id
stringlengths 33
33
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
33
| title
stringlengths 13
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 6
16.6k
| category_primary
stringclasses 60
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
132
| abstract
stringlengths 123
1.99k
| embeddings
listlengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.06393v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.06393v2
|
STimage-1K4M: A histopathology image-gene expression dataset for spatial transcriptomics
| 2024-06-10T15:48:07 | 2024-06-20T17:38:55 |
Jiawen Chen, Muqing Zhou, Wenrong Wu, Jinwei Zhang, Yun Li, Didong Li
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL, q-bio.GN, I.4.10; I.2.10
|
Recent advances in multi-modal algorithms have driven and been driven by the
increasing availability of large image-text datasets, leading to significant
strides in various fields, including computational pathology. However, in most
existing medical image-text datasets, the text typically provides high-level
summaries that may not sufficiently describe sub-tile regions within a large
pathology image. For example, an image might cover an extensive tissue area
containing cancerous and healthy regions, but the accompanying text might only
specify that this image is a cancer slide, lacking the nuanced details needed
for in-depth analysis. In this study, we introduce STimage-1K4M, a novel
dataset designed to bridge this gap by providing genomic features for sub-tile
images. STimage-1K4M contains 1,149 images derived from spatial transcriptomics
data, which captures gene expression information at the level of individual
spatial spots within a pathology image. Specifically, each image in the dataset
is broken down into smaller sub-image tiles, with each tile paired with
15,000-30,000 dimensional gene expressions. With 4,293,195 pairs of sub-tile
images and gene expressions, STimage-1K4M offers unprecedented granularity,
paving the way for a wide range of advanced research in multi-modal data
analysis an innovative applications in computational pathology, and beyond.
|
[
-0.47762802243232727,
-0.27901044487953186,
0.5883122682571411,
0.3604006767272949,
-0.45470380783081055,
0.18732360005378723,
0.14852643013000488,
-0.1338004767894745,
0.5591777563095093,
0.5867368578910828,
-0.6510234475135803,
-0.7101126313209534,
-0.8017951250076294,
0.20868809521198273,
0.004592840559780598,
0.723640501499176,
0.20126688480377197,
0.34577471017837524,
-0.4564254581928253,
-0.5509315133094788,
-0.12238571047782898,
-0.06861765682697296,
-0.27619192004203796,
0.07864844799041748,
0.7648259401321411,
0.44113999605178833,
0.9199443459510803,
1.0995135307312012,
0.8126067519187927,
0.24459780752658844,
0.240274116396904,
-0.16413229703903198,
-0.4668125808238983,
0.06383045762777328,
0.18057160079479218,
0.1271418184041977,
-0.22906558215618134,
-0.050863027572631836,
0.5544936060905457,
0.6069656610488892,
-0.10027914494276047,
-0.0036912523210048676,
-0.43865785002708435,
0.734460175037384,
-0.2905728816986084,
0.0764840841293335,
-0.05277195945382118,
0.6650715470314026,
-0.4564850628376007,
-0.40691518783569336,
0.22901126742362976,
-0.5506085157394409,
0.25055837631225586,
-0.6615273952484131,
0.03668857365846634,
-0.2843264639377594,
0.7941550016403198,
0.523381769657135,
-0.6426120400428772,
-0.0002006697322940454,
-0.19505101442337036,
0.3692606985569,
-0.7977728247642517,
0.11649837344884872,
0.2503614127635956,
0.6397563219070435,
-0.11737358570098877,
-0.9188258051872253,
0.01631207950413227,
-0.007877960801124573,
-0.39066994190216064,
0.5492311120033264,
-0.0852295532822609,
-0.013817530125379562,
0.27483171224594116,
0.4757407605648041,
-0.6918424963951111,
-0.08586476743221283,
-0.6813328266143799,
-0.4282030463218689,
0.3424730598926544,
0.44406959414482117,
0.29795897006988525,
-0.4804558753967285,
-0.7357990741729736,
0.14285661280155182,
-0.7343515157699585,
0.02306770533323288,
-0.02913837321102619,
0.08067097514867783,
-0.2114536315202713,
0.23072101175785065,
0.09830930829048157,
0.30432969331741333,
-0.39286237955093384,
-0.16787314414978027,
0.18780852854251862,
-0.5356021523475647,
-0.13643790781497955,
0.03771388903260231,
0.9853134155273438,
0.05427148938179016,
-0.6486877799034119,
0.1794319748878479,
0.5216256976127625,
-0.12552228569984436,
0.43664735555648804,
-1.0544888973236084,
-0.3186640739440918,
0.35033339262008667,
-0.9249486923217773,
-0.41175612807273865,
-0.04767858237028122,
-1.378119945526123,
-0.45412805676460266,
0.051489487290382385,
0.2451910674571991,
-0.5019750595092773,
-0.12433744221925735,
0.06448894739151001,
-0.41333672404289246,
-0.02638370171189308,
0.2788473665714264,
-0.09044470638036728,
0.23498478531837463,
0.06962371617555618,
0.9028306603431702,
-0.2753905653953552,
-0.29542216658592224,
-0.3562729060649872,
0.21575625240802765,
-0.5405491590499878,
0.734002411365509,
-1.098164439201355,
-0.4147647023200989,
-0.2702755630016327,
0.041392844170331955,
0.1975492686033249,
-0.3596503436565399,
0.5590545535087585,
-0.33831489086151123,
0.24135687947273254,
-0.7485376596450806,
-0.32802969217300415,
-0.1432476043701172,
-0.02091725915670395,
-0.962095320224762,
1.3383879661560059,
0.39916592836380005,
-0.6083065867424011,
0.348989337682724,
-0.7357274293899536,
-0.13731932640075684,
0.24657313525676727,
-0.7711359262466431,
-0.5107497572898865,
0.20585903525352478,
0.2037236988544464,
0.304582804441452,
-0.12617258727550507,
-0.027964163571596146,
-0.028743119910359383,
-0.12070301175117493,
-0.13545216619968414,
0.2256898581981659,
0.2558731734752655,
0.23678156733512878,
-0.42216432094573975,
-0.006642474792897701,
-0.5146747827529907,
-0.04847129061818123,
0.2971785068511963,
-0.31889501214027405,
-0.13890044391155243,
-0.2432563453912735,
-0.5143293738365173,
0.7718828320503235,
0.25935542583465576,
-0.7572464346885681,
0.5246289968490601,
-0.22647055983543396,
-0.11008454859256744,
0.450869619846344,
0.18941913545131683,
0.5065557360649109,
-0.41792625188827515,
0.6346989274024963,
0.575860321521759,
0.16206134855747223,
-0.4520155191421509,
-0.8602426052093506,
0.11177098751068115,
-0.7291070818901062,
0.013811852782964706,
0.3975958824157715,
-0.7349796891212463,
0.14146305620670319,
-0.6103439331054688,
-0.6736776828765869,
-0.5521920919418335,
-0.17111508548259735,
0.4182111322879791,
0.43753549456596375,
0.5556780695915222,
-0.4333021640777588,
-0.6330777406692505,
-1.3384478092193604,
0.3264908194541931,
0.6529879570007324,
-0.26539239287376404,
0.802229642868042,
0.2713187038898468,
-0.3958871364593506,
0.7417412996292114,
-0.6870847940444946,
-0.5169811844825745,
0.10300927609205246,
0.21881653368473053,
0.19929425418376923,
0.3993462324142456,
0.5320087671279907,
-0.4468647837638855,
-0.13458670675754547,
0.13831697404384613,
-0.715125322341919,
-0.465535432100296,
-0.0843699723482132,
-0.5477833151817322,
-0.39675071835517883,
0.34914252161979675,
-0.5212569832801819,
0.8897380232810974,
0.46221277117729187,
-0.42661598324775696,
0.5058390498161316,
-0.5366002321243286,
0.8766086101531982,
-0.8719385862350464,
-0.17654851078987122,
0.01982792280614376,
-0.28252896666526794,
-0.6666308641433716,
0.049586255103349686,
0.12607863545417786,
-0.09039396047592163,
-0.20830300450325012,
0.07482945919036865,
-0.09196092933416367,
-0.5308626890182495,
-0.22225125133991241,
-0.2647269368171692,
0.24004749953746796,
0.586023211479187,
0.05115455016493797,
0.6679161190986633,
0.5507029294967651,
-0.1444699466228485,
-0.04373800754547119,
0.5852379202842712,
-0.19539085030555725,
-0.12367730587720871,
-0.4384956955909729,
0.15516217052936554,
-0.26179689168930054,
0.507902979850769,
-1.0626815557479858,
-0.18305034935474396,
0.12722979485988617,
-0.3003595173358917,
0.21839503943920135,
-0.32232722640037537,
-0.229450523853302,
-0.2888972759246826,
-0.6024156212806702,
0.6761283278465271,
0.3953796923160553,
-0.25198471546173096,
0.7701430916786194,
0.39142125844955444,
-0.3773341178894043,
-0.259311705827713,
-0.7896531224250793,
0.4019922614097595,
-0.04612389951944351,
-0.7967572212219238,
0.40040838718414307,
0.11371974647045135,
0.33798885345458984,
-0.10870599746704102,
-0.11680961400270462,
-0.11792375147342682,
-0.4265652298927307,
0.37376371026039124,
0.24601344764232635,
-0.2563822865486145,
-0.18637701869010925,
0.03001442365348339,
-0.10335735231637955,
-0.24034923315048218,
0.06869771331548691,
0.17403756082057953,
0.23685431480407715,
-0.4153270125389099,
-0.04786679148674011,
0.8140950202941895,
0.7492518424987793,
-0.13860860466957092,
0.018468571826815605,
0.38668572902679443,
-0.7178907990455627,
0.13345485925674438,
0.015514776110649109,
-0.15714552998542786,
-0.4058971107006073,
0.2939283549785614,
-0.4633840322494507,
-0.8040086627006531,
0.6447295546531677,
-0.4099937975406647,
0.08854682743549347,
0.4096144735813141,
0.5278996229171753,
-0.11992256343364716,
0.9674447774887085,
0.14360792934894562,
0.08553611487150192,
0.03293956071138382,
-0.028540071099996567,
0.24644553661346436,
-0.5883394479751587,
-0.15741145610809326,
-0.5131512880325317,
-0.7120286226272583,
-0.37432733178138733,
-1.1030749082565308,
0.6576680541038513,
-0.34694936871528625,
-0.241708904504776,
0.1794188767671585,
-0.8588027954101562,
0.33281517028808594,
0.467142254114151,
0.3969862163066864,
-0.17015887796878815,
0.019698817282915115,
-0.007555483374744654,
-0.690762996673584,
-0.8932090997695923,
-0.5744619965553284,
0.6704697012901306,
0.4791102707386017,
0.4844825863838196,
0.539212703704834,
0.41274353861808777,
0.36561325192451477,
0.05876024067401886,
-0.5210309028625488,
0.34061768651008606,
-0.891484260559082,
-0.46867257356643677,
-0.13595545291900635,
-0.5947179794311523,
-0.87070631980896,
0.2529454529285431,
-0.25652456283569336,
-0.36333009600639343,
0.5155494809150696,
0.02201198600232601,
-0.535335123538971,
0.4079889953136444,
-0.3023487627506256,
1.05081045627594,
-0.40258046984672546,
-0.08466991037130356,
0.14383257925510406,
-0.9266144037246704,
0.2802450954914093,
0.19362735748291016,
0.4127834439277649,
-0.01577286794781685,
-0.29805105924606323,
0.779472291469574,
-0.3410365581512451,
0.6960502862930298,
-0.4159167408943176,
0.07982207834720612,
-0.2550155520439148,
0.5671113133430481,
0.37818849086761475,
-0.09600041061639786,
0.2452460080385208,
0.49570631980895996,
0.36348676681518555,
-0.7031387686729431,
-0.4041484296321869,
0.7162074446678162,
-0.4090506434440613,
0.055770691484212875,
-0.06894731521606445,
-0.42719078063964844,
-0.1198469027876854,
0.045953407883644104,
0.5690193176269531,
0.5619627237319946,
0.23158656060695648,
-0.0636088028550148,
0.7842462062835693,
-0.6626536250114441,
0.10601474344730377,
-0.22339627146720886,
-0.13634665310382843,
-0.46137040853500366,
0.9220725893974304,
0.013099286705255508,
-0.1251262128353119,
0.2229870706796646,
0.6971143484115601,
0.027195105329155922,
-0.5501474142074585,
-0.5595696568489075,
-0.1754724085330963,
-0.6875011324882507,
-0.5996454358100891,
-0.6501980423927307,
0.09994076937437057,
-0.20255562663078308,
-0.5553661584854126,
-0.5030347108840942,
-0.27461060881614685,
0.02013762854039669,
-0.21449311077594757,
0.39098843932151794,
0.8844033479690552,
-0.07713884860277176,
0.20721472799777985,
-1.344247579574585,
0.3937082290649414,
-0.0033440254628658295,
0.36535918712615967,
-0.5971589088439941,
-0.4824112057685852,
-0.25021716952323914,
-0.163143590092659,
-0.014121544547379017,
-0.973063051700592,
0.5125659704208374,
0.5145682692527771,
0.3324422240257263,
0.5404879450798035,
-0.49304115772247314,
0.919133722782135,
-0.5670632719993591,
0.9961435198783875,
0.15080155432224274,
-0.3997812867164612,
0.5478774905204773,
-0.5432208180427551,
0.49018484354019165,
0.3918706476688385,
0.3760928809642792,
-0.4091501832008362,
-0.4366587996482849,
-0.5700997710227966,
-0.9163683652877808,
0.5522444248199463,
0.32734087109565735,
-0.35156843066215515,
-0.012299531139433384,
0.4793016016483307,
0.7313134670257568,
0.09453568607568741,
-0.357088178396225,
-0.3666086792945862,
-0.6355088949203491,
-0.6631786227226257,
0.13220936059951782,
-0.2978917956352234,
-0.6388227939605713,
-0.23002639412879944,
0.20438455045223236,
-0.33287590742111206,
0.8497284054756165,
0.4354812800884247,
0.037439100444316864,
-0.042158570140600204,
-0.02077983133494854,
0.7116006016731262,
0.3059724271297455,
-0.18041740357875824,
0.49055716395378113,
0.16344772279262543,
-0.752579927444458,
-0.205025777220726,
0.08577119559049606,
0.315189927816391,
0.04545297473669052,
0.7363946437835693,
0.48447921872138977,
0.5403111577033997,
-0.41940170526504517,
0.7213243842124939,
-0.03925196826457977,
-0.7328502535820007,
0.013948255218565464,
-0.37500184774398804,
0.12258489429950714,
0.31400635838508606,
0.55582195520401,
0.3490300178527832,
0.6131606698036194,
0.05491842329502106,
0.5276971459388733,
0.05747496709227562,
-0.6561607718467712,
-0.27713140845298767,
0.4356418550014496,
-0.19024109840393066,
0.4385104477405548,
0.3764491081237793,
-0.155976802110672,
-0.5611184239387512,
0.8704997301101685,
0.03904878348112106,
0.3381524085998535,
0.08179979771375656,
0.10238746553659439,
0.7161346077919006,
0.2539764642715454,
0.3241201937198639,
0.3857605457305908,
0.3826553523540497,
-0.4718469977378845,
-0.25065359473228455,
-0.46194198727607727,
-0.05244307592511177,
0.012631930410861969,
-0.3845141530036926,
-0.1670754849910736,
-0.6136497855186462,
0.03516285866498947,
0.2832511365413666,
-0.13928605616092682,
-0.46173056960105896,
0.2358126938343048,
0.20348089933395386,
1.1742854118347168,
-0.782629668712616,
0.6788792014122009,
0.7054360508918762,
-0.1932048797607422,
-0.45038101077079773,
-0.46454450488090515,
0.17660874128341675,
-0.5046566724777222,
0.6298787593841553,
0.14938606321811676,
0.04731901362538338,
-0.11275790631771088,
-0.6579952239990234,
-1.0386472940444946,
1.3472728729248047,
0.13776680827140808,
-0.48492544889450073,
0.31570613384246826,
0.10153747349977493,
0.48707619309425354,
-0.6980929970741272,
0.008209981955587864,
0.5267332792282104,
0.6806811690330505,
0.5018492341041565,
-0.38622385263442993,
0.29322972893714905,
-0.19562655687332153,
0.14048214256763458,
0.5433792471885681,
-0.258501261472702,
0.5170601010322571,
-0.15819117426872253,
-0.35694020986557007,
0.04430900514125824,
0.14960013329982758,
0.052094466984272,
0.47610098123550415,
0.2717282772064209,
1.1122932434082031,
0.5133300423622131,
-0.70685875415802,
0.9800886511802673,
-0.20270109176635742,
0.04080762714147568,
0.7529855966567993,
-0.060069672763347626,
0.38429826498031616,
0.36118170619010925,
-0.3215395510196686,
0.30684584379196167,
0.9311323165893555,
0.056890327483415604,
0.6440906524658203,
0.07991909235715866,
-0.2587449550628662,
-0.31895339488983154,
0.35339850187301636,
-0.27716368436813354,
0.35453659296035767,
0.594792902469635,
-0.23079143464565277,
-0.4153193533420563,
0.25296750664711,
-0.3176599442958832,
-0.33070799708366394,
-0.33624717593193054,
0.9401825070381165,
-0.246616929769516,
0.10975804924964905,
-0.24757851660251617,
-0.1639840453863144,
0.7833756804466248,
-0.8990925550460815,
-0.3292640149593353,
-0.4581942558288574,
-0.4559638202190399,
-0.4941921830177307,
-0.987423837184906,
0.45325231552124023,
-0.46648237109184265,
-0.007192606572061777,
0.1330205798149109,
0.6809995770454407,
-0.28780046105384827,
-0.43133535981178284,
0.25327661633491516,
0.49312523007392883,
0.309318870306015,
0.3690342605113983,
-0.5267423987388611,
-0.03585805743932724,
0.04730663076043129,
-0.08787408471107483,
0.2509630024433136,
0.532904326915741,
0.06736883521080017,
0.2725769579410553,
0.5913645029067993,
0.09907099604606628,
0.11157052963972092,
-0.12482382357120514,
0.9542632699012756,
-1.034085988998413,
-0.22961044311523438,
-0.4298474192619324,
0.6640883684158325,
-0.23523367941379547,
-0.3914989233016968,
0.402028888463974,
0.5784973502159119,
0.14962691068649292,
0.06838415563106537,
0.8557893633842468,
-0.21963848173618317,
0.4051325023174286,
-0.22834396362304688,
0.40903496742248535,
-0.4735219478607178,
0.030415812507271767,
-0.15804588794708252,
-0.1734597235918045,
-0.6108421087265015,
0.43732568621635437,
-0.24703669548034668,
0.1941424161195755,
0.7237604856491089,
1.0097352266311646,
-0.15775738656520844,
-0.010069100186228752,
0.48093947768211365,
0.22805233299732208,
0.26193544268608093,
0.519884467124939,
0.49803534150123596,
-0.36969253420829773,
0.597029447555542,
-0.36580201983451843,
-0.6242059469223022,
-0.08599283546209335,
-0.9207156300544739,
-0.2569383382797241,
-0.816164493560791,
-0.3489251136779785,
-0.35293203592300415,
-0.24605487287044525,
0.739172637462616,
0.9258755445480347,
-0.693020224571228,
0.34190791845321655,
0.3515160381793976,
-0.37331265211105347,
-0.030542917549610138,
-0.147441565990448,
0.5837505459785461,
-0.06713531911373138,
-0.30682143568992615,
0.5811198353767395,
1.0180834531784058,
-0.02564074657857418,
0.11574210971593857,
-0.12215404212474823,
-0.3490808606147766,
-0.004387777764350176,
0.6325516104698181,
0.4131070673465729,
0.006592383608222008,
-0.08266657590866089,
-0.12800443172454834,
-0.3862305283546448,
0.5547485947608948,
1.022292137145996,
-0.5583786368370056,
0.5332906246185303,
0.5601105093955994,
0.9557098746299744,
0.3317546248435974,
-0.040288250893354416,
0.4522492289543152,
-1.062398910522461,
-0.176611989736557,
0.40717417001724243,
0.5189085006713867,
0.16579018533229828,
-0.7891125082969666,
0.38083764910697937,
0.09592720121145248,
-0.8004950284957886,
-0.18481135368347168,
0.3509577512741089,
-1.1455104351043701,
-0.5473893880844116,
0.9256013631820679,
0.04587118700146675,
-0.10562200099229813,
-0.23545384407043457,
-0.500272274017334,
-0.18037818372249603,
-0.539788544178009,
0.5838914513587952,
0.3642505705356598,
-0.4366976320743561,
-0.6418853402137756,
-0.583754301071167,
0.7625911235809326,
0.0650719404220581,
-1.0556539297103882,
-0.16836704313755035,
0.8669140338897705,
-0.015504598617553711,
0.1374761164188385,
0.8368682861328125,
-0.568715512752533,
0.6137247085571289,
0.03057723119854927,
0.026049064472317696,
-0.13019557297229767,
-0.0544552206993103,
-0.48664039373397827,
0.4305915832519531,
-0.27676787972450256,
-0.3179567754268646
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.06391v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.06391v1
|
Towards Lifelong Learning of Large Language Models: A Survey
| 2024-06-10T15:46:25 | 2024-06-10T15:46:25 |
Junhao Zheng, Shengjie Qiu, Chengming Shi, Qianli Ma
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
As the applications of large language models (LLMs) expand across diverse
fields, the ability of these models to adapt to ongoing changes in data, tasks,
and user preferences becomes crucial. Traditional training methods, relying on
static datasets, are increasingly inadequate for coping with the dynamic nature
of real-world information. Lifelong learning, also known as continual or
incremental learning, addresses this challenge by enabling LLMs to learn
continuously and adaptively over their operational lifetime, integrating new
knowledge while retaining previously learned information and preventing
catastrophic forgetting. This survey delves into the sophisticated landscape of
lifelong learning, categorizing strategies into two primary groups: Internal
Knowledge and External Knowledge. Internal Knowledge includes continual
pretraining and continual finetuning, each enhancing the adaptability of LLMs
in various scenarios. External Knowledge encompasses retrieval-based and
tool-based lifelong learning, leveraging external data sources and
computational tools to extend the model's capabilities without modifying core
parameters. The key contributions of our survey are: (1) Introducing a novel
taxonomy categorizing the extensive literature of lifelong learning into 12
scenarios; (2) Identifying common techniques across all lifelong learning
scenarios and classifying existing literature into various technique groups
within each scenario; (3) Highlighting emerging techniques such as model
expansion and data selection, which were less explored in the pre-LLM era.
Through a detailed examination of these groups and their respective categories,
this survey aims to enhance the adaptability, reliability, and overall
performance of LLMs in real-world applications.
|
[
-0.23043811321258545,
-0.8692771792411804,
0.37407657504081726,
-0.040832627564668655,
0.029885392636060715,
0.45764613151550293,
-0.5049475431442261,
-0.5278377532958984,
-0.1866646707057953,
0.5182985067367554,
-0.5245341062545776,
-0.32982373237609863,
-0.5203722715377808,
-0.08171296864748001,
-0.04363846033811569,
0.865913987159729,
-0.03307012841105461,
0.22717757523059845,
-0.4170501232147217,
-0.3576503098011017,
-0.6010949015617371,
-0.646087110042572,
-1.0354294776916504,
-0.42256689071655273,
0.7037950754165649,
0.46055907011032104,
0.25449487566947937,
0.16704022884368896,
0.19228290021419525,
0.21593943238258362,
-0.10131917148828506,
0.19547659158706665,
-0.7316004633903503,
0.38822507858276367,
-0.1332775205373764,
-0.45226263999938965,
-0.010886442847549915,
-0.21411314606666565,
0.9479296803474426,
0.8810275197029114,
-0.15871992707252502,
0.2548733353614807,
0.2971425950527191,
0.7470515966415405,
-0.4759903848171234,
-0.007248914800584316,
-0.7643518447875977,
0.13643015921115875,
-0.20602428913116455,
-0.13720253109931946,
-0.40983667969703674,
-0.49763473868370056,
0.16649509966373444,
-0.15805940330028534,
-0.21652653813362122,
-0.03681773692369461,
0.27413997054100037,
-0.030640536919236183,
-0.493176132440567,
-0.5647904872894287,
-0.9561223983764648,
0.8354765176773071,
-0.568223237991333,
0.6977821588516235,
0.12424905598163605,
0.21420881152153015,
-0.09612776339054108,
-0.5866586565971375,
-0.2756985127925873,
-0.6860504150390625,
0.2396879941225052,
0.19683977961540222,
0.21597357094287872,
-0.07142027467489243,
0.053350694477558136,
0.34915319085121155,
-0.5230103731155396,
0.5015755891799927,
-0.29574331641197205,
-0.1229458898305893,
0.4928761422634125,
0.32994455099105835,
0.2998729646205902,
0.46554073691368103,
-0.20627427101135254,
0.2468310296535492,
-1.1052470207214355,
0.020937269553542137,
0.2762822210788727,
0.03613942861557007,
0.02968418039381504,
0.2855222225189209,
-0.038993172347545624,
0.7143790125846863,
-0.20476064085960388,
-0.3599574565887451,
0.08375655859708786,
-0.2821745276451111,
0.16560052335262299,
-0.25399839878082275,
0.4280621111392975,
0.0664556622505188,
0.2639860510826111,
-0.3099326491355896,
-0.31082624197006226,
-0.351060152053833,
0.14825507998466492,
-0.33494287729263306,
-0.023900732398033142,
-0.06033191829919815,
-0.349854052066803,
0.10262890160083771,
-0.2748397886753082,
-0.7368684411048889,
-0.3412042558193207,
-0.5750170946121216,
0.35167115926742554,
-0.32752472162246704,
-0.22637823224067688,
-0.057261597365140915,
0.28183671832084656,
0.1722710132598877,
0.3552151322364807,
-0.8288331031799316,
0.22866196930408478,
0.5641168355941772,
0.9507043957710266,
-0.43039458990097046,
-0.3320050537586212,
-0.38594648241996765,
0.1687161922454834,
-0.26384419202804565,
0.6182023882865906,
-0.49367308616638184,
-0.5282065868377686,
0.31912893056869507,
0.07880043238401413,
-0.1168915182352066,
-0.7313767671585083,
0.07634054124355316,
-0.7322486639022827,
0.15563401579856873,
-0.10416898876428604,
-0.6966720819473267,
-0.16944409906864166,
0.43972522020339966,
-0.5326437950134277,
1.0453250408172607,
0.17489740252494812,
-0.4457649290561676,
0.48314228653907776,
-0.6276370882987976,
-0.2499612271785736,
0.24821944534778595,
-0.04113011807203293,
-0.5269736051559448,
0.06824584305286407,
-0.3185655474662781,
0.534221887588501,
-0.2696658968925476,
0.40252071619033813,
-0.6100114583969116,
-0.1267005205154419,
0.2543888986110687,
-0.4822712540626526,
0.4591309428215027,
0.061340123414993286,
-0.07417146861553192,
0.2646995782852173,
-0.5626963973045349,
-0.34907612204551697,
0.16168150305747986,
-0.5308111906051636,
-0.3940756022930145,
0.19431288540363312,
-0.08552811294794083,
0.4239416718482971,
0.41025644540786743,
-0.5551729202270508,
0.5164545774459839,
-0.25141605734825134,
0.34021419286727905,
1.0263516902923584,
0.3086649775505066,
0.3791406750679016,
-0.5614992380142212,
0.5792402029037476,
0.0025438754819333553,
0.26252639293670654,
-0.08889256417751312,
-0.18069840967655182,
-0.8648012280464172,
0.0032629251945763826,
0.023429084569215775,
0.5145548582077026,
-0.6075069308280945,
0.3739713132381439,
-0.5305339097976685,
-0.6934191584587097,
0.08690584450960159,
0.6069610714912415,
0.1152566522359848,
0.27787718176841736,
0.27422207593917847,
-0.17125380039215088,
-0.5567859411239624,
-0.45072755217552185,
-0.06276889890432358,
-0.06195785850286484,
0.12493332475423813,
0.3857950270175934,
0.8629863858222961,
-0.6387613415718079,
0.7784941792488098,
-0.32713717222213745,
-0.11242015659809113,
-0.4367983341217041,
-0.19828757643699646,
0.09577320516109467,
0.34171977639198303,
0.20348922908306122,
-0.6627260446548462,
-0.5687733888626099,
0.057968925684690475,
-0.7925440669059753,
0.4266989231109619,
-0.3420177698135376,
0.1807607263326645,
0.35405421257019043,
0.6308401823043823,
-0.2530268132686615,
-0.03733471781015396,
0.442694753408432,
-0.06466245651245117,
0.7786847352981567,
-0.28065940737724304,
-0.27315157651901245,
-0.7938933372497559,
0.13558202981948853,
-0.05625414103269577,
-0.21887817978858948,
-0.5071460008621216,
0.06956169754266739,
-0.019911248236894608,
0.14412125945091248,
-0.33133870363235474,
1.0411760807037354,
-0.6015687584877014,
0.12833185493946075,
-0.08863227069377899,
0.020690569654107094,
-0.6220371723175049,
0.23564228415489197,
0.14894211292266846,
0.6999977231025696,
0.5766967535018921,
-0.8094800710678101,
0.48601117730140686,
0.024490756914019585,
-0.3514502942562103,
0.4164937436580658,
-0.33979344367980957,
0.05951236933469772,
-0.18699121475219727,
0.5107454061508179,
-0.8507283329963684,
-0.14102137088775635,
0.24221663177013397,
-0.14735379815101624,
0.3093615472316742,
0.010262072086334229,
-0.6328457593917847,
-0.3393174409866333,
-0.1345648318529129,
0.20170417428016663,
0.6140413284301758,
-0.5065471529960632,
0.6822154521942139,
0.3657871186733246,
-0.43065404891967773,
-0.42454758286476135,
-0.3690505027770996,
0.09381186962127686,
-0.544753909111023,
-0.276169091463089,
0.06534483283758163,
-0.3991474509239197,
-0.2718442976474762,
-0.1917257457971573,
-0.09784364700317383,
0.08441072702407837,
0.11620843410491943,
0.19600573182106018,
0.3437540531158447,
-0.10761882364749908,
0.4863816201686859,
-0.30200669169425964,
0.034265317022800446,
-0.075940802693367,
-0.5694738626480103,
0.6496052742004395,
-0.10119571536779404,
-0.24764330685138702,
0.12177054584026337,
0.22554028034210205,
0.5057604908943176,
-0.05614710971713066,
1.080532431602478,
0.5404319763183594,
-0.2413911372423172,
-0.3505230247974396,
-0.7959091663360596,
-0.028175633400678635,
-0.43702593445777893,
0.273752361536026,
-0.1725425124168396,
-1.2843983173370361,
0.5241089463233948,
-0.47179922461509705,
0.3194502294063568,
0.40421968698501587,
0.7247093915939331,
-0.20432224869728088,
0.41577282547950745,
0.9076444506645203,
-0.33751150965690613,
0.5779045224189758,
-0.17687612771987915,
-0.1201595813035965,
-0.8956794738769531,
-0.36316683888435364,
-0.1309015452861786,
0.002185636665672064,
-0.2873010039329529,
-0.16009347140789032,
0.4016874432563782,
0.011678271926939487,
-0.3507179319858551,
0.049616601318120956,
-0.14104712009429932,
0.17647656798362732,
0.16652290523052216,
0.19277916848659515,
0.2040010392665863,
-0.16503331065177917,
-0.0544620081782341,
0.10059501975774765,
-0.6774097681045532,
-0.2938367426395416,
1.3014509677886963,
0.5388161540031433,
0.7262588739395142,
0.21960076689720154,
0.6156958937644958,
0.2786145806312561,
0.7242666482925415,
-0.7153981924057007,
0.4521193504333496,
-0.04406207054853439,
-0.5305250883102417,
-0.42935115098953247,
-0.5502340197563171,
-0.9959700703620911,
-0.11844785511493683,
-0.006953798234462738,
-0.694873571395874,
-0.15409331023693085,
0.17550984025001526,
-0.21387305855751038,
0.41545385122299194,
-0.18416914343833923,
0.5887005925178528,
-0.6456623673439026,
-0.5285336375236511,
-0.3198373019695282,
-0.6020905375480652,
0.37588217854499817,
-0.6109768152236938,
0.31759023666381836,
0.13779155910015106,
-0.23137161135673523,
0.8058738708496094,
0.09571921825408936,
1.070651650428772,
-0.18317341804504395,
-0.35678401589393616,
0.3072448968887329,
-0.06178344041109085,
0.5151644945144653,
0.043527308851480484,
0.04175923764705658,
0.13169386982917786,
0.0243267510086298,
-0.26716098189353943,
-0.2567843794822693,
0.7184173464775085,
-0.5927528142929077,
-0.3169284462928772,
-0.43763822317123413,
-0.444968044757843,
-0.6561242938041687,
0.08560332655906677,
0.08885243535041809,
0.3916622996330261,
-0.3319963812828064,
0.5770847201347351,
1.0444538593292236,
-0.31418582797050476,
0.2988153100013733,
0.6327069997787476,
-0.3322788178920746,
-0.31661248207092285,
1.0712831020355225,
0.4623492360115051,
0.5331500768661499,
0.47952812910079956,
0.17508955299854279,
-0.5415416955947876,
-0.7182771563529968,
0.04932432621717453,
0.43917733430862427,
-0.965335488319397,
0.13968192040920258,
-0.5802120566368103,
-0.32923826575279236,
-0.2677116096019745,
-0.18240022659301758,
-0.1444823443889618,
0.029568273574113846,
-0.46202850341796875,
0.008904790505766869,
0.2374967634677887,
0.727164089679718,
-0.06276033073663712,
0.2743052840232849,
-0.8796004056930542,
0.20980176329612732,
0.3862634599208832,
0.4069720208644867,
0.15428683161735535,
-0.7161467671394348,
-0.3671562075614929,
-0.08078017085790634,
-0.1846562922000885,
-0.5513780117034912,
0.26614242792129517,
0.5170291662216187,
0.8402155637741089,
0.1793857365846634,
-0.21863588690757751,
0.6095237731933594,
-0.5739511847496033,
0.8610817193984985,
0.21423256397247314,
-0.49259886145591736,
0.24564707279205322,
-0.46071910858154297,
0.4016297459602356,
0.6241276264190674,
0.9148346185684204,
-0.8855273127555847,
-0.1125924214720726,
-0.4089582860469818,
-0.9645752906799316,
0.009442931041121483,
-0.4565345346927643,
0.2882055640220642,
0.13122980296611786,
0.5589467287063599,
0.33883941173553467,
0.03590595722198486,
-0.9279562830924988,
-0.12337929010391235,
0.3308866024017334,
-0.23348841071128845,
-0.2704099416732788,
-0.2771538197994232,
0.040861353278160095,
-0.25720682740211487,
0.8057826161384583,
-0.2292720377445221,
0.17518088221549988,
-0.3038364350795746,
-0.4100143313407898,
0.20714649558067322,
0.1960902214050293,
0.4658204913139343,
1.0340070724487305,
-0.06112971156835556,
-0.09870634227991104,
0.6218858957290649,
-0.4051893353462219,
0.3292270302772522,
-0.4462355971336365,
0.009167256765067577,
-0.20474061369895935,
0.47965899109840393,
0.5127531290054321,
0.45094043016433716,
-0.897131085395813,
0.1422983556985855,
0.13416945934295654,
-0.03838369995355606,
-0.9882646799087524,
0.2319020926952362,
0.17365041375160217,
-0.05302973836660385,
0.3624782860279083,
-0.05123988538980484,
-0.2183721363544464,
-0.7365645170211792,
0.38641825318336487,
0.5220370292663574,
-0.48355498909950256,
-0.09342555701732635,
0.316964328289032,
0.07315811514854431,
-0.10473953187465668,
0.65988689661026,
-0.015529694966971874,
-0.23193864524364471,
0.23216204345226288,
0.5827292203903198,
0.61761873960495,
-0.22736720740795135,
-0.07069163024425507,
0.46702033281326294,
0.19005373120307922,
-0.3733447790145874,
-0.03042479231953621,
-0.16972734034061432,
-0.670886754989624,
-0.2912902534008026,
-0.8027218580245972,
-0.46986904740333557,
0.3530837297439575,
-0.4903836250305176,
0.0329105444252491,
-0.44732770323753357,
0.09510282427072525,
-0.49697962403297424,
-0.050002336502075195,
-0.64990234375,
0.3294532299041748,
0.1917959749698639,
1.0579633712768555,
-0.7476118206977844,
1.048490285873413,
0.3771969676017761,
-0.3954375684261322,
-0.2508314847946167,
-0.06892508268356323,
0.09897951781749725,
-0.5993043780326843,
0.7656923532485962,
0.051324766129255295,
-0.15010032057762146,
0.16143158078193665,
-0.5779389142990112,
-0.8219599723815918,
1.0120322704315186,
0.058166373521089554,
-0.7370178699493408,
-0.25462356209754944,
-0.05279541015625,
0.39874428510665894,
-0.2951917052268982,
0.08047337830066681,
0.5219842791557312,
0.33337515592575073,
0.05223361402750015,
-0.7613946199417114,
-0.32804158329963684,
-0.13166619837284088,
0.02412487007677555,
0.04193035885691643,
-0.6720575094223022,
0.44147127866744995,
0.1639174520969391,
-0.10675305128097534,
0.21241655945777893,
0.6325384378433228,
0.3094184398651123,
0.11040253937244415,
0.5442469716072083,
0.3083769679069519,
0.603430449962616,
-0.0454806350171566,
0.7304008603096008,
-0.38900527358055115,
0.4043123722076416,
1.1263421773910522,
-0.31279078125953674,
0.9543988108634949,
0.24599584937095642,
-0.21081344783306122,
0.47641921043395996,
0.8674825429916382,
-0.13123635947704315,
0.2776956856250763,
0.2703024446964264,
-0.5922452211380005,
-0.33443862199783325,
0.03563106060028076,
-0.42624005675315857,
0.21555013954639435,
0.7152851223945618,
-0.06374932825565338,
-0.030776267871260643,
0.4476245045661926,
-0.0662638247013092,
-0.11437156051397324,
-0.4198160171508789,
0.8849751353263855,
0.19165419042110443,
-0.6340014338493347,
0.34791427850723267,
-0.1896742731332779,
1.0400549173355103,
-1.1564557552337646,
0.07921487092971802,
-0.1907983124256134,
0.12450629472732544,
-0.00931693334132433,
-0.7232488393783569,
0.34231218695640564,
-0.1921919286251068,
0.05495408922433853,
-0.3853854537010193,
0.573106050491333,
-0.42298346757888794,
-0.3824581205844879,
0.31055527925491333,
0.3498978614807129,
-0.005633024964481592,
0.27400991320610046,
-0.7633639574050903,
0.22231841087341309,
-0.21711388230323792,
-0.13121727108955383,
0.5719007253646851,
0.06265796720981598,
-0.008617417886853218,
1.1940240859985352,
0.6540657877922058,
0.32730284333229065,
0.18018881976604462,
-0.13472919166088104,
0.7417253255844116,
-0.6161543726921082,
-0.2970731854438782,
-0.7793691754341125,
0.5436620712280273,
0.11085822433233261,
-0.4137580394744873,
0.9828302264213562,
0.5320210456848145,
0.9683114886283875,
-0.1608184576034546,
0.8711201548576355,
0.23217642307281494,
0.4163385033607483,
-0.7493278384208679,
0.6146903038024902,
-0.5379117131233215,
0.1671203374862671,
0.018284862861037254,
-0.9187750816345215,
-0.34881290793418884,
0.3371526598930359,
-0.5954092144966125,
0.1782396286725998,
0.5158017873764038,
0.46322697401046753,
0.0810743123292923,
-0.27867817878723145,
0.3495468199253082,
0.18795037269592285,
0.3196255564689636,
0.5845321416854858,
1.0850472450256348,
0.22633862495422363,
0.11734850704669952,
0.096751868724823,
-0.07285003364086151,
-0.23975953459739685,
-0.6728259325027466,
-0.7013640999794006,
-0.7482656240463257,
-0.3072592318058014,
-0.06015460565686226,
0.1941574513912201,
0.9334907531738281,
0.6464412212371826,
-0.6420527696609497,
-0.3660173714160919,
-0.18061566352844238,
-0.07894700020551682,
-0.05343850702047348,
-0.18506839871406555,
0.13614773750305176,
-0.4949727952480316,
-0.3554418683052063,
0.5065452456474304,
0.323449045419693,
-0.14450779557228088,
-0.680465817451477,
-0.23245811462402344,
-0.3439931273460388,
-0.06977278739213943,
0.8032562136650085,
0.7156385779380798,
-0.6596853733062744,
-0.42285704612731934,
-0.07792145013809204,
0.13890564441680908,
-0.054818522185087204,
0.6848440170288086,
-0.7372280359268188,
0.518201470375061,
0.25703004002571106,
0.8831596374511719,
0.4195612370967865,
-0.4024197459220886,
0.31814074516296387,
-0.5037046670913696,
-0.031277239322662354,
0.3746603727340698,
0.2954396605491638,
0.25646454095840454,
-0.359485387802124,
0.43022769689559937,
0.33732539415359497,
-0.8286765217781067,
-0.7242252230644226,
0.36490368843078613,
-0.7504093050956726,
-0.37501949071884155,
1.219104290008545,
-0.2457699328660965,
0.11283504962921143,
-0.4179054796695709,
-0.017607862129807472,
0.01964077353477478,
0.08302232623100281,
0.5842235684394836,
0.6929144263267517,
-0.16678141057491302,
-0.3431711196899414,
-0.8009665608406067,
0.23729316890239716,
0.018588576465845108,
-0.9955198168754578,
-0.013631912879645824,
0.6081842184066772,
0.741317629814148,
-0.16918785870075226,
0.6805523633956909,
-0.037943847477436066,
0.09314902871847153,
-0.260188490152359,
-0.1962040215730667,
0.2136179655790329,
-0.6057696342468262,
-0.6350212693214417,
0.23302188515663147,
0.38902121782302856,
0.37799620628356934
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.06385v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.06385v2
|
Low-Rank Quantization-Aware Training for LLMs
| 2024-06-10T15:44:22 | 2024-06-20T15:18:50 |
Yelysei Bondarenko, Riccardo Del Chiaro, Markus Nagel
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) are omnipresent, however their practical
deployment is challenging due to their ever increasing computational and memory
demands. Quantization is one of the most effective ways to make them more
compute and memory efficient. Quantization-aware training (QAT) methods,
generally produce the best quantized performance, however it comes at the cost
of potentially long training time and excessive memory usage, making it
impractical when applying for LLMs. Inspired by parameter-efficient fine-tuning
(PEFT) and low-rank adaptation (LoRA) literature, we propose LR-QAT -- a
lightweight and memory-efficient QAT algorithm for LLMs. LR-QAT employs several
components to save memory without sacrificing predictive performance: (a)
low-rank auxiliary weights that are aware of the quantization grid; (b) a
downcasting operator using fixed-point or double-packed integers and (c)
checkpointing. Unlike most related work, our method (i) is inference-efficient,
leading to no additional overhead compared to traditional PTQ; (ii) can be seen
as a general extended pretraining framework, meaning that the resulting model
can still be utilized for any downstream task afterwards; (iii) can be applied
across a wide range of quantization settings, such as different choices
quantization granularity, activation quantization, and seamlessly combined with
many PTQ techniques. We apply LR-QAT to LLaMA-2/3 and Mistral model families
and validate its effectiveness on several downstream tasks. Our method
outperforms common post-training quantization (PTQ) approaches and reaches the
same model performance as full-model QAT at the fraction of its memory usage.
Specifically, we can train a 7B LLM on a single consumer grade GPU with 24GB of
memory.
|
[
-0.1391964554786682,
-0.6086132526397705,
0.5848469734191895,
0.10065005719661713,
-0.47622770071029663,
0.2636529505252838,
-0.22293992340564728,
-0.167420893907547,
-0.09659074246883392,
0.3083058297634125,
-0.240072101354599,
-0.42442968487739563,
-0.47335734963417053,
-0.15122854709625244,
-0.28213900327682495,
0.739675760269165,
-0.022335337474942207,
0.0461389422416687,
0.02240007184445858,
-0.19485490024089813,
-0.30418384075164795,
-0.6900297999382019,
-0.9261125326156616,
-0.15549901127815247,
0.706048846244812,
0.2607368528842926,
0.5965264439582825,
0.641132116317749,
0.2716986835002899,
0.20282545685768127,
-0.24807101488113403,
0.01659628376364708,
-0.7685685157775879,
-0.04079980030655861,
0.1974506974220276,
-0.6049749851226807,
-0.676612377166748,
-0.2678025960922241,
0.8211410045623779,
0.30084970593452454,
-0.2517000734806061,
0.30283883213996887,
-0.032125603407621384,
0.8654527068138123,
-0.8672143816947937,
-0.12859994173049927,
-0.7406366467475891,
0.11684951931238174,
-0.21525056660175323,
-0.16561394929885864,
-0.29090258479118347,
-0.36234498023986816,
-0.15419326722621918,
-0.6187140345573425,
-0.10999248176813126,
0.0765521302819252,
0.4815710186958313,
0.5884518027305603,
-0.3782033920288086,
0.18705284595489502,
-0.7416629791259766,
0.8900979161262512,
-0.7041296362876892,
0.615425705909729,
0.4666600823402405,
0.28737539052963257,
0.06509678065776825,
-0.5824382305145264,
-0.3162905275821686,
-0.1373969167470932,
0.2337527871131897,
0.19854797422885895,
-0.07737459987401962,
0.29085466265678406,
0.32709914445877075,
0.49420055747032166,
-0.7339935898780823,
0.23490388691425323,
-0.10417111217975616,
0.01756446622312069,
0.15181273221969604,
0.05704805254936218,
-0.067631296813488,
0.07282739877700806,
-0.38711729645729065,
0.06663591414690018,
-0.9185460209846497,
0.12909358739852905,
-0.08550039678812027,
0.18685172498226166,
-0.08304210007190704,
0.3544299304485321,
-0.48287269473075867,
0.5516844391822815,
0.10783503204584122,
-0.37021932005882263,
-0.1359829306602478,
-0.12329932302236557,
-0.25548818707466125,
0.1358012855052948,
0.5993711948394775,
-0.07415489107370377,
0.12749917805194855,
-0.13857759535312653,
-0.40895166993141174,
0.05277096480131149,
-0.030107125639915466,
-1.1672776937484741,
-0.29547402262687683,
0.1231275200843811,
-0.38411611318588257,
-0.08851504325866699,
-0.47948765754699707,
-0.3169686198234558,
-0.2831145226955414,
-0.14350472390651703,
0.7354259490966797,
-0.5298724174499512,
0.05251582711935043,
0.04903702810406685,
0.3368968367576599,
0.36977049708366394,
0.49021005630493164,
-0.7190276980400085,
0.2985183894634247,
0.7038958668708801,
0.8222283124923706,
-0.09216678887605667,
-0.10527770966291428,
-1.0031654834747314,
0.2392488270998001,
-0.14037419855594635,
0.7120307087898254,
-0.2837054431438446,
-0.1884944885969162,
-0.27323758602142334,
-0.3333073854446411,
-0.06497931480407715,
-0.5819882750511169,
0.29123952984809875,
-0.6729520559310913,
-0.1656360626220703,
-0.138424813747406,
-0.4828656315803528,
0.01122425589710474,
0.21778346598148346,
-0.5995385050773621,
1.2075318098068237,
0.16966494917869568,
-0.5514044165611267,
0.2960890829563141,
-0.2762840986251831,
-0.14117226004600525,
0.08473479747772217,
-0.05012519657611847,
-0.6939001083374023,
0.2965186834335327,
0.2867882251739502,
0.3534873127937317,
-0.3407585322856903,
0.03146921470761299,
-0.19817954301834106,
-0.8143922686576843,
0.20237314701080322,
-0.27974754571914673,
0.2657056450843811,
0.15328490734100342,
-0.14016976952552795,
0.07772769778966904,
-0.6729947924613953,
0.13417206704616547,
0.1411920040845871,
-0.5638281106948853,
-0.3515509366989136,
-0.01369137316942215,
-0.23113703727722168,
-0.03706982731819153,
0.44637805223464966,
-0.27989092469215393,
0.2584805190563202,
-0.3289545774459839,
0.45229312777519226,
0.687573254108429,
-0.06744115799665451,
0.43335360288619995,
-0.33063000440597534,
0.5512548685073853,
-0.009910560213029385,
0.2556741237640381,
0.06109682470560074,
-0.1038934513926506,
-0.9849971532821655,
-0.6400629878044128,
0.5144811272621155,
0.5356247425079346,
-0.8667752742767334,
0.3000248074531555,
-0.4325738251209259,
-0.36776024103164673,
-0.3651334047317505,
0.26166895031929016,
0.4772534966468811,
0.09265529364347458,
0.2530137002468109,
0.007252334151417017,
-0.45661646127700806,
-0.645245373249054,
-0.25278887152671814,
-0.11884810030460358,
0.1060904860496521,
-0.06646749377250671,
0.3753657341003418,
-0.14078852534294128,
0.765582263469696,
-0.3732133209705353,
-0.2686096429824829,
-0.24935652315616608,
0.045207832008600235,
0.21631799638271332,
0.47400689125061035,
0.23707903921604156,
-0.4630544185638428,
-0.5915321111679077,
-0.09202705323696136,
-0.432478129863739,
0.04134805127978325,
-0.031241975724697113,
-0.17250683903694153,
0.17434699833393097,
0.47392645478248596,
-0.5587490797042847,
0.2225211262702942,
0.6155090928077698,
-0.02948114462196827,
0.2265855073928833,
-0.18955069780349731,
-0.05849503353238106,
-0.9461274743080139,
-0.0636480376124382,
-0.21111871302127838,
-0.5632790923118591,
-0.4979834258556366,
-0.08145884424448013,
0.07999316602945328,
-0.18830014765262604,
-0.4550555348396301,
0.670936644077301,
-0.43877464532852173,
-0.13572975993156433,
-0.31126704812049866,
-0.09689801186323166,
-0.0325777605175972,
0.692626416683197,
0.04418002814054489,
0.9955177903175354,
0.4020981788635254,
-0.5210232734680176,
-0.09329050779342651,
0.028956210240721703,
-0.30499446392059326,
0.523463249206543,
-0.49824273586273193,
0.2836426794528961,
-0.11657200008630753,
0.22425034642219543,
-0.7224229574203491,
0.19586074352264404,
0.12871164083480835,
-0.17825958132743835,
0.0851408913731575,
-0.3991265594959259,
-0.7659360766410828,
0.050325602293014526,
-0.41960445046424866,
0.7590395212173462,
0.8876354694366455,
-0.5857424736022949,
0.6822943091392517,
0.18303819000720978,
-0.06295280158519745,
-0.38622552156448364,
-0.35770726203918457,
-0.20010636746883392,
-0.5177249908447266,
-0.07034673541784286,
0.28986573219299316,
-0.0024587069638073444,
0.05363362282514572,
-0.23498742282390594,
-0.3988370895385742,
-0.17978137731552124,
0.2704414129257202,
0.24674063920974731,
-0.11079058051109314,
-0.229180246591568,
0.21839642524719238,
0.03664971888065338,
-0.24932698905467987,
-0.3821173310279846,
-0.23889486491680145,
0.5779125094413757,
-0.37887945771217346,
-0.31292960047721863,
-0.5216909646987915,
0.085441455245018,
0.3936678469181061,
-0.41937345266342163,
0.6452550888061523,
0.7793576121330261,
-0.43498387932777405,
-0.31356850266456604,
-0.5850780010223389,
-0.03893681615591049,
-0.4628671407699585,
0.4749092161655426,
-0.34037020802497864,
-1.1312341690063477,
0.3955440819263458,
-0.37408146262168884,
-0.16164815425872803,
0.07508812099695206,
0.4809887111186981,
-0.18589717149734497,
1.0157735347747803,
0.5517040491104126,
-0.21634730696678162,
0.716269314289093,
-0.3581640422344208,
0.2252597212791443,
-0.862066388130188,
0.2317872792482376,
-0.32553043961524963,
-0.34244322776794434,
-0.37284672260284424,
-0.663882315158844,
0.5939972996711731,
0.5341260433197021,
-0.5747038125991821,
0.02291213907301426,
-0.34769755601882935,
0.4848056137561798,
0.4544456899166107,
0.19491265714168549,
0.5061158537864685,
0.09921936690807343,
0.3347587585449219,
-0.005464695394039154,
-0.8402799367904663,
-0.23359759151935577,
1.1004862785339355,
0.38356757164001465,
0.9451632499694824,
0.034725483506917953,
0.9415311217308044,
0.2085050791501999,
0.2896241545677185,
-0.9660550951957703,
0.6030295491218567,
-0.32952141761779785,
0.011920561082661152,
-0.3951393961906433,
-0.588957667350769,
-0.8248906135559082,
0.3524366319179535,
-0.14805220067501068,
-0.5779001712799072,
-0.01949424296617508,
0.34610384702682495,
-0.6734217405319214,
0.3267402946949005,
-0.5137909054756165,
0.6423055529594421,
-0.5113365054130554,
-0.2901613116264343,
-0.41035589575767517,
-0.3040809631347656,
0.40145593881607056,
-0.37337395548820496,
0.12514223158359528,
-0.24161049723625183,
-0.20576691627502441,
0.907175600528717,
-0.46249812841415405,
0.7586697340011597,
-0.2962792217731476,
-0.1437583863735199,
0.20978398621082306,
-0.005695607513189316,
0.7039918303489685,
0.06758150458335876,
0.008759264834225178,
0.04056357219815254,
0.29357632994651794,
-0.49544379115104675,
-0.6012849807739258,
0.6499042510986328,
-0.9472224116325378,
-0.3855994939804077,
-0.40101802349090576,
-0.5064120292663574,
-0.3834221661090851,
0.05861377343535423,
-0.03307666257023811,
0.22953259944915771,
-0.09688784927129745,
0.15233439207077026,
0.8818361163139343,
-0.24593400955200195,
0.15916307270526886,
0.4211288392543793,
-0.30696895718574524,
-0.5882264971733093,
1.1009784936904907,
0.0699334591627121,
0.29186519980430603,
0.7461792826652527,
0.2629959285259247,
-0.14615043997764587,
-0.8212998509407043,
-0.17542672157287598,
0.3340575098991394,
-0.4678444564342499,
-0.46283388137817383,
-0.44008156657218933,
-0.30146121978759766,
0.12377800047397614,
-0.08427846431732178,
-0.6460415720939636,
-0.5219951272010803,
-0.13255774974822998,
0.2226639986038208,
0.5798048377037048,
0.20227152109146118,
0.11271505057811737,
0.9444953799247742,
-0.7706999778747559,
0.6558171510696411,
0.6007266044616699,
0.2581155002117157,
0.06827191263437271,
-0.6420854330062866,
-0.587000846862793,
0.04053320363163948,
-0.24142354726791382,
-0.32647863030433655,
0.18228530883789062,
0.45339542627334595,
0.2444051057100296,
0.31635937094688416,
0.028652368113398552,
0.8952703475952148,
-0.3795677423477173,
0.47381067276000977,
0.0303034670650959,
-0.9873231053352356,
0.4111595153808594,
-0.2913057506084442,
0.3696434795856476,
0.7640306949615479,
0.11846422404050827,
-0.2512171268463135,
-0.2175430804491043,
-0.23822520673274994,
-0.7644334435462952,
0.4384002685546875,
0.0481291338801384,
-0.16562685370445251,
0.2039768248796463,
0.5435342788696289,
-0.027780557051301003,
0.2163156121969223,
-0.8961817622184753,
-0.01069632638245821,
-0.03641599416732788,
-0.10740061104297638,
-0.07231798768043518,
-0.40232908725738525,
0.09079905599355698,
-0.3453584313392639,
0.6135233640670776,
-0.27626875042915344,
0.2651142179965973,
-0.06237083673477173,
-0.4304686188697815,
-0.07223155349493027,
0.38715389370918274,
0.4048853814601898,
0.511640191078186,
-0.4870873689651489,
0.1957857459783554,
0.37021222710609436,
-0.3669741153717041,
0.36685627698898315,
-0.04028429463505745,
-0.16036851704120636,
-0.22504642605781555,
0.04865737631917,
0.8345455527305603,
0.47500449419021606,
-0.7602866291999817,
0.46908485889434814,
-0.11560389399528503,
-0.11750347167253494,
-0.4101369380950928,
0.03329990804195404,
0.16172239184379578,
0.4961383640766144,
0.32206717133522034,
-0.2688533663749695,
-0.0858740583062172,
-0.33938461542129517,
-0.061422329396009445,
0.5210790634155273,
-0.19406849145889282,
-0.3125763535499573,
0.6244682669639587,
-0.012551738880574703,
0.03195755183696747,
0.37902432680130005,
-0.23695512115955353,
-0.47928497195243835,
0.3124335706233978,
0.336598664522171,
0.8185224533081055,
-0.13050100207328796,
0.00931360013782978,
0.23816952109336853,
0.1298973113298416,
-0.3738742470741272,
0.40302902460098267,
-0.1622399240732193,
-0.4963128864765167,
-0.6381986737251282,
-0.9120580554008484,
-0.39189571142196655,
0.2783377766609192,
-0.5093688368797302,
0.1516522616147995,
-0.670799195766449,
-0.2468561977148056,
-0.5530788898468018,
0.06030949577689171,
-0.5494846105575562,
0.1433432251214981,
0.35588839650154114,
0.6812340021133423,
-0.5997974276542664,
1.1975376605987549,
0.5308346748352051,
-0.052150409668684006,
-0.6588925123214722,
-0.01789756305515766,
-0.39345934987068176,
-1.0092799663543701,
0.7055615782737732,
0.0275154709815979,
-0.2276933491230011,
0.4134519100189209,
-0.36816146969795227,
-1.0021004676818848,
1.361718773841858,
0.4129190742969513,
-0.6611539721488953,
-0.18757006525993347,
0.16478990018367767,
0.3400975167751312,
-0.02211826667189598,
0.06476222723722458,
0.5429275035858154,
0.23878580331802368,
0.006718796212226152,
-0.8308120369911194,
0.09780707955360413,
0.06840963661670685,
0.33960649371147156,
0.3423703908920288,
-0.8853734731674194,
1.0163731575012207,
0.06729748845100403,
-0.16198477149009705,
0.4550963044166565,
0.7183635234832764,
0.7480825781822205,
0.07097258418798447,
0.5579150915145874,
0.8082125782966614,
0.6745927333831787,
0.0630517303943634,
0.7654924392700195,
-0.440896213054657,
0.35204172134399414,
0.9677395820617676,
-0.35341784358024597,
1.0608199834823608,
0.5999435782432556,
-0.29109105467796326,
0.21095949411392212,
0.5177878737449646,
0.20823895931243896,
0.690311849117279,
0.3637675642967224,
-0.36325979232788086,
-0.5236876010894775,
-0.04966037720441818,
-0.3901855945587158,
0.3868476152420044,
0.29490217566490173,
0.0455562099814415,
-0.31342121958732605,
-0.002762480638921261,
-0.06489983946084976,
-0.3097318708896637,
-0.6709402203559875,
0.7680948376655579,
0.4456222951412201,
-0.2623249888420105,
1.1329680681228638,
0.001019813003949821,
0.7776627540588379,
-0.6926261782646179,
0.10147307068109512,
-0.2840457260608673,
0.3151177167892456,
0.024518784135580063,
-0.08398228138685226,
-0.1231076717376709,
0.017164692282676697,
-0.05524509400129318,
-0.30592525005340576,
0.5100187659263611,
-0.3002907633781433,
-0.49382898211479187,
0.05489319935441017,
0.8142821788787842,
0.05541270226240158,
-0.3981873095035553,
-0.5152879953384399,
0.16264796257019043,
-0.2431243509054184,
-0.25556549429893494,
0.9445430040359497,
0.4197264611721039,
-0.23592199385166168,
0.8006564378738403,
0.45954954624176025,
0.2374885529279709,
0.1543542444705963,
0.0858289897441864,
0.8251091837882996,
-0.793867826461792,
-0.5395128726959229,
-0.6869279742240906,
0.3226328492164612,
0.48085907101631165,
0.06591770052909851,
0.43256649374961853,
0.7251744270324707,
0.5512441396713257,
0.08926383405923843,
0.7313268184661865,
0.38901081681251526,
0.5224782824516296,
-0.8645222187042236,
0.6095476746559143,
-0.6573444604873657,
0.354849249124527,
0.07957737892866135,
-1.0042871236801147,
-0.1732628345489502,
0.620320200920105,
-0.4044765532016754,
0.12900882959365845,
0.6310151815414429,
0.569109320640564,
-0.0731310024857521,
-0.38328781723976135,
0.4994334876537323,
0.11020262539386749,
0.11711670458316803,
0.9953064322471619,
1.2300758361816406,
-0.45935216546058655,
0.5336132645606995,
-0.2756374478340149,
-0.14409036934375763,
-0.32106471061706543,
-0.7828022241592407,
-0.9185689687728882,
-0.23431263864040375,
-0.41041287779808044,
0.008760943077504635,
0.2767862379550934,
0.7325395345687866,
0.6925495862960815,
-0.5585335493087769,
-0.3260270953178406,
0.0040620057843625546,
-0.013650134205818176,
-0.1758100986480713,
-0.13495072722434998,
0.5414671301841736,
-0.17871710658073425,
-0.510181188583374,
0.35463449358940125,
0.20662154257297516,
0.15482556819915771,
-0.20147791504859924,
-0.1947961151599884,
0.07394605129957199,
-0.12401988357305527,
0.7766927480697632,
0.3367086350917816,
-0.6344228982925415,
-0.24132035672664642,
-0.152922585606575,
-0.12167417258024216,
0.23083896934986115,
0.7426443099975586,
-1.001394271850586,
-0.07384392619132996,
0.3297853469848633,
0.7317497134208679,
0.6752398610115051,
0.23010499775409698,
0.26696857810020447,
-0.6420698761940002,
0.3234919607639313,
0.2790038585662842,
0.23243451118469238,
0.15378142893314362,
-0.24036483466625214,
0.2862052917480469,
0.053101323544979095,
-0.6034695506095886,
-0.9498977065086365,
0.14671427011489868,
-1.2412534952163696,
-0.16787715256214142,
1.0301189422607422,
0.04748103767633438,
-0.2033536732196808,
0.23353272676467896,
-0.1168656200170517,
0.19252735376358032,
-0.49074628949165344,
0.6647856831550598,
0.13779674470424652,
-0.1376410275697708,
-0.5952879786491394,
-0.6087554097175598,
0.5461169481277466,
0.6445598006248474,
-0.8372783064842224,
0.006217201240360737,
0.23819224536418915,
0.25524353981018066,
-0.3221234381198883,
0.8751726150512695,
0.17957624793052673,
0.23073098063468933,
-0.2857220470905304,
0.16879774630069733,
-0.07019801437854767,
-0.08974742889404297,
-0.47206056118011475,
-0.0024133885744959116,
0.6667202711105347,
-0.16070696711540222
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.06382v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.06382v1
|
Diffusion-RPO: Aligning Diffusion Models through Relative Preference Optimization
| 2024-06-10T15:42:03 | 2024-06-10T15:42:03 |
Yi Gu, Zhendong Wang, Yueqin Yin, Yujia Xie, Mingyuan Zhou
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Aligning large language models with human preferences has emerged as a
critical focus in language modeling research. Yet, integrating preference
learning into Text-to-Image (T2I) generative models is still relatively
uncharted territory. The Diffusion-DPO technique made initial strides by
employing pairwise preference learning in diffusion models tailored for
specific text prompts. We introduce Diffusion-RPO, a new method designed to
align diffusion-based T2I models with human preferences more effectively. This
approach leverages both prompt-image pairs with identical prompts and those
with semantically related content across various modalities. Furthermore, we
have developed a new evaluation metric, style alignment, aimed at overcoming
the challenges of high costs, low reproducibility, and limited interpretability
prevalent in current evaluations of human preference alignment. Our findings
demonstrate that Diffusion-RPO outperforms established methods such as
Supervised Fine-Tuning and Diffusion-DPO in tuning Stable Diffusion versions
1.5 and XL-1.0, achieving superior results in both automated evaluations of
human preferences and style alignment. Our code is available at
https://github.com/yigu1008/Diffusion-RPO
|
[
-0.2969135344028473,
-0.5977519750595093,
0.6857285499572754,
0.2415689378976822,
-0.21299447119235992,
-0.05762188136577606,
-0.42906472086906433,
-0.1213134303689003,
0.1557742804288864,
0.34216025471687317,
-0.4111684560775757,
-0.48049086332321167,
-0.6774822473526001,
-0.10251910239458084,
0.06539406627416611,
0.5910205245018005,
-0.08441329747438431,
0.03693980351090431,
-0.40809038281440735,
-0.10587763786315918,
-0.4703139066696167,
0.07276696711778641,
-0.8659879565238953,
-0.6148239970207214,
0.6219480037689209,
0.6253700256347656,
0.6983411312103271,
0.6862912178039551,
0.12162599712610245,
0.1896003782749176,
0.111970916390419,
0.3162299394607544,
-0.35364091396331787,
0.32186174392700195,
-0.24860499799251556,
-0.262955904006958,
-0.5135478377342224,
0.011433335952460766,
0.658647358417511,
0.4502074420452118,
-0.20394212007522583,
-0.16447021067142487,
0.04991595074534416,
1.1850605010986328,
-0.684036374092102,
-0.44370192289352417,
-0.2835845649242401,
0.2398366928100586,
0.057838402688503265,
-0.2989743947982788,
-0.7392938733100891,
-0.5336856245994568,
0.4922517240047455,
-0.7029367089271545,
0.23058876395225525,
0.26182353496551514,
0.82488614320755,
0.31553348898887634,
-0.46982407569885254,
-0.1115560531616211,
-0.4451333284378052,
1.0775132179260254,
-0.2909110486507416,
0.4780363142490387,
0.30473995208740234,
0.03219980001449585,
-0.0660337433218956,
-0.3329208195209503,
-0.43753960728645325,
-0.03283008560538292,
-0.08249680697917938,
0.215541809797287,
-0.18375740945339203,
-0.1337747424840927,
-0.3524680733680725,
-0.06955982744693756,
-0.6451956629753113,
0.23478299379348755,
0.06178247556090355,
-0.04691270738840103,
0.60488361120224,
-0.11661306768655777,
0.42375800013542175,
-0.022384800016880035,
-0.42529162764549255,
-0.03329889103770256,
-0.4047292172908783,
-0.173619344830513,
0.6072556972503662,
0.2115628719329834,
-0.34830790758132935,
0.4392665922641754,
-0.06125028431415558,
0.9440978765487671,
0.44781920313835144,
-0.37397658824920654,
0.39214661717414856,
-0.13680621981620789,
0.025267593562602997,
-0.0723138079047203,
1.0965265035629272,
0.8397687673568726,
0.2748160660266876,
-0.09177019447088242,
-0.14503566920757294,
-0.21680709719657898,
0.33720505237579346,
-0.7050294280052185,
-0.12104741483926773,
0.1608910709619522,
-0.7600027918815613,
-0.6049975752830505,
-0.3521813154220581,
-1.2304123640060425,
-0.45999401807785034,
-0.25701063871383667,
0.28903621435165405,
-0.17584140598773956,
-0.5580490231513977,
0.24555902183055878,
-0.42572686076164246,
0.11521076411008835,
0.32306617498397827,
-1.277577519416809,
0.04781685769557953,
0.8170974850654602,
1.1955646276474,
-0.6949265599250793,
-0.1589895337820053,
-0.3049831688404083,
-0.04694979637861252,
-0.41556277871131897,
1.1736769676208496,
-0.8115105032920837,
-0.7763785719871521,
0.049466781318187714,
-0.24150829017162323,
-0.02165202796459198,
-0.4727456569671631,
0.704329788684845,
-0.5350372195243835,
0.6198545694351196,
-0.13726533949375153,
-0.5299489498138428,
0.19966693222522736,
0.09010839462280273,
-0.31034648418426514,
1.0790683031082153,
0.1022476851940155,
-0.7310241460800171,
0.42848092317581177,
-0.7351526021957397,
-0.3628869652748108,
-0.26775696873664856,
-0.022225748747587204,
-0.7665945887565613,
-0.02453472651541233,
0.05453132465481758,
0.42599785327911377,
-0.19165587425231934,
0.28540748357772827,
-0.6081664562225342,
-0.10880089551210403,
0.05347413197159767,
-0.25649234652519226,
0.6235246658325195,
0.21427209675312042,
-0.034238263964653015,
0.4760194420814514,
-0.5311094522476196,
-0.24749717116355896,
0.2506098747253418,
-0.06136390566825867,
-0.5435891151428223,
0.06561997532844543,
-0.09200545400381088,
-0.013553452678024769,
0.44539183378219604,
-0.3634759485721588,
0.3822402060031891,
-0.3046046197414398,
0.533687949180603,
1.0406347513198853,
0.02539873495697975,
1.1146881580352783,
-0.23252251744270325,
0.5990427136421204,
-0.18393996357917786,
0.29966074228286743,
0.25356945395469666,
-0.7277623414993286,
-0.481475293636322,
-0.31195303797721863,
0.14310906827449799,
0.6041527986526489,
-0.21507133543491364,
0.6618122458457947,
-0.25774168968200684,
-0.42395707964897156,
-0.37306877970695496,
0.0019312871154397726,
0.3003007769584656,
1.2083740234375,
0.2986307144165039,
-0.21767036616802216,
-0.17342574894428253,
-1.1393373012542725,
0.0993800088763237,
-0.08579475432634354,
0.0632326602935791,
0.5092206597328186,
0.014805536717176437,
-0.2838103175163269,
1.1566582918167114,
-0.8095398545265198,
-0.06581886857748032,
-0.041762322187423706,
0.23974262177944183,
-0.15538562834262848,
0.5119212865829468,
0.8390759229660034,
-0.8761110305786133,
-0.7755340337753296,
0.02406924031674862,
-0.3953205347061157,
-0.4042516052722931,
0.22005556523799896,
-0.5921306610107422,
0.35291197896003723,
0.25014033913612366,
-0.06835443526506424,
-0.004094323143362999,
0.7146638631820679,
-0.36978235840797424,
0.40242910385131836,
-0.3619295656681061,
0.3665197193622589,
-1.305816650390625,
-0.03731710463762283,
0.5844602584838867,
-0.23369871079921722,
-0.5781447887420654,
-0.4306998550891876,
0.267613023519516,
-0.08086255192756653,
-0.4347239136695862,
0.9835674166679382,
-0.36991891264915466,
-0.14156539738178253,
-0.3208152949810028,
0.22555412352085114,
0.37404999136924744,
0.2432095855474472,
0.5483528971672058,
1.0994983911514282,
0.66592937707901,
-0.6072608828544617,
0.13677963614463806,
0.27491798996925354,
-0.30777207016944885,
0.8538191914558411,
-0.6434292197227478,
0.383218914270401,
-0.24115797877311707,
0.25624948740005493,
-1.3140591382980347,
-0.04404077306389809,
0.6280527710914612,
-0.34941384196281433,
0.5135499835014343,
-0.5207143425941467,
-0.1775738000869751,
0.1626499593257904,
-0.49182558059692383,
0.6864402890205383,
0.711857795715332,
-0.5391840934753418,
0.6325039267539978,
0.26445311307907104,
-0.057227447628974915,
-0.8611541986465454,
-0.3721109628677368,
-0.20451600849628448,
-0.6047555804252625,
-0.7217214107513428,
0.6582371592521667,
-0.06717753410339355,
-0.11106617003679276,
-0.12708550691604614,
0.08874054998159409,
0.0024370041210204363,
0.018092168495059013,
0.04366028308868408,
0.49238964915275574,
0.055138666182756424,
0.11694096028804779,
0.2212018072605133,
-0.41079407930374146,
-0.31543591618537903,
-0.49504974484443665,
0.6530448198318481,
0.3989645838737488,
0.07323967665433884,
-0.6835855841636658,
0.33793359994888306,
0.29499807953834534,
-0.08708768337965012,
0.4973219335079193,
0.5273163318634033,
0.13380053639411926,
-0.03410471975803375,
-0.45039936900138855,
0.14359824359416962,
-0.469148725271225,
0.18262800574302673,
-0.4313455820083618,
-0.6101897954940796,
0.1443096101284027,
-0.143239364027977,
0.1765207201242447,
0.25718745589256287,
0.4653778374195099,
-0.25211718678474426,
1.1782381534576416,
0.7398456931114197,
-0.08836313337087631,
1.1863999366760254,
-0.024120569229125977,
0.026772137731313705,
-0.8844665884971619,
-0.11731059849262238,
-0.5458585619926453,
-0.4192235767841339,
-0.37358540296554565,
-0.3811072111129761,
0.339400053024292,
-0.17036066949367523,
-0.17308133840560913,
0.05628611892461777,
-0.6724935173988342,
0.48916441202163696,
0.36262571811676025,
0.33033719658851624,
0.16672301292419434,
0.22261226177215576,
0.05296872928738594,
-0.07055456191301346,
-0.4430740177631378,
-0.5956986546516418,
1.1617026329040527,
0.3929571211338043,
0.7706944942474365,
0.16420310735702515,
0.8437525629997253,
0.5200297236442566,
0.19229942560195923,
-1.183603286743164,
0.3802664279937744,
-0.35366901755332947,
-0.09063634276390076,
-0.24368543922901154,
-0.2409828156232834,
-0.910058856010437,
0.28489556908607483,
-0.3322857916355133,
-0.4913763999938965,
0.4630807042121887,
0.5366083383560181,
-0.32609161734580994,
0.0010180908720940351,
-1.0779067277908325,
1.0157701969146729,
-0.12830738723278046,
-0.503423810005188,
-0.3045271337032318,
-0.5468936562538147,
0.1639813333749771,
0.19067834317684174,
0.07937655597925186,
-0.2572568356990814,
-0.6110276579856873,
0.6007707118988037,
-0.11643759161233902,
0.677795946598053,
-0.1268451064825058,
-0.4254438877105713,
-0.18664199113845825,
-0.05689183250069618,
0.27048465609550476,
-0.03057265840470791,
-0.36898088455200195,
-0.03076942078769207,
-0.30696770548820496,
-0.5423036813735962,
-0.817392110824585,
0.7929092645645142,
-0.8232617378234863,
-0.5787481069564819,
-0.19106802344322205,
-0.17248941957950592,
-0.21096296608448029,
0.1302519589662552,
0.5241227746009827,
0.39324304461479187,
-0.2654804587364197,
-0.34610435366630554,
0.9416688680648804,
-0.07574936747550964,
0.3001818358898163,
0.27543970942497253,
-0.29748737812042236,
-0.6594350934028625,
0.9818040728569031,
-0.3222007155418396,
0.7364633679389954,
0.6592829823493958,
0.7723150253295898,
-0.5284046530723572,
-0.46034130454063416,
-0.686748206615448,
0.4412473142147064,
-0.5469017624855042,
0.09315800666809082,
-0.6426131129264832,
0.4533088207244873,
-0.6210559010505676,
-0.5659070611000061,
-0.3784266412258148,
-0.34130293130874634,
-0.7050380706787109,
0.20491796731948853,
0.2841298580169678,
0.42317184805870056,
0.08416157215833664,
0.22884832322597504,
-0.5170077681541443,
0.3537179231643677,
0.43952664732933044,
0.4298079013824463,
-0.0945701077580452,
-0.8458192944526672,
0.16527552902698517,
-0.2596572935581207,
-0.2692500352859497,
-0.9111700654029846,
0.23431672155857086,
0.1177758201956749,
0.2298862785100937,
0.6977853775024414,
-0.10389580577611923,
0.6349192261695862,
-0.5911123156547546,
0.7374644875526428,
0.32671529054641724,
-0.7683049440383911,
0.7348750233650208,
-0.25811365246772766,
-0.11874347180128098,
0.6326795220375061,
0.5121116638183594,
-0.6492030620574951,
0.2204219549894333,
-0.4430634677410126,
-0.6076284050941467,
0.5427206754684448,
-0.3503645062446594,
0.21521230041980743,
-0.0005137145053595304,
0.6172937750816345,
0.2658332586288452,
-0.11526860296726227,
-0.4658801555633545,
-0.4219908118247986,
-0.1882859468460083,
-0.2825528383255005,
-0.0021505190525203943,
-0.44544413685798645,
-0.21116092801094055,
-0.005036206915974617,
0.8885718584060669,
-0.14189936220645905,
0.14811913669109344,
0.09628324955701828,
0.17478974163532257,
-0.2470232993364334,
0.24775616824626923,
0.838848352432251,
0.5190245509147644,
-0.21315206587314606,
-0.09575915336608887,
-0.3720032870769501,
-0.22856096923351288,
0.3366861641407013,
-0.22074639797210693,
-0.5302360653877258,
-0.24085818231105804,
-0.041720494627952576,
0.8206808567047119,
0.00032350546098314226,
-0.3106880784034729,
0.6405643820762634,
-0.2872251868247986,
-0.37575563788414,
-0.015424643643200397,
0.1628306359052658,
-0.09229030460119247,
-0.05227266624569893,
-0.007007777225226164,
0.23809483647346497,
0.21999287605285645,
-0.3633521795272827,
-0.03563826531171799,
0.6903030872344971,
-0.3459133803844452,
-0.19090233743190765,
0.4171867370605469,
0.5523073077201843,
-0.5420258641242981,
0.3293239176273346,
-0.15319135785102844,
-0.28943726420402527,
0.3309252858161926,
0.548539936542511,
1.039176106452942,
-0.17905113101005554,
0.5944833755493164,
0.44070500135421753,
-0.26519671082496643,
-0.43529197573661804,
-0.09419912099838257,
-0.39845603704452515,
-1.1361640691757202,
-0.06548700481653214,
-0.3253456652164459,
-0.48016542196273804,
-0.4011100232601166,
-0.5453667640686035,
0.5491800904273987,
-0.3709110617637634,
-0.27695658802986145,
0.07237210869789124,
-0.22549279034137726,
-0.14011099934577942,
-0.01140146516263485,
-0.13037170469760895,
0.6574149131774902,
-1.067801833152771,
0.8294540643692017,
0.7900229692459106,
-0.17542864382266998,
-0.3061849772930145,
0.3743742108345032,
0.014989933930337429,
-0.9212677478790283,
0.5194607377052307,
-0.06176342815160751,
-0.460821270942688,
0.21760118007659912,
-0.4136018455028534,
-0.6763445734977722,
1.0073355436325073,
0.2524022161960602,
-0.41350215673446655,
0.035477425903081894,
-0.44506552815437317,
0.3347454071044922,
-0.49446606636047363,
0.11418957263231277,
0.5172638893127441,
0.4935515820980072,
0.29998600482940674,
-0.5361218452453613,
-0.19093917310237885,
0.07020135223865509,
0.1960454285144806,
0.5613151788711548,
-0.9388074278831482,
0.1259564757347107,
-0.22368623316287994,
-0.3553318679332733,
0.10031932592391968,
0.7117468118667603,
0.2424459010362625,
0.2618471682071686,
0.7816110253334045,
0.737169086933136,
0.6213112473487854,
0.08019354939460754,
0.842099666595459,
-0.09746307879686356,
0.29306426644325256,
0.9518040418624878,
-0.36125802993774414,
0.7918182611465454,
0.6600545048713684,
-0.19813132286071777,
0.577694296836853,
0.7599791288375854,
0.23374170064926147,
0.8064481616020203,
-0.2555406987667084,
-0.34955114126205444,
-0.32084187865257263,
-0.2459055334329605,
-0.2616310119628906,
-0.027605213224887848,
0.04649249091744423,
-0.3680345416069031,
0.16220180690288544,
-0.1990242600440979,
0.09594589471817017,
0.33787134289741516,
0.03861670568585396,
0.930187463760376,
-0.2105986773967743,
-1.0354266166687012,
0.3627230226993561,
-0.02847328968346119,
1.1515170335769653,
-0.49312281608581543,
0.03346053138375282,
-0.2536921799182892,
-0.16738319396972656,
-0.2895395755767822,
-1.0174524784088135,
0.20945054292678833,
-0.19326548278331757,
-0.4946368634700775,
-0.5971551537513733,
0.6370915770530701,
-0.5215091705322266,
-0.24275192618370056,
0.20108826458454132,
0.0971100926399231,
-0.18241004645824432,
0.3060396611690521,
-0.8647984266281128,
0.03989182040095329,
0.16117598116397858,
-0.13229690492153168,
0.47954320907592773,
0.18711675703525543,
0.1729252189397812,
0.5389373898506165,
0.32249486446380615,
0.02371782250702381,
-0.32030850648880005,
0.4938121736049652,
0.2966506779193878,
-0.336402028799057,
-0.4404495358467102,
-1.0331076383590698,
0.4220838248729706,
-0.07499963045120239,
-0.34927669167518616,
0.35215577483177185,
0.6776790618896484,
0.4870201647281647,
-0.0857684463262558,
0.7171971797943115,
0.1212453842163086,
0.37738674879074097,
-0.6275766491889954,
0.3922581672668457,
-0.847444474697113,
-0.017478933557868004,
-0.34683987498283386,
-0.9640661478042603,
-0.19902543723583221,
0.6711623072624207,
-0.41811415553092957,
-0.010697297751903534,
0.523104190826416,
0.9735622406005859,
-0.1648707538843155,
-0.3529338836669922,
0.1725122183561325,
-0.50346839427948,
0.29461967945098877,
0.3057526648044586,
0.6570417881011963,
-0.15792427957057953,
0.27736103534698486,
-0.46373888850212097,
-0.6361107230186462,
-0.17972932755947113,
-1.303011178970337,
-0.6450358033180237,
-0.7593078017234802,
-0.6679909825325012,
-0.2609030306339264,
-0.055001333355903625,
1.0375020503997803,
0.9196466207504272,
-0.37538501620292664,
-0.2041023224592209,
-0.14243768155574799,
0.3477349281311035,
-0.11528649926185608,
-0.2575504183769226,
0.29024767875671387,
-0.4214498996734619,
-1.1220301389694214,
0.26834145188331604,
0.52430659532547,
0.42386430501937866,
-0.26962539553642273,
-0.21931932866573334,
-0.07990629225969315,
-0.08902695775032043,
0.5051710605621338,
0.263650119304657,
-0.8324916362762451,
-0.3002862334251404,
-0.07137390226125717,
-0.03199057653546333,
0.4343095123767853,
0.8678044676780701,
-0.40384984016418457,
0.6160682439804077,
0.821696400642395,
0.4563787579536438,
0.27841097116470337,
0.40161141753196716,
0.821121871471405,
-0.6833392977714539,
0.20149487257003784,
-0.16324733197689056,
0.3299145996570587,
0.4196191132068634,
-0.4762795865535736,
0.34384989738464355,
0.3300567865371704,
-0.6941877603530884,
-0.5323949456214905,
0.5175707340240479,
-1.2246323823928833,
-0.16887129843235016,
1.3017839193344116,
0.11629969626665115,
-0.12701214849948883,
0.04328346252441406,
-0.4460780918598175,
0.11794954538345337,
-0.9786761999130249,
0.7241144776344299,
0.6667647957801819,
-0.3840951919555664,
-0.31114766001701355,
-0.1783411055803299,
0.49757397174835205,
0.6042195558547974,
-0.612269937992096,
0.09210607409477234,
0.651317834854126,
0.5546315312385559,
0.046712279319763184,
0.8959833383560181,
-0.010431244038045406,
0.12274844199419022,
-0.5367652177810669,
0.07290024310350418,
0.22319908440113068,
-0.2021430879831314,
-0.5576308369636536,
0.02946002222597599,
0.24450203776359558,
-0.333758682012558
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.06371v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.06371v3
|
mHuBERT-147: A Compact Multilingual HuBERT Model
| 2024-06-10T15:32:42 | 2024-06-27T07:56:48 |
Marcely Zanon Boito, Vivek Iyer, Nikolaos Lagos, Laurent Besacier, Ioan Calapodescu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
We present mHuBERT-147, the first general-purpose massively multilingual
HuBERT speech representation model trained on 90K hours of clean, open-license
data. To scale up the multi-iteration HuBERT approach, we use faiss-based
clustering, achieving 5.2x faster label assignment than the original method. We
also apply a new multilingual batching up-sampling strategy, leveraging both
language and dataset diversity. After 3 training iterations, our compact 95M
parameter mHuBERT-147 outperforms larger models trained on substantially more
data. We rank second and first on the ML-SUPERB 10min and 1h leaderboards, with
SOTA scores for 3 tasks. Across ASR/LID tasks, our model consistently surpasses
XLS-R (300M params; 436K hours) and demonstrates strong competitiveness against
the much larger MMS (1B params; 491K hours). Our findings indicate that
mHuBERT-147 is a promising model for multilingual speech tasks, offering an
unprecedented balance between high performance and parameter efficiency.
|
[
-0.3307628631591797,
-0.5992904305458069,
0.3308008313179016,
0.5362732410430908,
-0.26630711555480957,
0.10606890171766281,
-0.5897371768951416,
-0.4775228798389435,
0.50620037317276,
0.08353489637374878,
-0.34122270345687866,
-0.35991886258125305,
-0.771572470664978,
0.21276947855949402,
-0.30134788155555725,
0.6557168960571289,
0.19509734213352203,
0.3511584997177124,
0.19130335748195648,
-0.08066053688526154,
-0.025155240669846535,
-0.7000967860221863,
-0.6041414737701416,
-0.25280946493148804,
0.9261704683303833,
0.6165433526039124,
0.6031990051269531,
0.5712181925773621,
0.27932554483413696,
0.3092026114463806,
-0.17044703662395477,
0.026026558130979538,
-0.5841319561004639,
0.12663018703460693,
0.2682541608810425,
-0.016117863357067108,
-0.4748534560203552,
-0.21877293288707733,
1.0633442401885986,
0.8953558802604675,
-0.76395583152771,
0.3559319078922272,
0.05325553938746452,
0.32236865162849426,
-0.473338782787323,
0.14505016803741455,
-0.627066433429718,
-0.38712987303733826,
-0.6199168562889099,
0.182410329580307,
-0.7431172728538513,
0.19309471547603607,
0.07493134588003159,
-0.6637169122695923,
-0.2258249670267105,
0.1584329754114151,
0.9544565081596375,
-0.1747165471315384,
-0.3728674352169037,
0.014974663034081459,
-0.5154451727867126,
1.2616127729415894,
-0.5267672538757324,
0.8455163836479187,
0.21689903736114502,
0.5183261036872864,
0.279056578874588,
-0.6932181715965271,
-0.29413560032844543,
-0.5213046073913574,
0.08791527152061462,
-0.10863099247217178,
-0.4499700963497162,
-0.121839240193367,
0.26828503608703613,
0.07179713249206543,
-0.651697039604187,
0.025945689529180527,
-0.9665188789367676,
-0.2896844148635864,
0.7232934832572937,
-0.015020468272268772,
-0.26106688380241394,
-0.4622988998889923,
-0.2360864281654358,
-0.048534758388996124,
-0.10878562182188034,
0.27536988258361816,
0.3141772747039795,
0.43956702947616577,
-0.2479306012392044,
0.4130672812461853,
-0.3627340793609619,
0.7572622299194336,
-0.07334103435277939,
-0.3633366823196411,
0.20702432096004486,
0.10885322839021683,
-0.10324427485466003,
0.14828522503376007,
1.0389206409454346,
-0.1958516538143158,
0.35373279452323914,
-0.10852567106485367,
-0.05566151440143585,
-0.3838365375995636,
0.3549998998641968,
-0.8835741281509399,
-0.4036104083061218,
0.04669724777340889,
-0.45447930693626404,
-0.0666700005531311,
0.2312275618314743,
-0.3925635814666748,
0.06216031685471535,
-0.6509125232696533,
0.3708251714706421,
-0.48601678013801575,
-0.03281773626804352,
-0.06215409189462662,
0.1275966316461563,
0.025231199339032173,
0.4256756007671356,
-1.0554442405700684,
0.21789900958538055,
0.5430127382278442,
0.6730554699897766,
-0.2170453816652298,
-0.5929057598114014,
-0.5771018266677856,
0.3493877053260803,
-0.5648074746131897,
0.5623360276222229,
-0.6066043972969055,
-0.1980341076850891,
-0.26411840319633484,
0.1662723422050476,
0.04153385013341904,
-0.5503504872322083,
0.49396005272865295,
-0.2251380831003189,
0.060489900410175323,
-0.13736073672771454,
-0.21194463968276978,
-0.4482639729976654,
0.25625139474868774,
-0.5527296662330627,
1.279513955116272,
0.3059784173965454,
-0.6503950953483582,
0.22723965346813202,
-0.47532182931900024,
-0.23088735342025757,
0.07231301069259644,
-0.22175996005535126,
-0.3149429261684418,
0.09245537221431732,
0.1137063056230545,
0.4974827170372009,
-0.4391856789588928,
0.7291283011436462,
-0.45910030603408813,
-0.4361063838005066,
0.23952017724514008,
-0.47856688499450684,
1.0153396129608154,
0.09257709234952927,
-0.08564180135726929,
0.4247390925884247,
-0.6730824708938599,
-0.05227899178862572,
0.002749077510088682,
-0.7539752125740051,
-0.08346182107925415,
-0.5660541653633118,
0.5216466784477234,
0.10701562464237213,
0.20667731761932373,
-0.7676103115081787,
0.07498230785131454,
0.012821674346923828,
0.292359858751297,
0.7317399978637695,
-0.5170758366584778,
0.14096511900424957,
-0.31059807538986206,
0.5639498233795166,
-0.14503799378871918,
0.3582947254180908,
-0.23604126274585724,
-0.6990683674812317,
-0.6148875951766968,
-0.7117769122123718,
0.8663817048072815,
0.6042740345001221,
-0.4853549003601074,
0.26050418615341187,
-0.47425577044487,
-0.772356390953064,
-0.7406235337257385,
0.1351344734430313,
0.08199112117290497,
0.3683050572872162,
0.5147193670272827,
-0.06024182587862015,
-0.33973032236099243,
-1.3114912509918213,
0.1945464313030243,
0.061447594314813614,
-0.15172895789146423,
0.524122953414917,
0.4841064214706421,
-0.5528272986412048,
0.30247461795806885,
-0.3952282667160034,
-0.08813929557800293,
-0.30713096261024475,
0.15191702544689178,
0.302521675825119,
0.44802287220954895,
0.776751697063446,
-0.5777463316917419,
-0.6663733124732971,
-0.005465757567435503,
-0.8256965279579163,
0.04473979026079178,
0.3127257227897644,
-0.1295689344406128,
0.14496009051799774,
0.6266071200370789,
-0.3500414192676544,
-0.08118569105863571,
0.8997814655303955,
0.1426171064376831,
0.9081105589866638,
-0.29197269678115845,
0.3166673183441162,
-1.096144676208496,
0.1696394830942154,
-0.325758695602417,
-0.20279744267463684,
-0.7168384194374084,
-0.009214445017278194,
0.28667575120925903,
-0.6016453504562378,
-0.47347697615623474,
0.4286075234413147,
-0.22066521644592285,
0.2952430546283722,
-0.03429286554455757,
0.14961040019989014,
-0.08566116541624069,
0.6067619919776917,
-0.17646360397338867,
0.46328920125961304,
0.9779927134513855,
-0.5008951425552368,
0.5565744042396545,
0.22258275747299194,
-0.3291025459766388,
0.449187695980072,
-0.9285441040992737,
-0.0819043517112732,
-0.19227108359336853,
0.30670925974845886,
-1.0352306365966797,
-0.4383549094200134,
0.17284360527992249,
-0.3624770939350128,
0.6510878205299377,
0.09821125864982605,
-0.5563482642173767,
-0.3802992105484009,
-0.2762272357940674,
0.7083215713500977,
0.1380981206893921,
-0.48113420605659485,
0.745067298412323,
0.43545058369636536,
-0.614078938961029,
-0.7058289051055908,
-0.7635878324508667,
0.1300242841243744,
-0.446606308221817,
-0.9734548330307007,
0.5649758577346802,
0.020168308168649673,
-0.1740916669368744,
-0.440297931432724,
0.04368860274553299,
-0.26695260405540466,
-0.22638173401355743,
0.007958545349538326,
-0.0465216226875782,
-0.18351806700229645,
0.3409234881401062,
0.11908254772424698,
-0.38274604082107544,
-0.2576359808444977,
0.06004742532968521,
0.4626770615577698,
-0.07859136164188385,
-0.176132470369339,
-0.5900344252586365,
0.7407593727111816,
0.6215711236000061,
-0.23931311070919037,
0.8002171516418457,
0.8927164077758789,
-0.44314658641815186,
0.19687330722808838,
-0.5094113945960999,
-0.3224584460258484,
-0.44905179738998413,
0.27849280834198,
-0.41913169622421265,
-0.9389730095863342,
0.38836535811424255,
0.11624607443809509,
0.09835627675056458,
0.28853121399879456,
0.4348236322402954,
-0.16130395233631134,
0.7192283868789673,
0.5235112905502319,
-0.22113119065761566,
0.5945984125137329,
-0.3380815088748932,
0.1367918998003006,
-0.7403436899185181,
-0.21787118911743164,
-0.6047968864440918,
-0.43712443113327026,
-0.5536431670188904,
-0.661751389503479,
0.49907824397087097,
0.2439337521791458,
-0.204725444316864,
0.4081110954284668,
-0.23363575339317322,
-0.07076984643936157,
0.9402116537094116,
0.0578729510307312,
0.05858989059925079,
0.03783454746007919,
-0.17776699364185333,
-0.3270781934261322,
-0.779592752456665,
-0.46181222796440125,
1.1504322290420532,
0.1875167191028595,
0.8928974270820618,
0.3113259971141815,
0.7728149890899658,
0.20638085901737213,
0.39943766593933105,
-0.7886238694190979,
0.4287509620189667,
-0.34086647629737854,
-0.8564452528953552,
-0.634249210357666,
-0.5106877088546753,
-1.056168794631958,
0.6789618134498596,
-0.237619087100029,
-0.8394578695297241,
-0.15056584775447845,
0.16229243576526642,
-0.2468968629837036,
0.15251870453357697,
-0.6720956563949585,
0.953162670135498,
-0.1842653751373291,
-0.14250671863555908,
-0.44528114795684814,
-0.6517272591590881,
0.5228968262672424,
-0.3041906952857971,
0.44945263862609863,
-0.5076276063919067,
0.2976343333721161,
0.922182023525238,
0.07549650967121124,
0.3690341114997864,
-0.19018693268299103,
-0.04698145389556885,
0.20659877359867096,
-0.06908796727657318,
0.13156525790691376,
0.23073457181453705,
-0.36087724566459656,
0.5560874938964844,
0.11736933887004852,
-0.6100155115127563,
-0.34769248962402344,
0.555742621421814,
-0.5754931569099426,
-0.27364107966423035,
-0.2970963716506958,
-0.6500216126441956,
-0.017481576651334763,
0.14086495339870453,
0.28618213534355164,
0.7842118144035339,
-0.2708915174007416,
0.7207643985748291,
0.24474233388900757,
-0.3318949043750763,
0.2969769239425659,
0.577604353427887,
-0.5226081013679504,
-0.5542024970054626,
0.9771694540977478,
0.43989238142967224,
0.13145712018013,
0.568065345287323,
0.4568370580673218,
-0.1996319442987442,
-0.07339479774236679,
-0.6562227606773376,
0.40216371417045593,
-0.5752759575843811,
-0.10502175986766815,
-0.8263395428657532,
0.04328395053744316,
-0.35825639963150024,
-0.003432408906519413,
-0.43906667828559875,
-0.6704049706459045,
-0.03561935946345329,
0.08178501576185226,
0.16314220428466797,
0.5159798860549927,
-0.41157159209251404,
0.591791033744812,
-0.7832529544830322,
0.5854430198669434,
0.4985979497432709,
0.15670374035835266,
-0.001198832062073052,
-0.7901365160942078,
-0.3939538300037384,
0.0792132169008255,
-0.5237833261489868,
-0.8242457509040833,
-0.022818250581622124,
0.3503001034259796,
0.6207824945449829,
0.5421711802482605,
-0.0652727261185646,
0.63380366563797,
-0.5936159491539001,
0.6331469416618347,
0.1284685581922531,
-1.024200439453125,
0.09783832728862762,
-0.58137047290802,
0.42740803956985474,
0.39757436513900757,
0.49844253063201904,
-0.7093680500984192,
-0.32846465706825256,
-0.7084926962852478,
-0.7420915365219116,
0.77947598695755,
0.08708103746175766,
0.14306016266345978,
0.27495476603507996,
0.12201398611068726,
0.19125990569591522,
0.4375899136066437,
-0.7763007879257202,
-0.4780530631542206,
0.14051444828510284,
0.018128270283341408,
-0.2864476144313812,
-0.3698088824748993,
-0.024255096912384033,
-0.7647624611854553,
0.8860085606575012,
-0.13462287187576294,
0.2943441867828369,
-0.2788883149623871,
-0.04495503380894661,
0.22083525359630585,
0.45147258043289185,
0.9330432415008545,
0.8016252517700195,
-0.1649363934993744,
0.0315253920853138,
0.2857274115085602,
-0.19511674344539642,
0.06562954187393188,
0.5900011658668518,
0.054812461137771606,
0.3236517310142517,
0.35601478815078735,
0.7257230281829834,
0.6892845034599304,
-0.7320482730865479,
0.35477232933044434,
0.04036577418446541,
-0.2962482273578644,
-0.014033662155270576,
-0.3820492625236511,
0.2518726587295532,
0.11157526075839996,
0.34536153078079224,
-0.18118010461330414,
0.23867526650428772,
-0.3598828911781311,
0.4686007499694824,
0.26704904437065125,
-0.6305240988731384,
-0.31161147356033325,
0.7175981402397156,
-0.09067925065755844,
-0.06359216570854187,
0.5270041823387146,
-0.24828200042247772,
-0.38364630937576294,
0.21920092403888702,
0.18334606289863586,
0.529066264629364,
-0.8370984196662903,
0.3066740334033966,
0.5358362197875977,
0.4706467390060425,
0.05703848972916603,
0.5312027931213379,
-0.07911001145839691,
-0.3026573359966278,
-0.44434717297554016,
-0.7155438661575317,
-0.5679205656051636,
-0.022069204598665237,
-0.9331235885620117,
0.3146922290325165,
0.0246396716684103,
-0.21533097326755524,
0.27527162432670593,
-0.3980484902858734,
-0.35220837593078613,
-0.022029690444469452,
0.16111595928668976,
0.8186929821968079,
-0.6603333950042725,
1.0117933750152588,
0.5483137369155884,
0.16608558595180511,
-0.8618289828300476,
-0.22219222784042358,
-0.0663718581199646,
-0.680202066898346,
0.30232375860214233,
0.43499889969825745,
-0.05639105662703514,
-0.15061341226100922,
-0.48494964838027954,
-0.9540327787399292,
0.8624882102012634,
0.9352831840515137,
-0.7149940729141235,
0.12071578949689865,
-0.11394885927438736,
0.2746947705745697,
-0.16521801054477692,
-0.13196994364261627,
0.4228171110153198,
0.6456514596939087,
-0.15400774776935577,
-1.278723955154419,
-0.4333071708679199,
-0.05342965945601463,
-0.30238956212997437,
0.25919705629348755,
-0.7781333327293396,
1.130455732345581,
-0.43252986669540405,
0.10158896446228027,
0.1834517866373062,
0.6339917778968811,
0.5985519886016846,
-0.0033682275097817183,
0.28513041138648987,
0.49285346269607544,
1.04056978225708,
-0.2774195969104767,
0.9840206503868103,
-0.4163113236427307,
0.4081352949142456,
0.9938854575157166,
0.10312081128358841,
1.0139211416244507,
0.5210646390914917,
-0.1688692718744278,
0.5237835049629211,
0.5072961449623108,
0.022810818627476692,
0.43669193983078003,
0.44491663575172424,
-0.10996881872415543,
-0.4541175067424774,
-0.3724253177642822,
-0.44646111130714417,
0.8141734600067139,
0.2884509861469269,
-0.15466426312923431,
-0.13600973784923553,
0.3064630329608917,
0.0534447617828846,
-0.21482513844966888,
-0.10956313461065292,
0.46874764561653137,
0.23510897159576416,
-0.3396260142326355,
0.7883957624435425,
0.37098243832588196,
0.6135563850402832,
-0.8519346117973328,
0.25864413380622864,
0.24334751069545746,
0.16945266723632812,
0.0837283805012703,
-0.42634299397468567,
0.04828972369432449,
-0.28644511103630066,
-0.25934210419654846,
-0.2909717261791229,
0.20362520217895508,
-0.79604172706604,
-0.84574294090271,
0.5397633910179138,
0.39179933071136475,
0.23358866572380066,
-0.32507455348968506,
-0.7371087074279785,
0.2967246174812317,
-0.07819364964962006,
-0.15655797719955444,
-0.020687321200966835,
0.4597833752632141,
-0.07014637440443039,
0.6833701729774475,
0.32934099435806274,
-0.1672431230545044,
0.3011978268623352,
0.20068876445293427,
0.5680520534515381,
-0.5700558423995972,
-0.5825780630111694,
-0.6018751859664917,
0.6879087090492249,
0.14143112301826477,
-0.29903292655944824,
0.6572734117507935,
0.8082306981086731,
0.6953961849212646,
-0.22693616151809692,
0.6983454823493958,
0.06216668337583542,
0.5836353302001953,
-0.2756885290145874,
0.4646599590778351,
-0.7448292374610901,
-0.4260145127773285,
-0.4257540702819824,
-0.8786742687225342,
-0.17262589931488037,
0.7232680916786194,
-0.052982211112976074,
0.15767024457454681,
0.5327945351600647,
0.5335666537284851,
-0.2288741171360016,
-0.026351334527134895,
0.4716109037399292,
-0.026274261996150017,
0.4143286943435669,
0.35459157824516296,
0.8665173649787903,
-0.5844472646713257,
0.7836368083953857,
-0.4138517379760742,
-0.36624401807785034,
-0.37551745772361755,
-0.45283564925193787,
-0.7435199022293091,
-0.6132082343101501,
-0.1702820509672165,
0.028857741504907608,
-0.3664250075817108,
0.8733428120613098,
1.1867058277130127,
-0.9386370182037354,
-0.6806358098983765,
0.8044691681861877,
-0.17983664572238922,
-0.4477952718734741,
-0.18917903304100037,
0.28405916690826416,
-0.0898062065243721,
-0.7382022738456726,
0.6525115966796875,
0.37713465094566345,
0.1134885847568512,
-0.16080905497074127,
-0.2471662163734436,
-0.18055148422718048,
-0.06604757905006409,
0.7173129320144653,
-0.11781832575798035,
-0.9788635969161987,
-0.03271215781569481,
0.2324731945991516,
-0.09441077709197998,
0.1820954829454422,
0.7398552298545837,
-0.1084371879696846,
0.6743549704551697,
0.24263975024223328,
0.30883464217185974,
0.6321970224380493,
0.08980438113212585,
0.568841814994812,
-0.8375235199928284,
0.4366157054901123,
-0.003918822854757309,
0.6040030717849731,
0.5188389420509338,
0.2654127776622772,
0.27480679750442505,
-0.05293390527367592,
-0.5824770331382751,
-0.7995994687080383,
0.11552263796329498,
-1.1848596334457397,
-0.17653906345367432,
1.0183731317520142,
0.10008446872234344,
0.1909983903169632,
-0.0703091248869896,
-0.5684458017349243,
0.066966712474823,
-0.8244667053222656,
0.824333131313324,
0.9422956109046936,
-0.2712583839893341,
-0.02243540808558464,
-0.811896026134491,
0.2812552750110626,
0.19834208488464355,
-0.6869345307350159,
0.10689856857061386,
0.20080901682376862,
-0.027412554249167442,
0.4938431978225708,
0.6572358012199402,
0.09382053464651108,
0.32976076006889343,
0.01854064129292965,
-0.03708288446068764,
0.1368345469236374,
-0.9081451296806335,
-0.22636906802654266,
0.2580513060092926,
0.21281814575195312,
-0.17785464227199554
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.06369v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.06369v3
|
Annotation alignment: Comparing LLM and human annotations of conversational safety
| 2024-06-10T15:30:13 | 2024-06-24T23:23:22 |
Rajiv Movva, Pang Wei Koh, Emma Pierson
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
To what extent do LLMs align with human perceptions of safety? We study this
question via *annotation alignment*, the extent to which LLMs and humans agree
when annotating the safety of user-chatbot conversations. We leverage the
recent DICES dataset (Aroyo et al., 2023), in which 350 conversations are each
rated for safety by 112 annotators spanning 10 race-gender groups. GPT-4
achieves a Pearson correlation of $r = 0.59$ with the average annotator rating,
higher than the median annotator's correlation with the average ($r=0.51$). We
show that larger datasets are needed to resolve whether GPT-4 exhibits
disparities in how well it correlates with demographic groups. Also, there is
substantial idiosyncratic variation in correlation *within* groups, suggesting
that race & gender do not fully capture differences in alignment. Finally, we
find that GPT-4 cannot predict when one demographic group finds a conversation
more unsafe than another.
|
[
-0.2974401116371155,
-0.45990249514579773,
0.4746741056442261,
0.08271462470293045,
-0.13527821004390717,
0.37224599719047546,
0.11613091081380844,
-0.8931658864021301,
0.23100094497203827,
0.14223259687423706,
-0.3034815788269043,
-0.5671989917755127,
-0.6452294588088989,
0.11733378469944,
-0.34579166769981384,
1.3061110973358154,
0.21991406381130219,
-0.008069279603660107,
-0.32556313276290894,
-0.08340991288423538,
-0.5112400650978088,
-0.9352023601531982,
-0.5748308300971985,
-0.2972874045372009,
0.6630385518074036,
0.10143627226352692,
1.1225215196609497,
0.8782476186752319,
0.8982520699501038,
0.2939208149909973,
-0.24674011766910553,
-0.10836159437894821,
-0.4459846615791321,
-0.030311474576592445,
0.006545513868331909,
-0.30935904383659363,
-0.57115638256073,
0.16207151114940643,
0.17624109983444214,
0.49677324295043945,
0.020121922716498375,
-0.04373078793287277,
0.16151757538318634,
0.3360045552253723,
-0.37675440311431885,
-0.07341374456882477,
-0.5079677104949951,
-0.0020186016336083412,
-0.1927661895751953,
-0.18045763671398163,
-0.058253031224012375,
-0.7018441557884216,
0.317256897687912,
-0.5526197552680969,
0.12972895801067352,
0.383748859167099,
0.7908830642700195,
0.44657784700393677,
-0.6641858816146851,
-0.2140081226825714,
-0.5887128710746765,
0.485358864068985,
-0.39751747250556946,
0.14177533984184265,
0.5427860617637634,
0.16212615370750427,
-0.23263755440711975,
-0.20155566930770874,
-0.6576821804046631,
0.0314512737095356,
-0.2163383960723877,
0.1526053100824356,
0.07088513672351837,
0.23271946609020233,
0.47423121333122253,
0.12366490066051483,
-0.5938250422477722,
0.42413222789764404,
-0.4845799505710602,
-0.5288313031196594,
0.950615644454956,
0.44924548268318176,
0.3865821063518524,
-0.10143771022558212,
-0.7085870504379272,
-0.08910417556762695,
-0.6021788716316223,
0.030116021633148193,
0.6693258285522461,
0.2767420709133148,
-0.4936516582965851,
0.4956151843070984,
0.036860473453998566,
0.4420281648635864,
-0.06343767791986465,
-0.3313819169998169,
0.5289406180381775,
-0.5471509099006653,
0.11915730684995651,
0.35672396421432495,
1.1846630573272705,
1.1872481107711792,
0.6598010659217834,
-0.11540170758962631,
0.13907963037490845,
0.213694766163826,
0.28595539927482605,
-0.549614667892456,
-0.40877869725227356,
-0.04209263622760773,
-0.12847498059272766,
-0.483203262090683,
0.19910928606987,
-0.7756772637367249,
-0.8964727520942688,
-0.21332719922065735,
0.2344365417957306,
-0.18110118806362152,
-0.20195601880550385,
-0.0715351328253746,
-0.010587374679744244,
0.30318036675453186,
0.3526473343372345,
-1.1320430040359497,
0.20877045392990112,
0.811816394329071,
0.9727170467376709,
-0.404977947473526,
-0.23743847012519836,
-0.056640345603227615,
0.10536576807498932,
-0.4597594439983368,
0.710910975933075,
-0.4468708038330078,
-0.5178839564323425,
0.07994293421506882,
-0.23174405097961426,
0.06530415266752243,
-0.18932250142097473,
0.7009975910186768,
-0.23247404396533966,
0.3549063801765442,
-0.52950119972229,
-0.4739912152290344,
-0.19556161761283875,
0.320732057094574,
-0.4808772802352905,
0.8177585601806641,
-0.24426548182964325,
-1.0503723621368408,
0.7518376111984253,
-0.5242080092430115,
-0.3221074044704437,
-0.07010471075773239,
-0.5582931041717529,
-0.5889576077461243,
-0.32729440927505493,
0.26156359910964966,
0.27797946333885193,
-0.10244344919919968,
0.17428116500377655,
-0.7300705313682556,
-0.4538029730319977,
0.7177149653434753,
-0.3791215717792511,
0.7574343085289001,
0.08630481362342834,
-0.17673362791538239,
0.2684587836265564,
-0.30236494541168213,
-0.2570851743221283,
-0.08968017250299454,
-0.09819737076759338,
-0.22229017317295074,
0.06749442964792252,
-0.09426750987768173,
0.45193400979042053,
0.32608774304389954,
-0.5584309101104736,
0.013146246783435345,
0.04733280465006828,
0.3279944658279419,
0.8653650879859924,
0.0796908363699913,
0.583753228187561,
-0.6545957326889038,
0.37075871229171753,
0.18181639909744263,
0.4909024238586426,
0.23094619810581207,
-0.7244101166725159,
-0.503092348575592,
-0.26001468300819397,
0.2608257830142975,
0.7661520838737488,
-0.1161022037267685,
0.7557905316352844,
-0.28901493549346924,
-0.4704807698726654,
-0.4011673033237457,
-0.06457861512899399,
0.4740716814994812,
0.5139660239219666,
0.24599257111549377,
-0.4469899535179138,
-0.47158125042915344,
-0.8980695009231567,
-0.14134733378887177,
-0.6422537565231323,
-0.03921198844909668,
-0.007197368424385786,
0.3198089301586151,
-0.18400336802005768,
1.1341291666030884,
-0.23588737845420837,
-0.24880436062812805,
0.20787692070007324,
0.1572878509759903,
-0.1409176141023636,
0.6116211414337158,
0.5895732641220093,
-0.7100833058357239,
-0.3715195655822754,
-0.027963852509856224,
-0.8539698123931885,
-0.24096348881721497,
0.08454882353544235,
-0.26967552304267883,
0.3137308955192566,
0.4392624497413635,
-0.4810829162597656,
0.6985461115837097,
0.4668228328227997,
-0.28019148111343384,
0.17759746313095093,
-0.019502539187669754,
0.2791317403316498,
-1.0564814805984497,
-0.20537272095680237,
0.13192230463027954,
-0.011967071332037449,
-0.7057328820228577,
-0.7215971350669861,
0.012777482159435749,
0.1969396471977234,
-0.33060067892074585,
0.2690557837486267,
-0.21918588876724243,
-0.13184411823749542,
-0.14410315454006195,
0.4598766565322876,
-0.3651900589466095,
0.1778690665960312,
-0.026323068886995316,
0.8915207386016846,
0.22060929238796234,
-0.2538045644760132,
0.06714516133069992,
0.5554313659667969,
-0.16285493969917297,
0.64127516746521,
-0.529371440410614,
0.37337997555732727,
0.08698227256536484,
0.3344011902809143,
-1.231435775756836,
-0.5172709822654724,
0.3731902539730072,
-0.5772438049316406,
-0.0005280862096697092,
-0.13910144567489624,
-0.43972235918045044,
-0.2620774209499359,
-0.45604684948921204,
0.3178540766239166,
0.6027811765670776,
-0.08665315806865692,
0.30594244599342346,
0.8075266480445862,
-0.32275721430778503,
-0.6507256627082825,
-0.6613075137138367,
0.12156705558300018,
-0.7524527311325073,
-0.601806640625,
0.044338058680295944,
-0.12207476794719696,
-0.4867006242275238,
-0.3481295704841614,
-0.17630766332149506,
0.05977093055844307,
0.2274744212627411,
0.6986731290817261,
0.4510628283023834,
0.1765444278717041,
0.19253715872764587,
-0.4497717022895813,
-0.2527918219566345,
0.24827246367931366,
0.360222190618515,
0.3542008101940155,
-0.1891905665397644,
-0.5151864886283875,
-0.43752002716064453,
0.0439009815454483,
0.28392869234085083,
0.1873072236776352,
0.6600877642631531,
0.49692752957344055,
-0.3847047984600067,
0.7889414429664612,
-0.6546766757965088,
-0.15187859535217285,
-0.482354998588562,
0.19746030867099762,
0.013004954904317856,
-1.1164212226867676,
0.72910475730896,
0.3579748272895813,
0.2116961032152176,
0.38221704959869385,
0.5181839466094971,
-0.5655513405799866,
1.0625618696212769,
0.41343268752098083,
-0.24583125114440918,
0.6345193386077881,
0.39729195833206177,
0.27714306116104126,
-0.5641204714775085,
-0.3496875464916229,
-0.3766387701034546,
-0.5776394605636597,
-1.0214020013809204,
-0.03733832761645317,
0.370109498500824,
-0.013687108643352985,
-0.5778271555900574,
0.18493399024009705,
-0.5673773884773254,
0.5624865293502808,
0.4328635036945343,
0.11610295623540878,
0.22819185256958008,
-0.1186748594045639,
0.18895192444324493,
-0.34890028834342957,
-0.4005866050720215,
-0.8536937236785889,
1.1243743896484375,
0.44237881898880005,
0.6280451416969299,
0.3080608546733856,
0.8075534701347351,
0.14601412415504456,
0.5190722942352295,
-0.370570570230484,
0.5821688771247864,
0.18944767117500305,
-0.8604316711425781,
-0.38744670152664185,
-0.37188249826431274,
-0.905800998210907,
-0.0033717334736138582,
-0.6026861667633057,
-1.0314911603927612,
-0.08044810593128204,
0.31204283237457275,
-0.3622131943702698,
0.10084977746009827,
-0.7757331132888794,
0.8189451694488525,
-0.6188113689422607,
-0.16338442265987396,
0.2633107304573059,
-1.1583069562911987,
0.45587366819381714,
-0.34431612491607666,
0.2472653090953827,
-0.6084786057472229,
-0.10097631812095642,
0.9908978343009949,
-0.22670878469944,
1.0530683994293213,
0.0379883274435997,
-0.11190271377563477,
0.2634788751602173,
-0.18404269218444824,
0.1753700077533722,
-0.0868607610464096,
0.049882713705301285,
0.5561733245849609,
-0.12290482968091965,
-0.19051654636859894,
-0.4068549871444702,
0.4043312072753906,
-0.8801427483558655,
-0.6698163747787476,
-0.7547374367713928,
-0.6665375232696533,
-0.1149357259273529,
-0.04719594493508339,
0.27847468852996826,
0.06595875322818756,
-0.16539330780506134,
-0.04174806550145149,
0.3028470277786255,
0.01911303959786892,
0.39008480310440063,
0.21854284405708313,
-0.21530751883983612,
-0.6431061625480652,
0.5522240996360779,
0.06333988159894943,
0.3366817831993103,
0.26450803875923157,
0.08612456172704697,
-0.5020890235900879,
-0.5146628022193909,
-0.1956814080476761,
0.199810191988945,
-0.7625481486320496,
-0.2529957890510559,
-0.5728641152381897,
-0.22118666768074036,
-0.24390444159507751,
-0.20264148712158203,
-0.07488589733839035,
-0.4074273705482483,
-0.17598986625671387,
-0.5252515077590942,
0.8338196873664856,
0.7534428238868713,
-0.2108118087053299,
0.514908492565155,
-0.5654541850090027,
-0.1282394826412201,
0.30131956934928894,
0.15861350297927856,
-0.5984473824501038,
-0.42605844140052795,
-0.0969390869140625,
0.09985142201185226,
-0.385821670293808,
-0.8116804957389832,
-0.10780519992113113,
-0.2896028757095337,
0.35431548953056335,
0.5701301097869873,
0.31922876834869385,
0.8977222442626953,
-0.4209630787372589,
0.8746574521064758,
0.6156463623046875,
-0.6210411787033081,
0.16218428313732147,
-0.546383798122406,
-0.1493513137102127,
0.8110370635986328,
0.4831143617630005,
-0.5122726559638977,
-0.4084323048591614,
-0.5837348699569702,
-0.8028636574745178,
0.3159559369087219,
0.44081273674964905,
0.07168561965227127,
-0.18103376030921936,
0.32142820954322815,
0.049807436764240265,
-0.1203230768442154,
-0.7493358850479126,
-0.1442292183637619,
-0.10382305830717087,
-0.6112496852874756,
-0.15930312871932983,
-0.40467560291290283,
-0.6746190190315247,
-0.02069726586341858,
0.12332190573215485,
-0.01904519461095333,
0.37760108709335327,
-0.27081242203712463,
0.17505870759487152,
-0.11166145652532578,
0.08425930142402649,
0.9251117706298828,
0.7365125417709351,
-0.33593982458114624,
0.39537280797958374,
0.5143749117851257,
-0.6002310514450073,
0.3486853837966919,
0.11341720074415207,
0.18585650622844696,
-0.45888471603393555,
0.50870281457901,
0.477983295917511,
0.18207253515720367,
-0.27183109521865845,
0.7004625797271729,
-0.27144041657447815,
-0.3019818067550659,
-0.4552519619464874,
0.4199658930301666,
0.18625281751155853,
0.30410900712013245,
0.17102546989917755,
-0.1299828439950943,
-0.12050095945596695,
-0.20923668146133423,
0.22985094785690308,
0.4853810966014862,
-0.32888349890708923,
-0.3567436635494232,
0.9219874739646912,
0.6738291382789612,
-0.7266885638237,
0.5281091928482056,
0.02103784866631031,
-0.5572327375411987,
0.4178597331047058,
0.11660812795162201,
0.8626434803009033,
-0.10557523369789124,
-0.2217273861169815,
0.414924681186676,
0.47289493680000305,
0.011121099814772606,
0.12545070052146912,
0.19620995223522186,
-0.802471935749054,
-0.32245635986328125,
-0.20664137601852417,
-0.8249707818031311,
-0.11836490035057068,
-0.5850154757499695,
0.16983143985271454,
-0.25818362832069397,
-0.532551109790802,
-0.10321474075317383,
-0.16761527955532074,
-0.606164813041687,
0.16365550458431244,
0.17192652821540833,
0.4326896071434021,
-1.0775591135025024,
0.5032714605331421,
0.6159698963165283,
-0.4943386912345886,
-0.5516656041145325,
0.38336506485939026,
0.3688156008720398,
-0.7286004424095154,
0.6004507541656494,
0.4265654385089874,
-0.06323190778493881,
-0.41189804673194885,
-0.4738087058067322,
-0.9078752994537354,
1.1981562376022339,
0.3847752511501312,
-0.6847390532493591,
0.09620554000139236,
0.43638017773628235,
0.6304728984832764,
-0.222500741481781,
0.31683310866355896,
0.6003856658935547,
0.34717756509780884,
-0.09802942723035812,
-1.3045159578323364,
-0.08469624817371368,
-0.06936141103506088,
-0.014012639410793781,
0.31873413920402527,
-0.607200562953949,
0.4352830946445465,
-0.2850531339645386,
-0.2918822169303894,
-0.10887804627418518,
0.5756292343139648,
0.45044606924057007,
0.5166780352592468,
0.7523916959762573,
0.4555114507675171,
0.8260220289230347,
-0.33528798818588257,
0.8924095034599304,
-0.2811903655529022,
0.21468621492385864,
1.0901843309402466,
-0.41986382007598877,
0.6363370418548584,
0.40795770287513733,
-0.38473615050315857,
0.20487454533576965,
0.9048609137535095,
0.40594178438186646,
0.3206130266189575,
0.043213434517383575,
-0.2507404386997223,
-0.2577211260795593,
0.1548720896244049,
-0.38632526993751526,
0.5011583566665649,
0.2951458990573883,
-0.230327770113945,
0.2562096416950226,
-0.47751227021217346,
0.30783793330192566,
-0.14788025617599487,
0.14269118010997772,
1.1192070245742798,
0.0430259108543396,
-0.48260441422462463,
0.24917671084403992,
-0.5696099400520325,
0.6687346696853638,
-0.36182498931884766,
0.17142033576965332,
-0.1613152027130127,
-0.00914489571005106,
-0.3912852108478546,
-1.3128100633621216,
0.28927138447761536,
0.07808911800384521,
0.11853992938995361,
-0.022142140194773674,
0.5428355932235718,
-0.38778236508369446,
-0.14003337919712067,
0.22267793118953705,
0.3205498158931732,
0.4827829897403717,
0.41115620732307434,
-0.5488188862800598,
0.30181315541267395,
-0.0079738674685359,
-0.015457912348210812,
0.4795192778110504,
0.45617586374282837,
-0.3436628580093384,
0.6035972833633423,
0.6739652156829834,
-0.29231926798820496,
0.17296597361564636,
-0.15774066746234894,
0.6226547956466675,
-0.8241745233535767,
-0.49589234590530396,
-1.1551812887191772,
0.6792665123939514,
-0.5013763904571533,
-0.5554784536361694,
0.6835318803787231,
0.41035279631614685,
0.7182778716087341,
0.4097825884819031,
0.8701305985450745,
0.14504064619541168,
0.42255809903144836,
-0.49243101477622986,
0.5472051501274109,
-0.0027177610900253057,
0.21620343625545502,
-0.4272792935371399,
-0.9655798077583313,
-0.5185656547546387,
0.9548730850219727,
-0.598035454750061,
0.2400258481502533,
0.4754386842250824,
0.8281707763671875,
0.25050151348114014,
0.30650684237480164,
0.16609808802604675,
-0.20319105684757233,
0.5268998146057129,
0.2747827172279358,
1.1230145692825317,
-0.022562498226761818,
0.6599874496459961,
-0.2699688971042633,
-0.2295006960630417,
-0.38291269540786743,
-1.285841703414917,
-1.062517762184143,
-0.44097715616226196,
-0.5885518789291382,
-0.2699677646160126,
0.019836220890283585,
0.9471325278282166,
0.5276848673820496,
-0.5680904984474182,
-0.11470971256494522,
0.1220286637544632,
-0.10309746861457825,
0.047443587332963943,
-0.16991470754146576,
0.2550656199455261,
-0.0878695547580719,
-0.4665223956108093,
-0.10940173268318176,
0.19800767302513123,
0.47823280096054077,
-0.05094679445028305,
-0.27114373445510864,
0.12668877840042114,
-0.14498725533485413,
0.3128376603126526,
0.12250299751758575,
-0.7417515516281128,
-0.8894786834716797,
-0.43221569061279297,
-0.40087205171585083,
0.2503001391887665,
0.49045073986053467,
-0.25687283277511597,
0.40743836760520935,
0.2481423318386078,
0.48550575971603394,
0.2244933545589447,
0.38123366236686707,
0.5056959390640259,
-0.7031368017196655,
0.09055278450250626,
0.10468753427267075,
0.3814365267753601,
0.6700311899185181,
-0.42833787202835083,
0.9180020093917847,
0.06339523196220398,
-1.094765543937683,
-0.7800287008285522,
0.22356390953063965,
-1.1980549097061157,
0.4502154588699341,
1.257428765296936,
0.060445111244916916,
0.1293656826019287,
-0.4108177125453949,
-0.329059898853302,
0.3082984387874603,
-0.5973316431045532,
0.9743021130561829,
0.6445240378379822,
-0.5646970272064209,
-0.11577597260475159,
-0.6709097027778625,
0.6602218747138977,
0.07755366712808609,
-0.9638256430625916,
0.11440618336200714,
0.4213000535964966,
0.3885883092880249,
0.5070671439170837,
0.7123429179191589,
0.026534654200077057,
0.29642441868782043,
-0.16902092099189758,
0.22419768571853638,
-0.0000657478958601132,
0.05781896039843559,
-0.28569453954696655,
-0.20847100019454956,
0.12673009932041168,
-0.4903741180896759
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.06366v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.06366v2
|
Symmetric Dot-Product Attention for Efficient Training of BERT Language Models
| 2024-06-10T15:24:15 | 2024-06-19T10:42:15 |
Martin Courtois, Malte Ostendorff, Leonhard Hennig, Georg Rehm
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Initially introduced as a machine translation model, the Transformer
architecture has now become the foundation for modern deep learning
architecture, with applications in a wide range of fields, from computer vision
to natural language processing. Nowadays, to tackle increasingly more complex
tasks, Transformer-based models are stretched to enormous sizes, requiring
increasingly larger training datasets, and unsustainable amount of compute
resources. The ubiquitous nature of the Transformer and its core component, the
attention mechanism, are thus prime targets for efficiency research. In this
work, we propose an alternative compatibility function for the self-attention
mechanism introduced by the Transformer architecture. This compatibility
function exploits an overlap in the learned representation of the traditional
scaled dot-product attention, leading to a symmetric with pairwise coefficient
dot-product attention. When applied to the pre-training of BERT-like models,
this new symmetric attention mechanism reaches a score of 79.36 on the GLUE
benchmark against 78.74 for the traditional implementation, leads to a
reduction of 6% in the number of trainable parameters, and reduces the number
of training steps required before convergence by half.
|
[
-0.5532655119895935,
-0.32608428597450256,
0.424305260181427,
0.36587056517601013,
-0.38276371359825134,
-0.29986315965652466,
-0.40196096897125244,
-0.3706960678100586,
0.271171510219574,
0.0759568065404892,
-0.6453478336334229,
-0.18547385931015015,
-0.533257007598877,
-0.12031019479036331,
-0.20704981684684753,
0.7606812715530396,
-0.11044683307409286,
0.06917138397693634,
-0.3003244996070862,
-0.1472620666027069,
-0.16832266747951508,
-0.46620285511016846,
-0.33611613512039185,
-0.3164692521095276,
0.6236003637313843,
0.2255467027425766,
0.6859265565872192,
0.5225740671157837,
0.919490396976471,
0.39840418100357056,
0.2228202223777771,
-0.08506970852613449,
-0.8010647892951965,
0.21132627129554749,
-0.01608850434422493,
-0.23254236578941345,
-0.6556265354156494,
0.009712177328765392,
0.6740714907646179,
0.6530482172966003,
0.049900926649570465,
0.33625343441963196,
0.645047664642334,
0.8347334861755371,
-0.678493082523346,
0.29631730914115906,
-0.5587491393089294,
0.05715791508555412,
0.022520849481225014,
0.40673622488975525,
-0.5106395483016968,
-0.35008925199508667,
0.24553446471691132,
-0.6394160389900208,
0.18940480053424835,
-0.2970466911792755,
1.0014417171478271,
0.5592069029808044,
-0.01863337866961956,
0.15825814008712769,
-0.6763477921485901,
1.1063836812973022,
-0.5634353756904602,
0.8199613690376282,
0.1297447383403778,
0.4536761939525604,
0.09491968899965286,
-0.7782660722732544,
-0.4920056164264679,
0.10895922034978867,
-0.10571378469467163,
0.2179781049489975,
-0.48060342669487,
0.008622935973107815,
-0.09263403713703156,
0.3864484131336212,
-0.5536843538284302,
-0.06024031713604927,
-0.1795804649591446,
-0.020854495465755463,
0.39265942573547363,
0.049374569207429886,
-0.06448128819465637,
0.04020977392792702,
-0.6215029954910278,
-0.16721971333026886,
-0.508682370185852,
0.05368772894144058,
0.28054454922676086,
0.3093182146549225,
0.01051879208534956,
0.3672734797000885,
-0.0011762453941628337,
0.8007053136825562,
0.7091267704963684,
0.24122647941112518,
0.321494460105896,
-0.14388588070869446,
-0.3913685083389282,
-0.11080295592546463,
0.571681559085846,
0.24505184590816498,
0.46105480194091797,
-0.2997998297214508,
-0.14923085272312164,
0.08072216808795929,
0.6087719202041626,
-0.9096716642379761,
-0.3495377004146576,
0.02180914767086506,
-0.7465774416923523,
-0.09939692169427872,
-0.12973198294639587,
-0.4982408881187439,
0.281850129365921,
-0.4670739471912384,
0.5718263983726501,
-0.5411802530288696,
-0.06947202235460281,
0.1724918931722641,
0.21705855429172516,
0.5291776657104492,
-0.08591899275779724,
-0.9496562480926514,
0.20960460603237152,
0.83683180809021,
0.47093695402145386,
-0.28230392932891846,
-0.08378060162067413,
-0.49239152669906616,
0.15594974160194397,
-0.1663513481616974,
0.7829216122627258,
-0.6430765390396118,
-0.0709499642252922,
-0.1158328652381897,
-0.17251363396644592,
-0.40831008553504944,
-0.3651440143585205,
0.7852708101272583,
-0.5772866606712341,
0.2904219627380371,
-0.22908231616020203,
-0.7030843496322632,
-0.2623382806777954,
0.1559789627790451,
-0.547609806060791,
1.014552116394043,
0.002035637851804495,
-0.6927808523178101,
0.34852901101112366,
-0.4234825372695923,
-0.5996833443641663,
0.054583657532930374,
-0.06005498021841049,
-1.0738908052444458,
0.11812535673379898,
0.23355671763420105,
0.43401819467544556,
-0.09734682738780975,
0.12902715802192688,
-0.8687347769737244,
-0.3162248730659485,
0.017561759799718857,
-0.22941190004348755,
0.7958321571350098,
0.19516904652118683,
-0.5114461183547974,
-0.0054086968302726746,
-0.646848201751709,
0.07482223957777023,
0.1170552596449852,
-0.11075705289840698,
-0.39062339067459106,
-0.1490429937839508,
-0.06304717063903809,
0.27224600315093994,
0.6572125554084778,
-0.683199942111969,
-0.05522802472114563,
-0.40028253197669983,
0.07745779305696487,
0.8419854640960693,
-0.28703564405441284,
0.5121304392814636,
-0.050897467881441116,
0.4174727201461792,
-0.12471560388803482,
0.5714468955993652,
-0.05337148159742355,
-0.4336411952972412,
-1.1636192798614502,
-0.6832219362258911,
0.4002915322780609,
0.10034490376710892,
-0.4073106348514557,
0.9278507232666016,
-0.2543642222881317,
-0.5264629125595093,
-0.8822338581085205,
0.19314423203468323,
0.5235002040863037,
0.5788974761962891,
0.30276766419410706,
-0.39133012294769287,
-0.4812837541103363,
-1.2201685905456543,
-0.380806565284729,
0.09213882684707642,
-0.05289952829480171,
0.4164227247238159,
-0.0022810513619333506,
0.027085712179541588,
1.1182265281677246,
-0.4132964015007019,
-0.5890334248542786,
-0.3517729938030243,
-0.0847015380859375,
0.5819190740585327,
0.28847187757492065,
0.7275817394256592,
-0.5984305739402771,
-1.1606758832931519,
-0.13108490407466888,
-0.6348317861557007,
-0.046362634748220444,
0.04013056680560112,
-0.09902014583349228,
0.22217752039432526,
0.2203914225101471,
-0.7218742370605469,
0.3103863298892975,
0.61042320728302,
-0.1408648043870926,
0.1977202445268631,
-0.07115906476974487,
-0.23270250856876373,
-0.9740394949913025,
0.20288322865962982,
0.037978626787662506,
-0.230190247297287,
-0.8317424058914185,
-0.047968339174985886,
0.358322411775589,
-0.13322483003139496,
-0.37218862771987915,
0.33255860209465027,
-0.6947912573814392,
-0.04598000645637512,
-0.18278980255126953,
0.024286191910505295,
-0.08136632293462753,
0.8216080665588379,
-0.04414795711636543,
0.6660979986190796,
0.8352372050285339,
-0.5464059114456177,
0.12376636266708374,
0.3396708369255066,
0.029994940385222435,
0.763343870639801,
-0.8423473238945007,
0.1613471359014511,
-0.03203614801168442,
-0.05473620072007179,
-1.1285806894302368,
0.27706030011177063,
0.34079480171203613,
-0.4705970287322998,
0.43730035424232483,
0.10881435126066208,
-0.4387703835964203,
-0.5067025423049927,
-0.4821597933769226,
0.3832663595676422,
0.6681687831878662,
-0.8971465229988098,
0.9529346823692322,
0.2230258285999298,
0.03586750105023384,
-0.4598415493965149,
-0.4549494683742523,
-0.17942951619625092,
-0.18599702417850494,
-0.9189853668212891,
0.2331620305776596,
0.008644389919936657,
0.17850378155708313,
0.2288064956665039,
-0.336652547121048,
-0.008339050225913525,
-0.1057683676481247,
-0.11485342681407928,
0.348764568567276,
-0.36635076999664307,
0.07109501212835312,
-0.2970298230648041,
-0.42412981390953064,
0.08956768363714218,
-0.4387059509754181,
0.5358445048332214,
-0.10329804569482803,
-0.5328819751739502,
-0.6211591958999634,
0.3624056875705719,
0.4692456126213074,
-0.457997590303421,
0.8291320204734802,
0.7375984191894531,
-0.059767015278339386,
-0.1816881000995636,
-0.6822006106376648,
-0.43078067898750305,
-0.5827335715293884,
0.30946075916290283,
-0.5542801022529602,
-0.5666010975837708,
0.3964243233203888,
0.2402714043855667,
-0.09257494658231735,
0.4723671078681946,
0.6269828677177429,
-0.2517922520637512,
1.0470091104507446,
0.6962684988975525,
-0.3049915134906769,
0.6757467985153198,
0.03182537853717804,
0.7078853249549866,
-0.7329226732254028,
-0.0016702708089724183,
-0.22684147953987122,
-0.7877005338668823,
-0.2765439748764038,
-0.30566298961639404,
0.44273459911346436,
-0.25082844495773315,
-0.19064734876155853,
0.7343212366104126,
-0.6040670275688171,
0.3115684986114502,
0.7769191861152649,
0.13420887291431427,
0.06829200685024261,
0.17616017162799835,
-0.036821138113737106,
-0.421660840511322,
-0.7473810911178589,
0.002880802610889077,
1.2237985134124756,
0.44764330983161926,
0.9223558306694031,
-0.10586752742528915,
0.8452975153923035,
-0.014509974978864193,
-0.05821854621171951,
-0.6153311729431152,
0.6737403273582458,
-0.4363110661506653,
-0.39944204688072205,
-0.21443673968315125,
-0.3160479664802551,
-0.8795380592346191,
0.19999626278877258,
0.0907822698354721,
-0.3846161365509033,
0.5618289709091187,
0.295662522315979,
-0.1519557237625122,
0.10380718857049942,
-0.9124748706817627,
1.1418241262435913,
-0.25094810128211975,
-0.28774070739746094,
-0.49159204959869385,
-0.6797515749931335,
0.12994246184825897,
-0.158047154545784,
-0.3508700728416443,
0.013979477807879448,
0.11405188590288162,
0.40496259927749634,
-0.18964456021785736,
1.0607082843780518,
-0.20659027993679047,
-0.07340013980865479,
-0.00019186112331226468,
-0.1041984036564827,
0.8250352144241333,
-0.39338645339012146,
0.17278677225112915,
0.22426636517047882,
-0.7448999881744385,
-0.5210098624229431,
-0.5749455690383911,
0.4180337190628052,
-0.6724242568016052,
-0.6678234338760376,
-0.17434722185134888,
-0.5149430632591248,
-0.1977565586566925,
0.2200040966272354,
0.16750285029411316,
0.09822618216276169,
-0.17240583896636963,
0.39269542694091797,
0.8958452939987183,
0.33593273162841797,
0.6067007780075073,
0.5773986577987671,
0.08960787206888199,
-0.25672808289527893,
1.058609127998352,
-0.11565430462360382,
0.3537764847278595,
0.32680413126945496,
-0.06630317121744156,
-0.30923059582710266,
-0.1622636765241623,
-0.06249053031206131,
0.44258251786231995,
-0.40522342920303345,
-0.3707846403121948,
-0.7301077842712402,
-0.5010237693786621,
-0.3924507200717926,
-0.03727482259273529,
-0.6961824893951416,
-0.6089754700660706,
-0.25930672883987427,
0.18626025319099426,
0.1083550676703453,
0.3216388523578644,
-0.1787666231393814,
0.20089401304721832,
-0.5815430879592896,
0.4293830692768097,
0.7974512577056885,
0.7972492575645447,
-0.02179202437400818,
-0.6195342540740967,
-0.4475294053554535,
-0.3265434205532074,
-0.4441407024860382,
-0.6959431171417236,
0.1481352150440216,
0.5533992648124695,
0.9737271666526794,
0.7012240290641785,
0.2105715572834015,
0.4975516200065613,
-0.6622305512428284,
0.2114957869052887,
0.27779504656791687,
-0.9642414450645447,
0.27235257625579834,
-0.19754183292388916,
0.23639008402824402,
0.2730823755264282,
0.3233334720134735,
-0.2866857647895813,
-0.6041396260261536,
-0.5531949400901794,
-0.562159538269043,
0.7223932147026062,
0.5429155826568604,
0.10081405192613602,
0.19825048744678497,
-0.10193639248609543,
-0.004842518828809261,
-0.12892383337020874,
-0.7420722246170044,
-0.4319702088832855,
-0.33633100986480713,
-0.47670692205429077,
0.07930769771337509,
-0.28748685121536255,
0.014362908899784088,
-0.14480029046535492,
0.8357479572296143,
-0.046419907361269,
0.4288947880268097,
0.14194156229496002,
-0.15554167330265045,
-0.087879978120327,
0.03647594153881073,
0.22509214282035828,
0.22589649260044098,
-0.14890894293785095,
0.07701064646244049,
-0.040631331503391266,
-0.4057186245918274,
-0.08585664629936218,
0.456941157579422,
-0.09768220782279968,
0.20099662244319916,
-0.032792408019304276,
0.6634692549705505,
0.2941795885562897,
-0.15160927176475525,
0.5255827903747559,
-0.005952916108071804,
-0.21098995208740234,
0.016546674072742462,
-0.0982816070318222,
0.31496670842170715,
0.48975491523742676,
0.27418407797813416,
0.0755322128534317,
0.40974414348602295,
0.060100849717855453,
0.5386417508125305,
0.6960400342941284,
-0.6763414740562439,
-0.3916579782962799,
0.6438075304031372,
0.4261682331562042,
-0.2704566717147827,
0.3332167863845825,
-0.09101910889148712,
-0.6667675971984863,
0.48210641741752625,
0.5353946685791016,
1.3441026210784912,
-0.6326869130134583,
0.1221964880824089,
0.2979296147823334,
0.2832941710948944,
0.3165903389453888,
0.08907928317785263,
-0.315917432308197,
-0.5644630789756775,
-0.3151733875274658,
-0.5580694675445557,
-0.09329748898744583,
-0.28822776675224304,
-0.643364667892456,
0.3803946077823639,
-0.062018685042858124,
-0.21837930381298065,
-0.05506136640906334,
-0.36691519618034363,
-0.6817735433578491,
0.12167967855930328,
0.4006253480911255,
0.6068986058235168,
-0.7713278532028198,
1.1112076044082642,
0.4902711510658264,
-0.19444392621517181,
-0.48454388976097107,
0.02833518199622631,
-0.3480936884880066,
-1.0131474733352661,
0.6285422444343567,
0.3123570382595062,
-0.26218271255493164,
-0.08956457674503326,
-0.051810525357723236,
-1.0365409851074219,
0.715709924697876,
0.6790472865104675,
-0.7583814263343811,
0.07131210714578629,
0.4480383098125458,
0.6079261302947998,
-0.37932512164115906,
-0.1237567663192749,
0.5170347094535828,
0.4794107675552368,
-0.17373599112033844,
-0.7414197325706482,
-0.06291963160037994,
-0.3438846468925476,
0.2402462512254715,
0.3159189522266388,
-0.8833083510398865,
0.7368173599243164,
0.11847787350416183,
-0.20218345522880554,
-0.14739525318145752,
0.9500628113746643,
0.0783984437584877,
-0.19114290177822113,
0.829692006111145,
0.9500100612640381,
0.12508873641490936,
0.011283447965979576,
0.6441559791564941,
-0.5755449533462524,
0.7591307759284973,
1.0282331705093384,
-0.19912472367286682,
0.8250190019607544,
0.6677791476249695,
-0.3693441152572632,
0.31913453340530396,
0.4540933072566986,
-0.34120243787765503,
0.7489569187164307,
-0.0881139487028122,
-0.12230642139911652,
-0.6390892863273621,
0.005090004298835993,
-0.4898965060710907,
0.30550193786621094,
-0.11522812396287918,
-0.42361846566200256,
-0.4134632647037506,
-0.1895020306110382,
-0.26650726795196533,
0.14278747141361237,
-0.03915904834866524,
0.8259185552597046,
0.1712372750043869,
-0.4389861226081848,
0.610405445098877,
-0.4536674916744232,
0.47045430541038513,
-0.568103551864624,
0.06690815091133118,
-0.3614858388900757,
0.7701629996299744,
0.03214484453201294,
-0.6939932703971863,
0.3457656800746918,
-0.22328458726406097,
-0.40727582573890686,
-0.33293476700782776,
0.740244448184967,
-0.6077896356582642,
-0.7598071694374084,
0.611197292804718,
0.06197509542107582,
-0.19846564531326294,
-0.2013970911502838,
-0.8703495264053345,
0.018709475174546242,
0.034749723970890045,
-0.3158521056175232,
0.20854757726192474,
0.3583363890647888,
0.5362818837165833,
0.5685752034187317,
0.38323140144348145,
-0.3312140703201294,
0.35018855333328247,
0.008427186869084835,
1.0817338228225708,
-0.2966858744621277,
-0.8268832564353943,
-0.7893707752227783,
0.46269655227661133,
-0.31635794043540955,
0.051762644201517105,
0.8341593742370605,
0.6564754247665405,
0.5919270515441895,
-0.19498048722743988,
0.4546799063682556,
0.075869619846344,
0.6316714286804199,
-0.10174079984426498,
0.7717545032501221,
-0.5625293254852295,
0.16317038238048553,
-0.2336042821407318,
-1.3604519367218018,
-0.297104150056839,
0.5562753677368164,
-0.30405065417289734,
0.13333943486213684,
0.6039673089981079,
0.48322194814682007,
-0.5073474645614624,
-0.08751185983419418,
0.3644079566001892,
0.17938317358493805,
0.17656047642230988,
0.7589647173881531,
0.3334031403064728,
-0.4812474548816681,
0.9747152924537659,
-0.28984197974205017,
-0.1899625062942505,
-0.29176923632621765,
-0.6839027404785156,
-1.1217647790908813,
-0.48688963055610657,
-0.20623598992824554,
-0.04860774800181389,
0.34456291794776917,
0.46892014145851135,
0.8729344010353088,
-0.9151396751403809,
-0.1160750538110733,
-0.018969839438796043,
-0.16564030945301056,
-0.41402897238731384,
-0.1742091178894043,
0.5684863328933716,
-1.0172806978225708,
-0.8771252036094666,
0.05629497021436691,
0.4313713312149048,
-0.1974686086177826,
-0.29531848430633545,
-0.16350366175174713,
-0.04034240543842316,
0.013404135592281818,
0.4108584225177765,
0.13485075533390045,
-0.6696696877479553,
-0.19900532066822052,
0.2730172574520111,
-0.22480106353759766,
0.4775215685367584,
0.6643601059913635,
-0.6641756892204285,
0.6272459626197815,
0.46683046221733093,
1.068115472793579,
0.6891767382621765,
-0.14508643746376038,
0.8981584310531616,
-0.743037760257721,
0.22622114419937134,
0.21232543885707855,
0.29987451434135437,
0.3460092544555664,
-0.3000582754611969,
0.30147770047187805,
0.08426518738269806,
-0.5665574073791504,
-0.41808512806892395,
0.2779151499271393,
-1.1124874353408813,
-0.09045451134443283,
0.7116877436637878,
-0.41141775250434875,
-0.4714338183403015,
0.04832323640584946,
-0.054132647812366486,
0.24446852505207062,
-0.5421571135520935,
1.0647648572921753,
0.5231132507324219,
-0.007790120784193277,
-0.2205761820077896,
0.18737463653087616,
0.369308203458786,
0.9506210684776306,
-0.4013223648071289,
0.08799050748348236,
-0.03278588503599167,
0.07431554049253464,
0.20661750435829163,
0.050553515553474426,
-0.0014778340701013803,
0.4841717481613159,
-0.13004159927368164,
0.44292470812797546,
0.15784570574760437,
-0.29545044898986816,
-0.36480727791786194,
0.15148282051086426,
-0.3023330271244049,
-0.7796394228935242
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10256v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10256v1
|
Explicit Word Density Estimation for Language Modelling
| 2024-06-10T15:21:33 | 2024-06-10T15:21:33 |
Jovan Andonov, Octavian Ganea, Paulina Grnarova, Gary Bécigneul, Thomas Hofmann
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Language Modelling has been a central part of Natural Language Processing for
a very long time and in the past few years LSTM-based language models have been
the go-to method for commercial language modeling. Recently, it has been shown
that when looking at language modelling from a matrix factorization point of
view, the final Softmax layer limits the expressiveness of the model, by
putting an upper bound on the rank of the resulting matrix. Additionally, a new
family of neural networks based called NeuralODEs, has been introduced as a
continuous alternative to Residual Networks. Moreover, it has been shown that
there is a connection between these models and Normalizing Flows. In this work
we propose a new family of language models based on NeuralODEs and the
continuous analogue of Normalizing Flows and manage to improve on some of the
baselines.
|
[
-0.1678079068660736,
-0.8910911083221436,
0.5145354866981506,
-0.030320892110466957,
-0.34882381558418274,
-0.027411961928009987,
-0.5951100587844849,
-0.2999880015850067,
0.18390458822250366,
0.6845018863677979,
-0.22981201112270355,
-0.6411544680595398,
-0.636954128742218,
-0.010243725031614304,
-0.5150727033615112,
0.4961377680301666,
-0.040977708995342255,
0.1320805847644806,
0.19264847040176392,
-0.49089229106903076,
-0.20091943442821503,
-0.4827975332736969,
-0.7330849766731262,
-0.43788278102874756,
0.5641511678695679,
0.049439687281847,
1.0981080532073975,
0.6514796018600464,
0.08928941190242767,
0.41165199875831604,
-0.515823245048523,
-0.07029648125171661,
-0.24245019257068634,
0.34536829590797424,
0.19537948071956635,
-0.17368409037590027,
-0.3525662124156952,
-0.11060229688882828,
0.9912610054016113,
1.1130927801132202,
-0.4997514486312866,
-0.23340710997581482,
-0.03682898357510567,
0.5207834243774414,
-0.7228063344955444,
-0.019069518893957138,
-0.46290549635887146,
0.2093229740858078,
0.08015882968902588,
-0.16817334294319153,
-0.3541315495967865,
-0.4850405156612396,
0.32625195384025574,
-0.134251207113266,
0.09346184134483337,
-0.16483812034130096,
0.7424740195274353,
0.0728447288274765,
-0.10231375694274902,
-0.4591526985168457,
-0.8453019261360168,
0.9460719227790833,
-1.272249460220337,
0.591860830783844,
0.31389379501342773,
0.17203116416931152,
-0.017415806651115417,
-0.69981449842453,
-0.47461020946502686,
-0.47813087701797485,
0.025522710755467415,
-0.13091985881328583,
-0.14725926518440247,
0.43745994567871094,
-0.14331190288066864,
0.2889364957809448,
-0.26498469710350037,
0.3586603105068207,
-0.1660979986190796,
-0.09904640167951584,
0.8163770437240601,
0.2543084919452667,
0.35354238748550415,
-0.10321421176195145,
-0.30693984031677246,
0.389159619808197,
-0.6037530303001404,
-0.16171352565288544,
0.25703972578048706,
0.32387790083885193,
-0.13766513764858246,
0.6683247685432434,
-0.24699951708316803,
0.8540920615196228,
-0.36329811811447144,
-0.09263114631175995,
0.08030137419700623,
-0.1630142629146576,
-0.44937339425086975,
-0.10317336767911911,
0.6633303165435791,
0.034631695598363876,
0.6873055100440979,
-0.26329466700553894,
-0.6018087267875671,
-0.07367153465747833,
-0.15375272929668427,
-0.7756754159927368,
-0.13981162011623383,
0.2678064703941345,
-0.27923083305358887,
-0.4001119136810303,
-0.37795549631118774,
-0.6306573748588562,
-0.6507760882377625,
-0.3521110415458679,
0.32092103362083435,
-0.4761938154697418,
-0.7012841105461121,
0.29672738909721375,
0.07691305875778198,
0.05550089105963707,
0.07437095791101456,
-0.8126173615455627,
0.704411506652832,
0.545009434223175,
0.9799345135688782,
-0.08255374431610107,
-0.0272793248295784,
-0.18263976275920868,
-0.02289113961160183,
-0.5248565673828125,
0.8252542614936829,
-0.6342682838439941,
-0.3710903525352478,
0.31446728110313416,
-0.21730643510818481,
-0.06746985763311386,
-0.5601604580879211,
0.41557568311691284,
-0.5190751552581787,
0.1997283548116684,
0.23753736913204193,
-0.9451585412025452,
-0.2569206655025482,
0.1212989017367363,
-0.5290707945823669,
1.0394937992095947,
0.281141459941864,
-0.546276867389679,
0.18291175365447998,
-0.5684638023376465,
-0.12461665272712708,
0.27030521631240845,
-0.035824522376060486,
-0.22669100761413574,
0.3255799412727356,
0.006104237865656614,
0.7165593504905701,
-0.07894967496395111,
0.5541791915893555,
-0.21134427189826965,
-0.30800968408584595,
0.14895519614219666,
-0.4168876111507416,
0.8870337605476379,
0.3291850984096527,
-0.023995909839868546,
0.52823406457901,
-0.6103010773658752,
-0.06097494810819626,
-0.13019470870494843,
-0.30350372195243835,
-0.5461583733558655,
0.41879045963287354,
-0.07057834416627884,
0.03612997755408287,
0.14939554035663605,
-0.5663517713546753,
0.01056565809994936,
-0.7508542537689209,
0.5538305640220642,
0.7910619974136353,
-0.040116384625434875,
0.6681823134422302,
0.04569746181368828,
0.7592748999595642,
0.16428139805793762,
0.02266119420528412,
0.13724130392074585,
-0.4711608588695526,
-0.7376558780670166,
-0.23827344179153442,
0.534043550491333,
0.5331689715385437,
-0.483249306678772,
0.3470224142074585,
-0.5929927229881287,
-0.4445797801017761,
-0.3075349032878876,
0.37867823243141174,
0.16551043093204498,
0.24995087087154388,
0.03989487141370773,
-0.14009350538253784,
-0.5453571677207947,
-0.8106608986854553,
0.03030615858733654,
0.001391239115037024,
0.1401776820421219,
0.12309043109416962,
0.13741254806518555,
-0.17111030220985413,
1.0154087543487549,
-0.5750604271888733,
-0.046526215970516205,
-0.8475977182388306,
-0.04446778446435928,
0.3813234269618988,
0.38384056091308594,
0.4544556438922882,
-0.451000839471817,
-0.493490070104599,
0.041926052421331406,
-0.48836278915405273,
0.013592202216386795,
0.24374935030937195,
0.06591451913118362,
0.27453699707984924,
0.6244968175888062,
-0.5916374325752258,
0.16854216158390045,
0.8995466828346252,
-0.5116363763809204,
0.5171840190887451,
-0.32487642765045166,
-0.6676759719848633,
-1.1584843397140503,
-0.017942603677511215,
0.40224042534828186,
-0.4519900381565094,
-1.1238789558410645,
0.19207826256752014,
0.01896161213517189,
-0.22652047872543335,
-0.5485603213310242,
1.0133951902389526,
-0.81975919008255,
-0.1064457893371582,
-0.21144069731235504,
0.32222703099250793,
-0.10632134228944778,
0.5017052888870239,
0.04523654282093048,
0.7802331447601318,
0.7172422409057617,
-0.5592479109764099,
0.28862765431404114,
-0.07249464839696884,
-0.5283448100090027,
0.22953055799007416,
-0.7362236380577087,
-0.12382107228040695,
-0.27261024713516235,
-0.002743880497291684,
-0.9410476088523865,
0.08015509694814682,
-0.06753327697515488,
-0.2762114405632019,
0.5327951312065125,
-0.25041624903678894,
-0.3446997404098511,
-0.2288416028022766,
-0.26285338401794434,
0.09999397397041321,
0.7167547345161438,
-0.24332362413406372,
0.7585431933403015,
0.7513946294784546,
-0.5189798474311829,
-0.38483718037605286,
-0.5565869808197021,
0.25078001618385315,
-0.18225383758544922,
-0.8544000387191772,
0.14442983269691467,
-0.08631107211112976,
-0.4960894286632538,
0.14186330139636993,
0.3063349425792694,
-0.5707826018333435,
0.18102309107780457,
0.095002681016922,
0.2863672375679016,
-0.6336658000946045,
0.2640950679779053,
0.07673097401857376,
0.044496599584817886,
-0.0554019995033741,
-0.12191197276115417,
0.689376175403595,
-0.18895061314105988,
0.14319168031215668,
-0.23659081757068634,
0.19841687381267548,
0.29671013355255127,
-0.09718054533004761,
0.9040120244026184,
0.46472421288490295,
-0.651419997215271,
-0.4485625922679901,
-0.6389375329017639,
-0.05357450619339943,
-0.5328585505485535,
0.601144552230835,
-0.09184766560792923,
-0.9707500338554382,
0.7021150588989258,
0.16023235023021698,
-0.09342233836650848,
0.4977833032608032,
0.4692138731479645,
-0.006212013773620129,
1.3681526184082031,
0.8586440682411194,
-0.1208205446600914,
0.5208433270454407,
-0.3913249373435974,
-0.04575531557202339,
-0.8692470788955688,
0.09162316471338272,
-0.4087875783443451,
-0.2881167232990265,
-0.29569244384765625,
-0.21510715782642365,
0.10460608452558517,
0.2739858031272888,
0.01563441939651966,
0.2830844223499298,
-0.3070373237133026,
0.3185785412788391,
0.1806383728981018,
-0.048746947199106216,
0.08355800807476044,
0.3109850287437439,
-0.3515934944152832,
0.08340884745121002,
-0.8705574870109558,
-0.3694545328617096,
0.7287998199462891,
0.6181010603904724,
0.4709136486053467,
0.009090384468436241,
0.4841185510158539,
0.1460457295179367,
0.8871041536331177,
-0.9336493015289307,
0.694762647151947,
-0.4712194800376892,
-0.5787273645401001,
-0.4864789545536041,
-0.5209930539131165,
-0.9903444051742554,
0.19050568342208862,
0.04661278426647186,
-0.6046265959739685,
0.37219521403312683,
0.011864997446537018,
-0.5503518581390381,
0.4976389408111572,
-0.7811537981033325,
0.6018808484077454,
-0.011520001105964184,
-0.2619662582874298,
-0.29295459389686584,
-0.20228639245033264,
0.36045995354652405,
0.22765274345874786,
0.24907127022743225,
-0.4079464375972748,
-0.2766868770122528,
0.7420652508735657,
-0.7764951586723328,
0.8042932152748108,
-0.42891016602516174,
-0.2758541703224182,
0.5669838190078735,
0.18293936550617218,
0.5064286589622498,
-0.23497985303401947,
-0.5654056072235107,
0.11635128408670425,
-0.26334530115127563,
-0.30945199728012085,
-0.34341296553611755,
1.0082446336746216,
-0.6000533699989319,
-0.41297686100006104,
-0.15740595757961273,
-0.7112569212913513,
-0.16997899115085602,
0.17128664255142212,
-0.15639378130435944,
0.7966150641441345,
0.02903558500111103,
0.10009805858135223,
0.4258125424385071,
-0.3000425398349762,
0.8314653038978577,
0.4097597301006317,
-0.27272894978523254,
-0.48194602131843567,
0.8801047205924988,
0.4875309467315674,
0.27837124466896057,
0.035328079015016556,
0.5224930047988892,
-0.5381996631622314,
-0.9748921394348145,
-0.4286276698112488,
0.27762821316719055,
-0.7381331324577332,
-0.07128603756427765,
-0.684584379196167,
-0.5800777077674866,
-0.3851116895675659,
-0.08841293305158615,
-0.20401057600975037,
-0.4868941903114319,
-0.1524173617362976,
-0.19443237781524658,
0.5204916000366211,
0.8382346034049988,
0.09162033349275589,
0.4037891924381256,
-0.644180178642273,
0.1572519987821579,
0.33836105465888977,
0.8157171010971069,
-0.06584886461496353,
-0.7347713708877563,
-0.3268374800682068,
0.10607130080461502,
0.06223081797361374,
-0.9392299056053162,
0.9007166624069214,
0.41061899065971375,
0.5926082730293274,
0.3906208872795105,
-0.3434085249900818,
0.5200091600418091,
-0.3609362244606018,
0.7669094204902649,
0.04149316996335983,
-0.8114244937896729,
0.05870792269706726,
-0.30474644899368286,
0.230769082903862,
0.3771820366382599,
0.10796203464269638,
-0.8046526908874512,
-0.2801016569137573,
-0.47034841775894165,
-0.7482560276985168,
0.2155085951089859,
0.1798257678747177,
0.5438680648803711,
-0.31024661660194397,
0.31650310754776,
-0.11374242603778839,
0.16904839873313904,
-0.6951335072517395,
-0.16693466901779175,
0.06420403718948364,
-0.5549312233924866,
-0.22968922555446625,
-0.6314406394958496,
0.46036839485168457,
-0.4407063126564026,
0.7226167917251587,
0.11783675849437714,
-0.02731948532164097,
0.06305080652236938,
-0.30359092354774475,
-0.24843627214431763,
0.16374638676643372,
0.8466795086860657,
0.6704394817352295,
-0.31204187870025635,
0.2524056136608124,
0.38320302963256836,
-0.42032283544540405,
0.07056856900453568,
0.01024671271443367,
-0.4857151508331299,
0.4933147728443146,
0.12462823837995529,
0.994223952293396,
0.4692854583263397,
-0.7187544703483582,
0.44610002636909485,
0.32741236686706543,
-0.15213146805763245,
-0.6153361797332764,
0.021389702335000038,
0.4280291199684143,
-0.13165488839149475,
-0.04470665007829666,
0.11441746354103088,
-0.029283206909894943,
-0.36637410521507263,
0.028446534648537636,
0.5379998683929443,
-0.8333940505981445,
-0.40036121010780334,
0.4848010838031769,
0.2924667000770569,
-0.4944256544113159,
0.6116819977760315,
-0.16588865220546722,
-0.38045623898506165,
0.5110452771186829,
0.2667270004749298,
1.13382887840271,
-0.5157628655433655,
0.13393156230449677,
0.43136388063430786,
0.11734143644571304,
-0.25476938486099243,
0.4746387302875519,
0.30422380566596985,
-1.0988315343856812,
-0.7699185609817505,
-0.7792903184890747,
-0.09067325294017792,
0.21932044625282288,
-0.243885800242424,
0.32387056946754456,
-0.5605888962745667,
-0.21401149034500122,
-0.15995605289936066,
0.01651906408369541,
-0.37150058150291443,
0.20298339426517487,
0.3562468886375427,
1.1885112524032593,
-0.6322085857391357,
1.1058729887008667,
0.4263279139995575,
-0.30027303099632263,
-0.6059613823890686,
-0.40753644704818726,
-0.4299299418926239,
-0.7040994167327881,
0.5394877195358276,
-0.06332792341709137,
-0.09424760937690735,
0.48270973563194275,
-0.4893651604652405,
-0.9154016971588135,
0.8306921124458313,
0.2663702666759491,
-0.372335284948349,
-0.05524458736181259,
0.08613503724336624,
0.773536741733551,
-0.35967010259628296,
0.11025068908929825,
0.25492343306541443,
0.3776730000972748,
-0.2878538966178894,
-0.3633088767528534,
-0.12137030810117722,
-0.45437803864479065,
0.3053203821182251,
0.5052925944328308,
0.05301614850759506,
0.9337676167488098,
0.018163926899433136,
-0.48876041173934937,
0.21348285675048828,
0.7593376040458679,
0.1593305468559265,
-0.09528214484453201,
0.7418721914291382,
0.4808763861656189,
0.34827929735183716,
0.15526142716407776,
1.3307757377624512,
-0.5972373485565186,
0.26357051730155945,
0.9511879086494446,
-0.3465617001056671,
1.1603800058364868,
0.4076255261898041,
-0.16563472151756287,
0.5784927606582642,
0.276513010263443,
0.22153665125370026,
0.18726268410682678,
0.5004186630249023,
-0.4487175941467285,
-0.09514761716127396,
-0.20678740739822388,
-0.1622520238161087,
-0.047502413392066956,
0.6867115497589111,
-0.49544602632522583,
-0.22126241028308868,
-0.27323317527770996,
0.017290892079472542,
0.13363945484161377,
-0.3658733665943146,
0.5833775401115417,
0.1277489960193634,
-0.4871944785118103,
0.8087879419326782,
0.4046829342842102,
0.95058673620224,
-0.717598557472229,
0.2509115934371948,
-0.5358594059944153,
-0.11535769701004028,
0.021450767293572426,
-0.8050408959388733,
0.37060970067977905,
-0.07932764291763306,
0.2650333642959595,
-0.35163819789886475,
0.8928343057632446,
-0.7619186639785767,
-0.9441835880279541,
0.44365108013153076,
0.49431827664375305,
0.04828953370451927,
-0.054626934230327606,
-0.6453394293785095,
-0.26733195781707764,
-0.3772866427898407,
-0.5515254735946655,
0.034392841160297394,
0.16866689920425415,
-0.08800747245550156,
0.8898481726646423,
0.4845130741596222,
0.5334097146987915,
0.5543580651283264,
0.3803999125957489,
0.556877076625824,
-0.5001226663589478,
-0.40867578983306885,
-0.8945325613021851,
0.4356991946697235,
-0.1737818419933319,
-0.3407607078552246,
0.5336115956306458,
0.49472129344940186,
0.21789635717868805,
-0.037335556000471115,
0.5368494987487793,
0.23325598239898682,
0.5049151182174683,
-0.4162711501121521,
0.8862133026123047,
-0.48110583424568176,
0.17766621708869934,
-0.12281832098960876,
-1.113720178604126,
-0.468975305557251,
0.37357065081596375,
-0.1851271688938141,
0.02704736404120922,
0.4414118230342865,
1.0819735527038574,
-0.2221321165561676,
-0.20071063935756683,
0.6169670820236206,
0.6287396550178528,
0.031258486211299896,
0.11203005909919739,
0.6523138284683228,
-0.12487689405679703,
0.25981849431991577,
-0.6544508934020996,
0.165188267827034,
-0.1365087926387787,
-0.850860059261322,
-0.6079753637313843,
-0.4731880724430084,
-0.36779549717903137,
-0.09400030225515366,
-0.070403553545475,
0.7392447590827942,
0.758696973323822,
-0.947540819644928,
-0.6313005089759827,
-0.4309866428375244,
0.11393805593252182,
-0.1357356607913971,
-0.20336462557315826,
0.3421139121055603,
-0.33992329239845276,
-0.5343786478042603,
0.5279456377029419,
0.32261866331100464,
0.11951699107885361,
-0.7007516622543335,
-0.38814449310302734,
-0.43495458364486694,
0.5370392799377441,
0.7321143746376038,
0.1989072561264038,
-0.6456272006034851,
-0.3665607273578644,
-0.10687288641929626,
-0.30392494797706604,
0.04217260330915451,
0.6029737591743469,
-0.6826473474502563,
0.19865261018276215,
0.7741791605949402,
0.4515364170074463,
0.12484488636255264,
-0.2827226519584656,
0.6586275696754456,
-1.014682650566101,
0.41273146867752075,
0.30204012989997864,
0.7290073037147522,
0.4387184679508209,
0.03427232429385185,
0.4557029902935028,
0.13748428225517273,
-0.09532000124454498,
-0.8876727223396301,
0.16579316556453705,
-0.7533654570579529,
-0.26500219106674194,
1.3120191097259521,
0.0870707780122757,
-0.32702696323394775,
-0.21449919044971466,
-0.1208706647157669,
0.3080781102180481,
-0.08140945434570312,
0.5199902653694153,
0.5192010402679443,
0.24733343720436096,
-0.45503169298171997,
-0.7265806198120117,
0.3849034905433655,
0.6564822196960449,
-0.6243804097175598,
0.04507094994187355,
0.377399206161499,
0.43267208337783813,
0.006243374664336443,
0.6257181763648987,
0.013354056514799595,
-0.1928412914276123,
-0.29636847972869873,
0.2700379192829132,
0.00880390778183937,
-0.0892305001616478,
-0.47812560200691223,
0.37634021043777466,
0.30415815114974976,
0.33738619089126587
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.06357v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.06357v1
|
MASSW: A New Dataset and Benchmark Tasks for AI-Assisted Scientific Workflows
| 2024-06-10T15:19:09 | 2024-06-10T15:19:09 |
Xingjian Zhang, Yutong Xie, Jin Huang, Jinge Ma, Zhaoying Pan, Qijia Liu, Ziyang Xiong, Tolga Ergen, Dongsub Shim, Honglak Lee, Qiaozhu Mei
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Scientific innovation relies on detailed workflows, which include critical
steps such as analyzing literature, generating ideas, validating these ideas,
interpreting results, and inspiring follow-up research. However, scientific
publications that document these workflows are extensive and unstructured. This
makes it difficult for both human researchers and AI systems to effectively
navigate and explore the space of scientific innovation. To address this issue,
we introduce MASSW, a comprehensive text dataset on Multi-Aspect Summarization
of Scientific Workflows. MASSW includes more than 152,000 peer-reviewed
publications from 17 leading computer science conferences spanning the past 50
years. Using Large Language Models (LLMs), we automatically extract five core
aspects from these publications -- context, key idea, method, outcome, and
projected impact -- which correspond to five key steps in the research
workflow. These structured summaries facilitate a variety of downstream tasks
and analyses. The quality of the LLM-extracted summaries is validated by
comparing them with human annotations. We demonstrate the utility of MASSW
through multiple novel machine-learning tasks that can be benchmarked using
this new dataset, which make various types of predictions and recommendations
along the scientific workflow. MASSW holds significant potential for
researchers to create and benchmark new AI methods for optimizing scientific
workflows and fostering scientific innovation in the field. Our dataset is
openly available at \url{https://github.com/xingjian-zhang/massw}.
|
[
-0.27232417464256287,
-0.31667590141296387,
0.5001972317695618,
0.055678267031908035,
-0.22451378405094147,
0.17040401697158813,
-0.10022104531526566,
-0.3605300486087799,
0.26201191544532776,
0.5270325541496277,
-0.46261581778526306,
-0.3373298943042755,
-0.7282800674438477,
0.6831835508346558,
-0.4286140203475952,
1.0442442893981934,
-0.25748348236083984,
0.09020606428384781,
-0.5588136315345764,
-0.24538655579090118,
0.04811781644821167,
-0.23287193477153778,
-0.1798693984746933,
-0.5586240887641907,
0.7988585233688354,
0.2340015470981598,
0.5379624366760254,
0.6203817129135132,
0.9817023873329163,
0.3460730314254761,
-0.024295980110764503,
0.5473238229751587,
-0.380272775888443,
0.321649432182312,
-0.07341887056827545,
-0.2550731599330902,
-0.45249027013778687,
-0.016240814700722694,
0.629380464553833,
0.7963696122169495,
0.01159628201276064,
0.4779870808124542,
0.18982671201229095,
0.6554911732673645,
-0.613011360168457,
0.4335533082485199,
-0.20276252925395966,
0.11257274448871613,
-0.2918976843357086,
-0.06704384833574295,
-0.08425596356391907,
-0.17149072885513306,
-0.006455085705965757,
-0.5748257040977478,
0.27141818404197693,
0.23480288684368134,
0.3368651568889618,
0.2805196940898895,
-0.3095400333404541,
0.1466524451971054,
-0.46199649572372437,
0.7987841963768005,
-0.9529765248298645,
-0.01840708777308464,
-0.1377965658903122,
0.31825315952301025,
-0.448978990316391,
-0.83003169298172,
-0.5565175414085388,
-0.015313293784856796,
-0.08661627024412155,
0.2050156146287918,
-0.06101180240511894,
0.10784536600112915,
0.3798014223575592,
0.21360895037651062,
-0.8127619028091431,
0.05542348697781563,
-0.6760464310646057,
-0.18669256567955017,
0.8994238972663879,
0.41502463817596436,
-0.05224553495645523,
0.05158793926239014,
0.1480189710855484,
-0.2767043709754944,
-0.5546779036521912,
-0.07724859565496445,
-0.08897354453802109,
0.24653737246990204,
-0.06927050650119781,
0.902633786201477,
-0.5426778793334961,
0.4587405025959015,
-0.5707529187202454,
-0.3150796890258789,
0.6863148808479309,
-0.4881563186645508,
-0.18262560665607452,
-0.28539127111434937,
1.1176867485046387,
0.17828261852264404,
-0.3035326600074768,
-0.036775972694158554,
-0.03821690380573273,
-0.31244152784347534,
0.14064544439315796,
-1.0458769798278809,
-0.08939897269010544,
0.22178412973880768,
-0.5497899055480957,
-0.2925688922405243,
0.10345645993947983,
-0.6768677830696106,
-0.7121902704238892,
-0.3680152893066406,
0.23071634769439697,
-0.17036017775535583,
-0.24412864446640015,
-0.3283151388168335,
-0.5097898244857788,
-0.36675921082496643,
0.598145067691803,
-0.35201674699783325,
-0.09070097655057907,
0.9580650329589844,
1.2421642541885376,
-0.47549766302108765,
-0.7755106091499329,
-0.37572962045669556,
0.08811785280704498,
-0.29547643661499023,
0.8061914443969727,
-0.6944007277488708,
-0.46315720677375793,
-0.26071587204933167,
0.01701074093580246,
0.08175553381443024,
-0.474275678396225,
0.4520968794822693,
-0.13465674221515656,
-0.020386701449751854,
-0.42305055260658264,
-0.4468840956687927,
-0.48616132140159607,
0.14408911764621735,
-0.7090192437171936,
0.9279730319976807,
-0.14457780122756958,
-0.7724112272262573,
0.49868324398994446,
-1.1741504669189453,
-0.6281532645225525,
0.13163398206233978,
-0.04642169550061226,
-0.233412966132164,
0.31414851546287537,
0.1219867393374443,
0.7970718741416931,
-0.4909977614879608,
0.3995857238769531,
-0.6285215616226196,
-0.06518558412790298,
0.10917478054761887,
-0.20516695082187653,
0.3996128439903259,
0.2406269609928131,
-0.18134957551956177,
0.5877102017402649,
-0.8965281248092651,
-0.22071956098079681,
-0.03723197057843208,
0.008207811042666435,
-0.3604143261909485,
-0.08090952038764954,
-0.18525470793247223,
0.24291113018989563,
0.13753776252269745,
-0.6907015442848206,
0.4143548905849457,
-0.08520014584064484,
0.7268016934394836,
0.32080012559890747,
0.23423753678798676,
0.20012466609477997,
-0.4851059317588806,
0.23318089544773102,
-0.06070602685213089,
0.2421398162841797,
-0.5936092138290405,
-0.5289649367332458,
-0.09584508091211319,
-0.29354631900787354,
-0.07647847384214401,
0.35259389877319336,
-0.6722365617752075,
0.30583804845809937,
-0.2017010599374771,
-0.9227631092071533,
-0.5921643376350403,
0.19934232532978058,
0.29056516289711,
0.7557014226913452,
0.40531307458877563,
-0.12841880321502686,
-0.526912271976471,
-0.7472245693206787,
-0.16292808949947357,
-0.13126486539840698,
-0.275760680437088,
0.14737176895141602,
0.9377266764640808,
-0.10146559774875641,
0.6610172986984253,
-0.5002497434616089,
-0.11761104315519333,
-0.11298560351133347,
0.8508872985839844,
0.33884918689727783,
0.24843540787696838,
0.0026532202027738094,
-0.7311890721321106,
0.08698439598083496,
-0.17629143595695496,
-1.0018261671066284,
-0.18747155368328094,
0.024442844092845917,
-0.24282397329807281,
-0.07928084582090378,
0.32138577103614807,
-0.5186355710029602,
0.253244549036026,
0.3380243480205536,
-0.2615799605846405,
0.748994767665863,
-0.3324013650417328,
0.5488080978393555,
-1.1395790576934814,
0.34214651584625244,
0.07651431113481522,
0.17224061489105225,
-0.47184786200523376,
-0.08578620851039886,
0.21348553895950317,
-0.19340217113494873,
-0.45454731583595276,
0.4354514181613922,
-0.5227872133255005,
-0.1569966971874237,
-0.4461645185947418,
-0.012544929049909115,
0.2821877896785736,
0.3349819481372833,
0.046998247504234314,
0.6837689280509949,
0.42618218064308167,
-0.6059271693229675,
0.26168233156204224,
0.24277427792549133,
-0.21781939268112183,
0.22183340787887573,
-0.7857212424278259,
-0.10664163529872894,
-0.21853400766849518,
0.3651862144470215,
-0.6919635534286499,
-0.17663002014160156,
-0.11381056904792786,
-0.2582895755767822,
0.008317653089761734,
0.07250220328569412,
-0.7704944014549255,
-0.6070215702056885,
-0.41730785369873047,
0.18845637142658234,
0.4197216033935547,
-0.194611594080925,
0.7168400287628174,
0.46853870153427124,
-0.32623904943466187,
-0.549536406993866,
-0.4633752703666687,
0.19048775732517242,
-0.027056679129600525,
-0.5076874494552612,
0.25128477811813354,
-0.1059354841709137,
-0.21150867640972137,
-0.0751902237534523,
-0.01516161672770977,
0.03645147755742073,
0.08049728721380234,
0.5894166231155396,
0.23885676264762878,
0.03479888662695885,
-0.29710623621940613,
0.1993366926908493,
0.04341325908899307,
0.17092622816562653,
-0.2107248157262802,
0.14422263205051422,
0.0697777271270752,
-0.5194921493530273,
-0.39420458674430847,
0.3270198404788971,
1.0650207996368408,
-0.24751153588294983,
0.3842584788799286,
0.8968760967254639,
-0.4478156566619873,
0.09892638772726059,
-0.3504525125026703,
-0.3449053466320038,
-0.406669557094574,
0.5641541481018066,
0.000040748938772594556,
-0.718863308429718,
0.4812827408313751,
-0.2135012000799179,
0.9748257398605347,
0.6219007968902588,
0.49300190806388855,
-0.1487894505262375,
0.9747658967971802,
0.48553207516670227,
-0.13517089188098907,
0.05796103924512863,
-0.2257811576128006,
-0.018948517739772797,
-0.9881742000579834,
-0.5109491944313049,
-0.7138895988464355,
-0.45022305846214294,
-0.011347396299242973,
-0.676347553730011,
0.6757802963256836,
-0.10954776406288147,
-0.12095896154642105,
0.23776905238628387,
-0.4997348189353943,
0.15974129736423492,
0.5253482460975647,
-0.36937928199768066,
0.46508660912513733,
-0.43112319707870483,
-0.027026867493987083,
0.026750914752483368,
-0.5660405158996582,
-0.6033170223236084,
1.2378398180007935,
0.1433739960193634,
0.8180386424064636,
-0.22732733190059662,
0.6912412643432617,
0.5291804671287537,
0.5837608575820923,
-0.5169829726219177,
0.47149011492729187,
0.031672634184360504,
-0.2554779648780823,
-0.5398204326629639,
-0.5306469202041626,
-0.8006445169448853,
0.4837151765823364,
-0.31263267993927,
-0.40193304419517517,
-0.15692660212516785,
0.17545276880264282,
-0.2078745812177658,
0.4539310336112976,
-0.3981335163116455,
0.6788803935050964,
-0.3381712734699249,
-0.34045955538749695,
-0.2747633457183838,
-0.6262020468711853,
0.48796066641807556,
-0.0837487280368805,
0.45626312494277954,
-0.4384913146495819,
-0.0572548434138298,
1.1632531881332397,
-0.6551247835159302,
0.7085347771644592,
-0.20291970670223236,
0.12508970499038696,
0.11231609433889389,
0.02939971163868904,
0.6414152979850769,
0.042145173996686935,
-0.05400590971112251,
0.4787682294845581,
0.1419006884098053,
-0.1917034536600113,
-0.4879628121852875,
0.4707084000110626,
-0.464985191822052,
-0.2234320342540741,
-0.43116095662117004,
-0.8062620162963867,
-0.14134034514427185,
0.4521126449108124,
0.19783011078834534,
0.4182504117488861,
-0.08688602596521378,
0.11702946573495865,
0.3782338500022888,
0.05679315701127052,
0.6436524987220764,
0.7070325613021851,
-0.027938639745116234,
-0.3668407201766968,
0.8206349015235901,
0.09214059263467789,
-0.22173649072647095,
0.5692439079284668,
0.27506697177886963,
-0.22654470801353455,
-1.0127978324890137,
-0.4943985342979431,
0.15022943913936615,
-0.25459951162338257,
-0.36496755480766296,
-0.9346909523010254,
0.18990322947502136,
-0.579627275466919,
-0.1119832992553711,
-0.35510799288749695,
-0.2552531957626343,
-0.26554441452026367,
0.08248162269592285,
0.20966149866580963,
0.9591302275657654,
-0.005129745230078697,
-0.2606743574142456,
-1.1104073524475098,
0.21795041859149933,
-0.1755072921514511,
0.0016077440232038498,
0.1942409723997116,
-0.36723586916923523,
-0.30166754126548767,
-0.015227781608700752,
-0.32610392570495605,
-0.587799608707428,
0.3094094693660736,
0.222006157040596,
0.6004610657691956,
0.7428146600723267,
0.15616962313652039,
0.5993898510932922,
-0.6379743218421936,
0.9434674382209778,
0.26277077198028564,
-0.5598011612892151,
0.4597662091255188,
-0.010789039544761181,
0.3576669692993164,
0.6076996922492981,
0.5066189765930176,
-0.6147403717041016,
-0.44175979495048523,
-0.43115362524986267,
-0.9642563462257385,
0.29129061102867126,
-0.004224658943712711,
-0.35941165685653687,
0.33808833360671997,
0.1691582053899765,
0.6413134932518005,
0.5491339564323425,
-0.004731269553303719,
-0.05889541283249855,
-0.13340051472187042,
-0.2963313162326813,
-0.10528220236301422,
0.09718035906553268,
-0.44137701392173767,
-0.13181741535663605,
0.8406246304512024,
-0.39035290479660034,
-0.027792662382125854,
0.1377757340669632,
-0.24558094143867493,
0.18552057445049286,
0.062034402042627335,
0.6718617677688599,
0.9426197409629822,
0.06980706006288528,
0.1425531953573227,
0.07743807882070541,
-0.6793862581253052,
-0.19959120452404022,
0.22436067461967468,
-0.25119584798812866,
0.00258631631731987,
0.7395960092544556,
0.5077506899833679,
0.16781792044639587,
-0.9901313185691833,
0.26300498843193054,
0.019540168344974518,
-0.6342840194702148,
-0.08240866661071777,
0.24887490272521973,
-0.16514723002910614,
0.4702874422073364,
0.7063077688217163,
0.2483951598405838,
0.5355981588363647,
-0.2331930547952652,
0.08523683249950409,
0.33029985427856445,
-0.08944480866193771,
-0.4377326965332031,
0.7584803104400635,
0.26783689856529236,
0.012574241496622562,
0.20835140347480774,
-0.33570775389671326,
-0.20745474100112915,
0.5287491083145142,
0.19057892262935638,
0.7121593952178955,
0.2700846791267395,
0.291050523519516,
0.35746097564697266,
0.21437546610832214,
-0.27893808484077454,
0.4271637499332428,
-0.06609657406806946,
-0.20756368339061737,
-0.5953332185745239,
-0.6958885788917542,
-0.8336966037750244,
0.1657598316669464,
-0.5176032781600952,
0.09776540845632553,
-0.2793915569782257,
0.08200382441282272,
0.402619332075119,
0.08488255739212036,
-0.5622285008430481,
-0.23636747896671295,
-0.08049116283655167,
1.036305546760559,
-0.9793511033058167,
0.38880279660224915,
0.7699474096298218,
-0.22744858264923096,
-0.5487069487571716,
-0.4869636297225952,
0.5110501050949097,
-0.6206527948379517,
0.1921580582857132,
0.0030782106332480907,
-0.00945818331092596,
-0.46259546279907227,
-0.5039699077606201,
-1.0579227209091187,
1.3755545616149902,
-0.08297962695360184,
-0.5958793759346008,
0.21645371615886688,
-0.22816221415996552,
0.5274350047111511,
-0.4965084195137024,
0.5254844427108765,
0.2857176959514618,
0.661647379398346,
0.36878201365470886,
-0.727018415927887,
0.21613112092018127,
-0.5439057946205139,
-0.19752296805381775,
0.31896039843559265,
-0.6927220821380615,
0.6370803117752075,
-0.5615361928939819,
0.09976238757371902,
-0.14087997376918793,
0.9232536554336548,
0.4759185016155243,
0.7234398722648621,
0.22480838000774384,
0.3886995315551758,
1.0202937126159668,
-0.1419830024242401,
0.5835619568824768,
-0.18735943734645844,
-0.06507617235183716,
0.8516228795051575,
-0.6432185173034668,
0.7152228951454163,
0.27803143858909607,
-0.26526808738708496,
0.270979642868042,
0.6395875215530396,
-0.4834632873535156,
0.2571135461330414,
0.1319044977426529,
0.054065026342868805,
0.26831725239753723,
-0.2049751877784729,
-0.31782066822052,
0.07833389937877655,
0.20721551775932312,
-0.3093903660774231,
-0.15628577768802643,
0.3272304832935333,
0.25660207867622375,
-0.2406797707080841,
-0.4459106922149658,
0.7845655083656311,
-0.14338679611682892,
-0.651017427444458,
0.08802256733179092,
-0.06297934800386429,
0.8666702508926392,
-0.6521781086921692,
-0.17573323845863342,
-0.2363908439874649,
-0.20131251215934753,
-0.3323380947113037,
-0.8344045281410217,
0.16544489562511444,
0.14775827527046204,
-0.33554789423942566,
-0.144906684756279,
0.4554375112056732,
-0.2608882486820221,
-0.5585111975669861,
-0.24207130074501038,
0.5070844292640686,
0.5480255484580994,
-0.1181102842092514,
-0.5799671411514282,
-0.10675863176584244,
-0.21823528409004211,
-0.43425214290618896,
0.2782106399536133,
0.4986726641654968,
-0.17058590054512024,
0.7149384021759033,
0.902894139289856,
0.29884785413742065,
-0.18785451352596283,
0.3142683207988739,
0.6762920618057251,
-0.7061102390289307,
-0.5092146396636963,
-0.7489625811576843,
0.38108405470848083,
-0.406530499458313,
-0.5097246170043945,
0.577250599861145,
0.7648746967315674,
0.5717799067497253,
0.09845968335866928,
1.1662145853042603,
-0.26371458172798157,
0.5205848813056946,
-0.17775151133537292,
0.8268266916275024,
-0.6172586679458618,
-0.014950678683817387,
-0.2763288617134094,
-0.6666335463523865,
-0.29912564158439636,
-0.06513936072587967,
0.09894634783267975,
0.009364147670567036,
0.7862536907196045,
0.5798576474189758,
0.1362111121416092,
0.39026808738708496,
0.17388050258159637,
0.18841712176799774,
0.5888506174087524,
0.2623159885406494,
0.397703617811203,
0.14314046502113342,
0.48573416471481323,
-0.2904037833213806,
-0.5267332792282104,
-0.3953770101070404,
-1.170885443687439,
-0.8826534152030945,
-0.7804177403450012,
-0.3186486065387726,
-0.06746010482311249,
-0.29355767369270325,
0.9692835807800293,
0.7660365104675293,
-0.8729820847511292,
0.0004290395590942353,
0.08728687465190887,
0.05650212988257408,
-0.7589060068130493,
-0.16216614842414856,
0.4532533586025238,
-0.16496898233890533,
-0.5497450828552246,
0.479435533285141,
0.6920477747917175,
0.053999658674001694,
-0.41602975130081177,
-0.04655029624700546,
0.15050283074378967,
-0.18332761526107788,
0.6094027161598206,
0.5525437593460083,
-0.4329400360584259,
0.3800235092639923,
0.04431329295039177,
0.15547248721122742,
-0.2586018443107605,
1.168683648109436,
-0.3625921905040741,
0.25896066427230835,
0.7415375113487244,
0.7332670092582703,
0.41938140988349915,
-0.13872921466827393,
0.5283674001693726,
-0.46689215302467346,
-0.16716201603412628,
0.4506987929344177,
0.566813051700592,
0.23820076882839203,
-0.24141328036785126,
0.6210378408432007,
0.295555055141449,
-0.603646457195282,
-0.9189535975456238,
-0.1640966385602951,
-0.8700518012046814,
-0.3060241639614105,
0.8984538912773132,
-0.18983259797096252,
-0.43055257201194763,
-0.14491964876651764,
-0.067725270986557,
0.24834412336349487,
-0.5582661628723145,
0.9778739213943481,
0.5196933150291443,
-0.6224899291992188,
0.0756579041481018,
-0.5918470621109009,
0.3437255024909973,
0.14730559289455414,
-1.0996592044830322,
0.3765382170677185,
0.4942981004714966,
0.10857704281806946,
0.2543419599533081,
0.4013560712337494,
-0.17494505643844604,
0.10100837051868439,
-0.06817436963319778,
0.30809858441352844,
-0.8771874308586121,
-0.5146515369415283,
0.09136249870061874,
0.4350822865962982,
-0.20403501391410828,
-0.021886929869651794
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.06355v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.06355v1
|
Sustained Vowels for Pre- vs Post-Treatment COPD Classification
| 2024-06-10T15:17:17 | 2024-06-10T15:17:17 |
Andreas Triantafyllopoulos, Anton Batliner, Wolfgang Mayr, Markus Fendler, Florian Pokorny, Maurice Gerczuk, Shahin Amiriparian, Thomas Berghaus, Björn Schuller
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD) is a serious inflammatory lung
disease affecting millions of people around the world. Due to an obstructed
airflow from the lungs, it also becomes manifest in patients' vocal behaviour.
Of particular importance is the detection of an exacerbation episode, which
marks an acute phase and often requires hospitalisation and treatment. Previous
work has shown that it is possible to distinguish between a pre- and a
post-treatment state using automatic analysis of read speech. In this
contribution, we examine whether sustained vowels can provide a complementary
lens for telling apart these two states. Using a cohort of 50 patients, we show
that the inclusion of sustained vowels can improve performance to up to 79\%
unweighted average recall, from a 71\% baseline using read speech. We further
identify and interpret the most important acoustic features that characterise
the manifestation of COPD in sustained vowels.
|
[
-0.5181573033332825,
-0.7283776998519897,
0.5206791758537292,
0.025458108633756638,
-0.2704053521156311,
0.7409598231315613,
0.013528524897992611,
-0.3533751964569092,
0.6093471050262451,
0.6062303781509399,
-0.41231629252433777,
-0.39917486906051636,
-0.9361528158187866,
0.2391408085823059,
-0.34523069858551025,
0.7906427979469299,
-0.1227845847606659,
0.09784799069166183,
0.4123464524745941,
-0.1542978584766388,
-0.7158968448638916,
-0.836322009563446,
-0.7925295829772949,
0.05571363493800163,
0.5308859348297119,
0.06369559466838837,
0.6600888967514038,
-0.13851745426654816,
0.3238188326358795,
0.331775963306427,
-0.2635034918785095,
-0.08766409754753113,
-0.5058515667915344,
0.42311152815818787,
0.49308332800865173,
-0.11231515556573868,
-0.4164527356624603,
-0.008934050798416138,
1.0373786687850952,
1.0696271657943726,
-0.24724550545215607,
-0.40348008275032043,
0.29086023569107056,
0.7202775478363037,
-0.18342691659927368,
-0.4095350503921509,
-0.3354678153991699,
0.35114455223083496,
-0.49919113516807556,
-0.3175778090953827,
-0.22141195833683014,
-0.21668869256973267,
0.2507365643978119,
-0.7605313062667847,
0.07093888521194458,
-0.11483138054609299,
0.7008486390113831,
0.33492907881736755,
-0.3787176311016083,
-0.29740723967552185,
-0.4229061007499695,
0.25413233041763306,
-0.28455886244773865,
0.9255459308624268,
0.11218573898077011,
-0.16393887996673584,
-0.671880304813385,
-0.7973974347114563,
-0.3142024874687195,
-0.29828864336013794,
-0.22407123446464539,
0.22772210836410522,
-0.2405967265367508,
0.483272522687912,
0.09021597355604172,
0.6533536911010742,
-0.5997735857963562,
0.03845268860459328,
-0.6262428760528564,
-0.4347357749938965,
0.2414850890636444,
-0.18582051992416382,
0.6356334090232849,
-0.020859258249402046,
-0.4147588908672333,
0.3532848060131073,
-0.46715542674064636,
0.4121069014072418,
0.294464647769928,
0.1135752722620964,
0.039202626794576645,
0.5303687453269958,
-0.23977145552635193,
0.37660208344459534,
0.37948042154312134,
-0.009652814827859402,
0.4318961203098297,
-0.19452089071273804,
-0.21138006448745728,
0.46073952317237854,
0.4124855697154999,
-0.18913774192333221,
0.08537319302558899,
-0.13235925137996674,
-0.08893831819295883,
0.2629104554653168,
0.22462597489356995,
-0.5112269520759583,
-0.354634553194046,
0.2835085391998291,
-0.5615365505218506,
0.044936053454875946,
0.03648199141025543,
-0.26379871368408203,
0.22378478944301605,
-0.4692884087562561,
0.24051342904567719,
-0.20052988827228546,
-0.7386757135391235,
0.42417988181114197,
-0.4080274701118469,
-0.1574029177427292,
0.21886657178401947,
-0.4901862144470215,
0.6608867049217224,
0.7643338441848755,
0.9144223928451538,
-0.3586837649345398,
0.17345137894153595,
-0.8035417795181274,
-0.14517946541309357,
-0.8333093523979187,
1.075628638267517,
-0.712336540222168,
-0.6524797081947327,
0.018031032755970955,
0.25821638107299805,
-0.501333475112915,
-0.8413903713226318,
0.7035757899284363,
-0.14838369190692902,
-0.11604631692171097,
-0.08584900945425034,
-0.4403401017189026,
0.09468391537666321,
-0.2747589647769928,
-0.6620166301727295,
1.2295633554458618,
0.2579341530799866,
-0.405539870262146,
0.6181486248970032,
-0.4962911009788513,
-0.6253096461296082,
0.2845294177532196,
-0.041601184755563736,
-0.3240760266780853,
0.5489814877510071,
-0.09274596720933914,
0.12992578744888306,
0.34926843643188477,
0.28486719727516174,
-0.2181437909603119,
-0.17225682735443115,
0.18690846860408783,
-0.35696080327033997,
0.5211687088012695,
0.3948127329349518,
-0.13849130272865295,
0.2051166146993637,
-0.7961920499801636,
0.12292938679456711,
-0.6811144351959229,
-0.41336679458618164,
-0.24382241070270538,
0.019397225230932236,
-0.11225125938653946,
0.0925670638680458,
-0.18707135319709778,
-0.6425737142562866,
0.16025209426879883,
-0.2538039982318878,
0.33563730120658875,
0.6176539659500122,
0.5590160489082336,
-0.3386395573616028,
-0.4465879797935486,
0.7204185724258423,
-0.0768071860074997,
0.16351798176765442,
0.028385931625962257,
-0.624134361743927,
-0.5014006495475769,
-0.6758500337600708,
-0.05757482722401619,
0.21629229187965393,
-0.4072536528110504,
0.42743048071861267,
0.1371411681175232,
-0.10446098446846008,
-0.5634407997131348,
0.23332296311855316,
0.5106892585754395,
0.7228953242301941,
0.2326686680316925,
-0.503717839717865,
-0.6380654573440552,
-0.5330839157104492,
-0.17822037637233734,
-0.5698662996292114,
0.08145581930875778,
0.18425603210926056,
0.2006506472826004,
0.04219427704811096,
0.252295583486557,
-0.5407946109771729,
-0.6096950769424438,
-0.060114532709121704,
0.42170605063438416,
0.2469629943370819,
0.4396960139274597,
0.3812565207481384,
-0.7663924098014832,
-0.43182024359703064,
0.034610506147146225,
-0.3887496590614319,
-0.6445351839065552,
-0.15390871465206146,
-0.49922752380371094,
0.20863306522369385,
0.967643678188324,
-0.21533982455730438,
0.5752964615821838,
0.6104031801223755,
-0.6509685516357422,
0.8338016271591187,
-0.31685900688171387,
0.2833518087863922,
-0.06414825469255447,
0.019571460783481598,
-0.4890890121459961,
-0.36440426111221313,
-0.5132251977920532,
-0.14532707631587982,
-0.4324165880680084,
-0.4727784991264343,
-0.42537060379981995,
0.051394324749708176,
-0.5454348921775818,
0.14246706664562225,
-0.17498540878295898,
0.07433507591485977,
0.08476067334413528,
0.1609848141670227,
0.699933648109436,
0.44737744331359863,
0.5454922318458557,
-0.6015656590461731,
-0.0654008612036705,
-0.07990144193172455,
-0.4075900912284851,
0.7611187100410461,
-0.7782925367355347,
0.14672498404979706,
0.37238195538520813,
0.40938231348991394,
-1.2470588684082031,
0.04490642994642258,
-0.02880498766899109,
-0.465678870677948,
0.2695974111557007,
0.012754939496517181,
-0.4036436676979065,
-0.5385032892227173,
0.05312565341591835,
0.36024147272109985,
0.42598652839660645,
-0.28472766280174255,
0.4285854995250702,
0.3950798511505127,
-0.5265042781829834,
0.21530568599700928,
-0.041195910423994064,
-0.14381763339042664,
-0.16345913708209991,
-0.41971060633659363,
0.5332158207893372,
-0.40993568301200867,
0.03318742662668228,
0.15145549178123474,
-0.31424757838249207,
-0.022369369864463806,
0.39892148971557617,
0.4514508545398712,
0.04512171447277069,
-0.18588018417358398,
0.2980707883834839,
0.04559911787509918,
-0.3704841136932373,
-0.23379364609718323,
-0.17459551990032196,
0.5786594152450562,
-0.03962167724967003,
-0.17781731486320496,
-0.8625056147575378,
0.9348371624946594,
0.8731296062469482,
-0.46178433299064636,
0.5512877106666565,
0.2632034718990326,
-0.698376476764679,
0.37797895073890686,
-0.49592456221580505,
0.17851805686950684,
-0.46090367436408997,
0.047120269387960434,
-0.7981125712394714,
-0.45790332555770874,
0.36835649609565735,
-0.3352115750312805,
-0.2316933125257492,
0.3680524230003357,
0.3995683491230011,
-0.6035534739494324,
1.171985149383545,
0.52198725938797,
0.15392735600471497,
0.42241171002388,
0.02977539226412773,
0.16424039006233215,
-0.9235620498657227,
-0.42337021231651306,
-0.5992518067359924,
-0.3075715899467468,
-0.2843991219997406,
0.09454844892024994,
0.5664210319519043,
0.738382875919342,
-0.10170795023441315,
-0.38295117020606995,
-0.6857334971427917,
0.057717446237802505,
0.0827995166182518,
0.4195463955402374,
0.06911715120077133,
-0.2542327046394348,
-0.11511392146348953,
-0.06976469606161118,
-0.42890453338623047,
-0.2518759071826935,
0.7633975148200989,
0.12347324937582016,
0.260422021150589,
0.017554283142089844,
0.7193781733512878,
0.6380262970924377,
0.1984151005744934,
-0.9662725925445557,
0.27015599608421326,
-0.46289926767349243,
-0.31475630402565,
-0.20865383744239807,
-0.048278409987688065,
-1.3847686052322388,
0.02841099165380001,
-0.26157864928245544,
-0.5390099883079529,
0.5896328091621399,
0.03844263777136803,
-0.5537324547767639,
0.06514783948659897,
-0.6570313572883606,
0.7737553715705872,
-0.5939238667488098,
0.14208489656448364,
-0.16773222386837006,
-0.2994632124900818,
0.012633336707949638,
-0.32349640130996704,
0.11410060524940491,
0.12626305222511292,
-0.05443954095244408,
1.1488888263702393,
-0.8771942257881165,
0.512248158454895,
-0.39924949407577515,
0.02115384303033352,
0.25134342908859253,
-0.2798018455505371,
0.2410326898097992,
-0.1418333500623703,
-0.10398143529891968,
0.14402790367603302,
0.2846660315990448,
-0.3200396001338959,
-0.6254386901855469,
0.40762966871261597,
-0.5338274240493774,
-0.8963515758514404,
-0.5085211396217346,
-0.056633271276950836,
-0.06882397830486298,
0.1687825471162796,
0.15259744226932526,
0.8609718680381775,
-0.23457781970500946,
0.46255454421043396,
0.6406807899475098,
-0.1366972029209137,
0.07277198135852814,
0.7719193696975708,
-0.3444899320602417,
-0.5010805130004883,
0.4761253595352173,
0.5932207703590393,
0.47625234723091125,
0.25444838404655457,
0.4362468421459198,
-0.46900177001953125,
-0.6743918061256409,
0.1024283915758133,
0.2009602189064026,
-0.34138575196266174,
0.14855720102787018,
-0.7729411721229553,
-0.17904330790042877,
-0.4334264397621155,
-0.4885692596435547,
-0.2453935146331787,
-0.07168436050415039,
-0.29841965436935425,
-0.38274523615837097,
0.23995040357112885,
0.5014936327934265,
-0.23598159849643707,
-0.0666770413517952,
-0.38746878504753113,
1.0290336608886719,
0.04609127715229988,
0.06798229366540909,
-0.3302501142024994,
-0.432782918214798,
0.018853941932320595,
-0.11536230146884918,
-0.03259428218007088,
-0.9277011156082153,
0.29164794087409973,
0.7430678009986877,
0.7862184643745422,
0.826385498046875,
0.57635498046875,
0.9837338924407959,
-0.4883788526058197,
0.911607563495636,
0.3212669789791107,
-0.997765302658081,
0.9585191011428833,
0.23435114324092865,
0.136044442653656,
0.38209185004234314,
0.5291531085968018,
-0.7637040019035339,
-0.8165180683135986,
-0.6785430312156677,
-0.8464208245277405,
0.284111887216568,
0.10607478022575378,
-0.376984566450119,
-0.5099924802780151,
0.2935345768928528,
0.20386788249015808,
0.08060428500175476,
-0.06575290113687515,
-0.230307474732399,
-0.2744203209877014,
-0.01709667220711708,
-0.10732393711805344,
-0.3316579759120941,
-0.1476004272699356,
-0.485587477684021,
0.4177786111831665,
0.11679238826036453,
0.1680888682603836,
0.6326594352722168,
-0.16957513988018036,
0.04389600083231926,
0.2196660339832306,
0.2621094286441803,
0.5818541049957275,
-0.4603354334831238,
0.02634579874575138,
-0.27898848056793213,
-0.7707849740982056,
0.4439522922039032,
-0.050368666648864746,
-0.019914139062166214,
0.2724326550960541,
0.5531681776046753,
0.629047155380249,
0.48230206966400146,
-0.7537935972213745,
0.4667983949184418,
-0.0549699030816555,
-0.13318070769309998,
-0.4330670237541199,
-0.021740585565567017,
-0.4518943428993225,
0.28700289130210876,
0.4049370586872101,
0.3252399265766144,
0.22429049015045166,
-1.006280779838562,
0.31874579191207886,
0.3100127577781677,
-0.644954264163971,
-0.33578431606292725,
0.5766425728797913,
0.3618430197238922,
-0.520470142364502,
0.6483171582221985,
-0.029329413548111916,
-0.9433831572532654,
0.6651580929756165,
0.6419469118118286,
0.9111414551734924,
-0.2124406099319458,
0.2225506752729416,
0.12047147750854492,
0.04574260860681534,
0.17849069833755493,
0.5448307991027832,
-0.3416686952114105,
-0.5752499103546143,
0.09306374192237854,
-0.47545868158340454,
-0.09305392950773239,
0.07453808933496475,
-1.4190669059753418,
0.09222298115491867,
-0.5075242519378662,
-0.25203973054885864,
0.09220677614212036,
0.28186213970184326,
-0.6017250418663025,
0.2917827069759369,
0.12947167456150055,
0.6431043148040771,
-0.9142259955406189,
0.7692484855651855,
0.5777247548103333,
-0.21684980392456055,
-0.7457001805305481,
0.0013395656133070588,
0.08366601169109344,
-0.5286169648170471,
0.9514839053153992,
0.16922976076602936,
-0.3618324100971222,
-0.0025780245196074247,
0.25788724422454834,
-0.6190382242202759,
0.54889315366745,
0.3760652542114258,
-0.7445350885391235,
0.5652793049812317,
-0.36269432306289673,
0.7252622246742249,
-0.34996864199638367,
0.17342343926429749,
0.5926753282546997,
0.4672646224498749,
-0.06476721167564392,
-1.0645947456359863,
-0.1955888718366623,
-0.389594167470932,
-0.15465675294399261,
0.054190050810575485,
-0.5171685814857483,
0.5716514587402344,
-0.22229044139385223,
-0.731358528137207,
0.1825244128704071,
0.31124067306518555,
0.37030109763145447,
0.3788711428642273,
0.7456538081169128,
0.5622795224189758,
1.3627204895019531,
-0.2374686747789383,
1.2265816926956177,
-0.38580751419067383,
-0.23658259212970734,
0.602816104888916,
-0.17836645245552063,
1.4745725393295288,
0.3235729932785034,
-0.19840560853481293,
0.47126704454421997,
0.7856470346450806,
0.5395681858062744,
0.6853903532028198,
0.2722494304180145,
-0.45543375611305237,
-0.33443960547447205,
-0.291593462228775,
-0.9370458722114563,
0.29249972105026245,
0.42138534784317017,
-0.036108486354351044,
0.44807180762290955,
0.5647148489952087,
0.12652574479579926,
0.1043536365032196,
-0.41257989406585693,
0.7835473418235779,
-0.037636078894138336,
-0.7569519281387329,
0.9250891208648682,
-0.8300276398658752,
0.4031795263290405,
-0.8569543957710266,
-0.14408768713474274,
-0.18268659710884094,
0.11682623624801636,
-0.3784673511981964,
-0.657708466053009,
0.4261777400970459,
-0.1643284261226654,
-0.6172118782997131,
-0.5908313393592834,
0.3752122223377228,
-0.4203857481479645,
-0.7060753107070923,
0.6489766240119934,
0.07311908900737762,
0.4715454578399658,
-0.13401062786579132,
-0.38237735629081726,
0.4833582639694214,
-0.07878392189741135,
0.013565515168011189,
0.10774354636669159,
0.5253347754478455,
0.1455676555633545,
0.482781320810318,
0.7592360377311707,
0.5235259532928467,
0.30399471521377563,
0.17081117630004883,
0.6939373016357422,
-0.3170892596244812,
-0.6416811347007751,
-0.19385287165641785,
0.46622881293296814,
0.20223623514175415,
-0.4388555586338043,
0.38800355792045593,
0.6092419624328613,
0.7156199812889099,
0.19962915778160095,
0.49386391043663025,
0.2729127109050751,
0.7434853911399841,
-1.0366809368133545,
0.8446014523506165,
-0.5647058486938477,
0.2835797667503357,
-0.3366408050060272,
-0.4083458483219147,
-0.2317424863576889,
0.6520280838012695,
-0.13157425820827484,
-0.2755681574344635,
0.9978415966033936,
0.5700476169586182,
0.3044019639492035,
-0.10580100119113922,
0.24230772256851196,
0.5008248686790466,
0.5780501365661621,
0.5374045968055725,
0.8075941205024719,
0.030131857842206955,
0.3549080491065979,
0.10533994436264038,
-0.4076745808124542,
-0.15408149361610413,
-0.5607447028160095,
-0.40380191802978516,
-0.6384041905403137,
-0.9979175329208374,
0.07361555844545364,
0.6434082388877869,
0.3551137447357178,
0.9399486780166626,
-0.6598203778266907,
0.11166742444038391,
-0.08042793720960617,
0.2219596803188324,
-0.8408872485160828,
-0.2004983276128769,
0.6404624581336975,
-0.1119292825460434,
-0.4891189932823181,
0.6722071170806885,
0.4351525902748108,
-0.030159680172801018,
0.015473742038011551,
-0.327511727809906,
-0.12118473649024963,
-0.17434601485729218,
0.5652961134910583,
0.5961362719535828,
-1.0155601501464844,
-0.36756619811058044,
-0.23673179745674133,
0.3355964422225952,
0.17161434888839722,
1.010677456855774,
-1.1022003889083862,
0.7743924856185913,
0.38929086923599243,
0.4593447744846344,
0.2987711429595947,
0.05985971540212631,
0.4298346936702728,
-0.5137239694595337,
0.24555079638957977,
0.3190616965293884,
0.6517713665962219,
-0.08516841381788254,
-0.4380258321762085,
0.16839922964572906,
0.43777164816856384,
-0.35896730422973633,
-1.0398240089416504,
-0.009735380299389362,
-1.0868016481399536,
-0.16197848320007324,
0.6268163323402405,
-0.5741929411888123,
0.26749318838119507,
-0.8142485618591309,
-0.5306217074394226,
0.08008290082216263,
-0.3704724609851837,
0.2939225137233734,
0.6213415861129761,
-0.4675760269165039,
-0.4108205735683441,
-0.40305840969085693,
0.4140075445175171,
0.29428762197494507,
-0.6689015030860901,
-0.37677738070487976,
0.32735541462898254,
0.07616643607616425,
-0.04409782961010933,
1.0360174179077148,
-0.2209586501121521,
0.2252594530582428,
0.17404413223266602,
-0.46239781379699707,
0.03488711267709732,
-0.5470783114433289,
0.0022296912502497435,
0.279610276222229,
-0.10463611036539078,
-0.4944833815097809
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.06331v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.06331v2
|
MedExQA: Medical Question Answering Benchmark with Multiple Explanations
| 2024-06-10T14:47:04 | 2024-07-03T10:13:56 |
Yunsoo Kim, Jinge Wu, Yusuf Abdulle, Honghan Wu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
This paper introduces MedExQA, a novel benchmark in medical
question-answering, to evaluate large language models' (LLMs) understanding of
medical knowledge through explanations. By constructing datasets across five
distinct medical specialties that are underrepresented in current datasets and
further incorporating multiple explanations for each question-answer pair, we
address a major gap in current medical QA benchmarks which is the absence of
comprehensive assessments of LLMs' ability to generate nuanced medical
explanations. Our work highlights the importance of explainability in medical
LLMs, proposes an effective methodology for evaluating models beyond
classification accuracy, and sheds light on one specific domain, speech
language pathology, where current LLMs including GPT4 lack good understanding.
Our results show generation evaluation with multiple explanations aligns better
with human assessment, highlighting an opportunity for a more robust automated
comprehension assessment for LLMs. To diversify open-source medical LLMs
(currently mostly based on Llama2), this work also proposes a new medical
model, MedPhi-2, based on Phi-2 (2.7B). The model outperformed medical LLMs
based on Llama2-70B in generating explanations, showing its effectiveness in
the resource-constrained medical domain. We will share our benchmark datasets
and the trained model.
|
[
-0.24612364172935486,
-0.47147753834724426,
1.0491191148757935,
-0.09410824626684189,
-0.25108927488327026,
0.04406735301017761,
0.01764415018260479,
-0.3078829348087311,
-0.07657334208488464,
0.34964627027511597,
-0.855471670627594,
-0.37448617815971375,
-0.5755590796470642,
0.17144976556301117,
-0.00829965341836214,
0.8761334419250488,
-0.28902220726013184,
0.5958336591720581,
-0.4463088810443878,
-0.4435541331768036,
-0.3158954977989197,
-0.31952980160713196,
-0.7106500864028931,
-0.3881450891494751,
0.6275959610939026,
0.3764541447162628,
0.747772216796875,
0.7712690234184265,
0.40392303466796875,
0.1915871948003769,
-0.04354487732052803,
0.2297900915145874,
-0.1598345935344696,
0.13793981075286865,
-0.13499516248703003,
-0.43272730708122253,
-0.4104178845882416,
0.07492902129888535,
0.5942765474319458,
0.9904676675796509,
-0.29242581129074097,
0.18515750765800476,
-0.31187278032302856,
0.6351467967033386,
-0.33463701605796814,
-0.17476505041122437,
-0.42807289958000183,
0.013823981396853924,
-0.03151220455765724,
-0.0933711901307106,
-0.06310001015663147,
-0.5208165049552917,
0.16745665669441223,
-0.7071335315704346,
0.16363243758678436,
0.08384691178798676,
0.6021397709846497,
0.5237091779708862,
-0.5880411863327026,
-0.13827566802501678,
-0.3262815475463867,
0.6206139326095581,
-0.8040743470191956,
0.34573763608932495,
0.16526074707508087,
0.8354713320732117,
0.039454057812690735,
-0.9953749775886536,
-0.6024988889694214,
0.023805752396583557,
0.16108758747577667,
0.35127177834510803,
-0.2133335918188095,
0.05598830431699753,
0.08601297438144684,
0.5040343403816223,
-0.7514525055885315,
0.2262645661830902,
-0.5285228490829468,
-0.07868017256259918,
0.2879628837108612,
0.3191903233528137,
0.25338438153266907,
0.0923994779586792,
-0.5302214622497559,
0.271529883146286,
-0.9340423941612244,
0.023730862885713577,
-0.107215516269207,
-0.24009867012500763,
-0.18256771564483643,
0.5526149272918701,
-0.15314936637878418,
0.5101710557937622,
-0.4404759109020233,
-0.1208580806851387,
0.3363381326198578,
-0.4051183760166168,
-0.2549835443496704,
-0.22576823830604553,
0.49474939703941345,
0.5138370394706726,
0.16303570568561554,
-0.23701801896095276,
0.1179381012916565,
0.14238083362579346,
-0.003917880821973085,
-0.7930377721786499,
-0.04428337886929512,
0.6976063251495361,
-0.9817845821380615,
-0.15161415934562683,
-0.3508414328098297,
-0.8681930303573608,
-0.7708899974822998,
-0.1517656147480011,
0.35685330629348755,
-0.13918814063072205,
-0.2652640640735626,
0.4522474408149719,
-0.09499270468950272,
0.26934126019477844,
0.2524147033691406,
-0.631601870059967,
0.5341060757637024,
0.5261951684951782,
0.6637254953384399,
-0.2756955027580261,
-0.17592427134513855,
-0.46070948243141174,
-0.08143574744462967,
-0.2688111364841461,
0.8196310997009277,
-0.45664918422698975,
-0.07547778636217117,
-0.03266117349267006,
-0.09080711007118225,
-0.06048479676246643,
-0.7514630556106567,
0.5771259069442749,
-0.2083154022693634,
0.5065540075302124,
-0.3583851456642151,
-0.5725194811820984,
-0.4887879192829132,
0.12091867625713348,
-0.47177329659461975,
0.6502123475074768,
0.15258049964904785,
-0.5900216102600098,
0.3481440246105194,
-0.7850017547607422,
-0.07803899794816971,
0.13866305351257324,
-0.4766683280467987,
-0.28536808490753174,
0.1488741934299469,
0.5116262435913086,
0.22609573602676392,
-0.9511821269989014,
0.35874873399734497,
-0.2752592861652374,
-0.276014119386673,
0.5123857259750366,
-0.5078035593032837,
0.7387552261352539,
0.21601177752017975,
-0.15900619328022003,
0.11003872007131577,
-0.6810896396636963,
0.23695184290409088,
0.29758888483047485,
-0.22605884075164795,
0.03279447183012962,
0.11415758728981018,
-0.22961106896400452,
0.4376763701438904,
0.14006321132183075,
-0.5432560443878174,
-0.02760300040245056,
-0.5804528594017029,
0.4968571364879608,
0.39608603715896606,
0.14829103648662567,
-0.12823177874088287,
-0.6135683059692383,
0.8698474764823914,
-0.09186935424804688,
0.4010414779186249,
-0.3294355869293213,
-0.7320674061775208,
-0.24467508494853973,
-0.37469351291656494,
0.24045194685459137,
0.45021647214889526,
-0.5672416090965271,
-0.27748748660087585,
-0.19436481595039368,
-0.41178271174430847,
-1.018318772315979,
-0.01488289050757885,
0.621970534324646,
0.7063853144645691,
0.5443544983863831,
-0.16118599474430084,
-0.46051502227783203,
-1.1263517141342163,
-0.49279096722602844,
-0.09796998649835587,
-0.2989427149295807,
0.5271683931350708,
0.386167973279953,
-0.25503411889076233,
0.45585939288139343,
-0.21611441671848297,
0.1733292043209076,
-0.19052980840206146,
-0.07195791602134705,
0.3481287360191345,
0.10785429179668427,
0.5166868567466736,
-0.7101803421974182,
0.05058601126074791,
-0.2951001524925232,
-0.5845879316329956,
-0.3486122488975525,
-0.01157605741173029,
0.12088088691234589,
-0.1930575966835022,
0.33168429136276245,
-0.5162151455879211,
0.18595607578754425,
0.6962451934814453,
-0.4193475842475891,
0.5850216150283813,
-0.20320622622966766,
0.2069154530763626,
-1.1135165691375732,
0.16670645773410797,
-0.15997670590877533,
-0.14884383976459503,
-0.5862541198730469,
0.2728474736213684,
-0.016757125034928322,
-0.12480677664279938,
-0.4676395654678345,
0.6312175393104553,
-0.3374911844730377,
-0.14414170384407043,
-0.12788672745227814,
0.2847423553466797,
0.22051052749156952,
0.3652311861515045,
-0.2684975564479828,
0.6829625368118286,
0.6548248529434204,
-0.33662334084510803,
0.43207183480262756,
0.33374857902526855,
-0.19278670847415924,
0.3527262806892395,
-1.0151671171188354,
-0.0333867184817791,
-0.11522801965475082,
0.2880312204360962,
-1.1429944038391113,
-0.184147447347641,
0.14682042598724365,
-0.5847827792167664,
-0.1589602380990982,
-0.18311545252799988,
-0.4880209267139435,
-0.6066112518310547,
-0.23071511089801788,
0.5927373766899109,
0.5263569951057434,
-0.6034660339355469,
0.4509566128253937,
0.34166449308395386,
-0.3723113536834717,
-0.5302816033363342,
-0.6129721999168396,
-0.039701975882053375,
-0.31781575083732605,
-0.5410352945327759,
0.3149372637271881,
-0.40335264801979065,
-0.3681046664714813,
-0.21805788576602936,
-0.41239073872566223,
-0.3521946370601654,
0.21869796514511108,
0.27141115069389343,
0.3225967288017273,
-0.5130994915962219,
0.45954716205596924,
0.24862535297870636,
-0.13919426500797272,
0.5017890930175781,
-0.0640258938074112,
0.25034472346305847,
-0.022313639521598816,
-0.5254349112510681,
-0.5048423409461975,
0.48491567373275757,
0.917922854423523,
-0.2776106894016266,
0.6142342686653137,
0.2111835777759552,
-0.5239184498786926,
0.17830637097358704,
-0.5694403052330017,
-0.28501951694488525,
-0.36262115836143494,
0.32563236355781555,
-0.4440534710884094,
-0.6555716395378113,
0.6194853782653809,
-0.2795811891555786,
0.3327734172344208,
0.668391227722168,
0.8787341117858887,
-0.11081192642450333,
1.3980951309204102,
0.15999962389469147,
0.2247036099433899,
-0.3918831944465637,
0.23789428174495697,
-0.033218465745449066,
-0.6429843902587891,
-0.32714492082595825,
-0.6435931324958801,
-0.08871220797300339,
-0.404269278049469,
-0.42717403173446655,
0.5082575678825378,
-0.1457175463438034,
-0.19028279185295105,
-0.33685776591300964,
-0.4273677170276642,
0.3841104805469513,
0.4004998207092285,
0.09369329363107681,
0.28727665543556213,
-0.18473297357559204,
-0.3579160273075104,
0.07298116385936737,
-0.734248697757721,
-0.502657413482666,
1.2209768295288086,
0.7215831279754639,
0.5042895674705505,
0.2866321802139282,
0.3982688784599304,
-0.08145248144865036,
0.2774635851383209,
-0.6574301719665527,
0.18468795716762543,
-0.29283931851387024,
-0.6848240494728088,
-0.1495499312877655,
-0.4176886975765228,
-0.9343417286872864,
0.43294113874435425,
-0.2826620042324066,
-0.51508629322052,
-0.14534467458724976,
0.1721126288175583,
-0.7020125985145569,
0.09805240482091904,
-0.6148643493652344,
0.9506362080574036,
-0.26945000886917114,
-0.017407633364200592,
-0.20111733675003052,
-0.7283616662025452,
0.5451728701591492,
-0.21000495553016663,
0.40728050470352173,
-0.3271697163581848,
-0.4042803645133972,
0.7942227721214294,
-0.4788963496685028,
0.47207456827163696,
-0.277907133102417,
-0.01722881570458412,
-0.19354690611362457,
-0.16359981894493103,
-0.015821542590856552,
0.23917751014232635,
-0.25626468658447266,
0.10152362287044525,
0.39508646726608276,
-0.5176876187324524,
-0.707586944103241,
0.5017955899238586,
-0.5721020698547363,
-0.5274503231048584,
-0.013220294378697872,
-0.5934050679206848,
-0.5064452290534973,
-0.006987268105149269,
0.19953131675720215,
0.6014822721481323,
0.13523580133914948,
0.06065782532095909,
0.7708138823509216,
-0.6473674178123474,
-0.021645566448569298,
0.7506647706031799,
-0.12372931092977524,
-0.38288867473602295,
0.4131692051887512,
-0.26860055327415466,
0.10131316632032394,
0.15950992703437805,
0.4295659363269806,
-0.5025539994239807,
-0.8365553617477417,
-0.6736438870429993,
0.48776790499687195,
-0.7525004148483276,
-0.033689748495817184,
-0.48978668451309204,
-0.13345259428024292,
-0.22779574990272522,
0.17255568504333496,
-0.15571735799312592,
-0.5082582235336304,
0.06277184933423996,
0.09683859348297119,
0.21780554950237274,
0.7698782086372375,
0.17612206935882568,
0.11921754479408264,
-0.7933506369590759,
0.805195152759552,
0.34709033370018005,
0.5459650754928589,
-0.21619555354118347,
-0.7122526168823242,
0.000027482814402901568,
0.014144090004265308,
0.030324580147862434,
-1.1766479015350342,
0.030723480507731438,
0.12659642100334167,
0.8833698034286499,
0.40335163474082947,
-0.17441023886203766,
0.5700246691703796,
-0.5814024209976196,
0.8048251867294312,
0.2624756693840027,
-0.7600827217102051,
0.5852954387664795,
-0.1512124389410019,
0.4978077709674835,
0.45980510115623474,
0.4110567271709442,
-0.6496590375900269,
-0.3240192234516144,
-0.5595175623893738,
-0.6562909483909607,
0.34410813450813293,
0.11407492309808731,
-0.16486045718193054,
0.15663307905197144,
0.6206520795822144,
0.4619152545928955,
-0.0007674507796764374,
-0.5565441846847534,
-0.46024295687675476,
0.10334256291389465,
-0.41338175535202026,
0.01594918593764305,
-0.4821716248989105,
-0.5193150043487549,
-0.06163671612739563,
0.5831043124198914,
-0.16102485358715057,
0.2850475013256073,
0.23041659593582153,
0.009141208603978157,
-0.041418999433517456,
0.3600621223449707,
0.8092594742774963,
1.0807998180389404,
0.10206571221351624,
0.2393302172422409,
0.3009635806083679,
-0.3307788670063019,
-0.036206118762493134,
0.533592939376831,
0.37462419271469116,
0.14642401039600372,
0.39343035221099854,
0.4870602786540985,
0.03504328057169914,
-0.9584910869598389,
0.729000449180603,
-0.3783515691757202,
-0.47559767961502075,
-0.04120606184005737,
-0.18363918364048004,
0.28726354241371155,
0.3547198474407196,
0.3531018793582916,
-0.18233980238437653,
0.2639932930469513,
-0.27384310960769653,
0.15745779871940613,
0.2617858946323395,
-0.2655240297317505,
-0.052285972982645035,
1.0415048599243164,
0.07497388124465942,
0.04547867551445961,
0.30776625871658325,
0.251712441444397,
-0.32312288880348206,
0.8147264122962952,
0.3435131013393402,
0.3688229024410248,
-0.3121578097343445,
0.09134648740291595,
0.27287009358406067,
0.30432114005088806,
0.18686409294605255,
0.7818970084190369,
0.09363186359405518,
-0.45526236295700073,
-0.6462036967277527,
-0.21726931631565094,
-0.7218541502952576,
0.3645823895931244,
-0.6174942255020142,
-0.07377812266349792,
-0.21731585264205933,
0.10576698184013367,
0.6284058690071106,
-0.0488848052918911,
-0.644004225730896,
0.3348347246646881,
0.11857953667640686,
1.096540927886963,
-0.8288729786872864,
0.7218399047851562,
0.7300189733505249,
-0.42131897807121277,
-0.824264645576477,
-0.03564614802598953,
0.21737366914749146,
-1.1559258699417114,
0.2922019958496094,
0.19685038924217224,
0.07413140684366226,
-0.2733400762081146,
-0.5037530660629272,
-0.6385475993156433,
0.9399080872535706,
0.4481028914451599,
-0.5088672637939453,
0.025161316618323326,
-0.0042957342229783535,
0.5855582356452942,
-0.35831978917121887,
0.31317806243896484,
0.6774663329124451,
0.4208829700946808,
-0.17508919537067413,
-0.921529233455658,
0.2689294219017029,
-0.2709505259990692,
-0.27409225702285767,
-0.11256062239408493,
-0.18715611100196838,
0.6255050301551819,
-0.5611379146575928,
-0.04141085222363472,
0.43046292662620544,
0.07502006739377975,
0.6256933808326721,
0.5697795152664185,
0.46825647354125977,
0.3790171444416046,
0.8213884234428406,
-0.09201498329639435,
1.1846976280212402,
-0.29336026310920715,
0.07770425826311111,
1.0372350215911865,
-0.05724821612238884,
0.62882000207901,
0.510017991065979,
-0.3106413781642914,
0.5169344544410706,
0.9494168162345886,
0.13355717062950134,
0.2801726460456848,
0.48412734270095825,
-0.26865023374557495,
-0.34231501817703247,
-0.020726781338453293,
-0.5948574542999268,
0.38492411375045776,
0.36031195521354675,
-0.6619652509689331,
-0.21628299355506897,
0.058430787175893784,
-0.03153969347476959,
0.009374807588756084,
-0.2854043245315552,
0.7237588763237,
0.053283847868442535,
-0.7068014740943909,
0.7615000009536743,
-0.05294852703809738,
0.011012107133865356,
-0.42810776829719543,
-0.16031302511692047,
-0.40115582942962646,
0.0022958393674343824,
-0.1291501820087433,
-0.7586373686790466,
0.05355553701519966,
0.004022148437798023,
-0.33300408720970154,
0.0023964254651218653,
0.4103321433067322,
-0.40503472089767456,
-0.1917736679315567,
0.10692425817251205,
0.7586109638214111,
0.6704533100128174,
-0.03036106377840042,
-0.9402415156364441,
-0.17861920595169067,
-0.11917705088853836,
-0.04837287589907646,
-0.10264691710472107,
0.39917367696762085,
0.1183328703045845,
0.8585572838783264,
0.4557851254940033,
0.18037216365337372,
-0.03159011900424957,
0.4006607234477997,
0.7487723231315613,
-0.39272236824035645,
-0.3068273067474365,
-0.7635976076126099,
0.3661718964576721,
0.041250310838222504,
-0.35383155941963196,
0.3271445333957672,
0.5167586803436279,
0.1767120361328125,
0.05489019304513931,
0.744618833065033,
0.41315239667892456,
1.0448461771011353,
-0.6278439164161682,
0.6826171875,
-0.9014694094657898,
0.3337826430797577,
0.21190592646598816,
-0.5663489103317261,
-0.39894458651542664,
0.1402292549610138,
-0.018723415210843086,
0.13792860507965088,
0.94797682762146,
0.6831632852554321,
-0.011153224855661392,
0.13094483315944672,
0.4041595458984375,
0.39706769585609436,
-0.04458050802350044,
0.7860012054443359,
0.8103169202804565,
-0.396697074174881,
0.7274598479270935,
0.0332731232047081,
-0.4100649654865265,
-0.10505840182304382,
-0.5964640378952026,
-0.6654536128044128,
-0.48746535181999207,
-0.32368865609169006,
-0.34845712780952454,
0.18282651901245117,
0.6434040665626526,
0.803499698638916,
-0.7333887815475464,
0.21876724064350128,
0.10985297709703445,
0.15814019739627838,
-0.4232034683227539,
-0.11996117979288101,
0.46700724959373474,
-0.10100103914737701,
-0.5007509589195251,
0.6495937705039978,
0.22775530815124512,
-0.0428607314825058,
-0.325055867433548,
-0.07071048766374588,
0.18365325033664703,
0.15939201414585114,
0.29468849301338196,
0.3185040354728699,
-1.1185675859451294,
0.06780149787664413,
0.017340170219540596,
-0.01998933218419552,
0.21890510618686676,
0.911352276802063,
-0.8121993541717529,
0.5730800032615662,
0.21239028871059418,
0.8539848327636719,
0.15999311208724976,
-0.11472251266241074,
0.6458284258842468,
-0.32506710290908813,
-0.39744263887405396,
0.22207419574260712,
0.5482116937637329,
0.21292200684547424,
-0.19038282334804535,
0.49761584401130676,
-0.008205750025808811,
-0.473910391330719,
-0.6755843758583069,
0.19303637742996216,
-0.9643847942352295,
-0.5826058387756348,
1.1413997411727905,
-0.24338126182556152,
0.06291026622056961,
-0.4508625566959381,
-0.2373480498790741,
0.2535829544067383,
-0.004385761450976133,
0.713403582572937,
0.47573402523994446,
-0.18731290102005005,
-0.4441448748111725,
-0.9715460538864136,
0.46498340368270874,
0.7846319079399109,
-1.207380771636963,
0.14904111623764038,
0.5117281079292297,
0.4837963581085205,
-0.3690556287765503,
0.6743776798248291,
-0.49692368507385254,
0.9479179382324219,
-0.16443033516407013,
-0.018307259306311607,
0.04468656703829765,
-0.1082405298948288,
-0.6741636991500854,
0.06866925209760666,
0.10539906471967697,
-0.49132922291755676
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.06329v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.06329v1
|
A Parameter-efficient Language Extension Framework for Multilingual ASR
| 2024-06-10T14:46:07 | 2024-06-10T14:46:07 |
Wei Liu, Jingyong Hou, Dong Yang, Muyong Cao, Tan Lee
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, eess.AS
|
Covering all languages with a multilingual speech recognition model (MASR) is
very difficult. Performing language extension on top of an existing MASR is a
desirable choice. In this study, the MASR continual learning problem is
probabilistically decomposed into language identity prediction (LP) and
cross-lingual adaptation (XLA) sub-problems. Based on this, we propose an
architecture-based framework for language extension that can fundamentally
solve catastrophic forgetting, debudded as PELE. PELE is designed to be
parameter-efficient, incrementally incorporating an add-on module to adapt to a
new language. Specifically, different parameter-efficient fine-tuning (PEFT)
modules and their variants are explored as potential candidates to perform XLA.
Experiments are carried out on 5 new languages with a wide range of
low-resourced data sizes. The best-performing PEFT candidate can achieve
satisfactory performance across all languages and demonstrates superiority in
three of five languages over the continual joint learning setting. Notably,
PEFT methods focusing on weight parameters or input features are revealed to be
limited in performance, showing significantly inferior extension capabilities
compared to inserting a lightweight module in between layers such as an
Adapter.
|
[
-0.2303132563829422,
-0.550908625125885,
0.31148532032966614,
0.1544194221496582,
-0.12596407532691956,
0.16558179259300232,
-0.43116459250450134,
-0.28457027673721313,
-0.03839685022830963,
0.34091854095458984,
-0.35993754863739014,
-0.149361252784729,
-0.4575203061103821,
-0.007213052362203598,
0.13824932277202606,
0.7540950179100037,
-0.159444198012352,
-0.15298685431480408,
0.24890048801898956,
-0.4542263448238373,
-0.4201740324497223,
-0.41596654057502747,
-0.9050878286361694,
-0.3220219910144806,
0.3645976483821869,
0.46944668889045715,
0.3421599268913269,
0.48479750752449036,
0.12049540132284164,
0.33612048625946045,
-0.04356222227215767,
0.2888087332248688,
-0.32869550585746765,
-0.09342232346534729,
-0.5663103461265564,
-0.21262972056865692,
-0.5620834231376648,
-0.515575110912323,
1.1314283609390259,
1.0158593654632568,
-0.16638049483299255,
0.08859778195619583,
0.19923065602779388,
0.7476016879081726,
-0.6236401200294495,
0.08198664337396622,
-0.8754546642303467,
-0.17875681817531586,
0.03413335233926773,
-0.15722446143627167,
-0.28539618849754333,
0.09479393064975739,
0.12411345541477203,
-0.3264225721359253,
-0.05198926851153374,
-0.16993512213230133,
0.61578768491745,
0.11524979025125504,
-0.1776605099439621,
-0.3788567781448364,
-0.9106908440589905,
0.8434515595436096,
-0.4074346423149109,
0.7611880898475647,
0.2927633821964264,
0.2671758532524109,
0.034659840166568756,
-0.11624784022569656,
-0.26154810190200806,
-0.30936527252197266,
0.10506463050842285,
-0.07269100844860077,
-0.16575752198696136,
-0.12959860265254974,
-0.0648651123046875,
0.2175881266593933,
-0.7817102074623108,
0.023238928988575935,
-0.45648637413978577,
-0.26379120349884033,
0.5267719030380249,
-0.2157602310180664,
0.3197602331638336,
0.3560906946659088,
-0.18343031406402588,
0.10754159837961197,
-0.8794203400611877,
0.03859352320432663,
0.3513118326663971,
0.48943033814430237,
-0.12574660778045654,
0.018890416249632835,
0.12270542234182358,
0.5814123153686523,
0.1768403947353363,
-0.2163546085357666,
0.41149747371673584,
0.0009264255058951676,
-0.09344532340765,
0.09010914713144302,
0.4542611837387085,
-0.22526906430721283,
0.2883329391479492,
-0.40908852219581604,
-0.19454969465732574,
-0.18076078593730927,
-0.17857006192207336,
-0.40993720293045044,
-0.30824950337409973,
0.08261221647262573,
-0.2360990047454834,
0.3465161621570587,
-0.24447692930698395,
-0.46639734506607056,
0.1509571522474289,
-0.20363275706768036,
0.6351994872093201,
-0.9337286949157715,
-0.48508331179618835,
0.17915457487106323,
0.2608594596385956,
0.1253419816493988,
0.04189394786953926,
-0.7862662672996521,
0.3364981412887573,
0.45042872428894043,
0.6064218878746033,
-0.22608597576618195,
-0.6952124238014221,
-0.9553858041763306,
0.4701935052871704,
-0.26213499903678894,
0.7110843658447266,
-0.7623670697212219,
-0.4760245680809021,
-0.1907539665699005,
0.34818559885025024,
-0.5487229824066162,
-0.7713311314582825,
0.3805354833602905,
-0.2969777286052704,
-0.11976001411676407,
-0.0751204788684845,
-0.4554557800292969,
-0.292741596698761,
0.21748097240924835,
-0.554441511631012,
0.7707239389419556,
0.12324127554893494,
-0.1922541707754135,
0.2102583348751068,
-0.47329339385032654,
-0.5232284665107727,
0.21156077086925507,
-0.11152485758066177,
-0.5339147448539734,
0.1456586867570877,
0.18387261033058167,
0.29049164056777954,
-0.21043133735656738,
0.49341878294944763,
-0.021633096039295197,
-0.38136112689971924,
-0.02681228704750538,
-0.552060067653656,
0.46116992831230164,
0.10607551783323288,
-0.35002923011779785,
-0.11883988976478577,
-1.1046783924102783,
-0.04226912185549736,
-0.16099773347377777,
-0.7939740419387817,
-0.370342493057251,
-0.015224670059978962,
0.12647892534732819,
0.04999386519193649,
0.17706720530986786,
-0.4978872239589691,
-0.12847363948822021,
-0.5918794870376587,
0.2398568093776703,
0.6615656018257141,
-0.11007309705018997,
0.5758969187736511,
-0.34633004665374756,
0.5403660535812378,
0.08942241966724396,
-0.10060734301805496,
-0.4797351360321045,
-0.26484864950180054,
-0.7450711131095886,
-0.20525339245796204,
0.0962778627872467,
0.5367996096611023,
-0.7807069420814514,
0.3957185447216034,
-0.3764965236186981,
-0.34999558329582214,
-0.12891609966754913,
0.3350380063056946,
0.9287902116775513,
0.3451464772224426,
0.3385715186595917,
-0.06963857263326645,
-0.48779964447021484,
-0.9016281366348267,
-0.3327668607234955,
-0.4087630808353424,
-0.050564318895339966,
0.32611334323883057,
0.28655439615249634,
-0.2222089171409607,
0.6817291378974915,
0.0373888798058033,
-0.33227548003196716,
-0.3937416076660156,
-0.14917375147342682,
0.12962940335273743,
0.8179824352264404,
0.6619620323181152,
-0.771497905254364,
-0.651880145072937,
0.4809090495109558,
-0.12114974111318588,
-0.005739785265177488,
-0.28905734419822693,
0.27317947149276733,
0.5145688056945801,
0.325870156288147,
-0.08873557299375534,
-0.07853380590677261,
0.7060530185699463,
-0.17237363755702972,
0.5667840242385864,
-0.5529862642288208,
-0.058170415461063385,
-0.9157717823982239,
0.12240128219127655,
-0.06759970635175705,
-0.07285191863775253,
-0.7139769196510315,
-0.10011719167232513,
0.22446352243423462,
-0.2549890875816345,
-0.4010941982269287,
0.6871522665023804,
-0.5502065420150757,
0.04054246470332146,
-0.3051926791667938,
-0.36538416147232056,
-0.2231660932302475,
0.6128196716308594,
0.19789427518844604,
0.7071654796600342,
0.9537566304206848,
-0.7348564863204956,
-0.014458531513810158,
-0.18110522627830505,
-0.05309240147471428,
0.36666959524154663,
-0.47972768545150757,
0.12927024066448212,
-0.3545449674129486,
-0.19767867028713226,
-0.863977313041687,
0.03431568667292595,
0.2081967294216156,
-0.38957035541534424,
0.615793764591217,
-0.3041759431362152,
-0.11967919021844864,
-0.032684434205293655,
0.002519905334338546,
0.3801947832107544,
0.4680615961551666,
-0.6277262568473816,
1.1144351959228516,
0.3930451571941376,
-0.3446274995803833,
-0.3781720995903015,
-0.5614568591117859,
0.0959157943725586,
-0.3046960234642029,
-0.3010769486427307,
0.5328303575515747,
-0.2936076521873474,
0.005896945483982563,
0.054271891713142395,
-0.2639007270336151,
-0.255556583404541,
-0.10700155049562454,
-0.04564274847507477,
-0.1556742638349533,
-0.3494354486465454,
0.22119860351085663,
0.2903141677379608,
-0.25157737731933594,
-0.26454952359199524,
-0.35730963945388794,
0.5485190153121948,
-0.4318615794181824,
-0.4539514482021332,
-0.2480241060256958,
0.6169776320457458,
0.5845637917518616,
-0.31041353940963745,
0.4815600514411926,
0.47543802857398987,
-0.34132155776023865,
-0.4123767912387848,
-0.6079583764076233,
0.2468002736568451,
-0.5219026803970337,
0.6588801145553589,
-0.9038089513778687,
-0.9369533061981201,
0.7547782063484192,
-0.23913615942001343,
0.002082180231809616,
0.2777706980705261,
0.5754971504211426,
0.2247907668352127,
0.5419300198554993,
0.8023751378059387,
-0.17413723468780518,
0.323194682598114,
-0.09129458665847778,
0.023121939972043037,
-0.6694654822349548,
-0.1984442174434662,
-0.2739225924015045,
-0.2145586907863617,
-0.4507962167263031,
-0.4061359167098999,
0.2667655646800995,
0.07547604292631149,
-0.09976312518119812,
0.6473726034164429,
-0.23742209374904633,
0.4977516829967499,
0.33839520812034607,
0.0064923991449177265,
0.16453582048416138,
0.06284778565168381,
-0.15415611863136292,
0.1190936267375946,
-0.7372512817382812,
-0.21400286257266998,
0.7786133885383606,
0.21640335023403168,
0.6940824389457703,
0.26419559121131897,
0.6253935694694519,
-0.10022573173046112,
0.03213196620345116,
-0.5853761434555054,
0.4624992311000824,
-0.38596832752227783,
-0.358316570520401,
-0.3244176208972931,
-0.4756399393081665,
-0.767227292060852,
0.2095441222190857,
0.242073193192482,
-0.8977155089378357,
0.5534685850143433,
0.3954378068447113,
-0.48802444338798523,
0.38962671160697937,
-0.6655470132827759,
0.5095449686050415,
-0.3618047535419464,
-0.4455106258392334,
-0.24202147126197815,
-0.4736706018447876,
-0.09239307045936584,
-0.5408887267112732,
0.25821593403816223,
-0.22495442628860474,
-0.22035598754882812,
0.5817452669143677,
-0.09260529279708862,
0.71279376745224,
-0.2714073061943054,
-0.26022011041641235,
0.18429076671600342,
0.06795685738325119,
0.3822173774242401,
0.11699128150939941,
-0.40758225321769714,
0.06585557013750076,
0.09093590080738068,
-0.39531511068344116,
-0.5027740001678467,
0.8054138422012329,
-0.6345963478088379,
-0.514123260974884,
-0.05112064257264137,
-0.6459213495254517,
-0.4745141565799713,
-0.010755467228591442,
0.07678345590829849,
0.5704874396324158,
-0.20797783136367798,
0.20707418024539948,
0.6307252049446106,
-0.5662928223609924,
0.6089115142822266,
0.9999064803123474,
0.037727367132902145,
-0.44248294830322266,
1.2584984302520752,
0.3926560878753662,
0.24798329174518585,
0.5862369537353516,
0.41960281133651733,
-0.0684347078204155,
-0.7225334644317627,
-0.5951088666915894,
0.24785593152046204,
-0.4773687720298767,
0.05237245932221413,
-0.6497979164123535,
-0.18216530978679657,
-0.3237907886505127,
-0.2919236123561859,
-0.5737767815589905,
-0.3191893696784973,
-0.19852133095264435,
0.06675636768341064,
0.25213199853897095,
0.09190600365400314,
-0.3072012960910797,
0.22539205849170685,
-0.9514518976211548,
0.15697641670703888,
0.2803691327571869,
0.438658744096756,
-0.043091677129268646,
-0.77669358253479,
-0.26346519589424133,
-0.18798868358135223,
-0.07326532900333405,
-0.6061595678329468,
0.4816473126411438,
1.1114099025726318,
0.7898501753807068,
0.5018521547317505,
-0.02198190800845623,
0.8564651608467102,
-0.8686492443084717,
0.3734259009361267,
0.1403600573539734,
-0.8677387833595276,
0.4843235909938812,
-0.31098097562789917,
0.3984125256538391,
0.5105131268501282,
0.3627602159976959,
-0.332698255777359,
-0.047939322888851166,
-0.29883435368537903,
-0.7852652072906494,
0.615227222442627,
-0.06218748167157173,
0.27730298042297363,
-0.05845115706324577,
0.51546311378479,
0.38531294465065,
-0.26133185625076294,
-0.5157268047332764,
-0.22503352165222168,
0.2346217781305313,
0.07099970430135727,
-0.25764361023902893,
-0.30629557371139526,
0.30494964122772217,
-0.437137633562088,
0.8848528861999512,
-0.3534999489784241,
-0.06667692214250565,
0.06192727014422417,
-0.23448032140731812,
-0.1322096437215805,
0.4326625466346741,
0.33378294110298157,
0.7982146739959717,
-0.040590185672044754,
0.03102591261267662,
0.42737770080566406,
-0.21410682797431946,
0.2947259545326233,
0.20060376822948456,
-0.03134747967123985,
0.13402575254440308,
0.23787319660186768,
0.690030038356781,
0.5097587704658508,
-0.9828323721885681,
0.05397677794098854,
0.362212210893631,
-0.1957007646560669,
-0.4166693389415741,
0.10089382529258728,
0.15795154869556427,
0.21740476787090302,
0.5195288062095642,
0.10712136328220367,
0.18625974655151367,
-0.7534949779510498,
0.5981611609458923,
0.3317132592201233,
-0.5168143510818481,
-0.6322941184043884,
0.43039602041244507,
0.10180683434009552,
-0.49036404490470886,
0.07629632949829102,
-0.26479148864746094,
-0.5942115783691406,
0.5285378098487854,
0.8514729738235474,
0.793342113494873,
-0.8252037763595581,
0.11029992997646332,
0.42908599972724915,
0.24772965908050537,
0.021769175305962563,
0.36857175827026367,
-0.2595033645629883,
-0.8051652312278748,
-0.4846911132335663,
-0.8443858623504639,
-0.25928425788879395,
0.09909743815660477,
-0.4171915054321289,
0.16279363632202148,
-0.3778530955314636,
0.22509922087192535,
-0.13292889297008514,
-0.1304033100605011,
-0.3365086019039154,
0.1407163143157959,
0.19496044516563416,
0.7428848147392273,
-0.8172377943992615,
1.3099209070205688,
0.9044855833053589,
-0.08494389802217484,
-0.7667998671531677,
-0.009205985814332962,
0.013784833252429962,
-0.7014763951301575,
0.611975371837616,
0.018612518906593323,
-0.4589233994483948,
-0.04158911854028702,
0.23944848775863647,
-1.0339837074279785,
0.6452608108520508,
0.7411755919456482,
-0.7254577279090881,
-0.10694869607686996,
0.2333909273147583,
0.3620828688144684,
-0.27767276763916016,
-0.18318429589271545,
0.7379096150398254,
0.20652659237384796,
0.351768434047699,
-1.1977052688598633,
-0.12035507708787918,
-0.30479535460472107,
0.10329697281122208,
0.21194936335086823,
-0.6920055747032166,
0.7258586287498474,
-0.1250813901424408,
-0.17215585708618164,
0.1271890103816986,
0.37106046080589294,
0.2944243252277374,
0.25513583421707153,
0.5204635262489319,
0.39512917399406433,
0.446397989988327,
0.26965734362602234,
0.6298342347145081,
-0.4116474688053131,
0.3165116608142853,
1.2988744974136353,
-0.31236839294433594,
0.8659460544586182,
0.44633594155311584,
-0.16428661346435547,
0.26914429664611816,
0.31471627950668335,
0.2178012877702713,
0.5862061381340027,
0.018305020406842232,
-0.3784024119377136,
-0.3538048267364502,
0.0793098658323288,
-0.37793657183647156,
0.5905695557594299,
0.6021370887756348,
-0.39028221368789673,
-0.3717162609100342,
0.3766716420650482,
-0.07177990674972534,
0.14292649924755096,
-0.4748084843158722,
0.6708566546440125,
0.053388845175504684,
-0.494742214679718,
0.6223360896110535,
-0.03746170923113823,
0.6913816332817078,
-0.653687596321106,
0.06346084177494049,
-0.17662502825260162,
0.5715731382369995,
0.007180425804108381,
-0.21232932806015015,
0.7274254560470581,
-0.2241416871547699,
-0.15859653055667877,
-0.1304583102464676,
0.6451077461242676,
-0.7393635511398315,
-0.7841289639472961,
0.49879005551338196,
0.4958374500274658,
0.14659340679645538,
-0.12934914231300354,
-0.7489600777626038,
0.22027114033699036,
0.02301376685500145,
-0.0679006427526474,
0.4459495544433594,
0.35265809297561646,
0.012450436130166054,
0.81772780418396,
0.43185412883758545,
0.14562998712062836,
0.06864143908023834,
-0.0021340942475944757,
0.9364608526229858,
-0.23973962664604187,
-0.523762583732605,
-0.8818157315254211,
0.37138181924819946,
0.2734343111515045,
-0.04600222781300545,
0.6154379844665527,
0.7075053453445435,
0.8846121430397034,
-0.15091456472873688,
0.6645343899726868,
0.05265112221240997,
0.5648207664489746,
-0.4528655707836151,
0.7893445491790771,
-0.7496894598007202,
0.37039363384246826,
-0.29925525188446045,
-0.889504611492157,
-0.4121919572353363,
0.508169949054718,
-0.28668028116226196,
-0.05906274542212486,
0.5014018416404724,
0.8318693041801453,
-0.2552017867565155,
-0.4099012017250061,
0.7792974710464478,
-0.006220878101885319,
0.20725516974925995,
1.0318931341171265,
0.4016939103603363,
-0.42637932300567627,
0.7396216988563538,
-0.08349621295928955,
-0.31525948643684387,
0.07803098857402802,
-0.6412738561630249,
-0.8562473058700562,
-0.7594024538993835,
-0.6232550144195557,
0.13375434279441833,
0.38460132479667664,
0.9064516425132751,
0.7613732814788818,
-1.1259161233901978,
-0.1819913685321808,
-0.05666900798678398,
-0.10297732055187225,
-0.35058996081352234,
-0.13607878983020782,
0.6017974615097046,
-0.36514812707901,
-0.9689452052116394,
0.772038459777832,
0.7357226014137268,
-0.2031630128622055,
0.00709157669916749,
-0.385273277759552,
-0.1006309986114502,
0.03013003058731556,
0.5887719988822937,
0.6640609502792358,
-0.7064324021339417,
-0.3061043918132782,
-0.05459840968251228,
0.6614630222320557,
0.10480346530675888,
0.7511836290359497,
-0.8582568764686584,
0.5140486359596252,
0.14417044818401337,
1.0627495050430298,
0.21537476778030396,
-0.245839461684227,
0.7548664808273315,
-0.6692798733711243,
0.24254387617111206,
0.1698814183473587,
0.603405237197876,
0.24446603655815125,
-0.22525674104690552,
0.18551208078861237,
0.12378578633069992,
-0.26984360814094543,
-0.5815432071685791,
0.4358285665512085,
-0.6912150382995605,
-0.38625821471214294,
1.0712964534759521,
-0.44111764430999756,
-0.1756177395582199,
-0.36369049549102783,
-0.11733509600162506,
-0.07551678270101547,
-0.23968163132667542,
0.5590874552726746,
0.3342488408088684,
-0.10112696141004562,
-0.5572860836982727,
-0.01730521209537983,
0.2525528073310852,
0.4244801700115204,
-0.5188283324241638,
0.14012610912322998,
0.3516745865345001,
0.47910070419311523,
0.2286110669374466,
0.7396079897880554,
-0.19595281779766083,
0.3721104562282562,
-0.11872239410877228,
-0.23595474660396576,
-0.10250283032655716,
-0.5942246317863464,
-0.4980984330177307,
0.36585280299186707,
0.05950767546892166,
-0.17256546020507812
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.06326v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.06326v3
|
Self-Tuning: Instructing LLMs to Effectively Acquire New Knowledge through Self-Teaching
| 2024-06-10T14:42:20 | 2024-06-15T09:45:37 |
Xiaoying Zhang, Baolin Peng, Ye Tian, Jingyan Zhou, Yipeng Zhang, Haitao Mi, Helen Meng
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) often struggle to provide up-to-date information
due to their one-time training and the constantly evolving nature of the world.
To keep LLMs current, existing approaches typically involve continued
pre-training on new documents. However, they frequently face difficulties in
extracting stored knowledge. Motivated by the remarkable success of the Feynman
Technique in efficient human learning, we introduce Self-Tuning, a learning
framework aimed at improving an LLM's ability to effectively acquire new
knowledge from raw documents through self-teaching. Specifically, we develop a
Self-Teaching strategy that augments the documents with a set of
knowledge-intensive tasks created in a self-supervised manner, focusing on
three crucial aspects: memorization, comprehension, and self-reflection. In
addition, we introduce three Wiki-Newpages-2023-QA datasets to facilitate an
in-depth analysis of an LLM's knowledge acquisition ability concerning
memorization, extraction, and reasoning. Extensive experimental results on
Llama2 family models reveal that Self-Tuning consistently exhibits superior
performance across all knowledge acquisition tasks and excels in preserving
previous knowledge.
|
[
-0.18630100786685944,
-0.5979703664779663,
0.5065361261367798,
0.08548927307128906,
-0.24398013949394226,
0.06697095930576324,
-0.10218453407287598,
-0.17117227613925934,
-0.044692542403936386,
0.6285940408706665,
-0.6498441100120544,
-0.30671054124832153,
-0.5069062113761902,
0.0038142181001603603,
-0.4134395718574524,
1.0409401655197144,
0.11502594500780106,
0.15767191350460052,
-0.2818640172481537,
0.21912595629692078,
-0.3855263292789459,
-0.24727587401866913,
-0.6937411427497864,
-0.582156240940094,
0.649765133857727,
0.6406142711639404,
0.3600480854511261,
1.102134346961975,
0.28730881214141846,
0.26975539326667786,
0.16797930002212524,
0.17116595804691315,
-0.6145003437995911,
0.2052992880344391,
-0.38334333896636963,
-0.6545373201370239,
-0.2794770300388336,
0.056306689977645874,
0.6466347575187683,
0.35126951336860657,
-0.3702494204044342,
0.18313628435134888,
0.24097999930381775,
0.755123496055603,
-0.5402623414993286,
0.0985807552933693,
-0.8136964440345764,
0.10198444128036499,
-0.1495078206062317,
-0.6147922277450562,
-0.19781549274921417,
-0.16193698346614838,
-0.058421600610017776,
-0.8673733472824097,
0.4071608781814575,
0.0005574009846895933,
0.6914682984352112,
0.39592739939689636,
-0.5062810182571411,
-0.3631674349308014,
-0.4180949032306671,
0.5858189463615417,
-0.6008251905441284,
0.41693994402885437,
0.500544011592865,
0.21980270743370056,
-0.29057443141937256,
-0.56563800573349,
-0.39103010296821594,
0.07066977769136429,
0.06268323212862015,
0.28090959787368774,
0.2207944542169571,
-0.04973481222987175,
0.14197520911693573,
0.488216757774353,
-0.3051435351371765,
0.3751770257949829,
-0.42850935459136963,
-0.1550290435552597,
0.5894981026649475,
0.07109056413173676,
0.1168140098452568,
-0.2635211944580078,
-0.3737219572067261,
-0.10782024264335632,
-0.8213099837303162,
-0.3627561926841736,
0.45009687542915344,
0.10034819692373276,
0.2343786209821701,
0.22429603338241577,
-0.31847360730171204,
0.6864823698997498,
0.28619277477264404,
-0.45220574736595154,
-0.03275955468416214,
-0.1491311937570572,
-0.018595067784190178,
0.010193772614002228,
0.5423866510391235,
0.13286077976226807,
0.32986193895339966,
-0.3262425363063812,
-0.3249525725841522,
-0.437663197517395,
0.3455256521701813,
-0.700348436832428,
-0.4663570523262024,
-0.271450400352478,
-0.31054919958114624,
-0.42987799644470215,
-0.2819841504096985,
-0.7242497801780701,
-0.33235061168670654,
-0.5788293480873108,
0.8542290925979614,
-0.43984100222587585,
-0.1906309425830841,
0.13537921011447906,
-0.09575694054365158,
0.41895970702171326,
0.42148759961128235,
-1.4872393608093262,
0.2448975294828415,
0.4413585960865021,
0.6429205536842346,
-0.31743133068084717,
-0.6081236600875854,
-0.38869571685791016,
0.5710989236831665,
-0.36023586988449097,
1.009827733039856,
-0.19449970126152039,
-0.39307472109794617,
-0.09996798634529114,
-0.13232894241809845,
-0.10532275587320328,
-0.6419793963432312,
0.19168786704540253,
-0.540035605430603,
0.28101110458374023,
-0.2015518695116043,
-0.8852362632751465,
0.009465903975069523,
0.137380912899971,
-0.3705911636352539,
1.069796085357666,
0.33279651403427124,
-0.32992058992385864,
0.20787325501441956,
-0.3323863446712494,
-0.6001316905021667,
0.03787098079919815,
-0.22743257880210876,
-0.3131631016731262,
0.29475054144859314,
0.23064005374908447,
0.7198847532272339,
-0.2143564075231552,
-0.013876506127417088,
-0.24552170932292938,
-0.16474077105522156,
0.0023633099626749754,
-0.3276505172252655,
0.393371045589447,
0.3382912874221802,
-0.09938887506723404,
-0.21912387013435364,
-0.7619553804397583,
0.1263248473405838,
0.1904316395521164,
-0.5083996653556824,
-0.20017294585704803,
-0.013076267205178738,
-0.5146383047103882,
0.2804183065891266,
0.3852508068084717,
-0.2549511790275574,
0.5223256349563599,
-0.42698025703430176,
0.3828008472919464,
0.9630367159843445,
0.08224581927061081,
0.3511304259300232,
-0.5348459482192993,
0.501258909702301,
0.012549730017781258,
0.17128169536590576,
-0.5785818099975586,
0.07446155697107315,
-1.0941195487976074,
0.1079539954662323,
0.0954795852303505,
0.29734379053115845,
-0.682680606842041,
0.35864824056625366,
-0.06870166957378387,
-0.3839246332645416,
-0.5973982810974121,
0.9721918702125549,
0.27915331721305847,
0.6120324730873108,
0.4544849991798401,
-0.07286456227302551,
-0.23728272318840027,
-0.709071934223175,
-0.38084131479263306,
0.15156495571136475,
0.152340367436409,
0.06950200349092484,
0.38865548372268677,
-0.26398929953575134,
0.8531007766723633,
-0.6517846584320068,
-0.5597217082977295,
-0.00892799161374569,
0.243073970079422,
0.0020109862089157104,
0.6052473187446594,
0.09080550074577332,
-0.3544382154941559,
-0.3665749132633209,
0.03803117573261261,
-0.906253457069397,
-0.017562922090291977,
-0.15913045406341553,
-0.22276952862739563,
0.15806448459625244,
0.8513321280479431,
-0.30397316813468933,
-0.07211580872535706,
0.3525930941104889,
-0.13035298883914948,
0.4072217643260956,
-0.5877155661582947,
-0.19134832918643951,
-1.1277899742126465,
-0.3669213354587555,
-0.18218670785427094,
-0.267167866230011,
-0.364574134349823,
-0.19645041227340698,
0.3787069022655487,
0.16307233273983002,
-0.24338078498840332,
0.7456386685371399,
-0.6865957975387573,
0.07383895665407181,
-0.5629927515983582,
0.26781269907951355,
0.0023638056591153145,
0.5248719453811646,
-0.1964247077703476,
0.792790412902832,
0.45450660586357117,
-0.6947930455207825,
0.2225869745016098,
0.2477680891752243,
-0.533261239528656,
0.5535961985588074,
-0.3443109691143036,
0.3043718934059143,
-0.16432110965251923,
-0.21742838621139526,
-0.44101956486701965,
-0.1247955709695816,
-0.06366105377674103,
-0.2085428684949875,
0.714015781879425,
-0.18459483981132507,
-0.5238664746284485,
-0.23132053017616272,
0.04872405529022217,
0.08651910722255707,
0.3966456353664398,
-0.8808333277702332,
0.7196288108825684,
0.28991812467575073,
-0.08804149180650711,
-0.4490755498409271,
-0.23054268956184387,
-0.2238200157880783,
-0.1836838275194168,
-0.29684290289878845,
0.2773321270942688,
-0.11087144911289215,
0.14415137469768524,
-0.08786579221487045,
-0.40064504742622375,
0.016856757923960686,
0.3836047053337097,
0.043503906577825546,
0.007703798823058605,
0.10302183777093887,
0.5783501863479614,
0.38059961795806885,
-0.31882765889167786,
0.12121432274580002,
-0.6647491455078125,
0.34451231360435486,
-0.0731973946094513,
-0.3687332570552826,
-0.3993692696094513,
-0.07771836966276169,
0.24638675153255463,
-0.2736331522464752,
0.42985960841178894,
0.5735832452774048,
-0.07235900312662125,
-0.5579919815063477,
-0.7974118590354919,
-0.4941457211971283,
-0.5742525458335876,
0.4098140597343445,
-0.49872004985809326,
-1.0212558507919312,
0.22360463440418243,
-0.4225844442844391,
0.023157717660069466,
0.5512591004371643,
0.5198177695274353,
-0.616668701171875,
0.9538658261299133,
0.8109993934631348,
-0.14115047454833984,
0.6668347716331482,
-0.3843044340610504,
-0.19405938684940338,
-0.8835409879684448,
-0.35702943801879883,
-0.3206448256969452,
0.0572211816906929,
-0.30729562044143677,
-0.294489324092865,
0.27772459387779236,
0.3481750786304474,
-0.19485291838645935,
0.09642018377780914,
-0.3120579719543457,
0.814875066280365,
0.5648526549339294,
0.11253238469362259,
0.4824768900871277,
0.0116301653906703,
-0.04785994067788124,
0.15782508254051208,
-0.9171637892723083,
-0.387230783700943,
1.2979093790054321,
0.3466302752494812,
1.058048129081726,
-0.028191223740577698,
0.9465318322181702,
0.25670504570007324,
0.33340513706207275,
-0.5815401673316956,
0.22035528719425201,
-0.047503989189863205,
-0.6354712247848511,
-0.5076636075973511,
-0.581815779209137,
-0.9588119983673096,
0.3845500349998474,
-0.13697449862957,
-0.39669254422187805,
-0.12190629541873932,
0.5342130661010742,
-0.2699492275714874,
0.15938988327980042,
-0.573401153087616,
0.917008638381958,
-0.8304128050804138,
-0.4684794545173645,
-0.43258944153785706,
-0.40896716713905334,
0.24353757500648499,
-0.4477902948856354,
0.09493706375360489,
-0.38048166036605835,
0.0362495593726635,
0.7669427990913391,
-0.01022939383983612,
0.8105278611183167,
-0.09572942554950714,
-0.36154618859291077,
0.053542133420705795,
0.23850609362125397,
0.39417406916618347,
0.09185492992401123,
-0.1530812531709671,
-0.10170400142669678,
0.35598841309547424,
-0.4633377492427826,
-0.935489296913147,
0.6471764445304871,
-1.0178427696228027,
-0.9397112131118774,
-0.42604324221611023,
-0.5286357998847961,
-0.32518789172172546,
0.3831358551979065,
0.22371412813663483,
0.25481677055358887,
-0.13489553332328796,
0.10944367200136185,
0.9853628873825073,
0.03410104662179947,
0.20539262890815735,
0.9851731657981873,
-0.33955878019332886,
-0.3771078288555145,
1.259732961654663,
0.30535686016082764,
0.33033114671707153,
0.42698001861572266,
0.4062657058238983,
-0.39420679211616516,
-0.583026111125946,
-0.2575784921646118,
0.44914573431015015,
-0.8682220578193665,
-0.41977983713150024,
-0.46131306886672974,
-0.20884113013744354,
-0.5039114356040955,
-0.0662221610546112,
-0.31422147154808044,
-0.32038602232933044,
-0.6220245957374573,
-0.10696744173765182,
0.19816963374614716,
0.9264858365058899,
-0.19396287202835083,
0.5457011461257935,
-0.6902207732200623,
0.13944676518440247,
0.7685943841934204,
0.3665470480918884,
0.019257713109254837,
-0.8875009417533875,
-0.5471785664558411,
-0.15906497836112976,
-0.5682123303413391,
-0.6898069381713867,
0.3864055573940277,
0.40936219692230225,
0.8517361879348755,
0.5064233541488647,
-0.09651084244251251,
0.6103411316871643,
-0.34843742847442627,
0.15412485599517822,
0.11314333230257034,
-0.8928186297416687,
0.818503201007843,
-0.5639299750328064,
0.4332800507545471,
0.7369189262390137,
0.48045414686203003,
-0.4602038860321045,
-0.25428852438926697,
-0.5212659239768982,
-0.4512024223804474,
0.739891529083252,
-0.19369253516197205,
0.31352075934410095,
-0.0023847606498748064,
0.9502176642417908,
0.17685824632644653,
0.2903948724269867,
-0.7409476637840271,
-0.05681078881025314,
-0.4999983012676239,
-0.35285210609436035,
-0.3068337142467499,
-0.3964725732803345,
-0.1327357441186905,
-0.5103181600570679,
0.8988091349601746,
-0.6600133180618286,
0.06538449227809906,
0.09575199335813522,
-0.4268589913845062,
-0.11437786370515823,
0.04849004000425339,
0.4040444791316986,
0.6823285818099976,
-0.04518478363752365,
0.30967947840690613,
0.4127606153488159,
-0.14001250267028809,
0.17677469551563263,
-0.14731930196285248,
-0.1338292807340622,
-0.6097092628479004,
0.33110538125038147,
0.6334145069122314,
0.5797041654586792,
-0.3792021572589874,
0.322661429643631,
0.15716446936130524,
-0.30339673161506653,
-0.3111003041267395,
0.6562654376029968,
0.1554875373840332,
0.15896232426166534,
0.39919039607048035,
-0.4791988432407379,
-0.110338494181633,
-0.4696461260318756,
0.221415176987648,
0.37319955229759216,
-0.2992892861366272,
-0.1387699395418167,
0.3649081289768219,
0.244516983628273,
-0.31467291712760925,
0.7443262338638306,
-0.1207578033208847,
-0.38353943824768066,
0.3519296944141388,
0.9741716384887695,
0.6696591973304749,
-0.33353912830352783,
0.15135404467582703,
0.2772168517112732,
0.26872751116752625,
-0.26320570707321167,
0.08932358026504517,
-0.4817989766597748,
-0.847623348236084,
-0.21484491229057312,
-0.8340325951576233,
-0.36272603273391724,
0.0504157580435276,
-0.773067057132721,
0.09400998800992966,
-0.5237876176834106,
0.1709749400615692,
-0.13522100448608398,
0.1939169019460678,
-0.47351986169815063,
0.1266278624534607,
-0.3200794458389282,
0.9023297429084778,
-0.6209047436714172,
1.2047816514968872,
0.25152745842933655,
-0.28802308440208435,
-0.7822225093841553,
-0.125104159116745,
-0.07718104869127274,
-0.9815803170204163,
0.5687147378921509,
-0.01805192045867443,
-0.14490734040737152,
0.5417738556861877,
-0.44235944747924805,
-1.154374122619629,
1.3365837335586548,
0.6244301199913025,
-0.7824242115020752,
-0.09902691841125488,
-0.05855582654476166,
0.49601367115974426,
-0.08565628528594971,
0.09014591574668884,
0.6011102199554443,
0.33822181820869446,
0.0840829387307167,
-0.552097499370575,
-0.3437257409095764,
-0.01572006195783615,
-0.20614713430404663,
0.23482179641723633,
-0.9519138932228088,
0.5421617031097412,
-0.18754960596561432,
-0.025826282799243927,
-0.13863243162631989,
0.8671678304672241,
-0.11512626707553864,
0.03491291403770447,
0.4244898855686188,
0.6156483888626099,
0.9657301902770996,
-0.013265730813145638,
0.8670433163642883,
-0.5727525949478149,
0.38785919547080994,
1.2785743474960327,
-0.10890115797519684,
0.6777200698852539,
0.32983148097991943,
0.08372896909713745,
0.49783170223236084,
0.5088844895362854,
-0.32777732610702515,
0.3363242745399475,
0.14776302874088287,
-0.2033090889453888,
-0.6255090236663818,
0.2648918330669403,
-0.29258784651756287,
0.6951932311058044,
0.3016343116760254,
-0.22506412863731384,
-0.21595710515975952,
0.10588326305150986,
0.0807918906211853,
0.0507676787674427,
-0.38585424423217773,
1.064136266708374,
0.25388026237487793,
-0.8727267384529114,
0.39712899923324585,
-0.10865527391433716,
0.44042912125587463,
-0.8240997195243835,
0.08704229444265366,
-0.3679167926311493,
0.22952650487422943,
-0.19356875121593475,
-0.5066473484039307,
0.13427087664604187,
-0.36186128854751587,
-0.28769615292549133,
-0.49130111932754517,
0.7453184723854065,
-0.5616300702095032,
-0.4941176772117615,
0.3772321045398712,
0.5962643027305603,
0.07427172362804413,
0.1353471428155899,
-0.6353862285614014,
-0.2159484326839447,
-0.13367070257663727,
-0.09133312851190567,
0.6400841474533081,
0.3458176255226135,
0.34255361557006836,
1.0147095918655396,
0.5818226933479309,
0.07406359910964966,
0.14392584562301636,
0.03235189616680145,
0.7413899898529053,
-0.7772235870361328,
-0.27686843276023865,
-0.7358765006065369,
-0.10701029002666473,
0.02812648005783558,
-0.41806164383888245,
1.092807650566101,
0.5588502883911133,
0.9633519649505615,
0.001021552481688559,
0.5860666632652283,
0.4962605834007263,
0.5030698776245117,
-0.8982760906219482,
0.7872273921966553,
-0.6489625573158264,
0.23039110004901886,
0.04379143565893173,
-0.6616765856742859,
0.010181263089179993,
0.8173518776893616,
-0.21667706966400146,
0.16280342638492584,
0.5359949469566345,
0.8349286317825317,
0.22185519337654114,
-0.024606451392173767,
0.5295749306678772,
0.22706486284732819,
0.2582889497280121,
0.41319870948791504,
0.9873514771461487,
-0.2011183202266693,
0.4858841300010681,
-0.4188922643661499,
-0.07341835647821426,
-0.08706600219011307,
-0.8472292423248291,
-1.0221930742263794,
-0.5548292398452759,
-0.2599509358406067,
0.024570010602474213,
0.28860440850257874,
0.7908344864845276,
0.8301435708999634,
-0.41688504815101624,
-0.386971116065979,
-0.11119870096445084,
0.39894574880599976,
-0.07284756749868393,
-0.12656307220458984,
0.2591596245765686,
-0.9984663128852844,
-0.502161979675293,
0.6448906064033508,
0.35663139820098877,
0.2694449722766876,
-0.5271323919296265,
-0.13378925621509552,
-0.07189013808965683,
0.01833309605717659,
0.4955799877643585,
0.43410158157348633,
-0.40104028582572937,
-0.09888257831335068,
-0.07604848593473434,
-0.05304911360144615,
0.04014375060796738,
0.8880251049995422,
-0.8153148293495178,
0.5658692121505737,
0.04784144461154938,
0.6374731659889221,
0.9297304153442383,
-0.1899605095386505,
0.5713710188865662,
-0.49665313959121704,
-0.3606569170951843,
-0.05617053434252739,
0.17522874474525452,
0.2760026454925537,
-0.45171087980270386,
0.36944860219955444,
0.2818636894226074,
-0.7894400358200073,
-0.5629843473434448,
0.14811068773269653,
-0.5434787273406982,
-0.4019830524921417,
0.9914555549621582,
0.04154167324304581,
-0.12651799619197845,
-0.15034987032413483,
-0.006094496231526136,
0.27574390172958374,
-0.06276332587003708,
1.2629817724227905,
0.5381620526313782,
-0.18435585498809814,
-0.2815925180912018,
-0.4312664568424225,
0.6833757758140564,
0.7025520205497742,
-1.01485013961792,
0.016317203640937805,
0.24961039423942566,
0.6549368500709534,
-0.18412858247756958,
0.7047271728515625,
0.08279278874397278,
0.2657546401023865,
-0.2656393051147461,
0.05966167896986008,
-0.2931930720806122,
-0.5986928939819336,
-0.5793642401695251,
0.15218175947666168,
0.3060670495033264,
0.19268371164798737
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10255v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10255v1
|
WarCov -- Large multilabel and multimodal dataset from social platform
| 2024-06-10T14:36:44 | 2024-06-10T14:36:44 |
Weronika Borek-Marciniec, Pawel Zyblewski, Jakub Klikowski, Pawel Ksieniewicz
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SI
|
In the classification tasks, from raw data acquisition to the curation of a
dataset suitable for use in evaluating machine learning models, a series of
steps - often associated with high costs - are necessary. In the case of
Natural Language Processing, initial cleaning and conversion can be performed
automatically, but obtaining labels still requires the rationalized input of
human experts. As a result, even though many articles often state that "the
world is filled with data", data scientists suffer from its shortage. It is
crucial in the case of natural language applications, which is constantly
evolving and must adapt to new concepts or events. For example, the topic of
the COVID-19 pandemic and the vocabulary related to it would have been mostly
unrecognizable before 2019. For this reason, creating new datasets, also in
languages other than English, is still essential. This work presents a
collection of 3~187~105 posts in Polish about the pandemic and the war in
Ukraine published on popular social media platforms in 2022. The collection
includes not only preprocessed texts but also images so it can be used also for
multimodal recognition tasks. The labels define posts' topics and were created
using hashtags accompanying the posts. The work presents the process of
curating a dataset from acquisition to sample pattern recognition experiments.
|
[
-0.6532975435256958,
-0.8052459955215454,
0.1432083398103714,
0.19839945435523987,
-0.35458019375801086,
0.4746510684490204,
-0.30600807070732117,
-0.4559799134731293,
0.2626405954360962,
0.6088119149208069,
-0.4222359359264374,
-0.8046135306358337,
-0.8562111854553223,
-0.0599224790930748,
-0.15101692080497742,
1.0480107069015503,
-0.19643846154212952,
-0.11440807580947876,
-0.16760924458503723,
-0.28482094407081604,
-0.27131155133247375,
-0.6393913626670837,
-0.4709215462207794,
0.01853356696665287,
0.5896667838096619,
0.7982616424560547,
0.36539480090141296,
0.45469486713409424,
0.6217706799507141,
0.377717524766922,
0.2643059492111206,
0.5463815927505493,
-0.5246292352676392,
0.4824776351451874,
-0.2134617120027542,
-0.05318959802389145,
-0.09458867460489273,
-0.034891627728939056,
0.3347795903682709,
0.40897029638290405,
-0.06044195592403412,
0.2780904471874237,
-0.06010594964027405,
0.5346616506576538,
-0.6516337394714355,
0.4322729706764221,
-0.4552147686481476,
-0.04527175426483154,
-0.09210854023694992,
-0.009368155151605606,
-0.37915289402008057,
0.06811797618865967,
-0.1384647786617279,
-0.7633451223373413,
0.22631143033504486,
-0.08867420256137848,
0.6777980923652649,
-0.1844175159931183,
-0.554135799407959,
-0.4882141649723053,
-0.7362117767333984,
0.8877035975456238,
-0.18150098621845245,
0.3385266661643982,
0.41732412576675415,
0.48546668887138367,
-0.4218688905239105,
-0.7950310111045837,
-0.3510577976703644,
0.2650248408317566,
0.44217410683631897,
0.16364991664886475,
-0.45766374468803406,
-0.3753114342689514,
0.16875618696212769,
-0.0144230667501688,
-0.36236572265625,
0.026766665279865265,
-0.622079610824585,
-0.5927964448928833,
0.9399763345718384,
0.14919312298297882,
0.2687326967716217,
-0.30820518732070923,
-0.2781315743923187,
-0.33298584818840027,
-0.14209413528442383,
0.13098300993442535,
0.33888596296310425,
0.33866098523139954,
-0.35770976543426514,
0.6723059415817261,
-0.3508123755455017,
0.6418797969818115,
-0.16059380769729614,
-0.4225906729698181,
0.5904881954193115,
-0.7801551818847656,
-0.08903566747903824,
0.06810681521892548,
1.1183786392211914,
0.6005269289016724,
0.13261450827121735,
-0.036169327795505524,
0.2300107777118683,
0.13384346663951874,
0.3583514988422394,
-0.7491999268531799,
-0.2936517298221588,
0.17778298258781433,
-0.43675124645233154,
-0.36399951577186584,
0.07494509965181351,
-0.938201904296875,
-0.5065649151802063,
-0.3440481126308441,
0.0763128325343132,
-0.3083169460296631,
-0.025410296395421028,
0.18472610414028168,
-0.2514907419681549,
-0.16327890753746033,
0.37456557154655457,
-0.38007834553718567,
0.07579079270362854,
0.4781501591205597,
0.8506965041160583,
-0.10342812538146973,
0.027907684445381165,
-0.5966707468032837,
-0.03968275338411331,
-0.4113563001155853,
0.763085663318634,
-0.6231860518455505,
-0.40368854999542236,
0.06144668161869049,
0.5793262124061584,
0.27224233746528625,
-0.164090096950531,
0.7286766767501831,
-0.5544477105140686,
0.0968061313033104,
-0.33737921714782715,
-0.23287634551525116,
-0.15972524881362915,
0.28284597396850586,
-0.8666409254074097,
0.86958247423172,
-0.15337581932544708,
-0.8818403482437134,
0.4246881604194641,
-0.49720409512519836,
-0.617347240447998,
0.3451942503452301,
-0.06515379995107651,
-0.6087533831596375,
-0.3082641065120697,
0.3519936800003052,
0.9773015975952148,
-0.39085718989372253,
0.40048059821128845,
-0.5357250571250916,
0.12294240295886993,
0.24526360630989075,
-0.07575485855340958,
0.8568090796470642,
0.4725649058818817,
-0.05107201635837555,
-0.10699401795864105,
-1.1708412170410156,
-0.14203594624996185,
-0.08506897836923599,
-0.3466261625289917,
-0.6753727793693542,
0.024017678573727608,
0.3619479537010193,
0.5611422061920166,
0.2631860375404358,
-0.7763636708259583,
0.3363807201385498,
-0.07831694930791855,
0.6320883631706238,
0.33355024456977844,
0.3496788442134857,
0.23902767896652222,
-0.22331710159778595,
0.5205819010734558,
0.15195786952972412,
0.3670158386230469,
-0.09551677852869034,
-0.6939144730567932,
-0.5477062463760376,
-0.45000699162483215,
0.06753678619861603,
0.41764959692955017,
-1.227935552597046,
0.4089471101760864,
-0.04591754451394081,
-1.1780266761779785,
-0.41974884271621704,
0.22363312542438507,
-0.03151186183094978,
0.35657158493995667,
0.34629419445991516,
0.004294809885323048,
-1.1443337202072144,
-0.8829163908958435,
0.17217926681041718,
0.3172382116317749,
0.29428809881210327,
0.3171879053115845,
0.6882444620132446,
-0.6882192492485046,
0.587793231010437,
-0.37755289673805237,
-0.10398271679878235,
-0.22973889112472534,
0.6099417805671692,
0.028503725305199623,
0.23385277390480042,
0.24901050329208374,
-0.9795182943344116,
-0.5665116906166077,
0.19526174664497375,
-0.7044462561607361,
0.03101184591650963,
0.08172568678855896,
-0.2965717613697052,
0.049941033124923706,
0.5283158421516418,
-0.25431719422340393,
-0.03380396217107773,
0.9286409020423889,
0.025300536304712296,
0.3088816702365875,
-0.21646802127361298,
0.38069361448287964,
-1.6789919137954712,
0.09623821824789047,
0.25273871421813965,
-0.2824678421020508,
-0.5790424942970276,
-0.285520076751709,
-0.0399092398583889,
-0.2982231676578522,
-0.58762526512146,
0.4691121280193329,
-0.39499208331108093,
0.2744300067424774,
-0.15283203125,
0.2349063903093338,
0.23668618500232697,
0.04389414191246033,
-0.10067490488290787,
0.49666643142700195,
0.756771445274353,
-0.5539164543151855,
1.1204609870910645,
0.22679144144058228,
-0.6291622519493103,
0.4066706895828247,
-0.3684983551502228,
0.0343455895781517,
-0.2282014638185501,
0.20460526645183563,
-1.1436411142349243,
-0.363119512796402,
0.47194698452949524,
-0.4016624987125397,
-0.20867080986499786,
-0.029773997142910957,
-0.551003634929657,
-0.5026611685752869,
-0.2640240788459778,
0.08734038472175598,
0.1589050441980362,
-0.26363080739974976,
0.3460965156555176,
1.02776038646698,
-0.10946586728096008,
-0.6561709046363831,
-0.5615625977516174,
0.2974621653556824,
-0.1390390545129776,
-0.49837180972099304,
0.15936331450939178,
-0.0840296596288681,
-0.21897369623184204,
0.012251653708517551,
0.30272457003593445,
-0.22525852918624878,
-0.061916254460811615,
0.513757050037384,
0.2904449999332428,
0.01875438168644905,
0.555845320224762,
-0.33783599734306335,
0.1653255969285965,
-0.13419638574123383,
-0.04419546201825142,
0.5652477145195007,
-0.08619263768196106,
0.08720167726278305,
-0.19861629605293274,
0.3581555485725403,
0.7207247614860535,
-0.2737773358821869,
0.7689374089241028,
0.8679338097572327,
-0.3174039423465729,
-0.14391201734542847,
-0.5889790058135986,
0.3363232910633087,
-0.4090926945209503,
0.17492929100990295,
-0.14625458419322968,
-0.7326503992080688,
0.48789095878601074,
-0.09607212990522385,
-0.06658712029457092,
0.6869928240776062,
0.6638617515563965,
-0.219251349568367,
0.8094903826713562,
0.5686728954315186,
-0.08395634591579437,
0.33437004685401917,
-0.30696916580200195,
0.05815039575099945,
-0.4741089642047882,
-0.5115490555763245,
-0.6067269444465637,
-0.19144095480442047,
-0.9068617224693298,
-0.6813462376594543,
0.14531347155570984,
-0.405317097902298,
0.24000757932662964,
0.6028698682785034,
-0.6247269511222839,
0.077574223279953,
0.34993958473205566,
0.1244397908449173,
0.21261070668697357,
0.2554464638233185,
0.17348887026309967,
-0.15106135606765747,
-0.6377502083778381,
-0.39550861716270447,
1.210376501083374,
0.048868414014577866,
0.8565213680267334,
-0.21783193945884705,
0.5454773902893066,
0.5661671161651611,
0.020014962181448936,
-0.8662662506103516,
0.36712023615837097,
-0.3827316462993622,
-0.4238215386867523,
-0.28051745891571045,
-0.42631542682647705,
-1.421398639678955,
-0.0068520125932991505,
-0.487342894077301,
-0.3548451066017151,
0.4822625517845154,
-0.02924371138215065,
-0.04443814605474472,
0.06125828996300697,
-0.5283647775650024,
0.8517739772796631,
-0.24152149260044098,
-0.3189162015914917,
-0.22954368591308594,
-0.572965145111084,
0.31325703859329224,
-0.23805782198905945,
0.7340153455734253,
-0.2270452380180359,
-0.08633025735616684,
1.0035463571548462,
-0.23491793870925903,
0.7763342261314392,
-0.006436097901314497,
-0.03691650927066803,
0.4748976230621338,
-0.3067971169948578,
0.49205905199050903,
-0.07968325167894363,
0.055182233452796936,
-0.01298557873815298,
0.18297559022903442,
-0.33337849378585815,
-0.29026177525520325,
0.6425682306289673,
-0.7990663647651672,
0.040294867008924484,
-0.4569944739341736,
-0.4702415466308594,
-0.10602927953004837,
0.23224666714668274,
0.3957350254058838,
0.6842711567878723,
-0.5842404961585999,
0.6317220330238342,
0.5776812434196472,
-0.37284842133522034,
0.28206735849380493,
0.35179951786994934,
-0.13108135759830475,
-0.5392618179321289,
1.0501909255981445,
0.4895608425140381,
-0.060400381684303284,
0.2802698612213135,
0.22199714183807373,
-0.02542414329946041,
-0.20164655148983002,
-0.13335560262203217,
0.14436718821525574,
-0.7334633469581604,
-0.258083313703537,
-0.828850507736206,
-0.0723910927772522,
-0.41156136989593506,
-0.11052293330430984,
-0.3916667401790619,
-0.25455015897750854,
-0.13126501441001892,
0.0850902870297432,
0.7440414428710938,
0.7234756350517273,
-0.2808506190776825,
0.2703712284564972,
-0.7391909956932068,
0.5266335606575012,
0.1476585417985916,
0.2063908874988556,
-0.3974021375179291,
-0.10495999455451965,
-0.562181830406189,
0.3090786635875702,
-0.04179098829627037,
-0.7387997508049011,
0.6231610178947449,
0.055278025567531586,
0.4758220314979553,
0.17372189462184906,
0.12173683941364288,
0.47224265336990356,
-0.2658728361129761,
0.43638187646865845,
0.2538512647151947,
-0.6566301584243774,
0.49194926023483276,
-0.3975728154182434,
0.3878173232078552,
0.4951699674129486,
0.8349686861038208,
-0.9666050672531128,
-0.234490767121315,
-0.816909670829773,
-0.8695381283760071,
0.6108576059341431,
-0.13530905544757843,
0.053137898445129395,
-0.04620477557182312,
-0.1901036947965622,
0.22585414350032806,
0.5545356869697571,
-0.2428053766489029,
-0.12162992358207703,
-0.37548139691352844,
-0.25233301520347595,
-0.3566708564758301,
-0.15416210889816284,
-0.25650113821029663,
-0.275193989276886,
0.7145919799804688,
0.020008346065878868,
-0.05791059136390686,
-0.15931916236877441,
-0.1868833303451538,
0.18775589764118195,
0.3033539354801178,
0.45195272564888,
0.5131750106811523,
0.042505715042352676,
0.31720396876335144,
-0.1056387796998024,
-0.5779473781585693,
0.27147620916366577,
-0.02661125548183918,
0.07495316118001938,
0.2172500342130661,
0.23616720736026764,
0.8101345896720886,
0.1557580679655075,
-0.9452598094940186,
0.7506698966026306,
-0.14002376794815063,
-0.4849407374858856,
-0.3188817799091339,
-0.11094438284635544,
0.11617067456245422,
0.19870130717754364,
0.08738324791193008,
0.13691799342632294,
0.26902446150779724,
-0.8481658697128296,
0.47074127197265625,
0.28560084104537964,
-0.3360134959220886,
-0.2202146053314209,
0.08112803101539612,
0.20838777720928192,
-0.19432348012924194,
0.4154832065105438,
-0.23441873490810394,
-0.3203229308128357,
0.6730433702468872,
0.18153250217437744,
0.4412478506565094,
-0.19409699738025665,
0.7970728874206543,
0.4897269606590271,
0.042232394218444824,
-0.18705083429813385,
0.3971777558326721,
0.04337937384843826,
-0.9438022971153259,
-0.4579521119594574,
-0.486230731010437,
-0.38893991708755493,
0.441057026386261,
-0.7587407827377319,
0.5114026069641113,
-0.382888525724411,
-0.3569459319114685,
0.3655240535736084,
-0.10963677614927292,
-0.9159964919090271,
0.37886282801628113,
0.18065288662910461,
0.4552746117115021,
-1.0600380897521973,
0.6487401127815247,
0.6280471086502075,
-0.24383534491062164,
-0.3540016710758209,
-0.6567628383636475,
-0.10842729359865189,
-0.8917598128318787,
0.7127110958099365,
0.025458667427301407,
0.024751920253038406,
-0.24357466399669647,
-0.7471432685852051,
-0.8017880916595459,
0.6048653721809387,
-0.005755836144089699,
-0.7621201872825623,
0.1259593963623047,
0.1428808718919754,
0.7330842614173889,
-0.46276286244392395,
-0.3043082654476166,
0.12868915498256683,
0.6116802096366882,
0.21121908724308014,
-0.47153881192207336,
-0.20962877571582794,
-0.47840195894241333,
-0.28798699378967285,
0.1831473559141159,
-0.6456132531166077,
0.7637063264846802,
0.06532816588878632,
-0.19273687899112701,
-0.5694413781166077,
0.08675413578748703,
0.007499748840928078,
0.19228138029575348,
0.33555832505226135,
0.29640650749206543,
0.7465783953666687,
-0.09265553206205368,
0.7206198573112488,
-0.18219278752803802,
0.3710057735443115,
0.9085193872451782,
-0.10888221859931946,
0.6906068325042725,
0.2814684510231018,
-0.033090874552726746,
0.35066530108451843,
0.6685513257980347,
-0.6420328617095947,
0.5242267847061157,
0.010182514786720276,
-0.22580988705158234,
-0.4312590956687927,
-0.4312022030353546,
-0.22217248380184174,
0.7486026287078857,
0.5859736800193787,
-0.35459861159324646,
-0.2583475708961487,
0.6950275897979736,
0.15876033902168274,
-0.02282565087080002,
-0.25997358560562134,
0.9349366426467896,
-0.1088111400604248,
-0.4802563786506653,
0.45754143595695496,
0.019302818924188614,
0.4678795039653778,
-0.49178868532180786,
0.11229784041643143,
0.29695969820022583,
-0.044527437537908554,
-0.19193093478679657,
-0.8433017134666443,
0.36765164136886597,
-0.04873504862189293,
-0.20411144196987152,
-0.30146166682243347,
0.9074490666389465,
-0.5730456113815308,
-0.9385845065116882,
0.4065897464752197,
0.5075134634971619,
0.3129737377166748,
0.11821940541267395,
-0.7364181280136108,
0.33916664123535156,
-0.13920578360557556,
-0.13289864361286163,
0.024043435230851173,
0.5929147005081177,
-0.06426981836557388,
0.5355423092842102,
0.6128067970275879,
0.2977778911590576,
0.05644399672746658,
0.11540389060974121,
0.818709135055542,
-0.35599058866500854,
-0.2983935475349426,
-0.7324305772781372,
0.42673277854919434,
-0.3307420015335083,
-0.21341431140899658,
0.7995067834854126,
0.7010715007781982,
0.6973077654838562,
0.009274929761886597,
1.3540763854980469,
-0.19497941434383392,
0.5512065291404724,
-0.2428915798664093,
0.5343419909477234,
-0.6654408574104309,
-0.44653967022895813,
-0.2488073855638504,
-0.33845874667167664,
-0.30288970470428467,
0.3438051640987396,
-0.27057644724845886,
-0.5479996800422668,
0.41131263971328735,
0.5914318561553955,
0.008942733518779278,
-0.16572564840316772,
0.267463356256485,
0.22472263872623444,
0.3266774117946625,
0.3056698739528656,
0.5955195426940918,
-0.5339173674583435,
0.7406300902366638,
-0.41964367032051086,
-0.011613511480391026,
-0.45688533782958984,
-0.8159361481666565,
-0.9334940314292908,
-1.047614574432373,
-0.33820396661758423,
-0.3776565194129944,
0.22548575699329376,
0.9173189997673035,
0.6189221143722534,
-0.889953076839447,
-0.13330209255218506,
0.1327088475227356,
-0.02443593554198742,
-0.015853188931941986,
-0.12007621675729752,
0.24003510177135468,
-0.22887268662452698,
-0.5346038937568665,
0.21860265731811523,
0.230278879404068,
0.039004869759082794,
-0.13250504434108734,
0.327836811542511,
-0.45063352584838867,
-0.20017755031585693,
0.9361156225204468,
0.3100031912326813,
-0.3805086314678192,
-0.14119559526443481,
0.024597464129328728,
-0.2913607358932495,
0.3383353352546692,
0.548304557800293,
-0.5001566410064697,
0.9987361431121826,
0.6675457954406738,
0.7773913145065308,
0.6532459855079651,
-0.047409169375896454,
0.51424241065979,
-0.7560956478118896,
0.25971779227256775,
-0.02218056283891201,
0.4181309640407562,
0.5729287266731262,
-0.18150895833969116,
0.24198950827121735,
0.49619194865226746,
-0.4352080523967743,
-0.6530975103378296,
-0.03878707066178322,
-1.055534839630127,
-0.3040751814842224,
1.1696891784667969,
0.2472245991230011,
-0.16279838979244232,
-0.5175633430480957,
-0.532794177532196,
0.6068723201751709,
-0.6149545311927795,
0.8176971673965454,
1.3023202419281006,
0.17404805123806,
-0.18157730996608734,
-0.7774250507354736,
0.4232695400714874,
-0.35956376791000366,
-1.0631489753723145,
0.11311973631381989,
0.39376601576805115,
0.11020158976316452,
0.3705204725265503,
0.3810841143131256,
0.13910254836082458,
0.15871647000312805,
0.028938420116901398,
0.414838045835495,
-0.056485339999198914,
-0.2993967831134796,
0.02987530454993248,
0.35530921816825867,
-0.3287796676158905,
-0.35274064540863037
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.06316v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.06316v1
|
Tx-LLM: A Large Language Model for Therapeutics
| 2024-06-10T14:33:02 | 2024-06-10T14:33:02 |
Juan Manuel Zambrano Chaves, Eric Wang, Tao Tu, Eeshit Dhaval Vaishnav, Byron Lee, S. Sara Mahdavi, Christopher Semturs, David Fleet, Vivek Natarajan, Shekoofeh Azizi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CE, cs.LG
|
Developing therapeutics is a lengthy and expensive process that requires the
satisfaction of many different criteria, and AI models capable of expediting
the process would be invaluable. However, the majority of current AI approaches
address only a narrowly defined set of tasks, often circumscribed within a
particular domain. To bridge this gap, we introduce Tx-LLM, a generalist large
language model (LLM) fine-tuned from PaLM-2 which encodes knowledge about
diverse therapeutic modalities. Tx-LLM is trained using a collection of 709
datasets that target 66 tasks spanning various stages of the drug discovery
pipeline. Using a single set of weights, Tx-LLM simultaneously processes a wide
variety of chemical or biological entities(small molecules, proteins, nucleic
acids, cell lines, diseases) interleaved with free-text, allowing it to predict
a broad range of associated properties, achieving competitive with
state-of-the-art (SOTA) performance on 43 out of 66 tasks and exceeding SOTA on
22. Among these, Tx-LLM is particularly powerful and exceeds best-in-class
performance on average for tasks combining molecular SMILES representations
with text such as cell line names or disease names, likely due to context
learned during pretraining. We observe evidence of positive transfer between
tasks with diverse drug types (e.g.,tasks involving small molecules and tasks
involving proteins), and we study the impact of model size, domain finetuning,
and prompting strategies on performance. We believe Tx-LLM represents an
important step towards LLMs encoding biochemical knowledge and could have a
future role as an end-to-end tool across the drug discovery development
pipeline.
|
[
-0.007817339152097702,
-1.0708369016647339,
0.7123990058898926,
-0.08465594798326492,
-0.23376166820526123,
0.30367693305015564,
-0.39402303099632263,
-0.5479357242584229,
0.28832757472991943,
0.6995751857757568,
-0.36328062415122986,
-0.5553985834121704,
-1.0093218088150024,
0.19842861592769623,
-0.3696942627429962,
1.2326411008834839,
-0.08604118227958679,
0.2743450105190277,
-0.024725228548049927,
0.03930852189660072,
-0.27519500255584717,
-0.42180076241493225,
-0.7205283641815186,
-0.5666365027427673,
0.8065845370292664,
0.25002163648605347,
0.533584713935852,
0.8995435237884521,
0.5464706420898438,
0.23883379995822906,
0.030299467965960503,
-0.03940390422940254,
-0.4708607494831085,
0.19008176028728485,
-0.21021364629268646,
-0.870245635509491,
-0.6924661993980408,
-0.04019653797149658,
0.4227113723754883,
0.8797643780708313,
-0.1783837527036667,
0.00040265024290420115,
0.062427353113889694,
0.5665848255157471,
-0.2218671292066574,
-0.05911446735262871,
-0.5227714776992798,
0.1584324836730957,
-0.25386056303977966,
-0.12130595743656158,
-0.16189992427825928,
-0.14345566928386688,
0.4361213147640228,
-0.5574039816856384,
0.13481886684894562,
0.04481486231088638,
0.5478116869926453,
0.32063326239585876,
-0.6399877667427063,
-0.5378437638282776,
-0.7897643446922302,
0.8298094272613525,
-0.5078882575035095,
0.2852882742881775,
0.1563699096441269,
0.3773992955684662,
-0.4302409887313843,
-0.7365083694458008,
-0.2766822576522827,
-0.5877958536148071,
0.1780422478914261,
-0.11266744881868362,
-0.06067736819386482,
0.4677152931690216,
0.2213677018880844,
0.05598932132124901,
-0.42390260100364685,
0.3586682081222534,
-0.546438455581665,
-0.292167603969574,
0.3449022173881531,
0.34299546480178833,
0.5063382387161255,
0.2235630750656128,
-0.5604475736618042,
0.4152046740055084,
-0.806050717830658,
0.1165664941072464,
-0.16085010766983032,
0.45348405838012695,
-0.19612500071525574,
0.7355684638023376,
0.24191372096538544,
0.5327029228210449,
-0.25131553411483765,
-0.34006309509277344,
-0.3556375205516815,
-0.2799498438835144,
-0.3683111369609833,
0.024859625846147537,
0.7317295670509338,
0.2819114625453949,
0.2848764955997467,
-0.332452654838562,
-0.27114301919937134,
0.17481061816215515,
0.36690497398376465,
-1.0489323139190674,
0.057807158678770065,
0.6716133952140808,
-0.37209969758987427,
-0.2350817322731018,
-0.3997635841369629,
-0.7441152930259705,
-0.4649607241153717,
-0.4312073290348053,
0.5165605545043945,
-0.7241121530532837,
-0.15391188859939575,
0.08251018822193146,
-0.06958404183387756,
0.05783095583319664,
0.46792325377464294,
-0.9826157689094543,
0.526451587677002,
0.5700966119766235,
0.8971964716911316,
-0.40242835879325867,
-0.2682109773159027,
-0.7404719591140747,
0.45177626609802246,
-0.38275963068008423,
0.767572820186615,
-0.7026402950286865,
-0.61475670337677,
-0.0704633966088295,
-0.10338878631591797,
0.03708208352327347,
-0.5747410655021667,
0.37392646074295044,
-0.3256841003894806,
-0.02006571553647518,
-0.3896670639514923,
-0.71417236328125,
-0.021735766902565956,
0.11662343144416809,
-0.44762158393859863,
0.5844331383705139,
0.3460676670074463,
-0.4129515588283539,
0.22943703830242157,
-0.8995707631111145,
-0.4686221182346344,
0.17484788596630096,
-0.32602816820144653,
-0.006564596202224493,
0.30374953150749207,
0.06158846244215965,
0.47951698303222656,
-0.8558908104896545,
0.5300238728523254,
-0.1276058554649353,
-0.5409318804740906,
0.3799956738948822,
0.09642867743968964,
0.42964500188827515,
0.34315380454063416,
-0.3350771367549896,
0.35053086280822754,
-0.4032445549964905,
-0.18462258577346802,
-0.01863224245607853,
-0.5936452746391296,
-0.06581363826990128,
-0.29891085624694824,
0.10462140291929245,
0.1501397341489792,
0.29122695326805115,
-0.6102918982505798,
0.3944067358970642,
-0.603812038898468,
0.7642334699630737,
0.6895347833633423,
-0.19370698928833008,
0.4569978713989258,
-0.4269331693649292,
0.8028693199157715,
0.3226175308227539,
-0.0722956508398056,
-0.16994649171829224,
-0.40261465311050415,
-0.6619859337806702,
-0.3670212924480438,
0.5206655263900757,
0.5746902823448181,
-0.48275026679039,
0.2330089807510376,
-0.36336037516593933,
-0.42734494805336,
-0.45617130398750305,
0.23021918535232544,
0.23537613451480865,
0.3333582878112793,
0.5603294968605042,
-0.34024009108543396,
-0.3710634112358093,
-0.8732340931892395,
-0.18022356927394867,
0.40062442421913147,
-0.08262328803539276,
0.24507145583629608,
0.6126001477241516,
-0.640305757522583,
0.7091431617736816,
-0.21082854270935059,
-0.7760196328163147,
-0.5432068109512329,
-0.014892847277224064,
0.28452759981155396,
0.29607757925987244,
0.3772013485431671,
-0.38033485412597656,
-0.3006495535373688,
0.14270074665546417,
-0.7242650389671326,
0.0198696069419384,
-0.04244738072156906,
0.10149694234132767,
0.14057134091854095,
0.44887033104896545,
-0.7353949546813965,
0.11773411929607391,
0.2290089875459671,
-0.14304691553115845,
0.26842832565307617,
-0.5633588433265686,
-0.014977851882576942,
-1.0762733221054077,
0.2667894959449768,
0.28238388895988464,
-0.18255649507045746,
-0.706839919090271,
0.03151683509349823,
-0.08338376879692078,
-0.1058788150548935,
-0.4018481969833374,
0.6173532605171204,
-0.3005586266517639,
-0.1014382615685463,
-0.4737350046634674,
0.0477483756840229,
-0.33167538046836853,
0.4605630040168762,
-0.060417164117097855,
0.781045138835907,
0.6462207436561584,
-0.7365503311157227,
0.3504372835159302,
-0.06321562081575394,
-0.08148457109928131,
0.4047299325466156,
-0.8443472385406494,
0.0988297238945961,
-0.0882946327328682,
0.37512046098709106,
-0.8505255579948425,
-0.3063320815563202,
0.05137547478079796,
-0.26811864972114563,
0.43256279826164246,
-0.09528584033250809,
-0.35769277811050415,
-0.3351622521877289,
-0.23752638697624207,
0.20235273241996765,
0.587071418762207,
-0.07023825496435165,
0.820223867893219,
0.5459062457084656,
-0.1826857477426529,
-0.5655493140220642,
-0.7957837581634521,
0.20229081809520721,
-0.3114016652107239,
-0.3708352744579315,
0.6630857586860657,
0.050603803247213364,
0.024225497618317604,
-0.23413768410682678,
-0.004970419220626354,
0.03337626904249191,
0.0752902701497078,
0.2956759035587311,
0.1829235553741455,
-0.11527164280414581,
0.1760103553533554,
0.41823267936706543,
-0.25387388467788696,
0.13271844387054443,
-0.39807477593421936,
0.5196548104286194,
0.1837150901556015,
-0.07926592230796814,
-0.32985636591911316,
0.41366901993751526,
0.7551254630088806,
-0.24367380142211914,
0.5703905820846558,
0.5460906028747559,
-0.49589189887046814,
-0.39527761936187744,
-0.09073009341955185,
-0.27067384123802185,
-0.4361304044723511,
0.5135765671730042,
-0.37644147872924805,
-1.0729069709777832,
0.3967371881008148,
-0.6301413774490356,
-0.07297671586275101,
0.20874927937984467,
0.7322238683700562,
-0.08518081903457642,
0.7509891986846924,
0.770707368850708,
-0.062114570289850235,
0.1448981612920761,
-0.3534051477909088,
0.1358119696378708,
-0.7624340057373047,
-0.19796761870384216,
-0.3725123107433319,
-0.5912288427352905,
-0.4515451192855835,
-0.6381319761276245,
0.6299358010292053,
0.0861213281750679,
-0.35186120867729187,
0.18980997800827026,
-0.5550184845924377,
0.2752987742424011,
0.6273666620254517,
0.25881990790367126,
0.14850641787052155,
-0.023265743628144264,
-0.3248785734176636,
-0.013747869059443474,
-0.513167679309845,
-0.6508160829544067,
1.772718071937561,
0.5435194373130798,
0.5429129600524902,
0.16951137781143188,
0.72060626745224,
0.4567970335483551,
0.5333980321884155,
-0.9588708877563477,
0.623498260974884,
-0.26139700412750244,
-0.5333769917488098,
-0.1837548315525055,
-0.21781641244888306,
-1.2803810834884644,
-0.24729867279529572,
-0.32008665800094604,
-0.7768362164497375,
-0.31102436780929565,
0.06254900991916656,
-0.6220411062240601,
0.3237333297729492,
-0.6084064245223999,
0.6852676868438721,
-0.4152257740497589,
-0.3747468590736389,
-0.5045386552810669,
-0.887900173664093,
0.3702802360057831,
-0.3104080259799957,
0.3389855921268463,
-0.09103002399206161,
-0.3562529981136322,
0.84300297498703,
-0.32286348938941956,
0.7425539493560791,
-0.193780779838562,
-0.3443659543991089,
0.10348305106163025,
0.16393959522247314,
0.40296319127082825,
-0.15779316425323486,
0.02196504734456539,
0.06014000624418259,
0.2147478312253952,
-0.3984231650829315,
-0.4540669620037079,
0.7917208075523376,
-0.9114564657211304,
-0.5857852697372437,
-0.3653136193752289,
-0.44411227107048035,
-0.2517424523830414,
0.22029031813144684,
0.31033292412757874,
0.3944179117679596,
-0.26858824491500854,
-0.14514921605587006,
0.6440349221229553,
-0.5634100437164307,
0.08475767821073532,
0.653371274471283,
-0.3440653085708618,
-0.3959638178348541,
0.8606706857681274,
0.18763631582260132,
0.1630355417728424,
0.7354802489280701,
0.10361239314079285,
-0.4466356039047241,
-0.9774799346923828,
-0.23149174451828003,
0.2917132079601288,
-0.4982580542564392,
-0.2579076588153839,
-0.7076002359390259,
-0.07719767838716507,
-0.19896991550922394,
-0.13059255480766296,
-0.2303159534931183,
-0.17099949717521667,
-0.21567746996879578,
-0.08227726072072983,
0.394369512796402,
0.8179565668106079,
0.09914826601743698,
0.23648300766944885,
-0.9961901903152466,
0.6948294043540955,
0.025360262021422386,
0.4789969325065613,
-0.14490069448947906,
-0.4690168499946594,
-0.4096991717815399,
0.3409375548362732,
-0.5115469694137573,
-0.8128678202629089,
0.34433308243751526,
0.214409738779068,
0.4511546790599823,
-0.01897568069398403,
-0.3131089210510254,
0.09038808196783066,
-0.382439523935318,
0.684809684753418,
0.2542835772037506,
-0.831971287727356,
0.880903422832489,
-0.6000102758407593,
0.012383012101054192,
0.07838521897792816,
0.4299396574497223,
-0.40323421359062195,
-0.30368489027023315,
-0.2790721654891968,
-0.6321846842765808,
0.6270254850387573,
-0.11043112725019455,
0.05208134278655052,
0.0636620819568634,
0.4719572365283966,
0.2807745039463043,
0.15705125033855438,
-0.5920450091362,
-0.138591468334198,
0.14244702458381653,
-0.39789116382598877,
0.07384946197271347,
-0.22107245028018951,
-0.36414238810539246,
-0.21127057075500488,
0.3217674195766449,
-0.28968140482902527,
0.5021283030509949,
0.24369007349014282,
-0.18854860961437225,
-0.2669835686683655,
0.5253158807754517,
0.585608959197998,
0.39827361702919006,
-0.22880016267299652,
-0.11720790714025497,
0.13437411189079285,
-0.6218276619911194,
0.23201875388622284,
0.34432920813560486,
0.14238594472408295,
-0.45517152547836304,
0.3475392758846283,
0.5425129532814026,
-0.07023366540670395,
-1.0829358100891113,
0.25026142597198486,
0.1610114723443985,
-0.29957982897758484,
-0.0527237206697464,
0.43572649359703064,
0.12025963515043259,
0.3485543727874756,
0.344562292098999,
0.04824921116232872,
0.18592797219753265,
-0.6717809438705444,
0.17272405326366425,
0.41562074422836304,
-0.3708950877189636,
-0.313880980014801,
1.002577781677246,
0.38609230518341064,
-0.43301400542259216,
0.4204206168651581,
0.24642586708068848,
-0.28642570972442627,
0.7625390291213989,
0.44670361280441284,
0.7189722657203674,
-0.1995333880186081,
0.055314455181360245,
0.20666274428367615,
0.199076846241951,
0.016261665150523186,
0.31238317489624023,
0.12425616383552551,
-0.6365527510643005,
-0.17646221816539764,
-0.7820059657096863,
-0.41119280457496643,
0.1086626946926117,
-0.13050413131713867,
0.45079296827316284,
-0.7140302062034607,
-0.37720566987991333,
0.33892300724983215,
0.15984457731246948,
-0.7526916265487671,
0.37217196822166443,
0.017484791576862335,
0.8640528321266174,
-0.36076968908309937,
1.3855628967285156,
0.6651527881622314,
-0.4287216067314148,
-0.701228678226471,
-0.25896793603897095,
0.008667588233947754,
-0.838790237903595,
0.6074447631835938,
0.29218465089797974,
-0.1123972088098526,
0.19770266115665436,
-0.3938548266887665,
-0.8034425973892212,
1.3848201036453247,
0.5745492577552795,
-0.8619984984397888,
-0.23048308491706848,
0.598584771156311,
0.8622391819953918,
-0.5484426021575928,
0.30551138520240784,
0.8806324005126953,
0.3272903561592102,
-0.07808999717235565,
-1.087350845336914,
0.21871821582317352,
-0.1843102127313614,
0.018730279058218002,
0.3472520709037781,
-0.49607571959495544,
0.6611381769180298,
-0.8515022993087769,
-0.1328413337469101,
0.3845481276512146,
0.2873903810977936,
0.3885563611984253,
0.21478872001171112,
0.15702636539936066,
0.4049803614616394,
0.7437961101531982,
-0.2515224814414978,
1.1152487993240356,
-0.5570542812347412,
0.022011732682585716,
0.7166681885719299,
-0.3772187829017639,
0.6764816641807556,
0.4773310720920563,
-0.5642526149749756,
0.19554153084754944,
0.5338815450668335,
-0.04397401213645935,
0.32353663444519043,
0.6455249786376953,
-0.19708560407161713,
-0.029800940304994583,
-0.3828660249710083,
-0.304458886384964,
0.41986823081970215,
0.7730379700660706,
-0.6764042377471924,
-0.023792721331119537,
0.26050326228141785,
-0.10758030414581299,
0.12946417927742004,
-0.232987642288208,
0.6294869184494019,
0.32868096232414246,
-0.7147376537322998,
0.5528746247291565,
0.24237625300884247,
0.7613105773925781,
-0.9129244089126587,
0.014686581678688526,
-0.26301759481430054,
0.13870278000831604,
0.03340138494968414,
-0.8391865491867065,
0.2151685506105423,
-0.0876196101307869,
-0.013286827132105827,
-0.11580687016248703,
0.5923871397972107,
-0.5348374843597412,
-0.39633575081825256,
0.5371708869934082,
0.6518624424934387,
0.05184822157025337,
0.07156485319137573,
-0.676022469997406,
0.14043107628822327,
-0.009442147798836231,
-0.0035291886888444424,
0.490607887506485,
0.5542059540748596,
0.10560247302055359,
0.9239626526832581,
0.5328088998794556,
0.16200897097587585,
-0.44308942556381226,
-0.01314539648592472,
0.7852284908294678,
-1.049047589302063,
-0.2467782348394394,
-0.8160849213600159,
0.2586241066455841,
0.37713223695755005,
-0.2423710823059082,
0.24225033819675446,
0.5397830009460449,
0.16808436810970306,
0.013614684343338013,
0.9095562100410461,
0.3305475413799286,
0.566911518573761,
-0.6403967142105103,
0.6064242720603943,
-0.5740384459495544,
0.5952968597412109,
0.03476677089929581,
-0.7303063869476318,
-0.20244678854942322,
0.14595142006874084,
-0.11568573117256165,
0.21774108707904816,
0.6638033986091614,
0.6768369078636169,
0.15842494368553162,
0.19444485008716583,
0.12201449275016785,
0.4542401134967804,
0.6032401919364929,
1.1847110986709595,
0.6536113023757935,
-0.3500584661960602,
0.3474469482898712,
0.08821242302656174,
-0.3235134482383728,
-0.0208772923797369,
-0.5756963491439819,
-0.8780956268310547,
-0.4230327010154724,
-0.16851694881916046,
-0.2911563813686371,
0.04165756702423096,
1.3623270988464355,
0.5546322464942932,
-0.6514533162117004,
-0.45787397027015686,
-0.38651230931282043,
-0.08834362030029297,
-0.1027771532535553,
-0.10641159862279892,
0.24194008111953735,
-0.15479078888893127,
-0.7304153442382812,
0.3907947242259979,
0.5181466937065125,
0.45086199045181274,
-0.24730758368968964,
-0.07177095115184784,
0.03156421706080437,
0.1298520416021347,
0.5899466276168823,
0.10782582312822342,
-0.9614577889442444,
0.06478992104530334,
0.04483466222882271,
-0.34637272357940674,
0.1292915940284729,
0.9432879090309143,
-0.8994865417480469,
0.19711406528949738,
-0.08576671779155731,
0.6815142035484314,
0.4732747972011566,
-0.4165147542953491,
1.0656448602676392,
-0.35402148962020874,
-0.020626766607165337,
0.3844636082649231,
0.3892650902271271,
0.2193591147661209,
-0.3820798397064209,
0.545113205909729,
0.09409025311470032,
-0.49008581042289734,
-0.6450262069702148,
0.13440580666065216,
-1.1870537996292114,
-0.5345284342765808,
1.1962695121765137,
0.056993305683135986,
-0.10751605778932571,
-0.1613541692495346,
-0.5042982697486877,
0.3253973722457886,
-0.5173329710960388,
0.8260193467140198,
0.5851433873176575,
-0.16221001744270325,
-0.09316768497228622,
-0.5537664890289307,
0.7796019911766052,
0.25450271368026733,
-0.9615062475204468,
0.17852254211902618,
0.33152100443840027,
0.464716374874115,
-0.08686722815036774,
1.00346839427948,
-0.0049363491125404835,
0.13146956264972687,
-0.3652772009372711,
-0.25204694271087646,
0.05071861669421196,
-0.31281575560569763,
-0.12642230093479156,
0.1982412487268448,
0.12357970327138901,
0.14130939543247223
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.06279v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.06279v1
|
Multi-Prompting Decoder Helps Better Language Understanding
| 2024-06-10T13:58:46 | 2024-06-10T13:58:46 |
Zifeng Cheng, Zhaoling Chen, Zhiwei Jiang, Yafeng Yin, Shiping Ge, Yuliang Liu, Qing Gu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Recent Pre-trained Language Models (PLMs) usually only provide users with the
inference APIs, namely the emerging Model-as-a-Service (MaaS) setting. To adapt
MaaS PLMs to downstream tasks without accessing their parameters and gradients,
some existing methods focus on the output-side adaptation of PLMs, viewing the
PLM as an encoder and then optimizing a task-specific decoder for decoding the
output hidden states and class scores of the PLM. Despite the effectiveness of
these methods, they only use a single prompt to query PLMs for decoding,
leading to a heavy reliance on the quality of the adopted prompt. In this
paper, we propose a simple yet effective Multi-Prompting Decoder (MPD)
framework for MaaS adaptation. The core idea is to query PLMs with multiple
different prompts for each sample, thereby obtaining multiple output hidden
states and class scores for subsequent decoding. Such multi-prompting decoding
paradigm can simultaneously mitigate reliance on the quality of a single
prompt, alleviate the issue of data scarcity under the few-shot setting, and
provide richer knowledge extracted from PLMs. Specifically, we propose two
decoding strategies: multi-prompting decoding with optimal transport for hidden
states and calibrated decoding for class scores. Extensive experiments
demonstrate that our method achieves new state-of-the-art results on multiple
natural language understanding datasets under the few-shot setting.
|
[
-0.6080822944641113,
-0.44397789239883423,
0.6090347170829773,
0.3810857832431793,
-0.3564208447933197,
-0.19702257215976715,
-0.1548900008201599,
0.31479302048683167,
-0.0036845721770077944,
0.36820051074028015,
-0.8356587290763855,
-0.3762819468975067,
-0.4586995840072632,
0.29586806893348694,
0.19458992779254913,
0.7609377503395081,
0.29478558897972107,
0.11256416141986847,
-0.12098578363656998,
-0.0901540145277977,
-0.6200224757194519,
-0.5801509618759155,
-0.9804063439369202,
-0.1477755606174469,
0.533501386642456,
0.5724825263023376,
0.18006376922130585,
0.32234448194503784,
0.0003711646713782102,
0.11716208606958389,
0.004467588849365711,
0.5919434428215027,
-0.21268635988235474,
-0.03168001025915146,
-0.09488033503293991,
-0.39977115392684937,
-0.1803455501794815,
-0.25248321890830994,
0.7077284455299377,
0.3674103021621704,
-0.12806996703147888,
0.10978328436613083,
0.4222251772880554,
0.5599357485771179,
-0.9519087076187134,
0.30381178855895996,
-0.4391801357269287,
-0.2019493579864502,
-0.028480514883995056,
-0.5290969610214233,
-0.8038739562034607,
-0.1162232831120491,
0.05755762755870819,
-0.6708250641822815,
-0.10720360279083252,
-0.2783049941062927,
0.6158704161643982,
0.4244377911090851,
-0.47990018129348755,
-0.28753986954689026,
-0.25536131858825684,
0.7278927564620972,
-0.5589995980262756,
0.17206108570098877,
0.5137606263160706,
0.6158143877983093,
-0.09753595292568207,
-0.13868741691112518,
-0.5519143342971802,
0.03838898986577988,
0.028899364173412323,
0.22690974175930023,
-0.09013956040143967,
0.019418872892856598,
0.07888428121805191,
0.12660861015319824,
-0.3464221954345703,
0.02149042673408985,
0.10149721801280975,
-0.3814973533153534,
0.09824307262897491,
0.08983702212572098,
0.18272319436073303,
-0.2530893087387085,
-0.4726601243019104,
-0.30733802914619446,
-0.655034601688385,
0.44641202688217163,
0.33484989404678345,
0.6096144914627075,
-0.2591322660446167,
0.1722930520772934,
-0.07175517827272415,
0.8505469560623169,
-0.03454239293932915,
-0.3438689410686493,
0.22588951885700226,
-0.4341936707496643,
0.0074212318286299706,
-0.29841718077659607,
0.6715173721313477,
0.13340966403484344,
0.17137248814105988,
0.19321586191654205,
-0.09476596862077713,
-0.01622936874628067,
0.1579607129096985,
-0.6563735604286194,
-0.14405573904514313,
0.04473182186484337,
-0.46653687953948975,
0.28452587127685547,
0.025920603424310684,
-0.9780812859535217,
-0.5285190939903259,
-0.08686811476945877,
0.7190902829170227,
-0.4649280309677124,
-0.18892741203308105,
0.32630106806755066,
-0.16258157789707184,
0.29058095812797546,
0.290176123380661,
-0.8919020891189575,
0.20619772374629974,
0.4407477080821991,
0.9922426342964172,
0.017067313194274902,
-0.5413768291473389,
-0.9546504020690918,
0.1340211182832718,
-0.05604095011949539,
0.8540670871734619,
-0.5913267135620117,
-0.43323349952697754,
-0.11091827601194382,
0.012202801182866096,
-0.422359436750412,
-0.24623939394950867,
0.6341327428817749,
-0.39838558435440063,
0.09920986741781235,
-0.5843852162361145,
-0.28255152702331543,
-0.4659530222415924,
0.2496834546327591,
-0.5352861881256104,
0.61525559425354,
-0.24230711162090302,
-0.3480297923088074,
0.32197871804237366,
-1.063955545425415,
-0.4675011932849884,
-0.32136571407318115,
0.1409020870923996,
-0.1899413764476776,
0.1818271279335022,
0.9837155342102051,
0.38841453194618225,
-0.04509996995329857,
-0.13077802956104279,
-0.12175136804580688,
-0.08875588327646255,
0.10144195705652237,
-0.7516251802444458,
0.6540466547012329,
0.2127847671508789,
0.24301186203956604,
0.284842848777771,
-0.7927658557891846,
-0.051326341927051544,
0.01983528397977352,
-0.5182240009307861,
-0.15079046785831451,
0.03333020210266113,
-0.46121421456336975,
0.2429417222738266,
-0.036375075578689575,
-0.23486478626728058,
0.30390918254852295,
-0.3642725646495819,
0.2892935574054718,
0.8148017525672913,
0.2745163142681122,
0.6860801577568054,
-0.3835285007953644,
0.7021028995513916,
0.2133258730173111,
0.028870992362499237,
-1.0325267314910889,
-0.5665766000747681,
-0.7337334156036377,
-0.47252148389816284,
-0.11272192001342773,
0.5024220943450928,
-0.9325313568115234,
0.18072015047073364,
-0.05860113352537155,
-0.15823137760162354,
-1.1342356204986572,
0.1240837574005127,
0.31840571761131287,
0.5422940850257874,
0.5052788853645325,
-0.08613665401935577,
-0.3248574137687683,
-0.47289812564849854,
-0.41060870885849,
0.18178381025791168,
-0.0486101396381855,
0.3615349233150482,
0.11663459241390228,
0.11702616512775421,
0.8234050869941711,
-0.266526460647583,
-0.28414854407310486,
-0.30299293994903564,
0.10324544459581375,
0.3614901304244995,
0.39699605107307434,
0.5880066156387329,
-0.34477806091308594,
-0.4164700508117676,
-0.43409955501556396,
-0.24401643872261047,
-0.1396084725856781,
-0.4093443751335144,
-0.16980266571044922,
-0.04209231212735176,
0.0562627837061882,
-0.5558556914329529,
0.09488677233457565,
0.6853047013282776,
-0.3311440646648407,
0.4893292784690857,
-0.37009674310684204,
0.28583773970603943,
-1.144640564918518,
0.005071889143437147,
-0.21693706512451172,
-0.15514101088047028,
-0.6867057085037231,
-0.08142267912626266,
0.1978084146976471,
-0.2478945553302765,
-0.3456076681613922,
0.5805939435958862,
-0.778412401676178,
-0.22739934921264648,
-0.44929200410842896,
-0.04484915733337402,
0.359255850315094,
0.5716413855552673,
0.03367071598768234,
1.0982205867767334,
0.9579180479049683,
-1.0381125211715698,
0.09245715290307999,
0.2723027169704437,
-0.04961378872394562,
0.3682986795902252,
-0.2062927782535553,
0.4932973086833954,
-0.5458821654319763,
0.33275747299194336,
-1.026733636856079,
0.09808886051177979,
0.3627840578556061,
-0.3702507019042969,
-0.022924257442355156,
-0.5773212313652039,
-0.3488820493221283,
-0.25477978587150574,
-0.46241724491119385,
0.19087086617946625,
0.32056304812431335,
-1.045295000076294,
0.7651481032371521,
0.047099508345127106,
-0.09970174729824066,
-0.5977562665939331,
-0.5875777006149292,
-0.012670115567743778,
-0.07861128449440002,
-0.4042225480079651,
-0.05449096858501434,
-0.3204488456249237,
0.3085342347621918,
-0.3154960572719574,
-0.07458267360925674,
0.03729923069477081,
0.1985497772693634,
0.15340447425842285,
0.05175180733203888,
-0.45812490582466125,
0.22269771993160248,
0.24732528626918793,
-0.5578078627586365,
-0.013039612211287022,
-0.35464298725128174,
0.7434468865394592,
0.010399405844509602,
-0.5661984086036682,
-0.8307052254676819,
0.411699503660202,
0.6548551321029663,
-0.5343987941741943,
1.113935947418213,
0.5550001263618469,
-0.2008744329214096,
-0.3976869583129883,
-0.17518192529678345,
-0.5690097212791443,
-0.46408510208129883,
-0.04459790140390396,
-0.9577696919441223,
-0.608920693397522,
0.45921191573143005,
-0.16483810544013977,
0.08061853051185608,
0.18275384604930878,
0.40594369173049927,
0.17482341825962067,
1.2005503177642822,
0.5184603929519653,
-0.0793071761727333,
0.4044887125492096,
-0.07898058742284775,
0.24877974390983582,
-0.6953929662704468,
-0.17189395427703857,
-0.6662092804908752,
0.04306100308895111,
0.012504168786108494,
-0.39713120460510254,
0.275322288274765,
0.3633340299129486,
0.00019632423936855048,
0.026607414707541466,
-0.30040499567985535,
0.6116381883621216,
0.5374878644943237,
0.1019112765789032,
0.2648998200893402,
0.04756321758031845,
-0.1257137507200241,
0.03412986174225807,
-0.8681874871253967,
-0.6701295971870422,
0.8589777946472168,
0.3250373303890228,
0.5459189414978027,
0.34864896535873413,
0.6465204954147339,
-0.10642072558403015,
0.09494537860155106,
-0.9740763902664185,
0.36627188324928284,
-0.24370823800563812,
-0.29957348108291626,
-0.08437339216470718,
-0.3743102550506592,
-0.7605610489845276,
0.5996074676513672,
-0.24687983095645905,
-0.6048568487167358,
0.31819042563438416,
0.33600878715515137,
-0.757217526435852,
0.09620760381221771,
-1.1131929159164429,
0.9497499465942383,
0.009837718680500984,
-0.00497492216527462,
-0.0609879344701767,
-0.3700021207332611,
0.2547622621059418,
0.0850609540939331,
0.422607958316803,
-0.22504697740077972,
-0.029974795877933502,
0.4708106219768524,
-0.2473682016134262,
0.8153419494628906,
-0.6756321787834167,
-0.037323590368032455,
0.24730545282363892,
-0.07664479315280914,
0.5360091924667358,
0.1521708220243454,
-0.3763236105442047,
-0.3795141279697418,
0.13695479929447174,
-0.5903990268707275,
-0.6535057425498962,
0.5802168846130371,
-0.6912311911582947,
-0.5851882100105286,
-0.27252957224845886,
-0.6225025057792664,
-0.38633862137794495,
0.06801200658082962,
0.2344886213541031,
0.5374188423156738,
0.15786536037921906,
-0.3026290535926819,
0.4796094298362732,
-0.38928353786468506,
0.7034668922424316,
0.6928414702415466,
-0.052234500646591187,
-0.16312836110591888,
0.9788731932640076,
-0.32742074131965637,
0.3454228937625885,
0.2884756624698639,
0.3880993127822876,
-0.5978441834449768,
-0.5556082725524902,
-0.7246303558349609,
0.07646447420120239,
-0.9251251220703125,
-0.19496981799602509,
-0.5898709893226624,
0.16542959213256836,
-0.5985750555992126,
-0.027878860011696815,
-0.2725377082824707,
0.10839521139860153,
-0.7557220458984375,
0.01513779815286398,
0.41277948021888733,
0.45691603422164917,
-0.11287757754325867,
0.6888325214385986,
-1.051002025604248,
0.5747231245040894,
0.35682597756385803,
0.22810764610767365,
0.08466388285160065,
-0.6214730739593506,
0.1661345511674881,
0.03329209238290787,
0.12294729799032211,
-1.154813528060913,
0.342788964509964,
0.5487005710601807,
0.6804174780845642,
0.6748929023742676,
0.2903427481651306,
0.73814857006073,
-0.462982714176178,
0.69195157289505,
0.1315961331129074,
-1.1261898279190063,
0.6030049920082092,
0.04835483804345131,
0.7236089110374451,
0.5946382284164429,
0.2613050639629364,
-0.41438400745391846,
0.1807592809200287,
0.1031041294336319,
-0.3783954083919525,
1.033908724784851,
-0.26695695519447327,
0.40125522017478943,
-0.037520598620176315,
0.178246408700943,
0.5283859372138977,
-0.13684974610805511,
-0.6406713128089905,
-0.387300044298172,
-0.46721023321151733,
-0.3318466544151306,
-0.09870059043169022,
-0.38793253898620605,
-0.009194188751280308,
-0.024391433224081993,
0.6891015768051147,
-0.5313844084739685,
0.10451237857341766,
-0.10298636555671692,
-0.40425655245780945,
0.3655012547969818,
0.7954710125923157,
0.5394110679626465,
0.5506860017776489,
0.0373513400554657,
0.4511345624923706,
0.21919001638889313,
-0.30347830057144165,
0.35789763927459717,
-0.00043186487164348364,
0.009916245937347412,
0.0736694261431694,
0.011516289785504341,
1.000375747680664,
-0.01641002856194973,
-0.4247076213359833,
0.6428764462471008,
-0.06433658301830292,
0.286848247051239,
0.3089011013507843,
0.13697652518749237,
0.006407811772078276,
0.025367073714733124,
0.5786350965499878,
0.15882311761379242,
0.009754599072039127,
-0.39489272236824036,
0.11513849347829819,
0.22941279411315918,
-0.0858597382903099,
-0.31121331453323364,
0.22912509739398956,
0.3554689586162567,
-0.3042130470275879,
0.08947572112083435,
-0.5874649286270142,
-0.4277040958404541,
0.242933452129364,
0.7892829775810242,
0.5179386138916016,
-0.4498554468154907,
0.45048317313194275,
0.405396431684494,
0.30302900075912476,
-0.21312285959720612,
0.4822557866573334,
-0.20775218307971954,
-0.7671915292739868,
-0.6886245012283325,
-0.6603752970695496,
-0.2261441946029663,
0.2424108237028122,
-0.7829851508140564,
0.21323251724243164,
-0.47307807207107544,
-0.015722377225756645,
-0.1356109380722046,
-0.27210015058517456,
-0.40259236097335815,
-0.16415300965309143,
-0.001561375567689538,
0.9702500104904175,
-0.7752854824066162,
0.9673312306404114,
0.7243635654449463,
-0.3699619770050049,
-0.7279919981956482,
0.028378289192914963,
0.29267171025276184,
-0.8715134859085083,
-0.01540631614625454,
0.3916671872138977,
-0.39385321736335754,
0.4897533655166626,
-0.18492868542671204,
-0.6485435962677002,
0.7029830813407898,
0.7286259531974792,
-0.44906964898109436,
0.292008638381958,
-0.23617275059223175,
0.11211702972650528,
-0.4720734655857086,
0.16712239384651184,
0.6857595443725586,
0.4573972523212433,
-0.05788281187415123,
-0.6684020161628723,
0.12206194549798965,
-0.04295986518263817,
-0.23825190961360931,
0.07347367703914642,
-0.2618212401866913,
0.7727921605110168,
-0.3865874111652374,
-0.5492171049118042,
0.11700352281332016,
0.4081897735595703,
0.38594263792037964,
0.3711130619049072,
0.47789129614830017,
0.15999232232570648,
0.7735973596572876,
-0.0027786686550825834,
1.0981709957122803,
-0.09606961905956268,
0.10068194568157196,
1.1312620639801025,
0.03992330655455589,
0.8425605297088623,
0.6414481401443481,
-0.06750952452421188,
0.32303228974342346,
0.5648667812347412,
0.24733209609985352,
0.9084864258766174,
-0.10968203097581863,
-0.5172926187515259,
-0.4685254991054535,
-0.10221210867166519,
-0.3376154899597168,
0.39667677879333496,
0.42632371187210083,
-0.10412582755088806,
-0.4075770676136017,
0.5668133497238159,
-0.052078910171985626,
0.23002980649471283,
-0.4071979522705078,
0.9751441478729248,
0.06689581274986267,
-0.535173773765564,
0.5856392979621887,
0.012211710214614868,
0.8474887013435364,
-0.6075243949890137,
0.010107566602528095,
-0.18579013645648956,
-0.04209159314632416,
-0.0721253752708435,
-0.5757360458374023,
0.08038069307804108,
-0.07105542719364166,
-0.37375006079673767,
-0.33875465393066406,
0.7061644792556763,
-0.4339955449104309,
-0.05309346690773964,
0.23347371816635132,
0.6806143522262573,
0.2599894106388092,
-0.3708944618701935,
-0.7195631265640259,
0.1608773022890091,
-0.1722153127193451,
-0.01923917979001999,
0.17811128497123718,
0.24383828043937683,
0.44489264488220215,
0.6737638115882874,
0.9216627478599548,
-0.03468221053481102,
0.2782365679740906,
0.6534450650215149,
0.6454135179519653,
-0.447458416223526,
-0.9218971729278564,
-0.810439944267273,
0.3948783278465271,
0.18284524977207184,
-0.363468199968338,
0.8520233035087585,
0.1382416933774948,
0.4685378074645996,
-0.21905246376991272,
0.7377997040748596,
0.523492157459259,
0.4393187463283539,
-0.8286334872245789,
0.6186633706092834,
-0.3278147876262665,
0.5184271335601807,
0.0032919379882514477,
-0.6724515557289124,
-0.18382351100444794,
0.651271641254425,
-0.2693746089935303,
-0.11948610097169876,
0.5226043462753296,
0.8268769383430481,
-0.0690840408205986,
0.1038210466504097,
0.2527521550655365,
-0.2053583711385727,
0.2794366776943207,
0.6180101037025452,
0.9160160422325134,
-0.09892233461141586,
0.7027261257171631,
-0.033358074724674225,
-0.24676890671253204,
-0.16650427877902985,
-0.7887387871742249,
-0.8422422409057617,
-0.5372258424758911,
-0.03179362043738365,
-0.10070142149925232,
0.11494383215904236,
0.6915531754493713,
0.9044415950775146,
-1.0143171548843384,
0.08448128402233124,
-0.054891131818294525,
0.31304067373275757,
-0.4514252245426178,
-0.22717930376529694,
0.36048540472984314,
-0.6803792119026184,
-0.6954240202903748,
0.9612268209457397,
0.332614541053772,
0.08564893901348114,
-0.07778262346982956,
-0.4155462980270386,
-0.22866277396678925,
0.035606905817985535,
0.6364777684211731,
0.2819206118583679,
-0.6788668632507324,
-0.2621777653694153,
-0.12133803963661194,
-0.002041185973212123,
0.15716910362243652,
0.8143512606620789,
-0.8805502653121948,
0.6024383306503296,
0.4090847969055176,
1.056205153465271,
0.30336079001426697,
0.02258821204304695,
0.5310694575309753,
-0.9530654549598694,
0.1992126703262329,
0.08395034819841385,
0.20269814133644104,
0.44109126925468445,
-0.2365873008966446,
-0.11153183877468109,
0.023452192544937134,
-0.06533580273389816,
-0.6051057577133179,
0.32968252897262573,
-0.8768713474273682,
-0.4466581642627716,
1.0891046524047852,
-0.35407090187072754,
-0.141089528799057,
-0.3914062976837158,
-0.44031602144241333,
0.08405046164989471,
-0.7464967370033264,
0.45529478788375854,
0.6113860011100769,
-0.08929983526468277,
-0.8218224048614502,
-0.3199436664581299,
0.4788256883621216,
0.6842662692070007,
-1.0456641912460327,
0.12686553597450256,
0.46772322058677673,
0.15490704774856567,
-0.04899042099714279,
0.7085463404655457,
0.21199265122413635,
0.2814067006111145,
-0.012862149626016617,
-0.24148230254650116,
-0.30824175477027893,
-0.4237177073955536,
-1.0210230350494385,
0.2686441242694855,
0.10448293387889862,
-0.6531633734703064
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10254v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10254v1
|
Towards Signal Processing In Large Language Models
| 2024-06-10T13:51:52 | 2024-06-10T13:51:52 |
Prateek Verma, Mert Pilanci
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
This paper introduces the idea of applying signal processing inside a Large
Language Model (LLM). With the recent explosion of generative AI, our work can
help bridge two fields together, namely the field of signal processing and
large language models. We draw parallels between classical Fourier-Transforms
and Fourier Transform-like learnable time-frequency representations for every
intermediate activation signal of an LLM. Once we decompose every activation
signal across tokens into a time-frequency representation, we learn how to
filter and reconstruct them, with all components learned from scratch, to
predict the next token given the previous context. We show that for GPT-like
architectures, our work achieves faster convergence and significantly increases
performance by adding a minuscule number of extra parameters when trained for
the same epochs. We hope this work paves the way for algorithms exploring
signal processing inside the signals found in neural architectures like LLMs
and beyond.
|
[
-0.3512851297855377,
-0.6542215347290039,
0.7429351210594177,
0.24294154345989227,
-0.3226923644542694,
0.09965284913778305,
-0.3953741192817688,
-0.6451717615127563,
-0.0934409499168396,
0.26834672689437866,
-0.43993717432022095,
-0.3183625638484955,
-0.6324267387390137,
-0.137483611702919,
-0.6939825415611267,
0.5153077244758606,
0.2904168367385864,
0.26146411895751953,
0.22290262579917908,
0.07756298780441284,
-0.07787904143333435,
-0.6554170250892639,
-1.1457037925720215,
-0.8032342195510864,
0.22726762294769287,
-0.23855051398277283,
0.5021476149559021,
0.39826875925064087,
0.15690039098262787,
0.34522247314453125,
-0.12457018345594406,
-0.22549036145210266,
-0.22603574395179749,
0.2041202187538147,
0.13119804859161377,
-0.6053576469421387,
-0.5343860983848572,
-0.1841583102941513,
0.8700159192085266,
0.9576897621154785,
-0.14582566916942596,
0.10773102194070816,
0.11499004065990448,
0.5463778376579285,
0.14333117008209229,
0.7308743596076965,
-0.6862766742706299,
0.0594254732131958,
-0.27767378091812134,
-0.4446592330932617,
-0.5672813653945923,
0.039733611047267914,
-0.25894075632095337,
-0.26661601662635803,
0.3050368130207062,
-0.07342863827943802,
0.37390127778053284,
0.06001299247145653,
-0.2162376195192337,
0.0028219709638506174,
-1.0811090469360352,
0.7626097202301025,
-0.6852932572364807,
0.9726037979125977,
0.24339845776557922,
0.29836663603782654,
-0.4036225974559784,
-0.8256182670593262,
-0.5527377724647522,
-0.3249618411064148,
0.19128327071666718,
-0.11671922355890274,
-0.24323345720767975,
0.16210021078586578,
0.4879491925239563,
0.41941043734550476,
-0.45055654644966125,
0.28498128056526184,
-0.42940717935562134,
-0.09062112867832184,
0.5678582787513733,
-0.007971401326358318,
0.20978906750679016,
0.426358699798584,
-0.03386646881699562,
-0.13905633985996246,
-0.888644814491272,
-0.197270467877388,
0.3239520788192749,
0.19617615640163422,
-0.046614427119493484,
0.3062618672847748,
-0.061436548829078674,
0.7759675979614258,
0.19485008716583252,
0.016917474567890167,
0.1862589716911316,
0.02775896154344082,
-0.3228228986263275,
0.06074240803718567,
0.6266556978225708,
-0.22784404456615448,
0.35519328713417053,
-0.17592717707157135,
-0.5374194979667664,
-0.11620768904685974,
0.1058783084154129,
-0.5306147336959839,
-0.2450171411037445,
0.1348571628332138,
-0.5734290480613708,
0.16324089467525482,
-0.22269171476364136,
-0.604901134967804,
-0.10039503127336502,
-0.7668023109436035,
0.23414474725723267,
-0.4023541510105133,
-0.31606459617614746,
0.2262730598449707,
0.05718421936035156,
0.501026451587677,
0.15936100482940674,
-1.2338557243347168,
0.28087183833122253,
0.9315988421440125,
0.6938561201095581,
0.3148294985294342,
-0.07963527739048004,
-0.6060978770256042,
0.1279301941394806,
-0.44902247190475464,
0.6269923448562622,
-0.6333760619163513,
-0.2991339862346649,
0.03936762735247612,
-0.22430385649204254,
0.11106804013252258,
-0.3852086663246155,
0.30600428581237793,
-1.309091567993164,
-0.010946087539196014,
0.03213024511933327,
-0.44275325536727905,
-0.2487182766199112,
-0.1954473853111267,
-0.9111124873161316,
0.8497657179832458,
0.23022454977035522,
-0.30824676156044006,
0.3892187774181366,
-0.799775242805481,
-0.6733540892601013,
0.13532133400440216,
-0.1258348524570465,
-0.3288867473602295,
0.33862847089767456,
0.43414604663848877,
0.618740975856781,
-0.4341655671596527,
0.15951450169086456,
-0.35216614603996277,
-0.5117262601852417,
0.36904358863830566,
-0.7565620541572571,
0.7805867791175842,
0.37654271721839905,
-0.30904966592788696,
0.15366855263710022,
-0.7060388922691345,
-0.05704983323812485,
-0.022386936470866203,
-0.5659316182136536,
-0.12439555674791336,
0.21835368871688843,
0.19186922907829285,
0.19447386264801025,
0.07008953392505646,
-0.5166597366333008,
0.19554060697555542,
-0.7435158491134644,
0.9001649618148804,
0.7232214212417603,
-0.20963642001152039,
0.4123436212539673,
-0.19025032222270966,
0.35534828901290894,
-0.1627422273159027,
-0.08341217786073685,
-0.472309947013855,
-0.5062226057052612,
-0.6632066369056702,
-0.33101534843444824,
0.13335257768630981,
0.10104541480541229,
-0.7704979777336121,
0.40413835644721985,
-0.5116251707077026,
-0.18423104286193848,
-0.4903864562511444,
0.2397136688232422,
0.03982410207390785,
0.0909150019288063,
0.3913533687591553,
-0.23472990095615387,
-0.557135820388794,
-0.6127129197120667,
-0.019833633676171303,
-0.279107928276062,
-0.36803102493286133,
-0.23838794231414795,
0.17088647186756134,
-0.06539296358823776,
0.7088197469711304,
-0.3676590919494629,
-0.10007113963365555,
-0.35299962759017944,
0.16076870262622833,
0.6796740293502808,
0.3408671021461487,
0.416515588760376,
-0.8245286345481873,
-0.17814691364765167,
0.1831926852464676,
-0.6644428372383118,
-0.133072167634964,
-0.05418946221470833,
0.3607655167579651,
0.2196219116449356,
1.0930075645446777,
-0.5885838270187378,
0.04201968014240265,
0.5149512887001038,
-0.09057841449975967,
0.3213702440261841,
-0.19939206540584564,
0.12902237474918365,
-0.8935260772705078,
-0.1223631277680397,
-0.11096284538507462,
-0.2972392737865448,
-0.6739023923873901,
-0.0018503564642742276,
-0.2784763276576996,
-0.16747437417507172,
-0.319782555103302,
0.5863205790519714,
-0.6500549912452698,
-0.44651883840560913,
-0.410508394241333,
-0.26139137148857117,
-0.3677816390991211,
0.5033264756202698,
0.07258040457963943,
0.8211933970451355,
0.6280943751335144,
-0.5329918265342712,
0.4724224805831909,
-0.12012339383363724,
-0.6025955677032471,
0.2969052195549011,
-0.7291277647018433,
0.13931916654109955,
-0.4562967121601105,
0.18742747604846954,
-1.1309009790420532,
-0.17091698944568634,
0.0832294151186943,
-0.49406489729881287,
0.5567534565925598,
-0.334060400724411,
-0.7556734681129456,
-0.38856175541877747,
-0.08262193948030472,
0.7174216508865356,
0.7983285784721375,
-0.8005331158638,
0.8080453872680664,
0.4554101228713989,
-0.16790556907653809,
-0.1443932205438614,
-0.7593880891799927,
0.015529611147940159,
-0.2749999165534973,
-0.5552113652229309,
0.2982390522956848,
0.19659766554832458,
-0.1763070672750473,
0.027734631672501564,
0.3437595069408417,
0.12475217878818512,
0.1904846727848053,
0.42425283789634705,
0.11867132037878036,
-0.4902557134628296,
0.42403489351272583,
-0.17990152537822723,
-0.3001171350479126,
0.09711531549692154,
-0.9393839240074158,
1.1763057708740234,
-0.1493290662765503,
-0.6981139779090881,
-0.2971213757991791,
0.31856465339660645,
0.7159845232963562,
-0.3324702978134155,
0.5788617134094238,
0.7405557632446289,
-0.28624585270881653,
-0.3805609345436096,
-0.4184008240699768,
-0.21982374787330627,
-0.5186611413955688,
0.5450624227523804,
-0.35653239488601685,
-0.9522786140441895,
0.4622429609298706,
0.08520582318305969,
0.014496051706373692,
0.6210098266601562,
0.898553192615509,
-0.07359548658132553,
1.0187690258026123,
0.6299070715904236,
-0.47806668281555176,
0.9082109928131104,
-0.28190624713897705,
0.4048786461353302,
-0.8091495633125305,
0.003613424953073263,
-0.22205403447151184,
-0.2777186930179596,
-0.2835176885128021,
-0.5447155833244324,
0.42943456768989563,
0.039138514548540115,
-0.6212924718856812,
0.2656601369380951,
-0.26063910126686096,
0.3370181620121002,
0.6947914958000183,
0.021138103678822517,
0.3430051803588867,
0.4525262117385864,
0.14876718819141388,
0.257214218378067,
-0.7628011107444763,
-0.20698221027851105,
1.2055585384368896,
0.5128016471862793,
0.8164436221122742,
-0.17616339027881622,
0.5083479881286621,
0.2871164381504059,
0.6973385810852051,
-0.7300273180007935,
0.5436069965362549,
-0.3958513140678406,
-0.46387529373168945,
-0.358216255903244,
-0.21581977605819702,
-0.9838559031486511,
0.22772544622421265,
-0.04851079732179642,
-0.897639811038971,
-0.08396711945533752,
0.019294213503599167,
-0.18958191573619843,
0.5790010094642639,
-0.4622584283351898,
0.19973638653755188,
-0.14283514022827148,
0.004002086352556944,
-0.47439244389533997,
-0.22895774245262146,
0.40628790855407715,
-0.1452033370733261,
0.2582371234893799,
-0.09402485936880112,
0.3095409572124481,
0.675862193107605,
0.04817550256848335,
1.133587121963501,
-0.18033482134342194,
-0.3647715151309967,
0.31127458810806274,
-0.03434253856539726,
0.24545596539974213,
-0.06187300756573677,
-0.17222803831100464,
0.34765899181365967,
-0.12673333287239075,
-0.22567641735076904,
-0.3069053888320923,
0.6011068224906921,
-0.6231400966644287,
-0.6411203145980835,
-0.23255008459091187,
-0.5439423322677612,
-0.25790461897850037,
0.004772693384438753,
0.09253288060426712,
0.6936034560203552,
-0.045791562646627426,
0.035405948758125305,
0.5785457491874695,
-0.06177256628870964,
0.735737144947052,
0.3077262043952942,
-0.4132201075553894,
-0.21091224253177643,
0.7216628193855286,
0.04042808338999748,
0.15857158601284027,
0.5262718200683594,
-0.20976975560188293,
-0.410365492105484,
-0.7847834229469299,
-0.33118730783462524,
0.28056004643440247,
-0.8313853144645691,
-0.09026063978672028,
-0.41846922039985657,
-0.41459032893180847,
-0.3079405426979065,
0.11672088503837585,
-0.19270332157611847,
-0.19545142352581024,
-0.18803000450134277,
-0.021047648042440414,
0.2594330906867981,
0.7422772645950317,
-0.05426469445228577,
0.7008819580078125,
-0.9371976256370544,
0.46405228972435,
0.4176197946071625,
0.5216630697250366,
0.38296863436698914,
-0.4954603910446167,
-0.29380831122398376,
-0.008841094560921192,
-0.08362450450658798,
-0.4384080171585083,
0.3321840763092041,
0.38522329926490784,
0.6864592432975769,
0.3608390986919403,
-0.4858287572860718,
0.35927143692970276,
-0.6027241349220276,
0.8153765201568604,
0.11129835247993469,
-0.941720724105835,
0.02469361200928688,
-0.4384748637676239,
0.4140026271343231,
-0.036148957908153534,
0.2950912117958069,
-0.721384584903717,
-0.22484008967876434,
-0.3317698836326599,
-0.8157281875610352,
0.5977203845977783,
-0.14989885687828064,
0.35573139786720276,
-0.0005478248349390924,
0.35848140716552734,
-0.05117315053939819,
0.02636159583926201,
-0.7371002435684204,
0.00500421691685915,
0.16409365832805634,
-0.36904385685920715,
-0.30409669876098633,
-0.3782447278499603,
-0.19935785233974457,
-0.1891874074935913,
0.4785369038581848,
-0.24990731477737427,
0.7895212769508362,
-0.17396381497383118,
-0.039433129131793976,
-0.22674179077148438,
0.3211941123008728,
0.1872512400150299,
0.643459141254425,
0.216382697224617,
0.11826831102371216,
0.06134780868887901,
-0.28833043575286865,
0.13765382766723633,
0.24581392109394073,
-0.0573316290974617,
-0.30064088106155396,
0.98680579662323,
0.8261035680770874,
0.20380330085754395,
-0.5345531105995178,
0.3077296316623688,
0.11042352020740509,
-0.048788830637931824,
-0.5332700610160828,
0.16280733048915863,
0.27690762281417847,
0.6823325157165527,
0.5758163928985596,
-0.19538243114948273,
-0.04784172773361206,
-0.6473608016967773,
0.3621932566165924,
0.5790073275566101,
-0.2931043207645416,
-0.6296467781066895,
0.939689040184021,
-0.03376159816980362,
-0.24346566200256348,
0.9330412149429321,
0.03583027794957161,
-0.6178723573684692,
0.6917822957038879,
0.6772606372833252,
1.0559619665145874,
-0.14387835562229156,
-0.06904350966215134,
0.18362529575824738,
0.04999033734202385,
-0.1959439516067505,
0.3183084726333618,
-0.22474807500839233,
-0.723841667175293,
-0.952761709690094,
-1.2081445455551147,
0.30564722418785095,
0.16257284581661224,
-0.20203056931495667,
0.07902415096759796,
-0.5687984824180603,
-0.13391496241092682,
0.18361616134643555,
-0.4102526903152466,
-0.7069844007492065,
0.10160675644874573,
0.5896163582801819,
0.7988030314445496,
-0.876918613910675,
1.1395790576934814,
0.3855708837509155,
-0.13911762833595276,
-0.7256777882575989,
0.049889497458934784,
-0.19921644032001495,
-1.0764333009719849,
1.1227043867111206,
0.029595235362648964,
-0.23870104551315308,
0.0462750568985939,
-0.4131786525249481,
-0.9595127105712891,
0.9335514903068542,
0.45501330494880676,
-0.7201759815216064,
0.10713478922843933,
0.203565314412117,
0.7948141098022461,
-0.3150418698787689,
0.030947068706154823,
0.8579404950141907,
0.4043029546737671,
0.2118861973285675,
-0.7629718780517578,
-0.10908005386590958,
-0.166495680809021,
0.003714154474437237,
0.5073245763778687,
-0.36110472679138184,
1.05568528175354,
-0.0506945438683033,
-0.3781285285949707,
0.11228545755147934,
0.8516027927398682,
-0.1742364466190338,
0.07090788334608078,
0.48800280690193176,
0.40142056345939636,
0.4523599445819855,
-0.27427196502685547,
1.0810811519622803,
-0.49877968430519104,
0.26329347491264343,
0.9076521396636963,
0.05703851953148842,
0.7636556625366211,
0.4691486656665802,
-0.6186258792877197,
0.1819438487291336,
0.5167235732078552,
-0.08423716574907303,
0.30256524682044983,
0.18221980333328247,
-0.5607353448867798,
-0.2313748002052307,
0.2866017818450928,
-0.3754902482032776,
0.4190467298030853,
0.6051031351089478,
-0.5425623655319214,
-0.2965436279773712,
0.20770670473575592,
-0.2668502628803253,
-0.01799595169723034,
-0.6581223607063293,
0.650227963924408,
0.38813015818595886,
-0.4790602922439575,
0.5371298789978027,
0.1468076854944229,
0.4742089509963989,
-0.6439063549041748,
-0.15041355788707733,
-0.05968020483851433,
0.11594809591770172,
-0.1138741746544838,
-0.9157130122184753,
0.34509143233299255,
-0.43705740571022034,
-0.2698538899421692,
-0.34291383624076843,
0.5772724151611328,
-0.6878716945648193,
-0.48680543899536133,
0.49911069869995117,
0.2965477406978607,
-0.10805448889732361,
-0.19187027215957642,
-0.22290170192718506,
0.22794565558433533,
-0.18087930977344513,
-0.34388232231140137,
0.11487416177988052,
0.2082718163728714,
-0.1960095316171646,
0.8045220375061035,
0.9074012637138367,
0.38569140434265137,
0.3053300082683563,
0.16818830370903015,
0.9158037900924683,
-0.739737868309021,
-0.5267087817192078,
-0.938872754573822,
0.028499800711870193,
0.29647302627563477,
0.0922636091709137,
0.22075684368610382,
0.22117923200130463,
0.9228268265724182,
-0.26991933584213257,
0.6131399273872375,
-0.009165975265204906,
0.08409446477890015,
-0.9131446480751038,
0.6201316714286804,
-0.3069612681865692,
0.5486398935317993,
0.13517096638679504,
-1.1899162530899048,
-0.5560470819473267,
0.28084850311279297,
-0.5275101065635681,
0.22111456096172333,
0.2727503776550293,
0.762631893157959,
-0.04105391725897789,
0.13096307218074799,
0.4288807213306427,
0.49040159583091736,
0.6621693968772888,
0.766907811164856,
0.9182936549186707,
-0.2006286233663559,
0.19468644261360168,
0.12504394352436066,
-0.014672587625682354,
-0.15662355720996857,
-0.636299192905426,
-0.7434899806976318,
-0.8846588730812073,
0.15319782495498657,
-0.09475310891866684,
-0.04227306693792343,
0.9700014591217041,
0.7542135715484619,
-0.7989802360534668,
-0.39022231101989746,
0.0719435065984726,
-0.017902322113513947,
-0.3619254231452942,
-0.15437830984592438,
0.4563882648944855,
-0.5356603264808655,
-0.9406417012214661,
0.529483437538147,
0.3682763874530792,
0.07074610143899918,
-0.44057005643844604,
0.05735819414258003,
0.14542782306671143,
-0.07032183557748795,
0.8772024512290955,
0.44400927424430847,
-0.390669584274292,
-0.3905041515827179,
-0.43074867129325867,
0.12660543620586395,
0.24590303003787994,
1.0365147590637207,
-0.9845768213272095,
0.2574806213378906,
0.5055591464042664,
0.760962724685669,
0.8658859729766846,
-0.36426469683647156,
0.6920156478881836,
-0.47300612926483154,
0.3589169681072235,
0.24045614898204803,
0.5582948327064514,
0.4216603636741638,
-0.26037272810935974,
0.3683434724807739,
0.1334514170885086,
-0.33642253279685974,
-0.4895193576812744,
0.4201057255268097,
-0.9088903665542603,
-0.2709712088108063,
1.0722436904907227,
0.04777708277106285,
-0.3944378197193146,
-0.2396952509880066,
0.0060352967120707035,
0.28321918845176697,
-0.23222918808460236,
0.7809180617332458,
0.7057740688323975,
-0.2216896414756775,
-0.12794813513755798,
-0.49197202920913696,
0.44755545258522034,
0.06211675703525543,
-0.4473050832748413,
0.2213493138551712,
0.2592909634113312,
0.428209125995636,
0.06667254120111465,
0.7575992345809937,
-0.3611314594745636,
0.21878808736801147,
0.0771508440375328,
-0.10120049864053726,
-0.1870986819267273,
-0.3450944423675537,
-0.7181848883628845,
0.4255550801753998,
0.3661655783653259,
0.01455911248922348
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.06263v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.06263v1
|
MaskLID: Code-Switching Language Identification through Iterative Masking
| 2024-06-10T13:44:29 | 2024-06-10T13:44:29 |
Amir Hossein Kargaran, François Yvon, Hinrich Schütze
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We present MaskLID, a simple, yet effective, code-switching (CS) language
identification (LID) method. MaskLID does not require any training and is
designed to complement current high-performance sentence-level LIDs.
Sentence-level LIDs are classifiers trained on monolingual texts to provide
single labels, typically using a softmax layer to turn scores into
probabilities. However, in cases where a sentence is composed in both L1 and L2
languages, the LID classifier often only returns the dominant label L1. To
address this limitation, MaskLID employs a strategy to mask text features
associated with L1, allowing the LID to classify the text as L2 in the next
round. This method uses the LID itself to identify the features that require
masking and does not rely on any external resource. In this work, we explore
the use of MaskLID for two open-source LIDs (GlotLID and OpenLID), that are
both based on the FastText architecture. Code and demo are available at
https://github.com/cisnlp/MaskLID.
|
[
-0.2732272446155548,
-0.6304298043251038,
0.09418822079896927,
0.6687831878662109,
0.012410988099873066,
0.5603398084640503,
-0.36805737018585205,
-0.7210789322853088,
0.17528696358203888,
0.7629919052124023,
-0.392208456993103,
-0.6844339370727539,
-0.3802092671394348,
-0.09965482354164124,
-0.5270689129829407,
0.9820260405540466,
-0.10219383984804153,
-0.22064168751239777,
0.01668492518365383,
0.0052113402634859085,
-0.4344222843647003,
-0.2603941559791565,
-0.5176334977149963,
-0.1228664442896843,
0.4365496337413788,
0.6614944934844971,
0.6503862738609314,
0.5018531084060669,
0.3610733449459076,
0.19163435697555542,
0.029895026236772537,
-0.07326807826757431,
-0.31879520416259766,
-0.08088204264640808,
-0.031222142279148102,
-0.36631903052330017,
0.20756424963474274,
-0.12473186105489731,
0.7170799374580383,
0.6183940768241882,
0.06284786015748978,
0.1774461269378662,
0.12034919112920761,
0.6779948472976685,
-0.9069883823394775,
0.3072930574417114,
-0.74281245470047,
0.3749341368675232,
-0.8999437689781189,
-0.12772253155708313,
-0.9121224284172058,
-0.1310606151819229,
-0.14154689013957977,
-0.5790824890136719,
0.05229826271533966,
0.1852649599313736,
0.9137237071990967,
0.23120279610157013,
-0.2725980877876282,
-0.4465271234512329,
-0.48561471700668335,
0.7352590560913086,
-0.3205617368221283,
0.2912982404232025,
0.2969663739204407,
0.7130914330482483,
0.2304874211549759,
-0.7069986462593079,
-0.5192476511001587,
-0.09113705903291702,
-0.36429688334465027,
-0.04207335039973259,
-0.1308186799287796,
-0.129985049366951,
0.04167918488383293,
0.49782177805900574,
-0.6941383481025696,
0.174662783741951,
-0.5583013296127319,
-0.6180744171142578,
0.3865097463130951,
-0.13185831904411316,
0.6848551034927368,
0.07047851383686066,
-0.7766367793083191,
-0.0162657443434,
-0.5033099055290222,
0.4229699671268463,
0.3115673363208771,
0.6716681122779846,
-0.04278808832168579,
0.33263206481933594,
-0.4330343008041382,
0.7776238322257996,
0.020177224650979042,
-0.2541351616382599,
0.633530855178833,
-0.038837600499391556,
-0.1280563324689865,
0.34386497735977173,
0.7734849452972412,
0.02535078674554825,
0.15575984120368958,
-0.5145255923271179,
-0.1912858784198761,
0.11394453048706055,
0.05754583328962326,
-0.8972111344337463,
-0.2703240215778351,
0.25194209814071655,
-0.38879069685935974,
-0.516722559928894,
0.10963062196969986,
-0.8649490475654602,
-0.4177824556827545,
-0.013410355895757675,
0.6055546998977661,
-0.11090316623449326,
-0.24136143922805786,
0.3183700740337372,
-0.0019964331295341253,
0.4282890558242798,
-0.011461585760116577,
-0.8600555062294006,
0.5908037424087524,
0.6142098903656006,
1.0107207298278809,
-0.7781784534454346,
-0.24367313086986542,
-0.8721388578414917,
0.03438876196742058,
-0.2635168433189392,
0.604714035987854,
-0.7876794934272766,
0.14175191521644592,
0.3578633964061737,
0.31502994894981384,
-0.08810128271579742,
-0.6388657689094543,
0.32608169317245483,
-0.6418915390968323,
0.3782743215560913,
0.18737976253032684,
-0.23267878592014313,
-0.046997830271720886,
-0.030381621792912483,
-1.011128306388855,
0.9709396362304688,
0.06342741847038269,
-1.0095105171203613,
0.3142789304256439,
-0.7929189205169678,
-0.6367277503013611,
0.432809442281723,
-0.1658082753419876,
-0.6936396956443787,
-0.322212278842926,
0.04447626695036888,
0.05345660820603371,
-0.1653771549463272,
0.062235649675130844,
0.014489617198705673,
-0.5834876298904419,
0.23525910079479218,
-0.08799899369478226,
1.2001041173934937,
0.4263373017311096,
-0.47969138622283936,
0.15766571462154388,
-0.6979439854621887,
0.21730194985866547,
-0.1040862426161766,
-0.3685353100299835,
-0.30595386028289795,
-0.10203711688518524,
0.5323383212089539,
0.14958347380161285,
0.21287193894386292,
-0.5997612476348877,
0.4865504503250122,
-0.04406033828854561,
0.362542062997818,
0.5604641437530518,
-0.08714123070240021,
0.7448423504829407,
-0.09350854903459549,
0.7021991014480591,
0.1749984323978424,
0.19933471083641052,
-0.24209144711494446,
-0.7324613928794861,
-0.6617305874824524,
-0.7642728090286255,
0.7098333835601807,
1.0981590747833252,
-1.2880396842956543,
-0.08663740009069443,
0.1956435889005661,
-0.2554158866405487,
-0.6201635003089905,
0.2882729470729828,
0.5799984335899353,
0.05174243822693825,
0.43856897950172424,
-0.5013955235481262,
-0.5227084755897522,
-0.9613325595855713,
-0.44393736124038696,
0.08295365422964096,
0.10552462190389633,
0.12852796912193298,
0.438572496175766,
-0.36371171474456787,
0.9512099623680115,
-0.6509698033332825,
-0.5478397011756897,
-0.1971309930086136,
-0.011862087063491344,
0.25500401854515076,
0.46999460458755493,
0.5661613345146179,
-0.9142720103263855,
-0.7703219652175903,
-0.041864171624183655,
-0.4794759452342987,
-0.45303070545196533,
-0.433025985956192,
-0.3803326189517975,
0.3015114367008209,
0.8168059587478638,
-0.2563501000404358,
0.3252212107181549,
0.6092814803123474,
-0.2101454734802246,
0.48530611395835876,
0.21341457962989807,
0.10365374386310577,
-0.8034501671791077,
0.14559271931648254,
-0.10344179719686508,
-0.10930728167295456,
-0.9981088638305664,
0.3161986470222473,
0.18830223381519318,
-0.13785682618618011,
-0.7764208912849426,
0.8904780149459839,
-0.7139906287193298,
-0.03886882960796356,
-0.07872273027896881,
-0.145489901304245,
-0.2418782263994217,
0.6088341474533081,
0.13869556784629822,
0.8211530447006226,
0.8572611212730408,
-0.46750861406326294,
0.09870348125696182,
0.149196058511734,
-0.8107497692108154,
0.13637058436870575,
-0.20373433828353882,
0.18459872901439667,
0.04636479169130325,
0.12738868594169617,
-0.9457229375839233,
-0.19966864585876465,
0.6747324466705322,
-0.3084461987018585,
0.28426215052604675,
-0.22739943861961365,
-0.37820369005203247,
-0.2899196743965149,
-0.3092818856239319,
0.8829477429389954,
0.35661983489990234,
-0.7139301300048828,
0.27816253900527954,
0.558325469493866,
-0.10182251036167145,
-0.8175488710403442,
-0.8954050540924072,
0.42342519760131836,
-0.18216456472873688,
-0.23927262425422668,
0.5427424907684326,
-0.15871718525886536,
-0.16669440269470215,
-0.0998147651553154,
-0.04871682822704315,
-0.7340267300605774,
-0.06513749063014984,
0.1903846710920334,
0.11149986833333969,
-0.07694360613822937,
0.09630954265594482,
0.12807711958885193,
-0.37951192259788513,
-0.3761879801750183,
-0.53204345703125,
0.4715183973312378,
-0.21275638043880463,
0.1284615844488144,
-0.2842637598514557,
0.46868249773979187,
0.29152289032936096,
-0.5759804248809814,
0.5398431420326233,
0.6780820488929749,
-0.45977675914764404,
-0.6002656817436218,
-0.25034335255622864,
0.11936254799365997,
-0.47984689474105835,
0.04898889735341072,
-0.7893274426460266,
-1.0326848030090332,
0.48268789052963257,
0.23677872121334076,
-0.197238489985466,
0.004221457056701183,
0.6578648090362549,
0.24280555546283722,
0.23264993727207184,
0.9186952114105225,
-0.12183877825737,
0.6475768685340881,
0.016430025920271873,
0.21815644204616547,
-0.46795329451560974,
-0.04207856208086014,
-0.4646833539009094,
-0.158908873796463,
-0.7273059487342834,
-0.6929551362991333,
0.0783129408955574,
0.12915094196796417,
0.1092911958694458,
0.8323403596878052,
-0.7802757024765015,
0.9853582978248596,
0.741238534450531,
0.32129916548728943,
0.39222463965415955,
0.10067316144704819,
0.003697456093505025,
0.0025301198475062847,
-0.43807074427604675,
-0.1744086891412735,
0.893646240234375,
0.3033272624015808,
0.7351379990577698,
0.11080609261989594,
0.8930021524429321,
0.6050650477409363,
0.1651557832956314,
-0.6548327803611755,
0.8425235748291016,
-0.2501138746738434,
-0.6439459323883057,
-0.3364391028881073,
-0.5426732301712036,
-0.9165557622909546,
0.321056067943573,
-0.009547639638185501,
-0.8369428515434265,
0.1416368931531906,
-0.012581179849803448,
-0.035950955003499985,
0.2123744785785675,
-0.681397557258606,
1.1419836282730103,
-0.08049262315034866,
-0.37407949566841125,
0.188785582780838,
-0.7602658867835999,
0.5509941577911377,
-0.16970624029636383,
0.24409045279026031,
0.14705964922904968,
-0.15868735313415527,
0.5589116215705872,
-0.2149326056241989,
0.9575608372688293,
-0.22813710570335388,
-0.2101600617170334,
0.37352028489112854,
0.33330264687538147,
0.0307175163179636,
-0.10902082920074463,
0.11062391847372055,
0.38802188634872437,
-0.08353989571332932,
-0.5327330827713013,
-0.39111268520355225,
0.5170657634735107,
-0.42877498269081116,
-0.3873029947280884,
-0.4625830352306366,
-0.5323528051376343,
-0.06513826549053192,
0.4609449505805969,
0.19143405556678772,
0.4853474199771881,
0.13615867495536804,
0.17882391810417175,
0.6874445080757141,
-0.6165429949760437,
0.5558858513832092,
0.5776739716529846,
-0.6120107769966125,
-0.2466268539428711,
1.293714165687561,
-0.032838303595781326,
0.5348855257034302,
0.9958761930465698,
0.1670994907617569,
0.11239553987979889,
-0.2245902717113495,
-0.594128429889679,
-0.09404867142438889,
-0.6165809035301208,
-0.042989958077669144,
-0.4603281319141388,
-0.3374813497066498,
-0.2336764633655548,
-0.16347941756248474,
-0.239947110414505,
-0.656147301197052,
0.2902565598487854,
0.2823522686958313,
0.05680356174707413,
0.21593886613845825,
-0.22725360095500946,
-0.018151650205254555,
-0.33590826392173767,
0.529094934463501,
0.1888706386089325,
0.40504929423332214,
-0.5039322376251221,
-0.19653530418872833,
-0.3181712031364441,
-0.2793542146682739,
0.05018594115972519,
-1.0987281799316406,
-0.006080728955566883,
0.27404797077178955,
0.519849419593811,
0.3860970735549927,
0.2794340252876282,
0.24466493725776672,
-0.6364518404006958,
0.5531028509140015,
0.12588192522525787,
-1.1994984149932861,
0.4041857421398163,
-0.13365119695663452,
0.4768417775630951,
0.6627456545829773,
0.3403220474720001,
-0.7311480641365051,
-0.6853582859039307,
0.06938190013170242,
-0.8293130397796631,
0.7833932042121887,
0.36503028869628906,
-0.22258232533931732,
0.08827348053455353,
0.0029168736655265093,
0.31668147444725037,
0.3787316381931305,
-1.1304264068603516,
-0.23041868209838867,
-0.1023457795381546,
-0.28912603855133057,
0.14509990811347961,
0.09578794986009598,
0.07406111061573029,
-0.060301773250103,
0.44816985726356506,
-0.34804752469062805,
0.444711834192276,
-0.14251549541950226,
-0.5529779195785522,
0.35343417525291443,
0.35634705424308777,
0.6942377686500549,
0.30565696954727173,
-0.07366691529750824,
0.2585853636264801,
-0.1461583822965622,
-0.5668564438819885,
-0.007680990733206272,
-0.1419803947210312,
-0.6689627766609192,
0.1576380729675293,
0.27802544832229614,
0.6864697337150574,
0.21414995193481445,
-0.7070377469062805,
0.8780791163444519,
0.245981365442276,
-0.16081379354000092,
-0.02285628579556942,
-0.10827597230672836,
-0.23923330008983612,
0.13139623403549194,
0.1792280524969101,
0.08368111401796341,
0.4119369685649872,
-0.820108950138092,
0.5391229391098022,
0.27958235144615173,
-0.4972682297229767,
0.14661036431789398,
0.5424562096595764,
0.24676060676574707,
-0.4931221902370453,
0.3795047998428345,
-0.4230256676673889,
-0.7822727560997009,
0.6711581945419312,
0.6097381114959717,
1.264302372932434,
-0.10020991414785385,
0.6880239248275757,
0.2936173975467682,
0.5999303460121155,
0.20463848114013672,
-0.15450964868068695,
-0.6160312294960022,
-0.7230913043022156,
-0.36283475160598755,
-0.5508986711502075,
-0.5559936761856079,
-0.18301750719547272,
-0.7817010283470154,
0.3079063296318054,
-0.16925211250782013,
0.4116746783256531,
-0.1065032109618187,
-0.2870427966117859,
-0.4829314351081848,
-0.03373456746339798,
0.36713913083076477,
1.104224443435669,
-0.9665297269821167,
1.0818631649017334,
0.3388146758079529,
-0.4056115448474884,
-0.1110578328371048,
0.3544207811355591,
0.16410723328590393,
-0.8544450402259827,
0.7382128238677979,
0.6261031627655029,
-0.13578160107135773,
-0.278939813375473,
-0.6509961485862732,
-0.4653288722038269,
0.7111845016479492,
-0.09215022623538971,
-0.4898022413253784,
-0.11500643193721771,
0.5282732844352722,
0.3655551075935364,
-0.485344797372818,
0.15523692965507507,
0.36474549770355225,
0.49069079756736755,
-0.1355895847082138,
-1.0520154237747192,
0.16271790862083435,
-0.3599507212638855,
0.1605057269334793,
0.2622303366661072,
-0.6358387470245361,
0.8009336590766907,
-0.23521143198013306,
-0.721435546875,
0.14328019320964813,
0.3980664014816284,
-0.16301791369915009,
0.3592683970928192,
0.7408918738365173,
0.40696844458580017,
0.6669552326202393,
-0.27060529589653015,
0.6636118292808533,
-0.47496551275253296,
0.3736516237258911,
1.238857626914978,
-0.3562191426753998,
0.9695447683334351,
0.4734589159488678,
0.12013968825340271,
0.717103898525238,
0.35362881422042847,
-0.07742466777563095,
0.9468203186988831,
0.612640917301178,
-0.2181342989206314,
-0.1951938271522522,
0.284234881401062,
-0.3383522629737854,
0.3082904815673828,
0.0807214230298996,
0.16721007227897644,
-0.12769392132759094,
0.5945904850959778,
0.11591771990060806,
-0.079798124730587,
-0.10803024470806122,
0.7038469910621643,
-0.2695719599723816,
-0.5915800333023071,
0.4355532228946686,
-0.00988362543284893,
0.7082860469818115,
-0.49755609035491943,
-0.04295964166522026,
-0.22882233560085297,
0.3943313956260681,
-0.28466352820396423,
-0.8885525465011597,
0.20922468602657318,
-0.1203559935092926,
-0.1860230714082718,
-0.5206533074378967,
0.6985181570053101,
-0.9125387072563171,
-0.3228374719619751,
0.2992401421070099,
0.047546520829200745,
0.2196289598941803,
0.10398663580417633,
-0.659509003162384,
0.4818679392337799,
0.03938746079802513,
-0.018480801954865456,
0.2114829421043396,
0.19530948996543884,
-0.33518025279045105,
0.7427290678024292,
0.4168194532394409,
-0.22897394001483917,
0.19338223338127136,
0.12911732494831085,
0.6479024291038513,
-0.6083208322525024,
-0.4911772906780243,
-0.4672323167324066,
0.6051305532455444,
-0.16172043979167938,
-0.3460959792137146,
0.565017819404602,
0.918898344039917,
0.9782273769378662,
-0.4361117482185364,
0.6863371729850769,
-0.20274899899959564,
0.43111833930015564,
-0.7735315561294556,
0.6169273257255554,
-0.4644860029220581,
0.24772188067436218,
-0.44687598943710327,
-1.021262764930725,
-0.6088332533836365,
0.4819684326648712,
-0.005578432697802782,
-0.3538351356983185,
1.047016978263855,
1.0573153495788574,
-0.03842681646347046,
-0.3056570589542389,
0.12983858585357666,
0.26022103428840637,
0.31525611877441406,
0.9570733308792114,
0.6177012324333191,
-0.5405580997467041,
0.8469880223274231,
-0.06065802648663521,
-0.7191160917282104,
-0.30073297023773193,
-0.7435762286186218,
-0.9675988554954529,
-0.8183155059814453,
-0.732081949710846,
-0.4254424273967743,
0.3070167005062103,
0.4307873845100403,
0.696512758731842,
-0.9065636396408081,
-0.3741966784000397,
0.019544636830687523,
0.24606309831142426,
-0.5209662914276123,
-0.3552418351173401,
0.09357091039419174,
-0.6745580434799194,
-0.6426947116851807,
0.43608659505844116,
0.41593998670578003,
-0.43456000089645386,
-0.22302432358264923,
0.07449189573526382,
-0.017497383058071136,
0.16779761016368866,
0.5196364521980286,
0.6881986856460571,
-0.6479441523551941,
-0.22029553353786469,
-0.03759429231286049,
-0.43638524413108826,
-0.0409657321870327,
1.0588208436965942,
-0.8223035931587219,
0.6276565194129944,
0.5487732291221619,
0.9035235643386841,
0.6362780332565308,
-0.4494127929210663,
0.06206034868955612,
-0.6835106015205383,
0.38609305024147034,
-0.09589856117963791,
0.03597690537571907,
0.09148062765598297,
0.13484735786914825,
0.5817897319793701,
0.23242203891277313,
-0.3724338710308075,
-1.097063422203064,
0.5517932772636414,
-1.2792246341705322,
-0.3642013669013977,
1.1790988445281982,
0.05116473510861397,
-0.2478450983762741,
-0.14693471789360046,
-0.47999897599220276,
-0.4690697491168976,
-0.12693287432193756,
0.7143077254295349,
0.5874255895614624,
0.28643736243247986,
-0.4027438163757324,
-0.554612934589386,
0.6841504573822021,
0.11156927794218063,
-1.0159847736358643,
-0.1451129913330078,
-0.01985298842191696,
0.08446633815765381,
0.486218124628067,
0.8307226896286011,
-0.08258695155382156,
0.38858869671821594,
0.05592772737145424,
0.29655444622039795,
0.204247385263443,
-0.8091158270835876,
0.038671500980854034,
0.3249783217906952,
-0.5184058547019958,
-0.626350462436676
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.06257v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.06257v1
|
Combining Embeddings and Domain Knowledge for Job Posting Duplicate Detection
| 2024-06-10T13:38:15 | 2024-06-10T13:38:15 |
Matthias Engelbach, Dennis Klau, Maximilien Kintz, Alexander Ulrich
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IR
|
Job descriptions are posted on many online channels, including company
websites, job boards or social media platforms. These descriptions are usually
published with varying text for the same job, due to the requirements of each
platform or to target different audiences. However, for the purpose of
automated recruitment and assistance of people working with these texts, it is
helpful to aggregate job postings across platforms and thus detect duplicate
descriptions that refer to the same job. In this work, we propose an approach
for detecting duplicates in job descriptions. We show that combining
overlap-based character similarity with text embedding and keyword matching
methods lead to convincing results. In particular, we show that although no
approach individually achieves satisfying performance, a combination of string
comparison, deep textual embeddings, and the use of curated weighted lookup
lists for specific skills leads to a significant boost in overall performance.
A tool based on our approach is being used in production and feedback from
real-life use confirms our evaluation.
|
[
-0.16880561411380768,
-0.5038055777549744,
0.5585828423500061,
0.2683703899383545,
-0.5405334830284119,
0.31766876578330994,
0.023657020181417465,
-0.6610612869262695,
0.6118371486663818,
0.8855182528495789,
-0.24765212833881378,
-0.719200074672699,
-0.8070588707923889,
0.19150494039058685,
-0.6176628470420837,
0.8142338991165161,
-0.179317444562912,
-0.2528701424598694,
-0.7187294363975525,
-0.3307105302810669,
-0.7208002209663391,
-0.4109935760498047,
-0.5871525406837463,
-0.06391797214746475,
0.27492818236351013,
0.22837024927139282,
0.6541620492935181,
0.8435015678405762,
0.5346522927284241,
0.3207997977733612,
0.12375033646821976,
0.7029443383216858,
-0.1428169310092926,
0.372639924287796,
-0.41329315304756165,
-0.2851925194263458,
-0.18148614466190338,
-0.23883409798145294,
0.6769984364509583,
0.5640302300453186,
0.08837731927633286,
-0.04378229379653931,
0.21252231299877167,
0.04089626297354698,
-0.6230686902999878,
-0.041074447333812714,
-0.5939385890960693,
0.020766347646713257,
-0.11975263804197311,
-0.43762969970703125,
0.014071410521864891,
-0.36987531185150146,
-0.12986037135124207,
-0.6155170798301697,
0.3507128357887268,
-0.057198263704776764,
0.5366396903991699,
-0.03603332117199898,
-0.5313577055931091,
-0.7035856246948242,
-0.5821959376335144,
0.7084366679191589,
-0.4457908272743225,
0.40941181778907776,
0.4061739146709442,
0.07034114003181458,
0.14141647517681122,
-0.6066597700119019,
-0.6232901811599731,
0.1965373009443283,
-0.48409947752952576,
0.026200493797659874,
0.11467204242944717,
-0.032967012375593185,
0.07898004353046417,
0.6085561513900757,
-0.7600640058517456,
0.5610459446907043,
-0.3017016649246216,
-0.14618465304374695,
0.48199743032455444,
0.09509965777397156,
0.32329660654067993,
0.07534372806549072,
-0.4399759769439697,
-0.3884086012840271,
-0.42496609687805176,
-0.0976676493883133,
0.6019678115844727,
0.12253972887992859,
0.10297796875238419,
0.4651128053665161,
-0.2556864321231842,
0.7011855244636536,
-0.041841793805360794,
0.02788064256310463,
0.20334607362747192,
-0.3397368788719177,
0.12470485270023346,
-0.10573571920394897,
0.6688824892044067,
0.43864375352859497,
0.09753280133008957,
-0.2670900225639343,
-0.22088634967803955,
0.07977627962827682,
0.7581713795661926,
-0.3813200891017914,
-0.05178334563970566,
0.10641027241945267,
-0.6854330897331238,
-0.5409142971038818,
0.409260630607605,
-0.47985056042671204,
-0.45140859484672546,
-0.07343843579292297,
0.3440602123737335,
-0.2755982279777527,
0.0011181537993252277,
0.02476932667195797,
-0.4712555706501007,
0.05024653673171997,
-0.03164561465382576,
-0.7621600031852722,
0.3088209629058838,
1.28811514377594,
0.7781466245651245,
-0.4086494445800781,
-0.3237055242061615,
-0.4596812129020691,
0.3703310191631317,
-0.09098204225301743,
0.739971935749054,
-0.8617693185806274,
-0.25583481788635254,
0.25382503867149353,
-0.010670873336493969,
0.12502911686897278,
-0.7909092307090759,
0.7535241842269897,
-0.8434049487113953,
0.15872982144355774,
-0.25735345482826233,
-0.6891146302223206,
-0.11791502684354782,
0.3398822844028473,
-1.0986000299453735,
1.0492258071899414,
0.25675031542778015,
-0.7861136198043823,
0.6912015080451965,
-0.3480343818664551,
-0.5667519569396973,
0.3401819169521332,
-0.36894869804382324,
-0.5871277451515198,
0.17604434490203857,
0.2840350866317749,
0.5069904327392578,
0.07952117919921875,
-0.24866719543933868,
-0.10510662943124771,
-0.6204920411109924,
0.15036799013614655,
0.07116921991109848,
0.4219229221343994,
0.017936674878001213,
-0.1625259667634964,
-0.3527289032936096,
-0.06191740930080414,
0.25249049067497253,
0.07117339968681335,
-0.39379552006721497,
-0.7864049673080444,
-0.20244847238063812,
0.0676271840929985,
0.17961396276950836,
0.4347914159297943,
-0.3720901906490326,
0.1629064530134201,
-0.1412319540977478,
-0.19719314575195312,
0.3874835669994354,
0.04865879565477371,
0.21562202274799347,
-0.40991419553756714,
0.6165679097175598,
0.08696295320987701,
0.0026929285377264023,
-0.08213382214307785,
-0.3354290723800659,
0.02448711358010769,
-0.13501359522342682,
0.14020070433616638,
0.777441680431366,
-0.9040062427520752,
0.9892327189445496,
-0.3337039351463318,
-0.5058213472366333,
-0.5702245235443115,
0.4036688506603241,
0.6120246052742004,
-0.005941303912550211,
0.33588671684265137,
-0.7194427847862244,
-0.7761543989181519,
-0.9987662434577942,
-1.0654066801071167,
0.23464801907539368,
-0.11542334407567978,
0.09796125441789627,
0.3006240129470825,
-0.36869651079177856,
0.8366848826408386,
-0.7393069267272949,
-0.5280708074569702,
0.000026241226805723272,
0.1690307855606079,
0.24657303094863892,
0.5472977757453918,
0.588580846786499,
-1.1103320121765137,
-0.7423868775367737,
0.09559854120016098,
-0.8835136890411377,
-0.0553441196680069,
-0.11730306595563889,
-0.07065670937299728,
-0.2359989583492279,
0.3162194490432739,
-0.639580249786377,
0.303394079208374,
0.5065470337867737,
-0.15680615603923798,
0.3548254370689392,
-0.07838795334100723,
0.45802390575408936,
-1.1537892818450928,
-0.005759452469646931,
0.24445870518684387,
-0.35528427362442017,
-0.35895049571990967,
0.30141741037368774,
-0.20533689856529236,
-0.13172534108161926,
-0.021244684234261513,
0.48724135756492615,
-0.4256148338317871,
-0.20813286304473877,
-0.49779966473579407,
0.4241788387298584,
0.1622738391160965,
0.2662561535835266,
-0.03151093050837517,
0.6067324280738831,
0.4111138880252838,
-0.4676642417907715,
0.5661287307739258,
0.5117197036743164,
-0.5479868650436401,
0.8921480774879456,
-0.5594965219497681,
0.35234829783439636,
-0.03843926638364792,
0.37731409072875977,
-0.8420856595039368,
0.13972046971321106,
0.08063719421625137,
-0.38843685388565063,
-0.019140699878335,
-0.20730280876159668,
-0.8270440697669983,
-0.7636047005653381,
-0.4402097165584564,
0.5424593687057495,
0.3329819440841675,
-0.5969693064689636,
0.2866192162036896,
0.3959168791770935,
-0.4195008873939514,
-0.7804424166679382,
-0.932697594165802,
-0.08355530351400375,
-0.09314528107643127,
-0.46880042552948,
1.09819495677948,
0.33838170766830444,
0.07766160368919373,
0.15138837695121765,
-0.29359352588653564,
-0.6977940797805786,
0.12857772409915924,
0.016475869342684746,
0.1217612475156784,
-0.049728140234947205,
0.0391375832259655,
0.335470587015152,
0.0500185564160347,
-0.23180104792118073,
-0.7380841970443726,
0.3767731785774231,
0.3661596179008484,
-0.6033598780632019,
-0.4967850148677826,
0.7374098896980286,
0.5108587741851807,
-0.02509891986846924,
0.913737416267395,
1.0034528970718384,
-0.39212751388549805,
-0.048405565321445465,
-0.744865894317627,
-0.1527487188577652,
-0.5264307856559753,
0.24555861949920654,
-0.05477098748087883,
-1.014480471611023,
0.37713295221328735,
-0.0865083709359169,
-0.11065673828125,
0.37413808703422546,
0.28319936990737915,
-0.18448907136917114,
0.8241142630577087,
0.6556168794631958,
-0.1022021695971489,
0.5511724948883057,
0.009083762764930725,
0.5023018717765808,
-0.4535678029060364,
-0.26370054483413696,
-0.2538999319076538,
-0.5790454745292664,
-0.598840057849884,
-0.5615365505218506,
0.1553134024143219,
0.0760444775223732,
0.5132700204849243,
0.7310456037521362,
-0.822191059589386,
0.6773272752761841,
0.5892062187194824,
0.0982484444975853,
0.39221274852752686,
0.28852251172065735,
-0.11498451232910156,
-0.08417649567127228,
-0.28469300270080566,
-0.5012004971504211,
0.9969514012336731,
-0.11757485568523407,
0.442600816488266,
-0.10164828598499298,
0.8514841198921204,
0.8097761869430542,
-0.042969513684511185,
-0.2777402102947235,
0.3575778603553772,
-0.7321001887321472,
-0.09276694804430008,
-0.1446349322795868,
-0.541942834854126,
-0.9832292795181274,
0.42832908034324646,
-0.32687637209892273,
-0.43067261576652527,
-0.11567233502864838,
0.20397727191448212,
-0.23189294338226318,
0.4727896451950073,
-0.4049382209777832,
0.773320198059082,
-0.380679726600647,
0.07765401154756546,
-0.5924827456474304,
-0.07099581509828568,
-0.04108530282974243,
-0.26614660024642944,
0.10694316774606705,
0.33566775918006897,
-0.25608396530151367,
0.6962550282478333,
-0.2240481972694397,
0.5473657846450806,
-0.007457508239895105,
-0.037555549293756485,
0.25640079379081726,
-0.0994495376944542,
0.6912015080451965,
-0.19048160314559937,
-0.11123419553041458,
0.22304923832416534,
0.06520691514015198,
-0.27043214440345764,
-0.5541450381278992,
0.9505000710487366,
-0.5018368363380432,
-0.14799104630947113,
0.08696706593036652,
-0.4522704482078552,
-0.052093129605054855,
0.3505760729312897,
0.3722151517868042,
0.2710951566696167,
-0.43852218985557556,
0.3612985908985138,
0.46258625388145447,
-0.30901211500167847,
-0.09065952152013779,
0.16953328251838684,
-0.12334757298231125,
-0.36090558767318726,
0.7805451154708862,
-0.09705513715744019,
-0.23578715324401855,
0.6946157217025757,
-0.3702727258205414,
-0.24339638650417328,
-0.11070617288351059,
0.09239783138036728,
0.2331240177154541,
-0.5490126013755798,
-0.27756786346435547,
-0.9739750623703003,
-0.031099287793040276,
-0.7438698410987854,
-0.3813391625881195,
-0.05336235463619232,
-0.3213282525539398,
0.0559585876762867,
0.014311392791569233,
0.44294652342796326,
0.9513519406318665,
-0.061511214822530746,
0.44626447558403015,
-0.7504376173019409,
0.46429964900016785,
0.5334678292274475,
0.6614785194396973,
0.04138146713376045,
-0.0019070106791332364,
-0.6751015782356262,
0.1363229602575302,
-0.6453303098678589,
-0.7120600342750549,
0.34678980708122253,
0.068669393658638,
0.9292948842048645,
0.17670942842960358,
-0.25449541211128235,
0.3362274765968323,
-0.08186480402946472,
0.4410449266433716,
0.009421531111001968,
-0.9515383243560791,
0.4906787574291229,
-0.2568078935146332,
0.10769902169704437,
0.7067681550979614,
0.9713220596313477,
-0.8631100654602051,
-0.41192126274108887,
-0.5960389375686646,
-0.9198070764541626,
0.4846797585487366,
0.6520407795906067,
0.03012751042842865,
-0.1504662036895752,
0.20160017907619476,
0.2833940088748932,
0.44194430112838745,
-0.42108991742134094,
-0.0815887451171875,
0.21292002499103546,
-0.40808749198913574,
0.22564777731895447,
-0.3199016749858856,
-0.09257536381483078,
0.03580525144934654,
0.2294277846813202,
0.20827831327915192,
0.5890957117080688,
-0.2387770414352417,
-0.4414246380329132,
0.30024489760398865,
0.018806835636496544,
0.29000625014305115,
0.45604589581489563,
0.11040915548801422,
0.1114264726638794,
0.3701990246772766,
-0.35901689529418945,
-0.33587440848350525,
-0.039784908294677734,
0.3599553108215332,
0.4588550329208374,
0.46757930517196655,
0.3973158001899719,
0.2863868772983551,
-0.5908671021461487,
0.8755810856819153,
0.27740535140037537,
-0.1036718413233757,
-0.3667742908000946,
-0.1603514701128006,
0.003657757770270109,
0.1934269666671753,
0.4922388195991516,
-0.016675429418683052,
0.14270555973052979,
-0.557558536529541,
0.5701462626457214,
0.40958520770072937,
-0.07062335312366486,
0.012702332809567451,
0.2958645820617676,
0.2780121862888336,
-0.6332719922065735,
0.564582884311676,
-0.2616012394428253,
-0.9179279208183289,
0.8672661185264587,
0.4684087336063385,
0.7759332656860352,
-0.23782946169376373,
0.1713164746761322,
0.014599752612411976,
-0.006400184705853462,
-0.38861310482025146,
0.3250293731689453,
-0.1460127830505371,
-0.7090890407562256,
-0.2895307242870331,
-0.20136496424674988,
-0.4967899024486542,
-0.11556136608123779,
-0.7691848874092102,
0.34645143151283264,
-0.4890957176685333,
-0.05890433117747307,
-0.14466100931167603,
-0.28578850626945496,
-1.0820623636245728,
0.18640223145484924,
0.18074177205562592,
0.3327670693397522,
-1.1734458208084106,
0.22789312899112701,
0.7024451494216919,
-0.29175105690956116,
-0.1769498586654663,
0.14439405500888824,
-0.13693608343601227,
-0.7463423609733582,
0.6374595761299133,
0.4312906861305237,
0.08142491430044174,
-0.4386596083641052,
-0.11328720301389694,
-0.758006751537323,
1.1777440309524536,
-0.033259790390729904,
-0.3294221758842468,
-0.21588169038295746,
0.2506629228591919,
0.5652365684509277,
-0.5501168966293335,
0.17883101105690002,
0.19498831033706665,
0.26828092336654663,
-0.27216821908950806,
-1.1025075912475586,
0.0820358544588089,
-0.18422813713550568,
0.10972575098276138,
0.16509342193603516,
-0.31218427419662476,
0.7848370671272278,
0.26965272426605225,
-0.4190773367881775,
0.01570937968790531,
0.37080439925193787,
0.3709481656551361,
0.3562890589237213,
0.6099753379821777,
0.6495615243911743,
0.9228442311286926,
0.18371403217315674,
0.9633021354675293,
-0.4524231255054474,
0.5562735795974731,
0.9829923510551453,
-0.23624968528747559,
0.663273274898529,
0.024746287614107132,
-0.09420372545719147,
1.081860899925232,
0.10492601245641708,
-0.4663940668106079,
0.49129313230514526,
0.007781708147376776,
-0.11576221883296967,
-0.27558261156082153,
-0.2744598686695099,
-0.5040369629859924,
0.47490745782852173,
0.30281615257263184,
-0.9372929334640503,
-0.22663938999176025,
0.15515047311782837,
-0.30912595987319946,
0.5089685320854187,
-0.1706715226173401,
0.6201170682907104,
0.12143925577402115,
-0.6298454403877258,
0.2633765637874603,
0.15551376342773438,
1.1556732654571533,
-0.15454304218292236,
-0.2845495045185089,
0.07766194641590118,
0.0715470016002655,
-0.25970223546028137,
-1.2004482746124268,
0.7619057893753052,
-0.21872876584529877,
-0.3117675483226776,
-0.7780534029006958,
0.9381951093673706,
-0.6488807797431946,
-0.1662389636039734,
0.4291929602622986,
0.29875779151916504,
0.07034262269735336,
-0.3504113256931305,
-0.5829160213470459,
-0.010279463604092598,
-0.23047691583633423,
0.6504960656166077,
0.06296327710151672,
0.5233163833618164,
0.05385689437389374,
0.533599853515625,
0.45495468378067017,
0.05981634557247162,
-0.1461428552865982,
-0.15767382085323334,
0.5941920876502991,
-0.7019962668418884,
-1.0010820627212524,
-0.605856716632843,
0.07999659329652786,
-0.7109414339065552,
-0.3211587965488434,
0.4243974983692169,
0.750166118144989,
1.1040929555892944,
-0.42920926213264465,
0.8736689686775208,
0.07069569826126099,
0.7065397500991821,
-0.388638973236084,
0.5610880255699158,
-0.712030291557312,
0.1514107882976532,
-0.5184823870658875,
-1.0436081886291504,
0.09764577448368073,
0.40028128027915955,
-0.15878674387931824,
0.37939563393592834,
0.8545023798942566,
0.8690029382705688,
-0.39461028575897217,
-0.34226492047309875,
0.2635398507118225,
-0.30131497979164124,
-0.2717553973197937,
0.6186246871948242,
0.6067636609077454,
-0.5444531440734863,
0.7955735325813293,
0.02938985824584961,
0.2551805078983307,
-0.60105961561203,
-0.6442312002182007,
-0.6283943057060242,
-0.5946990847587585,
-0.6036785244941711,
-0.39705169200897217,
0.06297373026609421,
0.567683756351471,
0.49628642201423645,
-0.7118590474128723,
-0.08886208385229111,
0.31511467695236206,
0.4256979823112488,
-0.6944962739944458,
-0.29414620995521545,
0.0822409838438034,
0.28322771191596985,
-0.43504539132118225,
0.2983068525791168,
0.3096112012863159,
-0.0712074339389801,
-0.004144927952438593,
0.31380242109298706,
-0.1528027206659317,
-0.08132537454366684,
0.4509735405445099,
0.19415250420570374,
-0.6215318441390991,
-0.2512064278125763,
-0.37865763902664185,
-0.4098726809024811,
-0.32949239015579224,
1.1611528396606445,
-0.7337625026702881,
0.20153167843818665,
0.8125840425491333,
0.9070844054222107,
0.22894330322742462,
0.2066957950592041,
0.6562334895133972,
-1.3969618082046509,
-0.09288741648197174,
0.20690986514091492,
0.20062753558158875,
0.5472436547279358,
-0.7138882875442505,
0.48062071204185486,
0.3562431335449219,
-0.3511207103729248,
-0.5430334806442261,
0.30332309007644653,
-1.0485304594039917,
-0.20776663720607758,
0.9392892122268677,
-0.03924456238746643,
0.6216608285903931,
-0.17676249146461487,
0.24882058799266815,
0.25061988830566406,
-0.17135782539844513,
0.9766367077827454,
0.4170442223548889,
0.3845830261707306,
0.05916259065270424,
-0.11955802887678146,
0.16938215494155884,
0.3734143078327179,
-0.5553248524665833,
-0.40311911702156067,
0.08598970621824265,
0.26617202162742615,
0.24772390723228455,
0.4613870084285736,
0.11437030881643295,
0.43710848689079285,
-0.093560129404068,
-0.0092923017218709,
-0.04716742783784866,
0.08997807651758194,
-0.19248829782009125,
0.15380029380321503,
-0.2551792860031128,
-0.4126979410648346
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.06251v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.06251v1
|
Learning Fine-Grained Controllability on Speech Generation via Efficient Fine-Tuning
| 2024-06-10T13:31:18 | 2024-06-10T13:31:18 |
Chung-Ming Chien, Andros Tjandra, Apoorv Vyas, Matt Le, Bowen Shi, Wei-Ning Hsu
|
eess.AS
|
eess.AS, cs.CL
|
As the scale of generative models continues to grow, efficient reuse and
adaptation of pre-trained models have become crucial considerations. In this
work, we propose Voicebox Adapter, a novel approach that integrates
fine-grained conditions into a pre-trained Voicebox speech generation model
using a cross-attention module. To ensure a smooth integration of newly added
modules with pre-trained ones, we explore various efficient fine-tuning
approaches. Our experiment shows that the LoRA with bias-tuning configuration
yields the best performance, enhancing controllability without compromising
speech quality. Across three fine-grained conditional generation tasks, we
demonstrate the effectiveness and resource efficiency of Voicebox Adapter.
Follow-up experiments further highlight the robustness of Voicebox Adapter
across diverse data setups.
|
[
-0.5565069317817688,
-0.726839542388916,
0.0194263719022274,
0.027981018647551537,
-0.12172753363847733,
-0.21472829580307007,
-0.21923337876796722,
-0.2618967294692993,
-0.2565547227859497,
0.5466601848602295,
-0.5353748202323914,
-0.301540732383728,
-0.5122518539428711,
-0.3827293813228607,
-0.24415212869644165,
1.0160983800888062,
0.23950806260108948,
-0.25112321972846985,
0.1456991285085678,
-0.09341107308864594,
-0.48978209495544434,
-0.2190667986869812,
-0.9237626194953918,
-0.45854470133781433,
0.26823586225509644,
0.4293516278266907,
0.7834284901618958,
0.5138135552406311,
0.03143720328807831,
0.35272613167762756,
-0.11326712369918823,
-0.08855031430721283,
-0.5065540075302124,
-0.2240172028541565,
-0.5715658664703369,
-0.7635570168495178,
-0.8027299046516418,
-0.09246547520160675,
0.47577178478240967,
0.4226096570491791,
-0.5081961750984192,
0.1348758190870285,
0.3547619581222534,
0.525325357913971,
-0.5576174855232239,
-0.04124125838279724,
-1.2171026468276978,
0.30929720401763916,
-0.010437488555908203,
-0.43954575061798096,
-0.32031282782554626,
-0.20343062281608582,
-0.058248188346624374,
-0.620083749294281,
0.4300740361213684,
-0.11729469895362854,
0.6932135820388794,
0.8570489883422852,
0.24783667922019958,
-0.06619331240653992,
-0.6978461742401123,
0.7343519330024719,
-0.6545690298080444,
0.3904014825820923,
0.2535896599292755,
0.6513487100601196,
-0.2819269895553589,
-0.5821172595024109,
-0.5223872065544128,
0.21798071265220642,
0.22423429787158966,
0.2151363044977188,
-0.8429334163665771,
0.23375657200813293,
0.1653880923986435,
0.23432649672031403,
-0.20005910098552704,
0.4589177668094635,
-0.16527296602725983,
-0.2579464912414551,
0.44793426990509033,
-0.11030261218547821,
0.22244223952293396,
0.011044522747397423,
0.05647091567516327,
0.030507974326610565,
-0.3403306305408478,
0.33727002143859863,
0.4278268814086914,
0.6349696516990662,
-0.2883743643760681,
0.45453333854675293,
-0.31314516067504883,
0.931041955947876,
0.8913766145706177,
0.026864351704716682,
0.010042930953204632,
-0.36006399989128113,
-0.4413944482803345,
0.34329840540885925,
0.5510856509208679,
0.18070298433303833,
0.3134027421474457,
-0.17090070247650146,
-0.01426160428673029,
0.009301970712840557,
0.39327356219291687,
-1.011059284210205,
-0.12360602617263794,
0.2221447378396988,
-0.3180476129055023,
-0.31403830647468567,
-0.28619059920310974,
-0.6407017111778259,
0.03450316935777664,
-0.4649991989135742,
0.5880974531173706,
-0.2580697536468506,
-0.17614388465881348,
0.1553240865468979,
0.08632571995258331,
0.282385915517807,
0.2807272672653198,
-0.9728583097457886,
0.22683681547641754,
0.5519869923591614,
0.6924163103103638,
-0.14546270668506622,
-0.18456347286701202,
-1.2347065210342407,
0.17136737704277039,
-0.29653558135032654,
0.5627750158309937,
-0.4774397909641266,
-0.18349511921405792,
-0.2752278447151184,
0.13864414393901825,
0.0392521470785141,
-0.8963826298713684,
0.3728894293308258,
-0.2770612835884094,
-0.011272753588855267,
0.3476255536079407,
-0.13344579935073853,
0.26322877407073975,
-0.20512212812900543,
-0.3331293761730194,
0.4189896881580353,
0.26498621702194214,
-0.44301292300224304,
0.5570008158683777,
-0.4940864145755768,
-0.27295228838920593,
-0.13728031516075134,
-0.10782666504383087,
-0.7362158894538879,
0.36640027165412903,
0.032111819833517075,
0.653739869594574,
0.06473266333341599,
0.4760797619819641,
-0.2894044816493988,
-0.06199971213936806,
0.11881104111671448,
-0.38102105259895325,
0.3968295753002167,
0.314384788274765,
-0.4901275336742401,
0.33272480964660645,
-1.1428357362747192,
0.2896779477596283,
-0.2769189774990082,
-0.465785950422287,
-0.026138536632061005,
-0.07438108325004578,
0.24126601219177246,
0.20158708095550537,
-0.10094691067934036,
-0.36123356223106384,
-0.08022172003984451,
-0.27746084332466125,
0.5196571946144104,
0.5051109790802002,
-0.3397316336631775,
0.522304892539978,
-0.19906526803970337,
0.5857875943183899,
0.2637711763381958,
-0.003927242010831833,
0.09790655225515366,
-0.04365251585841179,
-0.8752812743186951,
-0.12990859150886536,
0.33619001507759094,
0.3343798518180847,
-0.597314715385437,
0.7114681601524353,
-0.1257428377866745,
-0.42357224225997925,
-0.7063964009284973,
0.35094183683395386,
0.5010640621185303,
0.2879115641117096,
0.363901287317276,
-0.13585776090621948,
-0.347368448972702,
-0.978728711605072,
-0.42570915818214417,
0.4475727379322052,
-0.2225479781627655,
0.4346039295196533,
-0.05535197630524635,
-0.31788310408592224,
1.0289421081542969,
-0.16480161249637604,
-0.3170509338378906,
-0.33876147866249084,
0.1263105571269989,
0.18314619362354279,
0.8243479132652283,
0.6066458821296692,
-0.6230987906455994,
-0.3382954001426697,
0.41394007205963135,
-0.03806551545858383,
-0.4884456992149353,
-0.03294525295495987,
-0.3567672371864319,
0.08581943064928055,
0.6935197114944458,
-0.2726183533668518,
0.5029669404029846,
0.9353334307670593,
-0.33059942722320557,
0.15557761490345,
-0.11294364929199219,
-0.26939657330513,
-1.2820299863815308,
-0.0101736169308424,
-0.2745724022388458,
-0.49422788619995117,
-0.7079633474349976,
-0.5069257020950317,
-0.08663018047809601,
-0.47839823365211487,
-0.524618923664093,
0.23227794468402863,
-0.12816843390464783,
-0.13350754976272583,
-0.6458823680877686,
0.12751947343349457,
-0.11393940448760986,
0.40932542085647583,
-0.02390477806329727,
0.970154345035553,
0.5437415838241577,
-0.7820345163345337,
0.02266913652420044,
-0.00430429307743907,
-0.32536473870277405,
0.8947309255599976,
-0.8660593032836914,
0.020312348380684853,
-0.19076082110404968,
0.15332891047000885,
-0.6537001132965088,
-0.35563814640045166,
0.08305945247411728,
-0.32617872953414917,
0.3151395320892334,
-0.03160495683550835,
0.07100668549537659,
0.06689778715372086,
0.11521116644144058,
0.3798588514328003,
0.5308710336685181,
-0.7890962958335876,
0.8325691819190979,
0.4280046224594116,
-0.16852352023124695,
-0.1747460961341858,
-0.6374080777168274,
-0.45193198323249817,
-0.339448481798172,
-0.1412041336297989,
0.37667155265808105,
-0.2566993236541748,
0.09952078014612198,
-0.1303749978542328,
-0.36623454093933105,
-0.08497203141450882,
0.10826590657234192,
0.2985812723636627,
-0.331895649433136,
-0.14974470436573029,
-0.18210121989250183,
0.43400874733924866,
-0.21577081084251404,
-0.15944461524486542,
-0.253004252910614,
0.525512158870697,
0.20209366083145142,
-0.0630505308508873,
-0.5709324479103088,
0.3100425601005554,
0.531369686126709,
0.005515826400369406,
0.2814461588859558,
0.7541306018829346,
-0.3500310778617859,
-0.6001337170600891,
-0.4342036247253418,
0.11908785253763199,
-0.5305127501487732,
0.5927208662033081,
-0.7056607604026794,
-0.8583719730377197,
0.2675110399723053,
-0.02076064422726631,
0.0005887807346880436,
-0.034547679126262665,
0.42268118262290955,
0.2145870476961136,
0.9586667418479919,
0.7544059157371521,
-0.2514653503894806,
0.7827882170677185,
0.1305677592754364,
0.09210579097270966,
-0.7986262440681458,
0.1240270584821701,
-0.6841680407524109,
-0.3585139811038971,
-0.8076909184455872,
-0.5267493724822998,
0.035302404314279556,
0.38714542984962463,
-0.1888691931962967,
0.3349155783653259,
-0.538473904132843,
0.3873683512210846,
0.43773457407951355,
0.1503523290157318,
0.17078331112861633,
-0.0026249876245856285,
0.40663135051727295,
0.2132648080587387,
-0.9981575608253479,
-0.20405416190624237,
0.6398151516914368,
0.20242148637771606,
1.0328835248947144,
0.07189054042100906,
0.5868827700614929,
-0.00272447825409472,
0.14275041222572327,
-0.7801854610443115,
0.30513662099838257,
-0.342402845621109,
-0.43885257840156555,
-0.30185627937316895,
-0.3128984570503235,
-1.0441914796829224,
0.23602961003780365,
-0.14039510488510132,
-0.9942975044250488,
0.40184497833251953,
0.7234892249107361,
-0.6885561943054199,
0.044143300503492355,
-0.8350502848625183,
0.696357786655426,
-0.07294447720050812,
-0.5615022778511047,
-0.19272896647453308,
-0.458685040473938,
0.0058453879319131374,
-0.2737939953804016,
0.1392618715763092,
-0.2862480580806732,
0.1670202612876892,
0.7381260991096497,
-0.1145487129688263,
0.9425860047340393,
-0.3803638517856598,
-0.4239404797554016,
0.029950521886348724,
-0.16673488914966583,
0.481930673122406,
0.12543943524360657,
-0.007730330806225538,
-0.058389995247125626,
-0.11394146829843521,
-0.43028849363327026,
-0.6225808262825012,
0.8507753610610962,
-0.8581013083457947,
-0.6000525951385498,
0.17211563885211945,
-0.7808482050895691,
-0.45329391956329346,
0.33340781927108765,
0.40469664335250854,
0.3351775109767914,
-0.2669713497161865,
0.480669766664505,
0.690117597579956,
-0.4715328812599182,
0.3385087847709656,
0.5331155061721802,
-0.23288267850875854,
-0.387825608253479,
0.885093092918396,
0.13462597131729126,
0.7413079142570496,
0.4793481230735779,
0.3125934898853302,
0.21112173795700073,
-0.4522457718849182,
-0.19241200387477875,
-0.25881919264793396,
-0.15206001698970795,
-0.24373480677604675,
-0.6426576972007751,
-0.3687696158885956,
-0.16738270223140717,
-0.2610357999801636,
-0.656366229057312,
-0.11889978498220444,
-0.4915192425251007,
0.0211793202906847,
0.12660396099090576,
0.226169154047966,
-0.10832121223211288,
0.893204927444458,
-0.38150838017463684,
0.819303035736084,
0.7799042463302612,
0.6651358604431152,
-0.260159432888031,
-0.5668482780456543,
-0.21382692456245422,
0.02565602771937847,
-0.35336175560951233,
-0.3804786205291748,
0.10986883193254471,
0.4997738301753998,
0.48845723271369934,
0.3706477880477905,
-0.07187342643737793,
0.9494206309318542,
-0.6699836254119873,
0.3138491213321686,
0.1643124222755432,
-1.160649299621582,
0.8340475559234619,
-0.46726712584495544,
0.704360842704773,
0.6791131496429443,
-0.16136126220226288,
0.14522738754749298,
-0.32674440741539,
-0.5846587419509888,
-0.6451824903488159,
0.9620269536972046,
0.17717845737934113,
0.3187057673931122,
0.5638445019721985,
0.15273596346378326,
0.3127230405807495,
0.19662415981292725,
-0.5909740328788757,
-0.07673531025648117,
-0.56650710105896,
-0.2624790072441101,
-0.5582097768783569,
-0.10893130302429199,
-0.16783075034618378,
-0.3588641881942749,
0.5632796883583069,
-0.33398357033729553,
0.11184502393007278,
-0.14707976579666138,
0.05745118856430054,
-0.23473075032234192,
0.6781331300735474,
0.5030972957611084,
0.4544053375720978,
-0.19733962416648865,
0.0605255551636219,
0.1709015965461731,
-0.3817467987537384,
0.166935995221138,
0.3534597158432007,
-0.20237140357494354,
0.022534389048814774,
-0.12313671410083771,
1.3784394264221191,
0.5221959352493286,
-0.38178956508636475,
0.20294077694416046,
-0.10094150900840759,
-0.26232853531837463,
0.06165983900427818,
0.6440176963806152,
0.09880999475717545,
0.3773735463619232,
-0.08885015547275543,
0.17641018331050873,
0.12433215230703354,
-0.313501238822937,
0.1965237557888031,
0.6787606477737427,
-0.30271193385124207,
-0.30213358998298645,
0.814436674118042,
0.3701440989971161,
-0.5358503460884094,
-0.30063381791114807,
0.17514574527740479,
-0.03230474516749382,
0.3809632658958435,
0.8151417374610901,
0.9574756622314453,
-0.5973671078681946,
0.004250035155564547,
0.10863905400037766,
0.17612962424755096,
0.3355862498283386,
0.21388910710811615,
-0.5424614548683167,
-0.7644057273864746,
-0.22995933890342712,
-0.7771745324134827,
-0.3152579963207245,
0.4052625894546509,
-0.8614656329154968,
0.2800191640853882,
-0.3674299120903015,
-0.3651657998561859,
0.2068062722682953,
-0.44628283381462097,
-0.8542282581329346,
0.37152910232543945,
0.07641151547431946,
0.8077122569084167,
-0.7012342214584351,
0.8978279232978821,
0.402414470911026,
0.32621899247169495,
-0.9317284822463989,
0.17940500378608704,
-0.2884722054004669,
-0.6891119480133057,
0.2848113477230072,
0.20602445304393768,
-0.44656163454055786,
0.42601969838142395,
-0.3932081162929535,
-0.7538502812385559,
0.8848004937171936,
0.3828108310699463,
-1.1129053831100464,
0.24501043558120728,
0.14461584389209747,
0.24909399449825287,
-0.22084583342075348,
-0.024966275319457054,
0.8727913498878479,
0.3146445155143738,
-0.20513246953487396,
-0.9806188344955444,
-0.2765358090400696,
-0.2822648286819458,
0.2706049382686615,
0.011020725592970848,
-0.7167469263076782,
0.3497300446033478,
0.10437789559364319,
0.07021721452474594,
0.09821952134370804,
0.7636815905570984,
0.3235980272293091,
0.3395722508430481,
0.7571066617965698,
0.5109400153160095,
0.5162360668182373,
-0.1593606173992157,
0.5268439650535583,
-0.17050635814666748,
0.10769528150558472,
1.32158625125885,
0.007345457561314106,
0.705159068107605,
0.6676743626594543,
-0.16319267451763153,
0.032287273555994034,
-0.004434887319803238,
0.4543150067329407,
0.7431691288948059,
0.3806126117706299,
-0.17626835405826569,
-0.3170643150806427,
-0.21610139310359955,
-0.5003117322921753,
0.8050330281257629,
0.30745571851730347,
-0.3041294813156128,
-0.17547725141048431,
0.45057955384254456,
-0.10522421449422836,
0.10513141751289368,
-0.49261897802352905,
0.8970847725868225,
-0.04601705074310303,
-0.690250039100647,
0.7516839504241943,
-0.4648912847042084,
0.9064414501190186,
-0.5868870615959167,
0.21904051303863525,
-0.20602872967720032,
0.4382227063179016,
-0.3953011631965637,
-0.3225319981575012,
0.2315554916858673,
0.26063451170921326,
-0.4319226145744324,
-0.08524066209793091,
0.43856707215309143,
-0.5695011615753174,
-0.47946733236312866,
0.16267187893390656,
0.305711030960083,
-0.21091343462467194,
0.23075564205646515,
-0.47776639461517334,
0.34544533491134644,
0.07919693738222122,
-0.3320721685886383,
0.42093023657798767,
0.5867792963981628,
0.302987664937973,
0.4730105400085449,
0.48573100566864014,
0.20782506465911865,
0.2972329258918762,
0.2062644064426422,
0.850705623626709,
-0.531590461730957,
-0.6377643346786499,
-0.5228156447410583,
0.48332300782203674,
0.08029288798570633,
-0.2017955780029297,
0.4542454779148102,
0.4616823196411133,
0.9628291726112366,
-0.17954273521900177,
1.1069273948669434,
-0.0005080816918052733,
0.3880726993083954,
-0.756355345249176,
0.6814336776733398,
-0.4877732992172241,
-0.010540762916207314,
-0.4847038686275482,
-0.7844541072845459,
-0.04189223796129227,
0.6188093423843384,
-0.24535320699214935,
0.0027397247031331062,
0.15747523307800293,
0.9460514187812805,
-0.5989110469818115,
-0.2579384744167328,
0.5457202792167664,
0.2376491278409958,
0.39405331015586853,
0.526650607585907,
0.632520854473114,
-0.31870079040527344,
0.4552864730358124,
-0.34249454736709595,
-0.3786912262439728,
-0.19277699291706085,
-0.8109694123268127,
-0.9531631469726562,
-0.3110707402229309,
-0.425092875957489,
-0.3104982376098633,
0.24613797664642334,
0.6952539682388306,
1.0943011045455933,
-0.8798407316207886,
-0.08033568412065506,
-0.5499208569526672,
-0.15337957441806793,
-0.07259183377027512,
-0.26566603779792786,
-0.037046339362859726,
-0.35729649662971497,
-1.0957715511322021,
0.33468854427337646,
0.05325283110141754,
0.23262302577495575,
0.12121962755918503,
-0.09342805296182632,
0.4768001139163971,
0.20373179018497467,
0.4744560122489929,
0.36943119764328003,
-0.7573113441467285,
-0.2225567102432251,
-0.5368865728378296,
0.206462562084198,
0.07278065383434296,
0.7885693311691284,
-0.7570640444755554,
0.5684981942176819,
0.13076137006282806,
0.7758992314338684,
0.41097354888916016,
0.3969300091266632,
0.6236445307731628,
-0.7091298699378967,
0.5408731698989868,
-0.05306944623589516,
0.11927798390388489,
0.14254842698574066,
-0.2398061901330948,
-0.004137061536312103,
-0.4441368877887726,
-0.5830717086791992,
-0.6654518842697144,
0.33602622151374817,
-1.3072121143341064,
-0.03350122645497322,
1.030601143836975,
0.1894226223230362,
-0.15287946164608002,
0.11181753128767014,
-0.6677736639976501,
0.5819097757339478,
-0.45124515891075134,
0.6539907455444336,
0.24339623749256134,
-0.1674383133649826,
-0.3280940353870392,
-0.6124095916748047,
0.7643277645111084,
0.6285668015480042,
-1.133808970451355,
0.07663228362798691,
0.37169352173805237,
0.2929854094982147,
0.08672596514225006,
0.4386931359767914,
0.20807652175426483,
0.3292948603630066,
-0.260763943195343,
-0.08702083677053452,
-0.17786355316638947,
-0.2622387111186981,
-0.5021436214447021,
0.2196224480867386,
0.0524294413626194,
-0.48982512950897217
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.06663v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.06663v1
|
SecureNet: A Comparative Study of DeBERTa and Large Language Models for Phishing Detection
| 2024-06-10T13:13:39 | 2024-06-10T13:13:39 |
Sakshi Mahendru, Tejul Pandit
|
cs.CR
|
cs.CR, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Phishing, whether through email, SMS, or malicious websites, poses a major
threat to organizations by using social engineering to trick users into
revealing sensitive information. It not only compromises company's data
security but also incurs significant financial losses. In this paper, we
investigate whether the remarkable performance of Large Language Models (LLMs)
can be leveraged for particular task like text classification, particularly
detecting malicious content and compare its results with state-of-the-art
Deberta V3 (DeBERTa using ELECTRA-Style Pre-Training with Gradient-Disentangled
Embedding Sharing) model. We systematically assess the potential and
limitations of both approaches using comprehensive public datasets comprising
diverse data sources such as email, HTML, URL, SMS, and synthetic data
generation. Additionally, we demonstrate how LLMs can generate convincing
phishing emails, making it harder to spot scams and evaluate the performance of
both models in this context. Our study delves further into the challenges
encountered by DeBERTa V3 during its training phases, fine-tuning methodology
and transfer learning processes. Similarly, we examine the challenges
associated with LLMs and assess their respective performance. Among our
experimental approaches, the transformer-based DeBERTa method emerged as the
most effective, achieving a test dataset (HuggingFace phishing dataset) recall
(sensitivity) of 95.17% closely followed by GPT-4 providing a recall of 91.04%.
We performed additional experiments with other datasets on the trained DeBERTa
V3 model and LLMs like GPT 4 and Gemini 1.5. Based on our findings, we provide
valuable insights into the effectiveness and robustness of these advanced
language models, offering a detailed comparative analysis that can inform
future research efforts in strengthening cybersecurity measures for detecting
and mitigating phishing threats.
|
[
0.04861602932214737,
-0.9021783471107483,
0.11321975290775299,
0.07905854284763336,
-0.2328260838985443,
0.10213200747966766,
0.11932515352964401,
-0.7892342805862427,
0.18752402067184448,
0.4227578639984131,
-0.12002592533826828,
-0.38366687297821045,
-0.8005722761154175,
-0.053145408630371094,
-0.6934677362442017,
0.6821907162666321,
0.15551699697971344,
0.07822837680578232,
0.4239838719367981,
0.2404375970363617,
-0.20209549367427826,
-0.6452569961547852,
-0.904815673828125,
-0.23853082954883575,
0.6495458483695984,
0.2050655633211136,
0.35994428396224976,
0.07800990343093872,
0.9026573896408081,
0.343936026096344,
-0.14424385130405426,
-0.1721424162387848,
-0.576092541217804,
0.16883179545402527,
-0.2396000623703003,
-0.5404587388038635,
-0.30041584372520447,
-0.06921382248401642,
0.016789373010396957,
0.17407050728797913,
-0.10841135680675507,
0.1484583616256714,
0.07591289281845093,
0.7229719758033752,
-0.8573628664016724,
0.012512975372374058,
-0.9587796926498413,
0.029205946251749992,
-0.21699334681034088,
-0.2144847810268402,
-0.519454300403595,
-0.3776606023311615,
0.29685917496681213,
-0.20208735764026642,
-0.14087960124015808,
0.12677830457687378,
0.4800835847854614,
-0.22675848007202148,
-0.4612554609775543,
-0.38863423466682434,
-0.7350969910621643,
0.6557745337486267,
-0.6599870324134827,
0.23820094764232635,
0.3829224705696106,
0.48842906951904297,
-0.09987485408782959,
-0.6560794711112976,
-0.520029604434967,
-0.24505527317523956,
0.2235030233860016,
-0.13203537464141846,
-0.7867639660835266,
-0.0854097232222557,
0.23797082901000977,
0.3916079103946686,
-0.8060629367828369,
0.7055323719978333,
-0.6974161863327026,
-0.12264589220285416,
0.6180645227432251,
0.07272255420684814,
0.4424510896205902,
0.011743568815290928,
-0.12422891706228256,
-0.33605775237083435,
-0.9212775826454163,
0.14300993084907532,
0.5320652723312378,
0.27889683842658997,
-0.10995318740606308,
0.13510167598724365,
-0.020620370283722878,
0.4007166922092438,
0.06059998646378517,
-0.05043838173151016,
0.09581141173839569,
0.2710104286670685,
-0.47788605093955994,
0.07424867153167725,
0.796057939529419,
0.09798714518547058,
0.5624213814735413,
-0.07755404710769653,
-0.1373910754919052,
0.24693606793880463,
0.2471575140953064,
-1.0424598455429077,
-0.5793998837471008,
0.11070646345615387,
-0.6154268383979797,
-0.7062451839447021,
-0.04853197559714317,
-0.7086750864982605,
-0.8583006262779236,
-0.21909146010875702,
0.12971331179141998,
-0.33726567029953003,
-0.3982526957988739,
0.32265201210975647,
0.06415014714002609,
0.16120639443397522,
0.4276321232318878,
-0.9779512286186218,
0.32657670974731445,
0.7672176361083984,
0.7648401856422424,
-0.40330976247787476,
-0.016973208636045456,
-0.5212070345878601,
-0.2530163526535034,
-0.17066851258277893,
0.2430768609046936,
-0.5022500157356262,
0.06156722828745842,
0.33088523149490356,
-0.11681030690670013,
-0.1398806869983673,
-0.5524868369102478,
0.27807411551475525,
-0.9585223197937012,
-0.17144204676151276,
0.02848334051668644,
-0.32031843066215515,
-0.3952978551387787,
0.5808851718902588,
-0.9155941605567932,
0.5662870407104492,
-0.006143954116851091,
-1.0421779155731201,
0.09114420413970947,
-0.16432401537895203,
-0.3365136384963989,
0.031308311969041824,
0.07901721447706223,
-0.355269193649292,
0.08323780447244644,
-0.07367444038391113,
0.8516567349433899,
-0.5070026516914368,
0.23148182034492493,
-0.7417044043540955,
-0.33312085270881653,
0.5588831901550293,
-0.5925703644752502,
0.91594398021698,
0.20410260558128357,
-0.7343500256538391,
-0.17572526633739471,
-0.7373781800270081,
-0.3691764175891876,
0.2904107868671417,
-0.022707467898726463,
-0.5061313509941101,
-0.32562515139579773,
0.07016199082136154,
0.16666348278522491,
0.0337008498609066,
-0.4935597777366638,
0.015523212030529976,
-0.5560892820358276,
0.36849743127822876,
0.6334264874458313,
-0.13074786961078644,
0.360568642616272,
-0.23513561487197876,
0.5170620083808899,
0.25536924600601196,
0.31545141339302063,
0.042402710765600204,
-0.4119432866573334,
-0.6677026748657227,
-0.1403319239616394,
0.3569108545780182,
0.9678270816802979,
-0.6216023564338684,
0.18670988082885742,
-0.34100449085235596,
-0.7847744822502136,
-0.057766761630773544,
0.07129319757223129,
0.29073190689086914,
0.1981353610754013,
0.23540933430194855,
-0.03872429206967354,
-0.35849693417549133,
-0.9510717391967773,
-0.1699431836605072,
-0.3079773187637329,
-0.07106198370456696,
-0.20434914529323578,
0.7020924091339111,
-0.12060385197401047,
0.25527945160865784,
-0.2642471492290497,
-0.019086195155978203,
-0.4001595973968506,
-0.0979667603969574,
0.1903766542673111,
0.41781920194625854,
0.821133553981781,
-0.8554419279098511,
-0.5569225549697876,
-0.025856977328658104,
-0.6878193020820618,
0.2467607855796814,
0.1751101016998291,
0.14658567309379578,
-0.013041024096310139,
0.14263339340686798,
-0.37953606247901917,
0.5386287569999695,
0.4961242973804474,
-0.24197880923748016,
0.21817485988140106,
0.0838131383061409,
0.4656446874141693,
-1.0087175369262695,
0.13176590204238892,
0.07743862271308899,
-0.09153243154287338,
-1.1213970184326172,
0.060223162174224854,
0.31145018339157104,
-0.11399765312671661,
-0.6577053666114807,
0.41699203848838806,
-0.24739280343055725,
0.2887662947177887,
-0.37192195653915405,
0.16587702929973602,
-0.1367519646883011,
0.44888821244239807,
-0.1789480447769165,
0.44853273034095764,
0.7988913059234619,
-0.6149953603744507,
0.6343197822570801,
0.08991534262895584,
-0.5085561871528625,
0.4777704179286957,
-0.7656179666519165,
0.1711297631263733,
0.054804522544145584,
0.33358240127563477,
-0.7491305470466614,
-0.16528920829296112,
0.6759878396987915,
-0.37771958112716675,
0.3508353531360626,
0.04926956444978714,
-0.5251157283782959,
-0.38112249970436096,
-0.7222217321395874,
0.2430746853351593,
0.6801183819770813,
-0.5463628768920898,
0.40781956911087036,
0.2910313010215759,
-0.22588644921779633,
-0.6223024129867554,
-1.0093631744384766,
0.10990113765001297,
-0.6463488340377808,
-0.9015315175056458,
0.28460434079170227,
0.26393672823905945,
-0.6081330180168152,
-0.6473893523216248,
0.04673193022608757,
-0.15841352939605713,
0.5109065771102905,
0.15882016718387604,
0.17652158439159393,
-0.06611786037683487,
0.08953873813152313,
-0.13570868968963623,
0.06902956962585449,
0.16116754710674286,
-0.11532635986804962,
0.40216192603111267,
0.019193897023797035,
-0.5197721719741821,
-0.6989107728004456,
0.1311696618795395,
0.651488721370697,
-0.14135630428791046,
0.9884580373764038,
0.28552550077438354,
-0.5707882046699524,
-0.1616264134645462,
-0.6253469586372375,
-0.5385043025016785,
-0.4539428949356079,
-0.12486840039491653,
-0.08105172216892242,
-0.8000685572624207,
0.7305735349655151,
-0.02555108815431595,
0.08082681894302368,
0.33896979689598083,
0.25758615136146545,
0.21778282523155212,
0.691620945930481,
0.5490253567695618,
-0.5025601387023926,
0.5671535134315491,
-0.3431910574436188,
0.4769265651702881,
-0.3901604115962982,
-0.31233716011047363,
-0.6673400402069092,
-0.2845235764980316,
-0.7116286754608154,
-0.03622310236096382,
0.007098046131432056,
0.18876810371875763,
-0.29693394899368286,
0.5384039282798767,
-0.3670908510684967,
0.06929463148117065,
0.4795851409435272,
0.2183268517255783,
0.29783034324645996,
0.4708271622657776,
0.17162449657917023,
0.14567318558692932,
-0.46433714032173157,
-0.6096930503845215,
1.2772091627120972,
0.47527098655700684,
0.928014874458313,
0.4784451127052307,
0.5463374853134155,
0.42725250124931335,
0.216170072555542,
-0.4025399684906006,
0.43575534224510193,
-0.1408025622367859,
-0.436747670173645,
-0.18705078959465027,
-0.2973983883857727,
-1.2159348726272583,
0.28729814291000366,
-0.27157917618751526,
-1.2243921756744385,
-0.0316033773124218,
0.041783299297094345,
-0.3285180926322937,
0.5959388017654419,
-0.2692670226097107,
0.5623679757118225,
-0.11577317118644714,
-0.5157915353775024,
-0.3654309809207916,
-0.3887116312980652,
0.4413994252681732,
-0.4268740117549896,
0.13957583904266357,
-0.052618902176618576,
0.39449912309646606,
0.6411579251289368,
-0.06506223976612091,
0.9920657277107239,
-0.017221780493855476,
-0.4187282621860504,
0.3246462345123291,
0.19620710611343384,
0.9026034474372864,
0.14947707951068878,
-0.230802521109581,
0.19033141434192657,
-0.121101014316082,
-0.2077653408050537,
-0.675412654876709,
0.8743951916694641,
-0.4793917238712311,
-0.5557103157043457,
-0.5204322934150696,
0.07422607392072678,
-0.10275948792695999,
-0.013748508878052235,
0.2074052393436432,
0.5200405716896057,
-0.23368357121944427,
0.47408977150917053,
1.0750913619995117,
-0.3312767446041107,
0.4526485204696655,
0.7373722791671753,
-0.17216263711452484,
-0.3166281580924988,
0.5783724784851074,
-0.0297341737896204,
-0.10112611949443817,
0.6311161518096924,
0.21009212732315063,
-0.25087183713912964,
-0.8567557334899902,
-0.39723286032676697,
0.08771294355392456,
-0.7708991169929504,
-0.35208141803741455,
-0.8056035041809082,
-0.37445157766342163,
-0.6086737513542175,
-0.1495235115289688,
-0.016464432701468468,
-0.48309460282325745,
-0.19196219742298126,
-0.1326296627521515,
0.5191769003868103,
0.6025967597961426,
0.20408019423484802,
0.35520991683006287,
-0.9316447973251343,
0.02488142065703869,
0.21045689284801483,
0.042405929416418076,
0.22171185910701752,
-0.5830348134040833,
0.03867453336715698,
0.07877342402935028,
-0.416061133146286,
-1.177887201309204,
0.23251859843730927,
-0.295911580324173,
0.38837775588035583,
0.46244576573371887,
0.07023511081933975,
0.0452917143702507,
-0.08261515200138092,
0.7639920115470886,
0.2961687445640564,
-0.6824750900268555,
0.5477035045623779,
-0.4188489317893982,
-0.031151922419667244,
0.6393806338310242,
0.5845238566398621,
-0.45356011390686035,
-0.28147807717323303,
-0.5778716206550598,
-0.6138375401496887,
0.396779865026474,
0.6442630887031555,
0.16644726693630219,
0.15626564621925354,
0.21466262638568878,
0.0947699174284935,
0.22654218971729279,
-0.8818199038505554,
-0.11140362918376923,
0.3543328046798706,
-0.18817223608493805,
0.16619892418384552,
-0.3554513454437256,
0.04332621023058891,
-0.031078213825821877,
0.8593500852584839,
0.22647495567798615,
-0.10219340771436691,
-0.24657948315143585,
-0.20687688887119293,
0.3610105812549591,
0.2812880575656891,
0.4314786493778229,
0.6644498109817505,
0.2599242925643921,
0.16304031014442444,
0.3441438674926758,
-0.5990483164787292,
0.2647443413734436,
0.032918669283390045,
-0.23318830132484436,
-0.1434893161058426,
0.5791688561439514,
0.6395406723022461,
0.12352190166711807,
-0.6035547852516174,
0.787024974822998,
-0.011554906144738197,
-0.12482093274593353,
-0.49291977286338806,
0.1483876258134842,
-0.10436724871397018,
0.4517916738986969,
0.34906160831451416,
-0.32101258635520935,
0.46380525827407837,
-0.2890617847442627,
-0.05060889199376106,
0.3630547523498535,
-0.20546433329582214,
-0.35327810049057007,
0.26397639513015747,
0.39117392897605896,
-0.32637879252433777,
0.7453839778900146,
0.07682905346155167,
-0.5742794871330261,
0.7817323207855225,
0.42023372650146484,
1.0273925065994263,
-0.6266754865646362,
0.1578391045331955,
0.1885272115468979,
0.4360050559043884,
-0.26836884021759033,
0.220444917678833,
0.07035840302705765,
-0.4759429693222046,
-0.03821377828717232,
-0.4985716938972473,
-0.2265254557132721,
0.7103005647659302,
-0.42304548621177673,
0.22412721812725067,
-0.3943260610103607,
-0.0879676342010498,
0.1317242681980133,
-0.14284710586071014,
-0.6025375723838806,
-0.06229327246546745,
0.12613175809383392,
1.0277940034866333,
-0.7875944375991821,
0.595802903175354,
0.40488049387931824,
-0.06128408759832382,
-0.6351392269134521,
-0.06130604445934296,
0.23230794072151184,
-0.44892093539237976,
0.764121949672699,
0.5374876260757446,
-0.4041113555431366,
-0.371164470911026,
-0.32867497205734253,
-0.46635597944259644,
0.9934181571006775,
0.29015249013900757,
-0.9653135538101196,
0.12138817459344864,
0.363298624753952,
0.6205888986587524,
-0.13784390687942505,
0.17621304094791412,
0.44922497868537903,
0.26473796367645264,
0.06107937544584274,
-0.823611319065094,
0.0955919697880745,
-0.3232441246509552,
-0.045887310057878494,
0.13173633813858032,
-0.47529590129852295,
0.764096200466156,
0.37518662214279175,
-0.08579994738101959,
-0.09460170567035675,
0.4881698787212372,
0.15956749022006989,
0.5207321047782898,
0.40849408507347107,
0.34746265411376953,
0.6786459684371948,
0.11899306625127792,
0.5623291730880737,
-0.41233405470848083,
0.20858798921108246,
0.6293712854385376,
-0.37393081188201904,
0.803490936756134,
0.27131691575050354,
-0.08988800644874573,
0.474866658449173,
0.6347602605819702,
-0.055776745080947876,
0.354157030582428,
0.838342010974884,
-0.29857492446899414,
-0.045344170182943344,
0.2793292701244354,
-0.3810659348964691,
0.6895668506622314,
0.13608701527118683,
-0.6520232558250427,
-0.15152014791965485,
0.38542938232421875,
0.17846481502056122,
0.03485849127173424,
-0.4071442484855652,
0.5898247361183167,
0.20616614818572998,
-0.5540943145751953,
0.6002529263496399,
0.17025907337665558,
0.8281090259552002,
-0.542974054813385,
0.26370012760162354,
-0.2872411906719208,
0.589594841003418,
-0.0009431345388293266,
-0.23058435320854187,
0.2600743770599365,
0.2835174798965454,
0.23075267672538757,
-0.05202721059322357,
1.0359679460525513,
-0.07055577635765076,
-0.31227177381515503,
0.41633498668670654,
0.15694598853588104,
0.20482993125915527,
-0.3962167203426361,
-0.7359902858734131,
0.19959436357021332,
-0.18522551655769348,
-0.38659903407096863,
0.3751281201839447,
0.16078227758407593,
-0.05601264536380768,
0.901272177696228,
0.3796602189540863,
-0.16923251748085022,
-0.15030255913734436,
0.08906236290931702,
0.7572389841079712,
-0.34975481033325195,
-0.566047191619873,
-1.2329198122024536,
0.04797117039561272,
-0.5314452052116394,
0.027478665113449097,
0.8742830157279968,
0.5012014508247375,
0.7361571788787842,
-0.10703705251216888,
0.7022975087165833,
0.137388214468956,
0.24876727163791656,
-0.6523175239562988,
0.6433207392692566,
-0.2960033416748047,
0.3621240556240082,
-0.2638942301273346,
-0.9500373005867004,
-0.2030917853116989,
0.34139567613601685,
-0.3668572008609772,
0.02909000776708126,
0.5469381809234619,
0.7203884720802307,
-0.2657182216644287,
0.29573509097099304,
0.27663081884384155,
-0.19620545208454132,
0.462431937456131,
0.7118300795555115,
1.002915620803833,
-0.5328760743141174,
0.5089098811149597,
-0.040272511541843414,
-0.27957218885421753,
-0.5218065977096558,
-0.6085200309753418,
-1.3917489051818848,
-0.4005368649959564,
-0.2629369795322418,
-0.3862791657447815,
0.2504737675189972,
0.6271730065345764,
0.6019835472106934,
-0.9282957315444946,
0.13573279976844788,
-0.07858876883983612,
-0.17994637787342072,
0.045944955199956894,
-0.14340053498744965,
0.16493362188339233,
0.1367400735616684,
-0.6667551398277283,
0.25503790378570557,
0.28032687306404114,
0.49269792437553406,
-0.5985354781150818,
0.21184410154819489,
0.017816467210650444,
0.3567427098751068,
0.5891662240028381,
0.1585383117198944,
-0.567484438419342,
-0.029923010617494583,
0.12356793135404587,
-0.4614484906196594,
-0.37984615564346313,
0.9031438231468201,
-0.38291415572166443,
-0.06703250855207443,
0.8969326019287109,
0.8113692998886108,
0.5544862747192383,
-0.4864582121372223,
0.29838499426841736,
-0.01460628304630518,
0.08826573938131332,
0.16635648906230927,
0.3394528031349182,
0.34325554966926575,
-0.5011258125305176,
0.4811498522758484,
-0.1566917598247528,
-0.38517656922340393,
-0.662386417388916,
0.36732906103134155,
-0.6479662656784058,
-0.44498735666275024,
1.2790794372558594,
-0.39227479696273804,
-0.1673378050327301,
-0.25242874026298523,
0.03653169795870781,
0.051699601113796234,
-0.1221376359462738,
1.1195058822631836,
0.5299186110496521,
0.38895294070243835,
0.09899843484163284,
-0.44476383924484253,
0.5308359265327454,
0.14201997220516205,
-0.7233358025550842,
0.024682989344000816,
0.2872694134712219,
0.33679255843162537,
0.16935865581035614,
0.6348482370376587,
0.03046862781047821,
0.22282753884792328,
-0.12708032131195068,
-0.35608553886413574,
-0.08619991689920425,
-0.5813429355621338,
-0.4167611598968506,
0.3378204107284546,
-0.181471586227417,
-0.11137866228818893
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10253v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10253v1
|
Développement automatique de lexiques pour les concepts émergents : une exploration méthodologique
| 2024-06-10T12:58:56 | 2024-06-10T12:58:56 |
Revekka Kyriakoglou, Anna Pappa, Jilin He, Antoine Schoen, Patricia Laurens, Markarit Vartampetian, Philippe Laredo, Tita Kyriacopoulou
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IR, cs.LG
|
This paper presents the development of a lexicon centered on emerging
concepts, focusing on non-technological innovation. It introduces a four-step
methodology that combines human expertise, statistical analysis, and machine
learning techniques to establish a model that can be generalized across
multiple domains. This process includes the creation of a thematic corpus, the
development of a Gold Standard Lexicon, annotation and preparation of a
training corpus, and finally, the implementation of learning models to identify
new terms. The results demonstrate the robustness and relevance of our
approach, highlighting its adaptability to various contexts and its
contribution to lexical research. The developed methodology promises
applicability in conceptual fields.
|
[
-0.618384599685669,
-0.9478161334991455,
0.3876916170120239,
0.030466696247458458,
-0.06673313677310944,
0.5770784616470337,
-0.10974010825157166,
-0.35342708230018616,
0.5472056269645691,
0.25423547625541687,
-0.34704768657684326,
-0.5716084837913513,
-0.7149887084960938,
0.36678922176361084,
-0.686782956123352,
0.7505443096160889,
-0.28299781680107117,
-0.6205388307571411,
-0.03635803237557411,
0.043015267699956894,
-0.5390630960464478,
-0.16151711344718933,
-0.4672987461090088,
-0.06811008602380753,
0.09963355958461761,
0.46014830470085144,
0.6428323984146118,
0.4704188406467438,
0.4315428137779236,
0.3280395269393921,
-0.03854348883032799,
0.47235068678855896,
0.20765627920627594,
0.05199027061462402,
-0.2898625135421753,
-0.21662218868732452,
-0.2156490683555603,
0.0005903993151150644,
0.4372301697731018,
0.8689262270927429,
-0.08470659703016281,
0.04865138232707977,
-0.00784891378134489,
0.4783690869808197,
-0.5082145929336548,
0.2542931139469147,
-0.6315377354621887,
0.058566849678754807,
-0.02467343397438526,
-0.46114492416381836,
0.044437382370233536,
-0.23889018595218658,
0.37962332367897034,
-0.8457714915275574,
0.4896489679813385,
-0.12948720157146454,
0.8827647566795349,
-0.15247635543346405,
-0.0398598313331604,
-0.6485691070556641,
-0.6593730449676514,
0.504757285118103,
-0.37387922406196594,
0.3709464371204376,
-0.029886089265346527,
0.21498630940914154,
-0.10490356385707855,
-1.0098984241485596,
-0.5057814121246338,
-0.2155311107635498,
0.2725224494934082,
-0.19757546484470367,
0.029561243951320648,
-0.3522741198539734,
-0.11940161138772964,
0.04374231770634651,
-0.3700329661369324,
-0.03005203790962696,
-0.38099968433380127,
-0.2653305232524872,
0.6108317971229553,
-0.06329440325498581,
0.37042707204818726,
-0.17379575967788696,
-0.4000442326068878,
0.09094417095184326,
-0.45142480731010437,
-0.16893687844276428,
0.23804163932800293,
0.5499462485313416,
-0.2357390969991684,
0.6457945108413696,
-0.3440459668636322,
0.40011754631996155,
-0.013483145274221897,
-0.04986763745546341,
0.5890992879867554,
-0.697280764579773,
0.017809433862566948,
-0.18091192841529846,
0.6186398267745972,
0.046926334500312805,
0.09180581569671631,
-0.40313446521759033,
-0.45406854152679443,
0.17441144585609436,
0.5864226222038269,
-0.15378329157829285,
-0.5007186532020569,
0.2557082176208496,
-0.23770183324813843,
-0.7008353471755981,
0.12791723012924194,
-0.9527899026870728,
-0.2346038818359375,
-0.5137142539024353,
0.5437150597572327,
-0.48276251554489136,
-0.5926153063774109,
-0.19686326384544373,
-0.542140781879425,
0.06346498429775238,
0.32081860303878784,
-0.8151208758354187,
0.35905495285987854,
0.48283103108406067,
1.066048264503479,
-0.36472535133361816,
-0.13720086216926575,
0.39501428604125977,
-0.06326145678758621,
-0.7558749914169312,
1.0862185955047607,
-0.4126654267311096,
-0.8714196681976318,
0.04956479370594025,
-0.016021590679883957,
0.1507805436849594,
-0.35159745812416077,
0.35176634788513184,
-0.5120886564254761,
-0.05400290712714195,
0.3237341642379761,
-0.392758309841156,
-0.3268783688545227,
0.20287182927131653,
-0.6176949739456177,
1.0068002939224243,
0.18293200433254242,
-0.9002755284309387,
0.48274484276771545,
-1.342246174812317,
-0.34206849336624146,
0.5483615398406982,
-0.44620567560195923,
-0.11130542308092117,
0.2745089828968048,
0.04290159419178963,
0.17448082566261292,
-0.42653581500053406,
0.2652879059314728,
0.09859099239110947,
0.14450156688690186,
0.38202911615371704,
0.23936493694782257,
0.7093313336372375,
0.4441411793231964,
-0.39425644278526306,
-0.018628602847456932,
-0.625529944896698,
0.09593650698661804,
0.2770376205444336,
0.21817412972450256,
-0.5667137503623962,
-0.01713234931230545,
-0.0623416043817997,
0.20411159098148346,
0.49547234177589417,
-0.432711660861969,
0.08157895505428314,
-0.49849191308021545,
0.5830550789833069,
0.38254663348197937,
0.38436946272850037,
0.5924931168556213,
-0.28289327025413513,
0.45061349868774414,
0.11395112425088882,
-0.015503235161304474,
-0.35262009501457214,
-0.5561443567276001,
-0.8093149065971375,
-0.12455860525369644,
0.5542117357254028,
0.4829607605934143,
-0.8275431394577026,
0.7030689120292664,
-0.25900784134864807,
-0.6637781858444214,
-0.08733236789703369,
0.16873908042907715,
-0.1639775186777115,
0.3208971321582794,
0.29779499769210815,
-0.7398108839988708,
-0.534673273563385,
-0.7689818143844604,
-0.1564183086156845,
-0.18993273377418518,
0.19253987073898315,
0.07341449707746506,
0.7953285574913025,
-0.358151376247406,
1.2455288171768188,
-0.4756748378276825,
0.15431077778339386,
-0.12059196829795837,
0.6778535842895508,
0.06475651264190674,
0.5153489112854004,
0.3513385057449341,
-0.939638078212738,
-0.052913598716259,
0.05733608081936836,
-0.9038435816764832,
-0.0357140377163887,
0.15588253736495972,
-0.3310340940952301,
-0.007891924120485783,
0.7232300639152527,
-0.1367625892162323,
0.3837853670120239,
0.06823093444108963,
-0.2895706295967102,
0.40725472569465637,
-0.035929687321186066,
-0.12214390188455582,
-1.2935302257537842,
0.048340652137994766,
0.29120609164237976,
0.28337159752845764,
-0.6479018330574036,
0.46491971611976624,
0.1297251284122467,
-0.18146848678588867,
-0.5032055974006653,
0.8130197525024414,
-0.39535996317863464,
0.2754872739315033,
-0.35917866230010986,
0.38996419310569763,
0.03214861825108528,
-0.0072022429667413235,
0.4380534291267395,
0.5394076108932495,
0.6181555986404419,
-1.0849378108978271,
0.3192005157470703,
0.2580254375934601,
-0.028513826429843903,
0.3257553279399872,
-0.4622567892074585,
0.03910931944847107,
-0.10542143136262894,
-0.3088606894016266,
-0.8478016257286072,
0.054781075567007065,
0.1171298399567604,
-0.8421734571456909,
0.09766082465648651,
0.19159725308418274,
-0.7172088027000427,
-0.5538303852081299,
-0.1259782612323761,
0.21394780278205872,
0.27180004119873047,
-0.14492371678352356,
0.4443801939487457,
0.8378481864929199,
-0.3302544355392456,
-0.22783268988132477,
-0.5792643427848816,
0.37463316321372986,
-0.4885326325893402,
-0.5351877212524414,
0.4273844361305237,
0.1317344754934311,
-0.5015690922737122,
-0.00898382905870676,
0.15012161433696747,
-0.31729570031166077,
0.32307636737823486,
-0.22925019264221191,
0.35549378395080566,
0.02642727829515934,
0.4482148587703705,
-0.08729083836078644,
-0.0030967670027166605,
0.13678383827209473,
-0.877699613571167,
0.26152458786964417,
0.13319654762744904,
0.20072871446609497,
-0.23224571347236633,
0.27970942854881287,
0.10400790721178055,
-0.23878024518489838,
0.309181809425354,
0.49341103434562683,
-0.5027527213096619,
-0.4212419092655182,
-0.45013710856437683,
-0.19959208369255066,
-0.4458988904953003,
0.2906607389450073,
-0.5224229693412781,
-0.4925619661808014,
0.3657984733581543,
-0.4538096487522125,
0.44216421246528625,
0.7563536167144775,
0.7248754501342773,
0.07172226905822754,
0.3746483623981476,
1.2416242361068726,
0.45650243759155273,
0.21738913655281067,
-0.5921038389205933,
0.4700871407985687,
-0.6984347105026245,
-0.43880218267440796,
-0.5664404034614563,
0.03506914898753166,
-0.9576932191848755,
-0.69422447681427,
0.33334213495254517,
-0.17206308245658875,
-0.020447153598070145,
0.6135039925575256,
-0.3929157853126526,
-0.0782465785741806,
0.3727274537086487,
-0.26284563541412354,
0.40258660912513733,
0.06271007657051086,
-0.7477068305015564,
0.15639369189739227,
-0.6803513169288635,
-0.761183500289917,
1.5061168670654297,
0.45175081491470337,
0.631953239440918,
0.1916070282459259,
0.8705990314483643,
0.32865476608276367,
0.15650616586208344,
-0.9469523429870605,
0.3753758370876312,
0.2589553892612457,
-0.8152014017105103,
-0.42605042457580566,
-0.26287588477134705,
-0.8473866581916809,
-0.024106979370117188,
-0.295650452375412,
-0.6304529905319214,
0.26446545124053955,
-0.1655343770980835,
-0.46887627243995667,
0.08172861486673355,
-0.6629834771156311,
0.6101799607276917,
-0.22774986922740936,
-0.3525323271751404,
-0.054980792105197906,
-0.5104071497917175,
0.26124307513237,
-0.5420452952384949,
0.7386081218719482,
-0.28559717535972595,
-0.6568291783332825,
0.9700425267219543,
0.020196031779050827,
0.5925872921943665,
0.08862873166799545,
-0.31060194969177246,
0.9297775030136108,
0.24806244671344757,
-0.08505203574895859,
0.27761316299438477,
0.09001987427473068,
0.16669051349163055,
-0.037034954875707626,
-0.3085334599018097,
-0.5888007879257202,
0.393714040517807,
-0.6902694702148438,
-0.20243597030639648,
-0.6177581548690796,
-0.5592000484466553,
-0.4679184854030609,
0.21294407546520233,
-0.02214958518743515,
0.27553677558898926,
-0.6726096272468567,
-0.31525659561157227,
0.6261600852012634,
-0.16010701656341553,
0.6391383409500122,
0.6436957716941833,
-0.0685792863368988,
-0.18741604685783386,
0.8182996511459351,
0.12609900534152985,
0.005764257628470659,
0.3362397849559784,
0.13935120403766632,
-0.38486000895500183,
-0.5887168645858765,
-0.17944073677062988,
-0.054095201194286346,
-0.56252121925354,
-0.11298805475234985,
-0.7283713221549988,
-0.44661062955856323,
-0.6275414228439331,
0.016485754400491714,
-0.43691286444664,
-0.5772348046302795,
-0.10587125271558762,
0.052148494869470596,
0.4281701445579529,
0.8279521465301514,
-0.28796419501304626,
0.15051013231277466,
-0.6970473527908325,
0.3187839090824127,
0.23503799736499786,
-0.0931357741355896,
0.0320243239402771,
-0.501338541507721,
-0.39941534399986267,
-0.07827915251255035,
-0.5631154179573059,
-0.6687464714050293,
0.6089171171188354,
0.0927865281701088,
0.6103569269180298,
0.29815348982810974,
-0.2150915414094925,
0.012971705757081509,
-0.5546988248825073,
0.6843059062957764,
0.34783443808555603,
-0.8036338090896606,
0.7367726564407349,
-0.3997527062892914,
0.2678638994693756,
0.5891162157058716,
0.6269738674163818,
-0.5717383027076721,
0.04796086996793747,
-1.122885823249817,
-1.0089795589447021,
0.13128484785556793,
0.3605135381221771,
0.24067120254039764,
-0.2388753443956375,
0.45005112886428833,
0.3140316307544708,
0.49593353271484375,
-0.20034073293209076,
-0.16244281828403473,
-0.2509162724018097,
-0.14041277766227722,
-0.2244684249162674,
0.2763247489929199,
-0.32637345790863037,
-0.3759709596633911,
0.7045930027961731,
-0.3452354073524475,
0.6069931387901306,
0.11280378699302673,
-0.13009081780910492,
0.2756185233592987,
0.15209917724132538,
0.2668106257915497,
0.9093524217605591,
0.24910332262516022,
0.2506208121776581,
-0.04028391093015671,
-0.4343489110469818,
0.2490566521883011,
0.2460903525352478,
-0.33525022864341736,
0.21798698604106903,
0.18567775189876556,
0.48610082268714905,
0.14805355668067932,
-0.48355910181999207,
0.27336233854293823,
0.06175050511956215,
-0.5428234934806824,
-0.675529420375824,
-0.10620864480733871,
0.040973808616399765,
0.04201501980423927,
0.36954569816589355,
0.01573755405843258,
0.23391716182231903,
-0.7117515206336975,
0.6259894371032715,
0.32435163855552673,
-0.2164210081100464,
-0.43638360500335693,
0.47872650623321533,
0.45452880859375,
-0.1512826532125473,
0.014267044141888618,
-0.8118810653686523,
-0.29364755749702454,
0.6512507200241089,
0.4094393849372864,
0.9081921577453613,
-0.16356021165847778,
0.5352320671081543,
0.5654413104057312,
0.3118969798088074,
-0.0720910131931305,
0.4482562839984894,
0.04830438643693924,
-1.1113011837005615,
-0.07890689373016357,
-0.6851531863212585,
-0.09688052535057068,
-0.060342054814100266,
-0.20531097054481506,
0.7718686461448669,
-0.42860764265060425,
-0.36668357253074646,
0.20984168350696564,
0.12543876469135284,
-0.8686316013336182,
0.2775654196739197,
0.18004415929317474,
1.0716760158538818,
-0.9770596623420715,
0.6187963485717773,
0.9238523840904236,
-0.5506784915924072,
-0.4084160625934601,
0.11013136059045792,
0.19905813038349152,
-0.942888617515564,
0.716484546661377,
-0.22322513163089752,
-0.01730315014719963,
0.237656369805336,
-0.39720579981803894,
-1.376441478729248,
0.9352449178695679,
-0.6281613111495972,
-0.31088918447494507,
-0.2025882452726364,
-0.32927101850509644,
0.4721148610115051,
-0.8948630094528198,
0.17996281385421753,
0.7889650464057922,
0.34669843316078186,
0.16916775703430176,
-0.850355863571167,
-0.2856002151966095,
-0.28435376286506653,
0.27836769819259644,
0.17424803972244263,
-0.2932974398136139,
0.7345712780952454,
-0.21045051515102386,
-0.3842645287513733,
0.20029333233833313,
0.9436979293823242,
0.014531346037983894,
0.16497215628623962,
0.40479758381843567,
0.5609307885169983,
0.6906789541244507,
0.11757289618253708,
0.4713546633720398,
-0.5673303604125977,
0.23513253033161163,
0.7748740911483765,
-0.05954160913825035,
0.5383523106575012,
0.26609739661216736,
-0.2226957231760025,
0.6988546848297119,
0.9416085481643677,
-0.016524644568562508,
0.6000431776046753,
0.44214195013046265,
-0.3247246742248535,
0.22033153474330902,
-0.290544718503952,
-0.16977454721927643,
0.7115380167961121,
0.9905735850334167,
-0.34816235303878784,
-0.32639434933662415,
-0.017021920531988144,
-0.013010229915380478,
0.23039065301418304,
-0.37532612681388855,
0.8787058591842651,
0.12694232165813446,
-0.555065393447876,
0.3541191816329956,
0.3553641736507416,
0.7076834440231323,
-0.33187010884284973,
0.09306392073631287,
0.19531002640724182,
-0.34684592485427856,
-0.04435153678059578,
-0.4740574061870575,
0.32030442357063293,
-0.17876721918582916,
0.324566513299942,
0.2625497281551361,
0.5098577737808228,
-0.02449568174779415,
-0.8499822616577148,
0.12590964138507843,
1.3707008361816406,
0.09218744933605194,
0.4009873569011688,
-0.788864254951477,
-0.37216463685035706,
-0.47623834013938904,
0.34348466992378235,
-0.1460205465555191,
0.8010881543159485,
-0.26275232434272766,
0.3004487156867981,
0.29963418841362,
0.13671709597110748,
-0.030596408993005753,
0.034114498645067215,
0.7715670466423035,
-0.7953852415084839,
-0.7659928202629089,
-0.5964561700820923,
0.2938918471336365,
-0.07430677115917206,
-0.3816932141780853,
0.580830454826355,
0.33439016342163086,
0.7567256689071655,
0.2993370592594147,
1.3219186067581177,
-0.4486124515533447,
0.7717717289924622,
-0.22270312905311584,
0.3670332133769989,
-0.3260316252708435,
0.07126246392726898,
-0.4452361464500427,
-0.7319676876068115,
-0.2136489599943161,
0.56918865442276,
0.02346201241016388,
0.20930664241313934,
1.1277214288711548,
0.571404755115509,
0.06053797900676727,
0.23727695643901825,
-0.17788666486740112,
-0.049477748572826385,
0.05348046496510506,
-0.01820012927055359,
0.7388260960578918,
-0.30895403027534485,
-0.1681460440158844,
-0.42077165842056274,
-0.621331512928009,
-0.04581913724541664,
-0.9670352339744568,
-0.6452397108078003,
-0.9001791477203369,
-0.328654021024704,
-0.3357914686203003,
0.12888135015964508,
1.036516547203064,
0.5081796050071716,
-0.738094687461853,
-0.500848650932312,
-0.4963241517543793,
-0.2108686864376068,
-0.2739417850971222,
-0.25618600845336914,
0.2753537893295288,
-0.7997533082962036,
-0.5545942783355713,
0.2200794667005539,
0.010659294202923775,
0.13431474566459656,
-0.6604806184768677,
0.36597320437431335,
-0.4783537983894348,
0.377933144569397,
0.6595794558525085,
0.23370791971683502,
-0.3756251335144043,
-0.08047587424516678,
0.09700058400630951,
0.3416641354560852,
0.12506435811519623,
1.023270606994629,
-0.9431177973747253,
0.6610680818557739,
0.20940124988555908,
0.741369366645813,
0.051431722939014435,
-0.3154023587703705,
0.6325159072875977,
-0.6977730393409729,
0.41604605317115784,
0.3950681984424591,
0.19841940701007843,
0.4247666001319885,
-0.15313279628753662,
0.6765885949134827,
0.582606852054596,
-0.10191608965396881,
-0.30780550837516785,
0.2643345594406128,
-0.35153383016586304,
-0.5822295546531677,
0.9960190057754517,
0.2736871540546417,
-0.1408120095729828,
-0.3964773118495941,
0.32494375109672546,
0.2978367209434509,
-0.4914480447769165,
0.966885507106781,
0.7867103815078735,
-0.42411208152770996,
0.19078630208969116,
-0.8821468949317932,
0.6002840399742126,
-0.07492223381996155,
-0.7406688332557678,
-0.3063870966434479,
-0.01059640385210514,
0.27830374240875244,
0.783451497554779,
0.4492820203304291,
-0.43914011120796204,
0.08965248614549637,
0.15517690777778625,
0.4516730308532715,
0.369124174118042,
-0.4782755970954895,
-0.07414855062961578,
0.1149955615401268,
0.32914236187934875,
-0.1210041418671608
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10252v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10252v2
|
AutoSurvey: Large Language Models Can Automatically Write Surveys
| 2024-06-10T12:56:06 | 2024-06-18T02:11:31 |
Yidong Wang, Qi Guo, Wenjin Yao, Hongbo Zhang, Xin Zhang, Zhen Wu, Meishan Zhang, Xinyu Dai, Min Zhang, Qingsong Wen, Wei Ye, Shikun Zhang, Yue Zhang
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
This paper introduces AutoSurvey, a speedy and well-organized methodology for
automating the creation of comprehensive literature surveys in rapidly evolving
fields like artificial intelligence. Traditional survey paper creation faces
challenges due to the vast volume and complexity of information, prompting the
need for efficient survey methods. While large language models (LLMs) offer
promise in automating this process, challenges such as context window
limitations, parametric knowledge constraints, and the lack of evaluation
benchmarks remain. AutoSurvey addresses these challenges through a systematic
approach that involves initial retrieval and outline generation, subsection
drafting by specialized LLMs, integration and refinement, and rigorous
evaluation and iteration. Our contributions include a comprehensive solution to
the survey problem, a reliable evaluation method, and experimental validation
demonstrating AutoSurvey's effectiveness.We open our resources at
\url{https://github.com/AutoSurveys/AutoSurvey}.
|
[
-0.4207702875137329,
-0.7493704557418823,
0.5632046461105347,
0.1539248675107956,
0.19556666910648346,
0.2708435356616974,
-0.15693426132202148,
-0.2768678665161133,
0.22061334550380707,
0.581362247467041,
-0.5986452102661133,
-0.6634328961372375,
-0.27284184098243713,
0.11917769908905029,
-0.8939147591590881,
1.0881363153457642,
0.05024799332022667,
-0.26539528369903564,
-0.5397876501083374,
0.07281074672937393,
0.23360541462898254,
-0.3085049092769623,
-0.8019111752510071,
-0.1130719929933548,
0.4323260486125946,
0.20861732959747314,
0.5768800377845764,
0.5783593654632568,
0.3869720697402954,
0.45428231358528137,
0.2865500748157501,
0.48784324526786804,
-0.43233218789100647,
0.5397894382476807,
0.0287482887506485,
-0.3063816428184509,
-0.4939049780368805,
0.057952601462602615,
0.4933147728443146,
0.8621103763580322,
-0.27896255254745483,
0.52278071641922,
0.06408458203077316,
0.5474605560302734,
-0.599434494972229,
0.010880929417908192,
-0.5877115726470947,
-0.07644802331924438,
-0.1230931207537651,
-0.1520315706729889,
-0.16469262540340424,
-0.6506009101867676,
0.10039197653532028,
-0.47634539008140564,
0.23241189122200012,
0.19885282218456268,
0.5853164792060852,
0.44079113006591797,
-0.36648982763290405,
-0.5003048181533813,
-0.9508274793624878,
0.8113191723823547,
-0.6930346488952637,
0.08389802277088165,
0.47055521607398987,
0.4122954308986664,
-0.22520744800567627,
-0.8581124544143677,
-0.3832419514656067,
-0.6647242903709412,
-0.10644641518592834,
0.12209130078554153,
-0.04610098898410797,
0.0005970402271486819,
0.21714825928211212,
0.43083178997039795,
-0.6281419992446899,
0.09899790585041046,
-0.31149527430534363,
-0.10077362507581711,
1.2397128343582153,
0.7558426856994629,
0.32591718435287476,
-0.27208825945854187,
0.1420125961303711,
0.33870217204093933,
-0.5706077218055725,
0.030299531295895576,
0.540611207485199,
-0.16788868606090546,
0.1897570937871933,
0.5981836318969727,
-0.4907139837741852,
0.9061210751533508,
0.0336768738925457,
-0.10771463066339493,
-0.04819682985544205,
-0.4123349189758301,
-0.3237748146057129,
-0.3187086582183838,
1.14262855052948,
0.11169877648353577,
0.019106285646557808,
0.18822792172431946,
-0.45286786556243896,
-0.4038406312465668,
0.27660995721817017,
-0.3990914225578308,
-0.6033293008804321,
0.4255047142505646,
-0.7042537927627563,
-0.4106154143810272,
-0.2247575968503952,
-0.5976555943489075,
-0.5621338486671448,
-0.6195785403251648,
0.14140158891677856,
-0.1948050558567047,
-0.3792046308517456,
-0.10640251636505127,
0.08911110460758209,
0.2044382393360138,
0.521858274936676,
-0.5778822302818298,
0.37088730931282043,
0.4992799162864685,
0.5759522914886475,
-0.30284327268600464,
-0.27534836530685425,
-0.3117483854293823,
0.22651907801628113,
-0.3889659345149994,
1.112064003944397,
-0.3686523139476776,
-0.503828763961792,
0.0539986789226532,
-0.20089684426784515,
0.0674506425857544,
-0.39952582120895386,
0.06436429917812347,
-0.2861917316913605,
0.5693584084510803,
0.11978881061077118,
-0.5043298602104187,
0.1449919044971466,
0.362322062253952,
-0.7191159725189209,
1.3376188278198242,
0.3225399851799011,
-0.5752492547035217,
0.0985633060336113,
-0.6927176117897034,
-0.412008672952652,
0.14392773807048798,
-0.21378065645694733,
-0.4151492416858673,
0.1654817759990692,
0.26334571838378906,
0.3174162805080414,
-0.6047607660293579,
0.3492697775363922,
-0.1825026571750641,
-0.12105043232440948,
0.39831939339637756,
-0.2644370198249817,
1.2755672931671143,
0.5341358184814453,
-0.3932850956916809,
0.1834055781364441,
-0.6153578162193298,
0.1295931339263916,
-0.14812961220741272,
-0.14952392876148224,
-0.5103635787963867,
0.1791275441646576,
0.16652601957321167,
-0.03208101540803909,
0.395211786031723,
-0.5049899816513062,
0.511146605014801,
-0.4057755768299103,
0.23961976170539856,
0.4430138170719147,
-0.09152001887559891,
0.26094287633895874,
-0.39602264761924744,
0.946040689945221,
-0.4997911751270294,
0.3434099555015564,
-0.2507189214229584,
0.027500037103891373,
-0.8525590300559998,
-0.40224140882492065,
0.5470930337905884,
0.5936644673347473,
-0.7747825384140015,
0.7630788087844849,
-0.09878966957330704,
-1.0832914113998413,
-0.31905198097229004,
0.1317996084690094,
0.19036605954170227,
0.3395776152610779,
-0.01574532501399517,
-0.3081255853176117,
-0.5939041972160339,
-0.8252512216567993,
-0.29921725392341614,
-0.46013715863227844,
-0.06812077760696411,
0.17994582653045654,
0.48094087839126587,
-0.22559335827827454,
1.0990740060806274,
-0.8518427610397339,
-0.4096895754337311,
-0.3888471722602844,
0.5999623537063599,
-0.02347993291914463,
0.2742842733860016,
0.6159261465072632,
-0.41055217385292053,
-0.5880410075187683,
-0.42234042286872864,
-0.8168602585792542,
-0.6951629519462585,
-0.20858685672283173,
-0.1610526144504547,
0.4204305410385132,
0.9373888969421387,
-0.5766083598136902,
0.28405511379241943,
0.3929365873336792,
-0.1970292329788208,
0.5563883781433105,
-0.1456189602613449,
0.08999726921319962,
-0.9265919327735901,
0.3370612859725952,
0.04804783686995506,
-0.1890331655740738,
-0.28126078844070435,
-0.09286224842071533,
-0.2580021023750305,
-0.09709318727254868,
-0.013373702764511108,
0.6407365202903748,
-0.8121809363365173,
-0.04695490002632141,
-0.42936909198760986,
-0.13760709762573242,
-0.06390824913978577,
-0.07680239528417587,
-0.062146082520484924,
0.5193122029304504,
0.29556798934936523,
-0.7760571241378784,
0.7264896631240845,
0.2322378307580948,
-0.3901984691619873,
0.6764659285545349,
-0.6833085417747498,
-0.20116524398326874,
-0.3527173697948456,
0.5833207964897156,
-1.4274853467941284,
-0.3824557065963745,
0.14607416093349457,
-0.6062524914741516,
-0.02188938856124878,
0.133602112531662,
-0.42251554131507874,
-0.5359746217727661,
-0.34022122621536255,
0.45562291145324707,
0.6535065770149231,
-0.0569416806101799,
0.8356580138206482,
0.8334559798240662,
-0.7601580619812012,
-0.45365267992019653,
-0.4597856104373932,
0.3352298140525818,
-0.13708087801933289,
-0.22897528111934662,
0.036566030234098434,
-0.14051489531993866,
-0.3942975103855133,
0.03146032616496086,
0.37804585695266724,
-0.29596757888793945,
-0.07476074993610382,
0.02380487322807312,
0.24496658146381378,
0.19485367834568024,
0.15656885504722595,
-0.011565949767827988,
-0.007061363663524389,
0.46923789381980896,
-0.25819817185401917,
0.48687154054641724,
0.22897382080554962,
-0.6463695764541626,
-0.23317158222198486,
0.40310031175613403,
0.7663919925689697,
-0.476350337266922,
-0.1445026993751526,
0.524621844291687,
-0.1939564198255539,
-0.497158020734787,
-0.8515408039093018,
0.04106980189681053,
-0.4814833402633667,
0.33084020018577576,
-0.17043738067150116,
-0.5141322612762451,
0.3283182680606842,
-0.14237451553344727,
0.5055086016654968,
0.6753082871437073,
0.77532559633255,
-0.2158747762441635,
1.1410883665084839,
0.6881300806999207,
-0.32221952080726624,
0.1574939489364624,
-0.2508823573589325,
0.32203689217567444,
-0.6113719940185547,
-0.3885119557380676,
-0.9827231168746948,
-0.19069071114063263,
-0.25572022795677185,
-0.1776302605867386,
0.7346590161323547,
-0.7332310676574707,
-0.09929399937391281,
-0.049104105681180954,
-0.7621982097625732,
0.25839295983314514,
0.6672462821006775,
-0.4935503900051117,
0.5784595608711243,
0.20518586039543152,
0.12779660522937775,
-0.08048799633979797,
-0.7245985865592957,
-0.367021381855011,
1.121706247329712,
0.20476974546909332,
1.0016158819198608,
-0.22995659708976746,
0.876392126083374,
0.42858776450157166,
0.5456608533859253,
-0.7595093846321106,
0.6865993738174438,
-0.003887610975652933,
-0.6529698371887207,
-0.6986590623855591,
-0.047699667513370514,
-1.1343592405319214,
0.02710603177547455,
-0.049594078212976456,
-0.0874980166554451,
0.04582221806049347,
0.2230922281742096,
-0.7244191765785217,
0.06297653913497925,
-0.06251747161149979,
0.30118033289909363,
-0.5493562817573547,
-0.25395193696022034,
-0.16313190758228302,
-0.3365229666233063,
0.49567529559135437,
-0.14784011244773865,
0.3621789515018463,
-0.09085114300251007,
-0.20201195776462555,
0.7159940004348755,
-0.490132212638855,
0.857940673828125,
-0.29827213287353516,
-0.4661865532398224,
0.6068013906478882,
0.2815490961074829,
0.1960095465183258,
0.13414296507835388,
-0.16734474897384644,
-0.2957312762737274,
0.1977902203798294,
-0.17959477007389069,
-0.47737598419189453,
0.4808858335018158,
-0.5633184313774109,
-0.2606694996356964,
-0.7351294159889221,
-0.6890396475791931,
-0.2870083749294281,
0.0759490430355072,
0.20869755744934082,
0.46782103180885315,
-0.5020556449890137,
-0.13291463255882263,
0.7719413638114929,
-0.48290422558784485,
0.4689024090766907,
0.8594591617584229,
-0.5769979953765869,
-0.38286906480789185,
0.7436458468437195,
0.22121624648571014,
-0.2023768275976181,
-0.0562584325671196,
-0.19536720216274261,
-0.3965417742729187,
-0.5927071571350098,
-0.5235862135887146,
0.24082863330841064,
-0.36220696568489075,
-0.29964450001716614,
-0.8062111139297485,
-0.3664987087249756,
-0.5191569328308105,
-0.10569827258586884,
-0.3855063319206238,
-0.3197034001350403,
0.1462564319372177,
0.30052974820137024,
0.313626766204834,
1.0479816198349,
-0.14455394446849823,
0.04096677526831627,
-0.7539048194885254,
0.4811328947544098,
0.32354915142059326,
0.19175037741661072,
0.0278876181691885,
-0.33681586384773254,
-0.2302662879228592,
-0.23771601915359497,
0.08860220015048981,
-0.4907601475715637,
0.6199408173561096,
0.05305040627717972,
0.6601322889328003,
0.12027288973331451,
0.18883784115314484,
0.6351801753044128,
-0.31201791763305664,
0.9754838347434998,
-0.19853444397449493,
-0.8188844919204712,
0.4256865382194519,
-0.7114773988723755,
0.613088071346283,
1.0381454229354858,
0.6620266437530518,
-0.5207046270370483,
-0.768773078918457,
-0.5940942764282227,
-1.1874977350234985,
0.34457921981811523,
-0.1155802384018898,
0.15311284363269806,
0.056025534868240356,
0.1921602189540863,
0.18927936255931854,
0.4888080656528473,
-0.5281361937522888,
0.03611145541071892,
0.05188574641942978,
-0.49227258563041687,
0.017819546163082123,
-0.34713274240493774,
-0.37947630882263184,
-0.5552234649658203,
0.7059011459350586,
-0.0555102564394474,
0.26922526955604553,
0.31650635600090027,
-0.25834015011787415,
-0.05478766933083534,
-0.007559736259281635,
0.4003561735153198,
0.8410144448280334,
0.11641601473093033,
0.003604360157623887,
0.17407068610191345,
-0.3651213049888611,
0.2999274432659149,
0.2678239941596985,
-0.5678899884223938,
0.2713373303413391,
0.35213524103164673,
0.10899695008993149,
-0.25004759430885315,
-0.8232594728469849,
0.4032343924045563,
-0.14252528548240662,
-0.48519188165664673,
-1.2607816457748413,
0.06916608661413193,
0.014621234498918056,
-0.28146660327911377,
0.6736952066421509,
-0.483476847410202,
0.4839530289173126,
-0.4028792381286621,
-0.05655204504728317,
0.6963433623313904,
-0.13803143799304962,
0.1918870359659195,
0.5596243739128113,
0.28945794701576233,
-0.0444817952811718,
0.8100442290306091,
-0.27416762709617615,
-0.2076101452112198,
0.8457136750221252,
0.08552361279726028,
1.037006139755249,
-0.3838161826133728,
0.25531134009361267,
0.3490632176399231,
0.49615606665611267,
-0.0912872701883316,
0.4506845772266388,
0.04285937175154686,
-0.08595884591341019,
-0.6543582677841187,
-0.8026659488677979,
-0.4089488387107849,
0.3613344728946686,
-0.43836745619773865,
0.1438821256160736,
-0.33774101734161377,
0.0694337710738182,
-0.17524035274982452,
-0.04391651228070259,
-0.41597095131874084,
0.44880411028862,
0.05726237967610359,
0.868104100227356,
-0.9452550411224365,
0.48392778635025024,
0.9894694685935974,
-0.22302544116973877,
-0.7044694423675537,
-0.03499549999833107,
0.11916085332632065,
-0.46255165338516235,
0.5712876915931702,
-0.23967042565345764,
-0.3764515221118927,
0.15205347537994385,
-0.7065629363059998,
-1.2247872352600098,
0.9602676033973694,
-0.25592172145843506,
-0.5493232607841492,
-0.0792170986533165,
0.29501691460609436,
0.7670590281486511,
-0.4962422251701355,
0.7785592675209045,
0.5367899537086487,
0.7027812004089355,
-0.3102607727050781,
-1.0685882568359375,
0.020382994785904884,
-0.44379034638404846,
0.12190570682287216,
0.09021274745464325,
-0.6981724500656128,
0.7650901675224304,
0.37676990032196045,
0.1136799305677414,
0.29255518317222595,
0.8100091218948364,
0.05066414549946785,
0.33940601348876953,
0.8300269842147827,
0.44852349162101746,
0.7489742040634155,
0.030121881514787674,
0.8125753998756409,
-0.5447837710380554,
0.05686139687895775,
0.8683599829673767,
-0.4985125958919525,
0.33724281191825867,
-0.06643609702587128,
-0.1891905665397644,
0.6329182386398315,
0.5619882345199585,
-0.34831714630126953,
0.053196247667074203,
0.5396217703819275,
-0.30766862630844116,
-0.1563704013824463,
-0.14316338300704956,
-0.22885805368423462,
0.8031947612762451,
0.3967979848384857,
-0.30529481172561646,
-0.35504621267318726,
0.1093270555138588,
0.0552801750600338,
0.3219602108001709,
-0.4940044581890106,
0.8991342186927795,
-0.08576066792011261,
-1.2985584735870361,
0.5028680562973022,
0.09045761078596115,
0.6448045969009399,
-0.7192402482032776,
0.1163019984960556,
-0.40571141242980957,
-0.11712896823883057,
-0.5272468328475952,
-0.547014057636261,
0.5942336320877075,
0.011203113943338394,
0.090306855738163,
-0.41476497054100037,
0.839920699596405,
-0.5538062453269958,
-0.6816521286964417,
-0.2262767255306244,
0.8692406415939331,
0.30453041195869446,
0.23789505660533905,
-0.6945384740829468,
0.07785820960998535,
-0.018260177224874496,
-0.5109348893165588,
0.0884534940123558,
0.31539127230644226,
-0.24415792524814606,
0.8015904426574707,
0.49553996324539185,
0.33643805980682373,
-0.12939074635505676,
0.0038963290862739086,
0.6588209271430969,
-0.728754997253418,
-0.47323381900787354,
-0.7798221707344055,
0.5292388200759888,
-0.4247514009475708,
-0.1663874238729477,
0.9784675240516663,
0.9064520597457886,
0.5903152227401733,
-0.13481329381465912,
1.4878703355789185,
-0.40593281388282776,
1.0394420623779297,
-0.24179883301258087,
1.0077788829803467,
-0.5101040601730347,
0.15280835330486298,
-0.16003482043743134,
-0.9633958339691162,
-0.2613644599914551,
0.42863723635673523,
-0.2642589509487152,
0.09856235235929489,
0.7681856155395508,
0.8200346231460571,
-0.08803575485944748,
-0.41347113251686096,
-0.1523948311805725,
0.12061022967100143,
0.21630486845970154,
0.4133528172969818,
1.0254162549972534,
0.09742777049541473,
0.5896418690681458,
-0.050170090049505234,
-0.320700466632843,
-0.14316143095493317,
-0.8660005331039429,
-0.9029141664505005,
-0.6021720170974731,
-0.5024310350418091,
-0.2546650469303131,
-0.027408070862293243,
0.8297474980354309,
0.48119693994522095,
-0.5285625457763672,
-0.7473670244216919,
0.023398857563734055,
-0.3141305148601532,
-0.005277448799461126,
-0.2858867645263672,
0.3339889943599701,
-0.5694402456283569,
-1.0389119386672974,
0.2075025737285614,
0.13899648189544678,
-0.20280437171459198,
-0.9784460663795471,
0.3873707950115204,
-0.063080333173275,
0.18280808627605438,
0.5024333000183105,
0.5612059235572815,
-0.46291786432266235,
0.2760583460330963,
-0.004737435840070248,
-0.4326481521129608,
-0.44532346725463867,
1.014461874961853,
-1.0430397987365723,
0.18833717703819275,
0.7615755200386047,
0.6903519034385681,
0.4103364944458008,
0.15661825239658356,
0.9211501479148865,
-0.3073348104953766,
-0.019359180703759193,
0.4604824483394623,
-0.001589435152709484,
0.2817454934120178,
-0.468185693025589,
0.6579130291938782,
-0.13809549808502197,
-0.8061968088150024,
-0.9295145273208618,
0.3508380949497223,
-0.6312987208366394,
-0.5428754687309265,
1.1038404703140259,
0.25446927547454834,
-0.10501108318567276,
-0.5345752835273743,
-0.4107329249382019,
0.11274563521146774,
-0.06908059120178223,
1.278263807296753,
0.5957080125808716,
-0.46338513493537903,
0.03698146715760231,
-0.5168185234069824,
0.8913323283195496,
0.6015344858169556,
-1.1089508533477783,
0.03570235148072243,
0.9864075183868408,
0.3611721396446228,
-0.046755362302064896,
1.224932312965393,
-0.1585686057806015,
0.22345104813575745,
-0.3462352454662323,
0.20818102359771729,
-0.3070593476295471,
-0.17913202941417694,
-0.2228241115808487,
0.47214508056640625,
0.3089088499546051,
0.4896433353424072
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.06220v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.06220v1
|
Label-Looping: Highly Efficient Decoding for Transducers
| 2024-06-10T12:34:38 | 2024-06-10T12:34:38 |
Vladimir Bataev, Hainan Xu, Daniel Galvez, Vitaly Lavrukhin, Boris Ginsburg
|
eess.AS
|
eess.AS, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SD
|
This paper introduces a highly efficient greedy decoding algorithm for
Transducer inference. We propose a novel data structure using CUDA tensors to
represent partial hypotheses in a batch that supports parallelized hypothesis
manipulations. During decoding, our algorithm maximizes GPU parallelism by
adopting a nested-loop design, where the inner loop consumes all blank
predictions, while non-blank predictions are handled in the outer loop. Our
algorithm is general-purpose and can work with both conventional Transducers
and Token-and-Duration Transducers. Experiments show that the label-looping
algorithm can bring a speedup up to 2.0X compared to conventional batched
decoding algorithms when using batch size 32, and can be combined with other
compiler or GPU call-related techniques to bring more speedup. We will
open-source our implementation to benefit the research community.
|
[
-0.36535608768463135,
-0.6082630753517151,
0.654914379119873,
0.09309018403291702,
-0.7484878301620483,
0.15232254564762115,
-0.17105789482593536,
-0.37516504526138306,
-0.05028161033987999,
0.11995012313127518,
-0.16799908876419067,
-0.5158221125602722,
-0.7376243472099304,
-0.11485350877046585,
-0.07692352682352066,
0.6780619621276855,
0.04531589895486832,
0.029390156269073486,
0.021876543760299683,
-0.23083443939685822,
-0.33993834257125854,
-0.39143452048301697,
-0.6233121156692505,
-0.5211648941040039,
0.5746544599533081,
0.10650798678398132,
0.46323367953300476,
1.1918387413024902,
0.2340829223394394,
0.142499178647995,
-0.23332668840885162,
0.22276435792446136,
-0.35863304138183594,
0.3079591989517212,
0.08875014632940292,
-0.4107497036457062,
-0.340225487947464,
0.05274326354265213,
0.7192091941833496,
0.5612342953681946,
-0.13753223419189453,
0.25185829401016235,
-0.2406807541847229,
0.07669588923454285,
-0.884617269039154,
0.48419323563575745,
-0.2018256038427353,
0.029608573764562607,
-0.4757111370563507,
-0.5809324979782104,
-0.7733837366104126,
-0.12154582887887955,
-0.2574968636035919,
-0.8986815810203552,
0.3274824023246765,
0.413218230009079,
0.52676922082901,
0.3616402745246887,
-0.11800366640090942,
-0.32565760612487793,
-0.6606441736221313,
0.7301534414291382,
-0.4961579144001007,
0.65554279088974,
0.3415278494358063,
0.2240297943353653,
0.08514538407325745,
-0.9547380805015564,
-0.27215519547462463,
0.07133772224187851,
-0.01080305129289627,
0.1439112424850464,
-0.21799784898757935,
0.14186948537826538,
0.6214337944984436,
0.6368891000747681,
-0.4503619074821472,
0.021684780716896057,
-0.390446275472641,
-0.09334705024957657,
0.13416193425655365,
0.1667935997247696,
0.0021000003907829523,
0.3479503095149994,
-0.19309155642986298,
-0.27998268604278564,
-0.4370748698711395,
-0.1234142854809761,
0.4279072880744934,
0.1616741418838501,
-0.22020559012889862,
0.3588615953922272,
0.23839929699897766,
0.990790843963623,
-0.15786316990852356,
-0.11457791179418564,
0.19878160953521729,
-0.054293837398290634,
-0.39389562606811523,
0.5293053984642029,
0.6509740352630615,
0.02107432670891285,
-0.17781388759613037,
-0.6626771092414856,
-0.02564399316906929,
0.6186618804931641,
0.10893447697162628,
-0.5748353004455566,
-0.15990646183490753,
0.18979418277740479,
-0.34511205554008484,
-0.032166000455617905,
0.042521119117736816,
-0.6647869944572449,
-0.33295345306396484,
-0.17005771398544312,
0.1415577232837677,
-0.18990112841129303,
-0.2501410245895386,
0.31223180890083313,
-0.5005593299865723,
0.21500462293624878,
-0.4021480977535248,
-0.8149869441986084,
0.48470062017440796,
0.9951693415641785,
1.0146896839141846,
-0.1377280056476593,
-0.11606230586767197,
-1.0003565549850464,
0.5846690535545349,
-0.20160134136676788,
0.8185418844223022,
-0.7226406931877136,
-0.6507632732391357,
-0.6905766725540161,
-0.12926478683948517,
-0.06034831330180168,
-0.47480201721191406,
0.8766089081764221,
-0.5923524498939514,
-0.41794702410697937,
-0.4420894384384155,
-0.6514344811439514,
-0.1532023400068283,
0.13275626301765442,
-0.9556726217269897,
0.7198554277420044,
0.2683759033679962,
-0.9119224548339844,
0.28093111515045166,
-0.5837779641151428,
-0.650150716304779,
0.03881685808300972,
0.1588335782289505,
-0.8276262879371643,
0.1661279946565628,
0.5179969072341919,
-0.004204325843602419,
-0.62043297290802,
0.08208126574754715,
-0.3529590964317322,
-0.8672651648521423,
0.0879141241312027,
-0.2749131917953491,
0.8262217044830322,
0.6646703481674194,
-0.6308794021606445,
-0.019902348518371582,
-0.4228150248527527,
-0.06819500029087067,
-0.09119892865419388,
-0.28054967522621155,
-0.5127825140953064,
-0.2795015573501587,
-0.2180587351322174,
-0.4275413155555725,
-0.40776151418685913,
-0.809883713722229,
0.5622380375862122,
-0.05269699543714523,
0.52146315574646,
0.7207054495811462,
-0.25303012132644653,
0.39531588554382324,
-0.13513706624507904,
0.5634326934814453,
0.22896413505077362,
0.106474868953228,
-0.22605405747890472,
-0.6550390124320984,
-0.6440814137458801,
-0.5054231882095337,
0.3985285460948944,
0.2440468817949295,
-0.44784635305404663,
-0.3553733229637146,
-0.08447568863630295,
-0.46262866258621216,
-0.7807624936103821,
-0.020799918100237846,
0.5611227750778198,
0.6732699275016785,
0.41274115443229675,
-0.09477675706148148,
-0.8003345131874084,
-0.23547235131263733,
-0.5218800902366638,
0.0015278119826689363,
0.07685159891843796,
0.2713249921798706,
0.11025217920541763,
-0.584492027759552,
0.2867913246154785,
-0.7515674233436584,
0.018566759303212166,
0.056433867663145065,
0.1727086752653122,
0.5716989636421204,
0.6067059636116028,
0.20697803795337677,
-0.49399179220199585,
-0.1732892543077469,
0.08421740680932999,
-0.8122646808624268,
0.10176288336515427,
0.03879426047205925,
-0.4429078996181488,
0.2287018746137619,
0.4005514979362488,
-0.6020352244377136,
0.39027029275894165,
0.515457034111023,
-0.40544748306274414,
0.4977553188800812,
-0.3654736876487732,
-0.263536661863327,
-0.628456175327301,
-0.047048598527908325,
0.1554948091506958,
-0.16270241141319275,
-0.3749602437019348,
0.15530233085155487,
0.1734212189912796,
0.13854384422302246,
0.07639626413583755,
0.21590827405452728,
-0.7829369902610779,
-0.22905056178569794,
-0.22641050815582275,
-0.6229925155639648,
-0.07650011777877808,
0.18588630855083466,
0.2376445233821869,
0.8331481218338013,
0.8106510043144226,
-0.6587300300598145,
0.6052268147468567,
-0.028574256226420403,
-0.31581929326057434,
0.14515647292137146,
-0.6451165080070496,
0.5579630136489868,
-0.30314815044403076,
0.375178724527359,
-0.5062605738639832,
0.2007828950881958,
0.26397112011909485,
-0.18451300263404846,
0.2831259071826935,
-0.316424697637558,
-0.06747747957706451,
-0.7302045822143555,
-0.18721356987953186,
0.9086002111434937,
0.6455903649330139,
-0.8818999528884888,
0.7264615893363953,
0.5136637091636658,
0.36893489956855774,
-0.569980800151825,
-0.8534387350082397,
-0.01529022678732872,
-0.24703620374202728,
-0.15022386610507965,
0.10885068029165268,
0.0979587510228157,
-0.12225234508514404,
0.20815452933311462,
-0.2608009874820709,
0.20735719799995422,
-0.11932173371315002,
0.41222646832466125,
0.14206556975841522,
-0.3464334309101105,
-0.41021034121513367,
0.10973447561264038,
-0.5091847777366638,
0.17228926718235016,
-1.0250087976455688,
0.5256425738334656,
-0.3474804759025574,
-0.02400069497525692,
-0.3434528410434723,
0.27862781286239624,
0.6806554198265076,
-0.12290740758180618,
0.35531121492385864,
0.7862268090248108,
-0.37529218196868896,
-0.4462957978248596,
-0.486639142036438,
-0.03527456894516945,
-0.4730221629142761,
-0.2669185996055603,
-0.7285380363464355,
-0.5464752316474915,
0.6211928725242615,
0.038344576954841614,
-0.2937268912792206,
0.17874513566493988,
0.790980339050293,
-0.13192947208881378,
0.6809708476066589,
0.2779175937175751,
-0.2738000750541687,
0.15108096599578857,
-0.9511919021606445,
0.4394685626029968,
-0.935435950756073,
-0.5478775501251221,
-0.398833692073822,
-0.3421882688999176,
-0.47493237257003784,
-0.7275968790054321,
0.3384482264518738,
-0.3186560273170471,
-0.2940494120121002,
0.2713497579097748,
-0.799748957157135,
0.3064831793308258,
1.172932744026184,
0.24555428326129913,
0.2578439712524414,
0.1986839771270752,
-0.14890292286872864,
0.21755847334861755,
-0.7382799983024597,
0.06619000434875488,
0.9947466850280762,
0.07260548323392868,
1.2239307165145874,
-0.4148923456668854,
0.5688842535018921,
0.42427343130111694,
0.5098532438278198,
-0.8090844750404358,
0.14917917549610138,
0.12806576490402222,
-0.38674336671829224,
-0.10034675896167755,
-0.4568416178226471,
-0.8336266279220581,
0.2804451584815979,
0.2824001908302307,
-0.4605342447757721,
0.4307063817977905,
0.33298397064208984,
-0.1269814670085907,
0.8674803972244263,
-0.748816192150116,
0.664271891117096,
0.1597565859556198,
-0.33888307213783264,
0.12961149215698242,
-0.507291853427887,
0.4543789327144623,
0.22032921016216278,
-0.03039241023361683,
0.11542506515979767,
0.26440539956092834,
0.7440173029899597,
-0.4489573538303375,
0.3144572973251343,
-0.5545371174812317,
-0.1693851500749588,
0.5539275407791138,
-0.09288521111011505,
0.5500538349151611,
0.1758095771074295,
-0.38130834698677063,
0.0022193719632923603,
0.0012007278855890036,
-0.6446181535720825,
-0.3612547814846039,
0.680024266242981,
-0.5826309323310852,
-0.22635070979595184,
-0.6796795129776001,
-0.9690229892730713,
-0.22822102904319763,
-0.007088706828653812,
0.5039234757423401,
0.5566790103912354,
0.2971634268760681,
-0.18467646837234497,
0.6284909248352051,
0.2008804976940155,
0.4459173381328583,
-0.009517542086541653,
0.7067371010780334,
-0.49059417843818665,
1.205262303352356,
-0.0521581694483757,
-0.27489930391311646,
0.33992645144462585,
0.2465326339006424,
-0.6698164343833923,
-0.6135603189468384,
-0.31360742449760437,
0.4429638981819153,
-0.39330974221229553,
-0.43555280566215515,
-0.5773025751113892,
0.2153228372335434,
-0.5587774515151978,
-0.15886911749839783,
-0.2971155643463135,
-0.020595097914338112,
-0.15573622286319733,
-0.2682151198387146,
0.16598506271839142,
0.41717424988746643,
-0.37663373351097107,
0.30140843987464905,
-0.6653892397880554,
0.8224236369132996,
0.35287225246429443,
0.5048028230667114,
0.0662027969956398,
-0.19692382216453552,
-0.293234258890152,
0.09298381954431534,
-0.04565532132983208,
-0.6291638612747192,
0.34787121415138245,
-0.1786654144525528,
0.6479544043540955,
0.43163418769836426,
0.3624893128871918,
0.9645119905471802,
0.08275352418422699,
0.2635592818260193,
-0.0007835150463506579,
-1.160118818283081,
0.16838763654232025,
-0.18636728823184967,
0.2874475121498108,
0.12576337158679962,
0.0972517877817154,
-0.36342689394950867,
-0.4767114818096161,
-0.2595224380493164,
-0.6830681562423706,
0.6683430075645447,
0.11851169168949127,
-0.29841744899749756,
0.1811588853597641,
0.19815747439861298,
0.3488035202026367,
-0.09295477718114853,
-0.14398439228534698,
-0.5314626097679138,
-0.34477168321609497,
-0.15556104481220245,
-0.1202864944934845,
-0.5253363251686096,
-0.19344459474086761,
-0.8022634983062744,
0.6837626099586487,
-0.1329682171344757,
0.7299200296401978,
0.12990908324718475,
-0.2851002514362335,
-0.00668098172172904,
0.12444848567247391,
0.5596543550491333,
0.7285868525505066,
-0.4531554877758026,
0.6255435943603516,
0.010661954991519451,
-0.8833372592926025,
0.3007883131504059,
0.22562989592552185,
-0.20534004271030426,
0.1194600984454155,
0.14458809792995453,
1.3436472415924072,
-0.1830037236213684,
-0.23340974748134613,
0.0017637775745242834,
-0.1422271877527237,
-0.028584958985447884,
0.14695048332214355,
-0.19630782306194305,
0.1589042842388153,
0.3498290181159973,
0.39635175466537476,
-0.2616978883743286,
0.26252010464668274,
-0.273908406496048,
-0.02486700564622879,
0.14035442471504211,
0.09200163930654526,
-0.3478105366230011,
1.3400208950042725,
-0.14528106153011322,
0.13359348475933075,
0.8674326539039612,
-0.20992320775985718,
-0.2193673998117447,
0.8244190216064453,
0.9429081082344055,
0.8918646574020386,
-0.18456530570983887,
0.047013889998197556,
0.4248022735118866,
0.224510058760643,
-0.05424864590167999,
0.45996299386024475,
-0.6928648948669434,
-0.481219083070755,
-0.6223940253257751,
-0.7551068067550659,
-0.7660894989967346,
-0.056910011917352676,
-1.0946142673492432,
-0.2207302451133728,
-0.2605193257331848,
-0.22628286480903625,
0.24639050662517548,
-0.14855627715587616,
-0.5886918902397156,
0.321990430355072,
0.5120211839675903,
0.919185996055603,
-0.5009094476699829,
1.1074413061141968,
0.6008780598640442,
0.2841397821903229,
-0.7772662043571472,
-0.501410186290741,
-0.3270089626312256,
-0.7327448129653931,
0.31377169489860535,
0.0898035392165184,
-0.23286885023117065,
0.1671459674835205,
-0.3561166822910309,
-0.4985279440879822,
0.8770677447319031,
0.8782726526260376,
-0.7087268829345703,
-0.25828608870506287,
0.18779870867729187,
0.06502163410186768,
-0.016009505838155746,
0.27850979566574097,
1.2434252500534058,
0.8286997675895691,
0.0012747294967994094,
-0.5212869048118591,
0.27391016483306885,
-0.2377379983663559,
0.09748555719852448,
0.08405608683824539,
-0.31846699118614197,
0.7001803517341614,
-0.5554211735725403,
-0.05146431922912598,
-0.004938909318298101,
0.7223454713821411,
0.57127445936203,
0.73975670337677,
0.5063655972480774,
1.2515558004379272,
0.9734060168266296,
-0.5578159093856812,
1.403511881828308,
-0.3591682016849518,
0.6878271102905273,
0.7146834135055542,
0.25056061148643494,
-0.005783660802990198,
0.5591588616371155,
-0.05165908858180046,
0.30299466848373413,
0.6013442277908325,
-0.12843771278858185,
0.7057656049728394,
0.21924644708633423,
-0.5080472230911255,
-0.2607501745223999,
-0.05629203841090202,
-0.5771051645278931,
0.3403589129447937,
0.563303530216217,
-0.3453057110309601,
-0.1972089409828186,
0.20666737854480743,
-0.056856419891119,
-0.5069751739501953,
-0.4741155803203583,
0.3327574133872986,
0.2784925699234009,
-0.6240858435630798,
1.086539387702942,
0.009300853125751019,
0.7658659815788269,
-0.26437342166900635,
0.043237652629613876,
-0.23427097499370575,
0.3751620054244995,
-0.22650380432605743,
-0.5985696911811829,
0.19360239803791046,
-0.23753756284713745,
-0.14172805845737457,
-0.3934933841228485,
0.54988694190979,
-0.444306343793869,
-0.2917146384716034,
0.17135368287563324,
0.018274949863553047,
0.07065064460039139,
-0.1970258355140686,
-0.11953766644001007,
0.7742753624916077,
-0.37166011333465576,
-0.2985428273677826,
-0.2993844449520111,
0.13077175617218018,
-0.022105248644948006,
0.5233246088027954,
0.6050733923912048,
0.2324894666671753,
0.6539636850357056,
0.04657086357474327,
1.148998498916626,
-1.0119708776474,
-0.8318018913269043,
-0.6588209271430969,
0.1695663034915924,
0.08721009641885757,
-0.04842020943760872,
0.6986769437789917,
0.9986520409584045,
0.9685907363891602,
-0.30063867568969727,
0.8188539147377014,
0.15144816040992737,
-0.05085752159357071,
-0.3891412913799286,
0.39479804039001465,
-0.041325315833091736,
0.011835433542728424,
-0.25103434920310974,
-0.7300475835800171,
-0.2780029773712158,
0.29806074500083923,
-0.22336174547672272,
-0.17154523730278015,
0.6341235041618347,
0.5921494364738464,
-0.36209598183631897,
0.27187415957450867,
0.0918157771229744,
0.17876428365707397,
0.3605600893497467,
0.9148737192153931,
0.5697487592697144,
-0.5460832118988037,
0.44527286291122437,
-0.5862745046615601,
0.05605003610253334,
-0.037324924021959305,
-0.5284005403518677,
-0.6422147750854492,
-0.5259756445884705,
-0.37580421566963196,
-0.6178115010261536,
0.26461198925971985,
0.0330757237970829,
0.8696982860565186,
-0.8246320486068726,
-0.32970911264419556,
-0.3223095238208771,
0.5140368342399597,
-0.6501141786575317,
-0.16291621327400208,
0.49227234721183777,
-0.20448003709316254,
-1.1295040845870972,
0.46561500430107117,
0.21767611801624298,
-0.047722309827804565,
0.15559406578540802,
-0.46280431747436523,
0.14314992725849152,
-0.17699699103832245,
0.5559234023094177,
0.7934936881065369,
-0.3379409909248352,
0.12565460801124573,
-0.1690913438796997,
-0.015674840658903122,
0.15271830558776855,
1.3855462074279785,
-0.9981639385223389,
0.7418563961982727,
0.5759678483009338,
0.809299647808075,
1.4983124732971191,
0.13149045407772064,
0.433489054441452,
-0.3159758746623993,
0.612342894077301,
0.3565097153186798,
0.27144700288772583,
0.14123404026031494,
-0.4418124556541443,
0.5494552850723267,
0.7760938405990601,
-0.06868857890367508,
-1.2793468236923218,
-0.08941980451345444,
-1.448653221130371,
-0.1694319248199463,
1.1797704696655273,
-0.1364690363407135,
-0.764836311340332,
-0.05719517916440964,
0.02719123475253582,
0.728522002696991,
-0.3825168311595917,
0.34116339683532715,
0.2422579973936081,
-0.09188567847013474,
-0.28273317217826843,
-0.10499341040849686,
0.1729472577571869,
0.022853313013911247,
-0.5147826671600342,
-0.03992536664009094,
0.23664282262325287,
0.47248005867004395,
-0.05323696509003639,
0.6624265313148499,
-0.0923963263630867,
0.28535664081573486,
0.4769980311393738,
-0.20539972186088562,
-0.8994748592376709,
-0.24779993295669556,
-0.08257025480270386,
0.280987411737442,
-0.29082679748535156,
-0.7213383316993713
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.07584v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.07584v1
|
BrainChat: Decoding Semantic Information from fMRI using Vision-language Pretrained Models
| 2024-06-10T12:06:15 | 2024-06-10T12:06:15 |
Wanaiu Huang
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Semantic information is vital for human interaction, and decoding it from
brain activity enables non-invasive clinical augmentative and alternative
communication. While there has been significant progress in reconstructing
visual images, few studies have focused on the language aspect. To address this
gap, leveraging the powerful capabilities of the decoder-based vision-language
pretrained model CoCa, this paper proposes BrainChat, a simple yet effective
generative framework aimed at rapidly accomplishing semantic information
decoding tasks from brain activity, including fMRI question answering and fMRI
captioning. BrainChat employs the self-supervised approach of Masked Brain
Modeling to encode sparse fMRI data, obtaining a more compact embedding
representation in the latent space. Subsequently, BrainChat bridges the gap
between modalities by applying contrastive loss, resulting in aligned
representations of fMRI, image, and text embeddings. Furthermore, the fMRI
embeddings are mapped to the generative Brain Decoder via cross-attention
layers, where they guide the generation of textual content about fMRI in a
regressive manner by minimizing caption loss. Empirically, BrainChat exceeds
the performance of existing state-of-the-art methods in the fMRI captioning
task and, for the first time, implements fMRI question answering. Additionally,
BrainChat is highly flexible and can achieve high performance without image
data, making it better suited for real-world scenarios with limited data.
|
[
-0.2277229130268097,
-0.8035908341407776,
0.44812819361686707,
0.33012688159942627,
-0.6000741124153137,
-0.16035303473472595,
-0.055674683302640915,
-0.32350435853004456,
0.5015819072723389,
0.35827603936195374,
-0.8797885179519653,
-0.5140067338943481,
-0.5127223134040833,
-0.12581367790699005,
-0.2789207994937897,
1.0354467630386353,
0.2106069177389145,
0.37838059663772583,
-0.5780836343765259,
0.01726517081260681,
-0.8750406503677368,
-0.46271029114723206,
-0.6750603914260864,
-0.2619173228740692,
0.5400709509849548,
-0.07080139964818954,
0.6009052395820618,
0.2515861690044403,
0.5937637090682983,
0.20886005461215973,
0.16392630338668823,
0.04466632381081581,
-0.42463749647140503,
-0.055691398680210114,
0.09919588267803192,
-0.5566622018814087,
-0.4061669409275055,
-0.40746310353279114,
0.3413507044315338,
0.8973010182380676,
-0.16929806768894196,
-0.3008688986301422,
0.16127897799015045,
0.5325864553451538,
-0.5998474359512329,
0.6606643199920654,
-0.4929271638393402,
0.12971867620944977,
0.01834738813340664,
-0.3548012971878052,
-0.358485609292984,
-0.1045735627412796,
-0.06367900967597961,
-0.6745508313179016,
0.12821543216705322,
0.10932286083698273,
0.8659785985946655,
0.48129189014434814,
-0.15670131146907806,
-0.12742717564105988,
-0.2927889823913574,
0.4946397840976715,
-0.40488919615745544,
0.326474130153656,
0.7542684078216553,
0.39832186698913574,
-0.055922981351614,
-0.884429931640625,
-0.5822768211364746,
0.007179553154855967,
-0.25276926159858704,
0.4264989197254181,
-0.2814517319202423,
0.22010685503482819,
-0.06091482192277908,
0.22864969074726105,
-0.754464864730835,
-0.2799856662750244,
-0.3085564374923706,
-0.3133721351623535,
0.3134554326534271,
0.34984251856803894,
0.661438524723053,
-0.12639659643173218,
-0.34224119782447815,
-0.2544670104980469,
-0.4839218854904175,
-0.4138484001159668,
-0.14573049545288086,
-0.18945609033107758,
-0.2103937417268753,
0.6014206409454346,
-0.2233654111623764,
0.8412692546844482,
-0.14726750552654266,
0.3006727397441864,
0.28479981422424316,
-0.31152111291885376,
-0.12273576855659485,
0.01247447356581688,
0.7269554734230042,
0.7317336201667786,
-0.022645771503448486,
-0.454360693693161,
0.01170325092971325,
0.3512158691883087,
0.2687753140926361,
-0.8336478471755981,
-0.3992811441421509,
0.12088906019926071,
-0.657710075378418,
-0.00141441123560071,
-0.1300029754638672,
-0.5682533383369446,
-0.31839364767074585,
-0.052092138677835464,
0.4793316721916199,
-0.7527100443840027,
-0.4043707847595215,
0.4563829302787781,
-0.13935378193855286,
0.5346245169639587,
0.4571630358695984,
-0.8526216149330139,
0.20209571719169617,
0.3230409324169159,
0.7955883741378784,
-0.22642982006072998,
-0.08475801348686218,
-0.12822145223617554,
0.2373063713312149,
-0.2326885461807251,
0.6464115381240845,
-0.18502582609653473,
-0.12681721150875092,
-0.1899297833442688,
0.13210923969745636,
-0.24323369562625885,
-0.2041313797235489,
0.2704910635948181,
-0.889720618724823,
-0.05446654185652733,
-0.15207278728485107,
-0.6438096165657043,
-0.0792938843369484,
0.27232155203819275,
-0.5964425206184387,
0.2652302384376526,
-0.0053937132470309734,
-1.0383708477020264,
0.05396184325218201,
-1.09998619556427,
-0.6881060600280762,
0.5006179809570312,
-0.37299489974975586,
-0.08120515942573547,
-0.11431369185447693,
0.2436874657869339,
0.5555810332298279,
-0.19305720925331116,
0.1493789702653885,
-0.0988711416721344,
-0.3177505135536194,
0.31195399165153503,
-0.44383034110069275,
0.7897916436195374,
0.40347903966903687,
-0.11720211058855057,
-0.003848404623568058,
-0.5219053030014038,
0.2914523780345917,
0.42973002791404724,
-0.07984565943479538,
-0.4438941478729248,
0.014600536786019802,
0.31134408712387085,
-0.05329389125108719,
0.20535048842430115,
-0.7900766134262085,
-0.25365346670150757,
-0.49849042296409607,
0.8415644764900208,
0.28202202916145325,
-0.10932853072881699,
0.27219727635383606,
-0.11662706732749939,
0.3641546964645386,
0.22840318083763123,
0.0732669085264206,
-0.4553355872631073,
-0.5147091150283813,
-0.7576090097427368,
-0.27424466609954834,
0.37086811661720276,
0.7447665929794312,
-1.2257994413375854,
0.5684247016906738,
-0.6022022366523743,
-0.2049478441476822,
-0.8271559476852417,
-0.34146857261657715,
0.33531275391578674,
0.5070827007293701,
0.4201706647872925,
-0.5209923386573792,
-0.3703429698944092,
-1.0111063718795776,
0.1303858608007431,
-0.02455647476017475,
-0.2561365067958832,
0.16731290519237518,
0.3120066523551941,
-0.4220203161239624,
0.876914918422699,
-0.6717577576637268,
-0.539068877696991,
-0.24988079071044922,
0.29383042454719543,
-0.13894890248775482,
0.6841622591018677,
0.33561357855796814,
-0.8510026931762695,
-0.1745646446943283,
0.09576107561588287,
-1.0780088901519775,
0.2613282799720764,
-0.060090918093919754,
-0.272421270608902,
0.12153823673725128,
0.6450696587562561,
-0.8136069774627686,
0.5659863948822021,
0.5636844635009766,
-0.2584955394268036,
-0.1475285142660141,
-0.19435961544513702,
0.3225076198577881,
-1.042380928993225,
0.14677323400974274,
-0.6779496073722839,
-0.19655518233776093,
-0.3830684721469879,
-0.17701150476932526,
0.06336452066898346,
-0.32705172896385193,
-0.25285834074020386,
0.28336572647094727,
-0.620431125164032,
0.17869465053081512,
-0.2931666076183319,
-0.06872586905956268,
-0.05501799285411835,
0.6899558305740356,
0.32714205980300903,
0.5829577445983887,
0.7381524443626404,
-0.2567261755466461,
0.2505718171596527,
0.547738254070282,
-0.42314743995666504,
0.5296434760093689,
-0.6346912384033203,
0.36349016427993774,
-0.5177385807037354,
0.25323566794395447,
-1.173006296157837,
-0.3049294948577881,
0.37284672260284424,
-0.5922651886940002,
0.27322620153427124,
-0.06251107156276703,
-0.3695325553417206,
-0.09970884025096893,
0.12929470837116241,
0.7401265501976013,
0.5919073820114136,
-0.34289202094078064,
0.729663610458374,
0.5102565884590149,
-0.13758878409862518,
-0.46055954694747925,
-1.205335259437561,
0.3108321726322174,
0.2856782078742981,
-0.924910306930542,
0.46180686354637146,
-0.27952155470848083,
0.366634339094162,
0.22389091551303864,
-0.007751307915896177,
-0.4314059317111969,
-0.28983068466186523,
0.3285519778728485,
0.17252139747142792,
-0.13375049829483032,
0.09014290571212769,
0.19902510941028595,
-0.1440751999616623,
0.24221882224082947,
-0.11710935086011887,
0.6793884038925171,
-0.34491586685180664,
-0.42296040058135986,
-0.46630653738975525,
0.6578646898269653,
0.3647060990333557,
-0.3521415889263153,
0.6500750780105591,
0.6367937922477722,
-0.5152814388275146,
0.10749732702970505,
-0.4401050806045532,
-0.4625307023525238,
-0.4465853273868561,
0.6272348165512085,
-0.5426424741744995,
-0.8723297715187073,
0.25434011220932007,
0.06264201551675797,
-0.33651381731033325,
0.08647622168064117,
0.4347096085548401,
-0.46253272891044617,
0.8850573897361755,
0.6200114488601685,
0.2497086077928543,
0.41246089339256287,
-0.2993777096271515,
0.22711320221424103,
-0.6522654891014099,
-0.31332167983055115,
0.15235529839992523,
-0.03763122484087944,
0.0049276938661932945,
-0.5304524898529053,
0.3571092486381531,
-0.3258873522281647,
0.35693055391311646,
0.29351088404655457,
-0.5117083787918091,
0.6790394186973572,
0.334216445684433,
0.5766599774360657,
0.12074942886829376,
0.1662016361951828,
-0.13490530848503113,
-0.2751951515674591,
-1.0211366415023804,
-0.1119961068034172,
0.7508249878883362,
0.04772866517305374,
1.1145216226577759,
-0.3399624228477478,
0.4640023708343506,
0.18337151408195496,
0.2325240820646286,
-0.8241778016090393,
0.6256311535835266,
0.06710968166589737,
-0.5536491870880127,
-0.1384253054857254,
-0.3441622257232666,
-1.1217478513717651,
0.2818220853805542,
-0.14342857897281647,
-0.27936893701553345,
0.18373453617095947,
0.1725156158208847,
-0.3350520133972168,
0.03735588490962982,
-0.9187250137329102,
1.1779276132583618,
-0.055380672216415405,
-0.25736159086227417,
-0.3136029839515686,
-1.1178683042526245,
0.2984623908996582,
0.1412367820739746,
-0.04272165894508362,
0.21849055588245392,
0.009769037365913391,
0.7094281315803528,
-0.23802612721920013,
1.1210050582885742,
-0.13415247201919556,
0.17231608927249908,
0.2987339496612549,
0.12656553089618683,
0.02830956131219864,
-0.06163711100816727,
0.4963219165802002,
0.5062472820281982,
0.38610178232192993,
-0.4117077589035034,
-0.8049803972244263,
0.5189602375030518,
-0.686602771282196,
-0.3716810345649719,
-0.2501368820667267,
-0.7252014875411987,
-0.3091423213481903,
0.3013579845428467,
0.4037802219390869,
0.3290252387523651,
-0.2733217179775238,
0.3859735429286957,
0.6681424379348755,
-0.1703912764787674,
0.36833706498146057,
0.24079683423042297,
0.07136178016662598,
-0.5355932712554932,
0.9645596742630005,
-0.12798409163951874,
-0.0385669581592083,
0.7029670476913452,
-0.31473127007484436,
-0.24823255836963654,
-0.39061298966407776,
-0.28514111042022705,
0.3185192346572876,
-0.9262951016426086,
-0.3496739864349365,
-0.9643306136131287,
-0.42306068539619446,
-0.24929651618003845,
-0.09820418059825897,
-0.44077974557876587,
-0.29945749044418335,
-0.08194363117218018,
-0.006689487490803003,
0.15958645939826965,
0.23676623404026031,
0.15646636486053467,
0.5829910635948181,
-0.7325029373168945,
0.44060570001602173,
0.3108241558074951,
0.34684205055236816,
-0.1342540979385376,
0.13452576100826263,
-0.3257479965686798,
0.07004744559526443,
-0.025867018848657608,
-0.9366710782051086,
0.403669148683548,
-0.0063456944189965725,
0.4114464521408081,
0.14436200261116028,
0.2624814510345459,
0.6708368062973022,
-0.4064246416091919,
0.4434319734573364,
0.5562269687652588,
-0.7214769721031189,
0.5818284153938293,
-0.16236945986747742,
0.4829188883304596,
0.48786574602127075,
0.22567340731620789,
-0.43726295232772827,
-0.27555719017982483,
-0.32489195466041565,
-0.7754680514335632,
0.7772863507270813,
0.5016846060752869,
0.47835463285446167,
-0.2817430794239044,
0.14916278421878815,
-0.0373351089656353,
0.09763495624065399,
-0.7384463548660278,
-0.04038999602198601,
-0.637637734413147,
-0.6682503819465637,
0.24825212359428406,
-0.09706747531890869,
-0.34098854660987854,
-0.4032338261604309,
0.10870032757520676,
-0.2817704677581787,
0.8634277582168579,
0.4406653642654419,
-0.2929340600967407,
0.2920718491077423,
0.09966275840997696,
0.40654119849205017,
0.2701559066772461,
-0.09016188979148865,
0.17509901523590088,
0.12653562426567078,
-0.7504502534866333,
-0.1683545708656311,
0.07189745455980301,
0.0449284203350544,
-0.07813670486211777,
0.16423657536506653,
1.0601977109909058,
0.12248487025499344,
-0.840258777141571,
0.9642126560211182,
-0.5029923319816589,
-0.156455859541893,
-0.3986666202545166,
-0.09522797167301178,
0.3647795617580414,
0.08802802115678787,
0.1206112653017044,
0.2100280076265335,
0.2574129104614258,
-0.09871220588684082,
0.3070274591445923,
0.40776076912879944,
-0.38927212357521057,
-0.25793972611427307,
0.8106573224067688,
0.2686893045902252,
-0.004299926571547985,
0.6843450665473938,
0.1241622194647789,
-0.07852333784103394,
0.5065103769302368,
0.5958318114280701,
0.7889683246612549,
0.03588308021426201,
0.04667907953262329,
0.14120784401893616,
0.4142715334892273,
0.1935291588306427,
0.3499223291873932,
-0.3543359935283661,
-0.9086290597915649,
-0.46008482575416565,
-0.38740918040275574,
-0.11013863235712051,
0.17292585968971252,
-0.5149052739143372,
0.03463977947831154,
-0.30094170570373535,
-0.2657415270805359,
-0.004307412542402744,
-0.6662254929542542,
-0.6281663179397583,
0.3488495945930481,
0.011759133078157902,
0.5728394389152527,
-0.49097976088523865,
0.9759964942932129,
0.7050034999847412,
-0.6734495162963867,
-0.42013850808143616,
-0.11432123929262161,
-0.5741151571273804,
-0.87538743019104,
0.6853048205375671,
0.2435344010591507,
-0.2778864800930023,
0.40653565526008606,
-0.682011067867279,
-0.5949323177337646,
0.9900692701339722,
0.6029656529426575,
-0.20321305096149445,
-0.2238234281539917,
0.060754090547561646,
0.33653074502944946,
-0.41176632046699524,
0.26952242851257324,
0.023309528827667236,
0.35316717624664307,
0.2274455428123474,
-0.47425729036331177,
0.20153184235095978,
-0.45900189876556396,
0.1810789257287979,
-0.2185918539762497,
-0.424197256565094,
0.478925883769989,
-0.17727485299110413,
-0.5726521611213684,
-0.06933087855577469,
0.8886263370513916,
-0.15578939020633698,
0.17406907677650452,
0.5116769671440125,
0.3010711073875427,
0.27287667989730835,
-0.10252516716718674,
1.0848147869110107,
-0.532839834690094,
0.05765582621097565,
0.7732750773429871,
0.08243535459041595,
0.6652324795722961,
0.6556967496871948,
0.2064306139945984,
0.26159143447875977,
0.4981190264225006,
0.08895334601402283,
0.8574385643005371,
0.04286894574761391,
-0.21215490996837616,
-0.48924386501312256,
0.07092607021331787,
-0.29815325140953064,
0.484561949968338,
0.42786362767219543,
-0.12252283096313477,
-0.36994102597236633,
0.42573654651641846,
-0.08691152930259705,
-0.13021160662174225,
0.05266885459423065,
0.8425580263137817,
0.22951486706733704,
-0.5931857228279114,
0.8349566459655762,
-0.036481358110904694,
0.7227844595909119,
-0.8389419317245483,
-0.28286293148994446,
-0.2549353539943695,
0.06662968546152115,
-0.08501806855201721,
-0.5943025946617126,
0.602919340133667,
-0.3001601994037628,
-0.04678938537836075,
-0.18588563799858093,
0.9111277461051941,
-0.6228323578834534,
-0.16069521009922028,
0.2890802323818207,
0.3632369935512543,
0.420282781124115,
-0.24237321317195892,
-0.6098054647445679,
0.2375083565711975,
-0.2801513075828552,
0.01026170328259468,
0.2757169008255005,
0.18942716717720032,
-0.02939649485051632,
0.6565496325492859,
0.4996446669101715,
-0.35517075657844543,
0.043571360409259796,
-0.04211943969130516,
0.987010657787323,
-0.7410330176353455,
-0.7207176685333252,
-0.5769160985946655,
0.5090901255607605,
-0.06868347525596619,
0.030741900205612183,
0.41581466794013977,
0.36646607518196106,
0.6009601354598999,
-0.5705678462982178,
0.6757733821868896,
-0.3928437829017639,
0.040320985019207,
-0.709385335445404,
1.2617017030715942,
-0.6404440402984619,
-0.16685917973518372,
0.10188248008489609,
-0.4763792157173157,
-0.4655914902687073,
0.902535617351532,
-0.13450226187705994,
0.0843440517783165,
1.0473138093948364,
1.0723083019256592,
-0.18453092873096466,
0.24301519989967346,
0.6814951300621033,
0.136797234416008,
-0.16787323355674744,
0.8375201225280762,
0.9185882806777954,
-0.4650934636592865,
0.7955847978591919,
0.13878260552883148,
-0.2787794768810272,
-0.09082445502281189,
-0.5680931210517883,
-0.9810521602630615,
-0.7616828083992004,
-0.4473341703414917,
-0.21952275931835175,
0.11021839827299118,
0.5485180616378784,
0.9839385747909546,
-0.527164101600647,
-0.10723891854286194,
-0.22720566391944885,
-0.2158188372850418,
-0.10207240283489227,
-0.24067561328411102,
0.44847750663757324,
-0.5290939807891846,
-0.5726048946380615,
0.3519071340560913,
0.23035067319869995,
0.10707390308380127,
-0.12906107306480408,
-0.015335817821323872,
-0.03338918089866638,
-0.027207572013139725,
0.8177213072776794,
0.11771676689386368,
-0.5576518177986145,
-0.007376889232546091,
0.11680833250284195,
-0.34767210483551025,
0.18989919126033783,
0.7917837500572205,
-0.6436243057250977,
0.3326415717601776,
0.44431644678115845,
1.15183687210083,
0.955075204372406,
-0.3278232514858246,
0.4942215085029602,
-0.5868968963623047,
0.21308785676956177,
0.2703956663608551,
0.15101665258407593,
0.4789539575576782,
-0.38899222016334534,
0.47651591897010803,
0.25410112738609314,
-0.18498654663562775,
-0.5318053960800171,
0.15192361176013947,
-1.529581069946289,
-0.38834133744239807,
0.8555579781532288,
-0.31828573346138,
-0.6539499163627625,
-0.23611225187778473,
-0.47440579533576965,
0.11814503371715546,
-0.07594624161720276,
0.670730471611023,
0.7620456218719482,
-0.22452303767204285,
-0.4663408398628235,
-0.4734436869621277,
0.30158042907714844,
0.6602014899253845,
-0.8951205611228943,
-0.008086560294032097,
0.5454551577568054,
0.3235894739627838,
0.02632594108581543,
1.1254903078079224,
-0.45459210872650146,
0.30845871567726135,
0.16119514405727386,
0.29318904876708984,
-0.14680704474449158,
-0.10328096896409988,
-0.043401818722486496,
0.30804207921028137,
-0.27117958664894104,
-0.5450788736343384
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.06196v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.06196v2
|
LINGOLY: A Benchmark of Olympiad-Level Linguistic Reasoning Puzzles in Low-Resource and Extinct Languages
| 2024-06-10T11:50:29 | 2024-06-11T10:19:52 |
Andrew M. Bean, Simi Hellsten, Harry Mayne, Jabez Magomere, Ethan A. Chi, Ryan Chi, Scott A. Hale, Hannah Rose Kirk
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In this paper, we present the LingOly benchmark, a novel benchmark for
advanced reasoning abilities in large language models. Using challenging
Linguistic Olympiad puzzles, we evaluate (i) capabilities for in-context
identification and generalisation of linguistic patterns in very low-resource
or extinct languages, and (ii) abilities to follow complex task instructions.
The LingOly benchmark covers more than 90 mostly low-resource languages,
minimising issues of data contamination, and contains 1,133 problems across 6
formats and 5 levels of human difficulty. We assess performance with both
direct accuracy and comparison to a no-context baseline to penalise
memorisation. Scores from 11 state-of-the-art LLMs demonstrate the benchmark to
be challenging, and models perform poorly on the higher difficulty problems. On
harder problems, even the top model only achieved 38.7% accuracy, 24.7%
improvement over the no-context baseline. Large closed models typically
outperform open models, and in general, the higher resource the language, the
better the scores. These results indicate, in absence of memorisation, true
multi-step out-of-domain reasoning remains a challenge for current language
models.
|
[
-0.21639509499073029,
-0.5870110392570496,
0.41470155119895935,
0.32776662707328796,
0.03333243727684021,
0.007863729260861874,
-0.46387919783592224,
-0.5438938140869141,
-0.15525273978710175,
0.5286307334899902,
-0.4234522879123688,
-0.3387379050254822,
-0.4860502779483795,
0.32760775089263916,
-0.0795021504163742,
0.3256216049194336,
-0.12052787095308304,
-0.07969354093074799,
-0.3102051317691803,
-0.2301848977804184,
-0.5959879159927368,
-0.5490555167198181,
-0.5097206234931946,
-0.4329083561897278,
0.06283921003341675,
0.399501770734787,
0.518506646156311,
0.6012536287307739,
0.42336219549179077,
0.3250587284564972,
-0.5613479018211365,
0.5001999735832214,
-0.6433423757553101,
0.2783309817314148,
-0.3017400801181793,
-0.45766857266426086,
-0.405972421169281,
0.21760328114032745,
0.4758371412754059,
0.922932505607605,
-0.019343456253409386,
-0.017348770052194595,
-0.20793159306049347,
0.7064945101737976,
-0.5393528342247009,
0.39738592505455017,
-0.8683626651763916,
-0.03711036965250969,
-0.1266048699617386,
-0.010824876837432384,
-0.5446611046791077,
-0.28761136531829834,
0.06144300848245621,
-0.8473474979400635,
-0.16751426458358765,
0.4055376648902893,
0.7488313913345337,
0.26959100365638733,
-0.37938445806503296,
-0.7440003156661987,
-0.2781774699687958,
1.1416972875595093,
-0.6896464228630066,
0.46922940015792847,
0.3428766131401062,
0.21234288811683655,
-0.27856895327568054,
-0.31495970487594604,
-0.3134438693523407,
-0.610317587852478,
0.008697896264493465,
0.11057046800851822,
-0.10575578361749649,
-0.053405895829200745,
0.4534284472465515,
0.15652640163898468,
-0.48720237612724304,
0.026785152032971382,
-0.2724120616912842,
-0.08525019884109497,
0.5859979391098022,
0.07635556906461716,
0.2364024668931961,
-0.35922300815582275,
-0.2789507806301117,
0.15800538659095764,
-0.9115056395530701,
0.025850694626569748,
0.33130761981010437,
0.21202315390110016,
0.23342019319534302,
0.6327735781669617,
-0.5063295364379883,
0.7571965456008911,
-0.013446708209812641,
-0.23298493027687073,
0.2372509092092514,
-0.1932828575372696,
0.23204365372657776,
-0.0187998004257679,
0.43996602296829224,
0.20207054913043976,
0.5079255700111389,
-0.27738893032073975,
-0.4205169081687927,
-0.38002657890319824,
-0.3698371350765228,
-0.5731551647186279,
-0.3638095557689667,
0.090688057243824,
-0.2046377956867218,
0.08840591460466385,
-0.4063151180744171,
-0.4094940721988678,
-0.2983975112438202,
-0.24718846380710602,
0.2735064625740051,
-0.6863881945610046,
-0.28926318883895874,
0.19673000276088715,
0.1469378024339676,
0.18205280601978302,
0.351780503988266,
-0.7333970665931702,
0.1812158077955246,
0.9287707209587097,
0.7163001298904419,
-0.25682857632637024,
-0.5296688079833984,
-0.5177478194236755,
0.09168518334627151,
-0.6567567586898804,
0.7650146484375,
-0.7007392644882202,
-0.11779408156871796,
-0.21106214821338654,
-0.14982739090919495,
-0.3757390081882477,
-1.0848435163497925,
0.6706207394599915,
-0.49444344639778137,
-0.0550353117287159,
-0.17230206727981567,
-0.7010028958320618,
-0.1921251267194748,
0.46707090735435486,
-0.6923751831054688,
1.2696075439453125,
-0.029914187267422676,
-0.3895091712474823,
0.10497604310512543,
-0.35332608222961426,
-0.21966908872127533,
0.29503893852233887,
0.017693551257252693,
0.20508933067321777,
0.17530544102191925,
0.024839218705892563,
0.13898450136184692,
-0.5899421572685242,
0.45054030418395996,
-0.295854777097702,
-0.41390150785446167,
0.24176841974258423,
-0.3253777325153351,
0.8695958852767944,
0.19397439062595367,
-0.27768921852111816,
-0.2832695543766022,
-0.8927549719810486,
0.38561588525772095,
-0.08994778990745544,
-0.5915690660476685,
-0.5140447616577148,
-0.14675463736057281,
-0.1576480120420456,
0.44685035943984985,
0.39797475934028625,
-0.47000402212142944,
0.27335307002067566,
-0.537617027759552,
0.49019700288772583,
0.7018779516220093,
-0.32744720578193665,
0.07078251987695694,
-0.317190021276474,
0.2952005863189697,
-0.13359501957893372,
-0.07581480592489243,
-0.05819480121135712,
-0.7960641980171204,
-0.5130112767219543,
-0.3143194913864136,
0.3669483959674835,
0.8482381701469421,
-0.7211129665374756,
0.2283569723367691,
-0.3463422656059265,
-0.40332338213920593,
-0.48953577876091003,
0.40467017889022827,
0.7620272040367126,
0.4315989911556244,
0.2626805007457733,
-0.1371820867061615,
-0.2714185118675232,
-0.8642570376396179,
-0.47940072417259216,
-0.3121059536933899,
-0.10941637307405472,
0.7650392651557922,
0.7576219439506531,
0.08433284610509872,
0.61493319272995,
-0.047020867466926575,
0.01699030213057995,
-0.0779525488615036,
0.36456331610679626,
0.4061049222946167,
0.39832058548927307,
0.17452430725097656,
-0.7093532085418701,
-0.3786095380783081,
0.2358396202325821,
-0.8336951732635498,
-0.5183212161064148,
0.2744050920009613,
0.047584421932697296,
0.45003989338874817,
0.6638639569282532,
-0.7164698243141174,
-0.15369513630867004,
0.4921698272228241,
-0.4012034237384796,
0.6724846363067627,
-0.3684813976287842,
0.204498291015625,
-0.58487468957901,
0.25665849447250366,
-0.5379169583320618,
0.1484801322221756,
-0.6876751184463501,
0.28884968161582947,
0.22059431672096252,
-0.12340925633907318,
-0.5582485795021057,
0.9031481146812439,
-0.6757327318191528,
0.07715433835983276,
0.17454074323177338,
0.34123727679252625,
-0.20326435565948486,
0.44050049781799316,
0.13986936211585999,
0.621910572052002,
0.40882909297943115,
-0.29707813262939453,
0.525556206703186,
-0.0082170981913805,
-0.6428853273391724,
0.6504855155944824,
-0.550957202911377,
0.14044171571731567,
-0.07771047204732895,
-0.256390780210495,
-1.0282998085021973,
-0.14310869574546814,
-0.25730517506599426,
-0.29998892545700073,
0.24331922829151154,
-0.08166070282459259,
-0.45366227626800537,
-0.12838096916675568,
-0.12349899858236313,
0.8292149901390076,
0.47434866428375244,
-0.48412561416625977,
0.6480742692947388,
0.29816585779190063,
-0.07069302350282669,
-0.7775315642356873,
-0.5071086883544922,
0.21231302618980408,
-0.2824968695640564,
-0.7560155391693115,
0.11881127208471298,
-0.19897611439228058,
-0.5686987042427063,
0.16517895460128784,
-0.16812288761138916,
-0.12839557230472565,
0.13637526333332062,
-0.031987279653549194,
0.06977272033691406,
-0.3455619812011719,
-0.00433052983134985,
-0.4160153567790985,
-0.09341651201248169,
0.07719899713993073,
-0.23027421534061432,
0.406655490398407,
-0.2792309522628784,
-0.3631383776664734,
0.07001504302024841,
0.29188838601112366,
0.5901111364364624,
-0.11547116935253143,
0.43083927035331726,
0.025647468864917755,
-0.5632967352867126,
-0.2968369424343109,
-0.8191728591918945,
0.26300904154777527,
-0.42045092582702637,
0.39844757318496704,
-0.7616528868675232,
-0.7386993169784546,
0.5944923162460327,
-0.35655543208122253,
-0.21883535385131836,
0.3109927475452423,
0.48357707262039185,
0.25549551844596863,
0.9464805126190186,
0.1717248111963272,
0.02089555375277996,
-0.07915418595075607,
-0.03760559856891632,
0.21113011240959167,
-0.7608261108398438,
-0.35132524371147156,
-0.4658723473548889,
0.029185308143496513,
-0.5366407036781311,
-0.664970338344574,
0.3862953782081604,
0.6496354341506958,
-0.22845430672168732,
0.23907534778118134,
-0.2163417935371399,
0.7240906953811646,
0.5505587458610535,
-0.1444663405418396,
0.48207464814186096,
-0.41610297560691833,
-0.3518838584423065,
-0.011313149705529213,
-0.8104992508888245,
-0.47822675108909607,
1.0708478689193726,
-0.1958254724740982,
0.6530599594116211,
0.3104570209980011,
0.7241384983062744,
0.05495934933423996,
0.35825446248054504,
-0.7324546575546265,
0.7760940194129944,
-0.12263201922178268,
-0.8644320368766785,
-0.473676860332489,
-0.6488366723060608,
-0.8510901927947998,
0.431562602519989,
-0.007771184667944908,
-0.8408332467079163,
-0.06610609591007233,
0.06730866432189941,
-0.08153537660837173,
0.16062389314174652,
-0.6938899159431458,
1.0134270191192627,
-0.30053284764289856,
-0.5119368433952332,
-0.07201959937810898,
-0.3176996409893036,
0.6124789714813232,
-0.046432461589574814,
0.6316466331481934,
-0.40466633439064026,
-0.2572060525417328,
0.6569258570671082,
-0.28613460063934326,
0.5279233455657959,
-0.019608046859502792,
0.11727743595838547,
0.23715034127235413,
0.3236974775791168,
0.5509156584739685,
-0.11230409145355225,
-0.27844032645225525,
0.004617520608007908,
0.00689304992556572,
-0.5611246824264526,
-0.3813614845275879,
0.8315603137016296,
-0.6157301664352417,
-0.7656576633453369,
-0.37812289595603943,
-0.8380890488624573,
-0.4621516168117523,
0.3628208339214325,
0.06226848065853119,
0.5321746468544006,
-0.21640948951244354,
0.26704075932502747,
0.9988490343093872,
-0.28182095289230347,
0.31010258197784424,
0.5556849837303162,
0.08672924339771271,
-0.3136940002441406,
0.9801427721977234,
0.2472611367702484,
0.3270951211452484,
0.5391117334365845,
0.2203497439622879,
-0.3531835973262787,
-0.8049474358558655,
-0.5037605166435242,
0.34586024284362793,
-1.0865428447723389,
-0.03766796737909317,
-0.322733998298645,
-0.05547588691115379,
-0.22880762815475464,
-0.09276317805051804,
-0.4044378101825714,
-0.5503105521202087,
0.19393014907836914,
0.32100558280944824,
-0.1022135317325592,
0.8570414781570435,
-0.11718521267175674,
-0.545330822467804,
-0.43427273631095886,
0.2552776038646698,
0.5832211971282959,
0.35955846309661865,
0.04181431606411934,
-0.6387653350830078,
0.07667039334774017,
-0.23155179619789124,
0.07510881125926971,
-0.7386906743049622,
0.2318813055753708,
0.3080841600894928,
0.8459489941596985,
0.09732324630022049,
0.05062444508075714,
0.5124391317367554,
-0.6108016967773438,
0.7924535274505615,
-0.001658487832173705,
-1.107304334640503,
0.28807127475738525,
-0.33163145184516907,
0.4214259088039398,
0.3601143956184387,
0.360370010137558,
-0.6609358191490173,
-0.3464348018169403,
-0.3429081439971924,
-0.9359307885169983,
0.6475081443786621,
0.05714128166437149,
-0.2896427512168884,
-0.19472266733646393,
0.3964337706565857,
-0.030968869104981422,
0.09533055126667023,
-0.7261323928833008,
-0.07254178822040558,
-0.027667485177516937,
-0.11368672549724579,
-0.08461569249629974,
-0.3460988700389862,
-0.08680975437164307,
-0.1555260568857193,
0.7208293676376343,
-0.16789300739765167,
-0.265150249004364,
0.04811841994524002,
-0.5042210221290588,
-0.029259756207466125,
0.24092236161231995,
0.6214682459831238,
0.7861620187759399,
-0.1507440060377121,
0.22758902609348297,
0.47904834151268005,
-0.30104711651802063,
0.14066004753112793,
0.14954301714897156,
-0.13769187033176422,
-0.1334007978439331,
0.8556414246559143,
0.4219880700111389,
0.6689460277557373,
-1.1953541040420532,
0.43129974603652954,
0.1989925056695938,
-0.3326117694377899,
-0.08680304139852524,
-0.06263308227062225,
0.41311565041542053,
0.3143455684185028,
0.39667579531669617,
-0.18153266608715057,
0.12433409690856934,
-0.6426329016685486,
-0.09359455108642578,
0.548065185546875,
-0.08509179204702377,
-0.1942628175020218,
0.7694451808929443,
0.03604079410433769,
-0.39584171772003174,
0.39543330669403076,
-0.5073450803756714,
-0.4926854372024536,
0.7129355669021606,
0.5046040415763855,
0.5633683800697327,
-0.24775667488574982,
-0.06195755675435066,
0.5148639678955078,
0.4347529709339142,
-0.41993260383605957,
0.3985460698604584,
0.035322461277246475,
-0.6981499195098877,
-0.4227815866470337,
-0.5701385736465454,
-0.7027471661567688,
0.2774757444858551,
-0.47039416432380676,
-0.034306373447179794,
-0.07066716998815536,
0.4776219427585602,
0.11148560047149658,
0.2357233166694641,
-0.5201188921928406,
0.007985393516719341,
0.2596006691455841,
1.1196300983428955,
-0.616475522518158,
0.7506305575370789,
0.7896974682807922,
0.04523424059152603,
-0.6382469534873962,
-0.343753844499588,
0.13654166460037231,
-1.0158019065856934,
0.9636855721473694,
0.21865573525428772,
-0.2705822288990021,
-0.2082294225692749,
-0.19597168266773224,
-1.1275144815444946,
0.8603212237358093,
0.46568500995635986,
-0.38892003893852234,
0.09642522782087326,
0.13684776425361633,
0.6364237666130066,
-0.317743182182312,
0.36375540494918823,
0.6995663046836853,
0.6142870783805847,
0.20572374761104584,
-1.1358551979064941,
0.0952739417552948,
-0.5777563452720642,
0.04570787772536278,
0.024155234917998314,
-0.5992715358734131,
1.1583888530731201,
-0.0758681446313858,
-0.1822674423456192,
0.4503506124019623,
0.25269779562950134,
0.5300542712211609,
0.20618979632854462,
0.5286017656326294,
0.6215362548828125,
0.8657205104827881,
-0.2813084125518799,
0.7919923663139343,
-0.5018373131752014,
0.25414323806762695,
0.8221032023429871,
-0.4093257486820221,
0.8139335513114929,
0.411776065826416,
-0.03154318034648895,
0.2455269694328308,
0.3425007164478302,
0.43785560131073,
0.5213285684585571,
0.5264871120452881,
-0.152755007147789,
-0.42515838146209717,
-0.143589049577713,
-0.3110203146934509,
0.4274976849555969,
0.41785699129104614,
0.2802126407623291,
-0.23750227689743042,
-0.1906808316707611,
-0.011702843010425568,
0.27510809898376465,
-0.5193347930908203,
0.554046094417572,
-0.16599197685718536,
-1.094196081161499,
1.2680230140686035,
-0.1715031862258911,
0.643939733505249,
-0.42398813366889954,
-0.13806143403053284,
-0.4118151068687439,
0.32500430941581726,
-0.0443773977458477,
-0.6631066799163818,
0.005824812222272158,
-0.07940974831581116,
0.04907161369919777,
-0.17505481839179993,
0.5094028115272522,
-0.6753528714179993,
-0.30548325181007385,
0.41519320011138916,
0.7349424362182617,
0.4436066448688507,
0.1587810069322586,
-0.6423419117927551,
0.00008067388262134045,
-0.22721892595291138,
-0.5783510208129883,
0.16523900628089905,
0.8726916313171387,
-0.25277575850486755,
0.8313595056533813,
0.342572957277298,
0.24879240989685059,
0.27137139439582825,
-0.09641395509243011,
0.6197863221168518,
-0.7442261576652527,
-0.25988060235977173,
-0.5973680019378662,
-0.07275815308094025,
-0.2371743619441986,
-0.6324942111968994,
0.722777247428894,
0.7108734250068665,
1.0886969566345215,
-0.06251859664916992,
0.5160140991210938,
-0.02787518873810768,
0.5408584475517273,
-0.7727680206298828,
0.3034701347351074,
-0.5302841663360596,
0.31291261315345764,
-0.1771325320005417,
-0.5105200409889221,
-0.30338045954704285,
0.4926075339317322,
-0.531363844871521,
-0.10938497632741928,
0.8604743480682373,
0.9113134741783142,
-0.07338226586580276,
-0.06924141198396683,
0.5788829922676086,
0.3975716233253479,
0.06291823834180832,
1.1165432929992676,
1.0678244829177856,
-0.06210668757557869,
0.7742887735366821,
-0.2622116208076477,
-0.36480799317359924,
-0.19828931987285614,
-0.9220800399780273,
-1.1297614574432373,
-0.4983564019203186,
0.024948524311184883,
-0.10642000287771225,
0.2555829882621765,
0.8634761571884155,
0.5616482496261597,
-1.0160685777664185,
-0.49543899297714233,
0.0847465768456459,
0.3887767195701599,
-0.5732877254486084,
-0.19258925318717957,
0.2712736427783966,
-0.4435920715332031,
-0.816063404083252,
0.7514075040817261,
0.33532363176345825,
-0.3979870080947876,
-0.028047744184732437,
-0.29439210891723633,
-0.3665674924850464,
0.25962701439857483,
0.6290737390518188,
0.41591450572013855,
-1.0653693675994873,
-0.5252358317375183,
0.121078260242939,
-0.12887036800384521,
-0.11038171499967575,
0.7178602814674377,
-0.5216756463050842,
0.5621578097343445,
0.5314086079597473,
0.5012626647949219,
0.3824551999568939,
-0.2271825075149536,
0.18776105344295502,
-0.4543486535549164,
0.22751004993915558,
0.3962283134460449,
0.5627394318580627,
0.34996166825294495,
0.0699358731508255,
0.7040022015571594,
0.47550442814826965,
-0.472321480512619,
-1.1388895511627197,
0.28646886348724365,
-0.7082207202911377,
-0.49676549434661865,
1.0077362060546875,
-0.38162750005722046,
-0.35711759328842163,
-0.35202860832214355,
-0.00381730729714036,
-0.30407172441482544,
-0.14265042543411255,
0.9036359786987305,
1.1021705865859985,
-0.2930476665496826,
-0.15416787564754486,
-0.7009795904159546,
0.5809573531150818,
0.6167237758636475,
-0.6761556267738342,
0.32904884219169617,
0.4808030128479004,
0.24814139306545258,
0.3198125660419464,
0.6572107076644897,
-0.10063961893320084,
0.43810874223709106,
0.14903847873210907,
-0.16597692668437958,
-0.2432575225830078,
-0.3938358426094055,
-0.2106798142194748,
0.4441579282283783,
0.21903404593467712,
0.31346893310546875
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.06657v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.06657v1
|
Harnessing AI for efficient analysis of complex policy documents: a case study of Executive Order 14110
| 2024-06-10T11:19:28 | 2024-06-10T11:19:28 |
Mark A. Kramer, Allen Leavens, Alexander Scarlat
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR
|
Policy documents, such as legislation, regulations, and executive orders, are
crucial in shaping society. However, their length and complexity make
interpretation and application challenging and time-consuming. Artificial
intelligence (AI), particularly large language models (LLMs), has the potential
to automate the process of analyzing these documents, improving accuracy and
efficiency. This study aims to evaluate the potential of AI in streamlining
policy analysis and to identify the strengths and limitations of current AI
approaches. The research focuses on question answering and tasks involving
content extraction from policy documents. A case study was conducted using
Executive Order 14110 on "Safe, Secure, and Trustworthy Development and Use of
Artificial Intelligence" as a test case. Four commercial AI systems were used
to analyze the document and answer a set of representative policy questions.
The performance of the AI systems was compared to manual analysis conducted by
human experts. The study found that two AI systems, Gemini 1.5 Pro and Claude 3
Opus, demonstrated significant potential for supporting policy analysis,
providing accurate and reliable information extraction from complex documents.
They performed comparably to human analysts but with significantly higher
efficiency. However, achieving reproducibility remains a challenge,
necessitating further research and development.
|
[
-0.34400591254234314,
-1.003437876701355,
0.5485257506370544,
0.3012174963951111,
0.04216981306672096,
0.15693548321723938,
-0.3123311400413513,
-0.5158747434616089,
0.01898365095257759,
0.7017759680747986,
-0.48159950971603394,
-0.26377806067466736,
-0.6786510944366455,
0.321333646774292,
-0.4474496841430664,
0.8430390954017639,
-0.10168280452489853,
0.04552585259079933,
-0.1348346620798111,
0.00006582772766705602,
-0.34010040760040283,
-0.4683801531791687,
-0.6186758875846863,
-0.2780502140522003,
0.27145805954933167,
0.36185526847839355,
0.8401243090629578,
0.7675620913505554,
0.9427228569984436,
0.532527506351471,
-0.1486908346414566,
0.45039212703704834,
-0.2070627212524414,
-0.03614036738872528,
-0.24070587754249573,
-0.26332709193229675,
-0.684417188167572,
0.05511758476495743,
0.6163369417190552,
0.3453596532344818,
-0.23778776824474335,
0.07514693588018417,
0.02554427459836006,
0.7232549786567688,
-0.2932734191417694,
0.6271132826805115,
-0.7291581630706787,
-0.2905183732509613,
0.024171773344278336,
0.004657620098441839,
-0.24672603607177734,
-0.32251936197280884,
0.44062331318855286,
-0.6815602779388428,
-0.2608170211315155,
0.22473356127738953,
1.0622614622116089,
0.24286632239818573,
-0.14133834838867188,
-0.6211602091789246,
-0.800229549407959,
0.7371521592140198,
-0.6758205890655518,
0.18674586713314056,
0.4239485561847687,
0.17652489244937897,
-0.32770273089408875,
-0.856391429901123,
-0.7591713070869446,
-0.33845779299736023,
-0.09319700300693512,
0.017420198768377304,
-0.20901721715927124,
0.3559592366218567,
0.2560446262359619,
0.08990149199962616,
-0.46852874755859375,
0.24627967178821564,
-0.5878860354423523,
-0.3463212251663208,
1.0610466003417969,
0.2044084519147873,
0.36250394582748413,
-0.28682953119277954,
0.10504122078418732,
-0.3357066512107849,
-0.1766602247953415,
0.1992112100124359,
0.5031002163887024,
0.19838480651378632,
0.18567600846290588,
0.4217086136341095,
-0.2809601128101349,
0.3074120283126831,
-0.40022096037864685,
-0.0719672217965126,
0.09198104590177536,
-0.3297128975391388,
-0.2924637198448181,
-0.07452688366174698,
0.8786649703979492,
-0.05033009126782417,
0.3916829824447632,
-0.09334456920623779,
-0.28346186876296997,
-0.2906934916973114,
0.47935640811920166,
-0.6989209055900574,
0.007722646463662386,
0.42139455676078796,
-0.6045469045639038,
-0.25880885124206543,
0.40228962898254395,
-0.7973746657371521,
-0.34039199352264404,
-0.566084086894989,
0.15841872990131378,
-0.36387673020362854,
0.07883840799331665,
-0.12636789679527283,
-0.35529205203056335,
0.5322719216346741,
0.5477654337882996,
-0.7248153686523438,
0.20826569199562073,
1.184998631477356,
0.5051882266998291,
-0.31723934412002563,
-0.1601952463388443,
-0.26415395736694336,
-0.003962659277021885,
-0.4636855125427246,
0.8115983605384827,
-0.5131574273109436,
-0.3995708227157593,
0.07109587639570236,
0.06889651715755463,
-0.20626387000083923,
-0.6458092927932739,
0.5496386885643005,
-0.4814363121986389,
-0.085964135825634,
0.04829081892967224,
-0.46001893281936646,
-0.2164716273546219,
0.6428743004798889,
-0.967630922794342,
0.6426305174827576,
-0.0816783457994461,
-0.18077442049980164,
0.16138535737991333,
-0.8592909574508667,
-0.41604769229888916,
0.052311837673187256,
-0.6116535067558289,
-0.44970250129699707,
-0.18353700637817383,
0.28544577956199646,
0.31523892283439636,
-0.37222129106521606,
0.6185749173164368,
-0.12046632170677185,
-0.3022923171520233,
0.22978690266609192,
-0.8069429993629456,
0.8580101132392883,
0.2765844762325287,
-0.3360876441001892,
0.2523461878299713,
-0.4740411937236786,
0.05687415227293968,
0.0016320081194862723,
-0.7354147434234619,
-0.0026642917655408382,
0.08037584275007248,
-0.22749145328998566,
-0.23720183968544006,
0.39528897404670715,
-0.37986090779304504,
0.3164374530315399,
-0.2821604907512665,
0.3532966077327728,
0.9516655802726746,
0.06323220580816269,
0.4951702952384949,
-0.3435599207878113,
0.5011606812477112,
-0.5113644003868103,
0.2866358458995819,
-0.30514833331108093,
-0.41645801067352295,
-0.5753511190414429,
-0.30755358934402466,
0.49478018283843994,
0.9538941383361816,
-0.46240487694740295,
0.4047085642814636,
-0.389225572347641,
-0.41169315576553345,
-0.5437198281288147,
0.1474481076002121,
0.3203115463256836,
0.10876195132732391,
0.18690794706344604,
-0.022171059623360634,
-0.24201099574565887,
-0.9536643624305725,
-0.5799068808555603,
-0.5062903165817261,
0.14242303371429443,
0.4403262436389923,
0.6175808310508728,
-0.1887124925851822,
0.7844301462173462,
-0.3913506269454956,
-0.04225442185997963,
-0.4357478618621826,
0.388625830411911,
0.1302276849746704,
0.3663485050201416,
0.17600153386592865,
-0.9245792031288147,
-0.14214766025543213,
0.15216337144374847,
-0.8266599774360657,
0.14902058243751526,
-0.46167537569999695,
-0.2753574252128601,
0.26872020959854126,
0.5961406826972961,
-0.4985875189304352,
0.5303929448127747,
-0.06331386417150497,
-0.19164666533470154,
0.3180639147758484,
-0.4868720471858978,
0.01945359632372856,
-0.6773205399513245,
0.2466527670621872,
-0.13769260048866272,
-0.07718881964683533,
-0.8642992973327637,
0.14226877689361572,
0.029483262449502945,
-0.19784176349639893,
-0.2995677888393402,
0.3352494239807129,
-0.16059385240077972,
0.08941050618886948,
-0.13147319853305817,
-0.17089152336120605,
0.015957947820425034,
0.48167091608047485,
-0.02715911902487278,
0.7326440215110779,
-0.11337369680404663,
-0.32635819911956787,
0.27153709530830383,
0.4994969069957733,
-0.3836093842983246,
0.21459293365478516,
-0.46073755621910095,
0.07750923931598663,
-0.38872626423835754,
0.06268095970153809,
-0.6265692114830017,
-0.31971728801727295,
0.34690529108047485,
-0.08304231613874435,
0.26143521070480347,
0.3455348014831543,
-0.44184568524360657,
-0.33865535259246826,
-0.3488684594631195,
-0.09133115410804749,
0.31949546933174133,
-0.06025832146406174,
0.8607925772666931,
0.6649405360221863,
-0.4667682349681854,
-0.45265141129493713,
-0.3998192250728607,
0.1439434289932251,
-0.129637211561203,
-0.42170965671539307,
0.33410781621932983,
0.11472545564174652,
-0.7560093998908997,
0.025346258655190468,
-0.07814210653305054,
-0.3907579183578491,
0.39598336815834045,
0.2066354751586914,
0.41225045919418335,
-0.032957933843135834,
-0.07703801989555359,
0.19862326979637146,
-0.008717208169400692,
0.36003080010414124,
0.2044713944196701,
0.26652079820632935,
-0.25194084644317627,
-0.2739686965942383,
-1.020519733428955,
0.5010427832603455,
1.0138283967971802,
-0.36319321393966675,
0.6238527297973633,
0.1369474232196808,
-0.21610532701015472,
-0.19580380618572235,
-0.5250967741012573,
0.12214817106723785,
-0.5097615122795105,
0.2978556454181671,
-0.09091155230998993,
-0.3256397843360901,
0.2764897644519806,
-0.26471778750419617,
0.5048794150352478,
0.5602808594703674,
0.23598521947860718,
-0.1014828309416771,
0.8755810856819153,
0.5430201292037964,
-0.513594388961792,
0.7260873913764954,
-0.5207292437553406,
0.13760662078857422,
-0.30418968200683594,
-0.530755877494812,
-0.7899056077003479,
-0.15633022785186768,
-0.6265390515327454,
0.04547819122672081,
0.348886102437973,
-0.2854185402393341,
-0.1722876876592636,
0.05398016422986984,
-0.42873796820640564,
0.33394452929496765,
0.8539977073669434,
0.08379414677619934,
0.30114802718162537,
0.008225872181355953,
0.5231407880783081,
0.6309502124786377,
-0.41027677059173584,
-0.896175742149353,
0.9242912530899048,
0.42124468088150024,
0.5580731630325317,
-0.2010250687599182,
0.5546790957450867,
0.756951093673706,
0.20229703187942505,
-0.6860517859458923,
0.7509042024612427,
-0.4244794249534607,
-0.3702544569969177,
-0.830585777759552,
-0.2773626446723938,
-0.8678693175315857,
0.2533726394176483,
-0.433220773935318,
-0.4834388196468353,
0.19144944846630096,
-0.13349491357803345,
-0.5261801481246948,
-0.013008196838200092,
-0.5899423360824585,
0.8035545349121094,
-0.597669243812561,
0.10318539291620255,
-0.43962785601615906,
-0.4549698531627655,
-0.047124046832323074,
-0.10089157521724701,
0.25850412249565125,
-0.2416880875825882,
0.1371622532606125,
0.9786664843559265,
-0.5177460312843323,
0.4780556261539459,
0.02624957077205181,
-0.06267976760864258,
0.5240346789360046,
-0.2974889278411865,
0.5652142763137817,
-0.2725282311439514,
-0.6482490301132202,
0.3295133113861084,
0.2793838083744049,
-0.1839483678340912,
-0.5431157350540161,
0.30878645181655884,
-0.8303038477897644,
-0.8391579985618591,
-0.3612981140613556,
-0.7110377550125122,
0.17335444688796997,
0.3765999972820282,
-0.19206485152244568,
0.3803703486919403,
-0.3031265437602997,
0.1589459329843521,
0.39447081089019775,
-0.12826526165008545,
0.6160876750946045,
0.2928498089313507,
0.16148795187473297,
-0.29703280329704285,
0.9763234257698059,
0.6158818006515503,
-0.2517161965370178,
0.3238280415534973,
0.3237299621105194,
-0.09165754914283752,
-0.6971028447151184,
-0.4030514359474182,
0.02584063448011875,
-0.40918922424316406,
-0.06683897972106934,
-0.42344510555267334,
-0.38616082072257996,
-0.49894049763679504,
0.06854952126741409,
-0.024537265300750732,
-0.41921690106391907,
-0.4101829528808594,
0.08018623292446136,
0.047952309250831604,
0.728210985660553,
0.3231152594089508,
0.2617778182029724,
-0.6902530193328857,
0.5435584783554077,
0.25309881567955017,
0.036098916083574295,
-0.06004603952169418,
-0.058927349746227264,
0.07771213352680206,
-0.039448801428079605,
-0.5055065155029297,
-0.7142919898033142,
0.23794594407081604,
0.2541637420654297,
0.8080624341964722,
0.48797962069511414,
0.2297794371843338,
0.7190576791763306,
-0.32120370864868164,
0.6375499963760376,
-0.5668932199478149,
-0.7942805886268616,
0.4492342174053192,
-0.12180530279874802,
0.057235050946474075,
0.7413991093635559,
0.2143559455871582,
-0.11920370906591415,
-0.5308266878128052,
-0.5663164258003235,
-0.8737547397613525,
0.9131682515144348,
0.36473363637924194,
0.1928323358297348,
0.14890989661216736,
0.5797394514083862,
0.04137922823429108,
0.28908172249794006,
-0.02067204751074314,
0.13595056533813477,
0.24244438111782074,
-0.4795996844768524,
0.2966056764125824,
-0.032003019005060196,
-0.12751540541648865,
-0.02918454259634018,
0.6974332928657532,
0.06567524373531342,
0.014165150932967663,
0.2588573098182678,
-0.07732363045215607,
0.3187249004840851,
0.36803340911865234,
0.4341805577278137,
0.8898158073425293,
0.0654863491654396,
-0.23385237157344818,
0.22829186916351318,
-0.5557020306587219,
-0.27784284949302673,
0.2817060947418213,
-0.38222360610961914,
-0.2058732956647873,
0.7395846247673035,
0.43802061676979065,
-0.39175674319267273,
-1.1630935668945312,
0.47666385769844055,
-0.10313606262207031,
-0.18127384781837463,
-0.5672457218170166,
0.17556993663311005,
-0.3870325982570648,
0.5191332697868347,
0.35233715176582336,
-0.29094523191452026,
0.2072286605834961,
-0.8576638102531433,
0.24401459097862244,
0.7400731444358826,
0.0029654798563569784,
0.16062957048416138,
0.27308085560798645,
0.3047168254852295,
-0.6221786737442017,
1.0249181985855103,
-0.0402863509953022,
-0.5799098610877991,
1.136470079421997,
0.23646047711372375,
0.6465364694595337,
-0.06127183139324188,
0.29588446021080017,
-0.1434575766324997,
0.4399165213108063,
-0.22979798913002014,
0.499660462141037,
-0.18313758075237274,
-0.5198856592178345,
-0.21624764800071716,
-0.4383828341960907,
-0.721340537071228,
0.15849830210208893,
-0.5901819467544556,
0.03606380894780159,
-0.660294234752655,
-0.10044470429420471,
-0.04461883008480072,
0.16338013112545013,
-0.6018034815788269,
0.05576480180025101,
0.07266275584697723,
0.9970552921295166,
-0.688278079032898,
0.45640599727630615,
0.43139970302581787,
-0.2012554556131363,
-0.8956506252288818,
0.062003858387470245,
-0.060542114078998566,
-0.8798903822898865,
0.4347642660140991,
0.23387183248996735,
0.08403946459293365,
-0.3085242807865143,
-0.5627244114875793,
-0.4706571698188782,
1.142832636833191,
0.2203223705291748,
-0.5919699668884277,
-0.24235999584197998,
0.42309489846229553,
0.5851077437400818,
-0.09015260636806488,
0.3018466532230377,
1.142066240310669,
0.7454620599746704,
-0.3001767098903656,
-0.8350542187690735,
-0.05128494277596474,
-0.14994385838508606,
-0.20689043402671814,
0.24145378172397614,
-0.5738182067871094,
0.5536242723464966,
0.21240313351154327,
-0.07990703731775284,
0.2255394160747528,
0.7661076784133911,
-0.06606075912714005,
0.6172829866409302,
0.4793112576007843,
0.1835835576057434,
1.0432829856872559,
0.062023505568504333,
1.036271333694458,
-0.3182668089866638,
-0.07245077192783356,
0.6876445412635803,
-0.14284437894821167,
0.9493308067321777,
0.5084791779518127,
0.04678250849246979,
0.5287078022956848,
0.395769864320755,
-0.17094512283802032,
0.14954926073551178,
0.07409835606813431,
-0.09370557963848114,
-0.05876421928405762,
-0.30244776606559753,
0.15080368518829346,
0.6298456192016602,
0.4137963056564331,
-0.40186992287635803,
0.023091409355401993,
-0.0687614157795906,
0.10640857368707657,
-0.0012151512783020735,
-0.587030291557312,
1.1287330389022827,
-0.10371800512075424,
-1.0463874340057373,
-0.065274678170681,
0.10172276198863983,
-0.060622937977313995,
-0.5361407399177551,
-0.40463748574256897,
-0.07478614151477814,
0.14591290056705475,
-0.05469860881567001,
-0.9532880783081055,
0.5095872282981873,
0.29022517800331116,
0.0773177370429039,
-0.5654868483543396,
0.6194753646850586,
-0.18967555463314056,
-0.5756403207778931,
-0.09156160056591034,
0.38289836049079895,
0.1407630443572998,
-0.11869502067565918,
-0.8600425124168396,
0.24086540937423706,
-0.10695769637823105,
-0.33851394057273865,
-0.07477468252182007,
0.27659106254577637,
-0.3982751667499542,
0.6420749425888062,
0.6685172319412231,
0.21207943558692932,
-0.19429728388786316,
-0.2833700180053711,
0.7642313838005066,
-0.4775874614715576,
-0.55805504322052,
-1.035474181175232,
0.3415144979953766,
-0.4034198224544525,
-0.15928281843662262,
0.39105188846588135,
0.45227134227752686,
0.572059690952301,
0.2832559645175934,
0.8292942047119141,
-0.0872824490070343,
0.18619948625564575,
-0.5012065768241882,
0.7712559700012207,
-0.25289177894592285,
0.4570939242839813,
0.056305449455976486,
-0.6714462041854858,
-0.221457839012146,
0.3338322937488556,
-0.4355953633785248,
-0.47782832384109497,
0.36423003673553467,
0.7715451121330261,
0.1630987524986267,
0.12760213017463684,
-0.052716247737407684,
0.04799182340502739,
0.6862434148788452,
-0.0722954124212265,
0.6150627136230469,
-0.19309303164482117,
0.9704015254974365,
-0.13789239525794983,
-0.23022738099098206,
-0.12041465938091278,
-0.5769202709197998,
-0.8018535375595093,
-0.2748485207557678,
-0.03487972915172577,
-0.0502951443195343,
0.3022302985191345,
1.0313291549682617,
0.42017269134521484,
-0.7563108801841736,
-0.308135449886322,
-0.08906537294387817,
0.38559409976005554,
-0.07845700532197952,
-0.18261948227882385,
0.6353366374969482,
-0.23411238193511963,
-0.7953387498855591,
0.42441526055336,
0.27135276794433594,
-0.2078157514333725,
-0.151215597987175,
0.028227463364601135,
-0.08351385593414307,
0.4626670181751251,
0.3215111196041107,
0.4944920837879181,
-0.7316930890083313,
-0.27376723289489746,
-0.11422479152679443,
-0.07067342847585678,
-0.11349738389253616,
0.8507576584815979,
-0.4487181007862091,
0.39206692576408386,
0.8507857918739319,
1.128493309020996,
0.06047922000288963,
0.5056396722793579,
0.6164562106132507,
0.00608234666287899,
-0.1772807538509369,
0.14254291355609894,
0.2680862247943878,
-0.032950419932603836,
-0.48294687271118164,
0.3885626494884491,
-0.1616208851337433,
-0.6298308372497559,
-0.6546318531036377,
0.05083516612648964,
-0.7835395336151123,
-0.5288292169570923,
0.9401556849479675,
-0.2252710908651352,
-0.49646976590156555,
-0.1478639543056488,
-0.5483466982841492,
0.24461963772773743,
-0.5956425070762634,
0.8955572843551636,
0.6324952840805054,
-0.44128739833831787,
0.20123225450515747,
-0.5031669735908508,
0.2614566683769226,
0.19469064474105835,
-1.2383729219436646,
-0.07331251353025436,
0.22691413760185242,
-0.3035643398761749,
0.21872109174728394,
0.5787850022315979,
0.03117232955992222,
0.11320433765649796,
-0.21262121200561523,
-0.448080837726593,
-0.14491280913352966,
-0.7188297510147095,
-0.5798484683036804,
0.35334011912345886,
-0.05262742564082146,
-0.26181507110595703
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.06144v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.06144v2
|
Language Models Resist Alignment
| 2024-06-10T10:03:16 | 2024-06-13T06:46:14 |
Jiaming Ji, Kaile Wang, Tianyi Qiu, Boyuan Chen, Jiayi Zhou, Changye Li, Hantao Lou, Yaodong Yang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large language models (LLMs) may exhibit undesirable behaviors. Recent
efforts have focused on aligning these models to prevent harmful generation.
Despite these efforts, studies have shown that even a well-conducted alignment
process can be easily circumvented, whether intentionally or accidentally. Do
alignment fine-tuning have robust effects on models, or are merely superficial?
In this work, we answer this question through both theoretical and empirical
means. Empirically, we demonstrate the elasticity of post-alignment models,
i.e., the tendency to revert to the behavior distribution formed during the
pre-training phase upon further fine-tuning. Using compression theory, we
formally derive that such fine-tuning process disproportionately undermines
alignment compared to pre-training, potentially by orders of magnitude. We
conduct experimental validations to confirm the presence of elasticity across
models of varying types and sizes. Specifically, we find that model performance
declines rapidly before reverting to the pre-training distribution, after which
the rate of decline drops significantly. We further reveal that elasticity
positively correlates with increased model size and the expansion of
pre-training data. Our discovery signifies the importance of taming the
inherent elasticity of LLMs, thereby overcoming the resistance of LLMs to
alignment finetuning.
|
[
-0.22653983533382416,
-0.7321871519088745,
0.4842410981655121,
-0.11064616590738297,
-0.1789424866437912,
-0.03776278346776962,
-0.4765794277191162,
-0.5567728877067566,
0.08085867762565613,
0.44658270478248596,
-0.6873842477798462,
-0.0713590607047081,
-0.5621345043182373,
-0.0543205663561821,
-0.5823208689689636,
1.256671667098999,
0.06812732666730881,
0.05850774422287941,
-0.10938750207424164,
-0.27616214752197266,
-0.4262069761753082,
-0.3337874412536621,
-0.34535446763038635,
-0.44310659170150757,
0.5197632312774658,
0.09847235679626465,
1.1345314979553223,
1.227564811706543,
0.5570521354675293,
0.38516995310783386,
-0.2065349817276001,
-0.09535008668899536,
-0.7992411851882935,
0.2915128767490387,
-0.015161179006099701,
-0.6657896637916565,
-0.5974223613739014,
0.0704350546002388,
0.8904250264167786,
0.8431035876274109,
-0.4062570333480835,
0.09939217567443848,
0.459027498960495,
0.7419222593307495,
-0.3940882086753845,
-0.3584801256656647,
-0.9719532132148743,
-0.44079652428627014,
-0.34511348605155945,
-0.19746218621730804,
-0.26725777983665466,
-0.26969578862190247,
-0.07237479090690613,
-0.42957109212875366,
0.07570239156484604,
0.2056235373020172,
1.249080777168274,
0.6075482368469238,
-0.15427076816558838,
-0.10625146329402924,
-0.7926673293113708,
0.7065439224243164,
-0.7924636602401733,
0.6237701177597046,
0.16830645501613617,
-0.10449214279651642,
-0.46497586369514465,
-0.22037693858146667,
-0.5907465815544128,
-0.07032376527786255,
0.09208642691373825,
-0.32623764872550964,
0.009611491113901138,
0.14885184168815613,
0.2424829751253128,
0.4857320189476013,
-0.6547191739082336,
0.7522916197776794,
-0.2926250696182251,
-0.03843580186367035,
0.40823572874069214,
0.2624996602535248,
0.4568668603897095,
0.25857192277908325,
-0.18060822784900665,
-0.18798241019248962,
-1.0680640935897827,
0.19476790726184845,
0.8855373859405518,
0.6161463260650635,
-0.06022937223315239,
0.7171967029571533,
0.1740068793296814,
0.6595139503479004,
0.23228947818279266,
-0.08988438546657562,
0.05666075646877289,
-0.2823829650878906,
-0.2808160185813904,
0.010732720606029034,
0.6634801626205444,
0.38421830534935,
0.456015944480896,
-0.14009489119052887,
-0.4151791036128998,
0.1932089626789093,
0.3301433026790619,
-0.5881400108337402,
-0.005890078376978636,
0.2635264992713928,
-0.42340245842933655,
-0.24683618545532227,
0.09166574478149414,
-0.3207325339317322,
-0.36173704266548157,
-0.7279564142227173,
0.2956686019897461,
-0.4739580750465393,
-0.21897996962070465,
0.2982982397079468,
0.2789835035800934,
0.31868770718574524,
0.1864778846502304,
-1.1109710931777954,
0.4236921966075897,
1.1334290504455566,
0.6281554102897644,
-0.0650901272892952,
-0.4090248942375183,
-0.37877100706100464,
-0.10389946401119232,
-0.4226476550102234,
0.65805584192276,
-0.6693344712257385,
0.07401508092880249,
-0.06625329703092575,
0.3217915892601013,
-0.06071117892861366,
-0.5508313179016113,
0.544428825378418,
-0.39163926243782043,
0.0005513324285857379,
-0.0911942720413208,
-0.5849471688270569,
0.058076705783605576,
0.1116524487733841,
-0.4799847900867462,
0.7457486391067505,
-0.1763850450515747,
-0.4906097948551178,
0.4274636507034302,
0.019183266907930374,
-0.3349277675151825,
-0.3728119134902954,
-0.06413402408361435,
-0.6389015316963196,
0.6609752774238586,
-0.09761134535074234,
0.31255149841308594,
-0.27175310254096985,
0.19528719782829285,
-0.7514792680740356,
-0.5029683709144592,
0.31426382064819336,
-0.45057374238967896,
0.6426873803138733,
0.15306711196899414,
-0.10291823744773865,
0.07655040174722672,
-0.7368574142456055,
0.06379424035549164,
0.12360291182994843,
-0.19995321333408356,
-0.4441133141517639,
0.11557631194591522,
-0.1663832813501358,
0.2593682110309601,
0.08611279726028442,
-0.37153133749961853,
0.5769698619842529,
-0.6654160618782043,
0.2684022784233093,
1.016053557395935,
-0.42689743638038635,
0.656086266040802,
-0.5258668661117554,
0.47647735476493835,
-0.2400752305984497,
-0.002587661612778902,
0.06075695529580116,
0.09130110591650009,
-0.6493706703186035,
-0.16673429310321808,
0.45752647519111633,
0.43290001153945923,
-0.22641606628894806,
0.5308736562728882,
-0.576603889465332,
-0.653693675994873,
-0.7676812410354614,
0.29093053936958313,
0.41989827156066895,
0.42517799139022827,
0.06319361180067062,
-0.36759042739868164,
-0.42662888765335083,
-0.8751157522201538,
-0.5396476984024048,
-0.03585461899638176,
-0.1467163860797882,
0.07297597080469131,
0.21936339139938354,
-0.1429041624069214,
0.6532244682312012,
-0.21475434303283691,
0.016196245327591896,
0.04479305073618889,
0.17243313789367676,
0.08694641292095184,
0.790995180606842,
0.4923264980316162,
-0.4768122434616089,
-0.0731164813041687,
-0.05951578542590141,
-0.24756622314453125,
-0.3832695186138153,
-0.1280580461025238,
-0.04360304772853851,
0.4823065400123596,
0.4197375774383545,
-0.608342707157135,
0.3576924800872803,
0.776999294757843,
-0.220513254404068,
0.5403746366500854,
-0.2776954174041748,
0.05426641181111336,
-0.8207941055297852,
-0.11565764993429184,
0.06918000429868698,
-0.1527489721775055,
-0.49119046330451965,
-0.07762114703655243,
-0.01266574114561081,
0.0679863765835762,
-0.17842300236225128,
0.33857792615890503,
-0.45686468482017517,
-0.19193121790885925,
-0.35314178466796875,
-0.0854438841342926,
-0.017958056181669235,
0.18440592288970947,
-0.07812310755252838,
0.7970104217529297,
0.2707539200782776,
-0.7138201594352722,
-0.26269373297691345,
0.05936381220817566,
-0.455028235912323,
0.42201536893844604,
-0.8250887393951416,
0.01503569632768631,
-0.35025641322135925,
-0.07423041760921478,
-1.0012248754501343,
-0.15609383583068848,
-0.24508555233478546,
-0.19470655918121338,
0.8093703389167786,
-0.18154607713222504,
-0.4330764710903168,
-0.06354304403066635,
-0.41818928718566895,
0.2948954999446869,
0.5162233710289001,
-0.383076936006546,
0.31543830037117004,
0.3544449508190155,
-0.23688271641731262,
-0.49935340881347656,
-0.6622247695922852,
-0.24335308372974396,
-0.5308942198753357,
-0.7235344052314758,
0.2920144200325012,
-0.16393911838531494,
-0.34241780638694763,
-0.12418894469738007,
-0.16002890467643738,
0.03909386694431305,
0.4532642066478729,
0.23675429821014404,
0.28682273626327515,
-0.3664438724517822,
0.12525521218776703,
-0.1736617386341095,
0.06310692429542542,
-0.10494983941316605,
-0.1299610137939453,
0.8618906140327454,
-0.19711750745773315,
-0.25490468740463257,
-0.5341328382492065,
-0.11705079674720764,
0.8370053172111511,
-0.2555687427520752,
1.058761477470398,
0.31518328189849854,
-0.2985239028930664,
0.1326833963394165,
-0.6541494131088257,
-0.38066333532333374,
-0.5676085352897644,
0.3716757297515869,
-0.16193588078022003,
-0.893491268157959,
0.6283968091011047,
0.00766107439994812,
-0.018870322033762932,
0.38708871603012085,
0.49596524238586426,
-0.22810803353786469,
1.2250021696090698,
0.8884254693984985,
-0.009660176932811737,
0.6243862509727478,
0.2755430042743683,
0.3006075322628021,
-0.993984580039978,
0.13557708263397217,
-0.6659662127494812,
-0.5297301411628723,
-0.9199885725975037,
0.1632491648197174,
-0.03660042956471443,
0.33281224966049194,
-0.4000709056854248,
0.40747058391571045,
-0.5591312646865845,
0.567359447479248,
0.13798242807388306,
-0.0922699123620987,
0.006240027491003275,
0.02815393917262554,
0.4042888581752777,
-0.33325865864753723,
-0.5485479831695557,
-0.7022665739059448,
0.8645773530006409,
0.4717130661010742,
1.008046269416809,
0.25254490971565247,
0.5113744735717773,
-0.2790800929069519,
0.16934464871883392,
-0.6495110988616943,
0.3735542893409729,
-0.1891814023256302,
-0.461073100566864,
-0.4564601480960846,
-0.3608105182647705,
-1.1709480285644531,
-0.045061759650707245,
-0.4906575381755829,
-1.076151967048645,
0.23396216332912445,
0.45809653401374817,
-0.4692368507385254,
0.22647134959697723,
-0.7056846022605896,
0.8898553848266602,
-0.5419041514396667,
-0.6453061699867249,
0.016541479155421257,
-0.6399443745613098,
0.44314074516296387,
-0.29002687335014343,
0.2969682812690735,
-0.29179951548576355,
0.06250941008329391,
0.5620108842849731,
-0.48970216512680054,
0.7282875776290894,
0.09729936718940735,
-0.291164755821228,
-0.013570564799010754,
0.3561069071292877,
0.6279200911521912,
-0.2970638573169708,
-0.013614572584629059,
0.011487878859043121,
0.05675946921110153,
-0.3421020805835724,
-0.646058976650238,
0.6927525997161865,
-0.7045114636421204,
-0.7496026754379272,
-0.16389095783233643,
-0.7273653745651245,
-0.21732616424560547,
0.295963853597641,
0.17027856409549713,
0.3054891526699066,
-0.052119605243206024,
0.37798482179641724,
0.5684748291969299,
-0.059624068439006805,
0.3102247714996338,
0.5413692593574524,
-0.23072564601898193,
0.03537438064813614,
0.9632458686828613,
0.48121312260627747,
0.5240550637245178,
-0.04666416347026825,
0.18001997470855713,
-0.19656270742416382,
-0.833167552947998,
0.05309601500630379,
0.36722829937934875,
-0.10908251255750656,
-0.0496058315038681,
-0.2639777362346649,
0.11979331821203232,
-0.732731282711029,
-0.28901544213294983,
-0.6576799750328064,
-0.44906166195869446,
-0.2433997392654419,
-0.09469778835773468,
0.19433893263339996,
0.7999383211135864,
0.16880418360233307,
0.5548628568649292,
-0.7669644355773926,
-0.17695152759552002,
-0.04134542495012283,
0.624754011631012,
-0.11684302240610123,
-0.9234170317649841,
-0.0899973064661026,
0.20307624340057373,
-0.22101876139640808,
-0.3681991994380951,
0.40158188343048096,
0.3621109426021576,
0.14114287495613098,
0.6009747385978699,
-0.17149871587753296,
1.0278897285461426,
-0.8338249921798706,
0.5860909819602966,
0.06469792872667313,
-0.8061382174491882,
0.22474442422389984,
-0.6339958906173706,
0.25688454508781433,
0.6115750670433044,
0.29638034105300903,
-0.3606380224227905,
-0.41811394691467285,
-0.6150097250938416,
-0.8912112712860107,
0.5068615674972534,
-0.1268664002418518,
0.34991908073425293,
0.14542552828788757,
0.5939392447471619,
0.13143333792686462,
0.2130001038312912,
-0.7951496839523315,
0.00441748695448041,
0.08061761409044266,
-0.4415779709815979,
-0.05635630711913109,
-0.4756736755371094,
-0.043510764837265015,
-0.24828080832958221,
0.6586217284202576,
-0.03407926484942436,
-0.10899704694747925,
-0.22882936894893646,
-0.16698920726776123,
-0.3338199555873871,
0.25870516896247864,
0.9455569982528687,
0.44904351234436035,
-0.20342868566513062,
0.011519893072545528,
-0.08574860543012619,
-0.11958406865596771,
0.2266397625207901,
0.07861777395009995,
-0.06602185219526291,
-0.6005963683128357,
0.4200267791748047,
0.7804475426673889,
0.38020533323287964,
-0.5499053001403809,
0.3574313223361969,
-0.009201647713780403,
0.01927735097706318,
-0.1019241139292717,
0.13207273185253143,
0.03385630249977112,
0.18278446793556213,
-0.09243963658809662,
0.06372229009866714,
-0.1814374178647995,
-0.6449357271194458,
0.12766778469085693,
0.6781478524208069,
-0.31604456901550293,
-0.5971366167068481,
0.739211916923523,
-0.11117549985647202,
-0.4675842821598053,
0.6552467346191406,
0.18453499674797058,
-0.45579779148101807,
0.5409494638442993,
0.6144547462463379,
0.5104733109474182,
-0.5037146210670471,
-0.40705862641334534,
0.10969725996255875,
0.6022014021873474,
-0.49568524956703186,
-0.04431874677538872,
0.3744390308856964,
-0.97975754737854,
-0.4378036558628082,
-0.5789358615875244,
0.030152544379234314,
0.2674414813518524,
-0.7598903775215149,
0.3281719386577606,
-0.42882785201072693,
-0.11637628823518753,
-0.12771962583065033,
-0.32835546135902405,
-0.5936748385429382,
0.1769970953464508,
0.23672901093959808,
0.5724651217460632,
-1.0572432279586792,
0.7115812301635742,
0.5141234993934631,
-0.2871224582195282,
-1.0145493745803833,
0.062138207256793976,
0.20886197686195374,
-0.8514000773429871,
0.3282702565193176,
0.3448055386543274,
-0.0835895910859108,
-0.0775495320558548,
-0.7037835717201233,
-1.298432469367981,
0.6969780921936035,
0.7708256840705872,
-0.7889943718910217,
-0.030087649822235107,
0.1391299068927765,
0.679606556892395,
-0.1799807995557785,
0.004088957328349352,
0.6519002914428711,
0.37111544609069824,
-0.23159383237361908,
-1.0976001024246216,
0.01931742951273918,
-0.04380248486995697,
-0.10155889391899109,
0.5056811571121216,
-0.7161736488342285,
0.9358246326446533,
-0.04483702406287193,
-0.3109370470046997,
0.1970987170934677,
0.5905855298042297,
0.05854538828134537,
-0.13996316492557526,
0.660728931427002,
0.8161302208900452,
0.9120343923568726,
-0.26331567764282227,
1.1291993856430054,
-0.5147786736488342,
0.21437320113182068,
1.191702961921692,
-0.4349496364593506,
0.8159373998641968,
0.7894508838653564,
-0.042098067700862885,
0.26302433013916016,
0.5519120097160339,
0.10604652017354965,
0.3076031506061554,
0.2748323380947113,
0.2745339870452881,
-0.2972363829612732,
-0.30754104256629944,
-0.19761347770690918,
0.578819751739502,
0.26750102639198303,
-0.08066419512033463,
0.14812880754470825,
-0.31378790736198425,
0.06737680733203888,
0.28470662236213684,
-0.37076234817504883,
0.6272884607315063,
0.07996165752410889,
-0.7704161405563354,
0.6193754076957703,
-0.32601499557495117,
0.6948437690734863,
-0.6001412868499756,
0.2304513156414032,
-0.07045398652553558,
0.29027149081230164,
-0.35758525133132935,
-0.6815264225006104,
0.5066940188407898,
-0.25640860199928284,
-0.2331756353378296,
-0.24550017714500427,
0.6168676018714905,
-0.6519792675971985,
-0.2353321760892868,
0.10327764600515366,
0.3041399419307709,
-0.00826484989374876,
0.19357717037200928,
-0.44856560230255127,
0.43739014863967896,
-0.13063764572143555,
-0.5955691933631897,
0.6600152850151062,
0.483248770236969,
-0.0015298305079340935,
0.6799846887588501,
0.6029259562492371,
0.26922568678855896,
-0.08279084414243698,
-0.27002114057540894,
0.7008582353591919,
-0.2854614555835724,
-0.1410321146249771,
-1.0799750089645386,
0.5939581394195557,
0.03855064511299133,
-0.3089768588542938,
0.7017630338668823,
0.4488620162010193,
1.0247870683670044,
0.30611005425453186,
0.2324577420949936,
0.2945781350135803,
0.3400750458240509,
-0.698896586894989,
0.6861804723739624,
-0.7980836033821106,
0.5092940926551819,
-0.23682010173797607,
-1.0310285091400146,
-0.37963205575942993,
0.6276435852050781,
-0.4269598126411438,
0.05042482912540436,
0.4967491924762726,
0.9512293338775635,
-0.09199561178684235,
-0.2790299654006958,
0.2437278777360916,
0.38382139801979065,
0.2556535005569458,
0.11956478655338287,
0.6144980788230896,
-0.24258145689964294,
0.35933491587638855,
-0.13277067244052887,
0.07686030864715576,
-0.13378581404685974,
-1.0156817436218262,
-0.5556179285049438,
-0.4177576005458832,
-0.27911844849586487,
-0.5092177987098694,
-0.025325700640678406,
1.025019645690918,
0.5786523222923279,
-0.580299437046051,
-0.15832866728305817,
-0.13729821145534515,
0.05115003511309624,
0.011798059567809105,
-0.17511874437332153,
0.22207239270210266,
-0.39319515228271484,
-0.7588090300559998,
0.28474223613739014,
0.1587965041399002,
0.47185051441192627,
0.039948973804712296,
-0.004854076076298952,
-0.09433470666408539,
0.197165846824646,
0.06049391254782677,
0.6295771598815918,
-0.6360533833503723,
-0.6426804661750793,
-0.04321353882551193,
-0.29072245955467224,
0.13698484003543854,
0.7499445676803589,
-0.4044685959815979,
0.19100189208984375,
0.2929043769836426,
0.7849564552307129,
-0.07666392624378204,
0.12535245716571808,
0.9879713654518127,
-0.7740755081176758,
0.4437617361545563,
0.05295870453119278,
0.6231542229652405,
0.29399019479751587,
-0.30428969860076904,
0.3516048192977905,
-0.07799308001995087,
-0.85091233253479,
-1.3262090682983398,
0.2709485590457916,
-0.5544090270996094,
-0.21892476081848145,
0.974132776260376,
0.17721164226531982,
-0.5475346446037292,
0.2736445665359497,
0.01847655698657036,
0.27492809295654297,
-0.06518334895372391,
0.9791109561920166,
1.0697708129882812,
-0.01343173161149025,
-0.12306628376245499,
-0.25156766176223755,
0.5507712364196777,
0.9656645655632019,
-0.42578092217445374,
0.3486350476741791,
0.35696887969970703,
0.2935931384563446,
-0.051367342472076416,
0.20527909696102142,
0.04047711193561554,
-0.08539388328790665,
-0.4077770709991455,
0.06035543978214264,
0.005628095008432865,
-0.2560953199863434,
-0.8043529987335205,
-0.06990543007850647,
0.45123887062072754,
0.2145249843597412
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.06140v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.06140v1
|
Can I understand what I create? Self-Knowledge Evaluation of Large Language Models
| 2024-06-10T09:53:54 | 2024-06-10T09:53:54 |
Zhiquan Tan, Lai Wei, Jindong Wang, Xing Xie, Weiran Huang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Large language models (LLMs) have achieved remarkable progress in linguistic
tasks, necessitating robust evaluation frameworks to understand their
capabilities and limitations. Inspired by Feynman's principle of understanding
through creation, we introduce a self-knowledge evaluation framework that is
easy to implement, evaluating models on their ability to comprehend and respond
to self-generated questions. Our findings, based on testing multiple models
across diverse tasks, reveal significant gaps in the model's self-knowledge
ability. Further analysis indicates these gaps may be due to misalignment with
human attention mechanisms. Additionally, fine-tuning on self-generated math
task may enhance the model's math performance, highlighting the potential of
the framework for efficient and insightful model evaluation and may also
contribute to the improvement of LLMs.
|
[
-0.44521287083625793,
-0.679563581943512,
0.8373869061470032,
0.5046749711036682,
0.11392825096845627,
-0.04932311549782753,
-0.15051408112049103,
-0.2615092992782593,
-0.11702446639537811,
0.5261846780776978,
-0.8047624230384827,
-0.1468578428030014,
-0.5764897465705872,
0.1460578292608261,
-0.4306478202342987,
0.7003606557846069,
0.11875767260789871,
0.1528853476047516,
-0.57755446434021,
0.1115429624915123,
-0.5449074506759644,
-0.2261587530374527,
-0.45907536149024963,
-0.6373239159584045,
0.4859868884086609,
0.13366709649562836,
0.500552237033844,
0.7676010131835938,
0.5679433345794678,
0.38153311610221863,
-0.08735179901123047,
0.07398402690887451,
-0.5130390524864197,
0.11353272944688797,
-0.5351612567901611,
-0.45432549715042114,
-0.12180418521165848,
-0.20759601891040802,
0.690131425857544,
0.8889496326446533,
0.03342527523636818,
0.3791269361972809,
0.3491970896720886,
0.6776483058929443,
-0.5108232498168945,
0.05327064171433449,
-0.6510038375854492,
0.2294284701347351,
-0.0059434399008750916,
-0.11626949161291122,
-0.17473305761814117,
-0.14486882090568542,
0.271297812461853,
-0.3957323133945465,
0.2788865268230438,
-0.08370592445135117,
0.48025885224342346,
0.3018522560596466,
-0.6227202415466309,
-0.3731693923473358,
-0.6337580680847168,
0.7731361985206604,
-0.892008364200592,
0.4681360125541687,
0.24589039385318756,
0.5875260233879089,
-0.21089035272598267,
-0.6570308208465576,
-0.5779106616973877,
-0.19386276602745056,
-0.10631304234266281,
0.12493107467889786,
-0.1019301638007164,
-0.07209578156471252,
0.368986576795578,
0.5709766745567322,
-0.6515659093856812,
0.1555708795785904,
-0.4304039180278778,
-0.2751437723636627,
0.6743338108062744,
0.38331374526023865,
0.5398843288421631,
-0.47094571590423584,
-0.10494024306535721,
0.15397387742996216,
-0.6328855752944946,
-0.17925214767456055,
0.4123988151550293,
0.11536223441362381,
-0.00560524920001626,
0.8791083693504333,
-0.24646195769309998,
0.7686889171600342,
-0.057634759694337845,
-0.260005921125412,
-0.07221981137990952,
-0.31667038798332214,
-0.4861791431903839,
-0.3876800537109375,
0.7634115815162659,
0.017650950700044632,
0.22427953779697418,
-0.2221992462873459,
-0.21082869172096252,
-0.11639177799224854,
0.3220658600330353,
-0.6851506233215332,
-0.20070694386959076,
0.11019165813922882,
-0.5426782965660095,
-0.27514374256134033,
-0.18930721282958984,
-0.2041199803352356,
-0.49890023469924927,
-0.48221132159233093,
0.5987625122070312,
-0.21832552552223206,
-0.336485356092453,
0.36970341205596924,
0.09531890600919724,
0.23496641218662262,
0.40805289149284363,
-0.9236952066421509,
0.2584344744682312,
0.7129582762718201,
0.6646115779876709,
-0.02245401032269001,
-0.5324718952178955,
-0.3896067440509796,
0.02305876463651657,
-0.4444922208786011,
0.8672084808349609,
-0.09134367108345032,
-0.37170666456222534,
-0.2569209337234497,
-0.24825197458267212,
-0.30983904004096985,
-0.6131054759025574,
0.08361587673425674,
-0.5084498524665833,
0.2453310489654541,
-0.24211686849594116,
-0.8164390921592712,
-0.23642320930957794,
0.27103540301322937,
-0.38148432970046997,
0.8176155090332031,
0.09426876902580261,
-0.5601244568824768,
0.024329863488674164,
-0.6719098091125488,
-0.3738206624984741,
0.2888377904891968,
-0.3713356852531433,
-0.11189775913953781,
0.44419610500335693,
0.22017937898635864,
0.5198377966880798,
-0.5400800704956055,
0.3473215699195862,
-0.49207237362861633,
0.028113625943660736,
0.562065839767456,
-0.42462149262428284,
0.8026736974716187,
0.408447265625,
-0.351467102766037,
0.07977008074522018,
-0.7147365212440491,
0.22828754782676697,
0.14598537981510162,
-0.23807762563228607,
-0.08178680390119553,
0.05184672027826309,
-0.2588665187358856,
0.29692772030830383,
0.3924447000026703,
-0.20536352694034576,
0.11701435595750809,
-0.7202181220054626,
0.35729536414146423,
0.9020453095436096,
0.08184485882520676,
0.34082144498825073,
-0.22561043500900269,
0.7067705988883972,
-0.19424106180667877,
-0.08958470076322556,
-0.3609640598297119,
-0.11106665432453156,
-1.1667490005493164,
-0.0372101292014122,
0.21242207288742065,
0.2619893252849579,
-0.283003568649292,
0.5647477507591248,
-0.11019856482744217,
-0.6229965090751648,
-0.34253132343292236,
0.7199307084083557,
0.4674374759197235,
0.42363089323043823,
0.09287228435277939,
-0.14001809060573578,
-0.3050420880317688,
-1.0068913698196411,
-0.5324116349220276,
-0.018173495307564735,
-0.28109070658683777,
0.4190395474433899,
0.7627195119857788,
-0.42423877120018005,
0.8479018807411194,
-0.648673951625824,
0.03800146281719208,
-0.23318782448768616,
0.16333156824111938,
0.16288720071315765,
0.5136458277702332,
0.4566553235054016,
-0.31026485562324524,
-0.22573652863502502,
0.11899509280920029,
-1.122502088546753,
-0.22102609276771545,
-0.03302114084362984,
-0.20674271881580353,
-0.41746270656585693,
0.49117663502693176,
-0.4223521053791046,
0.25650274753570557,
0.40220555663108826,
-0.5667795538902283,
0.5368873476982117,
-0.3486044108867645,
-0.07810933887958527,
-1.0189741849899292,
-0.08688479661941528,
-0.1257256120443344,
-0.21460141241550446,
-0.43977051973342896,
-0.005232543218880892,
0.14787650108337402,
-0.20174342393875122,
-0.2924841046333313,
0.8712061047554016,
-0.6306402683258057,
-0.29283687472343445,
-0.2696208655834198,
0.36656808853149414,
0.08361177146434784,
0.1513185352087021,
-0.38396722078323364,
0.5404703617095947,
0.689533531665802,
-0.7988598346710205,
0.2077750563621521,
0.2036752849817276,
-0.9480358362197876,
0.43796300888061523,
-0.9484080672264099,
0.23420578241348267,
-0.19635409116744995,
-0.46863651275634766,
-1.2200826406478882,
-0.3752480447292328,
0.0349002331495285,
-0.3203869163990021,
0.19492006301879883,
-0.0922447219491005,
-0.44668683409690857,
-0.4816844165325165,
0.2591095268726349,
0.3722725212574005,
0.3357192277908325,
-0.7171320915222168,
0.7853977680206299,
0.22935017943382263,
-0.21320514380931854,
-0.38529732823371887,
-0.58327317237854,
-0.14314483106136322,
-0.15407966077327728,
-0.9122734665870667,
-0.03223635256290436,
-0.42157086730003357,
-0.5578181743621826,
-0.10661960393190384,
-0.11624092608690262,
0.05953630432486534,
0.544389009475708,
0.2017519325017929,
-0.18655754625797272,
-0.27235329151153564,
0.4335719048976898,
0.22446173429489136,
0.04680943116545677,
0.38538315892219543,
-0.1582438200712204,
0.44722071290016174,
-0.03600195422768593,
-0.6855542659759521,
-0.2970179319381714,
-0.09013283997774124,
0.5632070899009705,
-0.332587867975235,
0.20983734726905823,
0.1760094314813614,
-0.3649824261665344,
-0.37769949436187744,
-0.630549967288971,
-0.306122750043869,
-0.5028558373451233,
0.3703099489212036,
-0.5273587703704834,
-1.0622084140777588,
0.55446457862854,
0.008675307035446167,
0.009625009261071682,
0.7603256106376648,
0.6980948448181152,
-0.16179847717285156,
1.1667108535766602,
0.6854274272918701,
0.15650196373462677,
0.1772739440202713,
-0.17845645546913147,
0.23855939507484436,
-0.9085692763328552,
-0.19000977277755737,
-0.4302341341972351,
-0.07341504096984863,
-0.2642783224582672,
-0.4427754580974579,
0.27368229627609253,
0.3293290138244629,
-0.28734323382377625,
0.09709141403436661,
-0.2675796151161194,
0.5962141156196594,
0.2876138389110565,
-0.012699920684099197,
0.272273987531662,
-0.19182004034519196,
-0.10775628685951233,
-0.14520174264907837,
-0.6485978960990906,
-0.6303590536117554,
1.1538772583007812,
0.6616180539131165,
0.9892064929008484,
0.21596354246139526,
0.714565634727478,
0.38617637753486633,
0.32231006026268005,
-0.7868964672088623,
0.42776650190353394,
0.25026050209999084,
-0.7150503396987915,
-0.38304805755615234,
-0.6116292476654053,
-0.8163618445396423,
0.4219566583633423,
-0.21020251512527466,
-0.7407789826393127,
-0.1820351928472519,
0.2015937715768814,
-0.46136000752449036,
-0.105682872235775,
-0.7339393496513367,
1.2253059148788452,
-0.6773396134376526,
-0.08116819709539413,
-0.3914695978164673,
-0.14210297167301178,
0.5432850122451782,
-0.25508880615234375,
0.3213619589805603,
-0.4954124689102173,
0.1404404491186142,
0.8787244558334351,
-0.4084321856498718,
0.8520090579986572,
0.09543754905462265,
-0.32250839471817017,
0.4223746359348297,
0.45470473170280457,
0.034205351024866104,
0.21917961537837982,
-0.03693976253271103,
-0.06420022249221802,
-0.041882533580064774,
-0.21270427107810974,
-1.1583575010299683,
0.7227413654327393,
-0.7100782990455627,
-0.7720920443534851,
-0.14942564070224762,
-0.6646289825439453,
-0.11883874237537384,
0.40328073501586914,
0.01489137765020132,
0.4404259920120239,
-0.2816166281700134,
0.14878684282302856,
0.5170770883560181,
-0.2514709234237671,
0.3147048056125641,
0.6405065059661865,
-0.5694014430046082,
-0.36588141322135925,
0.794903576374054,
0.22175006568431854,
0.12572646141052246,
0.21551953256130219,
0.537205696105957,
-0.504514753818512,
-0.45933589339256287,
-0.4047571122646332,
0.3979755640029907,
-1.0198296308517456,
-0.12244194000959396,
-0.5604581832885742,
-0.13240359723567963,
-0.6005020141601562,
-0.06620301306247711,
-0.33064034581184387,
-0.29392051696777344,
-0.2785841226577759,
-0.030950337648391724,
-0.004262384958565235,
1.3170841932296753,
-0.10338139533996582,
0.497708797454834,
-0.642911970615387,
0.15435124933719635,
0.7827382683753967,
0.3092573285102844,
0.3226785659790039,
-0.8162083029747009,
-0.35379311442375183,
0.06147993728518486,
-0.5037432312965393,
-0.6961628794670105,
0.3504866361618042,
0.06582021713256836,
0.769885778427124,
0.6227770447731018,
-0.2744322717189789,
0.7579116821289062,
-0.4476752281188965,
0.6222792267799377,
0.32350894808769226,
-1.3966871500015259,
0.5931873917579651,
-0.3203217685222626,
0.4937077760696411,
0.16818515956401825,
0.2195991575717926,
-0.15192589163780212,
-0.3465130031108856,
-0.5613027215003967,
-0.460470974445343,
0.4117022454738617,
0.3484049141407013,
0.2914845645427704,
0.04425562918186188,
0.5733237266540527,
-0.05488178879022598,
0.12605763971805573,
-0.9711484909057617,
-0.1725545972585678,
-0.018712976947426796,
-0.18537388741970062,
-0.15131404995918274,
-0.3893113136291504,
-0.05442097410559654,
-0.16251875460147858,
0.45095106959342957,
-0.3549707233905792,
0.1582288295030594,
0.08104277402162552,
-0.22062788903713226,
-0.22113846242427826,
0.17813941836357117,
0.5183563828468323,
1.2080305814743042,
0.1862831562757492,
0.20513176918029785,
0.4035939872264862,
0.18457911908626556,
-0.07747910171747208,
-0.05765508487820625,
0.08791029453277588,
-0.3960057497024536,
0.6187008619308472,
0.7439833283424377,
0.35737717151641846,
-0.7702090740203857,
0.33467042446136475,
-0.16677318513393402,
-0.21433214843273163,
-0.1401429921388626,
0.32778191566467285,
0.3118233382701874,
0.47543326020240784,
0.26591312885284424,
-0.2209038883447647,
0.2195301204919815,
-0.5243346691131592,
0.14192944765090942,
0.5213426351547241,
-0.20916245877742767,
-0.1695847511291504,
0.5604987740516663,
-0.17154501378536224,
-0.35841989517211914,
0.4527580440044403,
0.10163357108831406,
-0.5082799196243286,
0.6730633974075317,
0.7857092022895813,
0.9209083914756775,
-0.2792278826236725,
0.13169467449188232,
0.3558807373046875,
0.30767112970352173,
-0.043540287762880325,
0.3303837180137634,
-0.36599770188331604,
-0.9074655175209045,
-0.5326957702636719,
-0.8856939673423767,
-0.1871432662010193,
0.16008581221103668,
-0.6089789271354675,
0.15290051698684692,
-0.44870468974113464,
-0.011143971234560013,
0.21697980165481567,
-0.23692423105239868,
-0.8060392737388611,
0.5169869065284729,
-0.16325779259204865,
0.7491308450698853,
-0.6868566870689392,
0.449384868144989,
0.4339854419231415,
-0.17389962077140808,
-0.8375699520111084,
-0.10663406550884247,
-0.24966606497764587,
-0.9733261466026306,
0.9168824553489685,
0.2507114112377167,
-0.15094433724880219,
0.09264414757490158,
-0.4641551971435547,
-1.062895655632019,
0.8503202795982361,
0.4934264123439789,
-0.5985932946205139,
-0.011867997236549854,
0.04815245792269707,
0.650592565536499,
-0.4133112132549286,
0.3494004011154175,
0.40492361783981323,
0.2466636598110199,
-0.07833443582057953,
-0.8286216259002686,
-0.17384594678878784,
-0.16402828693389893,
0.18751634657382965,
0.037789683789014816,
-0.35826537013053894,
0.7479462027549744,
-0.36489951610565186,
-0.24972066283226013,
0.07519200444221497,
0.8862542510032654,
0.01411281619220972,
0.10549996048212051,
0.4415222108364105,
0.5300809741020203,
0.7440210580825806,
-0.008488464169204235,
0.9747450351715088,
-0.48151519894599915,
0.6175181269645691,
1.2390649318695068,
0.04142405092716217,
0.48260554671287537,
0.1425699144601822,
-0.09444630146026611,
0.27395814657211304,
0.5859481692314148,
0.0005246251821517944,
0.24915441870689392,
0.5847173929214478,
-0.1490548998117447,
-0.7436830401420593,
0.14086484909057617,
-0.31358858942985535,
0.6046098470687866,
0.2748771607875824,
-0.5125159621238708,
-0.26679691672325134,
0.06280681490898132,
-0.320002943277359,
0.16012221574783325,
-0.4210803806781769,
0.8746146559715271,
0.23378394544124603,
-0.6307379603385925,
0.49423277378082275,
-0.03650970384478569,
0.16231638193130493,
-0.6753400564193726,
0.13976743817329407,
-0.08257787674665451,
0.14880026876926422,
-0.12272405624389648,
-1.0158400535583496,
0.3684502840042114,
-0.10251617431640625,
-0.15879365801811218,
-0.17688435316085815,
0.6755788922309875,
-0.3415581285953522,
-0.6616167426109314,
0.34381258487701416,
0.8957863450050354,
0.2022755742073059,
-0.01617598719894886,
-0.7790808081626892,
0.10209265351295471,
0.024302417412400246,
-0.28903961181640625,
0.18834362924098969,
0.4902562201023102,
0.3800554573535919,
0.9678366184234619,
0.5593825578689575,
-0.11131148040294647,
0.012539180926978588,
0.17420300841331482,
0.6350846886634827,
-0.7896489500999451,
-0.2745055556297302,
-1.1297188997268677,
0.3575126528739929,
0.09621014446020126,
-0.40489819645881653,
1.1184041500091553,
0.6373741626739502,
0.8833257555961609,
-0.3270392119884491,
1.0341650247573853,
0.1367466300725937,
0.46979591250419617,
-0.5541090369224548,
0.8517253994941711,
-0.8077970147132874,
0.23546689748764038,
-0.46012285351753235,
-0.8363522887229919,
-0.22371028363704681,
0.9651718139648438,
-0.6091455817222595,
0.10096332430839539,
0.43908777832984924,
0.6804542541503906,
-0.09340198338031769,
-0.22323884069919586,
0.7411260008811951,
0.24968042969703674,
0.32013916969299316,
0.3590831458568573,
1.12550687789917,
-0.3030513525009155,
0.2889893651008606,
-0.3070923089981079,
-0.13534806668758392,
0.0461026206612587,
-0.8898425698280334,
-1.2918509244918823,
-0.5362040996551514,
-0.28523004055023193,
-0.2728279232978821,
-0.3292323350906372,
0.771038293838501,
0.7422287464141846,
-0.558189868927002,
-0.6186004281044006,
-0.2531164586544037,
0.4568677246570587,
0.07359572499990463,
-0.21815241873264313,
0.22430266439914703,
-0.6461536884307861,
-0.6276925206184387,
0.625474214553833,
0.4166867136955261,
0.3078230619430542,
-0.7150144577026367,
-0.12357605248689651,
0.3198363184928894,
0.16439937055110931,
0.7542391419410706,
0.11608520150184631,
-0.7550526261329651,
-0.2297380566596985,
0.11236303299665451,
0.025350546464323997,
-0.24913965165615082,
0.9763996601104736,
-0.41015157103538513,
0.8085913062095642,
0.4777826964855194,
0.7656344771385193,
0.4605383574962616,
-0.29463061690330505,
0.7165552973747253,
-0.08327153325080872,
-0.3569262623786926,
0.029926657676696777,
0.5874941945075989,
0.3945530652999878,
-0.4546443819999695,
0.44232177734375,
0.15192227065563202,
-0.6832836866378784,
-0.7509127259254456,
0.4355916976928711,
-0.710136353969574,
-0.19588957726955414,
0.9405770897865295,
-0.15001481771469116,
-0.22075243294239044,
0.07617185264825821,
-0.1813976764678955,
0.07661673426628113,
0.2717699706554413,
1.0178488492965698,
0.638588547706604,
-0.3151073753833771,
-0.18725727498531342,
-0.46739378571510315,
0.2869827449321747,
0.6002975702285767,
-0.8738963603973389,
0.07317503541707993,
0.4568392038345337,
0.7137494683265686,
0.19946421682834625,
0.49755051732063293,
0.06920573860406876,
0.1956215500831604,
-0.2548682987689972,
0.01872236840426922,
0.15506099164485931,
-0.42908775806427,
-0.36024144291877747,
0.09589044749736786,
0.43636080622673035,
0.3664684593677521
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.06139v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.06139v1
|
Thunder : Unified Regression-Diffusion Speech Enhancement with a Single Reverse Step using Brownian Bridge
| 2024-06-10T09:52:25 | 2024-06-10T09:52:25 |
Thanapat Trachu, Chawan Piansaddhayanon, Ekapol Chuangsuwanich
|
cs.SD
|
cs.SD, cs.AI, cs.CL, eess.AS
|
Diffusion-based speech enhancement has shown promising results, but can
suffer from a slower inference time. Initializing the diffusion process with
the enhanced audio generated by a regression-based model can be used to reduce
the computational steps required. However, these approaches often necessitate a
regression model, further increasing the system's complexity. We propose
Thunder, a unified regression-diffusion model that utilizes the Brownian bridge
process which can allow the model to act in both modes. The regression mode can
be accessed by setting the diffusion time step closed to 1. However, the
standard score-based diffusion modeling does not perform well in this setup due
to gradient instability. To mitigate this problem, we modify the diffusion
model to predict the clean speech instead of the score function, achieving
competitive performance with a more compact model size and fewer reverse steps.
|
[
-0.2007475197315216,
-1.1415672302246094,
0.3115924000740051,
0.7465159296989441,
-0.21162767708301544,
-0.07734788954257965,
0.09752970933914185,
-0.4921230971813202,
0.486812949180603,
0.6242684125900269,
-0.6133795976638794,
-0.15174385905265808,
-0.6564560532569885,
-0.4716591238975525,
-0.6053663492202759,
0.7957406044006348,
0.5671196579933167,
0.030365990474820137,
0.2752681076526642,
0.1884465515613556,
-0.8215754628181458,
0.1037641316652298,
-0.9998765587806702,
-0.8612089157104492,
0.42560064792633057,
0.1738830953836441,
0.9184792041778564,
0.308039128780365,
0.5448669791221619,
0.2315933108329773,
-0.4406874477863312,
-0.4519633948802948,
-0.3628585934638977,
0.3751801550388336,
-0.09446999430656433,
-0.20503276586532593,
-0.5517473220825195,
0.017480405047535896,
0.7457341551780701,
0.8059585690498352,
-0.5017052292823792,
0.052515219897031784,
0.1490289717912674,
0.7725377082824707,
-0.7014864683151245,
-0.2392662763595581,
-0.5531816482543945,
-0.13724957406520844,
-0.22944489121437073,
-0.15395396947860718,
-0.18144476413726807,
-0.17180092632770538,
0.13256798684597015,
-0.11566668748855591,
0.17321406304836273,
-0.08497679233551025,
0.6400619149208069,
0.2626335620880127,
-0.11278890818357468,
0.5166119337081909,
-1.2620867490768433,
0.7612599730491638,
-0.6422943472862244,
0.6171718835830688,
0.22036071121692657,
0.30747437477111816,
-0.15772303938865662,
-0.9081617593765259,
-0.21476809680461884,
-0.22305935621261597,
0.20316113531589508,
0.48120686411857605,
-0.5676732063293457,
0.31570950150489807,
-0.13047322630882263,
0.15389132499694824,
-0.5017402768135071,
0.0992417111992836,
-0.5153644680976868,
-0.3187239170074463,
0.6512759923934937,
0.21305207908153534,
0.06740623712539673,
0.0006648930138908327,
-0.3726123571395874,
0.06774239242076874,
-0.3527505099773407,
0.2750649154186249,
0.3138293921947479,
0.7881075739860535,
-0.07349077612161636,
0.031007418408989906,
-0.02434392087161541,
0.5494023561477661,
0.11249477416276932,
-0.4169844686985016,
0.18524028360843658,
0.10549528151750565,
-0.6481837630271912,
0.223066046833992,
0.74270099401474,
0.18285728991031647,
-0.39923834800720215,
-0.3871266841888428,
-0.3435099720954895,
0.07574914395809174,
0.14143361151218414,
-0.9930980205535889,
-0.24904341995716095,
0.42770758271217346,
-0.491725891828537,
-0.20957957208156586,
-0.13486842811107635,
-0.7853641510009766,
-0.5874574184417725,
-0.2250378131866455,
0.7674242258071899,
-0.3119893968105316,
-0.681524395942688,
0.26408323645591736,
-0.5525265336036682,
-0.11191494017839432,
0.4096004068851471,
-0.713262140750885,
0.6785767078399658,
0.284978449344635,
1.0899615287780762,
0.12544770538806915,
-0.039436936378479004,
-0.642178475856781,
0.07649241387844086,
-0.38278287649154663,
0.8344939947128296,
-0.8770488500595093,
-0.8374446034431458,
-0.4986877739429474,
-0.3908279538154602,
-0.060713332146406174,
-0.6553111672401428,
0.6752875447273254,
-0.3864215314388275,
0.0628315880894661,
0.18878129124641418,
-0.18650200963020325,
-0.12540261447429657,
-0.4511526823043823,
-0.4231336712837219,
0.8784807920455933,
0.004519288428127766,
-0.7283135652542114,
0.2834552526473999,
-1.1724426746368408,
-0.40753448009490967,
0.05851232260465622,
0.21431595087051392,
-0.4782564043998718,
0.16765321791172028,
0.19869345426559448,
0.29937925934791565,
-0.37360939383506775,
0.3313799500465393,
-0.4657193124294281,
-0.5840646028518677,
-0.3030393123626709,
-0.5943122506141663,
1.1705965995788574,
0.3432340919971466,
-0.4400181472301483,
0.15876683592796326,
-0.7671141028404236,
-0.18945422768592834,
-0.2038545161485672,
-0.10925549268722534,
-0.36157041788101196,
-0.13927580416202545,
0.3155533969402313,
-0.09437277913093567,
-0.26043060421943665,
-0.6516528129577637,
-0.0815582349896431,
-0.32531699538230896,
-0.01751294918358326,
0.9088324904441833,
0.015296044759452343,
0.5606254935264587,
-0.2926521599292755,
0.664455771446228,
0.36253082752227783,
0.18298561871051788,
0.1006913036108017,
-0.859506368637085,
-0.31773611903190613,
-0.7380079627037048,
0.6652855277061462,
0.7799845933914185,
0.0982472375035286,
0.10950575768947601,
-0.05284511297941208,
-0.6822192668914795,
-1.0430554151535034,
0.1790032982826233,
0.12705965340137482,
0.7012577056884766,
0.47102320194244385,
-0.43922024965286255,
-0.8464083075523376,
-0.971015989780426,
-0.12010025978088379,
-0.21741661429405212,
0.07328057289123535,
0.241524338722229,
0.14378054440021515,
-0.40904271602630615,
1.0812978744506836,
-0.4105660617351532,
-0.5107508301734924,
-0.27085456252098083,
0.6810001730918884,
0.44138169288635254,
0.6433963775634766,
0.4525788426399231,
-1.0076770782470703,
-0.3254390060901642,
-0.11879316717386246,
-0.41373974084854126,
-0.5621017813682556,
-0.11611028015613556,
0.031164925545454025,
-0.38676998019218445,
0.4308287799358368,
-0.1273367553949356,
0.6152942776679993,
0.7813692688941956,
-0.40096569061279297,
0.5294824838638306,
-0.03974056616425514,
0.44188058376312256,
-1.0136454105377197,
-0.008154192939400673,
0.4084339737892151,
-0.11712589859962463,
-0.8891894221305847,
-0.19998320937156677,
-0.1514131873846054,
-0.1530117243528366,
-0.33819779753685,
0.4647614657878876,
-0.16671794652938843,
0.23005549609661102,
-0.720306396484375,
0.22474823892116547,
-0.21085059642791748,
-0.1371908336877823,
0.029416341334581375,
0.6983245611190796,
1.1007146835327148,
-0.7991899847984314,
0.3234075605869293,
-0.13618336617946625,
-0.05133819580078125,
0.5169707536697388,
-0.6783947944641113,
-0.056769151240587234,
-0.4182306230068207,
0.3101525902748108,
-1.0593106746673584,
0.04626331105828285,
-0.03962041065096855,
-0.5063875317573547,
0.3098469078540802,
-0.19976556301116943,
-0.2779403328895569,
-0.4113032817840576,
-0.17709584534168243,
0.0895405262708664,
0.8455381393432617,
-0.4389292001724243,
0.5861693620681763,
0.4513395428657532,
-0.3213757872581482,
-0.4654068946838379,
-0.8641032576560974,
0.12945592403411865,
-0.5386760234832764,
-1.0266669988632202,
0.6711869835853577,
-0.22847698628902435,
-0.5303986072540283,
-0.1446341574192047,
-0.06770426034927368,
-0.3581014573574066,
0.2562524676322937,
0.5473306775093079,
0.2510485351085663,
-0.1749429851770401,
0.1350570023059845,
0.33109933137893677,
0.02294820360839367,
-0.20891837775707245,
-0.14499028027057648,
0.26641881465911865,
0.23012873530387878,
0.138647198677063,
-0.8899019956588745,
0.5168606638908386,
0.5203496813774109,
0.06140924245119095,
0.6905011534690857,
0.8854061365127563,
-0.24642804265022278,
0.07934839278459549,
-0.49838945269584656,
-0.49505308270454407,
-0.46104082465171814,
0.08021245896816254,
-0.4674590229988098,
-0.5987565517425537,
0.5784286856651306,
-0.33048567175865173,
0.1328190118074417,
0.27542680501937866,
0.30497798323631287,
-0.19996893405914307,
1.2001519203186035,
0.8296489715576172,
-0.2250177264213562,
0.7024535536766052,
0.04719410836696625,
-0.017046157270669937,
-0.9778783917427063,
-0.17928674817085266,
-0.7065906524658203,
-0.46836307644844055,
-0.28062692284584045,
0.06281349062919617,
0.2922559082508087,
0.5236726403236389,
-0.15116935968399048,
0.2463170737028122,
-0.3383261263370514,
0.21324115991592407,
0.737491250038147,
0.40501633286476135,
0.21319006383419037,
-0.09192177653312683,
-0.1800650954246521,
-0.13421766459941864,
-0.4701518714427948,
-0.05862440541386604,
0.7395521402359009,
0.3897339701652527,
1.0412561893463135,
0.1969069540500641,
0.8209294080734253,
0.5113555192947388,
0.4431505501270294,
-0.3154168725013733,
0.43989795446395874,
-0.07896051555871964,
-0.8323383331298828,
-0.3906473219394684,
-0.4736461043357849,
-1.140823483467102,
0.4430793821811676,
-0.27449163794517517,
-1.366943359375,
0.10347398370504379,
0.1620916724205017,
-0.5088016390800476,
0.3348475992679596,
-0.8615511655807495,
0.5171934366226196,
0.39963120222091675,
-0.38940688967704773,
-0.3213134706020355,
-0.4976663887500763,
0.6101056933403015,
-0.1262299120426178,
0.5343448519706726,
0.08437556773424149,
0.22027990221977234,
0.9856178760528564,
-0.118920236825943,
0.7918497920036316,
-0.37757545709609985,
-0.07493782788515091,
0.27405816316604614,
0.08711420744657516,
0.4870625138282776,
-0.059108614921569824,
-0.11024467647075653,
-0.20418281853199005,
-0.42034462094306946,
-0.3610824942588806,
-0.9035061001777649,
0.65986567735672,
-0.4765911400318146,
-1.0125117301940918,
0.08063671737909317,
-0.6192807555198669,
-0.3867993652820587,
-0.09965956956148148,
0.048648152500391006,
0.4810945391654968,
-0.002588641829788685,
0.16076134145259857,
0.3030718266963959,
0.2829596698284149,
0.8584252595901489,
0.555311381816864,
-0.6511023044586182,
-0.5563321709632874,
0.5331155061721802,
0.19203828275203705,
0.30004626512527466,
0.13427619636058807,
0.6045985817909241,
-0.3997690677642822,
-0.7326697111129761,
-0.03071952611207962,
0.04219507798552513,
-0.2684968411922455,
0.10436516255140305,
-0.5824358463287354,
-0.16202861070632935,
-0.8173072338104248,
-0.036300305277109146,
-0.37368130683898926,
-0.4095745384693146,
-0.21800562739372253,
0.08635697513818741,
0.21910563111305237,
0.5279993414878845,
-0.7059400081634521,
0.5202276706695557,
-0.7017386555671692,
0.6288119554519653,
0.4517301321029663,
0.5273187756538391,
-0.08106426894664764,
-1.1501368284225464,
-0.19097359478473663,
0.10905233025550842,
-0.5530272722244263,
-0.9458842873573303,
0.4220104515552521,
0.1252305656671524,
0.5091545581817627,
0.6236007213592529,
-0.07503169029951096,
1.3122448921203613,
-0.34514880180358887,
0.8622094988822937,
0.7102110385894775,
-0.9318923950195312,
1.013423204421997,
-0.29124048352241516,
0.34831273555755615,
0.04907327517867088,
0.06286818534135818,
-0.27852964401245117,
-0.6956676244735718,
-0.8977501392364502,
-0.779655933380127,
0.624943733215332,
0.5116782784461975,
0.16263680160045624,
0.4319274127483368,
-0.12502385675907135,
0.03968116641044617,
0.0031176533084362745,
-0.5425731539726257,
-0.7491012811660767,
-0.13845914602279663,
0.48616647720336914,
-0.02141287364065647,
0.03503228351473808,
-0.08448821306228638,
-0.49547088146209717,
1.0333547592163086,
0.43483999371528625,
0.1328941434621811,
0.17832733690738678,
0.3626191318035126,
-0.2971402704715729,
0.5732040405273438,
0.4003583788871765,
0.28236669301986694,
-0.7019321322441101,
-0.10672548413276672,
0.04485515505075455,
-0.8113305568695068,
0.12672659754753113,
0.3441876173019409,
-0.3611340820789337,
0.2264699637889862,
-0.00985066220164299,
0.9423017501831055,
0.22228173911571503,
-0.290177583694458,
0.24814653396606445,
-0.008977157063782215,
-0.2204449623823166,
0.33620020747184753,
0.15288251638412476,
0.0007788942893967032,
0.7079949975013733,
0.6133074760437012,
0.5522350072860718,
0.505395233631134,
-0.5760616064071655,
0.30893802642822266,
0.5718743205070496,
-0.8188823461532593,
-0.09166085720062256,
1.00391685962677,
0.25637489557266235,
-0.4725051820278168,
0.3476772606372833,
0.12223349511623383,
0.036881256848573685,
0.272926926612854,
0.9802466630935669,
1.2355626821517944,
-0.5632123947143555,
0.34455162286758423,
0.23421332240104675,
0.21089138090610504,
-0.1287488043308258,
0.2927303612232208,
0.09787581115961075,
-0.47862595319747925,
-0.42958420515060425,
-0.6459115743637085,
-0.3187701404094696,
0.30536577105522156,
-0.7968327403068542,
0.14184865355491638,
-0.17051340639591217,
-0.6180119514465332,
0.21865524351596832,
-0.29962900280952454,
-0.2600443959236145,
0.5814356207847595,
0.16244761645793915,
0.8404650688171387,
-0.9869799017906189,
0.8386742472648621,
0.626780092716217,
-0.42248818278312683,
-0.638198733329773,
0.05569733679294586,
-0.04629117250442505,
-0.1760064661502838,
0.8173593282699585,
-0.07976868003606796,
-0.39636489748954773,
0.11159902065992355,
-0.6078291535377502,
-0.5677794814109802,
1.0971506834030151,
0.7424322366714478,
-0.5492276549339294,
0.10921899974346161,
-0.34853097796440125,
0.29491880536079407,
-0.24338996410369873,
0.46571439504623413,
0.6793526411056519,
0.5695525407791138,
0.24533674120903015,
-1.3050603866577148,
-0.33853456377983093,
-0.031958919018507004,
0.10554191470146179,
0.11700036376714706,
-0.5388502478599548,
0.6768549680709839,
-0.5217141509056091,
-0.30574139952659607,
-0.018540287390351295,
0.941018283367157,
0.26529428362846375,
0.4320620596408844,
0.6826748847961426,
0.6632460355758667,
0.8602654337882996,
-0.04547327756881714,
0.8561550378799438,
0.1625870168209076,
0.3272165358066559,
0.9134970307350159,
0.01847993955016136,
0.9244868159294128,
0.5560887455940247,
-0.43220487236976624,
0.6907899975776672,
0.3791184723377228,
0.39693889021873474,
0.7685961723327637,
0.05405469983816147,
-0.4235541522502899,
-0.4016111493110657,
-0.1991938054561615,
-0.4548056721687317,
0.3799041509628296,
0.0982699990272522,
-0.40854910016059875,
-0.378417432308197,
0.1685652732849121,
-0.10495341569185257,
0.07089829444885254,
-0.8896474242210388,
0.4961467385292053,
0.0414145328104496,
-0.3317790627479553,
0.3708142936229706,
-0.19555705785751343,
0.7925406098365784,
-0.5860034227371216,
0.07228309661149979,
-0.23817509412765503,
-0.09318836778402328,
-0.3520655930042267,
-0.6302980184555054,
0.17841792106628418,
-0.12106573581695557,
-0.44515421986579895,
-0.11786439269781113,
0.5807684659957886,
-0.29454904794692993,
-0.48343437910079956,
0.6827198266983032,
0.4510917365550995,
0.180906742811203,
-0.17783179879188538,
-0.8903389573097229,
-0.010617831721901894,
-0.1849726140499115,
-0.25993072986602783,
0.40462976694107056,
-0.053220078349113464,
0.4849432110786438,
0.9146599769592285,
0.578770637512207,
0.4754393398761749,
0.1917298287153244,
0.6029913425445557,
0.5119318962097168,
-0.7413779497146606,
-0.6421679258346558,
-0.8947912454605103,
0.8228152990341187,
-0.050969380885362625,
-0.10983619838953018,
0.5607284903526306,
0.577286422252655,
0.04882064461708069,
0.043309181928634644,
0.8926379084587097,
0.001382768852636218,
0.7134290337562561,
-0.4777578115463257,
0.6132709383964539,
-0.6447052359580994,
0.35819363594055176,
-0.9323152303695679,
-0.8946707248687744,
-0.5480023622512817,
0.30257081985473633,
-0.09474772959947586,
0.12787975370883942,
0.6043312549591064,
1.1127393245697021,
-0.11775539070367813,
0.3206652104854584,
0.8400239944458008,
0.3417101502418518,
0.21383699774742126,
0.028730444610118866,
0.41982701420783997,
-0.6199604272842407,
0.5883126854896545,
-0.31966206431388855,
-0.5516940951347351,
-0.011999092996120453,
-0.6346221566200256,
-0.5758852958679199,
-0.6825791001319885,
-0.6369433403015137,
-0.6638866662979126,
0.28127843141555786,
0.5396099090576172,
1.126724362373352,
-0.6355320811271667,
-0.26780664920806885,
-0.2876373827457428,
-0.00017402040248271078,
-0.684312641620636,
-0.3468678891658783,
0.13368596136569977,
-0.4287331998348236,
-0.7794241905212402,
0.8864343166351318,
0.610690176486969,
0.25006604194641113,
-0.2135533094406128,
0.013071256689727306,
-0.11395017802715302,
0.41372984647750854,
0.3821565806865692,
0.25434935092926025,
-0.7735111117362976,
-0.11502020806074142,
-0.35907965898513794,
0.1598069816827774,
0.07192850112915039,
0.6372051239013672,
-1.17372727394104,
0.6789788603782654,
0.2325994372367859,
0.29746830463409424,
0.4974662959575653,
0.19466328620910645,
0.5540843605995178,
-0.6143171787261963,
0.14785327017307281,
0.146132230758667,
0.5204723477363586,
0.08034341782331467,
-0.05431459844112396,
0.24382764101028442,
0.42124730348587036,
-0.5037693977355957,
-0.8392112255096436,
0.18690554797649384,
-1.089890956878662,
-0.34531542658805847,
1.1759544610977173,
0.18111589550971985,
0.01391881238669157,
-0.3090018033981323,
-0.47612032294273376,
0.09995759278535843,
-0.8308953642845154,
0.976424515247345,
0.30239391326904297,
-0.4234517812728882,
-0.43804028630256653,
-0.23484666645526886,
0.2781645357608795,
0.1757083237171173,
-0.38527241349220276,
-0.029249224811792374,
0.22584398090839386,
0.14265510439872742,
0.42087289690971375,
0.7267722487449646,
-0.16048626601696014,
0.49261122941970825,
0.5143667459487915,
-0.33653613924980164,
0.14683182537555695,
-0.42608219385147095,
-0.43998685479164124,
0.5944111943244934,
-0.128225177526474,
-0.3807855546474457
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.06131v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.06131v1
|
Building Bridges: A Dataset for Evaluating Gender-Fair Machine Translation into German
| 2024-06-10T09:39:19 | 2024-06-10T09:39:19 |
Manuel Lardelli, Giuseppe Attanasio, Anne Lauscher
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The translation of gender-neutral person-referring terms (e.g., the students)
is often non-trivial. Translating from English into German poses an interesting
case -- in German, person-referring nouns are usually gender-specific, and if
the gender of the referent(s) is unknown or diverse, the generic masculine (die
Studenten (m.)) is commonly used. This solution, however, reduces the
visibility of other genders, such as women and non-binary people. To counteract
gender discrimination, a societal movement towards using gender-fair language
exists (e.g., by adopting neosystems). However, gender-fair German is currently
barely supported in machine translation (MT), requiring post-editing or manual
translations. We address this research gap by studying gender-fair language in
English-to-German MT. Concretely, we enrich a community-created gender-fair
language dictionary and sample multi-sentence test instances from encyclopedic
text and parliamentary speeches. Using these novel resources, we conduct the
first benchmark study involving two commercial systems and six neural MT models
for translating words in isolation and natural contexts across two domains. Our
findings show that most systems produce mainly masculine forms and rarely
gender-neutral variants, highlighting the need for future research. We release
code and data at
https://github.com/g8a9/building-bridges-gender-fair-german-mt.
|
[
-0.30365055799484253,
-0.6129451990127563,
0.35229548811912537,
0.13847646117210388,
-0.007208247669041157,
-0.18148815631866455,
-0.196587935090065,
-0.16603118181228638,
-0.2820597290992737,
0.12134873121976852,
-0.5739606022834778,
-0.4304702877998352,
-0.8189042210578918,
0.5663556456565857,
-0.6308086514472961,
0.9601886868476868,
-0.24842897057533264,
0.4954207241535187,
-0.3456932604312897,
-0.4122459292411804,
-0.5191775560379028,
-0.3220662474632263,
-0.4089771807193756,
-0.5945802330970764,
0.5218852162361145,
0.35148167610168457,
0.7623113989830017,
0.6819629073143005,
0.45450344681739807,
0.31303730607032776,
-0.15474581718444824,
-0.18425346910953522,
-0.4731319844722748,
-0.007732379250228405,
-0.4778038263320923,
-0.4628933370113373,
-0.4639332890510559,
0.3141700327396393,
0.6510480642318726,
1.146010160446167,
0.010980485007166862,
0.4809975028038025,
0.2802470028400421,
0.798952579498291,
-0.2965813875198364,
0.3125293552875519,
-0.5028201937675476,
0.09133344888687134,
-0.5381185412406921,
0.14873585104942322,
-0.3299815058708191,
-0.2364804446697235,
0.09916312992572784,
-0.2258531153202057,
0.4326963722705841,
0.08738160133361816,
1.020235300064087,
-0.07118627429008484,
-0.7302636504173279,
-0.12340664863586426,
-0.1592118889093399,
0.7269874215126038,
-0.47216930985450745,
0.6198131442070007,
0.38182327151298523,
0.5392591953277588,
-0.2910431921482086,
-0.49807488918304443,
-0.3937892019748688,
0.06156022474169731,
-0.1558355838060379,
-0.030969584360718727,
-0.4809381365776062,
-0.24266305565834045,
0.09615646302700043,
0.10873796045780182,
-0.633510410785675,
-0.17453186213970184,
-0.5453214049339294,
0.022941606119275093,
0.3562791049480438,
-0.10794061422348022,
0.3487347662448883,
-0.5384131073951721,
-0.10208604484796524,
-0.16302835941314697,
-0.5341228246688843,
-0.022911768406629562,
0.6617286801338196,
0.6583799719810486,
-0.330304354429245,
0.5928789973258972,
0.02637980319559574,
0.416727751493454,
-0.0908232256770134,
0.2910798490047455,
0.8480191826820374,
-0.15822724997997284,
-0.08904359489679337,
-0.10915180295705795,
0.5630678534507751,
0.44994306564331055,
0.49478599429130554,
-0.5844223499298096,
-0.39901497960090637,
0.29631736874580383,
0.16020435094833374,
-0.7795447707176208,
-0.003100018249824643,
-0.20860294997692108,
-0.7147111296653748,
-0.2273183912038803,
0.016879435628652573,
-0.4138058125972748,
-0.025648802518844604,
-0.4369460940361023,
0.3120589852333069,
-0.10247035324573517,
-0.3731381297111511,
0.1245250254869461,
-0.45220547914505005,
0.03858480602502823,
-0.061131566762924194,
-0.45465439558029175,
0.3085779547691345,
0.5789108276367188,
0.610727846622467,
0.0101619902998209,
-0.3820365369319916,
-0.6566585898399353,
0.07314981520175934,
-0.3040233552455902,
0.3115865886211395,
-0.3830059766769409,
-0.30541080236434937,
0.05973900482058525,
0.44938793778419495,
0.036435797810554504,
-0.5876256227493286,
0.672798752784729,
-0.29188212752342224,
0.6689298748970032,
-0.24336615204811096,
-0.29652586579322815,
-0.01307715941220522,
0.08312959969043732,
-0.44708678126335144,
0.8144453763961792,
0.1412091851234436,
-0.7119930982589722,
0.0822540745139122,
-0.7503888010978699,
-0.6930083632469177,
-0.1418357491493225,
-0.27504774928092957,
-0.21739216148853302,
0.26860371232032776,
-0.05353556573390961,
0.23846063017845154,
-0.4138905107975006,
0.617455005645752,
-0.1918715238571167,
-0.18183615803718567,
0.20496754348278046,
-0.3393392562866211,
1.0464977025985718,
0.23358552157878876,
-0.42240050435066223,
-0.05821859836578369,
-0.30325523018836975,
-0.2652508616447449,
0.33623382449150085,
-0.05877268314361572,
-0.32928773760795593,
-0.04991307109594345,
0.31205928325653076,
0.5159704089164734,
0.01101748552173376,
-0.47455012798309326,
-0.29146087169647217,
-0.3545556962490082,
0.3303321599960327,
0.9935223460197449,
-0.7411113381385803,
0.746840238571167,
-0.3446958065032959,
0.43727120757102966,
0.08241099119186401,
-0.0005443775444291532,
0.11109600961208344,
-0.6704732179641724,
-0.6323246955871582,
-0.003090816317126155,
0.7174826860427856,
0.5962182283401489,
-0.9124268293380737,
0.37282150983810425,
-0.5291706919670105,
-0.17424878478050232,
-0.9973813891410828,
0.05087655037641525,
0.4989675283432007,
0.7966625094413757,
0.3113292157649994,
-0.3340957760810852,
-0.38821837306022644,
-1.2386120557785034,
-0.513375997543335,
-0.16142383217811584,
-0.23666217923164368,
0.37207648158073425,
0.7095105051994324,
-0.2702353894710541,
0.904891312122345,
-0.22603361308574677,
-0.35896530747413635,
0.02654968947172165,
0.24151594936847687,
0.2546367645263672,
0.4656422734260559,
0.6340094208717346,
-0.848483681678772,
-0.3507765531539917,
-0.14932742714881897,
-0.9314396381378174,
-0.4723488986492157,
0.30639246106147766,
-0.3609243929386139,
0.03131981939077377,
0.3556469678878784,
-0.2816088795661926,
0.22513961791992188,
0.7202744483947754,
-0.6769171357154846,
0.08678516745567322,
-0.09851304441690445,
0.24412280321121216,
-1.0487914085388184,
0.40393683314323425,
-0.06634064018726349,
-0.48746249079704285,
-0.4965514540672302,
0.1997637152671814,
-0.029708102345466614,
-0.14113061130046844,
-0.5171987414360046,
0.7175924777984619,
-0.3008672595024109,
-0.10631539672613144,
-0.30586281418800354,
0.29960504174232483,
-0.19150538742542267,
0.2371908277273178,
-0.37958914041519165,
0.6039403080940247,
0.28753986954689026,
-0.31551340222358704,
-0.15406125783920288,
0.44138553738594055,
0.15100125968456268,
1.0067145824432373,
-0.5622661709785461,
0.3310639560222626,
-0.593428909778595,
0.10022123903036118,
-0.54551762342453,
0.111610047519207,
0.6062182784080505,
-0.7208843231201172,
0.02190268412232399,
-0.19242976605892181,
-0.6866796016693115,
-0.18527060747146606,
-0.03775035962462425,
0.35925137996673584,
0.354206919670105,
-0.3192589282989502,
0.541733980178833,
0.5074687004089355,
-0.3265528082847595,
-0.3609510064125061,
-0.8949784636497498,
0.4469574987888336,
-0.0019387217471376061,
-0.7818952202796936,
0.3716406524181366,
-0.16771355271339417,
-0.3511839210987091,
0.4248952865600586,
-0.07516253739595413,
-0.16591812670230865,
0.4381789565086365,
0.24008770287036896,
0.1925121545791626,
-0.0319037027657032,
0.20637492835521698,
0.27229973673820496,
-0.32013240456581116,
0.04758066311478615,
-0.21713408827781677,
0.3137463331222534,
-0.5331681370735168,
-0.20722608268260956,
-0.18909616768360138,
0.8107908368110657,
0.29602327942848206,
-0.10543430596590042,
0.6380951404571533,
0.5974463224411011,
-0.6363962888717651,
-0.042950909584760666,
-0.24062854051589966,
-0.4043740928173065,
-0.42397430539131165,
0.3645148277282715,
-0.7760226726531982,
-0.9935569167137146,
0.2858350872993469,
0.013361808843910694,
0.3512289822101593,
0.599626362323761,
0.22512368857860565,
-0.40629228949546814,
0.9745274782180786,
0.708837628364563,
-0.013207915239036083,
0.07458726316690445,
0.31183716654777527,
0.1245066225528717,
-0.26289358735084534,
-0.04065677151083946,
-0.9462408423423767,
-0.7821352481842041,
-0.7683603167533875,
-0.42790859937667847,
0.04171006754040718,
0.007992248982191086,
-0.3003886938095093,
0.6398679614067078,
-0.26341044902801514,
0.14539073407649994,
0.5511013269424438,
-0.16075393557548523,
0.3983020782470703,
0.11798984557390213,
-0.13512207567691803,
-0.5620883107185364,
-0.6358565092086792,
-0.729093074798584,
0.9985281229019165,
0.3431236147880554,
0.13563013076782227,
0.20569509267807007,
0.6272460222244263,
0.5405916571617126,
0.6066156625747681,
-0.4063768982887268,
0.6146770119667053,
-0.5938234925270081,
-0.8354923725128174,
0.029546139761805534,
-0.9722919464111328,
-1.286413550376892,
0.210311159491539,
-0.23556523025035858,
-0.09690486639738083,
0.0953630730509758,
-0.20350168645381927,
0.6361662745475769,
0.290277898311615,
-0.5749199986457825,
0.9050154089927673,
-0.20118887722492218,
-0.17328208684921265,
-0.3119393289089203,
-0.7982668280601501,
0.013555356301367283,
-0.12282893061637878,
0.605570912361145,
-0.299572616815567,
0.08302893489599228,
0.6169491410255432,
0.058778006583452225,
0.5961389541625977,
-0.16580668091773987,
-0.08630117028951645,
-0.16092745959758759,
0.22026745975017548,
0.1402711421251297,
-0.26874998211860657,
-0.2659669816493988,
0.6114051938056946,
-0.33979493379592896,
-0.6235848069190979,
-0.2719644606113434,
0.3601982593536377,
-0.6693406105041504,
-0.45488160848617554,
-0.360855370759964,
-0.6883702874183655,
-0.03736952319741249,
0.405274897813797,
-0.06781326234340668,
0.004347438924014568,
-0.1826198250055313,
0.25207245349884033,
0.4230675995349884,
-0.18351729214191437,
0.176233172416687,
0.7389128804206848,
-0.330958753824234,
-0.3053944408893585,
0.8016689419746399,
0.17188331484794617,
0.04789469391107559,
0.027623478323221207,
0.046239666640758514,
-0.24173487722873688,
-0.08222334086894989,
-0.744907796382904,
0.22720173001289368,
-0.5657957196235657,
-0.009628045372664928,
-0.5075833201408386,
-0.06964446604251862,
-0.42769110202789307,
-0.3198455274105072,
-0.3032745122909546,
-0.4150390625,
-0.07097198069095612,
-0.2025352418422699,
-0.07903580367565155,
0.37391185760498047,
-0.14237309992313385,
0.09834539145231247,
-0.6765112280845642,
0.5323551893234253,
0.15559977293014526,
0.3527247905731201,
-0.3408098518848419,
-0.5063818693161011,
0.13740873336791992,
-0.010655539110302925,
-0.1754833608865738,
-0.9865115284919739,
0.1657768189907074,
-0.04937690868973732,
0.7066702842712402,
0.07314867526292801,
-0.020664341747760773,
0.40915969014167786,
-0.719226598739624,
0.35317692160606384,
0.42561590671539307,
-1.0600950717926025,
0.4344865679740906,
-0.41688624024391174,
0.18481484055519104,
0.6724480390548706,
0.16679759323596954,
-0.9521051645278931,
-0.46713295578956604,
-0.6776731014251709,
-0.8712461590766907,
0.63173907995224,
0.6105898022651672,
0.4917999505996704,
0.0008276210282929242,
0.21962670981884003,
0.20757189393043518,
0.56272292137146,
-0.8264655470848083,
-0.5964942574501038,
-0.11219649761915207,
-0.4056095778942108,
0.015098084695637226,
0.3526918292045593,
-0.2801162004470825,
-0.09573198109865189,
0.722478449344635,
-0.15018047392368317,
0.04253989830613136,
-0.01793600060045719,
-0.30344438552856445,
-0.05517727881669998,
0.5689276456832886,
0.024028509855270386,
0.25224044919013977,
-0.07106680423021317,
0.34723618626594543,
0.24553649127483368,
-0.0422055646777153,
0.3697478175163269,
0.39127835631370544,
-0.6437662243843079,
0.43674787878990173,
-0.13190023601055145,
0.5856351852416992,
0.0327179916203022,
-0.6258014440536499,
0.572897732257843,
-0.11914200335741043,
-0.42616039514541626,
0.11077892035245895,
-0.37639284133911133,
0.26066818833351135,
0.22836127877235413,
0.09149996191263199,
0.27734461426734924,
0.15612365305423737,
-0.4824274182319641,
0.3114370107650757,
0.25322097539901733,
-0.6851720213890076,
-0.3213246166706085,
0.8281387090682983,
0.6094105839729309,
-0.5940288305282593,
0.8329307436943054,
-0.6039865016937256,
-0.3361259996891022,
0.24526895582675934,
0.46861159801483154,
1.0539761781692505,
-0.029055727645754814,
0.3648236393928528,
0.286744624376297,
0.7031973004341125,
-0.13183628022670746,
0.33626455068588257,
0.1742221713066101,
-0.5473183989524841,
-0.09208828210830688,
-0.2808043658733368,
-0.07133768498897552,
-0.32812827825546265,
-0.5238955020904541,
0.3106228709220886,
0.02697504684329033,
-0.5774645209312439,
-0.511569619178772,
-0.2691922187805176,
-0.9037314057350159,
-0.1044619232416153,
0.40844693779945374,
0.9264015555381775,
-1.0979018211364746,
0.5608661770820618,
0.842505156993866,
-0.24887457489967346,
-0.3288719356060028,
-0.19502829015254974,
0.0810159221291542,
-0.3272031247615814,
0.5978407859802246,
0.1786394566297531,
-0.17735184729099274,
-0.17025911808013916,
-0.3375380039215088,
-0.2634914517402649,
0.8259138464927673,
0.9076329469680786,
-0.46997132897377014,
-0.2239440232515335,
0.6419106125831604,
0.2248411774635315,
-0.0839843824505806,
0.10167196393013,
0.26284122467041016,
0.7375051975250244,
-0.5143720507621765,
-0.9028175473213196,
0.023522643372416496,
-0.6598837971687317,
0.021800275892019272,
0.1728416383266449,
-0.47824251651763916,
0.8282588720321655,
0.24079696834087372,
-0.3928423225879669,
-0.04147384688258171,
0.7373715043067932,
0.25605615973472595,
0.4567570686340332,
0.8073861598968506,
0.5842886567115784,
0.9551573395729065,
-0.28088074922561646,
0.6364434361457825,
-0.22285553812980652,
0.11903554201126099,
1.0865176916122437,
-0.18116052448749542,
0.6130420565605164,
0.6896407604217529,
0.03429301455616951,
0.427080899477005,
0.22542895376682281,
-0.141704723238945,
0.291725218296051,
0.579110860824585,
-0.07454107701778412,
-0.32266804575920105,
-0.4405626356601715,
-0.5687786936759949,
0.2605239748954773,
-0.016248909756541252,
-0.4464007616043091,
-0.51309734582901,
-0.0939650759100914,
0.26119646430015564,
0.31603801250457764,
-0.007265815045684576,
0.22746627032756805,
0.47962796688079834,
-0.4637173116207123,
0.06781747937202454,
0.5037634968757629,
0.7294939160346985,
-0.524128258228302,
0.10633073002099991,
-0.21256107091903687,
0.06805621832609177,
-0.08490844815969467,
-0.6761149168014526,
0.2612375319004059,
0.24421127140522003,
-0.4382825493812561,
-0.7280064821243286,
0.5809360146522522,
-0.41593652963638306,
-0.5894773602485657,
0.5951387882232666,
1.096243977546692,
0.2769494652748108,
0.1699291169643402,
-0.8590242266654968,
-0.38397639989852905,
-0.03977181389927864,
0.06117551401257515,
0.4555542469024658,
0.46536147594451904,
-0.16531774401664734,
0.5234205722808838,
0.6589650511741638,
-0.13993477821350098,
-0.050060056149959564,
0.24774879217147827,
0.5959854125976562,
-0.4936373829841614,
-0.34479305148124695,
-0.6795030832290649,
0.6074400544166565,
-0.026482976973056793,
-0.3925367593765259,
0.7655957937240601,
0.8020748496055603,
0.9710832238197327,
0.0831451416015625,
0.5829534530639648,
-0.03166075423359871,
0.327775239944458,
0.09526703506708145,
0.9269704818725586,
-0.7298343181610107,
-0.12585917115211487,
-0.39175471663475037,
-0.7824150323867798,
-0.1881365180015564,
0.4236500561237335,
-0.07480482012033463,
-0.17880791425704956,
0.41431117057800293,
0.7350336909294128,
-0.08871471881866455,
0.0493159182369709,
0.09115836024284363,
0.07979749888181686,
0.26642030477523804,
0.4651517868041992,
0.6470030546188354,
-0.7266730070114136,
0.8563193678855896,
0.07679492980241776,
-0.11524917185306549,
0.15561392903327942,
-0.9285301566123962,
-0.6842110753059387,
-0.43782004714012146,
-0.512032687664032,
-0.5873304009437561,
0.4082172214984894,
0.8766307830810547,
0.5775051116943359,
-0.5525242686271667,
-0.5773791074752808,
-0.02496771328151226,
0.18830706179141998,
-0.17379692196846008,
-0.13621297478675842,
0.05434826388955116,
-0.2752852737903595,
-0.9676605463027954,
0.3156096637248993,
0.0617934912443161,
-0.0807647779583931,
-0.032152462750673294,
-0.43494752049446106,
0.024668432772159576,
-0.0046713827177882195,
0.4405454695224762,
-0.16745837032794952,
-0.3254722058773041,
-0.013127624057233334,
0.21073146164417267,
-0.41999807953834534,
0.14163002371788025,
0.5447537899017334,
-0.6730813384056091,
0.37302207946777344,
0.7013416290283203,
0.8764274716377258,
0.17848354578018188,
-0.406343013048172,
0.7060167789459229,
-0.8437492251396179,
0.014060811139643192,
0.19232404232025146,
0.487896203994751,
0.4676944315433502,
0.21693576872348785,
0.660661518573761,
0.6468097567558289,
-0.25800806283950806,
-0.8589960336685181,
0.18948997557163239,
-0.5821806788444519,
-0.46182116866111755,
0.9175344705581665,
-0.0681537464261055,
-0.22229346632957458,
-0.2315727174282074,
-0.07354426383972168,
0.5493216514587402,
-0.4750615358352661,
0.7339112758636475,
0.7507318258285522,
0.5444437265396118,
0.13707122206687927,
-0.8901415467262268,
-0.034859172999858856,
0.7846083045005798,
-0.7480031847953796,
-0.10654748976230621,
0.36588093638420105,
0.2866632342338562,
0.005963257048279047,
0.5560131669044495,
-0.3252519965171814,
0.207656592130661,
-0.2878313958644867,
0.22322893142700195,
0.07037102431058884,
-0.14187833666801453,
-0.32179105281829834,
0.32077497243881226,
-0.196590393781662,
-0.15779760479927063
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.06127v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.06127v1
|
Comparing Data Augmentation Methods for End-to-End Task-Oriented Dialog Systems
| 2024-06-10T09:36:05 | 2024-06-10T09:36:05 |
Christos Vlachos, Themos Stafylakis, Ion Androutsopoulos
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Creating effective and reliable task-oriented dialog systems (ToDSs) is
challenging, not only because of the complex structure of these systems, but
also due to the scarcity of training data, especially when several modules need
to be trained separately, each one with its own input/output training examples.
Data augmentation (DA), whereby synthetic training examples are added to the
training data, has been successful in other NLP systems, but has not been
explored as extensively in ToDSs. We empirically evaluate the effectiveness of
DA methods in an end-to-end ToDS setting, where a single system is trained to
handle all processing stages, from user inputs to system outputs. We experiment
with two ToDSs (UBAR, GALAXY) on two datasets (MultiWOZ, KVRET). We consider
three types of DA methods (word-level, sentence-level, dialog-level), comparing
eight DA methods that have shown promising results in ToDSs and other NLP
systems. We show that all DA methods considered are beneficial, and we
highlight the best ones, also providing advice to practitioners. We also
introduce a more challenging few-shot cross-domain ToDS setting, reaching
similar conclusions.
|
[
-0.4239436984062195,
-0.7601012587547302,
0.3743082284927368,
0.04795191064476967,
-0.3612896502017975,
0.22966286540031433,
-0.21838067471981049,
-0.42240920662879944,
-0.007222111336886883,
0.28478190302848816,
-0.7429245114326477,
-0.3833070993423462,
-0.3807022273540497,
0.5120605826377869,
-0.31907209753990173,
1.0763773918151855,
0.10991298407316208,
0.13793960213661194,
-0.5650458931922913,
-0.01590610295534134,
-0.7121598124504089,
-0.673225462436676,
-0.8219924569129944,
-0.35451191663742065,
0.16729478538036346,
0.16484512388706207,
0.5691514611244202,
0.314651221036911,
0.3170924186706543,
0.31713923811912537,
-0.08907997608184814,
0.575239896774292,
-0.30283117294311523,
0.4174553453922272,
0.08033491671085358,
-0.39752137660980225,
-0.48779308795928955,
-0.2529437839984894,
0.05031155049800873,
0.8329524993896484,
-0.05261087790131569,
0.034192100167274475,
0.21711213886737823,
0.5440499782562256,
-0.5485988855361938,
0.10090658813714981,
-0.399515837430954,
0.19944517314434052,
-0.10385329276323318,
-0.4725112318992615,
-0.31505274772644043,
-0.13913024961948395,
0.6249463558197021,
-0.7159748077392578,
-0.03307533636689186,
0.02236948348581791,
0.3727659583091736,
0.3749426603317261,
-0.5659103393554688,
-0.4796046316623688,
-0.6901202201843262,
0.7624991536140442,
-0.9635359644889832,
0.3284034729003906,
0.3422454595565796,
0.146415114402771,
-0.3588932752609253,
-0.37778645753860474,
-0.6702854037284851,
-0.12788034975528717,
0.0637783631682396,
0.4047798216342926,
-0.1630786508321762,
0.38510486483573914,
0.32364049553871155,
0.38834843039512634,
-0.5964605808258057,
0.044327251613140106,
-0.19613362848758698,
-0.15729589760303497,
0.4163209795951843,
0.20613473653793335,
0.10803405195474625,
-0.2802015542984009,
-0.39242103695869446,
-0.22641915082931519,
-0.5788232684135437,
0.017204154282808304,
0.46184566617012024,
0.24125421047210693,
0.07916513830423355,
0.7251097559928894,
-0.5166437029838562,
1.1095668077468872,
0.1617528647184372,
-0.22749106585979462,
0.3771766126155853,
-0.4876879155635834,
-0.476378470659256,
-0.24447563290596008,
0.5793524384498596,
0.7111732959747314,
0.14148005843162537,
-0.4915672540664673,
-0.1930641382932663,
0.07541504502296448,
0.30965137481689453,
-0.43045124411582947,
0.1848662793636322,
0.4854218065738678,
-0.23048405349254608,
-0.15886513888835907,
-0.2416161149740219,
-0.43065503239631653,
-0.1866399496793747,
-0.7361335754394531,
0.3397550582885742,
-0.3129189610481262,
0.06835927069187164,
0.011305266991257668,
-0.3026210069656372,
-0.006021276116371155,
0.6445543169975281,
-0.6355711817741394,
0.30566680431365967,
0.6610934138298035,
0.7977527976036072,
-0.3602510392665863,
-0.009660272859036922,
-0.5787191390991211,
0.017768494784832,
-0.5216832756996155,
0.8877906203269958,
-0.5106131434440613,
-0.49890318512916565,
0.06328048557043076,
-0.19431574642658234,
0.01397256925702095,
-0.7888628840446472,
0.7663707137107849,
-0.31684085726737976,
0.6359735727310181,
-0.19237694144248962,
-0.6326498985290527,
-0.15466101467609406,
0.3063524067401886,
-0.1920892596244812,
1.2245272397994995,
0.22445712983608246,
-0.4150184392929077,
0.6312069296836853,
-0.7746199369430542,
-0.4066120684146881,
-0.14156310260295868,
-0.17190702259540558,
-0.1411675363779068,
0.3532257378101349,
0.3460864722728729,
0.5430170893669128,
-0.4249534606933594,
0.22613292932510376,
-0.2532002329826355,
-0.13347232341766357,
0.17203444242477417,
-0.6217553615570068,
0.6936187744140625,
0.1822226494550705,
-0.23825417459011078,
-0.03182477876543999,
-0.6781032681465149,
0.17524835467338562,
-0.21159565448760986,
-0.23316091299057007,
-0.4105987250804901,
-0.2664618194103241,
-0.06731856614351273,
0.42651891708374023,
0.1419582962989807,
-0.9119561314582825,
0.2424386739730835,
-0.384108304977417,
0.23811887204647064,
0.6959097385406494,
-0.1642177850008011,
0.13011080026626587,
-0.4992799758911133,
0.3537752032279968,
0.2476860135793686,
0.08889801800251007,
-0.5142711400985718,
-0.509373128414154,
-0.7783929705619812,
-0.16693970561027527,
0.22441060841083527,
0.6119716763496399,
-1.1123628616333008,
0.6927022933959961,
-0.25517675280570984,
-0.11451224237680435,
-0.28539326786994934,
-0.07028190046548843,
0.36290493607521057,
0.6212419271469116,
0.26715922355651855,
-0.5883881449699402,
-0.5673129558563232,
-0.7871853113174438,
0.047024279832839966,
-0.21950797736644745,
-0.29008397459983826,
0.42471614480018616,
0.17042556405067444,
0.027354154735803604,
1.2245738506317139,
-0.19645102322101593,
-0.25757303833961487,
-0.16263990104198456,
0.0690765231847763,
-0.08145986497402191,
0.29884791374206543,
0.5532162189483643,
-0.36645185947418213,
-0.5826207399368286,
0.10655517131090164,
-0.7761282324790955,
-0.11667609214782715,
-0.2415623664855957,
0.17419660091400146,
0.42626726627349854,
-0.02545732446014881,
-0.6180192232131958,
0.731713593006134,
0.40981271862983704,
-0.245085671544075,
0.5217850208282471,
-0.27379798889160156,
0.4816705584526062,
-1.0473328828811646,
-0.17934677004814148,
0.10902243852615356,
-0.46591848134994507,
-1.1226898431777954,
-0.3194749653339386,
-0.3527970016002655,
0.008593851700425148,
-0.18152961134910583,
0.39789828658103943,
-0.3943726122379303,
-0.38122114539146423,
-0.5659948587417603,
0.04953845962882042,
0.054909609258174896,
0.812484085559845,
0.02501177415251732,
1.0645883083343506,
0.7019842863082886,
-0.5764548778533936,
0.6153270602226257,
0.4762866497039795,
-0.42794474959373474,
0.8743760585784912,
-0.6552019119262695,
0.5055623054504395,
-0.23473532497882843,
0.47464847564697266,
-1.0079631805419922,
-0.03197859600186348,
0.15946368873119354,
-0.5201753973960876,
0.07596312463283539,
-0.03432567045092583,
-0.5703747868537903,
-0.27815744280815125,
-0.3242940604686737,
0.1496337205171585,
0.49630206823349,
-0.7297030091285706,
0.4182327389717102,
0.2978528141975403,
-0.53544020652771,
-0.5831031203269958,
-0.42780765891075134,
0.5705292820930481,
-0.34251850843429565,
-0.4946424663066864,
0.34787487983703613,
-0.042793650180101395,
-0.0786379799246788,
-0.2732894718647003,
-0.4459938704967499,
-0.16546128690242767,
-0.10898244380950928,
0.19024351239204407,
0.22055360674858093,
0.2029421478509903,
-0.008535264059901237,
0.1671207845211029,
-0.1714051514863968,
-0.08947847783565521,
-0.36210373044013977,
0.5328426361083984,
0.14082926511764526,
-0.6185771822929382,
-0.6376437544822693,
0.5901597142219543,
0.5890429615974426,
0.23207911849021912,
0.34823089838027954,
0.44770917296409607,
-0.3644634187221527,
-0.06511685252189636,
-0.6499851942062378,
-0.13546667993068695,
-0.4259319007396698,
0.21842901408672333,
-0.39628446102142334,
-0.6886173486709595,
0.34153398871421814,
-0.14109493792057037,
0.5593100786209106,
0.14699606597423553,
0.42014840245246887,
-0.341314435005188,
1.0611903667449951,
0.463010311126709,
0.05946944281458855,
0.48297983407974243,
-0.27359163761138916,
0.28827375173568726,
-1.0801433324813843,
-0.29329216480255127,
-0.40658414363861084,
-0.22751563787460327,
-0.0355764701962471,
-0.5298039317131042,
0.5881964564323425,
-0.0032026495318859816,
0.2286876142024994,
0.4924198091030121,
-0.40726032853126526,
-0.00746446056291461,
0.6184291243553162,
0.15622326731681824,
0.6443861126899719,
0.34988075494766235,
0.24991776049137115,
-0.04476146399974823,
-0.8845949172973633,
-0.4448917508125305,
1.4486572742462158,
0.19398429989814758,
0.5640652179718018,
-0.011300199665129185,
0.5221163630485535,
0.45131349563598633,
0.10591289401054382,
-0.6674273014068604,
0.5346737504005432,
-0.2629392743110657,
-0.30172061920166016,
-0.4657960534095764,
-0.3647204637527466,
-0.830263078212738,
0.20413312315940857,
-0.14466233551502228,
-0.8199653625488281,
0.3843858540058136,
0.13806352019309998,
-0.34423261880874634,
0.19396275281906128,
-0.727942943572998,
0.3584860861301422,
-0.09607633203268051,
-0.2251887023448944,
-0.15033572912216187,
-0.542497992515564,
-0.03229331225156784,
-0.0027997533325105906,
-0.039684686809778214,
0.15485957264900208,
0.009743715636432171,
0.7740851044654846,
-0.7188599705696106,
0.7547779679298401,
-0.2099246084690094,
-0.4241154193878174,
0.4476167559623718,
-0.3867473602294922,
0.6232110857963562,
-0.050006940960884094,
0.03936237469315529,
0.13233794271945953,
0.01579192467033863,
-0.2506657838821411,
-0.9456037282943726,
0.46154865622520447,
-0.48207029700279236,
-0.5995407104492188,
-0.2400854527950287,
-0.8450472950935364,
-0.645699143409729,
-0.21493269503116608,
0.060193538665771484,
1.0277904272079468,
0.09816338866949081,
0.3781951367855072,
0.5100078582763672,
-0.01082128006964922,
0.45618072152137756,
0.1769234985113144,
0.04860113933682442,
-0.4072296917438507,
0.7739744186401367,
0.01647006720304489,
0.4835891127586365,
0.11734549701213837,
-0.1418258547782898,
-0.4240362048149109,
-0.7596250176429749,
-0.8909000158309937,
-0.4103504717350006,
-0.5101741552352905,
-0.24743831157684326,
-0.7765301465988159,
-0.03914056718349457,
-0.4619714319705963,
0.013051170855760574,
-0.19987598061561584,
-0.7104412913322449,
-0.06895244866609573,
-0.00858298409730196,
0.5283946990966797,
0.49529916048049927,
-0.022953270003199577,
0.4460199177265167,
-0.8216225504875183,
0.38120976090431213,
0.38895347714424133,
0.29952743649482727,
-0.017178043723106384,
-0.5500944256782532,
-0.23518069088459015,
0.473364919424057,
-0.2320343255996704,
-0.7883679866790771,
0.15708109736442566,
0.1920347362756729,
0.6019934415817261,
0.35171300172805786,
0.0029439579229801893,
1.015472173690796,
-0.2791692316532135,
0.8195943236351013,
0.28968673944473267,
-0.7929091453552246,
0.29051145911216736,
-0.3944123685359955,
0.2265668511390686,
0.6561896800994873,
0.026646431535482407,
-0.606183648109436,
-0.3238789141178131,
-0.516398012638092,
-0.7448500990867615,
0.8090834617614746,
0.5714911222457886,
0.07079321146011353,
0.045211061835289,
0.35421133041381836,
0.43571966886520386,
0.4632872939109802,
-0.3774397373199463,
-0.36174753308296204,
-0.028963705524802208,
-0.32991766929626465,
0.12832404673099518,
0.14671850204467773,
-0.22964370250701904,
-0.03820925951004028,
0.6126545667648315,
-0.3387887477874756,
0.3893747329711914,
0.3769235908985138,
-0.047218043357133865,
0.006066290196031332,
0.47678086161613464,
0.358193963766098,
0.6335762739181519,
-0.05764485150575638,
-0.34059494733810425,
0.3053073585033417,
-0.36074697971343994,
0.1580977588891983,
-0.10693899542093277,
-0.2083675116300583,
0.1810324490070343,
0.1177297905087471,
1.1869279146194458,
-0.21580292284488678,
-0.8044961094856262,
0.32380935549736023,
0.0754472017288208,
-0.26129013299942017,
0.10635493695735931,
0.04470416530966759,
-0.42742595076560974,
0.1886899322271347,
0.5625948309898376,
0.07791081815958023,
0.4267357885837555,
-0.8082135915756226,
-0.004379709716886282,
0.6729476451873779,
-0.24516533315181732,
-0.18526583909988403,
0.06576649099588394,
0.4795266389846802,
-0.3566940724849701,
0.20011745393276215,
-0.3094223141670227,
-0.32199516892433167,
0.4730050265789032,
0.5417725443840027,
0.8818843960762024,
0.1463042050600052,
0.31408727169036865,
0.12284638732671738,
0.18820735812187195,
0.07864182442426682,
0.24240146577358246,
-0.5298422574996948,
-0.46494415402412415,
-0.8112712502479553,
-0.21473728120326996,
-0.6461353898048401,
0.1776229441165924,
-0.643517792224884,
-0.07446576654911041,
0.026899244636297226,
-0.5212992429733276,
-0.3205302655696869,
0.01735544204711914,
-0.6251817345619202,
0.3085256516933441,
-0.13704682886600494,
0.7572445273399353,
-0.758368968963623,
0.27671244740486145,
0.8869678974151611,
0.2377263605594635,
-0.17666500806808472,
0.062257345765829086,
0.035652123391628265,
-0.4929278492927551,
0.5257747173309326,
-0.03375418484210968,
-0.00011179340071976185,
-0.09252119064331055,
-0.09956882148981094,
-0.7954506874084473,
1.0167912244796753,
-0.057305026799440384,
-0.4889349937438965,
-0.30470043420791626,
0.3274528682231903,
0.6653533577919006,
-0.43942776322364807,
0.46980318427085876,
0.5182341933250427,
0.28853750228881836,
0.0348888635635376,
-1.2364298105239868,
-0.2374637871980667,
-0.21235819160938263,
0.07805587351322174,
0.05683619901537895,
-0.4068266749382019,
0.34277623891830444,
-0.09619737416505814,
-0.374496728181839,
0.1509399712085724,
0.5792245268821716,
0.2251240462064743,
0.5282120704650879,
0.9201284646987915,
0.7072336673736572,
0.400115042924881,
-0.2699927091598511,
0.8162948489189148,
-0.22585497796535492,
0.1085265576839447,
1.0810154676437378,
-0.2628651559352875,
0.3204626142978668,
0.543042778968811,
-0.4312867820262909,
0.20737583935260773,
0.6355677843093872,
0.2981376349925995,
0.5876169800758362,
0.03908335044980049,
-0.17363043129444122,
-0.04294032230973244,
-0.47253432869911194,
-0.281276673078537,
0.25171005725860596,
0.48763155937194824,
0.25212669372558594,
-0.40664446353912354,
0.4201536178588867,
-0.34805789589881897,
-0.26478222012519836,
0.004120902623981237,
1.2374012470245361,
-0.1406029313802719,
-0.7251613140106201,
0.5093517899513245,
-0.30196699500083923,
0.8249009847640991,
-0.4123266935348511,
0.07221020013093948,
-0.08474628627300262,
-0.28646841645240784,
-0.2578527331352234,
-0.7070243954658508,
0.27823156118392944,
0.35479360818862915,
0.0034442392643541098,
-0.2933056056499481,
0.6087436079978943,
-0.4438135623931885,
-0.1610267609357834,
-0.07087719440460205,
0.799546480178833,
0.10673907399177551,
0.13819663226604462,
-0.47687241435050964,
-0.17227523028850555,
0.08913390338420868,
-0.29710057377815247,
0.2918561100959778,
0.2666222155094147,
-0.008245031349360943,
0.7575187087059021,
0.913330078125,
0.12024816870689392,
0.13179591298103333,
0.263409823179245,
0.8647524118423462,
-0.2129601091146469,
-0.46320435404777527,
-0.2985462546348572,
0.5562915802001953,
-0.5049722790718079,
-0.4297390580177307,
0.8064044713973999,
0.5849243998527527,
0.845245897769928,
0.19342902302742004,
1.0330464839935303,
-0.1783132702112198,
0.5914294123649597,
-0.4606917202472687,
-0.13374286890029907,
-0.36212700605392456,
0.2853701710700989,
-0.2949677109718323,
-1.1134074926376343,
0.07270575314760208,
0.4575020968914032,
-0.05506077781319618,
0.19010917842388153,
0.5506572723388672,
0.5641684532165527,
0.10590222477912903,
0.25314226746559143,
0.3375471830368042,
-0.151248961687088,
0.2888520061969757,
0.44504913687705994,
0.931867778301239,
-0.42780157923698425,
0.34632954001426697,
-0.4474315047264099,
-0.41138869524002075,
-0.03837401047348976,
-0.5054409503936768,
-0.9751974940299988,
-0.6905114650726318,
-0.2943015992641449,
0.035791534930467606,
0.42174720764160156,
0.907429039478302,
0.8329982161521912,
-0.6124191284179688,
-0.08970259875059128,
-0.16986806690692902,
-0.308060884475708,
-0.29489389061927795,
-0.18243329226970673,
0.15507309138774872,
-0.4482876658439636,
-1.0873090028762817,
0.5910384058952332,
0.6031965017318726,
0.12473384290933609,
-0.2489900141954422,
0.15448886156082153,
0.14688029885292053,
0.024866245687007904,
0.7448719143867493,
0.12940335273742676,
-0.8241487741470337,
-0.22289472818374634,
0.27703168988227844,
0.15696601569652557,
0.10328424721956253,
0.9366483092308044,
-0.9350041151046753,
0.6600567102432251,
0.5304292440414429,
0.8524053692817688,
0.2980668246746063,
0.20078347623348236,
0.8347665667533875,
-0.7535312175750732,
0.05157667398452759,
0.09554798156023026,
0.26652535796165466,
0.35901498794555664,
-0.26550307869911194,
0.554185152053833,
-0.04025249183177948,
-0.4671362340450287,
-0.8810062408447266,
0.12461360543966293,
-1.1170642375946045,
-0.13751594722270966,
0.9375706315040588,
-0.1765112727880478,
0.2567661702632904,
-0.574365496635437,
-0.4504050016403198,
0.180207759141922,
-0.571711003780365,
0.8969076871871948,
0.6817836165428162,
-0.44072508811950684,
0.23442114889621735,
-0.6202942728996277,
0.4163073003292084,
0.7441859245300293,
-1.320975661277771,
0.13405996561050415,
0.5883809328079224,
-0.22770732641220093,
0.32504981756210327,
0.5825786590576172,
0.06517847627401352,
0.27339351177215576,
-0.2445826530456543,
-0.3703155815601349,
-0.32516002655029297,
-0.4732750356197357,
-0.2937135696411133,
-0.1361149400472641,
-0.45005345344543457,
-0.2702634036540985
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.06125v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.06125v1
|
Verifiable Generation with Subsentence-Level Fine-Grained Citations
| 2024-06-10T09:32:37 | 2024-06-10T09:32:37 |
Shuyang Cao, Lu Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Verifiable generation requires large language models (LLMs) to cite source
documents supporting their outputs, thereby improve output transparency and
trustworthiness. Yet, previous work mainly targets the generation of
sentence-level citations, lacking specificity about which parts of a sentence
are backed by the cited sources. This work studies verifiable generation with
subsentence-level fine-grained citations for more precise location of generated
content supported by the cited sources. We first present a dataset, SCiFi,
comprising 10K Wikipedia paragraphs with subsentence-level citations. Each
paragraph is paired with a set of candidate source documents for citation and a
query that triggers the generation of the paragraph content. On SCiFi, we
evaluate the performance of state-of-the-art LLMs and strategies for processing
long documents designed for these models. Our experiment results reveals key
factors that could enhance the quality of citations, including the expansion of
the source documents' context accessible to the models and the implementation
of specialized model tuning.
|
[
-0.4391953647136688,
-0.6935782432556152,
0.8750512599945068,
0.04021550342440605,
-0.10167776793241501,
0.14108334481716156,
-0.21600964665412903,
-0.5209430456161499,
0.09603554010391235,
0.2804209291934967,
-0.48026561737060547,
-0.4309701919555664,
-0.39344140887260437,
0.3333463966846466,
-0.8392871618270874,
0.7796818017959595,
0.1170082613825798,
-0.20322228968143463,
-0.5750885605812073,
0.2118404060602188,
0.1118866503238678,
-0.41612422466278076,
-0.28768637776374817,
-0.6049779653549194,
0.7596968412399292,
0.37753933668136597,
0.4873262941837311,
0.7889286279678345,
0.43629926443099976,
0.201425701379776,
-0.1790449619293213,
0.40298542380332947,
-0.5765490531921387,
0.5059605240821838,
-0.765696108341217,
-0.11279640346765518,
-0.151814267039299,
-0.10445619374513626,
0.6832565665245056,
0.5156113505363464,
0.22183078527450562,
0.27728942036628723,
0.07196260243654251,
0.2605186402797699,
-0.6223293542861938,
-0.14459337294101715,
-0.927052915096283,
-0.1726793348789215,
-0.5363377332687378,
-0.45809701085090637,
-0.6401137113571167,
-0.3359345495700836,
-0.06265486776828766,
-0.4129762351512909,
0.5815096497535706,
0.07270527631044388,
1.156937599182129,
0.10445381700992584,
-0.14235953986644745,
-0.1517571061849594,
-0.7583891749382019,
0.7569910287857056,
-0.6322309970855713,
0.3192398250102997,
0.4198238253593445,
-0.08242746442556381,
-0.4783916771411896,
-1.1860722303390503,
-0.5936865210533142,
-0.2983279526233673,
-0.2581411302089691,
-0.13716605305671692,
-0.1893891543149948,
-0.40703287720680237,
0.4831157326698303,
0.4247112572193146,
-0.4061081111431122,
0.24207879602909088,
-0.313313364982605,
-0.2239946573972702,
0.6571190357208252,
0.007556971162557602,
-0.00423341104760766,
-0.6500411033630371,
-0.2448844462633133,
-0.0007963757961988449,
-1.0189546346664429,
-0.18243321776390076,
0.313862681388855,
0.23580196499824524,
0.14424970746040344,
0.8153032064437866,
-0.6026215553283691,
0.23077315092086792,
0.2287825047969818,
-0.08087889850139618,
0.1076197624206543,
-0.8088088631629944,
-0.06967509537935257,
0.037623852491378784,
0.5801074504852295,
-0.046234793961048126,
0.40286746621131897,
-0.20628708600997925,
0.07447253167629242,
-0.41446220874786377,
0.2986268997192383,
-0.8326544165611267,
-0.07861217856407166,
0.2807934582233429,
-0.3164755403995514,
-0.2781842052936554,
0.04539479315280914,
-0.33511224389076233,
-0.46830853819847107,
-0.30851003527641296,
-0.06001394987106323,
-0.6290397644042969,
0.014243283309042454,
-0.3965618908405304,
-0.2474358230829239,
0.0926240086555481,
0.17304398119449615,
-0.8225815296173096,
-0.35633614659309387,
0.6892275214195251,
0.8341560363769531,
-0.09355095773935318,
-0.4271794855594635,
-0.43842053413391113,
0.643418550491333,
-0.32238131761550903,
1.1763612031936646,
-0.7115052342414856,
-0.4756130278110504,
0.2417539656162262,
0.011009188368916512,
0.15235652029514313,
-0.3203575015068054,
0.6989893913269043,
-0.5920461416244507,
0.0037365758325904608,
-0.5585134029388428,
-0.7591920495033264,
0.32613256573677063,
0.13682086765766144,
-0.5551796555519104,
1.0876257419586182,
0.2410975992679596,
-0.8558771014213562,
0.590281069278717,
-0.2548249661922455,
-0.6761606931686401,
0.25523918867111206,
-0.27513259649276733,
-0.20413710176944733,
0.45060995221138,
0.13727575540542603,
0.4745369851589203,
-0.3520338833332062,
0.38878095149993896,
-0.2734544575214386,
0.009720178321003914,
0.3967544734477997,
-0.4401908814907074,
0.3242615759372711,
0.4436102509498596,
-0.09857204556465149,
-0.005121954251080751,
-1.1019742488861084,
0.09727121144533157,
0.09958963096141815,
-0.66173255443573,
-0.43790334463119507,
0.17393994331359863,
0.07735990732908249,
-0.06429853290319443,
0.4706047475337982,
-0.6952416896820068,
-0.022829445078969002,
-0.12070304900407791,
0.49411633610725403,
0.4355921447277069,
0.30732837319374084,
0.29832571744918823,
-0.13587377965450287,
0.25916680693626404,
-0.039047904312610626,
-0.06311877816915512,
-0.5595040917396545,
-0.11504777520895004,
-0.5420745611190796,
-0.13390371203422546,
0.42680826783180237,
0.16175955533981323,
-0.6062532067298889,
0.25762081146240234,
-0.5392533540725708,
-0.557334840297699,
-0.10458017885684967,
0.2806548476219177,
0.24704965949058533,
0.8301566243171692,
0.5017284154891968,
0.25018930435180664,
-0.6172971725463867,
-0.9276753664016724,
-0.1553872674703598,
-0.20805256068706512,
-0.26792794466018677,
0.2233511358499527,
0.6094049215316772,
-0.2094089388847351,
1.0075323581695557,
-0.2893480062484741,
0.22442252933979034,
-0.1475347876548767,
0.27230608463287354,
-0.1784110814332962,
0.6258896589279175,
0.46773502230644226,
-0.7752154469490051,
-0.5069881081581116,
0.06996744126081467,
-0.6640055775642395,
-0.30505943298339844,
-0.17746926844120026,
-0.31552886962890625,
0.15165145695209503,
0.8350709676742554,
-0.6142165660858154,
0.1399293839931488,
0.29144373536109924,
-0.33832648396492004,
0.38691309094429016,
-0.23913608491420746,
0.11427058279514313,
-1.1989097595214844,
0.16200466454029083,
0.07902844250202179,
-0.45898008346557617,
-0.1925661861896515,
0.205328568816185,
0.03160601854324341,
0.13558687269687653,
-0.23308035731315613,
0.2222920060157776,
-0.24590817093849182,
-0.02262343093752861,
-0.3596384525299072,
0.28006166219711304,
0.34693804383277893,
-0.04170200973749161,
0.09400526434183121,
0.5873910784721375,
0.18340253829956055,
-0.24490651488304138,
0.27289989590644836,
-0.0070411330088973045,
-0.5332505702972412,
0.731082558631897,
-0.8006275296211243,
-0.10319165140390396,
-0.07074268907308578,
0.43979203701019287,
-0.8830671310424805,
-0.5128950476646423,
-0.31758686900138855,
-0.3232991695404053,
0.4305616319179535,
0.07681722193956375,
-0.5830178260803223,
-0.045748572796583176,
-0.12737253308296204,
0.16629618406295776,
0.21080856025218964,
-0.5405775308609009,
0.41498538851737976,
0.18814967572689056,
-0.3743704855442047,
-0.2915476858615875,
-0.6050187945365906,
0.17387616634368896,
-0.0734025239944458,
-0.8327310085296631,
0.6193233132362366,
0.11905766278505325,
-0.20471157133579254,
0.04083022102713585,
-0.17354875802993774,
0.28050318360328674,
0.04146331548690796,
0.4298674464225769,
-0.07418426871299744,
-0.32149532437324524,
0.0005985330208204687,
0.4840375483036041,
-0.10011442005634308,
-0.1128026470541954,
-0.19491857290267944,
0.539199709892273,
0.1715923249721527,
-0.2087031751871109,
-0.0993737056851387,
0.7583507895469666,
0.5545950531959534,
-0.16317816078662872,
0.6600554585456848,
0.8062774538993835,
-0.37904807925224304,
-0.39674678444862366,
-0.44609251618385315,
0.018771471455693245,
-0.39692601561546326,
0.30304354429244995,
-0.44834959506988525,
-0.9380439519882202,
0.5372315049171448,
-0.1626332551240921,
0.08856766670942307,
0.5801507830619812,
0.621971070766449,
-0.23427258431911469,
0.7825901508331299,
0.30749690532684326,
0.16030533611774445,
0.5660994052886963,
0.01168445311486721,
-0.015116389840841293,
-0.685403048992157,
-0.5102022290229797,
-0.9847095012664795,
-0.20136764645576477,
-0.4129018485546112,
-0.470816433429718,
0.12990625202655792,
0.21482129395008087,
-0.20851360261440277,
0.29212790727615356,
-0.17123320698738098,
0.5286004543304443,
0.8651440143585205,
-0.07060658186674118,
0.4210340082645416,
0.45697569847106934,
-0.22384324669837952,
0.05411728844046593,
-0.6362344622612,
-0.7410604953765869,
0.7351295948028564,
0.46456271409988403,
0.8774657249450684,
0.038495130836963654,
0.7089070677757263,
0.44766053557395935,
0.054946575313806534,
-0.2414885014295578,
0.4262756109237671,
-0.1547725349664688,
-0.6662917733192444,
-0.39237338304519653,
-0.33149072527885437,
-0.713104784488678,
-0.023388909175992012,
-0.20090118050575256,
-0.6916667819023132,
0.38978350162506104,
0.01553958561271429,
-0.19942304491996765,
-0.23117195069789886,
-0.614059329032898,
0.531540036201477,
0.1892164796590805,
-0.6143271327018738,
-0.2715713083744049,
-0.38275909423828125,
0.1826012134552002,
-0.2172008454799652,
-0.0214077178388834,
0.04298903048038483,
0.2935762107372284,
0.40478718280792236,
-0.4988243877887726,
0.512991189956665,
-0.04093092307448387,
-0.4096158444881439,
0.2227485477924347,
0.13639330863952637,
0.8288141489028931,
0.3997744917869568,
-0.18394336104393005,
0.1799229383468628,
-0.04213528335094452,
-0.280424565076828,
-0.28318923711776733,
1.1985853910446167,
-0.43510493636131287,
-0.7708733081817627,
-0.13829530775547028,
-0.6586670279502869,
-0.29203173518180847,
0.4148227274417877,
0.6669679880142212,
0.21065707504749298,
-0.07161446660757065,
0.755642294883728,
0.9045001268386841,
-0.08479547500610352,
0.4126477539539337,
0.32352033257484436,
0.12309243530035019,
-0.26808273792266846,
0.7882220149040222,
0.24098260700702667,
0.2331782430410385,
0.5003952383995056,
-0.0012100021122023463,
-0.30285659432411194,
-0.8950222134590149,
-0.3445223867893219,
0.0660875216126442,
-0.7195600867271423,
-0.31115221977233887,
-0.5770587921142578,
-0.4814906418323517,
-0.6953900456428528,
-0.22364823520183563,
-0.27732691168785095,
-0.4150104820728302,
-0.3028940260410309,
-0.39028823375701904,
0.22873809933662415,
0.3637554943561554,
-0.1241958886384964,
0.11314085870981216,
-0.536238968372345,
0.2801080048084259,
0.12559552490711212,
0.13299015164375305,
-0.17479434609413147,
-0.5035872459411621,
-0.5189476609230042,
-0.010869011282920837,
-0.08698015660047531,
-0.5534624457359314,
-0.023487841710448265,
0.21047459542751312,
0.6018731594085693,
0.26487302780151367,
0.08475387096405029,
0.7092517018318176,
-0.6463895440101624,
1.0117396116256714,
0.017856167629361153,
-0.7984659075737,
0.7936418056488037,
-0.36207664012908936,
0.3472764194011688,
0.5410586595535278,
0.24822105467319489,
0.22215841710567474,
-0.7243625521659851,
-0.4931647777557373,
-1.0410760641098022,
0.3850597143173218,
0.33076077699661255,
0.2975033223628998,
-0.20020632445812225,
0.4585897624492645,
0.16555559635162354,
-0.09493882209062576,
-0.670570433139801,
0.10333144664764404,
-0.3711245656013489,
-0.11029922962188721,
0.03848375380039215,
-0.564956784248352,
-0.16418111324310303,
0.11835455894470215,
0.8028033971786499,
-0.16450145840644836,
-0.2632239758968353,
0.5529120564460754,
-0.09979863464832306,
-0.3466159999370575,
0.38744956254959106,
0.7525166869163513,
0.8426382541656494,
-0.0986679419875145,
0.3481196165084839,
-0.18382655084133148,
-0.42031100392341614,
-0.11472464352846146,
0.07981589436531067,
-0.7869192957878113,
0.3191447854042053,
0.5022991895675659,
0.5216991305351257,
-0.0138178626075387,
-0.5293107032775879,
0.14226028323173523,
0.06849191337823868,
-0.1405310481786728,
-0.30639588832855225,
0.31756094098091125,
0.2027975469827652,
0.6065249443054199,
0.6239223480224609,
-0.3390134274959564,
-0.18976983428001404,
-0.30749747157096863,
0.09823090583086014,
0.4291382133960724,
0.16305334866046906,
-0.137132927775383,
0.7408166527748108,
0.13344299793243408,
0.06848462671041489,
0.31789666414260864,
0.1900157332420349,
0.1095074862241745,
0.24506975710391998,
0.7138150334358215,
0.6341043710708618,
0.08471234142780304,
0.37780269980430603,
0.5180252194404602,
0.29983609914779663,
0.14122426509857178,
0.14766143262386322,
-0.39055582880973816,
-0.43445637822151184,
-0.36485642194747925,
-1.1342211961746216,
-0.28267377614974976,
0.27888724207878113,
-0.5052530765533447,
-0.033051855862140656,
-0.3356233239173889,
-0.31243976950645447,
0.30748042464256287,
-0.020535783842206,
-0.4227955639362335,
0.2601429224014282,
0.41751614212989807,
1.2038413286209106,
-0.6728522181510925,
0.959812581539154,
0.3825375735759735,
-0.6457911133766174,
-0.6835168600082397,
0.07046307623386383,
-0.5669310092926025,
-0.4299847483634949,
0.6775109171867371,
-0.4536598324775696,
-0.18654072284698486,
-0.04415995627641678,
-0.763056755065918,
-1.1658895015716553,
1.3067148923873901,
0.7415196299552917,
-0.6841983199119568,
-0.22844988107681274,
0.2929658591747284,
0.5447478890419006,
-0.38761472702026367,
-0.23525208234786987,
0.25898900628089905,
0.3873453140258789,
0.2373371720314026,
-0.5264220237731934,
0.3001152276992798,
-0.11997366696596146,
0.3423832058906555,
-0.27517643570899963,
-0.5190525650978088,
0.6540778279304504,
0.031665150076150894,
-0.2148306518793106,
0.3074847459793091,
1.2619463205337524,
0.7694697380065918,
0.3898061215877533,
0.15597011148929596,
0.4573434293270111,
0.8827835917472839,
-0.09954721480607986,
1.0615234375,
-0.3364681601524353,
0.2371646761894226,
1.443740725517273,
-0.3000193238258362,
0.9106248617172241,
0.8542069792747498,
0.06626945734024048,
0.9981085062026978,
0.5090682506561279,
-0.13575726747512817,
0.5200249552726746,
0.10614817589521408,
-0.19011804461479187,
-0.36347952485084534,
-0.5196753144264221,
-0.5787377953529358,
0.133784219622612,
0.33799684047698975,
-1.055184006690979,
-0.3566089868545532,
-0.02769002690911293,
0.10971060395240784,
0.18666882812976837,
-0.3070092797279358,
0.44135066866874695,
0.06731543689966202,
-0.9389358162879944,
0.29755833745002747,
0.17018640041351318,
0.21008117496967316,
-0.6254956126213074,
0.1725182831287384,
-0.5446370244026184,
0.00959214847534895,
-0.5245087146759033,
-0.6990117430686951,
0.11677359789609909,
0.5445902347564697,
-0.772404670715332,
-0.35522544384002686,
1.0811233520507812,
-0.22025543451309204,
-0.5077870488166809,
-0.11656706780195236,
0.3131062984466553,
-0.029464254155755043,
0.2360471785068512,
-0.08393124490976334,
-0.06408552080392838,
-0.07190244644880295,
-0.6942808628082275,
0.45897459983825684,
0.6985762119293213,
-0.04375648871064186,
0.3171657919883728,
0.9264087677001953,
0.1038191020488739,
0.2760142982006073,
0.3211338520050049,
0.701416552066803,
-0.5301793217658997,
-0.3647342622280121,
-0.7515762448310852,
0.3574831187725067,
-0.4002712368965149,
-0.19075313210487366,
1.1431465148925781,
0.5761724710464478,
1.0973159074783325,
-0.04576222226023674,
0.954783022403717,
-0.20215654373168945,
0.38156118988990784,
-0.6342751383781433,
0.4519914388656616,
-0.40070536732673645,
0.30208587646484375,
-0.25492921471595764,
-0.8649449944496155,
-0.07764638215303421,
0.43187156319618225,
-0.05923798680305481,
-0.03346884250640869,
0.5255717635154724,
0.7643564939498901,
-0.09944147616624832,
-0.15335795283317566,
0.11933445930480957,
0.20123456418514252,
0.47579142451286316,
0.3260507881641388,
0.8990138173103333,
-0.10406322032213211,
0.4320310652256012,
-0.28100040555000305,
0.16302001476287842,
-0.1864156275987625,
-1.0534238815307617,
-0.5784660577774048,
-0.45937401056289673,
-0.5618893504142761,
-0.5924155712127686,
-0.29798486828804016,
0.4835070073604584,
0.6385064721107483,
-0.7109830975532532,
0.3959199786186218,
-0.3762507140636444,
0.13020333647727966,
0.09874678403139114,
-0.24625380337238312,
0.35235169529914856,
-0.39375799894332886,
-0.9321157932281494,
0.6438621282577515,
0.296896368265152,
0.016945917159318924,
-0.7300849556922913,
-0.11808205395936966,
-0.23360346257686615,
0.43636927008628845,
0.5881817936897278,
0.32575464248657227,
-0.6421805620193481,
-0.5176016092300415,
0.07698708027601242,
-0.464534193277359,
-0.3397429287433624,
0.8731701970100403,
-0.780604898929596,
0.0733150839805603,
0.908757209777832,
0.3879275619983673,
0.49954119324684143,
0.358377605676651,
0.45528945326805115,
-1.0439143180847168,
-0.31190621852874756,
-0.13761284947395325,
0.5770670771598816,
0.2812296748161316,
-0.4436001479625702,
0.44596049189567566,
0.27512314915657043,
-0.6486621499061584,
-1.167653203010559,
0.2471996247768402,
-0.9581246972084045,
-0.3200048804283142,
1.3634883165359497,
-0.398243248462677,
-0.22937078773975372,
0.0035179262049496174,
0.13284122943878174,
0.16982980072498322,
-0.1882113367319107,
0.6640573740005493,
0.8127844333648682,
-0.2092570960521698,
0.15463635325431824,
0.0023696552962064743,
0.26131486892700195,
0.23489290475845337,
-0.611158013343811,
0.2678236663341522,
0.8401069045066833,
0.2484419196844101,
0.6814349889755249,
0.31656333804130554,
-0.17243236303329468,
0.20872247219085693,
0.27407699823379517,
-0.47682639956474304,
-0.44919514656066895,
-0.46211594343185425,
0.1548575907945633,
0.72293621301651,
0.08903659880161285,
0.19001533091068268
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.06124v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.06124v1
|
Enhancing Long-Term Memory using Hierarchical Aggregate Tree for Retrieval Augmented Generation
| 2024-06-10T09:29:08 | 2024-06-10T09:29:08 |
Aadharsh Aadhithya A, Sachin Kumar S, Soman K. P
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.7
|
Large language models have limited context capacity, hindering reasoning over
long conversations. We propose the Hierarchical Aggregate Tree memory structure
to recursively aggregate relevant dialogue context through conditional tree
traversals. HAT encapsulates information from children nodes, enabling broad
coverage with depth control. We formulate finding best context as optimal tree
traversal. Experiments show HAT improves dialog coherence and summary quality
over baseline contexts, demonstrating the techniques effectiveness for multi
turn reasoning without exponential parameter growth. This memory augmentation
enables more consistent, grounded longform conversations from LLMs
|
[
-0.41645878553390503,
-1.2798269987106323,
0.803491473197937,
0.09852930158376694,
-0.22660569846630096,
0.3993024230003357,
-0.04205232113599777,
-0.7366719245910645,
0.2554350197315216,
0.37614357471466064,
-0.45552194118499756,
-0.2968120276927948,
-0.39980775117874146,
-0.20494890213012695,
-0.3709002435207367,
0.8036925792694092,
0.16284167766571045,
-0.6364041566848755,
-0.45863527059555054,
-0.32387998700141907,
-0.5498949289321899,
-0.6822718977928162,
-1.0026015043258667,
-0.21479405462741852,
0.555076003074646,
0.39229363203048706,
0.9662205576896667,
0.4721860885620117,
0.1468643695116043,
0.42685839533805847,
-0.41500216722488403,
0.40651223063468933,
-0.5477351546287537,
0.5001738667488098,
-0.24342961609363556,
-0.09169041365385056,
-0.9959043860435486,
-0.3891119062900543,
0.7481997013092041,
0.7635082006454468,
-0.276444673538208,
-0.2845916152000427,
0.04528587684035301,
0.5667413473129272,
-0.6081218123435974,
0.19477999210357666,
-0.8087641000747681,
-0.06083224341273308,
0.007941403426229954,
-0.667678952217102,
-0.3363794982433319,
0.07728108018636703,
0.4410232603549957,
-0.4197608530521393,
0.03473884239792824,
0.18715691566467285,
0.6331160068511963,
0.11510481685400009,
-0.45615869760513306,
-0.29597923159599304,
-0.5226472616195679,
0.9221685528755188,
-0.49330517649650574,
0.3421468436717987,
0.6726354956626892,
0.27272793650627136,
-0.20005887746810913,
-0.6468999981880188,
-0.23869578540325165,
-0.24259641766548157,
-0.21259039640426636,
0.15611447393894196,
-0.15681645274162292,
0.4012090861797333,
0.239481121301651,
0.6864352822303772,
-0.09828617423772812,
-0.2583765685558319,
-0.21184107661247253,
-0.33610957860946655,
0.16098544001579285,
0.21949072182178497,
0.29781779646873474,
-0.2410905659198761,
-0.1390114724636078,
0.23579490184783936,
-0.49772360920906067,
0.10216303169727325,
-0.01508654560893774,
0.15576845407485962,
0.12714193761348724,
0.47994691133499146,
-0.10118875652551651,
0.7151054739952087,
0.2918984591960907,
-0.5066549777984619,
0.16932515799999237,
-0.5724730491638184,
-0.29539865255355835,
0.023055313155055046,
0.19823887944221497,
0.22341859340667725,
-0.06521684676408768,
-0.30067116022109985,
-0.2505519688129425,
-0.09414446353912354,
0.12118397653102875,
-0.8394622206687927,
0.11127224564552307,
0.21222974359989166,
-0.16621814668178558,
0.06848522275686264,
-0.23501065373420715,
-0.5088931918144226,
0.0660656988620758,
-0.3985542953014374,
0.18680314719676971,
-0.649385392665863,
-0.05423536151647568,
0.0783710777759552,
-0.1913723647594452,
0.05097734555602074,
0.4889357388019562,
-0.8272855281829834,
0.40780511498451233,
0.631595253944397,
0.6596065759658813,
-0.32417866587638855,
-0.12184476107358932,
-0.7011176943778992,
0.5359756350517273,
-0.3619045615196228,
0.6317375302314758,
-0.8130913972854614,
-0.3743809461593628,
-0.0028483092319220304,
0.07249096035957336,
0.22881928086280823,
-0.5790175795555115,
0.4246707260608673,
-0.6507124304771423,
0.6591616868972778,
0.015391048975288868,
-0.2795456051826477,
-0.09580467641353607,
0.3960910737514496,
-0.40127408504486084,
1.1649620532989502,
0.5851686596870422,
-0.7534343600273132,
0.4382660686969757,
-0.39899957180023193,
-0.7832080125808716,
-0.013380240648984909,
-0.2818174362182617,
-0.5248351097106934,
-0.046392325311899185,
0.6643391251564026,
0.1651422679424286,
-0.0757974162697792,
0.8006296157836914,
-0.08200164884328842,
-0.2812354266643524,
-0.21286308765411377,
-0.4319876432418823,
0.492344468832016,
0.17422281205654144,
-0.25029757618904114,
0.0965317115187645,
-0.4045572876930237,
-0.15711936354637146,
-0.06111558526754379,
-0.49615198373794556,
-0.46566906571388245,
0.2288535237312317,
-0.5173771381378174,
-0.16431090235710144,
0.22034364938735962,
-0.428431898355484,
0.19797401130199432,
-0.35557448863983154,
0.3539919853210449,
0.5682629346847534,
0.25897008180618286,
0.6424757242202759,
-0.49259790778160095,
0.3265884816646576,
0.5554945468902588,
-0.022134095430374146,
-0.826363205909729,
-0.3426531255245209,
-0.8751612901687622,
-0.1829536110162735,
-0.14976011216640472,
0.39451903104782104,
-1.0076775550842285,
0.585768461227417,
-0.3404429256916046,
0.32278183102607727,
-0.03370470553636551,
-0.1285714954137802,
0.1988162398338318,
0.8066200017929077,
0.5815512537956238,
-0.2859804034233093,
-0.7866321802139282,
-1.0118327140808105,
0.24058033525943756,
-0.24401672184467316,
-0.07459256052970886,
0.8074412941932678,
0.09745068848133087,
-0.5662795305252075,
1.140508770942688,
-0.3243868350982666,
-0.05030016601085663,
-0.23592209815979004,
0.018475307151675224,
0.35099467635154724,
0.27759411931037903,
0.38002434372901917,
-0.43833643198013306,
-0.28646260499954224,
-0.09851334244012833,
-0.4472273290157318,
0.02660469524562359,
-0.4751919209957123,
-0.32793593406677246,
0.3480677306652069,
0.39555829763412476,
-0.9136115908622742,
0.37689444422721863,
0.40005695819854736,
-0.30369821190834045,
0.1230665072798729,
-0.08358275145292282,
0.29688650369644165,
-0.9594478011131287,
-0.24226658046245575,
-0.4199608862400055,
-0.6900941133499146,
-0.2603563666343689,
-0.04425055906176567,
-0.12534792721271515,
0.007846066728234291,
-0.17349335551261902,
0.39575818181037903,
-0.6858348250389099,
-0.3544405400753021,
-0.38171276450157166,
0.27713996171951294,
-0.014268988743424416,
0.6281337738037109,
0.08309127390384674,
1.2123050689697266,
0.730682373046875,
-0.8031962513923645,
0.13581445813179016,
0.008115585893392563,
-0.3061763644218445,
0.732368528842926,
-0.42224279046058655,
0.2594863772392273,
-0.2770213186740875,
0.6832704544067383,
-0.8369672894477844,
-0.14756499230861664,
-0.053067900240421295,
-0.43377378582954407,
0.34436917304992676,
0.055990565568208694,
-0.22874146699905396,
-0.22184546291828156,
-0.3858548700809479,
0.46618977189064026,
0.5050881505012512,
-0.8423376083374023,
0.7987350225448608,
0.5104956030845642,
-0.3531884253025055,
-0.458217978477478,
-0.47388356924057007,
0.30279260873794556,
-0.2563219964504242,
-0.8766970634460449,
0.56880122423172,
-0.1274993121623993,
-0.2541104555130005,
-0.14423415064811707,
-0.30772635340690613,
0.05274224653840065,
-0.1344723254442215,
-0.0512867271900177,
-0.0009650902356952429,
-0.4805387854576111,
0.26867038011550903,
0.25465866923332214,
0.011811391450464725,
-0.07970912754535675,
-0.14110344648361206,
0.6217145919799805,
-0.22739015519618988,
-0.13337767124176025,
-0.04693903401494026,
0.5320161581039429,
0.6129862666130066,
0.19893820583820343,
0.5303609371185303,
0.24218904972076416,
-0.20502735674381256,
-0.0637926384806633,
-0.5994470715522766,
-0.12802964448928833,
-0.5076478719711304,
0.3624754548072815,
-0.5573509931564331,
-1.2856626510620117,
0.46225813031196594,
-0.16724815964698792,
0.050717152655124664,
0.44781914353370667,
0.3593943119049072,
-0.13470910489559174,
1.0871847867965698,
0.23740904033184052,
-0.38546884059906006,
0.5533757209777832,
-0.1338583528995514,
0.060691799968481064,
-1.10748291015625,
-0.035858187824487686,
-0.018460439518094063,
-0.14497174322605133,
-0.21799997985363007,
-0.7883763313293457,
0.31396329402923584,
0.33120083808898926,
-0.3956814408302307,
-0.023160524666309357,
-0.42082637548446655,
0.5558509230613708,
0.4207979142665863,
0.3251504898071289,
0.5106145143508911,
0.26683568954467773,
0.03517190366983414,
0.16078566014766693,
-0.7642531394958496,
-0.12032243609428406,
0.5258634090423584,
0.6153983473777771,
0.6419084072113037,
0.06646693497896194,
0.4663585126399994,
0.29325199127197266,
0.29073989391326904,
-0.8691274523735046,
0.6940616369247437,
0.3989819884300232,
-0.5397096276283264,
-0.568641185760498,
-0.4225738048553467,
-1.1981624364852905,
0.2838934063911438,
0.05314306542277336,
-0.7925286293029785,
0.0543719157576561,
0.1830504834651947,
-0.27150920033454895,
0.2500914931297302,
-0.4104846119880676,
0.08115933835506439,
-0.23967796564102173,
-0.39069151878356934,
-0.40735185146331787,
-0.6636434197425842,
0.37910860776901245,
0.19723092019557953,
0.04618394374847412,
0.18860389292240143,
-0.15461039543151855,
0.5185407400131226,
-0.4236706495285034,
0.8265451788902283,
-0.016655392944812775,
0.022966936230659485,
0.8837777376174927,
0.04679551720619202,
0.7683407068252563,
0.1182996928691864,
0.12132354825735092,
-0.033792853355407715,
-0.4312926232814789,
-0.4944547712802887,
-0.5824146270751953,
0.60093092918396,
-0.5876894593238831,
-1.1200873851776123,
-0.38602587580680847,
-0.6472924947738647,
-0.4897153973579407,
0.04958699271082878,
-0.15883095562458038,
0.28011614084243774,
-0.1210520938038826,
0.6667605638504028,
0.5697426199913025,
-0.32421040534973145,
0.356920063495636,
0.21394331753253937,
-0.46725744009017944,
-0.6501743793487549,
0.38099122047424316,
-0.13508109748363495,
0.4566749036312103,
0.3995541036128998,
0.3507678806781769,
-0.1223280280828476,
-0.5183542370796204,
-0.45836392045021057,
-0.0202813521027565,
-0.5642162561416626,
-0.4442920386791229,
-0.9127600789070129,
-0.4214910566806793,
-0.312374472618103,
-0.08492856472730637,
0.03930051252245903,
-0.5602430701255798,
0.0169377438724041,
-0.5592780113220215,
0.6390389800071716,
0.33329325914382935,
-0.09259890764951706,
0.6042166352272034,
-0.5721597075462341,
0.6844980120658875,
0.612949788570404,
0.3436049520969391,
0.26732683181762695,
-0.5294248461723328,
-0.24789339303970337,
0.16113881766796112,
-0.4092859625816345,
-0.5548176169395447,
0.30069732666015625,
0.2810368239879608,
0.4984998404979706,
0.29594919085502625,
-0.34794870018959045,
1.239514946937561,
-0.5837299227714539,
0.7360888719558716,
0.25988510251045227,
-0.9032878875732422,
0.5375272035598755,
-0.7107294797897339,
0.6841029524803162,
0.44943705201148987,
-0.021448194980621338,
-0.42590096592903137,
-0.47758927941322327,
-0.7880176901817322,
-1.0534158945083618,
0.6621949672698975,
0.22677215933799744,
0.28029313683509827,
-0.37902212142944336,
0.254852294921875,
-0.095738485455513,
0.04890865832567215,
-0.5230927467346191,
0.06607665866613388,
0.021357592195272446,
0.22618936002254486,
0.059527620673179626,
-0.6704604029655457,
-0.033697277307510376,
-0.610444962978363,
0.385642945766449,
0.0082496153190732,
0.2939211130142212,
0.2952304184436798,
0.09908240288496017,
-0.35976701974868774,
0.32230570912361145,
0.36340469121932983,
0.9606394171714783,
-0.43545007705688477,
0.3201899528503418,
0.5836130976676941,
-0.3150370717048645,
-0.19058381021022797,
-0.3343696594238281,
-0.0522695817053318,
0.020141424611210823,
0.5012018084526062,
0.7606701254844666,
0.3346066474914551,
-0.35909759998321533,
0.2354380041360855,
0.17352049052715302,
-0.07943297177553177,
-0.4123178720474243,
0.032839518040418625,
0.4539622366428375,
0.14240023493766785,
0.5124722123146057,
-0.24632112681865692,
0.19462478160858154,
-1.1104145050048828,
0.6457914710044861,
0.5367790460586548,
-0.0988735482096672,
0.04692785069346428,
0.22690144181251526,
0.2255275845527649,
-0.3668421506881714,
0.8145796060562134,
0.13081622123718262,
-0.5083001852035522,
0.39416733384132385,
0.866882860660553,
0.595791220664978,
-0.4101404547691345,
-0.08579941093921661,
0.5084673166275024,
0.05162535607814789,
0.08170521259307861,
0.18805119395256042,
-0.5659896731376648,
-0.6982158422470093,
-0.6815330982208252,
-0.49358895421028137,
-0.3810236155986786,
0.09766822308301926,
-0.3463900685310364,
-0.036733176559209824,
-0.3300027847290039,
-0.2258867472410202,
-0.5151310563087463,
-0.21700650453567505,
-0.34516239166259766,
0.3799830675125122,
0.02102431282401085,
0.7269991636276245,
-0.38308823108673096,
0.9178884029388428,
-0.023859981447458267,
-0.03908700868487358,
-0.39964601397514343,
-0.13161085546016693,
-0.4707561731338501,
-0.7924522161483765,
0.49063974618911743,
0.12084468454122543,
-0.5754683017730713,
-0.2962929308414459,
-0.6031544208526611,
-1.0792304277420044,
1.2587275505065918,
0.027655381709337234,
-0.6961222887039185,
-0.13932467997074127,
0.08815407752990723,
0.6180460453033447,
-0.692648708820343,
0.317897766828537,
0.6833456754684448,
0.3355916142463684,
0.7550164461135864,
-0.7264640927314758,
-0.06306739151477814,
-0.009114869870245457,
-0.15118762850761414,
0.32732152938842773,
-0.33648574352264404,
0.7978866696357727,
-0.18066635727882385,
-0.4777691960334778,
0.06160292774438858,
0.9712232351303101,
0.6340430974960327,
0.5265088677406311,
0.7399912476539612,
0.7342649698257446,
0.6963048577308655,
0.13393288850784302,
1.2202191352844238,
-0.34901419281959534,
-0.01666848547756672,
1.5252186059951782,
0.0810851901769638,
0.6062524318695068,
0.40849825739860535,
-0.07087130099534988,
0.6401474475860596,
0.6702428460121155,
0.7105445265769958,
0.40818268060684204,
0.07301922142505646,
-0.360700786113739,
-0.3551153838634491,
-0.1926271617412567,
-0.5237483382225037,
-0.06156843155622482,
0.7308189272880554,
-0.3463258743286133,
-0.17345048487186432,
-0.29665419459342957,
0.1496707797050476,
-0.10743119567632675,
-0.3669850826263428,
0.8018047213554382,
0.22001367807388306,
-1.0039787292480469,
0.6484543681144714,
-0.24103939533233643,
0.7575283050537109,
-0.3819725811481476,
-0.22692444920539856,
-0.4644407629966736,
0.005178913474082947,
-0.23066341876983643,
-0.7930414080619812,
0.469698965549469,
-0.1572788655757904,
0.022134505212306976,
-0.40918707847595215,
0.6929323673248291,
-0.6548346281051636,
-0.4588869512081146,
0.37233060598373413,
0.6516304612159729,
0.07468979060649872,
-0.06461351364850998,
-0.5201088190078735,
-0.14004264771938324,
-0.14941400289535522,
-0.4068527817726135,
0.2852114140987396,
0.7365350127220154,
-0.3065601587295532,
0.5480080246925354,
0.6495782136917114,
-0.1597309559583664,
-0.14453619718551636,
0.1625833958387375,
1.1306837797164917,
-0.8767369985580444,
-0.484649121761322,
-0.8340410590171814,
0.4595683515071869,
-0.36308637261390686,
0.028691956773400307,
0.66816246509552,
0.9071399569511414,
0.45667052268981934,
0.29680541157722473,
0.42283567786216736,
0.07609741389751434,
0.6811295747756958,
-0.44762328267097473,
0.22330503165721893,
-0.4538523554801941,
0.31231603026390076,
-0.20387521386146545,
-1.1099169254302979,
-0.18379276990890503,
0.5956321358680725,
-0.34108540415763855,
0.08607006072998047,
0.8725704550743103,
0.5700657963752747,
-0.40006086230278015,
-0.17810434103012085,
0.44808751344680786,
0.36263611912727356,
0.4801611602306366,
0.7053205966949463,
1.04840886592865,
-0.1322178989648819,
0.395366907119751,
0.08343936502933502,
-0.2617324888706207,
0.09092994034290314,
-0.8191800117492676,
-0.8761920928955078,
-0.34940293431282043,
-0.0571572370827198,
-0.38657110929489136,
0.22619502246379852,
0.6053224802017212,
0.7530370354652405,
-0.6295309066772461,
-0.267022043466568,
-0.26587098836898804,
0.30240070819854736,
0.26496627926826477,
-0.28929394483566284,
0.46861544251441956,
-0.48367416858673096,
-0.5373790860176086,
0.6029263734817505,
0.6865312457084656,
-0.048855334520339966,
-0.22145570814609528,
-0.16005952656269073,
-0.2097935676574707,
0.22724226117134094,
1.1917362213134766,
0.16780927777290344,
-0.7300911545753479,
-0.5789384841918945,
-0.17539778351783752,
-0.05237731710076332,
0.6932883858680725,
0.8624213337898254,
-1.145605206489563,
0.3547552227973938,
0.5591315031051636,
0.6219510436058044,
0.7484285235404968,
0.515327513217926,
0.6203383803367615,
-0.6250556111335754,
0.3633394241333008,
0.47270748019218445,
0.4703558683395386,
0.2951916456222534,
-0.4876991808414459,
0.5637996792793274,
-0.09179424494504929,
-0.5668081641197205,
-0.32378530502319336,
0.3470728099346161,
-1.1646729707717896,
-0.5021693110466003,
1.1402262449264526,
0.0805707648396492,
-0.20627479255199432,
-0.21759846806526184,
-0.5345656275749207,
-0.03369147703051567,
-0.6814415454864502,
0.7119884490966797,
0.6422730684280396,
-0.4224715828895569,
-0.42368751764297485,
-0.2689831256866455,
0.4250720739364624,
0.4068736732006073,
-0.8248838782310486,
-0.0391460545361042,
0.8427542448043823,
-0.1460789442062378,
0.2757911682128906,
1.0179905891418457,
-0.16840852797031403,
0.1618012934923172,
-0.10125819593667984,
-0.4605414569377899,
0.17732244729995728,
-0.5883677005767822,
0.22705639898777008,
0.2391967475414276,
0.07850577682256699,
0.17197050154209137
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.06110v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.06110v1
|
Recurrent Context Compression: Efficiently Expanding the Context Window of LLM
| 2024-06-10T08:50:59 | 2024-06-10T08:50:59 |
Chensen Huang, Guibo Zhu, Xuepeng Wang, Yifei Luo, Guojing Ge, Haoran Chen, Dong Yi, Jinqiao Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
To extend the context length of Transformer-based large language models
(LLMs) and improve comprehension capabilities, we often face limitations due to
computational resources and bounded memory storage capacity. This work
introduces a method called Recurrent Context Compression (RCC), designed to
efficiently expand the context window length of LLMs within constrained storage
space. We also investigate the issue of poor model responses when both
instructions and context are compressed in downstream tasks, and propose an
instruction reconstruction method to mitigate this problem. We validated the
effectiveness of our approach on multiple tasks, achieving a compression rate
of up to 32x on text reconstruction tasks with a BLEU4 score close to 0.95, and
nearly 100\% accuracy on a passkey retrieval task with a sequence length of 1M.
Finally, our method demonstrated competitive performance in long-text
question-answering tasks compared to non-compressed methods, while
significantly saving storage resources in long-text inference tasks. Our code,
models, and demo are available at https://github.com/WUHU-G/RCC_Transformer
|
[
-0.30774542689323425,
-0.6219519972801208,
0.6610809564590454,
0.09372691065073013,
-0.20251822471618652,
0.04956020042300224,
-0.500451922416687,
-0.42729631066322327,
-0.035837527364492416,
0.546526312828064,
-0.8072089552879333,
-0.33273398876190186,
-0.5352747440338135,
0.18082548677921295,
-0.5244314074516296,
0.7958669662475586,
-0.026430170983076096,
-0.31644564867019653,
-0.3804510533809662,
0.032759811729192734,
-0.8788229823112488,
-0.39914390444755554,
-0.5165587067604065,
-0.06714528053998947,
0.25067999958992004,
0.5387387275695801,
0.20576517283916473,
0.5437940955162048,
0.3267407715320587,
0.2787407636642456,
-0.14724694192409515,
0.24036915600299835,
-0.7472445964813232,
0.6114790439605713,
0.05788905546069145,
-0.1771811842918396,
-0.3279460370540619,
-0.4145786464214325,
0.8197591304779053,
0.5432966351509094,
-0.32117846608161926,
0.10595162212848663,
0.3328535556793213,
0.7405508756637573,
-0.7715778946876526,
0.13664378225803375,
-0.6318344473838806,
-0.13353261351585388,
0.24550962448120117,
-0.5308041572570801,
-0.7826827764511108,
0.011096550151705742,
0.08869227766990662,
-0.3688620924949646,
0.3939426839351654,
0.0863036960363388,
0.4905838668346405,
0.6082228422164917,
-0.507800281047821,
-0.14993169903755188,
-0.8337804079055786,
0.9519506096839905,
-0.5177844762802124,
0.4136410355567932,
0.1514199823141098,
0.1950535774230957,
-0.1769653707742691,
-0.9032469391822815,
-0.45133906602859497,
-0.031664494425058365,
-0.2586578130722046,
0.05180475488305092,
-0.2643616497516632,
0.09189475327730179,
0.48419687151908875,
0.3596873879432678,
-0.6282910108566284,
-0.15032947063446045,
-0.4442741870880127,
-0.1998581886291504,
0.31180715560913086,
0.296764075756073,
0.19380104541778564,
-0.10967875272035599,
-0.47021496295928955,
-0.15619604289531708,
-0.7618852853775024,
-0.03870570659637451,
-0.0033530564978718758,
0.12413673102855682,
0.03634420409798622,
0.4025896191596985,
-0.083965964615345,
1.190367579460144,
-0.25948649644851685,
-0.1621168553829193,
-0.18240681290626526,
-0.4137824773788452,
-0.22547189891338348,
-0.0008844720432534814,
0.33051973581314087,
0.3506616950035095,
-0.06922270357608795,
-0.16496869921684265,
-0.18189780414104462,
-0.20732523500919342,
0.5761399865150452,
-0.9444041848182678,
0.1375046670436859,
0.26483839750289917,
-0.3555678427219391,
0.165642648935318,
0.08073559403419495,
-0.7318964004516602,
-0.04904580116271973,
-0.279116153717041,
0.001007742015644908,
-0.34243205189704895,
0.2296106070280075,
0.18993651866912842,
0.06295083463191986,
0.3161921799182892,
0.4037777781486511,
-0.9058703780174255,
0.3275730013847351,
0.7773205637931824,
0.7572985887527466,
-0.3602990210056305,
-0.0701378732919693,
-0.5448046922683716,
0.12114865332841873,
0.06287761777639389,
0.7350535988807678,
-0.36324068903923035,
-0.4802953600883484,
0.020510800182819366,
0.23760798573493958,
0.04490504786372185,
-0.3782035708427429,
0.5489464402198792,
-0.7031802535057068,
0.20665304362773895,
-0.014065641909837723,
-0.5530586838722229,
-0.07725434750318527,
0.3318811357021332,
-0.917716383934021,
0.8599461913108826,
0.3201392590999603,
-0.6537902355194092,
-0.22052566707134247,
-0.46724870800971985,
-0.5697585344314575,
0.02407313883304596,
-0.14637356996536255,
-0.10691358149051666,
0.23346047103405,
0.437612920999527,
0.6109045743942261,
-0.4154451787471771,
0.07083591818809509,
0.05526293069124222,
-0.5724053978919983,
0.2781808078289032,
-0.6767957210540771,
0.4311875104904175,
0.2269931137561798,
-0.06930367648601532,
0.14140760898590088,
-0.4379950165748596,
0.08681722730398178,
-0.14003773033618927,
-0.6663650870323181,
-0.12808001041412354,
-0.12122081220149994,
0.030997956171631813,
-0.04781767353415489,
0.3478950560092926,
-0.5682611465454102,
0.5485722422599792,
-0.2973298132419586,
0.7814753651618958,
0.6102014780044556,
0.049120817333459854,
0.4120728075504303,
-0.3049773871898651,
0.6207118034362793,
-0.20108157396316528,
-0.08606575429439545,
-0.6416826248168945,
-0.022975798696279526,
-0.696951687335968,
-0.1825818568468094,
0.2098720371723175,
0.5463794469833374,
-0.779787003993988,
0.4424853026866913,
-0.8316540122032166,
0.03461704030632973,
-0.2424306720495224,
-0.13497625291347504,
0.24934911727905273,
0.5808380842208862,
0.5287587642669678,
-0.11127354204654694,
-0.7048124074935913,
-0.9746982455253601,
-0.13657984137535095,
-0.004755435511469841,
-0.3113904893398285,
0.6220937371253967,
0.39259079098701477,
-0.20694001019001007,
0.946429431438446,
-0.7353248596191406,
-0.005374749656766653,
-0.4119471609592438,
-0.05000090226531029,
0.288940966129303,
0.41070330142974854,
0.14660610258579254,
-0.6913647055625916,
-0.3017392158508301,
-0.22482682764530182,
-0.2803478240966797,
-0.0959855243563652,
-0.25591936707496643,
0.13165540993213654,
0.5618469715118408,
0.5986964106559753,
-0.6263461112976074,
0.46419426798820496,
0.8496699333190918,
-0.21578441560268402,
0.45608243346214294,
-0.229142963886261,
0.3651775121688843,
-1.311984896659851,
0.08191229403018951,
-0.20245380699634552,
-0.5572893023490906,
-0.5355401635169983,
0.053478747606277466,
0.17245084047317505,
-0.1705896407365799,
-0.46709319949150085,
0.47541344165802,
-0.6221367716789246,
-0.15783387422561646,
-0.5617929697036743,
0.13088013231754303,
0.0023748683743178844,
0.5418545603752136,
0.11352693289518356,
1.1024084091186523,
0.09962227940559387,
-0.5413237810134888,
0.0921788215637207,
0.03895685449242592,
-0.5142777562141418,
0.0755363330245018,
-0.5303098559379578,
0.36544594168663025,
-0.26040199398994446,
0.6303936243057251,
-1.0134203433990479,
-0.3278712034225464,
-0.015887770801782608,
-0.345594584941864,
0.5789898633956909,
-0.06803027540445328,
-0.2556658089160919,
-0.219371035695076,
-0.16432808339595795,
0.6400051116943359,
0.582247793674469,
-0.79561448097229,
0.7139793634414673,
0.1144794300198555,
-0.003250937908887863,
-0.9242516160011292,
-0.8405641317367554,
0.10947835445404053,
-0.16161464154720306,
-0.5247077345848083,
0.8039563298225403,
-0.1699906289577484,
0.08328831940889359,
-0.11300686746835709,
-0.4119705259799957,
0.03678362816572189,
0.006032048258930445,
0.2655240297317505,
0.27197474241256714,
-0.12971238791942596,
0.056624870747327805,
0.14549735188484192,
0.036344315856695175,
-0.05778981372714043,
-0.3362235724925995,
0.7565517425537109,
-0.11731807887554169,
-0.05847552418708801,
-0.32082971930503845,
0.49506905674934387,
0.49682512879371643,
0.3251655399799347,
0.8157458901405334,
0.15372107923030853,
-0.40280449390411377,
-0.36451318860054016,
-0.5403485298156738,
-0.4002171754837036,
-0.4341297149658203,
0.43132421374320984,
-0.22220668196678162,
-1.4658048152923584,
0.3178851008415222,
-0.06380103528499603,
0.008886723779141903,
0.08228223025798798,
0.41192683577537537,
-0.017896877601742744,
0.5530043840408325,
0.6991121172904968,
-0.33750152587890625,
0.4303525686264038,
-0.26224541664123535,
0.15790030360221863,
-1.0645904541015625,
0.05434277653694153,
-0.4457429349422455,
-0.3043854534626007,
-0.3813987374305725,
-0.7326167821884155,
0.2027468979358673,
0.11728288978338242,
-0.13939620554447174,
0.6425119638442993,
-0.6834914088249207,
0.6071617007255554,
0.1989835947751999,
0.17113293707370758,
0.24166908860206604,
0.12015139311552048,
0.3482520878314972,
-0.07494764775037766,
-0.8257203698158264,
-0.4235402047634125,
0.7829239368438721,
0.4843970239162445,
0.7258279919624329,
0.13112390041351318,
0.6591416001319885,
0.16211125254631042,
0.4351349174976349,
-0.945228099822998,
0.573966920375824,
0.004987475462257862,
-0.37942269444465637,
-0.21868164837360382,
-0.5409931540489197,
-0.9026272296905518,
-0.014920183457434177,
0.1049896627664566,
-0.9704076647758484,
-0.08628573268651962,
0.20495648682117462,
-0.4368347227573395,
0.26911070942878723,
-0.5061022639274597,
0.5359814763069153,
0.0038210339844226837,
-0.3978739082813263,
-0.20653337240219116,
-0.5686846375465393,
0.37762534618377686,
0.04478931054472923,
-0.05712014064192772,
0.2962723970413208,
-0.23249562084674835,
0.6049816012382507,
-0.3312322795391083,
0.8573293685913086,
0.05073690786957741,
-0.1425251066684723,
0.24935060739517212,
-0.010815192013978958,
0.576590359210968,
0.05875347554683685,
0.2591805160045624,
0.04538474977016449,
0.06145896762609482,
-0.38646766543388367,
-1.0605746507644653,
0.8525834083557129,
-0.2697872519493103,
-0.7495684027671814,
-0.27158322930336,
-0.8908260464668274,
-0.14844441413879395,
-0.06910671293735504,
0.19690077006816864,
0.6003579497337341,
-0.07534358650445938,
0.5358561873435974,
0.6825905442237854,
-0.26903682947158813,
0.6479373574256897,
0.37087714672088623,
0.08390673995018005,
-0.35848453640937805,
0.4608968198299408,
-0.2584187090396881,
0.17610380053520203,
0.7634977102279663,
-0.16984276473522186,
-0.2662922739982605,
-0.598560094833374,
-0.23548802733421326,
0.004286241251975298,
-0.6722462177276611,
-0.5720335841178894,
-0.40617042779922485,
-0.2840389013290405,
-0.4149780571460724,
-0.15631264448165894,
-0.3456804156303406,
-0.4383630156517029,
-0.2502743601799011,
0.03949068859219551,
0.16756375133991241,
0.5039629936218262,
0.2537230849266052,
0.3723284900188446,
-0.9047328233718872,
0.05569985881447792,
-0.004345157649368048,
0.14167219400405884,
0.25910985469818115,
-0.712069571018219,
-0.2922826409339905,
-0.1339377611875534,
-0.22445818781852722,
-0.7764004468917847,
0.5371360182762146,
-0.1012253388762474,
0.14001084864139557,
0.21549759805202484,
0.30883538722991943,
0.8295877575874329,
-0.6710431575775146,
0.8213475346565247,
0.07126589119434357,
-0.7288399338722229,
0.24568769335746765,
-0.0013497720938175917,
0.7463787794113159,
0.4461798369884491,
0.31267228722572327,
-0.506674587726593,
-0.07332250475883484,
-0.29197195172309875,
-1.1138466596603394,
0.5106275081634521,
0.28568577766418457,
0.265813946723938,
-0.1238536462187767,
0.758246898651123,
-0.09855300933122635,
-0.13533319532871246,
-0.7317845821380615,
-0.2606787383556366,
0.024893365800380707,
-0.3305952548980713,
-0.07626157999038696,
-0.7387225031852722,
-0.1424141228199005,
-0.05086648464202881,
0.5450775623321533,
-0.20686298608779907,
0.7149158120155334,
0.5788266658782959,
-0.27419614791870117,
0.3327905237674713,
0.6806994676589966,
1.0085370540618896,
0.5285128355026245,
-0.19254831969738007,
0.2589411735534668,
0.3612814247608185,
-0.597974419593811,
0.14581571519374847,
0.16743449866771698,
0.1061251163482666,
-0.3099393844604492,
0.6391196846961975,
0.794532299041748,
0.371082603931427,
-0.7397671341896057,
0.23744437098503113,
-0.37922462821006775,
-0.08397695422172546,
-0.42110082507133484,
0.006778962444514036,
0.038254521787166595,
0.27141234278678894,
0.5433692932128906,
-0.2548614740371704,
0.17084448039531708,
-0.3715587854385376,
0.2640186846256256,
0.3234458863735199,
-0.36727941036224365,
0.08212364464998245,
0.34872201085090637,
0.08213887363672256,
-0.33769211173057556,
0.8763671517372131,
0.20265378057956696,
-0.5583446025848389,
0.40210723876953125,
0.8356719613075256,
0.6455630660057068,
-0.05358361080288887,
-0.34346431493759155,
0.6485681533813477,
0.27592113614082336,
-0.20703400671482086,
-0.0410512275993824,
-0.5574348568916321,
-0.7027411460876465,
-0.9049743413925171,
-0.36847713589668274,
-0.14401009678840637,
0.29557105898857117,
-0.8156037926673889,
-0.01419271994382143,
-0.04195578396320343,
-0.0851106122136116,
-0.5494257807731628,
0.005025344435125589,
-0.3205268681049347,
-0.07598640024662018,
0.0944976806640625,
1.371687412261963,
-0.22927039861679077,
1.042994499206543,
0.28544673323631287,
0.0878804475069046,
-0.7452273368835449,
0.17036479711532593,
-0.19494985044002533,
-0.4819832742214203,
0.5869815945625305,
0.4964230954647064,
-0.3652932345867157,
0.07537762075662613,
-0.5499120354652405,
-0.8010828495025635,
1.3744100332260132,
0.2373911589384079,
-0.92450350522995,
-0.05864253640174866,
-0.003837958676740527,
0.4354037046432495,
-0.560849666595459,
0.02810901589691639,
0.7129948139190674,
0.3558172881603241,
-0.03526821359992027,
-0.6593074798583984,
0.308075875043869,
-0.05332415923476219,
0.1531936228275299,
0.27226534485816956,
-0.1410394161939621,
0.2765083611011505,
-0.1958126425743103,
-0.5519097447395325,
0.43336352705955505,
0.9192186594009399,
0.300855427980423,
0.032183002680540085,
0.6312364935874939,
0.48102283477783203,
0.48284071683883667,
-0.03520774468779564,
1.3988584280014038,
-0.5413908362388611,
0.4883674681186676,
1.3546085357666016,
-0.07010660320520401,
0.9267984628677368,
0.7421543598175049,
0.10895833373069763,
0.5760928392410278,
0.4520815312862396,
0.2453954815864563,
0.4751216471195221,
0.18409693241119385,
-0.512243390083313,
-0.21353566646575928,
0.018561892211437225,
-0.038344502449035645,
0.20525215566158295,
0.35736167430877686,
-0.3688639998435974,
-0.0029400542844086885,
0.02318243868649006,
-0.15444891154766083,
0.1369146704673767,
-0.11664342880249023,
0.6124976277351379,
0.13584446907043457,
-1.0544772148132324,
0.6880447268486023,
0.03801630809903145,
0.7646836638450623,
-0.36428746581077576,
-0.13240455090999603,
-0.24802137911319733,
0.13512387871742249,
-0.028790438547730446,
-0.8570907115936279,
0.5282113552093506,
-0.09446336328983307,
-0.45007845759391785,
-0.45206764340400696,
0.8220533728599548,
-0.6046603918075562,
0.014872102066874504,
0.20825330913066864,
0.1935657411813736,
0.08560030162334442,
0.10414548963308334,
-0.40235981345176697,
0.3664117753505707,
0.23692750930786133,
-0.44048789143562317,
0.31279802322387695,
-0.10406647622585297,
0.14443473517894745,
0.737494945526123,
0.4091000556945801,
-0.22156867384910583,
-0.18991930782794952,
-0.091191366314888,
0.8707916140556335,
-0.7149801254272461,
-0.12768849730491638,
-0.758215069770813,
0.535535454750061,
-0.1181240826845169,
0.11197549849748611,
0.49797311425209045,
0.5653876066207886,
0.881616473197937,
-0.21908023953437805,
0.5329329967498779,
-0.06984458863735199,
0.45723211765289307,
-0.7441380023956299,
0.4611159563064575,
-0.49816298484802246,
0.581244707107544,
0.20165970921516418,
-0.778983473777771,
-0.3273766338825226,
0.5688492655754089,
-0.16870065033435822,
-0.029446512460708618,
0.9248526692390442,
0.8738855123519897,
-0.17561909556388855,
-0.1082252785563469,
0.20339713990688324,
0.0486164465546608,
0.1724063605070114,
0.8913531303405762,
0.8816908001899719,
-0.4676007032394409,
0.7797672748565674,
-0.24232210218906403,
-0.0029541393741965294,
-0.05092211067676544,
-1.026124358177185,
-0.7442257404327393,
-0.7415993809700012,
-0.18514767289161682,
-0.5122767686843872,
-0.17299026250839233,
0.769562840461731,
0.7984501123428345,
-0.5743603706359863,
-0.2334263175725937,
-0.2024860978126526,
0.20144005119800568,
-0.13257767260074615,
-0.2957453429698944,
0.27629297971725464,
-0.2665041983127594,
-0.8044919967651367,
0.6076509952545166,
0.222421333193779,
-0.03412183001637459,
-0.2611779272556305,
-0.1853693723678589,
0.06710256636142731,
-0.0707717314362526,
0.823318600654602,
0.3811444640159607,
-0.6225622892379761,
-0.3849155306816101,
0.1459280550479889,
-0.01816871017217636,
-0.054191846400499344,
1.2459380626678467,
-0.9313229322433472,
0.06571033596992493,
0.564532995223999,
0.846500813961029,
0.5968107581138611,
0.21729765832424164,
0.6819639205932617,
-1.0026594400405884,
0.14681799709796906,
0.160021111369133,
0.506528913974762,
0.2804906964302063,
-0.47730547189712524,
0.4753236770629883,
-0.18560928106307983,
-0.7449604868888855,
-0.9872753024101257,
0.4480219781398773,
-1.2772135734558105,
-0.7156423330307007,
1.2155317068099976,
-0.17046670615673065,
-0.4335399866104126,
0.18742333352565765,
-0.22902150452136993,
0.159428671002388,
-0.37411603331565857,
0.7308687567710876,
0.6164392232894897,
-0.2689916789531708,
-0.4952281713485718,
-0.6467259526252747,
0.3950938582420349,
0.3213450312614441,
-0.7443664073944092,
0.3561426103115082,
0.5338919162750244,
0.25825950503349304,
0.13940545916557312,
0.4665522873401642,
0.00928846001625061,
0.2317480891942978,
-0.2637053430080414,
-0.0234952624887228,
-0.13750243186950684,
-0.5060772895812988,
-0.6405957937240601,
0.25937139987945557,
-0.227132648229599,
-0.01770550198853016
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.06097v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.06097v1
|
StreamAtt: Direct Streaming Speech-to-Text Translation with Attention-based Audio History Selection
| 2024-06-10T08:27:58 | 2024-06-10T08:27:58 |
Sara Papi, Marco Gaido, Matteo Negri, Luisa Bentivogli
|
cs.SD
|
cs.SD, cs.AI, cs.CL, eess.AS
|
Streaming speech-to-text translation (StreamST) is the task of automatically
translating speech while incrementally receiving an audio stream. Unlike
simultaneous ST (SimulST), which deals with pre-segmented speech, StreamST
faces the challenges of handling continuous and unbounded audio streams. This
requires additional decisions about what to retain of the previous history,
which is impractical to keep entirely due to latency and computational
constraints. Despite the real-world demand for real-time ST, research on
streaming translation remains limited, with existing works solely focusing on
SimulST. To fill this gap, we introduce StreamAtt, the first StreamST policy,
and propose StreamLAAL, the first StreamST latency metric designed to be
comparable with existing metrics for SimulST. Extensive experiments across all
8 languages of MuST-C v1.0 show the effectiveness of StreamAtt compared to a
naive streaming baseline and the related state-of-the-art SimulST policy,
providing a first step in StreamST research.
|
[
-0.12280382961034775,
-0.6206244826316833,
0.42057526111602783,
0.5771586298942566,
-0.5931678414344788,
0.3121410608291626,
-0.2907482981681824,
-0.38286489248275757,
0.4127502143383026,
0.3218154013156891,
-0.7711743712425232,
-0.17814134061336517,
-0.7897986173629761,
-0.21855852007865906,
-0.8124525547027588,
1.1334232091903687,
-0.3107459843158722,
-0.15258771181106567,
0.040059372782707214,
-0.1546671986579895,
-0.6324144601821899,
-0.13403543829917908,
-0.8842006921768188,
-0.046447593718767166,
0.5496656894683838,
0.11129842698574066,
0.7581087350845337,
0.5188081860542297,
0.9612154364585876,
0.1194988340139389,
0.04494234547019005,
0.13401654362678528,
-0.686142086982727,
0.46438783407211304,
0.005260470788925886,
-0.1339792013168335,
-0.49693915247917175,
-0.17020206153392792,
0.8609866499900818,
0.24537843465805054,
0.11173965036869049,
0.5318316221237183,
0.08996428549289703,
0.7727776765823364,
-0.6521283388137817,
-0.11086459457874298,
-0.445399671792984,
0.17544689774513245,
-0.4981006681919098,
-0.6728070974349976,
-0.4248755872249603,
-0.5535410642623901,
0.20413993299007416,
-0.4795151948928833,
-0.020565273240208626,
0.05339713767170906,
0.941356897354126,
0.8044928908348083,
-0.2111419290304184,
0.0075643714517354965,
-1.189135193824768,
0.8128865361213684,
-0.6138587594032288,
0.720204770565033,
0.4484638571739197,
0.4684152603149414,
0.11491012573242188,
-1.0204681158065796,
-0.19403794407844543,
0.07537030428647995,
0.04137283191084862,
0.35808268189430237,
-0.2787572145462036,
-0.06922034919261932,
-0.22475551068782806,
0.385372519493103,
-0.9070426225662231,
-0.22129851579666138,
-0.5104473829269409,
-0.3090641498565674,
0.8590202331542969,
-0.03314821422100067,
0.08160687983036041,
0.356462687253952,
-0.5407863855361938,
0.1652226597070694,
-0.7437427043914795,
0.048300258815288544,
0.1812623143196106,
0.41047167778015137,
-0.07858887314796448,
0.3074348568916321,
-0.32461050152778625,
0.2778438627719879,
-0.13274642825126648,
-0.19061216711997986,
0.2082691192626953,
-0.33888569474220276,
-0.09270162880420685,
0.5436813235282898,
0.7016766667366028,
-0.026219340041279793,
0.0840529352426529,
-0.01654367335140705,
-0.17135678231716156,
-0.0844322219491005,
0.29932552576065063,
-0.5950790047645569,
0.006649439223110676,
0.45457082986831665,
-0.20869430899620056,
-0.12640716135501862,
-0.306296706199646,
-0.38350966572761536,
0.007680556736886501,
-0.1782306581735611,
0.3484649062156677,
-0.4600667655467987,
-0.35000941157341003,
-0.30827945470809937,
0.30591318011283875,
0.22855477035045624,
0.4886118471622467,
-0.5002647638320923,
0.3099367022514343,
0.7209233045578003,
1.2683309316635132,
-0.8096377849578857,
-0.5100974440574646,
-1.0162049531936646,
0.13380658626556396,
-0.1437484174966812,
0.9627543687820435,
-0.395271360874176,
-0.17072096467018127,
0.08765307813882828,
-0.3759106993675232,
0.10267801582813263,
-0.04493248835206032,
0.6357953548431396,
-0.4131413400173187,
-0.1959654837846756,
0.1959386169910431,
-0.7050626277923584,
0.012470762245357037,
-0.26624614000320435,
-0.513003945350647,
0.9519532322883606,
0.02560449205338955,
-0.662405788898468,
0.43027472496032715,
-0.5458492636680603,
-0.6405982971191406,
0.5606651306152344,
-0.023526055738329887,
-0.4055476784706116,
-0.04552822187542915,
0.03481515124440193,
0.24568498134613037,
-0.07755859941244125,
0.3869018852710724,
-0.026202591136097908,
-0.4628302752971649,
-0.013426769524812698,
-0.7454503774642944,
0.5287045836448669,
0.5120794177055359,
-0.2009403258562088,
0.16502755880355835,
-0.15289391577243805,
0.05178859084844589,
0.01518227718770504,
-0.2155134081840515,
-0.019809382036328316,
0.5417113900184631,
0.4472416043281555,
-0.04474770650267601,
0.12545248866081238,
-0.5244966149330139,
-0.04499609023332596,
-0.3774064779281616,
0.7732008695602417,
0.629711925983429,
-0.14537225663661957,
0.2640427350997925,
-0.17640192806720734,
0.5678385496139526,
-0.30446410179138184,
0.2827746868133545,
-0.4034213721752167,
-0.22452042996883392,
-0.469280481338501,
-0.3635707497596741,
0.2177864909172058,
0.6785306334495544,
-0.4413616359233856,
-0.23933658003807068,
-0.6993550062179565,
-0.4233587384223938,
-1.0084619522094727,
0.20392842590808868,
0.18434323370456696,
-0.01971990428864956,
0.49290943145751953,
0.028877712786197662,
-0.40144166350364685,
-0.8807154893875122,
-0.27741867303848267,
-0.2827814817428589,
0.2542175352573395,
0.16861467063426971,
-0.1025790125131607,
0.08763645589351654,
0.8614183664321899,
-0.5173741579055786,
-0.7582865953445435,
-0.18034198880195618,
0.11550658941268921,
-0.07195192575454712,
0.28239089250564575,
0.42389780282974243,
-0.6871168613433838,
-0.7354859709739685,
0.08604664355516434,
-0.5619041323661804,
-0.16994167864322662,
-0.32268035411834717,
-0.07776504009962082,
-0.051017556339502335,
0.41861051321029663,
-0.274348646402359,
0.7392579913139343,
0.8476331233978271,
-0.14163808524608612,
0.3213816285133362,
0.07308021187782288,
0.1888171285390854,
-0.7112302184104919,
-0.17030353844165802,
-0.4364011883735657,
-0.6721628308296204,
-0.7363383173942566,
-0.054599255323410034,
-0.0567961148917675,
-0.26965880393981934,
-1.00216805934906,
0.639289915561676,
-0.11832389235496521,
-0.04204026237130165,
-0.2721870243549347,
0.2956532835960388,
-0.3469869792461395,
0.35027527809143066,
0.08589552342891693,
1.3022634983062744,
0.3186439275741577,
-0.5560639500617981,
0.41003960371017456,
0.4493231475353241,
-0.013938806019723415,
0.7937175631523132,
-0.5412377119064331,
0.3947388529777527,
0.20245812833309174,
0.2290266901254654,
-1.2574471235275269,
0.06632925570011139,
-0.1220947727560997,
-0.7107315063476562,
0.34804853796958923,
0.01825900748372078,
-0.045259639620780945,
-0.20263192057609558,
-0.08059608191251755,
0.5922281742095947,
0.4915074408054352,
-0.2672187089920044,
0.31562691926956177,
0.44956299662590027,
-0.6269177198410034,
-0.3447170853614807,
-0.488101601600647,
0.2501307725906372,
0.0022273173090070486,
-0.6514540910720825,
0.24784822762012482,
-0.16019269824028015,
-0.055830273777246475,
-0.1406179517507553,
-0.4103223979473114,
-0.3840199112892151,
-0.191721573472023,
0.1854824423789978,
0.11674986779689789,
-0.3378940522670746,
-0.023499298840761185,
0.45166224241256714,
-0.10149358958005905,
-0.27577921748161316,
-0.5136600732803345,
0.452195942401886,
-0.028379518538713455,
-0.3589440584182739,
-0.7991695404052734,
0.721220850944519,
0.19084244966506958,
-0.3870067298412323,
0.07804013788700104,
0.5684530138969421,
0.14769898355007172,
-0.29880931973457336,
-0.6169046759605408,
-0.13438750803470612,
-0.43225497007369995,
0.22491633892059326,
-0.26244837045669556,
-1.1114180088043213,
0.09232711046934128,
-0.07750257104635239,
0.4610324800014496,
0.199177086353302,
0.18868610262870789,
-0.48645690083503723,
0.7520847320556641,
0.3169093728065491,
-0.047083962708711624,
0.5391325950622559,
-0.03689740598201752,
0.16498877108097076,
-0.6961687207221985,
0.2500864863395691,
-0.29504168033599854,
-0.6223992705345154,
-0.4026055634021759,
-0.21765802800655365,
0.2976617217063904,
-0.3324950039386749,
-0.08019392192363739,
0.5325429439544678,
-0.4454100430011749,
0.37187856435775757,
0.22126418352127075,
-0.048797305673360825,
0.3096214830875397,
0.08011168241500854,
0.4913840889930725,
-0.4191540777683258,
-0.48180004954338074,
-0.2512160837650299,
0.7609919309616089,
0.23443472385406494,
0.6826750636100769,
0.1364387571811676,
0.8439565300941467,
0.8517076969146729,
0.2520357668399811,
-0.8515233397483826,
0.429447740316391,
-0.2789817154407501,
-0.4570741355419159,
-0.5754958391189575,
-0.20703168213367462,
-1.0894861221313477,
0.26007696986198425,
0.23244351148605347,
-0.5331306457519531,
-0.08762781322002411,
0.5201866030693054,
-0.3135756552219391,
0.17991986870765686,
-0.39906853437423706,
0.4442320466041565,
-0.32459378242492676,
-0.6777949929237366,
-0.16313685476779938,
-0.7101925611495972,
0.042636752128601074,
-0.06902895122766495,
0.2647799551486969,
-0.4315026104450226,
-0.19370022416114807,
0.5512326955795288,
-0.15610846877098083,
0.3521762192249298,
-0.13163922727108002,
0.040571603924036026,
0.2891613841056824,
0.5502362251281738,
0.6347137689590454,
-0.0956043228507042,
0.43067657947540283,
0.3812981843948364,
0.2814306616783142,
-0.4031343460083008,
-0.2652216851711273,
0.6320709586143494,
-0.6766954660415649,
-0.48480159044265747,
-0.6038005352020264,
-0.4276251494884491,
-0.1738513559103012,
0.2567487359046936,
0.1379072517156601,
0.25432828068733215,
-0.5491177439689636,
0.4443575441837311,
0.6640557050704956,
0.1852293461561203,
0.546573281288147,
0.5488841533660889,
-0.4277496635913849,
-0.19646663963794708,
1.2283005714416504,
0.05406123772263527,
0.4183078706264496,
0.5972060561180115,
0.08863566815853119,
-0.2453424483537674,
-0.7091832160949707,
-0.44298550486564636,
0.2563149631023407,
-0.28442510962486267,
-0.32384395599365234,
-0.6185044050216675,
-0.5266448855400085,
-0.4190702438354492,
-0.27903294563293457,
-0.8731892108917236,
-0.24327480792999268,
-0.1711435616016388,
-0.053494613617658615,
0.32660675048828125,
0.42939257621765137,
0.04204372689127922,
0.564576268196106,
-0.6919369697570801,
0.2958071529865265,
0.2235593944787979,
0.3077869415283203,
-0.4371594786643982,
-0.9049372673034668,
-0.2600598633289337,
-0.12269094586372375,
-0.30052149295806885,
-0.8566110134124756,
0.5429916977882385,
0.6297914385795593,
0.38795143365859985,
0.2926429212093353,
0.05268773436546326,
0.7699940204620361,
-0.9134415984153748,
0.8356424570083618,
0.11149852722883224,
-0.8212623596191406,
0.7598897814750671,
-0.3618636429309845,
0.5151193141937256,
0.749643862247467,
0.17999747395515442,
-0.868807852268219,
-0.6799895167350769,
-0.3245634436607361,
-1.0249894857406616,
0.7613080143928528,
0.6846571564674377,
0.16785283386707306,
0.24623212218284607,
-0.10134617984294891,
0.2485276162624359,
0.30852001905441284,
-0.19998799264431,
-0.3489221930503845,
-0.2801722288131714,
0.007533099036663771,
-0.1228284016251564,
-0.06195948272943497,
0.1834249496459961,
-0.1637810319662094,
0.7362231612205505,
0.11065632104873657,
0.35913851857185364,
0.36131224036216736,
-0.5149568319320679,
-0.11774304509162903,
0.306074321269989,
0.8739191293716431,
0.6214970350265503,
-0.3912622928619385,
0.04535321146249771,
0.06848768889904022,
-1.100033164024353,
0.3959941267967224,
-0.05361509695649147,
-0.6069645285606384,
0.2617417573928833,
0.32820791006088257,
1.2053978443145752,
0.3480150103569031,
-0.45480313897132874,
0.7256566286087036,
0.086042620241642,
-0.3234996795654297,
-0.7211319208145142,
-0.20727384090423584,
-0.1513836681842804,
0.10531671345233917,
0.4098747968673706,
-0.005853889510035515,
0.15010109543800354,
-0.09872793406248093,
0.37174397706985474,
0.09913299977779388,
-0.8318519592285156,
-0.2942344546318054,
0.9844179749488831,
0.4924059808254242,
-0.6282877326011658,
0.31464317440986633,
0.11807682365179062,
-0.07204961776733398,
0.008058902807533741,
0.2902425229549408,
1.4393730163574219,
-0.6631458401679993,
0.33883166313171387,
0.32476165890693665,
0.46987688541412354,
0.07455794513225555,
0.2453240305185318,
-0.23644228279590607,
-0.10176945477724075,
-0.7244265079498291,
-0.6960970163345337,
-0.19300778210163116,
0.1556328535079956,
-0.6873077750205994,
0.23663215339183807,
-0.22841709852218628,
-0.30406653881073,
0.017893370240926743,
-0.34616586565971375,
-0.7823755741119385,
-0.07249718904495239,
0.3350081145763397,
0.8054385781288147,
-0.7643584609031677,
0.8861914277076721,
0.44140565395355225,
-0.3441082239151001,
-0.4641432464122772,
-0.05883566662669182,
0.223965123295784,
-0.7660141587257385,
0.6638005375862122,
-0.38714155554771423,
-0.4369378387928009,
0.3741006553173065,
-0.6436017751693726,
-1.0799980163574219,
1.1299333572387695,
0.3159852921962738,
-0.759286642074585,
0.08812212198972702,
0.2876017093658447,
0.32968875765800476,
-0.14766953885555267,
0.10209891200065613,
0.5944446325302124,
0.39205068349838257,
0.32581478357315063,
-1.1418529748916626,
-0.43068641424179077,
0.055912092328071594,
0.0008795179310254753,
0.5472182035446167,
-0.8139928579330444,
0.6180433630943298,
0.12929849326610565,
-0.46595117449760437,
-0.38780277967453003,
1.010587453842163,
-0.23954874277114868,
0.5050113797187805,
0.3239734172821045,
0.17779624462127686,
0.37042054533958435,
-0.1772008240222931,
0.951524019241333,
0.07852432876825333,
0.2686290144920349,
1.6098108291625977,
-0.4316079914569855,
1.2291643619537354,
0.8788420557975769,
-0.5560696125030518,
-0.11742992699146271,
0.4287198483943939,
0.4228319227695465,
0.7596733570098877,
-0.19437824189662933,
-0.32657963037490845,
-0.2450941801071167,
-0.29530519247055054,
-0.49271339178085327,
0.4185756742954254,
0.2819799780845642,
0.054775651544332504,
-0.12664712965488434,
0.27053895592689514,
0.21759538352489471,
-0.05498437210917473,
-0.25300332903862,
1.0995638370513916,
0.2163015902042389,
-0.6284581422805786,
0.5961515307426453,
-0.6877827644348145,
0.5456281900405884,
-1.0095313787460327,
0.027590613812208176,
-0.6130130887031555,
0.08403069525957108,
-0.22669018805027008,
-0.904123067855835,
0.500424325466156,
0.1518760621547699,
0.13516153395175934,
-0.3296527862548828,
0.5364450216293335,
-0.6008548140525818,
-0.18866075575351715,
0.23503094911575317,
0.38727933168411255,
0.455436646938324,
-0.1469765603542328,
-0.5275382399559021,
0.42711639404296875,
0.13011233508586884,
-0.30593550205230713,
0.2112971395254135,
0.03132801130414009,
-0.040217723697423935,
0.6757303476333618,
0.5734897255897522,
0.6040293574333191,
0.23124055564403534,
-0.1725178062915802,
0.5279587507247925,
-0.313763827085495,
-0.6985602378845215,
-0.6418920159339905,
0.3083772659301758,
0.0729377418756485,
-0.23572024703025818,
0.6369105577468872,
0.6310880780220032,
0.8912815451622009,
0.22343960404396057,
0.9594243764877319,
0.05208856239914894,
0.5439433455467224,
-0.17725704610347748,
0.7030291557312012,
-0.6602960824966431,
-0.22555556893348694,
-0.13382935523986816,
-1.0453640222549438,
0.017771616578102112,
0.47132328152656555,
-0.17953598499298096,
-0.675723135471344,
1.0526105165481567,
0.3759606182575226,
-0.23235560953617096,
0.19172808527946472,
0.5452736020088196,
-0.02582952007651329,
0.3381776809692383,
0.47502845525741577,
0.6215507388114929,
-0.5434194207191467,
0.8609791994094849,
-0.04453651234507561,
-0.0676192194223404,
-0.31681910157203674,
-0.6955285668373108,
-0.4657706916332245,
-0.8022303581237793,
-0.45885494351387024,
-0.1565820723772049,
0.45318514108657837,
0.9956570267677307,
0.7098206281661987,
-0.9647520184516907,
-0.4523262679576874,
0.3729138970375061,
-0.19933636486530304,
-0.6639007329940796,
-0.11879139393568039,
0.39788034558296204,
-0.3567080795764923,
-0.536474883556366,
0.5477169752120972,
0.6946608424186707,
-0.0474022701382637,
-0.3312346637248993,
-0.2503417432308197,
-0.5208033323287964,
0.25307855010032654,
0.7369975447654724,
0.4943844676017761,
-0.6267505884170532,
-0.23018330335617065,
-0.2000451236963272,
-0.04962515830993652,
0.3100948631763458,
0.9454742670059204,
-0.4568510055541992,
0.5059033632278442,
0.7015824317932129,
0.8289382457733154,
1.1043403148651123,
-0.1608210951089859,
0.2772441506385803,
-0.9624006152153015,
0.375982403755188,
0.5902131795883179,
-0.15200740098953247,
0.25887420773506165,
-0.28570377826690674,
0.602709949016571,
0.19543632864952087,
-0.7442744970321655,
-1.000580906867981,
0.2102995216846466,
-1.1730908155441284,
0.20252148807048798,
1.0910769701004028,
-0.1231917217373848,
-0.08998831361532211,
-0.21503596007823944,
-0.46445032954216003,
0.19526182115077972,
-0.7009939551353455,
0.20417970418930054,
0.6414424777030945,
0.015191862359642982,
-0.38470393419265747,
-1.2150484323501587,
0.7273426651954651,
0.3580808639526367,
-0.6216303110122681,
0.13037972152233124,
0.35990965366363525,
-0.11729097366333008,
-0.09027427434921265,
1.0384938716888428,
0.11194176971912384,
0.19690607488155365,
-0.08751589804887772,
-0.2864382863044739,
-0.06616415083408356,
-0.44540029764175415,
0.12045450508594513,
-0.07594893127679825,
-0.1255730539560318,
-0.165022075176239
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10251v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10251v1
|
The Impact of Quantization on Retrieval-Augmented Generation: An Analysis of Small LLMs
| 2024-06-10T08:23:52 | 2024-06-10T08:23:52 |
Mert Yazan, Suzan Verberne, Frederik Situmeang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Post-training quantization reduces the computational demand of Large Language
Models (LLMs) but can weaken some of their capabilities. Since LLM abilities
emerge with scale, smaller LLMs are more sensitive to quantization. In this
paper, we explore how quantization affects smaller LLMs' ability to perform
retrieval-augmented generation (RAG), specifically in longer contexts. We chose
personalization for evaluation because it is a challenging domain to perform
using RAG as it requires long-context reasoning over multiple documents. We
compare the original FP16 and the quantized INT4 performance of multiple 7B and
8B LLMs on two tasks while progressively increasing the number of retrieved
documents to test how quantized models fare against longer contexts. To better
understand the effect of retrieval, we evaluate three retrieval models in our
experiments. Our findings reveal that if a 7B LLM performs the task well,
quantization does not impair its performance and long-context reasoning
capabilities. We conclude that it is possible to utilize RAG with quantized
smaller LLMs.
|
[
-0.43076062202453613,
-0.5588772296905518,
0.6808119416236877,
0.09258511662483215,
-0.2843286097049713,
0.1423075944185257,
-0.2759110629558563,
-0.4877595901489258,
0.021003106608986855,
0.4969753324985504,
-0.02161593548953533,
-0.03716783970594406,
-0.6075037121772766,
0.4159340560436249,
-0.23139888048171997,
1.0564661026000977,
0.18605706095695496,
-0.10926345735788345,
-0.4277653396129608,
-0.15871816873550415,
-0.44426459074020386,
-0.7623264789581299,
-0.7944555878639221,
-0.17678390443325043,
0.7136024236679077,
0.2777126133441925,
0.6622684597969055,
0.46481192111968994,
0.6424678564071655,
0.35153883695602417,
-0.44155576825141907,
-0.0837872251868248,
-0.5189067721366882,
0.19549407064914703,
-0.11342073231935501,
-0.7735031247138977,
-0.4855128526687622,
-0.002527030650526285,
1.0924562215805054,
0.5976083278656006,
-0.06495411694049835,
0.34863269329071045,
0.13552021980285645,
0.8938208222389221,
-0.8429951667785645,
-0.3654523193836212,
-0.6252555251121521,
-0.08786223083734512,
-0.3093383312225342,
-0.26808083057403564,
-0.4363015294075012,
-0.19385124742984772,
0.07455330342054367,
-0.4919593930244446,
0.3051588535308838,
0.22827284038066864,
0.6463829874992371,
0.3465052843093872,
-0.6178769469261169,
-0.3458884060382843,
-0.8425971269607544,
0.9329708814620972,
-0.5331642627716064,
0.25901928544044495,
0.45275604724884033,
0.22549360990524292,
0.06676369160413742,
-0.9155637621879578,
-0.3114995062351227,
-0.24300268292427063,
-0.2682802677154541,
-0.134864941239357,
-0.028677068650722504,
0.1199907511472702,
0.6345587372779846,
0.7066164612770081,
-0.43734210729599,
-0.04255357012152672,
-0.4834117889404297,
-0.016809364780783653,
0.3895224332809448,
0.20363985002040863,
-0.08176153153181076,
-0.4697781205177307,
-0.23066793382167816,
0.06695777177810669,
-0.8691045641899109,
0.034116119146347046,
0.3213335871696472,
0.16589674353599548,
0.26758235692977905,
0.5895882844924927,
-0.3258793354034424,
0.6733570098876953,
0.2522273063659668,
-0.1781127154827118,
-0.03389940410852432,
-0.5023360848426819,
-0.19842715561389923,
-0.1693974733352661,
0.5758768320083618,
-0.21430394053459167,
0.08426935225725174,
-0.01789635419845581,
-0.4176849126815796,
-0.39032450318336487,
0.2556585669517517,
-1.1455539464950562,
0.07636333256959915,
-0.17912669479846954,
-0.6063240766525269,
-0.21686603128910065,
-0.19267897307872772,
-0.2929553687572479,
-0.31819239258766174,
-0.24108517169952393,
0.6535122394561768,
-0.5477080941200256,
0.14558760821819305,
-0.08905817568302155,
-0.2973118722438812,
0.037571992725133896,
0.15480679273605347,
-0.9238176345825195,
0.3315885365009308,
0.7604116201400757,
0.7269330620765686,
0.024941449984908104,
0.012292196974158287,
-0.6557004451751709,
0.21191982924938202,
-0.3288761377334595,
0.5894548892974854,
-0.5580074787139893,
-0.6438670754432678,
-0.17275969684123993,
-0.1937556117773056,
0.19429226219654083,
-0.9050837755203247,
0.31642070412635803,
-0.8107901811599731,
0.11471963673830032,
-0.3405778408050537,
-0.45127612352371216,
0.23137027025222778,
0.02789277583360672,
-0.7635524868965149,
0.8181383609771729,
0.3316885232925415,
-0.731179416179657,
0.4555245339870453,
-0.19491298496723175,
-0.3279004991054535,
0.30343034863471985,
-0.27100110054016113,
-0.3990531861782074,
0.611954927444458,
-0.15991456806659698,
0.23987135291099548,
-0.39922434091567993,
0.021143434569239616,
-0.22629815340042114,
-0.6951766014099121,
0.322451651096344,
-0.3496744930744171,
0.3191041052341461,
0.14685295522212982,
-0.206386536359787,
-0.22892732918262482,
-0.6997061967849731,
0.17795440554618835,
0.013135732151567936,
-0.793526291847229,
-0.7041426301002502,
-0.02948213368654251,
-0.4527699947357178,
0.10185202956199646,
0.4340530335903168,
-0.37848538160324097,
0.220237135887146,
-0.6824127435684204,
0.2085532695055008,
0.6385784149169922,
0.30496159195899963,
0.9236396551132202,
-0.41355660557746887,
0.7365706562995911,
-0.12494925409555435,
-0.08302747458219528,
-0.010573542676866055,
-0.2258947193622589,
-0.793820321559906,
-0.2685976028442383,
0.707128643989563,
0.13101017475128174,
-1.11801278591156,
-0.0891837328672409,
-0.49249693751335144,
0.006571121048182249,
-0.43553489446640015,
0.15008343756198883,
0.7295884490013123,
0.0426873043179512,
0.0914573073387146,
-0.20876283943653107,
-0.5919681191444397,
-0.898125410079956,
-0.5428824424743652,
0.21321018040180206,
-0.34290948510169983,
0.3882943391799927,
0.5166548490524292,
-0.17243026196956635,
1.0625923871994019,
-0.46122440695762634,
-0.29234620928764343,
-0.0968492180109024,
0.16757646203041077,
0.06755004823207855,
0.3570224940776825,
0.341919481754303,
-0.8517248630523682,
-0.5394707918167114,
-0.1260751336812973,
-0.2652212679386139,
-0.043694403022527695,
-0.034225281327962875,
-0.10614120960235596,
0.3428592383861542,
0.3859454095363617,
-0.5697799921035767,
0.5631259083747864,
0.4117873013019562,
-0.20553606748580933,
0.44805383682250977,
-0.32064250111579895,
0.10579735785722733,
-0.9267240762710571,
-0.06491074711084366,
-0.04581303521990776,
-0.27944180369377136,
-0.33165520429611206,
0.10251747816801071,
0.1458519697189331,
-0.14555074274539948,
-0.4029728174209595,
0.8071228265762329,
-0.5624697208404541,
-0.5005898475646973,
-0.4624002277851105,
0.17948667705059052,
0.2701171338558197,
0.14523014426231384,
-0.07736429572105408,
1.092579960823059,
-0.12070409953594208,
-0.6564026474952698,
-0.18423020839691162,
0.045744143426418304,
-0.2845176160335541,
0.48606449365615845,
-0.5419862270355225,
0.16196595132350922,
-0.00735077727586031,
0.22741371393203735,
-0.5038502812385559,
-0.17549976706504822,
-0.32919472455978394,
-0.4931671917438507,
0.377755343914032,
-0.16998006403446198,
-0.7318819761276245,
-0.1294649839401245,
-0.5338630676269531,
0.6486514210700989,
0.6505763530731201,
-0.5129678249359131,
0.4414967894554138,
0.061504486948251724,
-0.002827064599841833,
-0.16501721739768982,
-0.4198242127895355,
-0.09145821630954742,
-0.5785685777664185,
-0.5810666084289551,
0.5224107503890991,
-0.14427970349788666,
-0.4640105366706848,
-0.20598293840885162,
-0.22724568843841553,
0.073479063808918,
0.14012248814105988,
0.18618901073932648,
-0.11160452663898468,
0.008785215206444263,
0.28670790791511536,
0.20186445116996765,
-0.06515257060527802,
-0.0043883053585886955,
-0.0424765981733799,
0.3807562291622162,
-0.251292884349823,
0.11893177777528763,
0.1240932047367096,
0.2345423847436905,
0.005738107021898031,
-0.42423173785209656,
0.9952584505081177,
0.6801167726516724,
-0.24734677374362946,
-0.22492527961730957,
-0.4041483700275421,
-0.2068493515253067,
-0.579170286655426,
0.02329866960644722,
-0.7186266779899597,
-1.3478963375091553,
0.28946176171302795,
-0.22049248218536377,
-0.4212511479854584,
0.4303087890148163,
0.619415819644928,
-0.33516231179237366,
1.0339607000350952,
0.5951449871063232,
0.3978293538093567,
0.6267452836036682,
-0.49472877383232117,
-0.01691361702978611,
-1.4156882762908936,
0.1067468672990799,
-0.3868832588195801,
-0.36533123254776,
-0.9179345369338989,
-0.5002797245979309,
0.5726133584976196,
0.4429079592227936,
-0.21873170137405396,
0.0457066148519516,
-0.5234289765357971,
0.46047136187553406,
0.6497407555580139,
0.20109017193317413,
0.2980155050754547,
-0.06555669009685516,
0.25600624084472656,
-0.13999348878860474,
-0.695024311542511,
-0.48166966438293457,
1.1077311038970947,
0.07792649418115616,
0.6576075553894043,
0.4599989950656891,
1.0318500995635986,
0.33741480112075806,
0.29017311334609985,
-0.8083932995796204,
0.5527321100234985,
-0.4313817024230957,
-0.577962338924408,
-0.3772449791431427,
-0.6835713386535645,
-1.3228894472122192,
0.39614444971084595,
-0.08118245005607605,
-0.4773160517215729,
0.2868368327617645,
0.003120984649285674,
-0.5741973519325256,
-0.2448410987854004,
-0.6013420820236206,
0.5435545444488525,
-0.014447379857301712,
-0.2856375575065613,
-0.30294719338417053,
-0.4843704402446747,
0.49648618698120117,
-0.47646450996398926,
0.31757259368896484,
0.062472179532051086,
-0.2810233533382416,
0.8611502051353455,
-0.5167924165725708,
0.6442720890045166,
-0.0032463213428854942,
0.051299799233675,
0.4590599238872528,
0.09945689141750336,
0.45192211866378784,
0.13270264863967896,
0.008333394303917885,
-0.2102198451757431,
0.2182466685771942,
-0.3840191960334778,
-0.6132246851921082,
0.86238032579422,
-0.5832616686820984,
-0.9173895716667175,
-0.39378657937049866,
-0.4911101758480072,
-0.223896324634552,
0.18048828840255737,
0.40662306547164917,
0.34807848930358887,
0.1548808515071869,
0.5978808999061584,
0.7932019829750061,
-0.257645845413208,
0.4420225918292999,
0.47024521231651306,
-0.23552806675434113,
-0.5528831481933594,
1.074611783027649,
0.396395206451416,
0.5555024147033691,
0.46527189016342163,
0.43747714161872864,
0.03133730962872505,
-0.4518166780471802,
-0.03404346480965614,
0.3413167893886566,
-0.6557350158691406,
-0.36152350902557373,
-0.42435336112976074,
0.012017089873552322,
-0.44874969124794006,
0.02960263192653656,
-0.13456742465496063,
-0.6402115821838379,
-0.5258122086524963,
0.14851069450378418,
0.21901418268680573,
0.48919498920440674,
-0.19459038972854614,
0.5901616215705872,
-0.8610135316848755,
0.536777138710022,
0.5243217945098877,
0.14929944276809692,
-0.07725823670625687,
-0.8098234534263611,
-0.7198755741119385,
-0.0787685364484787,
-0.2868482172489166,
-0.6309995651245117,
0.19248086214065552,
0.37972480058670044,
0.02613135613501072,
0.03426890820264816,
-0.07206577807664871,
0.6549127697944641,
-0.7082679867744446,
0.6228475570678711,
-0.1638178825378418,
-0.9294279217720032,
0.44594481587409973,
-0.2995225489139557,
0.5697431564331055,
0.4061099588871002,
0.21339505910873413,
-0.1903517246246338,
-0.1504644751548767,
-0.7574883699417114,
-0.78514164686203,
0.6153671741485596,
0.17202989757061005,
0.09429650008678436,
-0.2436455488204956,
0.7672966122627258,
-0.16873852908611298,
0.3657524585723877,
-0.5598627328872681,
0.02598152682185173,
0.3238429129123688,
0.15827244520187378,
0.06585486233234406,
-0.8351553678512573,
0.07774502038955688,
-0.1359928697347641,
0.4693484306335449,
-0.05143813043832779,
0.1454262137413025,
0.013336926698684692,
-0.07827465981245041,
0.007401330396533012,
0.2523290812969208,
0.49279648065567017,
0.48071974515914917,
-0.13477443158626556,
-0.014527318999171257,
0.18553316593170166,
-0.2508995532989502,
0.14168894290924072,
-0.2001051902770996,
-0.17211152613162994,
0.0706893801689148,
0.35432302951812744,
0.747710108757019,
0.43524760007858276,
-0.45986899733543396,
0.49137353897094727,
-0.03903781995177269,
0.05996661260724068,
-0.5379087924957275,
0.13920557498931885,
-0.03554004803299904,
0.367102712392807,
0.4009416103363037,
-0.2927919030189514,
0.3874175250530243,
-0.5229928493499756,
0.10281465947628021,
0.5935590863227844,
0.23424330353736877,
-0.20008252561092377,
0.6581036448478699,
-0.07387431710958481,
-0.5288427472114563,
0.388366162776947,
-0.43064358830451965,
-0.20454727113246918,
0.7059025764465332,
0.4426506459712982,
0.5925306677818298,
-0.1967841237783432,
-0.09402164816856384,
0.17553497850894928,
0.1705334186553955,
-0.0028760049026459455,
0.11933384090662003,
-0.28746867179870605,
-0.427275151014328,
-0.7537657618522644,
-0.9078694581985474,
-0.27269187569618225,
-0.1794877052307129,
-0.8503906726837158,
-0.04112205654382706,
-0.33444923162460327,
-0.6136065125465393,
-0.18729758262634277,
0.27727118134498596,
-0.6470325589179993,
0.45652809739112854,
0.09544287621974945,
0.4945541322231293,
-0.24166958034038544,
0.8838858604431152,
0.5457809567451477,
-0.4032612144947052,
-0.7729374766349792,
-0.05714816972613335,
-0.3743216395378113,
-0.4813010096549988,
1.040902018547058,
-0.09717933088541031,
0.05654105171561241,
0.30743375420570374,
-0.27532413601875305,
-1.1392347812652588,
1.328384518623352,
0.17084288597106934,
-0.44720736145973206,
-0.23947037756443024,
0.23005801439285278,
0.8839284777641296,
-0.06554017961025238,
0.07713708281517029,
0.765765368938446,
0.14773792028427124,
-0.027828432619571686,
-0.9077752828598022,
-0.07513508945703506,
0.26832470297813416,
0.6206202507019043,
0.573547899723053,
-0.7815937399864197,
0.8913339376449585,
-0.142744779586792,
-0.3087989389896393,
0.3743918240070343,
0.6851680278778076,
0.608552873134613,
0.23580630123615265,
0.2214243859052658,
0.5442302227020264,
0.3402882218360901,
0.07692485302686691,
1.4090931415557861,
-0.2547573447227478,
0.4221627414226532,
1.1310392618179321,
-0.08089958876371384,
0.9480735659599304,
0.6388404369354248,
-0.33044856786727905,
0.30636972188949585,
0.5082171559333801,
0.3977099359035492,
0.6148573160171509,
0.4343394637107849,
-0.5053390264511108,
0.06993933022022247,
-0.029493622481822968,
-0.239925354719162,
0.21174870431423187,
0.422721266746521,
-0.32407769560813904,
0.11982707679271698,
0.4357529878616333,
-0.10778237134218216,
0.03124806471168995,
-0.46634411811828613,
0.858781635761261,
0.4222939908504486,
-0.4129987955093384,
0.745486855506897,
0.18805982172489166,
0.7195743918418884,
-0.27096447348594666,
0.038387056440114975,
-0.4712396264076233,
0.06321974843740463,
-0.2723958492279053,
-0.4018053710460663,
0.41647979617118835,
-0.01960170269012451,
-0.5055477023124695,
-0.34747979044914246,
0.8433006405830383,
-0.24576708674430847,
-0.435497522354126,
0.05869285762310028,
0.5672131776809692,
0.098504938185215,
-0.340381920337677,
-0.3057888448238373,
0.24186129868030548,
-0.002602688269689679,
-0.6659611463546753,
1.0017377138137817,
0.8406673073768616,
-0.2826468050479889,
0.6288797855377197,
0.5353953242301941,
0.10227286070585251,
0.26642799377441406,
-0.029152706265449524,
0.7807621955871582,
-0.6951957941055298,
-0.06663482636213303,
-0.827043354511261,
0.26652929186820984,
0.19497917592525482,
0.03355159983038902,
0.8588467836380005,
0.6893874406814575,
0.8623806834220886,
-0.07133154571056366,
0.4297615885734558,
-0.058998268097639084,
0.6504078507423401,
-0.5099011659622192,
0.5070930123329163,
-0.6963188648223877,
0.5151950716972351,
0.1084405928850174,
-1.0310046672821045,
0.03001781739294529,
0.36542901396751404,
-0.6494203209877014,
0.30257225036621094,
0.6548064351081848,
0.339670330286026,
0.3463815450668335,
-0.5670132040977478,
0.6226769685745239,
0.023204268887639046,
0.287844717502594,
0.363997220993042,
0.9445628523826599,
-0.3577095866203308,
0.6509864926338196,
-0.48442307114601135,
-0.06366529315710068,
-0.07762251794338226,
-0.5199804306030273,
-0.7347692847251892,
-0.5187345743179321,
-0.1499471813440323,
-0.254148006439209,
-0.07228150963783264,
0.3143101930618286,
0.357303261756897,
-0.1322047859430313,
-0.140179842710495,
0.026964368298649788,
0.12235718220472336,
0.4133260250091553,
-0.3454991281032562,
0.2820204496383667,
-0.4676855802536011,
-0.8347974419593811,
0.28674671053886414,
0.21482133865356445,
-0.02453172393143177,
-0.23634982109069824,
-0.07206272333860397,
0.017367348074913025,
0.16042593121528625,
1.013706922531128,
0.12930510938167572,
-0.6216670870780945,
-0.35598430037498474,
-0.08214011788368225,
-0.27838608622550964,
0.05098198726773262,
0.9023603796958923,
-1.2135727405548096,
0.2492753267288208,
0.4166218638420105,
0.49875563383102417,
0.7456154823303223,
0.3714844882488251,
0.2989743649959564,
-1.0602092742919922,
0.2139279991388321,
0.4462153911590576,
0.23333683609962463,
0.17928896844387054,
-0.4466939866542816,
0.6112708449363708,
0.11981146782636642,
-0.8978488445281982,
-0.8983780145645142,
0.2388489693403244,
-0.4551914632320404,
-0.357890248298645,
1.2958042621612549,
0.02048492804169655,
-0.03206544369459152,
0.3874894082546234,
-0.16727520525455475,
0.08805707842111588,
-0.13315297663211823,
0.5717827081680298,
0.6482076644897461,
-0.27533334493637085,
-0.3004869222640991,
-0.591683566570282,
0.6846912503242493,
0.525260865688324,
-0.6262096166610718,
-0.42729541659355164,
0.5515313148498535,
0.17875230312347412,
0.07727017253637314,
0.879046618938446,
0.10639750957489014,
0.20266808569431305,
-0.12632028758525848,
-0.11526156216859818,
0.2530103325843811,
-0.08192892372608185,
-0.5582393407821655,
0.10284390300512314,
0.46531569957733154,
0.05938974395394325
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.06073v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.06073v1
|
Efficient k-Nearest-Neighbor Machine Translation with Dynamic Retrieval
| 2024-06-10T07:36:55 | 2024-06-10T07:36:55 |
Yan Gao, Zhiwei Cao, Zhongjian Miao, Baosong Yang, Shiyu Liu, Min Zhang, Jinsong Su
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
To achieve non-parametric NMT domain adaptation, $k$-Nearest-Neighbor Machine
Translation ($k$NN-MT) constructs an external datastore to store
domain-specific translation knowledge, which derives a $k$NN distribution to
interpolate the prediction distribution of the NMT model via a linear
interpolation coefficient $\lambda$. Despite its success, $k$NN retrieval at
each timestep leads to substantial time overhead. To address this issue,
dominant studies resort to $k$NN-MT with adaptive retrieval ($k$NN-MT-AR),
which dynamically estimates $\lambda$ and skips $k$NN retrieval if $\lambda$ is
less than a fixed threshold. Unfortunately, $k$NN-MT-AR does not yield
satisfactory results. In this paper, we first conduct a preliminary study to
reveal two key limitations of $k$NN-MT-AR: 1) the optimization gap leads to
inaccurate estimation of $\lambda$ for determining $k$NN retrieval skipping,
and 2) using a fixed threshold fails to accommodate the dynamic demands for
$k$NN retrieval at different timesteps. To mitigate these limitations, we then
propose $k$NN-MT with dynamic retrieval ($k$NN-MT-DR) that significantly
extends vanilla $k$NN-MT in two aspects. Firstly, we equip $k$NN-MT with a
MLP-based classifier for determining whether to skip $k$NN retrieval at each
timestep. Particularly, we explore several carefully-designed scalar features
to fully exert the potential of the classifier. Secondly, we propose a
timestep-aware threshold adjustment method to dynamically generate the
threshold, which further improves the efficiency of our model. Experimental
results on the widely-used datasets demonstrate the effectiveness and
generality of our model.\footnote{Our code is available at
\url{https://github.com/DeepLearnXMU/knn-mt-dr}.
|
[
-0.45101046562194824,
-0.613223671913147,
0.606367826461792,
0.06331703811883926,
-0.3603111207485199,
0.40810683369636536,
-0.286501944065094,
-0.5187337398529053,
-0.040592044591903687,
0.1501428335905075,
-0.41631069779396057,
-0.23259389400482178,
-0.7458860278129578,
0.2673329710960388,
-0.26845642924308777,
0.6246865391731262,
-0.21538583934307098,
-0.1490643322467804,
0.12774859368801117,
-0.2897273898124695,
-0.48785459995269775,
-0.3143867254257202,
-0.2882576584815979,
-0.21869106590747833,
0.5895015001296997,
0.33581072092056274,
0.7789204716682434,
0.9119731783866882,
0.750149130821228,
0.2833702266216278,
-0.32994383573532104,
0.21857796609401703,
-0.3218907117843628,
0.2307712435722351,
0.20988480746746063,
-0.5100107789039612,
-0.5312380790710449,
-0.251287579536438,
1.0060813426971436,
0.5967259407043457,
-0.05226798355579376,
0.0014870250597596169,
-0.00409285631030798,
0.990185022354126,
-0.5407609343528748,
0.0706387311220169,
-0.781091034412384,
0.45025503635406494,
-0.23972773551940918,
-0.4234403967857361,
-0.36149469017982483,
-0.3177237808704376,
0.4114823043346405,
-0.5933566093444824,
-0.04109058156609535,
-0.12022167444229126,
0.7698173522949219,
0.472244530916214,
-0.7656384110450745,
-0.26439565420150757,
-0.7804993987083435,
0.855634868144989,
-0.684342086315155,
0.8219572305679321,
0.48708587884902954,
0.7803418636322021,
-0.3733255863189697,
-0.661529541015625,
-0.4328906834125519,
-0.711434543132782,
0.2705771327018738,
0.09143945574760437,
0.0567275732755661,
-0.3667218089103699,
0.2634848356246948,
0.44977912306785583,
-0.41942864656448364,
0.024346204474568367,
-0.059465259313583374,
-0.03680284693837166,
0.15234330296516418,
0.3857744038105011,
-0.05652168393135071,
-0.14401371777057648,
-0.3661327064037323,
-0.05409890040755272,
-0.4305705726146698,
-0.08523694425821304,
0.30524832010269165,
0.3144141733646393,
-0.06015348434448242,
0.5405459403991699,
-0.34750840067863464,
0.6491946578025818,
0.20375488698482513,
-0.09312629699707031,
0.4625236690044403,
-0.4591027498245239,
0.10547773540019989,
-0.09314890205860138,
0.5610383749008179,
0.41336584091186523,
0.057978276163339615,
-0.3364206850528717,
-0.36468926072120667,
-0.33145052194595337,
0.40572255849838257,
-0.9461937546730042,
-0.15154746174812317,
0.06487578898668289,
-0.4944790005683899,
-0.4157763123512268,
-0.20161372423171997,
-0.9055743217468262,
-0.10202302783727646,
-0.3419646620750427,
0.5971356630325317,
-0.5484822392463684,
-0.23010307550430298,
-0.20476344227790833,
0.15354111790657043,
-0.087636798620224,
0.18816883862018585,
-0.47569677233695984,
0.24522042274475098,
0.32553568482398987,
1.2993664741516113,
-0.4043162167072296,
-0.1740236133337021,
-0.5436113476753235,
-0.17988522350788116,
-0.3525812327861786,
0.31607237458229065,
-0.6521823406219482,
-0.3197193443775177,
-0.27988794445991516,
-0.0031447545625269413,
-0.12945467233657837,
-0.7818958163261414,
0.17420554161071777,
-0.9942420721054077,
0.10581514984369278,
-0.3442075550556183,
-0.43577608466148376,
-0.23181971907615662,
0.30053946375846863,
-0.6190252304077148,
1.094156265258789,
0.24317125976085663,
-0.5739896297454834,
0.37670034170150757,
-0.8466001749038696,
-0.19209370017051697,
-0.20106148719787598,
0.3409728407859802,
-0.5720446109771729,
0.19458891451358795,
0.20831680297851562,
0.31340622901916504,
-0.13345035910606384,
0.3386169373989105,
-0.36345672607421875,
-0.4344819188117981,
0.34676849842071533,
-0.6213461756706238,
0.4686026871204376,
0.4619659185409546,
-0.42345091700553894,
-0.16238266229629517,
-0.8394366502761841,
0.027532486245036125,
0.21403643488883972,
-0.654767632484436,
-0.2703678011894226,
-0.023782717064023018,
-0.23525379598140717,
0.38237643241882324,
0.1557181030511856,
-0.24668847024440765,
0.3374757468700409,
-0.37065696716308594,
0.4530887305736542,
0.7819752097129822,
0.05312848091125488,
0.6394093036651611,
-0.3544415831565857,
0.5353645086288452,
0.040848854929208755,
0.08228780329227448,
0.08303104341030121,
-0.36009660363197327,
-0.5185446739196777,
0.07969865202903748,
0.7449073195457458,
0.5598584413528442,
-1.2757863998413086,
0.2137577384710312,
-0.5009682178497314,
-0.502646803855896,
-0.42082348465919495,
-0.1308605819940567,
0.26515135169029236,
0.7284324765205383,
0.5584114789962769,
-0.1556643396615982,
-0.22730472683906555,
-0.619782567024231,
-0.1320066750049591,
0.24366174638271332,
0.010313556529581547,
0.44140511751174927,
0.5782771706581116,
-0.13345633447170258,
0.5358166694641113,
-0.282235324382782,
-0.15931959450244904,
0.18054190278053284,
0.01462582964450121,
0.4790042042732239,
0.4118760824203491,
0.5886881351470947,
-0.9854176640510559,
-1.006897211074829,
0.1537030190229416,
-0.520668625831604,
-0.24499017000198364,
-0.12363956868648529,
-0.13929522037506104,
0.12430461496114731,
0.226486474275589,
-0.36070746183395386,
0.3467170298099518,
0.46957483887672424,
0.04960880056023598,
0.5912641286849976,
-0.3847525119781494,
0.37736862897872925,
-1.1525815725326538,
0.20881734788417816,
-0.42154425382614136,
-0.3514825701713562,
-0.6485771536827087,
0.2126747965812683,
0.31853705644607544,
0.011944849975407124,
-0.4612148702144623,
0.4926672875881195,
-0.5906570553779602,
-0.047639988362789154,
-0.4936493933200836,
0.20218507945537567,
-0.35926324129104614,
0.4657227694988251,
-0.08622093498706818,
0.9055459499359131,
0.08639446645975113,
-1.0473884344100952,
0.24178166687488556,
0.09290061891078949,
-0.32134810090065,
0.47857236862182617,
-0.28854960203170776,
0.3590356707572937,
0.16344498097896576,
0.16281303763389587,
-0.47758135199546814,
-0.045381031930446625,
0.43957599997520447,
-0.5913243889808655,
0.5069619417190552,
-0.4769205152988434,
-0.6501877903938293,
-0.2762879729270935,
-0.25118517875671387,
0.555016815662384,
0.4596012234687805,
-0.616637647151947,
0.3874205946922302,
0.18736116588115692,
-0.009938432835042477,
-0.7029474973678589,
-0.5878964066505432,
0.22757519781589508,
-0.17172154784202576,
-0.42495229840278625,
0.48812103271484375,
-0.13558809459209442,
0.21577873826026917,
0.1683988720178604,
-0.39373260736465454,
-0.04940132051706314,
0.08878359198570251,
-0.09160533547401428,
0.08279860764741898,
-0.35095736384391785,
-0.03633280098438263,
0.1592729538679123,
-0.3684391975402832,
-0.21330572664737701,
-0.5247800350189209,
0.581970751285553,
-0.09833353757858276,
-0.2953263223171234,
-0.3656071722507477,
0.18937066197395325,
0.6122081875801086,
-0.0360378660261631,
0.7633861899375916,
0.7318136096000671,
-0.3401578962802887,
0.0494772307574749,
-0.3590315580368042,
-0.045722346752882004,
-0.5252947807312012,
0.5625119209289551,
-0.6529818177223206,
-0.7596027255058289,
0.5993842482566833,
-0.21366925537586212,
-0.09660282731056213,
0.44496890902519226,
0.6108485460281372,
-0.016213182359933853,
0.8840464949607849,
0.36185410618782043,
0.275005578994751,
0.6906548142433167,
-0.31412065029144287,
0.07531097531318665,
-1.1620322465896606,
-0.30770644545555115,
-0.34919631481170654,
-0.788284957408905,
-0.8049647212028503,
-0.603179931640625,
0.5244748592376709,
0.024132970720529556,
-0.04126914218068123,
0.4876047968864441,
-0.4775523245334625,
0.3627972900867462,
0.6850374341011047,
0.13652896881103516,
0.1886332929134369,
0.08015080541372299,
-0.6429595351219177,
-0.439130961894989,
-0.7171677947044373,
-0.26330211758613586,
1.1689947843551636,
0.24431350827217102,
0.276963472366333,
0.39001545310020447,
0.3324703276157379,
0.3763561546802521,
0.032548196613788605,
-0.6411012411117554,
0.6388387680053711,
-0.24408595263957977,
-0.4821304976940155,
-0.09301134943962097,
-1.0183215141296387,
-1.0501658916473389,
0.26788580417633057,
-0.17781446874141693,
-0.4214644134044647,
0.25398099422454834,
0.19497868418693542,
-0.1209460124373436,
0.6049760580062866,
-0.6361055970191956,
0.6613585948944092,
-0.21649876236915588,
-0.09117551147937775,
-0.10581440478563309,
-0.9472842216491699,
0.20892925560474396,
-0.6480133533477783,
-0.12727834284305573,
-0.20838426053524017,
-0.2936389446258545,
0.34786778688430786,
-0.5301157236099243,
0.336685448884964,
-0.38783398270606995,
0.304518461227417,
0.10684582591056824,
0.4915388822555542,
0.7890860438346863,
-0.3042430281639099,
-0.3134792149066925,
0.180395245552063,
-0.04547525569796562,
-0.3609558939933777,
-0.7739115357398987,
0.6575106978416443,
-0.5202195048332214,
-0.31496235728263855,
-0.5111788511276245,
-0.6719090938568115,
-0.20533433556556702,
0.5164713263511658,
0.08987312763929367,
0.30219778418540955,
0.22836574912071228,
0.5496573448181152,
0.49765321612358093,
-0.3797398507595062,
0.34192463755607605,
0.6597999930381775,
-0.20887386798858643,
-0.5919151306152344,
1.221652626991272,
0.4992622137069702,
0.6169244647026062,
0.8531749844551086,
0.4764433205127716,
-0.4767061173915863,
-0.8624686598777771,
-0.6333450675010681,
0.03099718503654003,
-0.5602081418037415,
-0.24177755415439606,
-0.750948429107666,
-0.14448219537734985,
-0.12376372516155243,
0.06461547315120697,
-0.3772244155406952,
-0.608413815498352,
-0.05957043543457985,
0.23319321870803833,
0.4678373634815216,
0.394562691450119,
-0.18555377423763275,
0.39784353971481323,
-0.8953998684883118,
0.40944430232048035,
-0.10379116982221603,
0.5313072800636292,
0.3209189772605896,
-0.9517927765846252,
-0.276518851518631,
0.10819438099861145,
-0.2796630859375,
-0.8426584601402283,
0.3480103611946106,
0.17372362315654755,
0.44757407903671265,
0.11601116508245468,
0.3147411644458771,
0.792325496673584,
-0.9098011255264282,
0.4463769793510437,
-0.11467856913805008,
-0.6668038368225098,
0.33857592940330505,
-0.31292200088500977,
0.5744956135749817,
0.5189591646194458,
0.5422918796539307,
-0.6645970940589905,
-0.37866461277008057,
-0.3314632475376129,
-0.9241841435432434,
0.6721062660217285,
0.448391318321228,
0.05017109960317612,
0.10357064008712769,
0.5295008420944214,
0.13806819915771484,
0.2288791984319687,
-0.4075355529785156,
-0.2664867639541626,
-0.1392766833305359,
-0.097142294049263,
0.1615101397037506,
-0.27700039744377136,
0.48180681467056274,
-0.14601323008537292,
0.773065447807312,
0.048387493938207626,
0.5566187500953674,
0.14508584141731262,
-0.24007628858089447,
-0.041293904185295105,
-0.011977944523096085,
0.7784042358398438,
0.45300593972206116,
-0.5123112201690674,
0.22996185719966888,
0.47092339396476746,
-0.7873876690864563,
0.2949732542037964,
0.08213375508785248,
-0.3956829607486725,
0.20733197033405304,
0.08974160999059677,
0.6251165866851807,
0.08981649577617645,
-0.37577107548713684,
0.2745540738105774,
0.04192839190363884,
-0.16146574914455414,
-0.19117790460586548,
-0.16843663156032562,
-0.013736157678067684,
0.3519453704357147,
0.22381728887557983,
0.30012714862823486,
-0.019415605813264847,
-0.19104890525341034,
0.47151604294776917,
0.15853971242904663,
-0.2841004729270935,
-0.31020575761795044,
0.9091420769691467,
-0.13208359479904175,
-0.5745141506195068,
0.7728460431098938,
-0.4073823094367981,
-0.5547067523002625,
0.3705621659755707,
0.47951245307922363,
0.8528673052787781,
-0.3388427793979645,
-0.09502140432596207,
0.32490110397338867,
0.33790212869644165,
-0.0002893648634199053,
0.09491679072380066,
-0.100530706346035,
-0.29117825627326965,
-0.44756102561950684,
-0.5619792342185974,
-0.2751677632331848,
0.08864292502403259,
-0.43914052844047546,
0.18804503977298737,
-0.3259761929512024,
-0.4710777699947357,
-0.19272132217884064,
0.1852787882089615,
-0.4362134635448456,
-0.08761407434940338,
-0.3867056369781494,
0.943520724773407,
-0.15546756982803345,
0.8908155560493469,
0.359298437833786,
-0.259667307138443,
-0.4026108384132385,
0.16009211540222168,
0.0038997039664536715,
-0.8470807075500488,
0.6072847843170166,
-0.03271624445915222,
-0.08216933161020279,
-0.15003548562526703,
0.021974826231598854,
-0.9366287589073181,
1.1878679990768433,
0.2660348117351532,
-0.6341756582260132,
-0.07572267204523087,
0.2828684449195862,
0.4734889268875122,
-0.10818497836589813,
-0.1459932178258896,
0.08411019295454025,
0.5287411212921143,
0.1482183188199997,
-0.9642860293388367,
0.07717271149158478,
-0.3043269217014313,
0.13862460851669312,
0.6378873586654663,
-0.5053633451461792,
0.5372527837753296,
-0.09192360192537308,
-0.013187129981815815,
0.27841925621032715,
0.4160369038581848,
-0.0653546154499054,
0.4562309682369232,
0.5893040299415588,
0.37026911973953247,
0.6372199058532715,
-0.06616482883691788,
1.099557876586914,
-0.22492583096027374,
0.2305590659379959,
1.268314003944397,
0.0354546383023262,
0.9413150548934937,
0.4315371513366699,
-0.30094608664512634,
-0.0012926679337397218,
0.6979193687438965,
-0.19938640296459198,
0.8099386096000671,
0.17851103842258453,
-0.3223453462123871,
-0.04309586063027382,
0.059601791203022,
-0.5798280835151672,
0.1866852045059204,
0.10185181349515915,
-0.4293266534805298,
-0.07331998646259308,
-0.06917916983366013,
-0.11414604634046555,
-0.1799534410238266,
0.009924146346747875,
0.4180811941623688,
0.23488017916679382,
-0.34186598658561707,
0.7330329418182373,
0.14784300327301025,
0.4490613639354706,
-0.5050861835479736,
0.03197149187326431,
-0.15563248097896576,
0.18504467606544495,
0.12042079120874405,
-0.52033931016922,
0.48136746883392334,
-0.02784312516450882,
-0.17617931962013245,
-0.1653265655040741,
0.6519185304641724,
-0.40670034289360046,
-0.46759042143821716,
0.24923956394195557,
0.4877307713031769,
0.3374732732772827,
-0.16979043185710907,
-0.8033931851387024,
-0.07389990240335464,
-0.046038273721933365,
-0.2597571015357971,
0.6063209176063538,
0.791325032711029,
-0.007424423471093178,
0.8960378766059875,
0.8610012531280518,
0.11969845741987228,
0.4129634201526642,
-0.15723034739494324,
0.6787418723106384,
-0.6613468527793884,
-0.3352442681789398,
-0.8028795719146729,
0.23186901211738586,
0.13417433202266693,
-0.11209377646446228,
0.5561753511428833,
0.5925998091697693,
0.7344632744789124,
-0.02802153490483761,
0.16068550944328308,
0.060341522097587585,
0.5187520980834961,
-0.6166425943374634,
0.717984676361084,
-0.9289476871490479,
0.3226661682128906,
-0.27674129605293274,
-1.2054954767227173,
-0.3937733769416809,
0.4758259057998657,
-0.21967017650604248,
0.23942281305789948,
0.6818285584449768,
0.6471250057220459,
-0.3826253414154053,
-0.17062434554100037,
0.47643306851387024,
0.26376962661743164,
0.20247437059879303,
0.6434303522109985,
0.9115481972694397,
-0.4984517991542816,
0.8885092735290527,
-0.4602832496166229,
-0.011418839916586876,
-0.45503053069114685,
-1.1488040685653687,
-0.48340079188346863,
-0.5122769474983215,
-0.32252705097198486,
-0.5170199275016785,
0.04778753221035004,
0.9904299378395081,
0.5727731585502625,
-0.6514391899108887,
0.14448712766170502,
0.15714333951473236,
0.17542868852615356,
-0.3813554048538208,
-0.22268694639205933,
0.4340929090976715,
-0.2794247567653656,
-0.7695432901382446,
0.5304957628250122,
0.3018593490123749,
0.30083197355270386,
0.18680045008659363,
-0.3074661195278168,
-0.23783570528030396,
-0.2865583896636963,
0.551266074180603,
0.07615552842617035,
-0.46776697039604187,
-0.21164387464523315,
0.39152467250823975,
0.12973527610301971,
0.3060070276260376,
0.6388418674468994,
-0.5112627148628235,
0.6997540593147278,
0.35657399892807007,
1.1608974933624268,
0.6411115527153015,
-0.3770621716976166,
0.4713766276836395,
-0.6393976211547852,
-0.13543200492858887,
0.404949426651001,
0.03596378490328789,
0.13039332628250122,
-0.3264409005641937,
0.5269098281860352,
0.5633993744850159,
-0.7377015352249146,
-1.044025182723999,
0.15693949162960052,
-0.9567362070083618,
-0.12743069231510162,
0.860299825668335,
-0.030681360512971878,
-0.06865042448043823,
-0.20054557919502258,
0.06697377562522888,
0.3075442612171173,
-0.40069425106048584,
0.8761880993843079,
0.7638978362083435,
-0.07203944027423859,
0.008067409507930279,
-1.2629804611206055,
0.20933720469474792,
0.47815677523612976,
-0.19720301032066345,
-0.18358570337295532,
0.09512003511190414,
0.4329720735549927,
0.012785276398062706,
0.5703800916671753,
-0.3004421293735504,
0.2155597060918808,
-0.07429791986942291,
-0.40131068229675293,
-0.2952229976654053,
-0.27007806301116943,
-0.3131675720214844,
-0.02984771877527237,
-0.008965115994215012,
-0.46408262848854065
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.06056v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.06056v1
|
Synth-SBDH: A Synthetic Dataset of Social and Behavioral Determinants of Health for Clinical Text
| 2024-06-10T07:03:36 | 2024-06-10T07:03:36 |
Avijit Mitra, Emily Druhl, Raelene Goodwin, Hong Yu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Social and behavioral determinants of health (SBDH) play a crucial role in
health outcomes and are frequently documented in clinical text. Automatically
extracting SBDH information from clinical text relies on publicly available
good-quality datasets. However, existing SBDH datasets exhibit substantial
limitations in their availability and coverage. In this study, we introduce
Synth-SBDH, a novel synthetic dataset with detailed SBDH annotations,
encompassing status, temporal information, and rationale across 15 SBDH
categories. We showcase the utility of Synth-SBDH on three tasks using
real-world clinical datasets from two distinct hospital settings, highlighting
its versatility, generalizability, and distillation capabilities. Models
trained on Synth-SBDH consistently outperform counterparts with no Synth-SBDH
training, achieving up to 62.5% macro-F improvements. Additionally, Synth-SBDH
proves effective for rare SBDH categories and under-resource constraints. Human
evaluation demonstrates a Human-LLM alignment of 71.06% and uncovers areas for
future refinements.
|
[
-0.15628889203071594,
-0.7297552824020386,
0.8295674920082092,
0.1788686066865921,
-0.04203664883971214,
0.4563000500202179,
-0.05030827596783638,
-0.5750970840454102,
0.6167801022529602,
0.38143065571784973,
-0.8605089783668518,
-0.5026277303695679,
-0.37728357315063477,
0.4393499195575714,
-0.22167740762233734,
1.419662594795227,
0.12265325337648392,
0.3990994989871979,
-0.12121754884719849,
-0.012945112772285938,
-0.4014897048473358,
-0.4317798912525177,
-0.2596174478530884,
-0.27329275012016296,
0.6253983974456787,
0.0970749780535698,
0.5385754704475403,
0.6788082718849182,
0.5459551215171814,
0.18983551859855652,
0.017476772889494896,
0.3348920941352844,
-0.5642847418785095,
0.35488852858543396,
-0.3175300061702728,
0.012107091955840588,
-0.7976087927818298,
-0.09970153868198395,
0.513878583908081,
0.8066108226776123,
-0.12928259372711182,
0.5658779740333557,
-0.24991747736930847,
0.9666857123374939,
-0.4134480655193329,
0.20361647009849548,
-0.4094732701778412,
0.09100083261728287,
-0.24492990970611572,
0.07265022397041321,
-0.18183405697345734,
-0.48954513669013977,
0.4771933853626251,
-0.5849878787994385,
0.5918951630592346,
-0.18932552635669708,
0.2325233817100525,
0.3331535756587982,
-0.715441882610321,
-0.08225017786026001,
-0.7201160788536072,
0.31327491998672485,
-0.361147403717041,
0.5126991868019104,
0.21269124746322632,
0.5185250639915466,
-0.17910879850387573,
-0.7910308241844177,
-0.4128263592720032,
-0.11736375093460083,
-0.2784060537815094,
0.07842990756034851,
0.1819261610507965,
0.26242679357528687,
0.36609718203544617,
0.3963371813297272,
-0.6023547053337097,
-0.28270989656448364,
-0.7539451122283936,
-0.44379326701164246,
0.9510592222213745,
0.7367132306098938,
0.5087608695030212,
-0.2792350947856903,
-0.1754113882780075,
0.08639567345380783,
-0.7520327568054199,
-0.16998927295207977,
0.012278648093342781,
0.40802663564682007,
-0.19819746911525726,
0.6958580017089844,
-0.1130392998456955,
0.40037310123443604,
0.16728316247463226,
-0.26876673102378845,
0.46512356400489807,
-0.5442811250686646,
-0.010195674374699593,
0.5072681307792664,
0.5095542073249817,
0.38525909185409546,
-0.34513914585113525,
-0.10189928114414215,
-0.2529022991657257,
0.1878121793270111,
0.5352396965026855,
-0.839119017124176,
-0.5241550803184509,
0.4537310302257538,
-0.593556821346283,
-0.47309577465057373,
-0.09278897941112518,
-0.8655482530593872,
-0.5896347165107727,
-0.715755045413971,
0.24921004474163055,
-0.35024726390838623,
-0.2679416239261627,
-0.21763671934604645,
-0.3454706370830536,
-0.34383249282836914,
0.2224334329366684,
-0.9226016998291016,
0.487371563911438,
0.5506874322891235,
0.7665081024169922,
-0.4848366677761078,
0.09072036296129227,
-0.3336731493473053,
0.24651691317558289,
-0.4402531087398529,
0.4644342064857483,
-0.1511697620153427,
-0.6027025580406189,
-0.12415628135204315,
0.30866608023643494,
0.05706542357802391,
-0.6815268397331238,
0.16817906498908997,
0.15989775955677032,
-0.23339925706386566,
-0.31572550535202026,
-0.36632007360458374,
0.45884349942207336,
-0.06965728849172592,
-1.0668227672576904,
0.7178493738174438,
0.4730224907398224,
-0.5805659890174866,
0.41031262278556824,
-0.33764100074768066,
-0.8266465067863464,
0.16871149837970734,
-0.35776031017303467,
-0.4424467384815216,
0.4578852653503418,
0.06609123945236206,
0.11770284175872803,
-0.26215144991874695,
0.6091444492340088,
-0.32229194045066833,
-0.32668012380599976,
0.35407745838165283,
-0.24508199095726013,
0.849192202091217,
0.32221120595932007,
0.06536384671926498,
0.2696230113506317,
-1.1812084913253784,
-0.02487538941204548,
-0.04600817710161209,
-0.1092962697148323,
-0.2735310196876526,
-0.07887420058250427,
0.2989174425601959,
0.01182000245898962,
0.2876739501953125,
-0.6179890036582947,
-0.10212966054677963,
-0.18270307779312134,
0.4462708830833435,
0.7574223279953003,
0.3864394426345825,
0.12335257977247238,
-0.7785825729370117,
0.5824835300445557,
-0.2303432673215866,
0.3411150574684143,
0.24670739471912384,
-0.3782912492752075,
0.16561539471149445,
-1.0157965421676636,
0.17577612400054932,
0.3084997832775116,
-0.46099042892456055,
0.3115074932575226,
-0.1443735957145691,
-0.5212764739990234,
-0.9797018766403198,
-0.35353419184684753,
0.5665838122367859,
0.5867826342582703,
0.49874958395957947,
-0.06986211240291595,
-0.9399278163909912,
-0.9136531352996826,
-0.1104082390666008,
-0.05310453847050667,
-0.004118434619158506,
-0.0022314158268272877,
0.546412467956543,
-0.6023799777030945,
0.8547455668449402,
-0.6953210234642029,
-0.39597147703170776,
-0.3554369807243347,
-0.03258369117975235,
0.13464738428592682,
0.5007758736610413,
0.38284674286842346,
-0.4406997561454773,
-0.3920203447341919,
-0.13296517729759216,
-0.6038602590560913,
-0.521065890789032,
0.06846291571855545,
-0.15659074485301971,
-0.05714237317442894,
0.1405552327632904,
-0.5273458361625671,
0.5099524259567261,
0.45308512449264526,
-0.11115020513534546,
1.0996798276901245,
-0.3602779507637024,
0.04820583388209343,
-1.0411127805709839,
0.25370216369628906,
0.002445315709337592,
-0.08625028282403946,
-0.7534549832344055,
-0.058113668113946915,
0.038787681609392166,
-0.5664206147193909,
-0.2711446285247803,
0.651359498500824,
-0.1189609095454216,
0.13664384186267853,
0.24281305074691772,
-0.36852484941482544,
0.08256199210882187,
0.17903149127960205,
0.08570719510316849,
0.5434499382972717,
0.18684062361717224,
-0.23480434715747833,
0.351511687040329,
0.39308327436447144,
-0.31093212962150574,
0.796656608581543,
-0.8038115501403809,
-0.23672528564929962,
-0.2338949292898178,
0.5367371439933777,
-0.7677450180053711,
-0.7730994820594788,
-0.015163052827119827,
-0.09249572455883026,
0.14498941600322723,
0.01323374267667532,
-0.317232608795166,
-0.2557942867279053,
-0.414862722158432,
0.3424378037452698,
0.5469115972518921,
-0.14703750610351562,
0.13460125029087067,
0.8704409003257751,
-0.21310918033123016,
-0.03144146502017975,
-0.6601599454879761,
-0.23182080686092377,
-0.020469604060053825,
-0.19522400200366974,
0.8484023809432983,
-0.04841577634215355,
-0.3475922644138336,
-0.009594530798494816,
-0.5586183667182922,
-0.2751691937446594,
-0.2202765792608261,
0.40675806999206543,
0.4775961935520172,
0.054185230284929276,
0.24535419046878815,
0.21781060099601746,
-0.1994836926460266,
0.2646154761314392,
0.15657317638397217,
0.08706782013177872,
0.12693768739700317,
-0.2913438379764557,
-0.6179300546646118,
0.49265703558921814,
0.7556374669075012,
0.05445681884884834,
0.6432790160179138,
0.34026139974594116,
-0.6699624061584473,
-0.2530229091644287,
-0.3065066337585449,
-0.32848837971687317,
-0.39078760147094727,
0.4326745867729187,
-0.05534905940294266,
-0.5234350562095642,
0.49324509501457214,
0.14384888112545013,
-0.14233087003231049,
0.24734513461589813,
0.5063972473144531,
-0.23916690051555634,
1.1588863134384155,
0.03763772174715996,
0.3071649372577667,
0.2973490059375763,
-0.06343114376068115,
0.0980110689997673,
-0.9475979208946228,
-0.5176962614059448,
-0.28530752658843994,
-0.22588665783405304,
-1.00049889087677,
-0.23944103717803955,
0.9407110214233398,
-0.6830794811248779,
-0.4043452739715576,
0.24436472356319427,
-0.7266896963119507,
0.1473766416311264,
0.07111650705337524,
0.8994834423065186,
0.2503174841403961,
-0.2554214298725128,
-0.017715638503432274,
-0.36172565817832947,
-0.3378266394138336,
-0.09927092492580414,
1.2653355598449707,
0.1931084394454956,
0.7216947674751282,
0.1277628391981125,
0.9311664700508118,
0.5435564517974854,
0.27838823199272156,
-0.41751694679260254,
0.4973051846027374,
-0.23246894776821136,
-0.9953696131706238,
-0.22359810769557953,
-0.47813352942466736,
-0.6584787368774414,
0.056469276547431946,
-0.34871330857276917,
-0.4858400821685791,
0.16021159291267395,
0.23590503633022308,
-0.5423083305358887,
-0.12458831816911697,
-0.7609902620315552,
0.8318892121315002,
-0.34413519501686096,
-0.36812373995780945,
-0.16373157501220703,
-0.8336798548698425,
0.3248521387577057,
-0.5273605585098267,
0.19953566789627075,
-0.40694254636764526,
0.31783273816108704,
0.4317552447319031,
-0.8299251198768616,
0.8030232787132263,
0.07735510170459747,
0.04184005409479141,
0.07387448847293854,
0.009838470257818699,
0.29355573654174805,
0.18860290944576263,
-0.10255664587020874,
0.07921459525823593,
0.6973379254341125,
-0.15490247309207916,
-0.7327940464019775,
0.5887132287025452,
-0.5073848962783813,
-0.5001289248466492,
-0.5438353419303894,
-0.3357584774494171,
-0.39566612243652344,
0.1579618752002716,
0.020352032035589218,
0.8095848560333252,
-0.5281210541725159,
0.07972335815429688,
0.4104185402393341,
-0.3447333574295044,
-0.4237879812717438,
0.37901002168655396,
-0.12456774711608887,
-0.7926134467124939,
0.9640136957168579,
0.14809955656528473,
0.4065763056278229,
0.2603374719619751,
0.39122721552848816,
-0.5337557792663574,
-0.07244911789894104,
-0.2463976889848709,
0.20351210236549377,
-0.32658642530441284,
0.019066717475652695,
-0.3928435444831848,
-0.5639539361000061,
-0.5606082677841187,
-0.28389570116996765,
-0.17656806111335754,
-0.50208580493927,
-0.18311025202274323,
-0.356909841299057,
0.38975754380226135,
0.7711114287376404,
-0.23186403512954712,
-0.22764675319194794,
-0.6401162147521973,
0.8585009574890137,
0.29632309079170227,
0.3087548315525055,
-0.01748036779463291,
0.08785083144903183,
-0.0383899100124836,
0.29332149028778076,
-0.15341366827487946,
-1.116012692451477,
0.4438427686691284,
0.08263296633958817,
0.5433177947998047,
0.10946445912122726,
0.34825026988983154,
0.8398718237876892,
-0.6751489639282227,
0.6534234881401062,
0.3475317358970642,
-0.6816728711128235,
0.687532901763916,
-0.371062695980072,
0.16789798438549042,
0.8120237588882446,
0.28544148802757263,
-0.32821136713027954,
-0.17171312868595123,
-0.5836684703826904,
-0.782301664352417,
0.6667898297309875,
0.24458998441696167,
-0.40108954906463623,
-0.35938864946365356,
0.175744891166687,
0.36817464232444763,
0.18636077642440796,
-0.2537548840045929,
-0.19288191199302673,
-0.2576744258403778,
-0.77204829454422,
0.17625361680984497,
-0.1421782374382019,
-0.22558803856372833,
-0.6318015456199646,
0.5842113494873047,
0.05350829288363457,
0.28604066371917725,
0.40325406193733215,
0.010346947237849236,
-0.14430008828639984,
0.073855459690094,
0.40655478835105896,
0.555900514125824,
-0.5092442631721497,
0.4405157268047333,
0.11062342673540115,
-0.8304620981216431,
0.4178166389465332,
0.10092005133628845,
-0.11146975308656693,
0.030252886936068535,
0.4531363844871521,
0.46451106667518616,
0.2593136429786682,
-0.9708573818206787,
0.09539250284433365,
0.16516229510307312,
0.06245189532637596,
-0.25952276587486267,
0.2571556568145752,
-0.058563727885484695,
0.16135600209236145,
0.09934625029563904,
-0.1003771722316742,
0.24323764443397522,
-0.6222879886627197,
0.4761190712451935,
0.1653994619846344,
-0.5050153732299805,
-0.5969570875167847,
0.7951763272285461,
0.22195851802825928,
-0.4390876591205597,
0.5971212387084961,
-0.028919974341988564,
-0.01340075209736824,
0.8374359011650085,
0.8146294355392456,
0.7038506865501404,
-0.07468417286872864,
0.6376968622207642,
0.4850638508796692,
-0.12263958901166916,
-0.08530915528535843,
0.3545205891132355,
0.06338190287351608,
-0.2149665206670761,
-0.21950770914554596,
-0.6738178133964539,
-0.44666337966918945,
0.18291263282299042,
-0.9311568140983582,
0.35972869396209717,
-0.6236850023269653,
-0.5725007057189941,
0.18512685596942902,
-0.023758718743920326,
-0.6189384460449219,
0.19902025163173676,
-0.20996494591236115,
0.5090069770812988,
-0.7236648797988892,
0.5381950736045837,
0.6984221935272217,
-0.5272530913352966,
-0.33022233843803406,
0.03406745567917824,
0.4708084166049957,
-0.6102473735809326,
0.3920884132385254,
0.05265175923705101,
0.04193272069096565,
0.0027473538648337126,
-0.21352140605449677,
-0.6425549387931824,
1.011270523071289,
0.4088268578052521,
-0.48924747109413147,
-0.06240620091557503,
0.5027406811714172,
1.0622286796569824,
-0.2888028621673584,
-0.06413686275482178,
0.6039532423019409,
0.3456736207008362,
-0.04189097508788109,
-0.9410095810890198,
0.4194912314414978,
-0.2204514741897583,
0.23913288116455078,
-0.009385764598846436,
-0.28795915842056274,
0.49241942167282104,
-0.6163618564605713,
-0.16381558775901794,
0.10268561542034149,
-0.006275550927966833,
0.7000564336776733,
0.46967214345932007,
0.07575168460607529,
0.4420403242111206,
0.79582679271698,
-0.08446820825338364,
0.7144129276275635,
-0.13657455146312714,
0.1341615468263626,
1.1092233657836914,
-0.705435574054718,
0.15700805187225342,
0.23775945603847504,
-0.5378583669662476,
0.3432483375072479,
0.5874063372612,
0.16815194487571716,
0.9208459258079529,
0.4078797698020935,
-0.589828372001648,
-0.05114758759737015,
-0.2459217607975006,
-0.42412838339805603,
0.19518542289733887,
0.46253708004951477,
-0.4190042316913605,
-0.10252735763788223,
-0.12291231751441956,
-0.2531191408634186,
-0.188556969165802,
0.08731791377067566,
0.747725248336792,
0.08843053132295609,
-0.3432253897190094,
0.3102540075778961,
-0.3640126883983612,
-0.10131224989891052,
-0.5764538645744324,
-0.3622344732284546,
-0.1368941366672516,
0.1225031390786171,
-0.2636990547180176,
-0.5953413844108582,
0.5400312542915344,
-0.19018016755580902,
-0.3460850417613983,
-0.3742655813694,
0.6598096489906311,
-0.5193529725074768,
-0.5729991793632507,
-0.16662271320819855,
0.4438890516757965,
-0.06348339468240738,
0.27067306637763977,
-0.2935028076171875,
0.10220678150653839,
-0.10151655972003937,
0.2656644284725189,
0.5425235033035278,
0.6774652600288391,
-0.251459538936615,
0.4227711260318756,
0.8833410143852234,
0.6027534008026123,
-0.5008116960525513,
-0.07268315553665161,
0.5683797597885132,
-0.6447687745094299,
-0.4717937409877777,
-0.7077298760414124,
0.3628182113170624,
-0.09965232759714127,
-0.4055209755897522,
0.35271742939949036,
0.4117124676704407,
0.4875239133834839,
-0.28184065222740173,
0.8597918748855591,
-0.07987276464700699,
0.5490344166755676,
-0.21424707770347595,
0.9877145290374756,
-0.5262616276741028,
0.052733492106199265,
-0.29792433977127075,
-0.42750993371009827,
-0.12047652155160904,
0.5407888889312744,
0.05474032834172249,
-0.3577823042869568,
0.6580278277397156,
0.7063778638839722,
0.15675081312656403,
0.14885181188583374,
0.02726382575929165,
0.07974117994308472,
0.46934181451797485,
0.4018382728099823,
0.49891555309295654,
-0.1056383028626442,
-0.16071149706840515,
-0.31357064843177795,
-0.1936890035867691,
-0.15513190627098083,
-0.8169820308685303,
-0.6973304152488708,
-0.8400952816009521,
-0.49487629532814026,
-0.5052229166030884,
0.4369686543941498,
1.2749797105789185,
0.7447905540466309,
-0.869690477848053,
0.05023609474301338,
0.016079138964414597,
0.1839810162782669,
-0.5543544292449951,
-0.22206221520900726,
0.4871743619441986,
0.02306322380900383,
-0.14347749948501587,
0.31279221177101135,
0.14497943222522736,
0.2317638248205185,
-0.25728875398635864,
0.15726697444915771,
0.19765140116214752,
-0.04631650820374489,
0.5800532698631287,
0.20127716660499573,
-0.5354995131492615,
-0.12185171991586685,
-0.15746548771858215,
-0.24042825400829315,
-0.2875725328922272,
0.7304994463920593,
-0.8447559475898743,
0.6515407562255859,
0.573474645614624,
0.4986613690853119,
0.380519300699234,
0.09718374907970428,
0.5769796967506409,
-0.8378252983093262,
0.055601656436920166,
0.3014375865459442,
0.2887682020664215,
0.09621094167232513,
-0.4523734152317047,
0.5733654499053955,
0.533576488494873,
-0.29165026545524597,
-1.0149869918823242,
0.08019886165857315,
-0.8638666868209839,
-0.1761161983013153,
1.0889853239059448,
0.3735213279724121,
-0.228544220328331,
-0.2748982906341553,
-0.38582801818847656,
0.35140079259872437,
-0.47793272137641907,
1.3400739431381226,
0.37838608026504517,
-0.373570054769516,
0.31225794553756714,
-0.5968944430351257,
0.8512301445007324,
-0.033374834805727005,
-1.0169086456298828,
0.04232567921280861,
0.9539635181427002,
0.42026853561401367,
-0.14810818433761597,
0.9422619938850403,
-0.3157179355621338,
0.32016104459762573,
-0.15289999544620514,
-0.13072454929351807,
-0.11072039604187012,
-0.46823400259017944,
0.20651301741600037,
-0.23301060497760773,
-0.7250738739967346,
0.030975479632616043
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.06052v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.06052v1
|
A Multidimensional Framework for Evaluating Lexical Semantic Change with Social Science Applications
| 2024-06-10T06:46:09 | 2024-06-10T06:46:09 |
Naomi Baes, Nick Haslam, Ekaterina Vylomova
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Historical linguists have identified multiple forms of lexical semantic
change. We present a three-dimensional framework for integrating these forms
and a unified computational methodology for evaluating them concurrently. The
dimensions represent increases or decreases in semantic 1) sentiment, 2)
breadth, and 3) intensity. These dimensions can be complemented by the
evaluation of shifts in the frequency of the target words and the thematic
content of its collocates. This framework enables lexical semantic change to be
mapped economically and systematically and has applications in computational
social science. We present an illustrative analysis of semantic shifts in
mental health and mental illness in two corpora, demonstrating patterns of
semantic change that illuminate contemporary concerns about pathologization,
stigma, and concept creep.
|
[
-0.24666140973567963,
-0.9510596990585327,
0.7712273597717285,
0.336698979139328,
-0.009465493261814117,
0.08378814160823822,
-0.2701700031757355,
-0.41236087679862976,
0.6344296336174011,
0.36546313762664795,
-0.5145208835601807,
-0.8040761351585388,
-0.916517972946167,
0.08415224403142929,
-0.39078983664512634,
0.915926992893219,
0.012416060082614422,
0.2332225739955902,
-0.03229256346821785,
-0.07647794485092163,
-0.4845479726791382,
-0.34048983454704285,
-0.548676609992981,
-0.3083401322364807,
0.8681548237800598,
0.30316707491874695,
1.1602365970611572,
0.32137081027030945,
0.7706692814826965,
0.26923269033432007,
-0.19972488284111023,
-0.2236396223306656,
-0.33757632970809937,
0.3008617162704468,
-0.419563353061676,
-0.31011685729026794,
-0.39914098381996155,
-0.027112001553177834,
0.6190905570983887,
1.1565157175064087,
-0.12500403821468353,
0.27028611302375793,
-0.2674548327922821,
0.7574630975723267,
-0.7102406024932861,
0.39569714665412903,
-0.6989626884460449,
-0.11717136949300766,
-0.49336934089660645,
-0.10177327692508698,
0.2175881266593933,
-0.1789112240076065,
-0.028194980695843697,
-0.6223294138908386,
0.1448102444410324,
-0.41496431827545166,
0.507182776927948,
0.19941182434558868,
-0.4980233609676361,
-0.20503157377243042,
-0.5796950459480286,
0.5269296169281006,
-0.31569811701774597,
0.6635763049125671,
0.3017621636390686,
0.15832392871379852,
-0.22977130115032196,
-0.7197680473327637,
-0.5180398225784302,
-0.17736414074897766,
0.21107032895088196,
0.11515925824642181,
-0.338316410779953,
-0.1583564430475235,
0.11333733797073364,
0.1344434916973114,
-0.2656760513782501,
-0.15307100117206573,
-0.6016901731491089,
-0.4688456952571869,
0.6723761558532715,
0.5584039092063904,
0.6383925676345825,
-0.2438480257987976,
-0.11543896049261093,
-0.22671708464622498,
-0.47319361567497253,
-0.2074134647846222,
0.21830545365810394,
0.4937799572944641,
-0.17544357478618622,
0.6432923078536987,
-0.016526537016034126,
0.3780512511730194,
-0.2865121364593506,
-0.3700903058052063,
0.4966442584991455,
-0.5841788053512573,
-0.03800046443939209,
0.22946742177009583,
0.2603413164615631,
0.7261642217636108,
-0.2775653302669525,
-0.10029890388250351,
0.1696203649044037,
0.759323239326477,
0.30162134766578674,
-0.4905654788017273,
-0.0946747288107872,
0.032586295157670975,
-0.5073445439338684,
-0.09693104028701782,
-0.16902336478233337,
-0.9348084330558777,
-0.8928459882736206,
-0.6728960871696472,
0.055142275989055634,
-0.861640214920044,
-0.5375200510025024,
0.6489009857177734,
-0.5085514187812805,
0.28284651041030884,
0.306323379278183,
-0.5327121615409851,
0.2991580665111542,
0.9230515360832214,
1.0247966051101685,
-0.16535699367523193,
-0.3207883834838867,
0.042961616069078445,
0.2007819414138794,
-0.47504615783691406,
0.8183496594429016,
-0.7116581201553345,
-0.39754223823547363,
0.08184913545846939,
-0.0153206130489707,
-0.23512879014015198,
-0.3379365801811218,
0.26650774478912354,
-0.23503883183002472,
-0.23154909908771515,
-0.3007916510105133,
-0.16418011486530304,
-0.002800608752295375,
0.15742374956607819,
-0.6052953004837036,
1.000583529472351,
0.2787756025791168,
-0.9045541882514954,
0.46363282203674316,
-0.7493152618408203,
-0.3460821211338043,
-0.043386127799749374,
0.08353525400161743,
0.044989995658397675,
0.41503506898880005,
-0.402748703956604,
0.10830161720514297,
-0.2496974617242813,
0.14861203730106354,
-0.5917323231697083,
-0.15997149050235748,
0.33030039072036743,
0.08168806880712509,
0.833188533782959,
0.1496441513299942,
-0.14575642347335815,
0.15750177204608917,
-0.9125109314918518,
-0.22588618099689484,
-0.015204648487269878,
0.1824975609779358,
-0.768269419670105,
0.2712806165218353,
0.24730032682418823,
0.19880425930023193,
0.28973641991615295,
-0.637283205986023,
-0.05313938111066818,
-0.6173698902130127,
0.33562198281288147,
0.464803010225296,
0.19510823488235474,
0.4665062427520752,
-0.12243491411209106,
0.2265312373638153,
0.3517441153526306,
0.30308955907821655,
0.442656934261322,
-0.7823250889778137,
-0.4805908203125,
-0.33739662170410156,
-0.004043386317789555,
0.3689972460269928,
-0.5780640840530396,
0.14056918025016785,
-0.4276719391345978,
-0.45195674896240234,
-0.4334351718425751,
-0.19009678065776825,
-0.2664431631565094,
-0.01734374463558197,
0.5467124581336975,
-0.258314847946167,
-0.4184202551841736,
-0.8161461353302002,
-0.42592698335647583,
-0.38587385416030884,
0.03395812585949898,
-0.3169628083705902,
0.5638198256492615,
-0.6676276326179504,
0.8778659105300903,
-0.5882161259651184,
-0.19465290009975433,
0.1856617033481598,
0.34118565917015076,
-0.3132048547267914,
0.1864863485097885,
0.3926982283592224,
-0.6390712261199951,
0.15811817348003387,
-0.002291946206241846,
-0.26892170310020447,
-0.20564010739326477,
-0.058979686349630356,
-0.3998224139213562,
-0.11716265976428986,
0.6736786365509033,
-0.3952174782752991,
0.6110821962356567,
0.31126323342323303,
-0.7164292335510254,
0.6195318698883057,
-0.028124675154685974,
-0.029959693551063538,
-0.9739601612091064,
-0.2651883661746979,
-0.12234757840633392,
0.3719882071018219,
-0.6156389713287354,
0.12901535630226135,
-0.04237111285328865,
0.0005499940598383546,
-0.3361364006996155,
0.3251942992210388,
-0.09579499810934067,
0.06569992750883102,
0.17290417850017548,
0.534611701965332,
-0.030605146661400795,
-0.12174475938081741,
-0.32975953817367554,
0.12647174298763275,
0.5963526964187622,
-0.48294129967689514,
0.5802697539329529,
0.005214546341449022,
-0.15490174293518066,
0.8203600645065308,
-0.20689347386360168,
-0.12101396173238754,
-0.5289317965507507,
0.0364592969417572,
-0.7577484846115112,
-0.13719668984413147,
0.2725675404071808,
-0.36575040221214294,
-0.1737494021654129,
0.6849817633628845,
-0.7320964336395264,
-0.21412771940231323,
-0.6208292841911316,
0.23699763417243958,
-0.35862502455711365,
-0.01734892465174198,
0.35840946435928345,
0.5714705586433411,
-0.04910607635974884,
0.11727549880743027,
-0.7085586786270142,
0.4875887334346771,
-0.4148879647254944,
-0.7728926539421082,
0.8205772638320923,
-0.08426845073699951,
-0.9675024747848511,
0.19769641757011414,
-0.09230474382638931,
-0.13629864156246185,
0.1738109588623047,
0.050951819866895676,
0.19160029292106628,
-0.16290132701396942,
0.5667862296104431,
0.16196183860301971,
-0.10002397000789642,
0.4018368124961853,
-0.19841644167900085,
0.35111919045448303,
-0.23316781222820282,
-0.06370534747838974,
0.01814807951450348,
0.714527428150177,
0.716656506061554,
-0.10335353761911392,
0.8492284417152405,
0.7619996070861816,
-0.6388972401618958,
0.4414161443710327,
-0.31901389360427856,
0.14377166330814362,
-0.24990984797477722,
0.5886924266815186,
-0.3849307596683502,
-0.8637285828590393,
0.5933485627174377,
-0.010387107729911804,
-0.3029807507991791,
0.7446628212928772,
0.8533443212509155,
0.397952675819397,
1.1287175416946411,
0.5631862282752991,
0.37006300687789917,
0.29997462034225464,
0.047008052468299866,
0.5877012610435486,
-0.7591333985328674,
-0.44775980710983276,
-0.6600037813186646,
-0.021424055099487305,
-0.799615740776062,
-0.5753153562545776,
0.6376321315765381,
-0.05686864256858826,
-0.41773664951324463,
0.07369541376829147,
-0.2386440932750702,
-0.13445128500461578,
-0.14718151092529297,
0.0688289925456047,
0.12562939524650574,
-0.11291489005088806,
-0.19237543642520905,
-0.2567318379878998,
-0.3072505295276642,
-0.47111302614212036,
0.7184870839118958,
0.437233567237854,
0.675906777381897,
0.6202563643455505,
0.3898042142391205,
0.33962282538414,
0.26715660095214844,
-0.8517653346061707,
0.5376076698303223,
0.024501485750079155,
-0.45527321100234985,
-0.40045657753944397,
-0.28197476267814636,
-1.0638874769210815,
0.3725505471229553,
-0.3647628128528595,
-0.9375820159912109,
0.5015867352485657,
-0.38127240538597107,
-0.2131144255399704,
0.3084699213504791,
-0.5253795385360718,
0.6350035667419434,
-0.061881642788648605,
-0.17399579286575317,
-0.6916611790657043,
-0.6709897518157959,
0.14240308105945587,
-0.1760762482881546,
0.5212118029594421,
-0.6398777961730957,
-0.26137375831604004,
0.5864282846450806,
-0.3305750787258148,
0.8630824089050293,
-0.044570326805114746,
-0.2455773651599884,
-0.06810886412858963,
0.18191330134868622,
-0.2697758078575134,
0.23730234801769257,
-0.2476174533367157,
0.3601246476173401,
0.8351374864578247,
-0.354438841342926,
-0.6909321546554565,
0.6851023435592651,
-0.8524953126907349,
-0.462507963180542,
-0.4308546185493469,
-0.7229368090629578,
-0.4364258050918579,
0.053385570645332336,
-0.0744079202413559,
0.4251454770565033,
-0.48550286889076233,
-0.06984058022499084,
0.18498705327510834,
-0.2985898554325104,
0.07089105248451233,
0.28164249658584595,
-0.38147109746932983,
-0.20502035319805145,
0.6680757999420166,
0.10315712541341782,
0.18898312747478485,
0.05982061102986336,
0.5828202366828918,
-0.3863218426704407,
0.031232556328177452,
-0.07201725244522095,
0.33800196647644043,
-0.7588140964508057,
-0.2291203886270523,
-0.4560059905052185,
0.10320590436458588,
-0.9728947877883911,
-0.1454588770866394,
-0.07180596143007278,
-0.35778459906578064,
-0.23811820149421692,
0.28124675154685974,
0.6769512891769409,
0.8931239247322083,
-0.3965231478214264,
0.014369853772222996,
-0.4051753878593445,
0.19233989715576172,
-0.044259801506996155,
0.5714086890220642,
-0.17341645061969757,
-0.13170646131038666,
-0.20241408050060272,
0.19070221483707428,
-0.12442588806152344,
-1.374540090560913,
0.23810836672782898,
0.2453981637954712,
0.2860608696937561,
0.3382766544818878,
-0.004736935719847679,
0.8108723759651184,
-0.43924200534820557,
0.8278570771217346,
0.4719691574573517,
-1.0233560800552368,
0.5253121256828308,
-0.22962361574172974,
0.598785936832428,
0.5028910040855408,
0.26736822724342346,
-1.1167173385620117,
-0.4056384563446045,
-0.5345200896263123,
-0.8066241145133972,
0.3108961582183838,
-0.1852136254310608,
0.2456042468547821,
-0.5040026307106018,
0.5213311314582825,
-0.04624846577644348,
-0.17211495339870453,
-0.07798487693071365,
-0.35955119132995605,
-0.45618805289268494,
-0.17450080811977386,
-0.09463207423686981,
-0.28655147552490234,
-0.2545022964477539,
-0.6057169437408447,
0.32008007168769836,
-0.1107635498046875,
0.2964586615562439,
0.1267126351594925,
-0.16821372509002686,
0.20738999545574188,
0.44662386178970337,
0.5307501554489136,
0.7846879363059998,
-0.08636964857578278,
0.6904038786888123,
0.17019428312778473,
-0.6454138159751892,
-0.06134068965911865,
0.10438581556081772,
0.15718267858028412,
0.0835910513997078,
0.39321985840797424,
0.631682276725769,
0.6292715668678284,
-0.16108758747577667,
0.39725539088249207,
0.22190597653388977,
-0.21031779050827026,
-0.19692915678024292,
-0.2853885889053345,
0.20916226506233215,
0.03211744502186775,
-0.18812942504882812,
0.1832839697599411,
0.37567123770713806,
-0.875241756439209,
0.08333726972341537,
0.16504129767417908,
-0.6013354063034058,
-0.4591144323348999,
0.22117984294891357,
-0.21496590971946716,
-0.06500378251075745,
0.28858503699302673,
-0.2344876080751419,
-0.33160722255706787,
0.32605111598968506,
0.7305542230606079,
0.66136634349823,
-0.3180164694786072,
0.6178757548332214,
0.14249491691589355,
0.2380123883485794,
0.14457477629184723,
0.029907653108239174,
0.18328826129436493,
-0.9998588562011719,
-0.08329056203365326,
-0.7248026728630066,
-0.10678889602422714,
0.004871692042797804,
-0.914665699005127,
0.4132804870605469,
-0.28110772371292114,
-0.5150497555732727,
0.5591448545455933,
-0.2025703489780426,
-0.680470883846283,
0.006106233224272728,
0.3792826533317566,
0.6759671568870544,
-0.8312403559684753,
0.49857720732688904,
1.1758190393447876,
-0.24107712507247925,
-0.18802039325237274,
0.1429959386587143,
0.5173501372337341,
-0.6365085244178772,
0.6779917478561401,
0.008470607921481133,
-0.7294122576713562,
-0.2482621967792511,
-0.5199741721153259,
-1.273856520652771,
0.689172625541687,
0.1622886210680008,
0.1386583298444748,
0.11596311628818512,
0.4389394223690033,
0.820875883102417,
-0.3809821605682373,
0.0714818611741066,
0.987138032913208,
0.7039667367935181,
0.03887433558702469,
-0.52908855676651,
0.0204756036400795,
-0.18800781667232513,
0.7229965925216675,
0.3046202063560486,
-0.17354658246040344,
0.8808642029762268,
-0.02422860637307167,
-0.6822788119316101,
-0.304298460483551,
0.5174702405929565,
-0.09798665344715118,
0.12470916658639908,
0.6095900535583496,
0.432732492685318,
0.7310459613800049,
-0.03294569253921509,
0.8874067664146423,
-0.5235310792922974,
0.39236170053482056,
0.5540413856506348,
-0.46548086404800415,
0.4614637792110443,
0.3438268303871155,
-0.19218194484710693,
0.8028779625892639,
0.6387426257133484,
0.34708601236343384,
0.38831615447998047,
0.6546851396560669,
-0.42570027709007263,
-0.18113015592098236,
-0.27174362540245056,
-0.3535527288913727,
0.7694060802459717,
1.0175535678863525,
0.19947054982185364,
-0.7491496205329895,
0.22748947143554688,
0.45353999733924866,
0.09309195727109909,
-0.400134801864624,
0.5307000279426575,
0.006672894582152367,
-0.17213492095470428,
0.2417779266834259,
0.40201297402381897,
0.25640055537223816,
-0.4266687035560608,
-0.0847994014620781,
0.10668496787548065,
0.2679384648799896,
-0.17932838201522827,
-0.7517836093902588,
0.9585047364234924,
-0.3732532262802124,
-0.22313806414604187,
-0.19164808094501495,
0.8286496996879578,
-0.18999549746513367,
-0.7983080744743347,
0.9511715769767761,
0.4897947311401367,
0.11204645782709122,
-0.07432271540164948,
-0.8722432255744934,
0.37872958183288574,
-0.39799800515174866,
0.18407760560512543,
0.2421482354402542,
0.7278041243553162,
-0.42670977115631104,
0.10848192870616913,
0.5393725633621216,
0.39562129974365234,
0.011145608499646187,
0.5436011552810669,
0.7667734026908875,
-0.7190436124801636,
-0.3164485991001129,
-0.6551337838172913,
0.0396200530230999,
-0.048800792545080185,
-0.5734906196594238,
0.5524749159812927,
0.22085294127464294,
0.6962164640426636,
0.3507091999053955,
0.47278907895088196,
-0.2987814247608185,
0.22174818813800812,
-0.3998100757598877,
0.41977888345718384,
-0.6743649244308472,
-0.018758799880743027,
-0.49097496271133423,
-0.6686860918998718,
-0.8259304761886597,
0.5053967237472534,
-0.48829129338264465,
-0.30618584156036377,
0.9849862456321716,
0.7574584484100342,
0.39231619238853455,
0.2209673672914505,
0.29471588134765625,
0.4416518807411194,
0.05899728089570999,
0.025711247697472572,
0.8163832426071167,
-0.05003591254353523,
-0.17364299297332764,
-0.14998507499694824,
-0.45074325799942017,
0.09832486510276794,
-0.6793832778930664,
-0.37001943588256836,
-1.0702872276306152,
-0.5243718028068542,
-0.5559147596359253,
0.27857279777526855,
0.7973129749298096,
0.12604327499866486,
-0.37826135754585266,
-0.2494962364435196,
0.2541770040988922,
0.18451735377311707,
-0.45874208211898804,
-0.3219580054283142,
0.37665024399757385,
-0.5193639397621155,
-0.22760897874832153,
0.05506591498851776,
0.6896925568580627,
-0.5243899822235107,
-0.5450181365013123,
0.5339559316635132,
-0.3320048153400421,
0.2830236554145813,
1.2157073020935059,
-0.27822673320770264,
-0.9130202531814575,
-0.7824601531028748,
-0.05244183540344238,
-0.12005311995744705,
-0.020609013736248016,
0.9236077070236206,
-0.4861522316932678,
0.3333878219127655,
0.5122858285903931,
0.1944020539522171,
0.23373721539974213,
-0.46286728978157043,
0.21925528347492218,
-0.23389039933681488,
-0.0167795829474926,
-0.10035521537065506,
0.2932104766368866,
0.48300865292549133,
-0.31453433632850647,
0.3115246593952179,
0.5813002586364746,
-0.06591764092445374,
-0.3610617220401764,
0.3509075939655304,
-0.7954075336456299,
-0.45077091455459595,
1.1676664352416992,
0.4181287884712219,
-0.390550434589386,
-0.41265854239463806,
0.09785310178995132,
0.24053189158439636,
-0.19568763673305511,
0.8756824731826782,
0.7862119078636169,
-0.3835654556751251,
0.14040684700012207,
-0.530184268951416,
0.2909683585166931,
0.20049437880516052,
-0.6591702103614807,
-0.09429747611284256,
0.7013014554977417,
0.21809832751750946,
0.5005834102630615,
0.6024535298347473,
-0.7781540155410767,
-0.04475002363324165,
0.1253979504108429,
0.4230920374393463,
0.6932473182678223,
-0.1707303673028946,
-0.3218839168548584,
-0.055386923253536224,
-0.33476579189300537,
0.22682814300060272
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.06046v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.06046v1
|
MATES: Model-Aware Data Selection for Efficient Pretraining with Data Influence Models
| 2024-06-10T06:27:42 | 2024-06-10T06:27:42 |
Zichun Yu, Spandan Das, Chenyan Xiong
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Pretraining data selection has the potential to improve language model
pretraining efficiency by utilizing higher-quality data from massive web data
corpora. Current data selection methods, which rely on either hand-crafted
rules or larger reference models, are conducted statically and do not capture
the evolving data preferences during pretraining. In this paper, we introduce
model-aware data selection with data influence models (MATES), where a data
influence model continuously adapts to the evolving data preferences of the
pretraining model and then selects the data most effective for the current
pretraining progress. Specifically, we fine-tune a small data influence model
to approximate oracle data preference signals collected by locally probing the
pretraining model and to select data accordingly for the next pretraining
stage. Experiments on Pythia and the C4 dataset demonstrate that MATES
significantly outperforms random data selection on extensive downstream tasks
in both zero- and few-shot settings. It doubles the gains achieved by recent
data selection approaches that leverage larger reference models and reduces the
total FLOPs required to reach certain performances by half. Further analysis
validates the ever-changing data preferences of pretraining models and the
effectiveness of our data influence models to capture them. Our code is
open-sourced at https://github.com/cxcscmu/MATES.
|
[
-0.36609727144241333,
-0.5593116879463196,
0.5862139463424683,
0.29005682468414307,
-0.36596935987472534,
-0.25220468640327454,
-0.3129441440105438,
-0.5385094881057739,
0.20326602458953857,
0.2956251800060272,
-0.6321796774864197,
-0.23885256052017212,
-0.3404546082019806,
0.12083514034748077,
-0.30013197660446167,
0.7276932597160339,
0.07205837965011597,
0.12422606348991394,
-0.4176367521286011,
0.040033191442489624,
-0.6352345943450928,
-0.532195508480072,
-0.3532050848007202,
-0.4071512520313263,
0.43408069014549255,
0.3998313248157501,
0.7816966772079468,
0.7667896151542664,
0.45652681589126587,
0.20967622101306915,
0.00900178961455822,
-0.008113155141472816,
-0.8492454886436462,
0.239891916513443,
-0.1974879503250122,
-0.5920877456665039,
-0.39881154894828796,
0.23825809359550476,
0.4121212363243103,
0.55531245470047,
-0.1400376856327057,
0.29325708746910095,
-0.21560978889465332,
0.722775936126709,
-0.6876462697982788,
0.2803148925304413,
-0.9754270315170288,
-0.08475489914417267,
-0.6603950262069702,
-0.12529326975345612,
-0.5501218438148499,
-0.48353588581085205,
0.22299042344093323,
-0.7004402279853821,
0.025663506239652634,
0.1579006463289261,
0.5920490622520447,
0.3846133351325989,
-0.1148562878370285,
0.1305307000875473,
-0.7906457185745239,
0.5706507563591003,
-0.5110012888908386,
0.807073175907135,
0.6905271410942078,
0.31310951709747314,
0.033980272710323334,
-0.7445515394210815,
-0.31465041637420654,
-0.012835172936320305,
-0.049356598407030106,
-0.0038028794806450605,
-0.012231457978487015,
0.034983113408088684,
0.19685274362564087,
0.25468650460243225,
-0.621781051158905,
0.13877686858177185,
-0.4018605649471283,
-0.03828299418091774,
0.7038323283195496,
0.015294515527784824,
-0.04860440641641617,
0.22888314723968506,
-0.07416989654302597,
-0.23570102453231812,
-0.9240307211875916,
-0.127287358045578,
0.47070711851119995,
0.5363242030143738,
0.052642907947301865,
0.2602425217628479,
-0.5852401852607727,
1.1054441928863525,
0.1172759085893631,
0.31006136536598206,
0.2949358820915222,
-0.19911915063858032,
-0.1466168612241745,
-0.0521995946764946,
0.6180413365364075,
0.01654130406677723,
0.40242913365364075,
-0.36036887764930725,
-0.1367368996143341,
0.18576084077358246,
0.27177420258522034,
-1.1201053857803345,
-0.7218998670578003,
0.18297600746154785,
-0.4658546447753906,
-0.30358177423477173,
0.013746602460741997,
-0.6047474145889282,
-0.3314268887042999,
-0.5826048254966736,
0.44319388270378113,
-0.32458725571632385,
-0.32938241958618164,
0.17921246588230133,
-0.021226994693279266,
0.1502532809972763,
0.09503059834241867,
-0.950896680355072,
-0.05818098783493042,
0.44455140829086304,
0.6561306118965149,
-0.23078522086143494,
-0.42238321900367737,
-0.7727673649787903,
0.1609104573726654,
-0.365062415599823,
0.8812000751495361,
-0.9028513431549072,
-0.3665527403354645,
-0.17584551870822906,
-0.3041221499443054,
-0.33716511726379395,
-0.525783121585846,
0.36663389205932617,
-0.8382428288459778,
0.0800589844584465,
-0.36976873874664307,
-0.7862555384635925,
-0.0054489970207214355,
-0.04388347640633583,
-0.6653688549995422,
1.1241447925567627,
0.20052587985992432,
-0.826542854309082,
0.810940146446228,
-0.4874911606311798,
-0.35892748832702637,
0.014125049114227295,
-0.12412120401859283,
-0.4680545926094055,
-0.07344379276037216,
0.1653621643781662,
0.6429925560951233,
-0.13966307044029236,
0.08050119876861572,
-0.8527336716651917,
-0.36272475123405457,
-0.05936693400144577,
-0.01006242260336876,
0.5522983074188232,
0.037670593708753586,
0.05158589780330658,
0.35609444975852966,
-0.7043057084083557,
0.08218849450349808,
0.21292655169963837,
-0.19949907064437866,
-0.36606404185295105,
0.25161072611808777,
-0.13251006603240967,
0.2026440054178238,
0.10109193623065948,
-0.33715879917144775,
0.33584266901016235,
0.00304117682389915,
0.2459414303302765,
0.7614865899085999,
-0.10760588198900223,
0.44096726179122925,
-0.33507680892944336,
0.5343438386917114,
-0.37773486971855164,
0.41811832785606384,
0.14148478209972382,
-0.2562755048274994,
-0.5020651817321777,
-0.10084354132413864,
0.4762703776359558,
0.34805265069007874,
-0.7313858866691589,
0.253539502620697,
-0.3128490746021271,
-0.8273303508758545,
-0.4525493085384369,
0.4553998112678528,
0.10784216970205307,
0.3647851049900055,
0.5059810876846313,
-0.37122058868408203,
-0.6527818441390991,
-0.656027615070343,
-0.25418952107429504,
-0.2856694459915161,
0.2246660590171814,
0.34384360909461975,
0.09606039524078369,
-0.15550437569618225,
1.165879487991333,
-0.8025362491607666,
-0.0017210552468895912,
-0.34702396392822266,
-0.15142108500003815,
0.19816330075263977,
0.4695605933666229,
0.812404215335846,
-0.8115553259849548,
-0.5634285807609558,
-0.4308108687400818,
-0.527944028377533,
-0.06672409176826477,
-0.08550641685724258,
-0.6809478402137756,
-0.2817560136318207,
0.5842427611351013,
-0.4364587068557739,
0.3535456955432892,
0.5114682912826538,
-0.472245991230011,
0.7032355070114136,
-0.059940941631793976,
-0.24771660566329956,
-0.637491762638092,
0.18528695404529572,
-0.10460066050291061,
-0.5667757987976074,
-0.6147134900093079,
-0.20753417909145355,
0.20847167074680328,
0.09375183284282684,
-0.320463091135025,
0.47722482681274414,
-0.4530467092990875,
-0.1254313588142395,
-0.078021340072155,
-0.049004506319761276,
-0.2544790208339691,
0.2284712940454483,
0.47666358947753906,
0.6120829582214355,
0.8460297584533691,
-0.872273325920105,
0.24259065091609955,
0.6660090088844299,
-0.3896719515323639,
0.3055626451969147,
-0.512459933757782,
0.5476512312889099,
0.13916970789432526,
0.15172450244426727,
-0.4853326976299286,
-0.1787666529417038,
-0.07653133571147919,
-0.37119585275650024,
0.2617591321468353,
-0.3399665951728821,
-0.40895095467567444,
-0.20609506964683533,
-0.2147662341594696,
0.21656444668769836,
0.2548494338989258,
-0.7475010752677917,
0.4962576627731323,
0.37678131461143494,
-0.0888102799654007,
-0.17859867215156555,
-0.555346667766571,
-0.26937511563301086,
-0.21882547438144684,
-0.4226696193218231,
0.2666173577308655,
-0.44833841919898987,
0.05504057556390762,
-0.1808003932237625,
-0.1559940129518509,
-0.27147287130355835,
0.1224278062582016,
0.13985638320446014,
0.4947079122066498,
0.028265487402677536,
0.0034104606602340937,
-0.030855894088745117,
-0.17311091721057892,
0.08567508310079575,
-0.31438925862312317,
0.6859772801399231,
0.2900238037109375,
-0.16303713619709015,
-0.41106513142585754,
-0.1979653537273407,
0.45071595907211304,
-0.5735874176025391,
0.7520202994346619,
0.47940608859062195,
-0.0017253828700631857,
-0.4166315793991089,
-0.45827025175094604,
-0.49789533019065857,
-0.4851958751678467,
0.38533976674079895,
-0.26482269167900085,
-0.3252713978290558,
0.13834577798843384,
0.04872947558760643,
0.11724290996789932,
0.00468205101788044,
0.27987125515937805,
0.10806140303611755,
0.8860026597976685,
0.7872880697250366,
-0.5467445254325867,
1.0699079036712646,
-0.22815313935279846,
-0.10153254866600037,
-0.6237464547157288,
0.01523100957274437,
-0.41891375184059143,
-0.22501787543296814,
-0.381708562374115,
-0.1750348061323166,
0.13080449402332306,
0.048483092337846756,
-0.21027499437332153,
0.3692900836467743,
-0.2507821321487427,
0.5182504057884216,
0.5667097568511963,
0.4669373631477356,
0.12556742131710052,
-0.22657421231269836,
0.14895668625831604,
-0.06295780092477798,
-0.7615066170692444,
-0.06017298996448517,
1.4171857833862305,
-0.07140645384788513,
0.7659649848937988,
-0.061928436160087585,
0.4721137583255768,
0.16731859743595123,
0.20495516061782837,
-0.5103697776794434,
0.44928136467933655,
-0.00813454668968916,
-0.7929196953773499,
-0.05184359475970268,
-0.597760796546936,
-0.8600665926933289,
-0.028630239889025688,
-0.5255957245826721,
-0.6515164971351624,
0.23271113634109497,
0.4773139953613281,
-0.4186488091945648,
0.249037966132164,
-0.7359691858291626,
0.9616753458976746,
-0.3328293263912201,
-0.6695301532745361,
-0.45285898447036743,
-0.5125301480293274,
0.15076866745948792,
-0.22219227254390717,
-0.15016116201877594,
-0.09404277056455612,
0.31768134236335754,
0.7104533910751343,
-0.43281692266464233,
0.540299654006958,
-0.46491196751594543,
0.3735290765762329,
0.10665786266326904,
0.3358103334903717,
0.7259104251861572,
-0.05912455543875694,
-0.44600868225097656,
-0.01692870631814003,
-0.07477319240570068,
-0.3952822983264923,
-0.4157216548919678,
0.3046559691429138,
-0.6742200255393982,
-0.23235628008842468,
-0.06900343298912048,
-0.3657620847225189,
-0.5890932679176331,
0.2657276690006256,
0.26793837547302246,
0.3764893710613251,
-0.10296260565519333,
0.45075124502182007,
0.4438059628009796,
0.09941516816616058,
0.3435359001159668,
0.5848807096481323,
-0.5482568144798279,
-0.09169714897871017,
0.866253674030304,
0.05347801372408867,
0.5035890936851501,
0.11132162064313889,
0.07923979312181473,
-0.39045432209968567,
-0.7609714865684509,
-0.4216948449611664,
0.16691428422927856,
-0.4057812988758087,
-0.20631371438503265,
-0.3468327522277832,
0.1036250963807106,
-0.14265157282352448,
-0.07860929518938065,
-0.6917137503623962,
-0.14547665417194366,
-0.18001115322113037,
-0.10109738260507584,
0.5584216713905334,
0.5873041749000549,
0.021691370755434036,
0.621526300907135,
-0.5562562942504883,
0.2518750727176666,
0.4408072233200073,
0.6808502078056335,
-0.1625129133462906,
-0.3751583695411682,
-0.3228146731853485,
-0.03634266182780266,
-0.038743555545806885,
-1.0355522632598877,
0.20370399951934814,
0.32826927304267883,
0.6595134735107422,
0.5246210098266602,
0.09464942663908005,
0.5759532451629639,
-0.07824280858039856,
0.3226358890533447,
-0.27956193685531616,
-0.824920654296875,
0.6951007843017578,
-0.6337164044380188,
0.06242286041378975,
1.1139299869537354,
0.3748273253440857,
-0.23800043761730194,
0.12689745426177979,
-0.5432542562484741,
-0.7096425294876099,
1.0187612771987915,
0.30477991700172424,
-0.18463674187660217,
0.5062785744667053,
0.6217039823532104,
0.13222180306911469,
0.36638227105140686,
-0.6388965249061584,
-0.2818552553653717,
-0.032692801207304,
0.0671754702925682,
-0.11881984770298004,
0.15407687425613403,
0.44094640016555786,
-0.4730328917503357,
0.9086720943450928,
-0.1596744805574417,
-0.08155318349599838,
0.03632950037717819,
-0.3480296730995178,
0.080259770154953,
-0.23710136115550995,
-0.23752832412719727,
0.8114832043647766,
-0.5349363684654236,
-0.384319007396698,
0.15089477598667145,
-0.5702276229858398,
-0.15689411759376526,
0.417870432138443,
-0.5467591285705566,
0.03519478067755699,
0.0524737574160099,
1.0100563764572144,
0.08714820444583893,
-0.36602088809013367,
0.3711228370666504,
-0.4019906222820282,
0.14253324270248413,
-0.06752024590969086,
0.4279177486896515,
0.023660244420170784,
0.08317281305789948,
0.017778072506189346,
0.13683414459228516,
-0.12857499718666077,
-0.49729374051094055,
0.14614783227443695,
0.3545963168144226,
-0.3486032485961914,
-0.5631220936775208,
0.8086593151092529,
0.29992032051086426,
0.03203689679503441,
0.6827253103256226,
-0.4098217785358429,
-0.4256725013256073,
0.33182281255722046,
0.3878273665904999,
0.5689054727554321,
-0.4785500764846802,
0.14540281891822815,
0.4073214530944824,
0.10943600535392761,
-0.39568719267845154,
0.34933388233184814,
-0.13149523735046387,
-0.8309347629547119,
-0.41651472449302673,
-0.48537477850914,
-0.5427889227867126,
0.3073938190937042,
-0.7366420030593872,
0.7159457206726074,
-0.37943965196609497,
-0.046524547040462494,
-0.0611591674387455,
0.029721174389123917,
-1.0260486602783203,
0.30766668915748596,
0.16612471640110016,
0.9764657020568848,
-0.9138967990875244,
1.1696816682815552,
0.7508202195167542,
-0.30925285816192627,
-0.848263144493103,
0.06277120113372803,
0.07798697799444199,
-0.5865730047225952,
0.22424668073654175,
0.1694929301738739,
0.14497263729572296,
0.34058284759521484,
-0.5252909064292908,
-0.955085277557373,
0.9611609578132629,
0.7386062741279602,
-0.5374323725700378,
0.10284413397312164,
-0.15403330326080322,
0.23460961878299713,
-0.283939927816391,
0.5460080504417419,
0.8219043612480164,
0.4986511468887329,
0.0372936986386776,
-0.7982555031776428,
-0.18995144963264465,
-0.21334515511989594,
-0.23323117196559906,
0.1730981171131134,
-0.7526431679725647,
0.6831545829772949,
-0.0750255361199379,
0.006928888615220785,
-0.23423586785793304,
0.6803927421569824,
0.3213120698928833,
0.06197231262922287,
0.8590608239173889,
0.35330668091773987,
0.8913499712944031,
0.08849218487739563,
0.9889580607414246,
-0.5667198300361633,
0.18814125657081604,
1.376798391342163,
-0.3948839604854584,
1.103507161140442,
0.1296951025724411,
-0.39606738090515137,
0.41804084181785583,
0.9522510170936584,
0.02869160659611225,
0.5522841811180115,
-0.05611729621887207,
-0.006274088751524687,
-0.5673160552978516,
0.03692042827606201,
-0.4962311387062073,
0.8679497241973877,
0.09893926978111267,
-0.05831614136695862,
0.10793579369783401,
-0.3842962086200714,
0.01018428336828947,
-0.21731621026992798,
-0.21994781494140625,
0.8198292255401611,
-0.2385970950126648,
-0.6368564367294312,
0.3410933315753937,
-0.40413665771484375,
0.6641690135002136,
-0.9610388875007629,
0.27462759613990784,
-0.2340228110551834,
0.16942481696605682,
-0.33344072103500366,
-0.40655308961868286,
0.17727109789848328,
0.04930870980024338,
-0.2817363440990448,
-0.19668754935264587,
0.8126427531242371,
-0.43563103675842285,
-0.26801660656929016,
0.5315214991569519,
0.5978651642799377,
0.10382091253995895,
-0.5849044322967529,
-0.48755744099617004,
0.1265047788619995,
0.2816516160964966,
-0.36133503913879395,
0.23135226964950562,
-0.011047790758311749,
0.08176270127296448,
0.6756927371025085,
0.9211657643318176,
0.5743069648742676,
0.05265489220619202,
-0.08609728515148163,
0.9857606887817383,
-0.49665775895118713,
-0.7259953618049622,
-0.7423127293586731,
0.2973517179489136,
-0.20247018337249756,
-0.395128071308136,
0.6004824042320251,
0.8078005909919739,
0.9815959930419922,
0.13891492784023285,
0.7803442478179932,
-0.08983012288808823,
0.5557679533958435,
-0.49503475427627563,
0.8535345196723938,
-0.2824033796787262,
0.13589590787887573,
-0.3692643344402313,
-1.2472912073135376,
-0.0010508425766602159,
0.5892152786254883,
-0.6463202834129333,
0.1561278998851776,
0.34891271591186523,
0.8319332599639893,
-0.43538108468055725,
0.3246927559375763,
0.017078323289752007,
0.2690970301628113,
0.2145809382200241,
0.33918607234954834,
0.5767844915390015,
-0.08156872540712357,
0.5254174470901489,
-0.4103344976902008,
-0.15804007649421692,
-0.1214308887720108,
-0.9030460715293884,
-0.9233383536338806,
-0.5555441975593567,
-0.25994011759757996,
0.054834648966789246,
0.06270868331193924,
1.0634448528289795,
1.4108660221099854,
-0.6129984259605408,
-0.16002587974071503,
-0.18623784184455872,
-0.028428765013813972,
0.003338510636240244,
-0.15851935744285583,
0.34309765696525574,
-0.40773066878318787,
-0.4877907633781433,
0.6035973429679871,
-0.15765094757080078,
-0.050559740513563156,
-0.012533925473690033,
-0.17659960687160492,
-0.4223414957523346,
-0.11806507408618927,
0.310945600271225,
0.28225770592689514,
0.1625785231590271,
0.03965817764401436,
-0.16466404497623444,
0.25296422839164734,
0.16904301941394806,
0.7308956384658813,
-0.9821549654006958,
0.6253911852836609,
0.5388239622116089,
0.613078773021698,
0.7993780970573425,
0.1483534723520279,
0.6977970004081726,
-0.6873529553413391,
0.3721299469470978,
0.025413144379854202,
0.4075533151626587,
0.4393448233604431,
-0.3557586669921875,
0.6906458139419556,
0.3179146945476532,
-0.642625093460083,
-0.785716712474823,
-0.0012584649957716465,
-0.5356217622756958,
-0.24574849009513855,
1.1135320663452148,
-0.0072539555840194225,
-0.007889533415436745,
-0.03335382416844368,
-0.11591023206710815,
0.18413493037223816,
-0.47932276129722595,
0.6867805123329163,
0.5479769110679626,
-0.36372485756874084,
0.2417096495628357,
-0.843898355960846,
0.7858113050460815,
0.569080114364624,
-0.997978687286377,
0.2761038541793823,
0.5028144121170044,
0.1776103526353836,
-0.33631470799446106,
0.4787449836730957,
0.21912384033203125,
0.11964357644319534,
-0.04735284298658371,
-0.007206730078905821,
-0.2441478818655014,
-0.40133136510849,
-0.03560345619916916,
-0.2729760408401489,
0.20279622077941895,
-0.2001982033252716
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.06032v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.06032v1
|
The Curse of Popularity: Popular Entities have Catastrophic Side Effects when Deleting Knowledge from Language Models
| 2024-06-10T05:50:23 | 2024-06-10T05:50:23 |
Ryosuke Takahashi, Go Kamoda, Benjamin Heinzerling, Keisuke Sakaguchi, Kentaro Inui
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Language models (LMs) encode world knowledge in their internal parameters
through training. However, LMs may learn personal and confidential information
from the training data, leading to privacy concerns such as data leakage.
Therefore, research on knowledge deletion from LMs is essential. This study
focuses on the knowledge stored in LMs and analyzes the relationship between
the side effects of knowledge deletion and the entities related to the
knowledge. Our findings reveal that deleting knowledge related to popular
entities can have catastrophic side effects. Furthermore, this research is the
first to analyze knowledge deletion in models trained on synthetic knowledge
graphs, indicating a new direction for controlled experiments.
|
[
-0.6217195391654968,
-0.8619107604026794,
0.2726261019706726,
-0.20172372460365295,
-0.11960490047931671,
0.03925255313515663,
-0.12523303925991058,
-0.5195546746253967,
0.2832666337490082,
0.9832908511161804,
-0.045718964189291,
-0.45822983980178833,
-0.7778959274291992,
-0.3629908859729767,
-0.8649311661720276,
1.3104819059371948,
-0.15577355027198792,
0.09385409951210022,
-0.37924841046333313,
-0.22279532253742218,
-0.4782816767692566,
-0.6446182131767273,
-0.8186730146408081,
-0.07115303725004196,
0.7050347924232483,
0.11156587302684784,
0.8753073215484619,
0.42030033469200134,
0.4241669178009033,
0.23362411558628082,
-0.3919717073440552,
0.04785389453172684,
-1.1145285367965698,
-0.058671507984399796,
-0.3918994963169098,
-0.5453891754150391,
-0.19738326966762543,
0.2823821008205414,
0.8062871694564819,
0.7644525170326233,
-0.2745572328567505,
-0.042565930634737015,
0.027969591319561005,
0.6498673558235168,
-0.4254322052001953,
0.13161590695381165,
-0.8193433284759521,
-0.02748880535364151,
-0.037768468260765076,
-0.12731635570526123,
-0.26324090361595154,
-0.8079877495765686,
0.3952649235725403,
-0.3615817725658417,
0.14150473475456238,
0.1129332110285759,
1.070141077041626,
0.10255604982376099,
-0.30779826641082764,
-0.69815993309021,
-0.9616443514823914,
0.7044402360916138,
-0.22992251813411713,
0.6044070720672607,
0.3842076063156128,
0.24428747594356537,
-0.13214881718158722,
-0.4874781668186188,
-0.4948369264602661,
-0.09159690886735916,
0.04152604192495346,
-0.27439796924591064,
-0.18499311804771423,
-0.025881130248308182,
0.12828943133354187,
0.28899720311164856,
-0.15534204244613647,
0.1396666169166565,
-0.8031525611877441,
-0.08818715810775757,
0.36166295409202576,
0.24728284776210785,
0.7548119425773621,
-0.3180943727493286,
-0.39767706394195557,
0.4070430397987366,
-1.1884452104568481,
-0.18570582568645477,
0.48122265934944153,
-0.056233618408441544,
0.10499952733516693,
0.43333637714385986,
0.12083597481250763,
0.5053113698959351,
-0.4783989489078522,
-0.2672063410282135,
0.17695972323417664,
0.1364501565694809,
-0.11531799286603928,
-0.026794105768203735,
0.7148328423500061,
0.3908388614654541,
0.8253141045570374,
-0.5778442025184631,
0.08925600349903107,
-0.35296639800071716,
0.13200925290584564,
-0.4166618883609772,
0.013378025032579899,
-0.0471007339656353,
-0.5413593649864197,
-0.2776041328907013,
-0.19683431088924408,
-0.48106685280799866,
-0.8007310032844543,
-0.2757517397403717,
0.36435630917549133,
-0.7238974571228027,
-0.3014063835144043,
0.07773242890834808,
-0.39184293150901794,
-0.15207387506961823,
0.27611586451530457,
-0.5187013745307922,
0.28651928901672363,
0.6645757555961609,
0.6487318277359009,
-0.36844900250434875,
-0.22356364130973816,
0.04399655759334564,
0.2529074251651764,
-0.2521924376487732,
0.36497414112091064,
-0.2467207908630371,
-0.5881855487823486,
-0.1611253172159195,
0.031439416110515594,
-0.26885727047920227,
-0.87273108959198,
0.1297478824853897,
-0.772477924823761,
0.16727076470851898,
-0.4619172215461731,
-1.0043092966079712,
-0.2616315186023712,
0.0213768407702446,
-0.7458969354629517,
0.20545274019241333,
-0.1501820832490921,
-0.8756231665611267,
0.3734511435031891,
-0.18574538826942444,
-0.39033204317092896,
0.060806989669799805,
-0.12519891560077667,
-0.4821154475212097,
0.014359623193740845,
-0.40329834818840027,
0.5020360946655273,
-0.10241073369979858,
0.35008394718170166,
-0.47125768661499023,
-0.39968591928482056,
0.5109360814094543,
-0.25329455733299255,
1.0028491020202637,
0.6044986248016357,
-0.0870174691081047,
-0.4399133324623108,
-0.8507249355316162,
-0.46174970269203186,
0.29005730152130127,
-0.47205692529678345,
-1.018622636795044,
0.1200496181845665,
-0.5386483073234558,
0.20670051872730255,
0.09218546003103256,
-0.5869558453559875,
0.09834141284227371,
-0.40328606963157654,
0.3342148959636688,
0.693263053894043,
0.7130457162857056,
0.5038968920707703,
-0.36285459995269775,
0.1674942821264267,
0.40006786584854126,
0.4671240746974945,
0.5646790862083435,
-0.6323964595794678,
-0.7143352627754211,
0.057346101850271225,
0.008859416469931602,
0.2659125328063965,
-0.5396183133125305,
-0.04871533438563347,
-0.10136493295431137,
-0.5076074004173279,
-0.2862519323825836,
0.29930785298347473,
0.3471764922142029,
0.3782949149608612,
0.012316000647842884,
-0.04710797592997551,
-0.3849101960659027,
-0.9870997071266174,
-0.6495739221572876,
0.15129099786281586,
0.19547656178474426,
0.5892375707626343,
0.42735427618026733,
-0.3050660490989685,
1.0852863788604736,
-0.6972507834434509,
-0.4374198317527771,
-0.28293195366859436,
-0.23907683789730072,
-0.32059532403945923,
0.4278092682361603,
0.8440954089164734,
-0.6397961974143982,
0.000438554649008438,
-0.2916589081287384,
-0.8346938490867615,
0.27198290824890137,
0.18870632350444794,
-0.04316458851099014,
0.14548470079898834,
0.006646052934229374,
-0.8070290088653564,
0.25661224126815796,
0.4155366122722626,
0.009212921373546124,
0.6037947535514832,
0.0983327254652977,
0.17788797616958618,
-1.0599251985549927,
-0.21072402596473694,
-0.08697705715894699,
-0.011763242073357105,
-0.5581424832344055,
-0.04200534150004387,
-0.1121324896812439,
-0.22508373856544495,
-0.6247308254241943,
0.6209398508071899,
-0.28462955355644226,
0.0352884940803051,
0.06536242365837097,
0.37025830149650574,
-0.10313502699136734,
0.11023575812578201,
0.15283939242362976,
0.347802072763443,
0.526239812374115,
-0.8999661803245544,
-0.018653899431228638,
0.06433212012052536,
-0.48809322714805603,
-0.018058139830827713,
-0.23483915627002716,
0.05688365921378136,
-0.5173760056495667,
-0.22203433513641357,
-0.7520474195480347,
-0.03176169469952583,
0.22209756076335907,
-0.14533750712871552,
0.13576681911945343,
-0.05228975787758827,
-0.4665311574935913,
-0.45152196288108826,
0.07945960760116577,
-0.18888072669506073,
0.5145642161369324,
-0.40235862135887146,
0.26140666007995605,
0.8823071122169495,
-0.08833593875169754,
-0.5357540249824524,
-0.7308335900306702,
-0.26738691329956055,
-0.4708697497844696,
-0.28807970881462097,
-0.280899316072464,
-0.09716964513063431,
-0.5223603248596191,
0.11173346638679504,
0.16433686017990112,
-0.19712267816066742,
0.10953287035226822,
0.5694090723991394,
-0.11084658652544022,
0.21414080262184143,
0.6788274049758911,
0.12235292792320251,
-0.04405223950743675,
0.2932448089122772,
0.14225292205810547,
0.6040021181106567,
0.00975717231631279,
-0.09312056005001068,
-0.2782081961631775,
0.12906619906425476,
0.6048498749732971,
-0.03864342346787453,
1.263224482536316,
0.061162978410720825,
-0.5007852911949158,
-0.4449714124202728,
-0.6908872723579407,
-0.04614407196640968,
-0.42916232347488403,
0.49626630544662476,
-0.13365566730499268,
-0.7374260425567627,
0.6007990837097168,
-0.1330760419368744,
0.07195619493722916,
0.2195950150489807,
0.24428844451904297,
-0.0038802805356681347,
0.952637791633606,
0.3999975323677063,
-0.23882105946540833,
0.5710655450820923,
-0.7268189787864685,
0.19459445774555206,
-0.38946446776390076,
-0.3305674195289612,
-0.2805061340332031,
-0.18270866572856903,
-0.41337868571281433,
-0.09012262523174286,
0.18690678477287292,
0.33304157853126526,
-0.2135034054517746,
0.2564220130443573,
-0.13647529482841492,
0.5994244813919067,
0.5093741416931152,
0.19716796278953552,
0.5046687722206116,
0.015680978074669838,
-0.03732338547706604,
-0.1614740639925003,
-0.5073925256729126,
-0.4717399477958679,
1.1713883876800537,
0.5239980220794678,
0.8851127624511719,
-0.17319859564304352,
1.0601783990859985,
0.053748197853565216,
0.24581274390220642,
-0.5184429287910461,
0.5948717594146729,
-0.12193305790424347,
-0.7499319911003113,
-0.14382006227970123,
-0.737766444683075,
-0.7240049242973328,
-0.31061112880706787,
-0.008257521316409111,
-0.9025862216949463,
0.16156817972660065,
0.33566343784332275,
-0.2534955143928528,
0.7570734024047852,
-0.9282270073890686,
0.6277779340744019,
-0.09287029504776001,
-0.1869250386953354,
-0.4442899227142334,
-0.11961831152439117,
0.6810454726219177,
-0.14311140775680542,
0.45777586102485657,
-0.06546605378389359,
0.37568989396095276,
1.157330870628357,
-0.4512912631034851,
0.7079126834869385,
-0.3924316465854645,
-0.052167996764183044,
0.7030256986618042,
0.5530246496200562,
0.6838685274124146,
0.12748222053050995,
-0.11133222281932831,
0.40732449293136597,
0.02708711475133896,
-0.14466390013694763,
-0.5399410128593445,
1.0130562782287598,
-1.074212670326233,
-0.6467063426971436,
0.024104710668325424,
-0.41097646951675415,
-0.12087537348270416,
0.08248937875032425,
0.3598288595676422,
0.3433975875377655,
-0.3201909363269806,
0.022923627868294716,
0.7007669806480408,
-0.6255370378494263,
0.400826096534729,
0.6508132815361023,
-0.6367103457450867,
-0.2801576852798462,
1.2932586669921875,
0.8162159323692322,
0.43632224202156067,
-0.144182950258255,
0.18137764930725098,
0.07468470185995102,
-0.7044227719306946,
0.13152100145816803,
0.4507424831390381,
-0.811436653137207,
0.19147968292236328,
-0.8204028606414795,
-0.4335767924785614,
-0.2727452218532562,
0.06969010829925537,
-0.8082553148269653,
-0.35112178325653076,
-0.47159653902053833,
-0.2718198299407959,
0.3724876046180725,
1.1870324611663818,
0.10988862067461014,
0.33135801553726196,
-0.7157770395278931,
-0.023745417594909668,
0.301750123500824,
0.5916012525558472,
0.21947868168354034,
-0.09488049894571304,
-0.46196451783180237,
-0.0542636439204216,
-0.2953062057495117,
-0.8943490982055664,
0.5536507368087769,
-0.15207961201667786,
0.5972049832344055,
0.8981136679649353,
-0.020583894103765488,
0.35612648725509644,
-0.07801976799964905,
0.6986033320426941,
0.11642041802406311,
-0.6642557382583618,
0.3676607608795166,
-0.3350711166858673,
0.018863826990127563,
0.25776809453964233,
0.9716459512710571,
-0.768622636795044,
-0.7674285173416138,
-0.8438227772712708,
-0.5794022679328918,
0.5364669561386108,
-0.007901037111878395,
0.17502474784851074,
-0.5152797102928162,
0.5943824052810669,
0.43419355154037476,
0.5374236106872559,
-0.5539038777351379,
-0.6708120703697205,
0.17572708427906036,
0.18178147077560425,
0.14200101792812347,
-0.4917541742324829,
0.05015511065721512,
-0.16309192776679993,
0.7029041051864624,
0.7296457886695862,
-0.0030271392315626144,
-0.2277165800333023,
-0.18928509950637817,
-0.2704806625843048,
0.23360222578048706,
0.2362927794456482,
0.7261930704116821,
-0.14396214485168457,
0.14715811610221863,
0.17408232390880585,
-0.4744189381599426,
-0.1938806027173996,
-0.37060415744781494,
-0.6365485191345215,
-0.25167959928512573,
0.04101194068789482,
0.6661276817321777,
0.25705769658088684,
-0.5573365092277527,
0.37405940890312195,
-0.010898909531533718,
-0.0413413904607296,
-0.5700295567512512,
0.2539881765842438,
0.33887261152267456,
-0.18514499068260193,
0.23206178843975067,
0.4363803267478943,
0.17398039996623993,
-0.5769692063331604,
0.33100569248199463,
0.3699096441268921,
-0.5712764859199524,
-0.33248087763786316,
0.427432119846344,
0.08545257896184921,
-0.2917530834674835,
0.5928369164466858,
-0.18950866162776947,
-0.3293067514896393,
0.4040023982524872,
0.3799755871295929,
0.3744136095046997,
-0.270938903093338,
0.4011416435241699,
0.1419592648744583,
0.005606100894510746,
0.08385682851076126,
-0.01838948205113411,
0.5052996277809143,
-0.9772810935974121,
0.17127685248851776,
-0.7084442973136902,
-0.0049768611788749695,
0.588609516620636,
-0.4398924708366394,
0.2134806215763092,
-0.753796398639679,
-0.28983983397483826,
-0.08081125468015671,
-0.14043541252613068,
-0.8747501373291016,
0.11549602448940277,
0.04903801158070564,
0.2897045314311981,
-0.7788586616516113,
0.7939603924751282,
0.1713167279958725,
-0.8219689726829529,
-1.0476775169372559,
-0.3195427358150482,
0.23020553588867188,
-0.92082279920578,
0.8754292130470276,
-0.15481552481651306,
0.23078852891921997,
0.19486187398433685,
-0.48134565353393555,
-1.1305785179138184,
0.6973554491996765,
0.4074748456478119,
-0.8892392516136169,
-0.0874311700463295,
0.4558134973049164,
0.46648022532463074,
-0.29425331950187683,
0.020249446853995323,
0.7402889728546143,
0.14791548252105713,
-0.08744847029447556,
-0.9391248226165771,
-0.09021961688995361,
0.19476868212223053,
-0.19391193985939026,
0.29997602105140686,
-0.6567862629890442,
1.1530396938323975,
-0.3115764260292053,
-0.4450778365135193,
-0.12078592926263809,
0.03249242901802063,
-0.03601875528693199,
0.06726829707622528,
0.3063164949417114,
0.7023755311965942,
0.7623175978660583,
0.09026986360549927,
0.9653422236442566,
-0.40941858291625977,
0.524734616279602,
0.9661783576011658,
-0.09892379492521286,
0.6092896461486816,
0.4212487041950226,
0.081572026014328,
0.6088574528694153,
0.44836434721946716,
0.29139718413352966,
0.4925421476364136,
0.45365241169929504,
-0.05561123415827751,
-0.03038097731769085,
0.05656660720705986,
-0.38835978507995605,
0.3998253047466278,
0.4016428291797638,
-0.9666568040847778,
-0.14068420231342316,
0.4829394519329071,
0.4088602364063263,
-0.10416050255298615,
-0.3765173852443695,
0.8211781978607178,
0.2657622992992401,
-0.4659228026866913,
0.565070390701294,
-0.32315248250961304,
0.1549433320760727,
-0.4324178993701935,
0.11088103801012039,
-0.18555817008018494,
0.3891012966632843,
-0.24055320024490356,
-0.7702551484107971,
0.44136396050453186,
-0.3812450170516968,
-0.1534859538078308,
0.18342599272727966,
0.8610072731971741,
-0.46423688530921936,
0.08515037596225739,
0.7387709617614746,
0.7070569396018982,
0.4413945972919464,
-0.15159158408641815,
-0.6113084554672241,
-0.08144871145486832,
0.04088147357106209,
-0.5769948959350586,
0.543772280216217,
0.2127036601305008,
-0.16149932146072388,
1.0760385990142822,
0.332106351852417,
0.5267958641052246,
0.2627760171890259,
0.4818550646305084,
0.9568282961845398,
-0.6500679850578308,
-0.3775622546672821,
-0.549842357635498,
0.2697138786315918,
-0.1383543759584427,
-0.188815176486969,
0.9740920066833496,
0.637799084186554,
0.5574431419372559,
-0.31697672605514526,
0.9445287585258484,
0.0687440037727356,
0.7942676544189453,
-0.2778126299381256,
1.4479209184646606,
-0.4493910074234009,
0.5914304256439209,
-0.34782347083091736,
-0.8968242406845093,
-0.0701693519949913,
0.021901318803429604,
-0.8764736652374268,
0.11075922846794128,
0.661941647529602,
0.8139165639877319,
0.2602987289428711,
0.19202589988708496,
0.3459140360355377,
0.6423611640930176,
0.18397901952266693,
0.3546569347381592,
0.913430392742157,
-0.15831081569194794,
0.6822245121002197,
-0.39069873094558716,
-0.05233580619096756,
-0.06451915204524994,
-0.21270157396793365,
-1.0688233375549316,
-0.6841451525688171,
-0.246242493391037,
-0.2746829390525818,
0.43034523725509644,
0.6560955047607422,
0.27330178022384644,
-0.9218814373016357,
-0.10487411916255951,
-0.01925402320921421,
0.609440267086029,
0.03725395351648331,
-0.35973140597343445,
0.3807818293571472,
-0.05098327621817589,
-0.5636852979660034,
-0.027294153347611427,
-0.020856844261288643,
0.3960791230201721,
-0.40229400992393494,
-0.2519158720970154,
-0.11751525849103928,
0.008302594535052776,
0.38267847895622253,
0.27746984362602234,
-0.7799509763717651,
-0.46694305539131165,
-0.3303406238555908,
-0.1514543890953064,
-0.28150030970573425,
0.7380806803703308,
-0.7931521534919739,
0.528222382068634,
0.6277855634689331,
0.11275272071361542,
0.2176969051361084,
-0.023108147084712982,
0.7564372420310974,
-0.7420964241027832,
-0.06931707262992859,
-0.06667868793010712,
0.5596517324447632,
0.2515377402305603,
-0.5398048162460327,
0.09411231428384781,
0.49713820219039917,
-0.5895273685455322,
-0.6857700943946838,
-0.006217715796083212,
-0.4495706856250763,
-0.5325965881347656,
1.3804374933242798,
-0.145572230219841,
-0.3692188560962677,
-0.4013518691062927,
-0.19531838595867157,
0.407261461019516,
-0.5276816487312317,
1.0079152584075928,
0.667283833026886,
-0.014565370976924896,
-0.012308640405535698,
-0.5841169357299805,
1.027095079421997,
-0.0032231640070676804,
-0.4258533716201782,
0.19597846269607544,
0.3963940441608429,
0.9414947628974915,
0.28720900416374207,
0.42374151945114136,
-0.28921863436698914,
0.007860037498176098,
0.07712863385677338,
0.24510763585567474,
-0.3057694435119629,
-0.3781304955482483,
-0.04344019666314125,
0.6054487228393555,
0.14624007046222687,
0.12222765386104584
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.06027v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.06027v1
|
HOLMES: Hyper-Relational Knowledge Graphs for Multi-hop Question Answering using LLMs
| 2024-06-10T05:22:49 | 2024-06-10T05:22:49 |
Pranoy Panda, Ankush Agarwal, Chaitanya Devaguptapu, Manohar Kaul, Prathosh A P
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Given unstructured text, Large Language Models (LLMs) are adept at answering
simple (single-hop) questions. However, as the complexity of the questions
increase, the performance of LLMs degrade. We believe this is due to the
overhead associated with understanding the complex question followed by
filtering and aggregating unstructured information in the raw text. Recent
methods try to reduce this burden by integrating structured knowledge triples
into the raw text, aiming to provide a structured overview that simplifies
information processing. However, this simplistic approach is query-agnostic and
the extracted facts are ambiguous as they lack context. To address these
drawbacks and to enable LLMs to answer complex (multi-hop) questions with ease,
we propose to use a knowledge graph (KG) that is context-aware and is distilled
to contain query-relevant information. The use of our compressed distilled KG
as input to the LLM results in our method utilizing up to $67\%$ fewer tokens
to represent the query relevant information present in the supporting
documents, compared to the state-of-the-art (SoTA) method. Our experiments show
consistent improvements over the SoTA across several metrics (EM, F1,
BERTScore, and Human Eval) on two popular benchmark datasets (HotpotQA and
MuSiQue).
|
[
-0.2574852705001831,
-1.3462077379226685,
1.0218123197555542,
0.10145033895969391,
-0.2827509939670563,
0.40313267707824707,
0.03921162337064743,
-0.39078035950660706,
0.2619320750236511,
0.4361957311630249,
-0.6174206137657166,
-0.48700854182243347,
-0.5839056372642517,
0.2701895833015442,
-0.2025178074836731,
0.7625194191932678,
0.05491269752383232,
-0.29872626066207886,
-0.5829876065254211,
-0.06572356075048447,
-0.14996856451034546,
-0.48562008142471313,
-0.46718060970306396,
-0.3261234760284424,
0.6569216847419739,
0.3440495431423187,
0.7365362048149109,
0.6656774878501892,
0.5531848669052124,
0.29006704688072205,
-0.4931866526603699,
0.3551107347011566,
-0.4411909282207489,
0.4897078573703766,
0.1156357154250145,
-0.29617783427238464,
-0.5286238193511963,
-0.2397191822528839,
0.517788827419281,
1.1761151552200317,
0.09661994874477386,
0.2679639756679535,
0.15317043662071228,
0.9255933165550232,
-0.6399283409118652,
0.4082971513271332,
-0.6741839647293091,
-0.1232532188296318,
-0.3730906546115875,
-0.690536379814148,
-0.22150501608848572,
-0.12362781912088394,
0.2127758264541626,
-0.8627592325210571,
-0.22329135239124298,
0.22568917274475098,
0.4562578499317169,
0.403520405292511,
-0.7969930171966553,
-0.20577466487884521,
-0.73321932554245,
0.4532529413700104,
-0.3228364586830139,
0.3392947018146515,
0.3424530029296875,
0.46516212821006775,
-0.3047617971897125,
-0.9162548184394836,
-0.6402038335800171,
0.333395779132843,
-0.22651594877243042,
0.3205660879611969,
-0.23843298852443695,
0.09645011276006699,
0.34987494349479675,
0.2081253081560135,
-0.6350085139274597,
-0.26152729988098145,
-0.18996715545654297,
-0.16388565301895142,
0.41892287135124207,
0.36865827441215515,
-0.027819903567433357,
-0.14424307644367218,
-0.3377767503261566,
0.1717517226934433,
-0.5849303603172302,
0.12682339549064636,
0.1460133194923401,
0.33722445368766785,
0.3831477165222168,
0.6060686111450195,
-0.5584352612495422,
0.9772806763648987,
-0.12916117906570435,
-0.38192933797836304,
0.2656368911266327,
-0.2300155758857727,
-0.16395287215709686,
-0.1656586080789566,
0.7268681526184082,
0.39424964785575867,
0.35630014538764954,
-0.2971476912498474,
0.22553284466266632,
-0.5265146493911743,
-0.19681914150714874,
-0.8523225784301758,
-0.09834049642086029,
0.4052383303642273,
-0.23872826993465424,
-0.024703675881028175,
-0.2823425829410553,
-0.8137375712394714,
-0.47326695919036865,
-0.3025641441345215,
0.2977215647697449,
-0.318893164396286,
-0.010859409347176552,
0.2225927859544754,
-0.2963551878929138,
0.0014264632482081652,
0.39963477849960327,
-0.5930242538452148,
0.2063414454460144,
0.262755811214447,
0.6554328203201294,
0.18409444391727448,
-0.25575509667396545,
-0.5743750333786011,
0.6341258883476257,
0.07742579281330109,
0.7696191668510437,
-0.5194398164749146,
-0.29061853885650635,
-0.02540360949933529,
-0.0657167136669159,
-0.024006348103284836,
-0.36607423424720764,
0.5072343945503235,
-1.0635722875595093,
0.17589861154556274,
-0.4254375100135803,
-0.7868785858154297,
-0.17480167746543884,
0.5892042517662048,
-0.5039764046669006,
1.0091636180877686,
-0.10505746304988861,
-1.133872389793396,
0.029746506363153458,
-0.5496751666069031,
-0.5797393321990967,
0.2813834547996521,
-0.07530710846185684,
-0.07579249888658524,
-0.23834757506847382,
0.4488537311553955,
0.5276390314102173,
-0.45710089802742004,
0.21238259971141815,
-0.47819796204566956,
-0.4951251149177551,
0.06130875647068024,
-0.36250486969947815,
0.8764649629592896,
0.19370748102664948,
0.10534627735614777,
-0.11434140056371689,
-0.7924144864082336,
0.16698642075061798,
0.3030488193035126,
-0.7584279179573059,
-0.6603412628173828,
0.07329390197992325,
-0.21368034183979034,
0.00016030749247875065,
0.20275941491127014,
-0.6125455498695374,
0.38696542382240295,
-0.05417198687791824,
0.4804362654685974,
0.4368438720703125,
0.19160161912441254,
0.10762666910886765,
-0.2109290212392807,
0.4325743019580841,
0.019908277317881584,
0.045348312705755234,
-0.1417025476694107,
-0.681583821773529,
-0.30820968747138977,
-0.2958466708660126,
0.09496720880270004,
0.5440328121185303,
-0.7619783282279968,
0.326801598072052,
-0.4400109052658081,
-0.2400224506855011,
-0.4489094614982605,
0.21333323419094086,
0.07351724058389664,
0.9900299310684204,
0.6782053112983704,
0.21661366522312164,
-0.45394015312194824,
-0.5882877111434937,
-0.47236549854278564,
-0.2979947328567505,
-0.06439053267240524,
0.33358854055404663,
0.2503678798675537,
-0.21124795079231262,
1.1509029865264893,
-0.7811979055404663,
-0.17596250772476196,
-0.24877586960792542,
0.005200283136218786,
0.316857248544693,
0.015000359155237675,
0.14416459202766418,
-0.847773551940918,
-0.6802796125411987,
-0.32794123888015747,
-0.8074617385864258,
-0.012931344099342823,
0.2675926089286804,
-0.2192101627588272,
-0.190067857503891,
0.7106344103813171,
-0.8335215449333191,
0.16538016498088837,
0.4620246887207031,
-0.21008138358592987,
0.40517130494117737,
-0.0585869699716568,
0.2133098840713501,
-1.0878814458847046,
0.21286693215370178,
-0.17177267372608185,
-0.37551403045654297,
-0.6229426860809326,
-0.03456839174032211,
0.049867354333400726,
-0.015888649970293045,
-0.28797388076782227,
0.4526476562023163,
-0.38407766819000244,
0.034677762538194656,
0.07300710678100586,
0.42016100883483887,
0.3289254307746887,
0.5630893707275391,
0.08040767908096313,
0.5597322583198547,
0.6014176607131958,
-0.5819141864776611,
0.4744487404823303,
0.3804455101490021,
-0.20799177885055542,
0.3502935469150543,
-0.7416632175445557,
0.31442004442214966,
-0.3845424950122833,
0.5087534189224243,
-1.175553560256958,
-0.11453263461589813,
0.01662752591073513,
-0.37286803126335144,
0.31002238392829895,
-0.5583205819129944,
-0.6236661672592163,
-0.3899136483669281,
-0.30296972393989563,
0.4353407919406891,
0.3459870517253876,
-0.39774221181869507,
0.5500687956809998,
0.38180336356163025,
-0.04486358165740967,
-0.7129572033882141,
-0.6253530979156494,
0.0010894464794546366,
-0.3287634551525116,
-0.7841160893440247,
0.33746710419654846,
-0.1942039281129837,
-0.24599941074848175,
0.17434191703796387,
-0.15307137370109558,
-0.2034282237291336,
0.20923514664173126,
-0.0016480813501402736,
0.0891345739364624,
-0.14664791524410248,
0.3171032667160034,
0.1744343787431717,
-0.09065739810466766,
0.04521274194121361,
-0.4137788414955139,
0.5497873425483704,
-0.16529278457164764,
-0.3999965786933899,
-0.3613447844982147,
0.2545570433139801,
0.8636274337768555,
-0.23585361242294312,
0.7324927449226379,
0.4044986367225647,
-0.19603121280670166,
0.2298961877822876,
-0.3027002513408661,
0.03763774409890175,
-0.41599398851394653,
0.25006017088890076,
-0.596098005771637,
-1.0922869443893433,
0.39045587182044983,
-0.42655038833618164,
-0.07721998542547226,
0.3327668607234955,
0.4903810918331146,
-0.6298015117645264,
0.9471971392631531,
0.24839870631694794,
-0.11464835703372955,
0.02238827385008335,
-0.20906494557857513,
0.2930839955806732,
-0.8861231207847595,
-0.3306427001953125,
-0.6461411118507385,
-0.21506239473819733,
-0.5351288318634033,
-0.25369158387184143,
0.7454440593719482,
0.4084022641181946,
-0.20712371170520782,
-0.011898161843419075,
-0.11056557297706604,
0.5848332047462463,
0.5580219626426697,
0.0908314436674118,
0.9441462159156799,
-0.03020472824573517,
0.058625634759664536,
0.25528860092163086,
-0.7807288765907288,
-0.36129894852638245,
1.2807337045669556,
0.12098589539527893,
0.7990668416023254,
0.3237275779247284,
0.5853965282440186,
0.03768585994839668,
-0.06491627544164658,
-0.8213022351264954,
0.37698620557785034,
0.17880141735076904,
-0.823266327381134,
-0.5827951431274414,
-0.6473529934883118,
-1.0995376110076904,
0.3395816385746002,
-0.17149971425533295,
-0.6484614610671997,
-0.21227334439754486,
0.21262772381305695,
-0.478299617767334,
0.35152390599250793,
-0.4739745855331421,
0.6248010396957397,
-0.09437582641839981,
-0.4138700067996979,
0.08712340891361237,
-0.9030483365058899,
0.39184877276420593,
-0.017701683565974236,
0.3378535509109497,
-0.15982656180858612,
0.18248997628688812,
0.6704263091087341,
-0.4974581301212311,
0.4486326277256012,
-0.3036144971847534,
0.2428349405527115,
0.4727654755115509,
0.11569669097661972,
0.6123290061950684,
0.1875363290309906,
0.028782257810235023,
-0.09112714976072311,
0.22919414937496185,
-0.5303573608398438,
-0.9050045609474182,
0.4050690829753876,
-0.5879610776901245,
-0.7318347692489624,
-0.2730141282081604,
-0.8848350048065186,
-0.7829838991165161,
0.3079526722431183,
0.017480704933404922,
0.5142925381660461,
0.25929275155067444,
0.447599321603775,
0.6818181276321411,
0.040450070053339005,
0.24684880673885345,
0.5051240921020508,
-0.3294243812561035,
0.023540601134300232,
0.3416064381599426,
0.1071559339761734,
0.13010916113853455,
0.6404272317886353,
0.42855578660964966,
-0.7471396923065186,
-0.72054523229599,
-0.5429903268814087,
0.17323578894138336,
-0.6920353770256042,
-0.2485012412071228,
-0.9555261731147766,
-0.018270069733262062,
-0.5184326171875,
0.22346682846546173,
-0.046077560633420944,
-0.5533282160758972,
0.12232151627540588,
-0.04413657635450363,
0.5926286578178406,
0.4690572917461395,
0.2984972894191742,
0.31986910104751587,
-0.9635217189788818,
0.3486765921115875,
0.5740547776222229,
0.2970424294471741,
-0.23980547487735748,
-0.5241720080375671,
-0.12047386169433594,
0.03285316005349159,
-0.11535093933343887,
-0.9413305521011353,
-0.07553394883871078,
0.08373025804758072,
0.4649302363395691,
0.15732285380363464,
0.35165756940841675,
0.9482243657112122,
-0.3111104667186737,
0.3638625144958496,
0.0000983541103778407,
-0.6459711194038391,
0.4710918068885803,
-0.47093382477760315,
0.2395196408033371,
0.9445840716362,
0.8103321194648743,
-0.5032793283462524,
-0.23528258502483368,
-0.3792184889316559,
-0.8313751816749573,
0.46318188309669495,
0.16080114245414734,
0.0010387221118435264,
0.046338729560375214,
0.3931864798069,
-0.2885715365409851,
0.3622124195098877,
-0.4006232023239136,
-0.4500750005245209,
0.06042645499110222,
-0.23030675947666168,
0.04530452564358711,
-0.33887529373168945,
-0.2573128640651703,
-0.44934797286987305,
0.5485680103302002,
-0.24187712371349335,
-0.0821719542145729,
0.32058051228523254,
-0.26854050159454346,
0.0351656936109066,
0.2883074879646301,
-0.059544552117586136,
0.6354480385780334,
-0.5061725974082947,
0.46539631485939026,
0.008589417673647404,
-0.346080482006073,
0.07670550793409348,
0.08782585710287094,
-0.18278393149375916,
-0.16847926378250122,
0.47709929943084717,
0.36382126808166504,
-0.2259826958179474,
-0.7295514941215515,
0.6228162050247192,
-0.1158088892698288,
-0.09223710745573044,
0.04675654321908951,
-0.24682143330574036,
0.5376024842262268,
0.21947401762008667,
0.32977306842803955,
-0.18218298256397247,
0.34653395414352417,
-0.7879766225814819,
0.10623607039451599,
0.31525591015815735,
-0.35162362456321716,
0.01753847301006317,
0.4800311326980591,
0.2901169955730438,
-0.09499454498291016,
0.8351942300796509,
-0.28502875566482544,
-0.4418726861476898,
0.25949379801750183,
0.5172848701477051,
0.3550875186920166,
0.09469883888959885,
-0.0034467566292732954,
0.16746197640895844,
0.20879778265953064,
0.16693106293678284,
0.2807774245738983,
-0.14373686909675598,
-0.6949836015701294,
-0.6222271919250488,
-0.6692045331001282,
-0.3924013078212738,
0.21453717350959778,
-0.5866262912750244,
-0.0184335894882679,
-0.2287909835577011,
-0.039823733270168304,
-0.083685003221035,
0.13244831562042236,
-0.6055490374565125,
0.06240592151880264,
-0.1880359947681427,
0.9473267793655396,
-0.8068269491195679,
0.822908878326416,
0.8100160360336304,
-0.42863816022872925,
-0.7714000344276428,
0.17314667999744415,
0.11273550242185593,
-0.8219080567359924,
0.44242483377456665,
-0.03286440670490265,
-0.2954756021499634,
0.34610509872436523,
-0.20187990367412567,
-0.8406539559364319,
1.3664851188659668,
0.2908884286880493,
-0.5627491474151611,
-0.01347841415554285,
0.22588172554969788,
0.46681734919548035,
0.011279130354523659,
0.4767540693283081,
0.7397214770317078,
0.6378118395805359,
0.5079740285873413,
-0.6038005948066711,
-0.008000696077942848,
-0.2175515592098236,
-0.33714836835861206,
0.14702071249485016,
-0.5666401386260986,
0.6102972626686096,
-0.19412192702293396,
-0.07534849643707275,
-0.32560208439826965,
0.37149515748023987,
0.44046658277511597,
0.47520551085472107,
0.547519862651825,
0.5718222856521606,
1.148885726928711,
0.013787021860480309,
1.0260928869247437,
-0.5094343423843384,
0.39353758096694946,
1.2437899112701416,
-0.3184775114059448,
0.5193839073181152,
0.6994775533676147,
-0.46922755241394043,
0.3646942675113678,
0.6682075262069702,
0.5393345355987549,
0.3161204755306244,
0.3176211714744568,
-0.09572236239910126,
-0.3597281575202942,
-0.12611956894397736,
-0.2362438142299652,
0.53106689453125,
0.08450992405414581,
0.08682873100042343,
-0.3727691173553467,
-0.467558890581131,
0.24552638828754425,
-0.006783332210034132,
-0.07888376712799072,
0.7082153558731079,
-0.14814706146717072,
-0.41240012645721436,
0.4479474127292633,
-0.17254365980625153,
0.34881383180618286,
-0.6437925100326538,
0.19023554027080536,
-0.547147274017334,
-0.20586630702018738,
-0.2370607554912567,
-0.9576104879379272,
0.36135998368263245,
0.05676286295056343,
-0.27902713418006897,
-0.1515648365020752,
0.6154307723045349,
-0.5009660720825195,
-0.3581943213939667,
0.41736939549446106,
1.0479304790496826,
0.30533745884895325,
-0.47468000650405884,
-0.5738387107849121,
-0.14969424903392792,
-0.22128507494926453,
-0.6236324906349182,
0.240030437707901,
0.7441682815551758,
0.09222853928804398,
0.7787174582481384,
0.6011541485786438,
-0.04919153079390526,
0.12450384348630905,
0.21298694610595703,
0.8827235102653503,
-0.5058342218399048,
-0.33955273032188416,
-0.8583046793937683,
0.47228002548217773,
-0.17909453809261322,
-0.13934078812599182,
0.7959157824516296,
0.7059947848320007,
0.6310330033302307,
0.37476250529289246,
0.8183782696723938,
-0.05881704017519951,
0.5803659558296204,
-0.5948652029037476,
0.5607736110687256,
-0.7432081699371338,
0.38287001848220825,
-0.4004986882209778,
-0.8804417252540588,
-0.3549138903617859,
0.08336140960454941,
-0.016001276671886444,
-0.08298919349908829,
0.8341074585914612,
0.6409903764724731,
-0.07166460156440735,
-0.022685730829834938,
0.2524700164794922,
0.23118719458580017,
0.31171107292175293,
0.5583627820014954,
0.9948157072067261,
-0.31678515672683716,
0.9520573019981384,
-0.2628166675567627,
-0.24271178245544434,
-0.11645786464214325,
-0.7318915128707886,
-0.683327317237854,
-0.5372322201728821,
-0.27400410175323486,
-0.21931542456150055,
-0.09151442348957062,
0.646584153175354,
0.6458681225776672,
-0.3613949716091156,
-0.11619839817285538,
0.014738192781805992,
0.3538188934326172,
-0.06122906133532524,
-0.16659387946128845,
0.6188058853149414,
-0.41068923473358154,
-0.6170997023582458,
0.5258904099464417,
0.427420437335968,
-0.07711977511644363,
-0.0026550807524472475,
-0.0024973894469439983,
-0.3994468152523041,
0.04478675127029419,
0.738498866558075,
-0.02215273305773735,
-0.3055155277252197,
-0.23877009749412537,
0.22424288094043732,
0.04527343437075615,
0.08780022710561752,
0.898066520690918,
-0.6838154792785645,
0.46901512145996094,
0.6004903316497803,
0.8795756697654724,
0.7056386470794678,
0.3111131191253662,
-0.04097544774413109,
-0.7697522044181824,
-0.06023415923118591,
0.22360123693943024,
0.3758581578731537,
0.08979679644107819,
-0.30989784002304077,
0.4825390577316284,
0.5121057629585266,
-0.47793683409690857,
-0.5501890182495117,
0.28550148010253906,
-1.091161847114563,
-0.5396995544433594,
1.1469132900238037,
-0.17762243747711182,
-0.16881097853183746,
-0.5774207711219788,
0.06269216537475586,
0.2139059603214264,
-0.17740504443645477,
0.5499494075775146,
0.6099072694778442,
-0.49526214599609375,
0.1616199016571045,
-0.4700942039489746,
0.36511456966400146,
0.2841024398803711,
-0.8299871683120728,
0.2753148376941681,
0.5636701583862305,
0.30951055884361267,
0.026063265278935432,
0.9904751181602478,
-0.10824327170848846,
-0.24600166082382202,
-0.18517626821994781,
-0.24086050689220428,
-0.4073498249053955,
-0.5821336507797241,
-0.07110519707202911,
0.4952084422111511,
0.12450972199440002,
-0.08086732029914856
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.06025v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.06025v1
|
RepoQA: Evaluating Long Context Code Understanding
| 2024-06-10T05:15:30 | 2024-06-10T05:15:30 |
Jiawei Liu, Jia Le Tian, Vijay Daita, Yuxiang Wei, Yifeng Ding, Yuhan Katherine Wang, Jun Yang, Lingming Zhang
|
cs.SE
|
cs.SE, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Recent advances have been improving the context windows of Large Language
Models (LLMs). To quantify the real long-context capabilities of LLMs,
evaluators such as the popular Needle in a Haystack have been developed to test
LLMs over a large chunk of raw texts. While effective, current evaluations
overlook the insight of how LLMs work with long-context code, i.e.,
repositories. To this end, we initiate the RepoQA benchmark to evaluate LLMs on
long-context code understanding. Traditional needle testers ask LLMs to
directly retrieve the answer from the context without necessary deep
understanding. In RepoQA, we built our initial task, namely Searching Needle
Function (SNF), which exercises LLMs to search functions given their
natural-language description, i.e., LLMs cannot find the desired function if
they cannot understand the description and code. RepoQA is multilingual and
comprehensive: it includes 500 code search tasks gathered from 50 popular
repositories across 5 modern programming languages. By evaluating 26 general
and code-specific LLMs on RepoQA, we show (i) there is still a small gap
between the best open and proprietary models; (ii) different models are good at
different languages; and (iii) models may understand code better without
comments.
|
[
-0.32705023884773254,
-0.3595505356788635,
0.7871570587158203,
0.09124812483787537,
-0.36346280574798584,
-0.055489979684352875,
-0.2252315729856491,
-0.4846673309803009,
-0.20186929404735565,
0.5319228768348694,
-0.507487952709198,
-0.636262059211731,
-0.4439760744571686,
0.437336266040802,
-0.404744416475296,
0.889037549495697,
-0.23526223003864288,
0.2826879918575287,
-0.4781498908996582,
-0.3155635893344879,
-0.3371316194534302,
-0.425433874130249,
-0.09103970974683762,
-0.22238148748874664,
0.4378919005393982,
0.3783932030200958,
0.2951118052005768,
0.556865394115448,
0.4480701684951782,
0.2676765024662018,
-0.31267109513282776,
-0.036549169570207596,
-0.5321367979049683,
0.16838398575782776,
-0.27807173132896423,
-0.28136080503463745,
0.021648652851581573,
-0.16636142134666443,
0.7642256617546082,
0.49040958285331726,
-0.1165306493639946,
0.3397711515426636,
-0.00320998253300786,
0.9774236083030701,
-0.88298100233078,
0.11916278302669525,
-0.46676933765411377,
-0.1724473088979721,
-0.012466774322092533,
0.11207590252161026,
-0.335342139005661,
-0.19522711634635925,
0.28462010622024536,
-0.5035632252693176,
-0.17635038495063782,
-0.21457818150520325,
0.743190586566925,
0.3483014702796936,
-0.6702884435653687,
-0.6120460629463196,
-0.27921929955482483,
0.8675311207771301,
-0.5887977480888367,
0.5027547478675842,
0.21868114173412323,
0.44757890701293945,
-0.3259879946708679,
-0.9016764163970947,
-0.36720022559165955,
-0.5052043199539185,
0.06990775465965271,
0.003274887567386031,
0.03904265537858009,
-0.10796298831701279,
0.35029488801956177,
0.615656852722168,
-0.39229434728622437,
-0.07066552340984344,
-0.2642627954483032,
-0.20058052241802216,
0.32606399059295654,
-0.06542183458805084,
0.08334401249885559,
-0.5421338677406311,
-0.7541278600692749,
0.1468873769044876,
-0.8076735138893127,
0.17785508930683136,
0.13137716054916382,
0.05110030248761177,
-0.021948331966996193,
0.4690517485141754,
-0.3313838243484497,
0.8992037177085876,
-0.4745664894580841,
0.053692977875471115,
0.19055242836475372,
-0.4616098999977112,
-0.35920485854148865,
-0.3049229681491852,
0.6176119446754456,
0.13299794495105743,
0.3537888526916504,
-0.15194232761859894,
-0.383640319108963,
-0.3427591323852539,
0.3999919295310974,
-0.9042176008224487,
0.1804683953523636,
0.36357471346855164,
-0.41672712564468384,
0.024899188429117203,
0.20596708357334137,
-0.36662790179252625,
-0.5882042646408081,
-0.3689790368080139,
0.43828845024108887,
-0.42262986302375793,
-0.006676852237433195,
0.15170720219612122,
-0.2647722661495209,
0.2761170566082001,
0.17100250720977783,
-0.1747937947511673,
0.10030335187911987,
1.0462167263031006,
0.7965325713157654,
-0.11902379989624023,
-0.4266831576824188,
-0.7029675841331482,
-0.06422078609466553,
-0.38293910026550293,
0.6440908908843994,
-0.33493852615356445,
-0.2442895621061325,
0.14970330893993378,
0.32825419306755066,
0.2127339392900467,
-0.6738230586051941,
0.3475639224052429,
-0.6520521640777588,
0.08860929310321808,
-0.35019806027412415,
-0.7046197056770325,
-0.26617762446403503,
0.35502222180366516,
-0.6903460025787354,
0.9524943828582764,
0.6186997294425964,
-0.7354890704154968,
0.34380078315734863,
-0.5506216883659363,
-0.15349718928337097,
0.05086365342140198,
-0.1096668541431427,
-0.2287360578775406,
0.0823933407664299,
0.10819527506828308,
0.37714189291000366,
-0.37366774678230286,
0.3058999478816986,
-0.2342318594455719,
-0.9766247272491455,
0.5183106064796448,
0.014587615616619587,
0.7921746373176575,
0.2783401310443878,
-0.4598166048526764,
0.1963973492383957,
-0.44925493001937866,
-0.0532805435359478,
-0.15862399339675903,
-0.30696240067481995,
-0.5920663475990295,
-0.09100275486707687,
-0.06560812890529633,
0.038567639887332916,
0.3435038626194,
-0.32577961683273315,
0.36312440037727356,
-0.34505605697631836,
0.7699418067932129,
0.6338859796524048,
-0.07945661246776581,
0.5954289436340332,
-0.16548322141170502,
0.6138995885848999,
-0.16171906888484955,
0.23180699348449707,
-0.4371430575847626,
-0.15509414672851562,
-0.638945996761322,
-0.4541197419166565,
0.4401272237300873,
0.35503119230270386,
-0.9697626233100891,
0.31254616379737854,
-0.09712515026330948,
-0.41083425283432007,
-0.5300605297088623,
0.2556758522987366,
0.6777936816215515,
0.3777816891670227,
0.30277135968208313,
-0.4348992705345154,
-0.47580644488334656,
-1.0736552476882935,
-0.45711714029312134,
-0.16143372654914856,
-0.27211451530456543,
0.5144266486167908,
0.7296605706214905,
-0.5210015773773193,
0.6050798892974854,
-0.1627829372882843,
-0.1589970886707306,
0.07186013460159302,
-0.08986697345972061,
0.5402835607528687,
0.1391582489013672,
0.2974024713039398,
-0.6102172136306763,
-0.13425301015377045,
0.025482989847660065,
-0.5722834467887878,
-0.17403355240821838,
-0.038099877536296844,
-0.11817757040262222,
0.4108646512031555,
0.5263190865516663,
-0.4028888940811157,
0.2647817134857178,
0.7445880770683289,
-0.305916965007782,
0.5859612226486206,
-0.08517033606767654,
0.2757394313812256,
-0.8961565494537354,
0.33234336972236633,
-0.19391512870788574,
-0.21821296215057373,
-0.30332517623901367,
0.7639707326889038,
0.7225437164306641,
0.0261381883174181,
-0.701198160648346,
0.6869615316390991,
-0.6683351993560791,
-0.5278167128562927,
-0.25239723920822144,
0.2196265012025833,
0.1435246467590332,
0.18810728192329407,
-0.0413808710873127,
1.140466332435608,
0.40894800424575806,
-0.5355528593063354,
0.047113675624132156,
-0.10574553906917572,
-0.7442349791526794,
0.2642418444156647,
-0.6245604753494263,
0.260154664516449,
0.12983080744743347,
0.3067116141319275,
-0.9213443398475647,
-0.07055571675300598,
0.07345622032880783,
-0.3516719341278076,
0.06999614834785461,
-0.4712117910385132,
-0.3260992169380188,
-0.38907483220100403,
-0.32818591594696045,
0.42509183287620544,
0.3862803876399994,
-0.6362176537513733,
0.4732387065887451,
0.37960490584373474,
0.19713757932186127,
-1.043428897857666,
-0.44782230257987976,
0.09474175423383713,
-0.22559738159179688,
-0.48485347628593445,
0.06603386998176575,
-0.0321180634200573,
-0.3416908383369446,
-0.37842240929603577,
-0.3514222502708435,
-0.41429048776626587,
0.33690041303634644,
0.23430538177490234,
0.11163093894720078,
-0.1854138970375061,
0.4850905239582062,
-0.11540786176919937,
-0.18383893370628357,
0.231594517827034,
-0.4236457943916321,
0.46796485781669617,
-0.4467834234237671,
-0.221967875957489,
-0.2355322688817978,
0.19592787325382233,
0.7596579194068909,
-0.1743346005678177,
0.4937182366847992,
0.3501564860343933,
-0.1747010201215744,
-0.18994903564453125,
-0.5836805105209351,
-0.08136413991451263,
-0.4727212190628052,
0.40377548336982727,
-0.4687452018260956,
-1.187543272972107,
0.6205528378486633,
0.027758974581956863,
-0.13282662630081177,
0.25427231192588806,
0.46386826038360596,
0.1340947449207306,
0.4518197774887085,
0.5881747603416443,
-0.0462665855884552,
0.36105403304100037,
-0.17205920815467834,
-0.021402867510914803,
-0.9742707014083862,
-0.11357172578573227,
-0.6898472905158997,
0.05896595120429993,
-0.6207888126373291,
-0.6835227608680725,
0.28255125880241394,
0.516316294670105,
-0.45981496572494507,
0.5703299045562744,
-0.6518818140029907,
0.6921955347061157,
0.486962229013443,
0.04343603923916817,
0.37518125772476196,
-0.3480309247970581,
-0.020952295511960983,
0.07580568641424179,
-0.5499915480613708,
-0.5832868218421936,
1.0448745489120483,
0.635655403137207,
0.5737056136131287,
-0.029080087319016457,
0.8550795912742615,
-0.11605122685432434,
0.5841957926750183,
-1.1368021965026855,
0.29067888855934143,
-0.12288662046194077,
-0.5294222235679626,
-0.44217365980148315,
-0.49099433422088623,
-0.9476373791694641,
0.12141598761081696,
0.24284568428993225,
-0.41698265075683594,
0.011176396161317825,
-0.1761912703514099,
-0.0848594680428505,
-0.07422880828380585,
-0.6254146695137024,
0.9909828901290894,
-0.033662594854831696,
-0.2353030890226364,
-0.044017352163791656,
-0.44556018710136414,
0.5496346950531006,
-0.1995251178741455,
0.5030969977378845,
-0.17704540491104126,
-0.43500837683677673,
0.5955010056495667,
-0.3218529224395752,
0.3506985604763031,
-0.049881141632795334,
-0.32171210646629333,
0.40955138206481934,
0.2944786250591278,
0.2981615364551544,
0.4796070456504822,
-0.24829111993312836,
0.3993096649646759,
0.43385225534439087,
-0.5134196281433105,
-0.46432703733444214,
0.6957632303237915,
-0.5500041246414185,
-0.5844681859016418,
-0.442440003156662,
-0.3170529901981354,
0.06682035326957703,
0.2119881808757782,
0.14318472146987915,
0.22386638820171356,
-0.12458830326795578,
0.34195569157600403,
0.45179128646850586,
-0.384640634059906,
0.36758819222450256,
0.7143892049789429,
-0.2945600152015686,
-0.2890070974826813,
0.33027154207229614,
-0.18238264322280884,
0.09492843598127365,
0.3125573396682739,
0.30265992879867554,
-0.4041401445865631,
-0.38422006368637085,
-0.5192005634307861,
0.21989494562149048,
-0.8879579901695251,
-0.3720347285270691,
-0.29961535334587097,
-0.07624175399541855,
-0.20868071913719177,
0.09258542954921722,
-0.3821428716182709,
-0.09223403036594391,
-0.1443081796169281,
0.2722378969192505,
0.4550577402114868,
0.8847576379776001,
0.2184986025094986,
-0.054704099893569946,
-1.0323070287704468,
0.2542772889137268,
0.4075094759464264,
0.6608001589775085,
-0.06577105075120926,
-0.588342547416687,
-0.410801500082016,
-0.11220953613519669,
0.0029869608115404844,
-0.9773313999176025,
0.19805170595645905,
-0.12965737283229828,
0.44746366143226624,
0.1442532241344452,
0.1440034955739975,
0.686851441860199,
-0.5752969980239868,
0.7613244652748108,
-0.030937785282731056,
-1.392962098121643,
0.2948918342590332,
-0.2734646499156952,
0.5608726143836975,
0.5967167615890503,
0.37756040692329407,
-0.7798826694488525,
-0.3812757134437561,
-0.19889655709266663,
-0.757972776889801,
0.352609783411026,
0.06383536010980606,
0.08308594673871994,
-0.08745503425598145,
0.6425811648368835,
0.2701808512210846,
0.1486736238002777,
-0.7867699861526489,
0.0929126888513565,
-0.021643370389938354,
0.15923668444156647,
-0.1365465521812439,
-0.2518937885761261,
-0.260373055934906,
-0.18160296976566315,
0.14490540325641632,
-0.30235645174980164,
0.17987720668315887,
0.3146067261695862,
-0.1781764030456543,
0.023824650794267654,
0.4086691737174988,
0.6102839112281799,
1.0944973230361938,
-0.12840086221694946,
0.05484906956553459,
0.2806524932384491,
-0.32282665371894836,
-0.07045383006334305,
-0.017051730304956436,
0.14779025316238403,
-0.01999138854444027,
0.5040901899337769,
0.37908464670181274,
0.4545256197452545,
-1.0003724098205566,
0.7440180778503418,
-0.2625138461589813,
-0.18216489255428314,
-0.5172346830368042,
0.07952343672513962,
0.33268606662750244,
0.41560158133506775,
0.5556533932685852,
-0.4339298605918884,
0.4312698245048523,
-0.6254271864891052,
0.531915009021759,
0.4520101547241211,
-0.5765918493270874,
0.19272014498710632,
0.18759657442569733,
0.12471796572208405,
-0.43535059690475464,
0.5587572455406189,
0.007074194494634867,
-0.6275972127914429,
0.9563982486724854,
0.21592006087303162,
0.8543869853019714,
0.006837313063442707,
-0.04740554839372635,
0.3777407109737396,
0.23188069462776184,
-0.009896003641188145,
0.2487604171037674,
-0.215409055352211,
-0.38936647772789,
-0.7984959483146667,
-0.489384263753891,
-0.5676235556602478,
0.1931321769952774,
-0.8720503449440002,
0.3352985084056854,
-0.16962166130542755,
0.05835448578000069,
-0.36789700388908386,
0.18229307234287262,
-0.5338143706321716,
-0.0014702092157676816,
-0.09319300204515457,
1.3444374799728394,
-0.4482150971889496,
0.9712095260620117,
0.4895876944065094,
-0.05179987847805023,
-0.616462230682373,
0.036919042468070984,
-0.2312431037425995,
-0.837653398513794,
0.5909376740455627,
0.6387093663215637,
-0.013204904273152351,
-0.3052244484424591,
-0.6574817895889282,
-0.8649770021438599,
1.0999926328659058,
0.22220377624034882,
-0.838768482208252,
0.24957555532455444,
-0.3211589753627777,
0.5801103115081787,
-0.37849730253219604,
0.4041494131088257,
0.6472296118736267,
0.4607826769351959,
-0.10870817303657532,
-0.9714452624320984,
0.05403309315443039,
-0.16987726092338562,
0.10858405381441116,
0.3987869620323181,
-0.379680871963501,
0.9382456541061401,
-0.15417735278606415,
-0.2197992205619812,
0.5348883867263794,
0.42524778842926025,
0.6992888450622559,
0.47694769501686096,
0.565800130367279,
0.21118929982185364,
0.5342147350311279,
-0.14170360565185547,
1.282932996749878,
-0.4219178855419159,
0.5162174105644226,
1.03742516040802,
-0.23061606287956238,
1.0864975452423096,
0.7456859350204468,
-0.045284997671842575,
0.6312438249588013,
0.7728388905525208,
0.20155556499958038,
0.29976513981819153,
0.7359834313392639,
-0.04945400357246399,
-0.22977186739444733,
0.13320572674274445,
-0.5903465747833252,
0.3702434003353119,
0.15590660274028778,
-0.32925915718078613,
-0.03281696140766144,
-0.14165331423282623,
-0.20207425951957703,
0.24274156987667084,
-0.16686025261878967,
0.6774640679359436,
0.20906047523021698,
-0.785266637802124,
0.8783033490180969,
-0.07520695775747299,
0.5431098341941833,
-0.4828343987464905,
-0.12792250514030457,
-0.28801867365837097,
0.20518776774406433,
0.10528077185153961,
-0.9277235865592957,
0.19940730929374695,
-0.04642311483621597,
0.03044217824935913,
-0.011775299906730652,
0.4430088400840759,
-0.1633785218000412,
-0.0941508561372757,
0.618776261806488,
0.4657444953918457,
0.2838803231716156,
-0.25938650965690613,
-0.7740437388420105,
0.11684156209230423,
-0.218036949634552,
-0.3863544464111328,
0.34768348932266235,
0.6158865690231323,
0.011874954216182232,
0.7683979868888855,
0.6004999876022339,
-0.218175008893013,
-0.41028711199760437,
0.045642655342817307,
0.8711270689964294,
-0.8994783163070679,
-0.40862998366355896,
-0.7108100652694702,
0.44819512963294983,
0.011173590086400509,
-0.5670105814933777,
0.6642605662345886,
0.48124074935913086,
0.9278680682182312,
-0.17445673048496246,
0.3530697822570801,
0.3181765079498291,
0.6656094789505005,
-0.7540858387947083,
0.8138750791549683,
-0.7393655776977539,
0.373102068901062,
-0.1543276607990265,
-1.0195084810256958,
-0.23065489530563354,
0.7325345277786255,
-0.27593421936035156,
-0.05200563371181488,
0.8148623108863831,
0.6366584897041321,
0.3206336796283722,
-0.1657657027244568,
0.26875025033950806,
-0.027154669165611267,
0.0038303511682897806,
0.9113259315490723,
1.3792058229446411,
-0.5559857487678528,
0.5010308623313904,
-0.22748839855194092,
-0.22845563292503357,
-0.18474525213241577,
-1.1461535692214966,
-1.0267070531845093,
-0.5318372845649719,
-0.01578696258366108,
-0.5099193453788757,
0.07549586147069931,
0.6505532264709473,
0.6390712261199951,
-0.7897900342941284,
-0.585852861404419,
-0.06884937733411789,
0.4864102900028229,
-0.13246098160743713,
-0.2195463478565216,
0.2594505846500397,
-0.4354109764099121,
-0.7678754329681396,
0.43246594071388245,
0.31577593088150024,
-0.20612047612667084,
-0.41026297211647034,
-0.3869350850582123,
-0.0008850080776028335,
-0.1592729538679123,
0.5265119075775146,
0.17065845429897308,
-0.8501839637756348,
-0.3496677577495575,
0.33791664242744446,
-0.48471197485923767,
0.020737161859869957,
0.9621907472610474,
-0.9368314743041992,
0.44822320342063904,
0.522864580154419,
0.5660565495491028,
0.3412064015865326,
-0.1651386320590973,
0.647050678730011,
-0.3713752329349518,
0.1169331818819046,
0.28293922543525696,
0.3405694365501404,
0.1606707125902176,
-0.2652534246444702,
0.7525885701179504,
-0.19008614122867584,
-0.837509036064148,
-0.9476076364517212,
0.28311464190483093,
-0.7275547385215759,
-0.9033772945404053,
1.233625888824463,
-0.312335342168808,
-0.4506787955760956,
-0.24929408729076385,
-0.13349047303199768,
0.238742396235466,
-0.17745639383792877,
0.8472641110420227,
0.687540590763092,
0.24828919768333435,
-0.13277170062065125,
-0.6020702123641968,
0.5190733075141907,
0.3865378201007843,
-0.6562848091125488,
0.07481706142425537,
0.44475752115249634,
0.32341527938842773,
0.09584532678127289,
0.5286874175071716,
-0.17479464411735535,
0.5572865605354309,
-0.4055037498474121,
0.000485516939079389,
-0.12130177021026611,
-0.38844209909439087,
-0.7617821097373962,
-0.005285469815135002,
0.13160939514636993,
-0.04879803583025932
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.06648v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.06648v1
|
SignBLEU: Automatic Evaluation of Multi-channel Sign Language Translation
| 2024-06-10T05:01:26 | 2024-06-10T05:01:26 |
Jung-Ho Kim, Mathew Huerta-Enochian, Changyong Ko, Du Hui Lee
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Sign languages are multi-channel languages that communicate information
through not just the hands (manual signals) but also facial expressions and
upper body movements (non-manual signals). However, since automatic sign
language translation is usually performed by generating a single sequence of
glosses, researchers eschew non-manual and co-occurring manual signals in favor
of a simplified list of manual glosses. This can lead to significant
information loss and ambiguity. In this paper, we introduce a new task named
multi-channel sign language translation (MCSLT) and present a novel metric,
SignBLEU, designed to capture multiple signal channels. We validated SignBLEU
on a system-level task using three sign language corpora with varied linguistic
structures and transcription methodologies and examined its correlation with
human judgment through two segment-level tasks. We found that SignBLEU
consistently correlates better with human judgment than competing metrics. To
facilitate further MCSLT research, we report benchmark scores for the three
sign language corpora and release the source code for SignBLEU at
https://github.com/eq4all-projects/SignBLEU.
|
[
-0.2927188277244568,
-0.31224846839904785,
0.49223044514656067,
0.433564692735672,
-0.42359358072280884,
0.17911198735237122,
-0.09497962146997452,
-0.5691015720367432,
0.425019234418869,
0.31444260478019714,
-0.38725951313972473,
-0.4642702043056488,
-0.8257794976234436,
0.0572378896176815,
-0.284848153591156,
0.998114824295044,
-0.28163793683052063,
0.289089560508728,
0.26438623666763306,
-0.46737372875213623,
-0.41869258880615234,
-0.26275569200515747,
-0.5416839718818665,
-0.06802673637866974,
0.24311195313930511,
0.5537033677101135,
0.5960961580276489,
-0.05461588874459267,
0.8153892159461975,
0.28931745886802673,
0.38075631856918335,
0.04684954136610031,
-0.09806174784898758,
0.031982749700546265,
0.2970786690711975,
-0.2094753533601761,
-0.6739171743392944,
0.1869170069694519,
0.8983925580978394,
0.6254203915596008,
0.27239394187927246,
0.5102289319038391,
-0.1112336739897728,
0.5889096260070801,
-0.38912203907966614,
0.14226505160331726,
-0.15524736046791077,
-0.07725463807582855,
-0.2419375777244568,
-0.015079032629728317,
-0.43877533078193665,
-0.41646385192871094,
-0.2558397352695465,
-0.4972538650035858,
0.033139824867248535,
-0.02034572884440422,
0.35280442237854004,
0.40046003460884094,
-0.7522632479667664,
-0.37192222476005554,
-0.6500232219696045,
0.7168731689453125,
-0.6465996503829956,
1.0458528995513916,
0.2179657518863678,
0.29478561878204346,
-0.012131371535360813,
-0.39603322744369507,
-0.4304971396923065,
-0.6208312511444092,
-0.06345053762197495,
0.34032556414604187,
-0.05305952951312065,
0.03560628369450569,
0.3286670446395874,
-0.07009518146514893,
-0.5639104247093201,
-0.2712155282497406,
-0.4579225778579712,
-0.39730826020240784,
0.6902688145637512,
-0.2887319326400757,
0.5386954545974731,
-0.2562699019908905,
-0.5241427421569824,
-0.17166800796985626,
-0.3456861972808838,
0.036260079592466354,
0.35771045088768005,
0.37922367453575134,
-0.2764488458633423,
0.5532986521720886,
-0.17746253311634064,
0.6891264915466309,
-0.16157357394695282,
-0.24752120673656464,
0.41353273391723633,
-0.43385565280914307,
0.04884229227900505,
0.11080173403024673,
0.948482096195221,
0.10488449782133102,
-0.13995981216430664,
-0.1588362455368042,
-0.35869184136390686,
0.26566824316978455,
0.08697208762168884,
-0.3574719727039337,
-0.07569938898086548,
0.12614940106868744,
-0.38601529598236084,
0.018559006974101067,
0.2600458264350891,
-0.3235556185245514,
-0.1581234633922577,
-0.3842243552207947,
0.2177913337945938,
-0.525924563407898,
-0.5430420637130737,
-0.10548106580972672,
-0.1300954520702362,
0.2189413458108902,
0.3655511140823364,
-0.2827255129814148,
0.5055834650993347,
0.348398357629776,
0.8681252598762512,
-0.36538946628570557,
-0.3796091079711914,
-0.81519615650177,
-0.0835554450750351,
-0.04246130585670471,
0.5450026392936707,
-0.27038609981536865,
-0.12125445157289505,
-0.5815877914428711,
-0.10637801885604858,
-0.2720211446285248,
0.0032422158401459455,
0.6463786363601685,
-0.472898930311203,
-0.17127449810504913,
-0.016175702214241028,
-0.18135587871074677,
-0.023983988910913467,
0.048549242317676544,
-0.8582247495651245,
0.9001542925834656,
0.029027484357357025,
-0.17701707780361176,
0.2992843985557556,
-0.7673878073692322,
-0.6612723469734192,
0.128082737326622,
-0.16628988087177277,
-0.4471724331378937,
0.12178134173154831,
-0.05879170447587967,
0.35290029644966125,
0.07959558814764023,
-0.01817876659333706,
-0.17396290600299835,
0.014108334667980671,
0.5722668766975403,
-0.25887584686279297,
0.6600974798202515,
0.30582642555236816,
-0.7074225544929504,
0.16003111004829407,
-0.8390604853630066,
0.08345401287078857,
-0.25653254985809326,
-0.2678254544734955,
-0.22445420920848846,
-0.2106420397758484,
0.30639132857322693,
0.6123115420341492,
0.12184584885835648,
-0.8518788814544678,
-0.0011736097512766719,
0.2394191324710846,
0.3178707957267761,
0.27884870767593384,
-0.17400208115577698,
0.293737530708313,
-0.008417374454438686,
0.5528650283813477,
-0.13280992209911346,
0.3560887575149536,
0.16733059287071228,
-0.9234874248504639,
-0.7104647159576416,
-0.2507804334163666,
0.04507402703166008,
0.4710668921470642,
-0.5545323491096497,
0.09301197528839111,
-0.12491881102323532,
-0.4147537350654602,
-0.5866811871528625,
0.26764407753944397,
0.7737152576446533,
-0.027867605909705162,
0.4834256172180176,
-0.6435816287994385,
-0.2826880216598511,
-0.6363677382469177,
-0.2229873389005661,
-0.16719308495521545,
0.10666032135486603,
-0.12944065034389496,
0.42509767413139343,
0.15994428098201752,
0.248654305934906,
-0.19976761937141418,
-0.6364174485206604,
-0.04472578689455986,
0.24704313278198242,
-0.08268389105796814,
0.3726731240749359,
0.21932220458984375,
-0.9230135083198547,
-0.3410392999649048,
0.06375420093536377,
-0.5128791928291321,
-0.04396910220384598,
-0.5523624420166016,
-0.10283780097961426,
-0.11922625452280045,
0.5793893933296204,
-0.5681462287902832,
0.15512508153915405,
0.9004476070404053,
-0.5498068928718567,
0.6111087203025818,
-0.08644092828035355,
0.6461084485054016,
-0.7542593479156494,
0.21554119884967804,
0.011281096376478672,
-0.37740418314933777,
-0.6901723146438599,
0.36310768127441406,
0.49775612354278564,
-0.19296683371067047,
-0.7415331602096558,
0.4001100957393646,
-0.9256682991981506,
-0.49969950318336487,
0.023147309198975563,
0.6930307745933533,
-0.1930047869682312,
0.408870130777359,
-0.06368498504161835,
0.3758732080459595,
0.4044156074523926,
-0.6992986798286438,
0.4121144711971283,
0.27830770611763,
-0.29799121618270874,
0.8216406106948853,
-0.2447749823331833,
0.34354451298713684,
0.22452807426452637,
0.18537834286689758,
-1.2235898971557617,
0.04304201528429985,
0.23739100992679596,
-0.7424832582473755,
0.2722948491573334,
0.10695543140172958,
-0.24081557989120483,
-0.23942196369171143,
-0.11429352313280106,
0.5609159469604492,
0.09217920154333115,
-0.22658349573612213,
0.4066168963909149,
0.41201654076576233,
0.25502267479896545,
-0.360251784324646,
-0.8205965757369995,
0.18927055597305298,
0.06921875476837158,
-0.36572080850601196,
-0.06965852528810501,
-0.19106242060661316,
0.02993983030319214,
-0.31966790556907654,
-0.2745248079299927,
0.16152463853359222,
0.06736381351947784,
0.3005899488925934,
0.2710177004337311,
-0.1974707394838333,
-0.04558299481868744,
-0.05804995819926262,
-0.289101779460907,
0.027385780587792397,
-0.42224326729774475,
0.19132722914218903,
-0.4229690730571747,
-0.9860203266143799,
-0.6076629161834717,
0.27483031153678894,
0.8390143513679504,
-0.4809494614601135,
0.17671175301074982,
0.7405252456665039,
-0.3053244352340698,
0.21313783526420593,
-0.3797474503517151,
0.049932051450014114,
-0.37248632311820984,
0.1269448697566986,
-0.7261002659797668,
-0.5903229117393494,
0.36335480213165283,
-0.06163632124662399,
0.17375537753105164,
0.3528642952442169,
0.38852736353874207,
0.16121827065944672,
1.2659250497817993,
0.20186126232147217,
0.2162790596485138,
0.44700756669044495,
-0.04637153819203377,
0.33558011054992676,
-0.9395217299461365,
-0.2546370029449463,
-0.421421617269516,
-0.45070236921310425,
-0.3334152400493622,
-0.5765650272369385,
0.23805451393127441,
0.3007403016090393,
0.19308888912200928,
1.0189552307128906,
-0.6585528254508972,
0.08587605506181717,
0.3392346501350403,
0.060950253158807755,
0.6640990376472473,
-0.4312157928943634,
-0.28349795937538147,
0.010021157562732697,
-0.3712744116783142,
-0.7463968396186829,
1.0491427183151245,
0.23251035809516907,
0.4197480380535126,
0.6565068960189819,
0.7777546644210815,
0.2783029079437256,
0.7774881720542908,
-0.8776342868804932,
0.7126042246818542,
-0.030886521562933922,
-0.5828804969787598,
-0.37469348311424255,
-0.4682838022708893,
-0.8691685795783997,
0.35415029525756836,
-0.3726741075515747,
-0.5761488080024719,
-0.03141854330897331,
0.1823396533727646,
0.014285591430962086,
0.21819694340229034,
-0.7722476124763489,
0.8345750570297241,
-0.7652655243873596,
0.15265585482120514,
-0.18246851861476898,
-0.7399148941040039,
0.5286843776702881,
-0.2880414128303528,
0.6090657711029053,
-0.41957443952560425,
-0.2537026107311249,
0.8179813623428345,
0.018386438488960266,
0.8150626420974731,
-0.0746103897690773,
-0.20164041221141815,
0.06320272386074066,
0.24039246141910553,
0.23219071328639984,
0.09744516015052795,
-0.06274121254682541,
0.19411569833755493,
0.2872377932071686,
-0.42948609590530396,
-0.3694055676460266,
0.7092446088790894,
-0.6502567529678345,
0.09188631922006607,
-0.4305777847766876,
-0.2710621654987335,
-0.2844644784927368,
0.48157066106796265,
0.15469497442245483,
0.4239632487297058,
-0.7368746995925903,
-0.4463042616844177,
0.33412837982177734,
0.14712387323379517,
0.24815578758716583,
0.6165623068809509,
-0.13888484239578247,
-0.4246589243412018,
0.9943152666091919,
-0.2898620367050171,
0.7384880185127258,
0.5475117564201355,
-0.05442483350634575,
-0.3683306872844696,
-0.5686841607093811,
-0.8530759811401367,
0.40096375346183777,
-0.7421922087669373,
-0.20274873077869415,
-0.2742707133293152,
0.3179028630256653,
-0.6481775641441345,
0.11156070977449417,
-0.3905002176761627,
-0.7184520959854126,
0.06709689646959305,
0.06632741540670395,
-0.12925110757350922,
0.7759423851966858,
-0.028079470619559288,
0.13927339017391205,
-0.9446194171905518,
0.7072879076004028,
0.13770249485969543,
0.389723002910614,
-0.34472671151161194,
-0.08625887334346771,
-0.061742037534713745,
0.09869040548801422,
-0.26350367069244385,
-1.1773624420166016,
-0.0028916250448673964,
0.3011249899864197,
0.8390703201293945,
0.393444687128067,
0.14692378044128418,
0.394336462020874,
-0.33143413066864014,
0.5921407341957092,
0.9543424248695374,
-1.1818559169769287,
0.5277369022369385,
-0.026029473170638084,
0.5790393948554993,
0.6284362077713013,
0.4185103476047516,
-0.9646876454353333,
-0.9637953639030457,
-0.5355949997901917,
-0.47568297386169434,
0.5431599020957947,
0.5558832287788391,
-0.16577483713626862,
-0.22547568380832672,
-0.16394741833209991,
-0.03963933885097504,
0.06560444831848145,
-0.49830836057662964,
-0.40040987730026245,
-0.30976954102516174,
-0.25738805532455444,
-0.25501731038093567,
0.611732542514801,
-0.16153396666049957,
-0.12026714533567429,
0.6044691205024719,
-0.27844011783599854,
0.4562186300754547,
0.22534795105457306,
-0.7351454496383667,
-0.12452592700719833,
0.40878382325172424,
0.8381956219673157,
0.4954947531223297,
0.050245702266693115,
0.41855138540267944,
0.17197273671627045,
-0.8867617249488831,
0.26763197779655457,
0.10386639833450317,
-0.053237903863191605,
0.17031118273735046,
0.4344593584537506,
0.8880078196525574,
0.4462319016456604,
-0.5380751490592957,
0.5403013825416565,
-0.3397751450538635,
-0.3089107573032379,
-0.15443925559520721,
-0.25589004158973694,
0.018488146364688873,
0.10717508941888809,
0.20643453299999237,
0.4045649468898773,
0.07580447196960449,
-0.4458496570587158,
0.3297085165977478,
0.46365925669670105,
-0.6808522939682007,
-0.4151148200035095,
0.8396613001823425,
0.4876435697078705,
-0.45040273666381836,
0.461249440908432,
-0.4071934223175049,
-0.48075827956199646,
0.46767860651016235,
0.3238829970359802,
0.8359814286231995,
-0.45830202102661133,
0.4548768997192383,
0.43052491545677185,
0.5492718815803528,
-0.06387032568454742,
0.28554266691207886,
-0.3411952555179596,
-0.5538994669914246,
-0.4421245753765106,
-0.7122994661331177,
-0.47650694847106934,
-0.2162269502878189,
-0.663060188293457,
0.3248896896839142,
-0.30442720651626587,
-0.40478891134262085,
0.12177576124668121,
-0.20454388856887817,
-0.7172906398773193,
0.25009235739707947,
0.5275617241859436,
0.7386317849159241,
-1.0504437685012817,
0.7696982026100159,
0.8398234844207764,
-0.45810556411743164,
-0.7250066995620728,
-0.18147002160549164,
0.21977178752422333,
-0.5960163474082947,
0.560508131980896,
0.11583727598190308,
-0.6944107413291931,
0.23737847805023193,
0.002979204524308443,
-1.1340513229370117,
0.7423616647720337,
0.2945685088634491,
-0.4156739413738251,
0.249056875705719,
0.3121664822101593,
0.32798394560813904,
-0.23200394213199615,
0.36262521147727966,
0.7119988799095154,
0.7681179642677307,
-0.059037014842033386,
-1.2873375415802002,
0.5242153406143188,
-0.25470149517059326,
-0.2264687418937683,
0.6513187289237976,
-0.5353989601135254,
0.24793094396591187,
-0.500413715839386,
-0.4783632457256317,
0.04025132581591606,
0.6767348647117615,
0.22606074810028076,
0.3323209285736084,
0.5611993074417114,
0.3315331041812897,
0.7987875938415527,
-0.11575418710708618,
0.6232179999351501,
-0.35702094435691833,
0.34479063749313354,
0.8166648149490356,
0.031394194811582565,
0.8376657366752625,
0.5645995140075684,
-0.22989968955516815,
0.2724834084510803,
0.3006306290626526,
0.24564027786254883,
0.16738060116767883,
0.08112432062625885,
-0.273918092250824,
-0.27038055658340454,
0.4005323052406311,
-0.0741276741027832,
0.4948982000350952,
0.384613573551178,
-0.15066708624362946,
-0.10516431927680969,
0.47884565591812134,
-0.1832815408706665,
-0.05197766795754433,
-0.14055004715919495,
0.5440571308135986,
0.3539380729198456,
-0.7958434820175171,
0.6067171096801758,
0.008477718569338322,
0.5589975714683533,
-0.8267510533332825,
0.00274745374917984,
-0.02990720421075821,
0.18304483592510223,
-0.3113963305950165,
-0.7277529835700989,
0.3836677372455597,
-0.2526906132698059,
0.35908839106559753,
-0.583827018737793,
0.6109877228736877,
-0.3981951177120209,
-0.4881761968135834,
0.48319122195243835,
0.5982449054718018,
0.7418569922447205,
0.05301555246114731,
-0.9941706657409668,
0.1825585514307022,
-0.08697765320539474,
-0.16022546589374542,
0.1383427232503891,
0.11569005250930786,
-0.29327988624572754,
0.4896964430809021,
0.844575047492981,
0.10152518004179001,
0.33310648798942566,
0.38092470169067383,
0.3654705882072449,
-0.6665840148925781,
-0.4798213839530945,
-0.27835482358932495,
0.34009426832199097,
-0.07663171738386154,
-0.5703564882278442,
0.9204515218734741,
0.6613068580627441,
0.791921079158783,
-0.056282706558704376,
0.7425142526626587,
-0.27393996715545654,
0.017072981223464012,
-0.455636203289032,
0.6668818593025208,
-0.3526274561882019,
-0.12671461701393127,
-0.4930225610733032,
-1.091862678527832,
-0.5136793851852417,
0.41501671075820923,
-0.14758296310901642,
-0.1346636265516281,
1.0658210515975952,
0.48825347423553467,
-0.26859477162361145,
0.0215956699103117,
0.4737064838409424,
-0.3028067946434021,
0.135755255818367,
0.6756543517112732,
0.46462270617485046,
-0.7695521712303162,
0.8521820902824402,
0.0007186260190792382,
-0.5560603141784668,
-0.1040106937289238,
-0.785417914390564,
-0.5162319540977478,
-0.8303141593933105,
-0.5991880297660828,
-0.32758450508117676,
-0.2339998185634613,
0.46960315108299255,
0.8029693961143494,
-0.9393423795700073,
-0.4983620047569275,
0.1107545793056488,
0.09975186735391617,
-0.7243537306785583,
-0.13173122704029083,
0.2828349769115448,
-0.20467382669448853,
-0.5194265842437744,
0.6595372557640076,
0.14177826046943665,
0.05858321115374565,
-0.4036392867565155,
-0.5486206412315369,
-0.2788692116737366,
-0.1692497432231903,
0.7933893799781799,
0.4741101861000061,
-0.6150981187820435,
-0.3000468611717224,
0.02901431918144226,
-0.2822815477848053,
-0.045216791331768036,
1.1835551261901855,
-0.5017905235290527,
0.34651055932044983,
0.5147276520729065,
0.22793686389923096,
0.7505468130111694,
-0.17803815007209778,
0.2912362813949585,
-0.8978450298309326,
-0.22479234635829926,
-0.007384851109236479,
0.3561660051345825,
0.5569730401039124,
-0.22765569388866425,
0.24656718969345093,
0.2322319597005844,
-0.31855207681655884,
-0.4300972521305084,
0.5687326192855835,
-1.4385865926742554,
-0.17993779480457306,
1.0942904949188232,
0.11475200206041336,
-0.18677549064159393,
-0.40573200583457947,
-0.1372843086719513,
0.5850657224655151,
-0.41751429438591003,
0.27347663044929504,
0.5860702991485596,
-0.5030377507209778,
-0.19094906747341156,
-0.759933352470398,
0.4534724950790405,
0.31747114658355713,
-0.7237734198570251,
-0.1296880543231964,
0.47130075097084045,
0.2700027525424957,
0.6582411527633667,
1.016367793083191,
-0.07089926302433014,
0.4680880904197693,
-0.05933443829417229,
0.3255324065685272,
0.007190749980509281,
-0.15779738128185272,
-0.22363460063934326,
-0.1509823203086853,
0.22800680994987488,
-0.4046643078327179
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.06021v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.06021v1
|
Shoulders of Giants: A Look at the Degree and Utility of Openness in NLP Research
| 2024-06-10T04:47:27 | 2024-06-10T04:47:27 |
Surangika Ranathunga, Nisansa de Silva, Dilith Jayakody, Aloka Fernando
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We analysed a sample of NLP research papers archived in ACL Anthology as an
attempt to quantify the degree of openness and the benefit of such an open
culture in the NLP community. We observe that papers published in different NLP
venues show different patterns related to artefact reuse. We also note that
more than 30% of the papers we analysed do not release their artefacts
publicly, despite promising to do so. Further, we observe a wide language-wise
disparity in publicly available NLP-related artefacts.
|
[
-0.36772412061691284,
-0.6091413497924805,
-0.002870648168027401,
0.13986164331436157,
0.13937954604625702,
-0.15832744538784027,
-0.17450392246246338,
-0.7761586308479309,
0.5564790368080139,
0.5414112210273743,
-0.18249647319316864,
-0.29386410117149353,
-0.7947748303413391,
0.30524739623069763,
-0.7324250936508179,
1.197611927986145,
0.05643749237060547,
-0.37082281708717346,
-0.17826007306575775,
-0.8168207406997681,
0.3209458887577057,
-0.6194151639938354,
-0.9731816649436951,
-0.024928169324994087,
0.5839241147041321,
0.08032823354005814,
1.3239203691482544,
0.6154909133911133,
0.7142194509506226,
0.2908250689506531,
-0.5819196701049805,
-0.12362750619649887,
-0.45470893383026123,
-0.01901373080909252,
-0.4875631630420685,
-0.31413504481315613,
-0.6206786036491394,
0.2214105874300003,
0.7629847526550293,
0.9428712129592896,
-0.2993025779724121,
0.30417555570602417,
0.14884236454963684,
0.8812965750694275,
-0.43056440353393555,
-0.24856969714164734,
-0.46457386016845703,
0.33198055624961853,
-0.4640646278858185,
-0.16577261686325073,
-0.2156466394662857,
-0.33033496141433716,
0.31869471073150635,
-0.8101464509963989,
0.47350698709487915,
0.29492872953414917,
0.5615701675415039,
0.14493905007839203,
-0.038395196199417114,
-0.6852863430976868,
-0.4846830666065216,
1.0049047470092773,
-0.48933231830596924,
0.09971644729375839,
0.5107312202453613,
0.1031380146741867,
0.0794699490070343,
-0.8272660374641418,
-0.6785764694213867,
0.08914699405431747,
-0.48330238461494446,
-0.0541045255959034,
-0.7528747320175171,
-0.2900002896785736,
0.3790239095687866,
0.9100915193557739,
-0.615993082523346,
0.21615147590637207,
-0.46995070576667786,
0.16162532567977905,
0.7402830719947815,
-0.0935782939195633,
0.7356212735176086,
-0.17551954090595245,
-0.25883668661117554,
-0.17186349630355835,
-0.747978687286377,
-0.2297801822423935,
0.5954670906066895,
0.13094283640384674,
-0.1326574683189392,
0.7270418405532837,
-0.10934997349977493,
0.49920013546943665,
-0.22089892625808716,
-0.10716182738542557,
0.4286676347255707,
-0.09923549741506577,
-0.17888885736465454,
-0.2136848121881485,
0.8042600154876709,
0.2725552022457123,
-0.18410994112491608,
-0.39997991919517517,
-0.09537944942712784,
-0.5352696776390076,
0.32421454787254333,
-0.48564067482948303,
-0.040712252259254456,
0.3709235191345215,
-1.044240117073059,
-0.2589493691921234,
-0.12309780716896057,
-0.6225907206535339,
-0.5152671933174133,
0.0676468089222908,
0.24892526865005493,
-0.18456949293613434,
-0.7114692330360413,
0.14355431497097015,
-0.3719041645526886,
0.1872166246175766,
0.03894294425845146,
-0.8365371227264404,
0.3246498703956604,
0.8098269104957581,
1.1187546253204346,
-0.3328397572040558,
-0.2012893259525299,
-0.19845137000083923,
-0.10051136463880539,
-0.34819039702415466,
0.4202502965927124,
-0.047407589852809906,
-0.4344218969345093,
0.15821753442287445,
0.21452508866786957,
0.41108039021492004,
-0.6286655068397522,
1.0263888835906982,
-0.4858776926994324,
0.3241422176361084,
-0.2574473023414612,
0.014050120487809181,
-0.289205402135849,
0.1768004149198532,
-1.0780065059661865,
0.5468201041221619,
0.19402270019054413,
-1.0161705017089844,
0.39136096835136414,
-0.884704053401947,
0.01837238296866417,
0.09601511806249619,
-0.2373238503932953,
-0.2087949961423874,
0.2814065217971802,
0.13414336740970612,
0.16465747356414795,
-0.17732182145118713,
0.09834013879299164,
-0.167873814702034,
-0.05042770132422447,
0.2832482159137726,
-0.32772061228752136,
1.5542265176773071,
0.5637036561965942,
-0.06061306223273277,
-0.172862708568573,
-0.48103776574134827,
-0.26848870515823364,
-0.13607729971408844,
-0.2630794644355774,
-0.8209267854690552,
0.1330491304397583,
0.13758397102355957,
-0.09907237440347672,
0.07260183990001678,
-0.6637178659439087,
0.4355482757091522,
-0.3322860300540924,
0.17461621761322021,
0.5412482619285583,
-0.27813276648521423,
0.3193977475166321,
-0.5209252834320068,
0.5975555777549744,
-0.16424459218978882,
0.0017617868725210428,
0.2950804829597473,
-0.39126166701316833,
-0.359828382730484,
-0.2447960376739502,
0.3095707297325134,
0.03316144645214081,
-0.8640167713165283,
0.15303492546081543,
-0.06425964832305908,
-0.5452138781547546,
-0.5922607183456421,
-0.11767422407865524,
0.46499520540237427,
0.1574993133544922,
-0.00989426951855421,
-0.79896479845047,
-0.40017759799957275,
-1.0440747737884521,
-0.5647639036178589,
-0.32038983702659607,
-0.21771378815174103,
0.5212540626525879,
0.5827093720436096,
0.23853552341461182,
0.7557533979415894,
-0.6766374707221985,
-0.6016675233840942,
0.0548848882317543,
0.4098952114582062,
0.3548124432563782,
0.5800161361694336,
0.9682538509368896,
-0.7968302965164185,
-0.28433310985565186,
0.05100627243518829,
-1.0352342128753662,
-0.06847068667411804,
0.2218254655599594,
-0.09793731570243835,
0.3548429608345032,
0.6376791000366211,
-0.46959224343299866,
0.37309613823890686,
0.9157111048698425,
-0.446092426776886,
0.4974006414413452,
-0.26592233777046204,
0.05946790799498558,
-0.9739799499511719,
0.6599666476249695,
-0.16995181143283844,
0.2957247495651245,
-0.449000746011734,
0.3207327425479889,
-0.3043379783630371,
-0.2926393151283264,
-0.29323670268058777,
0.4619106948375702,
-0.728027880191803,
-0.2963419258594513,
-0.29504621028900146,
0.34855782985687256,
-0.02428326942026615,
0.09586858749389648,
0.22021491825580597,
0.755071759223938,
0.6024903059005737,
-0.3096599578857422,
-0.016619861125946045,
0.6165863871574402,
-0.44721099734306335,
0.5154424905776978,
-0.737032949924469,
-0.024425307288765907,
-0.36834457516670227,
0.12934169173240662,
-0.791935920715332,
-0.0984206423163414,
0.05444057285785675,
-0.5842316150665283,
0.16289082169532776,
-0.09250329434871674,
-0.3961345851421356,
-0.1461060494184494,
-0.28554394841194153,
0.5125125050544739,
0.4484117031097412,
-0.6121742129325867,
0.4040433168411255,
0.6967511177062988,
-0.26055407524108887,
-1.1569052934646606,
-1.0713562965393066,
0.03963291272521019,
-0.25898441672325134,
-0.5647679567337036,
0.0033452333882451057,
-0.0875868871808052,
-0.8109772801399231,
0.4147396683692932,
-0.15824252367019653,
-0.22577568888664246,
0.18549804389476776,
0.19418184459209442,
-0.19458046555519104,
-0.2992499768733978,
0.15525327622890472,
-0.15116606652736664,
0.0728013888001442,
0.21234062314033508,
-0.24098610877990723,
0.19878454506397247,
-0.35759854316711426,
-0.3668621778488159,
-0.06772361695766449,
0.5678660273551941,
0.27660924196243286,
-0.0409492664039135,
1.0531922578811646,
0.33240774273872375,
-0.23957957327365875,
-0.046627651900053024,
-0.3910907804965973,
0.24171100556850433,
-0.46308717131614685,
0.19386877119541168,
0.03539782017469406,
-0.8730984926223755,
0.49951472878456116,
0.15765680372714996,
0.31284385919570923,
0.7446895241737366,
0.29345664381980896,
0.12935768067836761,
0.376409649848938,
0.8292328119277954,
-0.13829906284809113,
0.18066512048244476,
-0.4212983548641205,
0.4945894777774811,
-1.044882893562317,
0.05589503422379494,
-0.9502087235450745,
-0.4417135715484619,
-0.7890616059303284,
-0.23154212534427643,
0.3801080882549286,
0.36965474486351013,
0.23684826493263245,
0.35870176553726196,
-0.788513720035553,
0.7062363624572754,
0.43367844820022583,
-0.19300970435142517,
0.8449714183807373,
-0.0435217022895813,
0.3025764524936676,
0.07612968236207962,
-0.6739691495895386,
-0.465377539396286,
1.1565968990325928,
0.24475790560245514,
0.55207359790802,
0.4871503710746765,
0.5304834246635437,
0.26175639033317566,
0.569084107875824,
-0.674485981464386,
0.319364458322525,
-0.4533296525478363,
-1.0697895288467407,
-0.7906255125999451,
-0.12699389457702637,
-1.2530862092971802,
0.3130994439125061,
-0.22902928292751312,
-0.6728639602661133,
0.42445099353790283,
-0.1555517166852951,
-0.327815979719162,
0.7033267021179199,
-0.2648886442184448,
0.4789194166660309,
0.20499014854431152,
-0.15735815465450287,
-0.2335360050201416,
-0.47181278467178345,
0.43521201610565186,
-0.25055766105651855,
0.3145744800567627,
0.2146063596010208,
0.009665579535067081,
1.1238527297973633,
-0.06990733742713928,
0.5047461986541748,
0.16935069859027863,
-0.2372625768184662,
0.4465566873550415,
0.18003535270690918,
0.13234134018421173,
-0.0216717179864645,
-0.2196945697069168,
0.38407883048057556,
-0.07986874878406525,
-0.29137083888053894,
-0.31918829679489136,
0.9561038613319397,
-0.95524662733078,
-0.5696701407432556,
-0.7266788482666016,
-0.7970464825630188,
0.10707850754261017,
0.2017955332994461,
-0.0004213687207084149,
0.5197408199310303,
-0.20438404381275177,
0.8430008888244629,
0.7974775433540344,
-0.624366044998169,
0.5535621643066406,
0.46098101139068604,
-0.29371118545532227,
-0.2258594036102295,
0.5115332007408142,
0.25609827041625977,
0.25224632024765015,
0.31888723373413086,
0.17174477875232697,
0.03234141692519188,
-0.678979754447937,
-0.3341560363769531,
0.10496928542852402,
-0.5904762148857117,
0.06572818756103516,
-0.769582986831665,
0.05291898921132088,
-0.34987321496009827,
-0.42087650299072266,
-0.2474079430103302,
-0.8867635726928711,
0.03432594612240791,
-0.007410851307213306,
0.4156637489795685,
0.763016402721405,
-0.6746922135353088,
0.33977842330932617,
-0.3950851857662201,
0.4662157893180847,
0.011741536669433117,
0.553655207157135,
0.2599739730358124,
-0.25045111775398254,
-0.29914095997810364,
-0.3497413098812103,
-0.40702909231185913,
-0.4601716101169586,
0.5191426277160645,
-0.2192610502243042,
0.5269339084625244,
0.5102145671844482,
0.20477375388145447,
0.2814745604991913,
-0.2501169741153717,
1.0714372396469116,
0.3778582513332367,
-0.5549529790878296,
0.12963274121284485,
-0.5800402164459229,
0.1122623085975647,
0.48949259519577026,
1.086669921875,
-0.6722585558891296,
-0.43907999992370605,
-1.1276805400848389,
-1.1414153575897217,
0.7101969718933105,
0.14809374511241913,
-0.008515426889061928,
-0.05863826349377632,
0.08105844259262085,
0.2994675636291504,
0.39597055315971375,
-0.6092209815979004,
-0.6036407947540283,
-0.20311583578586578,
0.3753422498703003,
-0.25191110372543335,
-0.26176345348358154,
-0.6338105797767639,
-0.02080567367374897,
0.4814196228981018,
0.03838563710451126,
0.055195167660713196,
0.433561235666275,
0.13671095669269562,
-0.06722922623157501,
0.23595409095287323,
0.22110643982887268,
1.076419711112976,
-0.15960131585597992,
0.10520996898412704,
0.10131660103797913,
-0.7074220180511475,
-0.39628270268440247,
-0.22381359338760376,
-0.32733431458473206,
0.12445269525051117,
0.36923718452453613,
0.33771467208862305,
-0.3161364197731018,
-0.5992538928985596,
0.4711746871471405,
0.0033467623870819807,
-0.4437948167324066,
-0.6626686453819275,
-0.3945135176181793,
0.15486964583396912,
0.26627758145332336,
0.571189820766449,
0.010142921470105648,
0.36918413639068604,
-0.9783132076263428,
0.08047489821910858,
0.653843879699707,
-0.21314752101898193,
-0.13864268362522125,
0.5950552225112915,
-0.07692241668701172,
-0.29289510846138,
0.7680306434631348,
-0.012236195616424084,
-0.02680215798318386,
0.2795284390449524,
0.37649673223495483,
1.123644471168518,
0.21247786283493042,
0.13349033892154694,
0.509925365447998,
0.541577160358429,
0.07799504697322845,
-0.04951971396803856,
0.1904236525297165,
-0.6218854784965515,
-0.460702508687973,
-0.7211553454399109,
-0.6289116144180298,
0.3136535882949829,
-0.7718788385391235,
-0.21027788519859314,
-0.11674446612596512,
-0.005804188083857298,
0.1350754350423813,
-0.03629481792449951,
-0.3495904207229614,
0.044353269040584564,
-0.4054775834083557,
1.0942398309707642,
-0.8805795311927795,
0.5374298691749573,
0.46757078170776367,
-0.5667884945869446,
-0.452262818813324,
0.06405956298112869,
0.07877304404973984,
-0.49695223569869995,
0.8831470608711243,
-0.31768712401390076,
0.16210688650608063,
-0.42983278632164,
-0.8237807154655457,
-1.0066218376159668,
1.1916264295578003,
-0.08505616337060928,
0.03634515404701233,
-0.07040832191705704,
-0.02941274642944336,
0.674442708492279,
-0.11582779139280319,
0.16245709359645844,
0.19639402627944946,
0.3078562915325165,
-0.2033022791147232,
-1.0917277336120605,
0.11913056671619415,
-0.2973145544528961,
-0.06846943497657776,
0.29270488023757935,
-0.7225982546806335,
1.0684837102890015,
0.14360015094280243,
-0.17997510731220245,
0.25889676809310913,
0.6743395924568176,
0.13743185997009277,
0.16613928973674774,
0.546107292175293,
0.7032044529914856,
0.47906389832496643,
-0.07786688953638077,
1.1473602056503296,
0.027339519932866096,
0.32497093081474304,
0.7294546365737915,
0.09157823771238327,
0.8952757120132446,
0.7557845115661621,
-0.24041728675365448,
0.4268268346786499,
-0.1425619125366211,
0.22221708297729492,
0.2694133222103119,
0.3982333838939667,
-0.3526374399662018,
0.44483235478401184,
-0.4222080111503601,
-0.41621142625808716,
0.3205484449863434,
0.23711667954921722,
-0.38092973828315735,
-0.4232589900493622,
-0.13480335474014282,
0.2667659521102905,
0.28261226415634155,
-0.34052252769470215,
0.6774512529373169,
0.08857446163892746,
-0.5787385702133179,
0.37765830755233765,
-0.24094358086585999,
0.7656292915344238,
-0.6595458984375,
-0.0332607626914978,
-0.14963805675506592,
0.18530288338661194,
-0.628343939781189,
-1.052716612815857,
1.0742894411087036,
-0.07668548077344894,
-0.0955875813961029,
-0.4496653079986572,
0.7235183715820312,
-0.044175244867801666,
0.16578491032123566,
-0.04177933931350708,
0.7723512649536133,
0.6421428918838501,
0.27364617586135864,
-0.3551678955554962,
0.049950797110795975,
-0.25798219442367554,
-0.5798711776733398,
0.666662335395813,
0.7519891858100891,
0.06687632203102112,
0.6813591122627258,
0.7019031047821045,
0.2985961437225342,
-0.38099247217178345,
-0.26178428530693054,
0.593887209892273,
-0.48034900426864624,
0.0019940510392189026,
-0.44085872173309326,
0.2886762320995331,
-0.34177127480506897,
-0.9163123369216919,
1.0252817869186401,
0.6403846740722656,
1.1051826477050781,
-0.18580810725688934,
0.6565350890159607,
-0.7019832730293274,
0.7132772207260132,
-0.29666975140571594,
1.2612495422363281,
-0.651299238204956,
-0.03931349515914917,
-0.36776548624038696,
-0.5096622109413147,
-0.31691235303878784,
0.5699176788330078,
-0.04685932770371437,
-0.4001038372516632,
1.009097933769226,
0.7049180269241333,
-0.05289736017584801,
0.3963719606399536,
0.1710917055606842,
0.2961927354335785,
-0.012713644653558731,
-0.1414211243391037,
0.42394766211509705,
-0.182895228266716,
0.4278871417045593,
-0.30671271681785583,
-0.5482240915298462,
0.10138747841119766,
-1.1538878679275513,
-0.5573198199272156,
-0.8542197346687317,
-0.29423728585243225,
-0.6505135893821716,
-0.07752794027328491,
0.3250541388988495,
0.14801692962646484,
-0.6339893341064453,
-0.5942889451980591,
0.293550968170166,
0.07388052344322205,
-0.7018201947212219,
-0.27758437395095825,
0.8165629506111145,
-0.129262775182724,
-0.6305676102638245,
0.12878841161727905,
0.012881562113761902,
-0.25388866662979126,
-0.487737774848938,
0.28459858894348145,
-0.247554749250412,
-0.11350968480110168,
0.7451300621032715,
0.611484944820404,
-0.36427363753318787,
-0.33099621534347534,
-0.020940352231264114,
0.16838862001895905,
-0.20347963273525238,
0.8647405505180359,
-0.5667762756347656,
0.13721615076065063,
0.7389856576919556,
0.7188692092895508,
0.3059111535549164,
-0.18523317575454712,
0.46023085713386536,
-0.8035687804222107,
0.104947529733181,
0.3260062634944916,
0.4553045630455017,
0.14705900847911835,
-0.05222901329398155,
1.063794732093811,
-0.053084149956703186,
-0.9489365816116333,
-1.0065796375274658,
0.19528056681156158,
-1.2067517042160034,
-0.33553391695022583,
0.9636954665184021,
-0.24996966123580933,
-0.19424064457416534,
-0.033421438187360764,
-0.14248532056808472,
-0.013537654653191566,
-0.009591770358383656,
1.029608130455017,
0.883979856967926,
-0.16496077179908752,
0.07205850630998611,
-0.9377557039260864,
0.7914058566093445,
0.22119082510471344,
-0.541334331035614,
0.16632334887981415,
0.36792880296707153,
-0.0005164325702935457,
0.8388810157775879,
0.8344262838363647,
-0.6784335374832153,
-0.21362628042697906,
0.206101655960083,
0.09081470966339111,
0.16243834793567657,
-0.06984420120716095,
-0.3120899200439453,
0.5344519019126892,
0.3055047392845154,
0.16293883323669434
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.06007v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.06007v1
|
CARES: A Comprehensive Benchmark of Trustworthiness in Medical Vision Language Models
| 2024-06-10T04:07:09 | 2024-06-10T04:07:09 |
Peng Xia, Ze Chen, Juanxi Tian, Yangrui Gong, Ruibo Hou, Yue Xu, Zhenbang Wu, Zhiyuan Fan, Yiyang Zhou, Kangyu Zhu, Wenhao Zheng, Zhaoyang Wang, Xiao Wang, Xuchao Zhang, Chetan Bansal, Marc Niethammer, Junzhou Huang, Hongtu Zhu, Yun Li, Jimeng Sun, Zongyuan Ge, Gang Li, James Zou, Huaxiu Yao
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.CY
|
Artificial intelligence has significantly impacted medical applications,
particularly with the advent of Medical Large Vision Language Models
(Med-LVLMs), sparking optimism for the future of automated and personalized
healthcare. However, the trustworthiness of Med-LVLMs remains unverified,
posing significant risks for future model deployment. In this paper, we
introduce CARES and aim to comprehensively evaluate the Trustworthiness of
Med-LVLMs across the medical domain. We assess the trustworthiness of Med-LVLMs
across five dimensions, including trustfulness, fairness, safety, privacy, and
robustness. CARES comprises about 41K question-answer pairs in both closed and
open-ended formats, covering 16 medical image modalities and 27 anatomical
regions. Our analysis reveals that the models consistently exhibit concerns
regarding trustworthiness, often displaying factual inaccuracies and failing to
maintain fairness across different demographic groups. Furthermore, they are
vulnerable to attacks and demonstrate a lack of privacy awareness. We publicly
release our benchmark and code in https://github.com/richard-peng-xia/CARES.
|
[
-0.11004114896059036,
-0.4478352665901184,
0.9178047776222229,
0.03830127418041229,
-0.3307771682739258,
-0.2384161800146103,
0.21175231039524078,
-0.9008576273918152,
-0.15818405151367188,
0.5254551768302917,
-0.29994985461235046,
-0.6098409295082092,
-0.595557689666748,
-0.09968744218349457,
-0.3859337270259857,
0.7269158959388733,
0.05484773963689804,
0.23017804324626923,
-0.7816967368125916,
-0.3661342263221741,
0.09507611393928528,
-0.543475329875946,
-0.5208795070648193,
-0.1607874631881714,
0.5327026844024658,
-0.2782978117465973,
0.7923704385757446,
0.5820012092590332,
1.0552375316619873,
0.25057023763656616,
-0.00008692664414411411,
0.42383652925491333,
-0.272785484790802,
0.1583932638168335,
-0.14654485881328583,
-0.31153634190559387,
-0.5540854930877686,
-0.05335785076022148,
0.4324999749660492,
0.3728265166282654,
-0.28957000374794006,
0.3667895197868347,
-0.2281939536333084,
0.7765824794769287,
-0.5783876180648804,
0.3561127185821533,
-0.7444924712181091,
0.12703010439872742,
-0.2355455905199051,
-0.24371527135372162,
-0.24782469868659973,
-0.5526617169380188,
0.41142794489860535,
-0.4634628891944885,
-0.03356778621673584,
0.005361540708690882,
0.894611656665802,
0.622346043586731,
-0.37513530254364014,
0.12105107307434082,
-0.33051547408103943,
0.6545425057411194,
-0.6201909184455872,
0.4875938296318054,
0.45591625571250916,
0.445854514837265,
-0.051653649657964706,
-1.1508047580718994,
-0.3626011312007904,
-0.2691260576248169,
0.014931845478713512,
0.23237527906894684,
-0.19985012710094452,
0.10656029731035233,
0.08492765575647354,
0.2240421026945114,
-0.41418033838272095,
-0.06894189864397049,
-0.5275608897209167,
-0.3773457109928131,
0.7061741948127747,
0.16680143773555756,
0.27573421597480774,
0.20754489302635193,
-0.7545189261436462,
-0.05025491863489151,
-0.6495891809463501,
0.28886300325393677,
0.11537225544452667,
-0.2435043454170227,
-0.36475521326065063,
0.6483955979347229,
-0.17346426844596863,
0.5976342558860779,
-0.20648328959941864,
-0.38764259219169617,
0.340867280960083,
-0.3315299153327942,
-0.47426465153694153,
-0.3403037488460541,
0.7944413423538208,
0.7823576927185059,
0.6515787243843079,
-0.035495687276124954,
-0.051003143191337585,
0.5220237970352173,
0.724869430065155,
-0.544593095779419,
-0.18562200665473938,
0.5994303226470947,
-0.588685929775238,
-0.45838645100593567,
-0.0298710186034441,
-0.2145731896162033,
-0.7377235889434814,
-0.18736937642097473,
0.25334063172340393,
-0.5134111046791077,
0.04166090860962868,
0.26913997530937195,
0.2254444807767868,
0.22545544803142548,
0.4399353563785553,
-0.2038416862487793,
0.07371595501899719,
0.6541094183921814,
0.37806352972984314,
-0.5017140507698059,
-0.43030211329460144,
-0.45927760004997253,
-0.2053426206111908,
-0.3096008896827698,
0.6623274683952332,
-0.42607083916664124,
-0.26909932494163513,
0.22618117928504944,
0.029177846387028694,
-0.22036273777484894,
-0.5228097438812256,
0.5184409618377686,
-0.49029964208602905,
-0.1642228364944458,
-0.1106141060590744,
-0.5386956930160522,
-0.16104421019554138,
0.6559415459632874,
-0.5187805891036987,
0.7049409747123718,
0.22480280697345734,
-0.6460537314414978,
0.25985315442085266,
-0.38257238268852234,
-0.38319525122642517,
0.14326629042625427,
-0.49975958466529846,
-0.7888699173927307,
0.16416600346565247,
0.0636170506477356,
0.7651394009590149,
-0.06130677089095116,
0.39836928248405457,
-0.6094902157783508,
-0.2058725655078888,
0.7425051331520081,
-0.5795562267303467,
0.7101183533668518,
-0.013159079477190971,
-0.14922231435775757,
0.220017209649086,
-0.5751760601997375,
0.38044655323028564,
0.09334897994995117,
-0.04781336709856987,
-0.3183671832084656,
0.08045779168605804,
0.1593795269727707,
0.24663572013378143,
0.43862754106521606,
-0.5110662579536438,
-0.1392325758934021,
-0.3045753836631775,
0.38481685519218445,
0.7270323634147644,
0.04225364699959755,
0.011661211960017681,
-0.32385021448135376,
0.4799479842185974,
0.4367806315422058,
1.0248119831085205,
-0.0015562871703878045,
-0.737486720085144,
-0.4009954631328583,
-0.28647729754447937,
-0.07546178996562958,
0.2958635985851288,
-0.5963076949119568,
0.024511391296982765,
-0.1884990781545639,
-0.6816588044166565,
-0.8164870142936707,
-0.12569789588451385,
0.750316858291626,
0.6530606150627136,
0.3629538118839264,
-0.537756621837616,
-0.024051396176218987,
-1.3337593078613281,
-0.36043983697891235,
-0.3458104431629181,
0.3183085024356842,
0.6366658210754395,
0.2952369451522827,
-0.6426386833190918,
0.5457225441932678,
-0.31080761551856995,
-0.35205817222595215,
0.36479082703590393,
-0.5373595952987671,
-0.3223631680011749,
0.20803149044513702,
0.7669869065284729,
-1.0555500984191895,
-0.27485185861587524,
0.08155957609415054,
-0.7921504974365234,
0.30202096700668335,
0.24937379360198975,
-0.00008200253068935126,
0.3365563452243805,
0.36181262135505676,
-0.6965462565422058,
0.6522984504699707,
0.9895011186599731,
-0.5158911943435669,
0.46300992369651794,
-0.36116379499435425,
0.2061670422554016,
-0.9933037757873535,
0.385459303855896,
0.18221743404865265,
-0.47441592812538147,
-0.4203139841556549,
0.3770763874053955,
0.15531998872756958,
0.15310707688331604,
-0.7480120062828064,
0.5460704565048218,
-0.06756646186113358,
-0.125088170170784,
0.4220092296600342,
0.004280047956854105,
0.08034446090459824,
0.13172367215156555,
-0.11811147630214691,
0.5448267459869385,
0.7135463953018188,
-0.4827395975589752,
0.24253958463668823,
0.15496383607387543,
-0.5280781388282776,
0.8768333196640015,
-0.778655469417572,
0.11425065249204636,
0.08281543850898743,
0.04729803279042244,
-0.5032747387886047,
-0.20914815366268158,
0.06206994876265526,
-0.6083227396011353,
0.07937052845954895,
0.09209152311086655,
-0.2996615469455719,
-0.23255039751529694,
-0.1946754902601242,
0.47260600328445435,
0.43202391266822815,
-0.28335633873939514,
0.6589784026145935,
0.8690013885498047,
0.163315087556839,
-0.6772915720939636,
-0.5879919528961182,
-0.08276422321796417,
-0.008112519048154354,
-0.6190768480300903,
0.08984613418579102,
-0.25132471323013306,
-0.4727209806442261,
0.10982738435268402,
-0.14484703540802002,
-0.39305901527404785,
0.15503153204917908,
0.5355871319770813,
0.39411112666130066,
-0.0565665103495121,
-0.0760839581489563,
-0.18044210970401764,
-0.09650333970785141,
0.18510125577449799,
-0.2524500787258148,
0.18477073311805725,
-0.4101299047470093,
-0.69785475730896,
-0.4499742388725281,
0.275446355342865,
1.107460856437683,
-0.5843597650527954,
0.6583570241928101,
0.6236564517021179,
-0.5418732166290283,
0.0657859817147255,
-0.6735966801643372,
-0.11179237067699432,
-0.41703763604164124,
0.49714502692222595,
-0.02783263847231865,
-0.9088197946548462,
0.49555447697639465,
0.1888570487499237,
0.10828381031751633,
0.34279653429985046,
0.554846465587616,
-0.31369221210479736,
0.8817552924156189,
0.6950984597206116,
-0.04045936092734337,
-0.06071974337100983,
0.0894283726811409,
0.35061702132225037,
-0.5734804272651672,
-0.7866924405097961,
-0.18319351971149445,
0.14025668799877167,
-0.6164096593856812,
-0.6974221467971802,
0.7012523412704468,
-0.46566420793533325,
-0.10936664044857025,
-0.08023609966039658,
-0.3229120969772339,
0.09410291910171509,
0.48794040083885193,
0.37891605496406555,
0.2827497720718384,
-0.018908247351646423,
-0.0004298244894016534,
-0.03835197910666466,
-0.42662179470062256,
-0.38202396035194397,
0.8406251668930054,
0.5803906917572021,
0.7512726783752441,
-0.13850624859333038,
0.3980635404586792,
0.32776427268981934,
0.20793390274047852,
-0.7497079372406006,
0.348662406206131,
-0.5994186997413635,
-0.5392807722091675,
-0.23960432410240173,
-0.22128745913505554,
-0.6090121865272522,
-0.13123537600040436,
-0.19269761443138123,
-0.5611544251441956,
0.011311652138829231,
0.6308382749557495,
-0.47845715284347534,
0.27240538597106934,
-0.5566869378089905,
0.7449197173118591,
-0.30324026942253113,
-0.2191188484430313,
-0.15406803786754608,
-0.8450326323509216,
0.23548094928264618,
-0.1550079584121704,
-0.02772899530827999,
-0.047477833926677704,
0.029948215931653976,
0.2596230208873749,
-0.10477655380964279,
0.9074001312255859,
0.00486337672919035,
0.04170010983943939,
0.04846126586198807,
0.0301485825330019,
0.35367846488952637,
-0.03338395431637764,
0.22664345800876617,
0.6793854236602783,
0.34099215269088745,
-0.36300167441368103,
-0.25641897320747375,
0.6279969811439514,
-0.588935375213623,
-0.28770333528518677,
-0.4760599136352539,
-0.35887059569358826,
-0.6136504411697388,
0.3119693100452423,
0.29248514771461487,
0.4722718298435211,
-0.1565944105386734,
0.3800305426120758,
0.9588704109191895,
-0.3425685465335846,
-0.0630422905087471,
0.3333480656147003,
-0.025320464745163918,
-0.2125544250011444,
0.6636945009231567,
-0.2370292991399765,
0.4656611680984497,
0.1100507378578186,
-0.012909435667097569,
-0.3317713141441345,
-0.604231595993042,
-0.4215664267539978,
0.2692500650882721,
-0.6036239266395569,
-0.31036376953125,
-0.5004753470420837,
-0.6209334135055542,
-0.24973586201667786,
-0.017821503803133965,
-0.8541955351829529,
0.11530080437660217,
0.025045203045010567,
0.0659141093492508,
0.31353580951690674,
0.5821797251701355,
0.6593675017356873,
-0.1456567496061325,
-0.8337252736091614,
0.41682037711143494,
0.31883296370506287,
0.7907138466835022,
-0.49564823508262634,
-0.24604716897010803,
-0.1345912218093872,
-0.13963767886161804,
0.1912371665239334,
-0.3366711437702179,
0.15843890607357025,
0.021994315087795258,
0.6948283314704895,
0.6194270849227905,
0.03223131224513054,
0.5361546874046326,
-0.675547182559967,
0.8740541338920593,
0.3664836883544922,
-0.6366750597953796,
0.27039802074432373,
-0.13885948061943054,
0.004544811323285103,
0.7066879868507385,
0.10687104612588882,
-0.3427714705467224,
-0.37479475140571594,
-0.6866326928138733,
-0.5914157032966614,
0.0014313574647530913,
0.08939272910356522,
-0.046108148992061615,
0.16289344429969788,
0.3736860752105713,
-0.027851169928908348,
0.22053641080856323,
-0.5285387635231018,
-0.4361291229724884,
-0.10966293513774872,
-0.39699500799179077,
0.04947562888264656,
-0.3669757544994354,
-0.4073837399482727,
0.117319256067276,
0.3662450313568115,
-0.3036147356033325,
0.08278600126504898,
0.4883173108100891,
0.3009841740131378,
-0.01033846940845251,
0.12044447660446167,
0.6774201393127441,
0.6050474643707275,
0.01577782817184925,
0.17350387573242188,
-0.10382523387670517,
-0.9454296231269836,
-0.35238224267959595,
0.001348125864751637,
-0.2266470342874527,
-0.18405359983444214,
0.4456750154495239,
0.6014007925987244,
-0.037209779024124146,
-0.7507328391075134,
0.9096534252166748,
-0.4291531443595886,
-0.20526959002017975,
-0.530217707157135,
0.08494319766759872,
0.1347268670797348,
0.34179776906967163,
-0.2041970193386078,
0.6545777916908264,
0.20277360081672668,
-0.32660263776779175,
0.1630057394504547,
0.48486393690109253,
-0.9831281304359436,
-0.30321362614631653,
0.675459623336792,
0.1119658425450325,
0.06014479696750641,
0.4371017515659332,
0.419539213180542,
-0.41443756222724915,
0.5321534276008606,
0.1281459927558899,
0.6430240869522095,
-0.27114272117614746,
0.1696336418390274,
0.072818323969841,
0.6391358971595764,
-0.13267873227596283,
0.48093944787979126,
0.3066897988319397,
-0.7381113767623901,
-0.10740869492292404,
-0.6116231083869934,
-0.5637463331222534,
0.26054370403289795,
-0.8522189259529114,
-0.2251155972480774,
-0.3380753695964813,
-0.481804758310318,
-0.31134840846061707,
-0.09493114799261093,
-0.9281510710716248,
0.6918002367019653,
0.1923532783985138,
1.1072081327438354,
-0.620576798915863,
0.8752785921096802,
0.8736245036125183,
0.08631713688373566,
-0.7283813953399658,
-0.008188464678823948,
-0.004980162251740694,
-1.2499887943267822,
0.19924356043338776,
0.10771256685256958,
-0.4319207966327667,
-0.5473979115486145,
-0.6131675243377686,
-0.47266384959220886,
1.161849021911621,
0.4873073399066925,
-0.6825740933418274,
0.14414459466934204,
0.11994481831789017,
0.772601306438446,
-0.306056410074234,
-0.4810487627983093,
0.36432287096977234,
0.3228077292442322,
-0.325728178024292,
-1.0331851243972778,
-0.043925005942583084,
-0.3752361536026001,
-0.09449788182973862,
-0.4048013389110565,
-0.7237383127212524,
0.6652054190635681,
-0.5287992358207703,
-0.08736552298069,
0.1404275894165039,
0.1292399764060974,
0.4971412420272827,
0.5957483649253845,
0.48460060358047485,
0.4873873293399811,
0.8363432288169861,
-0.10488425940275192,
1.5001091957092285,
-0.4464910626411438,
0.2006181925535202,
0.780923068523407,
-0.2905733287334442,
0.8659480214118958,
0.6002306938171387,
-0.21148087084293365,
0.10903049260377884,
0.33254772424697876,
0.08740666508674622,
0.4982320964336395,
-0.03848378732800484,
-0.2309989035129547,
-0.5047290921211243,
-0.1827406883239746,
-0.5038138031959534,
0.6863484978675842,
0.38047829270362854,
-0.678695559501648,
0.4238137900829315,
-0.31630322337150574,
-0.06312297284603119,
0.1173265129327774,
-0.3398916721343994,
0.5244426131248474,
0.42263901233673096,
-0.6410864591598511,
-0.08186142891645432,
-0.3800071179866791,
0.27327626943588257,
-0.7246851921081543,
-0.0020005202386528254,
-0.07581362128257751,
0.5055273771286011,
-0.28059592843055725,
-0.9990483522415161,
0.17934896051883698,
-0.10766097903251648,
-0.17027084529399872,
0.22145317494869232,
0.7737184166908264,
-0.24798141419887543,
-0.49533286690711975,
0.3735021650791168,
0.4815826416015625,
0.0894193947315216,
-0.09409277141094208,
-0.7700558304786682,
0.18098627030849457,
-0.002960814628750086,
-0.058708447962999344,
0.32611706852912903,
0.25061097741127014,
-0.08755481988191605,
1.0469231605529785,
0.5852968692779541,
0.4233522415161133,
-0.09773397445678711,
0.2748652994632721,
0.7916538119316101,
-0.3026866912841797,
-0.326734334230423,
-0.7284557819366455,
0.6118744611740112,
-0.2074756920337677,
-0.5564934015274048,
0.6728536486625671,
0.3348838686943054,
0.7256773710250854,
-0.16249831020832062,
0.7896850109100342,
0.4318265914916992,
0.338090717792511,
-0.5388141870498657,
1.1083390712738037,
-0.637477695941925,
0.03918313607573509,
-0.19845332205295563,
-0.3875616788864136,
-0.5855618119239807,
0.5971454977989197,
0.028221052139997482,
0.023654626682400703,
0.6187180280685425,
0.6919959187507629,
-0.00796153862029314,
-0.34093183279037476,
0.793135941028595,
0.2779041528701782,
0.1482355147600174,
0.4099654257297516,
0.6214639544487,
-0.3355102241039276,
0.32828399538993835,
-0.40136802196502686,
-0.11525383591651917,
-0.2460586428642273,
-0.9145727753639221,
-0.8728722333908081,
-0.5106703639030457,
-0.39754408597946167,
-0.4953600764274597,
0.06460322439670563,
0.48752179741859436,
0.9586406946182251,
-0.803759753704071,
0.4007609188556671,
0.35285162925720215,
-0.18968327343463898,
-0.17270971834659576,
-0.10266492515802383,
0.6273685693740845,
0.10026153177022934,
-0.3926001489162445,
0.05072727054357529,
0.6897253394126892,
-0.013286706060171127,
-0.6167634725570679,
-0.0644335001707077,
0.5707398653030396,
0.21390657126903534,
0.6647448539733887,
0.16634736955165863,
-0.9154381155967712,
-0.3556996285915375,
0.259458988904953,
-0.5791653394699097,
0.004505484364926815,
0.5254214406013489,
-0.6099571585655212,
0.6371386647224426,
0.011134064756333828,
0.7300397753715515,
-0.07003836333751678,
-0.1216764748096466,
0.29012399911880493,
-0.3199905753135681,
-0.2446555495262146,
0.29056093096733093,
0.7022265791893005,
0.5455362200737,
-0.48093920946121216,
0.394609272480011,
0.13130086660385132,
-0.5114061832427979,
-0.7085545659065247,
0.27157288789749146,
-1.4909696578979492,
0.06116357073187828,
1.036768913269043,
-0.6111948490142822,
-0.358027845621109,
-0.059912849217653275,
-0.07289187610149384,
-0.05849583446979523,
-0.03282318636775017,
0.9894250631332397,
0.11490379273891449,
-0.043626077473163605,
0.09808125346899033,
-0.4796465337276459,
0.6062974333763123,
0.26971080899238586,
-0.922831654548645,
-0.030416859313845634,
0.33003634214401245,
0.40986472368240356,
0.21325014531612396,
0.7358173131942749,
-0.6922067403793335,
0.533907949924469,
-0.13944542407989502,
-0.10880739986896515,
-0.20101194083690643,
-0.37332838773727417,
-0.16831529140472412,
0.1786729246377945,
0.0089755579829216,
-0.22101420164108276
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.06004v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.06004v1
|
FLEUR: An Explainable Reference-Free Evaluation Metric for Image Captioning Using a Large Multimodal Model
| 2024-06-10T03:57:39 | 2024-06-10T03:57:39 |
Yebin Lee, Imseong Park, Myungjoo Kang
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Most existing image captioning evaluation metrics focus on assigning a single
numerical score to a caption by comparing it with reference captions. However,
these methods do not provide an explanation for the assigned score. Moreover,
reference captions are expensive to acquire. In this paper, we propose FLEUR,
an explainable reference-free metric to introduce explainability into image
captioning evaluation metrics. By leveraging a large multimodal model, FLEUR
can evaluate the caption against the image without the need for reference
captions, and provide the explanation for the assigned score. We introduce
score smoothing to align as closely as possible with human judgment and to be
robust to user-defined grading criteria. FLEUR achieves high correlations with
human judgment across various image captioning evaluation benchmarks and
reaches state-of-the-art results on Flickr8k-CF, COMPOSITE, and Pascal-50S
within the domain of reference-free evaluation metrics. Our source code and
results are publicly available at: https://github.com/Yebin46/FLEUR.
|
[
-0.7703886032104492,
-0.37947919964790344,
0.6081095933914185,
0.4098920524120331,
-0.7337114810943604,
-0.20654544234275818,
0.04744242504239082,
-0.43887388706207275,
-0.01425660029053688,
0.3206537067890167,
-0.558238685131073,
-0.33162805438041687,
-0.6319835186004639,
0.17901241779327393,
-0.38398849964141846,
0.8834984302520752,
-0.30196210741996765,
0.165901780128479,
-0.7809081673622131,
-0.5183904767036438,
-0.3569338321685791,
-0.1378241628408432,
-0.4405290186405182,
0.06261499971151352,
0.7975501418113708,
0.42661675810813904,
0.9636668562889099,
0.5653435587882996,
0.8449781537055969,
0.2840331196784973,
0.35440704226493835,
0.5716274380683899,
-0.2583640217781067,
-0.37483182549476624,
-0.324603796005249,
-0.5290835499763489,
-0.3995390832424164,
0.048810843378305435,
0.4190441071987152,
0.3523377776145935,
0.29677680134773254,
0.16997559368610382,
-0.2995660901069641,
0.9702891111373901,
-0.5610474944114685,
0.5520355701446533,
-0.30956459045410156,
0.10104280710220337,
0.03851570188999176,
-0.7668761014938354,
-0.3226608335971832,
-0.2844791114330292,
0.08496544510126114,
-0.7606889605522156,
0.6214337944984436,
0.2645828127861023,
1.0817077159881592,
0.21400345861911774,
-0.2694809138774872,
0.004970763809978962,
-0.4980635941028595,
0.6936784982681274,
-0.1641812026500702,
0.3948623239994049,
-0.12519435584545135,
0.7030049562454224,
0.3168005347251892,
-0.5929937362670898,
-0.6585384607315063,
-0.15616905689239502,
-0.010946442373096943,
0.32091203331947327,
-0.2966216504573822,
-0.16375625133514404,
-0.09508271515369415,
0.6346139311790466,
-0.35562852025032043,
-0.26931652426719666,
-0.582084059715271,
-0.40846243500709534,
0.6023926138877869,
-0.1821010410785675,
0.2950953245162964,
0.03161773830652237,
-0.8725684881210327,
-0.035348791629076004,
-0.2706514000892639,
0.13961157202720642,
0.32083356380462646,
0.12381481379270554,
-0.24286127090454102,
0.3030489683151245,
0.27773144841194153,
0.3768347501754761,
-0.06376521289348602,
0.13869044184684753,
0.4392281770706177,
0.005568991415202618,
-0.0726848766207695,
-0.37029314041137695,
0.953820526599884,
1.0730515718460083,
0.4392904043197632,
-0.4151437282562256,
-0.2965613901615143,
-0.039535507559776306,
0.41215890645980835,
-0.781278669834137,
-0.05926132947206497,
0.17753756046295166,
-0.6803104877471924,
-0.44703012704849243,
0.4801200032234192,
-0.9901684522628784,
-0.3400244414806366,
-0.1477033495903015,
0.7705036997795105,
-0.32871392369270325,
-0.1782669574022293,
-0.0429043285548687,
-0.2621351182460785,
0.1398329883813858,
0.5190187096595764,
-0.29360297322273254,
0.21003443002700806,
0.2596864700317383,
1.2554106712341309,
-0.32241228222846985,
-0.3728877902030945,
-0.794807493686676,
-0.3010616600513458,
-0.4395524561405182,
1.078653335571289,
-0.4584885835647583,
-0.27696624398231506,
0.059000395238399506,
0.1692701131105423,
-0.02775590494275093,
-0.3366125524044037,
0.7202150821685791,
-0.4301097095012665,
0.19138790667057037,
-0.014219612814486027,
-0.4065566956996918,
-0.4945780038833618,
-0.14346128702163696,
-1.0237277746200562,
0.37583768367767334,
0.09493763744831085,
-0.8870818018913269,
0.538951575756073,
-1.0009654760360718,
-0.1779020130634308,
0.211421400308609,
0.1078551709651947,
-0.3715825080871582,
0.43249809741973877,
0.6218373775482178,
0.46495240926742554,
-0.4595946669578552,
0.09967450797557831,
-0.4564518332481384,
-0.7008882164955139,
0.4363384544849396,
-0.45318010449409485,
0.3627285659313202,
0.3780154287815094,
-0.12302382290363312,
0.49826580286026,
-0.2329271137714386,
-0.1028650552034378,
0.29389265179634094,
0.1482032835483551,
0.0449802428483963,
-0.12460164725780487,
0.04087108373641968,
0.15328332781791687,
-0.01752537302672863,
-0.46617817878723145,
-0.24945415556430817,
-0.08580697327852249,
0.4962790608406067,
0.5349058508872986,
0.15361641347408295,
0.5740444660186768,
-0.6588965058326721,
0.7053124904632568,
0.174042746424675,
0.4257866144180298,
-0.6270378232002258,
-0.38921624422073364,
-0.7249523401260376,
-0.6663351655006409,
0.16457918286323547,
0.24214911460876465,
-0.7890538573265076,
0.0024716388434171677,
-0.615081787109375,
-0.5084530115127563,
-0.8481088876724243,
0.3653769791126251,
0.24094179272651672,
0.45417720079421997,
0.5132340788841248,
-0.6037235856056213,
0.0946035087108612,
-1.3285022974014282,
-0.25223079323768616,
0.14185424149036407,
-0.024442415684461594,
0.2327217161655426,
0.26728305220603943,
0.22159741818904877,
0.5732515454292297,
-0.3790510296821594,
-0.6937049031257629,
-0.1257622241973877,
0.1792610138654709,
-0.028873899951577187,
0.3121046721935272,
0.7531181573867798,
-0.9286431074142456,
-0.08819501847028732,
-0.2152283638715744,
-0.6343113780021667,
-0.06607750058174133,
-0.3289983868598938,
-0.3413498103618622,
0.05647905543446541,
0.5830904245376587,
-0.634594738483429,
0.2070997655391693,
0.3030334711074829,
0.027164820581674576,
0.6277356147766113,
-0.46858274936676025,
0.395699679851532,
-0.49889665842056274,
0.021589744836091995,
0.27162954211235046,
-0.40744009613990784,
-0.22089344263076782,
0.5622090101242065,
0.0653434470295906,
-0.1529192179441452,
-0.5998356938362122,
0.5997456312179565,
-0.4480535686016083,
0.09476040303707123,
0.048204436898231506,
0.5159355401992798,
0.47622278332710266,
0.48480331897735596,
0.07753311097621918,
0.5876554250717163,
0.6243190765380859,
-0.22926394641399384,
0.2643318772315979,
-0.007700467016547918,
-0.6900634765625,
0.744909942150116,
-0.6083875894546509,
0.18070435523986816,
-0.4928545653820038,
0.1700933426618576,
-1.4619120359420776,
-0.013295409269630909,
0.07562322914600372,
-0.3248085677623749,
0.17277838289737701,
-0.28138601779937744,
-0.4674147963523865,
-0.41590747237205505,
-0.35232987999916077,
0.2985113263130188,
0.23997905850410461,
-0.6711917519569397,
0.5191136598587036,
-0.10356473922729492,
-0.006401954684406519,
-0.4446530044078827,
-0.6288272738456726,
-0.09469299018383026,
-0.5344716906547546,
-0.6723396182060242,
0.23840472102165222,
-0.42586416006088257,
-0.04906582832336426,
-0.16392207145690918,
-0.24972957372665405,
-0.2768881022930145,
-0.16564394533634186,
0.5393722057342529,
0.31327369809150696,
-0.2702474296092987,
0.36402735114097595,
-0.10626261681318283,
-0.20329277217388153,
0.12703828513622284,
-0.20547381043434143,
0.005122365429997444,
-0.6031091809272766,
-0.3280845284461975,
-0.5720732808113098,
0.29603585600852966,
1.2291233539581299,
-0.39547866582870483,
0.5324998497962952,
1.0879968404769897,
-0.10120672732591629,
-0.028263652697205544,
-0.4384058117866516,
-0.026838509365916252,
-0.37057846784591675,
0.10246603935956955,
-0.4637407064437866,
-0.4280637800693512,
0.433799684047699,
0.026038235053420067,
0.1994607299566269,
0.49062564969062805,
0.24042251706123352,
-0.1745092272758484,
0.7883074879646301,
0.19998444616794586,
0.3500518798828125,
0.2188173532485962,
-0.2179042398929596,
0.354123592376709,
-0.2272127866744995,
-0.08751417696475983,
-0.2383265495300293,
-0.3180011510848999,
-0.2316923290491104,
-0.6998129487037659,
0.21738022565841675,
0.11109833419322968,
0.15498223900794983,
-0.0910508781671524,
-0.3140042722225189,
0.6287330389022827,
0.3380443751811981,
0.1754019856452942,
0.24478833377361298,
0.22818799316883087,
-0.31967610120773315,
-0.13556213676929474,
-0.4003397226333618,
-0.4751484990119934,
0.7051683664321899,
0.46944737434387207,
0.4895589053630829,
0.17834094166755676,
0.5218145251274109,
0.6289295554161072,
0.6474485397338867,
-0.9087907075881958,
0.32257187366485596,
-0.26365017890930176,
-0.6501644253730774,
-0.035989370197057724,
-0.5890771746635437,
-0.6536787152290344,
0.5277978181838989,
-0.39735445380210876,
-0.5016177296638489,
-0.1628890484571457,
0.3989926278591156,
-0.3000771403312683,
0.263325959444046,
-0.9161930084228516,
1.067699909210205,
-0.5690914392471313,
-0.6374412178993225,
-0.0999021902680397,
-0.5147820115089417,
0.4201400578022003,
-0.0742967501282692,
0.8949195742607117,
-0.2939428687095642,
-0.07038087397813797,
0.5831751823425293,
-0.49969643354415894,
0.5825097560882568,
-0.6195934414863586,
0.11858291178941727,
0.3843499422073364,
0.3998092710971832,
-0.17709213495254517,
0.07111629098653793,
0.09593535959720612,
0.3966689705848694,
0.39100590348243713,
-0.42356011271476746,
-0.8558904528617859,
0.8304168581962585,
-0.5929535627365112,
-0.31366050243377686,
-0.04807571694254875,
-0.6685464382171631,
-0.12716105580329895,
0.1309199035167694,
0.31741899251937866,
0.6337025761604309,
0.21428924798965454,
0.03793364763259888,
0.18860933184623718,
-0.38805797696113586,
0.20110927522182465,
0.3180212378501892,
-0.37353891134262085,
-0.5960009098052979,
1.1348170042037964,
-0.16759534180164337,
0.11221352964639664,
0.7204267978668213,
0.31389525532722473,
-0.5522786974906921,
-0.2869613468647003,
-0.5645885467529297,
0.3632851243019104,
-0.8163110017776489,
-0.28457000851631165,
-0.22182345390319824,
0.19515858590602875,
0.2384192943572998,
-0.5233029127120972,
-0.2699476480484009,
-0.611280083656311,
0.08215539157390594,
-0.14936308562755585,
0.10001545399427414,
0.3601714074611664,
0.1515042781829834,
0.25897160172462463,
-0.8444429636001587,
0.38774922490119934,
0.16111864149570465,
0.6356667280197144,
0.2692963480949402,
-0.5010138750076294,
0.01558417547494173,
-0.09293456375598907,
-0.2130904495716095,
-0.6823920607566833,
0.16394859552383423,
0.4479994475841522,
0.4950565695762634,
0.8126423954963684,
0.023896316066384315,
0.7943616509437561,
-0.264871209859848,
0.7785205245018005,
0.5051179528236389,
-1.159671425819397,
0.23109668493270874,
-0.20597268640995026,
0.46459466218948364,
0.39857855439186096,
0.35178661346435547,
-0.1876029223203659,
-0.3075233995914459,
-0.4875808358192444,
-0.9947407245635986,
0.3956553637981415,
0.07942238450050354,
0.3782265782356262,
0.04403121396899223,
0.3676415979862213,
0.5284972786903381,
0.2289695143699646,
-0.8252636790275574,
0.008752611465752125,
-0.5409263968467712,
-0.08632639050483704,
-0.34309619665145874,
0.0036830054596066475,
-0.26816418766975403,
-0.2116343230009079,
0.49057909846305847,
-0.2764062285423279,
0.6406762599945068,
0.39087048172950745,
-0.518961489200592,
-0.30178576707839966,
0.2551054060459137,
0.9118717312812805,
0.8675118684768677,
-0.3973240256309509,
0.2660508453845978,
-0.23238001763820648,
0.03270144760608673,
-0.2457919865846634,
0.05675998702645302,
0.21220265328884125,
0.203142449259758,
0.8842793107032776,
0.7530296444892883,
0.273367315530777,
-0.7141669392585754,
0.9109753966331482,
-0.2117532640695572,
-0.7322405576705933,
-0.24567605555057526,
-0.1705605536699295,
-0.04715568944811821,
0.05699862167239189,
0.2958679795265198,
0.48535946011543274,
-0.08733512461185455,
-0.20123712718486786,
0.3114807903766632,
0.21570369601249695,
-0.977989912033081,
-0.23387505114078522,
0.945633053779602,
0.25731533765792847,
0.018951600417494774,
0.25210848450660706,
-0.09942878782749176,
-0.22523386776447296,
0.4075322151184082,
0.09822408854961395,
0.7978485226631165,
0.16890285909175873,
0.546627402305603,
0.35987618565559387,
0.4191594123840332,
0.2356298267841339,
0.37097951769828796,
-0.08229783177375793,
-0.5744364857673645,
-0.34093421697616577,
-0.5802400708198547,
-0.13843537867069244,
0.097770556807518,
-0.7994717955589294,
0.046063847839832306,
-0.5262132287025452,
0.04083032160997391,
0.6234964728355408,
-0.5271950960159302,
-1.0289311408996582,
0.1713453233242035,
0.11276457458734512,
1.2332628965377808,
-0.7908863425254822,
0.17704372107982635,
0.6564498543739319,
-0.9350466728210449,
-0.4881497919559479,
-0.14538651704788208,
0.11779788881540298,
-0.8565099835395813,
0.4668137729167938,
0.623559832572937,
-0.32357779145240784,
-0.3355771601200104,
-0.5410429239273071,
-0.1722714602947235,
0.9091433882713318,
0.4311468303203583,
-0.3861349821090698,
0.17175894975662231,
-0.21811755001544952,
0.5966830253601074,
-0.7363258004188538,
0.38783156871795654,
0.0965484231710434,
0.594237744808197,
0.07977074384689331,
-0.5624808669090271,
0.11304423958063126,
-0.4069935977458954,
-0.28189197182655334,
0.09629224985837936,
-0.7469242215156555,
0.3256024122238159,
-0.6885355114936829,
-0.08376533538103104,
0.26300033926963806,
0.44732242822647095,
-0.4907098710536957,
0.4954603612422943,
0.8645056486129761,
0.21190930902957916,
0.43855181336402893,
-0.30146825313568115,
1.27783203125,
-0.18175756931304932,
0.3562218248844147,
0.8790099024772644,
0.06252240389585495,
0.710794985294342,
0.5887963175773621,
-0.0743313655257225,
0.6431400775909424,
0.4637915790081024,
-0.214665487408638,
0.5260487794876099,
0.15593509376049042,
-0.0808037593960762,
-0.5297671556472778,
0.005333532579243183,
0.17000547051429749,
0.5101896524429321,
0.1546882539987564,
-0.796032726764679,
-0.21725022792816162,
0.0012017892440780997,
-0.24512656033039093,
0.1736280769109726,
-0.29924723505973816,
0.47938063740730286,
0.2399148792028427,
-0.62236088514328,
0.6400768160820007,
-0.20789028704166412,
0.1019042432308197,
-0.6086830496788025,
0.0067968000657856464,
-0.11651814728975296,
0.2417088896036148,
-0.4075435400009155,
-0.7858996391296387,
0.1777542531490326,
-0.10062310844659805,
-0.3286241590976715,
-0.10811653733253479,
0.12528611719608307,
-0.43458008766174316,
-0.5636639595031738,
0.28592976927757263,
0.4786151349544525,
0.4861226975917816,
-0.18831539154052734,
-0.6942078471183777,
-0.053085457533597946,
-0.011260458268225193,
0.329529732465744,
-0.08011772483587265,
0.24726161360740662,
-0.1797155737876892,
0.809382975101471,
0.613308846950531,
-0.2103443741798401,
-0.2835877537727356,
0.5872901082038879,
0.3196176588535309,
-0.1673050969839096,
-0.3191387355327606,
-0.5838358402252197,
0.7068042755126953,
-0.00021227232355158776,
0.05398019775748253,
0.2781420648097992,
0.4828515648841858,
0.348538875579834,
-0.586033284664154,
0.8220415115356445,
0.18832336366176605,
0.23081998527050018,
-0.44893714785575867,
0.6895781755447388,
-0.9923790693283081,
0.06234482675790787,
-0.5976933836936951,
-1.1259303092956543,
-0.5766156911849976,
0.6894267201423645,
-0.2506686747074127,
-0.06487566977739334,
0.7806310057640076,
0.7678121328353882,
-0.3771238327026367,
-0.14712239801883698,
0.39319345355033875,
0.012375942431390285,
0.24732425808906555,
0.17761260271072388,
0.7057809829711914,
-0.21798890829086304,
1.0175790786743164,
-0.3305114507675171,
-0.3338230848312378,
-0.08883938938379288,
-1.1821906566619873,
-0.8463570475578308,
-0.7116844058036804,
-0.6548323631286621,
-0.09322015941143036,
-0.12021060287952423,
0.5889157056808472,
0.7495335936546326,
-0.7808683514595032,
0.16547420620918274,
0.27495068311691284,
0.09744539856910706,
-0.7166463732719421,
-0.34195759892463684,
0.44319388270378113,
-0.1731349527835846,
-0.6315518021583557,
0.09422194212675095,
0.45747822523117065,
-0.05564035847783089,
-0.19228577613830566,
-0.19381895661354065,
0.06299684196710587,
0.3348880708217621,
0.41970154643058777,
0.011717133224010468,
-0.8805248737335205,
-0.41273680329322815,
-0.26764753460884094,
0.46134331822395325,
0.1714721918106079,
0.7707035541534424,
-0.15646488964557648,
1.116958498954773,
0.22958242893218994,
0.18641923367977142,
0.3767632246017456,
0.31858184933662415,
0.5978352427482605,
-0.7175655961036682,
0.02289542183279991,
-0.47327712178230286,
0.6641127467155457,
0.6448066234588623,
-0.06336760520935059,
0.46068698167800903,
0.28520673513412476,
-0.2969907820224762,
-0.486848384141922,
0.03925372660160065,
-1.2612755298614502,
0.010483969934284687,
0.5391930937767029,
-0.5427182912826538,
0.04574495181441307,
0.2615700662136078,
-0.33701494336128235,
-0.13119541108608246,
-0.3780730366706848,
0.7808634638786316,
0.8887408375740051,
-0.03921690583229065,
-0.552598774433136,
-0.5988550782203674,
0.23674970865249634,
0.2062911093235016,
-0.499906063079834,
-0.10988536477088928,
0.6047370433807373,
0.5740967988967896,
0.5183869004249573,
0.27944687008857727,
-0.549135684967041,
0.5770923495292664,
-0.09442909806966782,
0.06653362512588501,
-0.5257923007011414,
-0.3157133162021637,
-0.1276739090681076,
0.4755687415599823,
0.1735750287771225,
-0.3951273560523987
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.06000v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.06000v1
|
ThaiCoref: Thai Coreference Resolution Dataset
| 2024-06-10T03:47:24 | 2024-06-10T03:47:24 |
Pontakorn Trakuekul, Wei Qi Leong, Charin Polpanumas, Jitkapat Sawatphol, William Chandra Tjhi, Attapol T. Rutherford
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
While coreference resolution is a well-established research area in Natural
Language Processing (NLP), research focusing on Thai language remains limited
due to the lack of large annotated corpora. In this work, we introduce
ThaiCoref, a dataset for Thai coreference resolution. Our dataset comprises
777,271 tokens, 44,082 mentions and 10,429 entities across four text genres:
university essays, newspapers, speeches, and Wikipedia. Our annotation scheme
is built upon the OntoNotes benchmark with adjustments to address Thai-specific
phenomena. Utilizing ThaiCoref, we train models employing a multilingual
encoder and cross-lingual transfer techniques, achieving a best F1 score of
67.88\% on the test set. Error analysis reveals challenges posed by Thai's
unique linguistic features. To benefit the NLP community, we make the dataset
and the model publicly available at http://www.github.com/nlp-chula/thai-coref .
|
[
-0.6447734832763672,
-0.45864465832710266,
0.05340737849473953,
0.2718275189399719,
-0.4228501319885254,
0.14617861807346344,
-0.7369254231452942,
-0.6233102083206177,
0.2762378752231598,
0.7424109578132629,
-0.08955438435077667,
-0.7676834464073181,
-0.703325092792511,
0.6496249437332153,
0.04555192217230797,
0.8683414459228516,
-0.20583663880825043,
0.09970242530107498,
0.033737704157829285,
-0.5893856883049011,
-0.3769809305667877,
-0.7345706224441528,
-0.2785018980503082,
-0.4391176104545593,
0.27577105164527893,
1.323562502861023,
0.36240261793136597,
0.5651158094406128,
0.7802823185920715,
0.06835635006427765,
0.14208437502384186,
0.16250160336494446,
-0.24490758776664734,
0.20529668033123016,
-0.2998806834220886,
-0.29815030097961426,
-0.37230658531188965,
-0.12649735808372498,
0.4873666763305664,
0.6946148872375488,
0.19535386562347412,
0.2708282172679901,
-0.23607489466667175,
0.7109686732292175,
-0.6889784932136536,
0.45726436376571655,
-0.28030499815940857,
0.078108049929142,
-0.2738092243671417,
-0.06580684334039688,
-0.2144613265991211,
-0.3552774488925934,
0.36478155851364136,
-0.520203173160553,
0.1829260140657425,
-0.03154607489705086,
0.7572965621948242,
0.10615117102861404,
-0.6210827231407166,
-0.5710761547088623,
-0.3933022916316986,
0.5467201471328735,
-0.3413412570953369,
0.36836594343185425,
0.7588688731193542,
0.22866091132164001,
0.2922777831554413,
-0.4604877531528473,
-0.4767312705516815,
-0.015874508768320084,
-0.07125114649534225,
-0.04951610043644905,
0.05805728957056999,
0.19211725890636444,
0.18823638558387756,
0.6866979598999023,
-0.5945190787315369,
0.15788093209266663,
-0.29341670870780945,
-0.27594226598739624,
0.37508267164230347,
-0.2941741943359375,
0.01146116852760315,
-0.8473677635192871,
-0.009437918663024902,
0.0164275411516428,
-0.6563406586647034,
-0.056147392839193344,
0.06215042620897293,
0.503757894039154,
0.06926782429218292,
0.922924816608429,
-0.2782570421695709,
0.3264301121234894,
0.3924376964569092,
-0.28587064146995544,
0.09769607335329056,
-0.5439709424972534,
-0.01599692553281784,
0.7662602066993713,
0.5417259931564331,
0.8310568928718567,
0.6536305546760559,
-0.06032882258296013,
0.1367347687482834,
0.016221895813941956,
-0.08652645349502563,
-0.8694339990615845,
-0.46623605489730835,
0.3106823265552521,
-0.06830818206071854,
-0.11297597736120224,
-0.06279665976762772,
-0.7593693137168884,
-0.3941296637058258,
-0.3003867268562317,
-0.2803656756877899,
-0.5287516117095947,
-0.577043354511261,
0.1268785446882248,
0.02487330138683319,
0.11347553879022598,
-0.03179977834224701,
-0.3868032991886139,
0.21787813305854797,
0.43071720004081726,
0.8677339553833008,
-0.08950759470462799,
-0.06080537289381027,
-0.40017563104629517,
0.16187016665935516,
-0.30772489309310913,
0.9263344407081604,
-0.8411658406257629,
-0.856781542301178,
0.042962074279785156,
-0.10452616959810257,
0.19484464824199677,
-0.8093833327293396,
1.1230260133743286,
-0.245157852768898,
-0.09615366905927658,
-0.6807367205619812,
-0.5691962242126465,
-0.4290775656700134,
0.41509300470352173,
-0.962565541267395,
1.1237518787384033,
0.1139756515622139,
-1.0749015808105469,
0.3342757523059845,
-0.8766481280326843,
-0.3379552662372589,
0.07888646423816681,
0.14382286369800568,
-0.09501369297504425,
-0.06677853316068649,
0.5417653322219849,
0.4989195764064789,
-0.3770386874675751,
0.3584561049938202,
-0.2001761645078659,
0.1788850724697113,
0.054658081382513046,
0.3953263461589813,
0.554375946521759,
0.12951911985874176,
-0.06407871097326279,
-0.02354646660387516,
-0.9434912800788879,
-0.1482802927494049,
-0.29744455218315125,
-0.17838409543037415,
-0.5839336514472961,
-0.6598111391067505,
0.48861855268478394,
0.3609180748462677,
0.17953263223171234,
-0.6607438325881958,
0.302340030670166,
-0.032592497766017914,
0.31793949007987976,
0.31979840993881226,
0.27570775151252747,
0.45173248648643494,
-0.03160404786467552,
0.4916343092918396,
0.6277147531509399,
-0.4301886558532715,
-0.37299802899360657,
-0.4343489110469818,
-0.6604228615760803,
-0.28745412826538086,
0.539624810218811,
0.44559186697006226,
-0.6307135820388794,
0.5080864429473877,
-0.6034783124923706,
-0.688690185546875,
-0.5427432060241699,
0.14364741742610931,
0.3249802887439728,
0.7358823418617249,
0.3297489285469055,
-0.42052707076072693,
-1.2539784908294678,
-0.9618511199951172,
-0.22402073442935944,
-0.4682372510433197,
0.253832072019577,
0.34889739751815796,
0.7225149273872375,
-0.19481001794338226,
1.1488474607467651,
-0.23016119003295898,
-0.6701736450195312,
-0.21566279232501984,
0.3256773352622986,
-0.09939640760421753,
0.7049795985221863,
0.5124654769897461,
-0.7848343849182129,
-0.44155120849609375,
0.1695142686367035,
-0.5908087491989136,
-0.22746603190898895,
0.3708181083202362,
-0.03969815745949745,
0.011835066601634026,
0.1686033010482788,
-0.520814061164856,
0.1494496762752533,
0.4666904807090759,
-0.11362279951572418,
0.9584668278694153,
0.07462283223867416,
0.45525768399238586,
-1.1208908557891846,
0.23859678208827972,
0.32281798124313354,
-0.4686155319213867,
-0.2207612246274948,
0.033629510551691055,
0.05933578684926033,
-0.24384191632270813,
-0.12159668654203415,
0.5078719258308411,
-0.3110998570919037,
0.06399431079626083,
-0.20799317955970764,
0.1944817304611206,
-0.04442569240927696,
0.3274506628513336,
0.4890058934688568,
0.8288596868515015,
0.4149254858493805,
-0.585224449634552,
0.4992523789405823,
0.27258530259132385,
-0.2777829170227051,
1.218444585800171,
-0.4540044367313385,
0.26792454719543457,
0.1168999895453453,
0.3860204517841339,
-0.7126985192298889,
-0.4052030146121979,
0.15159448981285095,
-0.3582141697406769,
0.08871842920780182,
-0.17393602430820465,
-0.6279891729354858,
-0.1314852237701416,
-0.164162740111351,
0.7061821222305298,
-0.08376722037792206,
-0.524980902671814,
0.46288037300109863,
0.6504532098770142,
-0.14635777473449707,
-0.5100321769714355,
-0.5361359715461731,
0.3838580250740051,
-0.29017332196235657,
-0.20580895245075226,
0.3400082588195801,
0.09613413363695145,
-0.31289514899253845,
0.15840554237365723,
-0.023998579010367393,
-0.42604973912239075,
-0.4088459610939026,
0.4288857579231262,
-0.1558375507593155,
-0.5226752758026123,
0.15835407376289368,
-0.29283860325813293,
-0.21383658051490784,
0.006201063748449087,
-0.4060688018798828,
0.25229689478874207,
-0.3693320155143738,
-0.0793888047337532,
-0.14421699941158295,
0.4779205620288849,
0.49333932995796204,
-0.3712719976902008,
0.4349915385246277,
0.5278605222702026,
-0.8195703625679016,
0.2559024691581726,
-0.7501195073127747,
-0.056358445435762405,
-0.32661011815071106,
0.5434377193450928,
-0.7579623460769653,
-0.9728811979293823,
0.6648761630058289,
-0.22016212344169617,
0.0475875623524189,
0.4369114935398102,
0.5507994294166565,
0.3208664357662201,
0.507464587688446,
0.617696225643158,
-0.17310228943824768,
0.06030287221074104,
-0.046613190323114395,
0.2187637835741043,
-0.8276299238204956,
-0.17794504761695862,
-0.8423493504524231,
-0.2107863873243332,
-0.506544291973114,
-0.6360282897949219,
-0.06387647241353989,
0.5015323162078857,
-0.150003120303154,
0.7050304412841797,
-0.44111141562461853,
0.43933796882629395,
0.32037076354026794,
-0.1167743131518364,
0.7172037363052368,
-0.20553302764892578,
-0.348541796207428,
-0.5385004281997681,
-0.4934769570827484,
-0.7393652200698853,
1.1015293598175049,
0.04785803332924843,
0.3140299618244171,
-0.04068436846137047,
0.3462672829627991,
0.3725144863128662,
0.2994885742664337,
-0.7223843336105347,
0.4304782450199127,
-0.015138496644794941,
-0.614997386932373,
0.12927387654781342,
-0.3835134506225586,
-0.46418240666389465,
-0.33692026138305664,
0.3346191346645355,
-0.6088282465934753,
0.2680269181728363,
-0.1260061264038086,
0.019717341288924217,
0.35702773928642273,
-0.6189345717430115,
0.6928502321243286,
0.10210337489843369,
0.11652229726314545,
-0.18830500543117523,
-0.34763601422309875,
0.6034262776374817,
-0.14084133505821228,
0.014630571007728577,
-0.31519511342048645,
-0.027713719755411148,
1.0201983451843262,
-0.07904253900051117,
0.7846079468727112,
0.03442877531051636,
-0.014995717443525791,
0.25471702218055725,
0.180973082780838,
0.06949306279420853,
0.48480814695358276,
-0.22082781791687012,
0.24941924214363098,
0.1286325752735138,
-0.5492979884147644,
-0.2956598401069641,
0.9303318858146667,
-0.6437128782272339,
-0.06254668533802032,
-0.46062713861465454,
-0.30076855421066284,
-0.20518191158771515,
0.15539167821407318,
0.321735680103302,
0.21230585873126984,
-0.2754691541194916,
0.21234692633152008,
0.3961586356163025,
0.1643839031457901,
0.30643969774246216,
0.47882795333862305,
-0.4004766643047333,
-0.7623299956321716,
0.6070360541343689,
0.46146315336227417,
-0.20315876603126526,
0.3273933529853821,
-0.14665213227272034,
-0.6023377180099487,
-0.10216747224330902,
-0.42632412910461426,
0.4316234588623047,
-1.1837924718856812,
-0.440288782119751,
-0.5059191584587097,
-0.02384057454764843,
-0.5828697085380554,
-0.06628675013780594,
-0.6363661885261536,
-0.6964068412780762,
-0.3501676619052887,
-0.538370668888092,
0.5501894950866699,
0.7036375999450684,
-0.19010892510414124,
0.05949009209871292,
-0.536230742931366,
0.25790536403656006,
-0.12323445081710815,
0.49996042251586914,
-0.261200487613678,
-0.44838088750839233,
-0.3832883834838867,
-0.008590477518737316,
-0.008683141320943832,
-0.9143157601356506,
0.12114352732896805,
0.6494854688644409,
0.15031948685646057,
0.44405636191368103,
0.6859145760536194,
0.9126070141792297,
-0.09117275476455688,
0.7873643040657043,
0.17910782992839813,
-0.9673432111740112,
0.7469623684883118,
0.018943604081869125,
0.4188680350780487,
0.6691961288452148,
0.6429069638252258,
-0.9994899034500122,
-0.2814045548439026,
-0.6044201850891113,
-0.5119236707687378,
0.12213889509439468,
-0.006480385083705187,
-0.40883898735046387,
-0.11322104930877686,
0.7154488563537598,
0.30557194352149963,
0.14298690855503082,
-0.42891788482666016,
-0.16394734382629395,
-0.4089156687259674,
-0.15046973526477814,
-0.1577959954738617,
-0.4189831614494324,
0.038744859397411346,
-0.33186075091362,
0.6650074124336243,
-0.42817333340644836,
-0.07143079489469528,
0.5347551107406616,
-0.5911802053451538,
-0.21053114533424377,
0.20550747215747833,
0.5569015145301819,
0.8009527325630188,
-0.1329248547554016,
0.6161218285560608,
0.005630103405565023,
-0.8204020857810974,
0.24788062274456024,
-0.05036269873380661,
0.16930891573429108,
0.3470260500907898,
0.46333521604537964,
0.29745715856552124,
0.49320751428604126,
-0.8302904367446899,
0.05388300493359566,
-0.03441053628921509,
0.030874982476234436,
-0.4267699420452118,
-0.24055245518684387,
0.07989797741174698,
-0.13162416219711304,
0.5816583633422852,
0.15546001493930817,
-0.1497277021408081,
-0.12105963379144669,
0.5575433373451233,
-0.29907044768333435,
-0.6915913224220276,
-0.6730251312255859,
0.3488324284553528,
0.35829392075538635,
-0.1812894344329834,
0.7085613012313843,
-0.13730376958847046,
-0.8975845575332642,
0.23727810382843018,
0.27351221442222595,
0.7668899893760681,
-0.16541853547096252,
0.27999940514564514,
1.0146536827087402,
0.17466601729393005,
0.04254170134663582,
0.1188436895608902,
-0.08132848888635635,
-0.7691787481307983,
-0.5900730490684509,
-0.5855810046195984,
-0.6015399694442749,
-0.027259698137640953,
-0.8467016816139221,
0.3395328223705292,
-0.44777151942253113,
-0.3098309636116028,
-0.07360686361789703,
0.7492954134941101,
-0.6937598586082458,
0.22079108655452728,
-0.18791326880455017,
0.9584674835205078,
-0.8031424283981323,
0.9412655234336853,
1.0000888109207153,
-0.5232867002487183,
-0.36792221665382385,
-0.337521493434906,
-0.06755169481039047,
-0.3949931561946869,
0.7804761528968811,
0.4006233215332031,
0.10445082932710648,
0.05796242877840996,
-0.3039250671863556,
-0.4950280785560608,
0.6056275367736816,
0.5198070406913757,
-0.31152087450027466,
0.0020494461059570312,
0.43232592940330505,
0.34636154770851135,
-0.616409420967102,
0.2983347773551941,
1.0355788469314575,
0.756535530090332,
-0.3423706889152527,
-1.294709324836731,
0.036845315247774124,
-0.4449314475059509,
-0.1000383049249649,
-0.4163982570171356,
-0.4208262264728546,
0.4268154203891754,
-0.12415870279073715,
-0.0815330371260643,
-0.1885598748922348,
1.0197056531906128,
0.2934524118900299,
-0.04499850422143936,
0.44892415404319763,
0.7556402087211609,
0.7675542831420898,
-0.21535594761371613,
0.5343702435493469,
-0.4175138771533966,
0.3974604308605194,
1.095759630203247,
-0.40850552916526794,
0.8138245940208435,
0.5714191794395447,
0.062199417501688004,
0.2812502384185791,
1.0185356140136719,
0.3659089505672455,
0.31759563088417053,
-0.0920390635728836,
-0.27199500799179077,
-0.20730428397655487,
-0.831741213798523,
-0.4252646267414093,
0.5388652682304382,
0.4230574071407318,
-0.03704969957470894,
-0.4473847448825836,
0.5031870007514954,
0.08214836567640305,
0.2271919995546341,
-0.3075278699398041,
0.5687331557273865,
0.06712309271097183,
-0.6641963720321655,
0.25709375739097595,
0.07343393564224243,
0.6045997738838196,
-0.2211609184741974,
-0.1354743242263794,
-0.17997105419635773,
0.19514106214046478,
-0.327109158039093,
-0.7937102913856506,
0.34220749139785767,
0.1223517656326294,
-0.4492398798465729,
-0.014987577684223652,
0.6685663461685181,
-0.4919764995574951,
-0.5402625799179077,
0.3431060314178467,
0.2723076045513153,
0.16568709909915924,
-0.3151616156101227,
-0.4833137094974518,
-0.014141804538667202,
-0.23708085715770721,
-0.07199426740407944,
0.006915499921888113,
0.7405714988708496,
-0.05921284109354019,
0.5981890559196472,
0.4187922775745392,
0.3149508535861969,
0.15667028725147247,
-0.087076835334301,
0.6554285883903503,
-0.7394495606422424,
-0.5491114854812622,
-0.4093807339668274,
0.11874455213546753,
-0.11350135505199432,
-0.9586015939712524,
0.6664553284645081,
0.8450967073440552,
0.979444682598114,
0.08054105937480927,
0.8220926523208618,
-0.07623032480478287,
0.7533435225486755,
-0.26233479380607605,
0.40956324338912964,
-0.02040255442261696,
0.181380033493042,
-0.2674393057823181,
-0.7678470015525818,
-0.4940412938594818,
0.6171664595603943,
-0.35537371039390564,
-0.04000607877969742,
0.6853598356246948,
0.5709365606307983,
-0.07221637666225433,
0.4484151303768158,
0.18065808713436127,
0.18654346466064453,
0.4599997103214264,
0.4942097067832947,
0.32269948720932007,
-0.39318814873695374,
0.49957871437072754,
-0.8708704113960266,
0.309245765209198,
-0.47847414016723633,
-0.9225251078605652,
-0.8137952089309692,
-1.0716826915740967,
-0.7001844644546509,
-0.39040881395339966,
-0.1044415757060051,
1.1042524576187134,
0.7476809620857239,
-1.1356451511383057,
-0.3444453775882721,
0.0971410870552063,
0.07438552379608154,
-0.34241655468940735,
-0.2645752429962158,
0.4949394166469574,
-0.17349757254123688,
-0.7594351768493652,
-0.12609900534152985,
0.2779251039028168,
-0.2646423876285553,
-0.5149765610694885,
-0.20338523387908936,
-0.45358219742774963,
-0.45668500661849976,
0.41271552443504333,
0.3020174503326416,
-0.6941099762916565,
-0.6153777837753296,
0.013947048224508762,
-0.365114688873291,
0.4460565745830536,
1.1876726150512695,
-0.71551114320755,
0.6170530319213867,
0.1366725116968155,
0.7183709144592285,
0.39269837737083435,
-0.0760272741317749,
0.6427758932113647,
-0.9817832112312317,
0.23763908445835114,
0.5439473390579224,
0.3722362518310547,
0.7503105401992798,
-0.1873035579919815,
0.7182494401931763,
0.3624749779701233,
-0.32094645500183105,
-0.911138117313385,
0.10194171220064163,
-1.0026472806930542,
0.10899881273508072,
0.8772383332252502,
-0.42597365379333496,
-0.31800952553749084,
-0.6060523390769958,
-0.3867546021938324,
0.396646112203598,
-0.41190534830093384,
0.5097004175186157,
1.2257834672927856,
-0.010220257565379143,
-0.7225597500801086,
-0.2675262987613678,
0.49487408995628357,
0.1646069586277008,
-0.5447702407836914,
0.28835156559944153,
0.26496362686157227,
0.1097855195403099,
0.48306864500045776,
0.6091806292533875,
0.053730275481939316,
0.4999226927757263,
-0.013197004795074463,
0.1267990618944168,
-0.08957706391811371,
-0.21856150031089783,
-0.1272747963666916,
0.5397621989250183,
0.08014703541994095,
0.014834173023700714
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.05995v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.05995v1
|
A Dual-View Approach to Classifying Radiology Reports by Co-Training
| 2024-06-10T03:29:23 | 2024-06-10T03:29:23 |
Yutong Han, Yan Yuan, Lili Mou
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Radiology report analysis provides valuable information that can aid with
public health initiatives, and has been attracting increasing attention from
the research community. In this work, we present a novel insight that the
structure of a radiology report (namely, the Findings and Impression sections)
offers different views of a radiology scan. Based on this intuition, we further
propose a co-training approach, where two machine learning models are built
upon the Findings and Impression sections, respectively, and use each other's
information to boost performance with massive unlabeled data in a
semi-supervised manner. We conducted experiments in a public health
surveillance study, and results show that our co-training approach is able to
improve performance using the dual views and surpass competing supervised and
semi-supervised methods.
|
[
-0.11909732222557068,
-0.1355559378862381,
0.5961589813232422,
-0.10996532440185547,
-0.31881022453308105,
0.3378742039203644,
0.2459895759820938,
-0.8310301303863525,
0.522623598575592,
0.48577362298965454,
-0.08469155430793762,
-0.5608627200126648,
-0.9334771633148193,
-0.07104148715734482,
-0.2859189808368683,
0.914007842540741,
0.042934346944093704,
0.6844383478164673,
-0.5408664345741272,
-0.09422684460878372,
-0.39192917943000793,
-0.45025551319122314,
-0.5103775858879089,
-0.40567776560783386,
0.5912510752677917,
0.3367091119289398,
0.7386276125907898,
0.5041611194610596,
0.5629274249076843,
0.12733015418052673,
0.40300124883651733,
0.42923682928085327,
-0.1555013805627823,
-0.2849236726760864,
-0.021017367020249367,
-0.3182086646556854,
-0.1793145090341568,
0.34166419506073,
0.16287173330783844,
0.9082145094871521,
0.20494870841503143,
0.04423494264483452,
-0.11943645030260086,
0.6732195615768433,
-0.665276050567627,
0.32874730229377747,
0.12595461308956146,
0.2203485071659088,
0.13309690356254578,
-0.6834852695465088,
-0.7658653855323792,
-0.016276709735393524,
0.6194130182266235,
-0.32552823424339294,
0.38564321398735046,
0.0033746501430869102,
0.8171268701553345,
-0.0007012722198851407,
-0.7610578536987305,
-0.31766277551651,
-0.8298864364624023,
0.5287438035011292,
0.12883394956588745,
0.2052171379327774,
0.22945402562618256,
0.3742789328098297,
0.2963716685771942,
-0.8279809355735779,
0.19657811522483826,
-0.029709238559007645,
-0.7201675772666931,
0.5163930058479309,
-0.12417785823345184,
0.18282093107700348,
-0.08124390989542007,
0.41743704676628113,
-0.5811858177185059,
0.16465705633163452,
-0.49685731530189514,
-0.41787126660346985,
1.071596384048462,
0.10914609581232071,
0.5331324934959412,
-0.1335102617740631,
-0.6413369178771973,
-0.3016674816608429,
-0.2445491999387741,
0.13376352190971375,
-0.14025470614433289,
0.2573537230491638,
-0.5241310596466064,
0.08195586502552032,
-0.24090181291103363,
0.3556798994541168,
0.1388961672782898,
-0.18357299268245697,
0.5605440735816956,
0.06892174482345581,
-0.4254865348339081,
0.43362489342689514,
0.6009347438812256,
0.46223539113998413,
-0.542357861995697,
-0.2691419720649719,
-0.031017009168863297,
0.3489604592323303,
0.4541683495044708,
-0.6623944640159607,
-0.6674105525016785,
0.11386214941740036,
-0.7442445158958435,
-0.6944029331207275,
0.4049222767353058,
-0.7538360953330994,
-0.6576172113418579,
-0.5394060611724854,
0.5337930917739868,
-0.25307318568229675,
-0.3316859304904938,
0.29787713289260864,
-0.07610110193490982,
-0.2816498875617981,
0.8240997195243835,
-0.5189875960350037,
0.4690611958503723,
0.6894646286964417,
0.7139292359352112,
0.013624298386275768,
0.013448846526443958,
-0.7452298402786255,
0.24167633056640625,
-0.26160043478012085,
0.8656033277511597,
-0.7212268114089966,
-0.2699563801288605,
-0.11011768877506256,
-0.1844809502363205,
-0.3197861909866333,
-0.5903918743133545,
-0.005256942473351955,
-0.7388830184936523,
0.7354490756988525,
-0.03451152518391609,
-0.2733308672904968,
-0.509278416633606,
0.2537335455417633,
-0.5962041020393372,
0.7377927899360657,
0.176212877035141,
-1.1639903783798218,
0.6558545827865601,
-0.4374896287918091,
-0.60724276304245,
-0.0182192362844944,
-0.6667994260787964,
-0.8316041827201843,
0.1338788866996765,
0.35310500860214233,
0.36144712567329407,
-0.05524265393614769,
0.3270342946052551,
-0.07722094655036926,
-0.19099150598049164,
-0.014724013395607471,
0.023375535383820534,
0.6750612854957581,
-0.03569330647587776,
0.10253172367811203,
0.26564809679985046,
-0.6865245699882507,
0.0408061146736145,
0.007376886438578367,
-0.3238743245601654,
-0.6573328375816345,
-0.09698858112096786,
-0.2179204374551773,
0.07142438739538193,
-0.07689996063709259,
-0.5690658688545227,
-0.10245398432016373,
-0.4514358341693878,
-0.012161660939455032,
0.1810465306043625,
0.31529614329338074,
0.34692952036857605,
-0.6049216389656067,
0.3048153519630432,
0.3666583001613617,
0.329721063375473,
0.03859354555606842,
-0.4620957374572754,
-0.537351667881012,
-0.6082121133804321,
0.20843727886676788,
0.3358507454395294,
-0.5928009748458862,
0.11266683787107468,
-0.13810290396213531,
-0.4957488179206848,
-0.6370015144348145,
-0.3564615249633789,
0.6299644708633423,
0.607769787311554,
0.45637691020965576,
-0.9308458566665649,
-0.9001316428184509,
-1.0328099727630615,
-0.21615685522556305,
-0.04871300235390663,
0.08334529399871826,
0.2254948914051056,
0.4317529499530792,
0.026413435116410255,
0.48673418164253235,
-0.6695709228515625,
-0.3114657998085022,
-0.24147741496562958,
0.5319073796272278,
-0.008143271319568157,
0.21044455468654633,
0.4350406229496002,
-1.0966154336929321,
-0.7166473269462585,
-0.06903945654630661,
-0.8060042858123779,
0.2274494171142578,
0.06234748288989067,
0.03002217225730419,
0.07352503389120102,
0.3288184404373169,
0.3094029426574707,
0.8165696859359741,
0.5004903078079224,
-0.046721674501895905,
0.01025606133043766,
-0.6255622506141663,
0.2117864489555359,
-1.0654313564300537,
-0.22450602054595947,
0.16524100303649902,
-0.4712461531162262,
-0.669577419757843,
-0.321537047624588,
-0.022102711722254753,
-0.11984258145093918,
-0.15815261006355286,
-0.12226645648479462,
-0.6222309470176697,
-0.3957074284553528,
-0.199753075838089,
-0.5978279709815979,
0.24548722803592682,
0.3113698661327362,
0.5271002650260925,
0.3025919497013092,
0.7424586415290833,
-0.4225273132324219,
0.206589937210083,
0.02055029198527336,
-0.48829248547554016,
0.09480304270982742,
-0.19298385083675385,
0.6312733292579651,
-0.4183615744113922,
0.3521445691585541,
-0.8387981653213501,
-0.5538471341133118,
0.0709460973739624,
-0.47483381628990173,
0.7598366141319275,
-0.30021166801452637,
-0.22345618903636932,
-0.37512823939323425,
-0.4444437325000763,
0.08368517458438873,
0.3338127136230469,
-0.5615391731262207,
0.26328086853027344,
0.8250492215156555,
0.37939363718032837,
-0.5649157166481018,
-0.7519372701644897,
-0.03225697949528694,
-0.15615764260292053,
-0.649048388004303,
0.31514692306518555,
0.47835925221443176,
-0.22029241919517517,
0.19277650117874146,
-0.016532188281416893,
-0.27321168780326843,
0.10337496548891068,
0.5637075901031494,
0.6080132126808167,
-0.15478967130184174,
0.0050379023887217045,
-0.24190016090869904,
-0.22149235010147095,
0.16981270909309387,
-0.06518916040658951,
0.48355746269226074,
0.11464798450469971,
-0.2634964883327484,
-0.8423726558685303,
0.4477970600128174,
0.217978835105896,
-0.19535145163536072,
0.8172500729560852,
0.18932396173477173,
-0.08585318177938461,
-0.06498885899782181,
-0.1786729395389557,
-0.07133101671934128,
-0.32771989703178406,
0.5143583416938782,
-0.06257382780313492,
-0.6647516489028931,
-0.1417798399925232,
-0.05303775891661644,
-0.17140090465545654,
0.2732698619365692,
0.6407934427261353,
-0.47837167978286743,
0.9527574777603149,
0.9648017287254333,
-0.07493477314710617,
0.25259628891944885,
-0.24108146131038666,
0.006482183467596769,
-0.5271644592285156,
-0.7817971110343933,
-0.3264171779155731,
-0.2818508446216583,
-0.5364486575126648,
-0.5363089442253113,
0.8383211493492126,
-0.5428546071052551,
0.0746498852968216,
-0.1274346262216568,
-0.8299762606620789,
0.2500016987323761,
0.2942107319831848,
0.5782468318939209,
0.46984201669692993,
0.21352210640907288,
0.10035043209791183,
-0.05763066187500954,
-0.7460426688194275,
-0.36741676926612854,
1.2732173204421997,
0.40014365315437317,
0.6706437468528748,
-0.1875753402709961,
0.9802154898643494,
0.381517618894577,
0.3170962333679199,
-0.6865784525871277,
0.19852429628372192,
-0.5322474241256714,
-0.5281188488006592,
-0.09470675885677338,
-0.24221378564834595,
-0.9621696472167969,
0.44790783524513245,
-0.2657044231891632,
-0.4137900173664093,
0.1685393899679184,
0.20237676799297333,
-0.4651836156845093,
0.2050982564687729,
-0.8037165403366089,
0.48189133405685425,
-0.3613080680370331,
-0.20017556846141815,
-0.5936010479927063,
-0.776271641254425,
0.16476240754127502,
0.10880202800035477,
0.47363370656967163,
0.07669920474290848,
-0.037986379116773605,
0.9568966031074524,
-0.37491798400878906,
1.0908724069595337,
-0.4250101149082184,
0.42005667090415955,
0.24386490881443024,
-0.24820777773857117,
0.0022092917934060097,
0.33344706892967224,
0.39380037784576416,
0.05548599734902382,
0.10790693014860153,
-0.3514096736907959,
-0.41910499334335327,
0.1848313808441162,
-1.3904629945755005,
-0.47226589918136597,
-0.7967123985290527,
-0.8155147433280945,
-0.49473097920417786,
0.19787734746932983,
0.3892412483692169,
0.7603089213371277,
-0.17867016792297363,
-0.10625528544187546,
0.6218347549438477,
-0.29157623648643494,
-0.20492833852767944,
0.5478613972663879,
-0.2738586366176605,
-0.26176780462265015,
0.395466685295105,
0.35514336824417114,
0.2079293429851532,
0.9806782007217407,
0.4564162492752075,
0.07159122079610825,
-0.680102527141571,
0.0008735110750421882,
0.2304258495569229,
-0.4445936977863312,
0.08688949793577194,
-0.702473521232605,
-0.45783087611198425,
-0.5449972748756409,
0.08980309963226318,
-0.4548417031764984,
-0.07363872975111008,
0.1039896011352539,
0.14735627174377441,
0.11923685669898987,
0.9155067801475525,
-0.2664640545845032,
0.002928483998402953,
-0.5274803042411804,
0.10764741897583008,
0.3501380980014801,
0.15371529757976532,
-0.00516354339197278,
-0.5417729020118713,
-0.6000550985336304,
-0.08167529106140137,
-0.17443370819091797,
-0.6031997203826904,
0.3820331394672394,
-0.36927199363708496,
0.2876162528991699,
0.16668811440467834,
0.3429584205150604,
0.5878471732139587,
0.005029361695051193,
0.11197732388973236,
0.6187257766723633,
-0.2473127841949463,
0.6156400442123413,
-0.01126431580632925,
-0.09149277210235596,
0.6193493008613586,
0.5740716457366943,
-0.4805299639701843,
-0.1623944640159607,
-0.5906473398208618,
-0.48430925607681274,
1.159149169921875,
-0.18616023659706116,
-0.09491468220949173,
0.4530905783176422,
-0.11367902904748917,
0.3308162987232208,
-0.03631671518087387,
-0.09996339678764343,
-0.08439940214157104,
-0.12229104340076447,
-0.0076339757069945335,
0.02485845237970352,
-0.41816237568855286,
-0.6488866806030273,
-0.4002783000469208,
0.45478519797325134,
-0.053251445293426514,
0.3972572386264801,
0.3671911358833313,
-0.21075233817100525,
-0.144060418009758,
0.17130441963672638,
0.21568036079406738,
0.6811094284057617,
-0.5272365808486938,
0.7069144248962402,
-0.10991043597459793,
-0.7953529357910156,
-0.0750231221318245,
-0.3201374113559723,
-0.05256553739309311,
0.06726575642824173,
0.6948890089988708,
0.7746492624282837,
0.15208758413791656,
0.006999768316745758,
0.8063214421272278,
-0.24687054753303528,
-0.45271894335746765,
-0.35975298285484314,
0.011036530137062073,
-0.017528396099805832,
0.18979763984680176,
0.13749344646930695,
0.5574219822883606,
0.22617244720458984,
-0.9101573824882507,
0.2862253785133362,
0.09127466380596161,
-0.7108685970306396,
-0.5292906761169434,
0.3848155736923218,
0.18363873660564423,
0.16555263102054596,
0.6254646182060242,
0.036404550075531006,
-0.3372061252593994,
0.6845836043357849,
0.33648377656936646,
0.6245608925819397,
-0.03272243216633797,
0.40221187472343445,
0.4863894581794739,
-0.03989584371447563,
-0.07684897631406784,
0.03523974493145943,
0.16567690670490265,
-0.7123896479606628,
-0.40517646074295044,
-0.17894196510314941,
-0.34120774269104004,
0.33070671558380127,
-1.360517144203186,
0.5129786729812622,
-0.591401994228363,
0.16817884147167206,
0.4355621635913849,
0.2665068507194519,
-0.4173581004142761,
0.7541682124137878,
0.6541275382041931,
0.7850790619850159,
-1.0881855487823486,
1.1155835390090942,
1.0969666242599487,
-0.3466816842556,
-1.0415595769882202,
0.1384875774383545,
0.23910857737064362,
-1.2311882972717285,
0.5021530389785767,
0.5560659170150757,
-0.166621595621109,
-0.627836287021637,
-0.3741694688796997,
-0.6378759145736694,
1.0319904088974,
0.048748672008514404,
-0.39969292283058167,
-0.1208871379494667,
0.13563741743564606,
0.573284924030304,
-0.607037365436554,
0.15725575387477875,
0.2500821053981781,
-0.05191301926970482,
0.4519128203392029,
-0.8931331038475037,
-0.17656032741069794,
0.102237269282341,
-0.18210028111934662,
0.10945076495409012,
-0.8742479681968689,
0.5907881855964661,
-0.4709891378879547,
-0.34578096866607666,
-0.4071389436721802,
0.6903335452079773,
-0.07360483705997467,
1.073970079421997,
0.5729690194129944,
0.4660545587539673,
0.905302882194519,
0.2620486915111542,
1.0948609113693237,
0.07978415489196777,
0.5855183005332947,
1.3842087984085083,
-0.15809176862239838,
0.423144668340683,
0.2701629102230072,
-0.3117550313472748,
0.6555183529853821,
0.6224973201751709,
-0.23616762459278107,
1.0535895824432373,
-0.34822821617126465,
0.013494428247213364,
-0.4675118327140808,
-0.1659875512123108,
-0.38729768991470337,
0.7454456090927124,
0.13527381420135498,
-0.6237381100654602,
-0.29788458347320557,
0.08606153726577759,
0.1796574592590332,
0.22734709084033966,
-0.4891614615917206,
0.7894014716148376,
0.19800521433353424,
-0.4749722480773926,
0.13416635990142822,
-0.041577767580747604,
0.5424019694328308,
-0.2873452305793762,
0.2182028591632843,
-0.0148410489782691,
0.3387446105480194,
-0.6882575750350952,
-0.7218471169471741,
0.8167415857315063,
-0.05416963994503021,
-0.4093382954597473,
-0.3824794590473175,
0.7424752116203308,
0.004863427020609379,
-0.33479541540145874,
0.4177156090736389,
0.25283461809158325,
0.30964288115501404,
0.16853883862495422,
-0.3517484664916992,
-0.19044820964336395,
0.19064299762248993,
-0.014086552895605564,
0.8491523861885071,
0.11163049191236496,
-0.25132355093955994,
0.1147005707025528,
0.11618214100599289,
0.053984496742486954,
-0.35252273082733154,
0.09921452403068542,
0.8531085252761841,
-0.24402859807014465,
-0.8108189702033997,
-0.6759664416313171,
0.21703821420669556,
-0.2998332381248474,
0.03468030318617821,
0.5128864645957947,
1.2070903778076172,
0.9427168369293213,
0.09326829761266708,
1.010607361793518,
0.0002689728862605989,
1.0483691692352295,
-0.4460643529891968,
0.569251537322998,
-0.5732847452163696,
0.22945284843444824,
0.19686825573444366,
0.1385103315114975,
-0.4295179545879364,
0.19372022151947021,
-1.0488841533660889,
-0.23543286323547363,
0.7994847893714905,
0.793242871761322,
-0.07171495258808136,
0.24079017341136932,
0.37722235918045044,
0.05292864888906479,
0.041467905044555664,
0.8212214708328247,
1.05394446849823,
-0.2101798802614212,
0.32783207297325134,
-0.8043652176856995,
-0.31300079822540283,
-0.31874725222587585,
-0.13979952037334442,
-1.1063214540481567,
-0.4685353934764862,
-0.6753053665161133,
-0.5620578527450562,
-0.0738222673535347,
0.4482414424419403,
1.1243388652801514,
-0.6971477270126343,
-0.11637035757303238,
0.4187360405921936,
-0.3513493239879608,
0.022500300779938698,
-0.09426035732030869,
0.9107349514961243,
-0.02790200710296631,
-0.455934077501297,
0.17633192241191864,
0.6093218922615051,
-0.2618626356124878,
0.020688816905021667,
0.17172442376613617,
-0.07311882078647614,
-0.2646956741809845,
0.17779557406902313,
0.019112898036837578,
-0.13678599894046783,
-0.3332652151584625,
-0.4257475435733795,
-0.5411554574966431,
0.7281244993209839,
0.8872513771057129,
-1.016122817993164,
0.7178688645362854,
0.30140388011932373,
0.3321267068386078,
0.8667484521865845,
-0.09429284185171127,
0.1783515065908432,
-0.5753172039985657,
0.44902729988098145,
0.35747700929641724,
-0.1268848329782486,
0.2990626394748688,
-0.6657449007034302,
0.44916245341300964,
0.4238763451576233,
-0.22484521567821503,
-0.8364858627319336,
0.1537497192621231,
-0.9986662864685059,
-0.45988017320632935,
0.7448993921279907,
-0.09339266270399094,
-0.4215330481529236,
-0.3447962701320648,
0.07431071251630783,
0.5491953492164612,
-0.3493627607822418,
0.8824449777603149,
0.05786283686757088,
-0.8068587779998779,
-0.11898646503686905,
-0.4648209512233734,
0.30529046058654785,
0.20147117972373962,
-0.829397439956665,
-0.5438956022262573,
0.2918033301830292,
0.7430722713470459,
0.28883159160614014,
0.8504998683929443,
-0.3442138731479645,
0.4591767489910126,
0.1390693187713623,
-0.09826145321130753,
-0.3279784321784973,
-0.3972388505935669,
-0.2504390776157379,
0.5348091721534729,
-0.05299770459532738,
-0.6417255997657776
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.05981v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.05981v2
|
ShiftAddLLM: Accelerating Pretrained LLMs via Post-Training Multiplication-Less Reparameterization
| 2024-06-10T02:47:55 | 2024-06-11T15:14:30 |
Haoran You, Yipin Guo, Yichao Fu, Wei Zhou, Huihong Shi, Xiaofan Zhang, Souvik Kundu, Amir Yazdanbakhsh, Yingyan, Lin
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) have shown impressive performance on language
tasks but face challenges when deployed on resource-constrained devices due to
their extensive parameters and reliance on dense multiplications, resulting in
high memory demands and latency bottlenecks. Shift-and-add reparameterization
offers a promising solution by replacing costly multiplications with
hardware-friendly primitives in both the attention and multi-layer perceptron
(MLP) layers of an LLM. However, current reparameterization techniques require
training from scratch or full parameter fine-tuning to restore accuracy, which
is resource-intensive for LLMs. To address this, we propose accelerating
pretrained LLMs through post-training shift-and-add reparameterization,
creating efficient multiplication-free models, dubbed ShiftAddLLM.
Specifically, we quantize each weight matrix into binary matrices paired with
group-wise scaling factors. The associated multiplications are reparameterized
into (1) shifts between activations and scaling factors and (2) queries and
adds according to the binary matrices. To reduce accuracy loss, we present a
multi-objective optimization method to minimize both weight and output
activation reparameterization errors. Additionally, based on varying
sensitivity across layers to reparameterization, we develop an automated bit
allocation strategy to further reduce memory usage and latency. Experiments on
five LLM families and eight tasks consistently validate the effectiveness of
ShiftAddLLM, achieving average perplexity improvements of 5.6 and 22.7 points
at comparable or lower latency compared to the most competitive quantized LLMs
at 3 and 2 bits, respectively, and more than 80% memory and energy reductions
over the original LLMs. Codes and models are available at
https://github.com/GATECH-EIC/ShiftAddLLM.
|
[
-0.3029640316963196,
-0.6757947206497192,
0.32822898030281067,
0.4550304412841797,
-0.5070778131484985,
0.16228750348091125,
-0.1361405998468399,
-0.2525825500488281,
0.12594754993915558,
0.5898616313934326,
-0.5490957498550415,
-0.2715741991996765,
-0.7481297254562378,
-0.21279798448085785,
-0.23198232054710388,
0.6894035339355469,
-0.3852056562900543,
0.06573086977005005,
-0.1552354246377945,
-0.278478741645813,
-0.21960005164146423,
-0.5056735277175903,
-0.5578879714012146,
-0.25520551204681396,
0.3826965391635895,
0.23026591539382935,
0.5148768424987793,
0.6027762293815613,
0.7518942356109619,
0.18093931674957275,
-0.0013688596663996577,
0.2581886947154999,
-0.5215185284614563,
-0.027571283280849457,
0.1152273565530777,
-0.4731873869895935,
-0.7549751400947571,
-0.07797648012638092,
0.8500139713287354,
0.839451014995575,
-0.4909524917602539,
0.47548672556877136,
-0.34571757912635803,
0.7641385197639465,
-0.8187320232391357,
-0.17010726034641266,
-0.7989523410797119,
-0.04004054516553879,
-0.18435953557491302,
-0.29671773314476013,
-0.3735745847225189,
-0.6723393201828003,
-0.35022878646850586,
-0.6991466283798218,
0.16389010846614838,
-0.06018783152103424,
0.5272428393363953,
0.49288466572761536,
-0.14543206989765167,
0.22629518806934357,
-0.5742201209068298,
0.8214955925941467,
-0.7747613787651062,
0.7901579141616821,
0.1643192619085312,
0.1677539348602295,
0.04799479618668556,
-0.8212708830833435,
-0.32541313767433167,
-0.03142447769641876,
0.28258630633354187,
-0.07826772332191467,
-0.07920350879430771,
-0.07489107549190521,
0.3585943281650543,
0.26026779413223267,
-0.498507022857666,
0.11879240721464157,
-0.16244228184223175,
-0.24157580733299255,
0.5185244083404541,
0.19412016868591309,
0.03591039776802063,
0.7430211901664734,
-0.38386720418930054,
-0.03143306076526642,
-1.0839588642120361,
-0.17223507165908813,
0.3524501621723175,
0.06783360987901688,
0.07728911191225052,
0.3341454565525055,
-0.016188770532608032,
0.6499692797660828,
0.34483376145362854,
-0.08563407510519028,
0.5091536045074463,
-0.4821704924106598,
-0.12589725852012634,
0.010087682865560055,
0.4375913143157959,
0.14441752433776855,
0.13153287768363953,
-0.08514563739299774,
-0.38662514090538025,
0.10317320376634598,
0.4176098704338074,
-1.1918349266052246,
-0.27446889877319336,
-0.015698544681072235,
-0.4529961347579956,
-0.2943546175956726,
-0.4507501721382141,
-0.21872824430465698,
-0.12477115541696548,
-0.2846076786518097,
0.3542114198207855,
-0.3232439458370209,
-0.4683426320552826,
0.27089715003967285,
0.24248486757278442,
0.2311088889837265,
0.43243715167045593,
-0.9176658391952515,
0.1757144033908844,
0.615907609462738,
0.6624219417572021,
-0.5707078576087952,
-0.27034077048301697,
-0.6446477174758911,
0.167865589261055,
-0.47885972261428833,
0.7274513840675354,
-0.5496670007705688,
-0.43585503101348877,
-0.11437495052814484,
0.022789811715483665,
-0.15851284563541412,
-0.640372633934021,
0.3499395251274109,
-0.8776074647903442,
-0.05329621955752373,
0.09763704240322113,
-0.4536536633968353,
0.20692871510982513,
0.09880261868238449,
-0.6167365908622742,
1.169480323791504,
0.081680066883564,
-0.5824416875839233,
0.17107823491096497,
-0.6192461252212524,
-0.7219973206520081,
-0.11357191205024719,
0.10007956624031067,
-0.4601019024848938,
0.4736650884151459,
0.3695542812347412,
0.03742096200585365,
-0.15657225251197815,
-0.01697722263634205,
-0.033360905945301056,
-0.3293938934803009,
0.2749750316143036,
-0.5059176683425903,
0.8555320501327515,
0.05055902153253555,
-0.22178661823272705,
0.21255716681480408,
-0.7512654662132263,
0.3049648106098175,
-0.21641264855861664,
-0.6177846789360046,
-0.06202402338385582,
-0.21733252704143524,
-0.09571114927530289,
0.28655385971069336,
0.48794686794281006,
-0.5215126872062683,
0.28059038519859314,
-0.36962947249412537,
0.11178545653820038,
0.7659982442855835,
-0.2710978090763092,
0.6084011197090149,
-0.0928068608045578,
0.7313532829284668,
0.1952715367078781,
0.3295675218105316,
0.055656798183918,
-0.03474508598446846,
-0.7561347484588623,
-0.284961074590683,
0.21668215095996857,
0.37081900238990784,
-0.9753720760345459,
0.34743258357048035,
-0.5631529688835144,
-0.15016604959964752,
-1.0960233211517334,
0.26924946904182434,
0.43124711513519287,
0.5079996585845947,
0.46352025866508484,
-0.26814156770706177,
-0.42967888712882996,
-0.7296731472015381,
-0.2429858297109604,
0.08562027662992477,
0.018968001008033752,
0.007656728383153677,
-0.034951210021972656,
-0.41708505153656006,
0.521051824092865,
-0.4845484793186188,
-0.0935942754149437,
-0.094478078186512,
0.1585654765367508,
0.05822724848985672,
0.4100983440876007,
0.11100934445858002,
-0.5538216233253479,
-0.32172560691833496,
-0.06593598425388336,
-0.30338284373283386,
-0.4032772481441498,
0.062122564762830734,
-0.15066875517368317,
0.6092096567153931,
0.7438530325889587,
-0.5297582149505615,
0.23662371933460236,
0.6699378490447998,
-0.16615968942642212,
0.6589210033416748,
-0.3423735797405243,
-0.10503730922937393,
-0.9267721772193909,
-0.017187627032399178,
-0.5253446698188782,
-0.432755708694458,
-0.592100203037262,
0.007703336421400309,
0.299328476190567,
0.1612626016139984,
-0.49873125553131104,
0.437863290309906,
-0.7136349678039551,
-0.3394136428833008,
-0.3899993598461151,
0.022455492988228798,
-0.11195923388004303,
0.3290427029132843,
0.18514832854270935,
1.0104154348373413,
0.36945927143096924,
-0.45428505539894104,
0.19314926862716675,
-0.1611863523721695,
-0.27934661507606506,
0.41876909136772156,
-0.43993672728538513,
0.332582026720047,
0.10850632190704346,
0.16976042091846466,
-0.9805290102958679,
0.4360368251800537,
-0.10050018876791,
-0.29964813590049744,
0.3134368658065796,
0.08469691127538681,
-0.4066201150417328,
-0.055938854813575745,
-0.4113202691078186,
0.7580772042274475,
0.575907289981842,
-0.652466893196106,
0.5952787399291992,
0.3229222595691681,
-0.10095465183258057,
-0.4983927309513092,
-0.6505721807479858,
-0.11444944888353348,
0.09967458993196487,
-0.5359846353530884,
0.5666999816894531,
-0.07821933180093765,
-0.13140204548835754,
-0.1133955642580986,
-0.3161264955997467,
0.08496826142072678,
0.06813234090805054,
0.042189911007881165,
0.18374629318714142,
-0.3015330731868744,
0.29195669293403625,
0.1564624309539795,
-0.4297713339328766,
-0.017326276749372482,
-0.39543837308883667,
0.7193984389305115,
-0.17924392223358154,
-0.24177873134613037,
-0.24057184159755707,
0.035825032740831375,
0.42404839396476746,
-0.3082389533519745,
0.6241909861564636,
1.0203138589859009,
-0.05906893312931061,
-0.2533465623855591,
-0.6206698417663574,
-0.19942598044872284,
-0.4736393094062805,
0.6968068480491638,
-0.2477470487356186,
-0.9852261543273926,
0.17212973535060883,
-0.2868450880050659,
0.24583132565021515,
0.07771921157836914,
0.7672027945518494,
-0.013553136959671974,
0.6932083964347839,
0.5339500308036804,
-0.022339822724461555,
0.7242203950881958,
-0.03906873241066933,
0.08530094474554062,
-1.202447533607483,
0.2040257453918457,
-0.05053258687257767,
-0.43969541788101196,
-0.3676578402519226,
-0.9458891153335571,
0.22631637752056122,
0.04019077122211456,
-0.2655261158943176,
0.19645684957504272,
-0.4342154860496521,
0.556047797203064,
0.2732590138912201,
-0.08079089969396591,
0.3618079125881195,
0.1435687243938446,
0.12198750674724579,
-0.07950159162282944,
-0.5584458112716675,
-0.09872251003980637,
1.4105274677276611,
0.11306984722614288,
1.0261937379837036,
0.010446874424815178,
0.7377837300300598,
0.05404867231845856,
0.6029801368713379,
-0.5233586430549622,
0.77812260389328,
-0.28774285316467285,
-0.14445826411247253,
-0.4368365406990051,
-0.6240269541740417,
-0.9073734283447266,
0.4785636067390442,
0.04031391069293022,
-0.28949272632598877,
0.07389654964208603,
0.1278952956199646,
-0.15234754979610443,
0.33202096819877625,
-0.6239145398139954,
0.4771479070186615,
-0.4549432694911957,
-0.3293987512588501,
-0.4578430652618408,
-0.6116620302200317,
0.27931755781173706,
-0.058718450367450714,
0.06586922705173492,
-0.13816514611244202,
-0.48577582836151123,
0.5676255226135254,
-0.47154292464256287,
0.5575783848762512,
-0.28055569529533386,
-0.45028120279312134,
-0.1087108626961708,
0.22914616763591766,
0.7355211973190308,
-0.1196623221039772,
-0.04957173764705658,
0.3337254226207733,
-0.230047807097435,
-0.29789283871650696,
-0.5892545580863953,
0.7483003735542297,
-0.778193473815918,
-0.7022194266319275,
0.036066584289073944,
-0.9033282399177551,
-0.39908367395401,
0.15189869701862335,
-0.010594764724373817,
0.2110927850008011,
-0.06334042549133301,
0.1359192132949829,
0.8592979907989502,
-0.04266959801316261,
0.541351318359375,
0.6885106563568115,
-0.5302077531814575,
-0.44060835242271423,
1.0216524600982666,
0.08677952736616135,
0.582108199596405,
0.5162080526351929,
0.010829275473952293,
-0.4211212694644928,
-0.6805995106697083,
-0.3204207420349121,
0.18151283264160156,
-0.39079633355140686,
-0.1573418378829956,
-0.4884311258792877,
-0.12547287344932556,
-0.47427722811698914,
-0.11172512173652649,
-0.5891952514648438,
-0.7895556092262268,
-0.2506580352783203,
-0.2372506856918335,
0.17720428109169006,
-0.01444911677390337,
-0.08369410783052444,
0.4638727009296417,
-0.5683706402778625,
0.5486149787902832,
0.34190893173217773,
0.405289888381958,
-0.19861415028572083,
-0.8903670907020569,
-0.343457967042923,
-0.00977368839085102,
-0.22602500021457672,
-0.19687652587890625,
0.35829123854637146,
0.17273271083831787,
0.3306385278701782,
0.2744613289833069,
-0.22491420805454254,
0.8219948410987854,
-0.6106662154197693,
0.43453145027160645,
0.2933555841445923,
-0.8948313593864441,
0.15474675595760345,
0.03320520371198654,
0.5337861180305481,
0.5348427891731262,
0.037779130041599274,
-0.30002227425575256,
-0.1625196784734726,
-0.469393789768219,
-0.8400707840919495,
0.7515901327133179,
0.07679276168346405,
0.09463200718164444,
0.3746287524700165,
0.2725016474723816,
0.018837017938494682,
0.39721229672431946,
-0.6696599721908569,
-0.27235090732574463,
-0.08069321513175964,
-0.11866796761751175,
0.006292658858001232,
-0.28538981080055237,
-0.15888017416000366,
-0.446128249168396,
0.5923674702644348,
0.07045358419418335,
0.26322516798973083,
-0.05277351662516594,
-0.5749341249465942,
-0.19044728577136993,
0.19414441287517548,
0.7351138591766357,
0.9167842864990234,
-0.1502450704574585,
0.30202168226242065,
0.2244604229927063,
-0.7271562814712524,
0.44254446029663086,
0.2783963978290558,
-0.03541862219572067,
0.11782298982143402,
0.37906908988952637,
0.9993194341659546,
0.27768394351005554,
-0.47235941886901855,
0.39245137572288513,
-0.01750943437218666,
-0.14665605127811432,
0.001454790704883635,
-0.05025077238678932,
0.3633803725242615,
0.1736641526222229,
0.2727212607860565,
-0.09411255270242691,
-0.26306453347206116,
-0.1814178079366684,
0.0823112353682518,
0.5116071701049805,
0.007505732588469982,
-0.5362472534179688,
0.5205103754997253,
0.30884671211242676,
-0.4276859164237976,
0.5209358334541321,
-0.012732775881886482,
-0.16532783210277557,
0.3817785680294037,
0.7916820645332336,
1.1290265321731567,
-0.7518253922462463,
0.19130830466747284,
0.03200896829366684,
0.47970694303512573,
-0.02355330064892769,
0.1987297236919403,
-0.18319487571716309,
-1.0962064266204834,
-0.3502521812915802,
-0.7107453942298889,
-0.07688244432210922,
-0.15100109577178955,
-0.5810583829879761,
-0.11058342456817627,
-0.591396152973175,
-0.15207542479038239,
-0.15609171986579895,
-0.08141093701124191,
-0.536890983581543,
-0.017146648839116096,
0.021381666883826256,
0.8349990844726562,
-0.4957200884819031,
1.247970700263977,
0.6836476922035217,
-0.007983183488249779,
-0.4786985516548157,
-0.09401209652423859,
-0.5450756549835205,
-1.1768600940704346,
0.8822460770606995,
0.03101460263133049,
-0.32307448983192444,
0.21388359367847443,
-0.40324366092681885,
-0.9176828265190125,
1.1822545528411865,
0.6975985169410706,
-0.8277208805084229,
0.010855346918106079,
0.2643076479434967,
0.5402481555938721,
-0.36820727586746216,
0.1592404991388321,
0.7062158584594727,
0.3201454281806946,
0.11436770111322403,
-0.7148141264915466,
0.14703992009162903,
0.03118879348039627,
0.3175864815711975,
0.4905295968055725,
-0.5278948545455933,
1.142831563949585,
-0.22958901524543762,
-0.18338032066822052,
-0.34717342257499695,
0.4336252510547638,
0.34164756536483765,
-0.0656941756606102,
0.48745009303092957,
0.9030964970588684,
0.6844164133071899,
0.01025985088199377,
1.0088651180267334,
-0.2865649461746216,
0.0810653492808342,
1.2617051601409912,
-0.537590503692627,
0.9428691267967224,
0.9513244032859802,
-0.39763644337654114,
0.38915708661079407,
0.2808656692504883,
0.4868612587451935,
0.5735042095184326,
0.24930842220783234,
-0.508111298084259,
-0.4975777864456177,
0.21462656557559967,
-0.596225917339325,
-0.14145387709140778,
0.22059930860996246,
-0.2862150967121124,
-0.28994113206863403,
-0.0057255905121564865,
-0.1457114815711975,
-0.39118334650993347,
-0.4396561086177826,
0.8512879014015198,
0.15148048102855682,
-0.2996435761451721,
0.932337760925293,
-0.06852993369102478,
0.7224451303482056,
-0.6129907369613647,
0.06281767040491104,
-0.6320792436599731,
0.4977298080921173,
-0.1661984622478485,
-0.36478349566459656,
0.20576781034469604,
-0.1977507472038269,
-0.254239946603775,
-0.48081889748573303,
0.5940660238265991,
-0.695010244846344,
-0.8775375485420227,
0.16763481497764587,
0.4184347689151764,
-0.09549621492624283,
-0.09510748833417892,
-0.5547860264778137,
0.2897205054759979,
0.06658165156841278,
-0.4110938012599945,
0.5787584781646729,
0.47718334197998047,
-0.24891872704029083,
0.6654698252677917,
0.7847285270690918,
0.4483169913291931,
0.4017338454723358,
0.1413559764623642,
1.002246618270874,
-0.5037729144096375,
-0.2966582477092743,
-0.752926230430603,
0.14634214341640472,
0.2274542599916458,
-0.1421092450618744,
0.7068169116973877,
0.5175837278366089,
0.6670751571655273,
-0.16213537752628326,
0.4711543023586273,
0.3053959012031555,
0.28722062706947327,
-0.6501038074493408,
0.5941511392593384,
-0.47854676842689514,
0.35584524273872375,
0.005066917277872562,
-0.9550392031669617,
-0.34403008222579956,
0.4713367223739624,
-0.4552093744277954,
-0.09633158147335052,
0.5132834911346436,
1.0355448722839355,
0.021312199532985687,
-0.4385831952095032,
0.4040277302265167,
0.3456491529941559,
0.4216701090335846,
0.7184950113296509,
0.6620194911956787,
-0.3624691069126129,
0.6646919846534729,
0.07004360854625702,
-0.09183907508850098,
-0.35734647512435913,
-0.8130519390106201,
-0.6178984045982361,
-0.1980680674314499,
-0.46149370074272156,
-0.004010274540632963,
0.3528076708316803,
0.6380243301391602,
0.6394330263137817,
-0.6530632376670837,
-0.36922672390937805,
-0.23518402874469757,
0.24869658052921295,
-0.2862435579299927,
-0.18458369374275208,
0.46038955450057983,
-0.5925340056419373,
-0.4506591856479645,
0.322769433259964,
0.4125044345855713,
-0.042084887623786926,
-0.2831893265247345,
-0.13189058005809784,
-0.34203624725341797,
-0.004605619702488184,
0.717610239982605,
0.11851903051137924,
-0.5247066020965576,
-0.11330924183130264,
-0.22596022486686707,
-0.08125245571136475,
0.1595136672258377,
0.9148967862129211,
-0.7951384782791138,
0.37079644203186035,
0.4039820730686188,
0.958448588848114,
0.6972169876098633,
0.29526805877685547,
0.4951336979866028,
-0.9406836032867432,
0.43601641058921814,
0.28522825241088867,
0.09133465588092804,
0.24690179526805878,
-0.13576342165470123,
0.445512592792511,
0.18765029311180115,
-0.46370241045951843,
-0.8940773010253906,
0.20299410820007324,
-0.6004462242126465,
-0.1782541424036026,
1.123971939086914,
-0.13328953087329865,
-0.1882353127002716,
0.24996428191661835,
-0.13187524676322937,
0.04575832560658455,
-0.22235676646232605,
0.7773721218109131,
0.5581152439117432,
-0.1633978635072708,
-0.45203471183776855,
-0.09167470782995224,
0.5981622934341431,
0.7025602459907532,
-1.0439317226409912,
0.40136444568634033,
0.5394004583358765,
0.2638040781021118,
-0.0826331153512001,
0.7899661064147949,
-0.3317851126194,
0.2630194425582886,
-0.14901112020015717,
0.41785386204719543,
-0.3622453808784485,
-0.28414249420166016,
-0.5814976692199707,
0.018820548430085182,
-0.048633743077516556,
-0.523984432220459
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.05968v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.05968v1
|
Prompting Large Language Models with Audio for General-Purpose Speech Summarization
| 2024-06-10T02:04:28 | 2024-06-10T02:04:28 |
Wonjune Kang, Deb Roy
|
eess.AS
|
eess.AS, cs.CL
|
In this work, we introduce a framework for speech summarization that
leverages the processing and reasoning capabilities of large language models
(LLMs). We propose an end-to-end system that combines an instruction-tuned LLM
with an audio encoder that converts speech into token representations that the
LLM can interpret. Using a dataset with paired speech-text data, the overall
system is trained to generate consistent responses to prompts with the same
semantic information regardless of the input modality. The resulting framework
allows the LLM to process speech inputs in the same way as text, enabling
speech summarization by simply prompting the LLM. Unlike prior approaches, our
method is able to summarize spoken content from any arbitrary domain, and it
can produce summaries in different styles by varying the LLM prompting
strategy. Experiments demonstrate that our approach outperforms a cascade
baseline of speech recognition followed by LLM text processing.
|
[
-0.25817325711250305,
-0.6990640163421631,
0.7319353818893433,
0.17336733639240265,
-0.574257493019104,
-0.05913110449910164,
-0.5415931344032288,
-0.10913180559873581,
0.5654240250587463,
0.5017364025115967,
-0.5446702241897583,
-0.5076290369033813,
-0.4986419379711151,
0.275214284658432,
-0.6594842672348022,
0.9474530220031738,
0.2973649501800537,
0.12917660176753998,
-0.36426159739494324,
-0.007400063797831535,
-0.6675992012023926,
-0.46522074937820435,
-0.7918770909309387,
-0.5230426788330078,
0.6102372407913208,
0.4739030599594116,
0.45754775404930115,
0.5019656419754028,
0.013797537423670292,
0.2850402295589447,
-0.2608897387981415,
0.277831107378006,
-0.3401675522327423,
0.4830978810787201,
-0.010777858085930347,
-0.42577099800109863,
-0.5812861323356628,
-0.38275399804115295,
0.7883328795433044,
0.8481601476669312,
-0.10023292899131775,
0.3244391977787018,
0.0582900308072567,
0.39628660678863525,
-0.4214094877243042,
0.12480602413415909,
-0.6156628727912903,
-0.05655070021748543,
0.20033836364746094,
-0.618829607963562,
-0.5676089525222778,
-0.1398501694202423,
0.009194755926728249,
-0.287401407957077,
0.037903398275375366,
-0.016915539279580116,
0.26877912878990173,
0.37981531023979187,
-0.2902817726135254,
-0.36373138427734375,
-0.6916683912277222,
0.5455780625343323,
-0.7341945767402649,
0.3840582072734833,
0.2837716341018677,
0.32477259635925293,
0.011551360599696636,
-0.666968047618866,
-0.6108490824699402,
-0.11921463161706924,
0.1588277518749237,
0.3378005623817444,
-0.23289352655410767,
0.17043589055538177,
0.1272893100976944,
0.25339993834495544,
-0.7006059885025024,
0.2576448321342468,
-0.2728343605995178,
-0.0569295659661293,
0.4042765498161316,
0.22998730838298798,
0.3687956631183624,
0.1189299151301384,
0.08783478289842606,
0.03661360964179039,
-0.836811900138855,
0.02504737488925457,
0.31099066138267517,
0.538298487663269,
-0.3725219666957855,
0.8420772552490234,
-0.1874540150165558,
0.861583948135376,
0.06339078396558762,
-0.12139929831027985,
-0.0012666715774685144,
-0.12619337439537048,
-0.42771434783935547,
0.6651883721351624,
0.7268639206886292,
0.670023500919342,
0.36928117275238037,
-0.14148171246051788,
-0.31661754846572876,
-0.055945850908756256,
-0.23141233623027802,
-0.7759387493133545,
0.16257379949092865,
0.5068528056144714,
-0.2692691683769226,
0.039888493716716766,
-0.16071569919586182,
-0.5762913823127747,
-0.2076319009065628,
-0.7205719947814941,
0.37237071990966797,
-0.12145641446113586,
0.017124775797128677,
0.36872148513793945,
-0.42560258507728577,
0.4458530843257904,
0.39978811144828796,
-1.2779558897018433,
0.22769835591316223,
0.7216797471046448,
1.070083498954773,
-0.07090763747692108,
0.03146380931138992,
-1.036111831665039,
0.5859843492507935,
-0.38627293705940247,
0.7650001049041748,
-0.650545060634613,
-0.738796055316925,
0.05978895723819733,
-0.10851254314184189,
0.12842150032520294,
-0.5899831056594849,
0.3547250032424927,
-0.2825288474559784,
0.23815953731536865,
-0.23414219915866852,
-0.6147971153259277,
0.0012658709893003106,
0.07937990874052048,
-0.3650291860103607,
0.6806634664535522,
-0.3168478310108185,
-0.5051859617233276,
0.12743499875068665,
-0.5415928363800049,
-0.5052939653396606,
-0.020507650449872017,
-0.28964489698410034,
-0.061278775334358215,
0.2430509775876999,
0.6327152252197266,
0.7212344408035278,
-0.2963727116584778,
0.3980989456176758,
-0.07242977619171143,
-0.4311859607696533,
0.13256822526454926,
-0.5245804190635681,
0.44440957903862,
0.06276100128889084,
0.10113558918237686,
0.4757009744644165,
-0.5756581425666809,
-0.28234466910362244,
0.13783910870552063,
-0.46459805965423584,
-0.1076955646276474,
-0.06819812953472137,
-0.05756828561425209,
-0.24350588023662567,
0.3703961670398712,
-0.29821115732192993,
0.08125718683004379,
-0.5263350605964661,
0.6203892827033997,
0.7075491547584534,
0.04938732832670212,
0.43047165870666504,
-0.43308383226394653,
0.4783180356025696,
-0.32194986939430237,
-0.45981425046920776,
-0.9826526641845703,
-0.3878227174282074,
-0.515862226486206,
-0.3354801833629608,
0.14708781242370605,
0.6646744608879089,
-0.41295522451400757,
0.5682691335678101,
-0.5320367813110352,
-0.08382071554660797,
-0.26757878065109253,
-0.07186079770326614,
0.20019297301769257,
0.7070058584213257,
0.2942134439945221,
0.16167570650577545,
-0.6288073062896729,
-0.6519390940666199,
-0.11025606840848923,
-0.2918648421764374,
-0.682203471660614,
0.12360909581184387,
0.26615461707115173,
0.09675373882055283,
1.0423094034194946,
-0.3677319586277008,
-0.17568980157375336,
-0.6187025904655457,
0.20910955965518951,
0.5906073451042175,
0.30786678194999695,
0.3386027216911316,
-0.5446932315826416,
-0.09095077216625214,
-0.051144957542419434,
-0.7639802098274231,
-0.3412094712257385,
-0.21943773329257965,
0.2314685732126236,
-0.1870919167995453,
0.9742776155471802,
-0.5141139626502991,
-0.0027209785766899586,
0.37783464789390564,
-0.200920969247818,
0.6201887130737305,
-0.2720964252948761,
0.14684587717056274,
-1.2680217027664185,
0.05697470158338547,
-0.3551150858402252,
-0.4194125831127167,
-0.687396228313446,
-0.3417886197566986,
-0.34586194157600403,
-0.4288717210292816,
-0.36498454213142395,
0.5378962755203247,
-0.2906903326511383,
-0.355094313621521,
-0.41154706478118896,
0.2632417678833008,
0.048503268510103226,
0.33459657430648804,
0.1625218689441681,
0.9669850468635559,
0.5860658884048462,
-0.7643460631370544,
0.5529335737228394,
0.39832213521003723,
-0.16525480151176453,
0.5537484288215637,
-1.1507104635238647,
0.07017321139574051,
-0.44389843940734863,
0.4475431740283966,
-1.0892161130905151,
-0.6811575293540955,
-0.12439631670713425,
-0.7388988733291626,
0.35332703590393066,
0.019577348604798317,
-0.4338773787021637,
-0.031677037477493286,
-0.2417016625404358,
0.29518815875053406,
0.5564199686050415,
-0.5881055593490601,
0.982488751411438,
0.3429553210735321,
-0.8297934532165527,
-0.31748563051223755,
-0.8924315571784973,
0.3842203915119171,
-0.27428120374679565,
-0.5659042596817017,
0.39338743686676025,
-0.1767423301935196,
-0.22602815926074982,
-0.19688819348812103,
-0.005609461572021246,
0.2054901272058487,
-0.2082032561302185,
0.10450894385576248,
0.2981278598308563,
-0.32374969124794006,
0.22804099321365356,
0.3167780637741089,
-0.03909635171294212,
0.29923468828201294,
-0.49018147587776184,
0.6930108070373535,
0.1130048856139183,
-0.42253872752189636,
-0.44808194041252136,
0.6335827708244324,
0.6062701940536499,
-0.2354755699634552,
0.3341059684753418,
0.28857550024986267,
-0.2892422080039978,
-0.10991015285253525,
-0.2976732850074768,
-0.26830777525901794,
-0.42612528800964355,
0.4045051038265228,
-0.15507806837558746,
-1.1284362077713013,
0.6029881834983826,
-0.0802537053823471,
0.35833874344825745,
0.09628218412399292,
0.9120680689811707,
-0.12983408570289612,
1.2801854610443115,
0.44788190722465515,
-0.29118701815605164,
0.5642837882041931,
-0.02025209553539753,
0.17207281291484833,
-0.7714777588844299,
-0.16708464920520782,
-0.4604249894618988,
-0.21972081065177917,
0.12932197749614716,
-0.23281532526016235,
0.46115079522132874,
-0.06920216232538223,
-0.16066911816596985,
-0.07549567520618439,
-0.33325687050819397,
0.817984938621521,
0.40544000267982483,
-0.03064180538058281,
0.3756656050682068,
-0.02723764069378376,
-0.10351234674453735,
0.3959549069404602,
-0.5256685614585876,
-0.4957951605319977,
0.8457427620887756,
0.31505993008613586,
0.7514770030975342,
0.1019563376903534,
0.765524685382843,
0.36728328466415405,
-0.10100250691175461,
-1.085145354270935,
0.6111173033714294,
-0.04840428754687309,
-0.1154368594288826,
-0.568281888961792,
-0.28961747884750366,
-0.7361418604850769,
0.2618062198162079,
-0.05333426967263222,
-0.8321604132652283,
-0.02704502083361149,
0.24009500443935394,
-0.5616855025291443,
0.06829256564378738,
-0.5267667174339294,
0.3369182050228119,
0.03571581095457077,
0.10665639489889145,
-0.2539686858654022,
-0.5152708888053894,
0.3651677370071411,
0.20912504196166992,
0.4147678017616272,
-0.11063027381896973,
-0.23296864330768585,
0.7300313711166382,
-0.3442351818084717,
0.8785768747329712,
-0.0168420672416687,
-0.29914483428001404,
0.19324716925621033,
-0.038989849388599396,
0.3225812315940857,
0.1470152735710144,
0.035112977027893066,
-0.19156445562839508,
-0.36318081617355347,
-0.017766404896974564,
-0.7541289329528809,
0.4877500832080841,
-0.40608081221580505,
-0.6364783048629761,
0.014222835190594196,
-0.6295145750045776,
-0.3815930485725403,
0.16366243362426758,
0.29740679264068604,
0.8749344944953918,
-0.11342515051364899,
0.25843289494514465,
0.8960762619972229,
-0.22843727469444275,
0.5687686800956726,
0.30577924847602844,
-0.48376205563545227,
-0.6296490430831909,
0.825745165348053,
-0.1050310879945755,
0.32484880089759827,
0.5675180554389954,
0.29106777906417847,
-0.5921334028244019,
-0.5753074288368225,
-0.6405165791511536,
0.2417345941066742,
-0.8917032480239868,
-0.07734948396682739,
-0.624428927898407,
0.0166416447609663,
-0.5801578760147095,
-0.46212831139564514,
-0.028213780373334885,
-0.43642178177833557,
-0.42281895875930786,
-0.2667945623397827,
0.28059372305870056,
0.5744785070419312,
0.0574173703789711,
0.49057072401046753,
-0.8510968089103699,
0.5688515305519104,
0.672353208065033,
0.0404006764292717,
-0.08118832111358643,
-0.9010195732116699,
-0.09443791210651398,
-0.06935941427946091,
0.1601647287607193,
-0.8147974014282227,
0.36032938957214355,
0.4377756118774414,
0.412045955657959,
0.4534681737422943,
-0.05408620834350586,
0.632146954536438,
-0.7613875269889832,
1.0054545402526855,
0.5717968344688416,
-1.1180890798568726,
0.8254309892654419,
-0.6824896931648254,
0.8015709519386292,
0.2409936785697937,
0.06901527941226959,
-0.6654269695281982,
-0.48847031593322754,
-0.13000863790512085,
-0.9733555912971497,
0.45377278327941895,
-0.13506227731704712,
0.24398909509181976,
-0.046110596507787704,
0.06040313094854355,
-0.09187783300876617,
0.10439658164978027,
-0.24791836738586426,
-0.0212460495531559,
-0.22389119863510132,
-0.4634847640991211,
-0.09276589751243591,
-0.26268473267555237,
-0.24846410751342773,
-0.10771069675683975,
0.5232949256896973,
-0.44290509819984436,
0.22394098341464996,
0.3076664209365845,
-0.1616460382938385,
0.11091359704732895,
0.5412617921829224,
0.7153155207633972,
0.5921193957328796,
-0.06074065715074539,
0.16079840064048767,
0.3320006728172302,
-0.17563886940479279,
0.13428828120231628,
-0.22766149044036865,
-0.09531497955322266,
0.2315746396780014,
0.6344136595726013,
0.788081705570221,
0.5324437022209167,
-0.8817877769470215,
0.43367910385131836,
-0.12282069772481918,
-0.4691585302352905,
-0.3062147796154022,
-0.034193988889455795,
0.49178391695022583,
0.17525815963745117,
0.46044668555259705,
-0.4363082945346832,
0.30984699726104736,
-0.4772665798664093,
0.21994245052337646,
0.2638058364391327,
-0.16052985191345215,
-0.09493602812290192,
0.7769478559494019,
0.1980702430009842,
-0.3143368363380432,
0.32098114490509033,
0.18534432351589203,
-0.2449405938386917,
0.4813029170036316,
0.6496332287788391,
1.0006624460220337,
-0.1566208004951477,
0.03604469820857048,
0.21767579019069672,
-0.04868408292531967,
0.08645205199718475,
0.39782822132110596,
-0.36375758051872253,
-0.4329177439212799,
-0.932026743888855,
-0.635636031627655,
-0.8474191427230835,
0.01732603646814823,
-0.6873074769973755,
0.31720998883247375,
-0.5370979905128479,
-0.043825071305036545,
0.08252093940973282,
-0.8557723164558411,
-0.14783340692520142,
0.08113357424736023,
0.5235536694526672,
0.7945166826248169,
-0.7357761263847351,
0.4344380795955658,
0.4881889224052429,
-0.27161088585853577,
-0.78413325548172,
-0.18546448647975922,
0.0540030263364315,
-0.7957949042320251,
0.45580440759658813,
0.16544465720653534,
-0.486851304769516,
0.1328544020652771,
-0.6816516518592834,
-0.5836406946182251,
0.9997425079345703,
0.6890658736228943,
-0.7671308517456055,
-0.12331752479076385,
0.16146093606948853,
0.19149796664714813,
-0.469937801361084,
0.2302531898021698,
0.6679799556732178,
0.28126630187034607,
0.5374687910079956,
-0.936305046081543,
-0.14739584922790527,
-0.11928558349609375,
-0.16491709649562836,
0.005250024609267712,
-0.21232277154922485,
0.6760900616645813,
-0.3500472903251648,
-0.2782037854194641,
-0.16709886491298676,
0.9507725834846497,
0.4102787375450134,
0.27038782835006714,
0.4968491196632385,
0.27932241559028625,
0.8137103319168091,
-0.10877695679664612,
0.7092983722686768,
-0.2567119598388672,
-0.1588314026594162,
1.3399406671524048,
-0.12791283428668976,
0.8863373398780823,
0.40902087092399597,
-0.006511497311294079,
0.29325705766677856,
0.46859776973724365,
0.21934083104133606,
0.3257887363433838,
0.11997795850038528,
-0.46003443002700806,
-0.3419837951660156,
-0.4682021141052246,
-0.3361431658267975,
0.56730717420578,
0.4319135546684265,
-0.270437091588974,
-0.409004271030426,
0.15061327815055847,
-0.02134014293551445,
0.07652052491903305,
-0.7733975052833557,
1.111876130104065,
0.3154829740524292,
-0.5463905930519104,
0.5053137540817261,
-0.29350078105926514,
0.6442555785179138,
-0.7691959738731384,
-0.09952721744775772,
0.05815540626645088,
-0.2739974856376648,
-0.28994250297546387,
-0.7288782000541687,
0.2822389006614685,
0.2684955596923828,
-0.4163661301136017,
-0.3104231059551239,
0.40630629658699036,
-0.7081531882286072,
-0.3758644461631775,
0.11513339728116989,
0.336658775806427,
0.23276102542877197,
-0.042789656668901443,
-0.13065412640571594,
0.13151699304580688,
-0.1274753361940384,
-0.15444767475128174,
0.28405800461769104,
0.4684125781059265,
0.08637332916259766,
0.6415656208992004,
0.8895270228385925,
0.2123413383960724,
-0.08019402623176575,
0.7165696024894714,
0.8420893549919128,
-0.5941774845123291,
-1.0709514617919922,
-1.0189143419265747,
0.5126082897186279,
0.003632776904851198,
-0.08144783973693848,
0.4229333996772766,
0.42496347427368164,
0.4163305163383484,
0.03420962020754814,
0.9233735203742981,
0.30111539363861084,
0.49577823281288147,
-0.9262880682945251,
0.4996161162853241,
-0.3544127941131592,
0.2956918179988861,
0.002400355413556099,
-0.8030545115470886,
-0.35376155376434326,
0.3986860513687134,
-0.03867155313491821,
-0.10960837453603745,
0.3398180603981018,
0.690618634223938,
0.17438273131847382,
0.32236459851264954,
0.5332915186882019,
-0.006233151536434889,
0.4670838415622711,
0.31900501251220703,
0.7181087136268616,
0.21812215447425842,
0.47240230441093445,
0.49210789799690247,
-0.3070266842842102,
-0.21215258538722992,
-0.9144852757453918,
-1.04474937915802,
-0.4128808379173279,
0.003171049291267991,
-0.019921792671084404,
-0.039440982043743134,
1.1266487836837769,
0.44231295585632324,
-0.7850126028060913,
-0.31851428747177124,
0.12075478583574295,
0.022110268473625183,
0.008600516244769096,
-0.1593128889799118,
0.20993956923484802,
-0.440396249294281,
-0.8477101922035217,
0.7910857200622559,
0.5683612823486328,
0.15124675631523132,
-0.2872825264930725,
-0.22447232902050018,
0.28880953788757324,
0.2531161904335022,
0.7818071842193604,
0.15624886751174927,
-0.7835193872451782,
-0.15574972331523895,
-0.11437826603651047,
0.32742002606391907,
-0.11474528163671494,
1.043566346168518,
-0.7345365285873413,
0.368489533662796,
0.6173833012580872,
0.8012415170669556,
0.35603857040405273,
-0.12117035686969757,
0.9402709603309631,
-0.8057947754859924,
0.03940420225262642,
0.3841197192668915,
0.6506850123405457,
0.3489341735839844,
-0.24281249940395355,
0.08116641640663147,
-0.26492103934288025,
-0.47342512011528015,
-0.8156857490539551,
0.23135340213775635,
-1.0454989671707153,
-0.2559112012386322,
1.0265777111053467,
0.05866960063576698,
-0.24865111708641052,
-0.07182955741882324,
-0.3541124165058136,
0.300292044878006,
-0.6391884684562683,
0.18350352346897125,
0.5907497406005859,
-0.23157991468906403,
-0.24208776652812958,
-0.343296080827713,
0.1738971769809723,
0.26539069414138794,
-0.6176807284355164,
0.4928150773048401,
0.5860336422920227,
0.05616222321987152,
-0.008240770548582077,
0.8368328213691711,
-0.03863931819796562,
0.3955632150173187,
-0.07557164132595062,
-0.10807875543832779,
-0.39129871129989624,
-0.44127148389816284,
-0.7676345705986023,
0.15698957443237305,
-0.2217659205198288,
-0.07744168490171432
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.05967v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.05967v1
|
CVQA: Culturally-diverse Multilingual Visual Question Answering Benchmark
| 2024-06-10T01:59:00 | 2024-06-10T01:59:00 |
David Romero, Chenyang Lyu, Haryo Akbarianto Wibowo, Teresa Lynn, Injy Hamed, Aditya Nanda Kishore, Aishik Mandal, Alina Dragonetti, Artem Abzaliev, Atnafu Lambebo Tonja, Bontu Fufa Balcha, Chenxi Whitehouse, Christian Salamea, Dan John Velasco, David Ifeoluwa Adelani, David Le Meur, Emilio Villa-Cueva, Fajri Koto, Fauzan Farooqui, Frederico Belcavello, Ganzorig Batnasan, Gisela Vallejo, Grainne Caulfield, Guido Ivetta, Haiyue Song, Henok Biadglign Ademtew, Hernán Maina, Holy Lovenia, Israel Abebe Azime, Jan Christian Blaise Cruz, Jay Gala, Jiahui Geng, Jesus-German Ortiz-Barajas, Jinheon Baek, Jocelyn Dunstan, Laura Alonso Alemany, Kumaranage Ravindu Yasas Nagasinghe, Luciana Benotti, Luis Fernando D'Haro, Marcelo Viridiano, Marcos Estecha-Garitagoitia, Maria Camila Buitrago Cabrera, Mario Rodríguez-Cantelar, Mélanie Jouitteau, Mihail Mihaylov, Mohamed Fazli Mohamed Imam, Muhammad Farid Adilazuarda, Munkhjargal Gochoo, Munkh-Erdene Otgonbold, Naome Etori, Olivier Niyomugisha, Paula Mónica Silva, Pranjal Chitale, Raj Dabre, Rendi Chevi, Ruochen Zhang, Ryandito Diandaru, Samuel Cahyawijaya, Santiago Góngora, Soyeong Jeong, Sukannya Purkayastha, Tatsuki Kuribayashi, Thanmay Jayakumar, Tiago Timponi Torrent, Toqeer Ehsan, Vladimir Araujo, Yova Kementchedjhieva, Zara Burzo, Zheng Wei Lim, Zheng Xin Yong, Oana Ignat, Joan Nwatu, Rada Mihalcea, Thamar Solorio, Alham Fikri Aji
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Visual Question Answering (VQA) is an important task in multimodal AI, and it
is often used to test the ability of vision-language models to understand and
reason on knowledge present in both visual and textual data. However, most of
the current VQA models use datasets that are primarily focused on English and a
few major world languages, with images that are typically Western-centric.
While recent efforts have tried to increase the number of languages covered on
VQA datasets, they still lack diversity in low-resource languages. More
importantly, although these datasets often extend their linguistic range via
translation or some other approaches, they usually keep images the same,
resulting in narrow cultural representation. To address these limitations, we
construct CVQA, a new Culturally-diverse multilingual Visual Question Answering
benchmark, designed to cover a rich set of languages and cultures, where we
engage native speakers and cultural experts in the data collection process. As
a result, CVQA includes culturally-driven images and questions from across 28
countries on four continents, covering 26 languages with 11 scripts, providing
a total of 9k questions. We then benchmark several Multimodal Large Language
Models (MLLMs) on CVQA, and show that the dataset is challenging for the
current state-of-the-art models. This benchmark can serve as a probing
evaluation suite for assessing the cultural capability and bias of multimodal
models and hopefully encourage more research efforts toward increasing cultural
awareness and linguistic diversity in this field.
|
[
-0.7268949747085571,
-0.5903803706169128,
0.153114914894104,
0.2793627679347992,
-0.1850932240486145,
0.18630240857601166,
-0.2501382827758789,
-0.47529885172843933,
-0.056239910423755646,
0.5478547811508179,
-0.7342175841331482,
-0.5176160931587219,
-0.3774498999118805,
0.1367335170507431,
-0.07144460827112198,
0.5510895252227783,
-0.3250289857387543,
0.49279162287712097,
-0.5911622047424316,
-0.8207548260688782,
-0.5126720070838928,
-0.26052266359329224,
-0.11234301328659058,
0.3574883043766022,
0.5283610224723816,
0.3665415346622467,
0.5301063656806946,
0.3461662530899048,
0.4832446575164795,
0.2819296717643738,
-0.023121774196624756,
0.32725030183792114,
-0.4097153842449188,
0.17092657089233398,
-0.07915882766246796,
-0.4795171916484833,
0.12287208437919617,
-0.2734870910644531,
0.5659539103507996,
0.5574009418487549,
0.022597678005695343,
0.7075477242469788,
-0.325022429227829,
0.42808735370635986,
-0.9723454117774963,
0.07222725450992584,
-0.7552346587181091,
-0.0239169429987669,
-0.08007346838712692,
0.081670381128788,
-0.04662948101758957,
-0.3896871507167816,
0.158574640750885,
-0.5927367210388184,
0.022696318104863167,
-0.32570958137512207,
0.7929643988609314,
0.34707576036453247,
-0.9089189767837524,
0.17508016526699066,
-0.4710965156555176,
0.7313739061355591,
-0.07497933506965637,
0.5687808990478516,
0.16720840334892273,
0.8699954152107239,
0.3223995268344879,
-0.6603570580482483,
-0.7708554863929749,
0.05422612652182579,
0.3759239614009857,
0.338996946811676,
-0.2260744571685791,
-0.5247507691383362,
0.25884902477264404,
0.21164162456989288,
-0.8356596231460571,
-0.05954279005527496,
-0.5439557433128357,
-0.4552600085735321,
0.33712515234947205,
0.2581196129322052,
0.39094918966293335,
-0.18732944130897522,
-0.5254268050193787,
-0.2889881730079651,
-0.4458131194114685,
0.6363083124160767,
0.09687548130750656,
0.09105318784713745,
-0.17414294183254242,
0.5327053070068359,
-0.7123290300369263,
0.7124403715133667,
-0.6546210050582886,
0.0069166673347353935,
0.37731826305389404,
-0.5113286375999451,
-0.10503333061933517,
-0.48313093185424805,
0.6415083408355713,
0.8856152892112732,
0.45728829503059387,
0.33193638920783997,
0.27934297919273376,
0.15051321685314178,
0.043903496116399765,
-0.7012812495231628,
-0.06607303768396378,
0.02949346788227558,
-0.42874813079833984,
0.16613824665546417,
-0.21550799906253815,
-0.7618916630744934,
-0.41152331233024597,
-0.062247030436992645,
0.2413814216852188,
-0.18117503821849823,
-0.23121124505996704,
-0.20279750227928162,
-0.2766420245170593,
0.7759568691253662,
0.4951942265033722,
-0.43103301525115967,
-0.0024594126734882593,
0.2540285289287567,
0.34777289628982544,
-0.16748987138271332,
-0.36438143253326416,
-0.6726730465888977,
-0.254375159740448,
-0.322365939617157,
0.6136797070503235,
-0.6489375233650208,
-0.22743383049964905,
0.2073882520198822,
0.17391088604927063,
0.24144785106182098,
-0.4717986583709717,
0.4457099735736847,
-0.6125478744506836,
0.1561383455991745,
-0.9384010434150696,
0.18547575175762177,
-0.44252410531044006,
0.693432092666626,
-0.7289102673530579,
0.9751226902008057,
0.19933059811592102,
-0.6097553372383118,
0.5355583429336548,
0.0024087929632514715,
0.0413600355386734,
0.3548853397369385,
-0.5603882074356079,
-0.14687329530715942,
-0.07989910244941711,
0.725307822227478,
0.15368689596652985,
-0.646473228931427,
-0.09960661828517914,
-0.41176867485046387,
-0.3154740631580353,
0.3957958519458771,
-0.6286464929580688,
0.7594103217124939,
0.29632195830345154,
-0.15808337926864624,
-0.03366786241531372,
-0.7391405701637268,
0.3466240465641022,
0.1364431381225586,
-0.14825686812400818,
-0.46674811840057373,
-0.3728947639465332,
0.24806806445121765,
0.6090540885925293,
0.23420046269893646,
-0.6462299823760986,
0.06093069911003113,
0.1971767395734787,
0.0855691060423851,
0.48621368408203125,
-0.026273656636476517,
0.0026106953155249357,
-0.22664718329906464,
0.9178038239479065,
0.20619550347328186,
0.2957122027873993,
-0.24674278497695923,
-0.6739974021911621,
-0.5438715219497681,
-0.46874698996543884,
0.136973038315773,
0.6711005568504333,
-1.4590802192687988,
-0.6461402773857117,
-0.2198592722415924,
-0.6182907223701477,
-0.9276561737060547,
0.25157788395881653,
0.4303504526615143,
0.47278302907943726,
0.4482817053794861,
-0.6956532597541809,
-0.22375036776065826,
-1.115862488746643,
-0.3238990604877472,
-0.22517180442810059,
0.03901568055152893,
0.5306627154350281,
0.49972105026245117,
-0.02256501466035843,
0.5468838214874268,
-0.3085302710533142,
0.0875910222530365,
0.052121274173259735,
-0.005463161505758762,
0.014744657091796398,
0.10139542818069458,
0.7817561626434326,
-1.2729029655456543,
-0.5366243720054626,
0.04185071587562561,
-0.7387738823890686,
0.08676841109991074,
0.04851491376757622,
-0.32701459527015686,
0.00912939477711916,
0.23744294047355652,
-0.24099543690681458,
0.5060383081436157,
0.7768816351890564,
-0.21904641389846802,
0.5296027064323425,
-0.090793676674366,
0.6564473509788513,
-0.8954821825027466,
-0.03661322593688965,
0.09131453931331635,
0.07953613996505737,
-0.42341694235801697,
0.24138373136520386,
0.4410797953605652,
-0.11942917853593826,
-0.9416706562042236,
0.5627169013023376,
-0.35855820775032043,
-0.03222982957959175,
0.18072155117988586,
-0.1754554659128189,
0.06316474080085754,
0.6121283173561096,
0.20736593008041382,
0.7604919672012329,
0.7743886113166809,
-0.3197733163833618,
0.5064634084701538,
0.4366644024848938,
-0.5174444913864136,
0.9583303332328796,
-0.6892991662025452,
-0.1524515300989151,
-0.46652674674987793,
0.05571509525179863,
-1.2215700149536133,
-0.06060640141367912,
-0.014174992218613625,
-0.51519775390625,
-0.26252317428588867,
-0.2754690647125244,
-0.1587226837873459,
-0.5039407014846802,
-0.1515132188796997,
1.0167323350906372,
0.38704484701156616,
-0.6661673784255981,
0.5822678804397583,
0.27948957681655884,
-0.19979260861873627,
-1.1304932832717896,
-0.7661689519882202,
0.10262580215930939,
-0.16364829242229462,
-0.7889996767044067,
0.021342743188142776,
-0.4065767526626587,
-0.21204295754432678,
-0.27228134870529175,
0.020438550040125847,
-0.4671878218650818,
-0.05308431014418602,
0.066895991563797,
0.3213239312171936,
-0.46408939361572266,
0.06846852600574493,
-0.1506761759519577,
0.2542375326156616,
0.056605469435453415,
-0.22433000802993774,
0.31672564148902893,
-0.37521103024482727,
-0.5173999071121216,
-0.18451379239559174,
0.6822273135185242,
0.9442828297615051,
-1.1597410440444946,
0.6066237092018127,
0.9719881415367126,
-0.2563543915748596,
0.04197124019265175,
-0.5991480350494385,
0.2936457693576813,
-0.3880681097507477,
0.5009574294090271,
-0.6366384625434875,
-0.9178910255432129,
0.7136433720588684,
0.28764259815216064,
0.12879537045955658,
0.3155721426010132,
0.9085946679115295,
-0.11650973558425903,
0.7374706864356995,
0.5759671330451965,
0.15462234616279602,
0.239568829536438,
-0.061819277703762054,
-0.35776814818382263,
-0.47754961252212524,
-0.2742455303668976,
-0.479443222284317,
-0.14179439842700958,
-1.030562400817871,
-0.8689471483230591,
0.5358373522758484,
-0.39189600944519043,
-0.1878098100423813,
0.0735291987657547,
-0.4319177269935608,
0.49459075927734375,
0.7322108149528503,
-0.039317820221185684,
0.18374080955982208,
-0.006795038469135761,
-0.2711401879787445,
-0.17189466953277588,
-0.53518146276474,
-0.17826475203037262,
1.1070948839187622,
0.10395421832799911,
0.6081382036209106,
0.3691604733467102,
0.2641487717628479,
-0.027536621317267418,
0.16754400730133057,
-0.41479426622390747,
0.33863723278045654,
-0.17806106805801392,
-0.6821902990341187,
-0.20063862204551697,
-0.44593504071235657,
-0.6757497787475586,
0.7166224122047424,
-0.4680432975292206,
-0.6101902723312378,
0.4160638451576233,
0.15733002126216888,
-0.0879506841301918,
0.15358294546604156,
-0.5219639539718628,
1.1782355308532715,
-0.3794466257095337,
-0.550563395023346,
0.2176838219165802,
-0.7101742029190063,
0.5513023138046265,
0.04477912560105324,
0.2842666208744049,
-0.13842272758483887,
0.0023562046699225903,
0.37694570422172546,
-0.023176852613687515,
0.4590919017791748,
-0.12618733942508698,
0.053809426724910736,
0.41356074810028076,
0.07163789123296738,
0.00498042581602931,
0.23582136631011963,
0.0974094495177269,
0.3096471130847931,
0.3972797095775604,
-0.8391373157501221,
-0.5037480592727661,
0.5412126779556274,
-0.879550039768219,
-0.33676186203956604,
-0.21872097253799438,
-0.593874454498291,
-0.29351264238357544,
-0.01919311285018921,
0.17423444986343384,
0.48928502202033997,
-0.2802799940109253,
0.5333164930343628,
0.560479462146759,
-0.6969627737998962,
0.19536831974983215,
0.598955512046814,
0.0409943051636219,
-0.45210444927215576,
0.7897902131080627,
0.006367765832692385,
0.29368776082992554,
0.42920199036598206,
-0.23491115868091583,
-0.321803480386734,
-0.42065975069999695,
-0.7470385432243347,
-0.03816378861665726,
-1.036439299583435,
0.09291678667068481,
-0.6183064579963684,
0.021550295874476433,
-0.18069586157798767,
0.11901327967643738,
-0.2929060757160187,
-0.36023595929145813,
0.2889017164707184,
0.16330766677856445,
0.32224807143211365,
0.17745906114578247,
0.2971058785915375,
-0.1355399787425995,
-0.714210569858551,
0.7639485001564026,
0.7330824136734009,
0.28770169615745544,
-0.3192380964756012,
-0.2655443847179413,
-0.018509699031710625,
0.04045547544956207,
-0.18431885540485382,
-0.8764346837997437,
0.2599230706691742,
0.06271707266569138,
0.8123856782913208,
-0.1170181930065155,
0.15343335270881653,
0.6892079710960388,
-0.3899427354335785,
0.9727797508239746,
0.16612708568572998,
-0.5148497223854065,
0.20537413656711578,
-0.43116891384124756,
0.8862528800964355,
0.8377890586853027,
0.5957921147346497,
-0.9668763875961304,
-0.30032530426979065,
-0.1174825057387352,
-0.8679800033569336,
0.10860486328601837,
0.10191963613033295,
0.23736731708049774,
0.05319321155548096,
-0.09058760106563568,
0.21517476439476013,
0.3246273100376129,
-0.823493480682373,
-0.20624683797359467,
-0.5494821667671204,
-0.18600130081176758,
-0.11358404904603958,
0.04195703938603401,
-0.1979696899652481,
-0.276618093252182,
0.20663654804229736,
-0.4856503903865814,
0.025152789428830147,
0.08289504796266556,
-0.34711143374443054,
0.08291119337081909,
0.24339188635349274,
0.4259341061115265,
0.7150784730911255,
0.09258558601140976,
-0.01084009651094675,
0.5194455981254578,
-0.4432459771633148,
0.002330685732886195,
0.1889139860868454,
-0.15157124400138855,
-0.13969822227954865,
0.24528281390666962,
0.5665937662124634,
-0.39307060837745667,
-1.0943204164505005,
0.6270473003387451,
-0.8342846632003784,
-0.22811037302017212,
-0.3463013768196106,
-0.1412997543811798,
0.07826878130435944,
0.4094923436641693,
0.355394184589386,
-0.005792951676994562,
0.08876530081033707,
-0.5535982251167297,
0.22403384745121002,
0.5544753074645996,
-0.6171942949295044,
0.13588786125183105,
0.7496106028556824,
0.20806613564491272,
0.005337750539183617,
0.6605177521705627,
0.2003018856048584,
-0.5098267793655396,
0.8592903017997742,
-0.1554640829563141,
0.4157232642173767,
0.03696390613913536,
0.38805317878723145,
0.43626868724823,
0.592235267162323,
0.4494556486606598,
0.7866649627685547,
-0.17870712280273438,
-0.6213142275810242,
-0.3630007803440094,
-0.4601992964744568,
-0.5292067527770996,
-0.07633931934833527,
-0.9051714539527893,
0.17794013023376465,
-0.1934920847415924,
0.007631048560142517,
-0.04998618736863136,
-0.21579205989837646,
-1.2602434158325195,
0.5484090447425842,
0.4979606866836548,
0.9408597350120544,
-0.9271735548973083,
0.6214533448219299,
0.7375644445419312,
-0.4506458342075348,
-0.3297407031059265,
-0.11564963310956955,
0.18038535118103027,
-0.8741129040718079,
0.5633925199508667,
0.17529356479644775,
0.07164014875888824,
-0.49951934814453125,
-0.5672767758369446,
-0.8374208211898804,
0.9839492440223694,
0.32146111130714417,
-0.24317359924316406,
0.43614432215690613,
0.22269536554813385,
0.6327879428863525,
-0.3855050802230835,
0.5385237336158752,
0.28818756341934204,
0.3651750683784485,
0.2475564032793045,
-0.8307822942733765,
-0.09705449640750885,
-0.734401524066925,
0.04289793223142624,
-0.06668762117624283,
-0.7542608380317688,
0.9342823028564453,
-0.12975019216537476,
0.18274714052677155,
0.2404365986585617,
0.7620927691459656,
0.2994597256183624,
0.28257274627685547,
0.4936773180961609,
0.1305757611989975,
0.7019356489181519,
-0.21329866349697113,
1.0356768369674683,
-0.08350135385990143,
-0.10388272255659103,
1.0058915615081787,
-0.17284168303012848,
0.8450263738632202,
0.5173776149749756,
0.16332049667835236,
0.3891353905200958,
0.6903483271598816,
-0.11877751350402832,
0.34711551666259766,
0.29405292868614197,
-0.1934695839881897,
-0.5382789373397827,
-0.46434661746025085,
-0.48392513394355774,
0.9394333362579346,
0.11785279959440231,
-0.04856058210134506,
-0.12792298197746277,
0.05396035686135292,
-0.5132206678390503,
0.34067103266716003,
-0.25769782066345215,
0.48719164729118347,
-0.23043185472488403,
-0.8251122236251831,
0.8635669946670532,
-0.1631019562482834,
0.3873392343521118,
-0.6426946520805359,
-0.03915691003203392,
-0.2807652950286865,
-0.1618109941482544,
0.21680134534835815,
-0.7605524659156799,
-0.120526522397995,
0.22589752078056335,
-0.11817866563796997,
0.04770823195576668,
0.22517074644565582,
-0.6634392142295837,
-0.6287436485290527,
0.22248461842536926,
0.770394504070282,
-0.027862489223480225,
0.11700114607810974,
-0.7352861762046814,
0.07262267917394638,
0.043530404567718506,
0.02554301545023918,
0.10325191915035248,
0.4440549314022064,
-0.5734719634056091,
0.7084176540374756,
0.5204606056213379,
-0.20695962011814117,
0.23263420164585114,
0.1954498291015625,
0.7756310701370239,
-0.5211358666419983,
-0.4990062117576599,
-0.3678353726863861,
0.8490239977836609,
-0.11148779094219208,
-0.7313069701194763,
0.6747559905052185,
0.2700861394405365,
1.0329071283340454,
-0.14372405409812927,
0.8301186561584473,
0.15922565758228302,
0.10742227733135223,
-0.3780139982700348,
0.6069139242172241,
-1.0870065689086914,
-0.1509617269039154,
-0.47370490431785583,
-0.7912101149559021,
-0.12255070358514786,
0.17648985981941223,
-0.14956019818782806,
0.02033679559826851,
0.4257294535636902,
0.7851927280426025,
0.08692540228366852,
-0.08795804530382156,
0.4561646580696106,
-0.026508133858442307,
0.23079422116279602,
0.8493970036506653,
1.1894779205322266,
-0.35095128417015076,
0.9465247392654419,
-0.2803870737552643,
-0.1834409236907959,
0.13543957471847534,
-0.7003359794616699,
-0.8295437097549438,
-0.8204530477523804,
-0.3781653642654419,
-0.12022174149751663,
-0.13021372258663177,
0.6922283172607422,
0.6442891955375671,
-0.7030966877937317,
-0.13867069780826569,
0.7948533296585083,
-0.006981316022574902,
-0.45121610164642334,
-0.08731193095445633,
0.0675249770283699,
0.3288290798664093,
-0.6442105174064636,
0.06504455953836441,
0.16497105360031128,
-0.0008239966700784862,
-0.2610783278942108,
0.07650822401046753,
-0.1953081488609314,
0.03603950887918472,
0.5168609023094177,
0.46139535307884216,
-0.5843513011932373,
-0.23035478591918945,
0.3450244963169098,
-0.06992323696613312,
0.020110206678509712,
0.41055721044540405,
-0.6479974389076233,
0.9539194107055664,
0.6258028745651245,
0.9782635569572449,
0.7062563896179199,
-0.09111864864826202,
0.6087764501571655,
-0.6892216801643372,
0.2733907699584961,
0.18142111599445343,
0.4126693308353424,
0.5078995227813721,
-0.006405641324818134,
0.21867120265960693,
0.08532635122537613,
-0.12928840517997742,
-0.573067307472229,
0.42979755997657776,
-1.1708784103393555,
-0.31731343269348145,
0.875132143497467,
-0.08912915736436844,
-0.38438618183135986,
-0.04703632742166519,
-0.3108254671096802,
-0.028199631720781326,
-0.0027157841250300407,
0.45492351055145264,
0.7963955998420715,
0.3699634373188019,
-0.5525339841842651,
-0.8179842829704285,
0.19003508985042572,
0.5074436068534851,
-0.7334277033805847,
-0.08771825581789017,
0.606835663318634,
0.24896098673343658,
-0.07738231122493744,
0.6034107208251953,
-0.14890675246715546,
0.9416393041610718,
-0.13444411754608154,
0.26012054085731506,
0.1820603758096695,
-0.27607613801956177,
-0.31063133478164673,
0.34080833196640015,
-0.0981360450387001,
-0.3778252601623535
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.05955v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.05955v2
|
Turbo Sparse: Achieving LLM SOTA Performance with Minimal Activated Parameters
| 2024-06-10T01:21:59 | 2024-06-11T02:15:47 |
Yixin Song, Haotong Xie, Zhengyan Zhang, Bo Wen, Li Ma, Zeyu Mi, Haibo Chen
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Exploiting activation sparsity is a promising approach to significantly
accelerating the inference process of large language models (LLMs) without
compromising performance. However, activation sparsity is determined by
activation functions, and commonly used ones like SwiGLU and GeGLU exhibit
limited sparsity. Simply replacing these functions with ReLU fails to achieve
sufficient sparsity. Moreover, inadequate training data can further increase
the risk of performance degradation. To address these challenges, we propose a
novel dReLU function, which is designed to improve LLM activation sparsity,
along with a high-quality training data mixture ratio to facilitate effective
sparsification. Additionally, we leverage sparse activation patterns within the
Feed-Forward Network (FFN) experts of Mixture-of-Experts (MoE) models to
further boost efficiency. By applying our neuron sparsification method to the
Mistral and Mixtral models, only 2.5 billion and 4.3 billion parameters are
activated per inference iteration, respectively, while achieving even more
powerful model performance. Evaluation results demonstrate that this sparsity
achieves a 2-5x decoding speedup. Remarkably, on mobile phones, our
TurboSparse-Mixtral-47B achieves an inference speed of 11 tokens per second.
Our models are available at \url{https://huggingface.co/PowerInfer}
|
[
-0.2787739634513855,
-0.8925895094871521,
0.0957004651427269,
0.5343195796012878,
-0.31179359555244446,
-0.06023610010743141,
-0.40214094519615173,
-0.38741782307624817,
0.5835219621658325,
0.15198077261447906,
-0.7029680609703064,
0.02788340114057064,
-0.63143390417099,
0.11831171065568924,
-0.46290308237075806,
0.6409480571746826,
0.41280078887939453,
0.2071479856967926,
-0.029395319521427155,
-0.27290332317352295,
-0.20684483647346497,
-0.18592514097690582,
-0.7270799279212952,
-0.4967508614063263,
0.5588142275810242,
0.4086368978023529,
0.7773752808570862,
0.5768136382102966,
-0.13049131631851196,
0.28963300585746765,
-0.39215704798698425,
0.20483234524726868,
-0.947644054889679,
0.10306014865636826,
0.44672438502311707,
-0.21590515971183777,
-0.5729461908340454,
-0.38724616169929504,
0.7577351331710815,
0.7550820708274841,
-0.3709777593612671,
-0.1259394884109497,
0.3236567974090576,
0.5045849680900574,
-0.47932806611061096,
-0.027272522449493408,
-0.6372244954109192,
-0.12174033373594284,
0.1051902025938034,
-0.15678100287914276,
-0.2787995934486389,
-0.23949144780635834,
-0.18033459782600403,
-0.7182918190956116,
0.18587352335453033,
-0.1567157357931137,
0.8319581151008606,
0.8136357665061951,
0.06669667363166809,
0.14401093125343323,
-0.6432576179504395,
0.7163912057876587,
-0.6982491612434387,
0.6137558817863464,
0.2596820890903473,
-0.0983218401670456,
-0.5402500033378601,
-0.8596959114074707,
-0.477986216545105,
-0.35514509677886963,
-0.007704812567681074,
0.11753270030021667,
-0.24831530451774597,
0.010362275876104832,
0.40771785378456116,
0.10317148268222809,
-0.5711660385131836,
0.23287387192249298,
-0.15169984102249146,
-0.10304992645978928,
0.6525221467018127,
0.1838209182024002,
0.07751034200191498,
0.15695543587207794,
-0.31724610924720764,
0.22163036465644836,
-0.7911621332168579,
-0.06562845408916473,
0.3096380829811096,
0.26320475339889526,
0.0445999801158905,
0.10219788551330566,
-0.1415058970451355,
0.7520179152488708,
0.31511345505714417,
-0.1229821965098381,
0.11207606643438339,
-0.189170241355896,
-0.30693161487579346,
-0.010107866488397121,
0.7844957113265991,
-0.2264212667942047,
0.03134128078818321,
-0.27704760432243347,
-0.3075443208217621,
-0.3171672224998474,
0.101819708943367,
-1.0376266241073608,
0.05198902264237404,
0.12001489847898483,
-0.26617154479026794,
-0.19094103574752808,
-0.37056291103363037,
-0.7660343050956726,
-0.4774753451347351,
-0.07085005939006805,
0.307527095079422,
-0.40144532918930054,
-0.6333297491073608,
0.2367410957813263,
0.0840735211968422,
0.0725865364074707,
0.2217128723859787,
-1.1838628053665161,
0.6498759984970093,
0.5360822081565857,
0.5826815366744995,
0.007951217703521252,
-0.4925912618637085,
-0.5813091993331909,
-0.2648712694644928,
-0.28524458408355713,
0.8342713713645935,
-0.5326189994812012,
-0.18565203249454498,
-0.2465212047100067,
-0.12839585542678833,
-0.44930124282836914,
-0.6441484689712524,
0.4956948459148407,
-0.74269038438797,
-0.5266739130020142,
-0.06840263307094574,
-0.2196137011051178,
-0.2950662672519684,
-0.29877805709838867,
-0.7957189083099365,
1.691098928451538,
0.148774653673172,
-0.4135533273220062,
0.41097816824913025,
-0.09168613702058792,
-0.6855994462966919,
0.45145997405052185,
-0.3000636100769043,
-0.2570611238479614,
0.30294984579086304,
-0.09075891226530075,
0.5693272352218628,
-0.3465457260608673,
0.5897616147994995,
-0.20286840200424194,
-0.7283083200454712,
0.21762658655643463,
-0.3285554051399231,
0.6253425478935242,
0.24248360097408295,
-0.5274202227592468,
0.2785061299800873,
-0.8706234693527222,
-0.07724685221910477,
0.04404465854167938,
-0.4077287018299103,
-0.30824705958366394,
0.01905299723148346,
0.2176288217306137,
-0.0037111465353518724,
0.06240416690707207,
-0.12051602452993393,
0.07799585908651352,
-0.44308364391326904,
0.6942240595817566,
0.49139952659606934,
-0.28722020983695984,
0.5331093668937683,
0.091752789914608,
0.5199995040893555,
-0.26244404911994934,
-0.24830974638462067,
0.22372224926948547,
-0.5634770393371582,
-0.7125455141067505,
-0.8039160966873169,
0.6781391501426697,
0.3821735382080078,
-0.5590335726737976,
0.702738881111145,
-0.4142240285873413,
-0.47482791543006897,
-0.5533502101898193,
0.44322288036346436,
0.0718148797750473,
0.4466099739074707,
0.1735733300447464,
-0.13758423924446106,
-0.3312273919582367,
-0.8131782412528992,
-0.08826644718647003,
0.25119227170944214,
0.1336907148361206,
0.5306111574172974,
0.3000498414039612,
-0.14607608318328857,
0.7948864698410034,
-0.22649513185024261,
-0.06674836575984955,
-0.6846137046813965,
0.2911791205406189,
0.241613507270813,
0.3858761489391327,
0.435087651014328,
-0.7238476276397705,
-0.3832361698150635,
-0.2084742933511734,
-0.5796675086021423,
-0.32337892055511475,
-0.29056304693222046,
0.05115729570388794,
-0.13304190337657928,
0.5924222469329834,
-0.6462243795394897,
0.3613160252571106,
0.3538782596588135,
0.024367284029722214,
0.20071962475776672,
-0.2703680694103241,
-0.03220289945602417,
-0.7450623512268066,
0.21396882832050323,
0.20810578763484955,
-0.32171735167503357,
-0.9840412735939026,
-0.04187162220478058,
0.19406922161579132,
-0.13650672137737274,
-0.47411012649536133,
0.48906072974205017,
-0.416659951210022,
0.005136403255164623,
-0.4070873260498047,
-0.045466434210538864,
-0.23466768860816956,
0.782005250453949,
0.08701033145189285,
1.080161690711975,
0.6207975745201111,
-0.5974818468093872,
-0.06936045736074448,
-0.07408428192138672,
-0.10518373548984528,
-0.14104223251342773,
-0.85172039270401,
-0.08549318462610245,
-0.19136379659175873,
0.20349717140197754,
-1.1797199249267578,
-0.14575302600860596,
0.21138131618499756,
-0.27632245421409607,
0.6134694814682007,
-0.3040602207183838,
-0.5447824001312256,
-0.014868160709738731,
-0.297065407037735,
0.5663898587226868,
0.5527791976928711,
-0.4229872226715088,
0.8871814012527466,
0.43492597341537476,
-0.2080123871564865,
-0.9162636995315552,
-0.6141321659088135,
0.06741715222597122,
-0.10690101236104965,
-0.8252203464508057,
0.2948154807090759,
0.08633152395486832,
0.12141251564025879,
-0.010824675671756268,
-0.21024560928344727,
-0.3416830003261566,
0.2889801859855652,
0.357718825340271,
0.05376995727419853,
-0.28558972477912903,
-0.26600655913352966,
0.3816732168197632,
-0.3615226447582245,
-0.35532307624816895,
-0.17723998427391052,
0.7304708957672119,
0.012577438727021217,
0.1325301080942154,
-0.4960959851741791,
0.3621874153614044,
0.5663315653800964,
0.0016891576815396547,
0.747235119342804,
0.5710703134536743,
-0.5110782980918884,
-0.31992584466934204,
-0.6357998251914978,
-0.5230379104614258,
-0.4903094172477722,
0.4824335277080536,
-0.48385676741600037,
-0.94012451171875,
0.5753957629203796,
-0.09155935794115067,
-0.19487017393112183,
0.30231013894081116,
0.714222252368927,
0.34834983944892883,
0.8459562063217163,
0.6641581654548645,
-0.2929266393184662,
0.47791826725006104,
-0.4993118941783905,
0.308774471282959,
-0.5607341527938843,
-0.0920984148979187,
-0.36993148922920227,
-0.36231377720832825,
-0.2089286744594574,
-0.3967018127441406,
0.28474700450897217,
0.29904675483703613,
0.21032646298408508,
0.4201892912387848,
-0.3244565427303314,
0.3409583568572998,
0.24791362881660461,
0.2422550469636917,
0.08275586366653442,
0.42379456758499146,
-0.1161077469587326,
-0.16708603501319885,
-1.3491178750991821,
-0.15878602862358093,
0.6168369054794312,
0.444134920835495,
1.2201062440872192,
-0.32333502173423767,
0.4451976716518402,
0.21586449444293976,
0.37356480956077576,
-0.9500618577003479,
0.7908195853233337,
-0.15086729824543,
-0.413173109292984,
-0.16895447671413422,
-0.5093403458595276,
-0.9146832227706909,
0.355287104845047,
-0.35158589482307434,
-0.5711753368377686,
0.44821807742118835,
0.09564046561717987,
-0.796870231628418,
-0.06047484651207924,
-0.6467357277870178,
0.5858935713768005,
-0.07858338207006454,
-0.9856491684913635,
-0.45305150747299194,
-0.3887459635734558,
0.35740339756011963,
0.015929333865642548,
0.01575888879597187,
-0.23416152596473694,
-0.17573793232440948,
0.725020706653595,
-0.3031783998012543,
1.038225769996643,
-0.14680597186088562,
0.004164043348282576,
0.31464219093322754,
-0.011159675195813179,
0.3813159763813019,
0.16403906047344208,
-0.23499561846256256,
0.5367300510406494,
-0.42230546474456787,
-0.2936418056488037,
-0.5242887735366821,
1.0388317108154297,
-0.7167586088180542,
-0.4310479760169983,
-0.30646732449531555,
-0.5952349305152893,
0.04249576851725578,
0.2835758924484253,
0.17225584387779236,
0.5595967173576355,
-0.07900463789701462,
0.04126632213592529,
0.8231152296066284,
0.07402679324150085,
0.4407874047756195,
0.4604181945323944,
0.3693196177482605,
-0.5173160433769226,
1.0231261253356934,
0.27532461285591125,
-0.042936570942401886,
-0.047063522040843964,
0.06668088585138321,
-0.39300334453582764,
-0.7308720350265503,
-0.9163174033164978,
0.3586304485797882,
-0.40883275866508484,
-0.2304513156414032,
-0.8316590189933777,
-0.3587314188480377,
-0.406639963388443,
-0.02470257878303528,
-0.5408828854560852,
-0.4863665997982025,
-0.5587700009346008,
0.055527761578559875,
0.38060566782951355,
0.6136200428009033,
-0.10138716548681259,
0.5067524313926697,
-0.5938681364059448,
0.3878743350505829,
0.11002065241336823,
0.22044098377227783,
0.30226972699165344,
-0.8378924131393433,
-0.24716491997241974,
-0.1839682012796402,
0.025647448375821114,
-0.7880964875221252,
0.5841689705848694,
0.29422619938850403,
0.8439498543739319,
0.3589896559715271,
-0.24756498634815216,
0.990673303604126,
-0.5936803817749023,
0.5196002721786499,
0.0874146893620491,
-0.6390257477760315,
-0.08212855458259583,
-0.12092569470405579,
-0.18898196518421173,
0.6182370185852051,
0.4801531732082367,
-0.11796077340841293,
-0.23576204478740692,
-0.6401193141937256,
-1.1036794185638428,
0.8080708384513855,
0.12648199498653412,
0.3284682333469391,
0.2548089623451233,
0.6626169085502625,
0.17095375061035156,
0.053862884640693665,
-0.6423352360725403,
-0.5334584712982178,
-0.0716954842209816,
-0.16592508554458618,
0.21444368362426758,
-0.8174999952316284,
-0.07752910256385803,
-0.40655800700187683,
0.5929002165794373,
-0.11824440211057663,
0.15287990868091583,
0.2522972822189331,
-0.25369954109191895,
-0.3424202501773834,
0.11152636259794235,
0.8765105605125427,
0.5129376649856567,
-0.1310148388147354,
-0.04556777700781822,
0.47589385509490967,
-0.653117835521698,
0.1999555081129074,
0.4148355722427368,
-0.35084959864616394,
-0.05300433188676834,
0.15463805198669434,
0.5965341329574585,
0.5470502376556396,
-0.5447140336036682,
0.37842097878456116,
-0.33524903655052185,
-0.380280077457428,
-0.11168369650840759,
0.24748750030994415,
0.22889812290668488,
0.041213031858205795,
0.5695974826812744,
0.3004264831542969,
0.12815813720226288,
-0.01748722977936268,
0.4454970955848694,
0.37501299381256104,
-0.3872128129005432,
-0.36961832642555237,
0.8498270511627197,
0.35213980078697205,
-0.05297289788722992,
0.302183598279953,
-0.22779902815818787,
-0.4091735780239105,
0.5826684236526489,
0.6425984501838684,
0.9572582244873047,
-0.16453179717063904,
-0.15729762613773346,
0.501951277256012,
0.31027594208717346,
-0.3495839536190033,
0.42019617557525635,
-0.15520642697811127,
-0.7852427959442139,
-0.7240987420082092,
-0.6707731485366821,
0.07163859158754349,
0.328952431678772,
-0.5186276435852051,
0.15118567645549774,
-0.5642211437225342,
-0.008761798962950706,
0.03715843707323074,
-0.13109754025936127,
-0.2618241012096405,
0.08645615726709366,
0.08170134574174881,
1.2340055704116821,
-1.0940951108932495,
1.0440318584442139,
0.48681965470314026,
-0.24144123494625092,
-0.9012603163719177,
-0.020514607429504395,
-0.25714728236198425,
-0.8984926342964172,
0.8221513032913208,
0.09308411926031113,
-0.5745337605476379,
0.3543917238712311,
-0.4681057631969452,
-0.6863300204277039,
0.9417048096656799,
0.527067244052887,
-0.5975731015205383,
0.43259158730506897,
-0.008618438616394997,
0.4377724230289459,
-0.31106308102607727,
0.5247762799263,
0.8052656650543213,
0.43692347407341003,
0.29591599106788635,
-0.5581598877906799,
0.2114037722349167,
-0.26367315649986267,
-0.04610297456383705,
-0.02661740407347679,
-0.7005316019058228,
0.49584484100341797,
-0.06877704709768295,
-0.180771604180336,
0.2647739350795746,
0.8710975646972656,
0.19376462697982788,
0.13021863996982574,
0.5990745425224304,
0.8114699125289917,
0.6036797165870667,
-0.02626466006040573,
0.9066423773765564,
-0.55778568983078,
0.1935572773218155,
0.6785416007041931,
-0.29273784160614014,
0.7717903852462769,
0.48175695538520813,
0.09566690772771835,
0.20744121074676514,
0.5808291435241699,
0.13351713120937347,
0.6016232967376709,
0.13056451082229614,
-0.4932617247104645,
-0.4617564082145691,
-0.19605660438537598,
-0.30946215987205505,
0.12286452949047089,
0.5949087142944336,
0.03274836391210556,
-0.291015088558197,
-0.2549648880958557,
0.17019043862819672,
0.04467211291193962,
-0.16774040460586548,
0.7468053698539734,
0.07040155678987503,
-0.6521369814872742,
1.2318270206451416,
0.13966739177703857,
0.8109474182128906,
-0.8057159781455994,
-0.02782859094440937,
-0.5871403813362122,
-0.0013311175862327218,
-0.461588054895401,
-0.2564910352230072,
0.08557397872209549,
-0.05054790899157524,
-0.01503903791308403,
-0.13882093131542206,
1.0616283416748047,
-0.42297622561454773,
-0.3621284067630768,
0.48021119832992554,
0.3942124545574188,
0.12473580241203308,
0.027821632102131844,
-0.8797696232795715,
0.22816650569438934,
-0.03448326513171196,
-0.2715545892715454,
0.4141857326030731,
0.251945823431015,
0.22607049345970154,
0.6592638492584229,
0.7244058847427368,
0.22352178394794464,
0.34421613812446594,
0.28367382287979126,
1.3091962337493896,
-0.6721250414848328,
-0.2951948642730713,
-0.8036589622497559,
0.39098355174064636,
-0.011500544846057892,
-0.26863789558410645,
0.7354602813720703,
0.6252164244651794,
0.23287302255630493,
-0.03791125491261482,
0.5359756946563721,
-0.2210368812084198,
0.09742210060358047,
-0.4027392268180847,
0.8782625794410706,
-0.7968468070030212,
0.4008711874485016,
0.23354659974575043,
-0.688144862651825,
-0.4207426905632019,
0.6220591068267822,
-0.1565142124891281,
0.09215635061264038,
0.47223344445228577,
1.491601824760437,
-0.2615293264389038,
-0.06995777785778046,
0.5465914011001587,
0.23789717257022858,
-0.10754556953907013,
0.34784117341041565,
0.9108947515487671,
-0.5913136601448059,
0.5678622722625732,
-0.22357933223247528,
-0.5865474343299866,
-0.4310392439365387,
-0.7043328285217285,
-0.8055129647254944,
-0.13673923909664154,
-0.36137834191322327,
-0.5076830387115479,
0.06016587093472481,
0.7998491525650024,
1.1486973762512207,
-0.6157273650169373,
-0.3494579493999481,
-0.16130325198173523,
0.10877164453268051,
-0.44485214352607727,
-0.21527054905891418,
0.11416344344615936,
-0.48158299922943115,
-0.678047239780426,
0.9225513339042664,
0.4151014983654022,
-0.28470996022224426,
-0.10429486632347107,
-0.21762530505657196,
-0.18874041736125946,
0.04831764101982117,
0.281441330909729,
0.5380775332450867,
-0.5213919281959534,
0.24635878205299377,
0.11569565534591675,
-0.3316470980644226,
0.14361967146396637,
1.0974221229553223,
-0.7647479772567749,
-0.021747814491391182,
0.5966647267341614,
0.8280246257781982,
0.5985461473464966,
-0.024929674342274666,
0.3816831409931183,
-0.7025144696235657,
0.6303079128265381,
0.29952406883239746,
0.4535883069038391,
0.04268750175833702,
-0.5816943645477295,
0.32549163699150085,
0.4001051187515259,
-0.536604642868042,
-0.8816290497779846,
-0.028384363278746605,
-1.1251862049102783,
-0.23685429990291595,
1.2614789009094238,
0.01406786683946848,
-0.5277700424194336,
-0.19260135293006897,
-0.03383226320147514,
0.01929405890405178,
-0.7494214177131653,
0.460045725107193,
0.20487649738788605,
-0.2361183613538742,
-0.19768992066383362,
-0.6578581929206848,
0.6424902677536011,
0.9568111300468445,
-0.3140571415424347,
0.26374712586402893,
0.3201279044151306,
0.4857673645019531,
-0.11004118621349335,
0.8231441974639893,
0.07863733172416687,
0.3978187143802643,
0.34347426891326904,
0.005399479530751705,
-0.19108398258686066,
-0.38015007972717285,
-0.6969752311706543,
0.1402207911014557,
0.12043707817792892,
0.060749080032110214
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.05930v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.05930v1
|
Semisupervised Neural Proto-Language Reconstruction
| 2024-06-09T22:46:41 | 2024-06-09T22:46:41 |
Liang Lu, Peirong Xie, David R. Mortensen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Existing work implementing comparative reconstruction of ancestral languages
(proto-languages) has usually required full supervision. However, historical
reconstruction models are only of practical value if they can be trained with a
limited amount of labeled data. We propose a semisupervised historical
reconstruction task in which the model is trained on only a small amount of
labeled data (cognate sets with proto-forms) and a large amount of unlabeled
data (cognate sets without proto-forms). We propose a neural architecture for
comparative reconstruction (DPD-BiReconstructor) incorporating an essential
insight from linguists' comparative method: that reconstructed words should not
only be reconstructable from their daughter words, but also deterministically
transformable back into their daughter words. We show that this architecture is
able to leverage unlabeled cognate sets to outperform strong semisupervised
baselines on this novel task.
|
[
-0.1754821091890335,
-0.4243324398994446,
0.11641237884759903,
0.013821021653711796,
-0.1448523849248886,
0.3316768705844879,
-0.32271814346313477,
-0.23405127227306366,
0.3816314935684204,
0.3730926513671875,
-0.39864397048950195,
-0.14527854323387146,
-0.36643216013908386,
-0.0620197094976902,
-0.6153549551963806,
0.8479359149932861,
0.2944363057613373,
-0.10686368495225906,
-0.08349785953760147,
0.08616794645786285,
0.02673112414777279,
-0.41560813784599304,
-0.575406551361084,
-0.6520193815231323,
-0.05590632185339928,
0.30279237031936646,
0.473737508058548,
0.6023516654968262,
0.017459241673350334,
0.3430739939212799,
-0.4314083456993103,
0.26563459634780884,
-0.49197492003440857,
-0.16279324889183044,
-0.2596855163574219,
-0.5384278297424316,
-0.5805567502975464,
-0.0764998197555542,
0.5797427296638489,
1.2982432842254639,
-0.10654944181442261,
0.07440517842769623,
0.26756247878074646,
0.6635128259658813,
-0.40332117676734924,
0.23897986114025116,
-0.452903151512146,
0.17101401090621948,
-0.012600570917129517,
-0.2091730386018753,
-0.40097373723983765,
-0.08812092244625092,
0.229408860206604,
-0.3337502181529999,
0.5195063352584839,
-0.008984350599348545,
0.7834990620613098,
-0.040031470358371735,
-0.20982752740383148,
0.07449061423540115,
-1.1176211833953857,
0.6775721311569214,
-0.5009737014770508,
0.5154941082000732,
0.3694396913051605,
0.0646531730890274,
-0.3504275381565094,
-0.8283917903900146,
-0.4195770025253296,
-0.1154387965798378,
-0.09283805638551712,
0.20447298884391785,
-0.7188516855239868,
-0.18028564751148224,
0.0847415030002594,
0.548901379108429,
-0.7074002623558044,
0.40858206152915955,
-0.5337828993797302,
-0.5687839984893799,
0.3027935028076172,
0.0746738389134407,
0.3550717532634735,
-0.21074870228767395,
-0.5561549067497253,
-0.20594795048236847,
-0.8753533363342285,
-0.21513764560222626,
0.3275248408317566,
0.40829649567604065,
-0.1900607794523239,
0.510290801525116,
-0.3226626217365265,
0.799761950969696,
0.2466641366481781,
-0.13235943019390106,
0.0909632071852684,
-0.35369443893432617,
-0.15035124123096466,
0.0950884073972702,
0.492093563079834,
0.2777509093284607,
0.38059067726135254,
-0.677173376083374,
-0.08807860314846039,
0.15488643944263458,
0.13254553079605103,
-0.5006886124610901,
-0.7585767507553101,
-0.14539094269275665,
-0.4230646789073944,
-0.010829634964466095,
-0.3025267720222473,
-0.7831158638000488,
-0.12047123908996582,
-0.3544316589832306,
0.19425569474697113,
-0.3995364308357239,
-0.36156144738197327,
-0.00588064594194293,
-0.16364361345767975,
0.03474710136651993,
0.08890777081251144,
-1.0470824241638184,
0.4290786385536194,
0.6261135339736938,
0.6722331643104553,
0.11409999430179596,
-0.34285497665405273,
-0.14015528559684753,
0.036480553448200226,
-0.6462599039077759,
0.8248763680458069,
-0.13764090836048126,
-0.32464152574539185,
-0.16248150169849396,
0.07841984927654266,
0.2786201238632202,
-0.7977923154830933,
0.23549048602581024,
-0.5559089183807373,
0.03641388937830925,
0.02093644067645073,
-0.5316040515899658,
-0.15049408376216888,
0.3125355541706085,
-0.7127509117126465,
0.8299354910850525,
0.3496769964694977,
-0.6973077058792114,
0.28507569432258606,
0.3284633755683899,
-0.5057083368301392,
0.1648489236831665,
-0.3239894211292267,
-0.4536084830760956,
0.25937601923942566,
0.02264215797185898,
0.36505669355392456,
-0.3752121329307556,
0.3081148862838745,
-0.2112617790699005,
-0.19157887995243073,
-0.29828235507011414,
-0.35859936475753784,
1.0146819353103638,
-0.14834631979465485,
-0.49303558468818665,
-0.23094923794269562,
-1.066667914390564,
-0.21631427109241486,
0.10683219879865646,
-0.3734293580055237,
-0.6918657422065735,
-0.0323624350130558,
-0.41895297169685364,
0.004583514761179686,
0.1913301944732666,
-0.730052649974823,
0.2839112877845764,
-0.49995124340057373,
0.3264250159263611,
0.6207767128944397,
-0.19133025407791138,
0.8382097482681274,
-0.3644491732120514,
0.24385930597782135,
-0.10674771666526794,
-0.33861252665519714,
0.27060648798942566,
-0.08049868792295456,
-1.0115426778793335,
-0.39315950870513916,
0.3163702189922333,
0.2622721493244171,
-0.9076711535453796,
0.4808881878852844,
-0.7089589238166809,
-0.5006616115570068,
-0.22057029604911804,
-0.05136135220527649,
0.5524286031723022,
0.7603631019592285,
0.4685031771659851,
-0.10139741748571396,
-0.9718718528747559,
-1.3275492191314697,
0.25409096479415894,
-0.452071875333786,
0.03490764647722244,
0.08728591352701187,
0.3831404447555542,
0.2554093897342682,
0.581598699092865,
-0.3555091619491577,
-0.3607688844203949,
-0.25866544246673584,
0.3657735288143158,
0.1865103542804718,
0.4552389085292816,
0.49154922366142273,
-0.5457583665847778,
-0.3013665974140167,
0.026839623227715492,
-0.49251675605773926,
-0.10900644212961197,
-0.173076331615448,
0.04837090149521828,
-0.14724060893058777,
0.6156682372093201,
-0.3500991463661194,
0.39155685901641846,
0.6378222107887268,
-0.2336074262857437,
0.3122975528240204,
-0.4258626103401184,
-0.11344074457883835,
-1.1124070882797241,
0.17400671541690826,
-0.5331188440322876,
-0.37741637229919434,
-0.8412846326828003,
-0.23765482008457184,
0.1364147812128067,
0.050630923360586166,
-0.36926135420799255,
0.47234705090522766,
-0.9068277478218079,
-0.3976663649082184,
-0.4082562029361725,
-0.062021300196647644,
-0.2987748980522156,
0.3482411205768585,
0.4776192307472229,
0.6981494426727295,
0.5175138711929321,
-0.5316616296768188,
0.30437448620796204,
0.5602105855941772,
-0.4095008671283722,
0.3564596176147461,
-0.3681367039680481,
0.3117702305316925,
-0.12630996108055115,
0.21874886751174927,
-0.8103595972061157,
0.290550172328949,
-0.11559313535690308,
-0.4619491994380951,
0.5714840292930603,
-0.26365986466407776,
-0.2259235680103302,
-0.08643968403339386,
-0.1441705971956253,
0.33833569288253784,
0.635256290435791,
-0.7829563617706299,
0.5287072062492371,
0.33164823055267334,
-0.3254926800727844,
-0.5108004212379456,
-0.6223117113113403,
0.24589762091636658,
0.11906306445598602,
-0.20671360194683075,
0.57688307762146,
0.2617337107658386,
-0.2241114377975464,
0.040720995515584946,
-0.12859734892845154,
0.043189868330955505,
-0.0858582854270935,
0.12184310704469681,
0.44543081521987915,
-0.21874414384365082,
-0.0290859155356884,
-0.014743519015610218,
-0.1259274035692215,
-0.22855748236179352,
-0.3395126461982727,
0.7879563570022583,
0.09796866774559021,
0.18505223095417023,
-0.08891735225915909,
0.33698374032974243,
0.43201956152915955,
-0.15369074046611786,
0.3546891510486603,
-0.0021960840094834566,
-0.5425062775611877,
-0.5207169651985168,
-0.34685051441192627,
-0.15550470352172852,
-0.35016506910324097,
0.41439133882522583,
-0.35713842511177063,
-0.7779442071914673,
0.22846058011054993,
-0.18530024588108063,
-0.14125597476959229,
0.34654510021209717,
0.8263986110687256,
-0.3094945251941681,
0.5720595717430115,
0.6318355798721313,
-0.26934459805488586,
0.3134535551071167,
-0.49142295122146606,
-0.13946610689163208,
-0.9099743962287903,
-0.3440623879432678,
-0.6704256534576416,
-0.4525511562824249,
-0.38881024718284607,
-0.24923160672187805,
-0.15428289771080017,
0.033555883914232254,
-0.07890230417251587,
0.732318639755249,
-0.16357998549938202,
0.11421538889408112,
0.5981882214546204,
0.21047981083393097,
0.3631332814693451,
0.19690445065498352,
-0.14254440367221832,
0.013992588967084885,
-0.8347316980361938,
-0.654900312423706,
0.8576087951660156,
-0.16816502809524536,
0.6574927568435669,
0.032601382583379745,
0.8821444511413574,
0.10534193366765976,
0.21606139838695526,
-0.7204784154891968,
0.7502843141555786,
-0.54811692237854,
-0.6723328828811646,
0.04473930969834328,
-0.5082587003707886,
-1.138536810874939,
0.15342441201210022,
-0.1611797958612442,
-0.9226037859916687,
0.7202040553092957,
0.22923800349235535,
-0.4417039155960083,
0.4332980513572693,
-0.394999235868454,
0.3361562192440033,
-0.08049605786800385,
-0.23192206025123596,
-0.1461252123117447,
-0.5996195673942566,
0.20831888914108276,
-0.14772972464561462,
-0.10544231534004211,
0.14628846943378448,
0.07906267046928406,
0.6347078680992126,
-0.3782910108566284,
0.9870345592498779,
-0.09368032962083817,
0.044025059789419174,
-0.026671744883060455,
0.5166003704071045,
0.30109307169914246,
-0.30388399958610535,
0.2637660801410675,
0.0037832341622561216,
0.11376184970140457,
-0.3590352237224579,
-0.4516988694667816,
0.6472301483154297,
-0.5880907773971558,
-0.3412376344203949,
-0.42983606457710266,
-0.6097947359085083,
-0.24121804535388947,
0.2129746973514557,
0.2899177372455597,
0.6057901978492737,
-0.5575045347213745,
0.16799284517765045,
0.4549225866794586,
-0.09418527781963348,
0.6714206337928772,
0.5282731056213379,
-0.04055241867899895,
-0.0022744631860405207,
0.7493945360183716,
0.0872419998049736,
0.21449898183345795,
0.6810569167137146,
0.05822425335645676,
-0.24468514323234558,
-0.8206708431243896,
-0.36974048614501953,
0.07514210045337677,
-0.2983984649181366,
-0.11648285388946533,
-0.45798763632774353,
0.004869875032454729,
-0.19134993851184845,
0.12491213530302048,
-0.7103341221809387,
-0.7011781930923462,
-0.35423147678375244,
-0.09317301213741302,
-0.2764558792114258,
0.42673078179359436,
-0.4981236159801483,
0.008256183005869389,
-0.7980221509933472,
0.4931254982948303,
0.2616209387779236,
-0.09447090327739716,
0.14108723402023315,
-0.6136142015457153,
0.06275295466184616,
0.05346444249153137,
0.22736288607120514,
-0.7167574763298035,
0.508335530757904,
0.44448521733283997,
0.47001007199287415,
0.15583345293998718,
0.12811604142189026,
0.7148841023445129,
-0.7889982461929321,
0.4105801582336426,
0.11282576620578766,
-0.4687880873680115,
0.31043559312820435,
0.14380984008312225,
0.29231488704681396,
0.5507004261016846,
0.35977429151535034,
-0.1889132857322693,
-0.15046407282352448,
-0.7445217967033386,
-0.6826043725013733,
0.39557725191116333,
0.1585867553949356,
0.15798649191856384,
-0.09844750165939331,
0.31103381514549255,
0.3667141795158386,
-0.16689904034137726,
-0.13340166211128235,
0.08395044505596161,
-0.04681991785764694,
-0.0011996714165434241,
-0.2086564153432846,
0.024753574281930923,
-0.13105952739715576,
-0.16468536853790283,
0.5633208751678467,
0.11838360875844955,
0.45327118039131165,
0.08584442734718323,
-0.40651705861091614,
0.24121183156967163,
0.3439825177192688,
0.3093908429145813,
0.49137741327285767,
-0.22530916333198547,
0.7158812284469604,
-0.07856416702270508,
-0.43806514143943787,
0.33490169048309326,
0.28615614771842957,
-0.6658383011817932,
-0.04861379787325859,
0.7781552672386169,
0.8001493215560913,
0.13921765983104706,
-0.34225285053253174,
0.3459923267364502,
-0.021645527333021164,
-0.02494167909026146,
-0.3196358382701874,
-0.42851021885871887,
0.3398205041885376,
0.5646404027938843,
0.23757538199424744,
0.07656662911176682,
0.09490717202425003,
-0.9091452360153198,
0.38919880986213684,
0.2132437378168106,
-0.2216617614030838,
-0.7701274752616882,
0.4052913784980774,
-0.06229832395911217,
-0.42497003078460693,
0.9866742491722107,
0.04724743217229843,
-0.6341349482536316,
0.4855092167854309,
0.8975064754486084,
0.5252339243888855,
-0.19137437641620636,
0.18610996007919312,
0.47506651282310486,
0.1529521644115448,
-0.13067537546157837,
0.4900478422641754,
-0.2504035532474518,
-0.9104040265083313,
-0.2803137004375458,
-0.5918416380882263,
-0.006450592540204525,
0.11892633885145187,
-0.7898152470588684,
-0.050753626972436905,
-0.433638334274292,
-0.06052693724632263,
0.11647774279117584,
-0.2752818465232849,
-0.6255072355270386,
0.5082321166992188,
0.022995077073574066,
0.8219714760780334,
-0.8334622979164124,
0.9249531030654907,
0.57313072681427,
-0.33996808528900146,
-0.7053481936454773,
-0.14817728102207184,
-0.11718115210533142,
-0.7264285087585449,
0.7550637722015381,
-0.4648711085319519,
-0.39184558391571045,
0.3525538742542267,
-0.2432575821876526,
-0.31756776571273804,
0.8350998163223267,
0.6107624173164368,
-0.7441580295562744,
-0.34740352630615234,
-0.05174943432211876,
0.7984430193901062,
0.006800360046327114,
-0.1256646066904068,
0.5521547794342041,
0.04705754294991493,
-0.03682655841112137,
-0.8392204642295837,
0.005378400906920433,
-0.05255742371082306,
-0.13412593305110931,
0.389408141374588,
-0.3906598687171936,
0.6318858861923218,
-0.15331213176250458,
-0.5281832814216614,
0.39517641067504883,
0.7464132905006409,
-0.1252051293849945,
-0.18971975147724152,
0.555152177810669,
0.660266101360321,
0.3614123463630676,
-0.21447604894638062,
0.9916923642158508,
-0.012915044091641903,
0.320924311876297,
1.4434624910354614,
0.041177134960889816,
0.9299014210700989,
0.6532502770423889,
-0.2589963376522064,
0.1409483700990677,
0.5378745794296265,
0.01234418898820877,
0.6951941251754761,
0.07950622588396072,
-0.16894513368606567,
-0.39402368664741516,
-0.2797260284423828,
-0.16468526422977448,
0.9646791815757751,
-0.061994101852178574,
-0.5235170722007751,
-0.447114497423172,
-0.19988016784191132,
0.08032988011837006,
0.12248072028160095,
-0.19050408899784088,
0.8400372266769409,
0.1625404953956604,
-0.6524323225021362,
0.635164737701416,
-0.1899873912334442,
0.3151858448982239,
-0.5394612550735474,
-0.22789502143859863,
-0.7175633907318115,
0.2934623062610626,
-0.10087975859642029,
-0.41816991567611694,
0.38158345222473145,
-0.1785508096218109,
-0.056229617446660995,
-0.18520572781562805,
0.7308118939399719,
-0.5013453364372253,
-0.27140459418296814,
0.5300178527832031,
0.8022212982177734,
0.12314411997795105,
0.2728579342365265,
-0.1380567103624344,
-0.27830690145492554,
0.07407095283269882,
-0.1836923360824585,
0.27236074209213257,
-0.02906602993607521,
-0.2589801847934723,
0.4564265310764313,
0.45786863565444946,
0.643496036529541,
0.1398639678955078,
0.031442560255527496,
0.8864151835441589,
-0.5196495056152344,
-0.3353118300437927,
-0.7380296587944031,
0.3588251769542694,
-0.029515480622649193,
-0.1339048147201538,
0.4041113555431366,
0.801197350025177,
1.1886705160140991,
-0.14654415845870972,
0.5013144016265869,
-0.20113828778266907,
0.6070916056632996,
-0.39781033992767334,
0.6315913796424866,
-0.4950030744075775,
-0.0753963366150856,
-0.07955760508775711,
-1.027941107749939,
-0.1620846688747406,
0.48002561926841736,
0.04906992241740227,
-0.25112608075141907,
0.5905071496963501,
0.7727400660514832,
-0.35792651772499084,
-0.06911490112543106,
0.3986518383026123,
0.291753888130188,
-0.04197600856423378,
0.6350271701812744,
1.0013476610183716,
-0.10317278653383255,
0.5806211829185486,
-0.5906854867935181,
-0.5190955400466919,
0.28903093934059143,
-0.6801885962486267,
-0.7353094220161438,
-0.9122449159622192,
-0.09140411019325256,
-0.22752736508846283,
0.15709269046783447,
0.6067669987678528,
0.6437098979949951,
-0.7350856065750122,
-0.27043744921684265,
0.0807005986571312,
-0.45707404613494873,
-0.4070361852645874,
-0.05626600235700607,
0.7369183897972107,
0.34567052125930786,
-1.0296682119369507,
0.8954750895500183,
0.4382489323616028,
0.19542169570922852,
-0.20578713715076447,
0.16272835433483124,
-0.4596864581108093,
-0.11189079284667969,
0.40574899315834045,
0.6124181747436523,
-0.2631492018699646,
-0.47194552421569824,
-0.08869247138500214,
-0.11231990158557892,
0.2563360929489136,
0.9187706708908081,
-0.8000577688217163,
0.6642121076583862,
0.8826468586921692,
0.8783153891563416,
0.9333271980285645,
-0.11529229581356049,
0.6674967408180237,
-0.7670058608055115,
0.3132172226905823,
0.5021518468856812,
0.6321274638175964,
0.482591837644577,
-0.04102989286184311,
0.5015421509742737,
0.3062495291233063,
-0.006364941131323576,
-0.5746985673904419,
0.4673554599285126,
-0.9708065390586853,
-0.4702417552471161,
1.0060514211654663,
-0.4084418714046478,
-0.23865586519241333,
-0.23863375186920166,
-0.10577592253684998,
0.7357987761497498,
0.19560986757278442,
0.7881835103034973,
0.531190812587738,
-0.015097491443157196,
-0.2975071668624878,
-0.07450887560844421,
0.09184171259403229,
0.4344075322151184,
-0.596742570400238,
0.00884358398616314,
0.5478383302688599,
0.31924882531166077,
0.18674658238887787,
0.6753790378570557,
-0.31392350792884827,
0.19003601372241974,
0.37095117568969727,
0.11078815907239914,
-0.22392702102661133,
-0.4951682984828949,
-0.2463783323764801,
0.17280912399291992,
-0.07365857809782028,
-0.3391472101211548
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.05925v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.05925v1
|
Hello Again! LLM-powered Personalized Agent for Long-term Dialogue
| 2024-06-09T21:58:32 | 2024-06-09T21:58:32 |
Hao Li, Chenghao Yang, An Zhang, Yang Deng, Xiang Wang, Tat-Seng Chua
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Open-domain dialogue systems have seen remarkable advancements with the
development of large language models (LLMs). Nonetheless, most existing
dialogue systems predominantly focus on brief single-session interactions,
neglecting the real-world demands for long-term companionship and personalized
interactions with chatbots. Crucial to addressing this real-world need are
event summary and persona management, which enable reasoning for appropriate
long-term dialogue responses. Recent progress in the human-like cognitive and
reasoning capabilities of LLMs suggests that LLM-based agents could
significantly enhance automated perception, decision-making, and
problem-solving. In response to this potential, we introduce a model-agnostic
framework, the Long-term Dialogue Agent (LD-Agent), which incorporates three
independently tunable modules dedicated to event perception, persona
extraction, and response generation. For the event memory module, long and
short-term memory banks are employed to separately focus on historical and
ongoing sessions, while a topic-based retrieval mechanism is introduced to
enhance the accuracy of memory retrieval. Furthermore, the persona module
conducts dynamic persona modeling for both users and agents. The integration of
retrieved memories and extracted personas is subsequently fed into the
generator to induce appropriate responses. The effectiveness, generality, and
cross-domain capabilities of LD-Agent are empirically demonstrated across
various illustrative benchmarks, models, and tasks. The code is released at
https://github.com/leolee99/LD-Agent.
|
[
-0.3855718672275543,
-0.8805032968521118,
0.9902889132499695,
-0.026391422376036644,
-0.06744860112667084,
0.35169392824172974,
-0.2040923833847046,
-0.5742908120155334,
0.3697502017021179,
0.833581268787384,
-0.7382731437683105,
-0.40468066930770874,
0.05038539692759514,
0.19588731229305267,
-0.10604211688041687,
0.8252479434013367,
0.43899479508399963,
-0.04707970842719078,
-0.41458660364151,
-0.31987741589546204,
-0.5352299213409424,
-0.7559652924537659,
-0.9786355495452881,
-0.6807056665420532,
0.7577643990516663,
0.07207410782575607,
0.7252167463302612,
0.003919574432075024,
0.12334130704402924,
0.3533584177494049,
0.06130208820104599,
0.2933976650238037,
-0.3758106231689453,
0.4718124270439148,
-0.3775240480899811,
-0.32639819383621216,
-0.8901803493499756,
-0.1233823373913765,
0.4904525876045227,
0.4976070821285248,
-0.18992464244365692,
-0.24826757609844208,
-0.03259332478046417,
0.37115415930747986,
-0.3325905203819275,
0.13520897924900055,
-0.5892490148544312,
-0.11191422492265701,
0.23447956144809723,
-0.354643851518631,
-0.6664038896560669,
-0.2066502869129181,
0.3090441823005676,
-0.6744554042816162,
0.024301467463374138,
0.15746332705020905,
0.4613965153694153,
0.15174570679664612,
-0.3028434216976166,
-0.2719114422798157,
-0.9151625633239746,
0.7595099210739136,
-0.5642069578170776,
0.22423698008060455,
0.11193589121103287,
0.5658259391784668,
-0.24860194325447083,
-0.7429839968681335,
-0.6954720616340637,
-0.6962075233459473,
-0.02367306686937809,
0.1650400012731552,
-0.1699008345603943,
0.2911718487739563,
0.06569685786962509,
0.025647679343819618,
-0.30591997504234314,
0.1843782514333725,
0.08323254436254501,
-0.3188367784023285,
0.4243391454219818,
0.47623974084854126,
0.32292935252189636,
-0.04331592842936516,
-0.5184013247489929,
0.31155887246131897,
-0.5586726665496826,
-0.08058395981788635,
0.3636612296104431,
0.27502796053886414,
-0.055514976382255554,
0.3652709424495697,
-0.2860293686389923,
0.49721574783325195,
0.2227308303117752,
-0.20441342890262604,
0.04723590984940529,
-0.3383466899394989,
-0.0758703202009201,
-0.014529923908412457,
0.7055360078811646,
0.5742730498313904,
0.3614986836910248,
-0.28982460498809814,
-0.1727898269891739,
-0.3172922432422638,
0.3595464825630188,
-0.8047724962234497,
-0.23261944949626923,
0.2903084456920624,
-0.4314436614513397,
-0.20209893584251404,
-0.2951730787754059,
-0.6935459971427917,
-0.5539897084236145,
-0.27725574374198914,
0.32807064056396484,
-0.24361473321914673,
-0.13049422204494476,
0.03692985326051712,
0.15149708092212677,
0.27005845308303833,
0.7306809425354004,
-0.5986810326576233,
0.3156489133834839,
0.6211212873458862,
0.7181404232978821,
-0.49229323863983154,
-0.23504389822483063,
-0.8053033351898193,
0.14394186437129974,
-0.01785057969391346,
0.7891705632209778,
-0.7347513437271118,
-0.6402562260627747,
0.08017467707395554,
0.12159616500139236,
0.06172645092010498,
-0.706436038017273,
0.3024856448173523,
-0.5349873900413513,
0.5173159241676331,
0.09426623582839966,
-0.4043010473251343,
0.23341234028339386,
0.40948328375816345,
-0.4641210734844208,
0.7678722739219666,
0.2165301889181137,
-0.2555166184902191,
0.015045588836073875,
-0.7371713519096375,
-0.14778560400009155,
0.306264191865921,
-0.21209938824176788,
-0.2626447379589081,
-0.07051602005958557,
0.021755682304501534,
0.3896843194961548,
-0.41372865438461304,
0.2585008144378662,
-0.5137630701065063,
-0.23204632103443146,
0.41808560490608215,
-0.34399154782295227,
0.32413655519485474,
0.18963809311389923,
0.08798491954803467,
0.2151341736316681,
-0.8490949273109436,
-0.08743370324373245,
0.17723716795444489,
-0.3370620906352997,
-0.10974845290184021,
-0.03827411308884621,
-0.08083399385213852,
0.11314453929662704,
0.6040248870849609,
-0.8000285625457764,
0.13093972206115723,
-0.44951558113098145,
0.4706476330757141,
0.8941813707351685,
0.07494066655635834,
0.46076515316963196,
-0.4690154790878296,
0.5430633425712585,
0.0015124097699299455,
0.16763201355934143,
-0.709017276763916,
-0.44075605273246765,
-0.7028703689575195,
-0.2586032450199127,
-0.28315243124961853,
0.6582470536231995,
-0.7225487232208252,
0.5541212558746338,
-0.23150214552879333,
0.17483964562416077,
-0.13070222735404968,
0.04650173336267471,
0.3020404875278473,
0.49744927883148193,
0.1908690333366394,
-0.5744407773017883,
-0.43992894887924194,
-0.8209541440010071,
-0.058184996247291565,
-0.49252375960350037,
-0.29696980118751526,
0.6426011323928833,
0.3170205354690552,
-0.508289635181427,
1.3427338600158691,
-0.43674081563949585,
-0.257938414812088,
-0.4943428039550781,
-0.2136462926864624,
0.07456332445144653,
0.09311993420124054,
0.38287511467933655,
-0.503193736076355,
-0.42097005248069763,
0.11767438054084778,
-0.6851333379745483,
-0.2206406593322754,
-0.44691094756126404,
-0.15756113827228546,
0.49782973527908325,
0.2852760851383209,
-0.8779388666152954,
0.32102659344673157,
0.06684410572052002,
-0.2610676884651184,
0.6689431071281433,
-0.4107047915458679,
-0.10523459315299988,
-1.3251293897628784,
0.037053581327199936,
-0.23537090420722961,
-0.6553378701210022,
-0.7464225888252258,
-0.2516833543777466,
-0.3081718981266022,
-0.258505642414093,
-0.4564087390899658,
1.0286461114883423,
-0.22000806033611298,
-0.19974717497825623,
-0.6363247036933899,
0.4194996654987335,
0.13871416449546814,
0.7110848426818848,
0.045409150421619415,
0.7445053458213806,
0.3438555598258972,
-0.479868620634079,
0.8051298260688782,
0.2755555808544159,
-0.12953540682792664,
1.106689453125,
-0.6971303820610046,
0.5708121061325073,
-0.1100090816617012,
0.5119209885597229,
-0.8104126453399658,
-0.33403217792510986,
0.519343376159668,
-0.3302883803844452,
0.2908070683479309,
0.09648587554693222,
-0.46713411808013916,
-0.21842387318611145,
-0.22207513451576233,
0.10614320635795593,
0.48756176233291626,
-0.6623416543006897,
1.0141193866729736,
0.2307264655828476,
-0.47663363814353943,
-0.11072610318660736,
-0.2276550978422165,
0.356913685798645,
-0.20599792897701263,
-0.5383232235908508,
0.20445477962493896,
-0.5800451040267944,
-0.3353159427642822,
-0.33122584223747253,
-0.07629211246967316,
0.027957137674093246,
-0.03291730582714081,
0.34524962306022644,
0.2742506265640259,
0.07524184137582779,
0.22708581387996674,
-0.29184088110923767,
-0.24344339966773987,
0.11132962256669998,
-0.38638561964035034,
0.6836670637130737,
-0.2704724669456482,
-0.3718198835849762,
-0.5364903211593628,
0.38734060525894165,
0.542349100112915,
-0.039981529116630554,
0.5999636054039001,
0.4375492036342621,
-0.01099544670432806,
-0.16829639673233032,
-0.6721088886260986,
-0.25696542859077454,
-0.5097071528434753,
0.4021880328655243,
-0.42492109537124634,
-1.1002917289733887,
0.6662496328353882,
-0.26843947172164917,
0.10319702327251434,
-0.05863448604941368,
0.7602279782295227,
-0.26748359203338623,
0.9457247853279114,
0.5961506962776184,
-0.30803683400154114,
0.5058531165122986,
0.15914052724838257,
0.2119366079568863,
-0.8668907284736633,
-0.44170984625816345,
-0.13582122325897217,
-0.040923602879047394,
-0.3346380591392517,
-0.3237130343914032,
0.42907315492630005,
-0.2940898835659027,
-0.27752843499183655,
0.08961064368486404,
-0.2737749218940735,
0.48931652307510376,
0.29996344447135925,
0.038638174533843994,
0.37763696908950806,
-0.21639925241470337,
0.11625215411186218,
0.15503810346126556,
-0.21361611783504486,
-0.540708065032959,
0.8856732249259949,
0.46172356605529785,
0.7899908423423767,
0.08702247589826584,
0.8002128601074219,
0.4879891574382782,
0.19309057295322418,
-0.6742633581161499,
0.8794758319854736,
0.2939550280570984,
-0.44797858595848083,
-0.2992769181728363,
-0.19322699308395386,
-0.9889766573905945,
0.29887956380844116,
0.08608448505401611,
-1.1438753604888916,
0.034799400717020035,
0.1009458601474762,
-0.6637413501739502,
0.0876166969537735,
-0.4013313055038452,
0.5157939791679382,
-0.23078735172748566,
-0.44330894947052,
-0.42924392223358154,
-0.7407419681549072,
0.08940906822681427,
-0.19516223669052124,
0.017173148691654205,
-0.3524909019470215,
-0.07027822732925415,
0.2743760943412781,
-0.39930370450019836,
0.9638521075248718,
-0.05794549733400345,
-0.23420287668704987,
0.31367024779319763,
0.04415520653128624,
0.6953483819961548,
0.2994016706943512,
-0.05024692043662071,
-0.18591725826263428,
0.05263291671872139,
-0.23278166353702545,
-0.9166192412376404,
0.7217068672180176,
-0.5876272916793823,
-0.8844831585884094,
-0.20505596697330475,
-0.4256429076194763,
-0.1917504370212555,
0.1828797310590744,
-0.2559298872947693,
0.4815257489681244,
-0.6631885170936584,
0.21059978008270264,
0.6555206775665283,
-0.5750727653503418,
0.3623073399066925,
0.8534424901008606,
-0.526785671710968,
-0.4625231921672821,
0.9231263399124146,
-0.5583455562591553,
0.4498969316482544,
0.5038349628448486,
0.05041845142841339,
-0.1657339185476303,
-0.23180381953716278,
-0.26519519090652466,
0.2249448448419571,
-0.6676381230354309,
0.05288183316588402,
-0.7373020648956299,
-0.1635410636663437,
-0.19147583842277527,
-0.15174315869808197,
-0.20043502748012543,
-0.26906663179397583,
-0.3285694718360901,
0.007096722722053528,
0.12333918362855911,
0.5234944820404053,
0.07444345206022263,
0.36808183789253235,
-0.6280258893966675,
0.6038305759429932,
0.5071746110916138,
0.1564377248287201,
-0.3138887286186218,
-0.42801985144615173,
-0.29193776845932007,
-0.030960608273744583,
-0.5231552720069885,
-0.7095016837120056,
0.41104793548583984,
0.4492039382457733,
0.72280353307724,
0.3501006066799164,
-0.01873413845896721,
0.19615446031093597,
-0.5977073907852173,
0.8427554965019226,
0.21739816665649414,
-0.5452183485031128,
0.5810773968696594,
-0.5111283659934998,
0.5800698399543762,
0.3429231345653534,
-0.14136889576911926,
-0.5274150967597961,
-0.5589590072631836,
-0.3672259747982025,
-0.5627976655960083,
0.7870713472366333,
0.19722595810890198,
0.4707101881504059,
-0.05288458615541458,
0.6633107662200928,
0.13718582689762115,
0.3299352526664734,
-0.5839623808860779,
-0.3525518476963043,
-0.019738351926207542,
0.10511022806167603,
-0.2225589007139206,
-0.4150513708591461,
-0.07072076201438904,
0.004136450123041868,
0.41103851795196533,
-0.434907466173172,
0.3651183843612671,
0.11248660087585449,
0.005332542583346367,
-0.013720610179007053,
0.4444878399372101,
0.4544731676578522,
0.7340275645256042,
-0.4139240086078644,
-0.15469422936439514,
0.27946576476097107,
-0.19692063331604004,
-0.016142992302775383,
0.1141757145524025,
0.018045295029878616,
-0.03247153013944626,
0.11462205648422241,
0.7017666697502136,
0.4102824628353119,
-0.8462769985198975,
0.3093037009239197,
-0.2261923998594284,
0.10674484074115753,
-0.7339839935302734,
0.11719571053981781,
0.09788747131824493,
0.6234984397888184,
0.2517404556274414,
-0.24391917884349823,
0.12641699612140656,
-0.9073688387870789,
0.24625054001808167,
0.5199055671691895,
-0.1641952097415924,
-0.568669319152832,
0.751103937625885,
0.6541547775268555,
-0.5996996760368347,
0.6381593942642212,
-0.04599374160170555,
-0.3539648652076721,
0.3748869001865387,
0.46960270404815674,
1.1289187669754028,
-0.24813523888587952,
0.2914467751979828,
0.05987435206770897,
-0.1502605825662613,
0.3675297498703003,
0.10161875188350677,
-0.4752448499202728,
-0.8496332168579102,
-0.023751454427838326,
-0.7354465126991272,
-0.7230870723724365,
0.018026940524578094,
-0.5444907546043396,
-0.0697554424405098,
-0.44938144087791443,
-0.36262276768684387,
0.020428510382771492,
0.18015983700752258,
-0.5559627413749695,
-0.09695016592741013,
0.3639213442802429,
0.5961082577705383,
-0.11641373485326767,
1.20703125,
0.4538305401802063,
-0.10199134051799774,
-0.009081222116947174,
-0.015081916004419327,
0.044826775789260864,
-0.7472401261329651,
0.49650463461875916,
0.304338663816452,
-0.4445355236530304,
-0.04083572328090668,
-0.5263627767562866,
-0.5397589206695557,
1.2841304540634155,
0.372833251953125,
-0.5645862221717834,
-0.29690447449684143,
0.17824776470661163,
0.7646967172622681,
-0.7617667317390442,
0.23199649155139923,
0.6487369537353516,
0.2101055085659027,
0.3091041147708893,
-0.9986401200294495,
-0.2669326961040497,
-0.05690079554915428,
0.11148178577423096,
0.0864277109503746,
-0.8736076951026917,
0.45445314049720764,
-0.2617552876472473,
-0.11108502000570297,
0.6293936371803284,
0.8176618218421936,
0.4054622948169708,
0.5513070225715637,
0.489723265171051,
0.21110767126083374,
0.8017927408218384,
0.21074558794498444,
0.9332409501075745,
-0.4886314868927002,
0.1143016368150711,
1.3554656505584717,
-0.7429634928703308,
0.5574795603752136,
0.20996758341789246,
-0.10561931878328323,
0.7221816778182983,
0.2572994828224182,
0.19170057773590088,
0.42534133791923523,
-0.0884530246257782,
-0.7122911810874939,
-0.5430694222450256,
-0.274455189704895,
-0.13267655670642853,
0.18867753446102142,
0.3631593585014343,
-0.2993090748786926,
-0.19662371277809143,
0.25198695063591003,
-0.12505890429019928,
0.04445873200893402,
-0.14636990427970886,
0.8662134408950806,
0.4007335305213928,
-0.6062973737716675,
0.21141818165779114,
-0.04072410240769386,
0.5602408051490784,
-0.6217873692512512,
0.06119934096932411,
-0.32849547266960144,
0.30543240904808044,
0.18315503001213074,
-0.7231613397598267,
0.10591738671064377,
-0.13955987989902496,
-0.13327333331108093,
-0.5176000595092773,
0.9042858481407166,
-0.43472859263420105,
-0.07741198688745499,
0.3592292070388794,
0.5195692181587219,
0.35557225346565247,
-0.016233043745160103,
-0.6856601238250732,
0.17257830500602722,
-0.08029336482286453,
-0.34700870513916016,
0.5309021472930908,
0.11507201939821243,
0.03308498114347458,
1.1659438610076904,
0.3775564432144165,
-0.28981202840805054,
-0.31028228998184204,
0.33853664994239807,
0.8184062838554382,
-0.6507671475410461,
-0.4183490574359894,
-0.8273955583572388,
0.3002462387084961,
-0.04354826733469963,
-0.1067146360874176,
0.678634524345398,
0.6121164560317993,
0.5028221607208252,
0.1448422074317932,
0.7457167506217957,
0.3937087655067444,
0.5717397928237915,
-0.345090389251709,
0.38173240423202515,
-0.5017848610877991,
0.2693430781364441,
0.08486760407686234,
-0.8600823283195496,
0.0472390353679657,
0.281099408864975,
-0.11764642596244812,
0.24863974750041962,
0.354526162147522,
0.8018696308135986,
0.2907041311264038,
-0.04340872913599014,
0.7174480557441711,
0.20624825358390808,
0.6280151605606079,
0.7347292900085449,
1.0839942693710327,
0.22774775326251984,
0.42216840386390686,
0.07822994887828827,
0.008295532315969467,
-0.37982600927352905,
-0.5417879223823547,
-1.1126641035079956,
-0.6054355502128601,
-0.31939977407455444,
-0.25413456559181213,
0.40222129225730896,
1.0226091146469116,
0.5759041905403137,
-0.5025159120559692,
-0.15571439266204834,
0.11304391920566559,
0.026817575097084045,
0.4027033746242523,
-0.20045191049575806,
-0.05503895878791809,
-0.33345428109169006,
-0.8787486553192139,
0.7019660472869873,
0.6619382500648499,
-0.0031269455794245005,
-0.5774156451225281,
-0.39211195707321167,
0.3140738606452942,
0.41033935546875,
0.8262551426887512,
0.5548040866851807,
-1.003530740737915,
-0.46201932430267334,
-0.14360463619232178,
-0.15070708096027374,
0.2213827669620514,
0.6834472417831421,
-1.1415481567382812,
0.8260669708251953,
0.12397659569978714,
0.34171783924102783,
0.3698405623435974,
0.2069540172815323,
0.8897120952606201,
-0.5926122665405273,
0.17061689496040344,
0.22779500484466553,
0.27766284346580505,
0.3166623115539551,
-0.40370067954063416,
0.23335866630077362,
0.0753849521279335,
-0.7480337619781494,
-0.8342325687408447,
0.6210567355155945,
-1.131310224533081,
-0.1559048593044281,
1.109837532043457,
-0.181616872549057,
-0.10548033565282822,
-0.16365881264209747,
-0.4377037584781647,
-0.14126574993133545,
-0.5778239965438843,
0.6181118488311768,
0.599410891532898,
-0.5353171229362488,
-0.4035681486129761,
-0.5377587080001831,
0.367285817861557,
0.19129858911037445,
-0.9332011938095093,
-0.07101596146821976,
0.745756983757019,
0.1978486031293869,
0.22474926710128784,
0.9439849853515625,
0.22689224779605865,
0.3035305440425873,
-0.3190482556819916,
0.01712816208600998,
-0.09735121577978134,
-0.5714914798736572,
-0.27514833211898804,
0.0942399799823761,
0.1597086489200592,
-0.05245330184698105
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.05918v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.05918v1
|
Why Don't Prompt-Based Fairness Metrics Correlate?
| 2024-06-09T21:12:15 | 2024-06-09T21:12:15 |
Abdelrahman Zayed, Goncalo Mordido, Ioana Baldini, Sarath Chandar
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY, cs.LG
|
The widespread use of large language models has brought up essential
questions about the potential biases these models might learn. This led to the
development of several metrics aimed at evaluating and mitigating these biases.
In this paper, we first demonstrate that prompt-based fairness metrics exhibit
poor agreement, as measured by correlation, raising important questions about
the reliability of fairness assessment using prompts. Then, we outline six
relevant reasons why such a low correlation is observed across existing
metrics. Based on these insights, we propose a method called Correlated
Fairness Output (CAIRO) to enhance the correlation between fairness metrics.
CAIRO augments the original prompts of a given fairness metric by using several
pre-trained language models and then selects the combination of the augmented
prompts that achieves the highest correlation across metrics. We show a
significant improvement in Pearson correlation from 0.3 and 0.18 to 0.90 and
0.98 across metrics for gender and religion biases, respectively. Our code is
available at https://github.com/chandar-lab/CAIRO.
|
[
-0.6662471294403076,
-0.30115756392478943,
0.6556141972541809,
0.32247596979141235,
0.15147176384925842,
-0.06667360663414001,
0.04872838035225868,
-0.4371999502182007,
0.244134321808815,
0.004182297270745039,
-0.20143888890743256,
-0.2618838846683502,
-0.6128368973731995,
-0.010194231756031513,
-0.24037489295005798,
1.6240030527114868,
0.3766365945339203,
0.561337947845459,
-0.4211871325969696,
-0.6224244236946106,
-0.8259041905403137,
-0.4256460964679718,
-1.07961106300354,
-0.18959178030490875,
0.46661537885665894,
0.6244000792503357,
0.9373059272766113,
-0.015493125654757023,
0.8850914239883423,
0.2501274347305298,
-0.07429630309343338,
-0.10172463208436966,
-0.3479374647140503,
0.04049066826701164,
-0.3609338700771332,
-0.3243866562843323,
-0.6815165877342224,
0.2915509343147278,
0.40958452224731445,
1.0954461097717285,
0.07551214843988419,
0.3687528073787689,
0.05260404571890831,
0.5901521444320679,
-0.9380559921264648,
-0.07926156371831894,
-0.1721826195716858,
0.2739730775356293,
-0.2670014202594757,
-0.05906842648983002,
-0.1697082817554474,
-0.8068349957466125,
0.11815956979990005,
-0.375949501991272,
0.3249207139015198,
0.5031561255455017,
0.6484269499778748,
0.08055896311998367,
-0.42120829224586487,
-0.5850679874420166,
-0.34813299775123596,
1.1665631532669067,
-0.5475695729255676,
0.03706265985965729,
0.6537073850631714,
0.4961426556110382,
-0.10469234734773636,
-0.5451830625534058,
-0.6137648224830627,
-0.21753764152526855,
-0.3590144217014313,
0.3399646282196045,
0.05710948258638382,
-0.2642715573310852,
0.44588395953178406,
0.2956849932670593,
-0.20536817610263824,
0.19884860515594482,
-0.055272508412599564,
-0.5988726615905762,
0.5094226002693176,
0.41777414083480835,
0.40182292461395264,
-0.2694684863090515,
-0.45229583978652954,
-0.059444185346364975,
-0.33518755435943604,
0.6988827586174011,
0.6205121278762817,
0.20744732022285461,
-0.5632568597793579,
0.406217098236084,
0.11020929366350174,
0.42963501811027527,
0.24271616339683533,
-0.028285086154937744,
0.23116585612297058,
-0.4674360156059265,
0.17746183276176453,
0.1374014914035797,
1.1909209489822388,
0.6916044354438782,
0.3320758044719696,
-0.12988612055778503,
-0.21271908283233643,
0.05700857937335968,
-0.2753206193447113,
-0.7256373167037964,
-0.1232774406671524,
0.16871415078639984,
-0.35433775186538696,
-0.18333981931209564,
0.18397647142410278,
-0.9996230602264404,
-0.6442262530326843,
0.12937097251415253,
0.3819188177585602,
0.10192357003688812,
-0.05309261754155159,
0.08442161977291107,
-0.3131425678730011,
-0.01512985210865736,
0.4370437264442444,
-1.0291931629180908,
0.44853365421295166,
0.6581270694732666,
0.8431473970413208,
-0.13013191521167755,
-0.034379709511995316,
-1.3517895936965942,
-0.29957374930381775,
-0.4576593339443207,
0.378833532333374,
-0.6857950687408447,
-0.13016334176063538,
0.010286168195307255,
-0.22984562814235687,
0.38390061259269714,
-0.27169907093048096,
1.1287249326705933,
-0.4131230115890503,
0.711788535118103,
-0.7637491226196289,
-0.2870114743709564,
0.12877772748470306,
-0.008424767293035984,
-0.7285560965538025,
0.6821588277816772,
-0.13291870057582855,
-1.1680773496627808,
0.5312376618385315,
-0.43075990676879883,
-0.208894744515419,
-0.36440959572792053,
-0.4756138026714325,
-0.6065190434455872,
0.046429410576820374,
0.25785717368125916,
0.0007238583057187498,
-0.4741291105747223,
0.7994480729103088,
-0.6098385453224182,
-0.6473224759101868,
0.5247746109962463,
-0.49974390864372253,
0.9637809991836548,
0.2653317153453827,
-0.29020461440086365,
-0.2089781016111374,
-0.4967079758644104,
-0.40688496828079224,
-0.3185991942882538,
0.16498272120952606,
-0.3494758903980255,
-0.050596121698617935,
-0.3643047511577606,
0.26258599758148193,
0.29147645831108093,
-0.490317165851593,
-0.4274291396141052,
-0.18936459720134735,
-0.25931277871131897,
0.9138842225074768,
-0.558387815952301,
0.9869768023490906,
-0.7280011773109436,
0.3069826066493988,
0.43652817606925964,
-0.013645038940012455,
0.24261729419231415,
-0.78546541929245,
-0.6898975968360901,
-0.28217482566833496,
0.30447301268577576,
0.4349854290485382,
-0.3410932123661041,
0.37299537658691406,
-0.3312091827392578,
-0.2423124462366104,
-0.448543906211853,
-0.3448183834552765,
0.2479712963104248,
1.1230595111846924,
0.36504796147346497,
-0.8878219127655029,
-0.3622172772884369,
-0.6899082660675049,
-0.6124218106269836,
-0.11709128320217133,
0.2679692804813385,
0.3512195944786072,
0.23470257222652435,
0.5622703433036804,
1.2681400775909424,
-0.05901900678873062,
-0.3739330768585205,
0.3017081916332245,
0.055331986397504807,
0.640110433101654,
0.565894365310669,
0.9030490517616272,
-0.36417311429977417,
-0.5199499130249023,
-0.29409945011138916,
-0.7231025695800781,
-0.6573975682258606,
0.05100893974304199,
-0.19982823729515076,
-0.2104370892047882,
0.3630870580673218,
0.06337399780750275,
0.4667293429374695,
0.5314283967018127,
-0.7873109579086304,
0.6622588634490967,
-0.012108271941542625,
0.6419153213500977,
-0.9007551074028015,
0.08441154658794403,
-0.07217397540807724,
-0.21767425537109375,
-0.4469505846500397,
-0.39773309230804443,
-0.15029196441173553,
-0.042804278433322906,
-0.298103392124176,
1.1327852010726929,
-0.029827559366822243,
-0.4347335994243622,
-0.039664097130298615,
0.4321710467338562,
0.13882701098918915,
0.3479835093021393,
-0.3849644958972931,
1.113281488418579,
0.41973525285720825,
-0.6760113835334778,
-0.00925515592098236,
0.3848060667514801,
-0.1701977550983429,
0.9002100825309753,
-0.43584489822387695,
-0.08095841109752655,
0.015764251351356506,
0.20727397501468658,
-1.11174738407135,
0.14824841916561127,
0.5805501937866211,
-0.6641282439231873,
-0.33571571111679077,
0.0711221992969513,
-0.2484385371208191,
-0.1927737146615982,
-0.6127634048461914,
0.7799841165542603,
0.6955330967903137,
-0.6820065379142761,
0.332150936126709,
0.2935253381729126,
-0.027013802900910378,
-1.1863030195236206,
-0.7928213477134705,
-0.1762654334306717,
-0.2631015479564667,
-0.5917248129844666,
0.07931064814329147,
-0.15330344438552856,
-0.5552858114242554,
-0.07752378284931183,
-0.16931329667568207,
0.19380144774913788,
0.2287159562110901,
0.224086195230484,
0.03555819392204285,
-0.07952908426523209,
0.17590196430683136,
0.12358345836400986,
-0.20404799282550812,
0.1972251832485199,
0.1506323218345642,
0.4110550284385681,
-0.05768124759197235,
-0.5997298955917358,
-0.7431859374046326,
0.22994467616081238,
0.3720933496952057,
-0.1170213520526886,
0.9384878277778625,
0.8451651930809021,
-0.13909652829170227,
0.3269549608230591,
-0.5151993036270142,
-0.1231364756822586,
-0.5308614373207092,
0.09345033019781113,
-0.3342375159263611,
-0.8886545300483704,
1.130354642868042,
0.27352577447891235,
0.12561634182929993,
0.33463314175605774,
0.3293451964855194,
-0.144382506608963,
1.098067045211792,
0.2968977987766266,
0.03404892981052399,
0.7092151045799255,
0.42897680401802063,
0.3438279926776886,
-0.682373046875,
-0.11620615422725677,
-1.0018830299377441,
-0.32896772027015686,
-0.9846749901771545,
-0.14473018050193787,
0.22817787528038025,
0.3451322317123413,
-0.8454151153564453,
-0.3797546625137329,
-0.1387590914964676,
0.25774890184402466,
0.6997782588005066,
-0.09456035494804382,
0.49558693170547485,
0.2074265033006668,
-0.2734021842479706,
-0.4306073784828186,
-0.6273565292358398,
-0.5985031723976135,
0.9788658618927002,
0.05329623818397522,
0.7129606604576111,
0.4517495632171631,
0.5904896855354309,
0.6505155563354492,
0.24958516657352448,
-0.3581317663192749,
0.46397385001182556,
-0.4193170964717865,
-0.34466975927352905,
-0.007521464955061674,
-0.801236093044281,
-0.8627597093582153,
-0.004891751799732447,
-0.376616895198822,
-0.5662207007408142,
0.42704519629478455,
0.17226172983646393,
-0.46023648977279663,
0.26848477125167847,
-0.8985266089439392,
0.5723733305931091,
-0.05414038151502609,
-0.8320553302764893,
0.03306593373417854,
-0.40752947330474854,
0.4581296443939209,
-0.09951809048652649,
0.6621144413948059,
-0.21172888576984406,
0.15432420372962952,
1.0231812000274658,
-0.6662899255752563,
0.6967241764068604,
-0.13593895733356476,
-0.2703036665916443,
0.10382480174303055,
0.15839961171150208,
0.3164563477039337,
0.4697982668876648,
-0.36999839544296265,
0.38425448536872864,
-0.2375144511461258,
-0.6473414897918701,
-0.7072722315788269,
0.795687735080719,
-0.8665384650230408,
-0.7079206109046936,
-0.7817215323448181,
-0.5887482166290283,
-0.19720050692558289,
-0.059860412031412125,
-0.12204668670892715,
0.5539495348930359,
-0.10524514317512512,
-0.3622262477874756,
0.03450293093919754,
-0.6512144207954407,
0.6637936234474182,
0.3803372383117676,
-0.4802916646003723,
-0.4541526138782501,
0.6911664605140686,
-0.12243413180112839,
0.30437979102134705,
0.007703153882175684,
0.30578428506851196,
-0.28261417150497437,
-0.07636997103691101,
-0.10631366819143295,
0.028269639238715172,
-0.7775475978851318,
-0.2160888910293579,
-0.6864019632339478,
-0.10432831197977066,
-0.5476227402687073,
-0.36949145793914795,
0.16091862320899963,
-0.5703730583190918,
-0.14159806072711945,
0.2602211534976959,
0.4671271741390228,
0.6978808641433716,
-0.6892953515052795,
0.2729402780532837,
-0.5172516703605652,
0.2948760390281677,
0.3528096675872803,
0.41670289635658264,
0.3082217872142792,
-0.7607308626174927,
-0.12906870245933533,
0.21284127235412598,
-0.1552688330411911,
-0.6400060057640076,
0.028723634779453278,
-0.1282283067703247,
0.30876031517982483,
0.23562800884246826,
0.20659175515174866,
0.7562609910964966,
-0.4301982522010803,
0.9018632173538208,
0.7146598696708679,
-1.2047321796417236,
0.19690021872520447,
-0.06220981851220131,
-0.11575740575790405,
0.5179644227027893,
0.051330652087926865,
-0.5884023904800415,
-0.7652034759521484,
-0.35636022686958313,
-0.30932947993278503,
1.0102542638778687,
0.185148224234581,
0.17883944511413574,
-0.1978420913219452,
0.13995513319969177,
0.31434231996536255,
0.06225110590457916,
-0.6736083030700684,
-0.4357556402683258,
-0.2254461795091629,
-0.506022036075592,
0.029057318344712257,
-0.11751022934913635,
-0.13681821525096893,
-0.29000815749168396,
0.1718456745147705,
0.05235479399561882,
-0.03748222067952156,
0.1678888201713562,
-0.04041657969355583,
-0.014561962336301804,
0.34735941886901855,
0.5036545395851135,
0.509596049785614,
-0.19810345768928528,
0.23232415318489075,
0.050004370510578156,
-0.7015858292579651,
0.204109787940979,
-0.05150479078292847,
-0.26996326446533203,
0.022049633786082268,
0.22551123797893524,
0.7025184631347656,
-0.07353570312261581,
-0.2014906257390976,
0.8691973686218262,
-0.43765005469322205,
0.28967738151550293,
-0.16299013793468475,
0.19278058409690857,
-0.17841863632202148,
0.2891696095466614,
0.2012372463941574,
0.3830798268318176,
0.09109344333410263,
-0.31409406661987305,
0.20451439917087555,
0.5718457698822021,
-0.6319618821144104,
-0.2525879442691803,
0.7767212390899658,
0.5104937553405762,
-0.40373995900154114,
0.5300988554954529,
-0.5654387474060059,
-0.25033286213874817,
0.8411628007888794,
0.3244154751300812,
0.37224215269088745,
0.25185108184814453,
0.31851911544799805,
0.7723588347434998,
0.12874408066272736,
-0.005830269772559404,
0.11414975672960281,
0.008875713683664799,
-0.7540561556816101,
-0.29995930194854736,
-0.6288763284683228,
-0.336248517036438,
-0.41210857033729553,
-0.6474454998970032,
0.5098460912704468,
-0.2918836176395416,
-0.5274488925933838,
-0.4325469434261322,
0.4178225100040436,
-0.9629147052764893,
0.06770317256450653,
-0.23706798255443573,
0.5109330415725708,
-0.9898238778114319,
0.04747162014245987,
0.2555667459964752,
-0.8934124112129211,
-0.4751269817352295,
0.03978832811117172,
-0.3425286114215851,
-0.7701131701469421,
0.8764471411705017,
0.10276439785957336,
-0.04310282692313194,
-0.009219875559210777,
-0.4511510133743286,
-0.5496460199356079,
0.7785191535949707,
0.555438220500946,
-0.7796860337257385,
0.31916362047195435,
0.27780449390411377,
0.40070614218711853,
-0.2845146358013153,
1.052153468132019,
0.2415759563446045,
0.37979212403297424,
-0.2155252993106842,
-1.1120938062667847,
0.15449246764183044,
0.13892105221748352,
-0.38783347606658936,
-0.029582275077700615,
-0.5957150459289551,
0.8924132585525513,
-0.5719013214111328,
-0.35429540276527405,
0.219747394323349,
0.8367759585380554,
0.4952957332134247,
0.687469482421875,
0.3590656816959381,
0.7515403032302856,
1.0937340259552002,
-0.27809104323387146,
0.8487394452095032,
-0.1375969648361206,
0.5860586166381836,
1.374071717262268,
-0.5822762250900269,
0.27912697196006775,
0.60831218957901,
-0.164224311709404,
0.7412248253822327,
0.4270365536212921,
0.20402660965919495,
0.4905414283275604,
0.11302614957094193,
-0.36940357089042664,
-0.24986624717712402,
-0.5679419040679932,
-0.5951920747756958,
0.1119496077299118,
0.11874154210090637,
-0.10998570919036865,
-0.3825823664665222,
-0.18230248987674713,
0.06123849377036095,
0.3199698328971863,
-0.2736720144748688,
0.4671400189399719,
0.3664393126964569,
-0.7071508169174194,
0.02264237031340599,
-0.24574826657772064,
0.979215145111084,
-0.24959976971149445,
0.012391973286867142,
-0.6516119837760925,
0.026630345731973648,
-0.38478097319602966,
-0.8673042058944702,
0.0036533093079924583,
0.10952871292829514,
-0.18254603445529938,
-0.003790072863921523,
0.28421279788017273,
-0.32794177532196045,
-0.2300201654434204,
0.44637545943260193,
0.9965801239013672,
0.11558426916599274,
0.7650610208511353,
-0.5977708101272583,
-0.18269434571266174,
-0.32550346851348877,
0.386800080537796,
0.20122727751731873,
0.758057177066803,
-0.3130074739456177,
0.32819992303848267,
0.7176578044891357,
0.13972370326519012,
0.10000686347484589,
0.5523164868354797,
0.3236200511455536,
-0.6552944779396057,
-0.429267019033432,
-0.8874168992042542,
0.41845256090164185,
-0.2671821415424347,
-0.256666362285614,
0.7117510437965393,
0.36793088912963867,
0.6382752656936646,
0.28067082166671753,
0.5237324833869934,
-0.06740957498550415,
0.2616784870624542,
-0.3903622329235077,
0.7942987680435181,
-0.579936146736145,
0.5052893161773682,
-0.29176172614097595,
-0.8399162888526917,
-0.19415998458862305,
0.43129172921180725,
-0.5101709961891174,
0.5496224164962769,
0.8520504236221313,
0.864668071269989,
-0.3269268870353699,
-0.03864670917391777,
0.26488497853279114,
-0.028602777048945427,
0.5316594243049622,
0.5508708357810974,
1.0285449028015137,
-0.6301015615463257,
0.4278324842453003,
0.1940271258354187,
-0.24639315903186798,
-0.05898621678352356,
-0.9997633099555969,
-0.9201681613922119,
-0.30928343534469604,
-0.18263225257396698,
-0.885145366191864,
0.14785300195217133,
0.6331759691238403,
0.2666032612323761,
-1.051466464996338,
-0.24160179495811462,
-0.08725257217884064,
0.4429680407047272,
0.1434522271156311,
-0.28891319036483765,
0.5164757966995239,
-0.7381293177604675,
-0.7894836068153381,
-0.5586450099945068,
0.04193621873855591,
-0.04702863097190857,
-0.1366850584745407,
-0.32049575448036194,
-0.08476319909095764,
0.03789979964494705,
0.154197558760643,
0.046945247799158096,
-0.44910934567451477,
-0.6244356036186218,
-0.13427802920341492,
-0.5519189834594727,
0.13834667205810547,
0.6166641116142273,
-0.946998119354248,
0.46747496724128723,
0.7095051407814026,
0.583013117313385,
-0.21594223380088806,
-0.14487864077091217,
0.6245512962341309,
-0.7679131031036377,
0.17744751274585724,
0.06347135454416275,
0.5581303834915161,
0.5054497718811035,
-0.023662324994802475,
0.3982466459274292,
0.2831049859523773,
-0.6988266706466675,
-0.6862004399299622,
0.28947699069976807,
-0.8199687004089355,
0.30988726019859314,
0.8600562214851379,
-0.025620529428124428,
-0.1320706605911255,
-0.3659806251525879,
0.03668005391955376,
0.31390345096588135,
-0.7633521556854248,
0.95913165807724,
0.9196990728378296,
0.1515231728553772,
0.40014439821243286,
-0.3767693042755127,
0.5251582860946655,
1.0440267324447632,
-0.5002392530441284,
-0.3313736915588379,
0.4489392638206482,
0.2321542352437973,
0.3749599754810333,
1.2174338102340698,
-0.11996918171644211,
0.5384851098060608,
-0.1978204995393753,
-0.0904446691274643,
0.4604165852069855,
0.12035952508449554,
-0.4742741286754608,
0.0552615225315094,
-0.024807292968034744,
-0.17281554639339447
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.05906v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.05906v1
|
TTM-RE: Memory-Augmented Document-Level Relation Extraction
| 2024-06-09T20:18:58 | 2024-06-09T20:18:58 |
Chufan Gao, Xuan Wang, Jimeng Sun
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Document-level relation extraction aims to categorize the association between
any two entities within a document. We find that previous methods for
document-level relation extraction are ineffective in exploiting the full
potential of large amounts of training data with varied noise levels. For
example, in the ReDocRED benchmark dataset, state-of-the-art methods trained on
the large-scale, lower-quality, distantly supervised training data generally do
not perform better than those trained solely on the smaller, high-quality,
human-annotated training data. To unlock the full potential of large-scale
noisy training data for document-level relation extraction, we propose TTM-RE,
a novel approach that integrates a trainable memory module, known as the Token
Turing Machine, with a noisy-robust loss function that accounts for the
positive-unlabeled setting. Extensive experiments on ReDocRED, a benchmark
dataset for document-level relation extraction, reveal that TTM-RE achieves
state-of-the-art performance (with an absolute F1 score improvement of over
3%). Ablation studies further illustrate the superiority of TTM-RE in other
domains (the ChemDisGene dataset in the biomedical domain) and under highly
unlabeled settings.
|
[
-0.33149006962776184,
-0.8779417872428894,
0.531186580657959,
-0.2843000292778015,
-0.435397744178772,
0.19848360121250153,
-0.09880323708057404,
-0.5450094938278198,
0.14670443534851074,
0.37527886033058167,
-0.4884603023529053,
-0.6885557174682617,
-0.7175436615943909,
0.14401394128799438,
-0.7563049793243408,
0.8877732753753662,
-0.06277346611022949,
0.009307083673775196,
-0.2544344663619995,
-0.1295062005519867,
-0.27773359417915344,
-0.5892056822776794,
-0.8633872866630554,
-0.43355193734169006,
0.7765357494354248,
0.17642724514007568,
0.39748409390449524,
0.8517987132072449,
0.5590708255767822,
0.21084898710250854,
0.07488403469324112,
0.24528777599334717,
-0.3564527928829193,
0.30067315697669983,
-0.19506444036960602,
-0.47532862424850464,
-0.5238921642303467,
0.18403583765029907,
0.6820822358131409,
0.4943251609802246,
0.14286215603351593,
0.14110031723976135,
-0.36835670471191406,
0.6503621339797974,
-0.5009702444076538,
0.23563829064369202,
-0.7189014554023743,
0.20111039280891418,
-0.13565494120121002,
-0.442938894033432,
-0.46560755372047424,
-0.22132553160190582,
0.1504715383052826,
-0.6325083374977112,
0.5396476984024048,
0.1900286078453064,
1.2456467151641846,
0.2229812741279602,
-0.21925857663154602,
-0.18124952912330627,
-0.8645175695419312,
0.7980602979660034,
-0.36310261487960815,
0.7330498099327087,
0.47134706377983093,
-0.08062092214822769,
-0.13355384767055511,
-0.8137553930282593,
-0.27521568536758423,
-0.06669268012046814,
-0.0007131090969778597,
0.04959182068705559,
-0.2452683001756668,
0.013003995642066002,
0.4096841514110565,
0.6085655093193054,
-0.20967787504196167,
-0.0815838873386383,
-0.41041868925094604,
-0.1458360105752945,
0.09319465607404709,
0.11288691312074661,
0.45894020795822144,
0.0070382971316576,
-0.34486961364746094,
0.14627507328987122,
-0.3773309588432312,
-0.5687153339385986,
-0.06950849294662476,
0.2437310814857483,
0.1946151852607727,
0.5059657096862793,
0.21364867687225342,
0.5559557676315308,
0.02017982490360737,
-0.14534065127372742,
0.29986923933029175,
-0.2520347535610199,
-0.2052638679742813,
-0.0618097260594368,
0.932387113571167,
0.1243399903178215,
0.4939977526664734,
-0.6632376909255981,
-0.28012943267822266,
0.0728146955370903,
0.39783379435539246,
-0.8703233599662781,
-0.04127685725688934,
0.2766784429550171,
-0.5116716623306274,
-0.19763250648975372,
0.1758822500705719,
-0.9265216588973999,
-0.05934922397136688,
-0.28057244420051575,
0.42635294795036316,
-0.7670196294784546,
-0.4049737751483917,
-0.06111845001578331,
-0.47464537620544434,
0.18132588267326355,
0.2659105956554413,
-0.8621736764907837,
0.3446836471557617,
0.8784681558609009,
0.9381411075592041,
-0.38228103518486023,
-0.39606234431266785,
-0.6207323670387268,
0.39012831449508667,
-0.28079089522361755,
0.7419376969337463,
-0.6194227933883667,
-0.5124133825302124,
-0.010140001773834229,
-0.043304819613695145,
-0.12825998663902283,
-0.8186522722244263,
0.43990182876586914,
-0.6277769804000854,
0.351027250289917,
0.12287658452987671,
-0.5261552333831787,
0.23539818823337555,
0.43631312251091003,
-0.7833431959152222,
1.2050573825836182,
0.48503875732421875,
-0.7204124331474304,
0.48938503861427307,
-0.39182958006858826,
-0.5038185119628906,
-0.4583381712436676,
-0.17983287572860718,
-0.7068727612495422,
0.1623670607805252,
0.2619119882583618,
0.34016990661621094,
-0.5485121607780457,
0.13477347791194916,
-0.1870824247598648,
-0.3005841076374054,
0.37913715839385986,
-0.34509405493736267,
0.4368652403354645,
0.3159731328487396,
-0.0447329580783844,
0.02714814431965351,
-1.013564109802246,
-0.39510002732276917,
0.03673216700553894,
-0.42964968085289,
-0.4875504672527313,
-0.48414644598960876,
-0.34146183729171753,
0.4516425132751465,
0.23214881122112274,
-0.9127547144889832,
0.1604771912097931,
-0.3510792553424835,
0.46442779898643494,
0.37772470712661743,
0.3452800512313843,
0.5997711420059204,
-0.449396550655365,
0.6038357019424438,
0.23625899851322174,
-0.054548606276512146,
-0.27103671431541443,
-0.15664790570735931,
-0.7333714962005615,
-0.47960716485977173,
0.5597356557846069,
0.2867377698421478,
-0.6869120001792908,
0.22023339569568634,
-0.35753417015075684,
-0.27698302268981934,
-0.7371921539306641,
0.03172345086932182,
0.507760763168335,
0.9769720435142517,
0.4803099036216736,
-0.19934876263141632,
-0.5026771426200867,
-0.806117832660675,
-0.23110786080360413,
-0.2694595754146576,
-0.13804011046886444,
0.02467907778918743,
0.1883428990840912,
-0.38923799991607666,
0.9108970761299133,
-0.5362591743469238,
-0.460875540971756,
0.030945545062422752,
0.46790221333503723,
-0.08727160841226578,
0.5014351010322571,
0.11193308234214783,
-0.5972767472267151,
-0.2003181129693985,
-0.029632551595568657,
-0.786544919013977,
-0.11458081007003784,
-0.22856472432613373,
-0.17170356214046478,
0.3094993233680725,
0.6784595847129822,
-0.914174497127533,
0.3724059760570526,
-0.10424338281154633,
-0.06541921943426132,
0.3980260193347931,
-0.34038305282592773,
0.17077229917049408,
-1.3116323947906494,
0.17964813113212585,
0.036345694214105606,
-0.26438289880752563,
-0.44639652967453003,
-0.17868377268314362,
0.19033503532409668,
-0.3588273823261261,
-0.3456893861293793,
0.6971570253372192,
-0.775492250919342,
-0.34200939536094666,
-0.22834160923957825,
0.25848978757858276,
0.11349358409643173,
0.609609067440033,
0.2519647479057312,
0.602483332157135,
0.21176539361476898,
-0.32654914259910583,
0.08071593195199966,
0.34279942512512207,
0.1671418845653534,
0.5015711784362793,
-0.11044849455356598,
0.178933247923851,
-0.09116559475660324,
-0.10639446973800659,
-0.9200180768966675,
0.16190756857395172,
0.24473132193088531,
-0.8057023882865906,
0.8173778057098389,
-0.11611529439687729,
-0.687886655330658,
-0.11414115875959396,
-0.46845442056655884,
0.3749816417694092,
0.37158530950546265,
-0.40531641244888306,
0.8918277621269226,
0.5284091830253601,
0.05869917571544647,
-0.6551657915115356,
-0.7418796420097351,
0.018272588029503822,
-0.30966299772262573,
-0.33984512090682983,
0.32895657420158386,
0.402944952249527,
-0.1388111710548401,
0.2549794018268585,
-0.5432426929473877,
-0.516731858253479,
-0.1358070969581604,
0.3960261940956116,
0.3477049469947815,
-0.0537264347076416,
0.3037554621696472,
-0.12670785188674927,
-0.5598129034042358,
0.24885259568691254,
-0.033178266137838364,
0.5518798232078552,
0.18083836138248444,
0.09199987351894379,
-0.6099815368652344,
0.299164354801178,
0.8409762382507324,
-0.2140263319015503,
0.6791390180587769,
0.7624019980430603,
-0.778870701789856,
-0.0741228386759758,
-0.5896354913711548,
0.0019046170637011528,
-0.39369842410087585,
0.5180970430374146,
-0.5650314092636108,
-0.7886277437210083,
0.581231415271759,
-0.297843873500824,
0.16410565376281738,
0.5968944430351257,
0.269847571849823,
-0.0252574160695076,
0.4207347631454468,
0.5264178514480591,
-0.30247265100479126,
0.7165955305099487,
-0.1663602590560913,
-0.16832983493804932,
-0.9115163087844849,
-0.5384773015975952,
-0.7332332134246826,
-0.12173198163509369,
-0.3418641984462738,
-0.28039437532424927,
-0.1331702172756195,
-0.10133097320795059,
-0.25503072142601013,
0.5328398942947388,
-0.4335603713989258,
0.057127051055431366,
0.44696396589279175,
0.1801881641149521,
0.5527383089065552,
0.2231282740831375,
-0.05163586139678955,
-0.10848602652549744,
-0.5841201543807983,
-0.24763990938663483,
1.1535269021987915,
0.32719939947128296,
0.8123815059661865,
-0.2705812156200409,
1.0174566507339478,
0.14242058992385864,
0.6624281406402588,
-0.9919893741607666,
0.5558938980102539,
-0.15500029921531677,
-0.48126280307769775,
-0.4098290503025055,
-0.7435849905014038,
-1.4761688709259033,
0.0018807272426784039,
-0.2982634902000427,
-0.7423355579376221,
0.07996165007352829,
-0.05280552804470062,
-0.024845430627465248,
0.5446067452430725,
-0.7274448871612549,
0.7067859768867493,
-0.010568906553089619,
-0.36423927545547485,
-0.14730212092399597,
-0.7075639367103577,
0.2036750465631485,
-0.4748822748661041,
0.14932186901569366,
0.013123897835612297,
-0.433191180229187,
1.0398330688476562,
-0.5942030549049377,
0.4719799757003784,
-0.01968896947801113,
-0.12276843190193176,
0.17975285649299622,
0.16929563879966736,
0.23173774778842926,
-0.16567282378673553,
-0.2539399266242981,
0.3034780025482178,
0.015544400550425053,
-0.09169527888298035,
-0.7060722708702087,
0.7638322114944458,
-0.9032379388809204,
-0.49684593081474304,
-0.49491849541664124,
-0.7605318427085876,
-0.41869425773620605,
0.5464625954627991,
0.13644003868103027,
0.5292121171951294,
-0.21324624121189117,
0.02706604078412056,
0.6291519999504089,
-0.27933552861213684,
0.24100203812122345,
0.5506691932678223,
-0.10779132694005966,
-0.8114592432975769,
1.0420156717300415,
0.07651971280574799,
0.24335436522960663,
0.9097850918769836,
-0.0015034598764032125,
-0.376299649477005,
-0.4113785922527313,
0.01908327452838421,
0.4939576983451843,
-0.47852715849876404,
-0.2704937756061554,
-0.8851330280303955,
-0.3844417631626129,
-0.12805786728858948,
0.019037624821066856,
-0.5155012011528015,
-0.5383275747299194,
-0.5742974281311035,
-0.1691029667854309,
0.23576371371746063,
0.3451663851737976,
0.02972988411784172,
0.19133518636226654,
-1.0750714540481567,
0.8188903331756592,
-0.04230526462197304,
0.28031715750694275,
-0.06361924111843109,
-0.49159711599349976,
-0.20104697346687317,
-0.42556169629096985,
-0.12954308092594147,
-0.7503718733787537,
0.46013587713241577,
-0.058357320725917816,
0.3570847511291504,
0.2713027000427246,
0.04034658148884773,
0.7297270894050598,
-0.3400721549987793,
0.3146182894706726,
0.2765284478664398,
-0.5048682689666748,
0.47456371784210205,
-0.30702295899391174,
0.2011210024356842,
0.6452220678329468,
0.3087179362773895,
-0.3597344160079956,
-0.5112731456756592,
-1.0235323905944824,
-0.7363570928573608,
0.7576637864112854,
0.09037059545516968,
-0.23474469780921936,
-0.26014474034309387,
0.7934589982032776,
0.04695940017700195,
0.28143641352653503,
-0.3375796675682068,
-0.2609233856201172,
0.14095264673233032,
-0.30446964502334595,
0.11489679664373398,
-0.3752255439758301,
0.14352884888648987,
-0.15180714428424835,
0.5184717774391174,
0.5102120041847229,
0.6269116997718811,
0.3113154470920563,
-0.040707048028707504,
-0.41510894894599915,
0.14483897387981415,
0.19859099388122559,
0.6011377573013306,
-0.7159604430198669,
0.36043551564216614,
-0.09531300514936447,
-0.6295616030693054,
0.15440621972084045,
0.3122449219226837,
-0.005011690780520439,
0.1856575757265091,
0.43081676959991455,
0.16987542808055878,
0.2922082245349884,
-0.4098207354545593,
0.23943452537059784,
-0.22518610954284668,
-0.42004144191741943,
-0.17220155894756317,
0.002119044540449977,
0.14725807309150696,
0.023412302136421204,
0.35593125224113464,
-0.06319916248321533,
-0.2968441843986511,
-0.6876164674758911,
0.6517751216888428,
0.4068468511104584,
-0.49100571870803833,
-0.17548403143882751,
0.8317145109176636,
0.19117149710655212,
-0.7207082509994507,
0.820340096950531,
0.17275279760360718,
-0.06297383457422256,
0.5438947081565857,
0.637290358543396,
1.0642319917678833,
0.028492096811532974,
-0.06966784596443176,
0.6085324287414551,
0.37265488505363464,
-0.13498489558696747,
0.059131525456905365,
-0.12060648202896118,
-0.7000212073326111,
-0.3066929578781128,
-0.5846415758132935,
-0.33375677466392517,
0.3643096387386322,
-0.8090274333953857,
0.1934010237455368,
-0.49169230461120605,
-0.299548476934433,
0.01095603033900261,
0.20552872121334076,
-0.3925255835056305,
0.298725962638855,
-0.4201435446739197,
0.9739543199539185,
-0.38296422362327576,
1.143895149230957,
0.400169312953949,
-0.5020725727081299,
-0.5102836489677429,
0.03904622420668602,
-0.16559532284736633,
-0.7921423316001892,
0.5924293398857117,
0.07575785368680954,
-0.07875244319438934,
0.1824006885290146,
-0.019618939608335495,
-0.5844009518623352,
1.17894446849823,
0.6043238639831543,
-0.4920923709869385,
-0.1480327695608139,
0.23106999695301056,
0.4983922243118286,
-0.31334856152534485,
-0.047213878482580185,
0.574256181716919,
0.16232165694236755,
0.2162894755601883,
-0.4731064438819885,
0.23821796476840973,
-0.18978530168533325,
-0.2722204923629761,
0.7411491274833679,
-0.6106733679771423,
0.5293949246406555,
-0.021427027881145477,
-0.4942939877510071,
0.2317865490913391,
0.6726720929145813,
0.11940962821245193,
0.4690399169921875,
0.3205394744873047,
0.7422183752059937,
0.7297987937927246,
-0.11214611679315567,
0.7517845034599304,
-0.45035359263420105,
0.1959550380706787,
1.2785241603851318,
0.03176013007760048,
0.7175834774971008,
0.7031446099281311,
-0.06440803408622742,
0.09237127751111984,
0.6864850521087646,
0.05990453064441681,
0.21142323315143585,
0.03996788337826729,
-0.3038882315158844,
-0.14763587713241577,
-0.07258355617523193,
-0.2727000117301941,
-0.06951327621936798,
0.48029014468193054,
-0.6905629634857178,
-0.3608471155166626,
-0.3015141785144806,
-0.033221520483493805,
-0.09238798916339874,
-0.328830361366272,
0.7955800890922546,
0.3081250786781311,
-0.46196427941322327,
0.47569671273231506,
-0.09925998002290726,
0.48640429973602295,
-0.6715933084487915,
-0.1080380231142044,
-0.1583644151687622,
0.06932523846626282,
-0.16769705712795258,
-0.5431151390075684,
0.3892418444156647,
0.022425614297389984,
-0.3282930254936218,
-0.10204127430915833,
1.0818723440170288,
-0.5413329601287842,
-0.2176179438829422,
0.3079890012741089,
0.8451666831970215,
0.24348817765712738,
0.08881702274084091,
-0.6142663955688477,
-0.012002742849290371,
-0.20971621572971344,
-0.15745963156223297,
0.5052207112312317,
0.7766252756118774,
0.15054520964622498,
0.7185595035552979,
0.7198612689971924,
0.10786217451095581,
-0.2847571074962616,
0.08115267008543015,
0.8777233362197876,
-0.9736985564231873,
-0.04142995923757553,
-0.918491542339325,
0.02498769201338291,
0.010892941616475582,
-0.3630073070526123,
0.6094720363616943,
0.8401025533676147,
0.6738144159317017,
0.023616265505552292,
0.5780586004257202,
0.2752419412136078,
0.537773609161377,
-0.3231867253780365,
0.48927614092826843,
-0.5162227749824524,
0.2994295656681061,
-0.46970275044441223,
-0.9316149353981018,
-0.538346529006958,
0.34273648262023926,
-0.20682762563228607,
-0.03427963703870773,
0.9666215777397156,
0.7846673130989075,
-0.015256969258189201,
-0.18735505640506744,
0.48187294602394104,
0.08059301972389221,
0.36516743898391724,
0.5646749138832092,
0.8791542053222656,
-0.40326768159866333,
0.8273670077323914,
-0.0234597809612751,
-0.11712079495191574,
0.21519015729427338,
-0.6333536505699158,
-1.0846705436706543,
-0.5312614440917969,
-0.4304514229297638,
-0.5006929039955139,
0.04523264244198799,
0.7194784879684448,
0.4080869257450104,
-0.27461954951286316,
-0.004926700610667467,
-0.05621684342622757,
0.26103541254997253,
0.005878721363842487,
-0.2719341218471527,
0.600423276424408,
-0.343787282705307,
-0.8205103278160095,
0.13993659615516663,
0.4787445068359375,
0.09910019487142563,
-0.03770048916339874,
0.04440215602517128,
-0.3037492334842682,
-0.16821296513080597,
0.4407784044742584,
0.5827419757843018,
-0.3283396363258362,
-0.11497639119625092,
-0.2883610725402832,
-0.24007004499435425,
0.38972964882850647,
0.9806934595108032,
-0.6757497787475586,
0.5179946422576904,
0.36643439531326294,
0.8854145407676697,
0.8972559571266174,
0.1802671253681183,
0.7014230489730835,
-0.7181714177131653,
0.12380852550268173,
0.0661020278930664,
0.38335317373275757,
0.19443441927433014,
-0.4083922207355499,
0.7675178050994873,
0.4476667642593384,
-0.39741700887680054,
-0.6346679329872131,
-0.06873590499162674,
-1.2574502229690552,
-0.3377801477909088,
1.2207741737365723,
-0.10585983842611313,
-0.41198593378067017,
-0.30827659368515015,
-0.22096098959445953,
0.7501215934753418,
-0.6323362588882446,
0.962990403175354,
0.5880188345909119,
-0.22334271669387817,
-0.3408547341823578,
-0.49183446168899536,
0.4016093611717224,
0.146216481924057,
-0.8035207986831665,
0.14974309504032135,
0.4176718592643738,
0.4603840112686157,
0.25327980518341064,
0.9048852920532227,
-0.6054773926734924,
0.1569441854953766,
0.1321486532688141,
-0.005106168333441019,
-0.4809993505477905,
-0.2164170742034912,
-0.1573752909898758,
0.436483770608902,
0.12138882279396057,
-0.47777432203292847
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.05902v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.05902v1
|
Whose Preferences? Differences in Fairness Preferences and Their Impact on the Fairness of AI Utilizing Human Feedback
| 2024-06-09T19:42:25 | 2024-06-09T19:42:25 |
Emilia Agis Lerner, Florian E. Dorner, Elliott Ash, Naman Goel
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CY
|
There is a growing body of work on learning from human feedback to align
various aspects of machine learning systems with human values and preferences.
We consider the setting of fairness in content moderation, in which human
feedback is used to determine how two comments -- referencing different
sensitive attribute groups -- should be treated in comparison to one another.
With a novel dataset collected from Prolific and MTurk, we find significant
gaps in fairness preferences depending on the race, age, political stance,
educational level, and LGBTQ+ identity of annotators. We also demonstrate that
demographics mentioned in text have a strong influence on how users perceive
individual fairness in moderation. Further, we find that differences also exist
in downstream classifiers trained to predict human preferences. Finally, we
observe that an ensemble, giving equal weight to classifiers trained on
annotations from different demographics, performs better for different
demographic intersections; compared to a single classifier that gives equal
weight to each annotation.
|
[
-0.6406298875808716,
-0.16915369033813477,
0.44184622168540955,
-0.006115042604506016,
0.17844685912132263,
0.11183534562587738,
-0.24494729936122894,
-0.687866747379303,
0.17593248188495636,
0.36977288126945496,
-0.353781133890152,
-0.139725461602211,
-0.7963644862174988,
0.1974015086889267,
0.09248288720846176,
1.1918965578079224,
0.46737658977508545,
0.4390427768230438,
-0.30353304743766785,
-0.5780877470970154,
-0.5800687074661255,
-0.6935620307922363,
-0.6632574796676636,
-0.34858831763267517,
0.8705859184265137,
0.40272486209869385,
0.8574383854866028,
0.5509051084518433,
0.3830034136772156,
0.4581165909767151,
0.028856685385107994,
-0.21092353761196136,
-0.36244475841522217,
-0.03399689868092537,
-0.28814247250556946,
-0.6643097996711731,
-0.24750792980194092,
0.4586641788482666,
0.35863202810287476,
0.8320934772491455,
0.104365773499012,
0.1836651712656021,
0.17297019064426422,
0.9215951561927795,
-0.8728678226470947,
-0.07133884727954865,
-0.5488961338996887,
0.39690932631492615,
-0.36460545659065247,
-0.2039157599210739,
-0.2877434194087982,
-0.4712070822715759,
0.2202417254447937,
-0.5140885710716248,
0.4608723223209381,
0.2277834564447403,
0.5163726806640625,
0.6129093766212463,
-0.6232311129570007,
0.05195874348282814,
-0.5653570890426636,
1.0619416236877441,
-0.3374403715133667,
0.19948165118694305,
0.7126097083091736,
0.33154913783073425,
0.14880532026290894,
-0.35176366567611694,
-0.5442695021629333,
-0.022864187136292458,
-0.28396302461624146,
0.03519640490412712,
0.26439982652664185,
0.2547128200531006,
0.3916322588920593,
0.12908534705638885,
-0.28663089871406555,
0.23856638371944427,
-0.6378041505813599,
-0.17954915761947632,
1.0105310678482056,
0.08769256621599197,
-0.06843889504671097,
-0.3231200873851776,
-0.10251764208078384,
-0.11821090430021286,
-0.2629433274269104,
0.5975971221923828,
0.9262848496437073,
0.1839146763086319,
0.1588393598794937,
0.43414387106895447,
-0.3232947587966919,
0.4415571689605713,
0.090782031416893,
0.08255786448717117,
0.4762597680091858,
0.16224278509616852,
-0.031608790159225464,
0.17237751185894012,
0.796945333480835,
0.7208317518234253,
0.3837686777114868,
-0.1960141807794571,
-0.2829919457435608,
0.1602931171655655,
0.16466198861598969,
-0.49016761779785156,
-0.32790711522102356,
-0.15499506890773773,
-1.0026665925979614,
-0.44317880272865295,
0.4591370224952698,
-0.8448029160499573,
-0.8670273423194885,
-0.5647240877151489,
0.17559492588043213,
0.4295061230659485,
0.0009082042379304767,
-0.18059425055980682,
-0.4335828423500061,
0.09585099667310715,
0.4801448583602905,
-1.1124895811080933,
0.30257293581962585,
0.7421576380729675,
0.46201053261756897,
-0.22471153736114502,
-0.211288720369339,
-0.8487087488174438,
-0.3216967284679413,
0.10075224936008453,
0.837317168712616,
-0.8315253853797913,
-0.37276336550712585,
-0.26927924156188965,
-0.15682116150856018,
0.22000454366207123,
-0.6119758486747742,
0.544133722782135,
-0.5000836849212646,
0.49483492970466614,
-0.803256630897522,
-0.46400344371795654,
-0.15196692943572998,
-0.07825183123350143,
-0.8268497586250305,
0.5466809272766113,
0.22418974339962006,
-0.9941407442092896,
0.8960590362548828,
-1.020065188407898,
-0.4192467927932739,
0.21420814096927643,
-0.391134113073349,
-0.2868262529373169,
0.03511610999703407,
-0.06010718643665314,
0.11783131211996078,
0.004277894273400307,
0.19371195137500763,
-0.6989704966545105,
-0.42944738268852234,
0.506100058555603,
-0.393715500831604,
0.9525320529937744,
0.41629067063331604,
-0.6869076490402222,
0.33274543285369873,
-0.20991067588329315,
-0.21217110753059387,
-0.11037877947092056,
-0.3782176971435547,
-0.0777878388762474,
0.3074634075164795,
0.3547362983226776,
0.16485513746738434,
0.09160316735506058,
-0.5978460907936096,
-0.04789906367659569,
0.1280142366886139,
0.515082061290741,
1.4659088850021362,
-0.35136738419532776,
0.6450832486152649,
-0.743823766708374,
0.3711183965206146,
-0.13887032866477966,
0.48165225982666016,
0.5495780110359192,
-0.7516856789588928,
-0.5821951627731323,
0.05330090969800949,
0.810492992401123,
0.45115166902542114,
-0.1551087200641632,
0.45457568764686584,
-0.014135579578578472,
0.055487584322690964,
-0.6688105463981628,
0.09651149064302444,
0.05088482052087784,
0.47620129585266113,
0.047643695026636124,
-0.6812443733215332,
-0.5358858108520508,
-0.9667488932609558,
-0.388053297996521,
-0.38063544034957886,
0.03712184727191925,
0.6496208310127258,
0.26986953616142273,
-0.15117043256759644,
1.0805940628051758,
-0.3095259964466095,
-0.20460614562034607,
0.11023586243391037,
0.010188926942646503,
-0.3431124985218048,
0.4362199008464813,
0.6668616533279419,
-1.1929597854614258,
-0.38120898604393005,
-0.25388503074645996,
-0.4851449429988861,
-0.20013487339019775,
0.2916014790534973,
-0.32731565833091736,
0.24123084545135498,
0.16428516805171967,
0.15088918805122375,
0.5910111665725708,
0.4138905704021454,
-0.5406626462936401,
0.31608960032463074,
0.09013861417770386,
0.6277416944503784,
-0.6505257487297058,
0.02672754041850567,
0.14657245576381683,
-0.3412414789199829,
-0.11404529213905334,
-0.4572996199131012,
-0.33852896094322205,
0.41384485363960266,
-0.37406086921691895,
0.5236870646476746,
0.2716517746448517,
-0.17107470333576202,
-0.2826334834098816,
0.05323562026023865,
-0.05928274616599083,
0.47932884097099304,
-0.05733068287372589,
0.6709669828414917,
-0.016259456053376198,
-0.43444448709487915,
0.27488818764686584,
0.24795830249786377,
-0.1119091585278511,
0.8037384152412415,
-0.45910194516181946,
0.2737315595149994,
-0.4459712505340576,
0.34097427129745483,
-0.7007749080657959,
-0.33613935112953186,
0.3937358260154724,
-0.7951363921165466,
-0.34698963165283203,
-0.3181990087032318,
-0.3747257590293884,
-0.18803709745407104,
-0.45713579654693604,
0.5902231335639954,
0.6366100907325745,
-0.302795946598053,
0.5502777099609375,
0.7952591180801392,
-0.17209580540657043,
-0.828952431678772,
-0.650636613368988,
-0.099205881357193,
-0.40875640511512756,
-0.564144492149353,
0.14020748436450958,
-0.31367528438568115,
-0.5861558318138123,
0.18525105714797974,
0.2750966250896454,
-0.20251695811748505,
0.3764374256134033,
0.597538411617279,
0.1904071569442749,
0.1412809044122696,
0.21416868269443512,
0.17438437044620514,
-0.24949102103710175,
0.059796396642923355,
-0.12234844267368317,
0.3482581675052643,
-0.20513950288295746,
-0.29283490777015686,
-0.5479447841644287,
0.5217177271842957,
0.1186082661151886,
-0.24442361295223236,
0.5994020104408264,
0.6004747748374939,
-0.20722481608390808,
0.3399461507797241,
-0.646240770816803,
-0.37245067954063416,
-0.46147841215133667,
0.17586860060691833,
0.08307188749313354,
-1.1916053295135498,
0.6935217380523682,
0.3923639953136444,
0.3151548504829407,
0.6824793219566345,
0.42874300479888916,
-0.3441501557826996,
1.2935091257095337,
0.7508136630058289,
-0.27117735147476196,
0.5749865770339966,
0.04665873572230339,
-0.1792120337486267,
-0.507579505443573,
-0.272071897983551,
-0.831009030342102,
-1.0428606271743774,
-1.1411199569702148,
0.19067984819412231,
0.07774239778518677,
-0.22195176780223846,
-0.5406354069709778,
-0.4024178981781006,
-0.524986982345581,
0.7308439612388611,
1.0431158542633057,
0.28965553641319275,
0.2020079493522644,
-0.035331569612026215,
0.26913467049598694,
-0.2523353695869446,
-0.4613815248012543,
-0.5351588129997253,
1.2977211475372314,
0.14369089901447296,
0.45149728655815125,
0.12460967898368835,
0.6146838068962097,
1.0666766166687012,
0.6917949318885803,
-0.5272378921508789,
0.21832841634750366,
-0.39361149072647095,
-0.8225058913230896,
-0.1733803004026413,
-0.9019166231155396,
-1.0488406419754028,
0.08070287108421326,
-0.43803080916404724,
-0.5773952007293701,
0.20007209479808807,
0.16951414942741394,
-0.4569299817085266,
0.5288496613502502,
-0.8223366737365723,
0.8210039734840393,
-0.26875776052474976,
-0.3858990967273712,
-0.3737007677555084,
-1.1301838159561157,
0.050486769527196884,
0.09300994873046875,
0.25068601965904236,
-0.4143277406692505,
0.16072963178157806,
1.0028959512710571,
-0.3466213643550873,
0.7620348334312439,
-0.5856530666351318,
0.4314248561859131,
-0.0021570154931396246,
-0.26613757014274597,
-0.25433459877967834,
0.20420750975608826,
-0.25278013944625854,
0.4288840591907501,
-0.15083640813827515,
-0.5082175135612488,
-0.487657755613327,
0.5811743140220642,
-1.0861424207687378,
-0.6224757432937622,
-0.4571049213409424,
-0.5377194285392761,
0.00271641556173563,
0.06041589006781578,
0.07389441132545471,
0.2543957531452179,
0.18883641064167023,
0.07644879072904587,
0.5499973893165588,
-0.16757869720458984,
0.3716748058795929,
0.13480889797210693,
-0.021108070388436317,
-0.4267108142375946,
0.6984958052635193,
-0.012734330259263515,
-0.0015514398692175746,
0.20616890490055084,
0.28695935010910034,
-0.4200375974178314,
0.008733103983104229,
-0.48128679394721985,
-0.04904799535870552,
-0.7078213095664978,
-0.18498900532722473,
-0.5241526961326599,
-0.015901727601885796,
-0.38667213916778564,
-0.22988662123680115,
-0.020692873746156693,
-0.531717836856842,
-0.1703391820192337,
0.12204190343618393,
0.19776447117328644,
0.9707564115524292,
-0.19984674453735352,
0.26213952898979187,
-0.5053113102912903,
0.02406138926744461,
0.6405410170555115,
0.6038083434104919,
0.11024007946252823,
-0.399484246969223,
0.03321297466754913,
0.13809289038181305,
-0.34374910593032837,
-0.5260341763496399,
-0.09970629960298538,
-0.15036249160766602,
0.5640422105789185,
0.6105049848556519,
0.2096695899963379,
0.2672690153121948,
-0.1864062398672104,
0.7083726525306702,
0.02967909350991249,
-0.7423762083053589,
0.2525402307510376,
-0.023306213319301605,
-0.20807045698165894,
0.9696335792541504,
0.2259933352470398,
-0.7974767088890076,
-0.11497537046670914,
-0.4727833569049835,
-0.41270560026168823,
0.8424670100212097,
0.15108010172843933,
0.08533558994531631,
0.16444061696529388,
0.5923812985420227,
0.5295746922492981,
0.41875341534614563,
-0.8131341338157654,
-0.4880150556564331,
-0.2801089882850647,
-0.31877464056015015,
0.02350224368274212,
-0.014290664345026016,
-0.2937350869178772,
-0.313887357711792,
0.18020287156105042,
0.03761626034975052,
0.15568707883358002,
-0.12577922642230988,
0.051968224346637726,
-0.22331073880195618,
0.22980912029743195,
0.48259904980659485,
0.6380988955497742,
-0.08736676722764969,
0.2269768863916397,
0.11402005702257156,
-0.22693075239658356,
0.1272139549255371,
0.1339033991098404,
-0.2972715198993683,
-0.32320672273635864,
0.06932100653648376,
0.6573982238769531,
-0.36274874210357666,
-0.5887832045555115,
0.5200068950653076,
-0.6202216148376465,
-0.2429128736257553,
-0.08299995958805084,
0.3762299716472626,
-0.4648493230342865,
0.354795902967453,
0.3404429256916046,
0.6809855103492737,
0.5806695222854614,
-0.34291723370552063,
0.06138848513364792,
0.3491811454296112,
-0.672582745552063,
-0.21013304591178894,
0.8546367287635803,
0.49165475368499756,
-0.41904357075691223,
0.708249568939209,
-0.23658567667007446,
-0.746642529964447,
0.5229090452194214,
-0.18249976634979248,
0.7700143456459045,
-0.0367576889693737,
0.10337714850902557,
-0.06819962710142136,
-0.06184399500489235,
0.13952191174030304,
-0.12689626216888428,
-0.4801896810531616,
-0.694911539554596,
-0.311095267534256,
-0.4403683841228485,
-0.35057246685028076,
-0.40443795919418335,
-0.6252283453941345,
0.18746806681156158,
-0.5439699292182922,
-0.6381169557571411,
0.012607980519533157,
0.2937164604663849,
-0.8453603386878967,
0.09955061227083206,
0.12825611233711243,
0.30919864773750305,
-0.824167013168335,
0.27453646063804626,
0.8180626630783081,
-0.4953106641769409,
-0.36851221323013306,
0.15605264902114868,
0.07325416058301926,
-0.47043535113334656,
0.6493706703186035,
0.4338207542896271,
0.0707339346408844,
-0.3454032242298126,
-0.6360933780670166,
-0.32581889629364014,
0.6908439993858337,
0.3972233235836029,
-0.31556937098503113,
0.23749278485774994,
0.125626802444458,
0.38982346653938293,
-0.12005046010017395,
0.47595131397247314,
0.522602915763855,
0.6246233582496643,
-0.24424909055233002,
-0.9881840944290161,
-0.3572860360145569,
-0.3769545257091522,
-0.04500500485301018,
0.03723776713013649,
-1.009374737739563,
0.6836934685707092,
-0.27624642848968506,
0.08564410358667374,
-0.23681552708148956,
0.6535277962684631,
0.2372812032699585,
0.7063678503036499,
1.0016916990280151,
0.44830724596977234,
0.963571310043335,
-0.11719971895217896,
1.00416898727417,
0.03032749705016613,
0.1371835321187973,
0.8562095165252686,
-0.14324228465557098,
0.343880832195282,
0.2569628059864044,
-0.33000996708869934,
0.6114093065261841,
0.9858866930007935,
0.15808895230293274,
0.44878315925598145,
0.0983143225312233,
-0.39476367831230164,
-0.23531316220760345,
-0.3393292725086212,
-0.3589000701904297,
0.3924805819988251,
-0.165775865316391,
-0.20567305386066437,
0.3103943467140198,
-0.08294965326786041,
0.02112886682152748,
0.1536499261856079,
-0.4227571487426758,
0.8335223197937012,
-0.19329796731472015,
-0.6962177157402039,
-0.3447772264480591,
0.33630460500717163,
1.0369139909744263,
-0.11090084910392761,
-0.006516268942505121,
-0.35214683413505554,
0.0009143903735093772,
-0.5332517027854919,
-0.9645081758499146,
0.023535780608654022,
0.0007323010358959436,
-0.6901071071624756,
-0.06835409253835678,
0.32830655574798584,
-0.15213686227798462,
-0.16637402772903442,
0.03176200017333031,
0.07649490237236023,
0.11922652274370193,
0.018755970522761345,
-0.7800336480140686,
-0.012655694968998432,
0.048248663544654846,
0.12509551644325256,
0.28218623995780945,
0.3478870987892151,
-0.20726604759693146,
0.49430787563323975,
0.6371070146560669,
-0.12833815813064575,
0.16617737710475922,
0.3659321367740631,
0.6580037474632263,
-0.7222052812576294,
-0.5513284802436829,
-0.7854470610618591,
0.514824390411377,
-0.30420705676078796,
-0.36574336886405945,
0.48144206404685974,
0.5251322984695435,
1.024086594581604,
0.2763122022151947,
0.9880419969558716,
-0.2574906051158905,
0.2865804433822632,
-0.16277936100959778,
0.7831073999404907,
-0.4185411036014557,
0.05488116294145584,
-0.20131051540374756,
-0.846648097038269,
-0.25059500336647034,
0.7850747108459473,
-0.4162595868110657,
0.9017300009727478,
0.20035208761692047,
0.44136670231819153,
0.23113615810871124,
0.21031981706619263,
-0.05438734591007233,
-0.3500099778175354,
0.49689310789108276,
0.3129311800003052,
0.8837571740150452,
-0.06267750263214111,
0.21547363698482513,
-0.16726373136043549,
-0.400588721036911,
-0.39977729320526123,
-0.5746321678161621,
-0.8391053676605225,
-0.6537638306617737,
-0.16429835557937622,
-0.36828866600990295,
-0.029108453541994095,
1.1457055807113647,
0.894446074962616,
-0.7970559597015381,
-0.17157480120658875,
0.3785703480243683,
0.4852331280708313,
0.17141073942184448,
-0.31422749161720276,
0.21572105586528778,
-0.29213687777519226,
-0.7547717690467834,
-0.4642268717288971,
0.10362573713064194,
-0.21040679514408112,
-0.44535884261131287,
-0.5044243931770325,
0.3442569077014923,
-0.2467653453350067,
0.4122008681297302,
0.10731229186058044,
-0.5638922452926636,
-0.4351295828819275,
-0.11665400117635727,
-0.11508437246084213,
0.3333572745323181,
0.9460192322731018,
-0.8816454410552979,
0.4375573396682739,
0.5083168148994446,
0.5993911623954773,
0.07507015019655228,
0.22388134896755219,
0.17263498902320862,
-0.43085381388664246,
0.3225906789302826,
0.38623926043510437,
0.3585951030254364,
0.4207378029823303,
-0.36820560693740845,
0.3881123960018158,
0.6060534715652466,
-1.0156831741333008,
-0.5870738625526428,
0.07931037247180939,
-0.8685275912284851,
-0.07614122331142426,
0.8563989996910095,
0.1902948021888733,
-0.06672879308462143,
-0.23307794332504272,
-0.3190692663192749,
0.012041330337524414,
-0.9504088759422302,
1.198408603668213,
0.3988744020462036,
-0.3460942804813385,
-0.07226745039224625,
-0.5061003565788269,
0.4816522002220154,
0.45434728264808655,
-0.8371872901916504,
-0.2814014256000519,
0.638914167881012,
0.2738349735736847,
-0.20561502873897552,
0.6876168847084045,
-0.06519035995006561,
0.4485224485397339,
-0.37502381205558777,
0.18292684853076935,
0.218558207154274,
-0.17274631559848785,
-0.24356487393379211,
0.2103365957736969,
0.16763685643672943,
-0.014993791468441486
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.05888v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.05888v2
|
Feriji: A French-Zarma Parallel Corpus, Glossary & Translator
| 2024-06-09T19:08:33 | 2024-06-17T22:36:18 |
Mamadou K. Keita, Elysabhete Amadou Ibrahim, Habibatou Abdoulaye Alfari, Christopher Homan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Machine translation (MT) is a rapidly expanding field that has experienced
significant advancements in recent years with the development of models capable
of translating multiple languages with remarkable accuracy. However, the
representation of African languages in this field still needs to improve due to
linguistic complexities and limited resources. This applies to the Zarma
language, a dialect of Songhay (of the Nilo-Saharan language family) spoken by
over 5 million people across Niger and neighboring countries
\cite{lewis2016ethnologue}. This paper introduces Feriji, the first robust
French-Zarma parallel corpus and glossary designed for MT. The corpus,
containing 61,085 sentences in Zarma and 42,789 in French, and a glossary of
4,062 words represent a significant step in addressing the need for more
resources for Zarma. We fine-tune three large language models on our dataset,
obtaining a BLEU score of 30.06 on the best-performing model. We further
evaluate the models on human judgments of fluency, comprehension, and
readability and the importance and impact of the corpus and models. Our
contributions help to bridge a significant language gap and promote an
essential and overlooked indigenous African language.
|
[
-0.5652022957801819,
-0.38075587153434753,
0.458614706993103,
0.4096728563308716,
0.17171113193035126,
0.2743423581123352,
-0.1799522489309311,
-0.30689966678619385,
0.21951191127300262,
0.6752481460571289,
-0.20189444720745087,
-0.2022695392370224,
-0.6733620166778564,
0.37692904472351074,
-0.5622281432151794,
0.9304351210594177,
-0.17597508430480957,
-0.2761366069316864,
0.16045844554901123,
-0.4344508647918701,
-0.08921375870704651,
-0.5876699686050415,
-0.1615309864282608,
-0.5832357406616211,
0.8622890710830688,
0.4336094260215759,
1.340664267539978,
0.5232847929000854,
0.5476243495941162,
0.29876768589019775,
-0.040788255631923676,
0.5662351250648499,
-0.18894965946674347,
-0.21376380324363708,
-0.38378503918647766,
-0.4528774619102478,
-0.47753626108169556,
-0.3355514705181122,
0.5673020482063293,
0.9222612977027893,
0.012551859952509403,
-0.012660485692322254,
0.11768268048763275,
1.005854845046997,
-0.5008583664894104,
-0.1959749013185501,
-0.20711958408355713,
-0.4236747622489929,
-0.4818229377269745,
0.20577651262283325,
-0.13230153918266296,
-0.24956506490707397,
-0.24918687343597412,
-0.420365571975708,
0.19637516140937805,
0.011198796331882477,
1.1777552366256714,
0.2665199935436249,
-0.4245259463787079,
-0.14103703200817108,
-0.6140788197517395,
0.6695553064346313,
-0.38661083579063416,
0.3951758146286011,
0.7082757949829102,
0.5578159093856812,
-0.3183450698852539,
-0.8529303073883057,
-0.8801708817481995,
0.05521265044808388,
-0.06878083199262619,
-0.14633721113204956,
-0.04489842429757118,
-0.01847471483051777,
0.2453034371137619,
0.7002795934677124,
-0.6858829855918884,
-0.2711254060268402,
-0.44171738624572754,
-0.03018500655889511,
0.7028272151947021,
0.14270010590553284,
0.5995664000511169,
-0.31684592366218567,
-0.3625675141811371,
-0.12754479050636292,
-0.4471067488193512,
-0.21652476489543915,
0.49729788303375244,
0.4051225483417511,
-0.32228538393974304,
0.3230626583099365,
-0.5215247273445129,
0.7815231084823608,
-0.32527589797973633,
-0.08900471776723862,
0.5701174736022949,
-0.2826206088066101,
-0.088374063372612,
-0.3460678160190582,
1.2053848505020142,
0.3359907567501068,
0.3199348449707031,
-0.358756422996521,
-0.24558745324611664,
0.017678771167993546,
0.1712363213300705,
-0.7255023121833801,
-0.5048285722732544,
0.3945015072822571,
-0.31200650334358215,
-0.0966462641954422,
-0.17017759382724762,
-0.7509976625442505,
-0.529424786567688,
0.135909765958786,
0.4310656487941742,
-0.36172768473625183,
-0.31839799880981445,
0.0868176817893982,
0.18459650874137878,
-0.12619924545288086,
0.12425264716148376,
-1.0585956573486328,
0.19832919538021088,
0.38137108087539673,
1.0833568572998047,
0.10873272269964218,
-0.2788996994495392,
-0.24931403994560242,
0.10605616122484207,
-0.29610103368759155,
0.8426754474639893,
-0.24519555270671844,
-0.533657968044281,
-0.21390873193740845,
-0.17086873948574066,
-0.3506914973258972,
-0.6322519779205322,
0.945232093334198,
-0.29142728447914124,
-0.20746681094169617,
-0.41835254430770874,
0.04753625765442848,
-0.6969283819198608,
-0.024152198806405067,
-0.8860216736793518,
0.7380674481391907,
0.65280681848526,
-0.5225124359130859,
-0.10523127764463425,
-0.6605995893478394,
-0.5148477554321289,
0.39950835704803467,
-0.2536359429359436,
-0.23738700151443481,
0.06262657046318054,
0.49229758977890015,
0.10639443248510361,
-0.7168798446655273,
0.2810705006122589,
0.0771290510892868,
-0.37576767802238464,
0.538435697555542,
0.08328521996736526,
0.7849275469779968,
0.6299579739570618,
-0.1620975285768509,
-0.09157824516296387,
-0.49874162673950195,
0.3143267333507538,
-0.13244405388832092,
-0.11552980542182922,
-0.21184921264648438,
0.0010802214965224266,
0.47086143493652344,
0.3416418433189392,
0.13551001250743866,
-0.6227210164070129,
0.03228897973895073,
-0.6994083523750305,
0.49904635548591614,
0.23857976496219635,
-0.21729375422000885,
0.20634467899799347,
-0.5042504072189331,
0.5039957165718079,
-0.20711691677570343,
0.028598610311746597,
-0.1865498125553131,
-0.4209935665130615,
-0.8671538233757019,
-0.4588058590888977,
0.9328943490982056,
0.83531653881073,
-0.9591951966285706,
0.13609987497329712,
-0.4057196080684662,
-0.2805388569831848,
-0.744619607925415,
0.5589436292648315,
0.1606132537126541,
0.06141016259789467,
0.2507760524749756,
-0.23095470666885376,
-0.43175286054611206,
-1.372636079788208,
-0.4521273374557495,
-0.09517597407102585,
-0.005110034719109535,
0.06726405769586563,
0.5675726532936096,
-0.6211816072463989,
0.558414876461029,
-0.11857550591230392,
-0.2981742322444916,
-0.5265699625015259,
0.32815051078796387,
0.7067486047744751,
0.3732226490974426,
0.9036038517951965,
-1.1442482471466064,
-0.5965524911880493,
0.466838538646698,
-0.6719290614128113,
-0.4488787055015564,
-0.05645659565925598,
-0.4451112151145935,
-0.06482324004173279,
0.06673911958932877,
-0.2607538104057312,
0.3501366376876831,
0.7964870929718018,
-0.14880245923995972,
-0.11373914033174515,
0.1652626395225525,
0.4251582622528076,
-1.3335050344467163,
0.2916279435157776,
-0.35517942905426025,
-0.28156861662864685,
-0.7400671243667603,
0.46844127774238586,
0.14277416467666626,
-0.059623997658491135,
-0.08142451196908951,
0.4765556752681732,
-0.2316569685935974,
0.4851381182670593,
-0.6298890709877014,
-0.05788746848702431,
-0.09312429279088974,
0.5073922872543335,
-0.17303791642189026,
0.9678211212158203,
-0.041413553059101105,
-0.40766674280166626,
0.4215066730976105,
0.5540297627449036,
-0.4439433217048645,
0.38375428318977356,
-0.6779635548591614,
0.10987721383571625,
0.20008738338947296,
-0.2265198826789856,
-0.8710044026374817,
-0.5671296715736389,
0.43688225746154785,
-0.5901128649711609,
0.1395035982131958,
0.07569348067045212,
-0.6658569574356079,
-0.282676100730896,
0.10424185544252396,
0.24157755076885223,
0.45917096734046936,
-0.4601682126522064,
0.6797798871994019,
0.4226987063884735,
-0.45098230242729187,
-0.5237316489219666,
-0.9160645604133606,
0.35279086232185364,
0.1959276646375656,
-0.6462295055389404,
0.10026388615369797,
0.1411082148551941,
-0.26858851313591003,
-0.22634990513324738,
-0.2074325531721115,
-0.3073005676269531,
0.1461009979248047,
0.5615661144256592,
0.1281280517578125,
-0.056739479303359985,
-0.03129333257675171,
0.02660980261862278,
-0.14037953317165375,
-0.14782065153121948,
-0.10156093537807465,
0.43042460083961487,
-0.22685709595680237,
0.19985012710094452,
-0.0032830345444381237,
0.6259098649024963,
0.49741867184638977,
-0.2856881320476532,
1.139142632484436,
0.47429439425468445,
-0.399111270904541,
-0.23084691166877747,
-0.3329216539859772,
0.4575963020324707,
-0.45442092418670654,
0.0022146485280245543,
-0.6991369724273682,
-0.7808019518852234,
0.5072501301765442,
-0.3709013760089874,
-0.14856354892253876,
0.6361920833587646,
0.5921973586082458,
-0.07850728183984756,
0.896553099155426,
0.8460578918457031,
-0.14501416683197021,
0.20137405395507812,
-0.3541205823421478,
0.4173218905925751,
-0.7962665557861328,
-0.11156610399484634,
-0.705575704574585,
-0.4451403021812439,
-0.6339010000228882,
-0.3759576678276062,
0.38045400381088257,
0.39450958371162415,
0.09274439513683319,
0.5015581846237183,
-0.1318923830986023,
0.29526442289352417,
0.25254252552986145,
0.2189970165491104,
0.12677447497844696,
0.24254922568798065,
-0.5748205184936523,
-0.047296810895204544,
-0.6924731135368347,
-0.7175843715667725,
0.9007550477981567,
0.06112126633524895,
0.6230989694595337,
0.38261178135871887,
0.6430146098136902,
0.4248264729976654,
0.2880057990550995,
-0.5041300058364868,
0.33074936270713806,
-0.2819880247116089,
-0.6800209283828735,
0.0017368834232911468,
-0.5623878240585327,
-0.5096189975738525,
0.44240641593933105,
-0.204538494348526,
-0.6173696517944336,
0.45904505252838135,
0.07264429330825806,
-0.5642022490501404,
0.31195318698883057,
-0.49352970719337463,
1.0469417572021484,
-0.3485713601112366,
-0.627144992351532,
0.14013732969760895,
-0.5773105025291443,
0.35459786653518677,
-0.4189576208591461,
0.5460537672042847,
-0.2499237358570099,
-0.09443167597055435,
0.30743977427482605,
-0.6088423132896423,
0.26088079810142517,
0.2862195074558258,
-0.03818525746464729,
0.01293268520385027,
0.17986668646335602,
0.030305908992886543,
-0.1904025673866272,
-0.33691874146461487,
0.41292035579681396,
0.005340804811567068,
-0.5945271253585815,
-0.5615922212600708,
0.7440991401672363,
-0.7376750111579895,
-0.3926272392272949,
-0.6821059584617615,
-0.932590901851654,
-0.09572939574718475,
0.3302048146724701,
0.24768659472465515,
0.3231201469898224,
-0.1353600174188614,
0.2618321180343628,
0.46908119320869446,
-0.3499234616756439,
0.018512848764657974,
0.3446422517299652,
-0.5449347496032715,
-0.7075208425521851,
1.1261953115463257,
0.03519684821367264,
0.23559390008449554,
0.5136948227882385,
-0.08179433643817902,
-0.06330476701259613,
-0.6111373901367188,
-0.8954685926437378,
0.2566816210746765,
-0.40583720803260803,
-0.2952553629875183,
-0.887734055519104,
-0.33890727162361145,
-0.16339758038520813,
-0.15194162726402283,
0.024797871708869934,
-0.7396564483642578,
0.24714113771915436,
0.27882203459739685,
0.478924036026001,
0.6382943987846375,
-0.2072395235300064,
0.6167839765548706,
-0.8928890824317932,
0.763250470161438,
-0.010911856777966022,
0.09312746673822403,
-0.39097338914871216,
-0.4729767143726349,
-0.4195942282676697,
0.2964182198047638,
-0.2095925509929657,
-0.791123628616333,
0.4873039424419403,
0.47775527834892273,
0.45245441794395447,
0.07875508069992065,
0.1401117593050003,
0.5814615488052368,
-0.4298169016838074,
0.6133651733398438,
0.044116780161857605,
-0.8596746325492859,
0.4157447814941406,
-0.5606716871261597,
0.48927053809165955,
0.7368119955062866,
0.5443403124809265,
-0.7466394901275635,
-0.19268038868904114,
-0.13331860303878784,
-0.92695152759552,
0.5055172443389893,
0.5270295143127441,
0.04774172231554985,
-0.017733797430992126,
0.20816351473331451,
0.09687043726444244,
0.37080779671669006,
-0.2179233878850937,
-0.19712503254413605,
-0.21803544461727142,
-0.5231817364692688,
-0.41056621074676514,
-0.19359731674194336,
0.02564234845340252,
-0.24847964942455292,
0.6522835493087769,
-0.10683414340019226,
0.2952761948108673,
0.015835344791412354,
-0.3333427309989929,
-0.27739039063453674,
0.42764392495155334,
0.4816664457321167,
0.7313305735588074,
-0.08580299466848373,
-0.07025916874408722,
0.12008124589920044,
-0.6577760577201843,
0.05483175069093704,
0.35256242752075195,
-0.5121418237686157,
0.247181236743927,
0.06476233899593353,
0.7862762808799744,
-0.014436978846788406,
-0.7140053510665894,
0.2874850332736969,
0.24435266852378845,
-0.2856069505214691,
-0.24592112004756927,
0.11324919015169144,
0.16007302701473236,
0.2648329436779022,
0.3804011642932892,
0.24101479351520538,
0.37165161967277527,
-0.5453168153762817,
0.05098744481801987,
0.11471095681190491,
-0.09611288458108902,
-0.0659131407737732,
1.0494885444641113,
0.37772396206855774,
-0.10558678209781647,
0.47210457921028137,
-0.013880080543458462,
-0.9154013395309448,
0.23682646453380585,
0.2239793837070465,
0.8930558562278748,
-0.3939729630947113,
0.3004627525806427,
0.5555811524391174,
0.6912016272544861,
-0.1572202444076538,
0.7487623691558838,
-0.15656860172748566,
-0.5961084961891174,
-0.26655030250549316,
-1.0355201959609985,
-0.44241878390312195,
-0.09037338197231293,
-0.5400865077972412,
-0.12224969267845154,
-0.38370785117149353,
-0.4306592643260956,
0.2119893580675125,
0.023665115237236023,
-0.4010921120643616,
0.09502452611923218,
-0.01990807056427002,
0.8189232349395752,
-0.669665515422821,
1.1298274993896484,
0.68746417760849,
-0.6259070634841919,
-0.5755676627159119,
-0.21020062267780304,
-0.23615749180316925,
-0.4600376486778259,
0.706130862236023,
-0.028903871774673462,
-0.4483025372028351,
-0.054818544536828995,
-0.3365200459957123,
-0.43448200821876526,
0.6114078164100647,
0.36907637119293213,
-0.7657163739204407,
0.12652495503425598,
0.36197033524513245,
0.4758163392543793,
-0.22658945620059967,
-0.06947287917137146,
0.4723105728626251,
0.41841885447502136,
-0.09525029361248016,
-1.1213887929916382,
-0.07723347097635269,
-0.6141397356987,
0.347908079624176,
0.8423451781272888,
-0.6897082328796387,
1.0769850015640259,
-0.24339358508586884,
-0.5040361881256104,
0.8270580172538757,
0.6214746832847595,
-0.41351115703582764,
0.09770441055297852,
0.22374197840690613,
0.4987715184688568,
0.5374169945716858,
-0.3986303508281708,
1.2273342609405518,
-0.3559880554676056,
0.023703983053565025,
0.9782407283782959,
-0.41209495067596436,
0.9357953071594238,
0.3862212598323822,
-0.25346633791923523,
0.8375529050827026,
0.16508422791957855,
0.2099490761756897,
0.38123324513435364,
0.09079854935407639,
-0.5892453789710999,
-0.5441679358482361,
-0.3737756311893463,
-0.4401243031024933,
0.19134818017482758,
0.6948103308677673,
-0.7021384835243225,
0.010883652605116367,
0.03189622983336449,
-0.05472550168633461,
0.7227787971496582,
-0.2755553424358368,
0.3207911550998688,
0.324978232383728,
-0.2740078270435333,
0.9118618965148926,
0.2070898413658142,
0.364060640335083,
-0.6852734088897705,
-0.1313496232032776,
-0.1593797355890274,
0.48146048188209534,
-0.42398640513420105,
-0.6216229200363159,
0.17879001796245575,
0.18007579445838928,
-0.3508114218711853,
-0.14579178392887115,
0.5626978278160095,
-0.6274439096450806,
-0.5303367972373962,
0.22871245443820953,
0.6070848107337952,
0.2235434502363205,
-0.10099688172340393,
-0.5613024234771729,
0.27872973680496216,
0.025554969906806946,
0.3778347969055176,
0.06690216064453125,
0.10049469769001007,
-0.22931386530399323,
0.5416552424430847,
0.6297854781150818,
0.00897020474076271,
-0.025384457781910896,
-0.14481930434703827,
0.7711871266365051,
-0.6940297484397888,
-0.4387754201889038,
-0.6294121742248535,
0.25591546297073364,
-0.037065695971250534,
-0.12219059467315674,
0.9637035727500916,
0.5559072494506836,
0.7968311309814453,
-0.01263783872127533,
1.090303897857666,
-0.39219266176223755,
0.8444749712944031,
-0.24968281388282776,
1.0305455923080444,
-0.5986321568489075,
-0.09254590421915054,
-0.22789542376995087,
-0.7802068591117859,
-0.17983657121658325,
0.9003891944885254,
-0.10520496964454651,
-0.10634277760982513,
0.6470728516578674,
0.894779622554779,
0.024565281346440315,
0.18339557945728302,
0.39635777473449707,
0.10338462144136429,
-0.4128402769565582,
1.002251386642456,
0.7404969930648804,
-0.9978139996528625,
0.5530430674552917,
-0.22822409868240356,
-0.13826680183410645,
-0.0862460657954216,
-0.5613662004470825,
-1.0341434478759766,
-0.6089110374450684,
-0.16260583698749542,
-0.41173848509788513,
0.33647826313972473,
0.859582245349884,
0.19418460130691528,
-1.145974040031433,
-0.5251394510269165,
0.35673072934150696,
0.017901340499520302,
-0.44821473956108093,
-0.04821019992232323,
-0.06772332638502121,
0.14417438209056854,
-0.7390491366386414,
0.4637560546398163,
0.31163275241851807,
-0.117643803358078,
0.07552166283130646,
-0.2576296329498291,
-0.5535637736320496,
-0.005719226785004139,
0.45386508107185364,
0.7271636128425598,
-0.6164801716804504,
-0.016647737473249435,
-0.0012073166435584426,
-0.38109469413757324,
-0.17526021599769592,
0.6109299063682556,
-0.6579775810241699,
0.8249986171722412,
0.5840392112731934,
0.7530261874198914,
0.21206887066364288,
-0.15854524075984955,
0.9746372699737549,
-0.25138795375823975,
0.2511220872402191,
-0.11017407476902008,
0.1608964502811432,
0.5473185777664185,
-0.013794207945466042,
0.8034643530845642,
0.18097040057182312,
-0.5095590353012085,
-0.8178837895393372,
0.23887093365192413,
-0.8226283192634583,
0.01677381992340088,
0.6101136803627014,
-0.06444863229990005,
-0.34175360202789307,
-0.2668462097644806,
-0.3027837574481964,
0.13126318156719208,
-0.07548042386770248,
0.36697208881378174,
0.7648923397064209,
0.22719508409500122,
-0.2273261696100235,
-1.1052254438400269,
0.3351430296897888,
0.20900610089302063,
-0.32741492986679077,
-0.35424748063087463,
0.26372307538986206,
0.09604332596063614,
0.2920401394367218,
0.42665502429008484,
-0.12995471060276031,
0.61043381690979,
0.15755385160446167,
0.18705889582633972,
-0.10011255741119385,
-0.3229196071624756,
-0.3732680678367615,
0.017999544739723206,
0.06574232876300812,
-0.28761500120162964
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.05885v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.05885v1
|
Are Large Language Models Actually Good at Text Style Transfer?
| 2024-06-09T18:45:41 | 2024-06-09T18:45:41 |
Sourabrata Mukherjee, Atul Kr. Ojha, Ondřej Dušek
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We analyze the performance of large language models (LLMs) on Text Style
Transfer (TST), specifically focusing on sentiment transfer and text
detoxification across three languages: English, Hindi, and Bengali. Text Style
Transfer involves modifying the linguistic style of a text while preserving its
core content. We evaluate the capabilities of pre-trained LLMs using zero-shot
and few-shot prompting as well as parameter-efficient finetuning on publicly
available datasets. Our evaluation using automatic metrics, GPT-4 and human
evaluations reveals that while some prompted LLMs perform well in English,
their performance in on other languages (Hindi, Bengali) remains average.
However, finetuning significantly improves results compared to zero-shot and
few-shot prompting, making them comparable to previous state-of-the-art. This
underscores the necessity of dedicated datasets and specialized models for
effective TST.
|
[
0.02355107106268406,
-0.6909275650978088,
0.6417470574378967,
0.33002376556396484,
-0.4536170959472656,
0.13258475065231323,
-0.5310733914375305,
-0.5074633955955505,
-0.11685876548290253,
0.37561988830566406,
-0.2667781710624695,
-0.4539989233016968,
-0.6892264485359192,
0.3754722476005554,
-0.7508564591407776,
1.1466248035430908,
-0.13401885330677032,
-0.003267883323132992,
0.27829691767692566,
0.1965588927268982,
-0.45987048745155334,
-0.46051955223083496,
-0.8649966716766357,
-0.4238230884075165,
0.6057023406028748,
0.27879106998443604,
0.4569796025753021,
0.3456321060657501,
0.7089214324951172,
0.20477783679962158,
-0.0791795551776886,
-0.028935689479112625,
-0.6491443514823914,
0.026545491069555283,
-0.39939045906066895,
-0.430990606546402,
-0.25856447219848633,
-0.041792891919612885,
0.6453280448913574,
0.31746456027030945,
0.06459176540374756,
-0.059250518679618835,
0.20023177564144135,
0.8093231320381165,
-0.3458276689052582,
-0.014735684730112553,
-0.6136177182197571,
-0.03380805253982544,
-0.29778236150741577,
-0.13739825785160065,
-0.6616055965423584,
-0.6760610342025757,
0.1645922064781189,
-0.263815313577652,
-0.09381157159805298,
-0.10564464330673218,
1.005766749382019,
0.13973814249038696,
-0.6440438628196716,
-0.23377886414527893,
-0.8746951818466187,
0.8337627649307251,
-0.8287269473075867,
0.3448612689971924,
0.21243171393871307,
0.24738658964633942,
0.29468947649002075,
-0.4850665330886841,
-0.4139721393585205,
-0.1999158263206482,
-0.07423114031553268,
0.21302613615989685,
-0.13242222368717194,
-0.064145028591156,
0.023739833384752274,
0.3168625831604004,
-0.4306308627128601,
0.2547493875026703,
-0.4587385058403015,
-0.08315398544073105,
0.6140084266662598,
0.039651643484830856,
0.4344320297241211,
-0.363216370344162,
-0.44884365797042847,
0.03345206752419472,
-0.7543466091156006,
-0.13208848237991333,
0.26398617029190063,
0.5684714913368225,
-0.354554146528244,
0.3818243443965912,
-0.09903904795646667,
0.669679582118988,
-0.11521420627832413,
-0.41746413707733154,
-0.04287713021039963,
-0.6861796379089355,
-0.17652489244937897,
-0.058865174651145935,
0.9705808758735657,
0.5993814468383789,
0.8265252709388733,
-0.26490893959999084,
-0.4044099450111389,
-0.26427942514419556,
0.18201419711112976,
-0.9420034289360046,
-0.1958555281162262,
-0.12417056411504745,
-0.4104055166244507,
-0.4034353196620941,
-0.21483692526817322,
-0.9158231616020203,
-0.5580217242240906,
-0.555095374584198,
0.7112777233123779,
-0.6026756763458252,
-0.4338788092136383,
0.23950143158435822,
-0.14272809028625488,
0.6280500292778015,
0.549764096736908,
-0.8915057182312012,
0.04399421811103821,
0.5481923818588257,
1.2443666458129883,
-0.5408505201339722,
-0.00971154309809208,
-0.08042169362306595,
0.11339329928159714,
-0.6553175449371338,
0.9118591547012329,
-0.5507171154022217,
-0.354451984167099,
0.19970722496509552,
-0.17614160478115082,
-0.14333586394786835,
-0.3502487242221832,
0.545545756816864,
-0.3505139648914337,
-0.1269732415676117,
-0.4719630479812622,
-0.334238737821579,
0.06412086635828018,
0.2975459396839142,
-0.4899371266365051,
0.6887243390083313,
-0.005010652355849743,
-0.6188700795173645,
0.2346440553665161,
-0.46426886320114136,
-0.8312188982963562,
-0.1335165798664093,
0.31752780079841614,
-0.18317176401615143,
0.08960507065057755,
0.14719988405704498,
0.8197094202041626,
-0.21879510581493378,
0.044755373150110245,
-0.2483847439289093,
-0.6002894043922424,
0.23284809291362762,
-0.4721882939338684,
0.6137579083442688,
0.5161012411117554,
-0.1980183720588684,
0.010548089630901814,
-0.5572499632835388,
-0.07188288867473602,
0.04129280149936676,
-0.2825246751308441,
-0.3808789551258087,
-0.4451916217803955,
0.364369660615921,
0.3199087083339691,
0.14790524542331696,
-0.4999259114265442,
0.4413188695907593,
-0.25695377588272095,
0.7130287289619446,
0.7641879320144653,
0.07644882053136826,
0.5188219547271729,
-0.41653579473495483,
0.46706756949424744,
-0.21339772641658783,
-0.16311298310756683,
-0.08611419051885605,
-0.06786906719207764,
-0.7853546738624573,
-0.30898210406303406,
0.25641533732414246,
0.6146164536476135,
-0.8771931529045105,
-0.030582794919610023,
-0.34462782740592957,
-0.6022697687149048,
-0.27570366859436035,
-0.019598810002207756,
0.3759539723396301,
0.33104974031448364,
0.23063550889492035,
-0.08456063270568848,
-0.2786938548088074,
-0.9522674679756165,
-0.4836716055870056,
-0.014788318425416946,
0.11940322816371918,
-0.09224182367324829,
0.36376529932022095,
0.04964675381779671,
0.7064521908760071,
-0.2695988714694977,
-0.18834181129932404,
-0.5815138220787048,
0.3437068462371826,
-0.01734665222465992,
0.257709264755249,
0.7803349494934082,
-0.48400890827178955,
-0.830898106098175,
0.24273212254047394,
-0.5790902972221375,
-0.38666093349456787,
-0.40943899750709534,
-0.15517273545265198,
0.46542927622795105,
0.5406424403190613,
-0.41145145893096924,
0.21249012649059296,
0.7108558416366577,
-0.0548950657248497,
0.7165011763572693,
0.08104991912841797,
0.5625662803649902,
-1.3857216835021973,
0.12208437919616699,
0.35135936737060547,
-0.4601052403450012,
-0.8693239092826843,
-0.07576427608728409,
0.10400032252073288,
-0.04784231260418892,
-0.6859517693519592,
0.9303445219993591,
-0.32124006748199463,
0.07116779685020447,
-0.33871906995773315,
0.052488669753074646,
0.13306279480457306,
0.3676677346229553,
0.10316388309001923,
0.9500007629394531,
0.4064815640449524,
-0.5016709566116333,
0.1881742924451828,
0.04026654362678528,
-0.4084019362926483,
0.8635392189025879,
-0.5596232414245605,
0.2849465608596802,
0.048561710864305496,
0.21970483660697937,
-1.221214771270752,
-0.21653002500534058,
0.09089857339859009,
-0.025252386927604675,
0.5150122046470642,
-0.3483947813510895,
-0.5980172157287598,
-0.18205755949020386,
-0.25769585371017456,
0.053505465388298035,
0.7165532112121582,
-0.4209403693675995,
0.3200746178627014,
-0.1554194539785385,
-0.4480848014354706,
-0.3395755887031555,
-0.9020545482635498,
0.32495516538619995,
-0.3971908688545227,
-0.3599814176559448,
-0.02369053103029728,
-0.05543415993452072,
-0.2681967616081238,
-0.3100143373012543,
0.09774825721979141,
-0.23992225527763367,
0.014360670000314713,
-0.038279298692941666,
0.34618449211120605,
0.033332765102386475,
0.10338125377893448,
-0.1072080135345459,
0.2457423359155655,
-0.10581544786691666,
-0.0707351416349411,
0.6423506736755371,
-0.24099940061569214,
-0.1757490187883377,
-0.8536279201507568,
0.14718039333820343,
0.6227395534515381,
-0.29253944754600525,
0.7736044526100159,
0.7562918066978455,
-0.15295830368995667,
-0.22602686285972595,
-0.5575445294380188,
-0.04537453129887581,
-0.43853873014450073,
0.3351644277572632,
-0.5257226824760437,
-0.8158708214759827,
0.4384479224681854,
-0.05236819386482239,
0.0985330268740654,
0.4449220299720764,
0.5862249135971069,
-0.06574654579162598,
1.0038692951202393,
0.7316750288009644,
-0.19248545169830322,
0.7428474426269531,
-0.0484389029443264,
0.41286328434944153,
-0.5188688039779663,
0.1184697076678276,
-0.6255834102630615,
-0.2851549983024597,
-0.7388492822647095,
-0.05832132324576378,
0.1400689333677292,
-0.053390178829431534,
-0.27649134397506714,
0.16630123555660248,
-0.3090323805809021,
0.6785323619842529,
0.22594232857227325,
0.07775630801916122,
0.44295647740364075,
0.22593578696250916,
0.24260792136192322,
-0.124671570956707,
-0.296863853931427,
-0.6364514231681824,
0.9961012005805969,
0.3346535861492157,
1.034460186958313,
0.15115892887115479,
0.7328785061836243,
0.1632017344236374,
0.4300518333911896,
-1.0830472707748413,
0.4866492748260498,
-0.630987286567688,
-0.3515303432941437,
-0.1811732053756714,
-0.4620126783847809,
-0.6043636202812195,
-0.057392388582229614,
-0.13519228994846344,
-0.6222031116485596,
-0.10548792779445648,
0.023453738540410995,
-0.24010862410068512,
0.521900475025177,
-0.8458516001701355,
0.4657708406448364,
-0.0922432616353035,
-0.4621550738811493,
-0.046817272901535034,
-0.5098901987075806,
0.5782244205474854,
-0.5302221775054932,
0.15499497950077057,
-0.09865985810756683,
0.020532531663775444,
0.8239212036132812,
-0.0003411364450585097,
0.8230716586112976,
0.08886796236038208,
-0.43469563126564026,
0.19376632571220398,
0.4434947669506073,
0.4253730773925781,
-0.4236213266849518,
-0.3294910490512848,
0.30945542454719543,
0.108306884765625,
-0.22994863986968994,
-0.6260666251182556,
0.7015329599380493,
-0.8053219318389893,
-0.44028985500335693,
-0.19729743897914886,
-0.5070145130157471,
-0.42373284697532654,
0.44219231605529785,
0.32187843322753906,
0.589236319065094,
0.06464460492134094,
0.3129537105560303,
0.5256218910217285,
-0.18072748184204102,
0.5096027851104736,
0.33289337158203125,
-0.29720064997673035,
-0.10197962075471878,
0.9105406999588013,
0.30745264887809753,
0.6288385987281799,
0.273034930229187,
0.49371537566185,
-0.33312004804611206,
-0.6925792694091797,
-0.5806694030761719,
0.3237941861152649,
-0.7876447439193726,
-0.19405215978622437,
-0.492197185754776,
-0.4549921452999115,
-0.4643690586090088,
-0.48899176716804504,
-0.4749305248260498,
-0.29855480790138245,
-0.08412456512451172,
-0.033280011266469955,
0.5860415101051331,
1.1604599952697754,
0.1614764779806137,
0.4666113257408142,
-0.9695246815681458,
0.11897744238376617,
0.2807922065258026,
0.4852849543094635,
-0.07648008316755295,
-0.8599415421485901,
-0.10449361056089401,
-0.0748150423169136,
-0.13238310813903809,
-0.8560387492179871,
0.3972262144088745,
0.20443695783615112,
0.13059934973716736,
0.2985714077949524,
-0.05785846710205078,
0.5212122201919556,
-0.6023492217063904,
0.9688428640365601,
0.19071638584136963,
-0.9035243988037109,
0.307817280292511,
-0.6765081882476807,
0.47126588225364685,
0.6121237874031067,
0.581663966178894,
-0.9382287859916687,
-0.40767794847488403,
-0.1386706382036209,
-0.6151936054229736,
0.6452690362930298,
0.010493049398064613,
0.40135031938552856,
0.07002072781324387,
0.511874794960022,
0.18449647724628448,
0.09758924692869186,
-0.7144851684570312,
0.09178812056779861,
-0.17389598488807678,
-0.422830730676651,
-0.011652703396975994,
-0.15198497474193573,
0.1552155464887619,
-0.11321000754833221,
0.5362129807472229,
0.02053782530128956,
0.16243194043636322,
0.018723731860518456,
-0.15491586923599243,
-0.08344008773565292,
0.6412807703018188,
0.6033245325088501,
0.47187671065330505,
-0.12645573914051056,
0.15136553347110748,
0.0774698331952095,
-0.46577590703964233,
0.3100350499153137,
-0.2985268831253052,
-0.23601117730140686,
-0.20602817833423615,
0.3987794518470764,
0.735761821269989,
0.18175528943538666,
-0.22036123275756836,
0.5217522978782654,
-0.06774764508008957,
-0.18609938025474548,
0.22718606889247894,
-0.018074659630656242,
-0.042084354907274246,
0.025958791375160217,
0.1910490244626999,
0.008682084269821644,
0.20823591947555542,
-0.658122181892395,
-0.0645565614104271,
0.409873366355896,
-0.32176342606544495,
-0.4033757150173187,
0.4094683527946472,
0.3540465533733368,
-0.16923286020755768,
0.49905818700790405,
-0.024141283705830574,
-0.556532621383667,
0.32650429010391235,
0.7303474545478821,
0.7485907077789307,
-0.2105877846479416,
0.24928274750709534,
0.5309235453605652,
0.30075743794441223,
-0.35516712069511414,
-0.07105056941509247,
0.16753868758678436,
-0.6425105333328247,
-0.7624441385269165,
-0.9013791680335999,
-0.4814569056034088,
0.284305602312088,
-0.48667222261428833,
0.4899764358997345,
-0.40150320529937744,
-0.06982501596212387,
-0.20067258179187775,
-0.06096041575074196,
-0.7658974528312683,
0.09685094654560089,
0.3101799190044403,
0.8387824892997742,
-1.2474583387374878,
0.6920201182365417,
0.6906757354736328,
-0.32911503314971924,
-1.1402976512908936,
0.12915173172950745,
0.1911260485649109,
-0.6753497123718262,
0.6323073506355286,
0.24115344882011414,
-0.3519817292690277,
0.2564409375190735,
-0.6217524409294128,
-0.8818578124046326,
0.5890935063362122,
0.4092887043952942,
-0.7228065729141235,
0.034750796854496,
0.16240710020065308,
0.730021059513092,
0.1223534569144249,
0.3000929355621338,
0.8182945847511292,
0.6032029390335083,
0.30353495478630066,
-1.2492904663085938,
-0.06626443564891815,
-0.05938161537051201,
0.03856091573834419,
0.17104679346084595,
-0.8182256817817688,
0.6593191027641296,
-0.04684606194496155,
-0.25736749172210693,
0.13933803141117096,
0.41499850153923035,
-0.07142285257577896,
-0.02614925429224968,
0.33042725920677185,
0.3592836260795593,
0.48101502656936646,
-0.15678884088993073,
1.2407268285751343,
-0.10922329872846603,
0.19945882260799408,
0.793002188205719,
-0.4568851888179779,
1.025372862815857,
0.30728912353515625,
-0.1250084787607193,
0.3233685791492462,
0.5641992092132568,
0.22505949437618256,
0.5198522210121155,
-0.030571389943361282,
0.06310228258371353,
-0.18493075668811798,
-0.27665576338768005,
-0.15527009963989258,
0.49041253328323364,
0.015706472098827362,
-0.24682502448558807,
-0.23385247588157654,
0.30302268266677856,
0.4863196313381195,
-0.017058078199625015,
-0.44267478585243225,
0.9261578917503357,
0.25944983959198,
-0.6459137201309204,
0.6530433893203735,
-0.14242242276668549,
1.0099804401397705,
-0.6043163537979126,
0.015762999653816223,
-0.4493608772754669,
0.05016696825623512,
-0.2586628198623657,
-1.146002173423767,
0.2775063216686249,
0.23345619440078735,
0.038233593106269836,
-0.6516123414039612,
0.9817678928375244,
-0.5327125787734985,
-0.40866827964782715,
0.030992530286312103,
0.47159430384635925,
0.33548980951309204,
0.06008967012166977,
-0.4275476038455963,
0.11824900656938553,
-0.07432737946510315,
-0.31235358119010925,
0.49470973014831543,
0.4799220561981201,
-0.17745700478553772,
0.5208669304847717,
0.523884117603302,
0.4514375329017639,
-0.02108023129403591,
0.4206268787384033,
0.465798020362854,
-0.4832645058631897,
-0.25119590759277344,
-1.0463664531707764,
0.2386743426322937,
0.042723480612039566,
-0.1529649794101715,
0.9078818559646606,
0.198099285364151,
0.6447757482528687,
-0.16637355089187622,
0.8150290846824646,
0.19140231609344482,
0.401670902967453,
-0.7776567339897156,
1.0634338855743408,
-0.5374098420143127,
-0.12149091064929962,
-0.44300320744514465,
-1.0758717060089111,
-0.4014144837856293,
0.6340039968490601,
-0.5911179780960083,
0.2977759838104248,
0.6949398517608643,
0.6931519508361816,
0.0234477948397398,
-0.05894942209124565,
0.5100675821304321,
0.3402261435985565,
0.4827975928783417,
0.40466800332069397,
0.8078188300132751,
-0.07414333522319794,
0.4545474648475647,
-0.2283056229352951,
-0.1449531614780426,
-0.23008914291858673,
-1.1127386093139648,
-0.8707024455070496,
-0.5037087202072144,
-0.2079099416732788,
-0.16984960436820984,
0.1131218746304512,
0.9038947820663452,
0.7487954497337341,
-0.5212054252624512,
-0.05924126133322716,
0.1699441522359848,
-0.20338432490825653,
0.07723097503185272,
-0.24717594683170319,
0.3719722032546997,
-0.3925621807575226,
-0.9329239130020142,
0.1133958175778389,
0.23513589799404144,
0.23621980845928192,
-0.24028024077415466,
0.3320115804672241,
-0.1169607937335968,
0.3569287359714508,
0.8596716523170471,
0.006076865829527378,
-0.48356932401657104,
-0.6439211368560791,
-0.14555330574512482,
-0.5338817834854126,
0.014264416880905628,
0.8149750232696533,
-0.3975406885147095,
0.2691915035247803,
0.6824104189872742,
0.7249774932861328,
0.19748874008655548,
0.09981217235326767,
0.40094876289367676,
-0.7989979386329651,
-0.060216762125492096,
-0.010660853236913681,
0.3038359582424164,
0.7460362911224365,
-0.29168501496315,
0.4765028655529022,
0.07219935208559036,
-0.6869165897369385,
-0.7733973860740662,
0.013686256483197212,
-0.945529580116272,
-0.230737566947937,
1.7573633193969727,
0.07151206582784653,
-0.3060404062271118,
0.05782647058367729,
-0.49316170811653137,
0.3177899122238159,
-0.3245748281478882,
0.5697433352470398,
0.9814049005508423,
-0.06844772398471832,
-0.26147735118865967,
-0.7022522687911987,
0.516859233379364,
0.39677125215530396,
-1.0203144550323486,
0.23114673793315887,
0.3917555510997772,
0.5390210151672363,
-0.08440113812685013,
0.6429805755615234,
-0.09465518593788147,
0.01968654803931713,
-0.4477415382862091,
-0.013348842039704323,
0.0871504619717598,
-0.4639984965324402,
-0.5175893306732178,
-0.10087566077709198,
0.27318525314331055,
0.37043389678001404
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.05881v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.05881v2
|
LGR2: Language Guided Reward Relabeling for Accelerating Hierarchical Reinforcement Learning
| 2024-06-09T18:40:24 | 2024-06-16T10:28:45 |
Utsav Singh, Pramit Bhattacharyya, Vinay P. Namboodiri
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.RO
|
Developing interactive systems that leverage natural language instructions to
solve complex robotic control tasks has been a long-desired goal in the
robotics community. Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated exceptional
abilities in handling complex tasks, including logical reasoning, in-context
learning, and code generation. However, predicting low-level robotic actions
using LLMs poses significant challenges. Additionally, the complexity of such
tasks usually demands the acquisition of policies to execute diverse subtasks
and combine them to attain the ultimate objective. Hierarchical Reinforcement
Learning (HRL) is an elegant approach for solving such tasks, which provides
the intuitive benefits of temporal abstraction and improved exploration.
However, HRL faces the recurring issue of non-stationarity due to unstable
lower primitive behaviour. In this work, we propose LGR2, a novel HRL framework
that leverages language instructions to generate a stationary reward function
for the higher-level policy. Since the language-guided reward is unaffected by
the lower primitive behaviour, LGR2 mitigates non-stationarity and is thus an
elegant method for leveraging language instructions to solve robotic control
tasks. To analyze the efficacy of our approach, we perform empirical analysis
and demonstrate that LGR2 effectively alleviates non-stationarity in HRL. Our
approach attains success rates exceeding 70$\%$ in challenging, sparse-reward
robotic navigation and manipulation environments where the baselines fail to
achieve any significant progress. Additionally, we conduct real-world robotic
manipulation experiments and demonstrate that CRISP shows impressive
generalization in real-world scenarios.
|
[
0.14803530275821686,
-0.8924797773361206,
0.3058072328567505,
0.16727325320243835,
-0.00400513643398881,
0.41255930066108704,
-0.3181714117527008,
-0.28251972794532776,
0.09491287171840668,
0.15087224543094635,
-0.7060220241546631,
-0.2972491383552551,
-0.7130632996559143,
-0.30562281608581543,
0.3471277952194214,
1.1615430116653442,
-0.25018879771232605,
-0.25239691138267517,
-0.19471827149391174,
0.13359573483467102,
-0.20626232028007507,
-0.3741949796676636,
-0.7115796208381653,
-0.9699540138244629,
0.8328325152397156,
0.5233412384986877,
0.8195887804031372,
0.6947183609008789,
0.46165648102760315,
0.20856446027755737,
-0.2885548174381256,
0.2190139889717102,
-0.6976600885391235,
0.09958472102880478,
-0.11449732631444931,
-0.4775337278842926,
-0.37496230006217957,
-0.21461354196071625,
0.48090240359306335,
0.5801389217376709,
-0.5355007648468018,
-0.14783792197704315,
0.17874282598495483,
0.8985732197761536,
-0.47276413440704346,
0.7223832607269287,
-0.3513545095920563,
0.29299455881118774,
0.011445094831287861,
-0.43241384625434875,
-0.3186734914779663,
-0.24446767568588257,
-0.12028538435697556,
-0.830518364906311,
-0.23967351019382477,
0.00007701862341491506,
0.8539766073226929,
0.597611129283905,
-0.23049454391002655,
-0.16969162225723267,
-0.5546227097511292,
0.9658331871032715,
-0.45449987053871155,
0.3073767125606537,
0.4831133484840393,
0.4583187401294708,
-0.45807909965515137,
-0.6471121907234192,
-0.1371859908103943,
-0.6382083892822266,
-0.23068596422672272,
0.2749200463294983,
-0.21524961292743683,
0.2495695948600769,
0.26115891337394714,
-0.08007977157831192,
-0.5994294285774231,
0.4352121949195862,
-0.16899175941944122,
-0.17603255808353424,
0.15257549285888672,
0.006801447365432978,
0.09794776886701584,
-0.11299172788858414,
-0.6264747977256775,
-0.2521386444568634,
-0.6879226565361023,
0.77256178855896,
0.33141905069351196,
0.32389387488365173,
-0.26399701833724976,
0.46918806433677673,
-0.3707265257835388,
0.2480674684047699,
0.24321496486663818,
-0.4361352026462555,
0.36374449729919434,
0.01767786405980587,
-0.1103161871433258,
-0.03790495917201042,
0.5349649786949158,
0.2631860077381134,
0.05993784964084625,
-0.3925383687019348,
-0.49711135029792786,
-0.2831028997898102,
0.1865580677986145,
-0.5410073399543762,
-0.23471787571907043,
0.3707406520843506,
-0.5260933637619019,
-0.29147595167160034,
-0.2726868987083435,
-0.73110032081604,
-0.226994588971138,
-0.37148118019104004,
0.26991093158721924,
-0.1700471192598343,
-0.1668146550655365,
-0.005841437261551619,
-0.19533635675907135,
0.276746928691864,
0.40677890181541443,
-1.246493935585022,
0.11734279990196228,
0.8064063191413879,
0.7448693513870239,
-0.0157304760068655,
-0.3746933043003082,
-1.0243130922317505,
0.23993773758411407,
-0.3733927309513092,
0.666779637336731,
-0.4591304361820221,
-0.3060612976551056,
0.10634288191795349,
0.12086741626262665,
0.0815247893333435,
-0.6548166275024414,
0.34829333424568176,
-0.6549380421638489,
0.25856420397758484,
-0.16823498904705048,
0.004470594227313995,
0.04432949796319008,
0.42012813687324524,
-0.43384072184562683,
1.1962834596633911,
0.42961472272872925,
-0.376868337392807,
0.2566152513027191,
-0.5373053550720215,
-0.42500633001327515,
0.19347187876701355,
-0.1346069723367691,
-0.39908546209335327,
-0.2723075747489929,
0.014606449753046036,
0.04308319836854935,
-0.20555439591407776,
0.5422521233558655,
0.05797126516699791,
-0.3164689540863037,
-0.25608277320861816,
-0.1985068917274475,
0.13360565900802612,
0.008059022016823292,
-0.6890751123428345,
0.5130910277366638,
-0.12431886047124863,
0.2725568413734436,
0.097273088991642,
-0.674518883228302,
0.020727016031742096,
0.31777289509773254,
-0.11049001663923264,
0.2129858434200287,
0.5703203678131104,
-0.12628696858882904,
0.4876967668533325,
-0.3858746588230133,
0.1795046329498291,
0.8115529417991638,
-0.24710386991500854,
0.6594879031181335,
-0.43572530150413513,
0.6417444348335266,
-0.3875303268432617,
0.114549420773983,
0.04990328475832939,
-0.32952794432640076,
-0.428223580121994,
-0.28217601776123047,
0.12654419243335724,
0.9268436431884766,
-1.2124379873275757,
0.527093231678009,
-0.08861417323350906,
-0.19644443690776825,
-0.050863467156887054,
0.1232474222779274,
0.7672653198242188,
0.3445565402507782,
0.5497138500213623,
-0.06317255645990372,
-0.26181522011756897,
-0.8565622568130493,
-0.15961216390132904,
-0.4700290858745575,
-0.3878556787967682,
0.445157915353775,
0.35802173614501953,
-0.3250126838684082,
0.5705317854881287,
-0.12234464287757874,
-0.40204209089279175,
-0.5280530452728271,
0.6845689415931702,
0.15005458891391754,
0.4576192796230316,
0.19994688034057617,
-0.43425777554512024,
-0.059617120772600174,
0.19076977670192719,
-0.7416143417358398,
-0.2567565441131592,
-0.37862181663513184,
-0.0840066522359848,
0.3978045582771301,
0.5258337259292603,
-0.5216448903083801,
0.15773151814937592,
0.5182370543479919,
0.01642812043428421,
0.31018850207328796,
-0.4836728274822235,
-0.19720467925071716,
-0.32636669278144836,
0.014250894077122211,
-0.16445614397525787,
-0.22200345993041992,
-0.509471595287323,
0.07998773455619812,
-0.015156760811805725,
0.15832173824310303,
-0.31512248516082764,
0.43224039673805237,
-0.23652394115924835,
-0.11289452761411667,
-0.5988517999649048,
0.10511860996484756,
-0.4284093677997589,
1.0708425045013428,
0.4424394369125366,
0.4968717694282532,
0.2878531515598297,
-0.38027384877204895,
0.10466922074556351,
0.039819132536649704,
-0.09657499939203262,
0.011740078218281269,
-0.8002321124076843,
0.01391313411295414,
-0.29782724380493164,
0.5086052417755127,
-0.694755494594574,
-0.23662100732326508,
0.5667213797569275,
-0.46123066544532776,
0.3807489275932312,
-0.3230474293231964,
-0.410778284072876,
-0.09006091207265854,
-0.2420165240764618,
0.2144010365009308,
0.8999650478363037,
-0.5689354538917542,
0.49074265360832214,
0.26723557710647583,
-0.22838525474071503,
-0.7422127723693848,
-0.5484373569488525,
-0.07937426120042801,
0.07912997156381607,
-0.18092161417007446,
0.36651667952537537,
0.2444363683462143,
-0.20225584506988525,
-0.10024899244308472,
-0.359920471906662,
0.25363150238990784,
0.04335315153002739,
0.15455906093120575,
0.1843108832836151,
0.16729697585105896,
0.058003850281238556,
0.255813866853714,
-0.5185347199440002,
0.2559362053871155,
-0.27348434925079346,
0.5993055701255798,
-0.02638242579996586,
-0.2778167724609375,
-0.5292110443115234,
0.08100180327892303,
0.3994373083114624,
-0.06174781918525696,
0.5659903287887573,
0.7688379287719727,
-0.18794184923171997,
-0.30999475717544556,
0.07896918058395386,
-0.29053524136543274,
-0.5256378650665283,
0.6096410751342773,
-0.12610948085784912,
-1.005375862121582,
0.04196842014789581,
-0.4029258191585541,
0.3820303976535797,
0.12493658810853958,
0.6996474862098694,
-0.15487685799598694,
0.7407524585723877,
0.46002838015556335,
-0.034129031002521515,
0.6713860034942627,
-0.14095726609230042,
0.2687843441963196,
-0.5999493598937988,
-0.9064304828643799,
-0.31514763832092285,
-0.6151261925697327,
-0.7138408422470093,
-0.878002405166626,
0.42925992608070374,
0.2942945063114166,
-0.35217803716659546,
0.1625732034444809,
-0.2886230945587158,
0.4209325313568115,
0.5343347191810608,
0.03502965718507767,
-0.09405745565891266,
0.18497928977012634,
-0.11439141631126404,
-0.04284053295850754,
-0.8466658592224121,
-0.4081611931324005,
0.4247046113014221,
0.5918974876403809,
0.9413865208625793,
0.21790072321891785,
0.5712769031524658,
0.5127856731414795,
0.059136781841516495,
-0.9724439382553101,
0.45981353521347046,
-0.12436925619840622,
0.03766326606273651,
-0.48917725682258606,
-0.4617810547351837,
-1.075154423713684,
0.26774197816848755,
-0.01940922811627388,
-0.7423546314239502,
0.10456980019807816,
0.31216034293174744,
-0.2144642472267151,
0.22812201082706451,
-0.4911375641822815,
0.7015933990478516,
-0.4827343821525574,
-0.7235910892486572,
-0.2480693757534027,
-1.0468242168426514,
0.15765629708766937,
0.3187371790409088,
0.2011694461107254,
-0.16505077481269836,
-0.24108587205410004,
0.59112948179245,
-0.1459043323993683,
0.851699948310852,
-0.563503086566925,
-0.2847888767719269,
0.007152351550757885,
0.34793782234191895,
1.1373308897018433,
0.12100342661142349,
0.2776009738445282,
0.022685877978801727,
-0.3626396059989929,
-0.47180986404418945,
-0.7118825912475586,
0.5401376485824585,
-0.7907400131225586,
-0.45946404337882996,
-0.47337502241134644,
-0.8185291886329651,
-0.26561933755874634,
-0.1176326721906662,
-0.25919920206069946,
0.20006678998470306,
0.20074738562107086,
0.1757436841726303,
0.7008492946624756,
-0.47106266021728516,
0.40465047955513,
0.5131078958511353,
-0.2788274586200714,
-0.36896955966949463,
0.8803399205207825,
-0.3798128366470337,
0.5942088961601257,
0.785214900970459,
0.1379988193511963,
-0.4120003283023834,
-0.323794960975647,
-0.46497249603271484,
-0.029614156112074852,
-0.3991755247116089,
-0.027746668085455894,
-0.5580701231956482,
-0.18508008122444153,
0.07368527352809906,
-0.43196842074394226,
-0.2806147038936615,
-0.5605922937393188,
-0.08107459545135498,
0.0033158212900161743,
0.23173393309116364,
0.5776443481445312,
-0.39356401562690735,
0.42108678817749023,
-0.538872480392456,
0.6387190222740173,
0.3799794912338257,
0.17173856496810913,
-0.252671480178833,
-0.6377257108688354,
-0.18653598427772522,
0.2564898431301117,
-0.2038356214761734,
-0.3331763744354248,
0.46374303102493286,
-0.12108282744884491,
0.6552153825759888,
0.2593189775943756,
-0.2490890622138977,
0.6350484490394592,
-0.5203843712806702,
0.6987249255180359,
0.20806771516799927,
-0.6607796549797058,
0.4693911075592041,
-0.554839551448822,
0.33694350719451904,
0.27932149171829224,
0.25611886382102966,
-0.5296815037727356,
-0.21921426057815552,
-0.48149752616882324,
-1.224165439605713,
0.9371017813682556,
0.15975050628185272,
-0.18238911032676697,
0.18966369330883026,
0.29946666955947876,
-0.012226365506649017,
0.24939411878585815,
-0.7714604139328003,
-0.20941713452339172,
-0.1449877917766571,
0.13962958753108978,
-0.06764742732048035,
-0.2236635684967041,
-0.26104000210762024,
0.017172520980238914,
0.5605151653289795,
-0.24270837008953094,
0.6009967923164368,
-0.10647343844175339,
0.13191182911396027,
-0.4150988459587097,
0.3693823218345642,
0.6969766616821289,
0.12676513195037842,
-0.39769190549850464,
0.010445977561175823,
-0.026492519304156303,
-0.07896850258111954,
0.16020910441875458,
0.020357219502329826,
-0.023029932752251625,
-0.20264175534248352,
0.45045745372772217,
0.8090292811393738,
0.26333242654800415,
-0.8272823691368103,
0.20191079378128052,
0.33193978667259216,
-0.4437127709388733,
-0.1910998672246933,
0.09969596564769745,
-0.0913788229227066,
0.36442115902900696,
0.3470427393913269,
0.13838723301887512,
-0.17276588082313538,
-0.6586459279060364,
0.30462002754211426,
0.5216155648231506,
-0.5671246647834778,
-0.20826174318790436,
0.6147821545600891,
0.09373373538255692,
-0.3866528570652008,
0.5069536566734314,
-0.5263697504997253,
-0.5982835292816162,
0.7792989015579224,
0.6253852844238281,
0.7758808732032776,
0.10834052413702011,
0.4875950813293457,
0.5730453133583069,
0.5544795989990234,
-0.24299441277980804,
0.3055989146232605,
-0.4040299654006958,
-0.5468025207519531,
-0.4894680976867676,
-0.4165228307247162,
-0.6414263844490051,
-0.1409456729888916,
-0.6089062094688416,
-0.19192375242710114,
-0.5996490120887756,
0.18409323692321777,
-0.5803351402282715,
-0.15380863845348358,
-0.008936366066336632,
-0.18097186088562012,
0.266364187002182,
0.5757133960723877,
-0.6379541754722595,
0.9525538086891174,
0.42457854747772217,
-0.08212315291166306,
-0.7751783728599548,
0.18248756229877472,
0.1395372599363327,
-0.9491419196128845,
1.0645338296890259,
0.0036953315138816833,
-0.5518997311592102,
-0.19120225310325623,
-0.5183317065238953,
-0.8215590119361877,
1.299025297164917,
-0.01080706063657999,
-0.7294794917106628,
-0.164186492562294,
0.08749362081289291,
0.69255530834198,
-0.0541718564927578,
0.2662159204483032,
0.47706910967826843,
0.7042853832244873,
0.5151383876800537,
-0.9589833617210388,
-0.15016798675060272,
-0.16813142597675323,
0.005982967093586922,
0.5360932946205139,
-0.7641752362251282,
0.6620252132415771,
-0.48083069920539856,
-0.2122599333524704,
0.2719869017601013,
0.5418033599853516,
0.7823716402053833,
0.25570958852767944,
0.4167485535144806,
0.43822360038757324,
0.744330108165741,
-0.34446796774864197,
1.0436604022979736,
-0.13757039606571198,
0.4604044258594513,
0.9781462550163269,
-0.4010631740093231,
0.8167054653167725,
0.6865229606628418,
-0.1766761690378189,
0.7800201177597046,
0.4693589210510254,
0.26433607935905457,
0.9302242994308472,
0.4509502351284027,
-0.10988788306713104,
-0.2456027716398239,
-0.42833006381988525,
-0.30824851989746094,
0.13433654606342316,
0.34112563729286194,
0.013627112843096256,
-0.4191301763057709,
-0.09417349845170975,
0.1361885666847229,
0.05787539854645729,
-0.24536466598510742,
0.6912841796875,
-0.2042047381401062,
-0.7719336748123169,
0.7386050820350647,
0.20376916229724884,
0.6542140245437622,
-0.9460973143577576,
-0.3207847476005554,
-0.20443417131900787,
0.23338143527507782,
-0.10091649740934372,
-0.7215701341629028,
0.17795100808143616,
-0.03677303344011307,
-0.015597750432789326,
-0.8680180311203003,
0.40659013390541077,
-0.6129590272903442,
0.03564496710896492,
0.4022250175476074,
0.5815815329551697,
0.007180558983236551,
0.460620254278183,
-0.7493799924850464,
-0.292224258184433,
0.11858831346035004,
-0.1696893572807312,
0.60659259557724,
0.3128819465637207,
-0.07590483129024506,
0.9066430330276489,
0.6703413128852844,
-0.13335326313972473,
-0.24310655891895294,
-0.00819098949432373,
0.8233394622802734,
-0.5757669806480408,
-0.40309157967567444,
-0.43819373846054077,
0.5211927890777588,
0.3720598518848419,
-0.06507831811904907,
0.47603878378868103,
0.43875637650489807,
0.7026454210281372,
-0.03514784947037697,
0.4837401509284973,
-0.38618311285972595,
0.21818450093269348,
-0.8823763728141785,
0.27775776386260986,
-0.5791992545127869,
0.31081679463386536,
0.2539251744747162,
-0.45866692066192627,
-0.31126195192337036,
0.6101735830307007,
-0.2362137734889984,
0.19027525186538696,
0.824359118938446,
0.9975892305374146,
0.31540536880493164,
-0.46021631360054016,
0.330113023519516,
-0.02613900788128376,
0.29882311820983887,
0.9730706214904785,
1.0700767040252686,
-0.05429007485508919,
0.4275713860988617,
-0.2187567502260208,
-0.23551778495311737,
-0.05057157576084137,
-0.6861962676048279,
-0.7427687048912048,
-0.12842781841754913,
-0.2357526570558548,
-0.34372666478157043,
0.47372469305992126,
1.2888964414596558,
0.4779598116874695,
-0.5876867175102234,
-0.3404240012168884,
-0.361939936876297,
0.23763518035411835,
-0.5841917991638184,
-0.21022464334964752,
0.21698907017707825,
-0.6685196161270142,
-0.6109476089477539,
0.7871137261390686,
0.5069980621337891,
-0.150969460606575,
-0.020789846777915955,
-0.5563172698020935,
-0.01635321043431759,
-0.31593504548072815,
0.5549235939979553,
0.6512548327445984,
-0.902285099029541,
-0.1629008948802948,
0.014458044432103634,
-0.21063928306102753,
0.1680118292570114,
0.9339343309402466,
-0.9359583258628845,
0.18227481842041016,
0.5221328735351562,
0.568091094493866,
0.24914325773715973,
0.20013310015201569,
0.30614718794822693,
-0.7283596396446228,
0.36677417159080505,
0.1958889663219452,
0.14433777332305908,
-0.09272921830415726,
-0.2781386971473694,
0.46065449714660645,
0.15144053101539612,
-0.8169520497322083,
-0.5063429474830627,
0.3432316780090332,
-1.1768475770950317,
-0.18140873312950134,
1.5456624031066895,
-0.009245515801012516,
-0.16785621643066406,
-0.059951458126306534,
-0.2317419946193695,
0.0720987319946289,
-0.7651689052581787,
0.8726575374603271,
0.14391565322875977,
-0.23326991498470306,
-0.26643678545951843,
-0.676214337348938,
0.6154407858848572,
0.5794289112091064,
-0.8826655745506287,
0.09173957258462906,
0.47376763820648193,
-0.14606818556785583,
-0.0340554416179657,
0.4272637963294983,
-0.08031005412340164,
0.47145503759384155,
-0.1792420744895935,
0.2714741826057434,
-0.27142611145973206,
-0.5950295925140381,
-0.41695618629455566,
0.21884779632091522,
0.1761893928050995,
-0.1930638700723648
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.05876v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.05876v1
|
Zero-Shot End-To-End Spoken Question Answering In Medical Domain
| 2024-06-09T18:13:36 | 2024-06-09T18:13:36 |
Yanis Labrak, Adel Moumen, Richard Dufour, Mickael Rouvier
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
In the rapidly evolving landscape of spoken question-answering (SQA), the
integration of large language models (LLMs) has emerged as a transformative
development. Conventional approaches often entail the use of separate models
for question audio transcription and answer selection, resulting in significant
resource utilization and error accumulation. To tackle these challenges, we
explore the effectiveness of end-to-end (E2E) methodologies for SQA in the
medical domain. Our study introduces a novel zero-shot SQA approach, compared
to traditional cascade systems. Through a comprehensive evaluation conducted on
a new open benchmark of 8 medical tasks and 48 hours of synthetic audio, we
demonstrate that our approach requires up to 14.7 times fewer resources than a
combined 1.3B parameters LLM with a 1.55B parameters ASR model while improving
average accuracy by 0.5\%. These findings underscore the potential of E2E
methodologies for SQA in resource-constrained contexts.
|
[
-0.24406786262989044,
-0.9411102533340454,
0.9443550705909729,
-0.1574297547340393,
-0.37209221720695496,
0.16773304343223572,
-0.11101055145263672,
-0.716846764087677,
0.3563370108604431,
0.300139456987381,
-0.6121557354927063,
-0.33921194076538086,
-0.5357308983802795,
0.1579793393611908,
-0.15402011573314667,
0.6177272200584412,
-0.09111227840185165,
0.3450399339199066,
-0.4330465793609619,
-0.3518720865249634,
-0.7183032035827637,
-0.4342626631259918,
-0.9267217516899109,
-0.09189625084400177,
0.546640157699585,
0.6405617594718933,
0.5483413934707642,
0.4144402742385864,
0.16807246208190918,
0.13504227995872498,
-0.23377680778503418,
-0.06699543446302414,
-0.39903607964515686,
0.3916154205799103,
0.0025961287319660187,
-0.535172164440155,
-0.3845131993293762,
-0.019440101459622383,
0.23301471769809723,
0.7813413143157959,
-0.3415030837059021,
0.4674864411354065,
-0.5254804491996765,
0.44773200154304504,
-0.5950956344604492,
-0.34249311685562134,
-0.34412676095962524,
0.11188264936208725,
0.13251562416553497,
-0.43739083409309387,
-0.335848331451416,
0.04101906716823578,
0.259468138217926,
-0.6867331862449646,
-0.12692385911941528,
-0.14355304837226868,
0.5126527547836304,
0.3343106806278229,
-0.3517429232597351,
-0.22965170443058014,
-1.0466879606246948,
0.5751588344573975,
-0.8375889658927917,
0.3789368271827698,
0.262784481048584,
0.6209607124328613,
0.12892715632915497,
-0.6836510896682739,
-0.6225194931030273,
0.06361652910709381,
0.44511106610298157,
0.45574823021888733,
-0.4434564411640167,
0.19390657544136047,
0.07131267338991165,
0.01945658214390278,
-0.7657968401908875,
0.335691899061203,
-0.4869977533817291,
0.12255649268627167,
0.378688782453537,
0.0839952602982521,
0.5310589671134949,
0.022989867255091667,
-0.2271067500114441,
0.3148007392883301,
-0.7457697987556458,
0.0027846437878906727,
-0.3306160569190979,
-0.038652483373880386,
0.00789970438927412,
0.7594626545906067,
-0.34195107221603394,
0.5621206760406494,
-0.1260666847229004,
0.037724804133176804,
-0.04862154647707939,
-0.1863211691379547,
-0.5814395546913147,
-0.024292215704917908,
0.5916944146156311,
0.5115744471549988,
0.10268834978342056,
-0.2912311851978302,
-0.01732293888926506,
-0.26663073897361755,
0.07662802189588547,
-0.9530549645423889,
0.4101269841194153,
0.8176382184028625,
-0.2770531475543976,
-0.045583680272102356,
-0.6566546559333801,
-0.5181964039802551,
-0.10925998538732529,
-0.2127048820257187,
0.6358286142349243,
-0.4422255754470825,
-0.19351698458194733,
0.36579570174217224,
-0.08565442264080048,
0.6515476703643799,
0.30206918716430664,
-0.5852802395820618,
0.4943881928920746,
0.5699220299720764,
1.0008964538574219,
0.20744061470031738,
0.4257432818412781,
-0.5760412812232971,
0.05518971383571625,
-0.5854789018630981,
0.8785560131072998,
-0.40207090973854065,
-0.613486111164093,
-0.08222687989473343,
-0.2560986280441284,
-0.032087817788124084,
-0.7124010324478149,
0.5418835282325745,
-0.5010377168655396,
0.5709185004234314,
-0.07877863943576813,
-0.6253361701965332,
-0.1969381421804428,
-0.001289921929128468,
-0.2847660183906555,
0.7072847485542297,
0.2925622761249542,
-0.022387787699699402,
0.1362917125225067,
-0.679023802280426,
-0.31388020515441895,
0.22133706510066986,
-0.4255995452404022,
-0.23669607937335968,
0.3749605715274811,
0.3985595107078552,
0.27556905150413513,
-0.7560636401176453,
0.16868466138839722,
-0.05678876116871834,
-0.33658358454704285,
0.41175228357315063,
-0.5666295289993286,
0.669160008430481,
0.2446003258228302,
-0.23067936301231384,
-0.021179260686039925,
-0.6729021072387695,
0.1995972841978073,
0.31578612327575684,
0.11810119450092316,
-0.22836393117904663,
-0.29380956292152405,
0.0609411895275116,
0.5266233682632446,
0.07068322598934174,
-0.902543306350708,
-0.10545933991670609,
-0.45269811153411865,
0.43789708614349365,
0.21432891488075256,
0.345447301864624,
0.2548936903476715,
-0.5258073806762695,
0.8467331528663635,
-0.13650870323181152,
0.4369311034679413,
-0.19342179596424103,
-0.6605744957923889,
-0.49995043873786926,
-0.3535318672657013,
0.18468165397644043,
0.75013267993927,
-0.4850737452507019,
0.03476479649543762,
-0.1530720293521881,
-0.3951150178909302,
-0.9010027647018433,
-0.2688240110874176,
0.44785580039024353,
0.6083520650863647,
0.5654826164245605,
-0.37410807609558105,
-0.45486366748809814,
-0.8110948801040649,
0.03870250657200813,
-0.29202619194984436,
-0.4540819525718689,
0.7111671566963196,
0.04125569760799408,
0.05486154928803444,
0.9052121639251709,
-0.41382327675819397,
-0.18175850808620453,
-0.20154763758182526,
-0.12256887555122375,
0.36141157150268555,
-0.07063829898834229,
0.3418624997138977,
-0.38891470432281494,
-0.510995626449585,
0.0035740609746426344,
-0.8589859008789062,
-0.4688238799571991,
-0.48232072591781616,
0.06288807094097137,
0.1577165126800537,
0.2937261164188385,
-0.7772302627563477,
0.2240549772977829,
0.34082600474357605,
-0.27353888750076294,
0.4147500693798065,
-0.2011922299861908,
0.1732519268989563,
-1.093152403831482,
0.23880353569984436,
-0.004204682540148497,
-0.38071608543395996,
-1.1858264207839966,
0.09105991572141647,
-0.08631386607885361,
-0.34156471490859985,
-0.5296711325645447,
0.4982403516769409,
-0.6645767092704773,
-0.130299910902977,
-0.39177826046943665,
0.2930285334587097,
0.06966263055801392,
0.36482661962509155,
-0.02773226983845234,
0.8113683462142944,
0.503982663154602,
-0.15910892188549042,
0.3030162453651428,
0.32078638672828674,
0.17938384413719177,
0.7590222358703613,
-1.1053237915039062,
0.34970295429229736,
-0.19146643579006195,
0.23475083708763123,
-0.9094391465187073,
-0.04203053563833237,
0.11151451617479324,
-0.8283672332763672,
0.5980917811393738,
-0.03193740174174309,
-0.09780823439359665,
-0.16243122518062592,
-0.14404426515102386,
0.6470491886138916,
0.7598608136177063,
-0.014491415582597256,
0.2859351336956024,
0.4067365229129791,
-0.761150062084198,
-0.39817461371421814,
-0.4414297938346863,
0.4680889844894409,
0.037578508257865906,
-0.5589422583580017,
0.17033441364765167,
-0.023258676752448082,
-0.14017008244991302,
-0.1930476725101471,
-0.41634443402290344,
-0.2717396020889282,
-0.2710686922073364,
0.07547134906053543,
0.24412107467651367,
-0.3928375542163849,
0.07395940274000168,
0.257677286863327,
-0.2079508900642395,
0.009203088469803333,
-0.2451983094215393,
0.389535516500473,
0.5144519209861755,
-0.6615736484527588,
-0.8304896950721741,
0.9478709101676941,
0.8636109828948975,
-0.17080017924308777,
0.5211921334266663,
0.045981865376234055,
-0.5974916219711304,
0.02548612840473652,
-0.6254829168319702,
-0.15235111117362976,
-0.3531401753425598,
0.5680609941482544,
-0.07629256695508957,
-0.73445725440979,
0.4914434552192688,
-0.028012048453092575,
0.18288764357566833,
0.17143315076828003,
0.697842538356781,
-0.3861607611179352,
0.6380830407142639,
0.292900949716568,
0.14182314276695251,
0.03898875415325165,
-0.14716075360774994,
0.3238394260406494,
-0.8682522177696228,
-0.5100595951080322,
-0.3065938949584961,
-0.2229454219341278,
-0.09010709077119827,
-0.9889129996299744,
0.9074499011039734,
0.2493661493062973,
-0.1163235604763031,
0.14382366836071014,
-0.4998599588871002,
0.2674320638179779,
0.37354692816734314,
0.09896437078714371,
0.26095160841941833,
-0.13162855803966522,
0.2099931240081787,
0.16242729127407074,
-0.7791802883148193,
-0.2480660378932953,
1.1461542844772339,
0.5425436496734619,
0.2811930179595947,
0.2486223429441452,
0.5299145579338074,
-0.147380068898201,
-0.009049111045897007,
-0.893161952495575,
0.4654812812805176,
0.08537392318248749,
-0.5456881523132324,
-0.8805732131004333,
-0.016753261908888817,
-0.6803120374679565,
0.33754342794418335,
-0.00004996986172045581,
-0.4825643002986908,
0.17372837662696838,
-0.22076201438903809,
-0.8411649465560913,
0.18283504247665405,
-0.4792744219303131,
0.501153826713562,
-0.12015523761510849,
-0.2539220154285431,
-0.11391463875770569,
-0.8284371495246887,
-0.05561767891049385,
-0.17334820330142975,
0.1665358543395996,
-0.15935486555099487,
-0.3813006579875946,
0.6025293469429016,
-0.6255396008491516,
0.6788149476051331,
-0.38444432616233826,
-0.23786771297454834,
0.5113773941993713,
-0.10655640810728073,
0.5044286251068115,
0.058678846806287766,
-0.06893045455217361,
0.296701043844223,
0.275400847196579,
-0.44922131299972534,
-0.7880510091781616,
0.2598676383495331,
-0.7121773958206177,
-0.49726906418800354,
-0.3777748644351959,
-0.5260868668556213,
-0.5953800082206726,
-0.05208578705787659,
0.16456836462020874,
0.5578323602676392,
-0.26947328448295593,
0.05908157303929329,
0.6360100507736206,
-0.6904093027114868,
0.3884873688220978,
0.8367021083831787,
0.12525807321071625,
-0.427753746509552,
0.5316252112388611,
0.3563002943992615,
0.5282661318778992,
0.4883401095867157,
0.0190719086676836,
-0.5249344706535339,
-0.8073570728302002,
-0.9055222272872925,
0.4240938723087311,
-0.23238135874271393,
-0.336370587348938,
-0.7328584790229797,
-0.5215140581130981,
-0.4528895318508148,
-0.15575234591960907,
-0.3016285002231598,
-0.6253201961517334,
-0.29109978675842285,
-0.12251754105091095,
0.37665700912475586,
0.29809990525245667,
0.07161473482847214,
0.16103015840053558,
-0.8739317655563354,
0.4215049743652344,
0.18303678929805756,
0.3889493942260742,
-0.24356020987033844,
-0.9046013951301575,
-0.15170545876026154,
0.06274822354316711,
-0.14779235422611237,
-1.2413067817687988,
0.38303080201148987,
0.3993370234966278,
0.39527130126953125,
0.28631916642189026,
-0.06122512370347977,
0.7571757435798645,
-0.7894478440284729,
0.849412739276886,
0.5985982418060303,
-0.5937254428863525,
0.3311099410057068,
-0.264973908662796,
0.4519195258617401,
0.347741037607193,
0.3455623686313629,
-1.2072548866271973,
-0.33941882848739624,
-0.3165770471096039,
-1.0286247730255127,
0.2769344449043274,
0.21480560302734375,
0.19815193116664886,
-0.010222932323813438,
0.4260254502296448,
0.020015712827444077,
0.011562550440430641,
-0.015745343640446663,
-0.16999807953834534,
0.2171674370765686,
0.004791750572621822,
0.13867007195949554,
-0.4373169541358948,
-0.14400090277194977,
-0.1478036493062973,
0.5490091443061829,
-0.07387656718492508,
0.4354895055294037,
0.5689120292663574,
-0.023712648078799248,
-0.37441420555114746,
0.6489720344543457,
0.5587319135665894,
0.5128190517425537,
-0.022796310484409332,
-0.39034900069236755,
0.44012415409088135,
-0.23787327110767365,
0.27643436193466187,
-0.09403125941753387,
-0.1862141489982605,
0.20501047372817993,
0.2650083303451538,
0.6748279929161072,
0.05122508108615875,
-0.9321004748344421,
0.7176072597503662,
0.1860172301530838,
-0.3479641079902649,
-0.41987186670303345,
-0.33535826206207275,
0.24043546617031097,
0.2361118644475937,
0.43924063444137573,
-0.43592357635498047,
0.28710490465164185,
-0.46818673610687256,
0.43737077713012695,
0.4797179102897644,
-0.5481755137443542,
-0.31960010528564453,
0.7298750281333923,
0.19002433121204376,
-0.21934880316257477,
0.4429287016391754,
0.19033077359199524,
0.1458175778388977,
0.5775994062423706,
0.7788208723068237,
0.98579341173172,
-0.4300633370876312,
0.3741379976272583,
0.21650470793247223,
0.10323207080364227,
0.4133104681968689,
0.717594563961029,
0.1455228328704834,
-0.29805585741996765,
-0.9464864730834961,
-0.5558131337165833,
-0.6136409044265747,
0.1489974409341812,
-0.7089804410934448,
0.10956455767154694,
-0.4046892821788788,
0.0228255745023489,
0.06574445962905884,
-0.2109660506248474,
-0.3372529149055481,
0.378461629152298,
0.34767836332321167,
0.9428488612174988,
-0.6187391877174377,
0.4953251779079437,
0.4771522879600525,
-0.4481276273727417,
-0.8084003925323486,
-0.3761368989944458,
0.11643540114164352,
-0.8175430297851562,
0.1550973355770111,
-0.18250970542430878,
0.03428055718541145,
-0.10220759361982346,
-0.2386934906244278,
-0.7124783992767334,
1.2024199962615967,
0.23706060647964478,
-0.9040772914886475,
-0.1814006268978119,
0.4711243212223053,
0.8376294374465942,
-0.19152796268463135,
0.7436660528182983,
0.5111571550369263,
0.04757309332489967,
0.4985846281051636,
-1.208243727684021,
0.14849130809307098,
-0.19291244447231293,
-0.14074763655662537,
0.11099705845117569,
-0.6538902521133423,
0.29080265760421753,
-0.5907397270202637,
-0.3599652945995331,
0.11488556116819382,
0.47858425974845886,
0.12138229608535767,
0.6361340880393982,
0.26333239674568176,
0.4800201952457428,
0.5976620316505432,
0.2692546546459198,
0.8078063726425171,
-0.4162819981575012,
0.05787691846489906,
0.925797164440155,
-0.5822343826293945,
1.0444905757904053,
0.6047092080116272,
-0.2680507302284241,
0.12366984039545059,
0.6238698363304138,
0.28734737634658813,
0.1551823616027832,
0.30902642011642456,
-0.7255090475082397,
-0.2038014978170395,
-0.3842359483242035,
-0.3102185130119324,
0.5103508234024048,
0.2466953843832016,
-0.08968660980463028,
-0.2242845594882965,
0.02149645797908306,
0.018704986199736595,
-0.10492220520973206,
-0.07016018778085709,
1.0024311542510986,
0.3656708598136902,
-0.44146299362182617,
0.6414369344711304,
-0.10544850677251816,
0.29568061232566833,
-0.5215482115745544,
-0.13476406037807465,
-0.2830691337585449,
-0.5030714273452759,
-0.1300211101770401,
-0.5506991744041443,
0.3668229281902313,
0.2251386046409607,
-0.16436411440372467,
-0.06957080960273743,
0.49966201186180115,
-0.4782421290874481,
-0.2824879288673401,
0.20035791397094727,
0.9218430519104004,
0.3839961886405945,
-0.1591230183839798,
-0.3569483160972595,
-0.478552907705307,
-0.1387523114681244,
-0.23815706372261047,
0.2973102629184723,
0.3592973053455353,
-0.1296842396259308,
0.6374650597572327,
0.7972983121871948,
0.4251394271850586,
-0.002748140599578619,
0.2057269811630249,
0.6630046367645264,
-0.6575334668159485,
-0.4297375977039337,
-0.5407482981681824,
0.3895494043827057,
-0.10697001963853836,
-0.22038105130195618,
0.3032507002353668,
0.7348166704177856,
0.4537457227706909,
0.26037970185279846,
0.7970871329307556,
0.09754227101802826,
0.8216860294342041,
-0.23423708975315094,
0.7474071979522705,
-0.6317110061645508,
0.1862691044807434,
0.1346266269683838,
-0.5473125576972961,
-0.44603317975997925,
0.0858435332775116,
0.0269476231187582,
-0.011918596923351288,
0.6575801372528076,
0.8704337477684021,
0.22016359865665436,
0.07876881211996078,
0.9596123099327087,
0.19092436134815216,
0.3277864158153534,
0.8245541453361511,
0.4651258587837219,
-0.3935016095638275,
0.45330312848091125,
0.021240534260869026,
-0.562515914440155,
-0.1334989368915558,
-0.31265324354171753,
-0.37155842781066895,
-0.20509172976016998,
-0.2595471739768982,
-0.10995654761791229,
0.21541857719421387,
0.9698154926300049,
0.5591380596160889,
-0.7284930944442749,
0.004519336856901646,
0.3046971261501312,
-0.483889102935791,
-0.3068477213382721,
-0.08101267367601395,
0.38152843713760376,
-0.06569302827119827,
-0.6273741722106934,
0.5850347876548767,
0.7330158948898315,
-0.18651066720485687,
-0.12976637482643127,
0.00012996514851693064,
0.0023680636659264565,
0.6387761831283569,
0.7283814549446106,
0.663718581199646,
-0.6470962762832642,
-0.1679815649986267,
0.6435757279396057,
0.00017658858268987387,
0.157198965549469,
0.7782621383666992,
-0.7534648776054382,
0.6190019249916077,
0.36030539870262146,
0.9150699973106384,
0.3907461166381836,
0.06141980364918709,
0.6508862376213074,
-0.5113274455070496,
-0.22987580299377441,
0.6163451075553894,
0.14331896603107452,
0.1352575272321701,
-0.35544681549072266,
0.33202269673347473,
0.23362790048122406,
-0.6029756665229797,
-0.7634367942810059,
0.20340628921985626,
-1.145018458366394,
-0.3464212119579315,
1.3117457628250122,
0.02282940037548542,
-0.025655193254351616,
-0.4173794090747833,
-0.2099585384130478,
0.586660623550415,
-0.15069109201431274,
0.5370205044746399,
0.31018540263175964,
-0.46664711833000183,
-0.3315712511539459,
-1.0405837297439575,
0.05482006072998047,
0.8513301014900208,
-0.9282615184783936,
-0.12253285199403763,
0.6133420467376709,
0.45090144872665405,
-0.19867803156375885,
1.0682480335235596,
-0.34014856815338135,
0.5721875429153442,
-0.12124136090278625,
0.1492358148097992,
-0.27011603116989136,
-0.23226013779640198,
-0.5967444181442261,
0.1604858636856079,
0.03066825680434704,
-0.5307031869888306
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.05872v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.05872v1
|
STARLING: Self-supervised Training of Text-based Reinforcement Learning Agent with Large Language Models
| 2024-06-09T18:07:47 | 2024-06-09T18:07:47 |
Shreyas Basavatia, Keerthiram Murugesan, Shivam Ratnakar
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Interactive fiction games have emerged as an important application to improve
the generalization capabilities of language-based reinforcement learning (RL)
agents. Existing environments for interactive fiction games are domain-specific
or time-consuming to generate and do not train the RL agents to master a
specific set of skills. In this work, we introduce an interactive environment
for self-supervised RL, STARLING, for text-based games that bootstraps the
text-based RL agents with automatically generated games (based on the seed set
of game ideas) to boost the performance and generalization capabilities to
reach a goal of the target environment. These games let the agent hone their
skills on a predefined set of tasks. We create and test an environment with 100
games, generated using this automated framework that uses large language models
(GPT-3) and an interactive fiction game engine (based on Inform7) to provide
the user with the ability to generate more games under minimal human
supervision. Experimental results based on both the human participants and
baseline text-based RL agents reveal that current state-of-the-art text-based
RL agents cannot use previously learned skills in new situations at the level
humans can. These results enforce STARLING's potential to serve as a sandbox
environment for further research in self-supervised text-based RL.
|
[
-0.1857115775346756,
-0.9570157527923584,
0.4098433554172516,
0.3965449333190918,
0.22969751060009003,
0.20208701491355896,
-0.48500046133995056,
-0.275921106338501,
0.0638316422700882,
0.7353758215904236,
-0.5396859645843506,
-0.41847339272499084,
-0.22156673669815063,
0.2782367765903473,
-0.0012271249433979392,
1.3742432594299316,
-0.13556842505931854,
-0.1002201959490776,
-0.1423955261707306,
0.05051910877227783,
-0.4934293031692505,
-0.578880786895752,
-0.8033023476600647,
-0.3853418231010437,
0.5878251791000366,
0.674551248550415,
0.6361681818962097,
0.928956925868988,
0.3101467490196228,
0.4454018771648407,
0.3106729984283447,
0.08491366356611252,
-0.6236765384674072,
0.549193263053894,
-0.5049317479133606,
-0.3490560054779053,
-0.24508552253246307,
0.19848990440368652,
0.5319864153862,
-0.02317175269126892,
0.0967172384262085,
0.08178235590457916,
0.10605675727128983,
0.49919795989990234,
-0.4247857630252838,
0.4598686695098877,
-0.14767181873321533,
0.2596873641014099,
0.09687178581953049,
-0.3482038676738739,
-0.3696509301662445,
0.015246580354869366,
-0.08018944412469864,
-1.1165528297424316,
0.297479510307312,
0.3008931577205658,
0.5467739701271057,
0.3736741542816162,
-0.1642075926065445,
-0.5964663624763489,
-0.9361565113067627,
0.6469132304191589,
-0.45649412274360657,
0.10748245567083359,
0.4467368721961975,
0.5271393060684204,
-0.14253024756908417,
-0.3922092020511627,
-0.5493146777153015,
-0.6353877186775208,
-0.1594240367412567,
0.27782976627349854,
0.09941832721233368,
0.27399739623069763,
0.364763081073761,
0.086158387362957,
-0.5023292303085327,
0.24118192493915558,
-0.2505057156085968,
-0.09283807128667831,
0.7314995527267456,
0.18564504384994507,
0.363312691450119,
-0.017754489555954933,
-0.4439387321472168,
-0.46932291984558105,
-0.4848055839538574,
0.3687678575515747,
0.2904592752456665,
0.27564185857772827,
-0.07058694213628769,
0.38080647587776184,
-0.28430166840553284,
0.4775918126106262,
0.12723177671432495,
-0.26076456904411316,
0.07497523725032806,
-0.19580888748168945,
-0.0850844457745552,
0.05592357739806175,
0.8906660079956055,
0.36118924617767334,
0.4592186212539673,
-0.24695545434951782,
-0.4966433346271515,
-0.0003445071051828563,
0.23895856738090515,
-0.6730390191078186,
-0.39435824751853943,
0.11779454350471497,
-0.3890019357204437,
-0.7655547857284546,
-0.2069128453731537,
-0.7002665400505066,
-0.5466706156730652,
-0.11926344037055969,
0.4599519371986389,
-0.49189090728759766,
-0.18517442047595978,
-0.1613091081380844,
-0.04430519416928291,
0.08995886892080307,
0.1386748105287552,
-1.2336817979812622,
0.36605024337768555,
0.3215658664703369,
0.529991865158081,
-0.44775277376174927,
-0.791902482509613,
-0.8497020602226257,
0.28179508447647095,
-0.439123272895813,
0.8076685070991516,
-0.4636516273021698,
-0.38405507802963257,
0.03412327915430069,
-0.00875249132514,
-0.05211124196648598,
-0.44900721311569214,
0.0632290467619896,
-0.5273302793502808,
0.27951914072036743,
-0.052199866622686386,
-0.5957351922988892,
0.02044009044766426,
0.5555720925331116,
-0.44168829917907715,
0.7124900221824646,
-0.14994320273399353,
-0.32418492436408997,
0.3988637328147888,
-0.7496452927589417,
-0.4114486873149872,
0.2799181640148163,
-0.42773351073265076,
-0.31122735142707825,
-0.2954193353652954,
0.3782007098197937,
0.4892311096191406,
0.09193726629018784,
0.2291269153356552,
-0.118545763194561,
-0.5861576795578003,
0.246008962392807,
-0.24787405133247375,
-0.005848064552992582,
0.29274630546569824,
-0.6037910580635071,
0.3840670883655548,
-0.32187676429748535,
0.22151169180870056,
0.18856249749660492,
-0.44940757751464844,
-0.16076067090034485,
0.2119169384241104,
0.20351766049861908,
0.3078554570674896,
0.19709916412830353,
-0.4010680913925171,
0.41352567076683044,
-0.18467998504638672,
-0.06587643176317215,
0.43563318252563477,
0.13213875889778137,
0.43146732449531555,
-0.46287572383880615,
0.7736952304840088,
-0.204193115234375,
0.11823293566703796,
-0.4736407399177551,
-0.2508854269981384,
-0.9059608578681946,
-0.0979919359087944,
0.3482251763343811,
0.7189610600471497,
-1.1980013847351074,
0.3583641052246094,
0.09936113655567169,
-0.345816969871521,
-0.243273064494133,
0.18908366560935974,
0.6263464093208313,
0.0099342567846179,
0.4175650477409363,
0.1625828593969345,
-0.12789908051490784,
-0.7210297584533691,
-0.2893000841140747,
-0.19102144241333008,
0.16058611869812012,
0.3968358039855957,
0.5737810134887695,
-0.19933517277240753,
1.1040940284729004,
-0.24350756406784058,
-0.722267210483551,
-0.395246297121048,
0.15927661955356598,
-0.17604245245456696,
0.580266535282135,
0.30738767981529236,
-0.6383588910102844,
-0.6375581622123718,
0.22999046742916107,
-1.1533710956573486,
-0.05545886978507042,
-0.5244830846786499,
0.27204635739326477,
0.11321935802698135,
0.8686631917953491,
-0.14797236025333405,
0.26990777254104614,
0.5668205618858337,
-0.686185359954834,
0.7556750774383545,
-0.6775547862052917,
0.4818660020828247,
-0.492324560880661,
0.031230643391609192,
-0.062675341963768,
-0.45924872159957886,
-0.7031883001327515,
0.1967630684375763,
0.036911725997924805,
-0.20299042761325836,
-0.1078394204378128,
0.8099831938743591,
-0.5100837349891663,
0.10023495554924011,
-0.763163149356842,
0.3453741669654846,
-0.3481888473033905,
0.6646013259887695,
0.41930586099624634,
1.0757681131362915,
0.596623420715332,
-0.6360205411911011,
0.22018550336360931,
0.19550533592700958,
-0.07503661513328552,
0.45176196098327637,
-0.6470349431037903,
-0.15700258314609528,
0.015707146376371384,
0.10128840804100037,
-0.526404082775116,
-0.13912348449230194,
0.2887532114982605,
-0.22752583026885986,
-0.044895920902490616,
-0.04457322135567665,
-0.5233267545700073,
-0.047900013625621796,
0.14125941693782806,
0.18142157793045044,
0.6866117119789124,
-0.6106519103050232,
0.3079138994216919,
0.3062732219696045,
-0.2995389699935913,
-0.531221866607666,
-0.35306844115257263,
0.08158934116363525,
-0.3144068717956543,
-0.18033163249492645,
0.059607286006212234,
-0.23722758889198303,
-0.16610920429229736,
0.058546796441078186,
0.1882970929145813,
0.014447493478655815,
-0.03358651325106621,
0.3466113805770874,
-0.1136358380317688,
-0.12434431165456772,
0.5563349723815918,
0.13980939984321594,
-0.2770549952983856,
0.09578439593315125,
-0.22368364036083221,
0.06335263699293137,
-0.4179648458957672,
-0.21270138025283813,
0.05769573897123337,
0.2517831027507782,
0.230791836977005,
-0.27427828311920166,
0.5034478902816772,
0.4558165371417999,
-0.04937106370925903,
-0.7595933675765991,
-0.6035497188568115,
-0.16533979773521423,
-0.5686457753181458,
0.4391132593154907,
-0.3317694365978241,
-1.1905444860458374,
0.40135657787323,
-0.1918674111366272,
0.02262672409415245,
0.2520911693572998,
0.49807462096214294,
-0.29411956667900085,
0.7348456382751465,
0.8852208852767944,
0.05532592162489891,
0.4379352629184723,
-0.044441238045692444,
-0.2856120765209198,
-0.39914560317993164,
-0.09529544413089752,
0.10907603800296783,
-0.211991086602211,
-0.21796245872974396,
-0.5879158973693848,
0.18018034100532532,
0.08934871107339859,
-0.1835777908563614,
0.20747576653957367,
-0.39636898040771484,
0.8785850405693054,
0.40097537636756897,
-0.07543422281742096,
0.4636986255645752,
-0.04983267933130264,
-0.3134080469608307,
-0.005241484846919775,
-0.9230018854141235,
-0.4217948615550995,
0.78887540102005,
0.48989734053611755,
0.9236489534378052,
-0.1535140872001648,
0.8832911849021912,
0.8144524693489075,
0.44667333364486694,
-0.3221675157546997,
0.36376917362213135,
0.3177776336669922,
-0.5491206049919128,
-0.7239392399787903,
-0.512072741985321,
-1.0323421955108643,
0.32024848461151123,
-0.47988349199295044,
-0.522594153881073,
-0.09383431077003479,
0.42281413078308105,
-0.39283159375190735,
0.33554065227508545,
-0.665080726146698,
1.144588828086853,
-0.5163185000419617,
-0.5000101327896118,
-0.30105242133140564,
-0.1879720538854599,
0.2265707552433014,
-0.12953400611877441,
0.3981327414512634,
0.15017986297607422,
-0.07851958274841309,
0.6831952929496765,
-0.252110093832016,
0.9240914583206177,
-0.2128022462129593,
-0.10514946281909943,
0.35565322637557983,
0.43030381202697754,
0.5964863896369934,
0.052748050540685654,
0.27318066358566284,
-0.3034740388393402,
0.041215889155864716,
-0.3040596544742584,
-0.6852895617485046,
0.869690477848053,
-0.7736800909042358,
-0.4557966887950897,
-0.6645442247390747,
-0.6770075559616089,
-0.27752548456192017,
0.26477310061454773,
0.013750886544585228,
0.2053641825914383,
-0.5594878196716309,
-0.00948166474699974,
0.565012514591217,
-0.3736402690410614,
0.4900045096874237,
0.8228418231010437,
-0.6055586338043213,
-0.3235916197299957,
1.3015775680541992,
-0.12595035135746002,
0.23812852799892426,
0.08701136708259583,
0.19148682057857513,
-0.3074069619178772,
-0.546320915222168,
-0.44627130031585693,
0.1457526981830597,
-0.4995831549167633,
0.017492203041911125,
-0.510338306427002,
-0.20992717146873474,
-0.05582446977496147,
-0.3607896566390991,
-0.27599844336509705,
0.14442481100559235,
0.01258847676217556,
0.1579752266407013,
0.36865413188934326,
1.207419753074646,
-0.24314559996128082,
0.6365022659301758,
-0.6038109064102173,
0.11090460419654846,
0.36095893383026123,
0.5654404759407043,
-0.14995048940181732,
-0.31464722752571106,
-0.5483726263046265,
-0.1470697671175003,
0.00019439739116933197,
-0.6266504526138306,
0.3663700222969055,
0.11018037050962448,
0.6085512042045593,
0.23039990663528442,
0.0361015684902668,
0.2248053103685379,
-0.5826400518417358,
0.5621748566627502,
0.08688229322433472,
-0.495176762342453,
0.4478449523448944,
-0.779558539390564,
0.40939566493034363,
0.7001017332077026,
0.18343307077884674,
-0.7466533780097961,
-0.5567691326141357,
-0.6916171312332153,
-0.2691098749637604,
0.7285823822021484,
0.3699703812599182,
-0.24379748106002808,
-0.027154525741934776,
0.27184489369392395,
0.09235554188489914,
0.21211063861846924,
-1.0374022722244263,
-0.29339250922203064,
-0.10484296083450317,
-0.04368048906326294,
-0.629406750202179,
-0.01246528048068285,
0.07160970568656921,
0.09721190482378006,
0.701134443283081,
-0.4317866861820221,
0.08442825078964233,
0.27260875701904297,
-0.28449392318725586,
-0.06073335185647011,
0.14045332372188568,
0.3430714011192322,
0.15638680756092072,
-0.0019344844622537494,
-0.08626444637775421,
0.2748471796512604,
-0.3831309676170349,
0.35703930258750916,
0.05847718194127083,
-0.2881676256656647,
-0.5416839718818665,
0.48151201009750366,
0.6339499354362488,
0.5025507211685181,
-0.941753089427948,
0.5695212483406067,
-0.12514424324035645,
-0.28467342257499695,
-0.45275503396987915,
0.569256603717804,
-0.16218429803848267,
0.629320502281189,
0.13591890037059784,
0.040318094193935394,
-0.0274298507720232,
-0.41618552803993225,
0.6163153648376465,
0.21263247728347778,
-0.7721694111824036,
0.15456095337867737,
0.6426023840904236,
0.3931063115596771,
-0.4537786841392517,
0.4384554624557495,
-0.6957744359970093,
-0.4162833094596863,
0.4855145514011383,
0.719689667224884,
0.7264302968978882,
0.09270869195461273,
0.5526840686798096,
0.3251015245914459,
0.3079071044921875,
-0.045538529753685,
-0.06689027696847916,
-0.09369990974664688,
-0.5801243185997009,
-0.5868253111839294,
-0.36807185411453247,
-0.44905319809913635,
0.17195653915405273,
-0.13796491920948029,
-0.04306694120168686,
-0.5331946611404419,
0.09359532594680786,
-0.5041149854660034,
0.037339769303798676,
-0.5753829479217529,
0.24680766463279724,
0.2562386393547058,
0.6012030243873596,
-0.8390364646911621,
0.7985406517982483,
0.6725342273712158,
-0.4602978825569153,
-0.5977880954742432,
0.0415470264852047,
-0.0627293735742569,
-0.3317335247993469,
0.5400945544242859,
0.05646560341119766,
-0.043869562447071075,
0.208634153008461,
-0.4548836648464203,
-0.8507939577102661,
1.0750789642333984,
-0.09006372094154358,
-0.27615806460380554,
-0.03226558491587639,
0.1470309942960739,
0.7456598877906799,
-0.6378645896911621,
0.3857623338699341,
0.36005592346191406,
0.35005155205726624,
-0.24763481318950653,
-0.6939406991004944,
0.014366945251822472,
-0.4160133898258209,
-0.30603277683258057,
-0.28455838561058044,
-0.7133423089981079,
0.5359289050102234,
-0.12729083001613617,
-0.17043143510818481,
0.03792287036776543,
0.9904163479804993,
0.3820212781429291,
0.03247901424765587,
0.7169657349586487,
0.11517807841300964,
0.5681217908859253,
0.0462796613574028,
1.0251500606536865,
-0.3686743676662445,
0.36184415221214294,
0.9643056988716125,
-0.07986559718847275,
0.5745848417282104,
-0.0662955492734909,
0.2708308696746826,
0.5590325593948364,
0.3456271290779114,
-0.3525853455066681,
0.40143388509750366,
0.2662898302078247,
-0.17871466279029846,
-0.592180609703064,
0.05137515813112259,
-0.15233361721038818,
0.28502410650253296,
0.26062095165252686,
-0.16883419454097748,
-0.44293302297592163,
0.3053649663925171,
-0.243769571185112,
0.5020278096199036,
-0.21671579778194427,
0.6957617998123169,
-0.17700675129890442,
-0.8393607139587402,
0.25336959958076477,
-0.035176124423742294,
0.8318753242492676,
-0.8931575417518616,
-0.2839449644088745,
-0.10860668867826462,
0.3736683130264282,
0.17966987192630768,
-0.7444117069244385,
-0.33639782667160034,
0.03192082792520523,
-0.041332878172397614,
-0.3888359069824219,
0.8361366391181946,
-0.6218214631080627,
-0.3768104016780853,
0.30863097310066223,
0.7940086722373962,
0.36931031942367554,
-0.020518824458122253,
-0.8212816119194031,
-0.06852390617132187,
-0.08892016112804413,
-0.39272940158843994,
0.6500648856163025,
0.3691555857658386,
0.0258274395018816,
0.9574070572853088,
0.5347659587860107,
0.055537689477205276,
-0.2111237794160843,
-0.2826227843761444,
0.6899630427360535,
-0.8481923341751099,
-1.0112981796264648,
-0.5397918820381165,
0.3161274492740631,
-0.14851920306682587,
-0.5672527551651001,
0.9237269759178162,
0.5366712212562561,
0.5532092452049255,
-0.3593218922615051,
1.0432910919189453,
-0.12453403323888779,
0.24103988707065582,
-0.5719337463378906,
1.0531303882598877,
-0.22980356216430664,
-0.031065430492162704,
-0.18220512568950653,
-0.8631596565246582,
0.02800455130636692,
0.641784131526947,
-0.2237456887960434,
0.2903313934803009,
0.7036414742469788,
0.6309005618095398,
-0.10565374046564102,
-0.17067335546016693,
0.666582465171814,
0.014390714466571808,
0.3041350245475769,
0.4369661509990692,
0.8772788047790527,
-0.019930582493543625,
0.5814295411109924,
-0.1758427917957306,
-0.4912218749523163,
0.023017071187496185,
-0.7605355978012085,
-1.4424103498458862,
-0.6033990979194641,
-0.24441403150558472,
-0.1734105348587036,
0.45024171471595764,
0.9280557036399841,
0.6733367443084717,
-0.7070924639701843,
-0.46967822313308716,
-0.01658334955573082,
-0.04481721669435501,
-0.5324233174324036,
-0.20288138091564178,
0.23957233130931854,
-0.7913476824760437,
-0.5557725429534912,
0.8720076680183411,
-0.1345359981060028,
0.04198103025555611,
-0.6607607007026672,
-0.3264837861061096,
-0.02256539650261402,
-0.19685229659080505,
0.44046834111213684,
0.814062237739563,
-0.46395552158355713,
-0.3738188147544861,
-0.010943803004920483,
-0.22656862437725067,
-0.3141615092754364,
0.7262975573539734,
-1.2097845077514648,
0.4335126280784607,
-0.016057755798101425,
0.6949954032897949,
0.5689541697502136,
0.14157789945602417,
0.8989579677581787,
-0.6990727186203003,
-0.006452776025980711,
-0.0028047561645507812,
-0.17260286211967468,
0.095386803150177,
-0.4743131697177887,
0.5052328705787659,
0.16651177406311035,
-0.9523082375526428,
-0.2726544141769409,
0.05017310753464699,
-0.49254506826400757,
-0.2597894072532654,
1.297635555267334,
-0.08234573155641556,
-0.20087191462516785,
-0.13735362887382507,
-0.3941032886505127,
-0.05149785056710243,
-0.421206533908844,
0.7075033783912659,
0.5882787704467773,
-0.13664698600769043,
-0.03699684515595436,
-0.7458879351615906,
1.0364402532577515,
0.3648195266723633,
-0.8768426179885864,
0.3830726742744446,
0.562199056148529,
0.22327063977718353,
0.128484308719635,
0.7304394245147705,
0.48922526836395264,
0.41104403138160706,
0.21655939519405365,
0.5362846851348877,
-0.6066374778747559,
-0.6725876331329346,
-0.3766177296638489,
0.03139457479119301,
-0.05256042256951332,
0.09499431401491165
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.05870v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.05870v1
|
Machine Against the RAG: Jamming Retrieval-Augmented Generation with Blocker Documents
| 2024-06-09T17:55:55 | 2024-06-09T17:55:55 |
Avital Shafran, Roei Schuster, Vitaly Shmatikov
|
cs.CR
|
cs.CR, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Retrieval-augmented generation (RAG) systems respond to queries by retrieving
relevant documents from a knowledge database, then generating an answer by
applying an LLM to the retrieved documents.
We demonstrate that RAG systems that operate on databases with potentially
untrusted content are vulnerable to a new class of denial-of-service attacks we
call jamming. An adversary can add a single ``blocker'' document to the
database that will be retrieved in response to a specific query and,
furthermore, result in the RAG system not answering the query - ostensibly
because it lacks the information or because the answer is unsafe.
We describe and analyze several methods for generating blocker documents,
including a new method based on black-box optimization that does not require
the adversary to know the embedding or LLM used by the target RAG system, nor
access to an auxiliary LLM to generate blocker documents. We measure the
efficacy of the considered methods against several LLMs and embeddings, and
demonstrate that the existing safety metrics for LLMs do not capture their
vulnerability to jamming. We then discuss defenses against blocker documents.
|
[
-0.6856242418289185,
-0.9919260740280151,
0.47952744364738464,
-0.34694960713386536,
-0.12873832881450653,
0.4735778570175171,
0.312408447265625,
-0.6018093824386597,
0.4914933145046234,
1.057320475578308,
-0.28480666875839233,
-0.1503242552280426,
-0.7288476824760437,
-0.0818244218826294,
-0.5943732261657715,
1.1488462686538696,
0.04327316954731941,
-0.16486027836799622,
-0.517862856388092,
0.20547686517238617,
-0.8621205687522888,
-0.47582027316093445,
-0.6454433798789978,
-0.24348756670951843,
0.1873650997877121,
0.28386443853378296,
0.4212135672569275,
0.617941677570343,
0.6386504769325256,
0.2925352454185486,
0.05442231521010399,
0.17278681695461273,
-0.701973021030426,
0.7707810401916504,
-0.2219328135251999,
-0.43438443541526794,
-0.24549242854118347,
-0.11879235506057739,
0.5009785294532776,
0.28314605355262756,
0.19883115589618683,
0.0467340461909771,
-0.07354012876749039,
0.9489231705665588,
-0.9323818683624268,
-0.5676141381263733,
-1.1074467897415161,
0.05815841630101204,
-0.6552336812019348,
-0.31303730607032776,
-0.5980461835861206,
-0.17798085510730743,
-0.3610256612300873,
-0.44049879908561707,
0.2865428030490875,
0.6454647183418274,
0.843123733997345,
0.39538320899009705,
-0.3361663818359375,
-0.7262685894966125,
-0.7592909932136536,
0.5533455610275269,
-0.02818767912685871,
0.11532475054264069,
0.7537518739700317,
0.486113041639328,
-0.7186595797538757,
-0.4422526955604553,
-0.3202260732650757,
-0.03679241985082626,
-0.0754583328962326,
0.2771666347980499,
-0.26853933930397034,
0.016728561371564865,
0.3765326142311096,
0.47360625863075256,
-0.6481127142906189,
-0.0678257867693901,
-0.6495661735534668,
-0.24859367311000824,
0.7919577956199646,
0.2692617177963257,
0.05115273594856262,
-0.4164295494556427,
-0.697108805179596,
-0.058044712990522385,
-0.6167129874229431,
-0.2565951347351074,
0.5721433758735657,
-0.11678291857242584,
0.19473794102668762,
0.7762328386306763,
0.1947101205587387,
1.0008270740509033,
0.3706232011318207,
-0.5815478563308716,
-0.4136873185634613,
-0.014028686098754406,
-0.29324352741241455,
0.11898019164800644,
0.5366264581680298,
0.2355671525001526,
-0.4241505563259125,
-0.5051702857017517,
-0.6986359357833862,
-0.12902504205703735,
0.867999255657196,
-0.4226277470588684,
0.04282897338271141,
0.28145959973335266,
-0.3257823884487152,
-0.5207114219665527,
0.1763206124305725,
-0.7507213950157166,
-0.8164786100387573,
0.3539516031742096,
0.5667305588722229,
-0.38013920187950134,
0.13633114099502563,
-0.3224262595176697,
-0.4973851442337036,
0.20710530877113342,
-0.0870019868016243,
-0.498050332069397,
0.7098082304000854,
0.8150644898414612,
0.7512065172195435,
-0.18060699105262756,
0.13447098433971405,
-0.6497259736061096,
0.6238085627555847,
-0.546577513217926,
1.0159059762954712,
-0.08192746341228485,
-1.1117675304412842,
-0.3054124712944031,
0.10078679025173187,
-0.009669275023043156,
-0.761087954044342,
0.5665581822395325,
-0.8413223028182983,
0.06815803796052933,
0.029359813779592514,
-0.7801346182823181,
-0.07157764583826065,
0.40886399149894714,
-0.6794648170471191,
0.6596112847328186,
0.10083083063364029,
-0.8804712295532227,
0.07542309165000916,
-0.4868122339248657,
-0.5456001162528992,
-0.0020249043591320515,
-0.08563990890979767,
-0.6338933706283569,
0.3090623915195465,
-0.41722315549850464,
0.11644264310598373,
-0.42816904187202454,
-0.11941790580749512,
-0.11043449491262436,
-0.27075132727622986,
0.4287485182285309,
-0.043105579912662506,
0.6760039925575256,
0.6455807089805603,
-0.007229275535792112,
-0.23013851046562195,
-0.6591033339500427,
-0.02586343325674534,
0.41536930203437805,
-0.22137942910194397,
-0.49962687492370605,
-0.09869454801082611,
-0.44501549005508423,
-0.193477600812912,
0.3342367708683014,
-0.5328129529953003,
-0.036470621824264526,
-0.25665199756622314,
-0.322944313287735,
0.7765315175056458,
0.347258597612381,
0.2718832194805145,
-0.9699657559394836,
0.7165805697441101,
-0.12097812443971634,
0.09106674790382385,
-0.35049495100975037,
-0.46856844425201416,
-0.5708743929862976,
-0.16304880380630493,
0.3359050750732422,
0.6562173366546631,
-0.6790228486061096,
0.17904865741729736,
0.3169217109680176,
-0.4716971516609192,
-0.30623388290405273,
0.015867946669459343,
0.8563573360443115,
0.5903143286705017,
0.28094232082366943,
-0.5933116674423218,
-0.584242045879364,
-0.7742480635643005,
-0.4248066544532776,
0.1717901974916458,
0.009043822064995766,
0.5668542385101318,
0.16901902854442596,
-0.01654379442334175,
0.4847620725631714,
-0.5610893964767456,
-0.2943497896194458,
0.17104211449623108,
-0.06997999548912048,
0.07092368602752686,
0.503311276435852,
0.37713682651519775,
-0.8098785877227783,
-0.4992544949054718,
-0.06407933682203293,
-0.748506486415863,
-0.1019376739859581,
-0.07910150289535522,
-0.16187123954296112,
0.6856356263160706,
0.4710649847984314,
-0.30566439032554626,
0.5458160042762756,
0.47384926676750183,
-0.3987331688404083,
0.7340584397315979,
-0.16617777943611145,
0.05821796506643295,
-1.1952868700027466,
0.07789680361747742,
-0.5098235011100769,
-0.45138636231422424,
-0.7713607549667358,
0.4138283431529999,
-0.2582760155200958,
-0.39927586913108826,
-0.15485318005084991,
0.43712902069091797,
-0.6821272969245911,
-0.27289026975631714,
-0.7382432222366333,
0.29521211981773376,
0.13775254786014557,
-0.11561956256628036,
-0.4222430884838104,
0.6827025413513184,
0.3038608133792877,
-0.5621438026428223,
0.3966011106967926,
0.13833031058311462,
-0.10012184083461761,
0.7591982483863831,
-0.5275850296020508,
0.5586751699447632,
-0.24469855427742004,
0.0630866065621376,
-0.4653099775314331,
-0.3943692445755005,
0.4811573326587677,
-0.5147607326507568,
0.9248658418655396,
-0.48115864396095276,
-0.1572508066892624,
-0.5934332013130188,
-0.5027319192886353,
0.12721066176891327,
0.5364294648170471,
-0.08403793722391129,
0.4691772758960724,
0.923785388469696,
0.21637792885303497,
-0.8569654822349548,
-0.625097393989563,
0.16042545437812805,
-0.28103452920913696,
-0.6592309474945068,
0.3903447389602661,
-0.07318177819252014,
-0.44506093859672546,
0.2629237473011017,
-0.4303291141986847,
-0.12734003365039825,
0.4228529930114746,
0.5686759352684021,
0.10806369036436081,
0.10848090797662735,
-0.2447880357503891,
0.0387193001806736,
-0.4231085181236267,
0.17795220017433167,
-0.427429735660553,
0.45636147260665894,
0.4215236306190491,
-0.6527976393699646,
0.2724946141242981,
0.6047923564910889,
0.15997345745563507,
0.05049841105937958,
0.648675799369812,
0.2221822738647461,
-0.38552772998809814,
-0.1443755030632019,
-0.776504397392273,
-0.11298851668834686,
-0.45621123909950256,
-0.07494334131479263,
-0.52497798204422,
-0.7237259745597839,
0.3256884515285492,
-0.024279223755002022,
0.017757730558514595,
0.2919515371322632,
0.37019410729408264,
-0.17498759925365448,
0.49772340059280396,
0.5053313374519348,
0.13997387886047363,
0.18362540006637573,
-0.17949146032333374,
0.011601689271628857,
-0.9478474855422974,
-0.34266361594200134,
-0.6608977913856506,
-0.28665146231651306,
-0.7328605651855469,
-0.6530538201332092,
0.6195673942565918,
0.5406719446182251,
-0.08200301229953766,
0.2987898588180542,
-0.7076629400253296,
0.7362279295921326,
0.6178960204124451,
-0.05169006809592247,
0.40403109788894653,
-0.16442008316516876,
-0.128371462225914,
0.2767869234085083,
-0.7018458843231201,
-0.4854617714881897,
1.2515631914138794,
0.014145506545901299,
0.8249028921127319,
0.18596608936786652,
1.105226993560791,
0.3308010399341583,
0.30332863330841064,
-0.5351895093917847,
0.4189676344394684,
-0.11216628551483154,
-1.1571996212005615,
-0.1398596614599228,
-0.41171398758888245,
-1.1970891952514648,
0.11987103521823883,
-0.4786466658115387,
-0.7773404717445374,
-0.06336551159620285,
0.059330642223358154,
-0.00005968638652120717,
0.6406962275505066,
-0.5768746733665466,
0.49453186988830566,
-0.21836183965206146,
-0.3692677915096283,
-0.021674923598766327,
-0.5070034861564636,
0.7121466398239136,
-0.6526310443878174,
0.3804378807544708,
0.10445336252450943,
-0.049129921942949295,
0.7277000546455383,
-0.3065606951713562,
0.46708670258522034,
-0.2833292484283447,
0.054136089980602264,
0.5908560156822205,
0.527863621711731,
0.5528660416603088,
-0.032564908266067505,
0.017396414652466774,
-0.105394147336483,
-0.03974439576268196,
-0.5453473329544067,
-0.3349895775318146,
0.7458105683326721,
-0.4773058295249939,
-1.196347713470459,
-0.554520845413208,
-0.7506670355796814,
0.11914984881877899,
0.5886857509613037,
0.40240246057510376,
0.2958785593509674,
-0.21196861565113068,
0.13820306956768036,
0.8594059348106384,
-0.15865789353847504,
0.24391232430934906,
0.48635852336883545,
-0.3776493966579437,
-0.38982245326042175,
1.231833815574646,
0.3666411340236664,
0.3889322876930237,
0.394187867641449,
0.14254330098628998,
-0.0833882987499237,
-0.9074016809463501,
-0.3510908782482147,
0.1035168319940567,
-0.3969632387161255,
-0.6770440340042114,
-0.7282594442367554,
-0.16970212757587433,
-0.30885908007621765,
-0.2448817938566208,
-0.10104338824748993,
-0.48520708084106445,
0.2009003609418869,
0.3363521993160248,
0.38334083557128906,
1.2303860187530518,
-0.20525658130645752,
0.09489639103412628,
-1.0209143161773682,
0.48006972670555115,
0.20977365970611572,
0.3703698217868805,
-0.1748550981283188,
-0.32929158210754395,
-0.2801555097103119,
-0.2124698907136917,
-1.006208896636963,
-1.2071341276168823,
0.13632625341415405,
-0.3989960551261902,
0.5420572757720947,
0.27386197447776794,
0.43019774556159973,
0.3275987207889557,
-0.5613187551498413,
0.4350987374782562,
0.07017646729946136,
-0.7469243407249451,
0.46524181962013245,
-0.41633719205856323,
-0.15035389363765717,
0.22367803752422333,
0.5133821368217468,
-0.16290460526943207,
-0.684974193572998,
-0.6834902763366699,
-0.6767294406890869,
0.5518700480461121,
0.0008397019701078534,
-0.15622840821743011,
-0.05448834225535393,
0.20668597519397736,
-0.046428367495536804,
0.23699384927749634,
-0.37245574593544006,
-0.4165474474430084,
-0.27209925651550293,
0.3403327167034149,
0.2819267809391022,
-0.43412908911705017,
-0.502546489238739,
0.5416139960289001,
0.8004845380783081,
0.14919784665107727,
0.1919686198234558,
0.3076518774032593,
-0.03464603051543236,
-0.3803578019142151,
0.21835896372795105,
0.49273842573165894,
0.28969860076904297,
-0.1792326420545578,
0.022790543735027313,
0.2514320909976959,
-0.5448846817016602,
0.2612203061580658,
0.2697390019893646,
-0.693295419216156,
-0.055505283176898956,
0.08431601524353027,
0.468608558177948,
-0.05666191503405571,
-0.4589357078075409,
0.17826008796691895,
-0.037571076303720474,
-0.21172702312469482,
-0.47188588976860046,
0.21555683016777039,
-0.06392087042331696,
0.06719012558460236,
0.30660322308540344,
0.048934075981378555,
0.18190155923366547,
-0.20908859372138977,
0.20836220681667328,
0.8797782063484192,
-0.29920750856399536,
0.09197795391082764,
0.6944945454597473,
-0.11423740535974503,
-0.7307404279708862,
-0.17943492531776428,
-0.43956509232521057,
-0.2346678376197815,
0.4865718185901642,
0.9975563883781433,
0.8756188154220581,
-0.3140319883823395,
-0.21622426807880402,
0.026503464207053185,
0.5097424983978271,
0.3679642081260681,
0.053946513682603836,
0.017185812816023827,
-0.43841278553009033,
-0.09499002993106842,
-0.635330080986023,
-0.6788963675498962,
0.14607813954353333,
-0.6736310720443726,
0.10898925364017487,
-0.6857352256774902,
-0.28231966495513916,
-0.21981629729270935,
0.16810263693332672,
-0.18983250856399536,
-0.09054256975650787,
-0.09002519398927689,
0.7557618021965027,
-0.120584636926651,
0.4324585199356079,
0.7075082063674927,
-0.17861850559711456,
-0.5190194249153137,
0.12034367024898529,
0.17897330224514008,
-0.5890172719955444,
0.21127530932426453,
-0.11241354793310165,
-0.18609113991260529,
-0.21473318338394165,
-0.0057210237719118595,
-0.8696750402450562,
1.0563198328018188,
0.17033860087394714,
-0.4762636423110962,
0.1875179409980774,
0.004078473895788193,
-0.043217118829488754,
-0.02978372946381569,
-0.06445588171482086,
0.24778707325458527,
0.556448221206665,
-0.18580688536167145,
-0.6685746908187866,
0.16787514090538025,
0.10798636823892593,
-0.06006135046482086,
0.6258671879768372,
-0.6386895775794983,
0.6434551477432251,
-0.10806009918451309,
-0.4105454385280609,
0.09405498951673508,
0.337683767080307,
0.31786516308784485,
0.6986116170883179,
0.5080296993255615,
0.9345101714134216,
0.8709599375724792,
-0.00799354538321495,
1.4813976287841797,
-0.39346960186958313,
-0.10261183232069016,
0.8712621927261353,
-0.21933089196681976,
0.3416324257850647,
0.39582669734954834,
-0.036729082465171814,
0.1988862305879593,
0.024229081347584724,
0.008596423082053661,
0.1794177144765854,
0.47085875272750854,
-0.4943467080593109,
0.1551080048084259,
-0.19719769060611725,
-0.32401126623153687,
0.3447507917881012,
0.3625037968158722,
-0.08050363510847092,
-0.12375237047672272,
-0.10100655257701874,
0.20108263194561005,
0.47042116522789,
-0.17561747133731842,
1.2401068210601807,
0.28697311878204346,
-0.5793479681015015,
0.8209983706474304,
0.05441949516534805,
0.6079574227333069,
-0.4779094457626343,
0.33300840854644775,
-0.0939178541302681,
-0.07140450179576874,
-0.2618338465690613,
-0.4843303859233856,
0.7454469203948975,
0.2084299921989441,
-0.5363852977752686,
0.20611922442913055,
1.4542577266693115,
-0.036880750209093094,
-0.2442133128643036,
0.3048858642578125,
0.520376443862915,
0.282626748085022,
0.4119950234889984,
-0.5702435374259949,
0.21415358781814575,
-0.2506573498249054,
-0.3232622742652893,
0.791246235370636,
0.40124937891960144,
-0.15748725831508636,
0.6539267301559448,
0.791238009929657,
0.20885422825813293,
0.12252368777990341,
-0.4061134457588196,
1.0700393915176392,
-0.6103500127792358,
-0.2882533371448517,
-0.5676524043083191,
0.03188014402985573,
-0.2771907150745392,
0.2683352530002594,
0.9360783100128174,
0.7066830992698669,
1.0002613067626953,
0.06063290312886238,
0.9221540093421936,
-0.22594869136810303,
1.0380022525787354,
-0.4959177076816559,
0.9290300011634827,
-0.5026142597198486,
0.29379141330718994,
-0.2525545656681061,
-0.8009145855903625,
-0.05141931399703026,
0.06412558257579803,
-0.10806203633546829,
-0.13328969478607178,
0.685389518737793,
0.9510711431503296,
0.10160357505083084,
-0.1202525869011879,
0.5394036769866943,
0.19021032750606537,
0.3020020127296448,
0.4280723035335541,
0.7580131888389587,
-0.49192532896995544,
0.6896880269050598,
-0.28826504945755005,
-0.16839392483234406,
-0.10035277903079987,
-0.7866905331611633,
-0.7923220992088318,
-0.33634936809539795,
0.3040581941604614,
-0.7509709000587463,
0.5405092835426331,
0.36342841386795044,
0.47815385460853577,
-0.6631717681884766,
-0.30423933267593384,
0.16144101321697235,
0.7679669260978699,
0.20032750070095062,
-0.19770388305187225,
-0.0868036076426506,
-0.5421215891838074,
-0.4793965220451355,
0.7501780986785889,
0.15178804099559784,
0.22984138131141663,
-0.17163807153701782,
-0.012223506346344948,
-0.008252873085439205,
0.2656112313270569,
0.17601029574871063,
0.5931157469749451,
-0.44719645380973816,
-0.06661558151245117,
-0.12511299550533295,
0.043639663606882095,
-0.35140761733055115,
0.9624663591384888,
-0.7030946612358093,
0.49214446544647217,
0.35144731402397156,
1.0225948095321655,
0.4937695860862732,
0.043892886489629745,
0.4180203378200531,
-0.8072409629821777,
0.2904855012893677,
0.28307631611824036,
0.13774670660495758,
0.26118534803390503,
-0.48545369505882263,
0.34220409393310547,
0.4100653827190399,
-0.8944420218467712,
-1.1049391031265259,
0.4680502712726593,
-0.5840287804603577,
-0.4903092384338379,
0.5958095788955688,
-0.03222932666540146,
-0.5087502598762512,
-0.5896296501159668,
-0.1263289451599121,
0.07663757354021072,
-0.25452888011932373,
0.924865186214447,
0.19653256237506866,
-0.023058786988258362,
0.29366111755371094,
-0.4751094877719879,
0.5482645034790039,
0.15270724892616272,
-0.7101898193359375,
-0.16459321975708008,
0.39594796299934387,
0.11233466118574142,
0.5444391369819641,
0.7639092206954956,
-0.3919757008552551,
0.23075485229492188,
0.24099573493003845,
-0.25919800996780396,
-0.4642505347728729,
-0.3921368718147278,
-0.060842808336019516,
0.3992054760456085,
0.2641921937465668,
-0.19595399498939514
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.05862v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.05862v2
|
II-Bench: An Image Implication Understanding Benchmark for Multimodal Large Language Models
| 2024-06-09T17:25:47 | 2024-06-11T12:33:42 |
Ziqiang Liu, Feiteng Fang, Xi Feng, Xinrun Du, Chenhao Zhang, Zekun Wang, Yuelin Bai, Qixuan Zhao, Liyang Fan, Chengguang Gan, Hongquan Lin, Jiaming Li, Yuansheng Ni, Haihong Wu, Yaswanth Narsupalli, Zhigang Zheng, Chengming Li, Xiping Hu, Ruifeng Xu, Xiaojun Chen, Min Yang, Jiaheng Liu, Ruibo Liu, Wenhao Huang, Ge Zhang, Shiwen Ni
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV
|
The rapid advancements in the development of multimodal large language models
(MLLMs) have consistently led to new breakthroughs on various benchmarks. In
response, numerous challenging and comprehensive benchmarks have been proposed
to more accurately assess the capabilities of MLLMs. However, there is a dearth
of exploration of the higher-order perceptual capabilities of MLLMs. To fill
this gap, we propose the Image Implication understanding Benchmark, II-Bench,
which aims to evaluate the model's higher-order perception of images. Through
extensive experiments on II-Bench across multiple MLLMs, we have made
significant findings. Initially, a substantial gap is observed between the
performance of MLLMs and humans on II-Bench. The pinnacle accuracy of MLLMs
attains 74.8%, whereas human accuracy averages 90%, peaking at an impressive
98%. Subsequently, MLLMs perform worse on abstract and complex images,
suggesting limitations in their ability to understand high-level semantics and
capture image details. Finally, it is observed that most models exhibit
enhanced accuracy when image sentiment polarity hints are incorporated into the
prompts. This observation underscores a notable deficiency in their inherent
understanding of image sentiment. We believe that II-Bench will inspire the
community to develop the next generation of MLLMs, advancing the journey
towards expert artificial general intelligence (AGI). II-Bench is publicly
available at https://huggingface.co/datasets/m-a-p/II-Bench.
|
[
-0.6772645711898804,
-0.4596540629863739,
0.6569656133651733,
0.38222381472587585,
-0.20717653632164001,
-0.2904932498931885,
-0.2823692858219147,
-0.732062816619873,
-0.47944143414497375,
0.3486606478691101,
-0.5701587796211243,
-0.3620591163635254,
-0.8824164271354675,
-0.18518909811973572,
-0.33449169993400574,
0.36835965514183044,
0.01005538459867239,
0.4578135907649994,
-0.5279594659805298,
-0.5534068942070007,
-0.44240453839302063,
-0.2647496163845062,
-0.5420379042625427,
-0.209273099899292,
0.548367440700531,
0.18684464693069458,
0.8109024167060852,
0.5821956992149353,
0.6014612913131714,
0.30058303475379944,
0.16718485951423645,
-0.020428583025932312,
-0.24778300523757935,
0.05277084931731224,
-0.3916868567466736,
-0.5057689547538757,
-0.2908326983451843,
0.17884685099124908,
0.5923166871070862,
0.5453794002532959,
0.37445974349975586,
0.22749808430671692,
-0.1766275316476822,
0.8124400973320007,
-0.90069979429245,
0.35281145572662354,
-0.6556148529052734,
0.05511845648288727,
-0.09618813544511795,
0.15878497064113617,
-0.6654186248779297,
0.09077039361000061,
-0.004046325106173754,
-0.5162534117698669,
0.07076006382703781,
0.04977402091026306,
0.8709784746170044,
0.5039230585098267,
-0.6630321145057678,
0.11076638847589493,
-0.36032789945602417,
0.8141583800315857,
-0.626288890838623,
0.4590924382209778,
0.5762723684310913,
0.7379285097122192,
-0.06680893152952194,
-0.6709555983543396,
-0.7931552529335022,
-0.01880495622754097,
-0.11422725021839142,
0.34370195865631104,
-0.030501719564199448,
0.005099720321595669,
0.3638293743133545,
0.12072597444057465,
-0.46648192405700684,
0.2387751042842865,
0.08693939447402954,
0.010685950517654419,
0.5527861714363098,
0.036253321915864944,
0.12612059712409973,
-0.1654876470565796,
-0.5249533653259277,
-0.4724937081336975,
-0.6309074759483337,
0.3882986903190613,
0.05328460782766342,
0.05322675779461861,
-0.15147972106933594,
0.6640048027038574,
-0.12881998717784882,
0.6918777227401733,
-0.361814945936203,
-0.002943116007372737,
0.2578578293323517,
-0.28062114119529724,
-0.01211954653263092,
-0.39369067549705505,
0.6667776107788086,
0.8679322004318237,
0.22010566294193268,
0.22407346963882446,
-0.22296816110610962,
0.35518407821655273,
-0.04981890320777893,
-0.9229082465171814,
0.07358210533857346,
0.34496310353279114,
-0.6570634841918945,
-0.08656658232212067,
-0.03175745904445648,
-0.793921709060669,
-0.9765800833702087,
-0.4349447190761566,
0.3109898865222931,
-0.4811490774154663,
-0.3944142162799835,
-0.17634589970111847,
-0.3077954053878784,
0.5152344703674316,
0.5253844261169434,
-0.5105880498886108,
0.17985926568508148,
0.8073359727859497,
0.5316653251647949,
0.26764509081840515,
-0.515642523765564,
-0.7858371138572693,
0.07365523278713226,
-0.3359512388706207,
1.0148334503173828,
-0.7199990749359131,
-0.22263526916503906,
0.06871297955513,
-0.09607649594545364,
-0.005255410913378,
-0.6321114897727966,
0.8842670917510986,
-0.3844003677368164,
-0.036155153065919876,
-0.46433091163635254,
-0.4645015001296997,
-0.2164035141468048,
0.33628249168395996,
-0.5097728371620178,
0.8731544613838196,
-0.009736704640090466,
-0.527891993522644,
0.4013091027736664,
-0.4024738371372223,
-0.33888596296310425,
-0.17629912495613098,
-0.6173804998397827,
-0.167739138007164,
0.16380205750465393,
0.39062443375587463,
0.37087711691856384,
-0.6712943315505981,
0.38467276096343994,
-0.7852403521537781,
-0.30207550525665283,
0.5466338396072388,
-0.32653313875198364,
0.5074994564056396,
0.006973556242883205,
-0.679766058921814,
-0.07324202358722687,
-0.519313395023346,
0.24119387567043304,
0.11057624965906143,
-0.0169916320592165,
-0.20019666850566864,
0.20865564048290253,
0.18105140328407288,
0.5958846807479858,
0.16658298671245575,
-0.41165825724601746,
-0.07647009938955307,
-0.022651363164186478,
0.29454514384269714,
1.0588668584823608,
-0.337257981300354,
0.1932261735200882,
0.07468264549970627,
0.12913303077220917,
0.09359647333621979,
0.4773063659667969,
-0.060653310269117355,
-0.6202437877655029,
-0.582116961479187,
-0.4342480003833771,
0.28958696126937866,
0.5221617817878723,
-0.4920388162136078,
0.13730694353580475,
-0.2752872407436371,
-0.23666414618492126,
-0.5986027717590332,
0.09524152427911758,
0.8903775215148926,
0.39738285541534424,
0.44668468832969666,
-0.26715603470802307,
-0.485737144947052,
-1.4200490713119507,
-0.5010531544685364,
-0.19927328824996948,
0.002722960663959384,
0.7805900573730469,
0.39129266142845154,
-0.3506564795970917,
0.8158324360847473,
-0.30696767568588257,
-0.2680722177028656,
0.215034618973732,
0.4542296826839447,
0.2573484480381012,
0.26034918427467346,
0.6927043199539185,
-1.0178849697113037,
-0.6205703020095825,
0.023199645802378654,
-0.9292752742767334,
0.009162691421806812,
0.16983722150325775,
-0.2020193189382553,
0.222041055560112,
0.4244791865348816,
-0.8250573873519897,
0.47457605600357056,
0.5987201929092407,
-0.3064684569835663,
0.5910124182701111,
-0.0974346324801445,
0.2175801396369934,
-0.778474748134613,
0.16298796236515045,
0.3255835175514221,
0.01558999065309763,
-0.34242042899131775,
0.11346665769815445,
0.2733556628227234,
0.02826579473912716,
-0.07660187780857086,
0.7717866897583008,
-0.5312880277633667,
-0.6362882256507874,
-0.12148930132389069,
0.09034376591444016,
0.08579674363136292,
0.2640588581562042,
0.13771629333496094,
0.9614610075950623,
0.5878559947013855,
-0.13700468838214874,
-0.026493020355701447,
0.2316722869873047,
-0.6152355074882507,
0.8067202568054199,
-0.5791906118392944,
-0.03794899955391884,
-0.33408159017562866,
0.2785768508911133,
-1.2597079277038574,
-0.49097970128059387,
-0.01539364643394947,
-0.5611006617546082,
0.4560664892196655,
-0.11360174417495728,
-0.6101318597793579,
-0.5022192001342773,
-0.2523730993270874,
0.44828635454177856,
0.5587453842163086,
-0.6559739708900452,
0.7396007180213928,
0.35228094458580017,
-0.03788115084171295,
-1.0732321739196777,
-0.6066089868545532,
0.3247706890106201,
0.23537448048591614,
-0.6136219501495361,
0.08279550075531006,
-0.07051250338554382,
-0.6098377704620361,
0.04684687778353691,
0.13034729659557343,
-0.06663382798433304,
-0.07353491336107254,
0.5725573301315308,
0.2693225145339966,
-0.295329749584198,
0.2112586945295334,
-0.18888352811336517,
-0.08695289492607117,
0.1532764434814453,
0.08002966642379761,
0.506027340888977,
-0.3760423958301544,
-0.49885180592536926,
-0.4952186048030853,
0.36060091853141785,
0.9633780121803284,
-0.34619787335395813,
0.6177119016647339,
0.990343451499939,
-0.3117740750312805,
0.2694125473499298,
-0.7979580760002136,
-0.028339656069874763,
-0.43404605984687805,
0.36944159865379333,
-0.6338967680931091,
-0.2611955404281616,
0.38552290201187134,
-0.19266657531261444,
-0.06497544795274734,
0.529296338558197,
0.4412323534488678,
-0.3909165859222412,
1.4723882675170898,
0.1675734668970108,
-0.04388105124235153,
0.32155904173851013,
-0.23193304240703583,
0.15182755887508392,
-1.011319875717163,
-0.15753059089183807,
-0.3645358383655548,
-0.4583383798599243,
-0.3410548269748688,
-0.5767929553985596,
0.41586124897003174,
0.0811387300491333,
-0.16808708012104034,
0.017470385879278183,
-0.21374940872192383,
0.390370637178421,
0.6525978446006775,
0.2167152613401413,
-0.046831659972667694,
-0.04232366755604744,
-0.04843758046627045,
-0.01956779882311821,
-0.09832281619310379,
-0.21627239882946014,
0.9446027874946594,
0.3546924293041229,
0.5113028883934021,
0.23496052622795105,
0.1199302226305008,
0.36044418811798096,
0.42849215865135193,
-0.6314353346824646,
0.6644811630249023,
-0.4550340473651886,
-0.7458086609840393,
-0.023562220856547356,
-0.10820784419775009,
-0.7203516960144043,
0.517932653427124,
-0.3263361155986786,
-0.577616810798645,
0.36944249272346497,
0.09884245693683624,
0.004429419059306383,
0.08135256916284561,
-0.9182363152503967,
0.9159308671951294,
-0.37555932998657227,
-0.7226047515869141,
-0.586815595626831,
-0.9827553629875183,
0.48800989985466003,
0.3278151750564575,
0.5774860382080078,
-0.3894137144088745,
-0.18099424242973328,
0.2986569106578827,
-0.23697903752326965,
0.824015200138092,
-0.6414022445678711,
0.16555285453796387,
0.0973711758852005,
-0.062310606241226196,
0.4960884153842926,
-0.027270233258605003,
-0.3083899915218353,
0.026438044384121895,
-0.1648188978433609,
-0.5429333448410034,
-0.6063991785049438,
0.6867638230323792,
-0.9788591265678406,
-0.5189226269721985,
-0.12123704701662064,
-0.6698524951934814,
-0.6713039875030518,
0.12076231837272644,
0.10139661282300949,
0.7518936395645142,
0.11158351600170135,
0.2041834592819214,
0.36396121978759766,
-0.1454041600227356,
0.30821701884269714,
0.2950544059276581,
-0.1905236393213272,
-0.624280571937561,
0.6772227883338928,
-0.14963242411613464,
0.0686664879322052,
0.30750033259391785,
0.11963063478469849,
-0.6875271201133728,
-0.5313963294029236,
-0.5726728439331055,
0.20758451521396637,
-1.0954781770706177,
-0.12314894050359726,
-0.7664086818695068,
0.2570186257362366,
-0.5361405611038208,
-0.09435217827558517,
-0.1786281168460846,
-0.28481703996658325,
0.026607180014252663,
0.2207324206829071,
0.21869827806949615,
0.6222137212753296,
0.055136390030384064,
0.00234779785387218,
-0.6685834527015686,
0.38128942251205444,
0.43770846724510193,
0.5016180872917175,
-0.06545217335224152,
-0.36889398097991943,
0.015930982306599617,
0.1394532322883606,
0.09328260272741318,
-0.6209463477134705,
0.017745010554790497,
0.394906222820282,
0.7725831270217896,
0.6289917826652527,
-0.11520404368638992,
0.8123504519462585,
-0.34015509486198425,
0.6217269897460938,
0.4147389531135559,
-0.7248639464378357,
0.48468878865242004,
-0.4831274747848511,
0.2753191888332367,
0.704692006111145,
0.13905830681324005,
-0.19351519644260406,
-0.1717209815979004,
-0.35537660121917725,
-0.6163883209228516,
0.5424498319625854,
-0.06086907908320427,
-0.05150040239095688,
0.15721264481544495,
0.33108657598495483,
0.1357661634683609,
0.32019728422164917,
-0.7190778851509094,
-0.036236271262168884,
-0.23892824351787567,
-0.2384914606809616,
-0.28713223338127136,
-0.47418591380119324,
-0.24961599707603455,
-0.3682204782962799,
0.7016324400901794,
-0.35796400904655457,
0.28199025988578796,
0.05007855221629143,
-0.259073942899704,
-0.10332784056663513,
0.25426891446113586,
0.558348536491394,
0.5814123153686523,
-0.3482356369495392,
0.33063071966171265,
-0.08405549824237823,
-0.10747966915369034,
-0.11333110928535461,
0.17278175055980682,
0.19214491546154022,
-0.14340618252754211,
0.531432569026947,
0.8753721117973328,
0.05387071520090103,
-0.9780336022377014,
0.8363101482391357,
-0.22725476324558258,
-0.10819000005722046,
-0.2442924529314041,
-0.2936077415943146,
0.10240086913108826,
0.5549629926681519,
0.3895041346549988,
0.4593912959098816,
0.3324460983276367,
-0.7298692464828491,
0.12298382073640823,
0.6648144721984863,
-0.4615316390991211,
-0.19818291068077087,
0.40135446190834045,
-0.07415860146284103,
0.06685792654752731,
0.5465333461761475,
-0.17865990102291107,
-0.5420497059822083,
0.696310818195343,
0.39691269397735596,
0.6952171325683594,
0.06813554465770721,
0.16304481029510498,
0.5989348888397217,
0.22771340608596802,
0.10042110830545425,
0.31186917424201965,
-0.06223594397306442,
-0.6299482583999634,
-0.44192007184028625,
-0.558817982673645,
-0.4208814203739166,
-0.045364756137132645,
-0.7141937613487244,
0.1709299236536026,
-0.5397234559059143,
-0.40148046612739563,
0.2668651342391968,
-0.4748663306236267,
-0.7141804099082947,
0.3308197557926178,
0.3156404495239258,
0.87103271484375,
-0.6416207551956177,
0.7703353762626648,
0.8824170827865601,
-0.26685506105422974,
-0.5236717462539673,
-0.028293630108237267,
0.020578712224960327,
-1.1926822662353516,
0.9461634755134583,
0.6147985458374023,
-0.1832108497619629,
-0.29405930638313293,
-0.6239184141159058,
-0.6288405656814575,
1.055832862854004,
0.3844459652900696,
-0.35880813002586365,
0.3329344391822815,
0.1459178626537323,
0.5459429025650024,
-0.2939774990081787,
0.47676265239715576,
0.3399396240711212,
0.8582903742790222,
0.17613473534584045,
-0.6915553212165833,
0.1201077401638031,
-0.5711356997489929,
0.1906537413597107,
0.09642139077186584,
-0.504012942314148,
1.1842377185821533,
-0.3190792202949524,
-0.11923761665821075,
0.23645693063735962,
0.27792659401893616,
0.14482128620147705,
0.4287680983543396,
0.7325902581214905,
0.679611325263977,
0.3573276400566101,
-0.11992746591567993,
1.2572715282440186,
-0.24595953524112701,
0.20472148060798645,
1.1561920642852783,
-0.5558304786682129,
1.201722264289856,
0.6328588128089905,
-0.32039013504981995,
0.6472510695457458,
0.6384536623954773,
0.06296522170305252,
0.6398563385009766,
-0.08937718719244003,
-0.32925307750701904,
-0.5835243463516235,
-0.5387617349624634,
-0.5346127152442932,
0.5209028124809265,
0.5232179760932922,
-0.4276166260242462,
-0.2847101390361786,
0.027889331802725792,
-0.391141414642334,
0.13584376871585846,
-0.3318333327770233,
0.741490364074707,
-0.016906585544347763,
-0.9058017134666443,
0.6519907116889954,
-0.2073681354522705,
0.34647685289382935,
-0.2663978934288025,
-0.04619620367884636,
0.04420432448387146,
0.5944759845733643,
-0.11869114637374878,
-1.1107362508773804,
-0.14910820126533508,
-0.2337007373571396,
-0.2351403385400772,
-0.02905311994254589,
0.8485815525054932,
-0.1714455932378769,
-0.3422743082046509,
0.64034104347229,
0.4057858884334564,
-0.05524029582738876,
-0.27649322152137756,
-0.9378203749656677,
0.195308655500412,
-0.36765772104263306,
-0.10298293083906174,
0.4455015957355499,
0.10935287177562714,
-0.018036404624581337,
0.48099952936172485,
0.528491735458374,
-0.503788411617279,
-0.06173044070601463,
0.27661556005477905,
0.7338998317718506,
-0.3069841265678406,
-0.1067470908164978,
-0.7292328476905823,
0.5448888540267944,
-0.4382766783237457,
-0.16827800869941711,
0.40317144989967346,
0.4291752874851227,
0.4341990351676941,
-0.19009456038475037,
0.8243384957313538,
-0.12856176495552063,
0.3192720115184784,
-0.5255725383758545,
0.3128952980041504,
-0.8922250866889954,
-0.18730150163173676,
-0.07891087234020233,
-0.700794517993927,
-0.20240682363510132,
0.46530604362487793,
-0.6990047097206116,
-0.08419409394264221,
0.613143801689148,
0.7962169647216797,
-0.11068965494632721,
0.11328955739736557,
0.2784821391105652,
0.42541101574897766,
0.056702639907598495,
0.3340202271938324,
0.9808185696601868,
-0.43198972940444946,
0.360994815826416,
-0.3723302185535431,
-0.4188900291919708,
-0.24748963117599487,
-0.7629637718200684,
-0.8915411829948425,
-0.6569989919662476,
0.059798162430524826,
-0.48078691959381104,
0.004614553414285183,
0.7964034080505371,
0.6774051189422607,
-0.775813102722168,
-0.19173575937747955,
-0.15480169653892517,
-0.18985511362552643,
-0.27104583382606506,
-0.19673296809196472,
0.2867274582386017,
-0.2763623893260956,
-0.4941292703151703,
0.19820278882980347,
0.39797502756118774,
-0.08788006007671356,
-0.15910334885120392,
-0.19434364140033722,
-0.46597081422805786,
-0.048843782395124435,
0.8925907611846924,
0.2445802241563797,
-1.100367784500122,
-0.2955007553100586,
-0.06051928550004959,
-0.20479702949523926,
0.15793748199939728,
0.7027311325073242,
-0.5867466926574707,
0.5347123146057129,
0.36144235730171204,
0.6947612762451172,
0.6033186316490173,
-0.04103216156363487,
0.4088703989982605,
-0.6056152582168579,
0.29920440912246704,
-0.018106313422322273,
0.7082076072692871,
0.5069748163223267,
-0.24257901310920715,
0.6907032132148743,
0.21611621975898743,
-0.2987566590309143,
-0.8334288597106934,
0.39773043990135193,
-1.0521775484085083,
-0.4478459060192108,
1.1110249757766724,
-0.1653442680835724,
-0.3339676856994629,
0.21420389413833618,
-0.3395325243473053,
0.09752903878688812,
-0.24329279363155365,
0.563862144947052,
0.6032345294952393,
-0.1730145364999771,
-0.48446083068847656,
-0.6508530974388123,
0.16462329030036926,
0.707736611366272,
-0.958942174911499,
0.16804912686347961,
0.7459799647331238,
-0.1024680808186531,
0.21092528104782104,
0.510670006275177,
-0.2009522169828415,
0.5821706056594849,
0.06314607709646225,
0.14826032519340515,
0.12824615836143494,
-0.18279755115509033,
-0.021016709506511688,
0.11375615000724792,
0.3120017647743225,
-0.08442382514476776
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.05845v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.05845v1
|
MedREQAL: Examining Medical Knowledge Recall of Large Language Models via Question Answering
| 2024-06-09T16:33:28 | 2024-06-09T16:33:28 |
Juraj Vladika, Phillip Schneider, Florian Matthes
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In recent years, Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated an impressive
ability to encode knowledge during pre-training on large text corpora. They can
leverage this knowledge for downstream tasks like question answering (QA), even
in complex areas involving health topics. Considering their high potential for
facilitating clinical work in the future, understanding the quality of encoded
medical knowledge and its recall in LLMs is an important step forward. In this
study, we examine the capability of LLMs to exhibit medical knowledge recall by
constructing a novel dataset derived from systematic reviews -- studies
synthesizing evidence-based answers for specific medical questions. Through
experiments on the new MedREQAL dataset, comprising question-answer pairs
extracted from rigorous systematic reviews, we assess six LLMs, such as GPT and
Mixtral, analyzing their classification and generation performance. Our
experimental insights into LLM performance on the novel biomedical QA dataset
reveal the still challenging nature of this task.
|
[
-0.26472434401512146,
-0.5021475553512573,
0.8004887104034424,
-0.4615076184272766,
0.001144938520155847,
0.0800827369093895,
0.11746463179588318,
-0.49065566062927246,
0.20742109417915344,
0.7549678683280945,
-0.49971944093704224,
-0.5606377720832825,
-0.6003603339195251,
0.26924005150794983,
-0.3468845784664154,
1.1296591758728027,
-0.2192298173904419,
0.4288131892681122,
-0.32329630851745605,
-0.2048351913690567,
-0.34651297330856323,
-0.771097719669342,
-0.4722452163696289,
-0.345050573348999,
0.7029052376747131,
0.21352122724056244,
0.5306825041770935,
0.22227618098258972,
0.5726302266120911,
0.1090460866689682,
0.027433738112449646,
0.339896559715271,
-0.532564640045166,
0.11731009185314178,
-0.2730863094329834,
-0.6732098460197449,
-0.22315223515033722,
-0.1880090981721878,
0.6648023724555969,
0.8170669078826904,
-0.26935309171676636,
0.2781124711036682,
-0.13239982724189758,
0.6843591928482056,
-0.4097132086753845,
-0.12014127522706985,
-0.801025390625,
-0.08999011665582657,
0.11490117758512497,
-0.2923348546028137,
-0.3744009733200073,
-0.6086419224739075,
0.2350575476884842,
-0.415962815284729,
0.17421670258045197,
0.05391136184334755,
0.7037498354911804,
0.3123628795146942,
-0.527784526348114,
-0.5454874038696289,
-0.63316410779953,
0.4262145757675171,
-0.9366890788078308,
0.24416068196296692,
0.41982215642929077,
0.40531405806541443,
-0.15317204594612122,
-0.9301710724830627,
-0.4761280417442322,
0.035559024661779404,
-0.1466720849275589,
0.1375899761915207,
-0.020957762375473976,
0.11203145980834961,
0.19449102878570557,
0.49819910526275635,
-0.588991105556488,
-0.028688035905361176,
-0.5878884196281433,
-0.15164341032505035,
0.36144062876701355,
0.3667215406894684,
0.3981129825115204,
-0.12415003031492233,
-0.13975393772125244,
0.05710591375827789,
-1.0427961349487305,
0.002380375051870942,
-0.4664028286933899,
-0.2666720747947693,
0.1326977163553238,
0.7445805668830872,
-0.026557713747024536,
0.44274985790252686,
-0.1576189249753952,
-0.0878603383898735,
0.3018515110015869,
-0.26356637477874756,
-0.32227402925491333,
-0.0539928674697876,
0.5698392391204834,
0.2809525728225708,
0.20307089388370514,
-0.07308639585971832,
-0.21266485750675201,
-0.2525683343410492,
0.3485091030597687,
-0.7299690246582031,
-0.1592811495065689,
0.40518227219581604,
-0.6705630421638489,
-0.020954051986336708,
-0.16506750881671906,
-0.4097128212451935,
-0.5893645882606506,
-0.09106955677270889,
0.5019644498825073,
-0.41191810369491577,
-0.09920231252908707,
0.48626282811164856,
-0.0166024062782526,
0.3202076852321625,
0.2774239480495453,
-0.690135657787323,
0.33492985367774963,
0.4782436192035675,
0.3366583287715912,
-0.14670614898204803,
0.004021720960736275,
-0.30064457654953003,
0.10859090834856033,
-0.49772679805755615,
0.6489384770393372,
-0.20777128636837006,
-0.26827308535575867,
0.1838369220495224,
0.08094266802072525,
-0.3132786154747009,
-0.9137929081916809,
0.25865238904953003,
-0.846134603023529,
0.31465771794319153,
-0.44150668382644653,
-0.8338018655776978,
-0.350719690322876,
0.46062782406806946,
-0.6468432545661926,
0.6192286610603333,
0.10898151993751526,
-0.921954870223999,
0.2787988483905792,
-0.05977737158536911,
-0.2868596911430359,
0.060427937656641006,
-0.5650960206985474,
-0.24158363044261932,
0.16676774621009827,
0.39948874711990356,
0.4815745949745178,
-0.6751269102096558,
0.3687155246734619,
-0.011143502779304981,
-0.06109120324254036,
0.7575995326042175,
-0.2128991186618805,
0.4451494812965393,
0.18331968784332275,
0.051009777933359146,
0.036187417805194855,
-0.6772271990776062,
-0.006015372462570667,
0.12095281481742859,
-0.5197671055793762,
-0.4806392192840576,
-0.12015333771705627,
-0.3675929009914398,
0.47987478971481323,
0.16380338370800018,
-0.4917867183685303,
0.06465693563222885,
-0.4045872986316681,
0.3217264413833618,
0.3238791525363922,
0.6309735178947449,
0.0053213369101285934,
-0.770079493522644,
0.6856383085250854,
-0.12191910296678543,
0.1766802966594696,
-0.16533899307250977,
-0.40646040439605713,
-0.5635855793952942,
-0.12495516240596771,
0.38337767124176025,
0.4349517822265625,
-0.8778414130210876,
-0.021915167570114136,
-0.12653376162052155,
-0.28889036178588867,
-0.7342454791069031,
0.12353452295064926,
0.3849363625049591,
0.5759285092353821,
0.3881627917289734,
-0.24049268662929535,
-0.4163404703140259,
-1.0867342948913574,
-0.0662764236330986,
-0.19346660375595093,
-0.25230032205581665,
0.5874384045600891,
0.6049823760986328,
-0.3543461263179779,
0.6333380937576294,
-0.6248857378959656,
-0.0891335979104042,
-0.28366050124168396,
-0.09078890830278397,
0.21650321781635284,
0.16092564165592194,
0.4100072383880615,
-0.6451554894447327,
0.11391918361186981,
-0.29099297523498535,
-0.9907473921775818,
-0.009996427223086357,
-0.15188103914260864,
-0.05621125176548958,
-0.04103551805019379,
0.5786563754081726,
-0.5406635403633118,
0.08798062056303024,
0.5091670155525208,
-0.29040828347206116,
0.6866042017936707,
-0.3404037058353424,
0.38378697633743286,
-1.1182878017425537,
0.3558945059776306,
-0.3706899583339691,
-0.0032752789556980133,
-0.6307693719863892,
-0.16363754868507385,
0.20338845252990723,
0.08148859441280365,
-0.38070163130760193,
0.5455343723297119,
-0.3262329399585724,
0.12252844870090485,
-0.06964367628097534,
-0.008155398070812225,
0.07975854724645615,
0.20223964750766754,
0.1325494796037674,
0.5856327414512634,
0.11657727509737015,
-0.49442577362060547,
0.0035590108018368483,
0.5078469514846802,
-0.45880335569381714,
0.194332554936409,
-0.6314955949783325,
0.053388286381959915,
-0.22054371237754822,
0.1907259076833725,
-1.0457032918930054,
-0.4047410488128662,
-0.13135336339473724,
-0.403911292552948,
0.23995201289653778,
-0.0381758026778698,
-0.6040790677070618,
-0.4982477128505707,
0.14238430559635162,
0.5643532872200012,
0.673594057559967,
-0.24435099959373474,
0.4791358411312103,
0.6519997715950012,
-0.5385105609893799,
-0.46091005206108093,
-0.46584415435791016,
-0.13017748296260834,
-0.0696813315153122,
-0.2610599398612976,
-0.06192447617650032,
0.06036945432424545,
-0.18179292976856232,
-0.09909195452928543,
-0.21349385380744934,
-0.18349617719650269,
-0.04124554246664047,
0.0669085755944252,
0.4798988401889801,
-0.18452322483062744,
0.5143350958824158,
0.15623287856578827,
0.185668483376503,
0.5471606850624084,
-0.07874967902898788,
0.48946884274482727,
0.2345612347126007,
-0.5513984560966492,
-0.142439603805542,
0.3114941418170929,
0.6652829051017761,
-0.25372350215911865,
0.6354424357414246,
0.08658666163682938,
-0.6211135387420654,
-0.025234952569007874,
-0.897117018699646,
-0.38309094309806824,
-0.3322214186191559,
0.5411766767501831,
0.02352282404899597,
-1.0254031419754028,
0.5499076843261719,
-0.07083515077829361,
0.18617308139801025,
0.45308101177215576,
0.7712306976318359,
-0.15556582808494568,
0.9050118923187256,
0.07795757055282593,
-0.021904535591602325,
-0.14001990854740143,
-0.10584776848554611,
-0.27123624086380005,
-0.6558666825294495,
-0.5626171827316284,
-0.4663996398448944,
-0.07430505007505417,
-0.25384363532066345,
-0.6690993905067444,
0.6230228543281555,
-0.14633621275424957,
-0.26698610186576843,
-0.2621005177497864,
-0.0914532020688057,
0.21251459419727325,
0.43956923484802246,
0.25886884331703186,
0.5198256969451904,
-0.1449631005525589,
-0.2525359094142914,
0.09850781410932541,
-0.8671700358390808,
-0.4960569739341736,
1.3025171756744385,
0.42304638028144836,
0.9041491150856018,
-0.1545000970363617,
0.6386669874191284,
-0.09754104167222977,
0.2713591456413269,
-0.5309363603591919,
0.44517627358436584,
-0.04109365493059158,
-0.7577894330024719,
-0.001186511479318142,
-0.5155120491981506,
-0.917935311794281,
0.08748286962509155,
-0.6405417323112488,
-0.12841160595417023,
-0.048490431159734726,
0.07832785695791245,
-0.557001531124115,
0.3799455165863037,
-0.3635718524456024,
0.4875941276550293,
-0.32036566734313965,
-0.04053841531276703,
-0.22468513250350952,
-0.7149423956871033,
0.606906533241272,
-0.2684580981731415,
0.21207481622695923,
0.08027760684490204,
0.002102995989844203,
0.9559550881385803,
-0.11844751238822937,
0.6884365081787109,
-0.16488081216812134,
-0.23670995235443115,
0.23042823374271393,
0.09717461466789246,
0.12938226759433746,
0.16701528429985046,
0.1971449851989746,
-0.07422313094139099,
0.4084433615207672,
-0.333089143037796,
-0.547132134437561,
0.49753931164741516,
-0.5613420605659485,
-0.4894252419471741,
-0.3227826952934265,
-0.6976743340492249,
-0.6641405820846558,
0.12092004716396332,
0.039403751492500305,
0.5179097056388855,
-0.3342357873916626,
0.12318750470876694,
1.1103594303131104,
-0.8652958869934082,
-0.23170925676822662,
0.6871821880340576,
-0.43033260107040405,
-0.45518720149993896,
0.4821840822696686,
0.07653239369392395,
0.48491400480270386,
0.5034404993057251,
0.006419045384973288,
-0.35412734746932983,
-0.8980460166931152,
-0.40266576409339905,
0.5068541765213013,
-0.5281403064727783,
-0.20403149724006653,
-0.7735564112663269,
-0.5976703763008118,
-0.11905165016651154,
0.1687759906053543,
-0.13234710693359375,
-0.4285585284233093,
-0.07044713199138641,
-0.0009406004101037979,
0.27337318658828735,
1.0895276069641113,
0.3049376606941223,
-0.3041253685951233,
-1.1350963115692139,
0.5716620683670044,
0.49056220054626465,
0.2732222378253937,
0.06216118112206459,
-0.29294630885124207,
-0.22893044352531433,
0.06939279288053513,
-0.0058248210698366165,
-0.8980177044868469,
0.3511659801006317,
-0.03762149065732956,
0.7652168869972229,
0.27455466985702515,
0.05043237656354904,
0.3015500605106354,
-0.5229657888412476,
0.6536716222763062,
0.15698109567165375,
-0.22774577140808105,
0.5216535925865173,
-0.2969011962413788,
0.5329189300537109,
0.5639657974243164,
0.7153498530387878,
-0.6097049117088318,
-0.5187478065490723,
-0.5726498365402222,
-0.7574739456176758,
0.17883245646953583,
-0.00942312367260456,
-0.2022702693939209,
-0.1838749498128891,
0.665412425994873,
0.2678386867046356,
0.2360711544752121,
-0.258528470993042,
-0.12474407255649567,
0.32103320956230164,
-0.4497503638267517,
-0.10430141538381577,
-0.5359697937965393,
-0.4264513850212097,
-0.08081263303756714,
0.4803573489189148,
0.02941145747900009,
0.19249746203422546,
0.47474685311317444,
-0.21668791770935059,
0.2539387345314026,
0.4884578287601471,
0.40857627987861633,
0.7162460684776306,
-0.2090049535036087,
0.1914132535457611,
0.33646488189697266,
-0.5973544120788574,
0.09165652841329575,
0.006956845987588167,
-0.12206840515136719,
-0.2303001582622528,
0.4623427987098694,
0.2846721410751343,
0.11496010422706604,
-1.1956443786621094,
0.37411627173423767,
-0.19079755246639252,
-0.54742431640625,
-0.19875884056091309,
-0.023632830008864403,
0.3835422992706299,
0.2572377026081085,
0.5082236528396606,
-0.14656631648540497,
0.2709430754184723,
-0.45798459649086,
0.4181405007839203,
0.32535162568092346,
-0.3720744252204895,
-0.11489784717559814,
0.6288678050041199,
-0.10651057958602905,
0.24020595848560333,
0.6224711537361145,
0.39604073762893677,
-0.3510701656341553,
0.5202265381813049,
0.5251112580299377,
0.28357067704200745,
-0.10880399495363235,
0.01357981190085411,
0.5222880244255066,
0.12979459762573242,
-0.11326126009225845,
0.4967145025730133,
0.41834086179733276,
-0.6012197732925415,
-0.6084463000297546,
-0.4155353903770447,
-0.4455887973308563,
0.25842371582984924,
-0.818485677242279,
-0.30785953998565674,
-0.4048456847667694,
-0.1222909614443779,
-0.0879397839307785,
-0.24011032283306122,
-0.7081937789916992,
0.39459121227264404,
0.005700466223061085,
1.0068883895874023,
-0.8101795315742493,
0.7820847034454346,
0.5119205713272095,
-0.44783663749694824,
-1.0006588697433472,
-0.16219721734523773,
-0.033107366412878036,
-1.0251250267028809,
0.5216037034988403,
-0.2626641094684601,
0.0037382261361926794,
-0.20842576026916504,
-0.4682789146900177,
-0.5807473063468933,
1.1080138683319092,
0.2093888223171234,
-0.5554388761520386,
-0.2891046106815338,
0.21184520423412323,
0.6557798385620117,
-0.4037237763404846,
0.0817912220954895,
0.6628698110580444,
0.04301661252975464,
0.15994055569171906,
-0.8564727306365967,
0.2551758289337158,
-0.3092734217643738,
-0.3754480183124542,
0.01587793417274952,
-0.2285417765378952,
0.6167606711387634,
-0.5564005970954895,
-0.07717155665159225,
0.20125199854373932,
0.2680013179779053,
0.5645371079444885,
0.23175065219402313,
0.23025307059288025,
0.32938772439956665,
0.9911165833473206,
0.04232461750507355,
1.0519795417785645,
-0.14988651871681213,
0.013796471990644932,
1.1310508251190186,
-0.30447208881378174,
1.0283581018447876,
0.4696761965751648,
-0.041850317269563675,
0.44133806228637695,
0.4665164351463318,
0.22983208298683167,
0.4593484699726105,
0.40066367387771606,
-0.2747882902622223,
-0.46423104405403137,
-0.05395243316888809,
-0.535994827747345,
0.16510172188282013,
0.48632416129112244,
-0.8303849697113037,
0.02556581050157547,
0.19809579849243164,
-0.07712869346141815,
-0.014081631787121296,
-0.4210687279701233,
1.141845941543579,
0.26191219687461853,
-0.7501240968704224,
0.8548139929771423,
-0.44944924116134644,
0.23133283853530884,
-0.6557193994522095,
-0.2757017910480499,
-0.30841875076293945,
0.0651678591966629,
-0.04707908630371094,
-0.845384955406189,
-0.018864627927541733,
-0.1286499947309494,
-0.3535662591457367,
0.203471839427948,
0.6571720242500305,
-0.45553159713745117,
-0.384765625,
0.11268408596515656,
0.8169741630554199,
0.18214914202690125,
0.19015654921531677,
-0.4074113368988037,
-0.3354399502277374,
0.04369654506444931,
-0.006733270362019539,
0.46806612610816956,
0.42930206656455994,
-0.02247067168354988,
0.9686443209648132,
0.48771992325782776,
0.4609188437461853,
0.1275571584701538,
0.20547764003276825,
0.9493606090545654,
-0.8018712401390076,
-0.09030460566282272,
-0.4837186932563782,
0.1326194405555725,
0.12690037488937378,
-0.1582392156124115,
0.5673656463623047,
0.6546337604522705,
0.5423440933227539,
-0.28733259439468384,
0.9060200452804565,
0.19305501878261566,
0.9266183376312256,
-0.8659110069274902,
0.9687901735305786,
-0.5315255522727966,
0.27976223826408386,
-0.03361314535140991,
-0.18771547079086304,
-0.34285297989845276,
0.3520694673061371,
-0.2476835995912552,
-0.035263776779174805,
0.917117178440094,
0.762776255607605,
0.1955561339855194,
0.08991320431232452,
0.273762583732605,
0.4925232529640198,
0.2342931032180786,
1.1364624500274658,
0.9912413358688354,
-0.36728084087371826,
0.47391366958618164,
0.21176517009735107,
-0.11187885701656342,
0.014625007286667824,
-0.4518861770629883,
-0.9998186230659485,
-0.5681948065757751,
-0.015381359495222569,
-0.636076807975769,
0.1958649903535843,
0.9175176620483398,
0.44249364733695984,
-0.9193257689476013,
0.08388008922338486,
0.29158642888069153,
-0.1296985149383545,
-0.12151854485273361,
-0.0886034145951271,
0.6153995990753174,
-0.23236967623233795,
-0.17871034145355225,
0.3639570474624634,
-0.055935632437467575,
0.11048620194196701,
-0.12369387596845627,
-0.10996020585298538,
-0.2648221552371979,
0.04884760454297066,
0.3947222828865051,
0.3114057779312134,
-0.5383386611938477,
-0.05322321876883507,
0.21912366151809692,
-0.3186573386192322,
-0.04494388401508331,
1.077030062675476,
-0.8357235193252563,
0.28461742401123047,
0.5069672465324402,
0.9148816466331482,
0.5910979509353638,
-0.09183094650506973,
0.7293199896812439,
-0.21613569557666779,
-0.46487414836883545,
0.41138043999671936,
0.4748614728450775,
0.16253869235515594,
0.07660689949989319,
0.2530607283115387,
-0.16637232899665833,
-0.767742395401001,
-0.5268241763114929,
0.12500402331352234,
-0.9008752703666687,
-0.4764363467693329,
1.2500780820846558,
-0.09139297902584076,
0.03054150938987732,
-0.495553195476532,
-0.5775106549263,
0.1046086996793747,
0.05626404285430908,
0.9041407108306885,
0.5084434151649475,
-0.03970295190811157,
-0.1713685244321823,
-0.9458792805671692,
0.6549203991889954,
0.387937992811203,
-0.9883091449737549,
0.054969724267721176,
0.6571637988090515,
0.7679299116134644,
-0.24765822291374207,
0.8735546469688416,
-0.5972961187362671,
0.4677298367023468,
-0.2640034854412079,
0.09604452550411224,
0.07294692099094391,
-0.06910011917352676,
-0.29851776361465454,
0.38595280051231384,
0.4411729574203491,
0.08972401916980743
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.06641v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.06641v1
|
Investigation of the Impact of Economic and Social Factors on Energy Demand through Natural Language Processing
| 2024-06-09T16:25:14 | 2024-06-09T16:25:14 |
Yun Bai, Simon Camal, Andrea Michiorri
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
The relationship between energy demand and variables such as economic
activity and weather is well established. However, this paper aims to explore
the connection between energy demand and other social aspects, which receive
little attention. Through the use of natural language processing on a large
news corpus, we shed light on this important link. This study was carried out
in five regions of the UK and Ireland and considers multiple horizons from 1 to
30 days. It also considers economic variables such as GDP, unemployment and
inflation. We found that: 1) News about military conflicts, transportation, the
global pandemic, regional economics, and the international energy market are
related to electricity demand. 2) Economic indicators are more important in the
East Midlands and Northern Ireland, while social indicators are more useful in
the West Midlands and the South West of England. 3) The use of these indices
improved forecasting performance by up to 9%.
|
[
-0.39702093601226807,
-0.7204821705818176,
0.66283118724823,
0.2621362805366516,
-0.07289853692054749,
0.06295115500688553,
-0.10662467032670975,
-0.9859368801116943,
0.7088524103164673,
0.4074784517288208,
-0.18960103392601013,
-0.0945218950510025,
-0.39984509348869324,
0.21893729269504547,
-0.216208815574646,
0.5435130596160889,
0.09667688608169556,
0.005730407312512398,
0.062238819897174835,
0.0802183747291565,
-0.27697232365608215,
-0.1396825611591339,
-0.6999756693840027,
-0.4458463191986084,
0.45767366886138916,
0.1561582237482071,
0.6901441812515259,
0.19035926461219788,
0.7561741471290588,
0.315158486366272,
0.08221221715211868,
0.017415525391697884,
-0.37916046380996704,
0.1219152882695198,
-0.27794551849365234,
-0.04986347258090973,
-0.1501380354166031,
0.4401543438434601,
0.8270912766456604,
0.48582524061203003,
0.06883365660905838,
0.27765408158302307,
0.3070765733718872,
0.9092161655426025,
-0.5039893388748169,
0.48208409547805786,
-0.7409886121749878,
-0.2161647230386734,
-0.12109249085187912,
-0.4748159348964691,
-0.07867571711540222,
-0.34288159012794495,
0.3274863362312317,
-0.32113343477249146,
0.3158027231693268,
0.261483371257782,
0.8498981595039368,
-0.1265900582075119,
-0.6406459808349609,
-0.3377777636051178,
-0.6108341217041016,
0.9371770620346069,
-0.11720243096351624,
0.5869525074958801,
0.5404192209243774,
0.1392824947834015,
-0.2396165132522583,
-0.4476551115512848,
-0.148239403963089,
0.03404665365815163,
-0.38885098695755005,
0.0836377665400505,
-0.2737245559692383,
0.12601660192012787,
0.08463285118341446,
0.21995563805103302,
-0.14654484391212463,
-0.19097325205802917,
-0.9883831739425659,
-0.12190932780504227,
0.7004182934761047,
0.04029059782624245,
0.40344080328941345,
-0.6733034253120422,
-0.42093583941459656,
0.2303113043308258,
-0.7370132207870483,
0.3240739703178406,
0.6506304144859314,
0.6427422761917114,
-0.5178476572036743,
0.41395333409309387,
-0.16761630773544312,
0.47743719816207886,
-0.17990776896476746,
0.11923934519290924,
-0.17873014509677887,
-0.41519394516944885,
0.31646397709846497,
0.5571593046188354,
0.2644355893135071,
0.8736147284507751,
0.056063923984766006,
0.19467517733573914,
0.2730347812175751,
-0.18296842277050018,
0.12490572780370712,
-0.9036973118782043,
-0.08871512115001678,
-0.03180772066116333,
-0.4167986214160919,
0.027777155861258507,
0.18700529634952545,
-1.1962887048721313,
-0.3022339940071106,
-0.46234187483787537,
0.14214693009853363,
0.2201116532087326,
-0.3571886420249939,
0.14605340361595154,
-0.509274959564209,
0.1861443668603897,
0.021332023665308952,
-0.7121025323867798,
0.45018312335014343,
0.44163191318511963,
0.9418400526046753,
0.5014070272445679,
0.09036406874656677,
-0.5046004056930542,
0.056705452501773834,
0.18811026215553284,
0.9769372344017029,
-0.9100310802459717,
-0.030764803290367126,
0.018223844468593597,
0.40988457202911377,
-0.052299614995718,
-0.08068054169416428,
0.06633758544921875,
-0.4088001251220703,
0.37435436248779297,
-0.650160014629364,
-0.2284659445285797,
-0.3030892610549927,
-0.10025182366371155,
-0.8090553283691406,
0.8950799703598022,
0.10386383533477783,
-0.7731057405471802,
0.4978157877922058,
-0.8877538442611694,
-0.6996204257011414,
0.1376112699508667,
0.006856575142592192,
0.18512223660945892,
0.2243691235780716,
-0.031205113977193832,
0.48841434717178345,
-0.6862250566482544,
0.18226023018360138,
-0.27364489436149597,
0.1995469331741333,
0.06510400027036667,
-0.4595850706100464,
0.4111175239086151,
0.003894534893333912,
-0.39663925766944885,
-0.554945707321167,
-0.9659825563430786,
-0.49037373065948486,
-0.14902888238430023,
-0.28454816341400146,
-0.5270906686782837,
0.6392151713371277,
0.2948102653026581,
0.1689043641090393,
0.3240397572517395,
-0.8122320771217346,
-0.007775892503559589,
-0.41557714343070984,
0.6292961835861206,
0.5774520635604858,
0.5435163378715515,
0.4123559892177582,
-0.1903519183397293,
0.5147309899330139,
-0.31225311756134033,
0.130008265376091,
0.40007951855659485,
-0.5288982391357422,
-0.5586206316947937,
0.19506563246250153,
-0.05938735604286194,
0.36980900168418884,
-0.5550293326377869,
-0.129841610789299,
0.47847142815589905,
-0.40585777163505554,
-0.4915509819984436,
-0.19397825002670288,
-0.13795126974582672,
0.3478986620903015,
0.2086106240749359,
0.16085366904735565,
-0.9681893587112427,
-0.6068890690803528,
-0.5502670407295227,
-0.11082005500793457,
0.08955170214176178,
0.2837758958339691,
0.20386451482772827,
0.02412012591958046,
0.9641332626342773,
-0.35343506932258606,
-0.21821381151676178,
-0.22947528958320618,
0.2935648560523987,
0.5806333422660828,
0.28510016202926636,
0.8715295195579529,
-0.8410317897796631,
-0.5811283588409424,
0.1997285634279251,
-0.12326210737228394,
-0.43585801124572754,
-0.358298122882843,
-0.38496699929237366,
0.11583895981311798,
0.11935097724199295,
-0.12737327814102173,
0.35072240233421326,
0.5784106850624084,
-0.6159619688987732,
0.26714229583740234,
-0.32364657521247864,
0.3139270842075348,
-0.6559044718742371,
-0.15448810160160065,
0.7049025893211365,
-0.07982087880373001,
-0.4917210340499878,
-0.2765023410320282,
-0.31939494609832764,
-0.3799360394477844,
-0.5120609402656555,
0.5791735053062439,
-0.5418732762336731,
-0.04068133607506752,
-0.045947927981615067,
-0.006339598912745714,
0.6527135372161865,
-0.19010882079601288,
0.0340588204562664,
0.5614233016967773,
0.6011573076248169,
-0.5468552708625793,
0.3326987326145172,
-0.44058823585510254,
-0.3926337659358978,
0.1516341269016266,
-0.5732046365737915,
0.08073188364505768,
-0.06444233655929565,
-0.19472205638885498,
-0.6588982939720154,
-0.35731321573257446,
-0.43712398409843445,
-0.12311715632677078,
-0.1549472212791443,
0.04846462979912758,
-0.07560969144105911,
-0.15548497438430786,
-0.22298075258731842,
-0.4997864067554474,
0.34804731607437134,
-0.19300517439842224,
0.8241816759109497,
0.5088281035423279,
-0.14312858879566193,
0.1087677851319313,
-0.3563438951969147,
-0.13119150698184967,
-0.2146855592727661,
-0.6570618152618408,
0.3220079243183136,
0.369734525680542,
-0.9330288767814636,
0.07347692549228668,
-0.34031057357788086,
0.21546457707881927,
0.11462870240211487,
0.29380542039871216,
0.09129232913255692,
-0.05353410169482231,
0.0748102143406868,
-0.29926949739456177,
-0.05299852043390274,
0.6638944745063782,
-0.11445965617895126,
0.40309301018714905,
0.09805210679769516,
0.30951809883117676,
-0.4379638433456421,
0.7350220084190369,
0.5003568530082703,
0.12602993845939636,
1.0288290977478027,
0.39329344034194946,
-0.4797794222831726,
0.25326865911483765,
-0.5541253089904785,
-0.07224024832248688,
-0.5494375824928284,
-0.02232734113931656,
0.10195140540599823,
-0.5442759990692139,
0.2621750831604004,
0.17108388245105743,
0.16144077479839325,
0.8821214437484741,
0.16208313405513763,
-0.23708128929138184,
1.069016695022583,
0.44847986102104187,
-0.09613599628210068,
0.8124873638153076,
-0.2761441469192505,
0.33582624793052673,
-0.5987728238105774,
-0.1306852102279663,
-0.8855397701263428,
-0.39050787687301636,
-0.9436065554618835,
-0.02094913087785244,
0.39591240882873535,
-0.17931093275547028,
0.05940530449151993,
0.2932373583316803,
-0.24325071275234222,
0.49691876769065857,
0.09790980070829391,
0.08397400379180908,
-0.10126585513353348,
0.066329725086689,
0.22106531262397766,
0.035310011357069016,
-0.26825109124183655,
-0.5216694474220276,
0.5363132357597351,
0.009957099333405495,
0.5267149806022644,
0.10668770223855972,
0.3434912860393524,
0.602787435054779,
0.22988273203372955,
-0.6977999806404114,
0.11003464460372925,
-0.18878038227558136,
-0.6516258716583252,
-0.18517521023750305,
-0.6764510273933411,
-1.3923027515411377,
0.004365717060863972,
-0.3070630431175232,
-0.6144837737083435,
0.372961163520813,
-0.18868622183799744,
-0.45782002806663513,
0.26145145297050476,
-0.9234870076179504,
0.4690248966217041,
-0.2340189516544342,
-0.5344734191894531,
-0.6239551901817322,
-0.012151817791163921,
-0.180768683552742,
0.5876803994178772,
0.7708182334899902,
-0.5612884759902954,
0.533713161945343,
0.7546678781509399,
-0.3369508981704712,
0.7765024900436401,
-0.4536672532558441,
0.07166343182325363,
0.3543774485588074,
-0.602439284324646,
0.6906423568725586,
0.0960504487156868,
-0.5140621066093445,
-0.0770237147808075,
0.029521536082029343,
-0.6320623159408569,
-0.3889390528202057,
0.8180834650993347,
-0.9029059410095215,
-0.9021963477134705,
-0.5799812078475952,
-0.16785891354084015,
-0.1030174270272255,
-0.1928168386220932,
0.34771236777305603,
1.0007456541061401,
-0.2614802122116089,
0.19659408926963806,
0.11326292902231216,
0.05765039101243019,
0.7053326368331909,
0.35811612010002136,
-0.2690541446208954,
-0.2616647779941559,
0.7317725419998169,
0.6906588077545166,
0.4758300483226776,
0.5621340274810791,
0.6521533727645874,
-0.06385377049446106,
-0.023574577644467354,
0.05925057455897331,
0.11601224541664124,
-0.28687092661857605,
-0.1594560444355011,
-0.6633827686309814,
-0.01125221699476242,
-0.7357791066169739,
-0.49088379740715027,
-0.08508019149303436,
0.02034185454249382,
-0.484511137008667,
-0.37723687291145325,
0.8285179138183594,
0.8583016395568848,
-0.27552488446235657,
0.32014140486717224,
-0.7708972692489624,
0.3364233076572418,
0.472502738237381,
0.1692589670419693,
-0.16254448890686035,
0.18464279174804688,
-0.6393235325813293,
0.008284754119813442,
-0.2606004774570465,
-1.0113309621810913,
0.8437820076942444,
0.2433173805475235,
0.24435023963451385,
0.5938963890075684,
0.3674130141735077,
0.6509771347045898,
-0.43241626024246216,
0.8198375701904297,
0.4752908945083618,
-0.8636016249656677,
0.594650387763977,
-0.20294131338596344,
0.3970709443092346,
0.5045533180236816,
0.5319274663925171,
-0.5368695855140686,
-0.08017867803573608,
-0.6811206936836243,
-1.0508207082748413,
0.4603345990180969,
0.20376290380954742,
0.10050427913665771,
-0.18294933438301086,
0.09190206974744797,
0.08624257892370224,
-0.026309996843338013,
-0.26364827156066895,
-0.05267885699868202,
0.0009474587859585881,
0.4620964825153351,
0.12278543412685394,
-0.13746261596679688,
0.259966105222702,
-0.514614462852478,
0.42309197783470154,
0.3012649118900299,
0.2683081030845642,
0.4658408463001251,
0.21171332895755768,
-0.3271137475967407,
0.3816268742084503,
0.40024441480636597,
0.6492202877998352,
-0.6182540059089661,
0.19706475734710693,
0.2249530851840973,
-0.8079050183296204,
-0.04714678227901459,
0.11694188416004181,
-0.03855195641517639,
0.5802956819534302,
-0.049112044274806976,
0.808606743812561,
0.4358300566673279,
-0.17075194418430328,
-0.17426887154579163,
-0.35885724425315857,
-0.33876925706863403,
-0.561533510684967,
0.07783148437738419,
-0.11741849035024643,
0.41110315918922424,
0.6246078610420227,
0.17992328107357025,
0.461447536945343,
-1.1601461172103882,
-0.48320940136909485,
0.15415222942829132,
-0.7690258026123047,
-0.6355034708976746,
0.5069136023521423,
0.6962419748306274,
-0.5295975208282471,
0.13851645588874817,
-0.12117794156074524,
-0.665413498878479,
0.9393198490142822,
0.4762852191925049,
0.46818870306015015,
-0.011832799762487411,
0.09412290155887604,
0.14288529753684998,
0.5031672120094299,
0.12631037831306458,
1.0512298345565796,
0.16925422847270966,
-0.43063119053840637,
-0.3373143672943115,
-0.6526682376861572,
-0.42638489603996277,
-0.12254324555397034,
-0.9052780270576477,
0.4515136480331421,
-0.32686692476272583,
-0.42059043049812317,
0.27541181445121765,
0.7791469097137451,
-1.316799521446228,
0.0976967141032219,
0.018138598650693893,
0.6915267109870911,
-0.9765340089797974,
0.6580081582069397,
0.7817643880844116,
0.0016797236166894436,
-0.7714818120002747,
-0.35183557868003845,
-0.1476840227842331,
-0.41555577516555786,
0.4460946023464203,
0.43433690071105957,
-0.1671658456325531,
-0.27395984530448914,
-0.5021034479141235,
-1.3490426540374756,
0.8243857622146606,
0.2780100405216217,
-0.6613152027130127,
0.25892215967178345,
0.003832264570519328,
0.23958316445350647,
-0.47552719712257385,
0.20103058218955994,
0.766529381275177,
1.0270286798477173,
-0.41667911410331726,
-0.5249779224395752,
-0.23353926837444305,
-0.3854173719882965,
-0.3597666621208191,
0.8956225514411926,
-1.0075814723968506,
0.4542902708053589,
0.22376315295696259,
-0.496338814496994,
-0.5216496586799622,
0.47357097268104553,
-0.17010532319545746,
0.6989684104919434,
0.5568782687187195,
-0.18333342671394348,
0.9142546057701111,
0.022262178361415863,
1.0941455364227295,
-0.6156677603721619,
0.3747899830341339,
0.24449492990970612,
-0.7147730588912964,
0.6717113256454468,
0.6833871603012085,
-0.6829913854598999,
0.6332631707191467,
0.5815075635910034,
0.1934964507818222,
0.7702497243881226,
0.19671615958213806,
-0.32127004861831665,
-0.15719175338745117,
-0.49021244049072266,
-0.6815930008888245,
0.5228528380393982,
0.8116834759712219,
-0.27852725982666016,
-0.3588220477104187,
0.07900100946426392,
-0.10323666036128998,
-0.16720277070999146,
-0.5486942529678345,
0.539198100566864,
0.10921189934015274,
-0.23401643335819244,
-0.08410508930683136,
-0.07684987038373947,
0.5006828308105469,
-0.6513544321060181,
-0.08857016265392303,
0.07765590399503708,
-0.20466598868370056,
-0.3191336691379547,
-0.34106600284576416,
0.6463676691055298,
0.26030540466308594,
-0.5187281370162964,
-0.5614383816719055,
0.9002284407615662,
-0.11018849909305573,
-0.7591847777366638,
0.5491903424263,
0.12654034793376923,
0.06912334263324738,
-0.015689237043261528,
-0.17657528817653656,
-0.24808639287948608,
0.09713339805603027,
-0.4282631278038025,
0.6339039206504822,
0.5253128409385681,
0.7283452749252319,
-0.3310014009475708,
0.6002023220062256,
0.16261522471904755,
-0.2738338112831116,
0.08700086921453476,
0.5774416327476501,
-0.951331615447998,
-0.35813701152801514,
-0.5835452675819397,
0.005325563717633486,
-0.35617130994796753,
-0.556159257888794,
0.6639699935913086,
0.2524518072605133,
0.3334396183490753,
0.5468242764472961,
0.7211145162582397,
-0.2839425802230835,
0.3657395839691162,
-0.7348278164863586,
0.7374489307403564,
-0.33881208300590515,
0.08704286068677902,
-0.07372522354125977,
-0.8337349891662598,
0.2225247174501419,
0.3708634674549103,
-0.7860802412033081,
-0.34148237109184265,
0.6608728766441345,
0.3175438940525055,
0.26285964250564575,
0.5734898447990417,
0.19577571749687195,
-0.015229140408337116,
0.20879791676998138,
0.005159681662917137,
0.553865909576416,
-0.09503333270549774,
0.12134898453950882,
-0.5605716109275818,
0.01839975081384182,
-0.13675552606582642,
-0.8032099008560181,
-0.5250436067581177,
-0.35927388072013855,
-0.42869481444358826,
-0.3944440484046936,
-0.009234275668859482,
1.4368525743484497,
0.5210409164428711,
-0.8055545687675476,
-0.46860092878341675,
0.21305997669696808,
0.35747408866882324,
-0.372877299785614,
-0.35822463035583496,
0.5491084456443787,
-0.3144742250442505,
-0.6232526898384094,
0.4620192348957062,
0.35574275255203247,
-0.2945493757724762,
-0.34199538826942444,
0.6115998029708862,
-0.7030569314956665,
0.45371657609939575,
0.8794101476669312,
-0.06460060924291611,
-0.12800078094005585,
-0.5405071377754211,
0.20824161171913147,
0.10403058677911758,
0.21308104693889618,
0.8347930312156677,
-0.7326360940933228,
-0.03494994714856148,
0.7054802775382996,
0.37833818793296814,
0.3022179901599884,
-0.33258315920829773,
0.6326393485069275,
-0.8643346428871155,
-0.057003140449523926,
-0.24815820157527924,
0.90639328956604,
0.3354356288909912,
-0.8861366510391235,
0.3619651198387146,
0.4412408769130707,
-0.8347617983818054,
-0.2436530739068985,
-0.10213550925254822,
-0.5568530559539795,
-0.043266091495752335,
1.1771999597549438,
0.057623717933893204,
-0.4216235280036926,
-0.5218355059623718,
-0.1032237783074379,
-0.06418153643608093,
-1.0708198547363281,
1.0603770017623901,
1.046033263206482,
-0.25082045793533325,
-0.30856648087501526,
-0.937256932258606,
-0.12441641092300415,
0.18787027895450592,
-0.4410769045352936,
-0.09575249254703522,
0.5815882682800293,
-0.07946981489658356,
0.10670115053653717,
0.13052593171596527,
0.48082950711250305,
-0.20444516837596893,
0.1374901682138443,
-0.12711597979068756,
0.7059552073478699,
-0.2613806128501892,
0.018430020660161972,
0.41133686900138855,
-0.5284450650215149,
-0.031811535358428955
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.05814v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.05814v1
|
Unified Text-to-Image Generation and Retrieval
| 2024-06-09T15:00:28 | 2024-06-09T15:00:28 |
Leigang Qu, Haochuan Li, Tan Wang, Wenjie Wang, Yongqi Li, Liqiang Nie, Tat-Seng Chua
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.MM
|
How humans can efficiently and effectively acquire images has always been a
perennial question. A typical solution is text-to-image retrieval from an
existing database given the text query; however, the limited database typically
lacks creativity. By contrast, recent breakthroughs in text-to-image generation
have made it possible to produce fancy and diverse visual content, but it faces
challenges in synthesizing knowledge-intensive images. In this work, we rethink
the relationship between text-to-image generation and retrieval and propose a
unified framework in the context of Multimodal Large Language Models (MLLMs).
Specifically, we first explore the intrinsic discriminative abilities of MLLMs
and introduce a generative retrieval method to perform retrieval in a
training-free manner. Subsequently, we unify generation and retrieval in an
autoregressive generation way and propose an autonomous decision module to
choose the best-matched one between generated and retrieved images as the
response to the text query. Additionally, we construct a benchmark called
TIGeR-Bench, including creative and knowledge-intensive domains, to standardize
the evaluation of unified text-to-image generation and retrieval. Extensive
experimental results on TIGeR-Bench and two retrieval benchmarks, i.e.,
Flickr30K and MS-COCO, demonstrate the superiority and effectiveness of our
proposed method.
|
[
-0.42937013506889343,
-0.5917472839355469,
0.5655127763748169,
0.14603504538536072,
-0.5468168258666992,
-0.03739006444811821,
-0.37741246819496155,
-0.5772269368171692,
-0.0579519122838974,
0.542952835559845,
-0.2519789934158325,
-0.39608824253082275,
-0.3658718764781952,
0.2883771061897278,
-0.5094339847564697,
0.7353901267051697,
0.1449504941701889,
-0.22385722398757935,
-0.4010901153087616,
-0.39196082949638367,
-0.47266560792922974,
-0.4148206114768982,
-0.5052812099456787,
-0.04954604431986809,
0.5784687995910645,
0.09522239863872528,
0.5500701069831848,
0.7054916024208069,
0.63783198595047,
0.278482586145401,
0.21203367412090302,
0.40012112259864807,
-0.3136298954486847,
0.3499191701412201,
-0.4262833595275879,
-0.11021790653467178,
0.3112718164920807,
-0.36006397008895874,
0.5534636378288269,
0.32611340284347534,
0.06008872762322426,
0.09923045337200165,
-0.04832903668284416,
0.8864927887916565,
-0.9118673801422119,
-0.033541638404130936,
-1.0388550758361816,
0.1941436231136322,
-0.19885481894016266,
-0.3826034665107727,
-0.5431216955184937,
-0.1552807241678238,
-0.010053370147943497,
-0.5983578562736511,
0.35946378111839294,
0.06369312852621078,
0.7007009387016296,
0.07609064131975174,
-0.8053268790245056,
-0.511543333530426,
-0.6954599022865295,
0.6845815181732178,
-0.2446722686290741,
0.39104971289634705,
0.019252648577094078,
0.33053314685821533,
0.061753712594509125,
-0.9284175634384155,
-0.6128039956092834,
-0.15151116251945496,
-0.12458890676498413,
0.10056990385055542,
-0.23709271848201752,
-0.1796744465827942,
-0.008249543607234955,
0.46759921312332153,
-0.6399056315422058,
-0.12740100920200348,
-0.14938831329345703,
-0.03368255868554115,
0.8304412961006165,
0.017367593944072723,
0.4337582588195801,
-0.4812372028827667,
-0.5418351888656616,
-0.2974315285682678,
-0.6721420884132385,
-0.2838675081729889,
0.012580705806612968,
0.2229028046131134,
0.47456133365631104,
0.7124026417732239,
-0.11006025224924088,
0.6152215600013733,
-0.07079748064279556,
0.04281452298164368,
0.03953126072883606,
-0.27058354020118713,
-0.15173302590847015,
-0.37482091784477234,
1.2719465494155884,
0.45043396949768066,
0.1434316188097,
-0.3651945888996124,
-0.5549967885017395,
0.0535162054002285,
0.290070116519928,
-0.7768613696098328,
-0.31630608439445496,
-0.22788076102733612,
-0.3692031800746918,
-0.3631570041179657,
0.07242792844772339,
-0.987139880657196,
-0.18235665559768677,
-0.3695884346961975,
0.7245545387268066,
-0.3193514347076416,
-0.31940576434135437,
-0.24136734008789062,
-0.1679711937904358,
0.018059637397527695,
0.19646354019641876,
-0.8453467488288879,
-0.11594654619693756,
-0.029815388843417168,
0.4097179174423218,
-0.3464958667755127,
-0.05670178681612015,
-0.24795469641685486,
0.3537895083427429,
-0.5178892016410828,
0.958977222442627,
-0.24127773940563202,
-0.5989071130752563,
0.17016686499118805,
-0.22673280537128448,
0.04453219473361969,
-0.5870826840400696,
0.3948272168636322,
-0.6019535064697266,
0.26910972595214844,
-0.21914620697498322,
-0.25346770882606506,
-0.04677918553352356,
0.014721917919814587,
-0.8055498003959656,
1.0274722576141357,
-0.13781484961509705,
-0.7737523913383484,
0.458378404378891,
-0.6196713447570801,
-0.6122262477874756,
0.26652857661247253,
-0.6587575674057007,
-0.3948013484477997,
0.17695467174053192,
0.4166828393936157,
0.7006356716156006,
-0.6458503007888794,
0.48719143867492676,
-0.15925408899784088,
-0.08425495028495789,
0.2545848786830902,
-0.5671205520629883,
0.41472098231315613,
0.437441885471344,
-0.28911542892456055,
-0.19764305651187897,
-0.6849647760391235,
0.2756929099559784,
0.6405661702156067,
-0.5317129492759705,
-0.45316916704177856,
0.056995127350091934,
0.33119165897369385,
0.3296927809715271,
0.17272894084453583,
-0.4677848517894745,
0.15563930571079254,
0.273507684469223,
0.2955365478992462,
0.627710223197937,
0.0724409818649292,
0.5066917538642883,
-0.06753065437078476,
-0.027477160096168518,
0.017023487016558647,
-0.018050404265522957,
-0.6686258912086487,
-0.25121983885765076,
-0.6589689254760742,
-0.2837379574775696,
0.05318857729434967,
0.3265201151371002,
-1.1464241743087769,
0.24246294796466827,
-0.34759286046028137,
-0.39873385429382324,
-0.5029693245887756,
0.33725592494010925,
0.5944971442222595,
0.35500723123550415,
0.43514689803123474,
-0.4560037851333618,
-0.4186967611312866,
-0.9344452023506165,
-0.26618361473083496,
-0.052577730268239975,
-0.22137638926506042,
0.5943282246589661,
0.39700475335121155,
-0.322494238615036,
0.8665658831596375,
-0.5346377491950989,
-0.30064862966537476,
0.07294584810733795,
0.4045037031173706,
-0.28636565804481506,
0.5480717420578003,
0.6929296851158142,
-1.1384472846984863,
-0.5327903032302856,
0.12947998940944672,
-1.0804744958877563,
0.2896829843521118,
-0.08885693550109863,
-0.29908013343811035,
0.4948200285434723,
0.5489313006401062,
-0.7987948656082153,
0.4073229432106018,
0.18613965809345245,
-0.12502236664295197,
0.5680106282234192,
-0.261165976524353,
0.396160364151001,
-1.1544511318206787,
0.4934239387512207,
0.13369162380695343,
-0.15619294345378876,
-0.22337442636489868,
0.3663983643054962,
0.254807710647583,
-0.20312146842479706,
-0.18272145092487335,
0.6201075911521912,
-0.677009642124176,
-0.1660451889038086,
-0.05669969320297241,
0.11852364242076874,
0.28044378757476807,
0.5146803855895996,
0.06286963820457458,
0.7647101283073425,
0.602019727230072,
-0.7030236124992371,
0.3978448510169983,
0.10400553047657013,
-0.4073863923549652,
0.7383296489715576,
-0.5292872190475464,
0.36267516016960144,
-0.4622339606285095,
0.19413629174232483,
-0.9298335909843445,
-0.2539590001106262,
-0.16465578973293304,
-0.466288298368454,
0.3997199833393097,
0.34315061569213867,
-0.8470759391784668,
-0.5640944838523865,
-0.05056528002023697,
0.4294262230396271,
0.5966110229492188,
-0.8023664951324463,
0.5745916962623596,
0.36840182542800903,
-0.12417448312044144,
-0.5629774332046509,
-0.620256245136261,
0.27676472067832947,
-0.0580030120909214,
-0.4746464490890503,
0.4893302023410797,
-0.24167059361934662,
-0.0036852904595434666,
0.10541921108961105,
0.18933211266994476,
-0.12158834934234619,
-0.2813962697982788,
-0.020108800381422043,
0.3376696705818176,
-0.24955002963542938,
0.4098787307739258,
0.001503339852206409,
0.21416394412517548,
-0.13585308194160461,
-0.3317165672779083,
0.21450145542621613,
0.07918477058410645,
-0.36298009753227234,
-0.17438748478889465,
0.6832641363143921,
0.5661638975143433,
-0.5529599189758301,
0.2623535990715027,
0.8020508885383606,
-0.09946031123399734,
-0.05687132477760315,
-0.7144648432731628,
-0.05701110512018204,
-0.48732790350914,
0.4114762246608734,
-0.45825818181037903,
-0.6612616181373596,
0.05140143632888794,
-0.06770124286413193,
0.2658590078353882,
0.702235996723175,
0.5777794122695923,
-0.3494095504283905,
1.2174149751663208,
0.7278183698654175,
0.2037971466779709,
0.40433281660079956,
-0.20418405532836914,
-0.22188670933246613,
-0.746568500995636,
-0.47218096256256104,
-0.46037179231643677,
-0.03509695082902908,
-0.382779061794281,
-0.26743239164352417,
0.1815708726644516,
0.10609664767980576,
-0.18376024067401886,
0.36697477102279663,
-0.7942420244216919,
0.4718647003173828,
0.5239070653915405,
0.21059395372867584,
0.5415999293327332,
0.4372236132621765,
-0.6414228677749634,
-0.10820692032575607,
-0.6541228890419006,
-0.3513537645339966,
1.260064959526062,
-0.2813282310962677,
0.651611328125,
0.17044776678085327,
0.5539716482162476,
0.20463421940803528,
0.593137800693512,
-0.47848159074783325,
0.7198129892349243,
-0.4765464961528778,
-0.5566577315330505,
-0.03655674308538437,
-0.5386670231819153,
-1.1947189569473267,
0.43607112765312195,
-0.4292718768119812,
-0.465876042842865,
-0.023953672498464584,
0.061455752700567245,
0.01630220003426075,
0.3688470721244812,
-0.6224765777587891,
0.7229273319244385,
-0.4378758370876312,
-0.49172595143318176,
-0.0442679263651371,
-0.6359273791313171,
0.40749990940093994,
-0.24522291123867035,
0.13940903544425964,
0.06728163361549377,
0.0508103184401989,
0.48465144634246826,
0.17670242488384247,
0.4869641363620758,
0.04570227116346359,
-0.11792151629924774,
0.433170348405838,
0.0750865489244461,
0.048151955008506775,
-0.05670182406902313,
-0.09916656464338303,
-0.11113867163658142,
-0.2897001802921295,
-0.25210604071617126,
-0.6492599248886108,
0.51204514503479,
-0.6623883843421936,
-0.33390703797340393,
0.12253168970346451,
-0.5289595723152161,
-0.00011432804603828117,
0.3174234628677368,
0.5792650580406189,
0.6275545954704285,
-0.49111998081207275,
0.3566473424434662,
0.6238623261451721,
-0.3106757700443268,
0.6270554065704346,
0.45824795961380005,
-0.4798535704612732,
-0.604921817779541,
1.081180214881897,
-0.16276147961616516,
0.1308673769235611,
0.670352578163147,
-0.13659432530403137,
-0.7379387021064758,
-0.24095292389392853,
-0.7077570557594299,
0.1956261396408081,
-0.8125261068344116,
-0.4304463863372803,
-0.6346871256828308,
-0.16551214456558228,
-0.30233049392700195,
-0.06824309378862381,
-0.27832597494125366,
-0.06883411854505539,
-0.5102804899215698,
0.37212231755256653,
0.16799399256706238,
0.7663997411727905,
-0.022633543238043785,
-0.15605810284614563,
-0.8378610014915466,
0.41632282733917236,
0.6691385507583618,
0.17506979405879974,
0.21810731291770935,
-0.23318836092948914,
-0.03406163677573204,
-0.0569489523768425,
-0.6668780446052551,
-0.5934017300605774,
0.3306639790534973,
0.38521501421928406,
0.6392339468002319,
0.40053412318229675,
0.09659857302904129,
0.6018809676170349,
-0.5579397082328796,
0.5606074929237366,
0.6491689085960388,
-0.5594008564949036,
0.7376465797424316,
-0.3390218913555145,
0.36544692516326904,
0.36390894651412964,
0.23230020701885223,
-0.39117562770843506,
-0.350299596786499,
-0.6016711592674255,
-0.9271058440208435,
0.02719736471772194,
0.3452489674091339,
0.35728567838668823,
-0.016000892966985703,
0.21596798300743103,
0.008285346440970898,
0.2971045970916748,
-0.8333072066307068,
0.04317139461636543,
-0.229537695646286,
-0.31056737899780273,
-0.14433205127716064,
-0.0002669324167072773,
-0.10920748114585876,
-0.16872449219226837,
0.2956617772579193,
-0.27201372385025024,
0.41956424713134766,
0.24581825733184814,
-0.30582794547080994,
-0.2225840538740158,
0.3430383503437042,
0.1403309553861618,
0.2680683135986328,
0.0960826575756073,
0.15286947786808014,
-0.3227074444293976,
-0.30025431513786316,
0.17222312092781067,
0.1273130178451538,
-0.23353217542171478,
0.2027387171983719,
0.10021327435970306,
0.8904738426208496,
0.13246893882751465,
-0.8632007241249084,
0.5755720138549805,
-0.12504246830940247,
-0.37740153074264526,
-0.10333696752786636,
-0.012603620067238808,
-0.12318187952041626,
0.1790783554315567,
0.9385470151901245,
0.18877969682216644,
0.06048516184091568,
-0.5126660466194153,
0.45212849974632263,
0.7206279039382935,
-0.1575475037097931,
-0.13061578571796417,
0.670123815536499,
0.3933359682559967,
-0.10946392267942429,
0.668454647064209,
-0.3569537103176117,
-0.22043196856975555,
0.5261178612709045,
0.6755010485649109,
0.7783505916595459,
0.05236567556858063,
0.38396188616752625,
0.44843146204948425,
0.07360894232988358,
-0.1256503313779831,
0.1325521320104599,
-0.266012966632843,
-0.6999930739402771,
-0.18627206981182098,
-0.5669159293174744,
-0.019627153873443604,
0.08288197964429855,
-0.710660994052887,
0.0463239811360836,
-0.15386804938316345,
-0.28598037362098694,
0.05202937126159668,
-0.1329730898141861,
-0.7327938079833984,
0.3739917278289795,
0.1653551161289215,
0.562892496585846,
-0.3998931050300598,
0.6719321608543396,
0.8669977784156799,
-0.6176426410675049,
-0.7749452590942383,
-0.0720793753862381,
-0.15188974142074585,
-0.6630046367645264,
0.6909862756729126,
0.2722654640674591,
0.13091006875038147,
0.31223735213279724,
-0.7204705476760864,
-0.6166960597038269,
1.326666235923767,
0.34823623299598694,
-0.429220050573349,
-0.10602942854166031,
-0.10029184073209763,
0.4814901053905487,
-0.4046652019023895,
-0.0022926528472453356,
0.1819905787706375,
0.24951623380184174,
0.5307772755622864,
-0.6706886887550354,
0.016557199880480766,
-0.4073638916015625,
0.4198000729084015,
0.2486739158630371,
-0.4082646667957306,
0.877266526222229,
-0.43768686056137085,
-0.5761212110519409,
0.3332330286502838,
0.6377679705619812,
0.4055183231830597,
0.18949677050113678,
0.35961705446243286,
0.660696804523468,
0.41092145442962646,
0.07566539943218231,
0.9191344976425171,
-0.04625839367508888,
0.3846226930618286,
0.7087623476982117,
-0.026915417984128,
1.056965947151184,
0.43944796919822693,
0.021828696131706238,
0.2780854403972626,
0.35941779613494873,
-0.19133251905441284,
0.7371408343315125,
-0.10988308489322662,
-0.5121257305145264,
-0.13198845088481903,
-0.24097897112369537,
-0.2015897035598755,
0.3751237094402313,
0.32892709970474243,
-0.6168781518936157,
-0.3851027488708496,
0.11751967668533325,
-0.3452354669570923,
0.26864323019981384,
-0.30560439825057983,
0.9056196808815002,
0.03918042033910751,
-0.8138277530670166,
0.6435166001319885,
-0.10788102447986603,
0.8772386908531189,
-0.2800571620464325,
0.07941551506519318,
-0.10173479467630386,
0.022178644314408302,
0.03304576128721237,
-0.9752371311187744,
0.06186414882540703,
-0.06259068101644516,
-0.10477466881275177,
-0.18950611352920532,
1.0938879251480103,
-0.7113387584686279,
-0.45025455951690674,
0.16561995446681976,
0.5595334768295288,
-0.026776857674121857,
-0.20708972215652466,
-0.8464488387107849,
-0.04552850499749184,
0.07591509819030762,
-0.1745423972606659,
0.35361701250076294,
0.6210136413574219,
0.13819390535354614,
0.4886230528354645,
0.7343671917915344,
-0.2930130064487457,
-0.05565979331731796,
-0.08936849236488342,
0.8184823393821716,
-0.5126549005508423,
-0.19272162020206451,
-0.6776696443557739,
0.50197434425354,
-0.10677198320627213,
-0.23517559468746185,
0.3281012177467346,
0.42759692668914795,
0.7537357211112976,
-0.33133184909820557,
0.9911120533943176,
-0.2649305760860443,
0.016038093715906143,
-0.5737653970718384,
0.9326416254043579,
-1.0595566034317017,
-0.28300195932388306,
-0.5014482140541077,
-0.8118831515312195,
-0.32541611790657043,
0.34057939052581787,
0.18407003581523895,
-0.07434742152690887,
0.5938205718994141,
0.815288245677948,
-0.00010600326640997082,
-0.13153111934661865,
0.41543853282928467,
-0.13363191485404968,
0.18377970159053802,
0.5509351491928101,
0.8318970799446106,
-0.45807912945747375,
0.9094874858856201,
-0.08813130110502243,
0.05247771739959717,
-0.15686877071857452,
-0.8196671009063721,
-0.755683183670044,
-1.009949803352356,
-0.009404381737112999,
-0.038253966718912125,
-0.04281039535999298,
0.6108794808387756,
0.5721970796585083,
-0.27087026834487915,
-0.09725560992956161,
-0.24296413362026215,
-0.21796591579914093,
0.20251338183879852,
-0.2193101942539215,
0.3243947923183441,
-0.4298055171966553,
-0.6200705170631409,
-0.05038032308220863,
0.46391561627388,
0.41908544301986694,
-0.40594398975372314,
0.018972909078001976,
-0.19284459948539734,
-0.00794097688049078,
0.9954248666763306,
0.49499672651290894,
-0.5613416433334351,
0.1182548999786377,
0.08751705288887024,
-0.6676250696182251,
0.1479545682668686,
0.8900991082191467,
-0.810962975025177,
0.4165729582309723,
0.19197796285152435,
0.8507936000823975,
0.47681525349617004,
-0.18619413673877716,
0.479377418756485,
-0.8735278844833374,
0.11005096882581711,
0.22001880407333374,
0.16323255002498627,
0.680944561958313,
-0.17711104452610016,
0.31021758913993835,
0.3676896393299103,
-0.5019738078117371,
-0.5338718891143799,
0.29477301239967346,
-0.7235289216041565,
-0.4059048593044281,
1.088685154914856,
0.03883238509297371,
-0.16672804951667786,
0.199977308511734,
-0.2909345030784607,
0.2248406708240509,
-0.360083669424057,
0.8124415278434753,
0.286629855632782,
0.11295604705810547,
-0.40545934438705444,
-0.29904356598854065,
0.24382393062114716,
0.37742307782173157,
-0.9395822286605835,
-0.16157382726669312,
0.6819368004798889,
0.12203399091959,
0.3599644601345062,
0.8114243149757385,
-0.23555471003055573,
0.18615654110908508,
-0.04449543356895447,
0.31564468145370483,
0.24351809918880463,
-0.3628416955471039,
0.1386021077632904,
0.1734907478094101,
-0.08821703493595123,
-0.12025514245033264
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.05812v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.05812v1
|
Seventeenth-Century Spanish American Notary Records for Fine-Tuning Spanish Large Language Models
| 2024-06-09T14:54:22 | 2024-06-09T14:54:22 |
Shraboni Sarker, Ahmad Tamim Hamad, Hulayyil Alshammari, Viviana Grieco, Praveen Rao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large language models have gained tremendous popularity in domains such as
e-commerce, finance, healthcare, and education. Fine-tuning is a common
approach to customize an LLM on a domain-specific dataset for a desired
downstream task. In this paper, we present a valuable resource for fine-tuning
LLMs developed for the Spanish language to perform a variety of tasks such as
classification, masked language modeling, clustering, and others. Our resource
is a collection of handwritten notary records from the seventeenth century
obtained from the National Archives of Argentina. This collection contains a
combination of original images and transcribed text (and metadata) of 160+
pages that were handwritten by two notaries, namely, Estenban Agreda de Vergara
and Nicolas de Valdivia y Brisuela nearly 400 years ago. Through empirical
evaluation, we demonstrate that our collection can be used to fine-tune Spanish
LLMs for tasks such as classification and masked language modeling, and can
outperform pre-trained Spanish models and ChatGPT-3.5/ChatGPT-4o. Our resource
will be an invaluable resource for historical text analysis and is publicly
available on GitHub.
|
[
-0.2306579053401947,
-0.5427016615867615,
0.287893146276474,
0.21812140941619873,
-0.4674474895000458,
0.33475685119628906,
-0.47419705986976624,
-0.5408323407173157,
0.40282759070396423,
1.1154639720916748,
-0.5226259827613831,
-0.7449309229850769,
-0.43896132707595825,
0.0284085962921381,
-0.2274903804063797,
0.9782740473747253,
0.23566164076328278,
0.2104831486940384,
0.3014846444129944,
-0.05995529517531395,
-0.16620533168315887,
-0.266383558511734,
-0.8198193311691284,
-0.2268393337726593,
0.26633501052856445,
0.5760350227355957,
0.4691099226474762,
0.9563537836074829,
0.47384175658226013,
0.33463984727859497,
-0.041427381336688995,
0.3990437984466553,
-0.5972924828529358,
0.05421792343258858,
-0.4973068833351135,
-0.4420051872730255,
-0.6402838826179504,
-0.06069876253604889,
0.5697146654129028,
0.5311585664749146,
-0.09325241297483444,
0.1130116879940033,
-0.12892088294029236,
0.6603478193283081,
-0.29379892349243164,
0.36473485827445984,
-0.9321132302284241,
-0.29799455404281616,
-0.7420194149017334,
-0.796613872051239,
-0.22909462451934814,
-0.6122841238975525,
0.05844854936003685,
-0.15631075203418732,
0.6197282075881958,
0.1405583918094635,
0.8591912984848022,
0.45410358905792236,
-0.4397304356098175,
-0.4548549950122833,
-0.6837610006332397,
0.9257392883300781,
-0.6589763164520264,
0.5297051072120667,
0.6836917996406555,
0.4124951660633087,
-0.5739039778709412,
-0.49131613969802856,
-0.1409662961959839,
-0.438290536403656,
0.3387945294380188,
-0.15416695177555084,
-0.3687715232372284,
0.1641278862953186,
0.08709067106246948,
0.6321233510971069,
-0.4314482510089874,
0.37021878361701965,
-0.5959375500679016,
-0.5472339987754822,
0.6378347873687744,
0.09793192893266678,
0.16516681015491486,
0.10954594612121582,
0.04631940275430679,
-0.2281302958726883,
-0.808982253074646,
-0.22817601263523102,
0.5606227517127991,
0.47984904050827026,
-0.042080726474523544,
0.46536684036254883,
-0.18514953553676605,
0.8546112179756165,
0.040936872363090515,
-0.4194587469100952,
0.11207625269889832,
-0.19877241551876068,
-0.23374706506729126,
-0.10685114562511444,
0.5126045346260071,
0.36043307185173035,
0.4189363420009613,
-0.43698883056640625,
-0.33762624859809875,
-0.03767550736665726,
0.1499168872833252,
-0.6276163458824158,
-0.25927290320396423,
-0.19682541489601135,
-0.4510076344013214,
-0.04427380859851837,
-0.0019657269585877657,
-0.7019239664077759,
-0.4809301495552063,
-0.5465415120124817,
-0.006411666050553322,
-0.17012646794319153,
0.10908416658639908,
0.32155558466911316,
-0.12899918854236603,
0.02147061936557293,
0.18646767735481262,
-1.1118484735488892,
0.5171860456466675,
0.7530751824378967,
0.7334738969802856,
-0.05805131047964096,
-0.08406665921211243,
-0.4728347957134247,
0.002529226941987872,
-0.29316237568855286,
0.7366823554039001,
-0.4617772102355957,
-0.31022801995277405,
0.10023411363363266,
0.2239304929971695,
0.15549336373806,
-0.8274133801460266,
0.7252916097640991,
-0.7930352091789246,
-0.14257314801216125,
0.24884313344955444,
-0.3898518681526184,
-0.05049958825111389,
0.383574515581131,
-0.799880862236023,
0.9739819169044495,
0.004936681594699621,
-0.165439173579216,
0.1760750710964203,
-0.1717672199010849,
-0.5258042812347412,
-0.08770248293876648,
0.012716155499219894,
-0.35085591673851013,
0.36110201478004456,
0.10980357974767685,
0.5657852292060852,
-0.6263905763626099,
0.46540728211402893,
-0.3342483639717102,
-0.12015388160943985,
0.0024911074433475733,
-0.4371127784252167,
0.7128465175628662,
0.1619420051574707,
-0.34856483340263367,
0.01782361976802349,
-1.200404405593872,
-0.1533627063035965,
-0.20745007693767548,
-0.42792224884033203,
-0.3986794352531433,
-0.2423943430185318,
0.17141936719417572,
0.05531870946288109,
0.8861216902732849,
-0.565302848815918,
0.0640854761004448,
-0.5358522534370422,
0.6814042925834656,
0.3328928053379059,
0.15447929501533508,
0.3532775342464447,
-0.46527689695358276,
0.6368071436882019,
-0.3303699791431427,
0.1451900452375412,
-0.03079432062804699,
-0.2774396538734436,
-0.9304186105728149,
-0.11160265654325485,
0.32597970962524414,
0.39708930253982544,
-0.4083320200443268,
0.323513388633728,
-0.36538276076316833,
-0.8047710657119751,
-0.28390827775001526,
0.08137877285480499,
0.172263965010643,
0.4212956726551056,
0.4445047676563263,
-0.1699412763118744,
-0.6388154029846191,
-1.0170756578445435,
-0.06351548433303833,
0.034861087799072266,
-0.12495002150535583,
0.5277718305587769,
0.27461978793144226,
-0.16217797994613647,
0.6210432052612305,
-0.3009568154811859,
-0.6850966811180115,
0.24566540122032166,
0.12108790129423141,
0.24460192024707794,
0.26401761174201965,
0.6010770201683044,
-0.1836160123348236,
-0.17762547731399536,
0.2927539646625519,
0.011599634774029255,
-0.36734557151794434,
0.056907929480075836,
-0.016362283378839493,
0.457876980304718,
0.6865533590316772,
0.2395167201757431,
0.06035543233156204,
0.6245853304862976,
-0.21952404081821442,
0.15258730947971344,
-0.6378288269042969,
0.09958517551422119,
-1.0296870470046997,
0.07085362821817398,
0.12471281737089157,
-0.479086309671402,
-0.34351658821105957,
-0.11169680207967758,
0.40839362144470215,
0.21854884922504425,
-0.24620822072029114,
0.6267670392990112,
-0.6370470523834229,
0.14908245205879211,
-0.582477331161499,
0.02049904502928257,
-0.30304068326950073,
0.3317314684391022,
0.3030753433704376,
0.6909120678901672,
0.3925563097000122,
-0.3855797350406647,
-0.013172787614166737,
0.13683277368545532,
-0.15979692339897156,
0.6357031464576721,
-0.5027241706848145,
0.31185483932495117,
-0.156481072306633,
-0.2289169281721115,
-0.6208919286727905,
-0.039800096303224564,
-0.08304163813591003,
-0.08017458766698837,
0.30147939920425415,
-0.4036806523799896,
-0.38954752683639526,
-0.06757541000843048,
-0.362800270318985,
-0.1820230931043625,
0.28387051820755005,
-0.4863370358943939,
0.4354470372200012,
0.7170870304107666,
-0.07882644236087799,
-0.4284456670284271,
-0.7015020847320557,
0.39801016449928284,
-0.1992204785346985,
-0.5988101959228516,
0.46991628408432007,
0.2070360779762268,
-0.03416818007826805,
-0.3147951662540436,
-0.30240482091903687,
-0.42461228370666504,
0.010473190806806087,
0.22271668910980225,
0.36175528168678284,
-0.1515636146068573,
0.04477592557668686,
0.33766964077949524,
-0.19127905368804932,
-0.2980293929576874,
-0.4437214732170105,
0.635669469833374,
-0.08913446962833405,
-0.08190491795539856,
-0.22374852001667023,
-0.05836646258831024,
0.8339977860450745,
-0.2587013840675354,
0.4787991940975189,
-0.08238886296749115,
-0.5103287100791931,
-0.26470616459846497,
-1.0755428075790405,
-0.2971503436565399,
-0.4487117826938629,
-0.003182842396199703,
-0.23859839141368866,
-1.368949055671692,
0.8263123631477356,
-0.1301015019416809,
0.06987648457288742,
0.44775739312171936,
0.6271107792854309,
0.21922951936721802,
0.3800056576728821,
0.6769646406173706,
-0.37371301651000977,
0.8286125659942627,
-0.21967396140098572,
-0.12781567871570587,
-0.5264394879341125,
-0.3211709260940552,
-1.0279735326766968,
-0.338839054107666,
-0.7256403565406799,
-0.44301337003707886,
0.23215489089488983,
-0.10953456163406372,
-0.012340623885393143,
0.48937785625457764,
-0.14359444379806519,
0.6667637825012207,
0.6794713735580444,
0.0839386135339737,
0.6329523921012878,
-0.09148119390010834,
0.3183700144290924,
0.012022089213132858,
-0.35306239128112793,
-1.0056308507919312,
1.1930619478225708,
0.22746045887470245,
0.9221840500831604,
0.16175547242164612,
0.6509166955947876,
0.13245876133441925,
-0.11817183345556259,
-0.677943766117096,
0.38540351390838623,
-0.6021444201469421,
-0.5096586346626282,
-0.2630693018436432,
-0.21369819343090057,
-1.2808040380477905,
-0.1851024180650711,
-0.09484821557998657,
-0.5873430371284485,
0.3703595697879791,
0.5778690576553345,
-0.19549696147441864,
-0.14369291067123413,
-0.5379523634910583,
0.8913194537162781,
-0.2308441400527954,
-0.3237738609313965,
-0.2842332720756531,
-0.6557848453521729,
-0.0019096258329227567,
-0.07286463677883148,
-0.1142144724726677,
-0.029036298394203186,
-0.4317668080329895,
0.5182633996009827,
-0.5364007949829102,
0.9369969367980957,
0.04983306676149368,
-0.032651808112859726,
0.07737711071968079,
0.11581317335367203,
0.7486186623573303,
0.05706963315606117,
-0.3841824233531952,
0.2835340201854706,
0.30473563075065613,
-0.23107866942882538,
-0.4177858233451843,
0.82426518201828,
-0.7604949474334717,
-0.2511977255344391,
-0.20116077363491058,
-0.28789180517196655,
-0.10592509061098099,
0.454073041677475,
0.08091015368700027,
0.5435599684715271,
-0.4124903678894043,
0.2525063157081604,
0.6859424114227295,
0.25280171632766724,
0.4397738575935364,
0.955889880657196,
0.25920745730400085,
-0.24236345291137695,
0.9833689332008362,
0.38755980134010315,
-0.058172713965177536,
0.4629887342453003,
0.16644692420959473,
-0.682334303855896,
-1.1782450675964355,
-0.5592561960220337,
0.3081829249858856,
-0.3133242428302765,
-0.3045528531074524,
-0.42646294832229614,
0.16377510130405426,
-0.28889134526252747,
0.045248936861753464,
-0.31264638900756836,
-0.5071062445640564,
-0.8111327886581421,
0.24984128773212433,
0.4682427644729614,
0.6505728363990784,
0.13965840637683868,
0.3229680061340332,
-0.8640580773353577,
0.11100323498249054,
0.14993177354335785,
0.6024001240730286,
0.06558842211961746,
-0.536475419998169,
0.05147182568907738,
-0.1288851499557495,
-0.10543883591890335,
-0.9750394225120544,
0.3304581642150879,
0.34922271966934204,
0.4066767692565918,
0.3985244631767273,
0.01393959205597639,
0.7459607124328613,
-0.5411658883094788,
0.38395482301712036,
-0.46161678433418274,
-0.8711901307106018,
0.3285362720489502,
-0.7312484979629517,
0.16214630007743835,
1.0209667682647705,
-0.050673238933086395,
-0.6582273840904236,
-0.6229925751686096,
-0.6315085887908936,
-0.7925352454185486,
0.7096179723739624,
-0.21325945854187012,
0.2646517753601074,
-0.13238413631916046,
0.42300933599472046,
0.2282780408859253,
0.4675573706626892,
-0.33954399824142456,
-0.13112016022205353,
-0.1385558545589447,
-0.33896422386169434,
-0.14363424479961395,
-0.13911710679531097,
0.17268843948841095,
-0.017818624153733253,
0.9547566175460815,
-0.18173834681510925,
-0.4608911871910095,
-0.1987539529800415,
-0.41311827301979065,
0.085096575319767,
0.362222284078598,
0.9846598505973816,
0.6747137904167175,
-0.14499743282794952,
0.29701492190361023,
0.08381979912519455,
-0.6541957855224609,
0.0002063774736598134,
0.18436093628406525,
-0.28501880168914795,
-0.3284381330013275,
0.1662587672472,
0.957500159740448,
0.3073553442955017,
-0.7141885161399841,
0.2512262463569641,
0.10411576926708221,
-0.07538890838623047,
-0.4373239278793335,
0.24388082325458527,
0.13560128211975098,
0.41075944900512695,
0.2956673800945282,
-0.09468550980091095,
0.22239309549331665,
-0.5052777528762817,
-0.06481736898422241,
0.5711968541145325,
-0.2520105540752411,
-0.19702740013599396,
0.5479024648666382,
0.18674686551094055,
-0.6066789627075195,
0.3700252175331116,
-0.3011687695980072,
-0.22848549485206604,
0.43216630816459656,
0.5612902641296387,
0.6262702941894531,
0.09583740681409836,
0.06833735853433609,
0.29911911487579346,
0.5594033598899841,
-0.5506304502487183,
0.40031999349594116,
-0.1402158886194229,
-0.5361294746398926,
-0.29539555311203003,
-0.6231632232666016,
-0.49584001302719116,
0.5320119857788086,
-0.3787882328033447,
0.3734130263328552,
-0.6939104795455933,
0.011587696149945259,
-0.05699646472930908,
0.11363684386014938,
-0.6223214268684387,
0.10730041563510895,
-0.2600463330745697,
0.9337450861930847,
-0.7995330095291138,
0.6648593544960022,
0.6169540286064148,
-0.2132854461669922,
-0.5841498970985413,
-0.2602117359638214,
-0.05291294679045677,
-0.9266122579574585,
0.17119431495666504,
-0.4346652030944824,
-0.3867540955543518,
0.328081876039505,
-0.20381933450698853,
-0.9211006760597229,
0.6921525001525879,
0.6963578462600708,
-1.2124526500701904,
0.37688758969306946,
0.07624080777168274,
1.0613641738891602,
0.07128504663705826,
0.20615336298942566,
0.987511932849884,
0.4074786305427551,
0.25004538893699646,
-1.040414810180664,
-0.125508114695549,
-0.14280056953430176,
0.03869706019759178,
0.6467393636703491,
-0.7090082764625549,
0.3777877986431122,
0.2508220374584198,
-0.1209709420800209,
0.23489084839820862,
0.4735172986984253,
0.04076872020959854,
0.17258059978485107,
0.1257699429988861,
0.48623397946357727,
1.1842193603515625,
-0.23224148154258728,
0.5234842300415039,
-0.45229408144950867,
0.1943545937538147,
1.218806505203247,
-0.09106192737817764,
0.7585467100143433,
0.6632553935050964,
-0.11912525445222855,
0.055378176271915436,
0.8329145908355713,
-0.33231475949287415,
0.3577544093132019,
0.3696059286594391,
-0.2874714732170105,
-0.1532915234565735,
-0.11824459582567215,
-0.13219013810157776,
0.5056178569793701,
0.1702662855386734,
-0.5226167440414429,
-0.3980799615383148,
-0.04282438009977341,
0.048195239156484604,
0.22198806703090668,
-0.5824928879737854,
0.8370410203933716,
-0.16157466173171997,
-0.7602555751800537,
0.3876884877681732,
0.24565084278583527,
0.7616745233535767,
-0.2486148327589035,
0.17772403359413147,
-0.152356818318367,
0.16873711347579956,
-0.18649166822433472,
-0.3630724549293518,
0.4513535499572754,
0.16721287369728088,
-0.350061297416687,
-0.2963768243789673,
0.6687721014022827,
-0.5225110650062561,
-0.5068643689155579,
-0.0285613015294075,
0.408708393573761,
0.48579245805740356,
-0.04775695130228996,
-0.3291682302951813,
0.027044398710131645,
-0.03789963200688362,
0.04384420067071915,
0.11234841495752335,
0.33629393577575684,
-0.7145791053771973,
0.3084617257118225,
0.6688690185546875,
0.3001084327697754,
0.34774231910705566,
0.46243715286254883,
0.5420876145362854,
-0.6690399050712585,
-0.5078656673431396,
-0.929780900478363,
0.11711505800485611,
-0.023050673305988312,
-0.6448365449905396,
0.5935567617416382,
0.9162933826446533,
0.8618385195732117,
-0.16443268954753876,
0.5840088725090027,
0.22366352379322052,
0.622165322303772,
-0.46871039271354675,
0.8700349926948547,
-0.3850772976875305,
0.039267268031835556,
-0.0023823375813663006,
-0.9066162109375,
-0.7157281637191772,
0.5523634552955627,
-0.3704756200313568,
-0.0812632218003273,
0.40128064155578613,
1.0649960041046143,
-0.03906456381082535,
0.23164767026901245,
0.12829503417015076,
0.087928906083107,
0.2075396478176117,
0.25880634784698486,
0.5193142890930176,
-0.17536872625350952,
0.5036308169364929,
-0.18777216970920563,
-0.31965580582618713,
-0.31000542640686035,
-1.1547077894210815,
-1.1464728116989136,
-0.6121454834938049,
-0.3119033873081207,
-0.03207843005657196,
0.004906457383185625,
0.9009966850280762,
0.45041048526763916,
-0.8895799517631531,
-0.30355292558670044,
-0.27565011382102966,
0.023563126102089882,
0.21590135991573334,
-0.06323882937431335,
0.3364517390727997,
-0.12068865448236465,
-1.068093180656433,
0.6006933450698853,
0.4705337584018707,
0.5428562164306641,
-0.32485467195510864,
0.13607631623744965,
0.25677189230918884,
-0.09154655039310455,
0.2098817527294159,
0.5021872520446777,
-0.5480985641479492,
-0.24514365196228027,
0.26749321818351746,
-0.13285422325134277,
0.31103938817977905,
0.8560774326324463,
-0.5045002698898315,
0.39970314502716064,
0.6415967345237732,
0.5498480200767517,
0.8448154330253601,
-0.2096562534570694,
0.36474353075027466,
-0.6972546577453613,
0.304317831993103,
0.3943750858306885,
0.364986777305603,
0.3784080147743225,
-0.19542035460472107,
0.4274055063724518,
-0.1264907866716385,
-0.52532559633255,
-0.6391217708587646,
-0.06484688818454742,
-1.222414493560791,
0.21589992940425873,
0.6960868835449219,
0.24825547635555267,
-0.2821049690246582,
-0.3817300498485565,
-0.44155141711235046,
0.3221518099308014,
-0.6053037643432617,
1.0272667407989502,
0.7459496855735779,
-0.02229728363454342,
-0.18582145869731903,
-0.425434410572052,
0.42283812165260315,
0.12509377300739288,
-0.9994907975196838,
-0.06521103531122208,
0.6021396517753601,
0.3449414074420929,
-0.028789523988962173,
0.6545576453208923,
-0.23188039660453796,
0.21023046970367432,
-0.5187240839004517,
0.0273188054561615,
-0.24647638201713562,
-0.3314485251903534,
-0.5372198224067688,
0.1731473058462143,
0.4316807687282562,
-0.17399637401103973
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.05806v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.05806v1
|
Do Prompts Really Prompt? Exploring the Prompt Understanding Capability of Whisper
| 2024-06-09T14:44:59 | 2024-06-09T14:44:59 |
Chih-Kai Yang, Kuan-Po Huang, Hung-yi Lee
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
This research explores the interaction between Whisper, a high-performing
speech recognition model, and information in prompts. Our results unexpectedly
show that Whisper may not fully grasp textual prompts as anticipated.
Additionally, we find that performance improvement is not guaranteed even with
stronger adherence to the topic information in textual prompts. It is also
noted that English prompts generally outperform Mandarin ones on datasets of
both languages, likely due to differences in training data distributions for
these languages. Conversely, we discover that Whisper exhibits awareness of
misleading information in language tokens by effectively ignoring incorrect
language tokens and focusing on the correct ones. In summary, this work raises
questions about Whisper's prompt understanding capability and encourages
further studies.
|
[
-0.036218252032995224,
-0.7477099895477295,
0.829025149345398,
0.38417723774909973,
-0.16563019156455994,
0.05369236692786217,
-0.22609812021255493,
-0.6355512738227844,
0.03171966224908829,
0.13517767190933228,
-0.6843023896217346,
-0.09436477720737457,
-0.665014386177063,
0.1981179565191269,
-0.26490145921707153,
0.6940751671791077,
0.2815639078617096,
0.1067383736371994,
0.0673426166176796,
-0.09459627419710159,
-1.0014078617095947,
-0.6129146218299866,
-0.8668094873428345,
-0.0790252834558487,
0.5826607346534729,
0.33233240246772766,
0.6413958072662354,
0.5172138214111328,
0.1705346703529358,
0.25280287861824036,
-0.5284594297409058,
0.12452003359794617,
-0.32741037011146545,
0.34780246019363403,
0.08026974648237228,
-0.6610096096992493,
0.06714637577533722,
0.261406809091568,
0.8976941108703613,
0.563468337059021,
0.03543062508106232,
0.008331055752933025,
0.3059543967247009,
0.3580705523490906,
-0.38060224056243896,
0.16509681940078735,
-0.7400804162025452,
0.09228020906448364,
-0.2485123872756958,
-0.08192897588014603,
-0.746262788772583,
-0.08002322912216187,
0.8007727861404419,
-0.7267621755599976,
0.428365021944046,
0.3343874216079712,
0.8999196290969849,
0.234793558716774,
-0.22491680085659027,
-0.5855299234390259,
-0.5444521307945251,
0.7077316641807556,
-0.21921296417713165,
0.3641527593135834,
0.5639039278030396,
0.4879092276096344,
-0.034883297979831696,
-0.7011518478393555,
-0.6645521521568298,
-0.2965061366558075,
-0.15831579267978668,
0.2088647335767746,
-0.5468108057975769,
0.15131314098834991,
0.5659210085868835,
0.06294529139995575,
-0.5584226250648499,
0.21248804032802582,
-0.14449159801006317,
-0.5667651891708374,
0.14843609929084778,
0.28817811608314514,
0.46898218989372253,
-0.44339224696159363,
-0.5293626189231873,
-0.0617021769285202,
-0.5809085965156555,
0.7564248442649841,
0.06654923409223557,
0.5767956376075745,
-0.21185924112796783,
0.4799911677837372,
0.2404049038887024,
0.8696956038475037,
-0.024923529475927353,
-0.06345540285110474,
0.020607706159353256,
-0.3504924476146698,
-0.16055522859096527,
0.5558322668075562,
0.5721393823623657,
0.3147241175174713,
0.14651012420654297,
-0.14233770966529846,
-0.07445681840181351,
-0.08231467008590698,
-0.023772653192281723,
-0.4974368214607239,
0.04341112822294235,
0.30411139130592346,
-0.6072778701782227,
-0.03882542997598648,
0.08876989781856537,
-0.22921885550022125,
-0.6691882014274597,
-0.13302403688430786,
0.5896139144897461,
-0.5760275721549988,
-0.4420209228992462,
0.12981493771076202,
-0.7392832040786743,
0.39075085520744324,
0.5582490563392639,
-0.7851421236991882,
-0.09203727543354034,
0.7004233598709106,
0.9389629364013672,
-0.05902017280459404,
-0.5553210973739624,
-0.7257011532783508,
-0.19129504263401031,
-0.2797667384147644,
0.8096851110458374,
-0.6829925775527954,
-0.7435076236724854,
-0.041655533015728,
0.05007792264223099,
-0.5738593339920044,
-0.5865789651870728,
0.6862934231758118,
-0.2596505880355835,
0.31099849939346313,
-0.8709014058113098,
-0.6461940407752991,
-0.11035685241222382,
-0.048788003623485565,
-0.6311752200126648,
0.8105390071868896,
-0.18159519135951996,
-0.8655973076820374,
0.47532251477241516,
-0.28131023049354553,
-0.24433471262454987,
0.15972349047660828,
-0.06731715053319931,
0.13535502552986145,
0.11767678707838058,
0.2421266734600067,
0.3856450617313385,
-0.012755416333675385,
0.3256791830062866,
0.3336883783340454,
-0.5997004508972168,
0.7933182716369629,
-0.7868068814277649,
0.6249014735221863,
0.03374480456113815,
-0.25036418437957764,
0.07658527046442032,
-0.4268479645252228,
-0.19075357913970947,
0.026370298117399216,
-0.06061108782887459,
-0.2809288203716278,
-0.21961504220962524,
-0.147757887840271,
-0.09074133634567261,
0.3118843138217926,
-0.5698845386505127,
0.22163882851600647,
-0.349101722240448,
0.4977104067802429,
0.6401650309562683,
0.06809978187084198,
0.38929611444473267,
-0.5101596117019653,
0.6906982064247131,
-0.06954558938741684,
0.2156291902065277,
-1.0019437074661255,
-0.9499416947364807,
-0.5933981537818909,
-0.21217696368694305,
0.4868312478065491,
0.5705194473266602,
-0.6521989107131958,
0.1923704743385315,
0.19923895597457886,
-0.31771647930145264,
-1.0409784317016602,
-0.4526134133338928,
0.5864436030387878,
1.0364878177642822,
0.3161199390888214,
0.4871712923049927,
-0.5165560841560364,
-0.6360589861869812,
-0.5528731942176819,
-0.6201590299606323,
0.056680042296648026,
0.4618196189403534,
-0.0398334339261055,
0.16419443488121033,
1.0262161493301392,
-0.30725619196891785,
-0.09105686098337173,
-0.5049466490745544,
0.32820016145706177,
0.34019118547439575,
0.20809900760650635,
0.7202015519142151,
-0.815378725528717,
-0.298353910446167,
-0.33684468269348145,
-0.6665128469467163,
-0.08624914288520813,
-0.3381073474884033,
0.20600567758083344,
-0.1823791265487671,
0.4272693991661072,
-0.5307040810585022,
0.46289849281311035,
0.3767428994178772,
-0.6525070071220398,
0.7372602820396423,
-0.11763820797204971,
0.17316195368766785,
-0.7997490167617798,
-0.1585012674331665,
-0.060122616589069366,
-0.06954016536474228,
-0.8188837170600891,
-0.4179224967956543,
0.17261993885040283,
-0.21829739212989807,
-0.4311257004737854,
0.8305451273918152,
-0.3541112542152405,
0.09718255698680878,
-0.35121020674705505,
0.24570055305957794,
0.28841450810432434,
0.04750329628586769,
0.28893348574638367,
1.1663503646850586,
0.9563666582107544,
-0.6774778366088867,
0.15328896045684814,
0.3904421031475067,
-0.25444406270980835,
0.5463573336601257,
-0.8532314896583557,
-0.02142324298620224,
-0.24937687814235687,
-0.001863067620433867,
-1.250858187675476,
-0.2684161067008972,
0.1798662394285202,
-1.0121513605117798,
0.23117387294769287,
-0.30682694911956787,
-0.20310768485069275,
-0.11278191208839417,
-0.2169875204563141,
0.05047675222158432,
0.7004357576370239,
-0.8372015953063965,
0.4711494743824005,
0.23509086668491364,
-0.25277024507522583,
-0.6709350943565369,
-0.6163262724876404,
0.2815595865249634,
-0.10436121374368668,
-0.541344940662384,
0.14181819558143616,
-0.05647321790456772,
-0.3757348656654358,
-0.20514565706253052,
0.08919860422611237,
0.04542096331715584,
0.1088053360581398,
0.37884199619293213,
0.29069405794143677,
-0.2622143626213074,
0.5075547099113464,
0.05896420031785965,
-0.11575775593519211,
0.23206345736980438,
-0.12419087439775467,
0.4184250831604004,
0.04797545447945595,
-0.23274986445903778,
-1.105056881904602,
0.24256086349487305,
0.340882271528244,
-0.16471897065639496,
0.8298671841621399,
0.44014498591423035,
-0.2773146331310272,
0.03373171389102936,
-0.5976980328559875,
-0.16552327573299408,
-0.5034899711608887,
-0.04167100787162781,
-0.6074523329734802,
-0.8399927616119385,
0.7012702226638794,
0.11338523030281067,
0.013348090462386608,
0.4129776358604431,
-0.07547195255756378,
-0.5278849005699158,
1.2161774635314941,
0.49083277583122253,
-0.10720140486955643,
0.5863040089607239,
-0.1183423101902008,
-0.13557568192481995,
-0.8596922755241394,
-0.4050188362598419,
-1.0362310409545898,
0.003166527021676302,
-0.3145312964916229,
-0.09088266640901566,
0.45260268449783325,
0.16220782697200775,
0.3024151921272278,
0.12152624875307083,
-0.48147502541542053,
0.31406402587890625,
0.4413820803165436,
0.07584194839000702,
0.08580031245946884,
-0.25911977887153625,
-0.13919970393180847,
-0.33100426197052,
-0.8586260676383972,
-0.44749119877815247,
0.4781288802623749,
0.3881514072418213,
0.5194521546363831,
-0.021227648481726646,
0.3050195872783661,
0.2636506259441376,
-0.34801554679870605,
-0.7751646637916565,
0.43944087624549866,
0.32946181297302246,
-0.20176634192466736,
-0.42291566729545593,
-0.24033218622207642,
-1.3537925481796265,
0.07487702369689941,
-0.2344464212656021,
-0.4772776961326599,
0.2465898096561432,
0.1649225950241089,
-0.3441086411476135,
0.03479483723640442,
-1.0382661819458008,
0.4088398218154907,
-0.042808156460523605,
0.23881986737251282,
-0.05442333221435547,
-0.48236390948295593,
-0.10719611495733261,
0.2439926266670227,
0.21764032542705536,
-0.0507056750357151,
-0.04116389900445938,
1.0440739393234253,
-0.34126386046409607,
0.8959558606147766,
-0.5196609497070312,
-0.08940480649471283,
0.44995227456092834,
0.018011104315519333,
0.48559796810150146,
0.034278955310583115,
-0.3005606532096863,
0.01855170726776123,
-0.32993564009666443,
-0.4575973153114319,
-0.9086658954620361,
0.2306160181760788,
-0.5401022434234619,
-0.7583828568458557,
-0.39200159907341003,
-0.2594900131225586,
-0.2136494368314743,
0.05868035927414894,
0.6370560526847839,
0.8099685907363892,
-0.14298228919506073,
-0.29983219504356384,
0.8303238153457642,
-0.25062426924705505,
0.5281685590744019,
0.6652011275291443,
-0.1117229014635086,
-0.06113666668534279,
0.817245364189148,
0.27625471353530884,
0.19590002298355103,
0.284931480884552,
0.5659464001655579,
-0.6048061847686768,
-0.580958366394043,
-0.8577852249145508,
0.3073907792568207,
-0.6506631374359131,
0.1407356709241867,
-0.7149587273597717,
-0.27614349126815796,
-0.43357810378074646,
-0.1418120265007019,
0.15438704192638397,
-0.468803346157074,
-0.5892685055732727,
-0.2638985812664032,
0.7655899524688721,
1.0283348560333252,
0.1627623736858368,
0.45053696632385254,
-1.0100241899490356,
0.07842765003442764,
0.41631701588630676,
-0.07468884438276291,
0.35432398319244385,
-0.8532980680465698,
-0.1240285262465477,
-0.027817165479063988,
0.2586168944835663,
-0.9811335206031799,
-0.01923501491546631,
0.15079471468925476,
0.8601273894309998,
0.5495907068252563,
0.10228653997182846,
0.49322566390037537,
-0.4810144603252411,
1.3657277822494507,
0.12134396284818649,
-1.1591306924819946,
0.962929904460907,
-0.29307934641838074,
0.5293359756469727,
0.42754921317100525,
0.36786964535713196,
-0.7916900515556335,
-0.523480236530304,
-0.6493003368377686,
-0.34095218777656555,
0.7329567670822144,
0.16268792748451233,
0.2714678943157196,
0.09474191814661026,
0.49012133479118347,
0.25801682472229004,
0.19484612345695496,
-0.1580309420824051,
-0.4282527565956116,
-0.18071140348911285,
-0.037637826055288315,
0.0643705204129219,
-0.5129004120826721,
0.18318191170692444,
-0.14688482880592346,
0.1726153939962387,
0.03669006749987602,
0.35041484236717224,
0.41620194911956787,
0.0027358336374163628,
0.10609375685453415,
0.0604415088891983,
0.464002788066864,
0.5468523502349854,
0.13834445178508759,
0.0688004195690155,
0.20402126014232635,
-0.8778881430625916,
0.031354617327451706,
0.015932191163301468,
-0.10891001671552658,
0.31982070207595825,
0.9659897089004517,
1.1530768871307373,
0.117490753531456,
-0.7468210458755493,
0.6792363524436951,
-0.5464237332344055,
0.09646342694759369,
0.15318351984024048,
0.2759273946285248,
-0.1954657882452011,
0.08788540214300156,
0.693434476852417,
0.1637229174375534,
0.2695743143558502,
-0.5111809372901917,
-0.039839498698711395,
0.4308350682258606,
-0.6393125057220459,
-0.48224443197250366,
0.457209974527359,
0.38881823420524597,
-0.5031822919845581,
0.6985912919044495,
-0.03229507431387901,
-0.8892740607261658,
0.6398473381996155,
0.5517966747283936,
0.7856355309486389,
-0.4400102496147156,
0.33178120851516724,
0.24504585564136505,
0.3075045645236969,
0.13569822907447815,
0.6873965263366699,
-0.5068362951278687,
-0.6481228470802307,
-0.4189753532409668,
-0.1614542454481125,
-0.8605653643608093,
-0.18281851708889008,
-0.7832522392272949,
0.14848342537879944,
-0.2804555594921112,
-0.32005980610847473,
0.1801447719335556,
-0.2073129117488861,
-0.547001302242279,
0.06703069061040878,
-0.19243685901165009,
1.264175534248352,
-0.6621856093406677,
0.5877689719200134,
0.47818002104759216,
-0.07257238030433655,
-1.0992587804794312,
0.2047307938337326,
-0.053995002061128616,
-0.9698362350463867,
0.5502483248710632,
0.5078132748603821,
-0.2648496925830841,
-0.01160864531993866,
-0.44247308373451233,
-0.6211130619049072,
0.7318773865699768,
0.2997067868709564,
-0.4439553916454315,
-0.054814260452985764,
-0.13196662068367004,
0.4239622950553894,
-0.0670878067612648,
0.29027891159057617,
0.3307188153266907,
0.6284050345420837,
0.03350376710295677,
-1.1591475009918213,
-0.22667936980724335,
-0.20846427977085114,
-0.30875810980796814,
-0.10390724241733551,
-0.5691325068473816,
0.7681965827941895,
-0.47249066829681396,
-0.5596170425415039,
0.1504475325345993,
0.6385349035263062,
0.15396395325660706,
0.6803696751594543,
0.6035072803497314,
0.004149624612182379,
1.3874363899230957,
-0.3384620249271393,
1.0384577512741089,
-0.0326082743704319,
-0.20514187216758728,
0.8455125093460083,
-0.3663719594478607,
0.6906868815422058,
0.11283396929502487,
-0.15608464181423187,
0.3679578900337219,
0.7598029375076294,
0.31438034772872925,
0.33830299973487854,
-0.3106987774372101,
-0.43376773595809937,
-0.09107864648103714,
-0.6339944005012512,
-0.4196416139602661,
0.3053625524044037,
0.5442306995391846,
-0.26284530758857727,
0.15136763453483582,
0.4931454062461853,
-0.08116115629673004,
0.031294211745262146,
-0.37014076113700867,
1.0656136274337769,
-0.02349242940545082,
-0.7217900156974792,
0.6155340671539307,
-0.3520870804786682,
0.5877693891525269,
-0.6158426403999329,
-0.1465551257133484,
0.1096574068069458,
-0.588600754737854,
-0.10010936856269836,
-1.1498582363128662,
-0.02788241021335125,
0.16537168622016907,
-0.2843009829521179,
-0.2697475552558899,
0.9295212626457214,
-0.05280221253633499,
-0.05417782440781593,
0.12131653726100922,
0.5070986151695251,
0.2873041033744812,
-0.12015120685100555,
-0.6730085611343384,
0.17180000245571136,
-0.0009621246717870235,
0.05637088418006897,
0.10521093755960464,
0.5957714319229126,
0.2602488100528717,
0.649197518825531,
0.7509752511978149,
0.33724358677864075,
0.12816943228244781,
0.30713769793510437,
0.6697385311126709,
-0.7528743147850037,
-0.7927205562591553,
-0.893448531627655,
0.44875383377075195,
-0.18434403836727142,
-0.5024698376655579,
0.9355103373527527,
0.323428750038147,
0.41172996163368225,
0.23806577920913696,
0.9396828413009644,
0.3672879636287689,
0.8488604426383972,
-0.8471329212188721,
0.5709669589996338,
-0.050955839455127716,
0.12880367040634155,
-0.002877583261579275,
-0.46855035424232483,
0.08832351863384247,
0.3700823485851288,
-0.13021540641784668,
-0.15482033789157867,
0.46072790026664734,
0.5299585461616516,
0.44748634099960327,
0.6008186340332031,
0.4123183786869049,
0.20605890452861786,
0.1800760179758072,
0.1509416401386261,
1.4317597150802612,
-0.1503470540046692,
0.281915545463562,
0.10334504395723343,
-0.21731281280517578,
-0.13460280001163483,
-0.5659677982330322,
-1.0248621702194214,
-0.8920000195503235,
0.01850833185017109,
-0.44092127680778503,
0.06720314174890518,
0.7721714973449707,
0.7671487331390381,
-0.42197778820991516,
0.08188609778881073,
0.13179108500480652,
0.38151854276657104,
-0.22767941653728485,
-0.2384023815393448,
0.3668666183948517,
-0.4837225079536438,
-0.653372585773468,
0.831231951713562,
0.17200009524822235,
0.5472919940948486,
-0.19966965913772583,
-0.03078080341219902,
0.41362547874450684,
0.15142884850502014,
0.41265198588371277,
0.25589510798454285,
-0.6642842888832092,
-0.150467187166214,
0.4814559519290924,
-0.036921802908182144,
0.014242046512663364,
1.0804502964019775,
-1.2361761331558228,
0.6134365200996399,
0.5406509637832642,
0.4004630446434021,
0.046569257974624634,
-0.019480671733617783,
0.6178921461105347,
-0.7777999043464661,
0.2003757506608963,
0.18701449036598206,
0.37013983726501465,
0.3837336301803589,
-0.8183587789535522,
-0.04012051224708557,
0.08109530806541443,
-0.47692281007766724,
-1.0108064413070679,
0.21958544850349426,
-0.9435487389564514,
-0.19726687669754028,
1.0568972826004028,
-0.22303609549999237,
-0.22216399013996124,
-0.4677395522594452,
-0.8844045996665955,
0.10049509257078171,
-0.6760151386260986,
0.339478462934494,
0.8669372200965881,
-0.37291595339775085,
-0.16851170361042023,
-0.3317425847053528,
0.7552065849304199,
0.3322817385196686,
-0.24137665331363678,
0.39017847180366516,
0.1390780806541443,
-0.08343527466058731,
0.11315298080444336,
0.6879324913024902,
0.3317151963710785,
0.612209677696228,
-0.07727766782045364,
-0.579371988773346,
-0.0018235857132822275,
-0.46779578924179077,
-0.8956841826438904,
-0.04671257361769676,
0.5252058506011963,
-0.26018592715263367
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.05804v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.05804v2
|
A Survey on LLM-Based Agents: Common Workflows and Reusable LLM-Profiled Components
| 2024-06-09T14:42:55 | 2024-06-16T00:59:27 |
Xinzhe Li
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.SE
|
Recent advancements in Large Language Models (LLMs) have catalyzed the
development of sophisticated frameworks for developing LLM-based agents.
However, the complexity of these frameworks r poses a hurdle for nuanced
differentiation at a granular level, a critical aspect for enabling efficient
implementations across different frameworks and fostering future research.
Hence, the primary purpose of this survey is to facilitate a cohesive
understanding of diverse recently proposed frameworks by identifying common
workflows and reusable LLM-Profiled Components (LMPCs).
|
[
-0.48638251423835754,
-0.8153527975082397,
0.5181849598884583,
-0.04038232937455177,
0.11128434538841248,
0.5765834450721741,
0.010675770230591297,
-0.7236084938049316,
0.5781282782554626,
0.6992793083190918,
-0.6224195957183838,
-0.4541085958480835,
-0.39251846075057983,
0.271165668964386,
-0.3373278081417084,
0.7235022783279419,
-0.2679886519908905,
-0.1886645257472992,
-0.2752235233783722,
-0.36731308698654175,
-0.1711363047361374,
-0.457003653049469,
-0.5863068103790283,
-0.8159871697425842,
0.9755541086196899,
0.4859873354434967,
0.6180984973907471,
0.27631115913391113,
0.6321316957473755,
0.41287505626678467,
-0.2632008492946625,
0.30667218565940857,
-0.39814379811286926,
0.6836631298065186,
-0.1954614818096161,
-0.32136136293411255,
-0.882390558719635,
0.1240246370434761,
0.4949241280555725,
0.9304866194725037,
-0.1457347571849823,
0.23870109021663666,
-0.035004135221242905,
0.4574313163757324,
-0.6180436015129089,
0.25031065940856934,
-0.11193611472845078,
0.23262056708335876,
-0.1646471917629242,
-0.02887425571680069,
-0.3091734051704407,
-0.19970205426216125,
0.07267244160175323,
-0.4357876479625702,
0.05498182401061058,
-0.1370401233434677,
0.2661110460758209,
0.07315871119499207,
-0.4562196731567383,
-0.4010258615016937,
-0.9460055828094482,
0.9234543442726135,
-0.5991395711898804,
0.21306075155735016,
-0.02238445356488228,
0.5495233535766602,
-0.41377097368240356,
-1.1163170337677002,
-0.12459703534841537,
-0.3141328990459442,
0.15459690988063812,
-0.1419881284236908,
-0.04165183752775192,
0.01967315748333931,
0.021139061078429222,
0.4195147752761841,
-0.28607264161109924,
0.6109008193016052,
0.023710882291197777,
-0.33744966983795166,
0.5447301268577576,
0.663391649723053,
0.21376657485961914,
0.2768537998199463,
0.001045278855599463,
0.14362794160842896,
-0.8891108632087708,
0.03164631500840187,
-0.04132264479994774,
0.1843872368335724,
-0.12114765495061874,
0.4086422026157379,
-0.49679824709892273,
0.5768609046936035,
-0.04584630951285362,
-0.5244522094726562,
0.4860873520374298,
-0.39109447598457336,
-0.1842881590127945,
-0.4571688771247864,
0.5835103392601013,
0.18061639368534088,
0.22490619122982025,
-0.23228538036346436,
-0.62251216173172,
-0.25978899002075195,
0.09865593165159225,
-0.7042023539543152,
0.3093337118625641,
0.28829628229141235,
-0.5818760991096497,
-0.4026985764503479,
-0.2522927522659302,
-0.5784409046173096,
-0.6211984157562256,
-0.14476348459720612,
0.022489722818136215,
0.30509740114212036,
-0.4065823554992676,
-0.15888291597366333,
-0.046134866774082184,
0.5753254890441895,
0.5857146382331848,
-0.5500039458274841,
0.25017720460891724,
1.0272727012634277,
0.806659996509552,
-0.49848705530166626,
-0.4671638011932373,
-0.5137824416160583,
-0.06980974972248077,
-0.3070187270641327,
1.0000791549682617,
-0.7945002317428589,
-0.5083102583885193,
0.45375800132751465,
0.2930465042591095,
0.1454939842224121,
-0.7945727705955505,
0.1872718334197998,
-0.5494434237480164,
0.05357103794813156,
-0.4042525291442871,
-0.4391818344593048,
-0.1582155078649521,
0.5246008634567261,
-0.9846639037132263,
0.916942298412323,
0.4206392168998718,
-0.5733321905136108,
0.449975848197937,
-0.8014018535614014,
-0.3627459406852722,
0.23890677094459534,
-0.15421496331691742,
-0.33249717950820923,
0.06461940705776215,
-0.22137555480003357,
0.9219672679901123,
-0.5442925095558167,
0.26786738634109497,
-0.3675152361392975,
-0.5154657363891602,
0.4145101010799408,
-0.4212794005870819,
0.4469849765300751,
0.3449796438217163,
-0.25131165981292725,
0.338344931602478,
-0.94173663854599,
-0.2644384503364563,
-0.1000535637140274,
-0.42651721835136414,
0.14305512607097626,
-0.018280265852808952,
0.038977377116680145,
0.0967138260602951,
0.4329443573951721,
-0.41923895478248596,
0.25850433111190796,
-0.046031516045331955,
0.6086713075637817,
0.5380759239196777,
0.26823344826698303,
0.5528343319892883,
-0.6588323712348938,
0.9157810807228088,
-0.09208744764328003,
0.042171407490968704,
-0.043977219611406326,
-0.2884139120578766,
-0.4081146717071533,
-0.5623642206192017,
-0.230488583445549,
0.50038743019104,
-0.7176467180252075,
0.0427657887339592,
-0.0006918181315995753,
-0.9410730004310608,
-0.10469791293144226,
0.23157501220703125,
0.40626874566078186,
0.10900556296110153,
-0.12558043003082275,
-0.332457959651947,
-0.2844034433364868,
-0.9244441986083984,
0.026015629991889,
-0.27824097871780396,
0.1324644833803177,
0.3906043469905853,
0.7485814094543457,
-0.6620784401893616,
0.8572428226470947,
-0.29004138708114624,
0.2631291449069977,
-0.6720779538154602,
0.07049598544836044,
0.09766997396945953,
0.09624439477920532,
0.592170238494873,
-0.541653573513031,
-0.5184236168861389,
-0.06169027462601662,
-0.6207036375999451,
-0.5250300765037537,
0.21471264958381653,
0.13834013044834137,
0.2776229977607727,
0.6933150291442871,
-0.789016604423523,
0.28010687232017517,
0.2716136574745178,
-0.19954535365104675,
0.7017673254013062,
-0.10456689447164536,
0.1736699789762497,
-1.0634504556655884,
0.09697778522968292,
-0.10849124193191528,
-0.5421625375747681,
-0.7457941770553589,
0.25309377908706665,
-0.4622272253036499,
0.1596909463405609,
-0.762307345867157,
0.7312601804733276,
-0.5419031977653503,
-0.464139848947525,
-0.40465325117111206,
0.19265693426132202,
0.06873641908168793,
0.3187089264392853,
-0.07568970322608948,
0.7823971509933472,
0.6526667475700378,
-0.8028239607810974,
0.6911405920982361,
-0.05696185305714607,
-0.13542431592941284,
0.776131808757782,
-0.7113454937934875,
0.03990590199828148,
-0.06930322200059891,
0.2805558443069458,
-0.7114859819412231,
-0.2088780701160431,
0.7400728464126587,
-0.03151613101363182,
0.12282346934080124,
0.11371612548828125,
-0.5834798216819763,
-0.14924436807632446,
-0.35610654950141907,
0.5418659448623657,
0.4113854169845581,
-0.35219717025756836,
0.8785669207572937,
0.5011608004570007,
-0.10847000777721405,
-0.6208419799804688,
-0.6745508909225464,
0.006603877525776625,
-0.3546031713485718,
-0.6024084091186523,
0.17088830471038818,
-0.1550731062889099,
-0.6431155800819397,
-0.16323180496692657,
-0.019498977810144424,
-0.15481682121753693,
0.23769423365592957,
0.45423591136932373,
-0.13952122628688812,
-0.2773784399032593,
-0.0963301956653595,
-0.48573845624923706,
0.02620363049209118,
-0.007791609037667513,
0.2788795232772827,
0.6034379601478577,
-0.14502087235450745,
-0.5955424904823303,
-0.2748248875141144,
0.5757094025611877,
1.006388783454895,
-0.17687512934207916,
0.5851653218269348,
0.5833991765975952,
-0.1282348483800888,
-0.3495776951313019,
-0.40229734778404236,
-0.01957637071609497,
-0.483279287815094,
0.5111564993858337,
-0.3055751621723175,
-1.2564079761505127,
1.080870509147644,
-0.22475461661815643,
0.532993495464325,
0.08739165216684341,
0.9421955943107605,
0.07874294370412827,
0.4283575415611267,
0.7073243856430054,
-0.230751633644104,
0.6345379948616028,
0.029165619984269142,
0.09476736187934875,
-0.4752374291419983,
-0.22826701402664185,
-0.5373798608779907,
-0.21235619485378265,
-0.7647863626480103,
-0.7054309248924255,
-0.05780147388577461,
-0.5755608677864075,
-0.11856702715158463,
0.11039651185274124,
-0.2948818802833557,
0.3365303874015808,
0.17716866731643677,
-0.49233609437942505,
0.25639134645462036,
-0.2071886956691742,
0.007808966096490622,
0.5007766485214233,
-0.26245781779289246,
-0.8095554113388062,
1.04027259349823,
0.6119532585144043,
0.9437636137008667,
0.14894062280654907,
0.9727239012718201,
0.5985153913497925,
0.48274457454681396,
-0.8375376462936401,
0.8377475142478943,
0.16676512360572815,
-0.6487319469451904,
-0.4377291202545166,
-0.20383787155151367,
-1.039139747619629,
0.3167998790740967,
0.18061639368534088,
-0.7486921548843384,
0.16879549622535706,
-0.20288479328155518,
-0.11574865132570267,
0.3221714496612549,
-0.26018375158309937,
0.647230327129364,
0.07685502618551254,
-0.27711570262908936,
-0.11643686145544052,
-0.27155736088752747,
0.0981111079454422,
-0.20112505555152893,
0.016179058700799942,
-0.2533200681209564,
-0.14925912022590637,
0.6668282747268677,
-0.5034777522087097,
0.9529126882553101,
-0.18794551491737366,
-0.5393933057785034,
0.7509878873825073,
-0.08438998460769653,
0.5552419424057007,
-0.1123502254486084,
-0.06488645076751709,
-0.1477424055337906,
0.11736495047807693,
-0.257402241230011,
-0.5743846297264099,
0.5203889608383179,
-0.5970466732978821,
-0.6455960273742676,
-0.5612983107566833,
-0.5519886016845703,
-0.27613672614097595,
0.09421680867671967,
-0.2533891201019287,
0.4494898319244385,
-0.6146819591522217,
0.2758515179157257,
0.45645976066589355,
-0.04273290932178497,
0.8513336777687073,
1.030427098274231,
-0.35811394453048706,
-0.11526262760162354,
0.7274389863014221,
0.10618063807487488,
0.3111168146133423,
0.46355101466178894,
-0.2483181357383728,
-0.02757478877902031,
-0.7043716311454773,
0.18562723696231842,
0.14463423192501068,
-0.7044429779052734,
0.07150392234325409,
-0.31536245346069336,
-0.22435146570205688,
-0.22077828645706177,
-0.2603552043437958,
-0.6018372178077698,
-0.2803837060928345,
-0.3927958905696869,
-0.25644636154174805,
0.2452670931816101,
1.127639889717102,
-0.1389293372631073,
0.46640104055404663,
-0.6517007946968079,
0.12862348556518555,
0.30394434928894043,
0.3382241725921631,
-0.14892399311065674,
-0.22488732635974884,
-0.4307381212711334,
-0.2618562579154968,
-0.15746667981147766,
-0.7981365323066711,
0.26910924911499023,
0.0006117751472629607,
1.0196607112884521,
0.47830864787101746,
-0.09129422903060913,
0.13222800195217133,
-0.2746613323688507,
1.0209423303604126,
-0.19195282459259033,
-0.5708504915237427,
-0.06408718973398209,
-0.294638067483902,
0.056766316294670105,
0.598580539226532,
0.2867280840873718,
-0.6783751845359802,
-0.3811793625354767,
-0.24240742623806,
-0.7620878219604492,
0.3107375204563141,
0.024120597168803215,
-0.05631574988365173,
0.17563746869564056,
0.5069319605827332,
0.08148525655269623,
0.3292172849178314,
-0.6196469068527222,
-0.28857454657554626,
0.2761349081993103,
-0.020981058478355408,
-0.07485084980726242,
-0.3439458906650543,
-0.16162404417991638,
0.2283107340335846,
0.408450186252594,
-0.04450089856982231,
0.1742144525051117,
0.0279410257935524,
-0.28979089856147766,
0.11805891990661621,
0.47111982107162476,
0.4963993728160858,
0.8228861093521118,
-0.34563055634498596,
0.18680715560913086,
-0.06481880694627762,
-0.5811070799827576,
0.4732114374637604,
-0.1738298386335373,
-0.10174828767776489,
-0.09324797987937927,
0.5896384119987488,
0.4601573646068573,
0.28434044122695923,
-0.9126421809196472,
0.21085713803768158,
-0.13474465906620026,
-0.25042620301246643,
-0.41785728931427,
0.23570840060710907,
0.2846733331680298,
0.5706478357315063,
0.03155200183391571,
-0.34073299169540405,
-0.04974344000220299,
-0.7922300696372986,
0.3459765613079071,
0.39519816637039185,
-0.34480953216552734,
-0.28662243485450745,
0.050581637769937515,
0.5198770761489868,
-0.5412231087684631,
0.19359295070171356,
-0.43712562322616577,
-0.0733366459608078,
0.6387766003608704,
0.3195219933986664,
1.1483601331710815,
-0.05970054492354393,
0.4182514548301697,
-0.3505308926105499,
0.08797277510166168,
-0.1545163244009018,
0.36355647444725037,
0.03045130893588066,
-0.7601762413978577,
-0.25563129782676697,
-0.5023304224014282,
-0.7503901124000549,
-0.08482576906681061,
-0.4703790545463562,
0.016162021085619926,
-0.5862075686454773,
-0.36292535066604614,
0.04074545204639435,
0.2592252790927887,
-0.5989869236946106,
-0.023751171305775642,
-0.02379389852285385,
0.9144876003265381,
-0.9499804973602295,
0.6965958476066589,
0.9846497774124146,
-0.5465283393859863,
-0.671116292476654,
-0.23453952372074127,
0.12220681458711624,
-0.5919957160949707,
0.558428168296814,
-0.05877755954861641,
-0.4173080027103424,
-0.5232835412025452,
-0.5007190704345703,
-0.7046990990638733,
1.5270651578903198,
-0.027476459741592407,
-0.37035006284713745,
0.01170919369906187,
0.5380463600158691,
0.7118414044380188,
-0.9238290190696716,
0.37167513370513916,
0.7455425262451172,
0.42745551466941833,
0.31025296449661255,
-0.9107064604759216,
-0.05849051848053932,
-0.24214757978916168,
-0.14951761066913605,
-0.14763282239437103,
-0.8393560647964478,
1.0721335411071777,
0.24906468391418457,
-0.14404936134815216,
0.1436210721731186,
0.5362196564674377,
0.5739994049072266,
0.7920320630073547,
0.28530678153038025,
0.23364338278770447,
0.7376247048377991,
0.2898830771446228,
0.48397302627563477,
-0.4787006080150604,
0.09632088243961334,
1.0083588361740112,
-0.6115793585777283,
0.6587809324264526,
0.31155216693878174,
-0.14539289474487305,
0.6053119897842407,
0.6493673324584961,
-0.10273130238056183,
0.026523327454924583,
0.3980192244052887,
-0.43539485335350037,
-0.2416357547044754,
-0.3421405851840973,
-0.20028094947338104,
0.5603128671646118,
0.2543126344680786,
-0.29521018266677856,
-0.3706647753715515,
-0.22312584519386292,
0.26451969146728516,
-0.03452567011117935,
-0.4800611436367035,
0.627668559551239,
0.3012272119522095,
-0.6491523385047913,
0.029542725533246994,
0.1471983641386032,
0.7827174663543701,
-0.5050786733627319,
-0.04712357744574547,
-0.5438626408576965,
-0.11093906313180923,
-0.11180146783590317,
-0.8933534622192383,
0.15993717312812805,
0.015316070057451725,
-0.37071797251701355,
-0.4954266846179962,
0.9568458199501038,
-0.08216864615678787,
-0.17407149076461792,
0.2480422556400299,
1.145195484161377,
0.2629396319389343,
0.14610812067985535,
-0.4929627776145935,
0.2365066111087799,
-0.26558178663253784,
-0.46912190318107605,
0.429715633392334,
0.628498911857605,
-0.06260816752910614,
1.1731934547424316,
0.17313750088214874,
0.08942878991365433,
-0.058755721896886826,
0.26069846749305725,
0.811887800693512,
-0.9427706003189087,
-0.2669267952442169,
-0.5824259519577026,
0.40747568011283875,
0.09841679781675339,
-0.03463944047689438,
0.5927613973617554,
0.39067763090133667,
0.3510093688964844,
-0.07760272920131683,
0.7185803055763245,
0.12279166281223297,
0.6868952512741089,
-0.19782955944538116,
0.691441535949707,
-0.5388312339782715,
0.4663695693016052,
-0.32043948769569397,
-0.9504352807998657,
-0.11036934703588486,
0.34289881587028503,
0.09570218622684479,
0.31750932335853577,
0.4805215895175934,
1.1118980646133423,
0.20264925062656403,
-0.24137867987155914,
0.46446123719215393,
-0.043362174183130264,
0.7441308498382568,
0.45886680483818054,
1.1914182901382446,
0.3204754889011383,
0.1890527456998825,
0.20518718659877777,
0.026053279638290405,
-0.569192111492157,
-1.0108654499053955,
-0.9650046229362488,
-0.48272013664245605,
-0.6056213974952698,
-0.09347951412200928,
-0.17597201466560364,
0.955057680606842,
0.40700763463974,
-0.6229445338249207,
-0.4238182008266449,
0.11404099315404892,
0.5340229272842407,
-0.05157911777496338,
-0.19626346230506897,
-0.061043381690979004,
-0.1645369529724121,
-0.7396624088287354,
0.25577613711357117,
0.4384891092777252,
0.19071613252162933,
-0.80760258436203,
-0.31424960494041443,
0.11334803700447083,
0.3391951024532318,
0.6521648168563843,
0.6751406788825989,
-0.668981671333313,
-0.4073649048805237,
0.09820244461297989,
-0.34368300437927246,
-0.1035841777920723,
1.0751906633377075,
-0.579688549041748,
-0.04391416162252426,
0.8338733315467834,
0.5059716701507568,
0.025054968893527985,
-0.31891173124313354,
0.618708610534668,
-0.4496820569038391,
0.023008879274129868,
0.24730198085308075,
0.35583680868148804,
0.21243910491466522,
-0.04904230684041977,
0.53263920545578,
0.206771120429039,
-0.7245506644248962,
-1.0086497068405151,
0.5187800526618958,
-1.286496877670288,
-0.1602773815393448,
1.2342000007629395,
-0.34672024846076965,
-0.23282183706760406,
-0.4160992205142975,
-0.054462555795907974,
0.07088200002908707,
-0.30753055214881897,
0.3554116487503052,
0.7506622672080994,
-0.44663700461387634,
-0.32167837023735046,
-0.27732229232788086,
0.34844136238098145,
-0.12383051961660385,
-0.9386635422706604,
0.03190290555357933,
0.6811771988868713,
0.6186633706092834,
0.1208290308713913,
0.9142394661903381,
-0.03368861600756645,
0.005154414568096399,
0.03741002082824707,
0.021752838045358658,
-0.26912540197372437,
-0.37475988268852234,
-0.187775120139122,
0.4417624771595001,
0.47589918971061707,
0.04580425098538399
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.05798v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.05798v1
|
Hidden Holes: topological aspects of language models
| 2024-06-09T14:25:09 | 2024-06-09T14:25:09 |
Stephen Fitz, Peter Romero, Jiyan Jonas Schneider
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.NE
|
We explore the topology of representation manifolds arising in autoregressive
neural language models trained on raw text data. In order to study their
properties, we introduce tools from computational algebraic topology, which we
use as a basis for a measure of topological complexity, that we call
perforation.
Using this measure, we study the evolution of topological structure in GPT
based large language models across depth and time during training. We then
compare these to gated recurrent models, and show that the latter exhibit more
topological complexity, with a distinct pattern of changes common to all
natural languages but absent from synthetically generated data. The paper
presents a detailed analysis of the representation manifolds derived by these
models based on studying the shapes of vector clouds induced by them as they
are conditioned on sentences from corpora of natural language text.
The methods developed in this paper are novel in the field and based on
mathematical apparatus that might be unfamiliar to the target audience. To help
with that we introduce the minimum necessary theory, and provide additional
visualizations in the appendices.
The main contribution of the paper is a striking observation about the
topological structure of the transformer as compared to LSTM based neural
architectures. It suggests that further research into mathematical properties
of these neural networks is necessary to understand the operation of large
transformer language models. We hope this work inspires further explorations in
this direction within the NLP community.
|
[
-0.2674328088760376,
-0.9459980130195618,
0.7835149765014648,
-0.20226536691188812,
-0.15155692398548126,
0.15076491236686707,
-0.10961662232875824,
-0.20917023718357086,
0.14866633713245392,
0.5487943887710571,
-0.38682645559310913,
-0.5336539149284363,
-0.7139672636985779,
-0.09435391426086426,
-0.6956498622894287,
0.7192184329032898,
-0.12428057938814163,
-0.1699124276638031,
-0.2297341525554657,
-0.027321837842464447,
-0.14333197474479675,
-0.7241478562355042,
-0.5168105959892273,
-0.3034774363040924,
0.47022491693496704,
-0.20466427505016327,
0.6883856058120728,
0.8074304461479187,
0.5733309388160706,
0.46495118737220764,
-0.42916572093963623,
-0.18044699728488922,
-0.3386492431163788,
0.20443099737167358,
-0.0020379035267978907,
-0.47857779264450073,
-0.17891904711723328,
-0.11206325888633728,
0.9531400799751282,
1.0031440258026123,
-0.165379598736763,
-0.34952276945114136,
0.029177647083997726,
0.602737307548523,
0.1290154606103897,
0.21433261036872864,
-0.6786683797836304,
0.3044111132621765,
-0.31991907954216003,
-0.03695200756192207,
-0.007573539856821299,
-0.22788798809051514,
0.2163439393043518,
-0.2767389416694641,
0.529686450958252,
-0.1179218515753746,
0.8256807327270508,
0.38317152857780457,
-0.3983505666255951,
-0.39650654792785645,
-1.0013400316238403,
0.48016679286956787,
-0.5857583284378052,
0.6858797669410706,
0.09498103708028793,
0.4505510926246643,
-0.2694312632083893,
-0.6525359153747559,
-0.519388735294342,
-0.2122851312160492,
-0.4023231863975525,
-0.06969847530126572,
-0.2519164979457855,
0.04969562962651253,
0.22700196504592896,
0.849393904209137,
-0.7389113903045654,
0.044144757091999054,
-0.5972294211387634,
0.06557254493236542,
0.4305214583873749,
0.03551427647471428,
0.3791065216064453,
-0.2353583574295044,
-0.056398652493953705,
-0.19119657576084137,
-0.6515318155288696,
-0.12607358396053314,
0.47537922859191895,
0.12650008499622345,
-0.29670047760009766,
0.42797601222991943,
0.09550054371356964,
0.6917962431907654,
-0.36862921714782715,
0.14936386048793793,
-0.1393555849790573,
0.01285497099161148,
-0.40272220969200134,
-0.34922853112220764,
0.8603343963623047,
-0.6213801503181458,
0.37000954151153564,
-0.5330451726913452,
-0.2090749442577362,
0.05601328983902931,
0.42924728989601135,
-0.27665507793426514,
-0.5480330586433411,
0.06708942353725433,
-0.1785517781972885,
-0.45534205436706543,
0.10056214034557343,
-0.4592854082584381,
-0.49799710512161255,
-0.2766847014427185,
-0.014424278400838375,
-0.4354550540447235,
-0.4099421203136444,
0.27124130725860596,
0.09659336507320404,
0.20865096151828766,
0.2166653424501419,
-0.7859481573104858,
0.7567209601402283,
0.7901673913002014,
0.8761197328567505,
0.006901769433170557,
-0.305033415555954,
0.04544932022690773,
-0.046665776520967484,
-0.39476916193962097,
0.6507647633552551,
-0.6702173948287964,
-0.215124249458313,
0.050848498940467834,
0.145808607339859,
0.04619615152478218,
-0.33596354722976685,
0.5058000087738037,
-0.5381993651390076,
0.31626319885253906,
0.07161198556423187,
-0.4442541301250458,
-0.7122249007225037,
0.12488086521625519,
-0.7533562779426575,
0.6789565086364746,
0.09203436225652695,
-0.61899334192276,
-0.1046508252620697,
-0.6764021515846252,
-0.20335474610328674,
-0.06824840605258942,
-0.5826736688613892,
-0.4472424387931824,
0.5104140043258667,
0.0803571417927742,
0.3622331917285919,
-0.2151741087436676,
0.2823387682437897,
-0.12991033494472504,
-0.0763750821352005,
0.3202109932899475,
-0.37650126218795776,
0.8020246624946594,
-0.05911138653755188,
-0.4495364725589752,
0.09965373575687408,
-0.5926023721694946,
-0.35579442977905273,
0.3994694650173187,
-0.06196063384413719,
-0.3083829879760742,
0.10912691801786423,
-0.12061119079589844,
0.08160000294446945,
-0.29971402883529663,
-0.45056039094924927,
0.5002411007881165,
-0.6286978125572205,
0.5937926173210144,
0.7500898241996765,
-0.10138183832168579,
0.6332436203956604,
0.09338060021400452,
0.5476093292236328,
0.27378037571907043,
-0.04564188793301582,
-0.11990801244974136,
-0.5599924921989441,
-0.8749933838844299,
0.15783603489398956,
0.28045621514320374,
0.1866864114999771,
-0.5129508972167969,
0.29902592301368713,
-0.11670903116464615,
-0.5586209893226624,
-0.2504783570766449,
-0.23838157951831818,
0.13732017576694489,
0.10686695575714111,
0.039727017283439636,
-0.3257358968257904,
-0.19447384774684906,
-0.8399713635444641,
-0.3267349898815155,
-0.09786797314882278,
0.06403081119060516,
0.6215601563453674,
0.4753495752811432,
-0.4303387701511383,
0.7656553983688354,
-0.6031178832054138,
-0.1699685901403427,
0.21168892085552216,
0.05383392795920372,
0.5644949674606323,
0.4637734591960907,
0.5865722894668579,
-0.6344783306121826,
-0.11968924105167389,
0.2972162961959839,
-0.7774766087532043,
0.18965651094913483,
-0.056137941777706146,
0.08510275930166245,
0.150845468044281,
0.5563572645187378,
-0.7820343971252441,
0.5764328241348267,
0.6582040786743164,
-0.45350101590156555,
0.47832581400871277,
-0.009140820242464542,
-0.16858141124248505,
-0.5685824155807495,
0.007626574952155352,
-0.3699730336666107,
-0.3712765574455261,
-0.7591939568519592,
0.24869771301746368,
-0.2512741982936859,
-0.48933061957359314,
-0.11773267388343811,
0.6867857575416565,
-0.6926270723342896,
-0.2812897861003876,
-0.07238293439149857,
0.2615627646446228,
-0.25991055369377136,
0.6701818704605103,
-0.04155607149004936,
0.33836379647254944,
0.8555992245674133,
-0.7351235151290894,
0.3569927215576172,
0.10304773598909378,
-0.17201876640319824,
-0.16363227367401123,
-0.8904680609703064,
0.3158804178237915,
-0.17100554704666138,
0.10732951760292053,
-0.8839492201805115,
-0.07019669562578201,
0.21645930409431458,
-0.46267133951187134,
0.4870712459087372,
-0.46135881543159485,
-0.29401636123657227,
-0.26770997047424316,
0.17572055757045746,
0.6507068276405334,
0.3567768931388855,
-0.2674042582511902,
0.35678577423095703,
0.5549017190933228,
-0.15428297221660614,
-0.17008762061595917,
-0.6800165772438049,
0.09806058555841446,
-0.25711169838905334,
-0.7157431840896606,
0.12476107478141785,
0.14284466207027435,
-0.339464008808136,
0.11035773903131485,
-0.040467601269483566,
-0.13455116748809814,
0.15403327345848083,
0.250566691160202,
-0.24887190759181976,
-0.5591062903404236,
0.36985883116722107,
-0.015940630808472633,
-0.1936424970626831,
0.15738871693611145,
-0.923771858215332,
0.7131752371788025,
-0.4335416555404663,
-0.4741825461387634,
-0.25133875012397766,
0.38926878571510315,
0.7028312683105469,
-0.17316070199012756,
0.7176019549369812,
0.4107592701911926,
-0.7389857769012451,
-0.014470035210251808,
-0.40623319149017334,
-0.27863529324531555,
-0.5048359036445618,
0.28292322158813477,
-0.4420572817325592,
-1.141771674156189,
0.7163395881652832,
-0.01800280064344406,
-0.08367666602134705,
0.7144103050231934,
0.4575258493423462,
-0.028746549040079117,
0.482688844203949,
0.8075354099273682,
0.08664067834615707,
0.29197725653648376,
-0.5621958374977112,
0.4775386452674866,
-0.7300340533256531,
-0.005217359401285648,
-0.6178590655326843,
-0.27039653062820435,
-1.0393030643463135,
-0.5624229311943054,
0.3458528518676758,
0.35377296805381775,
-0.19525273144245148,
0.2471999078989029,
-0.609736442565918,
0.36611759662628174,
0.3019838035106659,
-0.35579290986061096,
0.08831177651882172,
0.3352417051792145,
-0.3588957190513611,
-0.08193867653608322,
-0.8168217539787292,
-0.5072154998779297,
0.561947762966156,
0.7158337831497192,
0.5372077226638794,
0.2878740727901459,
0.5829771161079407,
-0.07235237956047058,
-0.1515885889530182,
-0.746773898601532,
0.21841266751289368,
-0.3134130537509918,
-0.45166322588920593,
-0.6158180236816406,
-0.5662538409233093,
-1.0838795900344849,
0.06718894094228745,
-0.03927462175488472,
-0.8989769816398621,
0.42280593514442444,
0.022933054715394974,
-0.10333244502544403,
0.7678477764129639,
-0.40095987915992737,
0.6400513052940369,
-0.1893094778060913,
-0.03768264502286911,
0.04690857231616974,
-0.32894599437713623,
0.40960246324539185,
0.140527606010437,
0.08492837101221085,
0.40016964077949524,
0.24197141826152802,
0.7392669916152954,
-0.31415611505508423,
0.7353137731552124,
-0.03125902637839317,
-0.23636284470558167,
0.22703146934509277,
0.4928254187107086,
0.663910448551178,
0.10101265460252762,
0.16118019819259644,
0.5301916599273682,
-0.2965293824672699,
-0.3183697760105133,
-0.8031971454620361,
0.8870012760162354,
-0.9077745079994202,
-0.8361465334892273,
-0.608342707157135,
-0.40213704109191895,
-0.05837365984916687,
0.3576062023639679,
0.1566074937582016,
0.6425654292106628,
-0.06968655437231064,
0.3124319612979889,
0.7506313323974609,
-0.6023001670837402,
0.3659367561340332,
0.08579610288143158,
-0.5012811422348022,
-0.1198946088552475,
0.582314670085907,
0.19737890362739563,
-0.04654539376497269,
0.44326186180114746,
0.2779010832309723,
-0.208658367395401,
-0.8810310363769531,
-0.31968575716018677,
0.7532501220703125,
-0.5502232909202576,
0.01719738356769085,
-0.9081250429153442,
-0.6385523676872253,
-0.5592505931854248,
-0.07936228066682816,
-0.4092599153518677,
-0.7780117392539978,
-0.15450069308280945,
-0.1687173694372177,
0.5644127130508423,
1.5336859226226807,
0.08500850200653076,
0.4572162330150604,
-0.710374653339386,
0.14698059856891632,
0.3358260989189148,
0.8265501260757446,
0.04494417458772659,
-0.3783646523952484,
-0.18083776533603668,
-0.0914073958992958,
-0.22680090367794037,
-0.829197347164154,
0.4080769419670105,
-0.04395730793476105,
0.3872622549533844,
0.3172817528247833,
-0.33139702677726746,
0.4486953318119049,
-0.7666105628013611,
0.6716800332069397,
-0.059120938181877136,
-0.8519731760025024,
0.3037511706352234,
-0.7128097414970398,
0.3253729045391083,
-0.023379582911729813,
0.3391455113887787,
-0.754805862903595,
-0.5321091413497925,
-0.9560356736183167,
-0.6496454477310181,
0.5287957191467285,
0.5611885786056519,
0.1544809341430664,
0.23336978256702423,
0.5954847931861877,
0.09433653205633163,
0.08558303117752075,
-0.9118562936782837,
-0.4057941436767578,
-0.20061145722866058,
0.23134543001651764,
-0.2447272539138794,
-0.31674686074256897,
-0.0843849927186966,
-0.158221036195755,
0.2827104926109314,
0.1417190581560135,
0.6586992144584656,
0.41046857833862305,
-0.012392858974635601,
0.13193246722221375,
0.07342126965522766,
0.9137669801712036,
0.7307549715042114,
0.03827017545700073,
0.27369385957717896,
-0.06899402290582657,
-0.46229884028434753,
-0.05504824221134186,
-0.01621912606060505,
0.07222016900777817,
0.3014356791973114,
0.4999163746833801,
0.9702798128128052,
-0.015404434874653816,
0.19101861119270325,
0.18291105329990387,
-0.2311774492263794,
-0.089894600212574,
-0.5161019563674927,
-0.045943260192871094,
0.18641941249370575,
0.28136393427848816,
0.23034507036209106,
0.18278643488883972,
0.2717999219894409,
-0.42913827300071716,
0.2559857666492462,
0.352577805519104,
-0.8228799104690552,
-0.6223342418670654,
0.31304582953453064,
0.09399660676717758,
-0.785332202911377,
0.5909582376480103,
-0.2422284036874771,
-0.8155055642127991,
0.44966477155685425,
0.3520565330982208,
1.2232648134231567,
-0.32239067554473877,
0.10562674701213837,
0.22964376211166382,
0.6579833626747131,
0.5685554146766663,
-0.23433765769004822,
0.07247660309076309,
-0.49597376585006714,
-0.1951790750026703,
-0.8970776200294495,
0.02639944665133953,
0.42794543504714966,
-0.06855504959821701,
0.1342812329530716,
-0.5766685605049133,
0.22134365141391754,
-0.10681862384080887,
-0.14249864220619202,
-0.5164523720741272,
0.2287951111793518,
-0.0233992338180542,
0.6606681942939758,
-0.727984607219696,
0.6829656362533569,
0.6428502202033997,
0.07720006257295609,
-0.5751543045043945,
-0.04835669323801994,
-0.012055492959916592,
-0.43496185541152954,
0.4735497236251831,
-0.14970019459724426,
-0.1636912077665329,
-0.11757589876651764,
-0.3199913501739502,
-1.005272626876831,
0.7134146094322205,
0.29127413034439087,
-0.627278208732605,
-0.12266327440738678,
0.3310796320438385,
0.7491747736930847,
-0.2370709776878357,
0.20401747524738312,
0.34662795066833496,
0.2541233003139496,
-0.06859102100133896,
-0.5879395008087158,
-0.13427533209323883,
-0.3123590350151062,
0.05623522773385048,
0.5640224814414978,
-0.311789333820343,
1.0673160552978516,
0.25377634167671204,
-0.6170993447303772,
-0.18197393417358398,
0.5673375725746155,
-0.0036222918424755335,
-0.24869009852409363,
0.3797651529312134,
0.5553389191627502,
0.7359212040901184,
-0.4055791199207306,
1.345361351966858,
-0.11569175124168396,
0.46708306670188904,
0.7837010025978088,
0.29688194394111633,
0.2768588960170746,
0.32551369071006775,
-0.2781471312046051,
0.6043925285339355,
0.5002750754356384,
0.21360482275485992,
0.2156199961900711,
0.7257459163665771,
0.1261134296655655,
0.13706658780574799,
0.16656528413295746,
-0.5575871467590332,
0.5047243237495422,
0.4702598452568054,
-0.14932844042778015,
-0.11214037239551544,
-0.27213066816329956,
-0.00505924504250288,
0.10660505294799805,
0.02859029732644558,
0.8076153993606567,
0.40509775280952454,
-0.2513384521007538,
0.6705565452575684,
-0.0272973645478487,
0.2878594696521759,
-0.4974236488342285,
-0.128033846616745,
-0.3659847676753998,
0.011473564431071281,
-0.15777111053466797,
-0.6242510676383972,
0.7926360964775085,
-0.10544070601463318,
-0.1970827281475067,
-0.20264139771461487,
0.5910852551460266,
-0.45684540271759033,
-0.7443400025367737,
0.37445273995399475,
0.3798598349094391,
0.43414798378944397,
-0.10393845289945602,
-0.5468963980674744,
0.06476783752441406,
-0.16799385845661163,
-0.21175017952919006,
-0.152738556265831,
0.9049544334411621,
-0.06601494550704956,
0.42491817474365234,
0.5767785906791687,
0.37339159846305847,
0.25528526306152344,
0.0432475320994854,
0.9524976015090942,
-0.9397693276405334,
-0.5478842854499817,
-0.7878190875053406,
0.5526602864265442,
0.04257531091570854,
-0.10294431447982788,
0.4949616491794586,
0.3557914197444916,
0.7451677918434143,
-0.20345079898834229,
0.5043188333511353,
0.20449955761432648,
0.43516167998313904,
-0.5951363444328308,
1.1330658197402954,
-0.5366450548171997,
0.46621474623680115,
-0.4246494770050049,
-1.0647757053375244,
-0.5213835835456848,
0.5923171043395996,
-0.3471449315547943,
0.11045005917549133,
0.9572052359580994,
0.6631551384925842,
-0.375754714012146,
-0.1601761430501938,
0.48109927773475647,
0.6295943260192871,
0.5082252621650696,
0.3054782450199127,
0.9031965732574463,
-0.7034034729003906,
0.13998094201087952,
-0.19910934567451477,
-0.15948012471199036,
0.011109369806945324,
-0.6873663067817688,
-0.8669650554656982,
-1.0628440380096436,
-0.2747461497783661,
-0.061248715966939926,
-0.0032721490133553743,
0.08315029740333557,
0.6478028297424316,
-0.806968092918396,
-0.5359401702880859,
-0.5452438592910767,
0.5067751407623291,
0.17975984513759613,
-0.252457857131958,
0.49810197949409485,
-0.3685944974422455,
-0.4806036949157715,
0.243052139878273,
0.4943557679653168,
0.20824722945690155,
-0.580657422542572,
0.08112366497516632,
-0.30246591567993164,
0.03201965615153313,
0.5103286504745483,
0.08981361240148544,
-0.7619710564613342,
-0.3033761978149414,
0.131092831492424,
-0.032820943742990494,
0.050793249160051346,
1.069109320640564,
-0.7079227566719055,
0.355998158454895,
0.6264875531196594,
0.6605227589607239,
0.6608057618141174,
-0.4976586103439331,
0.8133565783500671,
-0.7102622389793396,
0.21640264987945557,
0.3508382737636566,
0.4152388274669647,
0.47213393449783325,
-0.32249218225479126,
0.4912591576576233,
0.26199665665626526,
-0.5058155655860901,
-0.8419268727302551,
0.5440204739570618,
-0.5680617094039917,
-0.29387831687927246,
0.9827190637588501,
-0.044987063854932785,
-0.35824310779571533,
-0.1664070188999176,
0.12125930935144424,
0.22881947457790375,
0.1042003408074379,
0.8827074766159058,
0.7464361190795898,
0.05400335043668747,
-0.35294008255004883,
-0.4698604643344879,
0.8763278126716614,
0.16995243728160858,
-0.5828390121459961,
0.09398296475410461,
0.14581845700740814,
-0.16857489943504333,
0.6360289454460144,
0.2668631970882416,
-0.3649066090583801,
-0.06828129291534424,
-0.11079344153404236,
-0.1833542138338089,
0.034185294061899185,
-0.7185073494911194,
-0.7763376235961914,
0.051710791885852814,
-0.02542935498058796,
0.16926872730255127
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.05797v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.05797v1
|
3D-MolT5: Towards Unified 3D Molecule-Text Modeling with 3D Molecular Tokenization
| 2024-06-09T14:20:55 | 2024-06-09T14:20:55 |
Qizhi Pei, Lijun Wu, Kaiyuan Gao, Jinhua Zhu, Rui Yan
|
q-bio.BM
|
q-bio.BM, cs.AI, cs.CE, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
The integration of molecule and language has garnered increasing attention in
molecular science. Recent advancements in Language Models (LMs) have
demonstrated potential for the comprehensive modeling of molecule and language.
However, existing works exhibit notable limitations. Most existing works
overlook the modeling of 3D information, which is crucial for understanding
molecular structures and also functions. While some attempts have been made to
leverage external structure encoding modules to inject the 3D molecular
information into LMs, there exist obvious difficulties that hinder the
integration of molecular structure and language text, such as modality
alignment and separate tuning. To bridge this gap, we propose 3D-MolT5, a
unified framework designed to model both 1D molecular sequence and 3D molecular
structure. The key innovation lies in our methodology for mapping fine-grained
3D substructure representations (based on 3D molecular fingerprints) to a
specialized 3D token vocabulary for 3D-MolT5. This 3D structure token
vocabulary enables the seamless combination of 1D sequence and 3D structure
representations in a tokenized format, allowing 3D-MolT5 to encode molecular
sequence (SELFIES), molecular structure, and text sequences within a unified
architecture. Alongside, we further introduce 1D and 3D joint pre-training to
enhance the model's comprehension of these diverse modalities in a joint
representation space and better generalize to various tasks for our foundation
model. Through instruction tuning on multiple downstream datasets, our proposed
3D-MolT5 shows superior performance than existing methods in molecular property
prediction, molecule captioning, and text-based molecule generation tasks. Our
code will be available on GitHub soon.
|
[
-0.40660688281059265,
-0.5567509531974792,
0.4952196478843689,
-0.16571930050849915,
-0.3786155879497528,
0.07391853630542755,
0.18146899342536926,
-0.4270874857902527,
0.014723164029419422,
0.6861764788627625,
-0.22221629321575165,
-0.6676661372184753,
-0.3748939037322998,
0.19033613801002502,
-0.07650461047887802,
0.783743143081665,
0.12696503102779388,
0.32432520389556885,
-0.38823431730270386,
-0.12136736512184143,
0.12695573270320892,
-0.8305820822715759,
-0.06682737171649933,
-0.06707211583852768,
0.5198529362678528,
0.38639357686042786,
0.30136460065841675,
0.9511283040046692,
0.9498432278633118,
0.2899053990840912,
-0.25481516122817993,
-0.059973541647195816,
-0.31982097029685974,
-0.2892338037490845,
-0.16244874894618988,
-0.36083558201789856,
-0.9511176943778992,
0.04386647418141365,
0.5524346828460693,
1.093174934387207,
0.00032031399314291775,
-0.06551017612218857,
-0.03723500296473503,
0.6987882852554321,
-0.41322413086891174,
0.03619180992245674,
-0.4577690064907074,
-0.01406290102750063,
-0.3868195414543152,
-0.06175849586725235,
0.017044242471456528,
0.18750618398189545,
0.18450970947742462,
-0.5900782346725464,
0.5526825189590454,
-0.1070283055305481,
0.5505394339561462,
-0.048807740211486816,
-0.7321216464042664,
-0.12576785683631897,
-0.4159579277038574,
0.390308678150177,
-0.789909303188324,
0.40261778235435486,
-0.09895043820142746,
0.28771305084228516,
-0.3097994327545166,
-0.8449971675872803,
-0.6340615749359131,
-0.2939597964286804,
0.004158609081059694,
0.15077194571495056,
0.24641036987304688,
0.5039235949516296,
-0.1947186291217804,
0.8258450627326965,
-0.5886930227279663,
-0.23780600726604462,
-0.7155530452728271,
-0.28707271814346313,
0.3439774811267853,
-0.07351816445589066,
0.27941814064979553,
-0.1737254410982132,
-0.9035392999649048,
-0.22522108256816864,
-0.5645298361778259,
-0.11206470429897308,
0.2636268734931946,
0.6971426010131836,
-0.11404837667942047,
0.6569725871086121,
-0.020023025572299957,
0.5074554681777954,
-0.06269089132547379,
0.05636562779545784,
0.3266829252243042,
-0.5391323566436768,
-0.38486072421073914,
0.22773964703083038,
0.8632315993309021,
0.23296797275543213,
0.01596243306994438,
0.11341384053230286,
-0.0488838329911232,
-0.2018955498933792,
0.14007234573364258,
-0.9089993834495544,
-0.3788118064403534,
0.5361115336418152,
-0.44067588448524475,
-0.3962581753730774,
0.4314393103122711,
-0.8421271443367004,
-0.5938811302185059,
-0.020935693755745888,
0.4227583408355713,
-0.5400157570838928,
-0.3013184070587158,
0.4479704797267914,
-0.29970693588256836,
-0.38185593485832214,
0.03267894685268402,
-1.1758933067321777,
0.17064820230007172,
0.4078373610973358,
0.8010908365249634,
-0.3982517719268799,
-0.26988258957862854,
-0.39801788330078125,
0.4835718870162964,
-0.04360073059797287,
0.4993044137954712,
-0.5369617938995361,
-0.7061123847961426,
-0.36069563031196594,
-0.19703255593776703,
0.14991071820259094,
-0.3430432081222534,
0.13425059616565704,
-0.10989774763584137,
0.41406014561653137,
0.049567919224500656,
-0.7606949210166931,
-0.3322913646697998,
0.19024862349033356,
-0.8946250677108765,
0.5326775908470154,
0.3529224097728729,
-0.45624691247940063,
0.10597451776266098,
-1.078626036643982,
-0.19650840759277344,
0.05398080125451088,
-0.3618803918361664,
-0.3456647992134094,
0.10025159269571304,
0.2903071939945221,
0.6716966032981873,
-0.2354714572429657,
0.03748039901256561,
-0.44146618247032166,
-0.11328333616256714,
-0.07345066964626312,
-0.2600099444389343,
0.5383743047714233,
0.09784503281116486,
-0.2100120633840561,
0.19690296053886414,
-1.0597631931304932,
-0.12427843362092972,
-0.2557024359703064,
-0.5933007597923279,
0.10425541549921036,
-0.4817187786102295,
0.2786848545074463,
0.03853194788098335,
0.45590338110923767,
-0.5644832849502563,
0.54768306016922,
-0.5755641460418701,
0.3972262740135193,
0.5900905728340149,
-0.06007025018334389,
0.8018820881843567,
0.13639190793037415,
0.5133399367332458,
0.6614030003547668,
-0.12835301458835602,
-0.5274537205696106,
-0.34795135259628296,
-0.2709987759590149,
-0.5037746429443359,
0.38419219851493835,
0.28459206223487854,
-0.44020888209342957,
0.17563460767269135,
-0.5227645635604858,
-0.335216760635376,
-0.11645791679620743,
0.29818856716156006,
0.4932151138782501,
0.41075599193573,
0.6613892912864685,
-0.37460848689079285,
-0.6250531673431396,
-0.8998726010322571,
-0.08462434262037277,
-0.1744535118341446,
-0.11046750843524933,
-0.09903689473867416,
0.5391857028007507,
-0.2778340280056,
0.8706830143928528,
0.004963718820363283,
-0.5784805417060852,
-0.5396348834037781,
0.06425470858812332,
0.13781718909740448,
0.8063441514968872,
0.4563392102718353,
-1.0412214994430542,
-0.08045237511396408,
0.3969949781894684,
-0.38986384868621826,
0.15920336544513702,
0.1459675431251526,
-0.06214514374732971,
0.26227447390556335,
0.6811827421188354,
-0.4283314049243927,
0.1346546858549118,
0.5699034929275513,
-0.5021721720695496,
-0.0023106157314032316,
-0.03546426072716713,
0.020930645987391472,
-1.4446678161621094,
0.2796871066093445,
-0.19053316116333008,
-0.182284414768219,
-0.5721886157989502,
0.042547572404146194,
-0.03210737183690071,
-0.029069384559988976,
-0.7853056192398071,
0.9297522902488708,
-0.5481510162353516,
-0.009064191952347755,
-0.0730694830417633,
0.15966206789016724,
0.24111604690551758,
0.6591764688491821,
-0.050845421850681305,
0.5084317922592163,
0.34191787242889404,
-0.6482458710670471,
0.2856366038322449,
-0.0045397416688501835,
-0.1287154108285904,
0.2900788187980652,
-0.44642361998558044,
-0.05183759704232216,
0.13462592661380768,
0.29243192076683044,
-0.8061239123344421,
-0.5614369511604309,
0.25679025053977966,
-0.44535624980926514,
0.19446443021297455,
-0.2652711272239685,
-0.09740635752677917,
-0.23010332882404327,
-0.1756473183631897,
0.499345064163208,
0.12565548717975616,
-0.508195698261261,
1.091078519821167,
0.3402290344238281,
0.26563647389411926,
-0.28741809725761414,
-0.6438388824462891,
-0.1945171356201172,
-0.13337531685829163,
-0.5480106472969055,
0.6917685866355896,
-0.011546739377081394,
0.2512909770011902,
0.015932857990264893,
-0.4566265344619751,
-0.16457174718379974,
-0.08593964576721191,
0.21522322297096252,
0.2198656052350998,
-0.44995805621147156,
0.013783164322376251,
-0.20645363628864288,
-0.2866520583629608,
-0.2549765408039093,
-0.6016148328781128,
0.38813281059265137,
-0.4674134850502014,
-0.26337292790412903,
-0.27238401770591736,
0.271805077791214,
1.0807174444198608,
-0.21371297538280487,
0.5616918206214905,
0.5127013921737671,
-0.27241164445877075,
0.1480754166841507,
-0.17375358939170837,
-0.17195738852024078,
-0.4831920862197876,
0.6009736061096191,
-0.7324225902557373,
-0.9880227446556091,
0.3682384788990021,
-0.13372069597244263,
-0.05147957429289818,
0.26514512300491333,
0.508394718170166,
-0.4164884686470032,
0.9897997379302979,
0.9273227453231812,
0.16950808465480804,
0.31117403507232666,
-0.1833166480064392,
0.29739615321159363,
-0.990338921546936,
-0.3528003394603729,
-0.15525318682193756,
-0.3192206919193268,
-0.4473875164985657,
-0.6395388841629028,
0.5027162432670593,
0.5768067836761475,
-0.18928998708724976,
0.33793917298316956,
-0.5282857418060303,
0.5728257894515991,
0.43913379311561584,
-0.20607222616672516,
0.09592414647340775,
0.1995413601398468,
-0.8649236559867859,
0.2983414828777313,
-0.7343727946281433,
-0.7285120487213135,
0.9924346208572388,
0.2698643207550049,
0.530581533908844,
0.24110941588878632,
0.5622915625572205,
0.004095644690096378,
-0.015670426189899445,
-0.4272371530532837,
0.6180368065834045,
-0.29870137572288513,
-0.5124159455299377,
-0.23641471564769745,
-0.4963928163051605,
-0.8359540700912476,
0.410549134016037,
-0.037342619150877,
-0.6549714803695679,
0.36885303258895874,
0.6281462907791138,
-0.4455292820930481,
0.43932870030403137,
-0.7069715857505798,
1.179890513420105,
-0.22357960045337677,
-0.1382153481245041,
0.15290610492229462,
-0.7647055387496948,
0.49071818590164185,
0.12228593230247498,
0.22014030814170837,
-0.3185637593269348,
-0.04709537699818611,
0.2680553197860718,
-0.5106402039527893,
0.7456573843955994,
-0.037835124880075455,
-0.2972269058227539,
0.03204618766903877,
0.180097296833992,
0.06542503088712692,
0.0909811407327652,
0.0257611982524395,
0.3101142942905426,
0.49892517924308777,
-0.6294008493423462,
-0.7313672304153442,
0.4921654462814331,
-0.3929659128189087,
-0.4753955900669098,
-0.2507063150405884,
-0.21366453170776367,
-0.28305548429489136,
0.3844086229801178,
0.26676055788993835,
0.5055640935897827,
-0.25226888060569763,
0.3808775246143341,
0.394738107919693,
0.1018710732460022,
0.3417334258556366,
0.4165140390396118,
-0.6348581910133362,
-0.5843701958656311,
1.153140664100647,
-0.3739071488380432,
0.40796706080436707,
0.8358187675476074,
0.15666615962982178,
-0.2934994399547577,
-0.35078611969947815,
-0.6584461331367493,
-0.12938858568668365,
-0.6830477118492126,
-0.15721523761749268,
-0.5309901237487793,
-0.13827387988567352,
-0.5467718839645386,
-0.23159189522266388,
-0.701996386051178,
-0.7024786472320557,
-0.22261078655719757,
-0.15312565863132477,
0.2069569230079651,
0.5879883766174316,
-0.3205524981021881,
0.05635901540517807,
-1.1217364072799683,
0.5629121661186218,
0.1143157109618187,
0.4018039107322693,
-0.3968404531478882,
-0.1648954153060913,
-0.428879052400589,
0.31267744302749634,
-0.1428423970937729,
-0.4889417588710785,
0.03020503930747509,
0.12876570224761963,
0.3854682445526123,
0.3636603355407715,
-0.5377893447875977,
0.6656244993209839,
-0.5004162192344666,
0.8996310234069824,
0.23516511917114258,
-0.9942411184310913,
0.5012863278388977,
-0.4416346848011017,
0.48249807953834534,
0.3768036365509033,
0.11203350126743317,
-0.46219414472579956,
-0.1418350487947464,
-0.4239831566810608,
-0.8705812692642212,
0.4842165410518646,
0.4221206307411194,
0.0058452836237847805,
-0.12828974425792694,
0.25120142102241516,
0.0012778188101947308,
0.29500842094421387,
-0.6950512528419495,
-0.06840582191944122,
-0.5812302231788635,
-0.5248593091964722,
0.1823856085538864,
-0.10777955502271652,
-0.07245998829603195,
-0.3652830421924591,
0.5754909515380859,
-0.3822401165962219,
0.3698548376560211,
0.351180762052536,
-0.07676268368959427,
0.34030988812446594,
0.05734213441610336,
0.8411518931388855,
0.25293534994125366,
-0.35661205649375916,
0.3350052237510681,
-0.18507765233516693,
-0.8246439099311829,
0.11378388851881027,
0.14443282783031464,
0.3730338215827942,
-0.14126914739608765,
0.46410176157951355,
0.7130696773529053,
0.2645970284938812,
-0.6984657645225525,
0.4090971350669861,
0.14039061963558197,
-0.34310436248779297,
0.26856666803359985,
0.27731120586395264,
0.2448754608631134,
0.013989133760333061,
0.246464803814888,
0.20315207540988922,
0.08066203445196152,
-0.6324109435081482,
0.20430760085582733,
0.2033972293138504,
-0.4948606491088867,
-0.3887520134449005,
0.8292762637138367,
0.6527433395385742,
0.10704103857278824,
0.27230018377304077,
0.1362593173980713,
-0.5474185943603516,
0.6885268092155457,
0.41402631998062134,
0.690105676651001,
-0.26704779267311096,
-0.05443979799747467,
0.3709844946861267,
0.06660746783018112,
0.1933944970369339,
0.3237890303134918,
-0.06887663155794144,
-0.7852673530578613,
0.15915486216545105,
-0.8050451874732971,
-0.1513703167438507,
0.12652599811553955,
-0.3530101478099823,
0.23186549544334412,
-0.3434716463088989,
0.24765925109386444,
-0.10298538208007812,
-0.1295374035835266,
-0.36708885431289673,
0.31720998883247375,
0.2843324840068817,
0.8397263288497925,
-0.18865598738193512,
0.9848804473876953,
0.7682642340660095,
-0.5298323631286621,
-0.4318855404853821,
-0.28483766317367554,
0.38340315222740173,
-0.3739326596260071,
0.5014575123786926,
0.41845571994781494,
-0.47062912583351135,
0.33328068256378174,
-0.4369712173938751,
-1.0587027072906494,
1.0715243816375732,
0.3399658501148224,
-0.6714550852775574,
0.012489387765526772,
0.5505762100219727,
0.4101538360118866,
-0.6378345489501953,
-0.06227801740169525,
0.5047618746757507,
0.3697667717933655,
0.3628372550010681,
-0.6841817498207092,
-0.24265897274017334,
-0.5803660154342651,
0.2334144413471222,
0.10666844248771667,
-0.4773094058036804,
0.7616075277328491,
-0.10609471052885056,
-0.3512252867221832,
0.2634502947330475,
0.739590585231781,
0.32346782088279724,
-0.2858785092830658,
0.21912835538387299,
0.3807387053966522,
0.76914381980896,
-0.05531219020485878,
1.1029353141784668,
-0.5642803907394409,
0.1309158354997635,
1.1217341423034668,
-0.25587397813796997,
0.7250093221664429,
0.6715603470802307,
0.09977740049362183,
0.3633534610271454,
0.471544474363327,
-0.11728047579526901,
0.441284716129303,
0.14694742858409882,
-0.32230013608932495,
-0.13562965393066406,
0.24967621266841888,
-0.35603830218315125,
0.45242801308631897,
0.44114771485328674,
-0.1514521688222885,
-0.17367906868457794,
0.3253670930862427,
-0.3201100528240204,
-0.08989299088716507,
-0.12749449908733368,
0.49346309900283813,
-0.009144138544797897,
-0.10142876952886581,
0.27227848768234253,
0.2348116785287857,
0.43418970704078674,
-0.43091362714767456,
-0.22183240950107574,
-0.44120851159095764,
0.2633424997329712,
0.13778163492679596,
-0.528878390789032,
0.075187548995018,
-0.28310608863830566,
-0.34819960594177246,
-0.40696102380752563,
0.2467661201953888,
-0.669373631477356,
-0.6763795018196106,
0.07346845418214798,
0.28482913970947266,
0.16556774079799652,
-0.035155847668647766,
-0.5744675993919373,
0.04878221079707146,
0.02944009006023407,
-0.287108838558197,
0.08451670408248901,
0.6031627655029297,
-0.012553662993013859,
0.5479061007499695,
0.731838047504425,
-0.2990560531616211,
0.10577171295881271,
0.0515783354640007,
0.7727532982826233,
-0.8922668695449829,
-0.35571715235710144,
-0.952294647693634,
0.8499377965927124,
0.009310400113463402,
-0.5060356259346008,
0.41793161630630493,
0.9605033993721008,
1.0161426067352295,
-0.17438338696956635,
0.7607304453849792,
-0.03321857377886772,
0.3670502007007599,
-0.8935141563415527,
0.6597709059715271,
-0.691114604473114,
0.42602381110191345,
-0.07041596621274948,
-0.820100724697113,
-0.49470773339271545,
0.6460156440734863,
0.3818489909172058,
0.20738844573497772,
0.8759369254112244,
0.8804356455802917,
-0.3901432156562805,
-0.09273310750722885,
0.3809838593006134,
0.3789252042770386,
0.6154797673225403,
0.434721976518631,
0.3446246087551117,
-0.45280733704566956,
0.6627576351165771,
-0.2220505177974701,
0.37378859519958496,
-0.3681493401527405,
-0.8514255881309509,
-1.1447679996490479,
-0.9124849438667297,
-0.010777225717902184,
-0.03335179015994072,
-0.1999373584985733,
0.8891945481300354,
0.8046965599060059,
-0.7718373537063599,
-0.18709075450897217,
-0.6788426637649536,
-0.06915794312953949,
0.17852628231048584,
-0.18756486475467682,
0.26856255531311035,
-0.08021702617406845,
-0.9114211797714233,
0.6494899392127991,
0.8080176115036011,
0.6843176484107971,
-0.4647025763988495,
0.08711645752191544,
-0.10094298422336578,
-0.039301205426454544,
0.4769919812679291,
0.26076140999794006,
-0.9230923652648926,
-0.010393505915999413,
-0.0014656857820227742,
-0.4572731852531433,
0.3798522651195526,
0.9027240872383118,
-0.7559353113174438,
0.6059662103652954,
0.3324871063232422,
0.5176137089729309,
0.3413529694080353,
-0.0430322103202343,
1.1969397068023682,
-0.6719298362731934,
0.09358624368906021,
0.20997588336467743,
0.3427659869194031,
0.4558314085006714,
-0.3429664075374603,
0.6366549730300903,
0.2749364972114563,
-0.007063120137900114,
-0.7025811076164246,
0.2714875340461731,
-1.130837321281433,
-0.44352975487709045,
0.7304344177246094,
0.11582865566015244,
-0.497973769903183,
0.12244027107954025,
-0.30253562331199646,
0.11132794618606567,
-0.16824066638946533,
0.5540089011192322,
0.8530526161193848,
-0.09445565193891525,
-0.21912872791290283,
-0.31193792819976807,
0.6718753576278687,
0.4030391275882721,
-0.7563969492912292,
-0.027081653475761414,
0.4144555330276489,
-0.03648774325847626,
0.21207158267498016,
0.4924943447113037,
-0.2653733789920807,
0.46003609895706177,
0.0446300245821476,
0.413173109292984,
-0.37294119596481323,
-0.5270256996154785,
-0.2310933917760849,
0.2994116544723511,
-0.7042379975318909,
-0.07820569723844528
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.05794v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.05794v2
|
RE-RAG: Improving Open-Domain QA Performance and Interpretability with Relevance Estimator in Retrieval-Augmented Generation
| 2024-06-09T14:11:19 | 2024-06-16T13:28:24 |
Kiseung Kim, Jay-Yoon Lee
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The Retrieval Augmented Generation (RAG) framework utilizes a combination of
parametric knowledge and external knowledge to demonstrate state-of-the-art
performance on open-domain question answering tasks. However, the RAG framework
suffers from performance degradation when the query is accompanied by
irrelevant contexts. In this work, we propose the RE-RAG framework, which
introduces a relevance estimator (RE) that not only provides relative relevance
between contexts as previous rerankers did, but also provides confidence, which
can be used to classify whether given context is useful for answering the given
question. We propose a weakly supervised method for training the RE simply
utilizing question-answer data without any labels for correct contexts. We show
that RE trained with a small generator (sLM) can not only improve the sLM
fine-tuned together with RE but also improve previously unreferenced large
language models (LLMs). Furthermore, we investigate new decoding strategies
that utilize the proposed confidence measured by RE such as choosing to let the
user know that it is "unanswerable" to answer the question given the retrieved
contexts or choosing to rely on LLM's parametric knowledge rather than
unrelated contexts.
|
[
-0.3478206992149353,
-0.6712353825569153,
0.6224574446678162,
-0.3114902079105377,
-0.2913486063480377,
-0.058542605489492416,
-0.20272044837474823,
-0.3267853260040283,
0.37387609481811523,
0.5102440714836121,
-0.27723243832588196,
-0.33363717794418335,
-0.39617884159088135,
0.13305582106113434,
-0.25197264552116394,
1.0084662437438965,
0.09094861149787903,
-0.17781640589237213,
-0.5181403160095215,
-0.1756543517112732,
-0.3120356798171997,
-0.22617515921592712,
-0.6815169453620911,
-0.20270584523677826,
0.4972103536128998,
0.38091719150543213,
0.641731858253479,
0.15692588686943054,
0.24917396903038025,
0.22144071757793427,
-0.22998566925525665,
0.37710851430892944,
-0.7312562465667725,
0.35545673966407776,
-0.46851846575737,
-0.48896268010139465,
-0.5851914286613464,
-0.23380175232887268,
0.6536905169487,
0.6179264783859253,
0.1269507110118866,
0.692838728427887,
0.19657737016677856,
0.521478533744812,
-0.9721181392669678,
0.029004868119955063,
-0.9082147479057312,
-0.321907639503479,
-0.007316731847822666,
-0.5639569163322449,
-0.5893054008483887,
-0.23356136679649353,
0.020352229475975037,
-0.7491322159767151,
0.3910687565803528,
0.20353788137435913,
0.9502615928649902,
0.5994170904159546,
-0.37525543570518494,
-0.030335813760757446,
-0.6510180234909058,
0.9623329043388367,
-0.5189787745475769,
0.47431379556655884,
0.6439324021339417,
0.43646541237831116,
-0.23969689011573792,
-0.9549005031585693,
-0.34819895029067993,
0.15864495933055878,
-0.15392239391803741,
0.2713514268398285,
0.10748348385095596,
-0.1276518553495407,
0.025209369137883186,
0.5110820531845093,
-0.2758982479572296,
-0.39880672097206116,
-0.24266302585601807,
-0.12002438306808472,
0.4229111671447754,
0.06855468451976776,
0.02287614531815052,
-0.11702936887741089,
-0.13567891716957092,
0.06077858805656433,
-0.6629788279533386,
0.2804723381996155,
-0.040612369775772095,
0.3254547119140625,
0.204991415143013,
0.6862317323684692,
-0.18470904231071472,
0.7367725968360901,
0.2423267662525177,
-0.34159597754478455,
0.2524794340133667,
-0.23727719485759735,
-0.06660029292106628,
-0.4406742453575134,
0.280984103679657,
-0.0635206401348114,
-0.050523582845926285,
-0.38763266801834106,
-0.3262231945991516,
-0.40495914220809937,
0.5772146582603455,
-0.6783306002616882,
0.07729240506887436,
0.2715137004852295,
-0.4978673756122589,
-0.10504326969385147,
0.19883812963962555,
-0.7899066209793091,
-0.015597864054143429,
-0.07584260404109955,
0.5605309009552002,
-0.20051316916942596,
-0.2364894449710846,
-0.07012079656124115,
-0.2204250544309616,
0.39341363310813904,
0.2599045932292938,
-0.526833176612854,
0.19396673142910004,
0.5670071840286255,
0.3853490948677063,
-0.024552766233682632,
-0.038336556404829025,
-0.8991104960441589,
0.11682897806167603,
-0.3132679760456085,
0.7295247912406921,
-0.5341012477874756,
-0.3155950903892517,
0.07527868449687958,
0.17995961010456085,
-0.058655995875597,
-0.5354819297790527,
0.8099362254142761,
-1.1103930473327637,
0.2886364459991455,
0.006397203076630831,
-0.39354589581489563,
-0.04187209531664848,
0.270192414522171,
-0.5525855422019958,
1.0264127254486084,
0.4520433843135834,
-0.8952584862709045,
0.47531577944755554,
-0.2715511918067932,
-0.31831973791122437,
-0.02783183753490448,
-0.1450543850660324,
-0.5060474276542664,
0.4537939429283142,
0.2875482738018036,
0.13776370882987976,
-0.48546841740608215,
0.07235804200172424,
-0.19133532047271729,
-0.5882280468940735,
0.27245670557022095,
-0.3153207302093506,
0.3394365906715393,
0.20260058343410492,
0.005043470300734043,
0.02837599627673626,
-0.7147263884544373,
0.4626871645450592,
0.05986681208014488,
-0.5619184374809265,
-0.4825870990753174,
-0.11256850510835648,
-0.08888598531484604,
-0.04772983863949776,
0.44738084077835083,
-0.5101349949836731,
-0.26397839188575745,
-0.6390345096588135,
-0.11501160264015198,
0.42775458097457886,
0.38697442412376404,
0.5985361337661743,
-0.5001551508903503,
0.7601913213729858,
-0.07269880920648575,
-0.1532498598098755,
0.03989628702402115,
-0.6545353531837463,
-0.5817700624465942,
-0.19938145577907562,
0.6590965986251831,
0.38342031836509705,
-1.2242258787155151,
0.061830323189496994,
-0.3796418309211731,
-0.08793384581804276,
-0.8501037359237671,
0.18800005316734314,
0.5943939685821533,
0.7250085473060608,
0.5606077313423157,
-0.09747803956270218,
-0.46195894479751587,
-0.7540515065193176,
-0.5974845290184021,
-0.15867921710014343,
-0.2696574926376343,
0.6416420340538025,
0.2517879009246826,
-0.23742106556892395,
1.1397104263305664,
-0.561940610408783,
-0.1369994431734085,
-0.13502703607082367,
0.0987888053059578,
0.33040404319763184,
0.25888508558273315,
0.28178948163986206,
-1.179298996925354,
-0.4609183371067047,
-0.06030889227986336,
-0.6553877592086792,
0.007047757972031832,
0.35786157846450806,
-0.16499806940555573,
0.14381535351276398,
0.31419315934181213,
-0.32473108172416687,
0.5481900572776794,
0.3169369399547577,
-0.14658889174461365,
0.351144015789032,
-0.19582071900367737,
0.4481967091560364,
-1.2009707689285278,
0.28700757026672363,
-0.24356453120708466,
-0.22923189401626587,
-0.586254358291626,
0.18067987263202667,
0.12135141342878342,
-0.21724651753902435,
-0.5182875990867615,
0.9371430277824402,
-0.4429005980491638,
-0.19867655634880066,
-0.49594488739967346,
0.3102858364582062,
0.14128629863262177,
0.40205976366996765,
0.03602391853928566,
1.2245153188705444,
0.28935277462005615,
-0.6856544017791748,
-0.3414524793624878,
0.3327508568763733,
-0.16870999336242676,
0.38832345604896545,
-0.5385482311248779,
0.21075919270515442,
-0.2682114243507385,
-0.011205102317035198,
-0.9018105864524841,
-0.42297545075416565,
-0.01976068504154682,
-0.7794920206069946,
0.3510532081127167,
-0.5066146850585938,
-0.25762662291526794,
-0.1873338222503662,
-0.13423579931259155,
0.6828353404998779,
0.7774689793586731,
-0.6222566366195679,
0.7253519892692566,
0.3916739523410797,
0.13652928173542023,
-0.8869682550430298,
-0.47361230850219727,
-0.31407228112220764,
-0.23234857618808746,
-0.6035123467445374,
0.36087754368782043,
0.1703566610813141,
-0.1854516863822937,
0.2204311490058899,
-0.4577009379863739,
-0.49545833468437195,
0.12734714150428772,
0.14080171287059784,
-0.03000021167099476,
-0.3876791000366211,
0.31693047285079956,
0.34702324867248535,
-0.21903112530708313,
-0.03040343150496483,
-0.247178316116333,
0.06697658449411392,
-0.03792063146829605,
-0.15242113173007965,
0.11569736152887344,
0.21566343307495117,
0.26085376739501953,
-0.39385026693344116,
0.9950604438781738,
0.6586571335792542,
-0.23896725475788116,
-0.30708444118499756,
-0.23355375230312347,
-0.2370864301919937,
-0.4408860206604004,
0.06502308696508408,
-0.6541275382041931,
-1.2259955406188965,
0.5183880925178528,
-0.22712695598602295,
-0.08469553291797638,
0.2962915599346161,
0.34147047996520996,
0.006263103801757097,
0.8180629014968872,
0.5925667881965637,
0.3048635423183441,
0.3726264536380768,
-0.05328257754445076,
0.10170281678438187,
-1.0927388668060303,
0.07369627058506012,
-0.47351375222206116,
0.005765232257544994,
-0.5212910175323486,
-0.602460503578186,
0.5683042407035828,
0.489433616399765,
-0.15070363879203796,
0.04094548150897026,
-0.4102887213230133,
0.4301753342151642,
0.49950841069221497,
0.22140218317508698,
0.22939248383045197,
-0.0013074865564703941,
0.08117054402828217,
0.0360344834625721,
-0.7948421835899353,
-0.5485847592353821,
1.296951413154602,
0.1858154833316803,
0.9550375938415527,
0.3343394696712494,
0.7876833081245422,
0.21173444390296936,
0.4618990421295166,
-0.5858956575393677,
0.33272498846054077,
-0.034752365201711655,
-0.7259567379951477,
-0.25531893968582153,
-0.5396559238433838,
-1.1845685243606567,
0.43524813652038574,
-0.16320429742336273,
-0.583522617816925,
0.32829511165618896,
0.2543855607509613,
-0.33454638719558716,
0.0636267364025116,
-0.575173556804657,
0.7288111448287964,
0.25269410014152527,
-0.4741676151752472,
0.23150289058685303,
-0.5448631048202515,
0.40067633986473083,
-0.15308696031570435,
0.09208732843399048,
0.19032421708106995,
-0.3243598937988281,
0.545355498790741,
-0.195229172706604,
0.5304811000823975,
-0.2358616292476654,
-0.10012705624103546,
0.6114609241485596,
-0.06177078187465668,
0.42802897095680237,
0.4955148994922638,
-0.255286306142807,
-0.1878449022769928,
-0.004126959014683962,
-0.49265745282173157,
-0.8418155908584595,
0.671986997127533,
-0.5138003826141357,
-0.8283522129058838,
-0.15734054148197174,
-0.5665081143379211,
-0.5047473311424255,
0.22954010963439941,
0.4018070697784424,
0.4382227063179016,
-0.11149977147579193,
0.37817615270614624,
0.8915389180183411,
-0.26719337701797485,
-0.17177052795886993,
0.4516355097293854,
-0.21793121099472046,
-0.5313584208488464,
0.8237178325653076,
-0.16063566505908966,
0.3503533601760864,
0.5907471179962158,
0.1153448298573494,
-0.3963131606578827,
-0.38722577691078186,
-0.3463153839111328,
0.1317964792251587,
-0.7734664082527161,
-0.4699101746082306,
-0.6036787033081055,
-0.129459410905838,
-0.526928186416626,
0.0023682911414653063,
-0.1598035842180252,
-0.372906893491745,
-0.3807145059108734,
0.29225054383277893,
0.27864813804626465,
0.38350579142570496,
0.10891687870025635,
0.11078421026468277,
-0.6058068871498108,
0.6787796020507812,
0.3260445296764374,
0.34575575590133667,
-0.2311384379863739,
-0.9403029680252075,
-0.47471264004707336,
0.1322283148765564,
-0.06705012172460556,
-0.8231651186943054,
0.2803904712200165,
0.15504956245422363,
0.6434470415115356,
-0.12054599821567535,
0.4350440502166748,
0.48291486501693726,
-0.43573877215385437,
0.669245183467865,
-0.42167767882347107,
-0.6798240542411804,
0.64926677942276,
-0.20407097041606903,
0.35241827368736267,
0.8486794233322144,
0.22395342588424683,
0.07206986844539642,
-0.4917726218700409,
-0.6567605137825012,
-0.9155372977256775,
0.6485236883163452,
0.19733619689941406,
-0.055414799600839615,
-0.25698307156562805,
0.6090325713157654,
-0.09986937046051025,
0.3405415117740631,
-0.39658161997795105,
-0.36404675245285034,
-0.18911603093147278,
-0.2320033311843872,
-0.1370604932308197,
-0.38439232110977173,
-0.13326910138130188,
-0.0012871103826910257,
0.8831160068511963,
-0.4157470166683197,
0.44763079285621643,
0.38701334595680237,
-0.2174634486436844,
-0.2814611792564392,
0.55840665102005,
0.4365730285644531,
0.8329206109046936,
-0.47138485312461853,
0.07470542192459106,
0.30416497588157654,
-0.4004937410354614,
0.23316888511180878,
-0.0057346513494849205,
-0.441899836063385,
0.11269577592611313,
0.06810270994901657,
0.4391918480396271,
0.40199095010757446,
-0.679334282875061,
0.43777230381965637,
-0.2618428170681,
0.0028538082260638475,
-0.27778080105781555,
0.08656692504882812,
-0.1688036471605301,
0.20507055521011353,
0.5227186679840088,
-0.03606453910470009,
0.29751846194267273,
-0.24557623267173767,
0.45634883642196655,
0.366164892911911,
-0.4288237690925598,
-0.08794542402029037,
0.8339827060699463,
-0.022068636491894722,
-0.3277963101863861,
0.17179684340953827,
-0.2795412242412567,
-0.2738429009914398,
0.5043427348136902,
0.6669827699661255,
0.9056829214096069,
-0.15063585340976715,
0.07663082331418991,
0.3818715214729309,
0.10433109104633331,
0.10620663315057755,
0.37134405970573425,
-0.15781375765800476,
-0.6968187689781189,
-0.6041914224624634,
-0.7557099461555481,
-0.41630905866622925,
0.12258975207805634,
-1.040230393409729,
-0.13172340393066406,
-0.13531501591205597,
-0.2881646454334259,
-0.2513819932937622,
0.05215023085474968,
-0.634661078453064,
0.38634756207466125,
-0.5594691634178162,
0.826553463935852,
-0.35694193840026855,
0.8111695051193237,
1.0730209350585938,
-0.601269006729126,
-0.7251660823822021,
0.5500935912132263,
-0.4301384687423706,
-0.3934876024723053,
0.701945960521698,
-0.13305693864822388,
-0.387470006942749,
0.21791785955429077,
-0.3523045778274536,
-0.991023063659668,
1.1427807807922363,
0.3158358037471771,
0.2286483198404312,
0.29426079988479614,
-0.3063659965991974,
0.668251633644104,
-0.3718443214893341,
0.21993814408779144,
0.27527889609336853,
0.17088058590888977,
0.08273185789585114,
-0.7522277235984802,
-0.00974367093294859,
-0.2479153722524643,
0.0708393082022667,
0.41257086396217346,
-0.384994775056839,
0.6974930763244629,
-0.12847110629081726,
-0.40343767404556274,
0.4547059237957001,
0.9327318072319031,
0.346962034702301,
0.5165327191352844,
0.22323891520500183,
0.40109214186668396,
0.5812735557556152,
0.014456425793468952,
1.1754815578460693,
-0.3825410306453705,
0.461824506521225,
1.2861533164978027,
-0.012805155478417873,
1.1076383590698242,
0.5735406875610352,
0.04541100934147835,
0.4466512203216553,
0.2374424934387207,
0.5731610655784607,
0.6432610750198364,
-0.01992538757622242,
-0.41316455602645874,
-0.3465098440647125,
-0.07868953049182892,
-0.39289847016334534,
0.18628054857254028,
0.2895420491695404,
-0.4011130928993225,
-0.25044408440589905,
0.01789393089711666,
-0.329842746257782,
0.38537123799324036,
-0.27023211121559143,
0.845642626285553,
0.1113690733909607,
-0.7902332544326782,
0.8188193440437317,
0.07734119892120361,
0.513651967048645,
-0.3691495656967163,
-0.12621012330055237,
-0.3204793334007263,
0.243123859167099,
-0.09748253226280212,
-0.8113164901733398,
0.32753637433052063,
-0.020040394738316536,
-0.5069940090179443,
0.012847392819821835,
1.0495233535766602,
-0.4298439919948578,
-0.154972642660141,
0.17231768369674683,
0.841013491153717,
0.19133685529232025,
0.04102575406432152,
-0.6186420321464539,
-0.2522335350513458,
-0.1413642317056656,
-0.23582513630390167,
0.41584312915802,
0.6612159013748169,
0.08647926151752472,
0.605720579624176,
0.5320985317230225,
-0.24456247687339783,
-0.037757132202386856,
-0.13877643644809723,
0.8745488524436951,
-0.5538831353187561,
-0.24219949543476105,
-0.09532467275857925,
0.4467804729938507,
-0.010881799273192883,
-0.30132800340652466,
0.925132691860199,
0.4446273446083069,
0.8277548551559448,
-0.13925674557685852,
0.3872436285018921,
-0.1733374148607254,
1.0202687978744507,
-0.4681907594203949,
0.5060482025146484,
-0.910591721534729,
0.3304131031036377,
-0.09528698027133942,
-0.8603994846343994,
-0.09644930809736252,
0.3900541663169861,
-0.5311772227287292,
0.2670421898365021,
0.45054179430007935,
0.771406888961792,
-0.17687618732452393,
-0.1972602903842926,
0.6050289869308472,
-0.09225688129663467,
0.022032011300325394,
0.35503554344177246,
0.678094208240509,
-0.7554654479026794,
0.48870745301246643,
-0.12852317094802856,
-0.09308768808841705,
-0.046051811426877975,
-0.4277382791042328,
-0.8825373649597168,
-0.5905129313468933,
-0.025321973487734795,
-0.6601393818855286,
0.17762669920921326,
0.4904014766216278,
0.526991069316864,
-0.7720435261726379,
0.039749398827552795,
0.17330199480056763,
0.3122221827507019,
-0.21204569935798645,
-0.26231491565704346,
0.4534589350223541,
-0.7583824992179871,
-0.6306045651435852,
0.5413535833358765,
0.035199813544750214,
-0.22048145532608032,
-0.02741210162639618,
-0.2160692662000656,
-0.28764498233795166,
0.138726606965065,
0.5607720017433167,
0.5350692272186279,
-0.7303141355514526,
-0.3461809754371643,
-0.004581407178193331,
0.017651155591011047,
0.05548262596130371,
0.6573604345321655,
-1.054620623588562,
0.37635621428489685,
0.5474488735198975,
1.1245231628417969,
0.45981156826019287,
0.5923475623130798,
0.42764410376548767,
-1.151158094406128,
-0.0031302093993872404,
0.38120824098587036,
0.15051540732383728,
0.1150202602148056,
-0.4205624461174011,
0.7196792364120483,
-0.022410262376070023,
-0.8539947271347046,
-0.8846874833106995,
0.21788129210472107,
-0.6270365715026855,
-0.3146212697029114,
1.1712180376052856,
-0.2913389503955841,
-0.6010724902153015,
-0.4095940589904785,
-0.014458803460001945,
0.06587707251310349,
-0.3635176420211792,
0.38925543427467346,
0.1810792088508606,
-0.023476041853427887,
-0.3117768466472626,
-0.645713746547699,
0.6802307963371277,
0.5999738574028015,
-0.7458460927009583,
-0.1782766878604889,
0.3705355226993561,
0.3508923649787903,
0.34232041239738464,
0.6740972995758057,
-0.14198459684848785,
0.49468204379081726,
0.0882880762219429,
-0.14307594299316406,
0.03872907906770706,
-0.36059343814849854,
-0.3283887803554535,
0.39238372445106506,
0.3975142538547516,
-0.14028824865818024
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.05766v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.05766v1
|
Gentle-CLIP: Exploring Aligned Semantic In Low-Quality Multimodal Data With Soft Alignment
| 2024-06-09T12:41:14 | 2024-06-09T12:41:14 |
Zijia Song, Zelin Zang, Yelin Wang, Guozheng Yang, Jiangbin Zheng, Kaicheng yu, Wanyu Chen, Stan Z. Li
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV
|
Multimodal fusion breaks through the barriers between diverse modalities and
has already yielded numerous impressive performances. However, in various
specialized fields, it is struggling to obtain sufficient alignment data for
the training process, which seriously limits the use of previously elegant
models. Thus, semi-supervised learning attempts to achieve multimodal alignment
with fewer matched pairs but traditional methods like pseudo-labeling are
difficult to apply in domains with no label information. To address these
problems, we transform semi-supervised multimodal alignment into a manifold
matching problem and propose a new method based on CLIP, named Gentle-CLIP.
Specifically, we design a novel semantic density distribution loss to explore
implicit semantic alignment information from unpaired multimodal data by
constraining the latent representation distribution with fine granularity, thus
eliminating the need for numerous strictly matched pairs. Meanwhile, we
introduce multi-kernel maximum mean discrepancy as well as self-supervised
contrastive loss to pull separate modality distributions closer and enhance the
stability of the representation distribution. In addition, the contrastive loss
used in CLIP is employed on the supervised matched data to prevent negative
optimization. Extensive experiments conducted on a range of tasks in various
fields, including protein, remote sensing, and the general vision-language
field, demonstrate the effectiveness of our proposed Gentle-CLIP.
|
[
-0.3984106183052063,
-0.8701990246772766,
0.5204532146453857,
-0.05183335393667221,
-0.42078840732574463,
-0.15799951553344727,
-0.15505360066890717,
0.0038842319045215845,
0.3277243971824646,
0.267837792634964,
-0.9411930441856384,
-0.7180535793304443,
-0.4167431592941284,
0.05743250250816345,
-0.3346561789512634,
0.9135345816612244,
-0.2192751169204712,
0.2436622977256775,
-0.18227951228618622,
-0.5752671957015991,
-0.6269629597663879,
0.020499104633927345,
0.04831443354487419,
0.31881245970726013,
0.5115759968757629,
0.30980947613716125,
0.6443620920181274,
0.8097591996192932,
0.6467240452766418,
0.25950267910957336,
0.013739997521042824,
0.5547488331794739,
-0.5533893704414368,
0.018830444663763046,
-0.18368428945541382,
-0.31387048959732056,
-0.24731606245040894,
0.11927392333745956,
0.9186167120933533,
0.761750340461731,
-0.021341467276215553,
0.005513708107173443,
0.1656329482793808,
0.4004051387310028,
-0.850888729095459,
-0.24284446239471436,
-0.4940439760684967,
0.27108150720596313,
-0.4605361819267273,
-0.38504934310913086,
-0.10772944986820221,
-0.09596926718950272,
-0.06448838859796524,
-0.7420436143875122,
0.40633538365364075,
0.030880268663167953,
0.825803816318512,
0.6041186451911926,
-0.7419548034667969,
0.07734085619449615,
-0.4514744281768799,
1.0034937858581543,
-0.1423594057559967,
0.48580342531204224,
0.03534848615527153,
0.29768553376197815,
-0.17636851966381073,
-0.32044169306755066,
-0.6968741416931152,
0.32529962062835693,
0.2796022593975067,
0.21107234060764313,
-0.0012571685947477818,
-0.06971630454063416,
-0.12103666365146637,
0.06626268476247787,
-0.4058873653411865,
0.03807465359568596,
-0.13360776007175446,
-0.6031059622764587,
0.37026554346084595,
0.3819015622138977,
0.26506784558296204,
-0.25881651043891907,
-0.8961099982261658,
-0.5970109105110168,
-0.512320876121521,
0.025415463373064995,
0.35112327337265015,
0.18107756972312927,
-0.11924299597740173,
1.0205280780792236,
0.16271665692329407,
0.6800968050956726,
0.06551151722669601,
-0.4627169966697693,
0.10731042921543121,
-0.679000973701477,
0.027754250913858414,
0.09828411787748337,
0.8111104369163513,
0.9540442824363708,
-0.23465442657470703,
-0.037402037531137466,
-0.077961266040802,
0.5325563549995422,
-0.04178478196263313,
-0.4675813913345337,
-0.2453911006450653,
-0.17761670053005219,
-0.3066239058971405,
-0.2703748643398285,
-0.020914074033498764,
-0.9537224769592285,
-0.22253897786140442,
-0.39518633484840393,
0.7158855199813843,
-0.506489098072052,
0.06438379734754562,
0.15259428322315216,
-0.246459499001503,
0.15944701433181763,
0.42273256182670593,
-0.7507550120353699,
0.01541497278958559,
0.5401937961578369,
1.0454151630401611,
-0.24528177082538605,
-0.28771498799324036,
-0.5941712260246277,
0.7199591398239136,
-0.14897917211055756,
0.8825131058692932,
-0.5170543193817139,
-0.3261994421482086,
-0.08962858468294144,
0.3989565074443817,
-0.11191485077142715,
-0.22060531377792358,
0.6390772461891174,
-0.017984693869948387,
0.07324668020009995,
0.16665929555892944,
-0.6058554649353027,
-0.13896101713180542,
0.3429644703865051,
-0.43835607171058655,
0.7227209806442261,
-0.06848356127738953,
-0.8235797882080078,
0.5710717439651489,
-0.07063882797956467,
-0.24288442730903625,
-0.30690038204193115,
-0.2987774908542633,
-0.5300107002258301,
-0.003294241614639759,
0.3658559322357178,
0.6032335758209229,
0.04057339206337929,
0.123822420835495,
-0.9281539916992188,
-0.21227425336837769,
0.17346325516700745,
-0.3485730290412903,
0.5556812286376953,
-0.0057614641264081,
-0.08656280487775803,
0.25266963243484497,
-0.5657246112823486,
-0.1042172983288765,
-0.04333742707967758,
0.3127270042896271,
-0.6118708848953247,
-0.16580411791801453,
0.11956898123025894,
0.2770991623401642,
0.00306847901083529,
-0.7058756351470947,
0.4415986239910126,
-0.13242235779762268,
0.3574191629886627,
1.0874545574188232,
-0.10747860372066498,
0.8124719858169556,
-0.34962040185928345,
0.27108636498451233,
0.1303102672100067,
0.34300193190574646,
0.26273295283317566,
-0.27372294664382935,
-0.2810511887073517,
-0.8420435786247253,
0.25621822476387024,
0.32626277208328247,
-0.801145613193512,
0.11725561320781708,
-0.19270405173301697,
-0.2806779146194458,
-1.0347673892974854,
0.5408111810684204,
0.299889475107193,
0.845935046672821,
0.3805813193321228,
-0.6182364225387573,
-0.10862050950527191,
-1.1428461074829102,
0.182420015335083,
0.5088987350463867,
-0.043786387890577316,
0.5487754940986633,
0.18208688497543335,
-0.51153564453125,
0.9819899201393127,
-0.8150931596755981,
-0.9516109228134155,
0.1299910992383957,
0.1341860443353653,
-0.06313621997833252,
0.7212274074554443,
0.5710223317146301,
-0.9976649284362793,
-0.2557072639465332,
-0.23140643537044525,
-0.6815329194068909,
0.1106780469417572,
0.21246781945228577,
-0.4699770212173462,
0.03245091810822487,
0.07069249451160431,
-0.4819622337818146,
0.27548348903656006,
0.569888174533844,
-0.1794711947441101,
0.2566811144351959,
-0.2623361349105835,
0.1422400325536728,
-1.009832501411438,
-0.05575085058808327,
0.16097639501094818,
-0.28272730112075806,
-0.28465306758880615,
-0.33134207129478455,
0.22465860843658447,
-0.21721406280994415,
-0.8543786406517029,
0.5162308216094971,
-0.4096289873123169,
-0.07649331539869308,
0.006637951359152794,
0.24357974529266357,
0.3814278542995453,
0.46017369627952576,
0.08508914709091187,
0.8323459625244141,
0.6519646048545837,
-0.49965906143188477,
0.29282164573669434,
0.745349109172821,
-0.25323382019996643,
0.9381135702133179,
-0.3799528181552887,
0.07504479587078094,
-0.2369385063648224,
0.37610068917274475,
-0.8569197654724121,
-0.400546133518219,
0.16908368468284607,
-0.10985545814037323,
0.48828259110450745,
-0.4491353929042816,
-0.42462581396102905,
0.10731959342956543,
-0.9482603073120117,
0.8307883143424988,
0.2775113880634308,
-0.3492286801338196,
0.2460222989320755,
0.6286587119102478,
0.007528956048190594,
-0.5698757767677307,
-0.6659616231918335,
-0.2227063775062561,
-0.4333552420139313,
-1.0062758922576904,
0.563904345035553,
0.02917708083987236,
0.2514660060405731,
0.18374666571617126,
-0.16597972810268402,
-0.07717302441596985,
-0.060655348002910614,
0.04710230976343155,
0.49312102794647217,
-0.10971759259700775,
-0.009830550290644169,
0.3730846345424652,
-0.13092276453971863,
-0.41377201676368713,
-0.277537077665329,
0.31999731063842773,
-0.020432885736227036,
-0.4990992546081543,
-0.6704309582710266,
0.4824826419353485,
0.1656343936920166,
-0.05194370821118355,
0.537535548210144,
1.071547508239746,
-0.1250099390745163,
0.028406936675310135,
-0.4670584797859192,
-0.18187138438224792,
-0.44804906845092773,
0.15327224135398865,
-0.19477543234825134,
-0.7607545852661133,
0.33335211873054504,
-0.10579247772693634,
-0.32796984910964966,
0.40666621923446655,
0.41143882274627686,
-0.6298356056213379,
1.4808545112609863,
0.9135721921920776,
0.3957020938396454,
0.42098987102508545,
-0.43109866976737976,
-0.11809364706277847,
-1.1088476181030273,
-0.4399920701980591,
-0.17670080065727234,
-0.5513791441917419,
-0.6587411165237427,
-0.5498583912849426,
0.6972416639328003,
0.08083558827638626,
0.2681991159915924,
0.24628445506095886,
-0.7440328598022461,
0.2379089891910553,
0.492523193359375,
0.3383781611919403,
0.058832403272390366,
-0.06824496388435364,
-0.14298178255558014,
-0.34749293327331543,
-0.577960729598999,
-0.3172400891780853,
0.8766505122184753,
0.08218735456466675,
1.2289577722549438,
0.2390335351228714,
0.5967250466346741,
0.25531071424484253,
-0.2132328599691391,
-0.7046797871589661,
0.4905867278575897,
-0.47052547335624695,
-0.3106793761253357,
-0.059126053005456924,
-0.529509425163269,
-0.8793230056762695,
0.09787359088659286,
-0.43874698877334595,
-0.5153433680534363,
0.31813496351242065,
0.32784488797187805,
-0.08603691309690475,
0.07526618242263794,
-0.8692060708999634,
1.1914466619491577,
-0.1513012796640396,
-0.7145724296569824,
0.11105009913444519,
-1.101775050163269,
0.39147213101387024,
0.08655833452939987,
0.1742457002401352,
-0.4413411319255829,
-0.22702032327651978,
0.9360406398773193,
-0.4070301949977875,
0.6593859791755676,
-0.3336087465286255,
0.04745054990053177,
0.23442527651786804,
0.11675576865673065,
0.2853451669216156,
0.07950963079929352,
0.558496356010437,
-0.09045959264039993,
0.4289044439792633,
-0.5903252363204956,
-0.6889838576316833,
0.6567431688308716,
-0.6065991520881653,
-0.20299723744392395,
-0.16217154264450073,
-0.7510494589805603,
-0.3048202693462372,
0.21517154574394226,
0.18128763139247894,
0.8198503255844116,
0.16766107082366943,
0.06512581557035446,
0.688211977481842,
0.15203876793384552,
0.2040584832429886,
0.1495986133813858,
0.14313168823719025,
-0.5575770139694214,
1.2964370250701904,
0.04665723070502281,
0.12232011556625366,
0.3610829710960388,
0.18929928541183472,
-0.712460458278656,
-0.4644789397716522,
-0.5119252800941467,
0.32809731364250183,
-0.713134229183197,
-0.3923591375350952,
-0.5781638622283936,
0.4706824719905853,
-0.4803965389728546,
-0.47499513626098633,
-0.36938196420669556,
-0.5814864635467529,
-0.37584635615348816,
0.3533177375793457,
0.19662298262119293,
0.4322386682033539,
-0.14484311640262604,
0.08645384013652802,
-0.9711651802062988,
0.3086852729320526,
0.2687043249607086,
0.2544870972633362,
-0.5205891132354736,
-0.23467035591602325,
0.2714502513408661,
0.07450009137392044,
-0.5747313499450684,
-0.806920051574707,
0.34735777974128723,
0.447040319442749,
0.2995123863220215,
0.4739789366722107,
0.12669020891189575,
1.0279762744903564,
-0.4847891926765442,
0.5637871623039246,
0.4498631954193115,
-0.754406213760376,
0.5886504650115967,
-0.3741343319416046,
0.15659910440444946,
0.8018572330474854,
0.30482637882232666,
-0.2915308475494385,
-0.2686454653739929,
-0.46166500449180603,
-0.8492349982261658,
0.5966631770133972,
0.09362702071666718,
0.09529910236597061,
-0.03158288821578026,
-0.06940505653619766,
0.3977862298488617,
0.19195355474948883,
-0.2503351867198944,
-0.0777263417840004,
-0.3976174294948578,
-0.6393654942512512,
-0.04501647874712944,
-0.11666932702064514,
-0.5835000276565552,
-0.18817895650863647,
0.43256014585494995,
-0.4799877107143402,
0.4957979917526245,
0.3300916254520416,
-0.37031421065330505,
0.0409700907766819,
0.131540909409523,
0.7444681525230408,
0.09957102686166763,
-0.35610103607177734,
0.4784255623817444,
-0.050248194485902786,
-0.3675134479999542,
0.30073532462120056,
0.35268810391426086,
-0.04641471058130264,
-0.03313511982560158,
0.2837400734424591,
0.4454825222492218,
0.5817409753799438,
-0.6663989424705505,
1.0288408994674683,
-0.013052799738943577,
-0.03756267577409744,
0.1686059534549713,
-0.14129674434661865,
-0.24254806339740753,
0.15688998997211456,
0.07926111668348312,
0.19638723134994507,
0.3159131705760956,
-0.44983816146850586,
0.6265095472335815,
0.8805545568466187,
-0.5715451836585999,
-0.4392217993736267,
0.5937915444374084,
0.11898449063301086,
0.19523173570632935,
0.43415606021881104,
-0.051176007837057114,
-0.47080013155937195,
0.18340325355529785,
0.4114384055137634,
0.5108076930046082,
0.11335954070091248,
0.24659086763858795,
-0.17913557589054108,
-0.24179556965827942,
0.05784030631184578,
0.05958614498376846,
-0.33162689208984375,
-0.5476933121681213,
-0.38164427876472473,
-0.4559735655784607,
-0.3411903381347656,
-0.5840098857879639,
-0.7217578291893005,
0.5676020979881287,
-0.2851448953151703,
-0.13716945052146912,
0.05736066401004791,
-0.19429853558540344,
-0.6990043520927429,
-0.10641837120056152,
-0.029819265007972717,
0.6091834902763367,
-0.835604190826416,
0.6403101086616516,
0.684395432472229,
-0.37902534008026123,
-0.6637020111083984,
-0.37634724378585815,
0.36522287130355835,
-0.9560617804527283,
0.37691858410835266,
0.3341147005558014,
-0.3699576258659363,
-0.029037337750196457,
-0.6785620450973511,
-0.5926067233085632,
1.1468759775161743,
0.47377127408981323,
-0.3181092441082001,
0.05901497229933739,
-0.21286535263061523,
0.14867503941059113,
-0.07257277518510818,
0.03621122986078262,
0.06661715358495712,
0.23690460622310638,
0.4252445101737976,
-0.6857998967170715,
-0.1410249024629593,
0.008027677424252033,
-0.1429697722196579,
0.6333669424057007,
-0.846919596195221,
0.48763689398765564,
0.0416923426091671,
-0.4152563512325287,
0.05520866811275482,
0.5903874039649963,
-0.013853724114596844,
0.5403239727020264,
0.4766547977924347,
0.6617667078971863,
0.41328349709510803,
-0.006655179895460606,
0.795551061630249,
0.06421935558319092,
0.764259934425354,
0.7336147427558899,
-0.3014558255672455,
0.534107506275177,
0.8576052188873291,
0.09301530569791794,
0.01984945870935917,
0.5414355397224426,
-0.1740015596151352,
1.006995439529419,
-0.3165222704410553,
-0.14074942469596863,
-0.35680902004241943,
-0.7960349917411804,
-0.17973148822784424,
0.47509557008743286,
0.01084848027676344,
0.09772229194641113,
-0.41862159967422485,
0.3547043204307556,
-0.17574870586395264,
0.10109677165746689,
-0.19089818000793457,
0.7497111558914185,
0.012623051181435585,
-0.1572878211736679,
0.5050244331359863,
-0.2974347472190857,
0.8945781588554382,
-0.5576042532920837,
-0.2281339466571808,
-0.038072582334280014,
0.17117485404014587,
-0.1674266755580902,
-1.1056511402130127,
0.2976682484149933,
-0.36950811743736267,
0.0013556546764448285,
-0.31986668705940247,
0.6543217301368713,
-0.6403250098228455,
-0.4662196636199951,
0.14905749261379242,
0.0962274894118309,
0.15808939933776855,
0.4140501022338867,
-0.6692489981651306,
0.2558979094028473,
-0.17815589904785156,
0.06292112171649933,
0.5015478730201721,
0.4779408276081085,
0.03461306542158127,
0.5721270442008972,
0.5171815752983093,
-0.15648894011974335,
0.1816563457250595,
-0.20439693331718445,
0.9960716962814331,
-0.4842759966850281,
-0.2690591514110565,
-0.6507465839385986,
0.36762934923171997,
0.012632208876311779,
-0.425664484500885,
0.7121731042861938,
0.4160810708999634,
0.7687846422195435,
-0.07190344482660294,
0.08481375128030777,
-0.013341975398361683,
0.29074087738990784,
-0.9502934217453003,
0.26064613461494446,
-0.9282616376876831,
-0.22059331834316254,
-0.6310872435569763,
-1.0766528844833374,
-0.4868210554122925,
0.49091529846191406,
-0.0429285429418087,
-0.32982107996940613,
0.6514153480529785,
0.8278469443321228,
-0.558673620223999,
-0.3216894567012787,
0.25570324063301086,
-0.04411526769399643,
0.2348513901233673,
0.5709152221679688,
0.8432751297950745,
-0.1922065019607544,
0.7335624694824219,
-0.6697870492935181,
-0.21548494696617126,
-0.1794978827238083,
-0.8678131699562073,
-0.7060521245002747,
-0.7179469466209412,
-0.2968579828739166,
-0.16711580753326416,
-0.051113877445459366,
0.8461264371871948,
0.80775386095047,
-0.39500150084495544,
0.45809465646743774,
0.21467697620391846,
0.06109489127993584,
-0.0746607631444931,
-0.21068045496940613,
0.7651231288909912,
-0.052097585052251816,
-0.7876747250556946,
0.3903428018093109,
0.4004688858985901,
0.4201684594154358,
-0.11450877785682678,
0.10051822662353516,
-0.32673442363739014,
-0.4462009370326996,
0.25130319595336914,
0.1813001185655594,
-0.6451539397239685,
-0.4373309314250946,
0.05078614130616188,
-0.04867590591311455,
-0.02858366072177887,
0.5994332432746887,
-0.5304943919181824,
0.6022520661354065,
0.2651095688343048,
0.7547703981399536,
0.5176401138305664,
0.17988507449626923,
0.47276318073272705,
-0.9327216744422913,
0.42244940996170044,
0.38569286465644836,
0.4117785096168518,
0.4601074755191803,
-0.1286856085062027,
0.319749116897583,
0.4898197650909424,
-0.390235960483551,
-0.9767122864723206,
0.2701301872730255,
-1.6808233261108398,
0.0047381604090332985,
1.0483932495117188,
0.014395534992218018,
-0.5869290828704834,
-0.05233820155262947,
-0.5117546319961548,
0.25368961691856384,
-0.3766254484653473,
0.5876743197441101,
0.43140819668769836,
-0.17152436077594757,
-0.12343407422304153,
-0.18304939568042755,
0.4483245313167572,
0.7495912313461304,
-0.23146691918373108,
-0.41336774826049805,
0.5428903698921204,
0.31737592816352844,
0.12620599567890167,
0.18682678043842316,
-0.03985094279050827,
0.2881876230239868,
-0.24610844254493713,
-0.20057356357574463,
-0.12302926182746887,
-0.404173344373703,
-0.31109675765037537,
0.17748771607875824,
-0.12087473273277283,
-0.6520658135414124
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.05761v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.05761v1
|
The BiGGen Bench: A Principled Benchmark for Fine-grained Evaluation of Language Models with Language Models
| 2024-06-09T12:30:30 | 2024-06-09T12:30:30 |
Seungone Kim, Juyoung Suk, Ji Yong Cho, Shayne Longpre, Chaeeun Kim, Dongkeun Yoon, Guijin Son, Yejin Cho, Sheikh Shafayat, Jinheon Baek, Sue Hyun Park, Hyeonbin Hwang, Jinkyung Jo, Hyowon Cho, Haebin Shin, Seongyun Lee, Hanseok Oh, Noah Lee, Namgyu Ho, Se June Joo, Miyoung Ko, Yoonjoo Lee, Hyungjoo Chae, Jamin Shin, Joel Jang, Seonghyeon Ye, Bill Yuchen Lin, Sean Welleck, Graham Neubig, Moontae Lee, Kyungjae Lee, Minjoon Seo
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
As language models (LMs) become capable of handling a wide range of tasks,
their evaluation is becoming as challenging as their development. Most
generation benchmarks currently assess LMs using abstract evaluation criteria
like helpfulness and harmlessness, which often lack the flexibility and
granularity of human assessment. Additionally, these benchmarks tend to focus
disproportionately on specific capabilities such as instruction following,
leading to coverage bias. To overcome these limitations, we introduce the
BiGGen Bench, a principled generation benchmark designed to thoroughly evaluate
nine distinct capabilities of LMs across 77 diverse tasks. A key feature of the
BiGGen Bench is its use of instance-specific evaluation criteria, closely
mirroring the nuanced discernment of human evaluation. We apply this benchmark
to assess 103 frontier LMs using five evaluator LMs. Our code, data, and
evaluation results are all publicly available at
https://github.com/prometheus-eval/prometheus-eval/tree/main/BiGGen-Bench.
|
[
-0.5720928907394409,
-0.7497376799583435,
0.7322458624839783,
0.27736663818359375,
0.03230712562799454,
-0.050697408616542816,
-0.6294722557067871,
-0.27476105093955994,
-0.5565548539161682,
0.5474328398704529,
-0.29666218161582947,
-0.5687357187271118,
-0.36134856939315796,
-0.0900254100561142,
-0.5312790274620056,
0.5756581425666809,
0.05340270325541496,
0.008649015799164772,
-0.2532711625099182,
-0.1458287537097931,
-0.3589318096637726,
-0.2651824951171875,
-0.25640368461608887,
-0.4588022530078888,
0.27103662490844727,
0.372749388217926,
0.6670603156089783,
0.6397742629051208,
0.6225478053092957,
0.32756707072257996,
-0.18355126678943634,
0.03377416357398033,
-0.4693269729614258,
0.015403671190142632,
-0.45033055543899536,
-0.1701725721359253,
-0.274422287940979,
0.14321649074554443,
0.8216831088066101,
0.9200354814529419,
-0.10607839375734329,
0.34537068009376526,
0.16346216201782227,
0.7050643563270569,
-0.8631428480148315,
0.14611728489398956,
-0.5807863473892212,
0.04943260923027992,
-0.20313939452171326,
0.13133986294269562,
-0.4510277211666107,
-0.5659880638122559,
0.07173354923725128,
-0.24201571941375732,
0.17388522624969482,
-0.03431925177574158,
0.7698601484298706,
0.036733970046043396,
-0.10616778582334518,
0.24395374953746796,
-0.9291787147521973,
1.0618313550949097,
-0.6584768295288086,
0.542436420917511,
0.5019813776016235,
0.7279682159423828,
-0.2340484857559204,
-0.8137990236282349,
-0.46540963649749756,
-0.6259199976921082,
0.24887654185295105,
-0.17879968881607056,
-0.14368143677711487,
0.06327055394649506,
0.3384740948677063,
0.6590495705604553,
-0.4970051050186157,
0.3355714678764343,
-0.35575950145721436,
-0.12666486203670502,
0.6758063435554504,
0.0752730518579483,
0.220784991979599,
-0.09403889626264572,
-0.4196680188179016,
-0.3406142592430115,
-0.6994635462760925,
-0.14767713844776154,
0.2357340008020401,
0.48059654235839844,
-0.03565025329589844,
0.40537989139556885,
-0.4766221344470978,
0.7598658800125122,
-0.2623237073421478,
0.03572705388069153,
0.5619614720344543,
-0.3162118196487427,
-0.27844497561454773,
-0.12336142361164093,
0.9621549844741821,
0.415434867143631,
0.17245477437973022,
-0.2961181104183197,
-0.3614400625228882,
-0.02065206877887249,
0.3693179786205292,
-0.9595821499824524,
0.16970866918563843,
0.2313113957643509,
-0.5944284200668335,
-0.24998383224010468,
-0.04948003962635994,
-0.9681105017662048,
-0.6341281533241272,
-0.37037602066993713,
0.4566749334335327,
-0.5750439763069153,
-0.24775271117687225,
0.18933387100696564,
-0.13961943984031677,
0.33682629466056824,
-0.06333839893341064,
-0.8288297653198242,
0.5408816933631897,
1.1061385869979858,
0.6155504584312439,
0.05613483116030693,
-0.4842106103897095,
-0.6584033966064453,
-0.1500912606716156,
-0.3703449070453644,
0.6330346465110779,
-0.7874177098274231,
-0.4645887017250061,
0.1395234763622284,
-0.11211306601762772,
-0.042266085743904114,
-0.6876200437545776,
0.8867836594581604,
-0.18605178594589233,
-0.028891250491142273,
-0.4069218933582306,
-0.7733151912689209,
0.08683690428733826,
0.1925049126148224,
-0.5762577056884766,
0.875278651714325,
0.2717118263244629,
-0.45121562480926514,
0.4240662753582001,
-0.5087021589279175,
-0.32957157492637634,
0.282087504863739,
-0.47246527671813965,
-0.2516726851463318,
0.3311097323894501,
-0.13426147401332855,
0.3652768135070801,
-0.7270438075065613,
0.252934068441391,
-0.6001514792442322,
-0.30001774430274963,
0.26132696866989136,
-0.3298519253730774,
0.32210928201675415,
0.4548390507698059,
-0.5707215070724487,
0.39447155594825745,
-0.9095959067344666,
0.3239537477493286,
0.041576627641916275,
-0.12482398748397827,
-0.47800591588020325,
0.20831702649593353,
0.17194464802742004,
0.14500854909420013,
0.06852921843528748,
-0.5571619272232056,
0.028546655550599098,
-0.29187676310539246,
0.3175564110279083,
0.656124472618103,
-0.3805229961872101,
0.23891863226890564,
-0.291899710893631,
0.3547748029232025,
-0.4037259817123413,
0.18146272003650665,
0.09688658267259598,
-0.08272910863161087,
-0.55367112159729,
-0.2731241285800934,
0.5821556448936462,
0.17084474861621857,
-0.41587695479393005,
0.8424702286720276,
-0.38071122765541077,
-0.873133659362793,
-0.48816829919815063,
0.43732932209968567,
0.765932559967041,
0.09319470822811127,
0.309150367975235,
-0.3578512370586395,
-0.3325952887535095,
-1.2745386362075806,
-0.08973977714776993,
-0.03085804544389248,
-0.18248853087425232,
0.1916225552558899,
0.3553773760795593,
-0.24130898714065552,
0.852338969707489,
-0.33818838000297546,
-0.07222842425107956,
-0.5214245915412903,
0.1756233274936676,
0.0929030328989029,
0.45645833015441895,
0.5341423153877258,
-0.6455267667770386,
-0.18339376151561737,
0.11458589136600494,
-0.528627336025238,
-0.3270431160926819,
0.20082129538059235,
-0.12503841519355774,
-0.09504609555006027,
0.7592875361442566,
-0.5180962681770325,
-0.054331857711076736,
0.6672770977020264,
-0.38449710607528687,
0.4789590835571289,
-0.3662692606449127,
0.08869772404432297,
-0.7469680309295654,
0.3281741738319397,
0.1830560714006424,
-0.12730222940444946,
-0.4684291183948517,
0.4809807538986206,
0.3277093470096588,
-0.056891199201345444,
-0.24929189682006836,
0.605907142162323,
-0.14523179829120636,
-0.27692076563835144,
-0.23245519399642944,
0.14476002752780914,
-0.0332878939807415,
-0.0002206571662100032,
-0.19430603086948395,
0.7270642518997192,
0.37522459030151367,
-0.5140913724899292,
0.1940140724182129,
-0.030528325587511063,
-0.699760913848877,
0.3972126543521881,
-0.6861633658409119,
-0.004687929060310125,
0.04053899645805359,
0.11392530798912048,
-0.8047109842300415,
-0.06275846809148788,
-0.16927596926689148,
0.15292209386825562,
0.27532514929771423,
-0.05472665652632713,
-0.5589658617973328,
-0.5487768650054932,
-0.4804815649986267,
0.15482939779758453,
0.7985566854476929,
-0.4759047031402588,
0.39779937267303467,
0.37668144702911377,
-0.1341308355331421,
-0.2294962853193283,
-0.45420777797698975,
0.021116359159350395,
-0.26375076174736023,
-0.5545172095298767,
0.46148011088371277,
-0.10046491771936417,
-0.5504205226898193,
-0.11739936470985413,
-0.17904983460903168,
0.10441754758358002,
0.3392598330974579,
0.21324703097343445,
0.01624799519777298,
-0.3635254204273224,
0.1727520078420639,
-0.24890172481536865,
-0.14407190680503845,
-0.04222791641950607,
-0.016129596158862114,
0.9881412982940674,
-0.4463111460208893,
-0.5952739715576172,
-0.0792938768863678,
0.008284000679850578,
0.7045773863792419,
-0.5930563807487488,
0.5071441531181335,
0.626979649066925,
-0.30914798378944397,
-0.33856672048568726,
-0.7823676466941833,
0.048228684812784195,
-0.4603697657585144,
0.3421752154827118,
-0.5092061758041382,
-0.6066235303878784,
0.42277514934539795,
-0.04056276008486748,
0.17327016592025757,
0.5456616282463074,
0.6477091312408447,
0.4014759361743927,
0.8508189916610718,
0.5099174380302429,
-0.11203180998563766,
0.36707478761672974,
-0.07314037531614304,
0.03791884705424309,
-0.850895345211029,
0.03423497453331947,
-0.7564598321914673,
-0.2214391529560089,
-0.5618221759796143,
-0.5329993963241577,
-0.04853624850511551,
0.23268967866897583,
-0.19108207523822784,
0.29192841053009033,
-0.2587662637233734,
0.5832018852233887,
0.6260817646980286,
-0.04618913680315018,
0.1948428899049759,
-0.237347811460495,
-0.18340447545051575,
0.10547444224357605,
-0.27547919750213623,
-0.8257182240486145,
1.2760848999023438,
0.6626604199409485,
0.7239473462104797,
0.06144529953598976,
0.7685242891311646,
0.285895973443985,
0.3560960590839386,
-0.6095681190490723,
0.7956353425979614,
-0.3760981559753418,
-0.5386425256729126,
-0.32369178533554077,
-0.6565104722976685,
-0.9161289930343628,
0.4544960558414459,
0.041277430951595306,
-0.9165108799934387,
-0.02085261046886444,
-0.09885411709547043,
-0.5031531453132629,
0.1359906941652298,
-0.7613361477851868,
1.2094404697418213,
-0.28684499859809875,
-0.5713825821876526,
-0.5153926610946655,
-0.2836981415748596,
0.3700428903102875,
-0.2917732894420624,
0.35285684466362,
-0.4546894431114197,
0.2331387847661972,
0.5568824410438538,
-0.4630338251590729,
0.5737017393112183,
-0.19067035615444183,
-0.13179229199886322,
0.16685523092746735,
0.10254526883363724,
0.06827022135257721,
-0.2902013063430786,
-0.2592613995075226,
-0.12814365327358246,
0.03285475820302963,
-0.3113495409488678,
-0.26778507232666016,
0.9936420917510986,
-0.6655445694923401,
-0.5292083621025085,
-0.14906048774719238,
-0.48381659388542175,
-0.574227511882782,
0.2585223913192749,
-0.1747596561908722,
0.559283435344696,
-0.6643950939178467,
0.5108503103256226,
0.5924379229545593,
-0.39849430322647095,
0.44681477546691895,
0.5253015756607056,
-0.6643220782279968,
0.04843393340706825,
0.956669270992279,
-0.07693419605493546,
0.4525867998600006,
0.056698527187108994,
0.4806123375892639,
-0.1533443182706833,
-0.7574094533920288,
-0.46317315101623535,
-0.04950881004333496,
-0.5630823373794556,
0.0796007364988327,
-0.42930006980895996,
-0.27323102951049805,
-0.19420112669467926,
0.1383139044046402,
-0.5818068385124207,
-0.20018768310546875,
0.43275460600852966,
0.0302471611648798,
0.03825538232922554,
0.6049465537071228,
0.04293389990925789,
0.1262224018573761,
-0.8655208349227905,
0.37806570529937744,
0.5250899195671082,
0.7394514679908752,
-0.1570076048374176,
-0.4574739336967468,
0.02818446420133114,
-0.02622867003083229,
-0.4221152663230896,
-0.3458673059940338,
-0.008618884719908237,
0.1471475511789322,
0.8309440612792969,
0.36741113662719727,
-0.034783411771059036,
0.38576123118400574,
-0.7023553848266602,
0.5362477898597717,
0.08316642791032791,
-0.996123194694519,
0.32165616750717163,
-0.40358787775039673,
0.36762842535972595,
0.9249076843261719,
0.059830453246831894,
-0.46699535846710205,
-0.3871515095233917,
-0.6157325506210327,
-0.7579677104949951,
0.5806506872177124,
0.23434168100357056,
0.19007711112499237,
0.044849857687950134,
-0.06840122491121292,
0.18124143779277802,
0.19672006368637085,
-0.4184914231300354,
0.08948468416929245,
0.09774818271398544,
-0.26343393325805664,
-0.2812191843986511,
-0.24092744290828705,
-0.2981905937194824,
-0.07597817480564117,
0.4435301721096039,
-0.003487530630081892,
-0.08847900480031967,
-0.05764532834291458,
-0.10977820307016373,
-0.1825941503047943,
0.7166473865509033,
0.5035276412963867,
1.030490756034851,
-0.5093472599983215,
0.13563786447048187,
0.04169946536421776,
-0.2378651648759842,
-0.06837663799524307,
0.6917445659637451,
0.009343858808279037,
-0.04104186221957207,
0.3425118625164032,
0.8001848459243774,
0.3457951843738556,
-0.9687907099723816,
0.5214663147926331,
-0.11120117455720901,
-0.10618868470191956,
-0.06097497418522835,
0.2452518194913864,
0.11952538043260574,
0.26915934681892395,
0.35961586236953735,
-0.3203716278076172,
0.1617356836795807,
-0.7109537720680237,
0.2543247938156128,
0.34693992137908936,
-0.4103339910507202,
-0.10291828960180283,
0.40790799260139465,
0.27975934743881226,
-0.2426021695137024,
0.2026291936635971,
-0.3664126694202423,
-0.361178994178772,
0.6007496118545532,
0.42649078369140625,
1.0334473848342896,
-0.37649938464164734,
0.2097521424293518,
0.16561740636825562,
0.2912299335002899,
-0.3291126787662506,
0.22137516736984253,
0.17691312730312347,
-0.5788707137107849,
-0.3474558889865875,
-0.9583380222320557,
-0.3900231420993805,
0.5397664904594421,
-0.552082896232605,
0.23310677707195282,
-0.5161194801330566,
-0.11003722250461578,
0.4329831004142761,
-0.10980798304080963,
-0.7148175835609436,
-0.010803986340761185,
0.5967724919319153,
1.0918546915054321,
-0.7830955386161804,
0.6932660341262817,
0.5246808528900146,
-0.3579421937465668,
-0.48857924342155457,
0.06614670902490616,
-0.10310009121894836,
-0.6916057467460632,
0.5927405953407288,
0.3683641254901886,
0.10981111973524094,
-0.2935876250267029,
-0.15507762134075165,
-0.562114417552948,
0.7452948093414307,
0.22454798221588135,
-1.017128348350525,
0.2542266845703125,
0.19618166983127594,
0.674701988697052,
-0.20333030819892883,
0.17753811180591583,
1.0011892318725586,
0.6503594517707825,
-0.19170071184635162,
-1.251244306564331,
0.0666179433465004,
-0.17656758427619934,
0.11947377771139145,
0.34874865412712097,
-0.5923410058021545,
0.7082128524780273,
0.146204873919487,
-0.02401595376431942,
0.27094778418540955,
0.31504344940185547,
0.44079485535621643,
0.1907547414302826,
0.6876517534255981,
0.5951420068740845,
0.5473857522010803,
-0.26051047444343567,
1.4985935688018799,
-0.4918406009674072,
0.36491134762763977,
0.9733889698982239,
-0.5600531101226807,
0.9165199995040894,
0.29409170150756836,
-0.382782518863678,
0.13917532563209534,
0.33967798948287964,
-0.08819060027599335,
0.5437020659446716,
0.6808317303657532,
-0.2294606864452362,
-0.38277214765548706,
-0.19420014321804047,
-0.4652913510799408,
0.41197746992111206,
0.2980024814605713,
-0.4666456878185272,
-0.4930579364299774,
-0.06564663350582123,
-0.026821952313184738,
0.30608823895454407,
-0.4142100214958191,
0.4858945906162262,
0.059154726564884186,
-0.670414924621582,
0.6241746544837952,
0.17407645285129547,
0.3180173933506012,
-0.7801291346549988,
0.09653222560882568,
-0.16216079890727997,
0.6188787221908569,
-0.0013614529743790627,
-0.7785294055938721,
-0.10273182392120361,
0.06752242147922516,
0.06197521090507507,
-0.15328067541122437,
0.6808170080184937,
-0.3183472156524658,
-0.5973520874977112,
0.35235533118247986,
0.5505912899971008,
-0.1297467052936554,
-0.0005381059017963707,
-0.5250262022018433,
0.5680500268936157,
-0.16202948987483978,
-0.40997421741485596,
0.4106454849243164,
0.34495216608047485,
-0.09441278129816055,
0.6764574646949768,
0.4889318346977234,
0.03246090188622475,
-0.12601077556610107,
0.5362629294395447,
0.8443759083747864,
-0.6940670609474182,
-0.1493004560470581,
-1.0527284145355225,
0.1958816647529602,
-0.2612794041633606,
-0.5138159394264221,
0.8070678114891052,
0.7407892346382141,
0.671342134475708,
0.09483973681926727,
0.8801560401916504,
-0.19737784564495087,
0.5067710876464844,
-0.46756958961486816,
0.6122791767120361,
-0.35319381952285767,
0.1782795488834381,
-0.44530048966407776,
-1.2470284700393677,
-0.09287412464618683,
0.5519298315048218,
-0.6949799060821533,
0.173810213804245,
0.5369489192962646,
0.5741555690765381,
-0.32896730303764343,
0.1535751223564148,
0.37782761454582214,
0.20701076090335846,
0.4430065453052521,
0.40184012055397034,
1.0572972297668457,
-0.1323697715997696,
0.35722485184669495,
-0.3327256739139557,
-0.34230437874794006,
-0.34148862957954407,
-0.8515097498893738,
-0.9547610282897949,
-0.3652392327785492,
-0.20406009256839752,
-0.2702886760234833,
0.09342093020677567,
1.0532702207565308,
0.6683905720710754,
-0.7596943378448486,
-0.41711124777793884,
-0.11406352370977402,
-0.1249365359544754,
-0.18531139194965363,
-0.1970204859972,
0.3672225773334503,
-0.7093501091003418,
-0.7575399279594421,
0.5963072180747986,
0.08347991853952408,
-0.1604146659374237,
-0.5658801198005676,
-0.0002452853077556938,
0.023974083364009857,
-0.056679610162973404,
0.5863687992095947,
0.27691635489463806,
-0.5197858214378357,
-0.4376467764377594,
-0.3819233775138855,
-0.36363616585731506,
-0.2653766870498657,
0.7246947288513184,
-0.6021230220794678,
0.4574446976184845,
0.38462504744529724,
0.9072235226631165,
0.39023351669311523,
-0.07285576313734055,
0.8916596174240112,
-0.47400128841400146,
0.13728119432926178,
0.11446379870176315,
0.5503975749015808,
0.3544204533100128,
0.4051614999771118,
0.6461945176124573,
-0.23391667008399963,
-0.5031753182411194,
-1.063797116279602,
0.052842848002910614,
-0.7626441121101379,
-0.39968952536582947,
1.4018046855926514,
-0.08500006794929504,
-0.14190159738063812,
0.1689869463443756,
-0.07233589887619019,
-0.13532370328903198,
-0.12054388225078583,
0.8408380746841431,
0.7048505544662476,
0.3789348602294922,
0.1460660696029663,
-0.934226930141449,
0.4060555398464203,
0.5941271781921387,
-0.8876944184303284,
0.44011175632476807,
0.5589747428894043,
0.2582727372646332,
0.3023642599582672,
0.1972268968820572,
-0.24007418751716614,
0.22610165178775787,
-0.10055577754974365,
0.2601903975009918,
0.06231594458222389,
-0.13429734110832214,
-0.35886669158935547,
0.2063034623861313,
0.4336586892604828,
-0.17277388274669647
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.05760v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.05760v1
|
Arabic Diacritics in the Wild: Exploiting Opportunities for Improved Diacritization
| 2024-06-09T12:29:55 | 2024-06-09T12:29:55 |
Salman Elgamal, Ossama Obeid, Tameem Kabbani, Go Inoue, Nizar Habash
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The widespread absence of diacritical marks in Arabic text poses a
significant challenge for Arabic natural language processing (NLP). This paper
explores instances of naturally occurring diacritics, referred to as
"diacritics in the wild," to unveil patterns and latent information across six
diverse genres: news articles, novels, children's books, poetry, political
documents, and ChatGPT outputs. We present a new annotated dataset that maps
real-world partially diacritized words to their maximal full diacritization in
context. Additionally, we propose extensions to the analyze-and-disambiguate
approach in Arabic NLP to leverage these diacritics, resulting in notable
improvements. Our contributions encompass a thorough analysis, valuable
datasets, and an extended diacritization algorithm. We release our code and
datasets as open source.
|
[
-0.41280242800712585,
-0.6970695853233337,
0.09094622731208801,
0.22673138976097107,
-0.5090901255607605,
0.4814613461494446,
-0.28086400032043457,
-0.7004138231277466,
0.12729045748710632,
0.45333147048950195,
-0.35719284415245056,
-0.9301731586456299,
-0.77410489320755,
0.5717414617538452,
-0.4398563504219055,
1.2409197092056274,
-0.12497816979885101,
-0.3858920931816101,
0.5637703537940979,
-0.28722530603408813,
-0.2203965038061142,
-0.8145387172698975,
-0.21152739226818085,
0.36895227432250977,
0.39479756355285645,
0.44150349497795105,
1.1517589092254639,
0.521245002746582,
0.620472252368927,
0.16122369468212128,
-0.13190852105617523,
0.47414249181747437,
-0.12391197681427002,
0.35828667879104614,
0.2871672213077545,
0.08809365332126617,
-0.07991782575845718,
-0.033554479479789734,
0.6087962985038757,
0.8893705010414124,
0.0008742014761082828,
-0.14239005744457245,
-0.14561526477336884,
0.8036316633224487,
-0.8529617190361023,
0.027743397280573845,
-0.4187859296798706,
0.24937617778778076,
-0.7004048228263855,
0.13658055663108826,
-0.030109943822026253,
-0.6244224905967712,
0.0019892314448952675,
-0.29188594222068787,
0.09152702242136002,
-0.13255950808525085,
0.8474055528640747,
0.28663548827171326,
-0.6171488165855408,
-0.6629289388656616,
-1.1114990711212158,
0.6661572456359863,
-0.5715646147727966,
0.21942830085754395,
0.5604773759841919,
0.2122000753879547,
-0.08076304942369461,
-0.8301656246185303,
-0.3759700655937195,
-0.06554786115884781,
-0.033693768084049225,
0.1476639062166214,
-0.30334195494651794,
0.04857989773154259,
-0.07142762094736099,
0.5013348460197449,
-0.3941848874092102,
0.1137920394539833,
0.0757029727101326,
-0.317204087972641,
0.6784953474998474,
0.012312310747802258,
0.39928877353668213,
0.30521950125694275,
0.1221308782696724,
-0.032519374042749405,
-0.7128645181655884,
-0.004861520603299141,
0.3578096926212311,
0.20636874437332153,
-0.24688021838665009,
0.7001197934150696,
-0.22306589782238007,
1.0023744106292725,
-0.629038393497467,
0.15529227256774902,
0.1465667486190796,
-0.6166107654571533,
-0.10144834220409393,
0.01253510545939207,
0.38743823766708374,
0.11277522146701813,
0.4317796230316162,
-0.28267326951026917,
-0.07400581985712051,
0.05144538730382919,
-0.12151506543159485,
-0.7417742609977722,
-0.5047934055328369,
0.15749774873256683,
-0.24176661670207977,
-0.1489211618900299,
0.007525377441197634,
-0.7611327171325684,
-0.5899163484573364,
0.0640784278512001,
-0.11152706295251846,
-0.2714480459690094,
-0.09075634926557541,
0.31593406200408936,
-0.30759820342063904,
0.004451545886695385,
0.26740673184394836,
-0.8261504173278809,
0.23944993317127228,
0.21928241848945618,
0.9224300980567932,
-0.0136069655418396,
0.08040931075811386,
0.01288982667028904,
0.09850803762674332,
-0.5986040830612183,
0.8773160576820374,
-1.0178015232086182,
-0.3827909827232361,
0.3887377977371216,
-0.4871785044670105,
0.008900240063667297,
-0.6736696362495422,
1.1343681812286377,
-0.7439300417900085,
-0.12986016273498535,
0.0011641733581200242,
-0.07166805863380432,
-0.3302694857120514,
0.05039118602871895,
-0.8883255124092102,
1.061777949333191,
-0.11484838277101517,
-0.7065927386283875,
0.4982088804244995,
-0.7672017216682434,
-0.6628463864326477,
0.17389017343521118,
0.00039318963536061347,
-0.5353822112083435,
0.08277203142642975,
0.3895455300807953,
0.16069038212299347,
0.0017312437994405627,
-0.1417178362607956,
0.09794986248016357,
-0.34367692470550537,
0.36752352118492126,
-0.39242565631866455,
0.5214255452156067,
0.14162041246891022,
-0.22113072872161865,
-0.27417489886283875,
-0.8289559483528137,
0.0682980865240097,
0.049072351306676865,
-0.47348782420158386,
-0.6311164498329163,
0.09524562954902649,
0.4126720130443573,
0.08408091217279434,
0.2775149941444397,
-0.3327387571334839,
0.39279672503471375,
-0.4565739035606384,
0.3096187710762024,
0.3705287277698517,
0.381085604429245,
0.28130123019218445,
-0.22438745200634003,
0.4779312014579773,
0.16165180504322052,
0.023847591131925583,
0.172936350107193,
-0.6887363195419312,
-0.8139764666557312,
-0.6650093197822571,
0.4803523123264313,
0.309368759393692,
-0.4918806552886963,
0.36712685227394104,
-0.08042603731155396,
-0.44471538066864014,
-0.5861791968345642,
-0.026944506913423538,
0.06808826327323914,
-0.08864591270685196,
0.43573668599128723,
-0.46867623925209045,
-0.814598023891449,
-0.9452128410339355,
-0.4279407560825348,
0.064076267182827,
0.23077769577503204,
0.09657664597034454,
0.4901559054851532,
-0.27006593346595764,
1.0184392929077148,
-0.3529796600341797,
-0.5662274956703186,
-0.09486575424671173,
0.5295347571372986,
0.26589205861091614,
0.023881463333964348,
0.44769448041915894,
-1.1565823554992676,
-0.7888493537902832,
0.06250151246786118,
-0.36025470495224,
-0.39051932096481323,
-0.07262827455997467,
-0.06164717674255371,
0.12456061691045761,
0.3215833604335785,
-0.23280231654644012,
0.7808782458305359,
0.39736077189445496,
-0.33855873346328735,
0.6265924572944641,
0.09736515581607819,
0.11769966036081314,
-0.37648361921310425,
0.22302013635635376,
-0.35495680570602417,
-0.01181964110583067,
-0.8523418307304382,
-0.15100011229515076,
-0.2629871666431427,
0.2796369791030884,
-0.09174179285764694,
0.2460036426782608,
-0.6599226593971252,
0.22045737504959106,
-0.3872678875923157,
-0.053321581333875656,
-0.18846268951892853,
0.18298965692520142,
0.2964269518852234,
0.7949838042259216,
0.3360902667045593,
-0.39372092485427856,
0.0844971239566803,
0.3819866478443146,
-0.4420716166496277,
-0.17001450061798096,
-0.261495441198349,
0.21317225694656372,
-0.30049100518226624,
0.26169008016586304,
-0.730182945728302,
-0.09805025905370712,
0.2809560000896454,
-0.06379564851522446,
0.06616027653217316,
-0.5258737206459045,
-0.6324507594108582,
-0.009389538317918777,
-0.43870872259140015,
0.3088652193546295,
0.3803502023220062,
0.07836797833442688,
-0.11764757335186005,
0.518913209438324,
-0.2371663600206375,
-0.6511580348014832,
-0.4318201541900635,
0.6240943670272827,
-0.1575905680656433,
-0.15366537868976593,
0.5106586217880249,
-0.0866398885846138,
-0.5031240582466125,
-0.11064349114894867,
-0.10213173925876617,
-0.44863349199295044,
0.36200714111328125,
0.22959542274475098,
-0.07359429448843002,
-0.08557641506195068,
-0.2039279192686081,
0.2872927784919739,
0.24486006796360016,
-0.15134340524673462,
-0.09392977505922318,
0.5822445154190063,
0.16108058393001556,
-0.030453195795416832,
-0.3030078113079071,
0.6429294347763062,
0.5743200778961182,
-0.48407089710235596,
0.7841876745223999,
0.3878941535949707,
-0.5834482312202454,
-0.19256936013698578,
-0.022108804434537888,
-0.07263991981744766,
-0.3928086757659912,
0.46325376629829407,
-0.2793264389038086,
-0.4554026126861572,
0.38761427998542786,
-0.19102045893669128,
0.3913804888725281,
0.3167223036289215,
0.7398009896278381,
0.05658740550279617,
0.9352229833602905,
0.788433313369751,
-0.17073887586593628,
0.21278411149978638,
-0.13832929730415344,
0.5010437965393066,
-0.5163853764533997,
-0.20581911504268646,
-0.7824187874794006,
-0.3122110366821289,
-0.627741813659668,
-0.38424167037010193,
0.41056883335113525,
0.15080927312374115,
-0.015523173846304417,
0.22586354613304138,
-0.4104636013507843,
0.6251642107963562,
0.37252485752105713,
-0.22341109812259674,
0.4747108817100525,
0.3155529499053955,
-0.2749483287334442,
-0.47137361764907837,
-0.4896954894065857,
-0.9774202704429626,
0.8265700340270996,
-0.013283352367579937,
0.25422781705856323,
0.4731080234050751,
0.6639965176582336,
0.8267481327056885,
0.4873821437358856,
-0.5754953026771545,
0.11420979350805283,
-0.01771635003387928,
-0.5935514569282532,
-0.17708411812782288,
0.10476445406675339,
-1.1363813877105713,
0.18146565556526184,
-0.21889251470565796,
-0.6290332078933716,
0.17759324610233307,
-0.40263915061950684,
-0.5405787229537964,
0.02609909139573574,
-0.38505926728248596,
0.5492609739303589,
0.14900417625904083,
-0.2068014144897461,
0.15364381670951843,
-0.7409330010414124,
0.1534021943807602,
-0.24056248366832733,
0.6532539129257202,
-0.11406809091567993,
-0.2660098373889923,
0.793177604675293,
-0.2600281238555908,
0.8757675886154175,
0.06924977153539658,
-0.3760215640068054,
0.5364319086074829,
0.30107802152633667,
0.3925568759441376,
0.07451651990413666,
-0.02385096065700054,
0.4605647027492523,
-0.1589665561914444,
-0.3300561010837555,
-0.23531532287597656,
0.46760064363479614,
-0.763314425945282,
-0.24657298624515533,
-0.8507563471794128,
-0.3656550347805023,
-0.15628781914710999,
0.14971785247325897,
0.012187271378934383,
0.2833535671234131,
-0.36828339099884033,
-0.3828609585762024,
0.24891982972621918,
0.05320011079311371,
0.7999869585037231,
0.44820061326026917,
0.020529864355921745,
-0.28664565086364746,
0.5772086977958679,
0.17837899923324585,
-0.2718360424041748,
0.378522127866745,
-0.18342214822769165,
-0.2470984011888504,
-1.0219000577926636,
-0.7235915064811707,
-0.041123129427433014,
-0.661702036857605,
-0.2488720417022705,
-0.6829692125320435,
-0.4887069761753082,
-0.21178078651428223,
-0.2336703985929489,
0.04934431612491608,
-0.45809054374694824,
-0.22537145018577576,
0.049511123448610306,
0.4065248370170593,
0.6511796116828918,
-0.2898862361907959,
0.2958698272705078,
-0.8613454699516296,
0.23706206679344177,
-0.06363314390182495,
-0.21578077971935272,
-0.19579826295375824,
-0.5627691149711609,
-0.45887914299964905,
0.2783106863498688,
-0.3719474971294403,
-1.0345866680145264,
0.6042335629463196,
0.6014824509620667,
0.026151437312364578,
0.5415796041488647,
0.31056463718414307,
0.5634877681732178,
-0.7655133008956909,
0.7700195908546448,
-0.23169371485710144,
-0.5656152963638306,
0.27812764048576355,
-0.20729921758174896,
0.29651743173599243,
0.6136534214019775,
0.5689039826393127,
-0.8888519406318665,
-0.6482673287391663,
-0.04822739586234093,
-1.10769784450531,
0.36093127727508545,
0.8615723252296448,
0.1296931356191635,
-0.08849742263555527,
0.13730958104133606,
0.5020196437835693,
0.20162728428840637,
-0.4480137526988983,
-0.4673575162887573,
-0.1398451328277588,
-0.29505598545074463,
0.06651102006435394,
-0.24149090051651,
-0.21575818955898285,
-0.12275655567646027,
0.4367307722568512,
0.15464502573013306,
0.1262267380952835,
0.31011682748794556,
-0.38039132952690125,
0.14546222984790802,
0.35033971071243286,
0.6803601384162903,
0.46588507294654846,
-0.24116191267967224,
0.44015681743621826,
-0.19118931889533997,
-1.188398003578186,
0.12204468250274658,
0.29800945520401,
-0.32404327392578125,
0.2679815888404846,
0.445243239402771,
0.231853187084198,
-0.11069352179765701,
-0.6344026923179626,
0.09383149445056915,
-0.13564060628414154,
0.23047219216823578,
-0.6394363045692444,
-0.31117749214172363,
-0.2690636217594147,
-0.06521493941545486,
0.777380108833313,
0.07818092405796051,
0.3590089678764343,
-0.48569634556770325,
0.20160239934921265,
0.4379998445510864,
-0.20224231481552124,
-0.4910810887813568,
0.39774569869041443,
0.2665398418903351,
-0.27436888217926025,
0.6099421381950378,
-0.06304015219211578,
-0.697026789188385,
0.5632784366607666,
0.36932915449142456,
0.6282640099525452,
0.15190772712230682,
0.42488083243370056,
0.03372342139482498,
0.5943735241889954,
0.5154693722724915,
0.43312209844589233,
-0.43910279870033264,
-0.7469674944877625,
-0.3539991080760956,
-0.7767782211303711,
-0.41220998764038086,
0.09485051780939102,
-0.17652150988578796,
0.2458518147468567,
-0.5611721277236938,
-0.2375165969133377,
0.22821854054927826,
0.18612295389175415,
-0.5443302392959595,
0.329878568649292,
0.4938928484916687,
0.5631693005561829,
-0.8070970177650452,
0.6779438853263855,
0.8671082258224487,
-0.32318824529647827,
0.024065908044576645,
0.18269199132919312,
-0.12094352394342422,
-0.7415028214454651,
0.48255211114883423,
0.2730538249015808,
-0.07411441951990128,
0.30872422456741333,
-0.5492721796035767,
-0.8326160907745361,
0.4593440294265747,
-0.08683167397975922,
-0.4580238461494446,
0.1162327229976654,
0.6569269895553589,
0.5108482241630554,
-0.011524918489158154,
0.4942755103111267,
0.7832010984420776,
0.672344982624054,
-0.3351791203022003,
-0.5625195503234863,
-0.09060189872980118,
-0.22329577803611755,
-0.4205015301704407,
0.4609297215938568,
-0.40445956587791443,
0.35571199655532837,
-0.26354140043258667,
-0.6123416423797607,
0.20355181396007538,
0.5273957252502441,
-0.14182470738887787,
0.25842610001564026,
-0.0178784541785717,
0.4163191318511963,
0.5163978338241577,
-0.07120317220687866,
0.5571665167808533,
-0.2453271597623825,
0.04578113183379173,
0.6893088221549988,
-0.5262638330459595,
0.39100149273872375,
0.5256358981132507,
-0.28165367245674133,
0.8109110593795776,
0.7945849299430847,
0.21596966683864594,
0.8518068790435791,
0.44209662079811096,
-0.8569684624671936,
-0.1915764957666397,
-0.5450307726860046,
-0.2101268619298935,
0.6410919427871704,
0.3702285885810852,
-0.16152358055114746,
-0.4196459949016571,
-0.14567790925502777,
0.3094980716705322,
0.17202246189117432,
-0.011617087759077549,
0.5729178786277771,
0.07805276662111282,
-0.14923590421676636,
0.8063267469406128,
0.5485168695449829,
0.39519622921943665,
-0.6010728478431702,
-0.40426895022392273,
-0.4970932900905609,
-0.16642002761363983,
-0.19558139145374298,
-0.3958045244216919,
0.4957015812397003,
0.2639060914516449,
-0.08077018707990646,
-0.137348011136055,
0.5311046242713928,
-0.15302406251430511,
-0.3866490125656128,
-0.17277410626411438,
0.4709770083427429,
0.35240715742111206,
-0.2238578051328659,
-0.3465224504470825,
0.05696302652359009,
-0.09190209954977036,
-0.18704047799110413,
0.13568633794784546,
0.4646170139312744,
-0.3989412188529968,
0.29855450987815857,
0.6643982529640198,
0.1942652463912964,
0.18948638439178467,
0.03729885071516037,
0.7841194272041321,
-0.6519291400909424,
-0.1773405224084854,
-1.1518017053604126,
0.3310316503047943,
-0.23058144748210907,
-0.4816246032714844,
0.8798065781593323,
0.7612185478210449,
0.5524811148643494,
0.0043258098885416985,
1.0119872093200684,
-0.19126129150390625,
0.09254756569862366,
-0.3941822946071625,
1.031632423400879,
-0.09343589842319489,
-0.0006019045249558985,
-0.062235716730356216,
-0.8070076704025269,
-0.9393603205680847,
0.49471816420555115,
0.002956268610432744,
-0.13679465651512146,
0.6728267073631287,
0.49641817808151245,
0.05672808736562729,
0.13807383179664612,
0.36771881580352783,
0.2621704936027527,
0.031653620302677155,
0.5028426647186279,
0.8043679594993591,
-0.33170104026794434,
0.2250598967075348,
-0.3657603859901428,
-0.4736652672290802,
-0.14354901015758514,
-0.7242147326469421,
-0.925397515296936,
-0.7639048099517822,
-0.563101053237915,
-0.1822306364774704,
0.3064311444759369,
0.6376938819885254,
0.37328481674194336,
-0.7941979765892029,
-0.084215447306633,
-0.21127450466156006,
0.21202830970287323,
-0.38809236884117126,
-0.15056179463863373,
0.5559887886047363,
0.018278220668435097,
-0.7969226241111755,
0.44353482127189636,
0.23972643911838531,
0.4206371307373047,
0.10883975774049759,
0.2577416002750397,
-0.3139517307281494,
0.30303648114204407,
0.4891035854816437,
0.39952266216278076,
-0.1381101757287979,
-0.010734726674854755,
-0.027088914066553116,
0.030354566872119904,
0.014642398804426193,
0.7883532047271729,
-0.7759894728660583,
0.24593999981880188,
-0.10339000821113586,
0.3450182378292084,
0.31989362835884094,
-0.12186259776353836,
0.1993134468793869,
-0.659440815448761,
0.4196270704269409,
0.7586662173271179,
-0.02408500574529171,
0.4310958981513977,
-0.047695234417915344,
0.42221301794052124,
0.3148764669895172,
-0.2875010669231415,
-0.8769909739494324,
0.5663220286369324,
-0.45719584822654724,
0.0036361878737807274,
1.151740550994873,
-0.11882907152175903,
0.13648861646652222,
-0.695124089717865,
-0.3621092438697815,
0.32090523838996887,
-0.30090853571891785,
1.2002432346343994,
0.7237769961357117,
0.1709500253200531,
0.1270497590303421,
-0.5914943814277649,
0.9236786961555481,
0.42889532446861267,
-0.6176501512527466,
0.19050085544586182,
0.5419048070907593,
-0.16386811435222626,
-0.053673528134822845,
0.476582407951355,
-0.13410980999469757,
-0.03222924470901489,
-0.16168399155139923,
0.08132249861955643,
0.23721159994602203,
-0.47895538806915283,
-0.3732531666755676,
0.11324402689933777,
0.2844390571117401,
-0.2632162868976593
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.05756v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.05756v1
|
EmbSpatial-Bench: Benchmarking Spatial Understanding for Embodied Tasks with Large Vision-Language Models
| 2024-06-09T12:23:14 | 2024-06-09T12:23:14 |
Mengfei Du, Binhao Wu, Zejun Li, Xuanjing Huang, Zhongyu Wei
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.MM
|
The recent rapid development of Large Vision-Language Models (LVLMs) has
indicated their potential for embodied tasks.However, the critical skill of
spatial understanding in embodied environments has not been thoroughly
evaluated, leaving the gap between current LVLMs and qualified embodied
intelligence unknown. Therefore, we construct EmbSpatial-Bench, a benchmark for
evaluating embodied spatial understanding of LVLMs.The benchmark is
automatically derived from embodied scenes and covers 6 spatial relationships
from an egocentric perspective.Experiments expose the insufficient capacity of
current LVLMs (even GPT-4V). We further present EmbSpatial-SFT, an
instruction-tuning dataset designed to improve LVLMs' embodied spatial
understanding.
|
[
-0.3904062807559967,
-0.72260582447052,
0.8147937059402466,
0.24834661185741425,
-0.037862442433834076,
-0.32707205414772034,
-0.15671122074127197,
-0.5386698842048645,
-0.0011501620756462216,
0.27304109930992126,
-0.6199162006378174,
-0.405355304479599,
-0.4673796594142914,
0.02173517271876335,
-0.28364333510398865,
0.30738121271133423,
-0.2689860761165619,
0.22894135117530823,
-0.4210093319416046,
-0.4241907000541687,
-0.5149543881416321,
-0.24095092713832855,
-0.0963289737701416,
-0.23918989300727844,
0.4477667212486267,
0.12335021048784256,
0.38406839966773987,
0.5453273057937622,
0.37241020798683167,
0.32899919152259827,
0.09302587807178497,
0.09833890199661255,
-0.3493462800979614,
0.2544668912887573,
-0.4351576566696167,
-0.3632245361804962,
-0.19454854726791382,
-0.33838433027267456,
0.766723096370697,
0.7607580423355103,
-0.4571269154548645,
0.20016855001449585,
-0.16799688339233398,
0.6669477224349976,
-0.9344380497932434,
0.310392826795578,
-0.3377406895160675,
0.4692731499671936,
0.05063877999782562,
-0.04696512222290039,
-0.45177969336509705,
-0.216849222779274,
-0.09232142567634583,
-0.7965947389602661,
0.24913407862186432,
0.34605732560157776,
0.5602959990501404,
0.682896614074707,
-0.28107529878616333,
0.21786722540855408,
-0.45398059487342834,
0.49731549620628357,
-0.3303525447845459,
0.894644558429718,
0.5090005993843079,
0.548688530921936,
0.22274738550186157,
-0.6527542471885681,
-0.21435412764549255,
-0.27350255846977234,
0.0026993395294994116,
0.3451193869113922,
-0.10969661921262741,
0.13959302008152008,
0.5081943869590759,
-0.10778950154781342,
-0.7167034149169922,
0.125183567404747,
-0.3015577495098114,
0.2578861713409424,
0.5499218702316284,
0.47597622871398926,
0.05276426300406456,
-0.05708115175366402,
-0.5458249449729919,
-0.18645137548446655,
-0.8287470936775208,
-0.2982499897480011,
-0.19690346717834473,
0.0031710825860500336,
0.05003383755683899,
0.7429047226905823,
-0.2656114399433136,
0.9407259821891785,
0.12093324959278107,
0.42961034178733826,
0.21272839605808258,
-0.17419931292533875,
-0.42661771178245544,
-0.21624194085597992,
0.10794620215892792,
0.35008054971694946,
0.023311160504817963,
-0.30980610847473145,
-0.36804935336112976,
-0.2734004259109497,
0.6555644273757935,
-0.8840284943580627,
-0.07397332787513733,
0.11028877645730972,
-0.559944212436676,
0.22668658196926117,
-0.04927266389131546,
-0.4729565978050232,
-0.6617763638496399,
-0.5513119697570801,
0.4913477301597595,
-0.5154282450675964,
-0.10982166230678558,
-0.07159056514501572,
-0.37077492475509644,
0.5279882550239563,
0.5721113085746765,
-1.070546269416809,
0.42399176955223083,
0.697121798992157,
0.7179512977600098,
0.13972443342208862,
-0.6365350484848022,
-0.2272307276725769,
0.5326256155967712,
-0.3349303603172302,
1.0200036764144897,
-0.5779705047607422,
-0.22798143327236176,
-0.012486614286899567,
0.07384989410638809,
-0.07926284521818161,
-0.6753198504447937,
0.2694520056247711,
0.012348323129117489,
-0.4583122134208679,
-0.8096413612365723,
-0.6027454137802124,
-0.24896714091300964,
0.4251590073108673,
-0.491587370634079,
1.103137493133545,
0.21496236324310303,
-0.2958229184150696,
0.6265413165092468,
-0.4431574046611786,
-0.19652186334133148,
0.24289847910404205,
-0.5321218371391296,
-0.07020861655473709,
0.43501487374305725,
0.2544293999671936,
0.648307204246521,
-0.2398962676525116,
0.2045600265264511,
-0.6262078881263733,
-0.5296026468276978,
0.029414089396595955,
-0.1118445098400116,
0.3815551698207855,
0.10469023138284683,
-0.30087682604789734,
-0.036420200020074844,
-0.5663416981697083,
0.03474440053105354,
0.12156162410974503,
0.1691773682832718,
-0.4700838625431061,
0.27242451906204224,
0.061787985265254974,
0.0664650946855545,
0.2946177124977112,
-0.6330806612968445,
0.09600164741277695,
-0.28855323791503906,
0.0703633576631546,
0.8282212615013123,
-0.3605601489543915,
0.5079761743545532,
-0.23117637634277344,
0.3302444815635681,
-0.30678701400756836,
0.08405348658561707,
0.05341661348938942,
-0.294641375541687,
-0.4917236268520355,
-0.28615832328796387,
-0.328602135181427,
0.2906522750854492,
-0.7867951393127441,
0.5221222639083862,
-0.33173897862434387,
-0.6217706799507141,
-0.15588568150997162,
-0.1709318310022354,
0.5169376730918884,
-0.014904272742569447,
0.2944318950176239,
-0.28088250756263733,
-0.29547402262687683,
-1.0301417112350464,
-0.4283377230167389,
-0.013679769821465015,
-0.10144694894552231,
0.8382189273834229,
0.7207685708999634,
-0.02038748748600483,
0.6664080023765564,
-0.47187143564224243,
-0.2914395034313202,
0.17214645445346832,
0.0753607451915741,
-0.194386824965477,
0.39368587732315063,
0.9320299625396729,
-0.6397152543067932,
-0.3096303939819336,
0.34514641761779785,
-0.9313616752624512,
-0.21779879927635193,
0.2716353237628937,
-0.21982736885547638,
0.021140629425644875,
0.5331152081489563,
-0.519769549369812,
0.5929410457611084,
0.5916626453399658,
-0.6608648300170898,
0.30305007100105286,
-0.5275518298149109,
0.3670986294746399,
-0.5563675761222839,
0.2945663034915924,
-0.07819276303052902,
-0.12424759566783905,
-0.3360501527786255,
0.31488093733787537,
0.47978675365448,
-0.27789178490638733,
-0.4202199876308441,
0.8476065993309021,
-0.7453777194023132,
-0.7271476984024048,
-0.07105131447315216,
0.23964622616767883,
-0.13151556253433228,
0.5921295881271362,
0.4224975109100342,
0.38056081533432007,
0.2570017874240875,
-0.291218101978302,
0.45554110407829285,
0.40772300958633423,
-0.42481285333633423,
0.806077778339386,
-0.5988996624946594,
0.03666211664676666,
-0.08356685936450958,
0.3947758376598358,
-0.896565318107605,
-0.25727275013923645,
0.05749562010169029,
-0.17318464815616608,
0.3696906864643097,
-0.08861804008483887,
-0.6111069917678833,
-0.3294331729412079,
0.005296887364238501,
0.6553698778152466,
0.37031129002571106,
-0.6402955055236816,
0.8948974609375,
0.2565220892429352,
-0.0010002440540120006,
-0.49659276008605957,
-0.8692809343338013,
-0.2880060374736786,
0.07546323537826538,
-0.497632771730423,
0.33569687604904175,
0.06658612191677094,
-0.19683986902236938,
0.12670381367206573,
-0.16423046588897705,
-0.17479181289672852,
0.026655487716197968,
0.45445388555526733,
-0.19829243421554565,
-0.18494127690792084,
0.19655324518680573,
-0.0015482258750125766,
0.08389578014612198,
0.337099552154541,
-0.062447674572467804,
0.1931222528219223,
-0.15346944332122803,
-0.8830598592758179,
-0.04677223414182663,
0.3173024654388428,
0.49043822288513184,
-0.17025324702262878,
0.7957599759101868,
0.5166136026382446,
-0.5902432203292847,
-0.2696692943572998,
-0.6773462295532227,
-0.12900392711162567,
-0.44661739468574524,
0.7338337302207947,
-0.5163032412528992,
-0.585396409034729,
0.5003566145896912,
-0.02887403592467308,
0.03194621950387955,
0.08204732835292816,
0.67038494348526,
-0.14326763153076172,
0.7412766814231873,
0.3648952543735504,
0.4027278423309326,
0.6612859964370728,
-0.03475337103009224,
-0.1599481701850891,
-0.9533410668373108,
-0.507897675037384,
-0.5565506219863892,
-0.55406254529953,
-0.2118104249238968,
-0.7965973019599915,
0.24992533028125763,
-0.5305190086364746,
-0.7224428057670593,
0.31772381067276,
-0.36438795924186707,
0.5555946230888367,
0.19543898105621338,
0.5284588932991028,
-0.1920483410358429,
-0.17221945524215698,
-0.06450213491916656,
-0.1347687989473343,
-0.6574367880821228,
-0.05755359306931496,
0.8292312622070312,
0.19560359418392181,
0.8867916464805603,
0.25513219833374023,
0.4378879964351654,
-0.0002677587035577744,
0.4835650622844696,
-0.46815288066864014,
0.507195234298706,
-0.15832562744617462,
-0.7889357209205627,
-0.22237010300159454,
-0.187764510512352,
-0.839303195476532,
0.7460933923721313,
-0.12533602118492126,
-0.841289222240448,
0.33899128437042236,
0.09226702898740768,
-0.20091423392295837,
0.28642332553863525,
-0.8037433624267578,
1.0081931352615356,
-0.5243818163871765,
-0.7545081973075867,
-0.49133896827697754,
-0.5366241335868835,
0.17370671033859253,
0.11469753086566925,
-0.016469407826662064,
-0.32638445496559143,
-0.4498457610607147,
0.43203243613243103,
-0.17546354234218597,
0.9698359966278076,
-0.6479902267456055,
-0.07253554463386536,
-0.17375117540359497,
0.1608666479587555,
0.42490825057029724,
-0.2833844721317291,
-0.07865966856479645,
0.18645890057086945,
-0.00580595014616847,
-0.5653284192085266,
-0.7479251623153687,
0.5489768385887146,
-0.6402978301048279,
-0.4410305321216583,
-0.2700784206390381,
-0.5302021503448486,
-0.4798556864261627,
-0.02159181237220764,
0.012985211797058582,
0.5436171889305115,
-0.7459268569946289,
0.4515603184700012,
0.664829432964325,
-0.444513201713562,
0.1469208002090454,
0.7530534267425537,
-0.14678436517715454,
-0.12362378090620041,
0.4816192090511322,
0.06862141937017441,
0.0929131880402565,
0.772743284702301,
0.013806266710162163,
-0.50411456823349,
-0.4313218891620636,
-0.46313589811325073,
0.17378674447536469,
-0.8155351877212524,
-0.17308925092220306,
-0.5134293437004089,
-0.012598826549947262,
-0.08376450091600418,
-0.4817081391811371,
-0.5121537446975708,
-0.1611265242099762,
0.07191026210784912,
-0.012484007515013218,
0.1953085958957672,
1.1372873783111572,
-0.06178547441959381,
-0.1703473925590515,
-0.836189329624176,
0.2983609139919281,
0.1399448662996292,
0.5805934071540833,
0.20131109654903412,
-0.6524384617805481,
-0.46786174178123474,
0.093113973736763,
-0.15614482760429382,
-0.7861688733100891,
0.42413458228111267,
0.0018534112023189664,
0.9754098653793335,
0.3383882939815521,
-0.24016784131526947,
1.0226107835769653,
-0.7831333875656128,
0.6247300505638123,
0.047924358397722244,
-0.8748306632041931,
0.6599901914596558,
-0.43727046251296997,
0.3346494436264038,
0.2822394371032715,
0.1399962306022644,
-0.36066320538520813,
-0.27568450570106506,
-0.601284921169281,
-0.5693292021751404,
0.6953181028366089,
0.08919666707515717,
-0.12290360778570175,
0.07467075437307358,
0.2041492611169815,
0.23088058829307556,
0.11104562133550644,
-0.5962503552436829,
0.09508609026670456,
-0.14200009405612946,
-0.17290353775024414,
-0.2016574591398239,
-0.07246080785989761,
-0.11609116941690445,
-0.6856119632720947,
0.3059418499469757,
-0.1164483055472374,
0.5115959048271179,
0.16728465259075165,
-0.3290296494960785,
-0.0548095740377903,
-0.09862770140171051,
0.6181378960609436,
0.7241604328155518,
-0.22024409472942352,
-0.042676761746406555,
0.5484503507614136,
-0.3518519699573517,
0.09290605038404465,
0.15057621896266937,
0.2731778621673584,
-0.3026654124259949,
0.35710054636001587,
0.7734518051147461,
0.8562799096107483,
-0.8613277077674866,
0.6891145706176758,
-0.07219775766134262,
-0.29044681787490845,
-0.4130747616291046,
-0.08684428036212921,
0.07122400403022766,
0.5384513735771179,
0.0709788054227829,
0.14270979166030884,
0.19636408984661102,
-0.34250205755233765,
0.061097439378499985,
0.3662174344062805,
-0.35491499304771423,
-0.2238703966140747,
0.7834433317184448,
0.40863463282585144,
0.08454979211091995,
0.6115009784698486,
0.17549791932106018,
-0.25857219099998474,
0.8280081748962402,
0.5374179482460022,
1.0415375232696533,
-0.2675251364707947,
-0.18021376430988312,
0.651192307472229,
0.3276761472225189,
-0.047890398651361465,
0.2171974629163742,
-0.5553469657897949,
-0.7948039174079895,
-0.10070805251598358,
-0.48574477434158325,
-0.49869880080223083,
-0.41823723912239075,
-0.9059954285621643,
-0.04979753866791725,
-0.413112610578537,
0.2104385793209076,
-0.15583352744579315,
-0.26329389214515686,
-0.9417423605918884,
0.08464136719703674,
0.319618821144104,
0.8830257654190063,
-1.0262374877929688,
0.7480292320251465,
0.8049504160881042,
-0.3355233371257782,
-0.5794513821601868,
-0.1440039426088333,
-0.13390053808689117,
-1.1392794847488403,
0.8198132514953613,
0.22320933640003204,
-0.18423615396022797,
-0.09494554251432419,
-0.5925730466842651,
-0.7654138207435608,
1.3869590759277344,
0.3969186246395111,
-0.5882851481437683,
0.1011132299900055,
-0.269860178232193,
0.6194596290588379,
-0.1690094769001007,
0.35717910528182983,
0.49223431944847107,
0.7376134395599365,
-0.1464671939611435,
-0.8202226758003235,
0.2142808586359024,
-0.3207612633705139,
0.14780116081237793,
0.32309073209762573,
-0.8036514520645142,
0.6481075286865234,
-0.29510319232940674,
-0.13341160118579865,
0.5305800437927246,
0.4915749430656433,
0.38741007447242737,
0.27384188771247864,
0.44860777258872986,
0.7244002223014832,
0.572506844997406,
-0.39105290174484253,
1.2911252975463867,
0.012907148338854313,
0.2731595039367676,
0.9056149125099182,
-0.5483222007751465,
1.1343636512756348,
0.3929898142814636,
-0.22476667165756226,
0.2689383625984192,
0.5238140821456909,
-0.1540173888206482,
0.5443519353866577,
0.2210683524608612,
-0.18829043209552765,
-0.3664683997631073,
0.16403445601463318,
-0.5691126585006714,
0.5384786128997803,
0.7785054445266724,
-0.3840479254722595,
-0.18825416266918182,
0.09798828512430191,
-0.7253060340881348,
0.12593452632427216,
-0.3242005705833435,
0.7802494168281555,
0.01299922727048397,
-0.7768893241882324,
0.5036717057228088,
-0.4034218192100525,
0.2213059365749359,
-0.5655908584594727,
-0.19567108154296875,
-0.15297427773475647,
0.4250752627849579,
-0.06492883712053299,
-1.062719702720642,
0.24913595616817474,
-0.1323600858449936,
-0.04118103161454201,
-0.593329131603241,
0.5715475082397461,
-0.338884174823761,
-0.06590079516172409,
0.5420894622802734,
0.6934729218482971,
0.35138949751853943,
-0.09567290544509888,
-0.5275842547416687,
0.048554033041000366,
-0.2313038408756256,
-0.15705916285514832,
0.3686593174934387,
0.7337831258773804,
0.2403971552848816,
0.6685773730278015,
0.1926833689212799,
-0.07455818355083466,
-0.02776239439845085,
0.20737700164318085,
0.6192100644111633,
-1.044255018234253,
-0.405747652053833,
-0.5100372433662415,
0.13374778628349304,
-0.05530141294002533,
-0.2503056526184082,
0.6132189631462097,
0.5259770154953003,
0.7429307699203491,
-0.4289294183254242,
0.5544078350067139,
-0.42113998532295227,
0.1347511112689972,
-0.702497661113739,
0.7212353348731995,
-1.0237425565719604,
-0.10051792114973068,
-0.20519904792308807,
-0.953222930431366,
-0.09254367649555206,
0.963996171951294,
-0.3694751262664795,
0.3266560733318329,
1.001656413078308,
0.8146414160728455,
-0.22448836266994476,
0.08569654822349548,
0.7934573888778687,
0.2829362452030182,
-0.1368301510810852,
0.8691376447677612,
1.1876429319381714,
-0.16689850389957428,
0.06996800750494003,
-0.1493476778268814,
-0.17214059829711914,
-0.35286352038383484,
-0.7891704440116882,
-0.808245062828064,
-0.7805607318878174,
0.10189251601696014,
-0.029349971562623978,
0.3314457833766937,
0.6709728240966797,
0.845163106918335,
-0.44245806336402893,
-0.10291432589292526,
-0.060303639620542526,
-0.2782993018627167,
-0.5286992192268372,
-0.10567504167556763,
0.21343667805194855,
-0.045612093061208725,
-0.7720921039581299,
0.3132167458534241,
0.41522446274757385,
-0.035408686846494675,
-0.28763535618782043,
-0.14465142786502838,
0.0050060320645570755,
-0.16410832107067108,
0.7964010238647461,
0.41099271178245544,
-0.969022810459137,
-0.4856063723564148,
-0.09902318567037582,
-0.17618726193904877,
-0.1448940634727478,
0.9114394187927246,
-0.7270606756210327,
0.5729155540466309,
0.5386057496070862,
0.7592766284942627,
0.8210031986236572,
-0.027467243373394012,
0.6945499777793884,
-0.8817114233970642,
0.4473492503166199,
0.2960922122001648,
0.7842427492141724,
0.23404432833194733,
-0.19810165464878082,
0.800312876701355,
0.14786285161972046,
-0.684447705745697,
-0.5425950884819031,
0.005491322372108698,
-1.1560165882110596,
-0.4347192645072937,
1.3169161081314087,
-0.12126583606004715,
-0.4831336438655853,
0.04556187242269516,
-0.2724480926990509,
-0.06229042634367943,
-0.059743668884038925,
0.5637734532356262,
0.6385031938552856,
-0.14571885764598846,
-0.2139720767736435,
-0.6850227117538452,
0.10456530004739761,
0.5134259462356567,
-1.0056449174880981,
0.3315240144729614,
0.7052969336509705,
0.22265572845935822,
-0.2056126892566681,
0.6235159635543823,
0.008619079366326332,
0.7339600920677185,
0.5747354030609131,
0.2687518894672394,
-0.025097040459513664,
-0.22084428369998932,
-0.14614491164684296,
-0.11293485760688782,
-0.07214121520519257,
-0.11515868455171585
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.05733v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.05733v1
|
MrRank: Improving Question Answering Retrieval System through Multi-Result Ranking Model
| 2024-06-09T11:00:01 | 2024-06-09T11:00:01 |
Danupat Khamnuansin, Tawunrat Chalothorn, Ekapol Chuangsuwanich
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) often struggle with hallucinations and outdated
information. To address this, Information Retrieval (IR) systems can be
employed to augment LLMs with up-to-date knowledge. However, existing IR
techniques contain deficiencies, posing a performance bottleneck. Given the
extensive array of IR systems, combining diverse approaches presents a viable
strategy. Nevertheless, prior attempts have yielded restricted efficacy. In
this work, we propose an approach that leverages learning-to-rank techniques to
combine heterogeneous IR systems. We demonstrate the method on two Retrieval
Question Answering (ReQA) tasks. Our empirical findings exhibit a significant
performance enhancement, outperforming previous approaches and achieving
state-of-the-art results on ReQA SQuAD.
|
[
-0.3063121736049652,
-0.6568259000778198,
0.5094485282897949,
0.14109867811203003,
-0.00046214304165914655,
0.7446653246879578,
-0.18777748942375183,
-0.4008908271789551,
0.45343783497810364,
0.22770965099334717,
-0.3896709382534027,
-0.4355575442314148,
-0.6983981132507324,
0.07786473631858826,
-0.05789743363857269,
0.7910935878753662,
0.33904367685317993,
0.1084108054637909,
-0.4192534387111664,
-0.2243889719247818,
-0.6558676958084106,
-0.630079984664917,
-0.5275276303291321,
-0.3402191996574402,
0.8340391516685486,
0.730455756187439,
0.7265331745147705,
0.3965311348438263,
0.8391457796096802,
0.33235326409339905,
0.09655389934778214,
0.49365052580833435,
-0.806885838508606,
0.6259363293647766,
-0.1833944320678711,
-0.4496418535709381,
-0.3289151191711426,
0.13107424974441528,
0.7568736672401428,
0.5775010585784912,
-0.42017003893852234,
0.09271933138370514,
-0.012408989481627941,
0.39440208673477173,
-0.6968743205070496,
-0.15557712316513062,
-0.7147248983383179,
-0.024290038272738457,
0.06884640455245972,
-0.6255055665969849,
-0.6720897555351257,
-0.601316511631012,
0.18511490523815155,
-0.40406474471092224,
-0.11615436524152756,
0.2919304668903351,
0.6847041249275208,
0.28719285130500793,
-0.07098858803510666,
-0.0213082954287529,
-0.5159770250320435,
1.0024487972259521,
-0.5710908770561218,
0.4234180152416229,
0.21319669485092163,
0.6608646512031555,
-0.001400838838890195,
-0.6930316090583801,
-0.1785685271024704,
-0.16578204929828644,
0.05201871693134308,
0.20557180047035217,
0.11667601019144058,
-0.3082132637500763,
-0.1580248326063156,
0.3255569636821747,
-0.5723295211791992,
0.15085093677043915,
-0.3779797852039337,
0.09554775059223175,
0.3211115300655365,
0.08414822071790695,
0.08355230838060379,
-0.1527073085308075,
-0.4105142652988434,
-0.4895879328250885,
-0.4745045602321625,
0.026514872908592224,
0.27893444895744324,
0.758320152759552,
0.46988150477409363,
0.7480033040046692,
-0.2765008211135864,
0.5913925766944885,
-0.16173692047595978,
-0.35975825786590576,
0.3671959340572357,
-0.06243839114904404,
-0.08343660086393356,
-0.13292492926120758,
0.3298642933368683,
0.22471480071544647,
0.09321113675832748,
-0.5722030997276306,
-0.25793495774269104,
-0.5177493095397949,
0.45864617824554443,
-0.73677659034729,
-0.23006296157836914,
0.12654989957809448,
-0.596442461013794,
-0.31845614314079285,
0.20859582722187042,
-0.9921508431434631,
-0.10950256884098053,
-0.21299196779727936,
0.9306517243385315,
-0.3332332670688629,
-0.3516407310962677,
-0.12465997040271759,
-0.34341949224472046,
0.2894926369190216,
0.41570982336997986,
-0.44319772720336914,
0.02298622764647007,
0.6294342279434204,
0.5979102849960327,
-0.22119714319705963,
-0.36278679966926575,
-0.6332377195358276,
0.280253529548645,
-0.26783445477485657,
0.7851779460906982,
-0.927193284034729,
-0.299250990152359,
0.04139992222189903,
-0.3284827470779419,
-0.21726949512958527,
-0.9225144386291504,
0.29448696970939636,
-1.0185718536376953,
0.589307963848114,
-0.030130812898278236,
-0.4304577708244324,
-0.016132285818457603,
0.3449152708053589,
-0.4593445658683777,
1.2329262495040894,
0.13977274298667908,
-0.4641067385673523,
0.07542948424816132,
-0.5380943417549133,
-0.4603121876716614,
-0.006084978114813566,
-0.042418550699949265,
-0.35009515285491943,
-0.03815068304538727,
0.11932241171598434,
0.39529848098754883,
-0.4231985807418823,
0.10552296042442322,
-0.163751482963562,
-0.6294817328453064,
0.03975246846675873,
-0.16944412887096405,
0.26994994282722473,
0.3217282295227051,
0.114838145673275,
0.009296366013586521,
-0.433928906917572,
0.4916364550590515,
-0.043815869837999344,
-0.8388145565986633,
-0.4421292245388031,
-0.1539982110261917,
-0.24808667600154877,
0.2108834683895111,
0.3639707863330841,
-0.2759428918361664,
0.25185319781303406,
-0.0154198557138443,
0.16732661426067352,
0.6126247644424438,
-0.0011079827090725303,
0.27846676111221313,
-0.5872025489807129,
0.5998631119728088,
-0.05917000770568848,
0.08020839840173721,
0.10609658062458038,
-0.5837968587875366,
-0.6560933589935303,
-0.4410397708415985,
0.4227156639099121,
0.7097480893135071,
-1.1156795024871826,
0.183904230594635,
-0.5581077933311462,
-0.4207128882408142,
-0.8663845062255859,
-0.02252587117254734,
0.505057156085968,
0.18343576788902283,
0.8111055493354797,
-0.1829567551612854,
-0.3519057333469391,
-0.8756248354911804,
-0.37869811058044434,
-0.21228310465812683,
-0.1167442798614502,
0.5750598311424255,
0.11392276734113693,
-0.1279570609331131,
0.7472561001777649,
-0.7163842916488647,
-0.3624134361743927,
-0.2035277932882309,
0.24249540269374847,
0.10885266214609146,
0.3733247220516205,
0.18777406215667725,
-0.8748946189880371,
-0.2304823398590088,
-0.18553537130355835,
-0.8787174224853516,
0.22316664457321167,
0.5503809452056885,
-0.09720586985349655,
0.029705321416258812,
0.6948643922805786,
0.023853963240981102,
0.03636528179049492,
0.3356192409992218,
-0.07928208261728287,
0.37643277645111084,
-0.26306864619255066,
0.8292021155357361,
-1.0767165422439575,
-0.06520213931798935,
-0.1183987408876419,
-0.24847698211669922,
-0.39335983991622925,
0.3287101984024048,
-0.023747902363538742,
-0.12721942365169525,
-0.2581675946712494,
0.23536090552806854,
-0.348734587430954,
-0.12178948521614075,
-0.1959921419620514,
0.1682937741279602,
-0.1390146166086197,
0.5393503904342651,
-0.19045445322990417,
1.1030992269515991,
0.2126057744026184,
-0.42040666937828064,
0.07441160082817078,
0.19296382367610931,
-0.12336860597133636,
0.43903017044067383,
-0.46073102951049805,
-0.06484531611204147,
-0.4434639513492584,
-0.14764459431171417,
-1.3041359186172485,
-0.12831610441207886,
-0.14864443242549896,
-0.7421814203262329,
0.4414581060409546,
-0.16204120218753815,
-0.5890417098999023,
-0.16093137860298157,
-0.4983934164047241,
0.5076345801353455,
0.4631247818470001,
-0.6442334651947021,
0.570034921169281,
0.392488569021225,
-0.4989878833293915,
-0.9181258678436279,
-0.4154507517814636,
0.26190221309661865,
-0.23447208106517792,
-0.5305517911911011,
0.37906935811042786,
0.06575241684913635,
-0.15697938203811646,
-0.1721416562795639,
0.019807511940598488,
-0.21852412819862366,
0.00609555235132575,
-0.023108728229999542,
0.40935418009757996,
-0.33831340074539185,
0.5178127884864807,
-0.01717168092727661,
0.08011967688798904,
-0.27964121103286743,
0.021407630294561386,
0.6069771647453308,
0.039889898151159286,
-0.16959667205810547,
-0.19321218132972717,
0.5207687616348267,
0.825289785861969,
-0.4498159885406494,
0.9592694044113159,
0.28426459431648254,
-0.12376857548952103,
-0.07098221033811569,
-0.8465944528579712,
-0.4717080295085907,
-0.46915024518966675,
0.33763206005096436,
-0.670889139175415,
-1.1281700134277344,
0.4024003744125366,
-0.3566751182079315,
-0.07772673666477203,
0.2798808515071869,
0.32532060146331787,
-0.15105466544628143,
0.9357933402061462,
0.7428868412971497,
-0.28090617060661316,
0.5586471557617188,
0.053895141929388046,
0.3658481538295746,
-0.8075262308120728,
-0.5860931873321533,
-0.8111078143119812,
-0.26637208461761475,
-0.6707319021224976,
-0.7108221650123596,
0.5180554986000061,
-0.026473352685570717,
-0.22151345014572144,
0.04086634889245033,
-0.5872870683670044,
0.39272478222846985,
0.6253432631492615,
0.332215279340744,
0.6187785267829895,
0.4362572133541107,
-0.2955988347530365,
-0.14632603526115417,
-0.9233402609825134,
-0.38722479343414307,
1.2664544582366943,
0.270158588886261,
0.9296994805335999,
0.6859700679779053,
0.7352039813995361,
0.4212140142917633,
0.4056748151779175,
-0.27566346526145935,
0.3859213590621948,
-0.19712093472480774,
-0.554017961025238,
-0.49655357003211975,
-0.6925791501998901,
-0.7108539938926697,
0.7923041582107544,
-0.45254725217819214,
-0.4928247928619385,
0.18973872065544128,
-0.4226504862308502,
-0.26220428943634033,
0.04251058027148247,
-0.6232937574386597,
0.3342963457107544,
0.13430750370025635,
-0.5650734901428223,
-0.3243364691734314,
-0.7696173787117004,
0.4819360077381134,
0.16705553233623505,
0.038583800196647644,
0.1864185929298401,
0.03599391505122185,
0.8628078699111938,
0.039455387741327286,
0.1453583687543869,
0.010331141762435436,
0.003960155416280031,
-0.21054355800151825,
-0.36291325092315674,
0.2880079448223114,
0.17788100242614746,
-0.47339385747909546,
-0.3127167820930481,
-0.16936653852462769,
-0.4100707173347473,
-0.5626734495162964,
1.0478907823562622,
-0.9135808348655701,
-0.6714531779289246,
-0.3914599120616913,
-0.7180782556533813,
-0.4282209277153015,
0.08946661651134491,
-0.05211808532476425,
0.3730391561985016,
0.009260760620236397,
0.415772020816803,
1.053823709487915,
-0.35545358061790466,
0.1412176787853241,
0.416152685880661,
-0.3268131911754608,
-0.511198103427887,
0.946662425994873,
0.020850056782364845,
0.4741860032081604,
0.5785205960273743,
-0.19648104906082153,
-0.4131894111633301,
-0.46604451537132263,
-0.13523955643177032,
0.3930967450141907,
-0.728219211101532,
-0.42266952991485596,
-0.8634878396987915,
-0.3618353307247162,
-0.7538399696350098,
0.20115402340888977,
-0.18775680661201477,
-0.5416642427444458,
0.06012802943587303,
0.19692212343215942,
0.2533206343650818,
0.48809319734573364,
-0.005738287698477507,
0.08171813935041428,
-0.4885476231575012,
0.6388902068138123,
0.472107857465744,
0.5205917954444885,
0.20786936581134796,
-0.6946735978126526,
-0.1952488124370575,
-0.1368284672498703,
-0.30510038137435913,
-0.6402837634086609,
0.22709046304225922,
0.08255694061517715,
0.9333179593086243,
0.0793427899479866,
0.1214507445693016,
0.9607565999031067,
-0.4600205421447754,
0.28959032893180847,
-0.04227612167596817,
-0.33552753925323486,
0.46676507592201233,
-0.1682891845703125,
0.1133723333477974,
0.9662543535232544,
0.35766300559043884,
-0.23631592094898224,
-0.7604385018348694,
-0.3776445984840393,
-1.0114084482192993,
0.597464919090271,
0.11138487607240677,
-0.1689513623714447,
0.21195454895496368,
0.37663841247558594,
-0.18597467243671417,
0.43025583028793335,
-0.5443500876426697,
-0.5809139013290405,
0.022738194093108177,
-0.16411322355270386,
-0.23877133429050446,
-0.27213194966316223,
-0.15794627368450165,
-0.3975454270839691,
0.8008052706718445,
0.06276796758174896,
0.5903560519218445,
0.26713553071022034,
-0.19174639880657196,
-0.07293400913476944,
0.300720751285553,
0.48591938614845276,
0.7175468802452087,
-0.5892860293388367,
0.08119989931583405,
-0.04843965545296669,
-0.2972107231616974,
0.24359257519245148,
0.30519527196884155,
0.22780972719192505,
-0.05972325801849365,
0.1792662888765335,
0.13077378273010254,
0.16895002126693726,
-0.6623191833496094,
0.2502978444099426,
-0.2896745800971985,
-0.11040256917476654,
0.05827966332435608,
0.06823424994945526,
0.16671907901763916,
0.45256850123405457,
1.0012754201889038,
-0.13163909316062927,
0.11920460313558578,
-0.8209257125854492,
0.4010239839553833,
0.6845106482505798,
-0.3120531439781189,
0.5335378050804138,
0.4200640618801117,
0.044201549142599106,
-0.3780418038368225,
0.7842663526535034,
0.09448817372322083,
-0.6299211978912354,
0.44042691588401794,
0.49248477816581726,
0.14696066081523895,
-0.5648792386054993,
0.2805418372154236,
0.2784450054168701,
0.3841331899166107,
-0.21837866306304932,
0.30580249428749084,
0.10355158895254135,
-0.49934089183807373,
-0.3126978278160095,
-0.396991491317749,
-0.5765660405158997,
0.0169542133808136,
-0.6662437319755554,
0.07877332717180252,
-0.2415136992931366,
0.07583805918693542,
-0.05347175523638725,
0.31082719564437866,
-0.24383391439914703,
0.23563452064990997,
-0.29853329062461853,
0.74067622423172,
-0.5781034231185913,
0.7232041954994202,
0.811095118522644,
-0.4284670054912567,
-0.7757452130317688,
0.21141496300697327,
-0.5102720856666565,
-0.6752285361289978,
0.6573885083198547,
0.15375667810440063,
-0.31048449873924255,
0.3828910291194916,
-0.36699751019477844,
-0.9090868830680847,
1.2981898784637451,
0.09147699177265167,
0.010100639425218105,
0.10423681139945984,
-0.010023235343396664,
0.3764776885509491,
-0.5049896240234375,
0.584068238735199,
0.18572558462619781,
0.5105913281440735,
0.29632866382598877,
-0.7885468006134033,
-0.16046735644340515,
-0.17915518581867218,
-0.13088250160217285,
0.22622227668762207,
-0.5573810338973999,
0.9545063376426697,
-0.3553629517555237,
-0.03967578336596489,
0.29130852222442627,
0.6641987562179565,
0.5812926888465881,
0.3060055077075958,
0.25012174248695374,
0.7203632593154907,
0.8256868720054626,
-0.11931092292070389,
0.8407266139984131,
-0.031812313944101334,
0.4437965750694275,
1.0072948932647705,
-0.32107964158058167,
1.1882954835891724,
0.6269142031669617,
-0.1075025424361229,
0.6887152194976807,
0.46666842699050903,
0.17287491261959076,
0.9413326978683472,
0.26141780614852905,
-0.2606470286846161,
-0.5874127149581909,
-0.01207111869007349,
-0.6615928411483765,
0.3439878225326538,
0.14307746291160583,
-0.4597471058368683,
-0.5270963311195374,
0.18145006895065308,
-0.24934719502925873,
0.2919841706752777,
-0.007240417879074812,
0.797386109828949,
-0.23963408172130585,
-0.8812313675880432,
0.6054968237876892,
0.2743530869483948,
0.8602453470230103,
-0.4304437041282654,
-0.36977913975715637,
-0.29993903636932373,
0.16257934272289276,
0.06467828899621964,
-0.5333450436592102,
-0.1741638034582138,
-0.22801938652992249,
-0.5646959543228149,
-0.287777841091156,
0.5973096489906311,
-0.5472577810287476,
-0.456585168838501,
0.32881292700767517,
1.1080518960952759,
0.11672944575548172,
0.005041659343987703,
-0.5765746831893921,
-0.07235988974571228,
-0.0527646467089653,
0.009881376288831234,
0.6311393976211548,
0.2943202257156372,
0.11771558225154877,
1.0607078075408936,
0.5836874842643738,
-0.16985008120536804,
0.151321142911911,
-0.10068514943122864,
0.9962061643600464,
-0.6275798082351685,
-0.35676324367523193,
-0.45454496145248413,
0.02430204674601555,
-0.25190991163253784,
0.025770368054509163,
0.7032306790351868,
0.6760040521621704,
0.5378484129905701,
0.13956475257873535,
0.6051840782165527,
0.030290119349956512,
1.0514335632324219,
-0.3122199773788452,
0.7133747935295105,
-0.8801149129867554,
0.46000736951828003,
-0.21607375144958496,
-0.9911179542541504,
-0.33868837356567383,
0.6642255783081055,
-0.1352425515651703,
0.21305419504642487,
0.6838470101356506,
0.9793193340301514,
-0.024788543581962585,
-0.2704639732837677,
0.4596012830734253,
-0.0769578143954277,
0.2277410924434662,
0.6233208179473877,
0.9790785908699036,
-0.5970313549041748,
0.6710590720176697,
0.11733243614435196,
-0.25905123353004456,
-0.48234090209007263,
-0.3776281774044037,
-0.6668115258216858,
-0.5090750455856323,
-0.10714737325906754,
-0.25429847836494446,
0.5839287638664246,
0.7458429336547852,
0.7363044023513794,
-0.4083251655101776,
-0.20835568010807037,
0.7548513412475586,
0.46943703293800354,
-0.21440637111663818,
-0.26660674810409546,
0.18362489342689514,
-0.5236026644706726,
-0.7865562438964844,
0.46082213521003723,
0.13885296881198883,
-0.24647711217403412,
-0.10624907910823822,
-0.05520274490118027,
-0.8863275647163391,
0.00042157285497523844,
0.6833294630050659,
0.075837641954422,
-0.46023425459861755,
-0.19461464881896973,
0.19141562283039093,
-0.37277472019195557,
0.2488022744655609,
0.6129669547080994,
-1.2034605741500854,
0.06816146522760391,
0.4724508821964264,
0.7653906941413879,
0.01414220966398716,
0.5627787709236145,
0.41338348388671875,
-0.7020035982131958,
-0.2782242000102997,
0.2605811357498169,
-0.1159147396683693,
0.3878699839115143,
-0.31885427236557007,
0.42892417311668396,
-0.11895795166492462,
-0.7058157324790955,
-0.9510024189949036,
0.01267612911760807,
-0.7025120258331299,
-0.6764543652534485,
0.9577984809875488,
0.03251834958791733,
0.3486447334289551,
-0.1929498165845871,
0.15907146036624908,
0.23214395344257355,
-0.5799756646156311,
0.9292293787002563,
0.7230052947998047,
-0.04384365305304527,
-0.2698041796684265,
-0.6845221519470215,
0.1263049989938736,
0.6796010136604309,
-0.8638898134231567,
-0.2834373116493225,
0.42532339692115784,
0.3817388415336609,
0.391148179769516,
0.28711003065109253,
-0.2982501685619354,
0.161407008767128,
-0.6294069290161133,
-0.10272157937288284,
-0.0649627074599266,
-0.6699225902557373,
-0.20603534579277039,
0.7506647706031799,
0.35107842087745667,
-0.252183198928833
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.05707v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.05707v1
|
QGEval: A Benchmark for Question Generation Evaluation
| 2024-06-09T09:51:55 | 2024-06-09T09:51:55 |
Weiping Fu, Bifan Wei, Jianxiang Hu, Zhongmin Cai, Jun Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Automatically generated questions often suffer from problems such as unclear
expression or factual inaccuracies, requiring a reliable and comprehensive
evaluation of their quality. Human evaluation is frequently used in the field
of question generation (QG) and is one of the most accurate evaluation methods.
It also serves as the standard for automatic metrics. However, there is a lack
of unified evaluation criteria, which hampers the development of both QG
technologies and automatic evaluation methods. To address this, we propose
QGEval, a multi-dimensional Evaluation benchmark for Question Generation, which
evaluates both generated questions and existing automatic metrics across 7
dimensions: fluency, clarity, conciseness, relevance, consistency,
answerability, and answer consistency. We demonstrate the appropriateness of
these dimensions by examining their correlations and distinctions. Analysis
with QGEval reveals that 1) most QG models perform unsatisfactorily in terms of
answerability and answer consistency, and 2) existing metrics fail to align
well with human assessments when evaluating generated questions across the 7
dimensions. We expect this work to foster the development of both QG
technologies and automatic metrics for QG.
|
[
-0.9085742235183716,
-0.6481243968009949,
0.6861491203308105,
0.0027029362972825766,
-0.10560841113328934,
0.08689519017934799,
0.35514044761657715,
-0.35076001286506653,
-0.3115014433860779,
0.15402640402317047,
-0.6055145263671875,
-0.23807021975517273,
-0.14643119275569916,
0.22626496851444244,
-0.27898597717285156,
0.8215120434761047,
0.17210380733013153,
-0.030743353068828583,
-0.8012109994888306,
-0.3403368592262268,
-0.4722801446914673,
-0.15474431216716766,
-0.5886560678482056,
-0.166795551776886,
0.2438923716545105,
0.38324040174484253,
0.7185497879981995,
0.1597675234079361,
0.30754631757736206,
0.29309970140457153,
0.2718938887119293,
0.4395369291305542,
-0.2430022656917572,
0.09835250675678253,
0.009237179532647133,
-0.1176634281873703,
-0.30057182908058167,
0.21356257796287537,
0.8445411920547485,
0.6293815970420837,
-0.17140083014965057,
0.7648038268089294,
-0.04534237086772919,
0.5412889719009399,
-0.6211587190628052,
0.0309423990547657,
-0.4080753028392792,
-0.0030475726816803217,
0.2337913066148758,
-0.027553480118513107,
0.32327941060066223,
-1.2971121072769165,
0.08685679733753204,
-0.6682688593864441,
0.5697662830352783,
0.14540888369083405,
0.8583452105522156,
0.08021312206983566,
-0.42914119362831116,
-0.1412617564201355,
-0.4725368022918701,
0.48952651023864746,
-0.521955668926239,
0.33677610754966736,
0.1123683825135231,
0.9017814993858337,
-0.21631678938865662,
-0.728175699710846,
-0.726827085018158,
-0.15381456911563873,
0.09812169522047043,
0.2692365050315857,
-0.18450257182121277,
-0.18963950872421265,
0.5000399947166443,
0.48593589663505554,
-0.9136229753494263,
-0.41337481141090393,
-0.41762539744377136,
-0.1888512521982193,
0.9395477771759033,
0.4399469196796417,
0.4040144383907318,
-0.2670730948448181,
-0.32010215520858765,
-0.42603304982185364,
-0.44878843426704407,
0.4120267629623413,
0.6533763408660889,
-0.054938800632953644,
0.4679633378982544,
0.19876275956630707,
-0.43459150195121765,
0.6298205256462097,
0.28405478596687317,
-0.16666476428508759,
0.1789507418870926,
-0.5508965253829956,
0.05558016523718834,
-0.20195665955543518,
0.7778725624084473,
0.615796685218811,
0.005220341496169567,
0.030163468793034554,
-0.12464924156665802,
-0.014330985955893993,
0.7248376607894897,
-0.8851169347763062,
-0.11554784327745438,
0.33317315578460693,
-0.3390684425830841,
-0.40270736813545227,
0.3028438091278076,
-0.8007123470306396,
-0.21710233390331268,
0.05538736656308174,
0.7803399562835693,
-0.17855416238307953,
-0.3573038876056671,
0.14348843693733215,
-0.23257498443126678,
0.49149829149246216,
0.24438200891017914,
-0.3900822103023529,
0.01134997047483921,
0.37579238414764404,
0.12113449722528458,
0.01902381144464016,
-0.3169596195220947,
-0.6764715313911438,
-0.3355240523815155,
-0.49190035462379456,
1.0526278018951416,
-0.40260031819343567,
-0.6605132222175598,
-0.044594861567020416,
-0.027596423402428627,
0.12726861238479614,
-0.8068669438362122,
0.633629322052002,
-0.490855872631073,
0.4914587438106537,
-0.7465983033180237,
-0.4598534405231476,
-0.21999791264533997,
0.40373438596725464,
-0.5075543522834778,
1.3222793340682983,
0.3995099663734436,
-0.6056124567985535,
0.8590494990348816,
-0.33176189661026,
-0.023622067645192146,
0.6087412238121033,
-0.49226677417755127,
-0.5968686938285828,
0.14068163931369781,
0.1969599574804306,
-0.015580140985548496,
-0.9979476928710938,
0.32279226183891296,
-0.07699807733297348,
-0.3804517984390259,
0.015916340053081512,
-0.31936395168304443,
0.5393295884132385,
0.28807148337364197,
-0.33189234137535095,
-0.05261029675602913,
-1.0347009897232056,
0.9539834856987,
0.09011305123567581,
-0.2794651687145233,
-0.08120930939912796,
-0.16282187402248383,
-0.5198331475257874,
0.3602217137813568,
0.1337123066186905,
-0.6238431334495544,
-0.003420304274186492,
-0.1303589940071106,
-0.06588248163461685,
0.1819523125886917,
0.6005492210388184,
-0.03851420804858208,
-0.5372876524925232,
1.040808081626892,
-0.10549343377351761,
0.23534387350082397,
0.1147908866405487,
-0.5964569449424744,
-0.44241493940353394,
0.29729434847831726,
0.3560262620449066,
0.44037240743637085,
-0.7175805568695068,
0.48397451639175415,
0.09341748058795929,
-0.9592981934547424,
-0.682516872882843,
-0.04114137217402458,
0.48663175106048584,
0.7341179251670837,
0.26208215951919556,
-0.4411143660545349,
-0.21164460480213165,
-0.9750136137008667,
-0.3097396194934845,
-0.6567440629005432,
-0.24313028156757355,
0.4140116572380066,
0.2564069926738739,
0.20210297405719757,
0.830333948135376,
-0.5226614475250244,
0.4248920977115631,
0.08309101313352585,
0.7762869596481323,
-0.25930917263031006,
0.40214163064956665,
0.5348268747329712,
-0.5081602931022644,
-0.17258840799331665,
-0.3915318548679352,
-0.7953189611434937,
-0.46323925256729126,
-0.1725560575723648,
-0.45699772238731384,
-0.4102167785167694,
0.3132604658603668,
-0.49670499563217163,
0.20616558194160461,
0.2824862599372864,
-0.28837189078330994,
0.9884408712387085,
-0.23534101247787476,
0.7745436429977417,
-1.008593201637268,
0.18317784368991852,
-0.12465588748455048,
0.012402711436152458,
-0.37134939432144165,
0.00796165969222784,
0.21812497079372406,
-0.4738415777683258,
-0.35366639494895935,
0.5970950126647949,
-0.4107065498828888,
-0.21846850216388702,
0.01194871123880148,
0.3472704589366913,
0.5261446237564087,
-0.13747915625572205,
-0.5187850594520569,
1.1187843084335327,
0.16857320070266724,
-0.6583792567253113,
0.5617879629135132,
0.33569496870040894,
-0.6740034222602844,
1.194056510925293,
-0.9977484941482544,
0.322711318731308,
-0.18755774199962616,
-0.04777580872178078,
-1.204810619354248,
-0.09826397150754929,
-0.1277424395084381,
-0.7388864755630493,
-0.02939309924840927,
0.19982774555683136,
-0.4962473511695862,
-0.7056370973587036,
-0.283077597618103,
0.6037516593933105,
0.8170536160469055,
-0.5026881694793701,
0.17891353368759155,
0.19020943343639374,
-0.051520559936761856,
-0.19116824865341187,
-0.1814219355583191,
-0.1667996048927307,
-0.24895650148391724,
-0.9726858735084534,
0.020870815962553024,
-0.25471067428588867,
-0.13001412153244019,
-0.001031168969348073,
-0.15762001276016235,
0.0051210373640060425,
-0.08660709112882614,
-0.0052330284379422665,
-0.09636814892292023,
-0.3526383340358734,
0.3593772351741791,
0.06919966638088226,
-0.029200240969657898,
0.39798030257225037,
-0.3391895890235901,
0.10901360958814621,
-0.2863771319389343,
-0.4769189953804016,
0.014928711578249931,
0.5030112862586975,
0.6436648964881897,
-0.544928252696991,
0.19118481874465942,
0.7652043700218201,
-0.32526615262031555,
-0.18874794244766235,
-0.754170298576355,
-0.06716227531433105,
-0.47332778573036194,
0.2804131805896759,
-0.44242119789123535,
-0.7855944633483887,
0.5707765817642212,
-0.10266174376010895,
0.10912729054689407,
0.785876452922821,
0.3117828071117401,
0.04028668627142906,
1.5000700950622559,
0.2738420069217682,
0.40994763374328613,
-0.14873144030570984,
0.09584515541791916,
0.20608454942703247,
-0.7765899896621704,
-0.34721919894218445,
-0.6228998899459839,
-0.07577766478061676,
-0.6683626770973206,
-0.347891628742218,
0.7717548608779907,
0.4063114821910858,
-0.4091988205909729,
0.0517939031124115,
-0.6579564213752747,
0.24057388305664062,
0.46635010838508606,
-0.41204604506492615,
0.06552881002426147,
-0.225420743227005,
-0.3304275870323181,
-0.010044442489743233,
-0.7479079365730286,
-0.6871160268783569,
0.7637362480163574,
0.06682629883289337,
0.4921833574771881,
-0.07707901298999786,
0.8235687613487244,
0.20081685483455658,
0.09134427458047867,
-0.4033086895942688,
0.5888406038284302,
0.3071114122867584,
-0.70018070936203,
-0.5691471099853516,
-0.5635607838630676,
-1.169312834739685,
0.48580384254455566,
-0.37490466237068176,
-0.4753399193286896,
0.0834440216422081,
0.04364573583006859,
-0.96109539270401,
0.1291954666376114,
-0.6607348918914795,
0.9268477559089661,
-0.3706573247909546,
-0.44885367155075073,
0.18337857723236084,
-0.4074287414550781,
0.4357532262802124,
-0.07826372981071472,
-0.18513423204421997,
-0.27491360902786255,
0.31453996896743774,
0.6950039863586426,
-0.5169629454612732,
0.2640981674194336,
-0.4471946060657501,
-0.04553326591849327,
0.960899829864502,
0.12961728870868683,
0.10341345518827438,
0.4419229328632355,
0.0328373983502388,
-0.3651267886161804,
0.3920401334762573,
-0.3979259133338928,
-0.8581898808479309,
0.5284377336502075,
-0.7594909071922302,
-0.6773565411567688,
-0.22998180985450745,
-0.4417642056941986,
-0.6302984952926636,
0.07986432313919067,
0.23224230110645294,
0.35389766097068787,
-0.5375844836235046,
-0.0566624216735363,
0.6453092098236084,
-0.5505229234695435,
0.062224894762039185,
0.4046151340007782,
-0.04830579459667206,
-0.5029445290565491,
0.8079105019569397,
0.14407937228679657,
0.21912725269794464,
-0.30502983927726746,
0.3108951449394226,
-0.5823222994804382,
-0.0287044458091259,
-0.8436759114265442,
0.036908239126205444,
-0.6033649444580078,
-0.31126895546913147,
-0.5609215497970581,
-0.4780249297618866,
-0.2845766246318817,
0.006294067017734051,
-0.20819179713726044,
-0.1778850257396698,
0.06124309450387955,
-0.10637041181325912,
0.06731954962015152,
0.6357230544090271,
0.03727518022060394,
-0.25218120217323303,
-1.1655057668685913,
0.3528759479522705,
1.1669268608093262,
0.3350115120410919,
-0.04998345673084259,
-0.3382243812084198,
0.0888623520731926,
0.016779305413365364,
-0.5820173025131226,
-0.7868966460227966,
-0.0217188261449337,
0.06577084213495255,
0.8995373249053955,
0.12069114297628403,
0.0002126789913745597,
0.5500398278236389,
-0.2939721345901489,
1.0932819843292236,
0.22480683028697968,
-0.7898842692375183,
0.6660747528076172,
-0.30694663524627686,
0.7569583058357239,
0.9204967617988586,
0.2820841670036316,
-0.4766981899738312,
-0.17220523953437805,
-1.0509589910507202,
-0.6424463391304016,
0.15015512704849243,
0.03371107578277588,
0.07504802197217941,
-0.32083168625831604,
0.479179322719574,
0.32388603687286377,
0.49123427271842957,
-0.16429631412029266,
0.23966559767723083,
-0.2857605516910553,
0.05873851478099823,
0.08796422183513641,
-0.25256165862083435,
-0.09053795784711838,
-0.08817243576049805,
0.1822388470172882,
-0.23868992924690247,
0.3534061908721924,
0.2500483989715576,
0.09551400691270828,
-0.39091676473617554,
0.34410467743873596,
0.5706180334091187,
0.8848727345466614,
-0.08500789850950241,
0.026236241683363914,
0.41678664088249207,
-0.2486322820186615,
0.5250352621078491,
0.04856257140636444,
-0.3296373188495636,
-0.1413588970899582,
0.055701401084661484,
0.5085565447807312,
-0.30169180035591125,
-0.3900371491909027,
0.4615228772163391,
-0.2051907181739807,
-0.7052475810050964,
-0.18358933925628662,
0.3415965437889099,
-0.14282594621181488,
0.2739972174167633,
0.2614698112010956,
-0.362750768661499,
0.1275656372308731,
-0.5242577195167542,
0.26703059673309326,
0.3676917254924774,
-0.42993369698524475,
-0.300485223531723,
0.8688111305236816,
0.1918019950389862,
-0.17517323791980743,
0.6281386017799377,
-0.765633225440979,
-0.45845192670822144,
0.7743321657180786,
0.2696297764778137,
1.0652905702590942,
-0.2783343195915222,
0.5872545838356018,
0.96580570936203,
0.354577898979187,
-0.02493233047425747,
0.9101948142051697,
0.03906826674938202,
-0.6255114078521729,
0.06728730350732803,
-0.7117117047309875,
-0.4081418216228485,
0.34376177191734314,
-0.7617313265800476,
-0.06223873794078827,
-0.35959094762802124,
-0.319513201713562,
-0.20152246952056885,
0.2192375212907791,
-0.9294372200965881,
0.7684817314147949,
-0.10110118985176086,
0.580237865447998,
-0.8851045370101929,
0.23283344507217407,
0.9405511617660522,
-0.6907550096511841,
-0.8512871265411377,
0.1773744523525238,
-0.08373639732599258,
-0.6020408272743225,
0.45282018184661865,
-0.07338985800743103,
-0.256390243768692,
-0.008977309800684452,
-0.3973441421985626,
-0.8643193244934082,
1.2816100120544434,
-0.06908971071243286,
-0.07382179796695709,
0.2845945954322815,
0.31388792395591736,
0.793571412563324,
-0.377057284116745,
0.35659468173980713,
0.642387330532074,
0.6221960783004761,
0.0318027064204216,
-0.6510223746299744,
0.21994107961654663,
-0.4240233302116394,
0.3342546224594116,
0.23745228350162506,
-0.802397608757019,
0.6304593086242676,
-0.2153376191854477,
-0.3376929759979248,
0.053828462958335876,
0.5765765309333801,
0.4577631652355194,
0.1548198014497757,
0.6672166585922241,
0.5437831282615662,
0.9218791127204895,
-0.3267041742801666,
0.9908767938613892,
-0.4193986654281616,
0.12378652393817902,
0.5867438912391663,
-0.36763882637023926,
0.4100715219974518,
0.03996895253658295,
-0.3363458514213562,
0.09530173987150192,
0.6131673455238342,
-0.2571658790111542,
0.3429301679134369,
0.7920828461647034,
-0.18876896798610687,
-0.42512744665145874,
0.005093206651508808,
-0.5835585594177246,
0.574948787689209,
0.011305260471999645,
0.1985834389925003,
-0.501901388168335,
-0.32375165820121765,
-0.3371848165988922,
0.06277623027563095,
-0.12970048189163208,
0.6854338645935059,
-0.2699914872646332,
-1.0611211061477661,
0.7798846364021301,
-0.13312064111232758,
0.03362373262643814,
-0.4689082205295563,
-0.2096450924873352,
-0.4593909978866577,
-0.2832586169242859,
-0.08698136359453201,
-0.7613463997840881,
0.1331901252269745,
0.006749777588993311,
0.04676031321287155,
0.07831723988056183,
0.7676902413368225,
-0.38207173347473145,
-0.5631035566329956,
-0.1909656822681427,
0.9769884347915649,
0.14306949079036713,
0.07250911742448807,
-0.7048975229263306,
-0.45577526092529297,
-0.12015300989151001,
-0.17933888733386993,
0.31997841596603394,
0.674150288105011,
-0.12682345509529114,
0.3805474042892456,
0.4611799418926239,
-0.13114959001541138,
0.17163075506687164,
0.24234668910503387,
0.5686299800872803,
-0.6723024845123291,
-0.3163365423679352,
-0.17403091490268707,
0.7674068808555603,
-0.1318741887807846,
-0.9036058187484741,
0.7779890298843384,
0.550796627998352,
0.7521747946739197,
0.16628986597061157,
1.038822889328003,
0.047623343765735626,
0.5171415209770203,
-0.23372839391231537,
0.7673777937889099,
-0.7799518704414368,
-0.030773017555475235,
-0.36443769931793213,
-1.1227787733078003,
0.13155046105384827,
0.4249013662338257,
-0.18128088116645813,
0.5168582797050476,
0.6693274974822998,
0.6146751642227173,
0.14265009760856628,
0.008093216456472874,
0.6536431312561035,
-0.5046015977859497,
0.2638251781463623,
0.49957871437072754,
1.1741093397140503,
-0.6257392168045044,
0.6332359910011292,
0.055718787014484406,
-0.18914920091629028,
0.0730905830860138,
-0.7590816020965576,
-0.6696849465370178,
-0.734736979007721,
-0.3943421542644501,
-0.29312005639076233,
-0.13398273289203644,
0.5899656414985657,
0.5387146472930908,
-0.5355312824249268,
-0.20292729139328003,
0.06400572508573532,
-0.29343295097351074,
-0.13421137630939484,
-0.2518562376499176,
0.22235704958438873,
-0.5335783958435059,
-0.3450251519680023,
0.16370278596878052,
0.18079014122486115,
0.07823099195957184,
-0.5096007585525513,
0.18460382521152496,
0.11669044196605682,
0.40670278668403625,
0.5308704972267151,
0.3751277029514313,
-0.37606438994407654,
-0.7930094599723816,
0.09453524649143219,
-0.1960429549217224,
-0.04582887515425682,
0.607093334197998,
-0.6996170282363892,
0.7100668549537659,
0.7987073659896851,
0.8199941515922546,
0.35934171080589294,
0.6374745965003967,
0.740067183971405,
-0.616771936416626,
-0.4610929489135742,
0.3500138521194458,
-0.03244033828377724,
0.22547446191310883,
-0.21750983595848083,
0.401917040348053,
-0.01665193773806095,
-0.8673340678215027,
-0.5621480345726013,
0.2007877081632614,
-0.3456116020679474,
0.11420679837465286,
0.9269436001777649,
-0.06981542706489563,
0.06397084146738052,
0.08875110000371933,
-0.1944373995065689,
0.197398841381073,
0.018748994916677475,
1.0217111110687256,
0.7686724662780762,
-0.35308894515037537,
-0.1709616333246231,
-0.8311246037483215,
0.6889967918395996,
0.5602205395698547,
-1.0962345600128174,
-0.1621861606836319,
0.6571024656295776,
0.2367679327726364,
0.14839377999305725,
0.43892741203308105,
-0.39943820238113403,
0.7309646606445312,
0.43131938576698303,
0.39995288848876953,
0.0674286037683487,
-0.13255208730697632,
-0.10892236977815628,
0.4418354630470276,
0.37051478028297424,
-0.2948058247566223
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.06636v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.06636v1
|
LLM Questionnaire Completion for Automatic Psychiatric Assessment
| 2024-06-09T09:03:11 | 2024-06-09T09:03:11 |
Gony Rosenman, Lior Wolf, Talma Hendler
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG, 68T50, I.2.7
|
We employ a Large Language Model (LLM) to convert unstructured psychological
interviews into structured questionnaires spanning various psychiatric and
personality domains. The LLM is prompted to answer these questionnaires by
impersonating the interviewee. The obtained answers are coded as features,
which are used to predict standardized psychiatric measures of depression
(PHQ-8) and PTSD (PCL-C), using a Random Forest regressor. Our approach is
shown to enhance diagnostic accuracy compared to multiple baselines. It thus
establishes a novel framework for interpreting unstructured psychological
interviews, bridging the gap between narrative-driven and data-driven
approaches for mental health assessment.
|
[
-0.6121587753295898,
-0.839290201663971,
1.0674301385879517,
0.22476409375667572,
0.04196992143988609,
0.2888701856136322,
-0.09986007958650589,
-0.5029887557029724,
0.18420006334781647,
0.4296908378601074,
-0.8851383924484253,
-0.502309262752533,
-0.5788019299507141,
0.3052324652671814,
-0.4128018617630005,
0.9312703013420105,
-0.21728187799453735,
0.2137996107339859,
-0.2322404533624649,
0.21697112917900085,
-0.14942727982997894,
-0.7623056769371033,
-0.7891219258308411,
-0.42643094062805176,
0.379678338766098,
0.113677017390728,
0.6337490081787109,
0.43866539001464844,
0.6315271258354187,
0.30003345012664795,
0.0007903599762357771,
0.01211877353489399,
-0.360507994890213,
-0.005251939408481121,
-0.08149506151676178,
-0.2853142023086548,
-0.5119118094444275,
0.30169612169265747,
0.36969125270843506,
0.9844303131103516,
-0.32274383306503296,
0.5150939226150513,
0.1099754273891449,
0.009340675547719002,
-0.44268378615379333,
0.00958741083741188,
-0.16132806241512299,
0.3589775264263153,
0.015487980097532272,
-0.24266241490840912,
-0.31639355421066284,
-0.4685129225254059,
0.029005032032728195,
-0.30006515979766846,
0.29583317041397095,
-0.16251543164253235,
0.3880278766155243,
0.29911214113235474,
-0.5084365010261536,
-0.11148927360773087,
-1.0276052951812744,
0.47721949219703674,
-0.7059319019317627,
-0.0313820019364357,
0.7816317081451416,
0.3639272451400757,
-0.14515824615955353,
-0.5815907716751099,
-0.48008209466934204,
-0.24614636600017548,
-0.25479796528816223,
0.24784494936466217,
0.03426152095198631,
0.35186636447906494,
0.40916118025779724,
0.6727278828620911,
-0.5925512313842773,
0.3012661337852478,
-0.41631069779396057,
-0.10931205749511719,
0.9147122502326965,
0.6996263861656189,
0.35624703764915466,
-0.1647164523601532,
-0.19999578595161438,
0.24478866159915924,
-0.3303089141845703,
0.17054124176502228,
-0.00014216707495506853,
-0.10464966297149658,
0.08088652044534683,
0.7026672959327698,
-0.19328121840953827,
0.6150205731391907,
0.3538488745689392,
-0.4804735779762268,
0.029398655518889427,
-0.18571728467941284,
-0.3955787420272827,
0.10770890861749649,
0.7743602395057678,
0.6869664788246155,
0.09102341532707214,
-0.18587471544742584,
-0.28705301880836487,
0.10828930884599686,
0.3508233428001404,
-0.4807747006416321,
-0.22374500334262848,
0.808085560798645,
-0.5732336640357971,
-0.1354486048221588,
-0.13455311954021454,
-0.8408411741256714,
-0.5937621593475342,
-0.5184491276741028,
0.19611123204231262,
-0.2404499650001526,
-0.15070895850658417,
0.10176200419664383,
-0.0934988334774971,
0.23399916291236877,
0.4494784474372864,
-0.5035347938537598,
0.5787268877029419,
0.5013174414634705,
0.5978086590766907,
-0.4658743441104889,
-0.1185569018125534,
-0.32280993461608887,
0.15629012882709503,
-0.48453742265701294,
0.8340973258018494,
-0.4044184982776642,
-0.4084360599517822,
-0.15146875381469727,
0.1625225991010666,
-0.09419199079275131,
-0.5978607535362244,
0.31565845012664795,
-0.07590357214212418,
0.5105588436126709,
0.032229259610176086,
-0.7055538892745972,
-0.2667894959449768,
0.5265020132064819,
-0.42183718085289,
1.3265618085861206,
0.7260222434997559,
-0.644900381565094,
0.18393494188785553,
-0.49775615334510803,
0.16965867578983307,
0.16085253655910492,
-0.05136311799287796,
-0.009227271191775799,
0.16895557940006256,
0.1849241852760315,
0.6363133788108826,
-0.45358461141586304,
0.5392632484436035,
-0.5464202165603638,
-0.4048682451248169,
0.6764649152755737,
-0.22289839386940002,
0.7269724011421204,
-0.0016760678263381124,
0.05082882195711136,
0.12087652832269669,
-1.13257896900177,
0.1998412162065506,
-0.027316316962242126,
-0.4424521327018738,
-0.18012955784797668,
-0.09164641797542572,
0.19311365485191345,
0.3946166932582855,
0.34672272205352783,
-0.6438725590705872,
0.08002205938100815,
-0.3946813941001892,
0.22254030406475067,
0.5323251485824585,
0.392100989818573,
0.0882081612944603,
-0.5934057831764221,
0.9717414379119873,
-0.1043219044804573,
0.3038782775402069,
0.11242600530385971,
-0.40273913741111755,
-0.3575390577316284,
-0.6942184567451477,
-0.043064724653959274,
1.0653190612792969,
-0.05886209011077881,
0.8550297021865845,
0.11136245727539062,
-0.6543431282043457,
-0.5054421424865723,
0.10700596123933792,
0.35894879698753357,
0.5298882126808167,
0.2827836573123932,
-0.4275279641151428,
-0.7985231280326843,
-0.6112372875213623,
0.10831598937511444,
-0.057306136935949326,
-0.49145737290382385,
0.1873520463705063,
0.25898846983909607,
-0.3372924327850342,
0.8053699135780334,
-0.5242013931274414,
-0.26936331391334534,
-0.3889491856098175,
0.1606559306383133,
0.33687278628349304,
0.20954589545726776,
0.31527164578437805,
-0.3949236273765564,
-0.4823604226112366,
-0.31906673312187195,
-0.9362740516662598,
-0.30639728903770447,
0.0003498056612443179,
0.25170108675956726,
-0.19602826237678528,
0.44646045565605164,
-0.8838508129119873,
0.48775508999824524,
0.237517848610878,
-0.35031405091285706,
0.5104096531867981,
-0.1545903980731964,
0.24509882926940918,
-1.015259861946106,
-0.010288748890161514,
-0.14451254904270172,
-0.2479403167963028,
-0.597964882850647,
-0.05277151241898537,
-0.2823457717895508,
-0.32519540190696716,
-0.38442909717559814,
0.343442440032959,
-0.34966301918029785,
-0.15619581937789917,
0.0705016478896141,
0.27836430072784424,
-0.062168609350919724,
0.4708772599697113,
-0.17334216833114624,
0.5439944863319397,
0.5225003957748413,
-0.5175235271453857,
0.62754225730896,
0.22602544724941254,
-0.19642393290996552,
0.8353621959686279,
-0.4914787709712982,
0.10723604261875153,
-0.4652865529060364,
0.1790352165699005,
-1.4340873956680298,
-0.30964773893356323,
0.06913037598133087,
-0.29369181394577026,
0.1423228532075882,
0.30323514342308044,
-0.3453781008720398,
-0.4877336621284485,
-0.3447912931442261,
0.4076746106147766,
0.4621775448322296,
-0.0731733962893486,
0.4415922164916992,
0.3151381015777588,
-0.414153516292572,
-0.19360986351966858,
-0.5769249796867371,
0.04956511780619621,
-0.7091161012649536,
-0.1895974576473236,
0.3124951720237732,
-0.37210941314697266,
-0.537225067615509,
-0.2261817753314972,
0.1787029206752777,
-0.3578234314918518,
0.1498173028230667,
0.2724291980266571,
0.45732173323631287,
-0.31332340836524963,
-0.16296754777431488,
-0.3019862174987793,
-0.003139424603432417,
0.3216714859008789,
0.287643700838089,
0.6497292518615723,
0.25276774168014526,
-0.3503105938434601,
-0.7422072291374207,
0.6608859896659851,
0.6996796727180481,
-0.013523383066058159,
0.3757013976573944,
0.3446118235588074,
-0.5393663048744202,
0.19531148672103882,
-0.5866509079933167,
0.0019160853698849678,
-0.3596215844154358,
0.30421027541160583,
-0.36599069833755493,
-0.9898072481155396,
0.6593098640441895,
-0.10885965824127197,
-0.2929355502128601,
0.2711532413959503,
0.6539990305900574,
-0.31829264760017395,
1.4428104162216187,
0.6139982342720032,
0.07816648483276367,
0.017031360417604446,
0.03009146824479103,
0.3111065924167633,
-0.8743754029273987,
-0.24198442697525024,
-0.34034428000450134,
-0.23682771623134613,
-0.5119727253913879,
-0.3618204891681671,
0.41257357597351074,
0.20852483808994293,
-0.4948173463344574,
-0.09685157984495163,
-0.652850866317749,
0.17414306104183197,
0.1903298944234848,
0.1979982554912567,
0.39268049597740173,
-0.2881513833999634,
0.110077865421772,
-0.3067057728767395,
-0.1731819361448288,
-0.5853058099746704,
1.1619876623153687,
0.48845037817955017,
0.5802238583564758,
0.003944879397749901,
0.7015085816383362,
0.32894259691238403,
0.7208437919616699,
-0.9633342623710632,
0.4795488119125366,
0.17879365384578705,
-0.39464670419692993,
-0.4207550883293152,
0.013021295890212059,
-0.5946224331855774,
0.06296643614768982,
-0.042351655662059784,
-1.138518214225769,
0.2614766061306,
-0.23188310861587524,
-0.6474708914756775,
-0.1219959408044815,
-0.440860778093338,
0.656067430973053,
-0.33566975593566895,
0.47476497292518616,
-0.09442328661680222,
-0.45104581117630005,
0.6254949569702148,
-0.48139461874961853,
0.028796201571822166,
-0.2946503758430481,
-0.16395293176174164,
0.7984082102775574,
-0.3432428240776062,
0.8282902836799622,
-0.21412216126918793,
-0.06287704408168793,
0.01794515550136566,
0.2496047019958496,
0.16849786043167114,
0.22751407325267792,
-0.055852219462394714,
-0.18772338330745697,
0.5566327571868896,
-0.09840593487024307,
-1.081775188446045,
0.1002572700381279,
-0.9858844876289368,
-0.6259320378303528,
-0.42432498931884766,
-0.8111625909805298,
-0.6264964938163757,
-0.02187025547027588,
0.09444703161716461,
0.18966740369796753,
-0.5699291229248047,
-0.20843754708766937,
0.639240026473999,
-0.36472517251968384,
0.20380234718322754,
0.8808798789978027,
-0.37056875228881836,
-0.46770063042640686,
0.15765167772769928,
0.10429055243730545,
0.14755484461784363,
0.4132477343082428,
0.053039319813251495,
-0.2674369513988495,
-0.5101983547210693,
0.10857373476028442,
0.3547680675983429,
-0.6154419183731079,
-0.16469456255435944,
-0.6853318810462952,
-0.5492653250694275,
-0.5611803531646729,
-0.04996201768517494,
-0.15866915881633759,
-0.43562474846839905,
-0.12699098885059357,
-0.630266010761261,
0.44425666332244873,
0.7817504405975342,
0.025358356535434723,
0.39152219891548157,
-0.6553375720977783,
0.5132547616958618,
0.13946783542633057,
0.0611344538629055,
-0.22174182534217834,
-0.5236610770225525,
0.174933061003685,
-0.08700782805681229,
-0.25876742601394653,
-1.0257408618927002,
0.6440216898918152,
0.2867066264152527,
0.48646044731140137,
0.5376033186912537,
0.010215663351118565,
0.9310864806175232,
-0.4057863652706146,
0.8104564547538757,
0.2320144772529602,
-0.6860253214836121,
0.7099223136901855,
-0.2140910029411316,
0.08496728539466858,
0.5448471903800964,
0.8853542804718018,
-0.6855965256690979,
-0.7047731280326843,
-0.7229864597320557,
-0.5913379788398743,
0.5627805590629578,
-0.37595340609550476,
-0.24347537755966187,
-0.2553688585758209,
0.46552538871765137,
-0.11665184050798416,
0.09360981732606888,
-0.4785926342010498,
-0.18145252764225006,
-0.046041090041399,
-0.4730106294155121,
-0.5515241026878357,
-0.6515445709228516,
-0.517645537853241,
-0.5665366649627686,
0.13961029052734375,
-0.027849936857819557,
0.46157965064048767,
0.47379404306411743,
0.0716606080532074,
-0.1707126498222351,
0.3154846131801605,
0.2219574749469757,
0.8721119165420532,
-0.5458469390869141,
0.13200174272060394,
0.19810687005519867,
-0.34323248267173767,
0.4634837210178375,
0.1814069151878357,
0.059041645377874374,
0.05500481650233269,
0.12272123247385025,
0.30004146695137024,
-0.04865052551031113,
-0.9391506910324097,
0.49047109484672546,
-0.11099506914615631,
-0.3081328570842743,
-0.7793133854866028,
-0.07264258712530136,
0.12775181233882904,
0.33557817339897156,
0.28804370760917664,
-0.41753944754600525,
0.39577367901802063,
-0.6810652613639832,
0.3993758261203766,
0.1896340698003769,
-0.4549625515937805,
-0.13603878021240234,
0.4406173527240753,
-0.38394713401794434,
-0.3882470428943634,
0.9052692651748657,
0.044803522527217865,
-0.21599501371383667,
0.6636858582496643,
0.6972416043281555,
0.766078531742096,
-0.5070168972015381,
0.41444697976112366,
0.23986513912677765,
0.21245744824409485,
-0.21315565705299377,
0.6210826635360718,
0.07287687808275223,
-0.7079324722290039,
-0.48640426993370056,
-0.8689395785331726,
-0.453790545463562,
0.5074111819267273,
-0.9876834154129028,
-0.08511260896921158,
-0.8034375309944153,
-0.14436696469783783,
-0.247834712266922,
0.02176962047815323,
-0.5116175413131714,
0.7265865802764893,
0.23788680136203766,
0.8764849901199341,
-0.923870325088501,
0.7166630029678345,
0.7133881449699402,
-0.4485573470592499,
-0.9446815848350525,
-0.3072725832462311,
0.10735820233821869,
-0.7471755146980286,
0.47074419260025024,
-0.0731334462761879,
0.35930225253105164,
-0.12671300768852234,
-0.28684577345848083,
-1.0423933267593384,
1.1674964427947998,
0.4081096649169922,
-0.27114540338516235,
-0.1668112874031067,
0.5245869159698486,
0.8247864246368408,
-0.5321744084358215,
0.3999362885951996,
0.7658206224441528,
0.44789737462997437,
-0.06313276290893555,
-1.1205871105194092,
0.18222837150096893,
-0.3340957462787628,
0.24261018633842468,
0.021037140861153603,
-0.13576801121234894,
0.8099848628044128,
0.06365154683589935,
-0.06083711236715317,
0.13679319620132446,
0.3835071921348572,
0.4803566038608551,
0.23018759489059448,
0.26198646426200867,
0.6548659205436707,
1.1937741041183472,
0.10272573679685593,
0.9700759649276733,
-0.5743822455406189,
0.2821652889251709,
1.0859501361846924,
-0.37670424580574036,
0.9029573798179626,
0.37296733260154724,
-0.47443005442619324,
0.3335658013820648,
1.1611037254333496,
-0.15368570387363434,
0.16324147582054138,
0.355895072221756,
-0.3700880706310272,
-0.20351554453372955,
-0.22627462446689606,
-0.07366783171892166,
0.5661126375198364,
0.6352816224098206,
-0.34089428186416626,
-0.2717481255531311,
0.3013419210910797,
-0.05668791010975838,
0.06519902497529984,
-0.36940374970436096,
0.7330543994903564,
0.2466806024312973,
-0.6270496249198914,
0.6215662360191345,
0.13879434764385223,
0.48958802223205566,
-0.5347814559936523,
0.17875853180885315,
-0.38674062490463257,
0.1332334280014038,
-0.39191725850105286,
-0.8655911684036255,
0.7153156995773315,
-0.010033543221652508,
-0.37654998898506165,
-0.4209752678871155,
0.5767137408256531,
-0.4550989270210266,
-0.5784286260604858,
0.3101412355899811,
0.7943892478942871,
0.4412034749984741,
-0.13063842058181763,
-0.7504506707191467,
-0.39004242420196533,
-0.38926494121551514,
-0.22901763021945953,
0.5664190649986267,
0.5202565789222717,
-0.08500109612941742,
0.8388909697532654,
0.20222869515419006,
0.2828860282897949,
-0.05022219941020012,
0.058999285101890564,
0.42914095520973206,
-0.8551689982414246,
-0.37672364711761475,
-0.7356163263320923,
0.3184279501438141,
0.18553119897842407,
-0.1919652372598648,
0.6723372936248779,
0.6053575277328491,
0.6756346225738525,
-0.07275446504354477,
0.832733690738678,
-0.012921546585857868,
0.9217339754104614,
-0.32316210865974426,
0.5527408123016357,
-0.4206078052520752,
-0.0837906002998352,
-0.18327908217906952,
-0.8227080702781677,
-0.23704147338867188,
0.5275045037269592,
-0.17892533540725708,
-0.23744116723537445,
1.026229977607727,
0.8451064229011536,
-0.0276112649589777,
-0.25225570797920227,
0.4125804603099823,
0.32927560806274414,
0.09029463678598404,
0.7768672704696655,
1.0491801500320435,
-0.13316303491592407,
0.10704182088375092,
-0.3204699456691742,
-0.35711026191711426,
0.4091777205467224,
-0.503075122833252,
-0.7820642590522766,
-0.45103898644447327,
-0.5442292094230652,
-0.33713340759277344,
-0.12791945040225983,
0.8301519751548767,
0.26596131920814514,
-0.6928683519363403,
-0.4952099323272705,
0.3310774266719818,
-0.17552249133586884,
-0.31424611806869507,
-0.37510770559310913,
0.2759098410606384,
-0.07614540308713913,
-0.48187747597694397,
0.33960679173469543,
0.49155524373054504,
-0.003941958770155907,
-0.5887110829353333,
0.26002296805381775,
-0.08682101964950562,
0.1120910793542862,
0.5056219696998596,
0.045153629034757614,
-0.8486772775650024,
-0.27554458379745483,
-0.1748274266719818,
-0.1800338178873062,
0.26683494448661804,
0.8075048327445984,
-0.7305891513824463,
0.010581329464912415,
0.3294411599636078,
0.5128008127212524,
0.24828171730041504,
0.21955004334449768,
0.8306719064712524,
-0.41384071111679077,
0.08996477723121643,
0.3292590379714966,
0.17021703720092773,
0.3340134024620056,
-0.8638368248939514,
0.3811199963092804,
0.17533276975154877,
-0.3953421711921692,
-0.9141202569007874,
0.10127279907464981,
-1.0918339490890503,
-0.1574392169713974,
0.9756377339363098,
-0.3475370407104492,
-0.19144921004772186,
-0.5875008702278137,
-0.23239284753799438,
0.07381624728441238,
0.12924470007419586,
0.9086782932281494,
0.681969404220581,
-0.5824071168899536,
-0.6307999491691589,
-0.5161222219467163,
0.714483916759491,
0.0717896968126297,
-0.6820207834243774,
-0.21676215529441833,
0.4974781572818756,
0.43346941471099854,
-0.03960806876420975,
1.2173974514007568,
-0.27000150084495544,
0.32756519317626953,
-0.40702036023139954,
0.13186603784561157,
0.37170153856277466,
0.08199051767587662,
-0.2944486141204834,
0.3453240692615509,
0.16933293640613556,
0.23715932667255402
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.05690v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.05690v1
|
MoPS: Modular Story Premise Synthesis for Open-Ended Automatic Story Generation
| 2024-06-09T08:31:14 | 2024-06-09T08:31:14 |
Yan Ma, Yu Qiao, Pengfei Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
A story premise succinctly defines a story's main idea, foundation, and
trajectory. It serves as the initial trigger in automatic story generation.
Existing sources of story premises are limited by a lack of diversity, uneven
quality, and high costs that make them difficult to scale. In response, we
introduce Modular Story Premise Synthesis (MoPS) which breaks down story
premises into modules like background and persona for automated design and
generation. MoPS consists of three phases: (1) Precollect a consistent set of
candidates for each module to form a nested dictionary. (2) Extract a key path
from the nested dictionary as the premise design. (3) Instruct an LLM to
integrate the design into a coherent premise sentence. Thorough evaluations
demonstrate that our synthesized premises excel in diversity, fascination,
completeness, and originality compared to those induced from large language
models and captured from public story datasets. Similarly, the extended novels
and scripts generated from our premises also exhibit higher quality. In
supplementary materials, we provide the MoPS code suite, along with 7.6k
generated premises and 1k extended stories. Code:
https://github.com/GAIR-NLP/MoPS.
|
[
-0.3098757565021515,
-0.5034226775169373,
0.8064193725585938,
0.41294580698013306,
-0.19559112191200256,
-0.0021372525952756405,
0.10503483563661575,
-0.28234025835990906,
0.36107122898101807,
0.8572929501533508,
-0.7269415855407715,
-0.4439548850059509,
-0.055804502218961716,
0.13943438231945038,
-0.2911657691001892,
0.9874998927116394,
-0.24817480146884918,
-0.4632684886455536,
-0.422947496175766,
0.04904591292142868,
-0.20994585752487183,
-0.3794286847114563,
0.014467358589172363,
-0.022980354726314545,
0.2477894127368927,
0.36498531699180603,
0.39889025688171387,
0.8125187158584595,
0.23320241272449493,
0.18438179790973663,
0.15156030654907227,
0.4092538058757782,
-0.17118771374225616,
0.49845772981643677,
0.07166162878274918,
-0.18773983418941498,
-0.4896935224533081,
0.11243642866611481,
0.5083662867546082,
0.6035669445991516,
-0.10221586376428604,
0.4302634596824646,
0.044552095234394073,
0.8347396850585938,
-0.6795924305915833,
0.0812823623418808,
-0.3879437744617462,
0.24761009216308594,
-0.04350754991173744,
-0.38246336579322815,
-0.4897994101047516,
-0.33159130811691284,
0.12273561209440231,
-0.41431525349617004,
0.44195833802223206,
-0.03618534654378891,
0.596229076385498,
-0.1091689020395279,
-0.4866836369037628,
-0.5045834183692932,
-0.6213451623916626,
0.4357662796974182,
-0.6359784603118896,
-0.20338687300682068,
0.08700469881296158,
0.02792782336473465,
-0.18749043345451355,
-0.7553131580352783,
-0.6118773221969604,
-0.4994202256202698,
-0.15297538042068481,
0.133763387799263,
-0.09816692024469376,
-0.02345822937786579,
0.3300674259662628,
0.6436013579368591,
-0.45101189613342285,
-0.4469727873802185,
-0.26254311203956604,
-0.002805362455546856,
0.6326590776443481,
0.49389612674713135,
0.4035792946815491,
-0.5291041731834412,
-0.5164871215820312,
0.019628746435046196,
-0.7469679117202759,
0.40175485610961914,
0.7309796810150146,
0.1366938352584839,
0.10618044435977936,
0.8727988600730896,
-0.42414265871047974,
0.6351130604743958,
0.18599873781204224,
-0.3288021981716156,
0.3513951599597931,
-0.6555814146995544,
-0.15860845148563385,
-0.20417892932891846,
0.8331000804901123,
0.5370792746543884,
-0.03136439621448517,
0.11109941452741623,
-0.38908421993255615,
-0.15374960005283356,
0.38603928685188293,
-0.5313619375228882,
0.007085175719112158,
0.40245798230171204,
-0.527309775352478,
-0.6288724541664124,
0.033221688121557236,
-0.566245973110199,
-0.38703176379203796,
-0.3572074770927429,
0.20059600472450256,
-0.4433606266975403,
-0.11718326061964035,
0.11471708118915558,
-0.45302537083625793,
0.20750218629837036,
0.0957418903708458,
-0.989345908164978,
0.43549221754074097,
0.43748390674591064,
0.9527130722999573,
-0.2996280789375305,
-0.41111069917678833,
-0.42616721987724304,
0.7023502588272095,
-0.49713876843452454,
0.7779070734977722,
-0.24663200974464417,
-0.5776348114013672,
0.07114114612340927,
-0.44052234292030334,
0.11424444615840912,
-0.5815611481666565,
0.5416218638420105,
-0.12910515069961548,
0.36324676871299744,
0.07226954400539398,
-0.3715977668762207,
0.15383972227573395,
0.16802866756916046,
-0.5439521670341492,
0.751261293888092,
0.07558553665876389,
-0.3718007504940033,
0.17313578724861145,
-0.7210610508918762,
-0.9814430475234985,
-0.1776188462972641,
-0.07531997561454773,
-0.07406499981880188,
0.4701102375984192,
0.5310627818107605,
0.22463363409042358,
-0.10620341449975967,
0.39507222175598145,
0.069761261343956,
0.28504201769828796,
0.025891106575727463,
0.0011000552913174033,
0.9667795300483704,
0.2557421028614044,
-0.16076748073101044,
0.1794515997171402,
-1.0511934757232666,
0.12192262709140778,
0.09966078400611877,
-0.33994778990745544,
-0.09996297955513,
0.2668730318546295,
-0.12399539351463318,
0.17792892456054688,
0.30919408798217773,
-0.3959318697452545,
0.36275553703308105,
-0.4081724286079407,
0.48105108737945557,
0.5396377444267273,
0.27815544605255127,
0.5556298494338989,
-0.6697936654090881,
0.7597341537475586,
-0.1552053987979889,
0.10043471306562424,
-0.8474469184875488,
-0.7285848259925842,
-0.6787496209144592,
-0.26683908700942993,
-0.16766172647476196,
0.4292325973510742,
-0.5784766674041748,
0.6778390407562256,
0.007641605567187071,
-0.4453417956829071,
-0.02756546624004841,
-0.121073879301548,
0.19232049584388733,
0.5729823112487793,
0.15070690214633942,
-0.30138981342315674,
-0.7978793978691101,
-0.9436243176460266,
-0.1668863594532013,
-0.2727124094963074,
-0.4559939503669739,
0.05753403902053833,
0.4631630480289459,
0.051430534571409225,
1.424872636795044,
-0.8460066318511963,
-0.42916905879974365,
-0.41373705863952637,
0.13616809248924255,
0.23806160688400269,
0.4408814013004303,
0.5566352605819702,
-0.6485450267791748,
-0.4034263789653778,
-0.21737724542617798,
-0.4888664484024048,
-0.3902481496334076,
-0.2327612340450287,
-0.11282071471214294,
0.12594227492809296,
0.2705569863319397,
-0.9385507106781006,
0.33189621567726135,
0.4580758512020111,
-0.1630447506904602,
1.025233507156372,
-0.0887574553489685,
0.23609741032123566,
-1.4531041383743286,
0.004554559011012316,
-0.35770317912101746,
-0.03809366375207901,
-0.4621654748916626,
0.3652982711791992,
-0.26501184701919556,
-0.5536825656890869,
-0.3186143636703491,
0.5678516030311584,
-0.5579952597618103,
-0.07494481652975082,
-0.05578356981277466,
-0.013833394274115562,
0.26731789112091064,
0.5977883338928223,
0.05163615569472313,
0.5852974057197571,
0.15036432445049286,
-0.5887340307235718,
0.4447007477283478,
0.38854631781578064,
-0.4335213005542755,
0.32047951221466064,
-0.5861563086509705,
0.10382236540317535,
0.3694015443325043,
0.63126140832901,
-0.9673673510551453,
-0.49862539768218994,
0.20367643237113953,
-0.4426017105579376,
-0.24640975892543793,
-0.3214753270149231,
-0.6838590502738953,
-0.2688632607460022,
-0.2514885365962982,
-0.14516153931617737,
0.6977061033248901,
-0.347419410943985,
0.7005342245101929,
0.5079344511032104,
-0.3770587146282196,
-0.023440949618816376,
-0.6895246505737305,
0.35362952947616577,
0.035744406282901764,
-0.8957948088645935,
0.36835578083992004,
-0.20285412669181824,
-0.4034322500228882,
0.03461656719446182,
-0.07309699803590775,
-0.26481592655181885,
-0.3018300235271454,
0.22299890220165253,
0.050100427120923996,
-0.43148112297058105,
-0.2165919840335846,
0.24072034657001495,
-0.2820301055908203,
0.09611855447292328,
-0.7145213484764099,
0.47455379366874695,
0.041619133204221725,
-0.32429808378219604,
-0.05906788632273674,
0.6708424091339111,
0.7537883520126343,
-0.21266162395477295,
0.23074711859226227,
0.1352774053812027,
-0.34071776270866394,
-0.41624993085861206,
-0.21023361384868622,
0.3548303246498108,
-0.5020068287849426,
0.06734516471624374,
-0.5651764869689941,
-0.5028476119041443,
0.40182438492774963,
0.24525582790374756,
0.45571741461753845,
0.5849564671516418,
0.8318784832954407,
-0.10357826203107834,
0.8412923812866211,
0.7472473382949829,
0.4192742705345154,
0.3217208981513977,
0.025197535753250122,
0.16629430651664734,
-0.5973102450370789,
-0.07959231734275818,
-0.1780848652124405,
-0.32174474000930786,
-0.0978350043296814,
-0.503864049911499,
0.34846609830856323,
-0.08215554803609848,
0.2677570581436157,
0.4703846275806427,
-0.35568031668663025,
0.7603684663772583,
0.7048328518867493,
-0.05841631069779396,
0.5986661314964294,
0.1367209404706955,
-0.3504064083099365,
-0.006273724138736725,
-0.5084259510040283,
-0.7845404148101807,
1.076925277709961,
0.19223885238170624,
0.3664648234844208,
0.19010628759860992,
0.885481595993042,
0.2964543402194977,
-0.04743807762861252,
-0.6963250637054443,
0.7839841246604919,
-0.1441381871700287,
-0.7378106713294983,
-0.0672152116894722,
-0.15921805799007416,
-0.5560833811759949,
0.16098067164421082,
-0.008573142811655998,
-0.5633238554000854,
0.2848299741744995,
0.12976494431495667,
-0.5437427759170532,
0.17040827870368958,
-0.9511540532112122,
0.540793240070343,
-0.1178116649389267,
-0.0032248676288872957,
-0.17002874612808228,
-0.6539473533630371,
0.6815526485443115,
-0.06316173821687698,
-0.06079608574509621,
-0.0306981410831213,
-0.19003376364707947,
0.5536066889762878,
-0.6753761768341064,
0.7158567905426025,
0.07972977310419083,
-0.193845734000206,
0.6926286220550537,
0.2322804033756256,
0.2703390121459961,
0.14900724589824677,
0.022597458213567734,
-0.15693359076976776,
-0.19721174240112305,
-0.2597784101963043,
-0.40389782190322876,
0.3580200970172882,
-0.28397640585899353,
-0.687163233757019,
-0.16128864884376526,
-0.8396609425544739,
-0.4727301299571991,
0.2863551080226898,
0.29211947321891785,
0.7643338441848755,
-0.35700660943984985,
0.22405128180980682,
0.47330328822135925,
-0.11556641757488251,
0.4481315612792969,
0.2983701825141907,
-0.40740057826042175,
-0.7267569899559021,
0.693681538105011,
-0.14361527562141418,
0.5532339811325073,
0.47666090726852417,
0.2596026062965393,
0.02236848697066307,
-0.8230750560760498,
-0.4588127136230469,
-0.36848512291908264,
-0.5931656956672668,
0.0790906697511673,
-0.8808886408805847,
-0.4101813733577728,
-0.6587503552436829,
-0.5018230080604553,
-0.15164518356323242,
-0.6869661211967468,
-0.09184443950653076,
-0.15640011429786682,
-0.0004725804610643536,
0.7885499596595764,
-0.22803285717964172,
0.1235148087143898,
-0.9660596251487732,
0.8026728630065918,
0.3647012710571289,
-0.050718069076538086,
-0.2805677354335785,
-0.19840584695339203,
-0.16365256905555725,
-0.0751236081123352,
-0.5706363916397095,
-0.7881596684455872,
0.5886462330818176,
0.09089480340480804,
0.45349231362342834,
0.4164726436138153,
0.15936678647994995,
0.5491847991943359,
-0.9873734712600708,
1.0085941553115845,
0.3524932861328125,
-0.885370135307312,
0.9391394257545471,
-0.883175253868103,
0.19337831437587738,
0.3907523453235626,
0.18908002972602844,
-0.2841204106807709,
-0.42390498518943787,
-0.7755005359649658,
-0.9754677414894104,
0.6161206364631653,
0.5826690196990967,
0.25833839178085327,
-0.03379054740071297,
0.09086119383573532,
0.3268503248691559,
0.5038831830024719,
-0.6812540292739868,
-0.18203072249889374,
-0.0856410339474678,
-0.2637978494167328,
-0.04811379685997963,
-0.483776718378067,
-0.4985271096229553,
-0.14368611574172974,
0.4326667785644531,
-0.10187035799026489,
0.20930437743663788,
0.23277302086353302,
-0.16106243431568146,
-0.16290923953056335,
0.1430870145559311,
0.7544344067573547,
0.8472497463226318,
-0.22168909013271332,
-0.08997198939323425,
-0.26082101464271545,
-0.5837874412536621,
0.28806784749031067,
0.0008106852183118463,
-0.4952634871006012,
0.23979069292545319,
0.5341695547103882,
0.6953751444816589,
-0.04239591211080551,
-0.7780637741088867,
0.3362595736980438,
0.13605943322181702,
-0.3220973610877991,
-0.35210880637168884,
0.3454064726829529,
0.06205188110470772,
0.2759321331977844,
0.5968086123466492,
0.3048664927482605,
0.023192930966615677,
-0.8177392482757568,
0.47270888090133667,
0.07728221267461777,
0.07109023630619049,
-0.29753589630126953,
0.48023998737335205,
0.5822889804840088,
-0.532325267791748,
0.18465179204940796,
-0.20724545419216156,
-0.26976603269577026,
0.7173507809638977,
0.620914876461029,
1.2603715658187866,
0.2266683429479599,
0.4535858929157257,
0.2040611356496811,
0.5414616465568542,
0.06996458023786545,
-0.06115736812353134,
-0.0784420520067215,
-0.5782409310340881,
-0.3534001410007477,
-0.8007614016532898,
-0.6539361476898193,
0.06853834539651871,
-0.4702146053314209,
0.49372148513793945,
-0.5492373108863831,
0.33631524443626404,
-0.3901689946651459,
-0.07051807641983032,
0.09724365919828415,
0.1419934779405594,
0.3694396913051605,
0.9443871378898621,
-0.6352183818817139,
0.46681496500968933,
0.7165538668632507,
-0.5103200674057007,
-0.3770082890987396,
0.5917872190475464,
0.05792136490345001,
-0.5858829617500305,
0.37618234753608704,
0.08461354672908783,
0.023552266880869865,
0.12738722562789917,
-0.40967878699302673,
-0.716987133026123,
1.0261170864105225,
0.27269935607910156,
-0.27607056498527527,
-0.3930724859237671,
0.24004626274108887,
0.5134408473968506,
-0.9237578511238098,
-0.3765929043292999,
0.24329525232315063,
0.12141625583171844,
0.24715086817741394,
-0.6221020221710205,
-0.0990503802895546,
-0.2774238884449005,
-0.2412407398223877,
-0.08713754266500473,
-0.3097575604915619,
0.8361926674842834,
-0.45345544815063477,
-0.1379389613866806,
0.5074648857116699,
0.6106405258178711,
0.6162088513374329,
0.36467623710632324,
0.5064066052436829,
0.5943305492401123,
0.4772582948207855,
0.0909726619720459,
1.083754301071167,
-0.1377028226852417,
0.07152655720710754,
1.1697789430618286,
-0.2911793887615204,
0.8413329720497131,
0.4091694951057434,
-0.22484639286994934,
0.6711289882659912,
0.5718257427215576,
0.08327239751815796,
0.5707113146781921,
-0.015236634761095047,
-0.16384656727313995,
-0.12383983284235,
0.18508654832839966,
-0.37089619040489197,
0.08577847480773926,
0.1725286841392517,
-0.30921441316604614,
-0.2742581367492676,
-0.05950420722365379,
-0.42010852694511414,
0.004099436104297638,
0.04812496900558472,
0.5122511386871338,
0.07402604073286057,
-0.6784494519233704,
0.07995353639125824,
-0.072669118642807,
0.16427075862884521,
-1.0038992166519165,
0.12354204058647156,
-0.2125825434923172,
-0.07038729637861252,
-0.12966206669807434,
-1.0355849266052246,
0.31578800082206726,
0.05446089059114456,
-0.648684024810791,
-0.8178683519363403,
0.7007830142974854,
-0.3767726421356201,
-0.4037418067455292,
-0.35326507687568665,
0.5393103361129761,
-0.2208225429058075,
-0.10852786898612976,
-0.4370233416557312,
-0.4158287048339844,
0.12521609663963318,
-0.5015143156051636,
0.20671702921390533,
0.6265138983726501,
0.23631234467029572,
0.47479063272476196,
0.9820526838302612,
-0.009936806745827198,
0.02783147618174553,
-0.24387499690055847,
0.704229474067688,
-0.6919223070144653,
-0.9312625527381897,
-0.684823751449585,
0.86737459897995,
-0.07279603183269501,
-0.6833826303482056,
0.6602743268013,
0.6612347960472107,
0.5198668241500854,
-0.38479968905448914,
1.012387752532959,
-0.45012831687927246,
0.2349550575017929,
-0.8168588280677795,
0.557158887386322,
-0.4394456446170807,
0.2114083468914032,
-0.27376997470855713,
-0.9990897178649902,
-0.153829425573349,
0.32329657673835754,
0.038276057690382004,
-0.3717079162597656,
1.09933602809906,
0.4341219663619995,
-0.005669783800840378,
-0.038829319179058075,
0.266818642616272,
0.13938739895820618,
0.37656766176223755,
0.44343727827072144,
1.0590221881866455,
-0.0701538473367691,
0.7286943793296814,
-0.18766964972019196,
-0.24966897070407867,
-0.0928930714726448,
-1.0662171840667725,
-0.8117470145225525,
-0.722132682800293,
-0.2167917639017105,
-0.2912338078022003,
-0.16143248975276947,
0.694187581539154,
0.5291781425476074,
-0.7296655178070068,
-0.3713195323944092,
-0.3449731767177582,
0.08417721092700958,
-0.19976601004600525,
-0.26078760623931885,
-0.07021832466125488,
-0.4359879195690155,
-0.5895586013793945,
0.6354504823684692,
0.5162641406059265,
-0.16953498125076294,
-0.47965866327285767,
0.041546571999788284,
-0.1802782565355301,
0.2578853964805603,
0.6529667377471924,
0.15228047966957092,
-0.6352674961090088,
0.013930294662714005,
-0.046290889382362366,
-0.13628186285495758,
0.1307404488325119,
1.378760576248169,
-0.728405773639679,
0.30242082476615906,
0.7510812282562256,
0.4384017586708069,
0.14165303111076355,
-0.0670752003788948,
1.2330549955368042,
-1.03192138671875,
0.17920124530792236,
0.37541139125823975,
0.5054181814193726,
-0.030573494732379913,
-0.20964060723781586,
0.6517871022224426,
0.6122086644172668,
-0.24205757677555084,
-0.8565682172775269,
0.6277197599411011,
-1.0278568267822266,
-0.2550288140773773,
1.2873716354370117,
-0.011257852427661419,
-0.22506044805049896,
-0.023250237107276917,
-0.4360605776309967,
-0.23791195452213287,
-0.1699138581752777,
0.5045989155769348,
0.8499701023101807,
-0.32586872577667236,
0.2020701766014099,
-0.5056310892105103,
0.31790268421173096,
0.00909107644110918,
-0.956376314163208,
0.18522240221500397,
0.9133008122444153,
0.11845123022794724,
0.45168450474739075,
0.8158211708068848,
-0.12825138866901398,
0.3005865514278412,
0.3476771116256714,
0.2083788812160492,
-0.37089526653289795,
-0.35455405712127686,
0.043267782777547836,
0.6047822833061218,
-0.48303040862083435,
-0.2387067675590515
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.05688v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.05688v1
|
Peer Review as A Multi-Turn and Long-Context Dialogue with Role-Based Interactions
| 2024-06-09T08:24:17 | 2024-06-09T08:24:17 |
Cheng Tan, Dongxin Lyu, Siyuan Li, Zhangyang Gao, Jingxuan Wei, Siqi Ma, Zicheng Liu, Stan Z. Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated wide-ranging applications
across various fields and have shown significant potential in the academic
peer-review process. However, existing applications are primarily limited to
static review generation based on submitted papers, which fail to capture the
dynamic and iterative nature of real-world peer reviews. In this paper, we
reformulate the peer-review process as a multi-turn, long-context dialogue,
incorporating distinct roles for authors, reviewers, and decision makers. We
construct a comprehensive dataset containing over 26,841 papers with 92,017
reviews collected from multiple sources, including the top-tier conference and
prestigious journal. This dataset is meticulously designed to facilitate the
applications of LLMs for multi-turn dialogues, effectively simulating the
complete peer-review process. Furthermore, we propose a series of metrics to
evaluate the performance of LLMs for each role under this reformulated
peer-review setting, ensuring fair and comprehensive evaluations. We believe
this work provides a promising perspective on enhancing the LLM-driven
peer-review process by incorporating dynamic, role-based interactions. It
aligns closely with the iterative and interactive nature of real-world academic
peer review, offering a robust foundation for future research and development
in this area. We open-source the dataset at
https://github.com/chengtan9907/ReviewMT.
|
[
-0.21457348763942719,
-0.5731414556503296,
0.8217791318893433,
0.2906738221645355,
-0.2380610555410385,
0.11678756028413773,
-0.4686310887336731,
-0.3829405903816223,
0.23184461891651154,
0.4491811692714691,
-0.5972122550010681,
-0.40294042229652405,
-0.5536929368972778,
0.2890792191028595,
-0.4626257121562958,
1.1358391046524048,
-0.05859164893627167,
0.5362709164619446,
-0.0380156934261322,
-0.03265676647424698,
-0.27481144666671753,
-0.3554445505142212,
-0.37198057770729065,
-0.6435751914978027,
0.6843204498291016,
0.12377387285232544,
0.5158950686454773,
-0.1814432591199875,
0.41222888231277466,
0.3154144883155823,
-0.31431710720062256,
0.21384434401988983,
-0.6241899132728577,
0.31665104627609253,
-0.19636648893356323,
-0.12501533329486847,
-0.7380821704864502,
0.340427428483963,
0.9615249633789062,
0.5154945254325867,
-0.3370349407196045,
0.11681991815567017,
0.29921406507492065,
0.6039895415306091,
-0.2131839543581009,
0.4124012887477875,
-0.5101045370101929,
0.15250778198242188,
-0.09233883768320084,
-0.08899226039648056,
-0.5779034495353699,
-0.36548224091529846,
0.14010882377624512,
-0.38057616353034973,
-0.21979191899299622,
-0.1160629540681839,
0.40470564365386963,
-0.24585473537445068,
-0.5475329756736755,
-0.2991134524345398,
-0.8949277997016907,
0.7306564450263977,
-0.7838702201843262,
0.32837942242622375,
0.009049874730408192,
0.39105942845344543,
-0.24711129069328308,
-0.6066104173660278,
-0.6224259734153748,
-0.14845547080039978,
-0.02271682769060135,
0.07414299249649048,
0.4290774464607239,
0.11672308295965195,
0.016865583136677742,
0.3937252163887024,
0.04420849680900574,
0.015618489123880863,
-0.4557400345802307,
0.12518210709095,
0.776687502861023,
0.3035663366317749,
-0.2104935646057129,
-0.1601855307817459,
-0.28906768560409546,
-0.1868012547492981,
-0.7486017942428589,
0.4201483428478241,
0.3998839259147644,
0.4702114760875702,
0.008735239505767822,
0.3948531448841095,
-0.21133410930633545,
0.4276179373264313,
-0.01940394751727581,
-0.2715378999710083,
0.21740657091140747,
-0.6870416402816772,
-0.11433711647987366,
-0.17393481731414795,
0.9558984041213989,
0.4409539997577667,
0.27356210350990295,
0.07653605192899704,
-0.3743795156478882,
-0.28541627526283264,
0.35720956325531006,
-1.002569556236267,
0.2516917288303375,
0.41424301266670227,
-0.6280254125595093,
-0.5160953998565674,
0.22202536463737488,
-0.8766452670097351,
-0.4638664424419403,
-0.579688310623169,
0.21185870468616486,
0.03126441314816475,
-0.22468292713165283,
0.28314879536628723,
0.36285462975502014,
0.21798503398895264,
0.6628381013870239,
-0.08007440716028214,
0.4252581298351288,
0.8483386635780334,
0.8145479559898376,
-0.390728235244751,
-0.4649133086204529,
-0.7144134044647217,
0.10394865274429321,
-0.07663628458976746,
0.43781590461730957,
-0.7543063163757324,
-0.5315653085708618,
0.29308417439460754,
0.0574151910841465,
0.11106070876121521,
-0.2515307366847992,
0.5521988868713379,
-0.5024397969245911,
0.2319413721561432,
-0.25500407814979553,
-0.23330989480018616,
0.14032503962516785,
0.6333219408988953,
-0.6161636710166931,
0.6692609190940857,
-0.3983619213104248,
-0.5499721169471741,
0.3303932845592499,
-0.614880383014679,
-0.24641337990760803,
0.033194560557603836,
-0.23264150321483612,
-0.5932430028915405,
0.1117279902100563,
0.2890419065952301,
0.5714459419250488,
-0.4371144771575928,
0.8834531903266907,
-0.43181729316711426,
-0.47901636362075806,
0.5523228645324707,
-0.2264346331357956,
0.4181470274925232,
-0.0000780162081355229,
-0.2385958880186081,
0.4936196208000183,
-0.605126142501831,
-0.034405119717121124,
-0.1413276344537735,
-0.4336983561515808,
0.10750754177570343,
0.33310288190841675,
0.10538807511329651,
0.2530174255371094,
-0.20195287466049194,
-0.8118566870689392,
0.42154577374458313,
-0.043908387422561646,
0.8084806799888611,
0.7749067544937134,
0.10095378011465073,
0.3505024015903473,
-0.2013658583164215,
0.35302603244781494,
-0.0676247626543045,
0.500270664691925,
-0.3400164544582367,
-0.3827216625213623,
-0.5687658190727234,
-0.18501991033554077,
0.16885100305080414,
0.18929629027843475,
-0.557086169719696,
0.12381619215011597,
-0.2733669877052307,
-0.4456624984741211,
-0.5077670216560364,
0.07458841055631638,
0.38348647952079773,
0.08156653493642807,
0.2423388510942459,
-0.3343314230442047,
-0.12981699407100677,
-0.5486394762992859,
-0.2094258964061737,
-0.3887016475200653,
0.2974071502685547,
0.5348277688026428,
0.4255858361721039,
-0.42254185676574707,
0.5884575843811035,
-0.21244841814041138,
-0.6193133592605591,
-0.21549034118652344,
-0.0016796416603028774,
0.36897918581962585,
0.11858666688203812,
-0.12797196209430695,
-0.5043771862983704,
-0.34358251094818115,
-0.31160590052604675,
-0.5030143857002258,
-0.1943698674440384,
-0.21807070076465607,
-0.04641766473650932,
-0.05123860016465187,
0.6400840878486633,
-0.5745837688446045,
0.1624000519514084,
0.5705700516700745,
-0.16371333599090576,
0.7091150879859924,
0.01984664611518383,
0.2861025333404541,
-0.7833501100540161,
0.11072944104671478,
0.01933976449072361,
-0.13095001876354218,
-0.3380272090435028,
0.14799106121063232,
-0.11352699995040894,
-0.325237512588501,
-0.21703027188777924,
0.5107566118240356,
-0.6491386890411377,
0.020467175170779228,
-0.028002267703413963,
0.2952690124511719,
0.016987739130854607,
0.3059258759021759,
0.13061460852622986,
0.55902099609375,
0.360496461391449,
-0.17407327890396118,
0.3616046905517578,
0.3763647973537445,
-0.7001954317092896,
0.49800828099250793,
-0.7632672190666199,
0.05018533393740654,
-0.05315454304218292,
0.7473964095115662,
-0.9249556660652161,
-0.1308276653289795,
-0.03536887466907501,
-0.0403544157743454,
0.18362291157245636,
-0.22715598344802856,
-0.6426680684089661,
-0.13132506608963013,
-0.6163373589515686,
0.39972296357154846,
0.07366663962602615,
-0.28181779384613037,
0.7061324715614319,
0.5214570164680481,
-0.6465060114860535,
-0.5633126497268677,
-0.1971925050020218,
0.43492186069488525,
0.20364701747894287,
-0.42938482761383057,
0.43551525473594666,
-0.006697325501590967,
-0.19140449166297913,
-0.28023797273635864,
0.12961769104003906,
0.2241082489490509,
-0.3836376667022705,
0.3318271040916443,
0.1441766768693924,
0.2202794998884201,
0.06971810013055801,
0.006596256047487259,
0.12766985595226288,
0.10614746809005737,
0.1453346461057663,
0.5707449913024902,
-0.2851785719394684,
-0.5943440794944763,
-0.35418662428855896,
0.4423755407333374,
0.9812315106391907,
-0.41083958745002747,
0.3534741997718811,
0.3632088601589203,
0.08953601866960526,
-0.3506985008716583,
-0.6714995503425598,
-0.5695385336875916,
-0.43675824999809265,
0.3538967967033386,
-0.2454828917980194,
-1.0225152969360352,
0.39542990922927856,
-0.011299260891973972,
0.31656813621520996,
-0.07929211854934692,
0.8165404796600342,
0.03184772655367851,
0.8718129396438599,
0.3491598963737488,
0.10353656113147736,
0.389693021774292,
-0.0036487861070781946,
0.503921389579773,
-1.0931373834609985,
-0.6640979647636414,
-0.3516412377357483,
-0.48028430342674255,
-0.47472983598709106,
-0.555956244468689,
0.7603998780250549,
-0.16864049434661865,
-0.16605842113494873,
-0.017735328525304794,
-0.3124556541442871,
0.1758045107126236,
0.13671593368053436,
0.020780319347977638,
0.496113121509552,
-0.1874113827943802,
-0.2721012532711029,
-0.05599575117230415,
-0.37504610419273376,
-0.6386126279830933,
1.0405263900756836,
0.5819619297981262,
1.0149837732315063,
-0.08118307590484619,
0.5665001273155212,
0.03356822207570076,
0.6012112498283386,
-0.8089771270751953,
0.8944480419158936,
0.1916847974061966,
-0.4612951874732971,
-0.45478954911231995,
-0.3469327688217163,
-0.6217206716537476,
0.536122739315033,
-0.3580082356929779,
-0.21352112293243408,
-0.00031428589136339724,
-0.15306316316127777,
-0.09894239157438278,
0.4807107448577881,
-0.163980633020401,
0.39506709575653076,
-0.30954447388648987,
-0.702131450176239,
-0.41836753487586975,
-0.52693110704422,
0.4097376763820648,
-0.14957956969738007,
0.39858853816986084,
-0.0998619794845581,
0.189184308052063,
0.5097661018371582,
-0.3928121328353882,
1.0870071649551392,
-0.39096084237098694,
-0.33765339851379395,
0.2822627127170563,
0.2057853490114212,
0.6582030057907104,
0.6009646058082581,
-0.19298286736011505,
0.1563006192445755,
0.1657230406999588,
0.24771693348884583,
-0.19924253225326538,
0.8178508281707764,
-0.7544286847114563,
-0.6882486343383789,
-0.6529473662376404,
-0.41127482056617737,
-0.4080750644207001,
0.041667111217975616,
-0.34590646624565125,
0.32032352685928345,
-0.31393951177597046,
0.3678285479545593,
0.2787749767303467,
-0.2848741412162781,
0.3589637875556946,
0.6759408116340637,
-0.5449172854423523,
-0.5188355445861816,
0.27123379707336426,
0.012966669164597988,
-0.028503216803073883,
0.05726220831274986,
0.19719842076301575,
-0.30227145552635193,
-0.5397987365722656,
-0.42951086163520813,
0.41560906171798706,
-0.38297879695892334,
-0.147884801030159,
-0.757080614566803,
-0.010076112113893032,
-0.30025824904441833,
0.14965225756168365,
-0.3070065379142761,
-0.10782349854707718,
0.10385913401842117,
0.1023436188697815,
-0.06821702420711517,
0.7585682272911072,
0.23762060701847076,
0.1332535594701767,
-0.8184638619422913,
0.07350904494524002,
0.460148423910141,
0.6857528686523438,
0.3659428060054779,
-0.36187586188316345,
0.02908647060394287,
-0.22650817036628723,
-0.36254000663757324,
-0.7621703743934631,
0.2351357489824295,
0.36035028100013733,
0.5259009003639221,
0.17782002687454224,
-0.12118498980998993,
0.4979204833507538,
-1.0796476602554321,
0.8913439512252808,
0.10765919834375381,
-0.849973201751709,
0.10232486575841904,
-0.4128625988960266,
0.29120978713035583,
0.6446416974067688,
0.15524107217788696,
-0.7519045472145081,
-0.3816998302936554,
-0.08199727535247803,
-0.9396660327911377,
0.7515556812286377,
0.09927743673324585,
0.3327326774597168,
0.3453684449195862,
0.37077513337135315,
0.17070747911930084,
0.5219214558601379,
-1.1019037961959839,
0.28296101093292236,
-0.05759412422776222,
0.27454572916030884,
-0.14760302007198334,
-0.5162384510040283,
-0.5059463381767273,
-0.10776907205581665,
0.7249986529350281,
-0.1585916429758072,
0.2797122895717621,
0.17775246500968933,
0.014776063151657581,
-0.2713092863559723,
0.6270097494125366,
0.5089496374130249,
0.6553972363471985,
-0.19590096175670624,
-0.11438043415546417,
-0.11389297246932983,
-0.2647415101528168,
0.19187070429325104,
0.028630618005990982,
-0.15040533244609833,
-0.10568457096815109,
0.22993047535419464,
0.4812633991241455,
0.3221723139286041,
-0.6327452659606934,
0.6271044015884399,
-0.12782222032546997,
-0.010926714166998863,
-0.24764487147331238,
-0.20302847027778625,
0.060782525688409805,
0.40797853469848633,
0.39345845580101013,
-0.3831460475921631,
0.3105234205722809,
-0.7838684320449829,
0.19914720952510834,
0.6005869507789612,
-0.34740710258483887,
-0.4157077372074127,
0.3641963303089142,
0.6920113563537598,
-0.23807723820209503,
0.4408778250217438,
-0.006212020758539438,
-0.46936726570129395,
0.23658263683319092,
0.23007506132125854,
0.9056845307350159,
-0.05917034670710564,
0.36542755365371704,
0.3533693552017212,
0.2331232726573944,
-0.2595950961112976,
0.18248559534549713,
0.009104959666728973,
-0.4613250494003296,
-0.8451358675956726,
-0.8921158313751221,
-0.8184159398078918,
0.3746718466281891,
-0.5659034848213196,
0.522826075553894,
-0.4810965061187744,
-0.40976423025131226,
-0.04240990802645683,
0.0857003703713417,
-0.21237464249134064,
-0.22174273431301117,
0.09372594207525253,
0.7553402781486511,
-0.6389144062995911,
0.6981881260871887,
0.6276276111602783,
-0.019020212814211845,
-0.3592125177383423,
0.056438032537698746,
0.045617491006851196,
-0.41727739572525024,
0.5340113639831543,
0.34358343482017517,
-0.3279459476470947,
-0.5465748310089111,
-0.553904116153717,
-0.39490991830825806,
0.9832960367202759,
0.012660840526223183,
-0.8783013224601746,
-0.09942492842674255,
0.028365368023514748,
0.801413893699646,
-0.5402352213859558,
0.35788199305534363,
0.08120938390493393,
0.49577081203460693,
-0.06332884728908539,
-1.1666945219039917,
-0.06671994924545288,
-0.40609610080718994,
0.05895047262310982,
0.1812215894460678,
-1.0076868534088135,
0.8927594423294067,
-0.06927571445703506,
0.05815448239445686,
-0.1011708676815033,
0.30156412720680237,
0.5570341348648071,
0.14541448652744293,
0.494171142578125,
0.22491326928138733,
0.2370380312204361,
-0.04726700857281685,
0.8303727507591248,
-0.5795912742614746,
0.4010311961174011,
1.066939353942871,
-0.9283124804496765,
0.8636769652366638,
0.6710404753684998,
-0.20246420800685883,
0.6021260023117065,
0.18647831678390503,
-0.07597136497497559,
0.32646751403808594,
0.37881961464881897,
-0.12885169684886932,
-0.36634770035743713,
-0.0069930036552250385,
-0.1469563990831375,
0.32160863280296326,
0.26740536093711853,
-0.21193870902061462,
-0.21885709464550018,
-0.09667843580245972,
0.09706722944974899,
0.1451525241136551,
-0.3047020435333252,
0.7641450762748718,
0.2911841869354248,
-0.8540353178977966,
0.15427467226982117,
0.34320127964019775,
0.7514440417289734,
-0.6213148236274719,
-0.23113973438739777,
0.029413467273116112,
0.15594683587551117,
-0.22123003005981445,
-1.180544137954712,
-0.01669512316584587,
0.16210098564624786,
-0.14850249886512756,
-0.7462015748023987,
0.5054253339767456,
-0.5710552334785461,
-0.4830944538116455,
0.4568839967250824,
0.6283974051475525,
-0.05734952539205551,
0.16772837936878204,
-0.695517361164093,
0.49786999821662903,
-0.21248872578144073,
-0.44633248448371887,
0.39134538173675537,
0.26242566108703613,
-0.34480834007263184,
0.6530816555023193,
0.6036179065704346,
0.2483726590871811,
-0.29582154750823975,
0.3582311272621155,
0.9188262820243835,
-0.4506041407585144,
-0.48101988434791565,
-0.6010962724685669,
0.36785098910331726,
-0.09685531258583069,
-0.2043008953332901,
0.33741042017936707,
0.420688271522522,
0.7926996946334839,
-0.01818045787513256,
0.610958456993103,
0.1725602000951767,
0.5596576929092407,
-0.39250820875167847,
0.725508987903595,
-0.36260518431663513,
0.3168107271194458,
-0.4597165584564209,
-1.1050571203231812,
-0.1605982780456543,
0.5486855506896973,
-0.3868277668952942,
0.2514787018299103,
0.46192270517349243,
0.6549635529518127,
0.00811272393912077,
-0.019277498126029968,
0.1041848435997963,
0.3277782201766968,
0.6853084564208984,
0.47967663407325745,
0.8425408601760864,
-0.33278465270996094,
0.4161990284919739,
0.16364791989326477,
-0.07601635903120041,
-0.2728429436683655,
-1.2413467168807983,
-0.9675765037536621,
-0.5834233164787292,
-0.17907197773456573,
-0.49930521845817566,
0.026587072759866714,
1.0373615026474,
0.5860104560852051,
-0.8745130300521851,
-0.6797906160354614,
0.29513511061668396,
-0.22386595606803894,
0.04896874725818634,
-0.1714174449443817,
0.09075754880905151,
-0.3957923650741577,
-0.9481795430183411,
0.4121023118495941,
0.42910927534103394,
-0.35190996527671814,
-0.7060002684593201,
-0.12548275291919708,
-0.041762951761484146,
0.12955020368099213,
0.8807553648948669,
-0.20022635161876678,
-0.727266788482666,
0.03912811726331711,
-0.03272775188088417,
-0.14436304569244385,
-0.03494470939040184,
1.1738611459732056,
-0.6430336833000183,
0.5997353792190552,
0.4429878294467926,
0.3661074638366699,
0.6346240639686584,
-0.26126936078071594,
0.602069079875946,
-0.4346234202384949,
-0.15296988189220428,
0.3636609613895416,
0.36020809412002563,
0.3586841821670532,
-0.09600214660167694,
0.40005332231521606,
0.0029598097316920757,
-0.6469758749008179,
-1.2300424575805664,
0.2973674237728119,
-1.0702338218688965,
-0.056425541639328,
1.4145636558532715,
-0.11237309128046036,
0.32693570852279663,
0.14882420003414154,
-0.34290388226509094,
-0.05250931158661842,
-0.675812304019928,
0.9097444415092468,
0.8962238430976868,
-0.1413145810365677,
-0.26685836911201477,
-0.3135054409503937,
0.4758034348487854,
0.25146543979644775,
-0.772996723651886,
0.24619431793689728,
0.6235433220863342,
0.31426724791526794,
0.11249745637178421,
0.5334142446517944,
-0.764568567276001,
-0.21152547001838684,
-0.9197859764099121,
0.015000976622104645,
-0.09239820390939713,
-0.612396240234375,
-0.5488872528076172,
0.3709549605846405,
0.21329282224178314,
0.7030997276306152
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.05678v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.05678v1
|
SinkLoRA: Enhanced Efficiency and Chat Capabilities for Long-Context Large Language Models
| 2024-06-09T07:23:34 | 2024-06-09T07:23:34 |
Hengyu Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Extending the functionality of the Transformer model to accommodate longer
sequence lengths has become a critical challenge. This extension is crucial not
only for improving tasks such as language translation and long-context
processing but also for enabling novel applications like chatbots, code
generation, and multimedia content creation. The primary obstacle is the
self-attention mechanism, which scales quadratically with sequence length in
terms of computation time and memory requirements. LongLoRA proposed shifted
sparse attention (S\(^2\)-Attn), effectively enabling context extension and
leading to non-trivial computation savings with similar performance to
fine-tuning with vanilla attention. However, LongLoRA is still not as efficient
as vanilla attention, reaching only 39\% of the perplexity improvement compared
to full attention. This inefficiency is due to the cyclic shift applied within
different attention head patterns, causing either chaos in the attention head
structure or unnecessary information exchange between token groups. To address
these issues, We propose \textbf{SinkLoRA}, which features better work
partitioning. Specifically, (1) we developed SF-Attn with a segmentation and
reassembly algorithm to proportionally return cyclically shifted groups of
attention heads to their un-shifted state together with global attention of
"sink attention tokens", achieving 92\% of the perplexity improvement compared
to full attention after fine tuning, and (2) applied a SOTA KV cache
compression algorithm H$_2$O to accelerate inference. Furthermore, We conducted
supervised fine-tuning with SinkLoRA using a self collected LongAlpaca-plus
dataset. All our code, models, datasets, and demos are available at
\url{https://github.com/Dexter-GT-86/SinkLoRA}.
|
[
-0.5226227045059204,
-0.6635240912437439,
0.5645607113838196,
0.6058620810508728,
-0.34477052092552185,
-0.06908787041902542,
-0.4612356722354889,
-0.6586823463439941,
0.2903496325016022,
0.48423129320144653,
-0.5836530327796936,
-0.18790806829929352,
-0.3844749927520752,
0.12472741305828094,
-0.44006645679473877,
0.9024755954742432,
0.24535571038722992,
-0.3128603994846344,
0.21993514895439148,
-0.21733741462230682,
-0.8768138885498047,
-0.16682064533233643,
-0.8431460857391357,
-0.16711747646331787,
1.0092113018035889,
0.44971686601638794,
0.8179053664207458,
0.5789217352867126,
0.5261719822883606,
0.3580034077167511,
-0.3956616520881653,
0.12388736754655838,
-1.1380904912948608,
0.06756142526865005,
-0.44944897294044495,
-0.4925087094306946,
-0.6600848436355591,
-0.44199657440185547,
0.5282055139541626,
0.5864151120185852,
0.1561296135187149,
0.35366809368133545,
0.10411401838064194,
0.8818824291229248,
-0.7611556053161621,
0.31981801986694336,
-0.402066171169281,
-0.052396684885025024,
-0.3084149956703186,
-0.09718849509954453,
-0.5010979175567627,
-0.06867393106222153,
0.23075240850448608,
-0.35231032967567444,
0.19606024026870728,
-0.2164774090051651,
0.5038319826126099,
0.7105146646499634,
-0.3923819363117218,
-0.08224992454051971,
-0.7536227107048035,
0.7634077072143555,
-0.6867924928665161,
0.5525864362716675,
-0.15631797909736633,
0.3250387907028198,
-0.1518038809299469,
-0.7779335975646973,
-0.3563598096370697,
0.21751151978969574,
-0.06772409379482269,
0.24492281675338745,
-0.20035769045352936,
0.15384024381637573,
0.26801592111587524,
0.39120805263519287,
-0.47780847549438477,
0.10489679872989655,
-0.5007396936416626,
0.17427879571914673,
0.6330609321594238,
0.14473766088485718,
0.005743095651268959,
-0.058748893439769745,
-0.394483357667923,
-0.1091122254729271,
-0.8277010321617126,
0.056348416954278946,
0.07083353400230408,
0.4212851822376251,
-0.1208541989326477,
0.2919045388698578,
-0.08938463032245636,
0.5966328382492065,
0.07428434491157532,
0.0933491513133049,
0.16457435488700867,
-0.062196701765060425,
-0.43980392813682556,
0.1605570912361145,
0.469136506319046,
0.07885374128818512,
0.17241676151752472,
-0.04859456419944763,
-0.010599677450954914,
0.01636820286512375,
0.38869622349739075,
-0.9493125677108765,
-0.20565760135650635,
0.33622506260871887,
-0.3306424915790558,
-0.23092345893383026,
-0.08880414813756943,
-1.1511310338974,
-0.22654440999031067,
-0.319564551115036,
0.08552148193120956,
-0.05549803376197815,
-0.25840041041374207,
0.20725131034851074,
0.20651495456695557,
0.1992661952972412,
0.5106576085090637,
-0.7286120653152466,
0.15480756759643555,
0.9757879376411438,
0.8731339573860168,
-0.770626962184906,
-0.2127235233783722,
-0.3763258755207062,
0.17002899944782257,
-0.3234322667121887,
0.7091576457023621,
-0.2835651934146881,
-0.26051074266433716,
-0.02455185540020466,
0.1626436710357666,
-0.3053184449672699,
-0.3562888205051422,
0.49720993638038635,
-0.7191474437713623,
0.24871432781219482,
-0.27443671226501465,
-0.4399268627166748,
-0.18242588639259338,
-0.127144455909729,
-0.8532107472419739,
0.6621928811073303,
0.22536979615688324,
-0.8204053044319153,
-0.07092072069644928,
-0.9024869203567505,
-0.5464619398117065,
0.012898905202746391,
0.09496521949768066,
-0.317379891872406,
0.20255716145038605,
0.1576985865831375,
0.26378825306892395,
-0.3668765425682068,
0.4494442045688629,
-0.32559528946876526,
-0.48268425464630127,
0.11184471845626831,
-0.632535994052887,
0.6915713548660278,
0.45478153228759766,
-0.5207391381263733,
0.5684489607810974,
-0.405897319316864,
-0.12109993398189545,
0.04810702055692673,
-0.3960900902748108,
-0.054399166256189346,
-0.0508134588599205,
0.25666460394859314,
0.2250727266073227,
0.1179552972316742,
-0.24028562009334564,
0.179054394364357,
-0.6412508487701416,
0.5913191437721252,
0.807292640209198,
-0.2772162854671478,
0.5089386105537415,
0.034074556082487106,
0.5879114866256714,
-0.06894444674253464,
0.24318474531173706,
-0.33781030774116516,
-0.420937180519104,
-1.0214186906814575,
-0.5054580569267273,
0.18905699253082275,
0.4612750709056854,
-0.6201698780059814,
0.2555350065231323,
-0.7912819981575012,
-0.13728691637516022,
-0.311349481344223,
0.15790435671806335,
0.4281112849712372,
0.48491594195365906,
0.4858020842075348,
-0.34405654668807983,
-0.4464787244796753,
-0.7929061651229858,
-0.058963824063539505,
0.23010525107383728,
-0.050294179469347,
0.28444790840148926,
0.08221685141324997,
-0.42725780606269836,
1.1487199068069458,
-0.8213438987731934,
-0.4098212718963623,
-0.4131593108177185,
-0.09678982198238373,
0.6469666361808777,
0.40418514609336853,
0.49906283617019653,
-0.8081270456314087,
-0.5924569368362427,
-0.07775158435106277,
-0.3967735469341278,
-0.17892786860466003,
-0.15569081902503967,
-0.2895200550556183,
0.36089056730270386,
0.5867729783058167,
-0.9367996454238892,
0.5570802092552185,
0.5009480118751526,
-0.4287404417991638,
0.35172033309936523,
0.1151835024356842,
-0.1501968801021576,
-1.2435483932495117,
0.2234184443950653,
-0.32680800557136536,
-0.5999566912651062,
-0.8359659910202026,
0.28373539447784424,
0.13113558292388916,
-0.18991917371749878,
-0.4810856282711029,
0.4886743128299713,
-0.5873025059700012,
-0.14815005660057068,
-0.707255482673645,
0.16477897763252258,
-0.1978427618741989,
0.8360854983329773,
-0.017122475430369377,
0.9720192551612854,
0.2977403998374939,
-0.413209468126297,
0.22037814557552338,
0.15343700349330902,
0.09628083556890488,
0.3558375835418701,
-0.7547286748886108,
0.2838899493217468,
-0.11072243005037308,
0.3944907784461975,
-1.110257863998413,
-0.16070593893527985,
0.15726466476917267,
-0.08563122153282166,
0.5815688967704773,
-0.09664399921894073,
-0.2613988220691681,
-0.5446327328681946,
-0.45447421073913574,
0.87079256772995,
0.4370242953300476,
-0.7522495985031128,
0.679513692855835,
0.2860441207885742,
-0.19060835242271423,
-0.5490701198577881,
-0.5838881134986877,
0.2657965421676636,
-0.42939314246177673,
-0.709459662437439,
0.3416382372379303,
-0.14621363580226898,
-0.04206452891230583,
-0.3544185757637024,
-0.14062334597110748,
0.015658063814044,
-0.18516351282596588,
0.15559348464012146,
0.193845734000206,
-0.4460889399051666,
0.2526527941226959,
0.08429639041423798,
-0.3187941610813141,
0.014051521196961403,
-0.2059972733259201,
0.8661683201789856,
-0.2052364945411682,
-0.24662312865257263,
-0.4166269600391388,
0.244815394282341,
0.7153040170669556,
-0.17427781224250793,
0.43385085463523865,
0.6436495184898376,
-0.07952083647251129,
-0.15594267845153809,
-0.778541624546051,
-0.20389977097511292,
-0.5497035384178162,
0.4379452168941498,
-0.2840723991394043,
-1.092034935951233,
0.7295446395874023,
-0.04642743244767189,
0.02482409030199051,
0.4535183608531952,
0.5070897340774536,
0.2715746760368347,
0.7603166699409485,
0.634398341178894,
-0.5864362716674805,
0.63690584897995,
-0.2466495782136917,
0.3421823978424072,
-0.9577612280845642,
0.3452938199043274,
-0.20083248615264893,
-0.36268675327301025,
-0.4962571859359741,
-0.733737051486969,
0.3700748682022095,
-0.26360654830932617,
-0.12732867896556854,
0.4296017289161682,
-0.560513973236084,
0.5691092610359192,
0.20846286416053772,
0.08891856670379639,
0.21563202142715454,
-0.30619490146636963,
0.6656987071037292,
0.01997416280210018,
-0.8049527406692505,
0.02060515061020851,
0.8250380158424377,
0.5716280341148376,
0.8422307372093201,
0.19565269351005554,
0.6036062240600586,
0.2697879672050476,
0.38101691007614136,
-0.7911322116851807,
0.43424227833747864,
0.0009805565932765603,
-0.4628405272960663,
-0.7250964045524597,
-0.36411604285240173,
-1.2227721214294434,
0.4876038432121277,
0.43844538927078247,
-0.8007811903953552,
0.4001786410808563,
0.12397626787424088,
-0.3899044990539551,
0.0295314509421587,
-0.6324002146720886,
0.9871149063110352,
0.1317775398492813,
-0.6279754042625427,
-0.5312483310699463,
-0.726765513420105,
0.46093088388442993,
-0.15223269164562225,
0.13598203659057617,
-0.08241493254899979,
0.05186313018202782,
0.4985474944114685,
-0.4182927906513214,
1.0363141298294067,
0.01610373705625534,
-0.6590774655342102,
0.26584145426750183,
0.09437767416238785,
0.6189503073692322,
0.2709868848323822,
0.34009525179862976,
0.049395494163036346,
-0.1831132173538208,
-0.3292040228843689,
-0.5527493357658386,
0.9144739508628845,
-0.44908612966537476,
-0.7290259003639221,
-0.24925711750984192,
-0.7452309727668762,
-0.05602279305458069,
0.38140276074409485,
0.01088736392557621,
0.2907141149044037,
0.08363854885101318,
0.2656746208667755,
0.8134713768959045,
0.0700840875506401,
0.725764811038971,
0.2154301255941391,
-0.39102494716644287,
-0.3692162036895752,
0.7952483892440796,
-0.006480776704847813,
0.19432996213436127,
0.36915233731269836,
0.1242419183254242,
-0.27238166332244873,
-0.19580833613872528,
-0.38675814867019653,
0.3273059129714966,
-0.7371857762336731,
-0.4561542272567749,
-0.5364609360694885,
-0.22513194382190704,
-0.5525330901145935,
-0.17602913081645966,
-0.7198823690414429,
-0.40772324800491333,
-0.524641752243042,
0.1418350785970688,
0.10010697692632675,
0.48758387565612793,
0.30373379588127136,
0.3683081269264221,
-0.5789766907691956,
0.42226311564445496,
0.4121112525463104,
0.27689751982688904,
0.35379093885421753,
-0.5875003337860107,
-0.19832931458950043,
-0.1232675313949585,
-0.14235126972198486,
-0.9349302053451538,
0.4870613217353821,
0.11315733939409256,
0.20230698585510254,
0.6419360637664795,
-0.06426338851451874,
1.027206301689148,
-0.5320311188697815,
0.3924255073070526,
0.029703816398978233,
-1.0818758010864258,
0.2772812843322754,
-0.47574952244758606,
0.8261086344718933,
0.5393762588500977,
-0.06728474795818329,
-0.47050461173057556,
-0.31754904985427856,
-0.3616434335708618,
-1.1200579404830933,
0.7121921181678772,
0.3687247335910797,
0.2345896065235138,
0.09325765073299408,
0.29405897855758667,
-0.08039066195487976,
0.09746647626161575,
-0.6786418557167053,
-0.14251239597797394,
-0.15909594297409058,
-0.1773422509431839,
-0.2807045876979828,
-0.4804580807685852,
-0.1844615489244461,
-0.4545244872570038,
0.48123130202293396,
-0.42495208978652954,
0.25723981857299805,
0.31425485014915466,
-0.29318559169769287,
-0.021556833758950233,
0.09929980337619781,
0.8258603811264038,
0.9388960003852844,
0.06007276475429535,
0.18904614448547363,
0.5912647247314453,
-0.4245651066303253,
-0.1691603660583496,
0.08676166087388992,
0.03411531448364258,
-0.1285054087638855,
0.4769602119922638,
0.7607212662696838,
0.6239541172981262,
-0.547552227973938,
0.4635331332683563,
-0.08318500220775604,
0.2585811913013458,
-0.3907530605792999,
0.08695009350776672,
0.32112741470336914,
0.4288851022720337,
0.30708494782447815,
-0.27964356541633606,
0.39376121759414673,
-0.4201377034187317,
0.06511909514665604,
0.20845310389995575,
-0.4622328579425812,
-0.24592413008213043,
0.4917742609977722,
0.1654348522424698,
-0.2355266809463501,
0.5004215240478516,
0.07356970757246017,
-0.5482208132743835,
0.5263684988021851,
0.7011904120445251,
0.9760299324989319,
-0.47558024525642395,
-0.08473064750432968,
0.19302761554718018,
-0.017719876021146774,
-0.053521204739809036,
0.21335160732269287,
-0.3196881115436554,
-0.3558712899684906,
-0.5214493274688721,
-0.507043182849884,
-0.022504281252622604,
-0.009701612405478954,
-0.507493793964386,
0.22498561441898346,
-0.14281690120697021,
-0.20552051067352295,
-0.17668424546718597,
-0.35797250270843506,
-0.45131435990333557,
-0.1255957931280136,
0.28197625279426575,
0.8793893456459045,
-0.5714057683944702,
0.8062353134155273,
0.19793911278247833,
-0.0717025026679039,
-0.5800158381462097,
-0.08801109343767166,
-0.29885756969451904,
-0.45161768794059753,
0.40695905685424805,
0.503257691860199,
-0.40118566155433655,
-0.05548752844333649,
-0.558178722858429,
-1.3267251253128052,
1.1827175617218018,
0.432054728269577,
-0.6824119091033936,
-0.09437420219182968,
0.3052870035171509,
0.8134431838989258,
-0.4060758650302887,
0.14794126152992249,
0.6636934280395508,
0.41991889476776123,
0.2482016235589981,
-1.0048073530197144,
0.27549049258232117,
-0.08615604788064957,
0.27721530199050903,
0.18682727217674255,
-1.0039013624191284,
0.8179475665092468,
-0.13729740679264069,
-0.3886739909648895,
-0.07726907730102539,
1.036866307258606,
-0.030067557469010353,
0.2616894245147705,
0.574388325214386,
0.541058361530304,
0.44118183851242065,
0.03893981873989105,
0.7558234333992004,
-0.36937984824180603,
0.5626044869422913,
1.378659963607788,
-0.30140677094459534,
0.7403148412704468,
0.6225088238716125,
-0.1507851481437683,
0.33586302399635315,
0.430794894695282,
0.15166224539279938,
0.41466113924980164,
0.24225199222564697,
0.04904143884778023,
-0.11829148232936859,
0.10307225584983826,
-0.31379011273384094,
0.38382574915885925,
0.21750064194202423,
-0.31152281165122986,
-0.24868033826351166,
0.03271253779530525,
0.17336010932922363,
-0.33585500717163086,
-0.31143075227737427,
0.8432713150978088,
0.2664834260940552,
-0.9372868537902832,
0.7902511954307556,
-0.28719356656074524,
0.690166175365448,
-0.2116495966911316,
0.0864170491695404,
-0.32277968525886536,
0.45514023303985596,
-0.19671176373958588,
-0.5753606557846069,
0.29253366589546204,
-0.168724924325943,
-0.09714071452617645,
-0.04934709146618843,
0.8080692887306213,
-0.4604850113391876,
-0.3872842788696289,
0.4525626599788666,
0.3075951039791107,
0.09885251522064209,
-0.34281304478645325,
-0.4897722899913788,
0.19482013583183289,
0.042222391813993454,
-0.5804517865180969,
0.2249307930469513,
0.164529487490654,
-0.25943723320961,
0.8593931794166565,
0.5972052216529846,
-0.2625429332256317,
0.20747365057468414,
0.3911706209182739,
1.2478622198104858,
-0.527371346950531,
-0.7286707162857056,
-0.9350544810295105,
0.28828170895576477,
-0.18072476983070374,
-0.17498600482940674,
0.6162638068199158,
0.7283782958984375,
0.6255786418914795,
-0.23742558062076569,
0.23583678901195526,
0.15834392607212067,
0.26430046558380127,
-0.3549168109893799,
0.6903150081634521,
-0.3825215697288513,
0.025123119354248047,
-0.3319433927536011,
-1.2529330253601074,
-0.22689813375473022,
0.36149558424949646,
-0.2708698809146881,
-0.06073762848973274,
0.7350917458534241,
0.5314009189605713,
-0.4403129518032074,
0.07543838024139404,
0.22022470831871033,
0.1751536726951599,
0.6348671317100525,
0.8122538328170776,
0.48979878425598145,
-0.25775861740112305,
0.41579940915107727,
-0.09377127885818481,
-0.11133285611867905,
-0.4113451838493347,
-0.6583930850028992,
-1.053835391998291,
-0.4026286005973816,
-0.07423460483551025,
-0.09540694206953049,
0.11876866966485977,
0.7162259817123413,
0.7830958962440491,
-0.8575014472007751,
-0.3355608582496643,
-0.1845192313194275,
0.10964576154947281,
-0.06811664998531342,
-0.28900840878486633,
0.6419316530227661,
-0.6974145770072937,
-0.8248069286346436,
0.46218881011009216,
0.3864097595214844,
0.027535367757081985,
-0.4419593811035156,
0.012531165033578873,
-0.078337661921978,
0.09075643867254257,
0.8618981838226318,
0.376234233379364,
-0.5424272418022156,
-0.2544720768928528,
-0.08784618228673935,
-0.04312533140182495,
0.2731655240058899,
0.802899956703186,
-0.576213002204895,
0.21465548872947693,
0.6687319278717041,
0.5946934223175049,
0.864009439945221,
0.23601862788200378,
0.5974735617637634,
-0.3978506624698639,
0.36359184980392456,
0.2671458125114441,
0.32925504446029663,
0.19276903569698334,
-0.6077689528465271,
0.7396817803382874,
-0.07475767284631729,
-0.7631540894508362,
-0.9104458689689636,
0.2993730902671814,
-1.1159759759902954,
-0.2868138253688812,
1.1956809759140015,
-0.20337429642677307,
-0.6689398884773254,
0.010146318934857845,
-0.3402409851551056,
0.35690760612487793,
-0.4180528223514557,
1.0773321390151978,
0.4366074502468109,
-0.19688890874385834,
-0.11103338748216629,
-0.41289496421813965,
0.6696102619171143,
0.6759555339813232,
-0.9104058146476746,
0.4814452826976776,
0.4144664704799652,
0.1560802012681961,
0.4800862669944763,
0.5511861443519592,
-0.013810492120683193,
0.317933589220047,
-0.5560198426246643,
-0.14770378172397614,
0.062305327504873276,
-0.6965473890304565,
-0.5742910504341125,
0.2717825472354889,
-0.21809984743595123,
0.060225069522857666
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.05673v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.05673v2
|
Flow of Reasoning: Efficient Training of LLM Policy with Divergent Thinking
| 2024-06-09T07:06:58 | 2024-06-24T15:49:09 |
Fangxu Yu, Lai Jiang, Haoqiang Kang, Shibo Hao, Lianhui Qin
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Divergent thinking, the cognitive process of generating diverse solutions, is
a hallmark of human creativity and problem-solving. For machines, sampling
diverse solution trajectories in complex reasoning problems is crucial for
robust outcomes, data augmentation, and enhanced model generalization. Large
language models (LLMs) often struggle with generating high-quality, diverse
reasoning. While supervised fine-tuning helps with quality, it requires
extensive supervision data to capture the full diversity of solutions.
Alternatively, reinforcement learning methods like PPO aim to find limited
highest-reward solutions while neglecting the solution diversity, akin to
convergent thinking. To address these limitations, we propose Flow of Reasoning
(FoR) -- an efficient LLM training approach enabling diverse reasoning with
minimal data. FoR formulates multi-step LLM reasoning as a Markovian flow from
an initial state to terminal states. The formulation allows to adapt principled
GFlowNet approaches to train the LLM as a policy, which is able to sample
multiple reasoning paths with probabilities proportional to the unnormalized
reward. Empirical results show that, with limited training data (e.g., 15
examples), FoR can discover diverse high-quality solutions that excel greatly
beyond current state-of-the-art methods across three tasks, including embodied
reasoning (BlocksWorld), math puzzle solving (Game24), and logical reasoning
(PrOntoQA). Code is available at https://github.com/Yu-Fangxu/FoR.
|
[
-0.34653303027153015,
-0.6195181608200073,
0.7505655288696289,
0.16040758788585663,
-0.19045495986938477,
0.2981374263763428,
-0.18601438403129578,
0.06970929354429245,
-0.12144023925065994,
0.5180343985557556,
-1.025818109512329,
-0.4869476556777954,
-0.5237367153167725,
-0.10944189876317978,
-0.097625233232975,
0.8673449158668518,
-0.27520641684532166,
0.07983885705471039,
-0.02747034840285778,
-0.03654027357697487,
-0.20404934883117676,
-0.10819274932146072,
-0.6392503976821899,
-0.6250636577606201,
0.6127964854240417,
0.5309492945671082,
0.5477346181869507,
0.40389394760131836,
0.41573968529701233,
0.27070608735084534,
-0.21634498238563538,
0.39462631940841675,
-0.56730717420578,
0.303826242685318,
-0.550172746181488,
-0.5550124049186707,
0.16370178759098053,
-0.15704916417598724,
0.6346486806869507,
0.680137574672699,
-0.40434515476226807,
-0.21435417234897614,
-0.05481402948498726,
0.7924705743789673,
-0.7535490393638611,
-0.1265287548303604,
-0.7262665033340454,
0.2491573840379715,
-0.06905168294906616,
-0.06080295890569687,
-0.20673410594463348,
-0.2735272943973541,
0.13489219546318054,
-0.5931464433670044,
-0.09515522420406342,
-0.1556527465581894,
0.4375757873058319,
0.557632565498352,
-0.16069497168064117,
-0.5032060742378235,
-0.7798711061477661,
0.8100699782371521,
-0.3839552104473114,
0.21454785764217377,
-0.14239747822284698,
0.48565474152565,
-0.31521913409233093,
-0.5284168124198914,
-0.6191398501396179,
0.14128535985946655,
0.47783875465393066,
0.35650819540023804,
-0.12946155667304993,
0.010809984058141708,
0.24968358874320984,
0.3211911618709564,
-0.4593348503112793,
0.2947867214679718,
-0.3548005223274231,
-0.1630837768316269,
0.8628456592559814,
0.4888349175453186,
0.02354101464152336,
0.3892807960510254,
-0.40930747985839844,
-0.08243962377309799,
-0.4255593419075012,
0.3313327133655548,
0.5712624192237854,
0.27216941118240356,
-0.034454215317964554,
0.32420504093170166,
-0.5693360567092896,
0.6383901238441467,
-0.31148380041122437,
-0.35670340061187744,
0.19254347681999207,
-0.2508127987384796,
-0.1308789849281311,
-0.26848578453063965,
0.6991060376167297,
-0.23938646912574768,
0.2849525809288025,
0.08158893138170242,
-0.25501999258995056,
-0.27957800030708313,
0.14363496005535126,
-0.6924777626991272,
-0.22204016149044037,
0.3786543607711792,
-0.09916742891073227,
-0.09408259391784668,
-0.10447793453931808,
-0.576855480670929,
-0.42463698983192444,
-0.4292037785053253,
-0.03918911889195442,
-0.5136629939079285,
-0.2939544916152954,
0.5189458131790161,
-0.3785540759563446,
0.22401617467403412,
0.6878725290298462,
-0.6868941187858582,
0.05055166780948639,
0.7836920022964478,
0.7627617716789246,
-0.3455595076084137,
-0.3972264528274536,
-0.40182021260261536,
-0.18141084909439087,
-0.28322121500968933,
0.8036542534828186,
-0.5425089001655579,
-0.32750406861305237,
0.003435521386563778,
-0.4708232879638672,
0.028975531458854675,
-0.584345281124115,
0.5243654847145081,
-0.3371036648750305,
0.10683876276016235,
-0.14304159581661224,
-0.6513344645500183,
-0.15706904232501984,
0.3498307764530182,
-0.4624435603618622,
0.34536683559417725,
-0.01434462983161211,
-0.6834893822669983,
0.26151955127716064,
-0.7734262347221375,
-0.36916959285736084,
0.0982714295387268,
-0.3414575457572937,
-0.23948436975479126,
-0.09459465742111206,
0.2877606153488159,
0.3801407516002655,
-0.17852893471717834,
0.1988542377948761,
-0.4945443272590637,
-0.2761358916759491,
0.25050005316734314,
-0.36734893918037415,
1.042535662651062,
0.6081901788711548,
-0.09963579475879669,
0.20661447942256927,
-0.40141603350639343,
0.10136479884386063,
0.17141598463058472,
-0.5160042643547058,
0.0300517026335001,
-0.01752379536628723,
-0.6034351587295532,
0.287180632352829,
-0.2073114812374115,
-0.16787181794643402,
0.3531280755996704,
-0.1983027309179306,
0.37832289934158325,
0.7725343704223633,
0.12461397796869278,
0.4261631369590759,
-0.39880964159965515,
0.5822029709815979,
0.3253990411758423,
0.16501429677009583,
-0.04334462806582451,
-0.7306135892868042,
-0.6041173338890076,
-0.5854247808456421,
-0.040670014917850494,
0.904288649559021,
-1.0000735521316528,
0.1752023696899414,
-0.0116779375821352,
-0.46621838212013245,
-0.3778277039527893,
0.3613584041595459,
0.13814324140548706,
0.26504579186439514,
0.23524166643619537,
0.062105949968099594,
-0.30941635370254517,
-0.6221643090248108,
-0.43758073449134827,
0.013195221312344074,
0.1296893060207367,
0.3652389347553253,
0.7437397241592407,
-0.33253440260887146,
0.6703068614006042,
-0.47310999035835266,
0.07500573992729187,
-0.46899083256721497,
0.19403569400310516,
0.41381725668907166,
0.3699457049369812,
-0.09777674823999405,
-0.5321404933929443,
-0.20114216208457947,
-0.08333133161067963,
-0.7170401811599731,
0.1915929764509201,
-0.4357090890407562,
-0.5180974006652832,
-0.026158306747674942,
0.35831671953201294,
-0.5105102062225342,
0.025613494217395782,
0.3159607946872711,
-0.25772151350975037,
0.556298553943634,
-0.10363922268152237,
-0.2866525650024414,
-0.6803414821624756,
-0.1639213263988495,
-0.08719237148761749,
-0.17537662386894226,
-0.46717166900634766,
0.17689022421836853,
-0.3963618874549866,
-0.09507571160793304,
-0.5750740766525269,
0.516668438911438,
-0.4280679225921631,
0.1703210473060608,
-0.17618060111999512,
0.13669762015342712,
-0.21093076467514038,
0.5104979276657104,
0.11414279043674469,
0.5034802556037903,
0.7280839681625366,
-0.6667144298553467,
0.6367828249931335,
0.041408803313970566,
-0.23147594928741455,
0.5272719860076904,
-0.22596953809261322,
0.23819676041603088,
-0.2855597138404846,
0.33726391196250916,
-0.6508028507232666,
0.022785043343901634,
0.28829801082611084,
-0.17361515760421753,
0.13707764446735382,
0.05583169683814049,
-0.07874889671802521,
-0.5641189217567444,
-0.20075425505638123,
0.14814986288547516,
0.564492404460907,
-0.6133765578269958,
0.5318385362625122,
0.27030664682388306,
0.07908931374549866,
-0.8847527503967285,
-0.7465766668319702,
-0.23899130523204803,
-0.306108683347702,
-0.5254486203193665,
0.08234918862581253,
-0.136691153049469,
-0.3777124583721161,
-0.035499583929777145,
-0.20578913390636444,
-0.27492305636405945,
0.3590484857559204,
-0.16294045746326447,
0.0789702981710434,
0.02662692219018936,
0.17357967793941498,
0.29232490062713623,
0.045187756419181824,
0.14266791939735413,
-0.8792957663536072,
0.4208013415336609,
-0.20778366923332214,
-0.5631317496299744,
-0.204481303691864,
0.385174959897995,
0.2973422408103943,
-0.04461953043937683,
0.5033015608787537,
0.6154695749282837,
-0.19998353719711304,
-0.9141693115234375,
-0.14020918309688568,
-0.055459797382354736,
-0.38576698303222656,
0.3305915296077728,
-0.5112775564193726,
-1.1390305757522583,
0.4233526885509491,
-0.28553155064582825,
0.19429010152816772,
0.17739509046077728,
0.9257360696792603,
-0.24716530740261078,
0.5881381034851074,
0.3315964639186859,
0.1247830018401146,
0.3942265510559082,
-0.5839852690696716,
0.11262816935777664,
-0.5440670251846313,
-0.39318645000457764,
-0.21103768050670624,
-0.46912702918052673,
-0.5423404574394226,
-0.7884146571159363,
0.04242299869656563,
0.2717748284339905,
-0.4410441219806671,
-0.398029625415802,
-0.5372671484947205,
0.6826730966567993,
0.6010265350341797,
0.1406501680612564,
0.3148222267627716,
-0.028665969148278236,
-0.5230783224105835,
0.287085622549057,
-0.8914317488670349,
-0.24714945256710052,
1.0236701965332031,
0.3588981032371521,
0.9007953405380249,
-0.01674240455031395,
1.146286129951477,
0.039870914071798325,
0.22562408447265625,
-0.8528277277946472,
0.5019955039024353,
-0.06871890276670456,
-0.49325522780418396,
-0.527814507484436,
-0.7204017639160156,
-0.8510763049125671,
0.39112305641174316,
-0.11665254086256027,
-0.6106534600257874,
0.03250962123274803,
0.11676307022571564,
-0.40690597891807556,
0.6614267230033875,
-0.273540198802948,
0.6720424890518188,
-0.3163757920265198,
-0.3271470069885254,
-0.49513381719589233,
-0.584852397441864,
0.6812583804130554,
0.17828410863876343,
0.06581324338912964,
-0.22526228427886963,
-0.04878193140029907,
0.3625151813030243,
-0.4458118677139282,
0.5717442035675049,
-0.3200535774230957,
-0.06345831602811813,
0.7744694352149963,
-0.04304879531264305,
0.3485338091850281,
0.22969509661197662,
0.31530067324638367,
0.11158055812120438,
-0.5644121170043945,
-0.44192221760749817,
-0.655768632888794,
0.4907058775424957,
-0.849387526512146,
-0.653094470500946,
-0.38093629479408264,
-0.7737282514572144,
-0.21151074767112732,
-0.014683321118354797,
0.14577098190784454,
-0.10418104380369186,
0.0650908350944519,
-0.0637107640504837,
0.9722497463226318,
-0.11348330974578857,
0.29433533549308777,
0.17810438573360443,
-0.2646900415420532,
-0.47794532775878906,
0.7598106265068054,
-0.12107688933610916,
0.3024430274963379,
0.45155125856399536,
0.35341235995292664,
-0.4216269850730896,
-0.7406487464904785,
-0.43364065885543823,
0.09013451635837555,
-0.9373987913131714,
-0.02986411564052105,
-0.494037002325058,
-0.3888316750526428,
0.19151350855827332,
-0.0705278217792511,
-0.330066055059433,
-0.4209027886390686,
-0.14558789134025574,
0.08547239005565643,
0.17275962233543396,
0.3278820812702179,
-0.19380387663841248,
-0.07573703676462173,
-0.5104013085365295,
0.13794423639774323,
0.6184733510017395,
0.2329331636428833,
-0.0671406164765358,
-0.36147525906562805,
-0.07005762308835983,
-0.006474009249359369,
-0.6249129772186279,
-0.6741300225257874,
-0.006726227700710297,
0.06327655166387558,
0.8593015670776367,
0.33643636107444763,
-0.16871370375156403,
0.3343687355518341,
-0.3222426772117615,
0.5726085305213928,
0.3850423991680145,
-0.762920618057251,
0.7551944255828857,
-0.14133843779563904,
0.33664843440055847,
0.43379807472229004,
0.6288113594055176,
-0.304267942905426,
-0.5248129963874817,
-0.524259626865387,
-0.6106716394424438,
0.3540888726711273,
0.05676600709557533,
-0.04494355618953705,
0.22382791340351105,
0.211245596408844,
0.17829155921936035,
0.06467574834823608,
-0.3204776346683502,
-0.012860025279223919,
-0.2624609172344208,
-0.15889236330986023,
0.19933094084262848,
0.29466742277145386,
-0.2338704615831375,
-0.37859320640563965,
0.6644533276557922,
-0.4318888783454895,
0.13510762155056,
0.2416653335094452,
-0.0182369202375412,
0.2933230698108673,
0.41710975766181946,
0.6661708950996399,
0.5085844397544861,
0.1822313517332077,
0.07183888554573059,
0.27671757340431213,
-0.24924232065677643,
0.3533487021923065,
-0.041936133056879044,
-0.1792854517698288,
-0.15895822644233704,
0.22095882892608643,
0.9511498212814331,
-0.37799501419067383,
-0.7932133674621582,
0.25820931792259216,
-0.08110474050045013,
-0.5259971022605896,
-0.0937996581196785,
0.5539698004722595,
0.3764391839504242,
0.7315298318862915,
-0.014487441629171371,
0.2698909342288971,
0.3134421110153198,
-0.5316463112831116,
0.00291782571002841,
0.43347659707069397,
-0.18824486434459686,
0.1349744200706482,
0.4109954833984375,
0.10661568492650986,
-0.22340083122253418,
1.0731549263000488,
-0.5528712272644043,
-0.4441453516483307,
0.33106520771980286,
0.347123384475708,
0.9312875866889954,
0.12164487689733505,
0.3663572371006012,
0.342065691947937,
0.08577000349760056,
-0.24673177301883698,
0.6237902641296387,
-0.18459710478782654,
-1.0332894325256348,
-0.7359195351600647,
-0.3935491442680359,
-0.7513012886047363,
0.03835596516728401,
-0.1811276525259018,
0.06265906244516373,
-0.6805823445320129,
-0.06825469434261322,
-0.381706565618515,
-0.08288257569074631,
-0.771989643573761,
0.093232661485672,
0.6287453770637512,
0.9610180854797363,
-0.7106858491897583,
0.680011510848999,
0.734490692615509,
-0.457696795463562,
-0.9883074164390564,
0.029897769913077354,
0.051912520080804825,
-0.7816389799118042,
0.6157882809638977,
0.03344716131687164,
-0.24872300028800964,
-0.2785448431968689,
-0.704779863357544,
-0.6302679181098938,
1.0565837621688843,
0.461761474609375,
-0.6136609315872192,
0.10244772583246231,
0.045662906020879745,
0.2702730596065521,
-0.5300369262695312,
0.27678409218788147,
0.6695926189422607,
0.27665212750434875,
0.5250372886657715,
-0.5314207673072815,
-0.04553414508700371,
-0.12400028854608536,
0.04192478582262993,
-0.12880392372608185,
-0.6112502217292786,
0.8755221366882324,
-0.6467579007148743,
-0.1848849058151245,
-0.19577504694461823,
0.6321220397949219,
0.830919086933136,
0.23546452820301056,
0.4929395914077759,
0.8908276557922363,
1.33447265625,
-0.2613738179206848,
0.9689670205116272,
0.08817292004823685,
0.21330401301383972,
0.9183753132820129,
-0.2416732758283615,
0.5456069111824036,
0.45912593603134155,
-0.15381699800491333,
0.9017729163169861,
0.5163620710372925,
0.14694616198539734,
0.6130622029304504,
0.8477565050125122,
-0.18307161331176758,
-0.5022622346878052,
0.18822990357875824,
0.021354563534259796,
0.45065099000930786,
0.2875666320323944,
0.010252275504171848,
-0.22246041893959045,
-0.025420941412448883,
-0.0800737589597702,
0.07552335411310196,
-0.5331636667251587,
0.5953319072723389,
0.26617440581321716,
-0.7889896631240845,
0.5921182632446289,
-0.35749268531799316,
0.6763097643852234,
-0.4141086935997009,
0.06874506920576096,
-0.3727433979511261,
0.3628949820995331,
-0.18680982291698456,
-1.1549543142318726,
0.4109095335006714,
-0.062359098345041275,
-0.0954575166106224,
-0.3400490880012512,
0.5212433338165283,
-0.20919491350650787,
-0.33782491087913513,
0.11503990739583969,
0.9305828213691711,
0.3610515296459198,
0.028723236173391342,
-0.9512105584144592,
-0.21043919026851654,
0.07719454914331436,
-0.216813325881958,
0.05384223163127899,
0.8850740194320679,
-0.08723346889019012,
1.09083092212677,
0.6172378063201904,
0.3202435076236725,
0.09010476619005203,
0.327219694852829,
0.8366618752479553,
-0.5838990211486816,
-0.678317666053772,
-1.0224628448486328,
0.7218829989433289,
-0.2626936137676239,
-0.5734472870826721,
0.14774411916732788,
0.37904348969459534,
0.9761573076248169,
0.012752778828144073,
0.8678126335144043,
0.33288946747779846,
0.2556940019130707,
-0.7633880972862244,
0.2901567220687866,
-0.4992765784263611,
0.25117868185043335,
0.05873838812112808,
-0.605776309967041,
-0.24341820180416107,
0.690589427947998,
-0.29182320833206177,
0.010290089063346386,
0.8124687075614929,
0.3118828535079956,
0.029414061456918716,
0.1943233609199524,
0.08971334248781204,
-0.16786353290081024,
0.4822518825531006,
1.0274080038070679,
1.3553375005722046,
0.22115778923034668,
0.4901403486728668,
-0.05037972331047058,
-0.27445608377456665,
-0.014017179608345032,
-0.7927833795547485,
-0.8164693713188171,
-0.21722501516342163,
-0.4034971296787262,
-0.17570821940898895,
0.0837499275803566,
0.9279953837394714,
0.6513679623603821,
-0.7142152786254883,
-0.31524425745010376,
-0.5703046917915344,
0.6035702228546143,
-0.45044058561325073,
-0.17752927541732788,
-0.19165830314159393,
-0.7920054793357849,
-0.4356035888195038,
0.22032485902309418,
0.3302760720252991,
-0.16575363278388977,
-0.5185067057609558,
-0.4585818648338318,
-0.027018949389457703,
0.10660906881093979,
0.3214561939239502,
0.2065209299325943,
-0.685288667678833,
0.09637415409088135,
-0.13513465225696564,
0.011835482902824879,
0.1087888777256012,
0.9321091771125793,
-0.5507313013076782,
0.3956775665283203,
0.6330526471138,
0.9838277697563171,
0.6896970868110657,
-0.2518060505390167,
0.33095231652259827,
-0.412529319524765,
0.11722982674837112,
0.7073054909706116,
0.44756653904914856,
0.23642100393772125,
-0.13020561635494232,
0.4566154181957245,
0.43009939789772034,
-0.5245981812477112,
-0.4609380066394806,
0.5827819108963013,
-0.7155239582061768,
-0.502151370048523,
1.133267879486084,
-0.24650751054286957,
-0.16646616160869598,
-0.0239558182656765,
-0.016872163861989975,
0.1611984372138977,
-0.438946932554245,
0.5170087814331055,
0.7181723713874817,
-0.47094669938087463,
-0.2648337483406067,
-0.37449201941490173,
0.3563593626022339,
0.2541028559207916,
-0.9587238430976868,
-0.16537970304489136,
0.26739928126335144,
0.2894105017185211,
0.10952343791723251,
0.7969000339508057,
0.17532436549663544,
0.12764951586723328,
0.26115682721138,
-0.14071276783943176,
-0.07559904456138611,
-0.5254514813423157,
-0.3462526500225067,
0.0665273368358612,
0.055097006261348724,
-0.1422114074230194
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.05661v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.05661v1
|
MS-HuBERT: Mitigating Pre-training and Inference Mismatch in Masked Language Modelling methods for learning Speech Representations
| 2024-06-09T06:30:28 | 2024-06-09T06:30:28 |
Hemant Yadav, Sunayana Sitaram, Rajiv Ratn Shah
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In recent years, self-supervised pre-training methods have gained significant
traction in learning high-level information from raw speech. Among these
methods, HuBERT has demonstrated SOTA performance in automatic speech
recognition (ASR). However, HuBERT's performance lags behind data2vec due to
disparities in pre-training strategies. In this paper, we propose (i) a Swap
method to address pre-training and inference mismatch observed in HuBERT and
(ii) incorporates Multicluster masked prediction loss for more effective
utilization of the models capacity. The resulting method is, MS-HuBERT, an
end-to-end self-supervised pre-training method for learning robust speech
representations. It beats vanilla HuBERT on the ASR Librispeech benchmark on
average by a 5% margin when evaluated on different finetuning splits.
Additionally, we demonstrate that the learned embeddings obtained during
pre-training encode essential information for improving performance of content
based tasks such as ASR.
|
[
-0.4095075726509094,
-0.5235296487808228,
0.18632619082927704,
0.2606911063194275,
-0.17879998683929443,
0.250928670167923,
-0.08238107711076736,
-0.20575204491615295,
0.5445098280906677,
0.5636743903160095,
-0.49856358766555786,
-0.06503145396709442,
-0.6812021732330322,
-0.11945754289627075,
-0.11849793046712875,
0.602687418460846,
-0.08682920783758163,
0.3180786669254303,
-0.34474536776542664,
0.1658393293619156,
-0.26377397775650024,
-0.6405514478683472,
-0.5850549340248108,
-0.21882325410842896,
0.19882920384407043,
0.39508211612701416,
0.474473774433136,
0.5156460404396057,
-0.025357557460665703,
0.31562623381614685,
0.24365048110485077,
0.2457754760980606,
-0.6204405426979065,
0.14633071422576904,
0.00662566302344203,
-0.06456691771745682,
-0.4387039542198181,
0.2393827736377716,
0.7605863213539124,
0.6002200841903687,
-0.45655545592308044,
0.04817724972963333,
0.2255890965461731,
0.25221574306488037,
-0.8942735195159912,
0.05906199291348457,
-0.7492960691452026,
0.07484078407287598,
-0.4035469591617584,
-0.18819718062877655,
-0.5610941648483276,
0.22321245074272156,
-0.08619473874568939,
-0.7470266819000244,
0.1664106249809265,
0.08640152961015701,
0.9676295518875122,
0.33613321185112,
-0.07279374450445175,
-0.004728450905531645,
-0.5640564560890198,
1.0315635204315186,
-0.7027187347412109,
0.5013719201087952,
0.7950231432914734,
0.41767561435699463,
0.07410146296024323,
-0.39511585235595703,
-0.6186901330947876,
-0.06300202012062073,
-0.20133472979068756,
0.1829329878091812,
-0.2396131455898285,
0.11159642785787582,
0.342436820268631,
0.07627655565738678,
-0.5176516175270081,
0.15849639475345612,
-0.5712298154830933,
-0.5386604070663452,
0.5660200715065002,
-0.33002686500549316,
-0.2141784131526947,
-0.04182829707860947,
-0.4009642004966736,
-0.2570691704750061,
-0.5660019516944885,
-0.14383834600448608,
0.6786168813705444,
0.30072373151779175,
0.00726304342970252,
0.2946169078350067,
-0.18953949213027954,
0.642966091632843,
0.1899903416633606,
-0.039412662386894226,
0.5762434601783752,
0.12928041815757751,
-0.23298360407352448,
0.30934229493141174,
0.6948374509811401,
-0.17848490178585052,
0.3331347107887268,
0.12510687112808228,
-0.23316679894924164,
-0.06459195911884308,
0.24780388176441193,
-0.6731410622596741,
-0.6832184791564941,
-0.03363481163978577,
-0.2720350921154022,
0.0587872713804245,
0.26546362042427063,
-0.40605661273002625,
0.16494303941726685,
-0.4556221067905426,
0.902650773525238,
-0.2147430032491684,
-0.31934377551078796,
0.13463564217090607,
0.057419661432504654,
-0.17441941797733307,
0.3505617380142212,
-0.8385361433029175,
0.5172410011291504,
0.3510165512561798,
0.4445247948169708,
-0.11993913352489471,
-0.3453314006328583,
-0.942233145236969,
0.2801346182823181,
-0.38637396693229675,
0.5932992696762085,
-0.47974860668182373,
-0.13030238449573517,
-0.1783178746700287,
-0.2634557783603668,
-0.22367827594280243,
-0.6954136490821838,
0.20831824839115143,
-0.3763042092323303,
0.2796308994293213,
0.10094689577817917,
-0.3773052394390106,
-0.1439683586359024,
-0.06616834551095963,
-0.5560997128486633,
1.0396453142166138,
-0.005620993208140135,
-0.8106955289840698,
0.1694217026233673,
-0.4170343279838562,
-0.4102688133716583,
-0.3574966788291931,
-0.12850375473499298,
-0.8468546867370605,
0.014554369263350964,
0.3819870352745056,
0.7549287676811218,
0.15937641263008118,
0.39700764417648315,
-0.40571749210357666,
-0.2523595690727234,
0.13645553588867188,
-0.41411951184272766,
0.6965662837028503,
0.17808297276496887,
-0.305842787027359,
0.28018030524253845,
-0.8359926342964172,
0.04114263504743576,
-0.1614745706319809,
0.13014599680900574,
-0.43913784623146057,
-0.20582331717014313,
0.15127575397491455,
0.3846997022628784,
-0.05996868014335632,
-0.38157564401626587,
-0.27198415994644165,
-0.20630842447280884,
0.2956145405769348,
0.8483154773712158,
-0.4825367331504822,
0.3671719431877136,
-0.2298353761434555,
0.5142117142677307,
0.2580096423625946,
0.02843010239303112,
-0.26005810499191284,
-0.39777907729148865,
-0.7032671570777893,
-0.6654481291770935,
0.7368702292442322,
0.5697745680809021,
-0.801537275314331,
0.2966997027397156,
-0.04542068764567375,
-0.07228929549455643,
-1.0339269638061523,
0.037977758795022964,
0.647489607334137,
0.5101404786109924,
0.782458484172821,
-0.4571390151977539,
-0.7114863991737366,
-0.9753372073173523,
-0.24987927079200745,
0.1398259997367859,
-0.25209325551986694,
0.10950489342212677,
0.32958653569221497,
-0.39242023229599,
0.928968608379364,
-0.3411456346511841,
-0.3082670271396637,
-0.06637483835220337,
0.3488979637622833,
-0.031220940873026848,
0.8971861600875854,
0.21673360466957092,
-0.7291982173919678,
-0.6183748841285706,
-0.35708296298980713,
-0.3639875650405884,
-0.262639582157135,
-0.19598044455051422,
-0.11982370913028717,
0.1982545703649521,
0.8111087083816528,
-0.4067276120185852,
0.5417580008506775,
0.6233055591583252,
0.1549166589975357,
0.6530893445014954,
-0.2468719631433487,
0.03116065450012684,
-0.944111704826355,
-0.05781983956694603,
-0.49850156903266907,
-0.5734856128692627,
-0.8079143762588501,
-0.3682394325733185,
0.01929052360355854,
-0.08437102288007736,
-0.34402787685394287,
0.5897051095962524,
-0.7253288626670837,
-0.14380837976932526,
-0.09420251101255417,
0.039992161095142365,
0.02389383874833584,
0.3272314965724945,
0.145942822098732,
0.7244076728820801,
0.8876900672912598,
-0.5031135678291321,
-0.2189800888299942,
0.2941248118877411,
-0.1582956165075302,
0.3785031735897064,
-0.49089357256889343,
0.31756091117858887,
-0.14345309138298035,
0.08891986310482025,
-0.7164689898490906,
-0.11762441694736481,
0.35268765687942505,
-0.5244036912918091,
0.9837538003921509,
0.028361374512314796,
-0.38064834475517273,
-0.06068243086338043,
-0.3844224810600281,
0.36976802349090576,
0.2516944706439972,
-0.5990486741065979,
0.8053067922592163,
0.5716770887374878,
-0.11304447799921036,
-0.8832541108131409,
-0.6898014545440674,
-0.017359895631670952,
-0.21775947511196136,
-0.5681294798851013,
0.6432865262031555,
-0.154960498213768,
0.014228226616978645,
-0.1704743653535843,
-0.32908621430397034,
-0.08698759227991104,
-0.03659164905548096,
0.07281451672315598,
-0.028936365619301796,
-0.3001258671283722,
0.013273008167743683,
0.11116036027669907,
-0.5804082155227661,
-0.14173045754432678,
-0.2868615388870239,
0.5204967856407166,
0.06954996287822723,
-0.46032947301864624,
-0.44110456109046936,
0.5725343823432922,
0.03659810870885849,
-0.2532971501350403,
0.7209615111351013,
0.7956515550613403,
-0.41661301255226135,
-0.1317509561777115,
-0.9138637781143188,
-0.4328804016113281,
-0.4593560993671417,
0.2530716061592102,
-0.5451903343200684,
-1.0364023447036743,
0.5629882216453552,
0.17053598165512085,
-0.346569299697876,
0.2914799749851227,
0.2056870460510254,
-0.30670687556266785,
0.5958166718482971,
0.52666175365448,
-0.14680524170398712,
0.4444715678691864,
-0.21967309713363647,
0.3007521331310272,
-0.748639702796936,
-0.08878310769796371,
-0.3964872360229492,
-0.0765649825334549,
-0.48792287707328796,
-0.800624430179596,
0.161958709359169,
0.35685354471206665,
-0.36836716532707214,
0.27643877267837524,
-0.2034953236579895,
0.3890870213508606,
0.7647018432617188,
-0.038293346762657166,
0.14593985676765442,
0.33101731538772583,
-0.055253464728593826,
-0.18844635784626007,
-0.9454989433288574,
-0.24485661089420319,
0.9029698371887207,
0.19591690599918365,
0.9757232666015625,
-0.12286576628684998,
0.828643798828125,
0.1327563375234604,
0.2338682860136032,
-0.3189637362957001,
0.41190487146377563,
-0.10297667235136032,
-0.5398760437965393,
-0.4332595467567444,
-0.6660321354866028,
-0.7438921928405762,
0.520723819732666,
-0.25786158442497253,
-0.6229866743087769,
0.12802904844284058,
0.4862573742866516,
-0.2676330506801605,
0.15457673370838165,
-0.5639742612838745,
1.1162933111190796,
0.053644150495529175,
-0.24284470081329346,
-0.2932133376598358,
-0.9415310025215149,
0.18806429207324982,
-0.21575939655303955,
0.17947518825531006,
-0.11008395254611969,
0.3209037780761719,
0.7675977349281311,
-0.28073790669441223,
0.7034733295440674,
-0.24509760737419128,
0.27347078919410706,
0.16980519890785217,
0.012843277305364609,
0.248668372631073,
0.03914766386151314,
-0.015665274113416672,
0.563906729221344,
-0.2340892255306244,
-0.5800836086273193,
-0.4938676357269287,
0.4181438982486725,
-0.6447351574897766,
-0.5681037902832031,
-0.6066469550132751,
-0.18069380521774292,
-0.23823902010917664,
-0.0025157949421554804,
0.43185922503471375,
0.4134669005870819,
-0.09266876429319382,
-0.0223142821341753,
0.7603758573532104,
-0.08581262081861496,
0.2574707865715027,
0.546400785446167,
-0.22046126425266266,
-0.43885537981987,
0.8656521439552307,
0.20635543763637543,
0.4416996240615845,
0.615032970905304,
0.15341722965240479,
-0.2732008099555969,
-0.411586195230484,
-0.3043422996997833,
0.22473254799842834,
-0.6096617579460144,
-0.4455733001232147,
-0.8456531763076782,
-0.3584107458591461,
-0.41088199615478516,
-0.10142318159341812,
-0.46535515785217285,
-0.5213189125061035,
-0.5224579572677612,
-0.10391248762607574,
-0.027441512793302536,
0.32950669527053833,
-0.6590556502342224,
0.6947411894798279,
-0.3726458251476288,
0.2667732834815979,
0.4691985547542572,
0.14795991778373718,
-0.23769108951091766,
-0.696684718132019,
-0.2111309915781021,
0.05956697091460228,
-0.23246720433235168,
-0.8395184278488159,
0.41432419419288635,
0.5564287304878235,
0.6324454545974731,
0.5811966061592102,
0.03266342729330063,
1.0344291925430298,
-0.6389570832252502,
0.3106255829334259,
0.22854600846767426,
-1.2856049537658691,
0.5385118126869202,
-0.14838673174381256,
0.1360042840242386,
0.5932185053825378,
0.4784434735774994,
-0.15513692796230316,
-0.2603857219219208,
-0.8082365989685059,
-0.650583028793335,
0.9486444592475891,
0.33419564366340637,
0.1499520242214203,
0.2818407416343689,
-0.11369180679321289,
0.10881301760673523,
0.5781566500663757,
-0.665385365486145,
-0.18882952630519867,
-0.40795937180519104,
0.05154984071850777,
-0.3700348138809204,
-0.38984182476997375,
0.09301381558179855,
-0.3812955319881439,
0.9627957344055176,
-0.18564242124557495,
0.39109593629837036,
-0.03496097773313522,
-0.2612418830394745,
0.029540136456489563,
0.13790655136108398,
0.7296000719070435,
0.5970358848571777,
-0.20242202281951904,
0.41963037848472595,
0.2516542673110962,
-0.4586578607559204,
-0.17286421358585358,
0.3864360451698303,
0.01926621049642563,
0.30310654640197754,
0.3039846420288086,
0.9616014361381531,
0.40983855724334717,
-0.46295225620269775,
0.5634185075759888,
0.18011541664600372,
-0.06552664190530777,
-0.2364381104707718,
-0.24896925687789917,
-0.06616394221782684,
-0.03612760081887245,
0.29692262411117554,
0.4875955879688263,
0.16045203804969788,
-0.35321277379989624,
0.5209212303161621,
0.37595421075820923,
-0.5291754603385925,
-0.2675856351852417,
0.5364026427268982,
-0.2778263986110687,
-0.13807635009288788,
0.5334888100624084,
-0.41998037695884705,
-0.7093308568000793,
0.09677033871412277,
0.5855050683021545,
0.6727439165115356,
-1.0829780101776123,
0.2963619530200958,
0.15740105509757996,
0.30973538756370544,
-0.22108641266822815,
0.3183092772960663,
-0.25387322902679443,
-0.7011629343032837,
-0.6279557347297668,
-0.590386152267456,
-0.21761691570281982,
0.06071972846984863,
-0.7269087433815002,
0.28592246770858765,
-0.09253524988889694,
-0.053446222096681595,
-0.08160501718521118,
-0.31814271211624146,
-0.5877631902694702,
0.0061391303315758705,
0.026122214272618294,
0.4904747009277344,
-0.8627105951309204,
0.9428820013999939,
0.3224034011363983,
-0.006670584436506033,
-0.7866737246513367,
0.05344171077013016,
-0.0961618721485138,
-0.6284665465354919,
0.6018022894859314,
0.36353933811187744,
-0.3824824392795563,
-0.09635745733976364,
-0.5246554613113403,
-0.8772742748260498,
0.533928394317627,
0.6754261255264282,
-0.4523807764053345,
0.3417164981365204,
-0.02126789651811123,
0.21147142350673676,
-0.42661744356155396,
0.3764438033103943,
0.25422027707099915,
0.2642226219177246,
0.14686891436576843,
-1.2351967096328735,
-0.23748837411403656,
-0.08531466871500015,
-0.00028724787989631295,
-0.01002905610948801,
-0.23515349626541138,
1.0656578540802002,
-0.10464341193437576,
-0.26228564977645874,
-0.21436941623687744,
0.78563392162323,
0.2946304678916931,
0.5117670893669128,
0.5217279195785522,
0.5649744272232056,
0.8203569054603577,
0.03040190041065216,
0.5491188764572144,
0.08184284716844559,
0.36423438787460327,
1.3359137773513794,
-0.104155994951725,
1.1296467781066895,
0.4477103054523468,
-0.1486150324344635,
0.3328459560871124,
0.5376154780387878,
0.2763287127017975,
0.7934934496879578,
0.4894811809062958,
-0.10017260164022446,
-0.6132393479347229,
0.24113595485687256,
-0.49570396542549133,
0.600120484828949,
0.43545374274253845,
-0.010726227425038815,
-0.10572691261768341,
0.2980102598667145,
0.10765336453914642,
0.13365024328231812,
-0.24061428010463715,
0.5711579918861389,
0.265408456325531,
-0.2556593418121338,
0.7652615308761597,
-0.07178055495023727,
0.825239360332489,
-0.651724100112915,
-0.1311129331588745,
0.047000039368867874,
0.07031217962503433,
-0.18772299587726593,
-0.25760769844055176,
0.45384272933006287,
-0.4152110815048218,
-0.21589219570159912,
-0.6600860357284546,
0.7578215599060059,
-0.7886687517166138,
-0.37952643632888794,
0.2724568247795105,
0.3675127327442169,
0.3737632632255554,
-0.36804574728012085,
-0.7147582769393921,
0.041592128574848175,
-0.10386180132627487,
0.08491112291812897,
0.3955013155937195,
0.2346622496843338,
-0.07111500948667526,
0.5432903170585632,
0.6104387640953064,
-0.09754869341850281,
0.1371038407087326,
-0.0011328499531373382,
0.8846475481987,
-0.2056138813495636,
-0.8428127765655518,
-0.710269570350647,
0.5539501309394836,
-0.28795361518859863,
0.029713815078139305,
0.7396737337112427,
0.7666106820106506,
1.1202380657196045,
-0.3178422749042511,
0.33435478806495667,
0.3644702434539795,
0.8052844405174255,
-0.7802270650863647,
0.891130268573761,
-0.3374006748199463,
0.1944751888513565,
-0.455952912569046,
-0.8951755166053772,
-0.3258330523967743,
1.2251081466674805,
-0.17940373718738556,
0.2605521082878113,
0.3939256966114044,
0.9176185131072998,
-0.5479505062103271,
-0.07989266514778137,
0.5498186349868774,
0.3318115174770355,
0.02443145029246807,
0.05891229957342148,
0.8129058480262756,
-0.6059378981590271,
0.12201323360204697,
-0.022729888558387756,
-0.26636046171188354,
-0.3275153636932373,
-0.7370230555534363,
-1.0552021265029907,
-0.7619996666908264,
-0.5172991752624512,
-0.3144172728061676,
0.26760002970695496,
0.871567964553833,
1.2452031373977661,
-1.0538337230682373,
-0.2475963830947876,
0.4977795481681824,
0.04901448264718056,
-0.3317570984363556,
-0.11928364634513855,
0.37656623125076294,
-0.21357691287994385,
-0.3589082360267639,
0.6272951364517212,
0.2647748589515686,
0.10045111924409866,
-0.34939518570899963,
-0.219206765294075,
-0.09831786900758743,
-0.0479336753487587,
0.5358293056488037,
0.23893313109874725,
-0.7617231607437134,
-0.09072186052799225,
-0.12114996463060379,
0.25084763765335083,
0.2587231397628784,
0.7882970571517944,
-1.03802490234375,
0.6630450487136841,
0.13749949634075165,
0.4691365957260132,
1.0187954902648926,
-0.01087944395840168,
0.4628877639770508,
-1.024794340133667,
0.22821325063705444,
0.2756913900375366,
0.14636440575122833,
0.59678053855896,
-0.06566794216632843,
0.23315487802028656,
0.08450644463300705,
-0.3552002012729645,
-0.9261793494224548,
0.20295189321041107,
-1.0101829767227173,
-0.10563170164823532,
0.7883905172348022,
-0.1790366768836975,
0.034545693546533585,
-0.3465111255645752,
-0.11432525515556335,
0.1383286565542221,
-0.4135925769805908,
0.7359439730644226,
0.4375348389148712,
-0.05446212738752365,
-0.2113809436559677,
-0.7228385210037231,
0.7728574872016907,
0.5335921049118042,
-0.6204912066459656,
-0.01864561252295971,
0.14897818863391876,
0.23092731833457947,
0.3705657720565796,
0.8706023097038269,
0.2769346535205841,
-0.03465116769075394,
-0.036808691918849945,
-0.03335085138678551,
-0.16838954389095306,
-0.7000641822814941,
-0.30709001421928406,
-0.13154366612434387,
-0.3336315155029297,
-0.37592536211013794
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.05659v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.05659v1
|
Do LLMs Exhibit Human-Like Reasoning? Evaluating Theory of Mind in LLMs for Open-Ended Responses
| 2024-06-09T05:57:59 | 2024-06-09T05:57:59 |
Maryam Amirizaniani, Elias Martin, Maryna Sivachenko, Afra Mashhadi, Chirag Shah
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Theory of Mind (ToM) reasoning entails recognizing that other individuals
possess their own intentions, emotions, and thoughts, which is vital for
guiding one's own thought processes. Although large language models (LLMs)
excel in tasks such as summarization, question answering, and translation, they
still face challenges with ToM reasoning, especially in open-ended questions.
Despite advancements, the extent to which LLMs truly understand ToM reasoning
and how closely it aligns with human ToM reasoning remains inadequately
explored in open-ended scenarios. Motivated by this gap, we assess the
abilities of LLMs to perceive and integrate human intentions and emotions into
their ToM reasoning processes within open-ended questions. Our study utilizes
posts from Reddit's ChangeMyView platform, which demands nuanced social
reasoning to craft persuasive responses. Our analysis, comparing semantic
similarity and lexical overlap metrics between responses generated by humans
and LLMs, reveals clear disparities in ToM reasoning capabilities in open-ended
questions, with even the most advanced models showing notable limitations. To
enhance LLM capabilities, we implement a prompt tuning method that incorporates
human intentions and emotions, resulting in improvements in ToM reasoning
performance. However, despite these improvements, the enhancement still falls
short of fully achieving human-like reasoning. This research highlights the
deficiencies in LLMs' social reasoning and demonstrates how integrating human
intentions and emotions can boost their effectiveness.
|
[
-0.7669808268547058,
-0.9299256205558777,
1.1195145845413208,
-0.13259178400039673,
-0.5349977016448975,
-0.023297671228647232,
-0.6727659106254578,
-0.4711921513080597,
0.31078580021858215,
0.1911247968673706,
-0.7834921479225159,
-0.39851781725883484,
-0.17606405913829803,
0.2905901074409485,
0.19023175537586212,
0.5501387715339661,
-0.06544117629528046,
0.09873876720666885,
-0.23889893293380737,
-0.1600552797317505,
-0.25331607460975647,
-0.5364589691162109,
-0.638482391834259,
-0.6128685474395752,
0.8206285834312439,
0.4054829180240631,
0.6610553860664368,
0.2743208706378937,
0.46480584144592285,
0.17703469097614288,
-0.1706669181585312,
0.4491147994995117,
-0.44726142287254333,
0.2523219585418701,
-0.5341026782989502,
-0.6702201962471008,
-0.5034112334251404,
0.14898838102817535,
0.3476542830467224,
0.5429915189743042,
-0.004437641706317663,
0.20800429582595825,
0.19328413903713226,
0.6221950650215149,
-0.6239655613899231,
-0.1554577350616455,
-0.66829514503479,
0.10918057709932327,
-0.11848132312297821,
-0.4539761245250702,
-0.3102727234363556,
-0.46179983019828796,
0.2822445034980774,
-0.37678492069244385,
0.11122757941484451,
0.09403198957443237,
0.562778890132904,
0.2558262348175049,
-0.4699160158634186,
-0.26886531710624695,
-0.482527494430542,
0.6879175305366516,
-0.5825087428092957,
0.25108417868614197,
0.22181062400341034,
0.18073976039886475,
-0.346439003944397,
-0.0833941102027893,
-0.9330902099609375,
0.10534632951021194,
-0.05875628814101219,
0.08253568410873413,
-0.24218453466892242,
0.32677406072616577,
0.39833271503448486,
0.3192862570285797,
-0.6904873251914978,
-0.10650283098220825,
0.01555243693292141,
0.0999089777469635,
0.8132439851760864,
0.32540813088417053,
0.21157222986221313,
-0.16386821866035461,
-0.33104071021080017,
-0.18923114240169525,
-0.449917733669281,
0.26138317584991455,
0.3392263650894165,
0.18557633459568024,
-0.07909077405929565,
0.6491903066635132,
-0.19399932026863098,
0.5920498371124268,
0.024352142587304115,
0.14259415864944458,
-0.12861673533916473,
0.10538330674171448,
-0.40764692425727844,
-0.1562647521495819,
0.6225050687789917,
0.7447198629379272,
0.9404201507568359,
0.13563410937786102,
-0.24562305212020874,
0.3496122658252716,
0.41957569122314453,
-0.35774004459381104,
-0.012778183445334435,
0.38235920667648315,
-0.6538138389587402,
-0.07422728091478348,
0.08475305140018463,
-0.6623644828796387,
-0.6181488633155823,
-0.27341577410697937,
0.30275121331214905,
-0.24147485196590424,
-0.4733920991420746,
0.4783678352832794,
-0.18570111691951752,
0.39962589740753174,
0.57930588722229,
-0.698727011680603,
0.1457391381263733,
0.6601034998893738,
0.5316665172576904,
-0.087052121758461,
-0.08290138095617294,
0.03010752983391285,
0.003788858186453581,
-0.3682044744491577,
1.0364203453063965,
-0.649581789970398,
-0.5245665907859802,
0.04925139248371124,
-0.17486163973808289,
0.05213186889886856,
-0.40808576345443726,
0.451576828956604,
-0.34542185068130493,
0.41923195123672485,
-0.7625576853752136,
-0.36847350001335144,
-0.4179302453994751,
0.4755997061729431,
-0.13266250491142273,
0.45056504011154175,
-0.18853650987148285,
-0.6657324433326721,
0.2280789166688919,
-0.9285327792167664,
-0.41809260845184326,
0.08457839488983154,
-0.40825358033180237,
0.1983579695224762,
0.3877716064453125,
0.06753168255090714,
0.6233946681022644,
-0.6837702989578247,
0.20068490505218506,
-0.62432861328125,
-0.4334801435470581,
0.8501791954040527,
-0.32422468066215515,
0.7241395115852356,
0.3123796582221985,
-0.14671754837036133,
0.26504525542259216,
-0.3910495340824127,
0.16818653047084808,
0.3389676511287689,
-0.16862784326076508,
-0.5532933473587036,
-0.09445580095052719,
-0.3855421543121338,
0.23208087682724,
0.2785158157348633,
-0.527346134185791,
0.5043634176254272,
-0.21788743138313293,
0.47297728061676025,
1.0862352848052979,
0.08514301478862762,
0.33775150775909424,
-0.50948566198349,
0.5693003535270691,
-0.10485952347517014,
0.03434658795595169,
-0.12354355305433273,
-0.7315573692321777,
-0.6421050429344177,
-0.005961006507277489,
-0.38123655319213867,
0.322589248418808,
-0.3868125379085541,
0.2755540609359741,
-0.10385244339704514,
-0.38060462474823,
-0.6245051026344299,
-0.13770164549350739,
0.46361061930656433,
0.45219677686691284,
0.2357145994901657,
-0.2555774450302124,
-0.4523070752620697,
-0.9507993459701538,
-0.6634543538093567,
-0.4468672573566437,
-0.2045958936214447,
0.41414955258369446,
0.3608989715576172,
-0.00037922331830486655,
0.8733330368995667,
-0.7905887365341187,
0.2153189331293106,
-0.1978003829717636,
0.09852128475904465,
0.05042091757059097,
0.1480773538351059,
0.17677851021289825,
-0.5774872303009033,
-0.03680919483304024,
-0.011612499132752419,
-0.9860630035400391,
-0.2042091190814972,
-0.08461911231279373,
-0.32593852281570435,
0.2270846962928772,
0.13120098412036896,
-0.9210700392723083,
0.44353288412094116,
0.07073063403367996,
-0.655888020992279,
0.42632293701171875,
-0.08659683912992477,
0.4616103768348694,
-0.9262179136276245,
-0.2122601419687271,
0.19665144383907318,
0.02707899920642376,
-0.4299025237560272,
-0.028588443994522095,
-0.05226625129580498,
0.18374688923358917,
-0.41756314039230347,
0.8330255746841431,
-0.393532395362854,
-0.26736772060394287,
-0.1301933228969574,
0.36614587903022766,
-0.04930955544114113,
0.5744079947471619,
0.16984006762504578,
0.6670991778373718,
0.267113596200943,
-0.7965989708900452,
0.3225836753845215,
0.13109853863716125,
-0.3174046576023102,
1.0238932371139526,
-0.5341328978538513,
0.41783636808395386,
-0.32257580757141113,
0.22212518751621246,
-1.069621205329895,
-0.5075170993804932,
0.5376973748207092,
-0.605862021446228,
-0.005882009398192167,
0.17441585659980774,
-0.3977797329425812,
-0.5194491147994995,
-0.2919710874557495,
0.16345907747745514,
0.723639726638794,
-0.32133984565734863,
0.6729414463043213,
0.17301848530769348,
0.0036767807323485613,
-0.1293550729751587,
-0.913719892501831,
-0.023573478683829308,
-0.39314761757850647,
-0.6923407912254333,
0.027388796210289,
-0.17896610498428345,
-0.8975118398666382,
0.04358942434191704,
-0.06891347467899323,
-0.06791079789400101,
0.009010514244437218,
0.08468666672706604,
0.08935041725635529,
-0.17167791724205017,
0.40918534994125366,
0.08911509066820145,
0.1849801242351532,
0.30299103260040283,
-0.16461887955665588,
0.46226510405540466,
-0.1809389889240265,
-0.6108860373497009,
-0.5835233330726624,
0.1392720639705658,
0.7011178731918335,
-0.15960101783275604,
0.4844334125518799,
0.19889652729034424,
-0.43973255157470703,
-0.14080755412578583,
-0.7222084403038025,
-0.5512959361076355,
-0.3716152608394623,
0.011450800113379955,
-0.5789291262626648,
-1.034449815750122,
0.5405474901199341,
0.141507089138031,
0.09601765125989914,
0.1799771636724472,
0.6890875101089478,
-0.5515291094779968,
0.9927029013633728,
0.19168946146965027,
0.40567025542259216,
0.2924969792366028,
0.1110333651304245,
0.07910477370023727,
-1.0630515813827515,
-0.2571019232273102,
-0.2489195168018341,
-0.6405259966850281,
-0.3470122218132019,
-0.4249553978443146,
0.163968026638031,
-0.11787466704845428,
-0.3919951319694519,
0.025512222200632095,
-0.6404062509536743,
0.4392821490764618,
0.2841625213623047,
0.21444082260131836,
0.3737960755825043,
-0.21340811252593994,
0.028968628495931625,
0.006065453868359327,
-0.40676257014274597,
-0.8149002194404602,
1.0411772727966309,
0.34897226095199585,
0.8365470767021179,
0.30792203545570374,
0.6094871759414673,
0.38581183552742004,
0.3817625641822815,
-0.5932052135467529,
0.9813582897186279,
0.35974758863449097,
-0.663314163684845,
-0.35203540325164795,
-0.28450021147727966,
-0.8970829248428345,
0.36743882298469543,
-0.25842493772506714,
-0.8866128325462341,
0.15310227870941162,
0.23198390007019043,
-0.2673288881778717,
0.4904629588127136,
-0.571976363658905,
0.5009822249412537,
-0.3274884521961212,
-0.24099478125572205,
-0.4738985002040863,
-0.6442755460739136,
0.5271068215370178,
0.08662919700145721,
0.032321106642484665,
-0.2785533368587494,
-0.03820427134633064,
0.6512305736541748,
-0.02665148861706257,
0.7704485654830933,
-0.19732382893562317,
-0.47710365056991577,
0.4115137755870819,
0.03520048037171364,
0.23305362462997437,
-0.10443751513957977,
-0.05616068094968796,
0.025886613875627518,
-0.38421565294265747,
-0.4255113899707794,
-0.9824983477592468,
0.4792375862598419,
-0.5636156797409058,
-0.9938191175460815,
-0.24392195045948029,
-0.465567409992218,
-0.25851985812187195,
0.01225214172154665,
-0.04003358632326126,
-0.033652205020189285,
-0.28478699922561646,
-0.04429254308342934,
0.9397910237312317,
-0.1312582790851593,
0.1746835559606552,
0.5923914909362793,
-0.3333553373813629,
-0.3902968168258667,
0.3881184756755829,
-0.09196840971708298,
0.36817336082458496,
0.3529767394065857,
0.31218019127845764,
-0.3513455092906952,
-0.14237280189990997,
-0.3391624987125397,
0.43087783455848694,
-0.7444989085197449,
0.005302663892507553,
-0.5785531997680664,
0.2754250764846802,
-0.30905333161354065,
-0.3871196508407593,
-0.09955578297376633,
-0.24442675709724426,
-0.2102978229522705,
-0.06050049141049385,
0.3800734579563141,
0.8914995193481445,
0.206782266497612,
0.0662173256278038,
-0.6066001057624817,
0.24597223103046417,
0.5288290977478027,
0.36167749762535095,
0.3739151954650879,
-0.46301308274269104,
0.041731417179107666,
0.36849233508110046,
-0.2941870391368866,
-1.078688621520996,
-0.12343215942382812,
-0.3169669508934021,
0.486175000667572,
0.8305624723434448,
0.2845204770565033,
0.7710766196250916,
-0.11740929633378983,
0.7450037598609924,
0.018794052302837372,
-0.7861723899841309,
0.6920064091682434,
-0.5365496873855591,
0.3712496757507324,
0.3059828579425812,
0.33461111783981323,
-0.5027790069580078,
-0.3088451325893402,
-0.4461919963359833,
-0.24776597321033478,
0.6014268398284912,
0.10623528063297272,
0.007500910200178623,
-0.34713539481163025,
0.5812883973121643,
-0.10709914565086365,
0.18096807599067688,
-0.49370068311691284,
-0.03494793921709061,
0.09761953353881836,
-0.13986852765083313,
0.024038754403591156,
-0.235426664352417,
-0.1750662475824356,
-0.10886096954345703,
0.4640766978263855,
-0.17556166648864746,
0.282532274723053,
0.5332503318786621,
0.15206056833267212,
-0.5544546842575073,
0.5604290962219238,
0.6824999451637268,
0.4331343472003937,
-0.3047996461391449,
0.18462499976158142,
0.32027554512023926,
-0.007200983352959156,
0.23654194176197052,
-0.29018718004226685,
0.06720353662967682,
-0.5108619928359985,
0.3175603151321411,
0.44450342655181885,
0.17155322432518005,
-0.9552359580993652,
0.4172806739807129,
-0.31903040409088135,
-0.18210826814174652,
-0.14777740836143494,
0.17205996811389923,
0.41902047395706177,
0.6709707975387573,
0.30752235651016235,
-0.042468078434467316,
-0.09595569968223572,
-0.8219928741455078,
-0.2927197515964508,
0.648140013217926,
-0.20976826548576355,
-0.49950799345970154,
0.6797559261322021,
0.3096810281276703,
-0.680691123008728,
0.534135639667511,
-0.2134118229150772,
-0.43105632066726685,
0.3955386281013489,
0.3592599332332611,
1.277140498161316,
-0.14393658936023712,
-0.15227589011192322,
0.032319217920303345,
0.35812756419181824,
0.0411873534321785,
0.8166763782501221,
-0.40849849581718445,
-1.1412179470062256,
-0.38415372371673584,
-0.41033485531806946,
-0.5639818906784058,
0.04221171885728836,
-0.8016260266304016,
0.19016072154045105,
-0.4963242709636688,
-0.35752934217453003,
-0.3061150014400482,
-0.14165200293064117,
-0.6842856407165527,
0.22388136386871338,
0.19213922321796417,
0.9561284184455872,
-0.6737852096557617,
0.6466172337532043,
1.3470221757888794,
-0.4045691192150116,
-0.49428340792655945,
0.44442158937454224,
0.13026370108127594,
-0.7679269909858704,
0.40810680389404297,
0.22953690588474274,
-0.4919471740722656,
-0.17211565375328064,
-0.46651211380958557,
-0.429238498210907,
0.9896535277366638,
0.32486554980278015,
-0.39304104447364807,
-0.1819087117910385,
-0.12919649481773376,
0.6786419749259949,
-0.4808710217475891,
0.19673791527748108,
0.35262978076934814,
0.6092430353164673,
-0.09172768890857697,
-0.6859055757522583,
0.16461676359176636,
-0.21671587228775024,
-0.022028552368283272,
0.11816304922103882,
-0.774620771408081,
0.6924443244934082,
-0.45180952548980713,
-0.38300302624702454,
-0.17219921946525574,
0.6711352467536926,
0.4005998373031616,
0.5708704590797424,
0.6291285157203674,
0.6419834494590759,
0.84110426902771,
0.10665158927440643,
1.0460814237594604,
-0.22401109337806702,
0.08101119101047516,
0.7300137877464294,
-0.5033779144287109,
0.6670055389404297,
0.4154370427131653,
-0.33231914043426514,
0.5251036286354065,
0.7009223103523254,
0.49525752663612366,
0.1932259052991867,
0.17119304835796356,
-0.3912145793437958,
-0.5583207607269287,
-0.19142243266105652,
-0.20765379071235657,
0.4990198612213135,
0.34159955382347107,
-0.22447076439857483,
0.13915316760540009,
-0.11179322004318237,
0.010298524983227253,
0.397377073764801,
-0.3620298206806183,
0.8083896040916443,
0.1833084523677826,
-0.8799504637718201,
0.29580628871917725,
-0.1989569514989853,
0.7440919876098633,
-0.4153941869735718,
0.04252183064818382,
-0.17430271208286285,
-0.04184439405798912,
-0.15183721482753754,
-1.2421901226043701,
0.2056712955236435,
0.20993800461292267,
-0.23403824865818024,
-0.3567245304584503,
0.8226393461227417,
-0.2790507674217224,
0.15632039308547974,
0.26708677411079407,
0.6959324479103088,
0.44916436076164246,
-0.1095295324921608,
-0.3445526361465454,
-0.005758881568908691,
0.17937657237052917,
-0.47059085965156555,
0.309940904378891,
0.6886366605758667,
-0.02736750803887844,
0.9382504820823669,
0.7509592175483704,
0.08493836969137192,
-0.5489000678062439,
-0.003908638842403889,
0.7933422327041626,
-1.0468305349349976,
-0.3333447575569153,
-1.1879922151565552,
0.4634253680706024,
-0.03389250114560127,
-0.4127538800239563,
0.5916752815246582,
0.2150297313928604,
0.8590262532234192,
-0.028280669823288918,
0.7547748684883118,
0.2037810981273651,
0.5379898548126221,
-0.4287036955356598,
0.5370361804962158,
-0.7165483832359314,
0.2193332016468048,
-0.40552324056625366,
-0.9098694920539856,
-0.1427503377199173,
0.7987083792686462,
-0.47493600845336914,
0.11314096301794052,
0.47274625301361084,
0.579793393611908,
0.18166887760162354,
0.41724419593811035,
0.40068796277046204,
0.14859533309936523,
0.15096430480480194,
0.7035300731658936,
1.1074408292770386,
0.44134676456451416,
0.2508266866207123,
0.015885338187217712,
-0.3573126494884491,
-0.16699464619159698,
-0.7915233969688416,
-1.0917725563049316,
-0.42816850543022156,
-0.033724453300237656,
-0.13654214143753052,
0.2607261836528778,
1.3416508436203003,
0.31824296712875366,
-0.3090114891529083,
-0.2022194117307663,
-0.13146942853927612,
0.34552863240242004,
0.09290636330842972,
-0.31801965832710266,
-0.02927067130804062,
-0.12161120772361755,
-0.5656760334968567,
0.11578889191150665,
0.5694906115531921,
0.13106580078601837,
-0.5717044472694397,
-0.059484489262104034,
-0.13317018747329712,
0.436631441116333,
0.6215845346450806,
0.11190951615571976,
-1.2200497388839722,
-0.6918238401412964,
0.13676850497722626,
-0.04999668151140213,
0.06094810739159584,
0.940670371055603,
-0.7160266041755676,
0.5141494274139404,
0.4462747871875763,
0.46017491817474365,
-0.05138736590743065,
0.20495066046714783,
0.6197549104690552,
-0.3367406129837036,
-0.07853644341230392,
0.3219764828681946,
0.4657072126865387,
0.2825393080711365,
-0.3628632426261902,
0.4953819811344147,
0.16738873720169067,
-0.6336630582809448,
-0.6936773061752319,
0.6491281390190125,
-0.8216033577919006,
-0.42307984828948975,
1.0843826532363892,
-0.044884078204631805,
-0.1501607745885849,
0.0823177769780159,
-0.3897652328014374,
0.25836336612701416,
-0.567946195602417,
0.8599132895469666,
0.9554324746131897,
-0.6666042804718018,
-0.2575482130050659,
-0.20265714824199677,
0.24160608649253845,
0.4196784198284149,
-0.8423901796340942,
0.2051873654127121,
0.3804432451725006,
-0.10375171899795532,
0.012958671897649765,
0.8692481517791748,
0.12959836423397064,
0.29499515891075134,
-0.33300918340682983,
0.27756163477897644,
0.15458783507347107,
0.029989028349518776,
-0.44114693999290466,
0.006189931184053421,
0.16854755580425262,
-0.1000775471329689
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.05654v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.05654v2
|
DomainRAG: A Chinese Benchmark for Evaluating Domain-specific Retrieval-Augmented Generation
| 2024-06-09T05:33:51 | 2024-06-17T03:01:39 |
Shuting Wang, Jiongnan Liu, Shiren Song, Jiehan Cheng, Yuqi Fu, Peidong Guo, Kun Fang, Yutao Zhu, Zhicheng Dou
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IR
|
Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG) offers a promising solution to address
various limitations of Large Language Models (LLMs), such as hallucination and
difficulties in keeping up with real-time updates. This approach is
particularly critical in expert and domain-specific applications where LLMs
struggle to cover expert knowledge. Therefore, evaluating RAG models in such
scenarios is crucial, yet current studies often rely on general knowledge
sources like Wikipedia to assess the models' abilities in solving common-sense
problems. In this paper, we evaluated LLMs by RAG settings in a domain-specific
context, college enrollment. We identified six required abilities for RAG
models, including the ability in conversational RAG, analyzing structural
information, faithfulness to external knowledge, denoising, solving
time-sensitive problems, and understanding multi-document interactions. Each
ability has an associated dataset with shared corpora to evaluate the RAG
models' performance. We evaluated popular LLMs such as Llama, Baichuan,
ChatGLM, and GPT models. Experimental results indicate that existing
closed-book LLMs struggle with domain-specific questions, highlighting the need
for RAG models to solve expert problems. Moreover, there is room for RAG models
to improve their abilities in comprehending conversational history, analyzing
structural information, denoising, processing multi-document interactions, and
faithfulness in expert knowledge. We expect future studies could solve these
problems better.
|
[
-0.4266531467437744,
-0.8826862573623657,
0.2785432040691376,
0.10696576535701752,
-0.12192287296056747,
0.24346120655536652,
-0.3113190829753876,
-0.469455361366272,
-0.11093699187040329,
0.38305696845054626,
-0.2337915599346161,
-0.29167574644088745,
-0.5588564872741699,
0.22304387390613556,
-0.47695261240005493,
1.0787389278411865,
-0.19927677512168884,
-0.07817256450653076,
-0.3227878510951996,
-0.012377491220831871,
-0.785747766494751,
-0.4693770408630371,
-0.6970627903938293,
-0.365335077047348,
0.2745010554790497,
0.09084438532590866,
0.40378761291503906,
0.3181380331516266,
0.6349266767501831,
0.25529393553733826,
-0.15980423986911774,
0.5738804340362549,
-0.7975095510482788,
0.3014534115791321,
-0.21109291911125183,
-0.07130959630012512,
-0.7718124389648438,
0.13487619161605835,
0.6250899434089661,
0.7782797813415527,
-0.12487508356571198,
0.2797515094280243,
0.13927599787712097,
0.5185627341270447,
-0.7311460375785828,
-0.13721849024295807,
-1.0288783311843872,
0.0068256426602602005,
-0.2793845236301422,
-0.2826654613018036,
-0.4388258457183838,
-0.2520162761211395,
0.12782283127307892,
-0.8259366154670715,
0.6306799054145813,
0.2162705510854721,
1.055008888244629,
0.34457871317863464,
-0.34162262082099915,
-0.32907623052597046,
-0.6659029722213745,
0.8119264245033264,
-0.4905299246311188,
0.4725624620914459,
0.4852045178413391,
0.5013765096664429,
-0.34293946623802185,
-0.7813507318496704,
-0.6344205737113953,
-0.24451285600662231,
-0.11715482175350189,
0.1914006471633911,
-0.041790712624788284,
-0.08133604377508163,
0.1815604269504547,
0.4294770359992981,
-0.8101968169212341,
-0.15290920436382294,
-0.490635484457016,
0.10621250420808792,
0.6349768042564392,
0.4337684214115143,
0.2803547978401184,
-0.23643285036087036,
-0.4168768525123596,
0.08199647814035416,
-0.668438196182251,
-0.1809401661157608,
0.20754344761371613,
0.2348216474056244,
0.16009284555912018,
0.3702712953090668,
-0.1234678402543068,
0.8765974044799805,
0.20707817375659943,
-0.16225335001945496,
0.02404000610113144,
-0.056482866406440735,
-0.21643105149269104,
-0.2926763892173767,
0.4319450259208679,
0.1400691568851471,
0.4170103371143341,
-0.29488444328308105,
-0.31957074999809265,
-0.10604158043861389,
0.5644100904464722,
-0.740524411201477,
-0.09369112551212311,
0.19871240854263306,
-0.3713628351688385,
-0.0923968032002449,
-0.03946946561336517,
-0.7021527886390686,
-0.42524445056915283,
-0.34489548206329346,
0.41613098978996277,
-0.29383018612861633,
-0.3222547769546509,
-0.05755532532930374,
-0.14514441788196564,
0.2531123161315918,
0.32134243845939636,
-0.7224375009536743,
0.3953666687011719,
0.9888491630554199,
0.6902099847793579,
-0.7788114547729492,
-0.4016566872596741,
-0.3964553773403168,
0.09887146204710007,
-0.41136786341667175,
1.0296837091445923,
-0.6635593771934509,
-0.6129599809646606,
0.015009362250566483,
-0.0692305639386177,
-0.5378907918930054,
-0.9621840119361877,
0.8693851828575134,
-0.7914794087409973,
0.03997300937771797,
-0.06357836723327637,
-0.7277716994285583,
-0.066745325922966,
0.25954243540763855,
-0.5597346425056458,
1.0358731746673584,
0.28854528069496155,
-0.8105884790420532,
0.24837929010391235,
-0.23721936345100403,
-0.12776316702365875,
0.4659607410430908,
-0.26678338646888733,
-0.2962363362312317,
-0.030621834099292755,
-0.1718331277370453,
0.6151289939880371,
-0.41552790999412537,
0.4925067126750946,
-0.00932255107909441,
-0.5279006958007812,
0.10447849333286285,
-0.3693258464336395,
0.6973899006843567,
0.3383042812347412,
-0.03149569034576416,
-0.29456213116645813,
-0.6014326214790344,
0.01108294166624546,
0.19087494909763336,
-0.4203227162361145,
-0.6151625514030457,
-0.26456642150878906,
0.03926478698849678,
-0.1533159613609314,
0.4075900912284851,
-0.1768110692501068,
0.24307185411453247,
-0.19842295348644257,
-0.24321530759334564,
0.6693028807640076,
0.037486732006073,
0.19626721739768982,
-0.47728148102760315,
0.6070315837860107,
-0.24776756763458252,
-0.1134076938033104,
0.019221115857362747,
-0.5235138535499573,
-0.7273837327957153,
-0.20063436031341553,
0.3795414865016937,
0.4523853659629822,
-0.7668875455856323,
0.06871698051691055,
-0.11870834231376648,
-0.5072020292282104,
-0.42584356665611267,
0.11768452823162079,
0.5874348282814026,
0.6933627128601074,
0.41859138011932373,
-0.3493857681751251,
-0.4223119914531708,
-0.5520849823951721,
-0.3964366614818573,
-0.03116774931550026,
0.019243506714701653,
0.6925849914550781,
0.5299540758132935,
-0.365343302488327,
0.8317505121231079,
-0.4969245493412018,
-0.2905789315700531,
-0.3270024061203003,
0.16572512686252594,
0.20013856887817383,
0.008728999644517899,
0.2851411700248718,
-1.0315868854522705,
-0.7370161414146423,
0.20187640190124512,
-0.7408400177955627,
-0.46212637424468994,
0.10001169890165329,
-0.10459299385547638,
0.40689000487327576,
-0.026940839365124702,
-0.6577174663543701,
0.525453507900238,
0.6763310432434082,
-0.4060375690460205,
0.9166455864906311,
-0.1395409256219864,
0.3354007601737976,
-0.7874996662139893,
0.44036662578582764,
-0.0017298333114013076,
0.02160872146487236,
-0.9480767846107483,
0.27969783544540405,
-0.06759561598300934,
-0.17224539816379547,
-0.17026814818382263,
1.0784589052200317,
-0.45706501603126526,
-0.22608792781829834,
-0.5240399837493896,
0.5159571170806885,
0.10293838381767273,
0.33607596158981323,
0.14993004500865936,
1.1556899547576904,
0.07762066274881363,
-0.8531631827354431,
0.07857624441385269,
0.3605244755744934,
-0.34888723492622375,
0.6365743279457092,
-0.6801638603210449,
0.18655137717723846,
0.11424935609102249,
0.14183512330055237,
-0.5915685892105103,
-0.3914286196231842,
-0.07958465814590454,
-0.521132230758667,
0.4417562484741211,
0.045710787177085876,
-0.025681165978312492,
-0.25857284665107727,
-0.06957349181175232,
0.5253311991691589,
0.30557185411453247,
-0.5434907674789429,
0.6380374431610107,
0.45799896121025085,
-0.16313911974430084,
-0.9498148560523987,
0.013191480189561844,
0.008602903224527836,
-0.21372424066066742,
-0.5144454836845398,
0.6356790065765381,
-0.08187688142061234,
-0.44167566299438477,
-0.005985941272228956,
-0.08121603727340698,
-0.31231051683425903,
0.009732449427247047,
0.02676425874233246,
0.4667113125324249,
-0.06356731802225113,
-0.008410831913352013,
-0.034084971994161606,
-0.12424780428409576,
-0.14155496656894684,
0.26641613245010376,
0.5822306275367737,
0.11934037506580353,
-0.16387663781642914,
0.03274637088179588,
0.15082412958145142,
0.1783522367477417,
-0.29457491636276245,
0.49476954340934753,
0.5602862238883972,
-0.34869879484176636,
-0.7368264198303223,
-0.628066897392273,
-0.01436681393533945,
-0.44466182589530945,
0.4191681146621704,
-0.5061834454536438,
-0.7960545420646667,
0.37145206332206726,
-0.23767684400081635,
0.09472408145666122,
0.5125172734260559,
0.6960132122039795,
0.17818666994571686,
0.5702025890350342,
0.4850658178329468,
0.04369958117604256,
0.03809967637062073,
-0.3737228214740753,
0.2313244640827179,
-1.1452385187149048,
-0.20351704955101013,
-0.6622500419616699,
0.032065462321043015,
-0.31605976819992065,
-0.6630093455314636,
0.4039321839809418,
0.2477441132068634,
-0.3581826388835907,
0.3403433859348297,
-0.6056375503540039,
0.32489824295043945,
0.27437546849250793,
-0.21857716143131256,
0.5012125372886658,
0.04566496983170509,
-0.10997936129570007,
-0.08172184973955154,
-0.7094041705131531,
-0.6134446859359741,
1.0127917528152466,
0.20147593319416046,
0.6605715155601501,
-0.020583366975188255,
0.4987602233886719,
0.394667387008667,
0.4266260862350464,
-0.7016416788101196,
0.6599319577217102,
-0.5783427357673645,
-0.6686010956764221,
-0.160800501704216,
-0.6182869672775269,
-1.1446994543075562,
0.37140733003616333,
-0.13384826481342316,
-0.41284066438674927,
0.062388285994529724,
-0.06145675480365753,
-0.196186363697052,
0.2089315950870514,
-0.22199630737304688,
0.6929152011871338,
-0.05983644351363182,
-0.3008333444595337,
-0.18993665277957916,
-0.14723597466945648,
0.6014904975891113,
-0.4952761232852936,
0.209605410695076,
-0.14468835294246674,
0.02464667707681656,
0.7883421778678894,
-0.05015654116868973,
0.555528998374939,
-0.17030979692935944,
-0.024325458332896233,
0.3480461835861206,
0.2541249096393585,
0.32700836658477783,
-0.32668259739875793,
-0.20165133476257324,
0.18813860416412354,
-0.01739145629107952,
-0.00911490898579359,
-0.5800426602363586,
0.7055523991584778,
-0.9179335236549377,
-0.8101240992546082,
-0.3791213035583496,
-0.6026898622512817,
-0.37298527359962463,
0.05240069702267647,
0.17658106982707977,
0.3270602226257324,
-0.4339814782142639,
0.05428054928779602,
0.7851161956787109,
-0.3321250081062317,
0.09500471502542496,
0.6843060255050659,
-0.3019051253795624,
-0.287605881690979,
1.0370545387268066,
0.320975124835968,
0.048025935888290405,
0.07982395589351654,
0.14067117869853973,
-0.046734683215618134,
-0.48639029264450073,
-0.5413164496421814,
0.3638212978839874,
-0.6378049850463867,
-0.39072513580322266,
-0.7417392134666443,
-0.5137604475021362,
-0.3514243960380554,
-0.1297445148229599,
-0.12193022668361664,
-0.3666302561759949,
-0.1672334223985672,
0.2533991038799286,
0.1954798549413681,
0.7914059162139893,
0.13542552292346954,
0.044756196439266205,
-0.68497234582901,
0.6898531913757324,
0.3615701198577881,
0.30059146881103516,
0.2449546605348587,
-1.0906617641448975,
-0.42744940519332886,
-0.3408801853656769,
-0.5394502282142639,
-0.6865661144256592,
0.5168823003768921,
0.3842044770717621,
0.8672500848770142,
0.18671321868896484,
0.2065761834383011,
0.7747653722763062,
-0.7087583541870117,
0.7658129334449768,
-0.39952489733695984,
-0.6734620332717896,
0.2561420202255249,
-0.39974021911621094,
-0.15119513869285583,
0.41027241945266724,
0.6343746185302734,
-0.4892485439777374,
-0.43325841426849365,
-0.5595952272415161,
-0.6826826333999634,
0.36110958456993103,
-0.00779138645157218,
0.2152024656534195,
-0.046702053397893906,
0.5000663995742798,
0.13010884821414948,
0.05177295580506325,
-0.3448686897754669,
-0.2777811288833618,
0.09554298222064972,
0.004301268141716719,
0.24969105422496796,
-0.2593704164028168,
0.006408723071217537,
-0.14337588846683502,
0.7331165671348572,
0.18229809403419495,
0.09576690196990967,
0.10388262569904327,
0.13756448030471802,
-0.2237265259027481,
0.1494181603193283,
0.5575733780860901,
0.7630311846733093,
-0.1676529496908188,
-0.17317116260528564,
0.43206706643104553,
-0.6998814940452576,
0.10408145189285278,
0.09977229684591293,
-0.17890003323554993,
0.1934741735458374,
0.21769699454307556,
0.508322536945343,
-0.07904408872127533,
-0.6820869445800781,
0.5397863984107971,
0.0019753635860979557,
-0.005324118304997683,
-0.40838423371315,
0.2870407998561859,
-0.2947636842727661,
0.10826341062784195,
0.7739972472190857,
-0.1532612293958664,
0.26812365651130676,
-0.3994406461715698,
0.34226077795028687,
0.4667455554008484,
0.10323085635900497,
-0.22272618114948273,
0.736893892288208,
0.14856377243995667,
-0.40494677424430847,
0.41311436891555786,
-0.13867522776126862,
-0.5719301104545593,
0.5148077607154846,
0.6939557790756226,
0.8658431768417358,
-0.49812743067741394,
0.10290485620498657,
0.5071238279342651,
-0.09090445935726166,
-0.1320241540670395,
-0.13430678844451904,
0.1476791948080063,
-0.8869181275367737,
-0.40058040618896484,
-0.8076890110969543,
-0.7126431465148926,
0.10781776160001755,
-0.5339592695236206,
0.2180543839931488,
-0.1859620213508606,
-0.36048752069473267,
-0.29193517565727234,
0.468851774930954,
-0.6852960586547852,
0.3664249777793884,
-0.24345260858535767,
0.995849072933197,
-0.5080224871635437,
0.8534995317459106,
0.5463048815727234,
-0.06845764070749283,
-0.7938768267631531,
0.03402961045503616,
-0.16166669130325317,
-0.7096786499023438,
1.0527222156524658,
-0.04756426438689232,
-0.2543649971485138,
-0.17669519782066345,
-0.2454061061143875,
-0.48149290680885315,
1.153870940208435,
0.04406711831688881,
-0.5053195953369141,
-0.08396749943494797,
-0.039174724370241165,
0.6619154214859009,
-0.5117186307907104,
0.17094507813453674,
0.625152051448822,
0.24798062443733215,
0.047804757952690125,
-1.1834388971328735,
-0.2035735845565796,
-0.32339543104171753,
0.011495021171867847,
-0.034289900213479996,
-0.6736857295036316,
1.153205394744873,
0.010533914901316166,
-0.3853566646575928,
0.09832959622144699,
0.5841079950332642,
0.8426324129104614,
0.680765688419342,
0.30363789200782776,
0.643470823764801,
0.9088805913925171,
0.13420653343200684,
1.0468045473098755,
-0.6124585866928101,
0.30381083488464355,
1.0344018936157227,
-0.5373307466506958,
1.1428067684173584,
0.11896962672472,
-0.1303894966840744,
0.4266226589679718,
0.32067012786865234,
0.0920543298125267,
0.31351715326309204,
0.1634739488363266,
-0.453186959028244,
-0.13183502852916718,
-0.3532675802707672,
-0.5291346311569214,
0.4337053894996643,
0.4724467396736145,
-0.10029783099889755,
-0.03631677106022835,
-0.11412160098552704,
0.05700717121362686,
0.2819546163082123,
-0.26240548491477966,
0.6590996980667114,
0.20634880661964417,
-0.7338867783546448,
0.9050500392913818,
0.060167718678712845,
0.637834370136261,
-0.3891267776489258,
-0.2689495086669922,
-0.6266485452651978,
0.09687186032533646,
-0.22308918833732605,
-0.5591620802879333,
0.32457441091537476,
0.5063327550888062,
-0.1434505432844162,
0.060748569667339325,
1.0433154106140137,
-0.2783404588699341,
-0.3282628357410431,
0.3468363583087921,
0.7036561965942383,
0.4753972887992859,
0.2520410716533661,
-0.5562860369682312,
0.34535863995552063,
-0.19600346684455872,
-0.4451579749584198,
0.3943708539009094,
0.5772708654403687,
-0.14152318239212036,
0.732949435710907,
0.3226349353790283,
0.460091769695282,
-0.08865172415971756,
0.08690713346004486,
0.8571837544441223,
-0.443895161151886,
0.17290283739566803,
-0.35759562253952026,
0.24709492921829224,
-0.08519582450389862,
-0.35187405347824097,
0.9100910425186157,
0.48978301882743835,
0.9993866086006165,
0.014673210680484772,
0.8002636432647705,
-0.018511667847633362,
1.0306204557418823,
-0.24537691473960876,
0.8788816332817078,
-0.6334100961685181,
0.3143933117389679,
-0.18166977167129517,
-1.1304147243499756,
-0.09635282307863235,
0.7473885416984558,
-0.47333383560180664,
0.22261057794094086,
0.48275625705718994,
0.7837180495262146,
-0.009317434392869473,
-0.2414289116859436,
0.6723072528839111,
0.01599288545548916,
0.11966336518526077,
0.3983404338359833,
0.8511645793914795,
-0.4380005896091461,
0.3836435079574585,
0.012032974511384964,
-0.20135754346847534,
-0.13465334475040436,
-0.534454882144928,
-1.0737311840057373,
-0.6740962266921997,
-0.06344611197710037,
-0.19009114801883698,
0.2899814546108246,
0.7754382491111755,
0.44578883051872253,
-0.7353693842887878,
-0.401140421628952,
0.37397414445877075,
-0.0630367323756218,
-0.019786611199378967,
-0.27574101090431213,
0.5873369574546814,
-0.615437924861908,
-0.8124492764472961,
0.42496949434280396,
-0.06197156384587288,
-0.20586048066616058,
-0.3450332581996918,
-0.1929135024547577,
0.12981730699539185,
0.29009467363357544,
0.6226653456687927,
0.2289118468761444,
-0.7225857377052307,
-0.13570822775363922,
0.05718390271067619,
-0.32364997267723083,
-0.19567129015922546,
0.8576368093490601,
-0.8609161376953125,
0.35121479630470276,
0.45727112889289856,
0.8638442158699036,
0.28961870074272156,
0.40526700019836426,
0.38473039865493774,
-0.6307039856910706,
-0.06647134572267532,
0.31923025846481323,
0.17484283447265625,
0.34892791509628296,
-0.2552683353424072,
0.7629646062850952,
0.27455461025238037,
-1.0652939081192017,
-0.8934062719345093,
-0.16409671306610107,
-0.7042248249053955,
-0.4382200241088867,
1.1235555410385132,
-0.3362279236316681,
-0.032960209995508194,
-0.4191315174102783,
-0.19216389954090118,
0.23147395253181458,
-0.09490615874528885,
1.1175365447998047,
0.4902207851409912,
-0.013101425021886826,
-0.13302920758724213,
-1.077752947807312,
0.7253131866455078,
0.26954662799835205,
-0.6816089153289795,
0.261217325925827,
0.3715950548648834,
0.031111806631088257,
0.15151678025722504,
0.8155975341796875,
0.12621769309043884,
0.22168490290641785,
-0.0006696879863739014,
-0.020882360637187958,
-0.09288320690393448,
-0.6162059903144836,
-0.13737700879573822,
0.19176581501960754,
0.15066030621528625,
0.31259557604789734
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.05651v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.05651v1
|
A Superalignment Framework in Autonomous Driving with Large Language Models
| 2024-06-09T05:26:38 | 2024-06-09T05:26:38 |
Xiangrui Kong, Thomas Braunl, Marco Fahmi, Yue Wang
|
cs.RO
|
cs.RO, cs.CL, cs.CV
|
Over the last year, significant advancements have been made in the realms of
large language models (LLMs) and multi-modal large language models (MLLMs),
particularly in their application to autonomous driving. These models have
showcased remarkable abilities in processing and interacting with complex
information. In autonomous driving, LLMs and MLLMs are extensively used,
requiring access to sensitive vehicle data such as precise locations, images,
and road conditions. These data are transmitted to an LLM-based inference cloud
for advanced analysis. However, concerns arise regarding data security, as the
protection against data and privacy breaches primarily depends on the LLM's
inherent security measures, without additional scrutiny or evaluation of the
LLM's inference outputs. Despite its importance, the security aspect of LLMs in
autonomous driving remains underexplored. Addressing this gap, our research
introduces a novel security framework for autonomous vehicles, utilizing a
multi-agent LLM approach. This framework is designed to safeguard sensitive
information associated with autonomous vehicles from potential leaks, while
also ensuring that LLM outputs adhere to driving regulations and align with
human values. It includes mechanisms to filter out irrelevant queries and
verify the safety and reliability of LLM outputs. Utilizing this framework, we
evaluated the security, privacy, and cost aspects of eleven large language
model-driven autonomous driving cues. Additionally, we performed QA tests on
these driving prompts, which successfully demonstrated the framework's
efficacy.
|
[
-0.27911484241485596,
-0.6242977976799011,
0.7203699946403503,
-0.24878662824630737,
-0.023130027577280998,
-0.05293077602982521,
-0.071357361972332,
-0.7333405613899231,
-0.24389950931072235,
0.4721183180809021,
-0.8599039316177368,
-0.550697922706604,
-0.19079121947288513,
-0.08327930420637131,
-0.4081476032733917,
0.6929786801338196,
0.16700182855129242,
0.19967225193977356,
-0.3307332694530487,
-0.1369144320487976,
-0.2014254331588745,
-0.776110053062439,
-0.3824099004268646,
-0.1517324149608612,
0.4660162329673767,
-0.1041804775595665,
1.1135063171386719,
0.7722524404525757,
0.5137982964515686,
0.34724393486976624,
0.27915558218955994,
0.045649461448192596,
-0.010499215684831142,
0.4409799873828888,
-0.4618312120437622,
-0.25504133105278015,
-0.42505648732185364,
-0.40006670355796814,
0.7517150640487671,
0.20746086537837982,
-0.07757248729467392,
-0.16794365644454956,
-0.15186575055122375,
0.3991726040840149,
-0.770938515663147,
0.17915520071983337,
-0.5230398774147034,
-0.4023186266422272,
-0.5296022295951843,
-0.05347250774502754,
-0.11412946879863739,
-0.3769392967224121,
-0.1397564858198166,
-0.7266808152198792,
0.020995741710066795,
0.08040904998779297,
1.0906336307525635,
0.6250041127204895,
-0.41674959659576416,
-0.0048502166755497456,
-0.692266583442688,
0.6719257235527039,
-0.8018571734428406,
0.691720187664032,
0.3178410828113556,
0.3844885230064392,
-0.36191749572753906,
-0.15032659471035004,
-0.9942311644554138,
-0.16234652698040009,
0.009805635549128056,
-0.056687209755182266,
-0.023407578468322754,
0.21961171925067902,
-0.16094233095645905,
0.07215812057256699,
-0.7779960632324219,
0.6170113682746887,
0.2313910573720932,
-0.19220738112926483,
0.9142323136329651,
0.40082648396492004,
0.21456752717494965,
0.24987713992595673,
-0.6623663306236267,
-0.4050173759460449,
-1.1318976879119873,
0.06262166798114777,
0.3726797103881836,
0.449002206325531,
-0.2271355539560318,
0.31144779920578003,
-0.18290695548057556,
0.4851956069469452,
-0.04330550134181976,
-0.460294246673584,
0.26818788051605225,
-0.6046432852745056,
-0.28275102376937866,
-0.10487410426139832,
1.0101823806762695,
0.5356947779655457,
0.1480283886194229,
-0.2637504041194916,
-0.32697588205337524,
0.013451546430587769,
-0.18191766738891602,
-0.41444921493530273,
0.15549799799919128,
0.38272151350975037,
-0.09313611686229706,
-0.11311805248260498,
0.36794695258140564,
-0.49997058510780334,
-0.7133766412734985,
-0.4276413917541504,
0.20337945222854614,
-0.33058851957321167,
-0.39683860540390015,
0.22287538647651672,
0.34189170598983765,
0.7610977292060852,
0.10556143522262573,
-0.980130672454834,
0.14236514270305634,
0.7653462886810303,
0.5279354453086853,
-0.09171514213085175,
-0.4588851034641266,
-0.24092981219291687,
0.6712667346000671,
-0.3067791759967804,
0.7377459406852722,
-0.5246500968933105,
-0.20027950406074524,
0.21493631601333618,
0.2397032529115677,
-0.11947914212942123,
-0.29430755972862244,
0.13600946962833405,
-0.8111798763275146,
-0.15869182348251343,
-0.06963557004928589,
-0.5201696753501892,
-0.2962786555290222,
0.3310111463069916,
-0.7144524455070496,
0.7182307839393616,
-0.18164001405239105,
-0.325556218624115,
0.3761060833930969,
-0.5277830958366394,
-0.6037883162498474,
0.3355623483657837,
-0.6355641484260559,
-0.46271058917045593,
-0.2688463628292084,
0.24519501626491547,
0.6915091276168823,
-0.22663086652755737,
0.5039379000663757,
-0.38783499598503113,
0.06790038198232651,
0.4539259970188141,
-0.45262497663497925,
0.7271920442581177,
-0.22421473264694214,
-0.4121912717819214,
0.383296936750412,
-0.42750585079193115,
-0.26864585280418396,
0.07417578250169754,
-0.2703040838241577,
-0.2857879102230072,
-0.05237067863345146,
0.09803465753793716,
0.16814909875392914,
0.44919419288635254,
-0.6393131017684937,
0.0952981561422348,
-0.4393079876899719,
0.1563347429037094,
1.1112802028656006,
0.02163088321685791,
0.5435187816619873,
-0.18367677927017212,
0.7009968161582947,
0.005790145136415958,
0.2687685489654541,
-0.11415819823741913,
-0.242063969373703,
-0.33738264441490173,
-0.13390091061592102,
0.2348143756389618,
0.746231734752655,
-0.6293001770973206,
0.5869013667106628,
-0.05037263035774231,
-0.23554891347885132,
-0.4220450818538666,
0.21239468455314636,
0.5737677216529846,
0.07156578451395035,
0.10554390400648117,
0.13832268118858337,
-0.19451500475406647,
-0.8304128050804138,
0.17777281999588013,
-0.14786887168884277,
0.13682228326797485,
0.23164036870002747,
0.5255607962608337,
-0.36728763580322266,
0.7840116024017334,
-0.2823808789253235,
-0.46874919533729553,
-0.007782771252095699,
-0.3416195213794708,
-0.38459455966949463,
0.8401004076004028,
0.518068253993988,
-0.827545702457428,
-0.13239017128944397,
0.0205179862678051,
-0.8029083609580994,
0.1624007523059845,
-0.4328847825527191,
-0.2692757546901703,
0.49583524465560913,
0.957255482673645,
-0.919394314289093,
0.3749392330646515,
0.5468647480010986,
-0.2878018319606781,
0.7112604379653931,
-0.26214027404785156,
-0.2557656466960907,
-0.7391283512115479,
-0.10208477079868317,
-0.03469417989253998,
-0.5206199884414673,
-0.34136417508125305,
0.43392571806907654,
0.014961879700422287,
0.14557458460330963,
-0.43602800369262695,
0.42913058400154114,
-0.5004206895828247,
-0.011397803202271461,
-0.17293846607208252,
0.04042118415236473,
-0.043321918696165085,
0.09562601149082184,
0.07292493432760239,
0.8968420624732971,
1.0309289693832397,
-0.753629207611084,
0.3476506471633911,
-0.11264103651046753,
-0.24853038787841797,
0.8286771774291992,
-0.45805054903030396,
0.10212966054677963,
-0.28522589802742004,
0.2948611378669739,
-0.9462055563926697,
-0.44953152537345886,
0.13280051946640015,
-0.3294130563735962,
0.4540141820907593,
0.1501450538635254,
-0.7421477437019348,
0.2881317436695099,
-0.02184954844415188,
0.42265355587005615,
0.015245027840137482,
-0.3781930208206177,
0.6651944518089294,
0.7538135647773743,
-0.40627071261405945,
-0.4179401099681854,
-0.553536593914032,
0.18312086164951324,
-0.3290213942527771,
-0.7425510883331299,
0.4235127568244934,
-0.09943870455026627,
-0.377750039100647,
-0.13025563955307007,
0.07084956765174866,
-0.011438922956585884,
0.35115107893943787,
0.43686962127685547,
0.3520427644252777,
-0.21299736201763153,
0.2796132564544678,
-0.08496508747339249,
-0.5106167793273926,
0.21241320669651031,
-0.23548975586891174,
0.5457504987716675,
-0.19217878580093384,
-0.4764723479747772,
-0.7659956812858582,
0.6605586409568787,
0.7802377343177795,
-0.4178866446018219,
1.033328890800476,
0.5342846512794495,
-0.4949384927749634,
0.07630635052919388,
-0.4007726311683655,
-0.40402424335479736,
-0.5465191006660461,
0.19701921939849854,
-0.35292327404022217,
-0.9252877831459045,
0.4885299503803253,
0.1780281662940979,
0.24037346243858337,
0.21453315019607544,
0.6071866154670715,
-0.14674009382724762,
1.4086425304412842,
0.8042517304420471,
-0.135757714509964,
0.49513909220695496,
0.1120934784412384,
0.2694627642631531,
-0.3997136354446411,
-0.5393927693367004,
-0.2833755910396576,
-0.10087396949529648,
-0.5275141596794128,
-0.2783721387386322,
0.31339335441589355,
-0.2277095466852188,
-0.3902139365673065,
0.1591089814901352,
-0.0465037003159523,
0.5827691555023193,
0.5905784368515015,
-0.008851282298564911,
0.2524659037590027,
-0.4740191102027893,
-0.08521488308906555,
0.2613546550273895,
-0.5039036870002747,
-0.47827765345573425,
0.9091780185699463,
0.3812788128852844,
1.027076005935669,
0.5553417205810547,
0.4056050479412079,
0.09736065566539764,
-0.042849041521549225,
-0.44174903631210327,
0.8383510708808899,
0.11532282084226608,
-0.646546483039856,
-0.47821372747421265,
-0.38319072127342224,
-1.0090292692184448,
0.12126614153385162,
-0.23805247247219086,
-0.7823593616485596,
0.2436242401599884,
0.016297029331326485,
-0.8679556846618652,
0.08369213342666626,
-0.3425845205783844,
0.7034603953361511,
-0.44202882051467896,
-0.41829854249954224,
-0.025573641061782837,
-0.9854127764701843,
0.33380094170570374,
-0.03409399837255478,
0.33325207233428955,
-0.2266508787870407,
-0.11274135112762451,
0.4630468785762787,
-0.3287601172924042,
0.8816681504249573,
-0.22835421562194824,
-0.397594153881073,
-0.17465229332447052,
0.3069431185722351,
0.5033478140830994,
0.30201515555381775,
0.1987418830394745,
0.14169231057167053,
-0.14383432269096375,
-0.08822668343782425,
-0.5628060698509216,
0.8848713636398315,
-0.5886818170547485,
-0.7238514423370361,
-0.39363569021224976,
-0.835037887096405,
-0.13743087649345398,
0.1878465712070465,
0.11331070959568024,
0.33107176423072815,
0.2028702348470688,
0.11188441514968872,
0.6896794438362122,
-0.11099158972501755,
0.6834052801132202,
0.7863447070121765,
-0.07757647335529327,
-0.1579737365245819,
0.8129172921180725,
0.16087937355041504,
0.43432149291038513,
0.26710447669029236,
0.13262733817100525,
-0.9342465400695801,
-0.5908796787261963,
-0.7696372270584106,
0.2841227054595947,
-0.562159538269043,
-0.4773801565170288,
-0.13885892927646637,
-0.23624752461910248,
-0.8021944165229797,
-0.2579890489578247,
-0.4950229525566101,
-0.3226298987865448,
-0.10893888026475906,
-0.5126054286956787,
0.2814863920211792,
0.6428670287132263,
-0.35162651538848877,
0.44525763392448425,
-0.5700470209121704,
0.08903449028730392,
0.273573100566864,
0.16466006636619568,
-0.021560320630669594,
-0.16611409187316895,
-0.058314450085163116,
-0.09430471807718277,
-0.08302289992570877,
-0.6380617022514343,
0.2264520674943924,
-0.0025365313049405813,
0.7869328260421753,
0.6999050378799438,
0.34231504797935486,
0.4660676419734955,
-0.3227798342704773,
0.6971904635429382,
0.20842024683952332,
-0.7740152478218079,
0.2254738062620163,
-0.3558311462402344,
0.20966309309005737,
0.6001837253570557,
0.1725451499223709,
-0.17206308245658875,
-0.5328566431999207,
-0.4110638201236725,
-1.127665400505066,
0.32347533106803894,
0.13806025683879852,
0.006696818396449089,
0.19213616847991943,
0.26670747995376587,
-0.1198490634560585,
0.18594178557395935,
-1.0528349876403809,
-0.2389523684978485,
0.14897458255290985,
-0.21098963916301727,
0.027061207219958305,
0.13812053203582764,
-0.2734374403953552,
-0.043517112731933594,
0.7434293627738953,
-0.18552978336811066,
-0.1387062817811966,
0.18056125938892365,
-0.0892641618847847,
0.1900303214788437,
0.17326633632183075,
0.9037935137748718,
0.40260741114616394,
0.05833321809768677,
0.43058666586875916,
-0.09005174785852432,
-0.180616095662117,
0.5380368232727051,
0.23348402976989746,
-0.3624780476093292,
-0.24492894113063812,
0.10524746030569077,
0.30330464243888855,
-0.17800584435462952,
-0.7273291349411011,
0.5714741349220276,
0.15230806171894073,
0.0030343399848788977,
-0.3844872713088989,
0.2010500133037567,
-0.12743240594863892,
0.39178842306137085,
0.300706684589386,
-0.021218566223978996,
-0.09491512179374695,
-0.2853716313838959,
0.3066982626914978,
0.6566787362098694,
-0.6405856013298035,
-0.31996527314186096,
0.7071618437767029,
0.05761018022894859,
-0.15474121272563934,
0.16939294338226318,
-0.38713663816452026,
-0.5069418549537659,
0.5586692094802856,
0.44232797622680664,
0.6849480271339417,
-0.6400668621063232,
-0.10003992915153503,
-0.09146739542484283,
0.5386268496513367,
-0.02563474141061306,
0.18380676209926605,
-0.014612209983170033,
-0.807239294052124,
-0.3847762644290924,
-0.3805997669696808,
-0.21885357797145844,
0.305545836687088,
-0.5043826103210449,
-0.3027479350566864,
-0.6602737903594971,
-0.2647923529148102,
-0.1990552544593811,
-0.5094720125198364,
-0.4325162470340729,
0.17322736978530884,
0.40442875027656555,
0.597753643989563,
-0.8227284550666809,
0.6808032393455505,
0.6059240102767944,
-0.22247466444969177,
-0.7415887713432312,
0.05137393996119499,
0.47455599904060364,
-0.7903363704681396,
0.33949732780456543,
0.41295769810676575,
-0.5726127028465271,
-0.14140266180038452,
-0.5776934027671814,
-1.059354543685913,
1.0508664846420288,
0.6771050691604614,
-0.6597461104393005,
-0.15433336794376373,
0.569907546043396,
0.10394494235515594,
-0.33589276671409607,
-0.32898184657096863,
0.815378725528717,
0.5333639979362488,
-0.18342669308185577,
-0.8083895444869995,
0.37852901220321655,
-0.03905663266777992,
-0.17061015963554382,
-0.0015417030081152916,
-0.741606593132019,
0.7449218034744263,
-0.12698446214199066,
-0.4440372586250305,
0.18458503484725952,
0.5281477570533752,
0.5381802916526794,
0.06371200829744339,
0.5619882941246033,
0.5594163537025452,
0.9028924703598022,
-0.00615955563262105,
0.885805606842041,
-0.3989536166191101,
0.11994045972824097,
1.1277517080307007,
-0.6202995181083679,
0.7494583129882812,
0.46833494305610657,
0.07015129923820496,
0.6360241174697876,
0.6068443059921265,
0.23050440847873688,
0.6770947575569153,
0.042843014001846313,
-0.47263258695602417,
-0.6585913896560669,
-0.45502087473869324,
-0.5236659049987793,
0.5101979970932007,
0.4582963287830353,
-0.31601253151893616,
-0.2562316358089447,
0.16837750375270844,
0.18945592641830444,
-0.05641477555036545,
-0.30059733986854553,
0.9440517425537109,
0.053366340696811676,
-0.38251033425331116,
0.23620863258838654,
0.20631544291973114,
0.2702709436416626,
-0.5306715369224548,
0.25401023030281067,
-0.10122783482074738,
0.3502938151359558,
-0.250365674495697,
-0.8291188478469849,
0.14740465581417084,
-0.2150600552558899,
-0.09291940927505493,
-0.33796408772468567,
0.4010372459888458,
-0.3382074236869812,
-0.4313661754131317,
0.3378751277923584,
0.2907066345214844,
-0.009651591069996357,
-0.16748753190040588,
-0.7487104535102844,
0.1418038159608841,
-0.3210909366607666,
-0.0639386773109436,
0.2471553534269333,
0.22148917615413666,
-0.09212509542703629,
0.7922373414039612,
0.8787325024604797,
-0.09267672151327133,
0.160417377948761,
0.45055973529815674,
0.8448319435119629,
-0.7147486209869385,
-0.8603023290634155,
-1.320516586303711,
0.5038190484046936,
0.12088866531848907,
-0.2632329761981964,
0.9529299736022949,
0.4655820429325104,
0.6341440677642822,
0.454312264919281,
0.8142215013504028,
0.40434974431991577,
0.14826567471027374,
-0.9506382942199707,
0.7214958071708679,
-0.30496031045913696,
0.39936336874961853,
-0.25726068019866943,
-0.6327826976776123,
-0.5197654962539673,
0.6829729676246643,
-0.18636786937713623,
-0.21144190430641174,
0.23329411447048187,
1.374266266822815,
0.07488846033811569,
-0.2071182280778885,
0.31462398171424866,
0.06069004535675049,
0.5454060435295105,
0.7062113285064697,
0.9400046467781067,
-0.2599796950817108,
0.4688490629196167,
0.08195845037698746,
-0.14469505846500397,
0.014389058575034142,
-0.7586512565612793,
-0.6528956294059753,
-0.5121227502822876,
-0.31610721349716187,
-0.17203941941261292,
-0.016744177788496017,
0.6737509965896606,
1.3318722248077393,
-0.6957588791847229,
-0.1899779587984085,
-0.32112917304039,
0.2333797961473465,
-0.10266811400651932,
-0.26703202724456787,
0.3006519079208374,
0.09874830394983292,
-0.4136609137058258,
0.7776642441749573,
0.47354656457901,
0.5299118161201477,
-0.8934043645858765,
-0.2165621817111969,
-0.13697320222854614,
0.13605953752994537,
0.05829871445894241,
0.1726856529712677,
-0.668367862701416,
-0.2915128767490387,
-0.017966359853744507,
-0.2584605813026428,
0.03403855487704277,
0.5061155557632446,
-0.5730430483818054,
0.234534353017807,
0.17496748268604279,
0.6906827688217163,
0.020943908020853996,
0.3179972767829895,
0.8498715162277222,
-0.648520290851593,
0.14566969871520996,
0.10413680970668793,
0.37261343002319336,
0.4691319167613983,
-0.6299676299095154,
0.04065627604722977,
0.08438699692487717,
-0.6536315679550171,
-0.7444959878921509,
0.6376619935035706,
-0.7103807926177979,
-0.3019532859325409,
0.997691810131073,
-0.25351133942604065,
-0.40774208307266235,
-0.6437265276908875,
0.1827540397644043,
-0.09661299735307693,
-0.5844406485557556,
0.4602419435977936,
0.33807429671287537,
-0.08106014877557755,
-0.37999075651168823,
-0.3193757236003876,
0.5270363092422485,
0.37574803829193115,
-0.8889612555503845,
0.38782253861427307,
0.5151264667510986,
-0.10821758210659027,
0.28371572494506836,
0.23064932227134705,
-0.05417473986744881,
0.3986557722091675,
-0.13552333414554596,
-0.18385279178619385,
-0.04996185749769211,
-0.7546606659889221,
-0.5759392380714417,
0.27819138765335083,
-0.09927187114953995,
-0.2972283363342285
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.05644v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.05644v2
|
How Alignment and Jailbreak Work: Explain LLM Safety through Intermediate Hidden States
| 2024-06-09T05:04:37 | 2024-06-13T05:39:31 |
Zhenhong Zhou, Haiyang Yu, Xinghua Zhang, Rongwu Xu, Fei Huang, Yongbin Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CR, cs.CY
|
Large language models (LLMs) rely on safety alignment to avoid responding to
malicious user inputs. Unfortunately, jailbreak can circumvent safety
guardrails, resulting in LLMs generating harmful content and raising concerns
about LLM safety. Due to language models with intensive parameters often
regarded as black boxes, the mechanisms of alignment and jailbreak are
challenging to elucidate. In this paper, we employ weak classifiers to explain
LLM safety through the intermediate hidden states. We first confirm that LLMs
learn ethical concepts during pre-training rather than alignment and can
identify malicious and normal inputs in the early layers. Alignment actually
associates the early concepts with emotion guesses in the middle layers and
then refines them to the specific reject tokens for safe generations. Jailbreak
disturbs the transformation of early unethical classification into negative
emotions. We conduct experiments on models from 7B to 70B across various model
families to prove our conclusion. Overall, our paper indicates the intrinsical
mechanism of LLM safety and how jailbreaks circumvent safety guardrails,
offering a new perspective on LLM safety and reducing concerns. Our code is
available at https://github.com/ydyjya/LLM-IHS-Explanation.
|
[
-0.04782724380493164,
-0.6142703294754028,
0.8320281505584717,
-0.2277207374572754,
-0.20037220418453217,
0.3217620253562927,
0.060645848512649536,
-0.600605845451355,
-0.1135159358382225,
0.4406159222126007,
-0.6209886074066162,
-0.529413640499115,
-0.5360327363014221,
-0.21473020315170288,
-0.47251763939857483,
1.3250311613082886,
-0.14053162932395935,
-0.05127156898379326,
0.2576991617679596,
-0.06264227628707886,
-0.39956343173980713,
-0.5589116811752319,
-0.14058667421340942,
-0.2206476628780365,
0.5954568386077881,
0.5148177742958069,
0.8694374561309814,
0.9621255397796631,
0.4792897701263428,
0.303392231464386,
-0.33460795879364014,
-0.3705078065395355,
-0.7343776226043701,
0.1108042523264885,
-0.15522897243499756,
-0.6705331206321716,
-0.2046566754579544,
0.19929058849811554,
0.0667506754398346,
0.19309133291244507,
-0.26375681161880493,
0.005287792533636093,
0.09581038355827332,
0.735957145690918,
-0.8167580366134644,
-0.29281193017959595,
-0.7933638095855713,
-0.019849030300974846,
-0.3393354117870331,
0.06262490898370743,
-0.4385720491409302,
-0.4859517216682434,
-0.16819673776626587,
-0.21785525977611542,
-0.13475702702999115,
0.23111525177955627,
1.1113646030426025,
0.36845043301582336,
-0.525824248790741,
-0.411992609500885,
-0.5467705130577087,
0.5824114680290222,
-0.6372362971305847,
0.18115371465682983,
0.2486562579870224,
0.19023917615413666,
-0.17821675539016724,
-0.13312825560569763,
-0.6143849492073059,
-0.2646189332008362,
0.020957034081220627,
-0.14520812034606934,
-0.16031700372695923,
0.2556930184364319,
0.2443961203098297,
0.31968244910240173,
-0.26600539684295654,
0.5996620655059814,
-0.5091498494148254,
-0.21554702520370483,
0.5263321995735168,
0.2597034275531769,
0.4901781380176544,
-0.21407108008861542,
-0.5357353687286377,
0.14045904576778412,
-1.207384705543518,
0.1959601193666458,
0.9700271487236023,
0.15452787280082703,
-0.4116906225681305,
0.7327674627304077,
0.35431671142578125,
0.45285800099372864,
0.24807293713092804,
-0.23390083014965057,
0.12386325001716614,
-0.06713300198316574,
-0.07927374541759491,
0.3835517168045044,
0.8159234523773193,
0.4556785225868225,
0.24098004400730133,
-0.3022931218147278,
-0.1894938051700592,
0.16032613813877106,
0.4709731638431549,
-0.6032366156578064,
0.0986519604921341,
0.3747950494289398,
-0.4817485809326172,
-0.8061456084251404,
-0.1766672134399414,
-0.5424638390541077,
-0.638195276260376,
-0.14975512027740479,
0.4139918088912964,
-0.42870447039604187,
0.020417090505361557,
0.14757037162780762,
0.20599496364593506,
0.43587058782577515,
0.16312506794929504,
-0.9865210056304932,
0.31885120272636414,
0.873020589351654,
0.5610041618347168,
0.02923896536231041,
-0.18454042077064514,
-0.3323804438114166,
0.23954978585243225,
-0.11422469466924667,
0.3905489146709442,
-0.364797979593277,
-0.03459283336997032,
-0.07253839075565338,
0.20676332712173462,
0.05020436272025108,
-0.28143173456192017,
0.6180307865142822,
-0.5772700905799866,
-0.09739354997873306,
-0.03562198206782341,
-0.4795556664466858,
-0.24246026575565338,
0.1384263038635254,
-0.5062048435211182,
0.5341615080833435,
-0.4287373721599579,
-0.9132992029190063,
0.2017054259777069,
-0.33271345496177673,
-0.4303467869758606,
-0.2506491541862488,
0.08665134757757187,
-0.5991613864898682,
0.302058607339859,
-0.08834975212812424,
0.4170140027999878,
0.07963494211435318,
0.3279780447483063,
-0.6052521467208862,
-0.4965660572052002,
0.4746636748313904,
-0.3605196177959442,
0.920547366142273,
0.31292346119880676,
-0.5114877223968506,
0.09084855765104294,
-0.5006552934646606,
-0.31418633460998535,
0.2951256036758423,
-0.25297173857688904,
-0.5226249694824219,
0.20022107660770416,
-0.23261529207229614,
0.3297184407711029,
0.3228051960468292,
-0.6449741721153259,
0.06274720281362534,
-0.3727050721645355,
0.5348505973815918,
1.071549654006958,
-0.0944523811340332,
0.5688030123710632,
-0.0578685998916626,
0.3803118169307709,
0.16694562137126923,
0.3588736355304718,
0.03748474642634392,
-0.14770908653736115,
-0.5679266452789307,
0.13913694024085999,
0.18356217443943024,
0.8757723569869995,
-0.16912685334682465,
0.4799586832523346,
0.0904766395688057,
-0.25248977541923523,
-0.8542740941047668,
0.35073769092559814,
0.7149662971496582,
0.48792415857315063,
0.22624176740646362,
-0.18727892637252808,
-0.46442869305610657,
-0.886747419834137,
-0.3859884440898895,
-0.4056664705276489,
0.4419689476490021,
-0.041334621608257294,
0.4532161056995392,
-0.23433268070220947,
0.4378677010536194,
-0.17626498639583588,
0.1379147469997406,
-0.10189821571111679,
-0.17150674760341644,
0.03465389087796211,
0.6374599933624268,
0.2971365451812744,
-0.5570590496063232,
-0.0048268744722008705,
-0.20114408433437347,
-0.863959550857544,
-0.03776901215314865,
-0.11189635097980499,
-0.2561759650707245,
0.054321471601724625,
0.6104487180709839,
-0.599884033203125,
0.6225780844688416,
0.3592919111251831,
-0.48478469252586365,
0.6012639999389648,
0.1453629434108734,
-0.1502082496881485,
-0.9481821656227112,
-0.26134195923805237,
-0.030085507780313492,
-0.14128689467906952,
-0.6534175872802734,
0.3162273168563843,
0.35335639119148254,
-0.042898014187812805,
-0.7506616711616516,
0.14188537001609802,
-0.5253903865814209,
0.02706821821630001,
-0.3473665714263916,
0.1540728062391281,
-0.13417984545230865,
0.26194897294044495,
-0.3869178295135498,
0.5846570134162903,
0.476739764213562,
-0.3003842830657959,
0.06315891444683075,
0.12070050090551376,
-0.2302938997745514,
0.3543207347393036,
-0.5269226431846619,
0.15487439930438995,
-0.12278977036476135,
-0.16664519906044006,
-0.8651110529899597,
-0.12913334369659424,
0.2366236448287964,
-0.194375142455101,
0.33343133330345154,
-0.45909732580184937,
-0.5631391406059265,
-0.30304309725761414,
-0.31386953592300415,
0.24407164752483368,
0.6884914040565491,
-0.49490541219711304,
0.1432396024465561,
0.6416483521461487,
0.018230145797133446,
-0.820961594581604,
-0.5893044471740723,
0.173550546169281,
-0.7025640606880188,
-0.4520159363746643,
0.22208170592784882,
0.013647112995386124,
-0.543337345123291,
0.1131109818816185,
-0.34347352385520935,
0.10196632891893387,
0.7089218497276306,
0.5950101017951965,
0.5189991593360901,
-0.08604694157838821,
-0.0635809600353241,
0.16099388897418976,
-0.08983197063207626,
0.38528069853782654,
-0.004746420308947563,
0.3364308476448059,
-0.5093576908111572,
-0.3970904052257538,
-0.5215645432472229,
0.07565480470657349,
0.5541565418243408,
-0.007972883060574532,
1.0451273918151855,
0.20318126678466797,
-0.2532675862312317,
0.047472450882196426,
-0.46660226583480835,
-0.10457891970872879,
-0.5359284281730652,
0.0753943994641304,
-0.14208735525608063,
-1.1046743392944336,
0.6202162504196167,
-0.06264138966798782,
0.10166246443986893,
0.08601907640695572,
0.5673553347587585,
-0.2596433162689209,
0.8852621912956238,
0.8895657658576965,
-0.18092581629753113,
0.3597129285335541,
0.24014802277088165,
0.4953860640525818,
-0.8579531311988831,
-0.20452472567558289,
-0.5347811579704285,
-0.44807082414627075,
-0.7802777290344238,
0.12735199928283691,
-0.011836715042591095,
0.6841342449188232,
-0.42197391390800476,
0.45164427161216736,
-0.3987688720226288,
0.9935533404350281,
0.27691373229026794,
0.3469861149787903,
0.16866528987884521,
-0.24098651111125946,
-0.34071242809295654,
0.02367611788213253,
-0.1497442126274109,
-0.8232424259185791,
0.9153921604156494,
0.6640116572380066,
1.248407006263733,
0.36361491680145264,
1.237889289855957,
-0.00021211944113019854,
0.4325776696205139,
-0.9157106876373291,
0.5965476632118225,
-0.040717095136642456,
-0.713150143623352,
-0.017224323004484177,
-0.15662604570388794,
-0.8074946403503418,
0.0928836539387703,
-0.27137407660484314,
-1.1316099166870117,
0.06488410383462906,
0.15155263245105743,
-0.3634567856788635,
0.44104278087615967,
-0.795041561126709,
0.8032670617103577,
-0.736928403377533,
-0.7297854423522949,
-0.07995101809501648,
-1.136116623878479,
0.7748582363128662,
-0.055381420999765396,
0.37683647871017456,
-0.42663636803627014,
0.18617287278175354,
0.6021462082862854,
-0.6508855223655701,
1.0796153545379639,
-0.25206610560417175,
-0.15686553716659546,
0.17949607968330383,
0.36757004261016846,
0.5652980804443359,
-0.07729759067296982,
0.010222974233329296,
0.04115531966090202,
-0.33419033885002136,
-0.26874208450317383,
-0.2988883852958679,
0.7008724808692932,
-0.839667797088623,
-0.9349498748779297,
-0.3530559241771698,
-0.6078039407730103,
-0.11891789734363556,
0.287235289812088,
0.0352310985326767,
-0.1625475138425827,
0.1642628312110901,
0.018205717206001282,
0.758482038974762,
-0.24679215252399445,
0.4852272570133209,
0.6145107746124268,
-0.1808810979127884,
-0.02925851196050644,
0.4444356858730316,
-0.07774513214826584,
0.30138587951660156,
0.12505318224430084,
0.21690113842487335,
-0.2156766653060913,
-0.8859192728996277,
-0.29277461767196655,
0.12477350234985352,
-0.7757903337478638,
-0.1854747235774994,
-0.39557287096977234,
-0.2698642909526825,
-0.16898185014724731,
-0.3822689950466156,
-0.19949942827224731,
-0.2901301383972168,
-0.21456459164619446,
-0.7273849248886108,
0.33691346645355225,
0.8523150086402893,
-0.22271619737148285,
0.469836950302124,
-0.8173576593399048,
0.31883561611175537,
0.07819032669067383,
0.30672404170036316,
0.014230127446353436,
-0.4567807614803314,
-0.24961866438388824,
-0.21130621433258057,
-0.49217814207077026,
-1.161564588546753,
0.13662897050380707,
-0.2620900273323059,
0.5958863496780396,
0.6163769960403442,
0.11778397113084793,
0.7960677742958069,
-0.7658421397209167,
0.44884419441223145,
0.31767019629478455,
-1.1942261457443237,
0.6361211538314819,
-0.3088224530220032,
-0.2849472165107727,
0.8447138667106628,
0.32536977529525757,
-0.30072033405303955,
-0.6501769423484802,
-0.5158734917640686,
-0.9748656749725342,
0.5726650953292847,
0.1009555459022522,
0.17234240472316742,
0.005807957611978054,
0.5592867732048035,
0.2540717124938965,
0.07808958739042282,
-1.2736974954605103,
-0.2103385627269745,
0.09912833571434021,
-0.5083047151565552,
0.0784134566783905,
-0.3363703489303589,
-0.4064907729625702,
-0.03566977009177208,
0.5531648397445679,
0.280703604221344,
0.14670248329639435,
-0.2627180218696594,
-0.3942372500896454,
-0.3154244124889374,
0.625923752784729,
0.47058817744255066,
0.3014528155326843,
-0.1796962022781372,
0.3049253523349762,
-0.21676243841648102,
-0.47962266206741333,
0.7145520448684692,
-0.08587853610515594,
-0.16108791530132294,
-0.5425171852111816,
0.15838314592838287,
0.878563642501831,
0.23063968122005463,
-0.43331843614578247,
0.6747119426727295,
-0.06790772080421448,
0.0737840011715889,
-0.16126911342144012,
0.3775300085544586,
0.164112389087677,
0.2919687032699585,
0.12744462490081787,
0.16113992035388947,
-0.027738479897379875,
-0.6817899346351624,
0.20436854660511017,
0.4442126452922821,
-0.49464306235313416,
-0.43127208948135376,
0.9904409646987915,
0.10924125462770462,
-0.2808205187320709,
0.5459400415420532,
-0.12267684936523438,
-0.5008869767189026,
0.5988650918006897,
0.6305502653121948,
1.0241541862487793,
-0.11161717772483826,
0.10511474311351776,
-0.06348869949579239,
0.7534253001213074,
-0.1268892139196396,
0.20692524313926697,
0.03984516113996506,
-0.8579244017601013,
-0.5042049288749695,
-0.6667553782463074,
-0.4071826934814453,
0.08724992722272873,
-0.8348466753959656,
0.11444604396820068,
-0.5718722343444824,
0.05491460859775543,
-0.24821273982524872,
-0.35930880904197693,
-0.3997860252857208,
0.0033997332211583853,
0.44263213872909546,
0.7080288529396057,
-1.0582321882247925,
0.7885254621505737,
0.4678008258342743,
-0.19699247181415558,
-1.1085671186447144,
0.3567149043083191,
0.3970768451690674,
-1.122051477432251,
0.46858420968055725,
0.6206814646720886,
-0.20463350415229797,
-0.2511681318283081,
-1.0324569940567017,
-0.716729462146759,
0.770928680896759,
0.41183698177337646,
-0.902988612651825,
-0.1375538557767868,
0.012216579169034958,
0.44377097487449646,
-0.06202683225274086,
-0.17161059379577637,
0.494806706905365,
0.2595975697040558,
-0.10423316061496735,
-0.6202275156974792,
0.39759406447410583,
-0.23895163834095,
-0.32057279348373413,
0.5461680293083191,
-0.45727166533470154,
0.6575434803962708,
-0.7125014662742615,
-0.2147434651851654,
0.10452350974082947,
0.2576442062854767,
0.5290917754173279,
0.33639228343963623,
0.36101847887039185,
0.9984641075134277,
0.6616784930229187,
-0.24712695181369781,
0.9106228351593018,
-0.4450221061706543,
0.24399513006210327,
0.9979693293571472,
-0.5889027118682861,
0.7025424242019653,
0.7743557095527649,
0.043915413320064545,
0.7046708464622498,
0.7512071132659912,
0.06434959918260574,
0.7326070070266724,
0.31471189856529236,
-0.20102857053279877,
-0.0900113582611084,
0.1336732804775238,
-0.05658181756734848,
0.46823087334632874,
0.3841902017593384,
-0.33649566769599915,
-0.11588162183761597,
0.2049720585346222,
0.47440823912620544,
-0.22534847259521484,
-0.51414954662323,
0.9594854712486267,
0.16255433857440948,
-0.4341154396533966,
0.43994417786598206,
0.05250336974859238,
0.5787949562072754,
-0.37330538034439087,
0.33363261818885803,
-0.08260691910982132,
0.16403041779994965,
-0.3922029435634613,
-1.1469577550888062,
0.2487116903066635,
0.3434698283672333,
0.10767606645822525,
-0.2317175567150116,
0.776574432849884,
-0.19870349764823914,
-0.13974256813526154,
0.4911882281303406,
0.36230066418647766,
0.14878560602664948,
0.36521926522254944,
-0.8523160815238953,
0.019277015700936317,
-0.06748447567224503,
-0.19855892658233643,
0.5270438194274902,
0.5116437673568726,
-0.07735272496938705,
0.5311238169670105,
0.6181063652038574,
0.008902373723685741,
0.3405887186527252,
-0.23769301176071167,
0.876251757144928,
-0.9315379858016968,
-0.561908483505249,
-1.3126568794250488,
0.7912347316741943,
0.24542208015918732,
0.055577848106622696,
0.6659085750579834,
0.3024842143058777,
0.77019864320755,
0.1812363713979721,
0.6821725368499756,
-0.07601582258939743,
0.07589774578809738,
-0.8158089518547058,
0.8551539182662964,
-0.3984164297580719,
0.5371159911155701,
-0.3571237623691559,
-0.6157600283622742,
-0.22374707460403442,
0.43180519342422485,
-0.612268328666687,
-0.36395561695098877,
0.640289306640625,
0.6923964023590088,
-0.00331482314504683,
-0.06572850793600082,
0.10780463367700577,
0.40203726291656494,
0.15479180216789246,
0.5956637263298035,
1.259182333946228,
-0.3221878409385681,
0.5513888597488403,
-0.408018559217453,
0.01109083741903305,
-0.11540290713310242,
-0.8694238662719727,
-0.7414947748184204,
-0.1072986051440239,
-0.18592040240764618,
-0.767772376537323,
0.34170815348625183,
0.6325021982192993,
0.5163070559501648,
-0.7399243116378784,
-0.24446891248226166,
-0.30484241247177124,
0.4580768644809723,
0.17230653762817383,
-0.29037320613861084,
0.12362518906593323,
-0.11986003071069717,
-0.19980266690254211,
0.4233066439628601,
0.42702537775039673,
0.2980816662311554,
-0.014770097099244595,
-0.10927494615316391,
-0.09202777594327927,
0.030793366953730583,
0.18010957539081573,
0.37622612714767456,
-0.7361260652542114,
-0.4389978051185608,
-0.3247116208076477,
-0.366324782371521,
0.20000648498535156,
0.5906707048416138,
-0.5168758034706116,
0.0674050897359848,
0.13724800944328308,
0.5920144319534302,
0.112877257168293,
0.09595176577568054,
0.3123849928379059,
-0.6512328386306763,
0.2374662160873413,
0.12712407112121582,
0.5694499611854553,
0.22148869931697845,
-0.6312891840934753,
0.3546082377433777,
0.06974335759878159,
-0.7104417681694031,
-1.0653108358383179,
0.4599786102771759,
-0.7234410047531128,
-0.2556648850440979,
0.865571141242981,
-0.18041062355041504,
-0.5437921285629272,
-0.15722642838954926,
0.019878586754202843,
0.24921010434627533,
-0.34582751989364624,
1.1088653802871704,
0.5435250401496887,
-0.12041082233190536,
-0.31791141629219055,
-0.5037076473236084,
0.30612754821777344,
0.293478399515152,
-0.8057131767272949,
0.02027883753180504,
0.37992751598358154,
0.5284308791160583,
0.030961446464061737,
0.135929137468338,
-0.4100801646709442,
0.2436995655298233,
-0.2982000410556793,
0.12087544798851013,
0.030031468719244003,
-0.2893543243408203,
-0.5906825661659241,
0.1957392394542694,
0.07918303459882736,
-0.09132701903581619
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.05629v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.05629v1
|
Separating the "Chirp" from the "Chat": Self-supervised Visual Grounding of Sound and Language
| 2024-06-09T03:38:21 | 2024-06-09T03:38:21 |
Mark Hamilton, Andrew Zisserman, John R. Hershey, William T. Freeman
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.IR, cs.LG, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
We present DenseAV, a novel dual encoder grounding architecture that learns
high-resolution, semantically meaningful, and audio-visually aligned features
solely through watching videos. We show that DenseAV can discover the
``meaning'' of words and the ``location'' of sounds without explicit
localization supervision. Furthermore, it automatically discovers and
distinguishes between these two types of associations without supervision. We
show that DenseAV's localization abilities arise from a new multi-head feature
aggregation operator that directly compares dense image and audio
representations for contrastive learning. In contrast, many other systems that
learn ``global'' audio and video representations cannot localize words and
sound. Finally, we contribute two new datasets to improve the evaluation of AV
representations through speech and sound prompted semantic segmentation. On
these and other datasets we show DenseAV dramatically outperforms the prior art
on speech and sound prompted semantic segmentation. DenseAV outperforms the
previous state-of-the-art, ImageBind, on cross-modal retrieval using fewer than
half of the parameters. Project Page:
\href{https://aka.ms/denseav}{https://aka.ms/denseav}
|
[
-0.4134940803050995,
-0.7793831825256348,
0.2832021117210388,
0.23145835101604462,
-0.5028916001319885,
-0.13718116283416748,
-0.33177247643470764,
-0.4159390330314636,
0.4815467596054077,
0.4830789864063263,
-0.4012834131717682,
-0.6586514711380005,
-0.5666185021400452,
-0.35288700461387634,
-0.46953877806663513,
0.5390495657920837,
0.4946598708629608,
0.16425009071826935,
-0.32396993041038513,
-0.43336862325668335,
-0.9512794613838196,
-0.33502525091171265,
-0.4219178855419159,
-0.10433027148246765,
0.3277020752429962,
0.4854047894477844,
0.6605690121650696,
0.8767545819282532,
0.4006132483482361,
0.29435473680496216,
-0.17277315258979797,
-0.012471710331737995,
-0.3790513873100281,
0.25212526321411133,
0.16835767030715942,
-0.22031918168067932,
0.03451158106327057,
-0.1672530621290207,
0.5841907858848572,
0.6456977128982544,
0.06735792011022568,
-0.14967317879199982,
-0.14436078071594238,
0.8183368444442749,
-0.7195854187011719,
0.17716524004936218,
-0.6929529309272766,
0.1985962688922882,
-0.040115680545568466,
-0.35847780108451843,
-0.0007918254123069346,
0.29905977845191956,
0.0957549437880516,
-0.7095740437507629,
0.1556100696325302,
-0.3247765302658081,
0.9095699191093445,
0.8342453837394714,
-0.3886151611804962,
-0.23993240296840668,
-0.5943817496299744,
0.847679615020752,
0.025177164003252983,
0.9877960681915283,
0.4926663935184479,
0.4910741448402405,
0.25209444761276245,
-0.5207226276397705,
-0.3292331099510193,
0.04199465364217758,
0.24330459535121918,
0.26176759600639343,
-0.09754552692174911,
0.22006091475486755,
-0.017105698585510254,
0.6122968196868896,
-0.5644155740737915,
-0.14788846671581268,
-0.5119532346725464,
-0.3883538842201233,
0.41672152280807495,
-0.2055957019329071,
0.41598236560821533,
-0.20923469960689545,
-0.28245142102241516,
-0.4013477563858032,
-0.2541913688182831,
0.03315232694149017,
0.08088698983192444,
0.21786713600158691,
-0.41932693123817444,
0.49917131662368774,
-0.4182937443256378,
0.4114323556423187,
0.31342804431915283,
-0.3454516530036926,
0.5822832584381104,
-0.2324734926223755,
-0.3502042889595032,
0.6017636656761169,
0.778444230556488,
0.18730111420154572,
0.10599357634782791,
-0.12770681083202362,
-0.026074016466736794,
0.40441104769706726,
-0.01350668165832758,
-0.4464035630226135,
-0.24212424457073212,
0.08321911096572876,
-0.38470742106437683,
-0.2111649364233017,
-0.0069710128009319305,
-0.4438712000846863,
-0.39590123295783997,
-0.5866491198539734,
0.5795648097991943,
-0.3858485519886017,
-0.41450682282447815,
0.2714317739009857,
-0.22037887573242188,
0.5236492156982422,
0.17876438796520233,
-1.0104478597640991,
0.2891043722629547,
0.6153689622879028,
0.8176242709159851,
0.09837282449007034,
-0.2967122197151184,
-0.65971839427948,
0.22224287688732147,
-0.5212291479110718,
0.9982233047485352,
-0.6021704077720642,
-0.03297584876418114,
-0.05876871943473816,
-0.20230628550052643,
0.5433943867683411,
-0.6997284293174744,
0.5673192739486694,
-0.321652352809906,
0.07060393691062927,
-0.5032780170440674,
-0.10711158812046051,
-0.16769368946552277,
-0.005461367778480053,
-0.5165753364562988,
1.0185352563858032,
-0.03248399868607521,
-0.7670409083366394,
0.8019727468490601,
-0.17905698716640472,
-0.4932490885257721,
0.028876394033432007,
-0.7291020750999451,
-0.11494209617376328,
0.11121060699224472,
0.41979721188545227,
0.4205016493797302,
-0.029159806668758392,
0.3559153378009796,
-0.37142497301101685,
-0.6611130833625793,
-0.3324841558933258,
-0.2484121471643448,
0.5387828350067139,
0.3295378088951111,
-0.46354207396507263,
0.18066877126693726,
-0.9714111685752869,
-0.22850832343101501,
0.13622142374515533,
-0.14093530178070068,
-0.5017493963241577,
0.02863970398902893,
-0.0019550255965441465,
0.21131174266338348,
0.11965809017419815,
-0.3154022991657257,
-0.17804130911827087,
-0.40180620551109314,
0.4179542064666748,
0.5050479769706726,
-0.11992883682250977,
0.7519203424453735,
0.048845574259757996,
0.27606767416000366,
0.14215630292892456,
-0.06021371856331825,
-0.35979560017585754,
-0.2916630208492279,
-0.747824490070343,
-0.6569116115570068,
-0.07570918649435043,
0.4448959529399872,
-0.34565821290016174,
0.7759451270103455,
-0.169328510761261,
-0.24672536551952362,
-0.6859319806098938,
0.33010709285736084,
0.1933990865945816,
0.5581789612770081,
0.47504210472106934,
-0.3513919413089752,
-0.8191615343093872,
-0.9671404957771301,
0.09711989015340805,
-0.20742788910865784,
-0.08085759729146957,
0.42670851945877075,
-0.0024647575337439775,
-0.5419179797172546,
0.7622905969619751,
-0.2104732096195221,
-0.7816005945205688,
0.058842048048973083,
0.1269242763519287,
-0.004379496444016695,
0.4408814311027527,
0.47654685378074646,
-0.7530999779701233,
-0.21094544231891632,
0.1014011800289154,
-1.2682723999023438,
-0.14568360149860382,
-0.17083518207073212,
0.0067353942431509495,
-0.2769004702568054,
0.7682228088378906,
-0.45238375663757324,
0.20599058270454407,
0.49001848697662354,
-0.22118927538394928,
0.19738784432411194,
-0.039160776883363724,
0.24172578752040863,
-0.7314669489860535,
-0.3240537643432617,
-0.24919842183589935,
-0.10633332282304764,
-0.3286093473434448,
-0.173946812748909,
-0.28521761298179626,
-0.33437031507492065,
-0.47896626591682434,
0.4013606309890747,
-0.6661950349807739,
-0.6269728541374207,
-0.48035189509391785,
0.2500685751438141,
0.08648139983415604,
0.4143868386745453,
0.2774847447872162,
0.7430812120437622,
1.2563600540161133,
-0.5691936016082764,
0.38985469937324524,
0.3410426676273346,
-0.42624709010124207,
0.6726526021957397,
-0.6676303744316101,
0.1253417283296585,
-0.2611768841743469,
0.10571427643299103,
-1.0349849462509155,
-0.300204336643219,
0.002971943002194166,
-0.6491543054580688,
0.13354994356632233,
-0.42549586296081543,
-0.3198457658290863,
0.24624314904212952,
0.020962433889508247,
0.7250697016716003,
0.6149483323097229,
-0.697870671749115,
0.5483167171478271,
0.8472307324409485,
0.22924450039863586,
-0.4935404360294342,
-0.828016459941864,
0.16848672926425934,
-0.45669078826904297,
-0.9397439360618591,
-0.06895545870065689,
0.17263779044151306,
-0.35723769664764404,
-0.1395898163318634,
-0.3430950939655304,
-0.30732885003089905,
-0.04209919273853302,
0.5143151879310608,
-0.47878116369247437,
-0.42044684290885925,
0.45626023411750793,
0.06462070345878601,
-0.1806856095790863,
0.08031890541315079,
-0.475441038608551,
0.25051090121269226,
-0.38016337156295776,
-0.2280038744211197,
-0.36520296335220337,
0.4381638467311859,
0.46796828508377075,
-0.463957816362381,
0.11922358721494675,
0.9788111448287964,
-0.38133952021598816,
0.012110496871173382,
-0.8238207101821899,
-0.2704266309738159,
-0.5509970784187317,
0.33834925293922424,
-0.45801302790641785,
-1.1074988842010498,
0.39327308535575867,
0.12137185037136078,
-0.4443189203739166,
0.33079850673675537,
0.3910132348537445,
-0.2895020544528961,
1.0648193359375,
0.6472288966178894,
0.02975299209356308,
0.6742709279060364,
-0.32973507046699524,
-0.01137737650424242,
-0.6599705219268799,
-0.3546964228153229,
-0.2680698037147522,
-0.2039794772863388,
-0.38564741611480713,
-0.5217723250389099,
0.32702335715293884,
0.19274261593818665,
-0.06801892817020416,
0.0915403813123703,
-0.7573479413986206,
0.6828697323799133,
0.6266132593154907,
0.03077390417456627,
0.02227729745209217,
0.442629873752594,
-0.11889992654323578,
-0.2790452241897583,
-0.6268884539604187,
0.01102861575782299,
0.7205309271812439,
0.318818598985672,
0.8053549528121948,
-0.32273441553115845,
0.7078143954277039,
0.5028682947158813,
-0.5202640295028687,
-1.0138591527938843,
0.48478439450263977,
-0.04336194694042206,
-0.3503307104110718,
-0.4730988144874573,
-0.3550874590873718,
-0.9461109042167664,
0.492725133895874,
-0.3340092897415161,
-0.340537965297699,
0.48567771911621094,
0.12007340043783188,
-0.0429476723074913,
0.07008837908506393,
-0.5683569312095642,
0.8640098571777344,
-0.524878740310669,
-0.44767412543296814,
-0.45120567083358765,
-0.6353653073310852,
0.28400224447250366,
0.2670862078666687,
0.40451037883758545,
-0.2950011193752289,
0.08245652168989182,
0.7772157788276672,
-0.06978905200958252,
0.722998321056366,
-0.28297123312950134,
-0.03330136090517044,
0.5707533359527588,
0.027359118685126305,
-0.15645505487918854,
0.17358265817165375,
0.441352516412735,
0.5204606056213379,
-0.061594679951667786,
-0.45949408411979675,
-0.6392982602119446,
0.9570965766906738,
-0.8763976693153381,
-0.3710481524467468,
-0.4390067160129547,
-0.328375905752182,
-0.10094831138849258,
0.5044578909873962,
0.13765811920166016,
0.481659471988678,
-0.24240167438983917,
0.6305710077285767,
0.8205195069313049,
-0.15623289346694946,
-0.021517256274819374,
0.16375721991062164,
0.04798794537782669,
-0.8384765982627869,
1.0712051391601562,
-0.10089244693517685,
-0.31582948565483093,
0.5452448129653931,
0.4766431152820587,
-0.3409411311149597,
-0.46273425221443176,
-0.14003850519657135,
0.2513422667980194,
-1.052101969718933,
0.13068409264087677,
-0.8458870649337769,
0.12054429948329926,
-0.4737120270729065,
-0.4266962707042694,
-0.6507819294929504,
-0.13787010312080383,
-0.39447563886642456,
-0.3221420347690582,
-0.00474196020513773,
0.49132055044174194,
-0.3783107101917267,
0.36563950777053833,
-0.505785346031189,
0.6316059231758118,
0.863307774066925,
0.2885169982910156,
-0.40497228503227234,
-0.5366007685661316,
-0.4451020658016205,
-0.11029794067144394,
0.15138264000415802,
-0.723013699054718,
0.33195337653160095,
0.20148304104804993,
0.5022015571594238,
0.7407035827636719,
-0.20395956933498383,
1.0030906200408936,
-0.33303871750831604,
0.638282299041748,
0.18226055800914764,
-0.913952648639679,
0.6997814178466797,
-0.42594224214553833,
0.586713433265686,
0.825994610786438,
0.0004335345875006169,
-0.4730152189731598,
-0.12044870853424072,
-0.4677587151527405,
-0.8207252025604248,
0.39930951595306396,
0.07304147630929947,
0.11659623682498932,
-0.2673265039920807,
0.09114163368940353,
-0.10674336552619934,
0.054066695272922516,
-0.54471755027771,
-0.09709418565034866,
-0.7582688927650452,
-0.031854551285505295,
-0.008466864936053753,
-0.3793628513813019,
-0.20746347308158875,
-0.3318297564983368,
0.32126808166503906,
-0.28495869040489197,
0.23897302150726318,
0.4055477976799011,
-0.3965054452419281,
-0.20290376245975494,
0.021588990464806557,
0.44372278451919556,
0.24565763771533966,
-0.29729247093200684,
0.4912908971309662,
0.07735100388526917,
-0.329985111951828,
0.1261335164308548,
-0.4008278548717499,
0.03709825500845909,
0.08915723860263824,
0.6058643460273743,
0.8845440149307251,
0.619050920009613,
-0.82057785987854,
0.7068110108375549,
-0.10945103317499161,
-0.37700432538986206,
-0.5581495761871338,
-0.07701577991247177,
-0.2120378166437149,
0.2217579483985901,
0.24993106722831726,
0.02462545409798622,
0.5033091306686401,
-0.49065732955932617,
0.522469699382782,
0.5007840991020203,
-0.8280365467071533,
-0.4167298972606659,
0.7346938252449036,
0.23362405598163605,
0.06626284122467041,
0.5009114742279053,
0.18606293201446533,
-0.12216957658529282,
0.4341941475868225,
0.26013872027397156,
1.098061442375183,
0.0722988098859787,
0.028628338128328323,
0.3683793544769287,
0.2950787842273712,
0.03500821441411972,
0.27608343958854675,
-0.6728461980819702,
-0.778012216091156,
-0.39920276403427124,
-0.4898822605609894,
-0.10770672559738159,
0.16356922686100006,
-0.6353326439857483,
0.4778166711330414,
-0.5688701868057251,
0.13799701631069183,
-0.19956287741661072,
-0.20516245067119598,
-0.6755708456039429,
0.41698595881462097,
0.5633220672607422,
0.47971898317337036,
-1.105491280555725,
0.7023206353187561,
0.7709103226661682,
-0.35195815563201904,
-0.5118470788002014,
-0.21210363507270813,
0.04676543176174164,
-0.6405330896377563,
0.7481694221496582,
0.41905179619789124,
-0.4537718594074249,
-0.29344379901885986,
-0.6593402028083801,
-1.0755339860916138,
0.9413632154464722,
0.593835711479187,
-0.29816365242004395,
0.11708145588636398,
-0.08149627596139908,
0.47608497738838196,
-0.2321823686361313,
0.31599804759025574,
0.35900235176086426,
0.42344367504119873,
0.33494091033935547,
-0.5188965201377869,
-0.3715040683746338,
-0.11279163509607315,
-0.4239296019077301,
-0.09403369575738907,
-0.7481264472007751,
0.43328985571861267,
-0.006480241194367409,
-0.27120596170425415,
-0.578902006149292,
1.103785514831543,
0.15104225277900696,
0.37652188539505005,
0.6097093224525452,
0.7246580719947815,
0.5278376340866089,
0.0009397281100973487,
0.6079011559486389,
-0.05750613659620285,
-0.032476671040058136,
1.1054694652557373,
-0.04503469169139862,
0.5314781069755554,
0.514502227306366,
0.24070048332214355,
0.2809141278266907,
0.4195314347743988,
0.016273140907287598,
0.7562236785888672,
-0.2455255538225174,
-0.14962328970432281,
-0.8046143651008606,
-0.23257847130298615,
-0.35016459226608276,
1.054597020149231,
0.2986590564250946,
-0.006426322273910046,
-0.10254264622926712,
0.1075909212231636,
-0.5695736408233643,
0.22078195214271545,
-0.2230457067489624,
1.0295958518981934,
0.18417921662330627,
-0.22458583116531372,
0.8493140339851379,
-0.4626348614692688,
0.7110243439674377,
-0.6889070868492126,
-0.371599406003952,
-0.23023666441440582,
-0.04768265411257744,
-0.4073846936225891,
-0.42540863156318665,
0.405222624540329,
-0.3571874797344208,
-0.03869242966175079,
-0.11326341331005096,
0.7806997895240784,
-0.5103154182434082,
-0.18311680853366852,
0.7093291878700256,
0.1523047536611557,
0.30419203639030457,
-0.24023248255252838,
-0.557079553604126,
0.4444063603878021,
-0.2825957238674164,
0.1360856592655182,
0.2963310480117798,
0.7635848522186279,
-0.06461504846811295,
0.6321884989738464,
0.6027889251708984,
0.04579240828752518,
0.16909782588481903,
0.23419752717018127,
0.7806259989738464,
-0.6584434509277344,
-0.8010160326957703,
-0.4275737702846527,
0.24244152009487152,
0.19993411004543304,
-0.08025036752223969,
0.6691606640815735,
0.6721861362457275,
1.0516352653503418,
-0.09432388097047806,
0.6772676110267639,
0.2635449767112732,
-0.012394632212817669,
-0.5965354442596436,
0.3200717866420746,
-0.7682201266288757,
-0.03790992498397827,
-0.3569801449775696,
-0.8899251818656921,
-0.414706289768219,
0.8336911797523499,
-0.09806417673826218,
-0.16177591681480408,
0.5644770264625549,
0.6439107060432434,
-0.3455507457256317,
-0.3497871160507202,
0.9158870577812195,
0.2245885133743286,
0.19614140689373016,
0.08261729031801224,
0.8013990521430969,
-0.4245842397212982,
0.7579669952392578,
-0.34891074895858765,
-0.23800541460514069,
-0.18151673674583435,
-0.47676607966423035,
-1.1006886959075928,
-0.5345802903175354,
-0.34535810351371765,
-0.09425824135541916,
0.0989948958158493,
0.7284250855445862,
1.1629178524017334,
-0.7392317056655884,
-0.38674357533454895,
-0.18042966723442078,
0.0793316513299942,
-0.4016111195087433,
-0.21965013444423676,
0.2402031123638153,
-0.32190778851509094,
-0.430496484041214,
1.2112308740615845,
0.6574540138244629,
-0.06490650027990341,
-0.3119426965713501,
-0.25520792603492737,
-0.024335112422704697,
-0.03790557384490967,
0.5566509366035461,
0.46290698647499084,
-0.8474199771881104,
-0.4151429533958435,
-0.13229167461395264,
0.011602813377976418,
0.546209990978241,
0.7122469544410706,
-1.0105586051940918,
0.861799955368042,
0.7592006325721741,
0.7312675714492798,
0.6686071753501892,
-0.018182829022407532,
0.3410753905773163,
-0.7262837886810303,
0.629396915435791,
0.21602217853069305,
0.4683243930339813,
0.5995528697967529,
-0.37920886278152466,
0.2869783043861389,
0.35521194338798523,
-0.4745500385761261,
-0.5470281839370728,
0.1915057748556137,
-1.2929638624191284,
0.022186066955327988,
1.1685789823532104,
0.4068056046962738,
-0.2866024076938629,
-0.118571437895298,
-0.3752363920211792,
0.30671951174736023,
-0.5040088295936584,
0.6703961491584778,
0.4345454275608063,
0.2597721815109253,
-0.5311482548713684,
-0.30114999413490295,
0.42390695214271545,
0.5818852782249451,
-0.30281779170036316,
-0.10100728273391724,
0.7463815212249756,
0.3079259693622589,
0.1676657348871231,
0.6880446076393127,
-0.20667923986911774,
0.4960801899433136,
0.24388624727725983,
0.28722238540649414,
-0.31908074021339417,
-0.7021180987358093,
-0.7639837265014648,
0.27109670639038086,
-0.035409197211265564,
-0.3053187131881714
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.05625v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.05625v1
|
ATLAS: Improving Lay Summarisation with Attribute-based Control
| 2024-06-09T03:22:55 | 2024-06-09T03:22:55 |
Zhihao Zhang, Tomas Goldsack, Carolina Scarton, Chenghua Lin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Lay summarisation aims to produce summaries of scientific articles that are
comprehensible to non-expert audiences. However, previous work assumes a
one-size-fits-all approach, where the content and style of the produced summary
are entirely dependent on the data used to train the model. In practice,
audiences with different levels of expertise will have specific needs,
impacting what content should appear in a lay summary and how it should be
presented. Aiming to address this, we propose ATLAS, a novel abstractive
summarisation approach that can control various properties that contribute to
the overall "layness" of the generated summary using targeted control
attributes. We evaluate ATLAS on a combination of biomedical lay summarisation
datasets, where it outperforms state-of-the-art baselines using mainstream
summarisation metrics. Additional analyses provided on the discriminatory power
and emergent influence of our selected controllable attributes further attest
to the effectiveness of our approach.
|
[
-0.3085513710975647,
-0.15568988025188446,
0.20128712058067322,
0.18808157742023468,
-0.36987125873565674,
0.09611353278160095,
0.15845432877540588,
-0.5862162709236145,
0.8144255876541138,
0.2828971743583679,
-0.10001800209283829,
-0.6270827651023865,
-0.9908209443092346,
0.27229806780815125,
-0.3909226953983307,
1.254938006401062,
-0.12505929172039032,
-0.28290635347366333,
-0.6077966690063477,
-0.6049457788467407,
-0.08620930463075638,
-0.23335227370262146,
-0.4298321604728699,
-0.5797960162162781,
1.1946001052856445,
0.2855805456638336,
1.0341509580612183,
0.9552142024040222,
0.5928090810775757,
0.06458158791065216,
-0.6163801550865173,
0.5270763039588928,
-0.7907133102416992,
-0.15691955387592316,
-0.187075674533844,
-0.1722700297832489,
-1.0461463928222656,
-0.05020750313997269,
0.5516302585601807,
0.9791861176490784,
0.002204917138442397,
0.07471055537462234,
0.15233610570430756,
0.8034877777099609,
-0.8339628577232361,
0.0043441555462777615,
-0.20302104949951172,
0.2172907292842865,
0.037846989929676056,
-0.3150704801082611,
-0.49343377351760864,
-0.13126420974731445,
-0.08736798167228699,
-0.8446710705757141,
0.03318048268556595,
0.2025853544473648,
0.7588241696357727,
0.12584060430526733,
-0.9166002869606018,
-0.19147619605064392,
-0.4890284836292267,
0.7691087126731873,
-0.8943154811859131,
0.05803680792450905,
0.462253600358963,
-0.04045485705137253,
-0.008595085702836514,
-0.6800087690353394,
-0.1526615470647812,
-0.1772228330373764,
-0.628280758857727,
0.3693244159221649,
-0.20414984226226807,
-0.08471139520406723,
-0.04015170782804489,
0.193637415766716,
-0.48500165343284607,
0.29257315397262573,
-0.8171594738960266,
-0.27205660939216614,
0.9786566495895386,
0.06885240226984024,
0.22360460460186005,
-0.07396654039621353,
-0.059948619455099106,
0.1605726033449173,
-0.855945348739624,
0.02266194485127926,
0.12042509019374847,
0.0643855482339859,
-0.19746918976306915,
0.5966127514839172,
-0.5522807836532593,
0.571508526802063,
0.130884051322937,
-0.19991843402385712,
0.23652037978172302,
0.13491125404834747,
0.20389272272586823,
0.25063279271125793,
0.825143575668335,
0.6305203437805176,
-0.21846993267536163,
-0.26857033371925354,
-0.15676243603229523,
-0.3800900876522064,
0.17046818137168884,
-0.7641340494155884,
-0.2067781686782837,
0.5420568585395813,
-0.599960207939148,
-0.4681238830089569,
-0.21226537227630615,
-0.3135225772857666,
-0.4386344850063324,
-0.37305185198783875,
0.35840556025505066,
-0.5322060585021973,
-0.14301785826683044,
-0.2658883333206177,
-0.14728021621704102,
0.12398848682641983,
0.5587019920349121,
-0.7685208916664124,
0.2856312096118927,
0.40706902742385864,
1.0977345705032349,
-0.5462095141410828,
0.02346951700747013,
-0.3021472990512848,
0.8091764450073242,
-0.4159018099308014,
0.8437482118606567,
-0.32179760932922363,
-0.5068314075469971,
-0.41911086440086365,
-0.29642292857170105,
0.2779286801815033,
-0.07900577038526535,
0.23340103030204773,
-0.5508326888084412,
0.16867056488990784,
-0.2202506959438324,
-0.3607408106327057,
-0.4138529300689697,
-0.03273013234138489,
-0.7585316300392151,
0.5483314394950867,
-0.010233413428068161,
-0.7726317048072815,
0.4317459464073181,
-0.6344454884529114,
-0.9904676079750061,
-0.11533157527446747,
-0.30512091517448425,
-0.6302334666252136,
0.18640796840190887,
0.4797223210334778,
0.3403099477291107,
0.17252609133720398,
0.10260841995477676,
0.05122579634189606,
0.010757926851511002,
0.04541191831231117,
0.33431902527809143,
0.4791927933692932,
0.3040134310722351,
-0.03676050528883934,
0.37206828594207764,
-0.9269328117370605,
0.12944015860557556,
-0.3041386008262634,
0.19785448908805847,
-0.37453919649124146,
0.30560949444770813,
-0.20443998277187347,
0.10553652048110962,
0.2844630181789398,
-0.13348568975925446,
0.11409439891576767,
-0.019050637260079384,
0.23144574463367462,
0.5775949954986572,
0.17467933893203735,
0.4445045292377472,
-0.7507477402687073,
0.5197917819023132,
-0.03396880254149437,
-0.1741788536310196,
-0.008566105738282204,
-0.25190114974975586,
-0.3624650239944458,
-0.7358302474021912,
0.4641333520412445,
0.3261231780052185,
-0.6037991046905518,
0.39528557658195496,
-0.20670045912265778,
-0.7154820561408997,
-0.3725142478942871,
0.119165800511837,
0.5298211574554443,
0.5002715587615967,
0.5187111496925354,
-0.6968205571174622,
-0.19485723972320557,
-1.130228042602539,
-0.06252660602331161,
-0.07310705631971359,
-0.5096654295921326,
0.2359515279531479,
0.5268834233283997,
0.05753263831138611,
0.8090172410011292,
-0.6798243522644043,
-0.412433385848999,
-0.5272234678268433,
0.6266179084777832,
0.015989549458026886,
0.6613074541091919,
0.4472930431365967,
-0.8889766931533813,
-0.13649161159992218,
0.2836921811103821,
-0.9721750617027283,
-0.48000016808509827,
-0.11707932502031326,
-0.19889746606349945,
-0.30959010124206543,
0.41862523555755615,
-0.4538029134273529,
0.5608289241790771,
0.25129255652427673,
-0.2537546753883362,
0.34167802333831787,
-0.5594010353088379,
0.12932029366493225,
-0.8233606815338135,
0.40905460715293884,
-0.17492623627185822,
-0.39424407482147217,
-0.408409059047699,
-0.003045175690203905,
0.12700916826725006,
-0.04882967844605446,
-0.5513695478439331,
0.09553035348653793,
-0.505047619342804,
-0.023989688605070114,
-0.2240089774131775,
-0.026960918679833412,
0.3991571068763733,
0.4327545464038849,
0.1290798932313919,
0.4810551404953003,
0.296455055475235,
-0.8416810631752014,
0.0049722990952432156,
0.7536531090736389,
0.09090317785739899,
0.4822179079055786,
-1.1707351207733154,
-0.025085974484682083,
-0.7710582613945007,
0.43154940009117126,
-0.747189462184906,
-0.40389883518218994,
-0.21480581164360046,
-0.5398109555244446,
0.4905414879322052,
0.42826899886131287,
-0.04534556716680527,
0.20336344838142395,
-0.41932252049446106,
0.3462047278881073,
0.5189833641052246,
0.1534343957901001,
0.959968626499176,
0.44499191641807556,
-0.46312832832336426,
-0.3775874078273773,
-0.6233967542648315,
0.12239237129688263,
-0.18547964096069336,
-0.4208903908729553,
0.4405149519443512,
0.0960325300693512,
-0.24025097489356995,
0.006500226445496082,
-0.09280829131603241,
-0.1097998395562172,
-0.014607713557779789,
0.25007569789886475,
-0.09376136213541031,
0.14757996797561646,
0.07891985028982162,
0.49070119857788086,
-0.12098991870880127,
-0.031925544142723083,
-0.0817360207438469,
-0.08659520745277405,
0.33712413907051086,
-0.05139310657978058,
-0.5265601873397827,
0.7224194407463074,
0.7633491158485413,
-0.6799041628837585,
0.7115849256515503,
0.13762842118740082,
0.0546603798866272,
-0.1559249311685562,
0.1859731823205948,
-0.04776743799448013,
-0.3273952007293701,
0.4652867913246155,
-0.04641779884696007,
-0.36892011761665344,
0.7747896313667297,
0.02449510246515274,
0.46463558077812195,
0.647642970085144,
0.4503125846385956,
-0.44043025374412537,
1.2517144680023193,
0.7992196083068848,
0.09932676702737808,
0.08676695078611374,
-0.31539902091026306,
-0.04165080934762955,
-0.8825851082801819,
-0.5260209441184998,
-0.457295686006546,
-0.8230441212654114,
-0.392374187707901,
0.04964115098118782,
0.9620654582977295,
-0.18373771011829376,
0.14987660944461823,
0.06220797449350357,
-0.48106566071510315,
0.49432632327079773,
0.36125364899635315,
0.4918951988220215,
0.4572274386882782,
-0.32601407170295715,
0.1993575543165207,
0.09092921763658524,
-0.8428247570991516,
-0.5622295141220093,
1.154664397239685,
0.17458447813987732,
0.8232496380805969,
0.3727589547634125,
0.41483771800994873,
0.7298644781112671,
0.5230457186698914,
-0.4612271189689636,
0.4268847405910492,
-0.06741094589233398,
-0.3421503007411957,
-0.19323216378688812,
-0.4838055372238159,
-0.9749765992164612,
0.2679602801799774,
-0.2805708348751068,
-0.5433993935585022,
0.3361353576183319,
0.5180869102478027,
-0.43965595960617065,
0.17158107459545135,
-0.5088686347007751,
0.3477666676044464,
-0.14086073637008667,
-0.32587558031082153,
-0.07046347111463547,
-0.9357431530952454,
0.33915525674819946,
-0.0711575374007225,
0.4802156090736389,
-0.17464402318000793,
-0.31658226251602173,
0.9143397212028503,
-0.4584944546222687,
0.6405424475669861,
0.4276120662689209,
-0.07623883336782455,
0.12255870550870895,
0.136764258146286,
0.3365376591682434,
-0.13001607358455658,
0.012641062960028648,
0.3063075840473175,
-0.12461157143115997,
-0.9469214677810669,
-0.5286455154418945,
0.4476398229598999,
-0.8624480366706848,
-0.37323543429374695,
-0.5000311732292175,
-1.0964068174362183,
-0.18773020803928375,
0.3333657681941986,
0.4870656430721283,
0.7661558389663696,
-0.024218803271651268,
0.37691664695739746,
0.7155632972717285,
-0.21953892707824707,
0.04819939285516739,
0.6619515419006348,
-0.10318056493997574,
-0.409963458776474,
0.8262276649475098,
0.39860033988952637,
0.6636230945587158,
0.6255885362625122,
0.1811515986919403,
0.07698245346546173,
-0.9167720079421997,
-0.13406968116760254,
-0.01201357040554285,
-0.5467519164085388,
-0.12963730096817017,
-0.7207450866699219,
-0.032299287617206573,
-0.6532878279685974,
-0.50858074426651,
0.08775996416807175,
-0.8197446465492249,
-0.22436484694480896,
-0.30722638964653015,
0.4285518527030945,
1.0398727655410767,
-0.27275264263153076,
0.5176851153373718,
-0.41537898778915405,
0.5334120988845825,
0.16669893264770508,
0.20398645102977753,
-0.16895923018455505,
-0.5831269025802612,
-0.2899356186389923,
-0.13827884197235107,
-0.5153119564056396,
-0.868326723575592,
0.6317212581634521,
0.5137357711791992,
0.2948147654533386,
0.5432806611061096,
0.27671313285827637,
0.17254523932933807,
-0.540311336517334,
0.5671131610870361,
0.25422459840774536,
-0.7398470640182495,
0.6562427878379822,
-0.5370872020721436,
0.5803472995758057,
0.43713900446891785,
0.5405687093734741,
-0.07908017933368683,
-0.9935861229896545,
-0.5813389420509338,
-1.241835594177246,
0.3703383803367615,
0.6240186095237732,
-0.315839946269989,
0.3890669047832489,
0.12629984319210052,
0.20986491441726685,
0.42165523767471313,
-0.6110178232192993,
-0.3099460005760193,
-0.23772121965885162,
-0.24759458005428314,
-0.06596123427152634,
-0.1609967201948166,
-0.5475270748138428,
-0.14602817595005035,
0.8439974784851074,
-0.06467348337173462,
-0.25186243653297424,
0.40774592757225037,
-0.16051815450191498,
-0.03579948469996452,
0.09510107338428497,
0.7830541729927063,
1.3225581645965576,
-0.5064927935600281,
0.3827807307243347,
0.07441049814224243,
-0.49184104800224304,
-0.13423052430152893,
-0.03401977941393852,
-0.6792597770690918,
0.1536203920841217,
0.7658399939537048,
0.5423631072044373,
-0.030092621222138405,
-0.49836617708206177,
0.15764787793159485,
0.22744841873645782,
-0.2696394920349121,
0.18711577355861664,
0.06050381436944008,
-0.2362373173236847,
-0.29985496401786804,
0.4365643262863159,
0.01580786146223545,
0.33951202034950256,
-0.12141172587871552,
0.24514150619506836,
0.21197722852230072,
-0.383850634098053,
-0.3111603856086731,
1.0245165824890137,
0.3361127972602844,
0.052399661391973495,
-0.14034222066402435,
-0.09279315173625946,
-0.13827639818191528,
0.8817991018295288,
0.33785003423690796,
0.5645753145217896,
-0.19550573825836182,
0.16671974956989288,
0.17720162868499756,
0.4681544899940491,
0.45233699679374695,
0.18598616123199463,
0.16676653921604156,
-0.32869186997413635,
-0.6190091967582703,
-0.04757899418473244,
-0.7371382117271423,
-0.12069082260131836,
-0.9799091219902039,
0.09770458191633224,
-0.48336052894592285,
0.1354474425315857,
0.4869254231452942,
-0.3543970584869385,
-0.23690684139728546,
0.41603606939315796,
-0.06202780827879906,
0.9118777513504028,
-0.8750848770141602,
0.19459168612957,
0.6887764930725098,
-0.5691139101982117,
-0.6250048279762268,
-0.4838452637195587,
0.07772098481655121,
-0.492196261882782,
0.46115589141845703,
-0.037444859743118286,
0.07313914597034454,
-0.007092862855643034,
-0.8242675065994263,
-0.9279953241348267,
1.2899577617645264,
0.08881217241287231,
-0.21349801123142242,
0.02965037152171135,
-0.18326124548912048,
0.47695407271385193,
-0.3459519147872925,
0.4792371094226837,
0.3635343015193939,
0.34513357281684875,
0.4153590798377991,
-1.0025521516799927,
-0.22357900440692902,
-0.3388012945652008,
-0.2579968571662903,
0.274349182844162,
-0.7156811952590942,
0.7078505158424377,
-0.31957438588142395,
0.15568944811820984,
-0.1776614487171173,
1.2473030090332031,
0.02985602244734764,
0.5547246336936951,
0.2573501467704773,
0.5270183682441711,
0.9910133481025696,
-0.005040269810706377,
1.3293596506118774,
-0.3172262907028198,
0.1515367031097412,
1.0310871601104736,
-0.3373279869556427,
0.39899739623069763,
0.31442248821258545,
-0.12480305880308151,
0.5102942585945129,
0.28554362058639526,
0.4773745536804199,
0.7105196714401245,
0.08779098838567734,
-0.18873175978660583,
0.07999977469444275,
-0.48136183619499207,
-0.5965027809143066,
0.4429631531238556,
0.41072338819503784,
-0.38891494274139404,
-0.25493866205215454,
-0.04712066799402237,
0.33768951892852783,
0.17508263885974884,
-0.9457446932792664,
0.9207180738449097,
0.09612201154232025,
-0.32322874665260315,
0.5595863461494446,
-0.1539590060710907,
0.2046729326248169,
-1.1456793546676636,
0.005585292354226112,
-0.32190218567848206,
-0.18460172414779663,
-0.6047199368476868,
-0.5255359411239624,
0.2605505883693695,
-0.05395340174436569,
-0.2723536789417267,
-0.36275002360343933,
0.4536619782447815,
-0.6248180270195007,
-0.6695412993431091,
-0.40148574113845825,
0.297994464635849,
0.1315298080444336,
0.3943789601325989,
0.12949232757091522,
-0.19807268679141998,
-0.09059920907020569,
-0.08485590666532516,
0.23694255948066711,
0.5381865501403809,
-0.3987830579280853,
0.7489706873893738,
0.5405997633934021,
0.513451337814331,
-0.5126296877861023,
-0.45769086480140686,
0.9037636518478394,
-0.5628158450126648,
-0.9886630773544312,
-0.35817644000053406,
0.5801825523376465,
-0.35682159662246704,
-0.4868365228176117,
0.6963815093040466,
0.596189558506012,
0.23641270399093628,
0.12242777645587921,
0.7559921741485596,
-0.20837385952472687,
0.5364388227462769,
-0.4280729293823242,
1.171453833580017,
-0.574771523475647,
0.039144162088632584,
-0.113034687936306,
-0.3006904423236847,
-0.5423640608787537,
0.38082215189933777,
-0.23704411089420319,
-0.13230185210704803,
0.6357697248458862,
0.4968804717063904,
0.021896012127399445,
-0.3419927954673767,
0.23556312918663025,
0.39437007904052734,
0.5031382441520691,
0.5259215235710144,
0.42001020908355713,
0.03779452666640282,
0.14046736061573029,
-0.004475784488022327,
-0.6813018321990967,
-0.0924079641699791,
-1.428168535232544,
-0.7024618983268738,
-0.12288780510425568,
-0.589524507522583,
-0.4017027020454407,
0.06848544627428055,
0.7276210784912109,
0.6599510312080383,
-1.0630849599838257,
-0.023774806410074234,
0.33250221610069275,
0.3558613955974579,
-0.5035256743431091,
-0.09809336066246033,
0.8776373863220215,
0.037079956382513046,
-0.3362983167171478,
0.035717494785785675,
0.3913860023021698,
-0.1206991896033287,
-0.014805175364017487,
-0.003211313160136342,
-0.03567139431834221,
0.12663596868515015,
0.5939217209815979,
0.6582692861557007,
-0.2714044153690338,
0.015298539772629738,
-0.39102229475975037,
-0.08507054299116135,
0.0269863773137331,
0.8262720108032227,
-0.7424092292785645,
0.4755859076976776,
0.3366492688655853,
0.4033240079879761,
0.1716480851173401,
0.23679865896701813,
0.9022567868232727,
-1.036145806312561,
0.42269793152809143,
0.4988463521003723,
0.25846460461616516,
0.2347196489572525,
-0.5169626474380493,
0.35358890891075134,
-0.10363596677780151,
-0.3901943564414978,
-0.6199225187301636,
0.09872489422559738,
-1.2052448987960815,
-0.05292074382305145,
1.0065478086471558,
-0.03428780660033226,
-0.15964508056640625,
0.08591106534004211,
-0.39844831824302673,
0.10168787091970444,
-0.3907657563686371,
1.0126739740371704,
0.29085132479667664,
-0.37428271770477295,
0.04936813563108444,
-0.4138975739479065,
0.4316529631614685,
0.5071815848350525,
-1.0148035287857056,
-0.18069040775299072,
0.7306811213493347,
-0.15878796577453613,
0.24156393110752106,
0.464036762714386,
-0.2035573273897171,
0.3580235242843628,
-0.6762891411781311,
0.2867869734764099,
-0.5270822048187256,
-0.33155375719070435,
-0.18350429832935333,
0.3655780851840973,
-0.1994704008102417,
0.03367757424712181
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.05615v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.05615v2
|
Video-Language Understanding: A Survey from Model Architecture, Model Training, and Data Perspectives
| 2024-06-09T02:36:28 | 2024-07-01T16:05:01 |
Thong Nguyen, Yi Bin, Junbin Xiao, Leigang Qu, Yicong Li, Jay Zhangjie Wu, Cong-Duy Nguyen, See-Kiong Ng, Luu Anh Tuan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Humans use multiple senses to comprehend the environment. Vision and language
are two of the most vital senses since they allow us to easily communicate our
thoughts and perceive the world around us. There has been a lot of interest in
creating video-language understanding systems with human-like senses since a
video-language pair can mimic both our linguistic medium and visual environment
with temporal dynamics. In this survey, we review the key tasks of these
systems and highlight the associated challenges. Based on the challenges, we
summarize their methods from model architecture, model training, and data
perspectives. We also conduct performance comparison among the methods, and
discuss promising directions for future research.
|
[
-0.610640287399292,
-0.4686930477619171,
0.6461102962493896,
0.26571109890937805,
-0.14319874346256256,
0.03876220062375069,
-0.11659389734268188,
-0.6562349200248718,
-0.35689473152160645,
0.2755049467086792,
-0.4638875424861908,
-0.32097169756889343,
-0.5213541984558105,
-0.14972838759422302,
-0.4454292953014374,
0.307204008102417,
-0.2616744339466095,
0.3201952874660492,
0.0015791876940056682,
-0.4402649402618408,
-0.21053862571716309,
-0.5806498527526855,
-0.4679919481277466,
-0.3518429100513458,
0.21252386271953583,
0.17278684675693512,
0.5096731781959534,
0.5438789129257202,
0.5257927179336548,
0.3617156147956848,
-0.11060085147619247,
-0.0022152208257466555,
-0.0113786980509758,
-0.18088474869728088,
-0.11249678581953049,
-0.37702494859695435,
-0.181013286113739,
-0.14622333645820618,
0.6085723638534546,
0.9048276543617249,
-0.07360184192657471,
0.4296666085720062,
0.09985297918319702,
0.6304966807365417,
-0.7558206915855408,
0.33551326394081116,
-0.3110739290714264,
0.3260481059551239,
0.15927021205425262,
-0.011931609362363815,
-0.14117160439491272,
0.22587186098098755,
0.5331953763961792,
-0.6795467138290405,
0.3738119304180145,
-0.0006059225415810943,
0.8697362542152405,
0.30384767055511475,
-0.568497896194458,
0.001913009095005691,
-0.8808508515357971,
0.6454957723617554,
-0.17712406814098358,
1.2478710412979126,
0.5255482196807861,
0.4515434801578522,
0.36613479256629944,
-0.27191227674484253,
-0.7339218258857727,
0.06476112455129623,
0.16244953870773315,
0.1788920909166336,
-0.11248882114887238,
0.12377563118934631,
0.28381267189979553,
0.16452069580554962,
-0.7829687595367432,
0.037512533366680145,
-0.3217373490333557,
-0.13525179028511047,
0.44792550802230835,
0.2414843738079071,
0.6697563529014587,
-0.4658586084842682,
-0.3642735779285431,
-0.45660078525543213,
-0.2605532705783844,
0.23745404183864594,
0.12390294671058655,
-0.13644233345985413,
-0.2222396284341812,
0.1664523184299469,
-0.3025956153869629,
1.2876683473587036,
-0.5457183718681335,
-0.24774231016635895,
0.10467880964279175,
-0.4356095492839813,
-0.8022315502166748,
-0.3064860999584198,
0.401151180267334,
0.4925850033760071,
0.3023022413253784,
-0.07206661254167557,
-0.1935892552137375,
0.5975919961929321,
0.17289474606513977,
-0.2317337542772293,
-0.17672334611415863,
-0.2046090066432953,
-0.7098853588104248,
-0.14157076179981232,
0.14024582505226135,
-0.6523441672325134,
-0.23477241396903992,
-0.6634775996208191,
0.4766988754272461,
-0.5005379319190979,
-0.5975193381309509,
0.3203752636909485,
-0.269420862197876,
0.6102938652038574,
0.5838617086410522,
-1.2474583387374878,
0.6035295724868774,
0.5040722489356995,
0.7349143028259277,
0.1785474568605423,
-0.6393667459487915,
-0.2971839904785156,
0.2412385493516922,
-0.25517919659614563,
0.8116393685340881,
-0.21126997470855713,
-0.05885625258088112,
-0.058130837976932526,
-0.18116608262062073,
-0.18038886785507202,
-0.5802186727523804,
0.01550841610878706,
-0.5435580015182495,
0.17591716349124908,
-0.36538925766944885,
-0.1102697104215622,
-0.5520504117012024,
0.4451400339603424,
-0.5903316736221313,
0.7062107920646667,
-0.03699861839413643,
-0.5371097326278687,
0.6209360361099243,
-0.5497598052024841,
-0.15811829268932343,
0.011549402959644794,
-0.301020085811615,
0.054152678698301315,
0.23628249764442444,
0.4415425658226013,
0.39460599422454834,
-0.05410977080464363,
0.12667059898376465,
0.08506439626216888,
-0.11742296814918518,
0.22487348318099976,
-0.5767435431480408,
0.4700313210487366,
0.6045272350311279,
-0.22440966963768005,
-0.24224317073822021,
-0.9507319927215576,
-0.1271696388721466,
-0.012985263019800186,
-0.27931180596351624,
-0.2645271420478821,
0.29934972524642944,
0.5236601233482361,
0.17448104918003082,
0.03474580496549606,
-0.35414448380470276,
-0.10279357433319092,
-0.2679058313369751,
0.6219068765640259,
0.549052357673645,
-0.25288301706314087,
0.5710241794586182,
0.16580767929553986,
0.6302266120910645,
0.16983674466609955,
0.2505485415458679,
-0.37828072905540466,
-0.2519899606704712,
-0.6532959938049316,
0.12647607922554016,
-0.23356226086616516,
0.6176937222480774,
-0.7334349751472473,
-0.2434268444776535,
-0.21195006370544434,
-0.24054504930973053,
-0.38100337982177734,
0.36311283707618713,
0.5528327822685242,
0.4117651879787445,
0.14414063096046448,
-0.34122946858406067,
-0.6132538318634033,
-0.7511782646179199,
-0.13471615314483643,
-0.7409898638725281,
-0.16489826142787933,
0.5590579509735107,
0.45419541001319885,
-0.07159862667322159,
0.7452778220176697,
-0.6296382546424866,
0.08538918197154999,
-0.2633605897426605,
0.05943094938993454,
0.05309470370411873,
0.12338447570800781,
0.838009774684906,
-1.317438006401062,
-0.22824110090732574,
0.23184356093406677,
-1.076127290725708,
0.19505061209201813,
0.03620309755206108,
0.3351515829563141,
0.06177597865462303,
0.4343665540218353,
-0.24390839040279388,
0.4208913743495941,
0.7093914747238159,
-0.40667134523391724,
0.3095339834690094,
-0.15078474581241608,
0.5030935406684875,
-0.7755580544471741,
-0.061602357774972916,
0.11835178732872009,
-0.1538306325674057,
-0.7566349506378174,
0.2037394493818283,
-0.13709521293640137,
-0.3313191831111908,
-0.8248217105865479,
0.5141903758049011,
-0.6926549077033997,
-0.5266267657279968,
-0.058308195322752,
0.12475292384624481,
0.024822641164064407,
0.41482746601104736,
0.5173273682594299,
0.6418375372886658,
0.9590230584144592,
-0.802708089351654,
0.8140292763710022,
0.26935577392578125,
-0.8301095366477966,
0.6078481674194336,
-0.554489016532898,
-0.014625037088990211,
-0.5053167939186096,
-0.2290635108947754,
-1.000426173210144,
-0.6210378408432007,
0.32604172825813293,
-0.6274204850196838,
-0.14565974473953247,
-0.20638564229011536,
-0.2510146200656891,
-0.25555846095085144,
0.11772607266902924,
0.5590320229530334,
0.35050761699676514,
-0.6739416122436523,
0.5579184889793396,
0.3763606548309326,
0.22132110595703125,
-0.5787222385406494,
-0.926186740398407,
0.41712525486946106,
-0.4247238039970398,
-0.6493262648582458,
0.07987042516469955,
0.1815035194158554,
-0.6740241646766663,
0.006908362731337547,
-0.20363689959049225,
-0.5017325282096863,
0.039183713495731354,
0.2661360502243042,
0.07562310248613358,
-0.2395440936088562,
0.2195124328136444,
-0.45849335193634033,
-0.1164209395647049,
-0.037775877863168716,
-0.3457295894622803,
0.33122798800468445,
-0.3131655156612396,
-0.47124573588371277,
-0.5206694602966309,
0.5828913450241089,
0.6720567941665649,
-0.41398298740386963,
0.4780014157295227,
0.5096914172172546,
-0.37995466589927673,
0.1161823496222496,
-0.5373010635375977,
-0.1858845204114914,
-0.4279610812664032,
0.6389707326889038,
-0.6328278183937073,
-0.7874269485473633,
0.44513875246047974,
0.043951842933893204,
-0.2383376806974411,
-0.057051315903663635,
0.589495062828064,
-0.4579648971557617,
0.9363877177238464,
0.6857860088348389,
-0.16358819603919983,
0.8341689109802246,
-0.30959588289260864,
0.20783796906471252,
-0.5519408583641052,
-0.45072388648986816,
-0.44777098298072815,
-0.1593540757894516,
-0.21383044123649597,
-0.16316305100917816,
0.4986603260040283,
0.11980658024549484,
-0.049635663628578186,
0.5183953046798706,
-0.31667980551719666,
0.21075867116451263,
0.5232776403427124,
0.1560300886631012,
0.36158621311187744,
0.0954444408416748,
0.0383228175342083,
-0.14104431867599487,
-0.8050625324249268,
-0.6678723096847534,
0.5193431973457336,
0.4669536352157593,
0.8901382684707642,
0.31468066573143005,
0.29877984523773193,
-0.08788043260574341,
-0.34518757462501526,
-0.8142508268356323,
0.666611909866333,
0.037886641919612885,
-0.4484063684940338,
-0.2285887449979782,
-0.12072359770536423,
-0.6660513877868652,
0.4260701835155487,
-0.025220289826393127,
-0.932341992855072,
0.18794748187065125,
0.4332416355609894,
-0.193036288022995,
0.34369346499443054,
-0.9016698002815247,
0.9495114088058472,
-0.49423453211784363,
-0.1097673699259758,
-0.35304683446884155,
-0.8370469212532043,
0.24790458381175995,
0.4713960289955139,
0.4306904673576355,
0.20659618079662323,
0.009493354707956314,
0.6291878819465637,
-0.14723235368728638,
0.6083225607872009,
-0.17303615808486938,
0.06487220525741577,
0.31461647152900696,
-0.0760364755988121,
-0.19720259308815002,
0.14416608214378357,
0.36961787939071655,
-0.13968053460121155,
0.16111670434474945,
-0.31676337122917175,
-0.7759159803390503,
0.1865968555212021,
-0.7844240069389343,
-0.3344922661781311,
-0.3906612992286682,
-0.29311469197273254,
-0.14057064056396484,
-0.007242762017995119,
0.07690528780221939,
0.6484890580177307,
-0.4430491030216217,
-0.0808173343539238,
0.7328787446022034,
-0.245401531457901,
0.6564766764640808,
0.5127846002578735,
-0.44429337978363037,
-0.12154863774776459,
0.9317139983177185,
-0.22921094298362732,
0.31850701570510864,
0.5623833537101746,
-0.27013692259788513,
-0.20448939502239227,
-0.44769540429115295,
-0.5628243684768677,
-0.01682366617023945,
-0.5155370831489563,
0.16169928014278412,
-0.5976226329803467,
-0.062229983508586884,
-0.4241791367530823,
0.02522735856473446,
-0.22882364690303802,
-0.07044374942779541,
-0.3300471305847168,
-0.3313819169998169,
0.24553532898426056,
0.9227437376976013,
-0.22335344552993774,
0.44521287083625793,
-0.8647743463516235,
0.785427987575531,
0.8213403820991516,
0.5520622730255127,
0.10976403206586838,
-0.297787070274353,
-0.40051162242889404,
-0.0686512365937233,
-0.0829383060336113,
-1.0175403356552124,
0.4842635989189148,
0.2082492709159851,
0.5179449319839478,
0.6762107610702515,
-0.7091904282569885,
0.8588255643844604,
-0.4868060350418091,
0.909233808517456,
0.07067311555147171,
-1.0354161262512207,
0.7961225509643555,
-0.28523606061935425,
0.2312127649784088,
0.4368669092655182,
0.33537548780441284,
-0.9577924609184265,
0.14186516404151917,
-0.32679423689842224,
-0.5044122934341431,
0.6130615472793579,
0.029439184814691544,
0.03647294268012047,
0.3775807023048401,
0.2528918385505676,
-0.2696509063243866,
0.039184924215078354,
-0.49803483486175537,
0.13174916803836823,
-0.39261242747306824,
0.07695578783750534,
-0.2309805005788803,
0.016068745404481888,
0.11704399436712265,
-0.33003827929496765,
0.02226952463388443,
-0.062370192259550095,
0.20247310400009155,
0.2071799337863922,
-0.5196372270584106,
-0.0222324151545763,
0.36862489581108093,
0.47660624980926514,
0.6619365215301514,
-0.07487794756889343,
0.29860562086105347,
0.2555786073207855,
-0.6444600224494934,
0.318374902009964,
-0.5904865264892578,
0.07153976708650589,
-0.0677591860294342,
0.6062561869621277,
1.0965789556503296,
0.25988537073135376,
-0.9165759086608887,
0.3922097384929657,
-0.06610250473022461,
-0.1988360583782196,
-0.2982754409313202,
0.11436519771814346,
0.04998006299138069,
0.2613855004310608,
0.28403136134147644,
0.23476582765579224,
0.3574044108390808,
-0.795513927936554,
-0.048995617777109146,
0.38121554255485535,
-0.4601840078830719,
-0.6910191178321838,
0.6689475774765015,
0.0006079832674004138,
-0.3540433645248413,
0.5942665338516235,
0.017179852351546288,
-0.7364025115966797,
0.5402350425720215,
0.2585268020629883,
0.571648895740509,
-0.13900789618492126,
0.3069745898246765,
0.16100651025772095,
0.2225789874792099,
-0.27846285700798035,
0.6324538588523865,
-0.5711638331413269,
-1.1229543685913086,
-0.38976356387138367,
-0.5740848183631897,
-0.46067723631858826,
0.1359301209449768,
-0.9119862914085388,
0.10798956453800201,
-0.15469351410865784,
0.018676383420825005,
-0.015427223406732082,
-0.32395100593566895,
-0.9166706204414368,
0.5198289155960083,
0.4350039064884186,
0.8550620675086975,
-1.3917912244796753,
0.7625236511230469,
1.223732590675354,
-0.35259485244750977,
-0.8176344037055969,
-0.5344617962837219,
0.14297035336494446,
-0.6577621102333069,
1.0040901899337769,
-0.19517287611961365,
-0.44997909665107727,
-0.10973196476697922,
-0.5683375000953674,
-0.5138348937034607,
0.8295844793319702,
0.35618671774864197,
-0.39273300766944885,
-0.33535170555114746,
0.020669514313340187,
0.5964182615280151,
-0.15735101699829102,
0.13382863998413086,
0.7486726641654968,
0.4939534068107605,
-0.08852192014455795,
-1.0720601081848145,
-0.6839866638183594,
-0.3289412558078766,
0.2614191472530365,
0.08395231515169144,
-0.6458839178085327,
0.49961912631988525,
-0.008645450696349144,
-0.2833558917045593,
-0.11232779175043106,
0.6174153089523315,
0.06890372931957245,
0.5676671266555786,
0.6937844157218933,
0.687520444393158,
0.029754120856523514,
0.10087821632623672,
0.7630415558815002,
0.08882896602153778,
0.3727974593639374,
0.865824282169342,
0.05480948090553284,
0.8094890713691711,
0.7357304096221924,
-0.506416916847229,
0.209396094083786,
0.7208107709884644,
0.1781168431043625,
0.3793554902076721,
-0.04278303682804108,
-0.4852794408798218,
-0.56238853931427,
-0.12817025184631348,
-0.2690039873123169,
1.110276222229004,
0.48556259274482727,
-0.1339893788099289,
-0.14331001043319702,
0.428490549325943,
-0.5715035200119019,
0.33264127373695374,
-0.22290608286857605,
0.9375256299972534,
0.06221560016274452,
-0.4779757559299469,
0.13115082681179047,
-0.23689809441566467,
0.5963372588157654,
-0.38866835832595825,
-0.22606338560581207,
-0.05760826915502548,
-0.045056670904159546,
-0.13308477401733398,
-0.8306241035461426,
0.32080498337745667,
0.25634121894836426,
-0.20391179621219635,
-0.5742902755737305,
0.6143012642860413,
-0.28038468956947327,
-0.19011549651622772,
0.36897316575050354,
0.6562498807907104,
0.421762079000473,
-0.050298601388931274,
-0.3582598567008972,
0.3895430266857147,
-0.11662812530994415,
-0.05066078156232834,
0.18820975720882416,
0.2790524661540985,
-0.08832887560129166,
0.795161783695221,
0.17833396792411804,
0.23131375014781952,
0.16125796735286713,
0.2730932831764221,
0.5777164697647095,
-0.8076677918434143,
-0.4535338282585144,
-0.8241325616836548,
0.1453678458929062,
0.23625828325748444,
-0.15820379555225372,
0.49388808012008667,
0.35876017808914185,
1.2079497575759888,
-0.30279746651649475,
0.6826358437538147,
-0.09425850212574005,
0.22578412294387817,
-0.6179556250572205,
0.6390066742897034,
-0.6695516109466553,
-0.2142963409423828,
-0.605600893497467,
-0.9969484210014343,
-0.4166308045387268,
0.7873232960700989,
-0.010068254545331001,
-0.23742640018463135,
0.4898420572280884,
0.6282018423080444,
-0.3144102096557617,
0.042416051030159,
0.4670726954936981,
0.036981724202632904,
0.26568537950515747,
0.7915329337120056,
1.0307952165603638,
-0.4763437509536743,
0.4267062246799469,
-0.06846846640110016,
-0.29028138518333435,
-0.021253418177366257,
-0.6012794971466064,
-0.6300470232963562,
-0.9863781929016113,
-0.010077619925141335,
0.2616192400455475,
0.10734014213085175,
0.6453869342803955,
0.9717467427253723,
-0.5530834197998047,
-0.5904806852340698,
-0.11485373228788376,
-0.0722641721367836,
-0.22087819874286652,
-0.13106204569339752,
0.21380892395973206,
0.02058473974466324,
-0.902972400188446,
0.45530879497528076,
0.548915445804596,
0.13581500947475433,
-0.5120906829833984,
-0.10098067671060562,
-0.15179553627967834,
-0.5479663014411926,
0.8222594261169434,
0.638788104057312,
-0.9809355735778809,
-0.6199414134025574,
0.3593505024909973,
0.06935591250658035,
0.07082061469554901,
1.0983431339263916,
-0.997355043888092,
0.7386046648025513,
0.8296760320663452,
0.5609371066093445,
0.7468628287315369,
-0.043364718556404114,
0.5975137948989868,
-0.26188087463378906,
0.5025644898414612,
-0.13769367337226868,
0.43444132804870605,
0.4794148802757263,
-0.004623382817953825,
0.41377368569374084,
0.3415185809135437,
-0.2696918249130249,
-0.6289172172546387,
0.5267574191093445,
-1.2347173690795898,
-0.038024578243494034,
0.6608182191848755,
-0.0731288492679596,
-0.3433719277381897,
-0.20874610543251038,
-0.27865365147590637,
0.1739756017923355,
0.09292857348918915,
0.46292611956596375,
0.8232883214950562,
-0.37257879972457886,
-0.6767036318778992,
-0.8077366948127747,
0.18645767867565155,
0.45810237526893616,
-0.6083483099937439,
-0.234476238489151,
0.5003688931465149,
0.2671623229980469,
0.02512962929904461,
0.5913881659507751,
0.1366385519504547,
0.6166626214981079,
0.047528427094221115,
-0.12378370761871338,
0.22549737989902496,
-0.6920438408851624,
-0.6539987921714783,
0.046030689030885696,
0.07544055581092834,
-0.4484589099884033
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10249v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10249v1
|
A Reality check of the benefits of LLM in business
| 2024-06-09T02:36:00 | 2024-06-09T02:36:00 |
Ming Cheung
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) have achieved remarkable performance in language
understanding and generation tasks by leveraging vast amounts of online texts.
Unlike conventional models, LLMs can adapt to new domains through prompt
engineering without the need for retraining, making them suitable for various
business functions, such as strategic planning, project implementation, and
data-driven decision-making. However, their limitations in terms of bias,
contextual understanding, and sensitivity to prompts raise concerns about their
readiness for real-world applications. This paper thoroughly examines the
usefulness and readiness of LLMs for business processes. The limitations and
capacities of LLMs are evaluated through experiments conducted on four
accessible LLMs using real-world data. The findings have significant
implications for organizations seeking to leverage generative AI and provide
valuable insights into future research directions. To the best of our
knowledge, this represents the first quantified study of LLMs applied to core
business operations and challenges.
|
[
-0.3749433755874634,
-0.9787392020225525,
0.7885023355484009,
0.37701869010925293,
-0.12350761145353317,
0.0009043500176630914,
-0.3207729756832123,
-0.7184697389602661,
-0.36725011467933655,
0.6665380597114563,
-0.7528472542762756,
-0.2605763375759125,
-0.31689661741256714,
0.42210525274276733,
-0.38549715280532837,
0.8179632425308228,
0.0319390594959259,
-0.09242764860391617,
-0.29589805006980896,
0.010825620032846928,
-0.7006891965866089,
-0.7737346887588501,
-0.9084291458129883,
-0.4805032014846802,
0.20986704528331757,
0.3488420248031616,
0.7993789315223694,
0.29149606823921204,
0.4701252579689026,
0.36623966693878174,
0.05154295638203621,
-0.06649621576070786,
-0.3050171136856079,
0.42594558000564575,
-0.1277327835559845,
-0.6732026934623718,
-0.5230143070220947,
0.05662187188863754,
0.7627464532852173,
1.0960261821746826,
-0.17933174967765808,
0.1686103492975235,
-0.03827504813671112,
0.9070004820823669,
-0.3223472833633423,
0.3543214201927185,
-0.7388566136360168,
0.17560215294361115,
-0.0017478389199823141,
0.16395334899425507,
-0.45727115869522095,
-0.2775149643421173,
0.3587999939918518,
-0.32072535157203674,
0.0778035894036293,
0.16441811621189117,
0.8255600929260254,
0.1304851621389389,
-0.23075509071350098,
-0.6230166554450989,
-1.1323424577713013,
0.6463444232940674,
-0.6128965616226196,
0.4487791061401367,
0.12768635153770447,
0.505685567855835,
-0.3061583638191223,
-0.8474829792976379,
-0.48542144894599915,
-0.26790279150009155,
0.2218014895915985,
0.003701260080561042,
-0.26233723759651184,
0.22069577872753143,
0.5798618793487549,
0.43708914518356323,
-0.31991279125213623,
0.514183759689331,
-0.10979406535625458,
0.09025862067937851,
0.29887154698371887,
0.3616812229156494,
0.3184886872768402,
0.24771548807621002,
-0.12840086221694946,
0.10533851385116577,
-0.6716797947883606,
0.09781502932310104,
0.08010789006948471,
0.3236050307750702,
-0.034797102212905884,
0.6488083004951477,
-0.07583163678646088,
0.7073773741722107,
-0.12856125831604004,
-0.18632866442203522,
-0.23872776329517365,
-0.2212647944688797,
-0.7080199122428894,
-0.19341051578521729,
0.4245719909667969,
-0.07210566848516464,
0.4932679235935211,
-0.26592275500297546,
-0.18523231148719788,
-0.016694987192749977,
0.38009172677993774,
-0.7790825963020325,
0.17766627669334412,
0.4254685640335083,
-0.27079176902770996,
0.1213347464799881,
-0.21227966248989105,
-0.35090863704681396,
-0.38714879751205444,
-0.3310145437717438,
0.03163648024201393,
-0.20810021460056305,
-0.13635963201522827,
0.1044359877705574,
-0.09463769942522049,
0.4153686463832855,
0.3560679852962494,
-0.7302116751670837,
0.020298605784773827,
0.8392055034637451,
0.958685040473938,
-0.08842329680919647,
-0.05234050750732422,
-0.2990698218345642,
0.08563133329153061,
-0.5871507525444031,
0.547548770904541,
-0.24708043038845062,
-0.6255876421928406,
0.28494101762771606,
-0.12673869729042053,
0.05322680622339249,
-1.1052113771438599,
0.6116615533828735,
-0.6717063188552856,
-0.40323930978775024,
-0.21087145805358887,
-0.6777603626251221,
0.03601982817053795,
0.4958950877189636,
-0.8087958097457886,
0.44712603092193604,
0.01767103187739849,
-0.1913927048444748,
0.5151894092559814,
-0.4779266119003296,
-0.592353880405426,
0.29150742292404175,
-0.26108479499816895,
-0.4624389708042145,
0.33634358644485474,
-0.23925018310546875,
0.6982386112213135,
-0.32540613412857056,
0.32305896282196045,
-0.2280912697315216,
0.0732625424861908,
0.8399289846420288,
-0.5223346948623657,
0.6252548694610596,
0.3506503701210022,
-0.19132958352565765,
-0.08561749011278152,
-0.8908733129501343,
-0.1641049087047577,
-0.053633030503988266,
-0.6069410443305969,
-0.027800392359495163,
0.14243082702159882,
-0.2174537181854248,
0.21096090972423553,
0.12143967300653458,
-0.25294455885887146,
0.13786563277244568,
-0.4703355133533478,
0.4661965072154999,
0.8570732474327087,
-0.23849545419216156,
0.38138577342033386,
-0.1884174346923828,
0.7980398535728455,
-0.0943586677312851,
-0.08046585321426392,
-0.2362883985042572,
-0.564569890499115,
-0.9257498979568481,
-0.5959849953651428,
0.07856767624616623,
0.5135675668716431,
-0.6206278204917908,
0.3387075364589691,
-0.32080385088920593,
-0.4674309492111206,
-0.2798759937286377,
0.18179845809936523,
-0.08702690154314041,
0.3761685788631439,
-0.20723269879817963,
-0.09437455236911774,
-0.6651543378829956,
-0.9964237213134766,
-0.2745603621006012,
-0.10878535360097885,
-0.12850801646709442,
0.43073245882987976,
0.2556541860103607,
-0.44536465406417847,
1.074212908744812,
-0.25794562697410583,
-0.11185409873723984,
-0.6875879168510437,
0.017549194395542145,
0.49693048000335693,
0.04659125208854675,
0.20881256461143494,
-0.7927098274230957,
-0.33804959058761597,
-0.08725067973136902,
-0.9594466686248779,
-0.12381549924612045,
-0.4378007650375366,
-0.0036366197746247053,
0.5096620917320251,
0.2932487428188324,
-0.8649134635925293,
0.29744991660118103,
0.6706828474998474,
-0.08739852160215378,
0.5453333258628845,
-0.21922791004180908,
-0.09963134676218033,
-0.8351035714149475,
0.13323163986206055,
0.11965780705213547,
-0.48766881227493286,
-0.889220118522644,
-0.08520785719156265,
0.003512683557346463,
-0.5484777688980103,
-0.3313988745212555,
0.4424072504043579,
-0.5200396776199341,
-0.47109436988830566,
-0.5322326421737671,
0.20961371064186096,
-0.07650971412658691,
-0.04843492805957794,
0.1909002959728241,
0.9599207639694214,
0.49090084433555603,
-1.226730465888977,
0.4227004051208496,
0.12111105024814606,
-0.8587048053741455,
0.72170090675354,
-0.5389478802680969,
-0.03335665911436081,
-0.13012510538101196,
0.2213306576013565,
-0.8520041704177856,
-0.10875383764505386,
-0.05479972064495087,
-0.3010517656803131,
0.20746026933193207,
0.07247724384069443,
-0.5881602764129639,
-0.44354745745658875,
0.2134622484445572,
0.05610726773738861,
0.715576171875,
-0.4312521815299988,
0.7116997838020325,
0.18111322820186615,
-0.20100800693035126,
-0.12057459354400635,
-0.9970384836196899,
0.3917205333709717,
-0.19091947376728058,
-0.7501102089881897,
-0.042662713676691055,
-0.04246450960636139,
-0.6573057174682617,
-0.21077507734298706,
-0.14180022478103638,
0.006566333118826151,
0.49375486373901367,
0.4160726070404053,
0.3840310871601105,
-0.00903591699898243,
-0.16289524734020233,
-0.364471435546875,
-0.12691636383533478,
0.30300745368003845,
-0.22696253657341003,
0.3330431282520294,
0.004042515996843576,
-0.40759706497192383,
-0.4299556612968445,
0.06034683436155319,
0.6872641444206238,
0.04383763298392296,
0.8249684572219849,
0.29529717564582825,
-0.609889030456543,
-0.3401436507701874,
-0.6077934503555298,
-0.03790784627199173,
-0.5373740196228027,
0.38851138949394226,
-0.31506434082984924,
-0.8859370946884155,
0.4280688464641571,
-0.46214577555656433,
0.16800542175769806,
0.18255312740802765,
0.6772981882095337,
0.06772857159376144,
0.8064779043197632,
0.7405301332473755,
0.028605008497834206,
0.22339363396167755,
-0.11720762401819229,
0.8937371373176575,
-0.7064000964164734,
-0.4430025815963745,
-0.6825875639915466,
-0.15539026260375977,
-0.5434681177139282,
-0.24717526137828827,
0.4982600510120392,
0.08680488914251328,
0.0557578019797802,
0.005813879426568747,
0.19786688685417175,
0.10935072600841522,
0.20593209564685822,
-0.2891952097415924,
0.36951181292533875,
0.009520523250102997,
0.1789744347333908,
-0.18855220079421997,
-0.61004239320755,
-0.8453934788703918,
0.6393120884895325,
0.4285593330860138,
1.0140388011932373,
0.1585787534713745,
0.1002478152513504,
0.4984760582447052,
0.36467230319976807,
-1.057656168937683,
0.6914658546447754,
0.013550992123782635,
-0.7640907168388367,
-0.33885690569877625,
-0.3308691382408142,
-1.05022132396698,
0.16200391948223114,
-0.19128556549549103,
-0.455612450838089,
-0.009336673654615879,
0.19624271988868713,
-0.40938714146614075,
0.3488791584968567,
-0.6882801651954651,
0.5396436452865601,
-0.5436946153640747,
-0.3833602964878082,
-0.16955220699310303,
-0.12370190769433975,
0.25348585844039917,
-0.2650303244590759,
0.5919390916824341,
-0.22613653540611267,
-0.09273829311132431,
0.3987569212913513,
-0.25932979583740234,
1.047232985496521,
0.18226999044418335,
-0.4279782474040985,
0.2702552080154419,
0.14449754357337952,
0.7114889025688171,
-0.09486720710992813,
-0.3287084698677063,
0.18919077515602112,
-0.3935341536998749,
-0.2342182993888855,
-0.619283139705658,
0.6748015284538269,
-0.33802372217178345,
-0.8302025198936462,
-0.46550923585891724,
-0.4821119010448456,
-0.6118850111961365,
0.12900230288505554,
-0.06817520409822464,
0.12029121816158295,
-0.3810644745826721,
0.3652395009994507,
0.7820383906364441,
-0.29930350184440613,
0.5827997922897339,
0.6512162089347839,
-0.13894464075565338,
-0.12427535653114319,
0.546374499797821,
0.22354646027088165,
0.4645730257034302,
0.2677627205848694,
-0.0020745168440043926,
-0.2575044631958008,
-0.5529354810714722,
-0.46993520855903625,
0.09282518178224564,
-0.6477373838424683,
-0.011453179642558098,
-0.5764232277870178,
-0.09804874658584595,
-0.36622872948646545,
-0.3426729738712311,
-0.32161784172058105,
-0.06726939231157303,
-0.3669429421424866,
-0.24485604465007782,
-0.09496088325977325,
0.7747119665145874,
0.17127864062786102,
-0.016393393278121948,
-0.7995299696922302,
0.19680215418338776,
0.3236807882785797,
0.329561710357666,
0.08465759456157684,
-0.36320653557777405,
-0.5659220218658447,
0.05242012441158295,
-0.1652936488389969,
-0.6819103956222534,
0.36456498503685,
0.1442837119102478,
0.7163043022155762,
0.4151447117328644,
-0.11578360944986343,
0.5815019011497498,
-0.5688930153846741,
0.9246569871902466,
-0.12148110568523407,
-0.9514562487602234,
0.4116027057170868,
-0.12576250731945038,
0.15899953246116638,
0.12051628530025482,
0.8144323229789734,
-0.5318348407745361,
-0.08363459259271622,
-0.43422800302505493,
-1.008838415145874,
0.5447839498519897,
0.1452145129442215,
0.486947625875473,
0.03269121050834656,
0.7498924136161804,
0.13047926127910614,
0.6020492911338806,
-0.5772409439086914,
-0.3292737901210785,
0.2819767892360687,
0.041616763919591904,
-0.008137986995279789,
-0.4905259609222412,
0.29193562269210815,
0.044339124113321304,
0.65509033203125,
0.11601731181144714,
0.08477558195590973,
0.016230273991823196,
-0.03613448888063431,
0.029067328199744225,
0.46273112297058105,
0.38920366764068604,
0.9404774308204651,
0.04171353578567505,
0.0036490317434072495,
0.2627986967563629,
-0.27354976534843445,
0.07743562757968903,
-0.33346647024154663,
-0.11838880181312561,
-0.13546572625637054,
0.22990217804908752,
0.8023621439933777,
-0.030680429190397263,
-1.1441582441329956,
0.09167706221342087,
0.19462630152702332,
-0.03211567550897598,
-0.47455793619155884,
0.04131394252181053,
0.1067156195640564,
0.40930214524269104,
0.2628597021102905,
-0.3033100962638855,
0.1256624311208725,
-1.129430890083313,
-0.15529415011405945,
0.7001654505729675,
-0.23024217784404755,
-0.16893133521080017,
0.4695265293121338,
0.15331633388996124,
-0.48676198720932007,
0.7251636981964111,
0.013225013390183449,
-0.2614232301712036,
0.5554930567741394,
0.8747982978820801,
0.8155642747879028,
0.005301796365529299,
-0.010534564033150673,
-0.043472081422805786,
0.44640052318573,
-0.0561959482729435,
0.1115453913807869,
0.3117060959339142,
-0.8839817047119141,
-0.37867966294288635,
-0.5710564255714417,
-0.8012166023254395,
0.4341149926185608,
-0.42480790615081787,
0.18905483186244965,
-0.7491353750228882,
-0.57541424036026,
-0.265308678150177,
-0.2813013195991516,
-0.7672978043556213,
0.28881704807281494,
0.12840819358825684,
0.8854562044143677,
-0.7131426334381104,
0.5366769433021545,
0.6894906759262085,
-0.13595105707645416,
-0.40424370765686035,
-0.17505203187465668,
-0.24823066592216492,
-0.9773653149604797,
0.7390393018722534,
0.1597849279642105,
-0.05980643630027771,
-0.05995762348175049,
-0.41338104009628296,
-0.4806537926197052,
1.0951120853424072,
0.4480437934398651,
-0.7907460331916809,
-0.06460589170455933,
0.5100036859512329,
0.5870958566665649,
-0.2836332619190216,
-0.1799793839454651,
0.6377074122428894,
0.4212578237056732,
-0.06894175708293915,
-0.6750482320785522,
-0.005808234214782715,
0.14576181769371033,
0.37788668274879456,
-0.0936063751578331,
-0.48794782161712646,
0.68890780210495,
-0.1274222880601883,
-0.2797073423862457,
0.027409501373767853,
0.697589099407196,
0.39441725611686707,
0.2779698669910431,
0.4119378328323364,
0.40979301929473877,
0.7758105993270874,
-0.06548885256052017,
1.1696100234985352,
-0.24210374057292938,
-0.07254265993833542,
0.7701916098594666,
-0.6966306567192078,
0.8011901378631592,
0.29273107647895813,
-0.2800360918045044,
0.536754846572876,
0.3667864203453064,
-0.09060725569725037,
-0.08721969276666641,
0.43965843319892883,
-0.40210601687431335,
-0.40267857909202576,
-0.3221423327922821,
-0.030126741155982018,
0.17705722153186798,
0.6573753952980042,
-0.181549072265625,
0.19365613162517548,
0.14492198824882507,
0.0518452487885952,
0.11720979958772659,
-0.276899129152298,
0.594244658946991,
0.4139690697193146,
-0.6030545234680176,
0.29545727372169495,
0.2086741179227829,
0.5920518636703491,
-0.6116365194320679,
0.13062448799610138,
-0.13034653663635254,
0.1854519546031952,
-0.1180388480424881,
-0.8044441342353821,
0.40798962116241455,
0.33828556537628174,
-0.08148606866598129,
-0.4313584268093109,
0.7336757183074951,
0.010742015205323696,
-0.4972021281719208,
0.20032411813735962,
0.5462832450866699,
0.14379636943340302,
-0.29685136675834656,
-0.39838624000549316,
0.3335336744785309,
-0.30672889947891235,
-0.21579058468341827,
0.23669110238552094,
0.7181722521781921,
0.12094689160585403,
1.1120611429214478,
0.457561194896698,
0.1604275107383728,
0.06833025813102722,
0.13082855939865112,
0.45341986417770386,
-0.6830066442489624,
-0.19817204773426056,
-1.061437726020813,
0.38658738136291504,
0.1704079806804657,
-0.008193525485694408,
0.9092637896537781,
0.6732650399208069,
0.8784137964248657,
-0.1250273436307907,
1.0864229202270508,
0.16876131296157837,
0.08055294305086136,
-0.7479754090309143,
0.4098668098449707,
-0.359112948179245,
0.43727436661720276,
-0.0032339945901185274,
-0.6122081279754639,
-0.14144626259803772,
0.5261262059211731,
-0.2999427616596222,
0.2531222403049469,
0.4435714781284332,
0.569409191608429,
0.19655060768127441,
-0.13821367919445038,
0.6976599097251892,
0.22842423617839813,
0.5303429961204529,
0.2779114842414856,
0.7940308451652527,
0.09659191220998764,
0.4858025312423706,
0.04843180254101753,
-0.11127329617738724,
-0.37982529401779175,
-1.0983753204345703,
-1.0232089757919312,
-0.3529064953327179,
-0.33518022298812866,
-0.4592249393463135,
0.0021593854762613773,
0.8681432008743286,
0.5540370345115662,
-0.6641862392425537,
-0.45639804005622864,
-0.15263883769512177,
0.059580981731414795,
-0.02576788328588009,
-0.18797975778579712,
-0.2558920383453369,
-0.5925840735435486,
-0.6965427398681641,
0.3014429807662964,
0.5247032046318054,
0.3507923483848572,
-0.4459248483181,
-0.0800604298710823,
-0.03276335075497627,
0.3474312722682953,
0.8297303318977356,
0.32958871126174927,
-0.46593010425567627,
0.09267400950193405,
0.06155658885836601,
-0.019149085506796837,
-0.08173242211341858,
1.066943883895874,
-0.43846747279167175,
0.1398724615573883,
0.4657538831233978,
1.0483145713806152,
0.2400141805410385,
-0.13263750076293945,
0.6519541144371033,
-0.37562376260757446,
0.019351355731487274,
0.09100919961929321,
0.3746815323829651,
0.510199785232544,
-0.32816073298454285,
0.3838299810886383,
0.3212698698043823,
-0.606919527053833,
-0.5916869640350342,
0.6540457010269165,
-0.7086740136146545,
-0.21462653577327728,
1.2692760229110718,
-0.05368999019265175,
-0.11422863602638245,
-0.17363305389881134,
-0.05756084620952606,
0.22309152781963348,
-0.16771815717220306,
0.6444328427314758,
0.8593368530273438,
-0.19613294303417206,
0.07278155535459518,
-0.8626660108566284,
0.3716331422328949,
0.39082789421081543,
-0.9101500511169434,
0.20329150557518005,
0.5810708999633789,
0.18252533674240112,
-0.13309219479560852,
0.7603188157081604,
0.12917742133140564,
-0.13767914474010468,
-0.3816748559474945,
-0.10516873747110367,
0.027371959760785103,
-0.32364940643310547,
-0.39965343475341797,
0.04867051541805267,
0.8149781823158264,
0.11594073474407196
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.05606v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.05606v1
|
GrowOVER: How Can LLMs Adapt to Growing Real-World Knowledge?
| 2024-06-09T01:16:04 | 2024-06-09T01:16:04 |
Dayoon Ko, Jinyoung Kim, Hahyeon Choi, Gunhee Kim
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In the real world, knowledge is constantly evolving, which can render
existing knowledge-based datasets outdated. This unreliability highlights the
critical need for continuous updates to ensure both accuracy and relevance in
knowledge-intensive tasks. To address this, we propose GrowOVER-QA and
GrowOVER-Dialogue, dynamic open-domain QA and dialogue benchmarks that undergo
a continuous cycle of updates, keeping pace with the rapid evolution of
knowledge. Our research indicates that retrieval-augmented language models
(RaLMs) struggle with knowledge that has not been trained on or recently
updated. Consequently, we introduce a novel retrieval-interactive language
model framework, where the language model evaluates and reflects on its answers
for further re-retrieval. Our exhaustive experiments demonstrate that our
training-free framework significantly improves upon existing methods,
performing comparably to or even surpassing continuously trained language
models.
|
[
-0.004421195015311241,
-0.7678152918815613,
0.6409696340560913,
0.13721159100532532,
0.06113061308860779,
0.5800191164016724,
-0.12553998827934265,
-0.7107769250869751,
-0.030749909579753876,
0.46101489663124084,
-0.6907850503921509,
-0.13594193756580353,
-0.43039923906326294,
-0.10196710377931595,
-0.4133627414703369,
0.6936141848564148,
-0.10321156680583954,
-0.10332703590393066,
-0.30912652611732483,
-0.48283910751342773,
-0.42073169350624084,
-0.289267897605896,
-0.680080235004425,
-0.3290286064147949,
0.39312493801116943,
0.40648189187049866,
0.9607345461845398,
0.442684143781662,
0.6763728857040405,
0.15999022126197815,
-0.27819520235061646,
0.43978267908096313,
-0.4945574104785919,
0.7778640985488892,
-0.09346405416727066,
-0.42063215374946594,
-0.33016228675842285,
-0.16982786357402802,
0.6956391334533691,
0.8392536044120789,
-0.5163435935974121,
0.14978846907615662,
-0.08798184245824814,
0.5393208861351013,
-0.48450759053230286,
0.23903900384902954,
-0.9149482250213623,
0.07249774038791656,
0.33192870020866394,
-0.3063045144081116,
-0.4678882658481598,
-0.5721304416656494,
0.3664183020591736,
-0.6741212606430054,
-0.02509024739265442,
0.16252829134464264,
0.7818340063095093,
0.1935177892446518,
-0.3199307918548584,
-0.4081089198589325,
-0.720055341720581,
0.7927588820457458,
-0.8615767359733582,
0.6115067005157471,
-0.1493918001651764,
0.5239802598953247,
-0.439729243516922,
-0.932854413986206,
-0.2635902166366577,
-0.5535178780555725,
0.07042647153139114,
0.044926419854164124,
-0.24289476871490479,
-0.1261856108903885,
0.26058080792427063,
0.5040014386177063,
0.015983106568455696,
-0.24866384267807007,
-0.10471949726343155,
0.17993152141571045,
0.4538936913013458,
0.25427162647247314,
0.5449581146240234,
0.32490554451942444,
-0.3042067885398865,
-0.09799738228321075,
-1.0740174055099487,
-0.0826963260769844,
-0.22303394973278046,
0.1747085303068161,
-0.07192948460578918,
0.34284836053848267,
-0.24110282957553864,
0.6940093040466309,
-0.09885866194963455,
0.06413807719945908,
0.2716750502586365,
-0.37109115719795227,
-0.2607545256614685,
-0.5869361162185669,
0.38059571385383606,
0.3169367015361786,
0.27832263708114624,
-0.3405826985836029,
-0.16086088120937347,
-0.3573231101036072,
0.433036208152771,
-0.67292720079422,
-0.08664168417453766,
0.09038344025611877,
-0.04755263030529022,
-0.3871921896934509,
-0.18548759818077087,
-0.7834622263908386,
-0.30984681844711304,
-0.14192086458206177,
0.2718574106693268,
-0.29557371139526367,
-0.3506740927696228,
0.08481216430664062,
0.04966873303055763,
0.39063116908073425,
0.6337358355522156,
-0.5162087082862854,
0.160934716463089,
0.6122069358825684,
0.832541286945343,
-0.3027016818523407,
0.05419282987713814,
-0.5990980267524719,
0.0394628681242466,
-0.7318670749664307,
0.7523038983345032,
-0.6013727188110352,
-0.30603548884391785,
0.4136854410171509,
0.10544179379940033,
-0.16756276786327362,
-1.0738023519515991,
0.22891747951507568,
-1.127012014389038,
0.31315818428993225,
-0.19576488435268402,
-0.4615972340106964,
-0.024365175515413284,
0.5762779116630554,
-0.45270001888275146,
1.2387663125991821,
0.25399214029312134,
-0.6479849815368652,
0.4778495132923126,
-0.5713658928871155,
-0.10392911732196808,
0.2647310793399811,
-0.11870778352022171,
-0.3483940362930298,
0.12465354055166245,
0.04422702267765999,
0.09148500114679337,
-0.28414449095726013,
0.2130604237318039,
-0.3889918029308319,
-0.10527639091014862,
0.4297649562358856,
-0.2764735817909241,
0.43388041853904724,
0.26444554328918457,
0.09489726275205612,
0.2765432596206665,
-0.766399621963501,
0.2520890235900879,
0.03281302750110626,
-0.6248551607131958,
-0.381236732006073,
0.24963811039924622,
-0.29763272404670715,
0.15745855867862701,
0.17192697525024414,
-0.5167722702026367,
0.4001423716545105,
-0.5789945125579834,
0.500879168510437,
0.4200343191623688,
0.5345737338066101,
0.29170703887939453,
-0.6170516014099121,
0.7603270411491394,
0.20364172756671906,
0.3077718913555145,
-0.31311920285224915,
-0.4080049693584442,
-1.0109055042266846,
-0.2150009423494339,
0.1968289166688919,
0.5944692492485046,
-0.822150468826294,
-0.002935568103566766,
-0.6679644584655762,
-0.4562351405620575,
-0.644024133682251,
0.22618041932582855,
0.056435197591781616,
0.08496391028165817,
0.5337921977043152,
-0.3676906228065491,
-0.5674613118171692,
-0.4953109323978424,
-0.45125970244407654,
-0.25253376364707947,
-0.1895418018102646,
0.4634273946285248,
0.09182241559028625,
-0.5113343000411987,
1.154183268547058,
-0.5304102897644043,
0.023601101711392403,
-0.15994340181350708,
-0.037617117166519165,
0.2100219577550888,
0.34251946210861206,
0.372713565826416,
-0.6944231986999512,
-0.5348287224769592,
0.13682524859905243,
-0.9316510558128357,
-0.11654055863618851,
-0.11306335031986237,
-0.03935513272881508,
-0.2797316908836365,
0.568444550037384,
-0.600055992603302,
0.1446830779314041,
0.3601614832878113,
-0.3076217472553253,
0.45960983633995056,
-0.24872569739818573,
0.153339222073555,
-1.0036060810089111,
-0.256752073764801,
-0.3496531546115875,
-0.5921547412872314,
-0.8402863144874573,
0.47655171155929565,
0.12453242391347885,
-0.13702400028705597,
-0.46493175625801086,
0.9655035734176636,
-0.6191938519477844,
-0.1729380041360855,
-0.10209096968173981,
0.41479000449180603,
0.055793631821870804,
0.22323884069919586,
-0.11657782644033432,
1.1485583782196045,
0.3745727837085724,
-0.7064091563224792,
0.3733856976032257,
0.24282723665237427,
-0.6155343651771545,
0.19789870083332062,
-0.4192943572998047,
0.08489999175071716,
0.1869177222251892,
-0.04852418601512909,
-0.7011178731918335,
-0.11767002195119858,
0.10330669581890106,
-0.3111802637577057,
0.21529819071292877,
-0.08319023251533508,
-0.4796783924102783,
-0.3963450789451599,
-0.29080548882484436,
0.24297288060188293,
0.6386234164237976,
-0.7726195454597473,
0.8458003401756287,
0.20137976109981537,
-0.2762552797794342,
-0.29646429419517517,
-0.4126967489719391,
0.049078382551670074,
-0.09076924622058868,
-0.578623354434967,
0.07153457403182983,
-0.2669830024242401,
-0.6126208901405334,
-0.02197827771306038,
-0.2164614498615265,
-0.1936018317937851,
0.12643082439899445,
-0.04114368557929993,
0.12379114329814911,
-0.2306850105524063,
0.1374569982290268,
0.060582008212804794,
0.35219308733940125,
0.0564374141395092,
-0.2173454314470291,
0.21007201075553894,
0.01560454536229372,
-0.38954958319664,
-0.00526230875402689,
-0.10564856976270676,
0.7502741813659668,
-0.051499105989933014,
0.7767977714538574,
0.211146742105484,
-0.18635141849517822,
-0.24076226353645325,
-0.8057565689086914,
-0.30135518312454224,
-0.496130108833313,
0.39758461713790894,
-0.3861764371395111,
-1.1357775926589966,
0.5950198173522949,
-0.5240086913108826,
0.4883194863796234,
0.35277777910232544,
0.4911295473575592,
-0.29520362615585327,
0.7343467473983765,
0.8220791816711426,
0.6028589606285095,
0.6979966163635254,
-0.015459032729268074,
0.05684163421392441,
-1.0753406286239624,
-0.307596892118454,
-0.10148755460977554,
0.17300206422805786,
-0.30375805497169495,
-0.7847445011138916,
0.22696706652641296,
0.2794116735458374,
-0.1326581984758377,
0.20041286945343018,
-0.2217235267162323,
0.08104807138442993,
0.1440855711698532,
0.08039820194244385,
0.4749414622783661,
0.123930424451828,
-0.2500987946987152,
-0.15911367535591125,
-0.8777075409889221,
-0.19357651472091675,
0.980280339717865,
0.5038489103317261,
0.909178614616394,
0.45050016045570374,
0.20898839831352234,
0.7069972157478333,
0.8586558699607849,
-0.6501203179359436,
0.4741978943347931,
0.30682188272476196,
-0.4659641683101654,
-0.1366576850414276,
-0.6200269460678101,
-0.8953533172607422,
0.5130677819252014,
-0.20332153141498566,
-0.3957774341106415,
0.34703361988067627,
0.1399301290512085,
-0.21483588218688965,
0.3616684377193451,
-0.47905880212783813,
0.4591842293739319,
-0.08170513063669205,
-0.4300391972064972,
-0.296378493309021,
-0.3941086232662201,
0.20453129708766937,
-0.3914107382297516,
0.46309009194374084,
-0.24548621475696564,
-0.14276883006095886,
0.6278457641601562,
-0.33699488639831543,
0.729832649230957,
-0.211298406124115,
-0.2950272858142853,
0.5162638425827026,
0.2472713738679886,
0.6083918213844299,
-0.002036298858001828,
-0.032509539276361465,
-0.14734908938407898,
0.1670657843351364,
-0.47204849123954773,
-0.9063840508460999,
0.4980333745479584,
-0.6096517443656921,
-0.7545093894004822,
-0.5091070532798767,
-0.6407382488250732,
-0.707655668258667,
-0.032004062086343765,
-0.4714120030403137,
0.24312789738178253,
-0.3040323853492737,
0.3903958797454834,
0.8245896697044373,
-0.36142289638519287,
-0.005348874256014824,
0.8437524437904358,
-0.7086711525917053,
-0.4239262640476227,
0.4982312321662903,
-0.017452018335461617,
0.7554106712341309,
0.22743579745292664,
-0.03312921151518822,
-0.12841376662254333,
-0.39018359780311584,
-0.40805840492248535,
0.34225723147392273,
-0.6387545466423035,
-0.18219512701034546,
-0.7614281177520752,
-0.4012914001941681,
-0.26554936170578003,
0.1355680227279663,
-0.07177764922380447,
-0.38621121644973755,
-0.1992059201002121,
-0.18582932651042938,
0.5563738346099854,
0.9350823760032654,
-0.04499812051653862,
0.22574441134929657,
-0.9367115497589111,
0.04418345168232918,
0.4411003291606903,
0.3408997356891632,
0.18107812106609344,
-1.0583491325378418,
-0.41558629274368286,
0.16746297478675842,
-0.21115319430828094,
-0.8010793924331665,
0.43001922965049744,
0.3757301867008209,
0.6718743443489075,
0.08566392958164215,
-0.12233514338731766,
0.4739372134208679,
-0.6300876140594482,
0.8234432339668274,
0.04900440201163292,
-0.43333694338798523,
0.5094181895256042,
-0.3540744483470917,
0.547434389591217,
0.5050196051597595,
0.2591792047023773,
-0.7286556959152222,
-0.34103602170944214,
-0.5178298354148865,
-0.7915639877319336,
0.26989659667015076,
0.015188666991889477,
0.4503955543041229,
-0.14668753743171692,
0.7114015817642212,
-0.1650627702474594,
0.4469837546348572,
-0.5845562815666199,
0.1277603656053543,
0.09487368166446686,
-0.3572561740875244,
0.5421744585037231,
-0.6143081784248352,
-0.1282753050327301,
-0.05174170807003975,
0.7847965359687805,
-0.30433401465415955,
0.3468068540096283,
-0.030772965401411057,
-0.1938754767179489,
-0.17537853121757507,
0.5430698990821838,
0.3382522165775299,
0.983594536781311,
-0.4371321499347687,
-0.06499581784009933,
0.534908652305603,
-0.45076560974121094,
0.3325336277484894,
-0.24115455150604248,
-0.34149467945098877,
-0.08814680576324463,
0.47980397939682007,
0.7856518626213074,
0.6949055790901184,
-1.1233705282211304,
0.38072454929351807,
-0.11452130973339081,
-0.05157528445124626,
-0.33671730756759644,
0.2011808305978775,
0.1277875453233719,
0.33439210057258606,
0.5999333262443542,
0.023457463830709457,
-0.26686492562294006,
-0.7705798149108887,
0.5109874606132507,
0.38628438115119934,
-0.7850951552391052,
-0.1284273862838745,
0.5281577110290527,
0.16349387168884277,
-0.4084612727165222,
0.657153844833374,
-0.07540374994277954,
-0.42482897639274597,
0.31869813799858093,
0.4484706521034241,
0.617587149143219,
-0.16085068881511688,
0.10220234841108322,
0.1732676774263382,
0.12829360365867615,
-0.1167297437787056,
0.3636351227760315,
-0.003960185218602419,
-0.9106367230415344,
-0.4438488781452179,
-0.7475521564483643,
-0.7658441662788391,
-0.12110696732997894,
-0.815203845500946,
-0.13321669399738312,
-0.5113565921783447,
-0.2469814270734787,
-0.5757278800010681,
-0.010971706360578537,
-0.5349605679512024,
0.39268791675567627,
-0.4125429689884186,
1.3169081211090088,
-0.513561487197876,
1.031431794166565,
0.6079968214035034,
-0.36644309759140015,
-0.49203750491142273,
0.0771973729133606,
-0.23503245413303375,
-0.8461437225341797,
0.8024417161941528,
-0.21495835483074188,
-0.030653417110443115,
0.20615476369857788,
-0.45090657472610474,
-1.1608878374099731,
1.2583564519882202,
0.09612137079238892,
-0.6677256226539612,
-0.20908349752426147,
-0.1519860327243805,
0.8129069805145264,
-0.678735613822937,
0.2100670486688614,
0.30410000681877136,
0.16152049601078033,
0.25352710485458374,
-0.5971166491508484,
-0.16250193119049072,
-0.10714124143123627,
0.09057913720607758,
-0.008746466599404812,
-0.6078320145606995,
0.3592521846294403,
-0.28092360496520996,
-0.32205459475517273,
0.23302972316741943,
1.0354390144348145,
0.4448685348033905,
-0.0025453781709074974,
0.5769246816635132,
0.5497686266899109,
0.6561862826347351,
-0.17070068418979645,
0.8566399216651917,
-0.5911282896995544,
0.4289555549621582,
1.4213048219680786,
-0.4323844611644745,
1.256607174873352,
0.27464500069618225,
-0.4135337769985199,
0.7866984009742737,
0.6897099614143372,
-0.08151957392692566,
0.5240753293037415,
0.09332183748483658,
-0.47528961300849915,
-0.32253575325012207,
-0.08384907245635986,
-0.41491663455963135,
-0.21877680718898773,
0.5194615721702576,
-0.2189498096704483,
-0.13615338504314423,
0.08025604486465454,
-0.017023850232362747,
0.06517326831817627,
-0.0944734737277031,
0.9147617220878601,
0.26269766688346863,
-0.7109014391899109,
0.45376700162887573,
-0.13804659247398376,
0.6230475306510925,
-0.7411250472068787,
-0.12693874537944794,
-0.5275275707244873,
0.11588672548532486,
0.051989324390888214,
-0.7488798499107361,
0.3525145351886749,
-0.0833861231803894,
-0.18565182387828827,
-0.2157922387123108,
0.7318903803825378,
-0.6375647783279419,
-0.3279280364513397,
0.681909441947937,
0.8305050730705261,
-0.1044134572148323,
0.3047516345977783,
-0.9604790806770325,
0.19857461750507355,
-0.012810507789254189,
-0.25297635793685913,
0.4078925848007202,
0.41709014773368835,
-0.04457889869809151,
1.2231873273849487,
0.7140763401985168,
0.2854432165622711,
0.46595004200935364,
0.29216432571411133,
0.9805788993835449,
-0.5408703684806824,
-0.10955832153558731,
-0.3979218602180481,
0.08249873667955399,
-0.16361497342586517,
0.2449972927570343,
0.7154795527458191,
0.3556179404258728,
0.5484683513641357,
0.08350808918476105,
0.7430007457733154,
0.08469156175851822,
0.9261932373046875,
-0.42268359661102295,
0.6016525626182556,
-0.8063340187072754,
0.5552433729171753,
0.22245176136493683,
-0.8949384093284607,
-0.23611131310462952,
0.3712669312953949,
-0.40251755714416504,
0.24416905641555786,
0.5336760878562927,
0.7232311367988586,
-0.08047318458557129,
-0.2861202359199524,
0.4917543828487396,
0.6376349329948425,
0.5757290124893188,
0.2145453244447708,
0.9244913458824158,
-0.45113468170166016,
0.4524664580821991,
0.3228784203529358,
-0.31436872482299805,
-0.1674194186925888,
-0.8085367679595947,
-0.6123127341270447,
-0.2402893453836441,
-0.5533453226089478,
-0.4361516237258911,
0.466810017824173,
0.7648804783821106,
0.6994388103485107,
-0.8833515644073486,
-0.1751713901758194,
0.042731426656246185,
0.027961397543549538,
-0.4255833923816681,
-0.29120302200317383,
0.09648507833480835,
-0.668837308883667,
-0.32307010889053345,
0.7325679659843445,
0.4302597939968109,
0.01426832377910614,
-0.4620714485645294,
0.04400055110454559,
-0.5822016596794128,
0.6087800860404968,
0.6935429573059082,
0.47878649830818176,
-0.6190089583396912,
-0.45129916071891785,
0.08049607276916504,
-0.06092651188373566,
0.35405269265174866,
0.6745032072067261,
-0.9056787490844727,
0.5201172828674316,
0.2912673056125641,
0.999478280544281,
0.5099244117736816,
0.17609600722789764,
0.7526119351387024,
-0.7197232246398926,
-0.14641043543815613,
-0.02851727046072483,
0.14694765210151672,
0.6142517924308777,
-0.1324586421251297,
0.7811703681945801,
0.4398949146270752,
-0.6549740433692932,
-0.9452066421508789,
0.403628408908844,
-0.7360692024230957,
-0.18347813189029694,
1.104490041732788,
-0.44781315326690674,
-0.10601212829351425,
-0.24443486332893372,
0.17289866507053375,
-0.006812283303588629,
-0.14646053314208984,
0.6610977053642273,
0.5933557748794556,
0.06306713074445724,
-0.5001701712608337,
-0.6949097514152527,
0.674268901348114,
0.40191879868507385,
-1.0210472345352173,
0.33150196075439453,
0.34432393312454224,
0.6279087066650391,
0.17660798132419586,
0.8046808242797852,
-0.15732963383197784,
0.060293808579444885,
-0.15431958436965942,
-0.07579055428504944,
0.25411558151245117,
-0.24207854270935059,
-0.1293347328901291,
0.18643245100975037,
0.7467265725135803,
0.2551502585411072
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.05602v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.05602v1
|
Can Prompt Modifiers Control Bias? A Comparative Analysis of Text-to-Image Generative Models
| 2024-06-09T00:54:57 | 2024-06-09T00:54:57 |
Philip Wootaek Shin, Jihyun Janice Ahn, Wenpeng Yin, Jack Sampson, Vijaykrishnan Narayanan
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
It has been shown that many generative models inherit and amplify societal
biases. To date, there is no uniform/systematic agreed standard to
control/adjust for these biases. This study examines the presence and
manipulation of societal biases in leading text-to-image models: Stable
Diffusion, DALL-E 3, and Adobe Firefly. Through a comprehensive analysis
combining base prompts with modifiers and their sequencing, we uncover the
nuanced ways these AI technologies encode biases across gender, race,
geography, and region/culture. Our findings reveal the challenges and potential
of prompt engineering in controlling biases, highlighting the critical need for
ethical AI development promoting diversity and inclusivity.
This work advances AI ethics by not only revealing the nuanced dynamics of
bias in text-to-image generation models but also by offering a novel framework
for future research in controlling bias. Our contributions-panning comparative
analyses, the strategic use of prompt modifiers, the exploration of prompt
sequencing effects, and the introduction of a bias sensitivity taxonomy-lay the
groundwork for the development of common metrics and standard analyses for
evaluating whether and how future AI models exhibit and respond to requests to
adjust for inherent biases.
|
[
-0.47707822918891907,
-0.6680199503898621,
0.526907742023468,
0.31809312105178833,
0.1544870138168335,
-0.19653071463108063,
0.22458253800868988,
-0.37574830651283264,
-0.32052987813949585,
0.2585795521736145,
-0.7296527624130249,
-0.13300932943820953,
-0.8071356415748596,
0.3292331099510193,
-0.020818958058953285,
1.0359219312667847,
0.013237603940069675,
0.3128908574581146,
-0.10355055332183838,
-0.23635710775852203,
-0.7890375852584839,
-0.21264009177684784,
-0.6132919788360596,
-0.0783504769206047,
0.6296899318695068,
0.07440650463104248,
1.1630973815917969,
0.7501886487007141,
0.35777097940444946,
0.2237185835838318,
-0.3650200068950653,
-0.06802213937044144,
-0.3096511662006378,
0.20397311449050903,
-0.3034689426422119,
-0.4392145574092865,
-0.13109801709651947,
0.24715055525302887,
0.5028625726699829,
0.5090847015380859,
0.5107475519180298,
0.10128724575042725,
0.10489486157894135,
0.5930286049842834,
-0.7314662933349609,
-0.046144068241119385,
-0.3515990972518921,
0.19786497950553894,
-0.029162105172872543,
-0.31942033767700195,
-0.665578305721283,
-0.5876880288124084,
-0.015297232195734978,
-0.6306445598602295,
0.29181230068206787,
0.09250085055828094,
0.5600056648254395,
0.7178608775138855,
-0.7582933902740479,
-0.4670197665691376,
-0.6462118625640869,
0.7852323651313782,
-0.24851886928081512,
0.0984727069735527,
0.09860389679670334,
0.08872529119253159,
0.008963373489677906,
-0.5050745010375977,
-0.41993236541748047,
-0.025659611448645592,
-0.03142735734581947,
0.06353963911533356,
-0.0074471780098974705,
0.11577853560447693,
0.6070979833602905,
0.06079244241118431,
-0.2528131604194641,
0.31373709440231323,
-0.33775651454925537,
-0.3604445457458496,
0.46015745401382446,
0.21072980761528015,
0.6360448002815247,
-0.22983436286449432,
-0.2930622398853302,
-0.012616528198122978,
-0.6471901535987854,
0.15136899054050446,
0.48073136806488037,
-0.0017927787266671658,
-0.19952115416526794,
0.5113124251365662,
0.08036050200462341,
0.49360010027885437,
0.524215042591095,
0.22902239859104156,
0.08032999187707901,
-0.3000032603740692,
-0.17588254809379578,
-0.0427054688334465,
0.6765163540840149,
0.8693101406097412,
0.217715322971344,
0.11821912229061127,
-0.10050427168607712,
0.25977930426597595,
0.22857150435447693,
-0.7675259113311768,
0.19651296734809875,
0.07682152092456818,
-0.8719145655632019,
-0.6302902698516846,
-0.07752504199743271,
-0.9556577205657959,
-0.8589841723442078,
-0.372384637594223,
0.13212352991104126,
-0.14988990128040314,
0.0855177491903305,
-0.3109607398509979,
-0.5380438566207886,
0.4659123122692108,
0.44571274518966675,
-0.7322207093238831,
-0.28943905234336853,
0.5000526309013367,
0.9147568941116333,
-0.19924190640449524,
-0.053012121468782425,
-0.23055200278759003,
-0.04042978584766388,
-0.3991660475730896,
0.5275714993476868,
-0.9772458076477051,
-0.7200458645820618,
0.09978023916482925,
-0.1981554627418518,
0.15648289024829865,
-0.17905907332897186,
0.6985092163085938,
-0.7093854546546936,
0.5422160029411316,
-0.632362961769104,
-0.2673240303993225,
-0.016366073861718178,
-0.10542847216129303,
-0.8926733136177063,
0.5782864093780518,
-0.15436039865016937,
-0.9566179513931274,
0.8459128141403198,
-0.7423017024993896,
-0.4026581048965454,
-0.11565399169921875,
-0.5317053198814392,
-0.21334752440452576,
0.02860221639275551,
0.47991853952407837,
0.25461190938949585,
-0.3929412066936493,
0.38083481788635254,
-0.1992003172636032,
-0.3025263845920563,
0.10507921874523163,
-0.6967787146568298,
1.114417314529419,
0.40940797328948975,
-0.614120364189148,
0.27550673484802246,
-0.4485597610473633,
-0.3816981613636017,
-0.18208925426006317,
-0.049715302884578705,
-0.1668126881122589,
-0.11620554327964783,
0.18149104714393616,
0.3116132915019989,
0.010253512300550938,
-0.11134157329797745,
0.2006653994321823,
0.2645252048969269,
0.45941969752311707,
1.2535394430160522,
0.15395359694957733,
1.0487748384475708,
-0.6456673741340637,
0.7556564807891846,
-0.06409092247486115,
0.4448280930519104,
-0.669005274772644,
-0.60226970911026,
-0.4236982762813568,
-0.35861727595329285,
-0.010632338933646679,
0.5559087991714478,
-0.8436242938041687,
0.2987532317638397,
-0.016011469066143036,
-0.33523625135421753,
-0.6049331426620483,
-0.3145514726638794,
0.1514005810022354,
0.6852021813392639,
0.18232478201389313,
-0.11162589490413666,
-0.07433122396469116,
-0.8964368104934692,
-0.4477923810482025,
-0.015739327296614647,
-0.11047179996967316,
0.4901546835899353,
0.17510823905467987,
-0.2961375117301941,
0.9611847996711731,
0.017948094755411148,
-0.024183277040719986,
0.11412032693624496,
0.36078548431396484,
0.11386601626873016,
0.6522305011749268,
0.8398481011390686,
-1.1135460138320923,
-0.22567884624004364,
-0.47429606318473816,
-0.7397297024726868,
-0.600854218006134,
-0.5911852121353149,
-0.2896665036678314,
-0.0009708291618153453,
0.5078028440475464,
-0.6963701844215393,
0.6921308636665344,
0.06685736030340195,
-0.7180041670799255,
0.5575401186943054,
0.1869557946920395,
0.691460132598877,
-0.8079001903533936,
0.03771745786070824,
0.17812933027744293,
-0.15134698152542114,
-0.40973106026649475,
0.18621130287647247,
0.1642279475927353,
0.11554332822561264,
-0.45929938554763794,
0.6717511415481567,
-0.43012791872024536,
0.01572253741323948,
-0.310940682888031,
-0.40612995624542236,
0.05639871209859848,
0.19069990515708923,
-0.09072517603635788,
1.0216599702835083,
0.7531196475028992,
-0.684546947479248,
0.09730002284049988,
0.47474342584609985,
-0.10940901935100555,
0.9358223080635071,
-0.7921572923660278,
0.20926597714424133,
-0.5812870264053345,
0.6147064566612244,
-0.7505727410316467,
-0.17140918970108032,
0.5425394773483276,
-0.510637640953064,
0.05832113325595856,
-0.09117881953716278,
-0.27619582414627075,
-0.13228529691696167,
-0.2933444082736969,
0.6964114904403687,
0.8582159280776978,
-0.4650305211544037,
0.7137323617935181,
0.05288120359182358,
-0.18743294477462769,
-0.664858341217041,
-0.6691278219223022,
-0.029882047325372696,
-0.46982017159461975,
-0.5258839130401611,
0.29391053318977356,
-0.3503524363040924,
-0.4728785753250122,
-0.1828584522008896,
0.023041075095534325,
0.07073894143104553,
0.08927467465400696,
0.4577089250087738,
0.38059860467910767,
0.21689535677433014,
0.01639971137046814,
0.31966719031333923,
-0.11284921318292618,
0.1694750189781189,
-0.2935749292373657,
0.2740086317062378,
0.5665856599807739,
-0.3665905296802521,
-0.7925571203231812,
0.3336625397205353,
0.8499181866645813,
-0.1140693798661232,
0.3274623155593872,
0.39509260654449463,
-0.1641150414943695,
0.03691193088889122,
-0.49635985493659973,
-0.30377304553985596,
-0.517300009727478,
0.04417848214507103,
-0.10085916519165039,
-0.8554986715316772,
0.5436665415763855,
-0.04779735580086708,
0.20502813160419464,
0.40461719036102295,
0.7956871390342712,
0.08673910796642303,
1.2436273097991943,
0.6560779213905334,
-0.21013596653938293,
0.7652539014816284,
0.11101669073104858,
-0.13069696724414825,
-0.5981236696243286,
-0.10511833429336548,
-0.7167372107505798,
-0.5114784836769104,
-0.6792508363723755,
-0.4081730842590332,
0.4302893877029419,
-0.28412607312202454,
-0.4043228328227997,
-0.3921980857849121,
-0.6624319553375244,
0.6497045159339905,
0.5729018449783325,
0.17266307771205902,
-0.00929118599742651,
-0.26669153571128845,
-0.010069276206195354,
0.021748587489128113,
-0.4362965524196625,
-0.7517174482345581,
1.0332167148590088,
0.39025968313217163,
0.8275565505027771,
-0.11661770194768906,
0.12086767703294754,
1.1339819431304932,
0.34628769755363464,
-0.4302082359790802,
0.4020802676677704,
0.21524952352046967,
-0.771935760974884,
-0.047379445284605026,
-0.21276116371154785,
-0.6159000992774963,
0.02728695049881935,
0.003801611252129078,
-0.5103205442428589,
0.7891450524330139,
0.2970244884490967,
-0.3519769310951233,
0.07095808535814285,
-0.7589094042778015,
0.5268993973731995,
-0.1476355493068695,
-0.6434664726257324,
-0.1572226881980896,
-0.8203122615814209,
0.16773656010627747,
0.07611740380525589,
0.29894354939460754,
-0.13875329494476318,
-0.13762331008911133,
0.40203768014907837,
-0.18223616480827332,
0.9657070636749268,
-0.2501090466976166,
0.03142479434609413,
0.08823025226593018,
0.1275118589401245,
0.45788514614105225,
0.15249262750148773,
-0.37490978837013245,
0.11551754176616669,
-0.3277939260005951,
-0.7708287239074707,
-0.4140316843986511,
0.49607107043266296,
-0.7399287223815918,
-0.5926042199134827,
-0.4266951084136963,
-0.5343641042709351,
0.027985768392682076,
0.24901586771011353,
0.6746581196784973,
0.32517901062965393,
-0.18635815382003784,
-0.13754169642925262,
0.771786630153656,
-0.4699433743953705,
0.5823681950569153,
0.12510594725608826,
0.02033473737537861,
-0.2703361511230469,
0.2589614987373352,
-0.14128857851028442,
0.38458046317100525,
0.06285755336284637,
0.07849098742008209,
-0.0385577566921711,
-0.2919280529022217,
-0.6697496175765991,
-0.2475191205739975,
-0.9630019068717957,
-0.06765471398830414,
-0.584882915019989,
0.14107045531272888,
-0.6603248119354248,
-0.6863840222358704,
0.20071469247341156,
-0.18621928989887238,
-0.715187132358551,
-0.2555548846721649,
0.36854270100593567,
0.8296886086463928,
0.059808213263750076,
0.37891140580177307,
-0.3697611093521118,
0.32986608147621155,
0.13920673727989197,
0.12067805975675583,
0.00131195446010679,
-0.5556375980377197,
0.2906683087348938,
-0.022263087332248688,
-0.3702011704444885,
-1.1110025644302368,
0.07539831101894379,
-0.09760492295026779,
0.3602597117424011,
0.39969760179519653,
0.029518304392695427,
0.25716346502304077,
-0.5465043187141418,
1.1807403564453125,
0.13643287122249603,
-1.099421501159668,
0.6980777978897095,
-0.47335541248321533,
0.40849068760871887,
0.3212863504886627,
0.5941034555435181,
-0.4667843282222748,
-0.3485015332698822,
-0.42011284828186035,
-0.6756370067596436,
0.660407304763794,
0.04049919545650482,
0.4850546717643738,
-0.004143828526139259,
0.4823789894580841,
0.4427350163459778,
0.1567385047674179,
-0.6957331299781799,
-0.30448296666145325,
-0.3821393549442291,
-0.207672581076622,
0.2513229548931122,
-0.2998853623867035,
-0.14599229395389557,
0.03756733238697052,
0.4228467345237732,
-0.0718437060713768,
0.08171346783638,
0.3352111876010895,
-0.11882919818162918,
-0.10108207911252975,
0.2631664574146271,
0.3766244649887085,
0.44268107414245605,
0.3605349659919739,
-0.04832671955227852,
-0.18071959912776947,
-0.31906959414482117,
0.2535114288330078,
0.01535063236951828,
-1.0738333463668823,
-0.17442813515663147,
0.17096222937107086,
0.9852676391601562,
-0.3546016812324524,
-0.3654099404811859,
0.514107882976532,
-0.00041174888610839844,
0.07690250873565674,
0.03754979372024536,
0.1272207796573639,
-0.7856777310371399,
0.18919704854488373,
0.4654707908630371,
0.69286048412323,
0.5234590768814087,
-0.32254695892333984,
0.02748316340148449,
0.4549455940723419,
-0.3645757734775543,
-0.332540363073349,
1.1287471055984497,
0.5186326503753662,
-0.1827932894229889,
0.43244248628616333,
-0.05202220007777214,
-0.3547649383544922,
0.9275385141372681,
0.33277466893196106,
0.8974322080612183,
-0.12018969655036926,
0.4729327857494354,
0.12990881502628326,
0.5905019044876099,
-0.02938779629766941,
0.149600550532341,
-0.15452316403388977,
-0.7745050191879272,
-0.16712908446788788,
-0.018978236243128777,
-0.310922771692276,
-0.28661319613456726,
-0.514181911945343,
0.39264407753944397,
-0.6944901347160339,
-0.4884376525878906,
0.1329365372657776,
-0.6583521962165833,
-0.897255539894104,
0.18179631233215332,
0.165679469704628,
1.0016915798187256,
-1.0060030221939087,
0.23511900007724762,
0.6711439490318298,
-0.4534233808517456,
-0.40793392062187195,
0.23728905618190765,
0.30063629150390625,
-0.5951523780822754,
0.645561695098877,
0.38556137681007385,
0.14834198355674744,
-0.06564250588417053,
-1.0098636150360107,
-0.5524728894233704,
0.9494269490242004,
0.2239038497209549,
-0.209551140666008,
-0.07467176765203476,
-0.1490439623594284,
0.22983114421367645,
-0.28300589323043823,
0.6833922863006592,
0.6225892901420593,
0.7198594212532043,
0.15304134786128998,
-0.6688008308410645,
0.17548172175884247,
-0.3146202862262726,
0.22123615443706512,
-0.09688159078359604,
-0.5796535015106201,
0.5825303196907043,
-0.29230204224586487,
-0.3006132245063782,
0.08903256803750992,
0.5117902159690857,
0.06361851096153259,
0.707701563835144,
0.36176350712776184,
0.21561764180660248,
0.7019143104553223,
-0.21385015547275543,
1.071308970451355,
-0.21146732568740845,
-0.19111493229866028,
0.8050433397293091,
-0.5012635588645935,
-0.156138613820076,
0.5589951276779175,
0.09182502329349518,
0.3574846088886261,
0.8282343745231628,
-0.1975523829460144,
0.5130043625831604,
-0.059866320341825485,
-0.2890283167362213,
0.1415507197380066,
-0.6046417355537415,
-0.3286987841129303,
0.0535876490175724,
0.3058716356754303,
-0.7242922186851501,
0.1116083562374115,
0.3269965946674347,
0.013169022276997566,
0.15344445407390594,
-0.5592410564422607,
0.645039975643158,
-0.2358698546886444,
-0.8293052315711975,
0.02664738893508911,
-0.14006026089191437,
1.0713367462158203,
-0.21915972232818604,
0.045582208782434464,
-0.302546888589859,
-0.37736380100250244,
-0.18363003432750702,
-0.5392160415649414,
0.02982814982533455,
0.11907115578651428,
-0.5293814539909363,
-0.5795807838439941,
0.6997940540313721,
0.06400181353092194,
-0.33633914589881897,
-0.12892813980579376,
0.2298223376274109,
-0.3404003083705902,
0.27033355832099915,
-0.6984341144561768,
0.32574883103370667,
0.057563673704862595,
-0.15571628510951996,
-0.21025823056697845,
0.3906102478504181,
-0.32815462350845337,
0.6090041995048523,
0.5354765057563782,
-0.08951304852962494,
0.39115720987319946,
0.058058083057403564,
0.7242019772529602,
-0.47383275628089905,
-0.6264058351516724,
-0.8810524344444275,
0.6848297715187073,
-0.12667995691299438,
-0.3871639370918274,
0.5787840485572815,
0.16405430436134338,
0.5894649624824524,
-0.19155943393707275,
1.1971120834350586,
-0.26052647829055786,
-0.019428014755249023,
-0.5531014204025269,
0.63273686170578,
-0.17166191339492798,
0.15418927371501923,
-0.28247198462486267,
-0.8347713351249695,
-0.14872391521930695,
0.28703340888023376,
-0.38023632764816284,
0.4612700939178467,
0.23519857227802277,
0.7417137622833252,
0.3305037021636963,
0.20485787093639374,
0.03322991728782654,
0.09189440310001373,
0.46326205134391785,
0.06778108328580856,
0.9915603399276733,
0.013240136206150055,
-0.008158393204212189,
-0.022096293047070503,
-0.666419267654419,
-0.10596081614494324,
-1.1222902536392212,
-0.695695161819458,
-0.3366716206073761,
-0.3783537447452545,
-0.387799471616745,
0.13642048835754395,
1.0215448141098022,
0.591702401638031,
-0.6052697896957397,
0.29473939538002014,
-0.2695978879928589,
0.3524312376976013,
-0.07729215174913406,
-0.25610271096229553,
0.19917544722557068,
-0.33156999945640564,
-0.9108104109764099,
-0.11411362141370773,
0.20543552935123444,
0.39152365922927856,
-0.28999006748199463,
-0.029450686648488045,
0.2846388816833496,
0.34708207845687866,
0.3996049463748932,
0.21612964570522308,
-0.7663073539733887,
-0.06211411952972412,
0.0750134065747261,
-0.2503216862678528,
-0.07346323877573013,
1.2108887434005737,
-0.8039252161979675,
0.5579174160957336,
0.705298662185669,
0.6269624829292297,
-0.36720210313796997,
0.13872972130775452,
0.803447961807251,
-0.5312122106552124,
0.34614020586013794,
0.26375460624694824,
0.2786940336227417,
0.388675332069397,
-0.7689278721809387,
0.2663937211036682,
0.23494578897953033,
-0.8552964925765991,
-0.5907598733901978,
0.400296151638031,
-0.6661524176597595,
-0.3695850074291229,
1.2602123022079468,
0.32748401165008545,
0.012984968721866608,
0.06773743778467178,
-0.7274537682533264,
0.26474347710609436,
-0.5728946328163147,
1.0188252925872803,
0.6459233164787292,
0.02083434909582138,
-0.28057074546813965,
-0.355019748210907,
0.6023297905921936,
0.5052344799041748,
-0.6244394183158875,
-0.13104248046875,
1.2362923622131348,
-0.01293186005204916,
-0.0432102344930172,
0.6278226375579834,
-0.17333517968654633,
0.480432391166687,
-0.3740242123603821,
0.12417090684175491,
0.15058650076389313,
-0.23810265958309174,
-0.6514346599578857,
-0.07556778937578201,
-0.06157359480857849,
-0.027328122407197952
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.05588v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.05588v1
|
CERET: Cost-Effective Extrinsic Refinement for Text Generation
| 2024-06-08T22:17:52 | 2024-06-08T22:17:52 |
Jason Cai, Hang Su, Monica Sunkara, Igor Shalyminov, Saab Mansour
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) are powerful models for generation tasks, but
they may not generate good quality outputs in their first attempt. Apart from
model fine-tuning, existing approaches to improve prediction accuracy and
quality typically involve LLM self-improvement / self-reflection that
incorporate feedback from models themselves. Despite their effectiveness, these
methods are hindered by their high computational cost and lack of scalability.
In this work, we propose CERET, a method for refining text generations by
considering semantic stability, entailment and inter-sample uncertainty
measures. Experimental results show that CERET outperforms Self-consistency and
Self-rerank baselines consistently under various task setups, by ~1.6% in
Rouge-1 for abstractive summarization and ~3.5% in hit rate for question
answering. Compared to LLM Self-rerank method, our approach only requires 9.4%
of its latency and is more cost-effective.
|
[
-0.24338595569133759,
-0.8711990118026733,
0.4898987114429474,
0.07174117863178253,
-0.18295826017856598,
0.21804794669151306,
-0.6925410032272339,
-0.4943239390850067,
0.0966014415025711,
0.46000197529792786,
-0.44865378737449646,
-0.40434443950653076,
-0.43949198722839355,
0.19013863801956177,
-0.4450856149196625,
1.029482364654541,
0.00921943224966526,
-0.2948220372200012,
-0.3085930347442627,
0.06483840197324753,
0.002120268763974309,
-0.2515525221824646,
-0.7206323742866516,
-0.25512078404426575,
0.5467026233673096,
0.7620530128479004,
0.6230449676513672,
0.4795079231262207,
0.35884732007980347,
0.34760424494743347,
-0.08518925309181213,
0.5632219910621643,
-0.7591366767883301,
0.7532395124435425,
-0.4209926724433899,
0.08619293570518494,
-0.3251170217990875,
-0.3393852114677429,
0.479758083820343,
0.41238102316856384,
-0.2515592873096466,
0.31814152002334595,
0.5273829102516174,
0.7784494161605835,
-0.7792279720306396,
-0.09205470979213715,
-0.7861961126327515,
-0.34549081325531006,
-0.29254019260406494,
-0.3594211935997009,
-0.5778751373291016,
-0.4505653977394104,
0.055066902190446854,
-0.689375638961792,
0.6527444124221802,
-0.06337054073810577,
0.8590514063835144,
0.41602393984794617,
-0.07664575427770615,
-0.43378010392189026,
-0.7391883730888367,
0.79112708568573,
-1.0577757358551025,
0.29562559723854065,
0.1166190356016159,
0.1122930720448494,
-0.1295054852962494,
-0.9500458240509033,
-0.45767250657081604,
-0.04257001727819443,
0.020766455680131912,
-0.02001507580280304,
-0.013978366740047932,
0.10369454324245453,
0.15368525683879852,
0.3951896131038666,
-0.2241060882806778,
-0.04271034151315689,
-0.3977009952068329,
-0.17127647995948792,
0.6502964496612549,
0.04359162598848343,
-0.11422564834356308,
0.05532651022076607,
-0.30034711956977844,
-0.19483867287635803,
-0.953378438949585,
-0.01945018582046032,
0.5629194974899292,
0.4312678873538971,
0.23738710582256317,
0.47741836309432983,
-0.6676033735275269,
0.6153480410575867,
0.41188478469848633,
-0.17718468606472015,
0.22038906812667847,
-0.5547270178794861,
-0.13066431879997253,
-0.10174910724163055,
0.7711192965507507,
0.2621842920780182,
0.06856456398963928,
-0.038902852684259415,
-0.11628860980272293,
-0.02180694043636322,
0.19430296123027802,
-1.0937986373901367,
-0.2686503529548645,
0.2962448000907898,
-0.215680330991745,
-0.4792543053627014,
-0.06826921552419662,
-0.9707534313201904,
-0.011741743423044682,
-0.2987355589866638,
0.18423974514007568,
-0.41665518283843994,
-0.049247972667217255,
-0.09139426052570343,
0.21646025776863098,
0.11353316903114319,
0.6635864973068237,
-1.0842523574829102,
0.1796363890171051,
0.4387558400630951,
0.4792376458644867,
0.02265000529587269,
-0.11029067635536194,
-0.7876564860343933,
0.05319613963365555,
-0.30994829535484314,
1.0122661590576172,
-0.5485450625419617,
-0.23153789341449738,
-0.09599864482879639,
-0.14391200244426727,
0.12223431468009949,
-0.2810419797897339,
0.8175970911979675,
-0.4274592101573944,
0.05054309964179993,
-0.4761253595352173,
-0.6804323792457581,
0.08393148332834244,
0.20640608668327332,
-0.44978204369544983,
1.1857496500015259,
0.1353064328432083,
-0.8941999077796936,
0.4549087882041931,
-0.08349014073610306,
-0.35219720005989075,
0.21963201463222504,
-0.30734187364578247,
-0.4219079315662384,
0.19767630100250244,
0.40436962246894836,
0.4288727045059204,
-0.4277068078517914,
0.3607833981513977,
-0.15169593691825867,
-0.1366289258003235,
-0.09078450500965118,
-0.4308584928512573,
0.10375482589006424,
0.4807935953140259,
-0.6198986172676086,
-0.06942104548215866,
-0.8704838752746582,
0.6320320963859558,
-0.3134171962738037,
-0.4920961856842041,
-0.04452221095561981,
0.1719084084033966,
0.02764422819018364,
0.2074437439441681,
0.41919657588005066,
-0.7679159641265869,
-0.14463666081428528,
-0.7165247797966003,
0.4255097806453705,
0.5435593128204346,
0.0518464520573616,
0.46471408009529114,
-0.329271137714386,
0.4707798957824707,
-0.3612273335456848,
-0.12666286528110504,
-0.4775693714618683,
-0.4220692217350006,
-1.0591849088668823,
0.16482959687709808,
0.587104856967926,
0.03477703779935837,
-0.7722232937812805,
0.17985013127326965,
-0.1690194010734558,
-0.6542304158210754,
-0.3896401524543762,
0.2893636226654053,
0.6321941018104553,
0.514445960521698,
0.32813766598701477,
0.2550899088382721,
-0.2751055657863617,
-0.7651609182357788,
-0.3761027157306671,
-0.30189424753189087,
0.3701859712600708,
-0.16169367730617523,
0.21171365678310394,
0.04673552140593529,
0.8820803165435791,
-0.26620641350746155,
0.013564526103436947,
-0.05575878545641899,
0.3100765645503998,
0.016390787437558174,
0.49601322412490845,
0.1717957854270935,
-0.6353788375854492,
-0.667931079864502,
0.05285535380244255,
-0.3375418186187744,
-0.38135579228401184,
-0.10078644752502441,
0.07063251733779907,
0.4962575435638428,
0.9348276853561401,
-0.16404226422309875,
0.37454110383987427,
0.7070249915122986,
-0.4555738866329193,
0.36574241518974304,
-0.5749703645706177,
0.22511735558509827,
-0.6631373763084412,
0.13681118190288544,
-0.08077963441610336,
-0.41755247116088867,
-0.5546224117279053,
0.4593215584754944,
0.21857871115207672,
0.0775877982378006,
-0.3901124596595764,
0.5130016803741455,
-0.6211107969284058,
0.31606411933898926,
-0.4769463837146759,
0.351897656917572,
0.21051199734210968,
0.4000192880630493,
-0.09345632046461105,
0.7346439957618713,
0.013769599609076977,
-0.6499406695365906,
0.018108943477272987,
0.06064542755484581,
-0.29782024025917053,
0.4594094455242157,
-0.8524132966995239,
0.1232316642999649,
-0.23149771988391876,
0.06093043088912964,
-1.017295241355896,
-0.1258835792541504,
0.037140097469091415,
-0.5356940627098083,
0.3706134557723999,
0.28100672364234924,
-0.2563265860080719,
-0.07432370632886887,
-0.24852041900157928,
0.4369020164012909,
0.42426684498786926,
-0.7131972312927246,
0.4683229923248291,
0.010876384563744068,
-0.5034101009368896,
-0.7205533981323242,
-0.3782256841659546,
-0.0494086891412735,
0.1162472516298294,
-0.6929756999015808,
0.6018062829971313,
-0.28680533170700073,
-0.29373040795326233,
-0.09235737472772598,
0.05312992259860039,
0.38274627923965454,
-0.22377261519432068,
0.14642930030822754,
-0.1485140472650528,
0.04794551432132721,
0.3788950741291046,
0.4475197196006775,
-0.185311421751976,
-0.20740532875061035,
-0.11129093915224075,
0.39272254705429077,
-0.16150978207588196,
-0.2656104862689972,
0.08787743747234344,
0.24480970203876495,
0.5783533453941345,
-0.3015250861644745,
0.3101327121257782,
0.2965356111526489,
-0.22912077605724335,
-0.7009281516075134,
-0.7441525459289551,
0.058411095291376114,
-0.5216572284698486,
0.29755496978759766,
-0.3237800896167755,
-1.0272396802902222,
0.304301917552948,
-0.014656958170235157,
0.43419700860977173,
0.7834845781326294,
0.7861502170562744,
0.028831424191594124,
0.6590833067893982,
0.5499545931816101,
0.40495580434799194,
-0.041767269372940063,
-0.03933096304535866,
0.09175661206245422,
-0.73506760597229,
-0.37164321541786194,
-0.711819589138031,
-0.22110450267791748,
-0.6595048308372498,
-0.47700783610343933,
0.16624923050403595,
0.18221665918827057,
-0.2596154808998108,
0.2924119532108307,
-0.7564542293548584,
0.46966731548309326,
0.609555721282959,
0.1414286494255066,
0.5737999081611633,
0.13345640897750854,
-0.06810487806797028,
-0.13221512734889984,
-0.7384260296821594,
-0.6400870680809021,
1.1335159540176392,
0.33510130643844604,
1.0001972913742065,
-0.04129207879304886,
0.7680082321166992,
0.15597331523895264,
0.354170560836792,
-0.29576733708381653,
0.35834816098213196,
-0.20667381584644318,
-0.4289902448654175,
-0.6986334919929504,
-0.4907352328300476,
-0.6825175285339355,
0.27617397904396057,
-0.3540502190589905,
-0.42474687099456787,
0.4581206738948822,
0.4235532581806183,
-0.5542618036270142,
0.23787325620651245,
-0.2759385108947754,
0.42884132266044617,
-0.013079345226287842,
-0.630038321018219,
-0.21873828768730164,
-0.38508450984954834,
0.1423187553882599,
-0.4376148283481598,
0.33594775199890137,
-0.2904643416404724,
-0.09052742272615433,
0.5586255788803101,
-0.9197050929069519,
0.6078972816467285,
-0.042703211307525635,
-0.5547146797180176,
0.5577410459518433,
0.049630504101514816,
0.840541660785675,
0.3250524699687958,
-0.292926549911499,
-0.2642061412334442,
0.06771299242973328,
-0.2212708592414856,
-0.6502829790115356,
0.9815802574157715,
-0.5228503346443176,
-0.5193215012550354,
-0.27006882429122925,
-0.34727662801742554,
-0.2518327832221985,
0.02890942431986332,
1.0023747682571411,
0.677216649055481,
-0.3050144612789154,
0.18784965574741364,
0.695684015750885,
-0.21067626774311066,
0.7159824967384338,
0.30779924988746643,
-0.25727999210357666,
-0.8066244125366211,
0.6619724035263062,
0.16562502086162567,
0.5064765810966492,
0.25325533747673035,
0.11984436213970184,
-0.21137867867946625,
-0.5175628066062927,
-0.4395299255847931,
0.07693568617105484,
-0.7701752781867981,
-0.5215355157852173,
-0.695590615272522,
-0.27870064973831177,
-0.4106484651565552,
-0.3162895441055298,
-0.5527580976486206,
-0.6513274312019348,
-0.35435959696769714,
0.09290629625320435,
0.30922093987464905,
0.6129027605056763,
-0.08528022468090057,
0.4554803669452667,
-0.4971521496772766,
0.07630564272403717,
0.30151599645614624,
0.29155418276786804,
-0.0007302694139070809,
-0.7653379440307617,
-0.25639528036117554,
0.17867091298103333,
-0.5106748342514038,
-0.48299258947372437,
0.44722017645835876,
0.6108537912368774,
0.27962926030158997,
0.4143005907535553,
0.2675260901451111,
0.4557045102119446,
-0.5943443179130554,
0.6935016512870789,
0.2926495671272278,
-0.9838864207267761,
0.442083477973938,
-0.36392977833747864,
0.4639468193054199,
1.106907844543457,
-0.20786152780056,
-0.28473785519599915,
-0.6554809212684631,
-0.8025497198104858,
-0.9721654653549194,
0.21543484926223755,
0.38390296697616577,
0.2317781001329422,
-0.21670250594615936,
0.5543303489685059,
0.23833030462265015,
0.1427910327911377,
-0.46777626872062683,
-0.0784747451543808,
0.020261721685528755,
-0.16722458600997925,
-0.17779088020324707,
-0.5561737418174744,
0.2007305771112442,
-0.19000519812107086,
1.0357232093811035,
-0.22241391241550446,
-0.07036112993955612,
0.5341109037399292,
0.15709775686264038,
-0.3424721658229828,
0.4927191436290741,
0.6511316299438477,
0.8950111269950867,
0.06600213050842285,
0.16955268383026123,
0.4187813699245453,
-0.37258467078208923,
0.4035061299800873,
-0.06340418010950089,
-0.3754883110523224,
0.33993709087371826,
0.16013875603675842,
0.27765047550201416,
0.3206700086593628,
-0.5898728370666504,
0.5958536863327026,
0.08276288956403732,
-0.47777116298675537,
-0.3738526999950409,
0.14608049392700195,
0.02451922371983528,
0.2722335755825043,
0.2030976116657257,
0.027007466182112694,
0.09992057085037231,
-0.18800067901611328,
0.27392837405204773,
0.2877900302410126,
-0.3930184841156006,
-0.06590507179498672,
0.8277766704559326,
0.4181462228298187,
-0.1168750524520874,
0.5283780694007874,
-0.28658527135849,
-0.23286393284797668,
0.4649072587490082,
0.5337371230125427,
0.7895632386207581,
-0.3288660943508148,
0.4199432134628296,
0.6460843086242676,
0.2751123905181885,
-0.4563247561454773,
0.32685768604278564,
0.07239632308483124,
-0.574381411075592,
-0.779072105884552,
-0.7446504235267639,
-0.5578644275665283,
-0.2292940765619278,
-0.5101773142814636,
0.536277174949646,
-0.5086298584938049,
-0.32928726077079773,
-0.16372422873973846,
-0.09213870018720627,
-0.45892855525016785,
0.43565085530281067,
-0.04182916134595871,
0.9348990321159363,
-0.4138157367706299,
0.5819514393806458,
0.31438446044921875,
-0.11444784700870514,
-0.6936901807785034,
-0.2599189281463623,
-0.4078282415866852,
-0.27625584602355957,
0.6461740136146545,
-0.057573579251766205,
-0.3072308897972107,
0.0984749123454094,
-0.6466614603996277,
-1.2007434368133545,
0.9734477996826172,
0.47877663373947144,
-1.2528899908065796,
-0.320837140083313,
-0.04095816612243652,
0.5269554257392883,
-0.30381157994270325,
0.26136067509651184,
0.3391927480697632,
0.3965524435043335,
0.15665605664253235,
-0.7213807702064514,
0.11753804236650467,
-0.3427104949951172,
0.03610862419009209,
0.5152290463447571,
-0.9067594408988953,
0.8641088008880615,
-0.4912864565849304,
-0.46824029088020325,
0.3380456268787384,
0.9177416563034058,
0.360237717628479,
0.28201824426651,
0.34678414463996887,
0.747553288936615,
0.9465893507003784,
-0.11162129044532776,
0.760577917098999,
-0.6202786564826965,
0.5275752544403076,
1.5672166347503662,
-0.08503119647502899,
0.9657936692237854,
0.4529048800468445,
0.09290777891874313,
0.7206476330757141,
0.46023982763290405,
-0.0023866556584835052,
0.5350985527038574,
0.3429068922996521,
-0.2821488082408905,
-0.3409784138202667,
0.2773436903953552,
-0.4924967885017395,
0.22115068137645721,
0.20224368572235107,
-0.714165210723877,
-0.46248939633369446,
-0.08779595047235489,
0.1875237077474594,
0.48723751306533813,
-0.1829497516155243,
0.5446496605873108,
-0.01721169985830784,
-0.807288646697998,
0.5546185970306396,
0.08710066974163055,
0.6162735223770142,
-0.3545665144920349,
-0.10683911293745041,
-0.1509373039007187,
0.18363778293132782,
-0.295680969953537,
-0.29603317379951477,
0.18138377368450165,
0.034751322120428085,
-0.21540172398090363,
-0.20745441317558289,
0.7266783118247986,
-0.6348235607147217,
-0.8103985786437988,
-0.016499079763889313,
0.4457029104232788,
-0.10823235660791397,
-0.08994520455598831,
-0.360600084066391,
0.10441224277019501,
0.14500792324543,
-0.3869951665401459,
-0.08248966187238693,
0.5007715821266174,
0.24567744135856628,
0.4855714440345764,
0.4348171055316925,
0.2627193331718445,
-0.1606917828321457,
-0.09568652510643005,
0.8601074814796448,
-0.4797106683254242,
-0.3938058912754059,
-0.9899792671203613,
0.5418300628662109,
-0.1644500195980072,
-0.6217700242996216,
0.7997909188270569,
0.46921098232269287,
0.8973044157028198,
0.3279831111431122,
0.823535680770874,
-0.03975224867463112,
0.6461392045021057,
-0.6007916927337646,
0.6511805653572083,
-0.20687676966190338,
0.40501514077186584,
-0.5230541229248047,
-1.2645796537399292,
-0.07683690637350082,
0.36226150393486023,
-0.12544012069702148,
0.0630747601389885,
0.8583419322967529,
0.7603013515472412,
0.31082242727279663,
0.18802835047245026,
0.3510025441646576,
-0.0526229590177536,
0.2567024827003479,
0.48573732376098633,
0.894473135471344,
-0.5631162524223328,
0.6483293771743774,
-0.3173283040523529,
-0.2101777195930481,
0.21319086849689484,
-0.9339889883995056,
-0.7318764328956604,
-0.5517116189002991,
-0.570314884185791,
-0.5638155937194824,
0.14812840521335602,
0.8588965535163879,
0.6514742374420166,
-0.6731676459312439,
0.03622564673423767,
-0.25058919191360474,
-0.41626933217048645,
-0.020040685310959816,
-0.11694742739200592,
0.3731512427330017,
-1.013196349143982,
-0.8105251789093018,
0.24143724143505096,
0.09448879957199097,
-0.2920982539653778,
-0.29507365822792053,
-0.08141089975833893,
0.19330669939517975,
0.2100096344947815,
0.5423296093940735,
0.2571827471256256,
-0.7719531059265137,
-0.2915867567062378,
0.10977548360824585,
-0.05204594135284424,
-0.022069010883569717,
0.8628132939338684,
-0.8843637108802795,
0.6585416793823242,
0.5423263311386108,
0.579948902130127,
0.6266955137252808,
0.35202863812446594,
0.72809898853302,
-0.526948869228363,
-0.33306777477264404,
0.052705250680446625,
0.31042248010635376,
0.43847954273223877,
-0.6585645079612732,
0.5594490766525269,
-0.20615163445472717,
-1.0686712265014648,
-0.4469154179096222,
0.04384801164269447,
-0.5540808439254761,
-0.310019314289093,
1.2802455425262451,
-0.047402799129486084,
-0.13445858657360077,
0.025467097759246826,
-0.2541886568069458,
0.05295118689537048,
-0.4822531044483185,
0.5410481691360474,
0.6090388894081116,
-0.02851521037518978,
-0.18933212757110596,
-0.23199057579040527,
0.77876877784729,
0.4242800772190094,
-0.8399998545646667,
0.5098116397857666,
0.5996869802474976,
0.22342133522033691,
0.2374958097934723,
0.611191987991333,
-0.29193252325057983,
0.1697143167257309,
-0.09676972776651382,
0.28910553455352783,
-0.030443666502833366,
-0.4104062020778656,
-0.2437475174665451,
0.39327502250671387,
0.24369123578071594,
0.33704182505607605
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.05587v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.05587v1
|
Creativity Has Left the Chat: The Price of Debiasing Language Models
| 2024-06-08T22:14:51 | 2024-06-08T22:14:51 |
Behnam Mohammadi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have revolutionized natural language processing
but can exhibit biases and may generate toxic content. While alignment
techniques like Reinforcement Learning from Human Feedback (RLHF) reduce these
issues, their impact on creativity, defined as syntactic and semantic
diversity, remains unexplored. We investigate the unintended consequences of
RLHF on the creativity of LLMs through three experiments focusing on the
Llama-2 series. Our findings reveal that aligned models exhibit lower entropy
in token predictions, form distinct clusters in the embedding space, and
gravitate towards "attractor states", indicating limited output diversity. Our
findings have significant implications for marketers who rely on LLMs for
creative tasks such as copywriting, ad creation, and customer persona
generation. The trade-off between consistency and creativity in aligned models
should be carefully considered when selecting the appropriate model for a given
application. We also discuss the importance of prompt engineering in harnessing
the creative potential of base models.
|
[
-0.15206527709960938,
-0.7200053930282593,
0.6019848585128784,
0.3369944989681244,
-0.16947421431541443,
0.4628062844276428,
-0.32706987857818604,
-0.575468122959137,
0.13288502395153046,
0.4306695759296417,
-0.8526371717453003,
-0.1695052981376648,
-0.6138288974761963,
-0.006260894704610109,
-0.2968810498714447,
0.9310957789421082,
-0.013415161520242691,
-0.11574004590511322,
-0.35675203800201416,
-0.05327344685792923,
-0.5801858901977539,
-0.21969392895698547,
-0.3581114411354065,
-0.5688626170158386,
0.8887871503829956,
0.5165533423423767,
1.0314929485321045,
0.7744162082672119,
0.42467862367630005,
0.3442836403846741,
-0.25373342633247375,
-0.004177925176918507,
-0.7964416146278381,
0.46627116203308105,
-0.28598296642303467,
-0.48550480604171753,
-0.04573167487978935,
0.25911957025527954,
0.4516489505767822,
0.7255248427391052,
-0.4598041772842407,
-0.03315085545182228,
0.1358410120010376,
0.7514660954475403,
-0.46013250946998596,
-0.09357534348964691,
-0.7282918095588684,
-0.09104268997907639,
-0.04567181318998337,
0.02299482375383377,
-0.38605746626853943,
-0.40799281001091003,
0.15428972244262695,
-0.6778582334518433,
-0.1884661763906479,
0.022101743146777153,
0.837929904460907,
0.8347330093383789,
-0.11265280097723007,
-0.4494415819644928,
-0.9002794027328491,
1.099533200263977,
-0.7364702224731445,
0.21998518705368042,
-0.00819415133446455,
0.09543173015117645,
-0.34841737151145935,
-0.39740487933158875,
-0.7520805597305298,
0.08884596824645996,
0.35645294189453125,
0.07763059437274933,
-0.3701397180557251,
-0.30147841572761536,
0.08351989835500717,
0.20232424139976501,
-0.37989822030067444,
0.823594331741333,
-0.2655339241027832,
0.17908038198947906,
0.8019357919692993,
0.26012760400772095,
0.42519423365592957,
0.018671026453375816,
-0.35991042852401733,
-0.161507710814476,
-0.5803780555725098,
0.2213519811630249,
0.8134857416152954,
0.08246227353811264,
0.06258758902549744,
0.6431702375411987,
-0.10626699030399323,
0.5435428023338318,
0.23900766670703888,
-0.376438170671463,
0.12138070166110992,
-0.0291387178003788,
-0.10780739039182663,
-0.05124187469482422,
0.8136509656906128,
0.31632378697395325,
0.14554131031036377,
-0.2779890298843384,
-0.23650413751602173,
0.206126868724823,
0.316112756729126,
-0.41334113478660583,
-0.22147893905639648,
0.08518168330192566,
-0.2763330042362213,
-0.5127601623535156,
-0.0006499423761852086,
-0.5988225936889648,
-0.7393723130226135,
-0.46660321950912476,
0.1503949910402298,
-0.02926824986934662,
-0.30854594707489014,
0.10759653151035309,
-0.5413533449172974,
0.03324063494801521,
0.2547317147254944,
-0.9397256374359131,
0.060345400124788284,
0.90482097864151,
0.40194979310035706,
-0.5425911545753479,
-0.2983956038951874,
-0.11960382759571075,
-0.06466833502054214,
-0.42948266863822937,
0.6726773381233215,
-0.6001102924346924,
-0.20746636390686035,
-0.3200262188911438,
-0.22493985295295715,
0.14190562069416046,
-0.7242483496665955,
0.35859107971191406,
-0.5523181557655334,
0.4835280776023865,
-0.39137712121009827,
-0.39743804931640625,
-0.21361543238162994,
-0.047121938318014145,
-0.7202113270759583,
0.7260043621063232,
0.19743108749389648,
-0.5304787158966064,
0.4338238835334778,
-0.1708439290523529,
-0.17755211889743805,
0.1302279233932495,
-0.30489060282707214,
-0.34551557898521423,
0.1454952359199524,
-0.03002178482711315,
-0.08802004903554916,
-0.3395218551158905,
0.4563639163970947,
-0.5559097528457642,
-0.35191068053245544,
0.7167269587516785,
-0.4134632647037506,
0.7103244662284851,
0.42467308044433594,
-0.49286019802093506,
0.2092762291431427,
-0.695446252822876,
-0.01953200250864029,
0.26122352480888367,
-0.58821702003479,
-0.10506303608417511,
-0.044578175991773605,
-0.07003767043352127,
0.5019715428352356,
0.0380607508122921,
-0.4552980065345764,
0.025776904076337814,
-0.5161157250404358,
0.46306610107421875,
0.8699679374694824,
-0.1262815296649933,
0.6490058898925781,
-0.7384633421897888,
0.9641461372375488,
0.03220879286527634,
-0.17443813383579254,
0.3023300766944885,
-0.7104492783546448,
-0.5843023657798767,
-0.3804956376552582,
-0.08116301894187927,
0.4803616404533386,
-0.37926051020622253,
0.45816299319267273,
-0.17457634210586548,
-0.7171030640602112,
-0.8904562592506409,
0.628650426864624,
0.14273293316364288,
0.3791735768318176,
-0.17460598051548004,
-0.26430273056030273,
-0.595382809638977,
-0.8367862701416016,
-0.559943675994873,
0.021612025797367096,
0.012075892649590969,
0.05639854818582535,
0.11838052421808243,
-0.2810189127922058,
1.068969964981079,
-0.17671865224838257,
-0.09903375059366226,
-0.5406057834625244,
0.0672716423869133,
0.397818386554718,
0.29870545864105225,
0.40863052010536194,
-0.4489109218120575,
-0.3610921800136566,
-0.3074359893798828,
-0.5428043007850647,
-0.428063303232193,
-0.25718116760253906,
-0.11927632242441177,
0.4549883008003235,
0.0742848664522171,
-1.024431824684143,
0.34678998589515686,
0.7276650667190552,
-0.1166091188788414,
0.2595866024494171,
0.3230940103530884,
-0.25859224796295166,
-0.715093195438385,
-0.1263909786939621,
-0.23471176624298096,
0.057687047868967056,
-0.32183197140693665,
-0.18210875988006592,
-0.36946818232536316,
-0.06980676203966141,
-0.31342029571533203,
0.5455119013786316,
-0.33987510204315186,
0.07055637985467911,
-0.5819816589355469,
0.2342369258403778,
0.24639227986335754,
0.4266946017742157,
-0.0949079617857933,
0.5946154594421387,
0.2825337052345276,
-0.4014473259449005,
0.4702508747577667,
0.22647783160209656,
-0.525933027267456,
0.19393669068813324,
-0.6137389540672302,
0.24588577449321747,
-0.5323838591575623,
0.16966524720191956,
-1.2179274559020996,
-0.3308444023132324,
0.2773996889591217,
-0.2767721712589264,
0.1842699646949768,
0.4246867299079895,
-0.3674663305282593,
-0.40032896399497986,
-0.3022610545158386,
0.2398608922958374,
0.8005589246749878,
-0.6293339729309082,
0.4330577850341797,
0.4887685179710388,
-0.320151150226593,
-0.7254617810249329,
-0.9758558869361877,
-0.016617806628346443,
-0.45097267627716064,
-0.6503560543060303,
0.33762499690055847,
-0.01949693076312542,
-0.5795824527740479,
0.0503062903881073,
-0.0908730998635292,
0.41727691888809204,
0.44523486495018005,
0.4953276216983795,
0.18877027928829193,
0.002375121461227536,
0.13690385222434998,
-0.3271878659725189,
0.2601017355918884,
0.03983645886182785,
-0.2991880476474762,
0.6354358196258545,
-0.026485664770007133,
-0.3886106014251709,
-0.5020755529403687,
0.08546791225671768,
0.4880833923816681,
-0.038549989461898804,
0.6886589527130127,
0.4451643228530884,
-0.06748244166374207,
-0.35793793201446533,
-0.5999796390533447,
0.03962413966655731,
-0.5333253741264343,
0.501491129398346,
0.22624334692955017,
-1.0190917253494263,
0.5357915163040161,
0.4904666841030121,
0.07978561520576477,
0.3809592127799988,
0.8177593350410461,
-0.13636229932308197,
1.0362942218780518,
0.7383661270141602,
0.1308576911687851,
0.6905574798583984,
0.08530119061470032,
0.675652027130127,
-0.61188805103302,
-0.3661663830280304,
-0.22129279375076294,
-0.8729900121688843,
-0.6148965954780579,
-0.10417787730693817,
-0.039283882826566696,
0.26361292600631714,
-0.2897973656654358,
0.07220981270074844,
-0.5124582052230835,
0.7050648927688599,
0.7174700498580933,
-0.0755547508597374,
0.218136265873909,
-0.0834747701883316,
0.05721982195973396,
-0.28799423575401306,
-0.9033727645874023,
-0.5393453240394592,
0.8165851831436157,
0.6628695726394653,
1.3645391464233398,
0.27120810747146606,
0.7234110236167908,
-0.03764749690890312,
0.406360000371933,
-0.967534065246582,
0.415597528219223,
0.13840949535369873,
-0.3336940407752991,
-0.41899022459983826,
-0.3419831693172455,
-0.818696916103363,
0.033874474465847015,
0.0009050099761225283,
-0.8148767352104187,
0.19770853221416473,
-0.006347959395498037,
-0.5149252414703369,
0.3544197380542755,
-0.5398285984992981,
0.7428711652755737,
-0.4977187216281891,
-0.5547700524330139,
-0.15423768758773804,
-0.42956843972206116,
0.571262538433075,
-0.13624003529548645,
0.2756415605545044,
-0.19287121295928955,
0.1910235434770584,
0.7955028414726257,
-0.1394936889410019,
0.9830432534217834,
0.14977464079856873,
-0.49492359161376953,
0.4949387013912201,
0.1861526519060135,
0.43016713857650757,
-0.0981718897819519,
-0.049182068556547165,
-0.18952366709709167,
-0.34986552596092224,
-0.1978807896375656,
-0.6150272488594055,
0.8572738170623779,
-0.8758374452590942,
-1.0659990310668945,
-0.16067345440387726,
-0.9413759112358093,
-0.045486316084861755,
0.05263358727097511,
0.2819277048110962,
-0.09495655447244644,
0.03374718874692917,
0.19573864340782166,
0.3194657266139984,
-0.3837488889694214,
0.5112850666046143,
0.19001661241054535,
-0.2134779691696167,
-0.5267136096954346,
0.7189474701881409,
-0.027095723897218704,
0.527050256729126,
-0.06593351811170578,
0.1623629778623581,
-0.3468642830848694,
-0.0799960196018219,
-0.16490988433361053,
0.22731627523899078,
-0.9361621141433716,
-0.17341366410255432,
-0.6551483273506165,
-0.007711597252637148,
-0.6572824716567993,
-0.13244861364364624,
-0.34989607334136963,
-0.6957025527954102,
-0.6962878108024597,
-0.15713675320148468,
0.07496955245733261,
1.0440648794174194,
-0.11603138595819473,
0.3660911023616791,
-0.6286366581916809,
-0.12254795432090759,
0.35469919443130493,
0.28561854362487793,
0.3657293915748596,
-0.6107009053230286,
-0.1324174851179123,
0.10381125658750534,
-0.7878183126449585,
-0.8002052307128906,
0.34975099563598633,
-0.07225377857685089,
0.6291844844818115,
0.5006619095802307,
-0.29822468757629395,
0.4050846993923187,
-0.15054190158843994,
0.8269087672233582,
0.2966564893722534,
-0.630129873752594,
0.10256113111972809,
-0.3440117835998535,
0.5404735207557678,
0.26349949836730957,
0.19054575264453888,
-0.6104430556297302,
-0.6130136847496033,
-0.5810936093330383,
-0.6503692269325256,
0.5657706260681152,
-0.19307450950145721,
0.1454191952943802,
-0.199746236205101,
0.08551078289747238,
0.24410860240459442,
0.3095399737358093,
-0.9279505014419556,
0.18030056357383728,
-0.1485992670059204,
-0.42533135414123535,
0.26192885637283325,
-0.3360650837421417,
-0.10751635581254959,
-0.13870668411254883,
0.6912270784378052,
0.15451525151729584,
-0.024986693635582924,
-0.10962459444999695,
0.0835888683795929,
-0.7675078511238098,
0.47686901688575745,
0.6043066382408142,
0.6228451728820801,
0.149557963013649,
0.055674027651548386,
-0.13220636546611786,
0.07746198773384094,
0.2560494542121887,
-0.23891900479793549,
-0.09865687787532806,
-0.2357529103755951,
0.24152718484401703,
0.8880872130393982,
0.11775781214237213,
-0.9885275363922119,
0.3450182378292084,
0.2582509219646454,
-0.09927371889352798,
-0.273311048746109,
0.39776524901390076,
0.3296258747577667,
0.4851113259792328,
0.011949482373893261,
0.22575882077217102,
-0.2004961520433426,
-0.7024896144866943,
0.06407758593559265,
0.7350776791572571,
-0.2367638498544693,
-0.30971285700798035,
0.8558752536773682,
0.029928939417004585,
-0.5096772909164429,
0.6853889226913452,
-0.14003969728946686,
-0.6463297009468079,
0.6345078945159912,
0.6780244708061218,
0.9335824251174927,
0.10546606034040451,
0.13510248064994812,
-0.046844638884067535,
0.1954280287027359,
-0.26462647318840027,
0.12553682923316956,
0.12010698020458221,
-0.9079018235206604,
-0.4756484627723694,
-0.6436046957969666,
-0.29636359214782715,
0.15720637142658234,
-0.36361807584762573,
0.2779795229434967,
-0.4740750193595886,
-0.38853439688682556,
-0.07457739859819412,
-0.2880215048789978,
-0.6889603734016418,
-0.2151244431734085,
0.5305283069610596,
0.5895906090736389,
-0.6642524003982544,
0.5179907083511353,
0.6205738186836243,
-0.43724822998046875,
-0.8809517025947571,
-0.21923686563968658,
0.27387726306915283,
-0.7075347900390625,
0.9273371696472168,
0.3320046663284302,
-0.13987062871456146,
0.008447693660855293,
-0.8080103993415833,
-1.1721444129943848,
0.8908802270889282,
0.26196569204330444,
-0.6613330245018005,
-0.3358612060546875,
0.2788337767124176,
0.6255209445953369,
-0.505933940410614,
-0.06524604558944702,
0.6432123780250549,
0.2726878225803375,
0.18942122161388397,
-0.8751482367515564,
-0.05493347719311714,
-0.09943678230047226,
0.06875740736722946,
0.03369523957371712,
-0.5342503786087036,
0.9134661555290222,
-0.5330272316932678,
-0.4225497245788574,
0.3695164918899536,
0.4869905114173889,
0.5558143854141235,
-0.01891346275806427,
0.3864794075489044,
1.0648142099380493,
0.758622407913208,
0.15700528025627136,
0.8121508955955505,
-0.028743650764226913,
0.06530047208070755,
1.0731499195098877,
-0.5945833921432495,
0.6501160264015198,
0.7823216319084167,
0.1102951243519783,
0.8688743710517883,
0.4008372724056244,
-0.22265860438346863,
0.6033452153205872,
0.4388858675956726,
0.03796514496207237,
-0.2606622278690338,
-0.31701529026031494,
0.05875525251030922,
0.44489455223083496,
0.21865041553974152,
-0.3000703454017639,
-0.1353551298379898,
-0.049148861318826675,
-0.04094468057155609,
0.3236938714981079,
0.16966822743415833,
0.8642460107803345,
0.2007756233215332,
-1.0944238901138306,
0.5152467489242554,
-0.1914035975933075,
0.7984131574630737,
-0.19091783463954926,
0.12483292818069458,
-0.0679527074098587,
0.3628748655319214,
-0.17810243368148804,
-1.0331131219863892,
0.3242318034172058,
-0.264313280582428,
-0.1177150160074234,
-0.43631458282470703,
0.5563304424285889,
-0.643501877784729,
-0.22228874266147614,
0.25717106461524963,
0.43470340967178345,
-0.23508340120315552,
0.10917793959379196,
-0.4857873320579529,
0.08642957359552383,
-0.049127090722322464,
-0.335920512676239,
0.1380903273820877,
0.4848269522190094,
0.07575152814388275,
0.7628843784332275,
0.6199494004249573,
0.017597420141100883,
-0.011606523767113686,
0.14784575998783112,
0.8417714834213257,
-0.7015371322631836,
-0.5219881534576416,
-0.9870556592941284,
0.4524460434913635,
0.11471955478191376,
-0.3987123966217041,
0.6139678359031677,
0.2774978280067444,
0.8819732666015625,
-0.19134649634361267,
0.7151891589164734,
0.19912904500961304,
0.4376187324523926,
-0.3630606532096863,
0.6486819386482239,
-0.5459977984428406,
0.5204758644104004,
-0.15076932311058044,
-0.9243468642234802,
-0.030743859708309174,
0.2326195389032364,
-0.3382396697998047,
-0.02008836716413498,
0.43634989857673645,
0.7467218041419983,
0.3019075393676758,
0.012535424903035164,
0.038879621773958206,
0.10138396173715591,
0.4427959620952606,
0.5276163816452026,
1.5064729452133179,
0.01006555650383234,
0.3423672616481781,
-0.2274332195520401,
-0.19474834203720093,
-0.08420815318822861,
-0.7938989400863647,
-0.9385115504264832,
-0.19988587498664856,
-0.21078284084796906,
-0.41544434428215027,
-0.344968318939209,
1.167871356010437,
0.15893247723579407,
-0.4904095530509949,
-0.19412006437778473,
-0.20295090973377228,
0.2945893108844757,
-0.0874519944190979,
-0.2576117217540741,
-0.18038971722126007,
-0.503807008266449,
-0.5515432357788086,
0.1672409325838089,
0.39789554476737976,
0.2844875454902649,
-0.3324822783470154,
-0.12711156904697418,
0.0255358275026083,
0.13562053442001343,
0.2722887098789215,
0.23303192853927612,
-1.1738744974136353,
0.020075181499123573,
0.19490766525268555,
-0.36098986864089966,
-0.001898683258332312,
0.5370955467224121,
-0.737525999546051,
0.16445355117321014,
0.6804832816123962,
0.8504146337509155,
-0.21564528346061707,
0.1839190125465393,
0.7041045427322388,
-0.505725622177124,
0.25048866868019104,
0.4390162527561188,
0.1781773865222931,
0.46132177114486694,
-0.3849465847015381,
0.18690383434295654,
0.3159690499305725,
-0.7301223278045654,
-0.7264504432678223,
0.524029552936554,
-0.7254877090454102,
-0.3139397203922272,
1.2445075511932373,
0.32409316301345825,
-0.3899117410182953,
0.36343541741371155,
-0.07762125134468079,
0.18977659940719604,
-0.318082332611084,
1.160630702972412,
0.983711838722229,
-0.15794096887111664,
-0.21113397181034088,
-0.1679912954568863,
0.61091148853302,
0.8469521999359131,
-0.541828989982605,
0.08536473661661148,
0.4797225594520569,
0.3530849516391754,
0.17393462359905243,
0.41673544049263,
-0.05993880331516266,
0.1501552313566208,
-0.3220170736312866,
0.09226708114147186,
0.1432315856218338,
-0.26617032289505005,
-0.4271897077560425,
-0.20154014229774475,
0.5564932823181152,
0.2036564201116562
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.05569v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.05569v1
|
Do LLMs Recognize me, When I is not me: Assessment of LLMs Understanding of Turkish Indexical Pronouns in Indexical Shift Contexts
| 2024-06-08T20:30:53 | 2024-06-08T20:30:53 |
Metehan Oğuz, Yusuf Umut Ciftci, Yavuz Faruk Bakman
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) have shown impressive capabilities in tasks such
as machine translation, text summarization, question answering, and solving
complex mathematical problems. However, their primary training on data-rich
languages like English limits their performance in low-resource languages. This
study addresses this gap by focusing on the Indexical Shift problem in Turkish.
The Indexical Shift problem involves resolving pronouns in indexical shift
contexts, a grammatical challenge not present in high-resource languages like
English. We present the first study examining indexical shift in any language,
releasing a Turkish dataset specifically designed for this purpose. Our
Indexical Shift Dataset consists of 156 multiple-choice questions, each
annotated with necessary linguistic details, to evaluate LLMs in a few-shot
setting. We evaluate recent multilingual LLMs, including GPT-4, GPT-3.5,
Cohere-AYA, Trendyol-LLM, and Turkcell-LLM, using this dataset. Our analysis
reveals that even advanced models like GPT-4 struggle with the grammatical
nuances of indexical shift in Turkish, achieving only moderate performance.
These findings underscore the need for focused research on the grammatical
challenges posed by low-resource languages. We released the dataset and code
\href{https://anonymous.4open.science/r/indexical_shift_llm-E1B4} {here}.
|
[
-0.24257420003414154,
-0.706441342830658,
0.5321211814880371,
0.1136680468916893,
-0.2924458682537079,
0.01470890361815691,
-0.194325789809227,
-0.3730561137199402,
0.11244995146989822,
0.3085346519947052,
-0.8522207140922546,
-0.19803248345851898,
-0.7784274816513062,
0.7242693901062012,
-0.3110223710536957,
0.7677803635597229,
-0.21936839818954468,
-0.014362195506691933,
0.056098438799381256,
-0.17957592010498047,
-0.2811759412288666,
-0.3174000084400177,
-0.26459118723869324,
0.04098493978381157,
0.5055455565452576,
0.6047247648239136,
0.30124205350875854,
0.4790882170200348,
0.8164700865745544,
0.31227102875709534,
0.007769190706312656,
0.15938255190849304,
-0.09040821343660355,
0.16059662401676178,
-0.26828649640083313,
-0.46792781352996826,
-0.186220183968544,
0.08132302761077881,
0.9515250325202942,
0.8663651347160339,
0.1019991934299469,
0.7671905159950256,
-0.05047810450196266,
0.7245873808860779,
-0.8246815800666809,
0.13901083171367645,
-0.8725153207778931,
0.019850092008709908,
-0.6868955492973328,
-0.05178804695606232,
-0.08857326209545135,
-0.17979538440704346,
0.058532655239105225,
-0.3486560881137848,
0.12617583572864532,
0.14796499907970428,
0.6950746178627014,
0.35081687569618225,
-0.7359529137611389,
-0.07012204080820084,
-0.7425865530967712,
0.6919981241226196,
-0.582028865814209,
0.38898414373397827,
0.2602558434009552,
0.16949403285980225,
-0.29078736901283264,
-0.5586004853248596,
-0.6642444133758545,
-0.242060124874115,
0.1544916033744812,
0.11775597184896469,
-0.21962350606918335,
-0.20030717551708221,
0.35938721895217896,
0.2606777250766754,
-0.6046987175941467,
0.08618220686912537,
-0.606983482837677,
-0.05475037172436714,
0.4139292538166046,
0.2495104968547821,
0.036713097244501114,
-0.0789913758635521,
-0.0455133356153965,
0.0478317067027092,
-0.8402303457260132,
0.3119626045227051,
0.7030400633811951,
0.4251661002635956,
0.2260933220386505,
0.9569215774536133,
-0.00043789204210042953,
0.5416901111602783,
0.3380856215953827,
-0.14474153518676758,
0.0834682509303093,
-0.34823739528656006,
-0.2721630930900574,
-0.011861423030495644,
0.5141178369522095,
0.1467481106519699,
0.16315829753875732,
0.03459106385707855,
0.08584535121917725,
0.06837601959705353,
0.1514493227005005,
-0.5213873982429504,
0.3413016200065613,
-0.1493794471025467,
-0.49271160364151,
-0.1451341211795807,
0.051977258175611496,
-0.3309040367603302,
-0.3862370550632477,
0.10662981122732162,
0.30190879106521606,
0.028120234608650208,
-0.46924906969070435,
0.01682395115494728,
0.3051089942455292,
0.3739979565143585,
0.2296895831823349,
-1.3227003812789917,
0.42378804087638855,
0.7143967151641846,
0.746798574924469,
-0.1325024515390396,
-0.46868547797203064,
-0.45681315660476685,
0.08940428495407104,
-0.4377143383026123,
0.6256552338600159,
-0.5365143418312073,
-0.27687177062034607,
0.15557287633419037,
0.4289371967315674,
-0.6579341292381287,
-0.7986434102058411,
0.5449211001396179,
0.007793773431330919,
0.31854966282844543,
-0.3745521903038025,
-0.4041473865509033,
-0.17896881699562073,
0.3241889774799347,
-0.5414759516716003,
1.0355826616287231,
0.02294476330280304,
-0.7674643397331238,
0.2100946307182312,
-0.35687100887298584,
-0.2721000909805298,
0.03901005536317825,
-0.35459545254707336,
-0.3518075942993164,
0.445539653301239,
0.07829008996486664,
0.4144017696380615,
-0.17261706292629242,
-0.10788306593894958,
-0.10581158101558685,
-0.482450008392334,
0.5074664950370789,
-0.28350239992141724,
0.48603537678718567,
0.045917876064777374,
-0.40644189715385437,
-0.20195218920707703,
-0.6844160556793213,
-0.1380671113729477,
0.08357051014900208,
-0.4509318172931671,
-0.2866836190223694,
-0.014952241443097591,
0.018220961093902588,
0.3798355460166931,
0.4086515009403229,
-0.45025917887687683,
0.3335295617580414,
-0.3481256067752838,
0.27782002091407776,
0.8756810426712036,
-0.1053628996014595,
0.36757856607437134,
-0.26226961612701416,
0.8362571597099304,
0.1430337280035019,
-0.1266045719385147,
0.24251462519168854,
-0.3086155951023102,
-0.9875571727752686,
0.03241744264960289,
0.15476082265377045,
0.7773744463920593,
-0.3610420227050781,
0.017427582293748856,
-0.17496304214000702,
-0.0035402195062488317,
-0.8274179100990295,
0.22480247914791107,
0.20115996897220612,
0.5889957547187805,
0.2603530287742615,
0.1202647015452385,
-0.4796482026576996,
-1.2846167087554932,
-0.5429565906524658,
-0.6343479752540588,
0.040270641446113586,
0.29472222924232483,
0.5178375840187073,
-0.12848986685276031,
0.42938876152038574,
0.16686084866523743,
-0.2842448949813843,
-0.37690040469169617,
0.08779273182153702,
0.5679031610488892,
0.18869133293628693,
0.1577371060848236,
-0.5187004208564758,
-0.4885270297527313,
-0.11751464009284973,
-0.5485420823097229,
-0.3358702063560486,
-0.1448647379875183,
0.13563644886016846,
0.34097209572792053,
0.7071825265884399,
-0.528533399105072,
0.24150215089321136,
0.6803335547447205,
-0.7243373394012451,
0.6162654757499695,
-0.10751589387655258,
0.13160596787929535,
-1.189629077911377,
0.2466808557510376,
-0.029167603701353073,
-0.20157116651535034,
-0.4947819113731384,
-0.24626681208610535,
-0.022788403555750847,
0.3485909402370453,
-0.5077140927314758,
0.5437877774238586,
-0.6112362146377563,
-0.3711529076099396,
0.12936455011367798,
-0.2604694664478302,
-0.3904826045036316,
0.20233339071273804,
-0.10671185702085495,
1.0291937589645386,
0.12364392727613449,
-0.5834153294563293,
-0.15959547460079193,
0.283376544713974,
-0.693017840385437,
0.9199213981628418,
-0.2088405191898346,
0.21105548739433289,
-0.002755499677732587,
-0.35497012734413147,
-0.864903450012207,
0.07146528363227844,
0.709955096244812,
-0.17750664055347443,
0.45779114961624146,
-0.33272019028663635,
-0.40968087315559387,
-0.2249819040298462,
-0.21375159919261932,
0.3103211224079132,
0.19739070534706116,
-0.33453795313835144,
0.25519996881484985,
0.23523670434951782,
-0.4369569420814514,
-0.9434876441955566,
-0.4681992828845978,
0.24635249376296997,
-0.6416020393371582,
-0.4787602424621582,
0.12937144935131073,
-0.12754592299461365,
-0.9133856892585754,
-0.04367828741669655,
-0.33672112226486206,
-0.07639383524656296,
0.42142409086227417,
0.1483590304851532,
0.02039935626089573,
-0.24014808237552643,
0.3090446889400482,
0.00408242316916585,
-0.2265983670949936,
0.09594731032848358,
-0.2100999802350998,
0.05824996903538704,
-0.4647834599018097,
-0.24895258247852325,
-0.4766312837600708,
0.29807066917419434,
0.4689851701259613,
-0.055723823606967926,
0.6379598379135132,
0.5930952429771423,
-0.30111777782440186,
0.24726809561252594,
-0.632851779460907,
-0.0735698789358139,
-0.4381949007511139,
0.573700487613678,
-0.631912350654602,
-1.0010546445846558,
0.5061241984367371,
-0.26652511954307556,
0.09599065780639648,
0.4479414224624634,
0.8403242230415344,
-0.49787437915802,
0.9080596566200256,
0.7100129723548889,
-0.07333950698375702,
0.44458621740341187,
0.015952231362462044,
0.23759455978870392,
-0.9827371835708618,
-0.08257503807544708,
-0.42928197979927063,
-0.6606543660163879,
-0.9188805222511292,
-0.30803200602531433,
0.5407105684280396,
-0.19928385317325592,
-0.08732005208730698,
-0.17274649441242218,
0.013734697364270687,
0.3525324761867523,
0.3369859755039215,
-0.18642577528953552,
0.35488247871398926,
-0.0037076084408909082,
0.08323159068822861,
-0.394571989774704,
-0.1846875697374344,
-0.7245761752128601,
0.927021861076355,
0.19158446788787842,
0.7670932412147522,
0.49758845567703247,
0.5344628691673279,
0.40029382705688477,
-0.1964680552482605,
-0.6587198376655579,
0.6301963329315186,
-0.020426077768206596,
-0.44361206889152527,
-0.4553750455379486,
-0.18613871932029724,
-1.266003966331482,
0.5402377247810364,
-0.2378665804862976,
-0.6694865822792053,
0.08150772750377655,
-0.13998299837112427,
0.008736667223274708,
0.21036264300346375,
-0.30538874864578247,
0.6826796531677246,
-0.1854405701160431,
-0.4167478084564209,
-0.1052749902009964,
-0.7047940492630005,
0.27859216928482056,
0.04060894250869751,
0.28108465671539307,
-0.6197444200515747,
-0.32515445351600647,
0.7574543952941895,
-0.5871009826660156,
0.5559470057487488,
-0.054937250912189484,
-0.0005142395384609699,
0.14954538643360138,
0.2440110594034195,
0.4532970190048218,
0.010521718300879002,
0.06450679898262024,
0.24965670704841614,
0.11672516912221909,
-0.316111296415329,
-0.3766676187515259,
0.5953535437583923,
-0.7086146473884583,
-0.7120678424835205,
-0.6828319430351257,
-0.3778882920742035,
-0.08520308136940002,
0.1189764067530632,
0.2855187952518463,
-0.18616770207881927,
-0.3482933044433594,
-0.18928901851177216,
0.2936255931854248,
0.21652385592460632,
0.522476851940155,
0.7423703670501709,
0.1100936159491539,
-0.055784922093153,
0.6128506064414978,
0.48149532079696655,
-0.14605560898780823,
0.37713032960891724,
0.2528206706047058,
-0.3982628583908081,
-0.49056172370910645,
-0.5924451351165771,
0.4154590368270874,
-0.5303520560264587,
0.17864073812961578,
-0.527144193649292,
0.04573652520775795,
-0.3860403001308441,
0.03227730840444565,
-0.2647703289985657,
-0.8814767003059387,
-0.3655508756637573,
-0.34658128023147583,
0.09269652515649796,
0.7945907115936279,
-0.1606692522764206,
0.15661318600177765,
-0.48570260405540466,
-0.08275704085826874,
0.428879052400589,
0.0011901591205969453,
-0.49671390652656555,
-0.6827864646911621,
-0.38597434759140015,
-0.3792663812637329,
-0.083194799721241,
-1.0355088710784912,
0.504425585269928,
0.45533931255340576,
0.4755418002605438,
0.30241549015045166,
-0.14770174026489258,
0.6738160252571106,
-0.6529829502105713,
0.5865980982780457,
-0.3297274708747864,
-0.9780828356742859,
0.35801172256469727,
-0.32337284088134766,
0.30963003635406494,
0.771504282951355,
0.1334947943687439,
-0.7948033809661865,
-0.41862228512763977,
-0.520844042301178,
-0.7373012900352478,
0.6360950469970703,
0.24794039130210876,
0.16310471296310425,
-0.047259606420993805,
0.7500033974647522,
0.25268882513046265,
0.3448649048805237,
-0.9164146780967712,
-0.4277905225753784,
0.27587786316871643,
-0.24545051157474518,
-0.16840504109859467,
-0.5280528664588928,
0.17966331541538239,
-0.14079594612121582,
0.5870720148086548,
-0.23069335520267487,
0.2530895173549652,
0.02468627318739891,
-0.4636032283306122,
-0.4179725646972656,
0.5145243406295776,
0.7048330903053284,
0.6886205673217773,
-0.24876628816127777,
0.45107364654541016,
0.32936590909957886,
-0.5474488735198975,
0.4652087390422821,
0.020318487659096718,
0.04442567005753517,
-0.024579208344221115,
0.5485943555831909,
0.49421489238739014,
0.21347247064113617,
-0.49581459164619446,
0.5282319188117981,
-0.31511160731315613,
-0.07606428861618042,
-0.4686725437641144,
-0.22656095027923584,
-0.23524047434329987,
0.6313336491584778,
0.32410526275634766,
-0.3845999538898468,
0.23692350089550018,
-0.33131280541419983,
-0.24908018112182617,
0.4754839241504669,
-0.08743204176425934,
-0.8396106958389282,
0.5323498249053955,
-0.06119404733181,
-0.16334101557731628,
0.8265798687934875,
0.14657974243164062,
-0.30342933535575867,
0.5478430986404419,
0.7174095511436462,
0.9526551365852356,
-0.48884254693984985,
0.22862683236598969,
0.4088284969329834,
0.73211669921875,
0.08736326545476913,
0.5716009140014648,
-0.11456823348999023,
-0.6304843425750732,
-0.14178627729415894,
-0.2567431330680847,
-0.5275347232818604,
0.2993466258049011,
-0.6579432487487793,
0.45029985904693604,
-0.5317181944847107,
-0.17469418048858643,
-0.45771387219429016,
0.28249379992485046,
-0.7203713059425354,
-0.21662534773349762,
0.274960458278656,
0.5222223401069641,
-1.1697614192962646,
0.5701589584350586,
0.977026104927063,
0.0008455056231468916,
-0.2665202021598816,
-0.03452496603131294,
0.06335106492042542,
-0.959719717502594,
0.7638363838195801,
0.23341430723667145,
-0.012605590745806694,
0.05832184478640556,
-0.5957670211791992,
-0.9145357608795166,
0.9260467886924744,
0.5453241467475891,
-0.5690091848373413,
0.1897713541984558,
0.4789256453514099,
0.4287553131580353,
-0.19556385278701782,
0.27005839347839355,
0.5295459628105164,
0.6566738486289978,
-0.16937187314033508,
-0.999447226524353,
-0.08514589071273804,
-0.2046438306570053,
-0.17038781940937042,
0.15862077474594116,
-0.8610345721244812,
1.2316702604293823,
-0.3115500509738922,
-0.26533281803131104,
0.11692406237125397,
0.5274627208709717,
0.016280848532915115,
0.2861926257610321,
0.3645293116569519,
0.5021699666976929,
1.0254780054092407,
0.216026172041893,
0.7020404934883118,
-0.03536354377865791,
0.08182187378406525,
0.9787889719009399,
-0.31067124009132385,
0.8886410593986511,
0.9287700057029724,
-0.16105076670646667,
0.3236793577671051,
0.9676565527915955,
0.19319289922714233,
0.5579619407653809,
0.0355941466987133,
-0.3630336821079254,
-0.5063393712043762,
-0.019232435151934624,
-0.4693850576877594,
0.6596700549125671,
0.5587664246559143,
-0.30117085576057434,
-0.2575811445713043,
-0.2175707370042801,
0.15829706192016602,
-0.23393192887306213,
-0.2561858296394348,
0.7898939847946167,
0.11308997869491577,
-0.3766976594924927,
0.4708445966243744,
0.1262023001909256,
0.22887744009494781,
-0.3628564774990082,
-0.10201697796583176,
-0.42097699642181396,
0.20666031539440155,
-0.06701426208019257,
-0.43851375579833984,
0.173538476228714,
-0.04530254751443863,
-0.29378217458724976,
-0.20506852865219116,
0.44325482845306396,
-0.3599967956542969,
-0.8857999444007874,
-0.06859369575977325,
0.9996564984321594,
0.4589400887489319,
0.1418725848197937,
-0.687362790107727,
-0.05208378657698631,
-0.1341436356306076,
-0.10156712681055069,
0.4670417606830597,
0.4876430928707123,
-0.5189347267150879,
0.5151375532150269,
0.34558790922164917,
0.19069191813468933,
0.3269338607788086,
-0.20134620368480682,
0.34515729546546936,
-0.7984935641288757,
-0.22280709445476532,
-1.122925043106079,
0.11204822361469269,
0.5027691125869751,
-0.40274694561958313,
0.8553720116615295,
0.45792466402053833,
0.6459965705871582,
-0.09414278715848923,
0.76090407371521,
0.2137896567583084,
0.5901492238044739,
-0.5384933948516846,
0.42914333939552307,
-0.5468333959579468,
0.25421157479286194,
-0.160928413271904,
-1.1386971473693848,
-0.23552341759204865,
0.9374216794967651,
-0.3354790508747101,
-0.274699330329895,
0.6484146118164062,
0.5063877105712891,
0.14129650592803955,
-0.4035615921020508,
0.5124620199203491,
0.5461968779563904,
0.34561553597450256,
0.6017004251480103,
1.207028865814209,
-0.3182620108127594,
0.23702843487262726,
-0.023352080956101418,
-0.04819643869996071,
-0.42058470845222473,
-0.9035057425498962,
-1.0326539278030396,
-0.715263843536377,
-0.38828128576278687,
-0.15410666167736053,
0.20366309583187103,
1.09891676902771,
0.3115788400173187,
-0.5552970170974731,
-0.5150794386863708,
0.13960762321949005,
0.37709105014801025,
-0.26813405752182007,
-0.11659267544746399,
0.35911503434181213,
-0.23652350902557373,
-0.8652390837669373,
0.6144632697105408,
0.2971149981021881,
0.12402186542749405,
-0.2505473494529724,
0.15525057911872864,
-0.38592424988746643,
-0.046605486422777176,
0.28195446729660034,
0.46250513195991516,
-0.7131649255752563,
-0.30408623814582825,
0.1762028932571411,
-0.023183923214673996,
0.1363268494606018,
0.7613639831542969,
-0.6082402467727661,
0.4770200252532959,
0.3552247881889343,
0.364406943321228,
0.4186215400695801,
-0.07386062294244766,
0.2920425236225128,
-0.6441359519958496,
0.2710975706577301,
0.041717905551195145,
0.4569307863712311,
0.37444061040878296,
-0.4275994896888733,
0.6363813281059265,
0.3130958080291748,
-0.5377151966094971,
-0.7650843858718872,
0.017545748502016068,
-0.6005577445030212,
0.08108630031347275,
1.1049549579620361,
0.06874298304319382,
-0.23552560806274414,
-0.22960031032562256,
-0.047739990055561066,
0.037786759436130524,
-0.05013052001595497,
1.131120204925537,
0.8931580781936646,
-0.42519351840019226,
-0.285730242729187,
-0.595200777053833,
0.29328617453575134,
0.5738438963890076,
-0.5610591769218445,
-0.11623983830213547,
0.38871946930885315,
0.41832849383354187,
-0.25993481278419495,
0.6181764006614685,
0.014801882207393646,
0.084254689514637,
-0.42459237575531006,
-0.17219758033752441,
-0.024827158078551292,
-0.21095426380634308,
-0.7756271362304688,
-0.3018845021724701,
0.39892569184303284,
-0.467742919921875
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.