907249451,
0.590080976486206,
-0.5097180604934692,
-0.035292938351631165,
0.14650385081768036,
-0.05681459605693817,
0.14135907590389252,
1.1043237447738647,
-0.7819886803627014,
0.7860282063484192,
0.30579790472984314,
0.7643218636512756,
0.39045703411102295,
-0.4534229636192322,
0.4919249415397644,
-0.7376714944839478,
0.2334887832403183,
0.2976185977458954,
0.012101619504392147,
0.15381574630737305,
-0.32721030712127686,
0.33096781373023987,
0.1597319096326828,
-0.39682111144065857,
-0.8201543092727661,
0.11481012403964996,
-1.0376794338226318,
-0.1910683661699295,
1.0429569482803345,
0.11898577213287354,
-0.0005335647729225457,
-0.5236056447029114,
-0.19232352077960968,
0.23917432129383087,
-0.6954982280731201,
0.8501949906349182,
0.7287357449531555,
0.12527386844158173,
-0.2246571183204651,
-0.5649981498718262,
0.2972717583179474,
0.46292009949684143,
-0.5637920498847961,
0.35251155495643616,
0.31379708647727966,
0.0522458478808403,
0.06794582307338715,
0.7773352861404419,
-0.5285354852676392,
0.6451771259307861,
0.095759816467762,
0.2516610026359558,
-0.02683148719370365,
-0.4408209025859833,
-0.6789689660072327,
-0.11677956581115723,
-0.40037861466407776,
-0.3888930082321167
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.03807v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.03807v1
|
Tool-Planner: Dynamic Solution Tree Planning for Large Language Model with Tool Clustering
| 2024-06-06T07:30:14 | 2024-06-06T07:30:14 |
Yanming Liu, Xinyue Peng, Yuwei Zhang, Jiannan Cao, Xuhong Zhang, Sheng Cheng, Xun Wang, Jianwei Yin, Tianyu Du
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.RO
|
Large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated exceptional reasoning
capabilities, enabling them to solve various complex problems. Recently, this
ability has been applied to the paradigm of tool learning. Tool learning
involves providing examples of tool usage and their corresponding functions,
allowing LLMs to formulate plans and demonstrate the process of invoking and
executing each tool. LLMs can address tasks that they cannot complete
independently, thereby enhancing their potential across different tasks.
However, this approach faces two key challenges. First, redundant error
correction leads to unstable planning and long execution time. Additionally,
designing a correct plan among multiple tools is also a challenge in tool
learning. To address these issues, we propose Tool-Planner, a task-processing
framework based on toolkits. Tool-Planner groups tools based on the API
functions with the same function into a toolkit and allows LLMs to implement
planning across the various toolkits. When a tool error occurs, the language
model can reselect and adjust tools based on the toolkit. Experiments show that
our approach demonstrates a high pass and win rate across different datasets
and optimizes the planning scheme for tool learning in models such as GPT-4 and
Claude 3, showcasing the potential of our method.
|
[
-0.19918708503246307,
-0.6522723436355591,
0.6566786170005798,
0.28493690490722656,
-0.23347510397434235,
0.5500797629356384,
-0.2496584802865982,
-0.12071739882230759,
0.17948591709136963,
0.29343774914741516,
-0.7505898475646973,
-0.5733692049980164,
-0.44891607761383057,
-0.04305111616849899,
-0.3235156834125519,
0.44419780373573303,
-0.16484665870666504,
-0.07984992861747742,
0.04384806379675865,
0.06962449103593826,
-0.8136503100395203,
-0.35049015283584595,
-0.9626442193984985,
-0.3217567801475525,
0.6485182642936707,
0.7626811265945435,
0.38363972306251526,
0.6330413818359375,
0.38821786642074585,
0.37595969438552856,
-0.18132519721984863,
0.02408323809504509,
-0.3933892548084259,
0.3522084653377533,
-0.24248255789279938,
-0.586260199546814,
-0.763535737991333,
-0.29364013671875,
0.48689162731170654,
0.8066926598548889,
-0.4174775779247284,
0.129877969622612,
-0.051604025065898895,
0.12813618779182434,
-0.44684821367263794,
0.30953913927078247,
-1.0552961826324463,
0.16727621853351593,
0.02384807914495468,
-0.03209354728460312,
-0.37709423899650574,
0.04673952981829643,
-0.005637801252305508,
-0.5712380409240723,
0.3215729594230652,
-0.21468214690685272,
0.2146935909986496,
0.37104594707489014,
-0.08702652156352997,
-0.14045026898384094,
-0.8376777172088623,
0.8857235312461853,
-0.6446690559387207,
0.24058280885219574,
0.19974848628044128,
0.5968772768974304,
-0.4529878795146942,
-0.4954487681388855,
-0.3889818489551544,
0.26628756523132324,
0.20671992003917694,
0.007943414151668549,
0.08041800558567047,
-0.06885597109794617,
0.5138943195343018,
-0.08603838086128235,
-0.5399158000946045,
0.4755679965019226,
-0.32950377464294434,
-0.10136930644512177,
0.6967450976371765,
0.22437264025211334,
-0.22867295145988464,
0.16706179082393646,
-0.1059408113360405,
-0.19162283837795258,
-0.7572524547576904,
-0.08898837864398956,
0.18241380155086517,
0.49313023686408997,
0.03357439860701561,
0.3282054364681244,
-0.004094758536666632,
0.6169148087501526,
-0.1420489400625229,
-0.7705835103988647,
0.11268645524978638,
-0.011990624479949474,
-0.46301090717315674,
0.12990672886371613,
0.3330540955066681,
0.004002751316875219,
-0.070005401968956,
-0.2742363214492798,
-0.4559870660305023,
0.06983234733343124,
0.3337630331516266,
-0.6683757901191711,
-0.23469336330890656,
0.3639160394668579,
-0.01322668232023716,
-0.3338530361652374,
-0.45609161257743835,
-0.5774909853935242,
-0.5024529695510864,
-0.26285019516944885,
0.1685933917760849,
-0.1498090922832489,
-0.6030798554420471,
0.110567107796669,
0.09428561478853226,
-0.029935838654637337,
0.570125162601471,
-0.42719730734825134,
0.21551473438739777,
0.5497406721115112,
0.7407124638557434,
-0.33766886591911316,
-0.29483717679977417,
-0.8138434290885925,
0.4770421087741852,
-0.37901774048805237,
0.7848723530769348,
-0.5048390626907349,
-0.8476362228393555,
-0.1025409922003746,
0.1026926338672638,
0.0707157775759697,
-0.5082030892372131,
0.4601523280143738,
-0.2679176330566406,
0.022057702764868736,
-0.36881521344184875,
-0.24737122654914856,
-0.3100661039352417,
0.47254684567451477,
-0.6435315012931824,
1.103628158569336,
0.1061529666185379,
-0.49236613512039185,
0.6168620586395264,
-0.6598746180534363,
-0.45389825105667114,
0.2068227380514145,
-0.3690084218978882,
-0.5306004285812378,
-0.06479858607053757,
0.20796583592891693,
0.7192704081535339,
-0.2689562737941742,
0.6318968534469604,
-0.3193967044353485,
-0.27106207609176636,
-0.3241567611694336,
0.13818949460983276,
0.5028750896453857,
0.16213534772396088,
-0.4822511076927185,
0.7914190888404846,
-0.6759828925132751,
0.022424744442105293,
0.3899257481098175,
-0.4102887809276581,
0.08967666327953339,
0.47213488817214966,
0.09399354457855225,
0.5108395218849182,
0.08234518021345139,
-0.5482197403907776,
0.4792829751968384,
-0.6396005153656006,
0.37809833884239197,
0.7463703751564026,
-0.4176386296749115,
0.2978172302246094,
-0.09897733479738235,
0.7574515342712402,
0.06250827014446259,
-0.03953750804066658,
-0.19235192239284515,
-0.21890033781528473,
-0.8093684911727905,
0.3504256010055542,
0.012205549515783787,
0.6432834267616272,
-0.7830566167831421,
0.4357055723667145,
-0.13440367579460144,
-0.7337037920951843,
0.11344026774168015,
0.08239232748746872,
0.23125261068344116,
0.24219775199890137,
0.22260209918022156,
-0.33525803685188293,
-0.4402287006378174,
-0.6787195205688477,
-0.03574126958847046,
-0.26814568042755127,
0.15875421464443207,
0.022931447252631187,
0.25422385334968567,
0.1435924470424652,
0.9278715252876282,
-0.6224164366722107,
-0.39197713136672974,
-0.9017574787139893,
0.055138833820819855,
0.36039549112319946,
0.27940070629119873,
0.47398948669433594,
-0.7693254947662354,
-0.5804266929626465,
0.08562837541103363,
-0.2624798119068146,
-0.10217752307653427,
-0.12409654259681702,
0.039619263261556625,
0.19759701192378998,
0.7108975052833557,
-0.33046644926071167,
0.3169703185558319,
0.4780798554420471,
-0.12897858023643494,
0.7916377782821655,
-0.12858927249908447,
-0.5820356607437134,
-1.2332407236099243,
0.09780193865299225,
-0.06513603776693344,
-0.2977140247821808,
-0.41548609733581543,
-0.03176344186067581,
-0.10838060081005096,
-0.00916450098156929,
-0.40395990014076233,
0.6336719989776611,
-0.33344700932502747,
-0.2757391631603241,
-0.4991118013858795,
-0.06584614515304565,
-0.46389102935791016,
0.6557720303535461,
0.017932318150997162,
0.9266586303710938,
0.5873972773551941,
-0.32700836658477783,
0.40214815735816956,
-0.022172212600708008,
-0.03163199871778488,
0.5398550033569336,
-0.4489656686782837,
0.09295936673879623,
0.12295957654714584,
0.23487745225429535,
-0.5719199180603027,
-0.29053622484207153,
0.06198282167315483,
-0.0980762392282486,
0.3855390250682831,
-0.21516653895378113,
-0.7541067004203796,
-0.5473614931106567,
-0.10382471978664398,
0.021932750940322876,
0.23220494389533997,
-0.3065950572490692,
0.9470334053039551,
0.565728485584259,
-0.40203025937080383,
-0.644443929195404,
-0.05650204420089722,
0.07382256537675858,
-0.3273080587387085,
-0.2953793406486511,
0.3248089551925659,
0.06354289501905441,
0.10150548815727234,
-0.00047712738160043955,
-0.38401874899864197,
0.020034104585647583,
0.20311108231544495,
0.3811664283275604,
0.01373856421560049,
0.13667269051074982,
0.3528151214122772,
-0.03252262622117996,
-0.2661550045013428,
0.029113389551639557,
-0.16260460019111633,
0.8763964772224426,
0.16100135445594788,
-0.6172569394111633,
0.07045622915029526,
0.21850703656673431,
0.5327067375183105,
-0.3807985782623291,
0.38533106446266174,
0.6600892543792725,
-0.40569964051246643,
-0.42687010765075684,
-0.6924463510513306,
-0.12314054369926453,
-0.4762127101421356,
0.6941999197006226,
-0.5942569971084595,
-0.7440028190612793,
0.4802974760532379,
-0.49977099895477295,
0.7691842317581177,
0.13817614316940308,
0.6987234950065613,
0.08703817427158356,
1.3814477920532227,
0.9842588901519775,
-0.21449925005435944,
0.4445226490497589,
-0.42670533061027527,
0.37510234117507935,
-0.5363069176673889,
-0.07598867267370224,
-0.44173091650009155,
-0.5987613797187805,
-0.21796412765979767,
-0.5363767147064209,
0.48373669385910034,
0.13583269715309143,
-0.11602701991796494,
0.3378585875034332,
-0.3355022072792053,
0.5510355234146118,
0.5206406712532043,
-0.412443071603775,
0.19573944807052612,
0.07391512393951416,
-0.37846314907073975,
0.18734492361545563,
-0.9838531017303467,
-0.49379807710647583,
0.9834905862808228,
0.2701129913330078,
0.5457490682601929,
-0.07607681304216385,
0.656868040561676,
-0.319124311208725,
0.24515412747859955,
-0.8697909712791443,
0.8589344024658203,
0.09426058083772659,
-0.32792046666145325,
-0.45146819949150085,
-0.09951075911521912,
-0.930703341960907,
0.28958573937416077,
-0.19148650765419006,
-0.9224753379821777,
-0.04518870636820793,
0.2948984205722809,
-0.17109616100788116,
0.655119776725769,
-0.7561035752296448,
0.8923680782318115,
-0.28409525752067566,
-0.3768572509288788,
-0.47430795431137085,
-0.4411153495311737,
0.10599570721387863,
-0.4430178999900818,
0.27821627259254456,
-0.34770339727401733,
0.10995566844940186,
0.7122722864151001,
-0.10688483715057373,
0.933987021446228,
-0.3130559027194977,
-0.024539686739444733,
-0.028302907943725586,
0.4581226408481598,
0.8405463099479675,
-0.21286539733409882,
-0.06761427968740463,
-0.48357605934143066,
0.22157196700572968,
-0.30499622225761414,
-0.4174082279205322,
0.5461297035217285,
-0.4018971621990204,
-0.7510247826576233,
-0.2926061451435089,
-0.910285472869873,
-0.2433466762304306,
0.5053173899650574,
-0.35380324721336365,
0.32507970929145813,
-0.13988536596298218,
-0.029165787622332573,
0.13965943455696106,
-0.2969578206539154,
0.6794041395187378,
0.3131125271320343,
-0.6633227467536926,
0.09612295031547546,
0.8345930576324463,
0.12640973925590515,
0.25054824352264404,
-0.1216217651963234,
0.06848686188459396,
-0.049878302961587906,
-1.0094118118286133,
-0.3222993314266205,
0.32426729798316956,
-0.7734621167182922,
-0.28103742003440857,
-0.6179444193840027,
-0.16848500072956085,
-0.020647414028644562,
-0.3357633650302887,
-0.3317496180534363,
-0.2814633846282959,
0.15615718066692352,
-0.05394783243536949,
0.16312499344348907,
0.8668914437294006,
0.14553168416023254,
0.5835596323013306,
-0.5624465942382812,
-0.19456195831298828,
0.027052855119109154,
0.3738135099411011,
0.037361029535532,
0.23950307071208954,
-0.2553318738937378,
-0.31014153361320496,
-0.6819927096366882,
-0.752058744430542,
0.503381609916687,
0.014941554516553879,
0.6169315576553345,
0.1868821531534195,
-0.01509335357695818,
0.6518473625183105,
-0.45957422256469727,
0.4104233384132385,
0.004623461980372667,
-0.5272535681724548,
0.6311590671539307,
-0.34123164415359497,
0.5883573889732361,
0.34729865193367004,
0.22578799724578857,
-0.698927640914917,
-0.6415668725967407,
-0.7836483716964722,
-0.8698021769523621,
0.853814959526062,
-0.12739001214504242,
-0.3619728684425354,
0.32790136337280273,
0.07778956741094589,
0.16457580029964447,
0.2338307797908783,
-0.6305848956108093,
0.13584893941879272,
0.2522240877151489,
-0.045985668897628784,
-0.146391361951828,
-0.16771036386489868,
-0.16934853792190552,
-0.35400253534317017,
0.628555953502655,
-0.495595246553421,
-0.03869098797440529,
-0.34102675318717957,
-0.004402948077768087,
-0.2878272533416748,
0.26260048151016235,
0.2911983132362366,
1.1225519180297852,
-0.01554942224174738,
0.12220879644155502,
0.6416091918945312,
-0.48552799224853516,
0.09801940619945526,
0.03517766296863556,
0.11671239882707596,
-0.14711114764213562,
0.3330756425857544,
0.5418828725814819,
0.354795902967453,
-0.8618701100349426,
0.24679328501224518,
0.12734393775463104,
-0.1081661731004715,
-0.3585096597671509,
0.28687986731529236,
0.6092225313186646,
0.3870149850845337,
0.14374521374702454,
-0.15423740446567535,
-0.22225047647953033,
-0.3155462145805359,
-0.043374884873628616,
0.42956581711769104,
-0.34318438172340393,
-0.29075372219085693,
0.2737935185432434,
0.2310129553079605,
-0.45952510833740234,
0.1971837878227234,
-0.4948919117450714,
-0.7669529914855957,
0.652373194694519,
0.6762037873268127,
0.6952035427093506,
-0.44109639525413513,
0.13299080729484558,
0.40274637937545776,
0.27168387174606323,
0.02195221185684204,
0.6267238855361938,
0.08555715531110764,
-0.5461813807487488,
-0.8866985440254211,
-0.7633452415466309,
-0.20866364240646362,
0.22788633406162262,
-0.0365399532020092,
0.6028369665145874,
-0.4283868670463562,
-0.08826203644275665,
-0.11375132203102112,
0.04758862778544426,
-0.6469162106513977,
-0.0075454129837453365,
-0.33600014448165894,
1.0578089952468872,
-0.6951712369918823,
1.0934314727783203,
0.9335166215896606,
0.04927777498960495,
-1.2685490846633911,
-0.19059674441814423,
0.3173755705356598,
-0.7097035646438599,
0.7043053507804871,
0.13750624656677246,
-0.1963711678981781,
0.28540676832199097,
-0.11348525434732437,
-0.9233386516571045,
1.159874677658081,
0.21492984890937805,
-0.7346765995025635,
-0.4501328766345978,
-0.010319952853024006,
0.12834835052490234,
-0.2674251198768616,
-0.1813315451145172,
0.7263062596321106,
0.29662373661994934,
0.5820884108543396,
-1.359291434288025,
-0.11553556472063065,
0.08207793533802032,
-0.2633756101131439,
0.7493499517440796,
-0.010821416974067688,
0.599611759185791,
-0.11559443175792694,
-0.4138530194759369,
-0.20867720246315002,
0.07640182226896286,
0.33072447776794434,
0.03430952876806259,
0.8909531235694885,
0.6965759992599487,
0.41637566685676575,
-0.15961553156375885,
0.48641711473464966,
-0.13523007929325104,
0.19970440864562988,
1.0606272220611572,
-0.40060752630233765,
0.9001587629318237,
0.374953955411911,
-0.32000023126602173,
0.05280175060033798,
0.6904827356338501,
0.15990349650382996,
0.22133749723434448,
0.14851950109004974,
-0.10439476370811462,
-0.4506894648075104,
-0.003478205995634198,
-0.17381638288497925,
0.5548507571220398,
0.5083726644515991,
-0.011012137867510319,
-0.7384584546089172,
-0.047905247658491135,
0.13665898144245148,
-0.04714346304535866,
-0.2693508565425873,
0.7205091714859009,
0.012288739904761314,
-0.4856877028942108,
0.23996715247631073,
0.03396105021238327,
0.4966362714767456,
-0.5273793935775757,
-0.08109305799007416,
0.29596877098083496,
0.25120118260383606,
-0.16476456820964813,
-0.7444819211959839,
0.5135793685913086,
-0.07945698499679565,
0.09225530922412872,
-0.24276821315288544,
0.7003331184387207,
-0.23588386178016663,
-0.7527056336402893,
0.30521824955940247,
0.8156698942184448,
-0.02457880973815918,
-0.0653994157910347,
-0.8021082878112793,
0.16739213466644287,
-0.11982229351997375,
-0.005385063122957945,
0.25014621019363403,
0.23986099660396576,
-0.3922441601753235,
0.7899108529090881,
0.6815394759178162,
0.36969277262687683,
0.008007562719285488,
-0.04823166877031326,
1.0008165836334229,
-0.5044837594032288,
-0.779143214225769,
-0.6652606725692749,
0.47896435856819153,
-0.3126952052116394,
0.055160265415906906,
0.444497674703598,
0.7082069516181946,
1.0633002519607544,
0.21425648033618927,
0.5625104904174805,
-0.04815678298473358,
0.878011167049408,
-0.3349860906600952,
0.3995666801929474,
-0.6480935215950012,
0.3886011242866516,
-0.31500494480133057,
-1.3582788705825806,
-0.4282495975494385,
0.5919195413589478,
-0.5472409725189209,
-0.11302651464939117,
0.6799599528312683,
0.6617488861083984,
-0.3705205023288727,
-0.13535374402999878,
0.2497490644454956,
0.07848987728357315,
0.8909364342689514,
0.6003466248512268,
0.5244320631027222,
0.46487313508987427,
0.3863224387168884,
-0.2804507315158844,
-0.19385141134262085,
-0.2163820117712021,
-0.9728109240531921,
-0.8021438121795654,
-0.7898200750350952,
-0.05180927738547325,
0.06491632759571075,
-0.11489300429821014,
1.2161883115768433,
0.849288284778595,
-0.42551788687705994,
-0.664347767829895,
-0.22580471634864807,
0.1532813310623169,
-0.16708727180957794,
-0.10999839752912521,
0.36604368686676025,
-0.5601199865341187,
-0.5646714568138123,
0.4036308228969574,
0.4912415146827698,
-0.09560992568731308,
-0.5346550345420837,
-0.03192724660038948,
-0.14064326882362366,
-0.41859957575798035,
0.7560447454452515,
0.2326139211654663,
-0.8864203095436096,
-0.13616056740283966,
-0.0709751769900322,
0.3662276864051819,
0.046825259923934937,
1.007922649383545,
-0.9900419116020203,
0.5918715000152588,
0.12491626292467117,
0.5723104476928711,
0.6981592178344727,
-0.5002276301383972,
0.6423673033714294,
-0.8618326783180237,
0.4566660225391388,
0.45975667238235474,
0.2972007691860199,
0.1519230455160141,
-0.013892504386603832,
0.6437076926231384,
0.003158298786729574,
-0.5057964324951172,
-1.0364309549331665,
0.5696011781692505,
-0.9277626276016235,
-0.4767281711101532,
0.8502190709114075,
0.11229100823402405,
0.0006659997743554413,
-0.4455576539039612,
-0.6906697750091553,
0.2330489456653595,
-0.05170240253210068,
0.7244304418563843,
0.7149314284324646,
-0.22984187304973602,
-0.15624040365219116,
-0.7625969052314758,
0.566930890083313,
0.19366519153118134,
-0.8818153738975525,
0.296321302652359,
0.3692096173763275,
0.20034591853618622,
0.2484208047389984,
0.5299935340881348,
0.20201735198497772,
0.20809607207775116,
-0.3301554322242737,
0.035482604056596756,
-0.1218942254781723,
-0.5832468867301941,
0.12421143054962158,
0.19560492038726807,
0.5667660236358643,
0.2584989666938782
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.03792v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.03792v1
|
Light-PEFT: Lightening Parameter-Efficient Fine-Tuning via Early Pruning
| 2024-06-06T07:03:29 | 2024-06-06T07:03:29 |
Naibin Gu, Peng Fu, Xiyu Liu, Bowen Shen, Zheng Lin, Weiping Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Parameter-efficient fine-tuning (PEFT) has emerged as the predominant
technique for fine-tuning in the era of large language models. However,
existing PEFT methods still have inadequate training efficiency. Firstly, the
utilization of large-scale foundation models during the training process is
excessively redundant for certain fine-tuning tasks. Secondly, as the model
size increases, the growth in trainable parameters of empirically added PEFT
modules becomes non-negligible and redundant, leading to inefficiency. To
achieve task-specific efficient fine-tuning, we propose the Light-PEFT
framework, which includes two methods: Masked Early Pruning of the Foundation
Model and Multi-Granularity Early Pruning of PEFT. The Light-PEFT framework
allows for the simultaneous estimation of redundant parameters in both the
foundation model and PEFT modules during the early stage of training. These
parameters can then be pruned for more efficient fine-tuning. We validate our
approach on GLUE, SuperGLUE, QA tasks, and various models. With Light-PEFT,
parameters of the foundation model can be pruned by up to over 40%, while still
controlling trainable parameters to be only 25% of the original PEFT method.
Compared to utilizing the PEFT method directly, Light-PEFT achieves training
and inference speedup, reduces memory usage, and maintains comparable
performance and the plug-and-play feature of PEFT.
|
[
-0.4438469409942627,
-1.1439412832260132,
0.3332516551017761,
0.23041699826717377,
-0.5825408697128296,
-0.1619914174079895,
-0.41805317997932434,
-0.4625418782234192,
-0.1851370632648468,
0.31366872787475586,
-0.45838457345962524,
-0.06624410301446915,
-0.0994667336344719,
-0.1497936099767685,
-0.494616836309433,
0.8421945571899414,
0.03484293445944786,
-0.1540793776512146,
0.22480906546115875,
0.12950162589550018,
-0.14407920837402344,
-0.06448017060756683,
-0.6426151990890503,
-0.2862165570259094,
0.5313970446586609,
0.5822277665138245,
0.7261948585510254,
0.7558508515357971,
0.4572923481464386,
0.23241764307022095,
-0.1299629658460617,
0.23147419095039368,
-0.6266999840736389,
-0.3118835687637329,
-0.0995907112956047,
-0.23343130946159363,
-0.47019240260124207,
-0.04604076221585274,
0.6102643609046936,
1.0517812967300415,
-0.23590107262134552,
0.28316617012023926,
0.16329124569892883,
0.8962278962135315,
-0.719258725643158,
-0.07299986481666565,
-0.7173830270767212,
-0.005791252013295889,
-0.20375075936317444,
-0.2572467625141144,
-0.06174042448401451,
0.016456808894872665,
-0.05961154028773308,
-0.5678872466087341,
0.5982833504676819,
0.06510516256093979,
0.9215184450149536,
0.12894342839717865,
-0.3404698073863983,
0.4653180241584778,
-0.9044316411018372,
0.8765273094177246,
-0.5899097919464111,
0.6399775147438049,
0.2976536154747009,
0.1074008047580719,
0.08878909051418304,
-0.8633626103401184,
-0.2679435610771179,
-0.23222140967845917,
-0.07293297350406647,
-0.03635659068822861,
0.25046506524086,
0.34166377782821655,
0.2844342291355133,
0.4521122872829437,
-0.3557131886482239,
-0.1476181596517563,
-0.3686733841896057,
-0.17079868912696838,
0.5362061858177185,
-0.18013198673725128,
-0.2678971290588379,
0.2770942449569702,
-0.5986274480819702,
-0.035154279321432114,
-0.8777523636817932,
0.060189761221408844,
0.3943755626678467,
0.2101120799779892,
0.28043079376220703,
0.18670740723609924,
-0.35856130719184875,
0.9518853425979614,
0.4405314028263092,
-0.4169044494628906,
0.06476788222789764,
-0.454481840133667,
-0.4122728407382965,
-0.21317820250988007,
0.5073839426040649,
0.4527318477630615,
0.10202178359031677,
-0.352823942899704,
-0.39977559447288513,
0.02430441416800022,
0.11405552178621292,
-0.9631194472312927,
-0.4964674711227417,
-0.03508729487657547,
-0.5005441308021545,
-0.23465865850448608,
0.10744476318359375,
-0.6726411581039429,
-0.0016672784695401788,
-0.28409072756767273,
0.5090441107749939,
-0.3588586747646332,
-0.392822265625,
0.18392232060432434,
0.12965424358844757,
0.16760842502117157,
0.5378894209861755,
-0.9728682637214661,
0.44427576661109924,
0.6733416318893433,
0.5871940851211548,
-0.06769230961799622,
-0.3739476501941681,
-0.6684461236000061,
0.19740228354930878,
-0.37386947870254517,
0.3473889231681824,
-0.46706581115722656,
-0.08061093091964722,
-0.3240889310836792,
0.314491331577301,
-0.08452042937278748,
-0.6280826926231384,
0.6813207268714905,
-0.46494224667549133,
-0.17724093794822693,
-0.004535079468041658,
-0.40177619457244873,
-0.12286091595888138,
-0.10087644308805466,
-0.3682177662849426,
1.067017674446106,
0.4064272940158844,
-0.4200673997402191,
0.6808905005455017,
-0.1286696195602417,
-0.5813008546829224,
0.1485918164253235,
-0.12010513246059418,
-0.6633507609367371,
0.5352469086647034,
0.22460487484931946,
0.6848871111869812,
-0.441375732421875,
0.5870339870452881,
-0.18861454725265503,
-0.7006657123565674,
-0.4194534122943878,
-0.4879165291786194,
0.4049946367740631,
0.20487502217292786,
-0.6113307476043701,
-0.11921162158250809,
-0.8769733309745789,
0.046135690063238144,
0.09639818221330643,
-0.4103991985321045,
-0.1304432898759842,
-0.03735809028148651,
0.4237229526042938,
-0.05485183745622635,
0.30521467328071594,
-0.40256044268608093,
0.007445690222084522,
-0.8024333119392395,
0.4960434138774872,
0.5542116165161133,
0.11088143289089203,
0.5861702561378479,
-0.36019638180732727,
0.33510512113571167,
-0.11638027429580688,
0.33714452385902405,
-0.3641268014907837,
-0.2748633027076721,
-0.6278097629547119,
-0.08584749698638916,
0.3282020092010498,
0.2603393495082855,
-0.4989398717880249,
0.5478444695472717,
0.29834553599357605,
-0.6815050840377808,
-0.13506698608398438,
0.4024496376514435,
0.52089923620224,
0.6972717642784119,
0.24011245369911194,
-0.19328586757183075,
-0.1645870804786682,
-0.9651897549629211,
-0.44051042199134827,
0.01131995115429163,
0.0368180125951767,
0.34093010425567627,
0.28136590123176575,
0.3051038086414337,
0.7089506983757019,
-0.30356788635253906,
-0.0877285897731781,
0.0766715556383133,
0.02569776587188244,
0.46883413195610046,
0.9534353613853455,
0.7706871628761292,
-1.2477059364318848,
-0.6666836142539978,
-0.04316804185509682,
0.04706922173500061,
-0.18109215795993805,
-0.16907434165477753,
0.1839650720357895,
-0.12927277386188507,
0.42080187797546387,
-0.44079744815826416,
0.28193217515945435,
0.4358806312084198,
-0.5934817790985107,
0.5705065727233887,
-0.3254740834236145,
0.29966405034065247,
-0.3900945484638214,
0.22964493930339813,
-0.011481568217277527,
-0.4598636031150818,
-0.687990665435791,
0.16034729778766632,
0.51483154296875,
-0.19099798798561096,
-0.6616322994232178,
0.48817068338394165,
-0.5754801630973816,
0.23373083770275116,
-0.24095995724201202,
-0.23812687397003174,
0.20217519998550415,
0.6161390542984009,
-0.09927982836961746,
0.8540835976600647,
0.5992313027381897,
-0.7937979102134705,
0.20552650094032288,
-0.30688220262527466,
-0.3008621037006378,
0.23734650015830994,
-0.6189869046211243,
-0.025425856932997704,
0.23600944876670837,
-0.48233845829963684,
-0.7990578413009644,
-0.08698125928640366,
0.11642000824213028,
0.14582325518131256,
0.3030202388763428,
-0.22592346370220184,
-0.6586148738861084,
-0.12410052865743637,
-0.374480277299881,
0.41734227538108826,
0.5718307495117188,
-0.5338181853294373,
0.463748574256897,
0.0914241150021553,
-0.174655482172966,
-0.14908605813980103,
-0.5062366724014282,
-0.2234823852777481,
-0.3571617901325226,
-0.6210355758666992,
0.9872796535491943,
-0.14188843965530396,
0.15465104579925537,
-0.18393538892269135,
-0.5158531665802002,
-0.27438345551490784,
0.4227878749370575,
0.006954491138458252,
0.007150048390030861,
-0.1285543590784073,
0.037644676864147186,
0.14328551292419434,
-0.22350770235061646,
-0.3119718134403229,
-0.32725080847740173,
0.43538421392440796,
-0.33976835012435913,
-0.5215979814529419,
-0.27471405267715454,
0.20372499525547028,
0.40019625425338745,
-0.2538010776042938,
0.7651463150978088,
0.7951526045799255,
-0.4073408246040344,
-0.25951001048088074,
-0.8509379029273987,
-0.40439099073410034,
-0.526525616645813,
0.39276209473609924,
-0.20682159066200256,
-0.9007418155670166,
0.27748721837997437,
-0.5052187442779541,
0.25517353415489197,
0.25427448749542236,
0.31677865982055664,
-0.018650442361831665,
1.164547085762024,
1.068106770515442,
0.2899445593357086,
0.9613552093505859,
-0.01846918836236,
0.13578777015209198,
-0.4228782653808594,
0.03598170727491379,
-0.45655423402786255,
-0.40132319927215576,
-0.041550520807504654,
-0.2535371482372284,
0.31116724014282227,
0.8633759021759033,
-0.26917874813079834,
0.34696221351623535,
-0.6023851037025452,
0.6602638363838196,
0.4554120898246765,
0.24284300208091736,
0.4044383466243744,
0.23893296718597412,
0.11143055558204651,
-0.13823965191841125,
-0.8179870247840881,
-0.28568097949028015,
0.8954818248748779,
0.22154740989208221,
0.6798989176750183,
-0.38412249088287354,
0.5033313035964966,
-0.23213951289653778,
0.0023490244057029486,
-0.6597826480865479,
0.5262806415557861,
-0.14765694737434387,
-0.5352951288223267,
-0.23891520500183105,
-0.5413212180137634,
-0.61328125,
0.35299620032310486,
-0.20636284351348877,
-0.7248141765594482,
0.49245157837867737,
0.6234514713287354,
-0.5302383899688721,
0.2389187067747116,
-1.0521399974822998,
0.9711211323738098,
-0.4591391682624817,
-0.6906073689460754,
-0.37118399143218994,
-0.5065120458602905,
0.25639456510543823,
-0.4086165130138397,
0.11706042289733887,
-0.23260854184627533,
-0.3988804519176483,
0.8050757646560669,
-0.5115371346473694,
0.6143171191215515,
-0.5684547424316406,
-0.03592386469244957,
0.09371519833803177,
-0.08492345362901688,
0.7597576975822449,
0.2667970359325409,
-0.06326041370630264,
-0.2592201232910156,
0.11311677098274231,
-0.4772290289402008,
-0.5496224761009216,
0.38898006081581116,
-0.38383060693740845,
-0.3582070767879486,
0.10089003294706345,
-0.19766634702682495,
-0.43538209795951843,
0.367227166891098,
0.14676490426063538,
0.31961584091186523,
-0.049331653863191605,
0.5931115746498108,
0.6409881114959717,
0.04127702862024307,
0.48253199458122253,
0.7066013216972351,
-0.30921024084091187,
-0.29002848267555237,
0.8506653308868408,
0.20253123342990875,
0.28626924753189087,
0.23818360269069672,
0.3361089527606964,
0.16499769687652588,
-0.9529091715812683,
-0.07260167598724365,
0.18535210192203522,
-0.2771872282028198,
-0.3355545997619629,
-0.2770291566848755,
0.113739974796772,
-0.09927652031183243,
-0.4535900950431824,
-0.5731501579284668,
-0.30667033791542053,
-0.16394828259944916,
0.1927516609430313,
0.3526497781276703,
0.057927656918764114,
0.17766152322292328,
0.7284068465232849,
-0.772083580493927,
0.6294991374015808,
0.3763786852359772,
0.6941918134689331,
-0.13636839389801025,
-0.3165450394153595,
-0.43629422783851624,
-0.08751113712787628,
-0.12829239666461945,
-0.8676466345787048,
0.24348589777946472,
0.723471462726593,
0.4516811966896057,
0.6614648103713989,
0.03625614568591118,
0.8396672606468201,
-0.42729634046554565,
0.6699525713920593,
0.47043105959892273,
-0.8521811366081238,
0.6791408061981201,
-0.3196089565753937,
0.22593998908996582,
0.7999816536903381,
-0.08230894804000854,
-0.06969640403985977,
-0.18151158094406128,
-0.9462831020355225,
-1.1603991985321045,
0.7984769344329834,
0.09789492934942245,
-0.09050079435110092,
0.3229403495788574,
0.6763726472854614,
0.2545015215873718,
0.5600196719169617,
-0.6442261338233948,
-0.14177660644054413,
0.11388105899095535,
0.09816216677427292,
-0.00840852316468954,
-0.20773743093013763,
-0.26571959257125854,
-0.622407078742981,
0.7013930678367615,
-0.40560317039489746,
0.041039057075977325,
0.08962836116552353,
-0.27949991822242737,
-0.5540522336959839,
0.12181250005960464,
0.07442347705364227,
1.0437381267547607,
-0.25690165162086487,
0.13939408957958221,
0.27789318561553955,
-0.5174452066421509,
0.06438874453306198,
0.2778502404689789,
-0.3826984167098999,
-0.07032447308301926,
0.2228223830461502,
0.7171463966369629,
0.6012880206108093,
-0.7433556318283081,
0.6610267758369446,
0.0927487462759018,
-0.37619417905807495,
0.1374102383852005,
0.526321291923523,
0.02926972135901451,
0.3744238317012787,
0.5285175442695618,
0.30985724925994873,
-0.05214841663837433,
-0.4085884392261505,
0.3695591688156128,
0.30922964215278625,
-0.21564024686813354,
-0.23625820875167847,
0.5873366594314575,
0.1720280796289444,
-0.24852870404720306,
0.061289478093385696,
-0.10198891907930374,
-0.11368981003761292,
0.755303680896759,
0.4345358908176422,
0.6500720381736755,
0.030616026371717453,
0.09123285114765167,
0.1401570737361908,
0.39828625321388245,
-0.28794828057289124,
0.4005870223045349,
-0.3367433547973633,
-0.42285752296447754,
-0.5727959275245667,
-0.9527851939201355,
-0.0744316577911377,
0.21340321004390717,
-0.35216519236564636,
0.2170109748840332,
-0.7423262596130371,
-0.07525720447301865,
-0.20843346416950226,
0.4030764698982239,
-0.7137454748153687,
0.4127119183540344,
-0.14079056680202484,
1.1217944622039795,
-0.9104856848716736,
0.8190592527389526,
0.8837583661079407,
-0.1511724442243576,
-0.9991232752799988,
-0.0910576805472374,
-0.31709250807762146,
-0.5561382174491882,
0.177495077252388,
0.1100236177444458,
-0.07164161652326584,
0.21874400973320007,
-0.548626720905304,
-0.7029920220375061,
1.1541860103607178,
0.9234263896942139,
-1.0730255842208862,
-0.10774131119251251,
-0.19071312248706818,
0.29951223731040955,
-0.19735005497932434,
-0.1128283143043518,
0.7292139530181885,
0.5997328162193298,
-0.04220030456781387,
-0.9955347180366516,
-0.018724743276834488,
-0.1016974076628685,
-0.05694079026579857,
0.37604066729545593,
-0.845990002155304,
0.8698367476463318,
0.18470443785190582,
-0.2777179479598999,
0.013989638537168503,
0.4698488116264343,
0.017594117671251297,
0.06285589933395386,
0.952445924282074,
0.31123077869415283,
0.6150045394897461,
-0.2867020070552826,
0.4815141558647156,
-0.7304866313934326,
0.544512152671814,
0.7274359464645386,
0.0753224790096283,
0.5734748244285583,
0.6814784407615662,
-0.3999708294868469,
-0.35760194063186646,
0.5620856285095215,
-0.201459139585495,
0.6866742968559265,
-0.3964489996433258,
-0.12298408150672913,
-0.4248614013195038,
0.09479532390832901,
-0.4958219826221466,
0.09333118051290512,
0.20756345987319946,
-0.27411261200904846,
-0.3222714364528656,
0.12933792173862457,
-0.2370104342699051,
-0.11941126734018326,
-0.462484747171402,
0.6861847639083862,
0.17926764488220215,
-0.5459573864936829,
0.595620334148407,
0.1622098833322525,
0.7224985957145691,
-0.6808642148971558,
0.020326798781752586,
-0.09362221509218216,
0.2742769122123718,
-0.3286951184272766,
-0.31854161620140076,
0.21701887249946594,
-0.15173186361789703,
-0.13600142300128937,
-0.6474202275276184,
1.057519555091858,
-0.5737203359603882,
-0.482867032289505,
0.2997746169567108,
0.640950620174408,
-0.19436722993850708,
-0.47332778573036194,
-0.9595363736152649,
-0.16771088540554047,
0.010578783228993416,
-0.6700671315193176,
0.35596784949302673,
0.3556816577911377,
0.2502901554107666,
0.28889864683151245,
0.6101189255714417,
0.39586877822875977,
-0.00994151271879673,
0.09877102077007294,
1.0724105834960938,
-0.5801998376846313,
-0.5990167260169983,
-0.7415609955787659,
0.501751720905304,
0.05881287157535553,
-0.3536248505115509,
0.4703958332538605,
0.4783799350261688,
0.7228237390518188,
0.054893121123313904,
0.22205986082553864,
-0.20275026559829712,
0.5406879782676697,
-0.5788363814353943,
0.5823957324028015,
-0.904263973236084,
0.27706894278526306,
-0.5856494307518005,
-1.3580759763717651,
-0.256671667098999,
0.6376712918281555,
-0.09346172958612442,
0.2733227610588074,
0.6467641592025757,
0.8818596005439758,
-0.5184404850006104,
-0.06027717515826225,
0.4501038193702698,
0.018794288858771324,
0.12432423233985901,
0.4815748929977417,
0.4185101389884949,
-0.39712509512901306,
0.5888195633888245,
-0.7205947041511536,
-0.41939038038253784,
-0.3619261682033539,
-0.9891425967216492,
-0.5075793862342834,
-0.3348713219165802,
-0.42622342705726624,
0.2996344268321991,
0.007226989138871431,
0.5347604155540466,
1.1607855558395386,
-0.8302141427993774,
0.0076797096990048885,
-0.5699561238288879,
-0.15108291804790497,
-0.6635081768035889,
-0.20684799551963806,
0.38693398237228394,
-0.3365634083747864,
-0.4369322955608368,
0.527073860168457,
0.48861372470855713,
-0.1150408387184143,
-0.148489847779274,
-0.00968419760465622,
-0.22318057715892792,
-0.3184727430343628,
0.3202038109302521,
0.20880787074565887,
-0.5883891582489014,
-0.19567860662937164,
-0.2812556028366089,
0.2347669154405594,
0.04242362827062607,
0.7676712274551392,
-0.868594765663147,
0.1805567890405655,
0.35950297117233276,
0.629611611366272,
0.7113528847694397,
0.07258009165525436,
0.7336414456367493,
-0.9293015599250793,
0.412335067987442,
0.34183046221733093,
0.45671066641807556,
0.09155483543872833,
-0.34026727080345154,
0.4645662009716034,
0.48967763781547546,
-0.41733264923095703,
-0.80620938539505,
0.2253905087709427,
-0.6830427646636963,
-0.434841513633728,
0.5018501877784729,
-0.10369931161403656,
-0.2574901878833771,
0.011106232181191444,
-0.41949790716171265,
0.21203386783599854,
-0.21715311706066132,
0.4957291781902313,
0.3834521174430847,
-0.10038165748119354,
-0.5484151244163513,
-0.5120572447776794,
0.7178390026092529,
0.8851457238197327,
-0.64055997133255,
0.21610763669013977,
0.3461339771747589,
0.1570769101381302,
0.09803581237792969,
0.62116539478302,
0.12467405200004578,
0.47092685103416443,
0.06363571435213089,
-0.4799342155456543,
-0.37060970067977905,
-0.7010002732276917,
-0.33135154843330383,
0.7239217758178711,
0.13373000919818878,
0.22013388574123383
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.03790v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.03790v1
|
End-to-End Trainable Soft Retriever for Low-resource Relation Extraction
| 2024-06-06T07:01:50 | 2024-06-06T07:01:50 |
Kohei Makino, Makoto Miwa, Yutaka Sasaki
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This study addresses a crucial challenge in instance-based relation
extraction using text generation models: end-to-end training in target relation
extraction task is not applicable to retrievers due to the non-differentiable
nature of instance selection. We propose a novel End-to-end TRAinable Soft
K-nearest neighbor retriever (ETRASK) by the neural prompting method that
utilizes a soft, differentiable selection of the $k$ nearest instances. This
approach enables the end-to-end training of retrievers in target tasks. On the
TACRED benchmark dataset with a low-resource setting where the training data
was reduced to 10\%, our method achieved a state-of-the-art F1 score of 71.5\%.
Moreover, ETRASK consistently improved the baseline model by adding instances
for all settings. These results highlight the efficacy of our approach in
enhancing relation extraction performance, especially in resource-constrained
environments. Our findings offer a promising direction for future research with
extraction and the broader application of text generation in natural language
processing.
|
[
-0.21662583947181702,
-0.8799114227294922,
0.4135025441646576,
-0.38365307450294495,
-0.49657103419303894,
-0.2817564308643341,
-0.7269551753997803,
-0.3765355944633484,
0.07744940370321274,
-0.10478831082582474,
-0.850325345993042,
-0.2433982491493225,
-0.42051398754119873,
0.31315454840660095,
-0.11746440082788467,
1.2557297945022583,
0.22229763865470886,
-0.3171215057373047,
-0.1854933202266693,
-0.3716672956943512,
-0.2973743677139282,
-0.4821823835372925,
-0.8265416026115417,
-0.3651222884654999,
0.7375978231430054,
0.6273872256278992,
0.5395198464393616,
0.4655081331729889,
0.213479682803154,
0.3557184636592865,
-0.3577462434768677,
0.2781966030597687,
-0.503838062286377,
0.5308429002761841,
-0.24631527066230774,
-0.4420541226863861,
-0.3009994924068451,
-0.11446171998977661,
0.25639328360557556,
0.6685705780982971,
-0.29865145683288574,
0.33538711071014404,
-0.15325115621089935,
0.8004366755485535,
-0.7020182609558105,
-0.023783836513757706,
-0.8304715752601624,
0.2646951675415039,
-0.2321251779794693,
-0.21015091240406036,
-0.36188942193984985,
-0.3198050558567047,
0.425161212682724,
-0.44485267996788025,
0.5268041491508484,
-0.02536650560796261,
1.0956820249557495,
0.18799299001693726,
-0.15869379043579102,
-0.2420732080936432,
-0.5650235414505005,
0.8505909442901611,
-0.5137819051742554,
0.5201879143714905,
0.4228186309337616,
0.3633030652999878,
0.038774583488702774,
-0.8835194706916809,
-0.3682442605495453,
-0.5572270750999451,
0.09971018880605698,
0.15026336908340454,
0.08445963263511658,
-0.15591087937355042,
0.29042375087738037,
0.3768419921398163,
-0.10190893709659576,
0.024494126439094543,
-0.3356976807117462,
0.15782205760478973,
0.17726974189281464,
0.1190754622220993,
0.03301207721233368,
-0.4081813395023346,
-0.06936797499656677,
-0.004936204757541418,
-0.6197823286056519,
0.15444841980934143,
0.43566998839378357,
0.6344243884086609,
0.022824611514806747,
0.5173159837722778,
-0.17002399265766144,
0.5469348430633545,
0.049502551555633545,
0.19683924317359924,
0.14519083499908447,
-0.12098561227321625,
-0.136093869805336,
0.2544420659542084,
0.7784728407859802,
0.18674077093601227,
0.3856843411922455,
-0.4736362099647522,
-0.2024238258600235,
-0.27121174335479736,
0.17500124871730804,
-0.9732702970504761,
-0.01606854423880577,
0.19395647943019867,
-0.8828773498535156,
-0.4321211278438568,
-0.06616067886352539,
-0.8574383854866028,
0.038309305906295776,
-0.17628158628940582,
-0.037353891879320145,
-0.6200136542320251,
-0.6516191363334656,
-0.44684505462646484,
-0.037148624658584595,
0.19408851861953735,
-0.06412510573863983,
-1.1516329050064087,
0.4094318449497223,
0.6559606790542603,
1.0594350099563599,
0.12345434725284576,
-0.04927128180861473,
-0.7376320362091064,
0.011131142266094685,
-0.27973079681396484,
0.7403764128684998,
-0.5847966074943542,
-0.3390398919582367,
0.1921517252922058,
0.037765759974718094,
0.12108779698610306,
-0.6735995411872864,
0.5352625846862793,
-0.5918457508087158,
0.3752906024456024,
-0.2898840308189392,
-0.3084332346916199,
0.15211914479732513,
0.4643924832344055,
-0.8335801959037781,
1.3376773595809937,
0.4692074954509735,
-0.4703529477119446,
0.43976354598999023,
-0.34250468015670776,
-0.4478917121887207,
-0.08411737531423569,
-0.3659343421459198,
-0.7924691438674927,
0.2888416647911072,
0.08280287683010101,
0.5308820009231567,
-0.5317144989967346,
0.13665784895420074,
-0.4353528618812561,
-0.04693722724914551,
0.21534916758537292,
-0.25627925992012024,
0.5363419651985168,
0.35687947273254395,
-0.24288220703601837,
-0.15679633617401123,
-0.9262822866439819,
0.09826726466417313,
0.39701539278030396,
-0.4878852367401123,
-0.5694183707237244,
-0.07159142196178436,
0.11535130441188812,
0.4438392221927643,
0.2592442035675049,
-0.8094959855079651,
0.19394473731517792,
-0.4457312226295471,
0.5388745665550232,
0.7037837505340576,
0.11438968777656555,
0.5719175338745117,
-0.2610049545764923,
0.38184061646461487,
-0.0075899590738117695,
-0.0816602110862732,
-0.2640303373336792,
-0.20678448677062988,
-0.7271448373794556,
0.17680242657661438,
0.6158396005630493,
0.1927071362733841,
-0.7877264618873596,
0.3706475794315338,
-0.4482170045375824,
-0.3031180799007416,
-0.4293901026248932,
0.13798610866069794,
0.67041015625,
0.8102343082427979,
0.2332024872303009,
-0.05750391632318497,
-0.3642885386943817,
-0.8776419162750244,
-0.1438840925693512,
0.09893204271793365,
-0.09070314466953278,
0.581048846244812,
0.2580357491970062,
0.28447186946868896,
1.1390399932861328,
-0.5556155443191528,
-0.5527896285057068,
-0.4427170753479004,
0.0987224355340004,
0.35201296210289,
0.22939655184745789,
0.5325056314468384,
-0.9854322075843811,
-0.5997018218040466,
0.17913293838500977,
-0.7855717539787292,
0.11168542504310608,
-0.07859232276678085,
-0.14109212160110474,
0.11647049337625504,
0.5610544681549072,
-0.489614874124527,
0.21536967158317566,
-0.08477258682250977,
-0.21661502122879028,
0.3983428478240967,
-0.3122904300689697,
-0.05736376345157623,
-1.2335625886917114,
0.272858589887619,
0.24605564773082733,
-0.3298579752445221,
-0.6085912585258484,
-0.2635935842990875,
0.14111724495887756,
0.023646453395485878,
-0.42292219400405884,
0.23370930552482605,
-0.6934049129486084,
-0.1778971403837204,
-0.1009034663438797,
-0.09920519590377808,
-0.22502103447914124,
0.644478440284729,
0.23114700615406036,
0.6752200126647949,
0.03178415074944496,
-0.6572785973548889,
0.2163132280111313,
0.44710707664489746,
-0.07279631495475769,
0.6884574294090271,
-0.49799084663391113,
0.503667950630188,
-0.16004925966262817,
-0.18763212859630585,
-0.46695488691329956,
-0.05691351369023323,
0.12156262993812561,
-0.5098020434379578,
0.34573525190353394,
-0.48181861639022827,
-0.4859617054462433,
0.007255200296640396,
-0.3400391936302185,
0.13402356207370758,
0.6476075053215027,
-0.6708222031593323,
0.5155314803123474,
0.07910840958356857,
-0.46164557337760925,
-0.4584767520427704,
-0.57318115234375,
0.04598435387015343,
-0.2041482776403427,
-0.3441738784313202,
0.4260267913341522,
0.18068577349185944,
-0.08167220652103424,
0.17263208329677582,
-0.095118947327137,
-0.4789963364601135,
-0.1702127307653427,
0.12256987392902374,
0.30529677867889404,
-0.20978714525699615,
0.17974551022052765,
0.02969546802341938,
-0.32297536730766296,
0.06301042437553406,
0.11497131735086441,
0.34273597598075867,
-0.08068298548460007,
-0.0071767657063901424,
-0.14858442544937134,
0.4042806029319763,
0.13306616246700287,
-0.18115994334220886,
0.8264980912208557,
0.37458279728889465,
-0.593390166759491,
-0.36455169320106506,
-0.4252716898918152,
-0.2979942262172699,
-0.5059140920639038,
0.600511372089386,
-0.58868408203125,
-0.6155375242233276,
0.4490230083465576,
-0.5494989156723022,
0.1662285178899765,
0.21908985078334808,
0.3691473603248596,
0.07089969515800476,
0.7545344829559326,
0.8750439882278442,
-0.1488976776599884,
0.6844078898429871,
-0.31950798630714417,
0.07677552103996277,
-0.9878016114234924,
-0.594150960445404,
-0.6271832585334778,
-0.38388386368751526,
-0.2350059300661087,
0.40678727626800537,
0.1441282033920288,
0.08407711982727051,
0.05177183449268341,
0.3714500069618225,
-0.7993475794792175,
0.4281069338321686,
0.5123295783996582,
0.4148154854774475,
0.3198673129081726,
0.3405151069164276,
-0.2091374695301056,
-0.4509071707725525,
-0.6738597750663757,
-0.20513679087162018,
0.9403767585754395,
0.01627061888575554,
0.2284124344587326,
0.24105963110923767,
0.7411988973617554,
0.020873690024018288,
0.35159918665885925,
-0.7874481678009033,
0.5166978240013123,
-0.14126387238502502,
-0.4268060326576233,
-0.2382710576057434,
-0.6521944999694824,
-1.1417087316513062,
-0.018909543752670288,
-0.10373039543628693,
-0.7811916470527649,
0.2374255657196045,
-0.013924775645136833,
-0.4865839183330536,
0.3911999464035034,
-0.6689572930335999,
0.5505680441856384,
-0.041645146906375885,
-0.6268185973167419,
0.09292028099298477,
-0.6737327575683594,
0.17235857248306274,
-0.04375797137618065,
0.06338045746088028,
-0.14956034719944,
-0.2850358486175537,
0.7704526782035828,
-0.7247022390365601,
0.36004647612571716,
-0.28059157729148865,
0.09864415228366852,
0.25636598467826843,
0.09877508878707886,
0.46940878033638,
-0.09890951961278915,
-0.46525833010673523,
-0.11138386279344559,
-0.43576228618621826,
-0.003369190264493227,
-0.5758718848228455,
0.6888422966003418,
-0.5304756760597229,
0.14736096560955048,
-0.29145416617393494,
-0.37426531314849854,
-0.12658607959747314,
0.27793124318122864,
0.4447351098060608,
0.6488395929336548,
-0.13064894080162048,
0.2800303101539612,
0.538037121295929,
-0.2125779241323471,
0.8170527219772339,
0.30465129017829895,
0.42968273162841797,
-0.5372267365455627,
1.1781097650527954,
0.13341739773750305,
0.09047362208366394,
0.1758221834897995,
0.22215954959392548,
-0.5081812143325806,
-0.3533497750759125,
-0.42272505164146423,
-0.12684500217437744,
-0.45432913303375244,
-0.4416517913341522,
-0.5444063544273376,
-0.2647869884967804,
-0.026688605546951294,
-0.011525338515639305,
-0.5197115540504456,
-0.33580338954925537,
-0.4698672890663147,
-0.11119140684604645,
0.6228342056274414,
0.545589804649353,
-0.08624086529016495,
0.32700103521347046,
-0.945564329624176,
0.503669023513794,
0.16837888956069946,
0.4480348229408264,
0.0639481171965599,
-0.4481929838657379,
-0.18163400888442993,
-0.427691251039505,
-0.10478924959897995,
-1.0211776494979858,
0.540662944316864,
0.5747044086456299,
0.25457632541656494,
0.44338881969451904,
0.23460812866687775,
0.6041622161865234,
-0.655104398727417,
0.55699223279953,
0.41953566670417786,
-0.3636869788169861,
0.7348390221595764,
-0.39407801628112793,
0.0924128070473671,
0.9187755584716797,
0.1780633181333542,
-0.3447200357913971,
0.14672161638736725,
-0.9198412299156189,
-1.0190958976745605,
0.9813563227653503,
0.36267223954200745,
0.16992680728435516,
-0.06041546165943146,
0.7876328229904175,
0.27501216530799866,
0.3661256432533264,
-0.5960196256637573,
-0.4528091251850128,
0.06786827743053436,
-0.3956965208053589,
0.3813053369522095,
-0.38907405734062195,
0.29576167464256287,
-0.05463641136884689,
0.675041139125824,
0.035594623535871506,
0.31195521354675293,
0.34775081276893616,
-0.19692601263523102,
-0.27400222420692444,
0.43429189920425415,
-0.007990442216396332,
0.5423201322555542,
-0.4552692174911499,
-0.033616047352552414,
0.2937971353530884,
-0.40680310130119324,
0.10220605880022049,
0.40053248405456543,
-0.37483230233192444,
0.27776265144348145,
0.06281619518995285,
0.3738967776298523,
0.30095839500427246,
-0.40502506494522095,
0.5595800876617432,
-0.17798519134521484,
-0.3401593267917633,
-0.2520558834075928,
-0.1193108782172203,
-0.038892511278390884,
0.15549972653388977,
0.5704248547554016,
-0.1272665560245514,
0.12797129154205322,
-0.3852590322494507,
0.34313100576400757,
0.3115047514438629,
-0.4788987338542938,
-0.25669682025909424,
0.8127291202545166,
0.2379889190196991,
-0.6849489808082581,
0.9312784671783447,
-0.33692488074302673,
-0.29921016097068787,
0.6891187429428101,
0.3341969847679138,
0.8439478874206543,
-0.06383033841848373,
-0.0033230299595743418,
0.5380022525787354,
0.1536329686641693,
0.01481633260846138,
0.27752652764320374,
-0.3635469377040863,
-0.43569207191467285,
-0.4380490481853485,
-0.33818957209587097,
-0.537296712398529,
0.5448520183563232,
-0.9493961334228516,
0.28142106533050537,
-0.4035632610321045,
-0.3215591013431549,
-0.11872556060552597,
0.22019633650779724,
-0.5469501614570618,
0.058077652007341385,
0.024118145927786827,
0.8060922026634216,
-0.36716824769973755,
0.706355631351471,
0.6903557777404785,
-0.5609589219093323,
-0.6786473989486694,
-0.317727655172348,
-0.1763545572757721,
-0.2931106984615326,
0.42658621072769165,
0.35087499022483826,
0.20187754929065704,
0.06824826449155807,
-0.5700035691261292,
-0.33426007628440857,
1.0631874799728394,
0.507095456123352,
-0.5710912942886353,
-0.1124815046787262,
0.2099606990814209,
0.33828747272491455,
-0.0957634225487709,
0.6870331168174744,
0.5802792906761169,
0.09529317915439606,
-0.022615818306803703,
-0.5216919183731079,
0.21279937028884888,
-0.588625431060791,
0.11698172241449356,
0.3772817850112915,
-0.8126227259635925,
0.6859792470932007,
-0.2555350065231323,
-0.08911038935184479,
0.2636602222919464,
0.8778170943260193,
0.46764034032821655,
0.2608414888381958,
0.6258509755134583,
0.3805403411388397,
0.5557660460472107,
0.009793947450816631,
0.7660847902297974,
-0.14089864492416382,
0.3042411208152771,
1.3220490217208862,
-0.22975261509418488,
0.8639301657676697,
0.6205846667289734,
-0.14379630982875824,
0.6159180998802185,
0.8411763310432434,
-0.00038610713090747595,
0.8190732598304749,
-0.1521853655576706,
-0.4301678538322449,
-0.18037855625152588,
-0.37533673644065857,
-0.3750157952308655,
0.010555981658399105,
0.36028867959976196,
-0.48019939661026,
-0.5353908538818359,
-0.2629123330116272,
-0.11524807661771774,
0.17026714980602264,
-0.1184176355600357,
0.8641501665115356,
0.28655102849006653,
-0.7070996761322021,
0.22189004719257355,
-0.07310859113931656,
0.8854058980941772,
-0.7144910097122192,
-0.284572035074234,
-0.13526298105716705,
0.20199571549892426,
-0.208928182721138,
-0.35722586512565613,
-0.00006799687980674207,
0.1698622852563858,
-0.20558792352676392,
-0.20291835069656372,
1.1378827095031738,
-0.505165159702301,
-0.20460504293441772,
0.18360388278961182,
0.7356893420219421,
0.14625267684459686,
-0.1267756074666977,
-0.782634973526001,
-0.338567316532135,
0.03339473530650139,
-0.6614322662353516,
0.41958650946617126,
0.6916866898536682,
0.2347259521484375,
0.5370694994926453,
1.0465455055236816,
0.2275698482990265,
-0.014182771556079388,
0.24706900119781494,
0.9945651888847351,
-0.7252242565155029,
-0.606775164604187,
-0.9227672219276428,
0.35657110810279846,
-0.44690272212028503,
-0.570796012878418,
0.2664138674736023,
0.529638946056366,
0.4971926808357239,
0.13870839774608612,
0.7774272561073303,
-0.38955989480018616,
0.6015133857727051,
-0.23925401270389557,
0.6648992300033569,
-0.32912033796310425,
0.059853747487068176,
-0.03157516568899155,
-1.0125426054000854,
0.1685916781425476,
0.6212167143821716,
-0.1517830342054367,
0.23321563005447388,
0.7655474543571472,
0.5244967341423035,
-0.29551562666893005,
0.055894508957862854,
0.08351501822471619,
-0.052503716200590134,
0.3554353415966034,
0.7219346761703491,
0.841683566570282,
-0.3996921181678772,
1.129804015159607,
-0.5953251123428345,
-0.08587010949850082,
0.10448023676872253,
-0.989046037197113,
-0.9829234480857849,
-0.5521538853645325,
-0.10840438306331635,
-0.3320375680923462,
0.04683665186166763,
0.982650637626648,
0.5991458296775818,
-0.3617728352546692,
0.1661517471075058,
-0.35436925292015076,
-0.17202699184417725,
-0.027203088626265526,
-0.2901172339916229,
0.4695212244987488,
-0.4642449915409088,
-0.6999443173408508,
0.24849647283554077,
-0.09084902703762054,
-0.1719123274087906,
0.12366461008787155,
-0.20973603427410126,
-0.22926224768161774,
-0.6189631223678589,
0.4510471820831299,
0.5590493083000183,
-0.14070793986320496,
0.05683114379644394,
-0.07703682780265808,
-0.003022832330316305,
0.2490023672580719,
0.6933655738830566,
-1.0637743473052979,
0.17039203643798828,
0.20671649277210236,
0.651117742061615,
0.668739378452301,
-0.09948616474866867,
0.61566162109375,
-1.1843165159225464,
0.3793489933013916,
0.2431996613740921,
0.31956881284713745,
0.4108164608478546,
-0.7204203605651855,
0.7852787375450134,
0.02132304385304451,
-0.3908540904521942,
-0.7825112342834473,
-0.08817317336797714,
-0.7943841218948364,
-0.11159259080886841,
1.2079081535339355,
0.10320638120174408,
-0.4851342439651489,
-0.24005083739757538,
-0.15394644439220428,
0.5758196711540222,
-0.8090255856513977,
0.6160947680473328,
0.27857670187950134,
-0.047323476523160934,
-0.2949483096599579,
-0.8094691038131714,
0.4868567883968353,
0.616131603717804,
-0.9929258823394775,
-0.04864897206425667,
0.21558715403079987,
0.42881134152412415,
0.010973107069730759,
0.7802190184593201,
-0.10784291476011276,
0.3027080297470093,
-0.17042477428913116,
-0.07690760493278503,
-0.6348730325698853,
-0.03285772725939751,
-0.2916184663772583,
0.21820423007011414,
-0.24767939746379852,
-0.34938547015190125
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.03776v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.03776v2
|
XL-HeadTags: Leveraging Multimodal Retrieval Augmentation for the Multilingual Generation of News Headlines and Tags
| 2024-06-06T06:40:19 | 2024-06-07T05:58:45 |
Faisal Tareque Shohan, Mir Tafseer Nayeem, Samsul Islam, Abu Ubaida Akash, Shafiq Joty
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV, cs.IR
|
Millions of news articles published online daily can overwhelm readers.
Headlines and entity (topic) tags are essential for guiding readers to decide
if the content is worth their time. While headline generation has been
extensively studied, tag generation remains largely unexplored, yet it offers
readers better access to topics of interest. The need for conciseness in
capturing readers' attention necessitates improved content selection strategies
for identifying salient and relevant segments within lengthy articles, thereby
guiding language models effectively. To address this, we propose to leverage
auxiliary information such as images and captions embedded in the articles to
retrieve relevant sentences and utilize instruction tuning with variations to
generate both headlines and tags for news articles in a multilingual context.
To make use of the auxiliary information, we have compiled a dataset named
XL-HeadTags, which includes 20 languages across 6 diverse language families.
Through extensive evaluation, we demonstrate the effectiveness of our
plug-and-play multimodal-multilingual retrievers for both tasks. Additionally,
we have developed a suite of tools for processing and evaluating multilingual
texts, significantly contributing to the research community by enabling more
accurate and efficient analysis across languages.
|
[
-0.6684379577636719,
-0.6876499056816101,
0.401492178440094,
0.40930116176605225,
-0.5222845077514648,
0.3473956286907196,
-0.2893194258213043,
-0.7196877598762512,
0.4217802882194519,
0.21289055049419403,
-0.6249673366546631,
-0.41858381032943726,
-0.42970213294029236,
0.2858227491378784,
-0.06317261606454849,
0.9666658043861389,
0.121576689183712,
-0.19213752448558807,
-0.21227183938026428,
-0.13354888558387756,
-0.5488688349723816,
-0.18381203711032867,
-0.720456600189209,
0.15975061058998108,
0.9020878076553345,
0.427318274974823,
0.5568510890007019,
0.9192995429039001,
0.5298129320144653,
0.21636849641799927,
0.01600657030940056,
0.6357355117797852,
0.03358534350991249,
0.03311336413025856,
-0.36304566264152527,
-0.10941386967897415,
-0.34697791934013367,
-0.23248092830181122,
0.7826748490333557,
0.5493066310882568,
0.17521677911281586,
0.043045829981565475,
-0.11670347303152084,
0.5621358752250671,
-0.5191928744316101,
0.08646882325410843,
-0.6480801105499268,
-0.15412425994873047,
-0.3664388060569763,
-0.47241419553756714,
-0.253127783536911,
-0.20447218418121338,
-0.09980325400829315,
-0.4910361170768738,
0.0021282027009874582,
0.14499393105506897,
1.0060176849365234,
-0.008623973466455936,
-0.7245376110076904,
-0.3462885022163391,
-0.30628326535224915,
0.8754770159721375,
-0.2529536783695221,
0.8048070073127747,
0.35800978541374207,
0.016066426411271095,
0.255655437707901,
-0.6705755591392517,
-0.3854442834854126,
-0.2636396884918213,
-0.29089754819869995,
0.1884053349494934,
-0.23477599024772644,
-0.2783655822277069,
0.1495649516582489,
0.11990521103143692,
-0.7324965596199036,
0.03925225883722305,
-0.31465914845466614,
-0.2968037724494934,
0.5136808753013611,
-0.16806289553642273,
0.46525222063064575,
-0.43240460753440857,
-0.3359626531600952,
-0.06901268661022186,
-0.6645368337631226,
-0.05776067450642586,
0.6430466175079346,
0.4302811920642853,
0.023368338122963905,
0.6558721661567688,
-0.29230237007141113,
0.9671375751495361,
0.11762801557779312,
-0.6005563139915466,
0.6910024285316467,
-0.722881019115448,
0.22483710944652557,
0.08191224932670593,
0.45829570293426514,
0.736008882522583,
-0.21356840431690216,
-0.19354486465454102,
-0.1432563066482544,
-0.03521431237459183,
0.2652914524078369,
-0.6004593968391418,
0.1534247100353241,
0.2581384778022766,
-0.33514827489852905,
0.10930144786834717,
0.02546907588839531,
-0.9064977765083313,
0.00591298146173358,
-0.45514336228370667,
0.29495200514793396,
-0.5053579807281494,
-0.13327741622924805,
-0.16401639580726624,
-0.5686255693435669,
0.24102942645549774,
0.1600940078496933,
-0.5333768725395203,
-0.4381953775882721,
0.34519535303115845,
0.6784324645996094,
-0.32441580295562744,
-0.1939198076725006,
-0.526686429977417,
0.26227039098739624,
-0.20324388146400452,
1.0361607074737549,
-0.8734702467918396,
-0.19157108664512634,
0.07485387474298477,
0.2858489751815796,
-0.08980683237314224,
-0.22524961829185486,
0.9353242516517639,
-0.6741105914115906,
-0.06469166278839111,
-0.43000897765159607,
-0.2945336401462555,
-0.10914970189332962,
0.4136534333229065,
-0.8323374390602112,
0.7409902811050415,
0.029593152925372124,
-0.901617169380188,
0.4708886444568634,
-0.4688999652862549,
-0.8199688196182251,
0.016425125300884247,
-0.2954743206501007,
-0.44076961278915405,
-0.07097260653972626,
0.6463868618011475,
0.37245413661003113,
0.04961030185222626,
-0.07160834968090057,
0.18364772200584412,
0.1168956458568573,
-0.12066973000764847,
-0.08672948181629181,
0.3206239938735962,
0.4152645170688629,
-0.05025096610188484,
-0.0656091719865799,
-0.7263593673706055,
-0.0907699391245842,
0.025581570342183113,
-0.7176409363746643,
-0.6000075340270996,
0.08860962092876434,
0.4762720465660095,
0.23072324693202972,
0.19319280982017517,
-0.605964720249176,
0.05319798365235329,
-0.011559807695448399,
0.14028775691986084,
0.24252475798130035,
0.2429065704345703,
0.38997188210487366,
-0.46711355447769165,
0.397894024848938,
0.19635620713233948,
-0.21088266372680664,
-1.0741709470748901,
-0.4151943624019623,
-0.3531210720539093,
-0.2529152035713196,
0.38634589314460754,
0.4681461751461029,
-1.3877893686294556,
0.3582219183444977,
-0.1847987174987793,
-0.5466265678405762,
-0.3390909731388092,
0.05967957526445389,
0.4309733510017395,
0.4640354514122009,
0.3642398416996002,
-0.1834760159254074,
-0.8068154454231262,
-0.9542986154556274,
-0.4665067195892334,
0.4187265634536743,
0.26891106367111206,
0.3777771294116974,
0.2078472524881363,
-0.235221728682518,
1.0150407552719116,
-0.43055179715156555,
-0.25068074464797974,
-0.5089380741119385,
0.3729262351989746,
-0.005090727936476469,
0.6339352130889893,
0.8036221265792847,
-1.2932640314102173,
-0.45604056119918823,
0.25647079944610596,
-0.4607105255126953,
-0.03908887133002281,
-0.3015417456626892,
-0.10716880112886429,
0.4237324893474579,
0.45012542605400085,
-0.6682527661323547,
0.07275392860174179,
0.3594513535499573,
-0.10290863364934921,
0.49947884678840637,
-0.04915613681077957,
0.31474173069000244,
-1.1045784950256348,
0.17579683661460876,
0.39168596267700195,
-0.4105193316936493,
-0.45827293395996094,
0.31966158747673035,
0.601723849773407,
-0.015562349930405617,
-0.45784202218055725,
0.46797633171081543,
-0.7467529773712158,
0.10948754101991653,
-0.3625548183917999,
0.2383049726486206,
0.3811662793159485,
0.2821427583694458,
0.264945387840271,
0.8361161351203918,
0.4111155569553375,
-0.6071826815605164,
0.30502668023109436,
0.14047864079475403,
-0.3853543698787689,
0.7794027328491211,
-0.3377225399017334,
-0.12086547166109085,
-0.6790902614593506,
0.1728677898645401,
-0.8172837495803833,
-0.41104698181152344,
0.14737707376480103,
-0.5466404557228088,
0.5820993781089783,
0.014754877425730228,
-0.761447548866272,
-0.3477099537849426,
-0.44957125186920166,
0.21876731514930725,
0.15397250652313232,
-0.280588835477829,
0.520478367805481,
0.816287636756897,
-0.44060781598091125,
-0.7588910460472107,
-0.5381382703781128,
0.25216275453567505,
-0.16037756204605103,
-0.2705385088920593,
0.5041347146034241,
-0.32416674494743347,
-0.008108258247375488,
0.01673406921327114,
-0.168260395526886,
-0.2239144891500473,
-0.007983366027474403,
-0.3988247513771057,
0.12293369323015213,
-0.16917456686496735,
0.24958324432373047,
0.5414894223213196,
0.0362529382109642,
-0.1759815514087677,
-0.2797594964504242,
0.49785155057907104,
0.20135968923568726,
-0.053351644426584244,
-0.07703180611133575,
0.707771360874176,
0.26487016677856445,
-0.8757559657096863,
0.5417722463607788,
1.081126093864441,
-0.44681406021118164,
0.08230283856391907,
-0.6484900712966919,
0.040482956916093826,
-0.38196882605552673,
0.5512617230415344,
-0.2547016441822052,
-0.7067030072212219,
0.21899552643299103,
0.06724678725004196,
0.09379542618989944,
0.4621562957763672,
0.4980582594871521,
-0.012286791577935219,
1.0060203075408936,
0.6593600511550903,
0.19501659274101257,
0.5025166869163513,
0.026507370173931122,
0.06226317584514618,
-0.7830786108970642,
-0.26889723539352417,
-0.518113374710083,
-0.13744547963142395,
-0.4894786477088928,
-0.29359591007232666,
0.4264444410800934,
-0.1886834353208542,
0.5365415811538696,
0.5937604308128357,
-0.46328169107437134,
0.518322765827179,
0.6705203652381897,
0.27491453289985657,
0.34321290254592896,
0.04591596871614456,
0.03344463184475899,
-0.11023811250925064,
-0.30471813678741455,
-0.21332186460494995,
0.8277837634086609,
0.11710483580827713,
0.8912264704704285,
0.022233296185731888,
0.3526935875415802,
0.18123774230480194,
0.026605913415551186,
-0.6650877594947815,
0.13280677795410156,
-0.04346888139843941,
-0.6086844801902771,
0.13433149456977844,
-0.3885435163974762,
-1.070313572883606,
0.31081947684288025,
-0.002788291545584798,
-0.6193702220916748,
0.38683485984802246,
0.018741171807050705,
-0.5509872436523438,
0.005384216550737619,
-0.6438145637512207,
0.7670080065727234,
-0.15812189877033234,
-0.25734445452690125,
-0.10528518259525299,
-0.8004357218742371,
0.13395997881889343,
-0.3476898968219757,
0.46881917119026184,
-0.1936458796262741,
-0.3439851403236389,
0.5009990930557251,
0.2695291340351105,
0.5381367802619934,
0.19012963771820068,
-0.33635884523391724,
0.20792049169540405,
-0.46978235244750977,
0.19625531136989594,
0.406951367855072,
0.1838008612394333,
0.1360885053873062,
-0.2720668911933899,
-0.1251247376203537,
-0.05242343991994858,
0.7773318290710449,
-0.5238332748413086,
-0.3907758295536041,
-0.2733007073402405,
-0.9049329161643982,
-0.12205419689416885,
0.44583842158317566,
0.25465989112854004,
0.780928373336792,
0.17402569949626923,
0.27617761492729187,
0.5793302059173584,
-0.31352341175079346,
0.8136744499206543,
0.5071666836738586,
-0.1549479216337204,
-0.41932567954063416,
1.1112865209579468,
0.42162376642227173,
-0.1751299351453781,
0.8604552149772644,
-0.2247917652130127,
-0.30737045407295227,
-0.38950490951538086,
-0.5817146897315979,
0.19287744164466858,
-0.6007737517356873,
-0.5792513489723206,
-1.0184804201126099,
0.01844969019293785,
-0.4767828583717346,
0.01449087169021368,
-0.17730729281902313,
-0.46051692962646484,
-0.10377859324216843,
-0.15607944130897522,
0.008815930224955082,
0.2502760887145996,
-0.26428765058517456,
0.2718469202518463,
-0.9897732734680176,
0.5710200071334839,
0.10103923082351685,
0.13811561465263367,
-0.30408722162246704,
-0.13662417232990265,
-0.5989101529121399,
0.03792940452694893,
-0.6793369650840759,
-0.997251033782959,
0.35359111428260803,
0.30269768834114075,
0.7372804284095764,
0.3584750294685364,
0.06709761917591095,
0.5648098587989807,
-0.8908481597900391,
0.6359663009643555,
0.033182792365550995,
-0.7600702047348022,
0.6812074184417725,
-0.45880845189094543,
0.3766400218009949,
0.16067782044410706,
0.755337119102478,
-0.36564555764198303,
-0.48577967286109924,
-0.16549427807331085,
-1.0871152877807617,
0.852527916431427,
0.29744812846183777,
0.4196551740169525,
-0.46333691477775574,
0.05392130836844444,
0.25298166275024414,
0.5172591209411621,
-0.6913885474205017,
-0.43155890703201294,
-0.15629734098911285,
0.0016887499950826168,
-0.066408671438694,
-0.26152870059013367,
0.07090084254741669,
-0.1344272494316101,
0.5532488226890564,
-0.1799187958240509,
0.306837797164917,
0.4092826247215271,
-0.38168957829475403,
-0.11805971711874008,
0.282171368598938,
0.7950760722160339,
0.9703501462936401,
-0.1422027349472046,
0.037614043802022934,
-0.2041638046503067,
-0.3514593243598938,
-0.26638615131378174,
0.6366621255874634,
0.052548572421073914,
0.6023685336112976,
0.08433084189891815,
0.7182451486587524,
0.2649726867675781,
-0.9253101944923401,
0.3110366463661194,
-0.009456890635192394,
0.2583574652671814,
-0.3325953781604767,
-0.3250824809074402,
0.03989076241850853,
0.26302921772003174,
0.7870615124702454,
0.24245885014533997,
0.370678573846817,
-0.6053482890129089,
0.5873008370399475,
0.5691043138504028,
-0.08057423681020737,
-0.3655567765235901,
0.6038936376571655,
0.24966579675674438,
0.039327554404735565,
0.007293052971363068,
-0.4581438899040222,
-0.33170631527900696,
0.588218092918396,
0.5314421057701111,
0.3998667001724243,
-0.3988078236579895,
0.26625365018844604,
0.4088868200778961,
0.5505402088165283,
0.16434434056282043,
0.2326633632183075,
-0.014618132263422012,
-0.6762366890907288,
-0.6223801374435425,
-0.6000280976295471,
-0.279792845249176,
-0.01149914599955082,
-0.6919835805892944,
0.2748098373413086,
0.09109721332788467,
-0.3773126006126404,
0.31070828437805176,
-0.0560031495988369,
-0.6056054830551147,
0.2676921784877777,
0.6201726198196411,
1.0449438095092773,
-0.5084167718887329,
0.6553599834442139,
1.1950796842575073,
-0.4573548138141632,
-0.34005504846572876,
0.09898645430803299,
-0.21891836822032928,
-0.6466198563575745,
0.5410006642341614,
0.4786083996295929,
0.4025423228740692,
0.37220296263694763,
-0.2534624934196472,
-0.8734517693519592,
0.7917029857635498,
0.3424970805644989,
-0.43040311336517334,
-0.3275618851184845,
0.07975365221500397,
-0.028642134740948677,
-0.3781192898750305,
0.3713237941265106,
0.45577090978622437,
0.7737307548522949,
0.08154280483722687,
-1.0745646953582764,
-0.2566105127334595,
-0.15378150343894958,
-0.027650097385048866,
0.3283490836620331,
-0.560053825378418,
1.0126574039459229,
-0.14125719666481018,
-0.22053822875022888,
-0.054100628942251205,
0.5842317342758179,
0.0067545878700912,
0.3112547695636749,
0.339247465133667,
0.585008978843689,
0.3480576276779175,
-0.16072311997413635,
1.1118278503417969,
-0.5781005620956421,
0.42595407366752625,
0.773953378200531,
-0.0653710886836052,
0.5876994729042053,
0.5055525898933411,
0.21054565906524658,
0.2967413067817688,
0.5540897250175476,
0.012056184932589531,
0.7278860807418823,
-0.33248215913772583,
-0.15133439004421234,
-0.20876044034957886,
-0.6151965260505676,
-0.3424094021320343,
0.43077313899993896,
0.5702535510063171,
-0.3741212487220764,
-0.7290184497833252,
0.4624859392642975,
0.5283467173576355,
-0.04739011824131012,
-0.579957127571106,
0.6342295408248901,
0.07331913709640503,
-0.8370134234428406,
0.1732262521982193,
0.43798741698265076,
0.6681345701217651,
-0.7294158339500427,
-0.06955333799123764,
-0.14186395704746246,
0.04118036851286888,
-0.11904242634773254,
-0.8252224922180176,
0.5257505774497986,
-0.09327177703380585,
-0.14061474800109863,
-0.21137146651744843,
0.8084438443183899,
-0.7804243564605713,
-0.6041210293769836,
0.04907770827412605,
0.7769497036933899,
-0.27356794476509094,
-0.2758415639400482,
-0.6236191391944885,
0.36237627267837524,
-0.09924186021089554,
-0.33382943272590637,
0.14525610208511353,
0.2819804251194,
0.04624864459037781,
0.272667795419693,
0.5359105467796326,
-0.16104181110858917,
0.05185851827263832,
-0.12383053451776505,
1.057512879371643,
-0.4478723406791687,
-0.6867244839668274,
-0.7803094983100891,
0.6641572713851929,
-0.23451028764247894,
-0.20332254469394684,
1.03627347946167,
0.7844788432121277,
0.9585342407226562,
-0.2850697338581085,
0.9161114692687988,
-0.3530971109867096,
0.5300523638725281,
-0.5686189532279968,
0.6721036434173584,
-0.8581870794296265,
-0.21251004934310913,
-0.3081863522529602,
-0.9369189143180847,
-0.37370750308036804,
0.2951629161834717,
0.1474868655204773,
0.07456734031438828,
0.7117912769317627,
0.4739614427089691,
-0.13824614882469177,
-0.2758892774581909,
0.24544325470924377,
-0.032791901379823685,
0.07045527547597885,
0.24293197691440582,
0.6286477446556091,
-0.18902580440044403,
0.6213932037353516,
-0.3402470052242279,
-0.11262764781713486,
-0.12377546727657318,
-0.9258995652198792,
-1.0349937677383423,
-0.6899983286857605,
-0.401498019695282,
0.15120485424995422,
0.15498849749565125,
1.0471192598342896,
0.6683789491653442,
-0.640663206577301,
0.0725591704249382,
0.3685232400894165,
0.2332935780286789,
-0.2231457680463791,
-0.24466313421726227,
0.3052617609500885,
-0.8977096080780029,
-1.097308874130249,
0.27160078287124634,
0.36978763341903687,
-0.24106775224208832,
0.09425592422485352,
0.3631790578365326,
-0.47068166732788086,
0.05468402057886124,
0.7637984752655029,
0.09058675915002823,
-0.46652549505233765,
-0.3519514501094818,
0.006827014964073896,
-0.03365989029407501,
0.26408082246780396,
0.7096104025840759,
-0.7845284342765808,
0.29051461815834045,
0.3309827744960785,
0.8019382357597351,
-0.0163594800978899,
0.19761191308498383,
0.2666451930999756,
-1.3032608032226562,
0.28037020564079285,
0.03220628947019577,
0.558692991733551,
0.49469515681266785,
-0.33619651198387146,
0.26505357027053833,
0.3783096671104431,
-0.34228116273880005,
-0.7311084866523743,
0.20753467082977295,
-1.0526869297027588,
-0.2251589298248291,
1.1391245126724243,
-0.161195307970047,
-0.17846189439296722,
-0.15280699729919434,
-0.5510739684104919,
0.19676031172275543,
-0.5977281332015991,
0.27945029735565186,
0.3995228111743927,
0.2366211861371994,
-0.6656274795532227,
-0.6567656397819519,
0.32347434759140015,
-0.1727656126022339,
-0.8179565668106079,
-0.44579264521598816,
0.45182856917381287,
-0.0018693999154493213,
0.6384710669517517,
0.285220742225647,
0.06193401664495468,
0.40953510999679565,
-0.26485675573349,
0.11674696207046509,
-0.06573251634836197,
-0.4109386205673218,
0.10549454391002655,
0.15384173393249512,
-0.3388618230819702,
-0.21715357899665833
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.