id
stringlengths 33
33
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
33
| title
stringlengths 13
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 6
16.6k
| category_primary
stringclasses 60
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
132
| abstract
stringlengths 123
1.99k
| embeddings
listlengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.08202v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.08202v1
|
A Dialogue Game for Eliciting Balanced Collaboration
| 2024-06-12T13:35:10 | 2024-06-12T13:35:10 |
Isidora Jeknić, David Schlangen, Alexander Koller
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Collaboration is an integral part of human dialogue. Typical task-oriented
dialogue games assign asymmetric roles to the participants, which limits their
ability to elicit naturalistic role-taking in collaboration and its
negotiation. We present a novel and simple online setup that favors balanced
collaboration: a two-player 2D object placement game in which the players must
negotiate the goal state themselves. We show empirically that human players
exhibit a variety of role distributions, and that balanced collaboration
improves task performance. We also present an LLM-based baseline agent which
demonstrates that automatic playing of our game is an interesting challenge for
artificial systems.
|
[
-0.49697399139404297,
-0.6830986142158508,
0.49565550684928894,
0.5134068131446838,
0.03538599982857704,
0.43910059332847595,
0.07004720717668533,
-0.7501621246337891,
0.530236542224884,
0.5911840796470642,
-0.5962507724761963,
-0.013978419825434685,
-0.21663950383663177,
0.1685190051794052,
0.2479843646287918,
0.8022683262825012,
0.31152236461639404,
0.3219773471355438,
-0.6311829686164856,
-0.406096488237381,
-0.886988639831543,
-0.194072425365448,
-1.0028184652328491,
-1.1316351890563965,
0.19777822494506836,
0.4623362421989441,
1.0316576957702637,
0.5497170090675354,
0.5605924725532532,
0.43462851643562317,
0.12869109213352203,
-0.056458212435245514,
-0.4849208891391754,
0.5164580941200256,
-0.26558786630630493,
-0.711296558380127,
-0.5283585786819458,
0.028531022369861603,
0.28607839345932007,
0.9628713726997375,
-0.5066140294075012,
-0.13441528379917145,
0.17308178544044495,
0.36314430832862854,
-0.31059741973876953,
-0.09753294289112091,
-0.2269032597541809,
0.29431137442588806,
0.22375677525997162,
-0.07570086419582367,
0.10717371106147766,
0.004076818469911814,
0.3707782030105591,
-0.9883231520652771,
-0.12969981133937836,
-0.0471697673201561,
0.6591790318489075,
0.5294296145439148,
-0.3286505341529846,
-0.3724559545516968,
-0.6651296019554138,
0.6825637221336365,
-0.35218870639801025,
-0.18101288378238678,
0.2669737935066223,
0.14556238055229187,
-0.341825395822525,
-0.4428624212741852,
-0.4684976637363434,
0.1251567304134369,
-0.03243505582213402,
0.6367449760437012,
-0.12203463166952133,
0.5392099022865295,
0.15821076929569244,
0.27679964900016785,
-0.0982678234577179,
0.09245296567678452,
-0.3181708753108978,
0.005314226262271404,
0.5661030411720276,
0.30382904410362244,
0.6801524758338928,
0.25451138615608215,
-0.4924389719963074,
0.2798791825771332,
-0.17226682603359222,
0.5143372416496277,
0.5219860076904297,
0.11007288843393326,
-0.2471581995487213,
0.7184851169586182,
-0.07207387685775757,
0.6497073769569397,
0.3665142357349396,
0.0679813101887703,
-0.2907197177410126,
-0.4383690059185028,
-0.3003307282924652,
0.1169954389333725,
0.5202867388725281,
1.0267401933670044,
-0.13513398170471191,
-0.15077894926071167,
-0.05791494995355606,
0.4289964437484741,
0.4188568890094757,
-0.4644520580768585,
-0.23768408596515656,
0.3221316337585449,
-0.30006468296051025,
-0.33128321170806885,
0.14542017877101898,
-0.47985002398490906,
-0.48997604846954346,
-0.34708166122436523,
0.4961794912815094,
0.1271827220916748,
0.02657473459839821,
-0.08014802634716034,
-0.6681241989135742,
0.2877572476863861,
0.6262726783752441,
-0.8930942416191101,
0.9025782346725464,
0.6375948786735535,
0.7398316264152527,
-0.26231589913368225,
-0.33358731865882874,
-0.5412337183952332,
0.29240208864212036,
-0.3339868187904358,
0.628162682056427,
-0.1767112761735916,
-0.8133344054222107,
-0.3225303888320923,
-0.324957013130188,
0.4185463488101959,
-0.6507307887077332,
0.4423113763332367,
-0.01780468225479126,
0.6024433970451355,
-0.31065621972084045,
-0.34181398153305054,
0.3323451280593872,
0.5558086633682251,
-0.673632025718689,
0.6994910836219788,
-0.09761638194322586,
-0.5879472494125366,
0.32526224851608276,
-0.798210859298706,
-0.5839693546295166,
0.46255165338516235,
-0.43970105051994324,
-0.31549781560897827,
-0.022750182077288628,
-0.24490472674369812,
-0.27834728360176086,
-0.4098719358444214,
-0.09745751321315765,
-0.2344781905412674,
-0.8009501695632935,
0.27781227231025696,
0.17761589586734772,
1.1139895915985107,
0.17940686643123627,
-0.4601466953754425,
0.05014032498002052,
-0.023522095754742622,
0.0826299637556076,
-0.06327877193689346,
-0.49455180764198303,
-0.07991591840982437,
0.3935881555080414,
-0.3372810482978821,
0.1498943567276001,
0.3805455267429352,
-0.5502605438232422,
0.27694642543792725,
-0.4175959825515747,
0.21628117561340332,
0.406208872795105,
-0.10965105891227722,
0.8865006566047668,
-0.6871263980865479,
0.3645276725292206,
-0.35422372817993164,
0.31694063544273376,
0.40869075059890747,
-0.8348168134689331,
-0.7443736791610718,
-0.5464714765548706,
-0.2770191729068756,
0.9843865036964417,
-0.6581922769546509,
0.7428483366966248,
0.14153146743774414,
0.14156213402748108,
-0.7317118048667908,
0.15937979519367218,
0.4083136320114136,
0.17445112764835358,
0.12341765314340591,
-0.7843374013900757,
-0.6103386282920837,
-0.8647927641868591,
0.06912967562675476,
-0.38505464792251587,
-0.2404850572347641,
0.5829383134841919,
-0.04032440856099129,
-0.33717063069343567,
1.1576342582702637,
-0.4820728003978729,
-0.7407544255256653,
-0.36582767963409424,
0.4651831090450287,
0.040108103305101395,
0.4072338938713074,
0.31986603140830994,
-0.6779850125312805,
-0.6827067136764526,
-0.21007269620895386,
-0.8123325109481812,
-0.20951522886753082,
-0.07237330824136734,
-0.25940510630607605,
0.07377878576517105,
0.4046553075313568,
-0.8899698853492737,
0.19083765149116516,
0.511202335357666,
-0.5167425274848938,
-0.08978831768035889,
-0.40301433205604553,
0.33071383833885193,
-1.1461676359176636,
0.10432437062263489,
-0.5157251954078674,
-0.46893641352653503,
-0.7692769765853882,
0.08992816507816315,
-0.7042072415351868,
-0.19893573224544525,
-0.13229362666606903,
0.17426881194114685,
-0.5459427833557129,
-0.28162723779678345,
-0.37121808528900146,
0.531645655632019,
0.04192682355642319,
0.3339211046695709,
0.04559241607785225,
0.3740471303462982,
0.3631293773651123,
-0.19733181595802307,
0.4975740909576416,
0.49194297194480896,
-0.08164602518081665,
1.114202857017517,
-0.6716516017913818,
0.08682800084352493,
0.08651905506849289,
0.5126935243606567,
-0.954031229019165,
-0.25556740164756775,
0.19895219802856445,
-0.40916362404823303,
0.06354416161775589,
-0.075597383081913,
-0.2742075026035309,
-0.24594859778881073,
-0.47679397463798523,
0.504658579826355,
0.34092196822166443,
-0.022837961092591286,
0.4648929536342621,
0.8384776711463928,
-0.1687888354063034,
-0.6807880997657776,
-0.7362069487571716,
0.17989303171634674,
-0.07282067835330963,
-0.7503425478935242,
0.533715009689331,
-0.3091345429420471,
-0.6404903531074524,
0.0593731589615345,
-0.18432296812534332,
-0.1551293432712555,
0.44455859065055847,
0.5059501528739929,
0.3107845187187195,
0.10890848189592361,
-0.3685716390609741,
-0.2981523275375366,
-0.014359023422002792,
-0.1258147805929184,
-0.02267107367515564,
0.2497817724943161,
-0.02410244196653366,
-0.33407843112945557,
-0.29852980375289917,
0.6370264291763306,
0.4623192846775055,
0.22615572810173035,
0.5195725560188293,
0.050697822123765945,
-0.46798139810562134,
-0.0055840229615569115,
-0.5425180196762085,
-0.18184073269367218,
-0.47700294852256775,
0.148917555809021,
-0.02173750475049019,
-0.8628907203674316,
0.6345442533493042,
-0.03767639398574829,
0.21922916173934937,
-0.10196860134601593,
0.5427563786506653,
-0.5236961841583252,
1.1721595525741577,
0.434749037027359,
-0.06823177635669708,
0.18658362329006195,
0.056395336985588074,
0.16043256223201752,
-0.3912217617034912,
-0.24404673278331757,
-0.13264299929141998,
-0.6859518885612488,
-0.36099597811698914,
-0.6725020408630371,
0.21315045654773712,
0.5837631225585938,
-0.26646727323532104,
0.19740243256092072,
-0.6246728897094727,
0.8271446824073792,
0.4719148874282837,
0.13094373047351837,
0.3227699398994446,
-0.4094603657722473,
-0.1801067292690277,
-0.07340273261070251,
-0.5550383925437927,
-0.22654500603675842,
0.21490705013275146,
0.10385338217020035,
0.46036460995674133,
0.5535873174667358,
0.9175872802734375,
0.4033481776714325,
0.061744675040245056,
-0.7490365505218506,
0.46452510356903076,
0.21030616760253906,
-0.8659590482711792,
-0.7696648836135864,
-0.3635280728340149,
-1.0821278095245361,
0.07402659952640533,
-0.49282336235046387,
-0.656321108341217,
-0.09188145399093628,
-0.026240285485982895,
-0.6640185713768005,
-0.027046680450439453,
-0.6515628099441528,
0.8351715207099915,
-0.32833927869796753,
-0.6483339667320251,
-0.463063508272171,
-0.8973426222801208,
0.045844126492738724,
0.4465080797672272,
0.1441735029220581,
-0.06602729111909866,
-0.13652603328227997,
0.1852579116821289,
-0.1463138461112976,
0.8380884528160095,
-0.20255430042743683,
0.29048049449920654,
0.4891080856323242,
0.5683126449584961,
0.3940557837486267,
0.12918423116207123,
0.11628081649541855,
-0.07524577528238297,
-0.20421934127807617,
-0.6670822501182556,
-0.6853158473968506,
0.5557169318199158,
-1.1909407377243042,
-0.9525527358055115,
-0.5480049848556519,
-0.8054450154304504,
-0.006993437185883522,
0.17430101335048676,
0.2131485641002655,
-0.16159687936306,
-0.7301713824272156,
0.44453001022338867,
0.19927702844142914,
0.03547380864620209,
0.44906744360923767,
0.28648611903190613,
0.11545015871524811,
-0.5570601224899292,
0.5963078141212463,
-0.11239524930715561,
0.5510259866714478,
0.3980434834957123,
0.08193130046129227,
-0.05268644541501999,
-0.007759096100926399,
-0.20612621307373047,
-0.27321454882621765,
-0.44919726252555847,
-0.10806082934141159,
-0.31445637345314026,
-0.07141362130641937,
-0.0867815837264061,
-0.86158686876297,
-0.28199702501296997,
-0.4618760347366333,
-0.22494526207447052,
-0.019459372386336327,
-0.3426372706890106,
0.9229306578636169,
-0.1839449107646942,
0.18579408526420593,
-0.4878110885620117,
0.2620507478713989,
0.8512809872627258,
0.2945358157157898,
-0.2646929621696472,
0.23093588650226593,
-0.10561908036470413,
0.3848963677883148,
-0.6120171546936035,
-0.6024417281150818,
0.12150578200817108,
-0.11956099420785904,
0.8358756899833679,
0.2278902381658554,
0.05676867440342903,
0.766228973865509,
-0.28395774960517883,
0.9702960252761841,
0.6887459754943848,
-1.0849318504333496,
0.14790426194667816,
-0.6320266723632812,
0.2972574234008789,
0.5915625095367432,
-0.03890779986977577,
-0.6114285588264465,
-0.5218414664268494,
-0.5099943280220032,
-0.7203079462051392,
1.2905125617980957,
0.7768692374229431,
-0.12916745245456696,
0.13281792402267456,
-0.11842777580022812,
-0.3361040949821472,
0.3411633372306824,
-0.885018527507782,
-0.21840430796146393,
-0.33146002888679504,
-0.07229878008365631,
0.013007722795009613,
-0.01906701549887657,
-0.8653665781021118,
-0.03657212108373642,
0.0696735680103302,
-0.045102156698703766,
0.3701663911342621,
0.29274821281433105,
0.014916513115167618,
-0.7120206952095032,
0.16641829907894135,
0.7644863128662109,
0.3350209891796112,
-0.13993099331855774,
0.22241365909576416,
0.5075989365577698,
-0.02041822113096714,
0.3069455921649933,
-0.1088227853178978,
0.08418119698762894,
-0.5213934779167175,
0.38225656747817993,
0.38616764545440674,
0.4797089993953705,
-0.3822821378707886,
0.569549560546875,
0.07728198915719986,
-0.3748796880245209,
-0.08089421689510345,
0.18876789510250092,
0.5244961380958557,
0.6999198794364929,
0.16418534517288208,
0.1600959151983261,
0.12529389560222626,
-0.9694470167160034,
0.40149128437042236,
0.6401815414428711,
-0.5372921824455261,
-0.13447809219360352,
0.586171567440033,
0.7660390138626099,
-0.9883084893226624,
0.42344334721565247,
-0.25375595688819885,
-0.6283289790153503,
0.7680808901786804,
0.5224729180335999,
0.6602334380149841,
-0.1270076483488083,
0.553013026714325,
-0.10720046609640121,
0.12462187558412552,
-0.33929145336151123,
0.2235117256641388,
-0.2865583300590515,
-1.0438958406448364,
-0.04582706838846207,
-0.08236780017614365,
-0.798940896987915,
-0.45860663056373596,
-0.4348825216293335,
0.332615464925766,
-0.29046866297721863,
-0.4169692099094391,
-0.11154517531394958,
0.3932308256626129,
-0.4413946568965912,
-0.4042526185512543,
0.28736475110054016,
-0.03568984568119049,
-0.5455426573753357,
0.4328397214412689,
0.7219752669334412,
-0.5167930126190186,
-0.2774064242839813,
0.07289521396160126,
0.23340123891830444,
-0.3746810257434845,
0.573862612247467,
-0.014857619069516659,
-0.27470484375953674,
0.01883833296597004,
-0.528626024723053,
-0.49110549688339233,
1.4210965633392334,
0.5099748373031616,
-0.05864015594124794,
-0.17836177349090576,
0.38547483086586,
0.8162339329719543,
-0.5018139481544495,
0.3648644983768463,
-0.04064932093024254,
0.3490259647369385,
0.2559746503829956,
-1.1019080877304077,
-0.03718709573149681,
-0.10520453006029129,
-0.28412991762161255,
0.03160196542739868,
-0.8853432536125183,
0.8633429408073425,
0.07088886201381683,
-0.23156407475471497,
0.25130119919776917,
0.27173760533332825,
0.34303247928619385,
0.39217424392700195,
0.8230602145195007,
0.5892668962478638,
0.4396761953830719,
-0.07496003806591034,
0.5959534645080566,
-0.17350926995277405,
0.1436794251203537,
1.0767855644226074,
-0.8730934858322144,
0.3395664095878601,
0.5358076095581055,
-0.04380571097135544,
0.2989828586578369,
0.19780002534389496,
-0.021153412759304047,
0.3450396955013275,
0.21576786041259766,
-0.4415875971317291,
-0.5505979657173157,
-0.44007235765457153,
0.29573121666908264,
0.35059306025505066,
0.10641378164291382,
0.2550320327281952,
-0.22351515293121338,
-0.3799203932285309,
-0.34834808111190796,
0.18972808122634888,
0.08179669082164764,
1.007680892944336,
0.2116946280002594,
-1.1187673807144165,
-0.11097840219736099,
-0.24633316695690155,
0.5039019584655762,
-0.22802124917507172,
-0.21000905334949493,
-0.17285199463367462,
0.32354435324668884,
-0.41697046160697937,
-0.8276544213294983,
0.036509860306978226,
-0.44176074862480164,
-0.1758154332637787,
-0.33391544222831726,
0.38128045201301575,
-0.7900394797325134,
-0.05095550790429115,
0.7268561124801636,
0.5372164845466614,
-0.1681440770626068,
0.3958730399608612,
-0.8110352158546448,
-0.17019769549369812,
-0.06844092160463333,
0.2787998616695404,
0.37394481897354126,
0.46492430567741394,
-0.02702976018190384,
0.5846579670906067,
0.44335150718688965,
0.01496175117790699,
-0.31194037199020386,
-0.03803069889545441,
0.5773932933807373,
-0.30280521512031555,
-0.6503372192382812,
-0.5632915496826172,
0.8107103109359741,
-0.6346981525421143,
-0.09519071877002716,
0.6365756988525391,
0.6969702839851379,
0.5180805921554565,
0.18980567157268524,
0.47958073019981384,
-0.10070616751909256,
0.19673311710357666,
0.08769596368074417,
0.6374279260635376,
-0.5176723003387451,
0.2033701390028,
-0.3643638789653778,
-0.8600910902023315,
-0.31808674335479736,
0.7569441199302673,
0.5877246856689453,
-0.3849928677082062,
0.3701556324958801,
0.5965391993522644,
-0.05151510611176491,
0.055550817400217056,
0.4996131360530853,
-0.12349436432123184,
0.33546310663223267,
0.44077268242836,
1.1359286308288574,
-0.03972412273287773,
0.49900659918785095,
-0.19902759790420532,
-0.3700818717479706,
-0.31296467781066895,
-0.5238339900970459,
-1.0652371644973755,
-0.3975009620189667,
-0.2679330110549927,
-0.4343511760234833,
0.027486909180879593,
1.5005813837051392,
0.6869689226150513,
-0.46375951170921326,
-1.1333643198013306,
-0.4186346232891083,
0.23895342648029327,
-0.285433292388916,
-0.19915151596069336,
-0.4437708258628845,
-0.10359661281108856,
-0.7588034272193909,
0.5784207582473755,
0.3693962097167969,
0.009418566711246967,
-0.0831979438662529,
-0.3531840443611145,
-0.41141292452812195,
0.4026404023170471,
0.4489968419075012,
0.44689449667930603,
-0.5509212017059326,
-0.32174474000930786,
0.21199356019496918,
-0.47524330019950867,
-0.00873903464525938,
1.0976152420043945,
-0.20742209255695343,
0.7658255100250244,
0.782027006149292,
0.47289690375328064,
0.3697669208049774,
0.2888391315937042,
1.2690552473068237,
-0.7304570078849792,
0.5005364418029785,
0.4820121228694916,
0.008993773721158504,
0.18895405530929565,
-0.4585976302623749,
0.6795304417610168,
0.4095214605331421,
-0.7667266726493835,
-0.7081266045570374,
0.19734929502010345,
-0.9807068705558777,
-0.15920589864253998,
0.6029251217842102,
-0.09606222063302994,
0.4481986463069916,
-0.39845386147499084,
-0.4494243860244751,
0.5462782979011536,
-0.4472182095050812,
0.8474021553993225,
0.9521644711494446,
-0.5975322127342224,
0.16188637912273407,
-0.23001572489738464,
0.7063496708869934,
0.6065489649772644,
-0.6592668890953064,
-0.3536900579929352,
0.5545219779014587,
-0.24247272312641144,
0.4658225476741791,
0.859662652015686,
0.4319066107273102,
0.3249513804912567,
0.07667858153581619,
0.24829304218292236,
0.22742213308811188,
-0.21113094687461853,
-0.033582188189029694,
-0.04891270399093628,
0.19123302400112152,
-0.09522069245576859
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12907v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12907v1
|
Reconciling Kaplan and Chinchilla Scaling Laws
| 2024-06-12T13:30:48 | 2024-06-12T13:30:48 |
Tim Pearce, Jinyeop Song
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Kaplan et al. [2020] (`Kaplan') and Hoffmann et al. [2022] (`Chinchilla')
studied the scaling behavior of transformers trained on next-token language
prediction. These studies produced different estimates for how the number of
parameters ($N$) and training tokens ($D$) should be set to achieve the lowest
possible loss for a given compute budget ($C$). Kaplan: $N_\text{optimal}
\propto C^{0.73}$, Chinchilla: $N_\text{optimal} \propto C^{0.50}$. This note
finds that much of this discrepancy can be attributed to Kaplan counting
non-embedding rather than total parameters, combined with their analysis being
performed at small scale. Simulating the Chinchilla study under these
conditions produces biased scaling coefficients close to Kaplan's. Hence, this
note reaffirms Chinchilla's scaling coefficients, by explaining the cause of
Kaplan's original overestimation.
|
[
-0.42701733112335205,
-0.21522264182567596,
0.32871657609939575,
0.37529894709587097,
0.04843652993440628,
-0.265144407749176,
-0.4587181806564331,
-0.19546891748905182,
0.4125809669494629,
0.5361564755439758,
-0.3911376893520355,
0.16281196475028992,
-0.4295116662979126,
-0.20831219851970673,
-0.49983084201812744,
1.1114144325256348,
0.1059960126876831,
0.39354196190834045,
0.013898978941142559,
-0.38891714811325073,
-0.1761586219072342,
-0.14549604058265686,
-0.7527722120285034,
-0.36580196022987366,
0.4576605260372162,
0.43000784516334534,
1.057429313659668,
0.9624507427215576,
0.49997517466545105,
0.21467627584934235,
0.07498934864997864,
-0.5843228697776794,
-0.32667970657348633,
-0.21733272075653076,
0.08461099117994308,
-0.9548171758651733,
-0.293691486120224,
0.1555023491382599,
0.7580642104148865,
0.6549242734909058,
-0.4607127904891968,
0.13480280339717865,
-0.1991533488035202,
0.8480166792869568,
-0.5122660994529724,
0.14148211479187012,
-0.5588085651397705,
0.34390872716903687,
-0.1408371776342392,
-0.18364417552947998,
-0.7327688336372375,
-0.3150157034397125,
-0.07159561663866043,
-0.689018189907074,
0.3446763753890991,
0.11494053155183792,
0.8293456435203552,
0.6120697855949402,
-0.2430359572172165,
-0.29902151226997375,
-0.39396995306015015,
1.207639455795288,
-0.7910777926445007,
0.5274801254272461,
0.3842446804046631,
0.43807294964790344,
0.12313705682754517,
-0.9824127554893494,
-0.5019615888595581,
-0.5356623530387878,
0.039226990193128586,
0.020489782094955444,
-0.33887526392936707,
-0.07841469347476959,
0.4901317358016968,
0.429294615983963,
-0.24901528656482697,
0.3500998318195343,
-0.710761308670044,
-0.46172529458999634,
0.6399487853050232,
0.22253406047821045,
0.17133551836013794,
-0.032119665294885635,
-0.2463407963514328,
-0.38400474190711975,
-0.6586266160011292,
0.16838642954826355,
0.20180639624595642,
0.5999873876571655,
-0.3417578935623169,
0.4622563421726227,
0.004578090272843838,
0.4502815306186676,
0.569320797920227,
-0.20835445821285248,
0.5032848119735718,
-0.23304025828838348,
-0.22695884108543396,
0.4077116847038269,
0.5110777616500854,
0.5482286214828491,
0.6447094082832336,
0.012513097375631332,
0.1796758621931076,
-0.23867809772491455,
0.7084172964096069,
-0.8158361911773682,
-0.1064099371433258,
-0.18884791433811188,
-0.6676698923110962,
-0.6081040501594543,
0.008154848590493202,
-0.8982668519020081,
-0.39077308773994446,
-0.27832508087158203,
0.4863852262496948,
0.19604133069515228,
-0.31860536336898804,
-0.10445696115493774,
-0.1672373116016388,
0.6328831911087036,
0.23898467421531677,
-1.1369422674179077,
0.4843403100967407,
0.5943607687950134,
0.8586005568504333,
0.22791989147663116,
-0.3820333480834961,
-0.6025679707527161,
-0.4146544635295868,
-0.584367036819458,
0.35945913195610046,
-0.4509228765964508,
-0.41336730122566223,
0.22099386155605316,
0.010912061668932438,
0.024022480472922325,
-0.6735235452651978,
0.6106097102165222,
-0.35170096158981323,
-0.13199807703495026,
-0.6028925776481628,
-0.4434033930301666,
-0.04323652759194374,
-0.11459386348724365,
-0.7287716269493103,
0.8746463656425476,
0.4061416983604431,
-0.7442823648452759,
0.6563147306442261,
-0.288556843996048,
-0.5355174541473389,
-0.11017657071352005,
-0.16781765222549438,
-0.49263995885849,
0.35485345125198364,
0.07006584852933884,
0.21173511445522308,
-0.686371386051178,
-0.028479205444455147,
-0.3944791853427887,
-0.399240642786026,
0.196727454662323,
-0.3268778324127197,
0.8951795697212219,
0.13422858715057373,
-0.5820988416671753,
0.10673342645168304,
-0.5196056962013245,
0.18485015630722046,
0.03346596285700798,
-0.36939647793769836,
0.06820452213287354,
0.045300524681806564,
0.11815202981233597,
-0.025339532643556595,
-0.03040085919201374,
-0.7466040253639221,
0.14655707776546478,
-0.42431560158729553,
0.788665771484375,
0.6235935091972351,
0.04473103955388069,
0.8422508835792542,
-0.28987133502960205,
0.4973028004169464,
-0.1354646533727646,
0.45597952604293823,
-0.04248809441924095,
-0.6131102442741394,
-0.6719669699668884,
0.04994944483041763,
0.2575698792934418,
0.10766790062189102,
-0.17444734275341034,
-0.19985784590244293,
-0.13921701908111572,
-0.7259621024131775,
-0.45882874727249146,
-0.057673364877700806,
0.037366218864917755,
0.5782315731048584,
0.7072230577468872,
-0.15844352543354034,
-0.5933440923690796,
-1.0728720426559448,
-0.4129791259765625,
-0.2148984968662262,
0.04613678157329559,
0.03010808490216732,
0.31167542934417725,
0.0012761924881488085,
1.0076240301132202,
-0.5833477973937988,
-0.4455421566963196,
-0.4158998131752014,
-0.0692489892244339,
0.22168275713920593,
0.6467543840408325,
0.8820570111274719,
-0.8877459168434143,
-0.9657994508743286,
-0.06347130239009857,
-0.23175236582756042,
-0.016836874186992645,
-0.3397570848464966,
0.33144980669021606,
0.17621800303459167,
0.9402636885643005,
-0.49029237031936646,
0.4778241217136383,
0.32794398069381714,
0.40711793303489685,
0.5819710493087769,
-0.151731476187706,
-0.2161579132080078,
-0.9711830019950867,
-0.29544755816459656,
0.29103031754493713,
0.08980225771665573,
-0.6929371356964111,
0.27204734086990356,
0.4514751732349396,
0.21951240301132202,
-0.3477112948894501,
0.4088316261768341,
-0.1657811999320984,
-0.1275791972875595,
-0.19835086166858673,
0.16769523918628693,
-0.25127917528152466,
0.6676162481307983,
-0.20531737804412842,
0.9372565746307373,
0.49580585956573486,
-0.35307076573371887,
0.21831941604614258,
0.06680215150117874,
0.1195036992430687,
0.7141592502593994,
-0.9089295268058777,
-0.34222233295440674,
0.16593419015407562,
0.5495412349700928,
-0.8864177465438843,
-0.04551107808947563,
0.05220305547118187,
-0.6838359236717224,
0.4640182852745056,
-0.2626523971557617,
-0.24689914286136627,
-0.26528018712997437,
-0.723910927772522,
0.49927982687950134,
0.8746166825294495,
-0.6350688934326172,
0.5688042640686035,
0.49406152963638306,
0.3373846709728241,
-0.7598512172698975,
-0.9188233017921448,
-0.019491668790578842,
-0.2956141233444214,
-0.2835559546947479,
0.39424487948417664,
-0.1728331744670868,
-0.40336596965789795,
-0.16249585151672363,
-0.35781264305114746,
-0.27535244822502136,
-0.35528793931007385,
0.27405938506126404,
0.05238621309399605,
-0.639254093170166,
0.024524083361029625,
0.14413805305957794,
-0.14577139914035797,
0.5104950070381165,
-0.27085211873054504,
0.513689398765564,
-0.1552705019712448,
-0.233482226729393,
-0.42682430148124695,
-0.23926416039466858,
0.7449902296066284,
-0.26413241028785706,
0.9043214321136475,
0.8268100023269653,
-0.3498947322368622,
-0.06604071706533432,
-0.5739068388938904,
-0.18579520285129547,
-0.5413756966590881,
0.2244938313961029,
-0.11681903898715973,
-0.5456711053848267,
0.7340996265411377,
0.16260488331317902,
0.11253605037927628,
1.1384525299072266,
0.6599509119987488,
0.18160532414913177,
0.8549883365631104,
0.5825775265693665,
-0.25769102573394775,
0.41448742151260376,
-0.3159744441509247,
0.34110650420188904,
-1.2773019075393677,
-0.196539968252182,
-0.7546658515930176,
-0.46930938959121704,
-1.043183445930481,
-0.4427727460861206,
0.08919033408164978,
-0.2540234327316284,
-0.36452603340148926,
0.575472891330719,
-0.16260705888271332,
0.5506582260131836,
0.5249491333961487,
-0.1273626685142517,
-0.06871847063302994,
-0.17929509282112122,
-0.28852829337120056,
-0.4498756229877472,
-0.5944979190826416,
0.08709976077079773,
1.4154046773910522,
0.2726365327835083,
0.7266641855239868,
-0.03380477800965309,
0.6228629350662231,
0.30449792742729187,
0.6273193359375,
-1.0343061685562134,
0.4616493582725525,
-0.03714863955974579,
-0.8677338361740112,
-0.5190495252609253,
-0.5072839260101318,
-0.6725674271583557,
0.2672315537929535,
-0.05982495844364166,
-0.7458595633506775,
0.15261144936084747,
-0.0003388090990483761,
-0.23573064804077148,
0.5178504586219788,
-0.2605825960636139,
0.6397315859794617,
0.36908093094825745,
-0.3372955918312073,
-0.5364601612091064,
-0.7469843029975891,
0.13475042581558228,
-0.3872990310192108,
0.1643471121788025,
0.20002932846546173,
-0.08340278267860413,
0.8524964451789856,
-0.6090391278266907,
0.8111532926559448,
-0.3447134494781494,
-0.07546400278806686,
0.5608046650886536,
-0.02491058222949505,
0.35017260909080505,
0.24928148090839386,
-0.07008849084377289,
-0.05818847194314003,
0.041278377175331116,
-0.572472333908081,
-0.6144073605537415,
0.8990722298622131,
-0.8081067800521851,
-0.3109501898288727,
-0.41265639662742615,
-0.38636595010757446,
-0.055468663573265076,
0.10766733437776566,
0.48258358240127563,
0.8568292856216431,
0.00030816212529316545,
0.5985725522041321,
0.43899106979370117,
-0.24697567522525787,
0.5367786884307861,
0.6745445132255554,
-0.11851340532302856,
-0.3465769290924072,
0.7916051149368286,
0.4432660937309265,
0.28592464327812195,
0.3753974139690399,
0.4857940375804901,
-0.2222101092338562,
-0.4435172975063324,
-0.3610011339187622,
0.4696175456047058,
-0.6940308213233948,
-0.14432963728904724,
-0.2904817759990692,
-0.40937116742134094,
-0.24542954564094543,
-0.43423962593078613,
-0.7155482769012451,
-0.5649853348731995,
-0.034075357019901276,
-0.08662813156843185,
0.03603295236825943,
0.7826656699180603,
-0.34403449296951294,
0.47723034024238586,
-0.6407410502433777,
-0.13639792799949646,
0.020228184759616852,
0.29405996203422546,
0.5148968696594238,
-0.9994418621063232,
-0.656936764717102,
0.09495092928409576,
-0.21485917270183563,
-0.7578328251838684,
0.03515114635229111,
0.16406680643558502,
0.6481553316116333,
0.5139158368110657,
0.15327021479606628,
0.6535072922706604,
-0.5383843183517456,
0.6739045977592468,
0.24643047153949738,
-1.0254096984863281,
0.06991469860076904,
-0.24792341887950897,
0.23874232172966003,
0.6933971047401428,
0.2775977551937103,
-0.7330085635185242,
-0.3452072739601135,
-0.9023087620735168,
-0.7459352016448975,
0.6099989414215088,
0.09784498065710068,
0.5200098752975464,
0.12104573100805283,
0.768706202507019,
-0.03297577425837517,
0.17425662279129028,
-0.602783739566803,
-0.17016027867794037,
-0.15545083582401276,
-0.23303420841693878,
-0.22748242318630219,
-0.15962865948677063,
0.11535114794969559,
-0.5729119181632996,
0.4118410050868988,
-0.08731043338775635,
0.17488634586334229,
0.03377653658390045,
-0.2772102653980255,
-0.38726794719696045,
-0.17198529839515686,
1.1686781644821167,
0.7192016839981079,
-0.07766566425561905,
-0.09540331363677979,
0.4853517711162567,
-0.9047302007675171,
-0.01150781475007534,
-0.47022271156311035,
0.17777119576931,
-0.2786980867385864,
0.742423415184021,
0.4196443259716034,
0.64776211977005,
-0.4156588315963745,
0.6254242658615112,
-0.040178071707487106,
-0.3811205327510834,
-0.6722237467765808,
0.15888112783432007,
-0.06630633026361465,
0.20604971051216125,
0.6238836050033569,
0.46633633971214294,
-0.11936316639184952,
-0.3672080338001251,
0.5653284192085266,
0.15491333603858948,
-0.6915568709373474,
-0.5354019999504089,
0.7421234250068665,
0.05314801260828972,
-0.34202516078948975,
1.0210105180740356,
0.014505859464406967,
-0.5521820187568665,
0.8801889419555664,
0.5337265729904175,
0.7693474292755127,
-0.3568797707557678,
0.37272483110427856,
0.8526929020881653,
0.6382430791854858,
-0.2716214954853058,
-0.20306555926799774,
0.014576023444533348,
-0.5511965155601501,
-0.21645213663578033,
-0.44656267762184143,
-0.47724154591560364,
-0.20820409059524536,
-1.2962288856506348,
0.22366943955421448,
-0.7528893947601318,
-0.339836448431015,
0.14515340328216553,
0.117735855281353,
-0.42150190472602844,
0.21469826996326447,
-0.24762961268424988,
1.0492011308670044,
-0.9641382098197937,
0.6092907786369324,
0.31142643094062805,
-0.6982319355010986,
-1.0801430940628052,
0.4188740849494934,
0.203055277466774,
-1.1185803413391113,
0.5293049812316895,
0.0021976823918521404,
0.04858973249793053,
0.050548430532217026,
-0.340828001499176,
-1.0038604736328125,
0.9458277821540833,
0.2606392502784729,
-0.2813890874385834,
0.11304173618555069,
0.04369109869003296,
0.7938231825828552,
-0.3738561272621155,
0.12169834226369858,
0.5128473043441772,
0.448999285697937,
0.17444655299186707,
-1.0590707063674927,
0.15139487385749817,
0.024368172511458397,
-0.28485924005508423,
0.6044564247131348,
-0.9375560879707336,
1.2228904962539673,
-0.5926288962364197,
0.1039009615778923,
-0.026670681312680244,
0.6268514394760132,
-0.33062952756881714,
0.19008976221084595,
0.3623926639556885,
0.5700306296348572,
0.3817610442638397,
0.07625238597393036,
1.0568541288375854,
-0.40157732367515564,
0.6547048091888428,
1.1042572259902954,
-0.15801718831062317,
1.0791808366775513,
0.5815249681472778,
-0.7828149795532227,
0.49040812253952026,
0.7121105790138245,
-0.2893202304840088,
0.4279842674732208,
0.37971946597099304,
0.40155029296875,
0.22509004175662994,
-0.05351603776216507,
-0.568615734577179,
0.4597816467285156,
-0.08887974172830582,
-0.40628582239151,
-0.13624829053878784,
-0.22457344830036163,
0.47794145345687866,
-0.1805826872587204,
-0.3334242105484009,
0.32043495774269104,
0.09577955305576324,
-0.4633922278881073,
0.4662230908870697,
0.06216338276863098,
0.3275100886821747,
-0.5498412251472473,
0.2747252583503723,
-0.44541871547698975,
0.43355926871299744,
-0.2733950912952423,
-0.5468153953552246,
0.32044002413749695,
-0.3092281222343445,
-0.03790401667356491,
0.032590560615062714,
0.26182401180267334,
-0.09176591038703918,
-0.4453437328338623,
0.16082853078842163,
-0.019615301862359047,
0.00237918714992702,
-0.047994498163461685,
-0.6136862635612488,
0.23180288076400757,
0.06433923542499542,
-0.2701736092567444,
0.5282005071640015,
-0.15067915618419647,
0.020839953795075417,
0.6381580829620361,
0.44200319051742554,
0.06358063220977783,
0.219429612159729,
0.23309165239334106,
0.736594557762146,
-0.30833008885383606,
-0.5628740787506104,
-0.87701815366745,
0.14919424057006836,
-0.029581919312477112,
-0.48387518525123596,
0.8646501302719116,
0.505382239818573,
0.694237470626831,
0.08122169971466064,
0.25292840600013733,
0.08922732621431351,
0.02070228010416031,
-0.30190354585647583,
0.6846516132354736,
-0.8965818881988525,
-0.09453728795051575,
-0.19244858622550964,
-1.357346773147583,
-0.14501194655895233,
0.7584062814712524,
-0.10001300275325775,
0.41582387685775757,
0.9487782716751099,
0.5684675574302673,
0.08217606693506241,
0.20683617889881134,
0.02771662175655365,
0.2841285765171051,
0.26784414052963257,
0.18188634514808655,
0.24417515099048615,
-0.5182320475578308,
0.3272356390953064,
-0.12469004094600677,
-0.06347674876451492,
-0.418819785118103,
-0.5073584914207458,
-0.7134207487106323,
-0.8536456227302551,
-0.3203853666782379,
-0.2713301181793213,
-0.5375406742095947,
0.7996405363082886,
0.6516343355178833,
-0.6965976357460022,
-0.4514332711696625,
-0.07774695008993149,
-0.16727831959724426,
-0.29680001735687256,
-0.21085502207279205,
0.19022634625434875,
-0.37973082065582275,
-0.484499454498291,
0.08040272444486618,
0.3268091678619385,
-0.0766359493136406,
-0.6071663498878479,
-0.2677842378616333,
0.16393886506557465,
0.4882790744304657,
0.09937437623739243,
0.34968507289886475,
-0.7535698413848877,
-0.4242117702960968,
-0.04531076177954674,
-0.31117480993270874,
0.32977601885795593,
1.1218584775924683,
-0.5473801493644714,
0.25882163643836975,
0.5148223638534546,
0.5433319807052612,
0.7462922930717468,
-0.31832364201545715,
0.5702708959579468,
-0.5258872509002686,
0.24509821832180023,
-0.012410408817231655,
0.15003521740436554,
0.215255007147789,
-0.15578609704971313,
0.5668599605560303,
-0.044521763920784,
-0.43540528416633606,
-1.0953189134597778,
0.3101996183395386,
-0.8411901593208313,
0.04800983890891075,
0.6844308972358704,
0.13874804973602295,
-0.17555895447731018,
0.3287334144115448,
-0.0635722205042839,
0.09323591738939285,
-0.17352625727653503,
0.5495578050613403,
0.7369444966316223,
-0.09672324359416962,
-0.1847262680530548,
-0.8607045412063599,
0.6402257084846497,
0.5896998643875122,
-0.27098461985588074,
-0.033910345286130905,
-0.1413808912038803,
0.24962803721427917,
0.3051290512084961,
0.5407902598381042,
-0.005996462423354387,
0.19741861522197723,
0.3709368109703064,
-0.5222414135932922,
0.26328134536743164,
-0.3032372295856476,
-0.3298676311969757,
-0.021915581077337265,
0.29335400462150574,
0.09534280747175217
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.08183v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.08183v2
|
Underneath the Numbers: Quantitative and Qualitative Gender Fairness in LLMs for Depression Prediction
| 2024-06-12T13:14:19 | 2024-06-14T09:34:35 |
Micol Spitale, Jiaee Cheong, Hatice Gunes
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Recent studies show bias in many machine learning models for depression
detection, but bias in LLMs for this task remains unexplored. This work
presents the first attempt to investigate the degree of gender bias present in
existing LLMs (ChatGPT, LLaMA 2, and Bard) using both quantitative and
qualitative approaches. From our quantitative evaluation, we found that ChatGPT
performs the best across various performance metrics and LLaMA 2 outperforms
other LLMs in terms of group fairness metrics. As qualitative fairness
evaluation remains an open research question we propose several strategies
(e.g., word count, thematic analysis) to investigate whether and how a
qualitative evaluation can provide valuable insights for bias analysis beyond
what is possible with quantitative evaluation. We found that ChatGPT
consistently provides a more comprehensive, well-reasoned explanation for its
prediction compared to LLaMA 2. We have also identified several themes adopted
by LLMs to qualitatively evaluate gender fairness. We hope our results can be
used as a stepping stone towards future attempts at improving qualitative
evaluation of fairness for LLMs especially for high-stakes tasks such as
depression detection.
|
[
-0.30047041177749634,
-0.490064412355423,
0.8911835551261902,
0.5565837621688843,
-0.13579311966896057,
0.28453394770622253,
0.1373049020767212,
-0.28181779384613037,
-0.16627267003059387,
0.1168336272239685,
-0.8726451396942139,
-0.6053202748298645,
-0.9048317670822144,
0.27558645606040955,
-0.3114873766899109,
0.9979400634765625,
0.265224426984787,
0.7980616092681885,
-0.3498219847679138,
0.18818825483322144,
-0.7695655822753906,
-0.5326203107833862,
-0.7976452112197876,
-0.7103193998336792,
0.38550934195518494,
0.2724020183086395,
0.6983460783958435,
-0.10998716205358505,
0.44409093260765076,
0.2701985239982605,
-0.30574244260787964,
-0.11339255422353745,
-0.7155144214630127,
-0.07399213314056396,
0.04323741793632507,
-0.9465635418891907,
-0.6009465456008911,
0.1652374267578125,
0.42557471990585327,
0.5968260765075684,
-0.21014249324798584,
0.31208348274230957,
0.2966664135456085,
0.811836838722229,
-0.49762505292892456,
0.15405364334583282,
-0.5656105279922485,
0.6776136159896851,
-0.09714899212121964,
0.07791896909475327,
-0.008309517987072468,
-0.7744783163070679,
0.004886406473815441,
-0.34165164828300476,
0.33993634581565857,
0.055957868695259094,
0.3795554041862488,
0.4033605754375458,
-0.6259987354278564,
-0.2403678447008133,
-0.24064254760742188,
0.991176962852478,
-0.6376471519470215,
-0.012499712407588959,
0.5749353170394897,
0.42718443274497986,
-0.2990244925022125,
-0.34733399748802185,
-0.3538646399974823,
0.139222651720047,
-0.013915430754423141,
0.19617336988449097,
-0.39803725481033325,
-0.12100780010223389,
0.34969353675842285,
0.40655645728111267,
-0.5234182476997375,
0.24705898761749268,
-0.44330161809921265,
0.06381034851074219,
0.5601140856742859,
0.35776159167289734,
0.28697752952575684,
-0.31834539771080017,
-0.3198516070842743,
0.41847509145736694,
-0.48033711314201355,
0.14333494007587433,
0.43047717213630676,
-0.06446543335914612,
-0.3856932520866394,
0.6382192969322205,
-0.04366431385278702,
-0.04893546551465988,
0.33693060278892517,
-0.10087820142507553,
0.18621554970741272,
0.06935158371925354,
-0.1980699896812439,
0.4148889183998108,
0.7953967452049255,
0.6379626393318176,
0.2858966886997223,
-0.0909201055765152,
-0.16192656755447388,
0.3143346309661865,
0.23371173441410065,
-0.7632375359535217,
-0.03213437274098396,
0.31944540143013,
-0.9103482961654663,
-0.5307039022445679,
-0.3417282998561859,
-0.8254207372665405,
-1.102900505065918,
-0.2640104293823242,
0.2791958749294281,
-0.2210497260093689,
-0.44060736894607544,
0.15990155935287476,
-0.359496533870697,
0.012169397436082363,
0.31120923161506653,
-0.6493595242500305,
0.23531697690486908,
1.0392638444900513,
0.9632648229598999,
-0.03893450275063515,
0.2585376501083374,
-0.33565714955329895,
-0.1340150088071823,
-0.2633717954158783,
0.7889432311058044,
-0.37842729687690735,
-0.4786428213119507,
-0.23505878448486328,
-0.08376744389533997,
0.14223507046699524,
-0.6172589659690857,
0.6428137421607971,
0.10299891978502274,
0.49137213826179504,
-0.4556749761104584,
-0.4926755130290985,
-0.11519079655408859,
0.17372214794158936,
-0.6975528597831726,
0.987201988697052,
0.2886267602443695,
-1.1178926229476929,
0.5283859968185425,
-0.5499541163444519,
-0.004143060650676489,
-0.272600919008255,
-0.435177206993103,
-0.618687093257904,
0.2448417842388153,
0.17743760347366333,
0.39796343445777893,
-0.5151302218437195,
0.6051872968673706,
-0.6833914518356323,
-0.5971131324768066,
0.6398777961730957,
-0.4072536826133728,
0.9022232890129089,
0.07877717912197113,
-0.5788450241088867,
-0.17422029376029968,
-0.43886011838912964,
-0.26909124851226807,
0.05893845111131668,
0.04451817646622658,
-0.17203393578529358,
-0.01832048036158085,
-0.40186023712158203,
0.1267888993024826,
-0.03850420191884041,
-0.5019859671592712,
-0.35249921679496765,
-0.1670391857624054,
0.3711825907230377,
1.0412510633468628,
-0.49758872389793396,
0.5001261234283447,
-0.412972629070282,
0.8847447037696838,
0.05348896235227585,
0.42762491106987,
0.4381987452507019,
-0.7023213505744934,
-0.38262203335762024,
-0.4676424264907837,
0.4940023124217987,
0.6817800998687744,
-0.45554712414741516,
0.24198263883590698,
0.11953525990247726,
-0.3382927477359772,
-0.7432302832603455,
-0.13555499911308289,
0.4850582480430603,
0.5093931555747986,
0.1457478255033493,
-0.40618789196014404,
-0.6088373064994812,
-0.9537808299064636,
-0.6036211848258972,
-0.01567067578434944,
-0.3374766707420349,
0.2530972361564636,
0.3519670069217682,
0.004795901942998171,
0.9634913206100464,
-0.4518449008464813,
-0.4538780450820923,
-0.06580060720443726,
0.25614672899246216,
0.4575192332267761,
0.41480058431625366,
0.5925580263137817,
-0.6572299003601074,
-0.0913587138056755,
-0.39526280760765076,
-0.891225278377533,
-0.31635159254074097,
0.3526008129119873,
-0.18513506650924683,
-0.01182838436216116,
0.16099482774734497,
-0.5466940999031067,
0.7937068939208984,
0.5243101119995117,
-0.6234005689620972,
0.40182337164878845,
0.40067678689956665,
0.21736115217208862,
-0.5824467539787292,
-0.30160123109817505,
0.20244340598583221,
-0.22320616245269775,
-0.3659283220767975,
-0.655001163482666,
-0.16352534294128418,
0.0016001224284991622,
-0.32595184445381165,
0.4533645212650299,
-0.22330784797668457,
-0.6327787637710571,
-0.1345967799425125,
0.06396925449371338,
0.0054061636328697205,
0.10155323892831802,
-0.22506485879421234,
0.6710783243179321,
0.4548352062702179,
-0.2204868048429489,
0.06364831328392029,
0.17575225234031677,
-0.4592154324054718,
0.8689613938331604,
-0.6464898586273193,
-0.0787648856639862,
-0.5206401348114014,
0.6236815452575684,
-1.3507583141326904,
0.31382375955581665,
0.6100569367408752,
-0.6481541991233826,
-0.03131341561675072,
-0.19596709311008453,
-0.28867799043655396,
-0.41658636927604675,
-0.40778848528862,
0.715687096118927,
0.6174739599227905,
-0.11699356138706207,
0.28700053691864014,
0.37165361642837524,
-0.34564387798309326,
-0.6292659640312195,
-0.914425790309906,
-0.09297864139080048,
-0.805988609790802,
-0.3210037052631378,
0.22174201905727386,
-0.04552248865365982,
-0.6414178609848022,
-0.28543606400489807,
-0.11464665085077286,
0.04632517322897911,
0.27696990966796875,
0.4950333833694458,
0.005826243199408054,
0.005012331064790487,
0.23132911324501038,
0.2033521831035614,
-0.36226746439933777,
0.31340059638023376,
0.25143760442733765,
0.42401909828186035,
-0.05589017644524574,
-0.3477587401866913,
-0.4869396984577179,
0.20841340720653534,
-0.09618641436100006,
0.28960543870925903,
0.5366207361221313,
0.946882426738739,
-0.4012983739376068,
0.07374533265829086,
-0.5037630796432495,
-0.27074116468429565,
-0.4453136920928955,
0.05905697122216225,
-0.2664251923561096,
-0.9371767640113831,
0.5042840242385864,
-0.06243429705500603,
-0.315633088350296,
0.24761740863323212,
0.5266275405883789,
-0.3517703115940094,
1.2952804565429688,
0.6444129943847656,
-0.09035909175872803,
0.31168892979621887,
-0.09419169276952744,
0.22221851348876953,
-0.7538965940475464,
-0.3236391842365265,
-0.6119048595428467,
-0.7170505523681641,
-0.7908588647842407,
-0.46272340416908264,
0.3423994481563568,
0.19338218867778778,
-0.6666735410690308,
-0.4306958019733429,
-0.40955719351768494,
0.21418896317481995,
0.3555447459220886,
0.5323618054389954,
0.32001861929893494,
-0.0022118811029940844,
0.1241140067577362,
-0.4866868555545807,
-0.6462241411209106,
-0.6103509664535522,
1.1674762964248657,
0.601566731929779,
0.5491582751274109,
0.008233032189309597,
0.5511974692344666,
0.9295675754547119,
0.5249128937721252,
-0.547505259513855,
0.3948875665664673,
-0.32895538210868835,
-0.5940132737159729,
-0.25927114486694336,
-0.541971743106842,
-1.1179972887039185,
0.48164427280426025,
-0.0757158026099205,
-0.5205848813056946,
0.43651092052459717,
-0.13921912014484406,
-0.3380102813243866,
0.25575584173202515,
-0.5247977375984192,
0.5831223726272583,
-0.3103175759315491,
-0.0538320317864418,
-0.2891422510147095,
-0.5786423087120056,
0.8230410814285278,
-0.05221407860517502,
0.5340754985809326,
-0.777902364730835,
-0.08600969612598419,
0.599492073059082,
-0.1406765729188919,
1.1073274612426758,
-0.31649887561798096,
-0.5309724807739258,
-0.0074465107172727585,
0.08196720480918884,
-0.092093326151371,
0.3809623420238495,
-0.4994577467441559,
0.546649694442749,
-0.051963936537504196,
-0.6341657042503357,
-0.49281203746795654,
0.5857159495353699,
-0.8608716130256653,
-0.45449694991111755,
-0.5404229760169983,
-0.38201799988746643,
-0.10751395672559738,
-0.04322639852762222,
0.03316374868154526,
0.11794625967741013,
-0.18683023750782013,
-0.16766975820064545,
0.6753100752830505,
-0.6942605376243591,
0.25021952390670776,
0.35082727670669556,
-0.3239978849887848,
-0.5153729915618896,
0.2834635078907013,
0.06120250001549721,
0.029251201078295708,
0.2368573695421219,
0.25170549750328064,
-0.3304236829280853,
-0.23058928549289703,
-0.14447671175003052,
0.13848260045051575,
-0.5135430097579956,
-0.4680384397506714,
-0.5477983951568604,
0.10119474679231644,
-0.3925994336605072,
0.08960352838039398,
-0.1601393222808838,
-0.6516022682189941,
-0.39771631360054016,
-0.258677214384079,
0.47219324111938477,
0.6507440805435181,
-0.20217666029930115,
0.485623300075531,
-0.38379648327827454,
0.9021692872047424,
0.22640112042427063,
0.4379241466522217,
0.12994009256362915,
-0.40270715951919556,
0.21446089446544647,
0.2530694603919983,
-0.5195826888084412,
-0.8207046985626221,
0.41563665866851807,
-0.2808019816875458,
0.3411993980407715,
0.4014243185520172,
0.12754160165786743,
0.6339080333709717,
-0.23516413569450378,
0.7202380895614624,
0.5290979146957397,
-0.9075183272361755,
0.3483855426311493,
-0.2356327325105667,
-0.03416649252176285,
0.30955028533935547,
0.45639142394065857,
-0.33205127716064453,
-0.35871464014053345,
-0.593250572681427,
-0.5882241725921631,
0.8296378254890442,
0.3569066524505615,
-0.1350032240152359,
0.09739917516708374,
0.44471630454063416,
0.5046565532684326,
0.5855289101600647,
-0.8613864183425903,
-0.3269382119178772,
-0.15665513277053833,
-0.28069454431533813,
-0.12251343578100204,
-0.4015961289405823,
-0.21468102931976318,
-0.15473449230194092,
0.21832484006881714,
-0.01570618897676468,
0.5936985611915588,
0.10535574704408646,
0.07826629281044006,
-0.26041337847709656,
0.19508767127990723,
0.18782123923301697,
0.8792287111282349,
-0.3609216511249542,
0.18552620708942413,
0.44445645809173584,
-0.2042381465435028,
0.18275240063667297,
-0.03459298238158226,
-0.17398789525032043,
0.1248234361410141,
0.3197679817676544,
0.8069560527801514,
0.19963712990283966,
-0.587713360786438,
0.5341833829879761,
-0.3591068983078003,
-0.34418928623199463,
-0.52967369556427,
0.0079978471621871,
0.08581460267305374,
0.8996913433074951,
0.40570834279060364,
-0.29616859555244446,
0.5806344151496887,
-0.5808284282684326,
-0.1769416779279709,
0.48562413454055786,
-0.535711944103241,
-0.15526412427425385,
0.6472253799438477,
-0.09314293414354324,
-0.2698313891887665,
0.5320983529090881,
0.09806523472070694,
-0.530969500541687,
0.9686040282249451,
0.27799883484840393,
0.9406531453132629,
-0.12139441072940826,
0.6168822646141052,
0.04565136507153511,
0.18974103033542633,
-0.219495952129364,
0.5680985450744629,
0.1651495397090912,
-0.5043480396270752,
-0.22366225719451904,
-0.5098661780357361,
-0.3711937963962555,
-0.12120643258094788,
-0.6717062592506409,
0.36218196153640747,
-0.30763331055641174,
-0.7164425849914551,
-0.2337133139371872,
0.21941377222537994,
-0.644143283367157,
0.3431333303451538,
0.5402784943580627,
0.47383663058280945,
-0.6944374442100525,
0.23718729615211487,
0.4370167553424835,
-0.16542503237724304,
-0.17389200627803802,
-0.08187044411897659,
0.18293848633766174,
-1.0037117004394531,
0.5846267938613892,
0.26694250106811523,
0.1230415403842926,
-0.3064247667789459,
-0.4776791036128998,
-0.6992305517196655,
1.4096475839614868,
0.6016131043434143,
-0.6023670434951782,
0.16033096611499786,
0.4394170045852661,
0.3763784170150757,
-0.06583669036626816,
0.7869135737419128,
0.6815712451934814,
0.7139132618904114,
-0.3393210172653198,
-0.954490602016449,
0.11155356466770172,
0.022262733429670334,
0.11393069475889206,
-0.1333809792995453,
-0.8786903023719788,
0.9628446698188782,
-0.18117208778858185,
-0.027818797156214714,
0.10472793877124786,
0.5841957926750183,
0.7962955236434937,
0.9803133010864258,
0.5773894786834717,
0.4822321832180023,
1.0004897117614746,
-0.1358649730682373,
1.003254771232605,
0.29752129316329956,
0.20645073056221008,
0.7605858445167542,
-0.3951353430747986,
0.23839877545833588,
0.3691447079181671,
-0.722221314907074,
0.5083141922950745,
0.9559048414230347,
0.13512346148490906,
0.39817577600479126,
0.7624830007553101,
-0.1865120530128479,
-0.12230418622493744,
-0.29244840145111084,
-0.6073810458183289,
0.08729368448257446,
0.3642141819000244,
-0.3027491867542267,
-0.15408901870250702,
-0.0026279001031070948,
0.34027397632598877,
-0.0096336854621768,
-0.575684666633606,
0.5500017404556274,
0.6697027683258057,
-0.14926639199256897,
0.4430295526981354,
0.10513094067573547,
0.8286334276199341,
-0.1701655387878418,
0.021296991035342216,
-0.7245029211044312,
0.16999664902687073,
-0.41379961371421814,
-0.8892752528190613,
-0.09294584393501282,
0.2050175964832306,
-0.38067787885665894,
-0.18478995561599731,
0.9201487302780151,
-0.26918962597846985,
-0.7199785113334656,
0.42980584502220154,
0.6399998664855957,
0.30100730061531067,
-0.2699420750141144,
-0.9638426899909973,
0.003863721387460828,
-0.09310658276081085,
-0.1399562507867813,
0.7017330527305603,
1.0516893863677979,
-0.20009441673755646,
0.9735769033432007,
0.25337570905685425,
-0.03425021097064018,
0.07188555598258972,
0.2931819260120392,
0.648039698600769,
-0.925416886806488,
-0.3857124447822571,
-1.0337022542953491,
0.36495789885520935,
0.014561033807694912,
-0.09043702483177185,
0.6901335716247559,
0.33138954639434814,
0.4267919659614563,
0.011440299451351166,
0.7516452670097351,
0.31858471035957336,
0.7106884717941284,
-0.48214176297187805,
0.5801541805267334,
-0.4808429479598999,
0.2747856080532074,
-0.5658550262451172,
-0.8460901379585266,
-0.16867074370384216,
0.5225731730461121,
-0.5577769875526428,
0.18622922897338867,
0.4768410921096802,
0.45595332980155945,
0.11862188577651978,
0.35836148262023926,
0.0332142673432827,
0.18771590292453766,
0.21553778648376465,
0.6140304803848267,
1.471047043800354,
-0.3932211995124817,
0.42529261112213135,
-0.08384779095649719,
-0.23363575339317322,
0.0051916418597102165,
-0.9874429702758789,
-0.913244366645813,
0.161723330616951,
-0.2956811189651489,
-0.15773142874240875,
0.2650001347064972,
0.43251851201057434,
0.26762670278549194,
-0.6052532196044922,
-0.3936214745044708,
0.1319969743490219,
0.5887258052825928,
-0.057905811816453934,
-0.26460182666778564,
0.24645408987998962,
-0.16775640845298767,
-0.5328826904296875,
-0.06615560501813889,
-0.06826939433813095,
-0.09924471378326416,
-0.23003807663917542,
-0.19641514122486115,
0.22786177694797516,
-0.22050751745700836,
0.6477673053741455,
-0.5464780926704407,
-0.6833665370941162,
0.171355739235878,
-0.47587114572525024,
-0.01682288944721222,
0.09713369607925415,
0.8571794033050537,
-1.0600805282592773,
-0.29734382033348083,
0.4046206772327423,
0.2820284068584442,
0.2632763087749481,
0.28416529297828674,
0.7437477111816406,
-0.24664773046970367,
-0.07989101111888885,
0.15618805587291718,
0.1667444407939911,
0.3353182077407837,
-0.6138046383857727,
0.8371407985687256,
0.09288305044174194,
-0.5910593271255493,
-1.0749542713165283,
-0.16940991580486298,
-0.685158908367157,
-0.532622754573822,
1.0445361137390137,
-0.05297943577170372,
0.04311090335249901,
-0.24615442752838135,
-0.4940333962440491,
0.36488765478134155,
-0.694341778755188,
1.100631594657898,
0.5989457964897156,
-0.22267286479473114,
-0.2164199948310852,
-0.8760277628898621,
0.5631992816925049,
0.7363377213478088,
-0.557101309299469,
-0.14284224808216095,
0.4307217597961426,
0.10651423782110214,
-0.4744737446308136,
0.7234593629837036,
-0.31309089064598083,
0.1133246198296547,
-0.38006168603897095,
0.08658643811941147,
0.44117632508277893,
0.21063204109668732,
-0.5326748490333557,
0.09800691902637482,
-0.13476526737213135,
0.054391082376241684
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.08173v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.08173v1
|
Semi-Supervised Spoken Language Glossification
| 2024-06-12T13:05:27 | 2024-06-12T13:05:27 |
Huijie Yao, Wengang Zhou, Hao Zhou, Houqiang Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Spoken language glossification (SLG) aims to translate the spoken language
text into the sign language gloss, i.e., a written record of sign language. In
this work, we present a framework named $S$emi-$S$upervised $S$poken $L$anguage
$G$lossification ($S^3$LG) for SLG. To tackle the bottleneck of limited
parallel data in SLG, our $S^3$LG incorporates large-scale monolingual spoken
language text into SLG training. The proposed framework follows the
self-training structure that iteratively annotates and learns from pseudo
labels. Considering the lexical similarity and syntactic difference between
sign language and spoken language, our $S^3$LG adopts both the rule-based
heuristic and model-based approach for auto-annotation. During training, we
randomly mix these complementary synthetic datasets and mark their differences
with a special token. As the synthetic data may be less quality, the $S^3$LG
further leverages consistency regularization to reduce the negative impact of
noise in the synthetic data. Extensive experiments are conducted on public
benchmarks to demonstrate the effectiveness of the $S^3$LG. Our code is
available at \url{https://github.com/yaohj11/S3LG}.
|
[
0.07902752608060837,
-0.5261467695236206,
0.4649248421192169,
0.23207740485668182,
-0.17578500509262085,
0.10219626128673553,
-0.3265478014945984,
-0.30436065793037415,
0.3215031325817108,
0.46598002314567566,
-0.47202613949775696,
-0.8744730949401855,
-0.5619540810585022,
0.15724773705005646,
-0.4377982020378113,
0.9740318059921265,
-0.04304909706115723,
0.02281198650598526,
0.3021329641342163,
0.015877438709139824,
-0.05169293284416199,
-0.22212952375411987,
-0.8540953397750854,
-0.16434237360954285,
0.0851169005036354,
0.49225053191185,
0.7479429244995117,
0.9058685302734375,
-0.021244827657938004,
0.1730014532804489,
-0.08555471897125244,
0.15259817242622375,
-0.6275229454040527,
-0.13886608183383942,
0.3107347786426544,
-0.3906129002571106,
-0.4021970331668854,
0.16103702783584595,
0.8800846934318542,
0.6601207256317139,
-0.43025726079940796,
0.212616965174675,
-0.13875454664230347,
0.5279601812362671,
-0.2997109591960907,
0.4583985507488251,
-0.38863587379455566,
0.04659019783139229,
-0.498124361038208,
0.2843472957611084,
-0.42167121171951294,
-0.27031248807907104,
-0.20303811132907867,
-0.8110573887825012,
0.19815026223659515,
0.10994185507297516,
0.9369075894355774,
0.39986810088157654,
-0.19751666486263275,
-0.1026519313454628,
-0.7985014915466309,
0.685207724571228,
-1.0452840328216553,
0.5948852896690369,
0.26736244559288025,
0.2682666480541229,
0.2165716290473938,
-0.6685652732849121,
-0.5338700413703918,
-0.16937966644763947,
-0.2962607741355896,
0.4118224084377289,
0.05023001506924629,
0.3689572513103485,
0.2867608666419983,
0.6809453964233398,
-0.5869185328483582,
0.2448166459798813,
-0.615249514579773,
-0.48413917422294617,
0.9127909541130066,
-0.18741893768310547,
0.25943002104759216,
-0.12569141387939453,
-0.42782318592071533,
0.2098393589258194,
-0.9150916337966919,
-0.49367663264274597,
0.11981353163719177,
0.6548619270324707,
-0.20405423641204834,
0.2931009829044342,
-0.16956235468387604,
0.9091614484786987,
0.04729409143328667,
-0.3041350841522217,
0.44925224781036377,
-0.3686182498931885,
-0.2450864166021347,
0.19607944786548615,
0.9341683983802795,
0.39656683802604675,
0.15146249532699585,
-0.04998910799622536,
-0.2855076193809509,
-0.22732678055763245,
-0.195724219083786,
-0.4200647473335266,
0.07439129799604416,
-0.022313009947538376,
-0.3551255166530609,
-0.001920012873597443,
-0.14541825652122498,
-0.2955605089664459,
-0.4934241473674774,
-0.4833693206310272,
0.4437485337257385,
-0.2693765163421631,
-0.1303258091211319,
0.3414996266365051,
0.2162434160709381,
0.07280378043651581,
0.438150554895401,
-0.7779145240783691,
0.1181526780128479,
0.35540273785591125,
0.9473124742507935,
-0.4095146954059601,
-0.21313373744487762,
-0.4098798632621765,
0.5030293464660645,
-0.15257595479488373,
0.3056003153324127,
-0.10060200095176697,
-0.3182143270969391,
0.05272756889462471,
-0.11211108416318893,
-0.25820204615592957,
-0.46730783581733704,
0.31364378333091736,
-0.2051156610250473,
0.29797816276550293,
0.2648400068283081,
-0.6803439855575562,
-0.10573176294565201,
-0.1950162947177887,
-0.5252352952957153,
1.4039280414581299,
0.2366548627614975,
-0.40803080797195435,
0.5037111639976501,
-0.5715213418006897,
-0.5909898281097412,
0.4761382043361664,
-0.4983854591846466,
-0.605893075466156,
-0.11920350790023804,
0.03209048509597778,
0.6105784773826599,
-0.332148939371109,
0.3128998577594757,
0.019849946722388268,
-0.4091239273548126,
-0.47470301389694214,
0.10336590558290482,
0.6199077367782593,
0.3235323429107666,
-0.6325691342353821,
0.06302158534526825,
-1.0341708660125732,
-0.23774856328964233,
-0.04291593283414841,
-0.24497318267822266,
-0.13059040904045105,
-0.1885368525981903,
-0.0962943285703659,
-0.0521407276391983,
0.4367705285549164,
-0.6779125332832336,
0.19469985365867615,
-0.4523695409297943,
0.15132740139961243,
0.6187769174575806,
-0.0852416530251503,
0.4938686192035675,
0.12489207834005356,
0.4333361089229584,
-0.11273261904716492,
0.38323307037353516,
0.21586723625659943,
-0.5058247447013855,
-1.019137978553772,
-0.2948787808418274,
0.1783817708492279,
0.5137149095535278,
-0.6547767519950867,
0.33325809240341187,
-0.17248547077178955,
-0.43190574645996094,
-0.6254003047943115,
0.38943415880203247,
0.5794141292572021,
0.25518134236335754,
0.3364776074886322,
0.01073882170021534,
-0.5126088261604309,
-1.0300929546356201,
-0.1764698177576065,
-0.24641111493110657,
-0.10400909185409546,
0.10322321206331253,
0.10635049641132355,
-0.29351264238357544,
0.6461401581764221,
-0.37788134813308716,
-0.8063430786132812,
-0.27732083201408386,
0.3165546655654907,
0.37238600850105286,
0.2682986557483673,
0.31773489713668823,
-0.5969603061676025,
-0.8447791934013367,
0.15106989443302155,
-0.6928983926773071,
-0.44677603244781494,
-0.3206566274166107,
0.16186130046844482,
0.05803573876619339,
0.9755105376243591,
-0.170706644654274,
0.6082615256309509,
0.7064455151557922,
-0.031961590051651,
0.5334885716438293,
-0.14627261459827423,
-0.10246244072914124,
-0.9573513865470886,
-0.23409689962863922,
-0.04298976808786392,
-0.42314520478248596,
-1.1513760089874268,
-0.24850942194461823,
-0.00494192773476243,
-0.3470090627670288,
-0.5324504375457764,
0.4836743474006653,
-0.7312347888946533,
-0.1328834891319275,
-0.2142760157585144,
0.46073877811431885,
-0.2685237228870392,
0.4581880271434784,
0.17969977855682373,
1.0182794332504272,
1.051115870475769,
-0.7092389464378357,
0.15998761355876923,
0.1273740828037262,
0.032416779547929764,
0.28765758872032166,
-0.5736650228500366,
0.08760839700698853,
-0.03613460808992386,
-0.06431920826435089,
-0.6681869626045227,
-0.1405179351568222,
0.3913766145706177,
-0.04631522297859192,
0.5231042504310608,
-0.032645631581544876,
-0.43055570125579834,
-0.14361843466758728,
-0.039008527994155884,
0.3631049692630768,
0.3306131362915039,
-0.5208939909934998,
1.0798307657241821,
0.6538425087928772,
0.11320802569389343,
-0.14957429468631744,
-0.8627213835716248,
0.21611501276493073,
-0.11401201039552689,
-0.44917675852775574,
0.20592528581619263,
-0.031132569536566734,
0.015269008465111256,
-0.5997357368469238,
-0.1245151087641716,
0.5115422010421753,
-0.15511958301067352,
0.24687284231185913,
-0.04601140692830086,
0.03431054204702377,
0.2567625343799591,
-0.19700466096401215,
-0.22389817237854004,
-0.24593812227249146,
-0.35312584042549133,
0.25944775342941284,
-0.4873582422733307,
-0.38099005818367004,
-0.618318498134613,
0.17113758623600006,
0.2079521119594574,
0.08323589712381363,
0.5887239575386047,
0.5529865622520447,
-0.2563081979751587,
-0.40842726826667786,
-0.3400558829307556,
0.08671991527080536,
-0.45790937542915344,
0.028573771938681602,
-0.4217987060546875,
-1.0755611658096313,
0.5738085508346558,
-0.11133894324302673,
0.05191044881939888,
0.42879730463027954,
0.4420192837715149,
-0.09092386066913605,
0.9610348343849182,
0.5871765613555908,
-0.12398026883602142,
0.46309956908226013,
-0.2580416202545166,
0.3664511740207672,
-0.5520883798599243,
-0.09350721538066864,
-0.08579611033201218,
0.15332213044166565,
-0.4441799521446228,
-0.5943266153335571,
0.5723206996917725,
0.14566129446029663,
0.11633632332086563,
0.7423601150512695,
-0.4788680374622345,
0.11836275458335876,
0.49046170711517334,
0.03373083844780922,
0.1822148859500885,
-0.26918908953666687,
0.08748047053813934,
0.2068578153848648,
-0.827345609664917,
-0.4140346348285675,
0.9263061285018921,
0.47601088881492615,
0.8401490449905396,
0.12883661687374115,
1.1274300813674927,
0.6353817582130432,
0.4991963803768158,
-0.6142958998680115,
0.8769152164459229,
-0.15015920996665955,
-0.4226149022579193,
-0.5896517038345337,
-0.460644006729126,
-0.684933602809906,
0.020424921065568924,
0.07619716227054596,
-0.7249304056167603,
0.028065867722034454,
0.4794602692127228,
-0.13438037037849426,
0.009715196676552296,
-0.8522621393203735,
0.7318323254585266,
-0.3091197907924652,
-0.06862890720367432,
0.03191646188497543,
-0.6867181658744812,
0.22875647246837616,
-0.27297618985176086,
0.4873815178871155,
-0.1332918107509613,
0.09403833746910095,
1.051216721534729,
-0.5248457193374634,
1.0165162086486816,
-0.31963175535202026,
-0.4974381625652313,
0.28876277804374695,
0.03156288340687752,
0.6181011199951172,
-0.005213735159486532,
-0.005792965181171894,
0.44883593916893005,
-0.25555863976478577,
-0.475622296333313,
-0.5168531537055969,
0.4208240807056427,
-0.5320282578468323,
-0.8097892999649048,
-0.5171369314193726,
-0.3100526034832001,
-0.27975237369537354,
0.4883985221385956,
0.049661751836538315,
0.22830936312675476,
0.0035168579779565334,
-0.2650148272514343,
0.5442115664482117,
0.031677935272455215,
0.14204256236553192,
0.5068709254264832,
-0.5769544839859009,
-0.34576448798179626,
0.9019984602928162,
-0.1481878012418747,
0.5779911875724792,
0.01163658406585455,
0.4149778187274933,
-0.35709401965141296,
-0.821761965751648,
-0.5002362132072449,
0.684174120426178,
-0.8768691420555115,
-0.1405327171087265,
-0.05219247564673424,
-0.2516804337501526,
-0.5504358410835266,
0.12958404421806335,
-0.46318164467811584,
-0.39954492449760437,
-0.4850260019302368,
-0.20100529491901398,
0.24552501738071442,
0.8696255087852478,
-0.41044187545776367,
0.8589369654655457,
-0.3122853934764862,
0.3016520142555237,
0.17144456505775452,
0.43232691287994385,
-0.4983118176460266,
-0.8214945197105408,
-0.578461229801178,
0.11604592204093933,
0.35155951976776123,
-0.7509245276451111,
-0.006393447984009981,
0.6615456342697144,
0.5883522033691406,
0.7485412359237671,
-0.2486603707075119,
0.7197139263153076,
-0.37897247076034546,
0.826564371585846,
0.42183446884155273,
-0.9969795346260071,
0.6049342751502991,
-0.44993725419044495,
0.40262702107429504,
0.7861277461051941,
0.27365437150001526,
-0.7568411827087402,
-0.7582406401634216,
-0.6450845003128052,
-0.8246656656265259,
0.9079025387763977,
0.3348258137702942,
-0.3015962541103363,
-0.04376661032438278,
0.3095281720161438,
0.10128658264875412,
0.09607323259115219,
-1.0379427671432495,
-0.6607338190078735,
-0.178981214761734,
-0.11951828002929688,
-0.3824712336063385,
-0.07312272489070892,
-0.29438379406929016,
-0.10199014097452164,
1.0879100561141968,
-0.20196394622325897,
-0.014851336367428303,
0.06885221600532532,
-0.2706329822540283,
0.13435664772987366,
-0.09384717047214508,
0.5191299915313721,
0.22251169383525848,
-0.17737846076488495,
0.3396901786327362,
0.11620273441076279,
-0.40121161937713623,
0.09787046164274216,
0.12495622038841248,
-0.773693859577179,
0.1588791012763977,
0.2530795633792877,
1.1175676584243774,
0.1760779619216919,
-0.362885445356369,
0.6053361296653748,
0.15746065974235535,
-0.37318655848503113,
-0.32201433181762695,
-0.11255116015672684,
-0.11795143783092499,
-0.1314096450805664,
0.20303793251514435,
-0.24384252727031708,
0.28588157892227173,
-0.37799444794654846,
0.25997161865234375,
0.07476556301116943,
-0.31506097316741943,
-0.12866179645061493,
0.6485044956207275,
0.14576786756515503,
-0.32486891746520996,
-0.007889087311923504,
-0.420538067817688,
-0.7064891457557678,
-0.05147286504507065,
0.3321472406387329,
0.7883989214897156,
-0.36057281494140625,
0.4533873498439789,
0.5296447277069092,
0.2720453441143036,
-0.23812726140022278,
0.28291094303131104,
-0.3852916657924652,
-0.5394369959831238,
-0.30950239300727844,
-0.7972579002380371,
-0.26009315252304077,
0.18337658047676086,
-0.4108128249645233,
0.3049149215221405,
-0.3600725531578064,
-0.10016248375177383,
-0.10246548801660538,
-0.4411797523498535,
-0.3596901595592499,
0.43622374534606934,
0.5534695982933044,
0.6484403014183044,
-1.2553950548171997,
0.46105921268463135,
0.4135534465312958,
-0.39749032258987427,
-0.8988134860992432,
-0.03822248801589012,
0.005645085126161575,
-1.0730929374694824,
0.5422356128692627,
0.12308643013238907,
-0.5784962773323059,
0.27398622035980225,
-0.2698797583580017,
-1.1543846130371094,
1.000352382659912,
0.0004957548226229846,
-0.6096974015235901,
0.23697488009929657,
0.5647223591804504,
0.5675545334815979,
-0.3954436480998993,
0.13012433052062988,
0.9152870774269104,
0.5837236642837524,
0.07085642218589783,
-1.1987025737762451,
0.12898573279380798,
0.01951872929930687,
0.2077360302209854,
0.1966247856616974,
-0.7785853147506714,
0.20522737503051758,
-0.042896680533885956,
-0.9413970708847046,
-0.17162320017814636,
0.9616134762763977,
0.13605256378650665,
0.3454159200191498,
0.6839898228645325,
0.5141197443008423,
0.7188808917999268,
-0.36949238181114197,
0.5117500424385071,
-0.44817596673965454,
0.3940889835357666,
1.025951862335205,
-0.19888953864574432,
0.30084118247032166,
0.5876158475875854,
-0.2677498757839203,
0.29379570484161377,
0.6157994866371155,
-0.027778295800089836,
0.38325202465057373,
0.4200585186481476,
-0.3795214295387268,
-0.16759246587753296,
0.05197843909263611,
0.043632879853248596,
0.5379021167755127,
0.3699783980846405,
-0.30934205651283264,
-0.44241464138031006,
0.3892708420753479,
0.1276685893535614,
0.20628276467323303,
-0.4499671161174774,
0.7677110433578491,
0.02717478759586811,
-0.388378769159317,
0.9682510495185852,
-0.13349564373493195,
0.577153205871582,
-0.6601274013519287,
0.29731228947639465,
-0.2526775300502777,
-0.061932992190122604,
-0.33443623781204224,
-0.6329977512359619,
0.08004885911941528,
-0.36358532309532166,
0.40629494190216064,
-0.7497552633285522,
0.5600383877754211,
-0.7827568054199219,
-0.349182665348053,
0.34263506531715393,
0.2807312607765198,
0.7156614661216736,
0.3533145487308502,
-0.8080363869667053,
0.14451076090335846,
0.27960026264190674,
-0.2871344983577728,
-0.11792252957820892,
0.2011204957962036,
-0.08982835710048676,
0.7237803936004639,
0.3757680654525757,
0.5000824928283691,
0.23300674557685852,
0.8686372637748718,
0.6425351500511169,
-0.45911628007888794,
-0.6314032077789307,
-0.37027084827423096,
0.30232319235801697,
-0.23372405767440796,
-0.14954353868961334,
1.175167441368103,
0.9256812334060669,
0.7470768094062805,
-0.10046138614416122,
0.8841383457183838,
-0.16051563620567322,
0.6707231998443604,
-0.6253376603126526,
0.43632587790489197,
-0.6246460676193237,
0.3743041157722473,
-0.1298050433397293,
-0.7615087628364563,
-0.6187872886657715,
0.4217698872089386,
-0.2752290666103363,
0.0939849317073822,
0.501835286617279,
1.139731764793396,
0.06139754131436348,
-0.06846502423286438,
0.5953919887542725,
0.2285481095314026,
0.183302640914917,
0.2803100645542145,
0.47970691323280334,
-0.6050865650177002,
0.4713568091392517,
-0.1319350302219391,
-0.5076785087585449,
-0.19103191792964935,
-0.7509697675704956,
-0.8895593881607056,
-0.8613013029098511,
-0.6390953063964844,
-0.30180129408836365,
0.02588142827153206,
0.34406206011772156,
0.8368082642555237,
-0.8133635520935059,
-0.46975138783454895,
-0.3468471169471741,
-0.3040366768836975,
-0.17624370753765106,
-0.2507544457912445,
0.5515477657318115,
-0.17651361227035522,
-0.5747597813606262,
0.7357696294784546,
0.4881400167942047,
0.31831079721450806,
-0.3288731276988983,
-0.28217437863349915,
-0.33431342244148254,
-0.11890625953674316,
0.39320704340934753,
0.5135284066200256,
-0.6837531328201294,
-0.4666469693183899,
-0.4195728302001953,
-0.0832434892654419,
0.04317865148186684,
0.6422541737556458,
-0.37162354588508606,
0.6187578439712524,
0.01419053040444851,
0.19989681243896484,
1.0198814868927002,
0.14889703691005707,
0.5865962505340576,
-1.0393238067626953,
0.06682858616113663,
0.21086572110652924,
0.282641738653183,
0.5682135820388794,
-0.43382057547569275,
0.5127721428871155,
0.2896788716316223,
-0.48529061675071716,
-0.7124513387680054,
0.5134121775627136,
-1.0389567613601685,
0.10035837441682816,
1.5889194011688232,
-0.004171623848378658,
-0.32474181056022644,
-0.20426803827285767,
-0.17030681669712067,
0.4888368844985962,
-0.2828916311264038,
0.6455250978469849,
0.43186333775520325,
-0.3809964656829834,
-0.3783840835094452,
-0.19466863572597504,
1.1447747945785522,
0.38535091280937195,
-0.759941577911377,
0.4844648540019989,
0.41100013256073,
0.064015693962574,
0.37729310989379883,
0.8178764581680298,
0.02993178181350231,
0.23116421699523926,
-0.22296719253063202,
0.5375152230262756,
-0.09033464640378952,
-0.23998290300369263,
-0.5096697807312012,
-0.38090386986732483,
-0.04053907096385956,
-0.13770653307437897
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.08155v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.08155v1
|
Examining Post-Training Quantization for Mixture-of-Experts: A Benchmark
| 2024-06-12T12:44:48 | 2024-06-12T12:44:48 |
Pingzhi Li, Xiaolong Jin, Yu Cheng, Tianlong Chen
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Large Language Models~(LLMs) have become foundational in the realm of natural
language processing, demonstrating performance improvements as model sizes
increase. The Mixture-of-Experts~(MoE) approach offers a promising way to scale
LLMs more efficiently by using fewer computational FLOPs through sparse
activation. However, it suffers from significant memory overheads,
necessitating model compression techniques. Post-training quantization, a
popular method for model compression, proves less effective when directly
applied to MoE models due to MoE's overlooked inherent sparsity. This paper
explores several MoE structure-aware quantization heuristics, ranging from
coarse to fine granularity, from MoE block to individual linear weight. Our
investigations reveal critical principles: different MoE structures (i.e.,
blocks, experts, linear layers) require varying numbers of weight bits for
effective and efficient quantization. Conclusions are supported by extensive
benchmarking across two representative MoE models and six tasks. We further
introduce novel enhancements to more accurately identify the most critical
weights in MoE quantization that necessitate higher bit allocations, including
the linear weight outlier scorer and MoE block scorer. Additionally, subsequent
experiments validate our findings in the context of both weight and activation
quantization.
|
[
-0.5770956873893738,
-0.7092790007591248,
0.47431543469429016,
0.17685778439044952,
-0.2829183340072632,
0.2757592797279358,
-0.38774144649505615,
-0.2272033542394638,
0.01662340573966503,
0.21736307442188263,
-0.17403994500637054,
-0.2676200866699219,
-0.9296877384185791,
0.02679571323096752,
-0.33505067229270935,
0.714053750038147,
-0.016644787043333054,
-0.06495267897844315,
-0.3175366222858429,
-0.21860520541667938,
-0.5326747894287109,
-0.5812406539916992,
-0.45463666319847107,
-0.11267637461423874,
0.30405929684638977,
0.07824902981519699,
0.7649358510971069,
0.6763052940368652,
0.41014841198921204,
0.2876377999782562,
-0.26856765151023865,
0.2435871660709381,
-0.4881364107131958,
0.1483134776353836,
0.0734148696064949,
-0.6289103031158447,
-0.6466435194015503,
-0.09674085676670074,
0.6524465084075928,
0.8248519897460938,
-0.5133107900619507,
-0.1428985595703125,
0.1048106700181961,
0.5390307903289795,
-1.00471031665802,
-0.03326227888464928,
-0.8914775252342224,
0.047843869775533676,
-0.2532060742378235,
-0.3040456473827362,
-0.25236430764198303,
-0.1665668785572052,
0.17094728350639343,
-0.5053437352180481,
0.1466793417930603,
0.03239921107888222,
0.7789739370346069,
0.5385726690292358,
-0.4690028727054596,
-0.0024035139940679073,
-0.45673760771751404,
1.0398765802383423,
-0.8161728978157043,
0.3604886829853058,
0.5121103525161743,
0.18581531941890717,
-0.153710275888443,
-0.16469042003154755,
-0.2808118462562561,
0.06474144756793976,
0.12574143707752228,
-0.10550610721111298,
-0.1154157966375351,
0.23142163455486298,
-0.003015701426193118,
0.7789211869239807,
-0.39768725633621216,
0.05456151068210602,
-0.14120149612426758,
-0.0770091637969017,
0.6277568936347961,
-0.05572882294654846,
-0.012082981877028942,
0.07364106923341751,
-0.41892844438552856,
-0.16507573425769806,
-0.5895897746086121,
-0.0859694555401802,
0.37884223461151123,
-0.07436762750148773,
0.11596055328845978,
0.3885459899902344,
-0.358474999666214,
0.7393216490745544,
0.13131771981716156,
0.02198212221264839,
0.09485751390457153,
-0.22816424071788788,
-0.13755644857883453,
-0.013336841948330402,
0.8855529427528381,
0.1383315920829773,
0.4816417396068573,
-0.33075085282325745,
-0.5742039084434509,
-0.20714718103408813,
0.2812865078449249,
-0.8979941606521606,
-0.5725112557411194,
0.24645692110061646,
-0.28277528285980225,
-0.2534716725349426,
-0.06899145990610123,
-0.3148818612098694,
-0.2538096308708191,
-0.3452873229980469,
0.8165519833564758,
-0.5919527411460876,
-0.49390554428100586,
0.3211449682712555,
-0.13963532447814941,
-0.09334982931613922,
0.19358469545841217,
-0.9750438928604126,
0.3646264970302582,
0.8470632433891296,
0.6284074783325195,
0.07729310542345047,
0.144148051738739,
-0.6159631609916687,
0.06078934296965599,
-0.44642993807792664,
0.8452311754226685,
-0.581251323223114,
-0.4902878999710083,
-0.28432342410087585,
-0.8798490166664124,
0.009476974606513977,
-0.8732325434684753,
0.321024090051651,
-0.5413409471511841,
-0.005811979994177818,
-0.29583027958869934,
-0.7338832020759583,
-0.0936865359544754,
0.30913370847702026,
-0.3679817020893097,
1.4042266607284546,
0.32613423466682434,
-0.5707827210426331,
0.5662180185317993,
-0.2116766721010208,
-0.35914885997772217,
0.11674326658248901,
-0.45676299929618835,
-0.25839918851852417,
0.6970292329788208,
0.3683212995529175,
0.7166715860366821,
-0.19833393394947052,
0.5774425268173218,
-0.266126811504364,
-0.38234564661979675,
0.5822333693504333,
-0.529326319694519,
0.46811196208000183,
0.06056402623653412,
-0.11186600476503372,
0.06583889573812485,
-0.9121001958847046,
0.14540672302246094,
-0.15002413094043732,
-0.49447140097618103,
-0.5133021473884583,
0.095144122838974,
-0.22557120025157928,
-0.048584502190351486,
0.25408947467803955,
-0.09567763656377792,
0.15952368080615997,
-0.30927595496177673,
0.580504298210144,
0.8857759833335876,
-0.04822712391614914,
0.5329713821411133,
-0.17643848061561584,
0.1961810439825058,
0.014198040589690208,
-0.008649768307805061,
-0.19427579641342163,
-0.46452343463897705,
-0.8060719966888428,
-0.5986442565917969,
0.6531448364257812,
0.316223680973053,
-0.773742139339447,
0.8593050241470337,
-0.5231570601463318,
-0.27660155296325684,
-0.667911171913147,
0.3101784288883209,
0.45163026452064514,
0.18906354904174805,
0.3609922528266907,
-0.5743719935417175,
-0.3483548164367676,
-0.9691701531410217,
-0.35651928186416626,
0.049061037600040436,
-0.2150522619485855,
0.03695502504706383,
0.36658531427383423,
0.13942906260490417,
1.2210432291030884,
-0.4092104732990265,
0.12223612517118454,
0.10379666090011597,
0.49401649832725525,
-0.02648295648396015,
0.6200357675552368,
0.3415709137916565,
-0.6422911882400513,
-0.4892900586128235,
-0.08024201542139053,
-0.5781254172325134,
-0.1375659853219986,
-0.012220562435686588,
-0.26397621631622314,
-0.06535651534795761,
0.3861101567745209,
-0.5697893500328064,
0.35877135396003723,
0.4851035475730896,
0.12580786645412445,
0.32208558917045593,
-0.31571754813194275,
0.026781318709254265,
-0.9395360350608826,
-0.2944123446941376,
0.09111151844263077,
-0.42501020431518555,
-0.4521857500076294,
0.3940543830394745,
0.0628470629453659,
0.19765833020210266,
-0.14582785964012146,
0.36815372109413147,
-0.7416794300079346,
-0.1418851613998413,
-0.4234432876110077,
-0.08912860602140427,
-0.07509785890579224,
0.6291983127593994,
0.09769190847873688,
0.8536101579666138,
0.6432989835739136,
-0.6060643792152405,
0.08882781118154526,
-0.21150483191013336,
-0.6425435543060303,
0.6772879362106323,
-0.7391817569732666,
0.15453538298606873,
-0.042883824557065964,
-0.01648404635488987,
-0.9801411032676697,
-0.1268330216407776,
0.09496784210205078,
-0.35709547996520996,
0.5243793725967407,
-0.09332100301980972,
-0.8768979907035828,
0.01263677328824997,
-0.41303011775016785,
0.6794710755348206,
0.8101736903190613,
0.022717177867889404,
0.6932995915412903,
0.30832773447036743,
-0.18182644248008728,
-0.308758944272995,
-0.6167930960655212,
0.11855972558259964,
-0.2559407651424408,
-0.6536205410957336,
0.39309656620025635,
-0.17331743240356445,
-0.39297956228256226,
0.015174215659499168,
-0.32311955094337463,
-0.43683135509490967,
0.37942150235176086,
-0.08738040924072266,
-0.16497229039669037,
-0.36735373735427856,
-0.07674731314182281,
0.40706104040145874,
-0.22549983859062195,
-0.07891158759593964,
-0.12471530586481094,
0.592519998550415,
-0.09748563170433044,
-0.11769947409629822,
-0.320773184299469,
0.39504238963127136,
0.1454557329416275,
-0.34255340695381165,
0.8134342432022095,
0.7419152855873108,
-0.42639681696891785,
-0.02375929243862629,
-0.8635536432266235,
-0.2046246975660324,
-0.4652854800224304,
0.41452187299728394,
-0.39107587933540344,
-0.8080573081970215,
0.35479509830474854,
0.04755422845482826,
0.09515872597694397,
0.20261770486831665,
0.5322275757789612,
-0.07999222725629807,
0.8590269088745117,
0.47767373919487,
-0.1121651753783226,
0.528751015663147,
-0.18601715564727783,
0.23428361117839813,
-0.9176540970802307,
0.1980149745941162,
-0.32037946581840515,
-0.487203449010849,
-0.09403734654188156,
-0.7612139582633972,
0.5026388168334961,
0.6779926419258118,
0.06795251369476318,
0.320448100566864,
-0.32999542355537415,
0.5771827101707458,
0.5615601539611816,
0.23280726373195648,
0.22948139905929565,
0.13262978196144104,
0.3189961016178131,
0.06239477917551994,
-0.8959298133850098,
-0.23768489062786102,
1.148116946220398,
0.2153000682592392,
0.5177949666976929,
-0.023827899247407913,
0.7469667196273804,
0.10340568423271179,
0.342457115650177,
-0.8346072435379028,
0.5796020030975342,
0.006223746109753847,
-0.5813724994659424,
-0.2628149092197418,
-0.6249243021011353,
-0.7435362935066223,
0.6566022038459778,
-0.36248311400413513,
-0.5259962677955627,
0.2772753834724426,
0.23724113404750824,
-0.7176227569580078,
0.14839941263198853,
-0.7748661041259766,
0.5476709008216858,
-0.0367950014770031,
-0.1381428986787796,
-0.4224771559238434,
-0.5992766618728638,
0.32027357816696167,
-0.1462438404560089,
0.3628064692020416,
-0.1276414841413498,
-0.29179486632347107,
0.6315822005271912,
-0.6503143310546875,
0.6649572849273682,
0.1140715703368187,
-0.262504905462265,
0.2746589183807373,
0.0782073587179184,
0.46203872561454773,
-0.13778060674667358,
-0.04169381037354469,
0.3069790005683899,
-0.3449092209339142,
-0.6486355066299438,
-0.6230881810188293,
0.37517452239990234,
-0.791252851486206,
-0.5139623880386353,
-0.0019319169223308563,
-0.7447842359542847,
-0.4272805452346802,
-0.06967388838529587,
0.3390944302082062,
0.6940151453018188,
0.3835483491420746,
0.5937114953994751,
1.093693494796753,
0.02554008550941944,
0.31784990429878235,
0.29456034302711487,
0.1880435049533844,
-0.5885375142097473,
1.0074729919433594,
0.3193986415863037,
0.27469074726104736,
0.643686056137085,
0.24699941277503967,
0.08908998221158981,
-0.9423521757125854,
-0.35550662875175476,
-0.047957826405763626,
-0.47829321026802063,
-0.26460692286491394,
-0.6983600854873657,
-0.10066276043653488,
-0.37185123562812805,
-0.15263909101486206,
-0.5725157260894775,
-0.3270144462585449,
-0.1840948760509491,
-0.03532221540808678,
0.26695650815963745,
0.3301483988761902,
0.21005463600158691,
0.7282090187072754,
-1.0138577222824097,
0.18149812519550323,
0.3128756284713745,
0.26124706864356995,
0.20500382781028748,
-0.4405069053173065,
-0.5248789191246033,
0.025856155902147293,
-0.24824556708335876,
-0.6295015811920166,
0.05527610704302788,
0.30935779213905334,
0.6237631440162659,
0.7894423007965088,
-0.07077246159315109,
0.89091557264328,
-0.47263407707214355,
0.6779956817626953,
0.021279921755194664,
-1.0011906623840332,
0.15262985229492188,
-0.33846110105514526,
-0.06191140413284302,
0.6297367811203003,
0.3224189281463623,
-0.08698587864637375,
-0.410667359828949,
-0.5927999019622803,
-1.112529993057251,
0.41086527705192566,
0.44171038269996643,
0.16095641255378723,
0.06321819871664047,
0.4230051040649414,
0.3046971261501312,
0.6826423406600952,
-0.6029216051101685,
-0.10396666824817657,
0.21748653054237366,
-0.3391362428665161,
0.09509682655334473,
-0.5432056784629822,
-0.025995535776019096,
-0.11410072445869446,
0.40381598472595215,
0.1859269142150879,
-0.10678724199533463,
-0.10359953343868256,
-0.43480217456817627,
-0.05656314641237259,
0.24188677966594696,
0.41902095079421997,
0.5751644372940063,
-0.29374343156814575,
0.04350268840789795,
0.022540217265486717,
-0.13927339017391205,
-0.01648174412548542,
0.035762425512075424,
-0.07277597486972809,
-0.10907858610153198,
0.5311210751533508,
0.8822668194770813,
0.7199774384498596,
-0.6428461074829102,
0.6308684945106506,
0.22437754273414612,
-0.24624492228031158,
0.12558509409427643,
0.3191794157028198,
-0.1752605140209198,
0.21953101456165314,
0.6053522229194641,
0.27236616611480713,
0.27318456768989563,
-0.4619811177253723,
-0.04913915693759918,
0.4279397428035736,
-0.05673585832118988,
-0.4270685613155365,
0.5129461288452148,
0.3412308990955353,
-0.06995169073343277,
0.3396850824356079,
-0.26892998814582825,
-0.5187739133834839,
0.361004501581192,
-0.06423485279083252,
0.7986518740653992,
-0.20814618468284607,
-0.18075323104858398,
-0.01828954555094242,
0.22706742584705353,
-0.3920172452926636,
0.12004653364419937,
-0.510061502456665,
-0.8109269738197327,
-0.6736042499542236,
-0.3826901316642761,
-0.2555435001850128,
-0.238636314868927,
-0.8761003017425537,
0.13850805163383484,
-0.4809446930885315,
-0.2576374411582947,
-0.3978685736656189,
-0.21564824879169464,
-0.5110776424407959,
0.17736385762691498,
0.1912880390882492,
0.7576137781143188,
-0.6163544654846191,
0.5837530493736267,
0.5858327746391296,
-0.06746484339237213,
-0.6692099571228027,
0.0017015165649354458,
-0.25989004969596863,
-0.8242779970169067,
0.38884687423706055,
0.0640556663274765,
0.2484462559223175,
0.08850787580013275,
-0.3338875472545624,
-0.7297898530960083,
0.8682703375816345,
0.2624446153640747,
-0.7293465733528137,
-0.13377869129180908,
-0.09685824066400528,
0.38656333088874817,
0.12426222860813141,
0.40381067991256714,
0.5258422493934631,
0.24576902389526367,
-0.03391677513718605,
-0.8077079057693481,
-0.12741632759571075,
-0.14699222147464752,
0.2380995750427246,
0.4400097727775574,
-0.656990110874176,
1.1878454685211182,
0.28982481360435486,
-0.11315331608057022,
0.18107160925865173,
1.009860634803772,
0.416378915309906,
0.07292528450489044,
0.638184666633606,
0.8142277002334595,
0.7264754176139832,
-0.02042142115533352,
1.101549506187439,
-0.5055550336837769,
0.27109596133232117,
0.8760692477226257,
-0.15052299201488495,
1.0197985172271729,
0.46817320585250854,
-0.5146008729934692,
0.3416001498699188,
0.7872809171676636,
0.36107704043388367,
0.5525238513946533,
0.34704339504241943,
-0.2959519922733307,
-0.5050686001777649,
0.11709843575954437,
-0.5859361886978149,
-0.0005178917781449854,
0.32462459802627563,
0.029031576588749886,
-0.13534902036190033,
-0.11162438243627548,
-0.025362491607666016,
-0.041353486478328705,
-0.45880183577537537,
0.7844876050949097,
0.17015159130096436,
-0.4010908901691437,
0.5437783598899841,
0.03563958406448364,
1.0916236639022827,
-0.5629367828369141,
0.2452419400215149,
-0.2856622636318207,
-0.052507806569337845,
-0.06134583801031113,
-0.6050591468811035,
0.07731447368860245,
-0.06608982384204865,
-0.17946934700012207,
-0.34782424569129944,
0.3691764771938324,
-0.5996307134628296,
-0.4645601809024811,
-0.22502699494361877,
0.4276033341884613,
0.26580995321273804,
-0.7394547462463379,
-0.38970693945884705,
0.02621499076485634,
-0.2670305371284485,
-0.437142014503479,
0.5020067095756531,
0.8617231845855713,
-0.08607081323862076,
0.560137152671814,
0.4115156829357147,
0.19320663809776306,
0.3250645399093628,
-0.040619634091854095,
0.8349803686141968,
-0.40904781222343445,
-0.5511638522148132,
-0.8984732031822205,
0.66192227602005,
0.08488255739212036,
-0.35295915603637695,
0.7142660021781921,
0.5840282440185547,
0.9398939609527588,
0.10354650765657425,
0.5210837721824646,
0.2655651867389679,
0.13654956221580505,
-0.7978470921516418,
0.47745630145072937,
-0.6776580810546875,
0.20494794845581055,
-0.2463551163673401,
-1.0393887758255005,
-0.1903531551361084,
0.6410179734230042,
-0.3061748445034027,
0.2171160876750946,
0.46739527583122253,
0.5507487654685974,
0.0016908146208152175,
-0.2419239580631256,
0.32978567481040955,
0.11106010526418686,
0.206434965133667,
0.575806200504303,
0.8968585729598999,
-0.49301180243492126,
0.6235321164131165,
-0.18496552109718323,
-0.1659172922372818,
-0.5154567360877991,
-0.7606339454650879,
-0.8557916283607483,
-0.33931365609169006,
-0.601548969745636,
0.16786225140094757,
-0.18981564044952393,
0.9811367988586426,
1.1094402074813843,
-0.6093371510505676,
-0.07497314363718033,
-0.07782667875289917,
0.007123681250959635,
-0.0972377136349678,
-0.25215283036231995,
0.14967885613441467,
-0.18629850447177887,
-0.7992473840713501,
0.3146023750305176,
0.46303591132164,
0.038711242377758026,
-0.3078489899635315,
-0.05944858863949776,
0.2480803281068802,
0.12492029368877411,
0.6553200483322144,
-0.23747149109840393,
-0.675441563129425,
0.015427472069859505,
-0.29906708002090454,
-0.08272382616996765,
0.17539556324481964,
0.9644954800605774,
-0.769821047782898,
0.3632078468799591,
0.6023746728897095,
0.8684358596801758,
0.03658674657344818,
0.22550912201404572,
0.6817232370376587,
-1.0884990692138672,
0.23388975858688354,
0.21840806305408478,
0.4540192186832428,
0.28908291459083557,
-0.3278535008430481,
0.39487987756729126,
0.2967068552970886,
-0.34347712993621826,
-1.101091742515564,
-0.0892823114991188,
-0.9246329665184021,
-0.34836068749427795,
0.8949466943740845,
-0.07474751025438309,
-0.14964644610881805,
0.14305560290813446,
-0.21597833931446075,
0.014854374341666698,
-0.6636129021644592,
0.7174031734466553,
1.0673166513442993,
0.0503048337996006,
-0.355448454618454,
-0.4091147780418396,
0.20489761233329773,
0.6617650389671326,
-0.59586101770401,
-0.2342732697725296,
0.22293001413345337,
0.16718420386314392,
-0.0336393341422081,
0.6899574398994446,
0.13297387957572937,
0.040577232837677,
0.037338197231292725,
0.09153328090906143,
-0.1170823872089386,
-0.2482907623052597,
-0.27395835518836975,
0.07962954044342041,
0.08216541260480881,
-0.10594967752695084
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.08124v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.08124v1
|
Legend: Leveraging Representation Engineering to Annotate Safety Margin for Preference Datasets
| 2024-06-12T12:06:32 | 2024-06-12T12:06:32 |
Duanyu Feng, Bowen Qin, Chen Huang, Youcheng Huang, Zheng Zhang, Wenqiang Lei
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The success of the reward model in distinguishing between responses with
subtle safety differences depends critically on the high-quality preference
dataset, which should capture the fine-grained nuances of harmful and harmless
responses. This motivates the need to develop a dataset involving preference
margins, which accurately quantify how harmless one response is compared to
another. In this paper, we take the first step to propose an effective and
cost-efficient framework to promote the margin-enhanced preference dataset
development. Our framework, Legend, Leverages representation engineering to
annotate preference datasets. It constructs the specific direction within the
LLM's embedding space that represents safety. By leveraging this safety
direction, Legend can then leverage the semantic distances of paired responses
along this direction to annotate margins automatically. We experimentally
demonstrate our effectiveness in both reward modeling and harmless alignment
for LLMs. Legend also stands out for its efficiency, requiring only the
inference time rather than additional training. This efficiency allows for
easier implementation and scalability, making Legend particularly valuable for
practical applications in aligning LLMs with safe conversations.
|
[
-0.18618738651275635,
-0.14523033797740936,
0.42558443546295166,
0.09269692748785019,
-0.29247575998306274,
0.07664504647254944,
-0.04986922815442085,
-0.35973650217056274,
0.6641678810119629,
0.6666178107261658,
-0.16688576340675354,
-0.6659953594207764,
-0.615557849407196,
-0.3161419630050659,
0.1671094000339508,
1.0211364030838013,
-0.05061079189181328,
-0.22110316157341003,
-0.18159861862659454,
-0.5044711828231812,
-0.7041963338851929,
-0.8188456296920776,
-0.5611417293548584,
-0.09016367793083191,
0.9122390747070312,
0.2975643575191498,
0.7704643607139587,
1.020505666732788,
0.3726373314857483,
0.16014912724494934,
0.12472663819789886,
0.1872224360704422,
-0.7038307785987854,
0.10142899304628372,
0.18331079185009003,
-0.43415024876594543,
-0.752659797668457,
0.2659396231174469,
0.14485087990760803,
0.6546351909637451,
0.25342491269111633,
0.04832988232374191,
0.4087817370891571,
0.7722671627998352,
-0.8612316846847534,
0.5607234239578247,
-0.2915753424167633,
-0.0030280810315161943,
-0.021431755274534225,
-0.47685930132865906,
-0.7519858479499817,
-0.7463147640228271,
-0.00016931432764977217,
-0.855476975440979,
-0.355722039937973,
0.10446544736623764,
0.7395148873329163,
0.4036864638328552,
-0.5451325178146362,
-0.18715406954288483,
-0.4156571626663208,
0.8019570112228394,
-0.28727447986602783,
0.2576691508293152,
0.3233521580696106,
0.5035374760627747,
0.0721319168806076,
-0.46127229928970337,
0.06296729296445847,
-0.37124380469322205,
-0.4146290421485901,
0.00004502532465266995,
-0.021225260570645332,
0.3697754740715027,
0.1056123748421669,
-0.25854530930519104,
-0.25780943036079407,
0.37672027945518494,
-0.14384429156780243,
-0.393522709608078,
1.0781563520431519,
0.060135576874017715,
0.10097131878137589,
-0.3499327301979065,
-0.6395890116691589,
-0.49249354004859924,
-1.080419898033142,
0.4750306308269501,
0.5132704973220825,
0.4640413224697113,
-0.1581483781337738,
0.5303136706352234,
-0.09375520795583725,
0.4560120701789856,
-0.26333150267601013,
-0.2117423266172409,
0.3606537878513336,
0.42045170068740845,
-0.09158250689506531,
0.4882794916629791,
0.6442769169807434,
1.2967172861099243,
0.2239832729101181,
-0.1311405748128891,
-0.3020904064178467,
0.14359278976917267,
0.37550753355026245,
-0.5560573935508728,
-0.28949683904647827,
0.00801929458975792,
-0.6466135382652283,
-0.7053066492080688,
-0.007468926254659891,
-0.7707946300506592,
-1.082203984260559,
-0.426974356174469,
0.439681738615036,
-0.2260666936635971,
-0.2756703197956085,
0.0999264195561409,
-0.110885389149189,
-0.032830413430929184,
0.22898156940937042,
-0.7916440367698669,
-0.12349098175764084,
0.7504981160163879,
0.5975138545036316,
-0.16080538928508759,
0.2390269935131073,
-0.7734586596488953,
0.4196687936782837,
-0.5312246084213257,
0.8952122926712036,
-0.4904516041278839,
-0.5057620406150818,
0.0712248757481575,
-0.004796319175511599,
0.29202041029930115,
-0.3875391483306885,
1.0637027025222778,
-0.3812466561794281,
-0.5974408984184265,
-0.6398236751556396,
-0.5997970104217529,
-0.4586584270000458,
0.153464674949646,
-0.8882867693901062,
0.609228789806366,
-0.16511580348014832,
-0.7296301126480103,
0.7718101143836975,
-0.5910271406173706,
-0.07200279831886292,
0.18541951477527618,
-0.5169358253479004,
-0.3039500415325165,
0.041475776582956314,
0.18671783804893494,
0.5467934608459473,
0.10893561691045761,
0.29236936569213867,
-0.7534507513046265,
-0.15255317091941833,
0.2494475394487381,
-0.3790469169616699,
0.5196004509925842,
0.0718383640050888,
-0.227401465177536,
0.291511595249176,
-0.4553215801715851,
-0.07058370113372803,
-0.0108379777520895,
-0.025442346930503845,
-0.8504016399383545,
0.05379236862063408,
0.08764076977968216,
-0.05164894834160805,
0.33968523144721985,
-0.3246699869632721,
0.12005652487277985,
-0.039088569581508636,
0.030226683244109154,
1.1958991289138794,
-0.11809350550174713,
0.6378082633018494,
-0.5773680806159973,
0.41477152705192566,
-0.32985949516296387,
0.35780972242355347,
0.14337602257728577,
-0.2900328040122986,
-0.6408091187477112,
-0.36027926206588745,
0.464073121547699,
0.46095502376556396,
-0.5190926194190979,
0.6337908506393433,
-0.3468010127544403,
-0.3140946328639984,
-0.2865320146083832,
-0.11853111535310745,
0.19535884261131287,
0.6215847730636597,
0.25758644938468933,
-0.13213081657886505,
-0.5812954902648926,
-1.3481004238128662,
-0.35500597953796387,
-0.4273218512535095,
-0.10726074129343033,
0.337782084941864,
-0.1795227974653244,
0.16021926701068878,
1.212395429611206,
-0.5847144722938538,
-0.16655233502388,
-0.10331738740205765,
0.08953498303890228,
-0.07957842946052551,
0.5637706518173218,
0.9252892732620239,
-0.9228036999702454,
-0.30875280499458313,
-0.2118377983570099,
-1.015712022781372,
-0.1892913579940796,
-0.07805384695529938,
-0.40213021636009216,
0.24286766350269318,
0.3284156620502472,
-0.10975717753171921,
0.6186997890472412,
0.3097788989543915,
-0.226871058344841,
0.2402392327785492,
0.038736067712306976,
0.24104097485542297,
-0.6655880212783813,
0.1373525857925415,
0.23076823353767395,
-0.021418122574687004,
-0.663764238357544,
-0.20889127254486084,
0.20365354418754578,
0.06419064849615097,
-0.39173242449760437,
0.47392013669013977,
-0.10751263052225113,
0.12189964205026627,
-0.23858389258384705,
-0.21321918070316315,
-0.13724693655967712,
0.313268780708313,
0.3370167016983032,
0.5462995767593384,
0.29180365800857544,
-0.48415765166282654,
0.09151200950145721,
0.028906693682074547,
0.12764804065227509,
0.6354947090148926,
-0.47871455550193787,
0.07645285129547119,
-0.14109326899051666,
0.2997829020023346,
-0.9225550889968872,
-0.38360196352005005,
0.48029863834381104,
-0.19933131337165833,
0.37629589438438416,
-0.6764340996742249,
-0.4692593514919281,
-0.04605414718389511,
-0.6196090579032898,
0.20336443185806274,
0.6717298626899719,
-0.5716836452484131,
0.5619363188743591,
0.8653474450111389,
-0.33661964535713196,
-0.8421114087104797,
-0.40625688433647156,
0.03894152492284775,
-0.7826525568962097,
-0.6174138784408569,
0.06374536454677582,
0.05719448998570442,
-0.32628676295280457,
-0.26359352469444275,
-0.33690863847732544,
0.37165510654449463,
0.10456014424562454,
0.5903435349464417,
0.5036028623580933,
0.06749672442674637,
0.35065820813179016,
0.3296751379966736,
-0.8225495219230652,
0.21318599581718445,
0.023288171738386154,
0.2217753827571869,
-0.007139179389923811,
-0.30056101083755493,
-0.012613988481462002,
0.438259094953537,
0.2563084661960602,
0.04791063815355301,
0.35886475443840027,
0.013891740702092648,
-0.3952096402645111,
-0.012292559258639812,
-0.5806493163108826,
-0.26630663871765137,
-0.5584734678268433,
-0.08180218935012817,
-0.0735594853758812,
-0.6729352474212646,
0.3759402930736542,
-0.13173307478427887,
0.42619913816452026,
0.3058900237083435,
-0.050163257867097855,
-0.12903018295764923,
1.0883632898330688,
0.652398407459259,
-0.15216346085071564,
0.14275208115577698,
-0.10402535647153854,
0.19475865364074707,
-0.3821306824684143,
-0.26600608229637146,
-0.2146645188331604,
-0.5844855904579163,
-0.6209297180175781,
-0.1924493908882141,
0.791400671005249,
0.19719339907169342,
-0.3848014771938324,
0.09230588376522064,
-0.7764056921005249,
0.37375709414482117,
0.4255509078502655,
0.21549010276794434,
0.20272621512413025,
0.2802785634994507,
0.08591026067733765,
-0.47457194328308105,
-0.4145607054233551,
-1.2360637187957764,
1.2098968029022217,
0.6255084872245789,
0.9930251836776733,
-0.062339745461940765,
0.9356304407119751,
0.2778300940990448,
0.6136245131492615,
-0.6922012567520142,
0.6825802326202393,
-0.19081135094165802,
-0.17885375022888184,
-0.19059278070926666,
-0.15710532665252686,
-0.8057490587234497,
-0.1118321418762207,
-0.276377409696579,
-0.6983532905578613,
0.35263606905937195,
0.36689481139183044,
-0.627776563167572,
0.33715060353279114,
-0.8179762959480286,
0.755599856376648,
-0.4376492202281952,
-0.3471274971961975,
0.029341736808419228,
-0.8008104562759399,
0.32295331358909607,
0.20830513536930084,
0.0947406142950058,
-0.23319925367832184,
-0.1930718719959259,
1.0622533559799194,
-0.20685231685638428,
1.0242944955825806,
-0.44542717933654785,
-0.09660378098487854,
0.14926853775978088,
0.20210573077201843,
0.5315637588500977,
0.2886269986629486,
-0.10510633885860443,
0.07585751265287399,
-0.3029825687408447,
-0.26795318722724915,
-0.5741347074508667,
0.7790946960449219,
-0.5039607882499695,
-0.5048494338989258,
-0.41608908772468567,
-0.6759161949157715,
-0.35135939717292786,
-0.06692880392074585,
0.06597629189491272,
0.11727274954319,
0.10160117596387863,
0.039217185229063034,
0.8213715553283691,
-0.40989670157432556,
0.3871444761753082,
0.28074491024017334,
-0.21201924979686737,
-0.4678278863430023,
0.9285151362419128,
0.4503636956214905,
-0.008748237043619156,
0.16378091275691986,
0.05817180126905441,
-0.7168337106704712,
-0.30658894777297974,
-0.5290578603744507,
0.03622778505086899,
-1.069425344467163,
-0.35597047209739685,
-0.7022745609283447,
-0.19648081064224243,
-0.09071321785449982,
-0.5409199595451355,
-0.36155813932418823,
-0.5656021237373352,
0.010245050303637981,
-0.6957391500473022,
0.8530396223068237,
0.7524374723434448,
-0.43966159224510193,
0.04118518531322479,
-0.5445629358291626,
-0.05526191368699074,
0.4428570866584778,
0.4575363099575043,
-0.27365201711654663,
0.051862429827451706,
0.1263897866010666,
-0.040251463651657104,
-0.28079885244369507,
-0.8172277808189392,
0.3386317789554596,
-0.5609127283096313,
0.8359082937240601,
0.45411598682403564,
0.7422411441802979,
0.3173600137233734,
-0.11962869018316269,
0.7285314798355103,
0.26064157485961914,
-0.47376763820648193,
0.42152151465415955,
-0.34031251072883606,
-0.7636448740959167,
0.657292902469635,
0.48754236102104187,
-0.2651599943637848,
-0.08914194256067276,
-0.648027777671814,
-0.906653881072998,
0.3131770193576813,
0.06118421629071236,
-0.06144654005765915,
0.29370859265327454,
0.24764660000801086,
0.5562925338745117,
0.12252496182918549,
-0.7023782730102539,
-0.5233535170555115,
-0.25141680240631104,
-0.20669713616371155,
-0.24579550325870514,
-0.3460114300251007,
-0.6918337941169739,
0.07281436771154404,
0.38922348618507385,
-0.3626057803630829,
0.28154611587524414,
-0.29637691378593445,
-0.036306481808423996,
0.09619133919477463,
0.21923968195915222,
0.5479206442832947,
0.5259912014007568,
-0.3854426443576813,
0.23387174308300018,
0.12482286244630814,
-0.20181924104690552,
0.3438282012939453,
0.44549235701560974,
-0.09083645790815353,
-0.08666367083787918,
0.20339469611644745,
0.6763657927513123,
0.006035763770341873,
-0.310534805059433,
0.44825321435928345,
0.0915987640619278,
0.0060707270167768,
-0.22302983701229095,
0.07744258642196655,
0.027763303369283676,
-0.0022204371634870768,
0.5696024298667908,
-0.0021770899184048176,
0.31301528215408325,
0.07096704095602036,
0.3586910665035248,
0.283295601606369,
-0.6089920997619629,
0.16224578022956848,
0.6446899771690369,
0.40325862169265747,
-0.10833083838224411,
0.07802443206310272,
-0.16782024502754211,
-0.25454872846603394,
0.710475742816925,
-0.12202507257461548,
0.8888294100761414,
0.07878721505403519,
0.3385236859321594,
0.3446834683418274,
0.2602252662181854,
0.11415522545576096,
0.14429226517677307,
0.27570441365242004,
-0.2652577757835388,
-0.23754407465457916,
-0.2934599816799164,
-0.29626208543777466,
0.0509088933467865,
-0.7472956776618958,
0.3742893934249878,
-0.39016222953796387,
-0.13913919031620026,
-0.19516220688819885,
-0.22632931172847748,
-0.43120500445365906,
0.06080835685133934,
0.25543883442878723,
0.839263379573822,
-1.1274677515029907,
0.34400686621665955,
0.6854245066642761,
-0.5697630047798157,
-1.090749740600586,
-0.09859844297170639,
0.18123413622379303,
-0.8321749567985535,
0.7626482844352722,
0.4902907907962799,
0.020471524447202682,
-0.3925167918205261,
-0.6548449397087097,
-0.4497433006763458,
1.1734569072723389,
0.7450418472290039,
-0.5953767895698547,
0.1204017624258995,
0.31214505434036255,
0.3374040126800537,
-0.49121618270874023,
0.22452083230018616,
0.5201303362846375,
0.5308994054794312,
-0.10513772815465927,
-0.8082486987113953,
0.3045465052127838,
-0.06353115290403366,
-0.011341478675603867,
0.10564278811216354,
-0.6317152380943298,
0.5028377175331116,
-0.008178453892469406,
-0.0979437455534935,
-0.15867114067077637,
0.568651556968689,
0.8243027329444885,
0.569683313369751,
0.8728498816490173,
0.4377284049987793,
0.6592093110084534,
-0.2063976526260376,
0.9990469217300415,
-0.30738458037376404,
0.2766582667827606,
0.6850196719169617,
-0.1653175801038742,
0.5756373405456543,
0.48491913080215454,
0.1631363481283188,
0.2098054140806198,
0.9408788084983826,
0.4856095016002655,
0.8024011850357056,
0.19227086007595062,
-0.32917511463165283,
-0.5874269008636475,
-0.27806562185287476,
-0.6626356840133667,
-0.023983055725693703,
0.39127734303474426,
-0.4934520423412323,
-0.3323115110397339,
0.023416193202137947,
0.051203541457653046,
0.020763447508215904,
-0.29244932532310486,
0.669924795627594,
0.22309494018554688,
-0.3695531189441681,
0.5234891176223755,
-0.36807018518447876,
0.656074047088623,
-0.4899638891220093,
-0.320660263299942,
-0.3437989056110382,
-0.04161222651600838,
-0.24790699779987335,
-1.142552375793457,
0.07424101233482361,
-0.23965974152088165,
0.09610423445701599,
-0.29768237471580505,
0.7969063520431519,
-0.15545785427093506,
-0.3427540063858032,
0.34181448817253113,
0.013730459846556187,
0.02564181759953499,
0.19825471937656403,
-0.614996075630188,
0.336770236492157,
-0.18040557205677032,
0.01989269256591797,
0.33546310663223267,
0.2288602888584137,
-0.3765611946582794,
0.6040502190589905,
0.46222537755966187,
-0.1475588083267212,
-0.12451198697090149,
-0.053130459040403366,
0.9659994840621948,
-0.36412644386291504,
-0.9857057332992554,
-0.6519156694412231,
0.9462636709213257,
-0.4581572711467743,
-0.005067340563982725,
0.4983968436717987,
0.655794084072113,
0.38767287135124207,
-0.016978897154331207,
1.0999023914337158,
-0.0410490408539772,
0.43241116404533386,
-0.6485152244567871,
0.951406717300415,
-0.4410194456577301,
0.49754950404167175,
-0.34116747975349426,
-0.6996330618858337,
-0.3758765161037445,
0.7236098647117615,
-0.4724367558956146,
0.03804199397563934,
0.3484610617160797,
0.9684600234031677,
-0.14738936722278595,
0.0884021520614624,
0.09468474239110947,
-0.21905045211315155,
0.5025897026062012,
0.6217593550682068,
0.8486353754997253,
-0.11687514930963516,
0.5753140449523926,
-0.3525370657444,
-0.5186395049095154,
-0.33252134919166565,
-1.3239262104034424,
-0.8299709558486938,
-0.42764395475387573,
-0.36749836802482605,
-0.6013401746749878,
0.22863219678401947,
1.1493163108825684,
0.7829329967498779,
-0.6288877129554749,
-0.20526796579360962,
0.2255338579416275,
-0.06825681775808334,
-0.249810129404068,
-0.17277805507183075,
0.7427065372467041,
-0.24470974504947662,
-0.27953198552131653,
0.16320687532424927,
0.39205506443977356,
0.18415264785289764,
-0.19439515471458435,
-0.4951130747795105,
0.4617568850517273,
-0.2204955667257309,
0.4514310956001282,
0.2544846832752228,
-0.6925333142280579,
-0.7802534103393555,
-0.1473139375448227,
-0.23478883504867554,
0.16514581441879272,
0.748457133769989,
-0.587691068649292,
0.49360454082489014,
0.3063824474811554,
0.8247231245040894,
0.17105667293071747,
-0.031000399962067604,
0.7981457710266113,
-0.6292316317558289,
0.15218132734298706,
0.20665888488292694,
0.324429988861084,
0.4125080108642578,
-0.7112392783164978,
0.8279773592948914,
0.028063906356692314,
-0.5355563163757324,
-0.8909865617752075,
0.16095592081546783,
-1.2443668842315674,
0.1116720512509346,
1.3567790985107422,
-0.16461114585399628,
0.05843938887119293,
-0.1179104745388031,
-0.5193639993667603,
0.14359363913536072,
-0.7062162160873413,
0.8502064347267151,
0.44020602107048035,
-0.29265451431274414,
-0.08077506721019745,
-0.6147104501724243,
0.8720524907112122,
0.36748072504997253,
-0.7121043801307678,
0.25828465819358826,
0.5164213180541992,
0.2786957919597626,
0.3061332106590271,
0.4070994257926941,
0.041387222707271576,
0.29875504970550537,
-0.15354523062705994,
0.1389816850423813,
-0.20096611976623535,
-0.21776676177978516,
-0.34132489562034607,
0.3365694284439087,
0.0563448928296566,
-0.47437819838523865
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.08116v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.08116v1
|
Supportiveness-based Knowledge Rewriting for Retrieval-augmented Language Modeling
| 2024-06-12T11:52:35 | 2024-06-12T11:52:35 |
Zile Qiao, Wei Ye, Yong Jiang, Tong Mo, Pengjun Xie, Weiping Li, Fei Huang, Shikun Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Retrieval-augmented language models (RALMs) have recently shown great
potential in mitigating the limitations of implicit knowledge in LLMs, such as
untimely updating of the latest expertise and unreliable retention of long-tail
knowledge. However, since the external knowledge base, as well as the
retriever, can not guarantee reliability, potentially leading to the knowledge
retrieved not being helpful or even misleading for LLM generation. In this
paper, we introduce Supportiveness-based Knowledge Rewriting (SKR), a robust
and pluggable knowledge rewriter inherently optimized for LLM generation.
Specifically, we introduce the novel concept of "supportiveness"--which
represents how effectively a knowledge piece facilitates downstream tasks--by
considering the perplexity impact of augmented knowledge on the response text
of a white-box LLM. Based on knowledge supportiveness, we first design a
training data curation strategy for our rewriter model, effectively identifying
and filtering out poor or irrelevant rewrites (e.g., with low supportiveness
scores) to improve data efficacy. We then introduce the direct preference
optimization (DPO) algorithm to align the generated rewrites to optimal
supportiveness, guiding the rewriter model to summarize augmented content that
better improves the final response. Comprehensive evaluations across six
popular knowledge-intensive tasks and four LLMs have demonstrated the
effectiveness and superiority of SKR. With only 7B parameters, SKR has shown
better knowledge rewriting capability over GPT-4, the current state-of-the-art
general-purpose LLM.
|
[
-0.17322766780853271,
-0.7476341128349304,
0.6381240487098694,
0.06265558302402496,
-0.33142802119255066,
0.040457651019096375,
-0.1469501256942749,
-0.17810742557048798,
0.2698805034160614,
0.7057493925094604,
-0.45505306124687195,
-0.38872405886650085,
-0.40035760402679443,
0.1784585565328598,
-0.08435780555009842,
1.2824281454086304,
-0.23311138153076172,
-0.1088377833366394,
-0.7269349694252014,
-0.06287341564893723,
-0.4679308533668518,
-0.40896305441856384,
-0.33937397599220276,
-0.45499715209007263,
0.9196638464927673,
0.4015657901763916,
0.6774623394012451,
0.5900717973709106,
0.4171485900878906,
0.1978713423013687,
0.004003192763775587,
0.20996510982513428,
-0.4581073224544525,
0.7242909669876099,
-0.17712147533893585,
-0.5397778749465942,
-0.7759921550750732,
-0.3087322413921356,
0.3474676311016083,
0.4907345175743103,
-0.5154421925544739,
0.03478538990020752,
0.2607288658618927,
0.8059691190719604,
-0.5710843205451965,
-0.10726269334554672,
-1.074354648590088,
-0.30757614970207214,
0.061651211231946945,
-0.00771339749917388,
-0.31825369596481323,
-0.5535863041877747,
0.20087042450904846,
-0.7387276887893677,
0.42127305269241333,
0.26565831899642944,
0.39495787024497986,
0.3706243336200714,
-0.32137149572372437,
-0.4083240032196045,
-0.5157826542854309,
0.8781766295433044,
-0.7238484621047974,
0.5317966938018799,
0.6097365021705627,
0.3971691131591797,
-0.3828253149986267,
-0.5688563585281372,
-0.5915012359619141,
-0.30570530891418457,
0.0031804402824491262,
0.17229978740215302,
-0.05007055774331093,
0.2365456372499466,
0.08629657328128815,
0.5707529187202454,
-0.3130442202091217,
-0.41119083762168884,
-0.2930796146392822,
-0.3931916654109955,
0.3982292413711548,
-0.02983022853732109,
-0.04007295146584511,
-0.31828269362449646,
-0.41556066274642944,
0.31124579906463623,
-0.8356750011444092,
-0.22513987123966217,
0.2870364487171173,
0.201351597905159,
0.33481353521347046,
0.7785462737083435,
-0.3751150369644165,
0.4148615300655365,
0.049384649842977524,
-0.419168621301651,
0.10798770189285278,
-0.3996746838092804,
-0.3046427369117737,
-0.15837666392326355,
0.38810524344444275,
0.321061372756958,
0.18445557355880737,
-0.34607988595962524,
-0.4351743161678314,
0.11235135048627853,
0.5426638722419739,
-0.46134141087532043,
-0.021412666887044907,
0.11748819053173065,
-0.29807594418525696,
-0.35848596692085266,
-0.447509765625,
-0.43201908469200134,
-0.46182093024253845,
-0.2769760489463806,
0.27479711174964905,
-0.5750879645347595,
-0.42210933566093445,
0.047058191150426865,
0.16521480679512024,
0.16340012848377228,
0.3364541530609131,
-0.8325522541999817,
0.17947396636009216,
0.7401961088180542,
0.5483304262161255,
-0.20534956455230713,
0.0488138310611248,
-0.45825645327568054,
0.43239036202430725,
0.06780959665775299,
0.8908335566520691,
-0.4928647577762604,
-0.3819291591644287,
-0.004540977068245411,
-0.13696449995040894,
-0.02661338821053505,
-0.3500126600265503,
0.7227139472961426,
-0.8114520311355591,
0.02526702731847763,
-0.4355103075504303,
-0.6537267565727234,
-0.0430457703769207,
0.5887900590896606,
-0.7453869581222534,
0.9918950200080872,
0.3122774660587311,
-0.944519579410553,
0.6442772746086121,
0.003605666570365429,
-0.5170173048973083,
-0.10156702995300293,
-0.201223686337471,
-0.6692792773246765,
0.28451159596443176,
0.01648031920194626,
0.25631242990493774,
-0.11299857497215271,
0.49315884709358215,
-0.5051605105400085,
-0.12620875239372253,
-0.13459162414073944,
-0.2876966893672943,
0.07216808944940567,
0.14655272662639618,
-0.1318259835243225,
0.09816067665815353,
-0.7319369316101074,
-0.023449676111340523,
-0.1812780201435089,
-0.5797898173332214,
-0.47417205572128296,
0.12543968856334686,
-0.2814260721206665,
0.13534338772296906,
0.17589673399925232,
-0.595653235912323,
0.447709321975708,
-0.4358213543891907,
0.06961122900247574,
0.8385817408561707,
-0.014207963831722736,
0.45808491110801697,
-0.5383153557777405,
0.9019257426261902,
-0.37548068165779114,
0.09250607341527939,
0.06583315879106522,
-0.40389856696128845,
-0.6524527668952942,
-0.11571886390447617,
-0.14935210347175598,
0.49404606223106384,
-1.0686489343643188,
-0.022899115458130836,
-0.09803622215986252,
-0.33421653509140015,
-0.6922444701194763,
0.5593225955963135,
0.7119648456573486,
0.9719868898391724,
0.37753379344940186,
0.12883292138576508,
-0.7580909729003906,
-1.099303960800171,
-0.3299308121204376,
-0.35269293189048767,
0.36530789732933044,
0.3035796582698822,
0.17597900331020355,
-0.27580317854881287,
0.7514952421188354,
-0.3869152069091797,
-0.3130527138710022,
-0.6466760039329529,
-0.3607284128665924,
0.15542618930339813,
0.2430761158466339,
0.09709068387746811,
-0.6571258306503296,
-0.43490663170814514,
-0.07065340131521225,
-0.5617449879646301,
-0.24349889159202576,
0.16837608814239502,
-0.3200986385345459,
0.5022204518318176,
0.16439200937747955,
-0.5031526684761047,
0.32860150933265686,
0.36636948585510254,
-0.30366194248199463,
0.7040819525718689,
-0.34022173285484314,
-0.03144097328186035,
-1.2384980916976929,
0.016513749957084656,
-0.1828661859035492,
-0.2446921467781067,
-0.45109090209007263,
-0.19208937883377075,
-0.13879923522472382,
0.35102537274360657,
-0.20006756484508514,
0.46720001101493835,
-0.45400914549827576,
0.12081804871559143,
-0.5474477410316467,
0.16825516521930695,
0.12970316410064697,
0.2680199146270752,
0.035995569080114365,
0.6322280764579773,
0.3130193054676056,
-0.3652702271938324,
0.3344627022743225,
0.4392557144165039,
-0.059039343148469925,
0.5983474254608154,
-0.6559088826179504,
0.15569889545440674,
-0.12804822623729706,
0.22089174389839172,
-0.8393231630325317,
-0.2305039018392563,
0.05780075117945671,
-0.3217243254184723,
0.28930750489234924,
-0.3223516345024109,
-0.4059697985649109,
-0.0708271712064743,
-0.37421590089797974,
0.21851098537445068,
0.4252050518989563,
-0.14660859107971191,
0.9846612215042114,
0.09199365228414536,
-0.26627305150032043,
-0.8665734529495239,
-0.5125564336776733,
-0.2435348778963089,
-0.19134816527366638,
-0.7911378145217896,
0.33099132776260376,
0.02248646505177021,
-0.1812109649181366,
0.1213240772485733,
-0.4263305068016052,
0.2918446660041809,
0.007014501839876175,
0.20116138458251953,
0.31885257363319397,
-0.07538501173257828,
0.041572004556655884,
0.14767765998840332,
-0.33339449763298035,
0.0893043652176857,
-0.11949127912521362,
0.24754051864147186,
0.1847323626279831,
-0.540543258190155,
-0.1368437558412552,
0.4048040807247162,
0.4946775436401367,
0.03313510864973068,
0.8054601550102234,
0.4052516520023346,
-0.2083151936531067,
-0.33182448148727417,
-1.0117124319076538,
-0.21634948253631592,
-0.43459171056747437,
0.21759605407714844,
-0.42911893129348755,
-1.0570920705795288,
0.5472404360771179,
0.3565558195114136,
0.09083816409111023,
0.3314819931983948,
0.41434407234191895,
0.0496276430785656,
0.9168878197669983,
0.828091561794281,
-0.23980620503425598,
0.44591668248176575,
0.11801102012395859,
0.10962661355733871,
-0.9403559565544128,
-0.4261913299560547,
-0.1846921294927597,
-0.04425662010908127,
-0.37185779213905334,
-0.1493186056613922,
0.24304762482643127,
0.16951115429401398,
-0.15035435557365417,
0.031086184084415436,
-0.4293844997882843,
0.21243152022361755,
0.6029863953590393,
0.23748961091041565,
0.5378402471542358,
0.20939427614212036,
-0.2809875011444092,
-0.1664147824048996,
-0.6769503355026245,
-0.6558887958526611,
1.1930195093154907,
0.18047034740447998,
1.0899860858917236,
0.020397109910845757,
0.5487322807312012,
0.29367899894714355,
0.39983630180358887,
-0.4875526428222656,
0.4358201324939728,
-0.06971267610788345,
-0.5621019005775452,
0.13024860620498657,
-0.33082854747772217,
-0.43725118041038513,
-0.046939294785261154,
-0.2952689528465271,
-0.1970745474100113,
-0.13481751084327698,
0.7035814523696899,
-0.3391357958316803,
0.25829872488975525,
-0.8177603483200073,
0.5299460291862488,
-0.2071165293455124,
-0.735800564289093,
-0.2490009069442749,
-0.39714884757995605,
0.3347054719924927,
-0.06719420105218887,
0.07320748269557953,
0.05061190575361252,
-0.10820144414901733,
0.4578346610069275,
-0.48611998558044434,
0.7811185121536255,
-0.5098447203636169,
-0.21326637268066406,
0.26292383670806885,
0.18049056828022003,
0.7424904704093933,
0.11521408706903458,
-0.44947320222854614,
-0.6029820442199707,
-0.05720057338476181,
-0.30088719725608826,
-0.8865216374397278,
0.6782864332199097,
-0.42291370034217834,
-1.0047498941421509,
-0.21671894192695618,
-0.4438486099243164,
-0.2972264587879181,
0.30609428882598877,
0.08195026218891144,
0.33718785643577576,
0.1811026781797409,
0.32825517654418945,
0.7765618562698364,
-0.19312416017055511,
-0.30254656076431274,
0.5918076634407043,
-0.3967960774898529,
-0.7011866569519043,
0.9243661165237427,
0.11393643915653229,
0.6384085416793823,
0.1550036072731018,
0.09556616842746735,
-0.46613970398902893,
-0.8523365259170532,
-0.39057695865631104,
0.3418966829776764,
-0.7399911284446716,
-0.4309772849082947,
-0.7280210852622986,
-0.0642712339758873,
-0.4737851321697235,
-0.38498854637145996,
-0.0891256332397461,
-0.45439332723617554,
-0.012610597535967827,
-0.3973182141780853,
0.7680420875549316,
0.7991741895675659,
0.2301175743341446,
0.011905054561793804,
-0.41918042302131653,
0.39597374200820923,
0.16774198412895203,
0.6718965172767639,
0.03197646886110306,
-0.46743494272232056,
-0.23547613620758057,
-0.15680848062038422,
-0.22296129167079926,
-0.6042004823684692,
0.17071186006069183,
0.1275978982448578,
0.883347749710083,
0.1477971076965332,
0.3013332784175873,
0.6557161211967468,
-0.41887933015823364,
0.5126467943191528,
-0.2654755413532257,
-0.49322518706321716,
0.7674847841262817,
-0.4193699359893799,
-0.12517473101615906,
0.8792863488197327,
0.05300049111247063,
-0.2973637878894806,
-0.6966919302940369,
-0.5271553993225098,
-1.0410562753677368,
0.3933039605617523,
0.14426195621490479,
0.1455954611301422,
-0.20123454928398132,
0.8047503232955933,
0.3351204991340637,
0.4082198441028595,
-0.5745779275894165,
-0.13378623127937317,
-0.3269190490245819,
-0.35733726620674133,
0.3518224358558655,
-0.7604327201843262,
0.17345894873142242,
0.059642717242240906,
1.0796092748641968,
-0.11674360930919647,
0.0724216103553772,
0.4393255114555359,
-0.14559052884578705,
-0.03928373008966446,
0.42388826608657837,
0.43481844663619995,
0.43852782249450684,
-0.2684818506240845,
0.3440694212913513,
0.25055572390556335,
-0.5722082853317261,
0.02292085625231266,
-0.023702923208475113,
-0.30645179748535156,
-0.33131760358810425,
0.3634755313396454,
0.43871748447418213,
0.3156680166721344,
-0.4414106011390686,
0.34821128845214844,
0.04397525265812874,
-0.22210152447223663,
-0.28255054354667664,
0.39072108268737793,
0.10051180422306061,
0.14634545147418976,
0.4235466420650482,
-0.19493743777275085,
-0.04468725249171257,
-0.11233244836330414,
0.3817891478538513,
0.7349182367324829,
-0.2984912693500519,
-0.40323421359062195,
0.7237170934677124,
0.12219545990228653,
0.0028555337339639664,
0.4052383005619049,
-0.09406169503927231,
-0.6452069282531738,
0.08550950884819031,
0.8114662170410156,
0.6651952266693115,
-0.12565134465694427,
-0.11529894173145294,
0.2491113543510437,
0.13594381511211395,
-0.13742594420909882,
0.6214575171470642,
-0.15914829075336456,
-0.7720385193824768,
-0.4020601809024811,
-0.8318225145339966,
-0.4092330038547516,
-0.050793204456567764,
-0.7512652277946472,
0.09380427747964859,
-0.3415820598602295,
-0.06416058540344238,
-0.4135538339614868,
0.25256818532943726,
-0.2575458288192749,
0.14848817884922028,
-0.3594745099544525,
1.1188188791275024,
-0.7101538181304932,
0.9151169657707214,
0.8077621459960938,
-0.6212260127067566,
-0.8130173683166504,
-0.3365112841129303,
0.01811404712498188,
-0.8417495489120483,
0.34665030241012573,
-0.08914854377508163,
-0.3926333785057068,
-0.003115003928542137,
-0.3594755530357361,
-0.773923397064209,
1.3868564367294312,
0.5246685743331909,
-0.4471531808376312,
-0.14286454021930695,
0.07585582137107849,
0.5819377899169922,
-0.3203304708003998,
0.02201957069337368,
0.31585586071014404,
0.3725382089614868,
0.23891735076904297,
-0.5728390216827393,
0.2060028463602066,
-0.291544109582901,
0.012194451875984669,
-0.044496793299913406,
-0.5996371507644653,
0.3163222372531891,
-0.06367272138595581,
-0.007685061078518629,
0.11984811723232269,
0.7508465051651001,
0.6722983121871948,
0.3575037121772766,
0.5191758275032043,
0.5791496634483337,
0.6433358192443848,
0.14186957478523254,
1.1077125072479248,
-0.2888462543487549,
-0.01412784494459629,
0.9407991766929626,
-0.3748056888580322,
0.8042547106742859,
0.7729211449623108,
0.07079129666090012,
0.6247571110725403,
0.04615825042128563,
0.1764695644378662,
0.5426312685012817,
0.06325236707925797,
-0.5499102473258972,
-0.3168647289276123,
-0.2726820111274719,
-0.2831437885761261,
-0.07896488904953003,
0.02200431004166603,
-0.5283545255661011,
-0.13834817707538605,
0.030142594128847122,
0.18963423371315002,
0.33719465136528015,
-0.192025825381279,
0.9653033018112183,
0.1493803858757019,
-0.8878774046897888,
0.4496837854385376,
-0.3767540454864502,
0.7720286250114441,
-0.6591620445251465,
-0.03790036961436272,
-0.4573218524456024,
0.39922651648521423,
-0.4966272711753845,
-0.856207549571991,
0.6854071617126465,
0.21944406628608704,
-0.8375330567359924,
-0.4409101903438568,
1.230226755142212,
-0.43062156438827515,
-0.5690177083015442,
0.42090409994125366,
0.5390447974205017,
-0.2194446325302124,
-0.09249355643987656,
-0.4800804555416107,
0.11239142715930939,
0.22931897640228271,
-0.5003554821014404,
0.40063995122909546,
0.5376093983650208,
-0.15114931762218475,
0.9963432550430298,
0.6788008809089661,
0.3487864136695862,
-0.07876042276620865,
0.1871042102575302,
1.2016242742538452,
-0.5286393165588379,
-0.1094311773777008,
-0.8185854554176331,
0.5859020352363586,
0.12792137265205383,
0.09912213683128357,
0.9987824559211731,
0.6116406321525574,
0.5647269487380981,
0.21965764462947845,
1.0617918968200684,
-0.003943276591598988,
0.8278207182884216,
-0.4117504358291626,
0.8472805023193359,
-0.4100516736507416,
0.5050991773605347,
-0.396898090839386,
-0.8079559803009033,
-0.39498451352119446,
0.5295650362968445,
-0.45760881900787354,
0.07064589858055115,
0.06788545846939087,
1.008347511291504,
0.0521208718419075,
-0.07145322114229202,
0.1956968754529953,
-0.022730430588126183,
0.43206164240837097,
0.5355292558670044,
0.7633897662162781,
-0.07821418344974518,
0.7806459069252014,
-0.1716168373823166,
-0.09301251173019409,
-0.0951666608452797,
-1.0845693349838257,
-0.7107548713684082,
-0.4195297658443451,
-0.1498032510280609,
-0.5707301497459412,
0.24798652529716492,
0.7838913798332214,
0.3940744996070862,
-0.6552289128303528,
0.2790282368659973,
-0.3042828142642975,
0.4801728427410126,
0.057089321315288544,
-0.19059297442436218,
0.3350081145763397,
-0.4754692316055298,
-0.17395362257957458,
0.39467093348503113,
-0.03452542424201965,
-0.11552895605564117,
-0.33555495738983154,
-0.2043745368719101,
0.06610475480556488,
-0.2143435925245285,
0.4904532730579376,
0.13390026986598969,
-0.7407935261726379,
-0.4118551015853882,
0.48976871371269226,
-0.029088428243994713,
-0.1770341992378235,
0.6669446229934692,
-0.9422634840011597,
0.5477153062820435,
0.39006850123405457,
0.7691336274147034,
0.06994131952524185,
0.25750887393951416,
0.9200777411460876,
-0.6573910713195801,
-0.33835482597351074,
0.13458983600139618,
0.3237365484237671,
0.5343360304832458,
-0.4302537441253662,
0.281729519367218,
0.38939449191093445,
-0.7574087381362915,
-0.8617402911186218,
0.3134283125400543,
-0.8478787541389465,
0.26771214604377747,
1.428169846534729,
-0.1802458018064499,
-0.18454407155513763,
-0.37998998165130615,
-0.4245242476463318,
0.31303757429122925,
-0.5128210783004761,
0.7806703448295593,
0.6784647703170776,
-0.04452388733625412,
-0.18250951170921326,
-0.4886898696422577,
0.6544402837753296,
0.371792733669281,
-0.3309435248374939,
0.43890872597694397,
0.6164434552192688,
0.589278519153595,
-0.13691850006580353,
0.8215813636779785,
-0.010665860958397388,
0.08785148710012436,
-0.23966766893863678,
-0.06611787527799606,
-0.5354712605476379,
-0.02648990973830223,
-0.12141703069210052,
0.09218066930770874,
0.37159037590026855,
0.24856440722942352
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.08101v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.08101v2
|
CoXQL: A Dataset for Parsing Explanation Requests in Conversational XAI Systems
| 2024-06-12T11:27:10 | 2024-06-13T03:16:47 |
Qianli Wang, Tatiana Anikina, Nils Feldhus, Simon Ostermann, Sebastian Möller
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Conversational explainable artificial intelligence (ConvXAI) systems based on
large language models (LLMs) have garnered significant interest from the
research community in natural language processing (NLP) and human-computer
interaction (HCI). Such systems can provide answers to user questions about
explanations in dialogues, have the potential to enhance users' comprehension
and offer more information about the decision-making and generation processes
of LLMs. Currently available ConvXAI systems are based on intent recognition
rather than free chat, as this has been found to be more precise and reliable
in identifying users' intentions. However, the recognition of intents still
presents a challenge in the case of ConvXAI, since little training data exist
and the domain is highly specific, as there is a broad range of XAI methods to
map requests onto. In order to bridge this gap, we present CoXQL, the first
dataset for user intent recognition in ConvXAI, covering 31 intents, seven of
which require filling multiple slots. Subsequently, we enhance an existing
parsing approach by incorporating template validations, and conduct an
evaluation of several LLMs on CoXQL using different parsing strategies. We
conclude that the improved parsing approach (MP+) surpasses the performance of
previous approaches. We also discover that intents with multiple slots remain
highly challenging for LLMs.
|
[
-0.19181452691555023,
-0.2869661748409271,
0.7575182914733887,
0.2914394736289978,
-0.1320502758026123,
0.010303557850420475,
0.14837764203548431,
-0.2782672941684723,
0.046912647783756256,
0.5113620758056641,
-0.7032564878463745,
-0.5839418172836304,
-0.1444704383611679,
0.044765837490558624,
-0.28725162148475647,
0.6042124032974243,
0.14220619201660156,
0.17080864310264587,
-0.19181779026985168,
-0.2973840534687042,
-0.6191606521606445,
-0.4054746925830841,
-1.1454445123672485,
-0.37541070580482483,
0.6889020204544067,
0.6967302560806274,
0.9399207234382629,
0.7382066249847412,
-0.013997402042150497,
0.19126245379447937,
-0.016876593232154846,
0.19383504986763,
-0.4887378215789795,
-0.08126795291900635,
-0.11541740596294403,
-0.6102955341339111,
-0.1626095473766327,
-0.2901681065559387,
0.6059309244155884,
0.8271703124046326,
-0.19219744205474854,
-0.05818619951605797,
-0.021347906440496445,
0.6538375616073608,
-0.7470388412475586,
0.24922524392604828,
-0.45055314898490906,
0.21916763484477997,
-0.010495869442820549,
-0.3057563900947571,
-0.5499688982963562,
-0.33286726474761963,
0.27060335874557495,
-0.7244007587432861,
-0.14477305114269257,
0.49076929688453674,
0.3339935839176178,
0.01842142641544342,
-0.63679039478302,
-0.46091726422309875,
-0.47782182693481445,
0.9441113471984863,
-0.5987876057624817,
0.47449150681495667,
0.24243901669979095,
0.6256601214408875,
-0.556896984577179,
-0.662998378276825,
-0.8408640027046204,
-0.07955032587051392,
-0.3338083028793335,
0.04750778526067734,
-0.35784175992012024,
0.4053254723548889,
0.2536373436450958,
0.20098407566547394,
-0.9416041374206543,
0.014106471091508865,
-0.2404036819934845,
-0.06937487423419952,
0.8025333881378174,
0.4441867470741272,
0.3295866847038269,
-0.17376820743083954,
-0.3472629189491272,
-0.10308565944433212,
-0.7206228971481323,
0.7660930752754211,
0.04626031219959259,
0.11478998512029648,
-0.044675376266241074,
0.6174405217170715,
-0.38055944442749023,
0.7271365523338318,
0.13753001391887665,
0.1201457679271698,
0.015340232290327549,
0.07834813743829727,
-0.5059602856636047,
0.42905864119529724,
0.7509765625,
0.3385121524333954,
0.04757244884967804,
-0.24664856493473053,
0.136958047747612,
-0.15964780747890472,
0.034302983433008194,
-0.30312642455101013,
0.03069874458014965,
0.8588247895240784,
-0.5878454446792603,
-0.20770417153835297,
-0.18748368322849274,
-0.29458823800086975,
-0.7878338694572449,
-0.5892103910446167,
-0.00154171884059906,
-0.35151907801628113,
-0.01630021445453167,
0.4790124297142029,
-0.19385971128940582,
0.7620956301689148,
0.4414295256137848,
-0.7321957945823669,
0.4739094376564026,
0.8349655866622925,
0.46716606616973877,
-0.3114907443523407,
-0.06239642575383186,
-0.8008770942687988,
0.11732346564531326,
-0.22337883710861206,
0.6762473583221436,
-0.9124130010604858,
-0.2822907865047455,
0.2438209056854248,
0.030920494347810745,
-0.1563340574502945,
-0.5555498003959656,
0.9478491544723511,
-0.770897626876831,
0.09561502188444138,
-0.38405919075012207,
-0.6442116498947144,
-0.5670301914215088,
0.3807414770126343,
-0.4754082262516022,
0.6504529714584351,
0.06449183076620102,
-0.5460766553878784,
0.15301230549812317,
-0.7450119853019714,
-0.21243439614772797,
0.33042025566101074,
-0.36688587069511414,
0.006127558182924986,
0.08523818850517273,
0.18965506553649902,
0.4442639648914337,
-0.5844187140464783,
0.45510998368263245,
-0.3837813436985016,
-0.3527708351612091,
0.5356144905090332,
-0.43970322608947754,
0.9652538299560547,
0.37291714549064636,
-0.11232531815767288,
0.3798847794532776,
-1.0099561214447021,
0.43290382623672485,
-0.15358155965805054,
-0.3217957317829132,
-0.3099568486213684,
0.29746320843696594,
-0.03287363797426224,
0.30735763907432556,
-0.04533854126930237,
-0.44916629791259766,
0.21316099166870117,
-0.5069557428359985,
0.38766083121299744,
0.4279863238334656,
-0.18992817401885986,
0.1691405028104782,
-0.3595306873321533,
0.6434634327888489,
0.25383758544921875,
0.3646712899208069,
-0.2992307245731354,
-0.3505760729312897,
-0.6961816549301147,
0.08882506936788559,
-0.1265774518251419,
0.685308575630188,
-0.945275068283081,
0.05486650764942169,
-0.33216285705566406,
-0.31408122181892395,
-0.42546334862709045,
-0.10830385237932205,
0.5839523077011108,
0.41861841082572937,
0.16862095892429352,
0.08591224253177643,
-0.5814756751060486,
-1.0083680152893066,
-0.2705114781856537,
-0.2647583782672882,
-0.2737124264240265,
0.8557718992233276,
-0.026247574016451836,
-0.14232394099235535,
1.1092482805252075,
-0.3336494565010071,
0.07128876447677612,
-0.6051978468894958,
-0.0041258991695940495,
0.35167396068573,
0.2451045960187912,
0.5002966523170471,
-1.0437871217727661,
-0.4816199839115143,
0.1565942019224167,
-0.6986370086669922,
-0.14088107645511627,
-0.22424915432929993,
-0.07177575677633286,
-0.12270732969045639,
0.4670058786869049,
-0.4190002977848053,
0.33722981810569763,
0.44250601530075073,
-0.38444334268569946,
0.42206865549087524,
0.014626995660364628,
0.16576190292835236,
-0.8238925337791443,
0.012087799608707428,
-0.015450282022356987,
-0.44519689679145813,
-0.8276993036270142,
-0.3025801479816437,
-0.052936453372240067,
-0.15253442525863647,
-0.8721808791160583,
0.5527688264846802,
-0.26595187187194824,
0.11092407256364822,
-0.23457354307174683,
0.20317701995372772,
0.03026946634054184,
0.6524688601493835,
0.2241130769252777,
0.5297853946685791,
0.7025986909866333,
-0.6418917179107666,
0.4885154664516449,
0.3832412660121918,
-0.05808238685131073,
0.11255010962486267,
-0.9649766087532043,
0.1551397144794464,
-0.2593831419944763,
0.1504124253988266,
-1.3888139724731445,
-0.3923434019088745,
0.5851565003395081,
-0.3794441223144531,
-0.2134341299533844,
-0.3729928135871887,
-0.02728784643113613,
-0.07834125310182571,
-0.31177642941474915,
0.723812460899353,
0.3162252902984619,
-0.8038491010665894,
0.6888049840927124,
0.3389335572719574,
0.010156786069273949,
-0.6115623712539673,
-0.29176512360572815,
0.16270692646503448,
-0.326437383890152,
-0.9302338361740112,
0.20623381435871124,
0.02205866016447544,
-0.3050878643989563,
-0.4497065246105194,
0.24587216973304749,
-0.2738947868347168,
-0.11501427739858627,
0.32661762833595276,
-0.05418117344379425,
-0.4040353298187256,
0.11829964816570282,
0.2692639231681824,
-0.09800248593091965,
0.2593027353286743,
-0.4475807249546051,
0.5729281902313232,
-0.09774062037467957,
-0.17377649247646332,
-0.8801444172859192,
0.6452511548995972,
0.7271021008491516,
-0.0217891838401556,
0.6492933034896851,
0.0422423779964447,
-0.18404266238212585,
0.03508131206035614,
-0.37021660804748535,
0.3337860703468323,
-0.4502221941947937,
-0.21399489045143127,
-0.3790757954120636,
-0.7953380346298218,
0.5512540340423584,
-0.27794817090034485,
0.050312984734773636,
0.17850372195243835,
0.13618558645248413,
0.07488327473402023,
1.5506848096847534,
0.4327271282672882,
-0.04340558126568794,
0.15770894289016724,
0.0023026217240840197,
0.15509648621082306,
-0.8499360084533691,
-0.18874578177928925,
-0.47921958565711975,
-0.3024507462978363,
-0.5351473689079285,
-0.005940787494182587,
0.34021976590156555,
-0.2695130705833435,
0.04773518443107605,
0.044416505843400955,
-0.2189592570066452,
0.4972866177558899,
0.5325531363487244,
-0.04900035262107849,
0.2707132399082184,
-0.11134292185306549,
0.17345166206359863,
0.19872750341892242,
-0.7633476853370667,
-0.5172911882400513,
0.7516307830810547,
0.14333711564540863,
0.8578771948814392,
0.3113052546977997,
0.22693395614624023,
0.4528934359550476,
-0.1213742271065712,
-0.7860356569290161,
0.5442836880683899,
-0.029596928507089615,
-0.23969967663288116,
-0.2455885410308838,
-0.3043869435787201,
-1.317453145980835,
0.33345887064933777,
-0.2203289270401001,
-0.9350045323371887,
0.4935891926288605,
0.5158475637435913,
-0.652976393699646,
-0.20414933562278748,
-0.8915328979492188,
0.897790789604187,
-0.21931742131710052,
-0.3364316523075104,
-0.045716412365436554,
-0.9050145149230957,
0.4490196704864502,
0.34506380558013916,
0.07029660046100616,
0.041141558438539505,
0.3010651171207428,
0.5031227469444275,
-0.34638282656669617,
0.7577894926071167,
-0.29638031125068665,
0.0473104864358902,
0.3970760405063629,
-0.16167844831943512,
0.45211607217788696,
0.4336887001991272,
-0.19836649298667908,
-0.1986483931541443,
0.33236467838287354,
-0.33530592918395996,
-0.8418763279914856,
0.4996660053730011,
-0.6437718868255615,
-0.6120703816413879,
-0.38486340641975403,
-0.5116474032402039,
-0.06400185078382492,
0.11140909790992737,
-0.0326797291636467,
0.5941892862319946,
-0.0484425351023674,
0.26421791315078735,
0.8202437162399292,
-0.37888962030410767,
0.06595908105373383,
0.40937182307243347,
-0.41991937160491943,
0.09259945154190063,
0.7598575353622437,
-0.3051069974899292,
-0.048822466284036636,
0.5236427187919617,
0.33135735988616943,
-0.4339291751384735,
-0.6686933636665344,
-0.3390638530254364,
0.06554971635341644,
-0.5292617678642273,
0.028318636119365692,
-0.7005656361579895,
-0.13733910024166107,
-0.5416844487190247,
-0.17603573203086853,
0.04750213399529457,
-0.5199239253997803,
-0.17189927399158478,
0.3460236191749573,
-0.06923288851976395,
0.420999139547348,
0.44139254093170166,
0.7733093500137329,
-0.9137812852859497,
0.3691912293434143,
0.16990146040916443,
0.1387283056974411,
-0.10903401672840118,
-0.2771659195423126,
0.08791092038154602,
0.33586037158966064,
-0.19757398962974548,
-0.7201142311096191,
0.4596113860607147,
0.2525436580181122,
0.5441893935203552,
0.8129207491874695,
0.30209290981292725,
0.583223819732666,
-0.26128724217414856,
0.768245279788971,
0.0719609260559082,
-0.8410583734512329,
0.7031422257423401,
-0.30735012888908386,
0.3250354826450348,
0.3915832042694092,
0.49521201848983765,
-1.0132222175598145,
0.06687450408935547,
-0.49914854764938354,
-0.6761359572410583,
1.048493504524231,
0.2875920236110687,
-0.055547527968883514,
-0.04535754397511482,
0.8792127370834351,
0.21048973500728607,
0.037338126450777054,
-0.5457697510719299,
-0.2781560719013214,
0.10833895951509476,
-0.43607816100120544,
0.18595218658447266,
-0.4663247764110565,
0.10604742914438248,
-0.11884664744138718,
0.6679994463920593,
-0.3236609101295471,
0.02480659820139408,
0.28108182549476624,
-0.20958122611045837,
0.2791673541069031,
0.48368027806282043,
0.5040608048439026,
0.6767455339431763,
0.08433105796575546,
0.10394976288080215,
0.07718721777200699,
-0.32034537196159363,
0.07687412947416306,
-0.02037476748228073,
0.009335256181657314,
-0.15389376878738403,
0.11226322501897812,
0.7948459386825562,
-0.051112543791532516,
-1.1848242282867432,
0.5849525928497314,
-0.7516474723815918,
0.09807655215263367,
-0.7301358580589294,
0.5939788222312927,
-0.28481170535087585,
0.3958180844783783,
0.09351755678653717,
-0.3059985339641571,
0.6542937755584717,
-0.5166060924530029,
-0.1612696349620819,
0.4240211248397827,
-0.7317066192626953,
-0.2497653067111969,
0.37880560755729675,
0.03214753419160843,
-0.42415133118629456,
0.7437303066253662,
-0.32156744599342346,
-0.15228793025016785,
0.43401581048965454,
0.47469964623451233,
0.6671124696731567,
-0.22290752828121185,
0.2701597511768341,
0.1436333805322647,
-0.17062059044837952,
0.20269618928432465,
0.5243245363235474,
-0.22288045287132263,
-0.8024001121520996,
-0.19817203283309937,
-0.3406519591808319,
-0.5851074457168579,
0.3092019557952881,
-0.7001860737800598,
0.4031585454940796,
-0.2907885015010834,
0.28618645668029785,
0.3987458050251007,
-0.3294891119003296,
-0.5302596688270569,
0.23019571602344513,
0.0506514236330986,
0.9836868643760681,
-0.6226667165756226,
0.6904086470603943,
0.7721989154815674,
0.060178693383932114,
-0.7777428030967712,
-0.37612423300743103,
0.12466520816087723,
-0.8059396743774414,
0.39975109696388245,
0.11856114864349365,
-0.2933085262775421,
-0.09135183691978455,
-0.8936294913291931,
-0.6654691100120544,
0.9537057876586914,
0.2903715670108795,
-0.5495411157608032,
0.10145153105258942,
0.5796153545379639,
0.3155161738395691,
-0.6441124677658081,
0.28844988346099854,
0.8432504534721375,
0.3424782156944275,
0.4131258428096771,
-0.4020515978336334,
0.021083379164338112,
-0.33731722831726074,
0.012406864203512669,
-0.001120918896049261,
-0.48511025309562683,
0.3496689796447754,
-0.06618931144475937,
-0.3588835895061493,
-0.06420038640499115,
0.6296466588973999,
0.3026968836784363,
0.7350329160690308,
0.6976903080940247,
0.03262624517083168,
0.8049038648605347,
0.0009309655288234353,
1.1873804330825806,
-0.016235867515206337,
-0.12352342903614044,
1.1614807844161987,
-0.42405134439468384,
0.5917649269104004,
0.4754205644130707,
-0.019794853404164314,
0.3141076862812042,
0.6489848494529724,
0.38712096214294434,
0.2598128020763397,
0.3103363811969757,
-0.45940032601356506,
-0.4258328080177307,
-0.30340269207954407,
0.10776364058256149,
0.5822405219078064,
0.684689998626709,
-0.31449899077415466,
-0.22535766661167145,
0.25629737973213196,
-0.03850068151950836,
-0.21153317391872406,
-0.34064093232154846,
0.9413768649101257,
-0.1494344025850296,
-0.9812196493148804,
0.5862131714820862,
-0.07374227046966553,
0.101725734770298,
-0.5919156670570374,
-0.26222190260887146,
-0.08375715464353561,
0.30854153633117676,
-0.3410834074020386,
-0.8555478453636169,
0.2911140024662018,
-0.2097388058900833,
-0.24240168929100037,
0.07063749432563782,
0.6791468262672424,
-0.36583220958709717,
-0.26364368200302124,
0.09785999357700348,
0.15915578603744507,
0.5562752485275269,
-0.26141756772994995,
-0.6468081474304199,
0.16808070242404938,
0.243186816573143,
0.007589175831526518,
0.03685512766242027,
0.3739362061023712,
-0.43372800946235657,
0.9242824912071228,
0.549824595451355,
-0.4884486794471741,
0.15616291761398315,
0.2283552587032318,
0.8582407832145691,
-0.6644056439399719,
-0.5188255310058594,
-0.6560627818107605,
0.5869500041007996,
-0.08480361104011536,
-0.33918583393096924,
0.42128223180770874,
0.7551208734512329,
0.4807344675064087,
0.21763457357883453,
1.0034531354904175,
0.025157099589705467,
0.4875001311302185,
-0.7296742796897888,
0.3837292492389679,
-0.514496386051178,
0.4525952637195587,
0.1523059755563736,
-0.5863469243049622,
-0.4400508403778076,
0.29548269510269165,
-0.18655741214752197,
-0.13991525769233704,
0.4997728765010834,
0.7051810026168823,
-0.2581656277179718,
0.4437791109085083,
0.4548981487751007,
0.24370045959949493,
0.7203463912010193,
0.7732707262039185,
1.0319184064865112,
-0.3671434223651886,
0.7559034824371338,
0.04631175473332405,
-0.45135846734046936,
-0.24828146398067474,
-0.7100796103477478,
-0.6620665192604065,
-0.5888528227806091,
-0.2841414511203766,
0.022687777876853943,
0.14581744372844696,
1.0133342742919922,
0.5987246632575989,
-0.8432445526123047,
-0.30359408259391785,
-0.21156512200832367,
0.31878817081451416,
-0.32385751605033875,
-0.1915716826915741,
0.4247109889984131,
-0.4668111503124237,
-0.5087546110153198,
0.5456209778785706,
0.4148298501968384,
-0.16906525194644928,
0.05848133936524391,
-0.10925102978944778,
-0.16557186841964722,
0.27088460326194763,
0.773309588432312,
0.5851836800575256,
-0.7931594848632812,
-0.4117988049983978,
0.1784907579421997,
0.17474909126758575,
0.40699443221092224,
0.9870067834854126,
-0.9512879848480225,
0.3962666094303131,
0.5387040376663208,
0.555084228515625,
0.29479265213012695,
0.03494958207011223,
0.5497702360153198,
-0.5414018630981445,
-0.10022170096635818,
0.1551356017589569,
0.39973869919776917,
0.06358468532562256,
-0.5856448411941528,
0.2119123339653015,
-0.39594322443008423,
-0.5886462926864624,
-0.4316590130329132,
0.226920485496521,
-1.5519180297851562,
-0.03386871889233589,
1.0851112604141235,
-0.1736377477645874,
-0.5178927183151245,
-0.7417756915092468,
-0.8863810896873474,
-0.07704583555459976,
-0.5077232122421265,
0.7014935612678528,
0.48283299803733826,
-0.6958910226821899,
-0.44382473826408386,
-0.3285607695579529,
0.5323445200920105,
0.25500035285949707,
-0.8468132019042969,
0.44054949283599854,
0.5381807684898376,
-0.05050179734826088,
0.11793849617242813,
0.562435507774353,
-0.09642264991998672,
0.5668772459030151,
-0.45073631405830383,
-0.14388883113861084,
0.2747536599636078,
-0.10406868159770966,
-0.39389631152153015,
0.31238430738449097,
0.045533761382102966,
-0.18942835927009583
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.08100v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.08100v1
|
Multimodal Table Understanding
| 2024-06-12T11:27:03 | 2024-06-12T11:27:03 |
Mingyu Zheng, Xinwei Feng, Qingyi Si, Qiaoqiao She, Zheng Lin, Wenbin Jiang, Weiping Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Although great progress has been made by previous table understanding methods
including recent approaches based on large language models (LLMs), they rely
heavily on the premise that given tables must be converted into a certain text
sequence (such as Markdown or HTML) to serve as model input. However, it is
difficult to access such high-quality textual table representations in some
real-world scenarios, and table images are much more accessible. Therefore, how
to directly understand tables using intuitive visual information is a crucial
and urgent challenge for developing more practical applications. In this paper,
we propose a new problem, multimodal table understanding, where the model needs
to generate correct responses to various table-related requests based on the
given table image. To facilitate both the model training and evaluation, we
construct a large-scale dataset named MMTab, which covers a wide spectrum of
table images, instructions and tasks. On this basis, we develop Table-LLaVA, a
generalist tabular multimodal large language model (MLLM), which significantly
outperforms recent open-source MLLM baselines on 23 benchmarks under held-in
and held-out settings. The code and data is available at this
https://github.com/SpursGoZmy/Table-LLaVA
|
[
-0.27850642800331116,
-1.073789119720459,
0.8076316118240356,
0.14288130402565002,
-0.36138784885406494,
-0.19016475975513458,
-0.1188933402299881,
-0.44764354825019836,
0.047645453363657,
0.536037802696228,
-0.6177716255187988,
-0.5640956163406372,
-0.5149123668670654,
0.01921115815639496,
-0.4435177743434906,
0.7571285963058472,
-0.1705782413482666,
0.22045733034610748,
-0.48147550225257874,
-0.19687996804714203,
-0.6897947788238525,
-0.19670435786247253,
-0.043600983917713165,
-0.3055935800075531,
0.9505308866500854,
0.7108732461929321,
0.5503710508346558,
0.5713421702384949,
0.5928213000297546,
0.2852035164833069,
0.31012770533561707,
0.28995901346206665,
-0.2790581285953522,
0.1997944861650467,
0.12645670771598816,
-0.5707721710205078,
-0.5910134315490723,
-0.3219018578529358,
0.40170809626579285,
0.3538273572921753,
-0.20062118768692017,
0.4888693392276764,
-0.09874098747968674,
0.6905207633972168,
-0.29377350211143494,
0.8170197606086731,
-0.8749180436134338,
0.25628718733787537,
-0.37717264890670776,
-0.15310731530189514,
-0.8998381495475769,
-0.15517102181911469,
-0.14184992015361786,
-0.7454448342323303,
-0.2278650403022766,
0.3588073253631592,
0.6884250640869141,
0.024549050256609917,
-0.9844473004341125,
-0.27656522393226624,
-0.5947146415710449,
0.4277055263519287,
-0.3271283507347107,
0.8673458695411682,
0.5154822468757629,
0.8361957669258118,
-0.2861250936985016,
-0.6977186799049377,
-1.065532922744751,
-0.586082935333252,
-0.12385335564613342,
-0.0725259929895401,
-0.004725422244518995,
-0.2148929089307785,
0.18133413791656494,
0.07617496699094772,
-0.7719348669052124,
0.020841296762228012,
0.025416331365704536,
-0.023952582851052284,
0.09383384883403778,
0.38163989782333374,
0.4443168044090271,
-0.2587793171405792,
-0.4504769742488861,
-0.1450943946838379,
-0.5465481877326965,
0.10209567099809647,
-0.13662371039390564,
0.26022303104400635,
-0.30168822407722473,
0.7811605334281921,
0.017789006233215332,
1.0292317867279053,
-0.31982406973838806,
-0.38543015718460083,
0.24625732004642487,
-0.26358628273010254,
-0.3621983826160431,
-0.4569013714790344,
0.4506962299346924,
0.5157765746116638,
0.22889046370983124,
-0.14042183756828308,
-0.13837245106697083,
0.24282261729240417,
0.16916155815124512,
-0.5473580360412598,
-0.061250317841768265,
0.10127884894609451,
-0.33343711495399475,
-0.10249773412942886,
-0.2469029426574707,
-0.9216786026954651,
-0.5590560436248779,
-0.7013950943946838,
0.5777347683906555,
-0.24944211542606354,
-0.13130123913288116,
-0.37235718965530396,
0.1655639410018921,
0.46827182173728943,
0.7157699465751648,
-0.86281818151474,
-0.10000734031200409,
0.27861395478248596,
0.6340169310569763,
-0.00875985436141491,
-0.16517682373523712,
-0.6483731865882874,
0.5606377720832825,
-0.256782203912735,
0.8948333859443665,
-0.6996010541915894,
-0.1493872106075287,
-0.07801578938961029,
0.014244254678487778,
-0.06067546457052231,
-0.2563423812389374,
0.2957559823989868,
-0.5733491778373718,
-0.04633322358131409,
-0.26506221294403076,
-0.06523693352937698,
-0.3218567967414856,
0.5851824283599854,
-0.908035397529602,
0.45187485218048096,
-0.21148687601089478,
-0.5253888368606567,
0.7063881158828735,
-0.731685221195221,
-0.28114017844200134,
-0.1225653812289238,
-0.2914063036441803,
-0.44811195135116577,
0.07013095170259476,
0.5988883376121521,
0.6097975969314575,
-0.39823442697525024,
0.4040222764015198,
-0.489256888628006,
0.10386683791875839,
0.48664286732673645,
-0.40225398540496826,
0.16009226441383362,
0.2947344481945038,
0.1222950667142868,
0.4456850588321686,
-0.8150929808616638,
-0.05050893500447273,
0.28189584612846375,
-0.5981481671333313,
-0.032965242862701416,
-0.057569365948438644,
0.3236333429813385,
0.3311578035354614,
-0.049906279891729355,
-0.25844502449035645,
0.26334378123283386,
0.2517184019088745,
0.5147002935409546,
0.7127116918563843,
-0.24895092844963074,
0.3921455144882202,
-0.13084776699543,
0.2088049203157425,
0.17109403014183044,
0.16320817172527313,
-0.3025863468647003,
-0.3157613277435303,
-0.6808018088340759,
-0.357211172580719,
0.34329670667648315,
0.5622931122779846,
-1.2280410528182983,
-0.2667665183544159,
-0.3935364782810211,
-0.2916375994682312,
-0.2738299071788788,
0.2794627249240875,
0.3180338144302368,
0.8049064874649048,
0.5064302086830139,
-0.1609676331281662,
-0.47867265343666077,
-1.068198800086975,
-0.119923435151577,
0.06052530184388161,
-0.001083958544768393,
0.5859224796295166,
0.6300665736198425,
-0.32606786489486694,
0.5995376706123352,
-0.2562517821788788,
-0.47677889466285706,
-0.5085198879241943,
0.12258751690387726,
0.21887242794036865,
0.3908124268054962,
0.28744804859161377,
-0.7714526653289795,
-0.49360963702201843,
0.44817620515823364,
-0.8338795900344849,
0.2534353733062744,
-0.2312793731689453,
-0.21886275708675385,
0.16556859016418457,
0.31463783979415894,
-0.6597501039505005,
0.19679446518421173,
0.4416484236717224,
-0.269025593996048,
0.3345158100128174,
-0.14117008447647095,
0.16530771553516388,
-0.956447184085846,
0.21364927291870117,
0.13271202147006989,
-0.379202663898468,
-0.7610543966293335,
0.22196562588214874,
0.5174465179443359,
-0.27636685967445374,
-0.5212194919586182,
0.44078412652015686,
-0.7891600728034973,
-0.31163015961647034,
0.2601858675479889,
0.06508301943540573,
0.05120139196515083,
0.7814300656318665,
-0.16838331520557404,
0.6261823177337646,
0.15121111273765564,
-0.30925536155700684,
0.36586758494377136,
0.41447311639785767,
-0.5222671031951904,
0.6446366310119629,
-0.3656351864337921,
0.09655430912971497,
-0.3996674716472626,
0.3012542724609375,
-1.1423834562301636,
-0.5700082778930664,
0.354811429977417,
-0.18125024437904358,
0.6042803525924683,
-0.22452498972415924,
-0.4603649377822876,
-0.3733564019203186,
-0.1770818531513214,
0.09259552508592606,
0.09448393434286118,
-0.4864388108253479,
1.1688820123672485,
0.5373534560203552,
-0.020708471536636353,
-1.0052434206008911,
-0.7642802000045776,
0.21032162010669708,
-0.10561610758304596,
-0.7005611658096313,
0.1558978259563446,
-0.004916854668408632,
-0.3517177999019623,
-0.31297576427459717,
-0.20286451280117035,
-0.1630898416042328,
-0.1390865594148636,
0.35473963618278503,
0.14743652939796448,
-0.10025566816329956,
0.33829325437545776,
-0.07186417281627655,
0.07243626564741135,
-0.01821582205593586,
0.19026823341846466,
0.7945893406867981,
-0.22579734027385712,
-0.3337644636631012,
-0.6194987297058105,
0.1288032829761505,
0.7893722057342529,
-0.36836427450180054,
0.5651187896728516,
0.7168883085250854,
-0.14684270322322845,
-0.042434144765138626,
-0.5348720550537109,
-0.0015152754494920373,
-0.3979758620262146,
0.6235222816467285,
-0.6392515301704407,
-0.4464578628540039,
0.7075672149658203,
0.18585337698459625,
0.145594522356987,
0.18980053067207336,
0.6969836950302124,
-0.4823282063007355,
0.8389680981636047,
0.5808014273643494,
0.24272893369197845,
0.3569128215312958,
-0.05001922324299812,
-0.30839356780052185,
-0.4696830213069916,
-0.6879927515983582,
-0.5782551765441895,
-0.47614166140556335,
-0.2766605615615845,
-0.49990594387054443,
0.4563548266887665,
-0.5490551590919495,
0.06535331904888153,
0.17506806552410126,
0.09540273994207382,
0.5703645944595337,
0.3805001676082611,
0.6002037525177002,
0.4969388544559479,
0.23532406985759735,
-0.15188360214233398,
-0.018791014328598976,
-0.47931140661239624,
-0.38853728771209717,
0.849777102470398,
0.42207440733909607,
1.1379038095474243,
0.22695626318454742,
0.29384008049964905,
0.305634081363678,
0.5212459564208984,
-0.6428882479667664,
0.6393924355506897,
-0.07366960495710373,
-0.6110281944274902,
-0.28756430745124817,
-0.5235570669174194,
-0.9489604830741882,
0.6613829135894775,
-0.585702121257782,
-0.4430360794067383,
-0.01994030922651291,
0.39148563146591187,
0.1762048900127411,
0.1694115251302719,
-0.9783671498298645,
1.1663672924041748,
-0.4077419638633728,
-0.5427617430686951,
-0.09788045287132263,
-0.6391555666923523,
0.6901124119758606,
0.033021315932273865,
0.567646324634552,
-0.22655221819877625,
-0.013120567426085472,
0.48257941007614136,
-0.1020246148109436,
0.7332165837287903,
-0.30459117889404297,
-0.19732904434204102,
-0.05835868418216705,
0.36788856983184814,
0.3825157880783081,
0.14009171724319458,
0.17050877213478088,
-0.23871253430843353,
-0.17072199285030365,
-0.26489701867103577,
-0.6325540542602539,
0.5628790259361267,
-0.5465614199638367,
-0.4543839693069458,
-0.04732738435268402,
-0.9478669762611389,
-0.3162676990032196,
0.010937575250864029,
-0.3381480872631073,
0.6450852155685425,
0.0640534907579422,
0.31127747893333435,
0.4272564649581909,
-0.39279884099960327,
0.4316178858280182,
0.40574270486831665,
-0.5326719284057617,
-0.3329509496688843,
0.8497307896614075,
0.16300523281097412,
-0.11609099060297012,
0.6560295820236206,
-0.12309105694293976,
-0.5753037333488464,
-0.4346594214439392,
-0.880933403968811,
0.07731951773166656,
-0.8300639986991882,
-0.2963452935218811,
-0.5758489966392517,
0.4876652657985687,
0.09426362812519073,
0.14841103553771973,
0.22759033739566803,
-0.36229467391967773,
-0.13319221138954163,
-0.1561238318681717,
0.3724574148654938,
0.6908000111579895,
0.31527647376060486,
0.31219014525413513,
-0.8055421113967896,
0.5483968257904053,
0.6727610230445862,
0.3527151048183441,
0.18001751601696014,
-0.41249534487724304,
0.061019379645586014,
-0.10081406682729721,
-0.11335423588752747,
-1.3015027046203613,
0.5773984789848328,
0.36015692353248596,
0.83039391040802,
0.16609656810760498,
-0.3985404074192047,
0.7744361758232117,
-0.7224433422088623,
0.45989489555358887,
0.30556151270866394,
-0.9213845133781433,
0.40907201170921326,
-0.39698314666748047,
0.44429999589920044,
0.42513614892959595,
0.3346649408340454,
-0.4270994961261749,
-0.0067492579109966755,
0.1465967446565628,
-0.8913585543632507,
0.5023671388626099,
-0.16514790058135986,
0.1535806506872177,
0.22832444310188293,
-0.017035193741321564,
0.4946845769882202,
0.3428025245666504,
-1.5064154863357544,
0.18343569338321686,
-0.1245526671409607,
-0.24874547123908997,
-0.005690968595445156,
-0.3394900858402252,
-0.06333167850971222,
-0.12248095870018005,
0.27833816409111023,
-0.1789184957742691,
0.3018820285797119,
-0.24976471066474915,
-1.0485975742340088,
0.03549611568450928,
0.5552040934562683,
0.9560486674308777,
0.9300403594970703,
-0.19878347218036652,
0.4790800213813782,
0.2477537989616394,
-0.43093085289001465,
0.18353700637817383,
-0.0977460965514183,
0.2973208427429199,
-0.10374770313501358,
0.2653864622116089,
0.7123151421546936,
0.09938836097717285,
-0.6540348529815674,
0.2648713290691376,
-0.2834538221359253,
-0.11789707839488983,
0.013514488935470581,
-0.2762720286846161,
0.16643297672271729,
0.322367399930954,
0.35280194878578186,
-0.30211398005485535,
0.060525082051754,
-0.80258709192276,
0.38136398792266846,
0.6068886518478394,
-0.1448211371898651,
-0.1582786738872528,
0.7330831289291382,
0.248183012008667,
-0.14034411311149597,
0.6431050896644592,
0.15728315711021423,
-0.09986259788274765,
0.5437528491020203,
0.5570715069770813,
0.20306682586669922,
0.013135815970599651,
0.31212007999420166,
0.204220712184906,
0.3965480327606201,
0.3736804723739624,
0.6103905439376831,
-0.22099368274211884,
-0.39696159958839417,
-0.5532864332199097,
-0.6872178316116333,
-0.3578161597251892,
0.08710917085409164,
-0.45862019062042236,
0.059671130031347275,
-0.3446716070175171,
-0.2601923942565918,
0.27602481842041016,
-0.50431889295578,
-0.786140501499176,
-0.004180006217211485,
0.17471227049827576,
0.6939959526062012,
-0.7761325836181641,
0.860727846622467,
0.49293676018714905,
-0.5766943097114563,
-0.6252617835998535,
-0.42842549085617065,
-0.047419048845767975,
-1.1381796598434448,
0.9249489903450012,
0.2208654284477234,
0.2719057500362396,
-0.31145259737968445,
-0.6115816831588745,
-0.6171690821647644,
1.0015710592269897,
0.5250263810157776,
-0.747654139995575,
0.0005262360791675746,
0.3982276916503906,
0.29890304803848267,
-0.1421113759279251,
0.41598761081695557,
0.3967743217945099,
0.9287344217300415,
-0.044404882937669754,
-0.9301148056983948,
0.035081133246421814,
-0.26121464371681213,
-0.03445468097925186,
0.2982425391674042,
-0.2318994402885437,
0.829975962638855,
-0.23326267302036285,
0.05536125227808952,
-0.3878544569015503,
0.6652494072914124,
0.013957151211798191,
0.3895431458950043,
0.4641038179397583,
0.5778195858001709,
0.38386815786361694,
-0.2491806298494339,
0.8130181431770325,
0.1809849739074707,
-0.04370885714888573,
1.1417951583862305,
-0.3115055561065674,
0.9541692733764648,
0.7145434021949768,
-0.14625637233257294,
0.33303436636924744,
0.501365602016449,
-0.07347891479730606,
0.4426553547382355,
0.1295391470193863,
0.1143440380692482,
-0.1488136202096939,
0.03069666214287281,
-0.3853648602962494,
0.7284882664680481,
0.5743066668510437,
-0.4408559501171112,
-0.6050831079483032,
0.15799935162067413,
-0.18839150667190552,
0.0440409854054451,
-0.5161281228065491,
0.9149574041366577,
-0.13322539627552032,
-0.159122034907341,
0.46054697036743164,
-0.13278332352638245,
0.3678382635116577,
-0.5193347930908203,
-0.3141618072986603,
-0.29297351837158203,
-0.16822336614131927,
-0.17726166546344757,
-0.8605788946151733,
0.11371467262506485,
-0.08854888379573822,
-0.13429223001003265,
-0.0884508341550827,
0.49056658148765564,
-0.6492185592651367,
-0.3071155548095703,
-0.006260883063077927,
0.8503226637840271,
0.04224969819188118,
0.18519015610218048,
-0.5908679962158203,
0.35664063692092896,
-0.003567027859389782,
-0.22741858661174774,
0.4915492534637451,
0.32305508852005005,
-0.12398219108581543,
0.8283783197402954,
0.6112498044967651,
-0.5435223579406738,
0.041962847113609314,
0.10513422638177872,
0.7333294749259949,
-0.47291356325149536,
-0.3842242658138275,
-0.9839701652526855,
0.6835397481918335,
0.1629725843667984,
0.01478227972984314,
0.47253212332725525,
0.2516474425792694,
0.4332601726055145,
-0.6770341992378235,
0.21158170700073242,
0.08216962963342667,
0.022034741938114166,
-0.8640701770782471,
0.8886651992797852,
-0.8299965858459473,
-0.015280017629265785,
-0.37204709649086,
-0.941177248954773,
-0.6279452443122864,
0.563187301158905,
-0.26415684819221497,
-0.1383085995912552,
0.3959338963031769,
0.6800766587257385,
-0.10943061113357544,
-0.3035902678966522,
0.45230093598365784,
0.3249650001525879,
0.3409898281097412,
0.5152971744537354,
0.9883912205696106,
0.06363565474748611,
0.8073703050613403,
0.09816673398017883,
-0.054905641824007034,
-0.25315824151039124,
-0.9131001830101013,
-0.7650359869003296,
-0.7661651968955994,
0.3132462203502655,
-0.02959754504263401,
0.08492885529994965,
0.8874975442886353,
0.5426814556121826,
-0.5563333630561829,
-0.3812532126903534,
0.24291439354419708,
0.15819352865219116,
0.08566246926784515,
-0.11532684415578842,
0.2187434881925583,
-0.14609959721565247,
-0.48452872037887573,
0.20478622615337372,
0.18993745744228363,
0.2891537547111511,
-0.0040656705386936665,
0.24691519141197205,
-0.4799061119556427,
-0.12319330126047134,
0.9155529737472534,
0.07938803732395172,
-0.8175661563873291,
-0.14226114749908447,
-0.06152108311653137,
-0.038395583629608154,
0.37505999207496643,
0.5011800527572632,
-0.5657367706298828,
0.4395936131477356,
0.4076509475708008,
0.6346246004104614,
0.7245728373527527,
-0.21403519809246063,
0.36652758717536926,
-0.7189196944236755,
0.26254501938819885,
0.07224169373512268,
0.612407386302948,
0.1891033947467804,
-0.07886790484189987,
0.45725730061531067,
-0.24940302968025208,
-0.3351083993911743,
-0.9626076817512512,
0.3238038122653961,
-1.3423315286636353,
-0.2596378028392792,
0.7617163062095642,
0.27069923281669617,
-0.6888276934623718,
0.025848576799035072,
-0.4949430823326111,
0.10400260984897614,
-0.5111192464828491,
0.8409234881401062,
0.4583795964717865,
-0.17123174667358398,
-0.6701024174690247,
-0.7142215371131897,
0.23639751970767975,
0.19560688734054565,
-1.171074628829956,
0.1748858541250229,
0.8310741782188416,
-0.030362548306584358,
0.09612593054771423,
0.22219033539295197,
-0.13748987019062042,
0.29596588015556335,
-0.04318626597523689,
0.325931578874588,
-0.33271709084510803,
-0.6772533655166626,
-0.05955802649259567,
0.4777377247810364,
0.14214026927947998,
-0.0744919702410698
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.08092v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.08092v1
|
Languages Transferred Within the Encoder: On Representation Transfer in Zero-Shot Multilingual Translation
| 2024-06-12T11:16:30 | 2024-06-12T11:16:30 |
Zhi Qu, Chenchen Ding, Taro Watanabe
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Understanding representation transfer in multilingual neural machine
translation can reveal the representational issue causing the zero-shot
translation deficiency. In this work, we introduce the identity pair, a
sentence translated into itself, to address the lack of the base measure in
multilingual investigations, as the identity pair represents the optimal state
of representation among any language transfers. In our analysis, we demonstrate
that the encoder transfers the source language to the representational subspace
of the target language instead of the language-agnostic state. Thus, the
zero-shot translation deficiency arises because representations are entangled
with other languages and are not transferred effectively to the target
language. Based on our findings, we propose two methods: 1) low-rank
language-specific embedding at the encoder, and 2) language-specific
contrastive learning of the representation at the decoder. The experimental
results on Europarl-15, TED-19, and OPUS-100 datasets show that our methods
substantially enhance the performance of zero-shot translations by improving
language transfer capacity, thereby providing practical evidence to support our
conclusions.
|
[
-0.16297630965709686,
-0.2272816151380539,
0.3817148506641388,
0.031263068318367004,
-0.17441512644290924,
0.29581835865974426,
-0.2661830484867096,
-0.4138982594013214,
0.493161141872406,
0.18534274399280548,
0.02047860622406006,
-0.0722033828496933,
-0.7585535645484924,
0.13989506661891937,
-0.2989298403263092,
0.9666581153869629,
-0.3899734616279602,
0.15722618997097015,
-0.2914740741252899,
-0.5369538068771362,
-0.46248042583465576,
-0.6526393294334412,
-0.5198774933815002,
-0.5380944013595581,
0.5112965703010559,
0.19756591320037842,
0.5296451449394226,
0.6228484511375427,
0.5097910165786743,
0.2633064091205597,
0.1387234777212143,
-0.2885088324546814,
-0.46795132756233215,
0.19374041259288788,
-0.17366819083690643,
-0.6975111365318298,
-0.17556077241897583,
-0.4366961419582367,
0.8406683206558228,
0.842058539390564,
0.26677238941192627,
0.09606365859508514,
0.01441086083650589,
0.31764617562294006,
-0.8469710350036621,
0.11872581392526627,
-0.46868377923965454,
0.31249186396598816,
-0.245248481631279,
-0.29377278685569763,
-0.4681295156478882,
0.1050754114985466,
-0.25910642743110657,
-0.27653059363365173,
0.08356557041406631,
-0.1957181990146637,
0.6229001879692078,
0.15284329652786255,
-0.6707947254180908,
-0.0024804212152957916,
-0.8347342610359192,
0.5660682916641235,
-0.3748714327812195,
0.2952422797679901,
0.04626114293932915,
0.1337839514017105,
0.3572787642478943,
-0.03310799226164818,
-0.5914273262023926,
-0.2122056782245636,
-0.248170405626297,
0.26706334948539734,
-0.3258092403411865,
-0.11614112555980682,
0.02917996421456337,
0.3958841562271118,
-0.6933748126029968,
0.09348730742931366,
-0.49800634384155273,
-0.27001118659973145,
0.6045265793800354,
-0.09708701819181442,
0.37667158246040344,
-0.06005364656448364,
-0.2971506416797638,
-0.20331121981143951,
-0.6899110674858093,
-0.08753011375665665,
0.24794043600559235,
0.2662045657634735,
-0.2021780163049698,
0.5910167098045349,
0.13671447336673737,
0.6218503713607788,
-0.020496197044849396,
0.12125147879123688,
0.4988016188144684,
-0.4184827506542206,
0.007008883636444807,
0.430759072303772,
0.7372979521751404,
0.15563707053661346,
0.2531532943248749,
-0.6267392635345459,
-0.14611345529556274,
0.1272205263376236,
0.01594419963657856,
-0.738223671913147,
0.13319800794124603,
-0.04545332118868828,
-0.2340523600578308,
0.006847037468105555,
0.005174329038709402,
-0.3333894908428192,
-0.12314625829458237,
-0.05747080594301224,
0.7070112824440002,
-0.31624287366867065,
-0.32117873430252075,
0.03369584679603577,
-0.1998334676027298,
0.46168825030326843,
-0.12975828349590302,
-0.9601513743400574,
0.2196781486272812,
0.09822875261306763,
0.7197834253311157,
-0.33860647678375244,
-0.43276792764663696,
-0.22905215620994568,
0.4561978876590729,
-0.6425256729125977,
0.5851796865463257,
-0.2700549364089966,
-0.14575426280498505,
0.17539574205875397,
0.15204685926437378,
-0.28575950860977173,
-0.4915236830711365,
0.02944587916135788,
-0.29233959317207336,
0.0005087681347504258,
-0.3391895592212677,
-0.42553606629371643,
-0.09943177551031113,
0.17959332466125488,
-0.4116857051849365,
0.579754114151001,
0.06635010242462158,
-0.23925021290779114,
0.02958793006837368,
-0.6511491537094116,
-0.5848488807678223,
0.16832204163074493,
-0.2944950759410858,
0.01611548475921154,
0.3165791630744934,
0.18447178602218628,
0.3624739646911621,
0.01754872128367424,
-0.1010182648897171,
-0.19201907515525818,
-0.4548391103744507,
0.4076031744480133,
-0.36222124099731445,
0.807830274105072,
0.20139725506305695,
-0.27221745252609253,
-0.2455044686794281,
-0.3927489221096039,
-0.2050510048866272,
0.47721540927886963,
-0.11056247353553772,
-0.34024283289909363,
-0.500284731388092,
-0.024379780516028404,
0.07809419929981232,
0.31938549876213074,
-0.8006183505058289,
0.19470296800136566,
-0.27681678533554077,
0.33428892493247986,
0.40422993898391724,
-0.045154668390750885,
1.0474239587783813,
-0.09671608358621597,
0.5987967252731323,
0.3982887864112854,
-0.33382922410964966,
-0.5343360900878906,
-0.31024542450904846,
-1.141165852546692,
0.1744832843542099,
0.4452948272228241,
0.739290714263916,
-0.926460325717926,
0.25178012251853943,
-0.4261320233345032,
0.14798955619335175,
-1.0700374841690063,
-0.0007473152363672853,
0.5701422095298767,
0.21526587009429932,
0.419956237077713,
-0.46217790246009827,
-0.1818493753671646,
-1.191718578338623,
-0.25080275535583496,
-0.10112268477678299,
0.19509102404117584,
-0.08202871680259705,
0.4798458218574524,
-0.05831999331712723,
0.3836122453212738,
-0.23865793645381927,
-0.3919256925582886,
-0.35604357719421387,
0.12870322167873383,
0.010286732576787472,
0.7073765993118286,
0.8850399255752563,
-0.5330818891525269,
-0.6529363393783569,
0.47686198353767395,
-0.9932345151901245,
0.11041207611560822,
-0.386976957321167,
-0.060118090361356735,
0.33652567863464355,
0.5032575130462646,
-0.459541380405426,
0.3009044826030731,
0.6327283382415771,
-0.281653493642807,
0.028046341612935066,
-0.4589555561542511,
0.42558225989341736,
-1.1221518516540527,
0.17948932945728302,
-0.325656533241272,
-0.3771519064903259,
-0.7359486222267151,
0.39761096239089966,
0.16216349601745605,
-0.3053167164325714,
-0.4650871157646179,
0.4085090160369873,
-0.6747745871543884,
-0.30240291357040405,
-0.12057400494813919,
0.14597934484481812,
-0.036884356290102005,
0.5280222296714783,
-0.16269855201244354,
0.7303289175033569,
0.6513045430183411,
-0.2685009837150574,
0.35784369707107544,
0.266262024641037,
0.17857052385807037,
0.8997577428817749,
-0.5351539254188538,
0.39900216460227966,
-0.41149717569351196,
-0.057480212301015854,
-0.8896346688270569,
0.08045016974210739,
0.5559130311012268,
-0.6939674615859985,
0.7150177955627441,
-0.30131056904792786,
-0.32930827140808105,
0.12531042098999023,
0.06553015857934952,
0.5455475449562073,
0.6162393093109131,
-0.21972404420375824,
0.10801707953214645,
0.23513630032539368,
-0.050264857709407806,
-0.46720266342163086,
-1.3485759496688843,
0.4417910575866699,
-0.08997916430234909,
-0.35528573393821716,
0.6751424670219421,
-0.07021843641996384,
0.047503869980573654,
0.43320974707603455,
0.03762861341238022,
-0.1709413230419159,
-0.09629795700311661,
-0.1694963276386261,
-0.08130457997322083,
-0.48482319712638855,
0.256803959608078,
0.0374365858733654,
-0.21375738084316254,
-0.03049158863723278,
-0.1693265587091446,
0.24316631257534027,
-0.04260043799877167,
-0.6150456070899963,
-0.22590523958206177,
0.7288616299629211,
0.5092953443527222,
-0.359551340341568,
0.9176630973815918,
0.5865441560745239,
-0.36936336755752563,
0.04890048876404762,
-0.16046074032783508,
0.0024739918299019337,
-0.3307196795940399,
0.44324755668640137,
-0.6623018383979797,
-0.7422423958778381,
0.7063875198364258,
0.21744151413440704,
-0.2472451627254486,
0.5716603994369507,
0.3779740333557129,
0.0954408124089241,
0.8941484093666077,
0.7206830978393555,
-0.26231229305267334,
0.37006768584251404,
-0.34686994552612305,
0.3794099688529968,
-0.8662042021751404,
-0.1637207567691803,
-0.5171003341674805,
-0.609404444694519,
-0.4528679847717285,
-0.43203818798065186,
0.23102295398712158,
0.22683751583099365,
-0.20775721967220306,
0.5779388546943665,
-0.30539000034332275,
0.6626235842704773,
0.3425122797489166,
-0.12048783153295517,
0.28667616844177246,
0.21648043394088745,
-0.15892024338245392,
-0.4171265959739685,
-0.7930721640586853,
-0.0961238220334053,
0.9879611134529114,
0.09864005446434021,
0.37511008977890015,
0.4364947974681854,
0.904628336429596,
0.15016116201877594,
0.0656718760728836,
-0.8192614316940308,
0.2288057804107666,
-0.28762051463127136,
-0.32844826579093933,
0.08857230097055435,
-0.41113612055778503,
-0.9647570848464966,
0.6129998564720154,
-0.1768699288368225,
-0.5799970030784607,
0.4359215795993805,
-0.11745095998048782,
-0.04866141453385353,
0.1892387419939041,
-0.650027334690094,
0.9954847097396851,
-0.448854923248291,
-0.23760704696178436,
-0.1568903774023056,
-0.5056002140045166,
0.21382679045200348,
-0.006437905132770538,
-0.042395468801259995,
0.2037079632282257,
-0.07689394801855087,
0.3780600428581238,
0.12457820773124695,
0.4015304744243622,
-0.060534246265888214,
-0.048561494797468185,
-0.08719362318515778,
0.3529401123523712,
0.1642991453409195,
-0.2766972482204437,
0.004574157763272524,
0.1794338971376419,
-0.24988041818141937,
-0.6066567301750183,
-0.8400341272354126,
0.6895497441291809,
-0.8323498368263245,
-0.3395605981349945,
-0.4830504059791565,
-0.44247937202453613,
-0.056881383061409,
0.18632426857948303,
0.3963196575641632,
0.1610422432422638,
-0.2006426900625229,
0.3909948170185089,
0.5127888917922974,
-0.08553770929574966,
0.6410173177719116,
0.5181012153625488,
-0.1923452466726303,
-0.156328946352005,
1.0532195568084717,
0.3538219630718231,
0.4149317741394043,
0.5737950801849365,
-0.16491974890232086,
-0.10743463039398193,
-0.5995815396308899,
-0.8553071618080139,
0.2410193532705307,
-0.912612795829773,
-0.16666699945926666,
-0.46347424387931824,
-0.3245137929916382,
-0.5005908608436584,
-0.3106095492839813,
-0.5212678909301758,
-0.4479912221431732,
-0.22870293259620667,
-0.04142758250236511,
-0.048945724964141846,
0.5166306495666504,
-0.10000386089086533,
0.24529673159122467,
-0.8636599183082581,
0.42157894372940063,
0.07502836734056473,
0.03222636878490448,
-0.17393247783184052,
-0.7996668815612793,
-0.46706077456474304,
0.10523078590631485,
-0.16857346892356873,
-1.1423718929290771,
0.363766610622406,
0.4917886257171631,
0.922256588935852,
0.17656978964805603,
0.03511020541191101,
0.7913342714309692,
-0.42607009410858154,
0.6817806363105774,
0.3049474358558655,
-1.017726182937622,
0.38481295108795166,
-0.052688807249069214,
0.5965122580528259,
0.35279956459999084,
0.3692735433578491,
-0.77573162317276,
-0.4398549795150757,
-0.44917023181915283,
-0.649393618106842,
0.6643627882003784,
0.2593713104724884,
0.5030590295791626,
-0.0037294027861207724,
0.24296791851520538,
-0.13076448440551758,
0.0009963472839444876,
-1.0046600103378296,
-0.4734766185283661,
-0.11689798533916473,
-0.09272808581590652,
-0.4275585114955902,
0.05884188041090965,
-0.08147882670164108,
-0.20428918302059174,
0.24635329842567444,
-0.37790146470069885,
0.7014844417572021,
0.33513277769088745,
-0.6960332989692688,
-0.1869698017835617,
0.33700427412986755,
0.4816632568836212,
0.43861281871795654,
0.08246808499097824,
0.3811991810798645,
0.17448890209197998,
0.019614484161138535,
0.4305424690246582,
-0.02463841810822487,
-0.33797675371170044,
0.26119017601013184,
0.42634519934654236,
1.026300072669983,
0.3081471621990204,
-0.11084578931331635,
0.8025705218315125,
0.43794921040534973,
-0.11263512074947357,
-0.09892137348651886,
-0.28642597794532776,
0.19351963698863983,
0.1816609650850296,
0.30253511667251587,
0.2570539116859436,
0.23126213252544403,
-0.6434749960899353,
0.028987739235162735,
0.320962518453598,
-0.5543707609176636,
-0.5922015309333801,
0.49450358748435974,
0.13559381663799286,
-0.19067256152629852,
0.4914253056049347,
-0.3189983069896698,
-0.48644816875457764,
0.5768301486968994,
0.9248753190040588,
0.976844310760498,
-0.4173688292503357,
0.39551299810409546,
0.43773144483566284,
0.5029017925262451,
0.09513108432292938,
-0.0776134803891182,
-0.11286496371030807,
-1.0626187324523926,
-0.423939973115921,
-0.31463122367858887,
-0.13256466388702393,
-0.14678452908992767,
-0.7765108346939087,
-0.082012839615345,
0.16014966368675232,
0.15114936232566833,
-0.10521532595157623,
-0.38586729764938354,
-0.6776064038276672,
-0.4689984619617462,
0.5465644001960754,
0.3310698866844177,
-0.9551335573196411,
0.9040505886077881,
0.7332139611244202,
-0.7409719228744507,
-0.2511366903781891,
-0.21749307215213776,
-0.2055441439151764,
-0.8324556350708008,
0.6809963583946228,
-0.05829877406358719,
-0.11549177765846252,
0.10981139540672302,
-0.27233436703681946,
-0.766531229019165,
0.7534444332122803,
1.0068145990371704,
-0.3341197371482849,
0.27656909823417664,
0.4682104289531708,
0.6588376760482788,
-0.5438199639320374,
0.023024218156933784,
0.3804520070552826,
0.39299988746643066,
0.02927481383085251,
-0.8379898071289062,
0.053371768444776535,
-0.2299525886774063,
0.17090751230716705,
0.28421252965927124,
-0.44800201058387756,
0.8523776531219482,
-0.10584046691656113,
-0.35195392370224,
-0.0797947496175766,
0.34479019045829773,
-0.2497798204421997,
0.011697139590978622,
-0.07224510610103607,
0.7013264298439026,
0.2786802351474762,
0.10709042847156525,
1.0923762321472168,
-0.22947441041469574,
0.2891654670238495,
0.7910452485084534,
-0.24222277104854584,
1.0854921340942383,
0.6834102272987366,
-0.13400223851203918,
0.3058781325817108,
0.12861084938049316,
0.05369918420910835,
0.6165388226509094,
0.06734969466924667,
-0.31244274973869324,
-0.14524689316749573,
-0.18217775225639343,
-0.44762736558914185,
0.640030026435852,
0.1607494354248047,
-0.4713369905948639,
-0.33032646775245667,
0.24435490369796753,
0.10294368118047714,
0.139659583568573,
-0.1444597691297531,
0.9108063578605652,
0.09792160242795944,
-0.6509692072868347,
0.8279367089271545,
-0.012369112111628056,
0.6122874021530151,
-0.43831169605255127,
-0.16545669734477997,
-0.5836979150772095,
0.30784374475479126,
-0.059025052934885025,
-0.7013406157493591,
0.5813833475112915,
-0.23887377977371216,
-0.14145325124263763,
-0.6975090503692627,
0.6389080882072449,
-0.923793375492096,
-0.420550674200058,
0.5411748290061951,
0.7278503179550171,
0.44033288955688477,
-0.04568452015519142,
-0.6471038460731506,
-0.02379610948264599,
0.00431082071736455,
0.1522027999162674,
0.6382001638412476,
0.32373684644699097,
0.012385549955070019,
0.1410711705684662,
0.39280813932418823,
0.34337756037712097,
0.25196653604507446,
-0.0712955892086029,
0.48681002855300903,
-0.6639733910560608,
-0.3095971941947937,
-0.7525650262832642,
0.39586278796195984,
0.15968072414398193,
-0.27779749035835266,
0.7014227509498596,
0.46512964367866516,
1.0302613973617554,
-0.18863412737846375,
0.7293674349784851,
-0.11148682236671448,
-0.13708394765853882,
-0.38293638825416565,
0.8477835655212402,
-0.5990211963653564,
-0.2596622705459595,
0.20768725872039795,
-1.063219666481018,
-0.4838777184486389,
0.6627027988433838,
0.09775189310312271,
-0.3583969473838806,
0.871080219745636,
0.6392636895179749,
-0.038794707506895065,
-0.7025955319404602,
0.6585885286331177,
-0.044595349580049515,
0.07221975922584534,
0.9094887375831604,
0.5488407015800476,
-0.8863306641578674,
0.6311431527137756,
-0.2596440613269806,
0.04656298831105232,
-0.17379005253314972,
-0.6728912591934204,
-0.5057654976844788,
-0.6039679050445557,
-0.5379433035850525,
-0.0623079389333725,
0.25563591718673706,
0.5019078254699707,
0.6010434627532959,
-0.8098331689834595,
-0.5392042398452759,
0.08439508825540543,
0.08234623074531555,
-0.26371899247169495,
-0.14632806181907654,
0.0723189264535904,
-0.6349372863769531,
-0.8260076642036438,
0.513883113861084,
0.3788592517375946,
0.10888368636369705,
-0.42457032203674316,
-0.30370524525642395,
-0.1232961118221283,
-0.2920660674571991,
0.6358743906021118,
0.3732336461544037,
-0.6335031986236572,
-0.2738510072231293,
0.1195988580584526,
-0.20182187855243683,
0.27931126952171326,
0.8228937387466431,
-0.6484668850898743,
0.6944702863693237,
0.5545753240585327,
0.9940434694290161,
0.6415070295333862,
-0.4222255349159241,
0.771304190158844,
-0.998132586479187,
0.40126290917396545,
0.1960638165473938,
0.45346271991729736,
0.5966103076934814,
-0.23564891517162323,
0.2328573316335678,
0.37754446268081665,
-0.14508308470249176,
-0.6380847692489624,
0.1859399974346161,
-0.8336132764816284,
-0.29296261072158813,
1.0523452758789062,
-0.3209180533885956,
-0.12811385095119476,
0.06010834500193596,
0.12274004518985748,
0.3074777126312256,
-0.10491949319839478,
0.2768179178237915,
0.6777656078338623,
0.009090976789593697,
-0.5709187388420105,
-0.5595188736915588,
0.07735724002122879,
0.5179092884063721,
-0.5204176306724548,
-0.43605807423591614,
0.2551853656768799,
0.0031968173570930958,
0.5324272513389587,
0.4869629740715027,
-0.22264854609966278,
0.09116114675998688,
0.2434503436088562,
0.31071823835372925,
-0.026553859934210777,
-0.13582776486873627,
-0.8704084157943726,
0.12154742330312729,
0.08548889309167862,
-0.6572137475013733
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.08080v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.08080v1
|
AustroTox: A Dataset for Target-Based Austrian German Offensive Language Detection
| 2024-06-12T11:04:11 | 2024-06-12T11:04:11 |
Pia Pachinger, Janis Goldzycher, Anna Maria Planitzer, Wojciech Kusa, Allan Hanbury, Julia Neidhardt
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY, I.2.7
|
Model interpretability in toxicity detection greatly profits from token-level
annotations. However, currently such annotations are only available in English.
We introduce a dataset annotated for offensive language detection sourced from
a news forum, notable for its incorporation of the Austrian German dialect,
comprising 4,562 user comments. In addition to binary offensiveness
classification, we identify spans within each comment constituting vulgar
language or representing targets of offensive statements. We evaluate
fine-tuned language models as well as large language models in a zero- and
few-shot fashion. The results indicate that while fine-tuned models excel in
detecting linguistic peculiarities such as vulgar dialect, large language
models demonstrate superior performance in detecting offensiveness in
AustroTox. We publish the data and code.
|
[
-0.20699374377727509,
-0.7588218450546265,
0.30488714575767517,
0.18547508120536804,
-0.20585398375988007,
-0.38254693150520325,
-0.20423683524131775,
-0.8195940256118774,
-0.11772511899471283,
0.885032594203949,
-0.3210781514644623,
-0.9462327361106873,
-0.6938176155090332,
0.560605525970459,
-0.8087306618690491,
1.1015019416809082,
0.031777091324329376,
-0.05826588347554207,
0.2896534502506256,
-0.5840089321136475,
-0.12501953542232513,
-0.6602423191070557,
-0.6350486278533936,
0.03773598372936249,
0.6644115447998047,
0.5592262148857117,
0.5497123003005981,
0.5197736620903015,
0.4864780306816101,
0.3489055931568146,
-0.09461656212806702,
-0.16998782753944397,
-0.3259560167789459,
0.09478368610143661,
-0.39478254318237305,
-0.6537947654724121,
-0.3120203912258148,
-0.5101597309112549,
0.30745577812194824,
0.23298333585262299,
-0.11220572143793106,
-0.14709322154521942,
-0.43422549962997437,
0.12525327503681183,
-0.8435974717140198,
0.4288732707500458,
-0.745660126209259,
0.05313907191157341,
-0.569431722164154,
0.40140795707702637,
-0.7570239305496216,
0.004917651880532503,
-0.1939166784286499,
-0.4792850613594055,
-0.27457281947135925,
0.24606606364250183,
0.5338665843009949,
-0.006161112803965807,
-0.48689401149749756,
-0.27020832896232605,
-0.41200071573257446,
0.6590071320533752,
-1.1208322048187256,
0.3063224256038666,
0.2917990982532501,
0.17916791141033173,
0.12891998887062073,
-0.5827233195304871,
-0.5433713793754578,
-0.3518441915512085,
-0.3580590784549713,
-0.245430126786232,
-0.7939382195472717,
0.19296935200691223,
0.28817638754844666,
0.047880347818136215,
-0.4449056386947632,
0.414728581905365,
-0.17713722586631775,
-0.45081833004951477,
0.8181281089782715,
0.24312545359134674,
0.6899131536483765,
-0.20763714611530304,
-0.09447086602449417,
0.2245270013809204,
-0.5439658164978027,
-0.28072211146354675,
0.810664713382721,
0.7615553736686707,
-0.07055395841598511,
0.5812762975692749,
-0.5993959903717041,
0.6036902070045471,
-0.26961955428123474,
0.33878204226493835,
0.2562280297279358,
0.033117152750492096,
0.15672184526920319,
0.19030079245567322,
0.9509080648422241,
0.4064282774925232,
0.680566668510437,
-0.1642228215932846,
-0.5525017976760864,
0.17124947905540466,
0.34843501448631287,
-0.8287314176559448,
-0.387741357088089,
0.041734930127859116,
0.004919149912893772,
-0.5793039202690125,
-0.23700487613677979,
-0.6600441336631775,
-0.409516841173172,
0.0897471159696579,
0.25491029024124146,
-0.3724144697189331,
-0.56940758228302,
0.18594728410243988,
-0.26292333006858826,
-0.21540842950344086,
-0.06835199892520905,
-0.85297691822052,
0.47995877265930176,
0.5815609693527222,
0.4698989689350128,
-0.4132927656173706,
-0.2664005160331726,
-0.5477216243743896,
-0.07727980613708496,
-0.5597836375236511,
0.9300548434257507,
-0.933366596698761,
-0.13470610976219177,
0.3722304403781891,
0.26588544249534607,
0.4082297086715698,
-0.7565284967422485,
0.8703725337982178,
-0.7256255149841309,
0.047338832169771194,
-0.0022713206708431244,
-0.1745976358652115,
-0.47092875838279724,
0.1502147763967514,
-0.623419463634491,
1.017630934715271,
0.4020198881626129,
-1.1143462657928467,
0.47658827900886536,
-0.7414215207099915,
-0.7694523334503174,
0.15761835873126984,
0.4503006041049957,
-0.47431647777557373,
-0.05221817269921303,
0.14144207537174225,
0.23191000521183014,
0.21181754767894745,
0.1550048291683197,
-0.51296466588974,
-0.25879740715026855,
0.03339073807001114,
-0.3116647005081177,
0.7136247158050537,
0.3654751777648926,
-0.4815176725387573,
0.2863316237926483,
-0.7727447748184204,
-0.3561955690383911,
0.2596755027770996,
-0.3698146939277649,
-0.6751179695129395,
0.13502448797225952,
0.5376196503639221,
0.1060352772474289,
-0.10501499474048615,
-0.7275152802467346,
-0.32286834716796875,
-0.5804059505462646,
0.23352520167827606,
0.5058883428573608,
0.03205246105790138,
0.10981322824954987,
0.028598647564649582,
0.4549889862537384,
0.46814805269241333,
0.2085430920124054,
-0.13157859444618225,
-0.37573549151420593,
-0.773640513420105,
0.12316105514764786,
-0.17482654750347137,
0.7344809174537659,
-0.7286720275878906,
0.5155983567237854,
-0.19718310236930847,
-0.5270894169807434,
0.03777529299259186,
0.05660530552268028,
0.6219220757484436,
0.35160794854164124,
0.3038940727710724,
-0.3392270505428314,
-0.631202757358551,
-1.2252075672149658,
-0.5121918320655823,
-0.5501919984817505,
0.04317900910973549,
0.5515079498291016,
0.493607759475708,
-0.16686764359474182,
0.7157119512557983,
-0.42475199699401855,
-0.0546867772936821,
-0.2059592306613922,
0.3236379027366638,
-0.06439228355884552,
0.07154306769371033,
0.8364667296409607,
-0.6333810687065125,
-0.6921750903129578,
0.2870379686355591,
-0.6756210923194885,
-0.6454070806503296,
0.5930702090263367,
-0.0177210234105587,
0.19646410644054413,
0.3131876289844513,
0.05338950455188751,
0.04384562000632286,
0.35627302527427673,
-0.29943758249282837,
0.6358644366264343,
0.44525134563446045,
0.3178160786628723,
-0.937742292881012,
-0.14500053226947784,
0.4288789629936218,
-0.43776366114616394,
-0.817363440990448,
0.040015991777181625,
0.014169097878038883,
-0.08370804041624069,
-0.9988722801208496,
0.6527020931243896,
0.07151490449905396,
0.3175623118877411,
-0.2291277050971985,
-0.13564500212669373,
-0.21636995673179626,
0.5010263919830322,
0.42211106419563293,
0.8535626530647278,
0.548651397228241,
-0.3064987361431122,
0.4602939486503601,
0.1985463947057724,
-0.31618502736091614,
0.6806818842887878,
-0.33986568450927734,
-0.05161306634545326,
-0.03902086615562439,
-0.028829224407672882,
-0.8869134187698364,
-0.4647877514362335,
0.501015305519104,
-0.23729044198989868,
0.22424106299877167,
-0.38692882657051086,
-0.2798003852367401,
-0.4014452397823334,
-0.08087320625782013,
0.4911854565143585,
0.10821733623743057,
-0.4592593014240265,
0.32641127705574036,
0.6411980390548706,
-0.4392251968383789,
-0.675041913986206,
-0.6974102258682251,
0.340436726808548,
-0.5442636609077454,
-0.3893589675426483,
-0.4673287868499756,
0.4372149109840393,
-0.4809708297252655,
-0.07837612181901932,
0.22212325036525726,
-0.32468414306640625,
0.12381596118211746,
-0.035809148102998734,
0.1633559763431549,
-0.5627450346946716,
0.08977968990802765,
-0.06379739195108414,
0.016668453812599182,
0.3737272024154663,
-0.24601802229881287,
0.2858678698539734,
-0.0695401132106781,
-0.16380846500396729,
-0.2900310456752777,
0.6483641266822815,
0.6906101703643799,
-0.13534943759441376,
0.4643227159976959,
0.28406450152397156,
-0.4738558530807495,
-0.32722678780555725,
-0.3319195806980133,
-0.2723751962184906,
-0.4431401789188385,
0.8632590770721436,
-0.11594660580158234,
-0.7011706829071045,
0.5887783765792847,
0.2440432459115982,
0.10504346340894699,
0.6311821937561035,
0.5708299875259399,
0.35501566529273987,
1.232698678970337,
0.4678843319416046,
-0.5407326817512512,
0.6229361891746521,
0.19625358283519745,
0.17555466294288635,
-0.267007052898407,
0.12387340515851974,
-0.6717551946640015,
0.08157362788915634,
-0.45662468671798706,
-0.005801088642328978,
0.1779247224330902,
-0.44567155838012695,
-0.622920036315918,
0.7089806795120239,
-0.5647380948066711,
0.4684307873249054,
0.10345671325922012,
0.16718724370002747,
0.30759716033935547,
0.10682585090398788,
-0.004255066625773907,
-0.10924354940652847,
-0.4936951696872711,
-0.4861745834350586,
1.008509874343872,
0.3499455451965332,
0.8818645477294922,
0.1870042383670807,
0.23828007280826569,
0.7363525629043579,
0.6186978816986084,
-0.8564434051513672,
0.3136291801929474,
-0.2631787955760956,
-1.1968709230422974,
-0.25457116961479187,
-0.4067712426185608,
-0.557287871837616,
-0.04045168682932854,
-0.12134832888841629,
-1.106947660446167,
0.08687356859445572,
0.10424699634313583,
-0.03185988962650299,
0.7138684391975403,
-0.8811728954315186,
0.9778784513473511,
-0.21169188618659973,
-0.4437851309776306,
-0.008716917596757412,
-0.40941479802131653,
0.4340971112251282,
-0.16114215552806854,
0.4297119081020355,
-0.31247857213020325,
-0.1371801793575287,
0.7800774574279785,
-0.2377336025238037,
1.05620276927948,
-0.12450304627418518,
-0.3626594841480255,
0.21944379806518555,
0.21382483839988708,
0.42651644349098206,
-0.22100691497325897,
-0.30287712812423706,
0.47787049412727356,
-0.13273859024047852,
-0.1608940064907074,
-0.09827648103237152,
0.30672314763069153,
-0.33509331941604614,
-0.5209106206893921,
-0.15482798218727112,
-0.45885446667671204,
-0.2012861669063568,
0.5196242332458496,
0.3866240978240967,
0.5912963151931763,
-0.23632900416851044,
-0.11670496314764023,
0.2911064028739929,
-0.3406203091144562,
0.060643892735242844,
0.7520132660865784,
-0.34647059440612793,
0.046813856810331345,
0.9980427622795105,
-0.14243443310260773,
0.3081686496734619,
0.1590462327003479,
0.0744548961520195,
-0.4081384837627411,
-0.646267831325531,
-0.6037386655807495,
0.02837553061544895,
-0.8422970771789551,
-0.2676791846752167,
-0.8046053051948547,
-0.1248936727643013,
-0.11484352499246597,
0.09749763458967209,
-0.43862998485565186,
-0.050050023943185806,
0.034877896308898926,
-0.16335178911685944,
0.5156108736991882,
1.1323360204696655,
-0.13256306946277618,
0.45226243138313293,
-0.6730678081512451,
0.0071829380467534065,
0.06652183830738068,
0.5289546251296997,
-0.2741294801235199,
-0.6160221099853516,
-0.19711755216121674,
0.19587442278862,
-0.10822759568691254,
-1.1124544143676758,
0.23429279029369354,
0.04777254909276962,
0.34058594703674316,
0.8757947683334351,
0.29322123527526855,
-0.013002543710172176,
-0.35461264848709106,
0.6471982002258301,
0.032205305993556976,
-0.8007979393005371,
0.7583723664283752,
-0.6059784889221191,
-0.20876066386699677,
0.3383098244667053,
0.5423870086669922,
-0.8169558048248291,
-0.8846626877784729,
-0.3628208637237549,
-0.6934873461723328,
1.1800673007965088,
0.03770369663834572,
0.651786208152771,
-0.4953095018863678,
-0.021088143810629845,
0.17213578522205353,
-0.05675298720598221,
-0.8189422488212585,
-0.3454645872116089,
0.10371226817369461,
-0.2638814151287079,
-0.032019905745983124,
-0.4856511652469635,
-0.2966630756855011,
-0.21306860446929932,
0.7518576383590698,
-0.18882010877132416,
-0.039256200194358826,
-0.31576281785964966,
-0.32351645827293396,
-0.23104089498519897,
0.4714773893356323,
0.20384056866168976,
0.46569356322288513,
0.03333929553627968,
0.13857974112033844,
0.5876520872116089,
-0.43689531087875366,
0.30029234290122986,
0.005750794429332018,
-0.19372931122779846,
0.1629035770893097,
0.5588930249214172,
0.9286272525787354,
0.5807395577430725,
-0.832878053188324,
0.6794381141662598,
0.11667756736278534,
-0.0017282941844314337,
0.03064092807471752,
0.2954410910606384,
-0.0709320604801178,
0.042806532233953476,
0.028240885585546494,
-0.15309563279151917,
0.6011462807655334,
-0.5972065329551697,
0.6292954683303833,
0.19841472804546356,
-0.8181610107421875,
-0.25487416982650757,
0.8099197745323181,
0.25572842359542847,
-0.38196229934692383,
0.5031837224960327,
-0.038218721747398376,
-0.9890802502632141,
0.548681914806366,
0.5830848813056946,
0.5507746338844299,
-0.18845722079277039,
0.2771380543708801,
0.6075118780136108,
0.29837265610694885,
0.2971644401550293,
0.030233701691031456,
-0.0476919487118721,
-0.9096634984016418,
0.07588662207126617,
-0.5915098786354065,
-0.3358498215675354,
-0.09485726803541183,
-0.7167931199073792,
0.36799025535583496,
-0.16232900321483612,
-0.12016946077346802,
0.3310742676258087,
-0.4058367908000946,
-0.11631865799427032,
0.17732109129428864,
0.5111512541770935,
1.1845402717590332,
-1.483557105064392,
0.481976181268692,
0.6430568099021912,
-0.385635644197464,
-0.6765920519828796,
-0.1395246535539627,
0.20688676834106445,
-1.065544605255127,
0.3649786114692688,
0.2121473103761673,
0.0423116609454155,
-0.007115501910448074,
-0.6177902817726135,
-0.2254091054201126,
0.07968351989984512,
0.46506646275520325,
-0.43013596534729004,
0.27167946100234985,
0.3248901069164276,
0.5589098334312439,
-0.026115121319890022,
0.38372132182121277,
1.0577832460403442,
0.5598104000091553,
0.018786225467920303,
-0.6661708354949951,
-0.10161569714546204,
-0.32177239656448364,
-0.38717737793922424,
0.4823361039161682,
-0.3107396960258484,
0.5553404092788696,
0.04547570273280144,
-0.3214941620826721,
-0.2049095332622528,
0.3301362097263336,
-0.2028605192899704,
0.09300766885280609,
0.5840989947319031,
0.6473349928855896,
0.30879074335098267,
-0.23917211592197418,
1.0175062417984009,
-0.12937958538532257,
0.3667709529399872,
0.8927159905433655,
-0.24156197905540466,
0.9067209959030151,
-0.004903663881123066,
-0.35209956765174866,
0.6265802383422852,
0.674828052520752,
0.10385298728942871,
0.3450651466846466,
0.1613406389951706,
-0.5080433487892151,
-0.25792014598846436,
-0.35224002599716187,
-0.1552288830280304,
0.6752030849456787,
0.4827192425727844,
-0.2413044571876526,
-0.69941246509552,
0.14776676893234253,
0.4633825123310089,
0.07597313076257706,
-0.3562106788158417,
1.101507544517517,
-0.15369608998298645,
-0.528046727180481,
0.43548575043678284,
0.04288998991250992,
0.8671491146087646,
-0.6734576225280762,
0.03661825880408287,
-0.2958697974681854,
0.18726301193237305,
-0.2770370543003082,
-1.1530756950378418,
0.498595654964447,
0.3429521322250366,
0.22252872586250305,
0.36144575476646423,
0.7028312683105469,
-0.36875638365745544,
-0.549310028553009,
0.5307738184928894,
0.036843422800302505,
0.2618802487850189,
-0.3431144058704376,
-0.6069671511650085,
0.01098984107375145,
-0.13992872834205627,
-0.2077287882566452,
-0.034556467086076736,
0.6170158982276917,
-0.32125282287597656,
0.5312056541442871,
0.46111857891082764,
0.16730786859989166,
0.06827698647975922,
-0.029938368126749992,
0.8398882746696472,
-0.2797733247280121,
-0.4077082574367523,
-0.842028796672821,
0.4171428978443146,
-0.2840716540813446,
-0.306452214717865,
0.5083472728729248,
0.8027988076210022,
0.9371011853218079,
0.061195939779281616,
0.9474945664405823,
-0.11513694375753403,
0.35071951150894165,
-0.22497901320457458,
0.7545048594474792,
-0.6987444758415222,
-0.13688161969184875,
-0.2240825742483139,
-0.6010674834251404,
-0.4750754237174988,
0.35586535930633545,
-0.47068193554878235,
0.039112675935029984,
0.423296183347702,
1.0619654655456543,
-0.27135950326919556,
0.12517781555652618,
0.5495082139968872,
0.4882217049598694,
0.16913917660713196,
0.4953310191631317,
0.8616933822631836,
-0.2157067060470581,
0.6246407628059387,
-0.5039665699005127,
-0.1756572127342224,
-0.4193630516529083,
-0.6723793148994446,
-0.8344372510910034,
-0.41205716133117676,
-0.049468062818050385,
-0.27174919843673706,
0.17001940310001373,
0.4967033863067627,
0.7635380625724792,
-1.4431166648864746,
-0.0667288675904274,
0.09285947680473328,
0.11046385765075684,
0.19166840612888336,
-0.26491090655326843,
-0.052841514348983765,
-0.39441877603530884,
-0.9662023186683655,
-0.03946539759635925,
0.4984007179737091,
-0.16977621614933014,
-0.0564286895096302,
0.0022228271700441837,
-0.15180470049381256,
0.21476224064826965,
0.5938178896903992,
0.4967445731163025,
-0.654346227645874,
-0.6955078840255737,
-0.13181172311306,
-0.33139804005622864,
0.2424178272485733,
0.5156461596488953,
-0.13481132686138153,
0.5992621779441833,
0.18620556592941284,
0.3736104965209961,
0.1493532508611679,
-0.008967661298811436,
0.4891762137413025,
-0.6833468079566956,
0.662480890750885,
0.3739393353462219,
0.5110257267951965,
0.3440982699394226,
-0.47241711616516113,
0.42919155955314636,
0.2412828952074051,
-0.149765744805336,
-0.7559778690338135,
0.13761822879314423,
-0.604350745677948,
-0.27462124824523926,
1.3569525480270386,
-0.31336483359336853,
-0.32013922929763794,
-0.48220697045326233,
-0.4476899206638336,
0.144858717918396,
-0.46652084589004517,
0.5609610080718994,
0.9762141704559326,
0.2318798154592514,
-0.05934042111039162,
-0.5701847076416016,
0.4689745008945465,
0.23255881667137146,
-0.9679152369499207,
0.3960396647453308,
0.62171870470047,
0.48198801279067993,
-0.05406052619218826,
0.3092378079891205,
-0.1924644410610199,
0.4315427541732788,
0.35907670855522156,
0.023363178595900536,
0.12620143592357635,
-0.3007095754146576,
-0.15167340636253357,
-0.13908074796199799,
0.12626248598098755,
-0.1603575199842453
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.08074v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.08074v1
|
A Concept-Based Explainability Framework for Large Multimodal Models
| 2024-06-12T10:48:53 | 2024-06-12T10:48:53 |
Jayneel Parekh, Pegah Khayatan, Mustafa Shukor, Alasdair Newson, Matthieu Cord
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV
|
Large multimodal models (LMMs) combine unimodal encoders and large language
models (LLMs) to perform multimodal tasks. Despite recent advancements towards
the interpretability of these models, understanding internal representations of
LMMs remains largely a mystery. In this paper, we present a novel framework for
the interpretation of LMMs. We propose a dictionary learning based approach,
applied to the representation of tokens. The elements of the learned dictionary
correspond to our proposed concepts. We show that these concepts are well
semantically grounded in both vision and text. Thus we refer to these as
"multi-modal concepts". We qualitatively and quantitatively evaluate the
results of the learnt concepts. We show that the extracted multimodal concepts
are useful to interpret representations of test samples. Finally, we evaluate
the disentanglement between different concepts and the quality of grounding
concepts visually and textually. We will publicly release our code.
|
[
-0.33589643239974976,
-0.7037138342857361,
0.7647914290428162,
-0.05812903493642807,
-0.4140929579734802,
0.2157396525144577,
-0.321427583694458,
-0.185456782579422,
0.22292596101760864,
0.09599617123603821,
-0.6343492269515991,
-0.2880416810512543,
-0.5689692497253418,
-0.005809016991406679,
-0.4188765287399292,
0.6910886168479919,
-0.2388797402381897,
0.11810176074504852,
-0.4173086881637573,
-0.2692737877368927,
-0.5157725214958191,
-0.37766405940055847,
-0.36038362979888916,
-0.28054744005203247,
0.5048500895500183,
0.2660738229751587,
0.6998345255851746,
0.5854336619377136,
0.4364013075828552,
0.3419575095176697,
-0.27834734320640564,
0.2853861153125763,
-0.22063782811164856,
-0.10289139300584793,
-0.44217193126678467,
-0.5158199667930603,
-0.09478489309549332,
-0.21777567267417908,
0.5641499757766724,
0.8605333566665649,
-0.12261920422315598,
-0.1186799556016922,
0.015057067386806011,
0.3097836971282959,
-0.4708619713783264,
0.572758138179779,
-0.5147550702095032,
0.009882498532533646,
0.06788872927427292,
-0.1878623068332672,
-0.3844287395477295,
0.39999333024024963,
-0.09243573248386383,
-0.8549427390098572,
0.056388940662145615,
0.039094533771276474,
0.5509127974510193,
-0.02932615764439106,
-0.743409276008606,
-0.5660311579704285,
-0.19223108887672424,
0.7004534006118774,
-0.5698989629745483,
0.6488068103790283,
0.172721266746521,
0.5431914925575256,
-0.025592975318431854,
-0.6902797818183899,
-1.0767178535461426,
-0.18911907076835632,
-0.039520420134067535,
0.15546350181102753,
0.301432728767395,
0.16703134775161743,
-0.057963937520980835,
0.4784449338912964,
-0.3513488173484802,
0.12085586041212082,
-0.13181835412979126,
-0.2509954869747162,
0.288017213344574,
0.1695479154586792,
0.29135388135910034,
-0.6414339542388916,
-0.7118505239486694,
0.14219844341278076,
-0.3012871742248535,
0.16212569177150726,
-0.14626668393611908,
0.2558450400829315,
-0.4225902855396271,
0.7745949625968933,
-0.005114452913403511,
0.4568256139755249,
0.023744456470012665,
-0.52225261926651,
0.5310834050178528,
-0.442044198513031,
-0.36821770668029785,
-0.20827357470989227,
0.475925475358963,
0.5195289850234985,
0.1562354564666748,
-0.29825544357299805,
-0.259380966424942,
0.10333114862442017,
0.13730013370513916,
-0.7103997468948364,
0.24602992832660675,
0.2977948784828186,
-0.9700549840927124,
-0.31236764788627625,
0.06347442418336868,
-0.6833391785621643,
-0.744649350643158,
-0.4374082684516907,
0.7102033495903015,
-0.5873416662216187,
-0.6972130537033081,
0.10650306940078735,
-0.3547118306159973,
0.158261239528656,
0.30076083540916443,
-0.8966577053070068,
-0.007486511953175068,
0.6498929858207703,
0.9901856184005737,
-0.10257867723703384,
-0.2710707187652588,
-0.1138024851679802,
0.3579198122024536,
-0.36985263228416443,
0.27075114846229553,
-0.5128731727600098,
-0.32868316769599915,
-0.13155198097229004,
0.17693276703357697,
-0.14322295784950256,
-0.349157452583313,
-0.023762943223118782,
-0.4599003791809082,
-0.14457917213439941,
-0.0520218200981617,
-0.5872476100921631,
-0.3963317275047302,
0.3528132438659668,
-0.6368248462677002,
0.5080462694168091,
-0.0062842704355716705,
-0.6297143697738647,
0.38023218512535095,
-0.8616505265235901,
-0.056763142347335815,
-0.136598140001297,
-0.29905056953430176,
0.2293728142976761,
0.40112611651420593,
0.020823385566473007,
0.7245126962661743,
-0.32758259773254395,
0.42189839482307434,
-0.4223457872867584,
-0.19703154265880585,
0.6636921763420105,
-0.6278973817825317,
0.44079816341400146,
0.5349961519241333,
-0.09833236783742905,
0.31315645575523376,
-0.9005117416381836,
-0.16969895362854004,
0.05638786032795906,
-0.1768738031387329,
-0.3210752606391907,
0.12699905037879944,
0.06372580677270889,
0.33616194128990173,
0.2258184552192688,
-0.3484591245651245,
-0.1368052214384079,
-0.28096550703048706,
0.888370931148529,
0.9442916512489319,
-0.2426510602235794,
0.594359815120697,
-0.0680769681930542,
0.2640877366065979,
0.6832873225212097,
0.13198301196098328,
-0.8565782308578491,
-0.21078503131866455,
-0.6806322932243347,
-0.6340502500534058,
0.054813601076602936,
0.02122822031378746,
-1.1634224653244019,
0.09851152449846268,
-0.28803136944770813,
-0.099614217877388,
-0.21100006997585297,
0.3048687279224396,
0.3067382872104645,
0.4224669337272644,
0.1906002312898636,
-0.3344443738460541,
-0.23840218782424927,
-1.0523887872695923,
0.05897302180528641,
-0.16768419742584229,
0.003920131828635931,
0.024658357724547386,
0.760485827922821,
-0.47621530294418335,
0.9165626168251038,
-0.17993071675300598,
-0.06102454289793968,
-0.18192723393440247,
0.17001308500766754,
0.09272008389234543,
0.3391697108745575,
0.2500858008861542,
-1.122205376625061,
0.1798340380191803,
0.11839304119348526,
-0.85279780626297,
0.4586378037929535,
-0.32869231700897217,
0.2189459651708603,
-0.04290744662284851,
0.6943526864051819,
-0.6617267727851868,
0.18420793116092682,
0.37321433424949646,
-0.5632551908493042,
0.3579345643520355,
-0.3702777922153473,
-0.12801992893218994,
-1.3999701738357544,
-0.20669260621070862,
0.007763692177832127,
-0.3633672297000885,
-0.20744308829307556,
0.6141001582145691,
0.20624053478240967,
-0.1570182889699936,
-0.47514259815216064,
0.6049595475196838,
-0.3991517424583435,
-0.07055150717496872,
-0.020923122763633728,
0.15283720195293427,
0.2565343677997589,
0.3942956030368805,
-0.07871821522712708,
0.5512450933456421,
0.6220255494117737,
-0.5786219835281372,
0.6368383169174194,
0.1131376326084137,
-0.5393206477165222,
0.7926765084266663,
-0.5897386074066162,
-0.30138421058654785,
-0.6597998738288879,
0.24546316266059875,
-1.2316160202026367,
-0.3616703450679779,
0.07785230129957199,
-0.4156576991081238,
0.10566103458404541,
0.04138597100973129,
-0.5741594433784485,
-0.13501499593257904,
-0.1461038738489151,
0.28284919261932373,
0.10781966149806976,
-0.7241120338439941,
0.9406111836433411,
0.2801952362060547,
0.1074945256114006,
-0.49334487318992615,
-0.6115826964378357,
0.17093616724014282,
-0.44307848811149597,
-0.47974270582199097,
0.160421684384346,
-0.36773374676704407,
-0.46157822012901306,
0.03200678154826164,
-0.10166920721530914,
-0.3799954652786255,
0.3084626793861389,
0.5641249418258667,
0.06896273791790009,
-0.28923338651657104,
0.8239186406135559,
-0.1763262301683426,
-0.0664241686463356,
0.19160029292106628,
-0.14226095378398895,
0.39406734704971313,
-0.0274935495108366,
-0.45393332839012146,
-0.45225805044174194,
0.365344762802124,
0.9704776406288147,
-0.1870090216398239,
0.8166192770004272,
0.8043420910835266,
-0.29566720128059387,
-0.1595446914434433,
-0.1566442847251892,
-0.028776826336979866,
-0.451430082321167,
0.5452595353126526,
-0.8012372851371765,
-0.5246178507804871,
0.6197697520256042,
-0.3075588643550873,
-0.15838657319545746,
0.46837979555130005,
0.6802167296409607,
-0.2671833038330078,
0.9955521821975708,
0.7978321313858032,
0.2910507023334503,
0.408409982919693,
-0.2723918855190277,
0.09923402220010757,
-0.5888194441795349,
-0.7446461915969849,
-0.02887159027159214,
-0.2058725357055664,
-0.19554609060287476,
-0.7839483618736267,
0.31304365396499634,
0.27806004881858826,
-0.24148176610469818,
-0.22936800122261047,
-0.01901656575500965,
0.40680360794067383,
0.35617896914482117,
0.14274448156356812,
0.3493189513683319,
-0.15983381867408752,
-0.6082484126091003,
0.10696770995855331,
-0.38225117325782776,
-0.44543907046318054,
1.1484253406524658,
0.6605508327484131,
0.8480212092399597,
0.45091521739959717,
0.33065471053123474,
0.17972134053707123,
0.045675262808799744,
-1.0550464391708374,
0.26327478885650635,
0.09718035906553268,
-0.7402958869934082,
-0.13742035627365112,
-0.45419231057167053,
-0.5488280653953552,
0.5859895348548889,
-0.42799949645996094,
-0.5520526170730591,
0.05283743888139725,
-0.14062435925006866,
-0.2771548926830292,
0.27517008781433105,
-0.96165931224823,
0.9489616751670837,
-0.33857208490371704,
-0.1034097969532013,
-0.5776680707931519,
-0.6830706596374512,
0.5206606388092041,
-0.3501662611961365,
0.8290943503379822,
0.014663158915936947,
-0.2427011877298355,
0.672673761844635,
-0.39650359749794006,
0.9989185929298401,
-0.1363486498594284,
-0.3646495044231415,
0.09348877519369125,
0.02113277278840542,
-0.07245926558971405,
0.3747848570346832,
0.058150142431259155,
0.016966918483376503,
0.36609113216400146,
-0.21704812347888947,
-0.9533005952835083,
0.6510211229324341,
-0.7041164040565491,
-0.30217644572257996,
-0.09253682941198349,
-0.8341429829597473,
-0.1970255821943283,
0.266437828540802,
-0.20008955895900726,
0.8933997750282288,
-0.030807549133896828,
0.300959050655365,
0.6187096238136292,
-0.31650859117507935,
0.5720195770263672,
0.3228662610054016,
-0.4607684314250946,
-0.23985236883163452,
0.9638247489929199,
-0.1008693128824234,
0.2846890091896057,
0.47924181818962097,
0.19773069024085999,
-0.6396329402923584,
-0.4496346116065979,
-0.5024099946022034,
0.03906835615634918,
-0.9891057014465332,
0.09340783208608627,
-0.30930420756340027,
0.1991422176361084,
-0.09101355075836182,
-0.10258965194225311,
-0.11298803985118866,
-0.5437191128730774,
-0.270114928483963,
-0.25961431860923767,
0.08933427929878235,
0.8478954434394836,
-0.11653690785169601,
0.431949257850647,
-0.6044614315032959,
0.8577381372451782,
0.4306269884109497,
0.5126884579658508,
0.14274995028972626,
-0.4822852611541748,
-0.34661227464675903,
0.3328210115432739,
-0.14002001285552979,
-0.6952997446060181,
0.15795138478279114,
0.2276611477136612,
0.6435167789459229,
0.8203027248382568,
-0.11799163371324539,
0.8544341325759888,
-0.44660380482673645,
0.8211257457733154,
0.7512767910957336,
-1.264775276184082,
0.2284787893295288,
-0.0991288274526596,
-0.01653994992375374,
0.16108089685440063,
0.18198205530643463,
-0.6614692807197571,
0.10981964319944382,
-0.47446924448013306,
-0.7946112155914307,
0.35878586769104004,
-0.20325544476509094,
0.42997267842292786,
-0.07179291546344757,
0.36470669507980347,
0.35001370310783386,
0.3007917106151581,
-0.7309072017669678,
-0.2226688265800476,
-0.5120748281478882,
-0.566661536693573,
-0.5764963030815125,
-0.42122840881347656,
-0.3559820353984833,
-0.15997080504894257,
0.05192282050848007,
-0.3881368935108185,
0.2635074257850647,
-0.03277994319796562,
-0.6254751682281494,
0.1871606856584549,
0.310005247592926,
0.6378375887870789,
1.0905402898788452,
-0.20063969492912292,
0.7147515416145325,
-0.09723585844039917,
-0.10660409182310104,
0.16640540957450867,
-0.17598509788513184,
0.32057812809944153,
0.0570087730884552,
0.5812205672264099,
0.7867001295089722,
0.4275261461734772,
-0.9842483401298523,
0.7205833792686462,
-0.013630250468850136,
-0.05450534075498581,
-0.32044607400894165,
-0.30288365483283997,
0.352222740650177,
0.46248987317085266,
0.42450588941574097,
-0.04550949111580849,
-0.10692098736763,
-1.016013264656067,
0.21692177653312683,
0.5601680278778076,
-0.35714563727378845,
-0.46976423263549805,
0.6983668208122253,
0.2231280356645584,
0.17378680408000946,
0.14955158531665802,
-0.15266340970993042,
-0.28407761454582214,
0.647040605545044,
0.4876335859298706,
0.2352733463048935,
0.10247824341058731,
0.39731597900390625,
0.04568026214838028,
0.16352736949920654,
0.06589321792125702,
0.24396854639053345,
-0.19291996955871582,
-0.9115641713142395,
-0.42937377095222473,
-0.571626603603363,
-0.22763878107070923,
0.056398872286081314,
-0.6889813542366028,
-0.031569261103868484,
-0.43552348017692566,
0.03259893134236336,
0.2994310259819031,
-0.48240140080451965,
-0.5616507530212402,
0.3580833077430725,
0.36771976947784424,
0.9121096134185791,
-0.7754585146903992,
0.6324493885040283,
0.7294527292251587,
-0.6798734068870544,
-0.6637255549430847,
-0.21415838599205017,
0.20981517434120178,
-1.155569076538086,
1.0726314783096313,
0.16298751533031464,
0.06420084834098816,
-0.11954128742218018,
-0.28912779688835144,
-0.7282364964485168,
1.084002137184143,
0.27444109320640564,
-0.3100561499595642,
-0.29886430501937866,
0.11731108278036118,
0.21775464713573456,
-0.38658320903778076,
0.4704197347164154,
0.1630426049232483,
0.4892551898956299,
0.24760212004184723,
-0.9148625135421753,
-0.03868051618337631,
-0.01988879218697548,
-0.013937577605247498,
-0.24182459712028503,
-0.3473881483078003,
1.0888643264770508,
-0.3284088671207428,
-0.20308014750480652,
-0.0489472970366478,
0.5531112551689148,
-0.0724499300122261,
0.42344143986701965,
0.5599738359451294,
0.4532611072063446,
0.766664981842041,
0.10878553986549377,
0.9631410837173462,
-0.14790219068527222,
0.5631038546562195,
0.6665435433387756,
0.11519370973110199,
0.7208035588264465,
0.8206363916397095,
0.05748709663748741,
0.4963405132293701,
0.6159871220588684,
0.4642171561717987,
0.6147444844245911,
0.23251734673976898,
-0.07645419985055923,
-0.42534253001213074,
-0.18678922951221466,
-0.27364975214004517,
0.7519469857215881,
0.5959089398384094,
-0.6424560546875,
-0.42843881249427795,
0.3775429129600525,
-0.23025795817375183,
-0.10499259829521179,
-0.692457377910614,
0.7256172895431519,
0.2542707920074463,
-0.03521835431456566,
0.5910282135009766,
0.09294621646404266,
0.7825450301170349,
-0.6069048643112183,
-0.03260786086320877,
0.07534509152173996,
0.391157329082489,
-0.12056449800729752,
-0.7470912337303162,
0.15994462370872498,
-0.3831469714641571,
-0.2870436906814575,
-0.36471477150917053,
0.3361450135707855,
-0.4309247136116028,
-0.5203078389167786,
0.1491617113351822,
0.7349098324775696,
0.14745548367500305,
-0.021085649728775024,
-0.5766851902008057,
0.04036710038781166,
-0.30005839467048645,
0.04119006171822548,
0.23919367790222168,
0.8624454140663147,
-0.04400353878736496,
0.924178421497345,
0.5741171836853027,
-0.1466829478740692,
0.018695753067731857,
0.02411280944943428,
0.7954209446907043,
-0.7918579578399658,
-0.5065349340438843,
-0.8126034736633301,
0.569673478603363,
0.19997529685497284,
-0.16945740580558777,
0.6986955404281616,
0.2732203006744385,
0.6259952187538147,
-0.10320229828357697,
0.6949710249900818,
0.030186202377080917,
0.3943902254104614,
-0.8617040514945984,
0.654773473739624,
-0.8862724900245667,
0.06766879558563232,
-0.16095614433288574,
-0.6360794901847839,
-0.14338386058807373,
0.7516188621520996,
0.22124218940734863,
-0.12274237722158432,
0.8853940367698669,
0.6413427591323853,
-0.34775277972221375,
-0.09850502014160156,
0.5546746850013733,
0.3662535548210144,
0.30343422293663025,
0.4951213002204895,
1.0904455184936523,
0.024131039157509804,
0.3515297472476959,
-0.01656588353216648,
-0.11725667864084244,
-0.1058550477027893,
-0.8083412647247314,
-0.8897448182106018,
-0.9931498765945435,
0.05746367201209068,
-0.16310320794582367,
-0.21444714069366455,
0.8626200556755066,
0.6828973889350891,
-0.4960302412509918,
-0.02461962029337883,
0.17859362065792084,
0.2962600290775299,
-0.19599883258342743,
-0.1850496381521225,
0.30910998582839966,
-0.35412660241127014,
-0.5545914173126221,
0.5285682082176208,
0.059959642589092255,
-0.042550187557935715,
-0.527972400188446,
-0.25909218192100525,
0.060108378529548645,
0.11777610331773758,
0.9794022440910339,
-0.15838587284088135,
-0.9392868876457214,
-0.4981240928173065,
-0.2169572412967682,
0.1786833554506302,
-0.08596187829971313,
0.875548243522644,
-0.8147936463356018,
0.7149993777275085,
0.07571050524711609,
0.5876032114028931,
0.20385602116584778,
-0.2317928671836853,
0.3700558543205261,
-0.6065686941146851,
0.360937237739563,
-0.19657430052757263,
0.7160703539848328,
0.23815734684467316,
0.05479968339204788,
0.20599815249443054,
0.3857153058052063,
0.24410030245780945,
-0.8145314455032349,
0.44481006264686584,
-1.198500156402588,
-0.6711386442184448,
1.1919595003128052,
-0.15006935596466064,
-0.07799338549375534,
-0.2925393581390381,
-0.10418635606765747,
0.12898243963718414,
-0.08965907990932465,
0.598067045211792,
0.753152072429657,
0.31643638014793396,
-0.37656617164611816,
-0.6092469692230225,
0.0447557233273983,
0.20562990009784698,
-0.60251784324646,
0.1037469282746315,
0.5781311392784119,
0.5317050814628601,
0.38303977251052856,
0.303245484828949,
-0.22855141758918762,
-0.0723843201994896,
-0.1016855388879776,
0.07951956242322922,
-0.4650894105434418,
-0.24797429144382477,
-0.5402355194091797,
0.3422752916812897,
0.09887456148862839,
-0.37965521216392517
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.08068v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.08068v1
|
Large Language Models Meet Text-Centric Multimodal Sentiment Analysis: A Survey
| 2024-06-12T10:36:27 | 2024-06-12T10:36:27 |
Hao Yang, Yanyan Zhao, Yang Wu, Shilong Wang, Tian Zheng, Hongbo Zhang, Wanxiang Che, Bing Qin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Compared to traditional sentiment analysis, which only considers text,
multimodal sentiment analysis needs to consider emotional signals from
multimodal sources simultaneously and is therefore more consistent with the way
how humans process sentiment in real-world scenarios. It involves processing
emotional information from various sources such as natural language, images,
videos, audio, physiological signals, etc. However, although other modalities
also contain diverse emotional cues, natural language usually contains richer
contextual information and therefore always occupies a crucial position in
multimodal sentiment analysis. The emergence of ChatGPT has opened up immense
potential for applying large language models (LLMs) to text-centric multimodal
tasks. However, it is still unclear how existing LLMs can adapt better to
text-centric multimodal sentiment analysis tasks. This survey aims to (1)
present a comprehensive review of recent research in text-centric multimodal
sentiment analysis tasks, (2) examine the potential of LLMs for text-centric
multimodal sentiment analysis, outlining their approaches, advantages, and
limitations, (3) summarize the application scenarios of LLM-based multimodal
sentiment analysis technology, and (4) explore the challenges and potential
research directions for multimodal sentiment analysis in the future.
|
[
-0.5785481929779053,
-0.8521597981452942,
0.6177898049354553,
0.45607513189315796,
-0.1921803504228592,
0.03163076564669609,
-0.5574131608009338,
-0.599664032459259,
0.2176143229007721,
0.26636868715286255,
-0.7090125679969788,
-0.40639567375183105,
-0.7533595561981201,
0.08845021575689316,
-0.16376538574695587,
0.8973067998886108,
0.060975972563028336,
0.33561140298843384,
-0.3320316970348358,
-0.31787100434303284,
-0.4191582202911377,
-0.9305353760719299,
-0.5818990468978882,
-0.14245668053627014,
0.8191632032394409,
0.34967130422592163,
0.48875200748443604,
-0.2814158499240875,
0.6972225308418274,
0.36102935671806335,
-0.05711917579174042,
-0.047564104199409485,
-0.17194409668445587,
0.39172807335853577,
0.13614927232265472,
-0.2882919907569885,
-0.7611250281333923,
0.15186171233654022,
0.5253925919532776,
0.40630200505256653,
0.02669314295053482,
-0.11319553852081299,
-0.23942288756370544,
0.6056682467460632,
-0.4261624813079834,
0.22905166447162628,
-0.33789557218551636,
0.2804328203201294,
-0.10535279661417007,
-0.2834642827510834,
-0.5351556539535522,
-0.14015649259090424,
0.24714909493923187,
0.10222554206848145,
-0.2489200234413147,
-0.004556505475193262,
0.2830706536769867,
0.07743322104215622,
-0.9536128640174866,
-0.4803609848022461,
-0.5751489400863647,
1.1661983728408813,
-0.7150862216949463,
0.6680168509483337,
-0.19357863068580627,
0.12455420196056366,
0.04968627914786339,
-0.4317018389701843,
-0.6584939360618591,
-0.40558332204818726,
0.15560369193553925,
0.34966129064559937,
-0.07664698362350464,
-0.03327810764312744,
0.08463908731937408,
0.4261976480484009,
-0.6460739970207214,
0.09511704742908478,
0.052355412393808365,
-0.009272859431803226,
0.5992922782897949,
0.2987689673900604,
0.48221853375434875,
-0.4647656977176666,
-0.6760164499282837,
-0.19286128878593445,
-0.30629122257232666,
0.004295085556805134,
0.11529698222875595,
0.09674973785877228,
-0.279747873544693,
0.6676840782165527,
-0.020358530804514885,
0.6606868505477905,
-0.35786712169647217,
-0.37551480531692505,
0.3659612834453583,
-0.34753847122192383,
-0.2194991260766983,
-0.04943817853927612,
1.0830096006393433,
0.8308345675468445,
0.34808406233787537,
0.20538176596164703,
-0.23918455839157104,
0.11266578733921051,
-0.04122007265686989,
-0.8749069571495056,
0.06073262542486191,
0.4204765856266022,
-0.6523546576499939,
-0.21301928162574768,
-0.26843714714050293,
-1.3014758825302124,
-0.7559928894042969,
-0.48207053542137146,
0.14432208240032196,
-0.23254574835300446,
-0.5798256993293762,
0.15999913215637207,
-0.18764640390872955,
0.3374086618423462,
0.36583638191223145,
-0.7812108397483826,
-0.07905681431293488,
0.6285656094551086,
0.9271930456161499,
-0.15338151156902313,
-0.10159789025783539,
-0.0613236203789711,
-0.3676801919937134,
0.030801057815551758,
0.8791779279708862,
-0.7144059538841248,
-0.45314496755599976,
0.12488140165805817,
-0.03872044011950493,
-0.277084618806839,
-0.06366609781980515,
0.6279783844947815,
-0.5556210875511169,
0.39751771092414856,
-0.31927594542503357,
-0.3268078863620758,
-0.22722871601581573,
0.815019428730011,
-0.7008235454559326,
0.7983408570289612,
-0.30278217792510986,
-0.9052150845527649,
0.14719286561012268,
-0.6524118781089783,
-0.2948873043060303,
-0.36121487617492676,
0.012084138579666615,
-0.24159017205238342,
0.3158837854862213,
0.31418898701667786,
0.8197959661483765,
-0.5177590847015381,
0.027886750176548958,
-0.5469908118247986,
0.09219077974557877,
0.868182361125946,
-0.7300290465354919,
0.43909215927124023,
0.32910585403442383,
0.030476722866296768,
0.20396709442138672,
-0.5903013348579407,
0.0734991505742073,
-0.035429954528808594,
-0.28868579864501953,
-0.3271254599094391,
0.12768130004405975,
0.5443357825279236,
0.5539426803588867,
0.44366103410720825,
-0.6962870359420776,
0.3380957543849945,
-0.005002664402127266,
0.5604190826416016,
0.6183863878250122,
-0.057105984538793564,
0.46967723965644836,
0.02145806886255741,
0.7179281115531921,
0.014116914011538029,
0.19578957557678223,
-0.4250938892364502,
-0.4419759511947632,
-0.5735218524932861,
-0.463816374540329,
-0.002456646878272295,
0.4051774740219116,
-0.5893792510032654,
-0.08611776679754257,
-0.2616514265537262,
-0.5584233999252319,
-0.21691517531871796,
-0.17229604721069336,
-0.021808529272675514,
0.17819762229919434,
0.050613630563020706,
-0.2448350340127945,
-0.6783461570739746,
-0.7032670974731445,
-0.24375854432582855,
-0.09793145209550858,
0.38164234161376953,
0.23634156584739685,
0.3237312138080597,
-0.5325061082839966,
0.7376694679260254,
-0.5038043856620789,
-0.22412078082561493,
-0.549098014831543,
0.29183855652809143,
0.07633710652589798,
-0.017482656985521317,
0.537947952747345,
-1.08305823802948,
-0.5680442452430725,
0.1869223564863205,
-0.6626797914505005,
0.07749015092849731,
-0.01195412315428257,
0.24746914207935333,
0.3769460618495941,
0.4806397557258606,
-0.8618205785751343,
-0.2303362488746643,
1.0820136070251465,
-0.15473532676696777,
0.45310482382774353,
0.05119879171252251,
0.4045562148094177,
-1.1576045751571655,
-0.04713894799351692,
0.24780622124671936,
-0.17680245637893677,
-0.6469558477401733,
-0.07570534944534302,
0.12167820334434509,
-0.12176258116960526,
-0.4027843773365021,
0.5397093892097473,
-0.49536779522895813,
-0.019522061571478844,
-0.476163774728775,
0.17383749783039093,
-0.14961329102516174,
0.2740871012210846,
0.1741846352815628,
0.5086061954498291,
0.4095275104045868,
-0.07841094583272934,
0.6951754093170166,
0.039169616997241974,
-0.18277397751808167,
0.7123598456382751,
-0.41866475343704224,
0.08072809875011444,
-0.3558495342731476,
0.42245426774024963,
-1.3140311241149902,
-0.3442580997943878,
0.10144072771072388,
-0.4816395342350006,
0.26794859766960144,
0.11773224174976349,
-0.5036951303482056,
-0.2366781383752823,
-0.6039264798164368,
0.37884825468063354,
0.29358312487602234,
-0.3810141980648041,
0.7658320069313049,
0.4056914448738098,
-0.4905032813549042,
-0.4982050061225891,
-0.5274490714073181,
0.2522958815097809,
-0.25506916642189026,
-0.712539553642273,
-0.1475224643945694,
-0.29722851514816284,
-0.3363298773765564,
-0.19673225283622742,
0.20374298095703125,
-0.10186458379030228,
-0.1653939038515091,
0.38166889548301697,
0.4156828224658966,
-0.19424861669540405,
0.36434194445610046,
-0.3865703046321869,
-0.10915293544530869,
0.18147394061088562,
0.13267317414283752,
0.7342165112495422,
-0.34553152322769165,
-0.2312798798084259,
-0.27215850353240967,
0.4883177876472473,
1.0563738346099854,
-0.49479255080223083,
0.5910115242004395,
0.9478992223739624,
-0.06237323209643364,
-0.04706450551748276,
-0.6720314621925354,
-0.020898377522826195,
-0.3954113721847534,
0.6748619079589844,
-0.17339454591274261,
-1.0669748783111572,
0.0966062992811203,
-0.043303173035383224,
-0.03949947655200958,
0.2629789710044861,
1.0338646173477173,
-0.15617243945598602,
1.1957143545150757,
0.709200382232666,
-0.3811012804508209,
0.7775264978408813,
0.20566783845424652,
0.4469820559024811,
-0.705851137638092,
-0.1279730647802353,
-0.48821523785591125,
-0.31095272302627563,
-0.7226569056510925,
-0.26186221837997437,
0.3908122181892395,
-0.6403428316116333,
0.11588411778211594,
-0.1643674224615097,
-0.19340066611766815,
0.005391025450080633,
0.07434951514005661,
-0.10240060091018677,
0.22101908922195435,
0.060387708246707916,
0.2032376527786255,
-0.11302625387907028,
-0.4930545389652252,
-0.36141547560691833,
0.9182676076889038,
0.5372564196586609,
0.7494994401931763,
0.053157348185777664,
0.24652478098869324,
0.19751957058906555,
0.5152496695518494,
-1.1547918319702148,
0.6156566739082336,
-0.2536827623844147,
-0.5985864400863647,
-0.05919857323169708,
-0.43592411279678345,
-0.5917263031005859,
0.4816407561302185,
-0.2291376292705536,
-0.5415548086166382,
-0.06791237741708755,
-0.11654942482709885,
0.08258478343486786,
0.11879912763834,
-0.7616752982139587,
0.8879060745239258,
-0.20624640583992004,
-0.10334500670433044,
-0.18614549934864044,
-0.4663621783256531,
0.534546971321106,
-0.08331982791423798,
0.6101115942001343,
-0.21703080832958221,
0.027991309762001038,
0.5359162092208862,
0.07341191172599792,
0.9218368530273438,
-0.24583576619625092,
-0.44571083784103394,
0.2971205413341522,
-0.19033822417259216,
0.29445749521255493,
0.05753176286816597,
-0.2019144594669342,
-0.028638053685426712,
0.09726640582084656,
-0.01918526366353035,
-0.5177024602890015,
1.014129638671875,
-0.7304240465164185,
-0.3488631248474121,
-0.6225787997245789,
-0.6134584546089172,
-0.46199101209640503,
-0.14245644211769104,
0.011012449860572815,
0.4115533232688904,
-0.18295839428901672,
0.379019170999527,
0.6765546798706055,
-0.15884841978549957,
0.7750076055526733,
0.23149317502975464,
-0.3379491865634918,
-0.4959096610546112,
0.8323415517807007,
-0.10311312973499298,
0.18034696578979492,
0.5869002342224121,
0.2354937344789505,
-0.47234317660331726,
-0.25370296835899353,
-0.2703252136707306,
0.22614793479442596,
-0.6385420560836792,
0.008533802814781666,
-0.6955872178077698,
0.06607484817504883,
-0.29988083243370056,
0.04324451461434364,
-0.47898340225219727,
-0.07055980712175369,
0.03846459090709686,
0.11306041479110718,
0.45143041014671326,
0.48237642645835876,
0.24916358292102814,
0.2860390245914459,
-1.1111263036727905,
0.3095014691352844,
0.37457844614982605,
0.21812844276428223,
-0.004460208583623171,
-0.09628503769636154,
0.05531996488571167,
0.07369350641965866,
-0.034469038248062134,
-0.9274380207061768,
0.5463313460350037,
-0.035011228173971176,
0.07722662389278412,
0.30905982851982117,
-0.21022915840148926,
0.3930053114891052,
-0.37219366431236267,
0.9771956205368042,
0.5061274170875549,
-0.7286684513092041,
0.08549017459154129,
-0.42169010639190674,
0.34194865822792053,
0.09843213856220245,
0.4468734562397003,
-1.0913972854614258,
0.05847971513867378,
0.1327299326658249,
-0.6272056698799133,
0.4339492917060852,
-0.19550247490406036,
0.4017183184623718,
-0.023639759048819542,
-0.0035147606395184994,
-0.028046689927577972,
0.28874334692955017,
-1.0295616388320923,
0.16508100926876068,
-0.05249684676527977,
-0.5756820440292358,
-0.429777592420578,
-0.564885139465332,
0.22770769894123077,
0.1996258944272995,
0.3309279978275299,
-0.14673404395580292,
0.47079983353614807,
0.07277826964855194,
-0.08687236905097961,
-0.021054066717624664,
0.7076236605644226,
0.48634040355682373,
0.31158962845802307,
-0.19669808447360992,
0.2744901478290558,
0.007567967288196087,
-0.4478834867477417,
0.1091376543045044,
-0.15688486397266388,
0.2128918617963791,
-0.0959983542561531,
0.3749520480632782,
0.6390964388847351,
0.26609668135643005,
-0.9170724153518677,
0.8205769658088684,
-0.1806885153055191,
0.040001776069402695,
-0.36788657307624817,
-0.3661896884441376,
0.2299274057149887,
0.34575968980789185,
0.09265369176864624,
0.022059831768274307,
0.06294722110033035,
-0.7629238367080688,
-0.24576427042484283,
0.7351118326187134,
-0.7360556721687317,
-0.5280442833900452,
0.19362378120422363,
0.12251847237348557,
0.1202206015586853,
0.47770199179649353,
0.09250392019748688,
-0.5467537045478821,
0.43048545718193054,
0.3435691297054291,
0.8513200283050537,
-0.2008567452430725,
0.08253971487283707,
0.02086137793958187,
0.10160840302705765,
-0.08831708133220673,
0.4780108630657196,
0.23621882498264313,
-0.7001034021377563,
-0.7230895161628723,
-0.683989942073822,
-0.49289941787719727,
-0.08503471314907074,
-0.3352804183959961,
0.21033677458763123,
-0.29964882135391235,
-0.2814951241016388,
-0.04163632541894913,
-0.23059003055095673,
-0.5173594951629639,
0.5235154032707214,
0.5636847615242004,
0.5337387323379517,
-0.6489444375038147,
0.669187068939209,
0.9416136741638184,
-0.2001734972000122,
-0.36252307891845703,
-0.16506488621234894,
0.19325804710388184,
-0.4353925287723541,
0.5373764634132385,
0.257904052734375,
-0.18111982941627502,
-0.29597800970077515,
-0.548086941242218,
-0.44682326912879944,
0.8459275960922241,
-0.01390941720455885,
-0.5856500267982483,
0.0817125216126442,
0.2414395660161972,
0.7143863439559937,
-0.30625951290130615,
0.5325131416320801,
0.2891659140586853,
0.5715047717094421,
0.029072102159261703,
-0.8371652364730835,
-0.1937766820192337,
-0.31954336166381836,
-0.19450408220291138,
0.3631463646888733,
-0.9493914842605591,
1.151780366897583,
0.29934921860694885,
0.08763644099235535,
-0.015233928337693214,
0.4612685441970825,
0.030498307198286057,
0.4246971905231476,
0.5671343207359314,
0.3433629274368286,
0.2375439703464508,
0.1256720870733261,
1.0307157039642334,
-0.2960098385810852,
0.4824455976486206,
0.7242677211761475,
-0.4504045844078064,
1.0969500541687012,
0.6263104677200317,
-0.14544612169265747,
0.2745896279811859,
0.4379619061946869,
0.05862666666507721,
0.14025931060314178,
-0.199354887008667,
-0.5125063061714172,
-0.39999285340309143,
-0.1869180053472519,
-0.3855411112308502,
0.6400220394134521,
0.38257962465286255,
-0.15146508812904358,
-0.18604041635990143,
0.40526723861694336,
0.028610574081540108,
-0.17800500988960266,
-0.40797463059425354,
0.6221778392791748,
0.22509965300559998,
-0.40629851818084717,
-0.058612048625946045,
0.16733576357364655,
0.9230283498764038,
-0.7381990551948547,
0.1973210722208023,
-0.11630237847566605,
0.2801375389099121,
-0.2030637562274933,
-0.8275217413902283,
0.03298507258296013,
0.12442313879728317,
-0.26380911469459534,
-0.4237039387226105,
0.9493423700332642,
-0.18658514320850372,
-0.39116203784942627,
0.4084310829639435,
0.6411178708076477,
-0.09766023606061935,
-0.46399158239364624,
-0.456474244594574,
0.34024578332901,
0.03253411129117012,
-0.6550526022911072,
0.46266576647758484,
0.6970175504684448,
0.04537556320428848,
0.6803827285766602,
0.603449285030365,
-0.2168286144733429,
0.16542206704616547,
0.14080698788166046,
0.8014270067214966,
-0.9075921773910522,
-0.24242469668388367,
-1.019858956336975,
0.5131575465202332,
0.0662526935338974,
-0.2765727937221527,
0.9059762954711914,
0.28936606645584106,
0.35078486800193787,
-0.3274345099925995,
0.9077897071838379,
-0.16416698694229126,
0.3780149519443512,
-0.5237048268318176,
0.564256489276886,
-0.7665644288063049,
-0.19202806055545807,
-0.5127741694450378,
-1.072221040725708,
-0.38309359550476074,
0.3137856125831604,
-0.3851344883441925,
0.03625285252928734,
0.7195349931716919,
0.6853179335594177,
0.06733241677284241,
0.35022929310798645,
0.32189011573791504,
0.24773168563842773,
0.42205512523651123,
0.5436854362487793,
1.4254815578460693,
-0.11136007308959961,
0.4225563406944275,
-0.02731591835618019,
-0.1743699610233307,
-0.36256033182144165,
-0.9663825631141663,
-0.9442664980888367,
-0.5166404843330383,
-0.17833057045936584,
0.057548120617866516,
-0.32483696937561035,
1.1113663911819458,
0.3974866271018982,
-0.513206958770752,
-0.1732366532087326,
0.2878339886665344,
-0.03147486597299576,
0.23510147631168365,
-0.1828528195619583,
0.07502949237823486,
-0.4134751558303833,
-0.9603271484375,
0.259032279253006,
0.4136466681957245,
-0.10187230259180069,
-0.38099971413612366,
0.06033409386873245,
-0.050912316888570786,
0.1444685459136963,
1.1780779361724854,
-0.077996626496315,
-0.49321773648262024,
-0.3778778910636902,
0.29888394474983215,
-0.293832927942276,
0.14547297358512878,
0.9974291324615479,
-0.2527773976325989,
0.47220391035079956,
0.7342819571495056,
0.4782777726650238,
0.39783456921577454,
-0.34550562500953674,
0.29931575059890747,
-0.47722703218460083,
0.21202486753463745,
0.12381542474031448,
0.46681496500968933,
0.40550854802131653,
-0.008952399715781212,
0.03177499398589134,
0.0470246821641922,
-0.5907928943634033,
-0.5791881084442139,
0.23748517036437988,
-1.5989515781402588,
-0.21672329306602478,
1.340445876121521,
0.1020074114203453,
-0.13838398456573486,
0.2845478951931,
-0.6734936237335205,
-0.05700693279504776,
-0.33807289600372314,
0.5540704727172852,
0.9727745652198792,
-0.05413360893726349,
-0.505282998085022,
-0.5584878921508789,
0.055456168949604034,
0.3950963020324707,
-0.8659564256668091,
0.06480483710765839,
0.6502622365951538,
0.05991586670279503,
0.06951164454221725,
0.5559683442115784,
-0.1958150416612625,
-0.05233362317085266,
-0.2292981892824173,
0.20815487205982208,
0.25475943088531494,
-0.15690667927265167,
-0.53342205286026,
0.7039234042167664,
0.2020798921585083,
0.05417763069272041
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.08055v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.08055v1
|
Learning Job Title Representation from Job Description Aggregation Network
| 2024-06-12T10:12:52 | 2024-06-12T10:12:52 |
Napat Laosaengpha, Thanit Tativannarat, Chawan Piansaddhayanon, Attapol Rutherford, Ekapol Chuangsuwanich
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Learning job title representation is a vital process for developing automatic
human resource tools. To do so, existing methods primarily rely on learning the
title representation through skills extracted from the job description,
neglecting the rich and diverse content within. Thus, we propose an alternative
framework for learning job titles through their respective job description (JD)
and utilize a Job Description Aggregator component to handle the lengthy
description and bidirectional contrastive loss to account for the bidirectional
relationship between the job title and its description. We evaluated the
performance of our method on both in-domain and out-of-domain settings,
achieving a superior performance over the skill-based approach.
|
[
-0.14762437343597412,
-0.2145971804857254,
0.3584369122982025,
-0.013435903936624527,
-0.468365341424942,
-0.006722761318087578,
-0.09701810777187347,
-0.5617964863777161,
0.4300135374069214,
0.5850962400436401,
-0.5708200931549072,
-0.14210478961467743,
-0.7366746068000793,
0.17835360765457153,
-0.24210456013679504,
0.9371645450592041,
0.09594469517469406,
-0.08745328336954117,
-0.6741067171096802,
0.0184251070022583,
-0.6733471751213074,
-0.1517392247915268,
-1.0951495170593262,
-0.6552608013153076,
0.5709912180900574,
0.23773500323295593,
0.5899755954742432,
0.8114542961120605,
0.5596399307250977,
0.262969434261322,
0.008064089342951775,
0.22408610582351685,
-0.2698434591293335,
0.18461991846561432,
-0.5635085701942444,
-0.2980172336101532,
-0.43584808707237244,
0.12629485130310059,
0.8489301800727844,
1.2305617332458496,
-0.25510266423225403,
0.27297720313072205,
0.11713221669197083,
0.7601478099822998,
-0.6267821788787842,
0.5925559997558594,
-0.49178749322891235,
0.2643044590950012,
-0.281043142080307,
-0.29588544368743896,
-0.36713987588882446,
0.16381078958511353,
0.3017231523990631,
-0.6162184476852417,
0.20572158694267273,
-0.04374028742313385,
0.8503722548484802,
0.13426826894283295,
-0.745061993598938,
-0.15519016981124878,
-0.8706344962120056,
0.7251367568969727,
-0.25201112031936646,
0.46554994583129883,
0.5865776538848877,
0.6296935677528381,
0.44481584429740906,
-0.5048509240150452,
-0.2794817388057709,
0.20661313831806183,
-0.3791574239730835,
0.604932963848114,
0.43847039341926575,
0.22410893440246582,
-0.15329457819461823,
0.522309422492981,
-0.35952523350715637,
0.3889453709125519,
-0.5487779974937439,
0.06230958178639412,
0.8762044310569763,
0.4132762849330902,
-0.20406441390514374,
-0.09679802507162094,
-0.5518435835838318,
-0.23176628351211548,
-0.4928429424762726,
0.09320062398910522,
0.559532105922699,
0.5215731859207153,
-0.014231935143470764,
0.4740872383117676,
-0.35627099871635437,
0.7048554420471191,
-0.14114125072956085,
-0.3707841634750366,
0.11326485127210617,
0.06014000624418259,
-0.5194527506828308,
0.14186923205852509,
0.2638474702835083,
0.33920618891716003,
-0.37297528982162476,
-0.4538160562515259,
-0.20326749980449677,
-0.4179081320762634,
0.7310796976089478,
-0.5127174258232117,
0.05175282806158066,
-0.11794927716255188,
-0.6773985028266907,
-0.2151542752981186,
0.19720782339572906,
-0.5402470827102661,
-0.6779631972312927,
-0.4422493875026703,
0.3313157260417938,
-0.2015172392129898,
-0.12469368427991867,
-0.22540242969989777,
-0.2991626262664795,
0.4152475595474243,
0.4629868268966675,
-0.6326315402984619,
0.18400226533412933,
0.649071991443634,
0.7914207577705383,
-0.3073967695236206,
-0.1908963918685913,
-0.44238921999931335,
0.44006407260894775,
-0.1809997260570526,
0.4221356511116028,
-0.645757794380188,
-0.4842875897884369,
0.06605389714241028,
0.17675146460533142,
-0.43137267231941223,
-0.6471618413925171,
0.1340906023979187,
-1.1908433437347412,
0.19501449167728424,
0.13904239237308502,
-0.618356466293335,
-0.5043489933013916,
0.132737934589386,
-0.8483050465583801,
0.6819948554039001,
0.431603342294693,
-0.8176038265228271,
0.35780155658721924,
-0.652186930179596,
-0.359141081571579,
0.17912930250167847,
-0.2531711161136627,
-0.45876339077949524,
-0.01561648678034544,
-0.14811007678508759,
0.6752997636795044,
-0.1165836751461029,
0.03375132381916046,
0.11044558882713318,
-0.6098916530609131,
-0.0034112681169062853,
-0.06356124579906464,
0.9443678259849548,
-0.045931924134492874,
-0.044170815497636795,
-0.2810964584350586,
-0.45289209485054016,
-0.51664799451828,
0.176142156124115,
-0.5045288801193237,
-0.574736475944519,
0.02294114977121353,
-0.3869371712207794,
0.14273998141288757,
0.2335192859172821,
-0.1901160329580307,
0.009503018110990524,
-0.4508720636367798,
-0.5727423429489136,
0.7317525744438171,
-0.09979742020368576,
0.7215150594711304,
-0.18792858719825745,
0.8845213651657104,
0.18784396350383759,
-0.026296347379684448,
-0.018273383378982544,
-0.3021789789199829,
-0.28046712279319763,
-0.12139660865068436,
0.34890472888946533,
0.6884532570838928,
-1.2345308065414429,
0.4811018705368042,
-0.38641074299812317,
-0.4807286262512207,
-0.47887393832206726,
0.22177919745445251,
0.6302117705345154,
0.8373193144798279,
0.5678032040596008,
-0.7989336848258972,
-0.6134941577911377,
-1.1083011627197266,
-0.3838610351085663,
-0.07463225722312927,
0.030284574255347252,
0.3423144817352295,
0.19443002343177795,
-0.4089289903640747,
0.875565230846405,
-0.40651801228523254,
-0.6068686246871948,
-0.29292523860931396,
0.2372240275144577,
0.3286924958229065,
0.2673426568508148,
0.15139256417751312,
-1.0191293954849243,
-0.44771289825439453,
0.2111520916223526,
-0.6944988369941711,
0.3436644375324249,
-0.33904916048049927,
-0.18140792846679688,
-0.05089057981967926,
0.3639957904815674,
-0.4648894667625427,
0.3563883602619171,
0.4165041446685791,
-0.34387558698654175,
0.8344438076019287,
0.10835011303424835,
-0.09284886717796326,
-1.2297028303146362,
0.28253790736198425,
0.275130957365036,
-0.321968138217926,
-0.3486740291118622,
0.0956563800573349,
-0.07053151726722717,
-0.1824796348810196,
-0.41419896483421326,
0.4527240991592407,
-0.6547771096229553,
-0.5286749601364136,
-0.2735973000526428,
0.12777870893478394,
0.1741326004266739,
0.4495908319950104,
0.24526230990886688,
0.8536818027496338,
0.6028943061828613,
-0.7542778849601746,
0.6889076232910156,
0.4465895891189575,
-0.2579372525215149,
0.7391338348388672,
-0.2783956527709961,
-0.24798914790153503,
-0.7347939014434814,
0.3891649544239044,
-0.6343629360198975,
-0.2568488121032715,
0.14153021574020386,
-0.04788455739617348,
0.5731013417243958,
-0.6232537031173706,
-0.24173866212368011,
-0.4929939806461334,
-0.17585225403308868,
0.32216107845306396,
0.4885352849960327,
-0.360442191362381,
0.3787323236465454,
0.25632721185684204,
-0.46962466835975647,
-0.9218228459358215,
-0.8452003002166748,
-0.06781890988349915,
-0.3625606894493103,
-0.1275772601366043,
0.9691624045372009,
0.6103653311729431,
-0.12438385933637619,
-0.2147703468799591,
-0.1777230203151703,
-0.6009302735328674,
0.10531900078058243,
0.08902472257614136,
0.3321785628795624,
-0.055484190583229065,
0.4093671143054962,
0.043336041271686554,
-0.17415215075016022,
0.2057427167892456,
0.07724195718765259,
0.17553682625293732,
0.4467644691467285,
-0.39620769023895264,
-0.4836244583129883,
0.3686097264289856,
0.25027868151664734,
-0.26809850335121155,
1.0899183750152588,
0.8478863835334778,
-0.045298948884010315,
-0.08150778710842133,
-0.17135024070739746,
-0.12155865132808685,
-0.45441776514053345,
0.5100284218788147,
-0.06127274036407471,
-0.47764062881469727,
0.5289793014526367,
-0.2818921208381653,
-0.12623755633831024,
0.7226624488830566,
0.20126692950725555,
-0.2848072052001953,
0.5315296649932861,
0.7956725358963013,
0.009520829655230045,
0.5488141775131226,
-0.5992172360420227,
0.03972393274307251,
-1.1659140586853027,
-0.551250696182251,
-0.05950240418314934,
-0.37742340564727783,
-0.23936738073825836,
-0.4790877103805542,
0.46233686804771423,
0.10217618942260742,
-0.11363935470581055,
0.43976151943206787,
-0.3585353493690491,
0.35397037863731384,
0.48063012957572937,
0.24004796147346497,
0.15071186423301697,
0.02403266914188862,
0.029291722923517227,
0.07557761669158936,
-0.24118120968341827,
-0.38327938318252563,
0.8396667838096619,
0.4001806974411011,
0.5175876021385193,
0.1701951026916504,
0.9187180995941162,
0.38112184405326843,
0.15786460041999817,
-0.6902099251747131,
0.3513498902320862,
-0.38907134532928467,
-0.3307690918445587,
-0.6945430040359497,
-0.5155421495437622,
-1.0819447040557861,
0.5529778003692627,
0.01654338836669922,
-0.5764822363853455,
0.15693700313568115,
0.10587441921234131,
-0.49502405524253845,
0.34135574102401733,
-0.466463565826416,
0.9859862923622131,
0.015452992171049118,
-0.1522512584924698,
-0.3165892958641052,
-0.9367404580116272,
0.23918645083904266,
-0.07179895788431168,
0.3209208846092224,
0.028063055127859116,
-0.33503273129463196,
0.9413885474205017,
-0.2791284918785095,
1.031632423400879,
-0.4028984308242798,
-0.007066675461828709,
0.27515164017677307,
-0.04721732810139656,
0.5030520558357239,
0.054768532514572144,
-0.5911583304405212,
-0.11543548107147217,
-0.2286967933177948,
-0.3630902171134949,
-0.4303058087825775,
0.3081277012825012,
-0.7193281650543213,
-0.3314509391784668,
-0.02352992445230484,
-0.4444778859615326,
-0.45772334933280945,
0.3486606180667877,
0.1321837604045868,
0.44577598571777344,
-0.21279624104499817,
0.15727633237838745,
0.5259578227996826,
-0.1004074290394783,
0.3547016382217407,
-0.023246070370078087,
0.12627117335796356,
-0.12107422947883606,
0.8241733908653259,
0.10039225220680237,
-0.09091826528310776,
0.6113812327384949,
-0.08809476345777512,
-0.4989124536514282,
-0.3089352548122406,
-0.3954305052757263,
0.11578089743852615,
-0.679961621761322,
-0.5143083333969116,
-0.4714559018611908,
-0.16805917024612427,
-0.35078439116477966,
-0.07192137837409973,
-0.15316160023212433,
-0.2486591637134552,
-0.37441903352737427,
-0.037170398980379105,
0.2704225182533264,
0.5271425843238831,
0.269018292427063,
0.5916979312896729,
-0.7184641361236572,
0.13779088854789734,
0.6911046504974365,
0.6526644229888916,
0.06817368417978287,
-0.418876975774765,
-0.8781039118766785,
0.20693963766098022,
-0.5320719480514526,
-1.0295579433441162,
0.29605501890182495,
0.4851703643798828,
0.7960707545280457,
0.6395837664604187,
0.08964818716049194,
0.6188961863517761,
-0.20779255032539368,
0.7414735555648804,
0.2957896590232849,
-0.5869722962379456,
0.352760910987854,
-0.26705145835876465,
0.08445775508880615,
0.7040220499038696,
0.7967984676361084,
-0.6013346314430237,
0.03978799283504486,
-0.6497342586517334,
-1.1639431715011597,
0.9599135518074036,
0.3938535451889038,
0.1499413698911667,
-0.114373579621315,
0.35032373666763306,
0.5119268894195557,
0.4275150001049042,
-0.5082692503929138,
-0.285103440284729,
0.026943691074848175,
-0.04471079260110855,
-0.13003966212272644,
-0.3022165894508362,
-0.08750971406698227,
-0.12251266837120056,
0.7273219227790833,
0.035212256014347076,
0.634079098701477,
0.0180190559476614,
-0.19424942135810852,
0.12035419046878815,
0.2060888260602951,
0.10051241517066956,
0.5852702260017395,
-0.11734943836927414,
0.25437965989112854,
0.19384199380874634,
-0.0754392147064209,
-0.30809029936790466,
0.23474492132663727,
0.49175378680229187,
0.10638868063688278,
0.4825478792190552,
0.6733678579330444,
-0.07418448477983475,
-0.6341841220855713,
0.8565885424613953,
0.43018239736557007,
-0.10629871487617493,
-0.4954530894756317,
-0.14365361630916595,
0.21579433977603912,
0.3291124999523163,
0.4407323896884918,
-0.06299442052841187,
0.49154016375541687,
-0.5296370387077332,
0.2381877899169922,
0.2201160043478012,
-0.4806879758834839,
0.08884385973215103,
0.5216635465621948,
0.2683880627155304,
-0.02347882091999054,
0.7225504517555237,
-0.4985145330429077,
-0.2498752474784851,
0.8952000737190247,
0.5289438366889954,
0.8716062903404236,
-0.2843298614025116,
0.38606491684913635,
0.04609979689121246,
-0.3554193675518036,
-0.15238220989704132,
0.01462241169065237,
-0.20655912160873413,
-0.45667797327041626,
-0.6343517899513245,
-0.4895766079425812,
-0.45238208770751953,
-0.36933907866477966,
-1.027824878692627,
-0.01887572556734085,
-0.35788318514823914,
-0.10392766445875168,
-0.1456204056739807,
-0.2570117115974426,
-0.9506791234016418,
0.531994640827179,
0.2947778105735779,
0.5904337763786316,
-0.9289329051971436,
0.540203332901001,
1.331683874130249,
-0.6403543949127197,
-0.4182385802268982,
-0.03926374018192291,
-0.2523452341556549,
-0.8932783603668213,
0.9234654903411865,
0.3203422427177429,
-0.16110019385814667,
-0.2413502037525177,
-0.004941168241202831,
-0.7523845434188843,
1.556538701057434,
0.20137132704257965,
-0.15881437063217163,
-0.41644933819770813,
-0.03662809729576111,
0.3411639928817749,
-0.5093055367469788,
0.2779546082019806,
0.11842678487300873,
0.1821727156639099,
0.006338810548186302,
-1.0861186981201172,
-0.06089754402637482,
-0.048029057681560516,
0.4858852028846741,
-0.12751521170139313,
-0.6722326874732971,
0.8041326999664307,
0.08203837275505066,
-0.28448450565338135,
-0.24690821766853333,
0.6952303647994995,
-0.11977873742580414,
0.2772601544857025,
0.6132215261459351,
0.3316047489643097,
0.6378203630447388,
0.27175411581993103,
1.0263078212738037,
-0.005472337361425161,
0.5254456400871277,
1.0516072511672974,
-0.1292220801115036,
0.5524189472198486,
0.48500844836235046,
-0.3606996536254883,
1.0863630771636963,
0.6529676914215088,
0.09336360543966293,
0.6492118835449219,
0.07280094921588898,
-0.12201288342475891,
-0.4022993743419647,
-0.21166415512561798,
-0.36359652876853943,
0.6206595301628113,
0.27868202328681946,
-0.7084071040153503,
-0.3676951229572296,
0.011149775236845016,
-0.3569625914096832,
0.18614743649959564,
-0.5964116454124451,
0.8409023284912109,
0.08174088597297668,
-0.22003668546676636,
0.2951468229293823,
0.22449332475662231,
0.6021656394004822,
-0.2468050867319107,
-0.27990734577178955,
-0.08242227882146835,
-0.1651894599199295,
-0.3516446352005005,
-0.8164176940917969,
0.7792049050331116,
-0.533446192741394,
-0.2637042999267578,
-0.4422619938850403,
0.6077855229377747,
-0.5986424684524536,
-0.24968749284744263,
0.24543479084968567,
0.4264116585254669,
0.19459402561187744,
-0.11336444318294525,
-0.6208803057670593,
-0.5078468322753906,
-0.4439844787120819,
0.04242271929979324,
0.25013601779937744,
0.3105444312095642,
0.09604624658823013,
0.6003314256668091,
-0.020829830318689346,
0.1468089073896408,
-0.18843694031238556,
-0.05102274939417839,
0.5063977837562561,
-0.7180317640304565,
-1.0408345460891724,
-0.46689939498901367,
0.5109758973121643,
-0.5713688135147095,
-0.07552342861890793,
0.4557895064353943,
0.601939857006073,
1.0026476383209229,
-0.3783230185508728,
0.7045155167579651,
-0.011977816931903362,
0.6360390782356262,
-0.48671865463256836,
0.47688859701156616,
-0.8762104511260986,
0.14924897253513336,
-0.2991335093975067,
-0.9586978554725647,
-0.2046627253293991,
0.44125884771347046,
-0.3836193382740021,
0.3421659469604492,
0.6190951466560364,
0.39109084010124207,
-0.33120736479759216,
-0.27062034606933594,
0.3555482029914856,
-0.22834362089633942,
-0.2893078327178955,
0.22826889157295227,
0.5286571383476257,
-0.3080248534679413,
0.5076013803482056,
-0.4181649088859558,
-0.04032537341117859,
-0.6571344137191772,
-0.6920220255851746,
-0.637775182723999,
-0.49030616879463196,
-0.6260344982147217,
-0.2517169713973999,
0.19890707731246948,
0.8101975917816162,
0.7438724040985107,
-0.4919419288635254,
-0.506027102470398,
0.36819636821746826,
0.29904451966285706,
-0.9048058986663818,
-0.28647416830062866,
0.5262064933776855,
-0.19701097905635834,
-0.45500993728637695,
0.48035377264022827,
0.07515028864145279,
-0.14192980527877808,
-0.0654406026005745,
-0.11438235640525818,
0.09607710689306259,
-0.2141309678554535,
0.8648262023925781,
0.23969537019729614,
-0.4432193338871002,
-0.10466479510068893,
-0.8078655004501343,
-0.06507747620344162,
-0.17091083526611328,
0.8979915976524353,
-0.589318037033081,
0.5180607438087463,
0.3944866955280304,
0.9579121470451355,
0.1396310031414032,
0.3709951639175415,
0.5223386287689209,
-1.3173327445983887,
0.06226745620369911,
0.2500227689743042,
0.42569008469581604,
0.4314940571784973,
-0.6876094937324524,
0.5237023234367371,
0.3087347447872162,
-0.21524709463119507,
-0.3561469614505768,
0.44298073649406433,
-1.1745264530181885,
-0.2768935561180115,
1.1806116104125977,
-0.041280634701251984,
0.09901073575019836,
-0.36042463779449463,
0.02511516585946083,
0.5588403940200806,
-0.34672877192497253,
0.8073360323905945,
0.08536656945943832,
-0.302038311958313,
-0.20565909147262573,
-0.3027119040489197,
0.26758715510368347,
0.0956118181347847,
-0.3438144028186798,
0.08520431816577911,
0.42443257570266724,
-0.010665982961654663,
0.08401194959878922,
0.7807855010032654,
-0.2727196216583252,
0.2914304733276367,
-0.1182033121585846,
0.3143500089645386,
-0.1541161835193634,
-0.31465378403663635,
-0.3160778880119324,
0.030357446521520615,
0.20865704119205475,
-0.4472091495990753
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.08050v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.08050v1
|
Adversarial Evasion Attack Efficiency against Large Language Models
| 2024-06-12T10:02:27 | 2024-06-12T10:02:27 |
João Vitorino, Eva Maia, Isabel Praça
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) are valuable for text classification, but their
vulnerabilities must not be disregarded. They lack robustness against
adversarial examples, so it is pertinent to understand the impacts of different
types of perturbations, and assess if those attacks could be replicated by
common users with a small amount of perturbations and a small number of queries
to a deployed LLM. This work presents an analysis of the effectiveness,
efficiency, and practicality of three different types of adversarial attacks
against five different LLMs in a sentiment classification task. The obtained
results demonstrated the very distinct impacts of the word-level and
character-level attacks. The word attacks were more effective, but the
character and more constrained attacks were more practical and required a
reduced number of perturbations and queries. These differences need to be
considered during the development of adversarial defense strategies to train
more robust LLMs for intelligent text classification applications.
|
[
-0.3669467270374298,
-1.1483359336853027,
0.40664538741111755,
0.11149071902036667,
-0.038944389671087265,
0.09871543198823929,
-0.21403078734874725,
-0.25763723254203796,
-0.08180758357048035,
0.7359389066696167,
-0.17815545201301575,
-0.5732831954956055,
-0.866691529750824,
0.10383650660514832,
-0.8946239948272705,
1.0733221769332886,
0.3387850522994995,
0.08443662524223328,
0.05434634909033775,
-0.05470435693860054,
0.030981190502643585,
-1.1778817176818848,
-0.7976740598678589,
-0.008931678719818592,
0.7325122356414795,
-0.24358341097831726,
0.8880324363708496,
-0.05066705122590065,
0.7904255390167236,
0.3561709225177765,
-0.4018714427947998,
-0.13253054022789001,
-0.480851948261261,
0.2725920081138611,
-0.00949771422892809,
-0.7727435827255249,
-0.3040362000465393,
-0.03807060047984123,
0.5074494481086731,
0.4456179141998291,
0.014219962991774082,
-0.19443002343177795,
0.09940049052238464,
0.5888847708702087,
-0.7315357327461243,
-0.29628074169158936,
-0.8056578636169434,
0.08054852485656738,
-0.3550237715244293,
0.003816507989540696,
-0.6231128573417664,
-0.3299953043460846,
0.04970754310488701,
-0.20318758487701416,
-0.05009319633245468,
-0.10478254407644272,
0.6918849945068359,
0.2806537449359894,
-0.28143832087516785,
-0.539604663848877,
-0.408408522605896,
0.7253842949867249,
-0.8810843229293823,
0.031199205666780472,
0.020392201840877533,
0.1383034586906433,
-0.4691758155822754,
-0.49827006459236145,
-0.5385958552360535,
-0.39982545375823975,
-0.07764697819948196,
-0.10157312452793121,
-0.4349997043609619,
0.29890239238739014,
0.41231006383895874,
0.2623462975025177,
-0.416080504655838,
0.3428160846233368,
0.08036522567272186,
-0.04366065189242363,
0.5223303437232971,
0.209558367729187,
0.5490237474441528,
-0.30528590083122253,
-0.48665234446525574,
-0.3039989769458771,
-0.7551475763320923,
0.007953350432217121,
0.7391930222511292,
0.2998369336128235,
0.1343165785074234,
0.5538560152053833,
0.1255955994129181,
0.560531735420227,
-0.18944373726844788,
-0.31149032711982727,
-0.2297487109899521,
-0.16331873834133148,
-0.09467922151088715,
-0.2391112744808197,
1.022209644317627,
0.002396786818280816,
0.17713409662246704,
-0.2250988483428955,
-0.4582149386405945,
0.11276689171791077,
0.48023709654808044,
-0.7260173559188843,
-0.08609560132026672,
-0.03663221374154091,
-0.1830747425556183,
-0.725039005279541,
0.12420910596847534,
-0.856693685054779,
-0.8834995627403259,
0.19690291583538055,
0.41834890842437744,
-0.4776906371116638,
0.11761460453271866,
0.0866277813911438,
-0.2153136283159256,
0.17872029542922974,
0.3967909514904022,
-0.6562308669090271,
0.41611671447753906,
0.8089613914489746,
0.6791307330131531,
-0.11314620077610016,
0.021134166046977043,
-0.40542155504226685,
-0.24318262934684753,
-0.17505188286304474,
0.47792497277259827,
-0.3268410563468933,
-0.6756188869476318,
0.07522762566804886,
-0.39140063524246216,
-0.2518889307975769,
-0.40273207426071167,
0.6336408257484436,
-0.9380399584770203,
0.21630136668682098,
-0.23117785155773163,
-0.5235469341278076,
-0.3961828947067261,
0.5196680426597595,
-0.8050285577774048,
0.6218074560165405,
0.007308516185730696,
-1.1208049058914185,
-0.04945098236203194,
-0.37397468090057373,
-0.6512415409088135,
-0.0477750338613987,
-0.038316816091537476,
-0.35489621758461,
0.30963370203971863,
0.1060299202799797,
0.648586094379425,
-0.26783713698387146,
-0.2857305407524109,
-0.5206552147865295,
-0.2802659571170807,
0.5869855284690857,
-0.8526418805122375,
0.8039699792861938,
0.1631414294242859,
-0.27123141288757324,
-0.05269675701856613,
-0.6958443522453308,
-0.11962971836328506,
0.3203599750995636,
-0.521142303943634,
-0.6946621537208557,
0.1547149270772934,
-0.14838124811649323,
-0.042462341487407684,
0.258877158164978,
-0.382788747549057,
0.5224834680557251,
-0.6951989531517029,
0.21788786351680756,
0.5795619487762451,
0.2032313197851181,
0.16840428113937378,
0.007959489710628986,
0.7937648892402649,
-0.22992061078548431,
0.19080115854740143,
0.16820600628852844,
-0.1752651035785675,
-0.7366857528686523,
-0.41483181715011597,
0.3253202438354492,
0.6883397698402405,
-1.0235060453414917,
0.19761061668395996,
-0.06889884173870087,
-0.6047220826148987,
-0.3295421302318573,
0.225178524851799,
0.6371280550956726,
0.08687180280685425,
0.1805194616317749,
0.10826703906059265,
-0.2232031524181366,
-0.6376320123672485,
-0.6114593148231506,
-0.18055953085422516,
0.08372215926647186,
0.028564708307385445,
0.5999356508255005,
-0.22779884934425354,
0.37561655044555664,
-0.4889069199562073,
-0.0022594258189201355,
-0.5058110952377319,
0.03602956235408783,
-0.1023467630147934,
-0.027742961421608925,
0.8660677075386047,
-0.6349087953567505,
-0.5177562832832336,
-0.11928299069404602,
-0.7579923868179321,
0.004060075618326664,
-0.11518740653991699,
0.002193639287725091,
0.45034676790237427,
0.3817676901817322,
-0.6976897716522217,
0.4303733706474304,
0.5845662355422974,
-0.23974426090717316,
0.419552743434906,
0.08516673743724823,
0.1465691477060318,
-0.8115108013153076,
-0.145067498087883,
0.09442153573036194,
-0.1503155380487442,
-0.9438127279281616,
0.41987401247024536,
-0.010780027136206627,
0.014795904979109764,
-0.5598517060279846,
0.296484112739563,
-0.09352711588144302,
0.10819415003061295,
-0.17771099507808685,
0.11754172295331955,
0.06155969575047493,
0.1819992959499359,
-0.36146607995033264,
0.6574530005455017,
0.42764440178871155,
-0.599254846572876,
0.44851231575012207,
-0.08812914788722992,
-0.34842637181282043,
0.4715186059474945,
-0.6094635725021362,
0.3759300410747528,
-0.05426318570971489,
0.19187821447849274,
-0.8901888132095337,
0.060974325984716415,
0.3547511398792267,
-0.5926784873008728,
0.6590232849121094,
0.08966574817895889,
-0.615121603012085,
-0.15333369374275208,
-0.7657376527786255,
-0.09543333947658539,
0.15861864387989044,
-0.7964211702346802,
0.5629756450653076,
0.1709674745798111,
-0.038645245134830475,
-0.891865611076355,
-0.6731212735176086,
0.34853145480155945,
-0.5914759635925293,
-0.5401372313499451,
-0.04251466318964958,
0.1606033891439438,
-0.5068359971046448,
-0.2100696712732315,
0.2689172029495239,
0.32103338837623596,
0.5524984002113342,
0.08613570779561996,
0.21549078822135925,
-0.004692825488746166,
-0.1252017617225647,
-0.4047125279903412,
0.23125068843364716,
0.21164162456989288,
0.08321897685527802,
0.814512312412262,
-0.19833260774612427,
-0.45705777406692505,
-0.5006347298622131,
0.29360225796699524,
0.8103985786437988,
0.0033309778664261103,
1.0889675617218018,
0.48700225353240967,
-0.17576970160007477,
-0.33867135643959045,
-0.49773967266082764,
0.07737259566783905,
-0.4780159890651703,
0.7189425826072693,
-0.36308926343917847,
-0.6349608302116394,
0.37979987263679504,
0.2881149351596832,
0.15088576078414917,
0.5049887895584106,
0.33776792883872986,
-0.13057595491409302,
1.3009815216064453,
0.22010284662246704,
-0.5999515652656555,
0.30499154329299927,
-0.26308557391166687,
0.22465789318084717,
-0.7687373161315918,
-0.14876633882522583,
-0.7063677906990051,
-0.03468194231390953,
-0.6061522364616394,
-0.14047467708587646,
0.28509315848350525,
0.05683910846710205,
-0.09739308804273605,
0.29879170656204224,
-0.16533316671848297,
0.11297482252120972,
0.39901942014694214,
-0.004756933078169823,
0.08390260487794876,
0.24941158294677734,
0.25802528858184814,
0.028128579258918762,
-0.6174113750457764,
-0.6437897682189941,
1.0693771839141846,
0.47530487179756165,
1.0415914058685303,
0.4555700421333313,
0.5259366631507874,
0.37425270676612854,
0.3896525800228119,
-1.0222957134246826,
0.8145920634269714,
-0.6395775675773621,
-0.4690452814102173,
-0.13807305693626404,
-0.5679720044136047,
-0.8345312476158142,
0.4828778803348541,
-0.29250454902648926,
-0.5187408328056335,
-0.2751789689064026,
-0.017841512337327003,
-0.220723494887352,
0.6731316447257996,
-0.5968036651611328,
0.5476053357124329,
-0.46403437852859497,
0.02669672854244709,
-0.17699645459651947,
-0.2752363085746765,
0.28144147992134094,
-0.3402930796146393,
0.2370845228433609,
0.37586578726768494,
-0.14891822636127472,
0.6896597743034363,
-0.3250896632671356,
0.8994969725608826,
-0.28203317523002625,
-0.16297802329063416,
0.20778118073940277,
0.1406848430633545,
0.6505249738693237,
-0.21528322994709015,
-0.17519375681877136,
0.107481449842453,
-0.22472338378429413,
-0.15061986446380615,
-0.7205074429512024,
0.7462819218635559,
-0.7588726282119751,
-1.0462359189987183,
-0.3888285458087921,
-0.30774548649787903,
-0.16462041437625885,
-0.09474240988492966,
0.28256383538246155,
0.4702465534210205,
-0.3587329685688019,
0.41692426800727844,
0.7984678745269775,
-0.5245804190635681,
0.5202913880348206,
0.5015039443969727,
-0.0748714730143547,
-0.4199358820915222,
0.871199369430542,
0.138853520154953,
0.5397505164146423,
0.5393310785293579,
0.10637367516756058,
-0.18126195669174194,
-0.7379114627838135,
-0.13306394219398499,
0.11908531934022903,
-0.8794214725494385,
-0.29544687271118164,
-0.6412040591239929,
-0.1643683761358261,
-0.5436766147613525,
-0.0848226472735405,
-0.2847025692462921,
-0.2604244649410248,
-0.3683440685272217,
0.11386417597532272,
0.3180994391441345,
0.8296258449554443,
0.5727738738059998,
0.5762131214141846,
-0.5570345520973206,
-0.023851042613387108,
0.28996697068214417,
-0.04246087744832039,
0.0501595064997673,
-0.5834406614303589,
-0.08843284845352173,
-0.16969212889671326,
-0.3912141025066376,
-1.1028386354446411,
0.42916321754455566,
-0.011190308257937431,
0.4630853533744812,
0.5877830982208252,
0.13588935136795044,
0.1852598339319229,
-0.25604161620140076,
0.9996973276138306,
0.2585635781288147,
-0.8243620991706848,
0.35083335638046265,
-0.15366701781749725,
0.18192170560359955,
0.4832417964935303,
0.5541503429412842,
-0.25939664244651794,
-0.43317949771881104,
-0.5386031270027161,
-0.7612491846084595,
0.5889357328414917,
0.16209794580936432,
0.21399784088134766,
-0.015270842239260674,
0.404100239276886,
-0.19074741005897522,
0.15634126961231232,
-0.6403533816337585,
-0.3137386441230774,
-0.013727431185543537,
-0.21056124567985535,
-0.1428709775209427,
-0.3413672149181366,
-0.09879782050848007,
0.027676966041326523,
0.7364231944084167,
0.21101133525371552,
-0.1282663494348526,
0.08748739212751389,
-0.1920517235994339,
0.48360732197761536,
0.39661723375320435,
0.40192660689353943,
-0.18147604167461395,
0.2051437646150589,
0.2678641080856323,
0.4828541874885559,
-0.5912281274795532,
0.12335521727800369,
-0.11393038928508759,
-0.2673325836658478,
-0.21749967336654663,
0.6950348615646362,
0.8367687463760376,
0.08511854708194733,
-0.5923863649368286,
0.5785658359527588,
-0.3204173445701599,
-0.06600770354270935,
-0.16024532914161682,
0.16340479254722595,
-0.04775108024477959,
0.33814573287963867,
-0.053504250943660736,
0.046399086713790894,
0.12715718150138855,
-0.5288127660751343,
-0.3213138282299042,
0.8865044713020325,
-0.2005234956741333,
-0.3064057230949402,
0.22793640196323395,
-0.012469458393752575,
-0.385610967874527,
0.3749217987060547,
-0.07571583986282349,
-1.1462537050247192,
0.5076159834861755,
0.4003545045852661,
0.7758695483207703,
-0.32180967926979065,
-0.060375142842531204,
-0.17103201150894165,
0.42721056938171387,
0.05273481085896492,
-0.10449004918336868,
0.22823220491409302,
-0.6577110290527344,
0.013765310868620872,
-0.6437439918518066,
-0.4583640694618225,
0.4196903109550476,
-0.5254499316215515,
0.13989602029323578,
-0.8454242944717407,
-0.4628114700317383,
0.09935882687568665,
0.0027524051256477833,
-0.33176159858703613,
0.1914883852005005,
0.3458902835845947,
0.6905047297477722,
-0.4118787348270416,
0.4944971203804016,
0.8685154914855957,
-0.39380720257759094,
-0.6582590341567993,
0.16292035579681396,
0.2054254710674286,
-0.6145047545433044,
0.7413718104362488,
-0.055277928709983826,
-0.4344738721847534,
-0.39032113552093506,
-0.469382643699646,
-0.6898667216300964,
0.5558871626853943,
0.20197784900665283,
-0.39013493061065674,
0.13536027073860168,
0.19229789078235626,
0.7633269429206848,
-0.06629576534032822,
0.13393794000148773,
0.6269150972366333,
0.35652831196784973,
-0.15351365506649017,
-0.5541384816169739,
0.02639484591782093,
-0.02252580225467682,
0.08385320752859116,
0.2618652284145355,
-0.7256507873535156,
0.7304632663726807,
0.07854587584733963,
-0.22272208333015442,
-0.01746131107211113,
0.5303553342819214,
-0.05417850241065025,
-0.060647062957286835,
0.6397619247436523,
0.6502381563186646,
0.5125007629394531,
-0.05063130334019661,
1.5180354118347168,
-0.38583630323410034,
0.11601126194000244,
0.6184314489364624,
-0.09865635633468628,
0.9544402360916138,
0.21646589040756226,
-0.3965718150138855,
0.20660685002803802,
0.20920120179653168,
-0.06991790235042572,
0.34892407059669495,
0.39467522501945496,
-0.42981916666030884,
0.11181613057851791,
0.2515140771865845,
-0.196308895945549,
0.41393184661865234,
0.5706067681312561,
-0.26770609617233276,
0.06193514168262482,
0.2711360454559326,
0.7263022661209106,
0.11759767681360245,
-0.33319568634033203,
0.84722501039505,
0.11453757435083389,
-0.5490404963493347,
0.5789611339569092,
0.23181620240211487,
1.0209155082702637,
-0.6860657334327698,
0.4706873297691345,
-0.031999897211790085,
0.5752927660942078,
-0.30048176646232605,
-0.5853475332260132,
-0.021499793976545334,
0.3304485082626343,
-0.05210709571838379,
0.12171608209609985,
0.7996653318405151,
-0.0857912078499794,
-0.37073954939842224,
0.39052292704582214,
-0.04726983606815338,
-0.09366943687200546,
-0.22056612372398376,
-0.616007387638092,
0.1975695937871933,
0.11523577570915222,
-0.775801420211792,
0.5606896281242371,
0.1689154952764511,
0.2755756378173828,
0.701429545879364,
0.47252869606018066,
0.4380493760108948,
0.008160949684679508,
0.36963993310928345,
0.8777737021446228,
-0.45840081572532654,
-0.17222651839256287,
-1.1120424270629883,
-0.02289341390132904,
-0.2796332836151123,
-0.07156745344400406,
1.1861660480499268,
0.20209796726703644,
0.5168898105621338,
0.12521590292453766,
0.9050540328025818,
0.307645708322525,
0.4761628806591034,
-0.5719414949417114,
0.7030186057090759,
-0.44442710280418396,
0.8171716332435608,
-0.4633176922798157,
-0.6383280158042908,
-0.3980506658554077,
0.36352047324180603,
-0.4184753894805908,
0.09539280086755753,
0.650399923324585,
0.6602254509925842,
0.5348665714263916,
0.15655751526355743,
0.27101296186447144,
0.39616045355796814,
0.7442952394485474,
0.2936440408229828,
1.1937793493270874,
-0.30568182468414307,
0.5723249912261963,
-0.14449016749858856,
-0.21145561337471008,
-0.028971390798687935,
-0.5028986930847168,
-1.248927116394043,
0.0773208811879158,
-0.2331627458333969,
-0.4856468141078949,
0.3031628131866455,
0.6659507155418396,
0.2214696705341339,
-0.6738892197608948,
0.06999914348125458,
0.17202168703079224,
0.05459952726960182,
0.31490838527679443,
-0.27029532194137573,
0.48395317792892456,
-0.3570578396320343,
-0.6741144061088562,
0.40743595361709595,
0.06949809193611145,
0.027311153709888458,
-0.6633560061454773,
0.19140726327896118,
-0.04207896441221237,
0.42137789726257324,
0.7535150647163391,
0.02282879874110222,
-0.72398841381073,
-0.30340951681137085,
-0.11425022035837173,
-0.40561559796333313,
-0.44437551498413086,
0.6152104735374451,
-0.43314334750175476,
0.2063639611005783,
0.5678855180740356,
0.8499947786331177,
-0.06100933998823166,
0.10794168710708618,
0.28927549719810486,
-0.6781880855560303,
0.06567457318305969,
0.38022899627685547,
0.42465347051620483,
0.3690199851989746,
-0.640171468257904,
0.15358780324459076,
0.2406955361366272,
-0.43414849042892456,
-0.8120520114898682,
0.13090276718139648,
-0.6089235544204712,
-0.6278910636901855,
1.552167296409607,
-0.4077604115009308,
-0.1125105544924736,
0.11612560600042343,
-0.27292361855506897,
-0.09728481620550156,
-0.28133392333984375,
0.6254420280456543,
0.8954948782920837,
0.03415351361036301,
0.27618589997291565,
-0.4920591711997986,
0.4276885986328125,
0.4450891315937042,
-0.7717490196228027,
-0.0658285990357399,
0.27006426453590393,
0.11334267258644104,
0.07502970099449158,
0.0756860226392746,
-0.25032418966293335,
-0.26359492540359497,
0.0041781822219491005,
-0.15913277864456177,
0.10199521481990814,
-0.22739256918430328,
-0.485111802816391,
0.6656343936920166,
0.10462682694196701,
-0.03905285522341728
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10284v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10284v1
|
Improving child speech recognition with augmented child-like speech
| 2024-06-12T08:56:46 | 2024-06-12T08:56:46 |
Yuanyuan Zhang, Zhengjun Yue, Tanvina Patel, Odette Scharenborg
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
State-of-the-art ASRs show suboptimal performance for child speech. The
scarcity of child speech limits the development of child speech recognition
(CSR). Therefore, we studied child-to-child voice conversion (VC) from existing
child speakers in the dataset and additional (new) child speakers via
monolingual and cross-lingual (Dutch-to-German) VC, respectively. The results
showed that cross-lingual child-to-child VC significantly improved child ASR
performance. Experiments on the impact of the quantity of child-to-child
cross-lingual VC-generated data on fine-tuning (FT) ASR models gave the best
results with two-fold augmentation for our FT-Conformer model and FT-Whisper
model which reduced WERs with ~3% absolute compared to the baseline, and with
six-fold augmentation for the model trained from scratch, which improved by an
absolute 3.6% WER. Moreover, using a small amount of "high-quality"
VC-generated data achieved similar results to those of our best-FT models.
|
[
-0.5114476084709167,
-0.29795047640800476,
-0.23672924935817719,
-0.09405189007520676,
-0.32947176694869995,
0.1643756777048111,
-0.2529667019844055,
-0.8199760913848877,
-0.2539425194263458,
0.4579470157623291,
-0.564130425453186,
-0.0938870832324028,
-0.5260159373283386,
0.013675670139491558,
-0.5361983776092529,
0.8031644821166992,
0.1833486109972,
0.4780619442462921,
-0.10436806827783585,
0.1750074177980423,
-0.30207815766334534,
-0.7008921504020691,
-0.9340425729751587,
-0.25229838490486145,
0.33158063888549805,
0.6867777109146118,
0.3843768537044525,
0.7384084463119507,
0.16564491391181946,
0.25316253304481506,
-0.38953474164009094,
0.10258333384990692,
-0.5554331541061401,
-0.09744703024625778,
-0.16111798584461212,
-0.06234372407197952,
-0.6931236386299133,
0.03268064185976982,
0.6455366611480713,
0.9307110905647278,
-0.10436376184225082,
-0.07262519747018814,
0.42960241436958313,
0.7416169047355652,
-0.4781365990638733,
0.11485586315393448,
-0.570937991142273,
0.056788597255945206,
-0.20423275232315063,
-0.29821446537971497,
-0.36666586995124817,
0.008906408213078976,
0.5805802941322327,
-0.6698294281959534,
0.6526305079460144,
-0.1342628002166748,
0.6669824719429016,
0.10099104046821594,
-0.17102929949760437,
-0.4043102264404297,
-1.0601441860198975,
0.7663547992706299,
-0.476588636636734,
0.787827730178833,
0.34275147318840027,
0.10742614418268204,
-0.08570205420255661,
-0.5572424530982971,
-0.5887757539749146,
-0.26231157779693604,
0.07926157861948013,
0.004498491529375315,
-0.5372898578643799,
0.03139657899737358,
0.2450476437807083,
0.24978874623775482,
-0.541077196598053,
0.18412797152996063,
-0.86604905128479,
-0.21923139691352844,
0.8105950951576233,
-0.02265951782464981,
0.11918502300977707,
0.12734296917915344,
-0.10170178860425949,
-0.41460052132606506,
-0.5701332092285156,
0.4155122935771942,
0.2712279260158539,
0.8622531890869141,
0.03220702335238457,
0.34084776043891907,
-0.3710455298423767,
0.7186199426651001,
0.7240753769874573,
-0.37516576051712036,
0.21100540459156036,
-0.40169596672058105,
-0.037149135023355484,
0.3862234950065613,
0.319871723651886,
0.2298947423696518,
0.5709887146949768,
-0.06650734692811966,
-0.3529818058013916,
0.25160133838653564,
0.0042761522345244884,
-0.7661831974983215,
-0.1592070311307907,
-0.4033890962600708,
-0.47253769636154175,
-0.047484248876571655,
0.06216726079583168,
-0.28292718529701233,
-0.15463918447494507,
-0.582209587097168,
0.29873043298721313,
-0.49177178740501404,
-0.2303914576768875,
0.052123744040727615,
-0.1447581946849823,
0.327314168214798,
0.2627665102481842,
-0.9318526983261108,
0.6984384059906006,
0.543032169342041,
0.4077228307723999,
-0.26777899265289307,
-0.1812877357006073,
-0.6515058279037476,
0.11332709342241287,
-0.5957168936729431,
0.9183971881866455,
-0.4346202611923218,
-0.812329113483429,
-0.13264533877372742,
0.0022252784110605717,
-0.1136549562215805,
-1.0282998085021973,
0.433193176984787,
-0.35081228613853455,
0.11979690194129944,
-0.26608583331108093,
-0.19616074860095978,
-0.059530649334192276,
-0.25662773847579956,
-0.42570722103118896,
0.8513288497924805,
0.1539788395166397,
-0.2655891180038452,
0.9545896649360657,
-0.4633626639842987,
-0.7641856670379639,
0.08429037779569626,
0.2975785732269287,
-0.30832821130752563,
0.2684156000614166,
0.5980159640312195,
0.23874324560165405,
-0.23060983419418335,
-0.0691867247223854,
0.10502145439386368,
-0.43549180030822754,
-0.041264913976192474,
-0.7205310463905334,
0.6631978154182434,
0.2338208109140396,
-0.0856449082493782,
-0.15017841756343842,
-0.9081850647926331,
-0.05292217433452606,
-0.19115956127643585,
-0.4052460193634033,
-0.22404426336288452,
0.022739773616194725,
0.3312351703643799,
0.5285855531692505,
0.1792072206735611,
-0.7335638403892517,
-0.1605735570192337,
-0.6324765086174011,
0.30097731947898865,
0.19005708396434784,
-0.11514096707105637,
0.33589550852775574,
-0.47914978861808777,
0.4112219512462616,
0.2553032636642456,
0.44354769587516785,
0.19184459745883942,
-0.30529308319091797,
-1.1143358945846558,
-0.18361182510852814,
0.2842079997062683,
0.3946116864681244,
-0.8833762407302856,
0.36987432837486267,
-0.44256746768951416,
-0.39593401551246643,
-0.7087582945823669,
-0.04778904467821121,
0.7573782205581665,
0.6693907976150513,
0.4565090835094452,
-0.7637408971786499,
-0.8318531513214111,
-0.8035992980003357,
0.046832919120788574,
-0.46140164136886597,
-0.025107890367507935,
0.3702180087566376,
0.1118495836853981,
-0.10749857127666473,
0.8031631112098694,
0.19012780487537384,
-0.35832270979881287,
-0.1876755803823471,
-0.08125724643468857,
-0.06700421124696732,
0.6939741969108582,
0.30585893988609314,
-0.7814050316810608,
-0.6926162838935852,
0.1855817437171936,
0.07655001431703568,
-0.1250225454568863,
0.32122641801834106,
0.5519391894340515,
0.5539103746414185,
0.5123600363731384,
-0.03992214426398277,
0.6830571889877319,
0.6998053193092346,
-0.17742402851581573,
0.2789035439491272,
-0.13997502624988556,
0.2218402624130249,
-0.6789084076881409,
-0.14113062620162964,
-0.27178335189819336,
-0.23311865329742432,
-0.9755019545555115,
-0.25541624426841736,
-0.12763187289237976,
-0.2464999556541443,
-0.773152232170105,
0.18330524861812592,
-0.479452520608902,
-0.16463056206703186,
-0.3935525715351105,
-0.0719941109418869,
-0.3047550320625305,
0.0008230750681832433,
0.22740501165390015,
1.1814677715301514,
0.5993609428405762,
-0.5979298949241638,
0.42993924021720886,
0.18849243223667145,
0.07846655696630478,
0.7004424333572388,
-0.7670621275901794,
0.20247483253479004,
0.01623494178056717,
0.25039243698120117,
-0.944857120513916,
-0.06003605201840401,
-0.19470195472240448,
-0.8096430897712708,
0.8284191489219666,
-0.20824852585792542,
-0.47175708413124084,
-0.5445026159286499,
-0.09818688035011292,
0.36027076840400696,
0.46654146909713745,
-0.8119998574256897,
0.4552556276321411,
0.5494359731674194,
-0.4230104684829712,
-0.17703916132450104,
-0.7755264639854431,
0.2283214032649994,
0.13576149940490723,
-0.7220199108123779,
0.4277881681919098,
0.09081940352916718,
0.29295065999031067,
0.11675099283456802,
-0.20840412378311157,
-0.2441960871219635,
-0.5501473546028137,
-0.0743546262383461,
0.21040259301662445,
-0.4112743139266968,
-0.05560314282774925,
0.2287759929895401,
-0.39676037430763245,
-0.141069233417511,
-0.20288589596748352,
0.47425326704978943,
-0.18611560761928558,
-0.09521465748548508,
-0.5489060878753662,
0.41370251774787903,
0.6272535920143127,
-0.07951955497264862,
0.4304948151111603,
0.26167500019073486,
-0.4303187131881714,
-0.2748793661594391,
-0.5742643475532532,
-0.03974799066781998,
-0.4779622256755829,
0.2160864621400833,
-0.6095489859580994,
-0.9924980401992798,
0.4858461916446686,
0.11599656194448471,
-0.4138869643211365,
0.47324544191360474,
0.35916775465011597,
0.025336183607578278,
1.209991455078125,
0.6204814910888672,
-0.10196422040462494,
0.5755366683006287,
-0.07868152856826782,
-0.028764136135578156,
-0.8799697160720825,
-0.3006727695465088,
-0.4285113215446472,
0.02508118376135826,
-0.9899376034736633,
-0.4024882912635803,
0.4618975818157196,
-0.06891283392906189,
-0.06560119241476059,
0.5410144925117493,
-0.8432806730270386,
0.21238276362419128,
0.6544601917266846,
0.05860905721783638,
0.2878822982311249,
-0.016722388565540314,
0.22114309668540955,
-0.2143421322107315,
-0.9336910843849182,
-0.2608823776245117,
0.8831505179405212,
0.1274292916059494,
0.6998382210731506,
-0.016052335500717163,
0.6180598139762878,
0.049454912543296814,
0.18215857446193695,
-0.6722427010536194,
0.5062024593353271,
-0.8576912879943848,
-0.5867631435394287,
-0.3979601263999939,
-0.27849316596984863,
-0.8477787971496582,
0.007329470012336969,
-0.3204880356788635,
-0.4805479645729065,
0.7570307850837708,
0.4220488667488098,
-0.3433694541454315,
0.017102951183915138,
-0.6766356825828552,
0.32754260301589966,
-0.1030309721827507,
-0.21012108027935028,
-0.18624956905841827,
-0.5862319469451904,
0.015383321791887283,
-0.2518211007118225,
-0.156659334897995,
0.38323551416397095,
0.01927565410733223,
0.6917240619659424,
-0.5367319583892822,
0.6752902269363403,
-0.3240249454975128,
-0.056378576904535294,
0.49792084097862244,
-0.38176628947257996,
0.4513787031173706,
-0.35152772068977356,
-0.07925739884376526,
0.1445549577474594,
-0.02343391254544258,
-0.23738227784633636,
-0.3988434970378876,
0.7178750038146973,
-0.9303115606307983,
-0.49329930543899536,
-0.3354480564594269,
-0.6017206907272339,
-0.3667636513710022,
-0.01350549515336752,
0.4047587215900421,
0.41898229718208313,
-0.19127562642097473,
0.4157322645187378,
0.6944019198417664,
-0.19334059953689575,
0.26786741614341736,
0.7468769550323486,
-0.06464144587516785,
-0.5489680767059326,
0.887268602848053,
0.6012977361679077,
0.5156633853912354,
0.0906047523021698,
0.21886037290096283,
-0.39533570408821106,
-0.556614339351654,
-0.4284740388393402,
0.09940224885940552,
-0.41482192277908325,
0.008531064726412296,
-0.373680055141449,
-0.6780144572257996,
-0.8362017869949341,
-0.26602423191070557,
-0.5330883264541626,
-0.5139743089675903,
-0.5055549740791321,
-0.01488843560218811,
0.33595147728919983,
0.49159637093544006,
-0.4297509491443634,
0.24651502072811127,
-0.480423241853714,
0.3613322675228119,
0.6249306797981262,
0.20766298472881317,
-0.025592075660824776,
-1.0804742574691772,
-0.23138019442558289,
-0.03132031112909317,
-0.0998571515083313,
-0.38730213046073914,
0.48386967182159424,
0.4722287952899933,
0.10511697828769684,
0.256738543510437,
0.04483047127723694,
1.267413854598999,
-0.7186014652252197,
0.6951431632041931,
0.24755877256393433,
-1.1268736124038696,
0.625977635383606,
-0.43466705083847046,
0.05284455791115761,
0.4941053092479706,
-0.3125055432319641,
-0.4485853612422943,
-0.09455506503582001,
-0.5722518563270569,
-0.8486070036888123,
0.9864473342895508,
0.014790707267820835,
0.20895379781723022,
0.42833295464515686,
0.07372520118951797,
0.08695291727781296,
0.11601772159337997,
-0.34983518719673157,
-0.20306463539600372,
-0.3279218375682831,
0.2296696901321411,
-0.26122403144836426,
-0.14442063868045807,
0.2558581233024597,
-0.8253364562988281,
0.8080066442489624,
0.1834728866815567,
-0.006617530714720488,
0.21408522129058838,
0.25615012645721436,
-0.6486427187919617,
0.38289675116539,
0.5640354752540588,
0.31593385338783264,
-0.05452273041009903,
-0.05112532153725624,
0.550279438495636,
-0.4318680763244629,
0.11476627737283707,
0.5279030799865723,
-0.35831987857818604,
-0.0793599933385849,
0.49138447642326355,
0.8074885606765747,
0.09056679904460907,
-0.5238559246063232,
0.4844309091567993,
0.10909319669008255,
-0.34794723987579346,
-0.41892701387405396,
0.3455246388912201,
-0.011948710307478905,
0.16685150563716888,
0.5008214712142944,
-0.00630291597917676,
0.34109368920326233,
-0.6643304228782654,
0.37297242879867554,
0.43706557154655457,
-0.7260450720787048,
-0.18966999650001526,
0.6460504531860352,
0.22344970703125,
-0.4719081521034241,
0.317023903131485,
-0.011776394210755825,
-0.5250794887542725,
0.34838318824768066,
0.921596109867096,
0.8841539621353149,
-0.7024016380310059,
0.0422891303896904,
0.2326785922050476,
0.464153528213501,
0.14690369367599487,
0.3719530403614044,
-0.24267975986003876,
-0.5677716135978699,
-0.3552597761154175,
-0.33903855085372925,
-0.47722333669662476,
0.20647010207176208,
-1.1037611961364746,
0.20438851416110992,
-0.18176016211509705,
-0.04144725576043129,
-0.012763378210365772,
0.06083546578884125,
-0.6007592678070068,
0.6325269341468811,
0.2973507046699524,
0.5669681429862976,
-0.760671079158783,
0.8997498154640198,
0.6977536678314209,
-0.20845264196395874,
-0.8965990543365479,
0.08939079940319061,
-0.18920952081680298,
-0.5852453112602234,
0.6495123505592346,
-0.06446265429258347,
-0.5775963068008423,
0.09151933342218399,
-0.5498865842819214,
-1.0203886032104492,
0.7551520466804504,
0.1804954707622528,
-0.8980658650398254,
0.10578365623950958,
0.5826607346534729,
0.9197862148284912,
-0.4189501702785492,
-0.37964192032814026,
0.6409584879875183,
0.22115585207939148,
0.21182596683502197,
-1.4385461807250977,
-0.29872334003448486,
-0.30072203278541565,
0.4492736756801605,
0.11593912541866302,
-0.42952969670295715,
0.8210879564285278,
-0.17078188061714172,
-0.31635022163391113,
0.006700700148940086,
0.7143504023551941,
0.3027788996696472,
0.6200926303863525,
0.7195748090744019,
0.28089800477027893,
0.2805446684360504,
0.0312773771584034,
0.6818859577178955,
-0.2589688003063202,
0.051121942698955536,
0.819165050983429,
-0.18545904755592346,
1.0070512294769287,
0.6281060576438904,
-0.11176571995019913,
0.10898604989051819,
0.3437521755695343,
0.2300194799900055,
0.647156834602356,
0.11895221471786499,
-0.365668922662735,
-0.14884120225906372,
-0.3442537486553192,
-0.32547610998153687,
0.5305894017219543,
0.6275162100791931,
-0.3157012164592743,
0.1902133822441101,
0.2691565752029419,
-0.2483556717634201,
0.13362295925617218,
-0.4680785536766052,
1.0026185512542725,
0.04037005454301834,
-0.4247298240661621,
1.0106526613235474,
-0.26696741580963135,
0.7671287655830383,
-0.3120177686214447,
-0.015397079288959503,
0.19953195750713348,
0.10656803101301193,
-0.2766997814178467,
-0.3302198350429535,
0.19362735748291016,
0.517638623714447,
-0.5129252672195435,
-0.19103072583675385,
0.6892447471618652,
-0.6308491826057434,
-0.7508510947227478,
0.46005016565322876,
0.4886711537837982,
0.11988943815231323,
0.3115614950656891,
-0.5001465082168579,
-0.12553982436656952,
-0.04138743877410889,
-0.10425949096679688,
0.05924306809902191,
0.4399898946285248,
-0.12584348022937775,
0.38986653089523315,
0.961669385433197,
0.508995532989502,
0.20401722192764282,
0.17373134195804596,
1.1131634712219238,
-0.2978730797767639,
-0.42392468452453613,
-0.2411249279975891,
0.4092368483543396,
0.21852044761180878,
-0.3821167051792145,
0.4942006766796112,
0.7579404711723328,
1.2387572526931763,
0.00630783848464489,
0.7190556526184082,
0.0106666786596179,
1.1360328197479248,
-0.2263132482767105,
0.6304476261138916,
-0.5516908168792725,
0.11624060571193695,
-0.6248637437820435,
-0.6676230430603027,
-0.33334165811538696,
0.7317249774932861,
-0.2640637755393982,
0.10122546553611755,
0.27093738317489624,
0.9962897896766663,
-0.21856045722961426,
-0.16989633440971375,
0.643729567527771,
-0.055071137845516205,
0.130918487906456,
0.494920015335083,
0.9244130253791809,
-0.5872715711593628,
0.710236132144928,
-0.4533579349517822,
-0.31779831647872925,
-0.1481831818819046,
-0.33629247546195984,
-0.5842366218566895,
-0.5042760372161865,
-0.27651160955429077,
-0.23072299361228943,
0.522984504699707,
0.8430426120758057,
0.9034491181373596,
-1.0622689723968506,
-0.28288400173187256,
-0.15082934498786926,
-0.6391690373420715,
-0.30907487869262695,
-0.17945189774036407,
0.21389399468898773,
0.10950017720460892,
-0.8447273373603821,
0.8110575675964355,
0.08980659395456314,
0.015649478882551193,
0.08272109180688858,
-0.294940710067749,
0.24548986554145813,
0.23660051822662354,
0.6636684536933899,
0.39656612277030945,
-0.8443068861961365,
-0.46479347348213196,
-0.0005050647305324674,
-0.030838320031762123,
0.19498907029628754,
0.6611393094062805,
-0.7316881418228149,
0.8501918911933899,
0.3659842014312744,
0.3320825695991516,
0.7235273718833923,
0.27835577726364136,
0.4779449999332428,
-0.7401463985443115,
0.1283321976661682,
0.4278465509414673,
-0.018977148458361626,
0.4912438988685608,
-0.13178642094135284,
0.2014511525630951,
0.11594593524932861,
-0.34759601950645447,
-0.7335647940635681,
0.12787805497646332,
-0.7898150086402893,
0.18376338481903076,
0.9862332344055176,
0.10116808116436005,
0.1429363489151001,
-0.3981088697910309,
-0.3133658766746521,
0.5634664297103882,
-0.6890884637832642,
0.5033724308013916,
0.43842267990112305,
-0.4771973192691803,
-0.2201034426689148,
-0.13042134046554565,
0.4389271140098572,
0.19013158977031708,
-0.4948633015155792,
0.1248655617237091,
0.5872161984443665,
0.16391344368457794,
0.2680722773075104,
0.5077363848686218,
-0.1803847700357437,
0.6461321711540222,
0.2147080898284912,
0.17807750403881073,
-0.08787371218204498,
-0.43557894229888916,
-0.648716390132904,
-0.041323378682136536,
0.16019149124622345,
-0.3751690685749054
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10283v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10283v1
|
Attentive Merging of Hidden Embeddings from Pre-trained Speech Model for Anti-spoofing Detection
| 2024-06-12T08:27:44 | 2024-06-12T08:27:44 |
Zihan Pan, Tianchi Liu, Hardik B. Sailor, Qiongqiong Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
Self-supervised learning (SSL) speech representation models, trained on large
speech corpora, have demonstrated effectiveness in extracting hierarchical
speech embeddings through multiple transformer layers. However, the behavior of
these embeddings in specific tasks remains uncertain. This paper investigates
the multi-layer behavior of the WavLM model in anti-spoofing and proposes an
attentive merging method to leverage the hierarchical hidden embeddings.
Results demonstrate the feasibility of fine-tuning WavLM to achieve the best
equal error rate (EER) of 0.65%, 3.50%, and 3.19% on the ASVspoof 2019LA,
2021LA, and 2021DF evaluation sets, respectively. Notably, We find that the
early hidden transformer layers of the WavLM large model contribute
significantly to anti-spoofing task, enabling computational efficiency by
utilizing a partial pre-trained model.
|
[
-0.3329831063747406,
-0.9475641250610352,
0.097603440284729,
-0.1104595735669136,
-0.3166550397872925,
0.3444393277168274,
0.06296568363904953,
-0.5847392678260803,
0.3299255073070526,
0.44483351707458496,
-0.4938587546348572,
-0.12698347866535187,
-0.7625302076339722,
-0.5294128656387329,
-0.7199180722236633,
0.8664844632148743,
0.2668280005455017,
-0.24196761846542358,
-0.23829980194568634,
-0.10718675702810287,
0.005505236331373453,
-0.7835955023765564,
-0.27121689915657043,
-0.24429883062839508,
0.29112595319747925,
0.05862594023346901,
0.5000227689743042,
0.4541066586971283,
0.2436332106590271,
0.3263513743877411,
0.06589300185441971,
0.2349623143672943,
-0.23733872175216675,
0.02150851860642433,
-0.015448655933141708,
-0.11918240785598755,
-0.6012918949127197,
0.11564647406339645,
0.7048200964927673,
0.04426679387688637,
-0.5617815852165222,
0.3091537356376648,
0.06983192265033722,
0.013156785629689693,
-0.7413566708564758,
-0.14932870864868164,
-0.8749666213989258,
0.1083856001496315,
-0.3088712692260742,
-0.3439381718635559,
-0.36048129200935364,
-0.12560321390628815,
0.2867453396320343,
-0.3451046049594879,
0.1906043440103531,
-0.08765161782503128,
0.7577173709869385,
0.44017359614372253,
-0.23759569227695465,
-0.08924851566553116,
-0.5910549163818359,
1.0056309700012207,
-0.7948393821716309,
0.5047224760055542,
0.42145514488220215,
0.2822127342224121,
-0.05705410614609718,
-0.445818156003952,
-0.6162225008010864,
-0.1560952067375183,
0.18981969356536865,
0.21415074169635773,
-0.875791072845459,
-0.16591237485408783,
0.029078729450702667,
0.24369123578071594,
-0.2590861916542053,
0.1529196947813034,
-0.38274073600769043,
-0.4795049726963043,
0.6236320734024048,
-0.3232377767562866,
0.23406314849853516,
-0.04183632880449295,
-0.5451145172119141,
-0.01775961183011532,
-0.3791177570819855,
0.20950819551944733,
0.5228725671768188,
0.45706769824028015,
-0.08113820850849152,
0.34222331643104553,
0.00543051864951849,
0.2916092872619629,
0.25784268975257874,
-0.012822967022657394,
0.5337939262390137,
-0.11297697573900223,
-0.4562537372112274,
0.389899343252182,
0.6392965912818909,
-0.10168866813182831,
-0.02104964852333069,
-0.07438553124666214,
-0.4113779366016388,
0.3730432093143463,
0.6205187439918518,
-0.33332785964012146,
-0.1515943706035614,
0.5106320977210999,
-0.39878422021865845,
-0.6210110187530518,
-0.02729242481291294,
-0.329619437456131,
-0.04381837323307991,
-0.17402184009552002,
0.9387593269348145,
-0.4108797609806061,
-0.7439051866531372,
0.0033864325378090143,
-0.13262751698493958,
0.191672220826149,
0.10507310181856155,
-0.30909448862075806,
0.3289591670036316,
0.5055395364761353,
0.4106695055961609,
-0.2097812443971634,
-0.7545568346977234,
-0.9136978983879089,
0.21994183957576752,
-0.30410632491111755,
0.5751649737358093,
-0.23174627125263214,
-0.43610015511512756,
-0.13142818212509155,
-0.029128776863217354,
-0.22621384263038635,
-0.6050679683685303,
0.3218350112438202,
-0.4190232753753662,
0.11037630587816238,
0.23669551312923431,
-0.5299549698829651,
-0.006797846406698227,
0.206033393740654,
-0.5762816071510315,
1.2126861810684204,
-0.10078908503055573,
-0.7359445095062256,
0.19932220876216888,
-0.7467405200004578,
-0.5726626515388489,
0.18019665777683258,
-0.08713644742965698,
-0.9080373644828796,
0.23565708100795746,
0.18759767711162567,
0.3925899863243103,
0.3685033321380615,
-0.012888103723526001,
-0.17907866835594177,
-0.40379172563552856,
0.269489049911499,
-0.6008798480033875,
0.8957903385162354,
0.2573578655719757,
-0.7763609290122986,
0.48247000575065613,
-0.9623600244522095,
0.29746684432029724,
0.18426333367824554,
-0.13789287209510803,
-0.23568765819072723,
-0.08477256447076797,
-0.0037498550955206156,
0.1468067765235901,
0.14905062317848206,
-0.5245203971862793,
-0.23045285046100616,
-0.27666857838630676,
0.41743525862693787,
0.48956748843193054,
-0.05116450414061546,
0.5804343819618225,
-0.3403644859790802,
0.4179406464099884,
0.48799535632133484,
0.5027123689651489,
-0.14150241017341614,
-0.6008312106132507,
-0.552514910697937,
-0.5889506340026855,
0.10230813920497894,
0.6199462413787842,
-0.4599238336086273,
0.6580843925476074,
-0.07500868290662766,
-0.7145575284957886,
-0.9954047203063965,
-0.008036987856030464,
0.4962747395038605,
0.23861396312713623,
0.6623747944831848,
-0.052324455231428146,
-0.3948762118816376,
-0.7956109046936035,
-0.27732741832733154,
0.1735280454158783,
-0.03267383575439453,
0.04707781597971916,
0.3589784502983093,
-0.3418397307395935,
0.8497823476791382,
0.045693814754486084,
-0.4114242196083069,
-0.038835108280181885,
0.09471908211708069,
-0.24947524070739746,
0.8069230318069458,
0.48578646779060364,
-0.7712868452072144,
-0.3676261007785797,
-0.20401836931705475,
-0.3812655210494995,
0.17277036607265472,
0.011958738788962364,
0.1743924766778946,
0.13302059471607208,
0.5060184597969055,
-0.5839332342147827,
0.869998037815094,
0.65283203125,
0.08198501914739609,
0.3521972894668579,
-0.471619188785553,
0.058943357318639755,
-0.7885697484016418,
-0.288291335105896,
-0.1454375982284546,
-0.20926737785339355,
-1.0095276832580566,
0.34838512539863586,
0.4777046740055084,
-0.1013871505856514,
-0.6132428646087646,
-0.09243718534708023,
-0.4963900148868561,
0.1740245521068573,
-0.2933301627635956,
0.1144641786813736,
-0.213537335395813,
0.21761980652809143,
-0.17737311124801636,
0.47742798924446106,
0.9631869196891785,
-0.2998930513858795,
0.28422215580940247,
-0.1965339332818985,
-0.21266914904117584,
0.26601508259773254,
-0.5128191113471985,
0.30000442266464233,
-0.0666741207242012,
0.4218710958957672,
-0.8994589447975159,
0.037547700107097626,
0.14933133125305176,
-0.5302771925926208,
0.38756051659584045,
-0.2732485830783844,
-0.4188311696052551,
-0.4689090847969055,
-0.4461555778980255,
0.37447264790534973,
0.5407717823982239,
-0.5546673536300659,
1.0183050632476807,
0.5823361277580261,
0.3806018531322479,
-0.48451805114746094,
-0.859451949596405,
-0.16564710438251495,
-0.29300129413604736,
-0.5497857928276062,
0.4146212339401245,
-0.018276730552315712,
0.18872059881687164,
-0.08750788122415543,
-0.23007293045520782,
-0.00007122505485313013,
0.010199123993515968,
0.4522703289985657,
0.25094228982925415,
-0.3211127817630768,
-0.5098848342895508,
-0.0641292929649353,
0.07464329153299332,
-0.21113407611846924,
-0.19791032373905182,
0.3477709889411926,
-0.07060212641954422,
-0.8237356543540955,
-0.8720688223838806,
0.609248697757721,
0.918011486530304,
-0.4803553521633148,
0.7161110639572144,
0.7331922054290771,
-0.539808452129364,
-0.3498164415359497,
-0.7993923425674438,
-0.28179898858070374,
-0.5204682946205139,
0.2306981086730957,
-0.46797576546669006,
-0.6078431606292725,
0.87925124168396,
0.23329350352287292,
-0.1544753462076187,
0.22045589983463287,
0.1727750450372696,
-0.09473196417093277,
0.9651706218719482,
0.5804176330566406,
-0.3008876144886017,
0.4985961318016052,
-0.19523049890995026,
0.26123860478401184,
-0.5623136162757874,
-0.3228050768375397,
-0.2141536921262741,
0.1490863859653473,
-0.533862292766571,
-0.6327198147773743,
0.08148925006389618,
0.0005654107662849128,
-0.10051199793815613,
0.26167231798171997,
-0.5000853538513184,
0.4440694749355316,
0.820438027381897,
0.3376416265964508,
-0.11689414829015732,
0.3563152551651001,
0.01659936085343361,
0.05735442414879799,
-0.699116051197052,
0.030015617609024048,
0.6588979959487915,
0.6421487927436829,
0.5832633972167969,
0.09753042459487915,
0.865398645401001,
0.23325280845165253,
-0.18992900848388672,
-0.6820250153541565,
0.31253886222839355,
-0.33389151096343994,
-0.5462402105331421,
-0.560571551322937,
-0.2029072791337967,
-0.6924837827682495,
0.22381331026554108,
-0.37596675753593445,
-0.6223102807998657,
0.11646131426095963,
0.2745197117328644,
-0.5725027322769165,
0.4034710228443146,
-0.5588105320930481,
0.4179663062095642,
0.09355823695659637,
-0.07167427241802216,
-0.26233696937561035,
-0.7934612035751343,
0.08828812837600708,
-0.3877536654472351,
0.3849470913410187,
0.03440296649932861,
0.46878162026405334,
0.7066249251365662,
-0.35380464792251587,
0.8019177317619324,
-0.43426990509033203,
-0.30072638392448425,
0.35333025455474854,
0.054365597665309906,
0.7733741402626038,
-0.564276933670044,
0.02789727970957756,
0.36881399154663086,
-0.01598498597741127,
-0.5882760286331177,
-0.43940579891204834,
0.5664059519767761,
-0.9180517196655273,
-0.6309959888458252,
-0.34895262122154236,
-0.11948034912347794,
-0.03521796688437462,
0.12669308483600616,
0.43590137362480164,
0.6965155601501465,
0.23924028873443604,
0.357062965631485,
0.6757042407989502,
-0.08419381827116013,
0.26810023188591003,
0.6150647401809692,
-0.06568868458271027,
-0.39994633197784424,
0.9103897213935852,
0.4078696072101593,
0.35529181361198425,
-0.016264518722891808,
0.3245265781879425,
-0.2704855799674988,
-0.6471706032752991,
-0.39669692516326904,
-0.0736927017569542,
-0.66888028383255,
-0.23250699043273926,
-0.6633687615394592,
-0.8895844221115112,
-0.6353368163108826,
0.10529525578022003,
-0.7635661959648132,
-0.03201267495751381,
-0.2530437111854553,
-0.03419514000415802,
0.08146778494119644,
0.7560068368911743,
-0.08344490826129913,
0.43789660930633545,
-0.7707555294036865,
0.32427409291267395,
0.3518749475479126,
0.13512971997261047,
0.3921806514263153,
-0.9187613725662231,
-0.23562079668045044,
0.10350801050662994,
-0.026102779433131218,
-0.8030256628990173,
0.15107044577598572,
0.25385940074920654,
1.1188256740570068,
0.4473707377910614,
0.26413068175315857,
0.9978105425834656,
-0.6336838006973267,
0.9524477124214172,
0.19738291203975677,
-1.2906657457351685,
0.7087022066116333,
-0.2255418300628662,
0.263548344373703,
0.06651972979307175,
0.1738235503435135,
0.1300133764743805,
-0.8182991147041321,
-0.8224091529846191,
-0.9092516303062439,
0.803180456161499,
0.30989331007003784,
0.2615453004837036,
0.3032410442829132,
-0.2139992117881775,
-0.24828281998634338,
0.09128200262784958,
-0.5726341009140015,
-0.5238845944404602,
-0.7773791551589966,
-0.13419786095619202,
0.0034778593108057976,
-0.41862568259239197,
-0.2689058780670166,
-0.45735156536102295,
0.5149683356285095,
0.2622565031051636,
0.06519965827465057,
0.020137356594204903,
-0.2115817368030548,
-0.3466511070728302,
0.13552112877368927,
0.69510418176651,
0.35984060168266296,
-0.272271066904068,
0.4359486997127533,
0.5150852799415588,
-0.525599479675293,
-0.030729059129953384,
0.004698484670370817,
0.20187897980213165,
-0.006946605630218983,
0.5057277679443359,
0.7938405871391296,
0.45228415727615356,
-0.1211927980184555,
1.0344812870025635,
0.11816751956939697,
-0.26594725251197815,
-0.2547715902328491,
0.1315566599369049,
-0.09352420270442963,
0.44308218359947205,
0.9050524234771729,
0.23355324566364288,
0.01478313934057951,
-0.46975982189178467,
0.605601966381073,
0.5459905862808228,
-0.27799805998802185,
-0.24117837846279144,
0.5845125913619995,
-0.05821133404970169,
-0.26512661576271057,
0.39523783326148987,
0.08184558898210526,
-1.0579999685287476,
0.37629473209381104,
0.9402598738670349,
0.5736928582191467,
-0.933476984500885,
-0.16091173887252808,
-0.07758264243602753,
0.3122510313987732,
0.005393097642809153,
0.07933616638183594,
-0.39429542422294617,
-0.6351698040962219,
-0.19644781947135925,
-0.5504856109619141,
-0.13007913529872894,
0.0766361877322197,
-0.9436772465705872,
0.2559792995452881,
-0.15401709079742432,
-0.14271023869514465,
0.16512194275856018,
-0.14090612530708313,
-0.4396813213825226,
0.24653363227844238,
0.2400694489479065,
0.712886393070221,
-0.9114636778831482,
1.3403987884521484,
0.514049768447876,
-0.1335453987121582,
-0.9325520396232605,
0.20574325323104858,
0.057910893112421036,
-0.816722571849823,
0.42696455121040344,
0.010342398658394814,
-0.6545950770378113,
0.13535171747207642,
-0.3127712607383728,
-0.7989642024040222,
0.8035140037536621,
0.21334706246852875,
-0.4802153706550598,
0.1428251415491104,
0.01114836148917675,
0.3472384512424469,
-0.22408446669578552,
-0.0023634948302060366,
0.31531262397766113,
0.11736903339624405,
0.10500873625278473,
-1.1071220636367798,
0.006626077461987734,
-0.23633284866809845,
-0.3282976448535919,
-0.10483936965465546,
-0.5192850232124329,
0.7756102085113525,
0.018943320959806442,
-0.2542705237865448,
-0.25123095512390137,
0.5910198092460632,
0.3084704279899597,
0.4608256220817566,
0.8635960221290588,
0.32080692052841187,
0.8749948143959045,
0.3233996033668518,
0.54661625623703,
-0.2960744798183441,
0.3154662251472473,
1.2682188749313354,
-0.1200886145234108,
1.276008129119873,
0.4005999267101288,
-0.19799572229385376,
0.3764194846153259,
0.23157960176467896,
-0.06764306128025055,
0.8420198559761047,
0.09861521422863007,
-0.2998640537261963,
-0.23511049151420593,
0.3465435206890106,
-0.6618598699569702,
0.686225414276123,
0.33241787552833557,
-0.11111664772033691,
-0.013984819874167442,
0.4781653583049774,
-0.20702219009399414,
-0.1845833957195282,
-0.24763542413711548,
0.9171675443649292,
-0.16693657636642456,
-0.18069949746131897,
0.5343130230903625,
-0.3327227830886841,
1.1152504682540894,
-0.6291592717170715,
0.31995689868927,
0.027475440874695778,
0.13429699838161469,
-0.5424847602844238,
-0.5298484563827515,
0.3107258379459381,
-0.13923677802085876,
-0.31842494010925293,
-0.04644777998328209,
0.8705741167068481,
-0.6169212460517883,
-0.2444373220205307,
0.7111237049102783,
0.25944003462791443,
0.2345685362815857,
-0.33826908469200134,
-0.5718778371810913,
0.35851433873176575,
0.09421559423208237,
-0.10770101100206375,
0.2831079661846161,
0.3243058919906616,
0.0852421447634697,
0.46657732129096985,
0.9180848598480225,
0.3240624964237213,
0.544059157371521,
0.2842269837856293,
0.8046202659606934,
-0.3949142396450043,
-0.9494855403900146,
-0.8906009197235107,
0.4973927438259125,
-0.23157969117164612,
0.33870530128479004,
1.1136127710342407,
0.47590699791908264,
0.658683717250824,
0.004267668351531029,
0.6644170880317688,
0.4784877598285675,
0.5950789451599121,
-0.06208300590515137,
1.1630691289901733,
-0.7956505417823792,
0.2216147482395172,
-0.35556867718696594,
-0.5447447896003723,
-0.19400081038475037,
0.6180830001831055,
0.16115082800388336,
-0.27530616521835327,
0.2691456377506256,
0.8446808457374573,
-0.5012319684028625,
0.08749623596668243,
0.7164135575294495,
-0.03550781309604645,
0.33387890458106995,
-0.022151939570903778,
0.9544897675514221,
-0.6459358930587769,
0.5025157332420349,
-0.31214791536331177,
-0.36119377613067627,
-0.4378678500652313,
-0.7500722408294678,
-0.7772690653800964,
-0.6826335787773132,
-0.45535025000572205,
-0.5065797567367554,
-0.012674374505877495,
0.882030725479126,
1.0156620740890503,
-0.9293469190597534,
0.14694128930568695,
0.2888815402984619,
-0.1638021469116211,
-0.12166999280452728,
-0.17313338816165924,
0.5497193932533264,
-0.02411024644970894,
-0.38294070959091187,
0.8306528329849243,
0.13494931161403656,
0.4830925464630127,
-0.2305329442024231,
0.11391636729240417,
-0.036283399909734726,
0.5572664141654968,
0.5418590307235718,
0.01036266703158617,
-0.9932510852813721,
-0.3672146201133728,
-0.3288273513317108,
-0.14408864080905914,
-0.03536631539463997,
0.5936917662620544,
-0.6203389167785645,
0.4378669261932373,
0.15360091626644135,
0.3578171730041504,
0.47058892250061035,
0.15352846682071686,
0.12373145669698715,
-1.052315354347229,
0.3347777724266052,
-0.09019757807254791,
0.1402314454317093,
0.20986425876617432,
-0.39898452162742615,
-0.23071357607841492,
0.03205638378858566,
-0.3508526384830475,
-1.3406990766525269,
-0.0566820353269577,
-0.8890809416770935,
-0.3333684802055359,
0.7677717208862305,
-0.2028132975101471,
-0.2380724847316742,
-0.22600239515304565,
-0.001478655613027513,
0.6418462991714478,
-0.358808308839798,
0.6388780474662781,
0.37929216027259827,
-0.03349527344107628,
-0.06929142028093338,
-0.24510440230369568,
0.706154465675354,
0.39899662137031555,
-0.3803544044494629,
0.05760212242603302,
-0.10822272300720215,
0.4168565571308136,
0.6061956882476807,
0.42339619994163513,
-0.0031120688654482365,
0.2998288869857788,
0.36460137367248535,
-0.33989080786705017,
-0.3156542479991913,
-0.5033500790596008,
-0.5362461805343628,
0.3714653253555298,
-0.24394682049751282,
-0.6473010182380676
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.07990v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.07990v1
|
Blowfish: Topological and statistical signatures for quantifying ambiguity in semantic search
| 2024-06-12T08:26:30 | 2024-06-12T08:26:30 |
Thomas Roland Barillot, Alex De Castro
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
This works reports evidence for the topological signatures of ambiguity in
sentence embeddings that could be leveraged for ranking and/or explanation
purposes in the context of vector search and Retrieval Augmented Generation
(RAG) systems. We proposed a working definition of ambiguity and designed an
experiment where we have broken down a proprietary dataset into collections of
chunks of varying size - 3, 5, and 10 lines and used the different collections
successively as queries and answers sets. It allowed us to test the signatures
of ambiguity with removal of confounding factors. Our results show that proxy
ambiguous queries (size 10 queries against size 3 documents) display different
distributions of homologies 0 and 1 based features than proxy clear queries
(size 5 queries against size 10 documents). We then discuss those results in
terms increased manifold complexity and/or approximately discontinuous
embedding submanifolds. Finally we propose a strategy to leverage those
findings as a new scoring strategy of semantic similarities.
|
[
-0.3886343240737915,
-0.9389065504074097,
0.7462666034698486,
0.0882495790719986,
-0.46265530586242676,
0.08487682044506073,
0.1386738419532776,
-0.5459422469139099,
0.6695516109466553,
0.25192514061927795,
-0.618377149105072,
-0.24194857478141785,
-1.0465868711471558,
0.46247631311416626,
-0.6052141785621643,
0.6755569577217102,
0.044648367911577225,
-0.025575419887900352,
-0.38199594616889954,
-0.24358631670475006,
-0.3939642608165741,
-0.007882672362029552,
-0.3146287798881531,
0.08643919229507446,
0.7980461716651917,
0.10170655697584152,
1.1260477304458618,
0.872244656085968,
0.8031222820281982,
0.3503475785255432,
-0.36667534708976746,
0.44935715198516846,
-0.543267548084259,
0.5592696666717529,
-0.36987990140914917,
-0.48466914892196655,
-0.1657564789056778,
-0.05205996707081795,
0.5347235798835754,
1.066738247871399,
0.17797039449214935,
0.3212750256061554,
-0.2240762859582901,
0.4532601833343506,
-0.863201916217804,
0.03333623707294464,
-0.8148486018180847,
0.12524567544460297,
-0.7597187161445618,
-0.5024576187133789,
-0.12908689677715302,
-0.06325781345367432,
0.2801781892776489,
-0.9797229170799255,
0.18415266275405884,
0.32490065693855286,
0.9547505974769592,
0.7339958548545837,
-0.8677253723144531,
-0.866593599319458,
-0.5179224014282227,
0.6255975365638733,
-0.5509793162345886,
0.5710951685905457,
0.2129543423652649,
0.11620263755321503,
-0.6614862084388733,
-0.7764649391174316,
-0.7520022392272949,
0.34409600496292114,
-0.2705678343772888,
0.13988621532917023,
-0.2038591057062149,
-0.08121169358491898,
0.23315012454986572,
0.33651119470596313,
-0.7903095483779907,
-0.035245779901742935,
-0.6291313171386719,
-0.29904523491859436,
0.6457556486129761,
0.2089717984199524,
0.35240083932876587,
-0.28578516840934753,
-0.46519941091537476,
-0.2298494577407837,
-0.6400313973426819,
0.08907847851514816,
0.7703444361686707,
0.26820799708366394,
0.09002447128295898,
0.9433445334434509,
-0.11849869787693024,
0.8592144250869751,
-0.24927476048469543,
0.32714056968688965,
0.20838914811611176,
0.08271761238574982,
0.05481216683983803,
0.08538464456796646,
0.5111002922058105,
0.22166301310062408,
-0.2204560935497284,
-0.024867594242095947,
-0.12899209558963776,
0.10214165598154068,
0.5371527671813965,
-0.16835515201091766,
0.030985821038484573,
0.4788590669631958,
-0.43845027685165405,
-0.30721887946128845,
0.36661896109580994,
-0.8744263648986816,
-0.5222108364105225,
-0.21521931886672974,
0.670709490776062,
-0.36838051676750183,
-0.08145857602357864,
0.35358330607414246,
-0.769135057926178,
0.5823568105697632,
-0.03644706681370735,
-0.5510716438293457,
0.5681898593902588,
1.0979245901107788,
0.7516087889671326,
0.03366731107234955,
-0.2925024628639221,
-0.5724318623542786,
0.1809670478105545,
-0.40154168009757996,
0.8517097234725952,
-1.0268348455429077,
-0.4257047772407532,
0.09458323568105698,
-0.21810664236545563,
0.13679173588752747,
-0.44833284616470337,
0.8002278804779053,
-0.5389885902404785,
0.39367786049842834,
-0.43579962849617004,
-1.1312134265899658,
-0.27535492181777954,
0.0831725001335144,
-0.6729671955108643,
1.2227667570114136,
0.2891947329044342,
-0.8976374268531799,
0.580564022064209,
-0.6005900502204895,
-0.24459969997406006,
0.4208524227142334,
-0.40308114886283875,
-0.24268966913223267,
0.30132994055747986,
0.005992995575070381,
0.2722916305065155,
-0.22333356738090515,
-0.10940874367952347,
-0.41978779435157776,
-0.7760846018791199,
0.4125232398509979,
0.32549870014190674,
0.7348471283912659,
0.17529962956905365,
-0.5323014855384827,
0.023547908291220665,
-0.45128944516181946,
0.07770828157663345,
0.07042433321475983,
0.1645262986421585,
-0.7544430494308472,
0.10735651105642319,
-0.2585983872413635,
-0.11138710379600525,
0.27208787202835083,
-0.49080508947372437,
0.39517471194267273,
-0.44651439785957336,
0.15406149625778198,
0.5659754872322083,
0.21387529373168945,
0.11118442565202713,
-0.35444411635398865,
0.5855606198310852,
0.26731693744659424,
0.17811319231987,
0.04161757603287697,
-0.8940396904945374,
-0.5913695693016052,
-0.09167752414941788,
0.3746750056743622,
0.28698399662971497,
-0.813117504119873,
0.4485785663127899,
-0.5506102442741394,
-0.5552661418914795,
-0.7042229771614075,
-0.13173791766166687,
0.19302313029766083,
0.0969969853758812,
0.3667197525501251,
-0.27255141735076904,
-0.423653781414032,
-0.865893542766571,
-0.7824954986572266,
-0.06914268434047699,
-0.10144629329442978,
0.45297929644584656,
0.6612265110015869,
-0.29260948300361633,
1.032730221748352,
-0.8290348052978516,
-0.26824381947517395,
0.30620479583740234,
0.10526146739721298,
0.21864540874958038,
0.1356762796640396,
0.31604042649269104,
-1.3460609912872314,
-0.03543488308787346,
-0.20081382989883423,
-0.5123720765113831,
-0.016846396028995514,
0.10689526796340942,
-0.043512701988220215,
-0.05396270006895065,
0.590050220489502,
-0.601826548576355,
0.472336083650589,
0.5301136374473572,
-0.6043707728385925,
0.07478505373001099,
-0.2467261105775833,
0.061484143137931824,
-0.6650874018669128,
-0.1374744176864624,
-0.3172277510166168,
-0.005409479606896639,
-0.5894282460212708,
0.2782731056213379,
-0.030864572152495384,
0.1563001424074173,
-0.2611545920372009,
0.6685078144073486,
-0.35419315099716187,
-0.12001954019069672,
0.00882207602262497,
0.7340641021728516,
-0.2446935474872589,
0.14396578073501587,
-0.33491629362106323,
0.2789377272129059,
0.4703464210033417,
-0.8341495394706726,
0.40248075127601624,
0.33077433705329895,
0.0675053596496582,
0.5728254914283752,
-0.7753084897994995,
-0.10475748032331467,
-0.1494913101196289,
0.27178242802619934,
-1.1432663202285767,
-0.4488752484321594,
0.26523083448410034,
-0.5661755800247192,
0.0881015881896019,
0.003649540478363633,
-0.12115450203418732,
-0.41741639375686646,
-0.4349072277545929,
0.7754055261611938,
0.3538629710674286,
-0.3933868110179901,
0.4185478091239929,
0.5355350375175476,
0.23327888548374176,
-0.557799756526947,
-0.3386930525302887,
-0.13615626096725464,
-0.42866250872612,
-0.7779907584190369,
0.22377119958400726,
0.20480461418628693,
-0.22694775462150574,
0.18528582155704498,
-0.25096258521080017,
0.1100410744547844,
-0.016454046592116356,
0.4103628396987915,
0.17146635055541992,
0.010378967970609665,
0.346365749835968,
0.26363223791122437,
-0.053896259516477585,
-0.12621267139911652,
-0.6180079579353333,
0.41191592812538147,
0.0007863491773605347,
-0.37259089946746826,
0.40308234095573425,
0.16428983211517334,
0.32416263222694397,
-0.09567700326442719,
0.5584951043128967,
0.8933265805244446,
-0.39185139536857605,
-0.10388828814029694,
-0.33712896704673767,
-0.09873886406421661,
-0.5271066427230835,
-0.22845642268657684,
-0.5953948497772217,
-1.1661415100097656,
0.8545219302177429,
-0.3409736752510071,
-0.32963326573371887,
0.8530181050300598,
0.24485541880130768,
-0.1757436990737915,
0.5620241165161133,
0.22814643383026123,
0.6169878840446472,
-0.11483301222324371,
-0.08785980939865112,
0.5409935712814331,
-0.91661536693573,
-0.2840767502784729,
-0.6662194728851318,
-0.573540449142456,
-1.4622067213058472,
-0.6230037212371826,
0.6529489159584045,
-0.11455820500850677,
0.01923746056854725,
0.3383170962333679,
-0.7330702543258667,
0.44249194860458374,
0.37080153822898865,
-0.035352371633052826,
-0.0721343532204628,
-0.35647067427635193,
-0.19356787204742432,
-0.13020777702331543,
-0.5340597033500671,
-0.227066308259964,
0.9934681057929993,
0.10276764631271362,
0.3305739760398865,
0.6003890037536621,
0.6833827495574951,
0.4326515793800354,
-0.5339662432670593,
-0.5222108364105225,
0.3848971128463745,
-0.24473391473293304,
-0.7914438843727112,
-0.646618664264679,
-0.5892109274864197,
-1.3793294429779053,
0.47197070717811584,
-0.3593931794166565,
-0.758984386920929,
0.44143345952033997,
-0.28132104873657227,
0.16374634206295013,
0.16175295412540436,
-0.341137558221817,
0.7198991179466248,
0.1276182234287262,
-0.1928681582212448,
0.11015758663415909,
-0.8351663947105408,
0.2564132511615753,
0.052529044449329376,
0.38078761100769043,
-0.16978228092193604,
-0.6403428316116333,
0.637942910194397,
-0.28207674622535706,
0.4807063639163971,
0.0461304746568203,
-0.2937317192554474,
0.1016692966222763,
0.3944587707519531,
0.5264227986335754,
-0.14460784196853638,
-0.07946449518203735,
0.25137442350387573,
0.40645065903663635,
-0.6839000582695007,
-0.7512261271476746,
0.470134973526001,
-0.40686410665512085,
-0.5727338194847107,
-0.5314801335334778,
-0.4762730300426483,
-0.17970727384090424,
0.43934008479118347,
0.4898902475833893,
0.5366510152816772,
0.08614248782396317,
0.20507220923900604,
0.6762233972549438,
-0.15936581790447235,
0.08792508393526077,
0.1476099193096161,
-0.24234344065189362,
0.038208264857530594,
0.9115118384361267,
-0.020398415625095367,
-0.11229854077100754,
0.5121940970420837,
0.24404563009738922,
-0.36661505699157715,
-0.2907114326953888,
-0.2251110076904297,
0.2944336235523224,
-0.5330453515052795,
-0.153206467628479,
-0.551990807056427,
0.056982483714818954,
-0.5605401992797852,
-0.14838668704032898,
-0.09085771441459656,
-0.5430590510368347,
0.10657861828804016,
0.13765409588813782,
0.46345922350883484,
1.2331706285476685,
-0.037775155156850815,
0.1577414572238922,
-0.5824028253555298,
0.23347371816635132,
-0.06088345870375633,
0.4977474808692932,
-0.38883596658706665,
-0.3976951241493225,
0.01522282138466835,
0.04468487948179245,
-0.037611838430166245,
-1.2552857398986816,
0.10498727858066559,
0.030835820361971855,
0.5124391317367554,
0.2611598074436188,
0.15320232510566711,
0.6211161017417908,
-0.21707889437675476,
1.0622566938400269,
-0.3339211940765381,
-1.1650073528289795,
0.5269121527671814,
-0.768968939781189,
0.2279532551765442,
0.18002842366695404,
0.8541537523269653,
-0.6669685244560242,
-0.7857453227043152,
-0.9935349225997925,
-0.9776296019554138,
0.2934820055961609,
0.3597835600376129,
0.05513694882392883,
-0.010108424350619316,
0.6435503959655762,
0.09836148470640182,
0.09744447469711304,
-0.15453094244003296,
-0.5230588316917419,
0.10930589586496353,
-0.09351658821105957,
0.13725192844867706,
-0.30684247612953186,
-0.22027504444122314,
-0.20634028315544128,
0.47130927443504333,
-0.13383124768733978,
0.15221968293190002,
0.3953840136528015,
0.07158499211072922,
0.12210626155138016,
0.10581642389297485,
0.8981924653053284,
0.7197457551956177,
-0.07092513889074326,
0.5255945920944214,
0.2579858601093292,
-0.6741932034492493,
0.006360135041177273,
-0.1789940446615219,
0.08313357084989548,
0.25769397616386414,
0.6913264989852905,
0.39968377351760864,
0.44991493225097656,
-0.5315662622451782,
0.4725951850414276,
0.08789282292127609,
-0.12991221249103546,
-0.11061259359121323,
0.07571563124656677,
-0.14919061958789825,
0.12209378182888031,
0.2775561809539795,
-0.332894504070282,
0.7157425880432129,
-0.4772339165210724,
0.16298869252204895,
0.47012707591056824,
-0.552544891834259,
0.13851307332515717,
0.3196943700313568,
-0.14427106082439423,
-0.18236719071865082,
0.5304325819015503,
-0.5796070694923401,
-0.738509476184845,
0.34627842903137207,
0.06490471959114075,
0.5455847382545471,
-0.16308453679084778,
0.2985858619213104,
0.0828021839261055,
0.43182867765426636,
0.44167423248291016,
0.39060866832733154,
-0.03821771591901779,
-0.4871346056461334,
0.03529340773820877,
-0.5751559734344482,
-0.595003068447113,
-0.37114217877388,
-0.8536689281463623,
0.36355865001678467,
0.13789543509483337,
-0.015552641823887825,
0.2924099266529083,
0.09777221083641052,
-0.3663218021392822,
0.12724900245666504,
-0.29965469241142273,
0.6074662208557129,
-0.7441017031669617,
0.19992443919181824,
0.7765129208564758,
-0.3983590304851532,
-0.7986447215080261,
0.04404236748814583,
0.49080464243888855,
-0.4883511960506439,
0.6275634765625,
-0.2409685105085373,
-0.22223900258541107,
-0.3563162088394165,
-0.3538244068622589,
-1.0621347427368164,
1.062286615371704,
0.11343859881162643,
-0.06584417819976807,
0.056621961295604706,
0.45720744132995605,
0.6621708273887634,
-0.258714884519577,
0.38048145174980164,
0.5624457001686096,
0.7350677847862244,
0.35169994831085205,
-0.7747833728790283,
0.2624373733997345,
-0.1781546026468277,
0.20203951001167297,
0.6050626039505005,
-0.3881700336933136,
0.8548800349235535,
0.18327011168003082,
-0.3323633372783661,
-0.06956080347299576,
0.5049502849578857,
0.041178055107593536,
0.3983692228794098,
0.4991021454334259,
0.560874879360199,
1.1837118864059448,
-0.5056426525115967,
1.141573190689087,
-0.042381495237350464,
0.546916127204895,
0.9402675628662109,
-0.17802537977695465,
0.8791950345039368,
0.6306846737861633,
-0.1843859851360321,
0.5979793667793274,
0.8145573735237122,
-0.05399308353662491,
0.07054594904184341,
0.611599326133728,
-0.013969916850328445,
-0.06555388122797012,
-0.11664759367704391,
-0.3982278108596802,
0.8409427404403687,
0.6386666893959045,
0.032891955226659775,
-0.20712830126285553,
-0.24567300081253052,
-0.1770092248916626,
0.10109428316354752,
0.26360461115837097,
0.7485888600349426,
-0.012491215020418167,
-0.42240890860557556,
0.20279045403003693,
-0.25596433877944946,
0.5574021935462952,
-0.44257083535194397,
-0.08154557645320892,
-0.11299354583024979,
-0.023542752489447594,
-0.4652271270751953,
-1.03708016872406,
0.4519089162349701,
-0.5116848349571228,
-0.00834963470697403,
-0.03218197450041771,
0.6678536534309387,
-0.37279894948005676,
-0.37704530358314514,
0.27441704273223877,
0.40794384479522705,
0.5925240516662598,
0.2254069447517395,
-0.4208805561065674,
0.5126410722732544,
-0.3458459973335266,
-0.04202884063124657,
-0.25363612174987793,
0.8821537494659424,
0.03860146179795265,
0.587227463722229,
0.5644057393074036,
0.29906943440437317,
0.44705045223236084,
-0.23072679340839386,
0.6697435975074768,
-0.5447515249252319,
-0.3714744746685028,
-0.5139862895011902,
0.2838877737522125,
-0.11422396451234818,
-0.5835398435592651,
0.8283684849739075,
0.5520543456077576,
1.037796974182129,
-0.01548079214990139,
0.0633619949221611,
-0.17660103738307953,
0.44593074917793274,
-0.5618604421615601,
0.4852207899093628,
-0.8706346154212952,
0.280242383480072,
-0.4467843472957611,
-1.059293270111084,
-0.38245928287506104,
0.35269489884376526,
-0.2610335052013397,
0.14947742223739624,
0.823223888874054,
0.6984761357307434,
-0.2172735184431076,
0.2664821743965149,
0.29430243372917175,
0.18363171815872192,
0.27757391333580017,
0.12081753462553024,
0.7224547266960144,
-0.7391421794891357,
0.1514771729707718,
-0.062030334025621414,
0.021582666784524918,
-0.3410342037677765,
-0.7266576290130615,
-0.41171857714653015,
-1.2795957326889038,
-0.38957464694976807,
-0.22908589243888855,
-0.05734507367014885,
0.4149363040924072,
0.37177184224128723,
-0.28534993529319763,
-0.1060759425163269,
0.14472541213035583,
0.5129343271255493,
-0.13019652664661407,
-0.29965266585350037,
0.34843042492866516,
-0.4857257306575775,
-0.5523114800453186,
0.12162218242883682,
0.4860939681529999,
-0.08243437856435776,
-0.25571075081825256,
0.059826236218214035,
-0.5233342051506042,
0.42328697443008423,
0.3128780126571655,
0.16382014751434326,
-0.8206847310066223,
-0.5055064558982849,
0.10746742784976959,
0.05047416687011719,
-0.5440351366996765,
0.9904541373252869,
-0.5294831991195679,
0.4845485985279083,
0.5536326169967651,
0.4978845417499542,
0.5263294577598572,
-0.251904159784317,
0.44910162687301636,
-0.8175416588783264,
0.22949212789535522,
0.06914491951465607,
0.24430209398269653,
0.04068164527416229,
-0.6407635807991028,
0.9037621021270752,
0.06596695631742477,
-0.4954439699649811,
-0.9588855504989624,
0.3163881301879883,
-1.2452863454818726,
-0.35772594809532166,
0.8931757807731628,
0.1895425170660019,
-0.2736334204673767,
-0.1553320586681366,
0.1082037016749382,
0.11394064873456955,
0.16760390996932983,
0.6791481971740723,
0.7462154030799866,
-0.29741302132606506,
0.3103853762149811,
-0.3600098192691803,
0.7096965909004211,
0.4336819052696228,
-0.6127699613571167,
-0.3295362889766693,
0.3153049349784851,
-0.05615679547190666,
0.6330146193504333,
0.08166738599538803,
-0.22050315141677856,
0.2808734178543091,
0.2514438331127167,
-0.44257673621177673,
0.23199471831321716,
-0.12860393524169922,
-0.2741786539554596,
0.08999834209680557,
-0.29617011547088623,
0.06308795511722565
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.07971v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.07971v2
|
It Takes Two: On the Seamlessness between Reward and Policy Model in RLHF
| 2024-06-12T07:52:17 | 2024-06-13T05:13:50 |
Taiming Lu, Lingfeng Shen, Xinyu Yang, Weiting Tan, Beidi Chen, Huaxiu Yao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Reinforcement Learning from Human Feedback (RLHF) involves training policy
models (PMs) and reward models (RMs) to align language models with human
preferences. Instead of focusing solely on PMs and RMs independently, we
propose to examine their interactions during fine-tuning, introducing the
concept of seamlessness. Our study starts with observing the saturation
phenomenon, where continual improvements in RM and PM do not translate into
RLHF progress. Our analysis shows that RMs fail to assign proper scores to PM
responses, resulting in a 35% mismatch rate with human preferences,
highlighting a significant discrepancy between PM and RM. To measure
seamlessness between PM and RM without human effort, we propose an automatic
metric, SEAM. SEAM quantifies the discrepancies between PM and RM judgments
induced by data samples. We validate the effectiveness of SEAM in data
selection and model augmentation. Our experiments demonstrate that (1) using
SEAM-filtered data for RL training improves RLHF performance by 4.5%, and (2)
SEAM-guided model augmentation results in a 4% performance improvement over
standard augmentation methods.
|
[
-0.4824109375476837,
-0.7945187091827393,
0.5262448787689209,
0.17799466848373413,
-0.07933111488819122,
0.3686199486255646,
-0.15263570845127106,
-0.49766242504119873,
0.22031834721565247,
0.4537794291973114,
-0.9564110040664673,
-0.24006694555282593,
-0.4622190594673157,
-0.20395492017269135,
0.06209757924079895,
1.2610554695129395,
-0.1389612853527069,
-0.08407717198133469,
-0.5572100877761841,
-0.15845812857151031,
-0.6824489235877991,
-0.2017901986837387,
-0.3416453003883362,
-1.0515010356903076,
0.6536270380020142,
0.5721078515052795,
1.0590711832046509,
0.9726831912994385,
0.32992562651634216,
0.32731667160987854,
0.03303353115916252,
0.3060600757598877,
-0.5221023559570312,
0.054843880236148834,
-0.3131866455078125,
-0.5187863707542419,
-0.26448357105255127,
0.1873513162136078,
0.5552896857261658,
0.7508854269981384,
-0.33034589886665344,
0.03787383809685707,
0.3920259475708008,
1.1045955419540405,
-0.7862777709960938,
0.4240150451660156,
-0.06716075539588928,
0.48114755749702454,
0.06750744581222534,
-0.31047892570495605,
-0.04684211686253548,
-0.618190586566925,
0.3358929455280304,
-0.5722352862358093,
0.10736121237277985,
0.1140935942530632,
1.0107537508010864,
0.568804919719696,
-0.1456686407327652,
0.019562361761927605,
-0.6641062498092651,
0.7946431636810303,
-0.5712699294090271,
0.5678431987762451,
0.6703901290893555,
-0.008539180271327496,
-0.26429229974746704,
-0.23989109694957733,
-0.43723607063293457,
-0.5212945342063904,
-0.16137927770614624,
0.20022878050804138,
0.3665408790111542,
0.3209682106971741,
0.0064174155704677105,
0.6080623269081116,
-0.6688681244850159,
0.2863868772983551,
-0.06489719450473785,
-0.32592636346817017,
0.7377094626426697,
0.4887809455394745,
0.09789563715457916,
-0.31716591119766235,
-0.38001328706741333,
-0.5074582099914551,
-0.32250627875328064,
0.6636332273483276,
0.4530547261238098,
0.2968144714832306,
-0.46455496549606323,
0.5897542238235474,
-0.4033326208591461,
0.6892268061637878,
-0.20367223024368286,
-0.21391667425632477,
0.07221679389476776,
-0.07392807304859161,
-0.3815923035144806,
-0.32007452845573425,
0.5762339234352112,
0.1296219378709793,
-0.034229010343551636,
-0.22723957896232605,
-0.49866577982902527,
0.04935362562537193,
0.4088834226131439,
-0.29759693145751953,
-0.3373687267303467,
0.3048425614833832,
-0.2500343322753906,
-0.48209238052368164,
0.33983415365219116,
-0.5833909511566162,
-0.4353199005126953,
-0.7425007820129395,
0.44216641783714294,
-0.17067581415176392,
-0.28257614374160767,
0.16529704630374908,
-0.24037691950798035,
0.2291404753923416,
0.20439159870147705,
-0.5531711578369141,
0.22297419607639313,
0.9909924864768982,
0.6979109048843384,
-0.4067397117614746,
-0.8688817024230957,
-0.43569448590278625,
-0.3632958233356476,
-0.5092090964317322,
0.8122745156288147,
-0.328509122133255,
-0.3757832646369934,
0.2628117501735687,
0.14245820045471191,
-0.06244942918419838,
-0.5223197340965271,
0.47247055172920227,
-0.42979857325553894,
0.48111477494239807,
-0.42024239897727966,
-0.4953889548778534,
-0.2564069330692291,
0.34237679839134216,
-0.6390684843063354,
1.117266058921814,
0.33872976899147034,
-0.6590949892997742,
0.7657357454299927,
-0.5124022364616394,
-0.2457338571548462,
0.05152059346437454,
0.04676206037402153,
-0.7830114960670471,
0.007921501062810421,
-0.06114921718835831,
0.17514987289905548,
-0.10796074569225311,
0.36711829900741577,
-0.6008579134941101,
-0.6260050535202026,
0.5576136708259583,
-0.4904360771179199,
0.3038316071033478,
0.06125315651297569,
-0.4530802071094513,
0.24853673577308655,
-0.5519020557403564,
0.20439550280570984,
-0.013808069750666618,
-0.9146242737770081,
-0.2292647361755371,
0.11348582804203033,
0.11787941306829453,
0.07209432870149612,
0.2256162166595459,
-0.39941754937171936,
0.11086086928844452,
-0.5997653007507324,
0.1601899415254593,
0.9391600489616394,
-0.14804041385650635,
0.5293473601341248,
-0.7025821805000305,
0.5581668615341187,
-0.05550869554281235,
0.2879413366317749,
-0.051832836121320724,
-0.01224990002810955,
-1.193759799003601,
-0.10626459121704102,
0.4642186164855957,
0.45253297686576843,
-0.6958805918693542,
0.5951462984085083,
-0.13555894792079926,
-0.18415392935276031,
-0.6096283197402954,
-0.017005935311317444,
0.7137040495872498,
0.2986932694911957,
0.2867862284183502,
-0.83271723985672,
-0.309748113155365,
-0.7715514302253723,
-0.6140101552009583,
-0.22081051766872406,
0.10850656032562256,
0.5144917368888855,
0.3241514265537262,
-0.027670864015817642,
1.0614817142486572,
-0.21910814940929413,
-0.12713317573070526,
-0.046051062643527985,
0.45045313239097595,
-0.009015526622533798,
0.5444604158401489,
-0.09744687378406525,
-0.5997287034988403,
-0.21248608827590942,
-0.05720124393701553,
-0.78011554479599,
0.07562601566314697,
-0.09209784120321274,
0.09176941215991974,
0.571740448474884,
0.013849458657205105,
-0.2867259383201599,
0.6158707141876221,
0.515693187713623,
-0.5935877561569214,
0.5637730956077576,
-0.5115967392921448,
0.45005255937576294,
-0.32924884557724,
-0.07188336551189423,
0.04503924772143364,
-0.5457693338394165,
-0.302556574344635,
0.19883273541927338,
0.13662782311439514,
-0.02022416889667511,
-0.36912840604782104,
0.41352352499961853,
-0.22489330172538757,
-0.3554912209510803,
-0.4780278205871582,
-0.11456499993801117,
0.10697365552186966,
0.7989997267723083,
-0.01728374883532524,
0.6199950575828552,
0.3052293360233307,
-0.8031532168388367,
0.3386886715888977,
0.04273911565542221,
-0.33772167563438416,
0.5636956095695496,
-0.7418288588523865,
0.10648836940526962,
-0.2990769147872925,
0.25891104340553284,
-0.8947863578796387,
-0.619827926158905,
0.2789718210697174,
-0.21363919973373413,
0.24391134083271027,
-0.11460999399423599,
-0.17226698994636536,
-0.3936922550201416,
-0.3613976538181305,
0.32847777009010315,
0.37115153670310974,
-0.4363120198249817,
0.3675258159637451,
0.43202486634254456,
0.048657745122909546,
-0.6949339509010315,
-0.7577598690986633,
-0.21604080498218536,
-0.1811533272266388,
-0.27362242341041565,
0.27503764629364014,
0.0335797555744648,
0.067404605448246,
0.1987244337797165,
-0.30264559388160706,
0.011204910464584827,
0.07660668343305588,
0.5819746851921082,
0.532913088798523,
-0.04552570730447769,
-0.09580541402101517,
-0.09392526745796204,
-0.13273102045059204,
0.06517341732978821,
-0.43426334857940674,
0.6187430024147034,
-0.13323502242565155,
-0.5465449690818787,
-0.8403715491294861,
-0.15783990919589996,
0.5280349254608154,
-0.21559768915176392,
0.5838780999183655,
0.5960738062858582,
0.14109006524085999,
-0.15919001400470734,
-0.6350674629211426,
-0.20901109278202057,
-0.45610693097114563,
0.2861999571323395,
-0.2749057114124298,
-1.0042433738708496,
0.15856775641441345,
0.13382379710674286,
0.05743924528360367,
0.08358579128980637,
0.27495914697647095,
0.013962555676698685,
0.9363478422164917,
0.9719179272651672,
-0.25408703088760376,
0.605415940284729,
-0.17105624079704285,
-0.11076436936855316,
-0.5454846024513245,
-0.6505671143531799,
-0.4377948045730591,
-0.25843551754951477,
-0.6956343054771423,
-0.31336790323257446,
0.4534575939178467,
0.15351887047290802,
-0.5689205527305603,
0.21826140582561493,
-0.3388955295085907,
0.6143540143966675,
0.6090149879455566,
0.5188109278678894,
0.058239053934812546,
-0.1260444074869156,
-0.0035784931387752295,
-0.11842674762010574,
-0.831487774848938,
0.028081905096769333,
0.6593489050865173,
0.6606011986732483,
0.9183263778686523,
-0.1572834849357605,
0.6252462863922119,
0.5831208825111389,
-0.23345965147018433,
-0.8410395383834839,
0.1546008586883545,
0.17666776478290558,
0.02660200744867325,
-0.6346277594566345,
-0.5700797438621521,
-0.7476531267166138,
0.0891573503613472,
-0.43623924255371094,
-0.3802284002304077,
0.2738383710384369,
0.40683862566947937,
-0.45737630128860474,
0.021654805168509483,
-0.30173027515411377,
0.8624417185783386,
-0.1921873539686203,
-0.7124953866004944,
-0.5159251093864441,
-0.5964794158935547,
0.46918365359306335,
0.30255547165870667,
0.2146688550710678,
-0.19787684082984924,
0.19596366584300995,
0.650095522403717,
-0.37678107619285583,
0.7297453880310059,
-0.23378784954547882,
-0.07328686863183975,
0.08518499881029129,
0.46099475026130676,
0.6992534399032593,
0.14946968853473663,
0.23669874668121338,
0.10112139582633972,
-0.06172701716423035,
-0.6314787864685059,
-0.5434417128562927,
0.6075013875961304,
-0.9853112697601318,
-0.2889820337295532,
-0.5555269718170166,
-0.9113913774490356,
-0.3487968146800995,
0.0020980816334486008,
-0.10750845074653625,
0.2209504395723343,
-0.20973165333271027,
-0.09565023332834244,
0.8614368438720703,
-0.47735175490379333,
0.40830838680267334,
0.592086672782898,
-0.2281479686498642,
-0.4397088289260864,
0.9113718271255493,
-0.24020305275917053,
0.3003943860530853,
0.2887101471424103,
0.310492604970932,
-0.6064205169677734,
0.16544196009635925,
-0.40276437997817993,
0.27061915397644043,
-0.43032845854759216,
-0.11744572222232819,
-0.3657045066356659,
-0.2493991255760193,
-0.35242316126823425,
0.007657507434487343,
-0.6640481352806091,
-0.25732600688934326,
-0.06514082103967667,
0.13841664791107178,
0.10741360485553741,
1.0788418054580688,
-0.32835546135902405,
0.0676536038517952,
-0.653645396232605,
0.09932752698659897,
0.4920172095298767,
0.5949935913085938,
0.01121028047055006,
-0.6990606784820557,
-0.4397937059402466,
0.2067803293466568,
-0.24936120212078094,
-0.3528575599193573,
0.3979160189628601,
0.0876084417104721,
0.28037911653518677,
0.3121775984764099,
-0.06054426729679108,
1.0272448062896729,
-0.28543588519096375,
0.8234328031539917,
0.17144522070884705,
-1.0698658227920532,
0.46660178899765015,
-0.14923644065856934,
0.3212891221046448,
0.36473897099494934,
0.32528743147850037,
-0.6642299294471741,
-0.3633107542991638,
-0.48240700364112854,
-0.7602093815803528,
1.0692654848098755,
-0.22734154760837555,
0.01657581515610218,
0.6202772259712219,
0.3043432831764221,
0.1280706375837326,
0.18592804670333862,
-0.711916446685791,
-0.21510310471057892,
-0.32945817708969116,
0.22396212816238403,
-0.12653036415576935,
-0.24502304196357727,
-0.2643238604068756,
-0.12092990428209305,
0.6663151979446411,
-0.050584323704242706,
0.0790475532412529,
0.16184839606285095,
0.027038482949137688,
-0.5896239280700684,
0.2806544601917267,
0.5370798110961914,
0.7282829284667969,
-0.1283571571111679,
-0.003884456120431423,
-0.08403901010751724,
-0.022109709680080414,
0.13286460936069489,
-0.10432654619216919,
0.0760166272521019,
-0.2504720985889435,
0.3334878981113434,
1.2108525037765503,
0.25187134742736816,
-0.6225634813308716,
0.48909497261047363,
0.01994304731488228,
-0.31345102190971375,
-0.12601280212402344,
0.4200280010700226,
-0.3012831211090088,
0.5273693203926086,
-0.08669159561395645,
0.1013995036482811,
-0.11331150680780411,
-0.5930855870246887,
0.44921186566352844,
0.47614625096321106,
-0.8931124806404114,
-0.11444688588380814,
0.5853559374809265,
-0.22479043900966644,
-0.511824369430542,
0.5924669504165649,
-0.09847034513950348,
-0.572796106338501,
0.4568595290184021,
0.2991922199726105,
0.6708145141601562,
-0.04031224921345711,
0.7504367828369141,
0.2823947072029114,
0.107323557138443,
-0.353539377450943,
0.07707831263542175,
-0.3481143116950989,
-0.5649067163467407,
-0.50588059425354,
-0.8334741592407227,
-0.5483181476593018,
0.08334191888570786,
-1.0282137393951416,
0.15219001471996307,
-0.3847464919090271,
0.1494738608598709,
-0.32691824436187744,
0.0447264239192009,
-0.7429447174072266,
0.23597832024097443,
0.0339246541261673,
0.5287548303604126,
-1.079141616821289,
0.6634531617164612,
0.5234770774841309,
-0.6408105492591858,
-1.105230450630188,
0.23143145442008972,
0.0665532648563385,
-0.9232751727104187,
0.42242732644081116,
-0.1608274132013321,
0.02471454255282879,
-0.26539888978004456,
-0.4119296669960022,
-0.810526430606842,
1.0622159242630005,
0.12398368120193481,
-0.38823312520980835,
-0.01714656874537468,
0.46883049607276917,
0.42583805322647095,
-0.05500461533665657,
0.2457142323255539,
0.9317880272865295,
0.4754205346107483,
-0.1620820015668869,
-1.1985421180725098,
-0.19132694602012634,
0.2586708068847656,
0.3038669526576996,
0.19197261333465576,
-0.6894479393959045,
0.9921520352363586,
-0.00442682858556509,
-0.07721325755119324,
0.06356974691152573,
0.5652707815170288,
0.5265440940856934,
0.4104771018028259,
0.6666876673698425,
0.8055844306945801,
0.5473551750183105,
-0.1729619950056076,
1.0832326412200928,
-0.06552711129188538,
0.731343150138855,
0.9122708439826965,
-0.08251770585775375,
0.5003456473350525,
0.4126007854938507,
-0.4160067141056061,
0.7025388479232788,
0.9464327692985535,
0.2495940625667572,
0.6814795732498169,
0.2192734032869339,
-0.039762645959854126,
-0.3356807231903076,
-0.22733688354492188,
-0.22285594046115875,
0.46950680017471313,
-0.05878499895334244,
0.12709321081638336,
-0.2043592631816864,
0.24595890939235687,
-0.12482914328575134,
0.20321370661258698,
-0.2913450300693512,
0.9530276656150818,
-0.01801765337586403,
-1.2368066310882568,
0.7390281558036804,
0.11031749844551086,
0.5704770684242249,
-0.4522404372692108,
-0.1436455249786377,
-0.5285776257514954,
0.12007948011159897,
-0.3749747574329376,
-0.8478409647941589,
0.18429692089557648,
-0.3124586045742035,
-0.14295238256454468,
-0.02483914978802204,
0.4884452521800995,
-0.6324611306190491,
-0.03672989830374718,
0.09556199610233307,
0.5058944821357727,
0.10820255428552628,
0.11627542227506638,
-0.942197322845459,
0.06486956030130386,
0.0813763216137886,
-0.18644477427005768,
0.44053465127944946,
0.3681831359863281,
0.25515297055244446,
0.7915340065956116,
0.6650792360305786,
0.3688698709011078,
-0.0800342932343483,
-0.05188767611980438,
0.7945169806480408,
-0.6945222020149231,
-0.8943386673927307,
-0.6931518316268921,
0.6599315404891968,
0.15342052280902863,
-0.2414853423833847,
0.4962102770805359,
0.39576688408851624,
1.0270222425460815,
-0.08518117666244507,
0.6819144487380981,
-0.10934006422758102,
0.5570608377456665,
-0.7240421772003174,
0.520142138004303,
-0.8358654379844666,
0.3125755190849304,
-0.24257169663906097,
-0.8647640943527222,
-0.03587088733911514,
0.5235783457756042,
-0.17509673535823822,
-0.15087251365184784,
0.6634340882301331,
0.9802910685539246,
-0.1490020900964737,
-0.014671744778752327,
0.34813129901885986,
-0.17135611176490784,
0.08094184845685959,
0.4603786766529083,
1.019789218902588,
-0.31690865755081177,
0.11577221006155014,
-0.44030746817588806,
-0.25132933259010315,
-0.11157733201980591,
-0.6268617510795593,
-0.650057315826416,
-0.4772535264492035,
-0.3083113729953766,
-0.7498422265052795,
0.4193447530269623,
1.1261069774627686,
0.8822202086448669,
-0.7556233406066895,
-0.5142288208007812,
-0.5547280311584473,
0.32266348600387573,
-0.3241809904575348,
-0.31859254837036133,
0.26656457781791687,
-0.8398887515068054,
-0.6414114236831665,
0.4696711599826813,
0.3227214515209198,
-0.0487016886472702,
-0.7215728163719177,
-0.5420812368392944,
0.18660181760787964,
-0.09226331859827042,
0.2735030949115753,
0.6227127909660339,
-0.7969462871551514,
-0.3922988474369049,
-0.3171246349811554,
-0.053278788924217224,
0.032135363668203354,
1.0168448686599731,
-0.9800800681114197,
0.2644723057746887,
0.48967134952545166,
0.8544856905937195,
0.37590673565864563,
0.13752733170986176,
0.4643575847148895,
-0.6962140202522278,
0.3222280740737915,
0.13742463290691376,
0.020315347239375114,
0.23211705684661865,
-0.3029845654964447,
0.3471834063529968,
0.361646831035614,
-1.142728328704834,
-0.9324029684066772,
0.3383226990699768,
-0.6630616188049316,
-0.302918016910553,
0.8930604457855225,
-0.26373279094696045,
-0.31105807423591614,
-0.1150800809264183,
0.16174869239330292,
0.24202024936676025,
-0.29895439743995667,
1.2004375457763672,
0.5403138995170593,
-0.3028516173362732,
-0.04466639831662178,
-0.4554021656513214,
0.8176596164703369,
0.7682477235794067,
-0.6636356711387634,
0.04238911345601082,
0.502217710018158,
0.3397495150566101,
-0.20778077840805054,
0.5802643895149231,
0.09887882322072983,
0.39551764726638794,
-0.10494668781757355,
0.03540591523051262,
-0.10509512573480606,
-0.6233196258544922,
-0.6944494843482971,
0.026976503431797028,
0.33135107159614563,
-0.155767560005188
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.07970v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.07970v1
|
Guiding In-Context Learning of LLMs through Quality Estimation for Machine Translation
| 2024-06-12T07:49:36 | 2024-06-12T07:49:36 |
Javad Pourmostafa Roshan Sharami, Dimitar Shterionov, Pieter Spronck
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The quality of output from large language models (LLMs), particularly in
machine translation (MT), is closely tied to the quality of in-context examples
(ICEs) provided along with the query, i.e., the text to translate. The
effectiveness of these ICEs is influenced by various factors, such as the
domain of the source text, the order in which the ICEs are presented, the
number of these examples, and the prompt templates used. Naturally, selecting
the most impactful ICEs depends on understanding how these affect the resulting
translation quality, which ultimately relies on translation references or human
judgment. This paper presents a novel methodology for in-context learning (ICL)
that relies on a search algorithm guided by domain-specific quality estimation
(QE). Leveraging the XGLM model, our methodology estimates the resulting
translation quality without the need for translation references, selecting
effective ICEs for MT to maximize translation quality. Our results demonstrate
significant improvements over existing ICL methods and higher translation
performance compared to fine-tuning a pre-trained language model (PLM),
specifically mBART-50.
|
[
-0.37270933389663696,
-0.3624365031719208,
0.6853456497192383,
-0.23070526123046875,
-0.6775694489479065,
0.1371491551399231,
-0.12593330442905426,
-0.17806896567344666,
-0.20942486822605133,
0.48529329895973206,
-0.5717778205871582,
-0.9376988410949707,
-0.7475578188896179,
0.11375275254249573,
-0.27584782242774963,
0.997827410697937,
-0.17272351682186127,
0.36559829115867615,
-0.376945823431015,
-0.20864221453666687,
-0.4335557818412781,
-0.5786671042442322,
-0.44367626309394836,
-0.4034382998943329,
0.19387920200824738,
0.5865106582641602,
0.5139793157577515,
0.6289554238319397,
0.378622442483902,
0.1414038985967636,
-0.10514334589242935,
0.6451113224029541,
-0.5908911824226379,
0.06427903473377228,
-0.19207064807415009,
-0.5539204478263855,
-0.19587372243404388,
0.23603132367134094,
0.7484079599380493,
0.5587449669837952,
0.020975248888134956,
0.3309989273548126,
0.4237115681171417,
0.4838394224643707,
-0.5102699398994446,
0.12721669673919678,
-0.8653834462165833,
0.15740849077701569,
-0.059579409658908844,
-0.5781035423278809,
-0.6569216251373291,
-0.2084082067012787,
0.2366466373205185,
-0.39261165261268616,
-0.010709628462791443,
0.2605076730251312,
0.8792362213134766,
0.3397606611251831,
-0.6466230154037476,
-0.5006938576698303,
-0.33859479427337646,
1.062403917312622,
-0.8803313374519348,
0.5602800846099854,
0.5939081311225891,
0.2138155996799469,
-0.38569554686546326,
-0.6349390149116516,
-0.37802654504776,
-0.22430743277072906,
-0.2355690449476242,
0.08864009380340576,
0.19182221591472626,
-0.10739848017692566,
-0.042184650897979736,
0.24605101346969604,
-0.4475118815898895,
0.04513140395283699,
0.0796896442770958,
0.055251602083444595,
0.39837580919265747,
0.08642364293336868,
0.27664610743522644,
-0.012127726338803768,
-0.576698362827301,
-0.06133774667978287,
-1.005387306213379,
0.2470352202653885,
-0.24135370552539825,
0.19977666437625885,
0.08379305154085159,
0.240971639752388,
-0.04893239215016365,
0.7618944644927979,
0.18772493302822113,
-0.5283839106559753,
0.11207955330610275,
-0.24663692712783813,
-0.30526864528656006,
-0.06034456193447113,
0.5268176794052124,
0.2726382911205292,
-0.1877814531326294,
-0.413702130317688,
-0.5074135661125183,
-0.485587477684021,
0.054415035992860794,
-0.6655411124229431,
0.13567407429218292,
-0.08889140188694,
-0.3450002372264862,
-0.10502750426530838,
0.16673000156879425,
-0.28330153226852417,
0.013791295699775219,
-0.5099571943283081,
0.507479727268219,
-0.4732878506183624,
0.32070842385292053,
-0.3400602638721466,
0.2835792303085327,
0.20074738562107086,
0.19714169204235077,
-0.59691321849823,
0.08902998268604279,
0.5095809698104858,
0.8606147170066833,
-0.42503517866134644,
-0.21399977803230286,
-1.070012092590332,
0.21863509714603424,
-0.5035164952278137,
0.6789650917053223,
-0.4043179452419281,
-0.46356478333473206,
-0.07408499717712402,
-0.20005755126476288,
0.15382890403270721,
-0.8054760098457336,
0.7083144783973694,
-0.7992528080940247,
0.25028690695762634,
-0.15275439620018005,
-0.902084231376648,
-0.46928828954696655,
0.22051414847373962,
-0.25535935163497925,
1.0677424669265747,
0.3028011620044708,
-0.36926397681236267,
0.7872328758239746,
-0.44098782539367676,
-0.42414602637290955,
0.18796376883983612,
-0.20851649343967438,
-0.48484161496162415,
0.4650537371635437,
0.4352194368839264,
0.7725228667259216,
-0.38458359241485596,
0.40364205837249756,
-0.06135405972599983,
-0.390851765871048,
0.3600158095359802,
-0.2936812937259674,
0.6720594167709351,
0.22892509400844574,
-0.25998935103416443,
0.32253700494766235,
-0.4681457281112671,
0.26729533076286316,
-0.25310060381889343,
-0.48528385162353516,
-0.492463082075119,
0.04366712272167206,
-0.14126773178577423,
0.5869253277778625,
0.05836792290210724,
-0.2674309015274048,
0.010255278088152409,
-0.42901355028152466,
0.2728036046028137,
0.6163381338119507,
-0.07478760927915573,
0.4847971498966217,
-0.07608027756214142,
0.4661538302898407,
0.023189015686511993,
0.1637677401304245,
-0.1890813559293747,
-0.35433417558670044,
-0.4959424138069153,
-0.19449929893016815,
0.3083053529262543,
0.35393574833869934,
-0.843719482421875,
0.45966044068336487,
-0.3000633120536804,
-0.31749698519706726,
-0.6817454695701599,
0.496213436126709,
0.6099622845649719,
0.6991066932678223,
0.507029116153717,
-0.2133663296699524,
-0.1835314929485321,
-0.5170028209686279,
-0.2605258524417877,
-0.025864128023386,
-0.06613285839557648,
0.38659194111824036,
0.35763105750083923,
-0.1516415923833847,
0.9832625985145569,
-0.42141491174697876,
-0.4302353858947754,
-0.350331574678421,
0.1219126358628273,
0.2507456839084625,
0.43782663345336914,
0.4733584225177765,
-0.926991879940033,
-0.9510027170181274,
-0.0008100042468868196,
-0.9017170667648315,
-0.2040911316871643,
0.06470485031604767,
-0.30527377128601074,
0.2081672102212906,
0.7103855013847351,
-0.10312126576900482,
0.19461487233638763,
0.8633261919021606,
-0.2761784791946411,
0.4150966703891754,
-0.3533876836299896,
0.11906497180461884,
-1.221652865409851,
0.012880046851933002,
0.1878039836883545,
-0.4646335542201996,
-0.5483794808387756,
0.3865615129470825,
0.502672553062439,
0.10318371653556824,
-0.6642581820487976,
0.7504158616065979,
-0.6471249461174011,
-0.047706060111522675,
-0.43355792760849,
0.3948010504245758,
0.1667696237564087,
0.421692818403244,
-0.08068764209747314,
1.1694233417510986,
0.28421786427497864,
-0.5908918380737305,
-0.17115484178066254,
0.16247178614139557,
-0.825488805770874,
0.6595995426177979,
-0.21141378581523895,
0.061523355543613434,
-0.1368318349123001,
0.19917434453964233,
-0.8703190684318542,
0.07680118829011917,
0.25488516688346863,
-0.47154495120048523,
0.5000241994857788,
-0.3541211783885956,
-0.5422961711883545,
0.11495791375637054,
0.16155856847763062,
0.4565388262271881,
0.5009329319000244,
-0.8643995523452759,
0.3474182188510895,
0.4459412693977356,
0.03796516731381416,
-0.5896729230880737,
-0.39447861909866333,
0.2883947789669037,
-0.26040592789649963,
-0.4240921139717102,
0.6735779643058777,
-0.2782025635242462,
-0.11960802972316742,
-0.10979223996400833,
-0.2339639663696289,
-0.27239981293678284,
0.3332379460334778,
0.02390773966908455,
0.17867569625377655,
-0.14221392571926117,
0.003935554064810276,
0.3723461329936981,
-0.23552963137626648,
-0.010833825916051865,
-0.6575605869293213,
0.28136274218559265,
0.08780364692211151,
-0.3076445460319519,
-0.5039684772491455,
0.24272945523262024,
0.4466411769390106,
-0.3575591742992401,
0.7569928765296936,
0.45717158913612366,
-0.20853041112422943,
-0.5091594457626343,
-0.3356378674507141,
-0.26985472440719604,
-0.4652489721775055,
0.3514452576637268,
-0.44391000270843506,
-0.9018361568450928,
0.27542901039123535,
-0.20881615579128265,
-0.1143205463886261,
0.15569067001342773,
0.2495783120393753,
-0.2211165875196457,
1.392922282218933,
0.7027730345726013,
-0.258863240480423,
0.5977061986923218,
-0.37305888533592224,
0.14129717648029327,
-1.0994551181793213,
-0.13399313390254974,
-0.2824166417121887,
-0.16200721263885498,
-0.35037025809288025,
-0.5505392551422119,
0.7172001004219055,
0.34773072600364685,
0.05956285446882248,
0.22306984663009644,
-0.019560515880584717,
0.4645122289657593,
0.6489285826683044,
0.15092270076274872,
0.44840720295906067,
0.20272871851921082,
-0.4987625181674957,
-0.053767137229442596,
-0.8665257692337036,
-0.6724504828453064,
0.9780414700508118,
0.06748386472463608,
0.47006428241729736,
0.09741176664829254,
0.626186192035675,
0.2338484674692154,
0.7218512296676636,
-0.7283756136894226,
0.41585949063301086,
-0.20763717591762543,
-0.36916905641555786,
-0.2416144609451294,
-0.6110852956771851,
-0.7377235889434814,
0.48673534393310547,
-0.073713518679142,
-0.6242417097091675,
-0.16040781140327454,
0.24924397468566895,
-0.12110038101673126,
0.27160266041755676,
-0.3502141237258911,
0.6930781006813049,
-0.45360320806503296,
-0.3121400773525238,
-0.2209327667951584,
-0.5583178997039795,
0.19686533510684967,
-0.26575762033462524,
0.17863735556602478,
-0.24183079600334167,
-0.0949598029255867,
0.34532973170280457,
-0.2103905826807022,
0.6156135201454163,
-0.06689490377902985,
-0.1642664074897766,
0.3659805655479431,
0.1392347663640976,
0.7660943269729614,
0.2517688572406769,
-0.35186561942100525,
0.3702598810195923,
-0.2260323464870453,
-0.4930401146411896,
-0.6958951354026794,
0.7510663270950317,
-0.7292936444282532,
-0.5696802139282227,
-0.13437043130397797,
-0.5200133323669434,
-0.30545759201049805,
0.2228148877620697,
0.5566843748092651,
0.45350974798202515,
-0.12475252151489258,
0.07951884716749191,
0.6960397958755493,
-0.314755380153656,
0.2834201157093048,
0.6948971152305603,
-0.024350272491574287,
-0.492164671421051,
0.8916422128677368,
0.23016449809074402,
0.3728012144565582,
0.8215060234069824,
0.15028546750545502,
-0.34571459889411926,
-0.8702738285064697,
-0.6920760869979858,
0.17288164794445038,
-0.915725827217102,
-0.4502672851085663,
-0.336719810962677,
-0.015248703770339489,
-0.05205671489238739,
-0.19515393674373627,
-0.08494704961776733,
0.2149297446012497,
-0.4767994284629822,
0.0826893225312233,
-0.13105526566505432,
0.5058704018592834,
0.4011036157608032,
0.5419602990150452,
-0.9976059198379517,
-0.17238126695156097,
0.014467187225818634,
0.36349740624427795,
-0.0801735371351242,
-1.0061203241348267,
-0.8006693124771118,
0.1551847606897354,
-0.3129318058490753,
-0.6881145238876343,
0.7798019647598267,
0.2307029813528061,
0.8508512377738953,
0.47962793707847595,
0.08928647637367249,
0.6097249388694763,
-0.46302077174186707,
0.7251060009002686,
-0.0721248984336853,
-1.180981159210205,
0.4746837317943573,
-0.01703181117773056,
0.3808126151561737,
0.5668664574623108,
0.5368243455886841,
-0.6146865487098694,
-0.26343241333961487,
-0.20536993443965912,
-0.8171292543411255,
0.5644667148590088,
0.12814415991306305,
0.04899292811751366,
-0.013108696788549423,
0.6790317296981812,
0.2531227767467499,
0.2888772189617157,
-0.5928702354431152,
-0.2843440771102905,
0.18622393906116486,
-0.16713885962963104,
-0.3770899772644043,
-0.2273121327161789,
0.10382311046123505,
-0.13893377780914307,
0.9411818981170654,
-0.4650609493255615,
-0.06548770517110825,
0.0690472424030304,
-0.6875799298286438,
-0.1310574859380722,
0.01877834089100361,
0.6764498353004456,
0.8956173658370972,
-0.2496439814567566,
0.1285213679075241,
0.449091374874115,
-0.09107495844364166,
0.2712656855583191,
-0.33544251322746277,
-0.41361090540885925,
0.06539233028888702,
0.20184610784053802,
0.7750006318092346,
0.21032169461250305,
-0.8010758757591248,
0.512985348701477,
0.04983270540833473,
0.11325665563344955,
-0.21941502392292023,
-0.028778251260519028,
-0.33464229106903076,
0.18672174215316772,
0.49500083923339844,
-0.17405983805656433,
0.11343985050916672,
-0.31973156332969666,
0.35851168632507324,
0.5989861488342285,
-0.9067984819412231,
-0.3440924882888794,
0.480022132396698,
0.17160634696483612,
-0.2150057554244995,
0.7569056749343872,
-0.2077479511499405,
-0.46682819724082947,
0.24663200974464417,
0.588840663433075,
0.9919928908348083,
-0.2109900861978531,
0.018444029614329338,
0.29170021414756775,
-0.011833617463707924,
-0.05786561220884323,
-0.09065264463424683,
-0.041140615940093994,
-0.7343501448631287,
-0.7431070804595947,
-0.4999707341194153,
-0.3453853726387024,
0.0681718960404396,
-0.6205583810806274,
0.27861475944519043,
-0.04789871722459793,
-0.17465122044086456,
-0.5942429900169373,
0.0801362469792366,
-0.6415235996246338,
0.4605747163295746,
0.11698093265295029,
1.0600852966308594,
-0.6454819440841675,
1.2091708183288574,
0.5860083699226379,
-0.33451777696609497,
-0.5412794947624207,
0.34809136390686035,
-0.07939546555280685,
-0.798789918422699,
0.868151068687439,
0.014548957347869873,
-0.35776689648628235,
0.32063084840774536,
-0.6072609424591064,
-1.265442132949829,
1.2134138345718384,
0.47112804651260376,
-0.30292657017707825,
0.2865760922431946,
0.058571796864271164,
0.3340900242328644,
-0.578407347202301,
0.06924871355295181,
0.29670560359954834,
0.21985341608524323,
-0.26847681403160095,
-0.5916656851768494,
-0.029740050435066223,
-0.11841225624084473,
0.09721938520669937,
0.2981698513031006,
-0.5087363123893738,
0.37183284759521484,
-0.19327618181705475,
-0.2652636468410492,
0.03611498326063156,
0.8438956141471863,
0.26940006017684937,
0.23532424867153168,
0.3675726056098938,
0.18558526039123535,
0.743156373500824,
0.15948452055454254,
1.144630789756775,
-0.6034010052680969,
0.32171228528022766,
1.2699428796768188,
-0.0347418449819088,
1.0104010105133057,
0.6724410653114319,
0.1724550575017929,
0.34259289503097534,
0.833935558795929,
0.19232560694217682,
0.7240719795227051,
0.13907527923583984,
-0.34432753920555115,
-0.36498743295669556,
-0.16285520792007446,
-0.07518178224563599,
0.25960731506347656,
0.48233816027641296,
-0.7575564384460449,
-0.10413607209920883,
0.12686240673065186,
0.1052326112985611,
0.11538071930408478,
-0.21530066430568695,
0.8825392723083496,
0.24367399513721466,
-0.8517557382583618,
0.7432471513748169,
0.23835593461990356,
0.5457448959350586,
-0.4237041473388672,
-0.0758509486913681,
-0.5512673258781433,
0.02613045834004879,
0.05896129086613655,
-0.6537656188011169,
0.05615072324872017,
-0.1954372227191925,
-0.3863982558250427,
-0.3640232980251312,
0.2355869859457016,
-0.4471606910228729,
-0.45886412262916565,
0.36611419916152954,
0.6483935713768005,
0.2755773663520813,
-0.21883855760097504,
-0.6948014497756958,
-0.2676716148853302,
-0.031573839485645294,
-0.151589497923851,
0.725771963596344,
0.4612467288970947,
-0.15063358843326569,
0.9050940275192261,
0.45759305357933044,
-0.09734320640563965,
-0.12280619144439697,
-0.3327086269855499,
0.5835069417953491,
-0.4719177186489105,
-0.4286360442638397,
-0.9188612103462219,
0.47402307391166687,
0.08523187786340714,
-0.39002129435539246,
0.8194854855537415,
0.6041823625564575,
1.3333858251571655,
0.13450510799884796,
0.8401532173156738,
0.47391194105148315,
0.2718748450279236,
-0.682649552822113,
0.6927838325500488,
-0.7525221109390259,
0.5008517503738403,
-0.2688998281955719,
-0.8971408009529114,
-0.5432313084602356,
0.5760619044303894,
-0.3665730953216553,
-0.09764886647462845,
0.6440436244010925,
0.9255027770996094,
-0.28247272968292236,
-0.4780592918395996,
0.7807393670082092,
0.02310020849108696,
0.420785516500473,
0.24957318603992462,
0.6317852139472961,
-0.4723843038082123,
0.6851987242698669,
-0.15190389752388,
-0.3132125437259674,
-0.40634340047836304,
-1.1220166683197021,
-0.6701235771179199,
-0.7075300216674805,
-0.226756751537323,
-0.25704360008239746,
0.13732364773750305,
1.3100732564926147,
1.0162454843521118,
-0.8065219521522522,
-0.5941151976585388,
0.14111001789569855,
0.30140361189842224,
-0.587038516998291,
-0.11400280147790909,
0.5405526161193848,
-0.6976832151412964,
-0.8661613464355469,
0.7280218601226807,
0.3075806200504303,
-0.051232460886240005,
-0.1062624603509903,
-0.42803052067756653,
-0.037560030817985535,
-0.02098912186920643,
0.92205411195755,
-0.1178145781159401,
-0.8786166310310364,
-0.1376442164182663,
-0.009097935631871223,
-0.2703680396080017,
0.339255690574646,
0.6648606061935425,
-0.6866379976272583,
0.47568508982658386,
0.4132148027420044,
0.6362940669059753,
0.4456406831741333,
0.004421586636453867,
0.8172892332077026,
-0.7789574265480042,
-0.22747570276260376,
0.10134919732809067,
0.34614288806915283,
0.377157598733902,
-0.3210621774196625,
0.4928113520145416,
0.07937858998775482,
-0.6102677583694458,
-0.672968864440918,
0.18670660257339478,
-0.5174985527992249,
-0.428114652633667,
1.0562233924865723,
-0.6208566427230835,
-0.14751362800598145,
0.0321909599006176,
-0.2848760187625885,
0.2373940795660019,
-0.4429331421852112,
0.9616246819496155,
0.4788624346256256,
-0.1325167417526245,
-0.20053960382938385,
-0.6615976095199585,
0.5965016484260559,
0.4410135746002197,
-0.6112284064292908,
-0.28248724341392517,
0.29210954904556274,
0.24946428835391998,
-0.311441570520401,
0.09622360020875931,
0.04847198724746704,
-0.011933919042348862,
-0.6291786432266235,
-0.02859751135110855,
0.17999914288520813,
-0.31020379066467285,
-0.372058629989624,
0.22132089734077454,
0.39999130368232727,
0.08913825452327728
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.07969v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.07969v1
|
LibriTTS-P: A Corpus with Speaking Style and Speaker Identity Prompts for Text-to-Speech and Style Captioning
| 2024-06-12T07:49:21 | 2024-06-12T07:49:21 |
Masaya Kawamura, Ryuichi Yamamoto, Yuma Shirahata, Takuya Hasumi, Kentaro Tachibana
|
eess.AS
|
eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SD
|
We introduce LibriTTS-P, a new corpus based on LibriTTS-R that includes
utterance-level descriptions (i.e., prompts) of speaking style and
speaker-level prompts of speaker characteristics. We employ a hybrid approach
to construct prompt annotations: (1) manual annotations that capture human
perceptions of speaker characteristics and (2) synthetic annotations on
speaking style. Compared to existing English prompt datasets, our corpus
provides more diverse prompt annotations for all speakers of LibriTTS-R.
Experimental results for prompt-based controllable TTS demonstrate that the TTS
model trained with LibriTTS-P achieves higher naturalness than the model using
the conventional dataset. Furthermore, the results for style captioning tasks
show that the model utilizing LibriTTS-P generates 2.5 times more accurate
words than the model using a conventional dataset. Our corpus, LibriTTS-P, is
available at https://github.com/line/LibriTTS-P.
|
[
-0.3463468551635742,
-0.6843640804290771,
0.3863430619239807,
0.29494747519493103,
-0.25996577739715576,
0.3852289915084839,
-0.38804084062576294,
-0.3364650011062622,
0.5278314352035522,
0.25466668605804443,
-0.42279502749443054,
-0.24730965495109558,
-0.2931975722312927,
0.33519887924194336,
-0.45627909898757935,
0.9521213173866272,
0.40645191073417664,
0.28229835629463196,
-0.07532508671283722,
-0.05752769857645035,
-0.5919618606567383,
-0.32130399346351624,
-0.579751193523407,
-0.016662294045090675,
0.8782995939254761,
0.46648770570755005,
0.8288509249687195,
0.2810367941856384,
0.05875738337635994,
0.15689292550086975,
-0.05801738053560257,
0.22310583293437958,
-0.14222726225852966,
0.2210799604654312,
-0.3887035846710205,
-0.14548493921756744,
-0.306884229183197,
-0.08879126608371735,
0.6420558094978333,
0.7084545493125916,
0.24581649899482727,
0.08807504177093506,
0.12109643965959549,
0.38031524419784546,
-0.46726784110069275,
0.2023039609193802,
-0.3212171196937561,
-0.20229275524616241,
-0.2652454972267151,
-0.5187245011329651,
-0.9031890034675598,
-0.4774210751056671,
0.4989248216152191,
-0.6024444699287415,
0.021893758326768875,
0.4464252293109894,
0.8055797815322876,
0.07936183363199234,
-0.3756938874721527,
-0.22757075726985931,
-0.7577950954437256,
0.4569120407104492,
-0.2875736355781555,
0.565218985080719,
0.26740744709968567,
0.4737527668476105,
0.2870941758155823,
-0.6648380756378174,
-0.48054707050323486,
-0.3448420763015747,
-0.48392799496650696,
0.10487344115972519,
-0.06407726556062698,
0.03518136963248253,
0.2047380954027176,
0.18061664700508118,
-0.7695088982582092,
0.23391731083393097,
-0.3444402515888214,
-0.3641525208950043,
0.4557860493659973,
-0.127261683344841,
0.29137399792671204,
-0.36108702421188354,
-0.49727150797843933,
-0.21384477615356445,
-0.5003045797348022,
0.2328924983739853,
0.31252530217170715,
0.48328059911727905,
-0.4571560025215149,
0.4099276065826416,
-0.17351575195789337,
0.7593393325805664,
-0.04220153018832207,
-0.2640644609928131,
0.28410154581069946,
-0.14747466146945953,
0.10820072144269943,
0.1769515722990036,
0.7901999950408936,
0.6153337955474854,
0.6429479122161865,
-0.20718500018119812,
-0.11790987849235535,
-0.37973088026046753,
-0.12029869854450226,
-0.6101287007331848,
-0.6097446084022522,
0.30473795533180237,
-0.5050677061080933,
-0.14466044306755066,
0.2008151412010193,
-0.9640237092971802,
-0.7890655994415283,
-0.4561655819416046,
0.5044193267822266,
-0.7474133968353271,
-0.3697086274623871,
-0.1291961818933487,
-0.27760812640190125,
0.24643085896968842,
0.5833356380462646,
-0.8908149003982544,
0.27934837341308594,
0.2220861166715622,
0.9527708292007446,
-0.6294096112251282,
-0.1868278533220291,
-0.8546624183654785,
-0.011316796764731407,
-0.22908903658390045,
0.7519969344139099,
-0.4296814799308777,
-0.5365389585494995,
0.2039211392402649,
0.04507908597588539,
0.1435791254043579,
-0.2993674576282501,
0.43140462040901184,
-0.2613644301891327,
0.38190191984176636,
-0.33452776074409485,
-0.5430594682693481,
-0.06531665474176407,
-0.3733825385570526,
-0.6558653712272644,
0.9075851440429688,
0.2213001251220703,
-0.9256396293640137,
0.2220388799905777,
-0.804020345211029,
-0.4345676302909851,
0.4996086359024048,
-0.3426054120063782,
-0.19977685809135437,
-0.17068028450012207,
0.2882806062698364,
0.42870375514030457,
-0.12479308247566223,
0.27682337164878845,
0.018534168601036072,
-0.19425669312477112,
0.5635628700256348,
-0.281135618686676,
0.9416975975036621,
0.4042174816131592,
-0.07931144535541534,
0.4920238256454468,
-0.6438461542129517,
-0.17485621571540833,
0.3122544586658478,
0.23419468104839325,
-0.07860828191041946,
-0.09870246052742004,
0.3265213966369629,
-0.2997654676437378,
0.5275163650512695,
-0.4811387062072754,
-0.01635640487074852,
-0.1823728233575821,
0.48004114627838135,
0.6971946954727173,
0.16352231800556183,
0.4240977466106415,
-0.6093432903289795,
0.4865879714488983,
-0.3388526737689972,
0.1225140392780304,
-0.7042233347892761,
-0.5872592329978943,
-0.5579338073730469,
-0.5310221910476685,
0.3464463949203491,
1.0450799465179443,
-0.6871552467346191,
0.5418307185173035,
-0.22393083572387695,
-0.7675670981407166,
-0.24837352335453033,
-0.4875938594341278,
0.3244096636772156,
0.4696088433265686,
0.4732179343700409,
0.05953140929341316,
-0.5656929612159729,
-1.1482287645339966,
-0.04076790064573288,
-0.3331749141216278,
-0.16175305843353271,
0.0932426005601883,
0.2890568971633911,
0.43678298592567444,
1.3266469240188599,
-0.19440099596977234,
0.3911237120628357,
-0.3026118874549866,
0.26106202602386475,
0.11228785663843155,
0.5169433951377869,
0.6414982080459595,
-0.8345871567726135,
-0.5203962922096252,
-0.3022316098213196,
-0.3529397249221802,
-0.5373795032501221,
-0.33362409472465515,
0.25754788517951965,
0.1189744770526886,
0.46773406863212585,
-0.3230865001678467,
0.16094765067100525,
0.4229550063610077,
-0.3711997866630554,
0.9164474606513977,
0.09292342513799667,
0.12731432914733887,
-1.2120230197906494,
0.13161039352416992,
-0.05911186337471008,
-0.38157957792282104,
-0.45138877630233765,
-0.4493429958820343,
-0.022977666929364204,
-0.4083343744277954,
-0.5841789245605469,
0.8427668809890747,
-0.4052775502204895,
-0.3565342426300049,
0.025607574731111526,
0.2921418845653534,
0.298123300075531,
0.3707628846168518,
0.34192976355552673,
1.3015773296356201,
0.6644762754440308,
-0.3894239068031311,
0.5169995427131653,
0.4865262508392334,
-0.3562529683113098,
0.6831710934638977,
-0.6479030847549438,
0.10974720865488052,
-0.14647036790847778,
0.3044445812702179,
-1.3523081541061401,
-0.1829945147037506,
0.11190818250179291,
-0.5461187362670898,
0.3408391773700714,
-0.22714370489120483,
-0.6400167346000671,
-0.12580431997776031,
-0.19491830468177795,
0.06607110798358917,
0.5868834257125854,
-0.6068313717842102,
0.6875184178352356,
0.05553574487566948,
-0.7604027986526489,
-0.15216194093227386,
-0.425802618265152,
0.08695495128631592,
-0.40918660163879395,
-0.6437777876853943,
0.7236385941505432,
-0.3086160719394684,
-0.33745434880256653,
-0.4117882549762726,
0.34404227137565613,
-0.022394966334104538,
0.05518675222992897,
0.2669332027435303,
0.347959041595459,
-0.05361408367753029,
0.2408582717180252,
-0.05797867476940155,
-0.08416372537612915,
-0.13990390300750732,
-0.16280008852481842,
0.795311689376831,
-0.18849943578243256,
-0.010251750238239765,
-0.9491907358169556,
0.5860587954521179,
0.29272425174713135,
-0.5991557240486145,
0.408072829246521,
0.6596689820289612,
0.0006887847557663918,
0.006058418191969395,
-0.4737497568130493,
-0.45865851640701294,
-0.4471859335899353,
0.16587702929973602,
-0.4461393356323242,
-0.9344779849052429,
0.46107417345046997,
0.12290658056735992,
0.1047278419137001,
0.11064183712005615,
0.40618687868118286,
-0.2750852108001709,
0.611844539642334,
0.4537607431411743,
0.060354672372341156,
0.9566908478736877,
0.18778561055660248,
-0.11382924020290375,
-0.35983946919441223,
0.03741394728422165,
-0.567887008190155,
-0.21179337799549103,
-0.8469358682632446,
-0.17405195534229279,
0.33051517605781555,
0.055498287081718445,
-0.30678802728652954,
0.36199498176574707,
-0.5972789525985718,
0.34273600578308105,
0.9261434078216553,
-0.03186381608247757,
0.10997013002634048,
-0.06499439477920532,
0.08250317722558975,
-0.26579269766807556,
-0.428253710269928,
-0.7643951773643494,
0.9021114110946655,
0.4289247393608093,
0.5831925868988037,
0.18154413998126984,
0.8551333546638489,
0.5323007702827454,
-0.022652480751276016,
-0.6401301026344299,
0.5908032059669495,
0.14387845993041992,
-0.3574846088886261,
-0.19920313358306885,
-0.08820552378892899,
-0.5983147621154785,
-0.2569580078125,
-0.28675854206085205,
-1.0301746129989624,
0.07720300555229187,
0.21807828545570374,
-0.8612497448921204,
0.1031421571969986,
-0.9160686135292053,
0.8508464694023132,
-0.2592187225818634,
-0.3408357501029968,
0.17610107362270355,
-0.805644690990448,
-0.14395789802074432,
0.3516722023487091,
0.17377948760986328,
-0.017925705760717392,
-0.011584950610995293,
0.9641837477684021,
-0.12063141167163849,
1.0014554262161255,
-0.27034974098205566,
-0.05260932818055153,
0.5070255398750305,
0.4327210783958435,
0.4529171884059906,
0.3224923014640808,
0.005448034964501858,
-0.07044368982315063,
0.24543221294879913,
-0.2663252353668213,
-0.5049476623535156,
0.2893929183483124,
-0.6262636780738831,
-0.45001792907714844,
-0.4143991768360138,
-0.5467400550842285,
-0.33846837282180786,
0.20104725658893585,
0.32102110981941223,
0.7965695261955261,
-0.18985402584075928,
0.21511931717395782,
0.7440964579582214,
-0.6416840553283691,
0.643615186214447,
0.5665900111198425,
-0.5427172183990479,
-0.7727829813957214,
0.9376574754714966,
-0.06235145032405853,
0.403915673494339,
0.6537395715713501,
0.37093445658683777,
-0.45931756496429443,
-0.5742824077606201,
-0.4567374289035797,
0.28283989429473877,
-0.5699158310890198,
0.06156011298298836,
-0.47476473450660706,
-0.08201851695775986,
-0.5458314418792725,
-0.2872473895549774,
-0.09535889327526093,
-0.7245758771896362,
-0.1585499495267868,
-0.22218923270702362,
0.8297604918479919,
0.5393123030662537,
-0.027727382257580757,
0.654826283454895,
-0.5455191135406494,
0.10114573687314987,
0.31502071022987366,
-0.012105141766369343,
-0.6107558608055115,
-0.6568096280097961,
0.12328435480594635,
-0.25373080372810364,
-0.24445579946041107,
-1.1808876991271973,
0.3464229106903076,
0.2059432864189148,
0.23007754981517792,
0.20014452934265137,
0.2039826214313507,
0.09337416291236877,
-0.5718933343887329,
1.2682075500488281,
0.1365482211112976,
-0.8332253694534302,
0.7089592814445496,
-0.8065937161445618,
0.027695374563336372,
0.39375171065330505,
0.31481337547302246,
-0.6542030572891235,
-0.3014904260635376,
-0.7258747816085815,
-0.6841304302215576,
0.5194952487945557,
0.12038930505514145,
-0.04608229547739029,
0.002839423716068268,
0.08179781585931778,
0.3158244490623474,
0.20185993611812592,
-0.783203661441803,
-0.4277900457382202,
-0.505951464176178,
-0.19825412333011627,
-0.15070199966430664,
-0.4392756521701813,
-0.20697413384914398,
-0.06774185597896576,
0.5178886651992798,
-0.21942204236984253,
0.38743826746940613,
0.3678640127182007,
0.035543471574783325,
0.23103417456150055,
0.5042259097099304,
0.8139215707778931,
0.6362251043319702,
-0.48082995414733887,
0.2530750334262848,
-0.0759330689907074,
0.03916638344526291,
-0.23737190663814545,
0.3324320912361145,
-0.2847456634044647,
0.4563310146331787,
0.464382529258728,
0.8860813975334167,
0.07097787410020828,
-0.6484251618385315,
0.5775126814842224,
0.16164585947990417,
0.22849832475185394,
-0.7525679469108582,
-0.22760845720767975,
0.12041788548231125,
0.1069832518696785,
0.44220590591430664,
-0.3326793313026428,
0.07162854820489883,
-0.3412971496582031,
0.43546509742736816,
0.10562503337860107,
-0.25599029660224915,
-0.2990342974662781,
0.6772087812423706,
0.6172387003898621,
-0.5470197200775146,
0.053979579359292984,
-0.44441255927085876,
-0.21315829455852509,
0.19078320264816284,
0.5098368525505066,
0.8576275706291199,
-0.3324805498123169,
0.3881266415119171,
0.36281585693359375,
0.06214692443609238,
0.399977445602417,
0.44847235083580017,
-0.1298626959323883,
-0.5562076568603516,
-0.3543757498264313,
-0.6907180547714233,
-0.8148303627967834,
-0.01024598814547062,
-0.6024986505508423,
0.5688860416412354,
-0.6541004180908203,
-0.1659468561410904,
0.2679918706417084,
-0.2470870167016983,
-0.24881640076637268,
0.040428031235933304,
0.364074170589447,
0.9562893509864807,
-0.8536897897720337,
0.8339381814002991,
0.5249924063682556,
-0.7277367115020752,
-0.730103075504303,
-0.18744607269763947,
0.14864581823349,
-0.546330451965332,
0.8329374194145203,
0.27245044708251953,
0.03888427093625069,
0.3266540467739105,
-0.3016754686832428,
-0.6476155519485474,
1.2240647077560425,
0.3535729944705963,
-0.7393017411231995,
-0.21923550963401794,
0.1068272590637207,
0.07532736659049988,
-0.45394057035446167,
0.4668085277080536,
0.36149832606315613,
0.5321797728538513,
-0.15839055180549622,
-1.3315876722335815,
-0.34392231702804565,
-0.07250316441059113,
-0.18876102566719055,
0.050472427159547806,
-0.4792552590370178,
0.9851332902908325,
0.05542445927858353,
-0.1705775409936905,
0.33572083711624146,
0.9386864304542542,
0.22484007477760315,
0.05124671384692192,
0.6925012469291687,
0.03641502931714058,
0.7956094145774841,
-0.2962612807750702,
0.8563331365585327,
-0.3794739246368408,
0.0014015864580869675,
1.3856223821640015,
-0.22429487109184265,
0.6767279505729675,
0.405928373336792,
-0.19332240521907806,
0.7089548110961914,
0.59879070520401,
0.1575728803873062,
0.3354261815547943,
-0.0022944342344999313,
-0.3547457754611969,
-0.2370212972164154,
-0.5815479755401611,
-0.26832664012908936,
0.31557029485702515,
0.24286587536334991,
-0.3857922852039337,
-0.012997007928788662,
0.2036506086587906,
0.24188882112503052,
0.33367234468460083,
-0.0697149708867073,
0.6782798767089844,
-0.06552506983280182,
-0.5474282503128052,
0.5599223971366882,
-0.2949652373790741,
0.6930035948753357,
-0.6469378471374512,
0.04185141250491142,
0.0999174416065216,
-0.3270663619041443,
-0.12730003893375397,
-1.0233678817749023,
0.056841637939214706,
-0.11199817061424255,
-0.10092847049236298,
-0.635840117931366,
0.4160511791706085,
-0.46525681018829346,
-0.2046516090631485,
0.10819607228040695,
0.4551975429058075,
0.2079603374004364,
0.11045057326555252,
-0.5174389481544495,
0.0641622245311737,
0.06190185993909836,
-0.035641446709632874,
-0.09876082092523575,
0.3539681136608124,
-0.21471375226974487,
0.4199630618095398,
0.34174874424934387,
0.021537477150559425,
-0.008973047137260437,
0.42693787813186646,
0.47549983859062195,
-0.530483603477478,
-0.7853684425354004,
-0.6655420064926147,
0.6135285496711731,
-0.27999183535575867,
-0.4264453649520874,
0.6797114610671997,
0.7090827226638794,
0.5764495730400085,
-0.19586943089962006,
0.9286625981330872,
-0.22635650634765625,
1.2019494771957397,
-0.6517378091812134,
0.4325591027736664,
-0.21244721114635468,
-0.12276691943407059,
-0.3684932291507721,
-0.7994858026504517,
-0.010774808004498482,
0.47773846983909607,
-0.43520620465278625,
0.03978181257843971,
0.7698724269866943,
0.9675939679145813,
0.13764464855194092,
0.35437068343162537,
0.3359422981739044,
0.03765804320573807,
0.3825080990791321,
0.2154121845960617,
0.9200402498245239,
0.038455843925476074,
0.30593141913414,
-0.488089919090271,
-0.3651728332042694,
-0.39177942276000977,
-1.0237594842910767,
-0.8572738766670227,
-1.0223664045333862,
-0.433196097612381,
-0.369974285364151,
0.10248515754938126,
1.2630524635314941,
0.5880273580551147,
-0.8866740465164185,
-0.34159624576568604,
0.21690303087234497,
-0.37716570496559143,
-0.15785695612430573,
-0.2948378920555115,
0.39925268292427063,
-0.34628263115882874,
-0.8096087574958801,
0.6777628660202026,
0.15637923777103424,
0.37224286794662476,
-0.3096718192100525,
-0.007899046875536442,
-0.10112233459949493,
-0.09846131503582001,
0.4800676703453064,
0.25189223885536194,
-0.7533935308456421,
-0.6068241596221924,
-0.017636945471167564,
0.07195951044559479,
-0.0029664533212780952,
0.78411465883255,
-0.6792751550674438,
0.4053936302661896,
0.3921077251434326,
0.4482889771461487,
0.19020728766918182,
0.06753940880298615,
0.5750479698181152,
-0.8904117941856384,
0.523206889629364,
0.4278613030910492,
0.4969269633293152,
0.6881176233291626,
0.008244585245847702,
0.3420482575893402,
0.3241511583328247,
-0.4344695210456848,
-0.69515061378479,
0.5293104648590088,
-1.4846501350402832,
-0.09799805283546448,
1.328333854675293,
-0.03787941485643387,
-0.16696546971797943,
-0.12353573739528656,
-0.8567003607749939,
0.23913516104221344,
-0.819401204586029,
0.1549394726753235,
0.5885385274887085,
-0.07498139142990112,
-0.4338916540145874,
-0.684384286403656,
0.8173614740371704,
0.579586923122406,
-0.5830813050270081,
0.4059755802154541,
0.5983750820159912,
0.23443034291267395,
0.4184933304786682,
0.5641117691993713,
0.04670818895101547,
0.34375718235969543,
-0.35165658593177795,
0.21430572867393494,
-0.2616085410118103,
-0.47149351239204407,
-0.06487850099802017,
0.037265852093696594,
0.327446848154068,
-0.23457801342010498
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.07967v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.07967v1
|
Better than Random: Reliable NLG Human Evaluation with Constrained Active Sampling
| 2024-06-12T07:44:36 | 2024-06-12T07:44:36 |
Jie Ruan, Xiao Pu, Mingqi Gao, Xiaojun Wan, Yuesheng Zhu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Human evaluation is viewed as a reliable evaluation method for NLG which is
expensive and time-consuming. To save labor and costs, researchers usually
perform human evaluation on a small subset of data sampled from the whole
dataset in practice. However, different selection subsets will lead to
different rankings of the systems. To give a more correct inter-system ranking
and make the gold standard human evaluation more reliable, we propose a
Constrained Active Sampling Framework (CASF) for reliable human judgment. CASF
operates through a Learner, a Systematic Sampler and a Constrained Controller
to select representative samples for getting a more correct inter-system
ranking.Experiment results on 137 real NLG evaluation setups with 44 human
evaluation metrics across 16 datasets and 5 NLG tasks demonstrate CASF receives
93.18% top-ranked system recognition accuracy and ranks first or ranks second
on 90.91% of the human metrics with 0.83 overall inter-system ranking Kendall
correlation.Code and data are publicly available online.
|
[
-0.3030078709125519,
-0.3482948839664459,
0.2331043779850006,
0.40400367975234985,
-0.24691611528396606,
0.3261784613132477,
-0.36758869886398315,
-0.7531604766845703,
0.10482389479875565,
0.20591361820697784,
-0.5882694125175476,
-0.41210541129112244,
-0.4340241551399231,
0.3706883490085602,
-0.4682762324810028,
0.9428837895393372,
0.44794929027557373,
0.15853764116764069,
-0.15833927690982819,
-0.16957813501358032,
-0.35588327050209045,
-0.3899461328983307,
-0.8597073554992676,
-0.5427756905555725,
0.16297972202301025,
0.24398641288280487,
0.9052932262420654,
0.21231509745121002,
0.8275769352912903,
0.29944974184036255,
-0.0891878753900528,
0.2430870682001114,
-0.47066524624824524,
-0.024209341034293175,
-0.3256317377090454,
-0.4321158230304718,
-0.36748141050338745,
0.28075551986694336,
0.46983423829078674,
0.7007076144218445,
-0.5493935942649841,
0.3075083792209625,
-0.010174085386097431,
0.645159125328064,
-0.6865594983100891,
-0.0010416463483124971,
-0.5438023805618286,
0.4120340645313263,
-0.2209027260541916,
-0.07788065075874329,
-0.35995858907699585,
-0.546873927116394,
0.3922988474369049,
-0.7489144802093506,
0.5570652484893799,
0.3213996887207031,
0.9040122628211975,
0.44781816005706787,
-0.25066420435905457,
-0.06508028507232666,
-0.7837207913398743,
0.8364985585212708,
-0.5912858247756958,
0.20124848186969757,
0.8455196619033813,
0.7720028758049011,
-0.08753619343042374,
-0.7757800221443176,
-0.3240448832511902,
-0.6672186851501465,
-0.013585579581558704,
0.36878344416618347,
-0.12777027487754822,
0.28627249598503113,
0.31620046496391296,
0.3706269860267639,
-0.568966269493103,
0.031357116997241974,
-0.34204620122909546,
-0.3927653729915619,
0.9875797629356384,
-0.08538606017827988,
0.19423635303974152,
-0.18560199439525604,
-0.4702509045600891,
-0.33745887875556946,
-0.5938310623168945,
-0.15824495255947113,
0.7391011118888855,
0.3752717971801758,
0.40413665771484375,
0.37028318643569946,
-0.2014155238866806,
0.9799112677574158,
0.34201955795288086,
-0.1485542505979538,
0.38935697078704834,
-0.3227074444293976,
-0.3042091131210327,
0.017431030049920082,
0.5866406559944153,
0.36260437965393066,
0.14358845353126526,
-0.5801337957382202,
-0.5205362439155579,
0.1643829494714737,
0.7415019273757935,
-0.24313423037528992,
-0.3510268032550812,
0.02938229963183403,
-0.6520543098449707,
-0.35654816031455994,
0.5308126211166382,
-0.5932325124740601,
-0.36402449011802673,
-0.20383189618587494,
0.365118145942688,
-0.09466278553009033,
-0.09372325241565704,
0.1479337513446808,
-0.15035761892795563,
-0.03996434062719345,
0.3791217505931854,
-0.44851982593536377,
0.5594392418861389,
0.34786462783813477,
0.6229650974273682,
-0.5618926286697388,
-0.12029654532670975,
-0.5915173292160034,
-0.2261342704296112,
-0.3522501587867737,
0.8182173371315002,
-0.2244444638490677,
-0.373031347990036,
-0.21995525062084198,
-0.023836536332964897,
0.07203162461519241,
-0.9767093658447266,
0.9774916172027588,
-0.5867574214935303,
0.07394375652074814,
-0.5010133981704712,
-0.32581228017807007,
0.023543616756796837,
0.26856720447540283,
-0.910786509513855,
1.206281304359436,
0.17775437235832214,
-0.5505964756011963,
0.8647403717041016,
-0.5720544457435608,
-0.3398101031780243,
0.1958128958940506,
0.10372618585824966,
-0.5293927788734436,
-0.18573959171772003,
0.23349709808826447,
0.3221180737018585,
-0.12910392880439758,
0.3680078387260437,
-0.5564560294151306,
-0.5843714475631714,
0.1842629611492157,
-0.5150170922279358,
0.8780578970909119,
0.5441399812698364,
-0.4105024039745331,
-0.0692293643951416,
-0.9460875391960144,
0.2884572744369507,
-0.19511494040489197,
-0.5608382821083069,
-0.12824513018131256,
0.18243540823459625,
0.1818198561668396,
-0.0111265629529953,
-0.14882159233093262,
-0.6252434253692627,
0.22272123396396637,
-0.22412227094173431,
0.15451250970363617,
0.5901985764503479,
-0.048766519874334335,
0.5752990245819092,
-0.46665269136428833,
0.7265833020210266,
-0.5965136885643005,
0.2755993604660034,
0.6603140234947205,
-0.43838319182395935,
-0.5497514009475708,
-0.040894728153944016,
0.7432181239128113,
0.6744472980499268,
-0.6926938891410828,
0.8606091141700745,
-0.08592011779546738,
-0.2970641553401947,
-0.5567890405654907,
0.20816269516944885,
0.6055740118026733,
0.1728522628545761,
0.2284756302833557,
-0.45320406556129456,
-0.5889951586723328,
-0.9328315258026123,
-0.23287807404994965,
-0.5011041760444641,
-0.4648094177246094,
0.27059271931648254,
0.20413866639137268,
-0.006855498533695936,
0.972844660282135,
-0.2395576536655426,
-0.5009436011314392,
-0.2227463275194168,
0.2780323326587677,
0.017303677275776863,
0.37167277932167053,
0.7047505974769592,
-0.6207306385040283,
-0.1680300086736679,
-0.34881001710891724,
-0.451528400182724,
-0.3792976140975952,
-0.062241312116384506,
-0.26119837164878845,
-0.17048156261444092,
0.4393927752971649,
-0.23954890668392181,
0.6011109948158264,
0.4686162769794464,
-0.2426767796278,
0.46692830324172974,
-0.2769690454006195,
0.14955651760101318,
-0.4958766996860504,
0.38587698340415955,
0.03708194941282272,
-0.3996778428554535,
-0.23874972760677338,
0.2895134687423706,
0.003701945533975959,
-0.020293714478611946,
-0.202270969748497,
0.5175442695617676,
-0.4446223974227905,
-0.23880083858966827,
-0.21556580066680908,
0.04130856320261955,
-0.17098835110664368,
0.16157755255699158,
-0.233660489320755,
0.6119377613067627,
0.08625388890504837,
-0.5545489192008972,
0.32357025146484375,
0.18511398136615753,
-1.0010391473770142,
0.5364357233047485,
-0.7917324304580688,
0.20372454822063446,
0.10484419763088226,
0.7065697312355042,
-0.8053609132766724,
-0.41346094012260437,
0.01863180100917816,
-0.31301337480545044,
0.11246751993894577,
0.09891222417354584,
-0.6975780129432678,
-0.6098811030387878,
0.03241541609168053,
0.23559755086898804,
0.468098908662796,
-0.6503174304962158,
0.043941743671894073,
0.5049874782562256,
0.46216699481010437,
-0.933975338935852,
-0.776305079460144,
-0.04264378920197487,
0.06713532656431198,
-0.34016597270965576,
0.45064324140548706,
0.01666347123682499,
-0.37019044160842896,
0.05279252305626869,
-0.42164111137390137,
-0.07613164931535721,
0.28356829285621643,
0.23795011639595032,
-0.02769656851887703,
0.3297420144081116,
0.14917795360088348,
-0.18757374584674835,
-0.19738397002220154,
-0.16525468230247498,
-0.04283178225159645,
0.08340919017791748,
-0.0953187569975853,
-0.942844569683075,
-0.37029582262039185,
-0.004069654271006584,
0.2569689154624939,
0.06239788979291916,
0.21361929178237915,
0.85841965675354,
-0.6591076850891113,
-0.46257996559143066,
-0.4611359238624573,
-0.33076444268226624,
-0.4453393220901489,
0.22846253216266632,
-0.05163944885134697,
-0.6930927634239197,
0.4656863212585449,
0.16114458441734314,
0.35977715253829956,
0.3096688389778137,
0.2685745060443878,
-0.06632032245397568,
1.1467503309249878,
0.401787132024765,
0.02369932271540165,
0.2573588788509369,
-0.11165584623813629,
0.2498837560415268,
-0.5160999894142151,
-0.3144098222255707,
-0.4971315860748291,
-0.8638660311698914,
-0.2056737244129181,
-0.4147837460041046,
0.4248947501182556,
0.5088303089141846,
0.10250788927078247,
0.24293608963489532,
-0.8341113924980164,
0.4435766041278839,
0.611440122127533,
0.4407450556755066,
0.17554281651973724,
-0.15695279836654663,
-0.4015629291534424,
0.10349509865045547,
-0.7100605964660645,
-0.5262961983680725,
1.0557658672332764,
0.059427905827760696,
0.8836259245872498,
0.0675986036658287,
0.5518827438354492,
0.7349806427955627,
0.5059173703193665,
-0.5835022330284119,
0.48883911967277527,
-0.013780767098069191,
-1.182986855506897,
-0.4643479883670807,
-0.3726724684238434,
-1.0990831851959229,
0.009339124895632267,
-0.5082209706306458,
-0.5928536057472229,
0.21896880865097046,
0.3491401970386505,
-0.8388245105743408,
0.4090366065502167,
-0.7628634572029114,
0.1337779462337494,
-0.20687271654605865,
-0.05318703502416611,
-0.09775369614362717,
-0.8644790649414062,
0.4437258243560791,
0.05962972342967987,
0.02730570174753666,
-0.2542286217212677,
0.21915097534656525,
0.9593851566314697,
-0.590846061706543,
0.7141470909118652,
-0.3509300649166107,
0.43007513880729675,
0.5421684980392456,
-0.1359076052904129,
0.34725406765937805,
0.3448983430862427,
-0.49254903197288513,
0.04333902522921562,
-0.18487359583377838,
-0.5567354559898376,
-0.700690746307373,
0.6609640717506409,
-0.9181939363479614,
-0.4087054431438446,
-0.6281729340553284,
-0.21569816768169403,
-0.304153710603714,
-0.1167415976524353,
0.27877527475357056,
0.08115687221288681,
-0.3011113107204437,
0.3087618052959442,
0.5332722663879395,
-0.2852991819381714,
0.3084590435028076,
0.14853443205356598,
-0.1506606936454773,
-0.5915520191192627,
0.44824013113975525,
0.26632264256477356,
0.22278791666030884,
0.28740638494491577,
0.03946271911263466,
-0.3330599367618561,
-0.4127078950405121,
-0.6527637839317322,
-0.15638504922389984,
-0.46754804253578186,
-0.5365564823150635,
-0.58551424741745,
-0.2200498729944229,
-0.17090439796447754,
-0.1870066076517105,
-0.3201698064804077,
-0.591628909111023,
-0.06998320668935776,
-0.4462504982948303,
0.2628997564315796,
0.7083989381790161,
-0.28411203622817993,
0.4261358678340912,
-0.5406849384307861,
0.2981823682785034,
0.6096640229225159,
0.6294258236885071,
0.09125416725873947,
-0.2799915075302124,
-0.0009793923236429691,
-0.08690404146909714,
-0.2734946608543396,
-0.6358149647712708,
0.18233507871627808,
0.2723831832408905,
1.0551509857177734,
0.7654455900192261,
0.20139706134796143,
0.98626708984375,
-0.1710597276687622,
0.76083904504776,
0.18903328478336334,
-0.7756945490837097,
0.2814450263977051,
-0.10595377534627914,
0.4742671251296997,
1.0950478315353394,
0.0029360372573137283,
-0.1903388500213623,
-0.22095666825771332,
-0.7048699855804443,
-0.9225885272026062,
0.8889598250389099,
0.43247905373573303,
-0.4128669202327728,
-0.08242180943489075,
0.6371212601661682,
0.11169097572565079,
0.03889995440840721,
-0.6713312864303589,
-0.2026049792766571,
-0.014531726017594337,
0.06467738002538681,
0.02975495532155037,
0.13840381801128387,
-0.3503561019897461,
-0.21435490250587463,
0.6354753971099854,
-0.0500376932322979,
0.5816236734390259,
0.17435190081596375,
-0.09737535566091537,
-0.3781137466430664,
-0.011304190382361412,
0.3925982415676117,
0.7743324637413025,
-0.5762675404548645,
0.20030835270881653,
0.488828182220459,
-0.5371811985969543,
0.19864171743392944,
-0.044655825942754745,
-0.1506294161081314,
0.10064025223255157,
0.5218262672424316,
0.6081597805023193,
0.30044353008270264,
-0.7193963527679443,
0.5354294180870056,
-0.26627814769744873,
-0.29525190591812134,
-0.33800584077835083,
0.2806939482688904,
-0.23327650129795074,
0.008017824962735176,
0.7471752762794495,
0.6458688974380493,
0.22536514699459076,
-0.25153017044067383,
0.4351702034473419,
0.3982234001159668,
-0.6218628287315369,
-0.24057070910930634,
0.7072033882141113,
0.2387656420469284,
-0.5538243055343628,
0.5949344635009766,
-0.5979437232017517,
-0.41607466340065,
0.7638036608695984,
0.40419453382492065,
0.7839539051055908,
-0.15675139427185059,
0.27544939517974854,
0.6559624671936035,
0.5181625485420227,
-0.740083634853363,
0.3352430462837219,
-0.1682148575782776,
-0.5640978217124939,
-0.5439494848251343,
-0.9095646739006042,
-0.6774946451187134,
0.10800928622484207,
-0.8789822459220886,
0.39675265550613403,
-0.586507260799408,
-0.6518967747688293,
-0.43609386682510376,
0.2569417655467987,
-0.8024911880493164,
0.5229575634002686,
0.05223984271287918,
0.9349145293235779,
-0.846748411655426,
0.525641679763794,
0.843140184879303,
0.08069662749767303,
-0.8173691034317017,
-0.09443527460098267,
0.004407230764627457,
-0.630302906036377,
0.40508490800857544,
-0.04483999311923981,
-0.016231872141361237,
-0.39819300174713135,
-0.6800463795661926,
-1.1045701503753662,
1.242418646812439,
0.3204151391983032,
-0.5676089525222778,
-0.057841960340738297,
-0.4123431444168091,
0.6757057905197144,
0.0925523042678833,
0.6526452302932739,
0.2667601704597473,
0.7481982707977295,
0.019628753885626793,
-1.137959599494934,
-0.07117928564548492,
-0.3724484443664551,
-0.06727121770381927,
0.06536510586738586,
-0.8303693532943726,
0.22011616826057434,
-0.22576361894607544,
-0.4337880611419678,
0.09089300036430359,
0.6594930291175842,
0.6872144937515259,
0.5251191258430481,
1.059064269065857,
0.7220397591590881,
0.9799476861953735,
-0.2523878514766693,
1.0996488332748413,
-0.19509248435497284,
0.2727804183959961,
0.8565170764923096,
-0.3308113217353821,
0.5710982084274292,
0.2246791571378708,
-0.5135297775268555,
0.260293185710907,
0.872571587562561,
-0.035524968057870865,
0.7619640231132507,
0.4673086404800415,
-0.1445506364107132,
-0.366393506526947,
0.34772729873657227,
-0.1837882697582245,
0.5412529706954956,
0.17813822627067566,
-0.33033809065818787,
-0.40648993849754333,
-0.014485766179859638,
-0.322793185710907,
-0.06828786432743073,
-0.08293984830379486,
0.47625356912612915,
0.04050065949559212,
-0.9286378026008606,
0.4551171064376831,
0.18232674896717072,
0.7045435905456543,
-0.592792272567749,
-0.03058347851037979,
0.10057353973388672,
0.06857825815677643,
-0.5060219764709473,
-0.3222247362136841,
0.2924576997756958,
-0.04621056094765663,
-0.025722669437527657,
-0.4433029890060425,
0.9270213842391968,
-0.12944404780864716,
-0.5516483187675476,
0.19748012721538544,
0.4874300956726074,
0.26667946577072144,
0.2311701774597168,
-0.735145092010498,
-0.16601143777370453,
-0.04805348068475723,
-0.32298773527145386,
0.33081814646720886,
0.14998266100883484,
-0.310481458902359,
0.7958059310913086,
0.9179469347000122,
0.1829584240913391,
0.08480150997638702,
0.21723704040050507,
0.35834628343582153,
-0.3597252666950226,
-0.4531916677951813,
-0.39848753809928894,
0.10696712136268616,
-0.3459344208240509,
-0.5925815105438232,
0.6211269497871399,
0.3703835606575012,
0.8808214664459229,
0.1854359358549118,
0.9455075263977051,
-0.1536635160446167,
0.6316720843315125,
-0.20575512945652008,
0.9934996962547302,
-0.2149937003850937,
0.33775293827056885,
-0.3704495429992676,
-1.0574530363082886,
-0.659639298915863,
1.0519802570343018,
-0.08038085699081421,
0.1776810735464096,
0.5415828227996826,
0.5893321633338928,
-0.19909706711769104,
0.03994610905647278,
0.36384740471839905,
-0.37471655011177063,
0.31152817606925964,
0.2940334379673004,
0.7598839998245239,
-0.2612452805042267,
0.5024756193161011,
-0.34679654240608215,
-0.4326087236404419,
-0.39506959915161133,
-0.8574752807617188,
-0.6891267895698547,
-0.2834298610687256,
-0.20977669954299927,
-0.46113207936286926,
0.06913548707962036,
1.1986398696899414,
1.0933982133865356,
-0.9524556994438171,
-0.12302899360656738,
-0.015742726624011993,
-0.06999509036540985,
-0.7180709838867188,
-0.2578990161418915,
0.4153905510902405,
-0.04272963106632233,
-0.7719768285751343,
0.35831311345100403,
0.12000533938407898,
-0.30087777972221375,
-0.4539622366428375,
-0.14334823191165924,
-0.12618273496627808,
-0.06327022612094879,
0.38827529549598694,
0.30823153257369995,
-0.78882896900177,
-0.5653324723243713,
0.08450598269701004,
-0.1483442485332489,
-0.29759645462036133,
0.7712109088897705,
-1.0397814512252808,
0.5158361792564392,
0.5242122411727905,
0.8353232741355896,
0.39749258756637573,
0.4330781102180481,
0.4640265703201294,
-0.7362678050994873,
-0.16925549507141113,
0.5340583920478821,
0.2780434489250183,
0.35886237025260925,
-0.3388974666595459,
0.8802796006202698,
0.23141519725322723,
-0.8531138300895691,
-0.9438657164573669,
0.011600574478507042,
-1.2302343845367432,
-0.06746391206979752,
1.393937110900879,
-0.2642005681991577,
-0.05664724111557007,
-0.3937642574310303,
-0.057538390159606934,
0.25065696239471436,
-0.48030322790145874,
1.3008525371551514,
0.7964600920677185,
-0.37637364864349365,
0.2900177538394928,
-0.4367508888244629,
0.5424779057502747,
0.558818519115448,
-0.6574922204017639,
-0.489414244890213,
0.24905647337436676,
0.26153793931007385,
0.2823634743690491,
0.6788750290870667,
-0.2200433611869812,
0.30847781896591187,
-0.1532452553510666,
0.1755649447441101,
0.014772339724004269,
-0.22394900023937225,
-0.15685656666755676,
0.40008464455604553,
0.0042908224277198315,
-0.07968919724225998
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.07964v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.07964v1
|
Political Leaning Inference through Plurinational Scenarios
| 2024-06-12T07:42:12 | 2024-06-12T07:42:12 |
Joseba Fernandez de Landa, Rodrigo Agerri
|
cs.SI
|
cs.SI, cs.CL, cs.CY
|
Social media users express their political preferences via interaction with
other users, by spontaneous declarations or by participation in communities
within the network. This makes a social network such as Twitter a valuable data
source to study computational science approaches to political learning
inference. In this work we focus on three diverse regions in Spain (Basque
Country, Catalonia and Galicia) to explore various methods for multi-party
categorization, required to analyze evolving and complex political landscapes,
and compare it with binary left-right approaches. We use a two-step method
involving unsupervised user representations obtained from the retweets and
their subsequent use for political leaning detection. Comprehensive
experimentation on a newly collected and curated dataset comprising labeled
users and their interactions demonstrate the effectiveness of using Relational
Embeddings as representation method for political ideology detection in both
binary and multi-party frameworks, even with limited training data. Finally,
data visualization illustrates the ability of the Relational Embeddings to
capture intricate intra-group and inter-group political affinities.
|
[
-0.6400455832481384,
-0.6466389298439026,
0.7718914747238159,
0.2930217683315277,
-0.45857900381088257,
0.6552643179893494,
-0.4842309057712555,
0.2906307876110077,
0.6326653361320496,
0.42648497223854065,
-0.6358763575553894,
-0.801360547542572,
-0.5326275825500488,
-0.33093008399009705,
-0.22945791482925415,
0.7303929328918457,
0.3197745382785797,
-0.061542216688394547,
-0.061893533915281296,
-0.17595331370830536,
0.15073326230049133,
-0.579038679599762,
-0.36246734857559204,
-0.5821942687034607,
0.49368590116500854,
0.5733080506324768,
0.7092450857162476,
0.31237417459487915,
-0.07748231291770935,
0.22340981662273407,
0.2319066822528839,
-0.10709495097398758,
-0.45528706908226013,
-0.17221051454544067,
-0.4476798474788666,
-0.5260452032089233,
0.26640674471855164,
0.21207940578460693,
0.4065306484699249,
0.37006276845932007,
-0.20574577152729034,
-0.06003354862332344,
-0.11584480851888657,
0.6384294033050537,
-0.7887886762619019,
0.2037394791841507,
-0.8297198414802551,
0.10560764372348785,
-0.2175365388393402,
-0.3687041103839874,
-0.3881216049194336,
-0.6286290287971497,
0.09056796878576279,
-0.1586746722459793,
0.285121887922287,
-0.15152348577976227,
0.5592280030250549,
-0.02091997116804123,
-0.7966668605804443,
-0.2901921272277832,
-0.5732585191726685,
0.756611704826355,
-0.283856064081192,
0.35069236159324646,
0.2130352109670639,
0.4230267107486725,
-0.206595316529274,
-0.5419282913208008,
-0.5734479427337646,
0.26585671305656433,
0.17521704733371735,
0.20715071260929108,
-0.059128399938344955,
-0.13273578882217407,
-0.1512233018875122,
-0.05167161673307419,
0.14650079607963562,
-0.11087977886199951,
-0.09019417315721512,
-0.04057738929986954,
0.4883280098438263,
-0.3111814260482788,
0.14638899266719818,
-0.7395843267440796,
-0.44354885816574097,
-0.1931799054145813,
-0.7363436222076416,
0.12149190902709961,
1.0012913942337036,
0.5183085799217224,
-0.18900969624519348,
0.5216329097747803,
0.09033241122961044,
0.30860430002212524,
0.2067847102880478,
0.35522186756134033,
0.37210750579833984,
-0.26670628786087036,
-0.04703724384307861,
-0.30428335070610046,
1.136599063873291,
0.4591648280620575,
0.46265313029289246,
0.19233816862106323,
0.08369272202253342,
0.16650335490703583,
-0.12721645832061768,
-0.3591034412384033,
-0.5129643678665161,
0.2271675169467926,
-0.5687763690948486,
-0.20207653939723969,
0.4860140085220337,
-0.9241410493850708,
-1.056038498878479,
-0.34807896614074707,
-0.09918417036533356,
-0.2603742480278015,
-0.8627017140388489,
-0.02588147483766079,
-0.39486125111579895,
0.17967067658901215,
0.3817569613456726,
-0.44374722242355347,
0.07428016513586044,
0.8827534317970276,
0.7755104899406433,
-0.15940363705158234,
-0.13585536181926727,
-0.03424336016178131,
-0.12350346148014069,
-0.2854803800582886,
0.9799875020980835,
-0.8000612854957581,
-0.08511770516633987,
0.2275494784116745,
0.04113493487238884,
-0.15848131477832794,
-0.39602524042129517,
0.33657246828079224,
-0.6034455895423889,
0.1987496018409729,
-0.5900290012359619,
-0.3154088258743286,
-0.09763676673173904,
0.12059018015861511,
-0.8912819623947144,
0.8747722506523132,
-0.19076818227767944,
-1.1138174533843994,
0.6520698070526123,
-0.5095323324203491,
-0.2003079056739807,
-0.46038123965263367,
-0.5415779948234558,
-0.20051006972789764,
0.2061159312725067,
0.2641979455947876,
0.8306592702865601,
0.011420093476772308,
0.41594693064689636,
-0.6848231554031372,
-0.07883304357528687,
0.23193083703517914,
-0.06662037968635559,
1.1551443338394165,
-0.2658511996269226,
-0.3383728563785553,
0.3831486105918884,
-0.4119839668273926,
-0.3789020776748657,
-0.046809665858745575,
0.01691344752907753,
-0.5058866143226624,
0.5366855263710022,
0.07409520447254181,
0.4971444606781006,
-0.0036832464393228292,
-0.7968349456787109,
0.03585413098335266,
-0.1603323072195053,
0.7769762873649597,
0.7342019081115723,
0.2715192437171936,
0.6291583776473999,
-0.026911601424217224,
0.2634439766407013,
0.22893185913562775,
0.0745023861527443,
0.5160226821899414,
-0.5031349062919617,
-0.39565351605415344,
-0.15694203972816467,
0.34943169355392456,
0.6517086625099182,
-1.279840350151062,
0.23144419491291046,
-0.2740030586719513,
-0.1677316576242447,
-0.26732906699180603,
-0.28721562027931213,
-0.09922299534082413,
-0.08806026726961136,
0.07893996685743332,
0.3141808807849884,
-0.5649254322052002,
-1.1415852308273315,
-0.3872186541557312,
-0.48091328144073486,
-0.09984041005373001,
0.3169310986995697,
0.9791805148124695,
0.01587304100394249,
0.9759567379951477,
0.010409833863377571,
0.16129058599472046,
-0.3000183403491974,
0.17301887273788452,
0.08624918758869171,
-0.010665728710591793,
0.29658153653144836,
-1.0689475536346436,
-0.5410467982292175,
0.19654908776283264,
-0.38275808095932007,
0.0938185602426529,
-0.03943633288145065,
-0.17811957001686096,
0.11493497341871262,
0.26199865341186523,
0.021595867350697517,
0.5053054094314575,
0.5594370365142822,
-0.46271663904190063,
0.01007471140474081,
0.28380894660949707,
0.46574780344963074,
-1.1708334684371948,
-0.2968263328075409,
0.2842266261577606,
-0.5181317329406738,
-0.5595564246177673,
-0.3119324743747711,
0.050223737955093384,
0.41806668043136597,
-0.5827908515930176,
0.09257838129997253,
-0.2589583694934845,
-0.17058096826076508,
-0.05154101178050041,
0.021184582263231277,
-0.4029965400695801,
0.21720504760742188,
0.37397223711013794,
0.4089878499507904,
0.2231806516647339,
0.27147671580314636,
-0.0031763864681124687,
-0.15927881002426147,
-0.47490164637565613,
0.48874232172966003,
-0.3524571657180786,
0.19022487103939056,
-0.3391912579536438,
0.3434385061264038,
-1.2456481456756592,
-0.4213268756866455,
0.41704416275024414,
-0.2858526110649109,
-0.22050899267196655,
-0.6250194311141968,
-0.7373726963996887,
-0.20289868116378784,
-0.5327178835868835,
-0.044575225561857224,
0.17671865224838257,
-0.5522735714912415,
0.7410951256752014,
0.8219442367553711,
0.3417041301727295,
-0.7811296582221985,
-0.5881150364875793,
-0.11775553226470947,
-0.5686560273170471,
-0.4587315618991852,
0.16212956607341766,
0.6399733424186707,
-0.39829009771347046,
0.16806267201900482,
0.22775745391845703,
-0.005420329049229622,
-0.33986589312553406,
0.45232149958610535,
-0.0742277204990387,
0.10990118235349655,
0.04901200160384178,
0.128876730799675,
0.1839514672756195,
0.06476478278636932,
-0.10481711477041245,
0.6483582854270935,
-0.3037196695804596,
-0.291953444480896,
-0.6422481536865234,
0.4447020888328552,
0.5698798298835754,
-0.1008588969707489,
0.8991293907165527,
0.519698977470398,
-0.31689828634262085,
-0.5214803814888,
-0.5548185706138611,
-0.22463566064834595,
-0.3649459183216095,
0.09974990785121918,
-0.09682600200176239,
-0.7980507016181946,
1.0242033004760742,
-0.3308772146701813,
0.14722326397895813,
0.3987993001937866,
0.836371898651123,
-0.14337021112442017,
0.6292518973350525,
0.4869852066040039,
0.20834124088287354,
0.5087063312530518,
-0.47410687804222107,
0.10440225154161453,
-0.3363513946533203,
-0.3116735517978668,
-0.41455861926078796,
-0.2942984700202942,
-0.9515579342842102,
-0.8476622700691223,
0.14600065350532532,
-0.2998242676258087,
-0.43360385298728943,
0.1841413974761963,
-0.37698858976364136,
0.7521302103996277,
0.34123462438583374,
0.4476681351661682,
-0.03868731111288071,
0.47338277101516724,
0.05234316736459732,
-0.31669458746910095,
-0.7866296768188477,
-0.3037278354167938,
0.9142869114875793,
0.3571908473968506,
0.496759831905365,
-0.007804120425134897,
0.8038260340690613,
0.40182170271873474,
0.543758749961853,
-0.6923038959503174,
0.2660384774208069,
-0.31058233976364136,
-0.5677923560142517,
-0.24454869329929352,
-0.44377458095550537,
-0.7211907505989075,
0.4992915391921997,
-0.541139543056488,
-0.5561875700950623,
0.7689275741577148,
-0.1011347696185112,
-0.14784136414527893,
0.7283622026443481,
-0.5087594985961914,
0.7980730533599854,
0.008625173941254616,
-0.464993417263031,
-0.31292209029197693,
-0.7909466624259949,
0.3589562773704529,
0.24897252023220062,
0.3881054222583771,
-0.3086073696613312,
-0.36908355355262756,
0.9533220529556274,
0.09811928868293762,
1.0843600034713745,
-0.5433241128921509,
0.33698636293411255,
0.3242394030094147,
-0.31022465229034424,
0.057311661541461945,
0.16862036287784576,
-0.4098885655403137,
0.2875578999519348,
0.05938706919550896,
-0.3190167248249054,
-0.49370548129081726,
0.737116277217865,
-1.1173486709594727,
-0.205619215965271,
-0.34332025051116943,
-0.2682031989097595,
-0.09840283542871475,
-0.06024542823433876,
0.2519042193889618,
0.133880615234375,
-0.24491797387599945,
0.5144333243370056,
0.44394099712371826,
0.02763972617685795,
0.37011465430259705,
-0.09469087421894073,
-0.15130102634429932,
-0.618176281452179,
0.6785159111022949,
0.22914238274097443,
-0.03937719389796257,
0.10900287330150604,
0.43644946813583374,
-0.6660174131393433,
-0.4068712592124939,
-0.14824840426445007,
0.3253900110721588,
-0.8305036425590515,
-0.0007623526616953313,
-0.3340018391609192,
0.2708192467689514,
0.28682422637939453,
-0.17296567559242249,
-0.5781421661376953,
-0.49098336696624756,
-0.07079922407865524,
-0.009752706624567509,
0.17808131873607635,
0.9635812640190125,
-0.04953503981232643,
0.6473482847213745,
0.19635944068431854,
0.0514451339840889,
-0.15399032831192017,
0.3300766348838806,
-0.19374869763851166,
0.023150358349084854,
0.2758404314517975,
-0.017249450087547302,
-0.12558786571025848,
-1.5501728057861328,
-0.012894638814032078,
0.11788099259138107,
0.34794238209724426,
0.4489271342754364,
0.37755030393600464,
0.3673541843891144,
-0.5035607218742371,
0.5755463242530823,
0.07001906633377075,
-0.723141610622406,
0.5591040253639221,
-0.4096605181694031,
-0.3724399507045746,
0.9114000797271729,
0.8300866484642029,
-0.17188993096351624,
-0.32675349712371826,
-0.6193932890892029,
-0.7066899538040161,
0.2824273705482483,
0.16437740623950958,
0.23154878616333008,
-0.026135403662919998,
0.5584526658058167,
0.16033220291137695,
0.32079729437828064,
-0.6720656752586365,
-0.2404259443283081,
-0.36484843492507935,
-0.11724291741847992,
0.06029912829399109,
0.13989019393920898,
-0.46471190452575684,
-0.2490885704755783,
0.34816858172416687,
-0.21585515141487122,
0.19400613009929657,
0.08948879688978195,
0.32348671555519104,
0.0702582448720932,
0.06363389641046524,
0.04898367449641228,
0.9995986223220825,
-0.13804219663143158,
0.22458237409591675,
-0.28498703241348267,
0.20968104898929596,
0.21008329093456268,
-0.087150439620018,
0.017988741397857666,
0.11829952895641327,
0.2552212178707123,
0.4578416049480438,
-0.09339141845703125,
0.0867888554930687,
0.6690107583999634,
-0.35395345091819763,
-0.3677939474582672,
-0.41936588287353516,
-0.1822195053100586,
0.5943571925163269,
0.28487393260002136,
0.40212249755859375,
0.010665946640074253,
0.09877211600542068,
-1.0427451133728027,
0.28999972343444824,
0.6660757660865784,
-0.3564915359020233,
-0.40490666031837463,
0.30574801564216614,
0.297066330909729,
-0.2835041284561157,
0.22132110595703125,
-0.11050327867269516,
-0.7800745964050293,
0.5542621612548828,
0.08740665763616562,
0.5654531121253967,
-0.06781642884016037,
0.5785660147666931,
0.21048657596111298,
0.30666881799697876,
0.1015302985906601,
0.44083213806152344,
0.012636452913284302,
-0.8915857672691345,
-0.46825721859931946,
-0.18465597927570343,
-0.3999062478542328,
0.02343926392495632,
-0.6339815855026245,
0.23281033337116241,
-0.6577464938163757,
-0.6765654683113098,
0.3092968761920929,
0.2766256332397461,
-0.4937804639339447,
-0.4015154540538788,
0.023473909124732018,
0.7263943552970886,
-1.666629433631897,
0.5491790175437927,
0.7505530714988708,
0.28728052973747253,
-0.18313296139240265,
0.303825318813324,
0.3274957239627838,
-0.5733642578125,
0.14880973100662231,
0.07050343602895737,
-0.3388654589653015,
-0.45268014073371887,
-0.6934128999710083,
-0.2418150156736374,
0.6950459480285645,
0.2895950675010681,
-0.31242498755455017,
0.07954475283622742,
0.07993882149457932,
0.37191063165664673,
-0.5507849454879761,
0.18398097157478333,
0.6329109072685242,
0.3328956365585327,
0.0434749610722065,
-0.2992068827152252,
0.002787459408864379,
-0.04003831371665001,
-0.12379464507102966,
0.5103258490562439,
-0.6963712573051453,
0.8413657546043396,
0.14886771142482758,
-0.4033525288105011,
-0.5595995187759399,
0.6592535972595215,
0.25613629817962646,
0.44164928793907166,
1.012076735496521,
0.14490367472171783,
0.6397911310195923,
-0.2752796709537506,
0.8035489916801453,
-0.35524749755859375,
0.49074435234069824,
0.9194513559341431,
-0.1476333886384964,
1.0250695943832397,
0.6671711802482605,
-0.10033927112817764,
1.0636769533157349,
0.9421872496604919,
0.2712879478931427,
0.45401862263679504,
0.1592087298631668,
-0.23751212656497955,
-0.5473081469535828,
-0.10468936711549759,
-0.028430499136447906,
0.39470407366752625,
0.7421768307685852,
-0.11326204240322113,
-0.30162757635116577,
0.007572301663458347,
0.04677674174308777,
0.42152243852615356,
-0.12749804556369781,
0.4966614544391632,
-0.13501279056072235,
-0.604305624961853,
0.04825150594115257,
-0.12773141264915466,
0.5729051828384399,
-0.09109116345643997,
-0.030982671305537224,
0.05907561257481575,
-0.024705974385142326,
-0.42141014337539673,
-1.3754079341888428,
0.31411296129226685,
-0.1489957720041275,
0.049738235771656036,
-0.11360640823841095,
0.61916583776474,
-0.27776899933815,
-0.432502806186676,
0.5260448455810547,
0.819725751876831,
0.02566112019121647,
-0.053697895258665085,
-0.959938645362854,
0.01711883768439293,
0.23907741904258728,
-0.36181285977363586,
0.07638853788375854,
0.5793910622596741,
-0.2913520932197571,
0.4785498380661011,
0.6839119791984558,
0.00027072062948718667,
-0.08324520289897919,
0.22999511659145355,
0.951392650604248,
-0.0837322399020195,
-0.3962295949459076,
-1.0139186382293701,
0.43537288904190063,
-0.4133491814136505,
-0.09498672187328339,
0.7701250314712524,
0.3495357036590576,
0.748009204864502,
0.09231851994991302,
0.7736660838127136,
-0.29091596603393555,
0.29123589396476746,
-0.198915496468544,
0.5129793286323547,
-0.38794493675231934,
-0.12337613850831985,
0.06572792679071426,
-0.5648343563079834,
-0.4100763201713562,
0.8606455326080322,
-0.683685839176178,
-0.0721200555562973,
0.4013822078704834,
0.6214990019798279,
-0.5222828388214111,
0.050590723752975464,
-0.19328275322914124,
-0.10235406458377838,
0.07136194407939911,
0.4947795569896698,
1.1518235206604004,
0.12879690527915955,
0.11234302073717117,
-0.7285703420639038,
-0.3883693814277649,
0.08839435875415802,
-0.9646556377410889,
-1.4849203824996948,
-0.7781694531440735,
-0.2563948333263397,
-0.7243914604187012,
0.04569723457098007,
1.0579625368118286,
0.7986973524093628,
-0.8850643634796143,
-0.42941659688949585,
0.2155076265335083,
0.5228206515312195,
0.3274804353713989,
-0.2519552409648895,
0.6456525921821594,
0.39158645272254944,
-0.699066162109375,
-0.17018531262874603,
0.12456837296485901,
-0.4487530291080475,
-0.5090333819389343,
0.2976626753807068,
-0.6062796711921692,
0.12316545099020004,
0.5302254557609558,
0.19270379841327667,
-0.8890981674194336,
-0.36981436610221863,
-0.12263907492160797,
0.2587355971336365,
0.24123790860176086,
0.9630817174911499,
-0.5859639048576355,
0.2930273711681366,
0.7807608842849731,
0.3940393328666687,
0.36043137311935425,
0.45436763763427734,
0.2515619695186615,
-0.7712735533714294,
0.2273782193660736,
0.28042593598365784,
0.2831558883190155,
0.6246663928031921,
0.11582066118717194,
0.4194989502429962,
0.24111783504486084,
-0.42005211114883423,
-0.6112120747566223,
0.17635753750801086,
-0.7513220906257629,
-0.3492825925350189,
1.2347006797790527,
-0.02076762169599533,
-0.4424322843551636,
-0.37592917680740356,
0.05834653601050377,
0.263560026884079,
-0.6144849061965942,
0.47146108746528625,
0.6990545988082886,
-0.24642963707447052,
-0.235691100358963,
-0.9446958303451538,
0.389638215303421,
-0.060399655252695084,
-0.5836447477340698,
0.10881708562374115,
0.21029001474380493,
0.4032794237136841,
0.20880655944347382,
0.6969324946403503,
0.12703345715999603,
0.12305769324302673,
-0.32844629883766174,
-0.23739871382713318,
0.36385729908943176,
-0.504879891872406,
-0.1668201982975006,
0.5263353586196899,
-0.4971497058868408,
-0.17754679918289185
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.07962v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.07962v1
|
Toward a Method to Generate Capability Ontologies from Natural Language Descriptions
| 2024-06-12T07:41:44 | 2024-06-12T07:41:44 |
Luis Miguel Vieira da Silva, Aljosha Köcher, Felix Gehlhoff, Alexander Fay
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
To achieve a flexible and adaptable system, capability ontologies are
increasingly leveraged to describe functions in a machine-interpretable way.
However, modeling such complex ontological descriptions is still a manual and
error-prone task that requires a significant amount of effort and ontology
expertise. This contribution presents an innovative method to automate
capability ontology modeling using Large Language Models (LLMs), which have
proven to be well suited for such tasks. Our approach requires only a natural
language description of a capability, which is then automatically inserted into
a predefined prompt using a few-shot prompting technique. After prompting an
LLM, the resulting capability ontology is automatically verified through
various steps in a loop with the LLM to check the overall correctness of the
capability ontology. First, a syntax check is performed, then a check for
contradictions, and finally a check for hallucinations and missing ontology
elements. Our method greatly reduces manual effort, as only the initial natural
language description and a final human review and possible correction are
necessary, thereby streamlining the capability ontology generation process.
|
[
-0.40932032465934753,
-0.6517103314399719,
0.8191543221473694,
-0.17304405570030212,
-0.03580303117632866,
-0.10045133531093597,
-0.3210507929325104,
-0.35364583134651184,
0.06037060543894768,
1.3054323196411133,
-0.7820643782615662,
-0.45732825994491577,
-0.4546757936477661,
0.3976399600505829,
-0.30147430300712585,
0.7071312069892883,
-0.11872489005327225,
-0.34785646200180054,
-0.041822876781225204,
0.20798364281654358,
-0.5735162496566772,
-0.2488735020160675,
-0.1907302588224411,
-0.4526372253894806,
0.12680985033512115,
0.5336971879005432,
0.7970221042633057,
0.8516378402709961,
0.5632042288780212,
0.4205267131328583,
0.12687548995018005,
0.4458688199520111,
-0.0990944653749466,
0.07615021616220474,
-0.1956920623779297,
-0.2839640974998474,
-0.9121895432472229,
-0.07209642976522446,
0.64744633436203,
0.5367408394813538,
-0.07284106314182281,
0.262205570936203,
0.22469322383403778,
0.0871497392654419,
-0.22854110598564148,
0.11733962595462799,
-0.9546632766723633,
0.10108557343482971,
0.009911014698445797,
-0.2617943286895752,
-0.19640591740608215,
-0.20214207470417023,
0.1464972347021103,
-0.7096736431121826,
0.11348824948072433,
0.047358784824609756,
0.6438560485839844,
0.2340596616268158,
0.05161389708518982,
-0.3443520963191986,
-0.7762889266014099,
0.9338128566741943,
-0.7256977558135986,
0.08556170016527176,
0.5108963251113892,
0.6111119389533997,
-0.20840266346931458,
-0.9007576107978821,
-0.9325997829437256,
-0.6511030793190002,
-0.1382049024105072,
-0.17776620388031006,
-0.02522234618663788,
0.12928254902362823,
0.17764054238796234,
0.14757709205150604,
-0.5322398543357849,
0.21361961960792542,
-0.08350399136543274,
-0.3507598638534546,
0.8442792296409607,
0.4151354730129242,
0.2361745983362198,
-0.5380604863166809,
-0.34590497612953186,
0.12646496295928955,
-0.49494054913520813,
-0.2635144591331482,
0.0841316431760788,
0.6664653420448303,
0.04704119265079498,
0.9182838797569275,
-0.49183812737464905,
0.7329086065292358,
-0.29771608114242554,
-0.5530858635902405,
-0.135274738073349,
-0.6055359244346619,
-0.2639354169368744,
0.09248074889183044,
0.6867976784706116,
0.1511230766773224,
-0.03104506991803646,
-0.41075587272644043,
-0.4801972210407257,
-0.12051685154438019,
0.6640236973762512,
-0.45695075392723083,
0.2502613365650177,
0.3959602415561676,
-0.3296305537223816,
-0.3760671317577362,
-0.0009310889290645719,
-0.6125938296318054,
-0.40196195244789124,
-0.31243476271629333,
0.5664710402488708,
-0.6875216364860535,
0.0027215213049203157,
0.037562090903520584,
0.06688901036977768,
0.23304857313632965,
0.03426789492368698,
-0.815962016582489,
0.09914899617433548,
0.7801201343536377,
0.69600510597229,
0.0923367291688919,
-0.2592174708843231,
-0.46773582696914673,
0.47512248158454895,
-0.04865715280175209,
0.5627588629722595,
-0.3113655745983124,
-0.3596716821193695,
0.029441209509968758,
-0.0009270042646676302,
0.5257253646850586,
-0.29906973242759705,
0.4282250702381134,
-0.5494459271430969,
-0.278572678565979,
-0.08362484723329544,
-0.5870702862739563,
-0.30552423000335693,
0.6831473708152771,
-0.6129828095436096,
0.7610318660736084,
0.29001301527023315,
-0.25162073969841003,
0.3425147533416748,
-0.9996519684791565,
-0.2459149807691574,
0.7006773352622986,
-0.13447576761245728,
-0.0483894944190979,
-0.19348198175430298,
-0.024869445711374283,
0.530834972858429,
-0.7013372778892517,
0.3436548709869385,
-0.10994531214237213,
0.264712393283844,
0.43897175788879395,
-0.11863657832145691,
0.621436357498169,
0.11480006575584412,
-0.4107185900211334,
0.2029002606868744,
-0.8878366947174072,
0.38712918758392334,
0.06460147351026535,
-0.2945185899734497,
0.04994984343647957,
-0.0979115292429924,
-0.20521755516529083,
0.06264717876911163,
0.554373025894165,
-0.49776917695999146,
0.36981967091560364,
-0.6735609769821167,
0.3304743468761444,
0.4746953547000885,
-0.22083023190498352,
0.5429573059082031,
-0.34359210729599,
0.5859163999557495,
-0.6805450320243835,
0.38690805435180664,
-0.26639920473098755,
-0.4550895392894745,
-0.6358564496040344,
-0.3089037537574768,
0.18191564083099365,
0.7446637749671936,
-0.700965940952301,
1.2604598999023438,
-0.2279108166694641,
-0.6689102053642273,
-0.17016717791557312,
0.5616285800933838,
0.4221320152282715,
0.67534339427948,
0.3567385971546173,
-0.37039121985435486,
-0.633046567440033,
-0.6741044521331787,
0.1485256552696228,
-0.4050546884536743,
-0.1907518059015274,
0.054555319249629974,
0.3975364863872528,
-0.466501921415329,
1.117572546005249,
-0.5623754262924194,
-0.6707486510276794,
-0.4985322654247284,
0.2252674102783203,
-0.20433442294597626,
0.1582147777080536,
0.09135206788778305,
-0.49343907833099365,
-0.009354276582598686,
0.18066205084323883,
-0.988845705986023,
-0.37225937843322754,
-0.038530971854925156,
-0.18702702224254608,
0.3854362368583679,
0.3439016044139862,
-0.5721415281295776,
0.36744722723960876,
0.3821156322956085,
-0.16670551896095276,
0.4878697097301483,
-0.3677034080028534,
-0.11309556663036346,
-1.073750376701355,
0.18513701856136322,
-0.3472810387611389,
0.04858984053134918,
-0.5453776717185974,
0.4219273626804352,
-0.03188556432723999,
-0.02980308048427105,
-0.2800576090812683,
0.49663183093070984,
-0.36133652925491333,
-0.03628756105899811,
-0.3637824058532715,
0.4565434157848358,
0.06453311443328857,
-0.053378261625766754,
-0.040042631328105927,
0.09697316586971283,
0.6584974527359009,
-0.7457482814788818,
0.8669756054878235,
0.38450661301612854,
-0.12725238502025604,
0.30530592799186707,
-0.3437102735042572,
-0.14108805358409882,
0.0831446498632431,
0.1433033049106598,
-0.9188357591629028,
-0.6403336524963379,
0.136795312166214,
-0.04718239977955818,
0.026326294988393784,
-0.04776585474610329,
-0.7656769752502441,
-0.6107416749000549,
-0.05459100008010864,
-0.11691789329051971,
0.576740562915802,
-0.20986488461494446,
0.9801260828971863,
0.38208651542663574,
-0.16042694449424744,
-0.1113203689455986,
-0.862450897693634,
0.3434951901435852,
0.023499391973018646,
-0.7533652186393738,
0.7200631499290466,
0.055278465151786804,
-0.20665067434310913,
-0.10903674364089966,
0.4736477732658386,
-0.10862546414136887,
0.08644013851881027,
0.31657904386520386,
0.5693643093109131,
-0.034195832908153534,
0.6381139755249023,
-0.09804567694664001,
-0.13636042177677155,
-0.049710750579833984,
-0.44131505489349365,
0.5895305275917053,
-0.14251437783241272,
-0.39196279644966125,
-0.47390633821487427,
0.34987500309944153,
0.36203891038894653,
-0.30214691162109375,
0.5859276056289673,
0.5745596885681152,
-0.4366365075111389,
-0.30701422691345215,
-0.5542888045310974,
-0.5362376570701599,
-0.5074698328971863,
0.28851082921028137,
-0.26764145493507385,
-0.7136544585227966,
0.5662472248077393,
0.0631026178598404,
0.4598972499370575,
0.3789879083633423,
0.622604489326477,
0.3452494144439697,
0.8094297051429749,
0.7565902471542358,
0.5357545614242554,
0.018791623413562775,
-0.1705118715763092,
0.3506597876548767,
-0.385114461183548,
-0.2907910943031311,
-0.4731989800930023,
0.0514569915831089,
-0.540122389793396,
-0.4199364185333252,
0.43463853001594543,
-0.035203903913497925,
-0.18489716947078705,
0.36839058995246887,
-0.6691051125526428,
0.2457585483789444,
0.1736636757850647,
-0.22830364108085632,
0.5307708382606506,
0.06612713634967804,
-0.12203281372785568,
0.00746686477214098,
-0.6396177411079407,
-1.1988840103149414,
1.2073668241500854,
0.24619647860527039,
0.6900814771652222,
0.2509075105190277,
0.8105008602142334,
0.1783771812915802,
0.6088139414787292,
-0.9543938040733337,
0.9509541988372803,
-0.14941468834877014,
-0.6549143195152283,
-0.8107272386550903,
-0.3116026520729065,
-0.7968965768814087,
-0.2989461123943329,
-0.4976630210876465,
-0.6087540984153748,
-0.5580834746360779,
0.30197346210479736,
-0.8041088581085205,
0.3859504461288452,
-0.3676162660121918,
0.5225821137428284,
-0.5318928360939026,
-0.024072173982858658,
-0.02890247479081154,
-0.57743239402771,
0.4614834785461426,
-0.5245500206947327,
0.18116088211536407,
-0.18222014605998993,
-0.37487396597862244,
0.4345226287841797,
-0.6015410423278809,
1.0026909112930298,
0.12007331848144531,
-0.3605864346027374,
0.5539387464523315,
0.176945298910141,
0.3643156588077545,
0.009459755383431911,
-0.40861430764198303,
-0.10377205163240433,
-0.2291504442691803,
0.001796846161596477,
-0.4676407277584076,
0.5656799077987671,
-0.629143476486206,
-0.5700027942657471,
0.1218181625008583,
-0.7175142168998718,
-0.2118404060602188,
0.40878745913505554,
0.2663021385669708,
0.3852299451828003,
-0.2744981050491333,
-0.27545005083084106,
0.4284302592277527,
-0.36016759276390076,
0.5546603798866272,
0.5558698177337646,
-0.43025335669517517,
-0.08322662860155106,
0.6087754964828491,
0.5574744939804077,
0.3432302176952362,
0.23963014781475067,
0.19797676801681519,
-0.4505482316017151,
-0.26782891154289246,
-0.5575651526451111,
0.09005466848611832,
-0.729753315448761,
-0.35750842094421387,
-0.8044810891151428,
-0.22721023857593536,
-0.7768058180809021,
-0.33812209963798523,
-0.3546813726425171,
-0.4131995439529419,
-0.23874954879283905,
0.2543346583843231,
0.7133691906929016,
0.8573132753372192,
0.010983306914567947,
0.3922632932662964,
-1.1835224628448486,
0.47293800115585327,
0.7760977745056152,
0.46125876903533936,
0.061628591269254684,
-0.8401740789413452,
-0.03546581417322159,
-0.09580191969871521,
-0.6122355461120605,
-0.7327511310577393,
0.5991322994232178,
0.2183683067560196,
0.6883984804153442,
0.2638251483440399,
0.2548002600669861,
0.3086049556732178,
-0.36889299750328064,
0.7605181932449341,
0.2136102318763733,
-1.0067015886306763,
0.8329739570617676,
-0.11290987581014633,
0.15385940670967102,
0.30101507902145386,
0.37505313754081726,
0.034974053502082825,
-0.41120100021362305,
-0.5608437061309814,
-0.8359420299530029,
0.5704920887947083,
-0.09377133101224899,
0.39316585659980774,
0.03849859535694122,
0.3454829156398773,
0.26740726828575134,
-0.1251567304134369,
-0.5973567366600037,
0.06452816724777222,
-0.21359199285507202,
-0.1757027506828308,
0.30606237053871155,
-0.17044755816459656,
-0.46000856161117554,
0.1595214456319809,
0.8197450041770935,
-0.4622192680835724,
0.026893990114331245,
0.11508647352457047,
-0.10613422095775604,
-0.17378191649913788,
0.52668297290802,
0.2590620219707489,
0.704999566078186,
0.05448218807578087,
0.2971784174442291,
0.5237982869148254,
-0.2799992859363556,
0.12838537991046906,
0.18824931979179382,
-0.014471017755568027,
-0.21173354983329773,
0.3590008318424225,
0.5151154398918152,
-0.0930686742067337,
-0.9727907776832581,
0.21805019676685333,
0.09154879301786423,
-0.26749828457832336,
-0.40095198154449463,
0.19327543675899506,
0.07087986916303635,
0.31893807649612427,
0.4625830054283142,
-0.41159823536872864,
-0.08117810636758804,
-0.47041788697242737,
0.16936813294887543,
0.30623868107795715,
-0.21152205765247345,
-0.016734804958105087,
0.19361191987991333,
0.16427680850028992,
-0.45273202657699585,
0.46586644649505615,
-0.6536460518836975,
-0.3551396131515503,
0.4222903549671173,
0.47460830211639404,
0.7804207801818848,
-0.19667869806289673,
0.26248061656951904,
0.20274192094802856,
0.6028967499732971,
-0.18054237961769104,
0.3115738332271576,
0.23810629546642303,
-0.8082194924354553,
-0.6390299201011658,
-0.9255638718605042,
-0.4275456666946411,
0.1499454379081726,
-0.26540008187294006,
0.3960552215576172,
-0.6036750674247742,
-0.5186033248901367,
0.24396440386772156,
-0.2354889065027237,
-0.5154268741607666,
0.21214202046394348,
0.2850460112094879,
0.7583277821540833,
-0.7058592438697815,
0.8363192081451416,
0.7537533640861511,
-0.49016085267066956,
-1.210304617881775,
-0.023737892508506775,
-0.06370624154806137,
-0.7122952342033386,
0.7293792366981506,
0.1487078070640564,
-0.19161349534988403,
0.04685783386230469,
-0.45260560512542725,
-0.6693848967552185,
1.294189453125,
0.35815203189849854,
-0.39582204818725586,
0.1554374098777771,
0.38430315256118774,
0.4922052025794983,
-0.6964101791381836,
-0.15366651117801666,
0.5607154965400696,
0.8278753161430359,
-0.03472548723220825,
-0.9823738932609558,
0.46071258187294006,
0.17957955598831177,
0.2389247566461563,
-0.08974725008010864,
-0.20978042483329773,
0.7240537405014038,
-0.4352080523967743,
0.011818884871900082,
0.3736940622329712,
0.5047292709350586,
0.37741759419441223,
-0.12384138256311417,
0.6359755396842957,
0.2600141167640686,
0.7448690533638,
0.1410875767469406,
1.0890498161315918,
-0.36333420872688293,
0.09494829922914505,
0.9055531024932861,
-0.6633117198944092,
0.6523446440696716,
0.4201919734477997,
0.006459319964051247,
0.3762480914592743,
-0.013812105171382427,
-0.2324545532464981,
-0.00583731010556221,
0.14423929154872894,
-0.4255894720554352,
-0.5955079197883606,
-0.3343532383441925,
-0.08351820707321167,
0.9898409247398376,
0.2895890474319458,
-0.5902756452560425,
-0.2988373637199402,
0.18138210475444794,
-0.20060649514198303,
0.21921078860759735,
-0.32546693086624146,
0.816502571105957,
-0.1011778861284256,
-0.9408900141716003,
0.6678009033203125,
0.4808209538459778,
0.552017331123352,
-0.7472719550132751,
-0.04600208252668381,
0.24028752744197845,
-0.14839015901088715,
-0.23207122087478638,
-0.9195746779441833,
0.6100530624389648,
0.31480100750923157,
-0.21619129180908203,
-0.315787672996521,
0.950587809085846,
-0.2869917154312134,
-0.6379027366638184,
0.4672805070877075,
0.4799269735813141,
0.12989693880081177,
0.17244543135166168,
-0.5153102874755859,
-0.06914187222719193,
-0.1966659277677536,
-0.12055237591266632,
0.02271590754389763,
0.5092672109603882,
-0.25867852568626404,
0.7771074771881104,
0.5111348628997803,
0.08618033677339554,
0.013470431789755821,
-0.053692203015089035,
0.7335963845252991,
-0.5520031452178955,
-0.5054514408111572,
-0.8352961540222168,
0.4977973699569702,
-0.01781938411295414,
-0.11928240209817886,
0.3619888722896576,
0.02089289017021656,
0.438358336687088,
-0.06501588225364685,
1.130605936050415,
-0.5245610475540161,
0.40344250202178955,
-0.47313567996025085,
1.0221766233444214,
-0.5258169770240784,
0.519224226474762,
0.16973580420017242,
-0.667131781578064,
-0.4981813132762909,
0.43930092453956604,
-0.18088962137699127,
0.069478340446949,
0.38330504298210144,
1.23272705078125,
-0.03968232497572899,
0.016448691487312317,
0.5896425843238831,
0.2432125210762024,
0.047038182616233826,
0.24424949288368225,
0.597756028175354,
-0.20898626744747162,
0.9800535440444946,
-0.03845919296145439,
-0.46721622347831726,
-0.29798227548599243,
-1.2957384586334229,
-0.6287493705749512,
-0.3385546803474426,
-0.18285833299160004,
-0.5068965554237366,
-0.3678211271762848,
0.9589235782623291,
0.6628320217132568,
-0.6406975984573364,
-0.2308739274740219,
-0.1865338534116745,
0.06258315593004227,
0.032518185675144196,
-0.20062515139579773,
-0.09230440855026245,
-0.4667600095272064,
-0.32383453845977783,
0.2434999942779541,
0.36259227991104126,
0.09158580750226974,
-0.8185445666313171,
-0.3097805380821228,
0.04087800905108452,
0.27678653597831726,
0.665958821773529,
0.12822586297988892,
-1.0885685682296753,
-0.42233970761299133,
-0.006681324448436499,
-0.28249984979629517,
-0.39011144638061523,
0.5889357328414917,
-0.6667121052742004,
0.5813796520233154,
0.36479735374450684,
0.6147366166114807,
-0.06696950644254684,
-0.6180364489555359,
0.5613002181053162,
-0.8585517406463623,
-0.14358024299144745,
0.08084268122911453,
0.18190531432628632,
0.49287378787994385,
-0.2975412607192993,
0.3617665469646454,
-0.03456675261259079,
-0.40180346369743347,
-0.8146993517875671,
0.5458890199661255,
-1.1031848192214966,
-0.17432348430156708,
1.105911135673523,
-0.3093661367893219,
-0.09951847046613693,
-0.46745914220809937,
-0.20490597188472748,
0.6429312825202942,
-0.014154870994389057,
1.0272560119628906,
0.43603822588920593,
-0.012490068562328815,
0.19630634784698486,
-0.41337209939956665,
0.36065664887428284,
0.1953437328338623,
-1.0327733755111694,
0.3269210457801819,
0.2382950633764267,
0.2014639675617218,
0.5593218207359314,
0.35656052827835083,
-0.23580215871334076,
0.12890399992465973,
-0.17254222929477692,
0.5881543159484863,
-0.12745516002178192,
-0.05330139026045799,
-0.08648844808340073,
0.339574933052063,
0.20364125072956085,
0.30890953540802
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.07935v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.07935v1
|
Defining and Detecting Vulnerability in Human Evaluation Guidelines: A Preliminary Study Towards Reliable NLG Evaluation
| 2024-06-12T06:59:31 | 2024-06-12T06:59:31 |
Jie Ruan, Wenqing Wang, Xiaojun Wan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Human evaluation serves as the gold standard for assessing the quality of
Natural Language Generation (NLG) systems. Nevertheless, the evaluation
guideline, as a pivotal element ensuring reliable and reproducible human
assessment, has received limited attention.Our investigation revealed that only
29.84% of recent papers involving human evaluation at top conferences release
their evaluation guidelines, with vulnerabilities identified in 77.09% of these
guidelines. Unreliable evaluation guidelines can yield inaccurate assessment
outcomes, potentially impeding the advancement of NLG in the right direction.
To address these challenges, we take an initial step towards reliable
evaluation guidelines and propose the first human evaluation guideline dataset
by collecting annotations of guidelines extracted from existing papers as well
as generated via Large Language Models (LLMs). We then introduce a taxonomy of
eight vulnerabilities and formulate a principle for composing evaluation
guidelines. Furthermore, a method for detecting guideline vulnerabilities has
been explored using LLMs, and we offer a set of recommendations to enhance
reliability in human evaluation. The annotated human evaluation guideline
dataset and code for the vulnerability detection method are publicly available
online.
|
[
-0.24381813406944275,
-0.6675190925598145,
0.5191239714622498,
0.31389114260673523,
-0.20841525495052338,
-0.20091752707958221,
-0.21094200015068054,
-0.605626106262207,
-0.25281858444213867,
0.6751074194908142,
-0.4993963837623596,
-0.5292869806289673,
-0.5445038676261902,
0.23230376839637756,
-0.29424357414245605,
1.1082580089569092,
0.2063075602054596,
-0.08995353430509567,
-0.43301764130592346,
-0.12016720324754715,
-0.6103594303131104,
-0.33611321449279785,
-0.4839460551738739,
-0.11372683942317963,
0.2896486818790436,
0.4356657862663269,
0.6127746105194092,
0.40499767661094666,
0.889552116394043,
0.20125627517700195,
-0.10076546669006348,
-0.02421422488987446,
-0.20453472435474396,
0.1385449469089508,
-0.059599388390779495,
-0.22454077005386353,
-0.6352672576904297,
-0.018094295635819435,
0.3143799304962158,
0.6850165724754333,
-0.3343389332294464,
0.4427527189254761,
0.19279548525810242,
0.6664774417877197,
-0.6295021772384644,
-0.05585392564535141,
-0.6051739454269409,
0.2149166762828827,
-0.380260705947876,
-0.23609420657157898,
-0.4159497916698456,
-0.6280773878097534,
0.33591675758361816,
-0.31126147508621216,
0.20132502913475037,
-0.0852387398481369,
0.4989945590496063,
0.10374516993761063,
-0.22791314125061035,
-0.3066208064556122,
-0.5940397381782532,
0.6124650835990906,
-0.7195920944213867,
0.20202060043811798,
0.7530426383018494,
0.41989636421203613,
-0.10206273943185806,
-0.596186101436615,
-0.2297290563583374,
-0.5988059639930725,
0.17139163613319397,
-0.29838088154792786,
-0.473464697599411,
-0.057483598589897156,
0.3176402151584625,
0.33442649245262146,
-0.7615469098091125,
0.15436270833015442,
-0.26437267661094666,
-0.5574951171875,
0.8143309354782104,
0.17315275967121124,
0.18856686353683472,
-0.35272878408432007,
-0.3663957118988037,
-0.021742289885878563,
-0.6098889708518982,
-0.39384788274765015,
0.8568612337112427,
0.31923237442970276,
0.10475962609052658,
0.35099878907203674,
0.12544777989387512,
0.5785207748413086,
-0.20079733431339264,
-0.1378108561038971,
0.31171363592147827,
-0.6965064406394958,
-0.018387315794825554,
-0.0836346447467804,
0.8152623176574707,
0.5777294635772705,
0.1532486230134964,
-0.5144262313842773,
-0.24368830025196075,
0.13831646740436554,
0.8288244009017944,
-0.31453937292099,
-0.1852179318666458,
-0.04641443118453026,
-0.46251899003982544,
-0.7187232375144958,
0.08305515348911285,
-0.9316868185997009,
-0.7691060900688171,
0.31534045934677124,
0.2516389787197113,
-0.15021303296089172,
-0.2585342228412628,
0.05700231343507767,
-0.02759752981364727,
0.3339138329029083,
0.035308681428432465,
-0.6752888560295105,
0.3871033191680908,
0.5773647427558899,
0.5492845177650452,
0.03142108768224716,
-0.17851483821868896,
-0.44473516941070557,
-0.2872980833053589,
-0.15097647905349731,
0.733626663684845,
-0.14489471912384033,
-0.40227648615837097,
0.08831751346588135,
-0.19472937285900116,
0.503862202167511,
-0.5058232545852661,
1.372991681098938,
-0.08539893478155136,
0.22470946609973907,
-0.15584932267665863,
-0.1684284657239914,
0.11472760885953903,
0.3422774374485016,
-0.7617554664611816,
0.9002800583839417,
0.3350476622581482,
-0.890158474445343,
0.37720486521720886,
-0.7066746354103088,
-0.4581352770328522,
0.14558623731136322,
0.2248634248971939,
-0.6596760153770447,
-0.028166387230157852,
0.2446487993001938,
0.041436567902565,
-0.6286032795906067,
0.16369138658046722,
-0.28388524055480957,
-0.17795097827911377,
0.24600528180599213,
-0.7231535911560059,
0.8908881545066833,
0.12420365959405899,
-0.4179758131504059,
0.20484137535095215,
-0.8527774214744568,
0.2138207107782364,
0.13386189937591553,
-0.38894063234329224,
-0.08986902981996536,
0.0631970465183258,
0.24705301225185394,
0.030546607449650764,
0.0331316739320755,
-0.25455886125564575,
0.11563143134117126,
-0.3503170311450958,
0.3329029381275177,
0.8681095838546753,
0.22049306333065033,
0.31217125058174133,
-0.1912093162536621,
0.7802064418792725,
-0.317192018032074,
0.5241597890853882,
-0.1165042594075203,
-0.5047944784164429,
-0.47586390376091003,
0.48117291927337646,
0.4351789355278015,
0.599901020526886,
-0.3297922909259796,
1.1503781080245972,
-0.1137876883149147,
-0.6232250332832336,
-0.5431902408599854,
0.3140905797481537,
0.577210545539856,
0.7038300633430481,
0.2299259901046753,
-0.5360265970230103,
-0.8249369859695435,
-0.8734503388404846,
-0.42806878685951233,
-0.549604594707489,
-0.25839558243751526,
0.08014559745788574,
0.45413583517074585,
-0.5753453373908997,
0.873757541179657,
-0.29897958040237427,
-0.39815691113471985,
-0.2625645399093628,
0.23478350043296814,
-0.16664466261863708,
0.39134371280670166,
0.4661765992641449,
-0.5916482210159302,
0.2256193906068802,
-0.4079398214817047,
-0.7428678274154663,
-0.34639328718185425,
0.09186746180057526,
-0.19741910696029663,
0.10705574601888657,
0.15139730274677277,
-0.027324413880705833,
0.5304834246635437,
0.5961294174194336,
-0.427029550075531,
0.7292618751525879,
-0.15989668667316437,
-0.15640203654766083,
-0.7224269509315491,
0.088275246322155,
0.2965352237224579,
-0.30917224287986755,
-0.46000635623931885,
-0.09324795007705688,
-0.061002217233181,
-0.06711042672395706,
-0.21951079368591309,
0.4073372185230255,
-0.21025432646274567,
0.00047022770741023123,
-0.08590379357337952,
0.26034045219421387,
0.13537941873073578,
0.021386945620179176,
-0.5421083569526672,
0.39789116382598877,
0.33362433314323425,
-0.3957095444202423,
0.454483300447464,
0.3084407150745392,
-0.5041824579238892,
0.5897194147109985,
-0.7382238507270813,
0.4612619876861572,
0.17807717621326447,
0.30840131640434265,
-0.5067744851112366,
-0.3429376482963562,
0.4660642445087433,
-0.39361733198165894,
0.15568429231643677,
-0.10581463575363159,
-0.5030703544616699,
-0.4198318421840668,
-0.5650634765625,
0.06655029952526093,
0.42008277773857117,
-0.032935433089733124,
0.07725837826728821,
0.7266786098480225,
0.06091020256280899,
-0.6908999681472778,
-0.6044058799743652,
0.4113523066043854,
-0.3322906494140625,
-0.8208628296852112,
-0.09526482224464417,
-0.047460366040468216,
-0.29936856031417847,
0.0019092140719294548,
-0.09010373055934906,
-0.03887908533215523,
0.6799373626708984,
0.39233288168907166,
0.09785060584545135,
-0.03897405043244362,
0.036335960030555725,
-0.37310758233070374,
-0.33186808228492737,
0.44815361499786377,
-0.11521867662668228,
0.14724352955818176,
-0.41566652059555054,
-0.5062810182571411,
-0.2206810563802719,
0.34419897198677063,
0.24627673625946045,
-0.2769126296043396,
0.2462916523218155,
0.7582949995994568,
-0.6382235288619995,
0.0657135620713234,
-0.49080896377563477,
-0.2261091023683548,
-0.3492848575115204,
0.31971022486686707,
0.203981414437294,
-0.6297923922538757,
0.4352964460849762,
-0.02522270940244198,
-0.03709917142987251,
0.6422049403190613,
0.2633168697357178,
0.040706366300582886,
0.9114938378334045,
1.0672963857650757,
-0.00200881389901042,
0.13245166838169098,
0.0345974937081337,
0.09051229804754257,
-0.8680709600448608,
-0.15377333760261536,
-0.7237836718559265,
-0.1074112132191658,
-0.6834548711776733,
-0.24112941324710846,
0.48745760321617126,
0.3370615243911743,
0.2594899833202362,
0.241765558719635,
-0.5188096165657043,
0.45931851863861084,
0.2219337821006775,
0.15980486571788788,
0.09370364993810654,
-0.3392261266708374,
-0.212126687169075,
-0.20079118013381958,
-0.4792949855327606,
-0.988705039024353,
1.163432240486145,
0.6042958498001099,
0.8877769708633423,
0.1389855444431305,
0.7063421607017517,
0.7313961386680603,
0.36986681818962097,
-0.5359910726547241,
0.395455002784729,
0.28100770711898804,
-0.6491715908050537,
-0.4532131552696228,
-0.4637981951236725,
-0.8970930576324463,
-0.2775322496891022,
-0.33336347341537476,
-0.8316095471382141,
0.11421315371990204,
0.12118108570575714,
-0.4367198050022125,
0.01012277603149414,
-0.794501781463623,
0.9664158225059509,
-0.37324878573417664,
-0.24845916032791138,
0.13377389311790466,
-0.9034576416015625,
0.44697073101997375,
-0.148310586810112,
0.16175077855587006,
-0.12146805226802826,
0.21273432672023773,
0.8311000466346741,
-0.3099632263183594,
0.8018766045570374,
-0.20594948530197144,
-0.15605592727661133,
0.3486626446247101,
-0.1302308440208435,
0.4699355959892273,
0.14842253923416138,
-0.27856722474098206,
0.18868647515773773,
-0.4110890030860901,
-0.32488125562667847,
-0.4592067301273346,
0.43615761399269104,
-0.41848224401474,
-0.3921734392642975,
-0.5458187460899353,
-0.04905543848872185,
-0.3147839903831482,
0.15393204987049103,
0.2212456911802292,
0.2507304251194,
-0.5197125673294067,
0.13249006867408752,
0.5461394786834717,
-0.24858953058719635,
0.2416490912437439,
0.14053891599178314,
-0.10845338553190231,
-0.5306341052055359,
0.7775564789772034,
-0.08518701791763306,
0.03743717446923256,
-0.2151409089565277,
0.40881872177124023,
-0.2595495879650116,
-0.6111796498298645,
-0.38119855523109436,
-0.08056092262268066,
-0.7730858325958252,
-0.46661317348480225,
-0.24125534296035767,
-0.1774420291185379,
-0.379379540681839,
-0.030882060527801514,
-0.1373811960220337,
-0.12813986837863922,
-0.08337607234716415,
-0.28594863414764404,
0.33553922176361084,
0.7999539375305176,
-0.09287513047456741,
0.021183684468269348,
-0.9901934862136841,
0.1831330507993698,
0.33674538135528564,
0.48936718702316284,
-0.2970813810825348,
-0.3749490976333618,
-0.2914985120296478,
-0.07665405422449112,
-0.5073080658912659,
-1.0031803846359253,
0.20326945185661316,
0.15465103089809418,
0.6923327445983887,
0.42038387060165405,
0.16409572958946228,
0.33776775002479553,
-0.35045531392097473,
0.7755705118179321,
0.09575772285461426,
-0.8597802519798279,
0.7262332439422607,
-0.291231632232666,
0.1796809732913971,
0.8618959188461304,
0.12718400359153748,
-0.5522750020027161,
-0.3743857741355896,
-0.7395426034927368,
-1.1027640104293823,
0.43750107288360596,
0.23328199982643127,
0.18537932634353638,
-0.0870237648487091,
0.4141139090061188,
0.1915014535188675,
0.1502234935760498,
-0.556536853313446,
-0.11288189888000488,
-0.04936462640762329,
0.139699324965477,
0.1672523021697998,
-0.44356614351272583,
-0.5578926205635071,
0.04797573760151863,
0.3834165930747986,
-0.21681779623031616,
0.21285688877105713,
0.10430163145065308,
-0.30214884877204895,
-0.346426397562027,
0.5094395279884338,
0.6960445046424866,
1.100028157234192,
-0.435073584318161,
0.11900220066308975,
0.1517266482114792,
-0.6275537610054016,
0.04686196520924568,
0.10990192741155624,
-0.13457120954990387,
-0.11076454073190689,
0.6304953694343567,
0.6157269477844238,
0.4139755666255951,
-0.6074060201644897,
0.7092707753181458,
-0.4627993702888489,
-0.13037672638893127,
-0.5247933268547058,
0.07163766026496887,
-0.20697642862796783,
-0.02942342683672905,
0.47715914249420166,
0.2276260405778885,
0.14416515827178955,
-0.42794451117515564,
0.4502303898334503,
0.2150866985321045,
-0.5023206472396851,
-0.36431533098220825,
0.6356425881385803,
0.48165929317474365,
-0.5204116106033325,
0.5866463780403137,
-0.3294749855995178,
-0.42889145016670227,
0.41075989603996277,
0.39944273233413696,
1.2755669355392456,
-0.16777625679969788,
0.20984485745429993,
0.24459244310855865,
0.829106330871582,
-0.02886662259697914,
0.3251846432685852,
0.13565966486930847,
-0.38604751229286194,
-0.22409652173519135,
-0.690101683139801,
-0.46815910935401917,
-0.01092222798615694,
-0.8489323258399963,
0.4211369454860687,
-0.4728436768054962,
-0.2923869490623474,
-0.01919221132993698,
0.020747041329741478,
-0.5292796492576599,
0.06582365185022354,
0.3412890136241913,
0.8996477127075195,
-0.9388514161109924,
0.4116716682910919,
0.5461645722389221,
-0.3769606351852417,
-0.4564768671989441,
0.2928604483604431,
0.0316334031522274,
-0.4133875072002411,
0.19460637867450714,
0.1715998500585556,
0.020905639976263046,
-0.3253045380115509,
-0.519334614276886,
-0.27400991320610046,
0.9963944554328918,
0.6240547895431519,
-0.30478328466415405,
-0.03517560660839081,
0.044898729771375656,
0.6424366235733032,
-0.16315530240535736,
0.31026995182037354,
0.6460142731666565,
0.8575337529182434,
-0.31059151887893677,
-0.9925152063369751,
0.02517397701740265,
-0.28203055262565613,
-0.02043767273426056,
0.0970267653465271,
-0.24929317831993103,
0.2217922806739807,
-0.4820554256439209,
-0.19188299775123596,
-0.003959332127124071,
0.3026707172393799,
0.12868070602416992,
0.4200843572616577,
0.6444553732872009,
0.6138921976089478,
0.7949904799461365,
-0.3566488027572632,
1.2737785577774048,
0.06585972011089325,
0.25052210688591003,
1.007427453994751,
-0.19561506807804108,
0.7183842062950134,
0.13505804538726807,
-0.2282397747039795,
0.48780566453933716,
0.4530413746833801,
-0.058265529572963715,
0.24355065822601318,
0.39650288224220276,
-0.25215402245521545,
-0.1000017523765564,
-0.16126547753810883,
-0.2824382185935974,
0.6428021788597107,
0.1625058650970459,
-0.47059735655784607,
-0.3750159740447998,
-0.08315645903348923,
0.14128203690052032,
0.13140830397605896,
-0.06703312695026398,
0.8376117944717407,
-0.08656462281942368,
-0.4204571545124054,
0.36792173981666565,
0.1866321861743927,
0.45071566104888916,
-0.7287583947181702,
-0.2303415685892105,
0.007837425917387009,
-0.042061563581228256,
-0.43292078375816345,
-0.8054842948913574,
0.39647695422172546,
0.3524653911590576,
-0.06930889934301376,
-0.22089196741580963,
0.9713064432144165,
0.029839159920811653,
-0.49453917145729065,
0.13705594837665558,
0.2662237584590912,
0.017766881734132767,
-0.0624338760972023,
-0.6694828867912292,
0.024297768250107765,
-0.22546401619911194,
-0.22137272357940674,
0.33992382884025574,
0.3952238857746124,
-0.2384154200553894,
0.5696514248847961,
0.6534640789031982,
-0.002264957409352064,
0.1337505429983139,
0.14903007447719574,
0.8152192234992981,
-0.7041475772857666,
-0.12447722256183624,
-0.8932397365570068,
0.715241014957428,
-0.17948460578918457,
-0.49828100204467773,
0.7471463680267334,
0.31299111247062683,
0.5803812146186829,
0.24213381111621857,
0.8359004855155945,
-0.04499804601073265,
0.1682092696428299,
-0.3190864622592926,
0.8286239504814148,
-0.0448899045586586,
0.40187156200408936,
-0.4419579803943634,
-0.7941055297851562,
-0.6335794925689697,
0.6171377301216125,
-0.03032396174967289,
0.11558100581169128,
0.5407986640930176,
0.5940924882888794,
0.39542528986930847,
-0.15507502853870392,
0.17794358730316162,
-0.1396416276693344,
0.47295114398002625,
0.2532758414745331,
0.7492160201072693,
-0.5975309014320374,
0.7682446837425232,
-0.2996671795845032,
-0.24336037039756775,
-0.4375426173210144,
-1.3351331949234009,
-0.39324426651000977,
-0.3757131099700928,
-0.3112266957759857,
-0.5829600095748901,
0.14246611297130585,
0.7162283062934875,
0.5439544320106506,
-0.49736151099205017,
-0.05105550214648247,
-0.1644860804080963,
0.33946847915649414,
-0.23064492642879486,
-0.27840402722358704,
0.1660643368959427,
-0.02159876562654972,
-0.11978412419557571,
0.2931217551231384,
0.4081723690032959,
-0.21620307862758636,
-0.8093879818916321,
-0.21809783577919006,
-0.011765475384891033,
-0.2060679793357849,
0.26841819286346436,
0.45305949449539185,
-0.6349795460700989,
-0.6086039543151855,
-0.09848962724208832,
-0.23188449442386627,
-0.14413832128047943,
0.7478616833686829,
-0.6567785143852234,
0.7253965735435486,
0.3004676103591919,
0.6600968837738037,
-0.18442712724208832,
-0.18036651611328125,
0.568225622177124,
-0.9713361859321594,
-0.03403965011239052,
0.6580477952957153,
0.2422136813402176,
0.5315466523170471,
-0.35803449153900146,
0.7662985324859619,
0.007605529855936766,
-0.7553870677947998,
-1.1510708332061768,
0.2160530686378479,
-0.9813650846481323,
0.435599148273468,
1.1519731283187866,
-0.3029441237449646,
-0.3016270399093628,
-0.23927180469036102,
-0.17604973912239075,
0.13082093000411987,
-0.14793458580970764,
0.9839264154434204,
0.6977431178092957,
-0.058324869722127914,
0.003486247966066003,
-0.6307802796363831,
0.4959646463394165,
0.010333659127354622,
-1.0710610151290894,
0.31165656447410583,
0.3736537992954254,
0.05299067869782448,
0.4494152367115021,
0.44955432415008545,
-0.32732146978378296,
0.6318353414535522,
0.004609391093254089,
0.162676140666008,
0.07156112790107727,
-0.11701268702745438,
-0.6452077031135559,
0.08635605126619339,
0.5472971796989441,
0.07278670370578766
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.07933v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.07933v1
|
Large Language Model Unlearning via Embedding-Corrupted Prompts
| 2024-06-12T06:56:20 | 2024-06-12T06:56:20 |
Chris Yuhao Liu, Yaxuan Wang, Jeffrey Flanigan, Yang Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Large language models (LLMs) have advanced to encompass extensive knowledge
across diverse domains. Yet controlling what a large language model should not
know is important for ensuring alignment and thus safe use. However, accurately
and efficiently unlearning knowledge from an LLM remains challenging due to the
potential collateral damage caused by the fuzzy boundary between retention and
forgetting, and the large computational requirements for optimization across
state-of-the-art models with hundreds of billions of parameters. In this work,
we present Embedding-COrrupted (ECO) Prompts, a lightweight unlearning
framework for large language models to address both the challenges of knowledge
entanglement and unlearning efficiency. Instead of relying on the LLM itself to
unlearn, we enforce an unlearned state during inference by employing a prompt
classifier to identify and safeguard prompts to forget. We learn corruptions
added to prompt embeddings via zeroth order optimization toward the unlearning
objective offline and corrupt prompts flagged by the classifier during
inference. We find that these embedding-corrupted prompts not only lead to
desirable outputs that satisfy the unlearning objective but also closely
approximate the output from a model that has never been trained on the data
intended for forgetting. Through extensive experiments on unlearning, we
demonstrate the superiority of our method in achieving promising unlearning at
nearly zero side effects in general domains and domains closely related to the
unlearned ones. Additionally, we highlight the scalability of our method to 100
LLMs, ranging from 0.5B to 236B parameters, incurring no additional cost as the
number of parameters increases.
|
[
-0.0713062584400177,
-0.9976186156272888,
0.7831754088401794,
-0.017317574471235275,
-0.27281615138053894,
0.0755721852183342,
-0.42080995440483093,
0.1283407062292099,
-0.14897316694259644,
0.47838225960731506,
-0.6427057385444641,
-0.30336999893188477,
-0.45381537079811096,
-0.107699453830719,
-0.09969979524612427,
0.845675528049469,
0.14785519242286682,
0.17602747678756714,
-0.572211742401123,
0.10614807903766632,
-0.6105552315711975,
-0.11707151681184769,
-0.6889920830726624,
-0.3131185472011566,
0.34152308106422424,
0.5960959196090698,
0.34817439317703247,
0.4436742961406708,
-0.3453253507614136,
0.3159070312976837,
-0.17218729853630066,
0.37614205479621887,
-0.8528769016265869,
0.31773820519447327,
-0.26404258608818054,
-0.3732829689979553,
0.015834098681807518,
-0.2467377781867981,
0.4712737202644348,
0.7642720341682434,
-0.5248048901557922,
0.0188461747020483,
0.47995978593826294,
0.4591694474220276,
-0.8658390641212463,
0.40622004866600037,
-0.8172286152839661,
0.019419804215431213,
-0.05967533960938454,
-0.2779671847820282,
-0.8368937969207764,
-0.15034382045269012,
-0.04154399409890175,
-0.705262303352356,
-0.034201957285404205,
0.2564208209514618,
0.6003055572509766,
0.5256280303001404,
-0.21678024530410767,
-0.25344496965408325,
-0.4821074306964874,
1.0298587083816528,
-0.5263598561286926,
0.4804832339286804,
0.5366019606590271,
0.058711227029561996,
-0.4147800803184509,
-0.3682544231414795,
-0.28181442618370056,
0.19007588922977448,
0.1547415554523468,
0.20999598503112793,
-0.46645477414131165,
0.03777968883514404,
0.2786068022251129,
-0.10842984914779663,
-0.3242035210132599,
0.5328046679496765,
-0.13702982664108276,
-0.44679635763168335,
0.19477637112140656,
0.17784981429576874,
0.28471702337265015,
-0.00424959696829319,
-0.25063613057136536,
-0.12218007445335388,
-1.1306649446487427,
-0.05590282753109932,
0.47735312581062317,
0.42091408371925354,
0.12432179600000381,
0.384363055229187,
0.0844401866197586,
0.5358297824859619,
0.18216903507709503,
-0.13964401185512543,
0.22314006090164185,
0.3152296841144562,
-0.014114806428551674,
0.17588402330875397,
0.6721894145011902,
0.16769132018089294,
0.2412901371717453,
-0.26707279682159424,
-0.5148537755012512,
-0.3585631251335144,
0.05701166391372681,
-0.6639851927757263,
-0.01789083145558834,
0.32933491468429565,
-0.17012926936149597,
-0.04293832182884216,
-0.19786131381988525,
-0.9589954018592834,
-0.7065431475639343,
-0.18468178808689117,
0.7472186088562012,
-0.5909819602966309,
0.03423728793859482,
0.09007778018712997,
-0.07064827531576157,
-0.0004339331644587219,
0.5608218908309937,
-0.8565340638160706,
-0.19056858122348785,
0.5571814179420471,
0.6271565556526184,
0.3741845190525055,
-0.24562664330005646,
-0.8473821878433228,
-0.018298713490366936,
-0.21820245683193207,
0.5329727530479431,
-0.6848136186599731,
-0.30288469791412354,
0.2774100601673126,
0.03709501773118973,
-0.03625164180994034,
-0.5403159260749817,
0.5072157382965088,
-0.6466202735900879,
0.10745147615671158,
-0.3367249071598053,
-0.9027349352836609,
-0.3141406178474426,
0.07556063681840897,
-0.5250915884971619,
0.664128303527832,
-0.06895942240953445,
-0.5673691630363464,
0.2809670567512512,
-0.056734684854745865,
-0.07543741166591644,
0.06297589093446732,
0.02265780046582222,
-0.5859892964363098,
0.13672949373722076,
0.21331605315208435,
0.6340029239654541,
-0.3398919999599457,
0.6218950152397156,
-0.6005973219871521,
-0.41328707337379456,
0.038598719984292984,
-0.7368432283401489,
0.8937819004058838,
0.11272110790014267,
-0.1859607696533203,
-0.10542549192905426,
-0.5641983151435852,
-0.10665076971054077,
0.2092164158821106,
-0.2269691377878189,
-0.5199286341667175,
0.04485909640789032,
-0.3365282416343689,
0.050546687096357346,
0.2818945050239563,
-0.7545626163482666,
0.11519334465265274,
-0.1607348620891571,
0.5943892002105713,
1.0147150754928589,
0.15159809589385986,
0.40646636486053467,
-0.28141817450523376,
0.2711036503314972,
0.30897057056427,
-0.10233756899833679,
-0.5996358394622803,
-0.38048428297042847,
-0.7245363593101501,
-0.27985286712646484,
0.18565411865711212,
0.5388646721839905,
-0.7852361798286438,
0.6036133170127869,
-0.02231881394982338,
-0.4747310280799866,
-0.6985487341880798,
0.3228035271167755,
0.4854111969470978,
0.5936394929885864,
0.4466976821422577,
0.27698081731796265,
-0.3209596872329712,
-0.47336816787719727,
-0.3584703803062439,
0.06262007355690002,
0.001399713451974094,
0.282355934381485,
0.5665848255157471,
-0.325100302696228,
0.6780257225036621,
-0.40089449286460876,
-0.312345415353775,
-0.0999172031879425,
0.038334812968969345,
0.07767383754253387,
0.4767448306083679,
0.09430239349603653,
-0.2765600383281708,
-0.1993211954832077,
-0.2600318193435669,
-0.665479302406311,
-0.10946118831634521,
-0.3848794996738434,
0.1016518846154213,
0.31210291385650635,
0.6920042634010315,
-0.5585775375366211,
0.12785375118255615,
0.3359268009662628,
-0.4543573260307312,
0.5670765042304993,
-0.49550774693489075,
-0.2693065106868744,
-0.8611695766448975,
-0.17127543687820435,
-0.2986038625240326,
-0.194749116897583,
-0.3656483590602875,
-0.25785157084465027,
0.25312480330467224,
-0.2119542807340622,
-0.3697010576725006,
0.5962635278701782,
-0.7234238982200623,
0.30232205986976624,
0.02637023851275444,
0.3437671959400177,
0.08560570329427719,
0.7036203742027283,
-0.1001446321606636,
0.5397589206695557,
0.7539865970611572,
-0.5382832288742065,
0.13427472114562988,
0.3659523129463196,
-0.3033817708492279,
0.34703144431114197,
-0.5411790609359741,
0.185422882437706,
-0.4562387466430664,
0.08330398797988892,
-0.703732967376709,
-0.050472334027290344,
-0.0012005985481664538,
-0.2731841802597046,
0.697813868522644,
-0.2848591208457947,
-0.5779305696487427,
0.008034233003854752,
-0.3495143949985504,
0.3319333791732788,
0.8399237394332886,
-0.9780168533325195,
0.5791625380516052,
0.24576392769813538,
-0.0730057805776596,
-0.7451378107070923,
-0.47924843430519104,
-0.15403570234775543,
-0.3166063129901886,
-0.3477107584476471,
0.00475347600877285,
0.05044209584593773,
0.0028539279010146856,
0.17480547726154327,
0.04600334167480469,
0.22815513610839844,
0.07892076671123505,
0.3680708110332489,
0.0689188614487648,
-0.11215522140264511,
0.3676648437976837,
0.34986984729766846,
-0.1928727626800537,
0.2676921486854553,
-0.5529289841651917,
0.5571458339691162,
0.011699569411575794,
-0.620427668094635,
-0.19495521485805511,
0.27235421538352966,
0.6142740249633789,
-0.2682610750198364,
1.0343589782714844,
0.29680660367012024,
-0.5496857166290283,
-0.7467288970947266,
-0.5335472822189331,
-0.1303904503583908,
-0.5213099718093872,
0.38399943709373474,
0.0030512181110680103,
-1.054668664932251,
0.6677781939506531,
-0.34241384267807007,
0.10079897195100784,
0.17831707000732422,
0.3247703015804291,
-0.0023806942626833916,
1.022560477256775,
0.5784898996353149,
-0.0077111972495913506,
0.338897705078125,
-0.15054766833782196,
0.25440946221351624,
-0.7790881395339966,
-0.5080417990684509,
-0.36089831590652466,
-0.0241901446133852,
-0.36864781379699707,
-0.47149011492729187,
0.3191881477832794,
0.536254346370697,
-0.7828445434570312,
-0.15437325835227966,
-0.03670592978596687,
0.6377238631248474,
0.525452196598053,
0.327869713306427,
0.18991884589195251,
0.0012253833701834083,
-0.43751317262649536,
-0.04635807126760483,
-0.7756341695785522,
-0.42042914032936096,
0.9174689054489136,
0.2997385859489441,
1.0001457929611206,
0.02262098342180252,
0.8744754791259766,
0.06473060697317123,
0.05215412378311157,
-0.7981898188591003,
0.28471139073371887,
-0.03603864088654518,
-0.1467602252960205,
-0.3885791301727295,
-0.5377358198165894,
-0.9311124086380005,
0.15022091567516327,
-0.25405359268188477,
-0.97855544090271,
0.3073400557041168,
0.4375346302986145,
-0.5325547456741333,
0.7876763939857483,
-0.648551881313324,
0.9160553812980652,
-0.1240481436252594,
-0.409612238407135,
-0.08774557709693909,
-0.32183197140693665,
0.2517186403274536,
-0.44603484869003296,
0.1615534871816635,
0.03568177670240402,
-0.09462396800518036,
0.6241787672042847,
-0.5859723687171936,
1.2187055349349976,
-0.3489604592323303,
-0.21045762300491333,
0.3712354004383087,
0.23962539434432983,
0.8558719158172607,
0.13414409756660461,
-0.04439869895577431,
0.11128371953964233,
-0.38558968901634216,
-0.38208872079849243,
-0.6998634934425354,
0.5728736519813538,
-0.7584864497184753,
-0.6570191979408264,
-0.2147291600704193,
-0.4189949035644531,
-0.39557892084121704,
0.3101644814014435,
0.42752301692962646,
0.6811917424201965,
-0.1460132896900177,
0.012681429274380207,
1.087735891342163,
-0.7313517332077026,
0.5070788860321045,
0.5979143977165222,
-0.06013673543930054,
-0.2868477404117584,
1.275227665901184,
0.035702306777238846,
0.3661506175994873,
0.39679646492004395,
0.2403765171766281,
-0.37595686316490173,
-0.45923852920532227,
-0.5600417852401733,
0.35593414306640625,
-0.8500762581825256,
-0.6457428932189941,
-0.613595724105835,
0.04530862346291542,
-0.21062174439430237,
-0.3255769908428192,
-0.4086534380912781,
-0.032504163682460785,
-0.5541631579399109,
-0.1188872754573822,
0.40028753876686096,
0.823199450969696,
-0.2046976536512375,
0.09160047769546509,
-1.067884922027588,
-0.2846866548061371,
0.0684065967798233,
0.3523869812488556,
0.4913189113140106,
-0.7101198434829712,
-0.09599056094884872,
0.26936057209968567,
-0.28705254197120667,
-0.8082730770111084,
0.4973164498806,
0.27050626277923584,
0.5948789119720459,
1.0411853790283203,
0.35623979568481445,
0.7197554707527161,
-0.6758566498756409,
0.571156919002533,
0.20498470962047577,
-1.1048442125320435,
0.375486820936203,
-0.45176461338996887,
0.11967248469591141,
0.39685916900634766,
0.40061843395233154,
-0.6104937791824341,
-0.46219033002853394,
-0.6470931172370911,
-0.975716233253479,
0.675537645816803,
-0.4992505609989166,
0.11204740405082703,
-0.19060049951076508,
0.26650458574295044,
0.25034788250923157,
0.24184541404247284,
-0.33624356985092163,
-0.29350948333740234,
-0.04911695048213005,
-0.2338883876800537,
-0.21099065244197845,
-0.4786621332168579,
0.09057886153459549,
-0.08923795819282532,
0.8597400188446045,
-0.10164804756641388,
0.20426025986671448,
-0.05303885042667389,
-0.5112473368644714,
-0.2851186692714691,
0.40935787558555603,
0.21705469489097595,
0.314729243516922,
0.1067345142364502,
0.18507906794548035,
0.4158388376235962,
-0.2300044745206833,
0.1734440177679062,
-0.15763546526432037,
-0.3926854431629181,
-0.3721192479133606,
0.47722187638282776,
0.7607895731925964,
0.55262690782547,
-0.975123405456543,
0.6028154492378235,
0.18900831043720245,
0.12478489428758621,
-0.3519202768802643,
-0.04229496419429779,
0.16497160494327545,
0.0720188319683075,
0.15472368896007538,
0.07341020554304123,
-0.14142245054244995,
-0.52951580286026,
0.30116763710975647,
0.46954864263534546,
-0.5011127591133118,
-0.28937384486198425,
0.5530310273170471,
0.20421960949897766,
-0.020952455699443817,
1.106581687927246,
-0.619945764541626,
-0.7497148513793945,
0.3392219543457031,
0.9173332452774048,
0.7106159925460815,
-0.2252424657344818,
0.3059704303741455,
0.39066100120544434,
0.2716600298881531,
-0.2880213260650635,
0.1816592812538147,
0.06671606004238129,
-0.8674574494361877,
-0.35687652230262756,
-0.6285442113876343,
-0.22738824784755707,
0.2009020894765854,
-0.7176748514175415,
0.0749707818031311,
-0.43407031893730164,
0.3021050989627838,
-0.4704052209854126,
-0.06429746001958847,
-0.56584233045578,
-0.23099364340305328,
-0.006007193122059107,
0.7767735719680786,
-0.9576901793479919,
0.3873457610607147,
0.5508836507797241,
-0.3224208950996399,
-0.8249346017837524,
-0.25816425681114197,
0.4295419156551361,
-1.0122088193893433,
0.29127541184425354,
0.2875714600086212,
0.028225697576999664,
0.14427916705608368,
-0.5990695953369141,
-0.8453359007835388,
0.9932049512863159,
0.6053860187530518,
-0.8253815174102783,
0.27574077248573303,
-0.06067147105932236,
0.1642933487892151,
-0.14062602818012238,
0.28947940468788147,
0.4404534101486206,
0.38025110960006714,
-0.10468029230833054,
-0.4509442448616028,
0.40943703055381775,
0.00966548640280962,
-0.47040510177612305,
0.5612594485282898,
-0.6399118304252625,
0.9319654703140259,
-0.8082354068756104,
-0.44187021255493164,
0.03982754796743393,
0.4475336968898773,
0.22065792977809906,
0.16488057374954224,
0.5852544903755188,
0.8608458042144775,
1.2953304052352905,
-0.18246681988239288,
0.6346685886383057,
-0.00521980132907629,
0.4104004204273224,
0.9543969035148621,
-0.1252681165933609,
0.7132424116134644,
0.35777747631073,
0.1964404284954071,
0.3102550208568573,
0.5823040008544922,
-0.11502761393785477,
0.4717329740524292,
0.17378082871437073,
-0.22843874990940094,
-0.6586689352989197,
-0.17958354949951172,
0.0862678736448288,
0.28691384196281433,
0.5564799308776855,
-0.02909725531935692,
-0.5213441848754883,
0.24213863909244537,
0.30365434288978577,
0.06374482810497284,
-0.41992050409317017,
0.7395275235176086,
0.26350951194763184,
-0.5169414281845093,
0.5156482458114624,
-0.18476291000843048,
0.6853843331336975,
-0.4564136266708374,
-0.2361472249031067,
-0.0785340666770935,
0.4157355725765228,
-0.12340150028467178,
-0.5261910557746887,
-0.1278223693370819,
-0.01571980118751526,
-0.07152851670980453,
-0.3723286986351013,
0.5082371830940247,
-0.9035796523094177,
-0.18855591118335724,
0.43982309103012085,
0.6315649747848511,
0.1379762589931488,
-0.12229922413825989,
-0.5900203585624695,
-0.1256045550107956,
0.07834593206644058,
-0.26831281185150146,
0.45536449551582336,
0.7523508667945862,
-0.054539501667022705,
0.9552991986274719,
0.5616679787635803,
0.006697905249893665,
-0.11295247077941895,
0.09345230460166931,
0.7800546288490295,
-0.6153851747512817,
-0.4493735730648041,
-0.8243695497512817,
0.49409419298171997,
0.1641494631767273,
-0.28838834166526794,
0.7942388653755188,
0.38621336221694946,
0.8156755566596985,
0.04786950722336769,
0.6327477693557739,
0.25544917583465576,
0.1936044991016388,
-0.7990490198135376,
0.9176633358001709,
-0.668793261051178,
0.46447721123695374,
-0.07882821559906006,
-0.6952196359634399,
-0.0699765607714653,
0.3757000267505646,
-0.05532025918364525,
0.2447706162929535,
0.592998206615448,
0.784835159778595,
0.10547345131635666,
0.11420696973800659,
0.5198814868927002,
0.38312503695487976,
0.15996578335762024,
0.7057204246520996,
0.998232901096344,
0.026981428265571594,
0.33174872398376465,
-0.22482819855213165,
-0.20041458308696747,
-0.08520384132862091,
-0.9070708155632019,
-0.9572667479515076,
-0.599385142326355,
-0.18856096267700195,
-0.35262951254844666,
0.1846773326396942,
1.0595420598983765,
0.14699162542819977,
-0.796392023563385,
0.25192975997924805,
0.03904528543353081,
0.36134976148605347,
-0.1270645558834076,
-0.17714232206344604,
0.49569594860076904,
-0.7273925542831421,
-0.6491044163703918,
0.46519482135772705,
0.13026082515716553,
0.09604828804731369,
-0.32091569900512695,
-0.10877449065446854,
0.1447116583585739,
0.02765556424856186,
0.4302135109901428,
0.3206002116203308,
-0.5102167129516602,
-0.36527019739151,
-0.03845791146159172,
0.3207634687423706,
-0.3802465498447418,
0.7987703084945679,
-0.763310432434082,
0.3726615905761719,
0.3439449369907379,
0.8572784066200256,
-0.06344830244779587,
-0.08803044259548187,
0.5999858379364014,
-0.9465893507003784,
-0.08885768055915833,
0.2576853930950165,
0.9154130816459656,
0.41574952006340027,
-0.5399672389030457,
-0.0998087003827095,
0.09632986783981323,
-0.621178925037384,
-1.0439562797546387,
0.05683709681034088,
-0.5419723391532898,
-0.45916444063186646,
1.1324660778045654,
-0.40482908487319946,
-0.37395837903022766,
-0.26745811104774475,
0.13786323368549347,
0.2505110502243042,
-0.7298948168754578,
0.533151388168335,
0.5098043084144592,
0.2060384303331375,
0.02581428550183773,
-0.25628888607025146,
0.4466550052165985,
0.4248769283294678,
-0.4625658392906189,
0.5915237069129944,
0.6768735647201538,
0.35097166895866394,
0.10300099104642868,
0.14297521114349365,
-0.11205405741930008,
0.14085650444030762,
0.19774670898914337,
0.02773878537118435,
-0.4537941515445709,
-0.5411891341209412,
-0.7750266194343567,
-0.08781217038631439,
-0.07537304610013962,
0.17760062217712402
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.07922v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.07922v1
|
Automated Information Extraction from Thyroid Operation Narrative: A Comparative Study of GPT-4 and Fine-tuned KoELECTRA
| 2024-06-12T06:44:05 | 2024-06-12T06:44:05 |
Dongsuk Jang, Hyeryun Park, Jiye Son, Hyeonuk Hwang, Sujin Kim, Jinwook Choi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In the rapidly evolving field of healthcare, the integration of artificial
intelligence (AI) has become a pivotal component in the automation of clinical
workflows, ushering in a new era of efficiency and accuracy. This study focuses
on the transformative capabilities of the fine-tuned KoELECTRA model in
comparison to the GPT-4 model, aiming to facilitate automated information
extraction from thyroid operation narratives. The current research landscape is
dominated by traditional methods heavily reliant on regular expressions, which
often face challenges in processing free-style text formats containing critical
details of operation records, including frozen biopsy reports. Addressing this,
the study leverages advanced natural language processing (NLP) techniques to
foster a paradigm shift towards more sophisticated data processing systems.
Through this comparative study, we aspire to unveil a more streamlined,
precise, and efficient approach to document processing in the healthcare
domain, potentially revolutionizing the way medical data is handled and
analyzed.
|
[
-0.1131933331489563,
-0.8370805978775024,
1.032787799835205,
-0.3422256410121918,
-0.4589311480522156,
0.3637707829475403,
-0.1319270133972168,
-0.9380630254745483,
0.0853724256157875,
0.47603902220726013,
-0.6356940865516663,
-0.429226815700531,
-0.6717106699943542,
0.45463085174560547,
-0.352993905544281,
0.9105717539787292,
-0.13120019435882568,
0.2607479989528656,
0.016388876363635063,
0.1062670648097992,
-0.35076168179512024,
-0.3636821210384369,
-0.5795881152153015,
-0.5713919401168823,
0.4665814936161041,
0.2851272225379944,
0.9456972479820251,
1.0192539691925049,
0.749250590801239,
0.37889114022254944,
0.4252485930919647,
0.02443898841738701,
-0.0055721234530210495,
0.09124927967786789,
-0.1663568913936615,
-0.2380899339914322,
-0.3686404228210449,
0.05854561924934387,
0.5206664204597473,
0.5151665806770325,
-0.08118101954460144,
0.15715761482715607,
-0.16567087173461914,
0.6755600571632385,
-0.06853923201560974,
0.33202144503593445,
-0.524768590927124,
0.09695947170257568,
-0.09220832586288452,
-0.36434733867645264,
-0.09809757024049759,
-0.7962673902511597,
0.3376707136631012,
-0.8109216690063477,
0.29353609681129456,
-0.1580817699432373,
0.96817946434021,
0.27389082312583923,
-0.23235826194286346,
-0.41229018568992615,
-0.8272364735603333,
0.6012660264968872,
-0.7234006524085999,
0.5916250944137573,
0.299291729927063,
0.25725018978118896,
0.0587390698492527,
-1.2574598789215088,
-0.42135146260261536,
0.17986398935317993,
-0.03780417889356613,
0.24837061762809753,
-0.46822959184646606,
0.09228375554084778,
0.09426537156105042,
0.4794328510761261,
-0.5247846245765686,
0.2462473213672638,
-0.5806527733802795,
-0.26125118136405945,
0.5399053692817688,
0.18241658806800842,
0.4709952175617218,
-0.24064409732818604,
-0.010633389465510845,
-0.13800981640815735,
-0.17163272202014923,
-0.2705203592777252,
0.12017273157835007,
0.14560666680335999,
0.016741907224059105,
0.4499170780181885,
-0.6667363047599792,
0.4265478253364563,
0.23921585083007812,
-0.23935511708259583,
0.43370527029037476,
-0.24717308580875397,
-0.546302318572998,
0.18605969846248627,
0.8966013789176941,
0.4008219838142395,
0.04775337502360344,
-0.5925545692443848,
0.230002298951149,
0.30794620513916016,
0.5502705574035645,
-0.7091436982154846,
-0.3462749123573303,
0.3837423026561737,
-0.6221733093261719,
-0.4053027033805847,
-0.08522038906812668,
-1.0985435247421265,
-0.1770171821117401,
-0.4676673710346222,
0.2653675079345703,
-0.6643528342247009,
-0.09738126397132874,
0.16114255785942078,
-0.12857073545455933,
0.1893949657678604,
0.549091637134552,
-0.8603641986846924,
0.5204373002052307,
0.7178454399108887,
0.8894743323326111,
-0.4174221158027649,
0.18649761378765106,
-0.39549168944358826,
0.09413350373506546,
-0.2245519757270813,
0.8387428522109985,
-0.536570131778717,
-0.2559899389743805,
-0.19692498445510864,
0.1806117594242096,
-0.441763699054718,
-0.637380063533783,
0.7763202786445618,
-0.5070043206214905,
0.23916813731193542,
-0.07191482931375504,
-0.5540218949317932,
-0.413237601518631,
0.1048726812005043,
-0.8505285382270813,
0.5919834971427917,
0.611614465713501,
-0.37166255712509155,
0.3240610361099243,
-0.7341086864471436,
-0.5310399532318115,
0.36786529421806335,
-0.37513354420661926,
-0.5521859526634216,
0.1406610906124115,
0.18802577257156372,
0.30165085196495056,
-0.5761420726776123,
0.23757727444171906,
-0.026773033663630486,
0.20122361183166504,
0.05114942044019699,
-0.16826573014259338,
0.5469065308570862,
0.3766074478626251,
-0.3702440857887268,
0.16340488195419312,
-0.74530029296875,
0.46508732438087463,
0.09728840738534927,
-0.2702665627002716,
-0.11725153774023056,
-0.31907814741134644,
-0.08481310307979584,
0.28334131836891174,
0.25717687606811523,
-0.600879430770874,
0.3124215006828308,
-0.530958890914917,
0.6577550172805786,
0.3479715883731842,
0.14226876199245453,
0.4125809669494629,
-0.4057976007461548,
0.5422397255897522,
-0.4425891637802124,
0.3696039915084839,
0.1581348329782486,
-0.6735988855361938,
0.020428815856575966,
-0.27619361877441406,
0.5724588632583618,
0.7624238729476929,
-0.6356721520423889,
0.13431090116500854,
-0.11655250191688538,
-0.5599047541618347,
-0.8129801154136658,
0.11301065981388092,
0.30408260226249695,
1.1517503261566162,
0.45237186551094055,
-0.3231273293495178,
-0.5770494937896729,
-1.0735636949539185,
-0.26843151450157166,
0.00855821743607521,
-0.1692126989364624,
0.12799124419689178,
0.12931670248508453,
-0.3465411961078644,
0.7719584703445435,
-0.5497741103172302,
-0.11238270252943039,
-0.5026820302009583,
0.35912641882896423,
0.3199375569820404,
0.7105463743209839,
0.2738761305809021,
-0.8827316164970398,
-0.5510541200637817,
0.5128932595252991,
-1.079885482788086,
-0.16829104721546173,
0.007162813562899828,
-0.026790816336870193,
0.259210467338562,
0.29301077127456665,
-0.988707423210144,
0.6049784421920776,
0.28753575682640076,
-0.1484111249446869,
0.5904419422149658,
-0.20548123121261597,
0.6013433933258057,
-0.8727527856826782,
0.24553422629833221,
-0.187862366437912,
-0.4377609193325043,
-0.8351756930351257,
0.09028216451406479,
0.38453540205955505,
0.12442265450954437,
-0.14341875910758972,
0.10531444102525711,
-0.3277386426925659,
-0.08033578097820282,
0.00184116221498698,
-0.40408462285995483,
0.10880229622125626,
0.26117444038391113,
0.1787109225988388,
0.5163205862045288,
0.13022272288799286,
-0.390641987323761,
0.2684427797794342,
0.36207351088523865,
-0.10010155290365219,
0.568534255027771,
-0.5490091443061829,
0.23746369779109955,
0.3701494038105011,
-0.06689804047346115,
-0.5177136063575745,
-0.7970849871635437,
0.2683441638946533,
-0.5648197531700134,
0.45636415481567383,
-0.09326822310686111,
-0.9047250151634216,
-0.3262239098548889,
-0.22481761872768402,
0.08346705883741379,
0.8761159181594849,
-0.018268980085849762,
0.7091585397720337,
0.32544800639152527,
-0.7869314551353455,
0.172279492020607,
-0.35217228531837463,
0.16303573548793793,
-0.3870355188846588,
-0.4337993860244751,
0.4905434548854828,
-0.022899052128195763,
-0.24851460754871368,
-0.11202459782361984,
-0.3432863652706146,
-0.43433985114097595,
0.1441844403743744,
-0.07540950179100037,
0.4281495213508606,
-0.29425328969955444,
-0.04830263555049896,
0.38103753328323364,
-0.170032799243927,
0.08580045402050018,
-0.1575312614440918,
0.5931669473648071,
-0.0005400829249992967,
-0.058723174035549164,
-1.166115641593933,
0.4964354336261749,
0.7232493162155151,
0.11369980871677399,
0.40588417649269104,
0.5889299511909485,
-0.6139998435974121,
0.710943877696991,
-0.6830893158912659,
-0.24477531015872955,
-0.3884483277797699,
0.07986579090356827,
0.05214297026395798,
-0.5677666068077087,
0.549186646938324,
-0.4001079797744751,
0.026491498574614525,
1.1226966381072998,
0.41833555698394775,
-0.2978930175304413,
1.3912073373794556,
0.5142703056335449,
0.18635033071041107,
0.21506184339523315,
0.012710059061646461,
0.004857917316257954,
-0.7770658731460571,
-0.21169503033161163,
-0.690168023109436,
-0.10396254062652588,
-0.5265801548957825,
0.0532325841486454,
0.6026469469070435,
-0.017977075651288033,
-0.00493374839425087,
0.05785368010401726,
-0.7162531018257141,
0.13907410204410553,
0.429795503616333,
0.2609698474407196,
0.5275130271911621,
-0.037683308124542236,
-0.08903463184833527,
-0.07278740406036377,
-0.666020393371582,
-0.5662011504173279,
1.1869895458221436,
0.28388547897338867,
0.36575186252593994,
-0.06158565357327461,
0.6936922073364258,
0.2579638957977295,
0.15500354766845703,
-0.5061537027359009,
0.07054255157709122,
-0.1584584265947342,
-0.3257124125957489,
-0.3201042115688324,
-0.31573253870010376,
-1.1224565505981445,
-0.0665045902132988,
-0.18063420057296753,
-1.0610891580581665,
0.040860697627067566,
-0.0815654993057251,
-0.8192332983016968,
0.29858988523483276,
-1.102028727531433,
0.7193728089332581,
-0.14167891442775726,
-0.24928316473960876,
0.04921616613864899,
-0.9384044408798218,
0.02766706980764866,
-0.48337939381599426,
0.2305157631635666,
0.17746034264564514,
0.031877122819423676,
0.6708014607429504,
-0.5987406969070435,
0.6372925639152527,
0.11840525269508362,
0.09770979732275009,
-0.1512487381696701,
-0.017324548214673996,
0.4161801338195801,
0.14032186567783356,
-0.1295815408229828,
0.30426478385925293,
0.3405073285102844,
-0.005939655937254429,
-0.5104113221168518,
0.5415723323822021,
-0.6765578389167786,
-0.1372583508491516,
-0.48542332649230957,
-0.6613847017288208,
-0.29670479893684387,
0.5988625288009644,
0.418037086725235,
0.4840814173221588,
-0.01339627057313919,
-0.053679127246141434,
0.6406030058860779,
-0.03496759012341499,
0.4045344889163971,
0.3849491775035858,
0.2385556548833847,
-0.5571008920669556,
0.5473074913024902,
0.18092189729213715,
0.17150186002254486,
0.317901611328125,
0.3463871479034424,
-0.3503981828689575,
-0.7474366426467896,
-0.6399685144424438,
0.14908331632614136,
-0.4405481219291687,
-0.41643577814102173,
-0.9110572934150696,
-0.25770503282546997,
-0.6254680752754211,
-0.322360098361969,
-0.40898874402046204,
-0.4606260061264038,
-0.5148465037345886,
-0.028534507378935814,
0.39196255803108215,
0.7773354649543762,
-0.057704322040081024,
0.4076359272003174,
-1.0675965547561646,
0.6487461924552917,
0.09698501974344254,
0.41773346066474915,
-0.33287400007247925,
0.06562118232250214,
-0.14748838543891907,
-0.2485673576593399,
-0.3616687059402466,
-1.1257010698318481,
0.6942087411880493,
0.1012175977230072,
0.5254109501838684,
0.24579599499702454,
-0.07537194341421127,
0.7742502093315125,
-0.5468376874923706,
0.6300860047340393,
0.3104957640171051,
-0.6519913077354431,
0.5493700504302979,
-0.45097336173057556,
0.6933550834655762,
0.803207278251648,
0.2796497344970703,
-0.21018457412719727,
-0.4144829511642456,
-1.1885290145874023,
-0.7959827184677124,
0.7146772146224976,
0.3330193758010864,
-0.42071089148521423,
0.1593482792377472,
0.5557025074958801,
0.6254251599311829,
0.5208513140678406,
-0.2267736941576004,
0.13238590955734253,
-0.06530104577541351,
-0.6242656111717224,
0.0005629903171211481,
0.16636452078819275,
-0.20829683542251587,
-0.4835488796234131,
0.3837559223175049,
-0.18806694447994232,
0.4865875244140625,
0.7099792957305908,
-0.2362285554409027,
-0.2913725972175598,
0.3418062925338745,
0.43019160628318787,
0.8241350054740906,
-0.25506702065467834,
-0.05156920850276947,
0.03204585611820221,
-0.9113593101501465,
-0.4628235101699829,
0.527021050453186,
-0.12483130395412445,
0.09721428900957108,
0.4272042214870453,
0.25179827213287354,
0.13311102986335754,
-0.5274689793586731,
-0.11526592820882797,
-0.2826067805290222,
-0.487983375787735,
-0.2108571082353592,
-0.08283789455890656,
-0.1538262963294983,
0.3735366463661194,
0.4927730858325958,
0.133446604013443,
0.6627873778343201,
-0.5009354948997498,
0.2927358150482178,
0.19533556699752808,
-0.23458001017570496,
-0.5094842314720154,
0.5984009504318237,
-0.11620905995368958,
-0.3536643087863922,
0.6758393049240112,
-0.013582602143287659,
-0.4552145302295685,
0.5457398295402527,
0.5744613409042358,
0.9129896759986877,
-0.5208644270896912,
0.193752259016037,
0.34215620160102844,
0.21618957817554474,
-0.09218832850456238,
0.48150700330734253,
0.023807210847735405,
-0.23552440106868744,
-0.37820684909820557,
-0.5100623369216919,
-0.31825459003448486,
0.31970563530921936,
-0.940971851348877,
-0.10515706241130829,
-0.580047607421875,
-0.14117781817913055,
0.4357748031616211,
0.05419204756617546,
-0.9046606421470642,
0.40866219997406006,
-0.1581081748008728,
0.5799243450164795,
-0.5465090274810791,
0.6739485859870911,
0.4743485748767853,
-0.21961358189582825,
-0.8424659371376038,
-0.18937921524047852,
0.1328134387731552,
-0.6975263357162476,
0.2085639089345932,
0.08189716190099716,
0.0678420141339302,
0.24399586021900177,
-0.4048483967781067,
-0.7327148914337158,
1.0012669563293457,
0.3007141053676605,
-0.652957558631897,
-0.27184394001960754,
0.08070753514766693,
0.7178197503089905,
-0.3301388919353485,
0.06163102388381958,
1.0443507432937622,
0.528954267501831,
-0.15537577867507935,
-1.3878965377807617,
0.05206625536084175,
-0.09032650291919708,
-0.5900892019271851,
0.43263083696365356,
-0.17704512178897858,
0.7208214402198792,
0.09755634516477585,
-0.20984147489070892,
0.142694890499115,
0.041035301983356476,
-0.3007041811943054,
0.7214851975440979,
0.3385591506958008,
0.5619879961013794,
0.9500979781150818,
-0.17607325315475464,
1.386443018913269,
-0.18012243509292603,
0.04410994052886963,
0.836421549320221,
-0.20723114907741547,
0.5548855662345886,
0.4674951136112213,
-0.13265088200569153,
0.5879173874855042,
0.7231422662734985,
0.1754010170698166,
0.544490396976471,
-0.43715476989746094,
-0.08917584270238876,
-0.09246759116649628,
0.23890219628810883,
-0.38117146492004395,
0.46881213784217834,
0.4478724002838135,
-0.5825085043907166,
-0.1680481731891632,
-0.07975868880748749,
0.28166183829307556,
-0.15177583694458008,
-0.5027055740356445,
1.4025509357452393,
-0.18250493705272675,
-0.8226465582847595,
0.3435647487640381,
-0.16919755935668945,
0.1379953920841217,
-0.7916106581687927,
-0.19647954404354095,
0.323653906583786,
-0.0929383859038353,
-0.47259074449539185,
-0.5125348567962646,
0.5449562668800354,
0.09622769802808762,
-0.2671997547149658,
-0.19835761189460754,
0.911297619342804,
0.0530996136367321,
-0.4764585793018341,
-0.12693969905376434,
0.6458532810211182,
0.07664825767278671,
-0.019987843930721283,
-0.7620915174484253,
0.17112484574317932,
0.12794944643974304,
-0.0025491840206086636,
0.31557440757751465,
0.19451391696929932,
-0.17465727031230927,
0.2633824646472931,
0.8992001414299011,
0.28734955191612244,
-0.1556139588356018,
-0.04626474902033806,
0.9635282158851624,
-0.7089666128158569,
-0.797232985496521,
-0.8757085800170898,
0.31823495030403137,
-0.4950796663761139,
-0.1949523240327835,
0.4687015116214752,
0.6130695939064026,
0.4485386312007904,
-0.09437497705221176,
1.042128086090088,
-0.11333103477954865,
0.8811308145523071,
-0.7178085446357727,
0.6923496723175049,
-0.21729791164398193,
0.014520854689180851,
-0.5363520979881287,
-0.4262940287590027,
-0.4112315773963928,
0.5099281668663025,
-0.270894318819046,
-0.18511076271533966,
1.0527082681655884,
0.06517049670219421,
-0.10333607345819473,
0.3337778151035309,
-0.004492835141718388,
0.3368951082229614,
0.21662537753582,
0.18922875821590424,
0.2900063395500183,
-0.32509124279022217,
0.18897108733654022,
-0.3659766912460327,
-0.39647138118743896,
-0.17544469237327576,
-0.7247558236122131,
-0.38972538709640503,
-0.560319185256958,
-0.4477858245372772,
-0.14759179949760437,
0.12724025547504425,
0.6414141058921814,
0.5936467051506042,
-0.6075756549835205,
0.25622737407684326,
-0.11348864436149597,
0.059973180294036865,
-0.5367006063461304,
-0.18566608428955078,
0.4777606427669525,
-0.28496864438056946,
-0.6570257544517517,
0.5185232758522034,
0.5237761735916138,
-0.03604505583643913,
0.22368860244750977,
0.1826322227716446,
-0.03448869660496712,
-0.07477626204490662,
0.45423901081085205,
0.631411075592041,
-0.5904509425163269,
-0.18111686408519745,
0.05735616385936737,
0.07375811785459518,
0.37803301215171814,
0.6029754281044006,
-0.7514094114303589,
0.7077773809432983,
0.20942750573158264,
0.7366578578948975,
0.3983519673347473,
0.11284530907869339,
0.8251520395278931,
-0.19261935353279114,
-0.38539716601371765,
0.40546947717666626,
0.029363341629505157,
0.24253404140472412,
-0.6864691972732544,
0.5890846252441406,
0.3512705862522125,
-0.6563541293144226,
-0.848540186882019,
-0.002031165873631835,
-1.289100170135498,
-0.17858028411865234,
0.9292700290679932,
0.18286700546741486,
-0.21109703183174133,
-0.5602942109107971,
-0.36933910846710205,
0.5954231023788452,
-0.4388905167579651,
0.892250120639801,
0.4797282814979553,
-0.7610188126564026,
0.011258305050432682,
-1.1733629703521729,
0.791652500629425,
-0.08198942244052887,
-1.022161841392517,
-0.4487869441509247,
0.3654232323169708,
0.5111585855484009,
0.18269173800945282,
0.6871634125709534,
-0.46609532833099365,
0.665651261806488,
-0.33585813641548157,
-0.08168170601129532,
0.06931695342063904,
-0.013802004978060722,
-0.37941667437553406,
0.37075042724609375,
-0.27566105127334595,
-0.07239788770675659
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.16925v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.16925v1
|
Analyzing Multi-Head Attention on Trojan BERT Models
| 2024-06-12T06:43:59 | 2024-06-12T06:43:59 |
Jingwei Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
This project investigates the behavior of multi-head attention in Transformer
models, specifically focusing on the differences between benign and trojan
models in the context of sentiment analysis. Trojan attacks cause models to
perform normally on clean inputs but exhibit misclassifications when presented
with inputs containing predefined triggers. We characterize attention head
functions in trojan and benign models, identifying specific 'trojan' heads and
analyzing their behavior.
|
[
-0.5328855514526367,
-0.8620403409004211,
0.4273547828197479,
0.11561346799135208,
-0.18308481574058533,
-0.2178320437669754,
0.10371924191713333,
-0.594154417514801,
0.27877911925315857,
0.5556341409683228,
-0.9045891165733337,
-0.037882834672927856,
-0.8231486082077026,
-0.26152265071868896,
-0.5622861981391907,
1.486350417137146,
0.5809444785118103,
0.030177364125847816,
0.405757337808609,
-0.04277177155017853,
-0.6938750147819519,
-0.6678881049156189,
-0.9057024717330933,
-0.01615814119577408,
1.1222494840621948,
-0.03462022542953491,
0.8053627610206604,
0.13065512478351593,
1.1101652383804321,
0.2213795781135559,
-0.19603972136974335,
-0.4044532775878906,
-0.6943826079368591,
0.315297394990921,
-0.3226044774055481,
-0.3038516342639923,
-0.5652034878730774,
0.18688219785690308,
0.3895517587661743,
0.26173165440559387,
0.3136579692363739,
0.4900662899017334,
0.1384558230638504,
0.48234549164772034,
-0.7028577923774719,
0.08341094106435776,
-0.7793534994125366,
0.19517914950847626,
-0.2026885449886322,
-0.07727086544036865,
-0.77410888671875,
-0.055258121341466904,
0.7206840515136719,
-0.24012799561023712,
0.6036864519119263,
0.09331565350294113,
0.7728966474533081,
0.30377620458602905,
-0.688374400138855,
0.22851987183094025,
-0.858622133731842,
1.1450601816177368,
-0.4022495150566101,
0.46162012219429016,
-0.0951545313000679,
0.21094202995300293,
0.012627096846699715,
-0.8530346751213074,
-0.5205200910568237,
-0.09433665871620178,
-0.18658487498760223,
0.29490238428115845,
-0.6480120420455933,
0.26077204942703247,
0.07964993268251419,
0.26110583543777466,
-0.3104053735733032,
-0.22497698664665222,
-0.6456422805786133,
-0.1798168271780014,
0.29472431540489197,
0.18691261112689972,
0.002666748594492674,
-0.20954570174217224,
-0.4192594587802887,
-0.1308925598859787,
-0.5227391123771667,
0.35153263807296753,
0.38995420932769775,
0.37151864171028137,
0.03519605100154877,
0.5587592720985413,
0.4665108025074005,
0.9461660981178284,
0.4758400619029999,
0.02393444813787937,
-0.07807192951440811,
0.1539459079504013,
-0.6919992566108704,
0.002017005579546094,
0.4212900996208191,
0.41130343079566956,
0.08600611239671707,
-0.32638782262802124,
-0.2510790228843689,
0.12154505401849747,
1.3347301483154297,
-0.22548101842403412,
-0.28056538105010986,
0.3836725652217865,
-0.6980692148208618,
-0.7862297892570496,
0.16681133210659027,
-0.8258793354034424,
-0.4975830316543579,
-0.35740336775779724,
0.9890860915184021,
-0.34896400570869446,
-0.06233801320195198,
0.033020708709955215,
-0.41132497787475586,
0.6478062272071838,
0.08583894371986389,
-0.7711321115493774,
0.18059375882148743,
0.7936488389968872,
0.6845263242721558,
-0.3141076862812042,
-0.15331245958805084,
-0.6382534503936768,
0.08275745064020157,
-0.11042312532663345,
0.7431641221046448,
-0.1885732263326645,
-0.07515860348939896,
0.05659835413098335,
0.25650554895401,
-0.5110957026481628,
-0.23384268581867218,
0.8168269395828247,
-0.9938400983810425,
0.0289878211915493,
-0.2903253138065338,
-0.23006485402584076,
-0.7474414110183716,
0.3482370972633362,
-0.797249436378479,
0.721666693687439,
0.09044711291790009,
-1.427433729171753,
0.22112450003623962,
-0.891423761844635,
-0.5193390250205994,
-0.21341274678707123,
0.10603988170623779,
-0.39737623929977417,
0.31470224261283875,
-0.04666316136717796,
0.7387672066688538,
-0.015672864392399788,
0.19566036760807037,
-0.36913666129112244,
-0.16791687905788422,
0.31291595101356506,
-0.19070665538311005,
1.0836360454559326,
0.150302454829216,
-0.5399062633514404,
0.5960369110107422,
-0.5724659562110901,
-0.5970205068588257,
0.12583355605602264,
0.279002845287323,
-0.34304553270339966,
0.13581007719039917,
0.34905537962913513,
0.3323313891887665,
0.09544303268194199,
-0.6806118488311768,
0.18851421773433685,
-0.5644417405128479,
0.30722153186798096,
0.8438660502433777,
0.2843731939792633,
0.0006402971921488643,
-0.5748006701469421,
0.4025835394859314,
0.5984798073768616,
0.613072395324707,
-0.03039623238146305,
-0.8509384989738464,
-1.2366118431091309,
-0.450733482837677,
-0.023368770256638527,
0.49628183245658875,
-0.513484537601471,
0.1663297563791275,
0.19518326222896576,
-0.45428532361984253,
-0.6810596585273743,
-0.5124897360801697,
0.17578278481960297,
0.8050088882446289,
0.3143254220485687,
-0.6126089096069336,
-0.29167211055755615,
-1.2938249111175537,
-0.2582806348800659,
-0.15975022315979004,
0.13466165959835052,
0.03786277398467064,
0.4163605570793152,
-0.3246409296989441,
1.128886342048645,
-0.42387253046035767,
-0.6109612584114075,
-0.36829936504364014,
0.5165390968322754,
0.32390856742858887,
0.34072810411453247,
1.0676915645599365,
-0.7817968130111694,
-0.23262947797775269,
-0.1431782841682434,
-0.5105102062225342,
0.40691500902175903,
-0.1529044806957245,
-0.1342691034078598,
0.03832675889134407,
0.1808045357465744,
-0.7717370986938477,
0.6514672636985779,
0.3126191198825836,
-0.1612679362297058,
0.6171219944953918,
0.12446798384189606,
0.2384725958108902,
-0.783313512802124,
0.273759663105011,
0.31449538469314575,
-0.09620846807956696,
-1.3576366901397705,
0.37626713514328003,
0.03882864862680435,
0.12118890136480331,
-0.9882789254188538,
0.029976747930049896,
0.056777071207761765,
-0.12243585288524628,
-0.23083433508872986,
-0.08837166428565979,
-0.00012922192399855703,
0.7167194485664368,
0.0018170698313042521,
0.5888549089431763,
0.998648464679718,
-0.7643675208091736,
0.6403906345367432,
0.20351369678974152,
0.1035744920372963,
0.572331428527832,
-0.9434475302696228,
0.3100513219833374,
-0.4931282699108124,
-0.11473412066698074,
-1.3085137605667114,
-0.40056365728378296,
0.5778776407241821,
-0.6843867301940918,
0.39141911268234253,
-0.07863279432058334,
-0.41770341992378235,
-0.6180911660194397,
-0.873500406742096,
0.3895225524902344,
0.2205915004014969,
-0.4196111857891083,
0.9474380016326904,
0.6099467277526855,
-0.10705838352441788,
-0.8042360544204712,
-0.558387041091919,
-0.38279423117637634,
-0.640581488609314,
-0.6998449563980103,
0.24948741495609283,
0.2882132828235626,
-0.44852423667907715,
-0.10742099583148956,
0.019784901291131973,
-0.42401617765426636,
0.08797033131122589,
0.13993646204471588,
0.6695989966392517,
-0.2939450144767761,
0.09881462156772614,
0.015441321767866611,
0.10320616513490677,
0.4799230098724365,
-0.2113909274339676,
0.3800046741962433,
0.02879193052649498,
-0.2693197429180145,
-0.8361367583274841,
0.2153216004371643,
0.9991729259490967,
-0.4130861759185791,
0.8921767473220825,
0.7354797124862671,
-0.45456719398498535,
0.41342681646347046,
-0.6853775382041931,
-0.7231214642524719,
-0.48976996541023254,
0.16852039098739624,
-0.2003605216741562,
-0.9766892194747925,
0.7174658179283142,
0.5836196541786194,
0.4889589548110962,
0.8991066813468933,
0.8824995160102844,
-0.3536441922187805,
0.9410887360572815,
1.059266209602356,
-0.46636316180229187,
0.24006441235542297,
0.12440888583660126,
0.47150811553001404,
-0.87929767370224,
-0.09171126037836075,
-0.43307846784591675,
-0.4565806984901428,
-0.5512266159057617,
0.012845001183450222,
0.6987457871437073,
-0.4976937770843506,
-0.21799223124980927,
0.44645366072654724,
-0.7239276170730591,
0.09822455048561096,
0.8838198184967041,
0.13012439012527466,
-0.04035952314734459,
-0.27747270464897156,
-0.08676818013191223,
-0.23141399025917053,
-0.5051900744438171,
-0.22508488595485687,
1.1800832748413086,
0.674974262714386,
0.736322283744812,
0.13204562664031982,
0.22720904648303986,
0.5021703839302063,
0.2805248498916626,
-1.0468789339065552,
0.20835451781749725,
0.06318878382444382,
-1.2773070335388184,
-0.21713581681251526,
0.24425522983074188,
-1.1492328643798828,
0.4444688856601715,
-0.11410536617040634,
-1.2575984001159668,
0.19725385308265686,
0.39488354325294495,
-0.9263150691986084,
0.2767867147922516,
-0.31941404938697815,
0.9932267069816589,
0.2142922431230545,
-0.12588681280612946,
-0.42115816473960876,
-1.2387322187423706,
0.8716741800308228,
-0.3120901584625244,
0.13165563344955444,
0.10395310819149017,
0.6328802108764648,
0.9867745041847229,
0.35274675488471985,
0.9715073704719543,
-0.05189995467662811,
-0.16126808524131775,
0.44802433252334595,
0.03572295978665352,
0.370758056640625,
0.06242677941918373,
0.47217926383018494,
-0.04112916812300682,
-0.04410415142774582,
-0.10205372422933578,
-0.10348770767450333,
0.3643639385700226,
-0.9805468916893005,
-0.7221899032592773,
-0.7065174579620361,
-0.7365381717681885,
-0.31760427355766296,
-0.06569354981184006,
0.3635232746601105,
0.2743811011314392,
0.08387167751789093,
0.08049576729536057,
1.128745198249817,
-0.2795637547969818,
0.37160682678222656,
0.3875015079975128,
-0.1363859623670578,
-0.08632765710353851,
0.6546577215194702,
-0.21545466780662537,
0.08726917207241058,
0.1913432627916336,
-0.1351788341999054,
-0.05592379346489906,
0.07048171013593674,
-0.3105616569519043,
0.49047690629959106,
-0.5969031453132629,
-0.11386482417583466,
-0.8959861993789673,
-0.3955013155937195,
-0.7738015055656433,
0.21464189887046814,
-0.366405189037323,
-0.5145474076271057,
-0.3670913279056549,
0.08525954931974411,
0.27848944067955017,
0.8342897295951843,
0.15061110258102417,
0.9319718480110168,
-1.0154445171356201,
0.5427290797233582,
0.5113685131072998,
-0.005791008472442627,
0.115145243704319,
-0.93402498960495,
-0.2213962972164154,
-0.44264987111091614,
-1.1030564308166504,
-1.3551746606826782,
0.5527917742729187,
-0.12909087538719177,
0.5490871071815491,
0.9282601475715637,
-0.07359643280506134,
0.3541509807109833,
-0.5802730917930603,
0.9157800674438477,
0.20783543586730957,
-1.0910820960998535,
0.6095672249794006,
-0.659516453742981,
0.037448834627866745,
0.08361431211233139,
0.6045714020729065,
-0.7142080664634705,
-1.095394253730774,
-0.6634913682937622,
-0.5888793468475342,
1.237361192703247,
0.2829166054725647,
0.20591118931770325,
0.21537841856479645,
0.2537468671798706,
0.1142086386680603,
0.26361700892448425,
-0.9594614505767822,
-0.7555639147758484,
-0.021325968205928802,
-0.05767427757382393,
0.10620196163654327,
-0.46757909655570984,
-0.30925801396369934,
-0.3197847008705139,
0.6805621385574341,
0.2973463237285614,
0.8748471140861511,
0.0009304449777118862,
-0.1117136999964714,
-0.21403878927230835,
0.016708428040146828,
0.8030310869216919,
0.35020869970321655,
-0.3475721776485443,
0.20604920387268066,
-0.02283664420247078,
-0.6611417531967163,
-0.011686169542372227,
-0.0052842022851109505,
0.05759752169251442,
0.2052912563085556,
0.3163774311542511,
0.577705442905426,
0.03736865893006325,
-0.2323569804430008,
0.7507209181785583,
-0.1206592321395874,
-0.06569922715425491,
-0.263040691614151,
-0.024265091866254807,
-0.16308465600013733,
0.40733492374420166,
0.4847307801246643,
0.3382643759250641,
0.7448421120643616,
-0.2140495777130127,
0.33575138449668884,
0.5619584918022156,
-0.8399452567100525,
-0.7204506993293762,
0.9479587078094482,
-0.004471427761018276,
0.11983141303062439,
0.7743157148361206,
0.30833595991134644,
-0.8181424140930176,
0.7375086545944214,
0.33476343750953674,
1.0270707607269287,
-0.5659024715423584,
-0.04530124366283417,
0.056240882724523544,
0.7265104055404663,
0.4124670624732971,
0.2630763351917267,
0.4130319356918335,
-0.710239827632904,
-0.41627606749534607,
-0.20910896360874176,
-0.4315846264362335,
0.6239873766899109,
-1.2050400972366333,
0.5233373641967773,
-0.2737215757369995,
-0.8553794622421265,
0.5439433455467224,
-0.7553174495697021,
-0.6406620144844055,
0.535770833492279,
0.27844443917274475,
0.4688205420970917,
-1.0095278024673462,
0.8303582072257996,
0.8918275237083435,
-0.06991161406040192,
-0.4390186667442322,
0.0981621965765953,
0.27703455090522766,
-0.6299207806587219,
0.9042904376983643,
0.4173296391963959,
-0.21650277078151703,
-0.08129176497459412,
-0.527327299118042,
-0.9013304114341736,
0.5277913808822632,
0.2833460867404938,
-0.2283627986907959,
-0.023577000945806503,
0.04091115668416023,
0.4084133803844452,
-0.004000658169388771,
-0.017603449523448944,
0.6338974833488464,
0.3090546727180481,
-0.26636064052581787,
-0.976300835609436,
-0.534554123878479,
0.060525644570589066,
-0.2292284220457077,
0.1937580555677414,
-0.8366823196411133,
1.391754150390625,
-0.04989435151219368,
0.05466337502002716,
-0.5034653544425964,
0.7416151165962219,
0.12900003790855408,
0.17233720421791077,
0.49181661009788513,
0.44909608364105225,
0.21321499347686768,
-0.024861253798007965,
0.872352659702301,
-0.6297418475151062,
0.784935474395752,
0.7802717089653015,
-0.15601308643817902,
0.5934298038482666,
0.7452788949012756,
-0.1069614514708519,
0.24177910387516022,
0.6109112501144409,
-0.15384860336780548,
0.7713226675987244,
0.0025163558311760426,
-0.2504943907260895,
0.03778707981109619,
0.11905170977115631,
-0.2561631202697754,
0.5283734202384949,
0.18850655853748322,
-0.45984166860580444,
0.0008536815294064581,
0.4168154001235962,
-0.1637478917837143,
-0.8106523156166077,
-0.40021783113479614,
0.6018126606941223,
-0.12583866715431213,
-0.49075496196746826,
0.008450048044323921,
0.38394245505332947,
0.6363625526428223,
-0.22588858008384705,
0.28692546486854553,
0.12538348138332367,
0.41348591446876526,
0.1852581799030304,
-0.49695587158203125,
0.7091044783592224,
-0.010861404240131378,
-0.3952336311340332,
0.2826414406299591,
0.9845295548439026,
0.04664209112524986,
-0.4713381230831146,
0.3004310727119446,
0.20534083247184753,
0.08758191764354706,
-0.20177863538265228,
-0.5925850868225098,
0.028308933600783348,
-0.14781394600868225,
-0.6524998545646667,
0.18880537152290344,
0.2283681482076645,
0.11541462689638138,
0.6533169150352478,
0.23957471549510956,
-0.39390385150909424,
0.4936492145061493,
0.0406370609998703,
0.9072641134262085,
-0.5331655144691467,
-0.5392375588417053,
-1.0819413661956787,
0.5435304641723633,
0.19480566680431366,
-0.18787042796611786,
0.7858880162239075,
0.4163881242275238,
0.5787042379379272,
-0.8011811971664429,
0.6095125675201416,
0.037423957139253616,
0.7595016956329346,
0.1528998166322708,
0.8877156972885132,
-0.40830692648887634,
-0.3867987394332886,
-0.49120622873306274,
-0.9859272837638855,
-0.5223711133003235,
0.8680505156517029,
-0.04100417718291283,
-0.2357996702194214,
0.7493711709976196,
0.4151557683944702,
-0.12990453839302063,
0.22902145981788635,
0.2356504648923874,
0.12321671843528748,
0.1221454069018364,
0.4107522666454315,
1.06892991065979,
-0.373700350522995,
0.003198038088157773,
-0.26304924488067627,
-0.15090292692184448,
-0.348997563123703,
-0.664897084236145,
-1.0760397911071777,
-0.33580467104911804,
-0.2983214259147644,
-0.13415414094924927,
-0.14617985486984253,
0.7880004644393921,
0.6001014113426208,
-1.2886292934417725,
-0.12229804694652557,
0.3532915413379669,
-0.10229001939296722,
-0.3628253936767578,
-0.33630862832069397,
0.4176010489463806,
-0.8308386206626892,
-0.6916980147361755,
-0.09402303397655487,
0.44572266936302185,
0.020694810897111893,
-0.3690756857395172,
0.6172673106193542,
-0.17333287000656128,
0.5392407178878784,
0.8498837947845459,
-0.23242463171482086,
-0.9057765007019043,
-0.5639423131942749,
0.2679978311061859,
-0.27920547127723694,
0.18677257001399994,
0.8295743465423584,
-0.6354478597640991,
0.13634788990020752,
0.13121619820594788,
0.6396176815032959,
0.3058888614177704,
-0.1376390904188156,
0.3686937391757965,
-0.8065627217292786,
0.2455538660287857,
0.38309118151664734,
0.309139221906662,
-0.09198172390460968,
-0.5408526659011841,
0.03569803386926651,
0.1920136958360672,
-0.7179692983627319,
-0.7627668380737305,
0.0942668542265892,
-1.3419607877731323,
-0.10673826187849045,
0.7313816547393799,
-0.4247075319290161,
-0.1917766034603119,
-0.23427312076091766,
-0.4451068341732025,
0.45736774802207947,
-0.28557178378105164,
1.180628776550293,
0.9450304508209229,
-0.3963399827480316,
-0.03127902001142502,
-0.6687219142913818,
0.3381083607673645,
0.4706997871398926,
-0.4570241868495941,
-0.08031631261110306,
0.42683178186416626,
0.035199686884880066,
0.4346065819263458,
0.008400769904255867,
-0.06271790713071823,
0.5448143482208252,
-0.49583736062049866,
-0.03625819459557533,
0.5938920974731445,
-0.8103596568107605,
-0.46427860856056213,
0.5201369524002075,
-0.0017149676568806171,
-0.5480497479438782
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.07913v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.07913v1
|
DeTriever: Decoder-representation-based Retriever for Improving NL2SQL In-Context Learning
| 2024-06-12T06:33:54 | 2024-06-12T06:33:54 |
Yuxi Feng, Raymond Li, Zhenan Fan, Giuseppe Carenini, Mohammadreza Pourreza, Weiwei Zhang, Yong Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IR
|
While in-context Learning (ICL) has proven to be an effective technique to
improve the performance of Large Language Models (LLMs) in a variety of complex
tasks, notably in translating natural language questions into Structured Query
Language (NL2SQL), the question of how to select the most beneficial
demonstration examples remains an open research problem. While prior works
often adapted off-the-shelf encoders to retrieve examples dynamically, an
inherent discrepancy exists in the representational capacities between the
external retrievers and the LLMs. Further, optimizing the selection of examples
is a non-trivial task, since there are no straightforward methods to assess the
relative benefits of examples without performing pairwise inference. To address
these shortcomings, we propose DeTriever, a novel demonstration retrieval
framework that learns a weighted combination of LLM hidden states, where rich
semantic information is encoded. To train the model, we propose a proxy score
that estimates the relative benefits of examples based on the similarities
between output queries. Experiments on two popular NL2SQL benchmarks
demonstrate that our method significantly outperforms the state-of-the-art
baselines on one-shot NL2SQL tasks.
|
[
-0.2658313810825348,
-0.31302616000175476,
0.40992867946624756,
0.0729774609208107,
-0.5213980674743652,
0.022092120721936226,
-0.040801115334033966,
-0.24500608444213867,
0.10783014446496964,
0.42954641580581665,
-0.5067328214645386,
-0.5104542970657349,
-0.5864356756210327,
0.3383122980594635,
-0.4522585868835449,
0.7831051349639893,
0.2437034696340561,
0.13317568600177765,
-0.38289085030555725,
-0.22700725495815277,
-0.5689069628715515,
-0.42352479696273804,
-0.6862390041351318,
-0.31920942664146423,
0.06817137449979782,
0.3115331530570984,
0.09438886493444443,
0.15460234880447388,
0.34413236379623413,
0.20181165635585785,
0.010630471631884575,
0.3469243347644806,
-0.7674950957298279,
0.455067902803421,
-0.47184687852859497,
-0.6511287093162537,
0.47982722520828247,
-0.23910339176654816,
0.7439199686050415,
0.7369949817657471,
-0.16558107733726501,
-0.04116716608405113,
0.16780929267406464,
0.6323683857917786,
-0.8512189984321594,
0.14255735278129578,
-0.8356578946113586,
0.27084726095199585,
-0.051061663776636124,
-0.21343094110488892,
-0.9128682017326355,
-0.5078593492507935,
-0.09306556731462479,
-0.3672296404838562,
0.05927775800228119,
0.10819042474031448,
0.6407982110977173,
0.4970076084136963,
-0.7544146776199341,
-0.11670204252004623,
-0.625999927520752,
0.9275900721549988,
-0.633253812789917,
0.6447308659553528,
0.33659255504608154,
0.4778762459754944,
-0.44028857350349426,
-0.7437087893486023,
-0.2355879694223404,
-0.12048514932394028,
-0.4159151017665863,
0.3475669324398041,
-0.3867534101009369,
-0.1597668081521988,
0.3616441488265991,
0.08852721005678177,
-0.5368115305900574,
0.024212725460529327,
0.07424092292785645,
-0.07556771486997604,
0.3979211151599884,
0.1621537208557129,
-0.010421295650303364,
-0.23031611740589142,
-0.5456493496894836,
-0.3065452575683594,
-0.8883126378059387,
0.05393624305725098,
0.06096262112259865,
0.3087325692176819,
0.13281825184822083,
0.38925784826278687,
-0.2625734508037567,
0.5852737426757812,
0.17472028732299805,
0.272457093000412,
0.2254122644662857,
-0.02000269666314125,
-0.008327377960085869,
0.18422392010688782,
0.6513572335243225,
0.2570899724960327,
-0.31732410192489624,
-0.3379397690296173,
-0.2845529019832611,
-0.17548419535160065,
0.1771009862422943,
-1.0718698501586914,
-0.08910968154668808,
0.08904591202735901,
-0.5144555568695068,
-0.09243128448724747,
0.28114381432533264,
-0.8675421476364136,
-0.4396161735057831,
0.046581972390413284,
0.2693595588207245,
-0.6219058036804199,
-0.4421447515487671,
0.050544001162052155,
-0.45124515891075134,
0.4008413553237915,
0.19339704513549805,
-0.6125267744064331,
0.5175157785415649,
0.6434690356254578,
0.5912187695503235,
-0.181216299533844,
0.17475710809230804,
-1.0805975198745728,
0.1944473683834076,
-0.5262612700462341,
0.6234484314918518,
-0.5554012060165405,
-0.5401195883750916,
0.16019976139068604,
-0.0007841730839572847,
-0.02374148555099964,
-0.8416878581047058,
0.4695577025413513,
-0.7023476362228394,
0.16683362424373627,
-0.6029785871505737,
-0.754535436630249,
-0.07860347628593445,
0.23266422748565674,
-0.750025749206543,
1.2079885005950928,
0.2767963111400604,
-0.8038374781608582,
0.530656099319458,
-0.4569189250469208,
-0.2733508348464966,
0.3682069778442383,
-0.49171608686447144,
-0.09048338234424591,
0.42966756224632263,
-0.008746611885726452,
0.27586814761161804,
-0.14610238373279572,
0.10094577074050903,
0.1305408626794815,
-0.7393336892127991,
0.1886114776134491,
-0.30530932545661926,
0.7027416825294495,
0.017334003001451492,
-0.39108484983444214,
0.03053692914545536,
-0.5533220171928406,
-0.09737351536750793,
0.1832912266254425,
-0.46961551904678345,
-0.7776098847389221,
0.21319161355495453,
-0.13571271300315857,
0.28925156593322754,
-0.07226579636335373,
-0.6063554883003235,
-0.061278168112039566,
-0.6766563653945923,
0.08776438981294632,
0.3758127689361572,
0.09820262342691422,
0.4264131784439087,
-0.012836252339184284,
0.46465635299682617,
0.11647232621908188,
-0.15977759659290314,
-0.009074068628251553,
-0.08918162435293198,
-0.5897359251976013,
-0.3239540159702301,
0.17597787082195282,
0.2947074770927429,
-1.009015440940857,
0.3026033043861389,
-0.3804798126220703,
-0.07715436071157455,
-0.5284081101417542,
0.011951787397265434,
0.6400230526924133,
0.7164308428764343,
0.5229094624519348,
-0.21020036935806274,
-0.5028678178787231,
-1.0169626474380493,
-0.4037921726703644,
0.0012053399113938212,
-0.10192055255174637,
0.19507735967636108,
0.589622437953949,
0.01974940113723278,
0.9784013628959656,
-0.3217756152153015,
-0.2401145100593567,
-0.46733829379081726,
-0.08204460144042969,
0.11429715901613235,
0.3685016632080078,
0.536170482635498,
-0.8374069333076477,
-0.24154947698116302,
-0.17763957381248474,
-0.7863506078720093,
0.24652506411075592,
0.0494145005941391,
-0.3560693562030792,
0.22905407845973969,
0.6126564145088196,
-0.6417475342750549,
0.39074084162712097,
0.14795701205730438,
-0.3983675241470337,
0.44276487827301025,
-0.1955004334449768,
-0.049640484154224396,
-1.0616222620010376,
-0.08195608854293823,
-0.11683965474367142,
-0.40576261281967163,
-0.5144684314727783,
0.28069719672203064,
0.44171062111854553,
0.1486808806657791,
-0.5387824177742004,
0.663342297077179,
-0.4744303822517395,
-0.10025107115507126,
-0.10737358778715134,
0.18916746973991394,
0.15823863446712494,
0.18638557195663452,
0.11454778164625168,
0.8389450907707214,
0.20365937054157257,
-0.4377683997154236,
0.1196819469332695,
0.44061166048049927,
-0.49837934970855713,
0.6252801418304443,
-0.5926713347434998,
0.1586993783712387,
-0.4150829315185547,
0.3929586708545685,
-0.9053177237510681,
-0.24910296499729156,
0.11649440973997116,
-0.003080114023759961,
0.5478255152702332,
-0.40666258335113525,
-0.5329950451850891,
-0.310282826423645,
-0.4714929759502411,
0.07219886034727097,
0.5602766871452332,
-1.0598381757736206,
0.6181894540786743,
0.06664063781499863,
0.3764534294605255,
-0.8682103753089905,
-0.8557873368263245,
0.09996390342712402,
-0.335824579000473,
-0.10302715748548508,
0.580011248588562,
0.11015309393405914,
-0.28392308950424194,
0.012304984033107758,
-0.3205004930496216,
0.358807235956192,
0.1334000676870346,
0.21291692554950714,
-0.09699421375989914,
-0.03427424654364586,
0.39683839678764343,
0.38678234815597534,
-0.1920320838689804,
0.18315905332565308,
-0.21241500973701477,
0.5933240652084351,
-0.19658562541007996,
-0.572511613368988,
-0.2509952783584595,
0.585101306438446,
0.051875222474336624,
-0.3581382632255554,
0.7701619863510132,
0.30691054463386536,
-0.3629682958126068,
-0.7385472059249878,
-0.4009307324886322,
-0.4918546974658966,
-0.49464738368988037,
0.640238881111145,
-0.5219343900680542,
-0.832729160785675,
0.29663214087486267,
-0.45496660470962524,
-0.03610308840870857,
0.18088169395923615,
0.026780011132359505,
0.03399144485592842,
1.0006098747253418,
0.41353216767311096,
0.07922843098640442,
0.40874922275543213,
-0.4534469246864319,
0.12629859149456024,
-0.9453451633453369,
-0.473613977432251,
-0.46306779980659485,
-0.11505142599344254,
-0.32618439197540283,
-0.3003575801849365,
0.246504545211792,
0.32198312878608704,
-0.38681742548942566,
0.2806658148765564,
-0.5169812440872192,
0.5609121322631836,
0.5714209675788879,
0.12744766473770142,
0.25258591771125793,
0.16195498406887054,
-0.3348967730998993,
-0.19261014461517334,
-0.5493015646934509,
-0.43114209175109863,
0.6789746880531311,
-0.1367661952972412,
0.640783429145813,
0.5513207912445068,
1.0051125288009644,
0.11396381258964539,
0.09363863617181778,
-0.8020842671394348,
0.6651803255081177,
-0.4348389804363251,
-0.2864830195903778,
0.026598017662763596,
-0.4889730215072632,
-0.9311242699623108,
0.6283701062202454,
0.004104943014681339,
-0.8114027976989746,
0.3568202555179596,
-0.050184424966573715,
-0.011933833360671997,
0.07531995326280594,
-0.39703261852264404,
0.766732931137085,
-0.1771123707294464,
-0.4674612879753113,
-0.13482145965099335,
-0.6695111393928528,
0.2870482802391052,
0.11631292849779129,
-0.05427640676498413,
0.04021177068352699,
-0.0564606674015522,
0.6119101643562317,
-0.3136555552482605,
0.6287686824798584,
-0.513417661190033,
0.005333468783646822,
0.032336924225091934,
0.5520301461219788,
0.694618821144104,
0.18617361783981323,
-0.6000280976295471,
-0.20740962028503418,
0.10560306906700134,
-0.10126589983701706,
-0.8369162082672119,
0.7404401898384094,
-0.40372392535209656,
-0.6037127375602722,
-0.26586368680000305,
-0.37075644731521606,
-0.2978035509586334,
0.04062262549996376,
0.20304842293262482,
0.6714807152748108,
-0.12708458304405212,
0.4867475628852844,
0.7193179130554199,
-0.2847783863544464,
0.5035082697868347,
0.5153419375419617,
-0.1550896167755127,
-0.10697412490844727,
0.6629208922386169,
-0.1845138669013977,
0.1591159552335739,
0.7914912700653076,
0.16022734344005585,
-0.6645039916038513,
-0.5174956321716309,
-0.3180103600025177,
0.15131834149360657,
-1.0041241645812988,
-0.4636552631855011,
-0.6438500881195068,
-0.1188974604010582,
0.08659863471984863,
0.013346454128623009,
-0.2970338463783264,
-0.32447731494903564,
-0.3359239101409912,
-0.38291141390800476,
0.45968079566955566,
0.4717460572719574,
0.13140225410461426,
0.07373644411563873,
-0.3401343822479248,
0.05147888511419296,
0.21643903851509094,
0.26423758268356323,
-0.021936943754553795,
-0.4482904076576233,
-0.040047548711299896,
-0.10489095747470856,
-0.01746545173227787,
-0.864246666431427,
0.45179277658462524,
0.3393550217151642,
0.8613204956054688,
0.5531066060066223,
0.43212124705314636,
0.6396429538726807,
-0.32556477189064026,
0.8085001707077026,
0.11983565241098404,
-0.7066411375999451,
0.8582996726036072,
0.1390855461359024,
0.18782645463943481,
0.8381136059761047,
0.5099209547042847,
-0.37186431884765625,
-0.4057445228099823,
-0.12351172417402267,
-0.9118451476097107,
0.6832070350646973,
-0.11604340374469757,
0.3206850290298462,
-0.5278759002685547,
0.38129302859306335,
0.32363688945770264,
0.03237363323569298,
-0.37611308693885803,
-0.0969444066286087,
-0.23642432689666748,
-0.5262295603752136,
0.24249108135700226,
-0.2841959297657013,
-0.1712721586227417,
-0.14975325763225555,
0.45790770649909973,
-0.3400571048259735,
0.31160491704940796,
0.10628379881381989,
-0.4230853319168091,
0.17873160541057587,
0.2010137140750885,
0.2018318921327591,
0.4479825794696808,
-0.49612024426460266,
0.5662389993667603,
0.27291247248649597,
-0.32771238684654236,
0.09060326218605042,
0.27194738388061523,
-0.24772454798221588,
0.12537787854671478,
0.2987087666988373,
0.7342097759246826,
0.43151071667671204,
-0.9539989829063416,
0.7211138010025024,
-0.35038936138153076,
-0.10980542004108429,
-0.289152055978775,
0.13767895102500916,
0.077297143638134,
0.4182265102863312,
0.6776821613311768,
-0.1755293607711792,
0.3923322558403015,
-0.3026696443557739,
0.30671271681785583,
0.7091503143310547,
-0.6626768112182617,
-0.0938258096575737,
0.7696473598480225,
-0.14173036813735962,
-0.22410497069358826,
0.8221346735954285,
-0.4593938887119293,
-0.3496394753456116,
0.49820348620414734,
0.9925806522369385,
0.6390752792358398,
-0.08862414956092834,
0.16379845142364502,
0.40959393978118896,
0.07702389359474182,
-0.287861168384552,
0.41411641240119934,
-0.15192477405071259,
-0.7014996409416199,
-0.21347099542617798,
-0.6229283809661865,
-0.11537259817123413,
-0.002534667495638132,
-0.8624053597450256,
-0.014793378300964832,
-0.19693365693092346,
-0.09904853254556656,
-0.37624698877334595,
0.11862549930810928,
-0.7836479544639587,
-0.24048306047916412,
-0.10697220265865326,
1.032670259475708,
-0.6747117042541504,
0.7867557406425476,
0.5285453796386719,
-0.6094672083854675,
-0.6354141235351562,
-0.07585272938013077,
-0.03571805730462074,
-0.3263930678367615,
1.00492262840271,
0.25783097743988037,
-0.379685640335083,
0.06975571066141129,
-0.3983764052391052,
-0.8953230977058411,
1.2071611881256104,
0.6460098028182983,
-0.504304051399231,
0.22431102395057678,
-0.025571836158633232,
0.33563733100891113,
-0.43245968222618103,
0.5678978562355042,
0.40084344148635864,
0.0848485454916954,
0.0831431895494461,
-0.2803105413913727,
0.44264280796051025,
-0.2633959949016571,
0.38243532180786133,
0.19316817820072174,
-0.5250279307365417,
0.36312782764434814,
-0.07729367911815643,
-0.3654136061668396,
0.09010250866413116,
0.5509356260299683,
0.5706712603569031,
0.19091975688934326,
0.4226796627044678,
0.3381209373474121,
0.8164333701133728,
-0.13268058001995087,
1.3125529289245605,
-0.09023188054561615,
0.223018616437912,
1.4940706491470337,
-0.5555708408355713,
1.085825800895691,
0.6221215724945068,
-0.0661373883485794,
0.7406308054924011,
0.4096338450908661,
0.05733311176300049,
0.9662657380104065,
0.2501559853553772,
-0.3847085237503052,
-0.2840111255645752,
-0.31650978326797485,
-0.2653627097606659,
0.47956258058547974,
0.4725112318992615,
-0.4459773600101471,
-0.44639018177986145,
0.14039787650108337,
-0.12760302424430847,
0.2847099006175995,
0.08478201925754547,
0.8465550541877747,
0.11354326456785202,
-0.38153141736984253,
0.5530368089675903,
-0.101935975253582,
0.7057917714118958,
-0.6553623080253601,
-0.4438076615333557,
-0.6229555606842041,
0.20239634811878204,
-0.1679440587759018,
-0.5402123332023621,
0.3047497868537903,
-0.19864660501480103,
-0.030775919556617737,
-0.12235552072525024,
0.7575640082359314,
-0.33132869005203247,
-0.33687958121299744,
0.7355785965919495,
0.4699670374393463,
0.2752562463283539,
0.03922644630074501,
-0.42150840163230896,
-0.03886988013982773,
-0.31765028834342957,
-0.21149598062038422,
0.41657736897468567,
0.44560304284095764,
-0.153970405459404,
0.6542956829071045,
0.36285921931266785,
-0.17183758318424225,
0.0341038778424263,
0.509074330329895,
0.8620179891586304,
-0.47665515542030334,
-0.2045809030532837,
-0.7438631653785706,
0.3981611430644989,
-0.4356921911239624,
0.008898084051907063,
0.8140825629234314,
0.9384029507637024,
0.970317542552948,
-0.09805738925933838,
0.6121823191642761,
0.06100441515445709,
0.48044586181640625,
-0.4316340684890747,
0.5591241717338562,
-0.5426039099693298,
0.34067702293395996,
0.0007677208632230759,
-0.7059270143508911,
-0.3273969292640686,
0.6739434599876404,
-0.22632786631584167,
-0.05531209707260132,
0.6687384247779846,
0.9804800152778625,
-0.10307539254426956,
-0.038786474615335464,
0.3892381191253662,
0.030594035983085632,
0.38417837023735046,
0.5550713539123535,
1.1194661855697632,
-0.45291221141815186,
0.4875989556312561,
-0.2362629473209381,
-0.009767706505954266,
-0.29645416140556335,
-0.7282196283340454,
-0.8073234558105469,
-0.591688871383667,
-0.20599378645420074,
-0.24334198236465454,
0.3017790615558624,
1.1173721551895142,
0.7251453399658203,
-0.6603873372077942,
-0.14105761051177979,
-0.04777343198657036,
0.11215050518512726,
-0.5876372456550598,
-0.24320906400680542,
0.593986988067627,
-0.38944652676582336,
-0.54505455493927,
0.8634447455406189,
0.0828554704785347,
-0.28582218289375305,
0.03923647850751877,
-0.07913993299007416,
-0.2159014195203781,
-0.1224818006157875,
0.872779905796051,
0.057789046317338943,
-0.6922953724861145,
-0.366155207157135,
-0.19823963940143585,
-0.009191636927425861,
0.0133383609354496,
0.5260368585586548,
-1.2104543447494507,
0.3172037601470947,
0.3491445779800415,
0.7108112573623657,
0.8488871455192566,
0.06169591844081879,
0.2113090604543686,
-1.0434865951538086,
0.17979875206947327,
0.31219935417175293,
0.4340033531188965,
0.49189630150794983,
-0.3852497935295105,
0.6344504952430725,
-0.14659136533737183,
-0.11151783168315887,
-0.8117181658744812,
0.3026767671108246,
-0.7959776520729065,
-0.4752903878688812,
1.1800278425216675,
-0.08102167397737503,
-0.12589967250823975,
-0.186738982796669,
0.1120348796248436,
0.20962323248386383,
-0.48583972454071045,
0.5033153891563416,
0.007333904970437288,
-0.05663345381617546,
-0.31983163952827454,
-0.6963641047477722,
0.5232352614402771,
0.33394670486450195,
-0.6667086482048035,
-0.019300924614071846,
0.42486944794654846,
0.4505216181278229,
-0.20964688062667847,
0.5099236369132996,
-0.2674010097980499,
-0.11293691396713257,
-0.034327659755945206,
-0.06722535192966461,
-0.08994850516319275,
-0.1271735429763794,
-0.49913081526756287,
0.24448110163211823,
0.06813188642263412,
-0.19612136483192444
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.07909v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.07909v1
|
Guiding Frame-Level CTC Alignments Using Self-knowledge Distillation
| 2024-06-12T06:22:52 | 2024-06-12T06:22:52 |
Eungbeom Kim, Hantae Kim, Kyogu Lee
|
eess.AS
|
eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.SD, stat.ML
|
Transformer encoder with connectionist temporal classification (CTC)
framework is widely used for automatic speech recognition (ASR). However,
knowledge distillation (KD) for ASR displays a problem of disagreement between
teacher-student models in frame-level alignment which ultimately hinders it
from improving the student model's performance. In order to resolve this
problem, this paper introduces a self-knowledge distillation (SKD) method that
guides the frame-level alignment during the training time. In contrast to the
conventional method using separate teacher and student models, this study
introduces a simple and effective method sharing encoder layers and applying
the sub-model as the student model. Overall, our approach is effective in
improving both the resource efficiency as well as performance. We also
conducted an experimental analysis of the spike timings to illustrate that the
proposed method improves performance by reducing the alignment disagreement.
|
[
-0.34102362394332886,
-0.2813786268234253,
0.3049272894859314,
-0.03044477477669716,
-0.4211733639240265,
0.43567752838134766,
-0.05261344090104103,
-0.045279279351234436,
-0.05290018394589424,
0.11156365275382996,
-0.4509987533092499,
-0.39397841691970825,
-0.6839144825935364,
0.05753587558865547,
-0.5395182967185974,
0.7963619232177734,
0.004624607041478157,
0.2764790654182434,
-0.19772279262542725,
-0.2241639345884323,
-0.768083393573761,
-0.5597905516624451,
-0.7924177050590515,
-0.7123050689697266,
0.22769823670387268,
0.24899210035800934,
0.22705461084842682,
1.0157595872879028,
0.4107632339000702,
0.36147210001945496,
-0.42149436473846436,
-0.08560121804475784,
-0.021839331835508347,
0.3074794113636017,
-0.36171385645866394,
-0.39579933881759644,
-0.1729036569595337,
-0.3093726933002472,
0.3711741268634796,
0.3194858431816101,
-0.5022972822189331,
0.060407061129808426,
0.4679936468601227,
0.6772602200508118,
-0.643505334854126,
0.06109907105565071,
-0.588921308517456,
0.2740694284439087,
-0.18513214588165283,
-0.23780196905136108,
-0.39636439085006714,
-0.24252699315547943,
0.4000529944896698,
-0.3882153332233429,
0.4749363362789154,
-0.36797305941581726,
0.5727441310882568,
0.8450887203216553,
-0.56459641456604,
-0.33838146924972534,
-0.7414382696151733,
0.39547932147979736,
-0.7889520525932312,
0.5078464150428772,
0.23179639875888824,
0.7371158599853516,
0.11639924347400665,
-0.510301411151886,
-0.775337278842926,
0.22445353865623474,
-0.21612468361854553,
0.06747719645500183,
0.027160532772541046,
0.09978082031011581,
0.37910065054893494,
0.14644524455070496,
-0.4325298070907593,
0.1139744222164154,
-0.635542631149292,
-0.24654826521873474,
0.3538650572299957,
0.09814649820327759,
0.02951333113014698,
-0.11268812417984009,
-0.5785112977027893,
-0.1911114752292633,
-0.2874678373336792,
0.19803361594676971,
0.18112589418888092,
0.1764269322156906,
-0.1034490168094635,
0.49632591009140015,
-0.08658045530319214,
0.687796950340271,
0.7551538944244385,
-0.28079137206077576,
0.36980876326560974,
-0.2477463334798813,
-0.08077234029769897,
0.9277717471122742,
0.7705461382865906,
0.07896702736616135,
0.20996160805225372,
0.0640590712428093,
-0.11083813011646271,
0.24656963348388672,
0.33935365080833435,
-0.7188923358917236,
-0.4460466504096985,
-0.10484757274389267,
-0.2820305824279785,
-0.11109228432178497,
-0.08872842788696289,
-0.6613559126853943,
-0.15288099646568298,
-0.6819721460342407,
0.6160849928855896,
-0.4884273409843445,
-0.23116065561771393,
-0.019638417288661003,
-0.23345375061035156,
0.1500454992055893,
0.1311938315629959,
-0.9550320506095886,
0.08420385420322418,
0.3491940200328827,
0.850330650806427,
-0.2669045925140381,
-0.03741297125816345,
-0.18274879455566406,
0.527908444404602,
-0.09983697533607483,
0.5256852507591248,
-0.4434109628200531,
-0.48623374104499817,
-0.346622109413147,
-0.17277909815311432,
-0.19683586061000824,
-0.4579155445098877,
0.1727762222290039,
-0.4436151087284088,
0.13842517137527466,
-0.10125085711479187,
-0.597856879234314,
-0.0727575272321701,
-0.010467510670423508,
-0.378152459859848,
1.0636203289031982,
-0.3323538601398468,
-0.8510041832923889,
0.479030579328537,
-0.6843164563179016,
-0.3736568093299866,
-0.05595731735229492,
-0.4345945417881012,
-0.36980926990509033,
-0.11044690757989883,
0.6927024722099304,
0.4757043719291687,
0.16602861881256104,
0.4790220260620117,
0.031940702348947525,
-0.12538135051727295,
0.11704082787036896,
-0.4975406229496002,
0.7664310336112976,
0.7154408097267151,
-0.4808137118816376,
-0.06836894154548645,
-0.8507270812988281,
-0.07719375938177109,
-0.2717374861240387,
-0.2538128197193146,
-0.472283273935318,
-0.15190643072128296,
-0.4605121314525604,
0.31994518637657166,
0.3125836253166199,
-0.5524896383285522,
0.25788578391075134,
-0.17191170156002045,
0.7574005722999573,
0.672212541103363,
-0.04955432936549187,
0.5885683298110962,
-0.04814588651061058,
0.29004305601119995,
0.5237851738929749,
0.1487978845834732,
-0.11805469542741776,
-0.1743333786725998,
-0.7429161071777344,
-0.001629153499379754,
0.4427799582481384,
0.16332264244556427,
-0.862714409828186,
0.5867353081703186,
-0.2110041230916977,
-0.5984499454498291,
-0.6886166334152222,
-0.053819406777620316,
0.5667989253997803,
0.8406794667243958,
0.7106869220733643,
-0.22772584855556488,
-0.5356290340423584,
-0.5668240189552307,
0.025195743888616562,
-0.14039388298988342,
0.12073524296283722,
-0.04304157570004463,
0.16699083149433136,
-0.016308680176734924,
1.2772330045700073,
-0.5242850184440613,
-0.5313500761985779,
-0.13864721357822418,
0.3330584764480591,
0.12463461607694626,
0.9567576050758362,
0.5530798435211182,
-0.5274418592453003,
-0.6725258827209473,
-0.08634091168642044,
-0.5675438046455383,
-0.22558897733688354,
0.058937765657901764,
-0.15412254631519318,
0.23823131620883942,
0.5880058407783508,
0.04246629402041435,
0.5674793124198914,
0.45523062348365784,
-0.237777441740036,
0.08829089254140854,
-0.2830008268356323,
0.42175155878067017,
-1.2399805784225464,
-0.16650642454624176,
0.0479704812169075,
-0.21478720009326935,
-0.6240465044975281,
-0.5404733419418335,
0.20262716710567474,
0.08386779576539993,
-0.3209315240383148,
0.15241023898124695,
-0.3355022370815277,
0.20257225632667542,
-0.44292163848876953,
0.12593106925487518,
0.058645714074373245,
0.4421265125274658,
0.3157426714897156,
0.6715180277824402,
0.5729027986526489,
-0.5321057438850403,
0.24614450335502625,
0.28311169147491455,
-0.19812659919261932,
0.6948885917663574,
-0.6063907146453857,
0.4644847512245178,
-0.10928065329790115,
0.24100445210933685,
-0.8835864067077637,
0.30423346161842346,
0.01486421562731266,
-0.5016340613365173,
0.6327413320541382,
-0.5470110177993774,
0.0114113949239254,
-0.4278737008571625,
0.41928690671920776,
0.8642256259918213,
0.4690769910812378,
-0.9652044773101807,
0.8857671618461609,
0.3209196925163269,
0.23374134302139282,
-0.690134584903717,
-0.8313891887664795,
-0.28802865743637085,
-0.4497586488723755,
-0.5099329948425293,
0.5778835415840149,
0.012741864658892155,
0.25266405940055847,
-0.1690337061882019,
-0.7079077959060669,
-0.3470942974090576,
-0.3736291229724884,
0.2609616219997406,
0.18027448654174805,
-0.2701660990715027,
0.05608336627483368,
0.2119506299495697,
-0.25866642594337463,
-0.22103461623191833,
-0.21477290987968445,
0.6567983031272888,
0.259056955575943,
-0.4755927324295044,
-1.03687584400177,
0.07622117549180984,
0.40584248304367065,
-0.20117275416851044,
0.36963531374931335,
0.3956034779548645,
-0.27345550060272217,
-0.16142238676548004,
-0.9602898359298706,
-0.29753002524375916,
-0.5585997104644775,
0.025355109944939613,
-0.34258002042770386,
-0.7417938709259033,
0.4384741485118866,
-0.009709138423204422,
-0.34887176752090454,
0.33817481994628906,
0.27471649646759033,
-0.24404193460941315,
0.9162761569023132,
0.5614112615585327,
-0.4058035910129547,
0.627638041973114,
-0.41717541217803955,
0.08602119237184525,
-0.8862448930740356,
-0.561816394329071,
-0.748952329158783,
-0.606594443321228,
-0.0672137662768364,
-0.23217052221298218,
0.44565632939338684,
0.24960768222808838,
-0.5373839735984802,
0.7657427191734314,
-0.9792506694793701,
0.40741756558418274,
0.4975876212120056,
0.21043509244918823,
0.3915029466152191,
-0.07870780676603317,
-0.3246905505657196,
-0.15018489956855774,
-0.7779936790466309,
-0.22496312856674194,
0.838927149772644,
0.2777986228466034,
1.007714867591858,
-0.17238390445709229,
1.0258022546768188,
0.22563721239566803,
-0.47756853699684143,
-0.39169976115226746,
0.25502970814704895,
-0.2289864867925644,
-0.5501110553741455,
-0.3839390277862549,
-0.37765395641326904,
-0.43973565101623535,
0.12236288189888,
0.020393872633576393,
-0.6449519991874695,
0.6068344712257385,
0.4184427261352539,
-0.583759069442749,
0.17970716953277588,
-0.8209806084632874,
0.7499828338623047,
-0.23190346360206604,
0.10178886353969574,
-0.33733221888542175,
-0.7287550568580627,
-0.1144004836678505,
0.01528395339846611,
-0.14395947754383087,
0.05851460620760918,
0.44375720620155334,
0.9227624535560608,
-0.6545376777648926,
0.7262417078018188,
-0.516198992729187,
0.0691162571310997,
0.5416160821914673,
-0.06865879893302917,
0.38554632663726807,
-0.2255782186985016,
0.04346821457147598,
0.2603655755519867,
0.362239807844162,
0.08845493197441101,
-0.7466365694999695,
0.5099866986274719,
-0.8630874752998352,
-0.53965824842453,
-0.3614409267902374,
-0.2513928711414337,
-0.08164235949516296,
-0.12797130644321442,
0.3365306556224823,
0.61757892370224,
0.24803030490875244,
0.4318143427371979,
0.6534498333930969,
0.288071870803833,
0.7159488201141357,
0.5744944214820862,
0.04722399264574051,
-0.3953303396701813,
0.647826075553894,
0.3767071068286896,
0.36655789613723755,
0.2818518877029419,
0.27385348081588745,
-0.6093788146972656,
-0.501539409160614,
-0.32994258403778076,
-0.23953397572040558,
-0.6531402468681335,
-0.4689350426197052,
-0.6260949969291687,
-0.6417001485824585,
-0.6612958312034607,
-0.26281577348709106,
-0.6639997959136963,
-0.4766968786716461,
-0.48738420009613037,
0.07003910839557648,
0.4432348608970642,
0.464019238948822,
0.019821714609861374,
0.7666195631027222,
-0.6805029511451721,
0.224929079413414,
0.35275253653526306,
0.11586137861013412,
0.058220382779836655,
-0.9809758067131042,
-0.18211907148361206,
0.1743016093969345,
-0.5422111749649048,
-0.7770121693611145,
0.2940250039100647,
0.24746903777122498,
0.624276876449585,
0.5760183930397034,
0.41756606101989746,
1.207856297492981,
-0.36424896121025085,
0.668317973613739,
0.5696132779121399,
-1.2148010730743408,
0.8126161694526672,
0.20200061798095703,
0.4347462058067322,
0.6329132318496704,
0.30652207136154175,
-0.4184119403362274,
-0.3202608525753021,
-0.28825095295906067,
-0.6160367727279663,
0.8648428320884705,
0.10769770294427872,
-0.20482847094535828,
0.27283036708831787,
0.2992449402809143,
-0.0008216362912207842,
0.022514285519719124,
-0.5340523719787598,
-0.21499966084957123,
-0.7160695791244507,
-0.6300708651542664,
0.2457444816827774,
-0.01881258934736252,
-0.15640220046043396,
-0.48418736457824707,
0.6646199226379395,
-0.2682427167892456,
-0.16899946331977844,
0.33210307359695435,
-0.10367294400930405,
0.041188329458236694,
0.21494288742542267,
0.19073887169361115,
0.415375292301178,
0.14975851774215698,
0.29888951778411865,
0.4461236596107483,
-0.5398156642913818,
0.48898547887802124,
-0.1747148483991623,
0.01154507976025343,
-0.18930262327194214,
-0.05122525244951248,
0.5920746326446533,
0.21165263652801514,
-0.01986978016793728,
0.6072189211845398,
0.013159189373254776,
-0.17285789549350739,
-0.1388278752565384,
0.4203483462333679,
0.02123277820646763,
0.804233729839325,
0.4535936117172241,
0.028154291212558746,
-0.048483218997716904,
-0.05337328463792801,
0.2662608027458191,
0.17064203321933746,
-0.45292454957962036,
-0.0667930617928505,
0.7226713299751282,
0.18955287337303162,
-0.21581445634365082,
0.7074397802352905,
0.21267585456371307,
-0.5677264928817749,
0.5978578329086304,
0.6515205502510071,
0.8989051580429077,
-0.6660140752792358,
0.025906892493367195,
0.5555868744850159,
-0.18129734694957733,
-0.29602304100990295,
-0.13947710394859314,
-0.5103423595428467,
-0.7375131249427795,
-0.20781399309635162,
-0.6437236070632935,
0.100433848798275,
-0.3264511525630951,
-0.995913028717041,
0.4888189733028412,
-0.28214988112449646,
-0.3757513165473938,
0.12525415420532227,
-0.13625088334083557,
-0.5338069200515747,
0.1545647531747818,
0.03103531524538994,
0.7650907635688782,
-0.5880531072616577,
1.4594558477401733,
0.20852214097976685,
-0.36777442693710327,
-1.1758521795272827,
-0.08220979571342468,
0.14471153914928436,
-0.6538023352622986,
0.9807897806167603,
-0.048180773854255676,
-0.2363952100276947,
0.19470392167568207,
-0.2682982385158539,
-0.8407878875732422,
1.5748450756072998,
0.23226390779018402,
-1.1969882249832153,
-0.27527284622192383,
0.21452990174293518,
0.5772111415863037,
-0.5606698989868164,
0.13803398609161377,
0.5452126264572144,
0.21680136024951935,
0.8258115649223328,
-1.1395984888076782,
-0.12646549940109253,
-0.014680891297757626,
0.18980008363723755,
0.04363198205828667,
-0.4293895959854126,
0.36468505859375,
-0.04323667660355568,
-0.461319237947464,
-0.3565833270549774,
0.8422423601150513,
0.06310926377773285,
0.434081107378006,
0.7473182678222656,
0.6802819967269897,
0.4808165729045868,
-0.18402761220932007,
-0.028927478939294815,
-0.5154931545257568,
0.4111914336681366,
1.4861111640930176,
-0.07925769686698914,
0.6143814921379089,
0.580264687538147,
-0.2319670468568802,
0.3769047260284424,
0.2656984031200409,
-0.21853207051753998,
0.8951357007026672,
0.032313693314790726,
-0.08712682127952576,
-0.3385005295276642,
0.1912360042333603,
-0.6295017600059509,
0.5889368653297424,
-0.006791506893932819,
-0.31412842869758606,
-0.2810477018356323,
0.16984042525291443,
-0.29507189989089966,
0.15884704887866974,
-0.37526294589042664,
1.1991196870803833,
-0.045166343450546265,
-0.5485104322433472,
0.605421245098114,
-0.4658200740814209,
0.8806583285331726,
-0.5022222399711609,
0.10381583869457245,
-0.005981259513646364,
0.25170662999153137,
-0.33219701051712036,
-0.7455567717552185,
0.5253587365150452,
0.10170520842075348,
-0.2958184480667114,
-0.21102549135684967,
0.4095110595226288,
-0.7991637587547302,
-0.15794652700424194,
0.30376556515693665,
0.09430019557476044,
-0.0029044663533568382,
0.12939397990703583,
-0.5545517802238464,
0.020491426810622215,
0.04370231553912163,
0.276879221200943,
0.3186185359954834,
0.5795073509216309,
0.35485562682151794,
0.5857042074203491,
0.36271679401397705,
-0.14253856241703033,
0.3957269787788391,
0.14189401268959045,
0.9979822635650635,
-0.42770683765411377,
-0.550477147102356,
-0.8943198323249817,
0.5567088723182678,
-0.04917007312178612,
-0.1888209879398346,
0.46342727541923523,
0.5234204530715942,
1.0169386863708496,
0.1318717896938324,
0.4710175395011902,
-0.0833376869559288,
0.44682446122169495,
-0.49507030844688416,
1.0519481897354126,
-0.3004951775074005,
0.4265214204788208,
-0.2412043958902359,
-0.6582778692245483,
0.12533104419708252,
0.8433240652084351,
-0.14584055542945862,
-0.05495033413171768,
0.5684034824371338,
0.8095482587814331,
0.005774493794888258,
0.3948892652988434,
0.2386026382446289,
0.1158740222454071,
0.4245791733264923,
0.4063988924026489,
0.8051648736000061,
-0.28728991746902466,
0.6078564524650574,
-0.6432170271873474,
-0.08598682284355164,
0.10283685475587845,
-0.810112476348877,
-0.956981360912323,
-0.9932386875152588,
-0.6845343112945557,
-0.24386100471019745,
0.2851318120956421,
1.165074348449707,
0.815153181552887,
-0.8325233459472656,
-0.10761025547981262,
-0.09634362161159515,
-0.2006133645772934,
-0.29583361744880676,
-0.21409258246421814,
0.46223774552345276,
-0.45193156599998474,
-0.6929873824119568,
0.4156953692436218,
-0.058919571340084076,
0.2969858646392822,
-0.1761164516210556,
-0.11839157342910767,
-0.09642789512872696,
-0.36660343408584595,
0.05770392343401909,
0.06896024942398071,
-0.626461923122406,
-0.3927740156650543,
-0.24024543166160583,
-0.14211636781692505,
0.32698675990104675,
0.9971473813056946,
-1.0077641010284424,
0.7860763072967529,
0.4818926155567169,
0.34605512022972107,
0.7019115686416626,
0.18107284605503082,
0.5548200607299805,
-0.7996722459793091,
-0.052811309695243835,
0.1467176079750061,
0.3442450761795044,
0.09524509310722351,
-0.3889797329902649,
0.34582796692848206,
0.12192901968955994,
-0.7970434427261353,
-0.6302785277366638,
-0.2375694215297699,
-1.0410048961639404,
-0.1124466061592102,
0.8327987194061279,
-0.2931118607521057,
-0.09083428233861923,
-0.13464227318763733,
-0.3290274441242218,
0.7816488146781921,
-0.5236390829086304,
1.0711599588394165,
0.4173303246498108,
-0.1694282740354538,
-0.10581322014331818,
0.006049290765076876,
0.4999152421951294,
-0.060087237507104874,
-0.26184117794036865,
0.06832348555326462,
0.21214206516742706,
0.5023065805435181,
0.2515506446361542,
0.4029155373573303,
-0.22820158302783966,
-0.21039600670337677,
-0.15112769603729248,
0.1344197541475296,
-0.3631381094455719,
-0.592718780040741,
-0.40570691227912903,
0.08498729020357132,
-0.40883946418762207,
-0.5532140135765076
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.07900v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.07900v1
|
Exploring Self-Supervised Multi-view Contrastive Learning for Speech Emotion Recognition with Limited Annotations
| 2024-06-12T06:06:55 | 2024-06-12T06:06:55 |
Bulat Khaertdinov, Pedro Jeuris, Annanda Sousa, Enrique Hortal
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
Recent advancements in Deep and Self-Supervised Learning (SSL) have led to
substantial improvements in Speech Emotion Recognition (SER) performance,
reaching unprecedented levels. However, obtaining sufficient amounts of
accurately labeled data for training or fine-tuning the models remains a costly
and challenging task. In this paper, we propose a multi-view SSL pre-training
technique that can be applied to various representations of speech, including
the ones generated by large speech models, to improve SER performance in
scenarios where annotations are limited. Our experiments, based on wav2vec 2.0,
spectral and paralinguistic features, demonstrate that the proposed framework
boosts the SER performance, by up to 10% in Unweighted Average Recall, in
settings with extremely sparse data annotations.
|
[
-0.4674750566482544,
-0.046442288905382156,
0.2496061623096466,
0.11909174919128418,
-0.42175713181495667,
-0.2676006555557251,
0.002186767989769578,
-0.3348484933376312,
0.4423728585243225,
0.44055500626564026,
-0.6044644117355347,
-0.4226733148097992,
-0.5831009745597839,
-0.02100834995508194,
-0.001796738593839109,
0.9398541450500488,
0.1253620833158493,
0.09927405416965485,
0.029833737760782242,
-0.37125417590141296,
0.040956657379865646,
-0.7473043203353882,
-0.3358553946018219,
-0.009678029455244541,
0.653448760509491,
0.44395530223846436,
0.2048439085483551,
0.28040972352027893,
0.17355825006961823,
0.2859594523906708,
-0.022257359698414803,
0.2951233983039856,
-0.5355414748191833,
0.34918907284736633,
0.3776993751525879,
-0.21172724664211273,
-0.19030329585075378,
0.2723694145679474,
0.5352305769920349,
0.25769996643066406,
-0.06802282482385635,
0.0648033395409584,
0.24684439599514008,
0.9541396498680115,
-0.9708589315414429,
0.2806043326854706,
-0.4353281855583191,
0.4600566625595093,
-0.16186320781707764,
-0.09064150601625443,
-0.25845950841903687,
-0.20146141946315765,
0.5432649254798889,
-0.5173594951629639,
0.10125067830085754,
-0.1287347823381424,
0.32845690846443176,
0.6229276061058044,
-0.5073221921920776,
-0.047572266310453415,
-0.4222744405269623,
0.5879634022712708,
-0.6298062801361084,
0.5792706608772278,
0.5090925693511963,
0.14095337688922882,
0.3631003499031067,
-0.4648190438747406,
-0.39885413646698,
-0.0564141720533371,
-0.03811783716082573,
0.5326732993125916,
-0.047898098826408386,
0.22437041997909546,
0.25551658868789673,
0.15986377000808716,
-0.4605807363986969,
0.14691829681396484,
-0.08292593061923981,
-0.22796015441417694,
0.5719804167747498,
0.03369585797190666,
-0.25518864393234253,
-0.203115776181221,
-0.2095281034708023,
-0.41504740715026855,
-0.28405317664146423,
0.21517501771450043,
0.4218248426914215,
0.40865856409072876,
-0.48486095666885376,
0.1781330704689026,
-0.2957363426685333,
0.16010865569114685,
-0.10774832963943481,
0.14372791349887848,
0.6966519951820374,
0.09862050414085388,
-0.24947740137577057,
0.23975294828414917,
0.5894944667816162,
0.35428255796432495,
0.10038597881793976,
0.3057591915130615,
0.15110071003437042,
0.07196429371833801,
0.20355626940727234,
-0.8557277917861938,
-0.7062690258026123,
0.33447542786598206,
-0.4161573350429535,
-0.010642001405358315,
-0.20874257385730743,
-1.172249674797058,
-0.894171953201294,
-0.28644171357154846,
0.3675609230995178,
-0.20807498693466187,
-0.38551485538482666,
-0.24820750951766968,
0.12685050070285797,
0.012240612879395485,
0.47019004821777344,
-0.8295288681983948,
0.05476287007331848,
0.10876858979463577,
0.6766699552536011,
0.09211835265159607,
-0.23198673129081726,
-1.0274325609207153,
-0.13776971399784088,
-0.41452574729919434,
0.4454321563243866,
-0.7123140692710876,
-0.40218472480773926,
0.23470495641231537,
-0.27967995405197144,
0.033780671656131744,
-0.33037546277046204,
0.5303957462310791,
-0.15026381611824036,
-0.0345599390566349,
-0.22307825088500977,
-0.5100032091140747,
-0.02522263117134571,
-0.16349700093269348,
-0.6650618314743042,
0.6909716129302979,
-0.16429772973060608,
-0.8388332724571228,
0.07172799855470657,
-0.43542081117630005,
-0.6107082962989807,
-0.27044031023979187,
-0.1921677589416504,
-0.667570948600769,
0.312177449464798,
0.37327882647514343,
0.673340916633606,
0.1656688004732132,
-0.3063428997993469,
-0.5052783489227295,
-0.07229116559028625,
0.08956372737884521,
-0.3798621594905853,
-0.0028013247065246105,
0.3798117935657501,
-0.4103938043117523,
0.22228790819644928,
-1.1191846132278442,
-0.12026684731245041,
-0.19080038368701935,
-0.09960248321294785,
-0.3492024838924408,
0.029408857226371765,
-0.014910695143043995,
0.39949676394462585,
0.03332991525530815,
-0.46311989426612854,
-0.10937214642763138,
-0.48088815808296204,
0.24423548579216003,
0.6737881898880005,
-0.2342626452445984,
0.2649383246898651,
0.25953227281570435,
0.37309929728507996,
0.3593025505542755,
0.002859758445993066,
-0.3713640570640564,
-0.101308673620224,
-1.0605181455612183,
-0.3255786895751953,
0.12826122343540192,
0.3438543975353241,
-0.6334149241447449,
0.2601141333580017,
0.2569878101348877,
-0.401930570602417,
-1.1391427516937256,
0.1825096309185028,
0.7630754113197327,
0.7726420760154724,
0.7617700099945068,
-0.18621309101581573,
-0.5549629926681519,
-1.0168588161468506,
-0.05447564646601677,
0.14194446802139282,
-0.018476951867341995,
0.768687903881073,
0.21732498705387115,
0.008998862467706203,
0.4227472245693207,
-0.2670496702194214,
-0.6808006167411804,
0.1030292958021164,
0.7975729703903198,
-0.23010818660259247,
0.5173763632774353,
0.25045934319496155,
-0.8979068994522095,
-0.332096129655838,
-0.19483374059200287,
-0.5994765758514404,
-0.1300986111164093,
-0.01964716427028179,
0.13399656116962433,
0.25758248567581177,
0.32863008975982666,
0.12849117815494537,
0.5330098271369934,
0.7323130965232849,
0.1038329005241394,
0.23640400171279907,
-0.5441121459007263,
0.32531777024269104,
-0.870787501335144,
-0.4144848585128784,
0.5040006041526794,
-0.022571081295609474,
-0.7594606280326843,
-0.5865926742553711,
0.3701087236404419,
-0.25852882862091064,
-0.7271974682807922,
0.20832087099552155,
-0.4971112012863159,
-0.144121915102005,
-0.3454279899597168,
0.3309997022151947,
-0.23168504238128662,
0.5879681706428528,
0.5709967017173767,
0.6555012464523315,
0.6107386946678162,
-0.5025691390037537,
0.2535049617290497,
0.30455371737480164,
-0.06289762258529663,
0.7811198234558105,
-0.2249513417482376,
0.37832629680633545,
-0.2567231059074402,
0.3670535087585449,
-1.1286829710006714,
-0.48123013973236084,
-0.2775982618331909,
-0.31422385573387146,
0.38774558901786804,
-0.24859242141246796,
-0.06138630211353302,
-0.11247856169939041,
-0.33409860730171204,
0.22402599453926086,
0.7140480875968933,
-0.8867079615592957,
0.8725857138633728,
0.2787947654724121,
-0.2852898836135864,
-0.4702155292034149,
-0.7628005146980286,
-0.20811614394187927,
-0.3139452636241913,
-0.3581758439540863,
0.023427899926900864,
0.12649793922901154,
0.17369134724140167,
-0.3653459846973419,
-0.2066110074520111,
0.12576596438884735,
0.01969594694674015,
0.6017955541610718,
-0.08859697729349136,
0.07801499962806702,
0.460506409406662,
0.11785723268985748,
-0.09382370114326477,
-0.009541681967675686,
0.05377364903688431,
0.3011176288127899,
-0.29842451214790344,
-0.3155442476272583,
-0.8220887780189514,
0.5387933254241943,
0.1567768007516861,
-0.7226710915565491,
0.24588710069656372,
0.716534435749054,
-0.2693347930908203,
-0.07744289934635162,
-0.7785826921463013,
-0.05903836712241173,
-0.3915516436100006,
0.5233640670776367,
-0.5271079540252686,
-1.0484027862548828,
0.5167099237442017,
-0.34543377161026,
-0.2975696325302124,
0.4480508267879486,
0.3854425251483917,
-0.34107154607772827,
1.0918426513671875,
0.44260653853416443,
-0.2321936935186386,
0.46925413608551025,
0.012716435827314854,
-0.10531716048717499,
-1.138961672782898,
-0.39459705352783203,
-0.5913721919059753,
-0.32160595059394836,
-0.6852384209632874,
-0.3557356595993042,
0.5104039311408997,
-0.07851406931877136,
-0.1941649317741394,
-0.09850387275218964,
-0.4713503122329712,
0.26905858516693115,
0.5672078728675842,
0.27173396944999695,
-0.27331772446632385,
-0.25167185068130493,
-0.009958697482943535,
-0.31543397903442383,
-0.3191564381122589,
0.030625425279140472,
0.9539247751235962,
0.23528148233890533,
0.7480385303497314,
-0.15126895904541016,
1.0834143161773682,
0.17834807932376862,
-0.038742080330848694,
-0.35264092683792114,
0.28277525305747986,
-0.49077725410461426,
-0.1340235471725464,
-0.2959023714065552,
-0.4698152542114258,
-0.5726329684257507,
0.4233798384666443,
-0.5441237688064575,
-0.7490571737289429,
0.4192773699760437,
0.4992380440235138,
-0.5960550904273987,
0.0024159627500921488,
-0.9295216202735901,
0.8690028190612793,
-0.5005322694778442,
-0.5747727155685425,
-0.3217582404613495,
-1.0756068229675293,
0.08697700500488281,
-0.15335287153720856,
0.2021145224571228,
-0.14797425270080566,
0.08461229503154755,
0.6522178053855896,
-0.144733265042305,
0.900006115436554,
-0.4891641139984131,
0.08091075718402863,
0.07492039352655411,
0.0055974689312279224,
0.525181770324707,
-0.09181741625070572,
-0.06436047703027725,
-0.13851433992385864,
-0.3097246587276459,
-0.3423256576061249,
-0.4752069413661957,
0.6674010753631592,
-0.699661910533905,
-0.3162771761417389,
-0.4032977223396301,
-0.2599450945854187,
-0.6436020731925964,
-0.2676984965801239,
0.04870589077472687,
0.4012204110622406,
0.04349685460329056,
0.40197980403900146,
0.8190128803253174,
-0.30856505036354065,
0.33886152505874634,
0.34015384316444397,
0.14246766269207,
-0.5973210334777832,
1.0164650678634644,
0.07165982574224472,
0.09773669391870499,
0.16975881159305573,
0.24706882238388062,
-0.6639715433120728,
-0.39221006631851196,
-0.10020944476127625,
-0.07542409747838974,
-0.6330550312995911,
-0.11994540691375732,
-0.6728047132492065,
-0.09315737336874008,
-0.651358962059021,
-0.057744789868593216,
-0.6283877491950989,
-0.12444895505905151,
-0.635368824005127,
-0.15037037432193756,
0.3481593430042267,
0.4004717767238617,
-0.49510782957077026,
0.3458036780357361,
-0.5993378758430481,
0.4676770269870758,
0.7914072871208191,
0.35889163613319397,
-0.06762780994176865,
-0.6001002192497253,
-0.19910390675067902,
-0.05229828134179115,
-0.009612007066607475,
-0.8410137891769409,
0.5133971571922302,
0.5726068615913391,
0.2776658236980438,
0.5237514972686768,
0.41312599182128906,
0.9578462243080139,
-0.38997599482536316,
0.8229358196258545,
0.47281521558761597,
-1.146145224571228,
0.9675020575523376,
0.021747557446360588,
0.1094805970788002,
0.6511602401733398,
0.5743563175201416,
-0.24172784388065338,
-0.11985639482736588,
-0.5472790002822876,
-1.0012108087539673,
0.6616804599761963,
0.20499339699745178,
0.24017277359962463,
0.262957900762558,
0.32227444648742676,
0.07367813587188721,
0.21757633984088898,
-0.5780928134918213,
-0.30283623933792114,
-0.6994659900665283,
-0.44134360551834106,
-0.25206828117370605,
-0.4582929313182831,
-0.004070125054568052,
-0.12133807688951492,
0.5048049688339233,
-0.28559502959251404,
-0.1299242228269577,
0.44626808166503906,
-0.00895391684025526,
0.1527000367641449,
0.3782186210155487,
0.5291234254837036,
-0.13732443749904633,
-0.3221804201602936,
0.37340670824050903,
0.2917017936706543,
-0.14834585785865784,
0.028833921998739243,
0.5194381475448608,
0.4888610541820526,
-0.41872575879096985,
0.16782215237617493,
1.3342945575714111,
0.19167275726795197,
-0.5127996206283569,
0.4659561514854431,
-0.0037353697698563337,
-0.203081414103508,
-0.18639062345027924,
-0.06306856125593185,
0.040462955832481384,
0.8183640241622925,
0.3199041485786438,
-0.2485751509666443,
0.5227202773094177,
-0.3640311360359192,
0.1715494692325592,
0.17795859277248383,
-0.6187012195587158,
-0.058005355298519135,
0.8972747921943665,
0.5799216032028198,
-0.09275893867015839,
0.4292169213294983,
-0.22031056880950928,
-0.6350570321083069,
0.25756222009658813,
0.25272464752197266,
0.9774132966995239,
-0.629534900188446,
0.11982876807451248,
0.22265806794166565,
-0.15305767953395844,
0.035034194588661194,
0.29897835850715637,
-0.45408642292022705,
-0.27654507756233215,
-0.15316639840602875,
-0.4382439851760864,
-0.6885682344436646,
0.06742283701896667,
-0.7900972366333008,
0.01152235921472311,
-0.22290416061878204,
0.10493408143520355,
0.11688289046287537,
-0.029715746641159058,
-0.606752336025238,
0.6673300862312317,
0.7654239535331726,
0.34825772047042847,
-0.9054110050201416,
0.9607884287834167,
0.36963045597076416,
-0.35860079526901245,
-0.8881356120109558,
-0.03491285443305969,
0.2564190924167633,
-0.6021668314933777,
0.6277592182159424,
0.43127769231796265,
-0.605994701385498,
-0.01660909131169319,
-0.40294891595840454,
-0.4198887348175049,
0.7823324203491211,
0.30674654245376587,
-0.9175043106079102,
0.41411834955215454,
0.018280887976288795,
0.8142745494842529,
-0.5281057953834534,
0.2802656888961792,
0.5123618245124817,
0.14110615849494934,
0.24758344888687134,
-0.6914246082305908,
-0.43145129084587097,
-0.3776736259460449,
-0.049244336783885956,
-0.08772023022174835,
-0.8645064234733582,
0.7062495350837708,
-0.1483808159828186,
0.13010430335998535,
-0.15409429371356964,
0.919654905796051,
0.23723848164081573,
0.458430677652359,
0.6495090126991272,
0.5294625163078308,
0.8898541331291199,
-0.0924791470170021,
0.7738981246948242,
-0.016612747684121132,
0.2489430159330368,
1.5435802936553955,
-0.6327921152114868,
1.124557614326477,
0.22483374178409576,
-0.0794534906744957,
0.08437483012676239,
0.7844448089599609,
-0.04938916489481926,
0.7502003908157349,
0.3294405937194824,
-0.20744635164737701,
-0.6206133365631104,
-0.2620542049407959,
-0.43978404998779297,
0.5047892928123474,
0.2540570795536041,
-0.2045544534921646,
0.10851869732141495,
0.4482625424861908,
-0.1505085825920105,
0.13564400374889374,
-0.4287286400794983,
0.9279972910881042,
0.14579957723617554,
-0.07319064438343048,
0.3348170816898346,
-0.6895909905433655,
0.8322436809539795,
-0.5705480575561523,
-0.07387561351060867,
-0.37333130836486816,
-0.06044811010360718,
-0.37899717688560486,
-0.6602588295936584,
-0.13031180202960968,
0.2072037309408188,
0.2370511293411255,
-0.16792577505111694,
0.5959753394126892,
-0.7703487277030945,
-0.31480878591537476,
0.6097416281700134,
0.14438378810882568,
0.36792469024658203,
-0.38043251633644104,
-0.43039825558662415,
0.0397433340549469,
-0.037942659109830856,
-0.3820895254611969,
0.5186176896095276,
0.5303243398666382,
0.42837822437286377,
0.5145385265350342,
0.18713316321372986,
0.009980722330510616,
0.18542541563510895,
0.4004990756511688,
0.8091720938682556,
-0.6821480393409729,
-0.730888843536377,
-0.565636157989502,
0.735314667224884,
-0.1984947770833969,
-0.38554608821868896,
0.4848408102989197,
0.5046448111534119,
0.785887598991394,
-0.02600262127816677,
0.7761071920394897,
0.4588633179664612,
0.8073915243148804,
-0.6179529428482056,
0.5409581065177917,
-1.0004628896713257,
-0.1929822713136673,
-0.5084217190742493,
-0.42256754636764526,
-0.3329886794090271,
0.8242766857147217,
-0.10562090575695038,
0.03279757872223854,
0.4473145306110382,
0.355559378862381,
0.27017733454704285,
0.1861303299665451,
0.5105799436569214,
0.25502097606658936,
0.1377304196357727,
0.7466393709182739,
0.7948836088180542,
-0.1674320548772812,
0.5798470973968506,
-0.5768342614173889,
-0.1279909312725067,
-0.3096829950809479,
-0.8862072825431824,
-0.9183745980262756,
-0.733156681060791,
-0.5395512580871582,
-0.18271617591381073,
0.11550040543079376,
1.054513692855835,
0.9241111874580383,
-0.6863106489181519,
0.07567379623651505,
0.29476186633110046,
-0.44228577613830566,
0.1293213963508606,
-0.0203094482421875,
0.5963406562805176,
-0.38488009572029114,
-0.70417320728302,
0.4263139069080353,
0.3719879388809204,
0.21203207969665527,
-0.06140381842851639,
-0.21873530745506287,
0.017268415540456772,
-0.087932288646698,
0.5036682486534119,
0.27631643414497375,
-0.695912778377533,
-0.3685903251171112,
-0.49059775471687317,
0.11253974586725235,
0.29993128776550293,
0.5450724959373474,
-0.7726126909255981,
0.8836002349853516,
0.08551031351089478,
0.8262760639190674,
0.9885222911834717,
0.14684179425239563,
-0.011546335183084011,
-1.0069820880889893,
0.3280963897705078,
0.29972219467163086,
0.44182661175727844,
0.2764037549495697,
-0.1901090145111084,
0.4115946292877197,
-0.10462477803230286,
-0.4959004521369934,
-0.590739369392395,
0.33624792098999023,
-1.1749629974365234,
0.026092154905200005,
0.899560809135437,
-0.42681851983070374,
0.1230301484465599,
0.417092502117157,
-0.4040873348712921,
0.3886409401893616,
-0.7241926789283752,
0.8301864266395569,
0.5355937480926514,
-0.6158355474472046,
-0.632271945476532,
-0.2879277169704437,
0.762454628944397,
0.6345173120498657,
-1.042299509048462,
0.3566170930862427,
0.8120386004447937,
-0.0935656949877739,
0.17191104590892792,
0.3903178572654724,
0.09801920503377914,
0.17755194008350372,
0.0691952258348465,
0.16584384441375732,
-0.10962603986263275,
-0.5109690427780151,
-0.8969597816467285,
0.3497479259967804,
-0.21360911428928375,
-0.41378211975097656
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.07890v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.07890v1
|
Exploring Speech Foundation Models for Speaker Diarization in Child-Adult Dyadic Interactions
| 2024-06-12T05:41:01 | 2024-06-12T05:41:01 |
Anfeng Xu, Kevin Huang, Tiantian Feng, Lue Shen, Helen Tager-Flusberg, Shrikanth Narayanan
|
eess.AS
|
eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Speech foundation models, trained on vast datasets, have opened unique
opportunities in addressing challenging low-resource speech understanding, such
as child speech. In this work, we explore the capabilities of speech foundation
models on child-adult speaker diarization. We show that exemplary foundation
models can achieve 39.5% and 62.3% relative reductions in Diarization Error
Rate and Speaker Confusion Rate, respectively, compared to previous speaker
diarization methods. In addition, we benchmark and evaluate the speaker
diarization results of the speech foundation models with varying the input
audio window size, speaker demographics, and training data ratio. Our results
highlight promising pathways for understanding and adopting speech foundation
models to facilitate child speech understanding.
|
[
-0.568730890750885,
-0.6555619239807129,
0.08820550888776779,
0.2487834244966507,
0.005393552128225565,
0.1855625957250595,
-0.20242439210414886,
-0.5733667016029358,
-0.38584885001182556,
0.37912091612815857,
-0.6768972277641296,
-0.1335243582725525,
-0.5595582723617554,
-0.06928014755249023,
-0.41759657859802246,
0.4009031057357788,
0.19344128668308258,
0.17334076762199402,
-0.18294011056423187,
0.4750981330871582,
-0.43885496258735657,
-0.29875943064689636,
-0.9260683059692383,
-0.635883092880249,
0.20541810989379883,
0.6436365246772766,
0.48313000798225403,
0.802017092704773,
0.5514400601387024,
0.26107922196388245,
-0.44266384840011597,
-0.42933300137519836,
-0.7985983490943909,
0.0647437646985054,
-0.13053080439567566,
0.03875244781374931,
-0.5811854004859924,
0.1994810849428177,
0.9007077813148499,
1.5509424209594727,
-0.6196353435516357,
-0.2506146728992462,
-0.229949489235878,
0.8196090459823608,
-0.6486534476280212,
0.23211033642292023,
-0.6782945990562439,
0.34673193097114563,
-0.16836851835250854,
0.05582128092646599,
-0.6017676591873169,
0.2829974889755249,
0.40108248591423035,
-0.1998995840549469,
0.6302410364151001,
-0.43044179677963257,
0.4042440950870514,
0.31892016530036926,
-0.4174419045448303,
0.005915119778364897,
-1.2532455921173096,
0.4247494041919708,
-0.49920064210891724,
0.8524129390716553,
0.7446601986885071,
0.41831326484680176,
-0.24898836016654968,
-0.6518317461013794,
-0.5665579438209534,
-0.05616600811481476,
-0.20463860034942627,
-0.3268096148967743,
-0.4672728180885315,
0.41719213128089905,
0.13398122787475586,
0.553854763507843,
-0.3248058259487152,
-0.010160357691347599,
-0.28809621930122375,
0.06146399676799774,
0.6867199540138245,
0.10535550862550735,
0.1986108273267746,
-0.02413506619632244,
-0.27964287996292114,
-0.1931385099887848,
-0.5943751335144043,
0.26266878843307495,
0.038694705814123154,
0.587698221206665,
-0.19850008189678192,
0.34783583879470825,
-0.35056036710739136,
1.0247308015823364,
0.3667382299900055,
-0.3488903045654297,
-0.07471294701099396,
-0.44695067405700684,
-0.46592584252357483,
0.41497576236724854,
0.27332162857055664,
0.19338388741016388,
0.4257456362247467,
-0.26607662439346313,
-0.1471601277589798,
0.10632746666669846,
-0.02037663944065571,
-1.1272305250167847,
-0.6115884184837341,
-0.15935058891773224,
-0.4984055459499359,
-0.08753028512001038,
0.021777605637907982,
-0.8681835532188416,
-0.7281492948532104,
-0.1567995548248291,
0.03131464868783951,
-0.35567325353622437,
-0.5983098745346069,
0.4248778522014618,
0.03792988136410713,
0.09831833094358444,
0.12759913504123688,
-1.327211856842041,
0.913388729095459,
0.6063559651374817,
0.38341617584228516,
0.018332816660404205,
0.04875683784484863,
-0.7928462028503418,
0.3016635775566101,
-0.32057034969329834,
0.19967199862003326,
-0.6750617027282715,
-0.790166437625885,
-0.4552948772907257,
-0.32804661989212036,
-0.5804377198219299,
-0.6115683317184448,
0.11378122866153717,
-0.29877540469169617,
-0.18029017746448517,
0.03444649279117584,
-0.4309239387512207,
-0.06226027384400368,
-0.17945225536823273,
-0.5897830128669739,
0.24703268706798553,
0.17703163623809814,
-0.8452538251876831,
0.3403639793395996,
-0.3427019715309143,
-0.5176694393157959,
-0.1392306238412857,
-0.07063989341259003,
-0.32149016857147217,
0.1608709692955017,
0.30602601170539856,
0.380683958530426,
-0.049694404006004333,
0.38436564803123474,
-0.0047983028925955296,
-0.4905899465084076,
0.19603142142295837,
-0.7160689234733582,
0.5382609963417053,
0.1183229610323906,
-0.46684467792510986,
-0.4107057452201843,
-0.9345154166221619,
-0.6367602348327637,
0.16856710612773895,
-0.30731895565986633,
-0.32546037435531616,
0.06901761144399643,
-0.02964344248175621,
-0.05906962230801582,
-0.10363130271434784,
-0.5606343746185303,
-0.032351501286029816,
-0.6311392188072205,
0.5296891331672668,
0.2693155109882355,
0.3013785183429718,
0.2672378122806549,
-0.12269588559865952,
0.5200556516647339,
0.08777207881212234,
-0.12074422836303711,
-0.10075884312391281,
-0.4250037670135498,
-0.7439718246459961,
-0.40061110258102417,
0.406524658203125,
0.2291916161775589,
-0.34923362731933594,
0.10606333613395691,
-0.30567508935928345,
-0.22019608318805695,
-0.4130036532878876,
-0.22765366733074188,
0.7814711332321167,
0.8417927622795105,
0.23078219592571259,
-0.404690146446228,
-0.666576087474823,
-0.8460495471954346,
0.23199580609798431,
-0.5358830094337463,
0.23488911986351013,
0.48878008127212524,
0.3168606162071228,
-0.01905745454132557,
1.228556513786316,
-0.06959035992622375,
0.17633576691150665,
-0.06660327315330505,
0.09058594703674316,
0.07286995649337769,
0.4519844353199005,
0.6968143582344055,
-1.2503498792648315,
-0.6583606004714966,
-0.18048954010009766,
0.08001479506492615,
-0.07917653024196625,
0.29224711656570435,
0.20315340161323547,
-0.33972349762916565,
0.1791388988494873,
-0.5251629948616028,
0.8745108842849731,
0.46049773693084717,
-0.47994524240493774,
0.2310539335012436,
0.33466604351997375,
0.21123312413692474,
-0.6206414103507996,
0.054391153156757355,
-0.016166921705007553,
-0.23660247027873993,
-1.1773316860198975,
-0.28808772563934326,
-0.3888471722602844,
-0.22254279255867004,
-0.4692288637161255,
0.2438047230243683,
-0.24750417470932007,
-0.3279247581958771,
-0.05421267822384834,
0.4634776711463928,
-0.15527667105197906,
0.018076607957482338,
0.2453174889087677,
1.0840418338775635,
0.367015540599823,
-0.5400316715240479,
0.3515968322753906,
0.4817913770675659,
-0.21800807118415833,
0.6937921047210693,
-0.6573896408081055,
0.232615128159523,
-0.0255134180188179,
0.4316292405128479,
-1.4092239141464233,
-0.37832948565483093,
0.23170998692512512,
-0.38081249594688416,
0.6239281296730042,
-0.5060346722602844,
-0.15604537725448608,
-0.3146360218524933,
0.00541776092723012,
0.365373432636261,
0.0842369943857193,
-0.6110761165618896,
0.2636978030204773,
0.5509423017501831,
-0.46983951330184937,
-0.7253307104110718,
-0.7307782173156738,
0.12408040463924408,
-0.19006966054439545,
-0.8157208561897278,
1.040343165397644,
-0.17222914099693298,
-0.6933817863464355,
-0.09611079096794128,
-0.21499276161193848,
-0.21918201446533203,
0.08931661397218704,
0.19820955395698547,
-0.21341684460639954,
-0.2466050684452057,
0.15096303820610046,
-0.24969497323036194,
-0.22508201003074646,
-0.1718778759241104,
0.29584214091300964,
0.6377357244491577,
-0.26274028420448303,
-0.30319300293922424,
-0.5557145476341248,
0.07920866459608078,
0.3013001084327698,
-0.29054468870162964,
0.7690451145172119,
0.4782641530036926,
-0.7701781392097473,
0.003245392581447959,
-0.20982931554317474,
-0.3065986633300781,
-0.38437125086784363,
0.2966935634613037,
-0.7341696619987488,
-0.5796408653259277,
0.31077298521995544,
0.013745865784585476,
-0.22201159596443176,
0.012100519612431526,
0.4458365738391876,
0.06306277215480804,
0.8319535851478577,
0.7186749577522278,
-0.037529539316892624,
0.4267328083515167,
-0.4053085744380951,
0.24655909836292267,
-0.7453499436378479,
-0.1846867948770523,
-0.5516673922538757,
-0.1996270716190338,
-0.3158069849014282,
-0.3978908360004425,
0.00820417795330286,
0.37978595495224,
-0.04400862008333206,
0.28290408849716187,
-0.35509955883026123,
0.3588419258594513,
0.02033834531903267,
0.09420972317457199,
0.43772321939468384,
0.011925260536372662,
-0.007464863825589418,
-0.02204958349466324,
-0.5951318740844727,
-0.2238689363002777,
0.5681325793266296,
0.7958347201347351,
0.6668586730957031,
0.280053973197937,
0.634330153465271,
0.28165557980537415,
0.06251808255910873,
-0.5319953560829163,
0.47810283303260803,
-0.4630514681339264,
-0.5847207307815552,
-0.4942084848880768,
-0.6124900579452515,
-0.7750565409660339,
0.37155553698539734,
-0.004967124201357365,
-0.9906122088432312,
0.819559633731842,
0.03780439496040344,
-0.42408573627471924,
0.13942481577396393,
-0.575315535068512,
0.7412986755371094,
0.2577421963214874,
0.039257146418094635,
-0.5113288164138794,
-0.6476651430130005,
0.30636700987815857,
0.1362875998020172,
0.3460734784603119,
-0.19833819568157196,
0.2300654947757721,
0.7374123930931091,
-0.2525443434715271,
1.0121376514434814,
-0.4310862720012665,
-0.13221044838428497,
0.17076851427555084,
0.14573906362056732,
0.18980778753757477,
0.12429048866033554,
-0.3320528566837311,
-0.28814440965652466,
-0.26459890604019165,
-0.24512304365634918,
-0.2181263566017151,
0.7125476598739624,
-0.7956826090812683,
-0.49444153904914856,
-0.11502768844366074,
-0.47499093413352966,
-0.5294655561447144,
-0.04573548212647438,
-0.2862224876880646,
0.5303974151611328,
-0.5611478090286255,
0.6286801695823669,
0.885917603969574,
0.35105863213539124,
0.6165568232536316,
0.7710441946983337,
-0.1288086324930191,
-0.4763677716255188,
0.6153614521026611,
-0.16840706765651703,
0.4190964102745056,
0.37987020611763,
0.15013998746871948,
-0.19300729036331177,
-0.7152596712112427,
-0.39171674847602844,
0.21603967249393463,
-0.741956889629364,
0.19860702753067017,
-0.4828721582889557,
-0.39137721061706543,
-0.43865320086479187,
0.155986025929451,
-0.423156201839447,
-0.634170413017273,
-0.16095437109470367,
-0.45530542731285095,
0.12527276575565338,
0.6822385191917419,
-0.11779552698135376,
0.7036247849464417,
-0.27402031421661377,
0.29787328839302063,
0.673527181148529,
0.3968020975589752,
0.17740951478481293,
-0.4251025319099426,
-0.11479754745960236,
0.21691466867923737,
-0.13114961981773376,
-1.1954855918884277,
-0.029401833191514015,
0.5207892656326294,
0.5482358932495117,
0.38710516691207886,
0.029279498383402824,
0.7385051250457764,
-0.32744187116622925,
0.7519838213920593,
0.09294251352548599,
-1.0771960020065308,
0.5098704099655151,
-0.4587608277797699,
-0.22265806794166565,
0.588948667049408,
-0.017937008291482925,
-0.5623324513435364,
0.4025910496711731,
-0.6031654477119446,
-0.6117334365844727,
0.8893730044364929,
0.5512564778327942,
-0.08657363802194595,
0.2728929817676544,
0.23661665618419647,
-0.0802399292588234,
0.5081730484962463,
-0.3796163499355316,
-0.2501114010810852,
-0.06375844031572342,
0.11279051005840302,
-0.24024377763271332,
-0.2951561212539673,
-0.3177793622016907,
-0.38032227754592896,
0.5525096654891968,
0.26972734928131104,
0.11552150547504425,
0.021904895082116127,
0.08844829350709915,
-0.6795140504837036,
0.23716126382350922,
0.5404549241065979,
0.8616836071014404,
-0.3950035274028778,
0.23487912118434906,
-0.025094464421272278,
-0.5218328237533569,
0.26486459374427795,
0.6266940832138062,
0.10429101437330246,
-0.19300691783428192,
0.5541227459907532,
0.9476694464683533,
0.34092000126838684,
-0.3756468594074249,
0.4749681055545807,
-0.35890400409698486,
-0.010833553969860077,
-0.032531216740608215,
0.17165322601795197,
0.32658207416534424,
0.03951451927423477,
0.22712278366088867,
-0.12056936323642731,
0.1232919991016388,
-0.42851611971855164,
0.6006219983100891,
0.20684008300304413,
-0.5685687065124512,
-0.19934962689876556,
0.44630733132362366,
0.5463528633117676,
-0.5161786675453186,
0.8099044561386108,
0.07895974069833755,
-0.3421938121318817,
0.6314587593078613,
0.6321007609367371,
0.7269179821014404,
-0.6479412317276001,
0.3384908437728882,
-0.18674027919769287,
0.06900060176849365,
0.4638175666332245,
-0.023181693628430367,
-0.39213934540748596,
-0.880379319190979,
-0.2005438208580017,
-0.5772049427032471,
-0.5818926692008972,
0.23766791820526123,
-0.5599819421768188,
0.13933366537094116,
-0.32546550035476685,
-0.3685332238674164,
0.3593153953552246,
0.2669221758842468,
-0.48088663816452026,
0.4045153558254242,
0.567028284072876,
0.8448501825332642,
-0.868865966796875,
0.6696231961250305,
0.6704480648040771,
-0.18981261551380157,
-0.3757804036140442,
0.19354669749736786,
0.018621310591697693,
-0.3401740491390228,
0.4727919399738312,
0.23635029792785645,
-0.4912314713001251,
0.20115381479263306,
-0.14753228425979614,
-0.4801238477230072,
1.0444362163543701,
0.3323986530303955,
-0.734480619430542,
0.04031912609934807,
0.4640918970108032,
0.5001847147941589,
-0.8387254476547241,
0.09581097960472107,
1.0487126111984253,
0.5130010843276978,
0.34162676334381104,
-1.2605308294296265,
-0.35882124304771423,
-0.242495596408844,
0.36556002497673035,
-0.007946936413645744,
-0.4710051715373993,
1.0857137441635132,
-0.22361205518245697,
-0.20286741852760315,
0.006566275376826525,
0.4554182291030884,
0.33915823698043823,
0.6735943555831909,
1.046207308769226,
0.3385206162929535,
0.5564701557159424,
-0.1474086493253708,
0.46807530522346497,
-0.3421841859817505,
0.22287507355213165,
0.849295973777771,
-0.2585276961326599,
0.743313193321228,
0.582634449005127,
-0.475772887468338,
0.403144508600235,
0.9205124378204346,
0.4846581518650055,
0.6814764738082886,
0.37580442428588867,
-0.47714585065841675,
-0.19672338664531708,
-0.292407363653183,
-0.43925538659095764,
0.5726329684257507,
0.7666630744934082,
-0.16097621619701385,
-0.054282333701848984,
0.1519586443901062,
-0.09102966636419296,
0.35600546002388,
-0.07281889021396637,
0.652235746383667,
0.22977982461452484,
-0.12455596029758453,
0.8256319761276245,
0.08685636520385742,
0.2234189808368683,
-0.27132031321525574,
-0.13768276572227478,
-0.1652528941631317,
0.2556985318660736,
-0.2983323931694031,
-0.5798512697219849,
0.11966964602470398,
0.0159154050052166,
-0.5281198620796204,
-0.21098507940769196,
0.782582700252533,
-0.5309581160545349,
-0.06062676012516022,
0.41468116641044617,
0.32988855242729187,
-0.04650518298149109,
0.2389126718044281,
-0.5838954448699951,
0.14806953072547913,
-0.03984413668513298,
-0.33207952976226807,
0.15667949616909027,
0.09252730756998062,
0.20381459593772888,
0.5499658584594727,
0.31273719668388367,
0.021222980692982674,
-0.07804001867771149,
0.35925546288490295,
0.7057328224182129,
-0.20469576120376587,
-0.5564384460449219,
-0.6520600914955139,
0.5207250118255615,
0.03512062877416611,
-0.08956202864646912,
0.16675539314746857,
0.19158117473125458,
0.8469762206077576,
0.015061086043715477,
0.3826415538787842,
-0.21078015863895416,
0.5417283773422241,
-0.19477523863315582,
0.5667821764945984,
-0.1401619166135788,
0.38816598057746887,
-0.3856927156448364,
-0.7754702568054199,
-0.03266417607665062,
0.7573037147521973,
-0.3757958710193634,
0.32025668025016785,
0.08858725428581238,
0.5515492558479309,
-0.288563996553421,
0.473075807094574,
0.22317269444465637,
0.24790959060192108,
0.6099717617034912,
0.54820716381073,
0.7196625471115112,
-0.10427181422710419,
0.32788124680519104,
-0.9521313309669495,
-0.4481528401374817,
-0.38010117411613464,
-0.651695191860199,
-0.9997855424880981,
-0.47097527980804443,
-0.28227534890174866,
0.0033180166501551867,
0.6097396612167358,
0.7905153632164001,
1.1868209838867188,
-0.7929586172103882,
-0.42853838205337524,
-0.21089904010295868,
-0.05995757132768631,
-0.3854968547821045,
-0.19946777820587158,
0.15003398060798645,
0.35108792781829834,
-0.7459791302680969,
1.1595209836959839,
-0.07940758764743805,
0.2181735783815384,
-0.5308921933174133,
-0.2654017210006714,
-0.12448700517416,
0.12902279198169708,
0.22181378304958344,
0.11407604068517685,
-0.6042077541351318,
-0.26878079771995544,
-0.25049474835395813,
-0.0354451909661293,
-0.023262226954102516,
0.759030818939209,
-0.7710332274436951,
0.6478481888771057,
0.491349995136261,
0.3127855360507965,
0.7904022932052612,
0.3710252344608307,
0.7196844816207886,
-1.0431007146835327,
0.3684193789958954,
0.18286147713661194,
0.14177341759204865,
0.7705637812614441,
-0.34847351908683777,
0.7028989791870117,
0.45818862318992615,
-0.28938916325569153,
-1.0586918592453003,
0.444644957780838,
-0.5722587704658508,
0.09613604098558426,
0.6170680522918701,
-0.2869201898574829,
0.22709183394908905,
0.054373111575841904,
-0.05453549325466156,
0.2699355483055115,
-0.30781733989715576,
0.6097654700279236,
0.7124475240707397,
-0.4472675025463104,
-0.4103139638900757,
-0.3622206747531891,
0.6054769158363342,
0.1458737850189209,
-0.329274445772171,
0.37243589758872986,
0.308302640914917,
0.14516378939151764,
0.2643473148345947,
0.7671981453895569,
0.17255806922912598,
0.2951754331588745,
0.18725042045116425,
-0.12235169112682343,
-0.06372101604938507,
-0.7675539255142212,
-0.4063449203968048,
0.007564113009721041,
0.008068700321018696,
-0.2996809482574463
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.07887v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.07887v1
|
An Empirical Study of Mamba-based Language Models
| 2024-06-12T05:25:15 | 2024-06-12T05:25:15 |
Roger Waleffe, Wonmin Byeon, Duncan Riach, Brandon Norick, Vijay Korthikanti, Tri Dao, Albert Gu, Ali Hatamizadeh, Sudhakar Singh, Deepak Narayanan, Garvit Kulshreshtha, Vartika Singh, Jared Casper, Jan Kautz, Mohammad Shoeybi, Bryan Catanzaro
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Selective state-space models (SSMs) like Mamba overcome some of the
shortcomings of Transformers, such as quadratic computational complexity with
sequence length and large inference-time memory requirements from the key-value
cache. Moreover, recent studies have shown that SSMs can match or exceed the
language modeling capabilities of Transformers, making them an attractive
alternative. In a controlled setting (e.g., same data), however, studies so far
have only presented small scale experiments comparing SSMs to Transformers. To
understand the strengths and weaknesses of these architectures at larger
scales, we present a direct comparison between 8B-parameter Mamba, Mamba-2, and
Transformer models trained on the same datasets of up to 3.5T tokens. We also
compare these models to a hybrid architecture consisting of 43% Mamba-2, 7%
attention, and 50% MLP layers (Mamba-2-Hybrid). Using a diverse set of tasks,
we answer the question of whether Mamba models can match Transformers at larger
training budgets. Our results show that while pure SSMs match or exceed
Transformers on many tasks, they lag behind Transformers on tasks which require
strong copying or in-context learning abilities (e.g., 5-shot MMLU, Phonebook)
or long-context reasoning. In contrast, we find that the 8B Mamba-2-Hybrid
exceeds the 8B Transformer on all 12 standard tasks we evaluated (+2.65 points
on average) and is predicted to be up to 8x faster when generating tokens at
inference time. To validate long-context capabilities, we provide additional
experiments evaluating variants of the Mamba-2-Hybrid and Transformer extended
to support 16K, 32K, and 128K sequences. On an additional 23 long-context
tasks, the hybrid model continues to closely match or exceed the Transformer on
average. To enable further study, we release the checkpoints as well as the
code used to train our models as part of NVIDIA's Megatron-LM project.
|
[
-0.6858692765235901,
-0.6882241368293762,
0.46092846989631653,
0.13211901485919952,
-0.16623400151729584,
0.27432581782341003,
-0.24392017722129822,
-0.36006373167037964,
0.21277526021003723,
0.5918842554092407,
-0.37377795577049255,
0.07925841212272644,
-0.5674198865890503,
0.07839950174093246,
-0.46326467394828796,
0.5215726494789124,
-0.05802806466817856,
-0.050765298306941986,
-0.09099768102169037,
-0.30352383852005005,
-0.577475368976593,
-0.6360918879508972,
-0.39890554547309875,
-0.36585572361946106,
0.45730072259902954,
0.21262037754058838,
0.9580528140068054,
0.46509692072868347,
0.4100695848464966,
0.22725199162960052,
-0.43464395403862,
0.21752992272377014,
-0.23285874724388123,
-0.09546055644750595,
-0.21902434527873993,
-0.5143526196479797,
-0.33270689845085144,
-0.005215325392782688,
0.7615141272544861,
0.678926408290863,
-0.19682414829730988,
0.283376544713974,
0.025737084448337555,
0.6834174394607544,
-0.7701852917671204,
0.2289365530014038,
-0.648581326007843,
0.17693136632442474,
-0.1244933009147644,
0.2312086671590805,
-0.6742264032363892,
-0.17959299683570862,
-0.1380055695772171,
-0.44819194078445435,
-0.03629908710718155,
0.1648653745651245,
1.0653437376022339,
0.39845722913742065,
-0.5825058817863464,
-0.2050093412399292,
-1.0809680223464966,
0.915408194065094,
-0.6692439317703247,
0.37542828917503357,
0.20101726055145264,
0.738324761390686,
-0.18622078001499176,
-0.3478020131587982,
-0.6665375828742981,
-0.30939599871635437,
-0.06418632715940475,
0.2301727831363678,
-0.24620918929576874,
-0.10914109647274017,
0.5417492985725403,
0.48060646653175354,
-0.3887366056442261,
0.3855192959308624,
-0.658884584903717,
-0.16742372512817383,
0.31101569533348083,
0.3675720989704132,
0.09847310185432434,
-0.46057575941085815,
-0.41364383697509766,
-0.16205191612243652,
-0.7443017363548279,
0.2105080783367157,
0.2999458312988281,
0.25618094205856323,
-0.15522922575473785,
0.7628057599067688,
0.12394002825021744,
0.7915753126144409,
0.06143539398908615,
-0.1984911561012268,
0.06724559515714645,
-0.36376652121543884,
-0.2780870795249939,
-0.284665584564209,
0.6931525468826294,
0.10012053698301315,
0.1256675124168396,
-0.25030985474586487,
-0.1582038253545761,
0.26615622639656067,
0.5562820434570312,
-0.6704102754592896,
0.16924794018268585,
0.06864216923713684,
-0.5055114030838013,
0.10612481087446213,
-0.17332208156585693,
-0.7365667819976807,
-0.3381754457950592,
-0.5220524668693542,
0.5222605466842651,
-0.541179358959198,
-0.40481624007225037,
0.021925153210759163,
-0.004878536332398653,
0.5408270359039307,
-0.06431369483470917,
-0.8636642694473267,
0.4255429804325104,
0.5770174264907837,
0.9244345426559448,
-0.36744701862335205,
-0.17985212802886963,
-0.15838560461997986,
0.06472612172365189,
-0.5179262161254883,
0.6030025482177734,
-0.7431285977363586,
-0.5840848088264465,
-0.18310266733169556,
-0.1347031146287918,
-0.3059949278831482,
-0.8217585682868958,
0.33377596735954285,
-0.4668436348438263,
-0.025865353643894196,
-0.3280157148838043,
-0.5325630903244019,
-0.1086321473121643,
-0.021796034649014473,
-0.8665274381637573,
1.1636085510253906,
0.3876611590385437,
-0.3562808036804199,
0.5287429094314575,
-0.661139190196991,
-0.6174463629722595,
-0.3205376863479614,
-0.18202447891235352,
-0.49466845393180847,
0.1536586582660675,
0.0493762269616127,
0.6132694482803345,
-0.6106479167938232,
0.3302649259567261,
-0.314323753118515,
-0.6183411478996277,
0.19888678193092346,
-0.08212997764348984,
0.5907560586929321,
0.29659900069236755,
-0.5335507392883301,
0.1350678950548172,
-0.8819578886032104,
-0.34656989574432373,
0.4077814817428589,
-0.3767320215702057,
-0.15773536264896393,
0.2397174835205078,
-0.20855720341205597,
0.5872332453727722,
-0.10058023035526276,
-0.40385982394218445,
0.15175992250442505,
-0.43143120408058167,
0.638187050819397,
0.6098511815071106,
-0.40406563878059387,
0.7213849425315857,
-0.177909716963768,
0.7501429319381714,
0.2775983214378357,
0.23209340870380402,
-0.2995232343673706,
-0.470562219619751,
-0.921750009059906,
-0.36523112654685974,
0.24383923411369324,
0.39722615480422974,
-0.730865478515625,
0.568071722984314,
-0.3075581192970276,
-0.6813602447509766,
-0.4839620590209961,
-0.020199935883283615,
0.24526740610599518,
0.3807045519351959,
0.5292072892189026,
-0.2654455304145813,
-0.4903527498245239,
-1.397379994392395,
0.01426623109728098,
0.19090020656585693,
-0.13246768712997437,
0.6497219800949097,
0.5352296829223633,
-0.13496297597885132,
1.0104694366455078,
-0.14455294609069824,
-0.08766486495733261,
-0.5438098907470703,
-0.2920520007610321,
0.22147899866104126,
0.2787468731403351,
0.8130366206169128,
-0.6674461960792542,
-0.17067672312259674,
-0.11725331097841263,
-0.559524416923523,
0.19053302705287933,
-0.15411235392093658,
0.08813104033470154,
0.10010969638824463,
0.36932530999183655,
-0.8229427337646484,
0.1901402324438095,
0.7920302748680115,
-0.08744332194328308,
0.41641509532928467,
-0.03807033225893974,
-0.05209088698029518,
-1.3393582105636597,
0.15055836737155914,
0.058389078825712204,
0.06599186360836029,
-0.539475679397583,
0.07595781981945038,
0.3078204393386841,
-0.30367663502693176,
-0.4938788414001465,
0.535183310508728,
-0.4037182927131653,
-0.5960401296615601,
-0.3915722072124481,
0.1894436627626419,
-0.14499247074127197,
0.716106116771698,
-0.10969984531402588,
0.9674717783927917,
0.5288958549499512,
-0.7519691586494446,
0.0754857286810875,
-0.019460899755358696,
-0.659373939037323,
0.31809863448143005,
-0.6587347388267517,
0.09485923498868942,
-0.02735254168510437,
0.5599048733711243,
-1.0271797180175781,
-0.031414907425642014,
-0.08736617118120193,
-0.1696506142616272,
0.20861785113811493,
-0.04104533791542053,
-0.7249805331230164,
-0.581588089466095,
0.0987299308180809,
0.25478434562683105,
0.7868918776512146,
-0.4796435832977295,
1.1336442232131958,
0.43332335352897644,
0.10295175760984421,
-0.5509123206138611,
-0.5591070055961609,
0.09449063241481781,
-0.2465849369764328,
-0.3553483486175537,
0.224277064204216,
0.2895117998123169,
-0.032305121421813965,
-0.20296987891197205,
-0.24996818602085114,
0.15673142671585083,
0.2927798926830292,
0.5988267064094543,
0.4806440770626068,
-0.42919105291366577,
-0.18379029631614685,
0.22254785895347595,
-0.30610209703445435,
-0.020533714443445206,
-0.07192783057689667,
0.7723933458328247,
-0.07319267839193344,
-0.3857439458370209,
-0.09359543770551682,
0.18300800025463104,
0.7743635177612305,
-0.4107058048248291,
1.1880868673324585,
0.4474934935569763,
-0.3610081672668457,
-0.21697594225406647,
-0.541209876537323,
-0.08417924493551254,
-0.4894249737262726,
0.29618799686431885,
-0.5919163823127747,
-0.9577087759971619,
0.6035418510437012,
-0.0927572175860405,
0.33909669518470764,
0.630583643913269,
0.7888349294662476,
0.14693520963191986,
1.0876961946487427,
0.4206872582435608,
-0.3036942780017853,
0.4337939918041229,
-0.23306839168071747,
0.2470504343509674,
-1.023236632347107,
-0.2151412069797516,
-0.5304226875305176,
-0.6503871083259583,
-0.38075464963912964,
-0.48350590467453003,
0.0920877754688263,
-0.022923847660422325,
-0.16246412694454193,
0.7844138741493225,
-0.28991636633872986,
0.43607431650161743,
0.44350385665893555,
-0.14969515800476074,
-0.13824699819087982,
-0.13112980127334595,
-0.42864686250686646,
0.07766718417406082,
-0.945636510848999,
-0.5936718583106995,
0.9280790090560913,
0.24709175527095795,
0.5618051886558533,
0.08141887187957764,
0.11165965348482132,
-0.03239847719669342,
0.2723710536956787,
-0.7041845917701721,
0.7642157077789307,
-0.18910335004329681,
-0.8953455090522766,
-0.11204130947589874,
-0.3362544775009155,
-0.9756536483764648,
0.49905139207839966,
-0.264350950717926,
-0.5977577567100525,
0.07942903786897659,
0.10063406080007553,
-0.3695875406265259,
0.5746190547943115,
-0.7722071409225464,
0.6754011511802673,
0.04123437777161598,
-0.0667763203382492,
-0.42237427830696106,
-0.6489374041557312,
0.3922678530216217,
-0.24555137753486633,
0.22087912261486053,
-0.3160433769226074,
0.06486400216817856,
0.5288176536560059,
-0.15604431927204132,
0.7581673860549927,
-0.18563321232795715,
0.012206234969198704,
0.3955594003200531,
0.10727346688508987,
0.35853052139282227,
-0.4207497835159302,
-0.20040592551231384,
0.17691943049430847,
-0.2919912338256836,
-0.6181761026382446,
-0.6358635425567627,
0.5955753326416016,
-0.8659792542457581,
-0.5636710524559021,
-0.07838033139705658,
-0.5961869359016418,
-0.44857680797576904,
0.08673888444900513,
0.11731848865747452,
0.3888593316078186,
0.0562480203807354,
0.6027242541313171,
0.4171864986419678,
-0.3866707682609558,
0.4031139612197876,
0.4702129662036896,
-0.3313985764980316,
0.031078830361366272,
0.6864756941795349,
0.29520183801651,
0.5677703619003296,
0.3876737654209137,
0.13451437652111053,
-0.24778208136558533,
-0.42642852663993835,
-0.7220996618270874,
0.04976095259189606,
-0.6351091861724854,
-0.024930298328399658,
-0.5650561451911926,
-0.270186185836792,
-0.031974367797374725,
-0.14200754463672638,
-0.6771182417869568,
-0.5021176338195801,
0.018253933638334274,
-0.1679552048444748,
0.11679739505052567,
0.6398932933807373,
0.3465336561203003,
0.2726939022541046,
-0.6128455996513367,
0.4365057349205017,
0.08570757508277893,
0.3282979130744934,
0.36357229948043823,
-0.6733579039573669,
-0.367100328207016,
-0.02030859887599945,
-0.2717800736427307,
-0.7725992202758789,
-0.06120406091213226,
-0.15092125535011292,
0.6915669441223145,
0.2086215764284134,
-0.2929571866989136,
0.6665307879447937,
-0.717039942741394,
1.0295298099517822,
0.09814633429050446,
-0.9160290360450745,
0.44057926535606384,
-0.20237521827220917,
0.2525745630264282,
0.2661516070365906,
0.4038853347301483,
-0.23167593777179718,
-0.45034515857696533,
-0.5130285620689392,
-0.6812072396278381,
0.708004891872406,
0.3823736906051636,
0.162716805934906,
-0.011351430788636208,
0.5003623962402344,
0.15453368425369263,
0.022786375135183334,
-0.4948575794696808,
-0.39886781573295593,
-0.30505242943763733,
-0.10000734776258469,
-0.36657992005348206,
0.00038404640508815646,
0.2079227715730667,
-0.0745810866355896,
0.43282151222229004,
-0.06095938757061958,
0.24554425477981567,
-0.2713318467140198,
-0.27039673924446106,
0.12368965893983841,
0.35344216227531433,
0.7776572108268738,
0.6400519013404846,
0.23604123294353485,
0.033291786909103394,
0.503481388092041,
-0.3180783689022064,
0.39752495288848877,
-0.02261197753250599,
-0.08286938816308975,
0.0567501038312912,
-0.0788160189986229,
1.0432299375534058,
0.569122850894928,
-0.695972204208374,
0.25229427218437195,
0.2083924561738968,
-0.14786753058433533,
-0.03706997632980347,
0.5055475831031799,
0.3465234637260437,
0.3318745791912079,
0.27684301137924194,
0.22790320217609406,
-0.1016516461968422,
-0.4712430238723755,
-0.07463895529508591,
0.4632994532585144,
-0.21737101674079895,
-0.3640838861465454,
0.841768205165863,
0.05198002606630325,
-0.395759254693985,
0.44158822298049927,
0.06848115473985672,
-0.23357751965522766,
0.8777595162391663,
0.6068441867828369,
0.5256710648536682,
-0.3367585241794586,
-0.06284399330615997,
0.39562493562698364,
0.40784600377082825,
-0.23795969784259796,
-0.03179818391799927,
-0.11314834654331207,
-0.746639609336853,
-0.5444942712783813,
-0.7159635424613953,
-0.6390781402587891,
0.21131263673305511,
-0.9478481411933899,
0.11349628865718842,
-0.7132276892662048,
-0.5286037921905518,
0.19805091619491577,
-0.17046527564525604,
-0.5910636782646179,
0.184486985206604,
0.212079256772995,
0.9884467124938965,
-0.6969618201255798,
0.997726321220398,
0.5885669589042664,
-0.2705705165863037,
-0.9867018461227417,
-0.3877151310443878,
-0.059293631464242935,
-0.8388053774833679,
0.35263997316360474,
0.186552956700325,
-0.1794973760843277,
-0.2996562719345093,
-0.042030420154333115,
-0.9315218925476074,
1.1932034492492676,
0.41976234316825867,
-0.7905578017234802,
-0.14837272465229034,
0.3348604142665863,
0.5155549049377441,
-0.11609425395727158,
-0.0018533621914684772,
0.764836847782135,
0.29769477248191833,
-0.04970192164182663,
-0.9630057215690613,
-0.008542060852050781,
-0.07132390886545181,
0.07678607851266861,
0.6286140084266663,
-1.0105412006378174,
0.787986695766449,
-0.10684194415807724,
-0.05991637334227562,
0.16567543148994446,
0.8492248058319092,
0.4465360641479492,
-0.11112359911203384,
0.6915351748466492,
0.3199566602706909,
0.4504314064979553,
-0.1968110352754593,
1.2310196161270142,
-0.4998262822628021,
0.2949203848838806,
0.8978263139724731,
-0.5863029956817627,
0.9675400257110596,
0.3693779706954956,
-0.440964013338089,
0.5579485893249512,
0.5405199527740479,
-0.24779647588729858,
0.23108693957328796,
0.09560175240039825,
0.20159126818180084,
-0.2691255509853363,
0.14172205328941345,
-0.1983204483985901,
0.3506695032119751,
0.30319997668266296,
-0.3616429269313812,
0.07264798134565353,
0.11144641041755676,
-0.07020875811576843,
-0.10805471986532211,
-0.32666394114494324,
0.3777741491794586,
0.28216296434402466,
-0.7386030554771423,
0.3780324459075928,
0.18353138864040375,
0.6359544396400452,
-0.6368926167488098,
0.47609788179397583,
-0.3124699592590332,
0.2584126591682434,
0.037229083478450775,
-0.6693801283836365,
0.4604225158691406,
0.0684673860669136,
-0.16034109890460968,
-0.06106287240982056,
0.6869615912437439,
0.00780658982694149,
-0.49618223309516907,
0.3866017758846283,
0.422744482755661,
-0.09063248336315155,
0.06840313225984573,
-0.6622450947761536,
-0.003784560365602374,
-0.35926759243011475,
-0.37064075469970703,
0.5682923197746277,
-0.1019536703824997,
0.0037836809642612934,
0.7007220387458801,
0.5356807708740234,
-0.11250165849924088,
0.3251938819885254,
0.18006889522075653,
0.6649339199066162,
-0.7506927847862244,
-0.49977728724479675,
-0.8739849328994751,
0.21082264184951782,
0.06696116924285889,
-0.26168525218963623,
0.8759925365447998,
0.8035984039306641,
0.6403020024299622,
-0.06416960060596466,
0.4751536548137665,
0.21084053814411163,
0.5136263966560364,
-0.6292034387588501,
0.4461282789707184,
-0.6717023253440857,
0.0004401863261591643,
-0.12388142198324203,
-1.2526230812072754,
0.06809131801128387,
0.513705313205719,
-0.3321690559387207,
0.24561071395874023,
0.44215336441993713,
0.6085115075111389,
-0.29097452759742737,
0.10919929295778275,
0.3615434169769287,
0.09664031863212585,
0.2578789293766022,
0.7146571278572083,
1.0478105545043945,
-0.29635804891586304,
0.6909480094909668,
-0.05807783827185631,
0.13130658864974976,
-0.3327656388282776,
-0.422256737947464,
-1.0498194694519043,
-0.5683498978614807,
0.033516403287649155,
-0.3353237807750702,
-0.23882809281349182,
0.691774845123291,
0.782687246799469,
-0.6562254428863525,
-0.13471229374408722,
0.2604031562805176,
-0.07008657604455948,
-0.30457812547683716,
-0.18981482088565826,
0.1888185441493988,
0.03110572136938572,
-0.741971492767334,
0.516791045665741,
0.5727440118789673,
0.06973832100629807,
-0.5302682518959045,
-0.015216264873743057,
0.11475368589162827,
0.5515170097351074,
0.8528663516044617,
0.1404954195022583,
-0.9811683297157288,
-0.2542610466480255,
0.3491835296154022,
-0.2903275489807129,
0.27839720249176025,
1.017759919166565,
-0.8062503337860107,
0.02338230237364769,
0.2030327469110489,
0.7843696475028992,
0.6915348768234253,
-0.24041485786437988,
0.41398748755455017,
-0.49599358439445496,
0.2772212326526642,
0.0482642725110054,
0.7385700941085815,
0.14663733541965485,
0.21973606944084167,
0.39138370752334595,
-0.07432284951210022,
-0.32050207257270813,
-0.719453752040863,
0.2663736045360565,
-1.0394688844680786,
-0.4115121066570282,
1.2294871807098389,
0.04561346769332886,
-0.11319643259048462,
0.0799662247300148,
-0.19931723177433014,
0.19591470062732697,
-0.027765002101659775,
0.6990688443183899,
0.8582636713981628,
0.11798378825187683,
-0.02604815363883972,
-0.656402587890625,
0.13079659640789032,
0.6025832295417786,
-0.6751362681388855,
-0.15660277009010315,
0.2371184378862381,
0.2019038051366806,
0.31378787755966187,
0.20836284756660461,
-0.0683685913681984,
0.3408759534358978,
0.16749468445777893,
-0.30118227005004883,
-0.11673147231340408,
-0.3404228091239929,
-0.2708877921104431,
0.3000403642654419,
-0.2122076153755188,
0.006589436903595924
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.07886v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.07886v1
|
Label-aware Hard Negative Sampling Strategies with Momentum Contrastive Learning for Implicit Hate Speech Detection
| 2024-06-12T05:24:58 | 2024-06-12T05:24:58 |
Jaehoon Kim, Seungwan Jin, Sohyun Park, Someen Park, Kyungsik Han
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Detecting implicit hate speech that is not directly hateful remains a
challenge. Recent research has attempted to detect implicit hate speech by
applying contrastive learning to pre-trained language models such as BERT and
RoBERTa, but the proposed models still do not have a significant advantage over
cross-entropy loss-based learning. We found that contrastive learning based on
randomly sampled batch data does not encourage the model to learn hard negative
samples. In this work, we propose Label-aware Hard Negative sampling strategies
(LAHN) that encourage the model to learn detailed features from hard negative
samples, instead of naive negative samples in random batch, using
momentum-integrated contrastive learning. LAHN outperforms the existing models
for implicit hate speech detection both in- and cross-datasets. The code is
available at https://github.com/Hanyang-HCC-Lab/LAHN
|
[
-0.3822001814842224,
-0.7191744446754456,
0.40773892402648926,
0.006286997813731432,
-0.21098937094211578,
0.07573682814836502,
-0.1315487027168274,
-0.6519617438316345,
0.22494080662727356,
0.31696775555610657,
-0.6424204111099243,
-0.7491097450256348,
-0.5499230623245239,
-0.2930438816547394,
-0.49172404408454895,
1.2459542751312256,
0.141694113612175,
0.289808064699173,
0.08724183589220047,
-0.2999042272567749,
0.05324326083064079,
-0.6628178358078003,
-0.8859983682632446,
-0.31140652298927307,
0.8607971668243408,
0.34741050004959106,
0.2263525128364563,
0.18812480568885803,
0.14375589787960052,
0.11124785989522934,
-0.13891328871250153,
-0.2173313945531845,
-0.7492244839668274,
0.5648503303527832,
-0.10512881726026535,
-0.3773731291294098,
-0.3647811710834503,
0.25612714886665344,
0.5408102869987488,
0.4038504660129547,
-0.1048877090215683,
0.030011596158146858,
0.026811089366674423,
0.346951961517334,
-0.9278742671012878,
-0.16521629691123962,
-0.7283002138137817,
0.21199901401996613,
-0.5883522629737854,
0.17155902087688446,
-0.37751060724258423,
-0.2501274347305298,
-0.17368976771831512,
-0.6094575524330139,
0.4157484769821167,
0.07763197273015976,
0.4496324062347412,
0.11135588586330414,
-0.3036554753780365,
-0.46857231855392456,
-0.7908446192741394,
1.0557425022125244,
-0.5878093838691711,
0.5579583048820496,
0.45440900325775146,
0.13984191417694092,
0.01616744138300419,
-0.34317973256111145,
-0.6812026500701904,
-0.34696143865585327,
0.30148372054100037,
0.286257803440094,
-0.15312208235263824,
0.19831247627735138,
0.22204621136188507,
0.12112647294998169,
-0.3208988606929779,
0.7330982089042664,
-0.43774688243865967,
-0.34471237659454346,
0.6326702833175659,
-0.025806793943047523,
-0.0802479162812233,
0.13112056255340576,
-0.3723994493484497,
-0.27811139822006226,
-0.5829755663871765,
-0.018418103456497192,
0.7647399306297302,
0.8203482031822205,
-0.07526357471942902,
0.39709028601646423,
-0.08931313455104828,
0.4842497408390045,
0.09932106733322144,
-0.12149116396903992,
0.516374409198761,
0.27175289392471313,
-0.046089962124824524,
0.36014819145202637,
0.5603114366531372,
0.01266186311841011,
0.3122776746749878,
-0.16169016063213348,
-0.20580719411373138,
0.3078884482383728,
0.16022779047489166,
-0.9473795294761658,
-0.12261473387479782,
0.36220747232437134,
-0.18324267864227295,
-0.3624030351638794,
-0.40551406145095825,
-0.708993136882782,
-0.985085129737854,
-0.12321760505437851,
0.33897480368614197,
-0.4122439920902252,
-0.356842041015625,
-0.14715959131717682,
-0.32165899872779846,
0.23930425941944122,
0.47646480798721313,
-0.4298875629901886,
0.333805650472641,
0.559194803237915,
0.5592504739761353,
-0.3965989947319031,
0.13630087673664093,
-0.8934797644615173,
-0.025555403903126717,
-0.1688288301229477,
0.5760823488235474,
-0.5588201284408569,
-0.28607475757598877,
0.06786871701478958,
-0.2598974108695984,
0.2853181064128876,
-0.6890829801559448,
0.8412753939628601,
-0.5996366739273071,
0.05131101235747337,
-0.08879845589399338,
-0.5351274013519287,
-0.3787197470664978,
0.33901140093803406,
-0.4195704162120819,
0.8153274059295654,
0.13183674216270447,
-0.6321181654930115,
0.4646154046058655,
-0.21628326177597046,
-0.6726111173629761,
-0.07402803748846054,
-0.19138574600219727,
-0.8826426267623901,
0.09432993084192276,
0.028452640399336815,
0.6216911673545837,
-0.03927737474441528,
0.13177715241909027,
-0.9765133857727051,
-0.4095461964607239,
0.06742370873689651,
-0.3972569406032562,
1.0266729593276978,
0.29945802688598633,
-0.5187711119651794,
0.26863107085227966,
-1.021166205406189,
-0.11699506640434265,
0.21042509377002716,
-0.09871943295001984,
-0.6640619039535522,
-0.0847054198384285,
0.06669129431247711,
0.26365065574645996,
-0.3517194390296936,
-0.652497410774231,
-0.050190508365631104,
-0.06219455972313881,
-0.16890038549900055,
0.9152384996414185,
-0.13762491941452026,
0.2330608367919922,
-0.17993243038654327,
0.6320098042488098,
0.31980374455451965,
-0.18913213908672333,
0.3722339868545532,
-0.271472305059433,
-0.8977129459381104,
-0.47308963537216187,
0.07429958879947662,
0.7238782644271851,
-0.714240550994873,
-0.06297768652439117,
0.2702655792236328,
-0.43500909209251404,
-0.5725600719451904,
0.2407202124595642,
0.6975613236427307,
0.6547209024429321,
0.6907774806022644,
-0.36693739891052246,
-0.7616024613380432,
-0.8044610619544983,
-0.3682408332824707,
-0.1520756185054779,
0.09080110490322113,
0.5295777916908264,
0.5171633362770081,
0.11269230395555496,
0.5250985026359558,
-0.34849417209625244,
-0.40720364451408386,
-0.136282280087471,
0.6020127534866333,
0.055636338889598846,
0.4055599570274353,
0.36704257130622864,
-0.886138379573822,
-0.5102344155311584,
-0.5534007549285889,
-0.45911645889282227,
-0.359708696603775,
0.2278127372264862,
0.15362301468849182,
0.2521427869796753,
0.5900571942329407,
0.010015691630542278,
0.2979288697242737,
0.5681384801864624,
-0.050442200154066086,
0.3980609178543091,
0.38802966475486755,
-0.003073405707255006,
-0.8119986653327942,
-0.29994508624076843,
0.415645033121109,
-0.20006069540977478,
-0.9813011884689331,
-0.18440918624401093,
-0.2916320264339447,
0.09774205088615417,
-0.9737959504127502,
0.46458908915519714,
-0.3027251958847046,
0.2580126225948334,
-0.16915860772132874,
-0.15898706018924713,
-0.32200172543525696,
0.6039547920227051,
0.4511965811252594,
0.6298159956932068,
0.268667995929718,
-0.8757715225219727,
0.0774538666009903,
-0.3173801302909851,
-0.3873820900917053,
0.9910743236541748,
-0.3417714834213257,
0.2910710275173187,
-0.45058971643447876,
0.41467520594596863,
-0.9081177115440369,
-0.047525111585855484,
0.6473597288131714,
-0.1933145374059677,
0.341144323348999,
-0.36835402250289917,
-0.1748690903186798,
-0.2965999245643616,
-0.3987696170806885,
0.6461317539215088,
0.6184724569320679,
-0.4451258182525635,
0.29835376143455505,
0.6378399133682251,
-0.01664312183856964,
-0.6385241746902466,
-0.690970778465271,
-0.5124221444129944,
-0.4671771824359894,
0.027430331334471703,
0.48207947611808777,
-0.02316444367170334,
-0.49080443382263184,
-0.27903568744659424,
0.00667218491435051,
-0.25027936697006226,
0.019426971673965454,
0.44814273715019226,
-0.19829769432544708,
0.012147726491093636,
0.2805769145488739,
-0.16288308799266815,
0.13815368711948395,
0.03563293442130089,
-0.25924521684646606,
0.6215503811836243,
-0.0405377633869648,
-0.26845094561576843,
-0.20671772956848145,
0.22227300703525543,
0.1796795278787613,
0.231919527053833,
0.8004706501960754,
1.1785613298416138,
-0.27035173773765564,
-0.29878613352775574,
-0.6150912642478943,
-0.1959250122308731,
-0.39139053225517273,
0.30941241979599,
-0.14177212119102478,
-1.033481240272522,
0.34335997700691223,
0.10310889035463333,
-0.31853094696998596,
0.414722204208374,
0.5137215256690979,
-0.5265331268310547,
0.8094815611839294,
0.4360054135322571,
-0.15277883410453796,
0.5223379135131836,
0.010276521556079388,
-0.10937947779893875,
-0.6705995798110962,
-0.07690820097923279,
-0.5622546076774597,
-0.37076541781425476,
-0.46765244007110596,
-0.6425612568855286,
0.376728355884552,
-0.008620614185929298,
-0.5827128887176514,
-0.04246704652905464,
-0.4534173011779785,
0.2802172303199768,
0.6868274807929993,
0.1779794842004776,
0.1443794071674347,
0.07583877444267273,
0.058271847665309906,
-0.36954838037490845,
-0.3367255926132202,
0.2911878824234009,
0.9351704716682434,
0.24247165024280548,
0.8422214984893799,
0.13208389282226562,
0.8608027696609497,
0.3969402611255646,
0.5722051858901978,
-0.8819646239280701,
0.5793282389640808,
-0.25764816999435425,
-0.8619444370269775,
-0.20895229279994965,
-0.4450908899307251,
-0.6825211048126221,
0.16089431941509247,
-0.2926894724369049,
-0.5610281825065613,
0.3424670696258545,
0.34287595748901367,
-0.31449684500694275,
0.5370276570320129,
-0.35027021169662476,
0.3656650483608246,
-0.26441916823387146,
-0.5586639046669006,
-0.2192678302526474,
-0.4088750183582306,
0.5507297515869141,
-0.07222111523151398,
0.41277414560317993,
-0.18494440615177155,
0.0611601248383522,
1.068317174911499,
-0.19442790746688843,
1.2333869934082031,
-0.6938323974609375,
-0.4991895854473114,
0.49809950590133667,
-0.061711568385362625,
0.5748900771141052,
-0.3331071734428406,
-0.1614287942647934,
0.2339954525232315,
-0.7491908073425293,
-0.27679887413978577,
-0.4011555314064026,
0.40453532338142395,
-0.4121021032333374,
-0.618026614189148,
-0.42487436532974243,
-0.5396265387535095,
-0.35322898626327515,
0.1388290822505951,
0.2656806707382202,
-0.017040666192770004,
-0.24372164905071259,
0.21089236438274384,
0.9037225842475891,
-0.3536810874938965,
0.12609997391700745,
0.6359170079231262,
-0.2695658206939697,
-0.34526297450065613,
1.1963510513305664,
0.32467740774154663,
0.07902511954307556,
0.4043436646461487,
0.12362005561590195,
-0.11519399285316467,
-0.6986029744148254,
0.025831935927271843,
0.07112297415733337,
-0.45517563819885254,
-0.06953896582126617,
-0.663578987121582,
-0.1726919412612915,
-0.4588155150413513,
-0.20750616490840912,
-0.3688524067401886,
-0.35190722346305847,
-0.13369262218475342,
0.0898343175649643,
0.35301709175109863,
0.4650963246822357,
-0.4529549181461334,
0.34603145718574524,
-0.2231377512216568,
0.6589092016220093,
0.4269310534000397,
0.21354439854621887,
-0.02542940340936184,
-0.714638352394104,
-0.07817958295345306,
0.026481499895453453,
-0.15417715907096863,
-0.9719293713569641,
0.4334271252155304,
-0.057534683495759964,
0.2930326759815216,
0.24158832430839539,
0.35002070665359497,
0.6389127373695374,
-0.39382433891296387,
0.504561722278595,
0.25199031829833984,
-0.7487253546714783,
0.48416659235954285,
-0.45394593477249146,
0.17667889595031738,
0.8116841316223145,
0.8605827689170837,
-0.3137759566307068,
-0.49539417028427124,
-0.5399382710456848,
-0.9361012578010559,
0.6326423287391663,
0.016781790181994438,
-0.005692755337804556,
0.0853695422410965,
-0.0275123193860054,
0.1418633908033371,
0.3754865527153015,
-1.0785216093063354,
-0.45073267817497253,
-0.13940101861953735,
-0.11672159284353256,
-0.13339363038539886,
-0.3939588665962219,
-0.260713666677475,
-0.4673701226711273,
1.0373021364212036,
0.09868524223566055,
0.12413094192743301,
-0.05855667218565941,
-0.28018951416015625,
0.16994327306747437,
0.6027936935424805,
0.6447014808654785,
-0.17894317209720612,
-0.5500627756118774,
0.013578738085925579,
0.2518152892589569,
-0.5769879221916199,
0.37179526686668396,
0.3129981458187103,
-0.2746862769126892,
-0.11394984275102615,
0.09061748534440994,
0.8464444875717163,
-0.013505188748240471,
-0.41659313440322876,
0.5343857407569885,
0.09732037037611008,
-0.40471765398979187,
-0.44982901215553284,
0.06155990809202194,
-0.09797275066375732,
0.3008023500442505,
0.3062029778957367,
-0.1897263377904892,
0.3435571789741516,
-0.2528248429298401,
0.1499066948890686,
0.6266545653343201,
-0.9331384301185608,
-0.10673272609710693,
0.4793491065502167,
0.12942808866500854,
-0.13213515281677246,
0.7548943758010864,
-0.4360313415527344,
-0.5823529958724976,
0.5344659686088562,
0.7160852551460266,
0.7364379167556763,
-0.34092065691947937,
0.28702324628829956,
0.341934472322464,
0.13721293210983276,
0.4038131535053253,
0.22943325340747833,
-0.33067938685417175,
-0.9243355989456177,
-0.19775737822055817,
-0.4977964162826538,
-0.5937675833702087,
0.6143293976783752,
-0.8147007822990417,
0.173582524061203,
-0.6388416290283203,
0.03091261349618435,
-0.04569798707962036,
-0.07820054888725281,
-0.6841611862182617,
0.4377262592315674,
0.5726826786994934,
0.595712423324585,
-0.94594806432724,
0.8488627076148987,
0.2567574977874756,
-0.26255133748054504,
-0.5213505029678345,
-0.031613197177648544,
0.45158883929252625,
-1.0179173946380615,
0.9297551512718201,
0.24752187728881836,
-0.45824500918388367,
-0.030670849606394768,
-0.7513112425804138,
-0.3986581265926361,
0.6182572841644287,
0.2645600140094757,
-0.6823413968086243,
0.30350470542907715,
-0.09067539870738983,
0.4189794659614563,
-0.15013091266155243,
0.16234378516674042,
0.17116238176822662,
0.3591825067996979,
0.3232594430446625,
-0.26244673132896423,
-0.0617247149348259,
-0.05899103358387947,
-0.3159298896789551,
0.20545446872711182,
-0.5513584613800049,
1.0712946653366089,
-0.19788503646850586,
-0.2251339852809906,
-0.3172930181026459,
0.965328574180603,
0.37322720885276794,
0.5948197841644287,
0.862157940864563,
0.7803173661231995,
0.9294697046279907,
0.07162711024284363,
0.8292790651321411,
0.22561483085155487,
0.0905071422457695,
1.5724971294403076,
-0.508430540561676,
0.8788110613822937,
0.37185218930244446,
-0.13460706174373627,
0.7165242433547974,
0.34917131066322327,
0.028840353712439537,
0.5009239912033081,
0.6354116201400757,
-0.7216354608535767,
-0.33943870663642883,
-0.5430489182472229,
-0.449062317609787,
0.5003385543823242,
0.7460635900497437,
-0.2200569063425064,
-0.2529550790786743,
0.1828623265028,
0.30689626932144165,
-0.00626750523224473,
-0.5773859024047852,
0.6293787956237793,
0.1168353334069252,
-0.3158116340637207,
0.6257103681564331,
-0.11389659345149994,
1.1826061010360718,
-0.4127534329891205,
-0.12153833359479904,
0.06493113934993744,
0.16329441964626312,
-0.22210681438446045,
-0.6717095971107483,
0.122276671230793,
0.1104981005191803,
-0.1804482638835907,
-0.17816004157066345,
0.7449659109115601,
-0.7397443056106567,
-0.20632104575634003,
0.39710813760757446,
0.2850378155708313,
0.1421816498041153,
-0.13180987536907196,
-0.7995443344116211,
0.11951674520969391,
-0.13139399886131287,
-0.22539022564888,
0.4700009226799011,
-0.09958808869123459,
-0.1364399641752243,
0.45090723037719727,
0.6266399621963501,
0.07231509685516357,
-0.18120156228542328,
0.461002379655838,
0.591295063495636,
-0.611731231212616,
-0.3327987492084503,
-0.8541204929351807,
0.4129079580307007,
-0.20353317260742188,
-0.08642394840717316,
0.8306800127029419,
0.4496908485889435,
1.066566824913025,
0.07438629865646362,
0.8277010917663574,
0.12970253825187683,
0.84652179479599,
-0.4407235085964203,
0.49003833532333374,
-0.525175154209137,
-0.03770606219768524,
-0.4512113034725189,
-0.6918642520904541,
-0.5462865233421326,
0.6333390474319458,
-0.428801029920578,
0.20276334881782532,
0.3890860974788666,
0.818297266960144,
-0.10648608207702637,
-0.08547219634056091,
0.2918037474155426,
0.5335745811462402,
0.36567941308021545,
0.5579484105110168,
0.6509348750114441,
-0.3392859995365143,
0.6005864143371582,
-0.43723952770233154,
-0.06126309558749199,
-0.2254229485988617,
-1.1279700994491577,
-0.7758581638336182,
-0.5310189723968506,
-0.44613873958587646,
-0.7185840010643005,
0.2564454674720764,
0.7240864038467407,
0.7680932879447937,
-1.1019494533538818,
-0.05327143892645836,
-0.06524370610713959,
0.25367462635040283,
-0.2275153398513794,
-0.27991777658462524,
0.166752889752388,
-0.18215888738632202,
-0.8868553042411804,
0.5397718548774719,
0.07156752794981003,
0.21343719959259033,
-0.06948788464069366,
-0.1447342038154602,
-0.4095037877559662,
-0.015480530448257923,
0.42754748463630676,
0.7540612816810608,
-0.39141348004341125,
-0.05160990729928017,
-0.6211443543434143,
-0.15132805705070496,
-0.06781357526779175,
0.8044295907020569,
-1.0244251489639282,
0.28991952538490295,
0.1975729912519455,
0.6262788772583008,
0.679290771484375,
-0.0793343260884285,
0.37326666712760925,
-0.9589478373527527,
0.4898192286491394,
0.5499433875083923,
0.14021368324756622,
0.3296310007572174,
-0.22358295321464539,
0.4152074456214905,
0.3362639546394348,
-0.1688363403081894,
-0.9530948400497437,
0.47765177488327026,
-0.9480438232421875,
-0.2965855002403259,
1.248826265335083,
0.0623474083840847,
-0.19686536490917206,
-0.28797608613967896,
0.023597760125994682,
0.39984604716300964,
-0.5205506086349487,
0.480754554271698,
0.5261234045028687,
-0.16296537220478058,
0.004146944265812635,
-0.23218896985054016,
0.6657791137695312,
0.5270230174064636,
-0.5040425062179565,
-0.16085682809352875,
0.3775613307952881,
0.05251330882310867,
0.10752695053815842,
0.8793672323226929,
0.13152481615543365,
0.1490125060081482,
0.012440752238035202,
0.16100481152534485,
-0.2270439863204956,
-0.4852074384689331,
-0.5462505221366882,
0.42021241784095764,
-0.27430975437164307,
-0.08371641486883163
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.07882v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.07882v2
|
Designing a Dashboard for Transparency and Control of Conversational AI
| 2024-06-12T05:20:16 | 2024-06-15T05:06:29 |
Yida Chen, Aoyu Wu, Trevor DePodesta, Catherine Yeh, Kenneth Li, Nicholas Castillo Marin, Oam Patel, Jan Riecke, Shivam Raval, Olivia Seow, Martin Wattenberg, Fernanda Viégas
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC
|
Conversational LLMs function as black box systems, leaving users guessing
about why they see the output they do. This lack of transparency is potentially
problematic, especially given concerns around bias and truthfulness. To address
this issue, we present an end-to-end prototype-connecting interpretability
techniques with user experience design-that seeks to make chatbots more
transparent. We begin by showing evidence that a prominent open-source LLM has
a "user model": examining the internal state of the system, we can extract data
related to a user's age, gender, educational level, and socioeconomic status.
Next, we describe the design of a dashboard that accompanies the chatbot
interface, displaying this user model in real time. The dashboard can also be
used to control the user model and the system's behavior. Finally, we discuss a
study in which users conversed with the instrumented system. Our results
suggest that users appreciate seeing internal states, which helped them expose
biased behavior and increased their sense of control. Participants also made
valuable suggestions that point to future directions for both design and
machine learning research. The project page and video demo of our TalkTuner
system are available at https://bit.ly/talktuner-project-page
|
[
-0.11903508752584457,
-0.8357077836990356,
0.687113344669342,
0.26886504888534546,
-0.10261842608451843,
0.4346414804458618,
-0.229526087641716,
-0.579227089881897,
0.19825929403305054,
0.47029122710227966,
-0.5209396481513977,
-0.6713442206382751,
-0.49118655920028687,
-0.29457929730415344,
-0.59903484582901,
0.9084790349006653,
0.016528388485312462,
-0.2687402367591858,
-0.346847265958786,
0.15207816660404205,
-0.6545948386192322,
-0.331838458776474,
-0.7754967212677002,
-0.4142739176750183,
0.2931699752807617,
0.4904300272464752,
0.8274021744728088,
0.45406460762023926,
-0.030820878222584724,
0.33208709955215454,
-0.23042942583560944,
-0.0707915648818016,
-0.790752112865448,
0.3414202332496643,
0.024685844779014587,
-0.9483664631843567,
-0.4805040955543518,
-0.003934933803975582,
0.13985665142536163,
0.5007113814353943,
-0.2976092994213104,
-0.03400120139122009,
0.490604430437088,
0.39884018898010254,
-0.5484493374824524,
0.7902650833129883,
-0.4008132815361023,
0.10604552179574966,
0.15945249795913696,
-0.09631210565567017,
-0.5876652598381042,
-0.1281125694513321,
0.05924929678440094,
-0.824701726436615,
-0.1727190762758255,
0.10835729539394379,
0.6563679575920105,
0.384713739156723,
-0.3927430510520935,
-0.36418458819389343,
-1.0630550384521484,
0.6084991097450256,
-0.672773003578186,
0.3908059895038605,
0.3968197703361511,
0.5722915530204773,
-0.13669613003730774,
-0.6359341144561768,
-0.6325874924659729,
-0.2581835389137268,
-0.3298039734363556,
0.5509558916091919,
-0.6333486437797546,
0.019306261092424393,
-0.1111292690038681,
0.045629408210515976,
-0.42639151215553284,
0.4167167544364929,
-0.5071675181388855,
-0.32680967450141907,
0.5115021467208862,
0.40270760655403137,
0.10242201387882233,
0.030536066740751266,
-0.2981396019458771,
0.1411198526620865,
-0.7071813941001892,
0.1931278109550476,
0.573547899723053,
0.11882871389389038,
-0.7550117373466492,
0.6268319487571716,
-0.26405423879623413,
0.4484255611896515,
-0.10268086940050125,
0.1939769834280014,
0.13053065538406372,
-0.2050195187330246,
-0.20175637304782867,
0.11027994006872177,
0.8574433326721191,
0.582593560218811,
0.22016648948192596,
-0.08332502096891403,
-0.02837330475449562,
0.20660631358623505,
0.4910263121128082,
-0.6564134955406189,
-0.26798105239868164,
0.6034053564071655,
-0.48488590121269226,
-0.4149237275123596,
-0.041542552411556244,
-0.48800212144851685,
-0.6130728125572205,
-0.6616349816322327,
0.3096645176410675,
-0.31680768728256226,
-0.23966512084007263,
-0.1364370435476303,
-0.10196314752101898,
0.07412727177143097,
0.6015843152999878,
-0.6754834055900574,
0.4809139668941498,
0.8549184799194336,
1.012840747833252,
-0.2850739359855652,
0.24474108219146729,
-0.15443547070026398,
0.19670164585113525,
-0.3301883935928345,
0.4226441979408264,
-0.5805578827857971,
-0.7460646033287048,
0.08434085547924042,
-0.18932649493217468,
0.2546485364437103,
-0.40925246477127075,
0.24090689420700073,
-0.24637967348098755,
0.49437201023101807,
0.37191465497016907,
-0.5732659101486206,
-0.09607141464948654,
0.08812181651592255,
-0.2231956273317337,
0.4180430769920349,
-0.1798541098833084,
-0.46405813097953796,
0.12724389135837555,
-1.1319233179092407,
-0.18576939404010773,
0.17622016370296478,
-0.4729700982570648,
-0.2898727357387543,
0.0493135042488575,
0.048962224274873734,
0.3468954861164093,
0.3037274479866028,
0.2425580769777298,
-0.044964808970689774,
-0.5953680276870728,
0.6168097257614136,
-0.6647436022758484,
0.7332280874252319,
0.4072831869125366,
-0.30473342537879944,
0.5834102630615234,
-0.702427327632904,
-0.05844232439994812,
-0.11597047001123428,
-0.21767249703407288,
0.03007139265537262,
0.05684890225529671,
-0.017716793343424797,
-0.04908493161201477,
0.45835521817207336,
-0.5875409841537476,
-0.24767491221427917,
-0.37727320194244385,
0.8295621871948242,
1.144410490989685,
-0.30633512139320374,
0.5421554446220398,
-0.2646729052066803,
0.680492103099823,
0.3392825126647949,
0.38716578483581543,
-0.6057599782943726,
-0.7323351502418518,
-0.9288617968559265,
-0.3978157043457031,
0.20936158299446106,
0.5441634654998779,
-0.37481895089149475,
0.6671302318572998,
0.04386351257562637,
-0.29697108268737793,
-0.7561047673225403,
0.05492905527353287,
0.30476054549217224,
0.7288411855697632,
-0.032713569700717926,
-0.47134679555892944,
-0.18441987037658691,
-1.1944421529769897,
-0.01613178662955761,
-0.3282638490200043,
-0.5175411105155945,
0.6557432413101196,
0.4030224680900574,
-0.20500293374061584,
1.106969952583313,
-0.6100280284881592,
-0.31426042318344116,
-0.008708013221621513,
0.15817303955554962,
0.3098459243774414,
0.4765164256095886,
-0.014606797136366367,
-0.601601779460907,
-0.33923834562301636,
0.20643360912799835,
-1.0842185020446777,
-0.1923181563615799,
0.023561108857393265,
-0.21428927779197693,
0.09091906994581223,
0.5229542255401611,
-0.6283227205276489,
1.0863341093063354,
0.3706999123096466,
-0.38844603300094604,
0.2154504358768463,
-0.32734784483909607,
-0.2548273503780365,
-0.739815890789032,
0.02210281416773796,
-0.06301882117986679,
-0.373836874961853,
-0.6087475419044495,
-0.3172750771045685,
0.0918610468506813,
-0.28592121601104736,
-0.6107481122016907,
0.5939861536026001,
-0.10641200095415115,
-0.1123589351773262,
-0.4229147434234619,
0.18622815608978271,
-0.036860011518001556,
0.5921664237976074,
-0.25736549496650696,
0.9773051142692566,
0.5649853944778442,
-0.5568472146987915,
0.07320573925971985,
0.4324742555618286,
-0.37070176005363464,
0.925598680973053,
-0.8623755574226379,
0.2453375905752182,
-0.4116514027118683,
0.31968846917152405,
-1.232853889465332,
-0.16851703822612762,
0.6623809337615967,
-0.49946871399879456,
0.08822199702262878,
-0.0014280249597504735,
-0.3404066264629364,
0.07767961174249649,
-0.13374903798103333,
-0.1531396359205246,
0.664006769657135,
-0.3076222538948059,
0.5340959429740906,
0.49181658029556274,
-0.2507402300834656,
-0.2065882831811905,
-0.6292040348052979,
0.2949222922325134,
-0.2943991720676422,
-0.4736500382423401,
0.22670552134513855,
-0.38468658924102783,
-0.4527229964733124,
-0.1513293981552124,
0.02813183143734932,
0.021204441785812378,
0.33585435152053833,
0.7790644764900208,
0.33668777346611023,
0.06303507089614868,
0.1122509315609932,
0.18917229771614075,
-0.34393399953842163,
0.13145314157009125,
-0.03661176934838295,
0.6207197308540344,
-0.2426319271326065,
-0.5781232118606567,
-1.209408164024353,
0.23023878037929535,
0.28136172890663147,
0.06185436621308327,
0.630987823009491,
0.434819757938385,
-0.11968523263931274,
-0.01947866939008236,
-0.24695034325122833,
-0.31149327754974365,
-0.5473563075065613,
0.010486941784620285,
-0.14193812012672424,
-1.034242868423462,
0.6968227624893188,
0.04972874000668526,
0.24939247965812683,
-0.04267636314034462,
0.8800079822540283,
-0.5054816007614136,
1.2226996421813965,
0.8146554231643677,
0.11346106976270676,
0.7064835429191589,
-0.09040968865156174,
0.052908413112163544,
-0.7103390693664551,
-0.6793916821479797,
-0.3879378139972687,
-0.5441315770149231,
-0.5760374665260315,
-0.07805545628070831,
0.5441527962684631,
-0.17477284371852875,
-0.36347004771232605,
-0.1700003445148468,
-0.5246851444244385,
0.4781898558139801,
0.8055897951126099,
0.5047566294670105,
0.6474359631538391,
-0.2648221254348755,
0.26197734475135803,
-0.1375940889120102,
-0.4520642161369324,
-0.7944589853286743,
1.2242680788040161,
0.5566439628601074,
0.9919975996017456,
0.05837666243314743,
0.5389596223831177,
0.579473078250885,
0.5589763522148132,
-0.704288125038147,
0.45445936918258667,
0.4368969798088074,
-0.49498218297958374,
-0.2795068323612213,
-0.15400183200836182,
-1.246347188949585,
0.27108511328697205,
-0.09560000151395798,
-1.0471969842910767,
0.03550667688250542,
0.24478308856487274,
-0.01810469850897789,
-0.17516160011291504,
-0.9780670404434204,
0.5488902926445007,
-0.2489376664161682,
-0.4668402373790741,
-0.32001861929893494,
-0.7816819548606873,
0.4371126890182495,
0.10008027404546738,
0.39754733443260193,
-0.1093311533331871,
-0.09647056460380554,
0.596310555934906,
-0.4443804919719696,
1.380470871925354,
-0.01257630530744791,
-0.2867957055568695,
0.1050143763422966,
0.198515385389328,
0.2603212893009186,
0.23384875059127808,
0.07227461040019989,
0.42196619510650635,
-0.3575096130371094,
-0.42718374729156494,
-0.7424418926239014,
0.5264201164245605,
-0.8744529485702515,
-0.7736803889274597,
-0.09967612475156784,
-0.5537086129188538,
-0.016688719391822815,
0.21855062246322632,
-0.22651992738246918,
0.17622382938861847,
-0.3910926282405853,
0.2718866467475891,
0.35414448380470276,
-0.24479663372039795,
0.17308832705020905,
0.6598033905029297,
-0.5001455545425415,
0.04672763869166374,
0.6669065952301025,
-0.2746444344520569,
0.23658940196037292,
0.2979423403739929,
0.18372797966003418,
-0.2810767590999603,
-0.5065754055976868,
-0.5016039609909058,
-0.0034120201598852873,
-0.5899400115013123,
0.11360718309879303,
-0.28465670347213745,
-0.3679211139678955,
-0.10716138780117035,
-0.05810894817113876,
-0.1660858392715454,
-0.4474256932735443,
-0.6950162649154663,
-0.1339590847492218,
0.08212177455425262,
0.9684493541717529,
0.012382269836962223,
0.9170848727226257,
-0.046977024525403976,
0.2478538453578949,
0.22561369836330414,
0.413103312253952,
-0.03757552430033684,
-0.4570715129375458,
-0.14472125470638275,
0.17376026511192322,
-0.7131051421165466,
-0.6205598711967468,
0.40204787254333496,
-0.05523782595992088,
0.5680128931999207,
0.6833823323249817,
0.009929533116519451,
0.34984341263771057,
-0.3763744533061981,
0.7565003037452698,
0.3397669494152069,
-0.888042688369751,
0.7912074327468872,
-0.23041491210460663,
0.2629854083061218,
0.33298158645629883,
0.11780861765146255,
-0.48235657811164856,
-0.9236862659454346,
-0.5092238783836365,
-0.5526154041290283,
0.676652193069458,
0.5636610984802246,
0.5453243851661682,
0.31302469968795776,
0.1457587629556656,
0.48251256346702576,
0.6149603128433228,
-0.4694816768169403,
-0.5251563787460327,
-0.5133324265480042,
-0.38248756527900696,
-0.15718938410282135,
-0.06472431868314743,
-0.47848477959632874,
0.07917625457048416,
0.13717246055603027,
-0.16190293431282043,
0.3271493911743164,
-0.1284458190202713,
0.06420514732599258,
0.07356448471546173,
0.3596874177455902,
0.5490344762802124,
1.0082125663757324,
-0.2150716930627823,
0.12855961918830872,
-0.3183923363685608,
-0.11804616451263428,
-0.0966024175286293,
-0.18474410474300385,
-0.4136296510696411,
-0.28871145844459534,
0.14982086420059204,
0.9157811999320984,
0.3627113103866577,
-0.6781983971595764,
0.4798005521297455,
-0.2141338288784027,
-0.13324150443077087,
-0.3488403558731079,
0.44088292121887207,
0.204744353890419,
0.4891187250614166,
0.22606447339057922,
-0.06075708568096161,
0.10652515292167664,
-0.6567935347557068,
-0.13017266988754272,
0.5994918346405029,
-0.7391859292984009,
-0.3869355320930481,
1.1759952306747437,
0.3030069172382355,
-0.8732911944389343,
0.6193990707397461,
0.4079244136810303,
-0.20495951175689697,
0.414387583732605,
0.4114093482494354,
0.5153815150260925,
0.09623011201620102,
0.4191892445087433,
-0.3281197249889374,
0.06903546303510666,
0.5228740572929382,
0.19467563927173615,
-0.5196835994720459,
-0.588798463344574,
-0.1724252998828888,
-0.13989639282226562,
-1.0814909934997559,
0.04993778467178345,
-0.6376577615737915,
0.18279708921909332,
-0.38165611028671265,
-0.16321134567260742,
0.07897255569696426,
-0.4162946045398712,
-0.7280974388122559,
-0.08478190749883652,
0.07531019300222397,
0.7018864750862122,
-0.5305734872817993,
0.31468287110328674,
0.14435157179832458,
-0.2534681260585785,
0.08980806916952133,
-0.4430377185344696,
0.1587601900100708,
-1.19231116771698,
0.5038468837738037,
0.058284223079681396,
0.06260336190462112,
-0.2749291956424713,
-1.1027659177780151,
-0.2895487844944,
1.1437783241271973,
0.2967255711555481,
-0.6381797790527344,
0.13136081397533417,
0.171808123588562,
0.787075936794281,
-0.346821665763855,
0.5340931415557861,
0.5207439661026001,
0.5440165400505066,
-0.021378517150878906,
-0.950679361820221,
-0.11027003079652786,
-0.16243337094783783,
-0.22414113581180573,
-0.3260054588317871,
-0.8200634121894836,
0.5574209690093994,
0.03945935517549515,
-0.23445388674736023,
-0.06224074959754944,
0.8895571827888489,
0.23964336514472961,
0.7433761954307556,
0.4404945373535156,
0.1273215264081955,
0.8647850751876831,
0.02026195079088211,
0.901285707950592,
-0.2779901325702667,
-0.10402265936136246,
0.9477341175079346,
-0.1606033891439438,
0.6522927284240723,
0.5509741902351379,
-0.31950289011001587,
0.6337526440620422,
0.24753884971141815,
0.34636572003364563,
0.41106775403022766,
0.43579497933387756,
-0.2511831820011139,
-0.04350455105304718,
-0.30535420775413513,
-0.1103731021285057,
0.4227794408798218,
0.5901436805725098,
-0.20015418529510498,
0.04799041152000427,
-0.023037878796458244,
0.26155924797058105,
0.07849590480327606,
-0.013033655472099781,
0.9178842902183533,
0.30319657921791077,
-0.3278774619102478,
0.26936662197113037,
-0.23466797173023224,
0.7679770588874817,
-0.5484652519226074,
-0.04010149836540222,
-0.34844714403152466,
-0.031649015843868256,
-0.20956017076969147,
-1.1546980142593384,
0.08127153664827347,
-0.04182574525475502,
0.10979808121919632,
-0.39397555589675903,
0.6100258231163025,
-0.2236337512731552,
-0.4332086741924286,
0.08903689682483673,
1.0187844038009644,
0.4447062313556671,
-0.009291533380746841,
-0.5565778613090515,
0.3652729094028473,
-0.03971591591835022,
-0.09559612721204758,
0.23750323057174683,
0.10856133699417114,
-0.06425299495458603,
1.2532267570495605,
0.693729043006897,
0.052670419216156006,
-0.18513810634613037,
-0.015411426313221455,
0.8306964039802551,
-0.5109164714813232,
-0.7837197184562683,
-0.7781476378440857,
0.5214605927467346,
-0.23020429909229279,
-0.22099579870700836,
0.6431472897529602,
0.71561598777771,
0.7259395718574524,
0.26590123772621155,
0.9811580777168274,
0.27718105912208557,
0.45311981439590454,
-0.3426247239112854,
0.8483587503433228,
-0.39484903216362,
0.43858495354652405,
0.13309429585933685,
-0.5129885673522949,
-0.12984338402748108,
0.3831408619880676,
-0.0692843347787857,
-0.16801057755947113,
0.14892779290676117,
0.7916876077651978,
-0.10185634344816208,
0.28362464904785156,
0.439429372549057,
0.5547575950622559,
0.777241587638855,
0.3542078137397766,
1.286671757698059,
0.11621055006980896,
0.6772260665893555,
-0.2997535169124603,
-0.3271055519580841,
-0.28376656770706177,
-0.6328195929527283,
-0.9015908241271973,
-0.4380970597267151,
-0.21049140393733978,
-0.25672510266304016,
0.19291618466377258,
0.24323175847530365,
0.8784738779067993,
-0.6311827301979065,
-0.46843603253364563,
-0.08365817368030548,
0.4109700918197632,
0.1717604398727417,
-0.28322550654411316,
0.14469511806964874,
-0.0769425630569458,
-0.9083405137062073,
0.5129011869430542,
0.2177181839942932,
0.08542264252901077,
-0.6022104620933533,
-0.2332841455936432,
0.5539999604225159,
-0.03766320273280144,
0.562639594078064,
0.2658253610134125,
-0.798419177532196,
-0.2965483069419861,
-0.279573529958725,
0.09068333357572556,
0.402960866689682,
0.6450206637382507,
-1.0464770793914795,
0.644389271736145,
0.0706598088145256,
0.186375230550766,
0.9455195665359497,
0.16129817068576813,
0.8357420563697815,
-0.5489364862442017,
0.11818834394216537,
0.005921846721321344,
0.03555914759635925,
0.21312475204467773,
-0.29121285676956177,
0.45554283261299133,
-0.20794136822223663,
-0.44958606362342834,
-0.7875534296035767,
0.2048608958721161,
-1.0777976512908936,
-0.2359604835510254,
0.6766862869262695,
-0.01050023827701807,
-0.19986645877361298,
-0.46471431851387024,
-0.5351794362068176,
0.1619742214679718,
-0.9722346663475037,
0.9608114361763,
0.5344929695129395,
-0.5535005927085876,
-0.10945958644151688,
-0.8766176700592041,
0.0902629867196083,
0.14567801356315613,
-0.9229676127433777,
0.013077359646558762,
0.41498517990112305,
0.18893390893936157,
0.023076890036463737,
0.76076740026474,
0.013192960061132908,
-0.05286679416894913,
-0.13597187399864197,
-0.17272211611270905,
-0.30616652965545654,
-0.2184976190328598,
-0.4096952974796295,
0.02020454593002796,
-0.1770860254764557,
-0.30758431553840637
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10281v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10281v1
|
Watermarking Language Models with Error Correcting Codes
| 2024-06-12T05:13:09 | 2024-06-12T05:13:09 |
Patrick Chao, Edgar Dobriban, Hamed Hassani
|
cs.CR
|
cs.CR, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Recent progress in large language models enables the creation of realistic
machine-generated content. Watermarking is a promising approach to distinguish
machine-generated text from human text, embedding statistical signals in the
output that are ideally undetectable to humans. We propose a watermarking
framework that encodes such signals through an error correcting code. Our
method, termed robust binary code (RBC) watermark, introduces no distortion
compared to the original probability distribution, and no noticeable
degradation in quality. We evaluate our watermark on base and instruction
fine-tuned models and find our watermark is robust to edits, deletions, and
translations. We provide an information-theoretic perspective on watermarking,
a powerful statistical test for detection and for generating p-values, and
theoretical guarantees. Our empirical findings suggest our watermark is fast,
powerful, and robust, comparing favorably to the state-of-the-art.
|
[
-0.11248663067817688,
-0.7183159589767456,
0.12029993534088135,
0.20583486557006836,
-0.3674612045288086,
0.2839920222759247,
-0.04382947459816933,
-0.5785186886787415,
0.015760252252221107,
0.6947427988052368,
-0.18887284398078918,
-0.5430666208267212,
-0.8423425555229187,
0.08861753344535828,
-0.7407916784286499,
1.0075809955596924,
-0.05634636431932449,
-0.028439445421099663,
0.05133432894945145,
-0.26216238737106323,
-0.30970901250839233,
-0.8396767377853394,
-0.5354660153388977,
-0.11968739330768585,
0.3303510844707489,
0.16372227668762207,
0.9538678526878357,
1.0737056732177734,
0.6133760809898376,
0.22467674314975739,
-0.19913969933986664,
0.18122509121894836,
-0.2777523696422577,
0.24904553592205048,
-0.10823211818933487,
-0.3924914300441742,
-0.2933015525341034,
-0.2614576816558838,
0.7016667127609253,
0.48829594254493713,
0.2167513221502304,
-0.07486610859632492,
0.056912221014499664,
0.8067734241485596,
-0.8873934745788574,
0.350161612033844,
-0.675313413143158,
0.009367589838802814,
-0.06095331907272339,
-0.3024742603302002,
-0.6487950086593628,
-0.6379635334014893,
-0.2916531264781952,
-0.1285264939069748,
0.3263373076915741,
0.24906888604164124,
1.0889415740966797,
0.22980132699012756,
0.04345789924263954,
-0.3426790237426758,
-1.034080147743225,
0.8150949478149414,
-0.7528174519538879,
0.3220120668411255,
0.7673400044441223,
0.12400779128074646,
-0.16100415587425232,
-0.6517805457115173,
-0.5210237503051758,
0.17129062116146088,
0.1783159226179123,
0.002040454652160406,
-0.4549520015716553,
-0.17041274905204773,
0.37460386753082275,
0.15811437368392944,
-0.38839223980903625,
-0.22501015663146973,
-0.1647483855485916,
-0.35572052001953125,
0.49195581674575806,
0.12080658972263336,
0.5219860672950745,
0.18753942847251892,
-0.04260466247797012,
-0.3885897696018219,
-0.7201313972473145,
-0.20005793869495392,
0.6287888884544373,
0.28767821192741394,
-0.12777011096477509,
0.3955731987953186,
-0.01543084904551506,
0.7304229736328125,
-0.3152000606060028,
-0.15890048444271088,
-0.18127258121967316,
-0.0323164165019989,
-0.0032319219317287207,
0.06803982704877853,
0.7215853333473206,
0.19228196144104004,
0.5076407790184021,
-0.16131366789340973,
-0.5906156897544861,
0.32425564527511597,
0.3504907488822937,
-0.9455617070198059,
-0.5526042580604553,
0.029939670115709305,
-0.6222096085548401,
-0.4544031620025635,
0.21876823902130127,
-0.6481348872184753,
-0.36295515298843384,
-0.09332561492919922,
0.4479444622993469,
-0.44862547516822815,
-0.11754559725522995,
0.24970819056034088,
-0.18446898460388184,
-0.12342385202646255,
0.10896170139312744,
-0.9420623779296875,
0.23705993592739105,
0.43275824189186096,
0.5959456562995911,
-0.02460201270878315,
0.045411378145217896,
-0.41128987073898315,
0.26203423738479614,
-0.5245702266693115,
0.9349896311759949,
-0.6054268479347229,
-0.26144716143608093,
0.07913005352020264,
0.06739173084497452,
0.5428208708763123,
-0.6165381669998169,
0.338998407125473,
-0.8776229023933411,
0.0871569886803627,
-0.15977147221565247,
-0.6644659042358398,
-0.07314204424619675,
-0.03416099026799202,
-0.8225575089454651,
0.7254390120506287,
0.10426376014947891,
-1.1419175863265991,
0.3423190414905548,
-0.46731501817703247,
-0.4387303590774536,
0.06452611088752747,
0.07623150199651718,
-0.9521463513374329,
-0.34222203493118286,
-0.04730349779129028,
0.28924399614334106,
-0.04393942654132843,
0.15614594519138336,
-0.5018383264541626,
-0.35895252227783203,
0.864318311214447,
-0.7081462144851685,
0.6684133410453796,
0.17140133678913116,
-0.5072047710418701,
-0.047979213297367096,
-0.830954372882843,
0.41094970703125,
0.2090989351272583,
-0.5860567092895508,
-0.23717494308948517,
0.29752445220947266,
0.23204250633716583,
-0.23516854643821716,
0.12967219948768616,
-0.42698755860328674,
-0.13939058780670166,
0.11896257847547531,
0.6703146696090698,
0.7463469505310059,
0.02393040992319584,
0.3716331720352173,
-0.33834829926490784,
0.4131300151348114,
-0.046241022646427155,
0.03626507148146629,
-0.3003244996070862,
-0.7205763459205627,
-0.4685361981391907,
-0.5713475942611694,
0.8573535680770874,
0.6872899532318115,
-0.6543916463851929,
0.6532021164894104,
-0.027462802827358246,
-0.22391954064369202,
-0.39726945757865906,
0.17526458203792572,
0.4634741544723511,
0.30545365810394287,
0.3868114650249481,
-0.5603874921798706,
-0.47419869899749756,
-0.898681104183197,
-0.4482351243495941,
-0.38692235946655273,
-0.05381146818399429,
0.1297852098941803,
0.5458319783210754,
-0.5352702140808105,
1.0249807834625244,
-0.3979639410972595,
0.19021974503993988,
-0.18558241426944733,
0.41829001903533936,
-0.1889667510986328,
0.8484352231025696,
0.43231719732284546,
-0.8535906076431274,
-0.3612886071205139,
-0.08988245576620102,
-0.5740903615951538,
-0.4275912344455719,
0.09779782593250275,
-0.17444470524787903,
0.3912273347377777,
0.14589574933052063,
-0.04482034593820572,
0.8339709043502808,
0.711045503616333,
-0.47276923060417175,
0.6285490393638611,
-0.5603336095809937,
0.32754677534103394,
-0.592157244682312,
0.24872738122940063,
-0.17711949348449707,
-0.46049782633781433,
-0.4151161015033722,
-0.1111392229795456,
0.49132809042930603,
-0.1785096526145935,
0.043407365679740906,
0.3672938346862793,
-0.2906438112258911,
0.007067581173032522,
-0.7255785465240479,
-0.3490379750728607,
0.16606676578521729,
0.15061944723129272,
0.19998905062675476,
0.5725615620613098,
0.27068766951560974,
-0.3853752911090851,
0.20630812644958496,
-0.009071491658687592,
-0.38136786222457886,
0.44571641087532043,
-0.684269368648529,
0.3126741349697113,
-0.38652297854423523,
0.0958472341299057,
-0.912894606590271,
-0.25114479660987854,
0.3686775863170624,
-0.5184570550918579,
0.4167296290397644,
-0.3985559344291687,
-0.721169650554657,
0.10938379168510437,
-0.05951100215315819,
0.4256269335746765,
0.7595317363739014,
-0.4339924156665802,
0.1890830546617508,
0.39670589566230774,
-0.1463194042444229,
-0.580280065536499,
-1.0322376489639282,
0.06795704364776611,
-0.08118046075105667,
-0.4794444441795349,
0.40235504508018494,
-0.06146843731403351,
-0.20003917813301086,
0.2785954475402832,
-0.10862290859222412,
-0.797697901725769,
0.1589774489402771,
0.24485087394714355,
0.2711311876773834,
-0.08852743357419968,
-0.27318790555000305,
-0.029973242431879044,
-0.41940319538116455,
-0.13327176868915558,
-0.3406384289264679,
0.2499694973230362,
-0.04425516352057457,
-0.4503348469734192,
-0.5808228850364685,
0.638659656047821,
0.49123406410217285,
-0.3082053065299988,
0.7163519263267517,
0.4689749777317047,
-0.9183485507965088,
-0.3032640814781189,
-0.2845808267593384,
-0.319263219833374,
-0.44727689027786255,
0.14528928697109222,
0.2561511695384979,
-0.754599392414093,
0.5500926971435547,
0.35154470801353455,
-0.03754359483718872,
-0.01783585734665394,
0.3256293535232544,
-0.16329778730869293,
1.055092453956604,
0.8098006844520569,
-0.18102221190929413,
0.6592015027999878,
-0.0293751023709774,
0.40703287720680237,
-0.1916676014661789,
-0.08491417020559311,
-1.057637095451355,
-0.03894266113638878,
-0.38606804609298706,
-0.4029931128025055,
-0.13828134536743164,
0.5045821070671082,
-0.41896116733551025,
0.5883545875549316,
-0.6613867878913879,
0.6001508235931396,
0.7269403338432312,
0.20644830167293549,
0.19433346390724182,
0.1438542902469635,
0.053071774542331696,
-0.409879207611084,
-0.6930174827575684,
-0.9158827066421509,
0.8879148364067078,
0.2598111629486084,
0.9730157852172852,
-0.027048148214817047,
0.5554859638214111,
0.7677022218704224,
0.4908358156681061,
-0.33035391569137573,
0.14843818545341492,
-0.021179478615522385,
-0.8843377828598022,
-0.07380668073892593,
-0.6422382593154907,
-0.8418561816215515,
-0.1766340583562851,
-0.49454525113105774,
-0.6913375854492188,
0.010430151596665382,
0.4432304799556732,
-0.07057822495698929,
0.6229199171066284,
-0.8118884563446045,
1.0704741477966309,
-0.36322304606437683,
-0.5463453531265259,
-0.11025495082139969,
-0.43562766909599304,
-0.1967850625514984,
-0.16356755793094635,
0.5230067372322083,
0.03974897414445877,
-0.04187105968594551,
0.7348254323005676,
-0.17512348294258118,
0.8453026413917542,
-0.2988799512386322,
-0.06635008752346039,
0.5238221287727356,
0.5447076559066772,
0.5962613224983215,
-0.05592722445726395,
0.07763920724391937,
0.07841872423887253,
0.09548988938331604,
-0.7160142660140991,
-0.5485219955444336,
0.1397499144077301,
-0.4640374779701233,
0.010277162306010723,
-0.38743945956230164,
-0.2360997200012207,
0.08330097049474716,
0.40110698342323303,
0.14486999809741974,
0.5506506562232971,
0.09900178760290146,
0.2195640206336975,
0.7549965977668762,
-0.6455250382423401,
0.5515433549880981,
0.5343850255012512,
-0.002199841197580099,
-0.5904842615127563,
1.1242403984069824,
-0.08461373299360275,
0.1984815150499344,
0.4715040922164917,
0.1679295003414154,
-0.31647515296936035,
-0.7797021269798279,
-0.5588905215263367,
-0.019935261458158493,
-0.8456501960754395,
-0.43524423241615295,
-0.458803653717041,
-0.153627410531044,
0.03198346868157387,
-0.24236702919006348,
-0.6010174751281738,
-0.1558271199464798,
-0.07989607006311417,
0.26128414273262024,
0.26165318489074707,
0.8336371779441833,
-0.13148245215415955,
0.16707482933998108,
-1.0436476469039917,
0.37086349725723267,
0.1895509660243988,
0.6378920674324036,
-0.25947463512420654,
-0.520052969455719,
-0.319834440946579,
0.31026074290275574,
-0.38734719157218933,
-0.8752226829528809,
0.4953451156616211,
0.0327037014067173,
0.2803198993206024,
0.4554387927055359,
0.3050942122936249,
0.3944137394428253,
-0.3811367154121399,
0.627871036529541,
0.21384811401367188,
-1.313153862953186,
0.4466097950935364,
-0.26311731338500977,
0.12192676961421967,
0.17786681652069092,
0.08574330806732178,
-0.3910560607910156,
-0.51296067237854,
-0.6717591881752014,
-0.6951581239700317,
0.37942448258399963,
0.3212105333805084,
0.1491670459508896,
-0.0026044915430247784,
0.4667246639728546,
-0.03006371110677719,
0.1399838626384735,
-0.9306954741477966,
-0.197917640209198,
-0.3309708833694458,
-0.34004926681518555,
0.40333321690559387,
-0.5682571530342102,
0.06017667427659035,
0.1369168758392334,
0.7129267454147339,
-0.19122792780399323,
0.5927411317825317,
0.14365413784980774,
0.04798872023820877,
-0.35123786330223083,
0.28352752327919006,
0.4592553973197937,
0.5217827558517456,
-0.14360880851745605,
0.2723805010318756,
-0.08920930325984955,
-0.3696722686290741,
0.19051849842071533,
-0.27910304069519043,
-0.3363574147224426,
0.007502859923988581,
0.6188216805458069,
0.5108470320701599,
0.1357172429561615,
-0.7862364053726196,
0.5056660771369934,
-0.2491767555475235,
0.03314204141497612,
-0.012157450430095196,
0.05824241042137146,
0.08655604720115662,
0.006096359342336655,
0.18887118995189667,
0.46524783968925476,
-0.04970220476388931,
-0.413485050201416,
0.2967202365398407,
0.3793941140174866,
-0.3800281584262848,
-0.3864494264125824,
0.932705283164978,
0.04165614768862724,
-0.49675115942955017,
0.36272233724594116,
-0.20478524267673492,
-0.7507840991020203,
0.583173394203186,
0.7298442721366882,
0.778044581413269,
0.05268741026520729,
-0.02397870272397995,
0.38227778673171997,
0.49480950832366943,
-0.338875412940979,
0.28943318128585815,
-0.08667708933353424,
-0.9847999811172485,
-0.42790502309799194,
-0.588856041431427,
-0.7120350003242493,
-0.1342976987361908,
-0.7257913947105408,
0.15284918248653412,
-0.7273436188697815,
-0.23288682103157043,
0.08674613386392593,
-0.3725816011428833,
-0.41202878952026367,
0.3824964165687561,
0.280612051486969,
0.5341629981994629,
-0.6812868714332581,
0.9717223644256592,
0.7295306921005249,
0.05851729214191437,
-0.6462251543998718,
-0.026647428050637245,
-0.17598067224025726,
-0.5136042833328247,
0.4682517349720001,
0.10638875514268875,
-0.27730152010917664,
-0.2999635338783264,
-0.8627384305000305,
-0.6116629242897034,
0.5070035457611084,
0.7453399300575256,
-0.2870800793170929,
0.552516758441925,
0.2592722177505493,
0.5598562955856323,
-0.23473647236824036,
-0.07793094962835312,
0.29059773683547974,
0.43645763397216797,
-0.45416268706321716,
-0.5071127414703369,
0.12884610891342163,
-0.1985805481672287,
0.17297279834747314,
0.09823987632989883,
-0.24987611174583435,
0.5098035335540771,
-0.10772579163312912,
-0.3843417465686798,
0.10799796879291534,
0.396890252828598,
-0.03860509395599365,
0.022648662328720093,
0.27635708451271057,
0.3311230540275574,
0.7464941740036011,
-0.34841689467430115,
0.9459598660469055,
-0.48691970109939575,
0.44760623574256897,
0.6845502853393555,
-0.1347610056400299,
0.8294256925582886,
0.26383063197135925,
-0.2801796793937683,
0.5483137369155884,
0.3250257968902588,
0.03597763180732727,
0.5359857678413391,
0.27829667925834656,
-0.34526175260543823,
-0.39146241545677185,
0.13631850481033325,
-0.26256126165390015,
0.17840801179409027,
0.21198825538158417,
-0.6176652312278748,
0.2502252757549286,
-0.44776421785354614,
-0.09921430796384811,
0.3505920469760895,
-0.01900470443069935,
0.6420846581459045,
0.036862585693597794,
-0.3227403163909912,
0.7320255041122437,
0.5314205884933472,
0.7296473383903503,
-0.4896931052207947,
-0.14267665147781372,
-0.1301623284816742,
0.46606695652008057,
-0.31154704093933105,
-0.7925024032592773,
0.6283281445503235,
0.34567883610725403,
-0.4713236391544342,
-0.41036272048950195,
1.0148940086364746,
-0.47117093205451965,
-0.24140076339244843,
0.3200117349624634,
0.09933555126190186,
0.1645483523607254,
-0.049914292991161346,
-0.6957937479019165,
0.3817949891090393,
0.12854012846946716,
0.2146099954843521,
0.22053682804107666,
0.5073534846305847,
0.06801632791757584,
0.9356665015220642,
0.6212178468704224,
0.15985840559005737,
0.09076938033103943,
-0.010573343373835087,
0.33946964144706726,
-0.796895444393158,
-0.6359015107154846,
-0.8795979619026184,
0.42279911041259766,
0.020009588450193405,
0.03431969881057739,
0.45590928196907043,
0.4417336583137512,
0.7847181558609009,
-0.29258131980895996,
1.17735755443573,
-0.1025834009051323,
0.20070363581180573,
-0.2935695946216583,
0.9618123769760132,
-0.18327461183071136,
0.21149708330631256,
-0.6243769526481628,
-0.9240157604217529,
-0.637054979801178,
0.8467597365379333,
0.11907849460840225,
-0.047513868659734726,
0.5390897989273071,
1.0273197889328003,
0.04973879083991051,
0.32358890771865845,
0.3160979151725769,
-0.33908089995384216,
0.2824345529079437,
0.30346938967704773,
0.9474053978919983,
-0.6014315485954285,
0.649441123008728,
-0.4666467308998108,
-0.3830273747444153,
-0.007499716244637966,
-1.136724829673767,
-0.8095120787620544,
-0.4796801507472992,
-0.7553297877311707,
-0.9105353951454163,
0.15850010514259338,
0.7479613423347473,
0.8196317553520203,
-1.3143118619918823,
-0.06725157052278519,
-0.1353207528591156,
0.2932998239994049,
-0.29230907559394836,
-0.17366470396518707,
0.23367643356323242,
-0.09231797605752945,
-0.6036367416381836,
-0.16264048218727112,
0.27379462122917175,
0.6503584980964661,
-0.06337473541498184,
-0.27033573389053345,
0.47783219814300537,
0.08838576078414917,
0.23797325789928436,
0.37263569235801697,
-0.16304653882980347,
-0.5479833483695984,
-0.29329317808151245,
-0.2925211191177368,
0.01892917789518833,
1.0422316789627075,
-0.25002947449684143,
0.4933038055896759,
0.4225396513938904,
0.8817650675773621,
0.16442807018756866,
-0.026624999940395355,
0.5273374319076538,
-0.5482883453369141,
0.2533096373081207,
0.30260321497917175,
0.4826039969921112,
0.784871518611908,
-0.006046019960194826,
0.18690186738967896,
0.5920500159263611,
-0.5999665856361389,
-0.9439114928245544,
0.03800133988261223,
-0.7036279439926147,
-0.21498526632785797,
1.0527153015136719,
-0.6080299615859985,
-0.3174441456794739,
-0.3442152142524719,
-0.24140480160713196,
0.20475627481937408,
-0.3725765645503998,
1.0234445333480835,
0.7757586240768433,
0.33668437600135803,
0.08563239127397537,
-0.25088509917259216,
0.4528025984764099,
0.4077052175998688,
-0.781708836555481,
0.26627597212791443,
0.46185293793678284,
0.6186913847923279,
0.09616445004940033,
0.32041412591934204,
-0.44341331720352173,
0.367265909910202,
0.3522872030735016,
0.42176446318626404,
0.1397220492362976,
-0.29569748044013977,
-0.18292582035064697,
0.2245115339756012,
0.2618727684020996,
-0.0838698297739029
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10280v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10280v1
|
Transferable Embedding Inversion Attack: Uncovering Privacy Risks in Text Embeddings without Model Queries
| 2024-06-12T05:09:58 | 2024-06-12T05:09:58 |
Yu-Hsiang Huang, Yuche Tsai, Hsiang Hsiao, Hong-Yi Lin, Shou-De Lin
|
cs.CR
|
cs.CR, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
This study investigates the privacy risks associated with text embeddings,
focusing on the scenario where attackers cannot access the original embedding
model. Contrary to previous research requiring direct model access, we explore
a more realistic threat model by developing a transfer attack method. This
approach uses a surrogate model to mimic the victim model's behavior, allowing
the attacker to infer sensitive information from text embeddings without direct
access. Our experiments across various embedding models and a clinical dataset
demonstrate that our transfer attack significantly outperforms traditional
methods, revealing the potential privacy vulnerabilities in embedding
technologies and emphasizing the need for enhanced security measures.
|
[
-0.06470218300819397,
-0.8354678750038147,
0.49617138504981995,
-0.2639002203941345,
-0.02989530935883522,
0.1258578896522522,
0.32869061827659607,
-0.7262371182441711,
0.14964057505130768,
0.9445593953132629,
-0.4341265559196472,
-0.2659064829349518,
-1.0343408584594727,
-0.14719724655151367,
-0.7557711601257324,
0.7238612771034241,
0.07778853923082352,
-0.04687101021409035,
-0.3327125906944275,
-0.04926875978708267,
-0.4407147765159607,
-0.5083470940589905,
-0.32723066210746765,
0.14337962865829468,
0.10456296801567078,
0.13964590430259705,
0.8804910182952881,
0.26436081528663635,
0.8391733169555664,
0.2062642127275467,
0.1831873059272766,
-0.46218153834342957,
-0.5543577075004578,
0.06064167618751526,
-0.344272643327713,
-0.6113689541816711,
-0.34096571803092957,
-0.09780672192573547,
0.5207486152648926,
0.7496684193611145,
0.04590991884469986,
0.009893049485981464,
-0.0253245010972023,
0.8149195909500122,
-0.9724858999252319,
-0.46908941864967346,
-0.6074215173721313,
0.2881394922733307,
0.0038464092649519444,
-0.2821633815765381,
-0.7183756828308105,
-0.7187721133232117,
0.5494160056114197,
-0.33836111426353455,
0.20114193856716156,
-0.015033978037536144,
0.5879591107368469,
-0.061025220900774,
-0.7249499559402466,
-0.23474295437335968,
-0.8027729988098145,
0.412477046251297,
-0.31588345766067505,
0.40523919463157654,
0.4207051992416382,
0.3312164843082428,
0.042892683297395706,
-1.0219849348068237,
-0.1278894692659378,
-0.32896509766578674,
-0.2178715020418167,
-0.21379272639751434,
-0.6495945453643799,
-0.0010668039321899414,
0.38641512393951416,
0.3642653822898865,
-0.5305540561676025,
-0.09287773072719574,
-0.43112367391586304,
-0.12412795424461365,
0.5743545293807983,
0.037848081439733505,
0.613937258720398,
-0.007008104585111141,
-0.8343920111656189,
-0.12309371680021286,
-0.8624107241630554,
-0.06112280860543251,
0.36454084515571594,
0.007329760584980249,
-0.24690917134284973,
0.6248235106468201,
0.4365406334400177,
0.5015307068824768,
0.00977792963385582,
0.3365758955478668,
0.1438562572002411,
-0.1549195945262909,
-0.18838007748126984,
0.32378825545310974,
0.5704562067985535,
0.2551412880420685,
0.08498416095972061,
-0.3746456503868103,
0.06763443350791931,
-0.3291926681995392,
0.7373530864715576,
-0.867060124874115,
-0.1318429857492447,
0.19269315898418427,
-0.4963769018650055,
-0.4974484443664551,
0.45612832903862,
-1.0252926349639893,
-0.7525007128715515,
0.39924272894859314,
0.6687207221984863,
-0.683842658996582,
-0.31196585297584534,
0.2526826560497284,
-0.2935280501842499,
0.3285338580608368,
0.08870148658752441,
-0.5749713778495789,
0.5421273112297058,
0.41464194655418396,
0.8549661636352539,
-0.21337547898292542,
0.13700909912586212,
-0.23043403029441833,
0.69417405128479,
-0.2257869839668274,
0.6092137098312378,
-0.683305025100708,
-1.0304176807403564,
0.19773094356060028,
0.14376062154769897,
-0.3130010664463043,
-0.17677906155586243,
0.4273272752761841,
-0.5819864273071289,
0.014206098392605782,
-0.01875343546271324,
-0.7765749096870422,
-0.2373049259185791,
0.314744770526886,
-0.9700097441673279,
0.6139888763427734,
0.07411478459835052,
-1.0805338621139526,
-0.34669798612594604,
-0.6710720062255859,
-0.28542792797088623,
-0.32265782356262207,
-0.05081501975655556,
-0.3492398262023926,
0.27764955163002014,
0.20710153877735138,
0.42693284153938293,
0.1821502298116684,
-0.2892845869064331,
-0.4248564541339874,
-0.2206750512123108,
0.7812520265579224,
-0.5376042723655701,
1.001953363418579,
0.12816603481769562,
-0.37889766693115234,
-0.3226700723171234,
-0.788899838924408,
-0.13750271499156952,
0.2581154704093933,
0.22734060883522034,
-0.818120539188385,
-0.4717845320701599,
-0.2891996502876282,
-0.20247645676136017,
0.19806595146656036,
-0.8028644323348999,
0.31070202589035034,
-0.3711858093738556,
0.37959712743759155,
0.6421918272972107,
0.505264937877655,
0.8171674609184265,
-0.2584758996963501,
0.8665269017219543,
-0.1315995156764984,
0.2421496957540512,
0.12293488532304764,
-0.4356100857257843,
-0.05033548176288605,
-0.23901943862438202,
0.5146212577819824,
0.7210258841514587,
-0.5468860864639282,
0.1485549360513687,
-0.2563994824886322,
-0.5603030323982239,
-0.6237505078315735,
-0.3563538193702698,
0.3891286253929138,
0.6984731554985046,
0.1428419053554535,
-0.0000035159196158929262,
-0.24679350852966309,
-1.0244156122207642,
-0.7009277939796448,
0.11061649024486542,
0.16153296828269958,
0.3570057451725006,
0.4363195598125458,
-0.3574427366256714,
0.43436500430107117,
-0.8309086561203003,
-0.17853225767612457,
0.070424385368824,
-0.04673958942294121,
-0.19463835656642914,
1.0117112398147583,
0.7569272518157959,
-0.8430546522140503,
-0.35543757677078247,
0.0023550852201879025,
-0.7820426821708679,
0.2596955895423889,
-0.2863088846206665,
-0.24518078565597534,
-0.2165403664112091,
0.7543047666549683,
-0.5020814538002014,
1.035601258277893,
0.7404033541679382,
-0.2230968475341797,
0.22575895488262177,
-0.46204090118408203,
0.22396671772003174,
-1.2576444149017334,
0.19658547639846802,
-0.32293975353240967,
-0.5158682465553284,
-0.8337095379829407,
0.34074559807777405,
0.33261293172836304,
-0.43448111414909363,
-0.5514562726020813,
0.3459170460700989,
-0.6265533566474915,
-0.10246991366147995,
-0.10498080402612686,
-0.1688704788684845,
0.09401421248912811,
-0.08283466845750809,
-0.21792665123939514,
0.6779842972755432,
0.7432851195335388,
-0.4012168347835541,
-0.13560235500335693,
0.38642048835754395,
-0.23731043934822083,
0.5781875252723694,
-0.5623355507850647,
0.6741659045219421,
-0.12338881939649582,
0.14937753975391388,
-1.1929130554199219,
0.0007565866690129042,
0.5725399851799011,
-0.7208993434906006,
0.6943070888519287,
-0.22965723276138306,
-0.017777616158127785,
0.11712104827165604,
-0.7183095216751099,
0.5558541417121887,
0.47468069195747375,
-0.3975093960762024,
0.831405758857727,
0.38401520252227783,
-0.15544475615024567,
-0.7481405735015869,
-1.0723925828933716,
0.2605736553668976,
-0.30325451493263245,
-0.4354674816131592,
0.8299313187599182,
0.11406444758176804,
0.1819000542163849,
0.33947697281837463,
0.12170077860355377,
-0.33511000871658325,
0.4322604537010193,
0.4369128346443176,
0.17847855389118195,
0.03292091563344002,
-0.21065478026866913,
0.3401933014392853,
-0.33929628133773804,
0.21582747995853424,
0.1238371953368187,
0.20683221518993378,
0.28306788206100464,
-0.6601458787918091,
-0.8269491195678711,
0.7700461149215698,
0.24670125544071198,
-0.11984916776418686,
1.0757179260253906,
0.2423962503671646,
-0.9359859228134155,
-0.08585640043020248,
-0.3404075503349304,
-0.1544128656387329,
-0.4585826098918915,
0.38985079526901245,
-0.3223734200000763,
-0.7410222291946411,
0.4538740813732147,
-0.23554277420043945,
-0.12362028658390045,
0.23551353812217712,
0.06806419789791107,
-0.18673142790794373,
1.1630609035491943,
0.7147411108016968,
0.18790178000926971,
0.5879688262939453,
-0.11230722069740295,
0.059788335114717484,
-0.8281139135360718,
-0.5058509111404419,
-0.6705707311630249,
-0.29851627349853516,
-0.8850678205490112,
-0.03813759982585907,
0.3421053886413574,
-0.023764848709106445,
-0.10760989040136337,
0.656764030456543,
-0.52605140209198,
0.3381938338279724,
0.36834099888801575,
0.724147617816925,
0.43681272864341736,
0.1929571032524109,
0.06809429824352264,
-0.10555018484592438,
-0.17100432515144348,
-0.284624844789505,
1.3995146751403809,
0.32599225640296936,
1.0828348398208618,
0.379763662815094,
0.6962726712226868,
0.5167601108551025,
0.351082444190979,
-0.5582062602043152,
0.30008363723754883,
-0.027938267216086388,
-0.7754045724868774,
-0.11979846656322479,
-0.2725435793399811,
-1.2143259048461914,
0.12786513566970825,
-0.33232030272483826,
-1.2065844535827637,
0.5892142057418823,
-0.011411814950406551,
-0.23884668946266174,
0.5607557892799377,
-0.8895676732063293,
0.5828534364700317,
0.017554065212607384,
-0.36175477504730225,
-0.09243070334196091,
-0.7871764898300171,
0.346719890832901,
-0.17214886844158173,
0.3589029610157013,
0.3134131133556366,
-0.21156218647956848,
0.6145533919334412,
-0.29428598284721375,
1.000117540359497,
-0.2561202049255371,
0.06432902067899704,
-0.055455051362514496,
0.6607857942581177,
0.6580108404159546,
0.05958068370819092,
-0.06496191024780273,
0.09103512763977051,
0.35972532629966736,
-0.515117347240448,
-0.8119080662727356,
0.8209288120269775,
-0.6659438014030457,
-0.8302931189537048,
-0.5702170133590698,
-0.254167765378952,
-0.3404451310634613,
0.2048085331916809,
0.21424633264541626,
0.21693015098571777,
-0.36015406250953674,
0.4027591049671173,
0.6985670924186707,
-0.4618016481399536,
0.24491582810878754,
0.26573899388313293,
-0.09301246702671051,
-0.3760066032409668,
0.7429769039154053,
0.11534653604030609,
0.41446414589881897,
0.5668755769729614,
0.354602187871933,
-0.32802072167396545,
-0.6432369947433472,
-0.2592848241329193,
0.1398114711046219,
-0.5904654264450073,
0.008911152370274067,
-0.6689832806587219,
-0.41280293464660645,
-0.6176164150238037,
-0.33121711015701294,
-0.458283394575119,
-0.5027858018875122,
-0.4232713580131531,
-0.5326365232467651,
0.35663318634033203,
0.6798579692840576,
0.019458333030343056,
0.27968186140060425,
-1.3060722351074219,
0.20324593782424927,
0.24248847365379333,
0.1562475711107254,
-0.09940361976623535,
-0.6823937892913818,
0.1663425713777542,
0.019420646131038666,
-0.28648078441619873,
-1.405181646347046,
0.32311877608299255,
0.021775858476758003,
0.5066193342208862,
0.5997938513755798,
0.3289102017879486,
0.5773423314094543,
-0.49278804659843445,
0.6932868361473083,
0.1712343543767929,
-1.0631169080734253,
0.5477212071418762,
-0.017316078767180443,
-0.3704690635204315,
0.755301296710968,
0.8430245518684387,
-0.05545974522829056,
0.17362059652805328,
-0.8667883276939392,
-0.5408862829208374,
0.4363546669483185,
0.34956055879592896,
0.5011658072471619,
0.30138009786605835,
0.6118020415306091,
0.3585432767868042,
0.1741786003112793,
-0.7302903532981873,
-0.3446798026561737,
-0.014565613120794296,
0.12312355637550354,
0.32859352231025696,
-0.24315811693668365,
-0.29770711064338684,
-0.27591249346733093,
0.28936880826950073,
0.30463895201683044,
0.6165285110473633,
0.5193467736244202,
-0.3289555013179779,
0.14535678923130035,
-0.06194738671183586,
0.40794074535369873,
0.36409634351730347,
-0.3901175856590271,
0.4314785599708557,
0.21378278732299805,
-0.8003793954849243,
0.27340230345726013,
0.2834588885307312,
-0.06810855865478516,
-0.052298255264759064,
0.4484442174434662,
0.5988587737083435,
0.30783137679100037,
-0.3563106060028076,
0.9481204152107239,
-0.2367728054523468,
-0.25585314631462097,
-0.4541337192058563,
-0.09787555038928986,
-0.001824751729145646,
0.06418055295944214,
0.05359373241662979,
0.20720170438289642,
0.4182443618774414,
-0.3539702892303467,
0.3295719027519226,
0.5242440700531006,
-1.0208392143249512,
-0.4781745672225952,
0.6721912622451782,
-0.0038473501335829496,
-0.46415233612060547,
0.457642138004303,
0.724014401435852,
-0.13866004347801208,
0.700107991695404,
0.8276365399360657,
0.9898879528045654,
-0.8426219820976257,
0.2485986351966858,
0.02097800187766552,
0.5262172818183899,
0.17444464564323425,
0.22577698528766632,
0.20076963305473328,
-0.5509533286094666,
0.21789947152137756,
0.14407362043857574,
-0.6264776587486267,
-0.2248411327600479,
-1.2933790683746338,
0.02610287256538868,
-0.5567976236343384,
-0.3235108554363251,
-0.019767947494983673,
-0.5291790962219238,
-0.6852002143859863,
0.08161725848913193,
-0.14216521382331848,
0.8719004392623901,
-0.741787850856781,
0.6175058484077454,
0.7336480021476746,
-0.09652295708656311,
-0.33399876952171326,
-0.04203209653496742,
-0.2517794668674469,
-1.0293728113174438,
0.08057210594415665,
0.2019818276166916,
-0.0365569144487381,
0.051604971289634705,
-0.6291791796684265,
-0.7983994483947754,
1.0518525838851929,
0.913015604019165,
-0.3489397466182709,
-0.2051372230052948,
0.3938904106616974,
0.28748053312301636,
-0.13091707229614258,
0.09137748181819916,
0.4111019968986511,
0.2128067910671234,
-0.04320431873202324,
-0.27517926692962646,
0.5891549587249756,
0.1754816323518753,
-0.14382150769233704,
-0.058217089623212814,
-0.2727530896663666,
0.6627230644226074,
-0.1795889437198639,
-0.3492772877216339,
0.01128065399825573,
0.3601420819759369,
-0.20344075560569763,
0.32129818201065063,
0.34121209383010864,
0.6016533970832825,
0.7040661573410034,
0.33040961623191833,
1.5933881998062134,
-0.2863672077655792,
0.17686381936073303,
0.8893211483955383,
-0.3170883357524872,
0.9042962193489075,
0.6398671269416809,
-0.16429200768470764,
0.6255194544792175,
0.13049839437007904,
0.2827759087085724,
0.8339827060699463,
0.11584875732660294,
-0.31967994570732117,
0.06393710523843765,
-0.030182771384716034,
-0.8070057034492493,
0.2977304458618164,
0.5199631452560425,
-0.7919722199440002,
-0.14648476243019104,
0.39000096917152405,
0.12002779543399811,
0.07509315758943558,
-0.10892853885889053,
0.813980221748352,
0.3329516053199768,
-0.08314505219459534,
0.14768359065055847,
-0.12105809897184372,
0.324114590883255,
-0.7313778400421143,
-0.12717650830745697,
-0.03046460449695587,
0.12998323142528534,
-0.3521827459335327,
-0.664761483669281,
0.5181402564048767,
-0.15827156603336334,
0.1485031396150589,
-0.09316074103116989,
1.048882246017456,
0.21198898553848267,
-0.5781728625297546,
0.38303226232528687,
0.45288988947868347,
-0.05297400802373886,
-0.02966775745153427,
-0.7226113677024841,
-0.17343315482139587,
0.0880543440580368,
-0.6432705521583557,
0.7892391681671143,
0.30430930852890015,
0.05229030176997185,
0.7800801992416382,
0.7648565769195557,
0.13322071731090546,
0.07323889434337616,
-0.23948824405670166,
0.9398157596588135,
-0.7721182703971863,
-0.4793041944503784,
-1.0846812725067139,
0.3929227888584137,
-0.07576673477888107,
-0.07795558124780655,
0.7394006848335266,
0.35446420311927795,
0.47042474150657654,
-0.22809144854545593,
0.7501419186592102,
0.2769155502319336,
0.5438591837882996,
-0.5467733144760132,
0.9336296916007996,
-0.36282673478126526,
0.2966671586036682,
-0.6228630542755127,
-0.49653157591819763,
-0.46132591366767883,
0.4271789789199829,
-0.3575737774372101,
-0.28804123401641846,
0.8640094995498657,
0.7709532380104065,
0.03222082182765007,
0.3292666971683502,
0.2649427056312561,
0.14956910908222198,
0.3893382251262665,
0.519299328327179,
0.855780303478241,
-0.7683284878730774,
0.47192373871803284,
-0.327151894569397,
-0.3214011788368225,
0.011048455722630024,
-1.2335247993469238,
-0.985525906085968,
-0.3474445939064026,
-0.43688133358955383,
-0.6806638836860657,
0.15882115066051483,
0.40918317437171936,
0.4006335735321045,
-0.6955240964889526,
0.23318181931972504,
0.004443144425749779,
0.20600342750549316,
-0.1053863987326622,
-0.28840023279190063,
0.7267752885818481,
0.6170937418937683,
-0.6690120100975037,
0.2620226740837097,
-0.14927954971790314,
0.4900834262371063,
-0.11299674212932587,
0.5192356109619141,
-0.2181660383939743,
0.14176416397094727,
0.10177110135555267,
0.3697308301925659,
-0.043070729821920395,
-0.4887661635875702,
-0.11622098088264465,
-0.10237086564302444,
-0.07775560021400452,
0.7839747071266174,
-0.6794677376747131,
0.43579134345054626,
0.5573834776878357,
1.4134758710861206,
0.45793411135673523,
0.14616356790065765,
0.4815857410430908,
-0.7908703088760376,
0.23490311205387115,
0.26214221119880676,
0.08856412768363953,
0.1844274252653122,
-0.9650155305862427,
0.23545199632644653,
0.18472698330879211,
-0.15335246920585632,
-1.0361117124557495,
0.08896281570196152,
-1.1052658557891846,
-0.4513998329639435,
0.7576389312744141,
-0.46054962277412415,
-0.5058797597885132,
-0.07735238969326019,
-0.2908652722835541,
-0.023491067811846733,
-0.26998135447502136,
0.7655560374259949,
0.3542368412017822,
-0.22258241474628448,
0.015994884073734283,
-0.6244395971298218,
0.41484662890434265,
0.20377540588378906,
-0.7299048900604248,
-0.2346794307231903,
-0.0548304058611393,
0.478645384311676,
0.07075246423482895,
0.33659568428993225,
-0.6273595094680786,
0.12837237119674683,
0.01561280433088541,
-0.32899391651153564,
-0.3303762376308441,
-0.023954356089234352,
-0.5500989556312561,
0.5341005921363831,
-0.20650440454483032,
-0.7243746519088745
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.07860v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.07860v1
|
BookSQL: A Large Scale Text-to-SQL Dataset for Accounting Domain
| 2024-06-12T04:22:27 | 2024-06-12T04:22:27 |
Rahul Kumar, Amar Raja Dibbu, Shrutendra Harsola, Vignesh Subrahmaniam, Ashutosh Modi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Several large-scale datasets (e.g., WikiSQL, Spider) for developing natural
language interfaces to databases have recently been proposed. These datasets
cover a wide breadth of domains but fall short on some essential domains, such
as finance and accounting. Given that accounting databases are used worldwide,
particularly by non-technical people, there is an imminent need to develop
models that could help extract information from accounting databases via
natural language queries. In this resource paper, we aim to fill this gap by
proposing a new large-scale Text-to-SQL dataset for the accounting and
financial domain: BookSQL. The dataset consists of 100k natural language
queries-SQL pairs, and accounting databases of 1 million records. We experiment
with and analyze existing state-of-the-art models (including GPT-4) for the
Text-to-SQL task on BookSQL. We find significant performance gaps, thus
pointing towards developing more focused models for this domain.
|
[
-0.11193378269672394,
-0.5721492767333984,
0.1438353806734085,
0.07847952842712402,
-0.4148130416870117,
0.08722115308046341,
0.031089238822460175,
-0.6815077662467957,
-0.12719039618968964,
0.8526425361633301,
-0.524592399597168,
-0.4780745208263397,
-0.43643903732299805,
0.14599759876728058,
-0.3800484836101532,
1.2334930896759033,
0.1785275638103485,
-0.09344681352376938,
-0.22327622771263123,
-0.04204539209604263,
-0.6373980641365051,
-0.6606358885765076,
-0.7218327522277832,
0.10582365095615387,
0.32355138659477234,
0.051123231649398804,
0.7729388475418091,
0.30901074409484863,
0.4495146572589874,
0.1622907519340515,
0.0742110162973404,
0.3174366056919098,
-0.26259303092956543,
0.15191638469696045,
-0.5223658680915833,
-0.16274899244308472,
-0.6433457732200623,
-0.40965208411216736,
0.8015637993812561,
0.7488014698028564,
-0.3756893277168274,
0.23669280111789703,
0.06059246137738228,
1.2044316530227661,
-0.4875946342945099,
0.7641304731369019,
-0.2573964297771454,
-0.0616045743227005,
-0.32958585023880005,
0.025227807462215424,
-0.3902471363544464,
-0.44950637221336365,
0.6179296970367432,
-0.7024352550506592,
0.2928963303565979,
0.15801101922988892,
0.6420418620109558,
-0.11342329531908035,
-0.8453501462936401,
-0.6515471935272217,
-0.5983269810676575,
0.5398579239845276,
-0.7908527851104736,
0.5674697756767273,
0.4861012399196625,
0.307416707277298,
0.14621394872665405,
-0.5344662666320801,
-0.3580138683319092,
0.07791667431592941,
-0.3411317467689514,
-0.055946554988622665,
-0.06281452625989914,
-0.31487005949020386,
0.1534416228532791,
0.2339714914560318,
-0.6769281625747681,
-0.15400786697864532,
-0.027643607929348946,
0.18962398171424866,
0.8358705043792725,
0.39865434169769287,
0.05003137141466141,
-0.06910008192062378,
-0.16599038243293762,
-0.13687090575695038,
-0.5427380204200745,
-0.05135791748762131,
0.22827930748462677,
0.7701094150543213,
0.09189628064632416,
0.4591553211212158,
-0.24879679083824158,
0.9999526739120483,
-0.4559420347213745,
-0.026408161967992783,
-0.06898859143257141,
-0.387100487947464,
-0.4012879729270935,
0.19457237422466278,
0.41301652789115906,
0.2906354069709778,
0.3121258616447449,
-0.2856488525867462,
-0.5458777546882629,
-0.35129237174987793,
0.15085729956626892,
-0.7506316304206848,
-0.21363620460033417,
0.29697704315185547,
-0.2764986753463745,
-0.05388893932104111,
-0.15653833746910095,
-0.8313910365104675,
-0.6240445971488953,
-0.5999072194099426,
0.5707703232765198,
-0.5101923942565918,
-0.34615781903266907,
0.08360783755779266,
-0.23530922830104828,
0.33152610063552856,
0.19738537073135376,
-1.0370994806289673,
0.8497477769851685,
0.9336175322532654,
0.6606484055519104,
0.013425306417047977,
0.22311128675937653,
-0.5763335227966309,
0.5811046361923218,
-0.5555932521820068,
0.7697759866714478,
-0.40799930691719055,
-0.3607577085494995,
0.2762480676174164,
-0.03706600144505501,
0.1078135073184967,
-0.6748504638671875,
0.4124199450016022,
-0.9968937039375305,
-0.017876744270324707,
-0.45132532715797424,
-1.0471677780151367,
-0.006678007077425718,
0.040836889296770096,
-1.0657386779785156,
0.783482015132904,
0.4445594251155853,
-0.47655344009399414,
0.5771239399909973,
-0.7022214531898499,
-0.6281285285949707,
0.4505864977836609,
-0.1821078360080719,
-0.4845195412635803,
-0.32843533158302307,
0.20640426874160767,
0.37068670988082886,
-0.9585457444190979,
0.596884548664093,
0.1981896013021469,
-0.1737000048160553,
0.20097821950912476,
-0.24810545146465302,
0.8428899049758911,
0.16129101812839508,
-0.0061696781776845455,
-0.7623748183250427,
-0.8596379160881042,
0.04574394226074219,
0.24882647395133972,
-0.25450876355171204,
-0.7681613564491272,
0.29600340127944946,
0.21919786930084229,
-0.3496418297290802,
0.4147491455078125,
-0.23751048743724823,
0.4873805344104767,
-0.29241302609443665,
0.5198505520820618,
0.4389705955982208,
-0.010217305272817612,
0.2706328332424164,
-0.22974318265914917,
0.46341025829315186,
-0.0893341526389122,
0.09325607120990753,
-0.18428710103034973,
-0.3962773084640503,
-0.07625053077936172,
-0.23770295083522797,
0.654930830001831,
0.5829141139984131,
-0.7040875554084778,
0.31176048517227173,
-0.25670918822288513,
-0.5703680515289307,
-0.07404180616140366,
0.03214475139975548,
0.1867520809173584,
0.34654325246810913,
0.2886659502983093,
-0.31710299849510193,
-0.13256289064884186,
-0.9678284525871277,
-0.7483225464820862,
0.1031496450304985,
-0.31358784437179565,
0.39063045382499695,
0.30859658122062683,
0.08244195580482483,
1.0018055438995361,
-0.8321776986122131,
-0.5934327244758606,
0.2243480086326599,
0.01881418563425541,
0.46721524000167847,
0.4312739968299866,
0.48907288908958435,
-1.188913345336914,
-0.6371104717254639,
0.25992777943611145,
-0.5418746471405029,
0.27598124742507935,
-0.16218559443950653,
-0.26273953914642334,
0.47448453307151794,
0.18278060853481293,
-0.7369557023048401,
0.4347286522388458,
0.21902412176132202,
-0.696898341178894,
0.5253394246101379,
0.006038718391209841,
0.013243352994322777,
-0.9855976700782776,
0.08209454268217087,
0.24866342544555664,
-0.1735028624534607,
-0.46635788679122925,
-0.41866040229797363,
0.5532958507537842,
-0.41491997241973877,
0.25582894682884216,
0.6103352308273315,
-0.6451733112335205,
-0.4317046105861664,
0.36868152022361755,
0.17988069355487823,
0.35686057806015015,
0.4107073247432709,
0.1638641655445099,
0.8425150513648987,
0.6314643621444702,
-0.6475810408592224,
0.4111593961715698,
0.6701153516769409,
-0.6415797472000122,
0.8059781193733215,
-0.33788663148880005,
-0.04639194905757904,
0.18785133957862854,
0.2347094565629959,
-0.9663419127464294,
-0.19938990473747253,
-0.1431705802679062,
-0.2500867545604706,
0.4770400822162628,
-0.29854103922843933,
-0.6374234557151794,
-0.20469240844249725,
0.025852862745523453,
0.3848431706428528,
0.2381979078054428,
-0.4747225046157837,
0.7965683341026306,
0.3693118691444397,
-0.7172079086303711,
-0.6004167199134827,
-0.7054042816162109,
0.3415650725364685,
0.06298850476741791,
-0.550981879234314,
0.41822507977485657,
0.15322726964950562,
-0.07329769432544708,
0.3851119875907898,
-0.21769531071186066,
-0.5088526010513306,
-0.3139289617538452,
-0.3255973160266876,
0.7324013710021973,
-0.4795071482658386,
0.5032492876052856,
-0.07384057343006134,
0.16423489153385162,
0.021989362314343452,
-0.7290623188018799,
0.008397223427891731,
0.05553511530160904,
-0.040905117988586426,
-0.2572947144508362,
0.4918781518936157,
0.3051789700984955,
-0.5222858190536499,
1.0019938945770264,
-0.26111119985580444,
-0.6037998795509338,
-0.34347236156463623,
-0.49907591938972473,
0.2591886520385742,
-0.483243852853775,
0.3256032168865204,
-0.1769452840089798,
-0.7822092771530151,
0.336698442697525,
0.01587824895977974,
0.4768373668193817,
0.5648298859596252,
0.3976890742778778,
0.2463086098432541,
0.5532815456390381,
0.5193155407905579,
-0.037737201899290085,
0.30653756856918335,
-0.19583801925182343,
0.4713800549507141,
-0.44757890701293945,
-0.23733390867710114,
-0.6934869289398193,
0.16761930286884308,
-0.4288489520549774,
-0.270153671503067,
0.11273135989904404,
-0.12626466155052185,
-0.35665538907051086,
0.48581039905548096,
-0.3701101541519165,
0.6562771201133728,
0.2518320679664612,
-0.41715097427368164,
0.5064660906791687,
0.09141211956739426,
0.1252305954694748,
0.07307586073875427,
-0.5038451552391052,
-0.43719005584716797,
1.0105044841766357,
-0.20338581502437592,
0.6469125151634216,
0.4648194909095764,
0.3723697066307068,
0.5923064351081848,
0.33176910877227783,
-0.6488689184188843,
0.16042806208133698,
-0.5209795832633972,
-1.0441416501998901,
-0.7208808660507202,
-0.6381347179412842,
-0.978483259677887,
0.10930254310369492,
0.10900788009166718,
-0.3260047435760498,
0.2831127941608429,
0.08974213898181915,
-0.39464443922042847,
0.3062313199043274,
-1.0108354091644287,
0.9829870462417603,
-0.17074410617351532,
-0.3611811101436615,
0.30770474672317505,
-0.5274418592453003,
0.24308271706104279,
-0.5728127360343933,
0.4757409989833832,
0.08341336250305176,
-0.12692305445671082,
0.9528306126594543,
-0.6275807023048401,
0.7040441036224365,
-0.2285321056842804,
-0.5977941155433655,
0.4856279194355011,
0.2475171983242035,
0.6218279600143433,
0.1729644536972046,
-0.3046829104423523,
0.12321189790964127,
0.5821760892868042,
-0.5583621859550476,
-0.5515175461769104,
0.2938838601112366,
-0.44576218724250793,
-0.19021235406398773,
-0.5784883499145508,
-0.37736934423446655,
-0.6752716898918152,
0.2118055522441864,
-0.35619762539863586,
0.872462272644043,
-0.2922404408454895,
0.10030079632997513,
0.3546304702758789,
-0.15901106595993042,
0.17619194090366364,
0.9326171875,
0.020403152331709862,
-0.2822321653366089,
0.9034061431884766,
0.6080400943756104,
0.23181767761707306,
0.49331578612327576,
-0.17785049974918365,
-0.5859874486923218,
-0.19518765807151794,
-0.3145006000995636,
0.3677009344100952,
-0.40212616324424744,
-0.744856059551239,
-0.1873141974210739,
-0.2044408619403839,
-0.7583995461463928,
0.04571094363927841,
-0.2866908013820648,
-0.47834694385528564,
-0.16066811978816986,
0.16442248225212097,
0.6758703589439392,
0.8380534648895264,
0.26191219687461853,
0.09563353657722473,
-1.1195013523101807,
0.4084678590297699,
0.43510520458221436,
0.7899190187454224,
0.31629273295402527,
-0.20187778770923615,
-0.6051557064056396,
-0.2856922447681427,
-0.13418841361999512,
-0.7091728448867798,
0.5857374668121338,
0.291957825422287,
0.1433819681406021,
0.39774060249328613,
0.29379165172576904,
0.5103273391723633,
-0.6902779340744019,
0.6923444271087646,
0.0442599393427372,
-0.9100719690322876,
0.3031928837299347,
-0.5597242712974548,
0.03105398267507553,
0.3608946204185486,
0.5802062153816223,
-0.9435214996337891,
0.03973110765218735,
-0.5858976244926453,
-0.9423995614051819,
0.8378273844718933,
0.2771720588207245,
-0.08854861557483673,
0.1596589982509613,
0.6305608153343201,
0.3939669132232666,
0.40947213768959045,
-0.3550739586353302,
-0.05032697692513466,
0.10846219956874847,
-0.08661556988954544,
-0.24427242577075958,
-0.2125152349472046,
0.11771056801080704,
-0.14515994489192963,
0.7410269975662231,
-0.06135423108935356,
0.09286916255950928,
0.186385378241539,
0.3402954638004303,
-0.18392324447631836,
0.05093763396143913,
-0.2045077532529831,
1.048626184463501,
-0.3030853867530823,
-0.3305043578147888,
-0.17433173954486847,
-0.49305960536003113,
-0.2082730084657669,
0.5506302118301392,
0.021549899131059647,
-0.06658462435007095,
0.37216418981552124,
0.4003722667694092,
0.048736244440078735,
-1.0008209943771362,
0.4408634603023529,
-0.1977280080318451,
-0.3406738042831421,
-0.5438567399978638,
-0.24792134761810303,
0.5957074761390686,
0.4698474705219269,
0.7463871836662292,
-0.3542453348636627,
0.2900645434856415,
-0.5200053453445435,
0.24911051988601685,
0.3938259184360504,
-0.10638178884983063,
-0.02276141382753849,
0.5721856355667114,
0.08142206072807312,
-0.44963887333869934,
0.8074586987495422,
-0.05576155707240105,
-0.2922738194465637,
0.7830626368522644,
0.27831265330314636,
0.49324536323547363,
-0.23815500736236572,
0.16124428808689117,
0.30545592308044434,
0.23926836252212524,
-0.13307015597820282,
0.16780705749988556,
-0.13957612216472626,
-0.535761833190918,
-0.5889498591423035,
-0.7552064657211304,
-0.7494890689849854,
-0.02338961511850357,
-0.8339133262634277,
0.31072762608528137,
-0.2630523145198822,
-0.03622879087924957,
0.34578418731689453,
0.24022243916988373,
-0.6476435661315918,
0.3606620132923126,
-0.05889033153653145,
0.9185687303543091,
-0.5267022848129272,
0.8392759561538696,
0.3137131631374359,
-0.3617249131202698,
-0.6689241528511047,
-0.29285895824432373,
-0.16113533079624176,
-0.5991367697715759,
0.5290514826774597,
-0.1518630087375641,
0.30493980646133423,
0.034540414810180664,
-0.6558511257171631,
-0.6400399804115295,
1.0943623781204224,
0.2036782205104828,
-0.8718748688697815,
-0.41407591104507446,
0.3852962553501129,
0.30529481172561646,
-0.24466894567012787,
-0.3617610037326813,
0.8851735591888428,
0.33546456694602966,
0.01664547808468342,
-0.67830491065979,
-0.12315034866333008,
-0.13180965185165405,
-0.012250280007719994,
0.6354615688323975,
-0.7346713542938232,
1.041553020477295,
0.21294088661670685,
-0.020440539345145226,
-0.020775161683559418,
0.491848349571228,
0.0011091867927461863,
0.43311887979507446,
0.3710763454437256,
0.27113160490989685,
1.018319845199585,
0.15841569006443024,
1.1266249418258667,
-0.024147700518369675,
0.6176410913467407,
1.1068708896636963,
-0.7247999906539917,
0.8584865927696228,
0.06931172311306,
-0.5569841265678406,
0.16538885235786438,
0.582215428352356,
-0.15340551733970642,
0.36062708497047424,
0.08988766372203827,
-0.5020065903663635,
-0.2598828971385956,
0.026738328859210014,
-0.36701199412345886,
-0.20286881923675537,
0.558256208896637,
0.0021395564544945955,
-0.09250988811254501,
-0.3736494183540344,
-0.26056376099586487,
-0.09894197434186935,
-0.03499963879585266,
0.7434022426605225,
0.30001917481422424,
-0.32823044061660767,
0.3823661506175995,
-0.05320821702480316,
0.252225399017334,
-0.8495165109634399,
-0.22182035446166992,
-0.32619521021842957,
-0.10720536857843399,
0.02296767197549343,
-0.7514671087265015,
0.15416747331619263,
0.13225717842578888,
0.09778466075658798,
-0.02240186370909214,
0.7328372001647949,
-0.3022253215312958,
-0.4330618679523468,
0.271963894367218,
0.36704549193382263,
0.053542472422122955,
-0.31754836440086365,
-0.4568776488304138,
-0.5524309873580933,
-0.22483573853969574,
-0.3586895763874054,
0.43562474846839905,
1.2775815725326538,
-0.0468955859541893,
0.3583472967147827,
0.6739467978477478,
-0.04343504458665848,
-0.18993769586086273,
-0.06672004610300064,
0.8433181643486023,
-1.0964317321777344,
-0.7086402773857117,
-0.6341931223869324,
0.14390328526496887,
-0.08688569068908691,
-0.1521940380334854,
0.4657618999481201,
0.961857795715332,
0.5411443114280701,
-0.09442620724439621,
0.838084876537323,
0.012581568211317062,
0.9034997224807739,
-0.4955650866031647,
0.7110203504562378,
-0.7600159049034119,
0.10745911300182343,
-0.4238109290599823,
-0.954026997089386,
-0.16994720697402954,
0.20740216970443726,
-0.12414082884788513,
-0.014552169479429722,
0.6377038359642029,
0.6048601269721985,
0.17936332523822784,
0.5488234758377075,
0.42874494194984436,
0.2988244593143463,
0.3011348247528076,
0.4265929162502289,
0.45096859335899353,
-0.5075900554656982,
0.6744052767753601,
0.06501499563455582,
-0.056650880724191666,
-0.2977863550186157,
-0.9443264007568359,
-0.5218967795372009,
-0.7498542666435242,
-0.40443727374076843,
-0.24985100328922272,
0.07442636787891388,
0.556545078754425,
0.21972444653511047,
-0.8280664086341858,
-0.5386061072349548,
0.2049519419670105,
-0.19234977662563324,
-0.2481694370508194,
-0.20448924601078033,
0.7013119459152222,
-0.3056500256061554,
-0.4657513499259949,
0.0010684070875868201,
0.15005482733249664,
-0.0749422088265419,
0.007296104449778795,
0.03888867795467377,
-0.3198546767234802,
0.279680460691452,
0.7276833057403564,
0.21064703166484833,
-0.03853326290845871,
0.08035960793495178,
-0.11399644613265991,
-0.05056250840425491,
-0.05187343806028366,
0.8577516078948975,
-0.5549405813217163,
0.13894879817962646,
0.04901284724473953,
1.0226521492004395,
0.7105059623718262,
0.023611854761838913,
0.48905155062675476,
-0.6370264291763306,
-0.11673735082149506,
0.32142847776412964,
-0.018033068627119064,
0.18253374099731445,
-0.6898983120918274,
0.8145288228988647,
0.17261120676994324,
-0.689930260181427,
-0.6126363277435303,
-0.174747496843338,
-0.99754399061203,
-0.475614458322525,
0.8523269891738892,
0.27591004967689514,
-0.26144784688949585,
-0.23056547343730927,
-0.18073947727680206,
0.09708821028470993,
-0.6654375791549683,
0.35056576132774353,
1.0211642980575562,
-0.07326187938451767,
0.3722170889377594,
-1.0793906450271606,
0.6867408156394958,
0.36024171113967896,
-0.7530689835548401,
0.7379972338676453,
0.7255964279174805,
0.2659201920032501,
-0.0613766610622406,
0.7340094447135925,
-0.2029184252023697,
0.20573553442955017,
0.05220847204327583,
0.013030752539634705,
0.33776429295539856,
0.05925862863659859,
-0.05290094390511513,
0.09925743192434311,
0.11258351057767868,
0.3120676279067993
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.07855v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.07855v1
|
VALL-E R: Robust and Efficient Zero-Shot Text-to-Speech Synthesis via Monotonic Alignment
| 2024-06-12T04:09:44 | 2024-06-12T04:09:44 |
Bing Han, Long Zhou, Shujie Liu, Sanyuan Chen, Lingwei Meng, Yanming Qian, Yanqing Liu, Sheng Zhao, Jinyu Li, Furu Wei
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
With the help of discrete neural audio codecs, large language models (LLM)
have increasingly been recognized as a promising methodology for zero-shot
Text-to-Speech (TTS) synthesis. However, sampling based decoding strategies
bring astonishing diversity to generation, but also pose robustness issues such
as typos, omissions and repetition. In addition, the high sampling rate of
audio also brings huge computational overhead to the inference process of
autoregression. To address these issues, we propose VALL-E R, a robust and
efficient zero-shot TTS system, building upon the foundation of VALL-E.
Specifically, we introduce a phoneme monotonic alignment strategy to strengthen
the connection between phonemes and acoustic sequence, ensuring a more precise
alignment by constraining the acoustic tokens to match their associated
phonemes. Furthermore, we employ a codec-merging approach to downsample the
discrete codes in shallow quantization layer, thereby accelerating the decoding
speed while preserving the high quality of speech output. Benefiting from these
strategies, VALL-E R obtains controllablity over phonemes and demonstrates its
strong robustness by approaching the WER of ground truth. In addition, it
requires fewer autoregressive steps, with over 60% time reduction during
inference. This research has the potential to be applied to meaningful
projects, including the creation of speech for those affected by aphasia. Audio
samples will be available at: https://aka.ms/valler.
|
[
-0.3909563422203064,
-0.7372161746025085,
0.12262856960296631,
-0.025917481631040573,
-0.22801455855369568,
0.2213541865348816,
0.02938096597790718,
-0.2645595669746399,
0.3793918490409851,
0.3544969856739044,
-0.6635792255401611,
-0.8460094928741455,
-0.300415962934494,
0.19567137956619263,
-0.49916112422943115,
0.977078378200531,
0.3883363604545593,
-0.2911929488182068,
0.2753574252128601,
-0.3479100167751312,
-0.4118751585483551,
-0.6212642192840576,
-0.6631146669387817,
-0.05912044644355774,
0.6129456162452698,
0.3424951732158661,
0.44117283821105957,
0.9404468536376953,
0.0778188556432724,
0.16662871837615967,
-0.15767571330070496,
-0.0836808830499649,
-0.37633568048477173,
0.5798194408416748,
0.24435415863990784,
-0.245657816529274,
-0.9370355010032654,
-0.32203468680381775,
0.628711998462677,
0.37440142035484314,
-0.34434759616851807,
0.3206340968608856,
0.002836748491972685,
0.6907932758331299,
-0.7740874886512756,
-0.41322410106658936,
-0.6425257921218872,
0.23860661685466766,
-0.1776690036058426,
-0.23607021570205688,
-0.5213744640350342,
-0.3917555809020996,
0.05517297238111496,
-0.5760630369186401,
0.059035833925008774,
-0.17465659976005554,
0.6285502910614014,
0.6068640947341919,
-0.06996138393878937,
0.002186606638133526,
-0.8327547311782837,
1.0267455577850342,
-0.8872101306915283,
0.5103101134300232,
0.14726515114307404,
0.18129703402519226,
0.1414032280445099,
-0.5695474147796631,
-0.516202986240387,
0.26966574788093567,
0.4069187045097351,
0.25569382309913635,
0.005473725032061338,
0.10427393764257431,
0.1675744354724884,
0.2857339084148407,
-0.7434830069541931,
-0.03766832500696182,
-0.10219224542379379,
-0.3062601089477539,
0.2455439567565918,
0.06198569014668465,
0.3842470049858093,
-0.0661059245467186,
-0.33008071780204773,
-0.1472693532705307,
-0.7847233414649963,
-0.046554792672395706,
0.30425146222114563,
0.6267840266227722,
-0.24600274860858917,
0.6034647226333618,
0.11925569176673889,
1.0208550691604614,
0.1711874008178711,
-0.22556304931640625,
0.26969608664512634,
-0.45954832434654236,
-0.3782116770744324,
0.5474541187286377,
0.7816599011421204,
0.06121674180030823,
0.12139376252889633,
-0.025558017194271088,
-0.04671857878565788,
0.24189385771751404,
0.1864175647497177,
-0.8727050423622131,
0.21956972777843475,
0.45334479212760925,
-0.1672634333372116,
-0.3907536566257477,
-0.3037154972553253,
-0.9976375102996826,
0.21500855684280396,
-0.2762431800365448,
0.3361690044403076,
-0.534195065498352,
-0.03358951583504677,
0.15767604112625122,
0.251049667596817,
0.28719618916511536,
0.12983952462673187,
-0.9613280296325684,
0.2602097988128662,
0.28599265217781067,
0.861429750919342,
0.06128230690956116,
-0.3128744661808014,
-0.9935482740402222,
0.1506757289171219,
-0.4842696189880371,
0.5480346083641052,
-0.22217100858688354,
-0.3704582154750824,
-0.08475004881620407,
-0.5757294297218323,
0.15388168394565582,
-0.20947372913360596,
0.6139979362487793,
-0.2734071612358093,
0.2807336151599884,
-0.0012985032517462969,
-0.3919188976287842,
0.1646491438150406,
0.03996458649635315,
-0.48466956615448,
0.936876654624939,
-0.05839429050683975,
-0.7188459038734436,
0.3692689538002014,
-0.4256647527217865,
-0.4674736559391022,
-0.09540968388319016,
-0.3205675780773163,
-0.5620452761650085,
0.03773189336061478,
0.3753557801246643,
-0.10802072286605835,
-0.12274360656738281,
-0.04412491247057915,
-0.1656273752450943,
-0.3368484675884247,
0.17294247448444366,
-0.701450765132904,
0.6861600279808044,
0.4402177035808563,
-0.34280112385749817,
-0.012772937305271626,
-0.8804177045822144,
0.3889847695827484,
-0.3298075199127197,
-0.2927912175655365,
-0.25415122509002686,
-0.05054248869419098,
0.04784450680017471,
0.019681071862578392,
0.04915516823530197,
-0.4728521406650543,
0.18276803195476532,
-0.6436729431152344,
0.460681289434433,
0.41403526067733765,
0.0015441607683897018,
0.6674849390983582,
-0.4979124367237091,
0.47852057218551636,
-0.442339152097702,
-0.00434931181371212,
-0.5763758420944214,
-0.1914355754852295,
-0.45625653862953186,
-0.8407235741615295,
0.7603580951690674,
0.6941769123077393,
-0.5881140828132629,
0.6874284148216248,
-0.3945567309856415,
-0.12595407664775848,
-0.9909561276435852,
-0.42296645045280457,
0.4583645164966583,
0.6527896523475647,
0.40699923038482666,
-0.26627659797668457,
-0.6196454167366028,
-0.4930303394794464,
-0.150559663772583,
-0.02707495167851448,
-0.2258574366569519,
-0.04970946162939072,
-0.09281142801046371,
0.3236823081970215,
1.0071609020233154,
-0.045570749789476395,
-0.1662815511226654,
0.14599603414535522,
0.35336312651634216,
0.22549617290496826,
0.476036012172699,
0.42606809735298157,
-0.457363098859787,
-0.4420939087867737,
-0.018503941595554352,
-0.6386191844940186,
-0.3478490710258484,
-0.07544425129890442,
-0.036457959562540054,
0.4365059733390808,
0.3904743194580078,
-0.36313456296920776,
0.5050055980682373,
0.5279415845870972,
-0.15265320241451263,
0.19986489415168762,
-0.09612642973661423,
0.5044949054718018,
-1.1634529829025269,
0.21660271286964417,
-0.16682681441307068,
-0.4892449676990509,
-0.8268527388572693,
-0.3956490755081177,
-0.27686411142349243,
-0.2961254119873047,
-0.5697822570800781,
0.22056914865970612,
-0.477737694978714,
-0.2044496089220047,
-0.11187700927257538,
0.20449751615524292,
-0.08263792097568512,
0.3926900029182434,
-0.004977110773324966,
0.9679621458053589,
0.6047594547271729,
-0.4348195195198059,
-0.06535827368497849,
0.32124289870262146,
-0.04946814477443695,
0.7611973285675049,
-0.6391178369522095,
0.33143410086631775,
-0.07017259299755096,
0.07515240460634232,
-0.644627034664154,
0.15991580486297607,
0.07530179619789124,
-0.89057856798172,
0.3893968462944031,
-0.3712916970252991,
-0.18967044353485107,
0.2006966769695282,
-0.369703471660614,
0.7777186632156372,
0.7465177178382874,
-0.3034871220588684,
0.43766775727272034,
0.5292372107505798,
-0.5117190480232239,
-0.7943089604377747,
-0.9678205847740173,
0.2784522473812103,
-0.22309139370918274,
-0.4418928027153015,
0.32251739501953125,
0.0031651766039431095,
-0.10987052321434021,
-0.022823482751846313,
-0.27654320001602173,
-0.032851263880729675,
-0.49674269556999207,
-0.10299182683229446,
0.3336849510669708,
-0.33580827713012695,
-0.1312709003686905,
0.12403042614459991,
-0.3033828139305115,
-0.5585606694221497,
-0.469349205493927,
0.3823723793029785,
-0.0556550957262516,
-0.4263377785682678,
-0.6159780621528625,
0.48237937688827515,
1.216753363609314,
-0.16723531484603882,
0.1162375956773758,
0.004292713478207588,
-0.4632015526294708,
-0.30092674493789673,
-0.28582724928855896,
-0.05710452049970627,
-0.37280309200286865,
0.1851688027381897,
-0.19504417479038239,
-0.9256351590156555,
0.3345048129558563,
0.14787623286247253,
0.09173572808504105,
0.008689023554325104,
0.5560442209243774,
0.08096196502447128,
0.815682590007782,
0.37873658537864685,
-0.2517836391925812,
0.46356576681137085,
-0.10299456119537354,
0.25166061520576477,
-0.650302529335022,
0.2507905960083008,
-0.4588961899280548,
-0.18612396717071533,
-0.43394190073013306,
-0.31374862790107727,
0.5113691687583923,
-0.08434170484542847,
-0.3087819516658783,
0.3996341824531555,
-0.9607497453689575,
0.28383493423461914,
0.40381696820259094,
-0.08194606751203537,
0.39634737372398376,
0.3304643929004669,
-0.01423418615013361,
-0.3121665120124817,
-0.7928396463394165,
-0.5198991894721985,
1.0758715867996216,
0.1749129444360733,
0.7201728224754333,
-0.03606649488210678,
0.8672235012054443,
0.29822686314582825,
-0.0854475125670433,
-0.8317190408706665,
0.402766615152359,
-0.2507826089859009,
-0.29636454582214355,
-0.6082297563552856,
-0.37011486291885376,
-0.7030215859413147,
0.2171122431755066,
-0.4672270119190216,
-0.617785632610321,
0.16048675775527954,
0.24411696195602417,
-0.721705973148346,
0.21360355615615845,
-0.5484079122543335,
0.6792498230934143,
-0.08021918684244156,
-0.37863945960998535,
0.08254753798246384,
-0.7044146656990051,
0.031115993857383728,
-0.130607008934021,
0.3556881844997406,
0.02074292115867138,
0.012780660763382912,
0.3190835416316986,
-0.5843406319618225,
0.6149387359619141,
-0.030456697568297386,
-0.24877697229385376,
0.41092637181282043,
0.06036010757088661,
0.27914324402809143,
-0.10405365377664566,
-0.18253947794437408,
0.06917760521173477,
0.22202132642269135,
-0.47466012835502625,
-0.4821515679359436,
0.6954663991928101,
-0.3649120628833771,
-0.042826298624277115,
-0.36284568905830383,
-0.6762152314186096,
-0.19201251864433289,
0.18458901345729828,
0.5331591963768005,
0.8526895642280579,
-0.35344478487968445,
0.1229458749294281,
0.7618550658226013,
-0.25411781668663025,
0.662083089351654,
0.31649249792099,
-0.21826939284801483,
-1.0149247646331787,
0.85846346616745,
0.24678389728069305,
0.4265786409378052,
0.5516138076782227,
-0.16369539499282837,
-0.2923298478126526,
-0.4995005130767822,
-0.7782222032546997,
0.01735476590692997,
-0.17537549138069153,
-0.28202736377716064,
-0.2651989459991455,
-0.2350568324327469,
-0.5155088305473328,
-0.4088008999824524,
-0.781683087348938,
-0.5439382791519165,
-0.10234025120735168,
0.09888339787721634,
0.24782802164554596,
0.24614311754703522,
-0.21016359329223633,
0.08897676318883896,
-1.0028327703475952,
0.45617181062698364,
0.343389093875885,
0.1152649074792862,
-0.2408100813627243,
-0.6079904437065125,
-0.07170822471380234,
0.20291467010974884,
0.0008867972064763308,
-0.7756121158599854,
0.6270473003387451,
0.05679938197135925,
0.013574348762631416,
0.03527284786105156,
0.19681553542613983,
0.6412449479103088,
-0.6846347451210022,
0.7370244264602661,
0.488278329372406,
-1.139493465423584,
0.4923643469810486,
-0.4664228856563568,
0.49197009205818176,
0.6262001991271973,
-0.22772356867790222,
-0.45189493894577026,
-0.475064218044281,
-0.40629199147224426,
-1.0212496519088745,
0.461270809173584,
0.5482180714607239,
-0.09106536954641342,
0.08421081304550171,
0.22730648517608643,
-0.01577381044626236,
0.24064837396144867,
-0.6605618596076965,
-0.4346984028816223,
-0.3750725984573364,
-0.460907906293869,
0.3925132155418396,
-0.11876153200864792,
-0.06260829418897629,
-0.12573739886283875,
0.6952619552612305,
0.07059584558010101,
0.2455722838640213,
0.5771217346191406,
0.19895365834236145,
-0.2963016629219055,
0.5498912930488586,
0.9408955574035645,
0.34507182240486145,
-0.17570579051971436,
0.23365336656570435,
0.26193711161613464,
-0.3794870674610138,
0.4229389727115631,
-0.01592010073363781,
-0.3888116776943207,
0.2276400774717331,
0.15434889495372772,
0.6859112977981567,
0.09219281375408173,
-0.446701318025589,
0.49340152740478516,
-0.04021744430065155,
-0.361603319644928,
-0.16318680346012115,
-0.4649394154548645,
-0.13912823796272278,
0.032682809978723526,
0.3831964433193207,
0.027247577905654907,
-0.1264500916004181,
-0.28432926535606384,
0.5246761441230774,
0.3087296187877655,
-0.3215898871421814,
-0.4121101200580597,
0.7196468710899353,
0.14650677144527435,
-0.6389504075050354,
0.23201331496238708,
-0.07099474966526031,
-0.06951425224542618,
0.26996248960494995,
0.40816730260849,
1.0337969064712524,
-0.5138401985168457,
0.028506973758339882,
0.4278407394886017,
0.32112419605255127,
0.03155956789851189,
0.40568822622299194,
-0.09575173258781433,
-0.4996577799320221,
-0.9635693430900574,
-0.6015242338180542,
-0.39510029554367065,
0.1993849128484726,
-0.6083326935768127,
0.45993417501449585,
-0.2792949974536896,
-0.21192461252212524,
-0.13149617612361908,
-0.6943745017051697,
-0.02919040061533451,
0.18908554315567017,
0.050816845148801804,
0.6533583402633667,
-0.6603984832763672,
1.0142152309417725,
0.2965702414512634,
-0.43960040807724,
-0.6025030612945557,
0.10429555922746658,
0.0656774640083313,
-0.5220195651054382,
0.3264131546020508,
-0.22305110096931458,
-0.5374860763549805,
0.32938817143440247,
-0.3969970643520355,
-0.6920205950737,
0.9274740815162659,
0.5877624154090881,
-0.8082038760185242,
-0.10106037557125092,
0.07643073052167892,
0.5309281349182129,
-0.2646653950214386,
-0.1310788244009018,
0.30113163590431213,
0.2994840443134308,
0.4038650691509247,
-0.9894148111343384,
-0.1628047376871109,
-0.018156645819544792,
-0.007931876927614212,
0.5227803587913513,
-0.20265547931194305,
0.565326452255249,
0.04100784286856651,
-0.454842746257782,
0.18712803721427917,
0.5849642157554626,
0.2860313951969147,
0.24693745374679565,
0.25859948992729187,
1.0508275032043457,
0.5601541996002197,
0.11423400044441223,
0.5148085951805115,
-0.644079864025116,
0.4498748779296875,
1.0902434587478638,
-0.26704299449920654,
0.8461509346961975,
0.7446249127388,
-0.13627637922763824,
0.07974474132061005,
0.14846785366535187,
0.27167561650276184,
0.7923489809036255,
0.19676928222179413,
-0.7910451292991638,
-0.09920131415128708,
0.03579329326748848,
-0.31750741600990295,
0.3165777623653412,
0.18378674983978271,
-0.01469572726637125,
-0.3565654754638672,
-0.09423510730266571,
-0.1587046980857849,
0.21774840354919434,
-0.15577320754528046,
0.6977112293243408,
0.06823494285345078,
-0.6220310926437378,
1.0379703044891357,
-0.4176160991191864,
0.9038519859313965,
-0.4672083258628845,
-0.2460438460111618,
-0.09831919521093369,
-0.12347058206796646,
-0.15745069086551666,
-0.3880496025085449,
0.5926706790924072,
0.184199258685112,
-0.3209667503833771,
-0.4187171757221222,
0.5592844486236572,
-0.7168505191802979,
-0.20059902966022491,
-0.019364776089787483,
0.5459239482879639,
0.09750040620565414,
0.1919381320476532,
-0.46207961440086365,
0.1572125107049942,
0.08032388985157013,
-0.04823514446616173,
0.3236088752746582,
0.599839985370636,
0.26925626397132874,
0.260444700717926,
0.5427380204200745,
0.34856054186820984,
0.06270099431276321,
-0.002792604034766555,
0.37296441197395325,
-0.5658560991287231,
-0.3075392544269562,
-0.7953433394432068,
0.685413122177124,
0.19515575468540192,
-0.16876834630966187,
0.42229926586151123,
0.6147223114967346,
0.5089699625968933,
0.057805921882390976,
1.045145034790039,
0.013440180569887161,
0.7062253952026367,
-0.6187438368797302,
0.6921401619911194,
-0.3100165128707886,
0.2538889944553375,
-0.20262141525745392,
-0.8319190740585327,
-0.3880786597728729,
0.7355989813804626,
0.1476331204175949,
-0.1662192940711975,
0.6712719798088074,
0.9783820509910583,
0.07178156077861786,
-0.0665462464094162,
0.740847110748291,
0.0288655124604702,
0.05102594941854477,
0.418570339679718,
0.5188685655593872,
-0.6004544496536255,
0.7777087092399597,
0.09147761017084122,
-0.35035207867622375,
0.22807471454143524,
-1.1105479001998901,
-0.33329635858535767,
-0.5059930682182312,
-0.436581552028656,
-0.30116143822669983,
0.23684409260749817,
0.8177486658096313,
0.699074923992157,
-0.758640706539154,
-0.3174281716346741,
-0.4601491093635559,
0.04705648869276047,
-0.053137943148612976,
-0.231775164604187,
0.18986310064792633,
-0.34493309259414673,
-0.8858375549316406,
0.6935660243034363,
0.8252364993095398,
0.31332603096961975,
0.032745275646448135,
0.03509250655770302,
-0.17519734799861908,
0.3183782994747162,
0.582377552986145,
0.6837573647499084,
-0.6645534038543701,
-0.3528722822666168,
0.26549232006073,
-0.1589774340391159,
0.28060734272003174,
0.8186734318733215,
-0.7474777102470398,
0.613879382610321,
0.5621610283851624,
0.718201756477356,
0.5755121111869812,
0.037359219044446945,
0.7032050490379333,
-0.6973128914833069,
0.08356283605098724,
0.4251581132411957,
0.0823540911078453,
0.22944898903369904,
-0.016622235998511314,
0.22503700852394104,
0.08877050131559372,
-0.7358677983283997,
-0.9303399920463562,
0.30204156041145325,
-1.1385903358459473,
-0.18793728947639465,
0.9890531301498413,
0.14210860431194305,
-0.2624480724334717,
-0.05792918801307678,
-0.33655837178230286,
0.493726521730423,
-0.5393461585044861,
0.7606443166732788,
0.595725953578949,
-0.15708178281784058,
-0.1382666677236557,
-0.42628854513168335,
0.4683365523815155,
0.5552961230278015,
-0.5874707698822021,
0.2193005532026291,
0.7561967372894287,
0.20796087384223938,
0.18633927404880524,
0.9450047612190247,
-0.41602301597595215,
0.23234198987483978,
0.07403960078954697,
0.5818150043487549,
0.09923388808965683,
-0.1219477653503418,
-0.5928509831428528,
0.20848259329795837,
-0.021881626918911934,
-0.5725300312042236
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.07850v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.07850v1
|
Dynamic Stochastic Decoding Strategy for Open-Domain Dialogue Generation
| 2024-06-12T03:38:45 | 2024-06-12T03:38:45 |
Yiwei Li, Fei Mi, Yitong Li, Yasheng Wang, Bin Sun, Shaoxiong Feng, Kan Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Stochastic sampling strategies such as top-k and top-p have been widely used
in dialogue generation task. However, as an open-domain chatting system, there
will be two different conversation scenarios, i.e. chit-chat and
knowledge-based question answering. In the former situation, responses
diversity is essential due to the one-to-many nature in dialogue. The latter,
on the other hand, requires less randomness given that stochastic decoding
strategy entails the risk of generating incorrect information. As a result, an
adaptive and flexible decoding strategy is needed to cope with these two
scenarios simultaneously. To this end, we propose the dynamic decoding strategy
(DDS), which can adjust the decoding space w.r.t. different contexts. In DDS,
both sequence-level and token-level adaptive search can be achieved to adjust
the decoding process in a unified framework. Besides, our adaptive algorithm
can not only be used during model inference, but it can also be applied during
the model training stage to further enhance the performance. Comprehensive
experiments indicate that the proposed decoding strategy can consistently
improve the performance of pre-trained dialogue models when coupled with four
well-used stochastic decoding algorithms.
|
[
-0.2986283600330353,
-0.8542998433113098,
0.2733297646045685,
0.3265177011489868,
-0.5033339262008667,
0.45806047320365906,
-0.19823512434959412,
-0.21330751478672028,
0.10045094043016434,
0.2558818459510803,
-0.9197072386741638,
-0.3933406174182892,
-0.45715853571891785,
0.051954738795757294,
0.1534440964460373,
0.8149925470352173,
0.053251367062330246,
0.11967431008815765,
-0.14282606542110443,
-0.10170888155698776,
-0.6883981823921204,
-0.3914313018321991,
-0.9013558626174927,
0.2431792914867401,
0.1121612936258316,
0.27117061614990234,
0.6337428092956543,
0.29089900851249695,
0.06009776517748833,
0.2503819465637207,
-0.26156920194625854,
0.3643862307071686,
-0.9263597726821899,
0.46554306149482727,
-0.13606441020965576,
-0.39506766200065613,
-0.4223915934562683,
-0.47115036845207214,
0.6337761282920837,
0.5350704789161682,
-0.590887188911438,
-0.21860696375370026,
0.06477432698011398,
0.20869404077529907,
-0.6182045936584473,
0.2663270831108093,
-0.7245115637779236,
0.1668221801519394,
0.09970007091760635,
-0.7207860350608826,
-0.35115689039230347,
-0.43799152970314026,
0.3434757590293884,
-0.6107814311981201,
0.127782940864563,
-0.19682030379772186,
0.5351699590682983,
0.05117755010724068,
-0.32519420981407166,
-0.44079479575157166,
-1.0608575344085693,
0.8552880883216858,
-0.8207891583442688,
0.30575498938560486,
0.1224513128399849,
0.43967729806900024,
-0.4311671555042267,
-0.5825770497322083,
-0.5739274621009827,
0.036240220069885254,
0.3157605528831482,
0.23977555334568024,
-0.1597186028957367,
0.04373935982584953,
0.15921036899089813,
0.32201051712036133,
-0.09031474590301514,
0.03183482214808464,
-0.1142842099070549,
-0.2239949107170105,
0.43001100420951843,
0.27881762385368347,
0.10310399532318115,
0.18439647555351257,
-0.21090862154960632,
-0.4286952018737793,
-0.41076305508613586,
0.1885421723127365,
0.5186004042625427,
0.3923686742782593,
-0.21806609630584717,
0.14040397107601166,
-0.3681577742099762,
0.3554231822490692,
0.25655537843704224,
-0.2881423234939575,
0.01912728324532509,
-0.6949784755706787,
-0.21217584609985352,
-0.018735244870185852,
0.563234806060791,
0.4029189944267273,
0.0918082445859909,
0.04706916585564613,
-0.00417309207841754,
-0.291629433631897,
0.27575579285621643,
-0.7596851587295532,
-0.17428405582904816,
0.10512016713619232,
-0.5076261162757874,
-0.5273609161376953,
-0.2966249883174896,
-1.1226578950881958,
-0.12879028916358948,
0.08440598100423813,
0.2548947036266327,
-0.5129312872886658,
-0.5946730375289917,
0.27596530318260193,
-0.03425772488117218,
0.12047699093818665,
0.6354401111602783,
-0.8944598436355591,
0.30725008249282837,
0.09179946780204773,
0.6830080151557922,
0.008303165435791016,
0.08166592568159103,
-0.6228456497192383,
0.0970483124256134,
-0.480560302734375,
0.5691859722137451,
-0.5623441338539124,
-0.6200422644615173,
0.19902127981185913,
-0.3673652708530426,
-0.2447637915611267,
-0.4237581491470337,
0.2702699601650238,
-0.7012667655944824,
0.303354412317276,
-0.1959475576877594,
-0.23526328802108765,
0.02200048603117466,
0.1007356122136116,
-0.5235443711280823,
0.7631819844245911,
0.27503544092178345,
-0.8039742112159729,
0.25500112771987915,
-0.7145108580589294,
-0.23036563396453857,
-0.024851346388459206,
-0.14907166361808777,
-0.3475984036922455,
0.23535069823265076,
0.4269685447216034,
0.03194747120141983,
-0.24195623397827148,
0.16637499630451202,
-0.25466933846473694,
-0.2053060680627823,
0.25649285316467285,
-0.610832929611206,
0.7052493095397949,
0.5109968781471252,
-0.2321264147758484,
0.25363796949386597,
-0.7386420965194702,
0.21933189034461975,
0.37858325242996216,
-0.5092882513999939,
-0.12990334630012512,
0.46233803033828735,
-0.4649456739425659,
-0.04771901294589043,
-0.15621423721313477,
-0.4521320164203644,
0.22040626406669617,
-0.4874337613582611,
0.3653099238872528,
0.5879645943641663,
0.5243931412696838,
0.41598182916641235,
-0.34492701292037964,
0.568015992641449,
0.4110003411769867,
-0.1262168437242508,
-0.3079722821712494,
-0.3164491355419159,
-0.6686175465583801,
-0.37571436166763306,
0.40837669372558594,
0.7517949342727661,
-1.1334228515625,
0.3300623297691345,
-0.3036370277404785,
-0.26181110739707947,
-0.6012683510780334,
-0.34172317385673523,
0.22181454300880432,
0.20643004775047302,
0.29537659883499146,
-0.5582027435302734,
-0.3848987817764282,
-0.37510770559310913,
-0.17592984437942505,
-0.22396895289421082,
-0.20288534462451935,
0.5980041027069092,
0.041422005742788315,
-0.08982027322053909,
0.9147265553474426,
-0.4899555742740631,
0.09219545871019363,
-0.448955774307251,
-0.00001639350193727296,
0.01669025979936123,
0.37525153160095215,
0.6481832265853882,
-0.6362485885620117,
-0.3452508747577667,
-0.34389302134513855,
-0.5214701294898987,
0.02673725038766861,
-0.29789668321609497,
-0.4262557327747345,
0.1771065890789032,
0.2573454976081848,
-0.5990060567855835,
0.5674905776977539,
0.36433523893356323,
-0.11319581419229507,
0.6234819889068604,
-0.2859245240688324,
0.4317833483219147,
-1.2348623275756836,
-0.36029061675071716,
-0.39663800597190857,
-0.015219004824757576,
-0.8124672174453735,
0.10228848457336426,
-0.3027923107147217,
-0.109629325568676,
-0.4404965937137604,
0.17643657326698303,
-0.3919604420661926,
0.2366517186164856,
-0.13327151536941528,
-0.09316892921924591,
-0.10827518254518509,
0.6631127595901489,
0.1818586140871048,
0.813054084777832,
0.5981746315956116,
-0.7292406558990479,
0.3919932544231415,
0.371871680021286,
-0.5498199462890625,
0.49898266792297363,
-0.30013447999954224,
0.2773987352848053,
-0.12497642636299133,
0.6030216217041016,
-1.1504274606704712,
-0.018064048141241074,
0.27774542570114136,
-0.3471270203590393,
0.30043551325798035,
-0.19271214306354523,
-0.29558342695236206,
-0.20899628102779388,
-0.14393837749958038,
0.7748637795448303,
0.45516714453697205,
-0.5196264386177063,
0.4670615494251251,
0.32766950130462646,
-0.48807594180107117,
-0.5506060123443604,
-0.21366877853870392,
0.010470558889210224,
-0.17639191448688507,
-0.771216869354248,
0.35099002718925476,
-0.26953572034835815,
0.05789859965443611,
-0.3029092848300934,
-0.3947221040725708,
0.08312712609767914,
0.05865422263741493,
-0.218058779835701,
0.015146349556744099,
-0.40305250883102417,
-0.23874948918819427,
0.2518284022808075,
0.0974763035774231,
-0.11909408122301102,
-0.6265959739685059,
0.8223266005516052,
0.32354387640953064,
-0.3652430474758148,
-0.47739270329475403,
0.7027079463005066,
0.529699981212616,
-0.23059868812561035,
0.8870518207550049,
0.415006548166275,
-0.19767074286937714,
-0.4236554801464081,
-0.09749945253133774,
-0.42509254813194275,
-0.4991243779659271,
0.3916088938713074,
-0.7090396285057068,
-0.9495659470558167,
0.6500609517097473,
-0.22963163256645203,
0.06942093372344971,
-0.0861380472779274,
0.7120097875595093,
-0.10916686803102493,
1.0340759754180908,
0.5802299380302429,
0.20873427391052246,
0.4677311182022095,
-0.026287199929356575,
0.6784561276435852,
-0.41034695506095886,
-0.17875981330871582,
-0.38940608501434326,
-0.16433760523796082,
-0.6372608542442322,
-0.63864666223526,
0.2837989628314972,
0.4444560408592224,
0.013777375221252441,
0.08443915843963623,
-0.21566474437713623,
0.1286190003156662,
0.7271701097488403,
0.11279307305812836,
0.20761816203594208,
0.45591410994529724,
-0.5157110095024109,
-0.06985312700271606,
-0.9502077698707581,
-0.1585134118795395,
0.8017878532409668,
0.4859342873096466,
0.9322130680084229,
0.35120874643325806,
0.413927286863327,
0.16272664070129395,
-0.324992299079895,
-0.5822232365608215,
0.6256066560745239,
0.1651587188243866,
-0.2133484035730362,
-0.4092092514038086,
-0.7676773071289062,
-0.8905699849128723,
0.21962270140647888,
-0.30932748317718506,
-0.6164987087249756,
0.23450003564357758,
0.07353443652391434,
-0.5148841738700867,
0.5481606721878052,
-0.23578839004039764,
0.6580497622489929,
0.08632855117321014,
-0.06018402427434921,
-0.2883240878582001,
-0.5272731781005859,
0.14082248508930206,
0.01438684668391943,
0.00416460121050477,
0.042859967797994614,
0.47928544878959656,
0.6370828747749329,
-0.2544272243976593,
0.7238419651985168,
-0.5651360154151917,
-0.2874387204647064,
0.44462350010871887,
0.25560057163238525,
0.5491921901702881,
0.12225909531116486,
0.06954192370176315,
0.047923821955919266,
0.33054548501968384,
-0.55119389295578,
-0.5632017850875854,
0.1810806542634964,
-0.8265029788017273,
-0.6623096466064453,
-0.22608569264411926,
-0.7068266272544861,
-0.5333892107009888,
0.08346743136644363,
0.36471274495124817,
0.44728654623031616,
-0.5308386087417603,
0.24020476639270782,
0.8253347277641296,
-0.5866900086402893,
0.27968737483024597,
0.4995598793029785,
0.24251234531402588,
-0.47164517641067505,
0.6416423916816711,
-0.26757675409317017,
0.573811411857605,
0.5308030247688293,
-0.005160912871360779,
-0.25522613525390625,
-0.9476175308227539,
-0.6250998377799988,
-0.07161466032266617,
-0.5395562052726746,
-0.22411693632602692,
-0.6696090698242188,
-0.4153653383255005,
-0.666898787021637,
0.061057887971401215,
-0.24017655849456787,
-0.2503871023654938,
-0.2190435230731964,
-0.09924426674842834,
0.24613967537879944,
0.1756693571805954,
0.08259668946266174,
0.40139880776405334,
-0.9515984654426575,
0.3256596028804779,
0.35939860343933105,
0.39208921790122986,
0.05567089468240738,
-0.44856375455856323,
-0.26533421874046326,
0.46188580989837646,
-0.24578341841697693,
-0.8819561004638672,
0.4408358037471771,
0.25660622119903564,
0.7777843475341797,
0.41308507323265076,
0.49787259101867676,
0.6050686836242676,
-0.5454686880111694,
0.7050957679748535,
0.03987282142043114,
-0.6544561386108398,
0.5284639596939087,
-0.6044782996177673,
0.3796512484550476,
0.4887828528881073,
0.23079025745391846,
-0.487853080034256,
-0.46531879901885986,
-0.3725326657295227,
-0.7196713089942932,
1.0537487268447876,
0.3292475640773773,
0.33990880846977234,
0.08035524934530258,
0.0022148187272250652,
0.10572811216115952,
0.3327149450778961,
-0.2101857215166092,
0.1043083667755127,
-0.4064514935016632,
-0.4994979500770569,
0.2144126445055008,
-0.32589468359947205,
-0.4590202867984772,
0.10156361013650894,
0.28913259506225586,
-0.199086993932724,
0.9610726833343506,
-0.07690151035785675,
0.040554191917181015,
-0.3125420808792114,
0.39214852452278137,
0.8246520161628723,
0.46111175417900085,
-0.42484813928604126,
-0.2566549479961395,
0.2661086320877075,
-0.4881362318992615,
0.11267092823982239,
-0.039106518030166626,
-0.08885378390550613,
-0.14640557765960693,
0.10420908033847809,
1.3147282600402832,
0.25831446051597595,
-0.6415470242500305,
0.4384154677391052,
-0.3044624328613281,
-0.4184470772743225,
-0.1391303390264511,
0.3861747682094574,
-0.10803987085819244,
0.41331833600997925,
0.5121975541114807,
0.2464675009250641,
-0.26556241512298584,
-0.5610514283180237,
0.2545524537563324,
0.39069268107414246,
-0.07803738862276077,
-0.24871842563152313,
0.4394383132457733,
0.3542552888393402,
-0.3271515965461731,
0.5342981815338135,
-0.16440148651599884,
-0.4615750312805176,
0.40569043159484863,
0.6255794763565063,
0.8181449174880981,
-0.45966461300849915,
0.3435562551021576,
0.16781413555145264,
-0.010871450416743755,
0.03520845249295235,
0.3329678773880005,
-0.3818152844905853,
-1.0035938024520874,
-0.3517783284187317,
-0.9518252015113831,
-0.4557425379753113,
0.2686529755592346,
-0.6184380054473877,
-0.08048640936613083,
-0.4146452844142914,
0.08181638270616531,
-0.4119241535663605,
-0.08554256707429886,
-0.4848614037036896,
0.13896428048610687,
-0.07686209678649902,
1.030828833580017,
-0.3400740623474121,
0.9241445660591125,
0.3388745188713074,
0.005355255678296089,
-0.5376415252685547,
0.2983608841896057,
0.0309611726552248,
-0.5752951502799988,
0.22243866324424744,
-0.20255011320114136,
-0.30317720770835876,
0.18196602165699005,
-0.26489678025245667,
-1.0501961708068848,
1.078166127204895,
0.017207443714141846,
-0.24900132417678833,
-0.3845619261264801,
0.16568860411643982,
0.46339064836502075,
-0.8530406951904297,
0.16048294305801392,
0.41126707196235657,
0.06343869119882584,
0.4018106758594513,
-1.01997709274292,
-0.004043763969093561,
-0.24636662006378174,
0.15874898433685303,
-0.042921263724565506,
-0.366766095161438,
0.6406301259994507,
-0.18157553672790527,
-0.7509512901306152,
0.4284439980983734,
0.7438109517097473,
0.2725531756877899,
0.23319348692893982,
0.6847630143165588,
0.39659085869789124,
0.5160217881202698,
-0.04465945065021515,
0.6847285628318787,
-0.21826469898223877,
0.12747043371200562,
0.8554801344871521,
-0.21423307061195374,
0.8093627095222473,
-0.023496154695749283,
-0.12398748099803925,
0.560863733291626,
0.6745591759681702,
0.2197323441505432,
1.0812677145004272,
0.09175699204206467,
-0.5243728756904602,
-0.22964361310005188,
0.38609495759010315,
-0.2591225206851959,
0.44129177927970886,
0.6251881718635559,
-0.10238432884216309,
-0.37729573249816895,
0.31403955817222595,
-0.17589734494686127,
-0.04808586463332176,
-0.08302424848079681,
1.1177301406860352,
-0.33162423968315125,
-0.8038555979728699,
0.8431586623191833,
0.22772806882858276,
0.5902187824249268,
-0.7414414286613464,
0.13185714185237885,
-0.29528623819351196,
0.1628013253211975,
0.2248164564371109,
-0.4811446964740753,
0.02348414435982704,
-0.1919194459915161,
-0.16583821177482605,
-0.20083531737327576,
0.6991811394691467,
-0.700668454170227,
-0.03168380260467529,
0.300993412733078,
0.588851273059845,
-0.08376377075910568,
0.26992952823638916,
-0.48798277974128723,
0.11648405343294144,
0.30098000168800354,
-0.07802689075469971,
0.47976866364479065,
0.4984048902988434,
0.02594819664955139,
0.44968557357788086,
0.829220712184906,
-0.06777561455965042,
0.12911157310009003,
0.14554376900196075,
0.988496720790863,
-0.543368935585022,
-0.8581676483154297,
-0.30131274461746216,
0.5171518325805664,
-0.11006545275449753,
0.02001546137034893,
0.5026810169219971,
0.0762166678905487,
0.8998563885688782,
-0.12354234606027603,
0.8121474981307983,
0.09696368128061295,
0.6348341703414917,
-0.5992375016212463,
0.4789715111255646,
-0.2885088324546814,
0.35773178935050964,
-0.20247863233089447,
-0.938751757144928,
0.048980962485075,
0.705487072467804,
0.012212874367833138,
0.25211629271507263,
0.46926748752593994,
0.8119662404060364,
-0.1231677234172821,
0.40146011114120483,
0.27659010887145996,
0.20732326805591583,
0.46675753593444824,
0.6620979309082031,
0.8538321256637573,
-0.13219095766544342,
0.719679594039917,
0.19238945841789246,
-0.5682491064071655,
-0.43274959921836853,
-0.6946364045143127,
-0.7080664038658142,
-0.37846532464027405,
-0.1847635805606842,
-0.5732839107513428,
0.17003533244132996,
0.6762121319770813,
0.677671492099762,
-0.7819709777832031,
-0.1598646491765976,
0.07627217471599579,
-0.1445024311542511,
-0.5181679129600525,
-0.22825013101100922,
0.009114257991313934,
-0.47614115476608276,
-0.849675178527832,
0.7428056597709656,
0.33755677938461304,
0.04662855714559555,
-0.04851297661662102,
-0.1567143350839615,
-0.11183782666921616,
0.6538233160972595,
0.7035631537437439,
0.29222068190574646,
-0.36774638295173645,
-0.3491058349609375,
0.12284541875123978,
-0.047352202236652374,
0.1540013998746872,
1.0616562366485596,
-0.6326054334640503,
0.5279889106750488,
0.6483297944068909,
0.6619473695755005,
0.6576128602027893,
0.08869244158267975,
0.8977217674255371,
-0.8651933670043945,
0.11307159811258316,
0.3327534794807434,
0.04216330498456955,
0.12826138734817505,
-0.19008049368858337,
0.07089509814977646,
0.4386749267578125,
-0.4232969284057617,
-0.9144576787948608,
0.5741408467292786,
-0.9771552085876465,
-0.5584209561347961,
0.8685747981071472,
-0.17492838203907013,
0.10919197648763657,
-0.2682426869869232,
-0.14439789950847626,
0.3814905881881714,
-0.4400674104690552,
0.766008198261261,
0.6539269089698792,
-0.10509578138589859,
-0.31132832169532776,
-0.3719727098941803,
0.7948616743087769,
0.4046876132488251,
-0.5465081334114075,
0.1386675238609314,
0.5243943929672241,
0.26254481077194214,
0.15865835547447205,
0.8954905271530151,
0.0007120709051378071,
0.2472948431968689,
0.3159531354904175,
-0.4595493972301483,
0.06779759377241135,
-0.304113507270813,
-0.025604356080293655,
0.3780219256877899,
-0.13298727571964264,
-0.3784772753715515
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.07842v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.07842v1
|
Dual-Pipeline with Low-Rank Adaptation for New Language Integration in Multilingual ASR
| 2024-06-12T03:17:57 | 2024-06-12T03:17:57 |
Yerbolat Khassanov, Zhipeng Chen, Tianfeng Chen, Tze Yuang Chong, Wei Li, Jun Zhang, Lu Lu, Yuxuan Wang
|
eess.AS
|
eess.AS, cs.CL
|
This paper addresses challenges in integrating new languages into a
pre-trained multilingual automatic speech recognition (mASR) system,
particularly in scenarios where training data for existing languages is limited
or unavailable. The proposed method employs a dual-pipeline with low-rank
adaptation (LoRA). It maintains two data flow pipelines-one for existing
languages and another for new languages. The primary pipeline follows the
standard flow through the pre-trained parameters of mASR, while the secondary
pipeline additionally utilizes language-specific parameters represented by LoRA
and a separate output decoder module. Importantly, the proposed approach
minimizes the performance degradation of existing languages and enables a
language-agnostic operation mode, facilitated by a decoder selection strategy.
We validate the effectiveness of the proposed method by extending the
pre-trained Whisper model to 19 new languages from the FLEURS dataset
|
[
-0.28928351402282715,
-0.2089390903711319,
0.015194055624306202,
0.10934596508741379,
-0.40479499101638794,
0.4408022165298462,
-0.25005248188972473,
-0.40972235798835754,
0.20383651554584503,
0.5662999153137207,
-0.24514754116535187,
-0.2727223038673401,
-0.9326655864715576,
0.12253955751657486,
-0.2600352168083191,
0.699726402759552,
-0.2256009578704834,
0.12832219898700714,
0.26323169469833374,
-0.2729191184043884,
-0.4549131691455841,
-0.8689702749252319,
-0.7899622917175293,
-0.1790943443775177,
0.3891226053237915,
0.3331114947795868,
0.33859753608703613,
0.2677900493144989,
0.36550694704055786,
0.2786886692047119,
0.08807945996522903,
0.19599108397960663,
-0.24213573336601257,
0.041346751153469086,
0.016699377447366714,
-0.12552861869335175,
-0.3760662078857422,
-0.2567407488822937,
1.054772138595581,
0.5889372825622559,
-0.1549731194972992,
0.21931059658527374,
0.25345730781555176,
0.4750000834465027,
-0.8267478346824646,
0.2560133934020996,
-0.691760778427124,
0.09172690659761429,
-0.32666704058647156,
-0.393398255109787,
-0.28160369396209717,
-0.0922425240278244,
0.26711270213127136,
-0.4297192096710205,
-0.24076275527477264,
-0.4202871322631836,
0.3599647581577301,
0.5088487863540649,
-0.5751662850379944,
-0.49827882647514343,
-0.9228841066360474,
0.6862928867340088,
-0.6330444812774658,
0.6508073806762695,
0.25913918018341064,
0.6110501289367676,
0.3519834280014038,
-0.5054107904434204,
-0.39298757910728455,
0.010523157194256783,
0.11845485121011734,
0.0240242350846529,
-0.31106439232826233,
-0.2627294659614563,
-0.06891363114118576,
0.2665288746356964,
-0.3364311158657074,
0.2199554294347763,
-0.5478684902191162,
-0.42811012268066406,
0.7141835689544678,
-0.22321070730686188,
-0.09026478230953217,
0.10502113401889801,
-0.3180226683616638,
-0.004967436660081148,
-0.4820602536201477,
0.29415497183799744,
0.5052807927131653,
1.0192925930023193,
-0.3922012746334076,
0.3558368980884552,
0.048704151064157486,
0.5444930195808411,
-0.10025064647197723,
-0.23939993977546692,
0.7165830135345459,
-0.19235992431640625,
0.013134963810443878,
0.4095204472541809,
0.8675476312637329,
-0.18535105884075165,
0.21609993278980255,
-0.0204557403922081,
-0.3418964147567749,
0.21946130692958832,
-0.14974156022071838,
-0.5587788820266724,
-0.06769029796123505,
-0.07901362329721451,
-0.19890384376049042,
-0.1366342008113861,
-0.023847801610827446,
-0.5507994294166565,
-0.37846753001213074,
-0.21492990851402283,
0.8694923520088196,
-0.20871728658676147,
-0.48646166920661926,
0.3116079270839691,
-0.04568331316113472,
0.3330565094947815,
0.4101788103580475,
-0.6046164035797119,
0.5802721977233887,
0.32872170209884644,
0.8070638179779053,
-0.14769062399864197,
-0.532963752746582,
-1.2549000978469849,
0.24021585285663605,
0.01383079681545496,
0.8092783689498901,
-0.5113925337791443,
-0.5161972045898438,
0.07847332954406738,
0.1810711920261383,
-0.44921669363975525,
-0.592494547367096,
0.6270499229431152,
-0.30659329891204834,
0.22120803594589233,
0.00037335974047891796,
-0.05658922716975212,
-0.06410405784845352,
-0.2552827298641205,
-0.3629770874977112,
0.9633093476295471,
-0.0457073450088501,
-0.5366397500038147,
0.1417471319437027,
-0.8958239555358887,
-0.9542405605316162,
-0.10052459686994553,
-0.22930927574634552,
-0.14649155735969543,
0.10429433733224869,
0.34510594606399536,
0.17481504380702972,
-0.23489834368228912,
0.025178205221891403,
0.2992646098136902,
-0.35690271854400635,
0.0646059662103653,
-0.5626442432403564,
0.7782135009765625,
0.3308868706226349,
-0.02628776989877224,
0.02073199488222599,
-0.7868666648864746,
0.05288999155163765,
-0.13068534433841705,
-0.5403680801391602,
-0.02002415433526039,
0.14416539669036865,
0.17384375631809235,
0.2578364312648773,
0.3203141987323761,
-0.47948259115219116,
0.13673487305641174,
-0.3824015259742737,
0.4395129680633545,
0.5380382537841797,
-0.08690022677183151,
0.43742722272872925,
-0.11691880971193314,
0.6468830704689026,
0.2876657545566559,
-0.057782940566539764,
-0.1346689909696579,
-0.4391789734363556,
-1.0151602029800415,
-0.3360481560230255,
0.47613099217414856,
0.8496426343917847,
-0.8971532583236694,
0.4520075023174286,
-0.3975183069705963,
-0.16927963495254517,
-0.9605775475502014,
0.31847891211509705,
0.49051931500434875,
0.2884153425693512,
0.43771860003471375,
-0.4302859604358673,
-0.8187646269798279,
-0.6740715503692627,
-0.05023118853569031,
-0.13801750540733337,
0.023705845698714256,
0.08369746059179306,
0.23307619988918304,
-0.34798458218574524,
0.7582558989524841,
-0.28008443117141724,
-0.48708024621009827,
-0.36380472779273987,
0.03811143338680267,
0.3331524431705475,
0.5105159282684326,
0.43727272748947144,
-0.5690094828605652,
-0.6270081400871277,
0.24772007763385773,
-0.4886692762374878,
0.049665793776512146,
0.3453975021839142,
0.030748305842280388,
0.15546782314777374,
0.45335501432418823,
-0.06029098480939865,
0.260824054479599,
0.8596203327178955,
0.07012702524662018,
0.23761427402496338,
-0.3277711272239685,
0.14535106718540192,
-1.175364375114441,
-0.09294683486223221,
-0.17912624776363373,
-0.1413397192955017,
-0.9448351860046387,
-0.36604779958724976,
-0.07855553179979324,
-0.4339700937271118,
-0.6447275876998901,
0.6331822872161865,
-0.6034272909164429,
-0.1852552741765976,
-0.33384281396865845,
-0.08230794221162796,
-0.06484238803386688,
0.3710935413837433,
0.28712528944015503,
0.7922271490097046,
1.00320565700531,
-0.648438036441803,
0.17799432575702667,
0.4011811316013336,
-0.2554241716861725,
0.3430406153202057,
-0.4155539870262146,
0.37221619486808777,
-0.21454118192195892,
0.11299774795770645,
-0.7694265842437744,
-0.05187160521745682,
0.22983801364898682,
-0.5774852633476257,
0.5086972713470459,
-0.7755693793296814,
-0.29434454441070557,
-0.332501620054245,
-0.18335135281085968,
0.1947333812713623,
0.7083343863487244,
-0.47075504064559937,
0.6739262938499451,
0.6809065937995911,
-0.372222900390625,
-0.6097695827484131,
-0.9574745297431946,
-0.023167261853814125,
-0.15721283853054047,
-0.44894346594810486,
-0.07460928708314896,
-0.12379617989063263,
0.1253986805677414,
-0.41271305084228516,
-0.1662060171365738,
-0.3209036588668823,
-0.11719699949026108,
0.1055009663105011,
-0.02352885715663433,
-0.5621306896209717,
-0.2564457356929779,
0.3210807740688324,
-0.4025690257549286,
-0.28336232900619507,
-0.357380211353302,
0.4833524227142334,
-0.11177331954240799,
-0.5994551777839661,
-0.7249400615692139,
0.502530574798584,
0.6882728338241577,
-0.6131006479263306,
0.6492923498153687,
0.6698891520500183,
-0.34206655621528625,
-0.013386169448494911,
-0.5486657619476318,
0.08897542208433151,
-0.48630884289741516,
0.14932000637054443,
-0.7127577066421509,
-0.85476154088974,
0.5914976000785828,
-0.0021428472828119993,
0.0018989738309755921,
0.2827789783477783,
0.43837398290634155,
-0.013739443384110928,
0.8014366030693054,
0.6695635914802551,
-0.3137323558330536,
0.39025017619132996,
-0.2905435264110565,
0.27749451994895935,
-0.95323646068573,
0.05606962740421295,
-0.6796724200248718,
-0.24160481989383698,
-0.5540521740913391,
-0.7023330330848694,
0.4902777075767517,
-0.036310289055109024,
-0.06691242009401321,
0.20835283398628235,
-0.36080339550971985,
0.3193037509918213,
0.5264962315559387,
-0.18991488218307495,
0.4917919933795929,
0.3045297861099243,
0.07564111053943634,
0.10024894028902054,
-0.6182900667190552,
-0.46084341406822205,
0.9642764925956726,
0.4352399706840515,
0.6819276213645935,
0.46778762340545654,
0.7145996689796448,
0.2164876013994217,
-0.007740269880741835,
-0.8386745452880859,
0.2731819152832031,
-0.637312114238739,
-0.3621116578578949,
-0.3216361105442047,
-0.27823594212532043,
-0.850977897644043,
0.6167538166046143,
-0.12230006605386734,
-0.6187329292297363,
0.37787771224975586,
0.2353743463754654,
-0.4560115933418274,
0.20436902344226837,
-1.001676321029663,
0.5923163890838623,
-0.3276800513267517,
-0.049677181988954544,
0.20047122240066528,
-0.7745279669761658,
-0.011901534162461758,
-0.37257540225982666,
0.40372124314308167,
-0.1980891078710556,
-0.05161936581134796,
0.8902817964553833,
-0.24806784093379974,
0.7002452611923218,
-0.6210400462150574,
-0.19758915901184082,
0.21109752357006073,
-0.4023478329181671,
0.5759262442588806,
-0.1065167710185051,
-0.44973281025886536,
0.3181285560131073,
0.13050901889801025,
-0.3088066577911377,
-0.345522403717041,
0.4841768443584442,
-1.024595022201538,
-0.38105955719947815,
-0.548128604888916,
-0.41345053911209106,
-0.5779829025268555,
0.1398291289806366,
0.3312511444091797,
0.6124638319015503,
-0.038420673459768295,
0.08166036754846573,
0.23613467812538147,
-0.2015191912651062,
0.28111204504966736,
0.8727254271507263,
-0.1955704241991043,
-0.5829465985298157,
0.9982836842536926,
0.21170958876609802,
0.33329614996910095,
0.40419164299964905,
0.27754703164100647,
-0.4244461953639984,
-1.045342206954956,
-0.6854261755943298,
0.08842801302671432,
-0.5185400247573853,
-0.12093410640954971,
-0.6705924868583679,
-0.6161038279533386,
-0.5905090570449829,
-0.14783288538455963,
-0.59610515832901,
-0.3039644956588745,
-0.31749019026756287,
0.3648572564125061,
0.3427506387233734,
0.48893436789512634,
-0.10242066532373428,
0.48998767137527466,
-0.8683239221572876,
0.3924337327480316,
0.33002039790153503,
0.19601206481456757,
-0.2727188467979431,
-1.1190805435180664,
-0.34868842363357544,
0.12367639690637589,
0.1296355277299881,
-0.6142832636833191,
0.40828773379325867,
0.6585710644721985,
0.7575453519821167,
0.2537529170513153,
0.1498093456029892,
0.7370873689651489,
-0.8084603548049927,
0.38357943296432495,
0.2663675546646118,
-0.9372568726539612,
0.6944909691810608,
-0.3680548667907715,
0.47513771057128906,
0.7533851861953735,
0.18059858679771423,
-0.5009849667549133,
-0.11162391304969788,
-0.010140912607312202,
-0.4864037334918976,
0.7655637860298157,
0.03622141852974892,
0.4116436541080475,
0.34848564863204956,
-0.02330927737057209,
0.28287580609321594,
0.26465317606925964,
-0.5994800925254822,
-0.40567952394485474,
-0.3004750907421112,
-0.2655448317527771,
-0.40330228209495544,
-0.16947494447231293,
-0.0556967556476593,
-0.40319010615348816,
0.5600005388259888,
-0.3070630431175232,
0.20014731585979462,
-0.2292332947254181,
-0.44306814670562744,
-0.15953198075294495,
0.4964703619480133,
0.3534068465232849,
0.37334007024765015,
-0.193696528673172,
0.1774565577507019,
0.3582727015018463,
-0.6580155491828918,
0.37367746233940125,
0.5758645534515381,
-0.03867743909358978,
0.032774195075035095,
0.18373386561870575,
1.0489134788513184,
0.5300577878952026,
-0.45416611433029175,
0.48038434982299805,
0.15095482766628265,
-0.2666737735271454,
-0.46317967772483826,
-0.05416607856750488,
-0.03847718983888626,
0.2755183279514313,
0.5227128267288208,
0.33707648515701294,
0.058890871703624725,
-0.5008677244186401,
0.010442090220749378,
0.4282485544681549,
-0.3428964912891388,
-0.45854905247688293,
0.3071790039539337,
0.5121782422065735,
-0.3648611009120941,
0.2396712601184845,
-0.23661847412586212,
-0.43389174342155457,
0.020067647099494934,
0.5316928029060364,
0.8303669095039368,
-0.8106517195701599,
0.09782533347606659,
0.21963728964328766,
0.3521822988986969,
0.07808022201061249,
0.4131511151790619,
0.01847556047141552,
-0.9173055291175842,
-0.4618259370326996,
-0.9170660376548767,
-0.37164318561553955,
0.14329613745212555,
-0.8315615653991699,
0.7324375510215759,
-0.19239158928394318,
0.07163885980844498,
-0.04901688173413277,
-0.11315183341503143,
-0.4312528967857361,
-0.08309899270534515,
0.4569847881793976,
0.7770637273788452,
-0.9574565887451172,
1.3773130178451538,
0.784443736076355,
-0.21023797988891602,
-0.4813474714756012,
-0.061442069709300995,
0.15913109481334686,
-0.9602818489074707,
0.3913220465183258,
-0.1834019422531128,
-0.7295706868171692,
0.23628675937652588,
0.22582505643367767,
-1.1929385662078857,
0.8523939847946167,
0.5412653684616089,
-0.27442601323127747,
0.022682135924696922,
0.15750490128993988,
0.4288600981235504,
-0.4436120092868805,
-0.20566551387310028,
0.41144293546676636,
0.25962159037590027,
0.5416184663772583,
-1.3658267259597778,
-0.5695415139198303,
-0.4130779206752777,
-0.10079622268676758,
0.3667910397052765,
-0.3991074562072754,
0.6386203169822693,
-0.18536889553070068,
-0.2511119544506073,
0.08742786198854446,
0.519221305847168,
0.20003977417945862,
0.3028232753276825,
0.7054322957992554,
0.12410753965377808,
0.6733028292655945,
0.09232715517282486,
0.526584267616272,
-0.09574498981237411,
0.06302902102470398,
1.3031784296035767,
-0.6591965556144714,
1.4920939207077026,
0.47670212388038635,
-0.3097735047340393,
0.4887411594390869,
0.15300434827804565,
0.228692427277565,
0.8069665431976318,
-0.049854882061481476,
-0.45029962062835693,
0.055856626480817795,
-0.04685892537236214,
-0.7123357653617859,
0.8808046579360962,
0.40324246883392334,
-0.052725907415151596,
-0.05736127123236656,
0.27016156911849976,
-0.06247773393988609,
-0.21030279994010925,
-0.18930231034755707,
0.7818695902824402,
-0.022645557299256325,
-0.1461261659860611,
0.7099117040634155,
-0.209610715508461,
1.0479023456573486,
-0.9899192452430725,
0.29075872898101807,
0.10906848311424255,
0.22324857115745544,
-0.09521981328725815,
-0.3526780903339386,
0.3596295714378357,
0.32067152857780457,
-0.14036104083061218,
-0.30880874395370483,
0.7543848752975464,
-0.5526728630065918,
-0.820556640625,
0.3519253134727478,
0.9265103340148926,
0.2697621285915375,
-0.04302229359745979,
-0.5655988454818726,
0.517652690410614,
0.02806059457361698,
0.15169863402843475,
0.40861186385154724,
0.2366933673620224,
0.25364449620246887,
0.5103379487991333,
0.7615302801132202,
0.13290821015834808,
0.2868909537792206,
0.38504114747047424,
0.8385356068611145,
-0.39999163150787354,
-0.7758030295372009,
-0.3763212561607361,
0.7579004764556885,
0.2736702859401703,
0.020868394523859024,
0.655565083026886,
0.7327561378479004,
0.5611879229545593,
-0.028855180367827415,
1.1595760583877563,
0.19623315334320068,
0.9192602038383484,
-0.5644769072532654,
0.6572821140289307,
-0.5039627552032471,
0.40251314640045166,
-0.3661435842514038,
-0.683677077293396,
-0.19124729931354523,
0.7723491191864014,
-0.3211287558078766,
0.024678485468029976,
0.5361613035202026,
0.6319065093994141,
-0.336381196975708,
-0.18998220562934875,
0.42154279351234436,
0.10623989254236221,
0.08751287311315536,
0.49280840158462524,
0.9705011248588562,
-0.645492434501648,
0.5594127774238586,
-0.13564710319042206,
-0.2313350886106491,
-0.13449637591838837,
-0.7849494814872742,
-0.5959835648536682,
-0.6559533476829529,
-0.5391761660575867,
-0.03571520373225212,
0.039050403982400894,
0.7975302338600159,
0.821743905544281,
-1.0732650756835938,
-0.6336347460746765,
0.4270944595336914,
-0.14758317172527313,
-0.020012879744172096,
-0.11445765197277069,
0.1297328770160675,
-0.12438273429870605,
-0.681782603263855,
0.9112050533294678,
0.3755515217781067,
0.13242706656455994,
-0.2607497572898865,
-0.4585217833518982,
-0.2806991934776306,
-0.15679125487804413,
0.684847354888916,
0.4708074927330017,
-0.6824007034301758,
-0.3026069402694702,
-0.1867794245481491,
0.3701097071170807,
0.2784940302371979,
0.7897855639457703,
-0.7895110845565796,
0.5392436385154724,
0.198464035987854,
0.5993605256080627,
0.5583661198616028,
-0.35186707973480225,
0.5516349673271179,
-0.8673627972602844,
0.5695992112159729,
0.21974556148052216,
0.39384859800338745,
0.5569801330566406,
0.05712094157934189,
0.2967738211154938,
0.07613398879766464,
-0.09577303379774094,
-1.0871186256408691,
0.24991492927074432,
-0.9544307589530945,
0.14877404272556305,
1.0497255325317383,
0.10022462159395218,
0.3667738437652588,
-0.38676509261131287,
-0.19782935082912445,
0.2236110121011734,
-0.3864642083644867,
0.07399605214595795,
0.4288237690925598,
-0.24227482080459595,
-0.41862332820892334,
-0.6727080941200256,
0.2458323985338211,
-0.10646666586399078,
-0.7268624305725098,
-0.02279602736234665,
0.3186170756816864,
0.2283543050289154,
0.17810793220996857,
0.9396713972091675,
-0.07040328532457352,
0.12695901095867157,
-0.13490590453147888,
-0.05080579221248627,
0.06889170408248901,
-0.21832482516765594,
-0.7744155526161194,
-0.05301298946142197,
0.4121088981628418,
-0.4682956337928772
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.07841v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.07841v1
|
Labeling Comic Mischief Content in Online Videos with a Multimodal Hierarchical-Cross-Attention Model
| 2024-06-12T03:16:45 | 2024-06-12T03:16:45 |
Elaheh Baharlouei, Mahsa Shafaei, Yigeng Zhang, Hugo Jair Escalante, Thamar Solorio
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
We address the challenge of detecting questionable content in online media,
specifically the subcategory of comic mischief. This type of content combines
elements such as violence, adult content, or sarcasm with humor, making it
difficult to detect. Employing a multimodal approach is vital to capture the
subtle details inherent in comic mischief content. To tackle this problem, we
propose a novel end-to-end multimodal system for the task of comic mischief
detection. As part of this contribution, we release a novel dataset for the
targeted task consisting of three modalities: video, text (video captions and
subtitles), and audio. We also design a HIerarchical Cross-attention model with
CAPtions (HICCAP) to capture the intricate relationships among these
modalities. The results show that the proposed approach makes a significant
improvement over robust baselines and state-of-the-art models for comic
mischief detection and its type classification. This emphasizes the potential
of our system to empower users, to make informed decisions about the online
content they choose to see. In addition, we conduct experiments on the UCF101,
HMDB51, and XD-Violence datasets, comparing our model against other
state-of-the-art approaches showcasing the outstanding performance of our
proposed model in various scenarios.
|
[
-0.3860064148902893,
-0.7135372161865234,
0.08752092719078064,
0.35095497965812683,
-0.2680495083332062,
0.16190984845161438,
0.024339402094483376,
-0.5381067991256714,
0.6259552240371704,
0.46661511063575745,
-0.7048397660255432,
-0.1010906845331192,
-0.813503623008728,
0.03547849506139755,
-0.45507732033729553,
1.0987188816070557,
0.3541203439235687,
-0.3351943790912628,
-0.13784605264663696,
0.0711844190955162,
-0.25703153014183044,
-0.3899032771587372,
-0.6444045901298523,
0.15801872313022614,
0.7894743084907532,
0.1257447451353073,
0.835322916507721,
0.5662301778793335,
0.9431207776069641,
0.32943469285964966,
0.12307347357273102,
0.5654885768890381,
-0.5948718190193176,
0.1108652725815773,
-0.6073113083839417,
-0.20106354355812073,
-0.46978500485420227,
-0.16412560641765594,
0.09261924028396606,
0.11982913315296173,
0.10954029113054276,
0.08594097942113876,
-0.4068094789981842,
0.1569407880306244,
-0.9685579538345337,
0.023303842172026634,
-0.3686128556728363,
0.3454538881778717,
-0.2913680970668793,
-0.6690860986709595,
-0.5818660855293274,
0.32254356145858765,
-0.5043602585792542,
-0.6129633188247681,
0.11221552640199661,
0.07033240050077438,
0.6471749544143677,
0.448727548122406,
-0.4392843246459961,
-0.06263978034257889,
-0.7314092516899109,
0.5389540791511536,
-0.3164379298686981,
0.5639995336532593,
0.5663083791732788,
0.22073912620544434,
0.2353370487689972,
-0.6806181073188782,
-0.6889097094535828,
0.004859974142163992,
0.1361173689365387,
0.26799476146698,
-0.5454590320587158,
-0.14269065856933594,
0.08760393410921097,
0.2659694254398346,
-0.3445112407207489,
0.029439926147460938,
-0.04850652813911438,
-0.5073439478874207,
0.5102523565292358,
0.3200979232788086,
0.5253016352653503,
-0.4413618743419647,
-0.7358503341674805,
-0.10595188289880753,
-0.25886738300323486,
0.20520921051502228,
0.7763557434082031,
0.1483573019504547,
-0.16184793412685394,
0.6710605025291443,
0.10352685302495956,
0.1700257658958435,
0.34938937425613403,
-0.6415259838104248,
0.13199864327907562,
-0.5264878869056702,
0.030360430479049683,
-0.28319495916366577,
1.004753589630127,
0.685558557510376,
0.3334140181541443,
-0.224685400724411,
-0.17184191942214966,
0.29185399413108826,
0.564802348613739,
-0.5163912177085876,
-0.4040394425392151,
0.10790403187274933,
-0.35653403401374817,
-0.5188076496124268,
-0.03435281664133072,
-0.8722025156021118,
-0.8213171362876892,
-0.12930329144001007,
0.48576638102531433,
-0.573955774307251,
-0.32466766238212585,
0.11810483783483505,
-0.3533407151699066,
-0.49869826436042786,
0.46186956763267517,
-0.6555783748626709,
0.2004159539937973,
0.27592286467552185,
0.6352579593658447,
-0.3289835751056671,
-0.005613470915704966,
-0.6466832756996155,
0.5922838449478149,
-0.04786433279514313,
0.8180379271507263,
-0.7154267430305481,
0.322900652885437,
-0.06141347438097,
0.2474110871553421,
0.00948379561305046,
-0.41286396980285645,
0.8399289846420288,
-0.6005300879478455,
-0.15698103606700897,
0.2841552495956421,
-0.08544199168682098,
-0.029904697090387344,
0.5656278133392334,
-1.1305224895477295,
0.7002779245376587,
0.051073942333459854,
-1.154939889907837,
0.2892027497291565,
-0.4546770453453064,
-0.6186090707778931,
-0.08130336552858353,
0.14937303960323334,
-0.49318215250968933,
-0.25052449107170105,
0.34726765751838684,
0.4215019941329956,
-0.10187911987304688,
0.2754509747028351,
-0.4390292167663574,
-0.15626589953899384,
0.5092964768409729,
-0.6731401681900024,
0.6593252420425415,
0.2762107849121094,
-0.252538800239563,
0.1155935674905777,
-0.4193529784679413,
-0.31315329670906067,
0.27264443039894104,
-0.011510403826832771,
-0.3488825857639313,
0.001675373176112771,
0.2605593502521515,
0.5235024690628052,
0.27249181270599365,
-0.6375527381896973,
-0.16569861769676208,
0.19635920226573944,
0.2506429851055145,
0.5416157841682434,
-0.1106901541352272,
0.14223100244998932,
-0.4065491259098053,
0.6599652171134949,
0.5305412411689758,
0.6665767431259155,
-0.37759697437286377,
-0.6566381454467773,
-0.40728846192359924,
-0.5829505324363708,
0.011432857252657413,
0.5355303883552551,
-0.8673204183578491,
0.3315340578556061,
-0.1664438396692276,
-0.23745514452457428,
-0.2504955530166626,
-0.05870199576020241,
0.4042833745479584,
0.106447733938694,
0.5063061118125916,
-0.6491416096687317,
-0.48923632502555847,
-0.6794934272766113,
-0.1334359496831894,
-0.13385598361492157,
0.14642180502414703,
0.4914766550064087,
0.3700011372566223,
-0.19647881388664246,
0.713178277015686,
-0.2523728907108307,
-0.7853450179100037,
-0.2467799186706543,
0.25704124569892883,
-0.16746219992637634,
0.2696647644042969,
0.6193681359291077,
-1.1000810861587524,
-0.43698757886886597,
0.11682437360286713,
-0.4853794276714325,
-0.07275350391864777,
-0.13126392662525177,
0.07654844224452972,
-0.29083123803138733,
0.31915658712387085,
-0.6262332201004028,
0.3911533057689667,
0.21635067462921143,
-0.2060644030570984,
0.6642810702323914,
0.2565401792526245,
0.6590363383293152,
-0.7073855400085449,
-0.18000340461730957,
0.1928747147321701,
-0.47561293840408325,
-0.6954848766326904,
0.5726487636566162,
-0.013139200396835804,
-0.12376310676336288,
-0.6742580533027649,
0.17620910704135895,
-0.027607569471001625,
0.0667908564209938,
0.10757441818714142,
0.02703767456114292,
-0.060237519443035126,
0.9031960368156433,
0.0960719883441925,
0.31448477506637573,
0.5317698121070862,
-0.21491406857967377,
0.7067844271659851,
-0.08500681072473526,
0.12457826733589172,
0.7796812057495117,
-0.3220294713973999,
0.0813078060746193,
-0.3317188322544098,
0.13858145475387573,
-1.2670667171478271,
-0.5920345187187195,
0.5692204833030701,
-0.6544491052627563,
0.474322646856308,
-0.37962374091148376,
-0.8617494106292725,
-0.3595067858695984,
-0.4743153750896454,
0.7348973155021667,
-0.15454630553722382,
-0.44667020440101624,
0.511298418045044,
0.5959576964378357,
-0.14693908393383026,
-0.7338383793830872,
-0.4497809410095215,
0.35903796553611755,
-0.3518638610839844,
-0.7775157690048218,
0.42777982354164124,
-0.16114351153373718,
0.18503884971141815,
-0.11032772064208984,
0.001954429317265749,
-0.4691372215747833,
-0.3560038208961487,
0.04073599725961685,
-0.11140226572751999,
0.0699029341340065,
-0.0322408527135849,
0.05760345607995987,
0.24486073851585388,
0.0941556766629219,
0.14113858342170715,
0.5026340484619141,
0.2855638563632965,
-0.4492592215538025,
-0.5930655598640442,
0.6765166521072388,
0.7233580946922302,
-0.42789149284362793,
0.04565864056348801,
1.0990548133850098,
-0.5568814873695374,
-0.08414792269468307,
-0.28073549270629883,
0.05025244504213333,
-0.4866262376308441,
0.4505152702331543,
0.03766290470957756,
-0.6904279589653015,
0.5016742944717407,
0.059701528400182724,
-0.29996955394744873,
0.20022723078727722,
0.46740832924842834,
-0.13810108602046967,
1.3805086612701416,
0.6971408128738403,
0.07346426695585251,
0.46208643913269043,
-0.14060451090335846,
0.39774712920188904,
-0.41472360491752625,
-0.4406042993068695,
-0.35301947593688965,
-0.4275362193584442,
-0.2929641306400299,
-0.6382142901420593,
0.4094015657901764,
0.019152164459228516,
-0.06702327728271484,
0.6359965801239014,
-0.24100372195243835,
0.5604751110076904,
0.11503429710865021,
0.4089493751525879,
0.4909999668598175,
0.22465461492538452,
0.08559027314186096,
-0.3345513939857483,
-0.5602261424064636,
-0.09375839680433273,
0.7452963590621948,
0.5939868688583374,
1.2573868036270142,
0.8200626373291016,
0.41519618034362793,
0.7637832760810852,
0.1186782643198967,
-0.7945530414581299,
0.44041678309440613,
-0.4419531226158142,
-0.8197029232978821,
-0.19883869588375092,
-0.26889580488204956,
-0.8219621181488037,
-0.013736497610807419,
-0.11320176720619202,
-0.7897223234176636,
0.2650340497493744,
-0.06426449865102768,
-0.23405565321445465,
0.5567107796669006,
-0.5552932024002075,
0.6985835433006287,
0.050427574664354324,
-0.6695299744606018,
-0.23496215045452118,
-0.8952799439430237,
0.7853272557258606,
0.06345342844724655,
0.6485720872879028,
0.3151283264160156,
-0.19014503061771393,
0.5783739686012268,
-0.18155792355537415,
1.2236841917037964,
0.17859306931495667,
-0.28897055983543396,
0.48130711913108826,
0.302357941865921,
0.3559039235115051,
0.05506208911538124,
0.6767041087150574,
-0.02947527915239334,
-0.2060900777578354,
-0.0727422684431076,
-0.4234165847301483,
0.4381754994392395,
-0.6867550611495972,
-0.21294695138931274,
-0.25148674845695496,
-0.9227458834648132,
-0.148565873503685,
0.25384312868118286,
0.14736293256282806,
0.6849316954612732,
0.26467007398605347,
0.19157958030700684,
0.9676377773284912,
-0.1049867644906044,
0.6129732131958008,
0.1447884738445282,
-0.14972913265228271,
-0.42457908391952515,
1.1783806085586548,
-0.11070343106985092,
0.2681688368320465,
0.6316187977790833,
0.10215162485837936,
-0.47008177638053894,
-0.13882951438426971,
-0.38754111528396606,
0.11415915936231613,
-0.9158193469047546,
-0.38434144854545593,
-0.9724652767181396,
-0.18395665287971497,
-0.6432758569717407,
0.1344703584909439,
-0.251796156167984,
-0.39999568462371826,
-0.3411324918270111,
0.28505632281303406,
0.10016991943120956,
0.6284485459327698,
-0.26342684030532837,
0.24688377976417542,
-0.7449805736541748,
0.7774572968482971,
0.2797100245952606,
0.3713842034339905,
0.020102927461266518,
-0.7139046788215637,
-0.06806343793869019,
-0.21844317018985748,
-0.8566859364509583,
-1.2450004816055298,
0.4379686713218689,
0.26905903220176697,
0.3605359196662903,
0.8137994408607483,
0.137455552816391,
0.5103211998939514,
-0.342324435710907,
0.6030737161636353,
0.6127410531044006,
-0.5009639859199524,
0.4142618775367737,
-0.656717836856842,
-0.13412727415561676,
-0.0392455980181694,
0.9519238471984863,
-0.42825937271118164,
-0.5483437776565552,
-0.49739569425582886,
-0.49680095911026,
0.5978701114654541,
0.29224175214767456,
0.3020613193511963,
-0.3272148668766022,
-0.4042324721813202,
0.08137796819210052,
0.3233863115310669,
-1.0285289287567139,
-0.2583165466785431,
-0.3906296193599701,
0.03269869461655617,
0.30408331751823425,
0.11061129719018936,
-0.15154507756233215,
-0.13757428526878357,
0.20799094438552856,
-0.25204336643218994,
0.45079025626182556,
-0.012114104814827442,
-0.37377074360847473,
-0.47446179389953613,
0.22390411794185638,
0.3426433801651001,
0.44587814807891846,
-0.17057818174362183,
0.4153480529785156,
-0.5895474553108215,
-0.7658934593200684,
0.07551583647727966,
-0.14359129965305328,
0.16516919434070587,
-0.07808133214712143,
0.5769070982933044,
0.3850010633468628,
0.21744729578495026,
-0.8767954111099243,
0.9385166764259338,
0.11641363799571991,
0.11024601757526398,
0.06533832103013992,
0.022869259119033813,
-0.14229615032672882,
0.20190657675266266,
0.16673146188259125,
0.46681660413742065,
0.6336641311645508,
-0.8091734051704407,
0.555613100528717,
0.1845654547214508,
-0.4772151708602905,
-0.2813640832901001,
0.770585834980011,
-0.01534612849354744,
-0.30005744099617004,
0.17372246086597443,
-0.41385775804519653,
-0.6578583121299744,
0.8106883764266968,
0.7588592171669006,
0.45921510457992554,
-0.31056174635887146,
0.641053318977356,
0.21482010185718536,
0.544765293598175,
0.571917712688446,
0.3674580752849579,
-0.06921062618494034,
-0.6952618956565857,
-0.5370664596557617,
-0.4341011643409729,
-0.2806296944618225,
0.21498192846775055,
-0.6290679574012756,
0.30819281935691833,
-0.5894525051116943,
-0.28235575556755066,
0.233244389295578,
-0.43455690145492554,
-0.5230759382247925,
0.4571314752101898,
0.28069883584976196,
0.5480509400367737,
-0.9540545344352722,
0.402166485786438,
0.6630870699882507,
-0.6175398826599121,
-0.30347636342048645,
-0.1967620551586151,
0.07294593006372452,
-0.6292198300361633,
0.457022100687027,
0.13545221090316772,
-0.06341121345758438,
-0.13791748881340027,
-0.7318469882011414,
-0.70339035987854,
0.5048328638076782,
0.11352360993623734,
-0.33188891410827637,
-0.03653755038976669,
0.3318081200122833,
0.525326669216156,
-0.3542235493659973,
0.45975273847579956,
0.24762143194675446,
0.3242265284061432,
0.23740844428539276,
-0.81110680103302,
-0.13865871727466583,
-0.44396984577178955,
-0.5058112144470215,
0.39749836921691895,
-0.7048614621162415,
0.985835611820221,
-0.5523692965507507,
-0.28517499566078186,
-0.09202101826667786,
0.4886499047279358,
0.1107088178396225,
0.5180976986885071,
0.7004861831665039,
0.8278904557228088,
0.19762957096099854,
0.047326959669589996,
0.9635564684867859,
0.12970483303070068,
0.41244280338287354,
0.9769293665885925,
0.08227495104074478,
0.49277520179748535,
0.45744073390960693,
-0.28922775387763977,
0.5186907052993774,
0.6719248294830322,
-0.05116238072514534,
0.6274523735046387,
-0.04795977100729942,
-0.01670725829899311,
-0.7999030947685242,
-0.8268886804580688,
-0.08714352548122406,
0.29769396781921387,
0.3608693480491638,
-0.09074163436889648,
-0.3000616431236267,
0.11943551152944565,
-0.04757581278681755,
0.02460668794810772,
-0.550067126750946,
0.565556526184082,
-0.28423258662223816,
-0.2645503580570221,
0.15228816866874695,
0.11674495786428452,
0.7443864941596985,
-0.3994249701499939,
-0.10081461071968079,
0.008976355195045471,
-0.04836136847734451,
-0.4367680847644806,
-0.96591717004776,
0.05309811234474182,
0.05235050991177559,
-0.23644915223121643,
0.1868959665298462,
0.8271909356117249,
-0.46875515580177307,
-0.3400961458683014,
0.2757225036621094,
0.10647150874137878,
0.24441249668598175,
-0.01774289458990097,
-0.5554510951042175,
-0.02500634826719761,
-0.34130698442459106,
0.27204766869544983,
0.3965460956096649,
0.724704384803772,
-0.3736501932144165,
0.7012485265731812,
0.5619969367980957,
-0.36009451746940613,
0.34580716490745544,
0.5030064582824707,
0.9161847829818726,
-0.34066835045814514,
-0.9307141304016113,
-0.34245043992996216,
0.6511861681938171,
-0.11161936819553375,
-0.4551359713077545,
0.46649792790412903,
0.35887035727500916,
0.8571207523345947,
-0.16339854896068573,
0.500040590763092,
-0.4562343955039978,
0.044586990028619766,
-0.21709580719470978,
0.24809196591377258,
-0.8434433937072754,
-0.13102832436561584,
-0.7415710687637329,
-0.6050741076469421,
-0.26684266328811646,
0.10506682097911835,
0.4139613211154938,
0.19893310964107513,
0.7794831991195679,
0.7402875423431396,
-0.6138507127761841,
0.07998023182153702,
0.45735427737236023,
-0.023080380633473396,
0.14368130266666412,
0.5638975501060486,
1.0886164903640747,
-0.4246574640274048,
0.7016428112983704,
-0.6648399233818054,
-0.3176359236240387,
-0.27018219232559204,
-0.8324348330497742,
-1.1256953477859497,
-0.4149520695209503,
-0.3456094264984131,
-0.09365976601839066,
-0.15060406923294067,
0.5099027752876282,
0.7532690167427063,
-0.6851996183395386,
0.226030170917511,
0.47372469305992126,
-0.03933241218328476,
-0.41297802329063416,
-0.28671368956565857,
0.09882302582263947,
-0.17951442301273346,
-0.6865527629852295,
0.24066206812858582,
0.5282394289970398,
-0.27958887815475464,
-0.41308650374412537,
-0.01634209416806698,
-0.4648354649543762,
0.19912831485271454,
0.7661454677581787,
-0.11334321647882462,
-0.7870644927024841,
-0.3888097405433655,
0.2505611479282379,
0.0007989462465047836,
0.009448591619729996,
0.947693407535553,
-0.25076061487197876,
0.562397301197052,
0.5891841053962708,
0.6157550811767578,
0.30987492203712463,
0.07953151315450668,
-0.166627436876297,
-1.173302173614502,
-0.04098431020975113,
0.29357677698135376,
0.35626912117004395,
0.25371021032333374,
-0.7393705248832703,
0.3544304072856903,
0.6449516415596008,
-0.31144317984580994,
-0.6457198262214661,
0.33795276284217834,
-1.2352983951568604,
-0.24700331687927246,
0.8739364147186279,
-0.2088364064693451,
0.014359164983034134,
-0.4035452604293823,
-0.2683143615722656,
0.20459768176078796,
-0.39137041568756104,
0.6822476387023926,
0.47669366002082825,
-0.14298559725284576,
-0.48106837272644043,
-0.27845948934555054,
0.05432705581188202,
0.18348613381385803,
-0.5994091629981995,
0.09135334938764572,
0.5514021515846252,
-0.015660634264349937,
0.6513885855674744,
0.2500532865524292,
-0.3489871919155121,
0.725908100605011,
-0.0573032982647419,
-0.01693563163280487,
-0.14181634783744812,
-1.1723202466964722,
0.002487217541784048,
0.5753865838050842,
-0.7363022565841675,
0.1672259271144867
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.07823v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.07823v1
|
PRoDeliberation: Parallel Robust Deliberation for End-to-End Spoken Language Understanding
| 2024-06-12T02:46:17 | 2024-06-12T02:46:17 |
Trang Le, Daniel Lazar, Suyoun Kim, Shan Jiang, Duc Le, Adithya Sagar, Aleksandr Livshits, Ahmed Aly, Akshat Shrivastava
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
Spoken Language Understanding (SLU) is a critical component of voice
assistants; it consists of converting speech to semantic parses for task
execution. Previous works have explored end-to-end models to improve the
quality and robustness of SLU models with Deliberation, however these models
have remained autoregressive, resulting in higher latencies. In this work we
introduce PRoDeliberation, a novel method leveraging a Connectionist Temporal
Classification-based decoding strategy as well as a denoising objective to
train robust non-autoregressive deliberation models. We show that
PRoDeliberation achieves the latency reduction of parallel decoding (2-10x
improvement over autoregressive models) while retaining the ability to correct
Automatic Speech Recognition (ASR) mistranscriptions of autoregressive
deliberation systems. We further show that the design of the denoising training
allows PRoDeliberation to overcome the limitations of small ASR devices, and we
provide analysis on the necessity of each component of the system.
|
[
-0.4144485592842102,
-0.6644035577774048,
0.2767302691936493,
0.08580128848552704,
-0.2626352608203888,
0.15014144778251648,
-0.13098935782909393,
-0.29720205068588257,
0.0836758241057396,
0.39382824301719666,
-0.6203960180282593,
-0.36721089482307434,
-0.505637526512146,
-0.0051555391401052475,
-0.31260672211647034,
0.6999199986457825,
0.22496433556079865,
0.3994114100933075,
-0.32422885298728943,
-0.2720537483692169,
-0.37628716230392456,
-0.46639150381088257,
-0.6343540549278259,
-0.3730623424053192,
0.1075354740023613,
0.3055740296840668,
0.7215802073478699,
0.43614235520362854,
0.18720529973506927,
0.4126684069633484,
-0.4228043258190155,
0.20078368484973907,
-0.6601605415344238,
0.2202957570552826,
0.020900188013911247,
-0.9141335487365723,
-0.3258329927921295,
0.21366961300373077,
0.7592969536781311,
0.8520471453666687,
-0.28947946429252625,
0.007578686345368624,
0.17165860533714294,
0.7006450891494751,
-0.6898022294044495,
0.4437251389026642,
-0.38074883818626404,
0.2072925865650177,
0.12168668210506439,
-0.13034023344516754,
-0.5448512434959412,
-0.48818883299827576,
0.007999648340046406,
-0.5559774041175842,
0.1818276196718216,
-0.18988285958766937,
0.5390329360961914,
0.5939129590988159,
-0.2243129014968872,
-0.06777431815862656,
-1.1119732856750488,
0.9789089560508728,
-0.9472149014472961,
0.7055137157440186,
0.6997782588005066,
0.35421222448349,
-0.03846874088048935,
-0.7140246629714966,
-0.585690975189209,
-0.059365589171648026,
0.01611059159040451,
0.3282484710216522,
-0.2291124016046524,
0.37136441469192505,
-0.04853096976876259,
0.35382452607154846,
-0.557865560054779,
0.3976079821586609,
-0.06973884999752045,
-0.20842105150222778,
0.35730889439582825,
0.17461243271827698,
-0.017134521156549454,
0.33095061779022217,
0.029701268300414085,
0.1458241194486618,
-0.5553646087646484,
0.16750329732894897,
0.4442882537841797,
0.02093636617064476,
0.04077545553445816,
0.1451776772737503,
-0.2397557944059372,
0.8776885867118835,
0.06854091584682465,
-0.06073416396975517,
0.3288761377334595,
-0.31055358052253723,
-0.37909573316574097,
-0.08516918867826462,
0.688936710357666,
0.21256151795387268,
0.1491086632013321,
-0.4001931846141815,
-0.18189412355422974,
0.0056751444935798645,
0.07896632701158524,
-0.710328221321106,
-0.47300705313682556,
0.29969489574432373,
-0.6973916292190552,
-0.27194660902023315,
0.142137810587883,
-0.3495749235153198,
0.0826009213924408,
-0.6242684125900269,
0.1830276995897293,
-0.0727173388004303,
-0.27162811160087585,
0.15157252550125122,
0.21500170230865479,
0.04406435042619705,
0.35591572523117065,
-0.7602947950363159,
0.6001559495925903,
0.5288211107254028,
0.8068270683288574,
0.0694275051355362,
-0.21595056354999542,
-0.8538901209831238,
0.21633696556091309,
-0.41032660007476807,
0.6999992728233337,
-0.5838573575019836,
-0.7313181161880493,
-0.42136508226394653,
-0.07010333240032196,
-0.46048223972320557,
-0.9581207036972046,
0.5961673259735107,
-0.6025274395942688,
0.22146470844745636,
-0.140573650598526,
-0.5530809164047241,
-0.33763059973716736,
0.09068860113620758,
-0.5817402005195618,
0.38682690262794495,
-0.17192618548870087,
-0.6634988188743591,
0.0982336476445198,
-0.4146859049797058,
-0.42126524448394775,
0.013052127324044704,
-0.39304956793785095,
-0.587107241153717,
0.12146490812301636,
0.40805143117904663,
0.3351709544658661,
-0.18482480943202972,
0.37083199620246887,
-0.11692427098751068,
-0.3108091652393341,
0.07191058993339539,
-0.4766852855682373,
0.8026890754699707,
0.4364907145500183,
-0.2546052634716034,
0.41464778780937195,
-0.7216188907623291,
-0.06658579409122467,
-0.10016746819019318,
-0.3242376744747162,
-0.20950181782245636,
0.4546281099319458,
-0.23374858498573303,
-0.09962000697851181,
0.0887930765748024,
-0.6706230640411377,
-0.23975525796413422,
-0.5041501522064209,
0.655525803565979,
0.5714039206504822,
0.03587252274155617,
0.5895141363143921,
-0.3401676118373871,
0.33315110206604004,
0.05038152635097504,
0.5037090182304382,
-0.044810280203819275,
-0.2804931402206421,
-0.9585378170013428,
-0.2727389931678772,
0.18991895020008087,
0.7597367763519287,
-0.6170908212661743,
0.5242046117782593,
-0.15144124627113342,
-0.4873550534248352,
-0.5341801047325134,
-0.005506468471139669,
0.5947712659835815,
0.5561860799789429,
0.32391825318336487,
-0.21167686581611633,
-0.4068232774734497,
-0.5738454461097717,
-0.16129480302333832,
-0.45177218317985535,
-0.07115999609231949,
0.26656967401504517,
-0.03750762715935707,
-0.22690893709659576,
0.9138500094413757,
-0.2800189256668091,
-0.6633477210998535,
-0.20309634506702423,
0.46552774310112,
0.3043975830078125,
0.5221076011657715,
0.26045796275138855,
-0.7681944966316223,
-0.2142229974269867,
-0.0183335579931736,
-0.7180417776107788,
-0.2287607043981552,
-0.3108217716217041,
0.267543226480484,
-0.26480740308761597,
0.7009757161140442,
-0.42911186814308167,
0.3548599183559418,
0.4034978449344635,
0.03991631418466568,
0.5807617902755737,
-0.25919029116630554,
-0.011533055454492569,
-0.7011629939079285,
-0.027351316064596176,
-0.4205523729324341,
-0.4362187385559082,
-0.939221978187561,
-0.10619314014911652,
-0.2859977185726166,
0.005189619027078152,
-0.3008113205432892,
-0.03566889837384224,
-0.6242259740829468,
-0.07769735902547836,
-0.1902870237827301,
0.0056211138144135475,
-0.11080721020698547,
0.1963692307472229,
0.24960647523403168,
0.8555514216423035,
0.40356045961380005,
-0.5954357981681824,
0.21280094981193542,
0.5092940926551819,
-0.41180938482284546,
0.14486978948116302,
-0.7778371572494507,
0.19584545493125916,
-0.26499468088150024,
0.09135136753320694,
-0.8853848576545715,
0.15285152196884155,
-0.22705157101154327,
-0.5636247992515564,
0.16140377521514893,
0.036204706877470016,
-0.26525214314460754,
0.07680926471948624,
-0.03882027044892311,
0.2084999978542328,
0.3673277497291565,
-0.28656959533691406,
0.6996219158172607,
0.7884290218353271,
-0.37383633852005005,
-0.5440753102302551,
-0.7045338749885559,
-0.03767665475606918,
0.2911471426486969,
-0.23221798241138458,
0.1683087944984436,
-0.0595233254134655,
-0.2818085551261902,
-0.15980617702007294,
-0.22622889280319214,
0.044756967574357986,
-0.0024596676230430603,
0.20289288461208344,
-0.06773678958415985,
0.056929003447294235,
-0.3132653832435608,
0.23160456120967865,
-0.27238431572914124,
0.17565278708934784,
0.01489416602998972,
0.4948573708534241,
-0.024848967790603638,
-0.5711050629615784,
-0.9162459969520569,
0.6330874562263489,
0.641699492931366,
-0.34539511799812317,
0.49870699644088745,
0.7209376692771912,
-0.19587233662605286,
-0.194331094622612,
-0.5715025067329407,
-0.41744622588157654,
-0.45376089215278625,
0.2889373004436493,
-0.4235943853855133,
-1.2131844758987427,
0.7382277846336365,
-0.1182059794664383,
0.39700889587402344,
-0.03692176938056946,
0.6179150938987732,
-0.14126257598400116,
1.0086766481399536,
0.4535035192966461,
-0.22335413098335266,
0.6142022609710693,
-0.4157772362232208,
0.3922608196735382,
-0.48382532596588135,
-0.5279746651649475,
-0.6056184768676758,
-0.2888258993625641,
-0.1415102183818817,
-0.5401319861412048,
0.33425307273864746,
0.24579350650310516,
-0.1451258361339569,
0.19070503115653992,
-0.2551555335521698,
0.3559280037879944,
0.7755054235458374,
0.30237653851509094,
0.2482297122478485,
-0.09051239490509033,
-0.24341453611850739,
-0.23886820673942566,
-0.6806190609931946,
-0.23816098272800446,
0.5254627466201782,
0.37670257687568665,
0.8159348368644714,
0.11520031094551086,
0.6858183145523071,
0.17259058356285095,
-0.06002281233668327,
-0.7160950303077698,
0.7179498076438904,
-0.3944016695022583,
0.0592629499733448,
-0.3586388826370239,
-0.5220388770103455,
-0.535642683506012,
0.22386451065540314,
-0.03011351078748703,
-0.5934094190597534,
0.7793296575546265,
0.3311874568462372,
-0.4194618761539459,
0.25233033299446106,
-0.5696479082107544,
0.6406895518302917,
0.12173246592283249,
-0.030169066041707993,
-0.5543796420097351,
-0.7917608618736267,
-0.06076075881719589,
0.15559712052345276,
0.24549180269241333,
-0.04516575485467911,
0.19549714028835297,
0.8080939650535583,
-0.5367341637611389,
1.09605872631073,
-0.6383811235427856,
0.1383509784936905,
0.3950727581977844,
0.3674719035625458,
0.5562176704406738,
0.008390420116484165,
0.0029281978495419025,
0.1494537591934204,
0.009511778131127357,
-0.09277992695569992,
-0.6028748750686646,
0.3901733160018921,
-0.9429465532302856,
-0.577775776386261,
0.04356261342763901,
-0.5538328289985657,
-0.36618512868881226,
-0.08190926164388657,
0.1729922741651535,
0.45473164319992065,
-0.2111351490020752,
0.313096284866333,
0.8248400092124939,
0.06246928498148918,
0.45850053429603577,
0.5286645293235779,
0.007902195677161217,
-0.4449384808540344,
1.0668245553970337,
0.036494649946689606,
0.303554892539978,
0.6836544275283813,
0.1639489382505417,
-0.4113210141658783,
-0.9231563806533813,
-0.033967964351177216,
0.13163022696971893,
-0.7014361619949341,
-0.09272941201925278,
-0.8518306612968445,
-0.38564881682395935,
-0.5385248064994812,
0.04838643968105316,
-0.5613452792167664,
-0.26251301169395447,
-0.8703957796096802,
-0.013623228296637535,
-0.068618543446064,
0.5088149309158325,
-0.22443601489067078,
0.7283968329429626,
-0.8742794990539551,
0.2979467511177063,
0.5582349300384521,
-0.04006783664226532,
-0.1969611644744873,
-0.7210673093795776,
-0.14155098795890808,
-0.14837680757045746,
-0.07551773637533188,
-0.8843116164207458,
0.6264166831970215,
0.5364558696746826,
1.0729427337646484,
0.7035621404647827,
0.3752546012401581,
0.8783069849014282,
-0.39060258865356445,
0.7515084743499756,
0.14213117957115173,
-1.0868149995803833,
0.5605501532554626,
-0.07950469851493835,
0.5641209483146667,
0.7494856715202332,
0.1371936947107315,
-0.32462236285209656,
-0.5113791823387146,
-0.12978215515613556,
-0.5797845125198364,
0.5920864343643188,
0.0846407413482666,
-0.1910647302865982,
0.0739210918545723,
0.11396687477827072,
-0.003109303768724203,
0.21151965856552124,
-0.3283326029777527,
0.08472890406847,
-0.2624845802783966,
-0.1305985301733017,
-0.24161739647388458,
-0.606719970703125,
-0.10451052337884903,
-0.25512099266052246,
0.38709166646003723,
-0.023586133494973183,
0.39679333567619324,
0.2771143317222595,
-0.27820253372192383,
0.0394548624753952,
0.348484069108963,
0.5131863951683044,
0.43865248560905457,
-0.12287643551826477,
0.11440391093492508,
0.11498919129371643,
-0.6084587574005127,
0.06090463325381279,
-0.0784827396273613,
-0.2183724343776703,
0.14841532707214355,
0.35599955916404724,
1.1221708059310913,
0.11284523457288742,
-0.4346810579299927,
0.494753360748291,
-0.22807550430297852,
-0.41591116786003113,
-0.20216156542301178,
-0.05121653527021408,
-0.037834882736206055,
0.3488498330116272,
0.12701937556266785,
0.2553684413433075,
0.4688865840435028,
-0.0550333596765995,
0.26697349548339844,
0.31334707140922546,
-0.3369189500808716,
-0.401607483625412,
0.9798584580421448,
0.38269922137260437,
-0.1748458296060562,
0.6599112749099731,
-0.1171846091747284,
-0.38605499267578125,
0.3385816812515259,
0.47115272283554077,
0.997724711894989,
-0.746416449546814,
0.17132939398288727,
0.1603972315788269,
0.3075732886791229,
-0.08285225927829742,
0.6130102276802063,
-0.6397249102592468,
-0.6738041639328003,
-0.6331814527511597,
-0.6706043481826782,
-0.5951682925224304,
0.03286893293261528,
-0.8826751708984375,
-0.15066079795360565,
-0.49432307481765747,
-0.3537794351577759,
-0.35967743396759033,
-0.33849677443504333,
-0.3677738904953003,
0.20438902080059052,
-0.15532928705215454,
0.628567636013031,
-1.076359510421753,
0.9967775344848633,
0.45251837372779846,
0.020181413739919662,
-0.5209627747535706,
-0.018566753715276718,
0.06953876465559006,
-0.5307915806770325,
0.7878457307815552,
0.13950617611408234,
-0.5979399085044861,
0.24212917685508728,
-0.21175213158130646,
-0.42486196756362915,
0.7906263470649719,
0.6238681674003601,
-1.0560643672943115,
-0.011687565594911575,
0.0632641389966011,
0.4424169659614563,
-0.1944410651922226,
0.30495819449424744,
0.6764787435531616,
0.14209799468517303,
-0.05488085001707077,
-1.2911159992218018,
-0.4168994426727295,
-0.29129189252853394,
0.17544932663440704,
-0.1752329170703888,
-0.3892485797405243,
0.8361226320266724,
-0.29166364669799805,
-0.2876511812210083,
-0.03672974929213524,
0.8754526972770691,
-0.010398201644420624,
0.1584399938583374,
0.8316335082054138,
0.48256030678749084,
0.49246224761009216,
-0.09522386640310287,
0.2855943739414215,
-0.2898959517478943,
0.307971328496933,
1.347654938697815,
-0.08379748463630676,
1.0172609090805054,
0.6594422459602356,
-0.3361428380012512,
0.24984125792980194,
0.6038812398910522,
0.45824384689331055,
0.8258827924728394,
-0.07108881324529648,
-0.7190163731575012,
-0.5671342611312866,
-0.11240159720182419,
-0.053062234073877335,
0.5880967378616333,
0.5225266218185425,
-0.22172412276268005,
-0.14439858496189117,
0.30191004276275635,
-0.14481043815612793,
0.3874480724334717,
-0.2585630416870117,
1.2121883630752563,
0.06095268577337265,
-0.3592301607131958,
0.6319085359573364,
-0.26216623187065125,
0.40513917803764343,
-0.35479098558425903,
0.10438396036624908,
-0.14485402405261993,
0.43478870391845703,
-0.21929940581321716,
-0.6355577707290649,
0.6040748953819275,
-0.3128804564476013,
-0.2218122035264969,
-0.30029183626174927,
0.47313839197158813,
-0.4440891146659851,
-0.09349431097507477,
0.3717086911201477,
0.6925041675567627,
0.4229746460914612,
-0.0557125024497509,
-0.6625180244445801,
0.27926796674728394,
0.07315463572740555,
-0.1661812961101532,
0.06787362694740295,
-0.015170533210039139,
-0.016848327592015266,
0.8003222942352295,
0.6096690893173218,
0.25560542941093445,
0.06247582659125328,
0.6480897068977356,
0.9470840096473694,
-0.028208477422595024,
-0.9194861054420471,
-0.6789864897727966,
0.17883609235286713,
-0.04377274587750435,
0.10248934477567673,
0.4542296230792999,
0.5269044637680054,
1.0212429761886597,
-0.08193652331829071,
0.7301881313323975,
0.21562498807907104,
0.7287201285362244,
-0.48525679111480713,
0.7920448184013367,
-0.10385363548994064,
0.27129653096199036,
0.13526275753974915,
-0.5595436692237854,
-0.5188174843788147,
0.8504737019538879,
-0.4213598668575287,
-0.26748019456863403,
0.28778696060180664,
0.888650119304657,
0.15692386031150818,
0.3314532935619354,
0.6451964974403381,
0.19481267035007477,
0.4534904956817627,
0.3718201816082001,
0.5733803510665894,
-0.13845589756965637,
0.34949880838394165,
-0.25616592168807983,
-0.3862112760543823,
-0.014110809192061424,
-0.41571372747421265,
-0.9680783152580261,
-0.6736168265342712,
-0.12438268214464188,
0.0426529124379158,
0.29154056310653687,
0.6116479635238647,
0.8249837756156921,
-1.0981147289276123,
-0.5861750841140747,
-0.43355897068977356,
-0.2594199478626251,
-0.38647547364234924,
-0.1384929120540619,
0.22341178357601166,
-0.5574639439582825,
-0.8981702923774719,
0.7011417150497437,
0.3170105814933777,
-0.11652116477489471,
-0.29643017053604126,
-0.322612464427948,
-0.02788940630853176,
-0.23029963672161102,
0.6098939776420593,
0.3328254520893097,
-0.8322275280952454,
0.09134887903928757,
-0.05639638006687164,
0.3992798924446106,
-0.02995910495519638,
0.9783717393875122,
-0.8552216291427612,
0.8760912418365479,
0.7425398826599121,
0.6741881966590881,
0.4216921031475067,
0.045509882271289825,
0.6674542427062988,
-0.5987178683280945,
0.40172719955444336,
0.41180628538131714,
0.31869345903396606,
0.20552445948123932,
-0.18552932143211365,
0.08293205499649048,
0.44674763083457947,
-0.924138605594635,
-0.8115887641906738,
0.3307362496852875,
-0.8821432590484619,
-0.1856042742729187,
0.7629773020744324,
-0.5884135961532593,
0.05820590257644653,
-0.41483160853385925,
-0.2489505261182785,
0.5519724488258362,
-0.29964807629585266,
0.2832830846309662,
0.16105031967163086,
-0.45903003215789795,
-0.6885977387428284,
-0.5207204818725586,
0.32698267698287964,
0.5685413479804993,
-0.7375502586364746,
0.3138280212879181,
0.4239026606082916,
0.07624311000108719,
-0.06316715478897095,
0.8047488331794739,
-0.19830776751041412,
0.22691796720027924,
0.03544818237423897,
-0.09511096775531769,
-0.40285563468933105,
-0.442282110452652,
-0.47558900713920593,
0.17801819741725922,
0.06737340986728668,
-0.6970685720443726
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.07822v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.07822v1
|
Tell Me What's Next: Textual Foresight for Generic UI Representations
| 2024-06-12T02:43:19 | 2024-06-12T02:43:19 |
Andrea Burns, Kate Saenko, Bryan A. Plummer
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
Mobile app user interfaces (UIs) are rich with action, text, structure, and
image content that can be utilized to learn generic UI representations for
tasks like automating user commands, summarizing content, and evaluating the
accessibility of user interfaces. Prior work has learned strong visual
representations with local or global captioning losses, but fails to retain
both granularities. To combat this, we propose Textual Foresight, a novel
pretraining objective for learning UI screen representations. Textual Foresight
generates global text descriptions of future UI states given a current UI and
local action taken. Our approach requires joint reasoning over elements and
entire screens, resulting in improved UI features: on generation tasks, UI
agents trained with Textual Foresight outperform state-of-the-art by 2% with
28x fewer images. We train with our newly constructed mobile app dataset,
OpenApp, which results in the first public dataset for app UI representation
learning. OpenApp enables new baselines, and we find Textual Foresight improves
average task performance over them by 5.7% while having access to 2x less data.
|
[
-0.2319471538066864,
-0.19341735541820526,
0.8940791487693787,
-0.04981113225221634,
-0.1465635746717453,
0.12934289872646332,
-0.06642180681228638,
-0.08302115648984909,
0.19671764969825745,
0.6469221115112305,
-0.6094273328781128,
-0.7574459910392761,
-0.1243971511721611,
-0.16942162811756134,
-0.15428245067596436,
0.9535347819328308,
-0.4457043409347534,
-0.3618440628051758,
-0.45981794595718384,
-0.12790435552597046,
-0.7472352981567383,
-0.23254285752773285,
-0.1897803246974945,
-0.26251113414764404,
0.7652872800827026,
0.9873757362365723,
0.6113057732582092,
0.32014450430870056,
0.05754954740405083,
0.31285560131073,
0.7376035451889038,
0.06372828781604767,
-0.5229895114898682,
-0.017797015607357025,
-0.07234488427639008,
-0.5750507116317749,
0.051467422395944595,
0.2837878167629242,
0.20703740417957306,
0.4119284749031067,
0.24727284908294678,
0.048719242215156555,
0.10647477954626083,
0.8673575520515442,
-0.9751772284507751,
0.22609804570674896,
-0.6373865008354187,
0.3337606191635132,
-0.04622615501284599,
-0.2679625451564789,
-0.65289306640625,
-0.2290601283311844,
0.18404416739940643,
-1.201242446899414,
0.02723013237118721,
0.2608698010444641,
0.9370593428611755,
0.3396984338760376,
-0.5914208292961121,
0.17922894656658173,
-0.8645567893981934,
0.8385472297668457,
-0.037503961473703384,
0.4325203001499176,
0.7277154922485352,
0.32311055064201355,
-0.06316261738538742,
-1.098134994506836,
-0.5833975672721863,
-0.34374916553497314,
-0.02819637954235077,
0.27907589077949524,
-0.0574222095310688,
0.08641226589679718,
-0.038522496819496155,
0.16994886100292206,
-0.5414506196975708,
-0.15554964542388916,
-0.12581248581409454,
-0.3299620449542999,
0.6591496467590332,
0.0740104615688324,
0.2998077869415283,
0.2681400179862976,
-0.6079064607620239,
-0.1112292930483818,
-0.6454117894172668,
0.18898628652095795,
-0.3019639253616333,
-0.25124630331993103,
-0.30881595611572266,
0.5360340476036072,
-0.15722747147083282,
0.5821571350097656,
0.019469739869236946,
0.32066670060157776,
0.306331604719162,
-0.22101227939128876,
-0.18225643038749695,
0.010526955127716064,
0.8051612973213196,
0.6076421141624451,
0.48129019141197205,
-0.2763882577419281,
0.037704188376665115,
0.004819242283701897,
0.5829160809516907,
-0.6320114731788635,
-0.31744322180747986,
0.18593257665634155,
-0.6034609079360962,
-0.29160192608833313,
0.10345925390720367,
-0.553520143032074,
-0.7861935496330261,
-0.45209163427352905,
0.32341262698173523,
-0.3745254576206207,
0.006808547768741846,
-0.3515545129776001,
-0.18504801392555237,
-0.08675368130207062,
0.31362149119377136,
-1.0298680067062378,
0.053964775055646896,
0.3779248297214508,
0.6072932481765747,
0.13072150945663452,
-0.5189966559410095,
-0.6212913990020752,
0.3238063156604767,
-0.6855570077896118,
0.8832564949989319,
-0.6285250782966614,
-0.29602742195129395,
-0.05842401459813118,
-0.2672453224658966,
-0.22710929811000824,
-0.33559730648994446,
0.3509662449359894,
-0.09821479767560959,
0.1920594424009323,
-0.003256638068705797,
-0.3392237424850464,
-0.3202687203884125,
-0.003741655731573701,
-0.8053863048553467,
0.8249292373657227,
0.28259995579719543,
-0.7846283316612244,
0.8373727798461914,
-0.5435310006141663,
-0.3711494505405426,
-0.08495204895734787,
-0.4311816394329071,
-0.3317292630672455,
0.3304435908794403,
0.49744582176208496,
0.697981059551239,
0.17763547599315643,
0.11278680711984634,
-0.30058354139328003,
-0.49286526441574097,
0.15743756294250488,
-0.11423710733652115,
0.08087508380413055,
0.24328060448169708,
-0.435884952545166,
0.21969449520111084,
-0.6397734880447388,
0.13062818348407745,
-0.3022543787956238,
0.1329285353422165,
-0.8166306018829346,
0.2695392668247223,
-0.06292687356472015,
-0.012183072976768017,
0.12796467542648315,
-0.6079596281051636,
-0.0000991585839074105,
-0.1941932588815689,
0.2739095985889435,
0.690430223941803,
-0.14828485250473022,
1.0801377296447754,
-0.22507761418819427,
0.3223456144332886,
0.0876043438911438,
0.29722246527671814,
-0.7066984176635742,
-0.5416426062583923,
-0.33808115124702454,
0.13977853953838348,
0.247778981924057,
0.5172997117042542,
-1.3947941064834595,
0.026976924389600754,
-0.38611331582069397,
-0.5236296057701111,
0.16620351374149323,
0.13218770921230316,
0.6396376490592957,
0.46193382143974304,
0.11812832951545715,
-0.29930323362350464,
-0.5161927938461304,
-0.5522255897521973,
-0.6946680545806885,
-0.30948978662490845,
-0.16232174634933472,
-0.001878237002529204,
0.4709213674068451,
-0.4594162404537201,
1.3947994709014893,
-0.3853749930858612,
-0.5383318066596985,
-0.2756148874759674,
0.4387958347797394,
-0.02243446558713913,
0.26792430877685547,
0.5056425929069519,
-1.34233820438385,
-0.5953558683395386,
0.5273321866989136,
-0.9476444125175476,
0.21949413418769836,
-0.3231152594089508,
0.09009510278701782,
0.16239750385284424,
0.5791590213775635,
-0.3661733567714691,
0.8482516407966614,
0.5415759086608887,
-0.5698975324630737,
0.52403324842453,
-0.2762655019760132,
0.12256181985139847,
-0.9786986112594604,
-0.11816337704658508,
0.18033508956432343,
-0.15190738439559937,
-0.6052121520042419,
-0.3363809585571289,
0.4424157440662384,
-0.6847239136695862,
-0.19634170830249786,
1.1362005472183228,
-0.5526726841926575,
-0.14394214749336243,
0.06401599943637848,
-0.15087707340717316,
0.029648447409272194,
0.5847418904304504,
0.0988316461443901,
0.9007129073143005,
0.1214093267917633,
-0.6359100937843323,
0.02269594743847847,
0.2396063655614853,
-0.4549517035484314,
0.3791474997997284,
-0.2082853615283966,
-0.19049052894115448,
-0.061469003558158875,
0.3999384641647339,
-0.8393338918685913,
-0.48991501331329346,
0.001543752965517342,
-0.6874796152114868,
0.021650366485118866,
0.21447056531906128,
-0.03525251895189285,
-0.6565622687339783,
-0.5195779204368591,
0.03722544014453888,
0.33284950256347656,
-0.5634208917617798,
1.080366611480713,
0.2056715488433838,
-0.16998860239982605,
-0.7226353287696838,
-0.6157347559928894,
-0.06457263976335526,
-0.038930296897888184,
-0.5190873742103577,
0.5374916195869446,
0.39451658725738525,
-0.18297816812992096,
0.03889486566185951,
-0.29305073618888855,
-0.2996971309185028,
-0.05294236168265343,
0.816179633140564,
0.09519263356924057,
0.0038949742447584867,
0.36374467611312866,
0.2939735949039459,
-0.4654202461242676,
-0.2111877053976059,
-0.3657289743423462,
0.03296659141778946,
0.08417905867099762,
-0.014291237108409405,
-0.6864160895347595,
0.25475385785102844,
0.44339701533317566,
-0.3268449902534485,
0.28189828991889954,
0.6479215025901794,
-0.13641487061977386,
0.061969563364982605,
-0.5112595558166504,
0.03098165988922119,
-0.5083199143409729,
0.25549429655075073,
-0.39197540283203125,
-0.6245777606964111,
0.4534393548965454,
-0.4711639881134033,
0.4736149311065674,
0.20087343454360962,
0.12370755523443222,
-0.524987518787384,
1.1005679368972778,
0.7509053349494934,
0.050224386155605316,
1.0112110376358032,
-0.29861268401145935,
-0.009850149042904377,
-0.299771249294281,
-0.5806204080581665,
-0.2701442241668701,
-0.3586476445198059,
-0.2876339256763458,
-0.4132080674171448,
0.3422437310218811,
-0.03229476138949394,
-0.6376726031303406,
-0.07001437246799469,
-0.31784945726394653,
0.4824860095977783,
0.8721281290054321,
0.3470599353313446,
0.22377042472362518,
0.3958439826965332,
-0.4233560562133789,
-0.2017793208360672,
-0.47673553228378296,
-0.6739243268966675,
1.3362900018692017,
0.2816649377346039,
0.8119135499000549,
-0.6768642663955688,
0.8871251344680786,
0.6514495015144348,
0.5539021492004395,
-0.49340710043907166,
0.5044391751289368,
-0.5338983535766602,
-0.1879366636276245,
-0.22177770733833313,
-0.3294929265975952,
-0.8786290884017944,
-0.005456185434013605,
-0.4505937695503235,
-0.7682576179504395,
0.2984497547149658,
0.3568791449069977,
-0.26328569650650024,
0.32783153653144836,
-1.1773831844329834,
0.9744501113891602,
-0.32027092576026917,
-0.42650511860847473,
0.06209008768200874,
-0.5004863739013672,
0.058681510388851166,
0.09090510755777359,
0.3782423138618469,
0.148659810423851,
-0.2549426555633545,
0.6026849746704102,
-0.5275088548660278,
0.8973599076271057,
-0.5023341178894043,
0.015333456918597221,
0.3909272253513336,
-0.11544255912303925,
0.4414660632610321,
-0.13745500147342682,
-0.11221455782651901,
-0.03481394052505493,
-0.2987919747829437,
-0.4309833347797394,
-0.6613606810569763,
0.34962061047554016,
-0.6666797995567322,
-0.059243567287921906,
-0.3910737633705139,
-0.2389903962612152,
-0.36288782954216003,
0.21978606283664703,
0.5810604095458984,
0.6095139384269714,
-0.6821796298027039,
0.08347241580486298,
0.4816363751888275,
-0.32402145862579346,
0.4735396206378937,
0.033284302800893784,
-0.3661286532878876,
-0.5792374610900879,
0.9498173594474792,
-0.21482181549072266,
-0.29427236318588257,
0.8484228849411011,
0.10927233844995499,
-0.44625189900398254,
-0.49581626057624817,
-0.7503650784492493,
-0.27649518847465515,
-0.2558048665523529,
-0.13663199543952942,
-0.3714960217475891,
0.30984601378440857,
0.05017229542136192,
-0.4042817950248718,
-0.2671249210834503,
-0.3273141384124756,
-0.26714301109313965,
-0.11321015655994415,
0.30431124567985535,
0.8022819757461548,
0.06952617317438126,
0.7116076946258545,
-0.9148459434509277,
0.5516765713691711,
0.41426870226860046,
0.3474930226802826,
-0.14699332416057587,
0.10977749526500702,
-0.5662712454795837,
0.2338237166404724,
-0.6446681022644043,
-0.545346736907959,
0.33448758721351624,
0.4471789300441742,
0.42190805077552795,
0.7447791695594788,
0.28963619470596313,
0.5491476655006409,
-0.7011909484863281,
0.8913801312446594,
0.7741813659667969,
-0.7662063241004944,
0.6696556806564331,
-0.34220340847969055,
0.37512341141700745,
0.7443773746490479,
0.5627376437187195,
-0.2634536623954773,
-0.2607172429561615,
-0.26746147871017456,
-0.4180302023887634,
0.33038249611854553,
0.12080053985118866,
0.3710552453994751,
0.3985437750816345,
0.4392048120498657,
0.42495718598365784,
-0.010973447933793068,
-0.6338851451873779,
0.061581842601299286,
-0.6167793869972229,
-0.4605465829372406,
-0.4171021580696106,
-0.100415900349617,
0.2500685155391693,
-0.33926689624786377,
0.0590645857155323,
-0.35091301798820496,
0.42312920093536377,
0.1799495369195938,
-0.24437215924263,
0.3004412353038788,
0.130601704120636,
0.28813979029655457,
0.7260398864746094,
0.07982999086380005,
-0.03011353872716427,
-0.04262620583176613,
-0.9608492255210876,
0.2959434390068054,
0.05500859022140503,
-0.13971157371997833,
0.2442866414785385,
0.48966678977012634,
1.0822757482528687,
0.6188980340957642,
-0.6606087684631348,
0.5785244703292847,
-0.3922056257724762,
-0.45098692178726196,
-0.5000513195991516,
0.073614701628685,
-0.31163597106933594,
0.190562441945076,
0.8326654434204102,
0.15292993187904358,
0.06311377137899399,
-0.7508770227432251,
0.16330841183662415,
-0.10145866125822067,
-0.6448524594306946,
-0.20027951896190643,
0.885461151599884,
0.5538831353187561,
0.09519154578447342,
0.42744049429893494,
-0.007524879649281502,
-0.36839285492897034,
0.49439117312431335,
0.18838682770729065,
0.8805913329124451,
-0.3055857717990875,
0.6452921628952026,
0.2584208846092224,
-0.049870170652866364,
-0.08062421530485153,
0.4867342412471771,
-0.3536417484283447,
-0.368411123752594,
-0.40937381982803345,
-0.3254780173301697,
-0.45254188776016235,
-0.3486137092113495,
-0.34151509404182434,
0.11995919048786163,
-0.3879898488521576,
-0.32340461015701294,
-0.10459943860769272,
-0.00046925386413931847,
-0.5851851105690002,
0.6201221346855164,
-0.08844226598739624,
0.8271821141242981,
-0.5929293632507324,
0.6550557613372803,
0.9253266453742981,
-0.3546176552772522,
-0.734508752822876,
0.07201952487230301,
-0.09607084095478058,
-0.495837539434433,
0.5036810636520386,
0.5432800650596619,
0.012870490550994873,
-0.19403702020645142,
-0.6930381059646606,
-0.3299068808555603,
1.1032229661941528,
0.39001861214637756,
-0.7703412771224976,
-0.39778101444244385,
0.05375443398952484,
0.2766575217247009,
-0.46383488178253174,
0.417754203081131,
0.1748698204755783,
0.47033870220184326,
-0.045784492045640945,
-0.6532229781150818,
-0.1720447838306427,
-0.44223645329475403,
0.23730547726154327,
0.19491355121135712,
-0.08428709954023361,
0.7642374634742737,
-0.7048954963684082,
-0.2359192818403244,
0.3268410861492157,
0.8060495853424072,
-0.0467473641037941,
1.372821569442749,
0.3220258355140686,
0.3806644678115845,
0.7870157957077026,
-0.22125326097011566,
1.3935315608978271,
0.1346360146999359,
-0.10879442095756531,
1.1771658658981323,
-0.27901455760002136,
1.011000633239746,
0.3861369788646698,
0.21033558249473572,
1.086558222770691,
0.7582882642745972,
0.5042710304260254,
0.8252078294754028,
-0.16350683569908142,
-0.3285233676433563,
0.030098307877779007,
0.11887770146131516,
-0.4872529208660126,
0.582294225692749,
0.4280454218387604,
-0.5547798871994019,
0.057838957756757736,
0.7934458255767822,
-0.14283894002437592,
0.6156725287437439,
-0.6398929953575134,
0.9996692538261414,
0.10732370615005493,
-0.7427722215652466,
0.5733763575553894,
-0.2865619957447052,
0.6890773773193359,
-0.69261234998703,
-0.1303359717130661,
-0.3560104966163635,
0.23413841426372528,
-0.34814852476119995,
-0.8482462167739868,
0.07670052349567413,
-0.06576140969991684,
-0.28305819630622864,
-0.5107203125953674,
0.9886006712913513,
-0.041360948234796524,
-0.18297454714775085,
0.16764065623283386,
0.2598700523376465,
-0.01142075378447771,
-0.6982044577598572,
-0.3632715344429016,
-0.14583155512809753,
0.0608210451900959,
-0.0084617855027318,
0.2412518858909607,
0.7229278683662415,
-0.5771498084068298,
0.9474737644195557,
0.4636591970920563,
-0.3788866102695465,
0.0522879883646965,
-0.13925544917583466,
0.9649720788002014,
-0.9211141467094421,
-0.7829493284225464,
-0.3944139778614044,
0.6227596402168274,
-0.3786126673221588,
-0.2548666298389435,
0.45754292607307434,
0.6523706316947937,
0.807530403137207,
-0.3634470999240875,
0.9591561555862427,
-0.032317254692316055,
0.316976934671402,
-0.5839042663574219,
0.9070996642112732,
-0.7420529127120972,
-0.28678229451179504,
-0.2852225601673126,
-0.8788488507270813,
-0.1275063306093216,
0.46819519996643066,
-0.5860720276832581,
-0.05253620818257332,
0.8099259734153748,
0.22552089393138885,
-0.13676659762859344,
0.2852531671524048,
0.4216451644897461,
-0.1511697918176651,
-0.18989065289497375,
0.6739005446434021,
0.9329825043678284,
-0.32798999547958374,
0.5518375635147095,
-0.2513866722583771,
-0.5152114629745483,
-0.04858723655343056,
-0.8254660367965698,
-0.9216897487640381,
-0.9802113175392151,
0.054515473544597626,
0.02571285143494606,
0.2649940252304077,
0.3736110329627991,
0.749472439289093,
-0.5119326710700989,
-0.1523316651582718,
-0.26939377188682556,
0.18148678541183472,
-0.2722068130970001,
-0.12725548446178436,
0.1732163280248642,
-0.3317877948284149,
-0.30061858892440796,
0.08614765107631683,
0.05942622572183609,
-0.08832672983407974,
0.17615856230258942,
-0.4694884121417999,
0.15708748996257782,
-0.4228515625,
0.9455870389938354,
0.7826869487762451,
-0.4009040892124176,
-0.07955124974250793,
-0.2881091833114624,
0.05121556296944618,
-0.06894320249557495,
1.1219449043273926,
-1.3603129386901855,
0.7105576395988464,
0.19454239308834076,
0.55035001039505,
0.6738359928131104,
-0.039916034787893295,
1.032202124595642,
-0.8662706017494202,
0.39492666721343994,
0.2615269720554352,
-0.04466024786233902,
-0.012963906861841679,
-0.15362747013568878,
0.5946071743965149,
-0.18087716400623322,
-0.18921591341495514,
-0.42611002922058105,
0.14119862020015717,
-0.7283579111099243,
-0.3045188784599304,
0.6438620090484619,
-0.3112930357456207,
-0.2679126560688019,
-0.47811955213546753,
-0.48859554529190063,
0.038432661443948746,
-0.5743196606636047,
0.5128340125083923,
0.05522793158888817,
0.0070913806557655334,
-0.4409015476703644,
-0.5915592908859253,
0.6244423389434814,
0.24060790240764618,
-0.9605714678764343,
-0.07964381575584412,
0.5511095523834229,
-0.14792904257774353,
0.2244889885187149,
0.9596893787384033,
0.003138187574222684,
0.5518476366996765,
0.2035915106534958,
0.02594255842268467,
-0.22422291338443756,
-0.6267299056053162,
0.2342478185892105,
-0.23066312074661255,
-0.20140428841114044,
-0.5182139873504639
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.07816v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.07816v1
|
Spoof Diarization: "What Spoofed When" in Partially Spoofed Audio
| 2024-06-12T02:23:57 | 2024-06-12T02:23:57 |
Lin Zhang, Xin Wang, Erica Cooper, Mireia Diez, Federico Landini, Nicholas Evans, Junichi Yamagishi
|
eess.AS
|
eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.SD
|
This paper defines Spoof Diarization as a novel task in the Partial Spoof
(PS) scenario. It aims to determine what spoofed when, which includes not only
locating spoof regions but also clustering them according to different spoofing
methods. As a pioneering study in spoof diarization, we focus on defining the
task, establishing evaluation metrics, and proposing a benchmark model, namely
the Countermeasure-Condition Clustering (3C) model. Utilizing this model, we
first explore how to effectively train countermeasures to support spoof
diarization using three labeling schemes. We then utilize spoof localization
predictions to enhance the diarization performance. This first study reveals
the high complexity of the task, even in restricted scenarios where only a
single speaker per audio file and an oracle number of spoofing methods are
considered. Our code is available at
https://github.com/nii-yamagishilab/PartialSpoof.
|
[
-0.39779654145240784,
-1.104729175567627,
0.394090861082077,
0.3317641615867615,
-0.1843581348657608,
0.292405366897583,
-0.030466916039586067,
-0.6102702617645264,
0.7532799243927002,
0.39981895685195923,
-0.4261576533317566,
-0.30783751606941223,
-0.5743761658668518,
-0.1333741694688797,
-0.927767276763916,
0.8614887595176697,
0.43332040309906006,
-0.10431840270757675,
-0.2276259809732437,
0.17363308370113373,
-0.37861186265945435,
-0.695434033870697,
-0.3867984414100647,
0.11198855936527252,
0.040304288268089294,
0.44695353507995605,
0.11985719203948975,
0.4399341940879822,
0.5406337380409241,
0.34496134519577026,
-0.29461419582366943,
-0.04681135341525078,
-0.0870269164443016,
-0.0926034078001976,
0.12738178670406342,
-0.4344007074832916,
-0.6088163256645203,
0.2840593159198761,
0.6604832410812378,
0.5992876887321472,
-0.7097365260124207,
0.10319330543279648,
-0.2951291501522064,
0.26611459255218506,
-0.7232553362846375,
-0.0988699421286583,
-0.713241457939148,
0.2214839905500412,
-0.7083662748336792,
-0.14111632108688354,
-0.4587346315383911,
-0.11964177340269089,
0.4371432960033417,
-0.5671514272689819,
0.8947338461875916,
-0.060125358402729034,
0.7545166611671448,
0.30792659521102905,
0.055476102977991104,
-0.32522284984588623,
-1.1494866609573364,
0.639380931854248,
-0.78570556640625,
-0.016699420288205147,
0.8439360857009888,
0.39154675602912903,
-0.1327698975801468,
-0.6585627198219299,
-0.673504650592804,
-0.10246875137090683,
0.078372061252594,
0.18986085057258606,
-0.3821508586406708,
0.10282006859779358,
0.372826486825943,
0.6631335020065308,
-0.07739885151386261,
-0.3902342915534973,
-0.33608365058898926,
-0.3543608486652374,
0.45788148045539856,
-0.447533518075943,
0.42212045192718506,
0.07779417932033539,
-0.5026379823684692,
0.27957621216773987,
-0.4486840069293976,
-0.1967102289199829,
0.5802773833274841,
0.3292424976825714,
-0.300200879573822,
0.2532481551170349,
-0.17553861439228058,
0.5142749547958374,
0.46256959438323975,
-0.2345820963382721,
0.4316475987434387,
-0.5436778664588928,
-0.19868506491184235,
0.4868535101413727,
0.4396600127220154,
0.03619829937815666,
-0.3562990427017212,
-0.25258734822273254,
-0.31168946623802185,
0.15865997970104218,
0.3606000542640686,
-0.1828509420156479,
-0.35351425409317017,
0.3547170162200928,
-0.24590203166007996,
-0.07960285991430283,
0.03777261823415756,
-0.9268646240234375,
-0.33103904128074646,
-0.09965323656797409,
0.9441137909889221,
-0.457831472158432,
-0.638695240020752,
0.22725550830364227,
-0.4165371358394623,
-0.20582842826843262,
-0.03630051016807556,
-0.6197901368141174,
0.7894794344902039,
0.45812785625457764,
0.8176215291023254,
-0.15545319020748138,
-0.6161074042320251,
-0.459739089012146,
0.2822968363761902,
-0.12529082596302032,
0.8380729556083679,
-0.04012138769030571,
-0.5878973603248596,
-0.2352500706911087,
0.023046890273690224,
-0.2704148292541504,
-0.7510658502578735,
0.17847898602485657,
-0.2969875633716583,
-0.13036905229091644,
-0.2245451658964157,
-0.48922333121299744,
-0.0851815715432167,
0.09398644417524338,
-0.9117893576622009,
1.2099117040634155,
-0.1372208446264267,
-1.0762192010879517,
0.36124300956726074,
-0.459255576133728,
-0.5609487295150757,
0.2964411675930023,
0.17895832657814026,
-0.5953207015991211,
-0.0038639919366687536,
-0.36551108956336975,
0.19209839403629303,
0.26763683557510376,
-0.07550282776355743,
-0.17739513516426086,
-0.599460244178772,
0.2746432423591614,
-0.14347165822982788,
0.6477571129798889,
0.14983615279197693,
-0.7640997171401978,
-0.08779111504554749,
-0.8425719141960144,
-0.35599398612976074,
0.18742693960666656,
-0.05103965103626251,
-0.5102408528327942,
0.36338111758232117,
-0.2664606273174286,
-0.2853037416934967,
0.20847715437412262,
-0.6372219324111938,
-0.3080510199069977,
-0.5325447916984558,
0.27728980779647827,
0.16193819046020508,
0.44177043437957764,
0.4998346269130707,
-0.4522014558315277,
0.42315420508384705,
0.09201386570930481,
0.3445671498775482,
0.11152608692646027,
-0.5155064463615417,
-0.46712955832481384,
-0.7039110064506531,
0.25605344772338867,
0.8094394207000732,
-0.5753871202468872,
0.023694366216659546,
0.18644845485687256,
-0.8623786568641663,
-0.2823222875595093,
-0.217341810464859,
0.48960015177726746,
0.1259467750787735,
0.4002429246902466,
-0.40182456374168396,
-0.7906558513641357,
-0.8040039539337158,
-0.018260056152939796,
-0.06414448469877243,
0.18909157812595367,
-0.21197658777236938,
0.3389342725276947,
0.07243756204843521,
0.905787467956543,
0.023227734491229057,
-0.38687726855278015,
-0.3254794180393219,
0.12156520783901215,
0.021020635962486267,
0.5130718946456909,
0.868659496307373,
-0.7463222742080688,
-0.39217257499694824,
-0.3453194200992584,
-0.2542530298233032,
-0.17840421199798584,
-0.17186476290225983,
0.290911465883255,
-0.0001690307108219713,
0.7751705646514893,
-0.6075539588928223,
0.8499414324760437,
0.46058186888694763,
-0.003685809439048171,
0.7948750853538513,
-0.24382971227169037,
0.11169255524873734,
-0.72965008020401,
0.01311501394957304,
0.12356627732515335,
0.14605364203453064,
-1.1131972074508667,
0.07220017910003662,
-0.1619732528924942,
0.10473275929689407,
-0.6030009388923645,
-0.12017274647951126,
-0.37101995944976807,
-0.11079620569944382,
-0.29281798005104065,
0.11547283083200455,
-0.36753368377685547,
0.1432221680879593,
0.019650114700198174,
0.6338247060775757,
0.8218742609024048,
-0.6406497359275818,
0.3889809250831604,
-0.001170217408798635,
-0.3578323721885681,
0.7228462100028992,
-0.5162114500999451,
0.29830560088157654,
0.033642448484897614,
0.4320024251937866,
-1.1833359003067017,
-0.1397533416748047,
0.4367204010486603,
-0.48155835270881653,
0.3541259467601776,
-0.5404611229896545,
-0.7286666035652161,
-0.1652928590774536,
-0.15723983943462372,
0.8165730834007263,
0.04083786532282829,
-0.2868298590183258,
0.5026743412017822,
0.7728158831596375,
0.06958482414484024,
-0.21211017668247223,
-0.4224144220352173,
0.01437581330537796,
-0.751506507396698,
0.009190712124109268,
0.6155459880828857,
-0.1767565757036209,
-0.24945621192455292,
-0.2608242928981781,
-0.3872707188129425,
-0.35377997159957886,
0.07362663745880127,
0.4118708670139313,
0.02228255569934845,
0.08675366640090942,
-0.7394804954528809,
-0.21708668768405914,
-0.11174625903367996,
-0.0220519807189703,
0.08528827875852585,
0.34969574213027954,
0.13449011743068695,
-0.5671384334564209,
-0.780182421207428,
0.6575304865837097,
0.5611248016357422,
-0.21319390833377838,
0.43054330348968506,
0.30378401279449463,
-0.5910738110542297,
-0.13374635577201843,
-0.6488391757011414,
-0.10867124795913696,
-0.4824528992176056,
0.23697906732559204,
-0.43989086151123047,
-0.31188201904296875,
0.7370718121528625,
-0.10527799278497696,
-0.07824509590864182,
-0.035569928586483,
0.22964951395988464,
-0.11232086271047592,
0.8845663666725159,
0.6564357280731201,
-0.022906992584466934,
0.3813115656375885,
-0.13503284752368927,
0.40676170587539673,
-0.3095480501651764,
-0.5271845459938049,
-0.8186649680137634,
-0.07014866918325424,
-0.48573946952819824,
-0.45901015400886536,
0.4327569007873535,
0.13725775480270386,
0.10391383618116379,
0.6524083018302917,
-0.3082263469696045,
0.6830891966819763,
1.0159690380096436,
0.18527929484844208,
-0.10206899791955948,
0.25945502519607544,
-0.08649599552154541,
0.06304662674665451,
-0.5784204602241516,
0.03721659630537033,
0.3772708475589752,
0.5429773926734924,
0.23541593551635742,
0.07340767234563828,
0.7781924605369568,
0.4776066541671753,
-0.2250169813632965,
-0.932017982006073,
0.6511427760124207,
0.013866616412997246,
-0.8668034672737122,
-0.22258305549621582,
-0.25648343563079834,
-0.6709118485450745,
-0.2400512397289276,
0.0552627369761467,
-0.9683812856674194,
0.27196648716926575,
0.1842547357082367,
-0.4431510865688324,
0.3680516481399536,
-0.7985181212425232,
0.5269168615341187,
0.07566229999065399,
0.1564520001411438,
-0.22723622620105743,
-0.8665645122528076,
0.21181215345859528,
-0.25493109226226807,
0.6282250285148621,
-0.03747476637363434,
0.41162529587745667,
1.0960278511047363,
-0.07911164313554764,
1.0631948709487915,
-0.6290452480316162,
-0.012341459281742573,
0.48025670647621155,
0.4214465916156769,
0.2812862992286682,
-0.33498039841651917,
0.052296463400125504,
0.379509836435318,
0.7971047759056091,
-0.6902362704277039,
-0.2711266577243805,
0.26938971877098083,
-0.6749240756034851,
-0.3917655944824219,
-0.36000698804855347,
-0.016332479193806648,
-0.3409598767757416,
0.2685677409172058,
0.5026412010192871,
0.23398500680923462,
-0.104673370718956,
-0.16389958560466766,
0.7672542929649353,
-0.2611793577671051,
0.4449184536933899,
0.787296712398529,
0.18759925663471222,
-0.48354631662368774,
1.1787160634994507,
-0.011837901547551155,
0.31415483355522156,
0.3159027099609375,
-0.01918766088783741,
0.06478976458311081,
-0.8364309072494507,
-0.17257094383239746,
0.360640287399292,
-0.4630699157714844,
-0.00449345912784338,
-0.19819727540016174,
-0.33453676104545593,
-0.21409855782985687,
0.32366466522216797,
-0.774080216884613,
-0.1324567347764969,
-0.027560371905565262,
-0.12655109167099,
-0.021970653906464577,
0.6737614274024963,
-0.3788864314556122,
0.72027587890625,
-0.4635045826435089,
0.2880004048347473,
0.0669422373175621,
0.35028842091560364,
-0.07157768309116364,
-0.6888189911842346,
-0.49042245745658875,
-0.03542306274175644,
-0.07511894404888153,
-1.242793321609497,
-0.030338894575834274,
0.09938777983188629,
0.942119836807251,
0.6178991198539734,
0.16552793979644775,
0.6645394563674927,
-0.5589562654495239,
0.8833522200584412,
0.07462339848279953,
-1.1057604551315308,
0.5640454888343811,
-0.363430917263031,
-0.07600891590118408,
0.586703896522522,
0.05935826525092125,
-0.4658220410346985,
-0.5914890766143799,
-0.6164517998695374,
-1.1676760911941528,
0.9931254386901855,
0.26200389862060547,
0.11210516840219498,
-0.14204344153404236,
0.17902430891990662,
-0.1621060073375702,
0.16412025690078735,
-0.44964084029197693,
-0.5495836734771729,
-0.3699488639831543,
0.2294250726699829,
-0.01779267005622387,
-0.5736886262893677,
-0.3915560841560364,
-0.48205551505088806,
0.70412278175354,
0.3535584509372711,
0.5948321223258972,
0.21538500487804413,
0.037861503660678864,
-0.15531297028064728,
-0.18287816643714905,
0.8764764070510864,
0.36717385053634644,
-0.4992124140262604,
0.4839690029621124,
0.47550633549690247,
-0.6783159375190735,
0.2114599347114563,
-0.01738779805600643,
0.03503899276256561,
0.2870761454105377,
0.3163599967956543,
0.5265522003173828,
0.3032101094722748,
-0.395912230014801,
0.7257484793663025,
-0.031465474516153336,
-0.29162919521331787,
-0.3777649700641632,
-0.12173373997211456,
-0.1263967752456665,
0.04680400714278221,
0.5715668201446533,
0.027186676859855652,
0.13276275992393494,
-0.30330538749694824,
0.47672322392463684,
0.25606298446655273,
-0.3293610215187073,
-0.6625939011573792,
0.46009111404418945,
-0.012060766108334064,
-0.3294634521007538,
0.14847330749034882,
-0.43335267901420593,
-0.7531152963638306,
0.7436285614967346,
0.7522444128990173,
0.5976616144180298,
-0.8402433395385742,
0.3381927013397217,
0.23106583952903748,
0.3769253194332123,
-0.31205135583877563,
0.12331119179725647,
-0.4051733613014221,
-0.6232654452323914,
-0.25613757967948914,
-0.42488574981689453,
-0.49785420298576355,
0.2607402205467224,
-0.8852517008781433,
0.17937573790550232,
-0.5630307197570801,
-0.2281753420829773,
0.04240339994430542,
-0.18925264477729797,
-0.0802554339170456,
0.20680353045463562,
0.12462536990642548,
1.0010666847229004,
-1.0853053331375122,
0.8011242747306824,
0.9881376624107361,
0.14435552060604095,
-0.6419118046760559,
0.3440329134464264,
0.28285208344459534,
-0.361895889043808,
-0.26872026920318604,
-0.15392033755779266,
-0.35938337445259094,
-0.03448475897312164,
-0.5012348294258118,
-0.73004549741745,
0.5871630907058716,
0.15772801637649536,
-0.3573375642299652,
0.15124836564064026,
0.1722276210784912,
0.46113693714141846,
0.22708940505981445,
0.03501632437109947,
0.9387817978858948,
0.2550825774669647,
0.21124167740345,
-1.302501916885376,
-0.22736677527427673,
-0.340922474861145,
-0.3900667428970337,
-0.0020740267354995012,
-0.7109056115150452,
0.2921120524406433,
0.018167590722441673,
-0.2579166889190674,
0.2139061540365219,
0.3036949932575226,
0.39034000039100647,
1.0294088125228882,
0.7849032282829285,
0.5765043497085571,
0.6730782985687256,
0.051716167479753494,
0.5836968421936035,
-0.22531317174434662,
0.283184289932251,
1.110351324081421,
-0.20171470940113068,
0.6896709203720093,
0.5893245339393616,
-0.42536166310310364,
0.06257422268390656,
0.8942074179649353,
0.0978366956114769,
0.907118558883667,
0.1055571436882019,
-0.603110671043396,
-0.0978441834449768,
0.18852044641971588,
-0.49979665875434875,
0.6815613508224487,
0.46560177206993103,
0.27340295910835266,
-0.13282492756843567,
0.14107979834079742,
0.024236613884568214,
-0.06137875095009804,
0.05687316507101059,
0.8690137267112732,
-0.23552222549915314,
-0.22329281270503998,
0.21698151528835297,
0.18298478424549103,
0.5629792809486389,
-0.49646082520484924,
0.15094226598739624,
-0.5159562826156616,
-0.106806680560112,
-0.3634742498397827,
-0.14082413911819458,
0.4747583866119385,
-0.18778781592845917,
-0.5306389331817627,
0.025841403752565384,
0.21223877370357513,
-0.16499777138233185,
-0.07820271700620651,
0.4078589975833893,
0.11970115453004837,
0.4647960066795349,
-0.135493665933609,
-0.37834057211875916,
0.20751546323299408,
-0.03170431777834892,
0.22608916461467743,
0.4649563431739807,
0.6230117678642273,
0.047654733061790466,
0.34718528389930725,
0.3837020695209503,
0.5968488454818726,
0.13672715425491333,
-0.06080855801701546,
0.29104477167129517,
-0.4713870882987976,
-0.8789077401161194,
-0.7708293199539185,
0.035595618188381195,
0.1582348644733429,
0.24349169433116913,
1.078743577003479,
0.8620713353157043,
0.8185900449752808,
-0.00765511067584157,
0.5817711353302002,
-0.1509505808353424,
1.0512279272079468,
-0.05847402662038803,
0.6752134561538696,
-0.5100404024124146,
0.8147229552268982,
-0.7672144770622253,
-0.5473673939704895,
-0.26807117462158203,
0.36884546279907227,
-0.22003091871738434,
-0.3005969822406769,
0.5556699633598328,
0.8729441165924072,
-0.4829649031162262,
0.1348431408405304,
0.2819977402687073,
0.044620055705308914,
0.17805370688438416,
0.13233277201652527,
1.1420371532440186,
-0.2395390123128891,
0.5087777376174927,
-0.5797041654586792,
-0.4527879059314728,
-0.07570625841617584,
-0.5145070552825928,
-0.6100446581840515,
-0.8040422797203064,
-0.7163028120994568,
-0.6244828104972839,
-0.09113748371601105,
0.38763895630836487,
1.0045757293701172,
-1.0551079511642456,
-0.3467058837413788,
-0.0147237628698349,
0.21420617401599884,
-0.5912964344024658,
-0.2521578371524811,
0.36149168014526367,
0.2777933180332184,
-0.6015226244926453,
0.8743183016777039,
0.1483340859413147,
0.4452245235443115,
0.11056125164031982,
0.2913251221179962,
-0.1439281851053238,
0.4261576235294342,
0.24149714410305023,
0.5544794201850891,
-0.5819625854492188,
-0.3420465588569641,
-0.2907567620277405,
0.09855638444423676,
-0.09605743736028671,
0.8166764378547668,
-0.5110569000244141,
0.46485063433647156,
0.15721829235553741,
0.10563138872385025,
0.47662553191185,
0.1867137998342514,
-0.03997277468442917,
-1.171060562133789,
0.5151804089546204,
-0.05152484402060509,
-0.07011669874191284,
0.1438438892364502,
-0.14807142317295074,
-0.09479755908250809,
0.823139488697052,
-0.3358196020126343,
-1.349062204360962,
0.010647502727806568,
-1.1090642213821411,
-0.23489201068878174,
1.03230881690979,
-0.21800543367862701,
-0.0971827283501625,
-0.3654748499393463,
-0.31486058235168457,
0.3867183327674866,
-0.08089134097099304,
1.1695377826690674,
0.6480810642242432,
-0.04677208513021469,
0.1457291692495346,
-0.6759920120239258,
0.7572516798973083,
0.3643879294395447,
-0.4052918553352356,
-0.301014244556427,
0.22446151077747345,
0.5940975546836853,
0.4840894043445587,
0.7912147045135498,
-0.06881275773048401,
0.6370671987533569,
0.1895332783460617,
-0.15332460403442383,
0.2731618881225586,
-0.716448187828064,
-0.04126274958252907,
0.3255861699581146,
-0.16585291922092438,
-0.800738513469696
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.07815v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.07815v1
|
Are Large Language Models Good Statisticians?
| 2024-06-12T02:23:51 | 2024-06-12T02:23:51 |
Yizhang Zhu, Shiyin Du, Boyan Li, Yuyu Luo, Nan Tang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated impressive capabilities across
a range of scientific tasks including mathematics, physics, and chemistry.
Despite their successes, the effectiveness of LLMs in handling complex
statistical tasks remains systematically under-explored. To bridge this gap, we
introduce StatQA, a new benchmark designed for statistical analysis tasks.
StatQA comprises 11,623 examples tailored to evaluate LLMs' proficiency in
specialized statistical tasks and their applicability assessment capabilities,
particularly for hypothesis testing methods. We systematically experiment with
representative LLMs using various prompting strategies and show that even
state-of-the-art models such as GPT-4o achieve a best performance of only
64.83%, indicating significant room for improvement. Notably, while open-source
LLMs (e.g. LLaMA-3) show limited capability, those fine-tuned ones exhibit
marked improvements, outperforming all in-context learning-based methods (e.g.
GPT-4o). Moreover, our comparative human experiments highlight a striking
contrast in error types between LLMs and humans: LLMs primarily make
applicability errors, whereas humans mostly make statistical task confusion
errors. This divergence highlights distinct areas of proficiency and
deficiency, suggesting that combining LLM and human expertise could lead to
complementary strengths, inviting further investigation into their
collaborative potential.
|
[
-0.10620439052581787,
-0.5208320021629333,
0.7960379123687744,
0.2749536633491516,
0.03034854121506214,
0.34639978408813477,
-0.49498602747917175,
-0.25507891178131104,
0.020690280944108963,
0.19529028236865997,
-0.2741067111492157,
-0.5991487503051758,
-0.6058666706085205,
0.3949202001094818,
-0.4580784738063812,
0.7960438132286072,
-0.09625058621168137,
0.5354819297790527,
-0.3625001907348633,
-0.06490637362003326,
-0.5404273867607117,
-0.6363959312438965,
-0.6719014048576355,
-0.21576380729675293,
0.6682201027870178,
0.3278810679912567,
0.5787204504013062,
0.19690169394016266,
0.6390843391418457,
0.28165990114212036,
0.012099649757146835,
0.21177607774734497,
-0.5263088941574097,
0.15059737861156464,
-0.20459498465061188,
-0.8602345585823059,
-0.6604018211364746,
0.033699292689561844,
0.7525165677070618,
0.9498873353004456,
-0.1429961621761322,
0.2870980501174927,
0.10229016840457916,
0.6587705612182617,
-0.4388355612754822,
0.5016177892684937,
-0.5147913694381714,
-0.1850910633802414,
-0.31495457887649536,
-0.07944280654191971,
-0.3996981978416443,
-0.7248272895812988,
0.01728648506104946,
-0.5985742211341858,
0.34974682331085205,
0.11975213885307312,
0.46327507495880127,
0.44004353880882263,
-0.47231513261795044,
-0.03889217600226402,
-0.44943487644195557,
1.1274540424346924,
-0.7311651706695557,
0.48392751812934875,
0.4447647035121918,
0.41813966631889343,
-0.7088853120803833,
-0.34959104657173157,
-0.4662295877933502,
-0.44632360339164734,
0.28783145546913147,
0.1003037616610527,
-0.27780136466026306,
-0.13985931873321533,
0.3563019633293152,
0.0614449605345726,
-0.5818021893501282,
0.3363458514213562,
-0.40091609954833984,
-0.33166125416755676,
0.6890580058097839,
0.2641533315181732,
0.3602469861507416,
0.07335923612117767,
0.09969507157802582,
-0.20020781457424164,
-0.7993333339691162,
-0.002571254735812545,
0.26378166675567627,
0.4504029154777527,
-0.26689863204956055,
0.7698079943656921,
-0.3960684537887573,
0.47149792313575745,
-0.5086826086044312,
-0.16686932742595673,
0.22036965191364288,
-0.18631716072559357,
-0.09917157888412476,
-0.1984596997499466,
0.7528889179229736,
0.06612890958786011,
0.6381298899650574,
-0.0896657407283783,
-0.02539682574570179,
0.02189183235168457,
0.1800064891576767,
-0.6111449003219604,
-0.44342681765556335,
0.3308357000350952,
-0.25273144245147705,
-0.028751054778695107,
-0.2607325613498688,
-0.7025666236877441,
-0.43861812353134155,
-0.24276021122932434,
0.36383256316185,
-0.41327762603759766,
-0.08718245476484299,
0.083552286028862,
-0.008333063684403896,
-0.07389899343252182,
0.5069935321807861,
-0.7755952477455139,
0.45576703548431396,
0.8921900391578674,
0.8072823882102966,
-0.5365684032440186,
-0.45551711320877075,
-0.49404069781303406,
-0.22031404078006744,
-0.8297329545021057,
0.777252197265625,
-0.15219886600971222,
-0.1987399011850357,
-0.09723703563213348,
-0.18143324553966522,
-0.01944343000650406,
-0.6053537130355835,
0.7177785634994507,
-0.5192835927009583,
-0.12148153781890869,
-0.591598629951477,
-0.6097530126571655,
-0.1651674509048462,
0.019111735746264458,
-0.6789571046829224,
0.9032036662101746,
0.1410873681306839,
-0.467507928609848,
0.7789337038993835,
-0.369549036026001,
-0.1655733734369278,
0.1648738533258438,
-0.30909278988838196,
-0.32100483775138855,
0.09107312560081482,
-0.06230480223894119,
0.6110595464706421,
-0.7609172463417053,
0.3704029619693756,
-0.5640320777893066,
-0.4809800684452057,
0.738978385925293,
-0.603222668170929,
0.7426599264144897,
0.1446831077337265,
-0.10526051372289658,
0.06976824253797531,
-0.5699962377548218,
0.16275078058242798,
-0.002907573012635112,
-0.39887934923171997,
-0.24130438268184662,
0.14954262971878052,
-0.2286386638879776,
-0.21208389103412628,
0.08540405333042145,
-0.3719578981399536,
-0.002588240895420313,
-0.16449224948883057,
0.23810100555419922,
0.6975082159042358,
-0.2293403595685959,
0.16787897050380707,
-0.4047306180000305,
0.5397917628288269,
-0.3522617518901825,
-0.22286178171634674,
0.3042774200439453,
-0.5422605276107788,
-0.4192589521408081,
-0.786568284034729,
0.487077921628952,
0.4782085418701172,
-0.6221224069595337,
0.3057537078857422,
-0.24026502668857574,
-0.6383435130119324,
-0.08032502233982086,
0.35627084970474243,
0.3205163776874542,
0.37013930082321167,
0.24194352328777313,
-0.3684319853782654,
-0.3641938865184784,
-0.8832281827926636,
-0.47066378593444824,
-0.3744213581085205,
-0.21995320916175842,
-0.03864425793290138,
0.6337408423423767,
0.13134993612766266,
0.8364273309707642,
-0.40986037254333496,
-0.006540186703205109,
-0.2799259424209595,
0.07649660110473633,
0.36814048886299133,
0.12497692555189133,
0.5995502471923828,
-0.528377890586853,
-0.3698856830596924,
-0.10963472723960876,
-1.0078233480453491,
-0.20737521350383759,
0.42155829071998596,
-0.03586917743086815,
0.19515421986579895,
0.13478723168373108,
-0.6966350078582764,
0.14689041674137115,
0.41384056210517883,
-0.1823713630437851,
0.9468684792518616,
-0.30621451139450073,
0.3559345602989197,
-0.7018691301345825,
-0.010135619901120663,
0.24829837679862976,
-0.1386989802122116,
-0.8182368278503418,
-0.1646490842103958,
0.2500327527523041,
0.10384828597307205,
-0.4107690155506134,
0.6626458764076233,
-0.39981821179389954,
-0.3141356110572815,
-0.03574758768081665,
-0.3218494653701782,
-0.38706016540527344,
0.16808733344078064,
-0.02810203656554222,
0.8795444965362549,
0.6752420663833618,
-0.6906431317329407,
0.20233741402626038,
0.16305871307849884,
-0.5658450722694397,
0.6483654975891113,
-0.6165368556976318,
-0.3068535327911377,
-0.028972521424293518,
0.3519601821899414,
-1.0884896516799927,
-0.8058821558952332,
-0.0463603138923645,
-0.36471420526504517,
0.13835851848125458,
0.1783621460199356,
-0.6311545372009277,
-0.5372568368911743,
-0.23987162113189697,
0.499149888753891,
0.7506551146507263,
-0.385966032743454,
0.21792931854724884,
0.31116783618927,
-0.40746358036994934,
-0.6398004293441772,
-0.41798943281173706,
0.11252214014530182,
-0.5043448805809021,
-0.2704627513885498,
-0.19879791140556335,
-0.04877066612243652,
-0.5956817865371704,
-0.3737969398498535,
-0.06661682575941086,
-0.3339254558086395,
0.191049724817276,
-0.0007457766914740205,
0.4872433841228485,
-0.1822843849658966,
0.31792137026786804,
-0.30479031801223755,
0.02833363227546215,
0.19745387136936188,
0.17413416504859924,
0.3385251760482788,
-0.014980229549109936,
-0.5615882873535156,
-0.4819265604019165,
0.0313425213098526,
0.48916345834732056,
-0.03916071727871895,
0.5536760687828064,
0.3280384838581085,
-0.2986023724079132,
-0.3225167989730835,
-0.6491307616233826,
-0.22585429251194,
-0.3990498483181,
0.6561591029167175,
-0.44489890336990356,
-0.8951366543769836,
0.4767884612083435,
0.07832314819097519,
0.09419746696949005,
0.2697393298149109,
0.5974647402763367,
-0.239089697599411,
1.0260077714920044,
0.4114394783973694,
-0.14756393432617188,
0.06177627667784691,
0.08900048583745956,
0.07498650252819061,
-0.5202692747116089,
0.12214972078800201,
-0.6422650814056396,
0.11488353461027145,
-0.41711530089378357,
-0.7107652425765991,
0.5594715476036072,
0.09543999284505844,
-0.5639134049415588,
0.034391652792692184,
-0.14087603986263275,
0.4234466552734375,
0.3393716812133789,
0.06058298051357269,
0.3267127573490143,
0.10743900388479233,
0.2496132254600525,
-0.27147457003593445,
-0.769892692565918,
-0.5773082375526428,
1.3716139793395996,
0.5529798269271851,
0.9735175371170044,
0.25893598794937134,
0.5753116607666016,
0.3260018527507782,
0.567955732345581,
-0.8445507287979126,
0.6197924017906189,
-0.2905210554599762,
-0.5333558917045593,
-0.5570060610771179,
-0.7987373471260071,
-0.7936133146286011,
0.311079740524292,
-0.20278184115886688,
-0.8662441968917847,
-0.06002577766776085,
0.23072177171707153,
-0.18310874700546265,
0.23400795459747314,
-0.6602751016616821,
0.6590403914451599,
-0.340313196182251,
-0.32964450120925903,
-0.1392965018749237,
-0.06150558218359947,
0.6153243184089661,
-0.4808328449726105,
0.4152613580226898,
-0.5131019949913025,
-0.19602559506893158,
0.7854213714599609,
-0.21843388676643372,
0.9346367716789246,
-0.0563495047390461,
-0.33983907103538513,
0.18303029239177704,
0.2846362590789795,
0.3171391189098358,
-0.09637320041656494,
-0.3841318190097809,
0.3071610629558563,
0.15233756601810455,
-0.6477261781692505,
-0.5537527203559875,
0.49505987763404846,
-0.6555376648902893,
-0.6210904717445374,
-0.45698124170303345,
-0.6701396703720093,
-0.5128061771392822,
0.12422432005405426,
-0.07604137063026428,
0.39232420921325684,
-0.4068432152271271,
0.18293313682079315,
0.7797242403030396,
-0.24494877457618713,
0.0750882476568222,
0.5686728954315186,
0.08248743414878845,
-0.1473539173603058,
1.0322797298431396,
0.04177771881222725,
0.34153130650520325,
0.2516753375530243,
0.31628015637397766,
-0.43303945660591125,
-0.5841929912567139,
-0.483220636844635,
0.2942981719970703,
-0.7060121893882751,
-0.14778167009353638,
-0.5256580710411072,
0.04753151163458824,
-0.30369535088539124,
0.058236636221408844,
-0.3354039490222931,
-0.2726328670978546,
-0.08076304942369461,
0.16607268154621124,
0.4447008967399597,
0.7171757221221924,
-0.04729988053441048,
-0.07340099662542343,
-0.5752757787704468,
0.33261290192604065,
0.33278971910476685,
0.2427522987127304,
0.19495686888694763,
-0.3598673641681671,
-0.08289143443107605,
-0.06434331834316254,
0.01591886766254902,
-0.7464807629585266,
0.3390811085700989,
0.08656864613294601,
0.8166855573654175,
0.012229260057210922,
-0.01010540034621954,
0.4008180797100067,
-0.5150482654571533,
0.7802767753601074,
0.28477799892425537,
-0.8078967928886414,
-0.030780617147684097,
-0.5713095664978027,
0.26589545607566833,
0.3860917389392853,
0.619159460067749,
-0.24224834144115448,
-0.4935203194618225,
-0.055482473224401474,
-0.5612413287162781,
0.5589969754219055,
0.17276829481124878,
-0.10692354291677475,
-0.05300583317875862,
0.26269015669822693,
0.1576690524816513,
0.22315244376659393,
-0.43122413754463196,
0.012022261507809162,
0.13393233716487885,
-0.40765222907066345,
-0.4326937198638916,
-0.094564288854599,
-0.2994750440120697,
-0.1690397560596466,
0.5295974016189575,
-0.4257672429084778,
0.08538579940795898,
-0.011869745329022408,
0.07460439205169678,
-0.08769476413726807,
0.4723483622074127,
0.40281420946121216,
1.1157128810882568,
-0.11884758621454239,
0.1790495663881302,
0.7358572483062744,
-0.5486755967140198,
0.3690316379070282,
0.044676799327135086,
0.18970444798469543,
-0.32042255997657776,
0.6408084034919739,
0.2597334384918213,
0.37238913774490356,
-0.9810305237770081,
0.3421969413757324,
-0.21014386415481567,
-0.3640304505825043,
-0.28386741876602173,
0.3098743259906769,
0.14701105654239655,
0.24212636053562164,
0.6427267789840698,
-0.24006208777427673,
0.12326066195964813,
-0.7419448494911194,
0.044586531817913055,
0.586325466632843,
-0.22009165585041046,
-0.3091074228286743,
0.7129559516906738,
-0.05661880597472191,
-0.12618902325630188,
0.08692260831594467,
-0.13043402135372162,
-0.5422557592391968,
0.8664177656173706,
0.39452946186065674,
0.5437168478965759,
-0.12933652102947235,
0.3971773386001587,
0.3627496659755707,
0.1553647667169571,
-0.4883227050304413,
0.5374001860618591,
0.08769916743040085,
-0.7285584807395935,
-0.5280721187591553,
-0.5944538116455078,
-0.8210881948471069,
-0.12373461574316025,
-0.5793391466140747,
0.17112918198108673,
-0.0940653383731842,
-0.13089744746685028,
0.12488128244876862,
0.09872176498174667,
-0.9047749638557434,
0.24433010816574097,
-0.20689167082309723,
0.8413116335868835,
-0.8373357057571411,
0.7102063894271851,
0.6816002726554871,
-0.18101933598518372,
-0.8380013108253479,
-0.029025381430983543,
0.20610816776752472,
-0.6154475808143616,
0.9565743803977966,
-0.12179400026798248,
0.10418400913476944,
-0.2524334788322449,
-0.4331509470939636,
-0.9419445395469666,
0.9744112491607666,
0.4648655652999878,
-0.6072983145713806,
0.19514955580234528,
0.2066766917705536,
0.8294352889060974,
-0.10060130804777145,
0.5709626078605652,
0.7129456996917725,
0.4033806025981903,
-0.17976699769496918,
-1.105124592781067,
0.21926666796207428,
0.2286192923784256,
-0.08796289563179016,
0.08729444444179535,
-0.8482555150985718,
1.0223379135131836,
-0.21407288312911987,
-0.07250623404979706,
0.39839234948158264,
0.7091805934906006,
0.6822777986526489,
0.3769760727882385,
0.5074117183685303,
0.15997296571731567,
1.071751594543457,
-0.0770622119307518,
1.087120771408081,
-0.06588345766067505,
0.08260755240917206,
0.9838871359825134,
-0.6418926119804382,
0.9619441628456116,
0.23627525568008423,
-0.7012648582458496,
0.22722980380058289,
0.6078181862831116,
0.14803887903690338,
0.13836941123008728,
0.4892324209213257,
-0.24295079708099365,
-0.3749328851699829,
0.1184627041220665,
-0.20992007851600647,
0.2829779386520386,
0.3068971037864685,
-0.0013447877718135715,
-0.1059311032295227,
-0.20183250308036804,
-0.057104118168354034,
0.09583869576454163,
-0.24574001133441925,
0.3859964609146118,
0.29827192425727844,
-0.6670945286750793,
0.5904937982559204,
-0.3724881410598755,
0.5068193078041077,
-0.6941208243370056,
-0.19613219797611237,
-0.10023754835128784,
0.05764545127749443,
-0.1606975495815277,
-0.9758684039115906,
-0.003655010834336281,
0.23180827498435974,
0.018959838896989822,
0.2644718587398529,
0.5481813549995422,
-0.2315206527709961,
-0.4279988706111908,
0.15130926668643951,
0.7467581033706665,
0.5466113090515137,
0.1619846075773239,
-0.3418773114681244,
0.013550681993365288,
-0.12362521886825562,
-0.09049833565950394,
0.3965184986591339,
0.3211747705936432,
-0.45092830061912537,
0.8850424885749817,
0.7104783654212952,
0.48522645235061646,
-0.12725846469402313,
0.2851584851741791,
0.553383469581604,
-0.687213122844696,
-0.2934888005256653,
-0.7906929850578308,
0.14131470024585724,
-0.0018286264967173338,
-0.25755637884140015,
1.0752629041671753,
0.47597503662109375,
0.5622683167457581,
-0.08008929342031479,
0.8750795125961304,
0.13782885670661926,
0.7705650329589844,
-0.5434813499450684,
0.6472911238670349,
-0.5126275420188904,
0.2543979287147522,
-0.2705424427986145,
-1.1181763410568237,
-0.2654302716255188,
0.27795830368995667,
-0.469206303358078,
0.07598619908094406,
0.6792129874229431,
0.5956669449806213,
-0.03293437510728836,
0.029775748029351234,
0.5669658184051514,
0.14170750975608826,
0.3711938261985779,
0.389157772064209,
0.9647772908210754,
0.03388003259897232,
0.2734285891056061,
0.0450727641582489,
-0.5075053572654724,
-0.034916698932647705,
-0.6462129354476929,
-1.2095226049423218,
-0.3624902367591858,
-0.08816210180521011,
-0.12444129586219788,
0.26085901260375977,
0.9029630422592163,
0.6502385139465332,
-0.8289117217063904,
-0.5675694346427917,
0.006257172208279371,
0.08804132044315338,
-0.2025402933359146,
-0.20280976593494415,
0.32551610469818115,
-0.3209543228149414,
-0.8057588338851929,
0.5299434065818787,
-0.05459171533584595,
-0.030241601169109344,
-0.5216888189315796,
-0.03835322707891464,
0.2915351092815399,
0.0776333212852478,
0.5380539298057556,
0.3770175576210022,
-0.6531702280044556,
-0.23907801508903503,
-0.17676343023777008,
-0.10756298899650574,
-0.24036404490470886,
0.6910032033920288,
-0.4646797478199005,
0.21681225299835205,
0.6792805194854736,
0.6783685088157654,
0.1324021816253662,
0.04998008534312248,
0.7823988199234009,
-0.3223955035209656,
-0.09440522640943527,
0.16049562394618988,
0.4266124963760376,
0.3294140100479126,
-0.18880949914455414,
0.6921512484550476,
-0.09373325109481812,
-0.8263634443283081,
-1.0555146932601929,
0.029073188081383705,
-0.7337381839752197,
-0.22331050038337708,
1.078214406967163,
-0.07305645942687988,
-0.31949448585510254,
-0.2699379622936249,
-0.05122809484601021,
0.04392161965370178,
-0.5583047866821289,
0.8586925268173218,
0.8147767782211304,
-0.34505659341812134,
0.13504184782505035,
-1.1886529922485352,
0.6527207493782043,
0.7702547311782837,
-0.9505970478057861,
0.13466231524944305,
0.37135815620422363,
0.5213201642036438,
-0.04218308627605438,
0.8008708357810974,
0.12105488777160645,
0.486253023147583,
-0.03213322535157204,
0.11442003399133682,
0.3994632363319397,
-0.3550843894481659,
-0.3284342288970947,
-0.1484273076057434,
0.36698830127716064,
0.3281664550304413
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.07814v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.07814v1
|
Collective Constitutional AI: Aligning a Language Model with Public Input
| 2024-06-12T02:20:46 | 2024-06-12T02:20:46 |
Saffron Huang, Divya Siddarth, Liane Lovitt, Thomas I. Liao, Esin Durmus, Alex Tamkin, Deep Ganguli
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.HC, I.2.7; K.4.2
|
There is growing consensus that language model (LM) developers should not be
the sole deciders of LM behavior, creating a need for methods that enable the
broader public to collectively shape the behavior of LM systems that affect
them. To address this need, we present Collective Constitutional AI (CCAI): a
multi-stage process for sourcing and integrating public input into LMs-from
identifying a target population to sourcing principles to training and
evaluating a model. We demonstrate the real-world practicality of this approach
by creating what is, to our knowledge, the first LM fine-tuned with
collectively sourced public input and evaluating this model against a baseline
model trained with established principles from a LM developer. Our quantitative
evaluations demonstrate several benefits of our approach: the CCAI-trained
model shows lower bias across nine social dimensions compared to the baseline
model, while maintaining equivalent performance on language, math, and
helpful-harmless evaluations. Qualitative comparisons of the models suggest
that the models differ on the basis of their respective constitutions, e.g.,
when prompted with contentious topics, the CCAI-trained model tends to generate
responses that reframe the matter positively instead of a refusal. These
results demonstrate a promising, tractable pathway toward publicly informed
development of language models.
|
[
-0.3605731129646301,
-0.45984283089637756,
0.59906005859375,
0.09780443459749222,
-0.15433742105960846,
0.11431694030761719,
-0.44376876950263977,
-0.26300346851348877,
0.08387020230293274,
0.7214733362197876,
-0.3159329295158386,
-0.1604108065366745,
-0.5138636231422424,
0.022184917703270912,
-0.4210450351238251,
0.8081634640693665,
0.37654006481170654,
0.3148142695426941,
-0.15563149750232697,
-0.17354974150657654,
-0.42635050415992737,
-0.7193018794059753,
-0.6860187649726868,
-0.4040892720222473,
0.6599709391593933,
0.4925188720226288,
0.7383086085319519,
0.6642570495605469,
0.3256959617137909,
0.3461597263813019,
-0.02501392737030983,
-0.011667132377624512,
-0.7937992215156555,
-0.39159196615219116,
-0.16409699618816376,
-0.5605233311653137,
-0.053028177469968796,
0.35623615980148315,
0.5178345441818237,
0.6282210350036621,
-0.39072275161743164,
0.19001728296279907,
-0.08912654221057892,
0.8310210704803467,
-0.7070930600166321,
0.2421862632036209,
-0.9251643419265747,
-0.20036165416240692,
-0.2659449279308319,
0.23940500617027283,
-0.42435353994369507,
-0.6179940700531006,
0.17935670912265778,
-0.6073207259178162,
-0.04150901362299919,
-0.09540048241615295,
0.6221143007278442,
0.2593793570995331,
-0.39319685101509094,
-0.13154415786266327,
-0.8184579014778137,
0.7955543398857117,
-0.8298897743225098,
0.45913541316986084,
0.449720174074173,
0.23910163342952728,
-0.23938211798667908,
-0.5891258120536804,
-1.0688667297363281,
-0.4484086036682129,
-0.12110323458909988,
0.22229120135307312,
0.19526831805706024,
0.19445447623729706,
-0.017649875953793526,
0.17728324234485626,
-0.3402949869632721,
0.27395209670066833,
-0.7751480340957642,
-0.11286015063524246,
0.7463266849517822,
0.08789822459220886,
0.2751591205596924,
-0.08965076506137848,
0.1432434320449829,
0.116109199821949,
-0.6254898309707642,
0.12059246003627777,
0.4987390637397766,
0.8315314650535583,
-0.2646414637565613,
0.6987568140029907,
-0.14572001993656158,
0.5914518237113953,
0.43416139483451843,
0.2930154800415039,
-0.34544840455055237,
-0.47865593433380127,
-0.17766985297203064,
0.052249956876039505,
0.9327341914176941,
-0.0035554999485611916,
0.32322660088539124,
-0.14414094388484955,
-0.22046515345573425,
0.46656063199043274,
0.628007173538208,
-0.48006466031074524,
0.013142768293619156,
0.4389305114746094,
-0.3897392451763153,
-0.6983096599578857,
0.23925234377384186,
-0.5293540954589844,
-0.9044398665428162,
-0.8854243755340576,
0.01032395102083683,
-0.036112792789936066,
-0.2126891165971756,
-0.16461637616157532,
-0.0659443810582161,
0.483625590801239,
0.24633653461933136,
-1.116589903831482,
0.36500468850135803,
1.2441076040267944,
0.8719736337661743,
-0.24561528861522675,
-0.2097165286540985,
-0.5506783723831177,
0.16174767911434174,
-0.5317372679710388,
0.69249427318573,
-0.8658599257469177,
-0.357592910528183,
0.22165101766586304,
-0.21342317759990692,
-0.02745683304965496,
-0.5349733829498291,
0.37318021059036255,
-0.4389313757419586,
0.2917667031288147,
-0.2952308654785156,
-0.48128294944763184,
0.23930394649505615,
0.2995743751525879,
-0.9999609589576721,
0.5131566524505615,
-0.2120026797056198,
-0.4497046172618866,
0.6713380813598633,
-0.9890162348747253,
-0.15599654614925385,
0.052938468754291534,
-0.540155291557312,
-0.36253470182418823,
0.13905809819698334,
0.3003602921962738,
0.2331819385290146,
-0.15678603947162628,
0.7098182439804077,
-0.623159646987915,
-0.2724584937095642,
0.3528462052345276,
-0.2750641107559204,
1.052832841873169,
0.24011805653572083,
0.010021897032856941,
0.4754062592983246,
-0.6727599501609802,
-0.30343297123908997,
-0.20126007497310638,
-0.563303530216217,
-0.15273228287696838,
0.31145694851875305,
-0.029386091977357864,
0.04591991752386093,
0.08980284631252289,
-0.376210480928421,
0.28479301929473877,
-0.5466728806495667,
0.6082454919815063,
1.0437101125717163,
-0.2397591471672058,
0.8192951083183289,
-0.5112181901931763,
0.24645644426345825,
-0.24054759740829468,
0.41387733817100525,
0.3726804852485657,
-0.35589760541915894,
-0.6691683530807495,
-0.036318060010671616,
0.30179139971733093,
0.5024749040603638,
-0.42463403940200806,
0.4743535816669464,
-0.13027043640613556,
-0.7251479029655457,
-0.5413051843643188,
0.029224395751953125,
0.09908218681812286,
0.10170801728963852,
0.013454638421535492,
-0.3493814766407013,
-0.39227744936943054,
-0.7055504322052002,
-0.3041187524795532,
-0.7334133386611938,
0.24847039580345154,
0.15410737693309784,
0.43454283475875854,
0.14130042493343353,
0.9883160591125488,
-0.033438101410865784,
-0.17281343042850494,
-0.39582374691963196,
0.4726209342479706,
0.16643060743808746,
0.3525746762752533,
0.37660273909568787,
-0.6732854247093201,
-0.16765685379505157,
0.23632366955280304,
-0.5331622362136841,
-0.1802021861076355,
-0.33559221029281616,
-0.3552440106868744,
-0.07716002315282822,
0.2653328478336334,
-0.48003360629081726,
0.38765108585357666,
0.6019091606140137,
-0.1455213576555252,
0.7074356079101562,
0.09706313163042068,
0.15571968257427216,
-1.3193610906600952,
0.22345659136772156,
-0.09423333406448364,
0.06093249097466469,
-0.7645291686058044,
0.37503260374069214,
-0.06413155049085617,
-0.373195081949234,
-0.5384583473205566,
0.37516894936561584,
-0.3188929855823517,
0.024616604670882225,
-0.28609248995780945,
0.2001742422580719,
-0.2334141880273819,
0.3816942274570465,
0.03748985007405281,
0.8596333861351013,
0.28019705414772034,
-0.745351254940033,
0.5857694745063782,
0.23696604371070862,
-0.42367449402809143,
0.65947425365448,
-0.8110993504524231,
0.48413267731666565,
-0.22948259115219116,
0.2681778073310852,
-0.54948890209198,
-0.31820860505104065,
0.33093729615211487,
-0.34822940826416016,
0.019827410578727722,
-0.1727180778980255,
-0.06214271858334541,
-0.27826160192489624,
-0.131408229470253,
0.3302604854106903,
-0.051773276180028915,
-0.2337242066860199,
0.6011041402816772,
0.9946921467781067,
-0.060307763516902924,
-0.5930063724517822,
-0.7885220646858215,
0.15717649459838867,
-0.17665095627307892,
-0.4061024487018585,
0.19822300970554352,
-0.05217088386416435,
-0.566261351108551,
-0.24036650359630585,
0.2434016466140747,
-0.5215592384338379,
0.19599291682243347,
0.26619869470596313,
0.1808500736951828,
-0.26164737343788147,
0.16591902077198029,
0.07056145370006561,
0.11263243108987808,
0.043652985244989395,
-0.2760072648525238,
0.45278236269950867,
0.12234152853488922,
-0.5437741875648499,
-0.8989936709403992,
0.36826008558273315,
0.8140895962715149,
-0.629938542842865,
0.778566837310791,
0.05478135123848915,
-0.46962982416152954,
0.10889662802219391,
-0.5598742365837097,
-0.01816624216735363,
-0.450091153383255,
0.13182112574577332,
0.1699371337890625,
-0.9715341925621033,
0.45418092608451843,
-0.12467578053474426,
0.41203126311302185,
0.20860138535499573,
0.6704192757606506,
0.2651243209838867,
0.8204305171966553,
0.7824943661689758,
-0.6754963397979736,
0.7819597125053406,
0.03312550485134125,
0.11473722755908966,
-0.4456808567047119,
-0.10305579751729965,
-1.0325531959533691,
-0.20484837889671326,
-0.5541142821311951,
-0.18655605614185333,
0.1506481021642685,
-0.012215244583785534,
-0.18942268192768097,
0.3471548557281494,
-0.48200225830078125,
0.7008799910545349,
0.539409875869751,
0.13287103176116943,
0.06704171746969223,
-0.3515486419200897,
-0.004766056314110756,
0.3595837652683258,
-0.3681197166442871,
-0.7374722361564636,
1.150037407875061,
-0.01847558654844761,
0.518223226070404,
0.3541480302810669,
0.9704098701477051,
0.3836687207221985,
0.5693569779396057,
-0.8133996725082397,
0.45130088925361633,
-0.12186506390571594,
-0.6889858245849609,
-0.750910758972168,
-0.3831883370876312,
-0.9068808555603027,
0.1394604742527008,
-0.5145135521888733,
-0.7378749847412109,
0.4104195237159729,
0.11417599022388458,
-0.7787842750549316,
0.059146832674741745,
-0.6768150329589844,
0.9497988224029541,
-0.197705939412117,
-0.26027992367744446,
-0.5437835454940796,
-0.3042648136615753,
0.4887220859527588,
-0.23004141449928284,
0.1896943747997284,
-0.11453721672296524,
0.18708883225917816,
0.5343220233917236,
-0.6534189581871033,
0.9576625227928162,
-0.14081571996212006,
-0.09926048666238785,
0.3243664503097534,
-0.33048006892204285,
0.41620054841041565,
0.23802508413791656,
-0.44598713517189026,
0.01332592498511076,
0.026302527636289597,
-0.2552334666252136,
-0.6956427693367004,
0.6527040004730225,
-1.153771162033081,
-0.815714955329895,
-0.3001067638397217,
-0.17947769165039062,
0.012176556512713432,
0.19367001950740814,
-0.2068384438753128,
0.38607263565063477,
-0.7389129400253296,
0.1354919821023941,
0.2009851485490799,
-0.046790629625320435,
0.3209049105644226,
0.4320138096809387,
-0.09544362872838974,
-0.42902350425720215,
0.7213870882987976,
0.10871051251888275,
0.1811288297176361,
0.27257299423217773,
0.44888797402381897,
-0.28633058071136475,
-0.48975205421447754,
-0.2983322739601135,
0.09938090294599533,
-0.42347171902656555,
0.044228166341781616,
-0.19856497645378113,
-0.07451175153255463,
-0.8322494029998779,
0.05392039567232132,
-0.3399779796600342,
-0.40269893407821655,
-0.3066914975643158,
0.04241977632045746,
-0.048553865402936935,
0.9528751969337463,
-0.00653832545503974,
0.250559538602829,
-0.5728291273117065,
0.4175645411014557,
0.5870178937911987,
0.3788706958293915,
-0.3181523382663727,
-0.4677965044975281,
-0.04685232788324356,
0.29968783259391785,
-0.36711421608924866,
-0.9928128719329834,
-0.13769006729125977,
0.3023589849472046,
0.6559469699859619,
0.37467873096466064,
0.19322676956653595,
1.0274038314819336,
-0.4314129054546356,
0.9736717343330383,
-0.03527883440256119,
-1.1516389846801758,
0.5569762587547302,
-0.14375039935112,
0.2921658158302307,
0.8457184433937073,
0.11342409253120422,
-0.7644636631011963,
-0.8707278966903687,
-0.08651620894670486,
-0.3430577516555786,
0.9077977538108826,
0.17054753005504608,
0.5464404821395874,
-0.03443503752350807,
0.45687928795814514,
-0.04731583967804909,
-0.0066907755099236965,
-0.8368368744850159,
0.2771221101284027,
-0.24767160415649414,
-0.17763829231262207,
0.2788807451725006,
0.14214175939559937,
-0.2044173628091812,
-0.35192468762397766,
0.5153102874755859,
-0.2761937975883484,
0.01758887805044651,
0.04658443480730057,
-0.12388642877340317,
-0.20672844350337982,
0.3106943666934967,
0.8716740608215332,
0.9659590721130371,
0.3795922100543976,
-0.181598961353302,
0.04672558233141899,
-0.32230138778686523,
-0.02268838882446289,
0.03130960837006569,
-0.26865023374557495,
-0.46111103892326355,
0.23920388519763947,
0.6225284934043884,
-0.02330191619694233,
-0.18265274167060852,
0.5500572919845581,
-0.28181809186935425,
-0.1578478068113327,
-0.4896453022956848,
0.04801023006439209,
-0.020036932080984116,
0.3959062099456787,
0.12198442965745926,
-0.06236184015870094,
-0.033151108771562576,
-0.7049037218093872,
0.2348519265651703,
0.5756623148918152,
-0.40398284792900085,
-0.22926971316337585,
0.6038333177566528,
0.4984501302242279,
-0.45025867223739624,
0.7764965295791626,
0.060748495161533356,
-0.46094492077827454,
0.6933727264404297,
0.22590304911136627,
0.8554252982139587,
-0.3120492994785309,
0.39505594968795776,
0.3433429002761841,
0.4894810616970062,
-0.20274470746517181,
0.025706671178340912,
-0.0018901921575888991,
-1.0170841217041016,
-0.6250572800636292,
-0.41657429933547974,
-0.5736381411552429,
0.3232475817203522,
-0.6127657890319824,
0.5813634395599365,
-0.7883805632591248,
-0.22269806265830994,
0.00964624248445034,
0.06378728896379471,
-0.4562632143497467,
-0.05116305127739906,
0.4629914164543152,
0.7358852028846741,
-0.9056626558303833,
0.9313662052154541,
0.39071565866470337,
-0.6675119996070862,
-0.9238094091415405,
0.14234967529773712,
0.20370931923389435,
-0.7638857364654541,
0.27148252725601196,
0.09687553346157074,
0.026189854368567467,
-0.23169219493865967,
-1.0777482986450195,
-0.5376858115196228,
0.9080467224121094,
0.4499630033969879,
-0.6118972301483154,
0.03579641506075859,
0.4618084728717804,
0.6110011339187622,
-0.29854869842529297,
0.2367209792137146,
0.5410005450248718,
0.6280772686004639,
-0.041361041367053986,
-0.9889827370643616,
0.02822350710630417,
-0.135538712143898,
-0.019211510196328163,
0.19609929621219635,
-0.7278491854667664,
0.5620684027671814,
-0.08658149838447571,
-0.5195565223693848,
0.21500051021575928,
1.0197807550430298,
0.18945160508155823,
0.24241729080677032,
0.5608707666397095,
0.3246689438819885,
1.0102821588516235,
-0.01247512735426426,
0.9666863083839417,
-0.5183347463607788,
-0.01994808204472065,
1.0276957750320435,
-0.5007611513137817,
0.7895881533622742,
0.50491863489151,
-0.014872672036290169,
0.2853742837905884,
0.4522109627723694,
-0.023150408640503883,
0.2781856656074524,
0.5858741402626038,
-0.30873775482177734,
-0.16595740616321564,
-0.29531845450401306,
-0.1496821790933609,
0.7286359071731567,
0.2689746022224426,
-0.12012849003076553,
0.15803048014640808,
-0.3428260087966919,
-0.2193695306777954,
0.544387936592102,
-0.32292863726615906,
1.039549708366394,
-0.0419701486825943,
-0.9301255941390991,
0.14584091305732727,
0.0005417910870164633,
0.3909090757369995,
-0.4204799234867096,
-0.16048391163349152,
-0.3592481315135956,
-0.22882650792598724,
-0.1530063897371292,
-0.6047573685646057,
0.5464801788330078,
0.24642974138259888,
-0.05160544067621231,
-0.058140721172094345,
0.31959235668182373,
-0.5137322545051575,
-0.5804101228713989,
0.023695170879364014,
0.2620234489440918,
0.07185500860214233,
-0.08704870939254761,
-0.919963002204895,
0.18675538897514343,
-0.4727678596973419,
0.14454013109207153,
-0.07417222857475281,
0.4911099374294281,
-0.4109624922275543,
0.44962817430496216,
0.8783836960792542,
0.21335460245609283,
-0.09172878414392471,
0.5336940288543701,
0.8477442264556885,
-0.37356650829315186,
-0.40094193816185,
-0.8311001658439636,
0.5312572717666626,
-0.3302305340766907,
-0.4748115539550781,
0.000385006598662585,
0.5036712884902954,
1.011038899421692,
0.19627779722213745,
0.8995093703269958,
0.010171576403081417,
0.059419624507427216,
-0.5016656517982483,
1.0445951223373413,
-0.18988314270973206,
0.11204583197832108,
-0.17217227816581726,
-0.757592499256134,
-0.4271051585674286,
0.4666723310947418,
-0.3586641252040863,
-0.14154954254627228,
0.3826357126235962,
1.147074818611145,
0.0321502760052681,
0.06757158041000366,
0.3622274398803711,
0.06134776026010513,
0.43282774090766907,
0.2000812590122223,
1.0140690803527832,
0.08964378386735916,
0.6114085912704468,
-0.06716296821832657,
-0.1386304646730423,
0.25094082951545715,
-0.7380010485649109,
-0.8972659111022949,
-0.5095931887626648,
-0.1508551388978958,
0.09065889567136765,
0.053516924381256104,
1.2562341690063477,
0.777954638004303,
-1.1007721424102783,
-0.6988608837127686,
-0.3006690740585327,
0.05688846856355667,
-0.0607445053756237,
-0.20984263718128204,
-0.20904622972011566,
-0.3196176588535309,
-0.8386909365653992,
0.42403021454811096,
0.04895927757024765,
-0.39269596338272095,
-0.4756494462490082,
-0.21391722559928894,
-0.2761584222316742,
0.3990410268306732,
0.37421098351478577,
0.46328333020210266,
-1.1306467056274414,
-0.6406708359718323,
-0.2589901387691498,
-0.32077544927597046,
-0.005082786548882723,
1.208187222480774,
-0.4938904047012329,
0.5253825783729553,
0.5492931604385376,
0.7150425910949707,
-0.07560345530509949,
-0.0030082524754107,
1.0777696371078491,
-0.3613256812095642,
0.06658882647752762,
0.08036456257104874,
0.2473655641078949,
0.16079512238502502,
-0.36938077211380005,
0.2866799235343933,
-0.012597213499248028,
-0.675423800945282,
-0.6019009351730347,
0.435850590467453,
-0.7676119804382324,
-0.0534745454788208,
0.8077437281608582,
0.0034454853739589453,
-0.3604848384857178,
-0.20212501287460327,
-0.3377193510532379,
0.6518577933311462,
-0.47941213846206665,
1.2690157890319824,
0.8372687101364136,
0.2565893232822418,
-0.3434087038040161,
-0.07510575652122498,
0.35523590445518494,
0.08569421619176865,
-0.891170859336853,
0.144790381193161,
0.5938239693641663,
-0.21570785343647003,
0.23735518753528595,
0.7943527698516846,
-0.1721164584159851,
0.25980037450790405,
-0.31650057435035706,
0.02895449846982956,
0.18787604570388794,
-0.25274524092674255,
-0.5690459609031677,
-0.0407002754509449,
0.2742149829864502,
0.03880968689918518
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.07812v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.07812v1
|
To be Continuous, or to be Discrete, Those are Bits of Questions
| 2024-06-12T02:08:45 | 2024-06-12T02:08:45 |
Yiran Wang, Masao Utiyama
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Recently, binary representation has been proposed as a novel representation
that lies between continuous and discrete representations. It exhibits
considerable information-preserving capability when being used to replace
continuous input vectors. In this paper, we investigate the feasibility of
further introducing it to the output side, aiming to allow models to output
binary labels instead. To preserve the structural information on the output
side along with label information, we extend the previous contrastive hashing
method as structured contrastive hashing. More specifically, we upgrade CKY
from label-level to bit-level, define a new similarity function with span
marginal probabilities, and introduce a novel contrastive loss function with a
carefully designed instance selection strategy. Our model achieves competitive
performance on various structured prediction tasks, and demonstrates that
binary representation can be considered a novel representation that further
bridges the gap between the continuous nature of deep learning and the discrete
intrinsic property of natural languages.
|
[
-0.4081496000289917,
-0.5067875385284424,
0.6767135262489319,
-0.05510184168815613,
-0.6225966811180115,
0.19260531663894653,
-0.2866846024990082,
-0.5394110083580017,
0.293461412191391,
0.3066963255405426,
-0.2981949746608734,
-0.4329955279827118,
-0.5638110041618347,
-0.13522282242774963,
-0.44655171036720276,
1.1150089502334595,
0.0971631109714508,
0.08475250750780106,
-0.36849868297576904,
-0.09851681441068649,
-0.5822378993034363,
-0.8132352232933044,
-0.7357221245765686,
-0.7907839417457581,
0.6684495806694031,
0.023937292397022247,
0.5503605604171753,
0.6636759042739868,
0.4381833076477051,
0.3404618203639984,
0.10535870492458344,
-0.4654618501663208,
-0.5132610201835632,
0.08547578006982803,
-0.1662697046995163,
-0.42453619837760925,
0.08113407343626022,
-0.08518115431070328,
1.1201770305633545,
1.1210724115371704,
-0.13100962340831757,
-0.3086615800857544,
0.016914285719394684,
0.6547650694847107,
-0.37843582034111023,
0.37438368797302246,
-0.644798219203949,
0.020134365186095238,
-0.17021527886390686,
-0.03449317440390587,
-0.5006186962127686,
-0.09831082820892334,
-0.2615305185317993,
-0.2657283842563629,
-0.09357200562953949,
-0.06489972770214081,
0.7604429721832275,
0.19772133231163025,
-0.3106313645839691,
-0.13600073754787445,
-0.868803083896637,
0.5468644499778748,
-0.6223335266113281,
0.30049920082092285,
0.204847052693367,
0.43320655822753906,
0.08642353862524033,
-0.8411312699317932,
-0.3212140202522278,
-0.26231515407562256,
-0.32081297039985657,
0.31322181224823,
0.26961156725883484,
0.1122218668460846,
-0.0745929405093193,
0.5820860266685486,
0.008924955502152443,
0.16450244188308716,
-0.3154323101043701,
-0.09837835282087326,
0.3962310552597046,
0.13575616478919983,
0.012050076387822628,
-0.13591912388801575,
-0.4744488596916199,
-0.12791113555431366,
-0.4025721549987793,
0.17249731719493866,
0.31921297311782837,
0.32797107100486755,
-0.16784504055976868,
0.2634586691856384,
0.005282043945044279,
0.35449880361557007,
0.2977299094200134,
0.36703741550445557,
0.04521900415420532,
-0.0992157906293869,
-0.088472880423069,
0.15046373009681702,
0.4844702184200287,
0.18756818771362305,
-0.0094158248975873,
-0.11099010705947876,
-0.27827420830726624,
0.17845237255096436,
0.37038514018058777,
-1.1049753427505493,
-0.668209433555603,
0.28185850381851196,
-0.6206774711608887,
-0.42396003007888794,
0.2938006818294525,
-0.15063618123531342,
-0.27305036783218384,
-0.2374664694070816,
0.3073672652244568,
-0.6080852746963501,
-0.230412557721138,
-0.002591462340205908,
-0.3829914927482605,
0.0506085567176342,
0.15904471278190613,
-1.1620455980300903,
0.7275972366333008,
0.5687384605407715,
0.529335618019104,
-0.14533337950706482,
0.4025324583053589,
-0.22217702865600586,
0.23396722972393036,
-0.6460959911346436,
0.4809891879558563,
-0.9948039054870605,
-0.3566972613334656,
-0.2087893933057785,
-0.285309374332428,
0.3465312719345093,
-0.5312759280204773,
-0.10141090303659439,
-0.6772882342338562,
-0.014662480913102627,
-0.18896903097629547,
-0.46574145555496216,
-0.19572526216506958,
0.18292875587940216,
-0.8228304386138916,
0.9107175469398499,
0.24898821115493774,
-0.8914165496826172,
0.2929007112979889,
-0.1438530534505844,
-0.06950001418590546,
0.5644716024398804,
-0.7239126563072205,
-0.6767388582229614,
0.28089639544487,
-0.27158528566360474,
0.3772932291030884,
0.34398338198661804,
0.26441746950149536,
-0.46179744601249695,
-0.7790604829788208,
0.5636324286460876,
-0.17462538182735443,
0.32424691319465637,
-0.18857012689113617,
-0.13174183666706085,
0.12871317565441132,
-0.7741515040397644,
0.018904929980635643,
-0.1036440059542656,
-0.6806105375289917,
-0.5674676895141602,
0.3526248037815094,
-0.0065297214314341545,
0.25600332021713257,
0.39030271768569946,
-0.679098904132843,
0.21006974577903748,
-0.25971123576164246,
0.4728188216686249,
0.9532935619354248,
0.021029673516750336,
0.49158400297164917,
-0.20389647781848907,
0.03354261443018913,
0.3509982228279114,
-0.1925273984670639,
-0.033630918711423874,
-0.37095025181770325,
-0.5795879364013672,
-0.2507385015487671,
1.0461463928222656,
0.1399586945772171,
-0.7246766686439514,
0.3572201132774353,
-0.42029833793640137,
-0.148491770029068,
-0.29129335284233093,
-0.3013508915901184,
0.30023255944252014,
0.24310335516929626,
0.05694947391748428,
-0.6501835584640503,
-0.5932603478431702,
-1.0998696088790894,
0.25415149331092834,
-0.07083602994680405,
-0.3067649006843567,
0.1972433179616928,
0.5850253105163574,
-0.4085828959941864,
0.5013708472251892,
-0.26003843545913696,
0.044697441160678864,
-0.05272495374083519,
0.22978928685188293,
0.5076290965080261,
0.7649999260902405,
0.18502488732337952,
-0.9892596006393433,
-0.42214226722717285,
0.24955949187278748,
-0.5081372857093811,
0.4152511656284332,
-0.22262462973594666,
-0.10887689888477325,
0.10865799337625504,
0.43019983172416687,
0.031510137021541595,
0.31524530053138733,
0.5140166878700256,
-0.18843615055084229,
0.5032337307929993,
-0.3489997982978821,
0.13236254453659058,
-0.8163698315620422,
-0.11364507675170898,
-0.4059043228626251,
-0.4143729507923126,
-0.3641335368156433,
-0.0100393733009696,
0.09931952506303787,
-0.1195010170340538,
0.056955110281705856,
0.30731600522994995,
-0.19813378155231476,
-0.292087197303772,
-0.305803507566452,
-0.18256008625030518,
-0.3458796739578247,
0.6737673878669739,
0.26895248889923096,
0.34951597452163696,
0.49556800723075867,
-0.6161128878593445,
0.11450183391571045,
0.08539533615112305,
-0.15735185146331787,
0.6501907110214233,
-0.6989606618881226,
0.16024236381053925,
-0.349873423576355,
0.38851451873779297,
-0.8789281845092773,
-0.2113446444272995,
0.2510901391506195,
-0.664376974105835,
0.7225263714790344,
-0.15681397914886475,
-0.5190963745117188,
-0.06050379201769829,
-0.5151500701904297,
0.5448154211044312,
0.7149800658226013,
-0.17681878805160522,
0.47189703583717346,
-0.044059351086616516,
-0.054222118109464645,
-0.2670571506023407,
-1.0333480834960938,
-0.14964720606803894,
-0.08249296993017197,
-0.4481191635131836,
0.9644072651863098,
-0.18583108484745026,
-0.026668621227145195,
0.4172724187374115,
-0.3663180470466614,
-0.016190560534596443,
-0.1154235377907753,
0.3615697920322418,
0.30883970856666565,
-0.07172556221485138,
0.3673173189163208,
-0.09836287051439285,
-0.23154912889003754,
0.1219247356057167,
-0.41353434324264526,
0.4821235239505768,
-0.03794651851058006,
0.019242458045482635,
-0.04210318624973297,
0.7453514337539673,
-0.3612034320831299,
0.06090984120965004,
0.8462648391723633,
0.6477459669113159,
-0.6403136849403381,
-0.3393532931804657,
-0.13963131606578827,
-0.12252355366945267,
-0.5406005382537842,
0.4019455015659332,
-0.5003838539123535,
-0.7998071908950806,
0.659781277179718,
-0.05071716010570526,
-0.08072737604379654,
0.5369807481765747,
0.4256821572780609,
-0.4603133201599121,
0.730387806892395,
0.9231231808662415,
0.3467331826686859,
0.6818278431892395,
-0.32638460397720337,
0.005313083995133638,
-0.8896504640579224,
-0.6277655363082886,
-0.32228603959083557,
-0.564374566078186,
-0.8761557340621948,
-0.3005536198616028,
0.36374470591545105,
0.2783905267715454,
-0.3662981390953064,
0.13933448493480682,
-0.6298345923423767,
0.15842010080814362,
0.7143833041191101,
0.5055572986602783,
-0.11583919078111649,
-0.030116450041532516,
-0.23107820749282837,
-0.18953336775302887,
-0.4932064414024353,
-0.28223761916160583,
0.7794890999794006,
0.21111765503883362,
0.6558240652084351,
-0.036192815750837326,
1.3130905628204346,
0.5283607840538025,
0.2834070026874542,
-0.6383763551712036,
0.3773346245288849,
-0.4268786311149597,
-0.31997954845428467,
-0.306247353553772,
-0.6861265301704407,
-0.9553982019424438,
0.20168627798557281,
-0.20118318498134613,
-0.7858791947364807,
0.41416603326797485,
0.05802512168884277,
-0.1139291375875473,
0.35871315002441406,
-0.41557130217552185,
0.5464321970939636,
0.01906006969511509,
-0.32762280106544495,
-0.23256617784500122,
-0.658343493938446,
0.3314981460571289,
0.014232923276722431,
0.27338096499443054,
0.23394018411636353,
-0.196846604347229,
0.9321919679641724,
-0.481658935546875,
0.8664467930793762,
-0.04012371972203255,
0.24922607839107513,
0.06330451369285583,
0.020259549841284752,
0.2185545265674591,
-0.07490530610084534,
-0.08479031175374985,
0.10337086766958237,
0.07928045839071274,
-0.605719804763794,
-0.7322571277618408,
0.6945382356643677,
-0.5250542163848877,
-0.42235082387924194,
-0.4613635838031769,
-0.5022922158241272,
-0.03579826280474663,
0.29499515891075134,
0.07070019841194153,
0.5302408933639526,
0.027626732364296913,
0.511298656463623,
0.7447640895843506,
-0.11981158703565598,
0.4655192494392395,
-0.10778909176588058,
0.02153629995882511,
-0.6012100577354431,
1.0690767765045166,
0.17515042424201965,
0.27455490827560425,
0.7760035395622253,
0.36966902017593384,
-0.27745330333709717,
-0.8207569122314453,
0.020071743056178093,
0.15184138715267181,
-0.9917827844619751,
-0.18792659044265747,
-0.19978336989879608,
-0.4427265524864197,
-0.12982460856437683,
-0.35433855652809143,
-0.029146436601877213,
-0.48812660574913025,
0.04925836622714996,
-0.1834343671798706,
-0.08993996679782867,
1.1419070959091187,
-0.19205446541309357,
0.09382111579179764,
-0.38100889325141907,
0.45608529448509216,
0.3912191390991211,
0.7825460433959961,
-0.12161681801080704,
-0.19786705076694489,
-0.4523800313472748,
-0.10145801305770874,
-0.21497130393981934,
-0.9137129187583923,
-0.0008296948508359492,
0.03915920853614807,
0.44987139105796814,
0.2622835636138916,
0.19562958180904388,
0.46800753474235535,
-0.4505438208580017,
0.5883090496063232,
0.47442537546157837,
-0.7993252873420715,
0.15885749459266663,
-0.25178635120391846,
0.2888505458831787,
0.4383927881717682,
0.42434316873550415,
-0.45038101077079773,
-0.24535122513771057,
-0.7725658416748047,
-0.8644311428070068,
0.5329641699790955,
0.42381152510643005,
0.1915951669216156,
-0.11808499693870544,
0.1471298187971115,
0.2108471691608429,
0.2701024115085602,
-1.0322864055633545,
-0.3207583725452423,
-0.40904584527015686,
-0.38146066665649414,
0.2856953740119934,
-0.3164026439189911,
0.21184244751930237,
-0.11993370205163956,
0.5209546685218811,
0.21148210763931274,
0.5469101667404175,
0.04556867107748985,
0.21828679740428925,
0.24699684977531433,
0.318678081035614,
-0.1379012167453766,
0.43152064085006714,
-0.4136819541454315,
0.46996602416038513,
-0.0981549620628357,
-0.22477222979068756,
-0.03521089255809784,
0.23929105699062347,
-0.32234013080596924,
0.13593463599681854,
0.29750877618789673,
0.5203914642333984,
0.6784070134162903,
-0.20192576944828033,
0.11653425544500351,
0.3963004946708679,
-0.30571186542510986,
-0.3242887556552887,
-0.15065161883831024,
0.391844242811203,
0.06530527025461197,
0.29343798756599426,
-0.09277677536010742,
0.4724259078502655,
-0.989763617515564,
0.3230823874473572,
0.431620329618454,
-0.5248382091522217,
-0.10200759768486023,
0.6984765529632568,
0.12209633737802505,
-0.22628313302993774,
0.7233074903488159,
-0.20842260122299194,
-0.43017974495887756,
0.6550402045249939,
0.4426910877227783,
0.4080793559551239,
-0.10991642624139786,
0.2125273197889328,
0.5302861928939819,
0.03710680082440376,
0.24009288847446442,
0.2580101490020752,
-0.4399469792842865,
-0.49283701181411743,
-0.05224087834358215,
-0.6518012285232544,
-0.4406285285949707,
-0.12965044379234314,
-0.7169632315635681,
0.098922498524189,
-0.7704220414161682,
-0.030992139130830765,
0.167483851313591,
0.263897180557251,
-0.5560349225997925,
0.4442279636859894,
0.5849942564964294,
0.44086581468582153,
-0.41138342022895813,
0.9534086585044861,
0.3971843421459198,
-0.7559359073638916,
-0.352763831615448,
-0.37817421555519104,
-0.6407758593559265,
-0.4240039885044098,
0.4868347942829132,
0.37309730052948,
0.17794057726860046,
-0.35086268186569214,
-0.7886196970939636,
-0.6932644248008728,
1.0023689270019531,
0.08518849313259125,
-0.6617726683616638,
-0.18928073346614838,
0.14851590991020203,
0.4002857208251953,
-0.464568167924881,
0.029431665316224098,
0.26925128698349,
0.48221248388290405,
0.1751849502325058,
-0.15358726680278778,
0.3870353102684021,
-0.3606927990913391,
0.6536340713500977,
0.3804394006729126,
-0.2778748571872711,
0.9653382897377014,
0.19357673823833466,
-0.605552613735199,
-0.04645645618438721,
0.8263883590698242,
0.3169189393520355,
0.08061942458152771,
0.36038947105407715,
0.27397969365119934,
0.5888195037841797,
-0.3466380536556244,
1.2463926076889038,
0.03840769827365875,
-0.00731153367087245,
1.147260069847107,
0.21679234504699707,
1.0589567422866821,
0.48310503363609314,
-0.3121533989906311,
1.246527075767517,
0.7192577719688416,
-0.19703546166419983,
0.7128674387931824,
0.7037121057510376,
-0.18151339888572693,
-0.3719513714313507,
0.11623373627662659,
-0.24960225820541382,
-0.10266441851854324,
0.45796048641204834,
-0.3551402986049652,
-0.00912221148610115,
-0.33034971356391907,
-0.41194233298301697,
0.372146338224411,
-0.4210496246814728,
0.7845089435577393,
0.11929664760828018,
-0.35670751333236694,
0.585667073726654,
0.18600516021251678,
0.8359835147857666,
-0.8796482682228088,
-0.6004446744918823,
-0.0825173631310463,
0.005140257999300957,
-0.3753608763217926,
-0.7082560658454895,
0.4435318410396576,
-0.6712576150894165,
-0.3699001669883728,
-0.1876782327890396,
0.6330276131629944,
-0.6585032939910889,
-0.6220265626907349,
0.28561702370643616,
-0.3850477933883667,
0.2513805627822876,
0.009190071374177933,
-0.4232838749885559,
0.25374943017959595,
-0.28957265615463257,
0.23609784245491028,
0.38350117206573486,
0.37584826350212097,
-0.10398910194635391,
0.2640793025493622,
0.32275527715682983,
0.050421569496393204,
0.09435611218214035,
0.003923033829778433,
0.9468638896942139,
-0.8710479736328125,
-0.6036616563796997,
-0.5183963775634766,
0.7451272010803223,
-0.2674406170845032,
0.18989260494709015,
0.2229132503271103,
0.4165427088737488,
0.9381541013717651,
-0.03259856253862381,
0.8472431898117065,
-0.12570682168006897,
-0.053444087505340576,
-0.5831374526023865,
0.37749749422073364,
-0.15765917301177979,
0.23590384423732758,
0.016411056742072105,
-0.6734604239463806,
0.08681659400463104,
0.24603892862796783,
-0.06333471834659576,
0.2653234601020813,
0.9505868554115295,
0.2305523008108139,
-0.10450530797243118,
-0.4144510328769684,
0.6490587592124939,
0.21670623123645782,
0.09068673104047775,
0.79345703125,
0.43913787603378296,
-0.4917730689048767,
0.6251031160354614,
-0.42660465836524963,
-0.2686866223812103,
0.04365190118551254,
-0.7328856587409973,
-0.9440405368804932,
-0.8612725138664246,
-0.4103144407272339,
-0.2959693968296051,
0.13897472620010376,
0.2988601624965668,
0.7997086644172668,
-0.7254858613014221,
-0.12813813984394073,
-0.02438199147582054,
0.0971694141626358,
-0.3461046814918518,
-0.21657896041870117,
0.33813920617103577,
-0.33794456720352173,
-0.5937971472740173,
-0.008020331151783466,
0.12901051342487335,
0.07654019445180893,
-0.4072750210762024,
-0.10022745281457901,
-0.012029542587697506,
0.27170220017433167,
0.509385347366333,
0.1030280664563179,
-0.6353322267532349,
-0.33425265550613403,
-0.5670632123947144,
-0.02978447452187538,
0.2423482984304428,
0.773219645023346,
-0.9905267953872681,
0.3957759737968445,
0.4338061213493347,
0.8044055104255676,
1.0153756141662598,
-0.010542706586420536,
0.6304314136505127,
-0.9438647031784058,
-0.07686488330364227,
0.3674141764640808,
0.4394456148147583,
0.6303261518478394,
-0.38438671827316284,
0.2546127438545227,
0.028849897906184196,
-0.09723880887031555,
-0.3647787272930145,
0.5826139450073242,
-1.1642158031463623,
-0.5903328657150269,
0.8331109881401062,
-0.1317947804927826,
-0.29227280616760254,
-0.09342093765735626,
-0.006923903711140156,
0.22325217723846436,
-0.41338372230529785,
0.7268978953361511,
0.7407011985778809,
0.10707729309797287,
-0.21162964403629303,
-0.1753680557012558,
0.32083091139793396,
0.09935834258794785,
-0.5791429877281189,
-0.2693236768245697,
0.4142597019672394,
0.3398074209690094,
0.188520610332489,
0.8309800028800964,
-0.40396571159362793,
0.1911713033914566,
0.47067493200302124,
0.05085147172212601,
-0.1766798198223114,
-0.16716454923152924,
-0.38651368021965027,
0.34860652685165405,
0.0024911356158554554,
-0.48638927936553955
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10278v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10278v1
|
Prompt-Based Length Controlled Generation with Multiple Control Types
| 2024-06-12T01:49:54 | 2024-06-12T01:49:54 |
Renlong Jie, Xiaojun Meng, Lifeng Shang, Xin Jiang, Qun Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large language models (LLMs) have attracted great attention given their
strong performance on a wide range of NLP tasks. In practice, users often
expect generated texts to fall within a specific length range, making length
controlled generation an important topic, especially for GPT-style models.
Existing length control methods mostly focus on a simple control type of "equal
to" a target length. Different from them, we propose a prompt-based method to
achieve length controlled generation under different control types with high
accuracy. In particular, we adopt reinforcement learning (RL) and sample
filtering with the reward signal given by rule-based reward models, which
enhances the length control ability of models by rewarding outputs that follow
certain control instructions. In addition, we introduce a standard prompt
extractor to parse arbitrary users' input into standard control instructions.
Experiments show that our method significantly improves the accuracy of
prompt-based length control on popular summarization datasets like CNNDM and
NYT under multiple control types. Moreover, both the standard prompt extractor
and RL-tuned model show strong generalization to unseen control prompt
templates.
|
[
-0.4005422592163086,
-0.7732282280921936,
0.6879444122314453,
0.5330239534378052,
-0.4799208343029022,
0.12475045770406723,
-0.386581689119339,
-0.07520837336778641,
0.34809309244155884,
0.4602689743041992,
-0.6813201308250427,
-0.4093170762062073,
-0.697681725025177,
0.5599316954612732,
-0.18806636333465576,
1.2601665258407593,
-0.23652024567127228,
-0.1919565498828888,
-0.03035993129014969,
0.172319695353508,
-0.6062654852867126,
-0.2956993579864502,
-0.8581333756446838,
-0.2620546519756317,
1.24984610080719,
0.3697221577167511,
0.6448889970779419,
0.6440887451171875,
0.27134260535240173,
0.18211929500102997,
-0.26785483956336975,
0.7294206619262695,
-0.27821698784828186,
0.3671267628669739,
0.044989511370658875,
-0.3660595118999481,
-0.14929607510566711,
-0.07329481840133667,
0.6982764601707458,
0.175882488489151,
-0.268560528755188,
-0.17048652470111847,
0.05276194214820862,
0.5072137713432312,
-0.5068716406822205,
-0.07955024391412735,
-0.2725346088409424,
0.19407275319099426,
0.055400025099515915,
-0.7042694687843323,
-0.5241597890853882,
-0.6824812889099121,
-0.20742207765579224,
-0.3357645869255066,
-0.03991706669330597,
0.2405344694852829,
0.6540712118148804,
0.10422471910715103,
-0.6084621548652649,
-0.47333797812461853,
-0.6534557342529297,
0.8092230558395386,
-0.9534341096878052,
0.14660057425498962,
0.2177276313304901,
0.43669137358665466,
-0.26192420721054077,
-0.49133986234664917,
-0.4559256434440613,
-0.6322615146636963,
-0.23636922240257263,
0.23410460352897644,
0.14970560371875763,
0.11128286272287369,
0.6217432618141174,
0.08308034390211105,
-0.5608737468719482,
0.5130960941314697,
-0.46406593918800354,
-0.17913366854190826,
0.6570377945899963,
0.4073718786239624,
0.22352154552936554,
-0.4042336344718933,
-0.29290637373924255,
-0.012978343293070793,
-0.8940609693527222,
0.295144647359848,
0.6560295820236206,
0.36428508162498474,
-0.1696738749742508,
0.9148439168930054,
-0.3111877143383026,
0.9056136012077332,
0.13059937953948975,
-0.2953853905200958,
-0.1750088632106781,
-0.253887802362442,
0.07039117068052292,
-0.0818561464548111,
0.8150254487991333,
0.4030609130859375,
0.30136239528656006,
-0.031382158398628235,
-0.5683147311210632,
-0.19351647794246674,
-0.04721943289041519,
-0.7613147497177124,
0.12054841220378876,
0.18651291728019714,
-0.4286409914493561,
-0.3668760359287262,
0.026734480634331703,
-0.6558505892753601,
-0.40692538022994995,
-0.4210171103477478,
0.12273428589105606,
-0.41408008337020874,
0.17798767983913422,
0.10965646058320999,
-0.16450844705104828,
0.22506952285766602,
0.3139040768146515,
-1.0400358438491821,
0.19763515889644623,
0.2078881859779358,
0.9944437146186829,
-0.7170508503913879,
-0.19174069166183472,
-1.1621887683868408,
-0.11542181670665741,
-0.4336816668510437,
0.47341325879096985,
-0.4266353249549866,
-0.5455736517906189,
0.06323282420635223,
-0.2471347451210022,
0.18711040914058685,
-0.09505130350589752,
0.2565162777900696,
-0.7204105257987976,
0.6607540249824524,
-0.07216770946979523,
-0.6690395474433899,
0.12748995423316956,
0.1666245013475418,
-0.49719542264938354,
0.6551114916801453,
0.021046694368124008,
-0.5704167485237122,
0.40469998121261597,
-0.610041618347168,
-0.5429441928863525,
0.09016876667737961,
-0.26440662145614624,
-0.3535904586315155,
0.1258542686700821,
0.5257548689842224,
0.5011284947395325,
-0.16976416110992432,
0.6684683561325073,
0.06945023685693741,
-0.2472199946641922,
0.30654507875442505,
-0.7821379899978638,
0.35496658086776733,
0.2480517476797104,
-0.1136200800538063,
0.6641539931297302,
-0.8060497045516968,
0.026119466871023178,
0.00969688780605793,
-0.8150464296340942,
0.06870255619287491,
-0.04264501482248306,
-0.012601856142282486,
0.29175224900245667,
0.3297315537929535,
-0.3964129686355591,
0.35302993655204773,
-0.1795639842748642,
0.343555748462677,
0.7392434477806091,
0.4878000319004059,
0.15986201167106628,
-0.600346028804779,
0.9061675667762756,
-0.14066632091999054,
-0.038924068212509155,
-0.487386554479599,
-0.11825063824653625,
-0.39909085631370544,
-0.3839268684387207,
0.2911362946033478,
0.6167719960212708,
-1.0844630002975464,
0.7460218667984009,
-0.05699588730931282,
-0.38586533069610596,
-0.09727534651756287,
-0.031263187527656555,
0.3448769450187683,
0.5222803950309753,
0.6435403227806091,
-0.00318097579292953,
-0.10253366827964783,
-0.6297709345817566,
-0.20224158465862274,
0.18144336342811584,
-0.5356286764144897,
0.43282806873321533,
0.22585026919841766,
0.31584876775741577,
1.1161748170852661,
-0.6710070967674255,
0.18216677010059357,
-0.5647065043449402,
0.19127336144447327,
0.3897019326686859,
0.4494864344596863,
0.1776459813117981,
-0.6712237000465393,
-0.31505128741264343,
-0.4278734028339386,
-0.3813188374042511,
-0.3054391145706177,
-0.49375826120376587,
0.2816544771194458,
0.0681060180068016,
0.430570125579834,
-0.5005728006362915,
0.3196890652179718,
0.35713180899620056,
-0.565900981426239,
0.9040949940681458,
-0.4937678575515747,
0.06331789493560791,
-0.9779242277145386,
-0.11822877824306488,
0.15630069375038147,
-0.5316368937492371,
-0.38940924406051636,
-0.33726903796195984,
0.12181422859430313,
-0.03772074356675148,
-0.565122663974762,
0.5774794816970825,
-0.1939886212348938,
-0.004041004925966263,
-0.4842626750469208,
-0.03369613736867905,
0.1718495637178421,
0.6381573677062988,
0.25210121273994446,
0.7333224415779114,
0.20772571861743927,
-0.9528666138648987,
0.690277636051178,
0.18843117356300354,
-0.3359188437461853,
0.36402228474617004,
-0.8947232961654663,
-0.106316477060318,
-0.27747461199760437,
0.45569315552711487,
-0.6710578799247742,
-0.23799632489681244,
0.19846341013908386,
-0.42708373069763184,
0.2503260672092438,
0.16176585853099823,
-0.5018446445465088,
-0.3067544996738434,
-0.20552106201648712,
-0.08068603277206421,
0.6124368906021118,
-0.6326333284378052,
0.4282861053943634,
-0.4461292326450348,
-0.5567567348480225,
-0.49921610951423645,
-0.3662400245666504,
-0.09694232046604156,
-0.5411940217018127,
-0.1062714084982872,
0.22944407165050507,
-0.3836436867713928,
0.09835433959960938,
-0.36509057879447937,
0.13612082600593567,
0.2905471920967102,
-0.030079009011387825,
0.09673450142145157,
0.28892508149147034,
0.03871205076575279,
0.21931231021881104,
0.5150739550590515,
0.0278884619474411,
0.023472381755709648,
-0.07306616753339767,
0.7155842185020447,
0.4493533670902252,
-0.24744664132595062,
-0.47932377457618713,
0.5058044791221619,
0.27047574520111084,
-0.4392435550689697,
0.47711560130119324,
0.3783882260322571,
0.0055875107645988464,
-0.4686371982097626,
-0.2900346517562866,
-0.5921587347984314,
-0.46585673093795776,
0.3393976092338562,
-0.3481067419052124,
-1.1561959981918335,
0.4320920407772064,
0.048919472843408585,
0.2761397957801819,
0.24802349507808685,
0.4264060854911804,
0.0482252761721611,
1.0321435928344727,
0.5163864493370056,
0.034407831728458405,
0.6020150184631348,
0.22677715122699738,
-0.2884504199028015,
-0.5163389444351196,
-0.13548699021339417,
-0.43458494544029236,
-0.3762650191783905,
-0.36388570070266724,
0.022434176877141,
0.24439670145511627,
0.2466057389974594,
-0.4105665981769562,
0.11078300327062607,
-0.35693904757499695,
0.5054976344108582,
0.6828261613845825,
0.2095315009355545,
0.2316095381975174,
-0.1207410991191864,
-0.16698519885540009,
-0.019214317202568054,
-0.742970883846283,
-0.28380274772644043,
0.7812285423278809,
0.39767536520957947,
0.9465672373771667,
0.04733232781291008,
0.7308100461959839,
0.47080138325691223,
-0.05964827537536621,
-0.6943541765213013,
0.37574511766433716,
-0.014060329645872116,
-0.005260082893073559,
-0.6887832283973694,
-0.7665170431137085,
-0.700149416923523,
-0.002342686988413334,
-0.15229496359825134,
-0.4740206301212311,
0.10456860810518265,
0.12208042293787003,
-0.6559900045394897,
0.1858387142419815,
-0.22783948481082916,
0.36400556564331055,
-0.4279364347457886,
-0.11595356464385986,
0.08858165144920349,
-0.5979138016700745,
0.37906739115715027,
0.05678665265440941,
-0.24141274392604828,
-0.1733577847480774,
-0.13000856339931488,
0.7736673951148987,
-0.3401046693325043,
0.7275722026824951,
-0.21518196165561676,
-0.24229170382022858,
0.20763961970806122,
0.05566952005028725,
0.9065268635749817,
0.37392479181289673,
0.22349104285240173,
-0.32423102855682373,
-0.40744879841804504,
-0.2883422076702118,
-0.5803640484809875,
0.43822622299194336,
-0.5125975012779236,
-0.47137629985809326,
-0.1210939884185791,
-0.603653073310852,
-0.15858370065689087,
0.16989649832248688,
0.5953981876373291,
0.6095236539840698,
0.1225687712430954,
0.03144500404596329,
0.6664555668830872,
-0.6295621991157532,
0.817152738571167,
0.5182440280914307,
-0.46436986327171326,
-0.6527324914932251,
0.7679911851882935,
-0.11302872002124786,
0.3909689784049988,
0.5259717106819153,
0.3690202534198761,
-0.6072395443916321,
-0.42478737235069275,
-0.5079838633537292,
0.08032022416591644,
-0.45625707507133484,
-0.3925786018371582,
-0.4786478281021118,
-0.3171432614326477,
-0.2919922471046448,
-0.30695840716362,
0.003735321806743741,
-0.237350732088089,
-0.5131897926330566,
-0.3942156434059143,
0.6388548016548157,
0.6653122305870056,
-0.038146570324897766,
0.6453760862350464,
-0.7631469368934631,
0.49155446887016296,
0.4786909818649292,
0.36169448494911194,
-0.3107926547527313,
-0.5990447998046875,
0.06811341643333435,
-0.35765984654426575,
-0.10357905924320221,
-0.9569097757339478,
0.673298180103302,
-0.09526141732931137,
0.17980405688285828,
0.2835545539855957,
0.055411964654922485,
0.10652980953454971,
-0.7039878368377686,
0.9061471819877625,
0.5256749391555786,
-0.7268293499946594,
0.5604523420333862,
-0.37529227137565613,
0.6287169456481934,
0.08837081491947174,
0.3619554042816162,
-0.8414592146873474,
-0.4253064692020416,
-0.3618282377719879,
-0.7502040266990662,
0.5909786224365234,
-0.0020925719290971756,
0.14401237666606903,
-0.15521663427352905,
0.2798277735710144,
0.271473228931427,
0.208031564950943,
-0.7554494738578796,
-0.12107294797897339,
-0.23549990355968475,
-0.21607793867588043,
-0.2274676412343979,
-0.5255594849586487,
-0.0830928385257721,
0.4978890120983124,
0.6273111701011658,
-0.2442515790462494,
-0.07045901566743851,
0.23153558373451233,
0.08004646748304367,
0.04661386460065842,
0.5982613563537598,
0.9681587219238281,
0.7619966268539429,
-0.1212388426065445,
0.07152020186185837,
0.05920781195163727,
-0.07060808688402176,
0.3394765853881836,
0.14750416576862335,
-0.45537301898002625,
0.08377271145582199,
0.2559033930301666,
1.1020451784133911,
-0.2278953194618225,
-0.65062016248703,
0.3820628821849823,
-0.06025936082005501,
-0.2028009444475174,
-0.08482286334037781,
0.3167818784713745,
-0.09618545323610306,
0.10811039060354233,
0.22230902314186096,
-0.1695842146873474,
-0.12274011224508286,
0.282920241355896,
0.2666705250740051,
0.11723553389310837,
-0.4185297191143036,
0.06653368473052979,
0.6874374747276306,
0.23123255372047424,
-0.26231303811073303,
0.69150710105896,
-0.22527968883514404,
-0.1276526302099228,
0.7049899697303772,
0.6200101971626282,
0.6407995223999023,
-0.1393030434846878,
0.4811910092830658,
0.36497247219085693,
0.2127067893743515,
-0.15352244675159454,
0.41470158100128174,
0.0027606706134974957,
-0.6818833351135254,
-0.8769216537475586,
-0.6245241761207581,
-0.35711297392845154,
0.3418770432472229,
-0.6197536587715149,
0.3191324472427368,
-0.5576809048652649,
0.031064650043845177,
-0.27403777837753296,
-0.040964581072330475,
-0.32434624433517456,
0.1699349582195282,
0.06474240124225616,
1.155814528465271,
-0.7962212562561035,
0.6694605946540833,
0.08356309682130814,
-0.436201810836792,
-0.9363757371902466,
-0.27753007411956787,
-0.20348699390888214,
-0.3572906255722046,
0.6302136778831482,
0.17764359712600708,
0.006518120411783457,
0.10704559087753296,
-0.5745159983634949,
-0.6540718078613281,
1.059429407119751,
-0.06531159579753876,
-0.8091332912445068,
-0.20683623850345612,
-0.2109076827764511,
0.30297356843948364,
-0.44382330775260925,
0.17299392819404602,
0.4740873873233795,
0.5162702202796936,
0.14007380604743958,
-0.6796766519546509,
0.11911733448505402,
0.17224258184432983,
0.34685587882995605,
0.14366751909255981,
-0.4252362847328186,
0.7193326950073242,
-0.1877824366092682,
-0.04198748245835304,
0.05733996629714966,
1.007916808128357,
0.7822588086128235,
0.03893105685710907,
0.47571268677711487,
0.0671946331858635,
0.6184543371200562,
0.1742229014635086,
1.014554500579834,
-0.2033609300851822,
0.0026070561725646257,
1.22593355178833,
-0.2595667541027069,
0.42582711577415466,
0.2735994756221771,
0.0166512131690979,
0.36352869868278503,
0.7652443647384644,
-0.11654358357191086,
0.484243243932724,
0.5176172256469727,
-0.1611631065607071,
-0.1502809375524521,
-0.13995389640331268,
-0.1469653844833374,
0.09286607801914215,
0.2508724629878998,
-0.4709727466106415,
-0.07772528380155563,
0.2492360919713974,
0.22085997462272644,
0.2131575047969818,
-0.5266351699829102,
0.855617105960846,
0.014162841252982616,
-0.9257784485816956,
0.40402066707611084,
0.3474295139312744,
1.0347474813461304,
-0.9999803304672241,
0.022111618891358376,
-0.43401914834976196,
-0.42230024933815,
0.11833116412162781,
-0.6774387955665588,
-0.1740928292274475,
0.16661113500595093,
-0.22604937851428986,
-0.3285941183567047,
0.6321727633476257,
-0.7044776082038879,
-0.15828382968902588,
-0.11280697584152222,
0.4371063709259033,
0.017460230737924576,
0.1403995305299759,
-0.35403379797935486,
-0.3432389795780182,
0.18679927289485931,
-0.6304122805595398,
0.068849116563797,
0.25034838914871216,
-0.24380499124526978,
0.5655516982078552,
0.70188969373703,
0.5687688589096069,
0.24353815615177155,
-0.0654788464307785,
0.740615963935852,
-0.777059018611908,
-0.8318901658058167,
-0.9258347749710083,
0.3447592556476593,
-0.1600501537322998,
-0.4508800506591797,
0.47775956988334656,
0.44410303235054016,
0.3761332035064697,
-0.3348613381385803,
0.8496463298797607,
-0.011130292899906635,
0.761021077632904,
-0.9479811787605286,
0.3955569863319397,
-0.2880809009075165,
0.05998982861638069,
0.2718476355075836,
-0.954593300819397,
-0.3346193730831146,
0.04145133122801781,
-0.22683535516262054,
0.15078935027122498,
0.554404079914093,
0.6374379396438599,
0.23186331987380981,
-0.2915251553058624,
0.44217777252197266,
-0.17269012331962585,
0.6730877757072449,
0.5093744397163391,
0.9201472997665405,
0.43259385228157043,
0.43332087993621826,
-0.02791324071586132,
-0.19202780723571777,
-0.06464411318302155,
-1.0543862581253052,
-0.7917599678039551,
-0.2454390525817871,
-0.0744372233748436,
-0.24652957916259766,
-0.10063236951828003,
0.9934206604957581,
0.39763757586479187,
-0.7089897394180298,
-0.054464567452669144,
-0.1714397370815277,
0.21915683150291443,
-0.36698371171951294,
-0.23938719928264618,
0.5455881357192993,
-0.6067102551460266,
-0.6500980257987976,
0.7432118654251099,
0.2682333290576935,
0.3381141722202301,
-0.3218766152858734,
-0.30007854104042053,
0.08199356496334076,
0.21219660341739655,
0.44563519954681396,
0.4291427731513977,
-0.7119671702384949,
-0.24775709211826324,
0.005718097556382418,
-0.26318874955177307,
-0.11616936326026917,
0.9835376739501953,
-0.773155689239502,
0.10924263298511505,
0.7140670418739319,
0.48782601952552795,
0.19950562715530396,
0.2164219319820404,
0.6766601204872131,
-1.171121597290039,
-0.17951151728630066,
0.3224914073944092,
0.345430463552475,
0.2302459180355072,
-0.5177497863769531,
0.18419040739536285,
-0.07012300193309784,
-0.6197250485420227,
-0.4086288511753082,
0.5302313566207886,
-0.8057005405426025,
-0.46412786841392517,
1.2631089687347412,
-0.19873563945293427,
0.10853958129882812,
0.35380062460899353,
-0.44202813506126404,
0.35293540358543396,
-0.6472976207733154,
0.6240838170051575,
0.43589282035827637,
-0.19756199419498444,
-0.4205204248428345,
-0.28058427572250366,
0.7716262340545654,
0.25982198119163513,
-0.9113177061080933,
0.09274516254663467,
0.8028539419174194,
0.11975280940532684,
0.0717163234949112,
0.5710203051567078,
0.06886196881532669,
0.20260657370090485,
-0.5774766802787781,
0.06477700173854828,
-0.41283369064331055,
-0.6687716841697693,
-0.5577744245529175,
0.2845822274684906,
-0.11019578576087952,
-0.014078956097364426
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.07801v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.07801v1
|
PolySpeech: Exploring Unified Multitask Speech Models for Competitiveness with Single-task Models
| 2024-06-12T01:35:46 | 2024-06-12T01:35:46 |
Runyan Yang, Huibao Yang, Xiqing Zhang, Tiantian Ye, Ying Liu, Yingying Gao, Shilei Zhang, Chao Deng, Junlan Feng
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
Recently, there have been attempts to integrate various speech processing
tasks into a unified model. However, few previous works directly demonstrated
that joint optimization of diverse tasks in multitask speech models has
positive influence on the performance of individual tasks. In this paper we
present a multitask speech model -- PolySpeech, which supports speech
recognition, speech synthesis, and two speech classification tasks. PolySpeech
takes multi-modal language model as its core structure and uses semantic
representations as speech inputs. We introduce semantic speech embedding
tokenization and speech reconstruction methods to PolySpeech, enabling
efficient generation of high-quality speech for any given speaker. PolySpeech
shows competitiveness across various tasks compared to single-task models. In
our experiments, multitask optimization achieves performance comparable to
single-task optimization and is especially beneficial for specific tasks.
|
[
-0.4029386639595032,
-0.531765341758728,
0.40696123242378235,
0.28303074836730957,
-0.3856009542942047,
0.04004029929637909,
-0.42512184381484985,
-0.4264146685600281,
0.6288454532623291,
0.43702948093414307,
-0.7614772319793701,
-0.3365459144115448,
-0.4273751676082611,
0.06787846982479095,
-0.4034044146537781,
0.7606504559516907,
0.4527010917663574,
0.23005977272987366,
-0.5229136943817139,
-0.1388539969921112,
-0.4911211431026459,
-0.8934636116027832,
-0.4886297881603241,
-0.5576421618461609,
0.42649146914482117,
0.4458868205547333,
0.33870765566825867,
0.33105117082595825,
0.35951289534568787,
0.36026909947395325,
-0.024821627885103226,
0.009942524135112762,
-0.40293803811073303,
0.5969434976577759,
-0.1882646530866623,
-0.10078131407499313,
-0.5483114123344421,
-0.09957955032587051,
0.7855059504508972,
0.7853332161903381,
-0.47865089774131775,
0.3868601620197296,
0.1100025624036789,
0.28471145033836365,
-0.5901488661766052,
0.30242058634757996,
-0.7270815372467041,
-0.13170020282268524,
-0.5929937362670898,
0.16687332093715668,
-0.2821374237537384,
0.06942853331565857,
0.2876291275024414,
-0.4728293716907501,
0.07032711058855057,
-0.27001550793647766,
0.5445058941841125,
0.3811836540699005,
-0.2199295312166214,
0.03142356127500534,
-0.7309609055519104,
0.8955831527709961,
-0.6016234159469604,
0.5590068101882935,
0.10262347757816315,
0.23389649391174316,
0.06946399062871933,
-0.8791227340698242,
-0.39887499809265137,
-0.21600329875946045,
0.3596833348274231,
0.3672741651535034,
-0.24248017370700836,
0.3335658609867096,
-0.10560797899961472,
0.012197980657219887,
-0.3384818732738495,
0.036774277687072754,
-0.15547938644886017,
-0.18914715945720673,
0.49923965334892273,
0.08589570224285126,
0.4087340235710144,
-0.10423146188259125,
-0.3407383859157562,
-0.16465221345424652,
-0.03494430333375931,
0.3293701410293579,
0.24114976823329926,
0.5714171528816223,
0.16013877093791962,
0.583583652973175,
-0.2822611629962921,
0.7441413402557373,
-0.5090863108634949,
-0.46014469861984253,
0.24897371232509613,
-0.41285035014152527,
0.18280461430549622,
0.2976778447628021,
0.3289829194545746,
-0.09673964232206345,
0.02888384461402893,
-0.38778623938560486,
0.025090457871556282,
0.3425379991531372,
0.4240912199020386,
-0.36861416697502136,
0.013300037942826748,
0.20848174393177032,
-0.37842682003974915,
-0.016212638467550278,
0.25985637307167053,
-0.5737865567207336,
0.10417293757200241,
-0.6437077522277832,
0.5214685797691345,
-0.17094379663467407,
-0.5728645920753479,
0.3993688225746155,
-0.4456078112125397,
-0.12152822315692902,
0.16489554941654205,
-0.700733482837677,
0.6670999526977539,
0.9205897450447083,
0.8017860054969788,
-0.37853315472602844,
-0.8344404697418213,
-0.502798318862915,
0.3144451975822449,
-0.19070401787757874,
0.7165626883506775,
-0.49168911576271057,
-0.3671685755252838,
-0.48488131165504456,
-0.2827322483062744,
-0.338346391916275,
-0.3852072060108185,
0.5058566927909851,
0.07968557626008987,
-0.2393561452627182,
-0.20852036774158478,
-0.34687915444374084,
-0.19216537475585938,
-0.18677698075771332,
-0.7727794647216797,
1.0075160264968872,
-0.34464168548583984,
-0.7240268588066101,
0.2757623791694641,
-0.8964704871177673,
-0.46555429697036743,
0.10612227767705917,
0.013181340880692005,
-0.3013533055782318,
0.4316808879375458,
-0.032648827880620956,
0.42011433839797974,
-0.41549745202064514,
-0.08748938888311386,
-0.19487760961055756,
-0.07479172199964523,
0.04268942400813103,
-0.08603761345148087,
0.5821883678436279,
0.1939089596271515,
-0.40785765647888184,
0.14310230314731598,
-0.6265104413032532,
0.060704346746206284,
0.10937558114528656,
-0.3210093080997467,
-0.21673458814620972,
0.36180558800697327,
0.1443059742450714,
0.18406428396701813,
0.23687930405139923,
-0.9564245939254761,
-0.18876183032989502,
-0.3560350835323334,
0.2030916064977646,
0.5116108059883118,
-0.13834330439567566,
0.1326804757118225,
-0.15494221448898315,
0.4615098237991333,
-0.182610884308815,
0.10697288811206818,
0.18214793503284454,
-0.7683795690536499,
-0.685152530670166,
-0.5920009613037109,
0.3787289559841156,
0.505012035369873,
-0.31135353446006775,
0.2422473430633545,
-0.2577408254146576,
-0.6337529420852661,
-0.5816958546638489,
-0.1085442453622818,
0.20766043663024902,
0.3635352551937103,
0.1634039431810379,
-0.472137987613678,
-0.5547778606414795,
-0.9255324602127075,
-0.3425215482711792,
0.1935565322637558,
0.12439309060573578,
0.0786772072315216,
0.353180468082428,
-0.04537312686443329,
0.8132649660110474,
-0.3690515458583832,
-0.2782670557498932,
-0.5028455853462219,
0.3199065029621124,
0.09664100408554077,
0.24460989236831665,
0.4452389180660248,
-0.8916006088256836,
-0.5028880834579468,
-0.12405849993228912,
-0.2316189706325531,
-0.13291902840137482,
0.23587843775749207,
0.11693856865167618,
-0.13858073949813843,
0.31002193689346313,
-0.37507760524749756,
0.2554621398448944,
0.7632383704185486,
-0.056049637496471405,
0.804271399974823,
-0.08293912559747696,
0.18231573700904846,
-1.0801277160644531,
0.14311479032039642,
-0.28951767086982727,
-0.36373743414878845,
-0.8438770771026611,
-0.03298842906951904,
-0.4712929427623749,
-0.8397971987724304,
-0.4943242073059082,
0.20303912460803986,
-0.17877879738807678,
-0.1975708156824112,
-0.37972283363342285,
0.27580276131629944,
-0.1004805788397789,
0.3550492227077484,
0.2280338555574417,
0.7675704956054688,
0.9614549875259399,
-0.484508752822876,
0.6670627593994141,
0.03876809403300285,
-0.3960544764995575,
0.35134562849998474,
-0.7401576042175293,
0.22682446241378784,
-0.07662298530340195,
0.06637153774499893,
-0.9815755486488342,
-0.18672002851963043,
-0.5478713512420654,
-0.3914395868778229,
-0.11230918020009995,
0.01898815482854843,
-0.5497620105743408,
-0.31637999415397644,
-0.13268150389194489,
0.28190770745277405,
0.19278056919574738,
-0.4223276376724243,
0.7327567338943481,
0.781699538230896,
-0.6684693694114685,
-0.3061579763889313,
-0.5138055682182312,
0.0490950345993042,
-0.052237629890441895,
-0.8627941012382507,
0.6191297173500061,
0.16064639389514923,
-0.004126355051994324,
-0.043002430349588394,
-0.25156864523887634,
-0.13569806516170502,
0.01614874228835106,
0.2571016252040863,
-0.009692390449345112,
-0.11989829689264297,
0.07741010189056396,
-0.181435689330101,
-0.28654956817626953,
-0.33277955651283264,
-0.24517126381397247,
0.76174396276474,
-0.1829432100057602,
-0.4233330488204956,
-0.7118231058120728,
0.8438242673873901,
0.7587733268737793,
-0.7206531167030334,
0.7718427181243896,
0.6002589464187622,
-0.2478831559419632,
-0.16143925487995148,
-0.6765872836112976,
-0.2832026779651642,
-0.4030551016330719,
0.5302771329879761,
-0.8389597535133362,
-0.7804926633834839,
0.21810099482536316,
-0.3253565728664398,
0.045914746820926666,
0.3115403652191162,
0.6999149322509766,
-0.013886909000575542,
1.3687297105789185,
0.5715727210044861,
0.01836298778653145,
0.5844214558601379,
0.07910363376140594,
0.14836251735687256,
-0.5012732744216919,
-0.24818378686904907,
-0.8702774047851562,
-0.18770532310009003,
-0.32305246591567993,
-0.3963402211666107,
0.7668474912643433,
-0.1368049830198288,
-0.05073661357164383,
0.5982590317726135,
-0.5165841579437256,
0.45530933141708374,
0.9237921833992004,
0.06165045499801636,
0.051566898822784424,
0.20001481473445892,
-0.3953741788864136,
-0.07620398700237274,
-0.8666343092918396,
-0.1866983026266098,
0.6786596179008484,
0.1393095999956131,
0.6708582043647766,
0.12803013622760773,
0.850582480430603,
-0.06803172826766968,
-0.8032738566398621,
-0.6057078242301941,
0.5187094807624817,
-0.8029758334159851,
-0.5143296718597412,
-0.35213571786880493,
-0.45696285367012024,
-0.9341860413551331,
0.44770336151123047,
-0.2751862406730652,
-0.953487753868103,
-0.007695356849581003,
0.04583325982093811,
-0.3220438063144684,
0.3191533386707306,
-0.8029958009719849,
1.0013353824615479,
-0.1425773799419403,
0.08305440843105316,
-0.8799182772636414,
-0.4421481490135193,
-0.08868338912725449,
0.06427456438541412,
0.15579372644424438,
-0.4352641701698303,
0.032646503299474716,
0.8438673615455627,
0.09748173505067825,
0.6444628238677979,
-0.24682559072971344,
0.4805641174316406,
0.1714096963405609,
0.0185407567769289,
0.2820477783679962,
-0.18595243990421295,
-0.2562706768512726,
0.19469031691551208,
0.2932059168815613,
-0.36001378297805786,
-0.2964646518230438,
0.7150549292564392,
-0.6017194390296936,
-0.49171116948127747,
-0.15906552970409393,
-0.37075623869895935,
-0.47014039754867554,
0.29413193464279175,
0.14595365524291992,
0.626713752746582,
-0.30943846702575684,
0.49274742603302,
0.3101392090320587,
0.04783325642347336,
0.3383331596851349,
0.14473788440227509,
0.16839763522148132,
-0.3383164703845978,
1.066110372543335,
0.007910345681011677,
0.31336119771003723,
0.22056837379932404,
0.46820276975631714,
-0.46520164608955383,
-0.2547564208507538,
-0.07204468548297882,
0.13853049278259277,
-0.3663382828235626,
-0.008615867234766483,
-0.5989822745323181,
-0.009420366957783699,
-0.7495586276054382,
0.18514376878738403,
-0.977443277835846,
-0.6814002394676208,
-0.0018998441519215703,
0.25826287269592285,
-0.08958761394023895,
0.8732696175575256,
-0.4213201403617859,
0.10123861581087112,
-0.6732751727104187,
0.6523572206497192,
0.6837560534477234,
0.37881627678871155,
-0.012517210096120834,
-0.07945944368839264,
-0.2786189317703247,
-0.03330376744270325,
-0.19844430685043335,
-0.8978282809257507,
-0.014723832719027996,
0.43473291397094727,
0.9010069370269775,
0.10379176586866379,
-0.24889764189720154,
0.6419707536697388,
-0.6242983937263489,
0.8662384748458862,
0.5026206374168396,
-1.1693168878555298,
0.6898470520973206,
-0.12055259197950363,
0.4381233751773834,
0.5044933557510376,
0.1859712451696396,
-0.7312231063842773,
-0.14587321877479553,
-0.5043509602546692,
-0.8135271668434143,
0.9780460000038147,
0.33074045181274414,
-0.004722518380731344,
0.25036370754241943,
-0.07023148238658905,
0.025227749720215797,
0.3506544828414917,
-0.4633103609085083,
-0.13191911578178406,
-0.47365960478782654,
-0.04306698963046074,
-0.06533750146627426,
-0.15186530351638794,
-0.2447202056646347,
-0.4005627930164337,
0.7367477416992188,
0.012892533093690872,
0.332045316696167,
0.018125386908650398,
-0.014395812526345253,
0.20656158030033112,
0.2894803583621979,
0.577867329120636,
0.6245019435882568,
0.06873968988656998,
-0.020319657400250435,
0.06715884059667587,
-0.33331939578056335,
0.08077282458543777,
0.1790623515844345,
0.308702677488327,
0.2320181131362915,
0.20596498250961304,
0.9418431520462036,
0.30231696367263794,
-0.5623304843902588,
0.5270245671272278,
0.0000574191399209667,
0.08112423121929169,
0.006932146847248077,
0.01853526197373867,
0.35312333703041077,
0.1555403172969818,
0.21080641448497772,
-0.02041512355208397,
0.10852327197790146,
-0.4065113961696625,
0.37232550978660583,
0.5005656480789185,
-0.0232414398342371,
-0.11922494322061539,
0.6910133957862854,
0.4158298671245575,
-0.4267696738243103,
0.33155664801597595,
0.06384209543466568,
-0.626505434513092,
0.41786184906959534,
0.5011997222900391,
0.8741992115974426,
-0.5746747255325317,
0.24452412128448486,
0.17734766006469727,
-0.07525072991847992,
-0.1252949833869934,
0.2156946063041687,
-0.2947702407836914,
-0.5808538794517517,
-0.5932456254959106,
-0.7428462505340576,
-0.6186817288398743,
-0.34904584288597107,
-0.719144344329834,
0.2539903521537781,
-0.01795392856001854,
-0.5514786243438721,
0.4883265197277069,
-0.2831798791885376,
-0.5010179281234741,
0.012470201589167118,
0.49554944038391113,
0.4677814543247223,
-0.46547427773475647,
0.8807296752929688,
0.7560921907424927,
-0.20375792682170868,
-0.6688733100891113,
-0.25727152824401855,
0.25805166363716125,
-0.48766326904296875,
0.5053059458732605,
-0.04013654589653015,
-0.6143415570259094,
0.1065865159034729,
-0.025121642276644707,
-0.9103410243988037,
0.6672640442848206,
0.5940992832183838,
-0.4680479168891907,
-0.2603287398815155,
0.45288464426994324,
0.1053704023361206,
-0.32035160064697266,
-0.25122737884521484,
0.4693623185157776,
0.30612120032310486,
-0.11790107190608978,
-1.4779173135757446,
-0.5303125977516174,
0.025439975783228874,
0.09693566709756851,
0.09632883220911026,
-0.6599579453468323,
0.9621466398239136,
0.09539473056793213,
-0.21682415902614594,
0.04744797572493553,
0.3762386739253998,
0.09807482361793518,
-0.22589349746704102,
0.8602758646011353,
0.699222981929779,
0.4821319282054901,
-0.1819574236869812,
0.7857699990272522,
-0.22531063854694366,
0.4234861433506012,
1.1298035383224487,
-0.1208798959851265,
0.9843663573265076,
0.4125315248966217,
-0.17347125709056854,
0.5127477049827576,
0.15998606383800507,
0.18825763463974,
0.5618966817855835,
0.06250794976949692,
-0.5219732522964478,
-0.6386703848838806,
-0.43014565110206604,
-0.08738300204277039,
1.1895482540130615,
0.0782327726483345,
0.3611837923526764,
-0.5467451214790344,
0.5059543251991272,
-0.27924323081970215,
0.03886283189058304,
-0.09687735885381699,
1.0752191543579102,
-0.03323225677013397,
-0.5367828011512756,
0.3364170789718628,
0.09848591685295105,
0.6367070078849792,
-1.0334219932556152,
0.0075460090301930904,
0.2160179764032364,
0.14941750466823578,
0.05782311037182808,
-0.4940096139907837,
0.3210729956626892,
-0.15507537126541138,
-0.27123263478279114,
-0.18119314312934875,
0.8459073305130005,
-0.46764251589775085,
-0.35436129570007324,
0.5481744408607483,
0.33685502409935,
0.1802511066198349,
-0.5821171998977661,
-0.9648001194000244,
0.2441835254430771,
-0.02871832251548767,
-0.016969293355941772,
0.11492113023996353,
0.023517930880188942,
0.4956139922142029,
0.5256658792495728,
0.6898779273033142,
0.5204667448997498,
0.29332664608955383,
0.38052117824554443,
0.517863929271698,
-0.5367153286933899,
-0.9443080425262451,
-0.5565371513366699,
0.48796477913856506,
-0.11703366786241531,
-0.1606636345386505,
0.6134930849075317,
0.6241936683654785,
0.7580245733261108,
-0.02872512862086296,
0.5279691219329834,
-0.006443576421588659,
1.057660698890686,
-0.20276044309139252,
0.6121450662612915,
-0.7850878238677979,
-0.4230605959892273,
-0.45388782024383545,
-0.8077980875968933,
-0.013192644342780113,
0.4751863181591034,
0.16201628744602203,
-0.2534240484237671,
0.5679057240486145,
0.6551103591918945,
-0.21812644600868225,
0.17480455338954926,
0.5448493361473083,
-0.12961030006408691,
0.17545472085475922,
0.3008006811141968,
0.5870993733406067,
0.004121443722397089,
0.5473692417144775,
-0.6882576942443848,
-0.3589436709880829,
0.09983290731906891,
-0.5518849492073059,
-0.44314703345298767,
-1.1315064430236816,
-0.13295358419418335,
-0.06124015152454376,
0.033803973346948624,
0.9674261808395386,
1.1879602670669556,
-0.7862511873245239,
-0.758889377117157,
0.18720309436321259,
-0.12994937598705292,
-0.5302581191062927,
-0.20808228850364685,
0.22887775301933289,
-0.7073215246200562,
-0.8701668977737427,
0.8964780569076538,
0.2904149293899536,
-0.15334190428256989,
-0.08738115429878235,
0.24531997740268707,
-0.3345504105091095,
0.14583958685398102,
0.6652370691299438,
0.13786199688911438,
-0.7467187643051147,
-0.02028173953294754,
-0.14659085869789124,
0.2654035687446594,
-0.1623702347278595,
1.2663607597351074,
-0.4562044143676758,
0.7679675221443176,
0.4341532289981842,
0.6696582436561584,
0.7285907864570618,
0.06421839445829391,
0.5096060037612915,
-0.8882126212120056,
0.5062550902366638,
0.5057812333106995,
0.3215268552303314,
0.12507204711437225,
0.06060631573200226,
0.2623884379863739,
0.3337123692035675,
-0.5968769192695618,
-0.6514471173286438,
0.23730210959911346,
-1.072806715965271,
-0.49982964992523193,
0.8488619327545166,
0.062315683811903,
-0.04077260568737984,
-0.12031738460063934,
-0.1357707381248474,
0.2687920331954956,
-0.3491188883781433,
0.41995322704315186,
0.9127501845359802,
-0.634419858455658,
0.07233905047178268,
-0.46541935205459595,
0.48587390780448914,
0.6849821209907532,
-0.6932081580162048,
0.1005377322435379,
0.10907813161611557,
0.3538864552974701,
0.35285520553588867,
0.4309084415435791,
-0.061948392540216446,
0.44650474190711975,
0.35799938440322876,
0.12917162477970123,
0.0008234833367168903,
-0.6160790324211121,
0.04866873100399971,
0.3329221308231354,
0.06188897043466568,
-0.6060052514076233
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.09444v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.09444v2
|
GenDistiller: Distilling Pre-trained Language Models based on an Autoregressive Generative Model
| 2024-06-12T01:25:00 | 2024-06-21T08:48:41 |
Yingying Gao, Shilei Zhang, Chao Deng, Junlan Feng
|
eess.AS
|
eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.SD
|
Pre-trained speech language models such as HuBERT and WavLM leverage
unlabeled speech data for self-supervised learning and offer powerful
representations for numerous downstream tasks. Despite the success of these
models, their high requirements for memory and computing resource hinder their
application on resource restricted devices. Therefore, this paper introduces
GenDistiller, a novel knowledge distillation framework which generates the
hidden representations of the pre-trained teacher model directly by a much
smaller student network. The proposed method takes the previous hidden layer as
history and implements a layer-by-layer prediction of the teacher model
autoregressively. Experiments on SUPERB reveal the advantage of GenDistiller
over the baseline distilling method without an autoregressive framework, with
33% fewer parameters, similar time consumption and better performance on most
of the SUPERB tasks. Ultimately, the proposed GenDistiller reduces the size of
WavLM by 82%.
|
[
-0.4736519753932953,
-0.4767293632030487,
0.35984259843826294,
-0.02142166718840599,
-0.10877854377031326,
0.3683375418186188,
-0.04550978168845177,
0.06519730389118195,
0.009006932377815247,
0.3735092878341675,
-0.318816602230072,
-0.29676106572151184,
-0.6842733025550842,
-0.24348901212215424,
-0.9152846932411194,
0.7546284198760986,
0.10240712016820908,
-0.07545069605112076,
-0.3194893002510071,
0.2894379198551178,
-0.1942235380411148,
-0.4841465353965759,
-0.5274426937103271,
-0.5672011375427246,
-0.005992883816361427,
0.33804816007614136,
0.27443861961364746,
0.6354776620864868,
-0.03038763254880905,
0.3931126892566681,
0.025909876450896263,
-0.17945043742656708,
-0.611553430557251,
0.22774644196033478,
-0.1793985664844513,
-0.2854177951812744,
-0.09816691279411316,
0.2192372977733612,
0.3460022509098053,
0.6501712203025818,
-0.5257481336593628,
0.252118855714798,
0.5237886309623718,
0.694977343082428,
-0.6128664016723633,
0.08907338976860046,
-0.5685939192771912,
0.13583305478096008,
-0.003410326549783349,
0.06270340830087662,
-0.20153562724590302,
-0.5655068755149841,
0.24772988259792328,
-0.3345365822315216,
0.7680352330207825,
-0.41760724782943726,
0.5140058994293213,
0.44941747188568115,
-0.2920256555080414,
0.004324407782405615,
-1.0754793882369995,
0.7241683006286621,
-0.6313610076904297,
0.2810659408569336,
0.5632236003875732,
0.5100303292274475,
0.11136428266763687,
-1.027098298072815,
-0.6525551676750183,
0.015570830553770065,
0.027874015271663666,
0.008604099974036217,
-0.33182376623153687,
-0.057719409465789795,
0.11953012645244598,
0.64641273021698,
-0.4229135811328888,
0.13754817843437195,
-0.52449631690979,
-0.17251324653625488,
0.4769081473350525,
-0.08156483620405197,
0.14347770810127258,
-0.1711503267288208,
-0.3507975935935974,
-0.19740775227546692,
-0.3672891855239868,
-0.22097504138946533,
0.202035054564476,
-0.059088096022605896,
-0.029010983183979988,
0.07109767198562622,
-0.32863739132881165,
0.5676242709159851,
0.22331352531909943,
-0.2844986319541931,
0.287462055683136,
0.003913387190550566,
-0.2899022102355957,
0.14348886907100677,
1.0566991567611694,
-0.10734378546476364,
0.22386589646339417,
-0.034733232110738754,
-0.14013901352882385,
-0.03103954717516899,
-0.08592415601015091,
-1.048811912536621,
-1.0372265577316284,
-0.13012877106666565,
-0.3442056477069855,
-0.3496197462081909,
-0.11728259176015854,
-0.7386080026626587,
-0.1406983882188797,
-0.174117773771286,
0.26642197370529175,
-0.5573903918266296,
-0.37685626745224,
-0.23045818507671356,
-0.15326297283172607,
-0.2566971778869629,
0.1369553655385971,
-0.8638570308685303,
0.18724484741687775,
0.2812977135181427,
0.689690887928009,
0.032036006450653076,
-0.2640362083911896,
-0.3341216444969177,
0.36061009764671326,
-0.24913367629051208,
0.3732104003429413,
-0.42889827489852905,
-0.6987830400466919,
-0.3349403738975525,
-0.13099542260169983,
-0.1494855433702469,
-0.6355040669441223,
0.35819271206855774,
-0.40112122893333435,
0.37694770097732544,
0.020014554262161255,
-0.7037818431854248,
-0.15135698020458221,
-0.45100346207618713,
-0.6891862154006958,
0.9006785154342651,
0.07206633687019348,
-0.4793604016304016,
0.44895341992378235,
-0.38800477981567383,
-0.48409464955329895,
0.35621801018714905,
-0.3499564826488495,
-0.46799179911613464,
0.1919724941253662,
0.5212779641151428,
0.565437376499176,
-0.20451720058918,
0.7045204639434814,
0.06321872025728226,
-0.11415089666843414,
-0.044909581542015076,
-0.8394275307655334,
0.9442678093910217,
0.5210749506950378,
-0.47215667366981506,
-0.20039278268814087,
-1.0142817497253418,
0.0055881985463202,
0.2837885916233063,
-0.3353187143802643,
-0.5836432576179504,
-0.08327604830265045,
-0.16878949105739594,
0.31464576721191406,
0.12900754809379578,
-0.6029582023620605,
-0.0997113510966301,
-0.15469826757907867,
0.7429998517036438,
0.7429520487785339,
-0.1601991504430771,
0.556625485420227,
-0.04532490670681,
0.6294355392456055,
0.0626552402973175,
0.22457869350910187,
-0.22550107538700104,
-0.21990478038787842,
-0.800308883190155,
-0.5106849074363708,
0.5198379755020142,
0.23015062510967255,
-0.800427258014679,
0.45147427916526794,
-0.27309033274650574,
-0.5387431383132935,
-0.722619891166687,
0.46841496229171753,
0.3830055594444275,
0.5826461911201477,
0.41666170954704285,
-0.0655609518289566,
-0.525547206401825,
-0.7776031494140625,
0.18347744643688202,
-0.11043724417686462,
-0.10385342687368393,
0.00021893417579121888,
0.19089475274085999,
-0.13313765823841095,
1.1557035446166992,
-0.5868483185768127,
-0.39665067195892334,
-0.32786861062049866,
0.38515061140060425,
0.11358920484781265,
0.8309143781661987,
0.6962777972221375,
-0.6825702786445618,
-0.5635927319526672,
-0.3568253517150879,
-0.5901165008544922,
-0.1882842630147934,
0.09080008417367935,
0.10552769154310226,
0.16115537285804749,
0.7451750040054321,
-0.3255169987678528,
0.3788726031780243,
0.8627170324325562,
-0.07615988701581955,
0.24305219948291779,
-0.4649536609649658,
-0.06623928248882294,
-1.1592199802398682,
-0.06433554738759995,
-0.22680360078811646,
-0.23218503594398499,
-0.42140766978263855,
-0.3024088740348816,
0.13026008009910583,
-0.38534221053123474,
-0.24882252514362335,
0.11762598901987076,
-0.6537724733352661,
0.39179331064224243,
-0.3245986998081207,
-0.08232134580612183,
0.19112378358840942,
0.14058944582939148,
-0.1015746220946312,
0.7423873543739319,
0.708385705947876,
-0.6549580693244934,
0.505621612071991,
0.18011927604675293,
-0.4882058799266815,
0.20964601635932922,
-0.6589137315750122,
0.13948297500610352,
-0.18224933743476868,
0.06894941627979279,
-1.012208104133606,
0.06943288445472717,
-0.23917768895626068,
-0.3475969433784485,
0.4438088536262512,
-0.3245082199573517,
-0.2551621198654175,
-0.8381890654563904,
0.05071259289979935,
0.357199102640152,
0.8423789739608765,
-0.8480457067489624,
0.7441042065620422,
0.39325791597366333,
-0.11700054258108139,
-0.33789700269699097,
-0.9192570447921753,
0.040635451674461365,
-0.2165173441171646,
-0.21461212635040283,
0.2708035707473755,
-0.13278938829898834,
0.17651717364788055,
0.24364356696605682,
-0.1877799779176712,
-0.18186692893505096,
0.10834590345621109,
0.4086533188819885,
0.1885809302330017,
-0.11452312022447586,
0.12674959003925323,
0.3242359757423401,
-0.16782771050930023,
0.10978404432535172,
-0.5148273706436157,
0.7083467245101929,
0.3027118444442749,
-0.3339635729789734,
-0.6671802401542664,
0.2624921202659607,
0.44057697057724,
-0.2239788919687271,
0.7294069528579712,
0.4306325614452362,
-0.05182882398366928,
-0.6193854808807373,
-0.7257870435714722,
-0.28620800375938416,
-0.5670328736305237,
0.26758521795272827,
-0.39669299125671387,
-0.8374674320220947,
0.35077041387557983,
-0.09914158284664154,
-0.34887659549713135,
0.3435768783092499,
0.17661137878894806,
0.06049046292901039,
0.8651826977729797,
0.6533989310264587,
-0.4249250590801239,
0.4611959457397461,
-0.595847487449646,
0.18038825690746307,
-0.4586637616157532,
-0.27797389030456543,
-0.3374144434928894,
-0.20030023157596588,
-0.3554353415966034,
-0.22888000309467316,
0.13950568437576294,
0.3022269010543823,
-0.11060050874948502,
0.3174377977848053,
-0.6391344666481018,
0.6255134344100952,
0.9129937291145325,
-0.2522209882736206,
0.2565992474555969,
0.14393916726112366,
-0.297533243894577,
0.14693154394626617,
-0.899948239326477,
-0.26243066787719727,
1.056459665298462,
0.19192403554916382,
0.8136218786239624,
-0.10957300662994385,
1.1467082500457764,
0.148707777261734,
0.09643815457820892,
-0.34929904341697693,
0.5422185063362122,
-0.38422825932502747,
-0.6001813411712646,
-0.4056031405925751,
-0.7085764408111572,
-0.6770530939102173,
0.33929234743118286,
0.05563268065452576,
-0.42271339893341064,
0.3643417954444885,
0.44283825159072876,
-0.5426437258720398,
0.4558943212032318,
-0.8398492336273193,
0.6007709503173828,
0.008904216811060905,
-0.19742310047149658,
-0.07780740410089493,
-0.29547083377838135,
0.2611871659755707,
-0.3210185766220093,
0.18991339206695557,
-0.17412172257900238,
0.5350480079650879,
0.9181413054466248,
-0.6814374327659607,
0.8485292196273804,
-0.5340139269828796,
-0.23234108090400696,
0.43513262271881104,
0.28769052028656006,
0.3732411563396454,
-0.011790838092565536,
0.013664184138178825,
0.1655106544494629,
0.05823835730552673,
-0.16929960250854492,
-0.47794288396835327,
0.9695114493370056,
-0.8135790824890137,
-0.767154335975647,
-0.13949106633663177,
-0.2399001568555832,
-0.1485653817653656,
0.28982052206993103,
0.5429736971855164,
0.4289649724960327,
-0.2988302707672119,
0.1837327629327774,
0.6737362146377563,
-0.11584843695163727,
0.8405899405479431,
0.6450502872467041,
-0.4163021445274353,
-0.3753519356250763,
0.8713974952697754,
0.397472620010376,
0.32827505469322205,
0.2166530042886734,
0.28923872113227844,
-0.2619721293449402,
-0.5545653700828552,
-0.2418714463710785,
-0.017603784799575806,
-0.585131049156189,
-0.27488642930984497,
-0.8714498281478882,
-0.48351484537124634,
-0.6582062840461731,
0.05483938008546829,
-0.5750061869621277,
-0.5543131232261658,
-0.5682438015937805,
-0.33136802911758423,
0.2934266924858093,
0.6521736979484558,
-0.5143241882324219,
0.4967590868473053,
-0.527159571647644,
0.3234518766403198,
0.8831170201301575,
0.28210434317588806,
0.18447257578372955,
-0.5951485633850098,
-0.11449429392814636,
0.012887861579656601,
-0.1993844360113144,
-0.539124071598053,
0.7139641046524048,
0.65340256690979,
0.6264534592628479,
0.6752147674560547,
0.28089839220046997,
0.5784043073654175,
-0.5312502384185791,
0.6502206921577454,
0.4029093384742737,
-1.0684700012207031,
0.8166031241416931,
0.03383652865886688,
0.3841649293899536,
0.563829243183136,
0.4441831409931183,
-0.03464015573263168,
-0.5835967659950256,
-0.547280490398407,
-0.8468782901763916,
0.5713195204734802,
-0.001563585246913135,
0.4351820647716522,
-0.01357457134872675,
0.07337801158428192,
0.3097708225250244,
0.12207609415054321,
-0.39888569712638855,
-0.48793405294418335,
-0.6475854516029358,
-0.18309076130390167,
-0.4414939284324646,
-0.6402016282081604,
0.07516556233167648,
-0.5943001508712769,
0.6103321313858032,
0.26469576358795166,
-0.07667414844036102,
0.0036695876624435186,
-0.19081605970859528,
-0.01193242147564888,
0.3893251121044159,
0.09028144180774689,
0.6060286164283752,
-0.11579214781522751,
0.5322732925415039,
0.097963348031044,
-0.718804121017456,
0.37165990471839905,
0.42516034841537476,
-0.3462772071361542,
-0.012398662976920605,
0.14310027658939362,
0.7824587225914001,
-0.04524720460176468,
-0.17260931432247162,
0.5492805242538452,
-0.1010705828666687,
-0.303958922624588,
-0.394579142332077,
0.297142893075943,
0.1467904895544052,
0.3078211843967438,
0.6700851321220398,
-0.12363104522228241,
0.2904183566570282,
-0.1595592349767685,
0.33178436756134033,
0.11072660982608795,
-0.433926522731781,
-0.2264682650566101,
0.9513207077980042,
0.26113879680633545,
0.21710838377475739,
0.6294310092926025,
-0.19555877149105072,
-0.38531768321990967,
0.3562556207180023,
0.7575218081474304,
0.7857762575149536,
-1.0082253217697144,
0.5231572985649109,
0.18225593864917755,
0.024250777438282967,
-0.10127826780080795,
0.055890604853630066,
-0.34215354919433594,
-0.5240018367767334,
-0.371555894613266,
-0.7991899251937866,
0.25729838013648987,
0.39765289425849915,
-0.7851718068122864,
-0.21177105605602264,
-0.5070005059242249,
-0.26577654480934143,
0.04096781834959984,
-0.33933258056640625,
-0.6746445298194885,
0.16002260148525238,
0.17248225212097168,
0.5302804112434387,
-0.9185003042221069,
1.244154691696167,
0.29523423314094543,
-0.1899338960647583,
-0.9536512494087219,
-0.07257860153913498,
-0.1693314164876938,
-0.6693530678749084,
1.0177361965179443,
-0.06611262261867523,
-0.21679538488388062,
0.4394400417804718,
-0.32983893156051636,
-0.914497435092926,
1.0252935886383057,
0.68857741355896,
-0.8842727541923523,
0.0035870568826794624,
0.18397031724452972,
0.35894325375556946,
-0.16316957771778107,
-0.027050593867897987,
0.47540029883384705,
-0.03344958275556564,
0.27846816182136536,
-0.918624758720398,
-0.008689707145094872,
-0.35449355840682983,
0.4252704977989197,
0.02155580371618271,
-0.3056538999080658,
1.0722098350524902,
-0.20376764237880707,
-0.5148977637290955,
-0.23355604708194733,
0.9047682881355286,
-0.16694766283035278,
0.04924877732992172,
0.3260933756828308,
0.6860153675079346,
0.7691208720207214,
0.02593095600605011,
0.6637987494468689,
-0.29344260692596436,
0.42087313532829285,
1.3897700309753418,
-0.0808793380856514,
0.5634700059890747,
0.34085750579833984,
-0.27365925908088684,
0.6980011463165283,
0.05461716651916504,
-0.036324530839920044,
1.0284066200256348,
0.2590150833129883,
-0.4273553788661957,
-0.27579307556152344,
0.11779627203941345,
-0.7053883075714111,
0.46976709365844727,
0.024654092267155647,
-0.5944862365722656,
-0.27907130122184753,
0.5853213667869568,
-0.034260667860507965,
0.13925659656524658,
-0.26582056283950806,
0.7338835000991821,
0.16867658495903015,
-0.3721025884151459,
0.8492773175239563,
-0.31316637992858887,
0.6899077892303467,
-0.25430816411972046,
0.13232408463954926,
-0.327992707490921,
0.33196744322776794,
-0.04319429025053978,
-0.36714282631874084,
-0.00043735746294260025,
-0.15967020392417908,
-0.24022293090820312,
-0.4095233976840973,
0.6387131214141846,
-0.6858540773391724,
-0.4840991199016571,
0.4159117639064789,
0.5413007140159607,
-0.09785162657499313,
-0.02429959923028946,
-0.47935962677001953,
-0.1500156819820404,
-0.008135105483233929,
-0.25579240918159485,
0.13212673366069794,
0.5683140158653259,
0.4375210106372833,
0.7180018424987793,
0.5226194262504578,
0.133883997797966,
0.25889769196510315,
0.2717873752117157,
1.077188491821289,
-0.3500763177871704,
-0.7811110019683838,
-1.000702142715454,
0.10904328525066376,
-0.14213095605373383,
0.09544672816991806,
1.0125281810760498,
0.6345832943916321,
0.9512811303138733,
-0.10956481099128723,
1.0904090404510498,
0.009181431494653225,
0.7158089280128479,
-0.3808681070804596,
1.1781500577926636,
-0.1749412566423416,
0.30219244956970215,
-0.27985110878944397,
-0.7605850100517273,
0.18580514192581177,
0.6317158341407776,
-0.43231910467147827,
0.08609156310558319,
0.45328497886657715,
0.5256704092025757,
-0.19796480238437653,
0.14523139595985413,
0.48226916790008545,
0.09813519567251205,
0.2637844979763031,
0.5508431196212769,
0.9573916792869568,
-0.26010897755622864,
0.38933101296424866,
-0.6833831071853638,
-0.28900817036628723,
-0.027547994628548622,
-0.6204509139060974,
-1.1079306602478027,
-0.9366317391395569,
-0.5285857319831848,
-0.03776458278298378,
0.10708145797252655,
0.628592848777771,
0.8824231624603271,
-0.912169337272644,
-0.09567849338054657,
-0.28394848108291626,
-0.1638801395893097,
-0.010731079615652561,
-0.24741943180561066,
0.4487479031085968,
-0.16575942933559418,
-0.617635190486908,
0.6084460616111755,
-0.21665740013122559,
0.464974582195282,
-0.48041945695877075,
0.08799517154693604,
0.11025813221931458,
-0.1363900899887085,
0.4584468603134155,
0.26945480704307556,
-0.35624924302101135,
0.050861895084381104,
-0.5369836091995239,
-0.04280175641179085,
-0.1892009973526001,
0.7819778919219971,
-1.1595336198806763,
0.46513035893440247,
0.33398810029029846,
0.2521032392978668,
0.7509490251541138,
-0.0915861427783966,
0.5793173909187317,
-0.7744442224502563,
0.19161997735500336,
0.14698559045791626,
0.3080580532550812,
0.29809296131134033,
-0.23283721506595612,
0.0772329568862915,
0.2329787015914917,
-0.38621410727500916,
-0.7460044622421265,
0.06078795716166496,
-0.38141605257987976,
-0.4921532869338989,
0.8514055609703064,
-0.2153262197971344,
-0.05964489281177521,
-0.11241117119789124,
0.17649789154529572,
0.4359721541404724,
-0.4353334903717041,
0.8511512875556946,
0.15544775128364563,
0.24462364614009857,
-0.4069916605949402,
-0.4564381539821625,
0.6506836414337158,
0.11534037441015244,
-0.4404031038284302,
0.08598238229751587,
0.4888927638530731,
0.4679014980792999,
0.08713109791278839,
0.6272873878479004,
-0.11677445471286774,
-0.22353360056877136,
0.010021325200796127,
0.1612776815891266,
-0.6318264603614807,
-0.4490559697151184,
-0.19855810701847076,
0.5155283212661743,
-0.14856214821338654,
-0.3995634615421295
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.07794v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.07794v2
|
Making Task-Oriented Dialogue Datasets More Natural by Synthetically Generating Indirect User Requests
| 2024-06-12T01:18:04 | 2024-06-16T21:20:34 |
Amogh Mannekote, Jinseok Nam, Ziming Li, Jian Gao, Kristy Elizabeth Boyer, Bonnie J. Dorr
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Indirect User Requests (IURs), such as "It's cold in here" instead of "Could
you please increase the temperature?" are common in human-human task-oriented
dialogue and require world knowledge and pragmatic reasoning from the listener.
While large language models (LLMs) can handle these requests effectively,
smaller models deployed on virtual assistants often struggle due to resource
constraints. Moreover, existing task-oriented dialogue benchmarks lack
sufficient examples of complex discourse phenomena such as indirectness. To
address this, we propose a set of linguistic criteria along with an LLM-based
pipeline for generating realistic IURs to test natural language understanding
(NLU) and dialogue state tracking (DST) models before deployment in a new
domain. We also release IndirectRequests, a dataset of IURs based on the Schema
Guided Dialog (SGD) corpus, as a comparative testbed for evaluating the
performance of smaller models in handling indirect requests.
|
[
-0.4455450177192688,
-0.8435052037239075,
0.5047309994697571,
0.301241010427475,
-0.09532151371240616,
0.009261691011488438,
-0.27696964144706726,
-0.48386016488075256,
0.01678188145160675,
0.9720761179924011,
-0.9965201616287231,
-0.16861513257026672,
-0.12470325827598572,
0.47705981135368347,
-0.27990224957466125,
0.7643925547599792,
-0.11660561710596085,
-0.14503994584083557,
-0.34635689854621887,
0.029939865693449974,
-0.4450017213821411,
-0.5461869835853577,
-0.674552321434021,
-0.2804650366306305,
0.512006938457489,
0.4075343906879425,
0.5734416842460632,
0.3935525119304657,
0.36480221152305603,
0.28643253445625305,
0.26085323095321655,
0.15066111087799072,
-0.17254357039928436,
0.3853986859321594,
-0.2561165988445282,
-0.4214774966239929,
-0.2217843234539032,
-0.13012030720710754,
0.3078424036502838,
0.6210207343101501,
-0.10000723600387573,
0.15283241868019104,
0.11382347345352173,
0.1655445396900177,
-0.4514337480068207,
0.24948371946811676,
-0.6556287407875061,
-0.09527869522571564,
-0.03839737921953201,
-0.20491646230220795,
-0.5507270097732544,
-0.24272029101848602,
0.6285739541053772,
-0.5856502056121826,
0.3696635365486145,
0.15393546223640442,
0.8257832527160645,
0.2883078455924988,
-0.599265992641449,
-0.38427993655204773,
-0.8368174433708191,
0.5989460945129395,
-0.834541380405426,
0.35043495893478394,
0.5069947838783264,
0.3005739152431488,
-0.2239789217710495,
-0.6908724904060364,
-0.7284250855445862,
-0.739446222782135,
-0.2892402112483978,
-0.11099894344806671,
-0.4732239842414856,
0.18845690786838531,
0.5043307542800903,
-0.09764190763235092,
-0.575250506401062,
-0.0993577316403389,
-0.14085260033607483,
-0.09072649478912354,
0.4374699890613556,
0.4712024927139282,
0.3322729766368866,
-0.37940075993537903,
-0.17927248775959015,
0.021637696772813797,
-0.7154334783554077,
-0.07004521042108536,
0.4998578727245331,
0.687555730342865,
-0.14464931190013885,
0.595892071723938,
-0.5458391904830933,
0.9356599450111389,
0.2540515959262848,
0.21295081079006195,
-0.009992479346692562,
-0.666153073310852,
-0.1962384432554245,
-0.12286336719989777,
0.39518415927886963,
0.26250791549682617,
0.08870849758386612,
-0.167663112282753,
-0.07485531270503998,
0.11149802058935165,
0.5238003730773926,
-0.7463297843933105,
-0.05538388341665268,
0.11898897588253021,
0.007823854684829712,
-0.15836068987846375,
-0.21237021684646606,
-0.43729493021965027,
-0.32319846749305725,
-0.9309314489364624,
0.15983019769191742,
-0.37200257182121277,
-0.30342042446136475,
-0.1535952240228653,
0.1342829167842865,
0.02000577002763748,
0.41113150119781494,
-0.6123022437095642,
0.7262378334999084,
0.6253125071525574,
0.6256749629974365,
-0.26689887046813965,
-0.08697903156280518,
-0.6570215225219727,
0.12317609041929245,
-0.012790265493094921,
0.8647218942642212,
-0.6341261863708496,
-0.41002157330513,
0.04757654294371605,
0.09287915378808975,
-0.15728342533111572,
-0.6886072754859924,
0.6309829354286194,
-0.21518205106258392,
0.2631058990955353,
-0.5058827996253967,
-0.23707619309425354,
-0.023922652006149292,
0.44921278953552246,
-0.33019623160362244,
0.8847854733467102,
0.16322878003120422,
-0.4778892993927002,
0.20122770965099335,
-0.7545235753059387,
-0.2322922945022583,
0.1346605122089386,
-0.20513111352920532,
0.10709185898303986,
0.0024607819505035877,
0.21118471026420593,
0.32175347208976746,
-0.9151225686073303,
0.47369855642318726,
-0.11567553132772446,
-0.20565588772296906,
0.14010322093963623,
-0.35587528347969055,
0.6076361536979675,
0.396660178899765,
-0.42293569445610046,
0.05627139285206795,
-0.4895729720592499,
0.08193569630384445,
-0.057509422302246094,
-0.08309286087751389,
-0.40297335386276245,
0.11766393482685089,
-0.2176818549633026,
0.06759538501501083,
0.051417026668787,
-0.4228127598762512,
0.2821863889694214,
-0.566931962966919,
0.2821849584579468,
0.851245641708374,
-0.033947404474020004,
0.3884165287017822,
-0.2533903419971466,
0.6606898903846741,
0.18855485320091248,
0.06382832676172256,
-0.0775456503033638,
-0.20675601065158844,
-1.080364465713501,
-0.3186792731285095,
0.03146132081747055,
0.6334748268127441,
-0.9087691903114319,
0.08975379914045334,
-0.33554473519325256,
-0.376216858625412,
-0.49782803654670715,
0.11684766411781311,
0.5194346904754639,
0.8446933627128601,
-0.02175287902355194,
-0.156576007604599,
-0.5713940858840942,
-0.9945998191833496,
-0.3159385621547699,
-0.34477463364601135,
-0.17255881428718567,
0.8513375520706177,
0.22939655184745789,
-0.3131210207939148,
1.1220991611480713,
-0.5294933915138245,
0.00498687569051981,
-0.31882911920547485,
0.3820453882217407,
0.3349818289279938,
0.3151026964187622,
0.5264416933059692,
-0.7861788868904114,
-0.6595422625541687,
-0.10718164592981339,
-0.6294515132904053,
-0.42415851354599,
0.05344141274690628,
-0.1442919820547104,
0.06118662655353546,
0.4347836375236511,
-0.8861518502235413,
0.3257977068424225,
0.3954678177833557,
-0.26494720578193665,
0.478843629360199,
-0.08616237342357635,
0.11367975175380707,
-1.0372698307037354,
0.041246939450502396,
0.28167426586151123,
-0.17670370638370514,
-0.7463639974594116,
0.08328955620527267,
-0.30814841389656067,
-0.2631988823413849,
-0.5089830160140991,
0.810133695602417,
-0.3565130829811096,
-0.03559080511331558,
-0.04088517650961876,
-0.06382261961698532,
-0.04352127015590668,
0.5471183657646179,
0.13493093848228455,
0.7543908953666687,
0.6306694149971008,
-0.8238539099693298,
0.6121975183486938,
0.14366987347602844,
-0.2871980369091034,
0.8200868964195251,
-0.9094702005386353,
0.3343036472797394,
-0.1337715983390808,
0.6198199391365051,
-0.8174296617507935,
-0.45365530252456665,
0.3584365248680115,
-0.03147910535335541,
-0.22999590635299683,
-0.33925071358680725,
-0.5989707112312317,
-0.2847917079925537,
0.16639916598796844,
0.3958399295806885,
0.39581775665283203,
-0.551585853099823,
0.749096691608429,
0.08116786926984787,
-0.5746698379516602,
-0.35342133045196533,
-0.24896354973316193,
0.24142120778560638,
-0.2090732902288437,
-0.6921119093894958,
0.3281339704990387,
-0.28345176577568054,
-0.5466710329055786,
-0.026579061523079872,
0.03328654542565346,
-0.15856026113033295,
0.008426557295024395,
0.4419877827167511,
0.17079401016235352,
-0.2800533175468445,
-0.031011903658509254,
-0.11348413676023483,
0.01556319184601307,
0.17281296849250793,
-0.2339565008878708,
0.6125252842903137,
-0.01899307407438755,
-0.5971599221229553,
-0.5002327561378479,
0.49319300055503845,
0.2829362154006958,
0.07636569440364838,
0.17708289623260498,
0.24815748631954193,
-0.3837636709213257,
-0.19409014284610748,
-0.6672407388687134,
-0.5386072397232056,
-0.5149732828140259,
0.014996296726167202,
-0.6478185057640076,
-0.5629822015762329,
0.3462936282157898,
-0.35979002714157104,
0.23216654360294342,
0.15150615572929382,
0.4789201021194458,
-0.28210532665252686,
1.2868578433990479,
0.2733587324619293,
0.2168983370065689,
0.23283159732818604,
-0.08422458171844482,
0.2776338756084442,
-0.686302125453949,
-0.10018417984247208,
-0.7243965268135071,
0.040514327585697174,
-0.4388441741466522,
-0.4560284912586212,
0.45547908544540405,
-0.2880803644657135,
0.011670379899442196,
0.5433058142662048,
-0.1772177517414093,
0.2678237557411194,
0.6258338093757629,
-0.0399179644882679,
0.22832243144512177,
-0.015278194099664688,
-0.0874900370836258,
-0.2538670599460602,
-0.4388883709907532,
-0.4681013524532318,
0.7316240668296814,
-0.051774267107248306,
0.6322260499000549,
0.3048120439052582,
0.23625370860099792,
0.5137715339660645,
0.21397165954113007,
-0.6714313626289368,
0.7051224112510681,
-0.014606512151658535,
-0.5164490938186646,
-0.03879309445619583,
-0.40231016278266907,
-0.8312287926673889,
0.2532995343208313,
0.07683739066123962,
-0.7184833884239197,
-0.02317908965051174,
0.4054749310016632,
-0.30150970816612244,
-0.09284437447786331,
-0.7645635008811951,
0.6282950639724731,
-0.0034649816807359457,
-0.2602994740009308,
-0.11646188795566559,
-0.49937885999679565,
0.27965018153190613,
0.17202770709991455,
0.003437155857682228,
-0.34735849499702454,
0.36159995198249817,
0.1168932169675827,
-0.7183233499526978,
1.1105097532272339,
-0.3344306945800781,
-0.1224687322974205,
0.3781881332397461,
0.27622243762016296,
0.8855190873146057,
0.07867444306612015,
-0.2744593024253845,
-0.16387209296226501,
-0.15639859437942505,
-0.30393290519714355,
-0.690292477607727,
0.7312323451042175,
-0.5343055725097656,
-1.05213463306427,
-0.37770846486091614,
-0.5307576656341553,
-0.40654340386390686,
-0.11152418702840805,
0.23261849582195282,
0.5265982747077942,
-0.3292662501335144,
-0.09303371608257294,
0.6063402891159058,
-0.0915398970246315,
0.06339312344789505,
0.7904704213142395,
0.03596732020378113,
0.26926735043525696,
0.929754376411438,
0.012527445331215858,
0.39870890974998474,
0.04365956410765648,
0.15358123183250427,
-0.27225223183631897,
-0.40767019987106323,
-0.5006287693977356,
0.10314992815256119,
-0.44460731744766235,
-0.2136111855506897,
-0.8064423203468323,
-0.1626087725162506,
-0.5033201575279236,
-0.004940561018884182,
-0.12917828559875488,
-0.09789552539587021,
-0.412749707698822,
-0.09443123638629913,
0.3827511668205261,
0.3916596472263336,
0.03578084334731102,
0.32535240054130554,
-0.5080505609512329,
0.5284922122955322,
0.3774105906486511,
-0.11028479039669037,
-0.3587791323661804,
-0.5981731414794922,
0.20042891800403595,
0.33389830589294434,
-0.14642544090747833,
-0.35584574937820435,
0.5860517024993896,
0.16054415702819824,
0.41778698563575745,
0.1221274584531784,
0.384014368057251,
0.8189084529876709,
-0.6091720461845398,
0.8326963186264038,
-0.02932831645011902,
-0.9153734445571899,
0.7089956402778625,
-0.5827727913856506,
0.47499924898147583,
0.44845083355903625,
0.3981165885925293,
-0.5398350358009338,
-0.4330942630767822,
-0.5001533627510071,
-0.7545891404151917,
0.9485454559326172,
0.1719433069229126,
0.6434469223022461,
0.08082034438848495,
0.33025017380714417,
0.28821176290512085,
0.06444906443357468,
-0.465675413608551,
-0.026706529781222343,
0.11037054657936096,
-0.0011382604716345668,
0.19818463921546936,
-0.0845227763056755,
-0.35504135489463806,
-0.18187539279460907,
0.5703317523002625,
-0.4198671579360962,
0.2896787226200104,
0.2030893713235855,
-0.08677449077367783,
-0.05665898695588112,
0.23070749640464783,
0.4179478585720062,
0.5728939175605774,
-0.2941383421421051,
0.12736988067626953,
0.255950927734375,
-0.1240469440817833,
0.14276669919490814,
0.048323918133974075,
-0.31061607599258423,
0.19396546483039856,
0.05536095052957535,
1.0565688610076904,
0.08702675998210907,
-0.9892870187759399,
0.38179075717926025,
-0.3595784306526184,
-0.01463362853974104,
-0.4814695119857788,
0.2505919337272644,
-0.04358586668968201,
0.020113447681069374,
0.1564941257238388,
0.12071514129638672,
0.252928763628006,
-0.7609526515007019,
0.12551476061344147,
0.34512579441070557,
-0.5557063817977905,
-0.5735053420066833,
0.35178592801094055,
0.532767117023468,
-0.37366533279418945,
0.8758582472801208,
-0.09647130221128464,
-0.2042209655046463,
0.5072647929191589,
0.6828017234802246,
0.7916757464408875,
-0.1450476497411728,
0.44474396109580994,
0.2520088255405426,
0.03949315845966339,
0.023704707622528076,
0.35111841559410095,
-0.2517223656177521,
-0.6294880509376526,
-0.3043595552444458,
-0.2597452700138092,
-0.6482660174369812,
0.01826796866953373,
-0.677172064781189,
0.4275610148906708,
-0.38608720898628235,
-0.24616730213165283,
0.01578647643327713,
-0.31471535563468933,
-0.9664109349250793,
0.06472722440958023,
-0.19959568977355957,
0.7276261448860168,
-0.5703547596931458,
0.808504045009613,
0.40782925486564636,
-0.10297321528196335,
-0.5302444100379944,
0.01925543323159218,
0.18469767272472382,
-0.6168357729911804,
1.0221211910247803,
-0.1513921618461609,
-0.17844580113887787,
-0.17383183538913727,
-0.6041972041130066,
-0.7187427878379822,
0.7605782151222229,
0.7509179711341858,
-0.5655962228775024,
-0.23076708614826202,
0.4001423418521881,
0.46096542477607727,
-0.3586747646331787,
0.2924429774284363,
0.5005528926849365,
0.33576515316963196,
0.13139794766902924,
-0.9943690299987793,
0.10704652220010757,
-0.2656397521495819,
-0.05646313726902008,
0.015717346221208572,
-0.5862852931022644,
0.6948188543319702,
-0.1096256673336029,
-0.25903403759002686,
0.1368066817522049,
0.523055374622345,
0.24139860272407532,
0.3697755038738251,
0.8076022863388062,
0.27630436420440674,
0.5308138132095337,
-0.22330118715763092,
1.3066660165786743,
-0.038593292236328125,
-0.300809770822525,
1.4876042604446411,
-0.762936532497406,
0.608878493309021,
0.6467235088348389,
0.2484009712934494,
0.4072774350643158,
0.6079950332641602,
0.22036394476890564,
0.6107116341590881,
0.5599529147148132,
-0.6391928195953369,
-0.20483794808387756,
-0.9165948629379272,
-0.11075697839260101,
0.3566420078277588,
0.4940105378627777,
-0.053517863154411316,
-0.06241730973124504,
0.22013579308986664,
0.046369340270757675,
0.009394562803208828,
0.12763890624046326,
0.9636500477790833,
-0.007950916886329651,
-1.0632878541946411,
0.5289863348007202,
-0.03820616006851196,
0.41087162494659424,
-0.7041154503822327,
-0.10840154439210892,
-0.34380337595939636,
-0.15103985369205475,
-0.010804185643792152,
-0.2833158075809479,
0.2162892371416092,
0.45342567563056946,
-0.015723349526524544,
-0.4405040144920349,
0.507884681224823,
-0.2344975620508194,
-0.46255242824554443,
0.22699150443077087,
0.49182093143463135,
0.06595472246408463,
-0.0658123716711998,
-0.7396666407585144,
0.11397693306207657,
0.05588221177458763,
-0.3367745876312256,
0.2994142472743988,
0.25463730096817017,
-0.20383232831954956,
0.816516101360321,
0.6932366490364075,
0.10523800551891327,
0.003865380771458149,
0.2918113172054291,
0.9047139883041382,
-0.5057735443115234,
-0.10054273903369904,
-0.5769616961479187,
0.4086834490299225,
-0.14712722599506378,
-0.2675624489784241,
0.6074022054672241,
0.23622500896453857,
0.6624397039413452,
-0.0455506332218647,
0.9895879626274109,
-0.17944754660129547,
0.6148467063903809,
-0.5396719574928284,
0.04310845956206322,
-0.33329302072525024,
0.34899139404296875,
-0.2004774957895279,
-0.965537965297699,
0.09240249544382095,
0.29995495080947876,
-0.09029623866081238,
-0.3002025783061981,
0.2858361601829529,
0.9176189303398132,
-0.32751980423927307,
0.20242151618003845,
0.1312900185585022,
0.2664533853530884,
0.5290017127990723,
0.3659851849079132,
1.1197559833526611,
-0.1964820921421051,
0.35978808999061584,
-0.35394036769866943,
0.15740478038787842,
-0.21026401221752167,
-0.8898620009422302,
-0.7875379323959351,
-0.7698961496353149,
-0.5229746699333191,
-0.3413916528224945,
0.1525995135307312,
1.1612753868103027,
0.8498342037200928,
-0.6854870319366455,
-0.3569033145904541,
-0.29745298624038696,
-0.15416084229946136,
-0.05680013820528984,
-0.28069359064102173,
-0.02111058309674263,
-0.19994832575321198,
-1.0142732858657837,
0.7116484642028809,
0.0856640413403511,
0.06972286105155945,
-0.3249998390674591,
-0.03249426931142807,
-0.003971681464463472,
0.4286147356033325,
0.4835446774959564,
0.36336439847946167,
-0.8491131067276001,
-0.37524139881134033,
0.1485174000263214,
-0.11604055762290955,
-0.08906830847263336,
1.0476555824279785,
-0.8612060546875,
0.5048267841339111,
0.4386643171310425,
0.524265468120575,
0.5393481254577637,
0.014814740046858788,
1.0280916690826416,
-0.9579272866249084,
0.19717442989349365,
0.4403326213359833,
0.157626211643219,
0.30469584465026855,
-0.4432171881198883,
0.5700764060020447,
0.0519057996571064,
-0.1171012744307518,
-1.1082569360733032,
0.3730040192604065,
-0.9458362460136414,
-0.02368282526731491,
1.1458061933517456,
-0.27943894267082214,
0.05559723451733589,
-0.3165157735347748,
-0.4888807237148285,
-0.09931468218564987,
-0.5005691647529602,
0.6492276787757874,
0.5701100826263428,
-0.36995285749435425,
0.09586817026138306,
-0.7097897529602051,
0.6050965785980225,
0.6239905953407288,
-1.0533815622329712,
0.4119168519973755,
0.6152473092079163,
0.1723869889974594,
0.07484198361635208,
0.6531220078468323,
0.3494815230369568,
0.025335729122161865,
-0.2298973798751831,
-0.41012439131736755,
0.2599391043186188,
-0.22355277836322784,
0.10717561095952988,
-0.06544962525367737,
-0.056184180080890656,
0.11677699536085129
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.07791v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.07791v1
|
Judging the Judges: A Systematic Investigation of Position Bias in Pairwise Comparative Assessments by LLMs
| 2024-06-12T01:12:28 | 2024-06-12T01:12:28 |
Lin Shi, Weicheng Ma, Soroush Vosoughi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
LLM-as-a-Judge offers a promising alternative to human judges across various
tasks, yet inherent biases, particularly position bias - a systematic
preference for answers based on their position in the prompt - compromise its
effectiveness. Our study investigates this issue by developing a framework to
systematically study and quantify position bias using metrics such as
repetitional consistency, positional consistency, and positional fairness. We
conduct experiments with 9 judge models across 22 tasks from the MTBench and
DevBench benchmarks and nearly 40 answer-generating models, generating
approximately 80,000 evaluation instances. This comprehensive assessment
reveals significant variations in bias across judges and tasks. Although GPT-4
often excels in positional consistency and fairness, some more cost-effective
models perform comparably or even better in specific tasks, highlighting
essential trade-offs between consistency, fairness, and cost. Our results also
demonstrate high consistency of judgment across repetitions, confirming that
position bias is not due to random variations. This research significantly
contributes to the field by introducing new concepts for understanding position
bias and providing a multi-dimensional framework for evaluation. These insights
guide the selection of optimal judge models, enhance benchmark design, and lay
the foundation for future research into effective debiasing strategies,
ultimately enhancing the reliability of LLM evaluators.
|
[
-0.46851107478141785,
-0.17550237476825714,
1.0794858932495117,
0.17040212452411652,
-0.05595967546105385,
-0.156757652759552,
0.022572020068764687,
-0.3684346377849579,
0.22572176158428192,
0.21124255657196045,
-0.15113423764705658,
-0.3707196116447449,
-0.891384482383728,
0.07062516361474991,
-0.3160863220691681,
0.7251103520393372,
-0.09594102948904037,
0.6327743530273438,
-0.352402001619339,
-0.34123966097831726,
-0.705735981464386,
-0.6123502254486084,
-0.40083667635917664,
-0.5240660905838013,
0.4662545919418335,
0.400552362203598,
0.7336859107017517,
0.4048725962638855,
0.5277777314186096,
0.23326100409030914,
-0.12853294610977173,
-0.16688795387744904,
-0.24154601991176605,
0.06765808910131454,
-0.4870327115058899,
-0.5613299608230591,
-0.45903825759887695,
0.7687953114509583,
0.389890193939209,
0.8099861741065979,
-0.39774999022483826,
0.16300079226493835,
-0.03280049189925194,
0.6024627685546875,
-0.6801922917366028,
-0.17994104325771332,
-0.5293024778366089,
0.20484167337417603,
-0.3646955192089081,
-0.2386946827173233,
-0.3594210147857666,
-0.6086810827255249,
0.07154101133346558,
-0.44457465410232544,
0.35486671328544617,
0.12904757261276245,
0.5981729626655579,
0.35405176877975464,
-0.9324942827224731,
0.11274591833353043,
-0.43133431673049927,
0.7419242858886719,
-0.5552148818969727,
0.4144454300403595,
0.45353418588638306,
0.3437574803829193,
0.10136847198009491,
-0.5599314570426941,
-0.2989642322063446,
-0.4066756069660187,
-0.07254127413034439,
0.43137046694755554,
0.1728518307209015,
0.06916839629411697,
0.4813167452812195,
0.2150689959526062,
-0.3424040973186493,
0.22893553972244263,
-0.016407901421189308,
-0.010252274572849274,
0.6003333926200867,
0.1983654946088791,
-0.0717742070555687,
-0.4021800458431244,
-0.35839954018592834,
-0.05425267294049263,
-0.6216181516647339,
0.2842603325843811,
0.674088716506958,
-0.017954107373952866,
0.20688438415527344,
0.39710533618927,
-0.5125283598899841,
0.7076717019081116,
0.5824964642524719,
0.0857248604297638,
-0.03643941879272461,
-0.3000660240650177,
-0.1205618679523468,
-0.07732760906219482,
0.6020187735557556,
0.8844493627548218,
-0.041010335087776184,
-0.133377343416214,
-0.2890745997428894,
0.21928411722183228,
0.7830776572227478,
-0.46605178713798523,
-0.16687564551830292,
-0.06275812536478043,
-0.6337108016014099,
-0.6172641515731812,
0.410826712846756,
-0.662041962146759,
-0.7241687774658203,
-0.6541434526443481,
0.3806774616241455,
0.1884402632713318,
0.08662031590938568,
-0.0072806719690561295,
-0.2432449460029602,
0.14672578871250153,
0.28123241662979126,
-0.8682671189308167,
0.48968732357025146,
0.7751910090446472,
0.4054570198059082,
-0.6108807325363159,
-0.379225492477417,
-0.600673258304596,
-0.1402326077222824,
-0.3928605616092682,
0.9383111000061035,
-0.5406705141067505,
-0.6418090462684631,
-0.2629839777946472,
-0.23195409774780273,
0.13594527542591095,
-0.7976493239402771,
0.9475757479667664,
-0.5031986236572266,
0.2568124234676361,
-0.8612886071205139,
-0.47101935744285583,
0.030522625893354416,
0.5720698237419128,
-0.6706387996673584,
1.0408155918121338,
0.1019824892282486,
-0.7324069738388062,
1.0295149087905884,
-0.3846922218799591,
-0.10290790349245071,
-0.3227541148662567,
-0.3874729871749878,
-0.1953164041042328,
0.34578269720077515,
0.4246000647544861,
0.04982537403702736,
-0.278544157743454,
0.4705412983894348,
-0.4449930191040039,
-0.7286711931228638,
0.21248523890972137,
-0.32990723848342896,
0.4181217551231384,
0.10945790261030197,
-0.519997239112854,
0.21998187899589539,
-0.5199871063232422,
-0.06827761977910995,
0.03327754884958267,
-0.24457646906375885,
-0.2744360864162445,
0.15356546640396118,
-0.33045604825019836,
0.15096619725227356,
-0.03815523162484169,
-0.3983907401561737,
0.11801028996706009,
-0.1273137480020523,
0.2192486822605133,
1.049169898033142,
0.005982476286590099,
0.7577878832817078,
-0.5248150825500488,
0.6456961631774902,
-0.0733671635389328,
0.47268128395080566,
0.31041139364242554,
-0.3080015778541565,
-0.3874053657054901,
0.226557657122612,
0.6565950512886047,
0.4243929088115692,
-0.3377417027950287,
0.18231989443302155,
-0.16474491357803345,
-0.1609705239534378,
-0.5254132747650146,
-0.006971626076847315,
0.31858766078948975,
0.5907232761383057,
0.15641151368618011,
-0.8101752400398254,
-0.3264502286911011,
-1.1029585599899292,
-0.6229671835899353,
0.018789304420351982,
0.07441404461860657,
0.13657066226005554,
0.38271692395210266,
0.23542939126491547,
0.9024584293365479,
-0.035963024944067,
0.15687040984630585,
0.15700329840183258,
-0.02027958631515503,
0.44047147035598755,
0.33273082971572876,
0.6108595728874207,
-0.6241447329521179,
-0.35584524273872375,
-0.5052780508995056,
-0.83067786693573,
-0.49061277508735657,
0.0613505057990551,
-0.5056814551353455,
-0.15942339599132538,
0.2229345291852951,
-0.5251603722572327,
0.598163902759552,
0.3128725290298462,
-0.4575423002243042,
0.8439489006996155,
0.0341801755130291,
0.5563870668411255,
-0.38984906673431396,
0.06772401183843613,
-0.07495923340320587,
-0.3498046100139618,
-0.34631583094596863,
0.14917726814746857,
0.11348458379507065,
0.4595010280609131,
-0.2503659725189209,
0.5929497480392456,
-0.3555000126361847,
-0.5077106356620789,
-0.41187652945518494,
0.5173183083534241,
0.30693942308425903,
0.24431155622005463,
-0.2480892688035965,
0.6049318313598633,
-0.02531411685049534,
-0.31404611468315125,
0.38208436965942383,
0.27825164794921875,
-0.5394189953804016,
1.2758151292800903,
-0.585207998752594,
0.33917245268821716,
0.23572011291980743,
0.5455141663551331,
-0.7804641127586365,
0.06052841991186142,
0.30728456377983093,
-0.18949392437934875,
0.2935826778411865,
-0.45696693658828735,
-0.4908697009086609,
-0.5295789241790771,
-0.5360890030860901,
0.4460624158382416,
0.2543652355670929,
-0.6871623992919922,
0.18731239438056946,
0.2335120439529419,
-0.23528005182743073,
-0.9914765954017639,
-0.3419012725353241,
0.0146047193557024,
-0.4107336699962616,
-0.42199045419692993,
0.5472109913825989,
-0.05535001680254936,
-0.7704477906227112,
-0.1534736007452011,
-0.7554044127464294,
0.405355304479599,
0.25442907214164734,
0.2670016586780548,
0.1631019413471222,
0.19686105847358704,
-0.156066432595253,
-0.15668213367462158,
-0.37458398938179016,
0.17090871930122375,
-0.2712421417236328,
0.30025479197502136,
0.18215273320674896,
-0.938694179058075,
-0.4656483829021454,
0.20512397587299347,
0.25846096873283386,
-0.010845895856618881,
0.16786086559295654,
0.1374012529850006,
-0.01932697370648384,
-0.0003079746675211936,
-0.8161841630935669,
-0.1188027560710907,
-0.4016001522541046,
0.02305871620774269,
-0.49612146615982056,
-0.5605073571205139,
0.44218775629997253,
0.31216734647750854,
0.1320733278989792,
0.2301078587770462,
0.5719712972640991,
-0.1780947595834732,
1.01955246925354,
0.3745426535606384,
-0.2728830575942993,
0.5355411767959595,
0.17301048338413239,
0.13140389323234558,
-0.8072651028633118,
-0.08839094638824463,
-0.5191566944122314,
-0.8746364712715149,
-0.38275858759880066,
-0.3101550340652466,
0.44311589002609253,
0.2849067151546478,
-0.5658342838287354,
-0.16065102815628052,
-0.5579253435134888,
0.6529621481895447,
0.9649825692176819,
0.23425349593162537,
0.3816753625869751,
-0.2892427146434784,
-0.5051645636558533,
-0.045457907021045685,
-0.2937818169593811,
-0.6696814298629761,
1.2538187503814697,
0.18715550005435944,
0.4920845627784729,
0.014315922744572163,
0.8057986497879028,
0.423539936542511,
0.3871280252933502,
-0.61810302734375,
0.4170350134372711,
0.02115047164261341,
-0.6507555246353149,
-0.04008884355425835,
-0.13113939762115479,
-0.5508817434310913,
0.7778915762901306,
0.08426882326602936,
-0.5019741058349609,
0.22250552475452423,
0.17085027694702148,
-0.42263129353523254,
0.23231011629104614,
-0.4579443633556366,
0.9096473455429077,
-0.5434962511062622,
-0.6708889007568359,
-0.20725083351135254,
-0.7550097107887268,
0.21559806168079376,
0.11685572564601898,
0.1440621167421341,
-0.20443078875541687,
0.062129102647304535,
0.63103848695755,
-0.4077962636947632,
0.5683035850524902,
-0.8294453024864197,
-0.12474974989891052,
0.05412014573812485,
0.29835179448127747,
0.5508662462234497,
0.2904905378818512,
-0.5038350224494934,
0.05288702994585037,
0.03332647681236267,
-0.43528929352760315,
-0.6266723871231079,
0.6075506210327148,
-0.6421629190444946,
-0.7898840308189392,
-0.5223454236984253,
-0.4734111428260803,
-0.5644320845603943,
0.014120474457740784,
0.17379158735275269,
0.28191685676574707,
-0.2754893898963928,
-0.2789185047149658,
0.3567187190055847,
-0.15051785111427307,
0.10813011974096298,
0.5619183778762817,
-0.13975653052330017,
-0.2344275414943695,
0.2087198793888092,
-0.11998070776462555,
0.006869001314043999,
0.3336651623249054,
0.20538504421710968,
-0.45392924547195435,
-0.7662726640701294,
-0.37870073318481445,
-0.01972576603293419,
-0.8081300854682922,
-0.09386953711509705,
-0.2203352153301239,
0.28117650747299194,
-0.24657593667507172,
-0.341591477394104,
-0.23879867792129517,
-0.6243936419487,
0.27313852310180664,
-0.6808043718338013,
-0.06484092026948929,
0.8710572123527527,
-0.13435299694538116,
0.38368064165115356,
-0.11024308204650879,
0.3670937418937683,
0.47566190361976624,
0.5424556732177734,
-0.10862446576356888,
-0.6996021270751953,
0.26879769563674927,
-0.08563916385173798,
-0.6032264232635498,
-0.6572344303131104,
0.04555150493979454,
-0.5361652374267578,
1.0534709692001343,
0.3658643960952759,
-0.1317926049232483,
0.62318354845047,
-0.5393002033233643,
0.9498279094696045,
0.24222618341445923,
-0.9411293268203735,
0.5349231362342834,
-0.38020268082618713,
0.07132889330387115,
0.8248822093009949,
-0.03711681813001633,
-0.46220725774765015,
-0.2489238828420639,
-0.6124486327171326,
-0.7290573716163635,
0.9588907957077026,
-0.004866764415055513,
-0.26636651158332825,
0.0045920745469629765,
0.4331022799015045,
0.3074021339416504,
0.47135791182518005,
-0.7831709980964661,
-0.16394445300102234,
-0.15406545996665955,
-0.0168102215975523,
-0.10395326465368271,
-0.3553584814071655,
-0.5008587837219238,
-0.16802090406417847,
0.39425310492515564,
0.07553566247224808,
0.21673904359340668,
0.11985815316438675,
-0.31255042552948,
-0.04185148701071739,
0.3827195465564728,
0.5509346127510071,
0.867871880531311,
-0.17228689789772034,
0.38378626108169556,
0.40252840518951416,
0.07276179641485214,
0.24779760837554932,
0.09248072654008865,
-0.31392931938171387,
-0.05411810800433159,
0.11647667735815048,
0.5703319311141968,
0.45372986793518066,
-0.18464279174804688,
0.6558491587638855,
0.09986122697591782,
-0.27932560443878174,
-0.27997761964797974,
-0.1634751409292221,
-0.07047086209058762,
0.5251348614692688,
0.013738466426730156,
0.16828693449497223,
0.36967092752456665,
-0.3562466502189636,
0.4082131087779999,
0.396269291639328,
-0.4253144860267639,
-0.2135317623615265,
1.034973382949829,
0.27116909623146057,
-0.05577012524008751,
0.4829121530056,
-0.22046051919460297,
-0.5158465504646301,
0.7171290516853333,
0.06054011732339859,
0.5728728175163269,
-0.07109460979700089,
0.10160631686449051,
0.11262674629688263,
-0.01174593809992075,
-0.5868105888366699,
0.2242787480354309,
-0.26736244559288025,
-0.694213330745697,
0.0740710198879242,
-0.5544187426567078,
-0.6879605650901794,
-0.4380551278591156,
-0.9678863883018494,
0.13105453550815582,
-0.40136560797691345,
-0.6433829069137573,
-0.1548766791820526,
0.12291346490383148,
-0.9030085802078247,
0.0034396799746900797,
0.3853405714035034,
0.8718093037605286,
-0.5396562814712524,
0.5787088871002197,
0.702752411365509,
-0.2705628275871277,
-0.5464352965354919,
-0.04950869083404541,
0.4245942234992981,
-0.9985578060150146,
0.5833317637443542,
0.2512822449207306,
-0.07890743762254715,
-0.5651633143424988,
-0.5367632508277893,
-0.5256731510162354,
1.2194652557373047,
0.330762654542923,
-0.6286042928695679,
-0.05736285820603371,
-0.11978267878293991,
0.4534878730773926,
-0.13762623071670532,
0.695301353931427,
0.8395193219184875,
0.7016889452934265,
-0.3400062024593353,
-1.180613398551941,
0.015873398631811142,
-0.19233407080173492,
0.03974303603172302,
0.18923942744731903,
-0.9168863296508789,
0.4510033428668976,
-0.0753762349486351,
0.33091822266578674,
0.24690212309360504,
0.1371278315782547,
0.6177246570587158,
0.5798426270484924,
0.6032865047454834,
0.6895697116851807,
0.8309038281440735,
-0.31461232900619507,
1.2020803689956665,
-0.2484624683856964,
0.2699454128742218,
1.2916542291641235,
-0.767708420753479,
0.5021700859069824,
0.67391037940979,
-0.42266738414764404,
0.5103839039802551,
0.7426925301551819,
-0.33554282784461975,
0.5850356221199036,
0.5156874060630798,
-0.10958149284124374,
-0.19531749188899994,
0.01233496144413948,
-0.22048217058181763,
0.33539894223213196,
-0.16689002513885498,
-0.5016102194786072,
-0.08341734111309052,
-0.3115748465061188,
-0.12121602147817612,
0.2853502631187439,
-0.38903504610061646,
0.36142992973327637,
0.33458033204078674,
-0.9266082048416138,
-0.06549835205078125,
0.2782674729824066,
0.8106837868690491,
-0.4120217263698578,
0.3193728029727936,
-0.5045103430747986,
0.16784299910068512,
-0.1912238746881485,
-0.7482751607894897,
-0.06041201204061508,
0.03371212258934975,
-0.41477611660957336,
-0.7647345066070557,
0.37552502751350403,
0.11525338143110275,
-0.18643487989902496,
0.5295180678367615,
0.6689008474349976,
0.043858740478754044,
-0.1006166934967041,
-0.7009541392326355,
-0.0538569912314415,
-0.21181495487689972,
-0.44222143292427063,
0.42942044138908386,
0.3190056085586548,
-0.2104959338903427,
0.3147127330303192,
0.21672821044921875,
0.030770983546972275,
0.1598213165998459,
0.6279467940330505,
0.38059625029563904,
-0.9238005876541138,
-0.5689988732337952,
-0.7120745778083801,
0.3527410924434662,
-0.2267000675201416,
-0.11314179748296738,
0.7466320395469666,
0.40072593092918396,
0.852719247341156,
0.09118703752756119,
0.6668273210525513,
0.042374465614557266,
0.6275956034660339,
-0.5194965600967407,
0.46265459060668945,
-0.4780493676662445,
0.37532955408096313,
-0.3155979812145233,
-0.8762527108192444,
-0.03535926342010498,
0.6498823165893555,
-0.6505658030509949,
0.39202091097831726,
0.6925097703933716,
0.44969990849494934,
-0.08628208190202713,
0.08265478163957596,
0.19934646785259247,
-0.000436771078966558,
0.26748591661453247,
0.49229690432548523,
1.1999506950378418,
-0.25407466292381287,
0.2897208333015442,
-0.30994802713394165,
-0.10293751209974289,
-0.12446962296962738,
-0.5885072350502014,
-0.6663171648979187,
0.13814352452754974,
-0.08319677412509918,
-0.08191996067762375,
-0.021975265815854073,
0.719769299030304,
0.829207718372345,
-0.897654116153717,
-0.3708503544330597,
0.3193355202674866,
0.11294405162334442,
-0.46397802233695984,
-0.16708596050739288,
0.24670837819576263,
-0.21781010925769806,
-0.788628101348877,
0.4866519868373871,
0.08350303769111633,
-0.4305519461631775,
0.18582385778427124,
-0.09164638817310333,
0.16589608788490295,
-0.19461064040660858,
0.48371532559394836,
-0.17142926156520844,
-0.9330058693885803,
-0.5653796792030334,
-0.21483579277992249,
-0.20868459343910217,
0.22459492087364197,
0.8912184834480286,
-0.8031840920448303,
0.4632759094238281,
0.3450884521007538,
0.3091394007205963,
0.3682344853878021,
0.6167623996734619,
0.689421534538269,
-0.6741693615913391,
0.029193172231316566,
0.08793207257986069,
0.6976028084754944,
0.10159945487976074,
-0.09944993257522583,
0.792123556137085,
0.36463576555252075,
-0.7163361310958862,
-0.798786997795105,
0.2820214629173279,
-1.1757283210754395,
-0.10131335258483887,
0.8874885439872742,
0.14718864858150482,
0.4203394055366516,
0.09920119494199753,
-0.17136934399604797,
0.02148127742111683,
-0.4335084557533264,
0.9152085185050964,
1.049506425857544,
-0.4433301091194153,
0.047365061938762665,
-0.8718582987785339,
0.2185424268245697,
0.7153796553611755,
-0.3613027036190033,
-0.2870379090309143,
0.5849774479866028,
0.6775434613227844,
-0.1625944823026657,
0.8505772948265076,
-0.42417868971824646,
0.21516695618629456,
-0.056382279843091965,
-0.004971442744135857,
0.06641582399606705,
-0.17326080799102783,
-0.6485918164253235,
0.2740861177444458,
0.26868176460266113,
0.0074057746678590775
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.07780v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.07780v1
|
A Critical Look At Tokenwise Reward-Guided Text Generation
| 2024-06-12T00:19:40 | 2024-06-12T00:19:40 |
Ahmad Rashid, Ruotian Wu, Julia Grosse, Agustinus Kristiadi, Pascal Poupart
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) can significantly be improved by aligning to
human preferences -- the so-called reinforcement learning from human feedback
(RLHF). However, the cost of fine-tuning an LLM is prohibitive for many users.
Due to their ability to bypass LLM finetuning, tokenwise reward-guided text
generation (RGTG) methods have recently been proposed. They use a reward model
trained on full sequences to score partial sequences during a tokenwise
decoding, in a bid to steer the generation towards sequences with high rewards.
However, these methods have so far been only heuristically motivated and poorly
analyzed. In this work, we show that reward models trained on full sequences
are not compatible with scoring partial sequences. To alleviate this issue, we
propose to explicitly train a Bradley-Terry reward model on partial sequences,
and autoregressively sample from the implied tokenwise policy during decoding
time. We study the property of this reward model and the implied policy. In
particular, we show that this policy is proportional to the ratio of two
distinct RLHF policies. We show that our simple approach outperforms previous
RGTG methods and achieves similar performance as strong offline baselines but
without large-scale LLM finetuning.
|
[
-0.06918271631002426,
-0.4406874477863312,
0.5221293568611145,
0.07590754330158234,
-0.3042850196361542,
0.022388095036149025,
-0.480917751789093,
-0.24774238467216492,
0.04187518358230591,
0.5679656863212585,
-0.7536161541938782,
-0.4270140528678894,
-0.6307386755943298,
0.31410497426986694,
-0.10021660476922989,
1.3104028701782227,
-0.09894587099552155,
-0.1484757363796234,
0.0720808207988739,
-0.08155948668718338,
-0.518869161605835,
-0.5491403937339783,
-0.890372097492218,
-0.4517833888530731,
0.8883023858070374,
0.3957160711288452,
0.5619869232177734,
0.8269708156585693,
0.1935003697872162,
0.1722053438425064,
-0.08669057488441467,
0.40621694922447205,
-0.6389886140823364,
0.08758325129747391,
-0.09563719481229782,
-0.5550026297569275,
-0.1477571725845337,
0.13390806317329407,
0.3413379192352295,
0.22328293323516846,
-0.27733880281448364,
-0.11408212035894394,
0.08013929426670074,
0.7187343239784241,
-0.49560827016830444,
0.14552618563175201,
-0.5718342661857605,
0.32882755994796753,
0.1525985449552536,
-0.41744303703308105,
-0.7687404155731201,
-0.473257839679718,
-0.01960562728345394,
-0.5233559012413025,
0.06367339938879013,
0.2872548997402191,
0.8336037397384644,
0.2640080451965332,
-0.5644107460975647,
-0.4474693834781647,
-0.3987123370170593,
0.8561325073242188,
-0.732995867729187,
0.03194553032517433,
0.4825415313243866,
-0.06076459214091301,
-0.25903838872909546,
-0.4900418519973755,
-0.4443013370037079,
-0.5137518048286438,
-0.17539887130260468,
0.20694522559642792,
0.006071641109883785,
0.501976490020752,
0.3463873267173767,
0.2863018214702606,
-0.4476052522659302,
0.23349589109420776,
-0.14260174334049225,
-0.19794373214244843,
0.49059873819351196,
0.23651476204395294,
-0.060691073536872864,
-0.6645546555519104,
-0.6180402040481567,
-0.42530572414398193,
-0.9552727341651917,
0.41288089752197266,
0.6528844833374023,
0.49710920453071594,
-0.08583522588014603,
0.5285733342170715,
0.03909440338611603,
0.6536104679107666,
0.13592089712619781,
-0.11125385016202927,
-0.07537755370140076,
-0.2623152732849121,
-0.1327807903289795,
0.17110799252986908,
0.900540292263031,
0.20764152705669403,
0.2509865462779999,
-0.22288687527179718,
-0.5525548458099365,
-0.1804165542125702,
0.32865285873413086,
-0.7549341917037964,
-0.025077398866415024,
0.23480695486068726,
-0.5228118896484375,
-0.5708348751068115,
0.17981721460819244,
-0.27574434876441956,
-0.24254395067691803,
-0.3515145778656006,
0.34867846965789795,
-0.2512941062450409,
-0.0804673284292221,
0.09439408034086227,
-0.14769774675369263,
0.21105967462062836,
0.04065469279885292,
-1.0726711750030518,
-0.15048879384994507,
0.7963539361953735,
0.7710294723510742,
-0.3590252101421356,
-0.3227045238018036,
-0.930186927318573,
0.0828721672296524,
-0.2666396200656891,
0.5897236466407776,
-0.41491103172302246,
-0.6342563033103943,
0.30449825525283813,
-0.009629188105463982,
0.14495736360549927,
-0.4513096511363983,
0.6545001864433289,
-0.409229040145874,
0.12033981084823608,
-0.4108111262321472,
-0.5264288783073425,
0.10773784667253494,
0.43956127762794495,
-0.5980497598648071,
0.8847872018814087,
0.2069021314382553,
-0.6868011355400085,
0.6353384852409363,
-0.33649328351020813,
-0.5688494443893433,
-0.13377468287944794,
-0.2897084653377533,
-0.48216795921325684,
0.16798192262649536,
0.21769019961357117,
0.3813202679157257,
-0.20024926960468292,
0.7278639674186707,
-0.1898457258939743,
-0.5928959846496582,
0.3239811360836029,
-0.6330678462982178,
0.2131386548280716,
0.25404614210128784,
-0.5954743027687073,
0.407772958278656,
-0.5358512997627258,
-0.004733372945338488,
-0.07556010782718658,
-0.7336273789405823,
-0.1149333119392395,
0.034242816269397736,
0.07794018089771271,
0.18832333385944366,
0.05285456031560898,
-0.3829721212387085,
0.47107189893722534,
-0.47125518321990967,
0.6236554980278015,
1.2729980945587158,
-0.14869870245456696,
0.5024611353874207,
-0.39286625385284424,
0.6585026383399963,
-0.027309872210025787,
0.20977924764156342,
-0.25156253576278687,
-0.09511326998472214,
-0.694844126701355,
-0.3140491545200348,
0.5801477432250977,
0.3563445508480072,
-0.7102031707763672,
0.5490012764930725,
-0.1076737716794014,
-0.04536599665880203,
-0.3019144833087921,
-0.14397935569286346,
0.5593014359474182,
0.32473504543304443,
0.22826652228832245,
-0.16615882515907288,
-0.31218379735946655,
-0.8411545753479004,
-0.3479878306388855,
-0.2760259211063385,
0.062194839119911194,
0.5233294367790222,
0.27487605810165405,
0.004320012405514717,
0.7860433459281921,
-0.4802078604698181,
-0.06845077872276306,
-0.34837642312049866,
0.47096186876296997,
0.20288720726966858,
0.3574817478656769,
0.2026740461587906,
-0.5568159222602844,
-0.3147854208946228,
-0.26742151379585266,
-0.35014858841896057,
-0.05033959448337555,
-0.4090181887149811,
-0.0899624228477478,
0.4048091769218445,
0.46277374029159546,
-0.41427868604660034,
0.3751142621040344,
0.468383252620697,
-0.5132275819778442,
0.28922775387763977,
-0.4174591898918152,
0.2149822860956192,
-0.8163930177688599,
-0.032968178391456604,
-0.11501310765743256,
-0.6593305468559265,
-0.2691894769668579,
0.07408618927001953,
0.0713878720998764,
0.024175386875867844,
-0.27130165696144104,
0.5297320485115051,
-0.25991469621658325,
-0.01802653819322586,
-0.6678470373153687,
-0.13806366920471191,
-0.04661225154995918,
0.8632246851921082,
0.16239716112613678,
0.8380845785140991,
0.012574992142617702,
-0.584029495716095,
0.2035045623779297,
0.2522636950016022,
-0.042523693293333054,
0.31381261348724365,
-0.5588553547859192,
0.06469161808490753,
-0.03244244307279587,
0.47944724559783936,
-0.7879271507263184,
-0.15573574602603912,
0.29248446226119995,
-0.422841876745224,
0.36557406187057495,
0.02377389743924141,
-0.434779554605484,
-0.1601739078760147,
-0.44596949219703674,
0.49242541193962097,
0.6215848922729492,
-0.9560790657997131,
0.42847222089767456,
0.04902283102273941,
-0.013984665274620056,
-0.6017419695854187,
-0.5747267603874207,
0.05573125556111336,
-0.34097903966903687,
-0.2923646867275238,
0.42496129870414734,
0.144737109541893,
0.14772577583789825,
-0.07939859479665756,
-0.11511692404747009,
0.4984973669052124,
-0.050357017666101456,
0.33903223276138306,
0.3402956426143646,
0.17766812443733215,
0.23446743190288544,
0.027439847588539124,
-0.27237510681152344,
0.04425480216741562,
-0.5311650037765503,
0.44009435176849365,
0.2529985308647156,
-0.33730223774909973,
-0.17209267616271973,
0.36726897954940796,
0.1504656821489334,
-0.033178962767124176,
0.6377639770507812,
0.6405676007270813,
0.045169293880462646,
-0.35901933908462524,
-0.2916066348552704,
-0.37641623616218567,
-0.4537527859210968,
0.3613017797470093,
-0.181786447763443,
-1.206847906112671,
0.22436591982841492,
-0.051178574562072754,
0.18201397359371185,
0.30124038457870483,
0.47244274616241455,
0.16645324230194092,
1.1770099401474,
0.6684114336967468,
0.011327823624014854,
0.5843230485916138,
0.04062945768237114,
0.10653573274612427,
-0.48017260432243347,
-0.34893909096717834,
-0.41454052925109863,
-0.2524418830871582,
-0.7303589582443237,
-0.011327791959047318,
0.34214621782302856,
0.1429477483034134,
-0.33129072189331055,
0.12380579113960266,
-0.551293134689331,
0.4853544533252716,
0.8017037510871887,
0.23032070696353912,
0.18922044336795807,
0.021537335589528084,
-0.17023810744285583,
0.1820223480463028,
-0.9550936818122864,
-0.3299283981323242,
1.1651548147201538,
0.18413645029067993,
0.7906829118728638,
-0.013604751788079739,
0.7845272421836853,
0.578001081943512,
0.2529238760471344,
-0.7050108909606934,
0.20548789203166962,
-0.18216156959533691,
-0.18479768931865692,
-0.35944467782974243,
-0.7163049578666687,
-0.9735841155052185,
-0.0019952200818806887,
-0.3567329943180084,
-0.33366748690605164,
-0.09965351969003677,
0.37965407967567444,
-0.5338155031204224,
0.14052250981330872,
-0.5945228934288025,
0.726487398147583,
-0.26839739084243774,
-0.4500728249549866,
-0.28195399045944214,
-0.5500546097755432,
0.4512743651866913,
0.11327313631772995,
0.048728425055742264,
0.09537137299776077,
0.21538549661636353,
0.8004146814346313,
-0.583060085773468,
0.7263287305831909,
-0.2447432577610016,
-0.16855734586715698,
0.06937921047210693,
0.049785442650318146,
0.8926444053649902,
0.20421089231967926,
0.17652617394924164,
-0.2607167363166809,
-0.05254977568984032,
-0.5670311450958252,
-0.3251156806945801,
0.6965895295143127,
-0.8581700921058655,
-0.7273372411727905,
-0.5538424849510193,
-0.4694533348083496,
-0.32108810544013977,
-0.19133318960666656,
0.379524290561676,
0.4998354911804199,
0.021964237093925476,
-0.14071685075759888,
0.7945631146430969,
-0.5491331815719604,
0.4652877449989319,
0.04334704205393791,
-0.199711874127388,
-0.5086572766304016,
0.947245717048645,
-0.45026513934135437,
0.37713423371315,
0.40321284532546997,
0.37475940585136414,
-0.6107177734375,
-0.27975335717201233,
-0.48976948857307434,
0.16313566267490387,
-0.6437918543815613,
-0.35295915603637695,
-0.21379753947257996,
-0.15535064041614532,
-0.2630471885204315,
-0.26414626836776733,
-0.08107753098011017,
-0.18247529864311218,
-0.4343513548374176,
-0.19125068187713623,
0.45982542634010315,
0.9153809547424316,
-0.2900506556034088,
0.31336936354637146,
-0.9327362775802612,
0.10287433862686157,
0.3384130895137787,
0.24190321564674377,
0.19381509721279144,
-0.5743650197982788,
-0.25089988112449646,
-0.039164211601018906,
-0.1720513552427292,
-0.6165897250175476,
0.24499544501304626,
-0.18005426228046417,
0.2772165834903717,
0.3020147383213043,
0.15646705031394958,
0.5263920426368713,
-0.5007940530776978,
0.7597677111625671,
0.5795590877532959,
-0.8338732123374939,
0.14926254749298096,
-0.3853255808353424,
0.22979804873466492,
0.4785284698009491,
0.030231112614274025,
-0.7372137904167175,
-0.20313306152820587,
-0.5016269087791443,
-0.9574649333953857,
1.0219066143035889,
-0.024252740666270256,
0.22369137406349182,
-0.21870625019073486,
0.5782343745231628,
0.2952013611793518,
0.23484843969345093,
-0.931345522403717,
0.0007002550410106778,
-0.40647467970848083,
-0.3752342462539673,
-0.004390810616314411,
-0.33527886867523193,
-0.1543172299861908,
0.05496643856167793,
0.6605386734008789,
-0.231587752699852,
0.3201003670692444,
0.21949274837970734,
0.05410030856728554,
-0.027939116582274437,
0.3578576445579529,
0.7876152396202087,
0.22871336340904236,
-0.16072331368923187,
0.0365440733730793,
-0.14030852913856506,
-0.20303356647491455,
0.34474167227745056,
-0.11647854000329971,
-0.14151793718338013,
-0.2660670578479767,
0.3007830083370209,
1.232150912284851,
0.13381974399089813,
-0.8566624522209167,
0.7610456347465515,
-0.16024352610111237,
-0.5607052445411682,
-0.24693243205547333,
0.14651332795619965,
-0.08523917943239212,
0.29367029666900635,
0.32187601923942566,
-0.15435242652893066,
-0.20676523447036743,
-0.43300479650497437,
0.08817176520824432,
0.4573404788970947,
-0.6649657487869263,
-0.013368968851864338,
0.6399019956588745,
0.32075849175453186,
-0.3692486882209778,
0.6737743020057678,
-0.45729494094848633,
-0.6100039482116699,
0.5411725044250488,
0.47359350323677063,
0.8297887444496155,
0.4471581280231476,
0.3669213652610779,
0.43096137046813965,
0.10738443583250046,
-0.386855810880661,
0.03958110883831978,
-0.3373892307281494,
-0.4064042270183563,
-0.6256323456764221,
-0.5245015025138855,
-0.3148398995399475,
0.08510564267635345,
-0.6439446210861206,
0.16193440556526184,
-0.32363957166671753,
-0.15346845984458923,
-0.504546046257019,
-0.28284844756126404,
-0.44107967615127563,
0.10158783197402954,
0.05194869637489319,
0.8168799877166748,
-0.5589593648910522,
0.6065627932548523,
0.1496497243642807,
-0.38161736726760864,
-1.195041537284851,
0.20721858739852905,
-0.3597620725631714,
-0.9479921460151672,
0.723691463470459,
0.0552423819899559,
-0.07066255062818527,
0.028274916112422943,
-0.4796552360057831,
-0.39354631304740906,
1.029306411743164,
0.1464051455259323,
-0.5927769541740417,
-0.4592658579349518,
0.19390380382537842,
0.22600403428077698,
-0.12589414417743683,
0.2903503179550171,
0.4544905722141266,
0.509166419506073,
0.25198379158973694,
-0.6474642157554626,
0.15358956158161163,
0.24779491126537323,
0.03867756947875023,
0.4119936227798462,
-0.7561363577842712,
0.578733503818512,
-0.10850606858730316,
-0.16169647872447968,
0.17943435907363892,
0.5294346809387207,
0.5453152656555176,
-0.08149272203445435,
0.6374027132987976,
0.4576778709888458,
0.5345908999443054,
-0.15282614529132843,
1.1138302087783813,
-0.2086005061864853,
0.38880041241645813,
0.6573848724365234,
-0.11753086745738983,
0.6823837757110596,
0.5780661702156067,
0.009890986606478691,
0.2873922884464264,
0.8686962127685547,
0.10617699474096298,
0.6951341032981873,
0.4964991807937622,
-0.17039279639720917,
-0.5673838257789612,
-0.1743154525756836,
-0.19625097513198853,
0.2591603994369507,
-0.18384245038032532,
-0.4443804919719696,
-0.23635262250900269,
0.1078491359949112,
0.003171969670802355,
0.16083204746246338,
-0.530441403388977,
0.7469683885574341,
0.05410194396972656,
-1.1437140703201294,
0.49793684482574463,
0.40425533056259155,
0.9942156672477722,
-0.680052638053894,
-0.0657058134675026,
-0.33993446826934814,
0.07474463433027267,
-0.12289521843194962,
-0.5353639125823975,
-0.06527986377477646,
0.19602802395820618,
-0.0389704555273056,
-0.450094997882843,
0.4018554091453552,
-0.40465047955513,
-0.10422491282224655,
0.08195115625858307,
0.30744993686676025,
-0.21415036916732788,
0.20566949248313904,
-0.5877729058265686,
-0.1750844419002533,
0.306640088558197,
-0.4109981060028076,
0.4801331162452698,
0.27665936946868896,
0.07773129642009735,
0.27864083647727966,
0.7706461548805237,
0.20388928055763245,
-0.03912391886115074,
0.08506374061107635,
0.594353199005127,
-0.9878669381141663,
-0.792277991771698,
-1.0187138319015503,
0.21414631605148315,
0.1691587269306183,
-0.33113881945610046,
0.3089838922023773,
0.4341704249382019,
0.8233481645584106,
0.12272816151380539,
0.7626425623893738,
0.22489500045776367,
0.2369653880596161,
-1.0256530046463013,
0.36637434363365173,
-0.6597556471824646,
0.19999006390571594,
0.11940188705921173,
-0.6727059483528137,
0.009944283403456211,
0.49944183230400085,
-0.08310981839895248,
0.11362142115831375,
0.7004752159118652,
0.7010249495506287,
0.1663733720779419,
0.05678027123212814,
0.29845282435417175,
-0.22149823606014252,
0.4039214849472046,
0.8999360203742981,
1.0226974487304688,
-0.020479632541537285,
0.7034624814987183,
0.3399626612663269,
-0.08280765265226364,
-0.06764215975999832,
-0.9355034232139587,
-0.979951798915863,
-0.47591719031333923,
0.1219555139541626,
-0.5677754282951355,
0.25339117646217346,
1.2707960605621338,
0.5399898290634155,
-0.5312659740447998,
-0.12671294808387756,
-0.4832226037979126,
0.045517198741436005,
-0.024766655638813972,
-0.1968165636062622,
0.4583183526992798,
-0.33639371395111084,
-0.6397688388824463,
0.13380222022533417,
0.3295849859714508,
-0.01280087511986494,
-0.4719817340373993,
-0.47351670265197754,
0.08293222635984421,
0.2768370509147644,
0.335720032453537,
0.303058385848999,
-0.7649521827697754,
-0.47490382194519043,
0.07281553000211716,
-0.4012470543384552,
0.1364586502313614,
1.186128854751587,
-0.8541896939277649,
-0.07024208456277847,
0.385189950466156,
0.7986652851104736,
0.5697470903396606,
0.1344132423400879,
0.5782369375228882,
-0.7785024642944336,
0.07759762555360794,
0.12935702502727509,
0.30619218945503235,
0.21393689513206482,
-0.3313356339931488,
0.21554678678512573,
0.14000986516475677,
-0.6776423454284668,
-0.8947036266326904,
0.5033572912216187,
-0.7744855284690857,
-0.4424591660499573,
1.4586870670318604,
-0.1390199065208435,
-0.2569240927696228,
0.21995526552200317,
-0.32705456018447876,
0.3328705430030823,
-0.5813788175582886,
0.8433517813682556,
0.6600444912910461,
-0.13939400017261505,
-0.03542833775281906,
-0.03669664263725281,
0.7272425889968872,
0.5261974334716797,
-0.6207339763641357,
0.21395111083984375,
0.4381365180015564,
0.09389108419418335,
-0.3593572676181793,
0.787118136882782,
0.16148248314857483,
0.3167535364627838,
-0.16790443658828735,
0.03653782606124878,
-0.36364662647247314,
-0.25153085589408875,
-0.49634215235710144,
0.08849390596151352,
0.49572643637657166,
0.009009715169668198
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.07778v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.07778v1
|
On Trojans in Refined Language Models
| 2024-06-12T00:01:32 | 2024-06-12T00:01:32 |
Jayaram Raghuram, George Kesidis, David J. Miller
|
cs.CR
|
cs.CR, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
A Trojan in a language model can be inserted when the model is refined for a
particular application such as determining the sentiment of product reviews. In
this paper, we clarify and empirically explore variations of the data-poisoning
threat model. We then empirically assess two simple defenses each for a
different defense scenario. Finally, we provide a brief survey of related
attacks and defenses.
|
[
-0.10000252723693848,
-1.0977433919906616,
0.37817293405532837,
-0.24171340465545654,
-0.021100172773003578,
0.05126609280705452,
0.14987923204898834,
-0.6794453859329224,
0.0006605170201510191,
0.6610909104347229,
-0.2558620572090149,
-0.3856939673423767,
-0.31786197423934937,
-0.1139545664191246,
-0.7346025705337524,
1.4116753339767456,
0.17725424468517303,
0.15279416739940643,
0.05486234650015831,
0.0989086776971817,
-0.6296343207359314,
-0.9528080224990845,
-0.5156243443489075,
0.04701549559831619,
0.495535671710968,
0.2852958142757416,
0.8048102259635925,
0.27847033739089966,
1.0068377256393433,
0.20583473145961761,
-0.04380951076745987,
-0.3432321846485138,
-0.1490498185157776,
0.43642738461494446,
-0.5009704828262329,
-0.8514593243598938,
-0.6013666391372681,
0.3200002610683441,
0.11730071157217026,
0.6492347121238708,
-0.052188605070114136,
0.14199988543987274,
-0.1679648607969284,
0.7404919862747192,
-0.8762304186820984,
-0.4632878601551056,
-0.9013432264328003,
0.13791735470294952,
-0.4193345606327057,
0.07218686491250992,
-1.0515642166137695,
-0.19278275966644287,
0.45672181248664856,
-0.3292357921600342,
0.23448041081428528,
0.36732977628707886,
0.9358304142951965,
-0.2467687875032425,
-0.6314584016799927,
-0.20793497562408447,
-1.0652731657028198,
1.0273960828781128,
-0.6677285432815552,
0.106290802359581,
0.15775658190250397,
0.529786229133606,
-0.369886577129364,
-1.0354374647140503,
-0.38931509852409363,
-0.7694857716560364,
-0.12185107916593552,
0.07546917349100113,
-0.634941577911377,
0.3000600039958954,
0.3099460005760193,
0.6576225161552429,
-0.529141902923584,
-0.007160720881074667,
-0.8798918724060059,
0.049744680523872375,
0.653072714805603,
0.6043715476989746,
0.4878976345062256,
-0.39068204164505005,
-0.7502544522285461,
-0.01093992032110691,
-0.9606032371520996,
0.09763740003108978,
0.586744487285614,
0.3742198646068573,
-0.007014511618763208,
0.5236728191375732,
-0.0001022482174448669,
0.8187285661697388,
-0.004797864705324173,
0.01573033817112446,
-0.040652912110090256,
-0.08055823296308517,
-0.39655089378356934,
0.02845502272248268,
0.5839946866035461,
0.47537845373153687,
-0.03225656598806381,
-0.2944296598434448,
-0.3789357542991638,
0.28131747245788574,
0.9861815571784973,
-0.41802868247032166,
-0.35269835591316223,
0.4984976053237915,
-0.25067758560180664,
-0.8345097899436951,
0.16214220225811005,
-0.7068973183631897,
-0.6703604459762573,
0.09689582884311676,
0.39193689823150635,
-0.25870463252067566,
-0.1170772835612297,
0.25884687900543213,
-0.38415268063545227,
0.09426547586917877,
0.09176328033208847,
-0.8828476667404175,
0.8304375410079956,
0.8151969909667969,
0.5252779126167297,
-0.40403279662132263,
-0.014817562885582447,
-0.45701661705970764,
0.08928117156028748,
-0.48472586274147034,
0.8196892738342285,
-0.5306965112686157,
-0.47898727655410767,
0.007760841399431229,
-0.30071985721588135,
-0.008514377288520336,
-0.6353960037231445,
0.9590592384338379,
-0.9286326169967651,
0.27588215470314026,
-0.014532151632010937,
-0.6611689329147339,
-0.6138085722923279,
0.5527151823043823,
-0.8937398791313171,
0.9346283674240112,
0.10906003415584564,
-1.5102428197860718,
0.21012112498283386,
-0.2876967489719391,
-0.3704470098018646,
-0.043248891830444336,
0.1274663358926773,
-0.008382493630051613,
0.3049844205379486,
-0.18487752974033356,
0.2620437443256378,
-0.5490431189537048,
0.08468347787857056,
-0.5689167976379395,
-0.06606561690568924,
0.5107486248016357,
-0.07494236528873444,
0.9296784400939941,
0.7028447389602661,
0.009624708443880081,
0.16416609287261963,
-0.6117855906486511,
-0.19746267795562744,
-0.03973039612174034,
-0.18681854009628296,
-0.6434023380279541,
0.2840477228164673,
-0.0499129518866539,
0.005974812898784876,
0.0659089982509613,
-0.6283761858940125,
0.3948758840560913,
-0.8164700865745544,
0.3062332272529602,
0.38568270206451416,
0.43119215965270996,
0.3988547921180725,
-0.44671207666397095,
0.6352198719978333,
0.33641767501831055,
0.6665667295455933,
0.0020620354916900396,
-0.4693683981895447,
-0.9396161437034607,
-0.17602141201496124,
0.4431345760822296,
0.9218453168869019,
-0.7324519157409668,
-0.00041176556260325015,
-0.044886503368616104,
-0.7278887629508972,
-0.4200369119644165,
-0.2503538727760315,
0.1798172891139984,
0.5450481176376343,
0.21838481724262238,
-0.47902780771255493,
-0.4424176812171936,
-0.9562787413597107,
-0.6933141350746155,
-0.43710437417030334,
0.1483670026063919,
0.15526869893074036,
0.3888648748397827,
-0.05578966438770294,
0.8826234936714172,
-0.6899147629737854,
0.0033603832125663757,
-0.4926191568374634,
0.1082022413611412,
0.3688070774078369,
0.41644391417503357,
0.8303253650665283,
-0.4541294574737549,
-0.535943329334259,
0.05203262344002724,
-0.7467465400695801,
0.03362485021352768,
0.0023432825691998005,
0.09269272536039352,
0.07380540668964386,
0.4128481149673462,
-0.6402391791343689,
0.6163294911384583,
0.23538358509540558,
-0.04747695103287697,
0.8005281090736389,
0.10672865808010101,
0.14281703531742096,
-1.2302221059799194,
-0.13198812305927277,
0.07011330872774124,
-0.11142987012863159,
-1.5579099655151367,
0.6895453333854675,
-0.19471584260463715,
0.06246916577219963,
-0.816795825958252,
0.4222166836261749,
-0.006031183060258627,
0.291328102350235,
-0.2738301455974579,
0.11102519929409027,
0.24087411165237427,
-0.10431129485368729,
-0.3641539514064789,
0.30675607919692993,
1.0879786014556885,
-0.8522844910621643,
0.7643145322799683,
-0.2779395580291748,
-0.3184998333454132,
0.39279401302337646,
-0.7228847742080688,
0.24512962996959686,
-0.05026629939675331,
0.0981355756521225,
-0.8970482349395752,
-0.32489585876464844,
0.4411354064941406,
-0.49206042289733887,
0.29850801825523376,
-0.34474605321884155,
-0.37669867277145386,
-0.41725048422813416,
-0.6970797777175903,
0.35866788029670715,
0.38717591762542725,
-0.40908676385879517,
0.37902772426605225,
0.43887069821357727,
-0.15782850980758667,
-0.7775914072990417,
-0.6720813512802124,
0.21034380793571472,
-0.834255039691925,
-0.798406720161438,
0.22657963633537292,
0.10527439415454865,
-0.9032328724861145,
-0.20697028934955597,
0.23300154507160187,
-0.177712544798851,
0.3717446029186249,
0.13221600651741028,
0.37190383672714233,
-0.10314085334539413,
0.12490261346101761,
0.026899663731455803,
0.007447986397892237,
0.2535336911678314,
0.007077141664922237,
0.32276639342308044,
0.05803033709526062,
-0.47535672783851624,
-0.38492292165756226,
0.47585782408714294,
0.4601779580116272,
-0.007227026391774416,
0.6449875831604004,
-0.12458600103855133,
-0.2943115830421448,
-0.021729663014411926,
-0.4126000702381134,
-0.49904781579971313,
-0.4918674826622009,
0.2006610482931137,
-0.2751723527908325,
-0.5574658513069153,
0.5597957968711853,
0.11195390671491623,
0.1624014973640442,
0.6866378784179688,
0.2745215892791748,
0.045869722962379456,
1.0580918788909912,
0.5828402638435364,
-0.41420337557792664,
0.2935481369495392,
0.17292936146259308,
0.3038455545902252,
-0.5840803980827332,
-0.16660277545452118,
-0.6775547862052917,
0.062236297875642776,
-0.7419337034225464,
0.21648404002189636,
0.18638555705547333,
0.16510282456874847,
-0.24930989742279053,
0.45502254366874695,
-0.17532972991466522,
0.2852199971675873,
0.4896638095378876,
-0.05543915927410126,
0.2970992624759674,
0.18559786677360535,
-0.2265811413526535,
-0.05471538379788399,
-0.4862891137599945,
-0.7403147220611572,
1.1505674123764038,
0.639565110206604,
1.0301240682601929,
0.29954180121421814,
0.5706210136413574,
0.6374638080596924,
0.337712824344635,
-0.7896893620491028,
0.4208013117313385,
-0.15860101580619812,
-1.3256934881210327,
0.4509159326553345,
-0.26411423087120056,
-0.9985825419425964,
0.059855084866285324,
-0.21275070309638977,
-1.2041659355163574,
-0.0961259976029396,
0.22809094190597534,
-0.459121972322464,
0.0938764438033104,
-0.6803439259529114,
0.5438421964645386,
-0.1882573366165161,
-0.252466082572937,
-0.2739465534687042,
-0.5916560292243958,
0.8723738789558411,
-0.1140594631433487,
0.14833424985408783,
0.07236304879188538,
0.48547109961509705,
0.6487823128700256,
-0.46114322543144226,
0.7521142363548279,
0.07910440862178802,
-0.00782017596065998,
0.566853404045105,
0.5066696405410767,
0.35776910185813904,
-0.07590574026107788,
-0.22371014952659607,
-0.4220854341983795,
-0.00014159509737510234,
-0.1993418186903,
-0.6381646394729614,
0.42983654141426086,
-0.3703245520591736,
-1.202187180519104,
-0.6399976015090942,
-0.3214702606201172,
-0.1702803075313568,
0.03253212198615074,
0.42324793338775635,
0.34329795837402344,
-0.35040050745010376,
-0.21582257747650146,
0.6957972049713135,
-0.5219408273696899,
0.2736688256263733,
0.5297024250030518,
-0.47260379791259766,
-0.2644840180873871,
0.5503019690513611,
-0.08673372864723206,
0.5180729627609253,
0.12845157086849213,
0.0711139589548111,
0.006590079050511122,
-0.4986628592014313,
-0.43615931272506714,
-0.15308643877506256,
-0.7706226110458374,
-0.20450440049171448,
-0.5814617872238159,
-0.28336629271507263,
-0.39168936014175415,
0.05475807934999466,
-0.3526526391506195,
-0.5951526165008545,
-0.08628755807876587,
-0.40882033109664917,
0.7381200790405273,
1.31472909450531,
0.21801099181175232,
0.5995964407920837,
-0.9019970893859863,
0.010661306791007519,
0.11827141791582108,
-0.01251366175711155,
0.10800524801015854,
-0.8174251317977905,
-0.23225848376750946,
0.05556598678231239,
-0.7710877656936646,
-1.4106168746948242,
0.40696510672569275,
-0.09170804917812347,
0.49614137411117554,
0.6890257596969604,
0.3174165189266205,
0.2577873170375824,
-0.49105730652809143,
1.286009430885315,
0.09336439520120621,
-0.8139058351516724,
0.5917375683784485,
-0.40447676181793213,
-0.36571788787841797,
0.250339150428772,
0.4979028105735779,
-0.42997655272483826,
-0.5745629072189331,
-0.6163439750671387,
-0.7709237337112427,
0.5479268431663513,
0.10216417908668518,
0.5093434453010559,
-0.1082196906208992,
0.4490301012992859,
-0.08133599907159805,
-0.0346747562289238,
-0.8621469140052795,
-0.4459746181964874,
0.09037996828556061,
0.04698739945888519,
0.3695870637893677,
-0.37672504782676697,
-0.30859601497650146,
-0.28012773394584656,
0.6504252552986145,
0.6693920493125916,
0.04718361794948578,
-0.11784714460372925,
-0.19156183302402496,
0.2793494760990143,
0.3764541745185852,
0.40303274989128113,
-0.012001026421785355,
-0.0663224458694458,
0.498536616563797,
0.29771995544433594,
-0.7335870862007141,
0.3833412528038025,
-0.04973919689655304,
-0.14239056408405304,
-0.18781039118766785,
0.3403826951980591,
0.6308546662330627,
-0.273764967918396,
-0.522924542427063,
0.49408018589019775,
-0.14019130170345306,
0.29392167925834656,
-0.03179991990327835,
0.2856781482696533,
-0.2894487977027893,
0.06822118163108826,
0.27629950642585754,
-0.1116919070482254,
0.6707684993743896,
-0.8031938672065735,
0.337289422750473,
0.43861865997314453,
-0.4692671298980713,
-0.5093053579330444,
0.4632384479045868,
-0.023836515843868256,
0.008809376507997513,
0.6916499137878418,
-0.1623530089855194,
-0.7535309791564941,
0.5181729793548584,
0.6241139769554138,
0.9849963188171387,
-0.5206134915351868,
-0.12741252779960632,
0.13053679466247559,
0.5252211689949036,
0.08168540894985199,
0.4713655114173889,
0.6259926557540894,
-0.5781228542327881,
0.06280390173196793,
-0.372147798538208,
-0.3618928790092468,
0.32573315501213074,
-0.7656446099281311,
0.3748053312301636,
-0.5906414985656738,
-0.736967921257019,
0.35134291648864746,
-0.16055919229984283,
-0.04438308626413345,
0.22817809879779816,
-0.033946506679058075,
1.013143539428711,
-0.9672321081161499,
0.6004239320755005,
0.7331940531730652,
-0.5196471214294434,
-0.738401472568512,
0.14486739039421082,
0.06197395920753479,
-0.01147774513810873,
0.876030445098877,
0.02133304625749588,
-0.19439280033111572,
-0.5786166787147522,
-0.5781329274177551,
-0.7517072558403015,
0.41781488060951233,
0.28145432472229004,
0.08200112730264664,
0.4477182924747467,
0.3587341904640198,
0.7153220772743225,
-0.41533347964286804,
0.045320991426706314,
0.5396445989608765,
-0.0027372241020202637,
-0.24208423495292664,
-0.5807433724403381,
-0.06463111937046051,
-0.41431954503059387,
-0.020498786121606827,
-0.0589662566781044,
-0.32140955328941345,
1.2773526906967163,
-0.04222828149795532,
-0.3421671986579895,
0.0873086005449295,
0.7078778743743896,
0.13272587954998016,
0.2263122946023941,
0.12192243337631226,
0.7154773473739624,
0.47651106119155884,
-0.006602054461836815,
1.40578293800354,
-0.45039066672325134,
0.23581448197364807,
1.03016996383667,
-0.39547789096832275,
0.9506403803825378,
0.1168723925948143,
-0.15407313406467438,
0.735178530216217,
0.9672189354896545,
-0.02826843410730362,
0.5184124708175659,
0.5251361727714539,
-0.7170038819313049,
0.2057281881570816,
-0.16726338863372803,
-0.34125378727912903,
0.3852706253528595,
0.5775879621505737,
-0.4146369397640228,
-0.022848287597298622,
-0.08298003673553467,
0.6020247340202332,
-0.2762691080570221,
-0.3883627951145172,
0.7328723073005676,
0.2100694328546524,
-0.7521880269050598,
0.4198186993598938,
0.5863524079322815,
0.19994358718395233,
-0.2564980685710907,
0.28999847173690796,
-0.33403992652893066,
0.33001047372817993,
-0.41352584958076477,
-0.592223048210144,
0.43260321021080017,
0.5157057642936707,
-0.16921387612819672,
0.6005770564079285,
0.8270737528800964,
-0.004363651853054762,
-0.28026866912841797,
0.06702057272195816,
0.21260035037994385,
0.07251173257827759,
0.23068736493587494,
-0.569352388381958,
-0.07556022703647614,
-0.20720291137695312,
-0.46224358677864075,
0.2175833135843277,
0.11211594194173813,
-0.29620957374572754,
0.8609397411346436,
0.3914599120616913,
-0.012482373043894768,
0.4620487093925476,
0.05367591232061386,
0.9613878130912781,
-0.565639078617096,
-0.4423748254776001,
-1.1907144784927368,
0.4720222055912018,
-0.15447407960891724,
0.10141110420227051,
1.124566912651062,
0.6668297052383423,
0.5409621000289917,
-0.14619779586791992,
0.898212730884552,
0.09744800627231598,
0.5636018514633179,
-0.4675792157649994,
0.7270102500915527,
-0.2809251844882965,
0.4291630685329437,
-0.5658937692642212,
-0.5967227220535278,
-0.42208290100097656,
0.19893181324005127,
-0.27887803316116333,
-0.06635871529579163,
0.7908068299293518,
0.7897706031799316,
0.04973701760172844,
0.1572650521993637,
-0.06337657570838928,
0.2739858031272888,
0.33412042260169983,
0.30455076694488525,
1.3094522953033447,
-0.47380509972572327,
0.07613421976566315,
-0.2308882772922516,
-0.09555528312921524,
-0.07881221175193787,
-0.848662257194519,
-0.9922316670417786,
-0.3881782293319702,
-0.26256513595581055,
-0.6271588802337646,
0.18475739657878876,
0.6496167182922363,
0.4367307126522064,
-1.0504887104034424,
-0.39183467626571655,
0.09143979102373123,
0.11433109641075134,
-0.014239613898098469,
-0.19518981873989105,
0.05740739777684212,
-0.4978233873844147,
-0.4388419985771179,
0.24016575515270233,
0.10420597344636917,
0.27195876836776733,
-0.32234987616539,
0.3608872592449188,
-0.06242982670664787,
0.7880404591560364,
0.5194807648658752,
0.08601412177085876,
-0.6095406413078308,
-0.4651810824871063,
-0.01128758117556572,
-0.327541321516037,
-0.14816232025623322,
0.7973757386207581,
-0.5017301440238953,
0.5617634057998657,
0.5962949395179749,
0.4398512542247772,
0.11180049180984497,
-0.1548192799091339,
0.754988431930542,
-0.9398447871208191,
0.21151821315288544,
0.06902819126844406,
0.38157108426094055,
0.31546300649642944,
-0.45843496918678284,
0.31929856538772583,
0.16535136103630066,
-0.17988011240959167,
-1.0912587642669678,
0.8180878758430481,
-0.9093331098556519,
-0.24154207110404968,
1.2324010133743286,
-0.3612053394317627,
-0.04480842500925064,
-0.2810993492603302,
-0.15500351786613464,
-0.005170776508748531,
-0.1451767235994339,
1.0971111059188843,
0.8598683476448059,
-0.009161553345620632,
0.3377499580383301,
-0.8885710835456848,
0.8214959502220154,
0.13515837490558624,
-0.900197446346283,
0.20594462752342224,
0.374125599861145,
0.20252956449985504,
0.1800614595413208,
-0.02686307020485401,
-0.27701371908187866,
0.38179269433021545,
0.10158421099185944,
-0.27961790561676025,
0.4588407278060913,
-0.5196480751037598,
-0.3395611345767975,
0.16052886843681335,
0.47217196226119995,
-0.08810301870107651
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10276v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10276v1
|
Soft Language Identification for Language-Agnostic Many-to-One End-to-End Speech Translation
| 2024-06-12T00:00:39 | 2024-06-12T00:00:39 |
Peidong Wang, Jian Xue, Jinyu Li, Junkun Chen, Aswin Shanmugam Subramanian
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
Language-agnostic many-to-one end-to-end speech translation models can
convert audio signals from different source languages into text in a target
language. These models do not need source language identification, which
improves user experience. In some cases, the input language can be given or
estimated. Our goal is to use this additional language information while
preserving the quality of the other languages. We accomplish this by
introducing a simple and effective linear input network. The linear input
network is initialized as an identity matrix, which ensures that the model can
perform as well as, or better than, the original model. Experimental results
show that the proposed method can successfully enhance the specified language,
while keeping the language-agnostic ability of the many-to-one ST models.
|
[
-0.2704945206642151,
-0.7142748832702637,
0.43526890873908997,
-0.012299776077270508,
-0.3409399092197418,
0.10768384486436844,
-0.45076656341552734,
-0.4955419600009918,
0.13423776626586914,
0.4684813320636749,
-0.6459241509437561,
-0.18354515731334686,
-0.5894200801849365,
0.10663754492998123,
-0.7040854096412659,
1.2354899644851685,
0.029498238116502762,
0.12221501022577286,
0.1977645307779312,
-0.6192870736122131,
-0.04368816316127777,
-0.564918577671051,
-0.7509055733680725,
-0.2697596549987793,
0.6085553765296936,
0.15903975069522858,
0.9978021383285522,
0.616157591342926,
0.40466317534446716,
0.4048667252063751,
-0.25996434688568115,
0.011075609363615513,
-0.47383108735084534,
0.05382577329874039,
-0.3977970778942108,
-0.22210659086704254,
-0.4706924259662628,
-0.09170281141996384,
0.75144362449646,
0.944383978843689,
-0.14901359379291534,
0.4516488015651703,
-0.08980631828308105,
0.3581235110759735,
-0.5523137450218201,
-0.17880778014659882,
-0.5039770007133484,
0.01927100494503975,
-0.3561655282974243,
-0.134172260761261,
-0.4779299795627594,
-0.41296422481536865,
0.2053208351135254,
-0.42431604862213135,
0.020238714292645454,
-0.3429622948169708,
0.8252248167991638,
0.11904844641685486,
-0.4029303789138794,
-0.35459238290786743,
-1.3712800741195679,
0.6740848422050476,
-0.7410480976104736,
0.5884116291999817,
0.07723996788263321,
0.35379260778427124,
-0.11216823756694794,
-0.6597597002983093,
-0.8081390261650085,
-0.17714864015579224,
0.12212183326482773,
0.15643297135829926,
-0.07100852578878403,
0.2409900575876236,
-0.142511248588562,
0.36165177822113037,
-0.51116943359375,
0.07335812598466873,
-0.5338331460952759,
-0.33112832903862,
0.6542769074440002,
-0.2660049796104431,
0.5161499381065369,
0.21902216970920563,
-0.3987835943698883,
0.22072459757328033,
-0.7488038539886475,
0.04670682176947594,
0.390208899974823,
0.7316095232963562,
-0.14503127336502075,
0.46602270007133484,
-0.0458836555480957,
0.5940986275672913,
-0.14471900463104248,
-0.4674268066883087,
0.5605253577232361,
-0.4133528470993042,
-0.19378305971622467,
0.4194541871547699,
0.7666712403297424,
-0.2593359649181366,
0.47050902247428894,
-0.49304312467575073,
-0.4097219705581665,
0.02841363102197647,
-0.2677593529224396,
-0.6184003949165344,
0.3260537385940552,
0.05532557889819145,
-0.5272160172462463,
-0.11442167311906815,
-0.04795452579855919,
-0.1782476007938385,
-0.06999590992927551,
-0.38357508182525635,
0.6222096681594849,
-0.19227272272109985,
-0.7267765998840332,
-0.06830012053251266,
0.040960896760225296,
0.4926832318305969,
0.212235689163208,
-0.8812494277954102,
0.7395147085189819,
0.5992041230201721,
0.9271108508110046,
-0.30069828033447266,
-0.32314440608024597,
-0.6931502819061279,
0.2813721299171448,
-0.5067189931869507,
0.5671557188034058,
-0.49648335576057434,
-0.24012216925621033,
0.07069042325019836,
0.17574547231197357,
0.1685863584280014,
-0.3339393138885498,
0.42257413268089294,
-0.4039117991924286,
0.28265711665153503,
0.08980392664670944,
-0.2011636346578598,
-0.12282367050647736,
-0.1282307505607605,
-0.6313135027885437,
0.8545790314674377,
0.34187060594558716,
-0.1231621578335762,
0.1345081925392151,
-0.4409938156604767,
-0.6194629073143005,
0.18328915536403656,
-0.19500526785850525,
-0.3756752014160156,
0.37909767031669617,
-0.21058405935764313,
0.26097142696380615,
-0.35098278522491455,
0.36117827892303467,
-0.3193885087966919,
-0.13855749368667603,
0.473296195268631,
-0.6999158263206482,
0.9374761581420898,
0.5480744242668152,
0.23344945907592773,
0.2572232782840729,
-0.9251130819320679,
-0.026165539398789406,
0.3422650098800659,
-0.5253121256828308,
-0.27441632747650146,
0.0845431536436081,
0.47319936752319336,
0.35319337248802185,
0.30139413475990295,
-0.787479817867279,
0.19809061288833618,
-0.6916419863700867,
0.6077414155006409,
0.6082668900489807,
-0.36381474137306213,
0.5760339498519897,
-0.15015527606010437,
0.5652851462364197,
0.08830224722623825,
0.12517496943473816,
-0.24415792524814606,
-0.6538611054420471,
-0.7039622664451599,
-0.21751046180725098,
0.7338346838951111,
0.9244243502616882,
-0.5665964484214783,
0.12186465412378311,
-0.41567784547805786,
-0.25219786167144775,
-0.7834281921386719,
0.5681012272834778,
0.603245198726654,
0.45716527104377747,
0.3109228312969208,
-0.44920575618743896,
-0.4523685574531555,
-1.0282297134399414,
-0.037356194108724594,
-0.1356109231710434,
-0.21405623853206635,
0.25119251012802124,
0.08199404925107956,
-0.1123872697353363,
0.8399887084960938,
-0.0051537747494876385,
-0.37892454862594604,
-0.5311253070831299,
-0.064348503947258,
0.5439999103546143,
0.47651880979537964,
0.5455417037010193,
-0.6778611540794373,
-0.594214141368866,
0.4561809301376343,
-0.5396609306335449,
-0.17464931309223175,
-0.1828065812587738,
0.03575092554092407,
-0.014452815055847168,
0.4641943871974945,
-0.21670140326023102,
0.32380491495132446,
0.7611355185508728,
-0.2957414388656616,
0.276692271232605,
-0.2191389501094818,
-0.046461835503578186,
-1.2569433450698853,
0.12928877770900726,
0.05924368277192116,
-0.4225831925868988,
-1.2385773658752441,
0.012585236690938473,
-0.17560507357120514,
-0.22915968298912048,
-0.8359472751617432,
0.5862260460853577,
-0.3940725326538086,
-0.20174159109592438,
-0.36660826206207275,
0.10529924184083939,
-0.17486920952796936,
0.5876706838607788,
0.07161936163902283,
0.8906887173652649,
0.6364398002624512,
-0.6088175177574158,
0.2859960198402405,
0.27376285195350647,
-0.12104832381010056,
0.4920161962509155,
-0.8319615721702576,
0.39880457520484924,
-0.36562520265579224,
-0.05899890512228012,
-1.2757376432418823,
0.13393184542655945,
0.258726567029953,
-0.6536414623260498,
0.45088455080986023,
-0.5354915857315063,
-0.2510809004306793,
0.12805835902690887,
0.31581762433052063,
0.5239303708076477,
0.34112751483917236,
-0.48730021715164185,
0.7096187472343445,
0.45609772205352783,
-0.6496326923370361,
-0.40893837809562683,
-0.7459877133369446,
0.29398852586746216,
-0.0326753593981266,
-0.425912469625473,
0.4355313181877136,
-0.15231981873512268,
-0.08703399449586868,
-0.126820906996727,
0.135213702917099,
-0.6385260224342346,
0.1612313836812973,
-0.04157712683081627,
0.36529284715652466,
-0.5694692134857178,
0.250278502702713,
0.24245943129062653,
-0.4612296223640442,
-0.22081045806407928,
-0.4637293815612793,
0.2783738970756531,
-0.12475500255823135,
-0.28019702434539795,
-0.37476471066474915,
0.9057173132896423,
0.6138097643852234,
-0.6200982928276062,
0.5360252857208252,
0.6709629893302917,
-0.5145249366760254,
-0.09634635597467422,
-0.2293553352355957,
0.07481885701417923,
-0.5459293723106384,
0.40012919902801514,
-0.7067503929138184,
-0.633152961730957,
0.6571188569068909,
-0.3213568925857544,
0.10575222223997116,
0.29665735363960266,
0.4216931164264679,
0.08403825014829636,
1.3334343433380127,
0.6656204462051392,
-0.14875486493110657,
0.45088130235671997,
0.13459442555904388,
0.1876947283744812,
-0.6492802500724792,
0.05910975858569145,
-0.6932674050331116,
-0.34604403376579285,
-0.5175073146820068,
-0.12267961353063583,
0.12293629348278046,
0.019801629707217216,
0.11257734149694443,
0.41520050168037415,
-0.6374584436416626,
0.3162800669670105,
0.602221667766571,
0.09490787982940674,
0.2597879469394684,
-0.043332088738679886,
-0.011092385277152061,
0.08052290976047516,
-0.47490331530570984,
-0.3716942071914673,
0.929381787776947,
0.579881489276886,
0.6776602268218994,
0.6722568869590759,
0.5723353624343872,
0.11348455399274826,
0.40801820158958435,
-0.9316017627716064,
0.43157461285591125,
-0.42601898312568665,
-0.627230703830719,
-0.39119577407836914,
-0.43952229619026184,
-0.9122710824012756,
0.1611935943365097,
-0.22220973670482635,
-0.811665952205658,
0.4222850501537323,
0.17403747141361237,
-0.16700224578380585,
-0.005136579275131226,
-0.7112375497817993,
0.5714190006256104,
-0.4588989019393921,
-0.4069027900695801,
-0.06292328983545303,
-0.40126511454582214,
0.02249668911099434,
-0.05787397548556328,
0.30650392174720764,
-0.11026744544506073,
-0.07352309674024582,
0.804654061794281,
-0.40069541335105896,
0.5913969874382019,
-0.19734406471252441,
-0.2538015842437744,
0.3519669771194458,
-0.010468936525285244,
0.4981898069381714,
-0.09075946360826492,
-0.2300122231245041,
0.4699096381664276,
-0.10461217910051346,
-0.26081496477127075,
-0.6241127848625183,
0.5070495009422302,
-0.8918389678001404,
-0.4859716296195984,
0.006309757009148598,
-0.23477835953235626,
-0.12073282897472382,
0.4673496186733246,
0.19712688028812408,
0.7792592644691467,
-0.14828181266784668,
0.273371160030365,
0.8841937780380249,
-0.1620713323354721,
0.5786465406417847,
0.8008049130439758,
-0.22635044157505035,
-0.4893339276313782,
1.1678017377853394,
0.18391938507556915,
0.4880232512950897,
0.3228955566883087,
0.4919144809246063,
-0.4743960201740265,
-0.6841516494750977,
-0.892525851726532,
0.0908418744802475,
-0.6714773774147034,
0.05187643691897392,
-0.37248942255973816,
-0.4526301324367523,
-0.38955429196357727,
-0.1745152622461319,
-0.7305780053138733,
-0.5532715916633606,
-0.13258075714111328,
-0.060855209827423096,
0.16688373684883118,
0.7080615758895874,
0.014002114534378052,
0.5843648314476013,
-0.5994079113006592,
0.4360290765762329,
0.35025718808174133,
0.6879115104675293,
-0.42520400881767273,
-1.0033272504806519,
-0.25605419278144836,
-0.06789907813072205,
0.11592518538236618,
-1.3771148920059204,
0.3294130265712738,
0.8856022357940674,
0.857663094997406,
0.7413173913955688,
-0.2052926868200302,
0.5110979080200195,
-0.8400598168373108,
0.4399966895580292,
0.48909443616867065,
-1.2276908159255981,
0.5495279431343079,
-0.1595507115125656,
0.3548271954059601,
0.5919045805931091,
0.13969606161117554,
-0.6123666167259216,
-0.19554495811462402,
-0.19564566016197205,
-0.798144519329071,
0.6324090957641602,
-0.055795133113861084,
0.38238659501075745,
0.16102103888988495,
0.3170028328895569,
0.12078432738780975,
0.17373740673065186,
-0.9801596999168396,
-0.5185860395431519,
-0.44002875685691833,
-0.36878231167793274,
-0.0755431279540062,
-0.13395307958126068,
-0.07538028061389923,
-0.2168298363685608,
0.5030741095542908,
-0.3091914653778076,
0.22078925371170044,
0.09486999362707138,
-0.22916795313358307,
-0.30143532156944275,
0.463134765625,
0.6836864948272705,
0.4944615662097931,
0.04244983568787575,
0.17424379289150238,
0.37319183349609375,
-0.3957386314868927,
0.43635550141334534,
-0.05278291553258896,
-0.21134160459041595,
0.2394823580980301,
0.07112333923578262,
0.7894058227539062,
0.1948525458574295,
-0.401429146528244,
0.6014835834503174,
-0.022991212084889412,
-0.35884469747543335,
-0.4472106695175171,
0.07274191826581955,
-0.025143859907984734,
-0.06115516275167465,
0.5148372650146484,
0.09228105843067169,
0.4138767123222351,
-0.6267856955528259,
0.2843087911605835,
0.6251345276832581,
-0.8092530965805054,
-0.5237986445426941,
0.764790952205658,
0.41518232226371765,
-0.8355936408042908,
0.4367479979991913,
-0.1647690087556839,
-0.3918730914592743,
0.42417338490486145,
0.8863096237182617,
1.1565815210342407,
-0.8798210024833679,
-0.00495875021442771,
0.30837661027908325,
0.4931832253932953,
0.4299916923046112,
0.27205249667167664,
-0.11005642265081406,
-0.7439444065093994,
-0.7172260284423828,
-0.6143669486045837,
-0.3341890275478363,
0.3050489127635956,
-0.7325055599212646,
0.4476434588432312,
-0.5190034508705139,
-0.16084866225719452,
0.09771191328763962,
-0.4331248104572296,
-0.651933491230011,
0.2480652779340744,
0.7517369985580444,
0.697199285030365,
-1.2193278074264526,
1.2282296419143677,
0.609258234500885,
-0.2891167104244232,
-0.5330301523208618,
-0.5875489115715027,
0.0013877396704629064,
-0.6926367282867432,
0.4307345151901245,
-0.07458233088254929,
-0.3150656521320343,
0.17572300136089325,
-0.6190817952156067,
-1.199940800666809,
0.7109900116920471,
0.5129340291023254,
-0.445555180311203,
0.18093903362751007,
0.46283969283103943,
0.5080474019050598,
-0.3439052700996399,
0.3692595362663269,
0.3095932900905609,
0.43932676315307617,
0.200730100274086,
-1.1889952421188354,
-0.03856602683663368,
-0.5648297667503357,
0.04937739297747612,
0.2250780165195465,
-0.4164072871208191,
0.7433860301971436,
-0.21369749307632446,
-0.5377169251441956,
-0.23270000517368317,
0.9949953556060791,
0.02047624997794628,
0.20555754005908966,
0.7286012172698975,
0.07653574645519257,
0.5457448363304138,
0.00017267126531805843,
0.5305023789405823,
-0.3899235427379608,
0.03121146745979786,
1.2219783067703247,
-0.22870326042175293,
0.9625978469848633,
0.4658108651638031,
-0.15868808329105377,
0.3427501320838928,
0.28212878108024597,
0.18089355528354645,
0.5426775813102722,
0.17184171080589294,
-0.41470831632614136,
-0.21940942108631134,
-0.2676507234573364,
-0.41342246532440186,
0.6338387727737427,
0.7072676420211792,
-0.3096219599246979,
-0.09771256893873215,
0.07229364663362503,
-0.07020681351423264,
0.05962253734469414,
-0.21822504699230194,
0.9659227728843689,
-0.03471532091498375,
-0.4984327554702759,
0.4935685098171234,
0.13682304322719574,
0.5422975420951843,
-0.8464489579200745,
-0.04601851850748062,
-0.009034995920956135,
0.04650840535759926,
-0.18505859375,
-0.5781217217445374,
0.32447388768196106,
-0.2424275279045105,
-0.23198600113391876,
-0.29668205976486206,
0.7748518586158752,
-0.7012410163879395,
-0.6479816436767578,
0.337816447019577,
0.5516647696495056,
0.20085649192333221,
0.3088867962360382,
-0.7231191396713257,
-0.03338039293885231,
-0.14204706251621246,
-0.2921352684497833,
0.22957459092140198,
0.22962865233421326,
0.02952185831964016,
0.6008549332618713,
0.8157941699028015,
0.2846991717815399,
0.18740467727184296,
0.1862974762916565,
0.5052586793899536,
-0.37926408648490906,
-0.5961999893188477,
-0.7223412990570068,
0.4276723861694336,
0.17251446843147278,
-0.6189165711402893,
0.523010790348053,
0.47189080715179443,
0.6870203018188477,
0.13225342333316803,
1.0983796119689941,
0.06214910373091698,
0.49422264099121094,
-0.29192081093788147,
0.6392350792884827,
-0.4449952244758606,
0.07869229465723038,
-0.4203071892261505,
-0.7113223671913147,
-0.006669873371720314,
0.5568841099739075,
0.16825169324874878,
-0.12140583992004395,
0.36643359065055847,
0.7357450127601624,
-0.228745236992836,
-0.24405385553836823,
0.6612743139266968,
0.08254984021186829,
0.36610615253448486,
0.46763476729393005,
0.5842545032501221,
-0.4218805432319641,
0.835759162902832,
-0.021478349342942238,
-0.5712334513664246,
-0.07382329553365707,
-0.7668389678001404,
-0.5495901107788086,
-0.7379661798477173,
-0.40971726179122925,
-0.5722613334655762,
0.06236499547958374,
0.7507210373878479,
0.9944934248924255,
-1.1280770301818848,
-0.31363117694854736,
0.01289295218884945,
0.033504828810691833,
-0.5287142395973206,
-0.09613339602947235,
0.028190292418003082,
-0.12748385965824127,
-0.854137659072876,
0.6874721646308899,
0.39820510149002075,
0.04294489324092865,
-0.7364629507064819,
-0.3655136823654175,
-0.055780790746212006,
0.4193045496940613,
0.5783395171165466,
0.7055115699768066,
-0.7432931661605835,
-0.1982746720314026,
-0.01606982760131359,
-0.004714253358542919,
0.1397043615579605,
0.5924556851387024,
-0.6936489343643188,
0.5638371109962463,
0.4239230155944824,
0.6861764192581177,
0.21211914718151093,
-0.16439223289489746,
0.8274719715118408,
-0.8470466136932373,
0.33563005924224854,
0.0615384615957737,
0.42784908413887024,
0.3208780586719513,
-0.20664633810520172,
0.24145840108394623,
0.21427799761295319,
-0.29921776056289673,
-0.7757207751274109,
0.38772037625312805,
-1.1484830379486084,
-0.08142954856157303,
1.1675702333450317,
-0.19767551124095917,
-0.3870294690132141,
-0.5589579343795776,
-0.04615529999136925,
0.3500136137008667,
-0.2811209559440613,
0.2976173162460327,
0.43885329365730286,
0.3592933416366577,
-0.3211166262626648,
-0.5326257348060608,
0.27525123953819275,
0.2442173808813095,
-0.5670902729034424,
-0.21473151445388794,
0.036775730550289154,
0.18051356077194214,
0.378419429063797,
0.7165391445159912,
-0.077573262155056,
0.3479180932044983,
-0.23653379082679749,
0.18564702570438385,
0.015712551772594452,
-0.3470153510570526,
-0.4621574282646179,
0.05635998025536537,
0.2412550300359726,
-0.29029911756515503
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.07759v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.07759v1
|
LT4SG@SMM4H24: Tweets Classification for Digital Epidemiology of Childhood Health Outcomes Using Pre-Trained Language Models
| 2024-06-11T22:48:18 | 2024-06-11T22:48:18 |
Dasun Athukoralage, Thushari Atapattu, Menasha Thilakaratne, Katrina Falkner
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This paper presents our approaches for the SMM4H24 Shared Task 5 on the
binary classification of English tweets reporting children's medical disorders.
Our first approach involves fine-tuning a single RoBERTa-large model, while the
second approach entails ensembling the results of three fine-tuned
BERTweet-large models. We demonstrate that although both approaches exhibit
identical performance on validation data, the BERTweet-large ensemble excels on
test data. Our best-performing system achieves an F1-score of 0.938 on test
data, outperforming the benchmark classifier by 1.18%.
|
[
-0.0414227694272995,
-0.3670807480812073,
0.5463738441467285,
0.18460555374622345,
-0.13856735825538635,
0.2944902777671814,
-0.2967299818992615,
-0.6247207522392273,
0.2163509726524353,
0.26926669478416443,
-0.6779435276985168,
-0.6462511420249939,
-0.9940741062164307,
0.013978413306176662,
-0.6136370301246643,
1.242248773574829,
-0.09602845460176468,
0.22551795840263367,
0.1276935487985611,
0.26871439814567566,
-0.04869716987013817,
-0.7661595940589905,
-0.7217974066734314,
0.03325565531849861,
0.7988461852073669,
0.5721045136451721,
0.3088364899158478,
0.31275057792663574,
0.8746029138565063,
0.11966799199581146,
0.3033802807331085,
0.011743106879293919,
-0.6249555945396423,
0.024527650326490402,
-0.22187797725200653,
-0.10598332434892654,
-0.3758537769317627,
0.2235911786556244,
0.1854148507118225,
0.6804397702217102,
-0.06427459418773651,
0.12724313139915466,
0.052391842007637024,
0.168198361992836,
-0.2666816711425781,
0.15912669897079468,
-0.42856279015541077,
0.16916343569755554,
-0.25172609090805054,
-0.4493827819824219,
-0.42203447222709656,
-0.4698411524295807,
0.19970163702964783,
-0.18675750494003296,
0.16526257991790771,
-0.15592381358146667,
0.8913668394088745,
0.06230778247117996,
-0.748938262462616,
-0.3664381504058838,
-0.7379903197288513,
1.12460458278656,
-0.7887224555015564,
0.2909194231033325,
0.5371043086051941,
0.37964504957199097,
0.2164907604455948,
-0.9114145636558533,
-0.3752194046974182,
0.1035780981183052,
0.01932176761329174,
0.11013840138912201,
-0.09248130023479462,
0.08449151366949081,
0.01689958944916725,
-0.0034153652377426624,
-0.664341151714325,
0.33174893260002136,
-0.568652868270874,
-0.21455498039722443,
0.808719277381897,
0.13454091548919678,
0.130944162607193,
-0.0032371690031141043,
-0.06701242178678513,
0.19626803696155548,
-0.47107210755348206,
-0.2786366641521454,
-0.09367027878761292,
0.4674127399921417,
-0.2229551076889038,
0.3956473469734192,
0.051065150648355484,
0.4219181537628174,
0.18728992342948914,
-0.2523907423019409,
0.5209375023841858,
-0.43472710251808167,
-0.028689466416835785,
-0.06812798231840134,
0.687700092792511,
0.3899171054363251,
0.23159557580947876,
-0.2426849901676178,
-0.3270874321460724,
0.22568179666996002,
0.5296797752380371,
-0.8968178033828735,
-0.4332108199596405,
0.3078170716762543,
-0.5681162476539612,
-0.5394266843795776,
0.03269433230161667,
-0.5352832078933716,
-0.25540539622306824,
-0.3190004527568817,
0.679959774017334,
-0.6560863852500916,
-0.1862434595823288,
-0.080342136323452,
0.099796362221241,
-0.20151442289352417,
0.5816705822944641,
-1.02257239818573,
0.45483648777008057,
0.8194534778594971,
0.5012600421905518,
-0.39911991357803345,
0.04538297653198242,
-0.24540938436985016,
0.0876360610127449,
-0.4374299645423889,
0.707073986530304,
-0.5631586313247681,
-0.015280434861779213,
0.11206279695034027,
-0.05112241208553314,
-0.38287314772605896,
-0.4100725054740906,
0.7274585962295532,
-0.31179603934288025,
0.2747448980808258,
-0.21585598587989807,
-0.7328657507896423,
0.06742515414953232,
0.28405383229255676,
-0.35291364789009094,
0.5872756838798523,
0.2427479326725006,
-1.0796985626220703,
0.6607882380485535,
-0.7282460927963257,
-0.6723160743713379,
0.07215069234371185,
-0.044428396970033646,
-0.46717777848243713,
0.003103184048086405,
0.23290541768074036,
1.065427303314209,
0.002062670886516571,
0.44691410660743713,
-0.37922903895378113,
-0.44467246532440186,
-0.09632064402103424,
-0.329629510641098,
0.6396458745002747,
0.25954264402389526,
-0.22614239156246185,
0.20554672181606293,
-0.5439748764038086,
0.19783276319503784,
0.16837750375270844,
-0.27714499831199646,
-0.14475460350513458,
0.19417844712734222,
0.37264323234558105,
0.2117568999528885,
0.23682168126106262,
-0.5148588418960571,
0.10100523382425308,
-0.0982469841837883,
0.5829780101776123,
0.580250084400177,
0.25642916560173035,
0.08371982723474503,
-0.8076531887054443,
0.3597443103790283,
0.27768588066101074,
0.5627700686454773,
0.07295715063810349,
-0.8349869251251221,
-0.23648494482040405,
-0.4662673771381378,
0.6435671448707581,
0.43905410170555115,
-0.9170524477958679,
0.5543556809425354,
-0.5620318651199341,
-0.5278683304786682,
-0.48558834195137024,
-0.1879507303237915,
0.2097865641117096,
0.09785712510347366,
0.24034519493579865,
-0.19095052778720856,
-0.7556478977203369,
-0.666510283946991,
0.15421901643276215,
-0.16244708001613617,
0.10998117178678513,
0.2876432538032532,
0.49696269631385803,
-0.6623015999794006,
0.3151054084300995,
-0.16878212988376617,
0.04639319330453873,
-0.007704597897827625,
0.3438388407230377,
0.06949339807033539,
0.5103743672370911,
0.8841005563735962,
-0.8576830625534058,
-0.6251309514045715,
0.0256942268460989,
-0.49533015489578247,
-0.24133463203907013,
0.4354761242866516,
0.20653536915779114,
0.3672451078891754,
0.13695041835308075,
-0.33596912026405334,
0.44142112135887146,
0.8099948167800903,
-0.2001136988401413,
0.43482670187950134,
0.12351139634847641,
0.3816223740577698,
-1.044232964515686,
-0.23952005803585052,
0.09747795760631561,
-0.5461998581886292,
-0.8153311610221863,
-0.04452420771121979,
0.08423131704330444,
0.23166140913963318,
-0.3449968099594116,
0.12918442487716675,
-0.008892667479813099,
0.19303375482559204,
-0.029693972319364548,
-0.28363266587257385,
-0.4225369691848755,
-0.03771466389298439,
-0.15416212379932404,
0.33338502049446106,
0.43951845169067383,
-0.4241187572479248,
0.3591294288635254,
-0.21552585065364838,
-0.05358735844492912,
0.3753325939178467,
-0.38480594754219055,
0.08006501197814941,
-0.03800131380558014,
0.29054370522499084,
-1.0444183349609375,
-0.43471184372901917,
0.16407708823680878,
-0.9285958409309387,
0.5071048736572266,
0.17337439954280853,
-0.9914793968200684,
-0.8272045850753784,
-0.4877817630767822,
0.18702124059200287,
0.529570996761322,
-0.6002838015556335,
0.2684703767299652,
0.7159797549247742,
-0.23612351715564728,
-0.17316663265228271,
-0.7282358407974243,
-0.05778339132666588,
-0.2741363048553467,
-0.5746948719024658,
0.534039318561554,
-0.13949117064476013,
0.02166134864091873,
0.1996525228023529,
-0.09606294333934784,
-0.4481428265571594,
0.020558515563607216,
0.10807296633720398,
0.02844126522541046,
-0.19852431118488312,
0.27637937664985657,
0.0590004101395607,
0.11196376383304596,
-0.1692979782819748,
-0.2283439189195633,
0.5871226787567139,
0.16029393672943115,
-0.13552157580852509,
-0.3904726803302765,
0.38389334082603455,
0.30883467197418213,
0.145578533411026,
0.7569335699081421,
0.6337380409240723,
-0.7778148651123047,
-0.19823093712329865,
-0.3200245499610901,
-0.3225184679031372,
-0.43671393394470215,
0.09428197145462036,
-0.3371376097202301,
-0.9512091875076294,
0.31292131543159485,
0.13336163759231567,
0.24113333225250244,
0.4555509686470032,
0.4693082571029663,
-0.7105778455734253,
1.1316606998443604,
0.5273483395576477,
-0.1455758512020111,
0.3313002586364746,
-0.24760086834430695,
0.2507759928703308,
-0.1877291202545166,
0.07080104947090149,
-0.6265612244606018,
-0.06627516448497772,
-0.7742329835891724,
-0.40405839681625366,
0.29046332836151123,
-0.33029505610466003,
-0.3066929876804352,
0.29543182253837585,
-0.5026509165763855,
0.15073806047439575,
0.4460218548774719,
0.44090893864631653,
-0.006140120793133974,
-0.21732085943222046,
-0.020703619346022606,
-0.3781141936779022,
-0.7541974782943726,
-0.4581703841686249,
1.3925137519836426,
0.396792471408844,
0.6391051411628723,
0.38477233052253723,
1.1783772706985474,
0.3921355605125427,
0.7611492872238159,
-0.6325274705886841,
0.35634905099868774,
-0.6039254665374756,
-0.8377535939216614,
-0.15065759420394897,
-0.6366773843765259,
-1.1728073358535767,
-0.12790152430534363,
-0.32937169075012207,
-0.9512142539024353,
-0.3243884742259979,
0.014375950209796429,
-0.3405880033969879,
0.09691876173019409,
-0.9702847599983215,
0.765845000743866,
-0.3405997157096863,
-0.03535018488764763,
-0.28571444749832153,
-0.6125224828720093,
0.39866501092910767,
-0.6352241635322571,
0.4494667649269104,
-0.04565087705850601,
-0.05194952338933945,
1.03749680519104,
-0.22092539072036743,
0.9213476181030273,
-0.0659518912434578,
0.15940897166728973,
-0.14006848633289337,
-0.35058727860450745,
0.0937899574637413,
-0.24933353066444397,
0.08197367936372757,
0.12209602445363998,
0.43340909481048584,
-0.7225342988967896,
-0.2790662348270416,
0.8727799654006958,
-0.8201696276664734,
-0.30037227272987366,
-0.7102799415588379,
-0.22001993656158447,
-0.43150559067726135,
0.3406655192375183,
0.16547110676765442,
0.37541866302490234,
0.01491178385913372,
0.21951694786548615,
0.44641703367233276,
-0.14455664157867432,
0.3494587540626526,
0.48635101318359375,
-0.34356382489204407,
-0.15462154150009155,
0.8107213377952576,
0.3340410590171814,
0.19793055951595306,
0.3670639097690582,
0.2702708840370178,
-0.12250137329101562,
-0.7776110172271729,
0.10190831869840622,
0.26276707649230957,
-0.654410183429718,
-0.1560693085193634,
-0.5326952934265137,
-0.658656895160675,
-0.8554421663284302,
-0.04433367773890495,
-0.1405791938304901,
-0.33207282423973083,
-0.47287777066230774,
-0.19552172720432281,
0.15238355100154877,
1.2582803964614868,
-0.1713687777519226,
0.22673067450523376,
-1.0057897567749023,
0.3006318509578705,
0.13925093412399292,
0.49696075916290283,
-0.10711568593978882,
-0.6060821413993835,
-0.2910190522670746,
0.02999235689640045,
-0.5201426148414612,
-0.9315237402915955,
0.31879234313964844,
0.10119635611772537,
0.6543929576873779,
0.5735925436019897,
0.09944650530815125,
0.5663262605667114,
-0.5547276139259338,
0.6948627233505249,
0.32224932312965393,
-0.7038634419441223,
0.5568965673446655,
-0.5146324038505554,
-0.13051888346672058,
0.41496607661247253,
0.8669681549072266,
-0.3481421172618866,
-0.15794672071933746,
-0.9555191993713379,
-0.6228647232055664,
0.6778573393821716,
0.33955588936805725,
-0.12485901266336441,
-0.08647336810827255,
0.04036342352628708,
0.23947438597679138,
0.1593971848487854,
-0.2780649960041046,
-0.011243383400142193,
0.04828908294439316,
-0.9134297370910645,
-0.3578747510910034,
-0.30246859788894653,
0.04161500930786133,
-0.5959137082099915,
0.5887895226478577,
0.12389298528432846,
0.4965422749519348,
-0.12436845898628235,
-0.006008212920278311,
-0.21722303330898285,
-0.09740889817476273,
0.5493737459182739,
0.7426795959472656,
-0.5459411144256592,
0.23730918765068054,
-0.26944148540496826,
-0.5758318305015564,
-0.06274771690368652,
0.281387597322464,
0.030879897996783257,
0.10280213505029678,
0.7290608882904053,
0.5064833164215088,
0.44666925072669983,
-0.4312214255332947,
0.7820660471916199,
-0.27993470430374146,
-0.38845372200012207,
-0.34699299931526184,
-0.07625128328800201,
0.2256494164466858,
-0.09210289269685745,
0.37221240997314453,
-0.030207861214876175,
0.11922045052051544,
-0.7417865991592407,
0.6794179081916809,
0.04081817343831062,
-0.11576218158006668,
-0.639320433139801,
0.39451998472213745,
0.3428862392902374,
-0.2461099475622177,
0.23325960338115692,
-0.2892407774925232,
-0.657832682132721,
0.6476358771324158,
0.3954148590564728,
0.49648648500442505,
-0.6041231155395508,
0.18267078697681427,
0.3237271010875702,
0.4117811322212219,
-0.09649638086557388,
0.625255286693573,
0.344705730676651,
-0.876305878162384,
-0.5287917256355286,
-0.4542291760444641,
-0.4119393527507782,
0.17669130861759186,
-0.5850774049758911,
0.35576388239860535,
-0.612419068813324,
-0.4243531823158264,
0.7026124000549316,
0.15959936380386353,
-0.8189427852630615,
0.5890594124794006,
0.3208952844142914,
0.54911869764328,
-0.9635648131370544,
1.0164636373519897,
0.745561957359314,
-0.25723856687545776,
-0.825262188911438,
0.48086684942245483,
0.12491751462221146,
-0.6718525886535645,
0.5729314088821411,
0.36696189641952515,
0.40752112865448,
0.1127583384513855,
-0.7249310612678528,
-0.8484636545181274,
0.6914172768592834,
-0.12191906571388245,
-0.5929428935050964,
-0.03772610053420067,
-0.13237826526165009,
0.623980700969696,
-0.41492971777915955,
0.2729934751987457,
0.6610042452812195,
0.3639918863773346,
0.21457287669181824,
-1.5325746536254883,
-0.26419511437416077,
-0.05736454576253891,
-0.20493076741695404,
0.12148430943489075,
-0.2455211877822876,
0.558951199054718,
-0.4571009874343872,
-0.31281015276908875,
-0.11175695061683655,
0.18805134296417236,
0.1071111336350441,
0.47865191102027893,
0.39378196001052856,
0.5856717824935913,
0.8068386316299438,
-0.3505231738090515,
1.151612401008606,
-0.19678007066249847,
0.6052494049072266,
0.8860629200935364,
-0.13835909962654114,
0.9741899371147156,
0.26487794518470764,
-0.4928966164588928,
0.05557521805167198,
1.076633334159851,
0.38364601135253906,
0.7758359313011169,
0.25183436274528503,
-0.10731847584247589,
0.09115461260080338,
0.14911344647407532,
-0.05080672353506088,
0.08864010870456696,
0.8003064393997192,
-0.22921432554721832,
0.0037099586334079504,
0.26704540848731995,
-0.04153139516711235,
-0.057503439486026764,
-0.4203812777996063,
0.758831262588501,
0.1940000206232071,
-0.24524660408496857,
0.5716298222541809,
0.08071722090244293,
0.9668183326721191,
-0.13089753687381744,
0.03935466706752777,
0.20556002855300903,
0.21557492017745972,
-0.32659390568733215,
-0.9170900583267212,
0.5891452431678772,
0.0014429721049964428,
-0.0877474695444107,
-0.1379045844078064,
0.7425071597099304,
-0.39383411407470703,
-0.6969689726829529,
0.3711322844028473,
0.23107773065567017,
0.33792856335639954,
0.12866757810115814,
-0.7261370420455933,
0.12462688982486725,
-0.04608315974473953,
-0.06884706020355225,
0.025932397693395615,
0.5135914087295532,
-0.28319939970970154,
0.5545307993888855,
0.5427839756011963,
0.22041991353034973,
0.31238260865211487,
0.2648884654045105,
0.6998920440673828,
-0.7202370166778564,
-0.34078720211982727,
-0.5953688025474548,
0.22862936556339264,
-0.06785143166780472,
-0.028747590258717537,
0.5322805047035217,
0.40330567955970764,
0.8924754858016968,
0.01154970284551382,
1.0054627656936646,
-0.16921313107013702,
1.2863060235977173,
-0.11278770864009857,
0.6217979192733765,
-0.521592915058136,
0.000809168559499085,
-0.1832914650440216,
-0.4576399028301239,
-0.5820211172103882,
0.6034665703773499,
-0.49440798163414,
0.3479325473308563,
0.9635621309280396,
0.3324142396450043,
-0.07734455913305283,
0.07868687063455582,
0.32926732301712036,
0.4212561249732971,
0.4414796233177185,
0.718284547328949,
0.6165213584899902,
-0.4066929221153259,
0.09010583162307739,
-0.41784974932670593,
-0.42478859424591064,
-0.5146222710609436,
-0.5008701086044312,
-1.0629408359527588,
-0.5839614272117615,
-0.24772685766220093,
-0.3370217978954315,
0.4407136142253876,
1.0700056552886963,
0.9360191226005554,
-1.151206612586975,
0.3294593393802643,
0.2366732358932495,
-0.2725355923175812,
0.010724703781306744,
-0.2322528213262558,
0.2893812954425812,
-0.22233158349990845,
-0.5132014155387878,
-0.009218522347509861,
-0.05428548529744148,
0.13453856110572815,
0.081545889377594,
0.03267955034971237,
-0.12222704291343689,
0.11542659252882004,
0.630541205406189,
-0.2449531853199005,
-0.5620658993721008,
-0.42463821172714233,
-0.3033525049686432,
-0.522445797920227,
0.0008710094843991101,
0.36236920952796936,
-0.34252116084098816,
0.10154534876346588,
0.4297747313976288,
0.6330302357673645,
0.6623411178588867,
0.07739691436290741,
0.36284947395324707,
-0.6811336278915405,
-0.181673064827919,
0.8045206665992737,
0.2210111767053604,
0.43662434816360474,
-0.23086607456207275,
0.4776683449745178,
0.26962006092071533,
-0.5413260459899902,
-0.8312343955039978,
-0.052844978868961334,
-1.1105393171310425,
-0.2272760570049286,
1.0938410758972168,
-0.14321808516979218,
-0.21627633273601532,
-0.23203256726264954,
0.06749896705150604,
0.24477329850196838,
-0.36711585521698,
0.8798238635063171,
0.7417440414428711,
0.026559388265013695,
-0.4094918370246887,
-0.720221996307373,
0.2920185923576355,
-0.037363164126873016,
-0.9011748433113098,
-0.578141987323761,
0.10752660036087036,
0.564965546131134,
-0.04011276364326477,
0.8600822687149048,
-0.19550472497940063,
0.29442837834358215,
-0.24099363386631012,
0.1218779906630516,
0.4823493957519531,
-0.3818671405315399,
-0.15695838630199432,
-0.12017548084259033,
-0.054472293704748154,
-0.16095022857189178
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.07753v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.07753v1
|
The MuSe 2024 Multimodal Sentiment Analysis Challenge: Social Perception and Humor Recognition
| 2024-06-11T22:26:20 | 2024-06-11T22:26:20 |
Shahin Amiriparian, Lukas Christ, Alexander Kathan, Maurice Gerczuk, Niklas Müller, Steffen Klug, Lukas Stappen, Andreas König, Erik Cambria, Björn Schuller, Simone Eulitz
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, 68T10, I.2
|
The Multimodal Sentiment Analysis Challenge (MuSe) 2024 addresses two
contemporary multimodal affect and sentiment analysis problems: In the Social
Perception Sub-Challenge (MuSe-Perception), participants will predict 16
different social attributes of individuals such as assertiveness, dominance,
likability, and sincerity based on the provided audio-visual data. The
Cross-Cultural Humor Detection Sub-Challenge (MuSe-Humor) dataset expands upon
the Passau Spontaneous Football Coach Humor (Passau-SFCH) dataset, focusing on
the detection of spontaneous humor in a cross-lingual and cross-cultural
setting. The main objective of MuSe 2024 is to unite a broad audience from
various research domains, including multimodal sentiment analysis, audio-visual
affective computing, continuous signal processing, and natural language
processing. By fostering collaboration and exchange among experts in these
fields, the MuSe 2024 endeavors to advance the understanding and application of
sentiment analysis and affective computing across multiple modalities. This
baseline paper provides details on each sub-challenge and its corresponding
dataset, extracted features from each data modality, and discusses challenge
baselines. For our baseline system, we make use of a range of Transformers and
expert-designed features and train Gated Recurrent Unit (GRU)-Recurrent Neural
Network (RNN) models on them, resulting in a competitive baseline system. On
the unseen test datasets of the respective sub-challenges, it achieves a mean
Pearson's Correlation Coefficient ($\rho$) of 0.3573 for MuSe-Perception and an
Area Under the Curve (AUC) value of 0.8682 for MuSe-Humor.
|
[
-0.7352327704429626,
-0.3461408317089081,
0.35260966420173645,
0.8671376705169678,
-0.23310737311840057,
0.006092810537666082,
-0.12145140022039413,
-0.6267578601837158,
0.3482106029987335,
-0.09046152234077454,
-1.2385146617889404,
-0.28606116771698,
-0.5170360803604126,
0.21503666043281555,
0.008617215789854527,
1.007009506225586,
0.24935010075569153,
0.32225683331489563,
-0.5581840872764587,
-0.4566501975059509,
-0.5977132320404053,
-0.37721771001815796,
-0.49786725640296936,
-0.16338762640953064,
0.8940359950065613,
0.3004078269004822,
0.15617673099040985,
-0.13695991039276123,
0.8312594294548035,
0.2984456717967987,
-0.0034133964218199253,
-0.1006358340382576,
-0.46062687039375305,
-0.044969670474529266,
-0.24013975262641907,
-0.3613368570804596,
-0.6635571122169495,
0.24068711698055267,
0.25500038266181946,
0.4701361656188965,
0.25789251923561096,
0.14178644120693207,
-0.17879512906074524,
0.38416600227355957,
-0.23972472548484802,
0.36073192954063416,
-0.5459412336349487,
0.4552878141403198,
-0.4332726299762726,
-0.33850565552711487,
-0.23319928348064423,
-0.06554226577281952,
0.13588900864124298,
-0.4483010172843933,
0.1161523386836052,
0.1410117745399475,
0.8507891297340393,
0.3201735317707062,
-0.5912696719169617,
-0.16030719876289368,
-0.460091233253479,
1.026513695716858,
-0.4860117733478546,
0.3890931010246277,
0.009907117113471031,
0.3045443594455719,
-0.051609981805086136,
-0.4648279547691345,
-0.8495495915412903,
0.11514034122228622,
0.33648139238357544,
0.638750433921814,
-0.46918559074401855,
-0.2663288414478302,
0.1856207698583603,
0.6359684467315674,
-0.6301676630973816,
-0.15480370819568634,
-0.3002786934375763,
-0.1900877058506012,
0.5048595666885376,
0.3004148602485657,
0.31260719895362854,
-0.5822650194168091,
-0.5450873970985413,
0.17044179141521454,
-0.40367165207862854,
0.22896808385849,
0.43844982981681824,
-0.06028749793767929,
-0.1202763020992279,
0.42601776123046875,
-0.3922215700149536,
0.10283951461315155,
-0.16923154890537262,
-0.1619175225496292,
0.7288002967834473,
-0.3419525623321533,
-0.07653004676103592,
-0.47106483578681946,
0.9027524590492249,
0.482038676738739,
0.1372014731168747,
-0.1911916881799698,
-0.1282486468553543,
0.39132606983184814,
0.2434655725955963,
-0.21302850544452667,
-0.17465320229530334,
0.04255098104476929,
-0.4942830502986908,
-0.5331175923347473,
-0.37654516100883484,
-1.1580289602279663,
-0.5548112392425537,
-0.45087531208992004,
0.645460844039917,
-0.37607884407043457,
-0.16422559320926666,
-0.029518522322177887,
-0.3092385232448578,
0.2654135525226593,
0.652136504650116,
-0.40236154198646545,
0.05000215023756027,
0.5885034799575806,
0.7430201172828674,
-0.29822686314582825,
-0.24247796833515167,
-0.24068298935890198,
-0.3137092590332031,
0.15790937840938568,
0.8265816569328308,
-0.44160351157188416,
-0.3352915942668915,
-0.3938055634498596,
0.2476235330104828,
-0.1903173178434372,
-0.25102144479751587,
1.0191515684127808,
-0.22811217606067657,
0.1882888823747635,
-0.681159257888794,
-0.12809275090694427,
-0.1817742884159088,
0.46525996923446655,
-0.8545214533805847,
0.935164749622345,
0.11146312206983566,
-0.8234237432479858,
0.49546024203300476,
-0.8417285680770874,
-0.48397165536880493,
-0.0690571665763855,
0.09964179992675781,
-0.3617013394832611,
0.25403815507888794,
0.2647916078567505,
0.1863599568605423,
-0.3459908068180084,
-0.07443933188915253,
-0.666144073009491,
-0.08256617188453674,
0.3591459393501282,
-0.6514781713485718,
0.6318562626838684,
0.17889314889907837,
-0.6640793681144714,
0.12886658310890198,
-0.8258844017982483,
-0.24296054244041443,
0.09243309497833252,
-0.36806514859199524,
0.23322145640850067,
0.05065080150961876,
0.10616789758205414,
0.6284507513046265,
0.16647103428840637,
-0.9565291404724121,
0.0513390488922596,
-0.04591740667819977,
0.5741506218910217,
0.9574465155601501,
-0.15411275625228882,
0.17913812398910522,
-0.12346024066209793,
0.7098722457885742,
0.26123490929603577,
0.5900217890739441,
-0.11877952516078949,
-0.8147414922714233,
-0.9538034796714783,
-0.3047953248023987,
-0.033562034368515015,
0.7213879823684692,
-0.4996747374534607,
-0.005009042099118233,
-0.41739335656166077,
-0.5208199620246887,
-0.6709781289100647,
0.003601419972255826,
0.1997617930173874,
0.694963812828064,
0.5200421214103699,
-0.30223843455314636,
-0.7345107793807983,
-0.8628787398338318,
-0.15713335573673248,
0.023353075608611107,
0.32168665528297424,
0.8002323508262634,
0.35139623284339905,
-0.1892520934343338,
0.6360951066017151,
-0.25408312678337097,
-0.48836198449134827,
-0.25421908497810364,
0.6425743699073792,
0.08035647869110107,
0.5820411443710327,
0.81602543592453,
-1.0750125646591187,
-0.11430926620960236,
-0.19876646995544434,
-0.7437360882759094,
-0.2605528235435486,
0.25128865242004395,
-0.011728729121387005,
0.22348856925964355,
0.12469058483839035,
-0.7166652083396912,
0.5687766075134277,
0.4225510060787201,
-0.057752575725317,
0.5691736936569214,
0.44359076023101807,
0.6042783856391907,
-0.8896179795265198,
-0.026725096628069878,
-0.0072762807831168175,
-0.053942374885082245,
-0.3722652494907379,
-0.2900213301181793,
-0.2882378399372101,
-0.3752753734588623,
-0.36264750361442566,
0.3145155906677246,
-0.24661949276924133,
-0.26484012603759766,
0.21314692497253418,
-0.02686968818306923,
0.13432972133159637,
0.5276394486427307,
-0.17244020104408264,
0.43825188279151917,
0.4439849853515625,
-0.19231203198432922,
0.9465197324752808,
0.1838568150997162,
-0.3837129473686218,
1.1661553382873535,
-0.482044517993927,
0.3192686438560486,
-0.17182572185993195,
0.28133997321128845,
-1.3409334421157837,
-0.3377571403980255,
0.08129390329122543,
-0.817549467086792,
0.1096833348274231,
0.11141747236251831,
-0.1437954306602478,
-0.6396896243095398,
-0.15682947635650635,
0.5838090181350708,
0.27570196986198425,
-0.3808674216270447,
0.9192934632301331,
0.20482105016708374,
-0.3137657940387726,
-0.7298979759216309,
-0.8452180624008179,
0.3604656755924225,
-0.5693957209587097,
-0.907167911529541,
0.2130158245563507,
-0.41309237480163574,
0.04635399207472801,
-0.0471830852329731,
0.04847574606537819,
0.2719077169895172,
0.032992471009492874,
0.38956543803215027,
0.2608850300312042,
-0.23188361525535583,
-0.10571836680173874,
-0.30357933044433594,
-0.13894812762737274,
0.21508337557315826,
-0.07659713178873062,
0.5211871266365051,
-0.3324688673019409,
-0.39065149426460266,
-0.5061565637588501,
0.3754194378852844,
0.8172763586044312,
-0.3936256468296051,
0.2600351870059967,
1.0178848505020142,
-0.2788540720939636,
0.03776869550347328,
-0.6907987594604492,
0.06758453696966171,
-0.42357704043388367,
0.3228846788406372,
-0.49586567282676697,
-0.6667343378067017,
0.8949861526489258,
-0.01694490946829319,
-0.22420893609523773,
0.3969617486000061,
0.5495612025260925,
-0.33718380331993103,
1.2572879791259766,
0.49981340765953064,
-0.3220507800579071,
0.3625359535217285,
-0.13506850600242615,
0.2460150569677353,
-0.9056336879730225,
-0.7165048122406006,
-0.5081711411476135,
-0.8915557861328125,
-0.05065244063735008,
-0.393911749124527,
0.3814653158187866,
-0.26660972833633423,
0.03588151931762695,
0.2881354093551636,
0.056415457278490067,
0.0728682279586792,
0.6159409284591675,
0.12181881815195084,
-0.035033438354730606,
-0.3082345724105835,
-0.29211193323135376,
-0.38819533586502075,
-0.33221858739852905,
0.04427758976817131,
0.7323041558265686,
0.3404487669467926,
0.6908583045005798,
0.34874653816223145,
0.3176000714302063,
0.4572819173336029,
0.2705966830253601,
-1.0786269903182983,
0.7139129638671875,
-0.10142466425895691,
-0.5317111611366272,
0.15884330868721008,
-0.4953639507293701,
-0.4012378752231598,
-0.14731049537658691,
-0.3607880473136902,
-0.87806636095047,
0.5604358315467834,
0.05114290490746498,
-0.05840561166405678,
0.15767766535282135,
-0.44241833686828613,
1.085945963859558,
-0.08696551620960236,
-0.3183322548866272,
-0.0898413211107254,
-0.7066834568977356,
0.4111655354499817,
0.14525221288204193,
0.3210285007953644,
-0.20007820427417755,
0.29433128237724304,
0.42424485087394714,
0.03073246218264103,
0.6904451847076416,
-0.1678464710712433,
0.2176932692527771,
-0.03951849415898323,
0.030083773657679558,
0.30719515681266785,
0.04427170753479004,
-0.0610746368765831,
0.03628869354724884,
-0.39868655800819397,
-0.3431430459022522,
-0.5751883387565613,
0.8072580099105835,
-0.679806113243103,
-0.4223804771900177,
-0.30529090762138367,
-0.678876519203186,
-0.5240793824195862,
-0.014570356346666813,
0.4044218361377716,
0.644344687461853,
-0.255670428276062,
0.5242096185684204,
0.6027034521102905,
-0.2551065981388092,
0.5771936178207397,
0.2521986961364746,
0.1269119828939438,
-0.7403783798217773,
1.067500114440918,
-0.03769608959555626,
0.013118715025484562,
0.2915099263191223,
0.12892410159111023,
-0.428377240896225,
-0.3446022868156433,
-0.4296763837337494,
-0.061938490718603134,
-0.9064093828201294,
-0.3274526596069336,
-0.8364241123199463,
0.18487703800201416,
-0.6719738245010376,
-0.00275553110986948,
-0.16112013161182404,
-0.4363315999507904,
-0.45079734921455383,
-0.08557883650064468,
0.226044699549675,
0.5679627060890198,
-0.20938889682292938,
0.07587987929582596,
-0.566560685634613,
0.07613537460565567,
0.29270702600479126,
0.1732676923274994,
-0.11180077493190765,
-0.36267974972724915,
0.13131177425384521,
-0.18847119808197021,
-0.3759510815143585,
-0.9993562698364258,
0.35461288690567017,
0.3710719645023346,
0.4646880328655243,
0.7313308715820312,
-0.1456843763589859,
0.8266159892082214,
-0.3145332336425781,
0.9722216129302979,
0.24911940097808838,
-1.017676830291748,
0.5497512817382812,
-0.5249276161193848,
-0.08214401453733444,
0.34981879591941833,
0.4716816246509552,
-0.5249089002609253,
-0.07082317769527435,
-0.47479701042175293,
-0.6743485331535339,
0.771378219127655,
0.16833564639091492,
0.2593004107475281,
-0.13497458398342133,
0.12238305062055588,
-0.1156492680311203,
0.4277145266532898,
-1.0361987352371216,
0.01691717840731144,
-0.6316642761230469,
-0.3872973620891571,
-0.04329037293791771,
-0.05968466401100159,
-0.19834619760513306,
-0.3825787305831909,
0.4711712598800659,
-0.20247535407543182,
0.5222979784011841,
0.029137039557099342,
0.01231179665774107,
-0.11229110509157181,
0.27875834703445435,
0.7598104476928711,
0.36187219619750977,
-0.3064165413379669,
0.1499265879392624,
0.29517772793769836,
-0.3727104961872101,
-0.13286647200584412,
0.020327294245362282,
0.16356205940246582,
-0.12530778348445892,
0.32524561882019043,
1.1494280099868774,
0.43529823422431946,
-0.5127381086349487,
0.6271223425865173,
0.05577225610613823,
-0.05102923884987831,
-0.36883074045181274,
-0.18917766213417053,
0.12372003495693207,
0.3899705111980438,
0.36217978596687317,
0.5578680038452148,
0.4617854356765747,
-0.8519384860992432,
0.17460139095783234,
0.4665709137916565,
-0.8132237792015076,
-0.8369081020355225,
0.6786181330680847,
0.1391027867794037,
0.043102674186229706,
0.29321905970573425,
-0.2690664827823639,
-1.0234038829803467,
0.7341228723526001,
0.565491259098053,
0.7733758091926575,
-0.1363704651594162,
0.26091066002845764,
0.21974243223667145,
0.23978038132190704,
0.27547091245651245,
0.6203390955924988,
0.10963548719882965,
-0.663030207157135,
-0.1519344002008438,
-0.8448765277862549,
-0.26230713725090027,
0.2307787984609604,
-0.6862706542015076,
0.38875070214271545,
-0.35353884100914,
-0.3837350606918335,
0.26066499948501587,
-0.1531851440668106,
-0.8193112015724182,
0.6251002550125122,
0.08456622064113617,
0.7971887588500977,
-0.7396270632743835,
0.3079354166984558,
0.8583337664604187,
-0.5574916005134583,
-0.6780380010604858,
-0.3575872778892517,
0.6307424306869507,
-0.626406192779541,
0.8874116539955139,
0.18321795761585236,
-0.22117704153060913,
-0.1731729358434677,
-0.5084854364395142,
-0.5911016464233398,
1.0893903970718384,
0.2125782072544098,
-0.026448342949151993,
0.04554358124732971,
0.17565971612930298,
0.40724584460258484,
-0.6124705076217651,
0.23003976047039032,
0.29670050740242004,
0.5945152640342712,
0.4812520444393158,
-0.7347181439399719,
-0.289725124835968,
-0.6819433569908142,
-0.38951003551483154,
-0.017870690673589706,
-0.8676775693893433,
1.2276183366775513,
0.015169222839176655,
0.068341925740242,
0.09510190784931183,
0.7152189612388611,
0.055193912237882614,
0.7293672561645508,
0.732196569442749,
1.1061848402023315,
0.5186034440994263,
-0.6176775097846985,
0.8326935768127441,
0.06740307062864304,
0.37349578738212585,
0.8026771545410156,
-0.2071094959974289,
0.7335895299911499,
0.3123167157173157,
-0.2554185688495636,
0.6259904503822327,
0.6228965520858765,
-0.11254440248012543,
0.44499659538269043,
0.05452549830079079,
-0.4076874554157257,
-0.34412968158721924,
-0.2373037338256836,
-0.30384334921836853,
0.6692721247673035,
0.21438492834568024,
-0.12587013840675354,
-0.06521179527044296,
0.601742148399353,
0.10098301619291306,
-0.3965030312538147,
-0.40049293637275696,
0.686303973197937,
0.032235901802778244,
-0.4847185015678406,
-0.09462472796440125,
-0.19582009315490723,
0.7487509846687317,
-0.4167839586734772,
0.11646860837936401,
-0.32460451126098633,
0.15984408557415009,
-0.3239114582538605,
-0.6725046038627625,
0.19343486428260803,
-0.08134079724550247,
-0.35825127363204956,
0.1278599500656128,
0.7692044377326965,
-0.0643349215388298,
-0.42455706000328064,
0.43061065673828125,
0.048766396939754486,
0.17491383850574493,
-0.20161162316799164,
-0.8725155591964722,
0.1184999868273735,
-0.17497867345809937,
-0.34619832038879395,
0.22736206650733948,
0.8229551315307617,
0.021457288414239883,
0.7222846746444702,
0.6579161286354065,
-0.05217490717768669,
0.2846429944038391,
0.37575361132621765,
1.049312710762024,
-0.6167476177215576,
-0.5143990516662598,
-0.516152024269104,
0.6151533126831055,
-0.1557549685239792,
-0.5834685564041138,
0.765488862991333,
0.3918090760707855,
0.33068418502807617,
-0.32142990827560425,
0.6487587094306946,
-0.32965731620788574,
0.3514406085014343,
-0.30003097653388977,
0.5205445885658264,
-1.0675116777420044,
-0.016322337090969086,
-0.8533632755279541,
-0.858398973941803,
-0.1100211888551712,
0.44837814569473267,
-0.26619642972946167,
0.16505052149295807,
0.5850669145584106,
0.6089662313461304,
-0.20760434865951538,
0.3422680199146271,
0.06307727843523026,
0.09423236548900604,
0.2579326927661896,
0.7191113233566284,
1.0366613864898682,
-0.23238220810890198,
0.6363255977630615,
-0.4129040241241455,
-0.33274951577186584,
-0.1803736388683319,
-1.0880223512649536,
-0.7494882941246033,
-0.5994692444801331,
-0.1532815545797348,
-0.4632314443588257,
-0.39363929629325867,
0.6286261081695557,
0.6263449192047119,
-0.885344922542572,
0.3037826120853424,
0.00720172980800271,
-0.055180083960294724,
-0.16751155257225037,
-0.3828718364238739,
-0.020682234317064285,
-0.37206950783729553,
-0.9067292213439941,
0.5584240555763245,
0.6560949683189392,
-0.09869810938835144,
-0.5078073143959045,
0.08982507884502411,
-0.13205403089523315,
0.3914879262447357,
0.6026584506034851,
0.24543730914592743,
-0.6270663142204285,
-0.5104032158851624,
0.48031508922576904,
0.21300874650478363,
0.10551350563764572,
0.7915547490119934,
-0.5269759893417358,
0.3845232129096985,
0.7855395078659058,
0.5226379632949829,
0.3147384524345398,
0.0014944076538085938,
0.36334025859832764,
-0.6668455600738525,
0.21143656969070435,
0.4411328136920929,
0.6598685383796692,
0.4278144836425781,
-0.34919625520706177,
0.5088812708854675,
1.0108530521392822,
-0.5441076159477234,
-0.971518874168396,
0.42982885241508484,
-1.5780603885650635,
0.23745954036712646,
0.6570122838020325,
-0.4845411479473114,
-0.3027850091457367,
-0.15616968274116516,
-0.19852286577224731,
-0.009372040629386902,
-0.15185290575027466,
0.7044589519500732,
1.0117350816726685,
-0.2605063021183014,
-0.5392850041389465,
-0.5447342991828918,
0.53319251537323,
0.6766914129257202,
-0.9065894484519958,
-0.40366917848587036,
0.5474691390991211,
0.2776593565940857,
0.4578056037425995,
0.496681809425354,
-0.3801279664039612,
0.4309990704059601,
-0.1360856592655182,
0.07228416204452515,
0.03206028789281845,
-0.560371994972229,
-0.14681991934776306,
0.32615119218826294,
-0.5480428338050842,
0.09127958863973618
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.07739v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.07739v1
|
UICoder: Finetuning Large Language Models to Generate User Interface Code through Automated Feedback
| 2024-06-11T21:53:46 | 2024-06-11T21:53:46 |
Jason Wu, Eldon Schoop, Alan Leung, Titus Barik, Jeffrey P. Bigham, Jeffrey Nichols
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.HC, cs.SE
|
Large language models (LLMs) struggle to consistently generate UI code that
compiles and produces visually relevant designs. Existing approaches to improve
generation rely on expensive human feedback or distilling a proprietary model.
In this paper, we explore the use of automated feedback (compilers and
multi-modal models) to guide LLMs to generate high-quality UI code. Our method
starts with an existing LLM and iteratively produces improved models by
self-generating a large synthetic dataset using an original model, applying
automated tools to aggressively filter, score, and de-duplicate the data into a
refined higher quality dataset. The original LLM is improved by finetuning on
this refined dataset. We applied our approach to several open-source LLMs and
compared the resulting performance to baseline models with both automated
metrics and human preferences. Our evaluation shows the resulting models
outperform all other downloadable baselines and approach the performance of
larger proprietary models.
|
[
-0.517764687538147,
-0.5301390886306763,
0.36301615834236145,
-0.08608417958021164,
0.05148261785507202,
-0.003975320141762495,
-0.26031601428985596,
-0.2833268642425537,
-0.07090289145708084,
0.8150870203971863,
-0.37398818135261536,
-0.4608318507671356,
-0.04277225583791733,
0.3691556751728058,
-0.42941030859947205,
0.893054187297821,
-0.12946906685829163,
-0.0010548412101343274,
-0.3183068633079529,
0.05649300664663315,
-0.3719671070575714,
-0.6437684297561646,
-0.25275832414627075,
-0.33495500683784485,
0.48011648654937744,
0.6276925802230835,
0.7269108891487122,
0.5689457654953003,
0.2817278802394867,
0.3691800832748413,
0.28072232007980347,
0.38665059208869934,
-0.6760639548301697,
0.012899658642709255,
0.12415140122175217,
-0.27695950865745544,
-0.30383172631263733,
-0.04952571541070938,
0.4252391457557678,
0.5206850171089172,
-0.06573569029569626,
0.31151631474494934,
0.3537905812263489,
0.7917094230651855,
-0.42274272441864014,
0.2382584661245346,
-0.3030970096588135,
-0.06949476897716522,
-0.047405749559402466,
-0.23133485019207,
-0.6708541512489319,
-0.6373774409294128,
-0.4358963370323181,
-0.391236275434494,
0.07143072038888931,
0.14768086373806,
0.6077551245689392,
0.45853930711746216,
-0.2886951267719269,
-0.17382948100566864,
-0.9034150838851929,
0.7217702865600586,
-1.0618455410003662,
0.48299866914749146,
0.19698931276798248,
0.14579655230045319,
-0.2486499696969986,
-0.6222248077392578,
-0.5948231816291809,
-0.9530673623085022,
-0.13232682645320892,
-0.03634629398584366,
-0.09454864263534546,
-0.01207274105399847,
0.32954928278923035,
0.4871200621128082,
-0.2261192500591278,
0.29008275270462036,
-0.5186095833778381,
-0.1268680840730667,
0.8026149272918701,
0.26456499099731445,
0.3153243362903595,
-0.37679144740104675,
-0.00559096597135067,
-0.013273749500513077,
-0.8003184795379639,
0.11424123495817184,
0.5400301218032837,
0.14393605291843414,
-0.07414855808019638,
0.7772566080093384,
-0.5331833362579346,
0.6880789995193481,
0.279655784368515,
-0.12371071428060532,
0.26637354493141174,
-0.3423556089401245,
-0.012768222950398922,
-0.48977604508399963,
0.8627345561981201,
0.5368924736976624,
0.4230572283267975,
-0.13199223577976227,
-0.5641859173774719,
0.009197891689836979,
0.5376272201538086,
-0.8012697696685791,
-0.5351603031158447,
0.09399130940437317,
-0.8204604983329773,
-0.2733966112136841,
0.09841059148311615,
-0.4844331741333008,
-0.25086843967437744,
-1.0770246982574463,
0.2544797658920288,
-0.16369250416755676,
-0.14693213999271393,
-0.18956680595874786,
-0.03193601220846176,
-0.053367409855127335,
0.6417570114135742,
-0.6978690028190613,
0.09044628590345383,
0.36018699407577515,
0.6123906970024109,
-0.41569119691848755,
-0.07990218698978424,
-0.7935532331466675,
-0.11796792596578598,
-0.45498573780059814,
0.6151828169822693,
-0.37628042697906494,
-0.5299890637397766,
-0.22834080457687378,
-0.3121127188205719,
0.4355125427246094,
-0.7722600102424622,
0.018883518874645233,
-0.31747812032699585,
-0.053344741463661194,
0.051522862166166306,
-0.5381312966346741,
0.0880713164806366,
-0.0003324947610963136,
-0.7865036725997925,
0.962096095085144,
0.4813147187232971,
-0.5469933152198792,
0.25369536876678467,
-0.7157992720603943,
-0.21436238288879395,
0.27439209818840027,
-0.34118640422821045,
-0.2728945016860962,
0.530114471912384,
0.2530554234981537,
0.4416247606277466,
-0.33848658204078674,
0.2511875331401825,
-0.3205260932445526,
-0.1204681396484375,
0.3684713542461395,
-0.3512687385082245,
0.5061243176460266,
0.692553699016571,
-0.27928948402404785,
0.3745276927947998,
-1.0597941875457764,
0.27769455313682556,
-0.2270277887582779,
-0.7570252418518066,
-0.08891795575618744,
-0.010133756324648857,
0.3708396553993225,
0.1835414320230484,
0.12318700551986694,
-0.45396628975868225,
0.3592413067817688,
-0.13985072076320648,
0.44147393107414246,
0.7487083077430725,
-0.21528016030788422,
0.461984783411026,
-0.42769962549209595,
0.5621742010116577,
-0.2042749673128128,
0.21385525166988373,
-0.2398066371679306,
-0.09034375101327896,
-0.8697196245193481,
-0.18220290541648865,
0.35879233479499817,
0.3740493953227997,
-0.9684388637542725,
0.5300805568695068,
-0.1699076145887375,
-0.41285771131515503,
-0.5228821635246277,
0.6265902519226074,
0.33842289447784424,
0.3721044659614563,
0.12183380872011185,
-0.7699203491210938,
-0.35382699966430664,
-0.7993178367614746,
0.11320388317108154,
-0.16396284103393555,
-0.3979544937610626,
0.3270001709461212,
0.3978053331375122,
-0.7610616683959961,
1.2081421613693237,
-0.294069766998291,
-0.05585791543126106,
-0.3000926375389099,
0.40907108783721924,
-0.13439367711544037,
0.5471247434616089,
0.5534778833389282,
-0.3680623769760132,
-0.38693904876708984,
0.19940601289272308,
-0.5954334735870361,
-0.4576147198677063,
-0.03533454239368439,
0.1147264763712883,
0.3235572278499603,
0.5798490047454834,
-0.09958858042955399,
0.2570309042930603,
0.5816076993942261,
-0.04767890274524689,
0.8488702774047852,
-0.299350380897522,
0.3818759024143219,
-0.9121385812759399,
0.3421851396560669,
0.03280429169535637,
-0.32288065552711487,
-0.4272705912590027,
0.34904566407203674,
0.059886634349823,
-0.20414581894874573,
-0.33146244287490845,
0.5612599849700928,
-0.5715692043304443,
0.042448610067367554,
-0.4110371470451355,
-0.5201844573020935,
0.034362904727458954,
0.49006256461143494,
-0.21503295004367828,
0.9098524451255798,
0.008942611515522003,
-0.6170732975006104,
0.6686835885047913,
0.11952104419469833,
-0.5614380240440369,
0.5584089756011963,
-0.7385978102684021,
0.1412961483001709,
-0.07078706473112106,
0.17341601848602295,
-0.9662274718284607,
-0.6923685669898987,
-0.045719098299741745,
-0.29857057332992554,
0.18321794271469116,
-0.21298708021640778,
-0.7296472787857056,
-0.6637735366821289,
-0.29590532183647156,
0.14066322147846222,
0.7619085311889648,
-0.5977622866630554,
0.5051690340042114,
0.3176341652870178,
-0.5023593902587891,
0.06873676180839539,
-0.5664755702018738,
0.1888677328824997,
0.10352038592100143,
-0.5199026465415955,
-0.02283930405974388,
-0.4550030827522278,
-0.35283926129341125,
-0.2943095862865448,
0.16982205212116241,
-0.055762678384780884,
0.035978447645902634,
0.428658127784729,
0.2722148001194,
-0.13388653099536896,
-0.04009975120425224,
-0.09276441484689713,
-0.1273486465215683,
-0.00515265017747879,
-0.01990452967584133,
0.40705493092536926,
-0.056402623653411865,
-0.5230200886726379,
-0.8686302304267883,
0.3540450930595398,
0.788820207118988,
-0.20255941152572632,
0.08542082458734512,
0.4719664752483368,
-0.026140158995985985,
-0.2089402675628662,
-0.8364221453666687,
-0.08879699558019638,
-0.5040478110313416,
0.11144925653934479,
-0.3964047431945801,
-1.0002623796463013,
0.5069728493690491,
-0.25704312324523926,
0.2432817816734314,
0.3508773744106293,
0.7862405776977539,
0.053791437298059464,
1.4624391794204712,
0.7742436528205872,
-0.2034597247838974,
0.5974331498146057,
-0.2635897994041443,
-0.10181070119142532,
-0.53122478723526,
-0.19418038427829742,
-0.7018998265266418,
-0.1280931830406189,
-0.47374746203422546,
-0.27002185583114624,
0.4847261905670166,
0.04266951605677605,
-0.2713497579097748,
0.20810796320438385,
-0.6108540892601013,
0.5156757235527039,
0.948580801486969,
0.13689157366752625,
0.4014066457748413,
0.16497297585010529,
-0.16389872133731842,
0.036000367254018784,
-0.634711742401123,
-0.5925002694129944,
1.0096908807754517,
0.42991653084754944,
1.6212644577026367,
-0.10186909139156342,
0.8172189593315125,
0.3399398624897003,
0.5353939533233643,
-0.6724624633789062,
0.1675909459590912,
-0.3046550154685974,
-0.04509279131889343,
-0.19869443774223328,
-0.7703836560249329,
-0.5317423343658447,
-0.2142179310321808,
-0.11026805639266968,
-0.4787770211696625,
0.04803450405597687,
0.5068053603172302,
-0.5351493954658508,
-0.053510550409555435,
-0.8644425868988037,
0.6866703033447266,
-0.40071702003479004,
-0.46623334288597107,
-0.004177488852292299,
-0.34649282693862915,
0.35198259353637695,
-0.09050550311803818,
0.28159257769584656,
0.07990123331546783,
0.37118619680404663,
0.394496887922287,
-0.8781589269638062,
0.9539846777915955,
-0.12578997015953064,
-0.5509061813354492,
0.3131472170352936,
0.2412102073431015,
0.45979762077331543,
0.020353440195322037,
-0.23814736306667328,
-0.032347291707992554,
-0.06590764969587326,
0.0025229693856090307,
-0.3995680809020996,
0.8436279296875,
-0.9511285424232483,
-0.4322892725467682,
0.31015545129776,
-0.5749741196632385,
-0.000127613267977722,
0.2826075255870819,
0.36645668745040894,
0.9198407530784607,
-0.013264679349958897,
0.2268713116645813,
0.35292017459869385,
-0.36114302277565,
0.1719258427619934,
0.2971157133579254,
-0.4284973740577698,
-0.6414588689804077,
0.8108330965042114,
0.01578230783343315,
0.2835136950016022,
0.07828488200902939,
0.012952559627592564,
-0.32065659761428833,
-0.4236544966697693,
-0.8045734167098999,
-0.1839427351951599,
-0.5626181364059448,
-0.4936220645904541,
-0.3682704567909241,
-0.3871691823005676,
-0.5123031139373779,
-0.2519025504589081,
-0.5142979025840759,
-0.28905820846557617,
-0.38032588362693787,
0.3141440749168396,
0.42806148529052734,
1.1761375665664673,
-0.14622823894023895,
0.33175256848335266,
-1.0652323961257935,
0.682717502117157,
0.4485839009284973,
0.6533109545707703,
0.09348514676094055,
-0.2988681495189667,
-0.34087300300598145,
0.1901751607656479,
-0.4622020125389099,
-0.4291415214538574,
0.5619092583656311,
0.11491119861602783,
0.5456414818763733,
0.24440672993659973,
0.24313472211360931,
0.613853394985199,
-0.6283540725708008,
0.8025496006011963,
0.4560874104499817,
-1.0079700946807861,
0.5653108954429626,
-0.2036893218755722,
0.8160610198974609,
0.5958516597747803,
0.033343225717544556,
-0.3296371102333069,
-0.6437727808952332,
-0.13081760704517365,
-0.671343207359314,
0.4959062933921814,
0.10253474861383438,
0.30013343691825867,
-0.0154680535197258,
0.48218265175819397,
0.3748818635940552,
0.13950692117214203,
-0.7231143712997437,
-0.02798931486904621,
-0.2665070593357086,
-0.28658443689346313,
0.06992939114570618,
-0.21117474138736725,
-0.07073651999235153,
-0.26585954427719116,
0.36342233419418335,
-0.3326253592967987,
0.11509069055318832,
-0.034038957208395004,
-0.346585214138031,
-0.34402090311050415,
0.3087262809276581,
0.2931331694126129,
0.9004012942314148,
0.18087805807590485,
-0.06996335834264755,
-0.08950792998075485,
-0.08213448524475098,
0.2572992146015167,
-0.03837050497531891,
-0.28408634662628174,
0.05030447989702225,
0.17922624945640564,
0.8295748233795166,
0.008716593496501446,
-0.6866730451583862,
0.33624541759490967,
-0.16643477976322174,
-0.15077972412109375,
-0.33173972368240356,
0.4471553862094879,
-0.31710049510002136,
0.08243350684642792,
0.3697109818458557,
0.0838334783911705,
0.3325479328632355,
-0.4382898807525635,
0.26703187823295593,
0.36806780099868774,
-0.10943052172660828,
-0.1613854020833969,
0.9091002345085144,
0.6524028778076172,
-0.2575068771839142,
0.7731741070747375,
0.08049401640892029,
-0.2624378502368927,
0.5161800384521484,
0.21046844124794006,
0.6589889526367188,
-0.09515906125307083,
0.042442385107278824,
0.47814270853996277,
-0.000053212464990792796,
-0.24180886149406433,
0.09191498160362244,
-0.17629943788051605,
-0.30016887187957764,
-0.7342930436134338,
-0.7480701208114624,
-0.43949586153030396,
0.12966957688331604,
-0.7140702605247498,
0.36098262667655945,
-0.40575093030929565,
-0.2059365063905716,
-0.14930002391338348,
-0.23551495373249054,
-0.7284753918647766,
0.05146149545907974,
0.24955710768699646,
0.6893446445465088,
-0.47372424602508545,
0.6658130288124084,
0.4616832435131073,
-0.5807556509971619,
-0.9739482998847961,
-0.17838206887245178,
0.034345779567956924,
-0.4474177360534668,
0.7723832130432129,
0.3199496269226074,
-0.20106643438339233,
0.22080297768115997,
-0.7948220372200012,
-0.7494426965713501,
0.7055501341819763,
0.428351491689682,
-0.9758608341217041,
-0.06447484344244003,
0.105768121778965,
0.4987407922744751,
-0.2241981476545334,
0.2828785479068756,
0.5282691717147827,
0.3739936947822571,
0.04634879156947136,
-1.3511441946029663,
-0.1497773826122284,
-0.5351588726043701,
0.48877787590026855,
0.061170365661382675,
-0.3468928933143616,
0.6191805601119995,
-0.3439256548881531,
-0.1460760533809662,
0.5332099795341492,
0.5796273350715637,
0.08171285688877106,
-0.029011866077780724,
0.28528568148612976,
0.5358308553695679,
0.516412079334259,
0.13901636004447937,
1.1519416570663452,
-0.4869458079338074,
0.23711815476417542,
1.0837383270263672,
-0.2611534297466278,
0.7932299375534058,
0.23758560419082642,
-0.041875116527080536,
0.5211374759674072,
0.3301263153553009,
-0.14800013601779938,
0.33785825967788696,
0.4837523102760315,
0.16756245493888855,
-0.1699114441871643,
0.0948709025979042,
-0.4116913676261902,
0.40695565938949585,
0.037928756326436996,
-0.3518773317337036,
-0.018147438764572144,
0.2761516571044922,
-0.22000737488269806,
0.20367278158664703,
-0.43194761872291565,
1.130789041519165,
-0.06984936445951462,
-0.8009815812110901,
0.8619886040687561,
0.07832176983356476,
0.9065138101577759,
-0.35588252544403076,
-0.11996299773454666,
-0.5217821598052979,
0.2559981048107147,
-0.3313346207141876,
-0.5484670996665955,
0.19885991513729095,
0.2859816253185272,
-0.3078080415725708,
-0.39323166012763977,
0.48181435465812683,
-0.37174493074417114,
-0.5775487422943115,
-0.05778608098626137,
0.4205096662044525,
-0.05550603196024895,
0.17525531351566315,
-0.4747552275657654,
0.33751556277275085,
0.10290825366973877,
-0.211039200425148,
0.11911111325025558,
0.3972930908203125,
0.04957357794046402,
0.7984272837638855,
0.8530599474906921,
0.01797073520720005,
0.11841471493244171,
0.40781038999557495,
0.909930408000946,
-0.4950227737426758,
-0.46011102199554443,
-0.6852889060974121,
0.6692590713500977,
-0.0014218880096450448,
-0.20732960104942322,
0.6749692559242249,
0.5605531334877014,
1.0891473293304443,
-0.5043023228645325,
1.0222378969192505,
0.047498393803834915,
0.46893513202667236,
-0.5556488037109375,
0.8410305380821228,
-0.5145784020423889,
0.31741389632225037,
-0.2718479037284851,
-0.936631977558136,
-0.3574853837490082,
0.6342973113059998,
0.03246970474720001,
0.13840104639530182,
0.15604549646377563,
0.982555091381073,
-0.16345812380313873,
-0.4427614212036133,
0.25824934244155884,
0.23749470710754395,
0.40988072752952576,
0.2463618814945221,
0.9878063201904297,
-0.03106672875583172,
0.3830187916755676,
-0.22657820582389832,
-0.4054573178291321,
-0.45189782977104187,
-0.7991717457771301,
-0.753216028213501,
-0.4987837076187134,
-0.45839178562164307,
-0.26147475838661194,
-0.2412332147359848,
1.0383546352386475,
1.0044747591018677,
-0.8535013198852539,
-0.5421581864356995,
-0.15608945488929749,
-0.22162677347660065,
0.05013413354754448,
-0.30717846751213074,
-0.23069517314434052,
-0.5952471494674683,
-0.744166910648346,
0.12297740578651428,
0.20978334546089172,
0.13696187734603882,
-0.5135342478752136,
-0.34077560901641846,
0.48784759640693665,
-0.045686203986406326,
0.788963258266449,
0.31122705340385437,
-0.8651131391525269,
-0.30516308546066284,
-0.26605844497680664,
-0.38049522042274475,
0.05007053166627884,
0.8884912729263306,
-0.841652512550354,
0.5424468517303467,
0.5395544171333313,
0.5434268116950989,
0.09481920301914215,
0.1897234320640564,
0.9924068450927734,
-0.6688293814659119,
-0.18165479600429535,
-0.018094755709171295,
0.27411890029907227,
0.4272425174713135,
-0.29054030776023865,
0.365108847618103,
-0.2620978355407715,
-0.7483978271484375,
-0.6061683893203735,
0.294761598110199,
-0.7113671898841858,
-0.2872057855129242,
1.2923548221588135,
0.04070282354950905,
-0.08686772733926773,
-0.0896494910120964,
-0.6376895308494568,
-0.06151814013719559,
-0.44860371947288513,
0.999714732170105,
0.3369189202785492,
-0.2801814377307892,
-0.2716285288333893,
-0.3511252999305725,
0.4809766113758087,
-0.0402531772851944,
-1.085349202156067,
0.20616212487220764,
1.2196625471115112,
0.39597734808921814,
0.11193106323480606,
0.5871757864952087,
-0.11761098355054855,
0.46548283100128174,
-0.17429989576339722,
0.43765243887901306,
-0.3113006055355072,
-0.4358298182487488,
-0.3215869665145874,
0.07039062678813934,
0.5005088448524475,
0.31548163294792175
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.07736v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.07736v1
|
MultiPragEval: Multilingual Pragmatic Evaluation of Large Language Models
| 2024-06-11T21:46:03 | 2024-06-11T21:46:03 |
Dojun Park, Jiwoo Lee, Seohyun Park, Hyeyun Jeong, Youngeun Koo, Soonha Hwang, Seonwoo Park, Sungeun Lee
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
As the capabilities of LLMs expand, it becomes increasingly important to
evaluate them beyond basic knowledge assessment, focusing on higher-level
language understanding. This study introduces MultiPragEval, a robust test
suite designed for the multilingual pragmatic evaluation of LLMs across
English, German, Korean, and Chinese. Comprising 1200 question units
categorized according to Grice's Cooperative Principle and its four
conversational maxims, MultiPragEval enables an in-depth assessment of LLMs'
contextual awareness and their ability to infer implied meanings. Our findings
demonstrate that Claude3-Opus significantly outperforms other models in all
tested languages, establishing a state-of-the-art in the field. Among
open-source models, Solar-10.7B and Qwen1.5-14B emerge as strong competitors.
This study not only leads the way in the multilingual evaluation of LLMs in
pragmatic inference but also provides valuable insights into the nuanced
capabilities necessary for advanced language comprehension in AI systems.
|
[
-0.4797615706920624,
-0.6727406978607178,
0.4661233127117157,
0.7460080981254578,
0.03234289586544037,
-0.00253179669380188,
-0.5742480754852295,
-0.3035607635974884,
-0.3459620475769043,
0.24329718947410583,
-0.31588780879974365,
-0.5051462054252625,
-0.4850670099258423,
0.15691785514354706,
0.027632156386971474,
0.6829752922058105,
-0.1862521916627884,
0.4837256371974945,
-0.3706623315811157,
-0.4566503167152405,
-0.17751950025558472,
-0.615657389163971,
-0.2936389446258545,
-0.5012098550796509,
0.41827648878097534,
0.41542497277259827,
0.5176159143447876,
0.015771856531500816,
0.5423533916473389,
0.31965598464012146,
-0.003616915550082922,
0.29460805654525757,
-0.1798219233751297,
0.169042706489563,
0.014317595399916172,
-0.4534814655780792,
-0.43622615933418274,
0.16076365113258362,
0.7600570321083069,
0.5096445679664612,
-0.06653806567192078,
0.09481347352266312,
0.03274192661046982,
0.424951434135437,
-0.6207881569862366,
0.30608999729156494,
-0.42582082748413086,
-0.17951832711696625,
0.15005579590797424,
0.0282762348651886,
-0.503676176071167,
-0.33731403946876526,
0.11688125133514404,
-0.46247977018356323,
-0.11080712080001831,
-0.09768025577068329,
0.885100245475769,
-0.09059629589319229,
-0.5473319292068481,
-0.17838561534881592,
-0.2790759801864624,
1.001775860786438,
-0.4281185567378998,
0.5051190853118896,
0.18865177035331726,
0.4361891448497772,
0.09026986360549927,
-0.7587057948112488,
-0.5929821133613586,
-0.7782136797904968,
-0.11660131067037582,
0.4135083258152008,
-0.09153349697589874,
0.18881747126579285,
-0.18645954132080078,
0.4338313341140747,
-0.7287653684616089,
0.13235655426979065,
-0.15164488554000854,
-0.3402022123336792,
0.6867087483406067,
-0.12649142742156982,
0.40208160877227783,
-0.17541846632957458,
-0.5710844993591309,
-0.23593264818191528,
-0.5339589715003967,
0.13014164566993713,
0.31884855031967163,
0.19101786613464355,
-0.12773051857948303,
0.38629716634750366,
0.06770971417427063,
0.9409895539283752,
-0.5372989177703857,
-0.39914998412132263,
0.24497804045677185,
-0.6584075093269348,
-0.16918954253196716,
-0.333407998085022,
0.6531267762184143,
0.3168620765209198,
0.49102601408958435,
0.08663202077150345,
-0.12581849098205566,
0.12321793287992477,
-0.1217876449227333,
-0.5648922324180603,
-0.007853100076317787,
0.2870546579360962,
-0.24593915045261383,
-0.02150530181825161,
0.17181755602359772,
-0.5572660565376282,
-0.3024482727050781,
-0.29519224166870117,
0.32147204875946045,
-0.5088959336280823,
-0.41180020570755005,
0.35475626587867737,
-0.12478728592395782,
0.5021282434463501,
0.4543699622154236,
-0.24076680839061737,
0.05874069780111313,
0.8402346968650818,
0.6476287245750427,
-0.34769171476364136,
-0.9496304988861084,
-0.5475419759750366,
-0.20900817215442657,
-0.21692390739917755,
0.8907526731491089,
-0.5743474960327148,
-0.3562828600406647,
0.009409049525856972,
0.23481608927249908,
-0.2176482081413269,
-0.4417339265346527,
0.5980857610702515,
-0.4878755211830139,
0.2557932734489441,
-0.12222244590520859,
-0.46469834446907043,
-0.44052883982658386,
0.761277437210083,
-0.48954230546951294,
0.8469980359077454,
-0.08565068989992142,
-0.5125067234039307,
0.274128794670105,
-0.5868501663208008,
-0.3711370825767517,
0.3280678987503052,
-0.2893441617488861,
-0.2643739581108093,
-0.07171183079481125,
0.20949587225914001,
0.42402830719947815,
-0.3903656601905823,
0.4376218616962433,
-0.34403491020202637,
-0.11992230266332626,
0.2291184812784195,
-0.6209145784378052,
0.7365506291389465,
0.0833701491355896,
-0.06186705455183983,
0.44074973464012146,
-0.6366940140724182,
0.1827061027288437,
0.12615007162094116,
-0.2507362365722656,
-0.4808940589427948,
-0.3577304780483246,
-0.15958504378795624,
0.21533748507499695,
0.32409021258354187,
-0.28827041387557983,
0.0307279322296381,
-0.24910491704940796,
0.36384662985801697,
0.6387002468109131,
0.20724578201770782,
0.365259051322937,
-0.21736299991607666,
0.9246883988380432,
-0.084653839468956,
0.18868927657604218,
-0.45507922768592834,
-0.5598662495613098,
-0.638489305973053,
-0.5837028622627258,
0.15971523523330688,
0.7418861389160156,
-0.6068519353866577,
0.20148800313472748,
-0.038269683718681335,
-0.6758927702903748,
-0.48541584610939026,
0.1455337405204773,
0.5004283785820007,
0.3150565028190613,
0.22834719717502594,
-0.07967425137758255,
-0.14940917491912842,
-1.0954785346984863,
-0.37420138716697693,
-0.20208702981472015,
0.09730935841798782,
0.49841246008872986,
0.6289295554161072,
-0.10708039999008179,
0.5372670292854309,
-0.21229681372642517,
0.08961798995733261,
-0.5592750310897827,
0.11968270689249039,
0.14611048996448517,
0.2510955333709717,
0.4325793981552124,
-0.863224983215332,
-0.41056832671165466,
0.19187848269939423,
-0.5707551836967468,
-0.1981022208929062,
-0.042496513575315475,
-0.0756363645195961,
-0.10977069288492203,
0.09457552433013916,
-0.5124297738075256,
-0.09622902423143387,
0.9230666756629944,
-0.25797224044799805,
0.8127066493034363,
-0.33037182688713074,
0.3779124915599823,
-0.9390823245048523,
0.03881850838661194,
0.2674283981323242,
-0.1766137182712555,
-0.5372889041900635,
0.4211876392364502,
0.37931331992149353,
-0.06056629493832588,
-0.778529167175293,
0.7179745435714722,
-0.63275545835495,
-0.37651968002319336,
-0.0001169171227957122,
0.7088118195533752,
0.574159562587738,
0.18702872097492218,
-0.06581906974315643,
1.1668705940246582,
0.543582022190094,
-0.8140342831611633,
0.6096797585487366,
0.24399857223033905,
-0.6825261116027832,
0.7077430486679077,
-0.6458172798156738,
-0.019837358966469765,
-0.1003875732421875,
0.13457460701465607,
-1.1161837577819824,
-0.1334226280450821,
-0.20936107635498047,
-0.5049424171447754,
-0.023480670526623726,
-0.11391807347536087,
-0.46882712841033936,
-0.20765458047389984,
-0.16341151297092438,
0.29612600803375244,
0.061765238642692566,
-0.45572230219841003,
0.5113812685012817,
0.30341511964797974,
-0.2677716016769409,
-0.7077106833457947,
-0.6300343871116638,
0.008574786596000195,
-0.334107905626297,
-1.0174862146377563,
0.06264554709196091,
-0.029362814500927925,
-0.7443963885307312,
-0.31571486592292786,
0.2589645981788635,
-0.18329854309558868,
0.2933557629585266,
-0.18652069568634033,
0.3391525149345398,
-0.14810195565223694,
0.2980445921421051,
-0.07206573337316513,
-0.12994380295276642,
-0.1425398588180542,
-0.3617154359817505,
0.5510445833206177,
-0.7418747544288635,
-0.8201851844787598,
-0.13152004778385162,
0.1102227196097374,
0.6669756174087524,
-0.8225597739219666,
0.5568820834159851,
0.7744195461273193,
-0.19295553863048553,
-0.24112924933433533,
-0.45047080516815186,
-0.16423697769641876,
-0.4108664095401764,
0.6291918754577637,
-0.584953784942627,
-1.0414241552352905,
0.6245042085647583,
-0.1917133927345276,
0.03129867836833,
0.40585699677467346,
0.7828069925308228,
0.32028400897979736,
0.8452882170677185,
0.34778186678886414,
0.10295790433883667,
0.10835101455450058,
-0.06742623448371887,
0.11412210762500763,
-0.6314788460731506,
-0.2629033625125885,
-0.5833656787872314,
0.04059957340359688,
-0.5107853412628174,
-0.6245878338813782,
0.6320412755012512,
0.10046616196632385,
-0.15676340460777283,
0.17908483743667603,
-0.209145650267601,
0.4221430718898773,
0.40316087007522583,
-0.24429458379745483,
0.5138964653015137,
-0.15319499373435974,
-0.32905706763267517,
-0.1866525411605835,
-0.6136123538017273,
-0.7140718698501587,
0.7166699171066284,
0.45737871527671814,
0.6113960146903992,
0.3644079864025116,
0.33941835165023804,
0.07598353177309036,
0.47269243001937866,
-0.9160826802253723,
0.5324400663375854,
0.08962199836969376,
-0.6348314881324768,
-0.25697028636932373,
-0.23513442277908325,
-0.8580049872398376,
0.8875668048858643,
0.20726998150348663,
-0.5052613615989685,
-0.057648852467536926,
-0.17791643738746643,
-0.3544098138809204,
0.007818235084414482,
-0.9635432958602905,
1.0651592016220093,
-0.6316444873809814,
-0.4338545501232147,
-0.24011316895484924,
-0.36341309547424316,
0.6744862794876099,
0.026135016232728958,
0.32779282331466675,
-0.2430807650089264,
-0.14389102160930634,
0.39952191710472107,
0.019443804398179054,
0.5985218286514282,
-0.11274339258670807,
-0.335648775100708,
0.35192325711250305,
0.10880979895591736,
0.3522306978702545,
0.4370978772640228,
-0.2579210102558136,
0.17408250272274017,
0.027795786038041115,
-0.35375893115997314,
-0.5904499292373657,
0.7651329040527344,
-0.7341105341911316,
-0.5791147351264954,
-0.35612621903419495,
-0.5529890656471252,
-0.3625815808773041,
0.25713294744491577,
-0.07449258863925934,
0.31083667278289795,
-0.3406168520450592,
0.2143973410129547,
0.571702241897583,
-0.6308246850967407,
0.3519393801689148,
0.7237729430198669,
-0.3188030421733856,
-0.5920936465263367,
0.8088400363922119,
-0.18162745237350464,
0.5188422203063965,
0.3152817487716675,
0.36269694566726685,
-0.5628800392150879,
-0.34801918268203735,
-0.5756955146789551,
0.25357428193092346,
-0.962384819984436,
0.037173639982938766,
-0.5423843264579773,
0.17649215459823608,
-0.269840270280838,
-0.04144855961203575,
-0.3609044849872589,
-0.15789778530597687,
0.013245047070086002,
-0.23379230499267578,
0.16136738657951355,
0.5595069527626038,
0.09946796298027039,
0.06113124638795853,
-0.9760458469390869,
0.007986587472259998,
0.2676801085472107,
0.25195127725601196,
-0.2695259749889374,
-0.5182126760482788,
-0.009427235461771488,
-0.10377387702465057,
-0.23792198300361633,
-0.9646155834197998,
0.3476896584033966,
0.19831058382987976,
1.005240559577942,
0.22271263599395752,
-0.004632111173123121,
0.5801971554756165,
-0.262818843126297,
1.0170345306396484,
0.03469165414571762,
-1.123334527015686,
0.29622069001197815,
-0.28203773498535156,
0.15873949229717255,
0.6558310985565186,
0.3186463713645935,
-0.6545459628105164,
-0.08876711130142212,
-0.48087820410728455,
-0.6802908182144165,
0.34412920475006104,
-0.06660885363817215,
-0.038390375673770905,
0.09705089777708054,
0.11922994256019592,
0.0666293278336525,
0.4244612455368042,
-0.8730447888374329,
-0.1873018741607666,
-0.03648785129189491,
0.0055231316946446896,
-0.3587590456008911,
-0.1753387749195099,
-0.3217298686504364,
-0.07843832671642303,
0.3800932466983795,
-0.24488376080989838,
0.21195828914642334,
0.31678274273872375,
-0.3224327564239502,
0.34482845664024353,
0.5509824156761169,
1.0226142406463623,
0.9602345824241638,
0.13749052584171295,
0.23266515135765076,
0.3015900254249573,
-0.15887127816677094,
0.3397086560726166,
0.14198769629001617,
0.19618888199329376,
-0.06974910944700241,
0.6838098764419556,
0.7803225517272949,
0.06897920370101929,
-0.7736968994140625,
0.8072088956832886,
-0.03963698819279671,
-0.20142856240272522,
-0.32569563388824463,
-0.25976940989494324,
0.09809493273496628,
0.1621141880750656,
0.1073337197303772,
-0.18284915387630463,
-0.13680438697338104,
-0.36405983567237854,
0.5046199560165405,
0.47445881366729736,
-0.3091931939125061,
-0.2853497266769409,
0.13671272993087769,
0.258064329624176,
-0.0715448409318924,
0.28979891538619995,
-0.5543726682662964,
-0.7849482893943787,
0.5545376539230347,
0.38058221340179443,
0.6765957474708557,
-0.2938626706600189,
0.1778770238161087,
0.2378097027540207,
0.6320293545722961,
-0.023458309471607208,
0.410936564207077,
0.07136959582567215,
-0.9518024325370789,
-0.7990157604217529,
-0.44437626004219055,
-0.6441102027893066,
0.13378171622753143,
-0.5896198749542236,
0.24232706427574158,
-0.1378897726535797,
0.039154186844825745,
-0.5104444622993469,
0.09625241905450821,
-0.4962555468082428,
-0.016370045021176338,
-0.014915995299816132,
1.126557469367981,
-0.8091697692871094,
0.8027610182762146,
1.0173054933547974,
-0.2926037013530731,
-0.6760194897651672,
0.027939848601818085,
-0.09960483014583588,
-1.162387728691101,
0.6963767409324646,
0.3046855330467224,
-0.27370649576187134,
-0.02081516943871975,
-0.3381615877151489,
-0.5331732034683228,
1.1103479862213135,
0.37253472208976746,
-0.32639214396476746,
0.3980204463005066,
-0.16612355411052704,
0.4871547818183899,
-0.3472996950149536,
0.4577346742153168,
0.5888970494270325,
0.9263930916786194,
-0.13889433443546295,
-1.0559146404266357,
-0.4307098090648651,
-0.21695773303508759,
-0.24427147209644318,
-0.055155958980321884,
-0.845856785774231,
0.8170002102851868,
-0.1520519256591797,
-0.07694099098443985,
-0.2528691291809082,
0.5981394648551941,
0.7211686372756958,
0.3820432722568512,
0.5235123038291931,
0.31902921199798584,
0.8334822654724121,
-0.21975253522396088,
1.2204265594482422,
-0.7220196723937988,
0.3749004900455475,
0.9282374978065491,
-0.5143888592720032,
0.678229808807373,
0.2933712899684906,
-0.2787095904350281,
0.39598241448402405,
0.6313354969024658,
0.06522335857152939,
0.17781764268875122,
0.29417645931243896,
-0.3696947395801544,
-0.41623494029045105,
-0.22424474358558655,
-0.2759355902671814,
0.5802819728851318,
0.44554924964904785,
0.01022194791585207,
-0.22219695150852203,
0.11590035259723663,
0.14238980412483215,
0.24210456013679504,
-0.18373948335647583,
0.5525674223899841,
0.1093963086605072,
-1.0298670530319214,
0.4872545003890991,
0.29150936007499695,
0.6289642453193665,
-0.8464621305465698,
0.13419771194458008,
-0.2662962079048157,
0.38509121537208557,
0.07236263900995255,
-0.816094160079956,
0.04046635329723358,
-0.11712603271007538,
0.37858515977859497,
-0.2662193477153778,
0.7760822772979736,
-0.5042973160743713,
-0.48029932379722595,
0.6147276759147644,
0.8527688384056091,
0.06305921822786331,
-0.24911034107208252,
-0.9985136985778809,
0.1973203867673874,
-0.03583136945962906,
-0.3628457486629486,
0.2486979365348816,
0.4238775372505188,
-0.04194273054599762,
0.8896641135215759,
0.4741002321243286,
0.15570612251758575,
0.010125900618731976,
0.4324128329753876,
0.572028636932373,
-0.35812532901763916,
-0.46209952235221863,
-0.867997944355011,
0.5508784055709839,
0.07684850692749023,
-0.29666900634765625,
1.1603494882583618,
0.33348265290260315,
0.8537030816078186,
0.06752800196409225,
1.0511980056762695,
0.3408638834953308,
0.27032509446144104,
-0.33396923542022705,
0.4316798448562622,
-0.6322580575942993,
0.14303798973560333,
-0.3010193109512329,
-0.7270973324775696,
-0.47525593638420105,
0.751519501209259,
-0.6047503352165222,
0.23531155288219452,
0.6794464588165283,
0.6781901121139526,
0.12728916108608246,
0.0032970779575407505,
0.5909194350242615,
-0.13797122240066528,
0.4847228527069092,
0.5353397727012634,
1.1638731956481934,
-0.20619237422943115,
0.47173094749450684,
-0.04801982641220093,
-0.48193371295928955,
0.01999208889901638,
-0.9986866116523743,
-0.8040412068367004,
-0.5264201760292053,
-0.10957252979278564,
-0.4054988622665405,
-0.18534140288829803,
0.8945050239562988,
0.5150251388549805,
-0.6782836318016052,
-0.42579615116119385,
-0.023025590926408768,
0.21569904685020447,
-0.2746524512767792,
-0.23852747678756714,
0.2526717483997345,
-0.5325008630752563,
-0.8271974325180054,
0.6978921890258789,
0.4900025427341461,
0.015851233154535294,
-0.7715333700180054,
-0.4731241762638092,
-0.24658574163913727,
-0.019527332857251167,
0.6518473029136658,
-0.09664996713399887,
-0.7347575426101685,
-0.03322581574320793,
0.2491428256034851,
-0.10169179737567902,
-0.10922309756278992,
0.8584781885147095,
-0.3376123607158661,
0.4947126507759094,
0.6177656054496765,
0.6702468991279602,
-0.012170801870524883,
0.21785639226436615,
0.6900497078895569,
-0.6529840230941772,
0.4375331401824951,
0.3467722237110138,
0.618617057800293,
0.4668215811252594,
-0.032269030809402466,
0.28537070751190186,
0.31303513050079346,
-0.5468224883079529,
-0.7805088758468628,
0.5309597253799438,
-0.588487982749939,
-0.2855316996574402,
1.522032618522644,
-0.5613260269165039,
-0.01172858476638794,
-0.1422431915998459,
-0.10966424643993378,
-0.029076529666781425,
-0.12196801602840424,
0.17251016199588776,
1.0067641735076904,
-0.038162000477313995,
-0.3889580965042114,
-0.7409554123878479,
0.15383723378181458,
0.6804318428039551,
-0.8375054001808167,
0.04605775699019432,
0.4813728332519531,
0.062284376472234726,
0.22064213454723358,
0.506454586982727,
-0.1740318238735199,
0.14185795187950134,
-0.17213329672813416,
0.18762518465518951,
-0.1297045201063156,
-0.4016747772693634,
-0.6380133628845215,
0.39809197187423706,
0.43439817428588867,
-0.19818705320358276
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.07735v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.07735v1
|
REAL Sampling: Boosting Factuality and Diversity of Open-Ended Generation via Asymptotic Entropy
| 2024-06-11T21:44:49 | 2024-06-11T21:44:49 |
Haw-Shiuan Chang, Nanyun Peng, Mohit Bansal, Anil Ramakrishna, Tagyoung Chung
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Decoding methods for large language models (LLMs) usually struggle with the
tradeoff between ensuring factuality and maintaining diversity. For example, a
higher p threshold in the nucleus (top-p) sampling increases the diversity but
decreases the factuality, and vice versa. In this paper, we propose REAL
(Residual Entropy from Asymptotic Line) sampling, a decoding method that
achieves improved factuality and diversity over nucleus sampling by predicting
an adaptive threshold of $p$. Specifically, REAL sampling predicts the
step-wise likelihood of an LLM to hallucinate, and lowers the p threshold when
an LLM is likely to hallucinate. Otherwise, REAL sampling increases the p
threshold to boost the diversity. To predict the step-wise hallucination
likelihood without supervision, we construct a Token-level Hallucination
Forecasting (THF) model to predict the asymptotic entropy (i.e., inherent
uncertainty) of the next token by extrapolating the next-token entropies from a
series of LLMs with different sizes. If a LLM's entropy is higher than the
asymptotic entropy (i.e., the LLM is more uncertain than it should be), the THF
model predicts a high hallucination hazard, which leads to a lower p threshold
in REAL sampling. In the FactualityPrompts benchmark, we demonstrate that REAL
sampling based on a 70M THF model can substantially improve the factuality and
diversity of 7B LLMs simultaneously, judged by both retrieval-based metrics and
human evaluation. After combined with contrastive decoding, REAL sampling
outperforms 9 sampling methods, and generates texts that are more factual than
the greedy sampling and more diverse than the nucleus sampling with $p=0.5$.
Furthermore, the predicted asymptotic entropy is also a useful unsupervised
signal for hallucination detection tasks.
|
[
-0.45691874623298645,
-0.5537106394767761,
0.39736565947532654,
0.1909482330083847,
-0.3381621539592743,
0.16611216962337494,
-0.43141108751296997,
-0.7190869450569153,
0.33027130365371704,
0.5138466954231262,
-0.6796200275421143,
-0.4786604344844818,
-0.37201234698295593,
0.07878047227859497,
-0.3497510254383087,
0.6817006468772888,
0.4404484033584595,
0.21557483077049255,
-0.12619459629058838,
0.19182144105434418,
-0.3241306245326996,
-0.48682060837745667,
-0.32207366824150085,
-0.14705000817775726,
0.3166621923446655,
0.4122582972049713,
0.551634669303894,
0.6682059168815613,
0.139666348695755,
0.17499063909053802,
-0.2313152253627777,
0.22722546756267548,
-0.6793482899665833,
0.38152453303337097,
-0.04287485405802727,
-0.7436037659645081,
-0.08531087636947632,
0.14030423760414124,
0.5994107127189636,
0.6572676301002502,
-0.1982472836971283,
0.11673848330974579,
-0.050554513931274414,
0.4072011411190033,
-0.8029870986938477,
-0.18522322177886963,
-0.7009244561195374,
0.2396395355463028,
0.17218466103076935,
-0.6164251565933228,
-0.5896541476249695,
-0.5360878109931946,
-0.07786890864372253,
-0.37881121039390564,
0.42430534958839417,
0.20034809410572052,
0.7555668950080872,
0.18281778693199158,
-0.02570502832531929,
-0.3746885657310486,
-0.9953189492225647,
0.9098271727561951,
-0.6839026212692261,
0.5307990312576294,
0.5791465640068054,
0.3448898494243622,
-0.024510731920599937,
-0.66530442237854,
-0.7549713850021362,
-0.4639118015766144,
0.3641006350517273,
0.3036520183086395,
0.10660935193300247,
-0.20800846815109253,
0.14064978063106537,
0.5112046599388123,
-0.4152557849884033,
0.12717725336551666,
-0.5741535425186157,
-0.34680604934692383,
0.3902713656425476,
0.17264164984226227,
0.4095456004142761,
-0.04391331598162651,
-0.23402808606624603,
-0.42770707607269287,
-0.6059482097625732,
-0.17456109821796417,
0.5574994683265686,
0.3735297620296478,
-0.1553836166858673,
0.5112760066986084,
-0.22185370326042175,
0.7151782512664795,
-0.13084504008293152,
-0.18603013455867767,
0.2466035932302475,
-0.4627925753593445,
-0.11416929960250854,
0.25409260392189026,
0.4463009238243103,
0.33983978629112244,
0.18366247415542603,
-0.17861875891685486,
-0.10114836692810059,
-0.2567801773548126,
0.266985148191452,
-0.9758222103118896,
-0.39615899324417114,
0.346797376871109,
-0.5429136157035828,
-0.4581277668476105,
0.33100032806396484,
-1.2163760662078857,
-0.3492218255996704,
-0.3612141013145447,
0.07255853712558746,
-0.5392197966575623,
-0.2928910255432129,
0.29804161190986633,
-0.294535368680954,
-0.02477331832051277,
0.2782604694366455,
-0.6272890567779541,
0.2080751359462738,
0.5020827054977417,
1.0054266452789307,
-0.06378749758005142,
-0.31207236647605896,
-0.6737271547317505,
-0.191924050450325,
-0.2931622564792633,
0.9160098433494568,
-0.4929027259349823,
-0.19797174632549286,
0.0569668784737587,
-0.3672090172767639,
0.11101742833852768,
-0.8018752932548523,
0.5933692455291748,
-0.5977311730384827,
0.30070027709007263,
-0.4507814049720764,
-0.37360987067222595,
-0.12367216497659683,
0.30445873737335205,
-0.8105559349060059,
0.7709193825721741,
0.03879434987902641,
-0.756702184677124,
0.6451838612556458,
-0.1529337465763092,
-0.1472187489271164,
0.08625040203332901,
-0.23072177171707153,
-0.3084641098976135,
0.08884520083665848,
0.12663845717906952,
0.1678466647863388,
-0.265834778547287,
0.32797253131866455,
-0.34295454621315,
-0.5552759170532227,
0.4323171079158783,
-0.6357612609863281,
0.9888107776641846,
0.4325094521045685,
-0.36993181705474854,
0.16134482622146606,
-0.9125100374221802,
-0.16411055624485016,
-0.13333351910114288,
-0.5022720694541931,
-0.1511567234992981,
-0.012384260073304176,
0.09029217809438705,
0.19766865670681,
-0.2801160514354706,
-0.6245386004447937,
0.0757678896188736,
-0.583253026008606,
0.04397745802998543,
0.6833669543266296,
0.04024837538599968,
0.3128770589828491,
-0.5850517153739929,
0.6241198778152466,
0.05182822421193123,
-0.26125288009643555,
0.09661456197500229,
-0.5777864456176758,
-0.37062767148017883,
-0.8298055529594421,
0.5472719669342041,
0.7052266597747803,
-0.6275665163993835,
1.0872997045516968,
-0.4429534077644348,
-0.3926432132720947,
-0.6574515700340271,
-0.23574864864349365,
0.16764697432518005,
0.4476414918899536,
0.43103623390197754,
-0.03192432224750519,
-0.7590742707252502,
-0.23693393170833588,
-0.24905602633953094,
-0.22403252124786377,
-0.4031670093536377,
0.05054518207907677,
0.4703080952167511,
-0.26770490407943726,
0.9507216215133667,
-0.5459241271018982,
-0.1567779779434204,
-0.3194431960582733,
0.3463231027126312,
0.18669520318508148,
0.4411764442920685,
0.16060127317905426,
-0.6783408522605896,
-0.10973669588565826,
-0.45998600125312805,
-0.7350133657455444,
-0.1043638065457344,
-0.23762698471546173,
-0.19633185863494873,
0.10215827822685242,
0.44655877351760864,
-0.5876363515853882,
0.2976840138435364,
0.3546946942806244,
-0.5972853302955627,
0.8641288876533508,
-0.14264340698719025,
0.0751943588256836,
-1.0082488059997559,
-0.04989882931113243,
-0.23215146362781525,
-0.11957040429115295,
-0.5018205046653748,
0.2191428393125534,
-0.11260175704956055,
0.020304713398218155,
-0.2619575560092926,
0.5136868357658386,
-0.48478782176971436,
-0.11927774548530579,
-0.35482022166252136,
-0.13930873572826385,
-0.136554554104805,
0.0503462590277195,
0.23384208977222443,
0.4881787598133087,
0.46518322825431824,
-0.6944511532783508,
0.5019861459732056,
-0.01366879791021347,
-0.583402693271637,
0.13455377519130707,
-0.10937938839197159,
-0.2947358787059784,
-0.35817623138427734,
0.4500257968902588,
-0.8641648888587952,
-0.29624366760253906,
0.38157838582992554,
-0.6427408456802368,
0.18963614106178284,
0.2543722093105316,
-0.3966999053955078,
-0.2654084861278534,
-0.568221926689148,
0.619570791721344,
0.7918063998222351,
-0.779502272605896,
0.3447656035423279,
0.056698836386203766,
0.1531568169593811,
-0.7032718062400818,
-0.7765834927558899,
0.2320576310157776,
-0.1323889195919037,
-0.6143635511398315,
0.21943435072898865,
-0.18553802371025085,
-0.41030076146125793,
0.13862751424312592,
-0.14812438189983368,
0.3209526836872101,
-0.036960188299417496,
0.02923324890434742,
0.27792173624038696,
-0.15704670548439026,
0.0723607987165451,
-0.13224156200885773,
0.024094941094517708,
-0.01394734252244234,
-0.6871690154075623,
0.9085972309112549,
0.23464541137218475,
-0.2844354510307312,
-0.2294335961341858,
0.03733861818909645,
0.28140372037887573,
0.05066419020295143,
0.9348077774047852,
0.7662127614021301,
-0.7052680850028992,
-0.46150195598602295,
-0.5056598782539368,
-0.610947847366333,
-0.37738481163978577,
0.20852893590927124,
-0.4167303144931793,
-0.848032534122467,
0.6220449805259705,
0.335980623960495,
0.05900809168815613,
0.20378710329532623,
0.947745680809021,
0.09948758780956268,
0.5091525316238403,
0.3994637131690979,
0.14603856205940247,
0.24848513305187225,
-0.24963165819644928,
0.4275117814540863,
-0.5252686142921448,
-0.4216943681240082,
-0.5043632388114929,
-0.315078467130661,
-0.4346960186958313,
-0.7978071570396423,
0.18301989138126373,
0.073011614382267,
0.21211333572864532,
-0.04721177741885185,
-0.5843802094459534,
0.3607351779937744,
0.8411023020744324,
0.2599106729030609,
0.41416555643081665,
0.35083144903182983,
0.024567939341068268,
-0.03759375959634781,
-0.6487362384796143,
-0.3349430561065674,
1.2046359777450562,
0.3107338547706604,
0.7749399542808533,
-0.16592223942279816,
0.909611165523529,
0.43828245997428894,
0.25605374574661255,
-0.8679332733154297,
0.4619089663028717,
0.224861741065979,
-0.6018849611282349,
-0.5390707850456238,
-0.7373611927032471,
-0.7614302039146423,
0.3758355677127838,
-0.3536573648452759,
-0.6505680680274963,
0.5770626664161682,
0.18015603721141815,
-0.5733914375305176,
0.5784146785736084,
-0.1565045565366745,
0.35847437381744385,
0.17568714916706085,
-0.2437969148159027,
-0.2115734964609146,
-0.5286610722541809,
0.7649292945861816,
-0.06582080572843552,
0.3150707185268402,
-0.060763828456401825,
0.0864870473742485,
0.806011438369751,
-0.2482932060956955,
0.714681088924408,
-0.21402610838413239,
-0.1049807071685791,
0.4935556650161743,
-0.011353306472301483,
0.3754534423351288,
0.2391698658466339,
-0.3409644663333893,
-0.20063160359859467,
-0.09531071037054062,
-0.5230034589767456,
-0.30086982250213623,
0.6488287448883057,
-0.763609766960144,
-0.34451308846473694,
-0.5241350531578064,
-0.6439300775527954,
-0.14319835603237152,
-0.11370465159416199,
0.9719226360321045,
0.40274885296821594,
-0.15443307161331177,
0.3325536251068115,
0.9472360610961914,
-0.3558862507343292,
0.2633948028087616,
0.02635025605559349,
0.010143869556486607,
-0.4567822515964508,
1.1825023889541626,
0.21196597814559937,
0.25843319296836853,
0.4294646680355072,
0.2477821558713913,
-0.3516777455806732,
-0.5192117691040039,
-0.42979082465171814,
0.16016225516796112,
-0.7434279918670654,
-0.26716822385787964,
-0.9974544644355774,
-0.15878254175186157,
-0.7443194389343262,
-0.16230428218841553,
-0.1373278647661209,
-0.43662214279174805,
-0.32125917077064514,
-0.478876531124115,
0.12588602304458618,
0.21668356657028198,
-0.36680924892425537,
0.11188486218452454,
-0.726839542388916,
0.651787281036377,
0.28402048349380493,
0.1793261021375656,
0.004602127242833376,
-0.8644192814826965,
-0.1418807953596115,
0.15562009811401367,
0.03916477411985397,
-0.9948409795761108,
0.619081974029541,
-0.04249412566423416,
0.5327731966972351,
0.3769129812717438,
0.38694554567337036,
0.5244655013084412,
-0.030791081488132477,
0.7684585452079773,
0.2450745850801468,
-0.6309941411018372,
-0.05828214809298515,
-0.009858843870460987,
0.2399827092885971,
0.6459164023399353,
0.2926817536354065,
-0.40504467487335205,
-0.585154116153717,
-0.5987411141395569,
-0.8803450465202332,
0.7443047761917114,
0.23373600840568542,
0.0614851750433445,
0.06879635900259018,
0.030910523608326912,
0.193585604429245,
0.21131357550621033,
-0.8481305241584778,
0.12066558748483658,
-0.5786558985710144,
-0.42626842856407166,
0.07605111598968506,
-0.385506808757782,
-0.15314608812332153,
-0.31106331944465637,
0.6604456901550293,
0.06935995817184448,
0.5011623501777649,
0.31183260679244995,
-0.12472627311944962,
-0.38072243332862854,
0.25964492559432983,
0.6850910782814026,
0.6364090442657471,
-0.6294921040534973,
0.5296801924705505,
0.15487629175186157,
-0.6689872741699219,
0.11849220097064972,
-0.14159207046031952,
-0.3767412602901459,
0.065468430519104,
0.5455136299133301,
0.8355526924133301,
-0.3227056562900543,
-1.0564498901367188,
0.22124585509300232,
-0.058004721999168396,
-0.30305957794189453,
-0.3683730959892273,
0.0401839055120945,
0.08203021436929703,
0.0746198296546936,
0.5462849140167236,
-0.013898398727178574,
0.20952516794204712,
-0.9614811539649963,
0.41773492097854614,
0.25686782598495483,
-0.3832932710647583,
-0.29961979389190674,
0.6627007722854614,
-0.04192506521940231,
-0.18614494800567627,
0.7969239354133606,
-0.5423108339309692,
-0.37152761220932007,
0.7990016937255859,
0.8658254742622375,
0.9903028607368469,
-0.11606465280056,
0.08289910107851028,
0.6803258657455444,
0.41972166299819946,
-0.32738664746284485,
0.4676281213760376,
-0.06302245706319809,
-0.8962995409965515,
-0.3274361193180084,
-1.113344669342041,
-0.12115415930747986,
0.297687292098999,
-0.5901421308517456,
0.1398797184228897,
-0.45899131894111633,
0.04819733276963234,
-0.4277106821537018,
-0.20840667188167572,
-0.1992761790752411,
0.6249597668647766,
0.2629857659339905,
0.9462438225746155,
-0.9619723558425903,
0.7218444347381592,
0.3021489381790161,
-0.25241485238075256,
-0.4636073112487793,
0.5776349306106567,
-0.04702640324831009,
-0.7074503898620605,
0.4174606204032898,
0.17240123450756073,
-0.14444443583488464,
0.046946972608566284,
-0.6346392631530762,
-0.7278451323509216,
0.9760125875473022,
0.20552973449230194,
-0.4300276041030884,
-0.16498160362243652,
-0.11804667115211487,
0.4089183211326599,
-0.39442652463912964,
-0.0225644763559103,
0.5848818421363831,
0.5032351613044739,
0.45697134733200073,
-0.189571812748909,
0.3966345191001892,
-0.2433227002620697,
-0.17720122635364532,
-0.04008045420050621,
-0.037261221557855606,
0.8226358890533447,
-0.2766762971878052,
-0.3072878420352936,
0.15238884091377258,
1.009156584739685,
0.8377071022987366,
0.3797556459903717,
0.6404308080673218,
0.5572798848152161,
0.9096692800521851,
0.07997258752584457,
0.8954441547393799,
-0.4791731834411621,
0.03783154860138893,
0.9027957320213318,
-0.07304553687572479,
0.7031263113021851,
0.4409010410308838,
-0.021635999903082848,
0.2769680619239807,
0.6640153527259827,
-0.1871168166399002,
0.49152979254722595,
0.5427055358886719,
-0.44903403520584106,
-0.3307068943977356,
0.03047574684023857,
-0.4210285544395447,
0.0242186039686203,
0.4070073664188385,
-0.11048214882612228,
-0.133957177400589,
0.19506533443927765,
0.02512480691075325,
0.2793632447719574,
-0.13708990812301636,
0.5602127909660339,
0.048624198883771896,
-0.8172445297241211,
0.9067488312721252,
0.1795150637626648,
0.9526443481445312,
-0.2348441332578659,
0.07960572838783264,
-0.20328986644744873,
-0.12786978483200073,
-0.30203956365585327,
-0.6503435969352722,
0.30693337321281433,
-0.10492602735757828,
-0.1442888230085373,
-0.07868321239948273,
0.7498667240142822,
-0.5754820108413696,
-0.5829111337661743,
0.2605275511741638,
0.3445098102092743,
0.1652984619140625,
-0.16380575299263,
-0.14124795794487,
0.01558634452521801,
0.18107996881008148,
-0.33354026079177856,
0.21452903747558594,
0.27562612295150757,
0.017046254128217697,
0.6232326030731201,
0.7479780912399292,
0.5272749662399292,
0.4205018877983093,
0.06529641151428223,
0.5927895307540894,
-0.8363358974456787,
-0.633097231388092,
-0.8577877283096313,
0.3289084732532501,
-0.12325574457645416,
-0.040836967527866364,
0.46341225504875183,
0.6232362389564514,
0.8271651864051819,
-0.33740007877349854,
0.8758905529975891,
-0.0526634156703949,
0.511333167552948,
-0.6465616226196289,
0.5526631474494934,
-0.41672441363334656,
0.2607094943523407,
0.15646815299987793,
-1.04999840259552,
-0.2907756268978119,
0.44947293400764465,
-0.07524797320365906,
-0.0945243388414383,
0.5481109023094177,
0.8777403831481934,
-0.2111167162656784,
0.11989475786685944,
0.40556564927101135,
0.13845194876194,
0.16836640238761902,
0.1450856626033783,
0.9802622199058533,
0.014330620877444744,
0.5930862426757812,
-0.2525053322315216,
-0.45273563265800476,
-0.41198429465293884,
-0.46173232793807983,
-0.670928418636322,
-0.43793249130249023,
-0.06214223802089691,
-0.6281283497810364,
0.018658144399523735,
1.1352876424789429,
0.5279459953308105,
-0.9284496903419495,
-0.4179980158805847,
-0.24036256968975067,
0.026617377996444702,
-0.40612122416496277,
-0.27167174220085144,
0.16001279652118683,
-0.5053704977035522,
-0.7842804789543152,
0.4023289382457733,
0.23402734100818634,
0.008970151655375957,
-0.18315471708774567,
-0.13693460822105408,
-0.16670212149620056,
0.36955755949020386,
0.529028058052063,
0.24948816001415253,
-0.578219473361969,
-0.10082931071519852,
0.08949457108974457,
-0.16351021826267242,
0.039459146559238434,
0.758081316947937,
-0.7387732267379761,
0.40824052691459656,
1.0188058614730835,
0.611827552318573,
0.49374616146087646,
0.24025404453277588,
0.6437540054321289,
-0.542706310749054,
0.27031996846199036,
0.6268562078475952,
0.14812903106212616,
0.20377930998802185,
-0.4021504819393158,
0.2993086874485016,
0.6603312492370605,
-0.22023873031139374,
-1.3000245094299316,
0.34309282898902893,
-0.9024509787559509,
-0.7618310451507568,
1.2315810918807983,
0.1455334573984146,
-0.1976316124200821,
-0.35669517517089844,
-0.12723186612129211,
0.6050299406051636,
-0.27898338437080383,
1.2248204946517944,
0.5668627023696899,
0.14898991584777832,
-0.0466659851372242,
-0.4905039966106415,
0.6531325578689575,
0.4372299313545227,
-0.7794477939605713,
0.24378246068954468,
0.5724767446517944,
0.01119896862655878,
0.2314670830965042,
0.752305269241333,
-0.043561387807130814,
0.34928709268569946,
0.1898420751094818,
0.12823529541492462,
0.023134641349315643,
-0.5697599649429321,
-0.34359827637672424,
0.4277612566947937,
0.08626721054315567,
-0.03634437173604965
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10275v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10275v1
|
ExHuBERT: Enhancing HuBERT Through Block Extension and Fine-Tuning on 37 Emotion Datasets
| 2024-06-11T21:30:15 | 2024-06-11T21:30:15 |
Shahin Amiriparian, Filip Packań, Maurice Gerczuk, Björn W. Schuller
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, 68T10, I.2
|
Foundation models have shown great promise in speech emotion recognition
(SER) by leveraging their pre-trained representations to capture emotion
patterns in speech signals. To further enhance SER performance across various
languages and domains, we propose a novel twofold approach. First, we gather
EmoSet++, a comprehensive multi-lingual, multi-cultural speech emotion corpus
with 37 datasets, 150,907 samples, and a total duration of 119.5 hours. Second,
we introduce ExHuBERT, an enhanced version of HuBERT achieved by backbone
extension and fine-tuning on EmoSet++. We duplicate each encoder layer and its
weights, then freeze the first duplicate, integrating an extra zero-initialized
linear layer and skip connections to preserve functionality and ensure its
adaptability for subsequent fine-tuning. Our evaluation on unseen datasets
shows the efficacy of ExHuBERT, setting a new benchmark for various SER tasks.
Model and details on EmoSet++: https://huggingface.co/amiriparian/ExHuBERT.
|
[
-0.48263004422187805,
-0.630803644657135,
-0.09652549773454666,
0.14456698298454285,
-0.35024043917655945,
0.0880899652838707,
-0.3209153711795807,
-0.7211232781410217,
0.7543599605560303,
0.16649018228054047,
-0.26248279213905334,
-0.217294842004776,
-0.52530437707901,
-0.048463329672813416,
-0.3212076425552368,
0.9611623287200928,
-0.056511543691158295,
0.09905565530061722,
0.14300034940242767,
-0.17860136926174164,
0.06256984174251556,
-0.6191948056221008,
-0.7971952557563782,
-0.3179570436477661,
0.40052855014801025,
0.5566064715385437,
0.37612608075141907,
0.35958951711654663,
0.2828467786312103,
0.19370348751544952,
-0.011654148809611797,
0.20798833668231964,
-0.566547155380249,
0.5718139410018921,
0.23070789873600006,
-0.1094769537448883,
-0.5913353562355042,
-0.2760661840438843,
0.3905385136604309,
0.3473975956439972,
-0.21982641518115997,
0.122869573533535,
0.12533199787139893,
0.8311817049980164,
-0.8605998158454895,
0.15469281375408173,
-0.24369217455387115,
0.21306458115577698,
-0.24371974170207977,
-0.33820629119873047,
-0.37180548906326294,
-0.2847312092781067,
0.4784913659095764,
-0.36206603050231934,
-0.09610025584697723,
0.003399884095415473,
0.7473289966583252,
0.17424620687961578,
-0.4194578230381012,
-0.03558238223195076,
-0.4309941828250885,
0.6038508415222168,
-0.4448256492614746,
0.5256968140602112,
0.3338901996612549,
0.32009920477867126,
0.06318151205778122,
-0.7040888667106628,
-0.2157333940267563,
-0.1001230999827385,
0.27420949935913086,
0.3095879852771759,
-0.46945586800575256,
0.10070203989744186,
0.47389650344848633,
0.39692676067352295,
-0.5741640329360962,
-0.11781007796525955,
-0.35129573941230774,
-0.1435457170009613,
0.5932161808013916,
-0.07289966940879822,
0.08254241198301315,
0.012891856953501701,
0.026653358712792397,
-0.4140692353248596,
-0.3965222239494324,
0.5565227270126343,
0.5240480303764343,
0.12430057674646378,
-0.2723154127597809,
0.2068433165550232,
-0.27761784195899963,
0.5712500810623169,
0.08338873088359833,
0.5890440344810486,
0.4389532506465912,
0.5869179964065552,
-0.2997349202632904,
0.31072238087654114,
0.49638083577156067,
0.12938839197158813,
0.3754940330982208,
0.21279729902744293,
0.01778918132185936,
-0.1311410814523697,
0.2998204529285431,
-0.9463611245155334,
-0.8210613131523132,
0.4612528085708618,
-0.2619486153125763,
-0.23442591726779938,
0.01676100492477417,
-0.9575933218002319,
-0.6648755669593811,
-0.4401431083679199,
0.43093347549438477,
-0.5123421549797058,
-0.22412621974945068,
0.06546178460121155,
-0.09630497545003891,
0.17437471449375153,
0.2915534973144531,
-0.9916296601295471,
0.5354844331741333,
0.7497175335884094,
0.6589851975440979,
-0.3004692494869232,
-0.20493516325950623,
-1.0760483741760254,
-0.12269436568021774,
-0.3712043762207031,
0.4465268552303314,
-0.7593984007835388,
-0.10389780253171921,
0.06835390627384186,
-0.017193341627717018,
0.5166965126991272,
-0.40872836112976074,
0.7948673367500305,
-0.3237607479095459,
-0.009523673914372921,
-0.1936403214931488,
-0.4852322041988373,
-0.4480195641517639,
0.03270157799124718,
-0.6504610180854797,
1.1575833559036255,
0.31980594992637634,
-0.5583674311637878,
0.13179297745227814,
-0.37924230098724365,
-0.748630702495575,
-0.1376224309206009,
0.06102873384952545,
-0.45464131236076355,
0.6746361255645752,
0.23371878266334534,
0.6051950454711914,
-0.3070640563964844,
0.18488165736198425,
-0.584121823310852,
-0.24991323053836823,
0.15067163109779358,
-0.16812939941883087,
0.6420786380767822,
-0.0290239155292511,
-0.3866990804672241,
0.23541860282421112,
-1.0922331809997559,
0.17157553136348724,
-0.3121805787086487,
-0.026610804721713066,
-0.49142929911613464,
-0.3094486594200134,
0.30146151781082153,
0.26847290992736816,
0.11236754804849625,
-0.6799762845039368,
-0.1878303438425064,
-0.3303149938583374,
0.3376632034778595,
0.7108091711997986,
-0.3826197683811188,
0.3113420307636261,
-0.25189948081970215,
0.6764668226242065,
-0.22071751952171326,
0.17860397696495056,
-0.2934510409832001,
-0.27564316987991333,
-1.1212868690490723,
-0.5064893960952759,
0.31768089532852173,
0.3492676019668579,
-0.21268640458583832,
0.2999727725982666,
-0.19939731061458588,
-0.5794591307640076,
-0.9121184945106506,
-0.3680666983127594,
0.18147113919258118,
0.5389094352722168,
0.651846706867218,
-0.5322977304458618,
-0.8691137433052063,
-0.85572749376297,
-0.10439137369394302,
0.21704964339733124,
0.26124703884124756,
0.5797291994094849,
0.3441338539123535,
-0.0423462875187397,
0.7233816385269165,
-0.314342200756073,
0.1549394130706787,
0.037620335817337036,
0.3062223792076111,
0.1440810263156891,
0.6642434000968933,
0.4417347013950348,
-0.8623828887939453,
-0.7600677013397217,
0.2729649543762207,
-0.7105393409729004,
-0.2940230071544647,
0.18927378952503204,
-0.32025235891342163,
0.2871990501880646,
0.12634411454200745,
-0.10830653458833694,
0.31977903842926025,
0.7319620847702026,
0.017084581777453423,
0.6821126341819763,
-0.11398813873529434,
0.29604101181030273,
-0.8741304278373718,
0.012239210307598114,
-0.2964062988758087,
-0.3522427976131439,
-1.0300277471542358,
-0.057265155017375946,
0.25266578793525696,
-0.5442884564399719,
-0.30502328276634216,
0.5278133749961853,
-0.4026198387145996,
-0.09627722203731537,
-0.30703914165496826,
0.043246980756521225,
0.047550126910209656,
0.5782648324966431,
0.16587144136428833,
0.14411336183547974,
0.9526020884513855,
-0.5018295645713806,
0.8227562308311462,
0.1481693834066391,
-0.22727735340595245,
0.665688157081604,
-0.8169105648994446,
0.2888683080673218,
0.0024272482842206955,
0.224443256855011,
-0.7370458245277405,
-0.4979081153869629,
0.086502805352211,
-0.4627504050731659,
0.6662690043449402,
0.053022902458906174,
-0.07180887460708618,
-0.20991751551628113,
-0.7073277235031128,
0.26322758197784424,
0.7761115431785583,
-0.6899260878562927,
1.0136772394180298,
0.4580964148044586,
-0.506697416305542,
-0.6842175126075745,
-0.8256805539131165,
0.10014427453279495,
-0.312783420085907,
-0.6434720754623413,
0.27391543984413147,
-0.007774496451020241,
0.011667141690850258,
-0.15652626752853394,
-0.2020176500082016,
-0.1979796141386032,
0.023165496066212654,
0.4922342598438263,
-0.16716884076595306,
0.18490704894065857,
0.18712444603443146,
0.5462450385093689,
-0.10942129790782928,
-0.14763474464416504,
-0.20139995217323303,
0.5719543695449829,
-0.09711305797100067,
-0.12971825897693634,
-0.4973187744617462,
0.6718266606330872,
0.5480289459228516,
-0.29999762773513794,
0.3528916537761688,
0.8823084235191345,
-0.45281943678855896,
-0.30587852001190186,
-0.45123764872550964,
-0.26427558064460754,
-0.4347842335700989,
0.39030253887176514,
-0.6614101529121399,
-1.090452790260315,
0.6626505851745605,
-0.08630368858575821,
-0.050062838941812515,
-0.1007130891084671,
0.31577885150909424,
-0.09400483965873718,
0.7925081849098206,
0.6427896618843079,
-0.2520316541194916,
0.5821237564086914,
-0.20513352751731873,
0.11658541858196259,
-1.2452685832977295,
-0.24389386177062988,
-0.28713271021842957,
-0.643539547920227,
-0.6200562119483948,
-0.18378201127052307,
0.3529733717441559,
0.18669858574867249,
-0.2331215739250183,
0.6083628535270691,
-0.4129030108451843,
-0.016709746792912483,
0.5419212579727173,
0.1811986118555069,
-0.2144029140472412,
0.2309892624616623,
0.18384842574596405,
-0.24220086634159088,
-0.5074335336685181,
-0.039557043462991714,
0.9046018123626709,
0.11696775257587433,
0.7458264827728271,
0.22153256833553314,
0.7999099493026733,
0.3817814886569977,
0.16269998252391815,
-0.7959389686584473,
0.3665800094604492,
-0.20226998627185822,
-0.4225369393825531,
-0.2822117805480957,
-0.3597751259803772,
-0.6043814420700073,
0.234718918800354,
-0.09621170908212662,
-0.9706304669380188,
0.4723184108734131,
0.4479229748249054,
-0.3219698965549469,
-0.15639956295490265,
-0.4860646426677704,
0.6046445369720459,
-0.30340471863746643,
-0.675827145576477,
-0.4619908928871155,
-0.6652121543884277,
0.132671058177948,
-0.39172080159187317,
-0.08675725013017654,
-0.23326526582241058,
0.009725061245262623,
0.6106479167938232,
-0.24346967041492462,
0.5007869005203247,
-0.1616179645061493,
-0.1953561007976532,
0.06559129059314728,
0.11895275861024857,
0.7682967185974121,
-0.08925890177488327,
-0.5810790657997131,
-0.0017382769146934152,
-0.1482102870941162,
-0.24268411099910736,
-0.7259019613265991,
0.6552923321723938,
-0.5357640981674194,
-0.17767643928527832,
-0.215377539396286,
-0.5485371947288513,
-0.27592822909355164,
-0.17647767066955566,
0.31387171149253845,
0.7735616564750671,
-0.2570696771144867,
0.41638001799583435,
0.3885987102985382,
-0.4896392226219177,
0.09359569102525711,
0.6295697093009949,
-0.22886627912521362,
-0.6273434162139893,
1.0472506284713745,
0.092694953083992,
0.1301921308040619,
0.6481751799583435,
0.317926287651062,
-0.18773838877677917,
-0.04923221096396446,
-0.20196379721164703,
-0.22535836696624756,
-0.5431911945343018,
-0.23805148899555206,
-0.913923978805542,
0.20366305112838745,
-0.5697134733200073,
-0.249649778008461,
-0.3689977824687958,
-0.7403531074523926,
-0.20708319544792175,
-0.04121757671236992,
0.7644792795181274,
0.10382033884525299,
-0.6450282335281372,
0.2809544801712036,
-0.7203748226165771,
0.2997308373451233,
0.41994914412498474,
0.193868026137352,
0.08857846260070801,
-0.902329683303833,
-0.2886798083782196,
0.044756025075912476,
-0.048355940729379654,
-0.9012326598167419,
0.5176852941513062,
0.7368001937866211,
0.1491852104663849,
0.6278218030929565,
0.33603841066360474,
0.8185878992080688,
-0.4083693027496338,
0.5343130826950073,
0.17050157487392426,
-1.4846750497817993,
0.6237048506736755,
-0.3972303569316864,
-0.04035254940390587,
0.34558624029159546,
0.5658825039863586,
-0.7353076934814453,
-0.08470229059457779,
-0.5520086288452148,
-1.1219836473464966,
0.7698246240615845,
0.07916153967380524,
0.1582076996564865,
0.3082221746444702,
0.2562634348869324,
0.3321508765220642,
0.35198894143104553,
-0.39477378129959106,
-0.15810491144657135,
-0.16912472248077393,
-0.19805678725242615,
0.11067674309015274,
-0.407265305519104,
-0.020887242630124092,
-0.4939950108528137,
0.823456883430481,
0.0026376659516245127,
0.2535116672515869,
0.02119510807096958,
-0.25091901421546936,
0.07769837975502014,
0.21734242141246796,
0.45374226570129395,
0.11903434246778488,
-0.34407341480255127,
0.17092075943946838,
0.3475736677646637,
-0.2926258444786072,
0.14115069806575775,
0.44123730063438416,
0.059670206159353256,
0.034065019339323044,
0.19794945418834686,
1.250288724899292,
0.40500518679618835,
-0.6792203783988953,
0.21650362014770508,
0.08278679847717285,
0.212041974067688,
-0.29421401023864746,
0.03835379704833031,
-0.2685937285423279,
0.4440942406654358,
0.21398070454597473,
-0.18780730664730072,
0.5923386812210083,
-0.5137929916381836,
0.4386448562145233,
0.05525226518511772,
-0.7927427887916565,
-0.5029336214065552,
0.35842862725257874,
0.4172360599040985,
-0.22608840465545654,
0.35708293318748474,
-0.36692115664482117,
-0.743611752986908,
0.5399159789085388,
0.4672994613647461,
1.0086205005645752,
-0.6641123294830322,
0.194971963763237,
0.35118645429611206,
-0.014418532140552998,
-0.08579162508249283,
0.8367859721183777,
-0.31402456760406494,
-0.5402423739433289,
-0.32636913657188416,
-0.5792352557182312,
-0.7152320742607117,
-0.11678241938352585,
-1.2322615385055542,
0.3355894982814789,
-0.2872411608695984,
-0.1643676906824112,
-0.3241768479347229,
-0.08102396130561829,
-0.3705402612686157,
0.089828260242939,
0.2155085802078247,
0.7011488080024719,
-0.6417220830917358,
0.72434002161026,
0.716772198677063,
0.1921226978302002,
-0.6619870066642761,
-0.381271094083786,
-0.012873700819909573,
-0.559471607208252,
0.40470293164253235,
0.4047781825065613,
-0.3805202543735504,
0.1463206261396408,
-0.3298981189727783,
-0.6599412560462952,
0.708282470703125,
0.5396078824996948,
-0.8073298335075378,
0.548413097858429,
-0.3705908954143524,
0.6326463222503662,
-0.35794854164123535,
0.33759811520576477,
0.7296313047409058,
0.28989115357398987,
-0.29484668374061584,
-0.7020300030708313,
-0.14078286290168762,
-0.5931135416030884,
-0.33915576338768005,
0.37803658843040466,
-0.6697545051574707,
0.7916476726531982,
-0.26016491651535034,
-0.10842888057231903,
0.10020509362220764,
0.6423812508583069,
0.07209301739931107,
0.14339305460453033,
0.20261794328689575,
0.6531841158866882,
1.2093619108200073,
-0.17959101498126984,
0.9190444946289062,
-0.5442981123924255,
0.35641056299209595,
1.5034637451171875,
-0.5006218552589417,
0.9955072402954102,
0.12819448113441467,
-0.024938227608799934,
0.5254984498023987,
0.6929916143417358,
-0.19616344571113586,
0.6225051283836365,
0.4493410885334015,
-0.36485064029693604,
-0.14143618941307068,
-0.5452088713645935,
-0.5315344929695129,
0.5934286713600159,
0.34223484992980957,
-0.17655742168426514,
0.2649640440940857,
0.4868888258934021,
-0.025357291102409363,
-0.3713538348674774,
-0.08849554508924484,
0.37679365277290344,
0.2552265226840973,
-0.26619312167167664,
0.47531363368034363,
-0.29358339309692383,
0.5599842667579651,
-0.6484558582305908,
0.09992566704750061,
-0.08107822388410568,
0.13295024633407593,
-0.2958540916442871,
-0.48754680156707764,
0.04158660024404526,
0.22017112374305725,
0.10782278329133987,
-0.16886575520038605,
0.635249674320221,
-0.6872310042381287,
-0.20955559611320496,
0.660893440246582,
0.16303803026676178,
0.48423269391059875,
-0.2705020308494568,
-0.3973049521446228,
0.2876007556915283,
-0.09401215612888336,
-0.3755820393562317,
0.013947080820798874,
0.5831899046897888,
0.2749413251876831,
0.6519010066986084,
0.41759055852890015,
0.19995109736919403,
-0.06674029678106308,
0.32867947220802307,
0.7733250856399536,
-0.496637225151062,
-0.5813083648681641,
-0.8441606760025024,
0.6720026731491089,
-0.26182085275650024,
-0.37444964051246643,
0.6290808320045471,
0.5363210439682007,
0.6047126650810242,
-0.05572950467467308,
0.842799186706543,
-0.1900366097688675,
0.3202708959579468,
-0.1584293097257614,
0.45428982377052307,
-0.7438401579856873,
-0.37056416273117065,
-0.7291456460952759,
-0.7850679755210876,
-0.18686744570732117,
0.8319942951202393,
-0.02727770246565342,
-0.07486189156770706,
0.570091962814331,
0.6024298071861267,
-0.05991802364587784,
0.29514196515083313,
0.46125128865242004,
0.10574686527252197,
0.3011070191860199,
0.7597874402999878,
0.8814114332199097,
-0.5881245732307434,
0.36593613028526306,
-0.3096047639846802,
-0.42995795607566833,
-0.3810477554798126,
-0.9034132957458496,
-0.6386820077896118,
-0.6289416551589966,
-0.41217514872550964,
-0.2078980952501297,
0.20951855182647705,
1.141587734222412,
1.011069655418396,
-0.9383791089057922,
-0.12844087183475494,
0.17532803118228912,
-0.3108867108821869,
-0.32681551575660706,
-0.13851606845855713,
0.4665733575820923,
0.04582991078495979,
-0.8554193377494812,
0.32593655586242676,
0.639897882938385,
0.05167549103498459,
0.19084273278713226,
-0.27071675658226013,
0.3490675091743469,
-0.07498697936534882,
0.7280966639518738,
0.3352668881416321,
-0.2953650653362274,
-0.1550607979297638,
-0.025569049641489983,
0.34621357917785645,
0.01917322166264057,
0.8020443916320801,
-0.54501873254776,
0.8435003161430359,
0.7548398375511169,
0.7450401186943054,
0.6767187714576721,
-0.036190055310726166,
0.8274416923522949,
-0.626258134841919,
0.3158070743083954,
0.33456718921661377,
0.5729432702064514,
0.547612726688385,
-0.097199447453022,
0.5972942113876343,
-0.20939908921718597,
-0.4091648459434509,
-0.8841121792793274,
0.41548454761505127,
-1.1361266374588013,
0.1906716674566269,
0.7939478158950806,
-0.4447554647922516,
0.20305414497852325,
0.03851277753710747,
-0.19348733127117157,
0.4719160795211792,
-0.9032675623893738,
0.7649754285812378,
0.790860116481781,
-0.6606528759002686,
-0.3556210696697235,
-0.5071730017662048,
0.5897836089134216,
0.5562152862548828,
-1.0532511472702026,
0.22009386122226715,
0.39538857340812683,
-0.291145384311676,
0.22315365076065063,
0.3146406412124634,
0.03499729186296463,
0.500644326210022,
-0.1256617307662964,
0.10056072473526001,
-0.10346692055463791,
-0.4952290654182434,
-0.7806596755981445,
0.1656479835510254,
-0.3126567602157593,
-0.14083392918109894
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.08520v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.08520v1
|
Automated Question Generation for Science Tests in Arabic Language Using NLP Techniques
| 2024-06-11T20:27:45 | 2024-06-11T20:27:45 |
Mohammad Tami, Huthaifa I. Ashqar, Mohammed Elhenawy
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CY
|
Question generation for education assessments is a growing field within
artificial intelligence applied to education. These question-generation tools
have significant importance in the educational technology domain, such as
intelligent tutoring systems and dialogue-based platforms. The automatic
generation of assessment questions, which entail clear-cut answers, usually
relies on syntactical and semantic indications within declarative sentences,
which are then transformed into questions. Recent research has explored the
generation of assessment educational questions in Arabic. The reported
performance has been adversely affected by inherent errors, including sentence
parsing inaccuracies, name entity recognition issues, and errors stemming from
rule-based question transformation. Furthermore, the complexity of lengthy
Arabic sentences has contributed to these challenges. This research presents an
innovative Arabic question-generation system built upon a three-stage process:
keywords and key phrases extraction, question generation, and subsequent
ranking. The aim is to tackle the difficulties associated with automatically
generating assessment questions in the Arabic language. The proposed approach
and results show a precision of 83.50%, a recall of 78.68%, and an Fl score of
80.95%, indicating the framework high efficiency. Human evaluation further
confirmed the model efficiency, receiving an average rating of 84%.
|
[
-0.6047128438949585,
-1.145532250404358,
0.39679694175720215,
0.282640665769577,
-0.10749249905347824,
0.15408700704574585,
0.17334191501140594,
-0.3605042099952698,
-0.051242947578430176,
0.3656429052352905,
-0.3442614674568176,
-0.6585953831672668,
-0.43786853551864624,
0.542019248008728,
-0.5666834115982056,
0.9454846978187561,
-0.41129425168037415,
-0.16404861211776733,
-0.16132044792175293,
-0.012786772102117538,
-0.3033106327056885,
-0.21882744133472443,
-0.8644543290138245,
-0.05348541960120201,
0.0662139281630516,
0.6128636598587036,
0.8421509265899658,
0.20102667808532715,
0.5565457940101624,
0.2615768015384674,
0.14905357360839844,
0.34531399607658386,
0.44178295135498047,
0.3332173824310303,
-0.06009575352072716,
-0.13788680732250214,
-0.14477935433387756,
-0.2244759202003479,
0.598190188407898,
0.7697882056236267,
-0.013812386430799961,
0.5851659178733826,
-0.13604404032230377,
0.7304414510726929,
-0.6373934149742126,
0.08252274245023727,
-0.5113499760627747,
0.2284802347421646,
0.06617750227451324,
-0.20874571800231934,
0.03385075554251671,
-0.7411108613014221,
0.02097344398498535,
-0.08277460187673569,
0.2392244040966034,
-0.012330266647040844,
0.7410654425621033,
0.18280628323554993,
-0.4248673915863037,
-0.7557063698768616,
-0.6191385388374329,
0.6155458092689514,
-0.6123903393745422,
-0.04343964904546738,
0.4245232045650482,
0.4735080599784851,
-0.13721604645252228,
-0.6866753101348877,
-0.7019839882850647,
-0.31738293170928955,
0.19267848134040833,
0.11752431094646454,
0.09615124017000198,
-0.19590549170970917,
0.11813695728778839,
0.023238446563482285,
-0.7823099493980408,
-0.1979694664478302,
-0.2428370714187622,
-0.18709677457809448,
0.8571583032608032,
0.12169913947582245,
0.44748976826667786,
-0.39543697237968445,
-0.04753883183002472,
-0.345636248588562,
-0.8075942397117615,
0.10465585440397263,
0.4185471832752228,
0.2783191502094269,
0.44480612874031067,
0.7116401195526123,
-0.35904088616371155,
0.7604320049285889,
-0.06651296466588974,
-0.046503931283950806,
0.07242847979068756,
-0.39574089646339417,
0.22376056015491486,
0.31812435388565063,
0.6910349726676941,
0.22096258401870728,
0.14655444025993347,
0.3006534278392792,
-0.11394431442022324,
0.1650494486093521,
0.2822427749633789,
-0.9775933623313904,
-0.05106653273105621,
0.6220964193344116,
0.06226867437362671,
-0.3914814293384552,
0.018779035657644272,
-0.7509847283363342,
0.14668282866477966,
0.11299794167280197,
0.5914866924285889,
-0.45837217569351196,
-0.009467925876379013,
0.3179517388343811,
0.25827500224113464,
0.3018795847892761,
0.2948797047138214,
-0.5901368260383606,
0.203189417719841,
0.18547581136226654,
0.4901879131793976,
-0.1741924285888672,
-0.04111625626683235,
-0.1536911427974701,
-0.044589076191186905,
-0.4012635052204132,
0.629192590713501,
-0.4421501159667969,
-0.5452322363853455,
0.16570405662059784,
-0.48995473980903625,
-0.09885063767433167,
-0.6288621425628662,
0.41943466663360596,
-0.8321126103401184,
0.5897481441497803,
0.1553819328546524,
-0.6030297875404358,
-0.3790230453014374,
0.44391465187072754,
-0.23781755566596985,
1.278632640838623,
0.09335744380950928,
-0.5500182509422302,
0.07583976536989212,
-1.0515724420547485,
-0.37030428647994995,
0.4094735383987427,
-0.2880406379699707,
-0.4796719253063202,
-0.45993179082870483,
0.536051869392395,
0.2737983465194702,
-0.1934579461812973,
0.4542602002620697,
0.4282356798648834,
-0.2239234894514084,
0.33133918046951294,
-0.2621484398841858,
0.566409707069397,
0.1695500910282135,
-0.8351211547851562,
-0.1377820372581482,
-0.754074215888977,
0.7010862231254578,
0.1330002397298813,
-0.39879509806632996,
0.04068069905042648,
0.09358425438404083,
0.06008513644337654,
0.3119943141937256,
0.31630825996398926,
-0.5914891362190247,
-0.013312042690813541,
-0.6601824164390564,
-0.08833388239145279,
0.3079095482826233,
0.5285184383392334,
0.025413161143660545,
-0.37675899267196655,
0.9507201313972473,
-0.11314994841814041,
0.04951547458767891,
-0.04655173793435097,
-0.7116513848304749,
-0.8364278078079224,
0.3616364002227783,
0.47044864296913147,
0.704301118850708,
-0.7451528906822205,
0.8300173282623291,
0.17838037014007568,
-0.7123929858207703,
-0.41638094186782837,
0.14822542667388916,
0.20217452943325043,
0.5489375591278076,
0.5637927651405334,
-0.1316741406917572,
-0.29853758215904236,
-0.7050794363021851,
-0.1186865046620369,
-0.4138354957103729,
-0.06845320016145706,
0.22205568850040436,
1.0005526542663574,
-0.04944006726145744,
1.0366320610046387,
-0.7970539331436157,
-0.007526712957769632,
-0.3620850145816803,
0.39519476890563965,
0.040254831314086914,
0.5838670134544373,
0.40024635195732117,
-0.9940113425254822,
-0.4677579700946808,
-0.2680337727069855,
-0.48484107851982117,
-0.23103052377700806,
-0.018040508031845093,
-0.027618270367383957,
0.29924464225769043,
0.33291152119636536,
-0.5710525512695312,
0.40345683693885803,
0.3018886148929596,
-0.4224526286125183,
0.845339298248291,
0.08393712341785431,
0.21791920065879822,
-1.2268259525299072,
0.16412770748138428,
-0.3289046883583069,
0.10848522186279297,
-0.42021507024765015,
0.4073919653892517,
-0.21961373090744019,
-0.32079821825027466,
-0.5008752942085266,
0.5940573215484619,
-0.08775864541530609,
0.3084455728530884,
-0.27247360348701477,
0.20369404554367065,
0.014410869218409061,
0.19518981873989105,
-0.11757118254899979,
0.847968339920044,
0.30887967348098755,
-0.7589996457099915,
0.31989729404449463,
0.37032294273376465,
-0.3846038579940796,
0.12498766928911209,
-0.7659197449684143,
0.31033819913864136,
0.043644022196531296,
0.0359768308699131,
-0.9449808597564697,
-0.12718264758586884,
0.2644664943218231,
-0.5041723251342773,
-0.03789594769477844,
0.42023739218711853,
-0.593733012676239,
-0.38508328795433044,
-0.2388809621334076,
0.4737672507762909,
0.5491878986358643,
-0.21925531327724457,
0.4364163875579834,
0.08472156524658203,
-0.7046772837638855,
-0.6281551122665405,
-0.14152759313583374,
-0.012597156688570976,
-0.11074197292327881,
-0.6475378274917603,
0.18972794711589813,
-0.1246577650308609,
-0.3328441381454468,
-0.04435177892446518,
-0.2042965590953827,
-0.09904306381940842,
0.27552351355552673,
0.21507379412651062,
0.14735133945941925,
-0.21284952759742737,
0.305250346660614,
0.569101095199585,
0.33277449011802673,
0.45001980662345886,
-0.19107608497142792,
0.6360189318656921,
-0.2825203835964203,
-0.4951956868171692,
-0.1766999214887619,
0.7692692279815674,
0.3891519010066986,
-0.35926303267478943,
0.5293107032775879,
0.5428441762924194,
-0.4523322284221649,
-0.2737223207950592,
-0.40575680136680603,
-0.2900661528110504,
-0.4841544032096863,
0.4592548906803131,
-0.3191564381122589,
-0.5960265398025513,
0.2998121380805969,
-0.15829747915267944,
0.08392031490802765,
0.6006407737731934,
0.48171254992485046,
-0.19409821927547455,
1.473304033279419,
0.2605705261230469,
0.1246924176812172,
-0.16782470047473907,
-0.22360554337501526,
0.35757365822792053,
-0.31408458948135376,
-0.27238214015960693,
-0.750619113445282,
-0.08183326572179794,
-0.5395935773849487,
-0.23489491641521454,
0.6481963396072388,
0.094476617872715,
-0.3280947506427765,
0.04054272547364235,
-0.3993704617023468,
0.3560645580291748,
0.4778265953063965,
-0.11654435843229294,
0.19781255722045898,
0.0662088468670845,
-0.3309638500213623,
0.07369308173656464,
-0.590842604637146,
-0.9306380748748779,
1.0609240531921387,
-0.0350494310259819,
0.1516597419977188,
0.20879241824150085,
0.9885237812995911,
0.36462825536727905,
0.2383369356393814,
-0.6834766268730164,
0.8421247005462646,
0.466836541891098,
-0.6739614009857178,
-0.5231332182884216,
-0.15476372838020325,
-0.955329418182373,
0.17074136435985565,
-0.28660449385643005,
-0.3289565145969391,
-0.4549451172351837,
-0.23289327323436737,
-0.5688770413398743,
-0.08177001774311066,
-0.39938023686408997,
0.5469071269035339,
-0.2623032033443451,
-0.15623310208320618,
0.060552120208740234,
-0.7961968779563904,
0.06315784156322479,
-0.4360376298427582,
0.042878877371549606,
-0.029424231499433517,
0.2115279734134674,
1.143064260482788,
-0.41855862736701965,
0.4699684679508209,
-0.3460054099559784,
-0.0764935091137886,
0.7255691885948181,
0.27971482276916504,
0.07533331960439682,
0.1336306631565094,
-0.05273091420531273,
-0.2429981231689453,
0.24275504052639008,
-0.29592639207839966,
-0.7551635503768921,
0.285451740026474,
-0.728718638420105,
-0.8993909358978271,
-0.5890985727310181,
-0.8284677267074585,
-0.5354992151260376,
0.1634823977947235,
-0.1697441190481186,
0.10343324393033981,
-0.053170137107372284,
-0.2651880085468292,
0.3704040050506592,
-0.49652400612831116,
0.260998010635376,
0.5705251693725586,
-0.5028053522109985,
-0.022014737129211426,
0.8337002396583557,
0.0040291654877364635,
0.15760625898838043,
0.07159344851970673,
0.22152893245220184,
-0.522922158241272,
-0.6355443596839905,
-0.586040198802948,
0.15291142463684082,
-0.5818971395492554,
-0.430497407913208,
-0.588942289352417,
-0.5123850107192993,
-0.6205890774726868,
-0.15671749413013458,
-0.06392073631286621,
-0.6658145189285278,
-0.1428879201412201,
-0.09482729434967041,
0.1494714915752411,
0.5155394077301025,
0.2621314227581024,
0.09161539375782013,
-0.8722242116928101,
0.3435472548007965,
0.3897547125816345,
-0.39464953541755676,
-0.34522294998168945,
-0.43849289417266846,
0.055929891765117645,
0.11883273720741272,
-0.8073120713233948,
-0.9403797388076782,
0.5138632655143738,
0.46331003308296204,
-0.032964661717414856,
0.23965831100940704,
0.022490087896585464,
0.35994482040405273,
-0.4657406508922577,
1.0047187805175781,
-0.15811172127723694,
-0.9200205206871033,
1.0614118576049805,
-0.015726059675216675,
0.5145440697669983,
0.652405321598053,
0.6666011810302734,
-0.38883736729621887,
-0.7302088141441345,
-0.7202838659286499,
-0.9436185956001282,
0.2786702811717987,
0.362915575504303,
0.1665640026330948,
-0.15725190937519073,
0.4995514154434204,
0.22476761043071747,
0.3410031497478485,
-0.25243380665779114,
-0.28284943103790283,
-0.16477687656879425,
-0.4958744943141937,
0.1585826277732849,
-0.04613937810063362,
-0.1341400146484375,
-0.3523930311203003,
0.8375914692878723,
-0.26125726103782654,
-0.05897751823067665,
0.2602076530456543,
-0.048674918711185455,
0.13948795199394226,
0.653641939163208,
0.5822084546089172,
0.6724115610122681,
-0.3144112825393677,
-0.12034258246421814,
0.19581501185894012,
-0.7301912307739258,
0.46236321330070496,
0.31616806983947754,
-0.5781113505363464,
0.10960206389427185,
0.10276485234498978,
0.041672106832265854,
-0.35645249485969543,
-0.8456119894981384,
0.4150038957595825,
0.008837331086397171,
-0.39597347378730774,
-0.6218608617782593,
0.11894866824150085,
-0.04956720024347305,
-0.0056488895788788795,
0.6600378155708313,
-0.01712329126894474,
0.20986825227737427,
-0.3162786364555359,
0.3845444917678833,
0.2974185049533844,
0.06297585368156433,
-0.0068268682807683945,
0.5622274279594421,
0.12829993665218353,
-0.30854305624961853,
0.7674388289451599,
-0.3927251398563385,
-0.7306722402572632,
0.812699556350708,
0.7296947240829468,
0.4853900671005249,
-0.5416887998580933,
0.7379825711250305,
0.5272803902626038,
0.15517807006835938,
0.16012191772460938,
0.9110273718833923,
-0.27826401591300964,
-0.918026864528656,
-0.1700325757265091,
-0.9097506999969482,
-0.7685726881027222,
0.0012595789739862084,
-0.5935060977935791,
-0.04933619499206543,
-0.4375201165676117,
-0.1866437792778015,
-0.20826907455921173,
0.2330814003944397,
-0.5298849940299988,
0.7650029063224792,
-0.0757761299610138,
0.8097551465034485,
-0.8445226550102234,
0.4375292658805847,
0.9432056546211243,
-0.49454164505004883,
-1.117878794670105,
-0.09697131812572479,
-0.37810036540031433,
-0.6945878863334656,
1.0351780652999878,
0.2766624391078949,
-0.22132627665996552,
0.24826470017433167,
-0.43996164202690125,
-0.8896976113319397,
0.9257414937019348,
-0.08510366827249527,
-0.09612974524497986,
-0.1647902876138687,
0.6673868298530579,
0.6548678278923035,
-0.3565407395362854,
0.3927881717681885,
0.4980522692203522,
0.5100422501564026,
-0.03963185101747513,
-0.5801565647125244,
0.19654247164726257,
-0.504670262336731,
-0.23119905591011047,
0.1582328826189041,
-0.02813657931983471,
0.507779061794281,
-0.19836558401584625,
-0.2882084250450134,
0.18350045382976532,
0.7328181862831116,
0.48089390993118286,
0.31617626547813416,
0.45616593956947327,
0.2985974848270416,
0.5907208919525146,
-0.1458837389945984,
0.7767122983932495,
-0.6019344925880432,
0.048893917351961136,
0.6840577721595764,
-0.4857131540775299,
0.8855097889900208,
0.6510884165763855,
-0.30030614137649536,
0.7968136668205261,
0.5147560238838196,
-0.0026426876429468393,
0.2258531153202057,
0.6818086504936218,
-0.45268386602401733,
0.047583095729351044,
-0.2741110920906067,
-0.45244863629341125,
0.8370323777198792,
0.45027950406074524,
-0.1693219244480133,
-0.35870182514190674,
-0.01293226983398199,
0.022110365331172943,
0.17287756502628326,
-0.06412262469530106,
0.45556312799453735,
-0.1366775780916214,
-0.9952214956283569,
0.4111378788948059,
0.18115536868572235,
0.1603398323059082,
-0.6635252833366394,
-0.3850860297679901,
-0.11612139642238617,
-0.17132820188999176,
-0.09212258458137512,
-0.6630319356918335,
0.2550867199897766,
0.14724764227867126,
0.23432426154613495,
-0.18039599061012268,
0.5380690693855286,
-0.5076612830162048,
-0.8402045369148254,
-0.3121456801891327,
0.8039567470550537,
0.3886043429374695,
-0.07023181766271591,
-0.8138724565505981,
-0.3320257067680359,
-0.14317987859249115,
-0.2077912837266922,
-0.025824032723903656,
-0.07024466246366501,
-0.11786486953496933,
0.6699352860450745,
0.5283557176589966,
0.28474387526512146,
0.11037131398916245,
0.04586372524499893,
0.4319145679473877,
-0.5829033851623535,
-0.32572299242019653,
-0.48704999685287476,
0.36060866713523865,
0.1404263973236084,
-0.2892060875892639,
0.7843276858329773,
0.4812732934951782,
0.7503597140312195,
0.025504304096102715,
0.889460563659668,
-0.09022939205169678,
0.4612240195274353,
-0.48290494084358215,
0.7700336575508118,
-0.43536704778671265,
-0.015796691179275513,
-0.3572516143321991,
-0.9410836100578308,
-0.4764818847179413,
0.5228657722473145,
-0.01741151325404644,
0.20093226432800293,
1.0383347272872925,
0.7413879632949829,
0.5794132351875305,
0.3180360794067383,
0.03574255481362343,
-0.17374752461910248,
0.4149057865142822,
0.5163690447807312,
0.9227983355522156,
-0.7927328944206238,
0.393580824136734,
-0.33859193325042725,
0.028495613485574722,
0.1268095225095749,
-0.3694864809513092,
-0.7623927593231201,
-0.7056340575218201,
-0.565965473651886,
-0.3092438578605652,
-0.035892412066459656,
1.0377014875411987,
0.03307651728391647,
-1.0400439500808716,
-0.22221246361732483,
-0.082877978682518,
-0.06697458773851395,
-0.14958569407463074,
-0.3399621248245239,
0.9276388883590698,
-0.3059535324573517,
-0.6609833836555481,
0.35435906052589417,
0.03137240558862686,
0.1542428731918335,
-0.3881092965602875,
0.3170550465583801,
-0.36922338604927063,
0.10746171325445175,
0.4904402792453766,
0.14360202848911285,
-0.47406765818595886,
-0.5293514132499695,
0.18464922904968262,
0.031332820653915405,
-0.3003704845905304,
0.3642842769622803,
-0.813597559928894,
0.331521600484848,
0.21885347366333008,
0.8502687811851501,
0.17749549448490143,
0.19823017716407776,
0.42982304096221924,
-0.6637637615203857,
-0.23798520863056183,
0.8229747414588928,
-0.04950190708041191,
0.34225931763648987,
-0.18195274472236633,
0.35999226570129395,
0.007193010300397873,
-0.5941614508628845,
-0.6541877388954163,
0.3370385766029358,
-0.6651524305343628,
-0.06505083292722702,
1.0046945810317993,
0.0936659425497055,
-0.08692551404237747,
-0.1985476016998291,
-0.42571863532066345,
0.27025431394577026,
-0.11497649550437927,
1.288137435913086,
0.7381005883216858,
-0.3675166070461273,
0.3202124238014221,
-0.42422905564308167,
0.4703556299209595,
1.1082842350006104,
-0.9914705157279968,
-0.7077042460441589,
0.26028239727020264,
0.14495448768138885,
0.508368730545044,
0.2506164312362671,
-0.18213346600532532,
0.40635064244270325,
-0.222572460770607,
0.19381514191627502,
0.03704698383808136,
-0.18711932003498077,
0.042293108999729156,
0.6986802816390991,
0.07757597416639328,
-0.21276240050792694
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.08519v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.08519v1
|
Question-Answering (QA) Model for a Personalized Learning Assistant for Arabic Language
| 2024-06-11T20:23:31 | 2024-06-11T20:23:31 |
Mohammad Sammoudi, Ahmad Habaybeh, Huthaifa I. Ashqar, Mohammed Elhenawy
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CY
|
This paper describes the creation, optimization, and assessment of a
question-answering (QA) model for a personalized learning assistant that uses
BERT transformers customized for the Arabic language. The model was
particularly finetuned on science textbooks in Palestinian curriculum. Our
approach uses BERT's brilliant capabilities to automatically produce correct
answers to questions in the field of science education. The model's ability to
understand and extract pertinent information is improved by finetuning it using
11th and 12th grade biology book in Palestinian curriculum. This increases the
model's efficacy in producing enlightening responses. Exact match (EM) and F1
score metrics are used to assess the model's performance; the results show an
EM score of 20% and an F1 score of 51%. These findings show that the model can
comprehend and react to questions in the context of Palestinian science book.
The results demonstrate the potential of BERT-based QA models to support
learning and understanding Arabic students questions.
|
[
-0.5992730259895325,
-0.9421330094337463,
0.6518803238868713,
-0.0037215854972600937,
-0.16374073922634125,
0.26992160081863403,
0.39375850558280945,
-0.3438267111778259,
0.14294324815273285,
0.2654913663864136,
-0.48300856351852417,
-0.4591447114944458,
-0.47223609685897827,
0.19743382930755615,
-0.505560576915741,
0.9739838242530823,
0.06097821146249771,
0.2420528382062912,
-0.04948108643293381,
0.03941813483834267,
-0.4101331830024719,
-0.26949384808540344,
-0.7303506731987,
-0.13990283012390137,
0.42621150612831116,
0.4863755404949188,
0.9362104535102844,
0.36122915148735046,
0.4363325834274292,
0.3702923655509949,
-0.24774298071861267,
-0.060791466385126114,
0.20435193181037903,
-0.05221153795719147,
-0.23209838569164276,
-0.5233241319656372,
-0.3760931193828583,
-0.3612825572490692,
0.4927349388599396,
0.6454043984413147,
0.04542076587677002,
0.6017975807189941,
-0.20397059619426727,
0.6261630654335022,
-0.20560088753700256,
-0.02816821075975895,
-0.2630510628223419,
-0.04513378068804741,
0.4968504309654236,
0.11097872257232666,
-0.2676985561847687,
-0.9079341888427734,
0.6914194226264954,
-0.4402085840702057,
0.22492048144340515,
-0.2324557602405548,
0.9182485938072205,
0.15166297554969788,
-0.31832948327064514,
-0.6251072287559509,
-0.6936215162277222,
0.6679807901382446,
-0.5888237357139587,
0.3228180706501007,
0.420246958732605,
0.740979790687561,
0.0716959685087204,
-0.7846488356590271,
-0.7848045825958252,
-0.27276161313056946,
0.12000349909067154,
0.16668832302093506,
0.07932329922914505,
-0.1283748596906662,
-0.27551114559173584,
0.06603047996759415,
-0.5250042676925659,
-0.31302401423454285,
-0.40300509333610535,
-0.06543921679258347,
0.3885197937488556,
-0.12515826523303986,
0.6256685256958008,
-0.2894037961959839,
-0.1189740002155304,
-0.37215110659599304,
-0.23621144890785217,
0.5586705207824707,
0.5022286772727966,
0.12621380388736725,
0.0717071145772934,
0.3446556031703949,
-0.26844093203544617,
0.7217369079589844,
0.05322318151593208,
0.05173724144697189,
-0.03149138763546944,
-0.07865942269563675,
0.00011219368752790615,
0.045991331338882446,
0.11712730675935745,
-0.11875253915786743,
0.25762516260147095,
-0.14286111295223236,
-0.04829486459493637,
-0.23494283854961395,
0.36485424637794495,
-0.9156163930892944,
-0.261772096157074,
0.4847780764102936,
-0.418861985206604,
-0.14819951355457306,
-0.17291271686553955,
-0.6840258240699768,
0.017747044563293457,
-0.22667694091796875,
0.9439362287521362,
-0.47977352142333984,
0.13822604715824127,
0.07639764994382858,
0.06761429458856583,
0.36226898431777954,
0.633912980556488,
-0.6651105284690857,
0.17291410267353058,
0.0403931587934494,
0.41689395904541016,
0.08231918513774872,
0.07599936425685883,
-0.03677983582019806,
-0.08699165284633636,
-0.2099059671163559,
0.7947420477867126,
-0.661312997341156,
-0.415384978055954,
0.20494641363620758,
-0.18420280516147614,
0.16913412511348724,
-0.3344776928424835,
0.44444164633750916,
-1.3352872133255005,
0.5000994205474854,
-0.30742138624191284,
-0.7199503183364868,
-0.7557514309883118,
0.20792146027088165,
-0.5698797702789307,
0.5884627103805542,
0.2734508216381073,
-0.3125288188457489,
-0.172918438911438,
-0.9344503879547119,
-0.09565431624650955,
0.07157721370458603,
0.02626265212893486,
-0.3823319971561432,
-0.3027380406856537,
0.41517141461372375,
0.17139528691768646,
-0.1302841603755951,
0.27938133478164673,
0.12734568119049072,
-0.24449831247329712,
0.5785259008407593,
-0.22897246479988098,
0.8014185428619385,
0.30706673860549927,
-0.1477917581796646,
0.20500265061855316,
-0.9148381948471069,
0.46771979331970215,
0.13686814904212952,
-0.6502382755279541,
-0.0470874048769474,
0.05302145704627037,
0.20277807116508484,
0.13337543606758118,
0.7768080830574036,
-0.9328442215919495,
0.14090286195278168,
-0.45873650908470154,
0.021536020562052727,
0.7815300226211548,
0.10349836200475693,
0.18419720232486725,
-0.5660920143127441,
0.6316229104995728,
-0.28292226791381836,
0.17083202302455902,
0.0009652902954258025,
-0.6142292618751526,
-0.8080641031265259,
-0.07491262257099152,
0.5915678143501282,
0.5722746253013611,
-0.6592549085617065,
0.5104223489761353,
0.2014150172472,
-0.7156869769096375,
-0.980131208896637,
0.11595926433801651,
0.4112716019153595,
0.7501410841941833,
0.6574802994728088,
-0.29581931233406067,
-0.24148379266262054,
-0.9949581623077393,
-0.08624740689992905,
-0.23129050433635712,
-0.11086916923522949,
0.3418295085430145,
0.462787926197052,
-0.24314436316490173,
1.2421913146972656,
-0.5707716941833496,
-0.10182585567235947,
-0.28188571333885193,
0.08680100739002228,
0.16339322924613953,
0.4805653691291809,
0.6176961064338684,
-0.9749423861503601,
-0.7027041912078857,
-0.06275150924921036,
-0.5912750363349915,
-0.12677763402462006,
0.15314015746116638,
-0.21130232512950897,
-0.007935027591884136,
-0.022752664983272552,
-0.185185968875885,
0.3657902479171753,
0.4396938681602478,
-0.5111505389213562,
0.6135984063148499,
-0.1712491810321808,
0.21928845345973969,
-1.239730954170227,
0.13242928683757782,
-0.17647768557071686,
-0.07851147651672363,
-0.7292842864990234,
0.3011593520641327,
0.08478043973445892,
-0.2611335813999176,
-0.5891979336738586,
0.7004680037498474,
0.21827371418476105,
0.03598392382264137,
-0.44969815015792847,
0.03193127363920212,
-0.018370771780610085,
0.53260737657547,
-0.046700701117515564,
1.1028075218200684,
0.2109927386045456,
-0.5931962132453918,
0.1651996672153473,
0.7852715849876404,
-0.4187983274459839,
0.08767180889844894,
-1.1338192224502563,
0.37137293815612793,
-0.17928171157836914,
-0.16921398043632507,
-1.0988487005233765,
-0.09533713757991791,
0.029080357402563095,
-0.5727258324623108,
0.04751374572515488,
0.2959955036640167,
-0.4439612329006195,
-0.15085747838020325,
-0.09716574102640152,
0.39445850253105164,
0.8095845580101013,
-0.777225136756897,
0.8704310059547424,
-0.05283511430025101,
-0.5596207976341248,
-0.4120241701602936,
0.039904382079839706,
-0.40792328119277954,
0.21077032387256622,
-0.5814365148544312,
0.1932889074087143,
-0.4956258237361908,
0.03366854786872864,
0.11562986671924591,
-0.062141302973032,
-0.44720637798309326,
0.18232221901416779,
0.0354166142642498,
0.32561326026916504,
-0.22372272610664368,
0.4295688569545746,
0.5043128132820129,
0.20449195802211761,
0.10670527815818787,
0.06905080378055573,
0.7251884937286377,
-0.32168692350387573,
-0.29917702078819275,
-0.7875691056251526,
0.3925482928752899,
0.4273930788040161,
-0.3608992099761963,
0.7181136012077332,
0.5794368386268616,
-0.24934640526771545,
0.202811598777771,
-0.5010203719139099,
-0.3645332455635071,
-0.5862129330635071,
0.6931471228599548,
-0.3889477849006653,
-0.5619335174560547,
0.6279762387275696,
-0.0519978366792202,
0.12330380827188492,
0.2722828984260559,
0.6772764921188354,
-0.38544750213623047,
1.350469946861267,
0.7214158773422241,
-0.09366508573293686,
0.36063918471336365,
-0.16302436590194702,
0.13319489359855652,
-0.6268965601921082,
-0.4051458537578583,
-0.7699557542800903,
-0.19825343787670135,
-0.3277338445186615,
0.018071608617901802,
0.6295499801635742,
0.017948992550373077,
-0.5475325584411621,
0.07051703333854675,
-0.5428469777107239,
0.2180069088935852,
0.9915791153907776,
0.26912975311279297,
0.06444515287876129,
0.05629361793398857,
-0.09790751338005066,
0.2259550541639328,
-0.49391087889671326,
-1.1262058019638062,
1.1261746883392334,
0.38320472836494446,
0.5421572327613831,
0.5945998430252075,
0.648670494556427,
0.49020954966545105,
0.3404664993286133,
-0.43894314765930176,
0.5737942457199097,
0.2277982085943222,
-0.8975964784622192,
-0.5364822149276733,
0.11471495777368546,
-0.9089750647544861,
0.2298598289489746,
-0.07345888763666153,
-0.6917218565940857,
0.014668922871351242,
0.03412891924381256,
-0.605218231678009,
0.057862866669893265,
-0.8881047368049622,
0.773521363735199,
-0.24991580843925476,
-0.0505305714905262,
-0.10036244243383408,
-0.7569330930709839,
-0.054865073412656784,
-0.20902355015277863,
-0.12716059386730194,
0.045349884778261185,
0.0679396390914917,
1.0560345649719238,
-0.23271392285823822,
0.8837433457374573,
-0.27886202931404114,
0.034530844539403915,
0.66316157579422,
0.2132461667060852,
0.07925550639629364,
-0.020907126367092133,
-0.17077061533927917,
-0.30113735795021057,
0.6128469109535217,
-0.8172162175178528,
-0.6489658355712891,
0.41095077991485596,
-1.50290048122406,
-0.8867615461349487,
-0.3730286657810211,
-0.8818509578704834,
-0.39986568689346313,
0.15290609002113342,
-0.3486641049385071,
0.1344803422689438,
-0.08634205907583237,
-0.09580275416374207,
0.7347351908683777,
-0.6804457306861877,
0.3198736906051636,
1.0467023849487305,
-0.24206803739070892,
-0.2117428034543991,
1.03144371509552,
-0.1693909913301468,
0.2660538852214813,
0.2973872721195221,
0.303572416305542,
-0.38048255443573,
-0.4754329323768616,
-0.6479482054710388,
0.2603246867656708,
-0.846057116985321,
-0.19398388266563416,
-0.5520313382148743,
-0.4185243546962738,
-0.39563265442848206,
-0.22588476538658142,
0.06386367231607437,
-0.2343161702156067,
-0.4886932969093323,
0.009628929197788239,
0.28392907977104187,
0.8467549085617065,
0.40068942308425903,
0.5700141787528992,
-1.03292715549469,
0.2155928611755371,
0.8134981989860535,
-0.03277859091758728,
0.03137081861495972,
-0.8914850950241089,
-0.048822395503520966,
0.06190052628517151,
-0.7438858151435852,
-1.237830400466919,
0.4492727220058441,
0.30613547563552856,
0.23755435645580292,
0.33575472235679626,
-0.0703301727771759,
0.22881397604942322,
-0.5523149967193604,
0.8224402070045471,
-0.14299875497817993,
-1.1070555448532104,
0.6901503205299377,
-0.049309778958559036,
0.45177677273750305,
0.24949531257152557,
0.7127094864845276,
-0.2861708402633667,
-0.37701869010925293,
-0.5529266595840454,
-0.492482453584671,
0.4764942526817322,
0.14609357714653015,
0.5098052620887756,
0.1808042973279953,
0.5886135101318359,
0.4125266969203949,
0.3097623884677887,
-0.5830272436141968,
-0.2517143487930298,
-0.2241479903459549,
-0.7051089406013489,
0.23100672662258148,
-0.3785002529621124,
0.15971294045448303,
-0.3500394821166992,
0.923967719078064,
-0.2279970347881317,
0.3186470568180084,
0.31723752617836,
-0.05084994435310364,
-0.12848129868507385,
0.4333586096763611,
0.5408923625946045,
0.7512953877449036,
-0.5111179947853088,
-0.26124307513237,
0.16546490788459778,
-0.5619418025016785,
0.3099137842655182,
0.2629965543746948,
-0.6013883948326111,
0.0670834556221962,
0.1542752981185913,
0.1789361983537674,
-0.32072776556015015,
-1.0412014722824097,
0.22887377440929413,
-0.1046467199921608,
0.0942971333861351,
-0.42263105511665344,
0.1916293501853943,
0.23887933790683746,
0.41944780945777893,
0.639312744140625,
-0.1198522076010704,
0.19460651278495789,
-0.46666771173477173,
0.16386842727661133,
0.3238195478916168,
-0.17525288462638855,
-0.4701944887638092,
0.606340765953064,
0.21053127944469452,
-0.5632914304733276,
0.39917537569999695,
-0.12344929575920105,
-0.7787413597106934,
1.105545997619629,
0.6543492674827576,
0.3534003794193268,
-0.712643027305603,
0.6966047883033752,
0.3467051088809967,
0.11399924010038376,
0.7360751032829285,
0.8019260168075562,
-0.11435341835021973,
-0.7889061570167542,
-0.0497320219874382,
-0.8666760921478271,
-0.7573434710502625,
0.04748537391424179,
-0.6575653553009033,
-0.2254030406475067,
-0.4984990358352661,
0.055067580193281174,
0.19967955350875854,
0.14426279067993164,
-0.9304683804512024,
0.689424455165863,
-0.3647990822792053,
0.904457151889801,
-0.7220711708068848,
0.8849664926528931,
1.0268021821975708,
-0.878491222858429,
-0.8640955686569214,
-0.21279580891132355,
-0.6368297338485718,
-1.1048786640167236,
1.1181780099868774,
-0.17045679688453674,
0.04581064730882645,
0.2932949960231781,
-0.47198593616485596,
-1.199194073677063,
0.9098361134529114,
0.1858707219362259,
-0.2837769687175751,
-0.05750347301363945,
0.23985819518566132,
0.6852730512619019,
-0.1799255907535553,
0.4096745550632477,
0.3764618933200836,
0.29101526737213135,
-0.07522568851709366,
-0.6171952486038208,
-0.16265913844108582,
-0.22265562415122986,
-0.14410565793514252,
-0.08816765993833542,
-0.5480530261993408,
0.6690304279327393,
-0.2673831284046173,
0.12385158985853195,
0.7418047785758972,
0.9366396069526672,
0.022498436272144318,
0.2506829500198364,
0.20686616003513336,
0.20127606391906738,
0.5482407212257385,
0.07198546081781387,
0.9887502193450928,
-0.46801504492759705,
0.2720775306224823,
0.7363473773002625,
-0.11002226173877716,
0.9114153981208801,
0.5130910873413086,
-0.46889397501945496,
0.8313670754432678,
0.6660265326499939,
0.23824642598628998,
0.6186643242835999,
0.19857561588287354,
-0.4830757677555084,
-0.11218207329511642,
-0.2801681458950043,
-0.4145142436027527,
0.3222848176956177,
0.2611110508441925,
-0.3382667601108551,
-0.24221494793891907,
0.1973235309123993,
-0.37603744864463806,
0.2897631525993347,
-0.26059913635253906,
0.6715662479400635,
-0.2893914580345154,
-0.6046413779258728,
0.2171766459941864,
0.3161337971687317,
0.006071134936064482,
-0.6591881513595581,
-0.21334338188171387,
-0.209771990776062,
-0.02767176739871502,
0.13679641485214233,
-0.5831149816513062,
-0.05544765666127205,
0.02577417716383934,
-0.21542848646640778,
0.22183391451835632,
0.4398145377635956,
-0.5784305930137634,
-0.7372759580612183,
-0.1796456128358841,
0.7158157825469971,
0.24256423115730286,
0.405805766582489,
-0.7587112784385681,
-0.18887001276016235,
0.07957860082387924,
0.03646276146173477,
0.2391968071460724,
-0.044146325439214706,
0.16145069897174835,
0.8696870803833008,
0.6053400039672852,
-0.12579742074012756,
0.22671116888523102,
-0.08176430314779282,
0.715904712677002,
-0.42257019877433777,
-0.4609835743904114,
-0.25392642617225647,
0.2771621644496918,
0.21703249216079712,
-0.3094501793384552,
0.5058546662330627,
0.16933360695838928,
0.7178888916969299,
-0.606919527053833,
0.7584651708602905,
0.18282783031463623,
0.7672297358512878,
-0.24924685060977936,
0.7963111400604248,
-0.4860402047634125,
-0.08517543226480484,
-0.10225069522857666,
-0.8669795989990234,
0.04930727928876877,
0.8604038953781128,
-0.23395615816116333,
0.40928977727890015,
0.5099351406097412,
0.5309812426567078,
0.22808021306991577,
0.22336441278457642,
0.38179874420166016,
-0.04601360484957695,
0.4633907973766327,
0.5114561915397644,
0.6937132477760315,
-0.5149753093719482,
0.4596470296382904,
-0.35921385884284973,
-0.12375343590974808,
-0.1957377940416336,
-0.2567170262336731,
-1.0090925693511963,
-0.7139439582824707,
-0.38128408789634705,
-0.17195820808410645,
0.2652575671672821,
1.1216707229614258,
0.3897162079811096,
-1.1006135940551758,
-0.16578225791454315,
0.09340082108974457,
0.06541483104228973,
-0.0610218420624733,
-0.2391069382429123,
1.0595877170562744,
-0.49327367544174194,
-1.0180343389511108,
0.09261016547679901,
-0.2066498100757599,
0.3902587890625,
-0.4038800299167633,
0.026237880811095238,
-0.40077412128448486,
0.4915240406990051,
0.49113279581069946,
0.47647881507873535,
-0.786905825138092,
-0.586381733417511,
0.2195759266614914,
-0.03730924800038338,
-0.24899297952651978,
0.21545490622520447,
-0.9613237380981445,
0.7871614098548889,
0.23556454479694366,
1.3061292171478271,
0.02490978315472603,
0.13652878999710083,
0.3811497390270233,
-0.6278243660926819,
-0.20984216034412384,
0.4516655206680298,
0.17460159957408905,
0.23838704824447632,
-0.3851895332336426,
0.11935240030288696,
-0.30452442169189453,
-0.6430556178092957,
-0.4635908305644989,
0.2811618447303772,
-0.9345192313194275,
-0.2846902906894684,
0.6320585608482361,
-0.22985009849071503,
-0.2613093852996826,
-0.17577601969242096,
-0.7321173548698425,
0.4255663752555847,
-0.376444011926651,
1.5155915021896362,
0.7332154512405396,
-0.040986403822898865,
0.16308678686618805,
-0.5073005557060242,
0.32801148295402527,
1.2081440687179565,
-0.9058845639228821,
-0.9251315593719482,
0.1172855943441391,
0.36750704050064087,
0.35255444049835205,
0.10111856460571289,
0.20146404206752777,
0.8163264989852905,
-0.5915554165840149,
0.376777321100235,
-0.04978417232632637,
-0.17601679265499115,
-0.13608375191688538,
0.3925282955169678,
0.36299562454223633,
-0.530961811542511
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.07696v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.07696v1
|
Sustainable self-supervised learning for speech representations
| 2024-06-11T20:21:36 | 2024-06-11T20:21:36 |
Luis Lugo, Valentin Vielzeuf
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Sustainable artificial intelligence focuses on data, hardware, and algorithms
to make machine learning models more environmentally responsible. In
particular, machine learning models for speech representations are
computationally expensive, generating environmental concerns because of their
high energy consumption. Thus, we propose a sustainable self-supervised model
to learn speech representation, combining optimizations in neural layers and
training to reduce computing costs. The proposed model improves over a
resource-efficient baseline, reducing both memory usage and computing cost
estimations. It pretrains using a single GPU in less than a day. On top of
that, it improves the error rate performance of the baseline in downstream task
evaluations. When comparing it to large speech representation approaches, there
is an order of magnitude reduction in memory usage, while computing cost
reductions represent almost three orders of magnitude improvement.
|
[
-0.1609133929014206,
-0.5643744468688965,
0.38859012722969055,
0.07858937978744507,
-0.17023849487304688,
-0.1353834718465805,
-0.27820882201194763,
-0.4137715995311737,
0.31433719396591187,
0.5584491491317749,
-0.729539692401886,
-0.17659150063991547,
-0.29291287064552307,
-0.14215874671936035,
-0.06294181197881699,
0.6722121834754944,
0.4729442894458771,
0.11353182792663574,
-0.3734121024608612,
-0.19665005803108215,
-0.5988348126411438,
-0.4705027937889099,
-1.014854073524475,
-0.38061580061912537,
0.5242845416069031,
0.38642048835754395,
0.48789334297180176,
0.9243208765983582,
0.15212668478488922,
0.47053107619285583,
0.15434859693050385,
-0.09629319608211517,
-0.5171447992324829,
0.10430558770895004,
-0.16115647554397583,
-0.03470010310411453,
0.04560088366270065,
0.4532727301120758,
0.5879953503608704,
0.5165228843688965,
-0.3770037293434143,
0.5320777893066406,
0.1607786864042282,
0.7164711952209473,
-0.7861555814743042,
0.532265305519104,
-0.662935197353363,
0.12210924178361893,
-0.0909990593791008,
-0.23313136398792267,
-0.45114952325820923,
-0.0864119678735733,
-0.29120901226997375,
-0.5368228554725647,
-0.05732555314898491,
-0.26802361011505127,
0.3747856318950653,
0.8477357625961304,
-0.08436210453510284,
-0.1368657797574997,
-0.6765108108520508,
1.1266324520111084,
-0.4852481782436371,
0.5080314874649048,
0.39831021428108215,
0.17537057399749756,
0.28810885548591614,
-0.5616966485977173,
-0.3937038779258728,
-0.27727869153022766,
0.1362050622701645,
0.557182252407074,
-0.34101933240890503,
0.1046798899769783,
0.01863664761185646,
-0.005716750398278236,
-0.39809373021125793,
0.19731643795967102,
-0.4346846342086792,
-0.2891499400138855,
0.9129759073257446,
-0.06615746766328812,
0.12478367984294891,
-0.4367537796497345,
-0.19567956030368805,
0.02832733653485775,
-0.36969512701034546,
-0.02876332961022854,
0.3547559380531311,
0.6435893177986145,
0.12204906344413757,
0.1636606603860855,
-0.03015349991619587,
0.4144744873046875,
-0.07414223253726959,
-0.2019437551498413,
0.19024667143821716,
-0.16070184111595154,
-0.13191068172454834,
0.43138787150382996,
0.5794806480407715,
0.10045775771141052,
0.1312135010957718,
-0.12236588448286057,
-0.04443961754441261,
0.4063451290130615,
0.6425092220306396,
-0.7707360982894897,
-0.6601522564888,
0.06946422159671783,
-0.6090131402015686,
-0.11145290732383728,
-0.3219021260738373,
-0.4455789625644684,
-0.024764880537986755,
-0.89005446434021,
0.27714499831199646,
-0.3990779221057892,
-0.1108320951461792,
-0.2713429927825928,
0.10001684725284576,
-0.24692657589912415,
0.2698402404785156,
-1.0182989835739136,
0.18277598917484283,
0.31659334897994995,
0.8416466116905212,
0.055862706154584885,
0.020634213462471962,
-0.48141491413116455,
0.26262253522872925,
-0.32548797130584717,
0.6161435842514038,
-0.4598023593425751,
-0.5696786046028137,
-0.5015752911567688,
-0.30295300483703613,
-0.07665461301803589,
-0.5149899125099182,
0.5091883540153503,
-0.09807407110929489,
0.21489815413951874,
-0.18043957650661469,
-0.5627832412719727,
-0.2736550569534302,
-0.32083436846733093,
-0.5906912684440613,
0.9975078105926514,
0.024377891793847084,
-0.5999903678894043,
0.3201693296432495,
-0.794460654258728,
-0.3532726764678955,
0.42797207832336426,
-0.02571915276348591,
-0.7675032615661621,
0.020790552720427513,
0.260386198759079,
0.5131405591964722,
0.028776865452528,
0.3986510932445526,
-0.09328858554363251,
-0.2928091883659363,
-0.5354301333427429,
-0.35718485713005066,
0.7400673031806946,
0.5752189755439758,
-0.4299134314060211,
0.33046039938926697,
-0.959575355052948,
0.05155697092413902,
0.25370198488235474,
-0.3069526255130768,
-0.4184878468513489,
0.2950630784034729,
0.16174805164337158,
0.03035777434706688,
0.28132694959640503,
-0.6895819902420044,
-0.2412898689508438,
-0.19895823299884796,
0.8892804384231567,
1.2369574308395386,
-0.20577989518642426,
0.3520466983318329,
-0.08914992958307266,
0.22893525660037994,
-0.27857506275177,
0.25068938732147217,
-0.13031288981437683,
-0.4023563265800476,
-0.6953979134559631,
-0.6096896529197693,
-0.0013900096528232098,
0.39929425716400146,
-0.3693861961364746,
0.5035111904144287,
-0.057654932141304016,
-0.635988175868988,
-0.6242650151252747,
0.34920066595077515,
0.2334246039390564,
0.7929251790046692,
0.6786680817604065,
0.2254941612482071,
-0.7211188077926636,
-0.9452745914459229,
-0.07867998629808426,
-0.2962909936904907,
0.11594458669424057,
0.5859456658363342,
0.6134936809539795,
-0.48450997471809387,
0.9661695957183838,
-0.01915719173848629,
-0.25676724314689636,
0.05447757989168167,
0.05761544778943062,
0.053957499563694,
0.8472557067871094,
0.5212857723236084,
-0.8246810436248779,
-0.43984463810920715,
-0.20444999635219574,
-0.8176848888397217,
0.027361707761883736,
-0.3029705286026001,
0.23302891850471497,
0.1846427023410797,
0.5135181546211243,
-0.5781190991401672,
0.2870868146419525,
0.700725257396698,
0.06703799217939377,
0.3839433789253235,
-0.46325647830963135,
-0.1979554444551468,
-0.6699745059013367,
-0.0973619818687439,
0.13260792195796967,
-0.23072676360607147,
-0.3464919924736023,
-0.1608729511499405,
0.005055470857769251,
-0.6378422975540161,
-0.2022523283958435,
0.28087154030799866,
-0.39463722705841064,
0.025812624022364616,
-0.3802333176136017,
-0.05714867636561394,
-0.23191334307193756,
0.39952677488327026,
0.07286851108074188,
1.0148894786834717,
0.7484366297721863,
-0.586563766002655,
0.3019322156906128,
0.07163476943969727,
0.027359014376997948,
0.42425188422203064,
-0.6001943945884705,
0.4700187146663666,
-0.29699546098709106,
0.13187077641487122,
-0.6939235925674438,
-0.07894491404294968,
0.001927361823618412,
-0.29938817024230957,
0.38923269510269165,
0.05393481254577637,
-0.3031618297100067,
-0.32382962107658386,
0.028389813378453255,
0.12116213887929916,
0.727543294429779,
-1.0816569328308105,
0.7665643692016602,
0.788480281829834,
-0.3515850901603699,
-0.13147065043449402,
-0.8402062058448792,
0.07150819897651672,
-0.3503686785697937,
-0.5785653591156006,
0.4929472804069519,
0.2266133576631546,
-0.05621344596147537,
0.1514313817024231,
-0.3405355215072632,
0.3921748399734497,
0.1443672627210617,
0.23664964735507965,
-0.10109035670757294,
0.021323824301362038,
0.6068989038467407,
-0.202178955078125,
-0.289710134267807,
0.33042722940444946,
-0.8681108951568604,
0.3402232825756073,
-0.19913804531097412,
-0.18885916471481323,
-0.9472406506538391,
0.6480181813240051,
0.22167758643627167,
-0.325380802154541,
0.779782772064209,
0.3630284070968628,
-0.4706915318965912,
-0.2949584126472473,
-0.5622403025627136,
-0.03796951845288277,
-0.6039330959320068,
0.34743964672088623,
-0.17506328225135803,
-0.7794317007064819,
0.3134254217147827,
-0.11921242624521255,
0.06945256143808365,
0.6948969960212708,
0.34026435017585754,
-0.5977554321289062,
1.0587947368621826,
0.6356723308563232,
-0.2816893458366394,
0.7616776823997498,
-0.35527393221855164,
0.1454622447490692,
-0.49895521998405457,
-0.3062475025653839,
-0.5261226296424866,
-0.03218455985188484,
-0.7646206021308899,
-0.4247626066207886,
0.15307863056659698,
-0.15303349494934082,
-0.8721292018890381,
0.23239107429981232,
-1.048529863357544,
0.32582637667655945,
0.8347976207733154,
0.17634715139865875,
-0.2853158712387085,
0.01708267815411091,
0.09506411850452423,
-0.0665927603840828,
-0.9733232855796814,
-0.6535835266113281,
0.8509401679039001,
0.3537765443325043,
0.6796864867210388,
-0.27046850323677063,
1.0933173894882202,
0.5307069420814514,
0.21235889196395874,
-0.5714111924171448,
0.584722101688385,
-0.22111259400844574,
-0.09261472523212433,
-0.439484566450119,
-0.878730297088623,
-0.93169105052948,
0.07931014150381088,
-0.08555075526237488,
-0.7139104008674622,
-0.23829954862594604,
0.3698253929615021,
-0.17666229605674744,
0.333435595035553,
-0.7889659404754639,
0.7856305241584778,
-0.5833279490470886,
-0.4284909665584564,
-0.8679947853088379,
-0.3534661829471588,
-0.2815144956111908,
-0.028907185420393944,
0.20547856390476227,
-0.1117812842130661,
0.31929537653923035,
1.0803242921829224,
-0.30771586298942566,
0.9104318022727966,
-0.708749532699585,
0.30944937467575073,
0.5268611907958984,
-0.3804806172847748,
0.3564971685409546,
-0.11292417347431183,
-0.09918390214443207,
0.38174664974212646,
-0.3615773022174835,
-0.6722965240478516,
-0.38063785433769226,
0.795865535736084,
-0.8976722359657288,
-0.802530825138092,
-0.4048236012458801,
-0.33963435888290405,
-0.20647481083869934,
0.06819245964288712,
-0.06198902055621147,
0.178903266787529,
-0.11110206693410873,
0.2845483720302582,
0.6338508129119873,
-0.24050486087799072,
0.5460404753684998,
-0.11986891180276871,
0.21910956501960754,
-0.5051508545875549,
0.9644714593887329,
0.40723472833633423,
0.012151754461228848,
0.030105529353022575,
0.6557501554489136,
-0.5801054239273071,
-0.5878080129623413,
-0.11175090819597244,
0.058583419770002365,
-0.8357473611831665,
-0.2189338356256485,
-0.6304847598075867,
-0.20144149661064148,
-0.4071449935436249,
-0.07182087004184723,
-0.6279364228248596,
-0.2440098524093628,
-0.7737981677055359,
-0.5168470144271851,
0.40870800614356995,
0.5660255551338196,
-0.4627653956413269,
0.2978132367134094,
-0.48137950897216797,
0.19904282689094543,
0.6109272837638855,
0.18271943926811218,
0.15418396890163422,
-0.376749187707901,
-0.4128875732421875,
0.019427180290222168,
-0.40949520468711853,
-0.5997623205184937,
0.5978779196739197,
0.686612606048584,
0.9395818710327148,
0.3612687587738037,
-0.04745861515402794,
0.9046996831893921,
-0.6001894474029541,
0.7582194209098816,
0.5384547114372253,
-1.133408546447754,
1.1034528017044067,
-0.27941206097602844,
0.3419139087200165,
0.44375258684158325,
0.41213512420654297,
-0.20563183724880219,
-0.16098162531852722,
-0.7258749604225159,
-0.7196335196495056,
0.46700412034988403,
0.24291643500328064,
0.43932008743286133,
-0.1728329360485077,
0.4048299193382263,
-0.09881280362606049,
-0.14026929438114166,
-0.6433123350143433,
-0.19848287105560303,
-0.8630987405776978,
-0.03332848101854324,
-0.3681689202785492,
-0.15073350071907043,
0.10348567366600037,
-0.6103670597076416,
0.9903808832168579,
-0.31399354338645935,
0.2973843514919281,
0.045520469546318054,
0.23116853833198547,
0.10168061405420303,
0.053438276052474976,
0.1777312308549881,
0.19829228520393372,
0.026726167649030685,
0.08454891294240952,
0.33843404054641724,
-0.2776980400085449,
0.089657723903656,
-0.0421115979552269,
-0.11290571093559265,
-0.11234159767627716,
0.2344122976064682,
0.8703957796096802,
0.24180921912193298,
-0.4713878631591797,
-0.05091431364417076,
0.0874907448887825,
-0.08744461834430695,
-0.4870873987674713,
0.1282762736082077,
0.4514421224594116,
0.15816710889339447,
0.3140980005264282,
0.4441763758659363,
0.23193401098251343,
-0.5873766541481018,
0.2885878086090088,
0.51700758934021,
-0.28916385769844055,
0.07741541415452957,
0.9464674592018127,
0.40584051609039307,
-0.3751218020915985,
1.0899728536605835,
-0.001376642845571041,
-0.4354013502597809,
0.46020033955574036,
0.5213242173194885,
0.8545962572097778,
-0.4509103298187256,
0.22798624634742737,
0.5863321423530579,
-0.017019230872392654,
0.17072643339633942,
0.27404043078422546,
-0.5319824814796448,
-0.4952085614204407,
-0.4922630488872528,
-0.6864340901374817,
-0.45826709270477295,
-0.2784695625305176,
-0.602486789226532,
-0.1408270001411438,
-0.6916422843933105,
-0.4006192982196808,
0.0696081817150116,
0.2306576371192932,
-0.4345349669456482,
0.40567976236343384,
0.5676246881484985,
0.5361717343330383,
-0.8095216155052185,
0.9814327955245972,
0.4132000207901001,
-0.20383955538272858,
-0.8140445351600647,
-0.5472633242607117,
-0.15007363259792328,
-0.5100157260894775,
0.9114936590194702,
0.5701281428337097,
-0.5915826559066772,
0.010821604169905186,
-0.8087729215621948,
-1.0688951015472412,
0.9552099108695984,
0.8802868723869324,
-0.7326834201812744,
0.28919050097465515,
-0.07622744143009186,
0.5608124732971191,
-0.2969963252544403,
-0.11735667288303375,
0.2625385820865631,
0.4391351044178009,
-0.0026604251470416784,
-0.7370584607124329,
-0.2971191704273224,
-0.4781268239021301,
0.15343409776687622,
-0.23094063997268677,
-0.8087483644485474,
0.7757553458213806,
-0.18503506481647491,
-0.6231468319892883,
-0.25181370973587036,
1.1357001066207886,
0.36527884006500244,
0.21793504059314728,
0.4368138313293457,
0.6805292367935181,
1.2757514715194702,
-0.11909368634223938,
1.01222562789917,
-0.35947945713996887,
0.46890538930892944,
0.8841674327850342,
-0.07068073004484177,
0.6826927065849304,
0.39556756615638733,
-0.10523058474063873,
0.4011257290840149,
0.7303808927536011,
-0.0909041091799736,
0.7837808132171631,
0.4648313820362091,
-0.3564278185367584,
-0.6448041200637817,
-0.23115567862987518,
-0.1351359784603119,
0.6603671312332153,
0.2515445649623871,
-0.2083711475133896,
-0.10196802020072937,
0.3709404170513153,
-0.30351805686950684,
0.38632747530937195,
-0.6626297831535339,
0.6836498975753784,
0.1975553035736084,
-0.450093150138855,
0.5331020951271057,
-0.2653735876083374,
0.6940453052520752,
-0.5290411710739136,
-0.09028118848800659,
0.180155411362648,
0.2542932629585266,
-0.284307599067688,
-0.28613120317459106,
0.5054715871810913,
-0.06232619658112526,
-0.06674573570489883,
-0.9111372828483582,
0.7117186188697815,
-0.21350228786468506,
-0.5797738432884216,
0.5313654541969299,
0.017496298998594284,
0.11296497285366058,
-0.18800489604473114,
-0.9710928797721863,
-0.06732015311717987,
0.0028221802785992622,
-0.15324078500270844,
0.15687917172908783,
-0.10436087101697922,
0.1283687800168991,
1.057671308517456,
0.8173924684524536,
0.12620191276073456,
0.08712451905012131,
0.1506868153810501,
0.854184091091156,
-0.621643602848053,
-0.9913128614425659,
-0.7131626009941101,
0.28768831491470337,
-0.061402980238199234,
0.03923279047012329,
0.6858682036399841,
0.5495542287826538,
0.7341174483299255,
0.05372095853090286,
0.9614927172660828,
0.25165995955467224,
0.22129251062870026,
-0.640262246131897,
0.8923075795173645,
-0.41547781229019165,
-0.12127376347780228,
-0.08948018401861191,
-0.810456395149231,
-0.07776784896850586,
1.2348119020462036,
-0.291769415140152,
0.20436087250709534,
0.1824152022600174,
0.45848381519317627,
0.18425202369689941,
0.43961307406425476,
0.4207668602466583,
-0.02093411609530449,
0.2861299216747284,
0.32806968688964844,
0.7658655047416687,
-0.048460703343153,
0.05295681953430176,
-0.5166075825691223,
-0.12640045583248138,
0.2538585960865021,
-0.8866119384765625,
-0.6490537524223328,
-0.6231077313423157,
-0.8130816221237183,
0.12145836651325226,
0.3511168360710144,
0.9315652847290039,
1.3307071924209595,
-0.8948531150817871,
-0.11158832907676697,
-0.3575025200843811,
-0.2879754304885864,
-0.41086167097091675,
-0.17840667068958282,
0.6219437122344971,
-0.5627392530441284,
-0.6303895115852356,
0.6684143543243408,
0.3545997440814972,
-0.2900066375732422,
-0.5196441411972046,
-0.12880702316761017,
-0.01777883805334568,
0.03716034069657326,
0.5705519318580627,
0.3445853888988495,
-0.6499588489532471,
-0.6554816961288452,
-0.1674983650445938,
0.18550416827201843,
0.30699557065963745,
0.32571426033973694,
-1.0581152439117432,
0.5875290632247925,
0.15059907734394073,
0.7458226680755615,
0.8698940873146057,
-0.027494532987475395,
0.1428232491016388,
-0.5747417211532593,
0.0708172395825386,
0.7088416814804077,
0.5999516844749451,
0.5147221684455872,
-0.6440030336380005,
0.3608773350715637,
0.1836010068655014,
-0.8387535214424133,
-0.31679993867874146,
0.1260453164577484,
-1.072115421295166,
-0.19272524118423462,
0.727411687374115,
-0.22898747026920319,
-0.22794906795024872,
0.11916565150022507,
-0.05472851172089577,
0.2598191499710083,
-0.3837850093841553,
0.8331986665725708,
0.2755858302116394,
-0.49555209279060364,
-0.6064386367797852,
-0.3514263927936554,
0.21309079229831696,
0.42263031005859375,
-0.6094624400138855,
0.13253572583198547,
0.5719565153121948,
0.2525719404220581,
0.46158692240715027,
0.5247520804405212,
0.16107450425624847,
0.06466226279735565,
0.317738801240921,
0.1555379033088684,
-0.1676906794309616,
-0.4940418004989624,
-0.20049823820590973,
0.27223020792007446,
-0.44325146079063416,
-0.28253260254859924
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10274v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10274v1
|
Using General Large Language Models to Classify Mathematical Documents
| 2024-06-11T20:15:57 | 2024-06-11T20:15:57 |
Patrick D. F. Ion, Stephen M. Watt
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.CL, cs.DL
|
In this article we report on an initial exploration to assess the viability
of using the general large language models (LLMs), recently made public, to
classify mathematical documents. Automated classification would be useful from
the applied perspective of improving the navigation of the literature and the
more open-ended goal of identifying relations among mathematical results. The
Mathematical Subject Classification MSC 2020, from MathSciNet and zbMATH, is
widely used and there is a significant corpus of ground truth material in the
open literature. We have evaluated the classification of preprint articles from
arXiv.org according to MSC 2020. The experiment used only the title and
abstract alone -- not the entire paper. Since this was early in the use of
chatbots and the development of their APIs, we report here on what was carried
out by hand. Of course, the automation of the process will have to follow if it
is to be generally useful. We found that in about 60% of our sample the LLM
produced a primary classification matching that already reported on arXiv. In
about half of those instances, there were additional primary classifications
that were not detected. In about 40% of our sample, the LLM suggested a
different classification than what was provided. A detailed examination of
these cases, however, showed that the LLM-suggested classifications were in
most cases better than those provided.
|
[
-0.3391822874546051,
-0.6685197353363037,
0.7893335819244385,
0.11140234768390656,
-0.19142687320709229,
-0.09537985175848007,
-0.4260866343975067,
-0.5715255737304688,
-0.18350251019001007,
0.6117424964904785,
-0.09321723878383636,
-0.7936896085739136,
-0.7267252802848816,
0.20956821739673615,
-0.7868804335594177,
1.0507265329360962,
-0.20249749720096588,
0.2579357624053955,
-0.6531398296356201,
0.0074701327830553055,
-0.0318252295255661,
-1.062990665435791,
-0.5977472066879272,
-0.34077009558677673,
0.6989402174949646,
-0.11409883201122284,
0.7101531624794006,
0.580569326877594,
0.7757288813591003,
0.4756436347961426,
-0.16130520403385162,
0.1334303915500641,
-0.23054033517837524,
0.07078604400157928,
-0.29615750908851624,
-0.9021772146224976,
-0.45193731784820557,
0.25792571902275085,
0.6964274048805237,
0.804530143737793,
-0.097671739757061,
0.21737892925739288,
0.14218175411224365,
0.6320640444755554,
-0.41702061891555786,
0.41815388202667236,
-0.44383126497268677,
0.0686461552977562,
-0.2984349727630615,
-0.2320694625377655,
-0.6262742877006531,
-0.5026174783706665,
0.2899934649467468,
-0.43380993604660034,
0.18318724632263184,
0.09199416637420654,
0.7855286598205566,
-0.0006266122218221426,
-0.383558988571167,
-0.885614275932312,
-0.922691822052002,
1.043505311012268,
-0.4826332628726959,
0.34083789587020874,
0.4696567952632904,
0.5209147930145264,
-0.16716809570789337,
-0.7438666820526123,
-0.25970420241355896,
-0.3560541570186615,
-0.0581684373319149,
0.0032646995969116688,
-0.41526663303375244,
0.03538110479712486,
0.40015363693237305,
0.2584175765514374,
-0.6633428335189819,
0.28050321340560913,
-0.42486920952796936,
-0.36472171545028687,
0.7579092383384705,
0.14712630212306976,
0.35359057784080505,
0.06306390464305878,
0.16122643649578094,
0.09609665721654892,
-0.6368414759635925,
-0.22934624552726746,
0.537047803401947,
0.28562283515930176,
0.11495442688465118,
0.9420891404151917,
0.017732176929712296,
0.8737061619758606,
-0.4962420165538788,
-0.32486552000045776,
0.2443579137325287,
-0.19077147543430328,
-0.19746367633342743,
-0.09472286701202393,
0.7453608512878418,
0.1692577451467514,
0.45770034193992615,
-0.049886394292116165,
-0.23668590188026428,
0.2093813568353653,
0.20501510798931122,
-0.7865676879882812,
-0.208682581782341,
-0.006873694248497486,
-0.4023909568786621,
-0.1991247534751892,
0.07011114060878754,
-0.516744077205658,
-0.24450521171092987,
-0.9547935724258423,
0.2812120020389557,
-0.1554909646511078,
0.050735268741846085,
0.036112986505031586,
0.2330026924610138,
-0.028358519077301025,
0.9751806855201721,
-0.6196060180664062,
0.33856722712516785,
1.0096334218978882,
0.9802136421203613,
-0.12156090885400772,
0.0488470159471035,
-0.2560001611709595,
-0.21272926032543182,
-0.35910871624946594,
1.0737115144729614,
-0.4658116400241852,
-0.3623422682285309,
0.24334432184696198,
-0.11765212565660477,
-0.0536213293671608,
-0.6247499585151672,
0.9206609129905701,
-0.8149078488349915,
0.6770814657211304,
0.06389527767896652,
-0.7303587198257446,
-0.24344627559185028,
0.3490470349788666,
-0.5537383556365967,
0.5282760858535767,
-0.014314452186226845,
-0.776256263256073,
-0.12418921291828156,
-0.7236396074295044,
-0.23338352143764496,
-0.1444542407989502,
-0.2086191326379776,
-0.35742175579071045,
0.08700710535049438,
-0.13743989169597626,
0.5350582003593445,
-0.4460216760635376,
0.2746215760707855,
-0.4095499515533447,
-0.3253606855869293,
0.5588138103485107,
-0.5790073871612549,
0.8558840751647949,
0.45881780982017517,
0.30139660835266113,
-0.1953388899564743,
-0.5517955422401428,
0.06815427541732788,
-0.07144688814878464,
-0.45736950635910034,
-0.5639761686325073,
0.07068759948015213,
-0.005178255494683981,
0.07145798951387405,
0.3394591510295868,
-0.3402321934700012,
0.3669964075088501,
-0.2965427041053772,
0.24980370700359344,
0.7166116237640381,
-0.28108683228492737,
0.500054121017456,
-0.3031654953956604,
0.5896434187889099,
-0.20969803631305695,
-0.12334257364273071,
-0.10990826040506363,
-0.708942711353302,
-0.8039356470108032,
-0.33490949869155884,
0.9122396111488342,
0.5963672399520874,
-0.5039382576942444,
0.6351876854896545,
-0.27411165833473206,
-0.6114086508750916,
-0.15783211588859558,
0.06621846556663513,
0.2639573812484741,
0.36730584502220154,
0.0509209968149662,
0.08444858342409134,
-0.3960738778114319,
-0.8737513422966003,
-0.10703901201486588,
-0.1900867372751236,
-0.3073212802410126,
0.39782723784446716,
0.4878431558609009,
-0.45450684428215027,
0.9551451206207275,
-0.7112197279930115,
-0.20594334602355957,
0.28192293643951416,
0.4738718569278717,
0.38073885440826416,
0.12765808403491974,
0.6815245151519775,
-0.8366944789886475,
-0.4845418930053711,
0.17080843448638916,
-0.993323028087616,
-0.3366630971431732,
0.31528031826019287,
-0.10999791324138641,
0.5120083689689636,
0.3688660264015198,
-0.42655524611473083,
0.5114056468009949,
0.36717963218688965,
0.004774344619363546,
0.4538072347640991,
-0.32752400636672974,
-0.007698868867009878,
-0.8071862459182739,
0.10031116753816605,
0.2402825504541397,
-0.11377402395009995,
-0.4481772184371948,
-0.14052101969718933,
0.08509552478790283,
-0.21581611037254333,
-0.3626529276371002,
0.5124715566635132,
-0.33325454592704773,
-0.21867217123508453,
-0.4171812832355499,
0.04732007160782814,
-0.39391806721687317,
0.2899896204471588,
0.05601280927658081,
0.570812463760376,
0.611531674861908,
-0.8629137873649597,
0.44199055433273315,
0.10601983219385147,
-0.42930305004119873,
0.6046696305274963,
-0.39160212874412537,
0.2662831246852875,
-0.3386956453323364,
0.30648285150527954,
-1.076373815536499,
-0.20302680134773254,
0.3680814206600189,
-0.6428495049476624,
0.19267898797988892,
-0.28438523411750793,
-0.9066604375839233,
-0.4657666087150574,
0.04726770520210266,
0.1672072559595108,
0.43429017066955566,
-0.4079833924770355,
0.8198772668838501,
0.33228039741516113,
-0.4518528878688812,
-0.2713431715965271,
-0.46327224373817444,
-0.01510101929306984,
-0.2643681764602661,
-0.6185314655303955,
0.029575182124972343,
-0.3393602669239044,
-0.5928172469139099,
0.22537106275558472,
-0.0028040800243616104,
-0.30421361327171326,
0.15666167438030243,
0.3291773498058319,
0.48754701018333435,
-0.18808794021606445,
0.43089938163757324,
-0.01473420299589634,
-0.14514370262622833,
0.17903193831443787,
-0.32564881443977356,
0.6586933135986328,
-0.18028861284255981,
-0.4467601180076599,
-0.3610265254974365,
0.1263015866279602,
0.5864594578742981,
-0.18558697402477264,
0.5228241682052612,
0.34886568784713745,
-0.4491131603717804,
-0.09262944757938385,
-0.4438595175743103,
0.3232646584510803,
-0.452309787273407,
0.15446874499320984,
-0.1550205796957016,
-0.9609532356262207,
0.4946820139884949,
-0.13943827152252197,
0.24924811720848083,
0.6660482883453369,
0.5854961276054382,
-0.0882360115647316,
1.1736609935760498,
0.571168065071106,
-0.1969090849161148,
0.3253585398197174,
-0.2267080396413803,
0.1128484383225441,
-0.5147188305854797,
-0.11353366822004318,
-1.236608624458313,
-0.1530560702085495,
-0.5981587171554565,
-0.2159319370985031,
0.39351123571395874,
-0.07690262794494629,
0.014631523750722408,
0.23662512004375458,
-0.4367806613445282,
0.6477312445640564,
0.27518197894096375,
-0.09493488073348999,
0.5412625074386597,
0.21794165670871735,
0.063761405646801,
-0.06652318686246872,
-0.32402968406677246,
-0.8071685433387756,
1.4006576538085938,
0.4196118414402008,
0.7784426212310791,
0.10274773836135864,
0.8035507202148438,
0.35655099153518677,
1.0721279382705688,
-0.9758391976356506,
0.692598283290863,
-0.3287450671195984,
-0.5836760401725769,
-0.26516759395599365,
-0.7828338742256165,
-1.221989393234253,
0.3353486955165863,
-0.014658881351351738,
-0.6306999325752258,
-0.2497260868549347,
-0.17131492495536804,
-0.2649707496166229,
0.10387483239173889,
-0.6646345853805542,
0.5009306073188782,
-0.5597795844078064,
0.021501753479242325,
-0.24812619388103485,
-0.267343670129776,
0.6145275831222534,
-0.600827157497406,
0.5691314339637756,
-0.050667885690927505,
-0.1292225420475006,
0.9689348936080933,
-0.31355026364326477,
0.5533819794654846,
0.004015842918306589,
-0.5453190207481384,
0.3899761438369751,
-0.015442837961018085,
0.1238785833120346,
-0.0821068286895752,
-0.2704869210720062,
0.2275063693523407,
-0.00655746553093195,
-0.1104225367307663,
-0.8553381562232971,
0.7190796136856079,
-0.9973180890083313,
-0.5764333009719849,
-0.7387961149215698,
-0.3327334523200989,
-0.06357306241989136,
0.42649972438812256,
0.10312118381261826,
0.5489256381988525,
-0.0299979317933321,
0.42323121428489685,
0.6524561047554016,
-0.07619739323854446,
0.18917429447174072,
0.7972913384437561,
-0.6598800420761108,
-0.49597641825675964,
0.8439559936523438,
0.4873296618461609,
-0.13777723908424377,
0.5634151101112366,
0.3825143873691559,
-0.4996866285800934,
-0.855177104473114,
-0.011429362930357456,
0.37007227540016174,
-0.7701035737991333,
-0.31113746762275696,
-0.5178029537200928,
-0.4687381982803345,
-0.46278077363967896,
0.14535540342330933,
0.07255159318447113,
-0.34941256046295166,
-0.6147016286849976,
0.2514532506465912,
0.16161438822746277,
0.8700865507125854,
0.04978477582335472,
0.21476200222969055,
-0.9348205924034119,
0.07363683730363846,
0.26879000663757324,
0.2702969014644623,
-0.12743569910526276,
-0.6560262441635132,
-0.2197169065475464,
0.07857707142829895,
-0.33259662985801697,
-0.49507349729537964,
0.38369739055633545,
0.009039985947310925,
0.7297719717025757,
0.4568106532096863,
0.09265495091676712,
0.24756662547588348,
-0.5493412613868713,
0.3665538728237152,
0.19670023024082184,
-0.7920387387275696,
0.31323617696762085,
-0.4521999955177307,
-0.10686962306499481,
0.25761687755584717,
0.7795009016990662,
-0.3543834686279297,
-0.22439944744110107,
-0.5998944640159607,
-0.42092129588127136,
0.6266893148422241,
0.23906098306179047,
0.1875772923231125,
0.19174359738826752,
0.4195500612258911,
0.014964289963245392,
0.3642773926258087,
-0.37459924817085266,
-0.15251335501670837,
0.30545559525489807,
-0.326761931180954,
-0.36611950397491455,
-0.019344452768564224,
-0.12560148537158966,
-0.24387575685977936,
0.417728990316391,
-0.03550465777516365,
0.4849214553833008,
0.008422364480793476,
-0.13033346831798553,
-0.11181862652301788,
0.1804032027721405,
0.8289186954498291,
0.9985128045082092,
-0.19359533488750458,
0.149813711643219,
-0.10779798030853271,
-0.4921359419822693,
0.05169586092233658,
0.25855711102485657,
-0.09815283864736557,
0.13932572305202484,
0.31782975792884827,
0.3524693250656128,
0.20640239119529724,
-0.6667159795761108,
0.29373255372047424,
-0.1453472524881363,
-0.4964974820613861,
-0.5306296944618225,
0.14695575833320618,
0.01774643547832966,
0.14799511432647705,
0.3274988532066345,
0.09349974989891052,
0.15557855367660522,
-0.544772744178772,
0.07185467332601547,
0.434336394071579,
0.22262488305568695,
-0.29596227407455444,
0.21831099689006805,
0.15946312248706818,
-0.6022578477859497,
0.5421002507209778,
-0.18481957912445068,
-0.7762431502342224,
0.45131048560142517,
0.32833048701286316,
0.8338728547096252,
-0.1359577178955078,
0.10873357206583023,
0.12697413563728333,
-0.034626804292201996,
-0.37688514590263367,
-0.19901444017887115,
-0.07262887060642242,
-0.8016431331634521,
-0.5254718065261841,
-0.796450138092041,
-0.883727490901947,
0.1236855611205101,
-0.4988814890384674,
0.520947277545929,
-0.5535832047462463,
-0.2775018811225891,
0.3519286513328552,
0.19713661074638367,
-0.5858944654464722,
0.008783560246229172,
0.368200421333313,
0.841269314289093,
-0.7528218626976013,
0.7982053160667419,
0.9447765946388245,
-0.15428130328655243,
-0.37768295407295227,
-0.2719156742095947,
0.04181070998311043,
-0.7177780866622925,
0.8632720112800598,
0.05990571901202202,
0.010221854783594608,
-0.14178426563739777,
-0.8850942254066467,
-0.8666249513626099,
0.9246423244476318,
0.21993237733840942,
-0.511576771736145,
-0.15756122767925262,
0.24810977280139923,
0.8809142708778381,
-0.19077199697494507,
0.3738463222980499,
-0.05387129262089729,
0.533501148223877,
0.35101795196533203,
-1.0757603645324707,
-0.5195363163948059,
-0.30696043372154236,
-0.11871539801359177,
0.27342307567596436,
-0.3898816406726837,
1.0818320512771606,
0.21684232354164124,
-0.26745977997779846,
0.3986872136592865,
0.74165278673172,
0.20618383586406708,
0.6002969741821289,
0.4256073236465454,
0.6713141798973083,
1.0681835412979126,
-0.2581677734851837,
0.8526405096054077,
-0.05557459220290184,
0.643074095249176,
0.7103855609893799,
-0.42805802822113037,
0.830312967300415,
0.009852924384176731,
-0.6068289875984192,
0.5003435015678406,
0.5904712080955505,
-0.252008855342865,
0.26384592056274414,
0.7229219675064087,
-0.1946479231119156,
-0.24984589219093323,
0.007421412039548159,
-0.5293077826499939,
0.22535370290279388,
0.6078698039054871,
-0.3227315843105316,
-0.5726765990257263,
0.10413086414337158,
0.11067903786897659,
0.19885782897472382,
-0.6211143732070923,
0.4383101463317871,
0.16556350886821747,
-0.6285299062728882,
0.3772719204425812,
0.19289231300354004,
0.6664330363273621,
-0.4868423044681549,
0.08779515326023102,
0.039663027971982956,
0.4578116834163666,
-0.1650182008743286,
-0.8821985721588135,
0.3106399178504944,
0.3490125238895416,
-0.16329115629196167,
-0.2567439079284668,
0.8891942501068115,
-0.2792113721370697,
-0.7881616950035095,
-0.07708807289600372,
0.5636250972747803,
0.5356476902961731,
-0.22232812643051147,
-0.5490802526473999,
0.11061134934425354,
-0.21977044641971588,
-0.09209862351417542,
0.6002892255783081,
0.6273247599601746,
-0.13469743728637695,
0.7668755650520325,
0.8501836061477661,
-0.16361059248447418,
-0.11270007491111755,
-0.06558854877948761,
0.8520985245704651,
-0.5456665754318237,
-0.45813700556755066,
-0.736518144607544,
0.048578739166259766,
0.015893856063485146,
-0.09082501381635666,
1.064010500907898,
0.7469149827957153,
0.7330079674720764,
-0.06446883082389832,
0.8496625423431396,
0.24871639907360077,
0.8147158026695251,
-0.5918046832084656,
0.7093156576156616,
-0.4016224145889282,
0.21925239264965057,
-0.28474634885787964,
-1.128801941871643,
-0.663330614566803,
0.5660595893859863,
-0.6647024154663086,
-0.08044436573982239,
0.6882391571998596,
0.3758271038532257,
0.04115506634116173,
0.18943214416503906,
0.24328549206256866,
-0.08467080444097519,
0.43408021330833435,
0.4008709192276001,
1.170507788658142,
-0.1054169088602066,
0.6482020616531372,
-0.019140632823109627,
-0.34046733379364014,
-0.31770363450050354,
-0.7817074656486511,
-1.1625813245773315,
-0.31627824902534485,
-0.43851909041404724,
-0.3941648602485657,
-0.11124452203512192,
0.923381507396698,
0.38764724135398865,
-0.7900109887123108,
-0.2525806128978729,
-0.005008753854781389,
0.18231339752674103,
0.3736034035682678,
-0.2040890008211136,
0.37578022480010986,
-0.2700183391571045,
-0.8800192475318909,
0.023170115426182747,
0.03777550905942917,
0.29942789673805237,
-0.34042420983314514,
-0.021043449640274048,
0.07110010087490082,
-0.09917847067117691,
0.7494743466377258,
0.38168808817863464,
-0.47885069251060486,
-0.017195317894220352,
0.22270846366882324,
-0.23316793143749237,
-0.14525756239891052,
0.8432118892669678,
-0.5028700828552246,
0.03966541588306427,
0.5701440572738647,
0.6950657963752747,
0.22949466109275818,
-0.04343004152178764,
0.37493735551834106,
-0.1952570527791977,
-0.21713392436504364,
0.3211521506309509,
0.4679044783115387,
0.04732752963900566,
-0.04040060564875603,
0.6011567115783691,
0.4243706166744232,
-0.8150091171264648,
-1.0146174430847168,
-0.11308462917804718,
-0.9574151039123535,
-0.18346916139125824,
1.2738869190216064,
-0.194315567612648,
-0.36215534806251526,
-0.049249317497015,
-0.41115519404411316,
0.045531194657087326,
-0.32958152890205383,
0.6358512043952942,
1.1409727334976196,
-0.1392737478017807,
0.06602969020605087,
-0.6202890276908875,
-0.030465103685855865,
-0.08102734386920929,
-1.073954701423645,
-0.1843491941690445,
0.5379863381385803,
0.11246678978204727,
0.7372204065322876,
0.3516736626625061,
-0.28035709261894226,
0.028750181198120117,
-0.5833755135536194,
-0.15762588381767273,
0.026976052671670914,
-0.4142317771911621,
-0.4808444678783417,
0.20332938432693481,
0.03943207859992981,
0.0985885038971901
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.07693v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.07693v2
|
A Labelled Dataset for Sentiment Analysis of Videos on YouTube, TikTok, and Other Sources about the 2024 Outbreak of Measles
| 2024-06-11T20:14:22 | 2024-06-16T21:10:55 |
Nirmalya Thakur, Vanessa Su, Mingchen Shao, Kesha A. Patel, Hongseok Jeong, Victoria Knieling, Andrew Bian
|
cs.CY
|
cs.CY, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SI, I.2.7; I.2.8; I.5.4; K.4.2; H.2.8; I.2.6
|
The work of this paper presents a dataset that contains the data of 4011
videos about the ongoing outbreak of measles published on 264 websites on the
internet between January 1, 2024, and May 31, 2024. The dataset is available at
https://dx.doi.org/10.21227/40s8-xf63. These websites primarily include YouTube
and TikTok, which account for 48.6% and 15.2% of the videos, respectively. The
remainder of the websites include Instagram and Facebook as well as the
websites of various global and local news organizations. For each of these
videos, the URL of the video, title of the post, description of the post, and
the date of publication of the video are presented as separate attributes in
the dataset. After developing this dataset, sentiment analysis (using VADER),
subjectivity analysis (using TextBlob), and fine-grain sentiment analysis
(using DistilRoBERTa-base) of the video titles and video descriptions were
performed. This included classifying each video title and video description
into (i) one of the sentiment classes i.e. positive, negative, or neutral, (ii)
one of the subjectivity classes i.e. highly opinionated, neutral opinionated,
or least opinionated, and (iii) one of the fine-grain sentiment classes i.e.
fear, surprise, joy, sadness, anger, disgust, or neutral. These results are
presented as separate attributes in the dataset for the training and testing of
machine learning algorithms for performing sentiment analysis or subjectivity
analysis in this field as well as for other applications. Finally, this paper
also presents a list of open research questions that may be investigated using
this dataset.
|
[
-0.4060976803302765,
-0.597314715385437,
0.005863290745764971,
0.19139915704727173,
-0.23586435616016388,
0.07637663930654526,
0.10348717123270035,
0.06324946135282516,
0.44810792803764343,
0.3351244628429413,
-0.5577468276023865,
-0.47310200333595276,
-0.6856939196586609,
0.16687655448913574,
-0.4268992245197296,
1.4452224969863892,
0.18867889046669006,
-0.09782133996486664,
-0.21471333503723145,
-0.07110093533992767,
0.07293292880058289,
-0.6371086835861206,
-0.26151537895202637,
0.02380572445690632,
0.5305176377296448,
0.6718247532844543,
0.46691277623176575,
0.48944130539894104,
0.7009527683258057,
0.2808760106563568,
0.013185457326471806,
-0.2868644595146179,
-0.4466806948184967,
-0.009460057131946087,
-0.35271134972572327,
-0.057674139738082886,
-0.6623936891555786,
0.31867891550064087,
0.3947761654853821,
0.43867745995521545,
0.08941897749900818,
0.6594215035438538,
0.1716291606426239,
0.43570995330810547,
-0.46919354796409607,
-0.13579604029655457,
-0.2842903137207031,
0.33319106698036194,
-0.1913197785615921,
-0.4300419092178345,
-0.22499333322048187,
-0.31006816029548645,
0.5408845543861389,
-0.36404791474342346,
0.30107447504997253,
-0.4838956296443939,
0.637279212474823,
0.2540189027786255,
-0.49700504541397095,
-0.31101658940315247,
-0.4872557520866394,
1.0843563079833984,
-0.6915609836578369,
0.11839314550161362,
0.22943389415740967,
0.13433533906936646,
-0.005557729862630367,
-0.4580792188644409,
-0.39308467507362366,
0.35356810688972473,
0.4987029731273651,
0.3335146903991699,
-0.6030722856521606,
-0.1988147646188736,
0.1110026016831398,
0.5132331252098083,
-0.8147106766700745,
-0.1640167087316513,
-0.6430727243423462,
-0.15903879702091217,
0.4730493426322937,
0.08334367722272873,
0.20015612244606018,
-0.568821907043457,
-0.39561039209365845,
-0.1844041645526886,
-0.3712780773639679,
0.7233088612556458,
0.35601890087127686,
0.32878491282463074,
-0.3778873383998871,
0.7645940184593201,
-0.42378124594688416,
0.7787116169929504,
-0.08532359451055527,
-0.6980062127113342,
0.8327078223228455,
-0.20496158301830292,
-0.4789558947086334,
0.27572202682495117,
0.7439037561416626,
0.8260301351547241,
0.3916865885257721,
0.33439475297927856,
0.2086990475654602,
0.27173474431037903,
0.3948765695095062,
-1.0261863470077515,
-0.49716827273368835,
0.384029746055603,
-0.7335692048072815,
-0.6616998314857483,
0.22818048298358917,
-1.2318507432937622,
-0.41870132088661194,
-0.37247583270072937,
0.21125881373882294,
0.029116693884134293,
-0.40597692131996155,
-0.07276410609483719,
-0.2737570106983185,
-0.020381705835461617,
-0.03678217902779579,
-0.5640914440155029,
0.03326333314180374,
0.5999569296836853,
0.6583763957023621,
0.04461146518588066,
0.014596991240978241,
-0.5892210006713867,
-0.0061719585210084915,
0.07284459471702576,
0.7703256607055664,
-0.7929614782333374,
-0.1886400431394577,
0.18674102425575256,
0.18772664666175842,
0.26181530952453613,
-0.3351714313030243,
0.44210052490234375,
-0.27325165271759033,
0.06025317311286926,
-0.25421759486198425,
-0.5353261828422546,
-0.45210596919059753,
0.46001294255256653,
-0.61588454246521,
0.49904531240463257,
-0.026600133627653122,
-0.6404334902763367,
0.2779141962528229,
-0.5809433460235596,
-0.27593278884887695,
-0.36742255091667175,
-0.08424483239650726,
-0.5212824940681458,
-0.14498808979988098,
0.13697774708271027,
0.7953773140907288,
-0.15090948343276978,
0.36039942502975464,
-0.654973030090332,
0.1309494823217392,
0.4281844198703766,
-0.2430345118045807,
0.8380821347236633,
0.3228274881839752,
-0.25654393434524536,
-0.2474222481250763,
-0.6274858713150024,
-0.10274731367826462,
-0.2233993411064148,
-0.13008876144886017,
-0.19203704595565796,
0.052466414868831635,
-0.0840490534901619,
0.3818601667881012,
0.11622694879770279,
-0.7510316371917725,
0.15596438944339752,
-0.25751811265945435,
0.3176054060459137,
0.8640539050102234,
0.47699466347694397,
0.19730177521705627,
-0.08083199709653854,
0.8038860559463501,
0.4451872408390045,
0.761239230632782,
0.039280716329813004,
-0.7834078073501587,
-0.42932021617889404,
-0.09317492693662643,
-0.03566938266158104,
0.5224429965019226,
-0.6948286890983582,
0.33619844913482666,
-0.3970227539539337,
-0.5406889319419861,
-0.22467252612113953,
0.11297058314085007,
0.3606899082660675,
0.9298195242881775,
0.48200201988220215,
-0.06740366667509079,
-0.7837685346603394,
-0.9212052226066589,
0.03458184003829956,
-0.22472664713859558,
0.23012696206569672,
0.09869936108589172,
0.43440985679626465,
-0.06187637522816658,
0.8826878070831299,
-0.5342721939086914,
-0.17751763761043549,
0.21830274164676666,
0.45826905965805054,
0.41792234778404236,
0.27493664622306824,
0.6544449925422668,
-1.048980474472046,
-0.37583938241004944,
0.009985812939703465,
-1.0408681631088257,
-0.12413190305233002,
0.38181072473526,
0.30028825998306274,
-0.23186853528022766,
0.11721618473529816,
0.3435695469379425,
0.3864947557449341,
0.9118244051933289,
-0.3887624740600586,
0.27636197209358215,
0.46112850308418274,
0.5074581503868103,
-1.120249629020691,
-0.14452886581420898,
0.504433274269104,
0.1032254695892334,
-0.8016061782836914,
-0.6290091872215271,
-0.35116633772850037,
-0.012480982579290867,
-0.6988662481307983,
0.3640097379684448,
0.289314329624176,
0.12125823646783829,
0.06194750592112541,
-0.0950993224978447,
-0.09209613502025604,
0.25369927287101746,
-0.2991790473461151,
0.5840412974357605,
0.7770045399665833,
-0.6606223583221436,
0.6111224889755249,
0.2997506856918335,
0.038544025272130966,
0.6673868894577026,
-0.3179419934749603,
-0.4516702890396118,
-0.11609512567520142,
-0.0968024805188179,
-0.79554283618927,
-0.42632564902305603,
0.47621452808380127,
-0.7724329829216003,
-0.07909286767244339,
-0.0753176361322403,
-0.08318637311458588,
-0.7261902689933777,
-0.6294469237327576,
0.4117424786090851,
0.2806655466556549,
-0.41643232107162476,
0.276358038187027,
0.7872595191001892,
-0.4337581992149353,
-0.8744928240776062,
-0.3759072721004486,
0.04164702445268631,
-0.6057705879211426,
-0.44802987575531006,
-0.2233056277036667,
-0.07893799990415573,
-0.4443546235561371,
0.3042137622833252,
-0.1436692476272583,
-0.22051207721233368,
-0.003743778681382537,
0.5147944688796997,
-0.05619866028428078,
0.001764977816492319,
0.1603640764951706,
-0.09958861768245697,
-0.045660555362701416,
0.07212773710489273,
-0.17319266498088837,
0.16494712233543396,
-0.2643890380859375,
0.0504450649023056,
-0.4382617473602295,
0.2882981300354004,
0.1292378157377243,
-0.24986551702022552,
0.12692847847938538,
0.48108920454978943,
-0.2681106925010681,
-0.12959501147270203,
-0.21627715229988098,
-0.09591522812843323,
-0.4334752559661865,
0.21538259088993073,
-0.25321003794670105,
-0.7548917531967163,
0.3101534843444824,
0.0987386405467987,
-0.15841452777385712,
0.4274298846721649,
0.6578977704048157,
-0.5354183912277222,
0.734431266784668,
0.4291609227657318,
-0.44779571890830994,
0.4526084363460541,
-0.5234851837158203,
0.12404301017522812,
-0.4203028082847595,
-0.2547580897808075,
-0.35889577865600586,
-0.4989160895347595,
-0.7147048711776733,
-0.2855290174484253,
0.40913790464401245,
-0.5150793194770813,
-0.40891650319099426,
-0.0250784270465374,
-0.5613585710525513,
0.28020185232162476,
0.5951151251792908,
0.2368524670600891,
0.05571567639708519,
0.41118481755256653,
0.20388643443584442,
-0.23055364191532135,
-0.4138508439064026,
-0.5706112384796143,
1.3731640577316284,
0.21750687062740326,
0.5722612142562866,
0.2596779763698578,
0.5903723835945129,
0.9193318486213684,
0.4616592526435852,
-0.7247806191444397,
0.44360342621803284,
-0.8497856259346008,
-0.5854064226150513,
-0.1282392144203186,
-0.22157275676727295,
-1.0647846460342407,
-0.4630976915359497,
-0.05840566009283066,
-0.7398518919944763,
0.18378613889217377,
0.11414795368909836,
-0.11965546756982803,
0.3048778176307678,
-0.47177138924598694,
0.7529217004776001,
-0.08836669474840164,
-0.31083908677101135,
-0.104239322245121,
-0.8569514751434326,
0.38555222749710083,
-0.015052583068609238,
0.2463178187608719,
-0.2059621512889862,
0.2767210006713867,
1.1358699798583984,
-0.5013570785522461,
0.8273108601570129,
-0.34353891015052795,
0.04110552743077278,
0.6562058329582214,
-0.41459208726882935,
-0.1909351944923401,
-0.16471894085407257,
-0.18397164344787598,
-0.10714375227689743,
-0.09057534486055374,
-0.42840129137039185,
-0.3074836730957031,
0.7660508751869202,
-0.8170899152755737,
-0.23962680995464325,
-0.638855516910553,
-0.24122874438762665,
-0.1307877153158188,
-0.027217157185077667,
0.062980517745018,
0.9499068856239319,
-0.16260963678359985,
0.5242440104484558,
0.7296803593635559,
-0.23813791573047638,
0.3998371362686157,
0.1665562391281128,
-0.09076588600873947,
-0.7595279812812805,
1.261731505393982,
0.2681196331977844,
-0.06491167098283768,
0.33804553747177124,
0.3465864062309265,
-0.21828018128871918,
-0.13637062907218933,
-0.17364786565303802,
-0.010130937211215496,
-0.5795783400535583,
-0.5317692756652832,
-0.39333656430244446,
-0.0028513127472251654,
-0.5048702359199524,
0.0990523025393486,
0.0018609316321089864,
-0.20087063312530518,
-0.3307333290576935,
-0.43214020133018494,
0.7840887308120728,
0.8363541960716248,
-0.09590529650449753,
0.5296575427055359,
-0.7109777927398682,
0.40463873744010925,
0.393534392118454,
0.41505876183509827,
-0.2898556590080261,
-0.4432251751422882,
-0.16935975849628448,
0.14854751527309418,
-0.6566771864891052,
-1.1326042413711548,
0.30328699946403503,
0.15615350008010864,
0.29494407773017883,
0.9588481187820435,
-0.021438905969262123,
0.7048600316047668,
-0.04427127540111542,
0.943855345249176,
0.22485628724098206,
-0.6692432165145874,
0.6624056100845337,
-0.6793004274368286,
-0.10153934359550476,
0.40786296129226685,
0.6630141139030457,
-0.31156447529792786,
-0.4352034628391266,
-0.890103816986084,
-0.4655248820781708,
0.5357810258865356,
0.03845210373401642,
-0.10868947952985764,
-0.08347932994365692,
0.1419183909893036,
0.16997259855270386,
0.4050954282283783,
-0.5765064358711243,
-0.599007248878479,
-0.5100589394569397,
-0.36948272585868835,
-0.46759504079818726,
-0.4357926845550537,
-0.20376555621623993,
-0.4100531339645386,
0.8503710627555847,
-0.0102144880220294,
-0.08056866377592087,
0.06055889651179314,
0.05494705215096474,
-0.14089177548885345,
0.10460711270570755,
0.16581737995147705,
0.49612662196159363,
-0.6027340888977051,
0.38997265696525574,
-0.5065231919288635,
-0.7114425301551819,
0.4343131482601166,
-0.06565935164690018,
-0.08877891302108765,
-0.13411107659339905,
0.13943417370319366,
0.2939668595790863,
0.07050871849060059,
-0.6374550461769104,
0.7066943049430847,
0.26771116256713867,
-0.26531684398651123,
-0.2986280024051666,
-0.26224517822265625,
-0.3496797978878021,
0.34667763113975525,
0.4046904742717743,
-0.0966113805770874,
0.6382559537887573,
-0.41186630725860596,
0.6515016555786133,
0.21735171973705292,
-0.40739718079566956,
-0.6452977061271667,
0.3249775767326355,
0.15891437232494354,
0.2192937135696411,
0.3045497536659241,
-0.10002199560403824,
-0.35831400752067566,
0.832856297492981,
0.15922249853610992,
0.7199220061302185,
-0.6919652223587036,
0.7858533263206482,
0.5057797431945801,
0.1919485181570053,
0.26585614681243896,
0.6760428547859192,
0.3633258640766144,
-0.5054599642753601,
-0.205581933259964,
-0.6633172035217285,
-0.3843514919281006,
0.4423074424266815,
-0.8957783579826355,
0.23302051424980164,
-0.3376522660255432,
-0.4143369197845459,
0.42425379157066345,
0.09858071804046631,
-0.5767391324043274,
0.88868248462677,
0.1739594042301178,
0.647301971912384,
-1.3796929121017456,
0.5560342669487,
0.9859834909439087,
-0.46941646933555603,
-0.5442640781402588,
-0.2489989697933197,
0.3665817975997925,
-0.39889609813690186,
0.2956029772758484,
0.2227076143026352,
0.08536159992218018,
-0.15854255855083466,
-0.6719666123390198,
-0.7397032380104065,
0.9303368330001831,
-0.09089487046003342,
0.056034497916698456,
0.5387192368507385,
0.3669045865535736,
0.5881944894790649,
-0.4405316412448883,
-0.20983083546161652,
0.6071955561637878,
0.45549842715263367,
0.007661476265639067,
-0.43792444467544556,
-0.3581244647502899,
-0.6689715385437012,
-0.5979738235473633,
0.0983595997095108,
-0.5915562510490417,
0.930945634841919,
0.24580825865268707,
0.26544398069381714,
-0.24287137389183044,
0.4929499626159668,
0.048088736832141876,
0.7707632780075073,
0.45086345076560974,
0.7385619282722473,
0.6640890836715698,
-0.07052945345640182,
0.7732712030410767,
0.11013633757829666,
0.36991435289382935,
0.9884535670280457,
0.15492524206638336,
0.8863164782524109,
0.7131878137588501,
-0.3301311433315277,
0.5142236351966858,
0.8261411786079407,
-0.40086984634399414,
0.7018184661865234,
0.051484618335962296,
-0.22403350472450256,
-0.05281373858451843,
-0.5123782753944397,
-0.4738789498806,
0.5465458631515503,
0.48060342669487,
-0.4724505543708801,
-0.31155189871788025,
0.5057336091995239,
0.19845172762870789,
-0.05285990238189697,
-0.6688807606697083,
0.8757206797599792,
-0.2247743308544159,
-0.40636420249938965,
0.22524546086788177,
-0.31404367089271545,
0.16906310617923737,
-0.2624952793121338,
0.05213378742337227,
-0.1148206889629364,
0.32673853635787964,
-0.5742521286010742,
-1.1035405397415161,
0.2892952561378479,
0.5370652675628662,
-0.3657885491847992,
-0.09496941417455673,
0.4349915385246277,
-0.16707965731620789,
-0.6492884755134583,
0.08476164191961288,
0.5896634459495544,
0.4478897452354431,
0.10225207358598709,
-0.7118516564369202,
-0.042528871446847916,
0.2502186596393585,
-0.3464588224887848,
0.16242560744285583,
0.4820083975791931,
-0.1471317708492279,
0.5388287305831909,
0.3699885308742523,
0.0408458486199379,
0.2376486212015152,
0.11676212400197983,
1.0260587930679321,
-0.7267315983772278,
-0.32342660427093506,
-0.8400447368621826,
0.6732913851737976,
-0.23505336046218872,
-0.18449252843856812,
0.9642013311386108,
0.8313291072845459,
0.5357799530029297,
-0.16125279664993286,
1.0552647113800049,
-0.32324862480163574,
0.5356142520904541,
-0.09729056805372238,
0.05618789419531822,
-0.6864613890647888,
-0.20840342342853546,
-0.44517606496810913,
-0.5233672261238098,
-0.3200436532497406,
0.2645259499549866,
-0.3806391954421997,
-0.2718445658683777,
0.31850141286849976,
0.5281325578689575,
-0.031583961099386215,
0.1487247198820114,
-0.11738914251327515,
0.5113940238952637,
0.47983449697494507,
0.19031023979187012,
0.6809132099151611,
-0.30452045798301697,
0.5083106160163879,
-0.7798437476158142,
-0.6531088948249817,
-0.4498116075992584,
-0.9289277791976929,
-0.8964114189147949,
-0.655523955821991,
-0.37566372752189636,
-0.47432172298431396,
0.11442479491233826,
0.765288770198822,
0.3502211570739746,
-1.1476131677627563,
-0.349682480096817,
0.3225357234477997,
0.008894771337509155,
-0.13128355145454407,
-0.2372262328863144,
0.38568809628486633,
-0.03485984355211258,
-0.7092142701148987,
0.004219315480440855,
0.30514588952064514,
-0.03970121219754219,
-0.06580927968025208,
0.2039915919303894,
-0.3461557626724243,
-0.135803684592247,
0.6737844347953796,
0.48287108540534973,
-0.5315900444984436,
-0.26462382078170776,
0.22426629066467285,
0.14888089895248413,
0.18959006667137146,
0.5120141506195068,
-0.6590187549591064,
0.7911289930343628,
0.4447789192199707,
0.2659793496131897,
0.2409520447254181,
0.6153653264045715,
0.17384672164916992,
-0.9136833548545837,
0.1893635243177414,
0.1053842231631279,
0.24216611683368683,
0.4205886423587799,
0.028149088844656944,
0.5927131772041321,
0.24305272102355957,
-0.46547815203666687,
-0.7338637709617615,
0.051285188645124435,
-1.3941822052001953,
0.06528963893651962,
1.097399115562439,
0.032843947410583496,
-0.19106732308864594,
-0.0932047888636589,
0.0616813562810421,
0.3520527780056,
-0.5953953862190247,
0.8295875191688538,
0.6273754239082336,
-0.2333521544933319,
0.12465330213308334,
-0.5528881549835205,
0.5583794116973877,
-0.04748791083693504,
-0.8953436613082886,
-0.2075723260641098,
0.44412147998809814,
0.1074797585606575,
0.12644754350185394,
0.28546810150146484,
-0.044786326587200165,
0.1906304806470871,
-0.2839258015155792,
0.12023172527551651,
0.19738225638866425,
-0.5535424947738647,
-0.4586741626262665,
0.34827321767807007,
-0.4290829598903656,
-0.39547252655029297
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.07692v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.07692v1
|
Transformer Models in Education: Summarizing Science Textbooks with AraBART, MT5, AraT5, and mBART
| 2024-06-11T20:14:09 | 2024-06-11T20:14:09 |
Sari Masri, Yaqeen Raddad, Fidaa Khandaqji, Huthaifa I. Ashqar, Mohammed Elhenawy
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.ET
|
Recently, with the rapid development in the fields of technology and the
increasing amount of text t available on the internet, it has become urgent to
develop effective tools for processing and understanding texts in a way that
summaries the content without losing the fundamental essence of the
information. Given this challenge, we have developed an advanced text
summarization system targeting Arabic textbooks. Relying on modern natu-ral
language processing models such as MT5, AraBART, AraT5, and mBART50, this
system evaluates and extracts the most important sentences found in biology
textbooks for the 11th and 12th grades in the Palestinian curriculum, which
enables students and teachers to obtain accurate and useful summaries that help
them easily understand the content. We utilized the Rouge metric to evaluate
the performance of the trained models. Moreover, experts in education Edu
textbook authoring assess the output of the trained models. This approach aims
to identify the best solutions and clarify areas needing improvement. This
research provides a solution for summarizing Arabic text. It enriches the field
by offering results that can open new horizons for research and development in
the technologies for understanding and generating the Arabic language.
Additionally, it contributes to the field with Arabic texts through creating
and compiling schoolbook texts and building a dataset.
|
[
-0.3448922634124756,
-0.44190844893455505,
0.18718495965003967,
-0.09865260124206543,
-0.246708482503891,
0.3727366626262665,
0.24246717989444733,
-0.11309526860713959,
0.10256654769182205,
0.5439209342002869,
-0.16546738147735596,
-0.4924308955669403,
-0.7681456804275513,
0.3220192492008209,
-0.7777577042579651,
1.273369312286377,
-0.006559484172612429,
0.09644081443548203,
-0.17809997498989105,
-0.10241343080997467,
-0.2897036671638489,
-0.23453140258789062,
-0.27842915058135986,
-0.5573188662528992,
0.21229085326194763,
0.48758789896965027,
0.7311661243438721,
0.5254355669021606,
0.6757071614265442,
0.39294886589050293,
-0.4887409508228302,
0.15577703714370728,
-0.1038597971200943,
0.015117759816348553,
-0.1909695267677307,
-0.338149756193161,
-0.7501196265220642,
-0.2382558137178421,
0.8445156216621399,
0.8122802376747131,
0.10060285031795502,
0.29305174946784973,
0.028555724769830704,
0.7190735936164856,
-0.5854489207267761,
0.019565114751458168,
0.1401546448469162,
0.19683067500591278,
0.3400851786136627,
0.016056867316365242,
-0.487563818693161,
-0.49239033460617065,
0.22307538986206055,
-0.2454633265733719,
0.45052558183670044,
-0.4697611629962921,
0.7201319932937622,
0.04184306785464287,
-0.7329867482185364,
-0.4001443684101105,
-0.7516218423843384,
0.5329958200454712,
-0.8034113645553589,
0.3422487676143646,
0.1276690512895584,
0.40103235840797424,
0.026280904188752174,
-1.0152946710586548,
-0.37228408455848694,
0.06104772910475731,
-0.37684541940689087,
0.5378850698471069,
-0.09707356244325638,
-0.08767113089561462,
-0.1596466451883316,
0.30599328875541687,
-0.4925309419631958,
-0.3145420551300049,
-0.8144034147262573,
-0.17791561782360077,
0.43105360865592957,
0.05387165769934654,
0.3586353361606598,
-0.12525056302547455,
-0.19479472935199738,
-0.4581356346607208,
-0.42623987793922424,
0.18977108597755432,
0.355561763048172,
0.10241887718439102,
-0.07984063029289246,
0.5404756665229797,
0.07336151599884033,
0.5497328042984009,
-0.4391631484031677,
-0.19033412635326385,
0.0009535886929370463,
-0.36454474925994873,
-0.11158943176269531,
0.23263804614543915,
0.5190207362174988,
0.40407031774520874,
0.23092547059059143,
-0.029728898778557777,
-0.14511148631572723,
-0.05460139736533165,
0.3553944230079651,
-1.2368665933609009,
-0.2535446286201477,
0.15133658051490784,
-0.4896220862865448,
-0.3718065023422241,
-0.033989422023296356,
-0.8703404664993286,
0.006830336060374975,
-0.21060840785503387,
0.3363565504550934,
-0.43875929713249207,
-0.17384479939937592,
0.056385040283203125,
-0.11304617673158646,
-0.15215012431144714,
0.206406369805336,
-0.7944050431251526,
0.4011542797088623,
0.24888350069522858,
1.0189541578292847,
-0.07909266650676727,
-0.13191168010234833,
0.085422083735466,
0.23386837542057037,
-0.19708283245563507,
0.8448016047477722,
-0.649737536907196,
-0.8335952162742615,
0.06929300725460052,
-0.05682236701250076,
0.18074287474155426,
-0.3335306644439697,
0.6573780179023743,
-0.5767958164215088,
0.3516516089439392,
0.00442034425213933,
-0.5999460220336914,
-0.6237664222717285,
0.016174111515283585,
-0.6325180530548096,
0.8990957736968994,
-0.07243843376636505,
-0.47401493787765503,
-0.24396780133247375,
-0.7559980750083923,
-0.4683365225791931,
-0.06986553221940994,
0.13852545619010925,
-0.6870012879371643,
-0.034161824733018875,
0.39210665225982666,
0.5311802625656128,
-0.1770199090242386,
0.511494517326355,
0.5239195227622986,
-0.22184813022613525,
0.2435671091079712,
-0.28333359956741333,
0.6248232126235962,
0.049945469945669174,
-0.19368450343608856,
0.2854895293712616,
-0.7611995339393616,
-0.09279973804950714,
-0.11228703707456589,
-0.28683042526245117,
-0.20945478975772858,
0.028656627982854843,
0.3816767930984497,
-0.10794039070606232,
0.1211482435464859,
-0.28598499298095703,
0.3864265978336334,
-0.3370809257030487,
0.33484625816345215,
0.49051913619041443,
-0.13423751294612885,
0.480896532535553,
-0.2845269441604614,
0.5725043416023254,
0.004121761303395033,
-0.08733135461807251,
-0.8643708825111389,
-0.33280622959136963,
-0.5509353280067444,
-0.14587810635566711,
0.3508741855621338,
0.2224549949169159,
-0.6080486178398132,
0.17440997064113617,
-0.39050817489624023,
-0.9878208041191101,
-0.3818039298057556,
-0.2793387770652771,
0.43732571601867676,
0.6582193374633789,
0.7181755304336548,
-0.17478011548519135,
-0.2886981964111328,
-0.9472467303276062,
-0.3341106176376343,
0.17740413546562195,
0.020511096343398094,
0.03197251260280609,
0.8398503065109253,
-0.2172572910785675,
1.0526142120361328,
-0.7898989319801331,
-0.0227058082818985,
-0.5617430806159973,
0.13407331705093384,
0.3209802210330963,
0.40997013449668884,
0.6248916387557983,
-1.0994871854782104,
-0.445155531167984,
0.020739004015922546,
-0.571754515171051,
-0.07182881236076355,
0.22764302790164948,
-0.048139508813619614,
0.06817353516817093,
0.3656957149505615,
-0.40908360481262207,
0.5202627778053284,
0.3149717152118683,
-0.6717471480369568,
0.5723207592964172,
-0.16753612458705902,
0.28535714745521545,
-1.1940232515335083,
0.17675204575061798,
-0.07221993058919907,
-0.26427558064460754,
-0.7629876732826233,
-0.06112322956323624,
0.31989815831184387,
-0.15128183364868164,
-0.30552780628204346,
0.5533057451248169,
-0.23228247463703156,
0.08871959894895554,
-0.5774513483047485,
0.05186120420694351,
0.09107524901628494,
0.18341362476348877,
0.14524002373218536,
0.7526869177818298,
0.19134391844272614,
-0.647593080997467,
0.26466917991638184,
0.440843403339386,
-0.12290184944868088,
0.10390153527259827,
-0.810506284236908,
-0.4048149883747101,
-0.19820918142795563,
0.5397212505340576,
-0.7853396534919739,
-0.41949760913848877,
0.13231398165225983,
-0.5137396454811096,
0.2853834629058838,
0.24191856384277344,
-0.2497703731060028,
-0.20442266762256622,
-0.21024449169635773,
0.4908837378025055,
0.7295523881912231,
-0.35557082295417786,
1.02992582321167,
0.15400026738643646,
-0.41430336236953735,
-0.8374685049057007,
-0.3738272786140442,
-0.05765597149729729,
0.008176535367965698,
-0.1653546392917633,
0.5043221116065979,
0.037515975534915924,
0.04101473465561867,
0.347060889005661,
-0.32556793093681335,
-0.06140151619911194,
0.02321562170982361,
0.18143771588802338,
0.45224669575691223,
-0.1258169263601303,
0.24279175698757172,
0.5381041765213013,
-0.2273489385843277,
0.11640734225511551,
-0.253383606672287,
0.41948217153549194,
-0.08863551169633865,
-0.06236103177070618,
-0.18170425295829773,
0.2668546438217163,
0.7568166255950928,
-0.173801988363266,
0.8573214411735535,
0.5292457938194275,
-0.4885178804397583,
-0.19612136483192444,
-0.17565582692623138,
-0.49171480536460876,
-0.45436978340148926,
0.6844919919967651,
-0.042824845761060715,
-0.38005876541137695,
0.37507548928260803,
-0.31496694684028625,
0.3030063211917877,
0.541331946849823,
0.6144819259643555,
0.14576755464076996,
0.6559814214706421,
0.8865217566490173,
-0.01583394780755043,
0.1832817941904068,
-0.4479904770851135,
0.3409438729286194,
-0.6460578441619873,
-0.47950664162635803,
-0.5834702253341675,
-0.31627151370048523,
-0.4759063124656677,
-0.085991270840168,
0.5556702613830566,
-0.029505770653486252,
-0.2110130339860916,
0.42512673139572144,
-0.8514261245727539,
0.7300942540168762,
0.5417813658714294,
0.058003466576337814,
0.43388980627059937,
0.22944745421409607,
-0.19054292142391205,
0.12330517172813416,
-0.6405194997787476,
-1.1118847131729126,
1.1120091676712036,
0.12073449790477753,
0.3627591133117676,
0.4281298816204071,
0.3890041410923004,
0.3486919105052948,
0.6512024402618408,
-0.6608068943023682,
0.6004523038864136,
-0.031115205958485603,
-0.5339718461036682,
-0.13383804261684418,
-0.09965313971042633,
-0.7134992480278015,
0.4211457073688507,
-0.04399266466498375,
-0.4804488718509674,
-0.027384042739868164,
-0.006794213317334652,
-0.18102890253067017,
0.3963770270347595,
-0.412654310464859,
0.540983259677887,
0.13563089072704315,
-0.25953900814056396,
-0.19069544970989227,
-0.8856898546218872,
0.1599166989326477,
-0.04825085029006004,
0.4626217186450958,
0.15746818482875824,
-0.0004357149882707745,
1.0276479721069336,
-0.22473764419555664,
0.80564945936203,
0.11229443550109863,
-0.049435701221227646,
0.4070722162723541,
0.08576546609401703,
0.0023706478532403708,
-0.19944919645786285,
0.03427578881382942,
-0.037856344133615494,
0.13130754232406616,
-0.3734179139137268,
-0.4902029037475586,
0.4195055663585663,
-0.998885452747345,
-0.40740498900413513,
-0.7104794383049011,
-0.7190890312194824,
0.269399493932724,
0.1951279640197754,
0.1897384524345398,
0.5982301235198975,
0.01731662079691887,
0.09958171099424362,
0.41719165444374084,
-0.32084959745407104,
0.7641161680221558,
0.6976650953292847,
-0.4655468463897705,
-0.5799012780189514,
0.9699825048446655,
0.3383632302284241,
0.17329832911491394,
0.3815976679325104,
0.23384931683540344,
-0.12849804759025574,
-0.35066351294517517,
-0.4804314076900482,
0.20206685364246368,
-1.0074818134307861,
-0.5156228542327881,
-0.8599334955215454,
-0.611153781414032,
-0.49854370951652527,
-0.48627594113349915,
-0.22099246084690094,
-0.5053738951683044,
-0.2484104037284851,
-0.19878356158733368,
0.29945242404937744,
1.0871310234069824,
0.04270459711551666,
0.6968333125114441,
-1.1602221727371216,
0.15034565329551697,
0.04922385886311531,
-0.10573698580265045,
0.200880765914917,
-0.7416649460792542,
-0.480478972196579,
-0.05431115999817848,
-0.8963636159896851,
-1.142846941947937,
0.7610774636268616,
0.26996392011642456,
-0.012098364531993866,
0.20178678631782532,
-0.11178839951753616,
0.08262426406145096,
-0.6322968602180481,
0.8546352386474609,
0.038674335926771164,
-1.0166105031967163,
0.5927073359489441,
-0.1325787901878357,
0.4173969626426697,
-0.13580575585365295,
0.6597747206687927,
-0.4881696105003357,
-0.3287607729434967,
-0.6792750358581543,
-1.0882123708724976,
0.7122718095779419,
0.48957309126853943,
0.15126603841781616,
0.44281744956970215,
0.350502610206604,
0.32145023345947266,
0.2707495093345642,
-0.6471363306045532,
-0.5534600019454956,
-0.5162832736968994,
-0.8018163442611694,
-0.21981486678123474,
-0.3442692756652832,
0.006047472357749939,
-0.324399471282959,
1.0506346225738525,
0.013975671492516994,
-0.023176033049821854,
0.1518266201019287,
-0.10679978132247925,
0.19507962465286255,
0.4344181716442108,
0.7557093501091003,
0.6041256785392761,
-0.07944799959659576,
0.16753223538398743,
0.11265717446804047,
-1.1634776592254639,
0.43992674350738525,
0.13022147119045258,
-0.38666728138923645,
0.26781415939331055,
0.6874772906303406,
0.2991010844707489,
0.19343778491020203,
-0.6828565001487732,
0.28035232424736023,
0.009721517562866211,
0.04247734323143959,
-0.1315276175737381,
0.1206977367401123,
0.19618476927280426,
0.328441321849823,
0.6836109757423401,
0.23021945357322693,
0.4203982949256897,
-0.21372483670711517,
0.08101280778646469,
-0.02819439396262169,
-0.09366440027952194,
-0.620303213596344,
0.5534763932228088,
0.17861852049827576,
-0.48059049248695374,
0.30393508076667786,
0.18567192554473877,
-0.7362363338470459,
1.0782403945922852,
0.9232364892959595,
0.5555896759033203,
-0.671856701374054,
0.5269784927368164,
0.5903379917144775,
0.2210441529750824,
0.0693468526005745,
0.0712772011756897,
-0.04439038783311844,
-0.6222090125083923,
-0.2235105335712433,
-0.6647602319717407,
-0.7430683970451355,
-0.14391127228736877,
-0.5261471271514893,
0.26455754041671753,
-0.03605979308485985,
-0.0807655081152916,
0.09686553478240967,
-0.31280064582824707,
-0.3977954387664795,
0.45430788397789,
-0.3802797198295593,
0.6669735908508301,
-1.03609299659729,
0.37265148758888245,
1.0509976148605347,
-0.40283337235450745,
-0.5685977935791016,
-0.4216906428337097,
-0.24649690091609955,
-0.21492472290992737,
0.7787680625915527,
0.20331181585788727,
-0.25638970732688904,
0.3338736593723297,
-0.47224706411361694,
-0.866915225982666,
1.2083467245101929,
0.11522480845451355,
-0.4413089454174042,
-0.11006012558937073,
0.2084062546491623,
0.5150793194770813,
-0.20213516056537628,
0.8033556342124939,
0.5379542708396912,
0.3212166130542755,
0.22790072858333588,
-0.5203023552894592,
-0.18474748730659485,
-0.5189687013626099,
-0.41001734137535095,
0.27167898416519165,
-0.507032036781311,
0.8450926542282104,
-0.13015536963939667,
-0.16991174221038818,
-0.08359616994857788,
0.7098298668861389,
0.028734710067510605,
0.38581594824790955,
-0.25411075353622437,
0.2631714642047882,
0.4201969504356384,
-0.19110849499702454,
0.841899037361145,
-0.42415767908096313,
0.4767187535762787,
0.9510115385055542,
0.2637626528739929,
0.5540792942047119,
0.23241649568080902,
-0.3860071003437042,
0.43820083141326904,
0.5815892219543457,
0.03202186897397041,
0.4724622368812561,
-0.08517857640981674,
-0.4980911910533905,
0.16302508115768433,
-0.3780239224433899,
-0.4974800944328308,
0.3977687358856201,
0.4858623445034027,
-0.4716339111328125,
-0.37277767062187195,
0.24639379978179932,
0.13814207911491394,
0.2206626981496811,
-0.37570425868034363,
0.646447479724884,
0.1484071910381317,
-0.5337371826171875,
0.20745019614696503,
0.22514605522155762,
0.11750370264053345,
-0.3756893277168274,
-0.20363399386405945,
-0.25539034605026245,
0.23477815091609955,
-0.3379252552986145,
-0.5450711250305176,
0.2216050922870636,
0.22958257794380188,
-0.20381277799606323,
-0.10736898332834244,
0.5979965925216675,
-0.49818700551986694,
-0.9115977883338928,
-0.06292149424552917,
0.37433579564094543,
0.1729087084531784,
0.5174195170402527,
-0.019918600097298622,
-0.13039527833461761,
-0.03223593533039093,
-0.3477817177772522,
-0.12775468826293945,
0.2150663584470749,
0.07152442634105682,
0.7435441613197327,
0.4191223382949829,
0.06902032345533371,
-0.2896978259086609,
-0.11314644664525986,
0.9333695769309998,
-0.6069861650466919,
-0.3976125717163086,
-1.1658228635787964,
0.7453641295433044,
-0.018768617883324623,
-0.15959526598453522,
0.5254401564598083,
0.635550856590271,
0.5543358325958252,
-0.31992441415786743,
0.9145720601081848,
0.2889464795589447,
0.28631776571273804,
-0.39141368865966797,
1.0152288675308228,
-0.21336598694324493,
0.01634763740003109,
-0.14694200456142426,
-1.0562705993652344,
-0.3157501816749573,
0.6083936095237732,
-0.015808556228876114,
0.16728439927101135,
0.9129530191421509,
0.29889893531799316,
-0.17731918394565582,
0.30723488330841064,
0.08454251289367676,
0.1788918823003769,
0.6248724460601807,
0.08347433060407639,
0.3706275224685669,
-0.7251393795013428,
0.2743956744670868,
-0.10633485019207001,
-0.20494160056114197,
-0.30373623967170715,
-0.6781730651855469,
-1.1098453998565674,
-0.7065398097038269,
-0.2810276448726654,
-0.08493825048208237,
0.061216145753860474,
0.8359650373458862,
0.15639476478099823,
-0.942655086517334,
-0.19893449544906616,
-0.1458236128091812,
0.20897330343723297,
-0.021412746980786324,
-0.17203488945960999,
0.9945390820503235,
-0.09263632446527481,
-0.8502179980278015,
0.059423770755529404,
0.1565036028623581,
0.5725609660148621,
-0.2127646803855896,
0.1765081286430359,
-0.11133760213851929,
0.23580943048000336,
0.5480790138244629,
-0.04745078831911087,
-0.5676332712173462,
0.0036664940416812897,
0.01554957590997219,
0.029676713049411774,
-0.11761312186717987,
0.6036413311958313,
-0.9972777962684631,
0.40719231963157654,
0.26007145643234253,
0.6744673848152161,
0.3998588025569916,
-0.021110132336616516,
0.5390734672546387,
-0.396451860666275,
-0.02530626766383648,
0.2924114167690277,
0.16354268789291382,
0.4337197542190552,
-0.0645703375339508,
0.5886711478233337,
0.08517948538064957,
-0.5381631255149841,
-0.7486472129821777,
0.10294359177350998,
-0.4236791431903839,
-0.256171852350235,
0.6047734618186951,
-0.158152237534523,
-0.1981143057346344,
0.1677253544330597,
-0.38819417357444763,
0.7431493997573853,
-0.2228124588727951,
0.935027003288269,
0.7646340727806091,
0.2441539466381073,
0.027502957731485367,
-0.5227904915809631,
0.31467729806900024,
0.40278807282447815,
-0.9315509796142578,
-0.3639572560787201,
0.19959919154644012,
-0.06642046570777893,
0.4100589156150818,
0.09995266050100327,
0.008397330529987812,
0.18792621791362762,
-0.18886218965053558,
0.32886582612991333,
-0.17671668529510498,
-0.5635301470756531,
-0.0017352590803056955,
0.36077529191970825,
-0.5032358169555664,
0.11275627464056015
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.09438v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.09438v1
|
Exploring Traffic Crash Narratives in Jordan Using Text Mining Analytics
| 2024-06-11T20:07:39 | 2024-06-11T20:07:39 |
Shadi Jaradat, Taqwa I. Alhadidi, Huthaifa I. Ashqar, Ahmed Hossain, Mohammed Elhenawy
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IR
|
This study explores traffic crash narratives in an attempt to inform and
enhance effective traffic safety policies using text-mining analytics. Text
mining techniques are employed to unravel key themes and trends within the
narratives, aiming to provide a deeper understanding of the factors
contributing to traffic crashes. This study collected crash data from five
major freeways in Jordan that cover narratives of 7,587 records from 2018-2022.
An unsupervised learning method was adopted to learn the pattern from crash
data. Various text mining techniques, such as topic modeling, keyword
extraction, and Word Co-Occurrence Network, were also used to reveal the
co-occurrence of crash patterns. Results show that text mining analytics is a
promising method and underscore the multifactorial nature of traffic crashes,
including intertwining human decisions and vehicular conditions. The recurrent
themes across all analyses highlight the need for a balanced approach to road
safety, merging both proactive and reactive measures. Emphasis on driver
education and awareness around animal-related incidents is paramount.
|
[
-0.4849611222743988,
-0.4905048608779907,
0.5457541942596436,
0.19365349411964417,
-0.24540431797504425,
0.2309064269065857,
0.3488970398902893,
-0.3448192775249481,
0.043605003505945206,
0.6704753041267395,
-0.6041229367256165,
-0.7446585893630981,
-0.32277101278305054,
-0.13941733539104462,
-0.4381195902824402,
1.1620304584503174,
-0.2802293002605438,
-0.025059884414076805,
-0.10619500279426575,
-0.2834348678588867,
-0.7941491603851318,
-0.6922342777252197,
-0.6648672223091125,
0.18466821312904358,
0.6746299862861633,
0.10082419216632843,
0.4371993839740753,
0.5532905459403992,
0.7468786835670471,
0.2638644278049469,
0.1298106610774994,
0.16492719948291779,
-0.297599196434021,
-0.17813675105571747,
-0.2076762318611145,
-0.34103795886039734,
-0.07310372591018677,
-0.009917198680341244,
0.6464380621910095,
0.913275957107544,
-0.3202461302280426,
-0.02819063700735569,
-0.11060430109500885,
0.6917778849601746,
-0.8502552509307861,
0.010558364912867546,
-0.45920538902282715,
0.15622326731681824,
-0.567613959312439,
-0.47230783104896545,
-0.017492279410362244,
-0.6592817902565002,
0.25713348388671875,
-0.030146421864628792,
0.12977401912212372,
0.16806426644325256,
0.46349626779556274,
0.23114968836307526,
-1.1699539422988892,
-0.8101457953453064,
-0.5651707649230957,
0.943301260471344,
-0.273586243391037,
0.21370908617973328,
0.1090419813990593,
0.1656321883201599,
-0.41698694229125977,
-0.43974393606185913,
-0.3971557021141052,
0.13704624772071838,
-0.16080206632614136,
0.14497675001621246,
0.20825839042663574,
0.04353330284357071,
-0.05401493236422539,
0.25457999110221863,
-0.6515354514122009,
-0.15557660162448883,
-0.4623413681983948,
-0.25044915080070496,
0.6726253032684326,
0.978670060634613,
0.5013886094093323,
0.0529579296708107,
-0.584912121295929,
-0.2733455002307892,
-0.5733888745307922,
0.5917807221412659,
0.5652757883071899,
0.2101517915725708,
-0.08755242824554443,
0.26369810104370117,
-0.08198494464159012,
0.3778143525123596,
-0.6427960395812988,
-0.6756024956703186,
0.392807275056839,
-0.585458517074585,
0.08361858129501343,
0.7691807746887207,
0.547020435333252,
0.8256326913833618,
0.5313061475753784,
-0.21120087802410126,
0.1373215764760971,
0.004521382972598076,
0.26082420349121094,
-0.8383243083953857,
-0.10694988816976547,
0.0409274660050869,
-0.787002444267273,
-0.48474302887916565,
0.4066934883594513,
-0.8329362869262695,
-0.4634250998497009,
-0.048591822385787964,
-0.20925232768058777,
-0.2978823482990265,
-0.6320672035217285,
0.34021827578544617,
-0.42550423741340637,
0.5080500841140747,
0.14633220434188843,
-0.590734601020813,
0.10767008364200592,
0.5797216892242432,
1.0484055280685425,
-0.14144517481327057,
-0.504309356212616,
-0.28795015811920166,
0.44770047068595886,
-0.4171222746372223,
0.8389056921005249,
-0.5027647614479065,
-0.6776118874549866,
0.44610169529914856,
0.002035029698163271,
-0.19563134014606476,
-0.29704537987709045,
0.8415818214416504,
-0.352249413728714,
-0.15863636136054993,
-0.17444774508476257,
-0.5012263655662537,
-0.8700385689735413,
0.28899043798446655,
-0.44313758611679077,
0.685693085193634,
-0.1767982393503189,
-0.915499746799469,
0.6134154200553894,
-0.7137039303779602,
-0.9599495530128479,
-0.2887672185897827,
-0.19582007825374603,
-0.6481678485870361,
0.33455875515937805,
0.11830351501703262,
0.3994190990924835,
-0.10419801622629166,
0.4332725703716278,
-0.0859336331486702,
-0.26025626063346863,
0.27275222539901733,
-0.3790341913700104,
0.8383498191833496,
-0.09434264898300171,
0.024198610335588455,
0.028793275356292725,
-0.6879199147224426,
-0.16118435561656952,
0.024906465783715248,
-0.4254949986934662,
-0.4634392559528351,
0.20762899518013,
0.23806099593639374,
0.17350167036056519,
-0.011258026584982872,
-0.5103226900100708,
-0.028439512476325035,
-0.4576074182987213,
-0.22403927147388458,
0.48547086119651794,
0.6931607127189636,
0.05304953083395958,
-0.5713276267051697,
0.3737938404083252,
0.46662119030952454,
-0.0845806747674942,
-0.37701529264450073,
-0.7194268703460693,
-0.6260213851928711,
0.38171106576919556,
0.08358244597911835,
0.5991747975349426,
-0.2759012281894684,
0.12877653539180756,
-0.13839370012283325,
-0.7120518088340759,
-0.22064130008220673,
-0.21581925451755524,
0.3243752121925354,
0.5886922478675842,
0.053617700934410095,
-0.6556816101074219,
-0.5085631012916565,
-0.5469228029251099,
-0.42968931794166565,
-0.34484246373176575,
0.45302334427833557,
0.32134461402893066,
0.4759332239627838,
-0.18600690364837646,
0.9443520903587341,
-0.7022503614425659,
-0.23168928921222687,
-0.18960578739643097,
0.4461504817008972,
-0.034761350601911545,
0.6355082392692566,
0.9726212620735168,
-0.9021029472351074,
-0.35114267468452454,
-0.16253891587257385,
-0.7415434718132019,
0.2804614305496216,
-0.3157455623149872,
-0.07954773306846619,
0.3437173366546631,
0.557033121585846,
-0.04808535426855087,
0.8816229701042175,
0.0975179597735405,
-0.6510692834854126,
0.40501049160957336,
0.07498341053724289,
0.47122922539711,
-0.6795223951339722,
-0.18556004762649536,
-0.006187472026795149,
-0.12185119837522507,
-0.7625788450241089,
-0.5102236270904541,
-0.3863677382469177,
0.1907329261302948,
-0.39539435505867004,
-0.17435809969902039,
-0.17912457883358002,
-0.07918190956115723,
-0.5394534468650818,
-0.2779841721057892,
-0.3216709792613983,
0.24087940156459808,
-0.007489364594221115,
0.5504881143569946,
0.5660074949264526,
-0.5353859663009644,
0.13308896124362946,
0.2545619308948517,
-0.6368535757064819,
0.2632860541343689,
-0.08626852929592133,
-0.1408357322216034,
-0.42022281885147095,
0.2367803305387497,
-0.9721735715866089,
-0.37774133682250977,
0.22909460961818695,
-0.21699343621730804,
-0.00008857624197844416,
-0.25058433413505554,
-0.5246437788009644,
-0.17244207859039307,
-0.4570080637931824,
0.14731833338737488,
0.3396094739437103,
-0.26571202278137207,
0.4590108096599579,
0.9979921579360962,
-0.3863276541233063,
-0.09635894745588303,
-0.5490004420280457,
0.2902527451515198,
-0.6241482496261597,
-0.7167357206344604,
0.062379371374845505,
-0.020789314061403275,
-0.31957852840423584,
-0.03853870555758476,
0.14157436788082123,
-0.3251092731952667,
0.5647295117378235,
0.5804446339607239,
0.25063595175743103,
-0.08432361483573914,
-0.03604372218251228,
-0.09596361964941025,
-0.29050788283348083,
0.5946381688117981,
0.14664605259895325,
0.4758390188217163,
0.02308349497616291,
0.006265161093324423,
-0.6293163299560547,
0.3897360563278198,
0.6142497658729553,
-0.169812873005867,
0.9458451271057129,
0.6982762217521667,
-0.2831626534461975,
0.3150659203529358,
-0.10488439351320267,
-0.010236441157758236,
-0.4529215693473816,
0.28114816546440125,
-0.35868698358535767,
-0.6281732320785522,
0.2364499270915985,
-0.6756410598754883,
0.01747708208858967,
0.388064980506897,
0.6103894114494324,
-0.34943705797195435,
1.1655938625335693,
0.5988646149635315,
-0.214553102850914,
0.3987717628479004,
0.1482200175523758,
0.3131103813648224,
-0.12690678238868713,
-0.659010648727417,
-0.34185463190078735,
-0.05259377136826515,
-0.9480491876602173,
0.052438877522945404,
0.4581790268421173,
-0.2340620905160904,
-0.2677164673805237,
-0.2739331126213074,
-0.25588494539260864,
0.594903290271759,
0.4549207389354706,
-0.3314255177974701,
0.2769569754600525,
0.1378922462463379,
0.05495789274573326,
-0.01262249331921339,
-0.4982947111129761,
-0.3587774634361267,
0.9589575529098511,
0.05378603935241699,
0.31215736269950867,
0.2911030352115631,
0.5184530019760132,
0.36114516854286194,
0.2521776854991913,
-0.24830836057662964,
0.4368031322956085,
0.08605234324932098,
-0.6583680510520935,
-0.06289435923099518,
-0.34257155656814575,
-1.1144345998764038,
-0.13123606145381927,
-0.32755300402641296,
-0.7847363948822021,
-0.11566270887851715,
-0.2883971333503723,
-0.22199946641921997,
0.3127541244029999,
-0.33830639719963074,
0.7880589962005615,
-0.4188884496688843,
0.10186593979597092,
-0.31256890296936035,
-0.8701699376106262,
0.5960193872451782,
-0.04167129471898079,
0.3981553614139557,
-0.36145544052124023,
0.15447838604450226,
1.0325202941894531,
-0.6235454082489014,
0.9261625409126282,
-0.23227354884147644,
0.2098151445388794,
0.6206850409507751,
-0.22722266614437103,
0.5148083567619324,
-0.17358921468257904,
0.2205551713705063,
0.23828543722629547,
-0.07007686048746109,
-0.30247464776039124,
-0.2353297621011734,
0.7311744093894958,
-0.7183375358581543,
-0.166987806558609,
-0.7804955840110779,
-0.5232279896736145,
-0.2553936541080475,
-0.1763637214899063,
-0.17127099633216858,
0.7356834411621094,
-0.1754077672958374,
-0.16751444339752197,
0.15249374508857727,
-0.20663398504257202,
0.9697918891906738,
0.6441197991371155,
-0.28714802861213684,
-0.4142236113548279,
1.1355459690093994,
0.06895794719457626,
-0.432778924703598,
-0.028483878821134567,
0.11949577927589417,
-0.38925406336784363,
-0.9973976612091064,
-0.6706450581550598,
-0.021284112706780434,
-0.5475782752037048,
-0.03944342955946922,
-0.7086153030395508,
-0.2824241518974304,
-0.06703554838895798,
-0.19673456251621246,
-0.24808931350708008,
-0.09360318630933762,
0.052284929901361465,
-0.11765827238559723,
0.4751476049423218,
0.9541229009628296,
-0.12264174968004227,
0.5284500122070312,
-1.0623517036437988,
-0.1293490082025528,
-0.12921318411827087,
0.12482054531574249,
0.19022797048091888,
0.12310504168272018,
-0.46199876070022583,
-0.4612848162651062,
-0.37980055809020996,
-0.7464993000030518,
0.4706512689590454,
-0.17187634110450745,
0.3333248198032379,
0.5603604316711426,
0.14088912308216095,
0.7201131582260132,
-0.5006194710731506,
0.6524842381477356,
0.49591588973999023,
-0.3717584013938904,
0.640015721321106,
-0.4566901922225952,
-0.10848923772573471,
0.8796153664588928,
0.6796454191207886,
-0.3666194975376129,
-0.12084633857011795,
-0.2197374403476715,
-0.9360579252243042,
0.47933781147003174,
0.5307092070579529,
-0.07871533185243607,
0.06181444972753525,
0.29931482672691345,
0.11194223910570145,
0.3624996244907379,
-0.33764442801475525,
-0.5658875107765198,
-0.039025962352752686,
-0.4936729371547699,
0.0759119763970375,
-0.368495374917984,
0.13021372258663177,
-0.32647499442100525,
0.6168732047080994,
0.17823322117328644,
-0.33162760734558105,
-0.20013625919818878,
-0.05498038977384567,
0.09377776831388474,
0.04188898578286171,
0.6526955962181091,
0.7801703810691833,
-0.4305335283279419,
0.13729745149612427,
0.17196087539196014,
-0.8538027405738831,
0.09366399049758911,
-0.052964020520448685,
-0.13335181772708893,
0.05010823905467987,
0.3598279356956482,
0.4957238733768463,
-0.026321468874812126,
-0.9199012517929077,
0.5127755403518677,
-0.26967471837997437,
-0.0654970183968544,
-0.6155078411102295,
0.31519022583961487,
-0.07012756913900375,
0.08040811121463776,
0.3469013571739197,
0.1131715327501297,
0.6691622734069824,
-0.6331436038017273,
-0.04015551507472992,
0.053980857133865356,
-0.6178160309791565,
-0.1659439653158188,
0.45758387446403503,
0.4447118937969208,
-0.018932227045297623,
0.5603301525115967,
-0.21941079199314117,
-0.6399715542793274,
0.7300599813461304,
0.18513962626457214,
0.7688629031181335,
-0.138650581240654,
-0.03985786437988281,
0.2688156068325043,
0.28645291924476624,
-0.034881964325904846,
0.40216386318206787,
0.2061709761619568,
-0.7066181898117065,
-0.2939319908618927,
-0.6443793177604675,
-0.3931550979614258,
0.04963570833206177,
-0.472831130027771,
0.03591112419962883,
-0.19381901621818542,
-0.005029866471886635,
-0.0777592882514,
0.09053610265254974,
-0.21782535314559937,
0.3709176182746887,
0.17026488482952118,
0.6674857139587402,
-0.7136512398719788,
0.32324767112731934,
0.880142867565155,
-0.5040783286094666,
-0.5670449733734131,
0.3939369022846222,
0.23082736134529114,
-0.4693995714187622,
0.45531246066093445,
0.6961103081703186,
-0.2069755494594574,
-0.008245299570262432,
-0.41292521357536316,
-0.6929987072944641,
0.9428853988647461,
-0.2518608570098877,
-0.48549097776412964,
0.2531047761440277,
0.6379388570785522,
0.10012324154376984,
-0.45252278447151184,
-0.07250755280256271,
1.058587670326233,
0.40343526005744934,
-0.017299562692642212,
-0.600437581539154,
0.008526344783604145,
0.10890965908765793,
-0.274312287569046,
0.5485213398933411,
-0.7543121576309204,
0.46705418825149536,
-0.12777376174926758,
-0.2344287782907486,
0.09746448695659637,
0.5205329060554504,
0.33893901109695435,
1.0869364738464355,
0.6989737749099731,
0.6934870481491089,
0.8650449514389038,
0.13527126610279083,
0.9663563370704651,
-0.39504164457321167,
0.21559587121009827,
0.8492416143417358,
-0.07675967365503311,
0.398147851228714,
0.22336070239543915,
-0.19984419643878937,
0.8059865236282349,
0.5815412998199463,
0.1277523785829544,
0.9647497534751892,
0.22684089839458466,
-0.4615883529186249,
-0.48197314143180847,
-0.5457936525344849,
-0.17188440263271332,
0.8860576152801514,
0.2221444994211197,
-0.1849524825811386,
-0.42890509963035583,
0.28592953085899353,
0.24959047138690948,
-0.3350549638271332,
-0.7038381695747375,
0.8464330434799194,
-0.29090702533721924,
-0.5240989327430725,
-0.11601179838180542,
0.10409688204526901,
0.2016650140285492,
-0.07936788350343704,
-0.13453525304794312,
0.07196962833404541,
0.27092546224594116,
-0.0233673807233572,
-1.0267869234085083,
0.5145033001899719,
0.01882164739072323,
-0.3262230455875397,
-0.141895592212677,
1.0475045442581177,
-0.13752973079681396,
-0.7150780558586121,
-0.05999916046857834,
0.5864496827125549,
0.5286054015159607,
-0.11720259487628937,
-0.3699692487716675,
0.1842389702796936,
0.11922549456357956,
-0.0077237715013325214,
0.29102227091789246,
0.44490793347358704,
-0.14088615775108337,
0.281950443983078,
0.6707084774971008,
-0.22314442694187164,
0.038009971380233765,
-0.024459101259708405,
1.0112433433532715,
-1.3041105270385742,
-0.5729287266731262,
-1.1648838520050049,
0.7045714259147644,
-0.28245872259140015,
-0.35642009973526,
0.715972900390625,
0.8443618416786194,
0.5603344440460205,
0.22801148891448975,
1.1035231351852417,
0.2634781002998352,
0.5411110520362854,
-0.6733302474021912,
0.6044079065322876,
-0.33273938298225403,
0.09208453446626663,
0.09791393578052521,
-0.3760400414466858,
-0.180868461728096,
0.441317617893219,
-0.30202609300613403,
-0.10519346594810486,
0.3458189070224762,
0.5237497091293335,
0.1717451810836792,
0.5445348024368286,
-0.012202095240354538,
0.02989591471850872,
0.32825756072998047,
0.4206218719482422,
1.235901117324829,
-0.22734050452709198,
0.8770613670349121,
0.06559523940086365,
-0.13309215009212494,
-0.5628117322921753,
-0.471285343170166,
-1.2871859073638916,
-0.4459471106529236,
-0.4704093337059021,
-0.10265856981277466,
0.15733474493026733,
0.2785134017467499,
0.5320603251457214,
-0.7311524748802185,
-0.08377701789140701,
-0.3866821825504303,
0.3297085464000702,
0.47584977746009827,
-0.2829890847206116,
0.32826346158981323,
-0.45946043729782104,
-0.27990296483039856,
0.3009112775325775,
0.708233654499054,
0.2843107581138611,
-0.11964917927980423,
0.07550591230392456,
-0.07890769094228745,
0.15927274525165558,
0.30829381942749023,
0.09392162412405014,
-0.043865546584129333,
-0.07134144008159637,
-0.571260392665863,
-0.0627308040857315,
-0.011653460562229156,
1.194288969039917,
-0.9502401351928711,
-0.0332033634185791,
0.2631027102470398,
0.5439335703849792,
0.6711829900741577,
0.02822631597518921,
0.49778294563293457,
-0.5170946717262268,
0.16184191405773163,
-0.16866272687911987,
0.3259469270706177,
0.3169328272342682,
-0.0035383044742047787,
0.5963475704193115,
0.5468290448188782,
-0.4861598312854767,
-0.8786059617996216,
0.21324726939201355,
-0.9146928191184998,
-0.45508408546447754,
0.86347895860672,
-0.016367582604289055,
-0.3008434474468231,
-0.8570405840873718,
-0.1915971338748932,
0.07759043574333191,
-0.29625973105430603,
0.6888582110404968,
0.39345434308052063,
-0.43233856558799744,
-0.028612080961465836,
-0.7406750321388245,
0.577392578125,
-0.13171181082725525,
-0.7435377836227417,
-0.312255859375,
0.3776922821998596,
0.1767074018716812,
0.003906106809154153,
0.39269793033599854,
0.43510034680366516,
0.20947736501693726,
0.08730468153953552,
-0.3526259660720825,
0.18975898623466492,
-0.3678317368030548,
0.221697136759758,
0.6458286643028259,
-0.21038313210010529,
-0.37957990169525146
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.07685v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.07685v1
|
Out-Of-Context Prompting Boosts Fairness and Robustness in Large Language Model Predictions
| 2024-06-11T20:05:15 | 2024-06-11T20:05:15 |
Leonardo Cotta, Chris J. Maddison
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Frontier Large Language Models (LLMs) are increasingly being deployed for
high-stakes decision-making. On the other hand, these models are still
consistently making predictions that contradict users' or society's
expectations, e.g., hallucinating, or discriminating. Thus, it is important
that we develop test-time strategies to improve their trustworthiness. Inspired
by prior work, we leverage causality as a tool to formally encode two aspects
of trustworthiness in LLMs: fairness and robustness. Under this perspective,
existing test-time solutions explicitly instructing the model to be fair or
robust implicitly depend on the LLM's causal reasoning capabilities. In this
work, we explore the opposite approach. Instead of explicitly asking the LLM
for trustworthiness, we design prompts to encode the underlying causal
inference algorithm that will, by construction, result in more trustworthy
predictions. Concretely, we propose out-of-context prompting as a test-time
solution to encourage fairness and robustness in LLMs. Out-of-context prompting
leverages the user's prior knowledge of the task's causal model to apply
(random) counterfactual transformations and improve the model's
trustworthiness. Empirically, we show that out-of-context prompting
consistently improves the fairness and robustness of frontier LLMs across five
different benchmark datasets without requiring additional data, finetuning or
pre-training.
|
[
-0.3637959361076355,
-0.8917474150657654,
1.0201066732406616,
0.23483732342720032,
-0.05238211527466774,
-0.37263253331184387,
-0.23184813559055328,
-0.24240835011005402,
-0.30867356061935425,
0.16949206590652466,
-0.6065549254417419,
-0.06646188348531723,
-0.5584749579429626,
0.019205467775464058,
-0.3564198613166809,
0.9383727312088013,
0.015325966291129589,
0.06830117851495743,
-0.47668835520744324,
-0.01388546358793974,
-0.6325298547744751,
-0.43088090419769287,
-0.9026364684104919,
-0.5097320079803467,
0.5898047685623169,
0.33401402831077576,
0.7734697461128235,
0.3830002248287201,
-0.08330266922712326,
0.25085291266441345,
0.026678679510951042,
0.12684564292430878,
-0.551832914352417,
0.12090891599655151,
-0.3682492673397064,
-0.6873982548713684,
-0.30311334133148193,
0.15065762400627136,
0.615312397480011,
0.6999914050102234,
-0.031010420992970467,
0.27893128991127014,
0.5097240209579468,
0.356882244348526,
-0.5882022380828857,
0.2402680367231369,
-0.7247419953346252,
-0.16588006913661957,
-0.21461212635040283,
-0.5336958169937134,
-0.7409274578094482,
-0.5208202004432678,
0.012042663060128689,
-0.7221971750259399,
0.06638941168785095,
0.30919215083122253,
0.7102236747741699,
0.2537250518798828,
-0.5344177484512329,
-0.01221209391951561,
-0.44382545351982117,
0.722408652305603,
-0.6256668567657471,
0.5423330068588257,
0.5061302781105042,
0.3555993139743805,
-0.6537212133407593,
-0.5864329934120178,
-0.7979199290275574,
-0.3217470049858093,
-0.15184345841407776,
0.08088713884353638,
-0.19232134521007538,
-0.15635335445404053,
0.6212955713272095,
-0.10833598673343658,
-0.3280975818634033,
0.4386884570121765,
0.11363951116800308,
-0.18046562373638153,
0.242064967751503,
0.09092866629362106,
0.01771755889058113,
0.00020535055955406278,
-0.330211341381073,
-0.23670881986618042,
-1.1227779388427734,
0.5284546613693237,
0.4464825391769409,
0.26631033420562744,
-0.1759531944990158,
0.32325440645217896,
-0.18979376554489136,
0.4768407642841339,
0.3157161474227905,
-0.12007199972867966,
-0.029904138296842575,
-0.1460430920124054,
-0.22160173952579498,
0.05449012666940689,
0.44757774472236633,
0.5482838749885559,
0.24982917308807373,
-0.15966537594795227,
-0.20408697426319122,
0.09701109677553177,
-0.019419478252530098,
-0.8192302584648132,
0.2587254047393799,
0.3125801384449005,
-0.6633312106132507,
-0.2278045266866684,
0.03877733275294304,
-0.8207299709320068,
-0.6570809483528137,
-0.3642128109931946,
0.6178637742996216,
-0.2653043866157532,
-0.023897778242826462,
-0.06075719743967056,
-0.04666118696331978,
0.09815198928117752,
0.3734327256679535,
-0.6460601687431335,
-0.01064161118119955,
0.6071497201919556,
0.7320002317428589,
0.1346321403980255,
-0.38545480370521545,
-1.4294530153274536,
0.24127668142318726,
-0.3092963695526123,
0.5372830033302307,
-0.44237077236175537,
-0.3400958478450775,
0.16649247705936432,
0.08235789835453033,
0.077435202896595,
-0.1790952831506729,
0.5825366973876953,
-0.68592768907547,
0.42623916268348694,
-0.7989384531974792,
-0.302144318819046,
-0.2653409540653229,
0.36864736676216125,
-0.33034494519233704,
0.9580633640289307,
0.019623007625341415,
-0.7480901479721069,
0.9009554982185364,
-0.7769173383712769,
-0.4197070002555847,
-0.15421055257320404,
-0.22343263030052185,
-0.20743286609649658,
0.2069755643606186,
0.6614322066307068,
0.5732442140579224,
-0.4899308383464813,
0.7636100649833679,
-0.7736227512359619,
-0.37550991773605347,
0.48862403631210327,
-0.7202855944633484,
0.752916693687439,
0.1672513782978058,
-0.6507413983345032,
0.13388261198997498,
-0.4210434556007385,
-0.0985601469874382,
0.021438756957650185,
0.040746383368968964,
-0.3592936396598816,
0.08743410557508469,
-0.18855372071266174,
0.4914700388908386,
-0.07227403670549393,
-0.5263127684593201,
-0.3883022665977478,
-0.5147005319595337,
0.46643921732902527,
1.0615001916885376,
-0.1400814950466156,
0.4948771595954895,
-0.5844415426254272,
0.27896708250045776,
0.08910427987575531,
0.4396202564239502,
-0.05210705101490021,
-0.6889250874519348,
-0.4307869076728821,
-0.23201225697994232,
-0.0687807947397232,
0.4056906998157501,
-0.7797555327415466,
0.3843677043914795,
-0.36161649227142334,
-0.07817848026752472,
-0.13532163202762604,
-0.13556009531021118,
0.31902921199798584,
0.9944987893104553,
0.31042319536209106,
-0.03591069206595421,
-0.2201031595468521,
-0.5312178134918213,
-0.4097394645214081,
-0.4670563340187073,
-0.055833689868450165,
0.36479452252388,
0.5044819116592407,
-0.23532310128211975,
1.2644847631454468,
-0.3598138093948364,
-0.05254293978214264,
-0.018529502674937248,
0.16164645552635193,
0.18400214612483978,
0.38825786113739014,
0.38510608673095703,
-0.8281474709510803,
-0.14798320829868317,
-0.22745713591575623,
-0.6156566739082336,
-0.36844998598098755,
-0.10080675780773163,
-0.12236101925373077,
0.2806743085384369,
0.8714438676834106,
-0.4570064842700958,
0.44584956765174866,
0.47603094577789307,
-0.49140089750289917,
0.35610082745552063,
-0.31100502610206604,
0.4508136808872223,
-0.9659145474433899,
0.22472237050533295,
-0.34650111198425293,
-0.14933465421199799,
-0.334811270236969,
-0.06749703735113144,
0.07433000206947327,
-0.05897682160139084,
-0.47034189105033875,
0.9181393980979919,
-0.1656416654586792,
0.007544699124991894,
-0.05356079712510109,
0.28703054785728455,
0.13598284125328064,
0.24788732826709747,
-0.08276112377643585,
0.7345330119132996,
0.5217398405075073,
-0.6234484314918518,
-0.13216619193553925,
0.1754903793334961,
-0.18223069608211517,
0.9445925354957581,
-0.5572895407676697,
-0.06713028997182846,
-0.46972891688346863,
0.5786687135696411,
-1.0126783847808838,
-0.26429036259651184,
0.13060232996940613,
-0.45556098222732544,
0.09430375695228577,
-0.13572020828723907,
-0.672566831111908,
-0.12592872977256775,
-0.3079143166542053,
0.48403608798980713,
0.6538960933685303,
-1.0593847036361694,
0.65189528465271,
0.13959024846553802,
-0.011263654567301273,
-0.4711592197418213,
-0.8138043880462646,
0.016375428065657616,
-0.5633288025856018,
-0.6980026364326477,
0.18637388944625854,
-0.16967985033988953,
-0.3203403055667877,
-0.16283786296844482,
0.10472303628921509,
0.05729994550347328,
0.13772675395011902,
0.5519920587539673,
0.38064390420913696,
0.021904172375798225,
0.11951537430286407,
0.2860206067562103,
-0.033519383519887924,
0.42651990056037903,
-0.3978195786476135,
0.2995506525039673,
0.036121565848588943,
-0.5258198976516724,
-0.19546110928058624,
0.419768363237381,
0.33188021183013916,
-0.07706549018621445,
0.7825650572776794,
0.58736252784729,
-0.3668714463710785,
-0.2758777439594269,
-0.7067636847496033,
-0.5718104243278503,
-0.5360100865364075,
0.016847867518663406,
-0.1474635899066925,
-1.2204002141952515,
0.6900227665901184,
-0.1052466481924057,
-0.15422286093235016,
0.04260452836751938,
0.4958328604698181,
0.18413148820400238,
1.0272343158721924,
0.3910777270793915,
0.003913477528840303,
0.4099150002002716,
0.3899480402469635,
0.23148319125175476,
-0.5501326322555542,
-0.26327311992645264,
-0.5562517642974854,
0.11626522988080978,
-0.4804784059524536,
-0.3835694193840027,
0.5864378213882446,
-0.04991093650460243,
-0.3890605866909027,
-0.11767318099737167,
-0.04374643415212631,
0.37399163842201233,
0.49177321791648865,
0.2643691301345825,
0.2676195800304413,
-0.10700854659080505,
-0.22149619460105896,
-0.019705748185515404,
-0.7452303171157837,
-0.3281336724758148,
0.8985760807991028,
0.5586416721343994,
0.6014426350593567,
0.11103539913892746,
0.5450655221939087,
0.04022792726755142,
0.562306821346283,
-0.5325325131416321,
0.4506431818008423,
0.16054245829582214,
-0.7830128073692322,
-0.3401285409927368,
-0.578135073184967,
-0.8080127835273743,
0.027708761394023895,
-0.30877286195755005,
-0.90913987159729,
0.4767579734325409,
0.32793259620666504,
-0.6595809459686279,
0.13271567225456238,
-0.6013007760047913,
0.6918343901634216,
0.15018843114376068,
-0.43416526913642883,
-0.16820906102657318,
-0.6669872999191284,
0.4331948161125183,
-0.23223868012428284,
0.5590304732322693,
0.07864440232515335,
0.1049632877111435,
0.5877701044082642,
-0.2638233006000519,
1.129088044166565,
-0.2797680199146271,
-0.3124037981033325,
0.18832579255104065,
0.28718483448028564,
0.9929519891738892,
0.5774358510971069,
0.038435813039541245,
0.1661863774061203,
-0.18648980557918549,
-0.08622769266366959,
-0.7439369559288025,
0.7946920394897461,
-0.21651065349578857,
-0.6292366981506348,
-0.30147701501846313,
-0.6441069841384888,
-0.6883097887039185,
0.23805701732635498,
0.4890325665473938,
0.7411055564880371,
-0.12991301715373993,
0.12783865630626678,
0.9258383512496948,
-0.4297075569629669,
0.6924805045127869,
0.44455450773239136,
-0.15436869859695435,
-0.15299342572689056,
0.4434146583080292,
-0.03868323192000389,
0.36560720205307007,
0.3441060185432434,
0.3903712034225464,
-0.8144406676292419,
-0.32489538192749023,
-0.3538520038127899,
-0.15448805689811707,
-0.8710523843765259,
-0.184713676571846,
-0.511683464050293,
0.1618616282939911,
-0.4478844702243805,
-0.4947068393230438,
-0.181078240275383,
-0.04415491968393326,
-0.11022572219371796,
-0.048048797994852066,
0.3685992658138275,
0.3922847807407379,
-0.097641222178936,
0.2651786208152771,
-0.7635856866836548,
0.013685394078493118,
0.4584041237831116,
0.34205785393714905,
0.13914154469966888,
-0.7438234090805054,
0.03720107302069664,
-0.07657857239246368,
0.07370349019765854,
-0.6163453459739685,
0.03888219967484474,
-0.11863820999860764,
0.5412349104881287,
0.3892565965652466,
0.2705632150173187,
0.6499903202056885,
-0.5759928226470947,
0.691331684589386,
0.13965901732444763,
-1.1420568227767944,
0.3743005096912384,
-0.5486530661582947,
0.1929517537355423,
0.5631985664367676,
0.21198013424873352,
-0.3475918173789978,
-0.490329772233963,
-0.4092288613319397,
-0.5282617211341858,
0.5857294797897339,
0.04178816080093384,
0.07072164863348007,
-0.03573098033666611,
0.23664253950119019,
0.39511898159980774,
0.024612417444586754,
-0.7756355404853821,
0.006758932955563068,
-0.20318150520324707,
-0.025791894644498825,
-0.2690357267856598,
-0.2161637544631958,
-0.33784160017967224,
0.02131206914782524,
0.4452073276042938,
-0.4031067490577698,
-0.006648642476648092,
0.3742692470550537,
0.037190116941928864,
-0.25007280707359314,
0.5215826034545898,
0.3809393048286438,
0.8551899790763855,
-0.07587702572345734,
0.15320748090744019,
0.4635636806488037,
-0.17545217275619507,
0.20278765261173248,
0.28628256916999817,
-0.2350202351808548,
-0.33075883984565735,
0.29375946521759033,
0.5833448767662048,
0.30338698625564575,
-0.46651002764701843,
0.7116050720214844,
-0.10951031744480133,
0.12559179961681366,
0.007829895243048668,
-0.10384105145931244,
-0.2418050765991211,
0.3554353415966034,
0.26423799991607666,
-0.0668472871184349,
0.2545427083969116,
-0.4878148138523102,
0.13713893294334412,
0.5156610608100891,
-0.33907702565193176,
-0.08419641107320786,
0.9727274775505066,
0.067451611161232,
0.23942652344703674,
0.2671447694301605,
-0.32086285948753357,
-0.2923392653465271,
0.17988815903663635,
0.6914580464363098,
0.7936585545539856,
0.04860841855406761,
0.3271961808204651,
0.188175231218338,
0.3098996579647064,
-0.37944185733795166,
0.12691989541053772,
0.030210932716727257,
-0.6080285906791687,
-0.6602271199226379,
-0.32440799474716187,
-0.2793208062648773,
0.10562005639076233,
-0.5951512455940247,
0.14750085771083832,
-0.2745794951915741,
-0.2593995928764343,
-0.46814554929733276,
-0.23957785964012146,
-0.5832858085632324,
0.38323068618774414,
0.054526060819625854,
0.955461323261261,
-0.8246356248855591,
0.7167198061943054,
0.40090587735176086,
-0.11216584593057632,
-0.8956769108772278,
0.23711112141609192,
0.1255957931280136,
-0.7496816515922546,
0.6950477957725525,
0.25619643926620483,
-0.1698840856552124,
-0.12633852660655975,
-0.5571063756942749,
-0.772788405418396,
1.0499579906463623,
0.7441027164459229,
-0.5406844615936279,
0.24902266263961792,
0.008524197153747082,
0.1427183598279953,
-0.24984623491764069,
0.20312051475048065,
0.44186919927597046,
0.6289746165275574,
-0.06614388525485992,
-0.9754778742790222,
0.8314226269721985,
0.1223514974117279,
0.021583959460258484,
0.07446663081645966,
-0.367505818605423,
0.8806881904602051,
-0.30091139674186707,
-0.23795880377292633,
-0.26938456296920776,
0.6994206309318542,
0.5080329179763794,
0.5416406393051147,
0.8356114029884338,
0.26170608401298523,
0.913187563419342,
-0.1481955349445343,
1.176153540611267,
0.08676803112030029,
-0.09246088564395905,
1.097652554512024,
-0.3604307472705841,
0.6253125667572021,
0.7144824862480164,
0.24342574179172516,
0.5017310380935669,
0.6098464727401733,
0.41862770915031433,
0.5019263625144958,
-0.23026683926582336,
-0.12864011526107788,
-0.3985321819782257,
-0.2995292842388153,
-0.6329682469367981,
0.2930162250995636,
0.049896545708179474,
-0.14128102362155914,
-0.33609920740127563,
-0.08690611273050308,
0.43874672055244446,
0.15397204458713531,
-0.44757184386253357,
0.2407887727022171,
0.23229260742664337,
-0.9992977976799011,
0.2940976023674011,
-0.13694754242897034,
0.6569374799728394,
-0.6192197799682617,
0.06298373639583588,
-0.19775651395320892,
0.16219653189182281,
-0.0560525506734848,
-0.747667133808136,
0.08189446479082108,
-0.35408905148506165,
-0.18826167285442352,
-0.36926352977752686,
0.5049830079078674,
-0.32172200083732605,
-0.04970646649599075,
0.44323328137397766,
0.5087045431137085,
-0.28395000100135803,
-0.2244814783334732,
-0.42902350425720215,
0.04420149326324463,
-0.42228400707244873,
-0.11583973467350006,
0.5248711705207825,
0.6305643916130066,
-0.5637979507446289,
0.6238053441047668,
0.9537808299064636,
-0.028496477752923965,
-0.3225041329860687,
0.1437804400920868,
0.905055582523346,
-0.45814386010169983,
-0.9023905992507935,
-1.0843145847320557,
0.49954095482826233,
-0.08619886636734009,
-0.2576698660850525,
0.9927629232406616,
0.03653235360980034,
0.814869225025177,
0.15603333711624146,
0.5858632922172546,
0.10925628989934921,
0.1769755333662033,
-0.8026964068412781,
0.8757237792015076,
-0.5581232905387878,
0.127298504114151,
-0.3804774284362793,
-0.6668847799301147,
-0.25629764795303345,
0.08401458710432053,
-0.4491967260837555,
0.24707292020320892,
0.8001134991645813,
0.997627854347229,
0.06740111112594604,
0.09929516911506653,
0.21261800825595856,
0.12829427421092987,
0.44313451647758484,
0.5267918705940247,
0.9230148196220398,
-0.05002616345882416,
0.3861497938632965,
0.13640648126602173,
-0.5930350422859192,
-0.11547397822141647,
-1.4449961185455322,
-1.2444509267807007,
-0.5314125418663025,
-0.025834664702415466,
-0.6973770260810852,
0.0395708791911602,
0.9325178861618042,
0.6439124345779419,
-0.746560275554657,
-0.007768899202346802,
-0.09191327542066574,
0.0932086780667305,
-0.09376130253076553,
-0.2085258960723877,
0.2855243384838104,
-0.44019681215286255,
-0.31728601455688477,
0.5156199336051941,
0.25868117809295654,
0.09636768698692322,
-0.09198348969221115,
-0.20063599944114685,
0.21724432706832886,
0.33807772397994995,
0.691105842590332,
0.05405425280332565,
-0.5451570749282837,
-0.5206233859062195,
-0.07535615563392639,
0.11155291646718979,
-0.29376357793807983,
0.8495450615882874,
-0.79908686876297,
0.2925122082233429,
0.46390360593795776,
0.4695742130279541,
0.042354516685009,
-0.09617701172828674,
0.8280099630355835,
-0.6124251484870911,
0.310213178396225,
-0.12903918325901031,
0.4894472658634186,
0.31177574396133423,
-0.7079204320907593,
0.1696443259716034,
0.10206767171621323,
-0.5511559844017029,
-1.117653489112854,
0.3101400136947632,
-0.534506618976593,
-0.2957662045955658,
1.2153549194335938,
-0.20951958000659943,
-0.28565099835395813,
-0.3429412245750427,
-0.16026464104652405,
0.1523285210132599,
-0.5424612760543823,
0.8413461446762085,
0.6596274971961975,
0.04685845598578453,
0.2691679298877716,
-0.4184996783733368,
0.8109486103057861,
0.552826464176178,
-0.9503859877586365,
0.16974236071109772,
0.4995514154434204,
0.13215936720371246,
-0.13980722427368164,
0.6183038949966431,
-0.24165211617946625,
0.3437536358833313,
-0.03251291438937187,
-0.5910837650299072,
-0.22975040972232819,
-0.33495596051216125,
-0.42071327567100525,
0.15396882593631744,
-0.007940328679978848,
0.15756607055664062
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10273v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10273v1
|
Beyond Words: On Large Language Models Actionability in Mission-Critical Risk Analysis
| 2024-06-11T19:20:27 | 2024-06-11T19:20:27 |
Matteo Esposito, Francesco Palagiano, Valentina Lenarduzzi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CR, cs.HC
|
Context. Risk analysis assesses potential risks in specific scenarios. Risk
analysis principles are context-less; the same methodology can be applied to a
risk connected to health and information technology security. Risk analysis
requires a vast knowledge of national and international regulations and
standards and is time and effort-intensive. A large language model can quickly
summarize information in less time than a human and can be fine-tuned to
specific tasks. Aim. Our empirical study aims to investigate the effectiveness
of Retrieval-Augmented Generation and fine-tuned LLM in Risk analysis. To our
knowledge, no prior study has explored its capabilities in risk analysis.
Method. We manually curated \totalscenarios unique scenarios leading to
\totalsamples representative samples from over 50 mission-critical analyses
archived by the industrial context team in the last five years. We compared the
base GPT-3.5 and GPT-4 models versus their Retrieval-Augmented Generation and
fine-tuned counterparts. We employ two human experts as competitors of the
models and three other three human experts to review the models and the former
human expert's analysis. The reviewers analyzed 5,000 scenario analyses.
Results and Conclusions. HEs demonstrated higher accuracy, but LLMs are quicker
and more actionable. Moreover, our findings show that RAG-assisted LLMs have
the lowest hallucination rates, effectively uncovering hidden risks and
complementing human expertise. Thus, the choice of model depends on specific
needs, with FTMs for accuracy, RAG for hidden risks discovery, and base models
for comprehensiveness and actionability. Therefore, experts can leverage LLMs
for an effective complementing companion in risk analysis within a condensed
timeframe. They can also save costs by averting unnecessary expenses associated
with implementing unwarranted countermeasures.
|
[
0.04197647422552109,
-0.651477038860321,
0.704852283000946,
-0.02282448299229145,
0.11377901583909988,
0.14452922344207764,
-0.08218499273061752,
-0.8715859651565552,
-0.05542181059718132,
0.6458773016929626,
-0.26594623923301697,
-0.4296244978904724,
-0.5415512919425964,
-0.2920273244380951,
-0.389024019241333,
0.9576379060745239,
-0.05503755807876587,
-0.12817955017089844,
0.07252468168735504,
0.11113669723272324,
-0.34673014283180237,
-0.7697505950927734,
-0.6507890224456787,
-0.05716416612267494,
0.5724257826805115,
0.27298468351364136,
0.6121158003807068,
0.05825977399945259,
0.9621533751487732,
0.35325002670288086,
-0.2609156370162964,
-0.01838630996644497,
-0.5378897190093994,
-0.1575414538383484,
-0.344769686460495,
-0.39836692810058594,
-0.6620095372200012,
0.14889183640480042,
0.4127507209777832,
0.7314848899841309,
-0.2710539400577545,
0.32783710956573486,
0.15340366959571838,
0.8475536704063416,
-0.6536037921905518,
0.15284959971904755,
-0.9656562209129333,
-0.020507680252194405,
-0.10360453277826309,
-0.44365042448043823,
-0.3913723826408386,
-0.2419101446866989,
0.531802237033844,
-0.3202957510948181,
0.12850813567638397,
0.13303448259830475,
0.6915973424911499,
0.11910751461982727,
-0.5016897916793823,
-0.27192291617393494,
-0.9950513243675232,
0.8227810263633728,
-0.43883293867111206,
0.2834310829639435,
0.23837101459503174,
0.4058203399181366,
-0.22185981273651123,
-0.6553797721862793,
-0.20292803645133972,
-0.4004513621330261,
0.11153925210237503,
0.040228135883808136,
-0.019962260499596596,
0.2779989540576935,
0.37880051136016846,
0.3266009986400604,
-0.3629116415977478,
0.2837671637535095,
-0.5916867256164551,
-0.4003353714942932,
0.7552534937858582,
0.35260409116744995,
0.07405196130275726,
-0.25829246640205383,
-0.44287461042404175,
-0.16153253614902496,
-0.9615710377693176,
0.0029652819503098726,
0.25415799021720886,
0.20391905307769775,
0.07240336388349533,
0.5392470955848694,
-0.17738181352615356,
0.3791346549987793,
-0.28399208188056946,
-0.3374823033809662,
0.2027982622385025,
-0.4019179046154022,
-0.45230886340141296,
-0.12198024988174438,
0.5526007413864136,
0.4784000515937805,
0.2082468718290329,
-0.27885037660598755,
-0.16684015095233917,
-0.1964181363582611,
0.6496267914772034,
-0.7032931447029114,
0.012680000625550747,
0.37637215852737427,
-0.38544321060180664,
-0.2930150032043457,
0.14304737746715546,
-0.6399157643318176,
-0.6093166470527649,
-0.19159278273582458,
0.5320323705673218,
-0.35621267557144165,
-0.1784369796514511,
0.2746809422969818,
-0.005585093982517719,
0.31736311316490173,
0.1339396983385086,
-0.24788300693035126,
0.1114601120352745,
0.5974699854850769,
0.7475550174713135,
-0.26324671506881714,
0.013821927830576897,
-0.4761132299900055,
0.2263125628232956,
-0.36200031638145447,
0.7858185172080994,
-0.17611831426620483,
-0.8129478693008423,
0.043969448655843735,
-0.13399769365787506,
-0.005338107701390982,
-0.4321492910385132,
0.6653096675872803,
-0.6949260234832764,
-0.16542162001132965,
-0.2975292205810547,
-0.44555556774139404,
-0.44750523567199707,
0.3701353967189789,
-0.5034345984458923,
0.9226672053337097,
-0.030798310413956642,
-0.7702602744102478,
0.6688826680183411,
-0.5763471126556396,
-0.3394620418548584,
-0.02959020435810089,
-0.2350563406944275,
-0.5117330551147461,
0.11077041178941727,
-0.025112498551607132,
0.7776642441749573,
-0.3804560899734497,
0.37596186995506287,
-0.35461050271987915,
-0.23398661613464355,
0.44499051570892334,
-0.5643366575241089,
0.3329022526741028,
0.1458083987236023,
-0.40553802251815796,
0.2359887659549713,
-0.6229292750358582,
0.21375812590122223,
-0.028433606028556824,
-0.41839224100112915,
-0.388156533241272,
0.21974846720695496,
0.1919011026620865,
0.32723376154899597,
0.145938441157341,
-0.2898595929145813,
-0.13634534180164337,
-0.5649542808532715,
0.19527828693389893,
0.5207923650741577,
0.2627669870853424,
0.3116054832935333,
-0.40517255663871765,
0.5833019614219666,
-0.22819165885448456,
0.1973864734172821,
0.14289559423923492,
-0.1296890527009964,
-0.5414320230484009,
-0.27361994981765747,
0.08604680001735687,
0.9359869360923767,
-0.5358505845069885,
0.2828018367290497,
-0.4198608696460724,
-0.7185989022254944,
-0.07158985733985901,
-0.08594072610139847,
0.653901219367981,
0.44485676288604736,
0.3402561545372009,
-0.15062116086483002,
-0.7017166018486023,
-0.7447671294212341,
-0.40743157267570496,
-0.22267132997512817,
-0.09332002699375153,
0.5127909183502197,
0.3921486735343933,
-0.5592978596687317,
0.6555054783821106,
-0.8339719772338867,
-0.125275120139122,
-0.4322105348110199,
0.1190619245171547,
0.16938547790050507,
0.25757554173469543,
0.47025516629219055,
-0.7708645462989807,
-0.3624676465988159,
0.07147993892431259,
-0.617382287979126,
0.09181006997823715,
-0.09464205056428909,
-0.17128367722034454,
0.46251118183135986,
0.6131250858306885,
-0.44741323590278625,
0.5890609622001648,
0.2919269800186157,
0.015600688755512238,
0.5605564117431641,
-0.4009118676185608,
0.11953821033239365,
-1.1077313423156738,
0.5714325904846191,
0.041581690311431885,
-0.09876648336648941,
-0.8796842098236084,
0.2994705140590668,
0.02187826856970787,
-0.13109230995178223,
-0.5496900081634521,
0.6263447403907776,
-0.5123569965362549,
-0.16010060906410217,
-0.4206116199493408,
-0.032700810581445694,
-0.13078168034553528,
0.1102026179432869,
-0.07126779854297638,
0.767555832862854,
0.3198992609977722,
-0.8904520273208618,
-0.20759199559688568,
-0.06002206727862358,
-0.4485965967178345,
0.28044766187667847,
-0.7378159165382385,
0.08508679270744324,
0.11151012033224106,
-0.0076958672143518925,
-0.9040226936340332,
-0.1664217710494995,
0.03046920895576477,
-0.18007592856884003,
0.6243929266929626,
0.2434360682964325,
-0.4004710912704468,
-0.36155465245246887,
-0.48081082105636597,
0.0017993233632296324,
0.45083698630332947,
-0.09193810820579529,
0.6040047407150269,
0.6067585945129395,
-0.33346378803253174,
-0.6159297227859497,
-0.6527314782142639,
0.18910780549049377,
-0.5468199849128723,
-0.49842914938926697,
0.1997080147266388,
-0.18301232159137726,
-0.4679740369319916,
-0.34889090061187744,
-0.37092921137809753,
-0.13165420293807983,
0.3932429850101471,
0.5980878472328186,
0.4479735791683197,
0.1096266508102417,
0.13300463557243347,
-0.22861143946647644,
-0.26149696111679077,
0.13340520858764648,
0.00371556100435555,
0.2659878730773926,
-0.2069631814956665,
-0.20396259427070618,
-0.23834030330181122,
0.3528723120689392,
0.5047444105148315,
-0.10698128491640091,
0.6769300699234009,
0.45965278148651123,
-0.3035450875759125,
0.18304449319839478,
-0.9281411170959473,
0.010915936902165413,
-0.5027966499328613,
0.5055263042449951,
-0.1516665667295456,
-0.8716122508049011,
0.5450539588928223,
-0.014529175125062466,
0.07957687228918076,
0.6781326532363892,
0.4348060190677643,
-0.26242268085479736,
0.5713819265365601,
0.9240455627441406,
-0.3622177839279175,
0.333434134721756,
-0.3279511630535126,
0.13787299394607544,
-0.7418252229690552,
-0.32339954376220703,
-0.5030250549316406,
-0.09421160072088242,
-0.6075537800788879,
-0.5866937637329102,
0.8629259467124939,
-0.2909959852695465,
-0.19037410616874695,
0.21034018695354462,
-0.26181989908218384,
0.11742719262838364,
0.3033137917518616,
0.2119291126728058,
0.30892521142959595,
0.04204453155398369,
0.11317373812198639,
0.116697758436203,
-0.4858347177505493,
-0.623583197593689,
1.343724250793457,
0.5936609506607056,
0.8776784539222717,
0.14487606287002563,
0.5010829567909241,
0.014829842373728752,
0.3892045319080353,
-0.9459125995635986,
0.5890656113624573,
-0.12731127440929413,
-0.9048197269439697,
-0.40468576550483704,
-0.4512963891029358,
-0.9075606465339661,
0.003929606173187494,
-0.43790510296821594,
-0.6338778734207153,
0.13093335926532745,
0.26082178950309753,
-0.6772958636283875,
0.1546889692544937,
-0.6509585380554199,
0.3031623065471649,
-0.3236010670661926,
-0.14304986596107483,
-0.40937715768814087,
-0.7246284484863281,
0.38740473985671997,
-0.4078108072280884,
0.2386096864938736,
0.13305173814296722,
-0.24401453137397766,
0.578015923500061,
-0.0535351037979126,
1.0227972269058228,
0.07597310096025467,
-0.2760303020477295,
0.3434940576553345,
0.17186816036701202,
0.5607744455337524,
0.12701426446437836,
-0.34249094128608704,
0.19024455547332764,
0.003452617209404707,
0.03830104321241379,
-0.3406338095664978,
0.6597698926925659,
-0.38332676887512207,
-0.825675368309021,
-0.6088736653327942,
-0.609724760055542,
-0.33413416147232056,
0.2724050283432007,
0.1462756246328354,
0.4143485724925995,
-0.2754407227039337,
0.24270957708358765,
0.7771788239479065,
-0.44401663541793823,
0.28106361627578735,
0.8340960741043091,
0.13817422091960907,
-0.3470476567745209,
0.7435916066169739,
0.3954577147960663,
0.28832781314849854,
0.5112930536270142,
0.2718449831008911,
-0.17528878152370453,
-0.7376771569252014,
0.20999783277511597,
0.08219386637210846,
-0.5847877860069275,
-0.21419821679592133,
-0.7855576872825623,
-0.4127562940120697,
-0.1751413196325302,
-0.17406463623046875,
-0.2228986769914627,
-0.07276109606027603,
-0.23188188672065735,
-0.3577301502227783,
0.3898230493068695,
0.45756688714027405,
0.0798352062702179,
0.16718000173568726,
-1.042750597000122,
0.31576383113861084,
0.1928846389055252,
0.2874796986579895,
-0.12782956659793854,
-0.33127450942993164,
-0.1853751391172409,
-0.20298618078231812,
-0.2804005742073059,
-0.7643049359321594,
0.3003286123275757,
0.1474720984697342,
0.783320963382721,
0.3912791609764099,
-0.05772102624177933,
0.7685675024986267,
-0.6339132785797119,
0.5429044365882874,
-0.13400082290172577,
-0.7955132722854614,
0.28466010093688965,
-0.33768731355667114,
-0.03862640634179115,
0.6884604692459106,
0.5236290693283081,
-0.3708547353744507,
-0.05534559488296509,
-0.6728098392486572,
-1.0881427526474,
0.5584135055541992,
0.09186244010925293,
-0.030455635860562325,
-0.003985665272921324,
0.6380129456520081,
-0.14599016308784485,
0.1301509588956833,
-0.3905763626098633,
0.06698785722255707,
0.32385289669036865,
0.14025761187076569,
-0.2762717306613922,
-0.6796342134475708,
-0.27400416135787964,
-0.000365162908565253,
0.6390672326087952,
-0.08071576058864594,
0.06323148310184479,
0.37827232480049133,
-0.12482629716396332,
0.02275087498128414,
0.4266713857650757,
0.6311854720115662,
0.6585708260536194,
-0.3824070394039154,
0.017715800553560257,
0.5740681290626526,
-0.6294135451316833,
-0.08552885055541992,
0.1374654322862625,
0.21079249680042267,
-0.452727347612381,
0.605050802230835,
0.44477036595344543,
0.4410446584224701,
-1.049033284187317,
0.33066216111183167,
0.2283354550600052,
-0.06203692778944969,
-0.5338590145111084,
0.15093368291854858,
-0.0036925554741173983,
0.3023800253868103,
0.26541373133659363,
-0.08927564322948456,
0.5914080142974854,
-0.5677299499511719,
0.17965751886367798,
0.60991370677948,
-0.39732640981674194,
-0.11638711392879486,
0.44912785291671753,
0.15897086262702942,
0.14021781086921692,
0.2304771989583969,
-0.065493643283844,
-0.2761569023132324,
0.6786128282546997,
0.22384774684906006,
0.9569762349128723,
-0.20823261141777039,
0.18413594365119934,
0.20762798190116882,
0.6044860482215881,
-0.2966513931751251,
0.6103800535202026,
0.5169644951820374,
-0.40516021847724915,
-0.5412974953651428,
-0.4529683291912079,
-0.575505793094635,
0.35430192947387695,
-0.5987539291381836,
0.03989001736044884,
-0.4426383078098297,
-0.2523527443408966,
-0.2652185261249542,
0.14284472167491913,
-0.6678457260131836,
0.4221803843975067,
-0.18078479170799255,
0.8991091251373291,
-0.6028188467025757,
0.294586181640625,
0.6228631138801575,
-0.12298362702131271,
-0.9887808561325073,
0.1871112883090973,
0.0862993448972702,
-0.63184654712677,
0.7179563641548157,
0.29718053340911865,
-0.11021119356155396,
-0.42057669162750244,
-0.21493104100227356,
-1.1456122398376465,
1.3750158548355103,
0.2815100848674774,
-0.564652144908905,
-0.10717164725065231,
0.08461421728134155,
0.6686517000198364,
-0.029954690486192703,
0.12648458778858185,
0.6227761507034302,
0.2995181977748871,
0.1588945984840393,
-0.9899696707725525,
0.15001237392425537,
0.2276880145072937,
0.2590402066707611,
0.2826243042945862,
-0.47153404355049133,
0.6149271726608276,
-0.37781062722206116,
-0.22797642648220062,
-0.035978078842163086,
0.5419882535934448,
0.3194107711315155,
0.4444774389266968,
0.36678653955459595,
0.23790526390075684,
0.6519491672515869,
0.27964308857917786,
1.3372931480407715,
-0.25148090720176697,
0.17099818587303162,
1.0193983316421509,
-0.4425491988658905,
1.0071203708648682,
0.3368167281150818,
-0.2421271651983261,
0.11753490567207336,
0.4669254422187805,
0.17873138189315796,
0.24338360130786896,
0.125925213098526,
-0.04382955655455589,
-0.1813959926366806,
0.06581095606088638,
-0.22110222280025482,
0.3815009891986847,
0.6360690593719482,
-0.42766109108924866,
-0.06439100950956345,
-0.09297512471675873,
-0.05255354568362236,
-0.1275230497121811,
-0.37114861607551575,
0.6793520450592041,
0.3005634546279907,
-0.3619225323200226,
0.30736055970191956,
-0.04868144914507866,
0.4960204064846039,
-0.6927804946899414,
0.1388893574476242,
0.1014384925365448,
0.21380570530891418,
-0.20270167291164398,
-0.813685953617096,
0.6300759315490723,
0.03517763689160347,
-0.08446750789880753,
0.02193758636713028,
0.7821792364120483,
-0.055716607719659805,
-0.7178764343261719,
0.22492755949497223,
0.37282079458236694,
0.13597111403942108,
-0.4208237826824188,
-0.43509840965270996,
-0.09659372270107269,
-0.31397631764411926,
-0.443803995847702,
0.22165736556053162,
0.24513714015483856,
-0.2625325620174408,
0.9112406969070435,
0.5350642204284668,
0.17067688703536987,
-0.22158515453338623,
-0.18142594397068024,
0.8839368224143982,
-0.7952318787574768,
-0.15908405184745789,
-0.7382504940032959,
0.5375107526779175,
-0.0075638205744326115,
-0.1337880641222,
0.7455343008041382,
0.4150439500808716,
0.41491490602493286,
-0.19095666706562042,
0.7463958263397217,
0.1168413832783699,
0.6325424313545227,
-0.832496166229248,
0.7882907390594482,
-0.5828720331192017,
0.4646242558956146,
-0.5815334916114807,
-0.5669382214546204,
-0.4621051251888275,
0.15688513219356537,
-0.5607044696807861,
0.039170391857624054,
0.6709195971488953,
0.7411656379699707,
0.16559331119060516,
-0.5336084961891174,
0.3544065058231354,
0.18217062950134277,
0.5594485402107239,
0.4602830708026886,
0.5332641005516052,
-0.2995050549507141,
0.590923011302948,
0.04901467263698578,
-0.2208651751279831,
-0.47652125358581543,
-1.12723970413208,
-1.015611171722412,
-0.25231850147247314,
-0.18958602845668793,
-0.20042426884174347,
-0.05772010236978531,
0.7034647464752197,
0.46595290303230286,
-0.5891268849372864,
0.03995386138558388,
0.17845682799816132,
-0.14760899543762207,
-0.0820620208978653,
-0.15279723703861237,
0.5311866402626038,
-0.12066026031970978,
-0.36942169070243835,
0.4441630244255066,
0.34942683577537537,
0.08305705338716507,
-0.21638913452625275,
0.22257593274116516,
0.03150784969329834,
0.3000428080558777,
0.774218738079071,
0.31876295804977417,
-0.6157565712928772,
-0.5453678965568542,
0.15101711452007294,
-0.16826537251472473,
-0.3508898615837097,
0.6263266801834106,
-0.3188961148262024,
0.30772775411605835,
0.5407692193984985,
0.8318718671798706,
0.1603137105703354,
-0.16779077053070068,
0.49989911913871765,
-0.563012421131134,
0.12784677743911743,
0.13628551363945007,
0.36289092898368835,
0.22139841318130493,
-0.9175939559936523,
0.6342719793319702,
-0.07522591948509216,
-0.6488682627677917,
-0.6913598775863647,
0.2788008749485016,
-1.0902695655822754,
-0.14566054940223694,
1.4695796966552734,
-0.07026783376932144,
0.10364473611116409,
-0.03176898881793022,
-0.48273876309394836,
0.2326074242591858,
-0.14236272871494293,
0.9675657153129578,
0.6059171557426453,
-0.03821549564599991,
0.3611685335636139,
-0.9188637137413025,
0.4655432403087616,
0.20227566361427307,
-0.973728597164154,
-0.017045358195900917,
0.3011826276779175,
0.41798070073127747,
0.25493329763412476,
0.529382050037384,
-0.23646876215934753,
0.21923887729644775,
-0.4276328980922699,
0.053431883454322815,
0.011842284351587296,
-0.5534341335296631,
-0.41544488072395325,
0.21456263959407806,
0.23569969832897186,
0.13570590317249298
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10272v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10272v2
|
Connected Speech-Based Cognitive Assessment in Chinese and English
| 2024-06-11T19:04:29 | 2024-06-18T10:41:48 |
Saturnino Luz, Sofia De La Fuente Garcia, Fasih Haider, Davida Fromm, Brian MacWhinney, Alyssa Lanzi, Ya-Ning Chang, Chia-Ju Chou, Yi-Chien Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SD, eess.AS, J.3; I.5.4
|
We present a novel benchmark dataset and prediction tasks for investigating
approaches to assess cognitive function through analysis of connected speech.
The dataset consists of speech samples and clinical information for speakers of
Mandarin Chinese and English with different levels of cognitive impairment as
well as individuals with normal cognition. These data have been carefully
matched by age and sex by propensity score analysis to ensure balance and
representativity in model training. The prediction tasks encompass mild
cognitive impairment diagnosis and cognitive test score prediction. This
framework was designed to encourage the development of approaches to
speech-based cognitive assessment which generalise across languages. We
illustrate it by presenting baseline prediction models that employ
language-agnostic and comparable features for diagnosis and cognitive test
score prediction. The models achieved unweighted average recall was 59.2% in
diagnosis, and root mean squared error of 2.89 in score prediction.
|
[
-0.16568982601165771,
-0.6586788296699524,
0.23590844869613647,
0.22317726910114288,
0.021476538851857185,
-0.30040013790130615,
-0.5034489631652832,
-0.7601548433303833,
0.13224217295646667,
0.4917061924934387,
-0.5511835217475891,
-0.1455686241388321,
-0.16311314702033997,
-0.4640354812145233,
-0.06427192687988281,
0.5299548506736755,
0.3715938329696655,
0.4912159740924835,
-0.41393783688545227,
-0.3507690131664276,
-1.2949544191360474,
-0.32809218764305115,
-1.0461764335632324,
-0.40724611282348633,
0.11655393987894058,
0.31312429904937744,
0.6899746656417847,
0.3362073600292206,
0.3981253504753113,
0.14646559953689575,
-0.020905252546072006,
-0.10138028860092163,
-0.06559503078460693,
-0.08185171335935593,
-0.2449834644794464,
-0.30884435772895813,
-0.7423302531242371,
0.20126836001873016,
0.5042094588279724,
1.1919406652450562,
-0.27364131808280945,
0.14641115069389343,
0.17740701138973236,
0.39848026633262634,
-0.3226637840270996,
0.24459640681743622,
-0.8276090025901794,
-0.04255157336592674,
-0.23739682137966156,
0.15700817108154297,
-0.3744971752166748,
-0.07462192326784134,
0.2618826925754547,
-0.6177941560745239,
0.08180524408817291,
-0.07187346369028091,
0.5048664212226868,
0.19445949792861938,
-0.3282929062843323,
-0.3312361538410187,
-0.5176653265953064,
0.7805917263031006,
-0.6953843235969543,
0.09426168352365494,
0.5507200360298157,
0.6374467611312866,
0.07401403784751892,
-0.8532214164733887,
-0.5312326550483704,
-0.6003322005271912,
-0.15077568590641022,
0.5531349778175354,
0.00046262418618425727,
0.07899963110685349,
0.07549277693033218,
0.4705520272254944,
-0.8576564192771912,
0.2391912043094635,
-0.4784696102142334,
-0.5115362405776978,
0.8325605988502502,
0.2853008508682251,
0.6308112144470215,
-0.1380498856306076,
-0.29097411036491394,
0.14658990502357483,
-0.5368198156356812,
0.31511789560317993,
-0.19216708838939667,
0.6830763816833496,
-0.27056053280830383,
0.30655622482299805,
-0.25096502900123596,
0.8001378178596497,
-0.21641793847084045,
-0.04720310494303703,
0.17875681817531586,
-0.3507860004901886,
-0.16253751516342163,
0.4992356300354004,
0.8123379349708557,
0.2765943706035614,
0.5950300693511963,
0.17231512069702148,
0.14204588532447815,
0.44081565737724304,
-0.02052389271557331,
-0.19834452867507935,
-0.5969741940498352,
0.3335965573787689,
-0.33767902851104736,
0.08702128380537033,
-0.0009382814751006663,
-0.5602067112922668,
-0.28279539942741394,
-0.35130998492240906,
0.36179670691490173,
-0.44690263271331787,
-0.4429931640625,
0.08657442033290863,
0.1253238022327423,
-0.05638189613819122,
0.16589932143688202,
-0.8478164076805115,
0.42472755908966064,
0.5418051481246948,
0.5384098291397095,
-0.3583761751651764,
-0.13200783729553223,
-0.48708492517471313,
0.18711821734905243,
-0.45872002840042114,
0.7832465171813965,
-0.48040854930877686,
-0.18692876398563385,
0.10453583300113678,
0.03748590126633644,
-0.43810248374938965,
-0.44740307331085205,
0.8702459335327148,
0.1012905016541481,
0.5192908644676208,
-0.09109367430210114,
-0.4977627396583557,
-0.3439628481864929,
0.15659776329994202,
-0.8393966555595398,
1.2049074172973633,
0.074854277074337,
-0.627629280090332,
0.38372039794921875,
-0.37056347727775574,
-0.5820817947387695,
0.40891191363334656,
-0.2724985182285309,
-0.12621843814849854,
-0.2167842835187912,
0.3071669042110443,
0.5023718476295471,
-0.507327139377594,
0.6640962362289429,
-0.3137744069099426,
-0.43078088760375977,
0.105260469019413,
-0.5227943062782288,
0.8866914510726929,
0.04129679501056671,
-0.0514855831861496,
0.10815969109535217,
-0.7641453146934509,
0.348874568939209,
-0.1898524910211563,
0.06875073909759521,
-0.42316028475761414,
0.2141556441783905,
0.07820471376180649,
0.23621658980846405,
0.5166354775428772,
-0.4237132668495178,
-0.27076455950737,
-0.41050949692726135,
0.4887044429779053,
0.32700490951538086,
0.1696120649576187,
-0.19398212432861328,
-0.4639362692832947,
0.23354801535606384,
0.1141921654343605,
0.30299484729766846,
-0.19268788397312164,
-0.8390768766403198,
-0.3604336678981781,
-0.2915308475494385,
0.19967028498649597,
0.8609170317649841,
-0.5751816034317017,
0.4484264850616455,
-0.5379555225372314,
-0.8477340936660767,
-0.4348795711994171,
-0.2559395134449005,
0.42801880836486816,
0.8430033326148987,
0.34334030747413635,
-0.30227211117744446,
-0.19844354689121246,
-0.6243941187858582,
-0.304860919713974,
-0.6047149896621704,
-0.29389259219169617,
0.23438605666160583,
0.10055721551179886,
0.10971453040838242,
0.39163559675216675,
-0.3035813570022583,
-0.6690267324447632,
-0.006823311094194651,
-0.17141292989253998,
0.4132916033267975,
0.587658166885376,
0.3187408447265625,
-0.7347890734672546,
-0.5117926597595215,
0.39673763513565063,
-0.7503818273544312,
0.07043109089136124,
0.0542580671608448,
0.28810369968414307,
-0.27375224232673645,
0.47196871042251587,
-0.1858760118484497,
0.22759725153446198,
0.5929410457611084,
-0.17335285246372223,
0.4001412093639374,
-0.09572961926460266,
0.21445514261722565,
-1.030922770500183,
-0.12701131403446198,
-0.14290504157543182,
0.02774483524262905,
-0.6930689811706543,
-0.284602552652359,
-0.1561952382326126,
-0.30791255831718445,
-0.3432537615299225,
0.35627689957618713,
-0.3371867537498474,
-0.10753379762172699,
-0.0791519284248352,
0.521447479724884,
-0.3381224572658539,
0.4074016213417053,
0.16052740812301636,
0.6952978372573853,
0.8615056872367859,
-0.4744095206260681,
0.32496705651283264,
0.10031645745038986,
-0.2684284448623657,
0.5668993592262268,
-0.8247063755989075,
0.02902350015938282,
0.44687730073928833,
-0.20389793813228607,
-1.3909820318222046,
-0.09702309966087341,
-0.23148539662361145,
-0.8080164194107056,
0.12931855022907257,
0.5208927989006042,
0.06414881348609924,
-0.3094618618488312,
-0.17041024565696716,
0.4622418284416199,
0.2043108195066452,
-0.23952661454677582,
0.6345322132110596,
0.6013363599777222,
-0.285492479801178,
-0.24727356433868408,
-0.9216291308403015,
-0.2778488099575043,
-0.15521559119224548,
-0.7810534238815308,
0.6072258353233337,
0.018525488674640656,
0.01274934969842434,
-0.022884797304868698,
0.2191275954246521,
-0.2510431408882141,
0.11662952601909637,
0.1949484497308731,
0.3976832628250122,
-0.3777003884315491,
0.28819262981414795,
-0.16521532833576202,
0.08388297259807587,
0.07287857681512833,
0.071312814950943,
0.2791491150856018,
-0.1594143807888031,
-0.3431553542613983,
-0.3161628246307373,
0.09480675309896469,
0.5010426044464111,
-0.3155386447906494,
0.208913192152977,
0.5156234502792358,
-0.9263091087341309,
0.09660904109477997,
-0.3455907702445984,
0.025608181953430176,
-0.401709645986557,
0.4011266827583313,
-0.5289769768714905,
-0.6299947500228882,
0.6916106939315796,
0.08654189109802246,
-0.06617473810911179,
0.5725605487823486,
0.732935905456543,
0.03118107281625271,
0.840268611907959,
0.3761081099510193,
-0.33888334035873413,
0.24877192080020905,
0.3124311566352844,
0.047826360911130905,
-0.7661123871803284,
0.023069381713867188,
-0.37553641200065613,
0.3076748549938202,
-0.803838312625885,
-0.25938886404037476,
0.3518715500831604,
0.06144348904490471,
-0.1759389489889145,
0.30127111077308655,
-0.6264100074768066,
0.039370954036712646,
0.26228588819503784,
0.03927982971072197,
0.13526102900505066,
-0.3585881292819977,
-0.3612392246723175,
-0.2949272692203522,
-0.6692204475402832,
-0.297427773475647,
1.0524158477783203,
0.021308936178684235,
-0.04649379849433899,
0.019581371918320656,
0.01713464967906475,
0.7281036376953125,
0.267660915851593,
-0.8781864643096924,
0.4731891453266144,
-0.40113601088523865,
-0.6575947999954224,
-0.46808743476867676,
-0.18132559955120087,
-0.8328847289085388,
0.0957244485616684,
-0.12605665624141693,
-1.0373740196228027,
-0.14460629224777222,
-0.1649494618177414,
-0.42465031147003174,
-0.2720238268375397,
-0.6198394894599915,
0.8637076616287231,
-0.1331397444009781,
-0.15133310854434967,
-0.44141635298728943,
-0.454878568649292,
0.855667769908905,
-0.16562436521053314,
0.16696922481060028,
-0.3558523952960968,
0.2845759391784668,
0.9803783297538757,
0.11554287374019623,
0.6606763601303101,
-0.12692415714263916,
0.3567894995212555,
0.3576202690601349,
-0.22551538050174713,
-0.1312876045703888,
0.06330111622810364,
-0.3955461382865906,
0.18796700239181519,
0.5563642978668213,
-0.5477718114852905,
-0.6732699275016785,
0.7138581275939941,
-0.5796465277671814,
-0.5291391611099243,
-0.5058164000511169,
-0.41854408383369446,
-0.869836151599884,
0.24983511865139008,
-0.05270889028906822,
0.4994305968284607,
-0.5325660705566406,
0.07225260883569717,
0.29373762011528015,
-0.09497597068548203,
0.4841986894607544,
0.7686803936958313,
0.02528352662920952,
-0.6972724795341492,
0.8433651328086853,
0.17528164386749268,
0.22491471469402313,
0.2868286669254303,
0.20730385184288025,
-0.15632858872413635,
-0.5402399301528931,
-0.07374704629182816,
0.11295890063047409,
-0.5908339619636536,
0.06336569786071777,
0.1517374962568283,
-0.5292510986328125,
-0.4912104308605194,
0.2177906334400177,
-0.3467586934566498,
-0.3285912275314331,
0.11094346642494202,
-0.10027273744344711,
0.05163738504052162,
0.47368124127388,
0.16726867854595184,
0.191695898771286,
-0.47037601470947266,
0.31840184330940247,
0.20978756248950958,
0.1513502150774002,
0.08658463507890701,
-0.3689853847026825,
-0.4196740984916687,
0.14277689158916473,
-0.24893473088741302,
-0.6666638255119324,
0.10656736046075821,
0.5099678635597229,
0.7693257331848145,
0.42985254526138306,
0.2594170868396759,
0.741295576095581,
-0.32460394501686096,
1.3040556907653809,
0.39064744114875793,
-1.0122559070587158,
0.6831173300743103,
-0.1985412985086441,
0.21704724431037903,
0.4272172152996063,
0.2779651880264282,
-0.820176899433136,
-0.247669979929924,
-0.5467584729194641,
-0.5236052870750427,
0.5012838840484619,
0.09253475069999695,
-0.24079997837543488,
-0.11457421630620956,
0.2186594009399414,
-0.1779734194278717,
-0.2423926293849945,
-0.4719800651073456,
-0.2397732436656952,
-0.15000253915786743,
-0.4542163014411926,
-0.3484037220478058,
0.09467554837465286,
-0.10827437043190002,
-0.5948125720024109,
0.6445524096488953,
-0.2903551459312439,
0.39713096618652344,
0.2999204099178314,
0.2311740517616272,
0.004750365391373634,
-0.07890798896551132,
0.4117354154586792,
0.7004067301750183,
-0.20278112590312958,
-0.24499598145484924,
0.33292505145072937,
-0.816826581954956,
-0.16748173534870148,
0.1587488055229187,
0.17123551666736603,
-0.1415477842092514,
0.8914161324501038,
0.6628322005271912,
0.18603019416332245,
-0.8039490580558777,
0.5764197111129761,
-0.12701024115085602,
0.0576285794377327,
-0.8558048605918884,
0.03253563120961189,
0.2778773903846741,
-0.03905826061964035,
0.2553344666957855,
-0.0560128279030323,
0.03301835432648659,
-0.6034556031227112,
0.4924497902393341,
0.41102418303489685,
-1.170814037322998,
-0.48196035623550415,
0.6623883247375488,
0.042959216982126236,
-0.12282201647758484,
0.6244274377822876,
0.25357064604759216,
-0.3695908486843109,
0.5236506462097168,
0.34000715613365173,
0.7686614394187927,
-0.4940314292907715,
-0.045381978154182434,
0.526968240737915,
0.42198115587234497,
0.14456652104854584,
0.3897407352924347,
0.06992006301879883,
-1.0747497081756592,
-0.15056723356246948,
-0.2022971659898758,
-0.3569386601448059,
0.16851045191287994,
-1.088658094406128,
0.4580453932285309,
-0.3401270806789398,
-0.15109460055828094,
0.33299005031585693,
0.6561650037765503,
-0.3840040862560272,
0.7496011257171631,
0.33558353781700134,
0.7803778648376465,
-0.982703447341919,
1.4265854358673096,
0.6980000138282776,
-0.5651165843009949,
-0.980847179889679,
0.12935873866081238,
-0.14651766419410706,
-0.9803286194801331,
0.10231538861989975,
0.2663794457912445,
0.2093343585729599,
-0.24239082634449005,
0.09823060035705566,
-0.6883853077888489,
1.3409626483917236,
0.27420780062675476,
-0.28252992033958435,
0.20721584558486938,
0.21868965029716492,
0.6710990071296692,
-0.6902281045913696,
0.6162724494934082,
0.8512278199195862,
0.35692501068115234,
0.008850686252117157,
-1.2073352336883545,
0.1422184556722641,
-0.2423955351114273,
0.0480269193649292,
-0.2151925414800644,
-0.6325981616973877,
0.9626806974411011,
0.2159048318862915,
-0.2465067207813263,
0.07561072707176208,
0.9933631420135498,
0.3925233483314514,
0.621637225151062,
0.4936431348323822,
0.23359638452529907,
1.1609413623809814,
-0.036995336413383484,
0.6918177008628845,
-0.4760105013847351,
0.0951886996626854,
1.215440273284912,
-0.40667662024497986,
1.1904594898223877,
0.3033325970172882,
-0.30121880769729614,
0.29594090580940247,
0.765466570854187,
0.22471921145915985,
0.4378579556941986,
-0.004097955767065287,
-0.17891982197761536,
-0.04092762991786003,
-0.5387387871742249,
-0.292828768491745,
0.6095495223999023,
0.763253927230835,
-0.03984396159648895,
0.17837154865264893,
-0.06034737080335617,
-0.19098548591136932,
0.6029739379882812,
-0.40096333622932434,
0.5655882358551025,
0.11892586946487427,
-0.9190243482589722,
0.7177817821502686,
-0.31694671511650085,
0.4354163408279419,
-0.5846301317214966,
0.03992355614900589,
-0.029082927852869034,
0.2265627533197403,
-0.03259265422821045,
-0.7879943251609802,
0.45577532052993774,
-0.5245819687843323,
-0.12319891899824142,
0.40008869767189026,
0.7013309001922607,
-0.6036556959152222,
-0.44951504468917847,
0.6636871099472046,
0.42444878816604614,
0.12045406550168991,
-0.03548108786344528,
-0.8477200865745544,
-0.2543163001537323,
0.22147448360919952,
0.08022565394639969,
0.19778861105442047,
0.26471078395843506,
-0.5379703640937805,
0.6000221967697144,
0.4162195920944214,
0.28621646761894226,
0.004483563359826803,
0.059070147573947906,
0.46867048740386963,
-0.6292222142219543,
-0.47390511631965637,
-0.4490906596183777,
0.4069206714630127,
-0.04013283550739288,
-0.6853447556495667,
0.382090300321579,
0.31743693351745605,
0.7397363781929016,
0.12778109312057495,
0.7233478426933289,
0.12228429317474365,
0.8184434175491333,
-0.4887203276157379,
0.7089008092880249,
-0.45192480087280273,
-0.02253708429634571,
-0.18233956396579742,
-0.5069707632064819,
-0.17250847816467285,
0.0794416293501854,
-0.4560486972332001,
-0.19763566553592682,
0.9343084096908569,
0.7382081151008606,
-0.04494040831923485,
0.41772690415382385,
0.8107243180274963,
0.04723823070526123,
0.2866160571575165,
0.957132875919342,
0.5204188823699951,
-0.6833743453025818,
0.1529994010925293,
-0.32679271697998047,
-0.3231777548789978,
0.25399917364120483,
-0.6358316540718079,
-0.946856677532196,
-0.8003014922142029,
-0.41865992546081543,
0.16248443722724915,
-0.006017820443958044,
0.32809892296791077,
0.5427736639976501,
-1.0505645275115967,
-0.4357997179031372,
-0.014360344968736172,
-0.14672043919563293,
-0.9267932772636414,
-0.31199008226394653,
0.574583113193512,
-0.07485029101371765,
-0.5636550784111023,
0.48518556356430054,
0.018043585121631622,
-0.3177434504032135,
-0.3286116421222687,
-0.011798852123320103,
-0.2969060242176056,
0.14243601262569427,
0.3355225920677185,
0.1884378343820572,
-0.9463181495666504,
-0.2997000813484192,
-0.3699837028980255,
-0.09374912083148956,
-0.17870783805847168,
0.5159875750541687,
-0.8203015327453613,
0.5909883379936218,
0.31585583090782166,
0.4306661784648895,
0.2574094831943512,
-0.0342148020863533,
0.7930957674980164,
-0.33225205540657043,
0.5420451164245605,
0.39293017983436584,
0.4913861155509949,
0.48702043294906616,
-0.507081925868988,
0.45874807238578796,
0.2532905638217926,
-0.2799330949783325,
-0.688835620880127,
0.1873394250869751,
-1.2476567029953003,
-0.11225441843271255,
0.5331251621246338,
-0.631260097026825,
-0.20833100378513336,
-0.24025200307369232,
0.010140527039766312,
0.4603808522224426,
0.014802365563809872,
0.3751624524593353,
0.8396554589271545,
-0.1795523762702942,
-0.0538325235247612,
-0.7742952704429626,
0.42527467012405396,
0.7331869602203369,
-0.38861796259880066,
0.160817489027977,
0.2816987633705139,
0.05252791568636894,
0.24844864010810852,
0.5496054291725159,
-0.10685765743255615,
0.5242264270782471,
0.04027116671204567,
-0.10438627004623413,
0.1543760895729065,
-0.01990382745862007,
-0.17851600050926208,
0.03491504490375519,
0.01800469309091568,
-0.4124670624732971
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.07657v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.07657v1
|
OPTune: Efficient Online Preference Tuning
| 2024-06-11T18:55:04 | 2024-06-11T18:55:04 |
Lichang Chen, Jiuhai Chen, Chenxi Liu, John Kirchenbauer, Davit Soselia, Chen Zhu, Tom Goldstein, Tianyi Zhou, Heng Huang
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Reinforcement learning with human feedback~(RLHF) is critical for aligning
Large Language Models (LLMs) with human preference. Compared to the widely
studied offline version of RLHF, \emph{e.g.} direct preference optimization
(DPO), recent works have shown that the online variants achieve even better
alignment. However, online alignment requires on-the-fly generation of new
training data, which is costly, hard to parallelize, and suffers from varying
quality and utility. In this paper, we propose a more efficient data
exploration strategy for online preference tuning (OPTune), which does not rely
on human-curated or pre-collected teacher responses but dynamically samples
informative responses for on-policy preference alignment. During data
generation, OPTune only selects prompts whose (re)generated responses can
potentially provide more informative and higher-quality training signals than
the existing responses. In the training objective, OPTune reweights each
generated response (pair) by its utility in improving the alignment so that
learning can be focused on the most helpful samples. Throughout our
evaluations, OPTune'd LLMs maintain the instruction-following benefits provided
by standard preference tuning whilst enjoying 1.27-1.56x faster training speed
due to the efficient data exploration strategy.
|
[
-0.44379332661628723,
-0.534041166305542,
0.44130876660346985,
-0.09951001405715942,
-0.07399139553308487,
0.18947000801563263,
-0.6100825667381287,
-0.19904491305351257,
0.4291638433933258,
0.4040929079055786,
-0.8683949112892151,
-0.1912819743156433,
-0.17320282757282257,
-0.025426853448152542,
0.2977152466773987,
0.7483609318733215,
-0.1782994568347931,
-0.05484278127551079,
-0.25971248745918274,
-0.07051744312047958,
-0.34096667170524597,
-0.21201907098293304,
-0.759709894657135,
-0.3819168508052826,
0.47668761014938354,
0.9913820624351501,
0.7243046164512634,
0.7634491324424744,
0.4317665696144104,
0.2996656894683838,
0.18565383553504944,
0.5515117645263672,
-0.9225932955741882,
0.23496143519878387,
0.06163604184985161,
-0.5155137777328491,
-0.40657272934913635,
-0.011412639170885086,
0.2617340683937073,
0.35360175371170044,
-0.4929333031177521,
0.027181489393115044,
-0.19684375822544098,
0.8190596699714661,
-0.5882922410964966,
-0.04368302971124649,
-0.5909909605979919,
0.36043235659599304,
0.03827594965696335,
-0.5955280065536499,
-0.3690033257007599,
-0.8067096471786499,
0.39295539259910583,
-1.1048742532730103,
-0.013554027304053307,
0.3465563952922821,
0.8895949125289917,
0.51735919713974,
-0.22424976527690887,
0.13007399439811707,
-0.45148712396621704,
0.9613714218139648,
-0.46892157196998596,
0.34770217537879944,
0.5487636923789978,
0.4295071065425873,
-0.29174163937568665,
-0.23655997216701508,
-0.216541588306427,
-0.1851549595594406,
0.11259796470403671,
0.3030731976032257,
0.24435549974441528,
0.12142025679349899,
0.11339186131954193,
0.42083173990249634,
-0.5092177987098694,
0.2773045599460602,
0.06676056981086731,
-0.1834871470928192,
0.8525417447090149,
-0.09543375670909882,
-0.0316612534224987,
-0.05816787853837013,
-0.2908763885498047,
-0.4976445436477661,
-0.6364756226539612,
0.1650344729423523,
0.7466797828674316,
0.22378499805927277,
0.0025844171177595854,
0.3556528687477112,
-0.5001654028892517,
0.9764226675033569,
0.4749743640422821,
-0.25150758028030396,
0.3814969062805176,
-0.09888484328985214,
0.0295020192861557,
0.4612840414047241,
0.6738487482070923,
0.648110032081604,
0.3541259765625,
-0.2061111330986023,
-0.13209202885627747,
-0.025055810809135437,
0.3827838599681854,
-0.6844695210456848,
-0.3153361678123474,
0.3261100947856903,
-0.27435949444770813,
-0.6960541605949402,
-0.08412275463342667,
-0.8377071022987366,
-0.18929775059223175,
-0.6511852741241455,
0.10655289888381958,
-0.2594785690307617,
-0.20428034663200378,
0.12097162753343582,
-0.008106477558612823,
0.1292426735162735,
0.3759518563747406,
-1.066085934638977,
0.07827447354793549,
0.5455470681190491,
0.5878446102142334,
-0.6787089109420776,
-0.06894419342279434,
-0.7839412689208984,
-0.044296473264694214,
-0.31193673610687256,
0.7855210900306702,
-0.6686534285545349,
-0.2988862693309784,
-0.009446635842323303,
-0.2618750333786011,
0.10922691971063614,
-0.5424438118934631,
0.6417089104652405,
-0.7116987109184265,
0.3885532319545746,
-0.2981894612312317,
-0.7468516826629639,
-0.1552238017320633,
0.3510892391204834,
-0.6537099480628967,
1.2621451616287231,
0.1608206182718277,
-0.7844018340110779,
0.6508159637451172,
-0.7064678072929382,
-0.07137930393218994,
-0.0581355020403862,
-0.2786509692668915,
-0.57393878698349,
-0.034909725189208984,
0.7406845092773438,
0.2979152202606201,
-0.02301894500851631,
0.555766761302948,
-0.4855926036834717,
-0.43633735179901123,
0.13530941307544708,
-0.18806371092796326,
0.43861106038093567,
0.18647894263267517,
-0.48581841588020325,
0.4405764639377594,
-0.7587071657180786,
0.43954822421073914,
0.2207692563533783,
-0.6167219281196594,
-0.28279897570610046,
0.34862256050109863,
0.035117894411087036,
-0.1276085525751114,
0.17796821892261505,
-0.6318689584732056,
0.3962412476539612,
-0.6037359833717346,
0.3739812970161438,
1.0093101263046265,
-0.09028640389442444,
0.41666898131370544,
-0.5093124508857727,
0.6374683976173401,
-0.3491053879261017,
0.2024764120578766,
0.16610807180404663,
-0.08206857740879059,
-0.8925254940986633,
-0.1473306119441986,
0.29898887872695923,
0.3037739098072052,
-0.6377877593040466,
0.5225733518600464,
-0.4538373053073883,
-0.3166711926460266,
-0.7246237993240356,
0.10933621972799301,
0.17677097022533417,
0.3503873944282532,
0.3406573235988617,
0.02580196037888527,
-0.5650800466537476,
-0.9091295003890991,
-0.28268882632255554,
0.18536362051963806,
0.27873316407203674,
0.8756533265113831,
-0.1091671735048294,
-0.2103576958179474,
1.3351764678955078,
-0.7776038646697998,
0.039170339703559875,
-0.3488512933254242,
0.049408674240112305,
0.29469671845436096,
0.1276451200246811,
0.3415912985801697,
-0.8294923901557922,
-0.642910361289978,
-0.06424953788518906,
-0.30481696128845215,
-0.10463976114988327,
-0.09010521322488785,
-0.4280584454536438,
-0.007126553915441036,
0.22701594233512878,
0.027068717405200005,
-0.1820191591978073,
0.5070199966430664,
0.09117814153432846,
-0.0012977271107956767,
-0.24643340706825256,
0.25056666135787964,
-0.9930172562599182,
-0.11814944446086884,
-0.2306659072637558,
-0.6267630457878113,
-0.20510083436965942,
0.06274891644716263,
0.20756365358829498,
0.06981105357408524,
-0.4965563416481018,
0.2763979136943817,
-0.4542113244533539,
-0.05187069997191429,
-0.2521010935306549,
0.39116525650024414,
-0.3117312490940094,
0.6783895492553711,
0.19936460256576538,
0.8334939479827881,
0.4081561863422394,
-0.7657185792922974,
0.5634934902191162,
0.15308992564678192,
-0.2665098011493683,
0.4347757399082184,
-0.33224618434906006,
0.4180243909358978,
-0.10638931393623352,
0.10980381816625595,
-0.766143262386322,
-0.3473654091358185,
0.1673787236213684,
-0.22294574975967407,
0.3325331509113312,
0.05580022186040878,
-0.08868566900491714,
-0.14960677921772003,
-0.6149613261222839,
0.36061185598373413,
0.27470964193344116,
-1.05355703830719,
0.3241279423236847,
0.5575790405273438,
0.06752707064151764,
-0.5852105021476746,
-0.09285376220941544,
-0.380903959274292,
-0.39253538846969604,
-0.39210331439971924,
0.574761688709259,
-0.07285872846841812,
-0.09288730472326279,
-0.24114687740802765,
-0.03356267884373665,
0.25943976640701294,
0.21715784072875977,
-0.0786789134144783,
0.4212473928928375,
0.0022393374238163233,
0.1095796450972557,
0.13329145312309265,
-0.22521346807479858,
-0.1683529168367386,
-0.23116551339626312,
0.6296948194503784,
0.10851436108350754,
-0.25373828411102295,
-0.2874409556388855,
0.0907304510474205,
0.3414819538593292,
-0.07293850928544998,
0.08490818738937378,
0.24827389419078827,
0.07847040146589279,
-0.3391138017177582,
-0.41926151514053345,
-0.46747952699661255,
-0.5132362842559814,
0.4243623912334442,
-0.0030510693322867155,
-0.7641854882240295,
-0.20148082077503204,
-0.23366813361644745,
0.5146730542182922,
0.11584170162677765,
0.1767675280570984,
-0.01961413212120533,
1.1339991092681885,
0.548888087272644,
-0.3523206114768982,
0.6611467599868774,
0.004090649075806141,
-0.00833619013428688,
-0.6699858903884888,
-0.053159456700086594,
-0.23230300843715668,
-0.6012272834777832,
-0.6266840696334839,
-0.3015749156475067,
0.4378167390823364,
-0.14337509870529175,
-0.1339828073978424,
0.25520846247673035,
-0.6935648918151855,
0.48410987854003906,
0.694077730178833,
0.4798920154571533,
0.20054951310157776,
0.3308926522731781,
-0.22526858747005463,
-0.3039535880088806,
-0.9564089179039001,
0.01961006224155426,
1.4707080125808716,
0.23160994052886963,
0.9411372542381287,
0.056803230196237564,
0.9827757477760315,
0.06325644254684448,
0.2661799490451813,
-0.9370610117912292,
0.43060916662216187,
0.19168245792388916,
-0.2727467715740204,
-0.3692513108253479,
-0.6603920459747314,
-0.7132127285003662,
0.24554578959941864,
-0.4228041172027588,
-0.38247570395469666,
-0.027731701731681824,
0.7428250312805176,
-0.5358750224113464,
0.1547957807779312,
-0.4592280089855194,
0.5512950420379639,
-0.9428000450134277,
-0.6213639974594116,
-0.3258292078971863,
-0.4504987895488739,
0.1670338213443756,
-0.037036534398794174,
0.020040923729538918,
-0.05261297523975372,
0.03472057357430458,
0.8823444247245789,
-0.24839083850383759,
0.5361523032188416,
-0.10164681077003479,
0.08984735608100891,
-0.16990937292575836,
-0.04775900021195412,
0.768064022064209,
-0.0341326966881752,
0.0886458232998848,
-0.3123360276222229,
-0.4427793622016907,
-0.0653463676571846,
-0.4622572362422943,
0.8630812168121338,
-1.0556445121765137,
-0.45525163412094116,
-0.5507036447525024,
-0.46222078800201416,
-0.5744221210479736,
0.00963515043258667,
0.23881982266902924,
0.21950079500675201,
-0.13922670483589172,
0.18198548257350922,
0.938159167766571,
-0.30522608757019043,
0.28337326645851135,
0.4870331883430481,
-0.4330295920372009,
-0.6882609128952026,
1.0738961696624756,
-0.28372302651405334,
0.32511386275291443,
0.7038716077804565,
0.5662685036659241,
-0.5529161095619202,
-0.07501981407403946,
-0.7027828097343445,
0.1123817041516304,
-0.31954917311668396,
-0.1404443234205246,
-0.5058630108833313,
0.24645452201366425,
-0.17613206803798676,
-0.3076830506324768,
-0.5220162272453308,
-0.28691366314888,
-0.3088759183883667,
-0.14800883829593658,
0.7209219932556152,
0.307359516620636,
0.04986162483692169,
0.3109583258628845,
-0.5139833092689514,
0.1788300722837448,
0.30377206206321716,
0.33056479692459106,
-0.18888677656650543,
-0.3715206980705261,
-0.015115732327103615,
0.11029154807329178,
-0.43747571110725403,
-0.8444441556930542,
0.30040600895881653,
0.3876146674156189,
0.6130263209342957,
0.8442282676696777,
0.34866324067115784,
0.8742764592170715,
-0.24975353479385376,
0.28365224599838257,
0.028289804235100746,
-0.5450953245162964,
0.6183411478996277,
-0.3089753985404968,
0.1250029057264328,
0.8819306492805481,
0.6710394024848938,
-0.4598003625869751,
0.03589572384953499,
-0.5667439699172974,
-1.0393059253692627,
1.0444309711456299,
-0.10717430710792542,
-0.2538136839866638,
0.3780784606933594,
0.4179666340351105,
0.043959613889455795,
0.35576489567756653,
-0.5544998645782471,
-0.4037846028804779,
-0.15995487570762634,
-0.10651759058237076,
-0.18516886234283447,
0.03745638579130173,
-0.1594536155462265,
-0.2799258232116699,
0.8305546045303345,
-0.2709299623966217,
0.11482372134923935,
0.0045227534137666225,
0.007515673991292715,
-0.3564338982105255,
0.12731850147247314,
0.3370765447616577,
0.34428977966308594,
-0.4578341543674469,
-0.07090352475643158,
0.0831337496638298,
-0.17682941257953644,
0.13355760276317596,
-0.11762548238039017,
-0.4405607283115387,
-0.31436747312545776,
-0.14876846969127655,
1.1539353132247925,
0.573455274105072,
-0.8217777013778687,
0.37406036257743835,
-0.2028508484363556,
-0.26040181517601013,
-0.3073495030403137,
0.4690655469894409,
-0.031722232699394226,
-0.12078797817230225,
-0.1295187920331955,
-0.029288070276379585,
0.05971144139766693,
-0.438541442155838,
0.1681288629770279,
0.47626274824142456,
-0.40183788537979126,
0.2928122282028198,
0.43858927488327026,
0.3400712013244629,
-0.22356829047203064,
0.7651068568229675,
-0.06674788892269135,
-0.7484639286994934,
0.3433286249637604,
0.3994531035423279,
0.6697993278503418,
-0.1290363073348999,
0.3711032569408417,
0.6268671751022339,
-0.10949116945266724,
-0.1555483192205429,
0.2355315387248993,
-0.3294079601764679,
-0.7933031320571899,
-0.17123547196388245,
-0.5541899800300598,
-0.6687284111976624,
0.03924344852566719,
-0.8315064311027527,
0.3607266843318939,
-0.2188633382320404,
-0.11626806855201721,
-0.42074063420295715,
-0.051557134836912155,
-0.3355396091938019,
0.06509711593389511,
-0.17040890455245972,
0.6197795867919922,
-0.568942129611969,
0.645156741142273,
0.6253933310508728,
0.04825786501169205,
-1.0115716457366943,
-0.03686228021979332,
0.02945849299430847,
-0.9268243908882141,
0.4292677640914917,
0.12107805907726288,
-0.1748240739107132,
0.279441773891449,
-0.39391911029815674,
-1.1491810083389282,
0.9575476050376892,
0.31601595878601074,
-0.9072721600532532,
0.1369810253381729,
-0.09495603293180466,
0.12473040819168091,
-0.2608128786087036,
0.6172389388084412,
0.5603644251823425,
0.6218127608299255,
0.018552055582404137,
-0.543850302696228,
-0.15275244414806366,
0.0012819359544664621,
-0.127570241689682,
0.36857131123542786,
-0.6360793113708496,
0.47290611267089844,
-0.2266748994588852,
-0.11713682860136032,
-0.34700900316238403,
0.5252431631088257,
0.21305479109287262,
-0.1802327185869217,
0.7575137615203857,
0.784578800201416,
0.7329128980636597,
-0.16145069897174835,
0.9245636463165283,
-0.34558793902397156,
0.4360833466053009,
1.2106236219406128,
-0.19919222593307495,
0.9982145428657532,
0.501473069190979,
-0.2049754410982132,
0.021151933819055557,
1.1025798320770264,
-0.018254589289426804,
0.7743792533874512,
0.28955700993537903,
-0.016793761402368546,
-0.6857550740242004,
-0.01846865750849247,
-0.339089572429657,
0.30219241976737976,
-0.12372046709060669,
-0.020004967227578163,
-0.24626564979553223,
-0.08197598904371262,
0.03859506547451019,
0.10199736803770065,
-0.24515841901302338,
0.9492083191871643,
-0.37095263600349426,
-1.404907464981079,
0.6889006495475769,
0.09323808550834656,
0.882163405418396,
-0.6452361345291138,
-0.041159890592098236,
-0.2369976043701172,
0.416753351688385,
-0.32167842984199524,
-0.332892507314682,
-0.1937301605939865,
-0.18383611738681793,
0.06472151726484299,
-0.33695757389068604,
0.32319119572639465,
-0.49252834916114807,
-0.2995773255825043,
0.2583318054676056,
0.12587502598762512,
-0.05136347562074661,
0.14131876826286316,
-0.6758185625076294,
0.015785159543156624,
0.4785839915275574,
-0.35975927114486694,
0.39478832483291626,
-0.30287864804267883,
0.09829453378915787,
0.6010415554046631,
0.7739683985710144,
0.2683400511741638,
0.04976161941885948,
-0.17309118807315826,
0.7718851566314697,
-0.3384690582752228,
-0.7060187458992004,
-0.5277436971664429,
0.1414555460214615,
-0.4032495617866516,
-0.5767887830734253,
0.6625937223434448,
0.6488232612609863,
1.0703034400939941,
0.03729536011815071,
0.777654767036438,
0.11358808726072311,
0.681448221206665,
-0.604069173336029,
0.5129022002220154,
-0.7377118468284607,
0.062367066740989685,
-0.15950146317481995,
-0.9350959062576294,
0.08845061808824539,
1.0900318622589111,
-0.3773115575313568,
-0.014474885538220406,
0.5846593976020813,
0.9930932521820068,
-0.2750468850135803,
0.2381417602300644,
0.001108179916627705,
-0.12780897319316864,
0.237663134932518,
0.6563968062400818,
0.6817688345909119,
-0.13302657008171082,
0.2590663731098175,
-0.4819019138813019,
-0.439859539270401,
-0.49842894077301025,
-0.9689649343490601,
-0.7253217101097107,
-0.09256497025489807,
-0.3094741404056549,
0.05273047089576721,
0.045091841369867325,
1.571144461631775,
0.7814701199531555,
-0.7414795756340027,
-0.33335164189338684,
-0.24921517074108124,
-0.11223107576370239,
-0.3719322383403778,
-0.21667709946632385,
0.40777263045310974,
-0.35165125131607056,
-0.8486284017562866,
0.5768082737922668,
0.015070190653204918,
-0.18085813522338867,
-0.2896167039871216,
-0.4295347332954407,
-0.1383315920829773,
-0.13952334225177765,
0.22785387933254242,
0.30445075035095215,
-0.5061240196228027,
-0.15072749555110931,
0.19445843994617462,
0.1428171843290329,
0.21837615966796875,
0.9002202749252319,
-0.7577661275863647,
0.7810277938842773,
0.43695753812789917,
0.9283908009529114,
0.6023576259613037,
0.042545516043901443,
0.7849576473236084,
-0.3737632930278778,
-0.10271918773651123,
0.20525798201560974,
0.3079518973827362,
0.2850967347621918,
-0.6061130166053772,
0.2512444853782654,
0.08016696572303772,
-0.6162895560264587,
-0.5824638605117798,
0.2173733413219452,
-0.9691164493560791,
-0.00416556978598237,
1.1872918605804443,
-0.01941380277276039,
-0.024820948019623756,
0.0822862982749939,
-0.4508560299873352,
0.018606800585985184,
-0.7620902061462402,
0.8049381375312805,
0.3365747034549713,
-0.4248482584953308,
0.012675178237259388,
-0.39695030450820923,
0.7270857095718384,
0.6608095169067383,
-0.8750013709068298,
0.044956739991903305,
0.5258989930152893,
0.1959971785545349,
-0.1676916629076004,
0.5154402852058411,
0.2547878623008728,
0.2705894112586975,
-0.47540926933288574,
-0.18306387960910797,
-0.30480313301086426,
-0.3499363660812378,
-0.11022373288869858,
0.1241859421133995,
0.18124040961265564,
-0.29096099734306335
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.07546v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.07546v1
|
Commonsense-T2I Challenge: Can Text-to-Image Generation Models Understand Commonsense?
| 2024-06-11T17:59:48 | 2024-06-11T17:59:48 |
Xingyu Fu, Muyu He, Yujie Lu, William Yang Wang, Dan Roth
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
We present a novel task and benchmark for evaluating the ability of
text-to-image(T2I) generation models to produce images that fit commonsense in
real life, which we call Commonsense-T2I. Given two adversarial text prompts
containing an identical set of action words with minor differences, such as "a
lightbulb without electricity" v.s. "a lightbulb with electricity", we evaluate
whether T2I models can conduct visual-commonsense reasoning, e.g. produce
images that fit "the lightbulb is unlit" vs. "the lightbulb is lit"
correspondingly. Commonsense-T2I presents an adversarial challenge, providing
pairwise text prompts along with expected outputs. The dataset is carefully
hand-curated by experts and annotated with fine-grained labels, such as
commonsense type and likelihood of the expected outputs, to assist analyzing
model behavior. We benchmark a variety of state-of-the-art (sota) T2I models
and surprisingly find that, there is still a large gap between image synthesis
and real life photos--even the DALL-E 3 model could only achieve 48.92% on
Commonsense-T2I, and the stable diffusion XL model only achieves 24.92%
accuracy. Our experiments show that GPT-enriched prompts cannot solve this
challenge, and we include a detailed analysis about possible reasons for such
deficiency. We aim for Commonsense-T2I to serve as a high-quality evaluation
benchmark for T2I commonsense checking, fostering advancements in real life
image generation.
|
[
-0.13704678416252136,
-0.6169056296348572,
0.6523421406745911,
0.07168228179216385,
-0.17963294684886932,
-0.3229531943798065,
-0.026635726913809776,
-0.3825007677078247,
-0.5820178389549255,
0.16626118123531342,
-0.5917096734046936,
-0.1843155324459076,
-0.5503357648849487,
0.2664373219013214,
-0.009849908761680126,
0.7244048714637756,
0.006166529841721058,
-0.07950028777122498,
-0.469725102186203,
-0.03343834728002548,
-0.6007324457168579,
0.20296069979667664,
-0.7226794958114624,
-0.2575988173484802,
0.4494701325893402,
0.40689605474472046,
0.6919129490852356,
0.34046506881713867,
0.22502169013023376,
0.2497328668832779,
-0.14146888256072998,
0.32174810767173767,
-0.6805884838104248,
-0.0947074443101883,
-0.3382347524166107,
-0.10726742446422577,
-0.07418367266654968,
0.25116047263145447,
0.3426417112350464,
0.20265676081180573,
0.307127445936203,
0.21087603271007538,
-0.014610180631279945,
0.3907107710838318,
-0.7829957008361816,
-0.14748039841651917,
-0.6816877722740173,
0.12865135073661804,
-0.10676173120737076,
0.06243940442800522,
-0.49420976638793945,
-0.18080289661884308,
-0.10770712792873383,
-0.7018075585365295,
0.4171423017978668,
0.15714314579963684,
1.1334964036941528,
0.2825911343097687,
-0.675045371055603,
-0.2959219217300415,
-0.3373798727989197,
0.695685625076294,
-0.5682624578475952,
0.13001681864261627,
0.17709967494010925,
0.3664698302745819,
0.023140454664826393,
-0.8843436241149902,
-0.8485109806060791,
-0.33290451765060425,
-0.15594400465488434,
0.39003145694732666,
-0.410607248544693,
-0.28100329637527466,
0.403251051902771,
0.035156287252902985,
-0.6178223490715027,
0.11027076095342636,
-0.4313398003578186,
0.0460338220000267,
0.5557976961135864,
0.07970400899648666,
0.2596055865287781,
-0.4121047854423523,
-0.5740571618080139,
-0.12594138085842133,
-0.666813850402832,
-0.19855497777462006,
0.4643825590610504,
-0.1600150316953659,
-0.18905290961265564,
0.5621026754379272,
0.15054532885551453,
0.393713116645813,
-0.0890248566865921,
0.3589586615562439,
-0.06231692433357239,
-0.3630170524120331,
0.02233310043811798,
-0.28165698051452637,
0.8415487408638,
0.9153811931610107,
0.27223899960517883,
-0.21910828351974487,
-0.435576856136322,
0.11173643171787262,
0.15741944313049316,
-0.9200378656387329,
-0.4712071120738983,
0.2775115668773651,
-0.4480975568294525,
-0.7949060797691345,
-0.23450979590415955,
-0.7852627635002136,
-0.6042287945747375,
0.05945688486099243,
0.7443755865097046,
-0.13687150180339813,
-0.5823265314102173,
-0.2778465449810028,
-0.638411283493042,
0.15596003830432892,
0.23213668167591095,
-0.6791031360626221,
0.20864732563495636,
0.8118167519569397,
0.9625077843666077,
-0.20485979318618774,
-0.19768550992012024,
-0.44580215215682983,
-0.024792825803160667,
-0.4415286183357239,
0.9835288524627686,
-0.44354048371315,
-0.48329049348831177,
-0.019573433324694633,
-0.29069238901138306,
-0.10259106010198593,
-0.7231723070144653,
0.408233106136322,
-0.44662660360336304,
0.23905372619628906,
-0.4275479316711426,
-0.7007941007614136,
0.2768866717815399,
0.3322966992855072,
-0.6957122087478638,
0.8342704176902771,
0.06107620894908905,
-0.8514661192893982,
0.3754771649837494,
-0.8391135931015015,
-0.2555896043777466,
0.15524861216545105,
-0.18473568558692932,
-0.5667674541473389,
0.24655109643936157,
-0.06482742726802826,
0.30830681324005127,
-0.4204862713813782,
0.5107091069221497,
-0.42776739597320557,
-0.2366832196712494,
0.5544071197509766,
-0.7775791883468628,
0.7287550568580627,
0.26359736919403076,
-0.24482116103172302,
0.01862584799528122,
-0.4739719033241272,
-0.18970446288585663,
0.5860294699668884,
0.2772510349750519,
-0.052119530737400055,
-0.15434448421001434,
0.5707157254219055,
0.16497796773910522,
0.23891033232212067,
-0.7248410582542419,
0.0031964152585715055,
0.12103413790464401,
0.6483554244041443,
0.7313637137413025,
0.2355518639087677,
0.09131366014480591,
-0.3561195135116577,
0.019666625186800957,
-0.02437564730644226,
0.11292062699794769,
0.02950945310294628,
-0.7681257724761963,
-0.46857750415802,
0.24717853963375092,
0.18973515927791595,
0.6061173677444458,
-0.8884497284889221,
0.06268511712551117,
-0.35473549365997314,
-0.5361452102661133,
-0.15834827721118927,
-0.2269754260778427,
0.6962503790855408,
0.8934069275856018,
0.3906770348548889,
-0.009303586557507515,
0.03309134021401405,
-0.9468957185745239,
-0.537739098072052,
0.04384632408618927,
-0.11815275251865387,
0.5960871577262878,
0.7301889657974243,
0.08483494073152542,
0.766302764415741,
-0.5337868332862854,
0.009731435216963291,
-0.16671600937843323,
0.6814074516296387,
-0.0585591159760952,
0.6450554132461548,
0.381710410118103,
-1.0959053039550781,
-0.18638809025287628,
-0.2643425464630127,
-0.7446228861808777,
-0.3200720548629761,
-0.23340460658073425,
0.17125438153743744,
0.1653028279542923,
0.5062508583068848,
-0.5311057567596436,
0.41152340173721313,
0.4188130497932434,
-0.6212382912635803,
0.637057900428772,
-0.35854679346084595,
0.27588918805122375,
-1.0590959787368774,
0.38469481468200684,
0.32642629742622375,
0.03094092570245266,
-0.7351640462875366,
0.08313291519880295,
0.30342918634414673,
-0.5180469155311584,
-0.641122043132782,
0.8893209099769592,
-0.23289163410663605,
-0.2383761703968048,
-0.20317667722702026,
0.007639116607606411,
0.09509217739105225,
0.3670155107975006,
0.21003217995166779,
1.0073139667510986,
0.3084031343460083,
-0.5362972021102905,
0.33349084854125977,
0.12312561273574829,
-0.3596022427082062,
0.7124442458152771,
-0.9818748831748962,
0.24474599957466125,
0.005200697109103203,
0.19601726531982422,
-1.191929578781128,
-0.4620305299758911,
0.23703978955745697,
-0.42746347188949585,
0.15981683135032654,
-0.017165370285511017,
-0.7036921381950378,
-0.2497081756591797,
-0.1505211442708969,
0.7738124132156372,
0.626867413520813,
-0.7389920949935913,
0.33877986669540405,
-0.11128266155719757,
0.09589490294456482,
-0.3420189619064331,
-0.7315658926963806,
0.4956201910972595,
-0.20351700484752655,
-0.7243239283561707,
0.31302011013031006,
0.028477545827627182,
-0.2440396249294281,
0.26122307777404785,
0.0719110444188118,
-0.17108142375946045,
0.19624406099319458,
0.08764518797397614,
0.18313094973564148,
-0.00185547792352736,
0.09522896260023117,
0.09599532186985016,
-0.2421981543302536,
0.1816929280757904,
-0.11006195843219757,
0.10925754904747009,
0.006045765243470669,
-0.3483171761035919,
-0.6643100380897522,
0.3944334387779236,
0.28831911087036133,
-0.1471182405948639,
0.20881222188472748,
0.5810003280639648,
-0.35623419284820557,
-0.10860764980316162,
-0.5638890266418457,
-0.025653496384620667,
-0.5196986198425293,
0.3505595624446869,
-0.39322778582572937,
-0.4868374764919281,
0.26640889048576355,
-0.2374279648065567,
0.19779090583324432,
0.49473249912261963,
0.17923294007778168,
-0.20679353177547455,
0.7883055806159973,
-0.04390326887369156,
0.6160797476768494,
0.2662799656391144,
-0.3305211663246155,
0.022054368630051613,
-0.7484886646270752,
-0.24828249216079712,
-0.26598846912384033,
-0.4422008693218231,
-0.5433286428451538,
-0.4394948482513428,
0.577264130115509,
-0.2843579947948456,
-0.27265989780426025,
0.20697025954723358,
-0.3607768714427948,
0.6799740195274353,
0.5426280498504639,
0.43376535177230835,
-0.02829793095588684,
-0.08515523374080658,
0.2991603910923004,
0.048370592296123505,
-0.5454482436180115,
-0.5394544005393982,
0.9920374155044556,
0.18487860262393951,
0.2720358371734619,
0.21957364678382874,
0.6391952037811279,
0.5549067854881287,
0.26670652627944946,
-0.5236804485321045,
0.7325321435928345,
-0.561722993850708,
-0.4154965877532959,
-0.024040723219513893,
-0.47728174924850464,
-0.8708350658416748,
-0.01647842489182949,
-0.3290872573852539,
-0.476169615983963,
0.05996926873922348,
0.38194671273231506,
-0.1589694321155548,
0.405603289604187,
-0.8101181387901306,
1.3121669292449951,
-0.2435777634382248,
-0.961439847946167,
-0.2626558244228363,
-0.49075618386268616,
0.517108678817749,
0.3238634467124939,
0.08090151101350784,
0.04893849045038223,
-0.22697599232196808,
0.615365743637085,
-0.28545084595680237,
0.8251820206642151,
-0.3892090618610382,
-0.10896039754152298,
0.3270607590675354,
0.01893950253725052,
0.4656181335449219,
0.010702849365770817,
-0.02632967010140419,
0.07703085988759995,
-0.28747421503067017,
-0.670232355594635,
-0.6498916149139404,
0.6364707350730896,
-0.631014883518219,
-0.47439637780189514,
-0.2292497456073761,
-0.2994386553764343,
-0.24579964578151703,
0.12316826730966568,
0.8033522367477417,
0.7856793403625488,
-0.4325271248817444,
-0.25850173830986023,
0.8640621900558472,
-0.22911511361598969,
0.5034894347190857,
-0.10901989042758942,
0.26579979062080383,
-0.38693806529045105,
1.1953775882720947,
-0.09068306535482407,
0.42962905764579773,
0.23673367500305176,
0.504491925239563,
-0.5864747762680054,
-0.4980282783508301,
-0.8138124346733093,
0.15663723647594452,
-0.7569090723991394,
-0.18575063347816467,
-0.37103548645973206,
0.09825420379638672,
-0.451643168926239,
-0.1805265247821808,
-0.17296598851680756,
-0.31876662373542786,
-0.5969555377960205,
0.13060712814331055,
0.18857786059379578,
0.9305673837661743,
0.02921880967915058,
-0.0029052093159407377,
-0.638399064540863,
0.5280062556266785,
0.7625055909156799,
0.41763874888420105,
0.07658370584249496,
-0.43219488859176636,
0.39100509881973267,
-0.14336666464805603,
-0.3950574994087219,
-1.0160490274429321,
-0.010574625805020332,
0.008265168406069279,
0.18248488008975983,
0.36816170811653137,
0.18640244007110596,
0.5015242695808411,
-0.47676053643226624,
1.2097876071929932,
0.4439578652381897,
-0.8190502524375916,
0.4846876263618469,
-0.418740838766098,
0.15399682521820068,
0.3310151696205139,
-0.015568171627819538,
-0.39082014560699463,
-0.27616673707962036,
-0.9247596859931946,
-0.5982962846755981,
0.29563790559768677,
0.4616668224334717,
0.14579592645168304,
-0.17058447003364563,
0.145130455493927,
0.01895138807594776,
-0.07039457559585571,
-0.681247889995575,
0.07121314108371735,
-0.5178535580635071,
-0.26568400859832764,
0.1660272628068924,
-0.36753013730049133,
-0.22008681297302246,
0.40696096420288086,
0.5157579183578491,
0.07641661167144775,
0.2986887991428375,
0.17166070640087128,
-0.005529150366783142,
-0.05954451858997345,
0.4280003309249878,
0.7813234329223633,
0.26290756464004517,
-0.022951314225792885,
0.30929407477378845,
0.10404923558235168,
-0.1650971621274948,
-0.06075366213917732,
-0.0030519079882651567,
-0.2957748472690582,
-0.06660167872905731,
0.41159793734550476,
0.9813137054443359,
0.15057092905044556,
-0.7402912378311157,
0.9276652932167053,
-0.12856294214725494,
-0.4931216835975647,
-0.07235915958881378,
0.16014975309371948,
0.04542398825287819,
0.32577380537986755,
0.35383182764053345,
0.39158961176872253,
0.2893402874469757,
-0.203231081366539,
0.1158389151096344,
0.39429643750190735,
-0.06428607553243637,
-0.3134557902812958,
0.8588865399360657,
0.5331991314888,
-0.36885514855384827,
0.5288044214248657,
-0.7395204901695251,
-0.3435235917568207,
0.9462183117866516,
0.6291442513465881,
1.0288492441177368,
0.33602041006088257,
0.2570928931236267,
0.6122338175773621,
0.13807247579097748,
-0.11514407396316528,
0.1914639174938202,
-0.09853863716125488,
-0.5573042631149292,
0.17050418257713318,
0.06776499003171921,
-0.4895320534706116,
0.3976936936378479,
-0.4594361186027527,
0.133746936917305,
-0.4072381854057312,
0.06136571988463402,
0.02420860156416893,
-0.13450750708580017,
-0.5303825736045837,
0.38265931606292725,
0.17319385707378387,
0.9259656667709351,
-1.2923898696899414,
0.33627161383628845,
0.6013025641441345,
-0.2239188402891159,
-0.5110484957695007,
0.1678602397441864,
0.013078844174742699,
-0.658629298210144,
0.5418910980224609,
0.4063131809234619,
-0.08534577488899231,
-0.034434571862220764,
-0.9015411138534546,
-0.27496108412742615,
1.1532708406448364,
-0.05310606211423874,
-0.369742751121521,
0.18196812272071838,
0.024841725826263428,
0.369938462972641,
-0.13588495552539825,
0.2434070110321045,
0.23983271420001984,
0.6522942781448364,
0.39438554644584656,
-0.5364157557487488,
0.2753729820251465,
-0.42148199677467346,
0.34012940526008606,
-0.06774484366178513,
-0.664444088935852,
0.5778298377990723,
-0.5155373811721802,
-0.518502414226532,
0.42668408155441284,
0.7370536923408508,
0.3951312303543091,
1.052628993988037,
0.7569334506988525,
0.6958605647087097,
0.4837303161621094,
-0.05796573683619499,
0.8563886284828186,
0.10063882172107697,
0.22068506479263306,
1.018050193786621,
-0.2896078824996948,
0.7957059741020203,
0.40778130292892456,
0.15019752085208893,
-0.008439861238002777,
0.5667890310287476,
-0.5639129877090454,
0.5778080224990845,
0.07020466774702072,
-0.349281370639801,
-0.29618361592292786,
-0.39089053869247437,
-0.2049035131931305,
0.08904577791690826,
0.24996121227741241,
-0.08127747476100922,
-0.24725379049777985,
0.05951346457004547,
-0.20787546038627625,
0.3723650872707367,
-0.15044745802879333,
0.8812156915664673,
-0.3405597507953644,
-0.8900270462036133,
0.4852102994918823,
-0.17649486660957336,
0.6755772233009338,
-0.13385234773159027,
-0.04898322746157646,
-0.22435827553272247,
-0.15301229059696198,
-0.12814262509346008,
-1.135928750038147,
0.14978289604187012,
0.39940232038497925,
0.12360867112874985,
-0.265296071767807,
0.7033695578575134,
-0.33492740988731384,
-0.46354344487190247,
-0.24596816301345825,
0.09876111894845963,
0.22337979078292847,
0.26866036653518677,
-0.7120093703269958,
-0.0927506536245346,
-0.029328344389796257,
-0.2282114177942276,
0.10143797099590302,
0.5308846235275269,
0.11687101423740387,
0.358883798122406,
0.41552165150642395,
-0.12604929506778717,
-0.22502291202545166,
-0.05751633271574974,
0.6713767051696777,
-0.41933801770210266,
-0.27140459418296814,
-0.5083964467048645,
0.5094072222709656,
-0.47963178157806396,
-0.719143807888031,
0.14907845854759216,
0.5904728174209595,
0.735907256603241,
-0.3184067904949188,
0.8495493531227112,
-0.1815333515405655,
0.09606608748435974,
-0.6130461096763611,
0.6735199689865112,
-0.801575779914856,
-0.001411708421073854,
-0.04930257052183151,
-0.481539785861969,
-0.002799057634547353,
0.22088712453842163,
-0.3654778003692627,
0.0007015176233835518,
0.5088775753974915,
1.0412386655807495,
-0.30800142884254456,
0.10060910880565643,
0.34405529499053955,
-0.01049930788576603,
0.33181139826774597,
0.652945339679718,
0.8831336498260498,
-0.5631260275840759,
0.6651738882064819,
-0.15277928113937378,
-0.2264300137758255,
0.020996537059545517,
-1.1434621810913086,
-0.7697424292564392,
-0.47984591126441956,
-0.5567850470542908,
-0.36131390929222107,
0.10087333619594574,
0.5133530497550964,
0.41778096556663513,
-0.640190839767456,
0.08765634149312973,
-0.6142405867576599,
-0.024394124746322632,
-0.2968466877937317,
-0.24111077189445496,
0.4018799960613251,
-0.29171958565711975,
-0.7270764708518982,
0.10710181295871735,
-0.007856525480747223,
0.24455924332141876,
0.05381431058049202,
0.0028430363163352013,
0.10651176422834396,
0.0393107570707798,
0.2626942992210388,
0.27166423201560974,
-0.7462655901908875,
-0.2512126863002777,
-0.08444461971521378,
-0.21171066164970398,
-0.1256287693977356,
0.804376482963562,
-0.46116530895233154,
0.35738471150398254,
0.433799147605896,
0.5356118083000183,
0.2516981065273285,
-0.011814520694315434,
0.20293006300926208,
-0.8008866906166077,
-0.06534165889024734,
0.21559102833271027,
0.15607702732086182,
0.4869040250778198,
-0.3393906354904175,
0.39342284202575684,
0.5163799524307251,
-0.45859861373901367,
-0.7626473307609558,
0.7499699592590332,
-1.012445092201233,
-0.5326728820800781,
1.339892864227295,
-0.08280757814645767,
-0.16882109642028809,
0.13499028980731964,
-0.1985207200050354,
0.3826347589492798,
-0.44572147727012634,
0.7766001224517822,
0.2760411202907562,
0.06015629693865776,
-0.5119199752807617,
-0.3283523917198181,
0.45512855052948,
0.4651227593421936,
-0.7646652460098267,
0.4116571247577667,
0.6771180629730225,
0.28314366936683655,
0.13283579051494598,
0.3363416790962219,
0.1104741171002388,
0.6863646507263184,
0.3466700315475464,
-0.4090951979160309,
-0.5380939841270447,
-0.04164406284689903,
-0.1749258190393448,
0.31697946786880493,
-0.2464464157819748,
-0.37560880184173584
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.07545v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.07545v1
|
Open-LLM-Leaderboard: From Multi-choice to Open-style Questions for LLMs Evaluation, Benchmark, and Arena
| 2024-06-11T17:59:47 | 2024-06-11T17:59:47 |
Aidar Myrzakhan, Sondos Mahmoud Bsharat, Zhiqiang Shen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Multiple-choice questions (MCQ) are frequently used to assess large language
models (LLMs). Typically, an LLM is given a question and selects the answer
deemed most probable after adjustments for factors like length. Unfortunately,
LLMs may inherently favor certain answer choice IDs, such as A/B/C/D, due to
inherent biases of priori unbalanced probabilities, influencing the prediction
of answers based on these IDs. Previous research has introduced methods to
reduce this ''selection bias'' by simply permutating options on a few test
samples and applying to new ones. Another problem of MCQ is the lottery ticket
choice by ''random guessing''. The LLM does not learn particular knowledge, but
the option is guessed correctly. This situation is especially serious for those
small-scale LLMs. To address them, a more thorough approach involves shifting
from MCQ to open-style questions, which can fundamentally eliminate selection
bias and random guessing issues. However, transitioning causes its own set of
challenges in (1) identifying suitable open-style questions and (2) validating
the correctness of LLM open-style responses against human-annotated
ground-truths. This work aims to tackle these significant difficulties, and
establish a new LLM evaluation benchmark through entirely open-style questions.
Consequently, we introduce the Open-LLM-Leaderboard to track various LLMs'
performance and reflect true capability of them, such as GPT-4o/4/3.5, Claude
3, Gemini, etc. Our code and dataset are available at
https://github.com/VILA-Lab/Open-LLM-Leaderboard.
|
[
-0.6569108366966248,
-0.9409943222999573,
0.5375850200653076,
0.1332019716501236,
-0.14184148609638214,
0.14738567173480988,
-0.4928058981895447,
-0.1990935355424881,
0.14148515462875366,
0.5567774176597595,
-0.4750205874443054,
-0.6098973751068115,
-0.39581355452537537,
0.029375161975622177,
0.11029138416051865,
0.8569319844245911,
-0.35464635491371155,
0.27960091829299927,
-0.36295998096466064,
-0.34967800974845886,
-0.45893770456314087,
-0.5822632312774658,
-0.6262170076370239,
-0.3298710286617279,
0.5989919304847717,
0.6049478650093079,
0.6876772046089172,
0.335513710975647,
0.5716827511787415,
0.10541288554668427,
-0.10915601998567581,
0.2510640621185303,
-0.47955822944641113,
0.0726466029882431,
-0.09840390086174011,
-0.3978836238384247,
-0.659787118434906,
0.3285505771636963,
0.6645281314849854,
0.5382789373397827,
-0.3439537286758423,
0.49442869424819946,
0.011107477359473705,
0.6522310376167297,
-0.6793555617332458,
-0.054953429847955704,
-0.7865809202194214,
0.13444019854068756,
-0.4138471782207489,
-0.2586928904056549,
-0.512335479259491,
-0.43155229091644287,
-0.1684129387140274,
-0.2260625809431076,
-0.2729465067386627,
0.2636549174785614,
0.5133098363876343,
0.0790313109755516,
-0.450329065322876,
-0.21696794033050537,
-0.6659828424453735,
0.7362030148506165,
-0.2607883810997009,
0.39023393392562866,
0.16549865901470184,
0.7137572169303894,
-0.03843818977475166,
-0.36086979508399963,
-0.21980814635753632,
-0.153335839509964,
0.23005148768424988,
0.40874922275543213,
0.1530573070049286,
-0.27082425355911255,
0.11762728542089462,
0.2922283709049225,
-0.5556928515434265,
0.38941267132759094,
-0.229068323969841,
-0.0735936090350151,
0.5371818542480469,
0.17790526151657104,
-0.05188225209712982,
0.21108050644397736,
-0.3768247663974762,
-0.1514131724834442,
-1.0476524829864502,
0.17471858859062195,
0.5095314979553223,
0.2222372442483902,
0.18474574387073517,
0.6978054642677307,
-0.2554722726345062,
0.6317550539970398,
-0.03122440166771412,
-0.1575062870979309,
0.3119741678237915,
-0.3150153160095215,
-0.15466409921646118,
-0.011385027319192886,
0.6796249151229858,
0.5295685529708862,
0.33762043714523315,
0.09476298093795776,
-0.20399095118045807,
-0.3515577018260956,
0.11910870671272278,
-0.6976203918457031,
-0.007698849309235811,
0.2846987545490265,
-0.4921417534351349,
-0.25777092576026917,
0.1574723869562149,
-0.8917703628540039,
-0.24111242592334747,
-0.1664135754108429,
0.5813822746276855,
-0.08534900844097137,
-0.19655027985572815,
-0.022320527583360672,
0.029581895098090172,
0.3609207570552826,
0.5384352207183838,
-0.6580883264541626,
0.23952598869800568,
0.36445149779319763,
0.7141773700714111,
-0.4639936089515686,
-0.1493595838546753,
-0.6920669078826904,
-0.09464551508426666,
-0.32170388102531433,
0.673870861530304,
-0.4979724586009979,
-0.3938130736351013,
-0.0801495686173439,
-0.2861352264881134,
-0.136084645986557,
-0.7319110631942749,
0.5848360657691956,
-0.6129806637763977,
0.18540523946285248,
-0.28626829385757446,
-0.19023849070072174,
0.20582959055900574,
0.5214403867721558,
-0.48157137632369995,
1.0138349533081055,
-0.1717793196439743,
-0.6598430275917053,
0.2204887568950653,
-0.7561323642730713,
-0.09599047899246216,
-0.18814779818058014,
-0.33854568004608154,
-0.3216959238052368,
0.06910031288862228,
0.5013540387153625,
0.18404290080070496,
-0.28689682483673096,
0.02163228765130043,
-0.433656245470047,
-0.2855013310909271,
0.5029913783073425,
-0.47529345750808716,
0.7136781215667725,
0.1785873919725418,
0.013890717178583145,
0.26486936211586,
-0.7659035921096802,
0.3021414577960968,
0.06541001796722412,
-0.5398456454277039,
-0.12534178793430328,
-0.10681669414043427,
-0.2167321890592575,
0.43185490369796753,
0.24426434934139252,
-0.4703342616558075,
0.21543650329113007,
-0.049594033509492874,
0.15518711507320404,
1.1573400497436523,
-0.03262336552143097,
0.31822317838668823,
-0.5503165125846863,
0.6627197265625,
0.12760071456432343,
0.4797438979148865,
0.14131440222263336,
-0.7543100714683533,
-0.46953603625297546,
-0.2647404670715332,
0.3126707375049591,
0.6201924085617065,
-0.6699619293212891,
0.19025376439094543,
0.0811934769153595,
-0.49069520831108093,
-0.8971854448318481,
0.21860505640506744,
0.204684779047966,
0.3521392345428467,
0.4572685956954956,
-0.3292176127433777,
-0.37893950939178467,
-0.7630965709686279,
-0.170791894197464,
-0.14840172231197357,
-0.08724475651979446,
0.5858235955238342,
0.5103285312652588,
-0.003381034592166543,
0.8877802491188049,
-0.696019172668457,
-0.11496623605489731,
0.11497693508863449,
-0.1395895779132843,
0.4277205169200897,
0.26391175389289856,
0.36775147914886475,
-0.7823792099952698,
-0.4285297989845276,
-0.09798463433980942,
-0.5738809108734131,
-0.28877222537994385,
0.2456827312707901,
-0.35880306363105774,
-0.0153319938108325,
0.35788413882255554,
-0.5807258486747742,
0.18579940497875214,
0.5963339805603027,
-0.14190709590911865,
0.7939976453781128,
-0.01395847275853157,
0.24193227291107178,
-0.8597384691238403,
-0.00144766247831285,
-0.18432331085205078,
0.07957400381565094,
-0.33349987864494324,
0.18458545207977295,
0.08316677808761597,
0.2263113111257553,
-0.5946434736251831,
0.8029567003250122,
-0.3961449861526489,
-0.24205666780471802,
0.1809072345495224,
0.3804353177547455,
-0.25850120186805725,
0.3679770529270172,
-0.14846082031726837,
0.8482897281646729,
0.47250306606292725,
-0.45827603340148926,
0.30496907234191895,
0.19081437587738037,
-0.29559364914894104,
0.7140138149261475,
-0.2250603586435318,
0.3381575644016266,
-0.20761165022850037,
0.14463573694229126,
-1.188363790512085,
0.09887391328811646,
0.1743977665901184,
-0.33867064118385315,
0.12469591945409775,
-0.08433262258768082,
-0.5983409285545349,
-0.3790449798107147,
-0.5425546169281006,
0.36669349670410156,
0.5834318995475769,
-0.6868268251419067,
0.4090109169483185,
0.2800544500350952,
-0.08283153921365738,
-0.7158792614936829,
-0.3647236227989197,
-0.07731123268604279,
-0.2585848271846771,
-0.5440954566001892,
0.17436854541301727,
-0.797668993473053,
-0.5516976118087769,
-0.26479676365852356,
-0.21493685245513916,
-0.006264442577958107,
0.2221388965845108,
0.14503414928913116,
0.42333847284317017,
-0.3545125722885132,
-0.05157678946852684,
-0.017102671787142754,
0.04415074735879898,
0.015248403884470463,
-0.33220669627189636,
0.5587326884269714,
-0.14930342137813568,
-0.4384893774986267,
0.12720495462417603,
0.0768480971455574,
0.6359239220619202,
-0.5476372838020325,
0.6112028956413269,
0.5689782500267029,
-0.11391327530145645,
-0.24346394836902618,
-0.5305351614952087,
-0.013694421388208866,
-0.4072454869747162,
0.00785193033516407,
-0.5923454761505127,
-1.1436808109283447,
0.6146628856658936,
-0.006883222609758377,
0.24652981758117676,
0.3382490277290344,
1.0476620197296143,
-0.08767115324735641,
0.9888392686843872,
0.09268733859062195,
0.14428210258483887,
0.25588536262512207,
0.04172050207853317,
-0.10854563117027283,
-1.0163670778274536,
-0.23381444811820984,
-0.5797163844108582,
-0.30144888162612915,
-0.6273022890090942,
-0.5446151494979858,
0.5917361378669739,
0.1324702799320221,
-0.18263095617294312,
-0.12890711426734924,
-0.31102994084358215,
0.5291537642478943,
0.5250729918479919,
0.14970098435878754,
0.5161038041114807,
-0.36061784625053406,
-0.5806297659873962,
0.0777299702167511,
-0.5075634121894836,
-0.5814495086669922,
1.594874382019043,
0.3193943202495575,
0.8757953643798828,
0.33473947644233704,
0.830536425113678,
-0.0759224146604538,
0.694863498210907,
-0.6272607445716858,
0.6794488430023193,
0.11360561847686768,
-0.8569770455360413,
-0.5165205597877502,
-0.46659791469573975,
-0.6289398074150085,
0.6492255330085754,
-0.24669620394706726,
-0.7482221126556396,
-0.11911389231681824,
-0.08534099161624908,
-0.43145039677619934,
0.40404215455055237,
-0.3622477054595947,
0.7415395975112915,
-0.2883099615573883,
-0.3600422441959381,
0.2204125076532364,
-0.4915277063846588,
0.506016731262207,
-0.3289550840854645,
0.3370581269264221,
-0.0826571062207222,
-0.14701291918754578,
0.5913441181182861,
-0.04214940592646599,
0.4549351930618286,
0.0693759024143219,
-0.20039893686771393,
0.3996838629245758,
-0.05696134269237518,
0.22860874235630035,
0.32134419679641724,
-0.2704635262489319,
0.0645572692155838,
-0.23646855354309082,
-0.16950993239879608,
-0.5460019707679749,
0.7182087302207947,
-0.8757175803184509,
-0.6625397205352783,
-0.23919150233268738,
-0.33127525448799133,
-0.45524150133132935,
0.08606154471635818,
0.14577443897724152,
0.25516512989997864,
-0.46267926692962646,
0.24229109287261963,
0.7399190664291382,
-0.16186760365962982,
0.3912627696990967,
0.47395551204681396,
-0.6950928568840027,
-0.6956972479820251,
0.39890843629837036,
0.36817529797554016,
0.38119304180145264,
0.40959155559539795,
0.2561480700969696,
-0.4134009778499603,
-0.7766916751861572,
-0.5753825902938843,
0.09595158696174622,
-0.7169194221496582,
-0.012022838927805424,
-0.3836269676685333,
-0.17557433247566223,
-0.28810110688209534,
0.08874258399009705,
-0.22604267299175262,
-0.4281894266605377,
-0.286144882440567,
-0.16851820051670074,
-0.07581440359354019,
0.5789055228233337,
0.11750573664903641,
0.004260651767253876,
-0.44636860489845276,
0.2776692509651184,
0.5984964966773987,
0.575683057308197,
-0.1529822051525116,
-0.4912070631980896,
0.007894651032984257,
-0.17223335802555084,
-0.5370593667030334,
-0.8643608093261719,
-0.10511036217212677,
-0.160594180226326,
0.7215337753295898,
0.2721690237522125,
0.06679467111825943,
0.422923743724823,
-0.7132033705711365,
0.5919005274772644,
0.1264011561870575,
-0.47511017322540283,
0.5053941011428833,
-0.4052215814590454,
0.2389257699251175,
0.8278806805610657,
0.43772774934768677,
-0.3089984059333801,
-0.3653066158294678,
-0.5755707621574402,
-0.43384599685668945,
0.47589418292045593,
0.33227160573005676,
-0.2844432592391968,
-0.029819412156939507,
0.2282259166240692,
0.10374445468187332,
0.5605601072311401,
-0.6855737566947937,
-0.3447054326534271,
0.013666973449289799,
-0.04236258193850517,
-0.32334205508232117,
-0.09483791142702103,
-0.2546261250972748,
-0.16209296882152557,
0.5965948700904846,
-0.24910897016525269,
0.06557471305131912,
0.026298794895410538,
0.02553493343293667,
-0.31463098526000977,
0.7339583039283752,
0.6475885510444641,
0.9693827629089355,
-0.6362853050231934,
0.09444056451320648,
0.29138684272766113,
-0.32261592149734497,
0.12657667696475983,
-0.02790684625506401,
-0.26839566230773926,
-0.16228948533535004,
0.01673802174627781,
0.4619846045970917,
0.041149917989969254,
-0.6574377417564392,
0.505141019821167,
-0.09091220796108246,
-0.17347343266010284,
-0.1906997412443161,
0.08240969479084015,
0.13750432431697845,
0.22881397604942322,
0.4033927023410797,
-0.049314484000205994,
-0.15089640021324158,
-0.9005345702171326,
0.2137465626001358,
0.5654944181442261,
-0.42118361592292786,
-0.08849544078111649,
0.6146880984306335,
0.15072683990001678,
-0.4681969881057739,
0.41244643926620483,
-0.1746978759765625,
-0.27090784907341003,
0.5930489301681519,
0.4449770748615265,
0.7353063225746155,
-0.3504278361797333,
0.1781088411808014,
0.24878808856010437,
0.46408766508102417,
-0.16685590147972107,
0.5060601830482483,
0.24261978268623352,
-0.9084534645080566,
-0.19232749938964844,
-0.6521894931793213,
-0.7567760348320007,
0.14889685809612274,
-0.8133637309074402,
0.36773133277893066,
-0.6645124554634094,
-0.31457003951072693,
-0.19741292297840118,
-0.0022435705177485943,
-0.6340829133987427,
0.13531309366226196,
0.19399835169315338,
1.0913995504379272,
-0.5895665287971497,
0.729058027267456,
0.8551167845726013,
-0.3262651264667511,
-0.44156262278556824,
-0.06404415518045425,
0.09338835626840591,
-0.9104230999946594,
0.4572106599807739,
0.11676501482725143,
0.1044793426990509,
-0.026044685393571854,
-0.6381796002388,
-0.6134525537490845,
1.3007858991622925,
0.10351134091615677,
-0.5399365425109863,
0.09082231670618057,
-0.0903627872467041,
0.34063297510147095,
-0.6073135137557983,
0.6247907876968384,
0.4790002107620239,
0.6045798659324646,
0.26159852743148804,
-1.1530414819717407,
-0.1467723399400711,
0.09014735370874405,
-0.30322861671447754,
0.3685753643512726,
-0.9032228589057922,
1.1445395946502686,
-0.25240492820739746,
0.22870241105556488,
0.13848158717155457,
0.35205385088920593,
0.7062350511550903,
0.37550920248031616,
0.42504897713661194,
0.5675011277198792,
0.8227612376213074,
-0.1499062329530716,
0.6977740526199341,
-0.12170805782079697,
0.4279642701148987,
1.154107689857483,
-0.5403155088424683,
1.1134295463562012,
0.5632262825965881,
-0.2529001235961914,
0.33066442608833313,
0.6406912803649902,
0.05898348242044449,
0.32074883580207825,
0.550893247127533,
-0.04337996244430542,
-0.34692156314849854,
0.06405612826347351,
-0.37226030230522156,
0.6475212574005127,
0.04638802260160446,
-0.09479459375143051,
-0.2488356977701187,
-0.0622127503156662,
0.10823620855808258,
-0.01513436809182167,
-0.4978136122226715,
0.5823348760604858,
0.11011339724063873,
-0.6545584201812744,
0.18882858753204346,
0.12235865741968155,
0.6640270352363586,
-0.6378970742225647,
0.006684104446321726,
-0.30275771021842957,
0.025208264589309692,
0.00174178765155375,
-0.9297733306884766,
-0.23252789676189423,
-0.07064714282751083,
-0.022320523858070374,
-0.3739608824253082,
0.5023269653320312,
-0.4355086386203766,
-0.3179030418395996,
0.23804610967636108,
0.8797213435173035,
0.10151571780443192,
-0.09331092983484268,
-0.6505491733551025,
0.06856795400381088,
-0.22740165889263153,
-0.23990043997764587,
0.6303381323814392,
0.37867188453674316,
-0.13750459253787994,
0.6402348875999451,
0.6091153025627136,
0.10267456620931625,
0.0025953787844628096,
0.06014040857553482,
0.742792546749115,
-0.5180482268333435,
-0.6015977263450623,
-0.9720068573951721,
0.38492804765701294,
-0.05702822282910347,
-0.4942922592163086,
0.8026911616325378,
0.7401960492134094,
0.7868881225585938,
0.016704872250556946,
0.5127426385879517,
0.26140573620796204,
0.3425094187259674,
-0.790124237537384,
0.6864702701568604,
-0.5144033432006836,
0.24420560896396637,
-0.36920925974845886,
-1.0169607400894165,
-0.19956547021865845,
0.3131238520145416,
-0.2676888704299927,
0.133711576461792,
0.7914823293685913,
0.612313985824585,
0.1557656228542328,
0.06454223394393921,
0.3755454123020172,
0.14886963367462158,
0.28148704767227173,
0.6587201356887817,
1.086080551147461,
-0.18992622196674347,
0.729827344417572,
0.0958327203989029,
-0.4763026535511017,
-0.2310410887002945,
-0.8661305904388428,
-1.0118352174758911,
-0.33620354533195496,
-0.28468772768974304,
-0.3845001459121704,
0.025273220613598824,
1.0002695322036743,
0.5213353037834167,
-0.6137837171554565,
-0.5725952982902527,
0.6175091862678528,
0.47031164169311523,
-0.224162757396698,
-0.16834940016269684,
0.11301840841770172,
-0.0876685306429863,
-0.41002076864242554,
0.3662155270576477,
0.3173588216304779,
0.0902329832315445,
-0.3543083071708679,
-0.10052986443042755,
-0.3156760036945343,
0.17099779844284058,
0.6682783365249634,
-0.00944275688380003,
-0.60356605052948,
-0.37850823998451233,
0.08820579200983047,
-0.010560259222984314,
0.39256274700164795,
0.6379148364067078,
-0.49707743525505066,
0.335223913192749,
0.2674522399902344,
0.6014445424079895,
0.36826184391975403,
0.0196858961135149,
0.15340453386306763,
-0.7481388449668884,
-0.27679184079170227,
0.20198529958724976,
0.3022605776786804,
0.030411778017878532,
-0.0028071037959307432,
0.6453056931495667,
0.2949197292327881,
-0.5218526721000671,
-0.8051480650901794,
0.31830987334251404,
-0.9431829452514648,
-0.2558680474758148,
1.2217893600463867,
0.21010176837444305,
-0.1589341163635254,
0.13497813045978546,
-0.23553425073623657,
-0.22264407575130463,
-0.29817497730255127,
0.5013721585273743,
1.080118179321289,
-0.24346239864826202,
-0.17459090054035187,
-0.8635155558586121,
0.27795878052711487,
0.10270065069198608,
-0.8854897618293762,
-0.10907062888145447,
0.4489436149597168,
0.2920496463775635,
0.17945338785648346,
0.9902675747871399,
-0.25533199310302734,
0.15257996320724487,
-0.3270111680030823,
-0.05841875821352005,
-0.031732916831970215,
-0.6175569295883179,
-0.3399924039840698,
0.6749143600463867,
0.29629993438720703,
-0.3242891728878021
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.07544v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.07544v2
|
Situational Awareness Matters in 3D Vision Language Reasoning
| 2024-06-11T17:59:45 | 2024-06-26T17:59:50 |
Yunze Man, Liang-Yan Gui, Yu-Xiong Wang
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Being able to carry out complicated vision language reasoning tasks in 3D
space represents a significant milestone in developing household robots and
human-centered embodied AI. In this work, we demonstrate that a critical and
distinct challenge in 3D vision language reasoning is situational awareness,
which incorporates two key components: (1) The autonomous agent grounds its
self-location based on a language prompt. (2) The agent answers open-ended
questions from the perspective of its calculated position. To address this
challenge, we introduce SIG3D, an end-to-end Situation-Grounded model for 3D
vision language reasoning. We tokenize the 3D scene into sparse voxel
representation and propose a language-grounded situation estimator, followed by
a situated question answering module. Experiments on the SQA3D and ScanQA
datasets show that SIG3D outperforms state-of-the-art models in situation
estimation and question answering by a large margin (e.g., an enhancement of
over 30% on situation estimation accuracy). Subsequent analysis corroborates
our architectural design choices, explores the distinct functions of visual and
textual tokens, and highlights the importance of situational awareness in the
domain of 3D question answering.
|
[
-0.48618966341018677,
-0.772535502910614,
1.0373661518096924,
0.16325898468494415,
0.07140818983316422,
-0.26314371824264526,
0.34205251932144165,
-0.599041759967804,
-0.24248021841049194,
0.48871779441833496,
-0.07463286072015762,
-0.5294086337089539,
-0.41009822487831116,
0.05447648838162422,
-0.10749029368162155,
0.140947625041008,
-0.05089971050620079,
-0.15580107271671295,
-0.38691097497940063,
-0.3218618929386139,
-0.5439199805259705,
-0.6779436469078064,
-0.49071288108825684,
0.1858067810535431,
0.2394140660762787,
0.4182799756526947,
0.9233953356742859,
0.49124377965927124,
0.39089488983154297,
0.43951717019081116,
-0.17045126855373383,
0.02986852452158928,
0.17990848422050476,
0.04297817125916481,
-0.10199306160211563,
-0.39354532957077026,
-0.379154235124588,
-0.06609746813774109,
0.42783933877944946,
0.9397574067115784,
-0.020457468926906586,
-0.15047180652618408,
-0.08306103199720383,
0.6588427424430847,
-0.7088607549667358,
0.3193794786930084,
-0.23996222019195557,
0.20951221883296967,
0.35115617513656616,
-0.06616624444723129,
-0.08955726027488708,
0.037907280027866364,
0.2762245237827301,
-0.7830440402030945,
0.23897719383239746,
0.08363267034292221,
0.5836789011955261,
0.7652330994606018,
-0.4691096842288971,
0.00854906253516674,
-0.5839543342590332,
0.44945013523101807,
-0.4154950976371765,
0.5297514200210571,
0.25010189414024353,
0.26332393288612366,
-0.29367706179618835,
-0.37945324182510376,
-0.6152980923652649,
-0.043596282601356506,
-0.02581656537950039,
0.43517249822616577,
-0.07721072435379028,
0.2626211941242218,
0.19605208933353424,
-0.011533856391906738,
-0.5089417695999146,
-0.22803723812103271,
-0.42654600739479065,
-0.20948903262615204,
0.3054148852825165,
-0.1354491412639618,
0.4113638401031494,
-0.40357276797294617,
-0.6317160129547119,
-0.2582799792289734,
-0.5201088786125183,
0.2511695921421051,
-0.05260101333260536,
0.01781061477959156,
-0.1687777191400528,
0.6561350226402283,
-0.09335862100124359,
0.8881701231002808,
-0.0739559754729271,
0.19322164356708527,
0.11886255443096161,
-0.20666393637657166,
-0.1355505883693695,
0.1341075450181961,
0.3561859428882599,
0.6297017931938171,
0.15652334690093994,
0.28057771921157837,
-0.21323524415493011,
-0.14962147176265717,
0.6447468996047974,
-0.28784340620040894,
-0.10526375472545624,
0.5501301884651184,
-0.07263553887605667,
0.05217170715332031,
0.17510564625263214,
-0.3810838758945465,
-0.8224153518676758,
-0.2761003375053406,
0.3440224826335907,
-0.08578953891992569,
-0.38258063793182373,
0.44887542724609375,
-0.21420885622501373,
0.6846936941146851,
0.7289291024208069,
-0.5679091811180115,
-0.23790094256401062,
0.69229656457901,
0.5847296714782715,
0.10850900411605835,
-0.3189414441585541,
-0.33178290724754333,
0.26660215854644775,
-0.7598814964294434,
1.056660532951355,
-0.02663297764956951,
-0.40813422203063965,
-0.17017558217048645,
-0.02826250158250332,
-0.26780450344085693,
-0.5937914252281189,
0.07495324313640594,
-0.209135040640831,
0.36986029148101807,
-0.30581754446029663,
-0.20562374591827393,
-0.3346739411354065,
0.5743179321289062,
-0.5021578669548035,
0.7089238166809082,
0.268035352230072,
-0.7308067083358765,
0.4176448583602905,
-0.6290323734283447,
-0.3349076509475708,
0.49177059531211853,
-0.6349640488624573,
-0.03590520843863487,
0.1214703619480133,
0.3927941620349884,
0.6021021604537964,
0.12936730682849884,
0.20694486796855927,
-0.20772027969360352,
-0.35434573888778687,
0.022007755935192108,
-0.3170541822910309,
0.5250505208969116,
0.15462130308151245,
-0.3771918714046478,
0.14493539929389954,
-0.4286675751209259,
-0.06662590056657791,
0.08740142732858658,
-0.2183111608028412,
-0.2617601156234741,
0.2016754299402237,
-0.5204067826271057,
0.1957818865776062,
0.48932766914367676,
-0.2597992420196533,
-0.20000433921813965,
-0.5312117338180542,
-0.02193821407854557,
0.5987532734870911,
0.15146802365779877,
0.6043035984039307,
0.000261208217125386,
0.6035559773445129,
0.07611829042434692,
0.2582891285419464,
-0.2245613932609558,
-0.768218457698822,
-0.6397385597229004,
-0.10476040840148926,
-0.6100866794586182,
0.822216808795929,
-0.8212584853172302,
0.11504853516817093,
0.015099654905498028,
-0.040782779455184937,
-0.19107221066951752,
-0.1832652986049652,
0.38814640045166016,
0.48215845227241516,
0.20642614364624023,
0.35321521759033203,
-0.35905587673187256,
-0.9682029485702515,
0.0896391049027443,
-0.8310897946357727,
-0.005851325113326311,
0.35551226139068604,
0.1277739554643631,
-0.04980543628334999,
0.8894569277763367,
-0.5535352230072021,
-0.05848947539925575,
-0.5437505841255188,
0.024252723902463913,
-0.06024455279111862,
0.42529886960983276,
0.7248324751853943,
-1.155928611755371,
0.04797026142477989,
0.30845072865486145,
-1.2456996440887451,
-0.12308070063591003,
-0.2515212893486023,
-0.07559537142515182,
0.2460431009531021,
1.1181285381317139,
-0.6023579239845276,
0.5438255667686462,
0.48469385504722595,
-0.6452040076255798,
0.05806528776884079,
-0.4041246771812439,
0.25765261054039,
-1.1030150651931763,
-0.18478204309940338,
0.05088162049651146,
-0.1443297266960144,
-0.6069155335426331,
0.2210797369480133,
-0.16111363470554352,
-0.1501837819814682,
-0.7654181718826294,
0.8412526249885559,
-0.4518294930458069,
-0.31991812586784363,
-0.330279141664505,
0.4968007206916809,
0.2774963676929474,
0.6100155711174011,
0.3287580609321594,
0.983874499797821,
0.4913559556007385,
-0.8035703897476196,
0.12623973190784454,
0.3609229624271393,
-0.5040251016616821,
0.5858097076416016,
-0.6737979054450989,
-0.1437261402606964,
-0.13126488029956818,
-0.10907008498907089,
-0.8986966013908386,
-0.315811425447464,
0.48330846428871155,
-0.5784862041473389,
-0.17679157853126526,
-0.13378144800662994,
-0.2872842252254486,
-0.3493393063545227,
0.2168344408273697,
0.3571314811706543,
0.138864204287529,
-0.570321261882782,
0.729356050491333,
0.6806266903877258,
0.05316739156842232,
-0.538024365901947,
-0.3943760097026825,
0.0435456857085228,
-0.17854620516300201,
-0.5448738932609558,
-0.2590877413749695,
0.023410804569721222,
-0.8387275338172913,
-0.2340487688779831,
-0.4666454792022705,
-0.08115765452384949,
0.5194462537765503,
0.419249564409256,
0.13130131363868713,
-0.22753983736038208,
-0.04722194746136665,
-0.3298962712287903,
-0.31186842918395996,
0.3780144155025482,
-0.2684157192707062,
0.07585857063531876,
-0.8137799501419067,
-0.7229965925216675,
-0.129004567861557,
0.3920229375362396,
0.7162407636642456,
0.14687293767929077,
0.5834867358207703,
0.20512184500694275,
-0.60114985704422,
0.08828917890787125,
-0.3814620077610016,
0.037899188697338104,
-0.5172743797302246,
0.5934098362922668,
-0.43450284004211426,
-0.8249063491821289,
0.5091432929039001,
0.13352161645889282,
0.0181554164737463,
0.33206114172935486,
0.20991311967372894,
-0.500159502029419,
1.3491731882095337,
0.6494240760803223,
0.3791040778160095,
0.24637389183044434,
-0.14567676186561584,
0.5506719350814819,
-0.8581455945968628,
-0.5337754487991333,
-0.33441686630249023,
-0.0044989213347435,
-0.1467827707529068,
-0.6102902293205261,
0.7693224549293518,
0.261027455329895,
-0.25881481170654297,
0.3955812454223633,
-0.3269038200378418,
0.6074444651603699,
0.2713068723678589,
-0.2249496877193451,
-0.05953245237469673,
-0.4303068518638611,
-0.14502190053462982,
0.30623313784599304,
-0.8458814024925232,
-0.6054458618164062,
0.1091541051864624,
0.2855623960494995,
0.2612922787666321,
0.26359692215919495,
0.21879670023918152,
0.045113932341337204,
-0.1972655951976776,
-0.657285213470459,
0.8814038038253784,
0.2662303149700165,
-0.4620850384235382,
-0.4800119698047638,
-0.2268787920475006,
-0.9020516872406006,
0.6871384382247925,
0.165592759847641,
-0.6048840284347534,
0.4836241602897644,
0.18106980621814728,
-0.5507446527481079,
0.23165729641914368,
-1.0013978481292725,
1.2053710222244263,
-0.3674883246421814,
-0.09268727898597717,
0.07784731686115265,
-0.6444767713546753,
0.028036633506417274,
0.2812584638595581,
0.3080594539642334,
-0.28450697660446167,
0.03110029548406601,
0.24252864718437195,
-0.363162636756897,
0.8844245672225952,
-0.2677174508571625,
-0.4043203890323639,
0.6188724637031555,
0.3238958716392517,
0.05790204927325249,
0.29236358404159546,
0.26081058382987976,
0.28054529428482056,
0.01799766905605793,
-0.37189310789108276,
-0.7149394750595093,
0.4424450397491455,
-0.6991859674453735,
-1.171282410621643,
-0.5903628468513489,
-0.30275237560272217,
-0.33211132884025574,
0.11873478442430496,
0.22719138860702515,
0.31420817971229553,
-0.13975834846496582,
0.3500366806983948,
0.7716655135154724,
-0.4313862919807434,
0.34263044595718384,
0.3862743079662323,
-0.3542325794696808,
0.04109641909599304,
0.5623239874839783,
-0.29699546098709106,
0.324918270111084,
0.505075991153717,
0.18777522444725037,
-0.3807015120983124,
-0.33085596561431885,
-0.6883458495140076,
-0.0951547920703888,
-1.099687933921814,
0.002488028258085251,
-0.8002017736434937,
-0.4499402344226837,
-0.2301965355873108,
-0.8317358493804932,
-0.5287060737609863,
-0.3197425305843353,
-0.25581085681915283,
-0.35311058163642883,
0.025324571877717972,
0.6857002377510071,
-0.0712757557630539,
0.10647661238908768,
-0.6595413684844971,
0.5826842784881592,
0.4901261627674103,
0.1926712542772293,
-0.31901320815086365,
-0.3742661774158478,
-0.0652972161769867,
0.15340003371238708,
0.3532622456550598,
-0.6073259115219116,
0.0726516991853714,
-0.4004773199558258,
0.839726448059082,
0.3589910566806793,
0.15518170595169067,
0.6851997971534729,
-0.10632514208555222,
0.889812707901001,
-0.011687476187944412,
-0.6460924744606018,
0.7771911025047302,
-0.516173779964447,
0.7950330972671509,
0.44237205386161804,
-0.3018936812877655,
-0.5308032035827637,
-0.5711902379989624,
-0.5205978155136108,
-0.9340248703956604,
0.70673006772995,
0.3241927921772003,
-0.09721498936414719,
-0.428916335105896,
0.4120231866836548,
-0.43932411074638367,
-0.012663458473980427,
-0.6893957853317261,
0.12408292293548584,
-0.4651108384132385,
0.1518593728542328,
0.12183037400245667,
-0.08971768617630005,
-0.19667162001132965,
-0.1699102222919464,
0.20973461866378784,
-0.4398117661476135,
0.29433029890060425,
0.3951956033706665,
-0.09023958444595337,
0.22782358527183533,
0.10334931313991547,
0.623528242111206,
0.5154703855514526,
-0.12766903638839722,
0.3896818161010742,
0.4066831171512604,
-0.3584253489971161,
0.035954549908638,
-0.2788460850715637,
-0.017169468104839325,
-0.4933624565601349,
0.4553719758987427,
0.6461895108222961,
0.3601219058036804,
-0.6846813559532166,
0.8234058022499084,
-0.1362723857164383,
-0.19708189368247986,
-0.5536947250366211,
0.2605474293231964,
-0.08067392557859421,
0.3955141007900238,
0.12041152268648148,
0.4428651034832001,
0.12996281683444977,
-0.27935847640037537,
0.07299111038446426,
0.2966096103191376,
-0.5489073991775513,
-0.17002452909946442,
0.7612515091896057,
0.1847781240940094,
-0.007239985279738903,
0.48617830872535706,
-0.1424407809972763,
-0.6745546460151672,
1.178154706954956,
0.29347118735313416,
0.9798460006713867,
-0.08397235721349716,
0.40441685914993286,
0.481358140707016,
0.47672656178474426,
-0.1947377771139145,
0.3269909918308258,
-0.20001478493213654,
-1.2563292980194092,
0.02478845790028572,
-0.40184733271598816,
-0.4849470257759094,
-0.157272070646286,
-0.3330451548099518,
0.054168254137039185,
-0.7381121516227722,
0.2142670452594757,
-0.4489023685455322,
-0.4026801288127899,
-0.40845853090286255,
0.4007328152656555,
0.37749409675598145,
0.4831463694572449,
-0.46528738737106323,
0.23141677677631378,
0.970607340335846,
-0.0686158612370491,
-0.7054059505462646,
0.1615004688501358,
0.1310563087463379,
-0.8623985648155212,
0.39233213663101196,
0.36874717473983765,
-0.986002504825592,
-0.20637783408164978,
-0.5996401309967041,
-1.08408522605896,
0.936453104019165,
0.23026975989341736,
-0.022142451256513596,
0.3368986248970032,
0.024643568322062492,
0.6703159809112549,
-0.2134498655796051,
-0.18136568367481232,
0.3187253773212433,
0.48704496026039124,
0.41682708263397217,
-0.399231493473053,
-0.3258309066295624,
-0.5949469804763794,
0.05267291143536568,
0.03063296526670456,
-0.5687407851219177,
0.3611105680465698,
-0.48079726099967957,
-0.4822846055030823,
-0.15072965621948242,
0.8109784722328186,
0.42310965061187744,
0.3419913351535797,
0.7035403847694397,
0.257107138633728,
0.482881098985672,
-0.1116265207529068,
1.33924400806427,
-0.23967279493808746,
-0.36551523208618164,
0.9467513561248779,
-0.44498777389526367,
0.5759198069572449,
0.3059781491756439,
0.30188339948654175,
0.16999755799770355,
0.5651895403862,
0.2941927909851074,
0.30700400471687317,
-0.2666848301887512,
-0.1854047030210495,
-0.5358332395553589,
0.11456872522830963,
-0.27111172676086426,
0.7531603574752808,
0.46181416511535645,
0.3120418190956116,
-0.029178567230701447,
0.1542230099439621,
-0.09195946902036667,
0.23697790503501892,
-0.23508428037166595,
0.9639489650726318,
0.027397194877266884,
-0.8203253149986267,
0.21010194718837738,
-0.019125523045659065,
-0.2502588629722595,
-0.3224555552005768,
-0.12073323875665665,
-0.4043026864528656,
0.2843712866306305,
0.0663391575217247,
-1.0817781686782837,
0.534878134727478,
-0.19926273822784424,
0.0729682520031929,
-0.4980509877204895,
0.3656372129917145,
-0.08419140428304672,
-0.34110575914382935,
0.36115169525146484,
0.6985684633255005,
0.19516752660274506,
-0.30085238814353943,
-0.4716334342956543,
-0.19656389951705933,
-0.12194684892892838,
-0.2545679211616516,
0.18533509969711304,
0.8184694051742554,
-0.3143535256385803,
0.8453954458236694,
0.4182450473308563,
-0.29454895853996277,
0.011394700966775417,
0.27832308411598206,
0.4992120563983917,
-0.6233564615249634,
-0.6371170282363892,
-0.4027245044708252,
0.3870970606803894,
0.09880055487155914,
-0.4652835428714752,
0.7017062902450562,
0.4508412480354309,
0.6375409960746765,
0.15532517433166504,
0.7063440084457397,
0.029316997155547142,
0.12498265504837036,
-0.6727962493896484,
0.43521153926849365,
-0.6693803071975708,
0.5622603297233582,
-0.14831934869289398,
-0.9240296483039856,
-0.7047130465507507,
1.1242258548736572,
-0.31395289301872253,
0.09091547131538391,
0.5184959769248962,
0.6616636514663696,
0.1940670758485794,
0.011521023698151112,
0.6960574984550476,
0.05516800284385681,
0.3818361759185791,
0.428993821144104,
1.0812417268753052,
-0.24123835563659668,
0.3208576738834381,
-0.10206900537014008,
0.007361209485679865,
-0.08621298521757126,
-0.7950270175933838,
-0.7545804977416992,
-0.9893433451652527,
-0.40122270584106445,
-0.16418400406837463,
-0.18008002638816833,
0.8138974905014038,
0.6455786824226379,
-0.6587099432945251,
-0.011915406212210655,
-0.3124730885028839,
0.34194377064704895,
-0.26684489846229553,
-0.20056216418743134,
0.2664816379547119,
-0.08377692103385925,
-0.4932100176811218,
0.8250581622123718,
0.7832803726196289,
0.4500371217727661,
-0.17510201036930084,
-0.19162817299365997,
-0.13943123817443848,
0.14013178646564484,
0.5981303453445435,
0.48263007402420044,
-0.8015755414962769,
-0.8442720174789429,
0.10809120535850525,
-0.3855550289154053,
0.2231568843126297,
0.6212790012359619,
-0.8484984040260315,
0.5909944176673889,
0.3984772861003876,
0.41546565294265747,
-0.03370654582977295,
0.3630158007144928,
0.804377019405365,
-0.8148379921913147,
0.4385136663913727,
0.1532680243253708,
0.6669782400131226,
0.5683545470237732,
-0.6896811127662659,
0.5515017509460449,
0.12957429885864258,
-0.250531405210495,
-0.3224294185638428,
0.32291755080223083,
-0.8839863538742065,
-0.6191900968551636,
1.2245548963546753,
0.053874485194683075,
-0.4125598073005676,
-0.48532000184059143,
-0.3740803003311157,
-0.07335007190704346,
0.1374800205230713,
0.7984437346458435,
0.7601985931396484,
-0.0994030311703682,
-0.6580203771591187,
-0.6442227363586426,
0.39511826634407043,
0.37055569887161255,
-1.0087815523147583,
0.07627972215414047,
0.7525137662887573,
-0.2868635058403015,
0.3026394844055176,
0.6693298816680908,
-0.1452677845954895,
0.46520644426345825,
0.12240732461214066,
0.12259882688522339,
0.0708455741405487,
-0.901492714881897,
-0.31922268867492676,
0.2743178904056549,
-0.1486033797264099,
-0.37807124853134155
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.07524v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.07524v1
|
Simple and Effective Masked Diffusion Language Models
| 2024-06-11T17:51:40 | 2024-06-11T17:51:40 |
Subham Sekhar Sahoo, Marianne Arriola, Yair Schiff, Aaron Gokaslan, Edgar Marroquin, Justin T Chiu, Alexander Rush, Volodymyr Kuleshov
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
While diffusion models excel at generating high-quality images, prior work
reports a significant performance gap between diffusion and autoregressive (AR)
methods in language modeling. In this work, we show that simple masked discrete
diffusion is more performant than previously thought. We apply an effective
training recipe that improves the performance of masked diffusion models and
derive a simplified, Rao-Blackwellized objective that results in additional
improvements. Our objective has a simple form -- it is a mixture of classical
masked language modeling losses -- and can be used to train encoder-only
language models that admit efficient samplers, including ones that can generate
arbitrary lengths of text semi-autoregressively like a traditional language
model. On language modeling benchmarks, a range of masked diffusion models
trained with modern engineering practices achieves a new state-of-the-art among
diffusion models, and approaches AR perplexity. We release our code at:
https://github.com/kuleshov-group/mdlm
|
[
-0.28858691453933716,
-0.8268555998802185,
0.4953826069831848,
0.18648934364318848,
-0.20680713653564453,
0.3561334013938904,
-0.00788081530481577,
-0.2974834740161896,
0.03814171999692917,
0.45647239685058594,
-0.16697710752487183,
-0.3904840350151062,
-1.0294398069381714,
-0.22594572603702545,
-0.609682559967041,
0.550304651260376,
-0.038980353623628616,
-0.0030987693462520838,
0.1489446759223938,
-0.11292612552642822,
0.005635061301290989,
-0.26913464069366455,
-0.9103403091430664,
-0.4889959990978241,
0.3175448477268219,
-0.14769992232322693,
0.48846739530563354,
1.0174546241760254,
0.19312429428100586,
0.2611553370952606,
-0.1861734539270401,
0.14874988794326782,
-0.2496165633201599,
0.15419167280197144,
0.21902060508728027,
0.007457416038960218,
-0.224387064576149,
0.05578117445111275,
0.7309160828590393,
0.791342556476593,
-0.6464836597442627,
-0.19119912385940552,
0.08295111358165741,
0.7303097248077393,
-0.737788736820221,
-0.06089622527360916,
-0.4338601529598236,
0.04936407506465912,
-0.34448501467704773,
0.25340452790260315,
-0.48492103815078735,
-0.26462849974632263,
-0.07114890962839127,
-0.24724991619586945,
0.19957147538661957,
-0.0032983338460326195,
0.5487756133079529,
0.36652886867523193,
-0.5361725687980652,
-0.30956214666366577,
-0.8091209530830383,
0.5699204802513123,
-0.6740384101867676,
0.6328079700469971,
0.38893669843673706,
0.5159898996353149,
0.09006520360708237,
-0.6096052527427673,
-0.5531178712844849,
-0.05398675054311752,
-0.02255270443856716,
-0.021204229444265366,
-0.40471768379211426,
0.039541393518447876,
0.011482798494398594,
0.3428860604763031,
-0.6647603511810303,
0.12968283891677856,
-0.12834970653057098,
-0.17688219249248505,
0.5421640276908875,
-0.009005909785628319,
0.07538790255784988,
0.2612224519252777,
-0.25790172815322876,
-0.009184306487441063,
-0.5286006331443787,
-0.2607061266899109,
0.4923366606235504,
-0.16086317598819733,
-0.31280970573425293,
0.26013970375061035,
-0.41020071506500244,
0.978307843208313,
-0.0031926799565553665,
-0.3057490885257721,
0.14306190609931946,
0.0165549423545599,
-0.384933739900589,
-0.26636743545532227,
0.6362007260322571,
-0.18277710676193237,
-0.06856342405080795,
-0.2443953901529312,
-0.5274653434753418,
0.08156822621822357,
-0.05206746235489845,
-0.7275494337081909,
-0.7945067286491394,
-0.10228078067302704,
-0.4717482924461365,
-0.2782352566719055,
-0.3298344314098358,
-0.7594467997550964,
-0.32812342047691345,
-0.01847212016582489,
0.5501492619514465,
-0.1946997344493866,
-0.5754694938659668,
0.468703955411911,
-0.13877283036708832,
-0.03571833297610283,
0.4162682592868805,
-0.722697913646698,
0.62123042345047,
0.27686384320259094,
0.8798261880874634,
-0.3291972875595093,
0.15070684254169464,
-0.5353506207466125,
0.03996330127120018,
-0.40289807319641113,
0.8785221576690674,
-0.6216123104095459,
-0.26294371485710144,
0.04421549662947655,
-0.32466748356819153,
-0.25503191351890564,
-0.6931283473968506,
0.14255017042160034,
-0.6777640581130981,
0.1430772989988327,
0.4020894467830658,
-0.3528027832508087,
-0.22656278312206268,
-0.02506166882812977,
-0.4983848035335541,
1.0690596103668213,
-0.0005365557735785842,
-0.3275264799594879,
0.07232435047626495,
-0.7762924432754517,
-0.3094179928302765,
0.07084184885025024,
0.0172637440264225,
-0.44875702261924744,
0.03843525052070618,
0.033407680690288544,
0.4253406226634979,
-0.024355914443731308,
0.18688195943832397,
-0.09599697589874268,
0.019547849893569946,
0.23973189294338226,
-0.5748374462127686,
0.7684086561203003,
0.6095285415649414,
-0.41377246379852295,
-0.27131909132003784,
-0.9495841264724731,
-0.2344704419374466,
0.07212367653846741,
-0.34241294860839844,
-0.5576967597007751,
-0.09119081497192383,
0.014852719381451607,
0.16613925993442535,
-0.10808786749839783,
-0.35296183824539185,
0.01911749690771103,
-0.2916105389595032,
0.19120551645755768,
0.708880603313446,
-0.06425082683563232,
0.8622457385063171,
-0.12083999067544937,
0.6361932158470154,
0.13306304812431335,
-0.02809859625995159,
-0.16816900670528412,
-0.7198666930198669,
-0.8640129566192627,
-0.8644328117370605,
0.5448333621025085,
0.27742457389831543,
-0.9290597438812256,
0.20373068749904633,
0.16999651491641998,
-0.4999401867389679,
-0.6887881755828857,
0.24430370330810547,
0.569611668586731,
0.6407883763313293,
0.04855676740407944,
-0.6846277713775635,
-0.42861208319664,
-0.8449928164482117,
-0.14496031403541565,
0.15455439686775208,
0.018857207149267197,
-0.01876724511384964,
0.4366052448749542,
-0.3453085124492645,
0.7917323708534241,
-0.6278588771820068,
-0.03752458468079567,
-0.08035323023796082,
0.41315412521362305,
-0.07536450028419495,
0.632034957408905,
0.5440280437469482,
-0.830986499786377,
-0.7580496668815613,
-0.16562944650650024,
-0.6478503346443176,
-0.4192381799221039,
0.11939208954572678,
-0.23600360751152039,
0.2696436643600464,
0.4240173399448395,
-0.5085790157318115,
0.5163246989250183,
0.8036643862724304,
-0.24536915123462677,
0.32624998688697815,
-0.24186725914478302,
0.02801608294248581,
-0.7738900780677795,
-0.025084253400564194,
0.19250282645225525,
-0.6335505247116089,
-0.9156967997550964,
0.12065506726503372,
0.1172507032752037,
-0.12269099056720734,
-0.42824459075927734,
0.8259530067443848,
-0.7842364311218262,
0.1955152004957199,
-0.46548786759376526,
0.03791088983416557,
-0.06713536381721497,
0.32597291469573975,
0.23124966025352478,
0.6523070335388184,
0.9189223051071167,
-0.9591575860977173,
0.04488549008965492,
-0.10113575309515,
-0.4908111095428467,
0.4647696912288666,
-0.545219898223877,
0.20054617524147034,
-0.32003408670425415,
0.05561888590455055,
-1.140522837638855,
-0.04276079311966896,
0.48148879408836365,
-0.2116229385137558,
0.6338909268379211,
-0.4035237729549408,
-0.4580756723880768,
-0.04822753369808197,
-0.002740350551903248,
0.48938292264938354,
1.046423316001892,
-0.4205445945262909,
0.6316796541213989,
0.5588387846946716,
-0.012638813816010952,
-0.3236284554004669,
-0.8101645708084106,
0.06845317780971527,
-0.2342301309108734,
-0.42563098669052124,
0.3716264069080353,
-0.3516548275947571,
-0.36806803941726685,
-0.025954540818929672,
0.0306970477104187,
-0.39289629459381104,
0.14230991899967194,
-0.06434150040149689,
-0.2779527008533478,
-0.12174586206674576,
-0.019236978143453598,
0.037044424563646317,
-0.2492891103029251,
-0.08354831486940384,
-0.4521338641643524,
0.6037087440490723,
0.26267802715301514,
-0.3882749676704407,
-0.2714586853981018,
0.532358705997467,
0.3222769796848297,
-0.19508732855319977,
0.9366959929466248,
0.28911685943603516,
-0.42763471603393555,
-0.30643194913864136,
-0.7753775715827942,
0.02336209826171398,
-0.5036059617996216,
0.10748527199029922,
-0.43120795488357544,
-0.6755092144012451,
0.6192178130149841,
-0.10058850795030594,
-0.128167524933815,
0.27116629481315613,
0.4833120107650757,
-0.10166367143392563,
1.1985934972763062,
0.8658621907234192,
0.23245994746685028,
0.5287252068519592,
-0.3174930810928345,
0.12028618156909943,
-0.8256597518920898,
-0.22866162657737732,
-0.5095077753067017,
0.10955312103033066,
-0.2549772262573242,
-0.5511482357978821,
0.2374081164598465,
0.0524410754442215,
-0.13364845514297485,
0.12896350026130676,
-0.5337007641792297,
0.4638771116733551,
0.48762065172195435,
0.040860746055841446,
0.3098689019680023,
0.35107311606407166,
-0.26770472526550293,
-0.05398020148277283,
-0.9609996676445007,
-0.5117789506912231,
0.6207720041275024,
0.5407484173774719,
1.055646538734436,
0.23426732420921326,
0.8886328339576721,
0.5009342432022095,
0.30201640725135803,
-0.3438597023487091,
0.41207826137542725,
-0.032943714410066605,
-0.38415926694869995,
-0.0808856412768364,
-0.4881714880466461,
-0.8648310899734497,
0.43060821294784546,
0.004856830462813377,
-0.38652127981185913,
0.4235718250274658,
0.24468272924423218,
-0.14743290841579437,
0.2573263645172119,
-0.8102815747261047,
0.7151824831962585,
0.09187323600053787,
-0.13626086711883545,
0.035255156457424164,
-0.38770177960395813,
0.4468348026275635,
-0.28608253598213196,
0.4460848867893219,
0.0330025851726532,
-0.12699146568775177,
0.7407438158988953,
-0.39730581641197205,
0.7696728110313416,
-0.25994011759757996,
-0.03398529812693596,
0.11347741633653641,
0.3656265139579773,
0.46237912774086,
-0.33367013931274414,
-0.0375993549823761,
0.14015433192253113,
-0.5249916911125183,
-0.5712012052536011,
-0.612698495388031,
0.5275242924690247,
-0.5070779323577881,
-0.4739367961883545,
-0.4421781301498413,
-0.21090558171272278,
0.21969924867153168,
0.17628733813762665,
0.3079099953174591,
0.42373937368392944,
0.07124603539705276,
-0.10402031242847443,
1.2077336311340332,
-0.019134311005473137,
0.7765621542930603,
0.8174355626106262,
-0.24754057824611664,
-0.4114701449871063,
0.5450649261474609,
0.22176072001457214,
0.5775704383850098,
0.260412335395813,
0.22418616712093353,
-0.30818232893943787,
-0.782447338104248,
-0.6535190939903259,
0.2613297700881958,
-0.7848214507102966,
-0.16700869798660278,
-1.0646148920059204,
-0.4298311769962311,
-0.44920608401298523,
-0.11095428466796875,
-0.4950653612613678,
-0.5150256752967834,
-0.1109674721956253,
0.12974593043327332,
0.32074862718582153,
0.8676665425300598,
-0.26400381326675415,
0.473930686712265,
-0.42140647768974304,
0.33065375685691833,
0.5500457882881165,
0.43442997336387634,
0.09309100359678268,
-0.740686297416687,
-0.363334059715271,
0.07323192059993744,
-0.13410726189613342,
-0.9259949326515198,
0.5422232747077942,
0.2937425673007965,
0.8802809119224548,
0.3218218982219696,
-0.02506016194820404,
0.6517035961151123,
-0.6394920945167542,
0.5963841080665588,
0.1884537637233734,
-0.881898045539856,
0.469825804233551,
-0.24204933643341064,
0.46827590465545654,
0.25142037868499756,
0.32176104187965393,
-0.32268694043159485,
-0.6115787625312805,
-0.5003640055656433,
-0.6653306484222412,
0.41818997263908386,
0.5687559843063354,
0.10657311975955963,
-0.02741733007133007,
0.12677539885044098,
0.051633741706609726,
0.2898268401622772,
-0.9360557794570923,
-0.6413347125053406,
-0.0021447078324854374,
-0.23283059895038605,
-0.06200507655739784,
-0.4112270176410675,
-0.04708649963140488,
-0.16529692709445953,
0.8587428331375122,
0.25272229313850403,
0.3627949059009552,
0.1305660754442215,
-0.3530685603618622,
-0.044252194464206696,
-0.03161795437335968,
0.8700412511825562,
0.35138246417045593,
-0.012254890985786915,
0.5582476258277893,
0.01010805182158947,
-0.5936742424964905,
0.443783700466156,
0.20089484751224518,
-0.36826756596565247,
0.2752721309661865,
0.010638242587447166,
0.56935054063797,
-0.03975389152765274,
-0.3402489423751831,
0.41686612367630005,
-0.059559416025877,
-0.16621050238609314,
-0.15766340494155884,
0.0425136461853981,
0.11200287193059921,
0.2506462633609772,
0.6027997732162476,
0.3394562304019928,
0.32968607544898987,
-0.3198597729206085,
0.2203071117401123,
0.417545884847641,
-0.16572551429271698,
-0.025464963167905807,
0.7846115231513977,
0.2269817292690277,
-0.721894383430481,
0.181142657995224,
-0.6104047298431396,
-0.47705337405204773,
0.44215118885040283,
0.5641649961471558,
0.9571810960769653,
-0.5194499492645264,
0.32401272654533386,
-0.06876703351736069,
0.38629353046417236,
-0.35038796067237854,
-0.1969316601753235,
-0.2259341925382614,
-0.5576519966125488,
-0.3780272901058197,
-0.6437222957611084,
-0.1655655950307846,
-0.1576458364725113,
-0.2849697470664978,
-0.07945642620325089,
-0.18516609072685242,
0.04405055567622185,
-0.03816558048129082,
-0.25767138600349426,
-0.5529497265815735,
0.24401947855949402,
0.052868567407131195,
0.8615660071372986,
-1.0062003135681152,
1.1111208200454712,
0.5301652550697327,
-0.1570962518453598,
-0.33298513293266296,
-0.20581066608428955,
-0.10202492028474808,
-0.6341850161552429,
0.7122506499290466,
0.05041428282856941,
-0.3986268639564514,
0.1666373908519745,
-0.4975029230117798,
-0.8321326971054077,
0.7004092335700989,
0.27779924869537354,
-0.43105548620224,
0.21843057870864868,
-0.0842888131737709,
0.5740842223167419,
-0.6972854137420654,
0.17215420305728912,
0.31909167766571045,
0.11505015194416046,
0.19301749765872955,
-0.592988133430481,
-0.24142952263355255,
-0.3003942668437958,
0.3112075626850128,
0.34960612654685974,
-0.4037487804889679,
0.6911724805831909,
0.32029592990875244,
-0.4411587417125702,
-0.0565330944955349,
0.49687302112579346,
0.18091987073421478,
0.5806878209114075,
0.4602508246898651,
0.6241235733032227,
0.6334905028343201,
0.015316843055188656,
0.9910849928855896,
-0.04731806740164757,
0.1599644124507904,
0.9689764976501465,
-0.27483680844306946,
0.6672463417053223,
0.27148646116256714,
-0.033654313534498215,
0.6443349719047546,
0.5080947279930115,
0.32900601625442505,
1.0798918008804321,
0.1376064121723175,
-0.5131809711456299,
-0.25431394577026367,
0.19126540422439575,
-0.23987962305545807,
0.18939751386642456,
0.10889849066734314,
-0.4224652051925659,
-0.2944892346858978,
0.37199389934539795,
0.057561393827199936,
0.3076249957084656,
-0.09164396673440933,
0.844847559928894,
0.07003094255924225,
-0.39653268456459045,
0.6523202657699585,
0.17724807560443878,
0.9324492812156677,
-0.5899768471717834,
-0.06953959167003632,
-0.46793320775032043,
0.020759068429470062,
0.07405004650354385,
-0.39045336842536926,
0.4380899667739868,
-0.009029862470924854,
-0.20257943868637085,
-0.6589041948318481,
0.6882357597351074,
-0.7099693417549133,
-0.5151454210281372,
0.1280554085969925,
0.41420191526412964,
0.3697803318500519,
-0.01178784016519785,
-0.6324624419212341,
0.03618843853473663,
-0.1157860979437828,
-0.08386881649494171,
0.3777816891670227,
0.2542905807495117,
0.21766789257526398,
0.8609210252761841,
0.5208573341369629,
0.15472380816936493,
0.48979151248931885,
-0.06622909009456635,
0.6137825846672058,
-0.3223479390144348,
-0.45772814750671387,
-0.9773944020271301,
0.6592400074005127,
-0.2568153440952301,
0.010828353464603424,
0.7892645597457886,
0.777500569820404,
0.5678431391716003,
-0.10429635643959045,
0.6038723587989807,
0.1682877391576767,
0.6594828367233276,
-0.738736093044281,
1.0635384321212769,
-0.4252966344356537,
0.4728507399559021,
-0.08153709769248962,
-0.8958353400230408,
-0.3507497012615204,
0.9244898557662964,
-0.03157587721943855,
0.22646725177764893,
0.49765369296073914,
0.9762925505638123,
-0.24930502474308014,
-0.6334244608879089,
0.5615262985229492,
0.0892961248755455,
0.31027472019195557,
0.3814880847930908,
0.8366954922676086,
-0.7624508142471313,
0.25353822112083435,
-0.40677350759506226,
-0.43168577551841736,
-0.08647747337818146,
-1.0356825590133667,
-0.8669602274894714,
-0.6570910215377808,
-0.8836287260055542,
-0.29636871814727783,
0.31524658203125,
0.45821964740753174,
1.2563709020614624,
-0.4063749313354492,
-0.27682632207870483,
-0.29340890049934387,
0.2315603792667389,
-0.1907035857439041,
-0.19905830919742584,
0.125179260969162,
-0.15745684504508972,
-0.7268550395965576,
0.3474178612232208,
0.2690713703632355,
0.5305549502372742,
-0.5408886075019836,
-0.21616536378860474,
-0.30268311500549316,
0.341190904378891,
0.6305180788040161,
0.19674116373062134,
-0.5800914168357849,
-0.014266269281506538,
-0.08582376688718796,
-0.3555983006954193,
0.04456968978047371,
0.618503987789154,
-0.8152167201042175,
0.7101715803146362,
0.3320598900318146,
0.40269383788108826,
0.889347493648529,
-0.24501003324985504,
0.5318594574928284,
-0.8376573324203491,
0.322957307100296,
0.18682348728179932,
0.11706029623746872,
0.38503989577293396,
-0.19508306682109833,
0.5428059101104736,
0.2605755031108856,
-0.41759639978408813,
-0.9772579669952393,
0.2469327598810196,
-0.6484892964363098,
-0.26102152466773987,
1.1644392013549805,
-0.044762346893548965,
-0.13510799407958984,
-0.4882464110851288,
-0.12031006813049316,
0.07896731793880463,
-0.32321417331695557,
0.7463606595993042,
0.640564501285553,
0.005828097462654114,
-0.7043662667274475,
-0.5331900715827942,
0.6223413348197937,
0.21868248283863068,
-0.5991384387016296,
-0.19796864688396454,
0.39801251888275146,
0.46330946683883667,
0.053110938519239426,
0.9955538511276245,
-0.05574726685881615,
0.13945306837558746,
0.06764434278011322,
-0.03360439091920853,
-0.09380799531936646,
-0.3292974829673767,
-0.7436263561248779,
0.11510453373193741,
0.15546740591526031,
-0.2846473157405853
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.07522v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.07522v1
|
Samba: Simple Hybrid State Space Models for Efficient Unlimited Context Language Modeling
| 2024-06-11T17:50:51 | 2024-06-11T17:50:51 |
Liliang Ren, Yang Liu, Yadong Lu, Yelong Shen, Chen Liang, Weizhu Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Efficiently modeling sequences with infinite context length has been a
long-standing problem. Past works suffer from either the quadratic computation
complexity or the limited extrapolation ability on length generalization. In
this work, we present Samba, a simple hybrid architecture that layer-wise
combines Mamba, a selective State Space Model (SSM), with Sliding Window
Attention (SWA). Samba selectively compresses a given sequence into recurrent
hidden states while still maintaining the ability to precisely recall memories
with the attention mechanism. We scale Samba up to 3.8B parameters with 3.2T
training tokens and show that Samba substantially outperforms the
state-of-the-art models based on pure attention or SSMs on a wide range of
benchmarks. When trained on 4K length sequences, Samba can be efficiently
extrapolated to 256K context length with perfect memory recall and show
improved token predictions up to 1M context length. As a linear-time sequence
model, Samba enjoys a 3.73x higher throughput compared to Transformers with
grouped-query attention when processing user prompts of 128K length, and 3.64x
speedup when generating 64K tokens with unlimited streaming. A sample
implementation of Samba is publicly available in
https://github.com/microsoft/Samba.
|
[
-0.3508853316307068,
-0.8637939095497131,
0.5349463820457458,
0.5292488932609558,
-0.36330142617225647,
0.2718510329723358,
0.0330350399017334,
-0.3321613371372223,
0.6543024778366089,
0.2632445991039276,
-0.2315216064453125,
-0.19980090856552124,
-0.30751609802246094,
-0.46978774666786194,
-0.5407506227493286,
0.8434674143791199,
-0.023520007729530334,
-0.2641347646713257,
-0.005245312117040157,
-0.36267945170402527,
-0.3719714283943176,
-0.40862199664115906,
-0.4649055004119873,
0.11940097063779831,
0.44467073678970337,
0.06914851814508438,
0.48596954345703125,
0.6863467693328857,
-0.09911862015724182,
0.23166848719120026,
-0.4020531475543976,
0.2255481481552124,
-0.5751389265060425,
0.02633715607225895,
-0.01135335024446249,
-0.06211976706981659,
-0.537942111492157,
-0.03875816985964775,
1.0620547533035278,
0.607782781124115,
-0.17913319170475006,
0.35239091515541077,
0.06946630030870438,
0.7226898074150085,
-0.6781917810440063,
-0.13399803638458252,
-0.6976104974746704,
0.05951910465955734,
-0.13780800998210907,
-0.23330937325954437,
-0.5658581852912903,
-0.15697965025901794,
0.17630741000175476,
-0.38149142265319824,
-0.14991939067840576,
0.019296154379844666,
0.8418288826942444,
0.19916443526744843,
-0.7777485251426697,
0.0673113614320755,
-0.8115299940109253,
0.6845548152923584,
-0.3065749704837799,
0.3378062844276428,
0.04514598101377487,
0.5066813230514526,
-0.2379906326532364,
-0.49312835931777954,
-0.4545815587043762,
-0.09714405238628387,
0.16490371525287628,
0.04858215153217316,
-0.09136577695608139,
0.06496405601501465,
0.16804887354373932,
0.4476001560688019,
-0.6051456928253174,
-0.23791395127773285,
-0.3718445897102356,
-0.34160542488098145,
0.18741607666015625,
0.15976329147815704,
0.06820937991142273,
0.11705446243286133,
-0.6667213439941406,
0.28025391697883606,
-0.6339694857597351,
0.27011415362358093,
-0.005764687433838844,
0.02451501414179802,
-0.1227034404873848,
0.3548944592475891,
0.02282758802175522,
1.095314383506775,
-0.03268826752901077,
-0.17376834154129028,
0.09420199692249298,
-0.09068207442760468,
-0.4072854518890381,
-0.4490584433078766,
0.3909485936164856,
-0.07030335068702698,
-0.3298128843307495,
-0.31668102741241455,
-0.1606452465057373,
0.22325141727924347,
0.3051084578037262,
-0.5394247174263,
0.07876993715763092,
0.31577596068382263,
-0.2624359130859375,
0.1642710566520691,
-0.17170225083827972,
-0.6080026030540466,
-0.21039535105228424,
-0.28696906566619873,
0.38280388712882996,
-0.7314022183418274,
-0.23005987703800201,
-0.0431612990796566,
0.0565120093524456,
0.25721481442451477,
0.24167871475219727,
-0.5084894299507141,
0.5139567852020264,
0.5641550421714783,
1.0710607767105103,
-0.608756422996521,
-0.23914387822151184,
-0.855148196220398,
0.4169084131717682,
-0.36702659726142883,
0.5183612704277039,
-0.7370167970657349,
-0.245928093791008,
-0.32129430770874023,
-0.1716340035200119,
-0.26829779148101807,
-0.24413645267486572,
0.2458907663822174,
-0.8032448291778564,
-0.1317802518606186,
0.03767234832048416,
-0.6925187110900879,
-0.2020646333694458,
-0.08793329447507858,
-0.5882968306541443,
1.0210776329040527,
0.264647513628006,
-0.37767598032951355,
0.23376229405403137,
-0.7659964561462402,
-0.6641361713409424,
0.25054502487182617,
-0.04529205709695816,
-0.1455187052488327,
0.01241061557084322,
0.019800858572125435,
0.5006896257400513,
-0.04671917110681534,
0.6343119144439697,
-0.39921098947525024,
-0.5922986268997192,
0.23454350233078003,
-0.24822892248630524,
0.6491948366165161,
0.4020472764968872,
-0.20357447862625122,
0.3232499957084656,
-0.9039514660835266,
-0.09519606828689575,
0.07056500762701035,
-0.8852344751358032,
-0.37882885336875916,
-0.2677050828933716,
0.19897691905498505,
0.3662528693675995,
0.2373609095811844,
-0.6254236102104187,
0.11318415403366089,
-0.2719976007938385,
0.49750882387161255,
0.8565922379493713,
-0.21925990283489227,
0.7304484248161316,
-0.05672754347324371,
0.7747887372970581,
0.28117725253105164,
0.06684503704309464,
-0.5045021772384644,
-0.2914867401123047,
-0.6851575374603271,
-0.6380042433738708,
0.4433860182762146,
0.32955673336982727,
-0.7700484991073608,
0.3922125995159149,
-0.32740944623947144,
-0.23686915636062622,
-0.5645087361335754,
0.016303427517414093,
0.402877539396286,
0.4738050401210785,
0.1957463026046753,
-0.2900104522705078,
-0.5956874489784241,
-1.0400588512420654,
-0.04124455153942108,
0.2987237274646759,
0.0710701271891594,
0.6053663492202759,
0.38278019428253174,
-0.3477342426776886,
1.2817903757095337,
-0.347523957490921,
-0.24480843544006348,
-0.2766091823577881,
-0.3512797951698303,
0.09927478432655334,
0.3614034056663513,
0.654778242111206,
-0.730047881603241,
-0.5832808613777161,
-0.14571797847747803,
-0.33635708689689636,
0.05939646065235138,
-0.12558667361736298,
-0.32310470938682556,
0.6103571653366089,
0.026115596294403076,
-0.48735225200653076,
0.14694970846176147,
0.8295255899429321,
-0.2558158040046692,
0.23217076063156128,
-0.0744825005531311,
-0.25433120131492615,
-1.2740232944488525,
0.3152921497821808,
0.17877508699893951,
-0.5241626501083374,
-0.651323676109314,
0.16985191404819489,
0.5339773893356323,
-0.3057887852191925,
-0.5827709436416626,
0.7592893838882446,
-0.6731723546981812,
-0.43321821093559265,
-0.45116719603538513,
0.2951009273529053,
-0.3076467514038086,
0.8799362778663635,
-0.09837719053030014,
0.6430137157440186,
0.7206334471702576,
-0.747673749923706,
0.21114227175712585,
-0.3575422167778015,
-0.3131316602230072,
0.2642964720726013,
-0.2601653039455414,
0.25320205092430115,
0.007564290892332792,
0.8613712787628174,
-1.1912389993667603,
-0.15678852796554565,
-0.06344656646251678,
-0.27339449524879456,
0.46636125445365906,
-0.20163477957248688,
-0.3706246316432953,
-0.504640519618988,
-0.24048076570034027,
0.2698741853237152,
0.3193591833114624,
-0.6378147602081299,
0.9240196943283081,
0.9937154054641724,
0.03327702358365059,
-0.7265818119049072,
-0.5042838454246521,
0.14864616096019745,
-0.256806343793869,
-0.5533172488212585,
0.34437116980552673,
-0.17273159325122833,
0.3601192831993103,
-0.04295307397842407,
-0.42631974816322327,
0.03769722208380699,
0.14542290568351746,
0.33310744166374207,
0.3353789448738098,
-0.14589627087116241,
-0.060909610241651535,
0.4214487373828888,
-0.05369825288653374,
-0.3508032262325287,
-0.7101433873176575,
0.797077476978302,
-0.5780887007713318,
0.13223664462566376,
-0.07018452882766724,
0.5474569201469421,
0.5956616997718811,
-0.05058639496564865,
0.9515315890312195,
0.2967999577522278,
-0.3650336265563965,
-0.46704763174057007,
-0.4483005702495575,
0.11291680485010147,
-0.47539180517196655,
0.16409337520599365,
-0.6739243268966675,
-1.3300265073776245,
0.6592526435852051,
-0.06647157669067383,
0.0759853795170784,
-0.09694353491067886,
0.38856491446495056,
-0.02064906246960163,
0.938302755355835,
0.6639977693557739,
-0.38368552923202515,
0.5558884739875793,
-0.18888433277606964,
-0.06381870806217194,
-0.9958755970001221,
0.01149470079690218,
0.011603848077356815,
-0.48124244809150696,
-0.11024613678455353,
-0.5299055576324463,
0.3453110158443451,
-0.07007268071174622,
-0.03766926750540733,
0.6111379861831665,
-0.30012980103492737,
0.8075277209281921,
0.4767448604106903,
0.05748337507247925,
-0.20722149312496185,
-0.009805564768612385,
-0.504608154296875,
0.14370279014110565,
-0.8331655859947205,
-0.38660532236099243,
0.7992298603057861,
0.47587013244628906,
0.6679878234863281,
0.1244613453745842,
0.4621042013168335,
0.18497590720653534,
0.1237364411354065,
-0.5703657865524292,
0.9924542307853699,
0.03410171717405319,
-0.664874792098999,
-0.27636080980300903,
-0.4094769060611725,
-0.7527016401290894,
0.6032242178916931,
0.26559269428253174,
-0.8167823553085327,
-0.032211873680353165,
0.37451615929603577,
-0.5136725306510925,
0.2787359952926636,
-0.6368837952613831,
0.648908793926239,
-0.13251133263111115,
-0.3303424119949341,
-0.15942245721817017,
-0.9230824708938599,
0.550383985042572,
-0.1625029742717743,
-0.06300418823957443,
0.01252993755042553,
-0.279673308134079,
0.6532111167907715,
-0.005371210630983114,
0.8440706133842468,
-0.24196857213974,
-0.038300126791000366,
0.24447672069072723,
0.3376942276954651,
0.37917253375053406,
-0.24571098387241364,
0.32434388995170593,
-0.0933714359998703,
-0.03524184972047806,
-0.6028379797935486,
-0.34730690717697144,
0.9865812659263611,
-0.6254466772079468,
-0.6201474666595459,
-0.2502196431159973,
-0.7206424474716187,
-0.3336910903453827,
0.058652229607105255,
-0.18677924573421478,
0.3204469084739685,
-0.09621179103851318,
0.3842291235923767,
0.6877185106277466,
-0.18586285412311554,
0.6199624538421631,
0.9321574568748474,
-0.4023578464984894,
-0.26657742261886597,
0.992175817489624,
0.2679694592952728,
0.11559753119945526,
0.5509850978851318,
-0.0024851462803781033,
-0.3123849034309387,
-0.1757041960954666,
-0.7250331044197083,
0.214792862534523,
-0.6425857543945312,
0.04377574101090431,
-1.0249935388565063,
-0.23652924597263336,
-0.49258580803871155,
-0.008498162031173706,
-0.39613115787506104,
-0.6609663367271423,
-0.05877207964658737,
-0.21032308042049408,
0.12113836407661438,
0.272586852312088,
-0.12464556097984314,
0.24699832499027252,
-0.6707373261451721,
0.4072237014770508,
0.2080446034669876,
0.5107725858688354,
0.30598190426826477,
-0.7124616503715515,
-0.5232422351837158,
-0.3515043556690216,
-0.4183965027332306,
-1.0417332649230957,
0.3970012366771698,
0.14389726519584656,
0.6541980504989624,
0.4687294363975525,
-0.11184441298246384,
0.829428493976593,
-0.47928565740585327,
0.8012094497680664,
0.024978503584861755,
-1.0307579040527344,
0.6332129836082458,
-0.36103975772857666,
0.35020503401756287,
0.12980476021766663,
0.42863020300865173,
-0.47920292615890503,
-0.37982866168022156,
-0.45297810435295105,
-1.0180083513259888,
0.9608219265937805,
0.04026022180914879,
-0.0824509784579277,
-0.040713146328926086,
0.16964197158813477,
0.17217500507831573,
0.05391310155391693,
-0.8152393698692322,
-0.3163667321205139,
-0.04796547070145607,
0.02985747717320919,
-0.032535143196582794,
-0.32075685262680054,
-0.19915470480918884,
-0.24829347431659698,
0.737367570400238,
-0.29212743043899536,
0.3290071487426758,
-0.19643673300743103,
-0.2927026152610779,
-0.10409817099571228,
0.3226200342178345,
0.8404879570007324,
0.7698436379432678,
-0.06070292741060257,
0.09185435622930527,
0.2469821721315384,
-0.2510947287082672,
0.34648972749710083,
0.158037468791008,
-0.19271600246429443,
-0.06355355679988861,
-0.34895631670951843,
0.957273006439209,
0.296994686126709,
-0.5587795376777649,
0.2752632200717926,
0.08611561357975006,
0.22755375504493713,
-0.18405306339263916,
0.19010844826698303,
0.3787517249584198,
0.0776948630809784,
0.4248752295970917,
0.08030616492033005,
0.21736615896224976,
-0.4156721532344818,
0.09610635042190552,
0.3863312602043152,
-0.2406943291425705,
-0.16143831610679626,
0.789705216884613,
0.4115188419818878,
-0.2103266566991806,
0.10969502478837967,
0.11926917731761932,
-0.24174638092517853,
0.5792531967163086,
0.7524200081825256,
0.8087758421897888,
-0.35455891489982605,
0.2411695420742035,
0.033264029771089554,
0.10554175078868866,
0.06766564399003983,
0.19345387816429138,
-0.5863237977027893,
-0.5678758025169373,
-0.30871638655662537,
-0.8918927311897278,
-0.32993894815444946,
0.36892369389533997,
-0.5937274098396301,
-0.1634049117565155,
-0.5235394835472107,
-0.20834362506866455,
-0.12290523201227188,
-0.08949651569128036,
-0.13123181462287903,
0.09135644882917404,
0.24179896712303162,
1.185282588005066,
-0.7277343273162842,
1.4966394901275635,
0.7344467043876648,
-0.023960039019584656,
-0.5963062644004822,
-0.11674550920724869,
0.24163228273391724,
-0.42205530405044556,
0.1629796326160431,
0.4365338683128357,
-0.3713672161102295,
-0.13680976629257202,
-0.45834892988204956,
-1.0148581266403198,
1.0726585388183594,
0.36948469281196594,
-0.7205787301063538,
0.08176955580711365,
-0.10336457192897797,
0.5900865793228149,
-0.5200474858283997,
-0.33154770731925964,
0.7169367074966431,
-0.06527280807495117,
0.24207906424999237,
-0.5393431186676025,
-0.010730473324656487,
-0.412556916475296,
0.48381584882736206,
0.27398598194122314,
-0.9454087018966675,
0.575389564037323,
-0.12430350482463837,
-0.482177197933197,
0.14530442655086517,
0.9898995757102966,
0.6312700510025024,
0.2703142464160919,
0.558851420879364,
0.5511569976806641,
0.7129529118537903,
0.06409914791584015,
1.179154872894287,
-0.38748711347579956,
-0.013852085918188095,
1.173543930053711,
-0.5348325967788696,
0.7718436121940613,
0.4628090262413025,
0.07985140383243561,
0.29338204860687256,
0.8157927393913269,
0.43963679671287537,
0.6691147685050964,
0.05532693490386009,
-0.21998077630996704,
-0.12691035866737366,
0.24093268811702728,
-0.15829282999038696,
-0.12915834784507751,
0.4335241913795471,
-0.25521373748779297,
0.24833114445209503,
0.2832375168800354,
-0.0774863213300705,
-0.08177720755338669,
-0.2755095958709717,
0.6210010051727295,
0.2661610245704651,
-0.8996005058288574,
0.4972834587097168,
0.16242794692516327,
0.7730455994606018,
-0.7051869630813599,
0.32012996077537537,
-0.5741058588027954,
0.3043650686740875,
0.21764139831066132,
-0.7754069566726685,
0.25135836005210876,
0.0895024985074997,
-0.32153964042663574,
-0.1693713217973709,
0.6795008182525635,
-0.5143473744392395,
-0.021477704867720604,
0.49259045720100403,
-0.01277056522667408,
0.23133741319179535,
0.07118889689445496,
-0.6212126016616821,
0.06659168004989624,
-0.1299823522567749,
-0.4212492108345032,
0.5487369298934937,
0.15382473170757294,
-0.1990528553724289,
0.904000997543335,
0.5166969299316406,
-0.0656236782670021,
0.5122950673103333,
-0.07785244286060333,
0.9850258231163025,
-0.7738072872161865,
-1.046470046043396,
-0.6309632658958435,
0.25314638018608093,
-0.047704875469207764,
-0.1473030298948288,
0.6422357559204102,
0.7949373126029968,
0.6234572529792786,
-0.31301867961883545,
0.6743996143341064,
0.01979140378534794,
0.5909993052482605,
-0.3502543568611145,
0.5214800238609314,
-0.5946881175041199,
0.19450004398822784,
-0.17474229633808136,
-0.8819026350975037,
0.029707932844758034,
0.33421918749809265,
-0.05350666865706444,
0.07835963368415833,
0.3806803226470947,
0.6912180781364441,
-0.30208566784858704,
-0.02108965441584587,
0.48234325647354126,
0.35707420110702515,
0.22282135486602783,
0.9139180183410645,
0.8769388198852539,
-0.14467650651931763,
0.7106174826622009,
-0.02757362090051174,
-0.3831341862678528,
-0.3866250813007355,
-0.6389755606651306,
-0.7522614002227783,
-0.7803122401237488,
-0.06865425407886505,
-0.31153175234794617,
-0.02704540267586708,
0.7644092440605164,
1.0073058605194092,
-0.7085625529289246,
-0.21408329904079437,
0.1813758909702301,
0.011666487902402878,
-0.26484933495521545,
-0.27623188495635986,
0.21613334119319916,
-0.009834563359618187,
-0.6711185574531555,
0.8627992272377014,
0.7289303541183472,
0.17293837666511536,
-0.3465578556060791,
-0.21338193118572235,
-0.21796303987503052,
0.3656271994113922,
0.8584598302841187,
0.45307549834251404,
-0.9204685688018799,
0.015618249773979187,
-0.04488147795200348,
-0.4092751741409302,
-0.14758408069610596,
0.6869603991508484,
-0.9618417620658875,
0.23245540261268616,
0.39024046063423157,
0.7627698183059692,
0.805874764919281,
-0.036821987479925156,
0.5179375410079956,
-0.9433668255805969,
0.12185069918632507,
0.0829504057765007,
0.5790826082229614,
0.18476024270057678,
-0.21832746267318726,
0.5299721956253052,
0.16721658408641815,
-0.37281545996665955,
-0.763096809387207,
0.20083977282047272,
-1.3556954860687256,
-0.5697905421257019,
1.234615683555603,
-0.30247464776039124,
-0.5008652210235596,
0.0667169839143753,
-0.39440131187438965,
-0.01335779670625925,
-0.6299465298652649,
0.6672789454460144,
0.5597438216209412,
-0.04748786985874176,
-0.2554383873939514,
-0.21019092202186584,
0.19347010552883148,
0.3964586853981018,
-0.4759790897369385,
-0.14364543557167053,
0.563751757144928,
0.3435986638069153,
0.23752710223197937,
0.8294447660446167,
0.015063082799315453,
0.4367053508758545,
-0.16582371294498444,
-0.3998805284500122,
-0.1742175966501236,
-0.8185397982597351,
-0.513996958732605,
0.5060979723930359,
-0.68204665184021,
-0.39731618762016296
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.07505v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.07505v1
|
THaLLE: Text Hyperlocally Augmented Large Language Extension -- Technical Report
| 2024-06-11T17:40:00 | 2024-06-11T17:40:00 |
KBTG Labs, Danupat Khamnuansin, Atthakorn Petchsod, Anuruth Lertpiya, Pornchanan Balee, Thanawat Lodkaew, Tawunrat Chalothorn, Thadpong Pongthawornkamol, Monchai Lertsutthiwong
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Recent advancements in Large Language Models (LLMs) have revealed new
capabilities and opportunities across the technological landscape. However, the
practicality of very large LLMs is challenged by their high compute cost, which
does not justify the benefits given their limited capability compared to
humans. While smaller, more practical LLMs have shown potential in financial
analysis, though they are not yet fully proficient, as evidenced by their
near-passing performance on the Chartered Financial Analyst (CFA) exam. In this
work, we present Financial Analyst Extension to our Text Hyperlocally Augmented
Large Language Extension (THaLLE), a series of 8B LLMs consistently achieving
highest performance on mock CFA exams against models of comparable size. We
thoroughly document the fine-tuning techniques used to facilitate future
research. Additionally, we introduce the use of Flare CFA, a publicly available
dataset for evaluating LLMs as a financial advisor.
|
[
-0.2607104480266571,
-0.893907368183136,
0.2253800928592682,
0.3880736827850342,
0.0181774590164423,
0.48290199041366577,
-0.4083574116230011,
-0.9268842935562134,
0.4855639338493347,
0.7377376556396484,
-0.39527231454849243,
-0.442156046628952,
-0.5579551458358765,
0.3226933479309082,
-0.608660101890564,
0.7288832068443298,
0.30925410985946655,
-0.1842595636844635,
0.13682536780834198,
0.0639604851603508,
-0.16659753024578094,
-0.5208797454833984,
-0.7544529438018799,
-0.17714670300483704,
0.3409002423286438,
0.5653080940246582,
0.8773272633552551,
0.38904044032096863,
0.6862407922744751,
0.3834431767463684,
-0.20993641018867493,
0.30410897731781006,
-0.5357677340507507,
-0.1953050047159195,
-0.152700737118721,
-0.28654617071151733,
-0.8930783271789551,
-0.010251175612211227,
0.6321596503257751,
0.9323110580444336,
0.12017297744750977,
0.31074705719947815,
-0.11834810674190521,
0.8822936415672302,
-0.6198696494102478,
0.1805063784122467,
-0.4545626640319824,
-0.1518947333097458,
-0.2202337235212326,
-0.2355712503194809,
-0.5701119899749756,
-0.3181665241718292,
0.49639928340911865,
-0.5734386444091797,
-0.2742795944213867,
0.15526309609413147,
0.8096926808357239,
0.0690663754940033,
-0.6332985162734985,
-0.04757161810994148,
-0.8143301010131836,
0.9161983728408813,
-0.7751597166061401,
0.562534749507904,
0.5111798644065857,
0.3362501859664917,
-0.06659920513629913,
-0.7498347759246826,
-0.24703596532344818,
-0.45962342619895935,
0.0957910344004631,
-0.09381207078695297,
-0.3183339536190033,
0.19603917002677917,
0.32199424505233765,
0.3275994658470154,
-0.15326140820980072,
0.4325410723686218,
-0.4560368061065674,
-0.4836702346801758,
0.7391099333763123,
0.2256857007741928,
-0.2179008275270462,
0.14555028080940247,
-0.29019737243652344,
0.04614013433456421,
-0.4362695515155792,
-0.29802456498146057,
0.23848797380924225,
0.3251737654209137,
-0.2383945733308792,
0.6816375851631165,
0.00006601108179893345,
1.1050355434417725,
-0.1281987428665161,
-0.44552311301231384,
0.08914749324321747,
-0.10989846289157867,
-0.3735993802547455,
0.09480256587266922,
0.32700902223587036,
0.5031329989433289,
0.3684641718864441,
0.037358518689870834,
-0.14911898970603943,
-0.538652241230011,
-0.08935309946537018,
-0.7139729261398315,
0.0674085021018982,
0.21174050867557526,
-0.3003038763999939,
-0.292290598154068,
-0.3043740689754486,
-1.0109660625457764,
-0.43701744079589844,
-0.49508410692214966,
0.17961347103118896,
-0.32136020064353943,
-0.07422609627246857,
0.28393352031707764,
0.027769217267632484,
0.30290690064430237,
0.2620106637477875,
-0.6169008016586304,
0.32863849401474,
0.5784918665885925,
0.6974694728851318,
-0.017773374915122986,
-0.2866886854171753,
-0.7393848896026611,
0.17442159354686737,
-0.5195353031158447,
0.743344783782959,
-0.5874598622322083,
-0.5803799629211426,
0.2748602330684662,
-0.31258848309516907,
0.1612573266029358,
-0.5151473879814148,
0.44876670837402344,
-0.8684390187263489,
-0.06557896733283997,
-0.27230700850486755,
-0.7852073907852173,
-0.24243424832820892,
0.3808760643005371,
-0.6061221361160278,
1.0780149698257446,
0.32558608055114746,
-0.5508928894996643,
0.20088036358356476,
-0.7158113121986389,
-0.4973607361316681,
0.3507826328277588,
0.1748279631137848,
-0.06596238166093826,
-0.053933728486299515,
0.0461401641368866,
0.36902952194213867,
-0.7639672756195068,
-0.08774495869874954,
-0.30429455637931824,
-0.3688734769821167,
0.38301995396614075,
-0.3689316511154175,
0.4014781415462494,
-0.052250705659389496,
-0.25714653730392456,
0.037445735186338425,
-1.1805275678634644,
0.039433348923921585,
-0.30010175704956055,
-0.263775110244751,
-0.4578491747379303,
-0.3602847456932068,
0.3719368278980255,
-0.09323740005493164,
0.43112996220588684,
-0.40715518593788147,
0.07224936783313751,
-0.7379608750343323,
0.28271037340164185,
0.6879240870475769,
-0.12453003972768784,
0.4526755213737488,
-0.05852135643362999,
0.5821866989135742,
-0.1941368132829666,
-0.06922055035829544,
0.006149741820991039,
-0.34381940960884094,
-0.8471783995628357,
-0.4673481285572052,
0.41732722520828247,
0.5282282829284668,
-0.523186981678009,
0.50697922706604,
-0.08179901540279388,
-0.5937752723693848,
-0.20193418860435486,
0.44301044940948486,
0.08931966125965118,
0.5503218770027161,
0.34411177039146423,
0.18446232378482819,
-0.6245323419570923,
-1.045061707496643,
-0.24454239010810852,
-0.08166325837373734,
0.36271947622299194,
-0.12488314509391785,
0.3923265039920807,
-0.4786047637462616,
1.1102172136306763,
-0.7588291764259338,
-0.2898288071155548,
-0.501818060874939,
-0.0076388162560760975,
0.08860529959201813,
0.19418062269687653,
0.8602874279022217,
-0.782633364200592,
-0.26479852199554443,
0.3090563714504242,
-0.38677993416786194,
-0.07958083599805832,
-0.14427028596401215,
-0.07261807471513748,
0.3082793653011322,
0.7753720283508301,
-0.13910533487796783,
0.4592495858669281,
0.7349083423614502,
-0.44781237840652466,
0.8376063108444214,
-0.38299185037612915,
-0.18360492587089539,
-1.019364833831787,
-0.05404281243681908,
0.594408392906189,
-0.2647179365158081,
-0.6151506304740906,
-0.13870395720005035,
0.026195961982011795,
-0.1492708921432495,
-0.19771292805671692,
1.0927881002426147,
-0.4500836133956909,
-0.2223931849002838,
-0.6602281928062439,
0.1159907728433609,
-0.12746617197990417,
-0.002602487104013562,
-0.005666925106197596,
0.9708046913146973,
0.6244125962257385,
-0.5555375814437866,
0.5232211947441101,
0.013890952803194523,
-0.4966365098953247,
0.3263554573059082,
-0.5482801795005798,
-0.12391772121191025,
0.17495861649513245,
0.16202621161937714,
-0.5934183597564697,
-0.3909139037132263,
-0.4955866038799286,
0.06761015206575394,
0.3799077570438385,
0.29311567544937134,
-0.47861960530281067,
-0.46322324872016907,
-0.14464987814426422,
0.4653398096561432,
0.33097973465919495,
-0.6287457942962646,
0.7898263931274414,
0.22195594012737274,
-0.045426495373249054,
-0.5883328318595886,
-0.6444845795631409,
0.5070276856422424,
-0.29066741466522217,
-0.7496205568313599,
0.1636774241924286,
-0.017250906676054,
-0.6855274438858032,
-0.295718789100647,
0.20622901618480682,
-0.1796613335609436,
0.06903991848230362,
-0.04053390026092529,
0.5602132081985474,
-0.3504057228565216,
0.13476617634296417,
-0.07777821272611618,
-0.09623733907938004,
0.023146547377109528,
-0.40768760442733765,
0.2771972119808197,
-0.3692218065261841,
-0.07973036915063858,
-0.4933180510997772,
0.10471551865339279,
0.8160501718521118,
-0.31269291043281555,
0.9289155006408691,
0.503800094127655,
-0.42856982350349426,
-0.10639294981956482,
-1.062143325805664,
-0.002862893044948578,
-0.6037153005599976,
0.6013262867927551,
-0.3176557421684265,
-1.248868703842163,
0.6006789207458496,
-0.07001884281635284,
0.23772583901882172,
0.4908543825149536,
0.571420431137085,
0.2224283367395401,
0.4955041706562042,
1.0398460626602173,
-0.28220903873443604,
0.2405950427055359,
-0.29510971903800964,
0.3213910460472107,
-0.44064128398895264,
-0.20093822479248047,
-0.4764387607574463,
-0.2478598654270172,
-0.47484785318374634,
-0.355431467294693,
0.5065605044364929,
-0.04958786070346832,
-0.31986507773399353,
0.28873082995414734,
0.0010350936790928245,
0.6254364252090454,
0.2291366308927536,
-0.23841916024684906,
0.4717835485935211,
0.01319064013659954,
0.12587648630142212,
-0.1369735449552536,
-0.46921125054359436,
-0.5484980344772339,
1.0067453384399414,
0.5182740092277527,
0.8082238435745239,
0.15516060590744019,
0.33612555265426636,
0.4026424288749695,
0.407379686832428,
-0.9402021169662476,
0.7081958055496216,
-0.041326023638248444,
-0.5338643193244934,
-0.32180944085121155,
-0.571293294429779,
-0.5257904529571533,
-0.1263834834098816,
-0.19118770956993103,
-0.889387309551239,
0.18572159111499786,
0.12792247533798218,
-0.5109665989875793,
0.3328492343425751,
-0.8427234292030334,
0.477895587682724,
-0.1348056048154831,
-0.42452189326286316,
-0.2909097671508789,
-0.20602403581142426,
0.6722849011421204,
-0.6878472566604614,
0.382415235042572,
0.12215565145015717,
-0.4246704578399658,
0.8507056832313538,
-0.5092976689338684,
0.8858528733253479,
0.24174536764621735,
-0.478496789932251,
0.3393095135688782,
0.2392255663871765,
0.34201622009277344,
0.33980241417884827,
-0.5338276028633118,
-0.11662434041500092,
0.027004115283489227,
-0.7066904306411743,
-0.5875476598739624,
0.9722815155982971,
-0.5079736709594727,
-0.7469994425773621,
-0.4395102858543396,
-1.0550035238265991,
-0.7274941205978394,
0.10669200122356415,
0.04257895052433014,
0.5620893836021423,
-0.2806464433670044,
-0.044922977685928345,
0.21810618042945862,
-0.2208947241306305,
0.48223790526390076,
0.4316345155239105,
-0.48094022274017334,
-0.36515381932258606,
0.6984977126121521,
0.026960264891386032,
0.3575455844402313,
0.30796170234680176,
0.257947713136673,
-0.48941686749458313,
-0.4329576790332794,
-0.10696969926357269,
0.44575822353363037,
-0.6643244028091431,
-0.14819906651973724,
-0.502488911151886,
-0.13413767516613007,
-0.5629618167877197,
-0.5935060977935791,
-0.2832529544830322,
-0.6825186610221863,
-0.21717894077301025,
-0.38487398624420166,
0.895847737789154,
0.7269038558006287,
-0.20583775639533997,
0.4351860582828522,
-1.24396550655365,
-0.31453511118888855,
0.1318621188402176,
0.21716174483299255,
0.2017236053943634,
-0.6453890800476074,
-0.6026325225830078,
-0.1939314901828766,
-0.029736775904893875,
-0.5496906042098999,
0.4643827974796295,
0.1194780245423317,
0.16567005217075348,
0.760571300983429,
-0.07680436968803406,
0.7976604104042053,
-0.0527561791241169,
0.6096869707107544,
0.3063531517982483,
-0.9237446188926697,
0.05827108025550842,
-0.4062672257423401,
0.37601223587989807,
0.46263739466667175,
0.2153109312057495,
-0.3549032509326935,
-0.1768912374973297,
-0.27755260467529297,
-0.5463556051254272,
0.2556212246417999,
0.12128056585788727,
0.2116396725177765,
-0.01016357820481062,
0.483611136674881,
-0.1346532106399536,
0.005865462590008974,
-0.3873082995414734,
-0.16509969532489777,
0.19751086831092834,
0.04679092764854431,
-0.3502665162086487,
-0.5268567204475403,
-0.1686139702796936,
-0.479519248008728,
0.7760400176048279,
-0.22363319993019104,
-0.2104540765285492,
0.10854896157979965,
0.17586684226989746,
-0.00741164805367589,
0.19471217691898346,
0.6928899884223938,
0.9851139187812805,
-0.2045193910598755,
-0.04972994327545166,
0.5346904993057251,
-0.5011522173881531,
-0.021978523582220078,
0.301359623670578,
0.29538607597351074,
-0.01439231913536787,
0.7219222784042358,
0.3448292315006256,
0.4611336588859558,
-1.06651771068573,
0.11307238787412643,
0.298176646232605,
-0.3231871426105499,
-0.22958314418792725,
-0.2816610634326935,
0.3185594975948334,
0.24335412681102753,
0.6671034097671509,
-0.18821397423744202,
0.004397280514240265,
-0.6286149024963379,
0.11002209782600403,
0.15121549367904663,
-0.6090831160545349,
-0.23585036396980286,
0.3532395660877228,
0.5083211064338684,
-0.19002893567085266,
0.4420090615749359,
-0.13229936361312866,
-0.6901226043701172,
0.6353625655174255,
0.580736517906189,
0.7102762460708618,
-0.03825114667415619,
0.10613725334405899,
0.1845240592956543,
0.40117233991622925,
-0.14807924628257751,
0.3294290006160736,
0.34333112835884094,
-0.49765482544898987,
-0.9124101996421814,
-0.7564593553543091,
-0.4169752299785614,
0.036570727825164795,
-0.48048195242881775,
0.351349800825119,
-0.5391103029251099,
-0.49373939633369446,
0.19387464225292206,
0.0981220230460167,
-0.36795517802238464,
0.2928246557712555,
-0.14998853206634521,
1.6984344720840454,
-0.27270516753196716,
0.6850559115409851,
0.730894148349762,
0.05325329303741455,
-0.7388246655464172,
-0.06889147311449051,
0.20510658621788025,
-0.5521026253700256,
0.8596790432929993,
-0.208069309592247,
-0.32734784483909607,
-0.0166685301810503,
-0.3058503568172455,
-0.7969179749488831,
0.722551703453064,
0.3450278341770172,
-0.7187709808349609,
-0.3919175863265991,
0.3568483889102936,
0.5970891118049622,
-0.3637104332447052,
0.19567503035068512,
0.9045387506484985,
0.6647563576698303,
0.21463626623153687,
-1.0742177963256836,
-0.3008354604244232,
0.12184230983257294,
-0.0875622034072876,
0.403554230928421,
-0.8867373466491699,
0.30299627780914307,
-0.3827309310436249,
0.4682912230491638,
0.1938299983739853,
1.134617567062378,
0.013509996235370636,
0.41071444749832153,
0.3685280680656433,
0.3520224690437317,
0.7664511203765869,
0.10217005014419556,
1.067562222480774,
-0.504914402961731,
0.259921669960022,
0.9687511324882507,
-0.6251353025436401,
0.752681314945221,
0.290779709815979,
-0.0016149389557540417,
0.43974563479423523,
0.508531928062439,
0.09237978607416153,
-0.18621231615543365,
0.08933813124895096,
-0.4263349175453186,
-0.582086443901062,
-0.3299520015716553,
-0.3282763361930847,
0.6627655625343323,
0.5195112824440002,
-0.17864355444908142,
-0.23184189200401306,
0.17683182656764984,
-0.1254602074623108,
0.3441578149795532,
-0.6378697156906128,
0.24055925011634827,
0.5036644339561462,
-0.13729456067085266,
0.308315634727478,
0.17907151579856873,
0.5449497103691101,
-0.691394031047821,
0.2778484523296356,
-0.1443949192762375,
0.27137327194213867,
-0.27399468421936035,
-0.5823475122451782,
0.4509596824645996,
0.2249085158109665,
0.09028873592615128,
0.08947023004293442,
0.6905578970909119,
-0.07213956862688065,
-1.0407395362854004,
0.5399760007858276,
0.5551548600196838,
-0.20760959386825562,
0.18148986995220184,
-0.39932817220687866,
-0.11532452702522278,
-0.08780644834041595,
-0.3084551692008972,
0.3889724016189575,
0.3870011270046234,
-0.13263699412345886,
0.9095906615257263,
0.6501314640045166,
0.1693931221961975,
-0.05957942456007004,
0.06943496316671371,
0.9057419896125793,
-0.805513858795166,
-0.5539039373397827,
-0.7727086544036865,
0.032308656722307205,
-0.21516256034374237,
-0.424469918012619,
0.9003419280052185,
1.0506389141082764,
0.5416312217712402,
0.1405402421951294,
0.510884702205658,
0.46283695101737976,
0.5535703301429749,
-0.5547933578491211,
0.6124303936958313,
-0.5616002678871155,
0.4371861219406128,
-0.4209301471710205,
-1.145434856414795,
-0.3498360514640808,
0.1181911826133728,
-0.6088460683822632,
-0.12234045565128326,
0.6178168654441833,
0.7584394216537476,
-0.059561848640441895,
0.3825170397758484,
0.6178961992263794,
0.3530256748199463,
0.125843808054924,
0.17819948494434357,
0.5801746845245361,
-0.1700940728187561,
0.6579537987709045,
-0.1692541539669037,
-0.3211979568004608,
-0.1986168473958969,
-0.856292724609375,
-1.1857330799102783,
-0.30526626110076904,
-0.44366511702537537,
-0.4962660074234009,
-0.2548362910747528,
1.1738349199295044,
0.5818796157836914,
-0.4316675066947937,
-0.641383171081543,
0.5626630187034607,
-0.18426939845085144,
0.009574230760335922,
-0.2169514149427414,
0.41431620717048645,
-0.11252334713935852,
-0.8107959628105164,
0.5687002539634705,
0.5491203665733337,
0.3330034017562866,
-0.3951271176338196,
-0.013116695918142796,
-0.08531893789768219,
0.4728376567363739,
0.9038479328155518,
0.2865833044052124,
-0.268515944480896,
-0.11438009887933731,
0.30138909816741943,
0.08213832974433899,
-0.21358557045459747,
0.842658281326294,
-0.45010173320770264,
0.24410203099250793,
0.17215090990066528,
0.9476480484008789,
0.44616907835006714,
-0.08135015517473221,
0.7696780562400818,
-0.3461873531341553,
0.49025478959083557,
0.2585481107234955,
0.29670998454093933,
0.06107966974377632,
-0.3449096977710724,
0.28582891821861267,
-0.04758899286389351,
-0.4076501429080963,
-0.7769889235496521,
0.0569123849272728,
-1.066501259803772,
-0.16172534227371216,
1.2881193161010742,
0.2726183533668518,
-0.2150540053844452,
-0.13218839466571808,
-0.2564842402935028,
-0.2630147933959961,
-0.3820550739765167,
0.5220052003860474,
0.9281938672065735,
0.08198421448469162,
-0.0004889904521405697,
-0.5149956941604614,
0.4911361038684845,
0.5308519601821899,
-0.808463990688324,
0.13335487246513367,
0.48675140738487244,
-0.06761734932661057,
0.23958100378513336,
0.417865514755249,
0.10510551929473877,
0.32443463802337646,
-0.4070398509502411,
-0.31137552857398987,
-0.0015987218357622623,
-0.20839296281337738,
-0.21958892047405243,
0.17581960558891296,
0.303789883852005,
0.43164899945259094
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.07504v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.07504v1
|
Just Because We Camp, Doesn't Mean We Should: The Ethics of Modelling Queer Voices
| 2024-06-11T17:39:46 | 2024-06-11T17:39:46 |
Atli Sigurgeirsson, Eddie L. Ungless
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Modern voice cloning models claim to be able to capture a diverse range of
voices. We test the ability of a typical pipeline to capture the style known
colloquially as "gay voice" and notice a homogenisation effect: synthesised
speech is rated as sounding significantly "less gay" (by LGBTQ+ participants)
than its corresponding ground-truth for speakers with "gay voice", but ratings
actually increase for control speakers. Loss of "gay voice" has implications
for accessibility. We also find that for speakers with "gay voice", loss of
"gay voice" corresponds to lower similarity ratings.
However, we caution that improving the ability of such models to synthesise
``gay voice'' comes with a great number of risks. We use this pipeline as a
starting point for a discussion on the ethics of modelling queer voices more
broadly. Collecting "clean" queer data has safety and fairness ramifications,
and the resulting technology may cause harms from mockery to death.
|
[
-0.4966394901275635,
-0.10171816498041153,
0.42602258920669556,
0.08021686226129532,
-0.16659855842590332,
-0.11285503953695297,
0.19358602166175842,
-0.5242601037025452,
0.012640281580388546,
0.5259633660316467,
-0.5386642813682556,
-0.02368103340268135,
-0.446798175573349,
0.01838529296219349,
-1.0220378637313843,
0.9550541043281555,
0.5975463390350342,
0.4327133595943451,
-0.06599001586437225,
-0.09710807353258133,
-0.279547780752182,
-0.4014204740524292,
-0.5665072798728943,
0.26089757680892944,
0.5768120884895325,
0.13852189481258392,
0.9045687913894653,
0.6412264704704285,
-0.17010755836963654,
0.27973613142967224,
-0.2578061819076538,
-0.3173302412033081,
-0.9974344372749329,
0.17874327301979065,
-0.1009993925690651,
-0.5772364735603333,
-0.3359905183315277,
0.7391032576560974,
0.5939620137214661,
0.6854521036148071,
-0.01613127440214157,
0.24895624816417694,
-0.26616770029067993,
0.6871776580810547,
-0.42069005966186523,
-0.5928835272789001,
-0.7778648138046265,
0.07055844366550446,
-0.13659580051898956,
0.020823249593377113,
-0.2153925895690918,
-0.5082038640975952,
0.17546670138835907,
-0.30981603264808655,
0.7264305353164673,
0.3296297490596771,
0.6228151321411133,
0.06480603665113449,
-0.3085688650608063,
-0.16684399545192719,
-0.9345237016677856,
0.7865752577781677,
-0.8216052055358887,
0.56203293800354,
0.3042243719100952,
0.2940960228443146,
-0.1926051378250122,
-0.8941425681114197,
-0.8413837552070618,
-0.14244502782821655,
0.054881125688552856,
-0.05257477983832359,
0.1589975208044052,
0.08382437378168106,
0.29171955585479736,
0.6160474419593811,
-0.26971524953842163,
-0.2677019536495209,
-1.2612777948379517,
-0.01168496161699295,
1.2312037944793701,
0.01851643994450569,
0.5191203951835632,
-0.06927958130836487,
-0.5084459185600281,
0.06305588036775589,
-0.6592251062393188,
0.11172004044055939,
1.051311731338501,
0.5565957427024841,
0.35548508167266846,
0.5303550362586975,
0.48191210627555847,
0.20199406147003174,
0.19333986937999725,
0.1977303922176361,
0.14829662442207336,
-0.1515173763036728,
-0.3905384838581085,
0.26362720131874084,
0.47290557622909546,
0.6248530149459839,
0.33619406819343567,
-0.12069731950759888,
-0.15144748985767365,
-0.015979649499058723,
0.836612343788147,
-0.5105404257774353,
0.05504610016942024,
0.4564360976219177,
-0.5494676828384399,
-0.17786210775375366,
0.2107875496149063,
-0.7150695323944092,
-0.5693793892860413,
-0.321850061416626,
0.5026065111160278,
-0.043416526168584824,
-0.43585124611854553,
0.16995200514793396,
-0.6652109026908875,
0.10712404549121857,
0.12284338474273682,
-0.6589016914367676,
0.3302517831325531,
0.7659144997596741,
0.4511888921260834,
-0.38215237855911255,
-0.3958583176136017,
-0.5721912384033203,
-0.17277131974697113,
-0.32452207803726196,
0.2863370478153229,
-0.2891172468662262,
-0.6430005431175232,
-0.16223138570785522,
0.15048308670520782,
0.10557998716831207,
-0.5771977305412292,
0.35661643743515015,
-0.07955139875411987,
0.6904836297035217,
-0.2563299238681793,
-0.7066856622695923,
-0.048807963728904724,
-0.522913932800293,
-0.8231407403945923,
0.6376293897628784,
0.11815953999757767,
-0.5188156366348267,
0.6527066230773926,
-0.40635165572166443,
-0.06499135494232178,
-0.0712830200791359,
-0.18399955332279205,
-0.3059079945087433,
0.17525538802146912,
-0.5670658349990845,
0.22133387625217438,
-0.011246382258832455,
0.33235108852386475,
-0.5346264243125916,
-0.635582447052002,
0.09065034985542297,
-0.047264594584703445,
1.0064526796340942,
0.4689972996711731,
-0.6016212105751038,
-0.08698517829179764,
-0.40846678614616394,
-0.05575667694211006,
-0.386844277381897,
0.16871851682662964,
-0.11730815470218658,
0.07657532393932343,
0.6441643834114075,
0.360733300447464,
-0.6015217900276184,
-0.8092281222343445,
-0.3829188644886017,
-0.3179317116737366,
0.405421644449234,
0.7306784391403198,
-0.24207785725593567,
0.5468650460243225,
-0.8335111141204834,
0.5520678162574768,
-0.3441920876502991,
0.5639771223068237,
0.6278741955757141,
-0.7682449817657471,
-0.41534921526908875,
-0.7510455846786499,
0.06650882214307785,
0.2591172754764557,
0.1919819712638855,
0.3489114046096802,
0.08835045993328094,
-0.4844672381877899,
-0.7774705290794373,
-0.019312784075737,
0.050827812403440475,
0.21408866345882416,
0.2303202599287033,
-0.6364171504974365,
-0.5138745903968811,
-1.1865923404693604,
-0.7209485769271851,
-0.448323518037796,
-0.23896518349647522,
0.2216017097234726,
0.2424299716949463,
-0.07136896252632141,
1.0856438875198364,
0.19543084502220154,
-0.1330520063638687,
-0.14942428469657898,
-0.08105212450027466,
0.15085077285766602,
0.6658125519752502,
0.720512330532074,
-1.294203758239746,
-0.1932385265827179,
-0.549652636051178,
-0.24480992555618286,
-0.2837221920490265,
-0.24646535515785217,
-0.24352113902568817,
-0.3012683391571045,
0.44520390033721924,
-0.6679767966270447,
0.6735370755195618,
0.34424325823783875,
-0.47819802165031433,
0.38637787103652954,
0.4796845614910126,
0.36228030920028687,
-0.666252076625824,
0.18860071897506714,
-0.31932246685028076,
-0.44572266936302185,
-0.8681226372718811,
0.1536434292793274,
-0.5036773085594177,
-0.3657850921154022,
-0.9736846089363098,
0.6561015248298645,
-0.09346355497837067,
-0.19835975766181946,
-0.37573039531707764,
0.18894539773464203,
0.23814789950847626,
0.0033730650320649147,
-0.28938308358192444,
0.7550573348999023,
0.34057462215423584,
-0.4179379940032959,
0.5061700940132141,
0.41462358832359314,
-0.01871148869395256,
0.5327193737030029,
-0.4261770248413086,
0.17500384151935577,
-0.4590933918952942,
0.34466832876205444,
-0.9562948942184448,
-0.14849700033664703,
0.08951950073242188,
-0.4868585467338562,
0.16373585164546967,
-0.10880623757839203,
0.029655052348971367,
-0.17170947790145874,
-0.6756188869476318,
0.5057209134101868,
0.8905558586120605,
-0.39970436692237854,
0.5093730688095093,
0.6326932311058044,
-0.3511234223842621,
-0.4791647791862488,
-0.7384635806083679,
-0.1444515585899353,
-0.6850517988204956,
-0.5737820267677307,
0.1202334463596344,
-0.06959130614995956,
-0.3233744204044342,
0.12333144247531891,
-0.22784945368766785,
-0.3994589149951935,
0.25959253311157227,
0.5336220264434814,
-0.10235413908958435,
0.10467074066400528,
0.11085466295480728,
-0.028448961675167084,
0.2748340368270874,
0.18478871881961823,
-0.05266832932829857,
0.1565811038017273,
-0.028917629271745682,
-0.11112181842327118,
-0.42224442958831787,
1.0423654317855835,
0.915632426738739,
0.4033881425857544,
0.39193570613861084,
0.4545021653175354,
-0.3400469422340393,
-0.15250645577907562,
-0.40763917565345764,
-0.19761373102664948,
-0.48473674058914185,
-0.1336708962917328,
0.2400670200586319,
-0.9220786690711975,
0.2647526264190674,
-0.06156932935118675,
0.34691035747528076,
0.4677714407444,
0.33529505133628845,
-0.585850715637207,
0.7718108296394348,
0.5784587264060974,
0.2489832192659378,
0.45670443773269653,
0.04922369495034218,
0.41339150071144104,
-0.5543413758277893,
-0.25810685753822327,
-0.4364771246910095,
-0.7247490286827087,
-0.7945242524147034,
-0.26361188292503357,
0.05716078728437424,
0.05429036170244217,
-0.3423205316066742,
0.20264196395874023,
-0.369568794965744,
0.5618864297866821,
0.6847052574157715,
-0.1484093815088272,
0.13087566196918488,
-0.1281333714723587,
0.20017923414707184,
-0.16848395764827728,
-0.3826450705528259,
-0.7919468879699707,
0.7527974843978882,
0.32695472240448,
0.5658307671546936,
-0.0605313666164875,
0.7802271842956543,
0.6924651861190796,
0.24958007037639618,
-0.36804625391960144,
0.3814990222454071,
-0.21205255389213562,
-1.4395439624786377,
-0.3282320499420166,
-0.2544666528701782,
-0.7396795749664307,
0.17117883265018463,
-0.18201293051242828,
-0.8676412105560303,
0.6382578611373901,
0.11503876745700836,
-0.2301872968673706,
0.5734623074531555,
-0.650231659412384,
0.4664153456687927,
-0.02255290187895298,
-0.4522387683391571,
-0.019045768305659294,
-0.9150980114936829,
0.45746564865112305,
-0.06991106271743774,
0.2886800169944763,
-0.47875475883483887,
0.20180390775203705,
0.5954996347427368,
-0.19916783273220062,
0.6238856911659241,
-0.12499309331178665,
-0.012952825985848904,
0.33522436022758484,
0.1447170078754425,
-0.2455497682094574,
0.08535955846309662,
-0.36560821533203125,
0.05097122862935066,
0.455620139837265,
-0.6890058517456055,
-0.6040798425674438,
0.5993672609329224,
-0.7188675999641418,
-0.9663140773773193,
-0.2581711411476135,
-0.37785494327545166,
-0.2001875787973404,
-0.07471882551908493,
0.40832680463790894,
0.06417752057313919,
-0.34888792037963867,
-0.04207153990864754,
0.21658825874328613,
-0.24612677097320557,
0.15381819009780884,
-0.2280614972114563,
-0.7173646092414856,
-0.4642651081085205,
0.4768785238265991,
-0.16344189643859863,
0.746584951877594,
-0.6685675978660583,
0.14615952968597412,
-0.4329085648059845,
-0.10144412517547607,
-0.5141375660896301,
0.2959810197353363,
-0.649669349193573,
0.1378885954618454,
-0.48682722449302673,
-0.1409032642841339,
-0.3225175440311432,
-0.18331696093082428,
-0.6005657315254211,
-0.7143324613571167,
-0.18689791858196259,
-0.21921633183956146,
0.2742272913455963,
0.8196761608123779,
-0.2201922982931137,
0.061019252985715866,
-0.6843185424804688,
0.43831613659858704,
0.7811046242713928,
0.3287873864173889,
-0.41004177927970886,
-0.41572123765945435,
0.28147459030151367,
0.18060211837291718,
-0.2044835388660431,
-0.8295074105262756,
0.3983374536037445,
0.39038461446762085,
0.5437195897102356,
-0.10253641754388809,
0.08013571053743362,
0.570008397102356,
-0.5300105214118958,
1.0774548053741455,
0.22590585052967072,
-1.2931416034698486,
0.20993904769420624,
-0.2575474977493286,
-0.2938993573188782,
0.946979820728302,
0.6875911951065063,
-0.7432371377944946,
-0.7141426205635071,
-1.030693531036377,
-0.7668149471282959,
0.38051068782806396,
0.5812769532203674,
0.656416118144989,
0.12797468900680542,
0.529089629650116,
0.48139816522598267,
0.6787064671516418,
-0.7081696391105652,
-0.25645679235458374,
-0.5951792597770691,
0.05417490750551224,
0.12559941411018372,
-0.002259176690131426,
-0.5059474110603333,
-0.38911232352256775,
0.4212043881416321,
0.25911611318588257,
0.5462789535522461,
0.43028736114501953,
0.2153010070323944,
-0.3980448246002197,
0.33070260286331177,
0.5476006865501404,
0.5711132287979126,
-0.3558037579059601,
0.20068258047103882,
-0.031028233468532562,
-0.47916656732559204,
0.3821668028831482,
-0.4082218408584595,
0.016131436452269554,
0.3005177676677704,
0.15716522932052612,
0.6394912004470825,
-0.35084792971611023,
-0.7859489917755127,
0.6955781579017639,
-0.184699147939682,
-0.08881088346242905,
-0.052134834229946136,
0.2570737302303314,
-0.021369434893131256,
0.34413760900497437,
0.32355478405952454,
0.40045595169067383,
0.5477831959724426,
-0.9703869819641113,
0.4781188368797302,
0.2840629816055298,
-0.45690882205963135,
-0.24335694313049316,
0.9493705034255981,
0.3919926583766937,
-0.6758129596710205,
0.5201873183250427,
0.05632403865456581,
-0.56175696849823,
0.4514947235584259,
0.3727100193500519,
0.9848808646202087,
-0.38446125388145447,
0.08091387897729874,
0.10253840684890747,
0.16505956649780273,
-0.15097355842590332,
0.42163583636283875,
0.3555862605571747,
-0.3238413333892822,
-0.1455601155757904,
-0.4009738564491272,
-0.47034090757369995,
0.0010069870622828603,
-0.6470991969108582,
0.2571786940097809,
-0.5197628736495972,
-0.3641260266304016,
-0.29442358016967773,
-0.41933342814445496,
-0.38839784264564514,
0.3052311837673187,
0.5935927629470825,
0.7844672203063965,
-1.1598515510559082,
0.4318719506263733,
0.1899198442697525,
0.14617547392845154,
-0.5097577571868896,
0.16491758823394775,
0.02782301791012287,
-0.10839499533176422,
0.5592663288116455,
0.4425802230834961,
-0.3202063739299774,
-0.20236918330192566,
-0.8208536505699158,
-0.5266523361206055,
0.7937561273574829,
0.6790173053741455,
-0.537055253982544,
-0.007744592614471912,
0.1563546359539032,
0.513855516910553,
-0.5347647666931152,
0.05802543833851814,
0.4362696707248688,
0.36578401923179626,
0.11784161627292633,
-1.3110777139663696,
-0.04216644912958145,
-0.4389473795890808,
-0.024952512234449387,
-0.16639098525047302,
-0.36477696895599365,
1.1107131242752075,
-0.13115592300891876,
-0.639493465423584,
0.14476509392261505,
0.28027641773223877,
0.18212556838989258,
0.620181679725647,
0.7675168514251709,
0.1459117829799652,
0.9470247626304626,
0.28720492124557495,
1.1639955043792725,
0.4584992229938507,
0.4026307761669159,
0.7900843024253845,
-0.5092592835426331,
0.5577870011329651,
0.609890341758728,
-0.12979374825954437,
0.1847604513168335,
0.3999529480934143,
0.03966643288731575,
0.6336945295333862,
0.7967717051506042,
-0.312282532453537,
-0.3583214581012726,
-0.2347036898136139,
-0.38614895939826965,
0.4382933974266052,
0.20077098906040192,
-0.4913288652896881,
0.08354967087507248,
0.014333385042846203,
-0.17643769085407257,
0.2672812342643738,
0.10694973915815353,
0.24369870126247406,
0.37462836503982544,
-0.31012222170829773,
0.6371150612831116,
-0.42255038022994995,
0.49579551815986633,
0.06856609880924225,
-0.09292998164892197,
-0.15950962901115417,
-0.3512011468410492,
-0.2958088517189026,
-0.4780379831790924,
0.5370709896087646,
-0.1524324119091034,
-0.16626328229904175,
-0.38210147619247437,
0.298602432012558,
-0.509641170501709,
-0.20755088329315186,
0.4094560742378235,
0.5690106749534607,
0.3962952494621277,
0.19815689325332642,
-0.6060628890991211,
0.11723408848047256,
-0.043839313089847565,
0.01533840037882328,
0.08923085033893585,
-0.024458076804876328,
0.1440235823392868,
0.6719797849655151,
0.7564914226531982,
0.4458826184272766,
0.43555542826652527,
-0.2054012417793274,
0.6576617360115051,
-0.8047987818717957,
-0.2794392704963684,
-0.6699978113174438,
0.6499216556549072,
-0.18982236087322235,
-0.43652188777923584,
0.3992930054664612,
0.48687508702278137,
0.7541036605834961,
-0.1310759335756302,
0.6640622615814209,
0.043781161308288574,
0.5111758708953857,
-0.32125237584114075,
1.0297850370407104,
-0.7043666839599609,
0.12565308809280396,
-0.2805737257003784,
-1.1264740228652954,
-0.3813376724720001,
0.5558593273162842,
0.016212869435548782,
0.19990018010139465,
0.6292087435722351,
0.8638055324554443,
-0.20140323042869568,
0.5428209900856018,
0.5108007788658142,
-0.022326329723000526,
0.2663114666938782,
0.14560794830322266,
1.2800118923187256,
-0.5987025499343872,
0.14325575530529022,
0.03578374534845352,
0.19658558070659637,
0.04188979044556618,
-0.8947672247886658,
-0.7210937738418579,
-0.7568204402923584,
-0.34651827812194824,
-0.44738104939460754,
-0.034404247999191284,
1.1797469854354858,
1.0849535465240479,
-0.6420909762382507,
-0.32621464133262634,
0.17954954504966736,
0.020763380452990532,
-0.1554722785949707,
-0.1497851014137268,
-0.09252588450908661,
-0.08715955913066864,
-1.1018661260604858,
0.4803066551685333,
0.03908132389187813,
0.008464159443974495,
-0.26299014687538147,
0.025038953870534897,
-0.15284276008605957,
0.4491129219532013,
0.26235851645469666,
0.32958996295928955,
-0.8711627125740051,
-0.5323138236999512,
-0.1646837741136551,
-0.23288530111312866,
-0.03952173888683319,
1.0269207954406738,
-0.5870544910430908,
0.39245399832725525,
0.49461400508880615,
0.45907729864120483,
0.33469247817993164,
0.04402434080839157,
1.059970736503601,
-0.5993483066558838,
0.11222171038389206,
0.6011888980865479,
0.19076092541217804,
0.39865386486053467,
-0.3994649052619934,
0.341971218585968,
0.389411985874176,
-0.5789440870285034,
-1.0850939750671387,
0.31113961338996887,
-1.053061842918396,
-0.10845644772052765,
1.082072377204895,
-0.19866876304149628,
-0.21641522645950317,
-0.3271860182285309,
-0.3917136490345001,
0.21128571033477783,
-0.18928639590740204,
0.9922589063644409,
0.31762948632240295,
-0.22645340859889984,
0.0027034031227231026,
-0.7075748443603516,
0.8792514801025391,
0.3262953758239746,
-0.4810429811477661,
-0.01009879820048809,
0.47806891798973083,
0.5159502029418945,
0.2111978977918625,
0.41144636273384094,
-0.24332137405872345,
0.4634776711463928,
-0.16138921678066254,
-0.037099920213222504,
0.19672757387161255,
-0.3553553521633148,
-0.35540688037872314,
0.053770262748003006,
0.026474637910723686,
-0.07857364416122437
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.07502v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.07502v1
|
Image Textualization: An Automatic Framework for Creating Accurate and Detailed Image Descriptions
| 2024-06-11T17:37:45 | 2024-06-11T17:37:45 |
Renjie Pi, Jianshu Zhang, Jipeng Zhang, Rui Pan, Zhekai Chen, Tong Zhang
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
Image description datasets play a crucial role in the advancement of various
applications such as image understanding, text-to-image generation, and
text-image retrieval. Currently, image description datasets primarily originate
from two sources. One source is the scraping of image-text pairs from the web.
Despite their abundance, these descriptions are often of low quality and noisy.
Another is through human labeling. Datasets such as COCO are generally very
short and lack details. Although detailed image descriptions can be annotated
by humans, the high annotation cost limits the feasibility. These limitations
underscore the need for more efficient and scalable methods to generate
accurate and detailed image descriptions. In this paper, we propose an
innovative framework termed Image Textualization (IT), which automatically
produces high-quality image descriptions by leveraging existing multi-modal
large language models (MLLMs) and multiple vision expert models in a
collaborative manner, which maximally convert the visual information into text.
To address the current lack of benchmarks for detailed descriptions, we propose
several benchmarks for comprehensive evaluation, which verifies the quality of
image descriptions created by our framework. Furthermore, we show that
LLaVA-7B, benefiting from training on IT-curated descriptions, acquire improved
capability to generate richer image descriptions, substantially increasing the
length and detail of their output with less hallucination.
|
[
-0.3773680627346039,
-0.5531664490699768,
0.42713719606399536,
0.3095036447048187,
-0.6549370884895325,
-0.10835718363523483,
-0.3897126615047455,
-0.8650506734848022,
0.14382904767990112,
0.6366404294967651,
-0.15494999289512634,
-0.6614423990249634,
-0.4733128547668457,
0.40641915798187256,
-0.6720596551895142,
0.9210349321365356,
-0.23636889457702637,
-0.021633731201291084,
-0.3877564072608948,
0.11850681900978088,
-0.4202529788017273,
-0.1418611854314804,
-0.43053147196769714,
0.15998584032058716,
0.580597460269928,
0.22060313820838928,
0.8373998403549194,
1.1897214651107788,
0.992361307144165,
0.30187034606933594,
0.20433469116687775,
0.3234015107154846,
-0.35973498225212097,
0.13906295597553253,
0.10074007511138916,
-0.16576971113681793,
-0.24207963049411774,
-0.16509509086608887,
0.4951949715614319,
0.3497869074344635,
0.3056689500808716,
0.1362563818693161,
-0.05341274291276932,
0.5318670272827148,
-0.6637468338012695,
0.41189488768577576,
-0.6283045411109924,
0.17761720716953278,
-0.2073753923177719,
-0.46454867720603943,
-0.3326588571071625,
-0.2513202428817749,
0.16845880448818207,
-0.9511082768440247,
0.3159020245075226,
0.2083154320716858,
1.1513292789459229,
0.49565571546554565,
-0.13662205636501312,
-0.37423625588417053,
-0.5809114575386047,
0.74604332447052,
-0.5597935318946838,
0.023820307105779648,
0.5859293341636658,
0.521213710308075,
0.19177000224590302,
-0.8006325364112854,
-0.3965495526790619,
-0.19481050968170166,
-0.434653103351593,
0.10538624972105026,
0.05735369026660919,
0.05183935910463333,
-0.05260573327541351,
0.5853936076164246,
-0.18015596270561218,
-0.09568924456834793,
-0.625312089920044,
-0.29164019227027893,
0.7331613302230835,
0.31407690048217773,
0.31407690048217773,
-0.18159763514995575,
-0.4985312819480896,
-0.04566798731684685,
-0.42760801315307617,
-0.08793491125106812,
0.0297554824501276,
-0.1535688191652298,
0.10893449187278748,
0.7918993234634399,
-0.34839263558387756,
0.7202922701835632,
-0.21709272265434265,
-0.2216431200504303,
0.0009225768153555691,
-0.5033039450645447,
-0.07018846273422241,
0.1455632746219635,
0.9522871971130371,
0.8982614874839783,
0.21229110658168793,
-0.44960495829582214,
-0.3471016585826874,
0.16832216084003448,
0.2559795379638672,
-0.9544520974159241,
-0.030683165416121483,
0.09682821482419968,
-0.6852430105209351,
-0.770070493221283,
0.14145828783512115,
-0.8415021896362305,
-0.49373775720596313,
-0.31437110900878906,
-0.06606601923704147,
-0.34442922472953796,
0.23740631341934204,
0.0072427247650921345,
-0.030736684799194336,
0.3131158649921417,
0.3437020182609558,
-0.6132875084877014,
0.27646684646606445,
0.24444453418254852,
0.6441479325294495,
-0.2201729565858841,
-0.2824714481830597,
-0.3577083945274353,
0.500582754611969,
-0.5397914052009583,
0.9222931861877441,
-0.5906628370285034,
-0.09998846054077148,
-0.019516637548804283,
-0.14062343537807465,
0.3309204578399658,
-0.3313595652580261,
0.5224531292915344,
-0.3097071647644043,
0.15466856956481934,
-0.011261423118412495,
-0.28660428524017334,
-0.15318287909030914,
0.3201019763946533,
-0.7636781930923462,
0.9383952021598816,
-0.32311534881591797,
-0.9654199481010437,
0.2733646333217621,
-0.6247226595878601,
-0.576399028301239,
0.2946745753288269,
-0.3865412771701813,
-0.3644522726535797,
0.24884581565856934,
0.6314370632171631,
0.6443120837211609,
-0.6534115672111511,
0.43090158700942993,
0.04067986086010933,
-0.616318941116333,
0.5369543433189392,
-0.2328958511352539,
0.19401192665100098,
0.22389256954193115,
-0.48177480697631836,
0.168897345662117,
-0.8185027837753296,
0.17889009416103363,
0.2814793884754181,
-0.20614822208881378,
-0.09791062027215958,
-0.1345013827085495,
0.5012003779411316,
-0.0706976130604744,
0.5188106298446655,
-0.3050699830055237,
0.10618147999048233,
-0.297917902469635,
0.31283634901046753,
0.6289135217666626,
-0.18352992832660675,
0.47886183857917786,
-0.10174084454774857,
0.41725650429725647,
-0.20335794985294342,
0.36668670177459717,
-0.8686835765838623,
-0.27018702030181885,
-0.7974425554275513,
-0.4482443928718567,
0.3028421700000763,
0.5862419605255127,
-0.8271480202674866,
0.4887959659099579,
-0.5180596113204956,
-0.3174990713596344,
-0.43659183382987976,
0.2759334444999695,
0.660890519618988,
0.4882080554962158,
0.47532588243484497,
-0.5199591517448425,
-0.30655255913734436,
-1.268724799156189,
-0.036938171833753586,
0.058387383818626404,
-0.10227471590042114,
0.30239352583885193,
0.343973308801651,
-0.30238792300224304,
0.8399686217308044,
-0.4956878423690796,
-0.7755177617073059,
0.01954055204987526,
0.10728143155574799,
-0.09276029467582703,
0.15643583238124847,
0.48079532384872437,
-0.8564192056655884,
-0.3707331717014313,
0.23432573676109314,
-0.9276240468025208,
-0.04933725297451019,
-0.33019572496414185,
-0.22651971876621246,
0.09808523952960968,
0.12248263508081436,
-0.420804500579834,
0.7436638474464417,
0.2450678050518036,
0.0019763449672609568,
0.5275903344154358,
-0.22226795554161072,
0.40135297179222107,
-1.0679925680160522,
0.1653108149766922,
0.14893652498722076,
-0.11167822778224945,
-0.1803753823041916,
0.2695077657699585,
-0.039460957050323486,
0.03767284005880356,
-0.2571481764316559,
0.462017685174942,
-0.666425347328186,
-0.1738957166671753,
-0.21791920065879822,
0.14029771089553833,
0.2882632911205292,
0.43799373507499695,
0.28416046500205994,
0.469341903924942,
0.8165750503540039,
-0.3044387102127075,
0.7134565114974976,
0.35931700468063354,
-0.2276390939950943,
0.7869311571121216,
-0.7762736082077026,
0.052219003438949585,
-0.10385048389434814,
0.43916046619415283,
-0.9040700793266296,
-0.7339329123497009,
0.14888478815555573,
-0.22395434975624084,
0.11680758744478226,
-0.07531461119651794,
-0.750276505947113,
-0.3600706458091736,
-0.3667900860309601,
0.4225706458091736,
0.29380643367767334,
-0.34441468119621277,
0.5786016583442688,
0.044465649873018265,
-0.06686734408140182,
-0.7065322399139404,
-0.8788648247718811,
0.808035135269165,
-0.1565423458814621,
-0.7292766571044922,
0.435715913772583,
0.005529898218810558,
0.01643785834312439,
0.03016739897429943,
0.12191379070281982,
-0.5339122414588928,
-0.13868142664432526,
0.20552882552146912,
0.42596301436424255,
0.05914248153567314,
0.36884042620658875,
0.18058505654335022,
-0.06239396706223488,
-0.19382067024707794,
-0.2829739451408386,
0.18326717615127563,
-0.17398031055927277,
-0.044492535293102264,
-0.714780867099762,
0.3117395341396332,
0.31579917669296265,
-0.4568275809288025,
0.29726070165634155,
0.9805794954299927,
-0.43755051493644714,
0.2899262011051178,
-0.6081467270851135,
0.0004020156047772616,
-0.45957931876182556,
0.40310072898864746,
-0.5252915024757385,
-0.42987874150276184,
0.2230105847120285,
-0.00548967532813549,
0.07959658652544022,
0.41205206513404846,
0.13087785243988037,
-0.38143518567085266,
0.8194275498390198,
0.3949193060398102,
0.26088663935661316,
0.24063389003276825,
-0.18898403644561768,
0.04457739740610123,
-0.6209642291069031,
-0.2372753620147705,
-0.23972712457180023,
-0.23549294471740723,
-0.2598496675491333,
-0.5482977032661438,
0.2988213300704956,
-0.01000953558832407,
0.07631399482488632,
0.2787488102912903,
-1.039829134941101,
0.8186366558074951,
0.29284244775772095,
0.273899644613266,
0.296991765499115,
0.48024919629096985,
0.10278318077325821,
-0.1541910469532013,
-0.2625278830528259,
-0.9013883471488953,
1.0399166345596313,
0.1789066642522812,
0.8512740135192871,
-0.24667340517044067,
0.6611271500587463,
0.4178207814693451,
0.20811384916305542,
-0.6788725256919861,
0.6272117495536804,
-0.4153420925140381,
-0.20483343303203583,
-0.17712745070457458,
-0.19364646077156067,
-0.9207506775856018,
-0.044144075363874435,
-0.5135786533355713,
-0.3381202220916748,
-0.03809560462832451,
0.28201740980148315,
0.025370629504323006,
0.09517397731542587,
-0.3811531364917755,
0.6283543705940247,
-0.6194024085998535,
-0.4900338351726532,
0.020069923251867294,
-0.8709801435470581,
0.24033531546592712,
-0.09341157972812653,
0.39935827255249023,
0.06501711905002594,
-0.3980001211166382,
0.4793242812156677,
-0.17167344689369202,
0.9769158363342285,
0.05981575325131416,
-0.1310836523771286,
0.25231829285621643,
0.05101393535733223,
0.3454013466835022,
-0.13435931503772736,
0.19083665311336517,
0.11690957099199295,
-0.03677385672926903,
-0.5287912487983704,
-0.36140379309654236,
0.4957182705402374,
-0.6357284188270569,
-0.16786570847034454,
0.16407854855060577,
-0.4986976385116577,
0.11788228899240494,
0.3131871819496155,
0.5076245665550232,
0.6900339126586914,
-0.2105926126241684,
0.17770586907863617,
0.6659908294677734,
-0.6431384682655334,
0.3648049831390381,
-0.35832902789115906,
-0.24567706882953644,
-0.8905383944511414,
0.7918305397033691,
-0.2960367202758789,
-0.12386878579854965,
0.6509926319122314,
0.1571912318468094,
-0.2695082128047943,
-0.5004820227622986,
-0.774695634841919,
0.04298989102244377,
-1.0122559070587158,
-0.5223912000656128,
-0.6927529573440552,
0.18576005101203918,
-0.25284478068351746,
-0.5297592878341675,
-0.2972396910190582,
-0.5291940569877625,
-0.23024901747703552,
0.001155792037025094,
0.3247709572315216,
1.0732297897338867,
0.482547402381897,
0.4051835834980011,
-0.6859480142593384,
0.4962041676044464,
0.16325904428958893,
0.37565651535987854,
-0.09648974984884262,
-0.2015574723482132,
-0.39359697699546814,
0.04329551383852959,
-0.2909039556980133,
-0.7375204563140869,
0.40005025267601013,
0.30527105927467346,
0.4036513864994049,
0.3087010085582733,
0.014105577953159809,
0.7874290347099304,
-0.30742278695106506,
0.8028891682624817,
0.5489015579223633,
-0.8859583139419556,
0.6774641275405884,
-0.3413092792034149,
0.23803333938121796,
0.30320653319358826,
-0.10943154990673065,
-0.10761447995901108,
-0.5472437143325806,
-0.32297372817993164,
-1.1671841144561768,
0.283033549785614,
0.47263917326927185,
0.3318138122558594,
0.17132212221622467,
0.4094914495944977,
0.26021844148635864,
0.21245235204696655,
-0.8515788912773132,
-0.0028044404461979866,
-0.5419366955757141,
-0.7059639096260071,
0.044334590435028076,
-0.30784842371940613,
-0.39900943636894226,
-0.017518701031804085,
0.44444698095321655,
-0.3763730823993683,
0.35728347301483154,
0.29844632744789124,
-0.5468018651008606,
0.08017301559448242,
0.29708757996559143,
0.4897480607032776,
0.6035025119781494,
0.2558818757534027,
0.2681609094142914,
-0.0012719325022771955,
-0.22286514937877655,
-0.0025895447470247746,
0.09186140447854996,
-0.0538485050201416,
0.045881692320108414,
0.6298115849494934,
0.8646110892295837,
0.14917275309562683,
-0.6514259576797485,
0.660967230796814,
-0.20440524816513062,
-0.0827309638261795,
-0.23272596299648285,
-0.23630523681640625,
-0.018927516415715218,
-0.1384252905845642,
0.5571622848510742,
0.127166286110878,
0.47091931104660034,
-0.1993602216243744,
0.04967951774597168,
0.1416333168745041,
-0.35158249735832214,
-0.07934495806694031,
0.6273587942123413,
0.2536681592464447,
0.08988218009471893,
0.5426996350288391,
0.0416288748383522,
-0.29466140270233154,
0.710656464099884,
0.2056833952665329,
0.7605787515640259,
0.38100534677505493,
0.31088098883628845,
0.30475470423698425,
0.3488728106021881,
-0.03286689519882202,
-0.14640726149082184,
-0.21986085176467896,
-0.283326119184494,
-0.40548911690711975,
-0.5675038695335388,
-0.12884117662906647,
-0.40898680686950684,
-0.6593217849731445,
0.308164119720459,
-0.4715498387813568,
-0.19402793049812317,
0.07903315871953964,
-0.374112993478775,
-0.8094425797462463,
0.49595019221305847,
0.29517242312431335,
0.5721420049667358,
-0.5906969904899597,
0.46821892261505127,
0.8749455809593201,
-0.6955105066299438,
-0.5116554498672485,
-0.15575994551181793,
-0.4883021414279938,
-0.5763784050941467,
0.6976965665817261,
0.5247370004653931,
-0.07801210135221481,
-0.2835333049297333,
-0.9336605668067932,
-0.5164194107055664,
1.3397321701049805,
0.40908005833625793,
-0.48658618330955505,
0.13248343765735626,
0.21282915771007538,
0.805476188659668,
-0.6969162225723267,
0.2620753347873688,
0.09772146493196487,
0.6577914357185364,
0.4015437066555023,
-0.838385820388794,
0.15234418213367462,
-0.39474114775657654,
0.41626790165901184,
-0.26965340971946716,
-0.3297472894191742,
0.39686256647109985,
-0.5091491937637329,
-0.16998177766799927,
0.5292388200759888,
0.4833289086818695,
-0.04175578057765961,
0.24923157691955566,
0.34718090295791626,
0.13446764647960663,
0.5242535471916199,
-0.20130014419555664,
1.2018924951553345,
-0.30668729543685913,
0.09876902401447296,
1.2122267484664917,
0.06573328375816345,
0.5910456776618958,
0.40201038122177124,
0.09261971712112427,
0.26464831829071045,
0.8296278119087219,
-0.28620046377182007,
0.3447026312351227,
0.18044058978557587,
0.01405273750424385,
-0.32668042182922363,
-0.2479691356420517,
-0.13029144704341888,
0.3702932894229889,
0.1619475781917572,
-0.985582172870636,
-0.046682894229888916,
0.10847651958465576,
-0.30160197615623474,
0.29851627349853516,
-0.2958090007305145,
0.9762649536132812,
-0.19962774217128754,
-0.30923590064048767,
0.6232986450195312,
-0.04210149124264717,
0.6271231770515442,
-0.14783185720443726,
-0.1033855676651001,
-0.03853556141257286,
-0.0792967900633812,
-0.5078803896903992,
-0.8579828143119812,
0.24406923353672028,
0.15803761780261993,
-0.10867054760456085,
-0.2158818393945694,
0.8566908836364746,
-0.533645510673523,
-0.6778035759925842,
0.03912539407610893,
0.0511578693985939,
0.44327354431152344,
0.08369136601686478,
-0.6461697220802307,
0.20350512862205505,
-0.09909601509571075,
-0.028193099424242973,
-0.13854891061782837,
0.361031174659729,
-0.3158574104309082,
0.5534464716911316,
0.36868706345558167,
-0.05568554624915123,
0.25368788838386536,
0.004285040777176619,
0.8064237833023071,
-0.5411581993103027,
-0.40753477811813354,
-0.5813860893249512,
0.5482614040374756,
-0.3984052836894989,
0.07674212008714676,
0.2543492913246155,
0.6435828804969788,
0.5885874032974243,
-0.3682529330253601,
1.0692355632781982,
-0.17146769165992737,
-0.2571207284927368,
-0.4071376919746399,
0.4713991582393646,
-0.4363226890563965,
0.2407943159341812,
-0.28394457697868347,
-1.1691102981567383,
-0.5384959578514099,
0.6803770065307617,
-0.002603421453386545,
-0.14096270501613617,
0.7622613906860352,
0.5168857574462891,
-0.04163384065032005,
-0.11058039218187332,
0.36862727999687195,
0.1334911286830902,
0.24540643393993378,
0.16805621981620789,
0.84405517578125,
-0.5982404351234436,
1.0101271867752075,
-0.5372046828269958,
-0.13785815238952637,
0.1170034185051918,
-0.9218286871910095,
-0.9025458097457886,
-0.6714473962783813,
-0.52728670835495,
-0.13527731597423553,
0.04245013743638992,
0.5078403353691101,
0.6325622797012329,
-0.4406820833683014,
-0.1564943790435791,
0.09593993425369263,
-0.22224467992782593,
-0.13252300024032593,
-0.2240622490644455,
0.5182949900627136,
-0.4123503565788269,
-0.6803401112556458,
-0.21859613060951233,
0.5635824799537659,
0.15655513107776642,
-0.317658394575119,
-0.03247066214680672,
0.2841148376464844,
0.02118624560534954,
0.516693115234375,
-0.3130910396575928,
-0.860230565071106,
0.007875079289078712,
-0.1320575773715973,
-0.279748797416687,
0.16425807774066925,
0.6622217297554016,
-0.42964842915534973,
0.6591916680335999,
0.11150695383548737,
0.6606924533843994,
0.43923693895339966,
-0.07777945697307587,
0.5392583012580872,
-0.7107051014900208,
0.06087678298354149,
-0.07232101261615753,
0.2897627651691437,
0.8593169450759888,
-0.615186870098114,
0.7438949942588806,
-0.027272118255496025,
-0.3044610619544983,
-0.6395977735519409,
0.10901068150997162,
-1.2767815589904785,
-0.07131504267454147,
1.1757779121398926,
-0.4732116460800171,
-0.42288562655448914,
0.15611065924167633,
-0.6850388646125793,
0.0875985249876976,
-0.2818780541419983,
0.7951455116271973,
0.4807965159416199,
0.2174815684556961,
-0.2654133141040802,
-0.11324644088745117,
0.17745426297187805,
-0.14396405220031738,
-0.9251134991645813,
0.059306800365448,
0.8656908869743347,
0.22037269175052643,
0.20705941319465637,
0.49241024255752563,
-0.2604707181453705,
0.3281753659248352,
-0.32647499442100525,
0.49597597122192383,
-0.10957369953393936,
-0.1738414317369461,
0.14512097835540771,
0.08554370701313019,
-0.03262634575366974,
-0.2261996865272522
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.07496v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.07496v1
|
TextGrad: Automatic "Differentiation" via Text
| 2024-06-11T17:32:21 | 2024-06-11T17:32:21 |
Mert Yuksekgonul, Federico Bianchi, Joseph Boen, Sheng Liu, Zhi Huang, Carlos Guestrin, James Zou
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
AI is undergoing a paradigm shift, with breakthroughs achieved by systems
orchestrating multiple large language models (LLMs) and other complex
components. As a result, developing principled and automated optimization
methods for compound AI systems is one of the most important new challenges.
Neural networks faced a similar challenge in its early days until
backpropagation and automatic differentiation transformed the field by making
optimization turn-key. Inspired by this, we introduce TextGrad, a powerful
framework performing automatic ``differentiation'' via text. TextGrad
backpropagates textual feedback provided by LLMs to improve individual
components of a compound AI system. In our framework, LLMs provide rich,
general, natural language suggestions to optimize variables in computation
graphs, ranging from code snippets to molecular structures. TextGrad follows
PyTorch's syntax and abstraction and is flexible and easy-to-use. It works
out-of-the-box for a variety of tasks, where the users only provide the
objective function without tuning components or prompts of the framework. We
showcase TextGrad's effectiveness and generality across a diverse range of
applications, from question answering and molecule optimization to radiotherapy
treatment planning. Without modifying the framework, TextGrad improves the
zero-shot accuracy of GPT-4o in Google-Proof Question Answering from $51\%$ to
$55\%$, yields $20\%$ relative performance gain in optimizing LeetCode-Hard
coding problem solutions, improves prompts for reasoning, designs new druglike
small molecules with desirable in silico binding, and designs radiation
oncology treatment plans with high specificity. TextGrad lays a foundation to
accelerate the development of the next-generation of AI systems.
|
[
-0.018839875236153603,
-0.947126567363739,
0.5200218558311462,
0.4173086881637573,
0.13850653171539307,
0.33515071868896484,
-0.3971145451068878,
-0.00789674837142229,
-0.2077324092388153,
0.17139773070812225,
-0.4829176068305969,
-0.6713473200798035,
-0.41222649812698364,
0.4630433917045593,
-0.4441760778427124,
1.1934233903884888,
-0.27109628915786743,
0.18861418962478638,
-0.5025710463523865,
-0.06827184557914734,
0.017088111490011215,
-0.1546880006790161,
-0.8415940403938293,
-0.6614689826965332,
0.7149650454521179,
0.2578161656856537,
0.280678391456604,
0.7174423336982727,
0.8215335607528687,
0.38173961639404297,
-0.006163160782307386,
0.08063691109418869,
-0.2042441964149475,
0.15657475590705872,
0.08035346120595932,
-0.2525710463523865,
-0.28037193417549133,
-0.05903219059109688,
0.32378366589546204,
0.5086349844932556,
0.090766042470932,
-0.11676813662052155,
-0.10527853667736053,
0.9571493268013,
-0.6538591980934143,
0.122745081782341,
-0.4692639410495758,
0.14307890832424164,
0.18137390911579132,
-0.14587390422821045,
-0.2940768003463745,
-0.5243203639984131,
0.4756008982658386,
-0.8316065669059753,
0.1817755252122879,
-0.30934256315231323,
0.8147128820419312,
0.41225895285606384,
-0.03644290566444397,
-0.3249475955963135,
-0.47224554419517517,
0.697402834892273,
-0.3440840244293213,
0.003643554635345936,
-0.03068539686501026,
0.19935913383960724,
0.11693097651004791,
-0.9843567609786987,
-0.18394984304904938,
-0.542927622795105,
-0.059797387570142746,
0.12002509087324142,
-0.20590506494045258,
0.39466211199760437,
0.1352439969778061,
0.5496963262557983,
-0.4774424433708191,
-0.13761627674102783,
-0.3134153187274933,
-0.2225528508424759,
0.46753403544425964,
-0.0017118153627961874,
0.7112638354301453,
-0.14895768463611603,
-0.04149321839213371,
-0.23715169727802277,
-0.5856909155845642,
-0.23414507508277893,
0.3197726607322693,
0.309562087059021,
-0.1310652792453766,
0.36987990140914917,
-0.2966320216655731,
0.40087074041366577,
-0.009549428708851337,
0.19254137575626373,
0.4830404222011566,
-0.31782758235931396,
-0.2811233103275299,
0.0393330343067646,
0.9053366184234619,
0.1783408373594284,
0.24080264568328857,
-0.15337876975536346,
-0.20505394041538239,
-0.033024001866579056,
0.22547674179077148,
-1.0176130533218384,
-0.7089278697967529,
0.2671408951282501,
-0.41028884053230286,
-0.6816893815994263,
-0.3112134635448456,
-0.9949527978897095,
-0.23558346927165985,
-0.2964009642601013,
0.8372815847396851,
-0.3870406150817871,
-0.009808208793401718,
-0.011610631830990314,
-0.42188209295272827,
-0.06632824242115021,
0.40850281715393066,
-0.6867673993110657,
0.4232063889503479,
0.40137848258018494,
1.087200403213501,
-0.5803095102310181,
-0.21059121191501617,
-0.53569495677948,
-0.11091997474431992,
-0.381001353263855,
0.9036609530448914,
-0.5319907665252686,
-0.45400282740592957,
0.007210843730717897,
-0.4013462960720062,
0.021332349628210068,
-0.6868010759353638,
0.5321964621543884,
-0.13702185451984406,
0.5362139344215393,
0.1660831868648529,
-0.2979705035686493,
-0.003650953993201256,
0.179933562874794,
-0.44844457507133484,
1.1842868328094482,
0.16848161816596985,
-0.55632084608078,
0.15137864649295807,
-1.2767688035964966,
-0.5365322828292847,
0.044373299926519394,
-0.21674185991287231,
-0.6166132092475891,
-0.0469820573925972,
0.4203239679336548,
0.14956551790237427,
-0.33087942004203796,
0.1480511873960495,
0.020775064826011658,
-0.2683488726615906,
-0.1721068173646927,
-0.4186767637729645,
0.6370949149131775,
0.0887928456068039,
-0.5207443833351135,
0.3394303321838379,
-0.7316067814826965,
0.11237098276615143,
-0.1868828982114792,
-0.723080575466156,
-0.28627949953079224,
0.024891840294003487,
0.043582215905189514,
-0.04930742830038071,
0.15657542645931244,
-0.40664684772491455,
0.3557479679584503,
-0.8692750930786133,
0.5866367220878601,
0.7166446447372437,
-0.10373474657535553,
0.7490246295928955,
-0.15211425721645355,
0.6104723215103149,
-0.11474958807229996,
0.000033182641345774755,
-0.2851020097732544,
-0.31260329484939575,
-0.8286241292953491,
-0.40226373076438904,
0.23054267466068268,
0.6779277920722961,
-0.7799346446990967,
0.25139158964157104,
-0.0755767896771431,
-0.24137961864471436,
-0.36346930265426636,
0.27921000123023987,
0.5045583248138428,
0.5616068243980408,
0.6578319668769836,
0.24880218505859375,
-0.3941579759120941,
-0.9112516045570374,
-0.5602301359176636,
-0.23098278045654297,
-0.09497791528701782,
0.2879440188407898,
0.46148648858070374,
-0.4069456458091736,
0.7098428010940552,
-0.6425010561943054,
-0.39271172881126404,
-0.179714173078537,
0.35123223066329956,
0.036003947257995605,
0.5095811486244202,
0.2971881031990051,
-0.9126245975494385,
-0.5019862055778503,
0.18763993680477142,
-0.578798234462738,
-0.5047340989112854,
-0.23095381259918213,
-0.3856622278690338,
0.016493655741214752,
0.7595380544662476,
-0.4365307092666626,
0.37279897928237915,
0.2721993625164032,
-0.00796601828187704,
0.47687527537345886,
-0.4198632538318634,
-0.10483423620462418,
-1.0064536333084106,
0.26920461654663086,
0.22252458333969116,
-0.17833900451660156,
-0.35533007979393005,
0.0934486985206604,
-0.2146981805562973,
-0.1529247760772705,
-0.33446982502937317,
0.8542162775993347,
-0.18336202204227448,
0.16450932621955872,
-0.20245687663555145,
0.013636395335197449,
0.10657457262277603,
0.287712037563324,
-0.13396915793418884,
1.0300140380859375,
0.5938224792480469,
-0.8475385904312134,
0.4870840013027191,
0.3495941460132599,
0.04514000192284584,
0.2711683511734009,
-0.8749931454658508,
0.06217927858233452,
-0.07052317261695862,
0.26526719331741333,
-0.8636491894721985,
-0.20290681719779968,
0.45575034618377686,
-0.5173946619033813,
-0.13022689521312714,
-0.09534817934036255,
-0.1616673767566681,
-0.32825958728790283,
-0.4537180960178375,
0.49135622382164,
0.4202949106693268,
-0.45313721895217896,
0.9648001194000244,
0.0172909926623106,
-0.2685123682022095,
-0.3947374224662781,
-0.8256182074546814,
0.1315312385559082,
0.013231740333139896,
-0.24595077335834503,
0.776300311088562,
-0.3886911869049072,
-0.46244552731513977,
-0.18909983336925507,
0.05489445477724075,
-0.19086487591266632,
0.0005352072766982019,
0.027307167649269104,
0.17335012555122375,
-0.3314181864261627,
0.38671791553497314,
0.5775262713432312,
-0.3511500954627991,
0.018622903153300285,
-0.6450045704841614,
0.40868234634399414,
-0.07368175685405731,
0.10078339278697968,
-0.5815214514732361,
0.299087792634964,
0.40330860018730164,
-0.10385284572839737,
0.09465440362691879,
0.4946865439414978,
-0.12025316804647446,
-0.31207889318466187,
-0.055628884583711624,
-0.21788033843040466,
-0.5713521838188171,
0.5384806394577026,
-0.2665439248085022,
-0.4009804129600525,
-0.05760089308023453,
-0.3300160765647888,
0.3247150778770447,
0.5653440952301025,
0.7068118453025818,
0.027648573741316795,
1.0783356428146362,
0.6321040987968445,
0.09693529456853867,
0.5849007964134216,
-0.20897455513477325,
-0.048347242176532745,
-0.4019336998462677,
-0.28527745604515076,
-0.6486706733703613,
-0.3622759282588959,
-0.5665075182914734,
-0.17321249842643738,
0.42390111088752747,
-0.19049686193466187,
-0.3704318404197693,
0.03322330117225647,
-0.7903975248336792,
0.7738215923309326,
0.48482468724250793,
0.15394431352615356,
0.3008856177330017,
0.40630680322647095,
-0.3507193922996521,
-0.0688178688287735,
-0.3809245824813843,
-0.4021884799003601,
1.147545576095581,
0.13932852447032928,
0.46309563517570496,
-0.22732923924922943,
0.8518694043159485,
0.6609553098678589,
0.5173556804656982,
-1.056852102279663,
0.5866101980209351,
-0.534794807434082,
-0.25712427496910095,
-0.0035270247608423233,
-0.8945826888084412,
-0.6593641042709351,
-0.07019439339637756,
-0.034999482333660126,
-0.4687848687171936,
-0.05651320517063141,
0.11916831880807877,
-0.25320717692375183,
0.009553768672049046,
-0.6810383200645447,
0.6919869780540466,
-0.09314872324466705,
-0.16035068035125732,
-0.18473762273788452,
-0.41064953804016113,
-0.22337986528873444,
-0.15731285512447357,
-0.00012383918510749936,
-0.032088056206703186,
-0.2796650230884552,
0.8408054113388062,
-0.2869129478931427,
0.4522084593772888,
-0.11707441508769989,
-0.3123130202293396,
0.02709752693772316,
0.26129281520843506,
0.028691137209534645,
0.1315760761499405,
-0.36798563599586487,
-0.2201039344072342,
-0.10960099846124649,
-0.21732039749622345,
-0.6786870956420898,
0.821416974067688,
-0.8258792161941528,
-0.3210725486278534,
-0.11401243507862091,
-0.367877334356308,
-0.06406297534704208,
0.5017057061195374,
0.3733028173446655,
0.6471295952796936,
-0.20176951587200165,
0.02848310023546219,
0.37812501192092896,
-0.47836747765541077,
0.764988124370575,
0.040892377495765686,
-0.3395322263240814,
-0.731228232383728,
1.1671209335327148,
-0.46725112199783325,
0.15205061435699463,
0.8357462882995605,
0.6263601779937744,
-0.37488090991973877,
-0.57704097032547,
-0.40506109595298767,
0.03893794119358063,
-0.8196861743927002,
-0.24023817479610443,
-0.720120370388031,
-0.08627593517303467,
-0.2370208501815796,
-0.1511884331703186,
-0.34699350595474243,
-0.529843807220459,
-0.3690146207809448,
-0.13604296743869781,
0.32420608401298523,
0.5929461121559143,
-0.041556887328624725,
0.21542274951934814,
-0.5734149813652039,
0.42655107378959656,
0.21743661165237427,
0.06587374210357666,
-0.44009536504745483,
-0.37682074308395386,
-0.04439208284020424,
0.016089672222733498,
-0.5496016144752502,
-0.43233224749565125,
0.2747325301170349,
0.6526331901550293,
0.2467152178287506,
0.239623561501503,
-0.051904357969760895,
0.3595820665359497,
-0.4630770683288574,
0.5975920557975769,
0.1402953714132309,
-1.149581789970398,
0.6695582270622253,
-0.4264444410800934,
0.25942757725715637,
0.73012375831604,
0.31569036841392517,
-0.37908273935317993,
-0.2872966527938843,
-0.3624858558177948,
-0.9538201093673706,
0.5464053750038147,
0.44876596331596375,
0.5197227001190186,
0.207709401845932,
0.6815532445907593,
0.11111079156398773,
0.3327811360359192,
-0.9413206577301025,
-0.37850961089134216,
-0.1278853565454483,
-0.7790060043334961,
0.18289397656917572,
0.3856850862503052,
-0.24389176070690155,
-0.5649389624595642,
0.6236852407455444,
-0.4744064509868622,
0.6393938660621643,
0.358854204416275,
-0.14818863570690155,
0.1832476407289505,
-0.06748859584331512,
0.5415099263191223,
0.5554906129837036,
0.13152332603931427,
-0.030285866931080818,
-0.05633130669593811,
-0.5941076874732971,
0.3194788694381714,
0.17779448628425598,
-0.4497515559196472,
0.08530905842781067,
0.2513120174407959,
0.5584927201271057,
-0.1630343645811081,
-0.7054160833358765,
0.5438752174377441,
-0.08152587711811066,
-0.5678054094314575,
0.039936017245054245,
0.18241114914417267,
-0.3568134009838104,
0.019685951992869377,
0.5666344165802002,
0.3818419873714447,
0.2803727388381958,
-0.263872891664505,
0.4265585243701935,
-0.0810939222574234,
-0.4552254378795624,
-0.029644634574651718,
0.47301405668258667,
0.49016815423965454,
-0.6152440309524536,
0.5268988609313965,
0.18407772481441498,
-0.5881735682487488,
0.7687801122665405,
0.291904091835022,
1.2660067081451416,
0.14751885831356049,
0.6888936161994934,
0.21462500095367432,
-0.14083798229694366,
-0.05049420893192291,
-0.059795379638671875,
-0.09251336008310318,
-0.4979825019836426,
-0.2203826755285263,
-0.5256334543228149,
-0.3181290924549103,
-0.04926559701561928,
-0.25944584608078003,
0.414146363735199,
-0.997089147567749,
-0.01827315054833889,
0.06815294176340103,
0.06994033604860306,
-0.10873828828334808,
0.4913099706172943,
0.013714607805013657,
0.7345105409622192,
-0.4408716559410095,
0.4231918156147003,
0.7807879447937012,
-0.4931916892528534,
-0.35250428318977356,
0.5507163405418396,
-0.14233869314193726,
-0.6119276881217957,
0.9777111411094666,
0.3722972273826599,
-0.3996427059173584,
0.25676229596138,
-0.5889535546302795,
-0.22875884175300598,
0.6869027614593506,
0.41425299644470215,
-0.21621964871883392,
-0.48538848757743835,
-0.04818789288401604,
0.6213246583938599,
-0.4064877927303314,
0.7051734328269958,
0.41829949617385864,
0.4995018541812897,
-0.0983530730009079,
-0.530471920967102,
-0.06042967364192009,
-0.33398911356925964,
-0.08057361841201782,
0.15902239084243774,
-0.4803670048713684,
0.7179139852523804,
-0.16297626495361328,
-0.031406693160533905,
0.2514975070953369,
0.47701701521873474,
-0.18474730849266052,
0.29964661598205566,
0.11800381541252136,
0.3341772258281708,
0.613561749458313,
-0.19239164888858795,
0.9237799644470215,
-0.3058187961578369,
0.2307942807674408,
0.5053413510322571,
0.167387917637825,
0.7721697092056274,
0.46696358919143677,
-0.18606901168823242,
0.8195539116859436,
0.5093538761138916,
-0.14423197507858276,
0.5493135452270508,
0.3647751212120056,
-0.449605792760849,
-0.07759353518486023,
0.18828651309013367,
-0.1313186138868332,
0.2799522876739502,
0.3176773190498352,
-0.5761983394622803,
-0.3055654764175415,
0.0949922725558281,
0.06518655270338058,
0.2714521288871765,
-0.3114796578884125,
0.9625329375267029,
0.06752587109804153,
-0.6382896304130554,
0.4708039462566376,
0.30958932638168335,
0.7891901135444641,
-0.5751283168792725,
-0.09879542142152786,
-0.4410119950771332,
0.4969339072704315,
-0.3185529410839081,
-0.39954081177711487,
0.2964470386505127,
-0.0870780497789383,
-0.11887925863265991,
-0.4071599543094635,
0.5053355693817139,
-0.2734944522380829,
-0.6782363057136536,
0.37037044763565063,
0.35452011227607727,
-0.06049467995762825,
-0.12045488506555557,
-1.194393515586853,
-0.026683000847697258,
0.06773632019758224,
-0.07896038144826889,
-0.062280524522066116,
0.2980283498764038,
0.33692798018455505,
0.8217049241065979,
0.6045491099357605,
0.14491091668605804,
-0.2520257532596588,
0.031163202598690987,
0.9589700102806091,
-0.507291853427887,
-0.3211796283721924,
-1.2262588739395142,
0.17054694890975952,
-0.22955375909805298,
-0.6182457208633423,
0.37783390283584595,
0.6184709072113037,
0.49518883228302,
0.2049911767244339,
0.8705938458442688,
0.18253356218338013,
0.3459572196006775,
-0.7503184080123901,
0.7822467684745789,
-0.8394383192062378,
0.26451393961906433,
-0.6613627076148987,
-0.8802593350410461,
-0.6588922142982483,
0.7057791352272034,
-0.4491277039051056,
0.25636208057403564,
0.9132310748100281,
0.8260643482208252,
0.08681023120880127,
-0.19964748620986938,
-0.09922434389591217,
0.024999229237437248,
0.6440261006355286,
0.3830121159553528,
0.6709177494049072,
-0.4816208481788635,
0.8932968378067017,
0.015028944239020348,
-0.16539378464221954,
-0.05889643728733063,
-0.6771431565284729,
-0.9495183825492859,
-0.36149662733078003,
-0.7239504456520081,
-0.32448822259902954,
0.35061731934547424,
1.170677900314331,
0.6833191514015198,
-0.6183688044548035,
-0.20619627833366394,
-0.8239702582359314,
-0.018847603350877762,
0.031041422858834267,
-0.3259457051753998,
0.3982599973678589,
-0.5786332488059998,
-0.9219996333122253,
0.457374632358551,
0.5258626937866211,
0.058603815734386444,
-0.24341750144958496,
-0.08379606157541275,
0.05705020949244499,
0.04458840191364288,
0.39524298906326294,
0.326602578163147,
-0.5245981812477112,
0.13844843208789825,
-0.07965905219316483,
-0.33041849732398987,
0.4750725030899048,
1.0561964511871338,
-0.8477200269699097,
0.31761932373046875,
0.703071653842926,
1.1162079572677612,
0.199384868144989,
0.04243163391947746,
1.019020438194275,
-0.6959995031356812,
0.08756148815155029,
0.5813053250312805,
-0.19361747801303864,
0.4805935025215149,
-0.3694289028644562,
0.09025205671787262,
0.48969078063964844,
-0.45912835001945496,
-0.5226913094520569,
0.07572140544652939,
-0.3983258903026581,
-0.5078915357589722,
1.2531638145446777,
-0.040573667734861374,
-0.3461938798427582,
-0.02208680659532547,
-0.5118423104286194,
0.01869998499751091,
-0.7711525559425354,
0.8794598579406738,
0.5510500073432922,
-0.16765309870243073,
-0.2777939438819885,
-0.12382032722234726,
0.944779098033905,
0.7703118324279785,
-1.253706693649292,
0.05616311356425285,
0.49982571601867676,
0.09775982052087784,
0.12359730154275894,
0.6096469163894653,
-0.1570514589548111,
0.2895352840423584,
-0.1537274718284607,
-0.16866600513458252,
0.0951351746916771,
-0.472901314496994,
-0.356964111328125,
0.061055853962898254,
-0.238040491938591,
-0.15904666483402252
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.07494v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.07494v2
|
CADS: A Systematic Literature Review on the Challenges of Abstractive Dialogue Summarization
| 2024-06-11T17:30:22 | 2024-06-12T10:47:09 |
Frederic Kirstein, Jan Philip Wahle, Bela Gipp, Terry Ruas
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Abstractive dialogue summarization is the task of distilling conversations
into informative and concise summaries. Although reviews have been conducted on
this topic, there is a lack of comprehensive work detailing the challenges of
dialogue summarization, unifying the differing understanding of the task, and
aligning proposed techniques, datasets, and evaluation metrics with the
challenges. This article summarizes the research on Transformer-based
abstractive summarization for English dialogues by systematically reviewing
1262 unique research papers published between 2019 and 2024, relying on the
Semantic Scholar and DBLP databases. We cover the main challenges present in
dialog summarization (i.e., language, structure, comprehension, speaker,
salience, and factuality) and link them to corresponding techniques such as
graph-based approaches, additional training tasks, and planning strategies,
which typically overly rely on BART-based encoder-decoder models. We find that
while some challenges, like language, have seen considerable progress, mainly
due to training methods, others, such as comprehension, factuality, and
salience, remain difficult and hold significant research opportunities. We
investigate how these approaches are typically assessed, covering the datasets
for the subdomains of dialogue (e.g., meeting, medical), the established
automatic metrics and human evaluation approaches for assessing scores and
annotator agreement. We observe that only a few datasets span across all
subdomains. The ROUGE metric is the most used, while human evaluation is
frequently reported without sufficient detail on inner-annotator agreement and
annotation guidelines. Additionally, we discuss the possible implications of
the recently explored large language models and conclude that despite a
potential shift in relevance and difficulty, our described challenge taxonomy
remains relevant.
|
[
-0.489876925945282,
-0.3633633852005005,
0.4943293631076813,
0.09670720249414444,
-0.21060237288475037,
0.45558369159698486,
-0.11544621735811234,
-0.44037649035453796,
0.1086677834391594,
0.48507407307624817,
-0.5592361092567444,
-0.4364635646343231,
-0.7739748358726501,
0.6143892407417297,
-0.33772116899490356,
1.2983323335647583,
-0.032115403562784195,
0.17955435812473297,
-0.2933308482170105,
-0.30276766419410706,
-0.44298988580703735,
-0.6159130930900574,
-0.47916850447654724,
-0.0600941926240921,
0.35763558745384216,
0.1578667163848877,
0.5202944278717041,
0.07108306139707565,
0.6210486888885498,
0.3355240821838379,
-0.4754991829395294,
0.23032429814338684,
-0.4568342864513397,
0.35268792510032654,
0.11476384848356247,
-0.35707294940948486,
-0.5158659219741821,
-0.20892925560474396,
0.43732360005378723,
1.1424589157104492,
-0.06187077611684799,
-0.06359907984733582,
0.129355788230896,
0.6770914793014526,
-0.4723150432109833,
0.2466093748807907,
-0.4792783260345459,
0.13587823510169983,
0.08572668582201004,
0.008902350440621376,
-0.35421091318130493,
-0.4233763515949249,
0.5055873394012451,
-0.427983820438385,
0.4646422266960144,
-0.11360952258110046,
0.45786017179489136,
0.17129944264888763,
-0.6827815175056458,
-0.5397661328315735,
-0.8873723745346069,
0.7073014974594116,
-0.8103929162025452,
-0.0774463415145874,
0.06095975637435913,
0.3996186852455139,
-0.020545365288853645,
-0.7248222827911377,
-0.3007606863975525,
-0.05010410025715828,
-0.4234887659549713,
0.4357997179031372,
-0.31716692447662354,
0.34995532035827637,
0.39048752188682556,
0.5961071252822876,
-0.47573229670524597,
-0.16140097379684448,
-0.707409679889679,
-0.2699013650417328,
0.7166313529014587,
0.7288992404937744,
0.295419842004776,
-0.34344589710235596,
0.13981689512729645,
0.09342390298843384,
-0.5484186410903931,
0.18047188222408295,
0.2666015625,
0.20918028056621552,
-0.2384720891714096,
0.4936085641384125,
-0.3278173506259918,
0.31887519359588623,
-0.18092739582061768,
-0.11223280429840088,
0.09371062368154526,
-0.6323378682136536,
0.19807562232017517,
0.08921574056148529,
0.8146761655807495,
0.54683518409729,
0.03453589230775833,
-0.10456360131502151,
-0.10348235070705414,
-0.10317645967006683,
0.07805373519659042,
-0.8022446632385254,
-0.10034549236297607,
0.3658038377761841,
-0.5114927291870117,
-0.22915595769882202,
-0.1014646366238594,
-0.44071927666664124,
-0.1086529865860939,
-0.43228188157081604,
-0.20177219808101654,
-0.20272356271743774,
-0.2730625569820404,
-0.10113182663917542,
-0.21323594450950623,
0.3078872561454773,
0.8583195805549622,
-0.9200927019119263,
0.563041627407074,
0.6547935605049133,
1.0927902460098267,
-0.21285565197467804,
0.09619869291782379,
-0.0030651292763650417,
-0.12440378963947296,
-0.2570374608039856,
0.8726454973220825,
-0.41345950961112976,
-0.9042630195617676,
0.013535337522625923,
0.19463320076465607,
-0.31223100423812866,
-0.39901381731033325,
0.4968785047531128,
0.10062293708324432,
0.2898213565349579,
-0.4514707326889038,
-0.2385195642709732,
0.0011894715717062354,
0.2812734842300415,
-0.6269916892051697,
0.7217082977294922,
0.007109636906534433,
-0.9433702230453491,
-0.11522908508777618,
-0.6009671092033386,
-0.4232247769832611,
-0.17761114239692688,
-0.3952236473560333,
-0.2493487298488617,
0.2295079231262207,
0.32104620337486267,
-0.022952614352107048,
-0.3273492753505707,
0.1775122433900833,
0.19017809629440308,
-0.27816104888916016,
0.18232333660125732,
-0.40118303894996643,
0.8887000679969788,
0.18120156228542328,
-0.18222913146018982,
0.16294491291046143,
-0.41728946566581726,
-0.15694844722747803,
-0.16517652571201324,
0.16814422607421875,
-0.038092583417892456,
0.051487796008586884,
0.05550608038902283,
0.22359342873096466,
0.018706921488046646,
-0.5389644503593445,
0.13374245166778564,
-0.43158823251724243,
0.4175121784210205,
0.47979751229286194,
0.11142437160015106,
0.21712322533130646,
-0.29282745718955994,
0.6758052706718445,
-0.07712120562791824,
0.22367408871650696,
-0.678137481212616,
-0.5144782066345215,
-0.6023072004318237,
-0.22321155667304993,
0.32954463362693787,
0.6361724138259888,
-0.4997863471508026,
0.3641491234302521,
-0.41245386004447937,
-0.5672633647918701,
-0.5775752663612366,
-0.23774467408657074,
0.3924339711666107,
0.2919875681400299,
0.26625269651412964,
-0.6348058581352234,
-0.34736424684524536,
-0.9562155604362488,
0.08490735292434692,
-0.25024089217185974,
-0.17032834887504578,
0.307133287191391,
0.490965873003006,
-0.014968717470765114,
1.0249844789505005,
-0.46065300703048706,
-0.38843676447868347,
-0.6726669669151306,
0.5922215580940247,
-0.05587776377797127,
0.34766319394111633,
0.24386908113956451,
-0.47340017557144165,
-0.47554463148117065,
0.05029357224702835,
-0.7559145092964172,
-0.196580171585083,
-0.12341984361410141,
0.43802130222320557,
0.25171658396720886,
0.6989346742630005,
-0.7583766579627991,
0.5917845964431763,
0.22591117024421692,
0.19320501387119293,
0.5987801551818848,
-0.022037046030163765,
0.26894527673721313,
-1.0398406982421875,
0.08711159974336624,
-0.2565568685531616,
-0.15941071510314941,
-0.5336382985115051,
-0.35297510027885437,
-0.4100412130355835,
-0.2601475417613983,
-0.25752970576286316,
0.15829943120479584,
-0.3600415587425232,
0.08720419555902481,
-0.3331180810928345,
0.41225773096084595,
-0.10794295370578766,
0.5564284920692444,
0.09017692506313324,
0.5605450868606567,
0.22416335344314575,
-0.34713125228881836,
0.3732616901397705,
0.5666800737380981,
-0.2522437870502472,
0.49695324897766113,
-1.058380126953125,
0.06760438531637192,
-0.37471500039100647,
0.9086129665374756,
-1.1607388257980347,
0.05729581415653229,
0.003522039158269763,
-0.36689263582229614,
0.24969734251499176,
-0.06964613497257233,
-0.15724095702171326,
-0.10834123939275742,
-0.5292862057685852,
0.6970400214195251,
0.4150511920452118,
-0.009137995541095734,
0.8052743673324585,
0.36542537808418274,
-0.8486953377723694,
-0.622552216053009,
-0.1476610004901886,
0.41053658723831177,
0.014454467222094536,
-0.5031546354293823,
0.3582383394241333,
0.031058231368660927,
-0.43772655725479126,
-0.15978603065013885,
-0.3465423285961151,
0.25961607694625854,
-0.09769292920827866,
0.1324574053287506,
0.2047155648469925,
0.015387952327728271,
-0.2007220834493637,
0.12386876344680786,
-0.3949202001094818,
0.4044032394886017,
0.35479146242141724,
0.09440954029560089,
-0.06267900764942169,
-0.3890470266342163,
-0.4485630989074707,
0.6341290473937988,
0.5502349138259888,
-0.13562782108783722,
0.17885178327560425,
0.41329720616340637,
-0.1577131599187851,
0.15522192418575287,
-0.4115510582923889,
-0.41519060730934143,
-0.294933944940567,
0.6190361976623535,
-0.20729514956474304,
-0.8335636258125305,
0.7643986940383911,
-0.33410900831222534,
0.5809996128082275,
0.46380865573883057,
0.38236862421035767,
-0.16792167723178864,
1.3630146980285645,
0.5143014788627625,
-0.017160968855023384,
0.07748231291770935,
-0.29018399119377136,
0.6540979743003845,
-0.9639726281166077,
-0.27894505858421326,
-0.7600516080856323,
-0.18566226959228516,
-0.6789783835411072,
-0.18103738129138947,
0.5519763827323914,
-0.3072277009487152,
0.34474509954452515,
0.15572935342788696,
-0.4443609118461609,
0.29339003562927246,
0.048474665731191635,
-0.20791730284690857,
0.6110018491744995,
-0.5279478430747986,
0.09016831964254379,
-0.29018890857696533,
-0.6443336606025696,
-0.6154935359954834,
0.9349783062934875,
0.2765767276287079,
0.8660702705383301,
0.25731685757637024,
0.3432721495628357,
0.24974678456783295,
0.3182395100593567,
-0.843819797039032,
0.5057640671730042,
0.06986816972494125,
-0.3422193229198456,
-0.39165934920310974,
-0.2980542480945587,
-0.877933919429779,
0.47544577717781067,
-0.0006960174650885165,
-0.728905975818634,
0.1009492501616478,
0.019127188250422478,
-0.23977316915988922,
-0.039262108504772186,
-0.4988243579864502,
0.7286373972892761,
-0.10129048675298691,
-0.08073636889457703,
-0.18893861770629883,
-1.098448395729065,
0.4287687838077545,
0.2764970362186432,
0.3057408332824707,
-0.09934941679239273,
0.36903268098831177,
0.7657502889633179,
-0.7396810054779053,
0.9005626440048218,
0.04061685502529144,
-0.18520411849021912,
0.23425105214118958,
-0.14669710397720337,
0.4478893578052521,
0.1248382180929184,
0.6308406591415405,
0.09141422808170319,
0.4640781283378601,
-0.3490764796733856,
-0.7658261656761169,
0.2947119176387787,
-0.4685359299182892,
-0.8868471384048462,
-0.7372199296951294,
-0.44162511825561523,
-0.3300400972366333,
-0.19584961235523224,
0.38503018021583557,
0.7265222072601318,
-0.486899733543396,
0.10284467786550522,
0.6624012589454651,
-0.13214193284511566,
0.3660280704498291,
0.2174782007932663,
-0.06356818228960037,
-0.37812814116477966,
0.7241835594177246,
0.07260320335626602,
0.3973698318004608,
0.35166484117507935,
-0.22346456348896027,
-0.17887602746486664,
-0.6762778162956238,
-0.4635840952396393,
0.21576794981956482,
-0.7216630578041077,
-0.06750650703907013,
-0.8913297653198242,
-0.5665722489356995,
-0.4654625952243805,
-0.11437872797250748,
-0.3354535400867462,
-0.8778108358383179,
0.17506451904773712,
-0.19736430048942566,
0.07282876968383789,
0.9750975966453552,
0.16767527163028717,
0.07213544100522995,
-0.6152699589729309,
0.0963725820183754,
0.2870490849018097,
0.04077698662877083,
0.11415079236030579,
-0.5193731784820557,
-0.36873099207878113,
-0.029407735913991928,
-0.6011595129966736,
-0.5959477424621582,
0.10811582952737808,
-0.19321416318416595,
0.3066641092300415,
0.27732720971107483,
0.30204370617866516,
0.6342871785163879,
-0.4934096336364746,
1.1089130640029907,
0.12818381190299988,
-0.8538475036621094,
0.5093592405319214,
-0.17060521245002747,
0.5249689817428589,
0.7555901408195496,
0.2742796540260315,
-0.6619182825088501,
-0.8047839403152466,
-0.4760059118270874,
-1.143581748008728,
0.7565880417823792,
0.5963277220726013,
0.28268325328826904,
0.057791076600551605,
-0.06541299819946289,
0.069021075963974,
0.15682107210159302,
-0.40676888823509216,
-0.32020777463912964,
-0.236636683344841,
-0.1562582552433014,
0.0651627779006958,
-0.16294759511947632,
-0.305149644613266,
-0.30875885486602783,
0.6418269276618958,
-0.1521296203136444,
0.10601966083049774,
0.38508355617523193,
-0.21892565488815308,
0.213733971118927,
0.5565260052680969,
0.8108254671096802,
0.7557567954063416,
-0.3895159959793091,
-0.0931449607014656,
0.3707784414291382,
-0.5244556069374084,
-0.06004650890827179,
0.19688428938388824,
-0.07133309543132782,
0.5162312984466553,
0.5340099334716797,
0.641901969909668,
0.39608296751976013,
-0.8030146360397339,
0.6478933095932007,
-0.49534305930137634,
-0.4873489439487457,
-0.5154861211776733,
-0.26611167192459106,
-0.21012099087238312,
-0.10479798167943954,
0.43783706426620483,
0.004215260501950979,
0.3731202781200409,
-0.4878333806991577,
-0.3017529249191284,
0.5507033467292786,
-0.6488416790962219,
-0.5343427658081055,
0.33609411120414734,
0.5791521072387695,
-0.006245772819966078,
0.3941250145435333,
-0.017051709815859795,
-0.4624309539794922,
0.4455782175064087,
0.25975996255874634,
1.0297242403030396,
-0.24077293276786804,
0.186594620347023,
0.39268797636032104,
0.4829081594944,
0.1745406985282898,
-0.10109269618988037,
-0.39875850081443787,
-0.36743292212486267,
-0.43627968430519104,
-0.131100594997406,
-1.0589874982833862,
0.12354025989770889,
-0.643726646900177,
0.1586197316646576,
-0.13372719287872314,
-0.13975553214550018,
0.15804007649421692,
-0.20111803710460663,
-0.2935706079006195,
-0.16622920334339142,
-0.2714501917362213,
0.8626229763031006,
-0.6601391434669495,
0.14874917268753052,
0.47936755418777466,
-0.3892751932144165,
-0.337079793214798,
-0.24126487970352173,
0.24190162122249603,
-0.11045447736978531,
0.31310775876045227,
0.07587691396474838,
-0.24742577970027924,
-0.2768673002719879,
-0.21853284537792206,
-0.49040326476097107,
1.0698269605636597,
0.17170292139053345,
-0.4175890386104584,
-0.4347405433654785,
0.2343069314956665,
0.7148962616920471,
-0.45984575152397156,
0.8034713268280029,
0.6803281903266907,
0.24380385875701904,
0.2253865748643875,
-1.166635274887085,
0.017165668308734894,
-0.589455783367157,
0.06605241447687149,
0.1297517567873001,
-0.5812737345695496,
0.4248778522014618,
-0.23851944506168365,
-0.38546380400657654,
0.22256775200366974,
0.33112120628356934,
-0.13741403818130493,
0.415955513715744,
0.3818086087703705,
0.28567880392074585,
0.26331353187561035,
-0.41361674666404724,
0.8538607954978943,
-0.21867087483406067,
0.20494753122329712,
1.119693398475647,
-0.39172282814979553,
0.36608949303627014,
0.36279240250587463,
-0.2991602122783661,
0.5351950526237488,
0.4527048170566559,
0.27702778577804565,
0.3169136345386505,
0.2949453294277191,
-0.5067248940467834,
0.014236390590667725,
-0.3491866886615753,
-0.5044922828674316,
0.4123334586620331,
0.5890028476715088,
-0.22695982456207275,
-0.47776544094085693,
-0.08062945306301117,
-0.047196581959724426,
0.05566940829157829,
-0.021367019042372704,
1.4150948524475098,
0.190031036734581,
-0.6453585028648376,
0.3128308355808258,
-0.07650936394929886,
0.27002930641174316,
-0.7347647547721863,
-0.2796856462955475,
-0.42048102617263794,
-0.34805652499198914,
-0.40227246284484863,
-0.3080459237098694,
0.4352259635925293,
0.045285195112228394,
-0.025492427870631218,
-0.2000308781862259,
0.2612225115299225,
-0.37455201148986816,
-0.37057366967201233,
-0.17099058628082275,
0.5425469875335693,
0.26973757147789,
0.23323778808116913,
-0.3404788374900818,
0.09794788807630539,
0.0003581221681088209,
-0.022719014436006546,
0.2336307168006897,
0.5952010750770569,
-0.2343922108411789,
0.342329740524292,
0.32469308376312256,
-0.02479926496744156,
-0.35584986209869385,
0.36746615171432495,
0.9031426310539246,
-0.831518828868866,
-0.502514660358429,
-0.5305335521697998,
0.6941655874252319,
-0.3100249171257019,
-0.3148549795150757,
0.664640486240387,
0.745675265789032,
0.5803018808364868,
0.11118271946907043,
1.203209638595581,
0.0398135781288147,
0.4691492021083832,
-0.37926995754241943,
0.3770446479320526,
0.03854817524552345,
0.5512747168540955,
-0.4052533507347107,
-0.8261101841926575,
-0.1506514698266983,
0.43859654664993286,
-0.2929830849170685,
0.07579223811626434,
1.1073614358901978,
0.7225601673126221,
0.12896178662776947,
0.4970797002315521,
0.06958919763565063,
0.11900687962770462,
0.511712372303009,
0.4470323622226715,
0.8315237760543823,
-0.5296342372894287,
0.6684621572494507,
-0.11604050546884537,
-0.3318854570388794,
-0.23806315660476685,
-0.5745677351951599,
-0.9935820698738098,
-0.8887487053871155,
-0.46041232347488403,
-0.3249334692955017,
0.0023923718836158514,
0.9115555882453918,
0.48657453060150146,
-0.9277861714363098,
-0.3280547857284546,
-0.02210792899131775,
0.2654028832912445,
-0.19783775508403778,
-0.21881195902824402,
0.42601868510246277,
-0.4233211874961853,
-0.9213913679122925,
-0.07880518585443497,
0.5034529566764832,
0.17243634164333344,
-0.2635319232940674,
0.07017096877098083,
0.20723849534988403,
0.07435117661952972,
0.6601277589797974,
0.3299776315689087,
-0.8636218309402466,
-0.06733287125825882,
-0.04160796105861664,
-0.09162881225347519,
-0.07431191951036453,
1.3707013130187988,
-0.6161100268363953,
0.5757265090942383,
0.23650886118412018,
0.5644667744636536,
0.5609342455863953,
0.008418528363108635,
0.8354417085647583,
-0.5536907911300659,
-0.05059811472892761,
0.40200382471084595,
0.34988921880722046,
0.4546632468700409,
-0.044857095927000046,
0.4163808822631836,
0.12584488093852997,
-0.38145267963409424,
-0.8584024310112,
0.3609965443611145,
-1.0837666988372803,
-0.077362060546875,
0.5705370903015137,
-0.07779867947101593,
0.15408825874328613,
-0.6795071363449097,
-0.5668210983276367,
-0.038037464022636414,
-0.24229547381401062,
1.179431676864624,
0.8365217447280884,
-0.34513917565345764,
-0.2456253618001938,
-0.38508760929107666,
0.8592650890350342,
0.45255348086357117,
-0.9018777012825012,
0.4268105924129486,
0.5212236046791077,
-0.19307871162891388,
0.34108325839042664,
0.7922956943511963,
-0.43875470757484436,
0.38198113441467285,
-0.18977254629135132,
-0.1678939312696457,
0.1219506710767746,
-0.12038351595401764,
-0.3282864987850189,
-0.08392569422721863,
0.018044576048851013,
0.3472473919391632
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.07492v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.07492v1
|
Paraphrasing in Affirmative Terms Improves Negation Understanding
| 2024-06-11T17:30:03 | 2024-06-11T17:30:03 |
MohammadHossein Rezaei, Eduardo Blanco
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Negation is a common linguistic phenomenon. Yet language models face
challenges with negation in many natural language understanding tasks such as
question answering and natural language inference. In this paper, we experiment
with seamless strategies that incorporate affirmative interpretations (i.e.,
paraphrases without negation) to make models more robust against negation.
Crucially, our affirmative interpretations are obtained automatically. We show
improvements with CondaQA, a large corpus requiring reasoning with negation,
and five natural language understanding tasks.
|
[
-0.4307255446910858,
-1.079483985900879,
0.9258643984794617,
0.23779460787773132,
-0.5101209878921509,
-0.22307153046131134,
0.15414097905158997,
-0.2976895272731781,
-0.024978674948215485,
0.9185538291931152,
-0.3138754963874817,
-0.43575945496559143,
-0.5563489198684692,
0.46187824010849,
-0.8861579895019531,
1.029646873474121,
0.1995897889137268,
0.0558781698346138,
-0.2633315622806549,
-0.2810962200164795,
-0.6736178398132324,
-0.07846450805664062,
-0.5349104404449463,
-0.5170844793319702,
0.3755156397819519,
0.5681349039077759,
1.3340532779693604,
0.5651256442070007,
0.3432684540748596,
0.37746480107307434,
-0.061073511838912964,
-0.3020182251930237,
-0.0433490052819252,
0.4045023024082184,
-0.51063072681427,
-0.5309869050979614,
-0.17333205044269562,
-0.13648568093776703,
0.5856817364692688,
1.1173070669174194,
0.024985002353787422,
-0.14990516006946564,
0.28104618191719055,
0.2952714264392853,
-0.5134491920471191,
-0.047685302793979645,
-0.8262080550193787,
-0.09077820926904678,
0.23797032237052917,
-0.07336835563182831,
-0.09036143869161606,
-0.6789501905441284,
0.4459790885448456,
-0.6152678728103638,
0.32487618923187256,
-0.16350805759429932,
0.8190964460372925,
0.19381454586982727,
-0.5400552153587341,
-0.4403271973133087,
-0.2525337040424347,
0.9528436064720154,
-1.041966199874878,
0.3570879101753235,
0.5022774934768677,
0.23728588223457336,
-0.20371240377426147,
-0.5262497663497925,
-1.0034157037734985,
-0.20206546783447266,
-0.17646369338035583,
-0.17319977283477783,
-0.1226213276386261,
0.22934022545814514,
0.17533408105373383,
0.35887786746025085,
-0.4953596591949463,
-0.17249394953250885,
-0.15548616647720337,
-0.11348352581262589,
0.3765091300010681,
-0.01584831438958645,
0.5058082342147827,
-0.7125306129455566,
-0.24910050630569458,
0.20567752420902252,
-0.5559713244438171,
-0.1644771844148636,
0.18063126504421234,
0.2503960132598877,
0.11053928732872009,
0.5336270332336426,
-0.2669113874435425,
0.7670180201530457,
-0.056478776037693024,
0.38217997550964355,
0.09559138864278793,
-0.5174806118011475,
-0.5314413905143738,
-0.19435878098011017,
0.23313264548778534,
0.23955874145030975,
0.10880579054355621,
-0.49844393134117126,
-0.15798507630825043,
0.3384566009044647,
0.21492590010166168,
-0.3625735640525818,
0.015154464170336723,
0.35667726397514343,
-0.38881930708885193,
-0.2750767767429352,
-0.2501867413520813,
-1.198632001876831,
-0.5810841917991638,
-0.7866165041923523,
0.8414221405982971,
-0.6041838526725769,
-0.08268076926469803,
0.21391615271568298,
-0.4200915992259979,
0.8343780040740967,
0.5259601473808289,
-0.6592277884483337,
0.5932245850563049,
1.0122010707855225,
0.718352735042572,
0.277682900428772,
-0.3564671576023102,
-0.7900211215019226,
-0.1921645849943161,
-0.4815930724143982,
0.7507727146148682,
-0.7391791939735413,
-0.18960043787956238,
-0.31177738308906555,
-0.035742875188589096,
-0.036269936710596085,
-0.451917439699173,
0.7931958436965942,
-0.33026596903800964,
0.3825523555278778,
-0.30480504035949707,
-0.5258181095123291,
-0.7279089093208313,
0.18347769975662231,
-0.1626766324043274,
0.44932821393013,
-0.280377596616745,
-0.42052146792411804,
0.1206560730934143,
-0.34616929292678833,
-0.5612902641296387,
0.0029700661543756723,
-0.09731748700141907,
-0.16266068816184998,
0.5001677870750427,
0.3959944546222687,
0.3553811013698578,
-0.3157750368118286,
0.4334774613380432,
-0.32537925243377686,
-0.35133469104766846,
0.23755016922950745,
-0.21603378653526306,
0.9061663150787354,
0.26947709918022156,
-0.8287837505340576,
0.10091938823461533,
-0.49514877796173096,
-0.19997751712799072,
-0.08797243237495422,
0.5368144512176514,
-0.5823783874511719,
-0.032456379383802414,
-0.24947957694530487,
0.4172915518283844,
-0.13819792866706848,
-0.5074775815010071,
-0.5102114081382751,
-0.6026854515075684,
0.23176588118076324,
0.6866409182548523,
0.23765774071216583,
0.8036991357803345,
-0.28926295042037964,
0.621149480342865,
-0.4671894907951355,
0.18367475271224976,
-0.029690390452742577,
-0.5892666578292847,
-0.9141979217529297,
-0.11317199468612671,
0.10624853521585464,
0.40904074907302856,
-1.0516154766082764,
0.167441263794899,
0.0037393944803625345,
-0.27098408341407776,
-0.5448538064956665,
0.23604954779148102,
0.49306443333625793,
0.9012322425842285,
0.8077468872070312,
-0.07454235851764679,
-0.3768101632595062,
-0.7887226343154907,
-0.5965436100959778,
0.18005360662937164,
0.09891150891780853,
0.027210328727960587,
0.6891561150550842,
0.019553471356630325,
0.49995866417884827,
-0.22738853096961975,
0.23104308545589447,
-0.4154790937900543,
0.46045947074890137,
0.2307373732328415,
0.4404900372028351,
0.4830319285392761,
-1.0283735990524292,
-0.29638931155204773,
-0.3344342112541199,
-0.911378800868988,
-0.43690773844718933,
-0.4908546507358551,
-0.6512290835380554,
-0.2644699215888977,
0.721195638179779,
-0.5666658282279968,
0.5546973943710327,
0.182675302028656,
-0.7498112320899963,
0.3053499460220337,
0.0115301962941885,
0.22070099413394928,
-0.675542950630188,
-0.25858965516090393,
0.05123596638441086,
-0.318897008895874,
-0.7760369777679443,
0.6092700958251953,
0.02116669900715351,
-0.0683000385761261,
-0.5614125728607178,
0.5864878296852112,
-0.5066093802452087,
0.021413959562778473,
-0.6453063488006592,
0.427600234746933,
0.32419389486312866,
0.21541926264762878,
0.1273825466632843,
0.24971237778663635,
0.7897389531135559,
-0.9262450933456421,
0.04216685891151428,
0.5489972829818726,
-0.15355321764945984,
0.7341748476028442,
-0.78045254945755,
-0.004152816720306873,
-0.6955353021621704,
0.0677521675825119,
-1.096327543258667,
-0.12277521193027496,
0.44144389033317566,
-0.4155932664871216,
0.0028103841468691826,
0.09861856698989868,
-0.1548931747674942,
-0.08281945437192917,
-0.5069738626480103,
0.1116432175040245,
0.5642517805099487,
-0.5040302872657776,
0.5085662603378296,
0.11353694647550583,
-0.36328941583633423,
-0.640410304069519,
-0.7846307158470154,
0.524546205997467,
-0.5400659441947937,
-0.09459498524665833,
0.11791533976793289,
0.18408344686031342,
-0.6409798264503479,
-0.1815318465232849,
-0.17065134644508362,
-0.2786075472831726,
0.4559745192527771,
0.12564218044281006,
0.23832902312278748,
-0.03368662670254707,
0.11273910105228424,
0.18086352944374084,
-0.011627916246652603,
0.06860044598579407,
-0.10433623939752579,
0.3743489384651184,
0.24198812246322632,
-0.15282854437828064,
-0.5571240186691284,
0.48136651515960693,
0.5984265804290771,
-0.15821515023708344,
0.7221974730491638,
0.1997779756784439,
-0.3847266137599945,
-0.09201302379369736,
-0.48568472266197205,
-0.36315396428108215,
-0.4362069070339203,
0.0027521010488271713,
-0.36670634150505066,
-0.5258813500404358,
0.2702401280403137,
0.42956215143203735,
0.1725633442401886,
0.419085294008255,
0.1388261616230011,
-0.12449188530445099,
0.8138279914855957,
0.16819767653942108,
0.3403962552547455,
0.21692757308483124,
0.23935681581497192,
0.1917266696691513,
-0.48901692032814026,
0.04305100440979004,
-0.9204251766204834,
-0.15671294927597046,
-0.3770517110824585,
-0.5964402556419373,
-0.043231356889009476,
0.11315599828958511,
-0.2165716141462326,
0.49323341250419617,
-0.3407435119152069,
0.4667368233203888,
0.5564935207366943,
0.23893867433071136,
0.3573944866657257,
-0.047285713255405426,
0.21674463152885437,
-0.3140726387500763,
-0.2780984342098236,
-0.6933460235595703,
0.9333793520927429,
0.10333854705095291,
0.4912642240524292,
0.34111258387565613,
0.9275023937225342,
-0.0053431144915521145,
0.13343138992786407,
-0.28579339385032654,
0.7828527092933655,
0.11399856954813004,
-0.6681802272796631,
-0.28472137451171875,
-0.5082915425300598,
-0.9296809434890747,
0.5787918567657471,
-0.35311776399612427,
-0.5836259722709656,
0.4765898585319519,
0.016334282234311104,
-0.3112899661064148,
0.0887405127286911,
-0.5831548571586609,
0.9467185735702515,
-0.10302980989217758,
-0.34240850806236267,
-0.3570314645767212,
-0.7628040313720703,
0.31050804257392883,
-0.1885225623846054,
0.393885999917984,
-0.21426060795783997,
-0.23402495682239532,
0.56284099817276,
-0.33265894651412964,
0.5746492743492126,
-0.3001927137374878,
0.022527193650603294,
0.5473523736000061,
0.3425351083278656,
0.41738444566726685,
-0.007365769241005182,
-0.5823907256126404,
0.08240629732608795,
-0.19630108773708344,
-0.8314973711967468,
-0.7699663639068604,
0.5724666714668274,
-0.13399596512317657,
-0.7192985415458679,
-0.36670053005218506,
-0.586322009563446,
-0.2800455093383789,
0.05334018915891647,
0.024482328444719315,
0.3692331612110138,
0.06675419211387634,
0.1518823504447937,
0.4754975140094757,
-0.662514328956604,
0.42358091473579407,
0.27555590867996216,
-0.20092740654945374,
-0.18157777190208435,
0.6889835596084595,
-0.03963954746723175,
0.544492244720459,
0.3690047562122345,
0.12882041931152344,
-0.6488761305809021,
-0.7825111746788025,
-0.14232292771339417,
0.2973651587963104,
-0.858308732509613,
-0.14109961688518524,
-0.9965287446975708,
0.252441942691803,
-0.7160490155220032,
-0.28968632221221924,
0.3636353313922882,
-0.6627044677734375,
-0.028753438964486122,
-0.2950889766216278,
0.3024534285068512,
0.5947524905204773,
-0.15958842635154724,
0.19692324101924896,
-0.5651717782020569,
0.883949875831604,
0.659713625907898,
-0.23247402906417847,
0.2819756269454956,
-0.7371783256530762,
0.286718487739563,
0.15107516944408417,
-0.2996782064437866,
-1.168035626411438,
0.4840182662010193,
0.30620357394218445,
0.5554827451705933,
0.017890170216560364,
0.10765432566404343,
1.0032624006271362,
-0.4389997720718384,
0.6477141380310059,
0.039177633821964264,
-1.499742031097412,
0.5339315533638,
-0.3688083291053772,
0.4640236794948578,
0.7322949767112732,
0.38910168409347534,
-0.473783940076828,
-0.9715945720672607,
-0.6121938228607178,
-0.9846824407577515,
0.2098163515329361,
0.55513995885849,
0.5221549868583679,
-0.2832682430744171,
0.4616129398345947,
0.6062166690826416,
0.4314798414707184,
-0.8845700025558472,
-0.038241319358348846,
-0.29191747307777405,
-0.29699698090553284,
-0.3142869770526886,
-0.1786361038684845,
0.29028692841529846,
-0.41998106241226196,
0.6170640587806702,
0.03238920122385025,
0.1315477043390274,
0.3211649954319,
-0.48515060544013977,
0.23070798814296722,
0.4892130494117737,
0.1875470131635666,
0.7984874248504639,
0.025737274438142776,
0.5289952158927917,
0.3964051902294159,
0.0714452937245369,
0.06238307058811188,
0.17023532092571259,
-0.34030765295028687,
0.4124792218208313,
0.4452067017555237,
0.52649986743927,
0.3804130554199219,
-0.5585600137710571,
0.32861462235450745,
0.01365703996270895,
-0.22787414491176605,
0.28222551941871643,
-0.078542061150074,
-0.023121096193790436,
0.22076527774333954,
0.25559213757514954,
-0.13690567016601562,
0.5302472114562988,
-0.6642957329750061,
0.4985813796520233,
0.39222776889801025,
-0.4530738592147827,
-0.13618655502796173,
0.8770006895065308,
-0.028009817004203796,
-0.016840863972902298,
0.5020249485969543,
-0.18372248113155365,
-0.5212480425834656,
0.6749091148376465,
0.5522831082344055,
0.8728702068328857,
-0.20159375667572021,
0.5564622282981873,
0.31579217314720154,
0.12197072803974152,
-0.006594142876565456,
0.4516143798828125,
-0.4945679008960724,
-0.6129111051559448,
-0.4096406400203705,
-0.6984042525291443,
-0.6581814885139465,
-0.21588265895843506,
-0.49920928478240967,
0.23404185473918915,
-0.30601808428764343,
0.1793362945318222,
0.2899715304374695,
-0.44801953434944153,
-0.47864222526550293,
0.3898490369319916,
0.2857685387134552,
0.6271762847900391,
-0.7692870497703552,
0.5241774916648865,
0.5568422675132751,
-0.6660256385803223,
-0.7470303177833557,
0.33054235577583313,
-0.16522978246212006,
-0.570986270904541,
0.4805033802986145,
0.23098304867744446,
0.09742860496044159,
-0.10628651082515717,
-0.4539865553379059,
-0.6029483079910278,
0.48985469341278076,
0.5706796050071716,
-0.28738531470298767,
0.10464029014110565,
0.1305466741323471,
0.4799325168132782,
0.18444252014160156,
0.1705542802810669,
0.4563540816307068,
0.5060005187988281,
-0.12275020778179169,
-0.8415296077728271,
0.3077492117881775,
0.08733132481575012,
-0.2807672321796417,
0.2662064731121063,
0.08529041707515717,
1.1441302299499512,
0.08844035118818283,
0.05706604942679405,
0.26279139518737793,
0.7717214226722717,
-0.16746929287910461,
0.4452400803565979,
0.7108433246612549,
0.45126351714134216,
0.7058344483375549,
0.13844190537929535,
1.048258662223816,
0.10517189651727676,
0.216513991355896,
1.1955515146255493,
-0.16565099358558655,
0.4685571491718292,
0.476733922958374,
0.1858239620923996,
0.5026854276657104,
0.3347298800945282,
0.4868132770061493,
0.5865415334701538,
-0.018833115696907043,
-0.523389995098114,
-0.5371847748756409,
-0.1223117858171463,
-0.36708417534828186,
0.5078109502792358,
0.16054774820804596,
-0.33747854828834534,
-0.6698700189590454,
0.17586691677570343,
0.16277052462100983,
0.650098979473114,
-0.5259214639663696,
0.6935348510742188,
0.3936677873134613,
-0.9280064702033997,
0.7366040349006653,
-0.09437815099954605,
0.6758529543876648,
-0.18042564392089844,
-0.36198890209198,
-0.3823004961013794,
0.005565909668803215,
-0.24921555817127228,
-0.8122134804725647,
0.8264143466949463,
0.09481300413608551,
0.4727522134780884,
-0.4256109297275543,
0.6930969953536987,
-0.41654181480407715,
-0.3912665545940399,
0.37772414088249207,
0.5864034295082092,
0.2878596782684326,
-0.2986125648021698,
-0.8386217951774597,
-0.5295573472976685,
0.16308827698230743,
0.207008495926857,
0.10631442070007324,
0.43730032444000244,
-0.18517805635929108,
0.47252726554870605,
0.4944559335708618,
-0.10820569843053818,
0.18930354714393616,
-0.22253704071044922,
0.48777586221694946,
-1.055092215538025,
-0.5017279386520386,
-1.206575632095337,
0.19092178344726562,
-0.2008315622806549,
-0.08003472536802292,
1.2792980670928955,
0.18650051951408386,
0.35907790064811707,
0.1525058150291443,
0.4399189054965973,
-0.04052099585533142,
0.4880199134349823,
-0.2370988130569458,
0.4076526165008545,
-0.5720598697662354,
-0.09389900416135788,
-0.8467501401901245,
-1.0166277885437012,
-0.5772603750228882,
0.9177577495574951,
-0.6964454650878906,
-0.5236631631851196,
0.5565845370292664,
0.6467195153236389,
-0.012597186490893364,
0.4578472971916199,
0.3672991096973419,
0.24409469962120056,
0.08883751183748245,
0.2958931028842926,
0.9954193234443665,
-0.5152068138122559,
0.41386541724205017,
-0.26107266545295715,
-0.0027509378269314766,
0.2312626987695694,
-0.7643844485282898,
-0.7333637475967407,
-0.1985677182674408,
-0.45195120573043823,
-0.46861910820007324,
0.2698625326156616,
0.7036371827125549,
0.37725359201431274,
-0.8405693173408508,
-0.15878544747829437,
-0.7731747627258301,
0.7229990363121033,
-0.15656152367591858,
-0.2341543585062027,
0.07177145779132843,
-0.7029784917831421,
-0.8247553110122681,
0.44067609310150146,
0.16509045660495758,
-0.12499507516622543,
0.27935612201690674,
-0.004649958107620478,
-0.724929928779602,
0.46532273292541504,
0.35078081488609314,
0.3307424783706665,
-0.5019357204437256,
-0.4278641939163208,
-0.20349767804145813,
0.037483278661966324,
-0.03147066757082939,
0.33466923236846924,
-0.7816711068153381,
0.3417876958847046,
0.5842933654785156,
0.7292073965072632,
0.08298809081315994,
0.2365257292985916,
0.8970220685005188,
-0.16809199750423431,
0.4464508593082428,
0.4737125635147095,
0.20094984769821167,
0.4797995984554291,
-0.02262759953737259,
0.25776946544647217,
0.14818350970745087,
-0.33317747712135315,
-0.8390617966651917,
0.23192420601844788,
-0.4148775339126587,
-0.6031585931777954,
0.994508683681488,
-0.09525544196367264,
-0.17511166632175446,
-0.6218000054359436,
-0.07811035960912704,
0.35662099719047546,
-0.19771580398082733,
0.5173138380050659,
0.5819128155708313,
-0.01815672032535076,
0.07311584055423737,
-0.8149071931838989,
0.35124045610427856,
1.0954598188400269,
-0.6624991297721863,
-0.23671960830688477,
0.5077509880065918,
0.15123575925827026,
-0.22651471197605133,
0.27018997073173523,
-0.09230659157037735,
0.468432754278183,
-0.10347802191972733,
-0.109197698533535,
0.4635309875011444,
-0.07921319454908371,
-0.718169629573822,
0.13606488704681396,
0.07879405468702316,
-0.3626747727394104
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.07483v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.07483v1
|
Advancing Annotation of Stance in Social Media Posts: A Comparative Analysis of Large Language Models and Crowd Sourcing
| 2024-06-11T17:26:07 | 2024-06-11T17:26:07 |
Mao Li, Frederick Conrad
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In the rapidly evolving landscape of Natural Language Processing (NLP), the
use of Large Language Models (LLMs) for automated text annotation in social
media posts has garnered significant interest. Despite the impressive
innovations in developing LLMs like ChatGPT, their efficacy, and accuracy as
annotation tools are not well understood. In this paper, we analyze the
performance of eight open-source and proprietary LLMs for annotating the stance
expressed in social media posts, benchmarking their performance against human
annotators' (i.e., crowd-sourced) judgments. Additionally, we investigate the
conditions under which LLMs are likely to disagree with human judgment. A
significant finding of our study is that the explicitness of text expressing a
stance plays a critical role in how faithfully LLMs' stance judgments match
humans'. We argue that LLMs perform well when human annotators do, and when
LLMs fail, it often corresponds to situations in which human annotators
struggle to reach an agreement. We conclude with recommendations for a
comprehensive approach that combines the precision of human expertise with the
scalability of LLM predictions. This study highlights the importance of
improving the accuracy and comprehensiveness of automated stance detection,
aiming to advance these technologies for more efficient and unbiased analysis
of social media.
|
[
-0.4447641968727112,
-0.739188015460968,
0.6120816469192505,
0.43869343400001526,
-0.5521905422210693,
0.34364619851112366,
-0.39269909262657166,
-0.5850189924240112,
0.5924890637397766,
0.30592775344848633,
-0.1784011572599411,
-0.6983076333999634,
-1.1005034446716309,
0.2298799753189087,
-0.4281326234340668,
0.7197962403297424,
-0.04870937019586563,
0.11112242192029953,
-0.1609823852777481,
-0.5311586260795593,
-0.041542261838912964,
-0.49135464429855347,
-0.7115105390548706,
-0.24130654335021973,
0.48096591234207153,
-0.004488800186663866,
0.9355907440185547,
0.5792137384414673,
0.6713895797729492,
0.28526654839515686,
-0.3140837550163269,
0.07031384855508804,
-0.23185038566589355,
0.10845586657524109,
-0.23081190884113312,
0.06824393570423126,
-0.48945891857147217,
0.11995353549718857,
0.7849015593528748,
0.5128999352455139,
0.15345509350299835,
0.19083954393863678,
-0.014067884534597397,
0.5456966757774353,
-0.2714754343032837,
0.037656188011169434,
-0.7189876437187195,
-0.12736782431602478,
-0.2956705689430237,
0.034299056977033615,
-0.24683362245559692,
-0.5174967646598816,
-0.03694646805524826,
-0.42516815662384033,
0.08178289979696274,
-0.03863949328660965,
0.9257531762123108,
0.25606149435043335,
-0.1153976321220398,
-0.21103857457637787,
-0.37005603313446045,
0.5944169759750366,
-0.8654468655586243,
0.3732532262802124,
0.3896119296550751,
0.1061815395951271,
-0.060061730444431305,
-0.4375174641609192,
-0.6250397562980652,
-0.21058347821235657,
0.07418399304151535,
-0.07877615094184875,
-0.10449859499931335,
0.0782543495297432,
0.3032599091529846,
0.2580282986164093,
-0.36339762806892395,
0.2915075719356537,
-0.10307380557060242,
-0.19354993104934692,
0.8977688550949097,
-0.2736611068248749,
0.21456390619277954,
-0.5433884859085083,
-0.45168519020080566,
0.04408355429768562,
-0.4977529048919678,
0.010465750470757484,
0.36482536792755127,
0.41897010803222656,
-0.0090955113992095,
0.8913245797157288,
-0.29249709844589233,
0.45371589064598083,
0.1626366227865219,
0.05300804600119591,
0.14500311017036438,
-0.012396305799484253,
-0.05606899410486221,
-0.16822727024555206,
1.203626275062561,
0.7575790286064148,
0.40914493799209595,
-0.10370095074176788,
-0.23237627744674683,
-0.03964199870824814,
0.15633803606033325,
-0.49830344319343567,
-0.09432653337717056,
0.2013651579618454,
-0.4568333029747009,
-0.30111658573150635,
0.3134419620037079,
-0.746715247631073,
-1.0462113618850708,
-0.4579830765724182,
0.07263792306184769,
-0.22828006744384766,
-0.40642035007476807,
-0.05722324922680855,
-0.13813191652297974,
0.5299452543258667,
0.5843416452407837,
-0.7027812600135803,
0.02807827666401863,
1.1723182201385498,
1.343607783317566,
-0.2045556902885437,
-0.17034977674484253,
-0.3506489098072052,
-0.1595875769853592,
-0.5325973629951477,
1.1012938022613525,
-0.5700380802154541,
-0.34304550290107727,
0.2374216765165329,
-0.13036081194877625,
0.25544387102127075,
-0.4082179367542267,
0.7573726177215576,
-0.6051862835884094,
-0.43922293186187744,
-0.6481593251228333,
-0.8320366144180298,
-0.04062030464410782,
0.36170732975006104,
-0.9145143628120422,
0.9906451106071472,
-0.24606430530548096,
-0.8418198823928833,
0.7039899230003357,
-0.579915463924408,
-0.3216891288757324,
0.3363480269908905,
-0.33878248929977417,
-0.2249695062637329,
0.03591611236333847,
0.301811546087265,
0.7480910420417786,
0.06572506576776505,
0.2292630672454834,
-0.746464729309082,
-0.2052023857831955,
0.3115564286708832,
-0.06415265053510666,
0.812738299369812,
-0.07037001103162766,
-0.3233039081096649,
0.3007142245769501,
-0.3333830237388611,
-0.31381699442863464,
0.21204030513763428,
-0.46246400475502014,
-0.3052131235599518,
0.3724570572376251,
0.05651738494634628,
0.18171323835849762,
0.14222599565982819,
-0.46090230345726013,
0.26627177000045776,
-0.1851092278957367,
0.46261361241340637,
0.9497408270835876,
-0.0021121238823980093,
0.46853506565093994,
-0.02327553741633892,
0.23279526829719543,
-0.522409200668335,
0.007413262501358986,
0.05955445393919945,
-0.6062700748443604,
-0.46422865986824036,
-0.17016389966011047,
0.29897040128707886,
0.3146685063838959,
-0.3401872217655182,
0.5423095226287842,
-0.33054813742637634,
-0.5878069400787354,
-0.738544762134552,
0.5074648261070251,
0.09089347720146179,
0.01076432690024376,
0.16368484497070312,
-0.309338241815567,
-0.595012366771698,
-0.7676920890808105,
-0.6621523499488831,
-0.6519055366516113,
0.13016271591186523,
-0.09957008063793182,
0.4305374324321747,
-0.09637981653213501,
0.9311529994010925,
-0.00634701969102025,
-0.0363297313451767,
-0.24590040743350983,
0.4148533046245575,
-0.18505944311618805,
-0.01506008766591549,
0.6223571300506592,
-0.7668971419334412,
-0.519429624080658,
-0.021979590877890587,
-0.6147791147232056,
-0.27873292565345764,
0.07239104807376862,
-0.23182427883148193,
0.45938679575920105,
0.6453248262405396,
-0.8551871180534363,
0.19825522601604462,
0.7166196703910828,
-0.25185951590538025,
0.4067855179309845,
0.4455301761627197,
0.28476399183273315,
-0.9862048029899597,
-0.08243081718683243,
0.6538653373718262,
-0.4410260319709778,
-0.4045051038265228,
-0.049882177263498306,
-0.014875704422593117,
0.20104868710041046,
-0.36082953214645386,
0.6363161206245422,
-0.22824405133724213,
-0.15449367463588715,
-0.3744751513004303,
0.4555679261684418,
-0.0630267933011055,
0.08287695795297623,
0.35876700282096863,
0.44746914505958557,
0.26882779598236084,
-0.19927449524402618,
0.47435885667800903,
0.10820333659648895,
-0.28418827056884766,
0.6761398315429688,
-0.7609291076660156,
0.26557615399360657,
-0.04794447496533394,
0.4039953649044037,
-1.1952351331710815,
-0.4258967936038971,
0.3837936818599701,
-0.693846583366394,
0.11722861975431442,
-0.4876040816307068,
-0.8528817892074585,
-0.3028579354286194,
-0.5652300715446472,
-0.15150074660778046,
0.2261255532503128,
-0.5029266476631165,
0.3835391402244568,
0.6072220802307129,
-0.24281081557273865,
-0.5778757929801941,
-0.47655218839645386,
0.40050387382507324,
-0.21543997526168823,
-0.5758532285690308,
-0.01729358732700348,
0.3547250032424927,
-0.8160715103149414,
-0.18300284445285797,
0.021435389295220375,
0.08776068687438965,
-0.03420533984899521,
0.2835022211074829,
0.03577215224504471,
-0.035968393087387085,
0.2739599943161011,
-0.23276104032993317,
-0.03814578428864479,
0.14111146330833435,
-0.03047938458621502,
0.4973767101764679,
-0.31882554292678833,
-0.5397219657897949,
-0.49403753876686096,
0.16960161924362183,
0.5332583785057068,
-0.10291097313165665,
0.6604393720626831,
0.7740134596824646,
-0.4251756966114044,
0.09972954541444778,
-0.7924692034721375,
0.06915661692619324,
-0.435395747423172,
0.14132191240787506,
0.2804080843925476,
-0.8260323405265808,
0.42043253779411316,
0.006998368073254824,
0.5350319743156433,
0.6376914978027344,
0.5914220213890076,
-0.32655981183052063,
0.9606491327285767,
0.4183703660964966,
-0.45996129512786865,
0.555418848991394,
0.09862279146909714,
0.006491128355264664,
-0.3987276554107666,
0.16953961551189423,
-0.5404086709022522,
-0.36070916056632996,
-0.6794054508209229,
-0.6010974049568176,
-0.13658060133457184,
0.0037786418106406927,
-0.09826778620481491,
0.19908037781715393,
-0.3487103283405304,
0.3292507231235504,
0.30683135986328125,
-0.14834384620189667,
0.4012521803379059,
-0.028813602402806282,
0.3586306869983673,
-0.13101904094219208,
-0.100742869079113,
-1.0908381938934326,
0.8329576253890991,
0.4758867919445038,
0.39102160930633545,
0.051027536392211914,
0.5600727796554565,
0.5362465381622314,
0.6547242999076843,
-0.955545961856842,
0.8176414966583252,
-0.07236071676015854,
-0.5797381401062012,
-0.2662433981895447,
-0.06596972048282623,
-0.4964473247528076,
0.24831274151802063,
-0.31212735176086426,
-0.6432461142539978,
-0.1707189828157425,
0.21910379827022552,
-0.20204399526119232,
0.5768046975135803,
-0.5633749961853027,
0.7508315443992615,
-0.20717723667621613,
-0.355117529630661,
-0.0038940897211432457,
-0.5560988783836365,
0.05151815712451935,
0.03834972530603409,
0.19591638445854187,
-0.4297422468662262,
-0.34873372316360474,
0.8910902142524719,
-0.2303190529346466,
1.1300714015960693,
-0.4835450351238251,
-0.2281772792339325,
0.520587682723999,
-0.14764276146888733,
0.5500593781471252,
0.10487774759531021,
-0.25607502460479736,
0.40488743782043457,
-0.3440166413784027,
-0.3309343159198761,
-0.2104095071554184,
0.6028159260749817,
-0.6931427717208862,
-0.46529272198677063,
-0.22097554802894592,
-0.1336415857076645,
-0.24130287766456604,
0.06721314787864685,
0.10179060697555542,
0.006603519897907972,
-0.5280974507331848,
0.2843739986419678,
0.45680710673332214,
0.05381204932928085,
0.5972738265991211,
0.1255141943693161,
-0.35471343994140625,
-0.488964319229126,
0.5670198202133179,
0.1993042677640915,
-0.0007309601060114801,
0.23235663771629333,
0.1667727828025818,
-0.5101218223571777,
-0.6838508248329163,
-0.48363474011421204,
0.2791605591773987,
-0.8966008424758911,
-0.0603480190038681,
-0.6296617388725281,
0.11429255455732346,
-0.6248029470443726,
-0.4507846236228943,
-0.4633682668209076,
-0.44599199295043945,
-0.008495577611029148,
-0.5005251169204712,
0.7650592923164368,
0.6898825168609619,
-0.035587113350629807,
0.33659255504608154,
-0.5355576872825623,
0.18319648504257202,
0.10383124649524689,
0.3645414710044861,
-0.28024840354919434,
-0.29155972599983215,
0.05275614559650421,
0.005589656066149473,
-0.23012611269950867,
-0.9352481961250305,
0.016502508893609047,
-0.0580480694770813,
0.4627809226512909,
0.6592539548873901,
-0.06654483824968338,
0.6573596596717834,
-0.1397089809179306,
0.8096165657043457,
0.04118937626481056,
-0.8705510497093201,
0.4755384922027588,
-0.7190269231796265,
0.027588805183768272,
0.7395076751708984,
0.5030582547187805,
-0.703472375869751,
-0.5675121545791626,
-0.47066402435302734,
-0.9029613733291626,
0.3804851174354553,
0.06893520057201385,
0.2500929832458496,
-0.18536822497844696,
0.35409021377563477,
0.03620597720146179,
0.18771040439605713,
-0.8987364768981934,
0.13582156598567963,
-0.18174418807029724,
-0.05803874507546425,
-0.2041040062904358,
-0.12509708106517792,
0.022627124562859535,
-0.29803231358528137,
0.549568772315979,
-0.16598723828792572,
-0.058525025844573975,
0.0770723819732666,
-0.2458452731370926,
-0.254113107919693,
0.07528209686279297,
0.2679721415042877,
0.646412193775177,
-0.07927447557449341,
0.02941003255546093,
0.2967629134654999,
-0.3751875162124634,
-0.13492652773857117,
0.11371365189552307,
-0.32761305570602417,
0.42090901732444763,
0.41392257809638977,
0.5898754000663757,
0.1538909375667572,
-0.5712277293205261,
0.5728065967559814,
0.2306460738182068,
-0.23056651651859283,
-0.48786357045173645,
-0.35197970271110535,
0.48854485154151917,
0.3236862123012543,
0.25206702947616577,
-0.09193810075521469,
-0.06769776344299316,
-0.2884711027145386,
0.03821659833192825,
0.6586421132087708,
-0.48816585540771484,
-0.3879050314426422,
0.41744354367256165,
0.23107749223709106,
-0.49945130944252014,
0.11388343572616577,
-0.2646975517272949,
-0.34111717343330383,
0.3504403233528137,
-0.06317980587482452,
0.9717125296592712,
-0.05059162154793739,
0.37193891406059265,
0.39244428277015686,
0.3220515847206116,
-0.4347277581691742,
0.019851112738251686,
-0.07648661732673645,
-0.6402652859687805,
-0.5877593159675598,
-0.5860530734062195,
-0.6010110378265381,
0.00022927235113456845,
-0.46030715107917786,
0.4866580367088318,
-0.8102805614471436,
-0.4932253658771515,
0.1933470517396927,
0.15257470309734344,
-0.3527872562408447,
-0.13104084134101868,
0.43682026863098145,
0.7484298944473267,
-0.8603866100311279,
0.41743242740631104,
1.1547032594680786,
-0.2848663032054901,
-0.5508294701576233,
0.4193533957004547,
0.42492663860321045,
-0.6324450969696045,
0.19568273425102234,
0.3074969947338104,
-0.19405080378055573,
-0.2831525206565857,
-0.81767737865448,
-0.4490589499473572,
0.8989812135696411,
0.34549739956855774,
-0.4838789701461792,
0.21906575560569763,
0.2667241096496582,
0.7753481864929199,
0.004944756161421537,
0.06896689534187317,
0.3661961257457733,
0.5642983913421631,
0.07266443222761154,
-0.7999363541603088,
0.03734868764877319,
-0.150711789727211,
-0.1104351058602333,
0.1761094480752945,
-0.8604185581207275,
0.49312323331832886,
0.004015728365629911,
-0.22531606256961823,
-0.1695011556148529,
0.7225462794303894,
0.45987096428871155,
0.37774166464805603,
0.5261369347572327,
0.4633924961090088,
0.6108950972557068,
-0.12932270765304565,
0.9556633234024048,
-0.02763652801513672,
0.3219248652458191,
0.6468120217323303,
-0.3899489641189575,
1.2643564939498901,
0.4940926432609558,
-0.1748013198375702,
0.2845331132411957,
0.7460499405860901,
-0.07079306989908218,
-0.026986243203282356,
0.03581470623612404,
-0.15465685725212097,
-0.3314878046512604,
-0.058673180639743805,
0.042796481400728226,
0.37089863419532776,
0.2938793897628784,
-0.4950011670589447,
-0.21892881393432617,
-0.41553187370300293,
0.37483999133110046,
0.2707107365131378,
-0.5335180759429932,
0.9534441828727722,
0.26312920451164246,
-0.6513328552246094,
0.15067410469055176,
0.013967474922537804,
0.8562114834785461,
-0.26985886693000793,
0.19777102768421173,
-0.04514680802822113,
-0.11758862435817719,
-0.4145256578922272,
-1.0226869583129883,
0.4495997428894043,
0.355403333902359,
0.07477053999900818,
-0.3331252634525299,
1.071515679359436,
0.10156997293233871,
-0.5140606164932251,
0.5564078092575073,
0.5119905471801758,
0.14236660301685333,
-0.29102206230163574,
-0.7542245984077454,
0.2487204670906067,
-0.33471930027008057,
-0.5476546883583069,
0.227972149848938,
0.42836540937423706,
-0.14474919438362122,
0.3540094196796417,
0.5697478652000427,
0.04331395402550697,
0.057237282395362854,
0.22087162733078003,
0.741062581539154,
-0.6599838137626648,
-0.09530863165855408,
-1.2794581651687622,
0.34960803389549255,
-0.4639454782009125,
-0.23707181215286255,
0.8655357360839844,
0.2924365997314453,
0.7621316909790039,
0.40143102407455444,
1.026807188987732,
-0.21550309658050537,
0.6605849266052246,
-0.31722092628479004,
0.7507752776145935,
-0.347993403673172,
0.12201418727636337,
-0.6109805107116699,
-0.8522754311561584,
-0.4098210036754608,
0.6489267945289612,
-0.5759230256080627,
0.04734780639410019,
0.1652650535106659,
0.6681004166603088,
0.13510258495807648,
0.07602206617593765,
-0.060859523713588715,
0.019886456429958344,
0.3358892798423767,
-0.10324623435735703,
0.9959546327590942,
0.07346072793006897,
0.4615062177181244,
-0.2680264711380005,
0.00861225463449955,
-0.4084460735321045,
-1.0192922353744507,
-1.055722951889038,
-0.5255147218704224,
-0.4817412197589874,
-0.32028746604919434,
-0.04394230619072914,
1.2523959875106812,
0.5363656878471375,
-0.6206936836242676,
-0.13385100662708282,
-0.02951817587018013,
0.04756912216544151,
-0.14503005146980286,
-0.21405182778835297,
0.2711755037307739,
-0.26783400774002075,
-0.7190201282501221,
0.06290192157030106,
0.22779381275177002,
-0.12684056162834167,
-0.38099753856658936,
-0.11147814989089966,
-0.2673036754131317,
0.1650627851486206,
0.7494516372680664,
0.39973387122154236,
-0.9601570963859558,
-0.433986097574234,
-0.008534345775842667,
-0.1595946103334427,
0.23535385727882385,
0.6190292835235596,
-0.2766195237636566,
0.21629470586776733,
0.5319869518280029,
0.5966086387634277,
0.08095473796129227,
0.5632394552230835,
0.3283258080482483,
-0.7714217305183411,
-0.07996831089258194,
0.24677406251430511,
0.42652320861816406,
0.8006510138511658,
0.03631618618965149,
0.3893444836139679,
0.2555813789367676,
-0.5616929531097412,
-0.7253761291503906,
-0.01448744721710682,
-1.091415524482727,
-0.1164921447634697,
1.7455564737319946,
-0.06658803671598434,
-0.09392686933279037,
-0.2010100781917572,
-0.36205923557281494,
0.24998624622821808,
-0.6988412737846375,
0.8853168487548828,
0.9738828539848328,
0.060814134776592255,
-0.15648385882377625,
-0.7365105748176575,
0.4997508227825165,
0.07983249425888062,
-0.5045254230499268,
0.28719595074653625,
0.552674412727356,
0.059672512114048004,
0.2832498252391815,
0.8247739672660828,
-0.08353520184755325,
0.027820037677884102,
-0.27442774176597595,
0.16776421666145325,
0.36536484956741333,
0.15884888172149658,
-0.37284472584724426,
0.10805555433034897,
0.5065126419067383,
-0.03605942055583
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.07476v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.07476v2
|
VideoLLaMA 2: Advancing Spatial-Temporal Modeling and Audio Understanding in Video-LLMs
| 2024-06-11T17:22:23 | 2024-06-17T16:40:43 |
Zesen Cheng, Sicong Leng, Hang Zhang, Yifei Xin, Xin Li, Guanzheng Chen, Yongxin Zhu, Wenqi Zhang, Ziyang Luo, Deli Zhao, Lidong Bing
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
In this paper, we present the VideoLLaMA 2, a set of Video Large Language
Models (Video-LLMs) designed to enhance spatial-temporal modeling and audio
understanding in video and audio-oriented tasks. Building upon its predecessor,
VideoLLaMA 2 incorporates a tailor-made Spatial-Temporal Convolution (STC)
connector, which effectively captures the intricate spatial and temporal
dynamics of video data. Additionally, we integrate an Audio Branch into the
model through joint training, thereby enriching the multimodal understanding
capabilities of the model by seamlessly incorporating audio cues. Comprehensive
evaluations on multiple-choice video question answering (MC-VQA), open-ended
video question answering (OE-VQA), and video captioning (VC) tasks demonstrate
that VideoLLaMA 2 consistently achieves competitive results among open-source
models and even gets close to some proprietary models on several benchmarks.
Furthermore, VideoLLaMA 2 exhibits reasonable improvements in audio-only and
audio-video question-answering (AQA & OE-AVQA) benchmarks over existing models.
These advancements underline VideoLLaMA 2's superior performance in multimodal
comprehension, setting a new standard for intelligent video analysis systems.
All models are public to facilitate further research.
|
[
-0.32187241315841675,
-1.100291132926941,
0.8188462853431702,
0.45969268679618835,
-0.11359578371047974,
-0.10591907054185867,
-0.4245646595954895,
-0.45983898639678955,
-0.1176760122179985,
0.43001890182495117,
-0.7578006386756897,
-0.5941901206970215,
-0.8400143980979919,
-0.4938439130783081,
-0.5157620310783386,
0.4444642961025238,
-0.2829371392726898,
0.38554492592811584,
-0.3197746276855469,
-0.2773961126804352,
-0.6747648119926453,
-0.2080634981393814,
-0.5318504571914673,
-0.30896249413490295,
0.3253578543663025,
0.4340651035308838,
0.7139111161231995,
0.5299508571624756,
0.6729552745819092,
0.31311407685279846,
-0.03326937556266785,
0.2157890647649765,
-0.26584431529045105,
0.10790828615427017,
-0.09733584523200989,
-0.35809895396232605,
-0.6422066688537598,
-0.1304033249616623,
0.7778980731964111,
0.6810532212257385,
-0.15517348051071167,
0.46255308389663696,
-0.1624232679605484,
0.42762327194213867,
-0.6801177859306335,
0.20149114727973938,
-0.5563880205154419,
0.2565743625164032,
0.08318845927715302,
-0.46096697449684143,
-0.36913737654685974,
-0.04497146978974342,
0.24181224405765533,
-0.7529749870300293,
0.15073342621326447,
-0.2643197476863861,
0.5170841217041016,
0.5177342891693115,
-0.5304670333862305,
-0.12638969719409943,
-1.1065828800201416,
0.5974442362785339,
-0.4033569097518921,
0.7986465096473694,
0.5317115783691406,
0.8834320902824402,
0.056585852056741714,
-0.7288516163825989,
-0.5530461668968201,
-0.012945383787155151,
0.4756786823272705,
0.32392069697380066,
-0.2523569166660309,
0.034814681857824326,
0.059514742344617844,
0.1079196035861969,
-1.0279430150985718,
0.3303898870944977,
-0.4856150448322296,
0.20349998772144318,
0.5342478156089783,
0.3288356363773346,
0.2600194811820984,
0.079244464635849,
-0.4445209503173828,
-0.059531521052122116,
-0.6291921138763428,
0.12356788665056229,
-0.01623731292784214,
-0.15694670379161835,
-0.3456187844276428,
0.6098297834396362,
-0.02814272604882717,
0.4674983024597168,
-0.40936845541000366,
-0.27817294001579285,
-0.042342886328697205,
-0.5489030480384827,
-0.5432268381118774,
-0.13261720538139343,
0.524070143699646,
0.46427667140960693,
0.09224949777126312,
0.22699697315692902,
0.2665107250213623,
0.01791166514158249,
0.059012774378061295,
-0.47722694277763367,
-0.28173884749412537,
0.1937437653541565,
-0.5148102045059204,
0.2516959607601166,
0.03302675858139992,
-0.8017932176589966,
-0.15509340167045593,
-0.5349992513656616,
0.5590780377388,
-0.1036304160952568,
-0.3662146329879761,
0.4238603711128235,
0.0615372359752655,
0.3393850326538086,
0.7465654015541077,
-1.0555802583694458,
0.4433918595314026,
0.8061310052871704,
0.9651634693145752,
0.020452547818422318,
-0.397571861743927,
-0.6507179737091064,
0.4072566330432892,
-0.37745580077171326,
0.7083817720413208,
-0.43974754214286804,
-0.17194515466690063,
0.1835731416940689,
-0.03936968743801117,
0.16585952043533325,
-0.5864968299865723,
-0.014863282442092896,
-0.6443966627120972,
0.1802603304386139,
-0.12315748631954193,
-0.1473296731710434,
-0.5091528296470642,
0.19795621931552887,
-0.5853150486946106,
1.1383014917373657,
-0.17961660027503967,
-0.04191320389509201,
0.21203584969043732,
-0.6010192632675171,
0.04693131148815155,
-0.2051999866962433,
-0.17746496200561523,
-0.1812404990196228,
0.019026432186365128,
0.2491263896226883,
0.07817099243402481,
-0.3554893732070923,
0.4350427985191345,
-0.4498010575771332,
-0.2503018081188202,
0.23767925798892975,
-0.44274550676345825,
0.26530221104621887,
0.30332082509994507,
-0.11955402046442032,
0.21870897710323334,
-0.38529500365257263,
-0.16727566719055176,
-0.023519106209278107,
-0.08629129827022552,
0.15051093697547913,
0.17870396375656128,
0.25837624073028564,
0.4245845079421997,
0.1497766226530075,
-0.27806106209754944,
-0.024197248741984367,
-0.11465528607368469,
0.47356364130973816,
0.6268731951713562,
-0.1663365662097931,
0.5795469880104065,
-0.0736779198050499,
0.5853134393692017,
-0.02513384446501732,
0.32788679003715515,
-0.3298027217388153,
-0.476749449968338,
-0.49450016021728516,
-0.19523338973522186,
-0.31639063358306885,
0.5379635691642761,
-0.50262451171875,
-0.12475034594535828,
-0.32699164748191833,
-0.5790530443191528,
-0.3487982749938965,
0.39098289608955383,
0.23098106682300568,
0.20971104502677917,
0.5007851123809814,
-0.2301272749900818,
-0.7655447125434875,
-0.6758668422698975,
0.1319691389799118,
-0.42937150597572327,
-0.1588706225156784,
0.4926885962486267,
0.4089677333831787,
-0.29461902379989624,
0.8431028127670288,
-0.4315180778503418,
-0.31061312556266785,
-0.3711741268634796,
0.07337898761034012,
0.09489171952009201,
0.1029825285077095,
0.5575695037841797,
-0.6299980282783508,
-0.14734411239624023,
-0.07698719203472137,
-0.8834768533706665,
-0.14945119619369507,
-0.0638980120420456,
0.1114296019077301,
-0.09552431106567383,
0.5406622290611267,
-0.5211835503578186,
0.290865033864975,
0.669116735458374,
-0.3073170781135559,
0.4776040017604828,
-0.30344223976135254,
0.3230748772621155,
-0.7900820374488831,
-0.2428932636976242,
0.08857544511556625,
-0.1008390337228775,
-0.5774508714675903,
0.1435924768447876,
-0.24276597797870636,
-0.28732454776763916,
-0.9053939580917358,
0.4728286564350128,
-0.19739024341106415,
-0.7894794940948486,
-0.3210744261741638,
0.47390785813331604,
-0.06768907606601715,
0.5327541828155518,
0.3481793701648712,
0.7222551107406616,
0.6044846177101135,
-0.3857901990413666,
0.5973266363143921,
0.2841687798500061,
-0.5644853711128235,
0.05617827922105789,
-0.6657932996749878,
0.012802516110241413,
-0.2527424693107605,
0.22007648646831512,
-1.2681838274002075,
-0.1826867163181305,
0.021356727927923203,
-0.5387817621231079,
-0.11498382687568665,
-0.2738628685474396,
-0.5174680352210999,
-0.050402067601680756,
-0.12138867378234863,
0.7223355174064636,
0.3289693593978882,
-0.627373456954956,
0.5210865139961243,
0.5049606561660767,
-0.4351377785205841,
-0.22325658798217773,
-0.7269289493560791,
0.06637389212846756,
-0.29091814160346985,
-0.8618608117103577,
0.1392882615327835,
-0.021611275151371956,
-0.39097848534584045,
-0.1789425015449524,
-0.16306611895561218,
-0.4931226372718811,
-0.06827246397733688,
0.30056554079055786,
0.24637828767299652,
-0.4557362198829651,
0.10557442903518677,
0.003068784484639764,
-0.06573276966810226,
0.19814103841781616,
-0.30566540360450745,
0.5148285031318665,
-0.01249728910624981,
-0.4009934961795807,
-0.5158498883247375,
0.5960462093353271,
0.5448504686355591,
-0.3405473828315735,
0.24409213662147522,
0.8604876399040222,
-0.5499258041381836,
-0.032775312662124634,
-0.60458904504776,
-0.11345590651035309,
-0.4565894603729248,
0.9444708228111267,
-0.16855628788471222,
-1.1492903232574463,
0.3192099630832672,
0.034542493522167206,
0.08274196088314056,
-0.02979443594813347,
0.9280363917350769,
-0.5081557035446167,
0.9743044376373291,
0.528459906578064,
0.22899027168750763,
0.7366198301315308,
-0.32446935772895813,
-0.02864469774067402,
-0.5089927911758423,
-0.6478846669197083,
-0.2994656562805176,
-0.35949763655662537,
-0.08929664641618729,
-0.8321556448936462,
0.5249963998794556,
0.04846698418259621,
-0.3194592595100403,
0.3373924493789673,
0.05719291418790817,
0.41668325662612915,
0.16960515081882477,
-0.05236594378948212,
0.19051390886306763,
0.28690266609191895,
0.3642553985118866,
-0.3843502998352051,
-0.6442089080810547,
-0.5084543228149414,
0.8732680082321167,
0.8409364819526672,
0.8597543239593506,
0.7364490628242493,
-0.12075638771057129,
0.28895363211631775,
-0.4411478042602539,
-0.7039837837219238,
0.7221006155014038,
-0.2562839388847351,
-0.297112375497818,
-0.16377317905426025,
-0.05383634194731712,
-0.6334804892539978,
0.26357102394104004,
0.03497153893113136,
-0.7808845639228821,
-0.03440499305725098,
0.14819058775901794,
-0.5468124151229858,
0.2750227749347687,
-0.4483988881111145,
0.7849459648132324,
-0.36996185779571533,
-0.45819324254989624,
-0.6889030933380127,
-0.4247893691062927,
0.3769654929637909,
0.2981538474559784,
0.262546569108963,
-0.1618778556585312,
-0.15134935081005096,
0.6991899013519287,
-0.12376519292593002,
0.4950994849205017,
-0.2094753235578537,
-0.20716065168380737,
0.47778499126434326,
0.3081721365451813,
0.07771788537502289,
0.614708423614502,
0.35747021436691284,
0.24650250375270844,
0.09684757888317108,
-0.07128280401229858,
-0.9219664335250854,
0.5939619541168213,
-0.792331874370575,
-0.4839155673980713,
-0.19596228003501892,
-0.8412421345710754,
-0.1413334608078003,
-0.24956214427947998,
-0.15278863906860352,
0.6446711421012878,
0.03306088224053383,
0.25918900966644287,
0.9422643184661865,
-0.35562679171562195,
0.49939316511154175,
0.648377001285553,
-0.4392322897911072,
-0.4765704274177551,
0.48784494400024414,
-0.2038770616054535,
0.22893820703029633,
0.6058117747306824,
-0.3342047929763794,
-0.44788870215415955,
-0.5272968411445618,
-0.16728270053863525,
0.15321098268032074,
-0.7018616199493408,
0.14424285292625427,
-0.5846839547157288,
-0.20967727899551392,
-0.4473503828048706,
0.01914294995367527,
-0.48704734444618225,
-0.41563230752944946,
-0.38000351190567017,
-0.33341866731643677,
0.23029571771621704,
0.6025239825248718,
-0.0897330716252327,
0.6067929863929749,
-0.7752606272697449,
0.506630539894104,
0.6107302904129028,
0.09049505740404129,
-0.2985740005970001,
-0.9587863087654114,
-0.47656962275505066,
-0.1372300237417221,
-0.4275379180908203,
-0.8768841624259949,
0.3442322313785553,
0.2516718804836273,
0.32267987728118896,
0.4509654939174652,
-0.8232913017272949,
1.0780898332595825,
-0.6301459074020386,
1.0387157201766968,
0.20993658900260925,
-0.7957723140716553,
0.7697197198867798,
-0.4783892035484314,
0.47108009457588196,
0.28652092814445496,
0.05485854670405388,
-0.6505722999572754,
-0.12567150592803955,
-0.12720239162445068,
-0.6627072095870972,
0.6846314072608948,
0.04599134624004364,
-0.10348232090473175,
0.25412797927856445,
0.17363950610160828,
0.05450865253806114,
-0.08945819735527039,
-0.5900168418884277,
0.05089288577437401,
-0.3419298529624939,
-0.041836511343717575,
-0.27928945422172546,
-0.5261881947517395,
0.05025392398238182,
-0.27589356899261475,
0.4674898087978363,
-0.10512053221464157,
0.5278154611587524,
0.17614927887916565,
-0.4403138756752014,
-0.18992182612419128,
0.317577064037323,
1.0488039255142212,
0.6915809512138367,
-0.2720601558685303,
0.35706257820129395,
0.40987536311149597,
-0.45417657494544983,
0.3204514980316162,
-0.1775306612253189,
0.30140745639801025,
0.22507666051387787,
0.6447917222976685,
0.9380908012390137,
0.6221619844436646,
-0.9547585844993591,
0.3855929672718048,
0.1497223824262619,
-0.40630239248275757,
-0.6940611600875854,
0.008630030788481236,
0.011455732397735119,
0.6406674981117249,
0.3698171377182007,
-0.18293723464012146,
0.23703151941299438,
-0.6162254810333252,
0.25176987051963806,
0.3627534508705139,
-0.3920266628265381,
-0.5698023438453674,
1.0089550018310547,
-0.12497802078723907,
-0.20695050060749054,
0.45783448219299316,
0.2667326033115387,
-0.18152225017547607,
0.7021808624267578,
0.5030087232589722,
0.6472690105438232,
-0.11093529313802719,
0.25545734167099,
0.49188709259033203,
0.3970701992511749,
-0.12875334918498993,
0.4885629117488861,
-0.383226215839386,
-0.32858213782310486,
-0.5462278127670288,
-0.2610069811344147,
-0.24416908621788025,
0.2947148084640503,
-0.8071999549865723,
0.27282485365867615,
-0.4690872132778168,
-0.21466629207134247,
-0.20009745657444,
-0.057155791670084,
-0.5398271083831787,
0.06261447817087173,
0.4541853964328766,
1.1611498594284058,
-0.8312088251113892,
1.105331301689148,
0.7740727663040161,
-0.23194162547588348,
-0.4001232087612152,
-0.4398932158946991,
0.29554569721221924,
-0.6244074702262878,
0.8283731341362,
-0.0684436559677124,
-0.1643156260251999,
-0.31680041551589966,
-0.3199136555194855,
-0.9840526580810547,
1.5093398094177246,
0.3873501121997833,
-0.7716042995452881,
-0.22909919917583466,
0.40036311745643616,
0.42939260601997375,
-0.23134072124958038,
0.5778405070304871,
0.5891150236129761,
0.2824285328388214,
0.11255159974098206,
-1.024843454360962,
-0.6748774647712708,
-0.23508809506893158,
0.11511663347482681,
0.0458056814968586,
-0.4512850344181061,
0.650766134262085,
-0.31588712334632874,
0.02435845322906971,
0.23699776828289032,
0.932639479637146,
0.44506287574768066,
0.6226083636283875,
0.31778714060783386,
0.5595487952232361,
0.19821229577064514,
-0.29439273476600647,
0.47863346338272095,
0.24649007618427277,
0.2798432409763336,
1.5265965461730957,
-0.22155018150806427,
1.0025603771209717,
0.6871188879013062,
-0.24454748630523682,
0.3664250075817108,
0.7481907606124878,
-0.05107875540852547,
0.6262125372886658,
-0.20489200949668884,
-0.4068465530872345,
-0.6145361065864563,
-0.08319474756717682,
-0.454513281583786,
0.7474935054779053,
0.4241148829460144,
-0.1012326180934906,
-0.37806522846221924,
0.22884635627269745,
-0.3332361876964569,
0.288798451423645,
-0.4779464304447174,
0.8956873416900635,
0.13829506933689117,
-0.5037044882774353,
0.002562830224633217,
0.09502068907022476,
0.22043736279010773,
-0.8626808524131775,
-0.01871935836970806,
-0.22966253757476807,
0.11286425590515137,
-0.1157669648528099,
-0.9820592403411865,
0.4327488839626312,
0.2889922857284546,
-0.44932129979133606,
-0.29747188091278076,
0.3380974531173706,
-0.931491494178772,
-0.1402350217103958,
0.5581527948379517,
0.2950161397457123,
0.11181634664535522,
0.19148796796798706,
-0.5550519824028015,
0.37970152497291565,
-0.45124372839927673,
0.15355972945690155,
0.232522115111351,
0.07616566866636276,
-0.03832656517624855,
0.6999269723892212,
0.42945218086242676,
0.06344388425350189,
0.14445528388023376,
0.2884973883628845,
0.28039446473121643,
-0.48195546865463257,
-0.5937814116477966,
-0.8461523652076721,
0.3583240509033203,
0.36667966842651367,
0.13997124135494232,
0.7778966426849365,
0.6035340428352356,
0.9280979633331299,
-0.1566765457391739,
0.38855648040771484,
0.3738803267478943,
0.027076663449406624,
-0.9238587617874146,
0.40094009041786194,
-0.6643772125244141,
0.30887192487716675,
-0.2795678675174713,
-0.8938296437263489,
-0.34403347969055176,
0.464061439037323,
-0.35925161838531494,
-0.011642026714980602,
0.6465432643890381,
0.9547426700592041,
-0.10591462254524231,
-0.003991851583123207,
0.2551543116569519,
0.2511274814605713,
0.4933358132839203,
1.1135200262069702,
1.0571489334106445,
-0.6156035661697388,
0.6995474100112915,
-0.05751490965485573,
-0.10487397015094757,
-0.1948380172252655,
-0.5301072001457214,
-0.6621704697608948,
-0.7954556345939636,
-0.4168698787689209,
0.04929239675402641,
0.10724271088838577,
0.8589433431625366,
0.9050235152244568,
-0.5143995881080627,
-0.6621332764625549,
0.20427316427230835,
-0.038207899779081345,
-0.2677377462387085,
-0.14295324683189392,
0.054638754576444626,
0.11650773882865906,
-0.7428627610206604,
0.9573231935501099,
0.7428043484687805,
-0.12291763722896576,
-0.34072965383529663,
-0.4952338933944702,
-0.29600000381469727,
0.032640233635902405,
0.8706898093223572,
0.32486310601234436,
-1.0010972023010254,
-0.20598457753658295,
0.030345454812049866,
0.05524984374642372,
0.07625910639762878,
0.9656375050544739,
-0.5523872375488281,
0.6931124925613403,
0.634210467338562,
0.40097731351852417,
0.7045432925224304,
-0.19840753078460693,
0.43689340353012085,
-0.575351893901825,
0.4882861375808716,
-0.0832052007317543,
0.4949870705604553,
0.11058208346366882,
0.062349963933229446,
0.41885194182395935,
0.04222577437758446,
-0.4359547793865204,
-0.8365129828453064,
0.4123041033744812,
-1.3382315635681152,
-0.2880358099937439,
1.289591670036316,
0.05092364922165871,
0.045915570110082626,
-0.02539507858455181,
-0.061662301421165466,
0.3659522533416748,
-0.10856185108423233,
0.5302333235740662,
0.5650279521942139,
0.19708141684532166,
-0.6798654794692993,
-0.9854751825332642,
0.11802346259355545,
0.6009057760238647,
-0.864847719669342,
-0.11361757665872574,
0.5755691528320312,
0.23753228783607483,
-0.2748577296733856,
0.7204087376594543,
-0.33605337142944336,
1.1067430973052979,
-0.341938853263855,
-0.23000101745128632,
-0.39701318740844727,
-0.9586321711540222,
-0.7031430006027222,
0.22881340980529785,
-0.031722452491521835,
-0.3573368191719055
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.07466v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.07466v1
|
Multimodal Belief Prediction
| 2024-06-11T17:12:41 | 2024-06-11T17:12:41 |
John Murzaku, Adil Soubki, Owen Rambow
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
Recognizing a speaker's level of commitment to a belief is a difficult task;
humans do not only interpret the meaning of the words in context, but also
understand cues from intonation and other aspects of the audio signal. Many
papers and corpora in the NLP community have approached the belief prediction
task using text-only approaches. We are the first to frame and present results
on the multimodal belief prediction task. We use the CB-Prosody corpus (CBP),
containing aligned text and audio with speaker belief annotations. We first
report baselines and significant features using acoustic-prosodic features and
traditional machine learning methods. We then present text and audio baselines
for the CBP corpus fine-tuning on BERT and Whisper respectively. Finally, we
present our multimodal architecture which fine-tunes on BERT and Whisper and
uses multiple fusion methods, improving on both modalities alone.
|
[
-0.6690390706062317,
-0.49530187249183655,
0.7565104365348816,
0.3804912865161896,
-0.15177972614765167,
-0.018017031252384186,
-0.4211832582950592,
-0.582966685295105,
0.4399937093257904,
0.2916209399700165,
-0.8001444935798645,
-0.588625967502594,
-0.771195113658905,
0.08112957328557968,
0.09841251373291016,
0.6433969736099243,
0.34978699684143066,
0.1115492507815361,
-0.2778263986110687,
0.049320582300424576,
-0.8604352474212646,
-0.3646116256713867,
-0.43883228302001953,
-0.4009443521499634,
0.4016156494617462,
0.5271186828613281,
0.8089311122894287,
0.09291940182447433,
0.13466776907444,
0.21766437590122223,
-0.11093562841415405,
0.18543054163455963,
0.2323470562696457,
0.39110267162323,
-0.12333860248327255,
-0.5371022820472717,
-0.3193137049674988,
0.16430729627609253,
0.6223642230033875,
0.5052831768989563,
0.004493470769375563,
-0.2033732384443283,
0.002882932545617223,
0.1844453364610672,
-0.46801257133483887,
0.4061727523803711,
-0.8987006545066833,
0.1404470056295395,
-0.11926037818193436,
-0.33626803755760193,
-0.7112336754798889,
-0.1932859569787979,
0.2604747414588928,
-0.3687424659729004,
0.37748396396636963,
0.23171795904636383,
0.4851493537425995,
0.2402769923210144,
-0.7490136027336121,
-0.3770957887172699,
-0.47118160128593445,
0.9090903401374817,
-0.5310851335525513,
0.7696532607078552,
0.9999173283576965,
0.1197672113776207,
-0.27852413058280945,
-0.14614205062389374,
-0.9075286388397217,
-0.2999557554721832,
-0.08527456969022751,
0.27578747272491455,
0.11608513444662094,
0.25119248032569885,
0.050702888518571854,
0.13545440137386322,
-0.615646481513977,
-0.11188630014657974,
0.103617362678051,
-0.39654937386512756,
0.3610067069530487,
-0.18478111922740936,
-0.09219180792570114,
-0.6454903483390808,
-0.5041100382804871,
-0.36477765440940857,
-0.2228097915649414,
0.14015039801597595,
0.013466271571815014,
0.314188688993454,
-0.0659695640206337,
0.5366048216819763,
0.07630061358213425,
0.4594697654247284,
0.08435075730085373,
-0.5949316620826721,
0.5007629990577698,
-0.21223796904087067,
-0.14695996046066284,
0.504967987537384,
0.8314767479896545,
0.35432156920433044,
0.05452272295951843,
0.0956863984465599,
-0.015999775379896164,
0.4953535497188568,
0.11947112530469894,
-0.3230235278606415,
-0.07338352501392365,
0.4590284824371338,
-0.5481575727462769,
0.013205137103796005,
-0.052612755447626114,
-0.6957526206970215,
-0.6523202657699585,
-0.27054473757743835,
0.42719951272010803,
-0.9485864043235779,
-0.6383455395698547,
0.039359718561172485,
-0.25823208689689636,
-0.24364106357097626,
0.4697485864162445,
-1.3491805791854858,
0.08950329571962357,
0.566307544708252,
0.7610852122306824,
0.05961611866950989,
-0.2404109388589859,
-0.3560357391834259,
0.3278822600841522,
-0.32081809639930725,
0.9500759243965149,
-0.8322062492370605,
-0.5808345675468445,
-0.001271545304916799,
0.04795007407665253,
-0.20745813846588135,
-0.31973326206207275,
0.9056277871131897,
-0.12190071493387222,
0.03656144440174103,
-0.3635435402393341,
-0.782824695110321,
-0.2761310636997223,
0.2877017557621002,
-0.6028000712394714,
0.6841177344322205,
-0.13365493714809418,
-0.7218063473701477,
0.5831072926521301,
-0.4976625442504883,
-0.24768708646297455,
-0.13410766422748566,
-0.2329009622335434,
-0.19365699589252472,
0.3568183481693268,
0.2855587899684906,
0.6093360781669617,
0.10662317276000977,
0.2681610882282257,
-0.5362253189086914,
0.033111821860075,
0.35275721549987793,
-0.5888453722000122,
0.31633684039115906,
0.13271598517894745,
-0.13172419369220734,
0.18154437839984894,
-0.7879682183265686,
0.04948252812027931,
-0.295311838388443,
-0.041023362427949905,
-0.22032976150512695,
0.5022029876708984,
0.13321560621261597,
0.25683194398880005,
0.1194969117641449,
-0.8576152920722961,
0.2500062584877014,
-0.5751866698265076,
0.2125389128923416,
0.7925266623497009,
0.011847399175167084,
0.20270021259784698,
-0.11398357152938843,
0.3598726689815521,
0.06719379127025604,
0.16661614179611206,
-0.4110073745250702,
-0.8915033340454102,
-0.32086941599845886,
-0.24387432634830475,
0.34455713629722595,
0.42721423506736755,
-0.37146925926208496,
0.31327149271965027,
0.07761026918888092,
-0.5807662606239319,
-0.5693151354789734,
-0.005416356027126312,
0.3791600167751312,
0.3377681076526642,
0.5755720734596252,
-0.1608404666185379,
-0.6815374493598938,
-0.9800451397895813,
-0.06471706926822662,
-0.6232765913009644,
-0.035424213856458664,
-0.02631302736699581,
0.36863163113594055,
-0.3063035309314728,
0.908022403717041,
-0.5212087035179138,
-0.6925337910652161,
0.0924215242266655,
0.5533941388130188,
0.32424646615982056,
0.4691304862499237,
0.3877110481262207,
-1.0939056873321533,
-0.4046560227870941,
0.20400087535381317,
-0.5632013082504272,
0.3745657503604889,
-0.15249097347259521,
0.3406868875026703,
0.12953515350818634,
0.2426498532295227,
-0.6848184466362,
0.35739776492118835,
0.9297740459442139,
-0.44945526123046875,
0.5739949345588684,
-0.11153777688741684,
0.20630674064159393,
-1.2239181995391846,
-0.6424803137779236,
0.20796363055706024,
-0.24590082466602325,
-0.3994097411632538,
-0.5684633255004883,
0.1984986513853073,
0.11384359747171402,
-0.0694417878985405,
0.2776213586330414,
-0.225341796875,
-0.20025070011615753,
-0.2664092183113098,
0.2130236029624939,
-0.0826755091547966,
0.4162210524082184,
0.7756015658378601,
0.5687052607536316,
0.6191020607948303,
-0.3409728705883026,
0.2717226445674896,
0.707000732421875,
-0.542138397693634,
0.49151161313056946,
-0.41886624693870544,
0.07547982782125473,
-0.09606865048408508,
0.30420783162117004,
-1.3764609098434448,
-0.19433516263961792,
-0.07923676818609238,
-0.9393682479858398,
0.45037445425987244,
-0.08648965507745743,
-0.604682445526123,
-0.03225397318601608,
0.06135788559913635,
0.11302345246076584,
0.10411742329597473,
-0.24735049903392792,
0.7414471507072449,
0.35914862155914307,
-0.5214913487434387,
-0.5392289161682129,
-0.3765449821949005,
0.17464148998260498,
0.15195684134960175,
-0.6339364051818848,
0.71200031042099,
-0.2773713171482086,
-0.17859888076782227,
-0.14573726058006287,
-0.09031402319669724,
0.04027688503265381,
-0.19968761503696442,
0.605292797088623,
0.26522383093833923,
-0.04388807713985443,
0.569252610206604,
0.272076278924942,
-0.4244166910648346,
-0.005562096834182739,
-0.2476166933774948,
0.40414509177207947,
-0.22447174787521362,
-0.4824714660644531,
-0.5674970149993896,
0.5709876418113708,
0.5027068257331848,
-0.18811041116714478,
0.815580427646637,
0.8407036662101746,
-0.3432687222957611,
0.04493624344468117,
-0.6834093928337097,
-0.09615429490804672,
-0.42645522952079773,
0.323025107383728,
-0.538165807723999,
-0.7997462153434753,
0.12319588661193848,
-0.07501085847616196,
-0.17606611549854279,
0.3158351182937622,
0.7131771445274353,
-0.5160509943962097,
1.297272801399231,
0.860496461391449,
0.17529256641864777,
0.4221749007701874,
0.1478479951620102,
-0.04280831292271614,
-0.512833297252655,
-0.4519979953765869,
-0.44251132011413574,
-0.2708289325237274,
-0.6949247717857361,
-0.29158514738082886,
0.7089946269989014,
0.16144870221614838,
0.22647394239902496,
0.39784467220306396,
-0.38457655906677246,
0.019409455358982086,
0.591605544090271,
0.037399955093860626,
0.05958233401179314,
-0.2362113744020462,
-0.2987390458583832,
-0.3965737521648407,
-0.21348030865192413,
-0.38358274102211,
0.9175191521644592,
0.4385432004928589,
0.21635811030864716,
0.247937873005867,
0.5777574181556702,
0.5292045474052429,
0.12515628337860107,
-0.8153634667396545,
0.31367337703704834,
0.12814782559871674,
-0.8924935460090637,
-0.17761246860027313,
-0.020645935088396072,
-0.6413792967796326,
0.40058550238609314,
-0.8185217380523682,
-0.7355974316596985,
0.4531358778476715,
0.2334636002779007,
-0.2500533163547516,
-0.03173397108912468,
-0.9373998641967773,
0.8497046828269958,
-0.06841181218624115,
0.16988742351531982,
-0.5902206301689148,
-0.753204882144928,
-0.04902786388993263,
-0.006136891897767782,
0.4293966293334961,
-0.3228241503238678,
0.05269020423293114,
0.6800597310066223,
0.015871183946728706,
0.9349081516265869,
-0.4101102650165558,
-0.04440326616168022,
0.04730096831917763,
0.08304216712713242,
0.34749555587768555,
0.35735249519348145,
-0.169966921210289,
0.07411926984786987,
0.36469778418540955,
-0.329242080450058,
-0.5107367038726807,
0.42782357335090637,
-0.8021447062492371,
-0.449786901473999,
-0.5089504718780518,
-0.5018118023872375,
-0.8812782168388367,
0.11145064979791641,
0.24409575760364532,
0.49900057911872864,
-0.27722442150115967,
0.41310369968414307,
0.9036030769348145,
-0.09488049149513245,
0.5999100804328918,
0.24431206285953522,
-0.11599137634038925,
-0.6680262088775635,
0.7762117385864258,
-0.16228722035884857,
0.3428170680999756,
0.8238211274147034,
0.2820293605327606,
-0.822922945022583,
-0.6615126729011536,
-0.0986630991101265,
0.0329846553504467,
-0.7202574610710144,
-0.13267286121845245,
-0.601421058177948,
0.21934998035430908,
-0.705801784992218,
-0.027297809720039368,
-0.39535412192344666,
-0.28779247403144836,
-0.11308718472719193,
-0.31491658091545105,
0.2978878319263458,
0.5015160441398621,
-0.19381482899188995,
0.20651836693286896,
-0.9439613819122314,
0.5306529402732849,
0.3286009132862091,
0.17389065027236938,
-0.5089602470397949,
-0.279416024684906,
-0.27315548062324524,
0.24701957404613495,
-0.49770262837409973,
-1.0898722410202026,
0.49013522267341614,
0.48603203892707825,
0.4891895353794098,
0.5785424113273621,
0.24764569103717804,
0.5073432922363281,
-0.3669159710407257,
0.7244874835014343,
0.7472272515296936,
-1.052022099494934,
0.9906830191612244,
-0.32523152232170105,
-0.09171581268310547,
0.39962828159332275,
0.48297664523124695,
-0.5711227059364319,
-0.346021443605423,
-0.48350605368614197,
-0.3689683973789215,
0.5030146241188049,
0.1329715996980667,
-0.16853828728199005,
-0.19041620194911957,
-0.20478205382823944,
0.49840691685676575,
0.40950384736061096,
-0.6522126197814941,
-0.32194119691848755,
-0.7395281791687012,
-0.26453697681427,
-0.6114533543586731,
-0.3087906241416931,
-0.05916813015937805,
-0.3756825625896454,
0.43424686789512634,
-0.4568868577480316,
0.6112187504768372,
0.28845271468162537,
0.07254957407712936,
-0.18395693600177765,
0.5340420007705688,
0.8640727400779724,
0.6266555190086365,
-0.6537296175956726,
0.19877071678638458,
0.07605184614658356,
-0.37548255920410156,
0.0775383859872818,
-0.06453635543584824,
0.21869713068008423,
0.41360190510749817,
0.5940147042274475,
1.0364875793457031,
0.2252693921327591,
-0.6139244437217712,
0.5730593800544739,
-0.08010029047727585,
-0.4362023174762726,
-0.819855272769928,
-0.2735953629016876,
0.32613712549209595,
0.43741533160209656,
0.3644629418849945,
0.633778989315033,
-0.14314596354961395,
-0.8499575257301331,
0.12907777726650238,
0.28405213356018066,
-0.6983959674835205,
-0.5192224383354187,
0.6705741882324219,
-0.09385772794485092,
-0.15769849717617035,
0.3076077103614807,
-0.18132221698760986,
-0.4127332866191864,
0.16134296357631683,
0.7288056015968323,
0.8717417120933533,
-0.3198624849319458,
0.4011123478412628,
0.18042467534542084,
0.08214759081602097,
0.11863163858652115,
0.30870190262794495,
-0.2305736392736435,
-1.2522656917572021,
-0.5762903094291687,
-0.8732523322105408,
-0.7039260268211365,
-0.20330800116062164,
-0.6989277005195618,
0.3176444172859192,
-0.5429933071136475,
-0.5462108254432678,
0.5001831650733948,
0.06777330487966537,
-0.4533666670322418,
0.48391851782798767,
0.600247323513031,
0.8081160187721252,
-0.8803901076316833,
1.2393499612808228,
0.6818079352378845,
-0.4475179612636566,
-0.43358173966407776,
0.12700152397155762,
0.2566637396812439,
-0.7086628079414368,
0.6956698894500732,
0.14751116931438446,
-0.11323223263025284,
-0.32110732793807983,
-0.401409775018692,
-0.7154579758644104,
0.8635497093200684,
0.41111889481544495,
-0.6143987774848938,
0.08886516094207764,
-0.18198083341121674,
0.29393938183784485,
-0.3752392828464508,
0.31091615557670593,
0.22436819970607758,
0.8258735537528992,
0.076063372194767,
-1.183491826057434,
-0.3553565442562103,
-0.12829963862895966,
-0.12907510995864868,
0.0710655227303505,
-0.37505802512168884,
0.9096570611000061,
-0.05268481373786926,
0.02428554557263851,
-0.22514425218105316,
1.1714133024215698,
0.19118817150592804,
0.5311764478683472,
0.8888632655143738,
0.23705820739269257,
0.8604185581207275,
-0.17706425487995148,
0.7580247521400452,
-0.15837450325489044,
0.19667302072048187,
0.8703060150146484,
-0.23395468294620514,
1.2494693994522095,
0.45659127831459045,
-0.3870050013065338,
0.7342295050621033,
0.7485359311103821,
0.20526783168315887,
0.7125322818756104,
-0.5440274477005005,
-0.28312328457832336,
-0.566333532333374,
-0.30054569244384766,
-0.3562023639678955,
0.7974331974983215,
0.8053107857704163,
-0.19032728672027588,
0.2869434058666229,
0.26296505331993103,
-0.29103735089302063,
0.13610577583312988,
-0.24499909579753876,
0.749900758266449,
0.12839795649051666,
-0.7185027599334717,
0.5535993576049805,
-0.08676839619874954,
0.7885728478431702,
-0.6953458189964294,
-0.11956322938203812,
0.5405040383338928,
0.27124425768852234,
-0.25835713744163513,
-0.9450194239616394,
0.3200952708721161,
-0.6205509305000305,
-0.6107775568962097,
-0.4757775366306305,
0.7676939964294434,
-0.43049660325050354,
-0.20718646049499512,
0.5316476225852966,
0.20445382595062256,
-0.03137035295367241,
-0.4171641767024994,
-0.5430259108543396,
-0.06827741116285324,
0.17635826766490936,
-0.06978476792573929,
0.480379194021225,
0.434963583946228,
0.16853345930576324,
0.6650593280792236,
0.5848881602287292,
0.07797524333000183,
-0.13731837272644043,
0.058893654495477676,
0.6735820174217224,
-0.7358541488647461,
-0.5063300728797913,
-0.6094934344291687,
0.283853143453598,
0.08885052800178528,
-0.42468950152397156,
0.6524795889854431,
0.15026332437992096,
0.7212184071540833,
-0.10318698734045029,
0.8843924403190613,
0.0006750114262104034,
0.765000581741333,
-0.6938719749450684,
0.38246825337409973,
-0.47861555218696594,
-0.24730424582958221,
-0.5516605377197266,
-0.8994402289390564,
0.10822191089391708,
0.6371765732765198,
-0.05579829216003418,
-0.26918476819992065,
0.8935968279838562,
0.6316613554954529,
0.3573138415813446,
0.6086326241493225,
0.5779141783714294,
0.19377638399600983,
0.05649254843592644,
0.3826773464679718,
0.7950668334960938,
-0.10715681314468384,
0.4662620723247528,
-0.2686046063899994,
-0.2074480503797531,
-0.2143588662147522,
-0.8993709683418274,
-0.7271382212638855,
-1.032090187072754,
-0.17455267906188965,
-0.22167657315731049,
-0.25646302103996277,
1.108489990234375,
0.79818195104599,
-1.0452065467834473,
-0.0510738305747509,
0.1555536538362503,
0.07095538824796677,
-0.6889317631721497,
-0.18004173040390015,
0.22007907927036285,
-0.31391504406929016,
-0.6552215814590454,
0.9370400309562683,
0.36278796195983887,
-0.08383635431528091,
-0.15694008767604828,
-0.18459917604923248,
-0.32270386815071106,
-0.0776728168129921,
0.7336689829826355,
0.0017252241959795356,
-1.0094144344329834,
-0.5373385548591614,
-0.05275425314903259,
0.3310709595680237,
0.1450285166501999,
0.49408790469169617,
-0.7283793091773987,
0.6892765164375305,
0.3529427945613861,
0.07916208356618881,
0.5584118962287903,
-0.07116793841123581,
0.6563424468040466,
-1.0348682403564453,
0.13415122032165527,
0.47890618443489075,
0.6059377789497375,
0.19956336915493011,
-0.09990964084863663,
0.08176091313362122,
0.32763102650642395,
-0.46948572993278503,
-0.6948790550231934,
0.3756534159183502,
-1.342457890510559,
-0.2873975336551666,
0.8843913078308105,
-0.15132565796375275,
0.02935343235731125,
-0.47115209698677063,
-0.3405574560165405,
0.11978822946548462,
-0.675559937953949,
0.302219957113266,
0.8643580079078674,
-0.2675211727619171,
-0.3420513868331909,
-0.5840075016021729,
0.5308414101600647,
0.47666773200035095,
-0.16352950036525726,
0.0637255534529686,
0.4373363256454468,
-0.07554090768098831,
0.738070547580719,
0.6132650971412659,
0.24130958318710327,
0.026825211942195892,
0.35452258586883545,
0.2749055027961731,
0.04854549840092659,
-0.49576708674430847,
0.17533905804157257,
0.5457786917686462,
0.15880386531352997,
-0.2659836709499359
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10270v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10270v1
|
A Conceptual Framework For Trie-Augmented Neural Networks (TANNS)
| 2024-06-11T17:08:16 | 2024-06-11T17:08:16 |
Temitayo Adefemi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Trie-Augmented Neural Networks (TANNs) combine trie structures with neural
networks, forming a hierarchical design that enhances decision-making
transparency and efficiency in machine learning. This paper investigates the
use of TANNs for text and document classification, applying Recurrent Neural
Networks (RNNs) and Feed forward Neural Networks (FNNs). We evaluated TANNs on
the 20 NewsGroup and SMS Spam Collection datasets, comparing their performance
with traditional RNN and FFN Networks with and without dropout regularization.
The results show that TANNs achieve similar or slightly better performance in
text classification. The primary advantage of TANNs is their structured
decision-making process, which improves interpretability. We discuss
implementation challenges and practical limitations. Future work will aim to
refine the TANNs architecture for more complex classification tasks.
|
[
-0.29508817195892334,
-0.31038978695869446,
0.32499563694000244,
0.17853473126888275,
-0.029651518911123276,
0.24521449208259583,
-0.22196201980113983,
-0.5060622096061707,
-0.16659006476402283,
0.44839656352996826,
-0.1530391126871109,
-0.722883939743042,
-0.5930160284042358,
0.2720194458961487,
-0.7305651307106018,
1.2033966779708862,
0.011142417788505554,
-0.08562196046113968,
0.24378789961338043,
-0.11366386711597443,
-0.3629567623138428,
-0.4430602490901947,
-1.051766037940979,
-0.4016146659851074,
0.9501329660415649,
0.2235485166311264,
0.6374029517173767,
0.538457453250885,
0.5153466463088989,
0.45840534567832947,
-0.22314652800559998,
0.3654954433441162,
-0.08007635921239853,
0.10061072558164597,
-0.23732136189937592,
-0.5446135997772217,
0.07200063019990921,
0.0641983300447464,
0.5130189061164856,
0.34054499864578247,
0.1456626057624817,
-0.07276700437068939,
0.1794687658548355,
0.5661713480949402,
-0.7105839848518372,
0.13364844024181366,
0.02829950675368309,
0.36364105343818665,
-0.09393712878227234,
-0.26935267448425293,
-0.5781375765800476,
-0.7008379101753235,
0.5676537156105042,
-0.35477644205093384,
0.5134616494178772,
0.16576427221298218,
0.7558014392852783,
0.015011484734714031,
-0.2753251791000366,
-0.19416110217571259,
-0.6866498589515686,
0.5879610180854797,
-0.4748081862926483,
0.536399781703949,
0.2030744105577469,
0.12684334814548492,
-0.009467440657317638,
-0.9974858164787292,
-0.2640092372894287,
0.07003897428512573,
-0.2999633252620697,
0.0008721703197807074,
0.06871440261602402,
0.4457189738750458,
0.025140462443232536,
0.6181389689445496,
-0.2987527549266815,
0.1059122309088707,
-0.20616358518600464,
-0.12593385577201843,
0.35847538709640503,
-0.1110190823674202,
0.2832607328891754,
-0.39631426334381104,
-0.545454204082489,
0.065116748213768,
0.09964103996753693,
-0.17486713826656342,
-0.24952735006809235,
0.4401017129421234,
0.12584000825881958,
0.40640291571617126,
0.07356391102075577,
0.9175273180007935,
-0.0793856531381607,
-0.01002595480531454,
0.16766317188739777,
-0.38967442512512207,
-0.5556584596633911,
0.03931741788983345,
0.9552150964736938,
0.25509366393089294,
0.3558993637561798,
-0.392313688993454,
-0.2958611249923706,
-0.13273312151432037,
0.2478262037038803,
-0.6729459762573242,
0.0954868346452713,
-0.011989603750407696,
-0.48741474747657776,
-0.6967933773994446,
0.164332315325737,
-0.5495845079421997,
-0.6644521951675415,
-0.4381909668445587,
0.3436661958694458,
-0.4270918667316437,
-0.11272908002138138,
0.3512970209121704,
-0.4921875,
-0.1691332459449768,
0.4501180052757263,
-0.5489532351493835,
0.5521795749664307,
0.6829659342765808,
1.3184573650360107,
-0.18732932209968567,
-0.3190520107746124,
-0.19894786179065704,
-0.09725335240364075,
-0.20870642364025116,
0.5906103849411011,
-0.26729878783226013,
-0.2243814915418625,
0.16681432723999023,
-0.14384141564369202,
-0.2504623234272003,
-0.1999513953924179,
0.38557299971580505,
-0.8230746984481812,
0.6663538813591003,
0.14337265491485596,
-0.3916829526424408,
-0.5877089500427246,
0.4382147490978241,
-0.9926654696464539,
1.0157859325408936,
0.4047105014324188,
-0.9757121205329895,
0.2157595008611679,
-0.5411468148231506,
-0.5577095150947571,
-0.10299026221036911,
0.1151304617524147,
-0.5135364532470703,
-0.009108362719416618,
-0.1381043642759323,
0.8155348896980286,
-0.4545604884624481,
0.19605667889118195,
-0.019208509474992752,
-0.33937034010887146,
0.36230239272117615,
-0.5331446528434753,
0.6910926103591919,
0.3981436789035797,
-0.37045472860336304,
-0.12739057838916779,
-0.6442158818244934,
0.015293055213987827,
-0.47611895203590393,
-0.6404799222946167,
-0.4099808931350708,
-0.46487388014793396,
0.27325236797332764,
0.11864784359931946,
-0.09639661759138107,
-0.591652512550354,
-0.14228418469429016,
-0.43986091017723083,
0.4961833357810974,
0.452100545167923,
0.1552262306213379,
0.6898517608642578,
-0.7195096611976624,
0.04898819699883461,
0.05377325415611267,
-0.04196155443787575,
-0.04824535548686981,
-0.31583115458488464,
-0.7040238380432129,
-0.0984211415052414,
0.7019073963165283,
0.7189264893531799,
-1.010157823562622,
0.24916911125183105,
-0.3622693419456482,
-0.1560191959142685,
-0.2670780122280121,
-0.1544991284608841,
0.5286046862602234,
0.4133092761039734,
0.04951272904872894,
0.18497326970100403,
-0.5757333636283875,
-0.6140990853309631,
-0.4428260326385498,
-0.15431322157382965,
0.0017150341300293803,
0.24524956941604614,
0.20977599918842316,
-0.06944386661052704,
0.849341630935669,
0.0426921471953392,
-0.3076176047325134,
-0.08124499022960663,
0.5892710089683533,
-0.04899785667657852,
0.20233039557933807,
0.4157560169696808,
-1.3523316383361816,
-0.30296382308006287,
0.2666264474391937,
-0.6429164409637451,
0.005177282728254795,
-0.2604556679725647,
0.14769402146339417,
0.4746498167514801,
0.11787578463554382,
-0.3529265820980072,
0.735292375087738,
-0.005786905065178871,
-0.24265512824058533,
0.06729789078235626,
0.15447278320789337,
0.43550464510917664,
-1.2730120420455933,
-0.17068520188331604,
0.48870769143104553,
-0.5641902089118958,
-0.799898087978363,
-0.48033463954925537,
0.03578804060816765,
-0.16325165331363678,
-0.4356004595756531,
0.5656381845474243,
-0.28469809889793396,
-0.24092960357666016,
-0.2786862254142761,
0.08125593513250351,
0.33450135588645935,
0.49607452750205994,
0.34316474199295044,
0.6607680320739746,
0.035221464931964874,
-0.8278144001960754,
0.5090436339378357,
0.07102134823799133,
-0.23205143213272095,
0.2894188165664673,
-0.28134533762931824,
-0.15883950889110565,
-0.17254140973091125,
0.0484933964908123,
-0.830777108669281,
-0.086021289229393,
0.21829062700271606,
-0.5722912549972534,
0.5235844850540161,
0.2943287193775177,
-0.48825740814208984,
-0.42987051606178284,
-0.4628591537475586,
0.4024514853954315,
-0.17458344995975494,
-0.7513753175735474,
0.8227423429489136,
-0.06819228082895279,
0.10061382502317429,
-0.7991481423377991,
-1.1429481506347656,
0.10718955099582672,
0.10241351276636124,
-0.4705422520637512,
0.44366875290870667,
0.4345182478427887,
-0.007286279462277889,
0.25114506483078003,
-0.10898458957672119,
-0.15245206654071808,
0.007519437465816736,
0.19484840333461761,
0.06742419302463531,
-0.3046073019504547,
0.4896613359451294,
-0.3722233176231384,
-0.0726669430732727,
-0.2530519664287567,
-0.5924789905548096,
0.3835286498069763,
-0.5121206641197205,
0.17762045562267303,
-0.8074324131011963,
0.16665370762348175,
0.6325834393501282,
-0.0856291800737381,
0.7372605204582214,
0.5290418863296509,
-0.476260244846344,
-0.3419892191886902,
-0.7062196135520935,
0.09012410044670105,
-0.3970092535018921,
0.23465466499328613,
-0.1321966052055359,
-0.777592658996582,
0.17514373362064362,
-0.15958261489868164,
0.17293260991573334,
0.28613927960395813,
0.2705809772014618,
-0.22197066247463226,
0.3299182951450348,
0.5433765053749084,
-0.010803721845149994,
0.863079309463501,
-0.4852070212364197,
0.0011216233251616359,
-0.5941329002380371,
-0.5070054531097412,
-0.5228270292282104,
-0.49361249804496765,
-0.5941529273986816,
-0.28461700677871704,
-0.03277844935655594,
-0.283591628074646,
-0.542533814907074,
0.15481850504875183,
-0.7839316129684448,
0.547903835773468,
0.5668978095054626,
0.4011118412017822,
0.3155040144920349,
0.08915092051029205,
0.17434369027614594,
0.309939444065094,
-0.770073413848877,
-0.3943841755390167,
0.6785741448402405,
0.46074897050857544,
0.6634289026260376,
-0.24781686067581177,
0.6980790495872498,
0.6882498264312744,
0.6138712763786316,
-0.8876831531524658,
0.31949812173843384,
-0.5037416219711304,
-0.5843424201011658,
-0.23651981353759766,
-0.6474542021751404,
-0.6321471929550171,
0.10380230844020844,
-0.13472020626068115,
-0.4890384376049042,
0.6509929895401001,
-0.5291073322296143,
-0.560185968875885,
0.7962403893470764,
-0.8803471922874451,
0.5058076977729797,
-0.4076489806175232,
-0.10502080619335175,
0.23083141446113586,
-0.60785973072052,
0.16163264214992523,
0.18391303718090057,
0.003725453047081828,
0.3752644956111908,
-0.5621282458305359,
1.0308738946914673,
-0.1973518431186676,
0.9413530230522156,
0.1651332676410675,
0.27130016684532166,
0.384618878364563,
-0.10845967382192612,
0.024192489683628082,
-0.06272044032812119,
-0.4656963646411896,
0.18933260440826416,
-0.1704034060239792,
-0.09346730262041092,
-0.9033424854278564,
0.4752194881439209,
-0.8458293676376343,
-0.3306538760662079,
-0.7616267800331116,
-0.548239529132843,
-0.11137570440769196,
0.7072060108184814,
0.5001683831214905,
0.7004126310348511,
0.05461638793349266,
0.4805358350276947,
0.7992590665817261,
0.20775862038135529,
0.6586145758628845,
0.21056130528450012,
-0.32620298862457275,
-0.9248310923576355,
0.5826502442359924,
0.27219557762145996,
0.1514109969139099,
0.8259209990501404,
0.12754938006401062,
-0.3912602365016937,
-0.5666255354881287,
-0.1515440046787262,
0.0017045598942786455,
-0.6273330450057983,
-0.5797196626663208,
-0.47834035754203796,
-0.9293980002403259,
-0.09528841823339462,
-0.025241537019610405,
0.010324889793992043,
-0.5415411591529846,
-0.5826587080955505,
-0.11324415355920792,
0.36479446291923523,
0.9958553910255432,
0.11005668342113495,
0.792780876159668,
-0.9133507013320923,
0.5653552412986755,
0.09602130949497223,
0.7889360189437866,
0.08101986348628998,
-0.20238515734672546,
-0.3694933354854584,
-0.031289778649806976,
-0.10151920467615128,
-0.9404459595680237,
-0.0775865763425827,
0.13417242467403412,
0.28045544028282166,
0.171965092420578,
0.08579856902360916,
0.06941919028759003,
-0.0928099974989891,
0.405304491519928,
0.26440614461898804,
-0.7471820712089539,
0.33852243423461914,
-0.341413289308548,
-0.06700872629880905,
0.5034887194633484,
0.4514637589454651,
-0.6114461421966553,
0.09846047312021255,
-0.5966145992279053,
-0.16948451101779938,
1.1815173625946045,
0.5028321146965027,
-0.2812212407588959,
0.08268661051988602,
0.8614168167114258,
-0.09439697861671448,
0.4057907462120056,
-0.6521806716918945,
-0.2647910416126251,
-0.276105672121048,
-0.5084076523780823,
0.22820252180099487,
-0.26063090562820435,
0.09508610516786575,
0.09176052361726761,
0.5615339279174805,
0.260891854763031,
0.1395697444677353,
0.43146827816963196,
0.08044684678316116,
0.21452084183692932,
0.2359861433506012,
0.244291290640831,
0.16532959043979645,
-0.20703789591789246,
0.1283133327960968,
0.10025149583816528,
-0.5874598026275635,
0.3474465310573578,
0.06137474626302719,
-0.2692689597606659,
0.24716238677501678,
0.340028315782547,
0.801311194896698,
0.44904130697250366,
0.24977803230285645,
0.3705506920814514,
-0.41859301924705505,
-0.28432685136795044,
0.1020558550953865,
0.041710030287504196,
-0.20732033252716064,
0.2734033465385437,
0.19260133802890778,
0.5974720120429993,
0.20713981986045837,
-0.33300116658210754,
0.26240965723991394,
0.02887868322432041,
-0.16518600285053253,
0.19452479481697083,
0.07507230341434479,
0.3663310408592224,
-0.8355503678321838,
0.4129903018474579,
0.2134702354669571,
-0.7008576989173889,
0.5823589563369751,
0.5906229615211487,
1.1289602518081665,
-0.15017209947109222,
0.498162180185318,
0.015588400885462761,
0.2756255865097046,
-0.4008888006210327,
0.10714162886142731,
-0.2683008313179016,
-0.7129063606262207,
-0.10700756311416626,
-0.5652785897254944,
-0.32020506262779236,
0.1364143192768097,
-0.4491046071052551,
0.4011150896549225,
-0.8344778418540955,
-0.5555701851844788,
0.24880197644233704,
0.15869024395942688,
-0.4784550070762634,
0.5552988648414612,
0.16623333096504211,
1.1947879791259766,
-0.398493230342865,
0.35973820090293884,
0.6225549578666687,
-0.4100760519504547,
-0.5461726188659668,
-0.14918072521686554,
-0.1949329674243927,
-0.2954358756542206,
0.5928890705108643,
0.3740135431289673,
-0.396580308675766,
-0.040683645755052567,
-0.2767963707447052,
-0.701219916343689,
0.9805998206138611,
0.014217070303857327,
-0.4227977395057678,
-0.5358777046203613,
0.33973428606987,
0.6274259090423584,
-0.47049596905708313,
0.1659490168094635,
0.4226072430610657,
0.5287070870399475,
0.129365473985672,
-0.7189813256263733,
-0.20559467375278473,
-0.2876817584037781,
0.47375819087028503,
0.29563093185424805,
-0.6568049192428589,
0.6765740513801575,
0.12473677843809128,
-0.5178796052932739,
0.2776504158973694,
0.4626742899417877,
-0.19629411399364471,
0.7440361380577087,
0.3741287589073181,
0.6518948078155518,
0.8079070448875427,
-0.4614405333995819,
1.093224287033081,
0.18280471861362457,
0.2076525241136551,
0.8757277727127075,
0.2266896367073059,
0.5539806485176086,
-0.19034810364246368,
0.08019569516181946,
0.8179842233657837,
0.8165542483329773,
0.04555848240852356,
0.19329321384429932,
-0.0030477256514132023,
-0.4647071361541748,
-0.016131915152072906,
-0.20824871957302094,
-0.10863941162824631,
0.09607850760221481,
0.3782547414302826,
-0.49262329936027527,
-0.30996277928352356,
0.46133357286453247,
-0.060415856540203094,
0.12463001906871796,
-0.5400130748748779,
0.9542536735534668,
0.24631556868553162,
-0.3178618252277374,
0.37251782417297363,
0.07385962456464767,
0.6000214219093323,
-0.15679655969142914,
0.19650259613990784,
0.0875091627240181,
0.467479407787323,
-0.6791793704032898,
-1.2966028451919556,
0.22803670167922974,
0.007126313634216785,
-0.6788198947906494,
-0.2595444321632385,
1.1199997663497925,
-0.3629203736782074,
-0.44405901432037354,
0.24001599848270416,
0.2815287709236145,
-0.23403611779212952,
-0.048336129635572433,
-0.5256021618843079,
-0.27469193935394287,
-0.14218400418758392,
-0.2241489589214325,
-0.08743594586849213,
0.984857439994812,
-0.1465674489736557,
0.6123136281967163,
0.49418577551841736,
0.11476903408765793,
-0.003947846125811338,
0.18913662433624268,
0.6871312856674194,
-0.7916809916496277,
-0.6425299644470215,
-0.8591325879096985,
0.0922776535153389,
-0.3758469521999359,
-0.08454762399196625,
0.5363152027130127,
0.5037842392921448,
0.6600208282470703,
0.27746254205703735,
0.7791768908500671,
0.16892403364181519,
0.6544435024261475,
-0.36839041113853455,
0.75230473279953,
-0.426839679479599,
0.3615906238555908,
0.07225866615772247,
-0.6620172262191772,
-0.70875483751297,
0.24866986274719238,
-0.3478522300720215,
0.35801181197166443,
0.683621346950531,
0.39065098762512207,
-0.041572850197553635,
0.7047147750854492,
0.014465246349573135,
-0.12184811383485794,
0.13171574473381042,
0.56414395570755,
1.0095266103744507,
-0.8087936043739319,
0.6637858152389526,
-0.4390565752983093,
-0.18436039984226227,
-0.049182940274477005,
-0.6699403524398804,
-1.214630126953125,
-0.5210403203964233,
-0.0924893245100975,
-0.4404924809932709,
0.1689438372850418,
0.6375560760498047,
0.7850976586341858,
-0.7987828254699707,
-0.03982636332511902,
-0.2952300012111664,
0.7638651728630066,
0.2054082155227661,
-0.24221357703208923,
0.3618956208229065,
-0.568975567817688,
-0.4927774667739868,
-0.3149559199810028,
0.24150948226451874,
0.2751460373401642,
0.15935848653316498,
0.10683248192071915,
-0.6075153350830078,
-0.2079363614320755,
0.544401228427887,
0.44562408328056335,
-0.4567241668701172,
-0.04677349328994751,
0.037974778562784195,
-0.40861353278160095,
0.01511839684098959,
0.9962705969810486,
-0.9758552312850952,
0.33266183733940125,
0.6767574548721313,
1.1290738582611084,
0.28523775935173035,
0.2286209762096405,
0.4455634355545044,
-0.8893508315086365,
-0.022532964125275612,
0.5609070658683777,
0.11029183864593506,
0.46188992261886597,
-0.5725250840187073,
0.4713776111602783,
0.13109736144542694,
-0.49417921900749207,
-0.511945366859436,
-0.17713198065757751,
-0.5930872559547424,
-0.29071512818336487,
1.1380447149276733,
0.022925160825252533,
-0.5388253927230835,
-0.363015353679657,
-0.36806467175483704,
0.5323278307914734,
-0.26692280173301697,
0.41470903158187866,
0.6465186476707458,
0.1237189844250679,
-0.4557259678840637,
-0.17600208520889282,
0.6645167469978333,
0.11431843787431717,
-0.6797360181808472,
-0.18416708707809448,
0.358126163482666,
0.0443892702460289,
0.5269379615783691,
0.29097577929496765,
-0.0883450135588646,
0.5464572310447693,
-0.3675101399421692,
-0.197942852973938,
-0.4863986670970917,
-0.7902424931526184,
-0.4010065197944641,
0.28302356600761414,
-0.39516469836235046,
-0.6197569370269775
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.07444v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.07444v1
|
On the Robustness of Document-Level Relation Extraction Models to Entity Name Variations
| 2024-06-11T16:51:14 | 2024-06-11T16:51:14 |
Shiao Meng, Xuming Hu, Aiwei Liu, Fukun Ma, Yawen Yang, Shuang Li, Lijie Wen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, 68T50, I.2.7
|
Driven by the demand for cross-sentence and large-scale relation extraction,
document-level relation extraction (DocRE) has attracted increasing research
interest. Despite the continuous improvement in performance, we find that
existing DocRE models which initially perform well may make more mistakes when
merely changing the entity names in the document, hindering the generalization
to novel entity names. To this end, we systematically investigate the
robustness of DocRE models to entity name variations in this work. We first
propose a principled pipeline to generate entity-renamed documents by replacing
the original entity names with names from Wikidata. By applying the pipeline to
DocRED and Re-DocRED datasets, we construct two novel benchmarks named
Env-DocRED and Env-Re-DocRED for robustness evaluation. Experimental results
show that both three representative DocRE models and two in-context learned
large language models consistently lack sufficient robustness to entity name
variations, particularly on cross-sentence relation instances and documents
with more entities. Finally, we propose an entity variation robust training
method which not only improves the robustness of DocRE models but also enhances
their understanding and reasoning capabilities. We further verify that the
basic idea of this method can be effectively transferred to in-context learning
for DocRE as well.
|
[
-0.2901627719402313,
-0.7592880129814148,
0.5907217264175415,
-0.38563287258148193,
0.0032560396939516068,
-0.044442929327487946,
-0.18277963995933533,
-0.6444660425186157,
-0.3130461275577545,
0.3712003827095032,
-0.3710450530052185,
-0.42119061946868896,
-0.9325964450836182,
0.3439137041568756,
-0.5809749960899353,
0.8544015288352966,
-0.24396328628063202,
0.03696397319436073,
-0.14386044442653656,
-0.12356293201446533,
-0.1895531862974167,
-0.15240927040576935,
-0.582135796546936,
-0.09434311836957932,
0.5989717245101929,
0.24573281407356262,
0.35502615571022034,
0.5705369710922241,
0.5955735445022583,
0.20656771957874298,
-0.09214067459106445,
0.23376333713531494,
-0.5012274384498596,
0.4846806228160858,
-0.31851598620414734,
-0.4268991947174072,
-0.33563876152038574,
-0.17265284061431885,
0.6337751150131226,
0.6712623238563538,
-0.2909502685070038,
-0.02401583082973957,
-0.06139947474002838,
0.2797453701496124,
-0.7997114062309265,
0.2706668972969055,
-1.0707440376281738,
-0.31243830919265747,
-0.17748847603797913,
0.039487119764089584,
-0.370402991771698,
0.0997529849410057,
0.3148856461048126,
-0.879195511341095,
0.6210583448410034,
-0.019903190433979034,
1.5866321325302124,
0.15932300686836243,
-0.3314531445503235,
-0.37415823340415955,
-0.9057952761650085,
0.5182166695594788,
-0.7646599411964417,
0.8728136420249939,
0.3599475026130676,
0.36059990525245667,
-0.15770640969276428,
-1.157419204711914,
-0.39475157856941223,
-0.1800967901945114,
0.08512463420629501,
-0.01735331118106842,
0.037296608090400696,
-0.1529465764760971,
0.6218034625053406,
0.5282620191574097,
-0.10702798515558243,
0.27076655626296997,
-0.18555526435375214,
-0.0607977956533432,
0.29603010416030884,
0.20207782089710236,
0.34984058141708374,
-0.16045862436294556,
-0.3512116074562073,
-0.06736225634813309,
-0.6470291614532471,
0.1915052980184555,
0.4797857701778412,
0.2436448484659195,
0.14308325946331024,
0.3859626352787018,
-0.0790577083826065,
0.4459129273891449,
0.3805778920650482,
-0.6317558884620667,
0.1561209112405777,
-0.28755414485931396,
-0.3732794225215912,
-0.4211118221282959,
0.7627012729644775,
0.08298657089471817,
0.11794440448284149,
-0.6628744006156921,
-0.3383612334728241,
-0.166602224111557,
0.37878772616386414,
-0.9706063270568848,
-0.15066319704055786,
0.2704619765281677,
-0.39722323417663574,
-0.4046918451786041,
0.22542181611061096,
-0.7627843618392944,
-0.1576070487499237,
-0.15157157182693481,
0.048843782395124435,
-0.8928945660591125,
-0.46077394485473633,
-0.17798513174057007,
-0.3174409866333008,
0.3269301652908325,
0.5619089007377625,
-1.0524883270263672,
0.3448880910873413,
0.8353311419487,
0.4331573247909546,
-0.25337573885917664,
-0.48786482214927673,
-0.6880295276641846,
0.3905925154685974,
-0.22134985029697418,
0.7925636172294617,
-0.6708487868309021,
-0.5946494936943054,
-0.12457358837127686,
0.2127765268087387,
-0.33001554012298584,
-0.5709106922149658,
0.5527895092964172,
-0.4418092370033264,
0.2455349862575531,
-0.2146078497171402,
-0.826983630657196,
0.3447810709476471,
0.3310824930667877,
-0.8096737265586853,
0.8949659466743469,
0.508240282535553,
-1.4547873735427856,
0.7362729907035828,
-0.06542602181434631,
-0.4421533942222595,
-0.1251690834760666,
-0.2722126245498657,
-0.5205236673355103,
0.06476541608572006,
0.3321169316768646,
0.17464447021484375,
-0.4354591965675354,
0.04026509448885918,
-0.3516120910644531,
-0.010092544369399548,
0.0887407585978508,
-0.22241318225860596,
0.8343908786773682,
0.2068699449300766,
-0.1897050142288208,
-0.43433424830436707,
-1.0129456520080566,
-0.33022597432136536,
0.09350097924470901,
-0.3800937533378601,
-0.642360270023346,
-0.17316462099552155,
-0.07870863378047943,
0.11170375347137451,
-0.12241076678037643,
-0.4786449372768402,
0.06689846515655518,
-0.4003075957298279,
0.4242858588695526,
0.4514875113964081,
0.40930137038230896,
0.7183236479759216,
-0.12531422078609467,
0.6791975498199463,
0.19758296012878418,
-0.043263934552669525,
-0.3297903537750244,
-0.28743013739585876,
-0.5072939395904541,
-0.5330576300621033,
0.8314607739448547,
0.4783293306827545,
-0.7190062999725342,
0.17108632624149323,
-0.5346193313598633,
-0.4890415072441101,
-0.26750311255455017,
0.20201750099658966,
0.13172532618045807,
1.076503038406372,
0.12965072691440582,
-0.44131794571876526,
-0.2872031033039093,
-0.6899827718734741,
-0.492851197719574,
-0.282116562128067,
-0.14461031556129456,
0.2927849590778351,
0.46203282475471497,
-0.19954177737236023,
0.837587296962738,
-0.269083708524704,
0.13156114518642426,
0.028792189434170723,
0.18658097088336945,
-0.01809726655483246,
0.33420655131340027,
0.4058694839477539,
-1.0013569593429565,
-0.5461907386779785,
-0.12251380831003189,
-0.6028132438659668,
0.18257282674312592,
-0.28990766406059265,
-0.14997240900993347,
0.04710223153233528,
0.39718008041381836,
-1.0675382614135742,
0.31829753518104553,
-0.03997085988521576,
-0.011223984882235527,
0.5280017852783203,
-0.1484871357679367,
-0.15248185396194458,
-1.2759997844696045,
0.0008804575190879405,
0.14990819990634918,
-0.3216402232646942,
-0.4846689701080322,
0.3365333676338196,
0.3369237184524536,
-0.10827869176864624,
-0.3519904613494873,
0.35205841064453125,
-0.8857080340385437,
0.019236519932746887,
0.20093345642089844,
0.15419569611549377,
0.2570239007472992,
0.036842696368694305,
-0.023392681032419205,
0.3683237135410309,
0.7546231746673584,
-0.4869103729724884,
0.21950474381446838,
0.37849026918411255,
-0.21870368719100952,
0.9919024109840393,
-0.42412084341049194,
0.1279958337545395,
-0.17950722575187683,
0.2709810733795166,
-0.548462450504303,
-0.2638099491596222,
0.1802596151828766,
-0.40740808844566345,
1.037506341934204,
-0.4348160922527313,
-0.35926979780197144,
-0.05195734649896622,
-0.13560087978839874,
-0.18889810144901276,
0.19361963868141174,
-0.4145471453666687,
0.9417166113853455,
0.3504181504249573,
-0.18787427246570587,
-0.8099164366722107,
-0.5387297868728638,
0.19427865743637085,
-0.46809759736061096,
-0.6550969481468201,
0.4492858350276947,
0.07405682653188705,
-0.30799946188926697,
0.11502440273761749,
-0.5189886689186096,
-0.3461243510246277,
0.15967321395874023,
0.34947469830513,
0.25428512692451477,
-0.039042845368385315,
0.09709057956933975,
0.019928621128201485,
-0.11185986548662186,
0.07480023056268692,
-0.07454104721546173,
0.18095608055591583,
0.19143208861351013,
0.0006822664872743189,
0.0629977211356163,
0.5064957141876221,
0.6071839332580566,
-0.45571368932724,
0.8174283504486084,
0.4775795638561249,
-0.6793222427368164,
-0.2991185486316681,
-0.36219170689582825,
-0.003237358992919326,
-0.3433687090873718,
0.4022674858570099,
-0.9673327803611755,
-0.5207479000091553,
0.6140939593315125,
-0.2676101624965668,
0.2030283659696579,
0.6315658688545227,
0.32887622714042664,
-0.1027107685804367,
0.38011428713798523,
0.7329973578453064,
0.09600942581892014,
0.4410898983478546,
-0.33183345198631287,
0.21271035075187683,
-0.90327388048172,
-0.27431729435920715,
-0.8561739325523376,
0.33284178376197815,
-0.7169699668884277,
-0.10038138180971146,
-0.35392847657203674,
0.24925415217876434,
-0.04180353134870529,
0.7322078943252563,
-0.19950361549854279,
0.18955354392528534,
0.12193391472101212,
-0.1415422260761261,
0.3953601121902466,
0.2807758152484894,
-0.2524290382862091,
-0.2760908305644989,
-0.41944044828414917,
-0.44047582149505615,
1.0529749393463135,
0.41639068722724915,
0.9223096966743469,
-0.053513556718826294,
1.053961992263794,
-0.02722259983420372,
0.34345635771751404,
-0.5519012808799744,
0.04032353311777115,
0.03609877824783325,
-0.477230966091156,
-0.42645585536956787,
-0.6435928344726562,
-1.1022545099258423,
0.0670570358633995,
-0.21345248818397522,
-0.9735391736030579,
0.7226706743240356,
-0.30159515142440796,
0.18512976169586182,
0.38673079013824463,
-0.5634438991546631,
0.7179110646247864,
-0.040757399052381516,
-0.23730425536632538,
0.22654074430465698,
-0.6636310815811157,
0.1066119447350502,
-0.45668765902519226,
0.2017938494682312,
0.11503072082996368,
-0.2684771716594696,
0.31189191341400146,
-0.6445708870887756,
0.35567691922187805,
0.07587159425020218,
-0.493265837430954,
-0.08446910977363586,
0.18491533398628235,
0.7385599613189697,
0.3780578374862671,
-0.2514832019805908,
0.13013845682144165,
-0.10187272727489471,
-0.23633429408073425,
-0.6279134154319763,
0.8408592939376831,
-0.5566803216934204,
-0.610848069190979,
-0.11092878878116608,
-0.486988365650177,
-0.450872004032135,
0.4903809726238251,
0.803551197052002,
0.5496640801429749,
-0.4050270915031433,
0.0962250605225563,
0.8440385460853577,
-0.025071172043681145,
0.3126109540462494,
0.48179399967193604,
0.06481271982192993,
-0.42535102367401123,
0.6295870542526245,
0.3953973352909088,
0.3124353289604187,
0.5971125960350037,
-0.3540569245815277,
-0.23121656477451324,
-0.5232706069946289,
-0.5456745028495789,
0.13622339069843292,
-0.859950065612793,
-0.021067962050437927,
-0.9531475305557251,
-0.106835275888443,
-0.4365684688091278,
0.13759277760982513,
-0.37485477328300476,
-0.5321641564369202,
-0.25326600670814514,
-0.22007893025875092,
-0.1811974048614502,
0.37417837977409363,
0.2613530158996582,
-0.3723323345184326,
-0.6882227659225464,
0.5002111792564392,
0.38009798526763916,
0.20653358101844788,
-0.21487869322299957,
-0.5557668209075928,
0.017358457669615746,
-0.22024020552635193,
-0.21748608350753784,
-1.2075341939926147,
0.053907159715890884,
0.31267204880714417,
0.699221670627594,
0.4098910987377167,
0.1510324627161026,
0.3308933973312378,
-0.3922001123428345,
0.6061360239982605,
0.13644009828567505,
-0.6123340129852295,
0.5013062953948975,
-0.436928391456604,
-0.045148301869630814,
0.5672202110290527,
0.41020357608795166,
-0.07684576511383057,
-0.7217904925346375,
-1.1001272201538086,
-0.9282732605934143,
0.39801454544067383,
0.35804322361946106,
0.17550329864025116,
0.08715996146202087,
0.46204936504364014,
0.4380691945552826,
0.05578857660293579,
-0.4384888708591461,
-0.23535165190696716,
-0.21205595135688782,
-0.015288128517568111,
0.19518941640853882,
-0.1561889946460724,
-0.09176388382911682,
0.030364012345671654,
0.6244717240333557,
0.08141562342643738,
-0.050639305263757706,
0.3521585166454315,
-0.27137836813926697,
-0.1582162231206894,
0.39819902181625366,
0.004655357450246811,
0.9881401658058167,
-0.25763416290283203,
0.06547009944915771,
0.21327443420886993,
-0.4428503215312958,
0.0156671442091465,
0.6588954925537109,
-0.4606470763683319,
0.35108551383018494,
0.41115137934684753,
0.6916171312332153,
0.2280389368534088,
-0.2909529507160187,
0.517912745475769,
-0.4999595582485199,
-0.13026411831378937,
-0.11943364143371582,
0.09897163510322571,
0.3210802972316742,
0.09760283678770065,
0.2884174585342407,
0.09590256959199905,
0.09219183027744293,
-0.48519644141197205,
0.12034523487091064,
0.24086613953113556,
-0.2183212786912918,
0.004865813534706831,
0.8161348700523376,
-0.12098516523838043,
-0.3790057897567749,
0.6178562045097351,
0.10761259496212006,
-0.06132873147726059,
0.6416003108024597,
0.5592899322509766,
0.7569812536239624,
-0.1857496052980423,
0.18421179056167603,
0.4153919219970703,
0.3530903458595276,
-0.030030466616153717,
-0.15497277677059174,
-0.2016809731721878,
-0.6428610682487488,
-0.05982721969485283,
-0.3624575734138489,
-0.4824909269809723,
0.1390247792005539,
-0.9155336618423462,
0.2997487783432007,
-0.27086880803108215,
-0.3592891991138458,
0.281898558139801,
-0.037879690527915955,
-0.7671282291412354,
0.31794971227645874,
0.026999181136488914,
1.1553616523742676,
-0.4436405301094055,
1.1238596439361572,
0.8756327629089355,
-0.6756255626678467,
-1.1697481870651245,
0.3934426009654999,
-0.4429208040237427,
-0.025314070284366608,
0.3578900098800659,
0.07129490375518799,
0.09044346958398819,
-0.1990358680486679,
-0.2864161729812622,
-0.7358792424201965,
1.2926671504974365,
0.681969940662384,
-0.7641745805740356,
-0.43328210711479187,
-0.009636685252189636,
0.5642887353897095,
-0.4900707006454468,
0.12919168174266815,
0.3260265290737152,
0.2855885326862335,
-0.052933219820261,
-0.7225794196128845,
0.08604097366333008,
-0.2954922616481781,
0.27519097924232483,
0.16113249957561493,
-0.4757821559906006,
0.7812513709068298,
-0.19123177230358124,
-0.4477561116218567,
0.04833028465509415,
0.6082779765129089,
0.08197677880525589,
0.20426064729690552,
0.7056592702865601,
0.7648866772651672,
1.1417808532714844,
-0.0875358134508133,
1.3100996017456055,
-0.20078931748867035,
0.5196935534477234,
1.3980566263198853,
-0.35422399640083313,
0.6808370351791382,
0.5302197337150574,
-0.09274190664291382,
0.7197315096855164,
0.663221538066864,
-0.15421539545059204,
0.5368930101394653,
-0.1663288176059723,
0.01763625629246235,
-0.18625660240650177,
0.20128637552261353,
-0.4913783371448517,
0.20329663157463074,
0.2449752688407898,
-0.5713351964950562,
-0.13650749623775482,
-0.4503462612628937,
0.1671941876411438,
-0.2089388072490692,
0.11235666275024414,
0.6344650387763977,
0.2646051347255707,
-0.6861686110496521,
0.3903674781322479,
0.056074004620313644,
0.34319981932640076,
-0.594492495059967,
0.10676439106464386,
-0.36054661870002747,
0.07812508195638657,
-0.2264229953289032,
-0.29037922620773315,
-0.013499448075890541,
0.08626778423786163,
-0.37597718834877014,
0.15533922612667084,
1.1330186128616333,
-0.3303014934062958,
-0.45535150170326233,
0.40142956376075745,
0.657879650592804,
-0.13953694701194763,
0.13964855670928955,
-0.6272006630897522,
-0.3028045892715454,
-0.2109561413526535,
-0.3720552325248718,
0.4535194933414459,
0.7773399949073792,
-0.08019857108592987,
0.5077314972877502,
0.5029613971710205,
0.17038318514823914,
0.018647197633981705,
0.13487571477890015,
0.8328678607940674,
-0.23924176394939423,
-0.39730241894721985,
-0.506486713886261,
0.4392176568508148,
-0.4416947364807129,
-0.29743078351020813,
0.7417563796043396,
0.39729857444763184,
0.8471253514289856,
-0.050009846687316895,
0.7345433831214905,
-0.2479599118232727,
0.40208110213279724,
-0.29937925934791565,
0.5239505767822266,
-0.4780372381210327,
0.44427254796028137,
-0.6193058490753174,
-1.132982611656189,
-0.010945851914584637,
0.14686043560504913,
-0.14805498719215393,
0.030791955068707466,
0.9157455563545227,
0.6951634287834167,
-0.34134283661842346,
-0.12956489622592926,
0.32126933336257935,
0.13089103996753693,
0.3981582522392273,
0.43209537863731384,
0.7330110669136047,
-0.5726529955863953,
0.7991049885749817,
-0.25141528248786926,
-0.009129746817052364,
0.21131068468093872,
-0.8680012226104736,
-0.7198199033737183,
-0.591866135597229,
-0.5025233030319214,
-0.5542841553688049,
0.18729905784130096,
0.2166808694601059,
0.7489259243011475,
-0.5892448425292969,
0.4250454008579254,
-0.11478205025196075,
0.1606442928314209,
-0.1283956915140152,
-0.23708239197731018,
0.41491249203681946,
-0.31228727102279663,
-0.8679693341255188,
0.3376525044441223,
0.10583145171403885,
-0.032850172370672226,
-0.0011806745314970613,
-0.32922443747520447,
-0.040881816297769547,
0.04001878947019577,
-0.09344662725925446,
0.372159481048584,
-0.6642534136772156,
-0.13831312954425812,
-0.10127393156290054,
-0.48152604699134827,
0.1941763013601303,
0.8819632530212402,
-0.3952498733997345,
0.5396856069564819,
0.5187718868255615,
0.6684661507606506,
0.7902072668075562,
0.03757382184267044,
0.6772229671478271,
-0.5890282988548279,
-0.06395874917507172,
-0.20824860036373138,
0.7303985953330994,
0.7262004613876343,
-0.5633564591407776,
0.7872145175933838,
0.3467435836791992,
-0.35943934321403503,
-0.799146831035614,
0.245741069316864,
-0.8311301469802856,
-0.20011071860790253,
1.1387308835983276,
-0.6918969750404358,
-0.02706574834883213,
-0.1554228812456131,
-0.01958349347114563,
0.463173508644104,
-0.3181900978088379,
0.6808137893676758,
0.7572669982910156,
0.18057455122470856,
-0.3771210014820099,
-0.3834366500377655,
0.21726001799106598,
0.08676395565271378,
-0.8052552342414856,
-0.05545143038034439,
0.3620122969150543,
0.9230254292488098,
0.10020296275615692,
0.47307607531547546,
-0.41196638345718384,
0.2680102288722992,
0.35263344645500183,
-0.3042813837528229,
-0.179087296128273,
-0.15393556654453278,
-0.09351417422294617,
0.32687827944755554,
0.28550148010253906,
0.16230446100234985
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.07440v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.07440v2
|
Textual Similarity as a Key Metric in Machine Translation Quality Estimation
| 2024-06-11T16:48:17 | 2024-07-01T09:30:34 |
Kun Sun, Rong Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Machine Translation (MT) Quality Estimation (QE) assesses translation
reliability without reference texts. This study introduces "textual similarity"
as a new metric for QE, using sentence transformers and cosine similarity to
measure semantic closeness. Analyzing data from the MLQE-PE dataset, we found
that textual similarity exhibits stronger correlations with human scores than
traditional metrics (hter, model evaluation, sentence probability etc.).
Employing GAMMs as a statistical tool, we demonstrated that textual similarity
consistently outperforms other metrics across multiple language pairs in
predicting human scores. We also found that "hter" actually failed to predict
human scores in QE. Our findings highlight the effectiveness of textual
similarity as a robust QE metric, recommending its integration with other
metrics into QE frameworks and MT system training for improved accuracy and
usability.
|
[
-0.23478232324123383,
-0.44198060035705566,
0.7058300971984863,
0.10015249252319336,
-0.40215417742729187,
0.024717098101973534,
0.05964323505759239,
-0.30538424849510193,
0.17026937007904053,
0.5195959806442261,
-0.4066087305545807,
-0.8005721569061279,
-0.5518662929534912,
0.24724842607975006,
-0.6970743536949158,
0.8134569525718689,
-0.10986285656690598,
-0.11409682780504227,
-0.5201775431632996,
-0.4008205831050873,
-0.5639931559562683,
-0.592998206615448,
-0.41194987297058105,
-0.20985373854637146,
0.4995501935482025,
-0.0031098260078579187,
1.1368142366409302,
0.6915727853775024,
1.0502010583877563,
0.34354934096336365,
0.2805836498737335,
0.07401016354560852,
-0.3006012737751007,
0.2646697461605072,
-0.29254841804504395,
-0.6548829078674316,
-0.5609499216079712,
0.1979639232158661,
0.5527694225311279,
0.582390546798706,
0.23401731252670288,
0.42816755175590515,
0.517605721950531,
0.8448382019996643,
-0.41439783573150635,
-0.12579452991485596,
-0.48503464460372925,
0.22066518664360046,
-0.17504921555519104,
-0.40628939867019653,
-0.3763836920261383,
-0.6274718046188354,
0.2608110308647156,
-0.7402468323707581,
0.29867663979530334,
0.34843090176582336,
1.335486888885498,
0.4222305417060852,
-0.5337522625923157,
-0.33754271268844604,
-0.4289848208427429,
1.006773829460144,
-0.6967834234237671,
0.4922146201133728,
0.5003158450126648,
0.31956803798675537,
-0.11954358965158463,
-0.5508349537849426,
-0.5125347971916199,
-0.29460182785987854,
-0.23574630916118622,
0.20269359648227692,
-0.11383108794689178,
-0.27989479899406433,
-0.07467922568321228,
0.4059847593307495,
-0.8661431074142456,
-0.24931740760803223,
0.022895529866218567,
-0.2980862259864807,
0.3295653760433197,
0.3400031626224518,
0.5125872492790222,
-0.37086790800094604,
-0.6490445137023926,
-0.24711522459983826,
-0.39721259474754333,
-0.009565469808876514,
0.19379021227359772,
-0.1681481897830963,
-0.06156099587678909,
0.5377185344696045,
-0.06732723861932755,
0.31328001618385315,
-0.2760114073753357,
-0.2364353984594345,
0.46099337935447693,
-0.6175960302352905,
-0.3556678295135498,
-0.39038780331611633,
1.3136003017425537,
0.7451730370521545,
0.22037117183208466,
-0.5099232196807861,
-0.13241735100746155,
-0.042015139013528824,
0.28736481070518494,
-0.5703174471855164,
-0.14267703890800476,
-0.18547897040843964,
-0.7122212052345276,
-0.20958352088928223,
0.6089464426040649,
-0.5880752801895142,
0.018745308741927147,
-0.29500752687454224,
0.48350846767425537,
-0.6592965126037598,
0.14895379543304443,
-0.29402780532836914,
-0.347192645072937,
0.30294376611709595,
-0.11371777951717377,
-0.5537861585617065,
0.4107939302921295,
0.8610994219779968,
1.1309993267059326,
-0.48900115489959717,
-0.5877400636672974,
-0.5817205905914307,
-0.061464909464120865,
-0.525093138217926,
0.7139739394187927,
-0.24888058006763458,
-0.42069438099861145,
-0.36275985836982727,
0.027024677023291588,
-0.16185928881168365,
-0.679602861404419,
1.0553309917449951,
-0.3193623721599579,
0.601678192615509,
-0.14376169443130493,
-0.6408931016921997,
-0.3881687521934509,
0.2114901840686798,
-0.7302869558334351,
1.3815484046936035,
0.3283911347389221,
-0.766855001449585,
0.7074912190437317,
-0.23493236303329468,
-0.20314724743366241,
-0.09841059893369675,
0.18924535810947418,
-0.8741580843925476,
0.3028523325920105,
-0.009553460404276848,
0.3883477747440338,
-0.4265185594558716,
0.14845134317874908,
-0.518858015537262,
-0.5177651643753052,
0.5970110297203064,
-0.6552004814147949,
0.5320557951927185,
0.16824854910373688,
-0.01854904741048813,
0.16229811310768127,
-0.43106964230537415,
0.4711955189704895,
-0.24373774230480194,
-0.19521167874336243,
-0.7178741693496704,
-0.0015704766847193241,
0.1544211208820343,
0.28242257237434387,
0.19006386399269104,
-0.32298770546913147,
-0.1507306545972824,
-0.5842453241348267,
0.2238844484090805,
0.2621665298938751,
0.002431235508993268,
0.6306161284446716,
-0.5622485280036926,
0.3415611684322357,
-0.2805355489253998,
0.07752105593681335,
0.013644193299114704,
-0.5937855243682861,
-0.25752174854278564,
-0.22076177597045898,
0.7419372200965881,
0.7603343725204468,
-0.4722050726413727,
0.7073039412498474,
-0.7594712972640991,
-0.5834117531776428,
-0.8335006237030029,
0.18444512784481049,
0.4438104033470154,
0.2520454525947571,
0.45267194509506226,
-0.4273526668548584,
-0.327055960893631,
-0.8732038736343384,
-0.7734818458557129,
-0.240621417760849,
-0.6531239151954651,
-0.15939415991306305,
0.4948410391807556,
0.002329415176063776,
0.8595418930053711,
-0.2551518380641937,
-0.4330524802207947,
0.3860618472099304,
0.2862718105316162,
0.07527367770671844,
0.3045946955680847,
0.7156829237937927,
-0.7037715911865234,
-0.8741961121559143,
0.15216216444969177,
-0.9849385023117065,
-0.19364535808563232,
0.16341464221477509,
-0.2539694011211395,
0.07732249051332474,
0.2822462320327759,
-0.2773018777370453,
0.3019227981567383,
0.8372541666030884,
-0.6018120646476746,
0.47855082154273987,
-0.329915314912796,
0.8071542382240295,
-1.3869647979736328,
0.028656071051955223,
-0.07431728392839432,
-0.17349670827388763,
-0.31002190709114075,
0.11600098013877869,
0.19181019067764282,
0.05868607386946678,
-0.40260326862335205,
0.5082353949546814,
-0.12807565927505493,
-0.20568667352199554,
-0.22312836349010468,
0.4034576416015625,
0.392635315656662,
0.13682381808757782,
-0.4513644278049469,
1.1148022413253784,
0.0921519547700882,
-0.2933284342288971,
0.3786707818508148,
0.2611924409866333,
-0.4579896330833435,
1.2045884132385254,
-0.717967689037323,
0.11703594028949738,
0.27522867918014526,
-0.19468285143375397,
-0.8227848410606384,
0.1521785855293274,
0.013397235423326492,
-0.8572925329208374,
0.029459940269589424,
0.1464560329914093,
-0.5194947123527527,
-0.1506631076335907,
-0.4415605068206787,
0.4930485785007477,
0.5498456954956055,
-0.05844168737530708,
0.2768104672431946,
0.05262923240661621,
-0.31741687655448914,
-0.30140119791030884,
-0.683980405330658,
0.39434975385665894,
-0.40798187255859375,
-0.6111282110214233,
0.3937634229660034,
0.09348877519369125,
-0.09088356047868729,
0.3406493067741394,
-0.07159417122602463,
-0.35868096351623535,
0.24285465478897095,
0.2814008593559265,
0.21370388567447662,
-0.5867471098899841,
0.2240651696920395,
0.1352781504392624,
-0.3777121603488922,
0.16602016985416412,
-0.34983450174331665,
0.19098588824272156,
0.034387677907943726,
-0.3522467613220215,
-0.6745948791503906,
0.411051481962204,
0.672274649143219,
-0.2078876793384552,
0.8290296196937561,
0.6300229430198669,
-0.3352569043636322,
0.5159377455711365,
-0.29865026473999023,
-0.03313468396663666,
-0.3680897355079651,
0.44574543833732605,
-0.6332229971885681,
-0.5747851133346558,
0.3206593692302704,
0.22661235928535461,
-0.3217962086200714,
0.7267586588859558,
0.2701750695705414,
-0.5842512249946594,
0.9317162036895752,
0.5156424045562744,
-0.2238302230834961,
0.2189197689294815,
0.11949671059846878,
-0.09229094535112381,
-0.7097112536430359,
-0.15615706145763397,
-0.9518551230430603,
-0.3063565492630005,
-0.8216879963874817,
-0.4918622672557831,
0.19483743607997894,
0.15303607285022736,
-0.3127148747444153,
0.5286340117454529,
-0.16921842098236084,
0.3994719386100769,
0.5559210181236267,
-0.22163785994052887,
0.5012272596359253,
0.11321640014648438,
-0.20874391496181488,
-0.5209349989891052,
-0.28103458881378174,
-1.042565107345581,
0.8881951570510864,
0.27773481607437134,
0.2884608209133148,
-0.06320533901453018,
0.5635517835617065,
0.47412291169166565,
0.24805358052253723,
-0.6894662976264954,
0.30333462357521057,
-0.36930492520332336,
-0.27306118607521057,
-0.48037388920783997,
-0.7399256229400635,
-0.9651666283607483,
0.3285265862941742,
-0.5740740299224854,
-0.3471654951572418,
-0.26243865489959717,
-0.2104659080505371,
0.09932856261730194,
0.15662796795368195,
-0.5929756760597229,
0.9763369560241699,
-0.027044076472520828,
-0.031687501817941666,
-0.10885456949472427,
-0.46434348821640015,
-0.1363188922405243,
-0.25967922806739807,
0.2430744618177414,
-0.4059349298477173,
-0.38668277859687805,
0.9544479846954346,
-0.38747403025627136,
0.2980957329273224,
0.32962489128112793,
-0.041048333048820496,
0.17359143495559692,
0.19025471806526184,
0.2541821002960205,
-0.23599275946617126,
-0.3918493390083313,
0.32092946767807007,
0.4316277801990509,
-0.8564780354499817,
-0.836840033531189,
0.7976205945014954,
-0.7536666989326477,
-0.10020807385444641,
-0.33944734930992126,
-0.35341233015060425,
-0.013453863561153412,
0.3448983132839203,
0.4490678906440735,
0.23947422206401825,
-0.5862483382225037,
0.2803128659725189,
0.18849752843379974,
-0.15133774280548096,
0.28023985028266907,
0.39595478773117065,
0.09129504859447479,
-0.6401528120040894,
0.9557748436927795,
0.020849399268627167,
0.39057445526123047,
0.9213300943374634,
0.07508674263954163,
-0.44979995489120483,
-0.3520094156265259,
-0.48133352398872375,
0.16119560599327087,
-0.36118510365486145,
-0.35357052087783813,
-0.47293978929519653,
-0.09710539877414703,
0.2135722041130066,
-0.2728891670703888,
-0.25564008951187134,
-0.2580143213272095,
-0.05143793299794197,
-0.03438498079776764,
0.1684524118900299,
0.5536803603172302,
0.6541540026664734,
0.3450848162174225,
-1.2665659189224243,
0.2866438925266266,
0.1177598088979721,
0.37426823377609253,
-0.3992159068584442,
-0.7768834233283997,
-0.4744580090045929,
0.31018587946891785,
-0.5653350949287415,
-0.9400466084480286,
0.43473052978515625,
0.289009690284729,
0.36570218205451965,
0.04287761077284813,
0.07012014836072922,
0.4217582643032074,
-0.5530204772949219,
0.813689112663269,
0.27879825234413147,
-1.156099557876587,
0.2796582281589508,
-0.11755648255348206,
0.2749902606010437,
0.7529946565628052,
0.2743675112724304,
-0.506798505783081,
-0.7972694635391235,
-0.34561681747436523,
-0.48951980471611023,
-0.07812511175870895,
0.564320981502533,
0.12201399356126785,
0.03665157034993172,
0.31393930315971375,
0.2666536271572113,
0.16779741644859314,
-0.441221684217453,
-0.16977128386497498,
-0.06352889537811279,
-0.6236886382102966,
-0.24691323935985565,
-0.049936722964048386,
0.4590842127799988,
0.044570889323949814,
0.4613661468029022,
0.02065652422606945,
0.33800816535949707,
0.1163933128118515,
-0.2244420200586319,
-0.21770882606506348,
0.5615593194961548,
0.3890082836151123,
0.4467501640319824,
-0.2429225891828537,
0.1821233183145523,
0.5336347818374634,
-0.7327844500541687,
0.3643631637096405,
-0.40280789136886597,
-0.14414221048355103,
0.2507389783859253,
0.6782383918762207,
0.5084391832351685,
0.16335204243659973,
-0.2569859027862549,
0.5060042142868042,
0.0575503446161747,
-0.2519320547580719,
0.05191861838102341,
-0.18353472650051117,
-0.014210093766450882,
-0.058949217200279236,
0.27669790387153625,
0.28238561749458313,
0.32632291316986084,
-0.476012647151947,
0.3327881097793579,
0.23318766057491302,
-1.171994924545288,
-0.44901126623153687,
0.5986803770065308,
0.27160847187042236,
-0.6048979759216309,
0.6247708201408386,
-0.10725197196006775,
-0.40188083052635193,
0.5341283679008484,
0.253612220287323,
0.8142533302307129,
-0.316333532333374,
0.17005442082881927,
0.3142852783203125,
0.4589548408985138,
-0.14087043702602386,
0.05649008974432945,
0.4960208833217621,
-0.3111780881881714,
-0.7673820853233337,
-0.5643123388290405,
-0.27203312516212463,
-0.42559897899627686,
-0.7292435169219971,
0.33940646052360535,
0.3142542839050293,
-0.3996073305606842,
-0.36495280265808105,
0.2764313220977783,
-0.7536266446113586,
0.38778814673423767,
-0.35651636123657227,
0.5786266922950745,
-0.9463812708854675,
0.8906971216201782,
0.6529586315155029,
-0.4113497734069824,
-0.656460165977478,
0.14027604460716248,
-0.1355566531419754,
-0.36290043592453003,
0.3082263767719269,
0.021765656769275665,
-0.16345509886741638,
-0.04201076552271843,
0.2623874843120575,
-0.453370600938797,
1.4162884950637817,
0.388052374124527,
-0.3500503897666931,
-0.054893478751182556,
0.3894430100917816,
0.7550830245018005,
-0.26379603147506714,
0.4594564735889435,
0.470098614692688,
0.3417132794857025,
-0.508516252040863,
-1.2215967178344727,
0.16937170922756195,
-0.039184387773275375,
-0.010533912107348442,
0.8175912499427795,
-0.35858678817749023,
0.31553390622138977,
0.023265132680535316,
-0.3132615387439728,
0.3808485269546509,
0.6023311614990234,
-0.29016774892807007,
0.652722954750061,
0.3226068317890167,
0.6437572240829468,
0.7904884219169617,
-0.16275188326835632,
0.890704333782196,
-0.06658788025379181,
0.708634614944458,
0.9399652481079102,
-0.11695742607116699,
1.1666450500488281,
0.37360242009162903,
-0.37610411643981934,
0.5125535726547241,
0.2826753258705139,
-0.033853933215141296,
0.3166767358779907,
-0.1748342365026474,
0.1341809630393982,
0.04125376045703888,
0.09855766594409943,
-0.3850293457508087,
0.26493364572525024,
0.045453693717718124,
-0.6723909974098206,
0.07235055416822433,
-0.019901707768440247,
-0.1311490833759308,
0.6410499215126038,
0.09072946757078171,
0.9493916630744934,
0.371754914522171,
-0.40760481357574463,
0.5759564638137817,
-0.11592907458543777,
0.3725382089614868,
-0.22776639461517334,
0.10836620628833771,
-0.13425618410110474,
-0.11172619462013245,
-0.11963667720556259,
-0.9728900790214539,
0.7511469125747681,
-0.18626585602760315,
-0.5983635187149048,
-0.0026767330709844828,
0.28757596015930176,
-0.22668111324310303,
-0.35446256399154663,
0.3796454966068268,
0.823958694934845,
0.19970782101154327,
-0.38607558608055115,
-0.6731765270233154,
-0.2857391834259033,
-0.264168918132782,
0.09980881214141846,
0.43236806988716125,
0.8891956806182861,
-0.08422145992517471,
0.7516151666641235,
0.484535813331604,
-0.13596904277801514,
0.042986199259757996,
-0.274880975484848,
0.1980859637260437,
-1.0715816020965576,
-0.28942054510116577,
-1.0440727472305298,
0.2193838506937027,
-0.20481885969638824,
-0.3273659348487854,
0.9571348428726196,
0.8129600882530212,
0.6643068194389343,
-0.20185725390911102,
0.6334056258201599,
0.41386091709136963,
0.6577161550521851,
-0.48450639843940735,
0.739743173122406,
-0.4508727192878723,
0.08739029616117477,
-0.4402061402797699,
-1.3973042964935303,
-0.29013726115226746,
0.40365782380104065,
-0.3112228512763977,
-0.23110699653625488,
1.3256776332855225,
0.6472700238227844,
-0.31364691257476807,
-0.24674038589000702,
0.7477922439575195,
-0.06410019844770432,
-0.01635371521115303,
0.5346531867980957,
0.7407305836677551,
-0.9801713228225708,
0.9270225167274475,
0.24771694839000702,
0.007147899828851223,
-0.17488552629947662,
-0.781974196434021,
-0.8270083665847778,
-0.7222449779510498,
-0.2484978437423706,
-0.3244938254356384,
0.17169012129306793,
0.7484434247016907,
0.4548262655735016,
-0.8180145621299744,
-0.12255498021841049,
0.16880202293395996,
0.29944413900375366,
-0.579125702381134,
-0.26775768399238586,
0.521111249923706,
-0.21883255243301392,
-0.7148853540420532,
-0.11934207379817963,
0.526268720626831,
0.11696308106184006,
0.1507580727338791,
-0.21758784353733063,
0.21269464492797852,
0.072734534740448,
0.6375097632408142,
-0.19149309396743774,
-0.8067260980606079,
-0.46086886525154114,
0.3245815336704254,
-0.6821442246437073,
0.11822851747274399,
0.6597066521644592,
-0.5126280784606934,
0.2530239224433899,
0.7752717733383179,
0.593809187412262,
0.08038914203643799,
0.09167255461215973,
0.764900267124176,
-0.47144362330436707,
-0.11578024178743362,
0.06366246193647385,
0.20001350343227386,
0.4125203788280487,
0.018746916204690933,
0.47708722949028015,
0.19096750020980835,
-0.818609356880188,
-0.4837908446788788,
0.22069492936134338,
-1.0330089330673218,
0.1694474220275879,
0.7180119156837463,
-0.467427521944046,
-0.19826340675354004,
-0.38955923914909363,
-0.38075289130210876,
0.18401044607162476,
-0.2812616527080536,
0.713602602481842,
0.8610162734985352,
0.48704794049263,
-0.009869382716715336,
-0.8568452000617981,
0.23035402595996857,
0.4291495978832245,
-0.7889280915260315,
-0.533846914768219,
0.06007364019751549,
0.37787356972694397,
0.1545839011669159,
0.24535709619522095,
-0.13857214152812958,
0.26043736934661865,
0.032080113887786865,
0.004656351637095213,
0.29492175579071045,
0.15508949756622314,
0.11705059558153152,
0.3521236181259155,
0.2747068703174591,
-0.327350914478302
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.07430v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.07430v1
|
Learning Domain-Invariant Features for Out-of-Context News Detection
| 2024-06-11T16:34:02 | 2024-06-11T16:34:02 |
Yimeng Gu, Mengqi Zhang, Ignacio Castro, Shu Wu, Gareth Tyson
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.MM
|
Multimodal out-of-context news is a common type of misinformation on online
media platforms. This involves posting a caption, alongside an invalid
out-of-context news image. Reflecting its importance, researchers have
developed models to detect such misinformation. However, a common limitation of
these models is that they only consider the scenario where pre-labeled data is
available for each domain, failing to address the out-of-context news detection
on unlabeled domains (e.g., unverified news on new topics or agencies). In this
work, we therefore focus on domain adaptive out-of-context news detection. In
order to effectively adapt the detection model to unlabeled news topics or
agencies, we propose ConDA-TTA (Contrastive Domain Adaptation with Test-Time
Adaptation) which applies contrastive learning and maximum mean discrepancy
(MMD) to learn the domain-invariant feature. In addition, it leverages target
domain statistics during test-time to further assist domain adaptation.
Experimental results show that our approach outperforms baselines in 5 out of 7
domain adaptation settings on two public datasets, by as much as 2.93% in F1
and 2.08% in accuracy.
|
[
-0.6202461123466492,
-0.6170135736465454,
0.3871244490146637,
0.15662115812301636,
-0.7613874673843384,
0.2815190553665161,
-0.2690374553203583,
-0.5141976475715637,
0.11445320397615433,
0.10078252851963043,
-0.3412371873855591,
-0.4101993441581726,
-0.7417342066764832,
-0.04953967407345772,
-0.26396942138671875,
1.0944979190826416,
-0.105652816593647,
-0.0657985731959343,
-0.16887950897216797,
-0.5614533424377441,
-0.7407565116882324,
-0.4145054519176483,
-0.4539315104484558,
0.05043095350265503,
-0.11152917891740799,
0.6140333414077759,
0.46746447682380676,
-0.011565964668989182,
0.19757148623466492,
0.16938480734825134,
0.3732958436012268,
0.7618879675865173,
-0.35337066650390625,
-0.27053824067115784,
-0.4072086811065674,
-0.1476513296365738,
-0.0368402935564518,
-0.042223505675792694,
0.4964072108268738,
0.4444652497768402,
0.02872338518500328,
0.03579322621226311,
0.2124861180782318,
0.7201927900314331,
-0.6690986752510071,
0.23872767388820648,
-0.8225663304328918,
-0.27444759011268616,
-0.21324171125888824,
-0.5401293635368347,
-0.6127583384513855,
-0.36620303988456726,
0.14955240488052368,
-0.949562132358551,
0.2590008080005646,
0.10250898450613022,
0.8827763795852661,
0.19234974682331085,
-0.6880658268928528,
-0.47963470220565796,
-0.4412677586078644,
0.7252991199493408,
-0.4626466929912567,
0.5516132712364197,
0.18430344760417938,
0.3761247992515564,
-0.5003776550292969,
-0.4303954839706421,
-0.74853515625,
0.20525667071342468,
-0.16867487132549286,
0.2694132328033447,
-0.46882161498069763,
-0.48015233874320984,
-0.19762152433395386,
-0.10695528984069824,
-0.6501821875572205,
0.18468980491161346,
-0.23298048973083496,
-0.025699779391288757,
0.2414221316576004,
-0.43633997440338135,
0.11002660542726517,
0.035811927169561386,
-0.7483760714530945,
-0.0004258921544533223,
-0.523596465587616,
0.06344377249479294,
-0.014431045390665531,
0.42445021867752075,
-0.5970823764801025,
0.03257889300584793,
0.05355996638536453,
0.5929785966873169,
0.48119449615478516,
-0.028333870694041252,
0.491146445274353,
-0.0713023990392685,
-0.2537841200828552,
0.07816945016384125,
0.2679732143878937,
0.4994490146636963,
0.22495658695697784,
-0.03971292823553085,
-0.17611132562160492,
0.189489483833313,
0.1451900154352188,
-0.6901025772094727,
-0.08321209996938705,
0.04440855607390404,
-0.5327224731445312,
0.14112752676010132,
0.23576153814792633,
-1.1109668016433716,
-0.6558539867401123,
-0.19278275966644287,
0.8206995129585266,
-0.30171382427215576,
-0.24145947396755219,
0.3072863519191742,
-0.21474497020244598,
-0.1509968787431717,
0.5169297456741333,
-0.47675907611846924,
0.05094197392463684,
0.06669721007347107,
0.6790164113044739,
-0.4520757496356964,
-0.23859120905399323,
-0.7968341112136841,
0.018835755065083504,
-0.16338877379894257,
0.9382498860359192,
-0.500079333782196,
-0.15381166338920593,
0.07246841490268707,
0.3103458881378174,
-0.3369411826133728,
-0.6949968934059143,
0.5416805148124695,
-0.9432805180549622,
0.27697238326072693,
-0.07745005190372467,
-0.5497790575027466,
-0.571707010269165,
0.0908716470003128,
-0.6985867619514465,
0.7363401055335999,
0.6712870001792908,
-0.7647345662117004,
0.7397312521934509,
-0.8294916152954102,
-0.43617701530456543,
-0.1388734132051468,
0.0805211067199707,
-0.817632794380188,
0.15572264790534973,
0.5823067426681519,
0.36534127593040466,
-0.1651531457901001,
0.3586815297603607,
-0.29186856746673584,
-0.3356427252292633,
0.64808589220047,
-0.37905803322792053,
0.6435313820838928,
0.24131566286087036,
-0.3004878759384155,
0.13890385627746582,
-0.8612692356109619,
-0.37887048721313477,
-0.03631601855158806,
-0.2884750962257385,
-0.5639921426773071,
-0.14694860577583313,
0.07386275380849838,
0.2271396666765213,
-0.23426905274391174,
-0.49024778604507446,
-0.04038569703698158,
0.006229414604604244,
0.28356149792671204,
0.5714845061302185,
0.364839643239975,
0.5119419097900391,
-0.5055740475654602,
0.25056228041648865,
0.7726877331733704,
0.167891263961792,
-0.09356994926929474,
-0.44568613171577454,
-0.5197802186012268,
-0.45941975712776184,
0.5504115223884583,
0.16336853802204132,
-1.2452188730239868,
0.4728400707244873,
-0.1961773931980133,
-0.03558606654405594,
-0.1828889548778534,
-0.013209231197834015,
0.29677051305770874,
0.6900715231895447,
0.6726832985877991,
-0.5649007558822632,
-0.6901164650917053,
-0.2821553349494934,
-0.2080719769001007,
0.25143134593963623,
0.2599288523197174,
-0.01482863537967205,
0.6642357110977173,
-0.2979818880558014,
0.980735719203949,
-0.3189641237258911,
-0.6867185235023499,
0.03997963294386864,
0.2559576630592346,
0.09582221508026123,
0.31891438364982605,
0.7706350088119507,
-1.320294737815857,
-0.5186214447021484,
0.05603976920247078,
-0.5951740741729736,
0.006754286587238312,
-0.3052253723144531,
-0.021954521536827087,
0.5022358298301697,
0.3531915843486786,
-0.5593570470809937,
0.3324480354785919,
0.6229662299156189,
-0.3898858428001404,
0.1428842395544052,
-0.2945614159107208,
0.3254547715187073,
-1.0824434757232666,
-0.2828699052333832,
0.36786559224128723,
-0.3926791250705719,
-0.618195116519928,
-0.24139390885829926,
0.3286779224872589,
-0.06250492483377457,
-0.6842392683029175,
0.5545309782028198,
-0.5646352767944336,
-0.16291414201259613,
-0.40109017491340637,
0.2977701425552368,
0.2645038366317749,
0.6065387725830078,
0.023766687139868736,
0.8686202764511108,
0.40899184346199036,
-0.9132958054542542,
0.11427121609449387,
0.24004895985126495,
-0.5019882321357727,
0.7548055648803711,
0.17575249075889587,
0.05659261718392372,
-0.2145734578371048,
0.5031601190567017,
-0.9300102591514587,
-0.23783957958221436,
0.3802521228790283,
-0.6500875949859619,
0.36152592301368713,
-0.10824934393167496,
-0.24184539914131165,
0.04931413754820824,
-0.522942841053009,
0.5533435344696045,
0.19116666913032532,
-1.116843581199646,
0.5615857839584351,
0.7010660767555237,
0.3294348418712616,
-0.5245688557624817,
-0.3712259829044342,
-0.27809610962867737,
-0.4242187738418579,
-0.3436650335788727,
0.6272062063217163,
-0.07397676259279251,
0.13552482426166534,
0.2436581701040268,
-0.21205143630504608,
-0.38939857482910156,
-0.00035186580498702824,
0.10746754705905914,
0.10549956560134888,
-0.30302882194519043,
0.2629176080226898,
0.10078626871109009,
0.12240184098482132,
-0.2871968150138855,
-0.18202520906925201,
0.35658925771713257,
0.16704151034355164,
-0.06659749895334244,
-0.5151442885398865,
0.3863973319530487,
0.7820696830749512,
-0.3334239423274994,
0.49758878350257874,
0.503873884677887,
-0.716140866279602,
-0.4688100218772888,
-0.12034004181623459,
-0.09025467187166214,
-0.39457646012306213,
0.31702372431755066,
-0.16130958497524261,
-0.6079114675521851,
0.402753621339798,
-0.4333188831806183,
-0.49370095133781433,
0.3343917727470398,
0.26168906688690186,
-0.1037529781460762,
0.5610988140106201,
0.90675288438797,
0.03051639534533024,
0.4999937117099762,
-0.21163123846054077,
0.14038695394992828,
-0.5996057391166687,
-0.15310169756412506,
-0.208624467253685,
-0.40751510858535767,
-0.5211000442504883,
-0.35972797870635986,
0.41128674149513245,
0.03139927238225937,
-0.02846400998532772,
0.3057880401611328,
-0.35557037591934204,
0.3424935042858124,
0.3842591941356659,
0.5110284090042114,
0.3201656639575958,
-0.013570514507591724,
0.4843702018260956,
-0.07373965531587601,
-0.47441670298576355,
0.108768530189991,
1.0945109128952026,
0.27125638723373413,
0.7707204222679138,
0.2531869113445282,
0.09339217841625214,
0.8377201557159424,
0.5064345002174377,
-0.5885493159294128,
0.048911046236753464,
-0.7192646265029907,
-0.4235006868839264,
-0.09298679232597351,
-0.1999262422323227,
-0.7010326385498047,
0.16452555358409882,
-0.3295632302761078,
-0.28443875908851624,
0.9525391459465027,
-0.0576670877635479,
-0.4838656187057495,
0.20344306528568268,
-0.9443885087966919,
0.8528095483779907,
-0.05330144986510277,
0.2350822240114212,
-0.08970773220062256,
-0.4723169505596161,
0.3218134641647339,
-0.611034095287323,
0.4241698384284973,
-0.04580844193696976,
0.03411667421460152,
0.5567981600761414,
0.18654657900333405,
1.0964698791503906,
-0.44353383779525757,
0.009711496531963348,
0.2569204270839691,
-0.1964392513036728,
0.5045883059501648,
0.1922730654478073,
0.2794925570487976,
0.04999452829360962,
-0.2996519207954407,
-0.15854491293430328,
-0.6060705184936523,
0.4713961184024811,
-0.7817306518554688,
-0.23183414340019226,
-0.5095642805099487,
-0.7264382839202881,
-0.5036075711250305,
0.10500743240118027,
0.38085493445396423,
0.4600742757320404,
-0.17399853467941284,
0.2692979574203491,
0.6378335952758789,
-0.14721329510211945,
0.6985105872154236,
0.8804057240486145,
-0.06119168549776077,
-0.3586360216140747,
1.0308290719985962,
0.04064051806926727,
0.019681302830576897,
0.5955772399902344,
-0.07255437225103378,
-0.5562301278114319,
-0.6718764305114746,
-0.6350155472755432,
0.006773230154067278,
-0.9661660194396973,
-0.5744835734367371,
-0.2717687785625458,
-0.16006267070770264,
-0.07197309285402298,
-0.2485172301530838,
-0.0812184140086174,
-0.2715711295604706,
-0.637382447719574,
0.15433722734451294,
0.33036157488822937,
0.17316539585590363,
0.13123612105846405,
0.5052903890609741,
-0.6458609700202942,
0.6667327284812927,
0.16596467792987823,
0.08504854887723923,
-0.5083776116371155,
-1.11919367313385,
-0.24915297329425812,
0.013883241452276707,
-0.45816728472709656,
-0.6637534499168396,
0.3850722908973694,
0.5573638677597046,
0.3325277864933014,
0.29843422770500183,
0.4341793358325958,
0.38289743661880493,
-0.09274954348802567,
0.35940268635749817,
0.23527385294437408,
-1.014502763748169,
0.3135926127433777,
0.02706158719956875,
0.04190309718251228,
0.3452032506465912,
0.6762180924415588,
-0.3264465630054474,
-0.2100025862455368,
-0.2979956567287445,
-0.19351403415203094,
0.6050215363502502,
-0.27219119668006897,
0.13653287291526794,
0.17684417963027954,
0.20812907814979553,
0.6610168218612671,
0.15002813935279846,
-0.7368617653846741,
0.025770114734768867,
-0.36578214168548584,
-0.24277490377426147,
-0.02353580854833126,
-0.17554734647274017,
-0.20144973695278168,
-0.050035130232572556,
0.5981446504592896,
-0.5318732857704163,
0.12400035560131073,
0.013023843057453632,
-0.6826453804969788,
-0.19468873739242554,
0.39438551664352417,
0.8970188498497009,
1.0348190069198608,
-0.33499985933303833,
0.26677271723747253,
0.11891339719295502,
-0.4281046390533447,
0.3176279366016388,
0.44286593794822693,
-0.11746930330991745,
0.2900064289569855,
-0.05093328654766083,
0.5761833190917969,
0.29665407538414,
-0.48205968737602234,
0.8694614768028259,
-0.1131935715675354,
-0.06166568771004677,
-0.12353148311376572,
-0.25934937596321106,
-0.36961829662323,
0.5138189792633057,
0.5459422469139099,
0.6231948137283325,
0.03692667931318283,
-0.6987636089324951,
0.5539150238037109,
0.27815309166908264,
-0.3778662085533142,
-0.40928447246551514,
0.7266699075698853,
0.35777875781059265,
0.19790107011795044,
0.12011826038360596,
-0.34487584233283997,
-0.38398477435112,
0.6225177049636841,
0.8004627823829651,
0.7734972238540649,
-0.17602811753749847,
0.46385473012924194,
-0.19584214687347412,
0.03899035230278969,
0.04634758085012436,
0.30773502588272095,
0.37760791182518005,
-1.2186617851257324,
-0.14378367364406586,
-0.28419989347457886,
-0.3467395305633545,
0.31910640001296997,
-0.344009131193161,
0.44797366857528687,
-0.3742161989212036,
-0.229608952999115,
0.270402729511261,
-0.1272876262664795,
-0.4623064398765564,
0.6221691966056824,
-0.030468937009572983,
0.8243526220321655,
-1.012452244758606,
1.026048183441162,
0.6549330949783325,
-0.3173147439956665,
-0.09778404980897903,
0.33737581968307495,
-0.013796740211546421,
-0.7275648713111877,
0.4545031785964966,
0.25319528579711914,
-0.16994629800319672,
0.05670565366744995,
-0.23451168835163116,
-0.5351587533950806,
0.985282301902771,
0.8176078796386719,
-0.4156970977783203,
0.38999706506729126,
-0.09326270967721939,
0.20317591726779938,
-0.7904449701309204,
-0.210904061794281,
0.3460922837257385,
0.39591923356056213,
-0.162354975938797,
-0.7749894261360168,
0.2485278844833374,
0.10977733880281448,
-0.17263999581336975,
0.22878733277320862,
-0.821761429309845,
0.9090765714645386,
-0.1794283241033554,
-0.3866328001022339,
-0.3224658668041229,
0.7208857536315918,
-0.07906132936477661,
0.7641072273254395,
0.6623879671096802,
0.26400214433670044,
0.7057943940162659,
-0.11062878370285034,
0.6803996562957764,
-0.056952908635139465,
0.3510272800922394,
1.0270007848739624,
-0.2353937178850174,
0.5228924751281738,
0.3095712661743164,
0.21326413750648499,
0.4434678852558136,
0.7721074223518372,
-0.03145245462656021,
1.157087802886963,
-0.15350008010864258,
-0.36817988753318787,
0.07034345716238022,
-0.23118160665035248,
-0.4239378571510315,
0.6149212121963501,
0.44635072350502014,
-0.22456783056259155,
-0.4265948534011841,
0.3491672873497009,
-0.05457949638366699,
0.250988245010376,
-0.4503226578235626,
0.32404962182044983,
0.09705379605293274,
-0.4622650742530823,
0.6604588627815247,
0.15178903937339783,
0.795917809009552,
-0.4047708511352539,
-0.13662555813789368,
-0.346880167722702,
0.5574488043785095,
-0.29952818155288696,
-0.7068864107131958,
0.23472483456134796,
-0.1758255958557129,
-0.49336525797843933,
0.12781672179698944,
0.7976812720298767,
-0.5049133896827698,
-0.11594642698764801,
0.5007907152175903,
0.6158300042152405,
-0.2443671077489853,
-0.28373444080352783,
-0.43976664543151855,
0.1511070281267166,
-0.17793279886245728,
0.08010172843933105,
0.4549611210823059,
0.7106993794441223,
-0.5508663058280945,
0.359267920255661,
0.5781212449073792,
-0.3152584135532379,
0.03775481879711151,
0.1681419461965561,
1.0826576948165894,
-0.37543731927871704,
-0.6517081260681152,
-0.5163770318031311,
0.3185879588127136,
0.15682543814182281,
-0.5843818783760071,
0.4337206184864044,
0.5630487203598022,
1.1715859174728394,
-0.3118699789047241,
0.682488203048706,
0.2320849895477295,
0.4423833191394806,
-0.8576187491416931,
0.627630889415741,
-0.5982764959335327,
0.09240146726369858,
0.03616461157798767,
-0.7194815278053284,
-0.4805311858654022,
-0.07931302487850189,
0.17682203650474548,
-0.08934751898050308,
0.8974385261535645,
0.7069145441055298,
-0.40330037474632263,
-0.006173618603497744,
0.3992047607898712,
-0.022039402276277542,
0.23644518852233887,
0.7980944514274597,
0.8661518096923828,
-0.47334256768226624,
0.5492865443229675,
-0.10723766684532166,
-0.2744531035423279,
-0.3297407627105713,
-0.9794536232948303,
-0.9097650647163391,
-0.7592419385910034,
-0.5357785224914551,
-0.25001260638237,
0.19666007161140442,
0.6418195366859436,
0.8588646650314331,
-1.1103355884552002,
0.11406436562538147,
0.3434056043624878,
0.19465556740760803,
-0.529837429523468,
-0.20649521052837372,
0.7485233545303345,
-0.24996663630008698,
-0.5542835593223572,
0.4617363214492798,
0.31247788667678833,
0.12371029704809189,
0.3724980652332306,
-0.013872118666768074,
-0.3369409143924713,
0.18526344001293182,
0.6026286482810974,
0.44277775287628174,
-0.24395598471164703,
-0.7038754224777222,
-0.35872021317481995,
0.12888021767139435,
0.48954010009765625,
0.7893993854522705,
-0.7113980650901794,
0.5188501477241516,
0.15827614068984985,
0.8198354244232178,
0.3004475235939026,
0.2175605595111847,
0.08933184295892715,
-1.19329035282135,
0.3749449849128723,
-0.14287976920604706,
0.3101913332939148,
0.4890298843383789,
-0.47413039207458496,
0.2832348346710205,
0.6229501962661743,
-0.2857258915901184,
-0.5994275212287903,
-0.020901747047901154,
-1.0921690464019775,
-0.5049030184745789,
0.8323885798454285,
-0.11618712544441223,
-0.07204827666282654,
-0.5511025786399841,
-0.1630619913339615,
0.3608558177947998,
-0.6193619966506958,
1.0161899328231812,
0.4014880061149597,
-0.12260982394218445,
-0.2396049201488495,
-0.4065448045730591,
0.6239175796508789,
-0.20307791233062744,
-1.0493899583816528,
-0.0837930291891098,
0.3352052867412567,
0.32256364822387695,
0.1519095003604889,
0.609106719493866,
-0.06198960915207863,
0.6850613951683044,
-0.2768833041191101,
-0.1871073842048645,
-0.1459677666425705,
-0.5439246296882629,
-0.44002625346183777,
0.09784377366304398,
-0.2651042342185974,
-0.9052404165267944
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.07424v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.07424v2
|
MINERS: Multilingual Language Models as Semantic Retrievers
| 2024-06-11T16:26:18 | 2024-06-19T08:29:51 |
Genta Indra Winata, Ruochen Zhang, David Ifeoluwa Adelani
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Words have been represented in a high-dimensional vector space that encodes
their semantic similarities, enabling downstream applications such as
retrieving synonyms, antonyms, and relevant contexts. However, despite recent
advances in multilingual language models (LMs), the effectiveness of these
models' representations in semantic retrieval contexts has not been
comprehensively explored. To fill this gap, this paper introduces the MINERS, a
benchmark designed to evaluate the ability of multilingual LMs in semantic
retrieval tasks, including bitext mining and classification via
retrieval-augmented contexts. We create a comprehensive framework to assess the
robustness of LMs in retrieving samples across over 200 diverse languages,
including extremely low-resource languages in challenging cross-lingual and
code-switching settings. Our results demonstrate that by solely retrieving
semantically similar embeddings yields performance competitive with
state-of-the-art approaches, without requiring any fine-tuning.
|
[
-0.17782901227474213,
-0.38647758960723877,
0.5223572850227356,
-0.024322159588336945,
-0.09603965282440186,
0.09043169021606445,
-0.4911961555480957,
-0.4821377694606781,
0.28204357624053955,
0.3212193250656128,
-0.2915401756763458,
-0.47947365045547485,
-0.8025051355361938,
0.302521675825119,
-0.704715371131897,
0.5013983249664307,
-0.06878974288702011,
-0.10296090692281723,
-0.11578010022640228,
-0.2790152132511139,
-0.55158931016922,
-0.6270020604133606,
-0.13255275785923004,
-0.3459186255931854,
0.7687271237373352,
0.051374200731515884,
0.8304218053817749,
0.7077482342720032,
0.13437478244304657,
0.3367440104484558,
-0.1900220513343811,
-0.04901852831244469,
-0.29272961616516113,
0.18261493742465973,
-0.4089241027832031,
-0.4725080728530884,
0.2162199467420578,
-0.11912353336811066,
0.7450758814811707,
0.7522453665733337,
-0.2589506506919861,
0.09807371348142624,
-0.040192730724811554,
0.0968593955039978,
-1.0758529901504517,
0.01375925075262785,
-1.1481916904449463,
0.05159326270222664,
-0.5480577349662781,
-0.024593444541096687,
-0.6100003719329834,
-0.13049107789993286,
0.04176662862300873,
-0.1487971693277359,
0.17627887427806854,
-0.07365518808364868,
0.76878422498703,
-0.14751766622066498,
-0.49415722489356995,
-0.4006901979446411,
-0.2471596896648407,
0.9447588324546814,
-0.44105497002601624,
0.6975756883621216,
0.36676186323165894,
0.302977591753006,
0.17157699167728424,
-0.9259547591209412,
-0.3963189721107483,
0.02546011656522751,
-0.22490324079990387,
-0.1303509771823883,
-0.06897372752428055,
-0.40336814522743225,
0.08629880100488663,
0.33212730288505554,
-0.28490450978279114,
0.1125703826546669,
-0.12716518342494965,
-0.44719502329826355,
0.2372806817293167,
0.08925958722829819,
0.43495866656303406,
-0.47372332215309143,
-0.4710957109928131,
-0.22434863448143005,
-0.6996765732765198,
0.13781142234802246,
0.27315816283226013,
0.8303037285804749,
0.1516115367412567,
0.5109692215919495,
-0.05287427455186844,
0.7061283588409424,
-0.6805931329727173,
-0.010084444656968117,
0.5375577807426453,
-0.24503827095031738,
0.17897701263427734,
0.1430589109659195,
0.5872861742973328,
0.3159150183200836,
0.009862584993243217,
-0.7144088745117188,
-0.4326997995376587,
0.29493603110313416,
0.14389702677726746,
-0.7552087306976318,
-0.03384082391858101,
0.19625970721244812,
-0.4859229326248169,
-0.03385448828339577,
0.020215624943375587,
-0.7345833778381348,
-0.36381635069847107,
0.11651912331581116,
0.5182642936706543,
-0.48968401551246643,
-0.7712206244468689,
0.09795042872428894,
-0.5067504644393921,
0.2644287347793579,
-0.39433151483535767,
-0.9015464782714844,
0.2619379162788391,
0.7848835587501526,
0.896206259727478,
-0.13971221446990967,
-0.775526762008667,
-0.9076129198074341,
0.045581746846437454,
-0.3249340057373047,
0.8816103935241699,
-0.8717576861381531,
-0.3609817624092102,
0.44389668107032776,
0.23792700469493866,
-0.37799087166786194,
-0.797001838684082,
0.6186326742172241,
-0.6554263830184937,
-0.22466827929019928,
-0.4797802269458771,
-0.3815248906612396,
-0.026333903893828392,
0.5416458249092102,
-0.8494458198547363,
1.173188328742981,
0.040487732738256454,
-0.8647434115409851,
0.45356541872024536,
0.013441160321235657,
-0.26689431071281433,
0.13317492604255676,
-0.17862901091575623,
0.08184454590082169,
0.2961682379245758,
0.0005344923702068627,
0.40287429094314575,
-0.1866110861301422,
0.07504261285066605,
-0.31120190024375916,
-0.49306240677833557,
0.28631019592285156,
-0.23986119031906128,
0.4514700174331665,
0.35451507568359375,
-0.09651034325361252,
-0.019263559952378273,
-0.5976303219795227,
0.27837643027305603,
0.16775770485401154,
-0.4538390338420868,
-0.6919933557510376,
0.28226009011268616,
0.36394593119621277,
0.6188415884971619,
0.18152950704097748,
-0.7561630010604858,
-0.17590872943401337,
-0.29666706919670105,
0.6460580229759216,
0.5907203555107117,
-0.5290777087211609,
0.08480492979288101,
-0.05331923067569733,
0.2724023461341858,
0.1575918197631836,
-0.306807279586792,
-0.4106103777885437,
-0.028965706005692482,
-0.39421892166137695,
-0.16791221499443054,
0.4926459789276123,
0.48226314783096313,
-0.8938372135162354,
-0.11669409275054932,
-0.5560145974159241,
-0.4384370446205139,
-0.8862591981887817,
0.31711429357528687,
0.49885642528533936,
0.09667044132947922,
0.3501870334148407,
-0.48793062567710876,
-0.3266485631465912,
-0.8598098754882812,
-0.8338653445243835,
0.13234645128250122,
0.24268490076065063,
0.451455682516098,
0.2780083119869232,
-0.5707647800445557,
0.8622280359268188,
-0.12106623500585556,
0.09065686166286469,
-0.31868448853492737,
-0.20949923992156982,
0.3176499605178833,
0.10774626582860947,
0.3122712969779968,
-0.9113783240318298,
-0.5341960191726685,
0.10805793106555939,
-0.7038708925247192,
0.18252645432949066,
0.4642537832260132,
-0.047349654138088226,
0.13548508286476135,
0.6389265656471252,
-0.3830409348011017,
0.08311650902032852,
0.6362001299858093,
-0.28100836277008057,
0.4313007891178131,
-0.1894799768924713,
0.00584269966930151,
-0.8999850749969482,
0.39767417311668396,
-0.2224314659833908,
-0.40185368061065674,
-0.5339371562004089,
0.48995015025138855,
0.5417268872261047,
-0.1999841332435608,
-0.6875882148742676,
0.7730829119682312,
-0.4873533844947815,
-0.1282368302345276,
-0.20572355389595032,
0.5974617600440979,
-0.16678361594676971,
0.2719268500804901,
0.11638692766427994,
0.5572478175163269,
0.6753719449043274,
-0.6651772260665894,
0.5042804479598999,
0.013897395692765713,
-0.5527611374855042,
0.6067865490913391,
-0.511951208114624,
0.06417671591043472,
-0.27706044912338257,
-0.3191082775592804,
-0.6838973760604858,
-0.07117529958486557,
-0.4146582782268524,
-0.2550531327724457,
0.30111947655677795,
-0.40993937849998474,
-0.8513741493225098,
-0.2665092647075653,
-0.2955421805381775,
0.34075474739074707,
0.2267409712076187,
-0.8641237616539001,
0.5850844383239746,
0.5537741184234619,
-0.09151224046945572,
-0.8010755181312561,
-0.6264737248420715,
0.16944141685962677,
-0.27216818928718567,
-0.42115354537963867,
0.42523857951164246,
0.19902530312538147,
-0.19999921321868896,
0.20969904959201813,
-0.023312071338295937,
0.06406425684690475,
0.19338393211364746,
-0.160858616232872,
-0.11022964119911194,
0.10608811676502228,
0.30928683280944824,
-0.14715610444545746,
-0.30447497963905334,
-0.04263460263609886,
-0.16018594801425934,
0.8894991874694824,
-0.18454480171203613,
-0.26612651348114014,
0.36483222246170044,
0.4466422498226166,
0.21881631016731262,
-0.6137168407440186,
0.822393536567688,
0.8045907020568848,
-0.5156137943267822,
0.042256541550159454,
-0.5309895873069763,
0.028709284961223602,
-0.42769062519073486,
0.5610074996948242,
-0.8201839923858643,
-0.9204987287521362,
0.7518448829650879,
-0.1740361899137497,
-0.02654491737484932,
0.6036654710769653,
0.6633996963500977,
0.5190494656562805,
1.0033432245254517,
0.6218637824058533,
-0.2958774268627167,
0.30549558997154236,
-0.030916040763258934,
0.05802277475595474,
-0.8142219185829163,
-0.2951253354549408,
-0.7864341735839844,
0.025455569848418236,
-0.932260274887085,
-0.1554405391216278,
0.11274978518486023,
0.13790054619312286,
-0.02372468262910843,
0.6994516849517822,
-0.22952668368816376,
0.5465161204338074,
0.5711718201637268,
-0.17603234946727753,
0.12014692276716232,
0.06667835265398026,
-0.634512186050415,
-0.08768024295568466,
-0.746095597743988,
-0.4285144507884979,
0.7448046803474426,
0.14956526458263397,
0.6175268292427063,
0.3996785581111908,
0.757533073425293,
0.07176083326339722,
0.01240649726241827,
-0.5305012464523315,
0.25904878973960876,
-0.3430962562561035,
-0.8397762179374695,
0.21065083146095276,
-0.3849617540836334,
-1.2619664669036865,
0.850741446018219,
-0.17716552317142487,
-0.9602890610694885,
0.10269884020090103,
-0.2205340564250946,
-0.030861495062708855,
0.461417019367218,
-0.8136922121047974,
1.2600958347320557,
-0.10406497120857239,
-0.5670939087867737,
-0.36593082547187805,
-0.5661365389823914,
-0.0403900183737278,
-0.0036015750374644995,
0.6524738073348999,
-0.2565641403198242,
-0.0698927566409111,
0.30249300599098206,
-0.31334930658340454,
0.5326188802719116,
-0.16415147483348846,
-0.0399964265525341,
0.27302488684654236,
0.3211421072483063,
0.3629395663738251,
-0.23128442466259003,
-0.3899424076080322,
0.1429000049829483,
0.5882129073143005,
-0.598315954208374,
-0.09272641688585281,
1.1850547790527344,
-0.5543836355209351,
-0.1403522789478302,
-0.4852164089679718,
-0.27683526277542114,
-0.03761083632707596,
0.5042275190353394,
0.2058752328157425,
0.7158158421516418,
-0.17315101623535156,
0.10812275111675262,
0.3058196008205414,
-0.28877514600753784,
0.6303801536560059,
0.30524587631225586,
-0.30935943126678467,
-0.17482990026474,
1.2981337308883667,
0.08758994936943054,
0.09889962524175644,
0.4245426058769226,
0.14113149046897888,
-0.6320416927337646,
-0.24158291518688202,
-0.637829601764679,
0.16068775951862335,
-0.878543496131897,
-0.13037662208080292,
-0.7821149826049805,
-0.009399485774338245,
-0.3303394615650177,
0.1769428849220276,
-0.4705919623374939,
0.019533077254891396,
0.14828161895275116,
0.1037183478474617,
0.20259539783000946,
0.5872355699539185,
0.010192076675593853,
0.05483412370085716,
-1.0860028266906738,
0.10035040974617004,
0.20345519483089447,
0.9201615452766418,
0.029115060344338417,
-0.18215547502040863,
-0.4959234297275543,
-0.22417457401752472,
-0.022376786917448044,
-0.8926333785057068,
0.420912504196167,
0.1893496811389923,
0.9400015473365784,
-0.05880600959062576,
-0.11756540834903717,
0.5998117327690125,
-0.7279836535453796,
0.711469292640686,
0.03814798220992088,
-1.03916597366333,
0.3308616280555725,
0.05509176850318909,
0.17032833397388458,
0.5118012428283691,
0.3884654939174652,
-1.0937790870666504,
-0.014376983977854252,
-0.43970581889152527,
-1.0598540306091309,
0.7614911198616028,
-0.11407063156366348,
0.3958132863044739,
-0.642656683921814,
0.24171976745128632,
0.19806110858917236,
0.23340459167957306,
-0.8122549057006836,
-0.11122091114521027,
-0.22777053713798523,
-0.15793557465076447,
-0.2724977135658264,
-0.3960117697715759,
0.22883166372776031,
0.41704094409942627,
0.5178048014640808,
-0.16481243073940277,
0.08905626088380814,
-0.03248826786875725,
-0.7855594158172607,
0.21270912885665894,
0.4923400580883026,
-0.08674179017543793,
0.5415624976158142,
-0.12481354922056198,
0.753144383430481,
0.2819248139858246,
-0.23776192963123322,
-0.2165621519088745,
0.3266591429710388,
0.14251096546649933,
0.12925302982330322,
0.2636559009552002,
0.6097606420516968,
0.4579143524169922,
-1.14248788356781,
0.4510989487171173,
-0.15268409252166748,
0.4205648899078369,
-0.1434764266014099,
-0.0864134132862091,
0.22629240155220032,
0.1881386935710907,
0.13865822553634644,
-0.19892758131027222,
0.33846405148506165,
-0.7466060519218445,
0.13206703960895538,
0.5407248735427856,
-0.5778430104255676,
-0.3297368586063385,
0.5077713131904602,
0.007877007126808167,
-0.22884421050548553,
0.7413397431373596,
-0.19617041945457458,
-0.5351844429969788,
0.04675169661641121,
0.6247491836547852,
0.6196027398109436,
-0.0787992849946022,
-0.28729644417762756,
0.42475759983062744,
0.33156055212020874,
-0.18177731335163116,
0.2240886241197586,
-0.029018906876444817,
-0.7967172265052795,
-0.3653305172920227,
-0.6400879621505737,
-0.20689715445041656,
-0.41261470317840576,
-0.8613696098327637,
0.3673385679721832,
0.14095723628997803,
-0.1736055463552475,
-0.09193849563598633,
0.09127848595380783,
-0.8770509362220764,
-0.022678488865494728,
0.18427160382270813,
1.1252671480178833,
-0.650390625,
0.8717823624610901,
0.7938573360443115,
-0.2511105537414551,
-0.37786513566970825,
-0.37462106347084045,
-0.1328647881746292,
-0.8401237726211548,
0.1864626109600067,
0.478656530380249,
-0.1508561372756958,
-0.09975042194128036,
-0.16474899649620056,
-0.809827983379364,
0.9598218202590942,
0.2609904110431671,
-0.369243860244751,
0.2798967957496643,
0.04671398922801018,
0.3351176679134369,
-0.054851025342941284,
0.4438958168029785,
0.7126983404159546,
0.12968362867832184,
-0.07981490343809128,
-0.9871368408203125,
-0.07358904182910919,
-0.5322336554527283,
0.3313893675804138,
0.41723528504371643,
-0.457594633102417,
0.9501946568489075,
-0.04338805004954338,
-0.34428077936172485,
0.04998345300555229,
0.38787317276000977,
0.26432114839553833,
0.0763293132185936,
0.5722455382347107,
0.6038066148757935,
0.7193673253059387,
-0.2805815637111664,
1.4464569091796875,
-0.6324682235717773,
0.42500823736190796,
0.7281819581985474,
-0.39136311411857605,
1.2086443901062012,
0.43898439407348633,
-0.16578732430934906,
0.6651927828788757,
0.6345449686050415,
0.3352574110031128,
0.6541289687156677,
0.16875293850898743,
-0.21258404850959778,
-0.5328673720359802,
-0.27403169870376587,
-0.4846932590007782,
0.3702760338783264,
0.37438586354255676,
-0.1912168264389038,
-0.4092714786529541,
-0.1954038292169571,
0.061597950756549835,
0.3847825527191162,
-0.3455861508846283,
0.6377851366996765,
0.010772649198770523,
-0.7102641463279724,
0.41737979650497437,
0.5125174522399902,
1.0510066747665405,
-0.6260923743247986,
0.24363137781620026,
-0.1380254030227661,
0.525388777256012,
-0.1243823915719986,
-0.6483163237571716,
0.32057979702949524,
0.10068713873624802,
-0.14887003600597382,
-0.03374411538243294,
0.7934612035751343,
-0.626864492893219,
-0.39352577924728394,
0.7628881931304932,
0.543296217918396,
0.29750803112983704,
-0.1738234907388687,
-0.6251607537269592,
0.4909694492816925,
-0.3865337073802948,
0.1682504415512085,
0.39853447675704956,
0.46068012714385986,
-0.003016319125890732,
0.5271407961845398,
0.4028632938861847,
-0.008484043180942535,
0.4106130301952362,
0.2126816362142563,
0.7672826051712036,
-1.0206822156906128,
-0.38273492455482483,
-0.9713954329490662,
0.2586163878440857,
0.06722386181354523,
-0.13593165576457977,
0.9096087217330933,
0.8484855890274048,
1.2510230541229248,
0.08008721470832825,
0.7352060675621033,
-0.16193887591362,
0.870499312877655,
-0.39193466305732727,
0.38419169187545776,
-0.7352888584136963,
0.02169279009103775,
-0.37887370586395264,
-0.8091938495635986,
-0.14780856668949127,
0.5978847146034241,
-0.07028872519731522,
0.199804425239563,
0.44901740550994873,
0.6253501772880554,
-0.30614209175109863,
-0.20058229565620422,
0.32895269989967346,
0.02205500192940235,
0.3222315311431885,
0.6194294691085815,
0.9897105693817139,
-0.5893455743789673,
0.6480348110198975,
-0.2579060196876526,
0.06169227510690689,
-0.05117982625961304,
-0.8935115933418274,
-0.6687988042831421,
-0.45371320843696594,
-0.06249630078673363,
-0.5687543749809265,
-0.08540574461221695,
1.0204395055770874,
0.5360509157180786,
-0.6864363551139832,
-0.48545634746551514,
0.43251949548721313,
0.26738303899765015,
-0.3357633352279663,
-0.09533872455358505,
0.3232356011867523,
-0.6282732486724854,
-0.9814165830612183,
0.3705604076385498,
0.12623386085033417,
-0.4745837450027466,
-0.21315352618694305,
-0.21539205312728882,
-0.36214765906333923,
-0.24066278338432312,
0.8242951035499573,
0.0841318741440773,
-0.7299764752388,
-0.1951461285352707,
0.2907959222793579,
-0.18545547127723694,
-0.155595600605011,
0.7085052728652954,
-0.9848418235778809,
0.8045806288719177,
0.36509090662002563,
0.6431216597557068,
0.5715889930725098,
-0.5145341157913208,
0.13739293813705444,
-0.8759545683860779,
0.23682734370231628,
-0.14093878865242004,
0.7353214025497437,
0.6029900312423706,
0.3034107983112335,
0.31434687972068787,
0.22992479801177979,
-0.23161762952804565,
-0.9537094235420227,
0.18966704607009888,
-0.48828214406967163,
-0.3969343900680542,
1.068973183631897,
-0.1356460005044937,
-0.2249162495136261,
0.03022059239447117,
0.13678303360939026,
-0.04837384447455406,
0.015618013218045235,
0.4480282962322235,
0.7228416800498962,
0.48010605573654175,
-0.21424804627895355,
-0.5814014673233032,
0.1624184250831604,
0.34644219279289246,
-0.20898759365081787,
0.09730914235115051,
0.29039931297302246,
0.502992570400238,
0.3013160824775696,
0.4834580421447754,
-0.5126568078994751,
-0.024774672463536263,
0.13874012231826782,
0.17719370126724243,
0.24839238822460175,
-0.21817784011363983,
-0.3835981786251068,
0.2013222575187683,
0.45466703176498413,
0.039518337696790695
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.07411v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.07411v1
|
VersiCode: Towards Version-controllable Code Generation
| 2024-06-11T16:15:06 | 2024-06-11T16:15:06 |
Tongtong Wu, Weigang Wu, Xingyu Wang, Kang Xu, Suyu Ma, Bo Jiang, Ping Yang, Zhenchang Xing, Yuan-Fang Li, Gholamreza Haffari
|
cs.SE
|
cs.SE, cs.CL
|
Significant research has focused on improving the performance of large
language model on code-related tasks due to their practical importance.
Although performance is typically evaluated using public benchmark datasets,
the existing datasets do not account for the concept of \emph{version}, which
is crucial in professional software development. In this paper, we introduce
VersiCode, the first comprehensive dataset designed to assess the ability of
large language models to generate verifiable code for specific library
versions. VersiCode encompasses 300 libraries across more than 2,000 versions
spanning 9 years. We design two dedicated evaluation tasks: version-specific
code completion (VSCC) and version-aware code editing (VACE). Comprehensive
experiments are conducted to benchmark the performance of LLMs, revealing the
challenging nature of these tasks and VersiCode, that even state-of-the-art
LLMs struggle to generate version-correct code. This dataset, together with the
proposed tasks, sheds light on LLMs' capabilities and limitations in handling
version-specific code generation, and opens up an important new area of
research for further investigation. The resources can be found at
https://github.com/wutong8023/VersiCode.
|
[
-0.2713961601257324,
-0.28256532549858093,
0.26851803064346313,
0.23494267463684082,
-0.17816105484962463,
0.2878250181674957,
-0.4796316921710968,
-0.3873659372329712,
0.20036739110946655,
0.8886721730232239,
-0.6221755743026733,
-0.7556043863296509,
-0.34415796399116516,
0.3495492935180664,
-0.5755926966667175,
0.9581685662269592,
-0.36276671290397644,
-0.060108039528131485,
-0.2830807566642761,
-0.16199228167533875,
-0.3859674632549286,
-0.4792218804359436,
-0.37606877088546753,
-0.14687973260879517,
0.5111020803451538,
0.5011469125747681,
0.5208067297935486,
0.8516810536384583,
0.5645748376846313,
0.23087814450263977,
-0.06281054764986038,
0.27346473932266235,
-0.38918688893318176,
0.3726319372653961,
-0.32071682810783386,
-0.5514381527900696,
-0.34960854053497314,
-0.5268158912658691,
0.30819791555404663,
-0.04837022349238396,
-0.2759220004081726,
0.338272362947464,
-0.05856841802597046,
0.7147659063339233,
-0.5110334753990173,
-0.09611669927835464,
-0.6411963105201721,
0.19678904116153717,
-0.564018726348877,
-0.22667574882507324,
-0.13655564188957214,
-0.5503854155540466,
-0.375586599111557,
-0.2811366319656372,
0.11487861722707748,
-0.2145780622959137,
0.7576045989990234,
0.3260735869407654,
-0.12464245408773422,
-0.4676743149757385,
-0.7913196086883545,
0.5751926898956299,
-0.7118902802467346,
0.3930457532405853,
0.19799061119556427,
0.38270097970962524,
-0.1846199929714203,
-1.0649148225784302,
-0.3742341995239258,
-0.3393378257751465,
0.35497424006462097,
0.03511353209614754,
-0.13906806707382202,
-0.36649981141090393,
0.3472130298614502,
0.6361014246940613,
-0.5590882301330566,
0.2400559037923813,
-0.6959266662597656,
-0.07511167973279953,
0.3897325396537781,
0.2751583755016327,
0.11535240709781647,
-0.30248337984085083,
-0.18118606507778168,
0.01593964919447899,
-1.1273691654205322,
-0.05451282858848572,
0.43137794733047485,
0.14689311385154724,
-0.06100355461239815,
0.6787073016166687,
-0.24751566350460052,
0.5675289034843445,
-0.3121868669986725,
0.19560542702674866,
0.3699747323989868,
-0.4155457615852356,
-0.26985275745391846,
-0.2338017374277115,
0.6685407757759094,
-0.05380963906645775,
0.36197611689567566,
-0.05668660253286362,
-0.31930437684059143,
-0.014264129102230072,
0.8348221778869629,
-0.6115387082099915,
-0.05673833191394806,
0.4714323580265045,
0.052284613251686096,
-0.6219501495361328,
-0.20667164027690887,
-0.4365142583847046,
-0.508080780506134,
-0.5856143236160278,
0.07385002076625824,
-0.12754209339618683,
-0.211504727602005,
0.027288982644677162,
0.19114741683006287,
-0.01966615952551365,
0.2815025746822357,
-0.5417006015777588,
0.40975090861320496,
1.020660638809204,
0.7126327157020569,
-0.37100958824157715,
-0.41362738609313965,
-0.3812190890312195,
0.10736650973558426,
-0.45963406562805176,
0.7251120209693909,
-0.44329503178596497,
-0.48856350779533386,
0.2125808745622635,
0.02956828474998474,
0.6058210730552673,
-0.6601293087005615,
0.5252872705459595,
-0.23983901739120483,
-0.3106471002101898,
-0.24349021911621094,
-0.4204617440700531,
0.3477986752986908,
0.3534280061721802,
-0.5780845284461975,
1.0242801904678345,
0.34683239459991455,
-0.8287768959999084,
0.4923289120197296,
-0.12659940123558044,
-0.38150081038475037,
0.06409543007612228,
-0.7105107307434082,
-0.6798936128616333,
0.215890571475029,
-0.08580105006694794,
0.16446013748645782,
-0.5384513735771179,
0.2870457172393799,
-0.1718454658985138,
-0.13814808428287506,
0.23229098320007324,
-0.1571124792098999,
0.5111204385757446,
0.48116472363471985,
-0.20854291319847107,
0.07053670287132263,
-0.48152032494544983,
0.1630011349916458,
-0.03467319533228874,
-0.33646827936172485,
-0.1529579758644104,
0.15142770111560822,
-0.1356843262910843,
0.06860029697418213,
0.4705061614513397,
-0.37627118825912476,
0.3194277584552765,
0.092821404337883,
0.4074609875679016,
0.7037878632545471,
-0.16819819808006287,
0.12954986095428467,
-0.5661268830299377,
0.7147195339202881,
-0.3044041693210602,
0.6985787749290466,
-0.2168128341436386,
-0.14948347210884094,
-0.4917488992214203,
-0.30215197801589966,
0.31065985560417175,
0.5284548401832581,
-0.7465142011642456,
0.24015048146247864,
-0.30875644087791443,
-0.7845412492752075,
-0.21912428736686707,
0.596610426902771,
0.5420670509338379,
0.06317421048879623,
-0.0339185893535614,
-0.5016874670982361,
-0.6264714598655701,
-0.8999826908111572,
-0.1340227574110031,
0.05077342689037323,
-0.029499396681785583,
0.15999360382556915,
0.4402906894683838,
-0.1299072951078415,
0.7344434857368469,
-0.21096861362457275,
-0.3094308376312256,
-0.10229729115962982,
-0.21290980279445648,
0.35042446851730347,
0.4790724813938141,
0.4138551950454712,
-0.6768575310707092,
-0.2826598882675171,
0.400924414396286,
-0.7646616101264954,
-0.3858768343925476,
0.04103275388479233,
0.011522668413817883,
0.08518945425748825,
0.6260380744934082,
0.0026451153680682182,
0.1394146829843521,
0.7643531560897827,
0.0007543228566646576,
0.5801712870597839,
-0.7289489507675171,
0.3504565954208374,
-0.8982222080230713,
0.11507371068000793,
0.035934071987867355,
-0.4348408579826355,
-0.3435696065425873,
0.26068493723869324,
0.46916449069976807,
-0.11651904881000519,
-0.4800375998020172,
0.05716555938124657,
-0.44735628366470337,
-0.40502408146858215,
-0.0025406861677765846,
0.010886477306485176,
-0.18267957866191864,
0.2605866491794586,
-0.06414138525724411,
0.7799595594406128,
0.6491934657096863,
-0.3685949444770813,
0.2344316840171814,
-0.06928309053182602,
-0.5585692524909973,
0.6385182738304138,
-0.8070666193962097,
0.1193460151553154,
-0.017263639718294144,
-0.13713230192661285,
-0.6137862205505371,
-0.21863813698291779,
0.15978752076625824,
-0.3015018701553345,
0.39085879921913147,
-0.29614850878715515,
-0.6183774471282959,
-0.5256553888320923,
-0.3322116732597351,
0.019837280735373497,
0.5635544061660767,
-0.37171074748039246,
0.3382638990879059,
0.4542054235935211,
-0.4232022166252136,
-0.4635339677333832,
-0.913994550704956,
0.13561180233955383,
-0.10175907611846924,
-0.5451645255088806,
0.13851997256278992,
-0.21576519310474396,
-0.17273567616939545,
-0.17936395108699799,
-0.37602129578590393,
-0.09922167658805847,
0.081691674888134,
0.39866751432418823,
0.07613582164049149,
0.09146688133478165,
-0.09783729165792465,
0.40529048442840576,
-0.1591631919145584,
-0.08940178155899048,
0.017298175022006035,
0.40755361318588257,
0.09865536540746689,
-0.5420077443122864,
-0.05221947655081749,
0.02024824544787407,
0.5927788615226746,
-0.6653617024421692,
0.17181378602981567,
-0.06480544060468674,
-0.1423434466123581,
-0.7325341105461121,
-0.3372868001461029,
0.40923213958740234,
-0.4818173348903656,
0.2702791392803192,
-0.35892021656036377,
-1.0613148212432861,
0.6643681526184082,
-0.09287534654140472,
0.3796418309211731,
0.02240113355219364,
0.5398420691490173,
0.41148024797439575,
0.4898431897163391,
0.43945035338401794,
0.056636516004800797,
0.6962605118751526,
-0.1451975405216217,
-0.1884801983833313,
-0.5018550157546997,
-0.1467975229024887,
-1.0634022951126099,
0.2065867930650711,
-0.6266994476318359,
-0.5331107378005981,
0.33937716484069824,
0.0191945917904377,
-0.2893970012664795,
0.7430804967880249,
-0.7827420830726624,
0.6229835748672485,
0.11230535805225372,
0.1358754187822342,
0.4648606777191162,
0.12682850658893585,
0.2942749857902527,
-0.1291910707950592,
-0.44161686301231384,
-0.5708912014961243,
1.3270381689071655,
0.32335561513900757,
0.6206539273262024,
0.15925464034080505,
0.9361693859100342,
0.7843341827392578,
0.5912100672721863,
-0.09215875715017319,
0.2425093948841095,
-0.48787423968315125,
-0.6309522986412048,
-0.02485775202512741,
-0.5718918442726135,
-0.7969768643379211,
0.043774522840976715,
-0.049470312893390656,
-0.6954229474067688,
-0.0354793481528759,
0.05546906962990761,
0.07632268220186234,
0.0012422131840139627,
-0.3728962540626526,
0.9670094847679138,
-0.3268356919288635,
-0.5275330543518066,
-0.2907024621963501,
-0.16947607696056366,
0.48194682598114014,
-0.5964970588684082,
0.4082179665565491,
0.1051362082362175,
-0.09269267320632935,
0.38820961117744446,
-0.7098772525787354,
0.45710012316703796,
0.036394666880369186,
-0.3242064118385315,
0.24812258780002594,
0.43678560853004456,
0.6851377487182617,
0.20817643404006958,
-0.2523505985736847,
0.17800743877887726,
0.17188681662082672,
-0.3026420474052429,
-0.2856217920780182,
1.1358643770217896,
-0.46363532543182373,
-0.29725220799446106,
-0.12893004715442657,
-0.054399680346250534,
0.06111405789852142,
0.2767353951931,
0.21546433866024017,
0.6777833104133606,
-0.16783758997917175,
-0.006873165722936392,
0.7844178676605225,
-0.32548725605010986,
-0.032451897859573364,
0.58463454246521,
-0.7914003729820251,
-0.5593740344047546,
0.9216907024383545,
0.3488186001777649,
0.26562896370887756,
0.07048768550157547,
-0.07908912748098373,
0.08485307544469833,
-0.9127358794212341,
-0.4843672215938568,
0.0022136580664664507,
-0.5618605017662048,
-0.2510473430156708,
-0.2075044959783554,
0.013639162294566631,
-0.12350891530513763,
-0.3120673894882202,
-0.6070076823234558,
-0.03575989603996277,
0.11937485635280609,
-0.052884455770254135,
0.4858766198158264,
1.0688135623931885,
-0.27597740292549133,
0.07933388650417328,
-0.5795612335205078,
0.372010737657547,
0.03327152505517006,
0.4215455949306488,
-0.48005178570747375,
-0.23987911641597748,
-0.23720209300518036,
-0.1152535155415535,
-0.10599172860383987,
-0.8155137896537781,
0.25094375014305115,
-0.27644237875938416,
0.6072016358375549,
-0.10631066560745239,
0.06882721185684204,
0.12628421187400818,
-0.2556496560573578,
0.6922888159751892,
0.11164865642786026,
-0.9657702445983887,
0.6244202852249146,
-0.37635338306427,
0.1762864887714386,
0.7981885671615601,
0.028623688966035843,
-0.39865973591804504,
-0.8038560152053833,
-0.6329713463783264,
-0.913209855556488,
0.48398932814598083,
0.4832160174846649,
0.0703933909535408,
0.04233371838927269,
0.3522995114326477,
0.31182414293289185,
0.4518764615058899,
-0.2538358271121979,
-0.2696473002433777,
0.03587945178151131,
-0.008636155165731907,
0.0866730660200119,
0.014979931525886059,
0.1278952658176422,
0.10019587725400925,
0.40312352776527405,
0.19540253281593323,
-0.06405086815357208,
0.25049886107444763,
0.0978967696428299,
-0.1286160796880722,
0.1417977660894394,
0.5732390284538269,
0.9413073062896729,
-0.09200961142778397,
0.04803318530321121,
0.11567028611898422,
-0.3431760370731354,
-0.11951093375682831,
-0.10895811766386032,
-0.18495604395866394,
0.1071767508983612,
0.13927708566188812,
0.3532780408859253,
-0.18967732787132263,
-0.7698913216590881,
0.6040599942207336,
-0.28704896569252014,
-0.06773132085800171,
-0.7147269248962402,
0.3815101683139801,
-0.15098723769187927,
0.2666603922843933,
0.19561432301998138,
0.09754198789596558,
-0.10420571267604828,
-0.3288816809654236,
0.462696373462677,
-0.15568026900291443,
-0.49917763471603394,
-0.12304778397083282,
0.6960949301719666,
0.03858277201652527,
-0.45507121086120605,
0.30823400616645813,
-0.13694505393505096,
-0.18274986743927002,
1.0534238815307617,
0.026554135605692863,
0.8547343015670776,
-0.10147795081138611,
0.21402215957641602,
0.375457763671875,
0.4016587436199188,
-0.21831688284873962,
0.5768371820449829,
-0.28610852360725403,
-0.2579118311405182,
-0.6385012865066528,
-0.4530232846736908,
-0.45380017161369324,
-0.14275822043418884,
-0.670444905757904,
0.3742467164993286,
-0.7369977235794067,
-0.19582772254943848,
-0.16937530040740967,
-0.07453310489654541,
-0.6066855192184448,
-0.09563758224248886,
0.09893862903118134,
1.1973990201950073,
-0.7616332173347473,
0.9801703095436096,
0.49241167306900024,
-0.41615375876426697,
-0.5837351083755493,
-0.40333858132362366,
-0.09116622805595398,
-0.4504215121269226,
0.1878499686717987,
-0.2276698350906372,
-0.006973851006478071,
-0.2424904704093933,
-0.7022210955619812,
-0.4975336194038391,
0.9925996661186218,
0.35093557834625244,
-0.890632688999176,
0.4772492051124573,
0.23109805583953857,
0.5986084938049316,
-0.25630488991737366,
0.163923442363739,
0.5842655301094055,
0.601639449596405,
-0.22817903757095337,
-1.0567939281463623,
-0.16734686493873596,
-0.4127848446369171,
0.19033539295196533,
0.4578248858451843,
-0.4747583866119385,
0.7217392325401306,
0.007602943107485771,
-0.01852179504930973,
0.2721141576766968,
0.5530214309692383,
0.35526663064956665,
0.19269771873950958,
0.13841675221920013,
0.3931061029434204,
0.8811299800872803,
-0.18194839358329773,
1.2582927942276,
-0.4195800721645355,
0.41379114985466003,
1.2859066724777222,
-0.4221145808696747,
0.6744107604026794,
0.4788283407688141,
-0.28880685567855835,
0.08554358780384064,
0.3070688843727112,
-0.07346739619970322,
0.406259149312973,
0.6964246034622192,
-0.17640632390975952,
-0.2262980043888092,
-0.009249506518244743,
-0.4469142258167267,
-0.048175908625125885,
0.18023553490638733,
-0.3942481577396393,
-0.23737293481826782,
-0.07682276517152786,
0.346266508102417,
0.4356686472892761,
-0.30821770429611206,
0.5157887935638428,
-0.08340304344892502,
-0.4543437063694,
0.3668895661830902,
-0.05253470316529274,
0.5464007258415222,
-0.928393542766571,
0.15586714446544647,
-0.5962099432945251,
0.3325737416744232,
-0.2828773856163025,
-1.0618363618850708,
0.5411403775215149,
0.4778776168823242,
-0.012079075910151005,
-0.1570107787847519,
0.43453681468963623,
-0.11261773854494095,
-0.36336320638656616,
0.19754791259765625,
0.33642998337745667,
0.17178231477737427,
0.21704474091529846,
-0.5361710786819458,
0.6859704256057739,
0.4484494924545288,
-0.2670924961566925,
0.3275719881057739,
0.7344595193862915,
-0.06053754687309265,
0.7476246953010559,
0.43590253591537476,
0.4184858798980713,
0.22029578685760498,
-0.061891019344329834,
0.8372117877006531,
-0.479838490486145,
-0.2593105435371399,
-0.43087953329086304,
0.36154934763908386,
-0.13307495415210724,
-0.7976595759391785,
0.6329656839370728,
0.7522267699241638,
1.1808018684387207,
-0.05193917080760002,
0.9752295613288879,
-0.4835011661052704,
0.42088770866394043,
-0.3865402340888977,
0.4331454634666443,
-0.6019364595413208,
0.5574049353599548,
-0.3184382915496826,
-0.7773774266242981,
-0.33500704169273376,
0.1520511507987976,
-0.19678732752799988,
-0.22613300383090973,
0.4190840721130371,
1.2791509628295898,
0.08074038475751877,
-0.15428093075752258,
0.30116626620292664,
0.0457870177924633,
0.5448213815689087,
0.5192097425460815,
0.9406978487968445,
-0.2941344380378723,
0.5557984113693237,
-0.4433552324771881,
-0.03334702178835869,
0.16279417276382446,
-0.9129061102867126,
-0.5477861762046814,
-0.43016523122787476,
-0.4226313531398773,
-0.38813069462776184,
0.33848369121551514,
0.7117211818695068,
0.3177025020122528,
-0.593591570854187,
-0.40524086356163025,
-0.4139518737792969,
0.1069723516702652,
-0.19659064710140228,
-0.034029241651296616,
0.08107196539640427,
-0.26418185234069824,
-0.6416940093040466,
0.19674061238765717,
0.1707489937543869,
-0.20144301652908325,
-0.48403802514076233,
-0.3814300000667572,
0.4520774185657501,
-0.10051974654197693,
0.045405905693769455,
0.5563437938690186,
-0.15524937212467194,
-0.015946192666888237,
-0.20693013072013855,
-0.47364678978919983,
0.09440293908119202,
1.106162667274475,
-0.569194495677948,
0.4389870762825012,
0.6142535209655762,
0.37117141485214233,
0.7197265028953552,
-0.3417253792285919,
0.4639618694782257,
-0.4399362802505493,
-0.128535196185112,
-0.014140642248094082,
0.3035022020339966,
0.15091358125209808,
-0.0591665543615818,
0.6751718521118164,
-0.2632875442504883,
-0.7247946262359619,
-0.7726477384567261,
0.29296794533729553,
-1.106563687324524,
-0.340224027633667,
0.933293879032135,
-0.1751914769411087,
-0.4905574917793274,
-0.10237584263086319,
-0.41287025809288025,
0.10010359436273575,
-0.34227555990219116,
0.46158552169799805,
0.2024737000465393,
0.3740038573741913,
-0.00644490122795105,
-0.7269517183303833,
0.35444533824920654,
0.08714372664690018,
-0.882537841796875,
0.4443381428718567,
0.7467001676559448,
0.4889869689941406,
-0.08904457837343216,
0.5334580540657043,
-0.46532830595970154,
0.3938652276992798,
0.026425767689943314,
0.51764315366745,
-0.4738832116127014,
-0.39124131202697754,
-0.31013160943984985,
0.2020326852798462,
0.48674485087394714,
0.2919493317604065
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10269v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10269v1
|
Markov Constraint as Large Language Model Surrogate
| 2024-06-11T16:09:53 | 2024-06-11T16:09:53 |
Alexandre Bonlarron, Jean-Charles Régin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
This paper presents NgramMarkov, a variant of the Markov constraints. It is
dedicated to text generation in constraint programming (CP). It involves a set
of n-grams (i.e., sequence of n words) associated with probabilities given by a
large language model (LLM). It limits the product of the probabilities of the
n-gram of a sentence. The propagator of this constraint can be seen as an
extension of the ElementaryMarkov constraint propagator, incorporating the LLM
distribution instead of the maximum likelihood estimation of n-grams. It uses a
gliding threshold, i.e., it rejects n-grams whose local probabilities are too
low, to guarantee balanced solutions. It can also be combined with a
"look-ahead" approach to remove n-grams that are very unlikely to lead to
acceptable sentences for a fixed-length horizon. This idea is based on the
MDDMarkovProcess constraint propagator, but without explicitly using an MDD
(Multi-Valued Decision Diagram). The experimental results show that the
generated text is valued in a similar way to the LLM perplexity function. Using
this new constraint dramatically reduces the number of candidate sentences
produced, improves computation times, and allows larger corpora or smaller
n-grams to be used. A real-world problem has been solved for the first time
using 4-grams instead of 5-grams.
|
[
-0.42862656712532043,
-0.8614756464958191,
0.7133088111877441,
-0.021666111424565315,
-0.3299250304698944,
-0.23573903739452362,
-0.3024660646915436,
-0.07330824434757233,
0.012892224825918674,
0.6615232229232788,
-0.803033173084259,
-0.7730979919433594,
-0.7163738012313843,
0.28976210951805115,
-0.1840740293264389,
1.3163000345230103,
-0.11610294133424759,
-0.18542499840259552,
-0.15117153525352478,
0.17204518616199493,
-0.34594643115997314,
-0.609258770942688,
0.03780388459563255,
-0.1915874481201172,
0.5135282874107361,
0.3988228738307953,
0.6571911573410034,
0.8616722822189331,
0.5241134762763977,
0.22733177244663239,
-0.17609256505966187,
0.2856317162513733,
-0.28448671102523804,
0.19341284036636353,
0.05269927531480789,
-0.49801430106163025,
-0.11896852403879166,
-0.034806206822395325,
0.9687861800193787,
0.6091464757919312,
-0.32622063159942627,
0.001099823391996324,
-0.17890483140945435,
0.6150310635566711,
-0.807926595211029,
0.151980459690094,
-0.5565952658653259,
0.20184747874736786,
-0.3332100808620453,
-0.1965395212173462,
-0.37142205238342285,
-0.3689512014389038,
-0.049681369215250015,
-0.5885827541351318,
-0.2327592670917511,
0.03821207582950592,
0.7274292707443237,
0.17749635875225067,
-0.5691028237342834,
-0.4756231904029846,
-0.7282302975654602,
0.9892988801002502,
-0.7205681800842285,
-0.0013077679323032498,
0.27945244312286377,
0.16619238257408142,
-0.5146639943122864,
-0.2818275988101959,
-0.6801893711090088,
-0.25841987133026123,
0.24051421880722046,
-0.054030999541282654,
-0.2193802446126938,
0.05280023440718651,
0.33756935596466064,
0.23750872910022736,
-0.5873680114746094,
0.1978558897972107,
-0.530296802520752,
-0.26606327295303345,
0.31963691115379333,
0.4397062063217163,
0.16859669983386993,
-0.4458141028881073,
-0.14828215539455414,
0.10538993775844574,
-0.8906487226486206,
-0.3711390197277069,
0.686782956123352,
0.22287960350513458,
0.17364245653152466,
0.896892786026001,
-0.38113513588905334,
1.0994375944137573,
-0.0020451326854526997,
-0.5000184774398804,
0.2256355583667755,
-0.19016362726688385,
-0.17522016167640686,
-0.0334467813372612,
0.6920415163040161,
0.4467271864414215,
0.21152633428573608,
0.3219624161720276,
0.03295852616429329,
0.3628435432910919,
-0.014882156625390053,
-0.8453229665756226,
-0.12420191615819931,
0.08206132799386978,
-0.2912488579750061,
-0.3197239637374878,
-0.16073641180992126,
-0.8285805583000183,
-0.2929646968841553,
-0.08399476855993271,
0.3786231279373169,
-0.5877010226249695,
0.08520431816577911,
0.29317793250083923,
0.19021201133728027,
-0.030752506107091904,
0.0032025007531046867,
-0.7920745611190796,
0.2681669294834137,
0.6810173988342285,
0.7358171343803406,
-0.14646434783935547,
-0.2536507546901703,
-0.7528785467147827,
0.26344650983810425,
-0.3326338231563568,
0.5968992114067078,
-0.7860527634620667,
-0.4837088882923126,
0.20397420227527618,
-0.4625808000564575,
0.1535111963748932,
-0.49881380796432495,
0.773565411567688,
-0.2270929366350174,
0.46051841974258423,
0.07711632549762726,
-0.7249168157577515,
0.046432144939899445,
0.36801841855049133,
-0.275132417678833,
0.8101349472999573,
0.04093659296631813,
-0.7408555746078491,
0.5697599649429321,
-0.13365459442138672,
-0.4873044490814209,
0.08122916519641876,
-0.30771902203559875,
-0.5858769416809082,
0.08809944987297058,
0.25450873374938965,
0.5640770196914673,
-0.5014164447784424,
0.5743229985237122,
-0.1575961858034134,
-0.04793578386306763,
0.31444892287254333,
-0.16943834722042084,
0.3250591456890106,
0.3992457687854767,
0.13104575872421265,
0.1146438717842102,
-1.2613892555236816,
0.17369526624679565,
-0.21414469182491302,
-0.9218504428863525,
-0.03818295896053314,
0.11409144848585129,
-0.05677761882543564,
0.20322825014591217,
0.0065573942847549915,
-0.5708470940589905,
0.3821849226951599,
-0.24384544789791107,
0.5722854137420654,
0.5380972623825073,
0.42990854382514954,
0.29771125316619873,
-0.24750956892967224,
0.7762784957885742,
-0.011978911235928535,
0.11661840230226517,
-0.3237130045890808,
-0.6216591596603394,
-0.5583335161209106,
-0.42269089818000793,
0.11148162186145782,
0.47522854804992676,
-0.8709238171577454,
0.5088768005371094,
-0.09269586205482483,
-0.36350634694099426,
-0.17622320353984833,
0.01217050664126873,
0.6253123879432678,
0.38664543628692627,
0.10328670591115952,
0.010411428287625313,
-0.7752901315689087,
-1.194059133529663,
-0.21780911087989807,
-0.09251059591770172,
0.12442586570978165,
-0.02382669225335121,
0.5209470987319946,
-0.061525557190179825,
0.654716968536377,
-0.9649458527565002,
-0.4948796331882477,
-0.3839055597782135,
0.25840476155281067,
0.4647098481655121,
0.7750416398048401,
0.2088633030653,
-0.735319972038269,
-0.39239081740379333,
-0.11827237159013748,
-0.23253805935382843,
-0.3751890957355499,
-0.11902227252721786,
0.19812417030334473,
0.5575364828109741,
0.5777558088302612,
-0.9113569259643555,
0.3419981896877289,
0.9067262411117554,
-0.1681424230337143,
0.8576942682266235,
-0.5308459401130676,
0.026211608201265335,
-1.1962515115737915,
0.015622122213244438,
0.18046686053276062,
-0.08408229798078537,
-0.8946048617362976,
0.17462405562400818,
-0.11835744231939316,
-0.26448455452919006,
-0.25578853487968445,
0.049642208963632584,
-0.6687936782836914,
0.11769157648086548,
-0.19243839383125305,
0.26095640659332275,
-0.2564239203929901,
0.3889467716217041,
-0.11003986746072769,
0.6542494297027588,
0.5164093971252441,
-0.7395802140235901,
0.10206975042819977,
0.389946311712265,
-0.7988231778144836,
0.7215214967727661,
-0.39098381996154785,
-0.16512857377529144,
-0.3030533492565155,
0.2695980966091156,
-0.8021198511123657,
-0.10725456476211548,
0.37670281529426575,
-0.4635676443576813,
0.32756367325782776,
-0.26580438017845154,
-0.7155172824859619,
-0.2191256582736969,
-0.019667698070406914,
0.334146112203598,
0.6674318909645081,
-0.1954822540283203,
0.22483377158641815,
0.46937012672424316,
0.03700600564479828,
-0.43729162216186523,
-0.9085060358047485,
0.3278653025627136,
-0.327274352312088,
-0.35608071088790894,
0.12630368769168854,
-0.19521231949329376,
-0.15918873250484467,
-0.0011423787800595164,
0.006777001544833183,
0.046623580157756805,
-0.2118268758058548,
0.16087235510349274,
0.20990823209285736,
-0.007818634621798992,
0.16782693564891815,
-0.04482070356607437,
-0.3707400858402252,
-0.17376808822155,
-0.5730600357055664,
0.6439523100852966,
0.16270719468593597,
-0.16932407021522522,
-0.487217515707016,
0.570156991481781,
0.3004627227783203,
-0.13721106946468353,
0.8756940364837646,
0.28948774933815,
-0.2540104389190674,
-0.2985796332359314,
-0.4505208730697632,
0.15342490375041962,
-0.4456064999103546,
0.6041616201400757,
-0.6708230972290039,
-1.1313259601593018,
0.20947006344795227,
0.08639180660247803,
-0.4156096875667572,
0.5183984637260437,
0.7718494534492493,
0.4596034586429596,
1.1064547300338745,
0.6106117963790894,
0.013833337463438511,
0.2710046172142029,
0.08922060579061508,
0.2322125881910324,
-1.089402675628662,
-0.3424461781978607,
-0.5937046408653259,
-0.18130239844322205,
-0.8398334980010986,
-0.5492236018180847,
0.4021676182746887,
0.05316101014614105,
-0.13049331307411194,
0.47449877858161926,
-0.5425591468811035,
0.41512826085090637,
0.6539229154586792,
-0.2138146609067917,
0.1869388222694397,
-0.2563484013080597,
-0.4369634985923767,
-0.4157842695713043,
-0.7307856678962708,
-0.4975912570953369,
1.0551183223724365,
-0.08111502230167389,
0.6198750734329224,
0.2947641611099243,
0.8375014662742615,
-0.04325784742832184,
0.09095918387174606,
-0.5087551474571228,
0.8319399952888489,
-0.12631551921367645,
-0.8454717397689819,
-0.04512227326631546,
-0.8408955335617065,
-0.8751716613769531,
0.276894748210907,
-0.4844808280467987,
-1.2629399299621582,
0.03811682388186455,
0.16318154335021973,
-0.12471586465835571,
0.3172265887260437,
-0.45451223850250244,
0.6885842084884644,
0.2684487998485565,
-0.20759674906730652,
-0.2464039921760559,
-0.4052034616470337,
0.5707486867904663,
-0.046891503036022186,
0.1820182502269745,
-0.2982390522956848,
-0.2027827799320221,
0.5214430093765259,
-0.44616734981536865,
0.7863102555274963,
0.0002555348619353026,
-0.2813558280467987,
0.36758309602737427,
0.43707823753356934,
0.7007980346679688,
-0.10916730016469955,
-0.08347170799970627,
-0.4588620960712433,
-0.05304844677448273,
-0.09916505962610245,
-0.4698069393634796,
0.9107135534286499,
-0.5010414123535156,
-0.9913727045059204,
-0.49921491742134094,
-0.7014469504356384,
-0.07075026631355286,
0.3890993893146515,
0.34902530908584595,
0.5695311427116394,
-0.14355197548866272,
0.27693799138069153,
0.24640999734401703,
-0.4208890199661255,
0.29492729902267456,
0.3146917223930359,
-0.5762950778007507,
-0.6864233016967773,
0.8090056777000427,
0.29344168305397034,
0.5743717551231384,
0.7041506767272949,
0.3759095370769501,
0.08576226979494095,
-0.9987779259681702,
-0.08858204632997513,
0.12475402653217316,
-0.8755941987037659,
-0.18717019259929657,
-0.6026283502578735,
-0.11678314208984375,
-0.2109624296426773,
-0.10166005045175552,
-0.05204711854457855,
-0.7536103129386902,
-0.4620554447174072,
0.00866811815649271,
0.23002201318740845,
0.6388571858406067,
-0.3163718581199646,
0.3155841827392578,
-0.6939773559570312,
0.18098333477973938,
0.013358565047383308,
0.27410438656806946,
-0.40832504630088806,
-0.45599445700645447,
-0.19477331638336182,
-0.34999290108680725,
-0.22844745218753815,
-0.7172892689704895,
0.6048377752304077,
0.2481224238872528,
0.4008537530899048,
0.5493572950363159,
0.14611732959747314,
0.5540652871131897,
-0.7419579029083252,
0.5979745984077454,
0.37786152958869934,
-1.0281996726989746,
0.3555639684200287,
-0.6929150223731995,
0.5953306555747986,
0.30987265706062317,
0.23010486364364624,
-0.7008426189422607,
-0.7068184018135071,
-0.44807565212249756,
-0.6476659774780273,
0.4135541617870331,
0.46751198172569275,
0.04807639867067337,
-0.3365442454814911,
0.612076997756958,
0.1472923308610916,
0.5243026614189148,
-0.5592319965362549,
-0.19028130173683167,
0.23307037353515625,
-0.20382389426231384,
-0.5748896598815918,
-0.6995795369148254,
0.004707802552729845,
-0.01799299567937851,
0.7711068987846375,
-0.12307902425527573,
-0.10584329068660736,
0.3092246353626251,
-0.015323230996727943,
-0.01987137459218502,
0.4348020851612091,
1.1092461347579956,
0.6989431977272034,
-0.16874922811985016,
0.35767287015914917,
-0.06408074498176575,
-0.41000640392303467,
0.15483835339546204,
-0.17537342011928558,
-0.3643362522125244,
-0.20213477313518524,
0.20803672075271606,
0.6575146913528442,
0.08472812175750732,
-0.6462660431861877,
0.19010211527347565,
0.37183448672294617,
-0.5203440189361572,
-0.22423219680786133,
-0.0020549336913973093,
0.0969761461019516,
0.21768373250961304,
0.30973994731903076,
-0.058782149106264114,
0.04528244957327843,
-0.5823331475257874,
0.25768232345581055,
0.4502132534980774,
-0.2279299795627594,
-0.3085085153579712,
0.8034818172454834,
-0.014801464974880219,
-0.42566731572151184,
0.28652456402778625,
-0.24472838640213013,
-0.6817927956581116,
0.5266431570053101,
0.7819861173629761,
0.7162101864814758,
-0.007168115582317114,
0.4502161145210266,
0.3801194131374359,
0.39220553636550903,
-0.09636025130748749,
0.33571135997772217,
0.22480247914791107,
-0.8328604102134705,
-0.6304718255996704,
-0.4651707708835602,
-0.33731406927108765,
0.014417613856494427,
-0.5276392102241516,
0.2478603720664978,
-0.7353798151016235,
-0.25876420736312866,
0.10810121893882751,
0.14539751410484314,
-0.17949405312538147,
0.12047439813613892,
0.14590024948120117,
0.5961468815803528,
-0.5966971516609192,
0.9987825155258179,
0.41076532006263733,
-0.21818356215953827,
-0.32869666814804077,
-0.05425790324807167,
0.34175950288772583,
-0.7499087452888489,
0.8272334933280945,
0.21766647696495056,
-0.06409498304128647,
0.07244294881820679,
-0.4052315652370453,
-0.8885871171951294,
0.7014655470848083,
0.3447888493537903,
-0.4521434009075165,
0.4109152555465698,
0.15065732598304749,
0.62416672706604,
-0.6033355593681335,
-0.5087361931800842,
0.49642929434776306,
0.6269382834434509,
0.16979223489761353,
-0.5377233624458313,
0.19440734386444092,
-0.10787400603294373,
0.35356929898262024,
0.7434367537498474,
-0.5013294816017151,
1.182347297668457,
-0.22545315325260162,
-0.3837181031703949,
0.4361230134963989,
0.49566519260406494,
0.3694019615650177,
-0.3262242376804352,
0.15851618349552155,
0.7029432654380798,
0.6386160850524902,
0.04640058055520058,
1.1975146532058716,
-0.2195126712322235,
0.4033355116844177,
1.062790870666504,
-0.3422968089580536,
0.7848070859909058,
0.9551621079444885,
-0.25058117508888245,
0.39379844069480896,
0.236738920211792,
-0.19751909375190735,
0.5468533039093018,
0.8354516625404358,
-0.2750367820262909,
-0.3093050718307495,
-0.15628091990947723,
-0.09855534136295319,
0.34998664259910583,
0.1973252147436142,
-0.08044088631868362,
-0.13035643100738525,
-0.06417623162269592,
0.3265753388404846,
0.4878106117248535,
-0.21632029116153717,
0.47400641441345215,
-0.00009927757491823286,
-0.7749510407447815,
0.538067102432251,
0.39154085516929626,
0.48937684297561646,
-0.605976402759552,
0.0859452486038208,
0.13680706918239594,
0.5623756051063538,
-0.02450268343091011,
-0.8190630078315735,
0.333261638879776,
-0.0967613086104393,
-0.16762912273406982,
-0.10965915769338608,
0.5454592108726501,
-0.5799060463905334,
-0.7829040884971619,
-0.14923657476902008,
0.17200158536434174,
0.1102370098233223,
0.17298701405525208,
-0.11079572886228561,
0.2217598408460617,
0.039474163204431534,
-0.34376487135887146,
0.4121755361557007,
0.512606143951416,
0.28271329402923584,
1.1098506450653076,
0.6315360069274902,
0.3843424916267395,
0.1357802152633667,
-0.40280166268348694,
0.7645800709724426,
-0.5911598205566406,
-0.6608269214630127,
-1.0123242139816284,
0.2962864637374878,
0.0902353823184967,
-0.5864055156707764,
0.8287909030914307,
0.5618528723716736,
0.47907784581184387,
-0.165347620844841,
0.7472729682922363,
-0.09039012342691422,
0.4038845896720886,
-0.908169686794281,
0.394713431596756,
-0.3128642141819,
0.2257518321275711,
-0.3580632209777832,
-1.0228973627090454,
-0.9607735276222229,
0.5407339930534363,
-0.41359150409698486,
-0.17051708698272705,
0.9667941927909851,
0.6402443051338196,
0.3372521996498108,
-0.3732495903968811,
0.6406280994415283,
0.043570660054683685,
0.28143301606178284,
1.0182242393493652,
0.797541618347168,
-0.05548153072595596,
0.8129399418830872,
-0.03036213293671608,
0.04286259412765503,
-0.15507405996322632,
-1.2559491395950317,
-1.0888816118240356,
-0.8260488510131836,
-0.48506659269332886,
-0.24918998777866364,
-0.0022453933488577604,
0.8003446459770203,
0.4086466133594513,
-0.5781373977661133,
-0.2793152630329132,
-0.29234179854393005,
0.09241795539855957,
0.0530921146273613,
-0.1622658520936966,
0.22979022562503815,
-0.1108362153172493,
-0.6964797973632812,
0.2341410368680954,
0.36422157287597656,
0.1516401320695877,
-0.34633997082710266,
-0.09009207785129547,
-0.5401664972305298,
0.1155267208814621,
0.3120499551296234,
0.2816173732280731,
-0.46766209602355957,
-0.6279392838478088,
-0.42798250913619995,
0.1549108773469925,
0.23183707892894745,
0.9697813391685486,
-0.5740846395492554,
0.33015114068984985,
0.3298282027244568,
0.4252777099609375,
0.6807109117507935,
-0.24463112652301788,
0.9015899896621704,
-0.8384786248207092,
0.538219153881073,
0.056533750146627426,
0.2583238482475281,
0.18543294072151184,
-0.21349863708019257,
0.03295077756047249,
0.14291469752788544,
-0.5366289019584656,
-0.9105909466743469,
0.7961764335632324,
-0.6287943720817566,
-0.3173464238643646,
1.3379560708999634,
0.024514030665159225,
-0.14952383935451508,
0.27769410610198975,
-0.20551319420337677,
-0.020283732563257217,
-0.37736746668815613,
0.5607107281684875,
0.9612758755683899,
0.1687750667333603,
-0.5083936452865601,
-0.6756321787834167,
0.49844789505004883,
0.28501877188682556,
-0.7146070599555969,
0.0010414746357128024,
0.7095553278923035,
0.16714000701904297,
0.1576027274131775,
0.41993603110313416,
-0.014306563884019852,
-0.11419807374477386,
0.12925247848033905,
0.14903147518634796,
-0.2832314372062683,
-0.2918168604373932,
-0.43700283765792847,
0.3828425109386444,
-0.030908288434147835,
-0.21977123618125916
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.07393v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.07393v2
|
Limited Out-of-Context Knowledge Reasoning in Large Language Models
| 2024-06-11T15:58:59 | 2024-06-24T14:59:54 |
Peng Hu, Changjiang Gao, Ruiqi Gao, Jiajun Chen, Shujian Huang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated strong capabilities as
knowledge bases and significant in-context reasoning capabilities. However,
previous work challenges their out-of-context reasoning ability, i.e., the
ability to infer information from their training data, instead of from the
context or prompt. This paper focuses on a significant facet of out-of-context
reasoning: Out-of-Context Knowledge Reasoning (OCKR), which is to combine
multiple knowledge to infer new knowledge. We designed a synthetic dataset with
seven representative OCKR tasks to systematically assess the OCKR capabilities
of LLMs. Using this dataset, we evaluated the LLaMA2-13B-chat model and
discovered that its proficiency in this aspect is limited, regardless of
whether the knowledge is trained in a separate or adjacent training settings.
Moreover, training the model to reason with complete reasoning data did not
result in significant improvement. Training the model to perform explicit
knowledge retrieval helps in only one of the tasks, indicating that the model's
limited OCKR capabilities are due to difficulties in retrieving relevant
knowledge. Furthermore, we treat cross-lingual knowledge transfer as a distinct
form of OCKR, and evaluate this ability. Our results show that the evaluated
model also exhibits limited ability in transferring knowledge across languages.
The dataset used in this study is available at
https://github.com/NJUNLP/ID-OCKR.
|
[
-0.3214420676231384,
-0.8226438760757446,
0.8112488985061646,
-0.1347503513097763,
-0.09973274916410446,
0.029420165345072746,
-0.40122517943382263,
-0.7183771133422852,
-0.42677178978919983,
0.6869256496429443,
-0.2908766567707062,
-0.07248365879058838,
-0.597317636013031,
-0.07162042707204819,
-0.3484135568141937,
0.7115352749824524,
-0.2568594515323639,
0.0296536386013031,
-0.5237575769424438,
-0.2086089849472046,
-0.6327618956565857,
-0.6859906315803528,
-0.3264070451259613,
-0.5794687271118164,
0.3576471209526062,
0.7073354721069336,
0.41827884316444397,
0.22222574055194855,
0.34724271297454834,
0.17743538320064545,
-0.2157926857471466,
0.457462877035141,
-0.7345293760299683,
0.029378853738307953,
-0.3064992427825928,
-0.44689834117889404,
-0.16809648275375366,
-0.5197362303733826,
0.7899221181869507,
0.8315297961235046,
0.16803835332393646,
0.06819571554660797,
0.12823085486888885,
0.5496950745582581,
-0.6703231334686279,
0.22289550304412842,
-0.8090217113494873,
-0.3207245469093323,
-0.12163054198026657,
0.10807325690984726,
-0.5569339394569397,
-0.13162672519683838,
0.37419918179512024,
-0.5398477911949158,
-0.32130855321884155,
0.08906808495521545,
0.5608932971954346,
0.18982231616973877,
-0.7490220069885254,
-0.4436323642730713,
-0.6426953673362732,
0.7641986012458801,
-0.8642285466194153,
0.5691068768501282,
0.5475562214851379,
0.5167185068130493,
-0.3469405770301819,
-0.3842345178127289,
-0.7173181176185608,
-0.2735254168510437,
-0.3677436113357544,
-0.2354179471731186,
-0.015530785545706749,
-0.2846432030200958,
0.37071096897125244,
0.003282896475866437,
-0.3807578384876251,
0.2026759535074234,
-0.49119436740875244,
0.13475088775157928,
0.6257696151733398,
-0.0452781543135643,
0.045419465750455856,
-0.131464883685112,
-0.5518656373023987,
0.05836595967411995,
-0.8104216456413269,
0.3155936300754547,
0.14191597700119019,
0.21892642974853516,
0.02066759392619133,
0.7515001893043518,
-0.3240910470485687,
0.7348661422729492,
-0.024646790698170662,
-0.42345714569091797,
-0.01065251138061285,
-0.2266288548707962,
-0.15405043959617615,
-0.0077331336215138435,
0.5336452722549438,
-0.002255242085084319,
0.027185820043087006,
-0.2530674934387207,
-0.17349401116371155,
-0.301179438829422,
-0.18377168476581573,
-0.4960819184780121,
0.18462686240673065,
0.04265977069735527,
-0.3426341116428375,
0.1945507675409317,
-0.08175390213727951,
-0.55678391456604,
-0.6334342360496521,
-0.1472516655921936,
0.588998556137085,
-0.5652350783348083,
-0.17257888615131378,
0.2241377979516983,
-0.14335468411445618,
0.2449120283126831,
0.3379696011543274,
-0.4952346086502075,
0.16605637967586517,
0.5381735563278198,
0.4073610305786133,
-0.22060269117355347,
-0.3236410617828369,
-0.33771398663520813,
0.20617246627807617,
-0.21519705653190613,
0.7320781350135803,
-0.6029794812202454,
-0.1799849569797516,
-0.09500519186258316,
-0.10418713092803955,
-0.2696065604686737,
-0.6344991326332092,
0.24249203503131866,
-0.6902905702590942,
0.09278389066457748,
-0.47796013951301575,
-0.674431562423706,
-0.4216570556163788,
0.029495883733034134,
-0.40310847759246826,
1.1799702644348145,
0.21448737382888794,
-0.7036185264587402,
0.48575329780578613,
-0.4963013827800751,
-0.45054301619529724,
0.06641697883605957,
-0.3406113088130951,
0.10411033779382706,
0.08126190304756165,
0.14897334575653076,
0.3845313489437103,
-0.5130882859230042,
0.4334469139575958,
-0.5791225433349609,
-0.39545688033103943,
0.5606738924980164,
-0.0852423682808876,
0.705608606338501,
0.10592826455831528,
-0.2953437268733978,
-0.17651882767677307,
-0.9033569097518921,
-0.03454345837235451,
0.1855383813381195,
-0.4681229591369629,
-0.6700305342674255,
-0.0031818929128348827,
-0.41864749789237976,
0.4317570924758911,
0.16594438254833221,
-0.570949375629425,
0.2828545868396759,
-0.2510124146938324,
0.6677627563476562,
0.29666242003440857,
-0.066681407392025,
0.7329174876213074,
-0.3371008038520813,
0.2216297835111618,
0.01900494284927845,
-0.03911067545413971,
-0.1557559072971344,
-0.588290810585022,
-0.8541563749313354,
-0.24589192867279053,
-0.04281170666217804,
0.514474630355835,
-1.0213326215744019,
0.4542678892612457,
-0.40041428804397583,
-0.304135799407959,
-0.3134448528289795,
0.22209137678146362,
0.40931427478790283,
0.6633794903755188,
0.48481786251068115,
-0.10159580409526825,
-0.42844662070274353,
-0.7211236953735352,
-0.12826469540596008,
-0.16015037894248962,
0.09566151350736618,
0.43601253628730774,
0.8135843276977539,
-0.1064264327287674,
1.1388400793075562,
-0.1676931083202362,
-0.3775336444377899,
-0.5475317239761353,
-0.11811240017414093,
0.1856960654258728,
0.27526265382766724,
0.20072831213474274,
-0.4824464023113251,
-0.3781028687953949,
0.2410566806793213,
-0.8676250576972961,
0.012490025721490383,
-0.12370659410953522,
-0.2227945327758789,
0.31030675768852234,
0.7963399887084961,
-0.5976329445838928,
0.47117188572883606,
0.5236096382141113,
-0.24285079538822174,
0.29479897022247314,
-0.2948066294193268,
-0.06880039721727371,
-0.5887923836708069,
0.214707151055336,
-0.48371657729148865,
-0.13679686188697815,
-0.6072529554367065,
0.011747605167329311,
0.1548110395669937,
0.07333225756883621,
-0.41648271679878235,
1.128417730331421,
-0.5513105392456055,
0.007716341409832239,
-0.23970578610897064,
0.25540852546691895,
0.0661509707570076,
0.5273494124412537,
0.2719723582267761,
0.4372459948062897,
0.3780832588672638,
-0.5186888575553894,
0.4061795473098755,
0.44366076588630676,
-0.8998379707336426,
0.6019884347915649,
-0.409821480512619,
0.3400493860244751,
-0.19062060117721558,
0.5227112770080566,
-1.171028971672058,
-0.3955802321434021,
0.0873199999332428,
-0.2826490104198456,
0.23286229372024536,
-0.18729010224342346,
-0.6199145913124084,
-0.3270129859447479,
0.18549396097660065,
0.6316418647766113,
0.5215744972229004,
-0.8134305477142334,
0.6970373392105103,
0.3106383681297302,
-0.0047033317387104034,
-0.42278385162353516,
-0.8286835551261902,
-0.3182618319988251,
-0.31946250796318054,
-0.8134525418281555,
0.16163334250450134,
0.15547430515289307,
-0.40428397059440613,
0.04326951503753662,
-0.16110087931156158,
-0.3379116356372833,
-0.22453361749649048,
0.09410978108644485,
0.06533292680978775,
-0.13724450767040253,
0.30397137999534607,
0.1059427410364151,
0.2859733998775482,
0.0733451321721077,
-0.19660724699497223,
0.22783270478248596,
0.016935864463448524,
-0.82136070728302,
0.04345604404807091,
0.3783726692199707,
0.44427192211151123,
-0.051906246691942215,
1.0313735008239746,
0.2203863263130188,
-0.2725016474723816,
-0.35209617018699646,
-0.8023176193237305,
-0.23643171787261963,
-0.37503039836883545,
0.40085649490356445,
-0.4467097222805023,
-1.1249140501022339,
0.6142506003379822,
0.1453947275876999,
-0.13318876922130585,
0.21253462135791779,
0.48257309198379517,
-0.009266954846680164,
0.9352529048919678,
0.3559477627277374,
0.11361093074083328,
0.2953011989593506,
-0.15911997854709625,
0.2902921736240387,
-0.9737245440483093,
-0.5868883728981018,
-0.336269348859787,
-0.05920033156871796,
-0.25430530309677124,
-0.5554590821266174,
0.47079363465309143,
0.28966349363327026,
-0.3681288957595825,
0.21842382848262787,
0.02847277745604515,
0.4837866425514221,
0.48354867100715637,
0.23031802475452423,
0.5528826117515564,
-0.21991004049777985,
-0.24125994741916656,
0.3388509154319763,
-1.074184775352478,
-0.29139459133148193,
0.7920634746551514,
0.4531254768371582,
0.7369562983512878,
0.1765064299106598,
0.3224310576915741,
-0.12236490100622177,
0.19550716876983643,
-0.7893735766410828,
0.5951403379440308,
0.10281454026699066,
-0.8946322202682495,
-0.4837913513183594,
-0.6379308700561523,
-0.8317625522613525,
0.42924535274505615,
-0.1270945817232132,
-0.932662308216095,
0.3147966265678406,
-0.07523291558027267,
-0.30886101722717285,
0.35482269525527954,
-0.7183805704116821,
0.6688443422317505,
-0.36061689257621765,
-0.22228361666202545,
0.004125745967030525,
-0.7967848777770996,
0.7005032300949097,
-0.41157153248786926,
0.6267845630645752,
-0.1309310793876648,
0.15895073115825653,
0.42125388979911804,
-0.3446096181869507,
0.996353030204773,
0.005410329904407263,
-0.4393137991428375,
0.35341978073120117,
0.1057044267654419,
0.7341612577438354,
-0.06495144218206406,
-0.053815051913261414,
0.2816384434700012,
-0.022818109020590782,
-0.25888752937316895,
-0.5654933452606201,
0.5209611654281616,
-0.6622560620307922,
-0.5582867860794067,
-0.17486180365085602,
-0.6671537756919861,
-0.5567928552627563,
0.13967777788639069,
0.3551676869392395,
0.2568945586681366,
0.09388154745101929,
0.5014341473579407,
0.545681357383728,
-0.3952014446258545,
0.16754312813282013,
0.5018324851989746,
-0.34992337226867676,
-0.30010703206062317,
0.676493227481842,
0.27447816729545593,
0.5675256252288818,
0.5942171812057495,
0.28013575077056885,
-0.6622931957244873,
-0.28523358702659607,
-0.45034053921699524,
0.3169970214366913,
-1.1922863721847534,
-0.09251086413860321,
-0.3442034125328064,
-0.25938186049461365,
-0.29811424016952515,
-0.05955744534730911,
-0.2404191941022873,
-0.29711776971817017,
-0.14362984895706177,
0.26371604204177856,
0.21866679191589355,
0.6770550608634949,
0.17531277239322662,
0.1628762185573578,
-0.8189073801040649,
0.08290185779333115,
0.3928205072879791,
0.25087693333625793,
0.25760748982429504,
-1.0512142181396484,
-0.276406466960907,
0.05739542096853256,
0.020408714190125465,
-0.8090408444404602,
0.12234411388635635,
0.09774651378393173,
0.8063225746154785,
0.3304915130138397,
0.33111870288848877,
0.7005494236946106,
-0.26672428846359253,
0.5641276240348816,
0.0813533142209053,
-0.8371702432632446,
0.23750023543834686,
-0.3576740026473999,
0.410941481590271,
0.3282657265663147,
0.3736180067062378,
-0.245154470205307,
-0.422931432723999,
-0.4285711646080017,
-0.8717570900917053,
0.8482356071472168,
0.11977589875459671,
-0.12833172082901,
0.12712392210960388,
0.2132512480020523,
0.3229493796825409,
0.032706134021282196,
-0.633708119392395,
0.10961022228002548,
0.037538789212703705,
0.18815115094184875,
-0.02765362709760666,
-0.33446988463401794,
-0.034807126969099045,
-0.30428966879844666,
0.6388935446739197,
-0.2612836956977844,
0.035452891141176224,
0.1044396311044693,
-0.3763767182826996,
-0.13030651211738586,
0.440232515335083,
0.5234193801879883,
0.8755877017974854,
-0.034536369144916534,
0.22349783778190613,
0.70597243309021,
-0.04771135747432709,
0.06529464572668076,
0.09827941656112671,
0.030506711453199387,
-0.32433417439460754,
0.5494497418403625,
0.9267901182174683,
0.3959137797355652,
-0.9046436548233032,
0.4752327799797058,
0.21003708243370056,
-0.1323784440755844,
-0.23127244412899017,
-0.04487853869795799,
0.09911219775676727,
0.5938488841056824,
0.3448069393634796,
-0.24210865795612335,
-0.13989412784576416,
-0.5832780599594116,
-0.24675340950489044,
0.4073422849178314,
-0.18032591044902802,
-0.10762164741754532,
0.44681334495544434,
-0.019554678350687027,
0.25168803334236145,
0.6045884490013123,
-0.10017862170934677,
-0.33254656195640564,
0.3126736581325531,
0.49588021636009216,
0.31075918674468994,
0.11871838569641113,
-0.23233680427074432,
0.23948608338832855,
0.24211807548999786,
-0.2599327564239502,
0.22853714227676392,
-0.2165473848581314,
-0.8915718197822571,
-0.6711887121200562,
-0.4469664394855499,
-0.4710753560066223,
0.5473979115486145,
-0.5818176865577698,
0.3987131714820862,
-0.07052014023065567,
-0.026817966252565384,
-0.2061760425567627,
-0.3572523891925812,
-0.6699286699295044,
0.015437071211636066,
0.1429339349269867,
0.9358296990394592,
-0.52006596326828,
1.0508373975753784,
0.7062463760375977,
-0.28859052062034607,
-0.6852586269378662,
-0.15582430362701416,
-0.05735403299331665,
-0.9749158024787903,
0.8978762030601501,
0.0510798804461956,
-0.07175415009260178,
-0.15843984484672546,
-0.34866994619369507,
-1.0533967018127441,
0.9366061687469482,
0.5362128615379333,
-0.5699830055236816,
-0.06953299790620804,
0.3175342082977295,
0.3911527395248413,
-0.37443092465400696,
0.2757066488265991,
0.7170723676681519,
0.49146610498428345,
0.5196033716201782,
-1.2934658527374268,
0.18173669278621674,
0.057689275592565536,
-0.001148805022239685,
0.010832997038960457,
-0.5069317817687988,
0.8409021496772766,
-0.44631075859069824,
-0.1124076098203659,
0.08169704675674438,
0.44819602370262146,
0.4105871319770813,
0.1260925531387329,
0.48324570059776306,
0.40337496995925903,
0.6643156409263611,
0.09562608599662781,
0.9727974534034729,
0.08306955546140671,
0.146875262260437,
1.34767484664917,
-0.5722001791000366,
1.038217306137085,
0.5827193856239319,
0.1347302496433258,
0.5650695562362671,
0.33059531450271606,
0.33874887228012085,
0.537451446056366,
0.03892439976334572,
-0.18211372196674347,
-0.4394274652004242,
-0.16933968663215637,
-0.4845646321773529,
0.7272679805755615,
0.2720041573047638,
-0.22506049275398254,
-0.1975090354681015,
0.08342558890581131,
0.12039966136217117,
-0.1773153692483902,
-0.1699996143579483,
0.9457563161849976,
0.20401589572429657,
-0.7557694911956787,
0.7908669710159302,
-0.1856091022491455,
0.38820481300354004,
-0.5798898935317993,
-0.032587841153144836,
-0.1959245651960373,
0.5018342733383179,
-0.07912479341030121,
-0.8301383852958679,
0.3415432274341583,
-0.12045209854841232,
-0.018034111708402634,
-0.2296537607908249,
0.9525980353355408,
-0.5454036593437195,
-0.2015148550271988,
0.5491786599159241,
0.7738680243492126,
0.08452125638723373,
-0.17919398844242096,
-0.14278851449489594,
-0.050297584384679794,
-0.300201952457428,
-0.2618642747402191,
0.6552082896232605,
0.8398721814155579,
-0.37206876277923584,
0.6730575561523438,
0.6628785729408264,
0.10720358788967133,
-0.017569467425346375,
-0.04976382851600647,
0.9898912310600281,
-0.5005716681480408,
-0.43381360173225403,
-0.8143972754478455,
0.372236430644989,
0.1571846306324005,
-0.1668255627155304,
0.7987188696861267,
0.32029932737350464,
1.189038634300232,
-0.09574992209672928,
1.030360221862793,
-0.05080895498394966,
0.6382353901863098,
-0.6062474846839905,
0.6651673316955566,
-0.683424711227417,
0.32863444089889526,
0.08390410244464874,
-0.5755574107170105,
0.045139577239751816,
0.6987181305885315,
-0.5966070294380188,
0.0575859509408474,
0.8034947514533997,
0.5274193286895752,
-0.13349251449108124,
-0.041652947664260864,
0.6170371174812317,
0.3561037480831146,
0.046069465577602386,
0.9246926307678223,
1.353487491607666,
-0.030003519728779793,
0.750980019569397,
-0.10759513080120087,
-0.23037783801555634,
-0.3739272356033325,
-1.0224623680114746,
-1.2609789371490479,
-0.5876209139823914,
0.08504467457532883,
-0.2790909707546234,
-0.18069621920585632,
0.8408188223838806,
0.7892120480537415,
-0.7275643944740295,
-0.35747742652893066,
-0.0480150543153286,
0.18468981981277466,
-0.08890003710985184,
-0.17561006546020508,
0.05879183113574982,
-0.22871145606040955,
-0.17301246523857117,
0.7097253799438477,
-0.0016480013728141785,
-0.2171882838010788,
-0.24073389172554016,
-0.14505167305469513,
-0.12607677280902863,
0.15426330268383026,
0.7254043817520142,
0.2727176547050476,
-0.7685568332672119,
-0.4167805314064026,
0.09683888405561447,
0.05156678333878517,
-0.14374122023582458,
0.8069685697555542,
-0.6916496753692627,
0.37528401613235474,
0.7225306034088135,
0.5161939263343811,
0.5796321630477905,
-0.2924722731113434,
0.35390591621398926,
-0.7490974068641663,
0.0339813195168972,
0.027279093861579895,
0.4639793932437897,
0.305277556180954,
-0.17106746137142181,
0.23245936632156372,
0.15766800940036774,
-0.47394996881484985,
-0.8571903705596924,
0.2353566586971283,
-0.656287670135498,
-0.4411550462245941,
1.7088552713394165,
-0.2823231518268585,
-0.06443271785974503,
-0.5140544772148132,
-0.3404119908809662,
0.15925532579421997,
-0.42245519161224365,
0.7116679549217224,
0.8157183527946472,
-0.35426852107048035,
-0.18682807683944702,
-0.593787431716919,
0.32852110266685486,
0.17015065252780914,
-1.0036933422088623,
0.13463439047336578,
0.41033199429512024,
0.299414724111557,
0.030897732824087143,
0.5926014184951782,
-0.02608252316713333,
0.035923756659030914,
-0.13226132094860077,
-0.228360116481781,
-0.20124316215515137,
-0.4428011178970337,
-0.20691165328025818,
0.10297608375549316,
0.008778611198067665,
0.20361101627349854
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.07378v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.07378v1
|
Large Language Models for Constrained-Based Causal Discovery
| 2024-06-11T15:45:24 | 2024-06-11T15:45:24 |
Kai-Hendrik Cohrs, Gherardo Varando, Emiliano Diaz, Vasileios Sitokonstantinou, Gustau Camps-Valls
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Causality is essential for understanding complex systems, such as the
economy, the brain, and the climate. Constructing causal graphs often relies on
either data-driven or expert-driven approaches, both fraught with challenges.
The former methods, like the celebrated PC algorithm, face issues with data
requirements and assumptions of causal sufficiency, while the latter demand
substantial time and domain knowledge. This work explores the capabilities of
Large Language Models (LLMs) as an alternative to domain experts for causal
graph generation. We frame conditional independence queries as prompts to LLMs
and employ the PC algorithm with the answers. The performance of the LLM-based
conditional independence oracle on systems with known causal graphs shows a
high degree of variability. We improve the performance through a proposed
statistical-inspired voting schema that allows some control over false-positive
and false-negative rates. Inspecting the chain-of-thought argumentation, we
find causal reasoning to justify its answer to a probabilistic query. We show
evidence that knowledge-based CIT could eventually become a complementary tool
for data-driven causal discovery.
|
[
-0.07921265065670013,
-0.9018993973731995,
1.2427939176559448,
0.3218192756175995,
0.018708502873778343,
-0.1310865879058838,
-0.4722367227077484,
-0.518985390663147,
0.26011160016059875,
0.6296579837799072,
-0.499508798122406,
-0.5709633231163025,
-0.592104434967041,
0.1005307137966156,
-0.19537977874279022,
0.5276380777359009,
-0.02291901409626007,
-0.09438848495483398,
-0.12872754037380219,
0.1768912822008133,
-0.48883384466171265,
-0.41584813594818115,
-0.8836848139762878,
-0.36104169487953186,
0.8865445852279663,
0.3607848882675171,
0.5830230116844177,
0.6520476341247559,
0.29228174686431885,
0.2987702488899231,
0.19220329821109772,
0.21708664298057556,
-0.4822060465812683,
0.20266582071781158,
-0.7499592304229736,
-0.4229743182659149,
-0.11952414363622665,
-0.09516841173171997,
0.32609355449676514,
0.9239753484725952,
-0.0186289232224226,
-0.23847459256649017,
-0.04089078679680824,
0.593300998210907,
-0.5716087818145752,
0.8082993030548096,
-0.7532812356948853,
-0.2811000943183899,
-0.3091922998428345,
-0.24069559574127197,
-0.5775470733642578,
-0.3448829650878906,
0.03019602783024311,
-0.5714176297187805,
0.2734847366809845,
0.14316940307617188,
0.5242063403129578,
0.47014567255973816,
-0.9577726125717163,
-0.2751184105873108,
-0.9303649663925171,
0.6442590951919556,
-0.5879992246627808,
0.40534061193466187,
0.3876095712184906,
0.24577131867408752,
-0.4853678047657013,
-0.7425838112831116,
-0.7328789234161377,
-0.33904239535331726,
-0.059625495225191116,
0.025802109390497208,
-0.053460922092199326,
0.140249103307724,
0.17330878973007202,
-0.10537112504243851,
-0.3605763018131256,
0.4154593348503113,
-0.086592897772789,
-0.3060300350189209,
0.697320282459259,
0.32546406984329224,
0.2495688945055008,
-0.16806970536708832,
-0.20226269960403442,
0.18107382953166962,
-1.1462069749832153,
-0.2701336741447449,
0.24121026694774628,
0.645704448223114,
0.048032645136117935,
0.7032583951950073,
-0.35676121711730957,
0.7748355269432068,
-0.0555526502430439,
-0.08215451240539551,
-0.4776642322540283,
0.04176003485918045,
-0.05303506925702095,
0.0021418302785605192,
0.7290257811546326,
0.048674099147319794,
-0.01017056219279766,
-0.2897506356239319,
-0.056629449129104614,
0.15381638705730438,
-0.35221362113952637,
-0.670851469039917,
-0.43236878514289856,
0.043483443558216095,
-0.12288712710142136,
0.16946589946746826,
-0.002470033010467887,
-0.4405694305896759,
-0.7223212718963623,
-0.7132243514060974,
0.27187106013298035,
-0.17652489244937897,
-0.26184624433517456,
0.2638292610645294,
-0.07862775027751923,
-0.02110487036406994,
0.4916330575942993,
-0.601649820804596,
0.10298933833837509,
0.6299915909767151,
0.37416407465934753,
-0.06571085005998611,
-0.1133425161242485,
-0.5206490755081177,
0.4173315167427063,
-0.47195467352867126,
0.7343149781227112,
-0.578219473361969,
0.01901315338909626,
-0.051800891757011414,
0.0326523631811142,
-0.09654016047716141,
-0.23138415813446045,
0.46321621537208557,
-0.752944827079773,
0.05261663720011711,
-0.8398177623748779,
-0.7005549073219299,
-0.20064498484134674,
-0.047790080308914185,
-0.5958438515663147,
0.5043891668319702,
-0.18511994183063507,
-0.8527992367744446,
0.667013943195343,
-0.24694226682186127,
-0.5358384251594543,
0.16371159255504608,
-0.45947331190109253,
-0.0155553063377738,
-0.12413594126701355,
-0.008817997761070728,
0.43049144744873047,
-0.9631936550140381,
1.0410958528518677,
-0.6766124367713928,
0.1232018917798996,
-0.009397007524967194,
-0.5148453116416931,
0.9629740118980408,
0.11875440180301666,
-0.6807240843772888,
-0.09784659743309021,
-0.863885760307312,
-0.28860166668891907,
-0.00794613640755415,
-0.2617914378643036,
-0.5222461819648743,
0.7870449423789978,
-0.30486273765563965,
0.13865090906620026,
0.2912268340587616,
-0.6136854887008667,
0.23589497804641724,
-0.042843326926231384,
0.21055015921592712,
0.9100394248962402,
0.10865595936775208,
-0.03977636620402336,
0.10277494788169861,
0.15583616495132446,
-0.07879291474819183,
0.05530213564634323,
0.3805065453052521,
-0.4900088906288147,
-0.812654435634613,
-0.2552368640899658,
-0.01623123325407505,
0.6437004804611206,
-1.0082987546920776,
0.4732339084148407,
-0.15958547592163086,
-0.33292192220687866,
0.26646512746810913,
-0.07816816121339798,
0.24230889976024628,
0.7302598357200623,
0.1805388331413269,
0.03963147848844528,
-0.5842005014419556,
-0.935128927230835,
-0.20586930215358734,
-0.49816039204597473,
0.06491903960704803,
0.489767462015152,
0.3841349184513092,
-0.26295462250709534,
1.0729421377182007,
-0.8831565976142883,
-0.03484245762228966,
-0.06144590675830841,
0.010536820627748966,
0.4252960681915283,
0.3143433928489685,
0.2223902940750122,
-0.742948591709137,
-0.22176872193813324,
0.019300376996397972,
-0.8660008907318115,
-0.45650675892829895,
-0.17208999395370483,
-0.025062179192900658,
0.002085114363580942,
0.8636540174484253,
-0.6976043581962585,
0.3372887969017029,
0.27339088916778564,
-0.5033946633338928,
0.7197163701057434,
-0.2621058523654938,
-0.0796816498041153,
-0.701134979724884,
0.20368751883506775,
0.04869302362203598,
-0.17838363349437714,
-0.4241717755794525,
0.011438333429396152,
-0.10620061308145523,
-0.021658653393387794,
-0.08562599122524261,
0.46800392866134644,
-0.44730451703071594,
0.1408899575471878,
-0.27104735374450684,
0.1499706357717514,
-0.33769160509109497,
0.4262448251247406,
0.31910985708236694,
0.21871520578861237,
0.5037094354629517,
-0.7045484781265259,
0.2148756980895996,
0.08328225463628769,
-0.3072895407676697,
0.43590790033340454,
-0.708499550819397,
-0.029168613255023956,
-0.19841831922531128,
0.3601432144641876,
-0.8431637287139893,
-0.42501476407051086,
-0.11128006130456924,
0.023601988330483437,
0.22525595128536224,
-0.12136299908161163,
-0.7935085892677307,
-0.32044780254364014,
0.31908607482910156,
0.2691120207309723,
0.056650348007678986,
-0.8309940099716187,
0.3581475019454956,
0.5521659255027771,
-0.14157402515411377,
-0.44804295897483826,
-0.31734710931777954,
0.3730001747608185,
-0.06386701762676239,
-0.721444845199585,
0.21523423492908478,
-0.05118990316987038,
-0.4535048007965088,
-0.10703373700380325,
0.07532176375389099,
0.11183760315179825,
0.1016029566526413,
0.2979891300201416,
0.07821012288331985,
-0.11725948005914688,
0.3928300738334656,
-0.0020859374199062586,
-0.17017020285129547,
0.2777006924152374,
-0.573063313961029,
0.3656085729598999,
0.10550723969936371,
-0.5481221675872803,
-0.08976107090711594,
0.5229308605194092,
0.5591527223587036,
0.020470933988690376,
0.7105790972709656,
0.1024133712053299,
-0.40528494119644165,
-0.2610226273536682,
-0.7230842113494873,
-0.13503070175647736,
-0.427150160074234,
0.09497647732496262,
-0.1024714782834053,
-1.0870083570480347,
0.5286803841590881,
-0.2785363793373108,
-0.27321815490722656,
0.6060078144073486,
0.6543954610824585,
0.35353487730026245,
1.0653258562088013,
0.6398789882659912,
-0.02580423466861248,
0.16800431907176971,
0.2150067239999771,
0.5751133561134338,
-0.20918484032154083,
-0.2652987241744995,
-0.6413127183914185,
0.11780424416065216,
-0.8766136765480042,
-0.34305089712142944,
0.5670800805091858,
0.052610382437705994,
-0.7319554686546326,
0.018789036199450493,
-0.1706276386976242,
0.3531530201435089,
0.5632023215293884,
0.38030102849006653,
0.2929454445838928,
-0.38061296939849854,
-0.12806487083435059,
0.23152875900268555,
-0.7749034762382507,
-0.19953596591949463,
0.7731978297233582,
-0.12798866629600525,
0.7790903449058533,
0.2619531452655792,
0.4762134253978729,
0.15549935400485992,
0.3672569990158081,
-0.3637252748012543,
0.6571948528289795,
-0.16973906755447388,
-0.7629861235618591,
-0.3230423033237457,
-0.5863369107246399,
-0.9296652674674988,
-0.05294822156429291,
-0.2914310693740845,
-0.8611236810684204,
0.7161254286766052,
0.16616782546043396,
0.005676314700394869,
0.3964077830314636,
-0.6866043210029602,
0.5624622702598572,
-0.04321417957544327,
-0.7704303860664368,
-0.1851833462715149,
-0.7296319007873535,
0.6759347319602966,
-0.10520463436841965,
0.15682649612426758,
0.05417323857545853,
0.3090994656085968,
0.590000331401825,
-0.7853602766990662,
1.4055840969085693,
-0.3180595338344574,
-0.006006679497659206,
0.41842296719551086,
0.08578192442655563,
0.9240691661834717,
0.24607250094413757,
-0.05679596960544586,
-0.11749919503927231,
-0.2437252700328827,
-0.33344176411628723,
-0.4059329330921173,
0.8399797677993774,
-0.5889135003089905,
-1.1343870162963867,
-0.22638052701950073,
-0.3861994445323944,
-0.35807934403419495,
0.48962804675102234,
0.04433843120932579,
0.31164464354515076,
-0.1410103738307953,
0.09054406732320786,
0.5792457461357117,
-0.4132678210735321,
0.28964999318122864,
0.896060585975647,
-0.05203969404101372,
-0.21608838438987732,
0.7933699488639832,
0.09112390130758286,
0.12605473399162292,
0.5854052901268005,
0.5356218218803406,
-0.17699585855007172,
-0.35296255350112915,
0.07765775918960571,
0.36218035221099854,
-0.6546475887298584,
-0.35271257162094116,
-0.5741812586784363,
0.11055310070514679,
-0.3982866108417511,
-0.08460162580013275,
-0.2984505295753479,
-0.5657886266708374,
-0.2837222218513489,
-0.3484211266040802,
0.37011101841926575,
0.8040481805801392,
-0.43698233366012573,
0.08418864011764526,
-0.2946726679801941,
0.168650284409523,
0.6091488599777222,
0.2674839198589325,
0.08158738911151886,
0.24753345549106598,
-0.23591767251491547,
-0.2701667845249176,
-0.1016772910952568,
-1.044230580329895,
0.3786693215370178,
-0.026883568614721298,
0.3988494575023651,
0.5874022245407104,
0.33183586597442627,
0.5378790497779846,
-0.5034037828445435,
0.6670263409614563,
0.17699860036373138,
-0.9474608898162842,
0.39137905836105347,
-0.6289678812026978,
-0.1373150497674942,
0.22384393215179443,
0.3867078125476837,
-0.31961193680763245,
-0.5791797637939453,
-0.6325981616973877,
-0.886939287185669,
0.22300638258457184,
-0.04029487073421478,
-0.38827288150787354,
-0.4021197557449341,
0.506543755531311,
0.15327925980091095,
0.022138191387057304,
-0.616278350353241,
-0.12454819679260254,
0.206585094332695,
0.17452849447727203,
-0.1624140590429306,
-0.1953042596578598,
-0.22252987325191498,
-0.2151683270931244,
0.5405099391937256,
-0.23272989690303802,
0.024915752932429314,
0.5348177552223206,
0.05162506550550461,
-0.1309155970811844,
0.23710408806800842,
0.39867690205574036,
0.8072802424430847,
-0.10913578420877457,
0.45520809292793274,
-0.20484624803066254,
-0.03317555412650108,
0.01052919588983059,
0.23899608850479126,
-0.3079783022403717,
-0.31446778774261475,
0.4852830767631531,
0.7612065076828003,
-0.04786844551563263,
-0.5670884251594543,
0.40327730774879456,
0.031013963744044304,
-0.005871351808309555,
-0.4038048982620239,
-0.016138920560479164,
0.2311035692691803,
0.36672237515449524,
0.3839373290538788,
-0.08848651498556137,
0.07390525192022324,
-0.5021265745162964,
0.09925196319818497,
0.5248234868049622,
-0.21102501451969147,
-0.40071797370910645,
0.984927237033844,
0.04797971621155739,
-0.04784112423658371,
0.5448417067527771,
-0.1456672102212906,
-0.551334023475647,
0.7076213955879211,
0.5688053369522095,
0.7207930088043213,
-0.19802211225032806,
0.1344521939754486,
0.24429857730865479,
0.5038336515426636,
-0.19889412820339203,
0.38365408778190613,
0.09744587540626526,
-0.8051623106002808,
-0.6671925783157349,
-0.17494083940982819,
-0.3532469570636749,
0.002046256558969617,
-0.4066925644874573,
0.3542860150337219,
-0.4430728554725647,
-0.07672375440597534,
-0.04057302325963974,
-0.0369986817240715,
-0.8804358839988708,
0.3223262131214142,
-0.11986710131168365,
0.6888309717178345,
-1.1792340278625488,
0.776387095451355,
0.07857047766447067,
-0.3096470534801483,
-1.0295016765594482,
-0.3513772785663605,
-0.039047155529260635,
-0.5753905177116394,
0.8951553106307983,
-0.18568818271160126,
-0.04019390791654587,
-0.23651203513145447,
-0.8299258947372437,
-0.8693089485168457,
1.0579253435134888,
0.6461905241012573,
-0.8015811443328857,
0.17640568315982819,
-0.029260126873850822,
0.5912976264953613,
-0.2482559233903885,
0.09623632580041885,
0.6090918779373169,
0.7377241849899292,
-0.24507659673690796,
-0.6080743670463562,
0.448406457901001,
0.12215714156627655,
-0.33868980407714844,
0.22370590269565582,
-0.7282593846321106,
0.8929861187934875,
-0.3800522983074188,
-0.20139271020889282,
-0.36393362283706665,
0.8224755525588989,
0.3129125237464905,
0.5543113350868225,
0.5846746563911438,
0.36383524537086487,
1.081865668296814,
0.14018948376178741,
1.2405697107315063,
-0.30777013301849365,
0.36039498448371887,
1.1437292098999023,
-0.5429063439369202,
0.6088491082191467,
0.5292955040931702,
-0.16239911317825317,
0.5921764969825745,
0.5909292697906494,
0.4026629328727722,
0.39574679732322693,
0.3348733186721802,
-0.41121652722358704,
-0.7601110935211182,
-0.14516198635101318,
0.028621139004826546,
0.22903846204280853,
0.5862494707107544,
-0.2917154133319855,
-0.1476300209760666,
-0.28145530819892883,
0.26491880416870117,
-0.013702454045414925,
-0.09473156929016113,
0.5355110168457031,
0.19734355807304382,
-0.8926079869270325,
0.3655380308628082,
0.016132820397615433,
0.07999444752931595,
-0.49962499737739563,
-0.007824989967048168,
-0.24329620599746704,
0.1161026656627655,
-0.15532885491847992,
-0.4252724349498749,
0.12348897010087967,
-0.16937074065208435,
-0.3581111431121826,
-0.0334065780043602,
0.6815038323402405,
-0.381233811378479,
-0.5501836538314819,
0.36450091004371643,
0.5966934561729431,
-0.11387576162815094,
0.08432015776634216,
-0.08718615770339966,
-0.26718416810035706,
0.11145097017288208,
-0.22753065824508667,
0.17400220036506653,
0.697870135307312,
-0.45221146941185,
0.6936048865318298,
0.6344611644744873,
0.2553328573703766,
-0.0760660320520401,
0.0380113422870636,
0.9214898943901062,
-0.6422040462493896,
-0.4596188962459564,
-0.8406447768211365,
0.09245377779006958,
-0.03309294953942299,
-0.01216734480112791,
0.684207558631897,
0.4281856417655945,
0.2687727212905884,
-0.006417242810130119,
0.9090321660041809,
-0.21221226453781128,
0.40753811597824097,
-0.7489155530929565,
0.4268801808357239,
-0.36868909001350403,
0.570833146572113,
-0.3615897297859192,
-0.535506546497345,
-0.6250872015953064,
-0.006041585933417082,
-0.6463817954063416,
-0.2111007273197174,
0.8200823068618774,
0.9459876418113708,
0.12596338987350464,
0.008834609761834145,
0.1536504030227661,
0.5820237398147583,
0.9315022230148315,
0.7391530275344849,
0.6929751634597778,
0.2455219030380249,
0.30782845616340637,
0.015031630173325539,
-0.571585476398468,
-0.0028265102300792933,
-1.2551651000976562,
-0.7955622673034668,
-0.7699545621871948,
-0.3822243809700012,
-0.23171214759349823,
0.08885826170444489,
0.7052035927772522,
0.50870680809021,
-0.5918945670127869,
-0.2101525366306305,
-0.44721102714538574,
0.5337436199188232,
-0.06271019577980042,
-0.21030309796333313,
0.9210366606712341,
-0.21427325904369354,
-0.41457298398017883,
0.5952717065811157,
0.24112845957279205,
-0.4642395079135895,
-0.18512767553329468,
0.21296723186969757,
-0.06948741525411606,
0.2841323912143707,
0.703625500202179,
0.5644015073776245,
-0.46727392077445984,
-0.6681870818138123,
-0.2654170095920563,
0.1394348442554474,
-0.41799455881118774,
1.2170636653900146,
-0.6626545190811157,
0.3321066200733185,
0.6983147859573364,
0.39485037326812744,
0.599962055683136,
-0.3358142375946045,
0.7831388711929321,
-0.4607941508293152,
0.11813492327928543,
0.08470182865858078,
0.7031658291816711,
0.28760623931884766,
-0.5250805616378784,
0.38493698835372925,
0.4927365779876709,
-0.843946635723114,
-0.5730924010276794,
0.5064558386802673,
-0.990436315536499,
-0.40457409620285034,
1.1480799913406372,
-0.02700573205947876,
-0.12166032940149307,
-0.39786115288734436,
0.016533924266695976,
0.15240339934825897,
-0.15349628031253815,
0.8052955269813538,
0.45456916093826294,
-0.37601491808891296,
0.18136323988437653,
-0.294657438993454,
0.3356793224811554,
0.16426591575145721,
-0.6689572930335999,
0.33330434560775757,
0.8125427961349487,
0.25298792123794556,
-0.0016083404188975692,
0.6973798871040344,
0.06148635223507881,
-0.04128086194396019,
-0.09812624007463455,
0.0007334300316870213,
0.18650569021701813,
-0.37022680044174194,
0.2809993624687195,
0.2991220951080322,
0.12967541813850403,
0.4337107241153717
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.07368v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.07368v1
|
When Linear Attention Meets Autoregressive Decoding: Towards More Effective and Efficient Linearized Large Language Models
| 2024-06-11T15:34:43 | 2024-06-11T15:34:43 |
Haoran You, Yichao Fu, Zheng Wang, Amir Yazdanbakhsh, Yingyan, Lin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Autoregressive Large Language Models (LLMs) have achieved impressive
performance in language tasks but face two significant bottlenecks: (1)
quadratic complexity in the attention module as the number of tokens increases,
and (2) limited efficiency due to the sequential processing nature of
autoregressive LLMs during generation. While linear attention and speculative
decoding offer potential solutions, their applicability and synergistic
potential for enhancing autoregressive LLMs remain uncertain. We conduct the
first comprehensive study on the efficacy of existing linear attention methods
for autoregressive LLMs, integrating them with speculative decoding. We
introduce an augmentation technique for linear attention that ensures
compatibility with speculative decoding, enabling more efficient training and
serving of LLMs. Extensive experiments and ablation studies involving seven
existing linear attention models and five encoder/decoder-based LLMs
consistently validate the effectiveness of our augmented linearized LLMs.
Notably, our approach achieves up to a 6.67 reduction in perplexity on the
LLaMA model and up to a 2$\times$ speedup during generation compared to prior
linear attention methods. Codes and models are available at
https://github.com/GATECH-EIC/Linearized-LLM.
|
[
-0.22091232240200043,
-0.6712877750396729,
0.4781244993209839,
0.32949575781822205,
-0.11527886986732483,
0.3794742524623871,
-0.25960054993629456,
-0.7965129017829895,
0.3184114396572113,
0.326774924993515,
-0.536020815372467,
-0.04527527093887329,
-0.6635227203369141,
0.10879586637020111,
-0.6325247287750244,
0.657229483127594,
-0.09827834367752075,
-0.16395026445388794,
-0.2327786535024643,
-0.023192880675196648,
-0.1873885542154312,
-0.7950621247291565,
-0.6367199420928955,
-0.2220173478126526,
0.6543961763381958,
-0.09590789675712585,
0.6609442234039307,
0.9023208022117615,
0.7127416729927063,
0.2931582033634186,
-0.025547094643115997,
0.3614574372768402,
-0.8288071751594543,
0.1672472059726715,
-0.11856026947498322,
-0.45738446712493896,
-0.5677230954170227,
-0.050922803580760956,
0.690238893032074,
0.9344840049743652,
-0.0032050732988864183,
0.14077959954738617,
-0.027663804590702057,
0.4891618490219116,
-0.7434718012809753,
-0.011738656088709831,
-0.6589691042900085,
0.042335111647844315,
0.0385466068983078,
-0.33826321363449097,
-0.3635930120944977,
-0.3753107488155365,
-0.029631735756993294,
-0.4190751016139984,
0.09215635806322098,
0.29427990317344666,
0.46324384212493896,
0.6623831391334534,
-0.24988023936748505,
-0.36307239532470703,
-1.0016429424285889,
0.7221010327339172,
-0.8147376179695129,
0.5607587099075317,
0.15745608508586884,
-0.23586653172969818,
-0.09563110768795013,
-0.8165897727012634,
-0.43329542875289917,
-0.23740258812904358,
0.07963414490222931,
-0.0747665986418724,
-0.47052353620529175,
0.24767400324344635,
0.42744964361190796,
0.6473249793052673,
-0.44154122471809387,
0.1516374796628952,
-0.23516717553138733,
-0.32878386974334717,
0.456251323223114,
0.43351683020591736,
-0.11261838674545288,
0.2561381161212921,
-0.394894003868103,
0.21579128503799438,
-0.5170673727989197,
0.03859289735555649,
0.33279430866241455,
-0.18842943012714386,
0.17857316136360168,
0.461703896522522,
-0.1845182329416275,
0.6585022807121277,
0.353539377450943,
0.04722419008612633,
0.06398095190525055,
-0.5361299514770508,
-0.0773012712597847,
-0.29082679748535156,
0.6492506861686707,
0.10443643480539322,
-0.046407658606767654,
-0.48087167739868164,
-0.3353591859340668,
0.3262781798839569,
0.1343642622232437,
-0.5307251811027527,
-0.36286553740501404,
0.30824944376945496,
-0.3624069094657898,
-0.19165712594985962,
-0.41597092151641846,
-0.4931660592556,
-0.06377654522657394,
-0.34670060873031616,
0.23403368890285492,
-0.23664066195487976,
-0.11172452569007874,
0.557922899723053,
0.43973270058631897,
0.2441575825214386,
0.27677085995674133,
-1.149080514907837,
0.21603618562221527,
0.7095925211906433,
0.5781500935554504,
-0.10943487286567688,
0.03452732414007187,
-0.5543961524963379,
0.014858411625027657,
-0.4897973835468292,
0.7931160926818848,
-0.5602977275848389,
0.03540593013167381,
-0.006097698584198952,
-0.36653709411621094,
-0.03049759939312935,
-0.19388924539089203,
0.6229304671287537,
-0.7815506458282471,
-0.046306464821100235,
-0.3201088309288025,
-0.6061316132545471,
0.0853036418557167,
0.1370793879032135,
-0.5495806932449341,
0.9790886640548706,
-0.1800842583179474,
-0.6686809062957764,
0.05724310502409935,
-0.22706186771392822,
-0.3693275451660156,
0.02133558690547943,
0.0015952234389260411,
-0.09970317780971527,
0.3405759334564209,
0.3397980034351349,
0.20240618288516998,
-0.341535747051239,
-0.018773404881358147,
-0.3743847608566284,
-0.23010492324829102,
0.3301512598991394,
-0.5338340997695923,
0.2945932149887085,
0.38104167580604553,
-0.10474281758069992,
-0.1453939974308014,
-0.523874819278717,
0.08145803213119507,
0.10616439580917358,
-0.3004699647426605,
-0.1287716180086136,
-0.016043392941355705,
-0.03193821385502815,
0.18493635952472687,
0.6890136003494263,
-0.33072134852409363,
0.2672109007835388,
-0.7564264535903931,
0.34145060181617737,
0.6357545256614685,
-0.08587925881147385,
0.45427805185317993,
0.029860543087124825,
0.6467928886413574,
-0.21801576018333435,
0.06869152933359146,
-0.4892181158065796,
0.02491304650902748,
-1.259231448173523,
-0.044664207845926285,
0.36127451062202454,
0.35289090871810913,
-0.7071657776832581,
0.4895605742931366,
0.07754446566104889,
-0.027369149029254913,
-0.5928971767425537,
0.23887769877910614,
0.5771825313568115,
0.29261305928230286,
0.06210930645465851,
-0.4299141764640808,
-0.6050984263420105,
-0.8081441521644592,
-0.2989162504673004,
-0.09968926012516022,
0.28205209970474243,
0.20528900623321533,
0.112002894282341,
-0.3875453472137451,
0.6001034379005432,
-0.42749926447868347,
0.059998489916324615,
-0.21941395103931427,
0.08772684633731842,
0.2319440096616745,
0.27260470390319824,
0.4423028528690338,
-0.2667882442474365,
-0.39510637521743774,
-0.02006869576871395,
-0.6434929966926575,
-0.16209878027439117,
-0.051913097500801086,
0.06470215320587158,
0.4144977033138275,
0.7487291693687439,
-0.5491318106651306,
0.20392058789730072,
0.38586941361427307,
-0.15458305180072784,
0.24723994731903076,
-0.29208874702453613,
-0.13146354258060455,
-0.691638708114624,
0.17437346279621124,
-0.17140737175941467,
-0.5274254679679871,
-0.9170098900794983,
0.07175827026367188,
0.1076623946428299,
0.05676873028278351,
0.05505075305700302,
0.23387350142002106,
-0.7583311796188354,
-0.21747271716594696,
-0.6803810000419617,
0.1720961034297943,
-0.019310934469103813,
0.4685628116130829,
-0.08643447607755661,
0.5977226495742798,
0.49922627210617065,
-0.34305238723754883,
0.5522026419639587,
-0.12200818955898285,
-0.0492447093129158,
0.004356239456683397,
-0.715112030506134,
0.5232148170471191,
-0.383667528629303,
0.20128512382507324,
-1.210721731185913,
-0.11963724344968796,
0.29613909125328064,
-0.38100960850715637,
0.4262006878852844,
0.2773423194885254,
-0.49661877751350403,
-0.5529090166091919,
-0.20449960231781006,
0.6995955109596252,
0.4514603316783905,
-0.4976450502872467,
0.5427370071411133,
0.2471202313899994,
-0.17999424040317535,
-0.9550390243530273,
-0.5204684734344482,
0.2808648943901062,
0.06674673408269882,
-0.499634325504303,
-0.08005885034799576,
-0.2232152670621872,
-0.1958925724029541,
0.05699889361858368,
-0.1463938057422638,
0.2970176339149475,
0.009911168366670609,
-0.2791101634502411,
0.2494281679391861,
-0.24635331332683563,
0.04737040773034096,
-0.25669899582862854,
-0.3386000692844391,
0.2788875997066498,
-0.7642008662223816,
0.6852205991744995,
-0.10435844957828522,
-0.2516648471355438,
-0.42341795563697815,
0.4092899262905121,
0.5140116214752197,
-0.3081882894039154,
0.4167058765888214,
0.6175355315208435,
-0.41256046295166016,
-0.18484854698181152,
-1.0665757656097412,
-0.29708802700042725,
-0.4804988503456116,
0.4343756139278412,
-0.16177023947238922,
-0.8874068260192871,
0.6665678024291992,
0.11403755843639374,
0.10172873735427856,
0.16508696973323822,
0.6329251527786255,
-0.0341491736471653,
0.9624886512756348,
0.8462416529655457,
-0.5491734743118286,
0.412491112947464,
-0.10865239799022675,
0.32761964201927185,
-0.7357380390167236,
-0.08041168004274368,
-0.18375074863433838,
-0.3240374028682709,
-0.22038617730140686,
-0.5708370804786682,
0.17729423940181732,
-0.009965491481125355,
0.39611268043518066,
0.12168766558170319,
-0.3501059412956238,
0.5626774430274963,
0.17453262209892273,
-0.00017887046851683408,
0.4346765875816345,
0.09488200396299362,
0.09751671552658081,
-0.1841338574886322,
-0.9582982063293457,
-0.10305923968553543,
1.17898428440094,
0.7345221042633057,
1.000548005104065,
-0.11436177790164948,
0.4035050868988037,
0.24466629326343536,
0.051011018455028534,
-0.7542405724525452,
0.3532538115978241,
-0.08704680949449539,
-0.4155043661594391,
-0.10407476872205734,
-0.29792240262031555,
-0.7952380776405334,
0.29609307646751404,
-0.17899242043495178,
-0.5616949796676636,
0.47548532485961914,
0.44618141651153564,
-0.6302418112754822,
0.057431917637586594,
-0.4777171313762665,
0.4580242335796356,
-0.3136015832424164,
-0.742236316204071,
-0.3231026232242584,
-0.5396002531051636,
0.5310572981834412,
-0.15346935391426086,
0.08481777459383011,
0.12251672148704529,
-0.37015506625175476,
0.3548487424850464,
-0.23448513448238373,
0.7661569118499756,
0.07734088599681854,
-0.5424544215202332,
-0.13371562957763672,
-0.1716172993183136,
0.9660406708717346,
0.14892256259918213,
0.14527064561843872,
-0.1436741054058075,
-0.3985050618648529,
-0.38990238308906555,
-0.5885249972343445,
0.8249008059501648,
-0.6893692016601562,
-0.6497713327407837,
-0.46243029832839966,
-0.9768962264060974,
-0.32282599806785583,
-0.04123659431934357,
0.1744597852230072,
0.5167580246925354,
0.04478883743286133,
-0.03622563183307648,
1.2487071752548218,
-0.012701893225312233,
0.4494780898094177,
0.479439914226532,
-0.2982249855995178,
-0.31954193115234375,
0.8220471143722534,
-0.15389104187488556,
0.4215908646583557,
0.35678112506866455,
-0.27032384276390076,
-0.3750092685222626,
-0.9823980927467346,
0.056981563568115234,
0.3674940764904022,
-0.7288053631782532,
-0.16601945459842682,
-1.0244287252426147,
-0.3461361229419708,
-0.4029974937438965,
-0.05975276231765747,
-0.5062942504882812,
-0.41145792603492737,
-0.35755521059036255,
0.11919290572404861,
0.2781088054180145,
0.8853091597557068,
-0.27332770824432373,
-0.01955707184970379,
-0.471042275428772,
0.43244031071662903,
0.25025516748428345,
0.10880346596240997,
0.1782642900943756,
-0.6791496276855469,
-0.49490392208099365,
-0.1937437206506729,
0.15606507658958435,
-0.3858565092086792,
0.6509506702423096,
0.0124352490529418,
0.6651688814163208,
0.4628787636756897,
-0.013730661012232304,
0.5147855281829834,
-0.43818458914756775,
0.32896682620048523,
0.23160681128501892,
-0.7856341004371643,
0.24482154846191406,
-0.47959956526756287,
0.39243313670158386,
0.33421850204467773,
0.2814309000968933,
-0.3899475634098053,
-0.64619380235672,
-0.3781796991825104,
-1.0739777088165283,
0.8777417540550232,
0.11946497857570648,
0.1424427628517151,
0.17147855460643768,
0.7037041783332825,
-0.026675725355744362,
0.13012626767158508,
-0.7777450680732727,
-0.29578733444213867,
0.1388658583164215,
-0.160150408744812,
-0.30909937620162964,
-0.7000776529312134,
0.06383981555700302,
-0.09792975336313248,
0.416945219039917,
0.15835979580879211,
0.34632807970046997,
0.3121476471424103,
-0.21385525166988373,
-0.3919329345226288,
0.012447885237634182,
0.6569974422454834,
0.3638685345649719,
-0.1865510195493698,
0.1506318897008896,
0.20366016030311584,
-0.4677986204624176,
0.14720207452774048,
0.30583855509757996,
-0.06786443293094635,
-0.10767635703086853,
0.36679649353027344,
0.9280645251274109,
0.31147313117980957,
-0.33949339389801025,
0.15785713493824005,
-0.17162057757377625,
-0.18078550696372986,
-0.49407118558883667,
-0.022671882063150406,
0.1624174863100052,
0.4374282658100128,
0.5349541306495667,
0.07933220267295837,
0.342353492975235,
-0.4079338312149048,
0.07141618430614471,
0.6262193918228149,
-0.12772820889949799,
-0.2124352604150772,
0.8454345464706421,
0.4192451536655426,
-0.083872489631176,
0.15777407586574554,
-0.19104960560798645,
-0.45230358839035034,
0.4286005198955536,
0.4780455529689789,
0.7261942625045776,
-0.2782348096370697,
-0.40970996022224426,
0.27351072430610657,
0.5535426735877991,
0.051427211612463,
0.18958239257335663,
-0.05188298225402832,
-0.5604597330093384,
-0.789677083492279,
-0.5869755744934082,
-0.30801868438720703,
0.2306326925754547,
-0.5203218460083008,
-0.13957415521144867,
-0.5110043883323669,
-0.12380269914865494,
-0.01596573367714882,
0.09702008962631226,
-0.38653358817100525,
-0.0625089555978775,
0.551057755947113,
0.5327109694480896,
-0.5311160683631897,
0.8509979248046875,
0.459290087223053,
0.01426755078136921,
-0.5458632111549377,
0.18371838331222534,
-0.25244230031967163,
-0.6510457396507263,
0.7114500999450684,
-0.1034260168671608,
-0.4442574977874756,
0.22116638720035553,
-0.3772211968898773,
-1.4343029260635376,
0.8065512180328369,
0.3969203233718872,
-0.9989778995513916,
-0.1382858157157898,
0.27659928798675537,
0.6495946049690247,
-0.45532605051994324,
0.3609287440776825,
0.6326243281364441,
0.11638098955154419,
0.1309729516506195,
-0.7645916938781738,
-0.05572505667805672,
-0.2800418436527252,
0.13110975921154022,
0.2683603763580322,
-0.8635465502738953,
0.7853285074234009,
-0.26339685916900635,
-0.2551642060279846,
0.20193229615688324,
1.0195330381393433,
-0.10672032833099365,
0.08391688764095306,
0.4145801067352295,
0.5145443081855774,
0.6626231670379639,
-0.03987201303243637,
0.9997223019599915,
-0.670548677444458,
0.2872805893421173,
0.8167321681976318,
-0.29840975999832153,
0.6693161129951477,
0.4684697389602661,
-0.18471196293830872,
0.09383165836334229,
0.3692653477191925,
0.24186979234218597,
0.44717296957969666,
0.05465206503868103,
-0.3947451710700989,
-0.3984384834766388,
-0.13759122788906097,
-0.4465363621711731,
0.1798413097858429,
0.7459222674369812,
-0.40918266773223877,
-0.11592880636453629,
0.14543454349040985,
-0.19457797706127167,
0.14039644598960876,
-0.3967672884464264,
0.6530346870422363,
0.1796104609966278,
-0.590224027633667,
1.005867600440979,
-0.08449822664260864,
0.8474518656730652,
-0.5344797968864441,
0.32515814900398254,
-0.3353334069252014,
0.4995579719543457,
-0.09251528978347778,
-0.31994640827178955,
0.1361876279115677,
-0.08143436908721924,
-0.4578132629394531,
-0.18542437255382538,
0.9068448543548584,
-0.7920007109642029,
-0.6156843304634094,
0.39758577942848206,
0.19765996932983398,
-0.07319501042366028,
0.30027633905410767,
-0.5013843774795532,
0.4223781228065491,
0.2165796011686325,
-0.18119704723358154,
0.24125470221042633,
0.3263729214668274,
0.39110445976257324,
0.7601015567779541,
0.7171919345855713,
0.0642075389623642,
0.21440215408802032,
-0.012371848337352276,
1.2381258010864258,
-0.5235145688056946,
-0.4348529875278473,
-0.7118222713470459,
0.2440861165523529,
0.10503610223531723,
-0.01978720724582672,
0.8340230584144592,
0.44709068536758423,
0.4935099184513092,
-0.024380814284086227,
0.7999463677406311,
0.25316929817199707,
0.48334044218063354,
-0.6656286120414734,
0.32972580194473267,
-0.41038936376571655,
0.5353386402130127,
-0.08425101637840271,
-0.8864708542823792,
-0.1728849858045578,
0.47515958547592163,
-0.44264981150627136,
0.016942469403147697,
0.7094833850860596,
0.7576823830604553,
0.09686693549156189,
-0.2255481630563736,
0.41357648372650146,
0.3900057375431061,
-0.0030790988821536303,
1.0185954570770264,
1.0627772808074951,
-0.5209226608276367,
0.6154327392578125,
-0.21535594761371613,
-0.24486644566059113,
-0.33214274048805237,
-0.6735332012176514,
-1.0508311986923218,
-0.18676412105560303,
-0.24001052975654602,
-0.18365921080112457,
0.4044327735900879,
0.9334508180618286,
0.447913259267807,
-0.6898282766342163,
-0.1055426076054573,
-0.11883429437875748,
-0.31140241026878357,
0.22836542129516602,
-0.1479007452726364,
0.22433681786060333,
-0.8633954524993896,
-0.8591169714927673,
0.42839086055755615,
0.4541875422000885,
0.003157178871333599,
-0.6899145841598511,
0.05991745740175247,
-0.16920064389705658,
0.23883391916751862,
0.6350106000900269,
0.4884065091609955,
-0.817199170589447,
0.00567115843296051,
0.3435766100883484,
-0.22098448872566223,
-0.1253943294286728,
0.9073749780654907,
-0.6740010380744934,
0.37433502078056335,
0.504536509513855,
0.7270690202713013,
0.5816572904586792,
0.09114128351211548,
0.7919526696205139,
-0.5355520248413086,
0.5486822128295898,
0.4367416799068451,
0.3133671283721924,
0.18092375993728638,
-0.6559482216835022,
0.14560961723327637,
0.19436129927635193,
-0.7689990401268005,
-0.8382856845855713,
0.2389473170042038,
-0.8967524170875549,
0.009870927780866623,
1.2442480325698853,
-0.08436889946460724,
-0.18436138331890106,
-0.369034081697464,
-0.03807896375656128,
-0.1549208164215088,
-0.44388216733932495,
0.6970736980438232,
0.587203323841095,
-0.1144024133682251,
-0.42833831906318665,
-0.4901404082775116,
0.5214366316795349,
0.7840264439582825,
-0.6260026693344116,
0.5133344531059265,
0.6482090353965759,
-0.09357327967882156,
0.12927529215812683,
0.5177116394042969,
-0.03201321139931679,
0.39692920446395874,
0.022987110540270805,
0.0468154214322567,
-0.022563239559531212,
-0.18093372881412506,
-0.6429533362388611,
0.008445690385997295,
0.2667942941188812,
0.17340518534183502
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.07365v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.07365v1
|
BvSP: Broad-view Soft Prompting for Few-Shot Aspect Sentiment Quad Prediction
| 2024-06-11T15:32:32 | 2024-06-11T15:32:32 |
Yinhao Bai, Yalan Xie, Xiaoyi Liu, Yuhua Zhao, Zhixin Han, Mengting Hu, Hang Gao, Renhong Cheng
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Aspect sentiment quad prediction (ASQP) aims to predict four aspect-based
elements, including aspect term, opinion term, aspect category, and sentiment
polarity. In practice, unseen aspects, due to distinct data distribution,
impose many challenges for a trained neural model. Motivated by this, this work
formulates ASQP into the few-shot scenario, which aims for fast adaptation in
real applications. Therefore, we first construct a few-shot ASQP dataset (FSQP)
that contains richer categories and is more balanced for the few-shot study.
Moreover, recent methods extract quads through a generation paradigm, which
involves converting the input sentence into a templated target sequence.
However, they primarily focus on the utilization of a single template or the
consideration of different template orders, thereby overlooking the
correlations among various templates. To tackle this issue, we further propose
a Broadview Soft Prompting (BvSP) method that aggregates multiple templates
with a broader view by taking into account the correlation between the
different templates. Specifically, BvSP uses the pre-trained language model to
select the most relevant k templates with Jensen-Shannon divergence. BvSP
further introduces soft prompts to guide the pre-trained language model using
the selected templates. Then, we aggregate the results of multi-templates by
voting mechanism. Empirical results demonstrate that BvSP significantly
outperforms the stateof-the-art methods under four few-shot settings and other
public datasets. Our code and dataset are available at
https://github.com/byinhao/BvSP.
|
[
-0.5233110785484314,
-0.2863398492336273,
0.42011210322380066,
0.3821938931941986,
-0.5262192487716675,
0.0032520703971385956,
-0.2817424237728119,
0.0049276286736130714,
0.026195509359240532,
0.3864501416683197,
-0.7731465101242065,
-0.6999785900115967,
-0.39768391847610474,
0.12270325422286987,
-0.0811467096209526,
1.1082053184509277,
0.3863939344882965,
0.15348897874355316,
-0.1438179612159729,
-0.32437747716903687,
-0.43920594453811646,
-0.21338823437690735,
-0.35763269662857056,
-0.0945366844534874,
0.4467974901199341,
0.6502253413200378,
0.3638085722923279,
-0.058125559240579605,
0.13300074636936188,
0.2534429430961609,
-0.33036524057388306,
0.16811907291412354,
-0.3203141689300537,
0.2699512839317322,
-0.07098007947206497,
-0.5543537139892578,
-0.343767374753952,
-0.2911866009235382,
0.6512720584869385,
0.6256238222122192,
0.02205093763768673,
0.29426610469818115,
0.3541838228702545,
0.8118017911911011,
-0.923465371131897,
0.007371365092694759,
-0.7643580436706543,
0.13257507979869843,
-0.20187634229660034,
0.1618538498878479,
-0.21604250371456146,
-0.24134355783462524,
0.12910810112953186,
-0.08515966683626175,
0.29587170481681824,
-0.03846701607108116,
0.4838602840900421,
-0.09444423019886017,
-0.5675574541091919,
0.35114213824272156,
-0.7156345248222351,
0.7108063101768494,
-0.6173006892204285,
0.34024778008461,
0.08385790884494781,
0.2862437069416046,
0.03423807770013809,
-0.4970772862434387,
-0.6653409600257874,
0.2329251766204834,
0.3757856488227844,
0.4651191830635071,
-0.13874834775924683,
0.2899821400642395,
0.29905593395233154,
0.3297385275363922,
-0.5079392790794373,
0.07971712201833725,
-0.3463471531867981,
-0.13318274915218353,
0.48568499088287354,
0.3611083924770355,
-0.3310632109642029,
-0.6269960403442383,
-0.4016682803630829,
0.08507169038057327,
-0.691848874092102,
0.5470728874206543,
0.19368977844715118,
0.4909313917160034,
-0.42453858256340027,
0.7094853520393372,
-0.38080793619155884,
0.6846773624420166,
0.1896863877773285,
0.1804380565881729,
0.3397647440433502,
-0.5227102637290955,
-0.32830801606178284,
-0.2974209785461426,
0.9700736999511719,
0.4697459042072296,
0.08629772812128067,
0.3850371837615967,
-0.13785596191883087,
-0.17354659736156464,
0.30443674325942993,
-0.5912033915519714,
0.09965819120407104,
0.4739842712879181,
-0.4567070007324219,
-0.22670979797840118,
-0.1369818150997162,
-0.9004386067390442,
-0.546617865562439,
-0.12231658399105072,
0.07032391428947449,
-0.5297068953514099,
-0.09715747088193893,
-0.0412532202899456,
-0.28542429208755493,
0.28654560446739197,
0.3942676782608032,
-0.9681665301322937,
0.14416749775409698,
0.7781721949577332,
0.9642801880836487,
-0.09817259758710861,
-0.2401750534772873,
-0.7042115926742554,
-0.20526716113090515,
-0.2248184233903885,
1.0718451738357544,
-0.5923224687576294,
-0.5210155844688416,
0.3743366003036499,
-0.3566073179244995,
0.3386426270008087,
-0.10486426204442978,
0.48519256711006165,
-0.21163643896579742,
0.2702544033527374,
-0.35405105352401733,
-0.2512247860431671,
-0.3265111446380615,
0.7699408531188965,
-0.36402055621147156,
0.6992207169532776,
0.1349911242723465,
-0.9632086753845215,
0.6083486080169678,
-0.2609844505786896,
-0.16284890472888947,
0.16152501106262207,
-0.47318828105926514,
-0.6121100783348083,
0.529918909072876,
0.5606890916824341,
0.6931984424591064,
-0.17321516573429108,
-0.23503072559833527,
-0.6080830693244934,
-0.04638142138719559,
0.1627258062362671,
-0.31062227487564087,
0.4851973354816437,
-0.2239443063735962,
0.09986157715320587,
0.25804728269577026,
-0.7166509628295898,
0.11821435391902924,
-0.35201120376586914,
-0.17003494501113892,
-0.2757893204689026,
-0.11216115951538086,
0.04240092635154724,
0.35558003187179565,
-0.15963847935199738,
-0.5102111101150513,
0.5941388010978699,
-0.9609287977218628,
-0.09106848388910294,
0.8154981732368469,
0.32835593819618225,
0.5448027849197388,
0.030403299257159233,
0.8672863841056824,
0.4747738242149353,
0.31492137908935547,
-0.1164545938372612,
-0.655238926410675,
-0.4218698740005493,
-0.2938183546066284,
0.27999165654182434,
0.31229937076568604,
-1.0748722553253174,
0.019668735563755035,
-0.15790192782878876,
-0.3224284052848816,
-0.5463851094245911,
0.2411053329706192,
0.5558263063430786,
0.2614201605319977,
0.3785924017429352,
-0.6344323754310608,
-0.5245577692985535,
-0.7663780450820923,
-0.39716804027557373,
-0.270762175321579,
0.016441861167550087,
0.33949291706085205,
0.14588074386119843,
-0.07032682001590729,
0.9166579842567444,
-0.7488905191421509,
-0.4334133565425873,
-0.6083605885505676,
0.31003889441490173,
0.5321423411369324,
0.07192381471395493,
0.5169687867164612,
-0.5811454057693481,
-0.5296972393989563,
-0.2892240285873413,
-0.2525721490383148,
0.16774871945381165,
0.04311450198292732,
0.04405384883284569,
0.2545657157897949,
0.11771094799041748,
-0.4844905436038971,
0.30068641901016235,
0.5658493041992188,
-0.3542400300502777,
0.6948743462562561,
0.31088191270828247,
-0.048843275755643845,
-1.2793937921524048,
-0.31368356943130493,
0.3213450610637665,
-0.15347003936767578,
-0.40163812041282654,
-0.3258460760116577,
-0.1143866777420044,
0.01973331905901432,
-0.7758550047874451,
0.36836838722229004,
-0.2704009711742401,
-0.10100562125444412,
-0.16695214807987213,
-0.4460117816925049,
0.21966607868671417,
0.4697950780391693,
0.1818968802690506,
0.2508775591850281,
0.8526520133018494,
-0.39534491300582886,
0.3404259979724884,
0.4199979603290558,
0.003681655740365386,
0.4363729953765869,
-0.37114301323890686,
0.19688639044761658,
-0.4598247706890106,
0.3318716883659363,
-1.0154273509979248,
0.12838619947433472,
0.20017500221729279,
-0.5743795037269592,
0.2937387526035309,
-0.7328391671180725,
-0.11449217796325684,
-0.32953977584838867,
-0.789208710193634,
0.31898778676986694,
0.263999879360199,
-0.1313289850950241,
0.67970871925354,
-0.0672769770026207,
-0.3297172784805298,
-0.8129972815513611,
-0.46951767802238464,
-0.12566636502742767,
-0.007295998279005289,
-0.41087105870246887,
0.08015857636928558,
0.08685372769832611,
0.024610299617052078,
-0.344526469707489,
0.019789764657616615,
0.06591401249170303,
-0.2108449786901474,
0.5368596315383911,
0.3160860240459442,
-0.5118486285209656,
0.03901619836688042,
0.19960017502307892,
-0.12159130722284317,
0.08411426842212677,
-0.23362873494625092,
0.4320400059223175,
-0.4214074909687042,
-0.157802551984787,
-0.18382993340492249,
0.43465712666511536,
0.24174854159355164,
-0.09470879286527634,
0.39009004831314087,
0.6563314199447632,
-0.17195332050323486,
-0.29337531328201294,
-0.3555540442466736,
-0.16501350700855255,
-0.4613325893878937,
0.23787833750247955,
-0.4574822187423706,
-0.5898131728172302,
0.22891290485858917,
-0.01247932855039835,
0.24984416365623474,
0.2009640485048294,
0.7252918481826782,
-0.0334642268717289,
1.2122807502746582,
0.8118973970413208,
-0.35735654830932617,
0.6573631167411804,
-0.6027668118476868,
0.013235962949693203,
-0.7850860953330994,
-0.24936099350452423,
-0.4147217273712158,
-0.21749474108219147,
-0.6987201571464539,
-0.3133919835090637,
0.5639601945877075,
-0.07936888933181763,
-0.039987076073884964,
-0.157504603266716,
-0.3763973116874695,
0.18294359743595123,
0.42326539754867554,
-0.044227756559848785,
0.15156428515911102,
0.09442780166864395,
-0.21702846884727478,
-0.246074840426445,
-0.590809166431427,
-0.04354444518685341,
1.203436017036438,
0.3682754635810852,
0.6104760766029358,
0.12632237374782562,
0.8922685384750366,
0.028967948630452156,
0.14616677165031433,
-1.147778868675232,
0.4755706489086151,
-0.33455991744995117,
-0.35438573360443115,
-0.005305956583470106,
-0.21085016429424286,
-0.8445265293121338,
0.20406486093997955,
-0.7253409624099731,
-0.6832876801490784,
0.35103312134742737,
0.28088802099227905,
-0.8587263822555542,
-0.2644287645816803,
-0.45736128091812134,
0.5328521132469177,
0.003943104762583971,
-0.5366218090057373,
-0.19035029411315918,
-0.6759283542633057,
0.3834537863731384,
0.37736356258392334,
0.07671721279621124,
-0.034824617207050323,
-0.04577966779470444,
0.5115810632705688,
-0.2034800797700882,
0.9253216981887817,
-0.2596011757850647,
0.4407637119293213,
0.30048227310180664,
0.03049190156161785,
0.2588786482810974,
0.4142078161239624,
-0.05511289834976196,
0.18017125129699707,
-0.11780161410570145,
-0.3211888372898102,
-0.517072319984436,
0.41366061568260193,
-0.7548987865447998,
-0.4920938313007355,
-0.5891458988189697,
-0.11341772228479385,
-0.609324038028717,
0.20674769580364227,
0.6763100028038025,
0.5596507787704468,
-0.030285870656371117,
0.11152379959821701,
0.2652820348739624,
0.038281239569187164,
0.5068606734275818,
0.39410966634750366,
-0.31221628189086914,
-0.46007630228996277,
0.7939391136169434,
-0.06087706238031387,
0.05845518410205841,
0.09825807064771652,
0.5390731692314148,
-0.23822085559368134,
-0.8347315192222595,
-0.5131087303161621,
0.10212524980306625,
-0.5780736207962036,
-0.6229104995727539,
-0.532975971698761,
-0.15730655193328857,
-0.725884735584259,
-0.27219992876052856,
-0.5213136672973633,
-0.3518386483192444,
-0.08597914129495621,
-0.07930660247802734,
0.3878464698791504,
0.6687813997268677,
0.04953324794769287,
0.246406689286232,
-0.9499714374542236,
0.49158579111099243,
0.37642702460289,
0.3078075051307678,
-0.2566487193107605,
-0.45555996894836426,
-0.07750223577022552,
0.023678008466959,
-0.5810455083847046,
-0.866818368434906,
0.5825338959693909,
0.29893311858177185,
0.1047193706035614,
0.6430143713951111,
-0.03596305474638939,
0.5871263742446899,
-0.3701501190662384,
1.1438661813735962,
0.5154624581336975,
-0.8705816268920898,
0.7261514067649841,
-0.2965969145298004,
0.4819028079509735,
0.8901665210723877,
0.5275349020957947,
-0.4604530334472656,
-0.49846819043159485,
-0.6382548809051514,
-1.028235912322998,
0.6792744398117065,
-0.012981484644114971,
0.24907849729061127,
0.18858766555786133,
0.27808788418769836,
0.2842634320259094,
0.429263174533844,
-0.6244112849235535,
-0.22892485558986664,
-0.6044179797172546,
-0.2889157235622406,
0.07993270456790924,
-0.2161659300327301,
0.041961804032325745,
-0.30616241693496704,
0.5049126744270325,
-0.6468366384506226,
0.19137904047966003,
-0.03332448750734329,
0.22797495126724243,
-0.08108469843864441,
0.38445597887039185,
0.25838494300842285,
0.23772920668125153,
-0.14401812851428986,
-0.0032346537336707115,
0.31797701120376587,
-0.4984567165374756,
-0.12521317601203918,
-0.11585215479135513,
-0.16950751841068268,
0.08032301068305969,
0.3864114284515381,
0.795853316783905,
0.02486666850745678,
-0.21724118292331696,
1.0414698123931885,
-0.2521718442440033,
-0.004648381378501654,
-0.3077754080295563,
0.0815131887793541,
-0.23229162395000458,
0.5267503261566162,
0.2839955985546112,
0.12037663161754608,
0.5239071846008301,
-0.680955708026886,
-0.10063827037811279,
0.4989986717700958,
-0.6863352060317993,
-0.5525680184364319,
0.2714410424232483,
0.4257652461528778,
-0.04129454866051674,
0.6369407773017883,
-0.3714008927345276,
-0.7404361963272095,
0.29666781425476074,
0.1657276749610901,
0.9615978598594666,
-0.07963062077760696,
0.40088367462158203,
0.3011871874332428,
-0.09385751932859421,
-0.06311815232038498,
0.7047713994979858,
-0.05746801197528839,
-0.8676276206970215,
-0.571334183216095,
-0.7155173420906067,
-0.5139875411987305,
0.20451195538043976,
-0.7302213311195374,
0.7556025385856628,
-0.704306960105896,
-0.2334887683391571,
0.2366594523191452,
0.17402951419353485,
-0.8132551312446594,
0.33960840106010437,
0.7509932518005371,
0.7788200378417969,
-1.1762100458145142,
0.6535959243774414,
0.944058895111084,
-0.4573037922382355,
-0.7544384002685547,
0.31050458550453186,
0.3804433047771454,
-0.7252970933914185,
0.2990703582763672,
0.31759557127952576,
-0.19375446438789368,
-0.08252011984586716,
-0.7450312972068787,
-0.4605475664138794,
0.6643628478050232,
-0.0019355613039806485,
-0.5475834608078003,
-0.009319700300693512,
-0.13221091032028198,
0.47958076000213623,
-0.35843998193740845,
0.24320445954799652,
0.3128272294998169,
0.228764608502388,
0.2958691120147705,
-0.48165813088417053,
0.0915113091468811,
-0.0925072580575943,
0.02011113055050373,
0.04241441935300827,
-0.6111896634101868,
0.4742458164691925,
-0.3363615572452545,
0.18030257523059845,
-0.39611881971359253,
1.1888493299484253,
0.4162379801273346,
0.5785228610038757,
0.6537408828735352,
0.03114745393395424,
0.247172012925148,
0.279311865568161,
0.8378514051437378,
-0.0033677732571959496,
0.1281074583530426,
0.8018680810928345,
-0.24269017577171326,
1.0066877603530884,
0.5488500595092773,
-0.18253599107265472,
0.7710238695144653,
0.40160927176475525,
-0.005373931955546141,
0.6384073495864868,
-0.08635146915912628,
-0.4032050371170044,
-0.2676692306995392,
0.007055975496768951,
-0.23153875768184662,
0.892322838306427,
0.6061468124389648,
-0.12461025267839432,
-0.0691615417599678,
0.08377578109502792,
-0.17550678551197052,
-0.24072124063968658,
-0.5841080546379089,
1.0129868984222412,
0.45877426862716675,
-0.8900935053825378,
0.35695451498031616,
-0.041439276188611984,
0.7810875177383423,
-0.4509967267513275,
0.0728335827589035,
-0.11647116392850876,
0.10171914845705032,
-0.5303977131843567,
-1.064408779144287,
0.2805190086364746,
-0.046847544610500336,
-0.16212865710258484,
-0.26594096422195435,
0.8868062496185303,
-0.33528605103492737,
-0.5361009836196899,
0.0725918859243393,
0.5318248271942139,
-0.13176771998405457,
-0.26570776104927063,
-0.8473010659217834,
-0.21084147691726685,
0.001646725577302277,
-0.5710548162460327,
0.3228992223739624,
0.610636293888092,
-0.10406443476676941,
0.3529605567455292,
0.4423248767852783,
0.31785041093826294,
-0.2844828963279724,
0.3757131099700928,
1.1631706953048706,
-0.8472888469696045,
-0.6316923499107361,
-0.8395426273345947,
0.7773973345756531,
0.058627959340810776,
-0.6820246577262878,
0.4573889970779419,
0.4091545343399048,
0.2840102016925812,
0.06681934744119644,
0.9629976749420166,
0.18481354415416718,
0.35035672783851624,
-0.6526914834976196,
0.32740893959999084,
-0.46860939264297485,
0.15935631096363068,
-0.29423797130584717,
-0.7093862891197205,
-0.25314879417419434,
0.28533485531806946,
-0.3644726872444153,
-0.0418219193816185,
0.661923348903656,
0.5959805250167847,
-0.10270727425813675,
0.011765886098146439,
0.2827165126800537,
0.32366085052490234,
0.024099472910165787,
0.4594338834285736,
0.731216311454773,
0.015613039955496788,
0.5768460035324097,
-0.3577626049518585,
-0.1183074340224266,
-0.5268082022666931,
-0.977349579334259,
-0.9086090326309204,
-0.6158673167228699,
-0.39382681250572205,
-0.7260041832923889,
-0.1423109769821167,
1.0776132345199585,
0.47962406277656555,
-0.6892713308334351,
0.14953447878360748,
-0.012972087599337101,
0.2528553605079651,
-0.275048166513443,
-0.1952846497297287,
0.032482363283634186,
-0.25320717692375183,
-0.4283134639263153,
0.22587120532989502,
0.4141162633895874,
-0.06807155162096024,
-0.37620994448661804,
0.2682745158672333,
0.038823630660772324,
0.11132310330867767,
0.7882362008094788,
0.2535039484500885,
-0.31954118609428406,
-0.30611950159072876,
-0.0988970473408699,
-0.03355277329683304,
0.20195744931697845,
0.8535957336425781,
-0.9458207488059998,
0.46959155797958374,
0.8327850103378296,
0.1632603406906128,
0.769180178642273,
0.06572841852903366,
0.7800202965736389,
-1.3579245805740356,
0.18648222088813782,
0.6826688647270203,
0.298990398645401,
0.3875487744808197,
-0.3507706820964813,
0.03181556239724159,
0.20326854288578033,
-0.16347821056842804,
-0.7059836983680725,
0.4998696744441986,
-1.1982239484786987,
-0.14386016130447388,
1.4565740823745728,
-0.06863728165626526,
-0.5042634010314941,
-0.3612842261791229,
-0.20847150683403015,
0.0339956060051918,
-0.6412290930747986,
0.6194297075271606,
0.37220335006713867,
-0.32294750213623047,
-0.3189181685447693,
-0.19992567598819733,
0.5558789968490601,
0.4696270227432251,
-0.48185381293296814,
-0.1309850811958313,
0.5619246363639832,
0.240351602435112,
-0.05200430005788803,
0.7554041147232056,
0.28868523240089417,
0.3900224566459656,
-0.039533499628305435,
0.16957919299602509,
-0.029941381886601448,
-0.3318561911582947,
-0.7557700276374817,
0.39167842268943787,
0.290751576423645,
-0.286022424697876
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10268v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10268v1
|
Autograding Mathematical Induction Proofs with Natural Language Processing
| 2024-06-11T15:30:26 | 2024-06-11T15:30:26 |
Chenyan Zhao, Mariana Silva, Seth Poulsen
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.HC
|
In mathematical proof education, there remains a need for interventions that
help students learn to write mathematical proofs. Research has shown that
timely feedback can be very helpful to students learning new skills. While for
many years natural language processing models have struggled to perform well on
tasks related to mathematical texts, recent developments in natural language
processing have created the opportunity to complete the task of giving students
instant feedback on their mathematical proofs. In this paper, we present a set
of training methods and models capable of autograding freeform mathematical
proofs by leveraging existing large language models and other machine learning
techniques. The models are trained using proof data collected from four
different proof by induction problems. We use four different robust large
language models to compare their performances, and all achieve satisfactory
performances to various degrees. Additionally, we recruit human graders to
grade the same proofs as the training data, and find that the best grading
model is also more accurate than most human graders. With the development of
these grading models, we create and deploy an autograder for proof by induction
problems and perform a user study with students. Results from the study shows
that students are able to make significant improvements to their proofs using
the feedback from the autograder, but students still do not trust the AI
autograders as much as they trust human graders. Future work can improve on the
autograder feedback and figure out ways to help students trust AI autograders.
|
[
-0.18213972449302673,
-0.5796587467193604,
0.31985700130462646,
0.2871450185775757,
0.04388706758618355,
0.17255333065986633,
-0.2271149754524231,
-0.49243825674057007,
-0.33563441038131714,
0.3497847616672516,
-0.2189842015504837,
-0.20814788341522217,
-0.5646165013313293,
0.32496756315231323,
-0.5060808062553406,
0.8600832223892212,
-0.44942647218704224,
0.49833598732948303,
-0.7449150681495667,
-0.009364668279886246,
-0.3852720856666565,
-0.6734194755554199,
-0.8848451972007751,
-0.7411023378372192,
-0.25665804743766785,
0.392309308052063,
0.5733758807182312,
0.8026832938194275,
0.383650004863739,
0.4772930443286896,
0.2076486051082611,
-0.029914915561676025,
-0.055150069296360016,
0.19768281280994415,
-0.2354615479707718,
-0.6222332119941711,
-0.3066265285015106,
0.2281569391489029,
0.4582459032535553,
0.6632220149040222,
-0.19740737974643707,
0.11925346404314041,
0.11362934112548828,
0.6674345135688782,
-0.5127773284912109,
0.7013509273529053,
-0.3809361755847931,
0.12210136651992798,
0.1268673539161682,
0.039416760206222534,
-0.636239230632782,
-0.7044637799263,
-0.03186468407511711,
-0.6838293075561523,
0.36666858196258545,
-0.35019651055336,
0.6501681804656982,
0.317719429731369,
-0.17219209671020508,
-0.5956239700317383,
-0.8340556621551514,
0.8225151300430298,
-0.6600688099861145,
0.2124994993209839,
0.6020300388336182,
0.5924648642539978,
0.097256600856781,
-0.5166327357292175,
-0.50704425573349,
-0.5159844756126404,
0.006866765208542347,
0.07375108450651169,
-0.019659604877233505,
-0.11590749025344849,
0.40922534465789795,
0.6496249437332153,
-0.37464481592178345,
0.20247432589530945,
-0.1488044559955597,
-0.3729349970817566,
0.8830878734588623,
0.21130302548408508,
0.3550851047039032,
-0.11066436767578125,
0.10544776916503906,
-0.4552503526210785,
-0.5363031625747681,
0.28696537017822266,
0.4012143909931183,
0.045096248388290405,
0.04313303157687187,
0.6658440828323364,
-0.33923348784446716,
0.7085682153701782,
0.33353519439697266,
0.03445488587021828,
0.15640398859977722,
-0.20298318564891815,
-0.06133085861802101,
-0.03957530856132507,
0.6565826535224915,
0.08196713775396347,
0.43081846833229065,
-0.1896507292985916,
-0.6208237409591675,
0.5159515142440796,
-0.17463211715221405,
-0.9066162109375,
-0.6455700993537903,
-0.18222938477993011,
-0.464606374502182,
-0.46727269887924194,
-0.2819066345691681,
-0.613616406917572,
-0.16131068766117096,
-0.9229748249053955,
0.6810150146484375,
-0.47717049717903137,
0.09378109127283096,
0.39126214385032654,
-0.04172096401453018,
-0.04178518429398537,
0.5026971101760864,
-1.0574012994766235,
0.42968499660491943,
0.45250457525253296,
0.5090785026550293,
0.14358974993228912,
-0.329432874917984,
-0.7334000468254089,
-0.12988914549350739,
-0.11076628416776657,
1.0370419025421143,
-0.5176369547843933,
-0.06087469682097435,
0.024513334035873413,
-0.17284241318702698,
-0.3065757155418396,
-0.7396842241287231,
0.7176679968833923,
-0.5872399806976318,
0.6700094938278198,
0.08154290914535522,
-0.8220873475074768,
-0.023605667054653168,
0.2042417824268341,
-0.40572038292884827,
0.9909510016441345,
0.059859223663806915,
-0.40568915009498596,
0.22655414044857025,
-1.004799723625183,
-0.4798175096511841,
0.044060032814741135,
0.203075110912323,
-0.5275099873542786,
0.09175457060337067,
0.6555238366127014,
0.4234139323234558,
-0.04830766096711159,
0.0858825147151947,
-0.26358562707901,
0.16911457479000092,
0.19059082865715027,
-0.3926229476928711,
0.9461775422096252,
0.19834956526756287,
-0.4139779806137085,
0.09429425746202469,
-0.8592947125434875,
0.15170025825500488,
0.3508043587207794,
-0.25889432430267334,
-0.4003133773803711,
-0.011612478643655777,
-0.27319270372390747,
0.373267263174057,
0.09865987300872803,
-0.6336774826049805,
0.310754656791687,
-0.6897848844528198,
0.6242454051971436,
0.5974841117858887,
-0.053775712847709656,
0.5335401296615601,
-0.4733317196369171,
0.4275721609592438,
0.13512150943279266,
0.09353413432836533,
-0.2442261278629303,
-0.3676428198814392,
-0.9098640084266663,
-0.020713509991765022,
0.4441537857055664,
0.6286918520927429,
-0.8480026721954346,
0.4821620583534241,
-0.01266733929514885,
-0.410696417093277,
-0.6060171723365784,
0.5174192190170288,
0.20093666017055511,
0.6454545855522156,
0.6480579376220703,
-0.262129545211792,
-0.42555367946624756,
-0.5431278944015503,
-0.5818966031074524,
-0.17968307435512543,
-0.1749373823404312,
-0.24426567554473877,
0.3817119300365448,
-0.20988893508911133,
1.0654098987579346,
-0.5000755190849304,
-0.34065115451812744,
-0.025613421574234962,
0.5691138505935669,
0.027341756969690323,
0.626736044883728,
0.3607608675956726,
-0.10504184663295746,
-0.5891739726066589,
-0.4311927855014801,
-0.8251134753227234,
-0.10314490646123886,
0.04796265438199043,
-0.08093275874853134,
0.25656449794769287,
0.34687647223472595,
-0.25649601221084595,
0.569778561592102,
0.1667100340127945,
-0.3292384445667267,
0.6494951248168945,
-0.3544272482395172,
-0.1422782838344574,
-0.7266203165054321,
-0.4113811254501343,
0.15877747535705566,
-0.6639196872711182,
-0.2510626018047333,
0.07581556588411331,
0.08284711837768555,
-0.2315090447664261,
-0.10455314815044403,
0.5097036957740784,
-0.5364533066749573,
0.26484474539756775,
-0.3264162838459015,
-0.11995992064476013,
0.0024492964148521423,
0.054185230284929276,
0.09935196489095688,
0.5746645927429199,
0.7919766306877136,
-0.6935843825340271,
0.5849407911300659,
0.25555455684661865,
-0.25163817405700684,
0.4927738308906555,
-0.8022500872612,
0.11087629944086075,
-0.15136384963989258,
0.2427404224872589,
-0.966076672077179,
-0.005494330544024706,
-0.018572073429822922,
-0.6256847977638245,
0.2121557593345642,
-0.39927393198013306,
-0.6654881238937378,
-0.5150129199028015,
-0.15061721205711365,
0.33369094133377075,
0.37390458583831787,
-0.8594824075698853,
0.546190619468689,
0.10487032681703568,
-0.26058048009872437,
-0.25913646817207336,
-0.3234723210334778,
0.05243575945496559,
0.15973302721977234,
-0.7655161619186401,
0.18677513301372528,
-0.32192912697792053,
-0.34281545877456665,
0.13288350403308868,
0.3158872425556183,
-0.155594140291214,
0.12849965691566467,
0.19218891859054565,
0.3535608947277069,
-0.1032269150018692,
0.1286403387784958,
0.2067699134349823,
-0.572271466255188,
0.4841344654560089,
-0.5087596774101257,
0.4395485818386078,
-0.22720034420490265,
-0.29784318804740906,
-0.650303840637207,
0.18264983594417572,
0.6707916259765625,
-0.5007157921791077,
0.5974113941192627,
0.3505019247531891,
-0.7055304646492004,
-0.2953777313232422,
-0.6188787817955017,
-0.5471727252006531,
-0.4512909948825836,
-0.058114420622587204,
-0.1263672560453415,
-0.47516611218452454,
0.3043256103992462,
0.03862178698182106,
0.4544316530227661,
0.7568468451499939,
0.8761889934539795,
0.01717785745859146,
1.3655812740325928,
0.6080761551856995,
-0.11600989103317261,
0.42492789030075073,
-0.5873315334320068,
0.23728780448436737,
-0.2993743419647217,
-0.1543762981891632,
-0.7635329961776733,
0.07668150216341019,
0.005438046529889107,
-0.16683804988861084,
-0.061422381550073624,
0.12219918519258499,
-0.030573170632123947,
0.3246341943740845,
-0.5835525989532471,
0.7842550277709961,
0.5553250908851624,
-0.09677574038505554,
0.6246250867843628,
0.34526798129081726,
-0.4857758581638336,
-0.18266889452934265,
-0.5071097016334534,
-0.5474452972412109,
1.1530088186264038,
0.33050763607025146,
0.6745024919509888,
-0.13602067530155182,
0.7266976833343506,
0.42228609323501587,
0.9280837178230286,
-0.9017587304115295,
0.34928572177886963,
-0.12308235466480255,
-0.5296711921691895,
-0.353096067905426,
-0.7374168038368225,
-0.6393610835075378,
-0.028654299676418304,
-0.33643990755081177,
-0.17106732726097107,
-0.08849722892045975,
0.1556209772825241,
-0.29053163528442383,
0.15544238686561584,
-0.6971747875213623,
0.6690654158592224,
-0.20122601091861725,
-0.5003580451011658,
-0.3600502908229828,
-0.21559791266918182,
0.14666937291622162,
0.14671917259693146,
0.2691730856895447,
0.035618916153907776,
0.7044305801391602,
0.8842818140983582,
-1.0373822450637817,
0.7148212790489197,
-0.4558311998844147,
-0.41150274872779846,
0.47039398550987244,
0.282949298620224,
0.39093831181526184,
0.44644612073898315,
-0.2759377658367157,
-0.23636388778686523,
0.04051722213625908,
-0.26526960730552673,
-0.6269145607948303,
0.6116583347320557,
-1.1480426788330078,
-0.2789002060890198,
-0.5234213471412659,
-0.49172332882881165,
-0.15714740753173828,
0.14187254011631012,
0.36314061284065247,
0.6046848297119141,
0.20982198417186737,
-0.2485792338848114,
0.5887563824653625,
0.2277747541666031,
0.7894518971443176,
0.44923165440559387,
-0.3243354260921478,
-0.7102503776550293,
0.9683247804641724,
0.2017044872045517,
0.023643461987376213,
0.17912201583385468,
0.31451037526130676,
-0.7655094265937805,
-0.3393445909023285,
-0.6457889080047607,
0.30462637543678284,
-0.8590049147605896,
-0.47229233384132385,
-0.5499399900436401,
-0.3185940086841583,
-0.7637481093406677,
-0.13088975846767426,
-0.42252862453460693,
-0.9182681441307068,
-0.11715761572122574,
-0.05942708998918533,
0.19290009140968323,
0.6628133654594421,
-0.2887008488178253,
0.12227312475442886,
-0.6998870968818665,
0.38153624534606934,
0.694187343120575,
0.5419602394104004,
0.16548475623130798,
-0.745043158531189,
-0.2564416825771332,
0.23984982073307037,
-0.610774576663971,
-0.48322734236717224,
0.5614935159683228,
0.2565807104110718,
0.4968118369579315,
0.45136311650276184,
0.09369228035211563,
0.6671748161315918,
-0.32658690214157104,
0.4805125892162323,
0.1703343391418457,
-1.2845392227172852,
0.4977208375930786,
0.010064344853162766,
0.022102119401097298,
0.6382229328155518,
0.34027162194252014,
-0.4183393716812134,
-0.3236231207847595,
-0.4609161913394928,
-0.4850535988807678,
0.41115647554397583,
0.12793241441249847,
-0.0578775517642498,
0.17743483185768127,
0.581596314907074,
0.3117712736129761,
-0.10564456880092621,
-0.8322052955627441,
-0.10733804106712341,
-0.7070425152778625,
-0.47406062483787537,
-0.22568944096565247,
-0.060606975108385086,
-0.02929508127272129,
-0.6437048316001892,
0.7501872777938843,
-0.1574353724718094,
0.24013842642307281,
0.1656782180070877,
-0.6604968309402466,
-0.35336509346961975,
0.26514288783073425,
0.40316176414489746,
0.7286491990089417,
-0.0019125223625451326,
0.011730041354894638,
0.04771463945508003,
-0.44305354356765747,
0.4775117039680481,
0.5176948308944702,
-0.41218459606170654,
0.10880675911903381,
0.2530517280101776,
0.3745611906051636,
-0.2490502893924713,
-0.35683026909828186,
0.4311094284057617,
-0.48710310459136963,
-0.4108524024486542,
-0.6233203411102295,
0.00650679599493742,
-0.22538398206233978,
-0.180728018283844,
0.41977909207344055,
0.24929992854595184,
0.18740354478359222,
-0.29914236068725586,
0.16126751899719238,
0.2682434916496277,
-0.1675446629524231,
-0.4898175001144409,
0.7549731135368347,
0.1471404880285263,
-0.2914024293422699,
0.8159914612770081,
-0.22838038206100464,
-0.7082226276397705,
0.4933401048183441,
0.8747267723083496,
0.9556145071983337,
-0.3373076617717743,
0.2762587070465088,
0.5539925694465637,
0.045809268951416016,
-0.2812982201576233,
-0.03988497331738472,
-0.17558221518993378,
-0.5663979053497314,
-0.7096701860427856,
-0.5730164051055908,
-0.6149090528488159,
-0.15584135055541992,
-0.6853867769241333,
0.21890197694301605,
-0.6750574707984924,
-0.10283420234918594,
-0.04193402826786041,
0.21803227066993713,
-0.7856263518333435,
0.25331389904022217,
0.16442309319972992,
0.5834901332855225,
-0.9641469120979309,
0.5746006369590759,
1.063360571861267,
-0.2370234876871109,
-0.7193529009819031,
-0.33536648750305176,
-0.12346743047237396,
-0.5628175139427185,
0.8044506907463074,
0.30586808919906616,
-0.048983123153448105,
0.032080475240945816,
-0.5802122950553894,
-0.5717687606811523,
0.6092431545257568,
0.28219857811927795,
-0.2794458866119385,
-0.06057017669081688,
0.28998348116874695,
0.656136691570282,
-0.2462935596704483,
0.6357666254043579,
0.09667155891656876,
0.17212438583374023,
0.07545764744281769,
-0.6190251708030701,
-0.11222544312477112,
-0.4341316819190979,
-0.26475170254707336,
0.18705745041370392,
-0.31769657135009766,
0.7712103724479675,
-0.1013173907995224,
-0.038004420697689056,
0.002277120016515255,
1.0284838676452637,
0.12895692884922028,
0.5337916612625122,
0.689766526222229,
0.9319509863853455,
0.8157719969749451,
-0.04751594364643097,
0.7119007110595703,
-0.501515805721283,
0.4437532126903534,
0.9650478959083557,
-0.1799476146697998,
0.761634111404419,
-0.03165346756577492,
-0.08286647498607635,
0.8405707478523254,
0.39826807379722595,
-0.035506848245859146,
0.14467668533325195,
0.5019692182540894,
-0.34142979979515076,
-0.6482350826263428,
0.11076311767101288,
-0.4490607678890228,
0.2647969424724579,
0.3580748438835144,
-0.16473449766635895,
-0.4372994601726532,
0.2030264288187027,
0.01804533414542675,
0.3069326877593994,
-0.5332357287406921,
0.7268370389938354,
-0.07281536608934402,
-0.8846948146820068,
0.6998961567878723,
0.283308744430542,
0.586978554725647,
-0.22202804684638977,
-0.10122808068990707,
-0.36008360981941223,
0.5905314087867737,
-0.3790762722492218,
-0.3977935314178467,
0.31088119745254517,
0.1851143091917038,
-0.383760005235672,
-0.4340062439441681,
0.6624292135238647,
-0.30907562375068665,
-0.9823134541511536,
0.06509920954704285,
0.3860120177268982,
-0.20535621047019958,
0.010924629867076874,
-0.5689826011657715,
-0.5319298505783081,
-0.27018898725509644,
0.1865612268447876,
0.14274515211582184,
0.3731808066368103,
-0.07670959830284119,
0.8978362083435059,
1.0446922779083252,
0.0868796706199646,
0.317095547914505,
0.10262005776166916,
0.7507109045982361,
-0.4412776827812195,
-0.41040468215942383,
-0.9441432952880859,
0.1781512200832367,
-0.13056932389736176,
-0.054593734443187714,
1.0278900861740112,
0.6486884355545044,
0.8821504712104797,
-0.14363956451416016,
0.7632721066474915,
0.4390031397342682,
0.6825891137123108,
-0.4590865969657898,
0.5719559788703918,
-0.0084006879478693,
0.23742805421352386,
-0.3049876391887665,
-0.8866090178489685,
-0.5949105024337769,
0.8864045143127441,
-0.44542044401168823,
-0.07692674547433853,
0.5560083985328674,
0.3784729242324829,
0.11906208097934723,
0.231471985578537,
-0.14624576270580292,
0.12559938430786133,
0.7057482600212097,
0.5268352627754211,
1.058395266532898,
-0.5094995498657227,
0.4141954183578491,
-0.7480548620223999,
-0.3953116238117218,
-0.13114133477210999,
-0.8017725348472595,
-1.1898000240325928,
-0.28981733322143555,
-0.7200628519058228,
-0.5828172564506531,
-0.08716751635074615,
1.1495052576065063,
0.5839798450469971,
-0.9834123849868774,
-0.27391552925109863,
-0.15844488143920898,
0.12741877138614655,
-0.227085679769516,
-0.2948544919490814,
0.4347062110900879,
-0.6761299967765808,
-0.6078199744224548,
0.3464062511920929,
0.11989278346300125,
0.21767649054527283,
-0.19386370480060577,
0.07137877494096756,
0.22501327097415924,
0.04378269985318184,
0.7314437031745911,
0.426559716463089,
-0.10049611330032349,
-0.02237863838672638,
0.07430243492126465,
0.04107747972011566,
0.15815497934818268,
0.8526604175567627,
-1.1239067316055298,
0.346316397190094,
0.5212442874908447,
0.6475736498832703,
0.40228092670440674,
-0.025056349113583565,
0.5897743701934814,
-0.12062104791402817,
-0.10505624115467072,
0.27456995844841003,
0.4692218005657196,
0.4782247543334961,
-0.29441577196121216,
0.15061798691749573,
0.5141004920005798,
-0.7869344353675842,
-0.7676615118980408,
-0.00804252177476883,
-0.28881219029426575,
0.14519929885864258,
0.6144365668296814,
-0.1288919299840927,
-0.10334718972444534,
-0.29941415786743164,
-0.0340258963406086,
0.3034936487674713,
-0.3974180221557617,
1.2183743715286255,
0.823807954788208,
0.0014784367522224784,
0.012599353678524494,
-0.26841071248054504,
0.4488402307033539,
0.7744941115379333,
-0.8867917060852051,
0.2336079180240631,
0.43325430154800415,
0.39857128262519836,
0.24289411306381226,
0.10396895557641983,
-0.5006296038627625,
0.2931980788707733,
-0.43614068627357483,
0.06457552313804626,
-0.3117954134941101,
-0.2931567430496216,
-0.6512256860733032,
0.24597667157649994,
0.23719701170921326,
0.055217500776052475
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.07359v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.07359v1
|
GLIMPSE: Pragmatically Informative Multi-Document Summarization for Scholarly Reviews
| 2024-06-11T15:27:01 | 2024-06-11T15:27:01 |
Maxime Darrin, Ines Arous, Pablo Piantanida, Jackie CK Cheung
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Scientific peer review is essential for the quality of academic publications.
However, the increasing number of paper submissions to conferences has strained
the reviewing process. This surge poses a burden on area chairs who have to
carefully read an ever-growing volume of reviews and discern each reviewer's
main arguments as part of their decision process. In this paper, we introduce
\sys, a summarization method designed to offer a concise yet comprehensive
overview of scholarly reviews. Unlike traditional consensus-based methods, \sys
extracts both common and unique opinions from the reviews. We introduce novel
uniqueness scores based on the Rational Speech Act framework to identify
relevant sentences in the reviews. Our method aims to provide a pragmatic
glimpse into all reviews, offering a balanced perspective on their opinions.
Our experimental results with both automatic metrics and human evaluation show
that \sys generates more discriminative summaries than baseline methods in
terms of human evaluation while achieving comparable performance with these
methods in terms of automatic metrics.
|
[
-0.2908165752887726,
-0.20942863821983337,
0.562487781047821,
0.4462391138076782,
-0.671875,
0.16381877660751343,
0.022252395749092102,
-0.078118696808815,
0.7826806306838989,
0.1885516494512558,
-0.33643168210983276,
-0.6983945965766907,
-0.3539457321166992,
0.29099398851394653,
-0.48998504877090454,
1.3531702756881714,
0.32788026332855225,
0.38481560349464417,
-0.11110759526491165,
-0.2455795407295227,
0.1363263875246048,
-0.07168428599834442,
0.04922814294695854,
-0.04341984540224075,
0.4655354917049408,
0.09127411246299744,
0.2219807207584381,
0.27029839158058167,
0.8114749789237976,
0.31125953793525696,
-0.40292081236839294,
0.3592977523803711,
-0.3802371621131897,
0.3739683926105499,
-0.20760957896709442,
-0.2802877426147461,
-0.47160011529922485,
-0.0427435077726841,
1.1112208366394043,
0.8978040814399719,
-0.1249224841594696,
0.279267817735672,
0.3488689064979553,
0.5778491497039795,
-0.5976252555847168,
0.04864627867937088,
-0.49124476313591003,
0.1754874736070633,
-0.27869713306427,
-0.34645822644233704,
-0.3716139793395996,
-0.4313547611236572,
0.03985537216067314,
-0.810088038444519,
0.5418179631233215,
-0.27015599608421326,
0.618095338344574,
0.12396106123924255,
-0.4598810076713562,
0.019100314006209373,
-0.42470788955688477,
0.7566084861755371,
-0.6535102128982544,
0.035112861543893814,
-0.37414196133613586,
0.18053387105464935,
-0.00214777491055429,
-0.9205402135848999,
-0.5203120112419128,
-0.08130314201116562,
-0.3433583378791809,
0.5571290850639343,
0.011954575777053833,
0.19063667953014374,
0.004811540246009827,
0.5085890293121338,
-0.6410331130027771,
-0.5668214559555054,
-0.49003204703330994,
-0.2559414505958557,
0.6268249154090881,
0.24646204710006714,
-0.03588539734482765,
-0.20042932033538818,
-0.18243978917598724,
0.012053974904119968,
-0.3663713037967682,
-0.0954832211136818,
0.22477126121520996,
0.007177294697612524,
0.04180687293410301,
0.430136114358902,
-0.4029957950115204,
0.6851793527603149,
-0.11393851786851883,
-0.25341659784317017,
0.37095269560813904,
-0.7472139000892639,
-0.03010931983590126,
-0.2602376937866211,
0.9720442295074463,
0.6598532199859619,
-0.16813336312770844,
0.08294044435024261,
-0.05249194800853729,
0.13647867739200592,
0.18228811025619507,
-0.73012375831604,
-0.20035436749458313,
0.06797926872968674,
-0.7585291862487793,
-0.40187081694602966,
0.5221934914588928,
-1.1470881700515747,
-0.5133360028266907,
-0.3137626349925995,
-0.252511203289032,
-0.07104069739580154,
-0.1440311074256897,
0.01463701669126749,
-0.5988729000091553,
-0.02391008846461773,
0.771896243095398,
-0.38431689143180847,
0.33636659383773804,
0.7315559983253479,
1.0711179971694946,
-0.32568228244781494,
-0.3751198649406433,
-0.544098436832428,
0.055145151913166046,
-0.1259085237979889,
1.0886027812957764,
-0.5600522756576538,
-0.6639938354492188,
-0.3197699785232544,
-0.19432200491428375,
0.08463554829359055,
-0.24465233087539673,
0.5709621906280518,
-0.19002507627010345,
0.13981404900550842,
-0.2382092922925949,
-0.0861799418926239,
-0.13568909466266632,
0.12672293186187744,
-0.31317591667175293,
0.5651950240135193,
-0.14126214385032654,
-0.998569667339325,
0.5277212262153625,
-0.5996686220169067,
-0.4943562150001526,
0.30893123149871826,
-0.2801053524017334,
-0.16489391028881073,
0.5220597982406616,
0.32815098762512207,
0.13944321870803833,
0.058966293931007385,
0.2986357808113098,
-0.4430179297924042,
-0.04792625457048416,
0.2721825838088989,
-0.12228075414896011,
0.5691729187965393,
0.39349564909935,
-0.27017197012901306,
0.6720075011253357,
-0.6519309282302856,
0.1485549807548523,
-0.2329593449831009,
0.03261352702975273,
-0.30523696541786194,
-0.11026199162006378,
0.03201806917786598,
-0.06543534249067307,
0.0839192345738411,
-0.4202539324760437,
0.12778043746948242,
-0.34144172072410583,
0.42035815119743347,
0.5742231607437134,
0.4609258472919464,
0.6447306871414185,
-0.22930458188056946,
0.5417406558990479,
-0.19774886965751648,
0.4320761263370514,
-0.6963657736778259,
-0.34017783403396606,
-0.4570898711681366,
-0.5011399388313293,
0.20816375315189362,
0.22148948907852173,
-0.2700560390949249,
0.16408616304397583,
-0.0022464764770120382,
-0.7154935598373413,
-0.6405555009841919,
-0.03346642479300499,
0.6288151741027832,
0.414978951215744,
0.09970767050981522,
-0.5352194905281067,
-0.34262824058532715,
-0.7930208444595337,
-0.6000744104385376,
-0.47959738969802856,
-0.08478809893131256,
0.08694619685411453,
0.5065656900405884,
0.16712473332881927,
0.7716131806373596,
-0.6910409927368164,
-0.32025423645973206,
-0.11545093357563019,
0.24447700381278992,
0.20264242589473724,
0.04919549077749252,
0.18063846230506897,
-0.613225519657135,
-0.1977883279323578,
-0.15472401678562164,
-0.7572658658027649,
-0.2739916145801544,
-0.4100905656814575,
-0.03671155497431755,
-0.34742891788482666,
0.2948281168937683,
-0.5173166394233704,
0.28988760709762573,
-0.04374408349394798,
-0.3407445251941681,
0.6926456093788147,
-0.24632805585861206,
0.18681347370147705,
-0.5687494874000549,
0.12008896470069885,
0.2033734768629074,
0.03621131554245949,
-0.05738130211830139,
0.3672119677066803,
-0.1584065854549408,
-0.03782588988542557,
-0.22844034433364868,
0.46216389536857605,
-0.6399195790290833,
-0.08622300624847412,
-0.02865239605307579,
0.5805736184120178,
0.3957587480545044,
0.11422315984964371,
0.024304894730448723,
0.3735197186470032,
0.4531015157699585,
-0.5219641923904419,
0.3049261271953583,
0.41899755597114563,
-0.23968061804771423,
0.6249438524246216,
-0.8304516077041626,
-0.18998868763446808,
-0.3717893064022064,
0.6060355305671692,
-0.9444450736045837,
-0.27883148193359375,
0.04881639406085014,
-0.5020751357078552,
0.10984763503074646,
0.08695866167545319,
-0.09049335867166519,
-0.07971933484077454,
-0.7342380881309509,
0.05325708165764809,
-0.05246200039982796,
-0.320028156042099,
0.6390585899353027,
0.9068419933319092,
-0.6151882410049438,
-0.6616357564926147,
-0.48692384362220764,
0.3727816343307495,
-0.1014382466673851,
-0.4765371084213257,
0.4962620437145233,
0.012296734377741814,
-0.784709095954895,
-0.1483755260705948,
-0.21360881626605988,
0.09261058270931244,
-0.04310879856348038,
0.19744661450386047,
0.3646564781665802,
0.19147320091724396,
-0.13606490194797516,
0.2924560010433197,
-0.06585249304771423,
0.036690853536129,
-0.21944384276866913,
0.1663467288017273,
-0.5009652972221375,
-0.31623709201812744,
-0.5365688800811768,
0.6640512347221375,
0.7869707345962524,
-0.40289488434791565,
-0.09126030653715134,
0.35936492681503296,
0.12676595151424408,
-0.27627313137054443,
-0.3723788559436798,
-0.4929295480251312,
-0.34636804461479187,
0.5783748626708984,
-0.24889852106571198,
-0.4732057452201843,
0.42253413796424866,
0.13241200149059296,
0.44618675112724304,
0.4449857175350189,
0.38107481598854065,
-0.24925975501537323,
0.8878717422485352,
0.33967092633247375,
0.250026673078537,
0.40452122688293457,
-0.01065952517092228,
0.20753225684165955,
-0.7070645689964294,
-0.5673064589500427,
-0.7588451504707336,
-0.21227386593818665,
-0.28276529908180237,
-0.11494125425815582,
0.5916762351989746,
0.10434531420469284,
0.1962728053331375,
0.004038109444081783,
-1.0048067569732666,
0.513600766658783,
0.36974668502807617,
-0.19584770500659943,
0.5581081509590149,
-0.1288754940032959,
-0.16613082587718964,
-0.2877860963344574,
-0.5487766265869141,
-0.7807977795600891,
0.8659138083457947,
0.2240125834941864,
0.7884339094161987,
-0.02118983492255211,
0.9175328016281128,
0.24556918442249298,
0.4910062253475189,
-0.6227753162384033,
0.8582178950309753,
-0.02308580093085766,
-0.25658702850341797,
-0.2594122588634491,
-0.40709036588668823,
-0.5560122728347778,
0.6948438882827759,
-0.14352227747440338,
-0.19717933237552643,
0.35831862688064575,
0.009344099089503288,
-0.498052179813385,
0.005196788348257542,
-0.6015688180923462,
0.5648409128189087,
-0.3178320825099945,
-0.2381545454263687,
-0.5382751226425171,
-0.8370761871337891,
0.458138644695282,
0.15483209490776062,
0.3263268768787384,
-0.0045786104165017605,
-0.18639114499092102,
0.8836132884025574,
-0.3505213260650635,
0.7230513095855713,
-0.2456522136926651,
0.2772451937198639,
0.24816051125526428,
0.1285993456840515,
0.05499480292201042,
0.4918114244937897,
0.40207841992378235,
0.20850832760334015,
0.29944470524787903,
-0.03659718856215477,
-0.49256157875061035,
0.6174046397209167,
-0.3710452914237976,
-0.5263232588768005,
-0.7725031971931458,
-0.23032592236995697,
-0.08946938812732697,
0.44852015376091003,
0.2839703857898712,
0.6122890710830688,
-0.3765227496623993,
-0.10803332924842834,
0.532028317451477,
-0.07795185595750809,
0.4156306982040405,
0.5277464985847473,
-0.28121110796928406,
-0.8537032008171082,
0.746344268321991,
-0.020198438316583633,
-0.2227112501859665,
0.39889654517173767,
0.19797387719154358,
-0.3372300863265991,
-0.7079620361328125,
-0.38368943333625793,
0.5516932606697083,
-0.6191216707229614,
-0.18161439895629883,
-0.9261102080345154,
0.25428688526153564,
-0.6494994759559631,
-0.041130200028419495,
0.01390908844769001,
-0.8892046809196472,
-0.07197961211204529,
-0.03699759021401405,
-0.21391037106513977,
0.9115596413612366,
-0.09627528488636017,
0.3786931335926056,
-0.8202510476112366,
0.37204068899154663,
0.2872331440448761,
0.20129196345806122,
-0.07372201234102249,
-0.4019768536090851,
0.15171033143997192,
-0.3340287506580353,
-0.5790314674377441,
-1.048165202140808,
0.4290549159049988,
0.4837648570537567,
0.647147536277771,
0.6871082186698914,
0.24525536596775055,
0.720766544342041,
-0.29099348187446594,
0.9055549502372742,
0.45250725746154785,
-0.8692106604576111,
0.6746911406517029,
-0.38771894574165344,
0.35998886823654175,
0.805539608001709,
0.028615623712539673,
-0.40653932094573975,
-0.558934211730957,
-0.6591255068778992,
-0.9312452673912048,
0.43638333678245544,
-0.159025177359581,
-0.06184326484799385,
-0.08056899160146713,
0.0014334943844005466,
0.09731623530387878,
0.40239977836608887,
-0.4621659219264984,
-0.08407975733280182,
-0.3668748736381531,
-0.008611400611698627,
0.23715217411518097,
-0.27011439204216003,
-0.620857298374176,
0.04800543934106827,
0.7159283757209778,
-0.17864640057086945,
-0.026126297190785408,
0.4679931402206421,
-0.07805009186267853,
0.30947890877723694,
0.46572020649909973,
0.7455751299858093,
0.9546324014663696,
-0.09369862079620361,
0.21237239241600037,
-0.09103824198246002,
-0.7201104164123535,
-0.3537656366825104,
-0.025106510147452354,
-0.39280417561531067,
0.7129020094871521,
0.5468109846115112,
0.3725830912590027,
0.0848630964756012,
-0.40701183676719666,
0.6330686211585999,
-0.38097867369651794,
-0.14356662333011627,
-0.15812334418296814,
-0.2651066184043884,
-0.234810471534729,
-0.010655703954398632,
0.5537585020065308,
0.36699387431144714,
0.507910966873169,
-0.34850791096687317,
0.3545592427253723,
0.5331321358680725,
-0.2207079827785492,
-0.46837279200553894,
0.4872322976589203,
0.5407214760780334,
0.00380206317640841,
0.14718306064605713,
-0.29451116919517517,
-0.3651284873485565,
0.34737494587898254,
0.2809666395187378,
1.0457683801651,
-0.12085831165313721,
0.5407456159591675,
0.4686104655265808,
0.28733137249946594,
0.043244730681180954,
0.05417506769299507,
-0.37580540776252747,
0.04778498411178589,
-0.5616925358772278,
-0.66499924659729,
-0.6148114800453186,
-0.3998689651489258,
-0.7818481922149658,
0.3139002025127411,
-0.5921751260757446,
-0.39164799451828003,
0.4373525083065033,
-0.20861198008060455,
0.08001416176557541,
-0.12031055241823196,
-0.1338043212890625,
0.8607172966003418,
-0.786688506603241,
0.16423767805099487,
0.5311013460159302,
-0.42724287509918213,
-0.3132610023021698,
0.07281055301427841,
0.24969933927059174,
-0.16549088060855865,
0.32267671823501587,
-0.06492689251899719,
-0.491655558347702,
-0.4417368173599243,
-0.4207720458507538,
-0.39791086316108704,
0.7117639780044556,
0.3848257064819336,
-0.7084208726882935,
-0.20471101999282837,
-0.5833583474159241,
0.6012091636657715,
-0.2188565880060196,
0.5973420143127441,
0.28098559379577637,
0.5340416431427002,
0.05114656686782837,
-0.7888022065162659,
-0.20826567709445953,
-0.6159121990203857,
-0.48950210213661194,
0.16498573124408722,
-0.6862820982933044,
0.5040844678878784,
-0.5203455090522766,
-0.5014387965202332,
-0.1074686273932457,
0.6676372289657593,
0.5153855085372925,
0.6663063168525696,
0.30862894654273987,
0.24524006247520447,
0.9810233116149902,
-0.16653551161289215,
0.7917707562446594,
-0.32096782326698303,
0.17193815112113953,
1.210921049118042,
-0.32333219051361084,
0.45631736516952515,
0.5522305965423584,
-0.3985126316547394,
0.31401485204696655,
0.3347713351249695,
-0.030150065198540688,
0.4372594356536865,
0.3241393566131592,
-0.39141929149627686,
-0.08644243329763412,
-0.35039472579956055,
-0.3830961287021637,
0.32151758670806885,
0.3338586986064911,
-0.12430588155984879,
-0.4869897961616516,
-0.1986696571111679,
0.039417680352926254,
0.36184415221214294,
-0.44911104440689087,
0.9924766421318054,
0.276731014251709,
-0.9756421446800232,
0.11329583078622818,
-0.06484119594097137,
0.7049608826637268,
-0.8119525909423828,
-0.2378864735364914,
-0.2850764989852905,
0.07450655102729797,
-0.5817536115646362,
-0.9203522205352783,
0.49741601943969727,
0.2119390070438385,
-0.26632019877433777,
-0.448900043964386,
0.3868401050567627,
-0.15659144520759583,
-0.3904434144496918,
-0.03886865824460983,
0.2270481139421463,
0.310781866312027,
0.09338417649269104,
-0.5416796207427979,
-0.12759146094322205,
0.024715187028050423,
0.022003062069416046,
0.11430742591619492,
0.45373451709747314,
-0.24180543422698975,
0.43414413928985596,
0.6507378220558167,
0.5297525525093079,
-0.12241308391094208,
0.39949560165405273,
0.8127365112304688,
-0.5210464000701904,
-0.9793462157249451,
-0.6787397861480713,
0.45927760004997253,
-0.5505315065383911,
-0.6157335042953491,
0.8690528273582458,
0.7487402558326721,
0.4796542227268219,
-0.05335479974746704,
0.7574353814125061,
0.12353102117776871,
0.6308906674385071,
-0.10409760475158691,
0.8027547597885132,
-0.21575546264648438,
0.3091863691806793,
-0.5075010061264038,
-0.8262577056884766,
-0.7141187787055969,
0.6443701982498169,
-0.15697477757930756,
-0.22816045582294464,
0.9928660988807678,
0.6753441095352173,
0.37812307476997375,
0.11946982890367508,
-0.09274899214506149,
0.0504399910569191,
0.2614862322807312,
0.052720777690410614,
0.8808803558349609,
-0.01763748750090599,
0.5230175256729126,
0.013613092713057995,
-0.5461513996124268,
-0.1308525800704956,
-0.8683929443359375,
-0.5272247791290283,
-0.5949587225914001,
-0.5527845621109009,
-0.4184291958808899,
-0.12675070762634277,
0.34487417340278625,
0.5593575239181519,
-0.9207435250282288,
-0.048512086272239685,
-0.06010771915316582,
0.12422721087932587,
-0.3220856785774231,
-0.2036653459072113,
0.46783289313316345,
-0.4536201059818268,
-0.5158885717391968,
0.33809101581573486,
0.6553546190261841,
-0.23085537552833557,
-0.29330065846443176,
0.06189301609992981,
0.2186504602432251,
-0.010177039541304111,
0.22796384990215302,
0.20000801980495453,
-0.6905449628829956,
0.37456610798835754,
0.08852706849575043,
-0.05018772929906845,
-0.28636881709098816,
1.216696858406067,
-0.6517083644866943,
0.6905152797698975,
0.7886977195739746,
0.2613348066806793,
0.4543318748474121,
-0.04312099888920784,
0.3144958019256592,
-0.5439974665641785,
0.01802673004567623,
0.6932199001312256,
0.5529096722602844,
0.30005794763565063,
-0.16247713565826416,
0.3553083539009094,
0.4239538013935089,
-0.42000332474708557,
-1.1763113737106323,
0.10219517350196838,
-1.220047950744629,
-0.11359953135251999,
0.9162278771400452,
-0.24010604619979858,
-0.03857044130563736,
-0.11740818619728088,
-0.32300522923469543,
-0.04860912635922432,
-0.5270823836326599,
0.8715410828590393,
0.446051687002182,
-0.15651586651802063,
0.040758438408374786,
-0.04875009134411812,
0.2979837656021118,
0.4489077627658844,
-0.8778547644615173,
0.17966362833976746,
0.8588346838951111,
0.03731672465801239,
0.4316571354866028,
0.7235350608825684,
-0.6095159649848938,
0.3524448871612549,
0.021897099912166595,
-0.05500347539782524,
-0.08368398249149323,
-0.5782543420791626,
-0.6304365992546082,
0.5532801747322083,
-0.15006043016910553,
-0.07275673002004623
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.